id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05506v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05506v2
|
Cross-Care: Assessing the Healthcare Implications of Pre-training Data on Language Model Bias
| 2024-05-09T02:33:14 | 2024-06-24T23:17:52 |
Shan Chen, Jack Gallifant, Mingye Gao, Pedro Moreira, Nikolaj Munch, Ajay Muthukkumar, Arvind Rajan, Jaya Kolluri, Amelia Fiske, Janna Hastings, Hugo Aerts, Brian Anthony, Leo Anthony Celi, William G. La Cava, Danielle S. Bitterman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly essential in processing natural
languages, yet their application is frequently compromised by biases and
inaccuracies originating in their training data. In this study, we introduce
Cross-Care, the first benchmark framework dedicated to assessing biases and
real world knowledge in LLMs, specifically focusing on the representation of
disease prevalence across diverse demographic groups. We systematically
evaluate how demographic biases embedded in pre-training corpora like $ThePile$
influence the outputs of LLMs. We expose and quantify discrepancies by
juxtaposing these biases against actual disease prevalences in various U.S.
demographic groups. Our results highlight substantial misalignment between LLM
representation of disease prevalence and real disease prevalence rates across
demographic subgroups, indicating a pronounced risk of bias propagation and a
lack of real-world grounding for medical applications of LLMs. Furthermore, we
observe that various alignment methods minimally resolve inconsistencies in the
models' representation of disease prevalence across different languages. For
further exploration and analysis, we make all data and a data visualization
tool available at: www.crosscare.net.
|
[
-0.11177384108304977,
-0.3558046519756317,
0.5036659240722656,
0.07471571117639542,
-0.005849739536643028,
-0.11170889437198639,
-0.09040871262550354,
-0.5368371605873108,
0.32635995745658875,
0.5013355612754822,
-0.505738377571106,
-0.7886275053024292,
-1.0402772426605225,
-0.1138431578874588,
-0.17016421258449554,
0.8825290203094482,
-0.09302859753370285,
0.5970686674118042,
-0.3820495307445526,
-0.1561545729637146,
-0.08066031336784363,
-0.7024555802345276,
-0.47819092869758606,
-0.43127620220184326,
0.561333179473877,
0.18136750161647797,
0.7673444151878357,
0.5357645153999329,
0.30526354908943176,
0.1101006492972374,
0.09620079398155212,
-0.22342275083065033,
-0.5111014246940613,
-0.02914479747414589,
-0.15247498452663422,
-0.5251619219779968,
-0.5766187310218811,
0.3417452573776245,
0.4120042324066162,
1.1954765319824219,
-0.03796977177262306,
0.17892612516880035,
-0.021114619448781013,
0.68936687707901,
-0.6030865907669067,
-0.06015962362289429,
-0.2189660221338272,
0.42419207096099854,
-0.6381828188896179,
-0.27173396944999695,
-0.10563360154628754,
-0.4676928222179413,
0.4006206691265106,
-0.39082545042037964,
0.2150718867778778,
0.07131996005773544,
0.6796993613243103,
0.41155707836151123,
-0.6193477511405945,
-0.21395236253738403,
-0.422916978597641,
0.7317580580711365,
-0.6369658708572388,
0.6349775195121765,
0.408621221780777,
0.34026962518692017,
-0.14353998005390167,
-0.6530415415763855,
-0.17431499063968658,
-0.18045447766780853,
-0.12993761897087097,
0.14571607112884521,
-0.4404528737068176,
0.046561069786548615,
0.22565896809101105,
0.44828590750694275,
-0.6740151047706604,
0.39765363931655884,
-0.534713089466095,
-0.3656194508075714,
0.579853355884552,
0.20670093595981598,
0.770561695098877,
0.0642433613538742,
-0.21759255230426788,
0.025506798177957535,
-1.1163771152496338,
-0.024785570800304413,
0.42305800318717957,
0.2511577904224396,
-0.4678925573825836,
0.6889538764953613,
0.10444889217615128,
0.48153629899024963,
-0.23605306446552277,
0.048613693565130234,
0.4565494656562805,
-0.18564698100090027,
-0.3477816879749298,
0.2574993669986725,
0.7386884689331055,
0.5233131647109985,
0.4732290208339691,
-0.30726149678230286,
0.35514017939567566,
0.12105034291744232,
0.4188021719455719,
-0.6278115510940552,
-0.11619296669960022,
0.23881320655345917,
-0.7359821200370789,
0.10086735337972641,
-0.2610383629798889,
-0.8068631887435913,
-0.381205677986145,
-0.21672312915325165,
-0.29903846979141235,
-0.04693984240293503,
-0.35821154713630676,
0.17714834213256836,
0.1689390242099762,
-0.2094155102968216,
0.10412585735321045,
-0.6140641570091248,
0.3094055950641632,
0.5711096525192261,
0.36885958909988403,
-0.41001904010772705,
-0.06708461791276932,
-0.5407264828681946,
-0.08336186408996582,
-0.21511739492416382,
0.7045068144798279,
-0.6364330053329468,
-0.5542699098587036,
0.2870999574661255,
-0.03822938725352287,
-0.08626645058393478,
-0.7571032047271729,
0.41519778966903687,
-0.19117319583892822,
0.2334774285554886,
-0.44519221782684326,
-0.42089906334877014,
0.22663098573684692,
0.2600320875644684,
-0.9365466833114624,
0.8212336897850037,
0.4732271432876587,
-1.0136644840240479,
0.829001247882843,
-0.37438148260116577,
-0.410431832075119,
-0.10124301165342331,
-0.5395607352256775,
-0.5080165266990662,
0.07244902849197388,
0.2258017510175705,
0.3776724636554718,
-0.5421162247657776,
0.36937636137008667,
-0.5910013318061829,
-0.15726089477539062,
0.11890211701393127,
-0.5341164469718933,
0.8175541162490845,
0.031102212145924568,
-0.24902769923210144,
0.09568879753351212,
-0.3918851613998413,
-0.09066511690616608,
-0.03212384507060051,
0.008024102076888084,
-0.6034760475158691,
0.018812881782650948,
0.12446293979883194,
0.36396604776382446,
0.011848055757582188,
-0.3338942229747772,
0.13541264832019806,
-0.4006381034851074,
0.03388288617134094,
0.36387762427330017,
-0.1282559335231781,
0.4168233275413513,
-0.5444989800453186,
0.8947619199752808,
0.2664060890674591,
0.6048150062561035,
0.26928025484085083,
-0.5108827352523804,
-0.08013137429952621,
-0.1714884638786316,
0.2821032404899597,
0.360402911901474,
-0.4710541069507599,
0.19975699484348297,
-0.4268229901790619,
-0.30924347043037415,
-0.7589685916900635,
0.033316001296043396,
0.5568529963493347,
0.34139397740364075,
0.49468937516212463,
-0.4143434762954712,
-0.6163025498390198,
-1.0171160697937012,
-0.6239442229270935,
-0.1797236055135727,
0.003160518128424883,
0.3749854564666748,
0.3277258276939392,
-0.6716414093971252,
0.6393564343452454,
-0.1565025895833969,
-0.3496340811252594,
-0.19023564457893372,
0.017042871564626694,
-0.21357135474681854,
0.5493797659873962,
0.5792022347450256,
-0.4534931480884552,
-0.3550602197647095,
-0.12901553511619568,
-0.5077006816864014,
-0.5354673862457275,
0.3433658480644226,
-0.2049783170223236,
0.06110857427120209,
0.4323587119579315,
-0.27166229486465454,
0.6698594689369202,
1.2238017320632935,
-0.20756490528583527,
0.48204755783081055,
-0.052710969001054764,
-0.06067274138331413,
-0.939568817615509,
0.10999572277069092,
0.3019998371601105,
-0.12159062922000885,
-0.46891021728515625,
-0.3813120424747467,
-0.1485295444726944,
0.1839958280324936,
-0.28667065501213074,
0.4887329041957855,
-0.4812212586402893,
0.008590830489993095,
0.06851112842559814,
-0.09089869260787964,
-0.058578044176101685,
-0.21943135559558868,
0.2363271266222,
0.573890745639801,
0.4364972710609436,
-0.3287038207054138,
-0.04240163043141365,
-0.04303568974137306,
-0.36289364099502563,
0.5970419645309448,
-0.5948509573936462,
-0.2427540272474289,
0.014795132912695408,
0.5158987045288086,
-0.5146051645278931,
0.15285933017730713,
0.36175110936164856,
-0.32008859515190125,
0.07753235101699829,
-0.06262563914060593,
-0.33655446767807007,
-0.3404526114463806,
0.00035543704871088266,
0.7640950679779053,
0.2767736315727234,
-0.20277747511863708,
0.3345128893852234,
0.8948968648910522,
-0.18725928664207458,
-0.6430811882019043,
-0.836291491985321,
-0.17536677420139313,
-0.26370900869369507,
-0.40736106038093567,
0.426137238740921,
0.18381863832473755,
-0.43247202038764954,
0.0865950658917427,
-0.2678535282611847,
-0.14779944717884064,
-0.20466242730617523,
0.3051491379737854,
0.2130555361509323,
-0.1674627810716629,
0.26388585567474365,
0.06734158843755722,
-0.03878328204154968,
0.23145435750484467,
-0.2588264048099518,
0.6243149042129517,
0.2669357657432556,
-0.8853309154510498,
-0.08091894537210464,
0.5982949137687683,
0.4534715712070465,
-0.1237797662615776,
0.507430374622345,
0.32056573033332825,
-0.5013250708580017,
-0.2515767812728882,
-0.5491704940795898,
0.0851157158613205,
-0.3303331434726715,
0.39911389350891113,
0.02267739549279213,
-0.9684786200523376,
0.4434147775173187,
-0.0785132572054863,
-0.07877575606107712,
0.3642038404941559,
0.59140545129776,
0.0023989779874682426,
0.8097654581069946,
0.6339910626411438,
-0.2578592002391815,
0.23222436010837555,
-0.136987566947937,
0.2629185914993286,
-0.8470843434333801,
-0.42738983035087585,
-0.6247389316558838,
-0.09103550761938095,
-0.8515195250511169,
-0.8378289937973022,
0.2940257787704468,
-0.15970054268836975,
-0.24309296905994415,
0.03424140438437462,
-0.27754291892051697,
-0.001791260321624577,
0.26651668548583984,
0.2589411735534668,
0.1632302701473236,
-0.12244429439306259,
-0.37409770488739014,
-0.49216538667678833,
-0.9245160818099976,
-0.43152931332588196,
1.3849703073501587,
0.5126888155937195,
1.0342665910720825,
-0.31583982706069946,
0.7414262890815735,
0.41356685757637024,
0.8271508812904358,
-0.5959005951881409,
-0.08652563393115997,
-0.41883134841918945,
-0.631993293762207,
-0.25464141368865967,
-0.6642358303070068,
-1.193816065788269,
0.15180063247680664,
-0.11249641329050064,
-0.5700646638870239,
0.43821054697036743,
0.41379114985466003,
-0.24288532137870789,
0.31112754344940186,
-0.4634040892124176,
1.0724211931228638,
-0.7084609270095825,
-0.28581929206848145,
-0.022809896618127823,
-0.6094925403594971,
0.5017457008361816,
-0.009441492147743702,
0.3318682312965393,
-0.31071603298187256,
0.040909916162490845,
0.6562124490737915,
-0.4472472667694092,
0.9160372614860535,
-0.06973931938409805,
-0.33723193407058716,
-0.3651117980480194,
-0.2317267805337906,
0.0019116237526759505,
0.13658928871154785,
-0.03346732258796692,
0.41418325901031494,
0.21889866888523102,
-0.7078111171722412,
-0.29198157787323,
0.5210814476013184,
-0.768951416015625,
-0.58404940366745,
-0.6756703853607178,
-0.5641699433326721,
-0.5513309836387634,
0.17177219688892365,
0.33966121077537537,
0.4464266896247864,
-0.6706964373588562,
-0.2144065946340561,
0.6439139246940613,
-0.6206870079040527,
-0.3396286368370056,
0.6189113259315491,
-0.3295647203922272,
-0.13446679711341858,
0.4579978287220001,
0.10732924193143845,
0.54575514793396,
0.15394245088100433,
0.23053215444087982,
-0.37311673164367676,
-0.48352861404418945,
-0.35142776370048523,
0.2951517403125763,
-0.4736402630805969,
0.11979728937149048,
-0.6446925401687622,
-0.2203158289194107,
-0.5499467849731445,
0.0959998294711113,
-0.3239514231681824,
0.21975530683994293,
-0.07811620831489563,
0.13749751448631287,
0.06137920543551445,
0.8038681745529175,
0.1722460240125656,
0.16911791265010834,
-0.8901751041412354,
0.152841255068779,
0.040640346705913544,
0.4751981794834137,
-0.11471158266067505,
-0.24427589774131775,
-0.30732712149620056,
0.2660995423793793,
0.1904486119747162,
-0.8318086862564087,
0.3424206078052521,
-0.11133112758398056,
1.0561745166778564,
0.4837690591812134,
-0.010190841741859913,
0.6375839114189148,
-0.5087194442749023,
0.5595117807388306,
0.4296802580356598,
-0.7220550775527954,
0.21765746176242828,
-0.10098233073949814,
0.4365956783294678,
0.8325440287590027,
0.7228233218193054,
-0.7689483761787415,
-0.3916357755661011,
-0.7221495509147644,
-0.7639997601509094,
0.4387008249759674,
-0.12756486237049103,
-0.16228815913200378,
-0.06281795352697372,
-0.04980812594294548,
0.06113049015402794,
0.0449703074991703,
-0.5115330815315247,
-0.2710875868797302,
-0.07419741153717041,
-0.31226858496665955,
-0.1301749348640442,
-0.1286384016275406,
-0.4979342222213745,
-0.09350983053445816,
0.41311514377593994,
0.028891559690237045,
0.1887003481388092,
0.24901649355888367,
-0.30225473642349243,
-0.29727035760879517,
0.29184040427207947,
0.48255595564842224,
0.8070381879806519,
0.006534733343869448,
0.2205350399017334,
0.02032674476504326,
-0.6805598139762878,
-0.0585869625210762,
0.4137156307697296,
0.04398530721664429,
0.2457003891468048,
0.7387703657150269,
0.6992159485816956,
0.47120121121406555,
-0.8243873715400696,
0.8265899419784546,
-0.1596350371837616,
0.10509510338306427,
-0.2800152599811554,
-0.17246785759925842,
0.20512479543685913,
0.07066887617111206,
-0.09292285144329071,
0.008967449888586998,
0.12874992191791534,
-0.5001443028450012,
0.20693707466125488,
0.533919095993042,
-0.7544423937797546,
-0.28907644748687744,
0.49624449014663696,
0.2258266806602478,
-0.03398386016488075,
0.45584145188331604,
0.4949878752231598,
-0.3737740218639374,
0.6340430974960327,
0.40018171072006226,
0.5974487662315369,
-0.3713168203830719,
0.1538642793893814,
0.08553467690944672,
0.6394354701042175,
-0.10429202765226364,
0.09741970896720886,
0.30270707607269287,
-0.7833378911018372,
-0.49058303236961365,
-0.4448883831501007,
-0.388871431350708,
0.13268053531646729,
-0.9249885678291321,
0.17390042543411255,
-0.03691169247031212,
-0.2504621744155884,
-0.1680663526058197,
-0.13243918120861053,
-1.0685945749282837,
0.44873690605163574,
0.41968315839767456,
1.1966758966445923,
-1.1967836618423462,
0.9559755325317383,
0.7238444089889526,
-0.4524717628955841,
-0.6657438278198242,
0.5001236200332642,
0.13459311425685883,
-1.1196504831314087,
0.6221306324005127,
0.14104236662387848,
0.00485692173242569,
-0.4447508454322815,
-0.20464622974395752,
-0.7560868859291077,
0.7192620635032654,
0.49692636728286743,
-0.8194971680641174,
-0.2216588854789734,
0.6142668724060059,
0.6120574474334717,
-0.6065911650657654,
0.30441489815711975,
0.7215514183044434,
0.44852474331855774,
-0.3366428315639496,
-1.1444741487503052,
-0.055781494826078415,
-0.3027294874191284,
0.12344519793987274,
0.11718433350324631,
-0.2939366102218628,
0.6787405014038086,
-0.07470172643661499,
-0.16433186829090118,
-0.3066752254962921,
0.12523795664310455,
0.427627295255661,
0.31049033999443054,
0.5496610403060913,
0.7617852091789246,
0.7346852421760559,
-0.15070191025733948,
1.3156800270080566,
-0.34303048253059387,
0.06367543339729309,
1.0639657974243164,
-0.6195803284645081,
0.41122952103614807,
0.4881613850593567,
-0.4884718656539917,
0.3362535834312439,
0.6143710017204285,
0.49782106280326843,
0.3048880696296692,
0.630741536617279,
-0.2767999470233917,
-0.09731229394674301,
-0.25535881519317627,
-0.6852771639823914,
0.26438936591148376,
0.5281583070755005,
-0.7094209790229797,
-0.37443599104881287,
-0.056738462299108505,
0.2275201380252838,
0.17313525080680847,
-0.23103518784046173,
0.4644036591053009,
0.34382015466690063,
-0.4787878096103668,
0.42036888003349304,
-0.34109970927238464,
0.6129480600357056,
-0.7419971823692322,
-0.11324594169855118,
-0.11247222125530243,
0.023691406473517418,
-0.38094818592071533,
-0.4907655417919159,
0.42515191435813904,
-0.014895319938659668,
-0.29265353083610535,
-0.33340683579444885,
0.5267988443374634,
-0.8120512366294861,
-0.5610087513923645,
0.744768500328064,
0.7657497525215149,
0.24473629891872406,
0.0799272209405899,
-0.6994404792785645,
0.4307902157306671,
-0.17198091745376587,
0.09358787536621094,
0.46940115094184875,
0.411905974149704,
-0.47223907709121704,
0.508704662322998,
0.5599130988121033,
0.6715812087059021,
0.17129375040531158,
0.48509353399276733,
0.786069929599762,
-0.27396851778030396,
-0.181333988904953,
-0.7819225788116455,
0.3192991018295288,
-0.04437459260225296,
-0.5398820638656616,
0.669701099395752,
0.5307763814926147,
0.768974781036377,
0.11913558840751648,
1.0084863901138306,
0.12758545577526093,
0.6107519865036011,
-0.4340822398662567,
0.850685179233551,
-0.6421480178833008,
0.06218889728188515,
-0.14601550996303558,
-0.4024462103843689,
-0.4937376379966736,
0.41056036949157715,
-0.8555976748466492,
0.16577893495559692,
0.6978951096534729,
0.5960579514503479,
-0.1490798443555832,
-0.08080229163169861,
0.22354735434055328,
0.08758619427680969,
0.11798717826604843,
0.49417644739151,
0.7111126184463501,
-0.1358788162469864,
0.1549353450536728,
-0.06749485433101654,
-0.18585175275802612,
-0.15839803218841553,
-0.9904098510742188,
-0.7251332402229309,
-0.06540688872337341,
-0.2089872658252716,
-0.43527668714523315,
0.32499635219573975,
0.8980942368507385,
0.865622341632843,
-0.998451292514801,
-0.20947512984275818,
0.12329578399658203,
-0.061794545501470566,
-0.15000519156455994,
-0.11934984475374222,
0.44142115116119385,
-0.08048422634601593,
-0.6477999687194824,
0.07668282836675644,
0.09708362817764282,
-0.12464946508407593,
-0.5611606240272522,
-0.18900001049041748,
-0.11832117289304733,
-0.30449366569519043,
0.3998261094093323,
0.2941589653491974,
-0.7346591949462891,
0.17660783231258392,
-0.12561680376529694,
-0.48876023292541504,
0.19837582111358643,
1.0606549978256226,
-0.6054166555404663,
0.38482221961021423,
0.2971625328063965,
0.7837706804275513,
0.2259700745344162,
-0.06589389592409134,
0.9413655400276184,
-0.2915659546852112,
0.05584482103586197,
0.4911317825317383,
0.5016674399375916,
0.4272601306438446,
-0.3628423810005188,
0.24470749497413635,
0.12450207769870758,
-0.3699827194213867,
-0.8046627640724182,
0.1326684206724167,
-0.8439667820930481,
-0.05662905052304268,
0.9976493120193481,
-0.379892498254776,
-0.17895002663135529,
-0.3419162929058075,
0.06978261470794678,
0.5063908696174622,
-0.20040535926818848,
0.7348167896270752,
0.4169718027114868,
-0.01208555605262518,
-0.1676878035068512,
-0.9882756471633911,
0.6692736148834229,
0.6407970190048218,
-1.0361520051956177,
-0.034043796360492706,
0.41468778252601624,
0.5103189945220947,
-0.17818468809127808,
1.0124551057815552,
-0.5616612434387207,
0.3082121014595032,
-0.3269827961921692,
0.43634700775146484,
0.4222720265388489,
-0.008213541470468044,
-0.22872619330883026,
-0.27289968729019165,
-0.16399851441383362,
0.20100805163383484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05496v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05496v1
|
Boosting Large Language Models with Continual Learning for Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-05-09T02:00:07 | 2024-05-09T02:00:07 |
Xuanwen Ding, Jie Zhou, Liang Dou, Qin Chen, Yuanbin Wu, Chengcai Chen, Liang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aspect-based sentiment analysis (ABSA) is an important subtask of sentiment
analysis, which aims to extract the aspects and predict their sentiments. Most
existing studies focus on improving the performance of the target domain by
fine-tuning domain-specific models (trained on source domains) based on the
target domain dataset. Few works propose continual learning tasks for ABSA,
which aim to learn the target domain's ability while maintaining the history
domains' abilities. In this paper, we propose a Large Language Model-based
Continual Learning (\texttt{LLM-CL}) model for ABSA. First, we design a domain
knowledge decoupling module to learn a domain-invariant adapter and separate
domain-variant adapters dependently with an orthogonal constraint. Then, we
introduce a domain knowledge warmup strategy to align the representation
between domain-invariant and domain-variant knowledge. In the test phase, we
index the corresponding domain-variant knowledge via domain positioning to not
require each sample's domain ID. Extensive experiments over 19 datasets
indicate that our \texttt{LLM-CL} model obtains new state-of-the-art
performance.
|
[
-0.35614290833473206,
-0.7731819748878479,
0.631747305393219,
0.23470991849899292,
-0.6241713762283325,
0.201168030500412,
-0.40952643752098083,
-0.47770076990127563,
0.007285826839506626,
0.5599914789199829,
-0.5683069825172424,
-0.5945331454277039,
-0.43902426958084106,
-0.01168058905750513,
-0.050961390137672424,
1.126082181930542,
-0.09914736449718475,
-0.020169401541352272,
-0.32708361744880676,
-0.44431981444358826,
-0.7262871861457825,
-0.7320266366004944,
-0.7363407015800476,
-0.3220047652721405,
0.40355393290519714,
0.3782619833946228,
0.2832120656967163,
0.29413068294525146,
0.31913724541664124,
0.12774574756622314,
-0.10793708264827728,
0.2442065328359604,
-0.3969093859195709,
0.4625691771507263,
-0.6647135615348816,
-0.3463444113731384,
-0.6138383746147156,
-0.18635571002960205,
0.5723819136619568,
0.8250760436058044,
0.03888768330216408,
-0.051985085010528564,
0.3162483870983124,
0.7213225960731506,
-0.4348384439945221,
0.377608060836792,
-0.8030308485031128,
-0.35615265369415283,
0.04183245822787285,
0.11846049129962921,
-0.4737177789211273,
-0.23270051181316376,
0.1046522781252861,
-0.28588491678237915,
0.10495327413082123,
0.16856345534324646,
0.985156238079071,
0.030524546280503273,
-0.13159433007240295,
-0.049514010548591614,
-0.7433587312698364,
1.2149584293365479,
-0.710767388343811,
0.43707728385925293,
0.19693075120449066,
-0.20504455268383026,
0.19448933005332947,
-0.24512727558612823,
-0.4826921224594116,
-0.17743927240371704,
0.1749912053346634,
0.13082920014858246,
-0.008469633758068085,
0.00718380231410265,
-0.22745291888713837,
0.44423550367355347,
-0.4334242641925812,
0.21204622089862823,
-0.017392413690686226,
0.03288066387176514,
0.5853753089904785,
0.10625442117452621,
0.17279715836048126,
0.041102975606918335,
-0.3917076587677002,
0.1885848343372345,
-1.0206862688064575,
-0.21744635701179504,
-0.13089966773986816,
0.444771945476532,
-0.12850630283355713,
0.3250296413898468,
-0.1530287265777588,
0.539524495601654,
0.32402563095092773,
0.005824155639857054,
0.21890698373317719,
-0.07122574746608734,
-0.12535899877548218,
-0.2271249145269394,
0.4746130704879761,
0.0913553312420845,
0.07249177247285843,
-0.20117519795894623,
-0.6449019312858582,
-0.037851300090551376,
0.49534162878990173,
-0.5992248058319092,
-0.309677392244339,
0.3741881549358368,
-0.3265638053417206,
-0.046583328396081924,
-0.01701832376420498,
-0.7995815277099609,
-0.16584955155849457,
-0.7033303380012512,
0.35525277256965637,
-0.6825628280639648,
-0.43048006296157837,
-0.14236809313297272,
0.44831952452659607,
0.26417452096939087,
0.21625691652297974,
-0.5418718457221985,
0.08388154953718185,
1.0390148162841797,
0.9899697303771973,
-0.6377832889556885,
-0.3252723813056946,
-0.4411943256855011,
-0.08255438506603241,
-0.3844429850578308,
0.8924756050109863,
-0.7820591330528259,
-0.3067414462566376,
0.33808788657188416,
0.10126683861017227,
-0.025586241856217384,
-0.7566738128662109,
0.20166024565696716,
-0.8657028079032898,
-0.05536416545510292,
-0.19290587306022644,
-0.6975268721580505,
-0.4720877408981323,
0.5467569828033447,
-0.5013373494148254,
0.7271084785461426,
0.26695555448532104,
-0.3296835124492645,
0.3541596233844757,
-0.4916941523551941,
-0.42607083916664124,
0.08196575194597244,
0.056031908839941025,
-0.8375353217124939,
0.3049992322921753,
0.22784759104251862,
0.6513968706130981,
-0.12755824625492096,
0.33017173409461975,
-0.48640504479408264,
0.2428116500377655,
0.3383379280567169,
-0.26453912258148193,
0.21210743486881256,
0.08243932574987411,
-0.20594212412834167,
0.030772684141993523,
-0.4878927171230316,
-0.21122649312019348,
-0.053100068122148514,
-0.24005292356014252,
-0.5577359795570374,
0.05877210199832916,
-0.08029624819755554,
0.3185866177082062,
0.5198198556900024,
-0.49788281321525574,
0.3238386809825897,
-0.5601648688316345,
0.05820108577609062,
0.720962405204773,
0.5011869668960571,
0.4525863826274872,
-0.4871080219745636,
0.6151503920555115,
0.5108152627944946,
0.23331905901432037,
-0.24576415121555328,
-0.19765791296958923,
-1.0144740343093872,
-0.20173148810863495,
0.20700283348560333,
0.3576715290546417,
-0.8525812029838562,
0.7376835346221924,
-0.4337694048881531,
-0.36507004499435425,
-0.15530632436275482,
0.5120350122451782,
0.4583524465560913,
0.09471958875656128,
0.4497697353363037,
-0.6733365654945374,
-0.30725744366645813,
-0.5012160539627075,
0.10244428366422653,
-0.16730481386184692,
0.22538341581821442,
0.179695263504982,
0.4588944911956787,
-0.17686709761619568,
1.1199727058410645,
-0.5338068604469299,
-0.408756285905838,
-0.7188283801078796,
0.1590086668729782,
0.17177684605121613,
0.39537110924720764,
0.5209901928901672,
-0.7447515726089478,
-0.35114404559135437,
0.1623365730047226,
-0.7755110263824463,
-0.01287058088928461,
-0.29276391863822937,
-0.1808260977268219,
0.4936552941799164,
0.20397785305976868,
-0.43996304273605347,
0.027212336659431458,
0.5413792133331299,
-0.11854316294193268,
0.6223190426826477,
0.11181242763996124,
-0.19483953714370728,
-1.2250767946243286,
0.021502690389752388,
0.22445759177207947,
-0.3696693181991577,
-0.5236850380897522,
0.13469867408275604,
0.0037319830153137445,
-0.05875850096344948,
-0.48474928736686707,
0.6563407182693481,
-0.4303972125053406,
0.22729258239269257,
-0.6559757590293884,
0.14649344980716705,
0.04570266976952553,
0.7250433564186096,
0.2860246002674103,
0.49325767159461975,
0.6273180842399597,
-0.8691319227218628,
0.05786404013633728,
-0.08292050659656525,
-0.056965406984090805,
0.7720363140106201,
-0.47612109780311584,
0.2760447561740875,
0.06321945041418076,
0.09507007151842117,
-0.5969924330711365,
-0.0052175577729940414,
0.08334235101938248,
-0.3157438337802887,
0.5017973184585571,
-0.20249131321907043,
-0.1320762038230896,
-0.07419247925281525,
-0.19236084818840027,
0.44402143359184265,
0.4021592438220978,
-0.6759898662567139,
0.9386299848556519,
0.44933265447616577,
-0.5014461874961853,
-0.5323642492294312,
-0.05618719011545181,
-0.05121524631977081,
-0.2389919012784958,
-0.2370641827583313,
0.20442622900009155,
-0.04437500238418579,
-0.3181205987930298,
0.08284221589565277,
-0.07190153747797012,
-0.12050551921129227,
-0.02802550606429577,
0.379400372505188,
0.36482149362564087,
-0.22434407472610474,
0.2787775695323944,
0.09132203459739685,
0.018578097224235535,
0.08105122298002243,
-0.6047088503837585,
0.8295572400093079,
-0.20644912123680115,
-0.23716527223587036,
-0.385567843914032,
0.375993549823761,
0.5411174297332764,
-0.23753592371940613,
0.8704673647880554,
0.09624399989843369,
-0.2902042865753174,
-0.6875888109207153,
-0.6150864958763123,
-0.1973371058702469,
-0.39825883507728577,
0.4431588649749756,
-0.3365570902824402,
-0.8955705165863037,
0.5114269852638245,
-0.30465683341026306,
0.1854245364665985,
0.5171958208084106,
0.5697251558303833,
-0.042722612619400024,
0.5975176095962524,
1.0095109939575195,
-0.7680701017379761,
0.5795078873634338,
-0.3680060803890228,
0.19971494376659393,
-0.9178536534309387,
-0.03176044672727585,
-0.24358592927455902,
0.022284043952822685,
0.02613505721092224,
-0.21427901089191437,
0.23361794650554657,
0.2675161063671112,
-0.29249995946884155,
0.09180919080972672,
-0.09892692416906357,
0.36459773778915405,
0.051806382834911346,
0.19949102401733398,
0.30759772658348083,
-0.01863599382340908,
0.20201420783996582,
0.16248565912246704,
-0.4792359173297882,
-0.181056410074234,
1.0267925262451172,
0.4315994679927826,
0.7074902653694153,
0.06013215705752373,
0.5760955214500427,
0.3992668688297272,
0.6339089274406433,
-0.9783512949943542,
0.4351855218410492,
-0.37643417716026306,
-0.07532083988189697,
0.03449999913573265,
-0.38513273000717163,
-0.6872429847717285,
-0.06550339609384537,
0.04046253487467766,
-0.38182738423347473,
0.24974386394023895,
0.301771879196167,
-0.11772111058235168,
0.33717480301856995,
-0.035508524626493454,
0.5056864023208618,
-0.29024553298950195,
-0.4801909029483795,
-0.4451732039451599,
-0.24519924819469452,
0.24599963426589966,
-0.38115283846855164,
0.19000019133090973,
0.10534080117940903,
0.14813406765460968,
0.5536739826202393,
-0.20587070286273956,
1.2496447563171387,
-0.326490581035614,
-0.3168090283870697,
0.31232592463493347,
0.25457167625427246,
0.4850030839443207,
0.20831944048404694,
0.07680574059486389,
0.45001062750816345,
-0.37084102630615234,
-0.304473340511322,
-0.5449391007423401,
0.650601327419281,
-0.7973514795303345,
-0.5561991333961487,
-0.36216825246810913,
-0.3634762465953827,
-0.5305275321006775,
0.09213022887706757,
-0.05390708148479462,
0.5621092319488525,
-0.22192054986953735,
0.16378886997699738,
0.8781880140304565,
-0.17003299295902252,
0.23375855386257172,
0.7387403845787048,
-0.3591879606246948,
-0.44000229239463806,
1.1497526168823242,
-0.18735148012638092,
0.37964028120040894,
0.502271294593811,
0.02749834582209587,
-0.3326526880264282,
-0.698486864566803,
-0.29335257411003113,
0.5754601359367371,
-0.59657883644104,
-0.5840269923210144,
-0.4729331433773041,
-0.2829557955265045,
-0.2251809537410736,
-0.17411448061466217,
-0.5199423432350159,
0.013970485888421535,
-0.3052915334701538,
-0.011359826661646366,
0.40236780047416687,
0.7037818431854248,
0.043808817863464355,
0.17766417562961578,
-0.9541659951210022,
0.06233267858624458,
0.128052219748497,
0.36355963349342346,
0.12032303214073181,
-0.8176705837249756,
-0.46193984150886536,
-0.11035609245300293,
-0.4567009508609772,
-0.46691104769706726,
0.5876648426055908,
0.4366878867149353,
0.3734804391860962,
0.5219207406044006,
0.0682399645447731,
0.32336491346359253,
-0.27108708024024963,
1.0904276371002197,
0.07549604028463364,
-1.0107866525650024,
0.6592935919761658,
-0.23113521933555603,
0.32889026403427124,
0.507810115814209,
0.3881285488605499,
-0.5290957093238831,
-0.6834943294525146,
-0.3901585638523102,
-1.065338373184204,
0.37215277552604675,
-0.25101202726364136,
0.38054054975509644,
-0.05282261222600937,
0.7012566328048706,
0.3660636246204376,
0.12223806977272034,
-0.739795982837677,
-0.0644383355975151,
-0.2948397397994995,
-0.3952587842941284,
0.15299180150032043,
-0.2509273886680603,
0.03374699503183365,
-0.08397737145423889,
1.0959832668304443,
-0.402866005897522,
0.07577233761548996,
-0.11527516692876816,
-0.368033230304718,
0.06223816052079201,
0.33104845881462097,
0.28795403242111206,
0.9745610356330872,
-0.04506467655301094,
-0.06375163793563843,
0.1881970763206482,
-0.5724785923957825,
0.03177255392074585,
-0.19518215954303741,
-0.184956893324852,
-0.13777592778205872,
0.2992718815803528,
0.6596579551696777,
0.07485070824623108,
-0.6421576738357544,
0.4874078333377838,
0.17880043387413025,
0.009643652476370335,
-0.5323855876922607,
0.011782997287809849,
-0.23075833916664124,
0.1731005162000656,
0.39177456498146057,
-0.0901954174041748,
-0.3659574091434479,
-0.6006452441215515,
0.4910386800765991,
0.4319257438182831,
-0.6088234186172485,
-0.5080793499946594,
0.29528966546058655,
0.2790311276912689,
0.07295063883066177,
0.6183882355690002,
-0.39099249243736267,
-0.8582620024681091,
0.40377530455589294,
0.5033237338066101,
1.0757927894592285,
-0.30319032073020935,
0.178935706615448,
0.1779584437608719,
0.015466023236513138,
-0.19168800115585327,
0.23535391688346863,
0.05134284496307373,
-0.8846741318702698,
-0.5425445437431335,
-0.9371368288993835,
-0.6123636364936829,
0.21597568690776825,
-0.7539064288139343,
0.01735006459057331,
-0.43224236369132996,
0.06400436908006668,
-0.49969950318336487,
-0.008893502876162529,
-0.5781376361846924,
0.44881269335746765,
-0.04900583624839783,
0.6186365485191345,
-0.8821799755096436,
1.1393170356750488,
0.6322734951972961,
-0.49037081003189087,
-0.6845499873161316,
0.44299328327178955,
-0.18423046171665192,
-0.38077256083488464,
0.6973876357078552,
0.13151341676712036,
-0.2414795160293579,
-0.3043372333049774,
-0.5926413536071777,
-0.6900969743728638,
0.8830649256706238,
-0.038332242518663406,
-0.7414221167564392,
0.32663920521736145,
0.04034401476383209,
0.6293196678161621,
-0.7130581736564636,
-0.2567481994628906,
0.523303747177124,
0.060513269156217575,
-0.17649224400520325,
-0.6184356212615967,
-0.03444764018058777,
-0.12021896988153458,
0.035287342965602875,
0.19408708810806274,
-0.8070333003997803,
0.8015653491020203,
0.1195957362651825,
-0.07538022845983505,
-0.02506979927420616,
1.3108166456222534,
0.2836640775203705,
0.3990669548511505,
0.7513071894645691,
0.47423940896987915,
0.5253440737724304,
-0.07299154251813889,
0.7771193981170654,
-0.6580883860588074,
0.6028001308441162,
1.125506043434143,
-0.4994086027145386,
1.2171999216079712,
0.052248820662498474,
0.04885999485850334,
0.7978934049606323,
0.40206632018089294,
0.062382034957408905,
0.4662201404571533,
-0.19988471269607544,
-0.4820987284183502,
-0.5067850351333618,
-0.16752754151821136,
-0.05012790486216545,
0.38036975264549255,
0.7424713969230652,
-0.3547753691673279,
0.03963259607553482,
0.3565763831138611,
0.33240383863449097,
0.06583525240421295,
-0.565654456615448,
1.018916368484497,
0.35793447494506836,
-0.7448475360870361,
0.4266245663166046,
-0.008536682464182377,
0.8333337306976318,
-0.7216775417327881,
0.1208113580942154,
-0.623456597328186,
0.3230860233306885,
0.01817416027188301,
-0.6995331645011902,
0.4416517913341522,
-0.042021743953228,
-0.47989487648010254,
0.06107906252145767,
0.5368053913116455,
-0.5063343644142151,
-0.5706632733345032,
0.3856012225151062,
0.37735751271247864,
-0.1317126303911209,
-0.3099727928638458,
-0.6806978583335876,
0.16353298723697662,
-0.017496172338724136,
-0.2719936966896057,
0.5307744741439819,
0.4304105043411255,
-0.07809016853570938,
0.6888711452484131,
0.34262749552726746,
0.32554441690444946,
-0.4610850512981415,
0.1565254181623459,
1.0990349054336548,
-0.6745169758796692,
-0.44190168380737305,
-0.7793234586715698,
0.2301698625087738,
-0.05460819974541664,
-0.19213218986988068,
0.5028660297393799,
0.48155540227890015,
0.7232549786567688,
0.04293157905340195,
0.9771340489387512,
0.12940365076065063,
0.6126309633255005,
-0.892181396484375,
0.6759136319160461,
-0.6641901731491089,
0.46836933493614197,
0.02306382916867733,
-1.098106026649475,
-0.33868464827537537,
0.2650236189365387,
-0.3428182303905487,
0.07633685320615768,
0.7726333737373352,
0.7496640682220459,
-0.1235940232872963,
-0.07077392935752869,
0.23515532910823822,
0.4950523376464844,
0.4994325041770935,
0.5209833979606628,
0.6482684016227722,
0.06347998976707458,
0.16602222621440887,
-0.3591041564941406,
-0.19633495807647705,
-0.10524334013462067,
-0.7199079990386963,
-0.8548462986946106,
-0.7999361753463745,
-0.4522670805454254,
-0.458743691444397,
0.08167316019535065,
0.9968451261520386,
0.6180889010429382,
-0.9868890047073364,
0.055906832218170166,
0.17368246614933014,
0.06501505523920059,
-0.5101103782653809,
-0.34164363145828247,
0.6450165510177612,
-0.7526165843009949,
-0.6501923203468323,
0.39031001925468445,
0.48691824078559875,
-0.4128667414188385,
-0.48243799805641174,
0.10908661037683487,
0.06217270717024803,
0.25637346506118774,
0.8050577044487,
0.4041000008583069,
-0.5486310720443726,
-0.5433184504508972,
-0.341690331697464,
0.21671392023563385,
0.2159021645784378,
0.9006699323654175,
-0.7319403886795044,
0.23152916133403778,
0.17759829759597778,
0.8430319428443909,
0.09750747680664062,
0.39149975776672363,
0.5856468081474304,
-1.0236897468566895,
-0.16756249964237213,
0.2577527165412903,
0.46533599495887756,
0.5107302665710449,
-0.40757736563682556,
0.08388999104499817,
0.28901347517967224,
-0.8053306937217712,
-0.4514846205711365,
0.30367809534072876,
-1.1974074840545654,
-0.47084933519363403,
1.3989391326904297,
-0.5210248231887817,
-0.28777414560317993,
-0.49573394656181335,
0.053717028349637985,
0.036554060876369476,
-0.6235257983207703,
1.0264770984649658,
0.3996586799621582,
-0.11692070960998535,
-0.22128650546073914,
-0.13970999419689178,
0.43741679191589355,
0.4047292172908783,
-0.9719659686088562,
0.3854024112224579,
0.6008055210113525,
0.6082184314727783,
0.1527228057384491,
0.39326274394989014,
-0.04476861283183098,
0.07736623287200928,
-0.4358767569065094,
0.10981094837188721,
0.19491742551326752,
-0.7207300066947937,
-0.55959552526474,
0.3916187584400177,
0.32726263999938965,
-0.007652132771909237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05493v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05493v1
|
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning With Adapters
| 2024-05-09T01:40:38 | 2024-05-09T01:40:38 |
Keyu Chen, Yuan Pang, Zi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the arena of language model fine-tuning, the traditional approaches, such
as Domain-Adaptive Pretraining (DAPT) and Task-Adaptive Pretraining (TAPT),
although effective, but computational intensive. This research introduces a
novel adaptation method utilizing the UniPELT framework as a base and added a
PromptTuning Layer, which significantly reduces the number of trainable
parameters while maintaining competitive performance across various benchmarks.
Our method employs adapters, which enable efficient transfer of pretrained
models to new tasks with minimal retraining of the base model parameters. We
evaluate our approach using three diverse datasets: the GLUE benchmark, a
domain-specific dataset comprising four distinct areas, and the Stanford
Question Answering Dataset 1.1 (SQuAD). Our results demonstrate that our
customized adapter-based method achieves performance comparable to full model
fine-tuning, DAPT+TAPT and UniPELT strategies while requiring fewer or
equivalent amount of parameters. This parameter efficiency not only alleviates
the computational burden but also expedites the adaptation process. The study
underlines the potential of adapters in achieving high performance with
significantly reduced resource consumption, suggesting a promising direction
for future research in parameter-efficient fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.49263569712638855,
-0.6024451851844788,
0.19652286171913147,
0.07029684633016586,
-0.38523998856544495,
0.0010717458790168166,
-0.4335731565952301,
-0.018443413078784943,
-0.29609912633895874,
0.36590099334716797,
-0.5360441207885742,
-0.15132077038288116,
-0.3876335918903351,
-0.1065487414598465,
0.08407630771398544,
0.9390823841094971,
-0.13681955635547638,
-0.15993037819862366,
-0.020095517858862877,
-0.2822537422180176,
-0.573447585105896,
-0.010436647571623325,
-0.6582927703857422,
-0.05216830223798752,
0.24974896013736725,
0.6168563961982727,
0.4217393398284912,
0.7285782098770142,
0.48640382289886475,
0.25934410095214844,
0.10343224555253983,
0.2580275237560272,
-0.7051336169242859,
0.133676216006279,
-0.4590426981449127,
-0.29952672123908997,
-0.2808094322681427,
-0.22640524804592133,
0.5717175602912903,
0.8314211368560791,
-0.11526434868574142,
0.37134984135627747,
0.42277079820632935,
0.8828965425491333,
-0.8343392014503479,
0.05569189786911011,
-0.9704853296279907,
-0.3918425142765045,
-0.022118179127573967,
-0.38729459047317505,
-0.38649919629096985,
-0.23008154332637787,
-0.008614114485681057,
-0.934119462966919,
0.29333755373954773,
0.07411063462495804,
0.493969589471817,
0.5774081945419312,
-0.013231090269982815,
0.029345136135816574,
-0.607720136642456,
0.6471127271652222,
-0.7386828660964966,
0.469671368598938,
0.10196377336978912,
0.36056947708129883,
-0.3142227530479431,
-0.7829061150550842,
-0.2973814010620117,
0.1024804413318634,
0.1997373402118683,
-0.046821173280477524,
-0.3188580572605133,
0.09486273676156998,
0.1018466129899025,
0.07108291983604431,
-0.5378387570381165,
0.32637283205986023,
-0.328712522983551,
-0.12876927852630615,
0.4005241096019745,
-0.0025447208900004625,
0.18200547993183136,
0.30356672406196594,
-0.1799592673778534,
-0.06573811918497086,
-0.48293381929397583,
0.26364365220069885,
0.011614466086030006,
0.6368141174316406,
0.04145277291536331,
0.044850025326013565,
-0.3750637471675873,
0.8584446907043457,
0.4758327007293701,
0.1817592978477478,
-0.005740474443882704,
-0.2936031222343445,
-0.027836160734295845,
-0.2514374256134033,
0.6090882420539856,
0.5473055243492126,
0.4924009442329407,
-0.360938161611557,
0.035129155963659286,
-0.2118411660194397,
0.2760937809944153,
-1.189510464668274,
-0.760627269744873,
-0.11200962215662003,
-0.34908780455589294,
0.02324720472097397,
-0.30036982893943787,
-0.7341600060462952,
-0.3666141927242279,
-0.3381049931049347,
0.5335426330566406,
-0.41005924344062805,
-0.030515192076563835,
0.30897051095962524,
-0.12917330861091614,
0.2014557272195816,
0.47362327575683594,
-1.0357688665390015,
0.5007216930389404,
0.3684285879135132,
0.760627806186676,
-0.3449680507183075,
-0.3612096309661865,
-0.7779392600059509,
0.0018078827997669578,
-0.31979089975357056,
0.9758392572402954,
-0.7431028485298157,
-0.14155299961566925,
-0.3112489581108093,
0.06773347407579422,
-0.5468100309371948,
-0.5414236187934875,
0.543078601360321,
-0.5112779140472412,
-0.041202254593372345,
-0.30228644609451294,
-0.5902894139289856,
-0.1212555393576622,
-0.0037100748158991337,
-0.4978793263435364,
1.0686415433883667,
0.22709637880325317,
-0.4697517156600952,
0.45021843910217285,
-0.9151725172996521,
-0.41797661781311035,
0.05168728157877922,
0.20336483418941498,
-0.10758332163095474,
0.3719627261161804,
0.4545538127422333,
0.4976032078266144,
-0.4998001158237457,
-0.08487626910209656,
-0.4590790271759033,
-0.4704703390598297,
0.05069674178957939,
-0.4479494094848633,
0.5322821736335754,
0.2574501931667328,
-0.09661296755075455,
0.15699753165245056,
-1.0250566005706787,
0.28361159563064575,
-0.07487767934799194,
-0.4806238114833832,
-0.4112241864204407,
-0.10698051005601883,
0.13320668041706085,
0.1815623641014099,
0.17817972600460052,
-0.49643653631210327,
0.34989291429519653,
-0.25302496552467346,
0.4939187169075012,
0.6601155996322632,
-0.05792952701449394,
0.6486693620681763,
-0.2425926923751831,
0.40959876775741577,
-0.03358226642012596,
-0.0772743821144104,
-0.23612280189990997,
0.00302928127348423,
-0.8681125640869141,
-0.40628114342689514,
0.5942388772964478,
0.4602912366390228,
-0.5774908065795898,
0.43425291776657104,
-0.245835542678833,
-0.6468571424484253,
-0.7747003436088562,
0.30475127696990967,
0.3209143877029419,
0.6437559723854065,
0.48082461953163147,
-0.23933996260166168,
-0.40499448776245117,
-0.6280636787414551,
-0.5885583162307739,
0.029313165694475174,
-0.13183711469173431,
0.31062039732933044,
0.20271073281764984,
0.251302570104599,
0.8401795625686646,
-0.6085400581359863,
-0.0785670056939125,
-0.2118305265903473,
0.05733552947640419,
0.1678856909275055,
0.5528605580329895,
0.8174627423286438,
-0.5443245768547058,
-0.7997825741767883,
0.07129418104887009,
-0.1609942615032196,
-0.21752643585205078,
-0.07482817769050598,
-0.06376928091049194,
-0.027469763532280922,
0.5881073474884033,
-0.16462190449237823,
0.060108255594968796,
0.4897334575653076,
-0.3651438057422638,
0.2571658194065094,
-0.5326071977615356,
0.22615520656108856,
-1.0529998540878296,
0.22869102656841278,
-0.17237818241119385,
-0.22557684779167175,
-0.9352820515632629,
-0.10965810716152191,
0.1878739893436432,
0.02147185429930687,
-0.40859076380729675,
0.707808792591095,
-0.4799644351005554,
0.3628329634666443,
-0.4338622987270355,
-0.003930517006665468,
0.02210560254752636,
0.6101386547088623,
-0.25292399525642395,
1.1039955615997314,
0.8300449252128601,
-0.8111633062362671,
0.0356718935072422,
0.2373841404914856,
-0.17828495800495148,
0.4275251030921936,
-0.6793995499610901,
0.34532326459884644,
-0.14725643396377563,
-0.08493407070636749,
-1.1877636909484863,
0.030891668051481247,
0.14610359072685242,
-0.2198564112186432,
0.14788714051246643,
-0.3313784897327423,
-0.3431430757045746,
-0.18251314759254456,
-0.43214520812034607,
0.5154314637184143,
0.5589233040809631,
-0.5846583843231201,
0.5646016597747803,
0.13423429429531097,
-0.3535807132720947,
-0.13490603864192963,
-0.3083031475543976,
-0.2333328127861023,
-0.37800103425979614,
-0.3305782377719879,
0.41106313467025757,
-0.37563273310661316,
0.29670917987823486,
-0.27200374007225037,
-0.2595459222793579,
-0.4916020333766937,
0.47314801812171936,
-0.12506943941116333,
-0.07038172334432602,
-0.4803912043571472,
-0.1084444597363472,
0.34691113233566284,
-0.17317789793014526,
-0.2881142497062683,
-0.37458130717277527,
0.4067186713218689,
-0.06864296644926071,
-0.2244812399148941,
-0.452593594789505,
0.06600813567638397,
0.7613362073898315,
-0.3071311414241791,
0.6675084233283997,
0.5891397595405579,
-0.19431054592132568,
-0.3855409026145935,
-0.5270671844482422,
-0.2485329806804657,
-0.5070865750312805,
0.5157699584960938,
-0.4837087094783783,
-0.9331790804862976,
0.7066987752914429,
-0.550724983215332,
0.15844294428825378,
0.08486033231019974,
0.43758073449134827,
0.06851805001497269,
0.827145516872406,
0.6547659039497375,
-0.2553280293941498,
0.568440854549408,
0.2268320918083191,
0.12555208802223206,
-0.96327805519104,
0.29406049847602844,
-0.6946480870246887,
-0.4988139271736145,
-0.6580381989479065,
-0.5157999396324158,
0.061264269053936005,
0.46232476830482483,
-0.3035678565502167,
0.6382589340209961,
-0.4964843988418579,
0.629698634147644,
0.4273112714290619,
0.06740385293960571,
0.16388803720474243,
-0.22583603858947754,
-0.025826232507824898,
-0.03701552748680115,
-0.8978660702705383,
-0.3247823119163513,
1.1494975090026855,
0.10486352443695068,
0.7044180631637573,
0.09999153763055801,
0.21289654076099396,
0.055713340640068054,
-0.14237210154533386,
-0.3958503007888794,
0.3919524550437927,
-0.5425847768783569,
-0.41932326555252075,
-0.44393643736839294,
-0.09822087734937668,
-0.8184880614280701,
0.42469125986099243,
-0.09786992520093918,
-0.9426426887512207,
0.5221614837646484,
0.49142682552337646,
-0.5509841442108154,
0.1476009041070938,
-0.7193280458450317,
0.9096383452415466,
-0.09385321289300919,
-0.40814220905303955,
-0.17774853110313416,
-0.5061473250389099,
-0.32428720593452454,
-0.36240479350090027,
-0.011944829486310482,
-0.42955660820007324,
-0.0668577328324318,
0.7211170792579651,
-0.014157232828438282,
0.7646890878677368,
-0.5287805795669556,
0.2559698522090912,
0.03673604875802994,
0.06315027177333832,
0.49445340037345886,
-0.04275458678603172,
-0.39169999957084656,
-0.22605857253074646,
0.2189359962940216,
-0.5793547034263611,
-0.8415869474411011,
0.549538254737854,
-0.6563841700553894,
-0.382454514503479,
0.21297666430473328,
-0.9418849945068359,
-0.5843262076377869,
0.5788891315460205,
0.08232403546571732,
0.43060168623924255,
-0.39969000220298767,
0.3822158873081207,
0.5943335294723511,
0.006287974305450916,
0.5905898213386536,
0.9088053107261658,
0.20222695171833038,
-0.16911081969738007,
0.8820043206214905,
-0.039276089519262314,
0.253861665725708,
0.4434313178062439,
0.27399367094039917,
-0.12356220930814743,
-0.9766638875007629,
-0.5581440329551697,
0.06915441155433655,
-0.42344027757644653,
-0.24276867508888245,
-0.2539219558238983,
0.005438362248241901,
-0.32492175698280334,
-0.23196721076965332,
-0.6438063383102417,
-0.41571909189224243,
-0.453289657831192,
0.2351403683423996,
0.5393450260162354,
0.20160242915153503,
0.1934056431055069,
0.7006760835647583,
-0.6112494468688965,
0.35472923517227173,
0.0945945456624031,
0.7203823328018188,
-0.29660698771476746,
-1.0394753217697144,
-0.25227469205856323,
0.06102024391293526,
-0.1989385038614273,
-0.41838860511779785,
-0.011671376414597034,
0.7952932119369507,
0.7130630612373352,
0.23695774376392365,
0.4840039312839508,
0.9748013019561768,
-0.6767269968986511,
0.3822186291217804,
-0.20868198573589325,
-0.8620157241821289,
0.37738126516342163,
-0.5213889479637146,
0.46025538444519043,
1.1918988227844238,
0.286055326461792,
-0.143023282289505,
0.00004586248905980028,
-0.2027030736207962,
-0.5785394906997681,
0.7482997179031372,
0.055355004966259,
0.327686071395874,
0.3711828589439392,
0.6847440600395203,
0.2705826759338379,
0.12319251149892807,
-0.18791358172893524,
-0.22870466113090515,
-0.08685752749443054,
-0.335464745759964,
-0.19320717453956604,
-0.0698571428656578,
0.15907597541809082,
-0.5565017461776733,
0.5333558320999146,
-0.6459439992904663,
0.101445272564888,
-0.17054228484630585,
-0.46009865403175354,
0.044319286942481995,
0.3959805965423584,
0.48311907052993774,
0.7648884654045105,
-0.17292705178260803,
-0.0823650136590004,
0.6221392154693604,
-0.3136252462863922,
0.11744868010282516,
0.4391429126262665,
-0.054296329617500305,
-0.1896076202392578,
0.07635728269815445,
1.1574779748916626,
0.5209245085716248,
-0.5389461517333984,
0.3495645225048065,
-0.09851773828268051,
-0.2626780569553375,
0.3773973286151886,
0.4246465563774109,
0.05247848480939865,
0.23976409435272217,
0.08925890922546387,
0.29928699135780334,
0.22811752557754517,
-0.15257835388183594,
0.31333836913108826,
0.32274219393730164,
-0.46551501750946045,
-0.631122350692749,
0.5726410746574402,
0.31621453166007996,
-0.22162561118602753,
0.3223133683204651,
0.1952909678220749,
-0.11513856053352356,
0.21622821688652039,
0.7108535170555115,
0.7254088521003723,
-0.537408173084259,
-0.034873563796281815,
0.20100414752960205,
0.03632809966802597,
-0.04299191012978554,
0.15680499374866486,
-0.19659797847270966,
-0.8043031692504883,
-0.35020631551742554,
-0.5275052189826965,
-0.19954527914524078,
0.051479969173669815,
-0.8002356290817261,
0.25972893834114075,
-0.4780255854129791,
0.11432008445262909,
0.1230226680636406,
-0.1675877869129181,
-0.6727796196937561,
0.04225465655326843,
-0.1931251585483551,
1.1688041687011719,
-0.8741841316223145,
0.8621538281440735,
1.0576127767562866,
0.037612464278936386,
-0.6361932158470154,
0.0786793977022171,
-0.25160497426986694,
-0.9295098185539246,
0.06345339864492416,
-0.045476339757442474,
-0.1571837067604065,
0.44532135128974915,
-0.02960406430065632,
-0.9118487238883972,
0.9390929937362671,
0.8181949257850647,
-0.6649076342582703,
-0.07983001321554184,
0.12229617685079575,
0.5861340761184692,
-0.2895009219646454,
0.2122788280248642,
0.9604381322860718,
0.37876182794570923,
0.025657104328274727,
-1.1369940042495728,
0.19685086607933044,
-0.387668639421463,
0.2352280467748642,
0.23158328235149384,
-0.5584294199943542,
0.5325367450714111,
-0.09238626807928085,
0.0440523661673069,
0.06889933347702026,
0.6208484172821045,
-0.0078033022582530975,
-0.09281730651855469,
0.6042382121086121,
0.14246417582035065,
0.8907692432403564,
0.18721406161785126,
0.5008119940757751,
-0.6632623076438904,
0.308609277009964,
1.1704771518707275,
-0.1369321048259735,
0.9587128162384033,
0.5104774236679077,
-0.09405867010354996,
0.333650678396225,
0.3076971173286438,
0.009116016328334808,
0.7849965691566467,
0.2465202361345291,
-0.009361366741359234,
-0.42608100175857544,
-0.0007944433600641787,
-0.12263471633195877,
0.568199634552002,
0.09608767181634903,
-0.07655952125787735,
-0.391561895608902,
0.1647467315196991,
-0.08023640513420105,
0.17509914934635162,
-0.2106267213821411,
1.0968940258026123,
-0.21268931031227112,
-0.6916998028755188,
0.7577893733978271,
-0.14386595785617828,
0.5385399460792542,
-0.38733378052711487,
0.17151428759098053,
-0.15798646211624146,
0.5703776478767395,
0.0717950388789177,
-0.5725904703140259,
0.11649345606565475,
-0.09237246960401535,
-0.34558895230293274,
-0.23948808014392853,
0.7993351221084595,
-0.4023236036300659,
-0.44997140765190125,
0.12445726990699768,
0.48826366662979126,
-0.08598917722702026,
-0.21767573058605194,
-0.8033480048179626,
-0.00894754659384489,
0.07430907338857651,
-0.25062817335128784,
0.5156959891319275,
0.47548988461494446,
-0.03577558696269989,
0.6587551832199097,
0.5239937901496887,
0.05728116258978844,
0.04182702675461769,
0.020184028893709183,
1.182771921157837,
-0.38230082392692566,
-0.5309731364250183,
-0.6892140507698059,
0.6336907148361206,
0.14224399626255035,
-0.5639995336532593,
0.6101396083831787,
0.5613747835159302,
0.7193054556846619,
-0.12124548107385635,
0.830233097076416,
0.10625279694795609,
0.6905825734138489,
-0.47609689831733704,
0.7351322174072266,
-0.4275793433189392,
0.2212333232164383,
-0.3438066244125366,
-0.8758717775344849,
-0.34847748279571533,
0.518268346786499,
-0.18532390892505646,
0.11295823007822037,
0.47082236409187317,
0.8173782229423523,
-0.45051485300064087,
-0.05590226128697395,
0.2431231141090393,
0.05037360265851021,
0.24824729561805725,
0.4550419747829437,
0.32386142015457153,
-0.5197739601135254,
0.49847111105918884,
-0.23131069540977478,
-0.3862190544605255,
-0.18775252997875214,
-1.0033286809921265,
-1.0651460886001587,
-0.6698169112205505,
-0.48928067088127136,
0.17822450399398804,
0.4248403012752533,
0.8291826844215393,
0.8914461135864258,
-1.066740870475769,
-0.1459975391626358,
-0.16629359126091003,
-0.3402942419052124,
-0.25652405619621277,
-0.12210193276405334,
0.5022901296615601,
-0.5383027791976929,
-0.5078420639038086,
0.5118833780288696,
0.1188899502158165,
-0.27505502104759216,
0.3756478726863861,
-0.02602803148329258,
0.11806897073984146,
0.09585406631231308,
0.4446031153202057,
0.3796493113040924,
-0.5354366302490234,
-0.33790990710258484,
0.08682497590780258,
0.37651515007019043,
0.18142932653427124,
0.7811732292175293,
-0.7065368294715881,
0.4690554440021515,
0.5026147365570068,
0.984521210193634,
0.29208189249038696,
0.20950578153133392,
0.7694573402404785,
-0.575773298740387,
0.08260173350572586,
0.04252951592206955,
0.16396711766719818,
0.200107142329216,
-0.08646289259195328,
0.12187254428863525,
-0.1427197903394699,
-0.5832892060279846,
-0.7805151343345642,
0.07219522446393967,
-0.9130346775054932,
-0.37267404794692993,
0.8825931549072266,
-0.17542240023612976,
-0.016494639217853546,
-0.2874335050582886,
-0.3382677435874939,
0.18885351717472076,
-0.43458113074302673,
0.6172547340393066,
0.3706643283367157,
-0.36923304200172424,
-0.39428621530532837,
-0.3064568042755127,
0.5944885015487671,
0.5209360718727112,
-0.8293291926383972,
0.5440909266471863,
0.1490022838115692,
0.6110044717788696,
-0.24409668147563934,
0.4701346158981323,
0.2658497989177704,
0.38895851373672485,
-0.18866907060146332,
-0.1734752655029297,
-0.2665206491947174,
-0.2839256823062897,
-0.4030129611492157,
0.0021400656551122665,
0.5225793123245239,
-0.41484683752059937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06704v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06704v1
|
Enhanced Review Detection and Recognition: A Platform-Agnostic Approach with Application to Online Commerce
| 2024-05-09T00:32:22 | 2024-05-09T00:32:22 |
Priyabrata Karmakar, John Hawkins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Online commerce relies heavily on user generated reviews to provide unbiased
information about products that they have not physically seen. The importance
of reviews has attracted multiple exploitative online behaviours and requires
methods for monitoring and detecting reviews. We present a machine learning
methodology for review detection and extraction, and demonstrate that it
generalises for use across websites that were not contained in the training
data. This method promises to drive applications for automatic detection and
evaluation of reviews, regardless of their source. Furthermore, we showcase the
versatility of our method by implementing and discussing three key applications
for analysing reviews: Sentiment Inconsistency Analysis, which detects and
filters out unreliable reviews based on inconsistencies between ratings and
comments; Multi-language support, enabling the extraction and translation of
reviews from various languages without relying on HTML scraping; and Fake
review detection, achieved by integrating a trained NLP model to identify and
distinguish between genuine and fake reviews.
|
[
-0.47519543766975403,
-0.6995970010757446,
0.19950321316719055,
0.4917149245738983,
-0.3283619284629822,
0.18269827961921692,
0.1734764128923416,
-1.0897586345672607,
0.5298823714256287,
0.5547757148742676,
-0.5779570937156677,
-0.45794710516929626,
-0.42918655276298523,
0.22129419445991516,
-0.36675015091896057,
0.9809381365776062,
-0.04223660007119179,
0.3721848726272583,
-0.17272713780403137,
-0.34629249572753906,
-0.12052604556083679,
-0.8070012331008911,
-0.5211971402168274,
-0.21151018142700195,
0.15536369383335114,
0.09116683900356293,
0.4413328170776367,
-0.08379390835762024,
0.6264552474021912,
0.27196788787841797,
0.15606091916561127,
0.7684966921806335,
-0.06108831241726875,
-0.004139207303524017,
-0.028349922969937325,
-0.3706492781639099,
-0.5605887174606323,
0.18179573118686676,
0.1578746885061264,
0.3080742657184601,
0.03478395938873291,
0.293228417634964,
0.1971595734357834,
0.77933669090271,
-0.7996763586997986,
0.17939040064811707,
-0.5345137119293213,
0.5390732884407043,
0.2816052734851837,
-0.37454473972320557,
-0.3291219472885132,
-0.477561354637146,
-0.1973801702260971,
-0.442340612411499,
0.23222953081130981,
-0.1706668585538864,
0.8094905018806458,
0.07517456263303757,
-0.2822561264038086,
-0.8515366911888123,
-0.8791214823722839,
0.7043257355690002,
-0.3752373456954956,
0.48581358790397644,
0.19387051463127136,
0.4481021761894226,
0.08395813405513763,
-0.6690545082092285,
-0.6600632071495056,
-0.135429248213768,
-0.24240820109844208,
0.4261142909526825,
-0.4143717288970947,
-0.19815434515476227,
0.14888177812099457,
0.541060745716095,
-0.3684573769569397,
-0.0031486612278968096,
-0.12876011431217194,
-0.44185423851013184,
0.667203426361084,
0.046511225402355194,
0.12797124683856964,
-0.19145110249519348,
-0.5310547947883606,
-0.13711920380592346,
-0.4811340868473053,
0.32110795378685,
0.7410826683044434,
0.1359826773405075,
0.12435808032751083,
0.3658483028411865,
-0.31065019965171814,
0.4324437975883484,
0.3282637596130371,
0.05619826912879944,
0.6305704116821289,
-0.18409126996994019,
-0.34045860171318054,
-0.06680060923099518,
0.9089018702507019,
0.35385942459106445,
-0.07221568375825882,
0.3365675210952759,
-0.6160065531730652,
0.4904056489467621,
0.3304879367351532,
-0.47589969635009766,
-0.24404865503311157,
0.25445014238357544,
-0.8655558228492737,
-0.7053600549697876,
0.5584642291069031,
-0.8284400701522827,
-0.4740539789199829,
-0.25773584842681885,
0.43557536602020264,
0.2750258445739746,
-0.4550832211971283,
0.09808841347694397,
-0.29255640506744385,
0.15511049330234528,
0.2906683385372162,
-0.34480252861976624,
0.32671433687210083,
0.6111630797386169,
0.46060487627983093,
-0.16505920886993408,
-0.0960247591137886,
-0.570209801197052,
-0.25102755427360535,
-0.3557114899158478,
1.0104711055755615,
-0.4543222486972809,
-0.25355324149131775,
0.10878116637468338,
0.3030504584312439,
0.21778513491153717,
-0.6685877442359924,
0.5267488360404968,
-0.8633335828781128,
0.1594802588224411,
0.10279140621423721,
-0.52901691198349,
-0.46628886461257935,
0.7762009501457214,
-0.9385283589363098,
0.8744555711746216,
0.01182719599455595,
-0.6583937406539917,
0.5682386755943298,
-0.7548019289970398,
-0.48493272066116333,
-0.05795002356171608,
0.19959188997745514,
-0.9232040047645569,
0.30863744020462036,
0.6032876968383789,
0.4246770143508911,
0.270792692899704,
-0.3162453770637512,
-0.6269665956497192,
-0.17386652529239655,
0.4867689609527588,
-0.34861505031585693,
1.0336614847183228,
0.4636671543121338,
-0.4111214578151703,
0.26058098673820496,
-0.598915159702301,
0.1520821899175644,
0.07727225869894028,
-0.2734636068344116,
0.07497453689575195,
-0.1487073004245758,
0.48688849806785583,
0.15941347181797028,
0.15587107837200165,
-0.5114551186561584,
0.32811474800109863,
-0.38429877161979675,
0.39062660932540894,
0.4741486608982086,
0.49331316351890564,
-0.01314492430537939,
-0.051788829267024994,
0.6633129715919495,
0.07506902515888214,
0.4281471371650696,
-0.0642085075378418,
-0.5322437286376953,
-0.7857121825218201,
-0.054684773087501526,
0.5714995265007019,
0.7492839694023132,
-0.6854237914085388,
0.6664261221885681,
0.06762077659368515,
-0.262703537940979,
-0.4994390308856964,
0.4503459930419922,
0.17062488198280334,
-0.00833731796592474,
0.270353227853775,
-0.7152740955352783,
-0.8438007235527039,
-0.6413148045539856,
-0.520976722240448,
-0.3842960000038147,
-0.24513819813728333,
0.04587668180465698,
0.26249194145202637,
-0.7615822553634644,
0.8333927989006042,
-0.21724343299865723,
-0.5655410885810852,
-0.33513158559799194,
0.11547244340181351,
0.021001731976866722,
0.17694754898548126,
0.2804252505302429,
-0.9493071436882019,
-0.5799277424812317,
0.23693637549877167,
-0.9014163017272949,
-0.2591560482978821,
-0.17650213837623596,
0.11072967201471329,
0.3405054211616516,
0.31774765253067017,
-0.3339654207229614,
0.41195082664489746,
0.38731616735458374,
0.13164447247982025,
0.45711517333984375,
-0.10570482909679413,
0.31333398818969727,
-0.7487858533859253,
-0.1272542029619217,
0.24541592597961426,
-0.4978444576263428,
-0.38721954822540283,
0.018341507762670517,
0.26491478085517883,
-0.1379987895488739,
-0.42149558663368225,
0.22333456575870514,
-0.38313567638397217,
-0.32182660698890686,
-0.5524668097496033,
0.004124052822589874,
0.46984320878982544,
0.4023934006690979,
0.3397761881351471,
0.23928511142730713,
0.09573399275541306,
-0.6006218194961548,
0.6128961443901062,
0.21136878430843353,
-0.4711524546146393,
0.6436729431152344,
-0.2505347430706024,
0.2891329824924469,
0.10868825018405914,
0.3397703170776367,
-0.8193851709365845,
-0.22128939628601074,
0.553905189037323,
-0.8883034586906433,
0.15744510293006897,
-0.13110847771167755,
-0.6333665251731873,
-0.5945801138877869,
-0.47224584221839905,
-0.13634714484214783,
0.3477672338485718,
-0.9530001282691956,
0.6940585374832153,
0.8035785555839539,
0.09783734381198883,
-0.40737384557724,
-0.46267884969711304,
0.05409378185868263,
-0.13792362809181213,
-0.2344149500131607,
-0.03139485418796539,
0.21869312226772308,
-0.39618372917175293,
-0.08732569962739944,
-0.02151014655828476,
-0.23031163215637207,
0.0874171033501625,
0.09408601373434067,
0.2170519381761551,
-0.009036066010594368,
0.08773639798164368,
-0.006290097255259752,
-0.26154574751853943,
0.21772421896457672,
-0.2766268849372864,
0.2588546574115753,
-0.2537806034088135,
-0.497537761926651,
-0.7100642919540405,
0.2417428195476532,
0.4750975966453552,
-0.19722558557987213,
-0.061783671379089355,
0.7409868240356445,
-0.40625083446502686,
-0.4590316712856293,
-0.5937815308570862,
-0.26884204149246216,
-0.48980024456977844,
0.3094719350337982,
-0.1019076555967331,
-0.4714531898498535,
0.19936580955982208,
-0.0007226472953334451,
-0.14984919130802155,
0.6166322827339172,
0.578135073184967,
-0.14183710515499115,
1.46836256980896,
0.9208254814147949,
-0.25180143117904663,
0.3300134837627411,
0.15723411738872528,
0.5647072196006775,
-0.457474946975708,
-0.2938559949398041,
-0.3442210555076599,
-0.3122745156288147,
-0.6713376045227051,
-0.15233463048934937,
0.12061483412981033,
0.2391703873872757,
0.2073224037885666,
0.28141680359840393,
-0.7651339769363403,
0.4705001413822174,
0.5163782238960266,
0.32062968611717224,
0.43471407890319824,
0.44796645641326904,
0.04226471111178398,
0.07822614163160324,
-0.43432649970054626,
-0.49384576082229614,
1.1357836723327637,
0.5046160221099854,
0.37251609563827515,
-0.2760547399520874,
0.17096181213855743,
0.8387517333030701,
0.6261118054389954,
-0.8870696425437927,
0.37716054916381836,
-0.0005812984891235828,
-0.4381887912750244,
0.2569904029369354,
-0.2874086797237396,
-0.5948444604873657,
0.0823695957660675,
-0.3683255612850189,
-0.25104570388793945,
0.16871093213558197,
0.181757852435112,
-0.2663106918334961,
0.5036620497703552,
-0.6616526246070862,
0.5656368136405945,
-0.6764917969703674,
-0.35658299922943115,
-0.3726804554462433,
-0.38513505458831787,
0.1761585921049118,
0.04817166551947594,
0.2490411251783371,
0.2632817029953003,
0.2282654345035553,
0.48651251196861267,
-0.21287284791469574,
0.8442553877830505,
-0.2631406784057617,
0.1519743800163269,
0.592142641544342,
0.17216593027114868,
0.47527074813842773,
-0.0006014920654706657,
0.3999948799610138,
0.4756664037704468,
-0.2449202537536621,
-0.24056531488895416,
-0.3242005407810211,
0.5307138562202454,
-0.7345348596572876,
-0.0761604830622673,
-0.438602477312088,
-0.04186753183603287,
-0.44574999809265137,
-0.056855473667383194,
-0.02425277791917324,
0.014284315519034863,
-0.05517890304327011,
0.016405805945396423,
0.4863334000110626,
-0.22216689586639404,
0.33330008387565613,
0.6124752163887024,
-0.4969898462295532,
-0.7955135107040405,
1.0690453052520752,
-0.3276558518409729,
-0.18625226616859436,
0.3635985851287842,
0.30492156744003296,
-0.5267789363861084,
-0.3918827772140503,
-0.6962461471557617,
-0.11495232582092285,
-0.8832966685295105,
-0.25621622800827026,
-0.8685046434402466,
-0.1268283575773239,
-0.26597458124160767,
0.1571306586265564,
-0.18321579694747925,
-0.4576049745082855,
-0.14473514258861542,
-0.2858637869358063,
0.20846329629421234,
1.1628466844558716,
-0.24687132239341736,
0.1148448958992958,
-0.8842122554779053,
0.34598028659820557,
0.44575345516204834,
0.38108980655670166,
0.15016311407089233,
0.007478949148207903,
-0.18932534754276276,
-0.10108072310686111,
-0.63071608543396,
-0.8068543672561646,
0.6352054476737976,
0.003458937630057335,
0.5199640393257141,
0.8814011812210083,
-0.23524804413318634,
0.45784634351730347,
0.07117109000682831,
0.7841954827308655,
0.2809581756591797,
-0.8714997172355652,
0.5428719520568848,
-0.09792568534612656,
-0.0762711614370346,
0.33425748348236084,
0.7325146794319153,
-0.3104473650455475,
-0.05086437612771988,
-0.4246991276741028,
-0.5774931311607361,
0.32729560136795044,
-0.1394120156764984,
-0.02766631916165352,
0.22653831541538239,
0.14387479424476624,
0.4835883677005768,
0.5258810520172119,
-1.0783579349517822,
0.15938624739646912,
-0.318947970867157,
0.05532056465744972,
0.0542694628238678,
-0.281532347202301,
0.0864739716053009,
-0.10897290706634521,
0.8427917957305908,
-0.06798556447029114,
0.1928144097328186,
0.12549565732479095,
-0.4405347406864166,
-0.150766983628273,
-0.0025901389308273792,
0.17383693158626556,
0.45673495531082153,
0.01856880448758602,
-0.15823526680469513,
0.03527684509754181,
-0.483162522315979,
-0.21803447604179382,
-0.08913832902908325,
-0.3274224102497101,
0.13061995804309845,
0.16808149218559265,
0.2636107802391052,
-0.2162582278251648,
-0.5073762536048889,
0.5794891119003296,
-0.14972755312919617,
-0.14403465390205383,
-0.5053316950798035,
-0.35309699177742004,
-0.39209938049316406,
0.12393507361412048,
0.16690707206726074,
0.5337340235710144,
0.5557310581207275,
-0.6067955493927002,
0.41867345571517944,
0.6763256192207336,
-0.8569673299789429,
-0.40230345726013184,
0.3035986125469208,
0.28407028317451477,
-0.377536416053772,
0.4456064999103546,
-0.28561967611312866,
-0.9411877393722534,
0.49377813935279846,
0.3090830147266388,
1.2264889478683472,
-0.1887662708759308,
0.1776576042175293,
0.2697863280773163,
0.3783363997936249,
0.11950889974832535,
0.25166603922843933,
-0.4117349684238434,
-0.75737464427948,
-0.14739346504211426,
-0.6870465874671936,
-0.7623515129089355,
0.24408528208732605,
-0.7034955024719238,
0.6224610209465027,
-0.5835075974464417,
-0.09862412512302399,
0.01753361150622368,
0.036043208092451096,
-0.5145269632339478,
0.24898862838745117,
0.3923076391220093,
0.46393585205078125,
-0.9944454431533813,
0.4465430676937103,
0.4163688123226166,
-0.41006192564964294,
-0.21921409666538239,
-0.012408219277858734,
0.14016121625900269,
-0.47560957074165344,
0.5073564052581787,
0.7870258688926697,
-0.4760000705718994,
-0.5246326923370361,
-0.3040733337402344,
0.017560498788952827,
0.34761425852775574,
-0.16784697771072388,
-0.494444340467453,
0.7128921151161194,
0.2227392941713333,
0.7850080132484436,
-0.4652774930000305,
0.5764057636260986,
0.4065256118774414,
0.25966572761535645,
-0.26294898986816406,
-0.67966628074646,
-0.35651129484176636,
-0.636580228805542,
-0.48850783705711365,
-0.009674864821135998,
-0.3742296099662781,
0.6146042943000793,
0.33928561210632324,
-0.20501551032066345,
-0.16770866513252258,
0.1824617087841034,
0.17815999686717987,
0.6553661227226257,
0.6061067581176758,
0.5543925166130066,
0.7532271146774292,
0.029273511841893196,
0.8919393420219421,
-0.32315945625305176,
0.4128905236721039,
0.7601238489151001,
-0.5881286263465881,
1.0408495664596558,
0.2605739235877991,
-0.2773916721343994,
0.6086288094520569,
0.8733545541763306,
-0.26327621936798096,
0.33352455496788025,
0.05661595240235329,
-0.3074008822441101,
-0.2801237106323242,
0.1365939825773239,
-0.33472707867622375,
0.27489233016967773,
0.5630514025688171,
-0.49024033546447754,
-0.0736468955874443,
-0.030773961916565895,
-0.4377666711807251,
0.01740795373916626,
-0.7709968090057373,
1.0857467651367188,
-0.013197304680943489,
-0.610343873500824,
0.32523438334465027,
0.13534080982208252,
0.7629325985908508,
-0.5329720973968506,
-0.348604291677475,
0.06107723340392113,
0.6447410583496094,
-0.5254165530204773,
-0.5711662173271179,
0.45071983337402344,
0.04701869562268257,
-0.17352035641670227,
-0.5679017901420593,
1.13650643825531,
0.13869623839855194,
-0.8368591666221619,
0.5920524001121521,
0.6447274684906006,
0.06474801152944565,
-0.20087780058383942,
-0.8787201046943665,
-0.08824290335178375,
0.07612190395593643,
-0.17679333686828613,
0.2147321254014969,
0.24859610199928284,
-0.12939007580280304,
0.35742881894111633,
0.9911597967147827,
-0.06557409465312958,
-0.09613420069217682,
0.07731850445270538,
0.6625660061836243,
-0.45299044251441956,
-1.1312899589538574,
-0.7402880191802979,
0.24902629852294922,
-0.49557772278785706,
-0.07804077118635178,
1.0402164459228516,
0.826296329498291,
1.0119547843933105,
-0.351375550031662,
0.9786818623542786,
0.40809908509254456,
0.7784472703933716,
-0.32381144165992737,
0.7262709140777588,
-0.3377598524093628,
0.507291316986084,
-0.06679736077785492,
-1.0813241004943848,
-0.5807615518569946,
0.8102834224700928,
-0.2772020399570465,
-0.15912503004074097,
0.5877222418785095,
0.7408948540687561,
-0.21210741996765137,
0.4973367154598236,
0.16170740127563477,
-0.013450405560433865,
0.10646702349185944,
0.13433663547039032,
1.0573711395263672,
-0.4837626516819,
0.5625777840614319,
-0.19233861565589905,
-0.10168320685625076,
-0.4070390462875366,
-0.7549320459365845,
-0.9418107867240906,
-0.05467113107442856,
-0.4354151487350464,
-0.8119503259658813,
-0.21156136691570282,
0.9009156823158264,
0.6501159071922302,
-1.4035439491271973,
-0.36994484066963196,
-0.20493298768997192,
0.1187603697180748,
-0.6528896689414978,
-0.2054917961359024,
0.19695943593978882,
-0.2720898687839508,
-0.5523596405982971,
0.34628814458847046,
0.4124741554260254,
-0.17560537159442902,
-0.5622422099113464,
0.08190061897039413,
0.18654555082321167,
0.012668090872466564,
0.693043053150177,
0.29789066314697266,
-0.6285148859024048,
-0.044022515416145325,
0.0012366380542516708,
0.34275883436203003,
0.31716975569725037,
0.9455244541168213,
-0.8926347494125366,
0.7535406947135925,
0.603942334651947,
0.6888772249221802,
0.531187117099762,
-0.06794615089893341,
0.30273520946502686,
-0.5999387502670288,
0.0843174159526825,
0.34189820289611816,
0.37381353974342346,
0.3912121653556824,
-0.3829263150691986,
0.2052968591451645,
0.4187018573284149,
-0.34528863430023193,
-0.7114453911781311,
0.3580355942249298,
-0.8019899129867554,
-0.3174439072608948,
0.7186407446861267,
-0.2513729929924011,
-0.24722933769226074,
-0.36183029413223267,
-0.14722606539726257,
-0.3203364610671997,
-0.2473536729812622,
1.165139079093933,
0.5005456805229187,
-0.3022245466709137,
0.14156299829483032,
-0.37929362058639526,
0.3193318545818329,
-0.05949896201491356,
-0.9184824824333191,
-0.36927980184555054,
0.4279203414916992,
0.2315574437379837,
0.34923285245895386,
0.36070600152015686,
-0.31896957755088806,
0.5503897070884705,
-0.12823444604873657,
0.12201713025569916,
0.001798860146664083,
-0.18695230782032013,
-0.7618644833564758,
0.6993287205696106,
-0.32022494077682495,
-0.24377000331878662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05478v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05478v1
|
Using Machine Translation to Augment Multilingual Classification
| 2024-05-09T00:31:59 | 2024-05-09T00:31:59 |
Adam King
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
An all-too-present bottleneck for text classification model development is
the need to annotate training data and this need is multiplied for multilingual
classifiers. Fortunately, contemporary machine translation models are both
easily accessible and have dependable translation quality, making it possible
to translate labeled training data from one language into another. Here, we
explore the effects of using machine translation to fine-tune a multilingual
model for a classification task across multiple languages. We also investigate
the benefits of using a novel technique, originally proposed in the field of
image captioning, to account for potential negative effects of tuning models on
translated data. We show that translated data are of sufficient quality to tune
multilingual classifiers and that this novel loss technique is able to offer
some improvement over models tuned without it.
|
[
-0.33219489455223083,
-0.3545396625995636,
0.07510410249233246,
0.08329559117555618,
-0.3028225600719452,
-0.03392188251018524,
-0.34681591391563416,
-0.6942583918571472,
-0.2066287100315094,
0.5698139667510986,
-0.23090790212154388,
-0.22851023077964783,
-0.7214916944503784,
0.2788637578487396,
-0.3533083498477936,
1.2796447277069092,
-0.23993872106075287,
0.41859257221221924,
-0.1465791016817093,
-0.3474055826663971,
-0.7763763666152954,
-0.853922963142395,
-0.5199832916259766,
-0.5281320810317993,
0.6757988929748535,
0.40630581974983215,
0.7844653725624084,
0.6003926396369934,
0.6780639886856079,
0.3163643181324005,
0.25550729036331177,
0.6465370059013367,
-0.26246464252471924,
-0.03784212842583656,
-0.017936207354068756,
-0.901847243309021,
-0.15496283769607544,
0.17536453902721405,
0.7792608141899109,
0.7093294858932495,
0.16373921930789948,
0.09754962474107742,
0.10864036530256271,
0.5546239018440247,
-0.4744449555873871,
0.2606619894504547,
-0.5567168593406677,
0.24896197021007538,
-0.16671448945999146,
-0.478326678276062,
-0.6701865792274475,
-0.09215352684259415,
-0.02216024324297905,
-0.4642897844314575,
0.4590323865413666,
0.07024477422237396,
0.9607999324798584,
0.486681193113327,
-0.5800986289978027,
-0.1318579912185669,
-0.7148186564445496,
0.7528315782546997,
-0.3898715376853943,
0.5483983159065247,
0.36947593092918396,
0.426113098859787,
0.3868168294429779,
-0.38354000449180603,
-0.3034728765487671,
-0.024905482307076454,
-0.33055028319358826,
0.06957302242517471,
0.1827530860900879,
-0.16055777668952942,
0.05662883073091507,
0.5116176009178162,
-0.23528407514095306,
0.34405604004859924,
-0.4779976010322571,
-0.4184054136276245,
0.6596944332122803,
0.026863684877753258,
0.4523635506629944,
0.07995019853115082,
-0.15714070200920105,
-0.24304306507110596,
-0.4974557161331177,
-0.004001510329544544,
0.4303397238254547,
0.7105799317359924,
0.033570896834135056,
0.571873664855957,
0.06636644899845123,
0.873731791973114,
-0.31505274772644043,
-0.26231247186660767,
0.27815893292427063,
-0.36231598258018494,
-0.05735825002193451,
0.239798441529274,
0.5315910577774048,
0.5551093220710754,
0.30137622356414795,
-0.27615034580230713,
-0.1462160050868988,
0.0764111801981926,
0.21324409544467926,
-0.7877439260482788,
-0.31244921684265137,
-0.29094982147216797,
-0.3866581916809082,
-0.3035374879837036,
0.08315415680408478,
-0.2857050895690918,
-0.27075374126434326,
-0.5128267407417297,
0.34508582949638367,
-0.08188366144895554,
-0.10161784291267395,
0.24695029854774475,
-0.2921980917453766,
-0.12432835251092911,
0.41050973534584045,
-0.8653568625450134,
-0.113717220723629,
0.34182754158973694,
0.9114773869514465,
-0.06261546164751053,
-0.41760775446891785,
-0.594805121421814,
0.03049870952963829,
-0.650574803352356,
0.6463301181793213,
-0.4206971824169159,
-0.06481868773698807,
-0.03566652536392212,
0.34398797154426575,
-0.20542246103286743,
-0.3025154769420624,
0.5670445561408997,
-0.48792344331741333,
0.34044158458709717,
0.16771440207958221,
-0.40184661746025085,
-0.5102460980415344,
0.40717750787734985,
-0.7255092859268188,
0.663475751876831,
-0.07086833566427231,
-0.5798069834709167,
0.46860411763191223,
-0.43489113450050354,
-0.8174991011619568,
0.027778416872024536,
0.3102160692214966,
-0.618059515953064,
0.2386479675769806,
0.3092343509197235,
0.7966675162315369,
-0.07970032095909119,
-0.030972154811024666,
-0.20237572491168976,
-0.16268180310726166,
0.33131662011146545,
-0.5180612206459045,
0.5013508200645447,
0.35079503059387207,
0.13116459548473358,
-0.20253601670265198,
-0.5076578855514526,
0.017976908013224602,
-0.14058206975460052,
-0.6877506971359253,
-0.5651978850364685,
-0.0939946100115776,
0.42022621631622314,
0.3112890422344208,
0.1000906303524971,
-0.3532324731349945,
0.236354261636734,
-0.4208923280239105,
0.4407036304473877,
0.207557812333107,
-0.12707923352718353,
0.5141345262527466,
-0.41496697068214417,
0.5822086334228516,
-0.08133748173713684,
-0.1071663647890091,
-0.5505409836769104,
-0.5710687041282654,
-0.7607885003089905,
-0.2770654857158661,
0.6415936350822449,
0.8106289505958557,
-0.9217402338981628,
0.0692400112748146,
-0.34892141819000244,
-0.5226894021034241,
-1.1028071641921997,
0.3380163609981537,
0.4064996540546417,
0.36285021901130676,
0.47102922201156616,
-0.13755320012569427,
-0.39876940846443176,
-0.8170055747032166,
-0.3466476500034332,
0.2345334142446518,
0.1361536979675293,
0.20265136659145355,
0.20108503103256226,
-0.46334370970726013,
0.13559642434120178,
-0.287509948015213,
-0.4817006289958954,
-0.2632414698600769,
0.13863088190555573,
-0.0602417029440403,
0.6617373824119568,
0.47707685828208923,
-1.0142956972122192,
-0.664797306060791,
0.6885042190551758,
-0.6654196381568909,
-0.04688357934355736,
-0.46922096610069275,
-0.2057332843542099,
0.3811241090297699,
0.42142266035079956,
-0.3441583514213562,
0.15069571137428284,
0.5123620629310608,
-0.0205781701952219,
0.29455652832984924,
-0.37071919441223145,
0.5072258114814758,
-1.0185036659240723,
-0.04600170999765396,
-0.013111266307532787,
-0.3963979482650757,
-0.801584780216217,
0.2774316668510437,
0.4693167805671692,
-0.13919849693775177,
-0.48763278126716614,
0.43325164914131165,
-0.2656727731227875,
0.2315933257341385,
-0.48001405596733093,
0.000582353794015944,
0.29373598098754883,
0.008121740072965622,
0.15592201054096222,
0.6738142371177673,
0.4753982722759247,
-0.8029346466064453,
0.17411133646965027,
0.4441165626049042,
-0.20665507018566132,
0.6696738004684448,
-0.13482201099395752,
-0.13536517322063446,
-0.3513627052307129,
-0.04466792196035385,
-0.6858440637588501,
-0.4111369252204895,
0.20596256852149963,
-0.6167075037956238,
0.8760761022567749,
-0.311016708612442,
-0.5750794410705566,
-0.342123806476593,
-0.004399425815790892,
0.18206016719341278,
0.12210860103368759,
-0.7765255570411682,
0.2945365905761719,
0.23313653469085693,
0.01035880483686924,
-0.46511363983154297,
-1.0672048330307007,
0.2828408479690552,
-0.5886538624763489,
-0.303529292345047,
0.386862188577652,
0.012952548451721668,
0.1712818741798401,
-0.23259949684143066,
0.0676124319434166,
-0.20563265681266785,
0.32891330122947693,
-0.09720806777477264,
0.22554370760917664,
-0.00899629108607769,
0.7276074290275574,
0.38603487610816956,
-0.2430129051208496,
-0.2902575433254242,
-0.5174062848091125,
0.26844626665115356,
0.01759348064661026,
-0.12815973162651062,
-0.5459590554237366,
0.4883725941181183,
0.5873473882675171,
-0.5956798195838928,
0.7461755871772766,
0.863457977771759,
-0.32723772525787354,
-0.14920882880687714,
-0.4191586375236511,
0.005679218098521233,
-0.3994479477405548,
0.4899820387363434,
-0.619992196559906,
-0.6823063492774963,
0.2963693141937256,
-0.12434149533510208,
-0.01252954825758934,
0.6263126730918884,
0.385832279920578,
-0.34132853150367737,
1.4335922002792358,
0.9882094264030457,
-0.1972074657678604,
0.5951943397521973,
-0.11581094563007355,
0.0486079677939415,
-0.5693625211715698,
-0.11191387474536896,
-0.8125964403152466,
-0.263360857963562,
-0.779072105884552,
-0.24686585366725922,
0.3595913052558899,
0.289350301027298,
0.09708953648805618,
0.4346846640110016,
-0.6936258673667908,
0.5224131941795349,
0.6477430462837219,
0.24097438156604767,
0.3633880317211151,
0.18515799939632416,
0.22224891185760498,
-0.18128202855587006,
-0.8817013502120972,
-0.6673339605331421,
1.018580675125122,
0.24441011250019073,
0.6623058915138245,
-0.02003244310617447,
0.4719368517398834,
0.13793878257274628,
0.591266393661499,
-0.8086658120155334,
-0.1796305924654007,
-0.594262421131134,
-0.6474461555480957,
-0.20831146836280823,
-0.5999893546104431,
-0.8747560977935791,
0.4395143687725067,
-0.3389022648334503,
-0.16395053267478943,
-0.12024430185556412,
0.39696213603019714,
0.07593205571174622,
0.3123014271259308,
-0.8359062075614929,
1.097888469696045,
-0.6916501522064209,
-0.01003291830420494,
-0.215288907289505,
-0.5529731512069702,
0.3428230285644531,
-0.4623222053050995,
0.3593783676624298,
0.03519668057560921,
-0.021172238513827324,
0.5291032195091248,
-0.208200603723526,
0.7077968120574951,
-0.10837996751070023,
-0.1540074646472931,
0.023274777457118034,
-0.1509452611207962,
0.2857026159763336,
-0.07448116689920425,
-0.0864073783159256,
0.318164587020874,
0.1309589147567749,
-0.36402514576911926,
-0.5482743978500366,
0.4692029356956482,
-0.760861873626709,
-0.18877814710140228,
-0.07535296678543091,
-0.7237831950187683,
-0.03291359916329384,
0.32105159759521484,
0.3939483165740967,
0.20086780190467834,
0.3384423553943634,
0.11063296347856522,
0.43284347653388977,
-0.4241170287132263,
0.2085951268672943,
0.5107598900794983,
-0.09914621710777283,
-0.37974071502685547,
1.2208200693130493,
0.29326871037483215,
0.3828315734863281,
0.5804222226142883,
0.2615613043308258,
-0.3156777024269104,
-0.5165278911590576,
-0.9816774129867554,
0.012080725282430649,
-0.8693798780441284,
-0.5352615118026733,
-0.47772759199142456,
0.024171676486730576,
-0.15336063504219055,
-0.03364047035574913,
-0.21730096638202667,
-0.5826799273490906,
-0.4011845588684082,
-0.1266370713710785,
0.2567419409751892,
0.39143407344818115,
0.023044800385832787,
0.4750557839870453,
-1.041703462600708,
0.11687114089727402,
-0.07138832658529282,
0.35214516520500183,
-0.3431522846221924,
-0.5801515579223633,
-0.6766074299812317,
0.13504944741725922,
-0.38891664147377014,
-0.7335988879203796,
0.5588602423667908,
0.693940281867981,
0.6132885217666626,
0.2994610667228699,
0.007347327657043934,
0.7989122271537781,
-0.5993424654006958,
0.3471983075141907,
0.2212623953819275,
-0.8203395009040833,
0.5795005559921265,
-0.09733746945858002,
0.4503001868724823,
0.49684908986091614,
0.5678927302360535,
-0.8492022752761841,
-0.44695591926574707,
-0.06218309327960014,
-0.4707581102848053,
0.6491861343383789,
-0.189039409160614,
0.4828411042690277,
0.13759079575538635,
0.3807034194469452,
0.4667516350746155,
0.26314619183540344,
-0.8767055869102478,
-0.13729923963546753,
-0.4231328070163727,
-0.23301653563976288,
-0.6123525500297546,
0.07524996995925903,
0.1358622908592224,
-0.32671618461608887,
0.8140472173690796,
-0.2554978132247925,
0.02432037703692913,
-0.08165936172008514,
-0.41184496879577637,
-0.16963410377502441,
0.18463750183582306,
0.48140615224838257,
-0.0015876108082011342,
0.26150617003440857,
0.15477870404720306,
0.19026830792427063,
-0.040050480514764786,
0.22046369314193726,
0.3151269555091858,
-0.4346776008605957,
0.18448449671268463,
0.33228227496147156,
0.8739672899246216,
0.07164435088634491,
-0.4444046914577484,
0.10670977830886841,
0.12195636332035065,
-0.1644073724746704,
0.21611171960830688,
-0.07722730189561844,
-0.19967149198055267,
0.015164915472269058,
0.08561775088310242,
0.4868887662887573,
0.3017272353172302,
-0.3452581465244293,
0.16608011722564697,
0.31081095337867737,
-0.5090811252593994,
0.008522339165210724,
0.6855400204658508,
0.12853720784187317,
-0.35068896412849426,
0.5768567323684692,
-0.024704793468117714,
-0.7482045292854309,
0.35428351163864136,
0.6034190058708191,
0.4765506684780121,
-0.4617821276187897,
0.14716728031635284,
0.4666256606578827,
0.5754354000091553,
-0.3647233545780182,
-0.0994194746017456,
-0.011113707907497883,
-0.6609727740287781,
-0.7295954823493958,
-0.5273317098617554,
-0.2139054238796234,
-0.3083633482456207,
-0.6571424603462219,
0.3598995506763458,
0.22951637208461761,
-0.19446805119514465,
0.1446179747581482,
-0.2481599748134613,
-0.6950535178184509,
0.26310834288597107,
0.3670390844345093,
0.687596321105957,
-1.0031797885894775,
0.8535351157188416,
1.0294603109359741,
-0.3736662268638611,
-0.4035642743110657,
-0.4045380651950836,
-0.319324791431427,
-0.4196423888206482,
0.5911914110183716,
0.6163203716278076,
-0.05446872487664223,
0.0467582568526268,
-0.3323037624359131,
-0.7130051255226135,
0.4020102024078369,
0.3412565588951111,
-0.5270325541496277,
0.3668321967124939,
0.4290369749069214,
0.6078082919120789,
-0.19568568468093872,
-0.24833418428897858,
0.38468465209007263,
0.5935459733009338,
-0.250967800617218,
-1.1177635192871094,
-0.3578561544418335,
-0.27054470777511597,
-0.06153320521116257,
0.44216305017471313,
-0.32959556579589844,
0.6589162349700928,
-0.2489408254623413,
-0.2852395474910736,
0.058103296905756,
0.24480009078979492,
-0.5574964880943298,
0.2922009527683258,
0.20464687049388885,
0.37944531440734863,
0.8544270992279053,
-0.21979965269565582,
1.0952441692352295,
-0.3192020356655121,
0.32453441619873047,
1.0492559671401978,
0.19966517388820648,
0.7730926871299744,
0.27164581418037415,
0.08511147648096085,
0.02309064008295536,
0.8766714334487915,
-0.21571968495845795,
0.5980989933013916,
0.11256758123636246,
-0.1858275681734085,
-0.46742209792137146,
-0.14099927246570587,
-0.2964171767234802,
0.49279531836509705,
0.37922343611717224,
-0.5103606581687927,
-0.091030552983284,
0.7363917827606201,
-0.056634046137332916,
0.31833478808403015,
-0.5132709741592407,
0.6697009801864624,
-0.03300490230321884,
-0.6698013544082642,
0.6800329089164734,
0.33545732498168945,
0.6361618638038635,
-0.20459626615047455,
0.016913607716560364,
-0.06611040234565735,
0.4603360593318939,
-0.2311752736568451,
-0.40344566106796265,
0.482415109872818,
-0.10224942862987518,
-0.26786455512046814,
-0.4925345480442047,
0.5488412380218506,
-0.8053105473518372,
-0.9389290809631348,
0.051475271582603455,
0.3860953450202942,
0.38943248987197876,
-0.21192698180675507,
-0.6307264566421509,
-0.18128542602062225,
-0.08260370790958405,
0.2833564281463623,
0.12536019086837769,
0.44481730461120605,
-0.20607762038707733,
0.8189870715141296,
0.5028231143951416,
-0.06924062967300415,
0.1096687763929367,
0.06693702191114426,
0.4346255660057068,
-0.33581405878067017,
-0.4076744019985199,
-0.8071248531341553,
0.46995848417282104,
0.08354726433753967,
-0.27231860160827637,
0.9124321937561035,
0.6483015418052673,
1.2567558288574219,
-0.3758886456489563,
0.8788355588912964,
0.31522440910339355,
0.5066515803337097,
-0.4450906813144684,
0.8624191284179688,
-0.7656015157699585,
-0.0515625961124897,
-0.21412569284439087,
-0.6144242286682129,
-0.9576174020767212,
0.6254674792289734,
-0.057014789432287216,
-0.183570995926857,
0.48929789662361145,
0.5649393200874329,
-0.05595698207616806,
-0.2865027189254761,
0.44884929060935974,
-0.27349525690078735,
0.26366952061653137,
0.304919570684433,
0.8181259036064148,
-0.7044366598129272,
0.8031437993049622,
-0.3457010090351105,
-0.0035671815276145935,
-0.10054583102464676,
-0.5984520316123962,
-1.1367501020431519,
-0.5127537250518799,
-0.4914095103740692,
0.03660690411925316,
-0.018547983840107918,
0.5480351448059082,
0.8886343240737915,
-0.8936490416526794,
0.020435119047760963,
0.15818187594413757,
0.13361938297748566,
-0.4579119086265564,
-0.11547558009624481,
0.11878769844770432,
-0.8972984552383423,
-0.879285991191864,
0.2513887882232666,
0.00011696075671352446,
0.4394611418247223,
-0.1587533801794052,
-0.18189586699008942,
-0.004822165239602327,
-0.36922603845596313,
0.8174806833267212,
0.03124213218688965,
-0.6534690260887146,
-0.18610763549804688,
-0.05998239666223526,
-0.028623806312680244,
0.08458631485700607,
0.6631675958633423,
-0.4153638780117035,
0.8389989137649536,
0.1822800189256668,
0.9169436693191528,
0.563701868057251,
-0.048420071601867676,
0.6942949891090393,
-0.8610210418701172,
0.13309231400489807,
-0.0019006194779649377,
0.2782471477985382,
0.677715539932251,
-0.377564013004303,
0.6020315885543823,
0.02652657963335514,
-0.38786810636520386,
-0.8921235203742981,
0.13557814061641693,
-0.4801180958747864,
-0.3884803056716919,
0.7037253975868225,
-0.21169014275074005,
0.19470983743667603,
-0.04775303974747658,
-0.5962530374526978,
0.35984930396080017,
0.0601656474173069,
0.7218138575553894,
0.82429039478302,
0.2396271824836731,
-0.33095425367355347,
-0.8313080072402954,
0.3657779395580292,
0.2714434564113617,
-0.8583865761756897,
0.005643496755510569,
0.5794995427131653,
-0.07364293932914734,
0.30912819504737854,
0.031015729531645775,
-0.016550827771425247,
0.3569125831127167,
-0.28201621770858765,
0.23645564913749695,
-0.023751655593514442,
-0.5624663233757019,
-0.5257292985916138,
0.005689453333616257,
0.12844473123550415,
-0.3311307728290558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05466v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05466v2
|
Poser: Unmasking Alignment Faking LLMs by Manipulating Their Internals
| 2024-05-08T23:44:08 | 2024-05-11T04:45:59 |
Joshua Clymer, Caden Juang, Severin Field
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Like a criminal under investigation, Large Language Models (LLMs) might
pretend to be aligned while evaluated and misbehave when they have a good
opportunity. Can current interpretability methods catch these 'alignment
fakers?' To answer this question, we introduce a benchmark that consists of 324
pairs of LLMs fine-tuned to select actions in role-play scenarios. One model in
each pair is consistently benign (aligned). The other model misbehaves in
scenarios where it is unlikely to be caught (alignment faking). The task is to
identify the alignment faking model using only inputs where the two models
behave identically. We test five detection strategies, one of which identifies
98% of alignment-fakers.
|
[
-0.09984565526247025,
-0.662573516368866,
0.4912051260471344,
-0.1912062019109726,
-0.225626140832901,
0.428272008895874,
0.41174057126045227,
-0.527044951915741,
0.11233921349048615,
0.7178847789764404,
-0.7499711513519287,
-0.28063833713531494,
-0.8297141790390015,
0.1346191167831421,
-0.8358956575393677,
0.7375237941741943,
-0.0515335276722908,
0.24204754829406738,
-0.15805785357952118,
-0.2810624837875366,
-0.47907447814941406,
-0.3827255070209503,
-0.44465699791908264,
-0.44711896777153015,
0.14382986724376678,
0.2782061994075775,
1.160474181175232,
1.0861343145370483,
0.4810614287853241,
0.402733713388443,
-0.07458958774805069,
0.10473699122667313,
-0.5575842261314392,
0.10457245260477066,
-0.07244515419006348,
-0.7594846487045288,
-0.4537867605686188,
0.29936790466308594,
0.5494772791862488,
0.24119383096694946,
-0.3292241096496582,
0.22846591472625732,
-0.14275626838207245,
0.3467629551887512,
-0.5731578469276428,
-0.07888996601104736,
-0.7271553874015808,
-0.21183310449123383,
-0.5722998380661011,
-0.04107149690389633,
-0.5442696213722229,
-0.14738500118255615,
-0.24553556740283966,
-0.5535273551940918,
0.18217839300632477,
0.39868420362472534,
0.8487892150878906,
0.4472629427909851,
-0.27637979388237,
-0.38584280014038086,
-0.6110594272613525,
0.7071579098701477,
-0.7760637402534485,
0.3171800374984741,
0.27540385723114014,
0.41944369673728943,
-0.44403666257858276,
-0.3820304870605469,
-0.9362746477127075,
0.16211211681365967,
-0.40805184841156006,
-0.05159716680645943,
-0.49823445081710815,
-0.18115046620368958,
0.473476380109787,
0.4772520661354065,
-0.7186107039451599,
0.3182448446750641,
-0.1613447070121765,
-0.2600833773612976,
0.5689236521720886,
0.23613259196281433,
0.7166482210159302,
-0.11703776568174362,
-0.46220168471336365,
0.03769389167428017,
-0.8629941940307617,
0.10025603324174881,
0.7191439270973206,
0.09289667755365372,
-0.0886218398809433,
0.8772032856941223,
0.21670159697532654,
0.8584648370742798,
0.5940714478492737,
-0.0070536378771066666,
-0.18527765572071075,
0.0067008971236646175,
-0.4641396999359131,
0.28681614995002747,
0.45703932642936707,
0.2630658745765686,
0.17127104103565216,
-0.11260070651769638,
-0.5118227601051331,
0.35101813077926636,
0.41445982456207275,
-0.31443241238594055,
-0.18869581818580627,
0.3355213701725006,
-0.48747122287750244,
-0.512791097164154,
0.07882038503885269,
-0.6032779812812805,
-0.6775413751602173,
-0.44817548990249634,
0.735614001750946,
-0.45908379554748535,
-0.1902497261762619,
0.18920932710170746,
0.09128385037183762,
0.8757573366165161,
0.14399245381355286,
-0.581567645072937,
0.35961899161338806,
1.1596437692642212,
0.6397886276245117,
-0.23223340511322021,
-0.21818295121192932,
-0.7343347072601318,
0.07383860647678375,
-0.4334391951560974,
0.8641808032989502,
-0.5277083516120911,
-0.174273282289505,
-0.04021036624908447,
0.3092056214809418,
-0.1448197215795517,
-0.531085193157196,
0.46526971459388733,
-0.7238054275512695,
0.2420673966407776,
-0.21958176791667938,
-0.8273166418075562,
0.06258533895015717,
0.28890150785446167,
-0.7314373850822449,
0.9576029777526855,
0.05288904905319214,
-0.5423080325126648,
0.45164918899536133,
-0.33319538831710815,
-0.1433817446231842,
0.08528101444244385,
-0.20333176851272583,
-0.4673137068748474,
0.1743709146976471,
0.2525136470794678,
0.2685418128967285,
0.08901255577802658,
0.1446663737297058,
-0.030630480498075485,
-0.7224425077438354,
0.6080917716026306,
-0.09881722927093506,
1.0073421001434326,
0.18250861763954163,
-0.3296021521091461,
0.12590964138507843,
-0.5325649976730347,
-0.22117789089679718,
0.12353847920894623,
0.009831366129219532,
-0.40706032514572144,
0.030032716691493988,
-0.331439346075058,
0.28610682487487793,
0.0556231290102005,
-0.5515246987342834,
0.20896349847316742,
-0.5748290419578552,
-0.02046438679099083,
0.8102038502693176,
-0.10247601568698883,
0.4499804675579071,
-0.6638652682304382,
0.82225501537323,
0.15681803226470947,
-0.04201169312000275,
-0.17168422043323517,
-0.3270547389984131,
-0.7432991862297058,
-0.46975570917129517,
-0.001595221576280892,
0.49218490719795227,
-0.648468554019928,
0.440441757440567,
-0.15807202458381653,
-0.430765300989151,
-0.9127034544944763,
0.16918990015983582,
0.8111582398414612,
0.37362703680992126,
0.18417389690876007,
0.03746915981173515,
-0.4772697985172272,
-0.8874220252037048,
-1.1624499559402466,
0.026569994166493416,
0.10663238167762756,
-0.5153203010559082,
0.5338664650917053,
0.0008325937087647617,
0.7731629610061646,
-0.230435311794281,
-0.2823600172996521,
0.022237980738282204,
0.1624719351530075,
0.21361133456230164,
0.4486951231956482,
0.5618706941604614,
-0.7168777585029602,
-0.3854377567768097,
-0.25691133737564087,
-0.5919444561004639,
-0.00893331877887249,
-0.08497297763824463,
0.0032524976413697004,
0.5122500061988831,
1.0993057489395142,
-0.42005792260169983,
0.7005944848060608,
0.7031074166297913,
-0.5243266224861145,
0.3631494343280792,
0.017742862924933434,
0.1990945041179657,
-1.0099984407424927,
0.11916100233793259,
-0.04987108334898949,
-0.317748099565506,
-0.8466781377792358,
0.1924964040517807,
0.18138250708580017,
0.14511112868785858,
-0.36730217933654785,
0.6011314392089844,
-0.8597323298454285,
-0.2503682076931,
-0.29090437293052673,
0.0457729734480381,
-0.1981671303510666,
-0.013020472601056099,
-0.24918417632579803,
0.783078670501709,
0.432964026927948,
-0.31160005927085876,
0.1310156136751175,
0.41935157775878906,
-0.7355830669403076,
0.8182744979858398,
-0.6102827191352844,
0.15767121315002441,
-0.429857462644577,
0.03719116374850273,
-1.5399683713912964,
-0.583835780620575,
0.2853376567363739,
-0.5086758732795715,
0.5950396656990051,
-0.43609535694122314,
-0.639163076877594,
-0.14373625814914703,
-0.05951603129506111,
0.3221701979637146,
0.5793142318725586,
-0.678001880645752,
0.7371483445167542,
0.4697410464286804,
0.34242355823516846,
-1.0092569589614868,
-0.6444538831710815,
-0.19002467393875122,
-0.41889235377311707,
-0.4304995536804199,
0.1885674148797989,
0.008986053988337517,
-0.505445659160614,
-0.14212137460708618,
-0.5847059488296509,
0.19003339111804962,
0.15484704077243805,
0.3781854808330536,
0.26639237999916077,
-0.261344313621521,
-0.3325222134590149,
-0.16422973573207855,
-0.11755294352769852,
0.20513692498207092,
0.39962393045425415,
0.5136868357658386,
-0.00882919505238533,
-0.6880685687065125,
-0.738689124584198,
0.028564725071191788,
0.8814927339553833,
-0.0787629634141922,
0.731890082359314,
0.28957563638687134,
-0.4680982530117035,
-0.06449014693498611,
-0.6765115857124329,
-0.13797447085380554,
-0.5717998743057251,
-0.02361174114048481,
-0.43633562326431274,
-0.79129958152771,
0.9509813785552979,
0.012570035643875599,
0.11872274428606033,
0.24020230770111084,
0.2787141501903534,
-0.181763157248497,
1.1986206769943237,
0.507509171962738,
-0.05682526156306267,
0.29403504729270935,
0.358166366815567,
0.46981123089790344,
-0.7556414604187012,
-0.18498435616493225,
-0.4385753273963928,
-0.6255799531936646,
-0.760136067867279,
-0.4116306006908417,
0.31825631856918335,
0.30665868520736694,
-0.14084623754024506,
0.4792446196079254,
-0.4186585545539856,
1.0826081037521362,
0.228648841381073,
-0.04208213835954666,
0.37843233346939087,
-0.16246560215950012,
-0.03927928954362869,
-0.14408400654792786,
-0.19765537977218628,
-0.5663579106330872,
0.9541175365447998,
0.31050583720207214,
0.7595497369766235,
0.5389954447746277,
0.4619649648666382,
0.017665553838014603,
0.5747948884963989,
-0.7656404972076416,
0.5476964116096497,
-0.09159638732671738,
-0.8759727478027344,
-0.14187027513980865,
0.07026348263025284,
-0.7872167229652405,
0.11791922152042389,
-0.2736786901950836,
-1.0189288854599,
0.1745913028717041,
0.504690945148468,
-0.17903685569763184,
0.37620386481285095,
-0.2698855400085449,
0.7468514442443848,
-0.2489820420742035,
-0.08906728029251099,
0.10537338256835938,
-0.9401610493659973,
0.7917511463165283,
-0.13435810804367065,
0.25587794184684753,
-0.17527461051940918,
0.13889898359775543,
0.4322757422924042,
-0.13043034076690674,
0.969657838344574,
-0.08297344297170639,
-0.34803321957588196,
-0.055138953030109406,
0.7763937711715698,
0.6767334342002869,
-0.2709130048751831,
-0.15683749318122864,
0.06598840653896332,
0.10719921439886093,
-0.3577377498149872,
-0.5574408173561096,
0.574449896812439,
-0.6550689935684204,
-0.8483867645263672,
-0.6531265377998352,
-0.6053324341773987,
-0.22291098535060883,
0.21078310906887054,
0.479841411113739,
0.24385187029838562,
-0.39340272545814514,
-0.04018354415893555,
0.6061103343963623,
0.03668849170207977,
0.32500579953193665,
0.6312052607536316,
-0.3193354308605194,
-0.09664557129144669,
0.4596594274044037,
-0.29604315757751465,
0.3795665204524994,
0.34685149788856506,
0.024934006854891777,
-0.25067010521888733,
-0.4040062129497528,
-0.2556125223636627,
0.48361894488334656,
-0.5765706300735474,
-0.15228073298931122,
-0.29856523871421814,
-0.14239069819450378,
-0.468091756105423,
-0.24093517661094666,
-0.41175153851509094,
-0.2543482184410095,
-0.18914970755577087,
0.022510604932904243,
0.0034420189913362265,
0.7364636063575745,
-0.004457153379917145,
0.7458710670471191,
-0.5621702671051025,
0.31499025225639343,
0.18002545833587646,
0.26104289293289185,
-0.36078426241874695,
-0.9674514532089233,
0.2439681589603424,
-0.0005221366882324219,
-0.10511749237775803,
-0.8533840775489807,
0.44061899185180664,
-0.2882653474807739,
0.712501049041748,
0.9286439418792725,
-0.11459937691688538,
0.980024516582489,
-0.36478158831596375,
0.5767092108726501,
0.022573057562112808,
-1.1926888227462769,
0.38778096437454224,
-0.4208226501941681,
0.18496641516685486,
0.25118446350097656,
0.4366738200187683,
-0.5208156704902649,
-0.5135315656661987,
-0.5614177584648132,
-0.39704644680023193,
0.8907848000526428,
0.011845524422824383,
-0.07184815406799316,
0.13774807751178741,
0.6210537552833557,
0.13970670104026794,
0.19814270734786987,
-0.7437179684638977,
-0.4051992893218994,
0.08772066235542297,
-0.3333231210708618,
-0.22199541330337524,
-0.39277297258377075,
-0.4889565110206604,
-0.11121291667222977,
0.457539439201355,
-0.17323456704616547,
0.32613405585289,
-0.0918937474489212,
-0.42159706354141235,
-0.460665762424469,
0.11605276167392731,
0.8446303606033325,
0.811389684677124,
-0.11599931120872498,
0.3014546036720276,
-0.2776050865650177,
-0.3033687472343445,
0.0846080556511879,
-0.23841547966003418,
-0.07142038643360138,
-0.15032652020454407,
0.46605271100997925,
0.48603200912475586,
0.4278791844844818,
-0.5759842395782471,
0.6614516377449036,
0.20986691117286682,
-0.025906845927238464,
-0.4605983793735504,
0.26013052463531494,
0.17277055978775024,
0.2675948143005371,
0.011780519969761372,
0.10760366916656494,
-0.18148843944072723,
-0.7433474063873291,
0.23850829899311066,
0.7153998613357544,
-0.5795056819915771,
-0.5780287981033325,
0.6866940855979919,
-0.3190437853336334,
-0.5673112869262695,
0.5647444725036621,
-0.08997063338756561,
-0.6890907883644104,
0.5798147320747375,
0.8103570342063904,
0.5820719003677368,
-0.8914056420326233,
0.12843507528305054,
0.1634972244501114,
0.6057566404342651,
-0.2748444378376007,
0.3963445723056793,
0.40497681498527527,
-1.2787630558013916,
-0.26370999217033386,
-0.4939018785953522,
-0.266602486371994,
0.31598562002182007,
-1.0986839532852173,
0.4429398477077484,
-0.05026910826563835,
0.22891217470169067,
0.3621377646923065,
-0.37796568870544434,
-0.3805057406425476,
-0.15360039472579956,
-0.03743603825569153,
0.7051143646240234,
-1.1219148635864258,
0.7130683064460754,
0.8441190719604492,
-0.03151634708046913,
-0.6398134231567383,
0.24589881300926208,
0.8667187094688416,
-1.3432974815368652,
0.4523526430130005,
0.11046572774648666,
-0.2121480107307434,
-0.06903590261936188,
-1.0133885145187378,
-0.9525229334831238,
1.0403335094451904,
0.39920780062675476,
-0.43512848019599915,
-0.15361234545707703,
0.2541296184062958,
0.48315009474754333,
-0.3309434652328491,
-0.15683050453662872,
0.827609658241272,
0.4787929356098175,
0.11562565714120865,
-0.835978090763092,
0.240032359957695,
0.021139021962881088,
-0.30669519305229187,
0.5250826478004456,
-0.5117900371551514,
0.9223953485488892,
-0.0854300782084465,
-0.4781164228916168,
0.3967287838459015,
0.24688220024108887,
0.41631507873535156,
0.4091663360595703,
0.6422716379165649,
0.7043390870094299,
0.8032659888267517,
-0.05155130475759506,
0.9050843119621277,
-0.3151877522468567,
0.15695039927959442,
1.2508323192596436,
-0.5365252494812012,
0.6318199038505554,
0.6668544411659241,
0.0687708854675293,
0.4594998359680176,
0.3867570757865906,
-0.21090206503868103,
0.34633171558380127,
0.17848682403564453,
0.007727831602096558,
-0.5827193260192871,
0.30479663610458374,
0.19106315076351166,
0.9580441117286682,
0.5941606163978577,
-0.2715151607990265,
-0.12608197331428528,
-0.3230914771556854,
0.42628785967826843,
0.3086320459842682,
-0.3070557415485382,
0.67668217420578,
-0.05048390477895737,
-0.7870145440101624,
0.1019938662648201,
-0.1743151843547821,
0.5543742179870605,
-0.22799263894557953,
-0.04351133480668068,
-0.18335969746112823,
0.3139709532260895,
-0.2513536810874939,
-0.8782351613044739,
0.2925173044204712,
-0.2557629346847534,
-0.07167794555425644,
-0.2831136882305145,
0.8236597776412964,
-0.3385283052921295,
-0.25861039757728577,
0.15944717824459076,
0.6921504735946655,
0.15927444398403168,
0.043501824140548706,
-0.5281359553337097,
-0.05889873206615448,
-0.03592386469244957,
-0.11792965233325958,
0.43524348735809326,
0.43495914340019226,
-0.28560465574264526,
0.7787132263183594,
0.8035871386528015,
-0.07125459611415863,
0.11335685849189758,
-0.46826598048210144,
0.5895593166351318,
-0.6948365569114685,
-0.3337293863296509,
-0.8924952745437622,
0.5082303285598755,
-0.11785367876291275,
-0.36343905329704285,
0.8853780627250671,
0.5572681427001953,
0.7836793661117554,
0.0477735660970211,
0.04027535766363144,
0.2939990758895874,
0.6780495643615723,
-0.5467604994773865,
0.887403130531311,
-0.45445987582206726,
0.44448989629745483,
-0.2444058656692505,
-0.6651039123535156,
-0.3257678151130676,
0.530635416507721,
-0.1501571238040924,
-0.20533980429172516,
0.6367458701133728,
1.0488086938858032,
-0.30773207545280457,
0.15259070694446564,
0.482151061296463,
0.46877703070640564,
0.06073224917054176,
0.05894996225833893,
1.1938530206680298,
-0.4939223527908325,
0.22851677238941193,
0.05936755612492561,
-0.016330817714333534,
-0.2020304799079895,
-1.0130069255828857,
-0.9775596261024475,
-0.45298585295677185,
-0.5294894576072693,
-0.47495970129966736,
-0.1417776346206665,
0.4080502688884735,
0.4181254506111145,
-0.8839744329452515,
-0.2003854513168335,
0.13018810749053955,
0.271729439496994,
-0.35173752903938293,
-0.2586762011051178,
0.20951277017593384,
0.04496776685118675,
-0.7727475762367249,
0.5736664533615112,
0.001147367642261088,
0.2469673454761505,
-0.1400120109319687,
0.15259318053722382,
-0.28683942556381226,
0.2932509481906891,
0.19654902815818787,
0.324825644493103,
-1.0439738035202026,
-0.49680987000465393,
0.25943705439567566,
-0.0448850654065609,
0.009457248263061047,
1.020232915878296,
-0.5251449942588806,
0.3800566792488098,
0.2304651439189911,
0.4306137263774872,
0.1946132928133011,
0.3227051794528961,
0.6603116393089294,
-0.9788379669189453,
-0.037080906331539154,
0.1988144814968109,
0.30312544107437134,
0.07629437744617462,
-0.5654632449150085,
0.421219140291214,
-0.027621597051620483,
-0.8375518321990967,
-1.186441421508789,
0.3826170265674591,
-0.9974079132080078,
-0.37855643033981323,
0.9590203762054443,
-0.03089834190905094,
-0.18327753245830536,
-0.16963839530944824,
0.36658793687820435,
0.2021975964307785,
0.005104284733533859,
0.6997718811035156,
0.8292607069015503,
-0.49987366795539856,
-0.09311150014400482,
-0.4946387708187103,
0.776261568069458,
0.40840208530426025,
-0.5341386795043945,
-0.0151301184669137,
0.5825493931770325,
0.6825346350669861,
0.28979241847991943,
0.26003769040107727,
-0.4033399224281311,
0.1724531501531601,
-0.3350907266139984,
-0.13869385421276093,
0.1333649456501007,
0.007347146049141884,
-0.7360048890113831,
-0.14949047565460205,
-0.12117476016283035,
-0.10266479104757309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05465v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05465v2
|
Vidur: A Large-Scale Simulation Framework For LLM Inference
| 2024-05-08T23:42:13 | 2024-05-21T05:17:29 |
Amey Agrawal, Nitin Kedia, Jayashree Mohan, Ashish Panwar, Nipun Kwatra, Bhargav Gulavani, Ramachandran Ramjee, Alexey Tumanov
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Optimizing the deployment of Large language models (LLMs) is expensive today
since it requires experimentally running an application workload against an LLM
implementation while exploring large configuration space formed by system knobs
such as parallelization strategies, batching techniques, and scheduling
policies. To address this challenge, we present Vidur - a large-scale,
high-fidelity, easily-extensible simulation framework for LLM inference
performance. Vidur models the performance of LLM operators using a combination
of experimental profiling and predictive modeling, and evaluates the end-to-end
inference performance for different workloads by estimating several metrics of
interest such as latency and throughput. We validate the fidelity of Vidur on
several LLMs and show that it estimates inference latency with less than 9%
error across the range. Further, we present Vidur-Search, a configuration
search tool that helps optimize LLM deployment. Vidur-Search uses Vidur to
automatically identify the most cost-effective deployment configuration that
meets application performance constraints. For example, Vidur-Search finds the
best deployment configuration for LLaMA2-70B in one hour on a CPU machine, in
contrast to a deployment-based exploration which would require 42K GPU hours -
costing ~218K dollars. Source code for Vidur is available at
https://github.com/microsoft/vidur.
|
[
-0.4661349654197693,
-0.9263718128204346,
0.6272886395454407,
0.8590688109397888,
-0.14311182498931885,
-0.039648763835430145,
-0.4043704867362976,
-0.3206613063812256,
0.029697973281145096,
0.6382483243942261,
-0.3809390962123871,
-0.5766755938529968,
-0.1325245499610901,
-0.24729852378368378,
-0.49814942479133606,
0.1481187492609024,
0.030256634578108788,
-0.2454950362443924,
-0.5086765289306641,
-0.074066661298275,
-0.2079695165157318,
-0.45917773246765137,
-0.7304676175117493,
-0.21377336978912354,
0.55550217628479,
0.22007007896900177,
0.5965889692306519,
0.7275987267494202,
0.5072522163391113,
0.3481530547142029,
-0.3899242877960205,
0.31341949105262756,
-0.5013778209686279,
0.3582940697669983,
-0.29282259941101074,
-0.5946915745735168,
-0.5381364226341248,
-0.35979875922203064,
0.7710044384002686,
0.6556241512298584,
-0.618168830871582,
0.4651838541030884,
-0.3510521650314331,
0.2687545120716095,
-0.8434848785400391,
0.17466294765472412,
-0.5229800939559937,
0.18426914513111115,
-0.2514650225639343,
0.19254663586616516,
-0.30825695395469666,
-0.27608928084373474,
0.1276221126317978,
-0.748995304107666,
0.2609015107154846,
0.4207856059074402,
0.40227842330932617,
0.4129604995250702,
-0.2898118793964386,
0.3625788688659668,
-0.8972048759460449,
0.8794520497322083,
-0.6282261610031128,
0.30045533180236816,
-0.032924503087997437,
0.4601142406463623,
-0.36040714383125305,
-0.7392577528953552,
-0.5430695414543152,
-0.07981405407190323,
0.24348056316375732,
0.1191379651427269,
-0.1434875875711441,
0.377736896276474,
0.38210639357566833,
0.32349130511283875,
-0.6325240135192871,
0.2585335671901703,
-0.3642207980155945,
-0.06918182224035263,
0.46918097138404846,
0.4704401195049286,
-0.13189542293548584,
0.4338194727897644,
-0.2454412877559662,
-0.1485348492860794,
-0.7419472932815552,
-0.17334780097007751,
0.3751779794692993,
0.01839596964418888,
-0.06740504503250122,
0.6304761171340942,
-0.2071344256401062,
0.7351915240287781,
-0.4488866627216339,
-0.1618635058403015,
0.2003473937511444,
-0.13798773288726807,
-0.5986921191215515,
0.058188606053590775,
0.7569065093994141,
0.26401880383491516,
0.14617884159088135,
0.042707234621047974,
-0.29885971546173096,
0.3462134003639221,
0.6576418876647949,
-0.9611418843269348,
0.3150996267795563,
0.25098729133605957,
-0.3125723898410797,
-0.39554017782211304,
-0.4694308638572693,
-1.0070054531097412,
-0.39924848079681396,
-0.2603722810745239,
0.14570176601409912,
-0.08101683109998703,
-0.38279107213020325,
0.3638744354248047,
-0.06090766564011574,
0.364692360162735,
0.537724494934082,
-0.5968006253242493,
0.43006566166877747,
0.7462995052337646,
0.9097573161125183,
-0.6529631614685059,
-0.24173066020011902,
-0.6699643135070801,
-0.011242765933275223,
-0.4311465322971344,
0.7342495322227478,
-0.4807513952255249,
-0.7583393454551697,
0.21240706741809845,
0.04046013951301575,
-0.2010633945465088,
-0.7458818554878235,
0.44034188985824585,
-0.6309800148010254,
-0.41863882541656494,
0.22630515694618225,
-0.4682721495628357,
-0.038021352142095566,
0.2389746904373169,
-0.8451728820800781,
1.1046139001846313,
0.15159213542938232,
-0.48954302072525024,
0.0029925303533673286,
-0.5414194464683533,
-0.5016487836837769,
-0.11028287559747696,
-0.21254725754261017,
-0.49084481596946716,
0.36780595779418945,
-0.11484360694885254,
0.3337732255458832,
-0.8512693643569946,
0.20052000880241394,
-0.4256918132305145,
-0.7686071991920471,
-0.03545574098825455,
-0.5359665155410767,
0.5419613122940063,
0.38143572211265564,
-0.533682644367218,
0.08602716773748398,
-0.673316478729248,
-0.18475474417209625,
0.1401296705007553,
-0.3639317452907562,
-0.07408914715051651,
0.17777709662914276,
-0.023251665756106377,
-0.28446751832962036,
0.21488089859485626,
-0.37864598631858826,
0.17550358176231384,
-0.32825371623039246,
0.12219215929508209,
0.49266934394836426,
-0.11627259105443954,
0.39413926005363464,
0.10992436856031418,
0.9003891944885254,
-0.04319828748703003,
0.6094495058059692,
-0.039467841386795044,
-0.3787684142589569,
-0.6577664613723755,
-0.1336289793252945,
-0.05945960432291031,
0.5308734178543091,
-0.4410163462162018,
-0.2820669412612915,
-0.28748011589050293,
-0.5991677641868591,
-0.4658949077129364,
0.22153857350349426,
0.5317708849906921,
0.4633648991584778,
0.2663833200931549,
0.12874449789524078,
-0.48723888397216797,
-1.1384538412094116,
0.005870034918189049,
-0.39970919489860535,
0.3125566244125366,
0.2299954742193222,
0.3710973262786865,
-0.3992518484592438,
0.8299999833106995,
-0.5851821303367615,
0.10633699595928192,
-0.055117204785346985,
0.05118300020694733,
0.320076584815979,
0.2581888437271118,
0.5790628790855408,
-0.7747111320495605,
-0.15105508267879486,
0.2148454636335373,
-0.7754060626029968,
-0.17244930565357208,
0.15319475531578064,
-0.2327573150396347,
0.05030934512615204,
0.8567138314247131,
-0.3646005392074585,
0.3986256420612335,
0.9325821399688721,
0.025163179263472557,
0.9437431693077087,
-0.540503978729248,
-0.22862941026687622,
-0.703283429145813,
0.21341253817081451,
0.016967570409178734,
-0.05990683287382126,
-0.23399849236011505,
0.22167441248893738,
0.06111656874418259,
0.10723884403705597,
-0.7136465311050415,
0.682786762714386,
-0.36000823974609375,
-0.2109571248292923,
0.03059489093720913,
-0.1230703815817833,
0.2593986988067627,
0.2063363939523697,
-0.07104261219501495,
1.590565800666809,
0.38665875792503357,
-0.6241937279701233,
0.40937042236328125,
-0.035670895129442215,
-0.5042388439178467,
0.6469330191612244,
-0.873934268951416,
-0.1921348124742508,
-0.026142017915844917,
0.037545543164014816,
-0.7418532371520996,
-0.24418368935585022,
-0.39358580112457275,
0.22070272266864777,
0.06206069514155388,
-0.4273033142089844,
-0.6102197766304016,
-0.32199519872665405,
-0.11440514028072357,
0.6336495876312256,
0.738503634929657,
-0.5596910715103149,
0.8734965324401855,
0.4804903268814087,
0.07572052627801895,
-0.6675083041191101,
-0.7868117690086365,
0.08789301663637161,
-0.3729516267776489,
-0.6405850052833557,
0.4405136704444885,
-0.12106744945049286,
-0.6501818299293518,
-0.3495674133300781,
-0.03746411204338074,
0.05547278746962547,
0.3521575331687927,
0.5362237691879272,
0.06667879223823547,
-0.6085709929466248,
0.014582577161490917,
0.21454840898513794,
-0.041113901883363724,
0.2231513112783432,
-0.4431309401988983,
0.4394283890724182,
-0.333944171667099,
-0.7334873080253601,
0.04353134334087372,
0.2440711110830307,
0.8737266659736633,
-0.2653448283672333,
0.6176630258560181,
0.5147826671600342,
-0.1727469116449356,
-0.42699599266052246,
-0.9473966360092163,
0.25099679827690125,
-0.4883646070957184,
0.3110833466053009,
-0.2767988443374634,
-0.5038072466850281,
0.5372009873390198,
-0.4926835000514984,
0.3573576807975769,
0.30432915687561035,
0.5506091117858887,
-0.04859115928411484,
0.8763782978057861,
0.49130702018737793,
-0.008893919177353382,
0.5665310621261597,
-0.37300512194633484,
-0.12410598248243332,
-0.7660722136497498,
-0.2843887507915497,
-0.4215403199195862,
0.015440762042999268,
-0.13615140318870544,
-0.9191887378692627,
0.6166598200798035,
-0.14484518766403198,
-0.3384823501110077,
0.11876621097326279,
-0.24199169874191284,
0.39328238368034363,
0.6151904463768005,
-0.25479787588119507,
0.32495981454849243,
0.2842199206352234,
-0.3760150074958801,
0.24109980463981628,
-0.44011959433555603,
-0.3196446895599365,
0.7915483713150024,
0.05486726760864258,
0.9138733744621277,
0.1539996862411499,
0.2690180540084839,
0.3113783895969391,
0.3133028745651245,
-0.4521716833114624,
0.5017157196998596,
-0.0003171343414578587,
-0.5725740194320679,
-0.3007906973361969,
-0.28410714864730835,
-0.8674639463424683,
0.4781509339809418,
0.024684786796569824,
-0.6320445537567139,
0.13325577974319458,
0.22802132368087769,
-0.4199138283729553,
0.38003993034362793,
-0.7092052698135376,
0.7391598224639893,
-0.2974150776863098,
-0.7109449505805969,
-0.42748215794563293,
-0.3549708425998688,
0.24604441225528717,
-0.31666499376296997,
0.20696021616458893,
-0.2340422421693802,
-0.10975217819213867,
0.34702223539352417,
-0.5087264180183411,
0.8292826414108276,
-0.23314717411994934,
-0.18060874938964844,
0.2601570785045624,
0.2115456908941269,
0.5946718454360962,
0.2098550796508789,
-0.7146161198616028,
0.14707937836647034,
-0.05294809117913246,
-0.3260619342327118,
-0.6875172257423401,
0.7018214464187622,
-0.6018226146697998,
-0.5761783719062805,
-0.14129023253917694,
-0.25759992003440857,
-0.07567236572504044,
0.056472595781087875,
0.0691886767745018,
0.25405022501945496,
-0.6019665598869324,
0.072911836206913,
1.1147607564926147,
-0.5491984486579895,
0.22737674415111542,
0.36805811524391174,
-0.5378996133804321,
-0.3532412052154541,
0.7049689292907715,
-0.11078093200922012,
0.3256365656852722,
0.3790859282016754,
0.017789354547858238,
-0.2136453539133072,
-0.8108097910881042,
-0.589652955532074,
0.1660195142030716,
-0.38996946811676025,
-0.049151696264743805,
-0.6122044920921326,
-0.18689797818660736,
0.09335272014141083,
-0.21543553471565247,
-0.830154299736023,
-0.08025780320167542,
-0.13760288059711456,
-0.12179195135831833,
0.5208838582038879,
0.4271761178970337,
0.1683075726032257,
0.9300410747528076,
-0.23187600076198578,
0.08962712436914444,
0.14924056828022003,
0.422181636095047,
-0.1407601684331894,
-0.2673349380493164,
-0.36652764678001404,
-0.08632399886846542,
-0.0217988733202219,
-0.20787100493907928,
0.25721895694732666,
0.10995135456323624,
0.6604498624801636,
0.5445005297660828,
-0.05711726099252701,
0.7671964764595032,
-0.43349018692970276,
0.6698818206787109,
-0.10401304811239243,
-0.6140151023864746,
0.2911757826805115,
-0.24850468337535858,
0.15446530282497406,
0.6956679821014404,
-0.22710712254047394,
-0.2823396623134613,
-0.21659640967845917,
-0.4391244947910309,
-0.9809321165084839,
0.3984885513782501,
0.17858916521072388,
0.11600219458341599,
0.0815708115696907,
0.40968552231788635,
-0.04821734502911568,
0.3642060458660126,
0.04176478460431099,
-0.3862309157848358,
0.3027324378490448,
0.031198451295495033,
-0.2831003963947296,
-0.3676029443740845,
-0.20685942471027374,
-0.27820008993148804,
0.5152425765991211,
-0.3071390688419342,
0.3601248264312744,
0.05399877205491066,
-0.3212259113788605,
0.2989014983177185,
-0.15644553303718567,
0.8371067643165588,
0.5513927340507507,
-0.2504182755947113,
0.29462119936943054,
0.5623447299003601,
-0.46885260939598083,
0.1706770658493042,
-0.03579981252551079,
0.00986736360937357,
0.15168923139572144,
0.3196122944355011,
0.9259263873100281,
0.2752629220485687,
-1.048803448677063,
0.6966338157653809,
-0.36769726872444153,
-0.28625956177711487,
-0.7690286040306091,
0.4088258743286133,
0.4438549280166626,
0.6345691680908203,
-0.07983769476413727,
-0.27631625533103943,
0.07739073038101196,
-0.029817407950758934,
-0.2166561782360077,
0.24563166499137878,
-0.24891288578510284,
-0.05171586200594902,
0.8820420503616333,
0.007611668203026056,
-0.20752301812171936,
0.6566517353057861,
-0.005965664982795715,
-0.22784247994422913,
0.99029141664505,
0.3882268965244293,
0.7529189586639404,
-0.19136425852775574,
0.12405538558959961,
-0.0235834252089262,
0.29779568314552307,
-0.5922935605049133,
0.41173097491264343,
0.02244437113404274,
-0.34080177545547485,
-0.5887129306793213,
-0.9590552449226379,
-0.7326639294624329,
-0.1474505066871643,
-0.4387741982936859,
0.1646854430437088,
-0.4540284276008606,
-0.2645542621612549,
-0.22503089904785156,
-0.2796917259693146,
-0.875460684299469,
0.0005842573009431362,
0.17701558768749237,
1.2885499000549316,
-0.5879800915718079,
0.7134737968444824,
0.6264765858650208,
-0.11771687865257263,
-0.45161905884742737,
-0.5053651928901672,
0.05917460843920708,
-0.8526567220687866,
0.3772275149822235,
-0.043188463896512985,
-0.48726963996887207,
-0.10136361420154572,
-0.3532294034957886,
-0.7978226542472839,
1.2177878618240356,
0.8973589539527893,
-0.6827198266983032,
-0.12419513612985611,
0.19582991302013397,
0.587290346622467,
-0.2889924943447113,
0.6099785566329956,
0.7396194338798523,
0.659998893737793,
-0.0064231883734464645,
-0.7084562182426453,
-0.19680070877075195,
-0.1997496485710144,
0.3319765627384186,
0.004130970686674118,
-0.8441572785377502,
0.8011173009872437,
-0.0999162346124649,
0.06248687580227852,
-0.020772026851773262,
0.4865124821662903,
0.3206714391708374,
0.32577985525131226,
0.6289060711860657,
0.35902509093284607,
0.811090886592865,
0.21311990916728973,
1.1040489673614502,
-0.3654633164405823,
0.1781001091003418,
0.9122759103775024,
-0.5726627111434937,
0.6889966726303101,
0.6386106610298157,
-0.20906873047351837,
0.272060364484787,
0.6199288368225098,
-0.07169841229915619,
0.2324107587337494,
0.5434341430664062,
-0.582850992679596,
-0.29430943727493286,
-0.22712311148643494,
-0.2504490315914154,
0.2725234925746918,
0.49582305550575256,
-0.41097378730773926,
-0.1628124862909317,
-0.10925014317035675,
0.15130740404129028,
-0.30081069469451904,
-0.12662804126739502,
0.5149088501930237,
0.2528272271156311,
-0.6869336366653442,
0.5639443397521973,
-0.07416603714227676,
0.3808150589466095,
-0.5795118808746338,
0.07739418745040894,
-0.47429728507995605,
0.4143664240837097,
-0.06527607887983322,
-0.37719306349754333,
0.24964192509651184,
-0.17772093415260315,
-0.12586332857608795,
-0.16093809902668,
0.4204612970352173,
-0.051752444356679916,
-0.46341750025749207,
0.7199978232383728,
0.5919498801231384,
0.2031841278076172,
-0.4129164218902588,
-0.2827839255332947,
0.4929843246936798,
-0.25259676575660706,
-0.6116623878479004,
0.36234354972839355,
0.4294626712799072,
-0.2544986307621002,
0.8040674924850464,
0.6846336722373962,
0.27039265632629395,
0.2520967721939087,
0.1637476682662964,
0.8249772191047668,
-0.4466211795806885,
-0.24141612648963928,
-0.9704483151435852,
0.3227849006652832,
-0.29438140988349915,
-0.22569091618061066,
0.2829544246196747,
0.7927118539810181,
0.4029315412044525,
-0.07053357362747192,
0.7716751098632812,
0.46615687012672424,
0.00944564864039421,
-0.47341880202293396,
0.5719847679138184,
-0.8286153674125671,
0.445220947265625,
-0.03844374790787697,
-0.9928459525108337,
-0.3646167814731598,
0.4281311631202698,
-0.17359206080436707,
-0.3692273199558258,
0.5488969683647156,
1.094278335571289,
-0.5324476361274719,
-0.05146358534693718,
0.4771391749382019,
0.16006287932395935,
0.4208289086818695,
0.13585571944713593,
0.7628626823425293,
0.06627988070249557,
0.5669152736663818,
-0.12380772829055786,
0.002855344908311963,
-0.6584864258766174,
-0.9516036510467529,
-0.7363752126693726,
-0.21899443864822388,
-0.12198400497436523,
-0.3292156457901001,
0.2773902714252472,
0.9075194001197815,
0.8250800967216492,
-0.3968092203140259,
-0.5623101592063904,
-0.14880818128585815,
0.1583024114370346,
-0.3193429112434387,
-0.13655711710453033,
0.13730669021606445,
-0.2700318992137909,
-0.7593483924865723,
0.6137478351593018,
0.2844370901584625,
-0.0898982360959053,
-0.5668931007385254,
0.05962380766868591,
0.21836166083812714,
0.1471196413040161,
0.6872049570083618,
0.3399348556995392,
-0.5048391222953796,
0.05621188506484032,
0.04528818652033806,
-0.22844663262367249,
-0.035339221358299255,
0.8553507924079895,
-0.6957039833068848,
0.42800214886665344,
0.4098120629787445,
1.0181413888931274,
1.0657967329025269,
-0.22886984050273895,
0.9107952117919922,
-0.6045204997062683,
0.32012617588043213,
0.0158980842679739,
0.48552265763282776,
-0.13994243741035461,
-0.14987681806087494,
0.7412624359130859,
0.06508097797632217,
-0.35711023211479187,
-1.0396889448165894,
0.04871545359492302,
-0.8375369906425476,
-0.04368068650364876,
1.2803977727890015,
-0.12225345522165298,
-0.5459295511245728,
-0.14736473560333252,
-0.21244485676288605,
0.08896200358867645,
-0.2952878177165985,
0.3858829438686371,
0.376595675945282,
0.13548524677753448,
0.13633161783218384,
-1.0500082969665527,
0.1744552105665207,
0.43915772438049316,
-0.7017498016357422,
0.23958173394203186,
0.30222654342651367,
0.1794266551733017,
0.005077969748526812,
0.2928527891635895,
0.062052179127931595,
0.02367510460317135,
0.22003376483917236,
0.33906710147857666,
-0.17430855333805084,
-0.2816835641860962,
-0.2679375410079956,
0.2548663914203644,
0.09908230602741241,
-0.018480315804481506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05444v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05444v1
|
Evaluating Students' Open-ended Written Responses with LLMs: Using the RAG Framework for GPT-3.5, GPT-4, Claude-3, and Mistral-Large
| 2024-05-08T22:23:58 | 2024-05-08T22:23:58 |
Jussi S. Jauhiainen, Agustín Garagorry Guerra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Evaluating open-ended written examination responses from students is an
essential yet time-intensive task for educators, requiring a high degree of
effort, consistency, and precision. Recent developments in Large Language
Models (LLMs) present a promising opportunity to balance the need for thorough
evaluation with efficient use of educators' time. In our study, we explore the
effectiveness of LLMs ChatGPT-3.5, ChatGPT-4, Claude-3, and Mistral-Large in
assessing university students' open-ended answers to questions made about
reference material they have studied. Each model was instructed to evaluate 54
answers repeatedly under two conditions: 10 times (10-shot) with a temperature
setting of 0.0 and 10 times with a temperature of 0.5, expecting a total of
1,080 evaluations per model and 4,320 evaluations across all models. The RAG
(Retrieval Augmented Generation) framework was used as the framework to make
the LLMs to process the evaluation of the answers. As of spring 2024, our
analysis revealed notable variations in consistency and the grading outcomes
provided by studied LLMs. There is a need to comprehend strengths and
weaknesses of LLMs in educational settings for evaluating open-ended written
responses. Further comparative research is essential to determine the accuracy
and cost-effectiveness of using LLMs for educational assessments.
|
[
-0.2452939748764038,
-0.8423810601234436,
0.8333881497383118,
0.09055840224027634,
-0.24843372404575348,
-0.0684136226773262,
-0.4722830355167389,
-0.3684510588645935,
-0.16479481756687164,
0.3601493835449219,
-0.022790901362895966,
-0.29098159074783325,
-0.37002602219581604,
0.31570568680763245,
-0.4153684377670288,
1.0137982368469238,
-0.5801776647567749,
0.3699892461299896,
-0.44459548592567444,
-0.08989587426185608,
-0.19265690445899963,
-0.5043376088142395,
-0.5986620187759399,
-0.47267526388168335,
0.6261888146400452,
0.23764413595199585,
0.46663060784339905,
0.19694477319717407,
0.8713554739952087,
0.2508678138256073,
-0.038150604814291,
-0.16914096474647522,
-0.6047466993331909,
0.06061087176203728,
-0.19340559840202332,
-0.23492221534252167,
-0.43158960342407227,
0.38522547483444214,
0.7770741581916809,
0.6714047789573669,
-0.20572535693645477,
0.5695945024490356,
0.24579790234565735,
0.6647155284881592,
-0.8604608774185181,
-0.14299815893173218,
-0.3622977137565613,
0.07464008033275604,
-0.16811595857143402,
-0.22666288912296295,
-0.6647478342056274,
-0.6076818108558655,
0.17350433766841888,
-0.36908742785453796,
-0.04023449122905731,
-0.4912668764591217,
0.7412266135215759,
-0.024042701348662376,
-0.22744642198085785,
-0.6585972309112549,
-0.8514121770858765,
0.6982378363609314,
-0.7508703470230103,
0.4439104199409485,
0.06105681508779526,
0.31013157963752747,
-0.15125425159931183,
-0.8840010762214661,
-0.6136971116065979,
-0.4528580904006958,
0.08785634487867355,
0.6621701121330261,
0.08653175085783005,
0.008692407980561256,
0.221477672457695,
0.5515358448028564,
-0.6009873151779175,
0.22309841215610504,
-0.31358274817466736,
0.14061066508293152,
0.36868664622306824,
0.4964544177055359,
-0.037315018475055695,
-0.04644801467657089,
-0.5713673830032349,
-0.1225724071264267,
-0.5488442778587341,
0.1154339611530304,
0.5469078421592712,
0.34839463233947754,
0.1279040277004242,
0.8633604645729065,
0.09523970633745193,
0.9025139212608337,
-0.3011167049407959,
-0.2553096115589142,
-0.05500065162777901,
-0.23691216111183167,
-0.4104526937007904,
-0.5214571952819824,
0.8033477663993835,
0.5404382348060608,
0.37970784306526184,
-0.19548547267913818,
-0.37149617075920105,
0.15215469896793365,
0.06329625844955444,
-0.9801115989685059,
0.09403534978628159,
0.34861886501312256,
-0.3793485760688782,
-0.2429792284965515,
0.044196825474500656,
-0.9920750260353088,
-0.21707108616828918,
-0.5428675413131714,
0.5739816427230835,
-0.019861795008182526,
-0.12598943710327148,
0.29235416650772095,
0.053962163627147675,
0.4279946982860565,
0.5345569849014282,
-0.46235769987106323,
0.5593686103820801,
0.42147743701934814,
0.8548110723495483,
-0.4886878430843353,
-0.17954373359680176,
-0.3377533257007599,
-0.11743959039449692,
-0.25463786721229553,
0.6553581357002258,
-0.6499379277229309,
-0.573144257068634,
0.04095369577407837,
-0.3434428870677948,
-0.3259545862674713,
-0.42061108350753784,
0.7216393351554871,
-0.6574311852455139,
0.6546233892440796,
-0.006312830839306116,
-0.7918791770935059,
0.18882085382938385,
0.31438934803009033,
-0.5320037007331848,
1.1423124074935913,
0.31409013271331787,
-0.7382456660270691,
-0.06992712616920471,
-0.6131767630577087,
0.03433162346482277,
-0.03608051314949989,
-0.13413628935813904,
-0.33881357312202454,
0.1566634476184845,
-0.0021748526487499475,
0.5657317042350769,
-0.663886308670044,
0.03245394676923752,
-0.11294175684452057,
-0.5882444381713867,
0.6358943581581116,
-0.5273749232292175,
0.5945565700531006,
0.23945921659469604,
-0.14883935451507568,
0.009273791685700417,
-0.5188645720481873,
0.25700604915618896,
0.303892582654953,
-0.7221826314926147,
-0.34270715713500977,
-0.34461626410484314,
-0.05122397094964981,
-0.12449507415294647,
0.2683597207069397,
-0.7538961172103882,
0.2395658791065216,
-0.02457677572965622,
0.04028332978487015,
0.8808665871620178,
0.0016978767234832048,
0.22754305601119995,
-0.30613428354263306,
0.871997594833374,
-0.230878546833992,
0.004659776110202074,
-0.06418517231941223,
-0.34709495306015015,
-0.6514070630073547,
0.04768356308341026,
0.3306869566440582,
0.44517433643341064,
-0.5735270977020264,
-0.31536614894866943,
-0.12779419124126434,
-0.7395802736282349,
-0.4234555959701538,
0.07438511401414871,
0.5209706425666809,
0.6438393592834473,
0.1752137541770935,
-0.21347424387931824,
-0.2030569314956665,
-0.3972780108451843,
-0.47543731331825256,
-0.13060829043388367,
-0.2296229749917984,
0.4699133336544037,
0.48580843210220337,
0.047640539705753326,
0.8582419753074646,
-0.6887016296386719,
0.02656540647149086,
0.009866810403764248,
0.08889792859554291,
0.31861013174057007,
-0.008009098470211029,
0.4182228744029999,
-0.48510733246803284,
-0.5857955813407898,
-0.07665702700614929,
-0.5977879166603088,
-0.31475603580474854,
0.011436155065894127,
0.03726692497730255,
0.36894088983535767,
0.32306748628616333,
-0.30856379866600037,
0.3002188205718994,
0.6061861515045166,
-0.28373152017593384,
0.9164026975631714,
-0.002638756763190031,
0.19714869558811188,
-0.8100951313972473,
0.10619427263736725,
0.14356060326099396,
-0.076521135866642,
-0.4256158769130707,
0.23183949291706085,
0.02973071299493313,
-0.10105575621128082,
-0.4451245665550232,
0.970802903175354,
-0.6063532829284668,
-0.07373270392417908,
-0.2403605729341507,
0.594419538974762,
-0.11171925067901611,
0.21882742643356323,
-0.1167328730225563,
0.9424024820327759,
0.11954259127378464,
-0.3336729407310486,
0.36389508843421936,
-0.17588724195957184,
-0.43938136100769043,
0.6413609981536865,
-0.678800106048584,
0.35015782713890076,
-0.09611063450574875,
0.2740468680858612,
-0.8511987328529358,
-0.13402488827705383,
0.14650219678878784,
-0.5451340675354004,
0.2327088713645935,
0.10611943155527115,
-0.29718196392059326,
-0.564971387386322,
-0.4025593400001526,
0.3380325734615326,
0.4993976354598999,
-0.5122250318527222,
0.7065163254737854,
-0.05234542861580849,
-0.24301095306873322,
-0.6264269948005676,
-0.1851019561290741,
-0.07329326122999191,
-0.24418708682060242,
-0.406796932220459,
-0.23166298866271973,
-0.4695656895637512,
-0.5064110159873962,
0.03511771187186241,
-0.16411598026752472,
-0.06727198511362076,
-0.008444003760814667,
0.019499558955430984,
0.43067675828933716,
-0.40013644099235535,
0.13257206976413727,
-0.46086105704307556,
0.11856129765510559,
0.060808803886175156,
-0.13874877989292145,
0.5501940846443176,
-0.24133771657943726,
-0.4599558115005493,
0.1325804740190506,
0.15483684837818146,
0.5884335041046143,
-0.18733245134353638,
0.5855490565299988,
0.43588337302207947,
-0.242384135723114,
-0.0882556289434433,
-0.6615049242973328,
-0.20582985877990723,
-0.4322666823863983,
0.205440953373909,
-0.4483216404914856,
-1.0193384885787964,
0.43580469489097595,
0.0828925371170044,
0.2547214925289154,
0.30676427483558655,
0.7707846164703369,
-0.10145904868841171,
0.40058696269989014,
0.31693705916404724,
0.23134075105190277,
0.2535842955112457,
-0.04016953706741333,
0.11494575440883636,
-1.0854649543762207,
-0.21847331523895264,
-0.7683517336845398,
-0.016567742452025414,
-0.4832215905189514,
-0.5905296802520752,
0.4315181076526642,
0.1653476059436798,
-0.08580108731985092,
-0.07020164281129837,
-0.3855489194393158,
0.5979985594749451,
0.22926653921604156,
0.18334172666072845,
0.35075482726097107,
-0.1614786684513092,
-0.25054821372032166,
0.02672942355275154,
-0.39855971932411194,
-0.8659898042678833,
1.391428828239441,
0.6434029340744019,
0.9247179627418518,
0.23802872002124786,
0.47396090626716614,
-0.10577881336212158,
0.9151543378829956,
-0.859790027141571,
0.7561004161834717,
-0.05628681927919388,
-0.41393131017684937,
-0.6357437968254089,
-0.593524694442749,
-0.9466773867607117,
0.5524083375930786,
0.009924876503646374,
-0.6584142446517944,
-0.35726380348205566,
-0.3549383580684662,
-0.0826975479722023,
0.43163836002349854,
-0.6012681722640991,
0.5438106060028076,
-0.22903648018836975,
-0.6493862867355347,
0.28487566113471985,
-0.3194220960140228,
0.41557741165161133,
-0.409565269947052,
0.11561664938926697,
-0.14027966558933258,
-0.16158123314380646,
1.0063306093215942,
-0.24458883702754974,
0.6382643580436707,
-0.08311931043863297,
-0.3604334592819214,
0.5760105848312378,
-0.08731140941381454,
0.16798564791679382,
0.026560746133327484,
-0.45670104026794434,
-0.11700347810983658,
0.13076651096343994,
-0.22814808785915375,
-0.7132581472396851,
0.682380735874176,
-0.803196907043457,
-0.667400598526001,
-0.675216794013977,
-0.603313684463501,
-0.18044652044773102,
0.16261859238147736,
0.06256014108657837,
0.6311376094818115,
-0.4062703251838684,
0.10009271651506424,
0.5907468795776367,
-0.16870516538619995,
0.4468019902706146,
0.9336373805999756,
-0.5365443229675293,
-0.3470457196235657,
0.6759506464004517,
0.21392284333705902,
0.5608891248703003,
0.048925284296274185,
0.6137763261795044,
-0.3144117295742035,
-0.3820211887359619,
-0.4710114002227783,
0.40475431084632874,
-0.7666094899177551,
-0.28173044323921204,
-0.499439537525177,
-0.23011301457881927,
-0.5370813012123108,
-0.19486352801322937,
-0.030624328181147575,
-0.23023223876953125,
-0.21617017686367035,
0.022282632067799568,
0.15201959013938904,
0.9695389866828918,
0.023121120408177376,
0.37991902232170105,
-0.6333971619606018,
0.28079667687416077,
0.24426092207431793,
0.6194154620170593,
0.06603293865919113,
-0.7239781618118286,
-0.12254827469587326,
-0.029586076736450195,
-0.4633364975452423,
-0.9543771147727966,
-0.05212559178471565,
-0.022137723863124847,
0.4512973427772522,
0.1636158525943756,
-0.014762739650905132,
0.4487966299057007,
-0.5407528877258301,
0.8354195952415466,
0.13006114959716797,
-0.7811761498451233,
0.11486367136240005,
-0.577277421951294,
0.5529579520225525,
0.3741823434829712,
0.486476331949234,
-0.512944757938385,
-0.45268896222114563,
-0.30368372797966003,
-0.6990125179290771,
0.5333619117736816,
0.10470137745141983,
0.23890464007854462,
-0.004188677296042442,
0.4976600706577301,
-0.024607060477137566,
0.0823042020201683,
-0.7818616628646851,
-0.06111415475606918,
0.2766586244106293,
-0.15972289443016052,
-0.1841639131307602,
-0.5244414210319519,
-0.1558506041765213,
-0.10114490985870361,
0.5726321339607239,
-0.0906393975019455,
0.2188286930322647,
0.2323385626077652,
0.2519420087337494,
-0.18693482875823975,
0.6694267988204956,
0.7347980737686157,
0.7444384098052979,
-0.4254169166088104,
-0.11162436008453369,
0.3439830243587494,
-0.8242741823196411,
0.2077808529138565,
0.04389427229762077,
-0.09255650639533997,
0.08778134733438492,
0.29510313272476196,
0.3352595567703247,
0.038037560880184174,
-0.5497599244117737,
0.6182171702384949,
-0.36939719319343567,
-0.043701209127902985,
-0.467301607131958,
-0.09209185093641281,
0.023566940799355507,
-0.0421670526266098,
0.21148568391799927,
-0.4636644423007965,
-0.03548670932650566,
-0.5449968576431274,
-0.08447299897670746,
0.318285197019577,
-0.2846856117248535,
0.01967373862862587,
0.32761168479919434,
0.14967544376850128,
-0.13436675071716309,
0.5118435621261597,
0.2604992389678955,
-0.39345583319664,
0.5751537084579468,
0.7520992159843445,
0.8917927742004395,
-0.6059489846229553,
0.20291279256343842,
0.42308661341667175,
0.3409508168697357,
-0.05077606439590454,
0.5577846169471741,
0.2386884242296219,
-0.496568500995636,
-0.20921863615512848,
-1.0084222555160522,
-0.9038717746734619,
0.26958534121513367,
-0.8916221261024475,
0.28661513328552246,
-0.32763445377349854,
-0.24582938849925995,
-0.296375572681427,
-0.04777589067816734,
-0.7279788255691528,
0.4223023056983948,
-0.3488481938838959,
1.1051466464996338,
-0.8377456665039062,
0.3838264048099518,
1.0518215894699097,
-0.45179125666618347,
-0.9405524730682373,
-0.025421809405088425,
-0.1433972269296646,
-0.5135678052902222,
0.43914973735809326,
-0.016872506588697433,
-0.22935791313648224,
-0.1529994010925293,
-0.27486249804496765,
-0.6578301787376404,
0.8791903853416443,
0.09257930517196655,
-0.5645961165428162,
-0.10067152976989746,
0.36431360244750977,
0.8360538482666016,
-0.2081153690814972,
0.7948949337005615,
0.6204299926757812,
0.45353224873542786,
0.23150894045829773,
-1.0247900485992432,
-0.18788480758666992,
-0.020060285925865173,
-0.17122752964496613,
0.29915836453437805,
-0.5942745804786682,
0.8146611452102661,
-0.24940212070941925,
-0.2360888421535492,
0.29420724511146545,
0.6727966070175171,
0.2564166784286499,
0.47014299035072327,
0.23096691071987152,
0.6549944877624512,
0.6163009405136108,
-0.30874598026275635,
1.0353660583496094,
-0.014582641422748566,
0.40489211678504944,
1.2287801504135132,
-0.30699869990348816,
1.085262417793274,
0.5494040846824646,
-0.39888501167297363,
0.34299737215042114,
0.5084860324859619,
0.053171832114458084,
0.1109544113278389,
0.7373834848403931,
-0.46023139357566833,
0.07451321929693222,
-0.19712117314338684,
-0.42224544286727905,
0.4383196234703064,
0.3411787152290344,
-0.10572478920221329,
-0.3503990173339844,
0.12920376658439636,
0.19911019504070282,
0.333865761756897,
-0.391783207654953,
0.6006602048873901,
0.2564562261104584,
-0.7995742559432983,
0.38227465748786926,
0.13510753214359283,
0.2946249544620514,
-0.4431224465370178,
0.08703173696994781,
-0.34681692719459534,
0.2765520215034485,
-0.20946484804153442,
-1.2468193769454956,
-0.0556814931333065,
0.4843985140323639,
-0.060969360172748566,
-0.10238301753997803,
0.596095085144043,
-0.40001922845840454,
-0.5636413097381592,
0.21795491874217987,
0.42808428406715393,
0.3311336934566498,
0.4140776991844177,
-0.31462132930755615,
0.3603896498680115,
-0.28736260533332825,
-0.5333918333053589,
0.19406214356422424,
0.18435759842395782,
0.11567670851945877,
0.409286230802536,
0.5045295357704163,
0.1653750091791153,
0.021431170403957367,
0.23091399669647217,
0.9254762530326843,
-0.25702670216560364,
-0.014266441576182842,
-0.614605188369751,
0.43082302808761597,
0.14274299144744873,
-0.4699922204017639,
0.948054313659668,
0.7370169758796692,
1.0767855644226074,
0.065668985247612,
0.8671162724494934,
0.3281185030937195,
0.8446153402328491,
-0.706633448600769,
0.31555455923080444,
-0.4199628233909607,
0.20079544186592102,
-0.6554230451583862,
-1.2397640943527222,
-0.030289513990283012,
0.41576066613197327,
-0.527748703956604,
0.3573571443557739,
0.9004386067390442,
0.34125229716300964,
0.15930375456809998,
0.06877482682466507,
0.44477587938308716,
0.05333973467350006,
0.41978719830513,
0.48709243535995483,
0.9807553291320801,
-0.43905383348464966,
0.35821202397346497,
-0.04718208312988281,
-0.47772639989852905,
0.06586689502000809,
-0.8329648375511169,
-1.0869938135147095,
-0.4481113851070404,
-0.13962595164775848,
-0.5800802707672119,
0.16478830575942993,
0.6836886405944824,
-0.2663576900959015,
-0.449106365442276,
-0.6318085789680481,
0.6006752848625183,
-0.2978920340538025,
0.3160207271575928,
-0.2579330801963806,
0.38924315571784973,
-0.18656356632709503,
-0.6998667120933533,
0.10443248599767685,
0.10790914297103882,
0.2785300612449646,
-0.40599483251571655,
-0.022158438339829445,
0.13575510680675507,
0.5371127128601074,
0.6198137998580933,
0.11466715484857559,
-0.7411989569664001,
-0.1960655152797699,
0.32778260111808777,
-0.5123480558395386,
-0.2252655029296875,
0.8061563968658447,
-0.44724148511886597,
0.5803042054176331,
0.49604323506355286,
0.5747734308242798,
0.3903500437736511,
0.1323617547750473,
0.4204693138599396,
-0.1888277381658554,
-0.27846962213516235,
0.333467960357666,
0.24421890079975128,
0.34324780106544495,
-0.03490880876779556,
0.7922172546386719,
0.027375273406505585,
-0.8385250568389893,
-0.892593502998352,
-0.08998006582260132,
-0.7942262887954712,
-0.2770846486091614,
1.263872742652893,
-0.40009504556655884,
-0.030034009367227554,
0.27742400765419006,
-0.1923513412475586,
0.09487247467041016,
-0.07727573812007904,
0.7269840836524963,
0.9948902130126953,
-0.09994953870773315,
-0.10655492544174194,
-0.7608916759490967,
0.059104591608047485,
0.34341588616371155,
-0.9674019813537598,
-0.0019088640110567212,
0.4311133325099945,
0.18898040056228638,
0.012094488367438316,
0.8479890823364258,
-0.32639822363853455,
0.16572214663028717,
-0.2590625584125519,
-0.10964890569448471,
0.0177776962518692,
-0.4040408432483673,
-0.43805238604545593,
0.20172792673110962,
0.13548098504543304,
0.08758638054132462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05435v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05435v1
|
Analysis and prevention of AI-based phishing email attacks
| 2024-05-08T21:40:49 | 2024-05-08T21:40:49 |
Chibuike Samuel Eze, Lior Shamir
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Phishing email attacks are among the most common and most harmful
cybersecurity attacks. With the emergence of generative AI, phishing attacks
can be based on emails generated automatically, making it more difficult to
detect them. That is, instead of a single email format sent to a large number
of recipients, generative AI can be used to send each potential victim a
different email, making it more difficult for cybersecurity systems to identify
the scam email before it reaches the recipient. Here we describe a corpus of
AI-generated phishing emails. We also use different machine learning tools to
test the ability of automatic text analysis to identify AI-generated phishing
emails. The results are encouraging, and show that machine learning tools can
identify an AI-generated phishing email with high accuracy compared to regular
emails or human-generated scam email. By applying descriptive analytic, the
specific differences between AI-generated emails and manually crafted scam
emails are profiled, and show that AI-generated emails are different in their
style from human-generated phishing email scams. Therefore, automatic
identification tools can be used as a warning for the user. The paper also
describes the corpus of AI-generated phishing emails that is made open to the
public, and can be used for consequent studies. While the ability of machine
learning to detect AI-generated phishing email is encouraging, AI-generated
phishing emails are different from regular phishing emails, and therefore it is
important to train machine learning systems also with AI-generated emails in
order to repel future phishing attacks that are powered by generative AI.
|
[
-0.23791487514972687,
-1.2323704957962036,
-0.24788084626197815,
0.1578277200460434,
-0.174812451004982,
-0.018865786492824554,
0.2109198123216629,
-0.714949369430542,
0.18561525642871857,
0.46433553099632263,
-0.5055545568466187,
-0.19297794997692108,
-0.6116153001785278,
0.4330483078956604,
-0.9646459221839905,
1.1344157457351685,
0.3747725188732147,
0.020624307915568352,
-0.1571522206068039,
0.15811282396316528,
-0.23366670310497284,
-0.5188692808151245,
-0.8754571080207825,
-0.11718226969242096,
0.33007192611694336,
0.28590357303619385,
0.06635230779647827,
0.39155295491218567,
0.9379323720932007,
0.4220369756221771,
0.4877775311470032,
-0.3932889997959137,
-0.3135020136833191,
-0.044724076986312866,
0.15090227127075195,
-0.4237035810947418,
-0.31526505947113037,
0.10381733626127243,
0.19754427671432495,
0.11460182070732117,
-0.08529756963253021,
0.33060982823371887,
0.04093128815293312,
0.7223886251449585,
-0.7415776252746582,
0.028906013816595078,
-0.7681529521942139,
0.17042161524295807,
-0.5472829341888428,
-0.6810314655303955,
-0.6560237407684326,
-0.3604184091091156,
0.3059580326080322,
-0.41911476850509644,
0.3498339354991913,
0.33521798253059387,
0.3240760266780853,
-0.16218015551567078,
-0.2276867777109146,
-0.6278758645057678,
-0.805480420589447,
0.3713440001010895,
-0.3933235704898834,
0.01644250936806202,
0.35141801834106445,
0.49435847997665405,
-0.29145219922065735,
-0.47556573152542114,
-0.39671990275382996,
-0.050099924206733704,
-0.18822726607322693,
0.13979850709438324,
-0.5806266665458679,
0.22094283998012543,
0.26343968510627747,
0.37908485531806946,
-1.1018402576446533,
0.2203746736049652,
-0.6269310712814331,
-0.3733066916465759,
0.9114595055580139,
0.18695025146007538,
0.6323743462562561,
0.20717443525791168,
-0.028233803808689117,
-0.17661717534065247,
-0.5235223174095154,
0.19817037880420685,
0.6473202705383301,
-0.026747042313218117,
-0.1712835431098938,
0.5180204510688782,
0.0018724938854575157,
0.47938233613967896,
0.303611695766449,
-0.3126809298992157,
-0.08552088588476181,
0.21709540486335754,
-0.5742887854576111,
0.228204146027565,
0.8573134541511536,
-0.16045305132865906,
0.5430336594581604,
-0.10013440996408463,
-0.13861435651779175,
0.2638501524925232,
0.6304271221160889,
-0.8046472668647766,
-0.49836963415145874,
0.4498155117034912,
-0.7740870118141174,
-0.7146428227424622,
0.465471476316452,
-0.9300008416175842,
-0.5104101896286011,
-0.11582567542791367,
-0.03324803709983826,
-0.22602951526641846,
-0.20992961525917053,
-0.21002116799354553,
-0.20878054201602936,
0.25836625695228577,
0.08516236394643784,
-0.9516698718070984,
0.3191482424736023,
0.687886118888855,
0.19276843965053558,
-0.2600327134132385,
-0.4271586239337921,
-0.7717721462249756,
0.05059177055954933,
-0.325784832239151,
0.8211930990219116,
-0.5969813466072083,
-0.15784917771816254,
0.3268805146217346,
-0.2992088198661804,
-0.11223356425762177,
-0.528685450553894,
0.125780388712883,
-0.7964392304420471,
0.4594730734825134,
0.37007373571395874,
-0.608506441116333,
-0.17029964923858643,
0.46419721841812134,
-0.7334374189376831,
0.5828205347061157,
-0.09736800193786621,
-0.8859721422195435,
0.2233877032995224,
-0.8578577637672424,
-0.7187240719795227,
0.4267537295818329,
-0.0878375768661499,
-0.6460177898406982,
0.24389855563640594,
-0.16711187362670898,
0.358691543340683,
-0.46793490648269653,
0.012816176749765873,
-0.3517180383205414,
-0.1889084279537201,
0.4497963488101959,
-0.5826526880264282,
1.025649070739746,
0.10852374136447906,
-0.7775488495826721,
0.28081414103507996,
-0.7468470335006714,
-0.08328473567962646,
0.30852949619293213,
-0.09555576741695404,
0.0061218407936394215,
-0.40037819743156433,
0.10139115154743195,
-0.11404120177030563,
-0.019306804984807968,
-0.27246588468551636,
-0.15429389476776123,
-0.6693978905677795,
0.1781330406665802,
0.7874723672866821,
0.23784556984901428,
0.2633500099182129,
-0.568189263343811,
0.7309190630912781,
0.1533031165599823,
0.28942474722862244,
-0.38724207878112793,
-0.5972368717193604,
-0.7656530141830444,
-0.27898406982421875,
0.08996563404798508,
1.1264910697937012,
-0.22990421950817108,
0.5131661891937256,
-0.08660221844911575,
-0.6807169318199158,
-0.47673550248146057,
-0.03961348906159401,
0.17329920828342438,
0.292786180973053,
0.13890227675437927,
-0.06405704468488693,
-0.26540419459342957,
-0.7391858100891113,
-0.3138781785964966,
-0.4712333083152771,
-0.06064445152878761,
-0.008523295633494854,
0.6907745003700256,
-0.040274713188409805,
0.5462035536766052,
-0.3011927604675293,
0.1136171892285347,
-0.012318720109760761,
0.426459401845932,
-0.4646332263946533,
0.5562081933021545,
0.6681727170944214,
-0.771062433719635,
-0.5977203249931335,
-0.23145294189453125,
-0.8769763708114624,
0.18491874635219574,
-0.4795193374156952,
0.11880099028348923,
0.02916012331843376,
0.05664768069982529,
-0.6264729499816895,
0.8063684105873108,
-0.048430897295475006,
-0.33853262662887573,
0.6376594305038452,
-0.33296746015548706,
0.40507620573043823,
-0.6230095624923706,
0.1448703408241272,
0.09701258689165115,
0.25930264592170715,
-1.044638752937317,
0.1140313446521759,
-0.03723699599504471,
-0.47167763113975525,
-0.2839355170726776,
0.5876641869544983,
-0.2554270029067993,
-0.04831100255250931,
-0.35868874192237854,
-0.3136064410209656,
-0.2692476511001587,
0.4380203187465668,
-0.21887455880641937,
0.5510274767875671,
0.7504580616950989,
-0.5950860977172852,
0.6191844940185547,
0.15501569211483002,
-0.20089207589626312,
1.1406216621398926,
-0.7700888514518738,
0.24100486934185028,
-0.019643427804112434,
0.41549596190452576,
-0.6938232183456421,
-0.4972233474254608,
1.1636475324630737,
-0.7989862561225891,
0.19561266899108887,
0.23291347920894623,
-0.25901317596435547,
-0.37944430112838745,
-0.33992719650268555,
0.39140355587005615,
0.40132778882980347,
-0.26032063364982605,
0.7885221838951111,
0.13062997162342072,
-0.2565014660358429,
-0.4781641364097595,
-0.6736690998077393,
0.05524931475520134,
-0.6367820501327515,
-0.8065847158432007,
0.0657535195350647,
-0.21353250741958618,
-0.49044108390808105,
-0.39053666591644287,
0.2514967620372772,
-0.1682630479335785,
0.7091023325920105,
0.4024001955986023,
0.13152936100959778,
-0.11755809932947159,
-0.05626646429300308,
-0.15434788167476654,
-0.2548041045665741,
0.46639400720596313,
-0.36520659923553467,
0.4244128167629242,
0.2491421401500702,
-0.8196455240249634,
-1.1700208187103271,
0.7745769023895264,
0.7276590466499329,
-0.43658098578453064,
0.8642439246177673,
0.5558549165725708,
-0.6197832822799683,
0.10979264974594116,
-0.4288311302661896,
-0.6765334010124207,
-0.4213279187679291,
-0.2539699971675873,
-0.12961213290691376,
-0.29870542883872986,
0.3020738959312439,
0.170782670378685,
0.27366429567337036,
0.5710618495941162,
0.3793914020061493,
-0.2810755968093872,
0.8653216361999512,
0.9077049493789673,
-0.4623488485813141,
0.550221860408783,
-0.1121942326426506,
0.33480367064476013,
0.04653990641236305,
-0.2934845983982086,
-0.6903154253959656,
-0.12735818326473236,
-0.7566554546356201,
0.41375991702079773,
-0.0027735780458897352,
-0.19818218052387238,
-0.39525437355041504,
0.06533673405647278,
-0.6755832433700562,
0.09307821094989777,
1.0388145446777344,
-0.28807511925697327,
-0.0731050968170166,
0.3691684901714325,
-0.04771862551569939,
0.35418960452079773,
-0.4378998577594757,
-0.5513538718223572,
1.5010461807250977,
-0.10713453590869904,
0.16837680339813232,
-0.031045718118548393,
0.7393540143966675,
1.0054194927215576,
0.4532740116119385,
-0.3099087178707123,
0.3946366310119629,
0.1640847623348236,
-0.3623867928981781,
-0.1839050054550171,
-0.13763079047203064,
-1.289009690284729,
-0.3084559738636017,
-0.5241805911064148,
-0.7604804635047913,
-0.4924623966217041,
0.12674175202846527,
-0.19368091225624084,
0.2486552894115448,
-0.3648638129234314,
0.6760988235473633,
-0.20320430397987366,
-0.0015557471197098494,
-0.35602691769599915,
-0.5934678316116333,
0.0889146700501442,
-0.37955376505851746,
0.194987490773201,
0.31939011812210083,
0.6390103697776794,
0.617112934589386,
-0.25451570749282837,
0.8416929244995117,
0.016742069274187088,
0.05280395969748497,
0.4979037642478943,
-0.03965643048286438,
0.7911288142204285,
0.0708613470196724,
0.033978935331106186,
-0.035333745181560516,
-0.4174841046333313,
-0.6355072855949402,
-0.45907628536224365,
0.2787465751171112,
-0.6078660488128662,
-0.6666831970214844,
-0.5333688855171204,
-0.20772527158260345,
0.25403285026550293,
0.2063126266002655,
0.4793151319026947,
0.21584004163742065,
-0.23103922605514526,
-0.02150718681514263,
0.672650158405304,
-0.15674324333667755,
0.3980090320110321,
0.39842137694358826,
0.25417375564575195,
-0.5565289855003357,
0.9387801289558411,
-0.12042681872844696,
-0.31074953079223633,
0.5297271013259888,
0.2074420303106308,
0.06829860061407089,
-0.9398342370986938,
-0.5970274209976196,
-0.030320417135953903,
-0.3311826288700104,
-0.2927286624908447,
-0.5224332809448242,
-0.5263044834136963,
-0.8997160196304321,
-0.202882319688797,
0.3384023606777191,
-0.019855717197060585,
-0.19908425211906433,
-0.07468221336603165,
0.3665938079357147,
0.6106423735618591,
0.18304948508739471,
0.49616971611976624,
-0.8978734612464905,
0.29598456621170044,
0.40793532133102417,
-0.16191433370113373,
0.03160566836595535,
-0.06472126394510269,
0.04659901559352875,
0.20616860687732697,
-0.2697427272796631,
-0.9983314275741577,
0.1666972041130066,
0.08181300759315491,
0.657455325126648,
0.892071545124054,
0.1988234966993332,
0.16701757907867432,
-0.020259326323866844,
0.7585880160331726,
0.13613244891166687,
-0.5698659420013428,
0.7146489024162292,
-0.2652915418148041,
-0.060523178428411484,
0.22097858786582947,
0.34202802181243896,
-0.5607004761695862,
-0.5541635155677795,
-1.0685510635375977,
-0.36959075927734375,
0.361371248960495,
0.6044604182243347,
0.09495826810598373,
0.06477615982294083,
0.28352317214012146,
0.2821648418903351,
0.3537038564682007,
-0.6131097078323364,
-0.4162108600139618,
0.047151755541563034,
-0.1540347784757614,
0.13902081549167633,
-0.2103923112154007,
-0.300803005695343,
0.3173265755176544,
0.6908137202262878,
0.2639201581478119,
0.4865116775035858,
-0.4812223017215729,
-0.06428349763154984,
-0.18909063935279846,
0.13167501986026764,
0.749755322933197,
0.3757123351097107,
0.300619900226593,
-0.1507020741701126,
-0.06337897479534149,
-0.5675696730613708,
0.10298425704240799,
0.23936054110527039,
-0.35106417536735535,
-0.19914062321186066,
0.7716158032417297,
0.38439464569091797,
-0.419708251953125,
-0.5989773273468018,
0.4396156668663025,
-0.027074404060840607,
-0.16123270988464355,
-0.8067166209220886,
0.27528876066207886,
-0.35484573245048523,
0.03096906654536724,
0.5281652212142944,
0.16036054491996765,
0.18140919506549835,
-0.17489035427570343,
0.20729224383831024,
0.7760366201400757,
-0.14518862962722778,
-0.3294752538204193,
0.39784348011016846,
0.5610880851745605,
-0.9061458706855774,
1.0819259881973267,
-0.07003173232078552,
-0.453941285610199,
0.8249152898788452,
0.5519022941589355,
1.0238711833953857,
-0.4787047505378723,
0.18888114392757416,
0.08207210898399353,
0.3293896019458771,
0.052560750395059586,
-0.05396747589111328,
-0.19210562109947205,
-0.47432228922843933,
0.33551496267318726,
-0.23414750397205353,
-0.2644798159599304,
0.4830300807952881,
-0.5566427707672119,
0.19753000140190125,
-0.578752875328064,
0.01975324936211109,
0.26514384150505066,
-0.05576340854167938,
-0.6133732199668884,
0.3007971942424774,
0.011191386729478836,
0.7261494994163513,
-1.0274181365966797,
0.5284454226493835,
0.5403681397438049,
-0.18381190299987793,
-0.3423212170600891,
0.22560438513755798,
0.5815572142601013,
-0.44170793890953064,
0.5382453203201294,
0.546576201915741,
-0.20526202023029327,
-0.10642897337675095,
-0.37635618448257446,
-0.23647433519363403,
1.032320261001587,
0.2116449922323227,
-0.22514072060585022,
0.20678932964801788,
0.6669729948043823,
0.5633431673049927,
-0.5138741135597229,
0.3324984014034271,
0.2513422667980194,
0.4288069009780884,
-0.06452874839305878,
-0.5028331279754639,
-0.28643980622291565,
-0.679473340511322,
-0.33870482444763184,
0.2095486968755722,
-0.26450246572494507,
0.6249634027481079,
0.35522615909576416,
-0.2036600410938263,
-0.007494685240089893,
0.7926852703094482,
0.27277687191963196,
0.7371461987495422,
0.1442839652299881,
0.5010607838630676,
0.9607974886894226,
0.19627398252487183,
0.6239852905273438,
-0.4899671673774719,
-0.11826114356517792,
0.5956845283508301,
-0.08348847925662994,
0.5044097900390625,
0.2129807025194168,
0.010117711499333382,
0.31520798802375793,
0.8032430410385132,
-0.2650567591190338,
0.1535581648349762,
0.6234134435653687,
-0.47004595398902893,
0.12529383599758148,
0.3122246563434601,
-0.4369359612464905,
0.5712770819664001,
0.27257972955703735,
-0.46160539984703064,
0.06430938839912415,
0.36450445652008057,
-0.036723483353853226,
0.12260301411151886,
-0.2373618632555008,
0.8916093707084656,
-0.3154122531414032,
-0.5853654742240906,
0.28196629881858826,
0.1576879769563675,
0.7099522948265076,
-0.43506401777267456,
0.21608388423919678,
-0.14837463200092316,
0.14680832624435425,
-0.15491512417793274,
-0.10271824151277542,
0.4998874366283417,
0.34696346521377563,
0.08697742223739624,
-0.0987045168876648,
0.999657928943634,
0.02154533751308918,
-0.5608641505241394,
-0.1212359145283699,
0.4309094548225403,
0.30774712562561035,
-0.21837468445301056,
-1.068312644958496,
-0.26305320858955383,
-0.14105181396007538,
-0.2543806731700897,
0.3473099172115326,
0.4080667793750763,
-0.06322979927062988,
1.0080476999282837,
0.7404916882514954,
0.02636006288230419,
-0.14003074169158936,
-0.2959291934967041,
0.30671030282974243,
-0.3422054946422577,
-0.6030287146568298,
-1.1575214862823486,
0.36398014426231384,
-0.5756931304931641,
-0.13674071431159973,
0.6070522665977478,
0.8233044743537903,
0.7591678500175476,
-0.16858184337615967,
0.9523453712463379,
0.03138067200779915,
0.27084997296333313,
-0.18997067213058472,
0.7191247344017029,
-0.16215863823890686,
0.46944567561149597,
-0.19286611676216125,
-0.8374896049499512,
-0.30707409977912903,
0.2987895905971527,
-0.29408982396125793,
0.08841615915298462,
0.4210929274559021,
0.5346739888191223,
0.013144983910024166,
0.2791849970817566,
0.03392552584409714,
-0.3241223692893982,
0.5178250074386597,
0.1437864601612091,
0.7454130053520203,
-0.436299592256546,
0.6743531227111816,
-0.30661049485206604,
-0.23228095471858978,
-0.7475910186767578,
-0.6036889553070068,
-1.1300809383392334,
-0.5034206509590149,
-0.4536772668361664,
-0.19575688242912292,
0.13765117526054382,
0.7192217707633972,
0.5470729470252991,
-1.075021743774414,
-0.1524438112974167,
-0.3947250247001648,
-0.15435484051704407,
-0.29788148403167725,
-0.2315906286239624,
0.20722705125808716,
-0.15956875681877136,
-0.5224271416664124,
-0.04088720306754112,
0.5508519411087036,
0.5320310592651367,
-0.37450045347213745,
0.2888445258140564,
0.10065001249313354,
0.40778592228889465,
0.24791137874126434,
0.5711809396743774,
-0.6305497288703918,
-0.30583658814430237,
0.11259647458791733,
-0.42160025238990784,
-0.011154723353683949,
0.9780223369598389,
-0.6620380282402039,
0.055643949657678604,
0.5575669407844543,
0.9464457631111145,
0.11313275992870331,
-0.08545468002557755,
0.6241387724876404,
-0.07343947142362595,
0.058340009301900864,
0.24310150742530823,
0.10859851539134979,
0.09622389823198318,
-0.7179195880889893,
0.3193625509738922,
0.26785117387771606,
-0.28578755259513855,
-0.5036131739616394,
0.2767046391963959,
-0.5449546575546265,
-0.3502075970172882,
0.6229821443557739,
-0.34629425406455994,
-0.06351371854543686,
-0.2704785168170929,
-0.07192892581224442,
0.2013631910085678,
-0.27524295449256897,
1.292466640472412,
0.5640324950218201,
-0.10920745879411697,
-0.049174487590789795,
-0.15173763036727905,
0.6813854575157166,
0.05024038255214691,
-1.2897330522537231,
-0.07661797106266022,
0.31164422631263733,
0.15031298995018005,
0.02586900256574154,
0.5631542801856995,
0.21619828045368195,
0.7229964137077332,
0.011701458133757114,
-0.38072168827056885,
0.006841651163995266,
-0.5340802073478699,
-0.13848257064819336,
0.5174846053123474,
-0.3198493421077728,
-0.1769927740097046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05418v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05418v1
|
Mitigating Exaggerated Safety in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-08T20:39:54 | 2024-05-08T20:39:54 |
Ruchi Bhalani, Ruchira Ray
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As the popularity of Large Language Models (LLMs) grow, combining model
safety with utility becomes increasingly important. The challenge is making
sure that LLMs can recognize and decline dangerous prompts without sacrificing
their ability to be helpful. The problem of "exaggerated safety" demonstrates
how difficult this can be. To reduce excessive safety behaviours -- which was
discovered to be 26.1% of safe prompts being misclassified as dangerous and
refused -- we use a combination of XSTest dataset prompts as well as
interactive, contextual, and few-shot prompting to examine the decision bounds
of LLMs such as Llama2, Gemma Command R+, and Phi-3. We find that few-shot
prompting works best for Llama2, interactive prompting works best Gemma, and
contextual prompting works best for Command R+ and Phi-3. Using a combination
of these prompting strategies, we are able to mitigate exaggerated safety
behaviors by an overall 92.9% across all LLMs. Our work presents a multiple
prompting strategies to jailbreak LLMs' decision-making processes, allowing
them to navigate the tight line between refusing unsafe prompts and remaining
helpful.
|
[
-0.38219118118286133,
-0.9537681341171265,
0.6104626059532166,
0.24796755611896515,
-0.14465811848640442,
-0.0000022129406715976074,
-0.1406908929347992,
-0.2500081956386566,
0.08765450865030289,
0.5354790091514587,
-0.6674837470054626,
-0.33047762513160706,
-0.5433774590492249,
-0.06475021690130234,
-0.23868785798549652,
0.9688279628753662,
-0.08341075479984283,
0.010832872241735458,
0.05028991773724556,
0.10567644238471985,
-0.6393635272979736,
-0.6128332614898682,
-1.0298497676849365,
-0.0913531556725502,
0.9447208642959595,
0.5208976864814758,
0.8395711779594421,
0.610656201839447,
0.37241604924201965,
0.1706918179988861,
-0.27916550636291504,
0.10988730192184448,
-0.6936647891998291,
0.26264169812202454,
-0.05700555816292763,
-0.42482465505599976,
-0.6694130897521973,
-0.1326116919517517,
0.5384716391563416,
0.42795923352241516,
-0.08887387812137604,
-0.07296548038721085,
0.2395433485507965,
0.4313686490058899,
-0.6893870234489441,
0.15156254172325134,
-0.5183827877044678,
-0.013933819718658924,
-0.16708014905452728,
-0.39910784363746643,
-0.6916965842247009,
-0.3914797902107239,
-0.0355159156024456,
-0.48058411478996277,
-0.2651250958442688,
0.2909233272075653,
0.5076059103012085,
0.17247740924358368,
-0.30953094363212585,
-0.17623041570186615,
-0.536834716796875,
0.7618635296821594,
-0.3689451813697815,
-0.12110672146081924,
0.6504524350166321,
0.3369673490524292,
-0.46936509013175964,
-0.19596406817436218,
-0.3313823640346527,
-0.32182449102401733,
0.04855549708008766,
-0.30340108275413513,
-0.4749615788459778,
0.2672041654586792,
0.5840062499046326,
-0.34953537583351135,
-0.558692455291748,
0.5684884190559387,
-0.32560500502586365,
-0.2948490083217621,
0.5644604563713074,
0.4408138394355774,
0.3257826864719391,
-0.03527919203042984,
-0.34292933344841003,
-0.5244593620300293,
-1.4004318714141846,
0.17126482725143433,
0.36842045187950134,
0.39691653847694397,
-0.13434180617332458,
0.5524516701698303,
-0.1444053053855896,
0.4780348539352417,
-0.13105200231075287,
-0.10067643970251083,
0.10215390473604202,
-0.045450661331415176,
-0.07910337299108505,
0.20652417838573456,
0.7593647241592407,
0.7481497526168823,
0.5253502130508423,
0.23219376802444458,
-0.30288705229759216,
0.052465617656707764,
0.13414327800273895,
-0.6376689672470093,
0.09776300191879272,
0.22863072156906128,
-0.1814928650856018,
-0.5585533976554871,
-0.27070820331573486,
-0.9877947568893433,
-0.7611661553382874,
0.002541374182328582,
0.6110855937004089,
-0.35453590750694275,
-0.09372047334909439,
0.2082512229681015,
0.11977031081914902,
0.11429359763860703,
0.3566666543483734,
-0.9484465718269348,
0.19748978316783905,
0.5866565108299255,
0.8800509572029114,
-0.024776773527264595,
-0.1785127818584442,
-0.830024003982544,
0.3333345949649811,
-0.46575769782066345,
0.6190642714500427,
-0.3636555075645447,
-0.6760289072990417,
0.07938505709171295,
-0.17313851416110992,
0.15983763337135315,
-0.27930089831352234,
0.7230126261711121,
-0.37873902916908264,
-0.06572331488132477,
-0.5474523305892944,
-0.4015715420246124,
-0.26850587129592896,
0.43662208318710327,
-0.6907986402511597,
0.6716354489326477,
-0.3279533386230469,
-0.6827481985092163,
0.39026013016700745,
-0.6045054793357849,
-0.39513951539993286,
-0.2665990889072418,
-0.12946151196956635,
-0.2976248860359192,
0.04036664962768555,
0.4201290011405945,
0.6721822023391724,
-0.18271279335021973,
0.23445424437522888,
-0.4902097284793854,
-0.2105989307165146,
0.22412529587745667,
-0.7892248630523682,
0.684478223323822,
0.1404544711112976,
-0.2547576427459717,
0.41713207960128784,
-0.41317108273506165,
-0.08078773319721222,
0.17739592492580414,
-0.3918773829936981,
-0.5361043214797974,
-0.19750888645648956,
-0.06023858115077019,
0.3569413423538208,
-0.09237641841173172,
-0.19157418608665466,
0.2270985245704651,
-0.32434362173080444,
0.11213777214288712,
0.8967965245246887,
0.08608071506023407,
0.30486947298049927,
-0.6820769309997559,
0.7710994482040405,
-0.17808490991592407,
0.23529814183712006,
-0.24983134865760803,
-0.45180484652519226,
-0.6690477728843689,
-0.3203486502170563,
-0.1186961904168129,
0.6465730667114258,
-0.8087384700775146,
0.4305729269981384,
-0.1185055822134018,
-0.46080830693244934,
-0.2878056764602661,
0.004771906416863203,
0.4744965732097626,
0.4471428096294403,
0.2847088575363159,
0.13230863213539124,
-0.49211588501930237,
-0.8109843730926514,
-0.2952590584754944,
-0.4481886029243469,
0.09528176486492157,
-0.0005504699656739831,
0.27966591715812683,
-0.05708520486950874,
0.7444983720779419,
-0.4006545841693878,
-0.04115091264247894,
-0.43475717306137085,
0.11710558831691742,
0.10260161757469177,
0.6424254179000854,
0.7629197239875793,
-0.6197256445884705,
-0.31292954087257385,
-0.3433772325515747,
-0.49128663539886475,
-0.11549734324216843,
-0.3382725119590759,
0.05970605090260506,
0.37553295493125916,
0.608058512210846,
-0.8853734135627747,
0.40037772059440613,
0.3534984290599823,
-0.2967822253704071,
0.5864434838294983,
-0.15415804088115692,
0.13777489960193634,
-0.7243181467056274,
-0.10472087562084198,
0.06538820266723633,
-0.2124299705028534,
-0.7171576619148254,
0.16850103437900543,
0.1666448563337326,
0.15017783641815186,
-0.7314121723175049,
0.7230806350708008,
-0.3801180422306061,
0.3121960759162903,
-0.24742308259010315,
0.07048557698726654,
-0.07000090926885605,
0.2263818085193634,
0.04703563079237938,
0.7576658129692078,
0.864713191986084,
-0.5954738855361938,
0.28551310300827026,
0.2799418568611145,
-0.3502514958381653,
0.17762386798858643,
-0.6258118152618408,
-0.08265525102615356,
-0.18450681865215302,
0.4114258587360382,
-1.0224921703338623,
-0.39327648282051086,
0.4221537411212921,
-0.09143166244029999,
0.3676608204841614,
-0.24476084113121033,
-0.5438782572746277,
-0.30216315388679504,
-0.6810309886932373,
0.3252747356891632,
0.6414892077445984,
-0.6092430949211121,
0.3750447630882263,
0.3032348155975342,
-0.6196152567863464,
-0.7229549884796143,
-0.5263859033584595,
0.24364027380943298,
-0.7043060064315796,
-0.5767015814781189,
-0.10603677481412888,
-0.30088087916374207,
-0.48415395617485046,
-0.377296507358551,
0.001420409418642521,
0.1026812270283699,
0.2251131534576416,
0.23887883126735687,
0.6407027244567871,
0.024718118831515312,
0.010517409071326256,
0.2911249101161957,
-0.3046155273914337,
0.3049240708351135,
0.20826449990272522,
0.6002528071403503,
-0.1329154372215271,
-0.43909937143325806,
-0.34051087498664856,
0.38379108905792236,
0.7692283987998962,
0.13929630815982819,
0.8336348533630371,
0.18227027356624603,
-0.33397215604782104,
-0.021494003012776375,
-0.47948211431503296,
-0.5340878367424011,
-0.5151712894439697,
0.24504010379314423,
-0.1257510483264923,
-0.898071825504303,
0.30460524559020996,
0.0032449732534587383,
0.28580302000045776,
-0.13032063841819763,
0.6162571907043457,
0.022328341379761696,
1.3553204536437988,
0.33696022629737854,
-0.25793060660362244,
0.30978935956954956,
0.039001792669296265,
0.1901160031557083,
-0.38670802116394043,
-0.13098445534706116,
-0.46492311358451843,
-0.10651614516973495,
-0.5262757539749146,
-0.42991483211517334,
0.6493886709213257,
-0.03291429206728935,
-0.15215888619422913,
0.31501975655555725,
-0.07137022167444229,
0.744679868221283,
0.3368857800960541,
0.11288489401340485,
0.1730300784111023,
0.13605844974517822,
-0.17170359194278717,
-0.07397724688053131,
-0.8375635147094727,
-0.675221860408783,
0.8577039241790771,
0.6528323292732239,
1.2696160078048706,
0.25138118863105774,
0.6500645279884338,
-0.0041319457814097404,
0.12158473581075668,
-1.0362348556518555,
0.7768974900245667,
0.17793670296669006,
-0.7524052262306213,
-0.2529538571834564,
-0.4486641585826874,
-0.887670636177063,
0.1881871074438095,
-0.42584970593452454,
-0.8813399076461792,
0.01474200002849102,
0.511483371257782,
-0.7760223746299744,
0.2351871132850647,
-0.6485530734062195,
0.5166484117507935,
-0.315553218126297,
-0.4433693587779999,
-0.34699371457099915,
-0.700556218624115,
0.5531665682792664,
-0.2610785663127899,
0.45768681168556213,
-0.2262783944606781,
-0.1028159037232399,
0.561133086681366,
-0.22384169697761536,
1.2604196071624756,
-0.01697901450097561,
-0.33825695514678955,
0.1568063348531723,
0.4945528507232666,
0.9280050992965698,
-0.04227735847234726,
-0.17560796439647675,
-0.09010584652423859,
-0.030494218692183495,
-0.19511106610298157,
-0.467000275850296,
0.8322228789329529,
-0.39989733695983887,
-0.8178171515464783,
-0.3252730965614319,
-0.641914963722229,
-0.3351733088493347,
0.11225244402885437,
0.40506914258003235,
0.3768756091594696,
-0.054610297083854675,
0.03803093358874321,
0.8711901903152466,
-0.37153369188308716,
0.5683512091636658,
0.31848958134651184,
-0.3651282489299774,
-0.22286935150623322,
0.6832271218299866,
0.05644387751817703,
0.5219177603721619,
0.11333893984556198,
0.4755457937717438,
-0.5505843162536621,
-0.579841673374176,
-0.2951001226902008,
0.07447351515293121,
-0.9123647212982178,
-0.24776138365268707,
-0.5682060122489929,
0.0365917794406414,
-0.2989543080329895,
-0.33721137046813965,
-0.07395908236503601,
-0.6318216919898987,
-0.27065718173980713,
-0.46303391456604004,
0.5053311586380005,
0.650165855884552,
-0.25694361329078674,
0.4900328814983368,
-1.0080839395523071,
0.05389665067195892,
0.0792146846652031,
0.14828306436538696,
-0.02727174013853073,
-0.4802704453468323,
0.17517629265785217,
-0.2824760973453522,
-0.09843167662620544,
-0.7871338725090027,
0.4717760384082794,
-0.16193316876888275,
0.6506093144416809,
0.6570554375648499,
0.5475545525550842,
0.4686623513698578,
-0.5575578212738037,
0.6031556725502014,
0.45820021629333496,
-0.767210066318512,
0.5368414521217346,
-0.6007406115531921,
-0.12247984856367111,
0.4136694371700287,
0.6239368915557861,
-0.5326831340789795,
-0.3832765221595764,
-0.457288920879364,
-1.0770463943481445,
0.6047096848487854,
0.15325017273426056,
0.44258013367652893,
-0.13727395236492157,
0.08317511528730392,
0.1252949833869934,
-0.045237813144922256,
-0.7994048595428467,
-0.26427504420280457,
0.2618519365787506,
-0.0955427959561348,
0.1636590212583542,
-0.5162916779518127,
-0.4864712357521057,
-0.13022200763225555,
0.6757482886314392,
-0.11643689125776291,
-0.2268475741147995,
-0.21887221932411194,
0.05976388230919838,
-0.1358279287815094,
0.509448230266571,
0.7919109463691711,
0.39969417452812195,
0.0527503602206707,
0.33703669905662537,
0.44385889172554016,
-0.28691646456718445,
0.35940021276474,
-0.27549421787261963,
-0.19144555926322937,
-0.2897956371307373,
0.3484857976436615,
0.8906133770942688,
0.2065344601869583,
-0.8556354641914368,
0.3938828408718109,
-0.02641761302947998,
0.10341662168502808,
-0.0761551558971405,
0.5351559519767761,
-0.10737002640962601,
0.026150686666369438,
0.06229160726070404,
0.09594152867794037,
-0.021253177896142006,
-0.2581246793270111,
0.17477478086948395,
0.3816078305244446,
-0.2238137125968933,
-0.0860043317079544,
0.4152607023715973,
0.35319095849990845,
-0.18615715205669403,
0.20841056108474731,
-0.023512598127126694,
-0.40272048115730286,
0.5443869829177856,
0.5287992358207703,
0.6635435223579407,
-0.21670883893966675,
0.1468091607093811,
0.4756949543952942,
0.5468262434005737,
-0.4550408720970154,
0.24290592968463898,
0.3516384959220886,
-0.7193683385848999,
-0.40727049112319946,
-0.0936342403292656,
-0.4680894911289215,
0.35097208619117737,
-0.7056371569633484,
0.525534987449646,
-0.7470892667770386,
-0.19375742971897125,
-0.19110062718391418,
-0.44319725036621094,
-0.14670763909816742,
-0.08035673201084137,
0.12611892819404602,
1.252508282661438,
-0.9333938956260681,
0.7563109397888184,
0.5381839871406555,
-0.25923970341682434,
-0.9243864417076111,
0.050185855478048325,
0.6228689551353455,
-0.9053424596786499,
0.49733981490135193,
0.3134539723396301,
-0.3156847357749939,
-0.0983392670750618,
-0.8162078261375427,
-0.6243295073509216,
0.6290789842605591,
0.5845933556556702,
-0.8771701455116272,
0.04636422544717789,
-0.14259463548660278,
0.16657331585884094,
-0.11624235659837723,
0.03730691596865654,
0.7986104488372803,
0.7463738918304443,
0.21039338409900665,
-0.8007450699806213,
0.26993808150291443,
0.006127637345343828,
-0.23394030332565308,
0.2117663025856018,
-0.3514564335346222,
0.5044646263122559,
-0.6103377342224121,
-0.13315807282924652,
0.24019601941108704,
0.17368727922439575,
0.819938600063324,
0.2014838457107544,
0.7923559546470642,
0.1106487587094307,
0.7829233407974243,
0.04800863191485405,
1.1253880262374878,
0.052938733249902725,
0.177267923951149,
1.0520676374435425,
-0.3909264802932739,
0.8464860916137695,
0.8058942556381226,
0.16692915558815002,
0.04730130359530449,
0.6574495434761047,
0.2067326456308365,
0.4697013795375824,
0.1232677474617958,
-0.4451915919780731,
-0.5915392637252808,
-0.14142514765262604,
-0.17814339697360992,
0.21979421377182007,
0.6849223375320435,
-0.1384536474943161,
-0.3120977282524109,
0.17716637253761292,
0.5958788394927979,
-0.16222257912158966,
-0.17006587982177734,
0.5759387612342834,
0.15176264941692352,
-0.5889356136322021,
0.6786475777626038,
-0.16342222690582275,
0.6033992171287537,
-0.6715700030326843,
-0.06214146688580513,
-0.09479101747274399,
-0.14521177113056183,
-0.00039101403672248125,
-1.0749711990356445,
0.13860590755939484,
0.20574958622455597,
-0.002615439472720027,
-0.29879507422447205,
0.6522541642189026,
-0.441153883934021,
-0.26308465003967285,
0.3974095582962036,
0.3359086215496063,
0.2045634537935257,
0.07952738553285599,
-0.5922180414199829,
0.2362542599439621,
-0.08973372727632523,
-0.3904830515384674,
0.42581483721733093,
0.2837536633014679,
-0.42838671803474426,
1.0507147312164307,
0.6212521195411682,
0.2981002926826477,
-0.06265641748905182,
-0.03413740545511246,
0.9829369187355042,
-0.5633776187896729,
-0.5903054475784302,
-1.103450059890747,
0.4898199439048767,
-0.016570791602134705,
-0.05375654622912407,
0.6837974786758423,
-0.030305512249469757,
0.543799877166748,
-0.09741341322660446,
0.7739075422286987,
0.010202350094914436,
0.24156454205513,
-0.8560254573822021,
0.9313400387763977,
-0.36647599935531616,
0.7085199952125549,
-0.303523451089859,
-0.5705568790435791,
-0.587973415851593,
0.7170946598052979,
-0.3064248561859131,
0.03276072442531586,
0.4932054281234741,
1.1887156963348389,
0.1405360847711563,
-0.08322293311357498,
0.6668031215667725,
0.2551411986351013,
0.448177307844162,
0.5015710592269897,
1.25015127658844,
0.04798666015267372,
0.7455282807350159,
-0.16112837195396423,
-0.44520047307014465,
-0.4676268994808197,
-1.2631053924560547,
-0.9867469668388367,
-0.13404065370559692,
-0.3375757038593292,
-0.4590291678905487,
-0.016538817435503006,
1.443339467048645,
0.7760103940963745,
-0.8108091354370117,
-0.05679382383823395,
0.10765336453914642,
0.15711423754692078,
-0.053431976586580276,
-0.12271381914615631,
0.20862440764904022,
-0.30574318766593933,
-0.5390557646751404,
0.733208954334259,
0.22998078167438507,
0.48298898339271545,
-0.2440144121646881,
-0.19860446453094482,
0.1343822330236435,
0.1759447157382965,
0.6083387732505798,
0.3105097711086273,
-0.6097906827926636,
-0.4943125247955322,
-0.10443640500307083,
-0.23412615060806274,
-0.19242516160011292,
0.7890839576721191,
-0.46423274278640747,
0.20706425607204437,
0.6050910949707031,
0.4484737515449524,
-0.12569785118103027,
-0.17272941768169403,
0.7335882186889648,
-0.9312753677368164,
0.1896987408399582,
0.12327750027179718,
0.542181670665741,
0.23104341328144073,
-0.6671791672706604,
0.3505081832408905,
-0.15517136454582214,
-0.40451765060424805,
-0.8308269381523132,
0.38163992762565613,
-0.8293697237968445,
-0.34167835116386414,
1.4432284832000732,
-0.21083614230155945,
-0.05489049106836319,
-0.33313053846359253,
-0.6709449291229248,
-0.13113923370838165,
-0.7165176272392273,
0.8268452882766724,
0.6340368986129761,
-0.2515065670013428,
-0.28803619742393494,
-0.6545623540878296,
0.6389928460121155,
0.5860370993614197,
-0.9212655425071716,
0.539310097694397,
0.6998898983001709,
0.2667075991630554,
0.07840225100517273,
0.2481667846441269,
0.03359532356262207,
0.3591960668563843,
-0.27967798709869385,
-0.2465469241142273,
-0.06872232258319855,
-0.6859294176101685,
-0.788707435131073,
-0.009255658835172653,
0.28723233938217163,
0.009430470876395702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05417v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05417v1
|
Fishing for Magikarp: Automatically Detecting Under-trained Tokens in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-08T20:37:56 | 2024-05-08T20:37:56 |
Sander Land, Max Bartolo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50
|
The disconnect between tokenizer creation and model training in language
models has been known to allow for certain inputs, such as the infamous
SolidGoldMagikarp token, to induce unwanted behaviour. Although such `glitch
tokens' that are present in the tokenizer vocabulary, but are nearly or fully
absent in training, have been observed across a variety of different models, a
consistent way of identifying them has been missing. We present a comprehensive
analysis of Large Language Model (LLM) tokenizers, specifically targeting this
issue of detecting untrained and under-trained tokens. Through a combination of
tokenizer analysis, model weight-based indicators, and prompting techniques, we
develop effective methods for automatically detecting these problematic tokens.
Our findings demonstrate the prevalence of such tokens across various models
and provide insights into improving the efficiency and safety of language
models.
|
[
-0.2838241457939148,
-0.4228512942790985,
0.2840997278690338,
0.06548308581113815,
-0.41200071573257446,
0.16661648452281952,
-0.08649394661188126,
-0.30553990602493286,
0.25124338269233704,
0.5208064913749695,
-0.4468347728252411,
-0.2401045560836792,
-0.9395164251327515,
0.22718635201454163,
-0.6762544512748718,
0.9238848686218262,
-0.011550281196832657,
0.18553388118743896,
-0.27915823459625244,
0.06371434777975082,
-0.7414170503616333,
-0.8288394212722778,
-0.7128821015357971,
-0.6858637928962708,
0.37645047903060913,
0.31518101692199707,
0.38135015964508057,
0.32435342669487,
0.44937780499458313,
0.31100860238075256,
-0.3784869611263275,
0.35419705510139465,
-0.2481103092432022,
-0.04563136026263237,
-0.06585767865180969,
-0.679771363735199,
-0.38799864053726196,
-0.08235406875610352,
0.6192030906677246,
0.572598397731781,
-0.00020674070401582867,
0.30596956610679626,
-0.11891211569309235,
0.314643532037735,
-0.7736455798149109,
0.12639069557189941,
-0.9314320087432861,
0.3259042501449585,
-0.5508482456207275,
-0.30060040950775146,
-0.5215916633605957,
0.09877323359251022,
-0.611497700214386,
-0.1703573763370514,
0.17742988467216492,
-0.06629247218370438,
0.71601802110672,
0.21350114047527313,
-0.3160887360572815,
-0.6460145711898804,
-0.31112486124038696,
0.686023473739624,
-0.847192645072937,
0.14553140103816986,
0.5964788198471069,
0.20852166414260864,
-0.6378901600837708,
-0.7371615767478943,
-0.6156426072120667,
-0.3049611747264862,
-0.22578324377536774,
-0.18763574957847595,
-0.47391313314437866,
0.012301760725677013,
0.09800814092159271,
0.37536191940307617,
-0.4058835208415985,
0.41107261180877686,
-0.20795248448848724,
-0.36156877875328064,
0.25493261218070984,
0.2625499963760376,
0.5865895748138428,
-0.4656645655632019,
-0.010723460465669632,
0.3507933020591736,
-0.8462243676185608,
-0.1056135892868042,
0.7124833464622498,
0.5350253582000732,
0.008622364141047001,
0.8922917246818542,
-0.11838285624980927,
0.76142817735672,
0.13593371212482452,
0.07462086528539658,
0.38027942180633545,
-0.13670310378074646,
0.003630132647231221,
0.23580943048000336,
0.7268823981285095,
0.0520441047847271,
0.46240201592445374,
-0.33999037742614746,
-0.6161813735961914,
-0.11183764040470123,
0.05627421289682388,
-0.821760892868042,
-0.07549313455820084,
0.2699677348136902,
-0.49594399333000183,
-0.6477839350700378,
0.07394610345363617,
-0.5663222670555115,
-0.6944337487220764,
-0.11005454510450363,
0.3434094488620758,
-0.19995516538619995,
-0.633621871471405,
0.1661238670349121,
-0.34108734130859375,
0.21023815870285034,
-0.3022747039794922,
-1.4330167770385742,
0.03760794550180435,
1.1497437953948975,
1.0470943450927734,
-0.013380713760852814,
-0.3782255947589874,
-0.9941150546073914,
0.011484920978546143,
-0.3478897213935852,
0.9104306101799011,
-0.8120802044868469,
-0.507948100566864,
0.1712905317544937,
0.11012287437915802,
-0.16321498155593872,
-0.6055518388748169,
0.3473100960254669,
-0.4350683391094208,
0.30508074164390564,
-0.4250465929508209,
-0.7818859219551086,
0.09230957925319672,
0.46658313274383545,
-0.3776591420173645,
0.9414036870002747,
0.03300512209534645,
-0.8906289339065552,
0.7191835641860962,
-0.8694257140159607,
-0.08158423751592636,
0.3125458061695099,
-0.04610021039843559,
-0.4137556850910187,
0.5036177039146423,
0.3220497667789459,
0.6008931994438171,
0.13996954262256622,
0.21054866909980774,
-0.27744370698928833,
-0.722034215927124,
0.5192797780036926,
-0.5484600067138672,
0.8431961536407471,
0.041141510009765625,
-0.3487977683544159,
0.21149256825447083,
-0.8144611120223999,
-0.04484443739056587,
0.1373627781867981,
-0.4000365436077118,
-0.36015674471855164,
-0.04703845828771591,
0.035465847700834274,
0.025962846353650093,
0.2035219371318817,
-0.31367892026901245,
0.6661891937255859,
-0.5555726289749146,
0.6151100993156433,
0.7753749489784241,
-0.08809792995452881,
0.15023158490657806,
0.21288448572158813,
0.6247602105140686,
0.021326130256056786,
0.203606516122818,
-0.31348276138305664,
-0.4130682051181793,
-1.015995979309082,
-0.5286762714385986,
0.47253596782684326,
0.4457893967628479,
-0.43117037415504456,
0.5590158104896545,
-0.24389658868312836,
-0.40592747926712036,
-0.4895181655883789,
0.3581673204898834,
0.2612549960613251,
0.14872777462005615,
0.13803255558013916,
-0.3309665322303772,
-0.6955766081809998,
-0.5320874452590942,
-0.4052222669124603,
-0.23987343907356262,
-0.23954536020755768,
-0.05859598144888878,
0.8418425917625427,
-0.606621503829956,
0.9968242049217224,
-0.10362241417169571,
-0.40991315245628357,
-0.41899213194847107,
0.39529523253440857,
0.23732809722423553,
0.38718679547309875,
0.783319890499115,
-0.5294238924980164,
-0.2637122571468353,
-0.07255411893129349,
-0.5945526361465454,
-0.3771568238735199,
-0.1146092638373375,
0.2678075432777405,
0.24336661398410797,
0.9217072129249573,
-0.8178361654281616,
0.22708986699581146,
0.6331075429916382,
-0.638495683670044,
0.42255285382270813,
-0.1886877417564392,
-0.12606628239154816,
-0.9539387226104736,
0.47824499011039734,
-0.5569935441017151,
-0.08180217444896698,
-0.7470591068267822,
0.06064741313457489,
0.018382064998149872,
0.08466660976409912,
-0.3604636490345001,
0.7772868871688843,
-0.4159114360809326,
-0.1867833286523819,
-0.5023453831672668,
-0.09488262981176376,
-0.438371866941452,
0.11444655805826187,
-0.30912309885025024,
1.088080644607544,
0.3451671004295349,
-0.17059394717216492,
0.5183890461921692,
0.08453568071126938,
-0.2183210700750351,
0.4656652510166168,
-0.6085956692695618,
0.2687216103076935,
-0.2154153734445572,
-0.045529209077358246,
-1.1637609004974365,
-0.3532562255859375,
0.6982008814811707,
-0.6127633452415466,
0.41976669430732727,
-0.8198426365852356,
-0.7144942879676819,
-0.5898779034614563,
-0.07346385717391968,
0.14277303218841553,
0.36067697405815125,
-0.6250807642936707,
0.6988125443458557,
0.3636215627193451,
-0.0009736238280311227,
-0.6386459469795227,
-0.5994448065757751,
0.4514884352684021,
-0.32020339369773865,
-0.1540241688489914,
-0.2512381076812744,
0.15182285010814667,
-0.09055625647306442,
-0.20088869333267212,
0.10128461569547653,
-0.1049472838640213,
0.3834879696369171,
0.5191267728805542,
0.19987252354621887,
-0.021318599581718445,
0.1948796808719635,
-0.25528717041015625,
-0.41337311267852783,
0.16025467216968536,
-0.29886355996131897,
1.1922985315322876,
-0.316216379404068,
-0.7632426023483276,
-0.3978480398654938,
0.0014028806472197175,
0.8120988607406616,
-0.4482561945915222,
0.8571227192878723,
0.856162428855896,
-0.27875369787216187,
0.1737465262413025,
-0.5801650881767273,
-0.026407390832901,
-0.5655898451805115,
0.4180593490600586,
-0.10342206805944443,
-0.7880095839500427,
0.7618616223335266,
0.008014188148081303,
-0.03699325770139694,
0.4289984703063965,
0.8184983730316162,
0.42988449335098267,
1.3926701545715332,
0.7663389444351196,
-0.5052253007888794,
0.6230335235595703,
-0.10363069921731949,
0.2788031995296478,
-0.5609638094902039,
-0.35836929082870483,
-0.5563651323318481,
-0.05602253973484039,
-0.4255127012729645,
-0.13678985834121704,
-0.1623014360666275,
-0.05692058429121971,
-0.023177461698651314,
0.058552101254463196,
-0.5076113343238831,
0.90262770652771,
0.4787261486053467,
-0.5262400507926941,
0.055713314563035965,
-0.05639097839593887,
-0.3647834062576294,
0.10059218108654022,
-0.7568859457969666,
-0.4249047040939331,
1.1796761751174927,
0.2644096612930298,
0.2540878355503082,
-0.1584746092557907,
0.833003580570221,
0.33464673161506653,
0.5099901556968689,
-0.9257156252861023,
0.461512953042984,
-0.08650162816047668,
-0.6754202246665955,
-0.07155487686395645,
-0.45067116618156433,
-0.9937793612480164,
0.14172634482383728,
-0.26618751883506775,
-0.7996068596839905,
0.13329313695430756,
0.30961430072784424,
-0.2813797891139984,
0.436555951833725,
-0.7360665202140808,
1.0153748989105225,
-0.28775614500045776,
0.3158787488937378,
-0.04356284439563751,
-0.1377231776714325,
0.42392057180404663,
-0.3443727195262909,
0.3493204712867737,
-0.212755024433136,
0.011426442302763462,
0.523508608341217,
-0.42380964756011963,
0.9441900849342346,
-0.42777663469314575,
-0.04946241155266762,
0.14512570202350616,
-0.0019653828348964453,
0.6724186539649963,
-0.23702916502952576,
0.11098957806825638,
0.2923276722431183,
-0.18830542266368866,
-0.37666696310043335,
-0.17423155903816223,
0.5024765133857727,
-0.5867910981178284,
-0.1812235563993454,
-0.4119929075241089,
-0.3243575692176819,
-0.028806131333112717,
0.446390837430954,
0.2668437063694,
0.21810957789421082,
0.19667233526706696,
0.09434424340724945,
0.36456266045570374,
-0.17031264305114746,
0.4738934636116028,
0.5182715654373169,
-0.4464868903160095,
-0.3827049732208252,
1.053651213645935,
0.13052694499492645,
-0.10302669554948807,
-0.18298634886741638,
0.20821619033813477,
-0.02565436251461506,
-0.7550511360168457,
-0.29304039478302,
0.2632341682910919,
-0.7114824056625366,
-0.29411858320236206,
-0.46686339378356934,
-0.25370004773139954,
-0.24414357542991638,
-0.013722271658480167,
-0.47137755155563354,
-0.2459091991186142,
-0.5422664284706116,
-0.04462144896388054,
0.3623020350933075,
0.6284326314926147,
-0.2236434519290924,
0.690121054649353,
-0.8228841423988342,
0.08381405472755432,
0.4757029116153717,
0.5333601832389832,
0.038972243666648865,
-0.6792898178100586,
-0.14016111195087433,
0.0270918607711792,
0.19846211373806,
-0.41255220770835876,
0.29812386631965637,
0.22164560854434967,
0.5733908414840698,
0.7989716529846191,
-0.3897508680820465,
0.8065458536148071,
-0.6405982971191406,
0.8693845272064209,
0.3332248330116272,
-1.1279598474502563,
0.4002574384212494,
-0.3036141097545624,
0.3338330388069153,
0.5120026469230652,
0.1880047768354416,
-1.095225214958191,
-0.5341733694076538,
-0.3980328142642975,
-1.0891722440719604,
0.46312665939331055,
-0.05155857652425766,
0.6786326766014099,
-0.31938546895980835,
0.5775122046470642,
-0.05589709058403969,
0.42226386070251465,
-0.783430814743042,
0.040498603135347366,
-0.22620640695095062,
-0.31771761178970337,
0.15237857401371002,
-0.6045426726341248,
0.002579652238637209,
-0.17798806726932526,
0.665840744972229,
-0.17301076650619507,
0.07189177721738815,
-0.45901528000831604,
-0.29500633478164673,
-0.3912521302700043,
0.2390928417444229,
0.7310651540756226,
0.8936253190040588,
-0.0573144406080246,
0.16513359546661377,
0.22149668633937836,
-0.653925359249115,
0.005321850068867207,
-0.0037294344510883093,
-0.1211652010679245,
0.19135476648807526,
0.5687206983566284,
0.546720027923584,
0.31094351410865784,
-0.9812535047531128,
0.8346405625343323,
-0.03635186329483986,
-0.0013662971323356032,
-0.6190010905265808,
0.22175578773021698,
-0.03413086757063866,
0.2950977683067322,
0.5336013436317444,
-0.14932389557361603,
0.00513637438416481,
-0.36568671464920044,
0.15139983594417572,
0.9098440408706665,
-0.44469350576400757,
-0.34497737884521484,
0.5393434166908264,
0.14400607347488403,
-0.3062573969364166,
0.8140420913696289,
-0.2528585195541382,
-0.9723501205444336,
0.34340766072273254,
0.3060389757156372,
0.8899120092391968,
-0.10058122128248215,
0.13496823608875275,
-0.04457638040184975,
0.5215257406234741,
-0.22423753142356873,
0.1545753926038742,
0.21338213980197906,
-0.6092151999473572,
-0.5902833938598633,
-0.6075796484947205,
-0.3284792900085449,
0.3693850338459015,
-0.4311980903148651,
0.42945483326911926,
-0.40652817487716675,
-0.32944566011428833,
0.035214170813560486,
-0.06191222742199898,
-0.38111716508865356,
-0.26145076751708984,
0.5788013935089111,
0.7899214029312134,
-1.1770884990692139,
0.6194323897361755,
0.5622637867927551,
-0.4247846305370331,
-0.5017038583755493,
-0.20911520719528198,
0.055174462497234344,
-1.216271162033081,
0.9147652387619019,
0.42244091629981995,
0.06534281373023987,
-0.041371170431375504,
-0.6393629908561707,
-0.7666282653808594,
0.7568417191505432,
0.3526630103588104,
-0.4320013225078583,
-0.020143453031778336,
0.6212171316146851,
0.41255679726600647,
-0.02898312173783779,
0.20086395740509033,
0.6689687967300415,
0.5815100073814392,
0.1636301875114441,
-0.8652928471565247,
-0.15330179035663605,
-0.1992495208978653,
-0.20927442610263824,
0.5603123307228088,
-0.4343813359737396,
0.8893335461616516,
0.21822801232337952,
-0.045992881059646606,
0.21904003620147705,
0.42883992195129395,
0.1561259776353836,
0.08615877479314804,
0.592961311340332,
0.5086386203765869,
0.8327999114990234,
-0.1035318523645401,
0.6425294876098633,
-0.39250510931015015,
0.5239124894142151,
0.7447670102119446,
-0.06421461701393127,
0.7792815566062927,
0.8251237273216248,
0.044115353375673294,
0.2207241803407669,
0.5405845642089844,
-0.5754224061965942,
0.37356337904930115,
0.3381512761116028,
-0.17835460603237152,
-0.5911874771118164,
0.027156569063663483,
-0.299821674823761,
0.725210428237915,
0.3389628231525421,
-0.3898008167743683,
-0.33640387654304504,
0.12569472193717957,
0.41037270426750183,
-0.5016378164291382,
-0.5812900066375732,
0.6838206648826599,
-0.0029564471915364265,
-0.34010204672813416,
0.6512436866760254,
0.06288900971412659,
0.8994263410568237,
-0.7631362676620483,
0.06486035883426666,
-0.5012796521186829,
0.31342706084251404,
-0.19705639779567719,
-0.2651369869709015,
0.23479612171649933,
0.3300303816795349,
0.12367695569992065,
-0.11225036531686783,
0.8811428546905518,
-0.3054739236831665,
-0.7064589262008667,
-0.07062621414661407,
0.3326614499092102,
0.14722251892089844,
-0.16732937097549438,
-0.6593025326728821,
0.12647999823093414,
-0.31026187539100647,
-0.3200747072696686,
0.3720497190952301,
0.5964905023574829,
0.047812264412641525,
0.8901256918907166,
0.8591132760047913,
0.29720833897590637,
0.044322751462459564,
0.03952561318874359,
0.8477104902267456,
-0.28358978033065796,
-0.3405434489250183,
-1.302464485168457,
0.557328462600708,
-0.1669713854789734,
-0.2592635154724121,
0.8337184190750122,
0.4978674054145813,
0.585537314414978,
-0.051423121243715286,
0.5244457125663757,
0.1468779295682907,
0.23993033170700073,
-0.49465638399124146,
1.0221785306930542,
-0.5738909244537354,
0.3141220808029175,
-0.16656193137168884,
-0.6590205430984497,
-0.4943358302116394,
0.5489972829818726,
-0.36675113439559937,
-0.2302369773387909,
0.11505536735057831,
0.7539371848106384,
-0.24785365164279938,
-0.3947339653968811,
0.09460853040218353,
0.0258305836468935,
0.5260763168334961,
0.07537439465522766,
0.9536333680152893,
-0.11918430030345917,
0.6505013108253479,
0.28752365708351135,
0.11043545603752136,
-0.7125972509384155,
-1.0509189367294312,
-1.3570417165756226,
-0.23412606120109558,
-0.08102717250585556,
-0.032869819551706314,
-0.005978557281196117,
1.144091010093689,
0.3887892961502075,
-1.0317654609680176,
-0.15993615984916687,
-0.22634705901145935,
0.15051987767219543,
0.0514567531645298,
-0.17794093489646912,
0.19215042889118195,
-0.6757676601409912,
-0.447451651096344,
0.27485164999961853,
0.18849027156829834,
0.43922021985054016,
-0.3979448080062866,
0.10328815132379532,
0.17514073848724365,
0.2705281674861908,
0.40822821855545044,
0.3434080481529236,
-0.602005124092102,
-0.4894462823867798,
-0.15920662879943848,
0.12576884031295776,
-0.17958414554595947,
0.8682011365890503,
-0.6164489984512329,
0.3545202314853668,
0.24405153095722198,
0.4618867039680481,
0.11959420889616013,
-0.3888506293296814,
0.38215309381484985,
-0.9675315618515015,
0.5592222809791565,
0.09467637538909912,
0.4374231696128845,
0.37338632345199585,
-0.14561784267425537,
0.2888345718383789,
0.39098024368286133,
-0.3751034736633301,
-1.4348433017730713,
0.018206113949418068,
-0.3429739475250244,
-0.3856874108314514,
1.1988039016723633,
-0.025871774181723595,
-0.18820327520370483,
0.05808784440159798,
-0.21391813457012177,
0.056203220039606094,
0.032167550176382065,
1.145593285560608,
0.8978509902954102,
0.23353271186351776,
0.04837765172123909,
-0.6723921298980713,
0.49805086851119995,
0.2130301594734192,
-0.6832129955291748,
0.37558454275131226,
0.4592822790145874,
0.5063022971153259,
0.2089524120092392,
0.5111706256866455,
0.07038187235593796,
0.30231910943984985,
-0.10380842536687851,
0.01114562712609768,
-0.4637739956378937,
-0.1611589640378952,
-0.452026903629303,
0.0953652635216713,
0.24242299795150757,
-0.09088169783353806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05386v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05386v1
|
Interpretability Needs a New Paradigm
| 2024-05-08T19:31:06 | 2024-05-08T19:31:06 |
Andreas Madsen, Himabindu Lakkaraju, Siva Reddy, Sarath Chandar
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ML
|
Interpretability is the study of explaining models in understandable terms to
humans. At present, interpretability is divided into two paradigms: the
intrinsic paradigm, which believes that only models designed to be explained
can be explained, and the post-hoc paradigm, which believes that black-box
models can be explained. At the core of this debate is how each paradigm
ensures its explanations are faithful, i.e., true to the model's behavior. This
is important, as false but convincing explanations lead to unsupported
confidence in artificial intelligence (AI), which can be dangerous. This
paper's position is that we should think about new paradigms while staying
vigilant regarding faithfulness. First, by examining the history of paradigms
in science, we see that paradigms are constantly evolving. Then, by examining
the current paradigms, we can understand their underlying beliefs, the value
they bring, and their limitations. Finally, this paper presents 3 emerging
paradigms for interpretability. The first paradigm designs models such that
faithfulness can be easily measured. Another optimizes models such that
explanations become faithful. The last paradigm proposes to develop models that
produce both a prediction and an explanation.
|
[
-0.1485884040594101,
-0.7030264139175415,
0.9760776162147522,
0.4397687315940857,
-0.4802306592464447,
-0.1372423768043518,
-0.02423274703323841,
-0.9423631429672241,
-0.2760569751262665,
0.450716495513916,
-0.39714059233665466,
-0.11214931309223175,
-0.7216275930404663,
0.17462563514709473,
-0.5241336226463318,
0.899442195892334,
-0.17237499356269836,
0.050678130239248276,
-0.4519343674182892,
-0.30653008818626404,
-0.6865835189819336,
-0.26250702142715454,
-0.5164130330085754,
-0.6303154230117798,
0.09940940886735916,
-0.15085910260677338,
1.2583409547805786,
0.9941302537918091,
0.47202470898628235,
0.29253333806991577,
-0.23655709624290466,
-0.1325911581516266,
-0.2815013527870178,
0.2503637373447418,
-0.44249576330184937,
-0.8673800230026245,
-0.6306610107421875,
0.25884073972702026,
0.6085633039474487,
0.8230311274528503,
-0.1342587172985077,
-0.01979425549507141,
0.2577775716781616,
0.4054122567176819,
-0.29195353388786316,
0.30259689688682556,
-0.7064330577850342,
-0.06694579124450684,
0.10920142382383347,
-0.3394169211387634,
-0.4984811544418335,
-0.25619059801101685,
0.48436635732650757,
-1.199242353439331,
0.10001341253519058,
0.25469666719436646,
0.6557216048240662,
0.35774970054626465,
-0.24240368604660034,
-0.13825350999832153,
-0.9142213463783264,
1.0214848518371582,
-0.715425968170166,
0.5239261388778687,
0.39890241622924805,
0.5290584564208984,
-0.10317412763834,
-0.9632599353790283,
-0.5818494558334351,
-0.11167235672473907,
0.016660325229167938,
0.01925070211291313,
-0.22699092328548431,
-0.1762581616640091,
0.03692709282040596,
0.18916001915931702,
-0.25117963552474976,
-0.0656123012304306,
-0.21933519840240479,
-0.1809152215719223,
0.5871215462684631,
0.19241014122962952,
0.30937325954437256,
-0.04545100778341293,
-0.39636746048927307,
0.37025150656700134,
-0.6062089800834656,
0.07746279984712601,
0.08783379197120667,
0.045760758221149445,
-0.049043938517570496,
0.16790525615215302,
-0.07152675092220306,
0.5273845791816711,
0.17139692604541779,
0.11078061163425446,
-0.13396401703357697,
-0.5271815657615662,
-0.20417603850364685,
-0.1380227655172348,
0.2565544843673706,
0.29917842149734497,
0.07607384026050568,
-0.2697603404521942,
-0.0455644465982914,
0.29412972927093506,
1.0131466388702393,
-0.38903337717056274,
-0.24482804536819458,
0.4161883294582367,
-1.007757306098938,
-0.5250366926193237,
0.015184721909463406,
-0.8031870722770691,
-0.37473541498184204,
-0.735254168510437,
0.5456421375274658,
-0.743810772895813,
-0.4988439381122589,
0.21177074313163757,
-0.12235323339700699,
0.4764089286327362,
0.7423853874206543,
-0.7047708034515381,
0.2990195155143738,
1.154081106185913,
0.7956013083457947,
-0.051072437316179276,
-0.5643956065177917,
-0.050960786640644073,
0.16509504616260529,
-0.4514702558517456,
0.7997558116912842,
-0.5346938371658325,
-0.33274680376052856,
-0.15786466002464294,
0.12616901099681854,
0.0867728441953659,
-0.061050355434417725,
0.4582039415836334,
-0.4822816252708435,
-0.08381672948598862,
-0.1516847014427185,
-0.5210761427879333,
-0.8090139627456665,
0.17489559948444366,
-0.5454791188240051,
0.45315924286842346,
0.012271873652935028,
-0.5012249946594238,
0.627543568611145,
-0.7717430591583252,
-0.4212840497493744,
0.27925536036491394,
-0.013967839069664478,
-0.29414013028144836,
0.409329354763031,
-0.2807818651199341,
0.0932869166135788,
-0.14110925793647766,
0.5246593952178955,
-0.4707791805267334,
-0.44390344619750977,
0.5877835154533386,
-0.46681448817253113,
0.6881420016288757,
0.39437711238861084,
-0.5781736373901367,
0.10247449576854706,
-0.5335935950279236,
0.2435426265001297,
-0.07168804854154587,
-0.0030668526887893677,
-0.26898664236068726,
0.748556911945343,
-0.1047455295920372,
0.1634114384651184,
0.2712832987308502,
-0.26022616028785706,
-0.17734190821647644,
-0.4821544587612152,
0.766688346862793,
1.0227816104888916,
-0.2158527970314026,
0.6818976402282715,
-0.6123802661895752,
0.32209694385528564,
-0.10588178783655167,
0.5971141457557678,
-0.08721030503511429,
-0.64795982837677,
-0.5272387862205505,
0.3141372501850128,
-0.14926622807979584,
0.407578706741333,
-0.583835780620575,
0.25348523259162903,
-0.31134194135665894,
-0.6971458792686462,
-0.42389994859695435,
0.035593967884778976,
0.3994375169277191,
0.44446778297424316,
0.44723087549209595,
-0.28760939836502075,
-0.4441864788532257,
-0.8190845251083374,
-0.9406070709228516,
-0.46118372678756714,
0.14896360039710999,
-0.0044553219340741634,
0.7437880039215088,
-0.29155871272087097,
0.8805660009384155,
-0.09097906947135925,
0.303890585899353,
-0.23865269124507904,
0.1699530929327011,
0.21198444068431854,
0.6683843731880188,
0.24126407504081726,
-1.3111430406570435,
-0.055160995572805405,
-0.0007194256177172065,
-1.2243825197219849,
0.5604748725891113,
-0.23419427871704102,
-0.09247706085443497,
0.0033237477764487267,
0.2710316777229309,
-0.4551970660686493,
0.5411750674247742,
0.08861135691404343,
-0.33712369203567505,
0.5566807985305786,
-0.09343650192022324,
-0.11979398876428604,
-0.7058618068695068,
0.06336313486099243,
0.004571403842419386,
-0.10277887433767319,
-0.9106920957565308,
0.3428526520729065,
-0.017568884417414665,
0.16688643395900726,
-0.6320345401763916,
0.6720614433288574,
-0.4055821895599365,
0.1449405401945114,
-0.4209120571613312,
-0.20801888406276703,
0.34301432967185974,
0.04417235031723976,
0.04322921112179756,
0.3791874945163727,
0.7587148547172546,
-0.8183125257492065,
0.13800343871116638,
0.6019653677940369,
-0.2944467067718506,
0.777113139629364,
-0.9429173469543457,
-0.06354938447475433,
-0.4501896798610687,
0.3943770229816437,
-0.4308684468269348,
-0.3848089873790741,
0.4152364432811737,
-0.7432850003242493,
0.22356928884983063,
-0.05026281625032425,
0.014501637779176235,
-0.060174889862537384,
-0.18906734883785248,
0.47717201709747314,
0.5424371361732483,
-0.3369522988796234,
0.8871209025382996,
0.04790155589580536,
-0.0962098240852356,
-0.6439314484596252,
-0.6896358728408813,
-0.07800207287073135,
-0.2595120072364807,
-0.6602989435195923,
0.2061835080385208,
-0.21248987317085266,
-0.7266433238983154,
0.2270965725183487,
-0.4921635687351227,
-0.267727792263031,
0.4442082941532135,
0.6185707449913025,
0.4838445782661438,
-0.2666599154472351,
0.018191171810030937,
-0.2005661427974701,
-0.5378454923629761,
0.2657409906387329,
-0.5430799722671509,
0.07762087881565094,
-0.40777212381362915,
-0.1543274223804474,
-0.8183733820915222,
0.46563398838043213,
0.7702004313468933,
-0.1606896072626114,
0.8879423141479492,
0.569956362247467,
-0.4798574149608612,
0.07206100225448608,
-0.21354608237743378,
-0.22025954723358154,
-0.4997139275074005,
0.14308299124240875,
-0.41106489300727844,
-0.508459210395813,
0.228621706366539,
-0.08918175846338272,
0.3082444667816162,
0.6187592148780823,
0.3263126611709595,
-0.2781772315502167,
1.1546497344970703,
0.8894728422164917,
0.3791472613811493,
0.23625636100769043,
0.10788434743881226,
0.3193877339363098,
-0.7643992900848389,
-0.330354779958725,
-0.3953557014465332,
0.049402009695768356,
-0.6484566926956177,
-0.1823779046535492,
0.294367253780365,
0.15404832363128662,
-0.19612695276737213,
0.17903268337249756,
-0.7027773261070251,
0.17676477134227753,
0.41321855783462524,
0.07452689111232758,
0.3613945543766022,
-0.3408961296081543,
0.37922194600105286,
0.10817362368106842,
-0.3347850739955902,
-0.9926127791404724,
1.2574201822280884,
0.6399545669555664,
0.6686552166938782,
0.09422348439693451,
0.12381935119628906,
0.2484595626592636,
0.5293934941291809,
-0.8219616413116455,
0.26991572976112366,
0.21957531571388245,
-0.9892998933792114,
-0.2865484654903412,
-0.10950752347707748,
-1.046547532081604,
0.3342377841472626,
-0.35379675030708313,
-0.7472801804542542,
0.3036213219165802,
0.46513840556144714,
-0.28131192922592163,
0.21965450048446655,
-0.4158646762371063,
0.7659798860549927,
-0.34244364500045776,
-0.35952016711235046,
-0.2375430315732956,
-1.0149669647216797,
0.49481651186943054,
-0.13733899593353271,
0.5681219100952148,
-0.031959258019924164,
0.011377458460628986,
0.7001568078994751,
-0.03573736548423767,
0.7670088410377502,
0.032889630645513535,
-0.015417356044054031,
0.24630050361156464,
0.16800647974014282,
0.4660399556159973,
0.2472270280122757,
-0.354336678981781,
0.4995671808719635,
0.47011518478393555,
-0.6340253949165344,
-0.7328492403030396,
0.20913489162921906,
-0.7329177260398865,
-0.6527281999588013,
-0.4462728500366211,
-0.4472854435443878,
-0.021583156660199165,
0.28540486097335815,
0.5698160529136658,
0.6145771741867065,
-0.2759948670864105,
0.024656306952238083,
0.7644866704940796,
0.014964478090405464,
-0.0473460778594017,
0.539778470993042,
-0.03949692100286484,
-0.027645336464047432,
0.9529284834861755,
-0.14242234826087952,
0.24036484956741333,
0.19960486888885498,
0.10917097330093384,
-0.29100796580314636,
-1.1252703666687012,
-0.021885883063077927,
0.08281594514846802,
-0.7310488224029541,
0.23588871955871582,
-0.4755752682685852,
-0.08274050056934357,
-0.2514001429080963,
-0.44694772362709045,
-0.3550271987915039,
-0.20798419415950775,
-0.26765531301498413,
-0.028849568217992783,
0.04170798882842064,
0.8983129858970642,
-0.1052616536617279,
0.29286259412765503,
-0.7067983150482178,
0.46792057156562805,
0.183546781539917,
0.35738933086395264,
-0.04199767857789993,
-0.5084623694419861,
-0.18713414669036865,
0.3110620975494385,
-0.45889806747436523,
-0.8638993501663208,
0.16953745484352112,
0.07891261577606201,
0.6714612245559692,
0.615994930267334,
0.03429305553436279,
0.3928571045398712,
-0.46937689185142517,
0.7161849141120911,
0.07397039979696274,
-1.3380296230316162,
0.6941114068031311,
-0.23280039429664612,
-0.14363259077072144,
0.5924261808395386,
0.4516431987285614,
-0.5481923818588257,
-0.4955437481403351,
-0.8309813737869263,
-0.7662023901939392,
0.6433975696563721,
0.2518911361694336,
0.21040166914463043,
0.3035653829574585,
0.7176558375358582,
0.8564184904098511,
0.36579737067222595,
-0.6886993646621704,
-0.14959381520748138,
-0.6099831461906433,
-0.09090370684862137,
-0.20371925830841064,
-0.02409161627292633,
-0.4060359299182892,
-0.17611096799373627,
0.4943011403083801,
-0.19112910330295563,
0.5773552656173706,
0.12263711541891098,
-0.11310981214046478,
-0.34479501843452454,
0.3937196135520935,
0.33575811982154846,
1.4320358037948608,
-0.2371734082698822,
0.4136773645877838,
-0.24381768703460693,
-0.4151441752910614,
0.16909407079219818,
0.010991928167641163,
-0.38942980766296387,
-0.22279497981071472,
0.8082890510559082,
0.7146121263504028,
-0.007001109421253204,
-0.4352932274341583,
0.3188651502132416,
0.0902450755238533,
-0.2689287066459656,
-0.5858237147331238,
0.21386168897151947,
-0.2894301116466522,
0.2702862620353699,
0.380329430103302,
0.5943750143051147,
0.17739613354206085,
-1.0333850383758545,
0.12282775342464447,
0.3808909058570862,
-0.547798216342926,
-0.7154558897018433,
1.1331950426101685,
0.04377281293272972,
-0.3150354027748108,
0.5338448286056519,
-0.058394573628902435,
-0.4720174968242645,
0.5620844960212708,
0.4955723285675049,
0.590773344039917,
-0.293235182762146,
0.38238540291786194,
0.0029340283945202827,
0.5322776436805725,
-0.1990601122379303,
0.30714818835258484,
0.0641077309846878,
-0.888225793838501,
-0.30766740441322327,
-0.5523492097854614,
-0.7894178032875061,
0.026721414178609848,
-1.1406710147857666,
-0.1471804827451706,
-0.28081515431404114,
0.022019576281309128,
0.520595371723175,
-0.18362262845039368,
-0.5691930651664734,
0.31746235489845276,
-0.406575471162796,
0.8191303014755249,
-0.8070337772369385,
0.4896318316459656,
0.7371336221694946,
-0.22483502328395844,
-0.47582563757896423,
0.07966756820678711,
0.368028849363327,
-0.9128206372261047,
0.11940770596265793,
0.18710440397262573,
0.13749174773693085,
-0.25603970885276794,
-0.9050108790397644,
-0.8823188543319702,
1.1026321649551392,
0.17545393109321594,
-0.040832072496414185,
-0.039633043110370636,
-0.3817770779132843,
0.5844091176986694,
-0.18218587338924408,
-0.032989323139190674,
0.7822656035423279,
1.102003812789917,
-0.2542569935321808,
-0.6651232242584229,
0.2228097915649414,
-0.4072977304458618,
-0.12572182714939117,
0.15004484355449677,
-0.30370935797691345,
0.8570117950439453,
-0.18778693675994873,
-0.2560376524925232,
0.2857751250267029,
0.6851766705513,
0.07907316833734512,
0.9335018992424011,
0.507816731929779,
0.07635704427957535,
0.5261238217353821,
-0.08852716535329819,
1.1731752157211304,
-0.14416445791721344,
0.1186656728386879,
0.8688184022903442,
-0.11924014985561371,
0.6755912899971008,
0.48743340373039246,
-0.1448124498128891,
0.4973966181278229,
0.764407753944397,
-0.07741869986057281,
0.35005244612693787,
-0.24720251560211182,
0.053270090371370316,
-0.5012167096138,
0.010008585639297962,
-0.34847214818000793,
0.6951094269752502,
0.5052372217178345,
-0.3823440372943878,
0.19470080733299255,
0.06199965998530388,
0.09518175572156906,
0.10821456462144852,
-0.12789037823677063,
0.5033922791481018,
0.20451104640960693,
-0.7498024106025696,
0.5061553120613098,
-0.03994319960474968,
0.3497183620929718,
-0.5670865774154663,
-0.16185416281223297,
0.18328067660331726,
0.0987490862607956,
-0.2791564464569092,
-0.8334148526191711,
0.5931947827339172,
-0.5586804151535034,
-0.23836229741573334,
-0.2872687578201294,
0.7216141819953918,
0.08796650916337967,
-0.35156911611557007,
0.19808773696422577,
0.8304159641265869,
0.2662632167339325,
-0.08145061135292053,
-0.6762043833732605,
0.09274217486381531,
-0.12471891194581985,
0.0375228114426136,
0.17583481967449188,
0.277436226606369,
-0.131729394197464,
1.0334354639053345,
0.6857486367225647,
0.06886003166437149,
-0.25122854113578796,
-0.7628099918365479,
0.7056881189346313,
-0.6855127215385437,
-0.6641828417778015,
-0.7931894063949585,
0.4179169237613678,
0.08067317306995392,
-0.22004716098308563,
0.673494279384613,
-0.0023922473192214966,
0.2831913232803345,
0.18541006743907928,
0.90900057554245,
0.059067584574222565,
0.2265692949295044,
-0.48627886176109314,
0.6374796628952026,
-0.6953776478767395,
0.17516714334487915,
-0.3036423325538635,
-0.9077830910682678,
-0.16669784486293793,
0.5558041334152222,
-0.2817130386829376,
0.018331177532672882,
0.8706615567207336,
0.19940000772476196,
0.035795167088508606,
0.6364434957504272,
0.06255923211574554,
0.4965113699436188,
0.07748933881521225,
0.3137960433959961,
1.2041776180267334,
-0.10313783586025238,
0.3343566954135895,
-0.06017763167619705,
-0.37249553203582764,
-0.2962622344493866,
-0.8258785605430603,
-0.32943639159202576,
-0.5523507595062256,
-0.24828770756721497,
-0.31600892543792725,
0.0492306649684906,
0.31829139590263367,
0.7841673493385315,
-0.5423919558525085,
0.16294078528881073,
-0.37906280159950256,
0.5250446200370789,
-0.9588633179664612,
-0.2526124119758606,
0.2751435935497284,
-0.22148214280605316,
-0.5269719362258911,
0.44740933179855347,
0.4239538908004761,
0.04251354932785034,
-0.1562144160270691,
-0.13749529421329498,
0.3364310562610626,
0.40627536177635193,
0.5761592984199524,
0.39409270882606506,
-0.9961948990821838,
-0.6232584118843079,
-0.22799904644489288,
0.40211787819862366,
0.16874894499778748,
0.7320550680160522,
-0.5623641014099121,
0.7182645797729492,
0.10450524091720581,
0.40235546231269836,
0.0033809635788202286,
0.12636667490005493,
0.9124366044998169,
0.24319137632846832,
-0.14352114498615265,
0.37337809801101685,
0.21829535067081451,
0.15048322081565857,
-0.4549587368965149,
0.5741251707077026,
0.1582612246274948,
-0.519385814666748,
-0.8329693078994751,
0.5853279829025269,
-0.999144434928894,
-0.6851853132247925,
0.7991288304328918,
-0.3047254979610443,
-0.26118209958076477,
-0.8228937387466431,
0.15848766267299652,
0.23737509548664093,
-0.13116149604320526,
0.7915623188018799,
0.5663805603981018,
-0.6487872004508972,
-0.03588905185461044,
-0.8785111308097839,
0.5397591590881348,
0.4864124357700348,
-0.813849687576294,
0.017039770260453224,
0.19054315984249115,
0.4113447368144989,
0.38987427949905396,
0.4479489326477051,
-0.15178577601909637,
0.5497511029243469,
0.3508557379245758,
-0.3590471148490906,
-0.1082308292388916,
-0.3958251178264618,
-0.43350595235824585,
0.009100246243178844,
0.1600179225206375,
-0.06555578112602234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06703v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06703v1
|
Interpretable Cross-Examination Technique (ICE-T): Using highly informative features to boost LLM performance
| 2024-05-08T19:20:34 | 2024-05-08T19:20:34 |
Goran Muric, Ben Delay, Steven Minton
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we introduce the Interpretable Cross-Examination Technique
(ICE-T), a novel approach that leverages structured multi-prompt techniques
with Large Language Models (LLMs) to improve classification performance over
zero-shot and few-shot methods. In domains where interpretability is crucial,
such as medicine and law, standard models often fall short due to their
"black-box" nature. ICE-T addresses these limitations by using a series of
generated prompts that allow an LLM to approach the problem from multiple
directions. The responses from the LLM are then converted into numerical
feature vectors and processed by a traditional classifier. This method not only
maintains high interpretability but also allows for smaller, less capable
models to achieve or exceed the performance of larger, more advanced models
under zero-shot conditions. We demonstrate the effectiveness of ICE-T across a
diverse set of data sources, including medical records and legal documents,
consistently surpassing the zero-shot baseline in terms of classification
metrics such as F1 scores. Our results indicate that ICE-T can be used for
improving both the performance and transparency of AI applications in complex
decision-making environments.
|
[
0.06879470497369766,
-0.753502607345581,
0.7413495182991028,
-0.012701400555670261,
-0.4214300811290741,
0.37224218249320984,
-0.06470529735088348,
-0.7121736407279968,
0.0062522669322788715,
0.38629987835884094,
-0.19006988406181335,
-0.8111675381660461,
-0.8119289875030518,
0.012121717445552349,
-0.6093031764030457,
1.189239263534546,
-0.2177053689956665,
0.2616480588912964,
-0.18966011703014374,
-0.28669679164886475,
-0.5039255023002625,
-0.21061541140079498,
-0.6912919282913208,
-0.39502251148223877,
0.3783743977546692,
0.42894136905670166,
0.7520927786827087,
0.8000715970993042,
0.47530844807624817,
0.1446089744567871,
0.14123961329460144,
-0.1213504746556282,
-0.27193254232406616,
-0.003101755166426301,
-0.2356887012720108,
-0.79317706823349,
-0.3901171088218689,
0.21469801664352417,
0.5056679248809814,
0.5224137902259827,
-0.03339219093322754,
0.13958337903022766,
0.07765089720487595,
0.1272842288017273,
-0.628507673740387,
0.2622802257537842,
-0.4214528799057007,
0.25821393728256226,
-0.32790470123291016,
-0.31534168124198914,
-0.5794479250907898,
-0.0044580427929759026,
0.2596389055252075,
-0.4738497734069824,
0.08615656197071075,
0.24969761073589325,
0.7911995053291321,
0.2951543629169464,
-0.4438873529434204,
-0.06188520789146423,
-0.626137912273407,
0.9287171959877014,
-0.4747786223888397,
0.44666779041290283,
0.010178686119616032,
0.6256499886512756,
0.2365081012248993,
-0.745189905166626,
-0.49966952204704285,
-0.32305681705474854,
-0.14924922585487366,
0.10768043994903564,
-0.36801519989967346,
0.060243718326091766,
0.23851530253887177,
-0.020666956901550293,
-0.4840780198574066,
0.44733065366744995,
-0.2448231428861618,
-0.39885586500167847,
0.6615889668464661,
0.4694024324417114,
0.5656737685203552,
0.09935899078845978,
-0.30213916301727295,
0.013828491792082787,
-0.7484453320503235,
0.17571592330932617,
-0.25681719183921814,
0.239263117313385,
-0.3097836673259735,
0.543602705001831,
-0.13736672699451447,
0.7718728184700012,
0.07657073438167572,
-0.3303872346878052,
0.1851435750722885,
-0.28846636414527893,
-0.25937458872795105,
0.20046932995319366,
0.5853819251060486,
0.31550005078315735,
-0.040140558034181595,
-0.0986466035246849,
-0.09971151500940323,
-0.13854989409446716,
0.1322694569826126,
-0.863045871257782,
0.07229383289813995,
0.4593256413936615,
-0.6795583367347717,
-0.49245116114616394,
-0.06934583187103271,
-0.8707113862037659,
-0.3994375169277191,
-0.25727227330207825,
0.3012799918651581,
-0.354880690574646,
-0.019825680181384087,
0.043818093836307526,
-0.11265936493873596,
0.39071476459503174,
0.8087092041969299,
-0.3969647288322449,
0.26463836431503296,
0.7838526964187622,
0.9234918355941772,
-0.4221556782722473,
-0.15792080760002136,
-0.9868679642677307,
0.13671112060546875,
-0.29755309224128723,
0.8437687754631042,
-1.1242883205413818,
-0.04620246961712837,
-0.1531568020582199,
-0.3991278111934662,
-0.11689725518226624,
-0.5174663662910461,
0.42737942934036255,
-0.3024492859840393,
0.17947973310947418,
0.43098124861717224,
-0.3572130501270294,
-0.3170740604400635,
0.5940727591514587,
-0.4205456078052521,
0.6930601596832275,
0.14620284736156464,
-0.6001661419868469,
0.7117229104042053,
-0.948246419429779,
-0.5152571201324463,
0.28088629245758057,
-0.5476370453834534,
-0.5781546831130981,
-0.11041177809238434,
0.4267860949039459,
0.6121312379837036,
-0.5839530825614929,
0.23229750990867615,
-0.39199739694595337,
-0.2840996980667114,
0.15185324847698212,
-0.25372257828712463,
0.7515122890472412,
0.2345150262117386,
-0.5246782898902893,
0.260739266872406,
-0.7756334543228149,
0.1527291238307953,
-0.08187654614448547,
-0.20474518835544586,
-0.21017248928546906,
-0.37180233001708984,
-0.09146963059902191,
0.16959622502326965,
0.04812345653772354,
-0.5487998723983765,
0.07086265087127686,
-0.022578051313757896,
0.24694319069385529,
0.34027305245399475,
-0.03553582355380058,
0.16918455064296722,
-0.2536517381668091,
0.9539519548416138,
0.19563280045986176,
0.276740163564682,
-0.19498710334300995,
-0.7288747429847717,
-0.41949209570884705,
-0.5975497364997864,
0.5105312466621399,
1.076175570487976,
-0.9973396062850952,
0.19821587204933167,
-0.10250509530305862,
-0.6214617490768433,
-0.9621384739875793,
0.0047005959786474705,
0.5513471961021423,
0.7751110792160034,
0.3943541944026947,
-0.031913310289382935,
-0.13698232173919678,
-0.8172813057899475,
-0.5925295352935791,
-0.25620976090431213,
-0.07433480769395828,
0.5043160915374756,
0.5972330570220947,
-0.1479087471961975,
0.38796064257621765,
-0.5576472878456116,
-0.09388063102960587,
-0.3663574159145355,
0.5926150679588318,
0.24296079576015472,
0.33562129735946655,
0.5390674471855164,
-0.6422083377838135,
-0.6473938226699829,
0.27838438749313354,
-1.0477570295333862,
-0.17745061218738556,
-0.4126485288143158,
0.11599629372358322,
0.09551826864480972,
0.4620329439640045,
-0.46145132184028625,
0.8193533420562744,
0.1429826319217682,
-0.4291677176952362,
0.4181000888347626,
0.06684019416570663,
0.36779293417930603,
-0.6578284502029419,
0.06051257252693176,
0.13895437121391296,
-0.22229929268360138,
-0.8734586834907532,
0.24284802377223969,
0.13856761157512665,
-0.24586638808250427,
-0.665777325630188,
0.794295072555542,
-0.4290880262851715,
0.071434885263443,
-0.1400107443332672,
-0.0034298100508749485,
0.09684384614229202,
0.09417068958282471,
0.0872146412730217,
0.573059618473053,
1.1077589988708496,
-0.4530080556869507,
0.20808853209018707,
0.1662198007106781,
-0.31212714314460754,
1.136834979057312,
-0.42047426104545593,
0.1649511605501175,
-0.24600529670715332,
0.1282377541065216,
-0.6656413674354553,
0.0006680026999674737,
0.4025091826915741,
-0.4012458622455597,
0.6119176149368286,
-0.09427065402269363,
-0.316424697637558,
0.10368846356868744,
-0.37402644753456116,
0.713968813419342,
0.3079568147659302,
-0.556352972984314,
0.9913941621780396,
-0.000005604228135780431,
-0.2336065173149109,
-0.8705040216445923,
-0.6956354975700378,
0.36606571078300476,
-0.4020613133907318,
-0.6254332065582275,
0.14455187320709229,
0.015522761270403862,
-0.46559906005859375,
0.013611635193228722,
0.10287975519895554,
-0.2627140283584595,
0.24918009340763092,
0.03335225582122803,
0.4670523703098297,
-0.28094059228897095,
0.015263093635439873,
0.0860140472650528,
-0.03271472826600075,
-0.05042899027466774,
-0.10558965057134628,
0.1821555495262146,
0.05290224030613899,
-0.3275966942310333,
-0.720503568649292,
0.43758830428123474,
0.6909458637237549,
-0.22457703948020935,
0.6548281311988831,
0.6071456074714661,
-0.3718620836734772,
-0.20801334083080292,
-0.48535698652267456,
-0.14974288642406464,
-0.31625866889953613,
0.33213719725608826,
-0.46790552139282227,
-0.8882789611816406,
0.5082523226737976,
0.025113830342888832,
0.04351621866226196,
0.3874798119068146,
0.2652471363544464,
-0.15104952454566956,
1.0120285749435425,
0.6412045359611511,
-0.14628027379512787,
0.43099072575569153,
0.14909017086029053,
0.22317767143249512,
-0.6372645497322083,
-0.5708466172218323,
-0.7118813395500183,
-0.17904679477214813,
-0.5083927512168884,
-0.4179687201976776,
0.7321234941482544,
-0.10812510550022125,
0.01581699587404728,
-0.1072697713971138,
-0.33217599987983704,
0.3690584897994995,
0.2930450141429901,
0.43039247393608093,
0.2407917082309723,
-0.07694168388843536,
-0.01861349679529667,
-0.010433310642838478,
-0.7037177681922913,
-0.37930819392204285,
1.406556248664856,
0.46433866024017334,
0.7996985912322998,
-0.20753464102745056,
0.6768923997879028,
0.35364025831222534,
0.5766136050224304,
-0.9124164581298828,
0.40154528617858887,
-0.1419868767261505,
-0.6129675507545471,
-0.4294210374355316,
-0.4123794436454773,
-0.9840537905693054,
0.20945993065834045,
-0.5468006730079651,
-0.7835276126861572,
-0.023654241114854813,
-0.04358913004398346,
-0.5713471174240112,
0.40852639079093933,
-0.5596189498901367,
0.8223000168800354,
-0.6914897561073303,
-0.26655113697052,
-0.32942405343055725,
-0.5483300685882568,
0.3860918879508972,
-0.36166471242904663,
0.1591094732284546,
0.11745411902666092,
-0.35648536682128906,
0.55423504114151,
-0.28998687863349915,
0.8489174246788025,
-0.20965999364852905,
0.17395350337028503,
0.09791500866413116,
0.08260032534599304,
0.3945538401603699,
-0.05476921424269676,
-0.24792686104774475,
0.48272705078125,
-0.07369469851255417,
-0.4379085302352905,
-0.9980783462524414,
0.181764155626297,
-0.548151969909668,
-0.796193540096283,
-0.5110664367675781,
-0.7978993654251099,
-0.0710507184267044,
0.354143351316452,
-0.0018185771768912673,
0.4754355549812317,
-0.044854674488306046,
0.02323664352297783,
0.4976593255996704,
-0.4671890437602997,
0.03190535306930542,
0.6502986550331116,
0.1347341686487198,
-0.1792365461587906,
0.7647146582603455,
0.10587889701128006,
0.22683654725551605,
0.6483447551727295,
0.32467421889305115,
-0.2139034867286682,
-1.1533393859863281,
-0.4576053023338318,
0.2515142560005188,
-0.6621856093406677,
-0.29797691106796265,
-0.5508150458335876,
-0.14180278778076172,
-0.49093568325042725,
-0.004722016863524914,
0.09846440702676773,
-0.39255091547966003,
-0.2996099889278412,
-0.10892383754253387,
0.1763405203819275,
0.794021725654602,
-0.02349632978439331,
0.17946675419807434,
-0.9060465693473816,
0.3518351912498474,
0.039757005870342255,
0.377906858921051,
-0.22106513381004333,
-0.6307888627052307,
-0.1809150129556656,
-0.4216541647911072,
-0.026816433295607567,
-0.7250722646713257,
0.2360415756702423,
0.07438650727272034,
0.9335466027259827,
0.5863147974014282,
0.06295530498027802,
0.7116609215736389,
-0.2713257074356079,
0.5384474992752075,
0.2615922689437866,
-1.083166241645813,
0.7295946478843689,
0.028509853407740593,
0.2628713846206665,
0.5071837902069092,
0.4820874333381653,
-0.33193182945251465,
-0.55866938829422,
-0.4591466188430786,
-0.6583547592163086,
0.892096757888794,
0.1655152589082718,
-0.3484572172164917,
0.4208299219608307,
0.527405858039856,
0.28864482045173645,
0.23239943385124207,
-0.4466741383075714,
-0.12628857791423798,
-0.08604728430509567,
-0.34817323088645935,
-0.025837434455752373,
-0.04180895537137985,
-0.2911614179611206,
-0.1236976832151413,
0.470294713973999,
-0.3171638548374176,
0.11593269556760788,
0.2029726207256317,
-0.10390780121088028,
0.026590518653392792,
0.4831887483596802,
0.6457690596580505,
0.8149186372756958,
-0.23530787229537964,
0.11416079103946686,
0.2716910243034363,
-0.4405854046344757,
-0.023355918005108833,
0.12560942769050598,
-0.35845011472702026,
-0.09794826060533524,
0.7942429184913635,
0.6763088703155518,
-0.17244569957256317,
-0.6338231563568115,
0.46620047092437744,
-0.13579624891281128,
-0.029118353500962257,
0.036087460815906525,
-0.008816398680210114,
-0.5474089980125427,
0.48813527822494507,
0.19441473484039307,
-0.03827662765979767,
0.42333289980888367,
-0.968626081943512,
0.3616379201412201,
0.4450105130672455,
-0.5868302583694458,
-0.08721627295017242,
0.5388259887695312,
0.09464661031961441,
-0.27450698614120483,
0.7544772624969482,
0.1069677472114563,
-0.3690226376056671,
0.7256135940551758,
0.2850032150745392,
0.8834161162376404,
-0.3628770112991333,
0.2875705659389496,
0.16359823942184448,
0.3437843918800354,
0.13443420827388763,
0.46407192945480347,
0.0010897415922954679,
-0.6462211012840271,
-0.33823874592781067,
-0.03476490452885628,
-0.6574043035507202,
0.2587079703807831,
-0.90239018201828,
0.2560233771800995,
-0.6990611553192139,
0.13812044262886047,
0.3384097218513489,
-0.20625431835651398,
-0.6857643127441406,
0.5279003977775574,
0.06962785869836807,
1.1269116401672363,
-0.9562205076217651,
0.6216887831687927,
0.7188884615898132,
-0.3838353455066681,
-0.7140289545059204,
0.19362452626228333,
0.3026164770126343,
-1.1378765106201172,
0.672271728515625,
0.19990046322345734,
-0.0031758910045027733,
-0.597054660320282,
-0.8322034478187561,
-0.5174221992492676,
1.1356209516525269,
0.39344701170921326,
-0.5034009218215942,
0.1969420164823532,
0.31249120831489563,
0.746051549911499,
-0.7059269547462463,
0.5099947452545166,
0.8723666071891785,
0.6236394643783569,
0.0743558406829834,
-1.1469528675079346,
0.37865281105041504,
-0.19342190027236938,
-0.510713517665863,
0.03184407576918602,
-0.4973582625389099,
0.5264027118682861,
-0.3762631118297577,
-0.15267299115657806,
-0.16767509281635284,
0.32802680134773254,
0.49853071570396423,
0.9030916094779968,
0.6075586676597595,
0.4459301233291626,
0.9275895953178406,
-0.04268111288547516,
1.23027765750885,
-0.3372027277946472,
-0.12749654054641724,
0.904352068901062,
-0.44348645210266113,
0.7525257468223572,
0.4487254321575165,
0.23696278035640717,
0.45089513063430786,
0.4641306400299072,
-0.34201857447624207,
0.3033857047557831,
0.14855949580669403,
-0.1644415706396103,
-0.564804196357727,
-0.5708506107330322,
0.03054954670369625,
0.6789019703865051,
0.45736363530158997,
-0.3366633951663971,
-0.25988999009132385,
0.1255577802658081,
0.1262447088956833,
-0.06843719631433487,
-0.6432026028633118,
0.7138887643814087,
0.19499355554580688,
-0.6424664855003357,
0.2948658764362335,
-0.2048584371805191,
0.4437461197376251,
-0.28840264678001404,
-0.582904577255249,
-0.016660969704389572,
0.11906055361032486,
-0.47176918387413025,
-1.0984529256820679,
0.16984084248542786,
0.16419707238674164,
0.13784071803092957,
-0.2657347619533539,
0.6917206645011902,
-0.23322845995426178,
-0.6526064276695251,
0.4104146957397461,
0.6668926477432251,
0.5718324780464172,
-0.007623777259141207,
-1.048492670059204,
0.01762557402253151,
-0.010502330958843231,
0.21276922523975372,
0.17832879722118378,
0.6603363752365112,
-0.4925093948841095,
0.8654528260231018,
0.3319232761859894,
0.1620284616947174,
-0.29638174176216125,
0.07215935736894608,
0.7405767440795898,
-0.867630660533905,
-0.44167208671569824,
-0.8099493384361267,
0.5674537420272827,
0.002121846890076995,
-0.13505156338214874,
0.35755738615989685,
0.6084497570991516,
0.7256006598472595,
0.21681730449199677,
1.0290937423706055,
0.06441941857337952,
0.6353462338447571,
-0.7367783784866333,
0.5546510219573975,
-0.5540466904640198,
0.35234835743904114,
-0.1214718148112297,
-0.3874949812889099,
-0.7029516696929932,
0.2772342562675476,
-0.35102012753486633,
0.1308610588312149,
0.8488724827766418,
0.5253269672393799,
-0.07427607476711273,
-0.2034415602684021,
0.5805191993713379,
0.3130161166191101,
0.3664206862449646,
0.5014341473579407,
0.8639089465141296,
-0.3398682475090027,
0.8459542989730835,
-0.11051635444164276,
-0.4594819247722626,
-0.1596652865409851,
-0.8409960865974426,
-1.3078930377960205,
-0.02526371367275715,
-0.7341122627258301,
-0.38747742772102356,
0.045116715133190155,
0.6301233768463135,
0.8290137052536011,
-0.9392022490501404,
-0.06290196627378464,
0.6114073395729065,
0.2535110116004944,
-0.3169625699520111,
-0.2229253351688385,
0.4640207290649414,
-0.14625045657157898,
-0.551365852355957,
0.3746926486492157,
0.41916418075561523,
0.030336620286107063,
-0.045532725751399994,
-0.014997851103544235,
-0.0034704848658293486,
-0.05193230137228966,
0.5637215971946716,
0.14862795174121857,
-0.6509449481964111,
-0.306649386882782,
0.004537196364253759,
0.1619533896446228,
0.3919728100299835,
0.8983990550041199,
-0.4931834638118744,
0.5105752348899841,
0.4486575722694397,
0.8402750492095947,
0.6568355560302734,
-0.07648925483226776,
0.6933582425117493,
-0.31816262006759644,
-0.1189035177230835,
0.459435373544693,
0.3490397036075592,
0.14046914875507355,
-0.8679969906806946,
0.5643354654312134,
0.07819981127977371,
-0.10196972638368607,
-0.7889524698257446,
0.20637354254722595,
-1.0294288396835327,
-0.3704098165035248,
0.8107144236564636,
-0.5609346032142639,
-0.28541919589042664,
-0.5050067901611328,
0.055950846523046494,
0.19805626571178436,
-0.6179419755935669,
0.9675637483596802,
0.5047230124473572,
-0.6321415305137634,
-0.5880758762359619,
-0.5526869893074036,
0.2906978130340576,
0.5061874389648438,
-1.2578474283218384,
-0.3720368444919586,
0.2754763960838318,
0.5612392425537109,
0.34146246314048767,
0.36907511949539185,
-0.38111770153045654,
0.5259215831756592,
-0.13110460340976715,
-0.08737187832593918,
-0.14351658523082733,
-0.6023404598236084,
-0.7817090749740601,
0.1858486533164978,
0.03066233918070793,
-0.13444948196411133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05378v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05378v1
|
"They are uncultured": Unveiling Covert Harms and Social Threats in LLM Generated Conversations
| 2024-05-08T19:08:45 | 2024-05-08T19:08:45 |
Preetam Prabhu Srikar Dammu, Hayoung Jung, Anjali Singh, Monojit Choudhury, Tanushree Mitra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as an integral part of modern
societies, powering user-facing applications such as personal assistants and
enterprise applications like recruitment tools. Despite their utility, research
indicates that LLMs perpetuate systemic biases. Yet, prior works on LLM harms
predominantly focus on Western concepts like race and gender, often overlooking
cultural concepts from other parts of the world. Additionally, these studies
typically investigate "harm" as a singular dimension, ignoring the various and
subtle forms in which harms manifest. To address this gap, we introduce the
Covert Harms and Social Threats (CHAST), a set of seven metrics grounded in
social science literature. We utilize evaluation models aligned with human
assessments to examine the presence of covert harms in LLM-generated
conversations, particularly in the context of recruitment. Our experiments
reveal that seven out of the eight LLMs included in this study generated
conversations riddled with CHAST, characterized by malign views expressed in
seemingly neutral language unlikely to be detected by existing methods.
Notably, these LLMs manifested more extreme views and opinions when dealing
with non-Western concepts like caste, compared to Western ones such as race.
|
[
0.012724176049232483,
-0.8321689963340759,
0.3061645030975342,
-0.03649522736668587,
-0.1291850060224533,
0.34177857637405396,
-0.1361316442489624,
-0.4686526358127594,
0.2918681800365448,
0.8579457402229309,
-0.710922122001648,
-0.6638116836547852,
-0.5672067403793335,
-0.13756926357746124,
-0.479052871465683,
1.1020597219467163,
0.4673686921596527,
0.002627997426316142,
-0.1332477331161499,
-0.18314407765865326,
-0.3525707721710205,
-0.7662329077720642,
-0.101606585085392,
-0.059496086090803146,
0.563620924949646,
0.4653882384300232,
0.8251112103462219,
0.25639843940734863,
0.680468738079071,
0.262481153011322,
-0.27113014459609985,
-0.000703832134604454,
-0.9092488288879395,
0.4059846103191376,
-0.274715393781662,
-0.4879697561264038,
-0.04762900248169899,
0.25468745827674866,
0.10121216624975204,
1.0943665504455566,
0.09167154878377914,
0.447118878364563,
0.08879083395004272,
0.7248635292053223,
-0.6684485077857971,
-0.316587895154953,
-0.7599684596061707,
-0.02083967626094818,
-0.5165379643440247,
0.017119310796260834,
-0.38388341665267944,
-0.2617807388305664,
-0.09448613226413727,
-0.1593189835548401,
0.191120445728302,
-0.1726045459508896,
0.47710880637168884,
0.029652636498212814,
-0.9047350287437439,
-0.3489784300327301,
-0.8893943428993225,
0.6979680061340332,
-0.47420722246170044,
0.20163224637508392,
0.275251179933548,
0.2522795498371124,
-0.37576860189437866,
-0.527934730052948,
-0.2387034147977829,
-0.07576997578144073,
-0.15869340300559998,
0.00514562800526619,
-0.5138847231864929,
0.016756534576416016,
0.23539650440216064,
0.24314531683921814,
-0.32776790857315063,
0.3787650167942047,
-0.8189478516578674,
-0.3178190290927887,
0.9292227625846863,
0.6364561319351196,
0.5372274518013,
-0.16267694532871246,
-0.37374645471572876,
0.029819656163454056,
-1.0628528594970703,
0.01790263131260872,
0.6714393496513367,
0.11836650967597961,
-0.10028884559869766,
0.6030397415161133,
0.19312474131584167,
0.1316215693950653,
-0.18492726981639862,
0.17561492323875427,
-0.22717082500457764,
0.03572685271501541,
-0.1050080806016922,
-0.12869173288345337,
0.9471595287322998,
0.6286731958389282,
0.4238584637641907,
-0.05972025915980339,
-0.13586345314979553,
0.6472004055976868,
0.31871965527534485,
-0.47961246967315674,
0.0689576268196106,
-0.17957043647766113,
-0.25512444972991943,
-0.6756206154823303,
-0.1000814139842987,
-1.0201166868209839,
-1.0312117338180542,
0.3166601061820984,
-0.12526878714561462,
0.029342567548155785,
-0.08481476455926895,
-0.06650619953870773,
-0.26846790313720703,
0.40091681480407715,
0.2076946496963501,
-0.47734978795051575,
0.24351561069488525,
0.5243560075759888,
0.5928482413291931,
-0.23416486382484436,
0.0941561684012413,
-0.13923324644565582,
0.14423269033432007,
-0.5413877964019775,
0.625491738319397,
-0.7250888347625732,
-1.0306150913238525,
0.2848310172557831,
0.05693906545639038,
0.3344515860080719,
-0.4808894395828247,
1.0795245170593262,
-0.49124273657798767,
-0.0786815732717514,
-0.4409487843513489,
0.041763097047805786,
-0.1870422065258026,
0.15584027767181396,
-0.04665093496441841,
1.0166720151901245,
0.013299963437020779,
-0.6596699357032776,
0.11234433203935623,
-0.6020640730857849,
-0.4599102735519409,
0.3721145987510681,
-0.041519489139318466,
0.026710251346230507,
0.2667417824268341,
-0.2194374054670334,
0.5518316030502319,
-0.5645493865013123,
0.12151600420475006,
-0.4897781312465668,
-0.29424741864204407,
0.5680949091911316,
-0.587813138961792,
0.986190676689148,
0.3082664906978607,
-0.3588315546512604,
0.2538270056247711,
-0.3403329849243164,
-0.4115667939186096,
0.19631421566009521,
-0.08128179609775543,
-0.9443427920341492,
-0.08886003494262695,
-0.1969604194164276,
0.17915387451648712,
-0.19342631101608276,
-0.7743356227874756,
-0.07727956771850586,
-0.36226168274879456,
0.4578794538974762,
0.9326665997505188,
0.1004878506064415,
0.4809083938598633,
-0.20574404299259186,
0.4257664382457733,
0.14083123207092285,
0.5354717373847961,
0.23563042283058167,
-0.332427442073822,
-0.8224713206291199,
0.09241432696580887,
-0.4542412757873535,
0.49834051728248596,
-0.5719541907310486,
0.12945181131362915,
-0.1938595175743103,
-0.890529990196228,
-0.2406417578458786,
0.10789798945188522,
0.31518998742103577,
0.27963119745254517,
-0.03273563086986542,
-0.0012276950292289257,
-0.41246798634529114,
-1.086959958076477,
-0.7421419024467468,
-0.30618804693222046,
0.05685274675488472,
0.20528241991996765,
0.6194318532943726,
-0.7413812875747681,
0.6462184190750122,
-0.6807658672332764,
-0.4940122663974762,
0.046556055545806885,
-0.041762035340070724,
-0.1412481963634491,
0.14091502130031586,
0.05816621705889702,
-0.6168911457061768,
-0.49300169944763184,
-0.21240706741809845,
-0.7806833386421204,
-0.32975977659225464,
0.13877981901168823,
-0.19373798370361328,
-0.1087711974978447,
0.5811154246330261,
-0.36297789216041565,
0.5710344314575195,
0.41744405031204224,
-0.30487242341041565,
0.6310095191001892,
0.23144488036632538,
0.008482269942760468,
-0.9050421118736267,
-0.2663591802120209,
0.037877846509218216,
0.23402142524719238,
-0.7874771952629089,
0.06406787037849426,
-0.08619596064090729,
-0.3706505000591278,
-0.8026804327964783,
0.518212616443634,
-0.7199590802192688,
0.2064782828092575,
0.16553515195846558,
0.1812000870704651,
-0.09294460713863373,
0.10414736717939377,
-0.21997985243797302,
0.5253883600234985,
0.47811487317085266,
-0.6315619945526123,
0.335262656211853,
0.30343005061149597,
-0.2807532548904419,
0.4281245470046997,
-0.5546374320983887,
0.48217150568962097,
-0.17904166877269745,
0.3481309711933136,
-0.9632951617240906,
-0.43602490425109863,
-0.02001284807920456,
-0.30076342821121216,
-0.10065104067325592,
-0.06300978362560272,
-0.35216662287712097,
-0.5597768425941467,
-0.5950890183448792,
0.7576383352279663,
0.7324821352958679,
-0.23320257663726807,
0.21227362751960754,
0.8083722591400146,
0.0025572895538061857,
-0.6347857117652893,
-0.9793785214424133,
0.339243620634079,
-0.5466915965080261,
-0.7401592135429382,
-0.02058900147676468,
0.1984003335237503,
-0.861945390701294,
-0.3170546293258667,
0.048502177000045776,
0.11083588004112244,
0.0876394733786583,
0.691760778427124,
0.30199211835861206,
0.09864219278097153,
-0.011222507804632187,
-0.06921769678592682,
0.2552247941493988,
0.4084402322769165,
0.18429876863956451,
0.3017539381980896,
0.014672157354652882,
-0.4903073012828827,
0.18240024149417877,
0.690471887588501,
0.8324404954910278,
-0.17249245941638947,
0.6956543922424316,
0.3036239445209503,
-0.22855481505393982,
-0.25206995010375977,
-0.7174309492111206,
-0.2970960736274719,
-0.5149909853935242,
0.38817298412323,
0.2960215210914612,
-1.0460293292999268,
0.6810029149055481,
-0.2636345326900482,
0.010520819574594498,
0.327584832906723,
0.4379090368747711,
-0.01592443510890007,
0.7753114104270935,
0.6070742607116699,
0.19874584674835205,
0.2239646464586258,
-0.13079260289669037,
0.2722317576408386,
-0.7740458846092224,
-0.6641339659690857,
-0.4940989315509796,
-0.19025708734989166,
-0.7572229504585266,
-0.42669692635536194,
0.8097472190856934,
-0.11861641705036163,
-0.3632161617279053,
-0.018015805631875992,
-0.5159117579460144,
0.6075156927108765,
0.3035874664783478,
-0.12275845557451248,
0.1526491940021515,
0.03677685186266899,
0.0100353779271245,
-0.23173847794532776,
-0.44359269738197327,
-0.795500636100769,
1.0323947668075562,
0.42695173621177673,
1.4179680347442627,
0.36468273401260376,
0.3104720711708069,
0.6013323664665222,
0.5522846579551697,
-0.7800514698028564,
0.801060676574707,
-0.0867731049656868,
-0.8709445595741272,
-0.1041448786854744,
-0.10886333137750626,
-1.177359938621521,
0.2599428594112396,
-0.14967912435531616,
-0.8730724453926086,
0.38843780755996704,
-0.09488589316606522,
-0.1498379111289978,
0.44507259130477905,
-0.3969516158103943,
0.30433592200279236,
-0.29852068424224854,
-0.5772744417190552,
-0.07193637639284134,
-0.7827016711235046,
0.8963031768798828,
-0.10472474247217178,
0.5915294885635376,
-0.3062557876110077,
0.051871731877326965,
0.914932906627655,
-0.4113842248916626,
1.5105770826339722,
0.06327179074287415,
-0.40513813495635986,
0.22186975181102753,
0.5223178863525391,
0.35741758346557617,
-0.13070441782474518,
-0.19146960973739624,
0.478813111782074,
-0.0408160462975502,
-0.3229692280292511,
-0.3175792396068573,
0.8723074793815613,
-0.859595000743866,
-0.917210042476654,
-0.34048086404800415,
-0.6547616720199585,
-0.19856062531471252,
0.13489514589309692,
0.34978699684143066,
0.346660852432251,
-0.5684584975242615,
0.1884632706642151,
0.6563851833343506,
-0.6462884545326233,
0.30490773916244507,
0.6512616276741028,
-0.027185853570699692,
-0.13886815309524536,
0.34090325236320496,
-0.009477495215833187,
0.6031950116157532,
-0.11231088638305664,
0.12726350128650665,
-0.4205508530139923,
-0.08983436971902847,
-0.17550130188465118,
0.2953389883041382,
-0.9207205772399902,
-0.2758451998233795,
-0.7158677577972412,
-0.0712357833981514,
-0.7315250039100647,
-0.4183935523033142,
-0.27367615699768066,
0.20703370869159698,
-0.03070306032896042,
-0.010880466550588608,
0.12132652848958969,
1.0681440830230713,
-0.12972402572631836,
0.3816475570201874,
-0.7505884170532227,
0.011272731237113476,
0.3382028043270111,
-0.04099462553858757,
-0.3138030171394348,
-0.5948094725608826,
0.029299844056367874,
0.2945624887943268,
-0.4967339336872101,
-1.2566418647766113,
0.3469668924808502,
-0.1272822916507721,
0.4108142852783203,
0.6206533312797546,
0.792521595954895,
0.4074358642101288,
-0.26782459020614624,
1.0225753784179688,
0.13689814507961273,
-0.48247045278549194,
0.46147841215133667,
-0.5148877501487732,
-0.01483684778213501,
0.349962443113327,
0.5962066650390625,
-0.9633970260620117,
-0.619530975818634,
-0.579291582107544,
-0.7237300872802734,
0.5576115846633911,
-0.16212612390518188,
0.8451455235481262,
-0.3570827841758728,
-0.004247956443578005,
0.03834668919444084,
0.009951652958989143,
-0.9155519604682922,
-0.5137190222740173,
0.11380255967378616,
0.20831915736198425,
-0.1396339237689972,
-0.7017822265625,
-0.4053104817867279,
-0.18978999555110931,
0.3040139079093933,
0.3011351525783539,
0.08728299289941788,
0.028360644355416298,
-0.19334140419960022,
-0.4183409810066223,
0.59246826171875,
0.46528488397598267,
0.07753355801105499,
0.12867075204849243,
0.4920400381088257,
0.2406565397977829,
-0.5268924832344055,
0.5451313257217407,
-0.6622239947319031,
-0.06485414505004883,
-0.20747654139995575,
0.4097525179386139,
0.7096772193908691,
0.1825873702764511,
-0.5519000887870789,
0.8615512251853943,
0.15803247690200806,
-0.17898398637771606,
-0.4133128225803375,
-0.11561209708452225,
0.003989718854427338,
0.04891497641801834,
0.19253617525100708,
0.04986610263586044,
0.1114092543721199,
-0.9965213537216187,
-0.2736256718635559,
0.9231833815574646,
-0.7036199569702148,
-0.40771281719207764,
0.4738360047340393,
0.569645881652832,
-0.616472065448761,
0.6749126315116882,
-0.060173265635967255,
-0.6858620047569275,
0.07970665395259857,
0.5767126679420471,
0.87517249584198,
-0.3279242217540741,
0.4012296795845032,
0.011745080351829529,
0.7076225876808167,
0.48097214102745056,
-0.229324072599411,
0.20812992751598358,
-0.8423434495925903,
-0.0033657674212008715,
-0.691785991191864,
-0.20918752253055573,
0.4586672782897949,
-0.5947075486183167,
0.13833411037921906,
-0.26607704162597656,
-0.059553470462560654,
-0.28688228130340576,
-0.24868230521678925,
-0.48770391941070557,
-0.22270487248897552,
0.04947670176625252,
0.7414548397064209,
-1.2537177801132202,
0.38662874698638916,
0.6787452697753906,
-0.10940439999103546,
-0.544161319732666,
0.16063416004180908,
0.4848403036594391,
-0.7488712072372437,
0.8649920225143433,
0.020063260570168495,
-0.2301412969827652,
-0.11377780139446259,
-0.5653441548347473,
-0.5011214017868042,
0.48605218529701233,
0.4887758791446686,
-0.25549137592315674,
0.022644512355327606,
0.6786174178123474,
0.6314190626144409,
-0.016794908791780472,
0.22474804520606995,
0.4901295304298401,
0.3876199722290039,
0.09526757895946503,
-0.7074153423309326,
0.18236877024173737,
-0.2755005359649658,
-0.025624176487326622,
0.3736743927001953,
-0.7281662225723267,
0.7137061357498169,
-0.37616491317749023,
-0.6028326153755188,
-0.42451414465904236,
0.15191613137722015,
-0.18353813886642456,
-0.0034417251590639353,
0.3175559937953949,
-0.1767306923866272,
0.5240010619163513,
0.01976858265697956,
1.0156739950180054,
0.10169770568609238,
-0.14181144535541534,
0.5841829180717468,
-0.4104118049144745,
0.3463023602962494,
0.3997790515422821,
-0.0812772884964943,
0.5607811808586121,
0.5593780279159546,
0.17562724649906158,
0.21984170377254486,
0.6378965377807617,
-0.4852069318294525,
-0.07829216122627258,
-0.4254293441772461,
-0.11885486543178558,
0.645268440246582,
0.6747021079063416,
-0.2117466777563095,
-0.35797110199928284,
0.11986880004405975,
0.18839797377586365,
0.3224412798881531,
-0.36396077275276184,
0.7460318207740784,
0.2812711298465729,
-0.4637788236141205,
0.5616940855979919,
0.030301712453365326,
1.0700271129608154,
-0.568996250629425,
0.1720433235168457,
-0.5046758055686951,
0.0790313109755516,
-0.3162727952003479,
-0.666318416595459,
0.3457959294319153,
-0.0751214250922203,
-0.023414211347699165,
-0.07076655328273773,
1.017709732055664,
-0.30236050486564636,
-0.41392233967781067,
0.5402765274047852,
0.7184402346611023,
0.49662646651268005,
-0.1708601862192154,
-0.5884278416633606,
0.10574635863304138,
0.032680243253707886,
0.0921424850821495,
0.4601919651031494,
0.5491148829460144,
-0.6640645265579224,
0.9121745824813843,
0.7495685815811157,
0.14949733018875122,
0.17191669344902039,
-0.024721767753362656,
0.8592883348464966,
-0.5676684975624084,
-0.16641561686992645,
-1.1860297918319702,
0.2768462300300598,
-0.04766010493040085,
-0.28364408016204834,
0.959148108959198,
0.281201034784317,
0.6670575737953186,
-0.14749589562416077,
0.5034751892089844,
0.3124394714832306,
0.38342180848121643,
-0.026788629591464996,
0.8957095146179199,
-0.3547317385673523,
0.6195744872093201,
-0.6839584708213806,
-0.6903653144836426,
-0.13216465711593628,
-0.023062774911522865,
-0.5250818133354187,
-0.022608652710914612,
0.6199535727500916,
1.1833993196487427,
0.060669198632240295,
-0.03361897170543671,
0.6714586019515991,
0.3022441864013672,
0.3267800509929657,
0.3346448540687561,
1.4646522998809814,
-0.016533752903342247,
0.5040695667266846,
-0.16320814192295074,
-0.10168876498937607,
-0.03931104391813278,
-0.6032282114028931,
-1.054234504699707,
-0.6188628673553467,
-0.21887025237083435,
-0.2621864974498749,
-0.058843668550252914,
0.5650692582130432,
0.3885025680065155,
-0.351006418466568,
-0.4501417577266693,
0.3410336375236511,
-0.0090443454682827,
0.4234604239463806,
-0.34055083990097046,
0.11509426683187485,
-0.0810685083270073,
-0.5406166315078735,
0.2316206395626068,
0.24137359857559204,
0.16749222576618195,
-0.6943804025650024,
0.07739676535129547,
-0.035493772476911545,
0.3104570508003235,
0.8584668636322021,
-0.05184340849518776,
-0.81172114610672,
-0.25759243965148926,
-0.055890582501888275,
-0.17843517661094666,
-0.6014072299003601,
0.852954626083374,
-0.5418667793273926,
0.018878767266869545,
0.06806258857250214,
0.36762309074401855,
-0.13674908876419067,
-0.2786388695240021,
0.5777150988578796,
-0.9092158675193787,
0.20166443288326263,
0.32956957817077637,
0.12334191799163818,
0.4775853455066681,
-0.8039530515670776,
0.6572864651679993,
0.328797310590744,
-0.439199298620224,
-1.3648911714553833,
0.3856242299079895,
-0.355308473110199,
-0.3387875258922577,
1.625356912612915,
0.12649212777614594,
-0.18205565214157104,
-0.35865718126296997,
-0.38431158661842346,
0.25770503282546997,
-0.2301781177520752,
0.6309624910354614,
0.32698220014572144,
0.025447160005569458,
0.2522903382778168,
-0.535305917263031,
0.7218825817108154,
0.44141092896461487,
-0.7349989414215088,
0.41264376044273376,
0.5737358331680298,
0.3885033428668976,
0.19607150554656982,
0.5434945821762085,
-0.2700149118900299,
0.006882155779749155,
-0.07547174394130707,
-0.016093451529741287,
0.005062183365225792,
0.10665832459926605,
0.0550696961581707,
0.01581459864974022,
-0.03279672563076019,
0.09213918447494507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05376v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05376v2
|
Kreyòl-MT: Building MT for Latin American, Caribbean and Colonial African Creole Languages
| 2024-05-08T19:06:19 | 2024-05-13T17:21:56 |
Nathaniel R. Robinson, Raj Dabre, Ammon Shurtz, Rasul Dent, Onenamiyi Onesi, Claire Bizon Monroc, Loïc Grobol, Hasan Muhammad, Ashi Garg, Naome A. Etori, Vijay Murari Tiyyala, Olanrewaju Samuel, Matthew Dean Stutzman, Bismarck Bamfo Odoom, Sanjeev Khudanpur, Stephen D. Richardson, Kenton Murray
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A majority of language technologies are tailored for a small number of
high-resource languages, while relatively many low-resource languages are
neglected. One such group, Creole languages, have long been marginalized in
academic study, though their speakers could benefit from machine translation
(MT). These languages are predominantly used in much of Latin America, Africa
and the Caribbean. We present the largest cumulative dataset to date for Creole
language MT, including 14.5M unique Creole sentences with parallel translations
-- 11.6M of which we release publicly, and the largest bitexts gathered to date
for 41 languages -- the first ever for 21. In addition, we provide MT models
supporting all 41 Creole languages in 172 translation directions. Given our
diverse dataset, we produce a model for Creole language MT exposed to more
genre diversity than ever before, which outperforms a genre-specific Creole MT
model on its own benchmark for 26 of 34 translation directions.
|
[
-0.3506733477115631,
-0.40817931294441223,
0.3297656178474426,
0.6458390951156616,
-0.4433111846446991,
0.7341686487197876,
-0.5338543057441711,
-0.6339293718338013,
0.5550097227096558,
0.8878573179244995,
-0.10059560090303421,
-0.6593943238258362,
-0.960983395576477,
0.35786736011505127,
-0.4833022654056549,
0.9224053025245667,
-0.2086075246334076,
0.05221756547689438,
0.14087547361850739,
-0.4565455913543701,
-0.5475690364837646,
-0.649095356464386,
-0.29892730712890625,
0.057232677936553955,
0.7960895299911499,
0.7205923795700073,
0.744304895401001,
0.8892166614532471,
0.5842538475990295,
0.27407294511795044,
0.3318987190723419,
0.35960665345191956,
-0.4490119516849518,
0.2715250253677368,
0.014041228219866753,
-0.5399873852729797,
-0.6654412746429443,
-0.35576072335243225,
0.37997907400131226,
1.1159374713897705,
-0.08040458709001541,
0.49550580978393555,
-0.09605343639850616,
0.8109008073806763,
-0.6028181910514832,
0.28957968950271606,
-0.5577414035797119,
-0.11636265367269516,
-0.5779757499694824,
-0.17514270544052124,
-0.49976637959480286,
-0.6853872537612915,
-0.0237119160592556,
-0.06312426179647446,
-0.013106328435242176,
0.20442701876163483,
0.46753767132759094,
-0.08198370039463043,
-1.0676915645599365,
-0.4180615544319153,
-0.7562739253044128,
0.9013224244117737,
-0.3483680188655853,
0.6773239970207214,
0.5588782429695129,
0.5767338871955872,
-0.14175057411193848,
-0.8522638082504272,
-0.517905056476593,
-0.16639494895935059,
0.11541204899549484,
-0.03774433583021164,
-0.1559944897890091,
-0.10220371931791306,
-0.21024157106876373,
0.2168319672346115,
-0.7038637399673462,
0.04085971787571907,
-0.9798499941825867,
-0.00845380686223507,
0.7111976742744446,
0.3339216411113739,
0.39317238330841064,
-0.2193417102098465,
-0.1000569611787796,
-0.15197588503360748,
-0.6879938840866089,
-0.15953704714775085,
0.3466366231441498,
0.6739939451217651,
-0.18980911374092102,
0.8432179093360901,
0.4101289212703705,
0.9376699924468994,
-0.425839364528656,
-0.3177624046802521,
0.2430393397808075,
-0.21144622564315796,
-0.3532032370567322,
0.03661288693547249,
0.7484662532806396,
0.47999319434165955,
0.24390438199043274,
-0.19943073391914368,
-0.16086451709270477,
-0.1463961899280548,
0.3151160180568695,
-0.8459305167198181,
-0.1992654651403427,
0.2745688855648041,
-0.6500923037528992,
-0.16754725575447083,
-0.3397669196128845,
-0.880424439907074,
-0.3161003589630127,
-0.4430231750011444,
-0.03541899472475052,
-0.45672351121902466,
-0.37828725576400757,
0.07229020446538925,
0.02236771397292614,
-0.22444762289524078,
0.16959425806999207,
-0.8099454641342163,
0.5481186509132385,
0.3076685667037964,
0.9730430245399475,
-0.37087786197662354,
-0.24150140583515167,
-0.32434505224227905,
-0.15887175500392914,
-0.44048839807510376,
0.43479904532432556,
-0.6206980347633362,
-0.6939053535461426,
0.07308588922023773,
0.1080356016755104,
-0.2299075722694397,
-0.6671679615974426,
0.6460589170455933,
-0.6861613392829895,
-0.09871947020292282,
-0.3667609691619873,
-0.16174423694610596,
-0.3667181432247162,
-0.051456935703754425,
-0.44156506657600403,
0.7581474781036377,
0.7365171313285828,
-0.3228021562099457,
0.24043986201286316,
-0.261761337518692,
-0.5901455283164978,
0.08050566911697388,
0.05638345703482628,
-0.09161011129617691,
0.2560988962650299,
-0.019123872742056847,
0.21851886808872223,
-0.6152706742286682,
0.23098069429397583,
-0.2344578206539154,
-0.21961894631385803,
0.17310792207717896,
-0.10534577816724777,
1.060834527015686,
0.6393946409225464,
-0.20434871315956116,
-0.22111299633979797,
-0.7088433504104614,
0.10106592625379562,
0.014969738200306892,
-0.3287821412086487,
-0.4627508819103241,
-0.2998068332672119,
0.4856301546096802,
0.3875187635421753,
0.11975566297769547,
-0.46248194575309753,
0.26229310035705566,
-0.13591201603412628,
0.306450754404068,
0.4144890606403351,
-0.22075819969177246,
0.4151342809200287,
0.12053877115249634,
0.9462750554084778,
0.04092487320303917,
-0.18006497621536255,
-0.15104874968528748,
-0.667277991771698,
-0.6932106614112854,
-0.3851999342441559,
0.7723569869995117,
0.6915284395217896,
-0.6108664274215698,
0.07426731288433075,
-0.3549675941467285,
-0.4691328704357147,
-0.8405895829200745,
0.012369109317660332,
0.33924412727355957,
0.40108323097229004,
0.5632219314575195,
-0.44074392318725586,
-0.8233035802841187,
-1.0478973388671875,
-0.07994764298200607,
0.14417728781700134,
0.16195867955684662,
0.4268261790275574,
0.4325074255466461,
-0.21728946268558502,
0.4407123029232025,
-0.46367400884628296,
-0.05843371897935867,
-0.4402662217617035,
-0.1381692737340927,
0.24653658270835876,
0.31610849499702454,
1.0351537466049194,
-0.7412047982215881,
-1.1741056442260742,
0.4081529676914215,
-0.6543651819229126,
-0.18012972176074982,
0.41185668110847473,
0.004633029457181692,
0.42976292967796326,
0.2828202247619629,
-0.3371036946773529,
0.2768254280090332,
0.8140190243721008,
0.030303100124001503,
0.5036537051200867,
-0.18557390570640564,
0.5138522982597351,
-1.264461636543274,
0.21680034697055817,
-0.2178826928138733,
-0.21746385097503662,
-0.6084986329078674,
0.24210429191589355,
0.1233530193567276,
-0.3444252014160156,
-0.2691495418548584,
0.5083404779434204,
-0.5332843661308289,
-0.06188760697841644,
-0.24494491517543793,
0.30453723669052124,
-0.2831974923610687,
0.4767802953720093,
-0.07315496355295181,
0.6723743677139282,
0.32296767830848694,
-0.6298759579658508,
0.20666158199310303,
0.17378582060337067,
-0.2756790220737457,
0.5512670874595642,
-0.7035611867904663,
0.14493697881698608,
0.07281160354614258,
0.2295103818178177,
-0.7378473877906799,
-0.3375122547149658,
0.09021822363138199,
-0.6094198226928711,
0.47931498289108276,
-0.6485485434532166,
-0.30118200182914734,
-0.5763797163963318,
0.16151297092437744,
0.5031006932258606,
0.5031516551971436,
-0.32442572712898254,
0.25112199783325195,
0.7555074095726013,
-0.566946804523468,
-0.7518289089202881,
-0.8649405241012573,
0.6298654079437256,
-0.16868644952774048,
-0.569553792476654,
0.05154189467430115,
-0.005162600427865982,
-0.38981008529663086,
-0.2385101467370987,
-0.07017064839601517,
-0.3853321671485901,
-0.24960346519947052,
0.09629607945680618,
0.1853787899017334,
-0.29291272163391113,
-0.09910804778337479,
0.26207852363586426,
0.20301270484924316,
-0.16606037318706512,
-0.8682654500007629,
0.9162772297859192,
0.19248263537883759,
-0.07888542860746384,
0.16257379949092865,
0.6857527494430542,
0.8911275267601013,
-0.6313092708587646,
1.0578465461730957,
0.5697130560874939,
-0.15439321100711823,
-0.02908005751669407,
-0.28716781735420227,
0.40244102478027344,
-0.4159972369670868,
0.44625335931777954,
-0.546076774597168,
-0.9499425292015076,
0.6037636995315552,
0.12313954532146454,
-0.08522055298089981,
0.1819431036710739,
0.7784122228622437,
-0.020679397508502007,
1.0713717937469482,
0.7008553147315979,
-0.1494394987821579,
0.19073180854320526,
-0.34516653418540955,
0.1607513576745987,
-0.600976824760437,
-0.24734754860401154,
-0.8877617716789246,
-0.45007994771003723,
-1.031253457069397,
-0.5605122447013855,
0.31334251165390015,
-0.005540498998016119,
-0.032318804413080215,
0.9486125111579895,
-0.2949214279651642,
0.2222549319267273,
0.5154455304145813,
-0.12564347684383392,
0.0867256224155426,
0.2529550790786743,
-0.41294997930526733,
-0.3253990411758423,
-0.5062367916107178,
-0.5310201644897461,
1.530782699584961,
0.0015217976178973913,
0.3378658592700958,
0.3689023554325104,
0.7832350134849548,
0.3579733073711395,
0.27822548151016235,
-0.6497979760169983,
0.31565335392951965,
-0.4740401804447174,
-0.4792823791503906,
0.2320292741060257,
-0.4940057396888733,
-1.251333475112915,
0.1847708374261856,
0.137671560049057,
-0.6970660090446472,
0.40962889790534973,
0.23692463338375092,
0.16650903224945068,
0.32731884717941284,
-0.786283552646637,
0.8211095333099365,
-0.08326472342014313,
-0.08197589218616486,
-0.30559128522872925,
-0.8491835594177246,
0.590001106262207,
-0.17259131371974945,
0.27901723980903625,
0.1971401870250702,
0.08666394650936127,
0.1306770294904709,
-0.5889767408370972,
0.43211209774017334,
-0.24998430907726288,
-0.16364462673664093,
0.4333229064941406,
0.5729525685310364,
0.2843896448612213,
-0.09807463735342026,
-0.10209730267524719,
0.2268902212381363,
-0.01260094903409481,
-0.6942319869995117,
-0.3381046652793884,
0.7613600492477417,
-0.7498148083686829,
-0.1795864850282669,
-0.19655849039554596,
-0.6056441068649292,
-0.1269354671239853,
0.3756762146949768,
0.1636824756860733,
0.4724642336368561,
-0.050090234726667404,
0.4023173749446869,
0.31162896752357483,
-0.1833008974790573,
0.21175344288349152,
0.666584312915802,
-0.6724081039428711,
-0.8572145700454712,
1.2118133306503296,
0.314325213432312,
0.3420552611351013,
0.41476303339004517,
-0.24152635037899017,
-0.2239713966846466,
-0.8522484302520752,
-0.6859268546104431,
0.005280061159282923,
-0.3727814257144928,
-0.2141331136226654,
-1.0625505447387695,
0.04873797297477722,
-0.42809030413627625,
-0.2181519865989685,
-0.2224382758140564,
-0.9428617358207703,
0.3105987012386322,
-0.062284428626298904,
0.0039015403017401695,
0.7058393955230713,
-0.08837877213954926,
0.3220483064651489,
-1.1062942743301392,
0.19689102470874786,
0.06704505532979965,
0.018654456362128258,
-0.01159981731325388,
-0.4618663787841797,
-0.634360671043396,
0.3449597656726837,
-0.22855059802532196,
-0.9075661301612854,
0.8254527449607849,
0.06283688545227051,
0.28655490279197693,
-0.05037359148263931,
-0.10271188616752625,
0.5663750171661377,
-0.6450896859169006,
0.7264878153800964,
0.14340974390506744,
-0.7164902091026306,
0.3800290524959564,
-0.5149071216583252,
0.08057533949613571,
0.4995807111263275,
0.4656527042388916,
-0.8171734809875488,
-0.5860198140144348,
-0.43368297815322876,
-0.8502485156059265,
0.4926595091819763,
0.341183066368103,
0.03586272522807121,
-0.33602049946784973,
0.1048261970281601,
0.3130124509334564,
0.6054809093475342,
-0.3051026165485382,
-0.41301894187927246,
-0.31780168414115906,
-0.30552607774734497,
-0.29336482286453247,
-0.03111829236149788,
0.12201478332281113,
-0.20268796384334564,
0.3148876130580902,
-0.09544563293457031,
0.2218841165304184,
-0.07003176212310791,
-0.5085940361022949,
-0.2444380819797516,
0.2724466025829315,
1.1385091543197632,
0.7923763990402222,
-0.40161198377609253,
0.07339625805616379,
0.010249101556837559,
-0.9477611780166626,
0.1613141894340515,
0.07094912230968475,
-0.12296576052904129,
0.05145144835114479,
0.1999250203371048,
0.5639940500259399,
-0.2034302055835724,
-0.5377575159072876,
0.06055985763669014,
0.024755820631980896,
0.0747247263789177,
-0.14882539212703705,
-0.12300680577754974,
0.19740252196788788,
0.0383325070142746,
0.361759752035141,
0.571283757686615,
0.11154820024967194,
-0.5687531232833862,
0.10679826140403748,
0.04349549859762192,
-0.5769751071929932,
-0.54721599817276,
0.7810401320457458,
0.3496617376804352,
-0.3391626179218292,
0.6663552522659302,
-0.15539036691188812,
-0.6045758724212646,
0.7605482935905457,
0.7575311660766602,
0.8031882047653198,
-0.28688567876815796,
0.2214643508195877,
0.45387977361679077,
0.5496780276298523,
0.27136269211769104,
0.5352697372436523,
0.0908210501074791,
-0.41587650775909424,
-0.32012268900871277,
-0.7689226269721985,
-0.26362404227256775,
-0.22610731422901154,
-0.6675755381584167,
0.3258300721645355,
-0.1899081915616989,
-0.31453701853752136,
-0.06835808604955673,
0.052450619637966156,
-0.784687876701355,
0.26485446095466614,
-0.1370311975479126,
1.0369778871536255,
-0.6303412318229675,
1.0271981954574585,
0.6726090312004089,
-0.6368008852005005,
-0.4224558174610138,
-0.2487679123878479,
0.060630347579717636,
-1.0217193365097046,
0.8570758104324341,
-0.34450048208236694,
-0.14681227505207062,
0.0912710651755333,
-0.4309483766555786,
-0.6296481490135193,
0.8720473051071167,
0.6080892086029053,
-0.5540313124656677,
0.339298278093338,
0.41799888014793396,
0.6999121904373169,
-0.6475722789764404,
0.05110209807753563,
0.581791341304779,
0.5390571355819702,
-0.12833072245121002,
-1.2448177337646484,
-0.33219385147094727,
-0.17065542936325073,
-0.06127411499619484,
0.7293729782104492,
-0.8459298610687256,
0.8561192154884338,
-0.3250259757041931,
-0.003092378843575716,
0.1319141834974289,
0.5161011815071106,
0.18400438129901886,
0.29763397574424744,
0.14219309389591217,
0.40389326214790344,
0.7487279772758484,
-0.045209016650915146,
1.1170293092727661,
-0.6146794557571411,
0.013676119036972523,
1.1520559787750244,
-0.34894177317619324,
0.669879674911499,
0.34680697321891785,
-0.42569804191589355,
0.527686595916748,
0.772627055644989,
0.25264298915863037,
0.3869238495826721,
0.29160284996032715,
-0.2835681736469269,
-0.04598210006952286,
-0.3798907697200775,
-0.5083476305007935,
0.5704731941223145,
0.521289587020874,
-0.5769644379615784,
0.10991185903549194,
0.010275240987539291,
0.3206768333911896,
0.2151121348142624,
-0.24028533697128296,
0.11271746456623077,
0.35120514035224915,
-0.5978530049324036,
0.8285109400749207,
0.20489321649074554,
0.16927039623260498,
-0.5554791688919067,
-0.02142903581261635,
-0.6044030785560608,
0.08529508113861084,
-0.08540478348731995,
-0.6237775087356567,
0.416010320186615,
0.005629751365631819,
-0.36000072956085205,
-0.1445319950580597,
0.575448215007782,
-0.7585443258285522,
-0.5479790568351746,
0.39848780632019043,
0.7770180106163025,
0.2086309790611267,
0.1330207884311676,
-0.34684768319129944,
-0.010953408665955067,
0.16396749019622803,
0.32035204768180847,
0.4044235944747925,
0.47670015692710876,
-0.3310668170452118,
0.6943532824516296,
0.5521202683448792,
0.354461669921875,
0.2593037486076355,
0.04474535584449768,
0.6596063375473022,
-0.6004660725593567,
-0.3550587296485901,
-0.5464060306549072,
0.42913997173309326,
-0.12334185093641281,
-0.38786739110946655,
1.028877854347229,
0.8237447142601013,
0.6493977308273315,
-0.24433214962482452,
0.9579350352287292,
-0.338179349899292,
0.39518213272094727,
-0.12312044948339462,
0.7070634961128235,
-0.5689840912818909,
0.014990584924817085,
-0.26635298132896423,
-1.185041904449463,
-0.33551931381225586,
0.07713409513235092,
0.10379917174577713,
0.07794120907783508,
0.8218393921852112,
0.45874667167663574,
-0.24302397668361664,
-0.04635751619935036,
0.3365209102630615,
0.41038328409194946,
0.19577181339263916,
0.27717125415802,
0.2584936320781708,
-0.5374260544776917,
0.8303353786468506,
-0.20002318918704987,
-0.1570204496383667,
-0.2523431181907654,
-0.7058196663856506,
-0.8700774312019348,
-0.5379801988601685,
-0.08382858335971832,
-0.6097655892372131,
0.09231387078762054,
1.166493535041809,
0.7418305277824402,
-1.2058354616165161,
-0.7268344759941101,
0.25368255376815796,
0.18612077832221985,
-0.3687385618686676,
-0.2008739858865738,
0.29092204570770264,
-0.1631617397069931,
-0.8875191807746887,
0.6706782579421997,
0.6564687490463257,
0.07561855763196945,
-0.2931681275367737,
-0.12537485361099243,
-0.09090965241193771,
0.01069172378629446,
0.9707366228103638,
0.3375055193901062,
-0.34667328000068665,
-0.2661094069480896,
0.4910782277584076,
-0.3366696238517761,
0.0419706292450428,
1.0467413663864136,
-0.4586842954158783,
0.6104475259780884,
0.3396191895008087,
0.44877535104751587,
0.589718759059906,
-0.43618735671043396,
1.0789669752120972,
-0.9311588406562805,
0.24432475864887238,
0.2760522961616516,
0.4384235441684723,
0.2867296636104584,
0.059113457798957825,
0.7520326375961304,
0.30834752321243286,
-0.6867417097091675,
-0.9777500033378601,
0.1839117705821991,
-0.992310643196106,
0.12025235593318939,
0.7603590488433838,
-0.18304146826267242,
-0.2379114031791687,
-0.40493708848953247,
-0.28117504715919495,
0.11395776271820068,
-0.2842366099357605,
0.7246580123901367,
0.6897146701812744,
0.1928320825099945,
-0.2565517723560333,
-0.9944069385528564,
0.3536781370639801,
-0.04113641008734703,
-0.5370040535926819,
-0.0830877423286438,
0.44295167922973633,
0.23289629817008972,
0.19953805208206177,
0.6725466251373291,
-0.08624706417322159,
0.12979307770729065,
0.09280209243297577,
0.12566080689430237,
0.17656786739826202,
-0.461902379989624,
0.14338192343711853,
0.11786572635173798,
0.018044453114271164,
-0.08380287885665894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05374v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05374v1
|
Arctic-Embed: Scalable, Efficient, and Accurate Text Embedding Models
| 2024-05-08T19:05:18 | 2024-05-08T19:05:18 |
Luke Merrick, Danmei Xu, Gaurav Nuti, Daniel Campos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
This report describes the training dataset creation and recipe behind the
family of \texttt{arctic-embed} text embedding models (a set of five models
ranging from 22 to 334 million parameters with weights open-sourced under an
Apache-2 license). At the time of their release, each model achieved
state-of-the-art retrieval accuracy for models of their size on the MTEB
Retrieval leaderboard, with the largest model, arctic-embed-l outperforming
closed source embedding models such as Cohere's embed-v3 and Open AI's
text-embed-3-large. In addition to the details of our training recipe, we have
provided several informative ablation studies, which we believe are the cause
of our model performance.
|
[
-0.4356432259082794,
-0.6845303177833557,
0.6351707577705383,
-0.18888165056705475,
-0.18967193365097046,
0.06476183235645294,
-0.045173510909080505,
-0.28934478759765625,
0.09596972912549973,
0.6488242745399475,
-0.28526219725608826,
-0.8424843549728394,
-0.5364658832550049,
-0.15752258896827698,
-0.5799924731254578,
0.7274455428123474,
-0.13620507717132568,
0.022784365341067314,
-0.232001394033432,
-0.34045618772506714,
-0.36966249346733093,
-0.36162281036376953,
-0.3477315604686737,
-0.010472816415131092,
0.5614757537841797,
0.7836511135101318,
0.7437456250190735,
0.9251308441162109,
0.6978161931037903,
0.1377073973417282,
0.054068222641944885,
-0.22435465455055237,
-0.4358294904232025,
0.23808610439300537,
0.010023729875683784,
-0.19297680258750916,
-0.4197736084461212,
0.1926107406616211,
0.7400449514389038,
0.38821667432785034,
-0.4795703887939453,
0.24667979776859283,
-0.17527155578136444,
0.5342696905136108,
-0.6419285535812378,
-0.17334075272083282,
-0.504514217376709,
-0.07337058335542679,
-0.1455945074558258,
0.3513314127922058,
-0.8077081441879272,
-0.4466303884983063,
0.37871289253234863,
-0.5814381241798401,
0.23722289502620697,
0.5040703415870667,
0.7616488337516785,
0.11207307130098343,
-0.561001718044281,
-0.5524938702583313,
-0.624732494354248,
0.9770414233207703,
-0.7266351580619812,
0.77955162525177,
0.6932741403579712,
0.2751057744026184,
0.22177517414093018,
-0.8501791954040527,
-0.1360616385936737,
0.07424794882535934,
0.03327997028827667,
-0.0747872143983841,
-0.18042659759521484,
0.007225246634334326,
0.00000890441606316017,
0.4969024658203125,
-0.7641056180000305,
0.22029589116573334,
-0.2999439537525177,
0.22864316403865814,
0.5293580889701843,
0.14728333055973053,
0.24982556700706482,
0.32493695616722107,
-0.12943926453590393,
-0.14466239511966705,
-0.8292958736419678,
-0.6019500494003296,
0.284730464220047,
0.16350364685058594,
-0.39570650458335876,
0.7861855626106262,
-0.10268985480070114,
0.6050050854682922,
-0.0678112581372261,
0.2314583957195282,
0.24916288256645203,
-0.18638768792152405,
-0.394438773393631,
0.14388002455234528,
0.5887546539306641,
0.185317724943161,
-0.32281243801116943,
-0.3245673179626465,
-0.27111464738845825,
-0.25351282954216003,
0.4635598659515381,
-0.8207516670227051,
-0.17476128041744232,
0.28818222880363464,
-0.48157423734664917,
-0.47803568840026855,
-0.0011623359750956297,
-0.507154107093811,
-0.07684595882892609,
0.03470752015709877,
0.6389376521110535,
-0.5907774567604065,
-0.39508065581321716,
0.09132687747478485,
-0.3937099277973175,
0.2658529579639435,
0.2631394863128662,
-0.8926425576210022,
0.41763561964035034,
0.48722270131111145,
1.0035885572433472,
0.07008170336484909,
-0.06238456442952156,
-0.24427425861358643,
0.23857080936431885,
-0.35974159836769104,
0.7130322456359863,
-0.8901122808456421,
-0.1727389097213745,
0.15769535303115845,
-0.354557603597641,
0.16497334837913513,
-0.3673474192619324,
0.3366335928440094,
-0.9799812436103821,
0.24052096903324127,
-0.42425113916397095,
-0.9284652471542358,
-0.5466093420982361,
0.2808069884777069,
-1.0742714405059814,
1.1472588777542114,
0.1990993767976761,
-0.586661696434021,
0.3563157021999359,
-0.9348879456520081,
0.11333348602056503,
0.12941765785217285,
0.15599867701530457,
-0.5557158589363098,
0.17258742451667786,
0.2287636250257492,
0.6462390422821045,
-0.634846031665802,
-0.10928270220756531,
-0.1848861426115036,
-0.17278729379177094,
-0.0855182483792305,
-0.0804465115070343,
0.5753809213638306,
0.4694962203502655,
-0.06879514455795288,
0.016241952776908875,
-0.6075701713562012,
0.029150957241654396,
0.2638044059276581,
-0.3042546212673187,
-0.721670925617218,
-0.12718665599822998,
0.10016276687383652,
-0.12094931304454803,
0.048787012696266174,
-0.7172537446022034,
0.11693783104419708,
-0.25823813676834106,
0.6100986003875732,
0.4705847501754761,
0.0786610096693039,
0.5398075580596924,
-0.4602344334125519,
0.426447331905365,
0.10125644505023956,
-0.10328763723373413,
-0.5031812191009521,
-0.5223588943481445,
-0.3782360553741455,
-0.4430590867996216,
0.6559990644454956,
0.0901576355099678,
-0.619672954082489,
0.34192290902137756,
-0.20196688175201416,
-1.0185338258743286,
-0.6577110886573792,
-0.05562548711895943,
0.36036309599876404,
0.20947781205177307,
0.25970157980918884,
0.146296888589859,
-0.21666327118873596,
-0.9640153646469116,
-0.24485936760902405,
0.23666945099830627,
0.17141613364219666,
0.17963720858097076,
1.0075839757919312,
-0.0191266480833292,
0.7199801802635193,
-0.6035411953926086,
-0.03460289165377617,
-0.06785492599010468,
0.27010950446128845,
-0.01417824998497963,
0.6218317747116089,
0.6996355652809143,
-0.6422310471534729,
-0.9435220956802368,
0.09108641743659973,
-0.8389248251914978,
0.4570944309234619,
0.20533058047294617,
-0.16387216746807098,
0.1994435042142868,
0.4060747027397156,
-0.3744020164012909,
0.4416930079460144,
0.9427481889724731,
-0.3846893608570099,
0.2549492120742798,
-0.11408347636461258,
0.15999332070350647,
-1.3649653196334839,
0.13052944839000702,
0.050658226013183594,
-0.32132548093795776,
-0.4781370460987091,
0.5089792609214783,
0.1668417900800705,
-0.13093219697475433,
-0.4769369661808014,
0.5089568495750427,
-0.6566232442855835,
-0.006069175433367491,
0.21405528485774994,
0.15487852692604065,
-0.01133799273520708,
0.34205499291419983,
-0.16671060025691986,
0.6972851753234863,
0.5883607268333435,
-0.4521484673023224,
0.35306963324546814,
0.4172723889350891,
-0.3778836131095886,
0.5211221575737,
-0.7985009551048279,
0.5092140436172485,
0.03025820665061474,
-0.10856978595256805,
-1.1326043605804443,
-0.36811286211013794,
0.08392692357301712,
-0.39734265208244324,
0.1695256382226944,
-0.32429051399230957,
-0.8076419830322266,
-0.017735455185174942,
-0.4528888165950775,
0.6047654151916504,
0.6556331515312195,
-0.7323843836784363,
0.7215777039527893,
0.4622610807418823,
-0.17839351296424866,
-0.4687372148036957,
-0.517739474773407,
-0.08184441179037094,
-0.16445249319076538,
-0.5235903263092041,
0.3632121980190277,
-0.1827569454908371,
-0.07683534920215607,
0.5025984048843384,
0.24285268783569336,
-0.23253779113292694,
0.04613379389047623,
0.22092501819133759,
0.05320199579000473,
-0.3939683735370636,
0.2853466868400574,
0.3682112991809845,
0.19473271071910858,
-0.08697997033596039,
-0.2596907913684845,
0.6735185384750366,
-0.30278775095939636,
-0.2567668557167053,
-0.3545747697353363,
0.4621231257915497,
0.6046886444091797,
-0.3280752897262573,
1.3590928316116333,
0.3442516028881073,
-0.7764574289321899,
-0.16715814173221588,
-0.6060970425605774,
-0.14678238332271576,
-0.46649685502052307,
0.19717220962047577,
-0.16931575536727905,
-0.844514787197113,
0.48937109112739563,
0.020147399976849556,
0.4106646478176117,
0.7663124799728394,
0.42903032898902893,
-0.11304569989442825,
1.2602505683898926,
0.4970543384552002,
0.26308533549308777,
0.28602147102355957,
-0.46443164348602295,
-0.3900871276855469,
-1.0698060989379883,
-0.43970540165901184,
-0.6728430986404419,
-0.29457855224609375,
-0.35751861333847046,
-0.22301970422267914,
0.21659766137599945,
-0.19879522919654846,
-0.7336978316307068,
0.20896892249584198,
-0.6658565402030945,
0.4506770074367523,
0.793048083782196,
-0.0033366570714861155,
0.11604337394237518,
0.31545084714889526,
-0.6055071353912354,
-0.1740570068359375,
-0.7042099237442017,
-0.5033217668533325,
1.4874805212020874,
0.4610159397125244,
0.8306521773338318,
0.29107266664505005,
0.6756578683853149,
0.45265665650367737,
0.5609956979751587,
-0.6079760193824768,
0.19193102419376373,
-0.1286579668521881,
-1.0523511171340942,
-0.32725992798805237,
-0.21153318881988525,
-0.8226437568664551,
-0.0065814657136797905,
-0.5478526949882507,
-0.46880435943603516,
-0.1962352991104126,
0.08532662689685822,
0.00015508869546465576,
0.6023708581924438,
-0.6503223180770874,
0.7988033890724182,
0.01857493259012699,
-0.143214613199234,
-0.34637221693992615,
-0.4025859832763672,
0.08126620203256607,
-0.15434470772743225,
0.13487890362739563,
0.02618304453790188,
-0.1573324054479599,
1.0029524564743042,
-0.2821520268917084,
0.7628321647644043,
-0.2998657524585724,
0.09270617365837097,
0.1859179586172104,
0.03350301831960678,
0.5454421639442444,
-0.10917897522449493,
-0.22319765388965607,
0.3163338303565979,
-0.1780272126197815,
-0.34506896138191223,
-0.254705548286438,
0.8239063620567322,
-1.0648006200790405,
-0.1476774364709854,
-0.5935019254684448,
-0.20516438782215118,
0.12522144615650177,
0.5570203065872192,
0.3417360186576843,
0.615425169467926,
-0.4947182238101959,
0.7986604571342468,
0.9435083270072937,
-0.32283520698547363,
0.35473117232322693,
0.5208271145820618,
-0.3095446825027466,
-0.9756709337234497,
0.731727659702301,
0.19997119903564453,
0.20331059396266937,
0.38228142261505127,
-0.03520502895116806,
-0.13164617121219635,
-0.7592892050743103,
-0.45568400621414185,
0.5893739461898804,
-0.6635662317276001,
-0.3808369040489197,
-0.6939855813980103,
-0.2650652825832367,
-0.12202749401330948,
-0.41081947088241577,
-0.8048334717750549,
-0.38442280888557434,
-0.47726577520370483,
-0.32386860251426697,
0.5707816481590271,
1.3220503330230713,
0.2656360864639282,
0.9062963724136353,
-0.9420267939567566,
-0.05179508402943611,
-0.1095576360821724,
0.7955862283706665,
-0.007528854999691248,
-0.41751959919929504,
-0.9077743291854858,
0.1130622997879982,
-0.4124937951564789,
-0.8630199432373047,
0.5428954362869263,
0.1292218714952469,
0.5675839185714722,
0.1632080227136612,
-0.03499941527843475,
0.1758359968662262,
-0.5783562064170837,
1.0349253416061401,
0.21808983385562897,
-0.9801748394966125,
0.6350888609886169,
-0.35671496391296387,
0.3847947418689728,
0.24768739938735962,
0.7429105639457703,
-0.36899182200431824,
-0.39780956506729126,
-0.8317453861236572,
-0.7858198285102844,
0.8493980169296265,
0.23800617456436157,
0.09191517531871796,
0.03238753229379654,
0.7052749395370483,
0.3537798821926117,
0.20059002935886383,
-0.3453509509563446,
-0.3821558654308319,
-0.10812436044216156,
-0.4887198209762573,
0.0477045513689518,
-0.49626877903938293,
0.000015834752048249356,
0.040599945932626724,
0.9004575610160828,
0.10315262526273727,
0.5558282136917114,
0.006092791445553303,
-0.1759454756975174,
-0.3371254503726959,
-0.1501510739326477,
0.5601403117179871,
0.29062387347221375,
-0.4550510048866272,
0.030812595039606094,
0.08354692161083221,
-0.7695194482803345,
-0.023075208067893982,
-0.08550819009542465,
-0.01868973858654499,
-0.016071179881691933,
0.34943121671676636,
0.6052092909812927,
-0.042835380882024765,
-0.514630138874054,
0.3152819871902466,
-0.34105485677719116,
-0.4484557807445526,
-0.5365791916847229,
-0.0505484901368618,
0.2358666956424713,
0.06826625764369965,
0.4493137300014496,
0.03178514167666435,
0.1767263263463974,
-0.19820636510849,
0.16785350441932678,
0.5147256255149841,
-0.4694713056087494,
-0.5065537095069885,
0.9394431710243225,
0.15687300264835358,
-0.09282650798559189,
1.2414308786392212,
0.12554168701171875,
-0.26252061128616333,
0.37783005833625793,
0.5690091848373413,
0.9606326818466187,
-0.4616226255893707,
0.19701094925403595,
0.5103341937065125,
0.5203134417533875,
-0.14999186992645264,
0.45809388160705566,
0.5083152651786804,
-0.7948873043060303,
-0.16014748811721802,
-0.37074798345565796,
-0.5826259255409241,
0.029225420206785202,
-0.9392365217208862,
0.34701353311538696,
-0.5967669486999512,
-0.29674258828163147,
0.17790035903453827,
-0.010881493799388409,
-0.9956311583518982,
0.2947421371936798,
0.08400335162878036,
1.2221992015838623,
-0.8879042267799377,
0.6915261745452881,
1.0857017040252686,
-0.43354859948158264,
-0.5808812975883484,
-0.2840013802051544,
-0.09510070085525513,
-0.7888987064361572,
0.5443426370620728,
0.015034666284918785,
0.10565920174121857,
0.41230595111846924,
-0.937932550907135,
-1.229317545890808,
1.3688156604766846,
0.34227797389030457,
-0.3642563223838806,
-0.1422351598739624,
-0.08269482105970383,
0.2826758325099945,
-0.6965629458427429,
0.29801642894744873,
0.2194645255804062,
0.31270065903663635,
0.1028619036078453,
-0.8211288452148438,
0.1872245967388153,
-0.1976766437292099,
0.04208967089653015,
0.37212803959846497,
-0.6700394153594971,
0.6857977509498596,
-0.031086213886737823,
-0.007924708537757397,
0.006714239250868559,
0.586200475692749,
-0.004186486359685659,
0.17398501932621002,
0.23998843133449554,
0.9462307095527649,
0.5689578056335449,
-0.13233210146427155,
1.1699258089065552,
-0.3190228044986725,
0.4465976655483246,
0.8806353807449341,
-0.05064988508820534,
1.1672672033309937,
0.13604095578193665,
0.209932342171669,
0.5230218768119812,
0.6298328638076782,
-0.046016789972782135,
0.8477210402488708,
-0.4218152165412903,
-0.007600648328661919,
-0.02547883242368698,
-0.010472355410456657,
-0.3036305010318756,
0.28090712428092957,
0.7677033543586731,
-0.6987981200218201,
-0.06365437805652618,
0.006590832024812698,
0.16077378392219543,
-0.3027963936328888,
-0.17023788392543793,
1.0141136646270752,
0.006882186979055405,
-0.41948646306991577,
0.6296482682228088,
0.10781677067279816,
0.2351359874010086,
-0.5208770036697388,
-0.3543930947780609,
0.017721733078360558,
-0.0162346214056015,
-0.11410710215568542,
-0.8782626986503601,
0.3880287706851959,
-0.16654349863529205,
-0.07576500624418259,
-0.06235240772366524,
0.4688374102115631,
-0.4211640954017639,
-0.3864646852016449,
-0.02538071945309639,
0.3974328339099884,
0.09369609504938126,
-0.03259802982211113,
-0.6227164268493652,
0.3205587565898895,
-0.11556679010391235,
-0.5359510183334351,
0.07978033274412155,
0.35496068000793457,
0.21117666363716125,
0.49542343616485596,
0.5776617527008057,
-0.16732840240001678,
0.030376076698303223,
-0.4641251862049103,
0.8647711277008057,
-0.88541179895401,
-0.39859750866889954,
-0.7590988278388977,
0.7081566452980042,
0.029949089512228966,
-0.18875020742416382,
0.74400395154953,
0.9602038264274597,
0.6259407997131348,
-0.1473364233970642,
1.0088828802108765,
-0.00952509418129921,
0.4903368055820465,
-0.5509290099143982,
0.7067652344703674,
-0.7596730589866638,
0.35575932264328003,
-0.13375593721866608,
-1.0829267501831055,
-0.5129442811012268,
0.41664427518844604,
-0.045015595853328705,
0.1237921416759491,
0.7012441158294678,
0.4309477210044861,
-0.12586252391338348,
0.2946350574493408,
0.36019232869148254,
0.38410887122154236,
0.5111819505691528,
0.11305700987577438,
0.6141309142112732,
-0.6083922982215881,
0.34579211473464966,
-0.2268475443124771,
-0.23607568442821503,
-0.5384575724601746,
-0.9450245499610901,
-0.9579130411148071,
-0.7634319067001343,
-0.437296986579895,
-0.205633744597435,
0.08936850726604462,
1.0069993734359741,
0.755379319190979,
-0.7473307847976685,
-0.031107096001505852,
0.10899419337511063,
0.018349768593907356,
-0.23363807797431946,
-0.1486818492412567,
0.4808225631713867,
-0.08574927598237991,
-0.6290374398231506,
0.16293802857398987,
0.20777857303619385,
0.17336516082286835,
-0.17933793365955353,
-0.09619101136922836,
-0.24023659527301788,
0.30804646015167236,
0.5021650791168213,
-0.10797077417373657,
-0.4171600043773651,
-0.4543275535106659,
0.23015980422496796,
-0.11599132418632507,
0.07655204087495804,
0.2850315570831299,
-0.4976785182952881,
0.46193474531173706,
0.33154016733169556,
0.5298770666122437,
0.7013710737228394,
-0.31460458040237427,
0.7217570543289185,
-0.9790880680084229,
-0.23244766891002655,
0.16669051349163055,
0.2814338803291321,
0.3200252652168274,
-0.3699550926685333,
0.6776975393295288,
-0.05286368727684021,
-0.7551986575126648,
-0.9355586767196655,
-0.06675155460834503,
-0.894243061542511,
-0.09080328047275543,
0.7962492108345032,
-0.11845385283231735,
-0.13083474338054657,
0.13675543665885925,
-0.17139041423797607,
0.1450589895248413,
-0.6147788763046265,
0.4079640507698059,
0.7774900197982788,
0.09293372929096222,
-0.34264618158340454,
-0.7169056534767151,
0.28629788756370544,
-0.08326885849237442,
-0.6078358292579651,
-0.09501805156469345,
0.47416430711746216,
0.4666922688484192,
0.2655693590641022,
0.05717065930366516,
-0.1717253476381302,
0.2345176339149475,
0.37668728828430176,
0.19577376544475555,
-0.17872358858585358,
-0.3666473925113678,
-0.03800666704773903,
0.11812270432710648,
0.4716453552246094,
-0.06809777021408081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05348v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05348v1
|
The Effect of Model Size on LLM Post-hoc Explainability via LIME
| 2024-05-08T18:27:20 | 2024-05-08T18:27:20 |
Henning Heyen, Amy Widdicombe, Noah Y. Siegel, Maria Perez-Ortiz, Philip Treleaven
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) are becoming bigger to boost performance.
However, little is known about how explainability is affected by this trend.
This work explores LIME explanations for DeBERTaV3 models of four different
sizes on natural language inference (NLI) and zero-shot classification (ZSC)
tasks. We evaluate the explanations based on their faithfulness to the models'
internal decision processes and their plausibility, i.e. their agreement with
human explanations. The key finding is that increased model size does not
correlate with plausibility despite improved model performance, suggesting a
misalignment between the LIME explanations and the models' internal processes
as model size increases. Our results further suggest limitations regarding
faithfulness metrics in NLI contexts.
|
[
-0.10928891599178314,
-0.6679824590682983,
1.0302859544754028,
0.3425457179546356,
-0.5923686623573303,
-0.17062242329120636,
-0.2705119252204895,
-0.7032751441001892,
-0.015242772176861763,
0.34426209330558777,
-0.4322306215763092,
-0.08153630048036575,
-0.5179146528244019,
0.17386434972286224,
-0.3768729865550995,
0.8361870050430298,
-0.2636679410934448,
0.04130787029862404,
-0.04322996735572815,
-0.015827514231204987,
-0.9314203858375549,
-0.300301194190979,
-0.384660542011261,
-0.5320607423782349,
0.763852596282959,
0.5759362578392029,
1.15485417842865,
0.8612701296806335,
0.21995972096920013,
0.187102809548378,
-0.3034146726131439,
0.0060501378029584885,
-0.4851096570491791,
0.27844730019569397,
-0.24306367337703705,
-0.5976089835166931,
-0.4846494793891907,
0.06337632983922958,
0.7099220156669617,
0.8034167289733887,
0.15127061307430267,
0.08680768311023712,
0.19765253365039825,
0.6966333389282227,
-0.7936305999755859,
-0.005756186321377754,
-0.6872641444206238,
-0.25938931107521057,
0.2712116837501526,
-0.17908714711666107,
-0.6099198460578918,
-0.21107950806617737,
0.3608248829841614,
-0.5483255386352539,
0.31582871079444885,
0.027517009526491165,
0.8425721526145935,
0.13516399264335632,
-0.27037638425827026,
-0.4242948889732361,
-1.0406489372253418,
0.9808820486068726,
-0.8823257088661194,
0.041982222348451614,
0.2419428527355194,
0.32187220454216003,
-0.1675664484500885,
-0.3937043845653534,
-0.6413685083389282,
-0.09488707035779953,
-0.15665552020072937,
-0.20898546278476715,
-0.21714015305042267,
0.27370014786720276,
0.20671477913856506,
0.5059260129928589,
-0.6939607858657837,
0.23233139514923096,
-0.268681138753891,
-0.048867374658584595,
0.7055184245109558,
0.19757552444934845,
0.100128673017025,
0.03489750996232033,
-0.14667664468288422,
0.36781349778175354,
-0.9403277039527893,
-0.11933520436286926,
0.27308571338653564,
0.1836589276790619,
-0.02756667509675026,
0.5213163495063782,
-0.16006316244602203,
0.9667293429374695,
0.10755269974470139,
-0.0068985954858362675,
-0.13428135216236115,
-0.5601717233657837,
-0.6045820713043213,
0.46761006116867065,
0.40800583362579346,
0.2713155448436737,
0.40811577439308167,
-0.26766058802604675,
0.24980169534683228,
0.0486927404999733,
0.09947597235441208,
-0.9680992960929871,
-0.12461935728788376,
0.45117366313934326,
-0.5782108306884766,
-0.2491634488105774,
-0.04833775386214256,
-0.1596205085515976,
-0.5202744007110596,
-0.3947226107120514,
0.7333036065101624,
-0.37149283289909363,
-0.4360503852367401,
0.4189956486225128,
-0.37671974301338196,
0.5856861472129822,
0.7686663866043091,
-0.7153428792953491,
0.14164377748966217,
0.5911489725112915,
0.9166240096092224,
0.14112968742847443,
-0.148371621966362,
-0.27566292881965637,
0.010861882008612156,
-0.7285621166229248,
0.4149622917175293,
-0.17329612374305725,
-0.09441395848989487,
-0.27396345138549805,
0.07650700956583023,
-0.2023640275001526,
-0.5778604745864868,
0.20611871778964996,
-0.5773938894271851,
-0.04557591304183006,
-0.47324424982070923,
-0.377126008272171,
-0.39177003502845764,
-0.02976923994719982,
-0.4479138255119324,
0.5478377342224121,
0.043068576604127884,
-0.961728572845459,
0.49622902274131775,
-0.3461236357688904,
-0.1540534496307373,
0.07653756439685822,
-0.03604521229863167,
-0.04560388997197151,
0.560653805732727,
-0.14161857962608337,
0.5724759101867676,
-0.5074090361595154,
0.4609438478946686,
-0.581443190574646,
-0.8488115668296814,
0.5566885471343994,
-0.5460132956504822,
1.0780527591705322,
0.2272205948829651,
-0.4075678288936615,
0.21494849026203156,
-0.5659369230270386,
-0.11253718286752701,
0.24720226228237152,
-0.10987278819084167,
-0.21428847312927246,
0.02967824973165989,
-0.576907753944397,
0.3655504286289215,
0.15525700151920319,
-0.6545907258987427,
-0.17467592656612396,
-0.45445922017097473,
0.45787227153778076,
0.6540188193321228,
-0.02404414489865303,
0.5400457978248596,
-0.39824262261390686,
0.5407119393348694,
-0.12758579850196838,
0.1315578818321228,
-0.19499880075454712,
-0.5338859558105469,
-0.677753210067749,
-0.46628338098526,
0.2934481203556061,
0.2239001989364624,
-0.4540218710899353,
0.010990770533680916,
-0.6488400101661682,
-0.534878671169281,
-0.38794153928756714,
0.314073383808136,
0.34251663088798523,
0.232996866106987,
-0.13454364240169525,
-0.14991402626037598,
-0.5820575952529907,
-1.2273688316345215,
-0.40069445967674255,
-0.4417062997817993,
-0.1465824991464615,
0.33731570839881897,
0.5496694445610046,
0.0042922766879200935,
1.2229527235031128,
-0.14872820675373077,
0.26335617899894714,
-0.7454930543899536,
0.1946031153202057,
0.46506229043006897,
0.15783628821372986,
0.6645726561546326,
-0.5237663388252258,
-0.3726132810115814,
-0.16425538063049316,
-0.663322925567627,
-0.12419603765010834,
-0.25602665543556213,
-0.06740100681781769,
0.32159003615379333,
0.15124264359474182,
-0.5871159434318542,
0.7357545495033264,
0.5063231587409973,
-0.35110148787498474,
0.6465368270874023,
-0.4990091621875763,
-0.1414169818162918,
-0.41790199279785156,
-0.38047298789024353,
-0.07185156643390656,
-0.37522539496421814,
-0.6942497491836548,
-0.043760333210229874,
-0.0346885621547699,
0.2576155662536621,
-0.5837554931640625,
0.4948381185531616,
-0.638041615486145,
-0.3504628539085388,
-0.5644705295562744,
0.42009034752845764,
0.22625260055065155,
0.21997039020061493,
-0.051760077476501465,
0.5749255418777466,
0.5523595809936523,
-1.0070440769195557,
0.11700067669153214,
-0.00794224813580513,
-0.24792857468128204,
0.05836553871631622,
-1.0342063903808594,
-0.29074662923812866,
-0.30878114700317383,
0.502596378326416,
-1.3500261306762695,
-0.39767131209373474,
-0.21979489922523499,
-0.6945366859436035,
0.1993141621351242,
-0.20976947247982025,
-0.5463650226593018,
-0.28632852435112,
-0.6146088242530823,
0.181319460272789,
0.6143045425415039,
-0.7145203351974487,
0.5443271398544312,
-0.23793527483940125,
0.022084156051278114,
-0.33801722526550293,
-0.9388507008552551,
-0.12133539468050003,
-0.48785650730133057,
-1.1266130208969116,
0.28182631731033325,
-0.3096717894077301,
-0.7636672258377075,
-0.34437042474746704,
-0.3331280052661896,
-0.3596728444099426,
0.4729461371898651,
0.569424569606781,
0.3439437747001648,
-0.4579203724861145,
0.21024416387081146,
-0.10354169458150864,
0.2843833863735199,
0.2753347158432007,
0.11546231061220169,
0.4581112265586853,
-0.26632773876190186,
0.13134172558784485,
-0.7593123316764832,
-0.20183607935905457,
0.6353359222412109,
0.2112237811088562,
1.3815088272094727,
0.11950954794883728,
0.007855609990656376,
-0.0756840631365776,
-0.33723586797714233,
-0.10494419932365417,
-0.4374440014362335,
-0.10218826681375504,
-0.29724615812301636,
-0.805552065372467,
0.6009590029716492,
0.32617178559303284,
0.03635049983859062,
0.6747558116912842,
0.5208427309989929,
-0.02056668885052204,
0.9314867854118347,
0.26799023151397705,
0.29109901189804077,
0.26144298911094666,
-0.0794948935508728,
0.22332383692264557,
-0.8562074303627014,
0.06155778095126152,
-0.42696741223335266,
-0.18752706050872803,
-0.5104747414588928,
-0.5186141133308411,
-0.29464808106422424,
0.3230762481689453,
-0.5245311856269836,
0.22165028750896454,
-0.17042681574821472,
0.45901256799697876,
0.2447197437286377,
-0.13970448076725006,
0.33760425448417664,
-0.07060755789279938,
0.2963353991508484,
0.08059199154376984,
-0.8810389041900635,
-0.5713399648666382,
0.803031325340271,
0.6306403279304504,
0.7330927848815918,
0.40409278869628906,
0.5156762003898621,
0.04689338803291321,
0.23597273230552673,
-0.7102720141410828,
0.39962124824523926,
0.08245493471622467,
-1.0674816370010376,
-0.5048390030860901,
-0.33601677417755127,
-0.9788344502449036,
0.5966731905937195,
-0.12193861603736877,
-0.9014728665351868,
0.21466010808944702,
0.4702757000923157,
-0.5311616063117981,
0.13739408552646637,
-0.6679761409759521,
0.6486856341362,
-0.31120556592941284,
-0.5907657146453857,
-0.3241402804851532,
-0.6144358515739441,
0.6413727402687073,
-0.09582313150167465,
0.4099755585193634,
-0.3008669912815094,
0.24386721849441528,
0.5923053026199341,
-0.5364643335342407,
0.8232800364494324,
-0.20907552540302277,
-0.2572307884693146,
0.5555635690689087,
0.47170618176460266,
0.35348987579345703,
0.1161540299654007,
-0.363818496465683,
0.2161811888217926,
-0.18271885812282562,
-0.4465668499469757,
-0.6655867099761963,
0.8032933473587036,
-0.6163949370384216,
-0.8597685098648071,
-0.23687255382537842,
-0.6048868894577026,
0.0346059687435627,
-0.15748971700668335,
0.15624885261058807,
0.37603622674942017,
-0.01480623334646225,
0.5721232891082764,
0.8584632277488708,
-0.5515658855438232,
0.5646187663078308,
0.6998056173324585,
-0.3201192319393158,
0.16086411476135254,
0.6987833976745605,
0.252354234457016,
0.5612437129020691,
0.06033443287014961,
0.3309745490550995,
-0.08199621737003326,
-0.9616953730583191,
-0.3483649492263794,
0.5698785781860352,
-0.5595782995223999,
0.20936062932014465,
-0.4146665036678314,
-0.0917593389749527,
-0.4210187792778015,
-0.3177218437194824,
-0.26747390627861023,
-0.815258264541626,
-0.4638846814632416,
-0.3339858949184418,
0.47219911217689514,
0.8728706240653992,
0.047671105712652206,
0.7396016120910645,
-0.4427609443664551,
0.2506199777126312,
0.28603193163871765,
0.37192174792289734,
0.28065744042396545,
-1.2711021900177002,
-0.1580154299736023,
0.18495652079582214,
-0.07573547214269638,
-1.0231022834777832,
0.35568010807037354,
0.11023140698671341,
0.4260932207107544,
0.5915070176124573,
-0.041874635964632034,
0.7553126215934753,
-0.29473963379859924,
0.9055854082107544,
0.016910605132579803,
-0.9652227163314819,
0.5015284419059753,
-0.5916935801506042,
0.4238504469394684,
0.3109385073184967,
0.2844047546386719,
-0.11334861814975739,
-0.4259853661060333,
-0.6412338614463806,
-0.9115140438079834,
0.9474020600318909,
0.43913358449935913,
0.08820367604494095,
-0.025378305464982986,
0.804637610912323,
0.2368156462907791,
-0.036436520516872406,
-0.9361466765403748,
-0.25471436977386475,
-0.030895669013261795,
0.06563366204500198,
-0.12465039640665054,
-0.7764520645141602,
0.3217301070690155,
-0.06364414095878601,
0.9701457023620605,
0.13055600225925446,
0.18069513142108917,
0.35419538617134094,
-0.48343944549560547,
-0.09463393688201904,
0.3890276849269867,
0.6941019892692566,
1.2381826639175415,
-0.4852580428123474,
0.18773604929447174,
0.16587257385253906,
-0.19042620062828064,
-0.009314415045082569,
-0.16984772682189941,
0.17309121787548065,
0.13312403857707977,
0.900242030620575,
0.8741910457611084,
0.005689837969839573,
-0.6177202463150024,
0.6125591397285461,
-0.25390878319740295,
-0.4474749267101288,
-0.452016681432724,
0.2554282248020172,
0.029990246519446373,
0.17421498894691467,
0.23681850731372833,
-0.45771172642707825,
0.12521369755268097,
-0.6955402493476868,
-0.5430658459663391,
0.5002605319023132,
-0.6078456044197083,
-0.4127618968486786,
0.508857786655426,
-0.11445440351963043,
-0.0038759110029786825,
0.5237550139427185,
-0.01816587895154953,
-0.15222522616386414,
0.8110863566398621,
0.4741477370262146,
0.46660247445106506,
-0.2317582070827484,
0.49791258573532104,
0.35210472345352173,
0.5138965845108032,
-0.19829367101192474,
0.160328671336174,
0.04524514451622963,
-0.725365400314331,
-0.6938961744308472,
-0.42933082580566406,
-0.098269023001194,
0.39228901267051697,
-0.6528074145317078,
-0.06356238573789597,
-0.5132573246955872,
0.1640826165676117,
0.3115271329879761,
-0.25164398550987244,
-0.6045944690704346,
0.33802056312561035,
0.13379278779029846,
0.8814563155174255,
-0.9462522864341736,
0.6217362880706787,
0.3343442380428314,
-0.3835112452507019,
-0.9047645330429077,
-0.1675480455160141,
0.10449487715959549,
-0.659125804901123,
0.9120792746543884,
0.3319820165634155,
-0.2981047034263611,
-0.6412054300308228,
-0.558738112449646,
-1.038438081741333,
1.2309181690216064,
0.6557859182357788,
-0.3597832918167114,
-0.07693052291870117,
-0.004368165973573923,
0.7145876288414001,
-0.37887564301490784,
0.27616551518440247,
0.6910472512245178,
0.32968592643737793,
0.14612849056720734,
-1.067395567893982,
0.07525932788848877,
0.35603469610214233,
0.24181194603443146,
0.037766918540000916,
-0.36878812313079834,
0.9580461978912354,
-0.34450212121009827,
-0.07891010493040085,
0.12966088950634003,
0.48155587911605835,
0.40970873832702637,
0.26370659470558167,
0.5627242922782898,
0.16123788058757782,
0.6070064902305603,
0.10117574036121368,
1.5675755739212036,
0.02982350066304207,
0.10679522901773453,
1.3526026010513306,
-0.38645726442337036,
0.6061123013496399,
0.414846807718277,
-0.01944798417389393,
0.8935072422027588,
0.7928490042686462,
0.3702763319015503,
0.29229071736335754,
0.43985310196876526,
-0.08157602697610855,
-0.36767199635505676,
-0.014352201484143734,
-0.11426495015621185,
0.5981250405311584,
0.35704442858695984,
-0.8453434109687805,
-0.17142891883850098,
-0.2643197178840637,
-0.03082738257944584,
-0.20788173377513885,
-0.6385843753814697,
0.5706710815429688,
0.008153516799211502,
-0.6229736804962158,
0.7258257269859314,
0.05746683105826378,
0.2032928466796875,
-0.34459468722343445,
0.0063149272464215755,
-0.12975867092609406,
0.29358989000320435,
-0.15820220112800598,
-0.6749722361564636,
0.36816203594207764,
-0.1141863614320755,
-0.44662296772003174,
-0.10868437588214874,
0.7932896018028259,
0.01924142986536026,
-0.16275885701179504,
0.4594738185405731,
0.4084194600582123,
0.5461387634277344,
-0.31741106510162354,
-0.327037513256073,
-0.08262751996517181,
0.08520198613405228,
-0.20532001554965973,
0.22676166892051697,
0.5884352922439575,
-0.3425634205341339,
0.6962419152259827,
0.2239307314157486,
-0.046008188277482986,
0.05806034430861473,
-0.1546955555677414,
0.45534729957580566,
-0.570942759513855,
-0.07129823416471481,
-1.27933931350708,
0.33942389488220215,
0.06225070729851723,
0.14603647589683533,
1.077306866645813,
0.5052217841148376,
0.3375980854034424,
-0.08198533207178116,
0.6488568186759949,
0.26298171281814575,
0.5499463677406311,
-0.42607933282852173,
0.3246028423309326,
-0.5381903648376465,
0.4181864261627197,
-0.21599552035331726,
-0.9847415685653687,
-0.08199453353881836,
0.5989740490913391,
-0.4569198489189148,
0.021656159311532974,
0.7370246052742004,
0.469343900680542,
0.15872254967689514,
0.173470601439476,
0.41422441601753235,
0.7204279899597168,
0.08111780881881714,
0.3129410147666931,
0.8427741527557373,
0.0543241873383522,
0.5886304378509521,
0.03573065996170044,
-0.1375402808189392,
-0.45318251848220825,
-1.0328365564346313,
-0.9128775000572205,
-0.10109993815422058,
-0.3589341342449188,
-0.3356633484363556,
-0.027537362650036812,
0.451020210981369,
0.6764805316925049,
-0.5294148325920105,
-0.06737563759088516,
-0.3008088767528534,
0.3227814733982086,
0.048922739923000336,
-0.24701057374477386,
0.20110607147216797,
0.04974636435508728,
-0.1419447362422943,
0.28404486179351807,
0.3260754644870758,
0.24314333498477936,
-0.15271154046058655,
-0.09571892023086548,
-0.21157856285572052,
0.6213280558586121,
0.6693299412727356,
0.15382835268974304,
-1.10557222366333,
-0.31935083866119385,
-0.1685350388288498,
0.2873162627220154,
-0.0005378053174354136,
0.7727257013320923,
-0.8605276942253113,
0.4135496914386749,
0.42064982652664185,
0.17889274656772614,
0.563829243183136,
-0.10482589900493622,
0.7271155714988708,
-0.6501889228820801,
0.1231086477637291,
-0.2522180378437042,
0.5255070924758911,
0.4610097408294678,
-0.4389227330684662,
0.5028650164604187,
-0.2787435054779053,
-0.5208555459976196,
-0.7808670997619629,
0.2632206678390503,
-0.878902792930603,
-0.8166052103042603,
1.3437873125076294,
-0.23428018391132355,
-0.18831419944763184,
-0.2738841772079468,
-0.12178231030702591,
0.28104013204574585,
-0.10538027435541153,
0.5306096076965332,
1.1812604665756226,
-0.33362001180648804,
-0.04226560890674591,
-0.8928283452987671,
0.2979170083999634,
0.3552279472351074,
-0.46202313899993896,
0.5864525437355042,
0.687335729598999,
0.4533013105392456,
0.11231040209531784,
0.6407184600830078,
-0.07971545308828354,
0.5559366941452026,
-0.2291806936264038,
-0.22454476356506348,
0.10718083381652832,
-0.36384040117263794,
-0.7606134414672852,
-0.11098011583089828,
0.5896092653274536,
0.1262066662311554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05347v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05347v1
|
Benchmarking Educational Program Repair
| 2024-05-08T18:23:59 | 2024-05-08T18:23:59 |
Charles Koutcheme, Nicola Dainese, Sami Sarsa, Juho Leinonen, Arto Hellas, Paul Denny
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The emergence of large language models (LLMs) has sparked enormous interest
due to their potential application across a range of educational tasks. For
example, recent work in programming education has used LLMs to generate
learning resources, improve error messages, and provide feedback on code.
However, one factor that limits progress within the field is that much of the
research uses bespoke datasets and different evaluation metrics, making direct
comparisons between results unreliable. Thus, there is a pressing need for
standardization and benchmarks that facilitate the equitable comparison of
competing approaches. One task where LLMs show great promise is program repair,
which can be used to provide debugging support and next-step hints to students.
In this article, we propose a novel educational program repair benchmark. We
curate two high-quality publicly available programming datasets, present a
unified evaluation procedure introducing a novel evaluation metric rouge@k for
approximating the quality of repairs, and evaluate a set of five recent models
to establish baseline performance.
|
[
0.1317068189382553,
-0.4293517470359802,
0.36308854818344116,
0.2497147172689438,
0.1152057945728302,
0.7118496894836426,
-0.23049402236938477,
-0.3402366042137146,
0.12762796878814697,
0.635749101638794,
-0.43276381492614746,
-0.4821881055831909,
-0.5658289194107056,
-0.005917037837207317,
-0.32962387800216675,
0.8113407492637634,
-0.07598994672298431,
0.2106046825647354,
-0.40999624133110046,
-0.2296571582555771,
-0.6945288181304932,
-0.17690658569335938,
-0.8103768825531006,
-0.30758431553840637,
0.22923702001571655,
0.6101721525192261,
0.5229160785675049,
0.7633609771728516,
0.7147902250289917,
0.3190214931964874,
0.2837405502796173,
-0.0827736034989357,
-0.7204297780990601,
-0.07611750066280365,
-0.07612010836601257,
-0.33639973402023315,
-0.6224833130836487,
-0.03573485091328621,
0.7022600769996643,
1.022178053855896,
-0.14488057792186737,
0.29834121465682983,
0.26288947463035583,
0.9092332124710083,
-0.8818111419677734,
0.11424019187688828,
-0.6294249296188354,
-0.05873061716556549,
-0.019933629781007767,
0.03246604651212692,
-0.26196497678756714,
-0.8511040210723877,
-0.46773794293403625,
-0.36531901359558105,
0.014224370941519737,
-0.3000592291355133,
0.49149563908576965,
0.4380140006542206,
-0.2711849510669708,
0.054539237171411514,
-0.5523058772087097,
0.8793094158172607,
-0.935562014579773,
0.3072338104248047,
0.24739018082618713,
0.5253859162330627,
-0.33581507205963135,
-0.6041744351387024,
0.019934920594096184,
-0.21978598833084106,
0.25195983052253723,
0.07973384112119675,
0.006379786413162947,
-0.1340709775686264,
0.3504177927970886,
0.5817208290100098,
-0.5083261728286743,
0.2794511020183563,
-0.46032002568244934,
-0.2453099638223648,
0.4684355556964874,
0.4877799153327942,
0.24497759342193604,
0.14027029275894165,
-0.4963865578174591,
-0.22330209612846375,
-0.9503132104873657,
0.13169695436954498,
0.4865788221359253,
0.19867955148220062,
-0.049519628286361694,
0.31293439865112305,
-0.22794611752033234,
0.8085103631019592,
-0.6768940687179565,
-0.26386064291000366,
0.26429060101509094,
-0.0820431262254715,
-0.3726465702056885,
-0.2096395194530487,
0.4654221832752228,
0.7776992321014404,
0.37761130928993225,
-0.3170259892940521,
-0.48489707708358765,
0.30248263478279114,
0.2963642179965973,
-0.5960383415222168,
-0.41222986578941345,
-0.1691519320011139,
-0.2389117032289505,
-0.21337765455245972,
-0.09766044467687607,
-0.6442258358001709,
-0.7516474723815918,
-0.565362274646759,
0.43126243352890015,
-0.2056855857372284,
-0.3111399710178375,
0.09285832941532135,
0.0387786366045475,
0.10137934237718582,
0.21032209694385529,
-0.535228431224823,
0.2892628610134125,
0.8043266534805298,
0.7446960806846619,
0.053465358912944794,
-0.3249669373035431,
-0.49292299151420593,
0.00026092087500728667,
-0.5687710642814636,
0.8498759865760803,
-0.9052745699882507,
-0.4841706454753876,
0.09271515905857086,
0.058631137013435364,
0.03598370403051376,
-0.8811725974082947,
0.5790277123451233,
-0.1449069082736969,
-0.3207046687602997,
-0.40831542015075684,
-0.6222274303436279,
0.3227892220020294,
0.40764787793159485,
-0.5356588959693909,
1.3519362211227417,
0.46427658200263977,
-0.5072500109672546,
0.2947899103164673,
-0.13211236894130707,
0.010433356277644634,
0.03030906431376934,
0.02584562636911869,
-0.6412003040313721,
0.08666284382343292,
-0.0961533710360527,
0.21372170746326447,
-0.39547866582870483,
0.3767626881599426,
-0.5977862477302551,
-0.7983434796333313,
0.008085870184004307,
-0.43127402663230896,
0.8113403916358948,
-0.32714763283729553,
-0.1798350214958191,
0.08103009313344955,
-1.1152287721633911,
0.25395846366882324,
-0.03344995528459549,
-0.45774516463279724,
-0.4939958155155182,
-0.17967011034488678,
-0.14436586201190948,
0.06683226674795151,
0.37616825103759766,
-0.6778168082237244,
0.464409202337265,
-0.2510926425457001,
0.22655904293060303,
1.0765447616577148,
-0.18141166865825653,
0.1014423817396164,
-0.33993664383888245,
0.6512708067893982,
-0.27744707465171814,
0.2153020054101944,
-0.31090813875198364,
-0.09180132299661636,
-0.8091861009597778,
-0.35501864552497864,
0.25692835450172424,
0.21068954467773438,
-0.4941521883010864,
-0.08803417533636093,
-0.3158707022666931,
-0.5732171535491943,
-0.6581073999404907,
0.149080291390419,
0.5830716490745544,
0.5567591786384583,
0.4324413239955902,
-0.39603206515312195,
-0.7492600679397583,
-0.8065692782402039,
-0.6211277842521667,
-0.19832715392112732,
-0.272024929523468,
0.28048840165138245,
0.28390440344810486,
-0.17406485974788666,
0.5494627952575684,
-0.5224179625511169,
-0.14727237820625305,
0.06801240146160126,
-0.16304871439933777,
0.21842022240161896,
0.21030746400356293,
0.3798869252204895,
0.15135279297828674,
-0.6385052800178528,
-0.5072887539863586,
-0.43507516384124756,
-0.21077804267406464,
0.25565123558044434,
0.024660207331180573,
0.09876324981451035,
0.5768133401870728,
0.07821048051118851,
0.31586530804634094,
0.6964777112007141,
-0.4370594024658203,
0.8199246525764465,
-0.3774183392524719,
0.5008972883224487,
-0.6672412753105164,
-0.021369369700551033,
-0.2138880491256714,
-0.1666543185710907,
-0.194806307554245,
-0.03927173092961311,
0.2561180293560028,
-0.09009535610675812,
-0.09286942332983017,
0.6695481538772583,
-0.5582973957061768,
-0.2637012004852295,
-0.4056921899318695,
0.283501535654068,
-0.2904289662837982,
0.2051793336868286,
-0.44722428917884827,
0.5050172209739685,
0.7377550601959229,
0.00031878994195722044,
0.47268790006637573,
-0.1452922224998474,
-0.41784772276878357,
0.6659650206565857,
-0.8569451570510864,
0.2595105767250061,
0.20412105321884155,
0.12036917358636856,
-1.019736886024475,
-0.2607419788837433,
0.03927827626466751,
-0.2198854386806488,
0.1512896865606308,
-0.3510873019695282,
-0.40197306871414185,
-0.4774327278137207,
-0.5264381766319275,
0.31290775537490845,
0.470254510641098,
-0.7922480702400208,
0.15999987721443176,
0.23988130688667297,
-0.09205147624015808,
-0.8384758234024048,
-0.09567010402679443,
0.2519040107727051,
-0.04649317264556885,
-0.43761375546455383,
0.03404218330979347,
-0.1548500955104828,
-0.24787290394306183,
-0.035979121923446655,
-0.4577515125274658,
-0.1510591357946396,
0.3708440363407135,
0.45349347591400146,
0.4561094045639038,
-0.31244969367980957,
0.041620466858148575,
-0.2066238522529602,
-0.23740838468074799,
0.17674295604228973,
0.1393277645111084,
0.2457173764705658,
-0.09404003620147705,
-0.6315226554870605,
0.3730941712856293,
-0.1071249321103096,
0.7336564064025879,
-0.2754077911376953,
0.503133237361908,
0.1662459671497345,
-0.40216314792633057,
-0.5312288403511047,
-0.6042225360870361,
-0.24515381455421448,
-0.4623149037361145,
0.4842351973056793,
-0.008839056827127934,
-0.5544645190238953,
0.11530082672834396,
-0.2559598386287689,
0.16930735111236572,
-0.11135630309581757,
0.18561924993991852,
0.1622226983308792,
0.8363244533538818,
0.8557370901107788,
-0.4225102365016937,
0.07073193043470383,
-0.11614327877759933,
0.34099382162094116,
-0.7051059007644653,
-0.35655760765075684,
-0.7616770267486572,
-0.3352358937263489,
-0.03185978904366493,
-0.4130978584289551,
0.06055803969502449,
0.518447756767273,
-0.331383615732193,
0.4917086064815521,
-0.40061646699905396,
0.8689974546432495,
0.4843951463699341,
-0.049802083522081375,
0.4800921380519867,
-0.09244228154420853,
-0.08652479201555252,
-0.029089512303471565,
-0.5146063566207886,
-0.8892937898635864,
1.3216347694396973,
0.35141950845718384,
0.6904886960983276,
0.04099193960428238,
0.8129249811172485,
0.22933101654052734,
0.7957618236541748,
-0.45335453748703003,
0.6763398051261902,
-0.39216533303260803,
-0.16505683958530426,
-0.5587365627288818,
-0.34142613410949707,
-0.8967854976654053,
-0.08708859235048294,
0.03242861106991768,
-0.834892749786377,
-0.36204925179481506,
0.2390054166316986,
-0.08123636245727539,
0.45718440413475037,
-0.37912705540657043,
1.0857092142105103,
-0.11476846039295197,
-0.350046843290329,
-0.3774838447570801,
-0.33288562297821045,
0.3666200339794159,
-0.11772029101848602,
0.16448743641376495,
-0.4595417082309723,
0.21045713126659393,
0.6593804955482483,
-0.6557314991950989,
0.7282583117485046,
-0.28813040256500244,
-0.14511863887310028,
0.007796136196702719,
0.04789488762617111,
0.2875420153141022,
0.08958198875188828,
-0.14127539098262787,
0.09036386013031006,
0.056138187646865845,
-0.5138156414031982,
-0.4970606863498688,
1.107340693473816,
-0.5817062854766846,
-0.42849987745285034,
-0.2532760500907898,
-0.6240424513816833,
-0.6250362396240234,
-0.13250476121902466,
-0.32678425312042236,
0.6807083487510681,
-0.20465801656246185,
0.16449947655200958,
0.4524686336517334,
-0.25514981150627136,
0.6642581820487976,
1.0581375360488892,
-0.005041882861405611,
-0.08754809945821762,
1.0181703567504883,
-0.0714975893497467,
0.045578017830848694,
0.07294388860464096,
-0.10207650065422058,
-0.06392500549554825,
-0.27738818526268005,
-0.42201370000839233,
0.08092741668224335,
-0.7950380444526672,
-0.4938369393348694,
-0.2732459604740143,
-0.1460707038640976,
-0.16085411608219147,
-0.36618995666503906,
-0.6010835766792297,
-0.4533361494541168,
0.16701635718345642,
-0.0938049703836441,
0.06288374215364456,
0.6714714765548706,
-0.053648754954338074,
-0.043404724448919296,
-0.788877010345459,
0.20551446080207825,
0.17617376148700714,
0.9799433946609497,
0.15756304562091827,
-0.4491889476776123,
-0.45819026231765747,
0.03348240628838539,
-0.4968709647655487,
-0.518729031085968,
-0.11015312373638153,
0.1620316058397293,
0.6917299628257751,
0.16800586879253387,
0.07948847115039825,
0.5214831829071045,
-0.6142680644989014,
0.7285887598991394,
0.27770355343818665,
-0.6741058826446533,
0.5284200310707092,
-0.0994386300444603,
0.3953230679035187,
0.5161964297294617,
0.1406395137310028,
-0.5961591601371765,
-0.7522107362747192,
-0.5876644849777222,
-0.9110594987869263,
0.39238619804382324,
-0.302487850189209,
0.06111879646778107,
-0.08891033381223679,
0.05611144378781319,
0.16737227141857147,
-0.060923393815755844,
-0.36700162291526794,
-0.339756578207016,
-0.1431325227022171,
-0.3107004463672638,
-0.31209796667099,
-0.17436547577381134,
-0.09963510185480118,
0.016556669026613235,
0.9091982245445251,
0.062155939638614655,
-0.1790088564157486,
-0.5873876214027405,
-0.18956312537193298,
-0.11927811801433563,
0.3793725371360779,
0.3368188142776489,
0.9491062164306641,
-0.13772675395011902,
-0.019117681309580803,
0.03830956295132637,
-0.3496609330177307,
0.3963879644870758,
-0.029869144782423973,
0.10775020718574524,
0.046963661909103394,
0.5560404658317566,
0.5262467265129089,
0.5931416749954224,
-0.9601913094520569,
0.5475896596908569,
0.022155774757266045,
0.28037703037261963,
-0.17599153518676758,
0.4151049554347992,
0.182714581489563,
0.29624009132385254,
0.22972321510314941,
0.038850847631692886,
0.036396849900484085,
-0.6516054272651672,
0.17996281385421753,
0.4050961434841156,
-0.48545801639556885,
-0.3475550413131714,
0.6136541962623596,
0.22724120318889618,
-0.6119878888130188,
0.8557214736938477,
0.2591574788093567,
-0.33189693093299866,
0.8919634819030762,
0.4196989834308624,
0.9095480442047119,
-0.41300567984580994,
0.4965408742427826,
0.821973979473114,
0.19385570287704468,
-0.2777787744998932,
0.1683768332004547,
0.17849965393543243,
-0.41987186670303345,
-0.2561423182487488,
-0.6611915826797485,
-0.45031261444091797,
0.3454204499721527,
-0.6916530132293701,
0.3109375238418579,
-0.4476763904094696,
0.007750286255031824,
-0.22620350122451782,
-0.0874306857585907,
-0.5461007952690125,
0.4307693541049957,
-0.06438349187374115,
1.012380599975586,
-1.166722059249878,
0.7690779566764832,
0.7285617589950562,
-0.3745197355747223,
-0.904820442199707,
-0.06198756396770477,
-0.023397231474518776,
-0.6959385275840759,
0.5504867434501648,
0.12380409240722656,
-0.015668515115976334,
-0.22852621972560883,
-0.2931820750236511,
-0.6967380046844482,
0.7270074486732483,
0.6523798108100891,
-0.9850447177886963,
0.05405163764953613,
0.36536598205566406,
0.6922983527183533,
-0.06050095334649086,
0.45731914043426514,
0.7036431431770325,
0.3769894540309906,
-0.24239550530910492,
-0.9057870507240295,
-0.028638994321227074,
-0.2554363012313843,
-0.11092957854270935,
0.4612921178340912,
-0.488660991191864,
0.45638126134872437,
-0.34727153182029724,
0.18774637579917908,
0.21214348077774048,
0.27106547355651855,
0.37747231125831604,
0.3674026131629944,
0.36040544509887695,
0.7327632308006287,
0.7151215672492981,
-0.394194096326828,
0.8154225945472717,
-0.5561821460723877,
0.5017789602279663,
1.573878526687622,
0.006146382540464401,
0.7672991156578064,
0.3005863428115845,
-0.502832293510437,
0.3307648003101349,
0.5237237811088562,
-0.34540390968322754,
0.4571147859096527,
0.6477622985839844,
-0.2769446074962616,
-0.23267753422260284,
0.1462320238351822,
-0.40841007232666016,
0.17882196605205536,
-0.0407923199236393,
-0.26008328795433044,
-0.40040525794029236,
-0.16253264248371124,
-0.14738720655441284,
0.26494166254997253,
-0.5036721229553223,
0.4403858184814453,
0.0607016384601593,
-0.579362154006958,
0.6900252103805542,
0.05606863647699356,
0.10907009243965149,
-0.3732549548149109,
-0.34380877017974854,
-0.7449617981910706,
0.5992550849914551,
-0.24163316190242767,
-0.6441227793693542,
0.2796917259693146,
-0.013760338537395,
-0.22430050373077393,
0.04888001084327698,
0.5685408711433411,
-0.424405962228775,
-0.5677983164787292,
0.5526139736175537,
0.10433606803417206,
0.15286602079868317,
0.1305241584777832,
-0.5130515694618225,
0.4095134139060974,
-0.13964717090129852,
0.005203861277550459,
0.4902280569076538,
0.18909066915512085,
-0.0898989737033844,
0.8919945955276489,
0.08022025227546692,
0.18935053050518036,
0.1812269687652588,
0.41578415036201477,
0.6674495339393616,
-0.25045350193977356,
0.1060793474316597,
-0.681715190410614,
0.7571943402290344,
-0.12586194276809692,
-0.36813151836395264,
1.014304757118225,
0.8432070016860962,
1.0311875343322754,
-0.24461081624031067,
0.7498230338096619,
0.2650589644908905,
0.6150122880935669,
-0.31995493173599243,
0.3968088626861572,
-0.4093793034553528,
0.7256725430488586,
-0.5790173411369324,
-1.2936439514160156,
-0.01676635816693306,
0.3380882441997528,
-0.07638268917798996,
-0.0426279716193676,
0.5171511173248291,
1.0765522718429565,
-0.14912152290344238,
-0.1696854531764984,
0.5636129379272461,
0.2878590524196625,
0.07728233188390732,
0.6158833503723145,
0.7980237603187561,
-0.523661196231842,
0.47431281208992004,
-0.19072315096855164,
-0.39614686369895935,
-0.08275796473026276,
-0.870272696018219,
-0.8464000225067139,
-0.32709792256355286,
-0.8484469652175903,
-0.4020267128944397,
0.4727157950401306,
0.6977339386940002,
0.28902313113212585,
-0.8063116669654846,
-0.22525078058242798,
0.08950094878673553,
0.03301357105374336,
-0.35200241208076477,
-0.16715265810489655,
0.4365067780017853,
-0.43949300050735474,
-0.5472018718719482,
0.691052258014679,
0.3230050504207611,
-0.40734419226646423,
-0.3050205409526825,
-0.0978977233171463,
0.4507090747356415,
0.17382819950580597,
0.3675825893878937,
0.40947675704956055,
-0.5409068465232849,
-0.5400441288948059,
-0.13500720262527466,
-0.09241745620965958,
-0.008352062664926052,
1.0636780261993408,
-0.7714147567749023,
0.42096105217933655,
0.17557813227176666,
0.7871012687683105,
0.10467427968978882,
-0.32428064942359924,
0.5098069906234741,
-0.7183343172073364,
-0.27529582381248474,
0.07214287668466568,
0.46786367893218994,
0.5519258975982666,
0.1008659079670906,
0.6929079294204712,
0.10950019210577011,
-0.7075663805007935,
-1.1104103326797485,
-0.001766547211445868,
-0.33262836933135986,
-0.30583930015563965,
0.8727562427520752,
-0.5735316276550293,
0.2528744339942932,
-0.0026610475033521652,
-0.003179663559421897,
0.1139405146241188,
0.133828803896904,
1.1788315773010254,
0.6940799355506897,
0.2741302251815796,
-0.0320681594312191,
-0.38107454776763916,
0.22045333683490753,
0.17431294918060303,
-0.729945182800293,
0.2965102791786194,
0.6837239265441895,
0.7706684470176697,
-0.2651832699775696,
0.6370331645011902,
-0.20864102244377136,
0.1723843663930893,
0.09952832758426666,
0.047464288771152496,
-0.0947108119726181,
-0.5882735252380371,
-0.14559301733970642,
0.15650314092636108,
0.17182336747646332,
0.05613236501812935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05345v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05345v1
|
QuaLLM: An LLM-based Framework to Extract Quantitative Insights from Online Forums
| 2024-05-08T18:20:03 | 2024-05-08T18:20:03 |
Varun Nagaraj Rao, Eesha Agarwal, Samantha Dalal, Dan Calacci, Andrés Monroy-Hernández
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Online discussion forums provide crucial data to understand the concerns of a
wide range of real-world communities. However, the typical qualitative and
quantitative methods used to analyze those data, such as thematic analysis and
topic modeling, are infeasible to scale or require significant human effort to
translate outputs to human readable forms. This study introduces QuaLLM, a
novel LLM-based framework to analyze and extract quantitative insights from
text data on online forums. The framework consists of a novel prompting
methodology and evaluation strategy. We applied this framework to analyze over
one million comments from two Reddit's rideshare worker communities, marking
the largest study of its type. We uncover significant worker concerns regarding
AI and algorithmic platform decisions, responding to regulatory calls about
worker insights. In short, our work sets a new precedent for AI-assisted
quantitative data analysis to surface concerns from online forums.
|
[
-0.45213738083839417,
-0.6562821865081787,
0.7003121376037598,
0.42515894770622253,
-0.3485957086086273,
0.25459614396095276,
0.0966603234410286,
-0.5274483561515808,
0.3033159673213959,
0.14169277250766754,
-0.7675061225891113,
-0.4634995460510254,
-0.3396250009536743,
0.13509663939476013,
-0.6610010266304016,
0.7779824137687683,
0.3270062208175659,
0.06235478073358536,
-0.522685706615448,
-0.3072045147418976,
-0.13475218415260315,
-0.5262494087219238,
-0.8650109767913818,
0.07182431221008301,
0.9093291759490967,
0.31888511776924133,
0.4036787748336792,
0.4860702157020569,
0.6247614622116089,
0.3385974168777466,
-0.11394040286540985,
0.29587337374687195,
-0.7598247528076172,
0.0034032107796519995,
-0.048568129539489746,
-0.6531757116317749,
-0.41303426027297974,
-0.0160537026822567,
0.4141824543476105,
0.5551285147666931,
-0.23363128304481506,
0.4920147955417633,
0.04611286148428917,
0.5951713919639587,
-0.6528375148773193,
0.15811575949192047,
-0.5086291432380676,
-0.0056581050157547,
0.019321009516716003,
-0.37886956334114075,
-0.17415404319763184,
-0.9029150009155273,
-0.22896265983581543,
-0.7237840294837952,
-0.05379839614033699,
0.19142913818359375,
0.4379536509513855,
0.24489277601242065,
-0.43655648827552795,
-0.35474538803100586,
-0.6725437641143799,
0.9298006892204285,
-0.9350136518478394,
-0.005123411770910025,
0.42274585366249084,
0.46083158254623413,
-0.039750076830387115,
-0.8955645561218262,
-0.5565050840377808,
0.29576194286346436,
-0.22662143409252167,
-0.025241967290639877,
-0.1525413691997528,
0.016318656504154205,
0.21657204627990723,
0.30947595834732056,
-0.5083579421043396,
0.08909095078706741,
-0.4612691104412079,
0.011392464861273766,
0.725942850112915,
0.4385533332824707,
0.2906639873981476,
-0.06732934713363647,
-0.3456059992313385,
0.044392868876457214,
-0.4657936096191406,
0.03051770105957985,
0.16366562247276306,
-0.025578169152140617,
-0.20956340432167053,
0.4225597679615021,
-0.26438117027282715,
0.3264223337173462,
-0.0012199709890410304,
-0.15612132847309113,
0.15904095768928528,
-0.14892639219760895,
0.09283732622861862,
0.03243383765220642,
0.8041988611221313,
0.8745724558830261,
0.043468840420246124,
-0.023100661113858223,
-0.07641749829053879,
-0.09136886149644852,
0.08151094615459442,
-0.8676652312278748,
-0.10902097821235657,
0.6791707873344421,
-0.8619356155395508,
-0.47348469495773315,
0.5214901566505432,
-0.927638590335846,
-0.7796362638473511,
-0.1702079176902771,
0.11600548028945923,
0.0943998396396637,
-0.5252683162689209,
-0.1727549284696579,
-0.3129592537879944,
0.344333291053772,
0.46700403094291687,
-0.4006270468235016,
0.17833049595355988,
1.027084231376648,
1.0448585748672485,
-0.4083614647388458,
0.12235364317893982,
-0.5595220923423767,
0.06395385414361954,
0.02548760175704956,
1.1171677112579346,
-0.553899347782135,
-0.3188643753528595,
0.3746269643306732,
-0.1650015115737915,
0.17429500818252563,
-0.5098830461502075,
0.22621773183345795,
-0.811219334602356,
0.31794360280036926,
-0.31857335567474365,
-0.7003594636917114,
-0.2548994719982147,
0.5900132656097412,
-0.7243555188179016,
1.1401537656784058,
0.2253882735967636,
-1.1029280424118042,
0.3591660261154175,
-0.8380961418151855,
-0.1876259297132492,
0.25150564312934875,
-0.39376136660575867,
-0.21707573533058167,
0.11980559676885605,
0.12642338871955872,
0.2611011862754822,
-0.42175766825675964,
0.17170709371566772,
-0.5343803763389587,
-0.47000834345817566,
0.9030151963233948,
-0.22856299579143524,
0.9217082262039185,
0.23934471607208252,
-0.3847907483577728,
0.508198618888855,
-0.6790116429328918,
0.22674480080604553,
-0.20460544526576996,
-0.19300179183483124,
-0.3547910153865814,
0.2810218632221222,
-0.1253347247838974,
0.20368969440460205,
0.31544965505599976,
-0.4634474217891693,
-0.19442670047283173,
-0.5349942445755005,
0.7443214058876038,
0.837948739528656,
0.43268173933029175,
0.3396093547344208,
-0.6057378649711609,
0.8690617084503174,
-0.2110365331172943,
0.4208280146121979,
0.047558680176734924,
-0.4285861551761627,
-0.7548211812973022,
-0.11742821335792542,
0.055055614560842514,
0.3939565420150757,
-0.6188063025474548,
0.08802188187837601,
-0.08289093524217606,
-0.3890819251537323,
-0.5912072062492371,
-0.0793968066573143,
0.06677215546369553,
0.1390203833580017,
0.10534338653087616,
-0.07586634159088135,
-0.4540148973464966,
-0.7183812260627747,
-0.2749861776828766,
-0.5113366842269897,
-0.23729567229747772,
0.12412520498037338,
0.12800279259681702,
-0.3731275498867035,
1.2257128953933716,
-0.5839568376541138,
0.05408088117837906,
-0.13636115193367004,
0.4885217249393463,
-0.03922467678785324,
0.1694936603307724,
0.15710552036762238,
-0.7369124889373779,
-0.6712672114372253,
0.0180316474288702,
-0.8564164638519287,
-0.31624868512153625,
-0.34923055768013,
-0.351652055978775,
-0.26618632674217224,
0.7214359045028687,
-0.6619383096694946,
0.2655969560146332,
0.2164088785648346,
0.06655467301607132,
0.3140872120857239,
0.22324585914611816,
0.20605216920375824,
-0.9746084213256836,
0.15027418732643127,
-0.07970025390386581,
-0.35773611068725586,
-0.47276571393013,
-0.02169656567275524,
-0.09937049448490143,
0.04711852967739105,
-0.609812319278717,
0.47109025716781616,
-0.14872033894062042,
-0.09137707203626633,
-0.520168125629425,
0.35625600814819336,
-0.0135048134252429,
0.2519049346446991,
-0.47059133648872375,
0.657984733581543,
-0.07017223536968231,
-0.617620050907135,
0.38858819007873535,
0.31921902298927307,
-0.16025348007678986,
0.5637812614440918,
-0.6308707594871521,
0.49976515769958496,
-0.10548354685306549,
-0.00397493364289403,
-1.0883663892745972,
-0.221917062997818,
0.40968114137649536,
-0.6683220267295837,
-0.36606308817863464,
0.15278330445289612,
-0.4084376394748688,
-0.17920364439487457,
-0.8774987459182739,
0.5345703959465027,
0.13607729971408844,
-0.1318875551223755,
0.7127648591995239,
0.9380797743797302,
-0.5324418544769287,
-0.1517086923122406,
-0.40237435698509216,
-0.0008507882594130933,
-0.5831172466278076,
-0.39128202199935913,
0.04515402391552925,
-0.1516655832529068,
-0.8603578209877014,
-0.0007106047123670578,
0.1252691149711609,
-0.4398081302642822,
0.21856221556663513,
0.4451899528503418,
0.07162576168775558,
-0.11586550623178482,
0.09832961857318878,
0.18225492537021637,
-0.3580074906349182,
0.7207555770874023,
0.01029971893876791,
0.45049339532852173,
0.05026066303253174,
-0.19069598615169525,
-0.684506893157959,
0.49366462230682373,
0.4088992774486542,
0.021261822432279587,
0.6273314952850342,
0.7296753525733948,
-0.3721114695072174,
-0.1999605894088745,
-0.5259425044059753,
-0.4258163869380951,
-0.5817311406135559,
0.14481496810913086,
0.2956395149230957,
-1.3613064289093018,
0.42055457830429077,
-0.4505424499511719,
0.2579360008239746,
0.5493302941322327,
0.5970685482025146,
-0.48355329036712646,
1.3373616933822632,
0.791828989982605,
-0.11538969725370407,
0.4129505455493927,
0.1374521106481552,
0.1670556515455246,
-0.22336457669734955,
-0.3217542767524719,
-0.6978470683097839,
-0.4500479996204376,
-0.4953868091106415,
-0.35517603158950806,
0.48541656136512756,
-0.2597017288208008,
-0.026525916531682014,
-0.19607530534267426,
-0.27960169315338135,
0.45064595341682434,
0.4240945279598236,
0.0396936796605587,
0.48594194650650024,
-0.11338513344526291,
0.31249526143074036,
-0.22893445193767548,
-0.7107162475585938,
-0.6546595692634583,
0.5680234432220459,
0.2822384238243103,
0.4735797643661499,
-0.00006741224933648482,
0.2561388611793518,
0.810092568397522,
0.7155806422233582,
-0.835422933101654,
0.7100746631622314,
0.35144758224487305,
-0.5929973125457764,
-0.26104244589805603,
-0.8662930130958557,
-0.8167799115180969,
0.20963531732559204,
-0.2929523289203644,
-0.3690311908721924,
0.1331186145544052,
-0.020935792475938797,
-0.6341148614883423,
0.29272252321243286,
-0.2896522879600525,
0.5369997620582581,
-0.37297019362449646,
-0.15934063494205475,
-0.4710882306098938,
-0.7512426376342773,
0.3006625771522522,
-0.2222604602575302,
0.7259306311607361,
-0.4415428340435028,
-0.17054089903831482,
0.9827576279640198,
-0.47150760889053345,
1.0718979835510254,
-0.233121857047081,
-0.04188522323966026,
0.5199542045593262,
0.013560882769525051,
0.2671724855899811,
0.08574716746807098,
-0.033996496349573135,
0.08876008540391922,
0.3301446735858917,
-0.18133951723575592,
-0.5915425419807434,
0.5324296951293945,
-0.8321836590766907,
-0.26186999678611755,
-0.21233606338500977,
-0.22631683945655823,
-0.3241928815841675,
0.07818428426980972,
0.04240866377949715,
0.21216891705989838,
-0.20504800975322723,
0.16208721697330475,
0.33558982610702515,
-0.26516035199165344,
0.2715667188167572,
0.43619799613952637,
-0.4235542416572571,
-0.6149976253509521,
0.9590961337089539,
-0.1833919733762741,
-0.01984500326216221,
0.4494195878505707,
0.34211140871047974,
-0.4619531035423279,
-0.3656960725784302,
-0.07722577452659607,
0.29418930411338806,
-0.758577823638916,
-0.4604235589504242,
-0.5157251358032227,
0.09114383906126022,
-0.07636673748493195,
-0.03909599781036377,
-0.049308087676763535,
-0.5937035083770752,
-0.5101225972175598,
-0.26508018374443054,
0.46187344193458557,
1.008363127708435,
-0.006244164425879717,
0.6713246703147888,
-1.1996960639953613,
0.1068815067410469,
0.4038255214691162,
0.17264148592948914,
0.22065354883670807,
-0.12896572053432465,
-0.5701842904090881,
0.1420360803604126,
-0.11801088601350784,
-0.8460480570793152,
0.5058372616767883,
0.15156662464141846,
0.5232819318771362,
0.660878598690033,
0.4893553853034973,
0.625210165977478,
0.20957203209400177,
0.606880784034729,
0.05496186763048172,
-0.6623209714889526,
0.39970001578330994,
-0.34102103114128113,
0.039949964731931686,
0.8719403147697449,
0.6838819980621338,
-0.7104129195213318,
-0.4417727589607239,
-0.3559107482433319,
-0.8716588616371155,
0.4463083744049072,
0.1166195496916771,
0.1716545820236206,
-0.1517782211303711,
0.6318854689598083,
0.15891823172569275,
0.5831243991851807,
-0.5042546987533569,
0.08329824358224869,
0.16577653586864471,
-0.39944157004356384,
0.5950106382369995,
-0.4198000729084015,
-0.07121210545301437,
-0.13574354350566864,
0.27455759048461914,
-0.19003696739673615,
0.17114433646202087,
-0.016500722616910934,
-0.23460853099822998,
-0.3006513714790344,
0.04637116938829422,
0.3451051712036133,
1.0296728610992432,
-0.06052058935165405,
0.31440868973731995,
0.28055405616760254,
-0.1817113310098648,
-0.017637230455875397,
-0.3046867549419403,
-0.17958474159240723,
-0.21355314552783966,
0.29335182905197144,
0.2231389582157135,
0.33405885100364685,
-0.9618432521820068,
0.5274196267127991,
-0.45224422216415405,
-0.23746486008167267,
-0.4391917884349823,
0.0964120402932167,
0.15837834775447845,
0.4044671952724457,
0.6794794797897339,
-0.41554129123687744,
0.2671619653701782,
-0.47123682498931885,
0.22383861243724823,
0.14480027556419373,
-0.7832511067390442,
-0.4133574068546295,
0.6906111240386963,
0.3966681659221649,
-0.2782232463359833,
0.5191588997840881,
-0.17440123856067657,
-0.4695155620574951,
0.574214518070221,
-0.04545912146568298,
0.7704474925994873,
0.1818419247865677,
0.3833504021167755,
0.3556402325630188,
0.008015637286007404,
-0.08902410417795181,
0.3803776204586029,
0.15374022722244263,
-0.5243078470230103,
-0.5370483994483948,
-0.36681532859802246,
-0.6862300038337708,
-0.18246041238307953,
-0.7272933721542358,
0.03500882536172867,
-0.7805054783821106,
-0.6094008088111877,
-0.4020741879940033,
-0.10046295076608658,
-0.055219680070877075,
0.024584341794252396,
-0.28794464468955994,
0.4919458329677582,
-0.6326941251754761,
0.335725873708725,
0.5323949456214905,
-0.1789451390504837,
-0.4477582275867462,
-0.02186567522585392,
0.17634087800979614,
-0.6189317107200623,
0.24527166783809662,
0.35822930932044983,
-0.30371585488319397,
0.12352358549833298,
-0.8169182538986206,
-0.4103793799877167,
0.988378643989563,
0.15159164369106293,
-0.5187987089157104,
0.12757320702075958,
0.44751304388046265,
0.40600746870040894,
-0.38392096757888794,
0.34521594643592834,
0.3811704218387604,
0.5226684808731079,
-0.09585215151309967,
-0.47174206376075745,
0.19949762523174286,
-0.377827912569046,
-0.1858951300382614,
0.07953548431396484,
-0.7907063364982605,
0.7207830548286438,
0.07974163442850113,
-0.4214841425418854,
-0.11893852055072784,
0.7797581553459167,
0.24725160002708435,
0.6344739198684692,
0.7062203288078308,
-0.001863165176473558,
0.9612939953804016,
0.35662251710891724,
0.600366473197937,
-0.5748322606086731,
0.4349336326122284,
0.8198061585426331,
-0.3373715877532959,
0.9438871145248413,
0.49091798067092896,
-0.29018232226371765,
0.4643256366252899,
0.6285854578018188,
0.15241952240467072,
0.16165928542613983,
0.12343381345272064,
-0.3461816608905792,
-0.26823607087135315,
-0.2920149564743042,
-0.26385438442230225,
0.17440886795520782,
0.48332837224006653,
0.05067744478583336,
-0.05739327520132065,
-0.1441991776227951,
-0.007529759779572487,
0.14855237305164337,
-0.2964896857738495,
1.158463716506958,
0.37750568985939026,
-0.26074308156967163,
0.03409760072827339,
0.2579634189605713,
0.6698813438415527,
-0.34094032645225525,
-0.12998583912849426,
-0.3977050483226776,
0.09080972522497177,
-0.37256768345832825,
-0.5177903771400452,
0.5204793214797974,
0.07977931201457977,
0.17701992392539978,
-0.19341593980789185,
0.9271681904792786,
-0.06599485874176025,
-0.49702882766723633,
0.2034885734319687,
0.8088963031768799,
0.08101420849561691,
-0.44334977865219116,
-0.6721754670143127,
0.20098121464252472,
-0.00660155713558197,
0.05313630402088165,
0.43013182282447815,
0.7183497548103333,
-0.044550735503435135,
0.6795710325241089,
0.7255893349647522,
-0.14676924049854279,
-0.10273786634206772,
-0.044750817120075226,
1.0777021646499634,
-0.9259867668151855,
-0.46564921736717224,
-0.9031551480293274,
0.5891377329826355,
-0.4128628671169281,
-0.41505366563796997,
0.77960604429245,
0.5453606843948364,
0.4719150960445404,
0.36230847239494324,
0.8810867667198181,
0.10591764003038406,
0.9322556257247925,
-0.38554075360298157,
0.8372207880020142,
-0.5182541012763977,
0.4062083959579468,
0.19900742173194885,
-0.630765974521637,
-0.2520217299461365,
0.7837827801704407,
-0.21883085370063782,
-0.07740383595228195,
0.5067633986473083,
0.8475189805030823,
0.17976003885269165,
0.3278980553150177,
0.08665468543767929,
0.2981486916542053,
0.4207254946231842,
-0.018225135281682014,
1.345041275024414,
0.008455962873995304,
0.6965395212173462,
-0.010160262696444988,
-0.07566801458597183,
-0.5759716033935547,
-0.707832396030426,
-0.9704939723014832,
-0.2320440113544464,
-0.42468133568763733,
-0.2401825487613678,
-0.20245814323425293,
1.0372387170791626,
0.44451841711997986,
-0.8009202480316162,
-0.4498840868473053,
0.06026330217719078,
0.15837030112743378,
-0.0015468290075659752,
-0.3352474272251129,
0.05558847263455391,
-0.17348293960094452,
-0.14532680809497833,
0.14077261090278625,
0.3901350200176239,
-0.3357253074645996,
-0.5570517182350159,
-0.05544787272810936,
-0.04646337777376175,
0.07671746611595154,
0.7593646049499512,
0.17365844547748566,
-0.21398651599884033,
-0.20219340920448303,
0.1277732402086258,
-0.23641440272331238,
0.27545613050460815,
1.0479298830032349,
-0.46211034059524536,
0.03530653938651085,
0.6545869708061218,
0.6747915744781494,
0.5402669906616211,
0.4573463797569275,
0.6404008865356445,
-0.5123947858810425,
-0.04756909981369972,
0.3067793548107147,
-0.1587522327899933,
0.25298935174942017,
-0.21529769897460938,
0.2818237543106079,
0.2851729691028595,
-0.48028871417045593,
-0.7431450486183167,
-0.2551914155483246,
-0.8810045123100281,
-0.4697269797325134,
1.1198205947875977,
-0.04255419969558716,
-0.24771592020988464,
-0.4892675578594208,
-0.4282081425189972,
0.13633163273334503,
-0.5836529731750488,
1.165752649307251,
0.3443431556224823,
-0.1351136416196823,
-0.47056302428245544,
-0.6985471248626709,
0.32744020223617554,
-0.002726572332903743,
-1.139070749282837,
-0.07831709086894989,
0.5541842579841614,
-0.043972719460725784,
-0.3273327648639679,
1.0707753896713257,
0.09918297827243805,
0.0235650222748518,
-0.20316852629184723,
-0.4553062617778778,
0.17044611275196075,
-0.051528699696063995,
-0.201917827129364,
0.6365535855293274,
0.35320138931274414,
0.17193664610385895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05329v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05329v2
|
KV-Runahead: Scalable Causal LLM Inference by Parallel Key-Value Cache Generation
| 2024-05-08T18:03:22 | 2024-05-13T18:32:37 |
Minsik Cho, Mohammad Rastegari, Devang Naik
|
cs.DC
|
cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Model or LLM inference has two phases, the prompt (or prefill)
phase to output the first token and the extension (or decoding) phase to the
generate subsequent tokens. In this work, we propose an efficient
parallelization scheme, KV-Runahead to accelerate the prompt phase. The key
observation is that the extension phase generates tokens faster than the prompt
phase because of key-value cache (KV-cache). Hence, KV-Runahead parallelizes
the prompt phase by orchestrating multiple processes to populate the KV-cache
and minimizes the time-to-first-token (TTFT). Dual-purposing the KV-cache
scheme has two main benefits. First, since KV-cache is designed to leverage the
causal attention map, we minimize computation and computation automatically.
Second, since it already exists for the extension phase, KV-Runahead is easy to
implement. We further propose context-level load-balancing to handle uneven
KV-cache generation (due to the causal attention) and to optimize TTFT.
Compared with an existing parallelization scheme such as tensor or sequential
parallelization where keys and values are locally generated and exchanged via
all-gather collectives, our experimental results demonstrate that KV-Runahead
can offer over 1.4x and 1.6x speedups for Llama 7B and Falcon 7B respectively.
|
[
-0.17722845077514648,
-0.7733889222145081,
0.5592419505119324,
0.7214779257774353,
-0.4780241847038269,
0.08926291018724442,
-0.1379251778125763,
-0.3257123827934265,
0.27652081847190857,
0.7025314569473267,
-0.5050112009048462,
-0.5244694352149963,
-0.48248037695884705,
-0.035312410444021225,
-0.3210315704345703,
0.4720604717731476,
-0.20451807975769043,
-0.08903411775827408,
-0.21380974352359772,
-0.17366757988929749,
-0.749782145023346,
-0.2532555162906647,
-0.7542256712913513,
-0.2727217376232147,
0.7044993042945862,
0.6027698516845703,
0.3409450054168701,
0.832818865776062,
0.4682409167289734,
0.31115350127220154,
-0.04285850375890732,
-0.00809535849839449,
-0.6018999814987183,
0.6704379320144653,
0.05305858701467514,
-0.6134191751480103,
-0.4254559576511383,
-0.24892018735408783,
0.7371840476989746,
0.27176138758659363,
-0.05632681027054787,
0.3689393699169159,
-0.32161253690719604,
0.7605016827583313,
-0.8856403231620789,
0.22616082429885864,
-0.5730498433113098,
-0.008766685612499714,
-0.3809467852115631,
-0.13849622011184692,
-0.5505250692367554,
-0.37833696603775024,
0.058741915971040726,
-0.7303263545036316,
0.15919150412082672,
0.2983115315437317,
0.6522082686424255,
0.4873583912849426,
-0.5040868520736694,
0.1406475454568863,
-0.4416234493255615,
0.7926528453826904,
-0.6162862777709961,
0.37798571586608887,
0.028355948626995087,
0.4948633313179016,
-0.35255828499794006,
-1.073767900466919,
-0.6280664205551147,
-0.23639051616191864,
0.10252068191766739,
0.20474568009376526,
0.0017859687795862556,
0.24737560749053955,
0.344703733921051,
0.37761303782463074,
-0.30419665575027466,
0.3745352625846863,
-0.12120018899440765,
-0.1512228548526764,
0.06900870054960251,
0.4523937702178955,
0.11010788381099701,
-0.13331198692321777,
-0.3946884274482727,
-0.33299291133880615,
-0.9231373071670532,
0.2308586686849594,
0.24416500329971313,
0.3195033073425293,
-0.1516375094652176,
0.43737560510635376,
-0.7507290244102478,
0.45925694704055786,
0.20860810577869415,
-0.21031337976455688,
0.13192251324653625,
-0.3734758496284485,
-0.39941513538360596,
0.2674403488636017,
0.5809999108314514,
0.1782403141260147,
0.10921140015125275,
-0.08634321391582489,
0.2175949364900589,
0.09740689396858215,
0.3650513291358948,
-1.0887497663497925,
0.22563272714614868,
0.36810940504074097,
-0.5522778630256653,
-0.5420440435409546,
-0.41971415281295776,
-0.9994223713874817,
-0.30314502120018005,
-0.2917231321334839,
0.3054032027721405,
0.03429962694644928,
0.0018153716810047626,
0.022623881697654724,
0.0020341563504189253,
0.18994244933128357,
0.39307013154029846,
-0.6465040445327759,
0.35686853528022766,
0.4765987694263458,
0.8272899985313416,
-0.46615952253341675,
-0.3514883816242218,
-0.8889939188957214,
0.21467329561710358,
-0.06328621506690979,
0.5753234028816223,
-0.40301617980003357,
-0.32519832253456116,
-0.0507110171020031,
-0.15194973349571228,
0.060678351670503616,
-0.45976048707962036,
0.5135379433631897,
-0.8516006469726562,
-0.39673709869384766,
-0.7077035307884216,
-0.3672970235347748,
-0.17712321877479553,
0.05755714327096939,
-0.7794662714004517,
1.0039689540863037,
-0.3045170307159424,
-0.7572543025016785,
0.46923381090164185,
-0.23944473266601562,
-0.546393632888794,
-0.15895837545394897,
-0.1459943652153015,
-0.31884053349494934,
0.24437859654426575,
0.5165379643440247,
0.4018685519695282,
-0.793195366859436,
0.4633263051509857,
-0.43873754143714905,
-0.3816213309764862,
-0.3106864094734192,
-0.42744797468185425,
0.47067731618881226,
0.049328699707984924,
-0.849829912185669,
0.3513072729110718,
-0.6771122813224792,
-0.11962984502315521,
0.09050535410642624,
-0.18565839529037476,
-0.136526957154274,
0.042902108281850815,
-0.030693667009472847,
0.15059643983840942,
0.2640310525894165,
-0.3527383804321289,
0.27091819047927856,
-0.1768200397491455,
-0.09640766680240631,
0.8126546740531921,
-0.16944222152233124,
0.3621733486652374,
-0.10490651428699493,
0.6265208125114441,
0.3824446499347687,
0.16973982751369476,
-0.22990761697292328,
-0.43982866406440735,
-0.9523366689682007,
-0.6214514970779419,
0.06262623518705368,
0.3862801790237427,
-0.6693434119224548,
0.07051344215869904,
-0.372016966342926,
-0.4451411962509155,
-0.5447087287902832,
-0.05676849186420441,
0.6132202744483948,
0.8948997259140015,
0.3923567831516266,
0.05489955097436905,
-0.32948461174964905,
-1.262055516242981,
-0.3507080078125,
-0.2822551727294922,
0.41680169105529785,
0.39380180835723877,
0.1421259045600891,
0.021869516000151634,
0.7169879674911499,
-0.3879876434803009,
0.09766097366809845,
-0.0824333056807518,
0.36315983533859253,
0.33938565850257874,
0.3219289779663086,
0.21787452697753906,
-0.550240695476532,
-0.4243094325065613,
-0.06947637349367142,
-0.5787642598152161,
-0.655724287033081,
-0.1369221955537796,
-0.42516079545021057,
0.16281329095363617,
0.4195308983325958,
-0.6804556846618652,
0.42062318325042725,
0.2894594371318817,
-0.4072406589984894,
0.6302666664123535,
-0.1530207246541977,
0.45909708738327026,
-0.990113377571106,
0.11460762470960617,
-0.609390377998352,
-0.3209334909915924,
-0.408002644777298,
0.22634820640087128,
0.12077531218528748,
0.225870281457901,
-0.3963324725627899,
0.6148219704627991,
-0.302146852016449,
-0.170123890042305,
-0.5322290658950806,
-0.10892529040575027,
-0.16176240146160126,
0.5282015800476074,
-0.15640036761760712,
0.9987524747848511,
0.49116799235343933,
-0.518363356590271,
0.21374216675758362,
-0.032927870750427246,
-0.2025807797908783,
0.3199460804462433,
-0.5853115320205688,
-0.019971219822764397,
0.005895487032830715,
0.6268389821052551,
-0.9538537263870239,
-0.11169786751270294,
0.012600566260516644,
0.07143811136484146,
0.2762085795402527,
0.08733873814344406,
-0.7560550570487976,
-0.506801187992096,
-0.2455269694328308,
0.8927141427993774,
0.7376223802566528,
-0.9549989700317383,
0.6269215941429138,
0.16204755008220673,
0.04819447547197342,
-0.9062753915786743,
-0.41454464197158813,
-0.026120275259017944,
-0.499001145362854,
-0.6983909010887146,
0.2803991138935089,
0.13402390480041504,
-0.11250901222229004,
-0.15381033718585968,
-0.3139326274394989,
0.08966666460037231,
-0.014136983081698418,
0.4233478605747223,
0.027226727455854416,
-0.2623610198497772,
0.005411535035818815,
0.47569388151168823,
-0.2385087013244629,
-0.07440844178199768,
-0.5150430202484131,
0.5813799500465393,
-0.1432812660932541,
-0.35507771372795105,
-0.5329381227493286,
0.3513893783092499,
0.9656499624252319,
0.0546821728348732,
0.7778580784797668,
0.5138809680938721,
-0.02037697657942772,
-0.11989422887563705,
-0.916135311126709,
-0.2606177031993866,
-0.4910951554775238,
0.034860387444496155,
-0.3841732442378998,
-1.2413407564163208,
0.8033237457275391,
-0.2286507785320282,
0.08795268833637238,
0.3580161929130554,
1.0897136926651,
0.2508524954319,
0.6342340707778931,
0.1433773785829544,
-0.32706400752067566,
0.21560953557491302,
0.12475591897964478,
0.14395809173583984,
-0.49027296900749207,
-0.03126152232289314,
-0.4103470742702484,
-0.4724617600440979,
-0.40203529596328735,
-0.681187629699707,
0.4362427294254303,
0.21624654531478882,
-0.363154798746109,
0.10694149881601334,
-0.2184777408838272,
0.2848556339740753,
0.8177183866500854,
0.07119670510292053,
0.44786760210990906,
-0.14181727170944214,
-0.5073557496070862,
-0.015229626558721066,
-0.5326961874961853,
-0.08984584361314774,
1.0344666242599487,
0.009084505029022694,
0.7015425562858582,
-0.1021156832575798,
0.612855851650238,
0.1907109022140503,
0.4349210560321808,
-0.4703717827796936,
0.6424285769462585,
0.3344351649284363,
-0.5501418709754944,
-0.12123799324035645,
-0.40581199526786804,
-0.6156511902809143,
0.6023643612861633,
0.1619940996170044,
-0.9061898589134216,
0.016480684280395508,
0.49284669756889343,
-0.05070725828409195,
0.19150574505329132,
-0.6569695472717285,
0.7378963828086853,
0.15257753431797028,
-0.50297611951828,
-0.7212843298912048,
-0.6589444279670715,
0.9261202216148376,
-0.31220096349716187,
-0.15599720180034637,
-0.025556933134794235,
-0.0015667104162275791,
0.7391334772109985,
-0.6894910931587219,
0.927126407623291,
-0.29419589042663574,
0.0141683304682374,
0.27836793661117554,
-0.1801002025604248,
1.0364757776260376,
0.2723250687122345,
0.16523897647857666,
0.049750711768865585,
-0.27262401580810547,
-0.4565964639186859,
-0.5990882515907288,
0.8267074227333069,
-0.4650365710258484,
-0.9176484942436218,
-0.0899650976061821,
-0.7801868319511414,
-0.1431555300951004,
0.3147363066673279,
0.09975012391805649,
0.20755741000175476,
0.1109854206442833,
0.05985552445054054,
0.47574248909950256,
-0.24924176931381226,
0.4416877329349518,
0.5093141794204712,
-0.2425248771905899,
-0.41699346899986267,
0.6829917430877686,
-0.10657372325658798,
0.360008180141449,
0.5285805463790894,
0.24715042114257812,
-0.2731908857822418,
-0.5069814920425415,
-0.33554404973983765,
0.1796751618385315,
-0.6074219942092896,
-0.2740170657634735,
-0.9877195358276367,
0.19053485989570618,
-0.2719550132751465,
-0.27002811431884766,
-0.6492929458618164,
-0.4409237504005432,
0.023681174963712692,
0.05872168391942978,
0.6827305555343628,
0.016797753050923347,
-0.04350605979561806,
0.8300089836120605,
-0.5261417031288147,
0.6723000407218933,
0.3267524540424347,
0.04488914832472801,
0.41782939434051514,
-0.31818386912345886,
-0.25450173020362854,
-0.4686603844165802,
-0.23052141070365906,
-0.6799185872077942,
0.14903846383094788,
-0.3133677840232849,
0.2549591064453125,
0.5617099404335022,
0.179445281624794,
0.9746513962745667,
-0.7132154107093811,
0.5295930504798889,
0.08507366478443146,
-0.9226087331771851,
0.13535422086715698,
-0.5185351967811584,
0.47915610671043396,
0.7683928608894348,
-0.05043286830186844,
-0.3191623091697693,
-0.618176281452179,
-0.45009928941726685,
-1.0840954780578613,
0.7275044322013855,
0.5096822381019592,
-0.24998271465301514,
-0.09116726368665695,
0.2708533704280853,
0.148812398314476,
0.3013901114463806,
-0.36877307295799255,
-0.4825083613395691,
0.11959756910800934,
-0.1989721804857254,
0.15572278201580048,
-0.3398275375366211,
0.0633126050233841,
-0.35198816657066345,
0.5115031599998474,
-0.002327173249796033,
0.28493449091911316,
0.052118055522441864,
-0.07167799025774002,
-0.1505403220653534,
0.04781179130077362,
0.5833038687705994,
0.44062864780426025,
-0.20055736601352692,
0.29876431822776794,
0.24366524815559387,
-0.751994252204895,
0.3295100927352905,
0.1378966122865677,
-0.10787518322467804,
-0.18373896181583405,
0.33661583065986633,
0.9173007607460022,
0.4739702045917511,
-0.7775071263313293,
0.2768571376800537,
-0.27091190218925476,
-0.010009385645389557,
0.19595012068748474,
-0.014669588766992092,
0.2861189544200897,
0.6569143533706665,
0.05149466171860695,
-0.5808483362197876,
0.06746987998485565,
0.07279272377490997,
0.19604262709617615,
0.25007519125938416,
0.31229862570762634,
-0.13572190701961517,
0.9072520136833191,
0.047625526785850525,
0.06522811204195023,
0.6809394359588623,
0.17539285123348236,
-0.41701823472976685,
0.8699859976768494,
0.7108532786369324,
1.1768707036972046,
-0.14093565940856934,
-0.07245320826768875,
0.24098819494247437,
0.27430447936058044,
-0.19655580818653107,
0.4482150971889496,
-0.5318772196769714,
-0.3990056812763214,
-0.5978357195854187,
-0.934288740158081,
-0.3418078124523163,
0.13126443326473236,
-0.7273393869400024,
0.027466928586363792,
-0.18944720923900604,
0.03842908889055252,
-0.18979880213737488,
-0.2271943986415863,
-0.7702233791351318,
-0.040942493826150894,
-0.12431017309427261,
0.8971907496452332,
-0.6151199340820312,
0.9249802827835083,
0.2886812090873718,
0.03710983693599701,
-0.7169525623321533,
0.07573495805263519,
0.014480088837444782,
-0.9494552612304688,
1.0945075750350952,
0.3878856301307678,
-0.05345624312758446,
0.27352917194366455,
-0.08598142862319946,
-1.0575944185256958,
1.3858256340026855,
0.2629009187221527,
-0.6270806193351746,
0.060543499886989594,
-0.011003070510923862,
0.13257335126399994,
-0.2075956165790558,
0.2679153084754944,
0.6211938858032227,
0.6892865896224976,
0.26697319746017456,
-0.6405524015426636,
0.45546647906303406,
0.13891565799713135,
0.12772589921951294,
0.41694751381874084,
-0.6419118642807007,
0.5970545411109924,
0.08540235459804535,
-0.014961602166295052,
0.039306942373514175,
1.0023438930511475,
0.7074430584907532,
0.23614798486232758,
0.6369931101799011,
0.9772829413414001,
0.5949422121047974,
0.3308062255382538,
0.9389221668243408,
-0.3627950847148895,
0.13215944170951843,
1.1984622478485107,
-0.2686660885810852,
0.6169203519821167,
0.9478110074996948,
-0.05876992642879486,
0.13016203045845032,
0.5909711122512817,
0.4688549339771271,
0.6482413411140442,
0.37307512760162354,
-0.567294180393219,
-0.2327457219362259,
-0.03143361210823059,
-0.31268200278282166,
0.18384425342082977,
0.19023938477039337,
-0.2542569935321808,
-0.5610693097114563,
-0.07726627588272095,
0.07415411621332169,
-0.687458336353302,
-0.14249677956104279,
0.33001747727394104,
0.26748740673065186,
-0.8800148963928223,
0.5373180508613586,
-0.061615411192178726,
0.2956656813621521,
-0.4864047169685364,
0.11288870871067047,
-0.1955215334892273,
0.12003479897975922,
0.37659937143325806,
-0.08359907567501068,
0.07242722064256668,
0.01610751636326313,
-0.4214980900287628,
-0.210482656955719,
0.7359257340431213,
-0.14515703916549683,
-0.3308122456073761,
0.41121143102645874,
0.36318472027778625,
0.029536401852965355,
-0.07330188900232315,
-0.2368522733449936,
0.1554565727710724,
-0.33463290333747864,
-0.749962329864502,
0.4050739109516144,
0.2518768608570099,
-0.4057094156742096,
0.49498242139816284,
0.7176820039749146,
-0.11403781175613403,
0.6131864190101624,
0.22114285826683044,
0.9925789833068848,
-0.6795614957809448,
-0.7531278729438782,
-1.0777957439422607,
0.5001897811889648,
0.010558069683611393,
-0.2874026596546173,
0.6646707057952881,
0.309855580329895,
0.38285160064697266,
-0.06287062168121338,
0.36477839946746826,
0.13125064969062805,
-0.14900630712509155,
-0.6759468913078308,
0.6866759657859802,
-0.5826355814933777,
-0.02819923311471939,
-0.2546314001083374,
-0.7139809727668762,
-0.14701788127422333,
-0.06559216231107712,
-0.059773437678813934,
-0.17152702808380127,
0.9238080978393555,
0.6724425554275513,
-0.11516361683607101,
0.025352345779538155,
0.2535863220691681,
0.31243228912353516,
0.45750537514686584,
0.46313199400901794,
0.5095317959785461,
-0.042597703635692596,
0.2179652601480484,
-0.08615290373563766,
-0.3076527416706085,
-0.3332720696926117,
-0.8872765898704529,
-1.0385644435882568,
-0.24736887216567993,
0.14036352932453156,
-0.3359053134918213,
0.0435008630156517,
0.5395876169204712,
0.5754895210266113,
-0.4905323088169098,
-0.13685421645641327,
-0.6178723573684692,
0.23516845703125,
-0.11159554123878479,
-0.2174789309501648,
0.5077014565467834,
-0.7669567465782166,
-0.5291590094566345,
0.5621418356895447,
0.6212137341499329,
-0.29756027460098267,
-0.1309664100408554,
0.009014608338475227,
-0.1197456419467926,
0.17485108971595764,
0.40487536787986755,
0.2986677289009094,
-0.949817419052124,
-0.028520744293928146,
-0.23543447256088257,
-0.03680996596813202,
-0.07582136988639832,
1.1376335620880127,
-0.9753228425979614,
0.5340327620506287,
0.6562827825546265,
1.2853429317474365,
0.9712308645248413,
-0.13679949939250946,
0.7656208872795105,
-0.47684335708618164,
0.4694477915763855,
-0.11104350537061691,
0.2264387458562851,
-0.33435243368148804,
-0.5332202315330505,
0.14465399086475372,
0.502439022064209,
-0.6229322552680969,
-0.8338829278945923,
0.3283657133579254,
-1.2941228151321411,
-0.07674010843038559,
0.8918696641921997,
0.0666796863079071,
-0.4180840849876404,
0.07740211486816406,
0.11320905387401581,
0.5062666535377502,
-0.48803749680519104,
0.6841186285018921,
0.6509935855865479,
-0.03392372652888298,
0.016470162197947502,
-0.7421499490737915,
0.29070329666137695,
0.8182869553565979,
-0.9813780188560486,
0.18829059600830078,
0.31790924072265625,
-0.07707111537456512,
-0.25839802622795105,
0.8347474932670593,
0.001848895801231265,
0.30205732583999634,
0.002084574196487665,
-0.013583285734057426,
-0.07200293987989426,
-0.4360540807247162,
-0.2190108299255371,
0.1798575222492218,
-0.23920583724975586,
-0.31303927302360535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05253v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05253v1
|
Open Source Language Models Can Provide Feedback: Evaluating LLMs' Ability to Help Students Using GPT-4-As-A-Judge
| 2024-05-08T17:57:39 | 2024-05-08T17:57:39 |
Charles Koutcheme, Nicola Dainese, Sami Sarsa, Arto Hellas, Juho Leinonen, Paul Denny
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown great potential for the automatic
generation of feedback in a wide range of computing contexts. However, concerns
have been voiced around the privacy and ethical implications of sending student
work to proprietary models. This has sparked considerable interest in the use
of open source LLMs in education, but the quality of the feedback that such
open models can produce remains understudied. This is a concern as providing
flawed or misleading generated feedback could be detrimental to student
learning. Inspired by recent work that has utilised very powerful LLMs, such as
GPT-4, to evaluate the outputs produced by less powerful models, we conduct an
automated analysis of the quality of the feedback produced by several open
source models using a dataset from an introductory programming course. First,
we investigate the viability of employing GPT-4 as an automated evaluator by
comparing its evaluations with those of a human expert. We observe that GPT-4
demonstrates a bias toward positively rating feedback while exhibiting moderate
agreement with human raters, showcasing its potential as a feedback evaluator.
Second, we explore the quality of feedback generated by several leading
open-source LLMs by using GPT-4 to evaluate the feedback. We find that some
models offer competitive performance with popular proprietary LLMs, such as
ChatGPT, indicating opportunities for their responsible use in educational
settings.
|
[
-0.07832098007202148,
-0.5362638831138611,
0.8322343826293945,
-0.059823177754879,
-0.09762497246265411,
0.0746741071343422,
-0.40074872970581055,
-0.6104931235313416,
-0.315283864736557,
0.43764975666999817,
-0.18081623315811157,
-0.5723753571510315,
-0.4793176054954529,
0.12522751092910767,
-0.530326783657074,
1.1975115537643433,
-0.12015470862388611,
0.6012170314788818,
-0.41129016876220703,
0.07394468039274216,
-0.3682725131511688,
-0.7780088782310486,
-0.5884358286857605,
-0.42340797185897827,
0.3805942237377167,
0.32967087626457214,
0.7242580652236938,
0.1790790855884552,
0.5949029922485352,
0.31770986318588257,
0.09529883414506912,
-0.41689857840538025,
-0.56917804479599,
-0.07133641839027405,
-0.4365135133266449,
-0.5508299469947815,
-0.5058033466339111,
0.5035935044288635,
0.6499168276786804,
0.41358262300491333,
-0.18421684205532074,
0.33366602659225464,
0.3754312992095947,
0.5423067808151245,
-0.2632113993167877,
0.33160141110420227,
-0.42236942052841187,
-0.019668515771627426,
-0.21554584801197052,
0.10068286955356598,
-0.41901907324790955,
-0.9467408657073975,
0.03442921116948128,
-0.399088054895401,
0.0881759524345398,
-0.2947074770927429,
0.7742382287979126,
0.2797531485557556,
0.06311687082052231,
-0.6017327308654785,
-0.895003080368042,
0.7887707948684692,
-1.1117740869522095,
0.39306536316871643,
0.38229501247406006,
0.5055038928985596,
0.0657506138086319,
-0.6232815980911255,
-0.4351588189601898,
-0.580817461013794,
0.10914614051580429,
0.15644577145576477,
-0.09442699700593948,
0.11241142451763153,
0.14656394720077515,
0.6450693011283875,
-0.3038991689682007,
0.25107380747795105,
-0.5461928248405457,
-0.24523158371448517,
0.3880102038383484,
-0.023365920409560204,
0.24595549702644348,
-0.1617034524679184,
-0.026131264865398407,
0.16971828043460846,
-0.849325954914093,
0.004468761850148439,
0.9064523577690125,
0.3200749158859253,
0.21249915659427643,
0.7492509484291077,
-0.012478388845920563,
0.6978833079338074,
-0.1996854692697525,
-0.04879648610949516,
0.14216652512550354,
-0.3378033936023712,
-0.04623621329665184,
-0.3577703535556793,
0.8393584489822388,
0.3890448808670044,
0.39173147082328796,
-0.19956383109092712,
-0.5072949528694153,
0.2388269454240799,
0.25831449031829834,
-0.7857110500335693,
-0.39259904623031616,
0.07718513906002045,
-0.5961825251579285,
-0.3594737946987152,
0.14962011575698853,
-0.697524905204773,
-0.23738345503807068,
-0.5653933882713318,
0.4732651114463806,
-0.20607581734657288,
-0.3272823989391327,
-0.06415600329637527,
0.1516530066728592,
-0.025433888658881187,
0.6177318096160889,
-0.6916079521179199,
0.5063351988792419,
0.5748533010482788,
0.858681857585907,
-0.21141499280929565,
-0.2100817859172821,
-0.49882641434669495,
-0.2298012226819992,
-0.18254350125789642,
0.5301549434661865,
-0.6029313802719116,
-0.4950478672981262,
-0.03820471838116646,
-0.17966771125793457,
0.34198394417762756,
-0.5345737934112549,
0.3884570896625519,
-0.5382519960403442,
0.47348400950431824,
-0.28244873881340027,
-0.678728461265564,
-0.01283307932317257,
0.21328772604465485,
-0.6511561870574951,
0.8287442922592163,
0.37265145778656006,
-0.655907928943634,
0.230089470744133,
-0.769719660282135,
0.09129015356302261,
0.2649751305580139,
-0.48847606778144836,
-0.27380135655403137,
0.07476566731929779,
0.052542317658662796,
0.18370722234249115,
-0.20932680368423462,
0.163307324051857,
-0.45292869210243225,
-0.3575734794139862,
0.328676700592041,
-0.38597214221954346,
0.6780890226364136,
0.3033903241157532,
-0.4992605447769165,
0.31064707040786743,
-0.5718714594841003,
0.2611171305179596,
0.06407278031110764,
-0.6843205094337463,
-0.18725308775901794,
-0.0736103281378746,
-0.06248137354850769,
0.02383478172123432,
0.19978761672973633,
-0.679515540599823,
0.19231776893138885,
-0.28028395771980286,
0.4603239595890045,
1.0279345512390137,
-0.12416339665651321,
0.27580493688583374,
-0.1403980702161789,
0.8453593254089355,
-0.3559272587299347,
0.18399743735790253,
0.02527615800499916,
-0.6028589010238647,
-0.4150804877281189,
-0.015791360288858414,
0.5182233452796936,
0.22734233736991882,
-0.7236349582672119,
-0.07321932911872864,
0.1299998164176941,
-0.40152737498283386,
-0.8343880772590637,
0.38642770051956177,
0.4494924247264862,
0.2712355852127075,
0.07103969901800156,
-0.49546191096305847,
-0.31473609805107117,
-0.6001091599464417,
-0.49895820021629333,
-0.4708639979362488,
-0.2793397009372711,
0.37279248237609863,
0.4540926218032837,
-0.1947958767414093,
1.0497111082077026,
-0.2554740011692047,
-0.1763106882572174,
-0.03779459372162819,
-0.053116556257009506,
0.11340688914060593,
0.2577279806137085,
0.5306528210639954,
-0.20871417224407196,
-0.2210397869348526,
-0.19598346948623657,
-0.6607451438903809,
-0.35575324296951294,
0.3326517343521118,
0.15452350676059723,
0.1539701521396637,
0.0652555599808693,
-0.3406878709793091,
0.15624362230300903,
0.6953241229057312,
-0.2270858883857727,
0.7691657543182373,
-0.25145435333251953,
0.13883014023303986,
-0.6828078627586365,
-0.06624696403741837,
-0.005565717350691557,
-0.2100808173418045,
-0.1401767134666443,
0.23785869777202606,
0.04215335100889206,
-0.19968198239803314,
-0.4395237863063812,
0.49718818068504333,
-0.37186959385871887,
-0.2972177565097809,
-0.39714792370796204,
0.2572445571422577,
-0.25973761081695557,
0.070257768034935,
-0.0863531082868576,
0.7421801686286926,
0.3031221628189087,
-0.20742042362689972,
0.4955625832080841,
0.05128327012062073,
-0.5104801654815674,
0.501846969127655,
-0.6929270029067993,
0.4796020984649658,
0.30568093061447144,
0.1541212797164917,
-0.7240209579467773,
-0.38501331210136414,
0.35379651188850403,
-0.635369598865509,
0.08456697314977646,
-0.3559560477733612,
-0.6180696487426758,
-0.5142797231674194,
-0.350952684879303,
0.06577452272176743,
0.4330332279205322,
-0.6541114449501038,
0.21350422501564026,
0.3509799838066101,
-0.3053777813911438,
-0.4176570177078247,
-0.5021754503250122,
0.03808657079935074,
0.19834236800670624,
-0.3758179545402527,
-0.2770996391773224,
-0.2674320340156555,
-0.49028632044792175,
0.34875476360321045,
-0.015426619909703732,
0.01817670837044716,
0.17939506471157074,
0.3829312324523926,
0.440140962600708,
-0.2629677355289459,
-0.07104387134313583,
-0.3133176565170288,
0.03478898108005524,
0.32608872652053833,
-0.4610225260257721,
0.2277541309595108,
-0.6415421366691589,
-0.8765082359313965,
-0.2867726683616638,
0.04376910254359245,
0.5297703742980957,
-0.08882367610931396,
0.2653638422489166,
0.37123849987983704,
-0.2295086681842804,
-0.28216272592544556,
-0.4556092917919159,
-0.3574869632720947,
-0.4787208139896393,
0.1507459580898285,
-0.013082161545753479,
-1.1402709484100342,
0.15884707868099213,
0.1641501635313034,
0.22484800219535828,
0.19726236164569855,
0.8610206842422485,
0.08580087870359421,
0.853940486907959,
0.6316602826118469,
-0.21763473749160767,
0.45863860845565796,
-0.20096784830093384,
0.3747110366821289,
-0.5202620029449463,
-0.26198023557662964,
-0.7738574743270874,
0.01554052159190178,
-0.5110347270965576,
-0.2785320281982422,
0.11399596929550171,
0.01160094141960144,
-0.13978834450244904,
-0.0030982540920376778,
-0.5403627157211304,
0.8022789359092712,
0.7481591105461121,
0.043292827904224396,
0.5086884498596191,
-0.18865063786506653,
-0.14290954172611237,
0.04154026880860329,
-0.3654181957244873,
-0.9724625945091248,
1.2884025573730469,
0.6537483334541321,
1.090943455696106,
0.20235347747802734,
0.6991416811943054,
0.3188759684562683,
0.9056544899940491,
-0.8272072076797485,
0.5896749496459961,
0.02415403351187706,
-0.6116227507591248,
-0.30129051208496094,
-0.7071477770805359,
-0.5162269473075867,
0.09159979969263077,
0.1751270592212677,
-0.690828263759613,
-0.35281726717948914,
0.1777343899011612,
-0.3259739577770233,
0.36958885192871094,
-0.7579680681228638,
0.7218289971351624,
-0.4055536687374115,
-0.5365164279937744,
-0.07291228324174881,
-0.35887622833251953,
0.4380069673061371,
-0.19791355729103088,
0.37817779183387756,
-0.09459470957517624,
0.28819143772125244,
0.7851545810699463,
-0.6490418910980225,
1.011924147605896,
-0.4389709234237671,
-0.41883206367492676,
0.5101037621498108,
0.15853255987167358,
0.17898771166801453,
0.11298142373561859,
-0.2250450700521469,
0.3710263967514038,
-0.01585833914577961,
-0.13602657616138458,
-0.523150622844696,
1.0290790796279907,
-1.1284104585647583,
-0.7740829586982727,
-0.27985212206840515,
-0.3185289800167084,
-0.23436756432056427,
0.2748262882232666,
0.12584690749645233,
0.227151557803154,
-0.016245678067207336,
-0.012085777707397938,
0.18268851935863495,
-0.2645379602909088,
0.18741421401500702,
0.9148771166801453,
-0.6047763228416443,
-0.4090726375579834,
1.0283923149108887,
0.12031138688325882,
0.34969833493232727,
-0.2653319239616394,
0.4100346267223358,
-0.3730618357658386,
-0.6300573945045471,
-0.6563301682472229,
0.2793075442314148,
-0.9988176226615906,
-0.0591900534927845,
-0.20870019495487213,
-0.1791919767856598,
-0.381111741065979,
0.08763875812292099,
-0.29121196269989014,
-0.4661121666431427,
-0.2714179456233978,
-0.27976536750793457,
0.04799586534500122,
1.4744338989257812,
-0.02772924304008484,
0.15666484832763672,
-0.784527063369751,
-0.03704908862709999,
0.40215399861335754,
0.8547663688659668,
-0.06320200115442276,
-0.3707547187805176,
-0.20758022367954254,
-0.035207174718379974,
-0.5153191089630127,
-0.804186224937439,
0.08189082890748978,
-0.1229691356420517,
0.6850376725196838,
0.3705715239048004,
-0.1439645141363144,
0.08411767333745956,
-0.4862080514431,
1.251284122467041,
0.11077207326889038,
-1.0658528804779053,
0.5643685460090637,
-0.36502647399902344,
0.13643553853034973,
0.3609533905982971,
0.4442169666290283,
-0.21904592216014862,
-0.9215629696846008,
-0.46149733662605286,
-0.5212526917457581,
0.8957704305648804,
0.2288060337305069,
0.10826559364795685,
0.12755320966243744,
0.38355356454849243,
0.3253938555717468,
0.45100343227386475,
-1.130218267440796,
0.043795954436063766,
-0.47782737016677856,
-0.1076558455824852,
-0.023139186203479767,
-0.2121182084083557,
0.012749850749969482,
-0.01681884378194809,
0.6528477668762207,
0.061449650675058365,
0.07604959607124329,
-0.1634545624256134,
0.06966214627027512,
-0.3492435812950134,
0.4667785167694092,
0.3641555607318878,
0.7856466770172119,
-0.25989317893981934,
0.07951416075229645,
-0.1517113596200943,
-0.48889532685279846,
0.24354083836078644,
-0.05870528519153595,
-0.2378731220960617,
0.1476527899503708,
0.10993168503046036,
0.4972202479839325,
0.12495166808366776,
-0.5237955451011658,
0.6836079359054565,
-0.1773689240217209,
-0.1326315999031067,
-0.18776939809322357,
0.1883215755224228,
0.02241511270403862,
0.2020341157913208,
0.03229697048664093,
-0.06950444728136063,
0.15084782242774963,
-0.5556827187538147,
0.10857200622558594,
0.44535693526268005,
-0.2490161508321762,
-0.572022557258606,
0.8362469673156738,
0.46212658286094666,
-0.4472341537475586,
0.5734071135520935,
0.1542074978351593,
-0.5341859459877014,
0.3504106104373932,
0.4546908736228943,
0.8461309671401978,
-0.4542371928691864,
0.1712825447320938,
0.2771270275115967,
0.3873156011104584,
-0.2793870270252228,
0.17717769742012024,
-0.11365266889333725,
-0.42359820008277893,
-0.5467918515205383,
-0.7196809649467468,
-1.0907018184661865,
0.32267460227012634,
-0.6064334511756897,
0.31711116433143616,
-0.43692564964294434,
-0.4141385853290558,
-0.23614932596683502,
-0.09433072060346603,
-0.5811498761177063,
-0.01635752059519291,
0.19691874086856842,
0.6081523299217224,
-0.7690690159797668,
0.9380272626876831,
0.7744268178939819,
-0.6372541785240173,
-1.068052053451538,
0.0070524620823562145,
0.13072741031646729,
-0.5796114206314087,
0.8076339364051819,
0.12313085049390793,
-0.2666712701320648,
-0.09251268208026886,
-0.6131534576416016,
-0.6711103916168213,
0.6730835437774658,
0.6252058148384094,
-0.69146728515625,
-0.29744023084640503,
0.29028207063674927,
0.7069350481033325,
0.020990876480937004,
0.7285600304603577,
0.3256149888038635,
0.41361576318740845,
-0.10587940365076065,
-1.1439565420150757,
-0.14795079827308655,
-0.2901670038700104,
0.00686080614104867,
-0.02391161024570465,
-0.4206107258796692,
0.9574827551841736,
-0.21032151579856873,
-0.10381916165351868,
0.050729576498270035,
0.47176018357276917,
0.14479663968086243,
0.2818411886692047,
0.31487181782722473,
0.4170980155467987,
0.750432014465332,
0.006185575388371944,
1.2449406385421753,
-0.38494056463241577,
0.6045179963111877,
1.254953384399414,
-0.34436365962028503,
0.7720829844474792,
0.34513089060783386,
-0.4118916690349579,
0.4249294400215149,
0.5533051490783691,
-0.07269199192523956,
0.346270889043808,
0.6159395575523376,
-0.13716888427734375,
0.12405458092689514,
0.32597920298576355,
-0.45364779233932495,
0.07059711962938309,
0.1916063129901886,
-0.36398017406463623,
-0.3274948298931122,
0.04675093665719032,
-0.11618928611278534,
0.04745928943157196,
-0.4204014241695404,
0.6459112167358398,
0.18757759034633636,
-0.6648284196853638,
0.26766178011894226,
0.038672756403684616,
0.5287838578224182,
-0.5091163516044617,
-0.17683298885822296,
-0.17636221647262573,
0.37971657514572144,
-0.4273088872432709,
-0.854591429233551,
0.210971862077713,
0.4498042166233063,
-0.03369582071900368,
-0.2749280631542206,
0.5625836849212646,
-0.23979778587818146,
-0.339775949716568,
0.40149950981140137,
0.5939106941223145,
0.38393962383270264,
0.024243006482720375,
-0.41380575299263,
0.26406389474868774,
-0.05628006160259247,
-0.3455696403980255,
0.4062325656414032,
0.24274688959121704,
0.041723474860191345,
0.5774897336959839,
0.7090123295783997,
0.37696054577827454,
-0.024119578301906586,
0.20858334004878998,
0.877651035785675,
-0.374306321144104,
-0.3975875675678253,
-0.8655411601066589,
0.08202793449163437,
0.18979421257972717,
-0.12608563899993896,
1.156607985496521,
0.48684608936309814,
1.2686173915863037,
-0.1281053125858307,
1.1487735509872437,
0.24312017858028412,
0.7042867541313171,
-0.5296072959899902,
0.7751580476760864,
-0.22729329764842987,
0.6866249442100525,
-0.47367119789123535,
-0.9523650407791138,
-0.036539021879434586,
0.5398754477500916,
-0.6228764653205872,
0.18715263903141022,
0.5479228496551514,
0.48156577348709106,
0.11150982230901718,
0.31783971190452576,
0.35235634446144104,
0.20701570808887482,
0.6665740013122559,
0.24161937832832336,
1.2614984512329102,
0.14301127195358276,
0.49637657403945923,
-0.09711244702339172,
-0.3341915011405945,
-0.2241446077823639,
-0.7594833970069885,
-0.9472759962081909,
-0.2710380256175995,
-0.24036799371242523,
-0.48165035247802734,
0.014805877581238747,
0.8443154692649841,
0.49754783511161804,
-0.8649472594261169,
-0.4051033556461334,
-0.008680840022861958,
0.007145906798541546,
0.26545679569244385,
-0.2794893682003021,
0.08551812171936035,
-0.40519270300865173,
-0.7249835729598999,
0.4536859393119812,
0.023017097264528275,
0.0016266972525045276,
-0.7002924680709839,
-0.2222316414117813,
0.5331321954727173,
0.056742556393146515,
0.5248175859451294,
0.006566451862454414,
-0.9458677172660828,
-0.3634917438030243,
-0.1806318312883377,
-0.152556911110878,
-0.041549064218997955,
0.9852195382118225,
-0.7296742796897888,
0.44203925132751465,
0.2508879005908966,
0.6282529234886169,
0.17530182003974915,
-0.02265266142785549,
0.6161748766899109,
-0.3921942710876465,
-0.2812386453151703,
0.4685371220111847,
0.4068771004676819,
0.43998289108276367,
-0.291814923286438,
0.5579165816307068,
0.20056188106536865,
-0.9310122132301331,
-0.8212302327156067,
-0.02540227212011814,
-0.5580751299858093,
-0.1748417764902115,
1.3165432214736938,
-0.5639312267303467,
-0.03323087468743324,
0.07737694680690765,
-0.39818689227104187,
0.007807834539562464,
-0.5287702679634094,
0.804705798625946,
0.9752484560012817,
-0.16183829307556152,
-0.01986631751060486,
-0.8358209133148193,
0.3648902475833893,
0.18464815616607666,
-0.9040782451629639,
-0.04887901619076729,
0.7845662832260132,
0.5969141125679016,
0.03260271996259689,
0.6959952116012573,
-0.44081395864486694,
0.20829647779464722,
-0.22747737169265747,
0.15798822045326233,
-0.21157392859458923,
-0.15792642533779144,
-0.6432614922523499,
0.3403490483760834,
0.6635006070137024,
-0.018992001190781593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05254v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05254v2
|
You Only Cache Once: Decoder-Decoder Architectures for Language Models
| 2024-05-08T17:57:39 | 2024-05-09T14:12:45 |
Yutao Sun, Li Dong, Yi Zhu, Shaohan Huang, Wenhui Wang, Shuming Ma, Quanlu Zhang, Jianyong Wang, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce a decoder-decoder architecture, YOCO, for large language models,
which only caches key-value pairs once. It consists of two components, i.e., a
cross-decoder stacked upon a self-decoder. The self-decoder efficiently encodes
global key-value (KV) caches that are reused by the cross-decoder via
cross-attention. The overall model behaves like a decoder-only Transformer,
although YOCO only caches once. The design substantially reduces GPU memory
demands, yet retains global attention capability. Additionally, the computation
flow enables prefilling to early exit without changing the final output,
thereby significantly speeding up the prefill stage. Experimental results
demonstrate that YOCO achieves favorable performance compared to Transformer in
various settings of scaling up model size and number of training tokens. We
also extend YOCO to 1M context length with near-perfect needle retrieval
accuracy. The profiling results show that YOCO improves inference memory,
prefill latency, and throughput by orders of magnitude across context lengths
and model sizes. Code is available at https://aka.ms/YOCO.
|
[
-0.17247681319713593,
-0.6404306292533875,
0.4278213381767273,
0.21038785576820374,
-0.3101905882358551,
-0.11110668629407883,
-0.08098011463880539,
-0.5012611746788025,
0.29151153564453125,
0.6242625713348389,
-0.24944613873958588,
-0.36762315034866333,
-0.31634241342544556,
-0.09907510876655579,
-0.36105450987815857,
0.8641554117202759,
0.3759235739707947,
-0.05579974129796028,
-0.3322743773460388,
-0.02780814655125141,
-0.5096454620361328,
-0.2836960256099701,
-0.6144348382949829,
-0.02198633924126625,
0.41621023416519165,
0.3843243420124054,
0.34555584192276,
0.9636343717575073,
-0.09600216150283813,
0.31807518005371094,
-0.03301319107413292,
0.047539908438920975,
-0.6260850429534912,
0.4258216917514801,
-0.039665885269641876,
-0.43935707211494446,
-0.4886872172355652,
-0.29229292273521423,
0.4792582094669342,
0.5505505800247192,
-0.10550800710916519,
0.09771855175495148,
-0.18808160722255707,
0.5093621611595154,
-1.3690918684005737,
0.24776291847229004,
-0.9012213945388794,
-0.22115136682987213,
-0.3150689899921417,
-0.08481855690479279,
-0.6634142398834229,
-0.14400485157966614,
0.11147770285606384,
-0.5503103137016296,
0.3101002275943756,
-0.38167881965637207,
0.5734559297561646,
0.41340017318725586,
-0.30551502108573914,
0.05277400091290474,
-0.6676660776138306,
0.7653214335441589,
-0.7465270161628723,
0.4946272671222687,
0.38045310974121094,
0.28967487812042236,
0.26454785466194153,
-1.0405223369598389,
-0.5147872567176819,
0.022877436131238937,
0.05867583677172661,
0.2444303035736084,
0.026620717719197273,
-0.11236261576414108,
-0.08941441029310226,
0.3569395840167999,
-0.43563008308410645,
-0.19777385890483856,
-0.40166518092155457,
-0.26017844676971436,
0.2914705276489258,
0.24591344594955444,
0.19889231026172638,
0.23369824886322021,
-0.23706257343292236,
-0.2804744839668274,
-0.767453134059906,
-0.07628843933343887,
0.22130124270915985,
0.3513292968273163,
0.20876756310462952,
0.13119259476661682,
-0.1764688640832901,
0.6215620040893555,
-0.015855297446250916,
-0.07323402166366577,
0.19674687087535858,
-0.40760669112205505,
-0.233787402510643,
0.17259806394577026,
0.9917886853218079,
-0.0661720335483551,
0.04647410660982132,
-0.5614831447601318,
-0.0918041542172432,
0.12934915721416473,
0.8037580251693726,
-0.860387921333313,
-0.16597221791744232,
0.10599904507398605,
-0.18113510310649872,
-0.23361830413341522,
-0.12755060195922852,
-0.7031812071800232,
0.09117786586284637,
0.17614935338497162,
0.4730292856693268,
-0.05990804731845856,
-0.19328485429286957,
0.6576803922653198,
0.034907471388578415,
0.0841188058257103,
0.07543335855007172,
-0.9681711792945862,
0.6679210662841797,
0.5852548480033875,
0.7740268707275391,
-0.18105173110961914,
-0.445483535528183,
-0.6858112215995789,
-0.009601718746125698,
-0.42885762453079224,
0.6390154957771301,
-0.4748401343822479,
-0.49594250321388245,
0.011621943674981594,
0.10477076470851898,
-0.040193598717451096,
-0.24530768394470215,
0.6242619156837463,
-0.9701579213142395,
0.0643186941742897,
-0.3428836166858673,
-0.369956374168396,
0.07392355799674988,
-0.013407296501100063,
-1.0215611457824707,
0.9489523768424988,
-0.04774683341383934,
-0.7576165795326233,
0.20085203647613525,
-0.5193904042243958,
-0.7863380908966064,
0.07889409363269806,
-0.13503038883209229,
-0.4291319251060486,
0.39104458689689636,
0.13857288658618927,
0.17843955755233765,
-0.3675991892814636,
-0.060282833874225616,
-0.20668698847293854,
-0.5889669060707092,
-0.2944074869155884,
-0.30823275446891785,
0.671552300453186,
0.3779391050338745,
-0.3689590394496918,
0.007431806996464729,
-0.8083909749984741,
0.31102120876312256,
0.3337094187736511,
-0.4257674217224121,
-0.33020859956741333,
0.17601130902767181,
0.16176605224609375,
0.1716766655445099,
0.3479768931865692,
-0.7247453927993774,
0.5013776421546936,
-0.2932788133621216,
0.6718018651008606,
0.5751590132713318,
-0.3257746994495392,
0.6454108357429504,
0.056988880038261414,
0.41476312279701233,
0.3452039361000061,
-0.03381286561489105,
-0.9113348126411438,
-0.4030303657054901,
-0.7615790367126465,
-0.052975691854953766,
0.05791143700480461,
0.38668304681777954,
-0.4051554501056671,
0.243936687707901,
-0.3761148154735565,
-0.29492464661598206,
-0.8709357976913452,
0.05038204416632652,
0.6672526001930237,
0.6673488616943359,
0.5488207340240479,
-0.35440120100975037,
-0.4184689521789551,
-0.8901938796043396,
-0.07661734521389008,
-0.13887903094291687,
0.22630873322486877,
0.20153509080410004,
0.27879980206489563,
-0.18828897178173065,
0.9607193470001221,
-0.6106687188148499,
-0.08387120068073273,
-0.2106916457414627,
0.10118160396814346,
-0.12876327335834503,
0.4480348229408264,
0.5729396343231201,
-0.6457880735397339,
-0.6157661080360413,
0.1281762421131134,
-0.20578275620937347,
-0.11861633509397507,
-0.08655521273612976,
0.06519141793251038,
0.5041705965995789,
0.49130719900131226,
-0.3937622308731079,
0.35585567355155945,
0.5770725011825562,
-0.24136489629745483,
0.43166106939315796,
-0.5698081851005554,
0.05229616537690163,
-1.0089315176010132,
0.3484566807746887,
-0.4999792277812958,
-0.4238838851451874,
-0.49354636669158936,
-0.06951475143432617,
0.43163785338401794,
0.07919839024543762,
-0.3654223680496216,
0.854387104511261,
-0.4306224286556244,
-0.03540666401386261,
-0.45202404260635376,
-0.041624777019023895,
0.3486424684524536,
0.3968576192855835,
0.06968038529157639,
1.1087477207183838,
0.7448891997337341,
-0.7621873021125793,
-0.1086370050907135,
0.055392440408468246,
-0.29864779114723206,
-0.035396113991737366,
-0.9549747109413147,
0.7699326276779175,
-0.2600902020931244,
0.11143598705530167,
-0.9740288257598877,
0.14914779365062714,
-0.13975584506988525,
-0.28383132815361023,
0.4902893006801605,
-0.3005993962287903,
-0.3653196692466736,
-0.3559149503707886,
-0.16258461773395538,
0.6562106609344482,
0.2821352779865265,
-0.5852624773979187,
0.6255125403404236,
0.4562109410762787,
0.3008142411708832,
-0.933197021484375,
-0.9722152352333069,
0.04969476908445358,
0.18279798328876495,
-0.49897462129592896,
0.3845544755458832,
-0.4469330310821533,
0.40899744629859924,
0.150790274143219,
-0.2505120635032654,
-0.3020651340484619,
0.2258487194776535,
0.35071417689323425,
0.18948936462402344,
-0.4556575119495392,
0.1503898650407791,
0.046987134963274,
-0.4544543921947479,
-0.10865455120801926,
-0.7435378432273865,
0.7798874378204346,
-0.40957435965538025,
-0.24015428125858307,
-0.5080344080924988,
0.7003821730613708,
0.8732395768165588,
-0.5136967897415161,
1.0218944549560547,
0.3000465929508209,
-0.22274217009544373,
-0.12586906552314758,
-0.7576870322227478,
0.0015399976400658488,
-0.4707244336605072,
0.43881329894065857,
-0.7832595705986023,
-0.7890592813491821,
0.8132743239402771,
0.43546897172927856,
0.1297912299633026,
0.20392407476902008,
0.6056653261184692,
0.2244378626346588,
0.9729445576667786,
0.6471782326698303,
-0.6411076784133911,
0.534153163433075,
-0.2253071516752243,
0.33314648270606995,
-0.5882769227027893,
-0.21404822170734406,
-0.6734291911125183,
-0.10094307363033295,
-0.3888343274593353,
-0.3600403368473053,
0.022002123296260834,
0.22667884826660156,
-0.43045127391815186,
0.44750621914863586,
-0.3252158761024475,
1.0441832542419434,
0.4374193251132965,
-0.05053078383207321,
0.3490977883338928,
-0.22264811396598816,
0.014199086464941502,
-0.00515971053391695,
-0.7147454619407654,
-0.28289124369621277,
1.2066926956176758,
0.07918502390384674,
0.9215965270996094,
-0.2473166584968567,
0.741030752658844,
0.005726708099246025,
0.026853693649172783,
-0.8355537056922913,
0.31452274322509766,
-0.18369704484939575,
-0.7953640818595886,
-0.06831563264131546,
-0.5569650530815125,
-0.9408273100852966,
0.2160099297761917,
0.13858653604984283,
-0.7473508715629578,
0.05777733027935028,
0.3102797567844391,
-0.276627779006958,
0.5203344225883484,
-0.6389372944831848,
1.1272692680358887,
-0.24073773622512817,
-0.4775732159614563,
-0.1687006652355194,
-0.7543821930885315,
0.13349567353725433,
-0.13948534429073334,
-0.28155839443206787,
0.41107386350631714,
-0.24951986968517303,
0.24207346141338348,
-0.1663617342710495,
0.568445086479187,
0.13216470181941986,
0.18458391726016998,
0.312146931886673,
0.30379363894462585,
0.49772003293037415,
0.06119978427886963,
-0.12451238185167313,
0.1121172234416008,
0.128635972738266,
-0.5828327536582947,
-0.5447315573692322,
0.8565945625305176,
-0.8017368316650391,
-0.4814252555370331,
-0.15751560032367706,
-0.46554213762283325,
-0.0428767055273056,
0.6227655410766602,
0.268137663602829,
0.4943749010562897,
-0.3286440968513489,
0.3584963381290436,
0.8551215529441833,
-0.0679614469408989,
0.43338915705680847,
0.49257200956344604,
0.02871495671570301,
-0.1718335598707199,
0.623810887336731,
-0.14066261053085327,
0.6181057691574097,
0.46661531925201416,
0.3174678385257721,
-0.17785419523715973,
-0.35596391558647156,
-0.510773241519928,
0.18401102721691132,
-0.9221330285072327,
-0.30506324768066406,
-1.130690336227417,
-0.10655643790960312,
-0.6614083647727966,
0.023689929395914078,
-1.2501057386398315,
-0.26305675506591797,
-0.08122158795595169,
0.13361790776252747,
0.05300470441579819,
0.6785927414894104,
0.06488922983407974,
0.4681665897369385,
-0.7700796127319336,
0.3048635423183441,
0.37980589270591736,
0.45419561862945557,
0.032442644238471985,
-0.24283429980278015,
-0.4109228849411011,
-0.08310717344284058,
-0.043451253324747086,
-0.6114864349365234,
0.4458276927471161,
0.18084345757961273,
0.5326790809631348,
0.6232903599739075,
-0.04766575247049332,
0.8991134762763977,
-0.5840111970901489,
0.616786003112793,
0.0021293796598911285,
-1.2351206541061401,
0.35563406348228455,
-0.00613575940951705,
0.7177999019622803,
0.8654637336730957,
0.2579767405986786,
-0.5596962571144104,
-0.14265458285808563,
-0.4190158545970917,
-0.9253141283988953,
0.8648971915245056,
-0.1432446986436844,
0.4272192716598511,
-0.42154017090797424,
0.4677446186542511,
0.04739579185843468,
0.04823619872331619,
-0.6309559941291809,
-0.48942187428474426,
-0.51003098487854,
0.1335793435573578,
0.00988625455647707,
-0.37617138028144836,
0.07710044085979462,
-0.034056998789310455,
0.4861428141593933,
-0.2649858891963959,
0.2821684777736664,
0.05481798201799393,
-0.2573738694190979,
-0.17947909235954285,
0.15241888165473938,
0.5959565043449402,
0.5870344042778015,
-0.1477741301059723,
0.1565089076757431,
0.10236404091119766,
-0.6650561690330505,
-0.27944499254226685,
-0.40676426887512207,
-0.0788172110915184,
-0.036588143557310104,
0.2528202533721924,
0.8819543719291687,
0.5589722990989685,
-0.5357292294502258,
0.4619112014770508,
-0.4006820321083069,
0.30723315477371216,
0.07594481855630875,
0.180781751871109,
0.3216334283351898,
0.035143379122018814,
0.07615477591753006,
-0.10498295724391937,
0.03983771800994873,
-0.6571605205535889,
0.17537906765937805,
0.28683510422706604,
-0.03252136707305908,
-0.38999590277671814,
0.8856934905052185,
-0.08508362621068954,
-0.06334075331687927,
0.7905085682868958,
-0.17954333126544952,
-0.6421340107917786,
0.579545795917511,
0.986721932888031,
1.050100564956665,
-0.39044642448425293,
-0.08958099037408829,
0.6754419207572937,
0.0694938600063324,
-0.3920934796333313,
0.12467997521162033,
-0.5344868302345276,
-0.7575397491455078,
-0.40225526690483093,
-0.6000175476074219,
-0.027822790667414665,
0.13850168883800507,
-0.9439548254013062,
0.179848775267601,
-0.16624435782432556,
0.06202755123376846,
-0.20575588941574097,
0.14892584085464478,
-0.7960894107818604,
0.07515978813171387,
0.21418330073356628,
0.9199540615081787,
-0.8329223394393921,
1.445159912109375,
0.40065890550613403,
-0.24218861758708954,
-0.5355327129364014,
-0.18048201501369476,
0.008839095011353493,
-0.724317193031311,
0.6099827885627747,
0.198665052652359,
-0.6468569040298462,
0.06900674849748611,
-0.3627873361110687,
-0.8960084319114685,
1.0319496393203735,
0.23487886786460876,
-0.5182358026504517,
-0.16288617253303528,
-0.04209687188267708,
0.3994153141975403,
-0.5358175039291382,
0.4362768530845642,
0.6800013780593872,
0.23057091236114502,
0.21749621629714966,
-0.7466615438461304,
-0.2430635392665863,
-0.30095091462135315,
0.1336997151374817,
0.2922128736972809,
-0.471749871969223,
1.0502694845199585,
-0.34158584475517273,
-0.5041612386703491,
0.09451465308666229,
0.5678764581680298,
-0.05654432252049446,
-0.06194872409105301,
0.5058924555778503,
0.7360432744026184,
0.5955070853233337,
0.1393209993839264,
1.3966424465179443,
-0.5273212790489197,
0.38433048129081726,
1.5030922889709473,
0.0010322830639779568,
0.7697938084602356,
0.24649329483509064,
0.0916263684630394,
0.2758607864379883,
0.1280452460050583,
0.5752163529396057,
0.8356964588165283,
-0.0744989663362503,
-0.06534258276224136,
-0.5009687542915344,
0.12154865264892578,
-0.5133096575737,
0.5176416635513306,
0.07774008065462112,
-0.06901387870311737,
-0.24784968793392181,
-0.2136555314064026,
0.12187113612890244,
-0.13581198453903198,
-0.14853227138519287,
0.5998399257659912,
-0.0656658411026001,
-0.7003501057624817,
0.3846690058708191,
-0.1872536987066269,
0.4617311954498291,
-0.9986602663993835,
0.2481522560119629,
-0.5414819121360779,
0.386494517326355,
0.03962666913866997,
-0.5323652029037476,
0.3632816672325134,
-0.16266898810863495,
-0.5136169791221619,
-0.36287403106689453,
0.5145660042762756,
-0.6238184571266174,
-0.21166428923606873,
0.4330005347728729,
0.35857078433036804,
-0.016601791605353355,
-0.21926645934581757,
-0.39084914326667786,
0.5641583800315857,
-0.25695499777793884,
-0.5049829483032227,
0.23404067754745483,
0.3984786868095398,
0.08530951291322708,
0.8136976361274719,
0.5536195039749146,
0.07260621339082718,
0.5113053321838379,
0.26322299242019653,
1.155511736869812,
-0.6564092636108398,
-0.6113716959953308,
-0.660754919052124,
0.5407894253730774,
0.2040388286113739,
-0.3748444616794586,
0.5063877105712891,
0.7160269618034363,
1.0435872077941895,
-0.11848751455545425,
0.45093435049057007,
0.017855647951364517,
-0.030744167044758797,
-0.31698518991470337,
0.8564736843109131,
-0.8716204166412354,
0.15635007619857788,
-0.05075580254197121,
-0.6635156273841858,
-0.18249821662902832,
0.6947773694992065,
-0.08025778830051422,
-0.05906399339437485,
0.6507218480110168,
0.6842910051345825,
-0.26589474081993103,
-0.06142377108335495,
0.4078792333602905,
0.13026706874370575,
0.4433296322822571,
0.8356043100357056,
0.35575634241104126,
-0.6926937103271484,
0.48276251554489136,
-0.34957870841026306,
0.20337973535060883,
-0.17414113879203796,
-0.8530490398406982,
-0.7292163968086243,
-0.7780426144599915,
-0.2809375822544098,
-0.32525500655174255,
-0.14818541705608368,
0.46660396456718445,
1.1534855365753174,
-0.7700220942497253,
-0.1666615903377533,
-0.015728743746876717,
0.031032687053084373,
-0.15379996597766876,
-0.20172801613807678,
0.19859594106674194,
-0.8060588836669922,
-0.862168550491333,
0.6002300381660461,
0.5032481551170349,
-0.34719622135162354,
-0.29868975281715393,
-0.09203191101551056,
-0.010016744025051594,
0.09276363998651505,
0.387238085269928,
0.461849570274353,
-0.5802164673805237,
-0.00790737010538578,
0.1381198912858963,
-0.5005103945732117,
0.4667908251285553,
1.230018973350525,
-1.1683998107910156,
1.1701323986053467,
0.7468920946121216,
1.084193229675293,
1.001812219619751,
-0.3100857436656952,
0.5498046278953552,
-0.37332436442375183,
0.35156092047691345,
0.3846038281917572,
0.3046227991580963,
-0.09193351119756699,
-0.29203328490257263,
0.1663547158241272,
-0.1425703912973404,
-0.5112327337265015,
-0.6313435435295105,
0.2801508605480194,
-1.183983325958252,
-0.3406136631965637,
0.4980992376804352,
-0.3259042501449585,
-0.4392017722129822,
-0.04448327794671059,
0.20618514716625214,
0.24588486552238464,
-0.30406537652015686,
0.783799946308136,
0.4940067529678345,
0.3877372741699219,
-0.26416513323783875,
-0.7342935800552368,
0.3359827399253845,
0.4820537269115448,
-0.7804573774337769,
0.1022285595536232,
0.20142671465873718,
0.5691647529602051,
0.33849284052848816,
0.6285648345947266,
-0.3402809202671051,
0.3205242156982422,
0.18840117752552032,
-0.0013832335826009512,
-0.40420228242874146,
-0.776617705821991,
-0.44486117362976074,
0.10011263936758041,
-0.3883293569087982,
-0.36758026480674744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05248v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05248v2
|
LLMs with Personalities in Multi-issue Negotiation Games
| 2024-05-08T17:51:53 | 2024-05-09T01:09:09 |
Sean Noh, Ho-Chun Herbert Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MA
|
Powered by large language models (LLMs), AI agents have become capable of
many human tasks. Using the most canonical definitions of the Big Five
personality, we measure the ability of LLMs to negotiate within a
game-theoretical framework, as well as methodological challenges to measuring
notions of fairness and risk. Simulations (n=1,500) for both single-issue and
multi-issue negotiation reveal increase in domain complexity with asymmetric
issue valuations improve agreement rates but decrease surplus from aggressive
negotiation. Through gradient-boosted regression and Shapley explainers, we
find high openness, conscientiousness, and neuroticism are associated with fair
tendencies; low agreeableness and low openness are associated with rational
tendencies. Low conscientiousness is associated with high toxicity. These
results indicate that LLMs may have built-in guardrails that default to fair
behavior, but can be "jail broken" to exploit agreeable opponents. We also
offer pragmatic insight in how negotiation bots can be designed, and a
framework of assessing negotiation behavior based on game theory and
computational social science.
|
[
-0.7178205251693726,
-0.5381422638893127,
0.8730615377426147,
0.2744908630847931,
0.17778412997722626,
0.2196134626865387,
-0.3574599325656891,
-0.47209182381629944,
0.18609175086021423,
0.3814220726490021,
-0.388635516166687,
-0.19659455120563507,
-0.9150621891021729,
0.06877245008945465,
0.08375383913516998,
0.9510107040405273,
0.3209052085876465,
0.071527861058712,
-0.1212644949555397,
-0.31408247351646423,
-0.5722301006317139,
-0.7901290655136108,
-0.9611270427703857,
-0.643944501876831,
0.7175172567367554,
0.25463396310806274,
0.8740266561508179,
0.376756489276886,
0.8267876505851746,
0.43572741746902466,
-0.2141127735376358,
-0.42098966240882874,
-0.3196185827255249,
0.349092036485672,
-0.45209071040153503,
-0.6398419737815857,
-0.6930217742919922,
0.45619478821754456,
0.26579323410987854,
0.5068055987358093,
-0.19116143882274628,
-0.021724078804254532,
-0.280250608921051,
0.7104635834693909,
-0.3375355303287506,
0.23119868338108063,
-1.0313079357147217,
0.06103585660457611,
-0.1482764333486557,
0.1912333071231842,
-0.23943860828876495,
-0.13930362462997437,
0.15048553049564362,
-0.4443594217300415,
-0.3028092682361603,
-0.02076140232384205,
0.7621029615402222,
0.4079269468784332,
-0.7764796614646912,
-0.2552613317966461,
-0.43641331791877747,
0.7520447969436646,
-0.3994033932685852,
-0.09662437438964844,
0.2541382312774658,
0.47153612971305847,
-0.4162524342536926,
-0.4104180335998535,
-0.605134129524231,
-0.3903350532054901,
0.009297685697674751,
0.34709495306015015,
-0.3303197920322418,
0.3005700409412384,
0.5018337965011597,
0.144293874502182,
-0.28524988889694214,
0.2941398024559021,
-0.1260179579257965,
-0.10457129031419754,
1.2181661128997803,
0.3497788608074188,
0.10552828758955002,
-0.021281490102410316,
-0.4148578345775604,
0.12671969830989838,
-0.5186507701873779,
0.305431991815567,
0.8144577741622925,
0.10966362059116364,
-0.1292898803949356,
0.3831956088542938,
0.09547219425439835,
0.30807462334632874,
0.2688485085964203,
0.04614904150366783,
-0.009878531098365784,
-0.21701720356941223,
0.02125594951212406,
-0.3032352030277252,
0.8395824432373047,
0.41008633375167847,
0.7044841051101685,
-0.16565056145191193,
-0.17354153096675873,
0.11421389877796173,
0.491484135389328,
-0.5784336924552917,
-0.12887969613075256,
0.7833163142204285,
-0.6672956943511963,
-0.4428304433822632,
-0.02138633467257023,
-0.7333571910858154,
-0.7018561959266663,
-0.23777644336223602,
0.13577160239219666,
-0.106834277510643,
-0.2902931571006775,
0.014435424469411373,
-0.32901450991630554,
0.6284583806991577,
0.3225766718387604,
-0.5832154750823975,
0.3892907500267029,
0.5737515687942505,
0.587761640548706,
-0.23517341911792755,
-0.5713486075401306,
-0.45014503598213196,
0.12584064900875092,
-0.3963398039340973,
0.8609152436256409,
-0.5840736031532288,
-0.49180519580841064,
-0.28992143273353577,
-0.3715530335903168,
0.13769131898880005,
-0.6529731154441833,
0.46631622314453125,
-0.30658331513404846,
-0.22778895497322083,
-0.40203478932380676,
-0.366142600774765,
0.18866883218288422,
0.8331709504127502,
-0.6363743543624878,
0.37778475880622864,
-0.25030583143234253,
-0.1575966626405716,
0.42986515164375305,
-0.9505416750907898,
-0.39808389544487,
0.035894520580768585,
-0.2308502048254013,
-0.2714090347290039,
0.20881585776805878,
-0.2872999906539917,
0.4476516842842102,
-0.2842969000339508,
0.3886723220348358,
-0.49235665798187256,
-0.20899970829486847,
0.8669894933700562,
-0.2032170295715332,
0.5876786112785339,
0.22327207028865814,
-0.040690235793590546,
0.4694877862930298,
-0.09251461178064346,
-0.2407054454088211,
0.3066447675228119,
-0.541644275188446,
0.045578282326459885,
0.3120175898075104,
-0.15947452187538147,
0.4934881031513214,
0.3735182583332062,
-0.35642722249031067,
0.393958181142807,
-0.17819301784038544,
0.49984443187713623,
1.187795639038086,
-0.262157678604126,
0.347678542137146,
-0.640807569026947,
0.346905916929245,
0.19719597697257996,
0.328750342130661,
0.37951523065567017,
-0.5164464712142944,
-0.6122519969940186,
-0.31115224957466125,
0.16480472683906555,
0.474188894033432,
-0.3942541778087616,
0.3358881175518036,
-0.233650341629982,
-0.5232604742050171,
-0.5143802165985107,
-0.15624791383743286,
0.4000134766101837,
-0.167463481426239,
0.06866655498743057,
-0.5628142952919006,
-0.038262978196144104,
-0.6686848998069763,
-0.6564303636550903,
-0.17645588517189026,
0.2021067887544632,
0.5866758227348328,
0.6576470136642456,
0.007727975491434336,
0.7041870951652527,
-0.35600027441978455,
-0.4176922142505646,
-0.18153266608715057,
0.22539950907230377,
0.1161709576845169,
0.3062819838523865,
0.5632545948028564,
-0.8192722201347351,
-0.481145441532135,
-0.022630393505096436,
-0.5249108672142029,
0.3201647698879242,
-0.0627027079463005,
-0.02787020057439804,
0.284432590007782,
0.5255946516990662,
-0.6954091191291809,
0.2523213028907776,
0.05569713935256004,
-0.5396155118942261,
0.6055845618247986,
-0.2655772864818573,
0.012429650872945786,
-0.8514798879623413,
-0.027991073206067085,
0.081838458776474,
-0.08987729996442795,
-0.6270624399185181,
0.3272668123245239,
-0.4303213953971863,
-0.07678482681512833,
-0.5261343717575073,
0.7084105014801025,
-0.34723374247550964,
-0.35264328122138977,
-0.24845199286937714,
0.4581214189529419,
-0.28202277421951294,
0.5604602098464966,
0.007439702749252319,
0.6151570677757263,
0.3889862596988678,
-0.6987636089324951,
0.5859467387199402,
0.07645224034786224,
0.01151419896632433,
1.079626441001892,
-0.5897986888885498,
0.3027893602848053,
-0.385168194770813,
0.3021734654903412,
-0.6756118535995483,
-0.1546938568353653,
0.089686319231987,
-0.3869474530220032,
-0.05773109197616577,
-0.1266109049320221,
-0.24813693761825562,
-0.2470165342092514,
-0.5544611811637878,
0.254817932844162,
0.37911257147789,
-0.03613419458270073,
0.7064757943153381,
0.45740726590156555,
-0.2708263695240021,
-0.6480475068092346,
-0.5534471273422241,
0.3417263925075531,
-0.5318728089332581,
-0.27198106050491333,
0.5228170156478882,
-0.41652795672416687,
-0.6868540644645691,
-0.28708866238594055,
0.17442618310451508,
-0.03912899270653725,
0.39128372073173523,
0.03960808739066124,
-0.036702871322631836,
0.16732433438301086,
0.05031508207321167,
-0.18640407919883728,
-0.43258652091026306,
0.23825187981128693,
0.17264026403427124,
0.559468150138855,
-0.3363938331604004,
-0.43695253133773804,
-0.1208183541893959,
0.3745999336242676,
0.7855392098426819,
-0.5194892883300781,
0.6408225893974304,
0.34175100922584534,
-0.3626224100589752,
0.19780714809894562,
-0.4486280381679535,
-0.1718258559703827,
-0.43526726961135864,
0.45054057240486145,
-0.8114506602287292,
-0.7964934706687927,
1.1037317514419556,
-0.21250881254673004,
0.1775195598602295,
0.3606618344783783,
0.812492311000824,
-0.10334588587284088,
1.0214134454727173,
0.3105488121509552,
-0.1971382200717926,
0.36938661336898804,
0.044956959784030914,
0.2392231822013855,
-0.6519339084625244,
-0.3086073100566864,
-0.5863099694252014,
-0.6530119776725769,
-0.7940353155136108,
-0.1728253960609436,
0.2753204107284546,
-0.1721547693014145,
-0.8467203378677368,
-0.15571001172065735,
-0.36829873919487,
0.7788469791412354,
0.41635236144065857,
0.013543514534831047,
0.42877835035324097,
-0.5129567980766296,
0.3453148603439331,
-0.13572487235069275,
-0.21672846376895905,
-0.5186154246330261,
1.0137568712234497,
0.4843369424343109,
0.5536528825759888,
0.8163362145423889,
0.5226689577102661,
0.3189854621887207,
0.32867199182510376,
-1.0754244327545166,
0.6021152138710022,
-0.09530127048492432,
-0.808233916759491,
-0.37739458680152893,
-0.4298141896724701,
-1.1234925985336304,
0.27340924739837646,
-0.38397160172462463,
-0.7947931289672852,
0.228830948472023,
-0.012736853212118149,
-0.3722843527793884,
0.14140185713768005,
-0.4734056890010834,
0.7534754872322083,
-0.5296059846878052,
-0.2664032578468323,
-0.40571340918540955,
-0.700465977191925,
0.3834306299686432,
0.08439668267965317,
0.14786070585250854,
-0.46634694933891296,
-0.21349158883094788,
0.3869301974773407,
0.09800431877374649,
0.6702514290809631,
-0.10129550099372864,
-0.034052204340696335,
-0.10259182751178741,
0.29771527647972107,
0.5568446516990662,
0.0031343032605946064,
-0.23692265152931213,
0.19595012068748474,
0.06804291158914566,
-0.662280797958374,
-0.6391060948371887,
0.42146435379981995,
-1.099979043006897,
-0.7297751903533936,
-0.8103426694869995,
-0.6876941919326782,
-0.07678849995136261,
-0.00883004441857338,
-0.007922207936644554,
-0.17617875337600708,
-0.48979130387306213,
-0.11030565947294235,
0.6136413216590881,
-0.17446169257164001,
0.39709731936454773,
0.5410289764404297,
-0.039818715304136276,
-0.12038159370422363,
0.9957734942436218,
0.031977180391550064,
0.3429277241230011,
-0.17259544134140015,
0.1432739794254303,
-0.11762610822916031,
-0.6156395077705383,
0.052680667489767075,
0.03980961814522743,
-0.5537392497062683,
-0.3255927264690399,
-0.19434644281864166,
-0.23999270796775818,
-0.11513768881559372,
-0.37136518955230713,
-0.4046212434768677,
-0.05541861802339554,
0.019696833565831184,
0.021477939561009407,
0.3409235179424286,
0.9674980044364929,
-0.026313308626413345,
0.4399835467338562,
-0.33362916111946106,
0.15605923533439636,
0.377338707447052,
0.46069249510765076,
0.04182678088545799,
-0.2757977247238159,
0.049592792987823486,
-0.0716727077960968,
-0.5721364617347717,
-0.898081362247467,
0.2068307101726532,
-0.07865358889102936,
0.722246527671814,
0.4973301887512207,
0.105492003262043,
0.2520553469657898,
-0.23638564348220825,
0.874761700630188,
0.1426045149564743,
-1.0506645441055298,
0.23736460506916046,
-0.5523769855499268,
-0.161082461476326,
0.4541659951210022,
0.19687184691429138,
-0.5512332320213318,
-0.3137727677822113,
-0.7368524670600891,
-0.6559816002845764,
0.6685277223587036,
0.08356894552707672,
0.2382524609565735,
0.08082098513841629,
0.4537574350833893,
-0.09866722673177719,
0.45595091581344604,
-1.052391529083252,
-0.34372761845588684,
0.040785811841487885,
-0.2159179300069809,
0.00659056194126606,
-0.012807321734726429,
-0.5755781531333923,
-0.07010878622531891,
0.37725144624710083,
-0.26352351903915405,
0.3954024910926819,
-0.24996978044509888,
0.05837949365377426,
0.17861588299274445,
0.6099170446395874,
0.6833489537239075,
0.5257707834243774,
-0.10879117995500565,
0.17386427521705627,
0.11898173391819,
-0.2204098254442215,
0.4331415891647339,
0.1777772158384323,
0.5453559756278992,
-0.7365309596061707,
0.3029913008213043,
0.48522886633872986,
-0.172744482755661,
-0.7443452477455139,
0.6699315905570984,
-0.2066640406847,
-0.4812411069869995,
-0.27834251523017883,
0.14011535048484802,
0.039878569543361664,
0.7351574301719666,
0.12348072975873947,
-0.23647147417068481,
0.021310729905962944,
-0.9162749648094177,
-0.004404628183692694,
0.7941264510154724,
-0.2873418629169464,
-0.1384553760290146,
0.4557505249977112,
0.581050455570221,
-0.6138134598731995,
0.5139474272727966,
-0.468228280544281,
-0.4810793697834015,
0.8655902147293091,
0.17407754063606262,
0.5947472453117371,
-0.037152569741010666,
0.2219914048910141,
-0.27907171845436096,
0.3769264817237854,
0.14429426193237305,
0.359184592962265,
0.3238199055194855,
-1.0429291725158691,
-0.25723108649253845,
-0.12708066403865814,
-0.7822086215019226,
0.10915257781744003,
-0.5464625954627991,
0.020027615129947662,
-0.5121485590934753,
-0.4387195408344269,
-0.037545133382081985,
0.47712865471839905,
-0.7841156721115112,
-0.28367140889167786,
-0.032887835055589676,
0.5910816192626953,
-0.6630143523216248,
0.4967232048511505,
0.9063218832015991,
-0.6840225458145142,
-0.39026927947998047,
0.24546121060848236,
-0.12380823493003845,
-0.7636098265647888,
0.4440435469150543,
-0.17531803250312805,
0.302303671836853,
-0.04957016184926033,
-0.7106643915176392,
-0.6175476312637329,
1.0452367067337036,
0.7566877007484436,
-0.21173714101314545,
-0.039906151592731476,
0.0689891055226326,
0.38133496046066284,
-0.32675525546073914,
0.35124683380126953,
0.9167138338088989,
0.8261876702308655,
-0.030928457155823708,
-0.8722110390663147,
0.000886276364326477,
0.006021319888532162,
-0.17291872203350067,
0.03379413112998009,
-1.2482532262802124,
0.887640655040741,
-0.27834823727607727,
0.31507593393325806,
-0.02205304615199566,
0.4720102846622467,
0.6397934556007385,
0.3804941773414612,
0.4302472174167633,
0.3416503369808197,
0.7684499025344849,
-0.2419760674238205,
0.8442229628562927,
-0.21890288591384888,
0.2661941945552826,
0.6909383535385132,
-0.7489424347877502,
0.4682415723800659,
0.47804176807403564,
-0.3012784421443939,
0.47789910435676575,
0.7152417898178101,
0.11733902245759964,
0.2598089575767517,
0.6406680941581726,
-0.2061464637517929,
-0.4483019709587097,
-0.22549156844615936,
-0.01885928586125374,
0.7274379730224609,
0.39996859431266785,
0.03553815558552742,
-0.06210935860872269,
-0.1422995626926422,
0.3843802511692047,
0.13078875839710236,
-0.42743030190467834,
0.856072187423706,
0.29126426577568054,
-0.6072613596916199,
-0.2643817961215973,
0.22197896242141724,
0.8076297044754028,
-0.41091954708099365,
0.035208236426115036,
-0.26319777965545654,
0.0670204609632492,
0.028477175161242485,
-1.0790287256240845,
0.17673364281654358,
-0.2378574162721634,
-0.19430163502693176,
-0.29532501101493835,
0.6093325018882751,
-0.23044182360172272,
-0.1637745350599289,
0.30332374572753906,
0.790411651134491,
0.41277363896369934,
-0.16181571781635284,
-0.9665471315383911,
0.026299746707081795,
-0.5005325078964233,
-0.43960726261138916,
0.7018129229545593,
0.51137375831604,
0.0018464823951944709,
0.787308394908905,
0.37470123171806335,
0.24409200251102448,
-0.3089064955711365,
-0.19559346139431,
0.6610741019248962,
-0.8477495908737183,
-0.2981796860694885,
-0.8822195529937744,
0.6910384297370911,
-0.24184684455394745,
-0.33878079056739807,
0.2740241289138794,
0.09249044954776764,
0.544042706489563,
0.25849252939224243,
0.7336598634719849,
0.05552973225712776,
-0.04872392863035202,
-0.5007425546646118,
0.9518197774887085,
-0.3523794710636139,
0.0013704041484743357,
-0.15075264871120453,
-0.5609233975410461,
-0.053679704666137695,
0.7063243985176086,
-0.40258222818374634,
0.3784114420413971,
0.507908284664154,
0.4174036979675293,
0.13200274109840393,
-0.32490840554237366,
0.4031510353088379,
0.23620612919330597,
0.5263043642044067,
0.79298335313797,
0.813156008720398,
-0.04684249684214592,
0.5517961978912354,
0.24987496435642242,
-0.1387341022491455,
-0.11369581520557404,
-0.7626091241836548,
-1.0884912014007568,
-0.5477501153945923,
-0.18835072219371796,
-0.3453391194343567,
-0.016348646953701973,
0.9636249542236328,
0.46318620443344116,
-0.3100285828113556,
-0.5248168706893921,
0.19264361262321472,
0.7237839102745056,
-0.1814984530210495,
-0.24400030076503754,
0.07630353420972824,
-0.2920784652233124,
-0.7210461497306824,
0.03122657909989357,
0.11673033237457275,
0.08791563659906387,
-0.4653167128562927,
-0.1789551079273224,
-0.07460752874612808,
0.49666357040405273,
0.6155444383621216,
0.10699424147605896,
-0.7986475825309753,
-0.4610256254673004,
-0.1838436871767044,
-0.17141327261924744,
0.1138073280453682,
0.848108172416687,
-0.47749102115631104,
0.09025903046131134,
0.09773571789264679,
0.34646517038345337,
0.06656716763973236,
-0.12387914955615997,
0.5378580689430237,
-0.6448542475700378,
0.28950926661491394,
0.38460683822631836,
0.2875995635986328,
-0.1086379662156105,
-0.2795616686344147,
0.4178786873817444,
0.1297367513179779,
-0.6155564188957214,
-0.766768753528595,
0.6175627112388611,
-0.6927339434623718,
-0.35350939631462097,
0.8957497477531433,
-0.05463164299726486,
0.11842403560876846,
-0.24761486053466797,
-0.10654093325138092,
-0.05336017161607742,
-0.643626868724823,
0.7843385338783264,
1.1332032680511475,
-0.5672222971916199,
-0.05006135255098343,
-0.5709598660469055,
0.6231140494346619,
0.2604049742221832,
-1.0341060161590576,
-0.004426761996001005,
0.43481341004371643,
-0.0186625886708498,
0.2199806272983551,
0.9009049534797668,
0.18320704996585846,
0.21933962404727936,
-0.229838564991951,
0.21160565316677094,
0.12422394007444382,
-0.3840588331222534,
-0.3822072148323059,
0.19775770604610443,
0.5062850117683411,
0.10697206854820251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05204v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05204v1
|
CARE-SD: Classifier-based analysis for recognizing and eliminating stigmatizing and doubt marker labels in electronic health records: model development and validation
| 2024-05-08T16:40:18 | 2024-05-08T16:40:18 |
Drew Walker, Annie Thorne, Sudeshna Das, Jennifer Love, Hannah LF Cooper, Melvin Livingston III, Abeed Sarker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Objective: To detect and classify features of stigmatizing and biased
language in intensive care electronic health records (EHRs) using natural
language processing techniques. Materials and Methods: We first created a
lexicon and regular expression lists from literature-driven stem words for
linguistic features of stigmatizing patient labels, doubt markers, and scare
quotes within EHRs. The lexicon was further extended using Word2Vec and GPT
3.5, and refined through human evaluation. These lexicons were used to search
for matches across 18 million sentences from the de-identified Medical
Information Mart for Intensive Care-III (MIMIC-III) dataset. For each
linguistic bias feature, 1000 sentence matches were sampled, labeled by expert
clinical and public health annotators, and used to supervised learning
classifiers. Results: Lexicon development from expanded literature stem-word
lists resulted in a doubt marker lexicon containing 58 expressions, and a
stigmatizing labels lexicon containing 127 expressions. Classifiers for doubt
markers and stigmatizing labels had the highest performance, with macro
F1-scores of .84 and .79, positive-label recall and precision values ranging
from .71 to .86, and accuracies aligning closely with human annotator agreement
(.87). Discussion: This study demonstrated the feasibility of supervised
classifiers in automatically identifying stigmatizing labels and doubt markers
in medical text, and identified trends in stigmatizing language use in an EHR
setting. Additional labeled data may help improve lower scare quote model
performance. Conclusions: Classifiers developed in this study showed high model
performance and can be applied to identify patterns and target interventions to
reduce stigmatizing labels and doubt markers in healthcare systems.
|
[
-0.28206634521484375,
-0.734672486782074,
0.5565720796585083,
-0.0165676549077034,
-0.14344674348831177,
-0.020500898361206055,
0.027395764365792274,
-0.6951092481613159,
0.22161877155303955,
0.6003933548927307,
-0.2726041078567505,
-0.9107210636138916,
-0.7901194095611572,
0.358074814081192,
-0.12163324654102325,
1.253828525543213,
-0.14460793137550354,
0.09978441148996353,
0.025560583919286728,
0.018169451504945755,
-0.2880963981151581,
-0.9498857855796814,
-0.7160043120384216,
0.016309237107634544,
0.2410655915737152,
0.30067604780197144,
0.5651602745056152,
0.5218976140022278,
0.8527334332466125,
0.18044231832027435,
-0.218306764960289,
0.19571514427661896,
-0.1365821808576584,
0.2265673577785492,
0.3812631070613861,
-0.39822983741760254,
-0.6386117935180664,
-0.26884353160858154,
0.35865306854248047,
0.1777769923210144,
-0.09959281980991364,
0.25252586603164673,
-0.19800075888633728,
0.5713932514190674,
-0.6281580924987793,
0.3137606084346771,
-0.5272785425186157,
0.20422771573066711,
-0.46700620651245117,
-0.058120645582675934,
-0.5231826901435852,
-0.5734488368034363,
0.10094831138849258,
-0.48172834515571594,
0.46090567111968994,
0.2430056780576706,
1.083548665046692,
0.5923471450805664,
-0.23736804723739624,
-0.44587352871894836,
-0.526984453201294,
0.5588037371635437,
-0.596062183380127,
0.49375274777412415,
0.6354663968086243,
0.04903200641274452,
0.16357694566249847,
-0.5288622975349426,
-0.3802643120288849,
-0.08763565123081207,
-0.20245611667633057,
0.06242995709180832,
-0.42482468485832214,
0.4994277060031891,
0.643417477607727,
0.2805943787097931,
-0.4999513626098633,
0.2240607589483261,
-0.5589808225631714,
-0.5687344670295715,
0.5577490329742432,
0.1316317766904831,
0.37549060583114624,
-0.522011399269104,
-0.37105265259742737,
0.17918069660663605,
-0.28227683901786804,
0.08225635439157486,
0.029749317094683647,
-0.02021517977118492,
0.005737779196351767,
0.6816762089729309,
-0.10438656806945801,
0.46850043535232544,
-0.19685904681682587,
-0.32570773363113403,
0.5545109510421753,
0.07866157591342926,
-0.41951844096183777,
0.34416916966438293,
0.8276961445808411,
0.5896586179733276,
0.27013838291168213,
0.0027480456046760082,
-0.31024956703186035,
0.48649001121520996,
0.3895052373409271,
-0.5732932090759277,
-0.4014403820037842,
0.3097030818462372,
-0.4768323004245758,
-0.1179673820734024,
-0.14144814014434814,
-0.7833296656608582,
-0.508796751499176,
-0.13668213784694672,
0.123041070997715,
-0.5208892226219177,
0.030717898160219193,
0.13216324150562286,
-0.19605161249637604,
-0.16478794813156128,
0.3481746315956116,
-0.43099072575569153,
0.6115788221359253,
0.4773821532726288,
0.8511090874671936,
-0.5002474784851074,
0.5535003542900085,
-0.3423880636692047,
-0.05664239823818207,
-0.2178473025560379,
0.686703622341156,
-0.44397395849227905,
-0.3680122494697571,
0.3539656400680542,
0.06940202414989471,
-0.14022038877010345,
-0.8289240598678589,
1.2244895696640015,
-0.34541118144989014,
0.0953579694032669,
-0.022731643170118332,
-0.679223358631134,
-0.1428445428609848,
0.19684065878391266,
-0.7605509161949158,
1.218213438987732,
0.19498129189014435,
-0.9433671832084656,
0.6894462704658508,
-0.6840625405311584,
-0.41565585136413574,
0.3117391765117645,
0.049877651035785675,
-0.8491533994674683,
-0.11808455735445023,
0.22652645409107208,
0.5965948104858398,
-0.2468697726726532,
0.42291325330734253,
-0.1653757393360138,
-0.19724471867084503,
0.23544429242610931,
-0.260379433631897,
0.392320841550827,
0.30703791975975037,
-0.3070341944694519,
0.04870027303695679,
-0.8805128931999207,
0.029859347268939018,
-0.23014064133167267,
-0.3658794164657593,
-0.7361162900924683,
-0.017430759966373444,
0.43907439708709717,
0.32260769605636597,
-0.05082572251558304,
-0.619110107421875,
0.05120755732059479,
-0.2795864939689636,
-0.011686649173498154,
0.4097553491592407,
0.3530804514884949,
-0.16642247140407562,
-0.4024999737739563,
0.589964747428894,
0.4027300477027893,
0.5747705698013306,
0.09262058138847351,
-0.8737592101097107,
-0.8438050150871277,
-0.6761934757232666,
-0.057799212634563446,
0.607925534248352,
-0.5923708081245422,
0.5041643381118774,
-0.1276642382144928,
-0.21389953792095184,
-1.0152904987335205,
-0.19669117033481598,
0.5975832343101501,
0.7413987517356873,
0.9325940012931824,
-0.3206999599933624,
-0.7232194542884827,
-1.2218976020812988,
-0.24131514132022858,
-0.5963224768638611,
0.08443921059370041,
0.32526692748069763,
0.3400958478450775,
-0.6024536490440369,
0.7269731760025024,
-0.7779533863067627,
-0.7139618396759033,
0.21874701976776123,
0.18884864449501038,
-0.04303783178329468,
0.25873950123786926,
0.22034727036952972,
-0.7872195243835449,
-0.2719114422798157,
0.07039274275302887,
-0.4611037075519562,
-0.3388040363788605,
0.17620263993740082,
0.2134769856929779,
0.3175777196884155,
0.4137435257434845,
-0.3295537829399109,
0.647117018699646,
0.13724513351917267,
-0.23966056108474731,
0.5146263241767883,
0.057872969657182693,
0.2717190384864807,
-0.8712460398674011,
-0.11260395497083664,
0.3522377908229828,
0.0815836489200592,
-0.8349042534828186,
-0.3570237457752228,
0.06799577176570892,
0.29149752855300903,
-0.39478933811187744,
0.2488073706626892,
-0.31080302596092224,
0.6168904900550842,
0.1451740562915802,
-0.2862086594104767,
0.05553236976265907,
0.16123653948307037,
0.2836136519908905,
0.4081723690032959,
0.4719633162021637,
-0.5966336131095886,
-0.044625360518693924,
0.20093189179897308,
-0.22904665768146515,
0.5221509337425232,
-0.2659617066383362,
-0.04171536862850189,
-0.255514919757843,
-0.030954616144299507,
-0.9033672213554382,
-0.3342636525630951,
0.4286949038505554,
-0.13633418083190918,
0.2748706042766571,
-0.25552988052368164,
-0.32873058319091797,
-0.5343526601791382,
-0.10725700855255127,
0.2819748818874359,
0.41283705830574036,
0.005780404899269342,
0.2538619637489319,
0.666897714138031,
-0.10082375258207321,
-0.372549831867218,
-0.6967062950134277,
-0.06824882328510284,
-0.3808695077896118,
-0.07866089046001434,
0.21843087673187256,
0.05252370610833168,
-0.45439213514328003,
-0.18095138669013977,
-0.15323905646800995,
-0.454167902469635,
0.05378865823149681,
0.5462402105331421,
0.5965914130210876,
-0.16550402343273163,
0.5700531601905823,
0.32846707105636597,
0.11373115330934525,
0.3418900966644287,
-0.05741503834724426,
0.19343999028205872,
-0.05225313827395439,
-0.31173133850097656,
-0.6852653622627258,
0.32120418548583984,
0.5579527020454407,
-0.002042375737801194,
0.6369143128395081,
0.6543067097663879,
-0.8813892006874084,
0.1157301813364029,
-1.0245100259780884,
-0.017718253657221794,
-0.3424617648124695,
0.3945249319076538,
-0.29838231205940247,
-1.085260272026062,
0.3275411128997803,
0.06701091676950455,
-0.19063910841941833,
0.6116558909416199,
0.45258232951164246,
0.05411430448293686,
0.9391700029373169,
0.42577603459358215,
-0.13469505310058594,
-0.03570512682199478,
0.0304761603474617,
0.1908445656299591,
-0.9235699772834778,
-0.5725063681602478,
-0.7782397866249084,
0.17009355127811432,
-0.748443603515625,
-0.7102468609809875,
0.5867400169372559,
0.06951059401035309,
-0.12053188681602478,
0.08517984300851822,
-0.9994867444038391,
-0.1543891280889511,
0.11154747009277344,
0.40860846638679504,
0.33881932497024536,
-0.05736294388771057,
-0.23019148409366608,
-0.4486755430698395,
-0.3613812029361725,
-0.7100456357002258,
0.8544406890869141,
0.7513666152954102,
0.5762549042701721,
-0.027964038774371147,
0.7936616539955139,
0.5471757650375366,
0.9053904414176941,
-1.0728765726089478,
0.17642737925052643,
-0.04666098579764366,
-0.6940542459487915,
-0.09427335858345032,
-0.27479904890060425,
-0.5694619417190552,
0.01244512852281332,
-0.10447407513856888,
-0.86707603931427,
0.36473438143730164,
0.05398443341255188,
-0.33931973576545715,
0.3508833348751068,
-0.8779972791671753,
0.6207768321037292,
-0.18976007401943207,
0.14059700071811676,
0.30067044496536255,
-0.499603271484375,
0.3170624077320099,
-0.21310041844844818,
0.40499550104141235,
-0.00885910913348198,
-0.16738180816173553,
1.0146549940109253,
-0.3768024146556854,
0.8503413796424866,
-0.015469697304069996,
-0.11103790253400803,
0.24463383853435516,
0.06200197711586952,
0.18595321476459503,
0.02781786397099495,
-0.27445316314697266,
0.32909223437309265,
0.12450280785560608,
0.002535774139687419,
-0.1406124085187912,
0.22234727442264557,
-0.7931933999061584,
-0.6631026864051819,
-0.5357407927513123,
-0.14930738508701324,
-0.3249732553958893,
0.12368080765008926,
0.43853360414505005,
0.23841646313667297,
-0.24601688981056213,
-0.16904813051223755,
0.9037601351737976,
-0.2563757002353668,
-0.09326642751693726,
0.5050888061523438,
0.013516946695744991,
-0.3708319365978241,
0.7276059985160828,
0.10747336596250534,
0.10577983409166336,
0.4902440905570984,
0.13185083866119385,
-0.19924859702587128,
-0.5668715238571167,
-0.27306997776031494,
0.24913010001182556,
-0.5640724301338196,
-0.3333134651184082,
-1.2738722562789917,
-0.409272700548172,
-0.49174410104751587,
0.1137990728020668,
0.03441557660698891,
-0.07318486273288727,
-0.5878596901893616,
-0.3133752942085266,
0.5762293934822083,
0.865260899066925,
0.1220540776848793,
0.1687442511320114,
-0.6113894581794739,
0.35806289315223694,
-0.12497605383396149,
0.22263705730438232,
-0.33491945266723633,
-0.47403162717819214,
-0.21265533566474915,
-0.28566354513168335,
-0.15718795359134674,
-1.206360936164856,
0.5588608384132385,
0.18725095689296722,
0.24668753147125244,
0.7089724540710449,
0.2885027527809143,
0.5951719880104065,
-0.43935978412628174,
0.807275116443634,
0.32890585064888,
-0.9037814140319824,
0.8876323103904724,
-0.08068066835403442,
-0.0787954330444336,
0.6054467558860779,
0.83829665184021,
-0.6981676816940308,
-0.6705473065376282,
-0.6832050085067749,
-0.9767128825187683,
0.7106084227561951,
0.07950755208730698,
-0.5112000107765198,
-0.32937294244766235,
0.4002191126346588,
0.040833745151758194,
0.15461347997188568,
-0.4793969988822937,
-0.7348000407218933,
0.019612722098827362,
-0.3637998402118683,
-0.03353486582636833,
-0.5029874444007874,
-0.28092479705810547,
-0.22697150707244873,
0.6754340529441833,
-0.163113534450531,
0.1594904512166977,
0.5926758646965027,
-0.08705360442399979,
-0.3202586770057678,
0.5982898473739624,
0.3115130364894867,
0.16447095572948456,
-0.1934332549571991,
0.2956564426422119,
0.18571880459785461,
-0.9249458312988281,
0.11817585676908493,
0.27989792823791504,
-0.4463922083377838,
0.42612752318382263,
0.16683906316757202,
0.9985061883926392,
-0.045816779136657715,
-0.5098351240158081,
0.4835973381996155,
-0.10028377920389175,
-0.015569386072456837,
-0.29832029342651367,
0.008049232885241508,
-0.327777624130249,
-0.22618933022022247,
0.17274387180805206,
0.3716457188129425,
0.6622223854064941,
-0.008948546834290028,
0.3676263391971588,
0.20910659432411194,
-1.1723315715789795,
-0.23634038865566254,
0.5909578204154968,
-0.2960622310638428,
-0.2370748221874237,
0.3964625597000122,
-0.004166684579104185,
-0.6944960951805115,
0.5390016436576843,
0.34707748889923096,
0.8914425373077393,
-0.3514854609966278,
0.6420480012893677,
0.4299653470516205,
0.681832492351532,
-0.0970849022269249,
0.31779682636260986,
0.04990670457482338,
-0.560454249382019,
-0.16267083585262299,
-0.7302380204200745,
-0.4311869442462921,
0.12801580131053925,
-1.2034481763839722,
0.3267052471637726,
-0.35599902272224426,
-0.6541681885719299,
0.09288152307271957,
-0.18358394503593445,
-0.9656798839569092,
0.6151987314224243,
0.35790902376174927,
0.7069395184516907,
-1.1473870277404785,
0.6260952949523926,
0.9985645413398743,
-0.3739846348762512,
-0.9803822636604309,
0.05383215472102165,
0.3573364317417145,
-0.5203059315681458,
0.739539623260498,
0.3383614420890808,
0.1377035528421402,
-0.35702601075172424,
-0.3564283549785614,
-0.5618891716003418,
0.5390563607215881,
0.03808852657675743,
-0.6797071695327759,
0.14028997719287872,
0.18765923380851746,
0.9742415547370911,
-0.1872279793024063,
0.5698041319847107,
0.7625339031219482,
0.45495176315307617,
-0.2777770459651947,
-1.126105785369873,
0.2622133195400238,
-0.338761568069458,
-0.11144986748695374,
0.3359425663948059,
-0.44050687551498413,
0.46634483337402344,
-0.1389724761247635,
-0.34649065136909485,
-0.146205335855484,
0.34781312942504883,
0.24010692536830902,
0.5840330123901367,
0.35926342010498047,
0.7687389254570007,
1.0301145315170288,
-0.3727911412715912,
0.9160980582237244,
0.12356722354888916,
0.30721426010131836,
0.6620395183563232,
-0.41272902488708496,
0.6845896244049072,
0.5224146842956543,
-0.1843341439962387,
0.6871118545532227,
0.4905672073364258,
0.2399711012840271,
0.15504804253578186,
0.36694857478141785,
-0.5794559121131897,
-0.2298240065574646,
-0.6399559378623962,
-0.3327869474887848,
0.13701143860816956,
0.8187857866287231,
-0.4716988503932953,
0.2144831120967865,
0.3509259521961212,
0.3415552079677582,
-0.17125138640403748,
-0.07831032574176788,
1.018468976020813,
0.1511206179857254,
-0.6120975017547607,
0.5530957579612732,
-0.11009994894266129,
0.6628920435905457,
-0.410615473985672,
-0.1637856364250183,
0.21172259747982025,
0.21308887004852295,
-0.43526291847229004,
-0.6144159436225891,
0.1487683653831482,
0.125361368060112,
-0.35427701473236084,
-0.14994622766971588,
0.7193952798843384,
-0.29508674144744873,
-0.5617702007293701,
0.31470170617103577,
0.4262494444847107,
0.3478914201259613,
0.19593331217765808,
-0.7319173812866211,
0.27116867899894714,
0.009872380644083023,
-0.053615640848875046,
0.10188929736614227,
0.6077631115913391,
-0.3677542805671692,
0.625903844833374,
0.5578534603118896,
0.5615482330322266,
0.0937916561961174,
0.3942968249320984,
0.8364607691764832,
-0.391679048538208,
-0.4639766216278076,
-0.600629448890686,
0.38062506914138794,
0.038381773978471756,
-0.6565887928009033,
0.44079071283340454,
0.6731346845626831,
0.7868348956108093,
-0.19601544737815857,
0.8779752850532532,
-0.0501314215362072,
0.7142110466957092,
-0.3943117558956146,
0.628995418548584,
-0.3658068776130676,
0.18263624608516693,
-0.5727816224098206,
-0.3611654043197632,
-0.6213629245758057,
0.4534606635570526,
-0.42032748460769653,
-0.14396439492702484,
0.7747272253036499,
0.7272189259529114,
0.3945666253566742,
0.11231884360313416,
0.2859339118003845,
0.44811004400253296,
0.36040958762168884,
0.24317015707492828,
0.592340886592865,
-0.5933689475059509,
0.19685164093971252,
-0.3992421329021454,
-0.4018392264842987,
-0.20307457447052002,
-0.4225449860095978,
-0.7345715165138245,
-0.5322830080986023,
-0.8025767803192139,
-0.6187817454338074,
0.3186629116535187,
0.9229639172554016,
0.5074413418769836,
-1.2675896883010864,
0.13712027668952942,
0.28248754143714905,
0.10113085061311722,
-0.2710750997066498,
-0.351177841424942,
0.5394791960716248,
-0.19920948147773743,
-0.47183236479759216,
-0.10289311408996582,
0.4765869677066803,
-0.07304142415523529,
-0.09959563612937927,
0.0297625120729208,
-0.17984265089035034,
-0.37308841943740845,
0.5007976293563843,
0.07619713246822357,
-0.9116768836975098,
-0.20457886159420013,
0.08487708121538162,
-0.42921024560928345,
0.09297096729278564,
0.7944667935371399,
-0.6092491745948792,
0.7495238184928894,
0.15315128862857819,
0.4118243455886841,
0.0817500501871109,
0.05250357463955879,
-0.020927172154188156,
-0.458234578371048,
-0.15292972326278687,
0.6878960132598877,
0.35080599784851074,
0.41624915599823,
-0.7954922318458557,
0.2914555072784424,
0.4084910750389099,
-0.33719339966773987,
-0.7897115349769592,
-0.0920688807964325,
-0.850104033946991,
0.17123264074325562,
1.186784029006958,
-0.17986878752708435,
-0.16331088542938232,
-0.7999709844589233,
-0.4331974387168884,
0.44847020506858826,
-0.5402950644493103,
0.829402506351471,
0.5192852020263672,
-0.3198417127132416,
-0.035489119589328766,
-0.6457269191741943,
0.8907386064529419,
0.33955132961273193,
-0.9408078193664551,
-0.2701314091682434,
0.5245167016983032,
0.09265081584453583,
0.3020198941230774,
0.8416509628295898,
-0.3801760673522949,
0.12182004004716873,
-0.478215754032135,
0.470912903547287,
0.3111436665058136,
-0.12832841277122498,
-0.33429837226867676,
0.21345172822475433,
0.05282232165336609,
-0.1252603977918625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05189v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05189v2
|
MIDGARD: Self-Consistency Using Minimum Description Length for Structured Commonsense Reasoning
| 2024-05-08T16:25:42 | 2024-06-02T18:47:44 |
Inderjeet Nair, Lu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We study the task of conducting structured reasoning as generating a
reasoning graph from natural language input using large language models (LLMs).
Previous approaches have explored various prompting schemes, yet they suffer
from error propagation due to the autoregressive nature and single-pass-based
decoding, which lack error correction capability. Additionally, relying solely
on a single sample may result in the omission of true nodes and edges. To
counter this, we draw inspiration from self-consistency (SC), which involves
sampling a diverse set of reasoning chains and taking the majority vote as the
final answer. To tackle the substantial challenge of applying SC on generated
graphs, we propose MIDGARD (MInimum Description length Guided Aggregation of
Reasoning in Directed acyclic graph) that leverages Minimum Description Length
(MDL)-based formulation to identify consistent properties among the different
graph samples generated by an LLM. This formulation helps reject properties
that appear in only a few samples, which are likely to be erroneous, while
enabling the inclusion of missing elements without compromising precision. Our
method demonstrates superior performance than comparisons across various
structured reasoning tasks, including argument structure extraction,
explanation graph generation, inferring dependency relations among actions for
everyday tasks, and semantic graph generation from natural texts.
|
[
-0.2799365520477295,
-1.0580339431762695,
0.6581931114196777,
0.21278060972690582,
-0.1664503812789917,
-0.1734798401594162,
-0.1362750083208084,
-0.08164390176534653,
0.3318537771701813,
0.2934662401676178,
-0.5431931018829346,
-0.4278375804424286,
-0.5735240578651428,
0.7266806364059448,
-0.29118767380714417,
0.8727986216545105,
-0.06306126713752747,
-0.5764008164405823,
-0.4255017340183258,
-0.3328380286693573,
-0.08559217303991318,
-0.20613963901996613,
-0.5204991698265076,
-0.4132196605205536,
0.7375401854515076,
0.4960777759552002,
0.7497011423110962,
1.0872880220413208,
0.04668405279517174,
0.32598185539245605,
-0.28275421261787415,
0.6874756813049316,
-0.45906364917755127,
0.1522129476070404,
-0.4073001742362976,
0.17479446530342102,
-0.5384630560874939,
0.14903508126735687,
0.9603295922279358,
0.7149057984352112,
-0.1761818677186966,
0.23728395998477936,
0.38670551776885986,
0.6950160264968872,
-0.5228056907653809,
0.10716117173433304,
-0.3691556453704834,
-0.03659818693995476,
-0.39319688081741333,
-0.04284898564219475,
-0.3903244137763977,
-0.06712028384208679,
-0.1612553596496582,
-0.7356308698654175,
0.2866598963737488,
0.43069353699684143,
0.8000823855400085,
0.5134636163711548,
-0.5249570608139038,
-0.2856055796146393,
-0.45057782530784607,
0.6938300132751465,
-0.8168150782585144,
0.47924360632896423,
0.365721732378006,
0.24917897582054138,
-0.4845779538154602,
-0.8963868618011475,
-1.0955944061279297,
-0.07528882473707199,
-0.49953803420066833,
-0.0003923177719116211,
-0.3296533524990082,
0.3017890751361847,
0.2160283327102661,
0.17589232325553894,
-0.7586196660995483,
0.032266195863485336,
-0.38509178161621094,
-0.2979913651943207,
0.6198117733001709,
0.16142943501472473,
-0.12817612290382385,
-0.6505522727966309,
-0.210205078125,
-0.05559949576854706,
-0.668770968914032,
-0.13178546726703644,
0.3708978593349457,
0.3049929141998291,
-0.1342718005180359,
0.8042116761207581,
-0.5782458782196045,
0.9012225270271301,
0.39906805753707886,
-0.19723205268383026,
0.08540187776088715,
-0.2656278908252716,
-0.4855020046234131,
-0.032255709171295166,
0.8956525325775146,
0.22572356462478638,
0.01957676373422146,
0.003499309765174985,
-0.06383246183395386,
0.016461173072457314,
-0.1529129445552826,
-0.6319972276687622,
-0.4641726613044739,
0.44913506507873535,
-0.6464049816131592,
-0.26460301876068115,
-0.34782645106315613,
-0.6098698377609253,
-0.39211153984069824,
-0.45511382818222046,
0.1308087259531021,
-0.14807511866092682,
-0.12551908195018768,
0.00976524781435728,
-0.0884309932589531,
0.032690681517124176,
0.08345919847488403,
-0.8852466344833374,
0.5737374424934387,
0.6347240209579468,
0.7166773676872253,
-0.10059243440628052,
-0.5659080147743225,
-0.6891036033630371,
0.3905710279941559,
-0.38249126076698303,
0.7266342043876648,
-0.18996356427669525,
-0.11459416151046753,
-0.46208417415618896,
-0.09541594982147217,
0.08508717268705368,
-0.32558631896972656,
0.5102651119232178,
-0.041639603674411774,
0.21889527142047882,
-0.1972542107105255,
-0.7777529358863831,
0.09969548881053925,
0.7170077562332153,
-0.5007302165031433,
1.0052937269210815,
0.10295844823122025,
-0.8392304182052612,
0.2878592014312744,
-0.6864230036735535,
-0.38891974091529846,
0.20831845700740814,
-0.30883753299713135,
-0.22757069766521454,
-0.11548003554344177,
0.1757088005542755,
0.41249242424964905,
-0.046690434217453,
0.31798309087753296,
-0.280787855386734,
-0.0799955278635025,
0.028640510514378548,
-0.5440807938575745,
0.4490441679954529,
0.4427245557308197,
-0.17676056921482086,
0.17426365613937378,
-0.7929850816726685,
0.06571362912654877,
0.09109187126159668,
-0.22412437200546265,
-0.09474645555019379,
0.09414154291152954,
-0.3631204664707184,
0.1803610920906067,
0.3214144706726074,
-0.8863658905029297,
0.13587772846221924,
-0.35782134532928467,
0.3045513331890106,
1.1527670621871948,
0.02804267406463623,
0.3371032774448395,
-0.21170490980148315,
0.2282055914402008,
-0.11236830800771713,
0.3005692958831787,
0.09593914449214935,
-0.33121180534362793,
-0.463591605424881,
-0.32019999623298645,
0.3156921863555908,
0.17728708684444427,
-0.7249518036842346,
0.30700093507766724,
-0.2862176299095154,
-0.3427586555480957,
-0.3008077144622803,
0.2787308096885681,
0.5742133259773254,
0.9529011845588684,
0.3877051770687103,
0.15790434181690216,
-0.5766555070877075,
-0.9020887017250061,
-0.3131495416164398,
-0.21121877431869507,
0.2771768271923065,
0.286833256483078,
0.34391167759895325,
-0.2939566969871521,
1.0433160066604614,
-0.6661822199821472,
-0.11364317685365677,
-0.4146839678287506,
0.0633462443947792,
0.49989286065101624,
0.3656711280345917,
0.22282063961029053,
-0.5894511938095093,
-0.6449046730995178,
-0.10202474892139435,
-0.9074172377586365,
-0.2563045024871826,
0.15206992626190186,
-0.2056826949119568,
0.08751029521226883,
0.33318087458610535,
-0.6859110593795776,
0.3098093271255493,
0.9751103520393372,
-0.5432007312774658,
0.8403552174568176,
-0.4059603810310364,
-0.12644505500793457,
-0.9401929974555969,
-0.008781236596405506,
0.101691834628582,
-0.393759548664093,
-0.5749143958091736,
-0.16397103667259216,
-0.11004582792520523,
0.12589964270591736,
-0.14489704370498657,
1.0258861780166626,
-0.44711098074913025,
0.33620285987854004,
-0.2798740565776825,
0.2493470162153244,
0.3272777497768402,
0.4664593040943146,
-0.40036824345588684,
0.6475797891616821,
0.4130961298942566,
-0.8177075982093811,
0.41081488132476807,
0.46079471707344055,
0.37796536087989807,
0.7795611023902893,
-0.9150240421295166,
0.19235852360725403,
-0.2682183086872101,
0.3394300639629364,
-0.89281165599823,
-0.46301499009132385,
0.42599010467529297,
-0.3999228775501251,
0.14724282920360565,
-0.5030077695846558,
-0.7740710973739624,
-0.4866052567958832,
0.03230435401201248,
0.3621927499771118,
0.5644784569740295,
-0.6431447863578796,
0.6938066482543945,
0.10260513424873352,
-0.03695724904537201,
-0.6390917897224426,
-0.35402655601501465,
0.054395176470279694,
0.006690983194857836,
-0.8075050115585327,
0.0549272857606411,
-0.14614014327526093,
-0.3013159930706024,
0.023591693490743637,
-0.2842123806476593,
0.07225441932678223,
-0.09934069961309433,
0.14870785176753998,
-0.06387435644865036,
0.012922294437885284,
0.3108702003955841,
0.18979069590568542,
-0.15363675355911255,
-0.13454142212867737,
-0.5785828828811646,
0.3329547047615051,
-0.24168701469898224,
-0.5188499689102173,
-0.41511261463165283,
0.3685497045516968,
0.344257116317749,
-0.10050033032894135,
0.3973451852798462,
0.11389198154211044,
-0.2641509473323822,
-0.3624265789985657,
-0.3208427429199219,
-0.1355832815170288,
-0.521568775177002,
-0.09924821555614471,
-0.5456807017326355,
-0.7905963063240051,
0.3590790927410126,
-0.1292601227760315,
0.10886169224977493,
0.7114198803901672,
0.2274957001209259,
-0.3992806375026703,
1.1512479782104492,
0.33029910922050476,
0.32346561551094055,
-0.009313561953604221,
-0.15044277906417847,
0.26960405707359314,
-0.8617092370986938,
-0.2731357216835022,
-0.3162219524383545,
-0.36025533080101013,
-0.4617331326007843,
-0.2370416671037674,
0.4927281141281128,
-0.019249960780143738,
-0.2992570400238037,
-0.056933432817459106,
-0.8149150609970093,
0.5881022214889526,
0.4789784252643585,
-0.08021379262208939,
0.15112732350826263,
0.04626627638936043,
-0.36519530415534973,
0.06162426620721817,
-0.7733763456344604,
-0.6500871181488037,
0.8718559145927429,
0.0003285250277258456,
0.680905818939209,
0.14208121597766876,
0.9919589757919312,
0.542435884475708,
0.1892932653427124,
-0.4300483167171478,
0.6539270281791687,
-0.2550227642059326,
-0.4146326184272766,
-0.6422839760780334,
-0.7202563881874084,
-1.239304542541504,
0.26021432876586914,
-0.08164597302675247,
-0.512783408164978,
-0.09768648445606232,
0.6064797639846802,
-0.06332233548164368,
0.22552254796028137,
-0.36506232619285583,
0.9284096956253052,
-0.05405162647366524,
-0.4687694013118744,
0.05115984380245209,
-0.7465220093727112,
0.22079651057720184,
0.4052048921585083,
0.22189843654632568,
-0.1892956644296646,
0.4345722198486328,
0.6778683662414551,
-0.6113927364349365,
0.820071816444397,
-0.3056180477142334,
0.16973380744457245,
0.4177902340888977,
0.2684735953807831,
0.8540859222412109,
-0.15418626368045807,
0.028096577152609825,
-0.1992262601852417,
0.07933702319860458,
-0.7781893610954285,
-0.7673406004905701,
0.5596955418586731,
-0.5985339283943176,
-0.7107636332511902,
-0.4138820767402649,
-0.6326500773429871,
-0.09228171408176422,
0.5041431188583374,
0.09961274266242981,
0.5469493865966797,
-0.1498720645904541,
-0.05205855518579483,
0.7594354748725891,
0.35936567187309265,
0.3177030086517334,
-0.023271454498171806,
-0.017788778990507126,
-0.48676472902297974,
0.6945033073425293,
0.13947507739067078,
0.17127244174480438,
-0.09934322535991669,
0.6409147381782532,
-0.7287608981132507,
-0.6910766363143921,
-0.7425903677940369,
0.4807969927787781,
-0.8746039271354675,
-0.2784585654735565,
-0.6982872486114502,
-0.05661940202116966,
-0.5573980808258057,
-0.17940399050712585,
-0.2798759341239929,
-0.6122359037399292,
-0.013228090479969978,
-0.18389098346233368,
0.29862889647483826,
1.0057101249694824,
-0.1598244160413742,
0.2603585124015808,
-0.7147489786148071,
0.46775463223457336,
0.3571808338165283,
0.36482736468315125,
-0.0708656907081604,
-0.2818065583705902,
0.023903891444206238,
0.17295849323272705,
-0.27939486503601074,
-0.8011543154716492,
0.14570002257823944,
0.23227433860301971,
0.7790914177894592,
0.3939315676689148,
0.2123233824968338,
0.7720809578895569,
-0.38383644819259644,
0.6844666600227356,
0.2915976047515869,
-0.997107982635498,
0.5056436061859131,
-0.34319937229156494,
0.2563386857509613,
0.4389040470123291,
-0.06842188537120819,
-0.6400946974754333,
-0.41890427470207214,
-0.9906975030899048,
-0.5761818885803223,
0.044366199523210526,
0.28845733404159546,
-0.022166922688484192,
-0.31261396408081055,
0.3483056426048279,
-0.04322454333305359,
0.05971178412437439,
-0.6028911471366882,
-0.13621287047863007,
-0.43383780121803284,
-0.6731815338134766,
0.07852684706449509,
-0.22550539672374725,
-0.532560408115387,
-0.19641447067260742,
0.5067270994186401,
-0.5837090611457825,
-0.20265132188796997,
0.5574539303779602,
-0.027279548346996307,
0.09006091952323914,
0.40857458114624023,
0.5167256593704224,
0.813157320022583,
0.17888392508029938,
0.6630973815917969,
0.21589259803295135,
-0.17546963691711426,
0.16907885670661926,
0.20963391661643982,
-0.2840149402618408,
0.007314001210033894,
0.2969573736190796,
0.22849473357200623,
-0.12064361572265625,
-0.4385221600532532,
0.5375089049339294,
0.18555989861488342,
-0.28419649600982666,
-0.144608274102211,
-0.2290838211774826,
-0.023332588374614716,
0.1988886445760727,
0.22383509576320648,
0.05583048239350319,
0.15861493349075317,
-0.31195345520973206,
0.26815861463546753,
0.28328704833984375,
-0.2946246564388275,
-0.23518717288970947,
0.6934818029403687,
-0.009035360999405384,
-0.12340430915355682,
0.8737618923187256,
-0.6728533506393433,
-0.32225462794303894,
0.4390184283256531,
0.6228941082954407,
0.6863259673118591,
0.11329902708530426,
0.18608510494232178,
0.2746971845626831,
0.11259978264570236,
-0.13638682663440704,
0.3717172145843506,
-0.03433650732040405,
-0.628032922744751,
-0.44766339659690857,
-0.6958163976669312,
-0.33552512526512146,
-0.5375105738639832,
-0.21476620435714722,
-0.07689397782087326,
-0.629718542098999,
0.08974887430667877,
-0.0568714402616024,
0.048400234431028366,
-0.36873164772987366,
0.32081037759780884,
-0.009531170129776001,
0.9383252263069153,
-0.9462900757789612,
0.6848989725112915,
0.45762333273887634,
-0.28577345609664917,
-1.1773101091384888,
-0.30091097950935364,
0.1749301701784134,
-0.35867300629615784,
0.32023751735687256,
-0.13138194382190704,
-0.3895600736141205,
-0.050754331052303314,
-0.9386932253837585,
-0.7453657984733582,
1.2150770425796509,
0.06474186480045319,
-0.17458167672157288,
0.10307235270738602,
-0.14904867112636566,
0.5398642420768738,
-0.4324459433555603,
-0.2870802879333496,
0.34109556674957275,
0.7450869679450989,
0.5642139315605164,
-0.787462592124939,
0.4243525266647339,
-0.22946344316005707,
-0.3324989974498749,
0.21779346466064453,
-0.5473639369010925,
0.9424005150794983,
-0.27150633931159973,
-0.27219220995903015,
0.025486433878540993,
0.8764533996582031,
0.971695601940155,
0.6910260319709778,
0.3949362635612488,
0.6584981679916382,
1.3079527616500854,
0.0906534343957901,
1.2525243759155273,
-0.20071959495544434,
0.22627584636211395,
1.232733964920044,
-0.19004717469215393,
0.5223893523216248,
0.5741823315620422,
0.07864028215408325,
0.5335797667503357,
0.5756876468658447,
-0.06754308938980103,
0.3433745801448822,
0.1557227373123169,
0.04204952344298363,
-0.09526389837265015,
-0.13082469999790192,
-0.026460913941264153,
0.37930211424827576,
0.10570114850997925,
-0.20604653656482697,
-0.23717442154884338,
-0.5065955519676208,
0.26127782464027405,
0.32854992151260376,
-0.2804848551750183,
0.6161799430847168,
0.05368441343307495,
-0.7546976804733276,
0.7595617175102234,
0.007113534491509199,
0.3291563093662262,
-0.4621258080005646,
-0.29229113459587097,
-0.289277046918869,
0.10695812851190567,
-0.40576693415641785,
-0.8931604623794556,
0.3648802638053894,
-0.1744057983160019,
-0.3351961374282837,
-0.3993889391422272,
0.7440654635429382,
-0.24247576296329498,
-0.34513211250305176,
-0.1078188568353653,
0.4847516417503357,
0.3258955478668213,
0.22984452545642853,
-0.4569905698299408,
-0.2861461937427521,
-0.24466514587402344,
0.07533294707536697,
-0.03193798288702965,
0.8281585574150085,
-0.0908324122428894,
0.6877107620239258,
0.8945229053497314,
0.21010883152484894,
0.24867983162403107,
-0.16208729147911072,
0.8932996392250061,
-0.48013249039649963,
-0.4737124741077423,
-0.9130456447601318,
0.5024908185005188,
-0.5043945908546448,
-0.39980241656303406,
0.9446865320205688,
0.7129163146018982,
0.37582680583000183,
0.3220163583755493,
0.7393542528152466,
-0.22555573284626007,
0.38968273997306824,
-0.5149524211883545,
0.42928239703178406,
-0.35067111253738403,
0.0015729402657598257,
-0.047482848167419434,
-0.689741849899292,
-0.2522932291030884,
0.3511485159397125,
-0.01070274319499731,
-0.18689246475696564,
0.8081567287445068,
0.6154859662055969,
-0.30444270372390747,
-0.22735700011253357,
0.30792176723480225,
0.4099580645561218,
0.38613173365592957,
0.23464427888393402,
0.6342600584030151,
-0.003954265266656876,
0.5880638957023621,
0.1084643006324768,
-0.25007641315460205,
0.052901893854141235,
-0.8536704778671265,
-0.698137104511261,
-0.33745813369750977,
-0.12164619565010071,
-0.7889784574508667,
0.10343587398529053,
0.8892903327941895,
0.6951093673706055,
-0.4289085268974304,
-0.06523256748914719,
-0.17226426303386688,
0.48452579975128174,
-0.4259103834629059,
-0.17952340841293335,
0.5158188939094543,
-0.3266656994819641,
-0.4456877112388611,
0.4380452632904053,
0.41882336139678955,
0.11875159293413162,
-0.26012054085731506,
-0.5152590274810791,
-0.27445289492607117,
0.2670799195766449,
0.5047963857650757,
0.496145635843277,
-0.873850405216217,
-0.554254949092865,
0.053798384964466095,
-0.13710255920886993,
0.1929989606142044,
0.5470495820045471,
-0.6136034727096558,
0.5941356420516968,
0.6620970964431763,
0.28807905316352844,
0.5942679643630981,
0.2816757261753082,
0.48910051584243774,
-0.9985211491584778,
-0.026326369494199753,
0.26559871435165405,
0.43799424171447754,
0.4355992078781128,
-0.32874563336372375,
0.5786740779876709,
0.24932454526424408,
-0.6924189329147339,
-0.6457046270370483,
0.6455536484718323,
-1.0449544191360474,
-0.22944262623786926,
1.226218581199646,
-0.21827217936515808,
-0.45665812492370605,
-0.283483624458313,
0.009125860407948494,
0.19492068886756897,
-0.09668982774019241,
0.6852383613586426,
0.5136212110519409,
-0.4958604872226715,
-0.22550195455551147,
-0.08575630187988281,
0.5803360939025879,
0.06385936588048935,
-0.568158745765686,
0.22549213469028473,
0.6586040258407593,
0.5147935748100281,
0.10354220122098923,
0.8763628005981445,
0.01318010501563549,
0.03853610157966614,
0.1471676081418991,
-0.2241295576095581,
-0.31652921438217163,
-0.4080047607421875,
0.0397522896528244,
0.2385142296552658,
0.13579043745994568,
-0.0685165598988533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05176v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05176v1
|
Encoder-Decoder Framework for Interactive Free Verses with Generation with Controllable High-Quality Rhyming
| 2024-05-08T16:13:40 | 2024-05-08T16:13:40 |
Tommaso Pasini, Alejo López-Ávila, Husam Quteineh, Gerasimos Lampouras, Jinhua Du, Yubing Wang, Ze Li, Yusen Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Composing poetry or lyrics involves several creative factors, but a
challenging aspect of generation is the adherence to a more or less strict
metric and rhyming pattern. To address this challenge specifically, previous
work on the task has mainly focused on reverse language modeling, which brings
the critical selection of each rhyming word to the forefront of each verse. On
the other hand, reversing the word order requires that models be trained from
scratch with this task-specific goal and cannot take advantage of transfer
learning from a Pretrained Language Model (PLM). We propose a novel fine-tuning
approach that prepends the rhyming word at the start of each lyric, which
allows the critical rhyming decision to be made before the model commits to the
content of the lyric (as during reverse language modeling), but maintains
compatibility with the word order of regular PLMs as the lyric itself is still
generated in left-to-right order. We conducted extensive experiments to compare
this fine-tuning against the current state-of-the-art strategies for rhyming,
finding that our approach generates more readable text and better rhyming
capabilities. Furthermore, we furnish a high-quality dataset in English and 12
other languages, analyse the approach's feasibility in a multilingual context,
provide extensive experimental results shedding light on good and bad practices
for lyrics generation, and propose metrics to compare methods in the future.
|
[
-0.30885565280914307,
-0.39796966314315796,
0.18241623044013977,
0.5262799263000488,
-0.5171155333518982,
0.033765777945518494,
-0.407501757144928,
-0.5187095999717712,
0.31365036964416504,
0.7697476744651794,
-0.7803726196289062,
-0.6057313680648804,
-0.5922147631645203,
0.31556272506713867,
-0.3372005522251129,
1.0722943544387817,
-0.2585359215736389,
-0.2962316870689392,
-0.08803319185972214,
-0.10313599556684494,
-0.4235149621963501,
-0.1132049411535263,
-0.4695596694946289,
-0.486664742231369,
0.43752411007881165,
0.5829740166664124,
0.609448254108429,
0.7846872210502625,
0.29383179545402527,
0.2144044190645218,
0.042039383202791214,
0.2974272072315216,
-0.5386404991149902,
0.5340672135353088,
0.012582769617438316,
-0.6276818513870239,
-0.34244391322135925,
0.2422332465648651,
0.4663025736808777,
0.2953254282474518,
-0.19380885362625122,
0.3640340566635132,
-0.052400220185518265,
0.8631585836410522,
-0.4741249084472656,
0.05771057680249214,
-0.8044962882995605,
0.3461061120033264,
-0.30059871077537537,
-0.7339897751808167,
-0.4799768030643463,
-0.4836919605731964,
-0.08067473024129868,
-0.713735818862915,
0.39857742190361023,
0.2366430014371872,
1.0185365676879883,
0.2825906574726105,
0.12183481454849243,
-0.39235955476760864,
-0.5504184365272522,
0.5697897672653198,
-0.6146987080574036,
0.4993171691894531,
0.28863954544067383,
0.20563377439975739,
-0.18854570388793945,
-0.9896793961524963,
-0.5592559576034546,
-0.08301248401403427,
0.1766849309206009,
0.46473169326782227,
0.008327693678438663,
0.0828111320734024,
0.24104328453540802,
0.4563550353050232,
-0.539231538772583,
-0.17456801235675812,
-0.11092554777860641,
-0.0027324394322931767,
0.6382357478141785,
0.12366912513971329,
0.6525890231132507,
-0.25429749488830566,
-0.4727160334587097,
-0.11684326082468033,
-0.7791234254837036,
0.2743949890136719,
0.7984920740127563,
0.3056970536708832,
-0.3002493679523468,
0.6186466217041016,
-0.0816330760717392,
0.6513684988021851,
0.3336534798145294,
-0.11544183641672134,
0.33865296840667725,
0.009176560677587986,
-0.1213245689868927,
0.24881330132484436,
0.9518749117851257,
0.4697025418281555,
0.5913445949554443,
-0.36036500334739685,
-0.4989432096481323,
0.18882374465465546,
0.276439905166626,
-0.7795290946960449,
-0.45169347524642944,
0.20472168922424316,
-0.5297442674636841,
-0.33079764246940613,
0.0704633966088295,
-0.6443815231323242,
-0.21447108685970306,
-0.5636568069458008,
0.628474771976471,
-0.7164815664291382,
-0.1756616085767746,
0.34380537271499634,
-0.17941705882549286,
0.027875127270817757,
-0.122602179646492,
-0.9422862529754639,
-0.14497125148773193,
0.7371851205825806,
0.7516986727714539,
0.05582471191883087,
-0.4545380473136902,
-0.5684826374053955,
0.08355265110731125,
-0.3459918797016144,
0.5575968027114868,
-0.4537370502948761,
-0.21138621866703033,
-0.18699662387371063,
-0.029124708846211433,
-0.29795077443122864,
-0.5226325392723083,
0.6062343120574951,
-0.5027226805686951,
0.052514951676130295,
-0.0027561760507524014,
-0.6966251134872437,
-0.06532129645347595,
-0.1426047682762146,
-0.48536840081214905,
0.5628388524055481,
-0.014972055330872536,
-1.0926960706710815,
0.3265972137451172,
-0.35752761363983154,
-0.3101845681667328,
0.027623329311609268,
-0.301714688539505,
-0.4761165678501129,
0.42917415499687195,
0.14842209219932556,
0.48878213763237,
-0.180267333984375,
-0.05271703377366066,
0.02105461061000824,
-0.47975802421569824,
0.35057300329208374,
-0.2964475154876709,
0.5063091516494751,
0.5450237393379211,
-0.11827294528484344,
0.27646124362945557,
-0.9874962568283081,
0.32451823353767395,
0.25178614258766174,
-0.49162644147872925,
-0.06979592889547348,
-0.03310971334576607,
0.24942995607852936,
0.07560906559228897,
-0.056798338890075684,
-0.6420199275016785,
-0.09168969839811325,
-0.7772993445396423,
0.5851563811302185,
0.3747372031211853,
0.21580438315868378,
0.2943597137928009,
-0.6630991101264954,
0.9377685189247131,
-0.14615733921527863,
0.0002556621911935508,
-0.20160020887851715,
-0.33822160959243774,
-0.71884685754776,
-0.14149178564548492,
0.4517366886138916,
0.556544840335846,
-0.7470876574516296,
0.5114271640777588,
-0.3666553199291229,
-0.32356497645378113,
-1.0807714462280273,
0.23843860626220703,
0.3384420573711395,
0.25725048780441284,
0.387358695268631,
-0.3646067976951599,
-0.5778176188468933,
-0.543819785118103,
-0.39280572533607483,
0.2144060581922531,
0.12782828509807587,
-0.11363275349140167,
-0.00505828857421875,
-0.14577068388462067,
0.7665544748306274,
-0.3518814444541931,
-0.019177280366420746,
-0.474996417760849,
0.39162692427635193,
0.22234806418418884,
0.7404291033744812,
0.37427613139152527,
-0.6377828121185303,
-0.4863576292991638,
-0.1079694926738739,
-0.4028143286705017,
-0.3175504803657532,
-0.2637379467487335,
-0.5179561972618103,
-0.14191415905952454,
0.5875877737998962,
-0.5152400732040405,
0.0427166111767292,
0.5585258603096008,
-0.25920799374580383,
0.5261974334716797,
-0.19384169578552246,
0.15536804497241974,
-1.1519694328308105,
0.04914575070142746,
-0.35724982619285583,
-0.17456874251365662,
-0.6644828915596008,
0.3778449594974518,
0.253560870885849,
-0.1777413934469223,
-0.19482170045375824,
0.04992757737636566,
-0.48969438672065735,
0.2593630850315094,
-0.4134451150894165,
0.08739553391933441,
0.14323140680789948,
0.18646855652332306,
0.04144950956106186,
0.6875848174095154,
0.4500749707221985,
-0.3609548509120941,
0.3145596981048584,
0.1713663637638092,
-0.7358585596084595,
0.38529762625694275,
-0.5653237700462341,
0.19233781099319458,
-0.6337001919746399,
0.040274910628795624,
-0.7715643048286438,
-0.28513261675834656,
0.17040269076824188,
-0.6859911680221558,
0.7219831347465515,
-0.22394374012947083,
-0.35454678535461426,
-0.253654420375824,
-0.03953370451927185,
0.5001271963119507,
0.6485500335693359,
-0.4874876141548157,
0.3643766939640045,
-0.08833909779787064,
-0.16081152856349945,
-0.4409901797771454,
-0.6883795261383057,
0.07575984299182892,
-0.4733406901359558,
-0.5327357053756714,
0.42134401202201843,
0.0005693796556442976,
0.07328072935342789,
-0.20133373141288757,
-0.034284114837646484,
0.31418177485466003,
-0.0312771275639534,
0.3009631633758545,
-0.268398642539978,
-0.15457768738269806,
0.1315806806087494,
0.2134648710489273,
-0.5032292604446411,
0.07624082267284393,
-0.41993993520736694,
0.5918377041816711,
0.29268571734428406,
-0.26433876156806946,
-0.5494811534881592,
0.45575615763664246,
0.6287575364112854,
-0.726882815361023,
0.3345571458339691,
0.7494094967842102,
-0.23655660450458527,
-0.6203612089157104,
-0.21183937788009644,
0.33235952258110046,
-0.4980233311653137,
0.011005708947777748,
-0.4947426915168762,
-0.5147412419319153,
0.5153985023498535,
-0.0565498061478138,
-0.06700409203767776,
0.2855628430843353,
0.1278713047504425,
-0.1862790584564209,
0.841518759727478,
0.8872624635696411,
0.2174723595380783,
0.5634139776229858,
-0.49127766489982605,
0.1080651506781578,
-0.7883756160736084,
-0.04692167043685913,
-0.45902058482170105,
-0.5557249784469604,
-0.6613868474960327,
-0.20233353972434998,
0.2843618392944336,
0.6846950054168701,
-0.2048293948173523,
0.3153255879878998,
-0.6158733367919922,
0.4812522828578949,
0.35714778304100037,
0.149648979306221,
0.18214647471904755,
0.012119924649596214,
-0.45760825276374817,
-0.08304297924041748,
-0.6922250390052795,
-0.2600306272506714,
0.9233484268188477,
0.31204459071159363,
0.7542493343353271,
0.18064261972904205,
1.1846623420715332,
-0.1433456540107727,
0.26209521293640137,
-0.8300025463104248,
0.23884156346321106,
-0.387468159198761,
-0.17562127113342285,
-0.13696178793907166,
-0.3874661922454834,
-0.8258693814277649,
-0.11479201167821884,
-0.35711050033569336,
-0.5466551780700684,
-0.05816201493144035,
0.20693182945251465,
-0.5205767154693604,
0.2231110781431198,
-0.5309098958969116,
0.7035029530525208,
-0.111028291285038,
-0.09452769160270691,
0.06295690685510635,
-0.6086419820785522,
0.29376205801963806,
0.07761452347040176,
0.30548903346061707,
-0.16059863567352295,
0.05098853260278702,
0.5407325625419617,
-0.4400166869163513,
0.5255483388900757,
-0.23743301630020142,
-0.4175371825695038,
0.31521645188331604,
0.21888023614883423,
0.6006495952606201,
0.02473912015557289,
0.05162641033530235,
-0.35493800044059753,
0.007158685475587845,
-0.14080093801021576,
-0.4901467561721802,
0.8590216636657715,
-0.6923519372940063,
-0.3234480023384094,
0.07418690621852875,
-0.49904948472976685,
-0.2536693215370178,
0.1660403311252594,
1.0145562887191772,
0.5466731190681458,
0.31169408559799194,
0.1649099588394165,
0.6771051287651062,
-0.3864457309246063,
0.3968653976917267,
0.055060312151908875,
-0.3103996217250824,
-1.045486569404602,
0.9163519740104675,
0.2160363495349884,
0.35721355676651,
0.6089263558387756,
0.26836538314819336,
-0.3665323257446289,
-0.7467887997627258,
-0.7342116832733154,
0.06669217348098755,
-0.5844483375549316,
-0.354319304227829,
-0.46407487988471985,
-0.2530776262283325,
-0.35708925127983093,
-0.18854466080665588,
-0.32616907358169556,
-0.2836485803127289,
-0.2953137457370758,
0.03140758350491524,
0.732936680316925,
0.5997280478477478,
0.05647588148713112,
0.263921320438385,
-1.0624796152114868,
0.6316846013069153,
0.12434712052345276,
0.8436002135276794,
0.1800043284893036,
-0.5484850406646729,
-0.21963372826576233,
-0.16327354311943054,
-0.11437336355447769,
-1.0046885013580322,
0.296884149312973,
0.38184911012649536,
0.2567445635795593,
0.2991403639316559,
0.2449595034122467,
0.8796538710594177,
-0.6697679162025452,
0.6266500949859619,
0.40282922983169556,
-0.8575668334960938,
0.6249287724494934,
-0.34442058205604553,
0.24138261377811432,
0.5908778309822083,
0.10011883825063705,
-0.6223824620246887,
-0.36982664465904236,
-0.2501927614212036,
-1.1453757286071777,
0.3797172009944916,
0.2793084383010864,
0.20449769496917725,
-0.07488581538200378,
0.6840947270393372,
0.44802212715148926,
0.0398685485124588,
-0.474134236574173,
-0.33739352226257324,
-0.617567777633667,
-0.6956326961517334,
-0.4401906430721283,
0.03757768124341965,
0.11120245605707169,
-0.14062635600566864,
0.6285308599472046,
-0.01631511189043522,
0.029652435332536697,
0.394228458404541,
-0.1289205253124237,
-0.6295282244682312,
0.4136168658733368,
0.47368156909942627,
0.21810021996498108,
-0.06948128342628479,
0.22669920325279236,
-0.2158609926700592,
-0.6586296558380127,
0.1683092713356018,
0.042269494384527206,
-0.6039963960647583,
-0.12340743839740753,
0.2820635735988617,
1.1581884622573853,
0.1784980297088623,
-0.4983636140823364,
0.350018173456192,
-0.06759732961654663,
-0.24739091098308563,
-0.3013209402561188,
0.3583340048789978,
0.18157325685024261,
0.22265535593032837,
0.06994527578353882,
0.14364686608314514,
-0.0946044921875,
-0.22514496743679047,
0.315174400806427,
0.20468562841415405,
-0.35980454087257385,
-0.23722827434539795,
0.8224294781684875,
0.050245873630046844,
-0.3973134160041809,
0.19855156540870667,
-0.17150278389453888,
-0.3176645040512085,
0.43774619698524475,
0.7766285538673401,
1.1977434158325195,
0.1150360107421875,
-0.026747655123472214,
0.3943592607975006,
0.17995093762874603,
0.023146383464336395,
0.7219948172569275,
-0.18139150738716125,
-0.6611559391021729,
-0.5784295797348022,
-1.108515739440918,
0.02702716365456581,
0.3315805494785309,
-0.8834003210067749,
0.09195024520158768,
-0.41923364996910095,
-0.20279540121555328,
-0.08475200086832047,
-0.15047577023506165,
-0.6641730070114136,
0.25046390295028687,
0.1410287618637085,
1.0958483219146729,
-0.61146479845047,
0.6200051307678223,
0.8100632429122925,
-0.38451310992240906,
-0.8504161238670349,
0.39013999700546265,
-0.39095884561538696,
-0.3960559368133545,
0.297751784324646,
0.4275563657283783,
-0.29184091091156006,
0.6106946468353271,
-0.5827463269233704,
-0.7638738751411438,
1.1444350481033325,
0.21748298406600952,
-0.6514867544174194,
0.24171182513237,
0.005470999516546726,
0.4565727114677429,
-0.3595272898674011,
-0.2594858407974243,
0.43645983934402466,
0.2887686789035797,
-0.05794988572597504,
-0.7130212783813477,
-0.04045870900154114,
-0.44718727469444275,
0.1218995749950409,
0.4249245524406433,
-0.5652772188186646,
0.689913809299469,
-0.10045062750577927,
-0.7044615149497986,
0.5539813041687012,
0.7609972357749939,
0.11569016426801682,
0.3134200870990753,
0.2941332757472992,
0.9263039827346802,
0.5143229365348816,
-0.09607291966676712,
0.653296172618866,
-0.6989589333534241,
0.15944381058216095,
1.083365797996521,
0.007987484335899353,
0.8842300772666931,
0.449602335691452,
-0.03005334362387657,
0.37570688128471375,
0.32738879323005676,
0.26505279541015625,
0.6294253468513489,
0.6135241389274597,
-0.19995196163654327,
-0.4974496066570282,
0.11896879225969315,
-0.4942552447319031,
0.5400067567825317,
0.2939881384372711,
-0.5717365741729736,
-0.0061828880570828915,
0.045309942215681076,
-0.3465443551540375,
0.6558873653411865,
-0.3994928002357483,
0.7997032999992371,
0.1027710884809494,
-0.6146063804626465,
0.7802137732505798,
0.20741623640060425,
0.970004677772522,
-0.5041242837905884,
0.08554922789335251,
-0.0892510786652565,
0.018533634021878242,
-0.21973083913326263,
-0.7307039499282837,
0.10988294333219528,
0.1612083613872528,
-0.24403227865695953,
-0.2852119505405426,
0.6438038945198059,
-0.6735562682151794,
-0.353618860244751,
0.21512454748153687,
0.4317691922187805,
-0.11772527545690536,
0.26807376742362976,
-0.48481759428977966,
0.06836405396461487,
-0.07839062809944153,
-0.2527698874473572,
0.04094890132546425,
0.7318955659866333,
0.26662319898605347,
0.4979766607284546,
0.5698007941246033,
0.4592861831188202,
0.2693607211112976,
0.5804895162582397,
0.3723681569099426,
-0.7449429631233215,
-0.7044153213500977,
-0.3988250494003296,
0.3937157392501831,
0.44137299060821533,
-0.16725072264671326,
0.39706405997276306,
0.22623920440673828,
1.026952862739563,
-0.31503161787986755,
0.8737146258354187,
0.09512753039598465,
0.47707629203796387,
-0.9711211323738098,
1.083012580871582,
-0.4108734130859375,
-0.10589738190174103,
-0.2246895134449005,
-0.6796457171440125,
-0.31476739048957825,
0.4805212616920471,
0.08173859864473343,
-0.0911950170993805,
0.20765119791030884,
0.6824471950531006,
-0.09455020725727081,
0.1986740082502365,
0.28201940655708313,
0.04215540736913681,
0.012821131385862827,
0.5160367488861084,
0.8852621912956238,
-0.568038821220398,
0.31790363788604736,
-0.5573117136955261,
-0.09209015220403671,
0.197891503572464,
-1.011344075202942,
-0.6111664175987244,
-0.40964260697364807,
-0.2260625958442688,
-0.17668204009532928,
-0.05136512592434883,
1.3596409559249878,
0.3157651126384735,
-0.8359776735305786,
0.052629586309194565,
-0.4614522457122803,
-0.22460639476776123,
-0.407105028629303,
-0.21453236043453217,
0.20288054645061493,
-0.5686074495315552,
-0.4280155897140503,
0.3641889691352844,
0.01731930300593376,
0.3300909399986267,
-0.0009464420145377517,
-0.37885239720344543,
0.11261925846338272,
0.1880417764186859,
0.5413177609443665,
0.06277720630168915,
-0.6591281890869141,
-0.3655783236026764,
-0.20513223111629486,
0.04935320094227791,
-0.08764775097370148,
0.9307778477668762,
-0.44008445739746094,
0.6040568351745605,
0.8427683115005493,
0.44245925545692444,
0.03470483422279358,
0.20092999935150146,
0.4035029113292694,
-0.9117894768714905,
-0.1946408599615097,
0.13074158132076263,
0.30755940079689026,
0.34744030237197876,
-0.21883907914161682,
0.04037797078490257,
0.20651480555534363,
-0.3632006049156189,
-0.5071122050285339,
0.543184220790863,
-0.8070446252822876,
-0.059449467808008194,
1.0109224319458008,
-0.2249031364917755,
-0.03680110722780228,
0.1353731006383896,
-0.22913004457950592,
0.7360985279083252,
-0.08855456113815308,
0.647942066192627,
0.47930821776390076,
-0.1590721607208252,
-0.26409444212913513,
-0.503571629524231,
0.7908992767333984,
0.19299370050430298,
-0.21302752196788788,
0.2819328308105469,
0.4764014482498169,
0.38497740030288696,
0.07902610301971436,
0.3733895421028137,
-0.27843156456947327,
0.25040608644485474,
-0.05014795809984207,
0.3027609884738922,
-0.41975897550582886,
-0.6601921319961548,
-0.46502232551574707,
0.35026681423187256,
0.40403082966804504,
-0.3489181697368622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05175v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05175v1
|
Air Gap: Protecting Privacy-Conscious Conversational Agents
| 2024-05-08T16:12:45 | 2024-05-08T16:12:45 |
Eugene Bagdasaryan, Ren Yi, Sahra Ghalebikesabi, Peter Kairouz, Marco Gruteser, Sewoong Oh, Borja Balle, Daniel Ramage
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The growing use of large language model (LLM)-based conversational agents to
manage sensitive user data raises significant privacy concerns. While these
agents excel at understanding and acting on context, this capability can be
exploited by malicious actors. We introduce a novel threat model where
adversarial third-party apps manipulate the context of interaction to trick
LLM-based agents into revealing private information not relevant to the task at
hand.
Grounded in the framework of contextual integrity, we introduce AirGapAgent,
a privacy-conscious agent designed to prevent unintended data leakage by
restricting the agent's access to only the data necessary for a specific task.
Extensive experiments using Gemini, GPT, and Mistral models as agents validate
our approach's effectiveness in mitigating this form of context hijacking while
maintaining core agent functionality. For example, we show that a single-query
context hijacking attack on a Gemini Ultra agent reduces its ability to protect
user data from 94% to 45%, while an AirGapAgent achieves 97% protection,
rendering the same attack ineffective.
|
[
-0.2847561240196228,
-1.0014597177505493,
0.19420193135738373,
-0.3007088899612427,
0.33259066939353943,
-0.018693074584007263,
0.22091294825077057,
-0.4671771824359894,
0.0925133153796196,
0.9312092661857605,
-0.4633176326751709,
-0.12295375764369965,
-0.5245212912559509,
-0.8384226560592651,
-0.5184337496757507,
0.9351649880409241,
0.22234012186527252,
-0.6482515335083008,
-0.1436414122581482,
0.15430447459220886,
-0.41185373067855835,
-0.8688246607780457,
-0.46087148785591125,
-0.24231834709644318,
0.22444328665733337,
0.35401058197021484,
1.2852447032928467,
0.6138866543769836,
0.19560803472995758,
0.22301270067691803,
0.06499860435724258,
-0.11644945293664932,
-0.6216370463371277,
0.30069500207901,
-0.021557360887527466,
-0.3619821071624756,
-0.5656144618988037,
0.035761985927820206,
0.24434392154216766,
0.5206952095031738,
-0.5738689303398132,
-0.41015827655792236,
-0.050027258694171906,
0.6237545013427734,
-0.8166548609733582,
-0.11629865318536758,
-0.9250267148017883,
-0.048172980546951294,
-0.22483839094638824,
-0.09675321727991104,
-0.38087597489356995,
0.014678200706839561,
-0.10419930517673492,
-0.6824958324432373,
0.042049605399370193,
-0.06567452102899551,
1.1824862957000732,
0.5744883418083191,
-0.3658820390701294,
0.053103119134902954,
-0.6139259934425354,
0.15926437079906464,
-0.4108922481536865,
0.38665345311164856,
0.4639665186405182,
0.3182055950164795,
-0.2381628006696701,
-0.5155645608901978,
-0.6998873949050903,
-0.1738830953836441,
0.06538466364145279,
-0.05474548786878586,
-0.7288183569908142,
0.043838899582624435,
0.036673810333013535,
0.08813618123531342,
-0.6079017519950867,
0.010863185860216618,
-0.14609496295452118,
-0.337911456823349,
0.3233151435852051,
0.13003875315189362,
0.552291750907898,
-0.07820369303226471,
-0.729408323764801,
-0.15144449472427368,
-0.9035494923591614,
0.32417020201683044,
0.41290098428726196,
0.13135933876037598,
-0.018695704638957977,
0.4192829728126526,
-0.2489074319601059,
0.6904350519180298,
0.017235973849892616,
0.15413357317447662,
-0.22831271588802338,
0.2548061013221741,
-0.33435502648353577,
0.019040659070014954,
0.43224313855171204,
0.2800959348678589,
0.10908451676368713,
-0.4129413664340973,
-0.03771406412124634,
0.05674910172820091,
0.36129021644592285,
-0.7377974987030029,
-0.11049129068851471,
0.174973264336586,
-0.044036172330379486,
-0.5246241688728333,
0.4879475235939026,
-0.5800681114196777,
-0.8156314492225647,
-0.021872231736779213,
0.33391737937927246,
-0.25032904744148254,
-0.3045128285884857,
0.13692685961723328,
0.086717389523983,
0.26574233174324036,
0.2604624330997467,
-0.7810284495353699,
0.5741752982139587,
0.8765449523925781,
0.6839354038238525,
0.06353724747896194,
-0.5333267450332642,
-0.46092304587364197,
0.4498986005783081,
-0.29205429553985596,
0.5495516061782837,
-0.7382631897926331,
-0.6302128434181213,
-0.1769200563430786,
0.020111145451664925,
-0.33906421065330505,
-0.36911097168922424,
0.022123141214251518,
-0.8647397756576538,
-0.0656142309308052,
-0.05590982362627983,
-0.3919070363044739,
-0.19841471314430237,
0.3592674136161804,
-0.5961315631866455,
0.777121365070343,
0.1315387338399887,
-0.4449612498283386,
0.22042907774448395,
-0.5787171125411987,
-0.21497957408428192,
0.14675524830818176,
-0.2059674710035324,
0.08025271445512772,
-0.1614689826965332,
0.19252634048461914,
0.3616480827331543,
0.39716631174087524,
-0.045717041939496994,
-0.2570277154445648,
-0.14704927802085876,
0.5968230366706848,
-0.5306401252746582,
0.6050679087638855,
0.33681437373161316,
-0.37218937277793884,
-0.06228626146912575,
-0.45043614506721497,
-0.06036614254117012,
-0.20467627048492432,
-0.17393696308135986,
-0.45718449354171753,
-0.27355000376701355,
-0.1928364634513855,
0.3623628616333008,
0.31502285599708557,
-0.35725292563438416,
0.19811826944351196,
-0.36747705936431885,
0.34452924132347107,
0.9291983246803284,
0.2417757660150528,
0.5983286499977112,
-0.3899551033973694,
0.7444964647293091,
0.08975134044885635,
0.3722076117992401,
-0.2025957703590393,
-0.42636314034461975,
-0.5773718357086182,
-0.05324435606598854,
-0.05109851807355881,
0.683501660823822,
-0.5457403063774109,
0.45352327823638916,
-0.19833680987358093,
-0.5804213881492615,
-0.10204468667507172,
0.17722797393798828,
0.30647897720336914,
0.496209055185318,
-0.13906235992908478,
-0.07868281751871109,
0.26842883229255676,
-0.6385405659675598,
-0.48564523458480835,
-0.1510455459356308,
0.23263338208198547,
0.6968558430671692,
0.20415902137756348,
-0.598618745803833,
0.9747412204742432,
-0.6812787652015686,
-0.2811899483203888,
0.06028968095779419,
-0.25357314944267273,
-0.06852202862501144,
0.7112278938293457,
0.2691059708595276,
-0.9646347165107727,
-0.3545304834842682,
-0.027254926040768623,
-0.5225682854652405,
-0.14575396478176117,
-0.12339548021554947,
-0.39177536964416504,
0.20438838005065918,
0.8049853444099426,
-1.0871362686157227,
0.906038224697113,
0.5772594809532166,
-0.7513384222984314,
-0.09319309145212173,
-0.11860090494155884,
-0.15119172632694244,
-0.9120489358901978,
0.18849697709083557,
-0.3017904460430145,
-0.33206796646118164,
-1.056995153427124,
0.14925923943519592,
0.01783042587339878,
-0.7557477355003357,
-0.7220975160598755,
0.8523778319358826,
-0.21503010392189026,
0.2118564248085022,
-0.6261003017425537,
0.10909558832645416,
0.10160261392593384,
0.3609524071216583,
-0.15035173296928406,
0.7226829528808594,
0.5727154016494751,
-0.6660879850387573,
0.07580618560314178,
0.38154318928718567,
0.236930251121521,
0.47846055030822754,
-0.40019577741622925,
0.4964754283428192,
-0.12399625033140182,
0.5935423970222473,
-0.7886296510696411,
-0.5200285911560059,
0.3843393921852112,
-0.7273043394088745,
0.21570619940757751,
-0.1761932671070099,
-0.21870028972625732,
0.26230260729789734,
-0.12122955173254013,
0.25516214966773987,
0.23165732622146606,
-0.6753323674201965,
0.6375991106033325,
0.7667447924613953,
-0.178513303399086,
-0.7733714580535889,
-0.778712809085846,
0.4512251317501068,
-0.3349585235118866,
-0.8439781665802002,
0.2992783486843109,
0.13781772553920746,
-0.4004053771495819,
0.12174233049154282,
-0.42995038628578186,
-0.29158371686935425,
0.4437865912914276,
0.6519293189048767,
0.14341537654399872,
0.44631171226501465,
-0.1005653515458107,
-0.3380502164363861,
-0.2988229990005493,
-0.04845213517546654,
-0.2487781047821045,
0.604391872882843,
-0.3389013707637787,
-0.448306143283844,
-0.22481223940849304,
0.4182867407798767,
0.5107842683792114,
-0.01410362683236599,
0.7912436723709106,
0.4063378870487213,
-0.6545844674110413,
-0.1657112091779709,
-0.5749885439872742,
-0.2961690127849579,
-0.5704918503761292,
-0.08391013741493225,
-0.24181953072547913,
-0.8906204104423523,
0.517769455909729,
0.21125377714633942,
-0.24181364476680756,
-0.06024505943059921,
0.22946783900260925,
0.45091959834098816,
0.8787090182304382,
0.8167418241500854,
-0.5451164841651917,
0.5381873250007629,
-0.19885721802711487,
0.2077493816614151,
-0.7383614778518677,
-0.33543795347213745,
-0.3719697594642639,
0.11471491307020187,
-0.4974108338356018,
-0.27828437089920044,
0.5421884059906006,
0.12755678594112396,
-0.12882764637470245,
0.3625124990940094,
-0.517722487449646,
0.7814784646034241,
0.3464793860912323,
0.13912145793437958,
0.07402943074703217,
-0.11463508009910583,
0.33523625135421753,
0.35091033577919006,
-0.47706758975982666,
-0.6862443685531616,
0.8845869302749634,
0.37450075149536133,
1.325199007987976,
0.5309383869171143,
0.4540059268474579,
0.38025784492492676,
-0.012185725383460522,
-0.5314322113990784,
0.6565574407577515,
0.20295734703540802,
-1.011390209197998,
-0.337851881980896,
-0.19072023034095764,
-1.296960473060608,
0.7070632576942444,
0.2921984791755676,
-1.3675647974014282,
0.29917365312576294,
0.0063790068961679935,
-0.2732710838317871,
0.16717040538787842,
-0.591182291507721,
0.7247722148895264,
-0.059976886957883835,
-0.6724007725715637,
-0.015523888170719147,
-0.7824271321296692,
0.2252969592809677,
0.0030809135641902685,
0.21075354516506195,
-0.3478812277317047,
-0.29738518595695496,
0.4377734065055847,
-0.7719118595123291,
0.9612755179405212,
-0.562137246131897,
0.02538376674056053,
0.24453052878379822,
0.5130963921546936,
0.6232195496559143,
0.3650789260864258,
0.20008373260498047,
0.128160297870636,
-0.20476080477237701,
-0.48251548409461975,
-0.5085991024971008,
0.8435967564582825,
-0.6905672550201416,
-0.8721145391464233,
-0.6017731428146362,
-0.43784186244010925,
-0.33620917797088623,
0.29433485865592957,
0.0706707239151001,
0.30327510833740234,
-0.3094770908355713,
0.2761119306087494,
0.5477958917617798,
-0.1542876660823822,
0.5597866177558899,
0.7524166107177734,
0.0883418470621109,
-0.1442543864250183,
0.7493735551834106,
-0.22915145754814148,
0.36860620975494385,
0.33579063415527344,
0.3123933970928192,
-0.21901340782642365,
0.022478820756077766,
-0.3336253762245178,
-0.23190729320049286,
-0.8877671957015991,
-0.11513874679803848,
-0.703824520111084,
-0.3377617299556732,
-0.5943983793258667,
-0.4179837703704834,
-0.16478927433490753,
-0.4428672194480896,
-0.17818252742290497,
-0.18669496476650238,
0.12647686898708344,
0.4449540674686432,
-0.1978825181722641,
0.7709991931915283,
-0.5424929261207581,
0.25276145339012146,
0.538621187210083,
-0.13461969792842865,
-0.18356972932815552,
-0.21505118906497955,
-0.04656808078289032,
-0.19662177562713623,
-0.7326349020004272,
-0.8827753663063049,
0.6112431287765503,
0.06397280842065811,
0.7258589267730713,
0.6195178627967834,
0.0774320587515831,
0.5746809244155884,
-0.26997509598731995,
1.0305464267730713,
-0.0481935553252697,
-1.1118488311767578,
0.5573158860206604,
-0.6143026351928711,
0.1184198334813118,
0.5768569111824036,
-0.12162630259990692,
-0.745639443397522,
-0.39574679732322693,
-1.052072525024414,
-1.087116003036499,
0.6819575428962708,
0.43735572695732117,
0.3162495195865631,
0.2859412729740143,
0.20423303544521332,
-0.0300249345600605,
0.5223753452301025,
-0.7723764777183533,
0.06378043442964554,
-0.44731080532073975,
0.2422533631324768,
0.059244025498628616,
0.1835147589445114,
-0.4434419572353363,
0.16667477786540985,
0.5234304070472717,
-0.14986097812652588,
0.16583792865276337,
0.33959099650382996,
-0.22255057096481323,
0.03700632229447365,
0.45842444896698,
0.5631480813026428,
0.5553035736083984,
-0.02433048002421856,
0.17601826786994934,
-0.13040032982826233,
-0.5285533666610718,
0.31415021419525146,
0.3320483863353729,
-0.14269331097602844,
-0.32957080006599426,
0.062487781047821045,
0.6591581106185913,
0.046997491270303726,
-0.5259332060813904,
0.9093334078788757,
0.004580677952617407,
0.2133798450231552,
-0.4647775888442993,
0.3582814633846283,
-0.21697542071342468,
-0.01440594531595707,
0.34205183386802673,
0.28249385952949524,
0.21911509335041046,
-0.45141318440437317,
0.33430901169776917,
0.44679152965545654,
-0.5503036379814148,
-0.22442954778671265,
0.9502891898155212,
0.26216837763786316,
-0.17845913767814636,
0.17851020395755768,
0.14242340624332428,
-0.5120265483856201,
0.7445378303527832,
0.35307130217552185,
0.803861141204834,
-0.49054235219955444,
-0.06938709318637848,
-0.47955626249313354,
0.45542460680007935,
0.1084379181265831,
0.20233401656150818,
-0.1152358204126358,
-0.9620358943939209,
0.22450104355812073,
0.07592017948627472,
-0.7552680969238281,
0.37604695558547974,
-0.5468846559524536,
-0.18271969258785248,
-0.5046607255935669,
-0.0860821083188057,
-0.0864998996257782,
-0.3165060877799988,
-0.5896357893943787,
0.10286322981119156,
0.13249334692955017,
0.7913307547569275,
-0.5288644433021545,
0.8568281531333923,
0.5102367997169495,
-0.028444532305002213,
-0.8793557286262512,
0.5206296443939209,
0.5819216966629028,
-0.9429670572280884,
0.39879265427589417,
0.4239894449710846,
-0.31900525093078613,
-0.2471204400062561,
-0.5251067876815796,
-0.8174374103546143,
0.938000500202179,
0.3179772198200226,
-0.28221625089645386,
0.009427618235349655,
0.252525269985199,
0.19382058084011078,
-0.27558982372283936,
-0.049271583557128906,
0.5268923044204712,
0.5362898707389832,
-0.0954170748591423,
-0.6613039970397949,
0.267438143491745,
-0.23878133296966553,
-0.08366066217422485,
0.09622597694396973,
-1.0343353748321533,
0.9003658294677734,
0.10809619724750519,
-0.2806239426136017,
-0.06073947995901108,
0.09803297370672226,
0.24713139235973358,
0.48737987875938416,
0.6573183536529541,
0.6931741237640381,
0.9285505414009094,
0.028034145012497902,
1.0484755039215088,
-0.6101000308990479,
0.01595396362245083,
0.7493466138839722,
-0.6345177888870239,
0.46467843651771545,
0.38190948963165283,
0.31599411368370056,
0.36406025290489197,
0.2998218834400177,
0.2994687259197235,
0.5670982599258423,
0.2126287966966629,
-0.6044715642929077,
0.038765814155340195,
-0.17631416022777557,
-0.4712815582752228,
0.7148815393447876,
0.5339768528938293,
0.1637849658727646,
-0.0028700854163616896,
0.02505197748541832,
0.7058126926422119,
0.09163294732570648,
-0.19672873616218567,
0.8540638089179993,
0.04675055295228958,
-0.7478146553039551,
0.4412352442741394,
-0.017876289784908295,
0.300782710313797,
-0.5197572112083435,
0.270985871553421,
-0.13664866983890533,
0.3148837983608246,
-0.4173576831817627,
-0.34317880868911743,
0.15305911004543304,
-0.06470543891191483,
0.27870500087738037,
-0.11382397264242172,
1.1696240901947021,
-0.19222375750541687,
0.04890595003962517,
0.18221807479858398,
0.5219004154205322,
0.14176636934280396,
-0.28698229789733887,
-0.6916782259941101,
-0.009392249397933483,
-0.33858394622802734,
-0.5625587105751038,
0.24842500686645508,
0.21779002249240875,
0.040456224232912064,
0.8697544932365417,
0.7538219690322876,
0.16589170694351196,
-0.01532022189348936,
0.03472781181335449,
1.125317931175232,
-0.9813877940177917,
-1.0986870527267456,
-0.9260697960853577,
0.31740474700927734,
-0.19064471125602722,
-0.10600882768630981,
0.9150650501251221,
0.5606284141540527,
0.6171665787696838,
0.3490156829357147,
1.0334925651550293,
-0.09020024538040161,
0.365682989358902,
-0.6480342149734497,
0.9241130352020264,
-0.28180813789367676,
0.5392056107521057,
-0.14300847053527832,
-0.49140116572380066,
-0.07154294103384018,
0.34675389528274536,
-0.1304992139339447,
0.03070622682571411,
0.4987303912639618,
1.1162835359573364,
-0.05145617946982384,
0.014986218884587288,
0.3542134463787079,
-0.08142363280057907,
0.8530929684638977,
0.6867852807044983,
1.215824842453003,
-0.19076281785964966,
0.6610468029975891,
-0.09267477691173553,
-0.3796946406364441,
-0.23834629356861115,
-0.7472440004348755,
-0.8870213031768799,
-0.25049763917922974,
-0.1409577578306198,
-0.5744088292121887,
0.0769755020737648,
0.3395751416683197,
1.3347622156143188,
-0.25069865584373474,
-0.08556990325450897,
-0.3450332283973694,
-0.04140069708228111,
-0.019835185259580612,
-0.3439773619174957,
0.07711676508188248,
0.03231982886791229,
-0.3326912522315979,
0.854073703289032,
0.12451541423797607,
0.2187490314245224,
-0.27401304244995117,
-0.0627402514219284,
0.3670293092727661,
0.47914987802505493,
0.023036442697048187,
0.5869578719139099,
-0.7467250823974609,
-0.29835280776023865,
-0.2130555659532547,
-0.2463432401418686,
-0.007061364594846964,
0.7957387566566467,
-0.6432592272758484,
0.3694842755794525,
0.1857225000858307,
0.7264703512191772,
0.48841482400894165,
0.4971465468406677,
0.33600375056266785,
-1.0253461599349976,
0.4963505268096924,
0.18646708130836487,
0.09266000241041183,
0.3410879075527191,
-0.9541410803794861,
0.5195043683052063,
0.060061849653720856,
-0.7171723246574402,
-0.7678359150886536,
0.37036022543907166,
-1.0099453926086426,
-0.5993340611457825,
1.2899644374847412,
-0.04438932612538338,
-0.28247666358947754,
-0.1277918964624405,
-0.10270436853170395,
-0.19487784802913666,
-0.9240445494651794,
0.8109960556030273,
0.6883386373519897,
-0.3906444013118744,
0.18770794570446014,
-0.7242037653923035,
0.5152313709259033,
0.11745138466358185,
-1.0057013034820557,
0.2970457673072815,
0.4229566156864166,
0.24355046451091766,
0.09188671410083771,
0.7558475732803345,
-0.2333419919013977,
0.0974598154425621,
0.11503521353006363,
-0.26321035623550415,
-0.35766977071762085,
-0.5964342951774597,
-0.6387984156608582,
0.24916033446788788,
-0.1395777314901352,
-0.40855976939201355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05161v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05161v1
|
Motion Capture Analysis of Verb and Adjective Types in Austrian Sign Language
| 2024-05-08T15:54:12 | 2024-05-08T15:54:12 |
Julia Krebs, Evie Malaia, Ronnie B. Wilbur, Isabella Fessl, Hans-Peter Wiesinger, Hermann Schwameder, Dietmar Roehm
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, q-bio.NC
|
Across a number of sign languages, temporal and spatial characteristics of
dominant hand articulation are used to express semantic and grammatical
features. In this study of Austrian Sign Language (\"Osterreichische
Geb\"ardensprache, or \"OGS), motion capture data of four Deaf signers is used
to quantitatively characterize the kinematic parameters of sign production in
verbs and adjectives. We investigate (1) the difference in production between
verbs involving a natural endpoint (telic verbs; e.g. arrive) and verbs lacking
an endpoint (atelic verbs; e.g. analyze), and (2) adjective signs in
intensified vs. non-intensified (plain) forms. Motion capture data analysis
using linear-mixed effects models (LME) indicates that both the endpoint
marking in verbs, as well as marking of intensification in adjectives, are
expressed by movement modulation in \"OGS. While the semantic distinction
between verb types (telic/atelic) is marked by higher peak velocity and shorter
duration for telic signs compared to atelic ones, the grammatical distinction
(intensification) in adjectives is expressed by longer duration for intensified
compared to non-intensified adjectives. The observed individual differences of
signers might be interpreted as personal signing style.
|
[
-0.41273969411849976,
-0.6563273072242737,
0.48115378618240356,
-0.16863831877708435,
-0.2427012175321579,
-0.31084302067756653,
-0.0021993285045027733,
-0.659473717212677,
0.7221038341522217,
0.3978900611400604,
-0.4931497275829315,
-0.674003005027771,
-0.9450245499610901,
0.1727614551782608,
-0.5014247298240662,
0.7338261008262634,
-0.7171744108200073,
0.05149148404598236,
0.28310611844062805,
-0.6313110589981079,
-0.07478385418653488,
-0.4723701477050781,
-0.40662845969200134,
-0.052552420645952225,
0.22326812148094177,
0.39753347635269165,
0.7431592345237732,
0.41957753896713257,
0.6520209312438965,
0.3828916847705841,
-0.057984162122011185,
-0.2482285350561142,
0.012814394198358059,
0.3363460302352905,
0.24079546332359314,
-0.4022164046764374,
-0.5357488393783569,
0.06103777885437012,
0.8212130069732666,
0.822515070438385,
0.14307190477848053,
0.31429392099380493,
-0.36218535900115967,
0.6241268515586853,
-0.4148796498775482,
0.03477773070335388,
0.1413949429988861,
0.2412417232990265,
-0.6562265753746033,
-0.20190654695034027,
-0.011633486486971378,
-0.2088940292596817,
-0.015001571737229824,
-0.2846207022666931,
0.2848688066005707,
0.19320136308670044,
0.9868521690368652,
0.06824737042188644,
-0.5555899143218994,
-0.4140573740005493,
-0.9932595491409302,
0.403304785490036,
-1.1369190216064453,
0.7649574875831604,
0.18880978226661682,
0.1736738681793213,
-0.13786441087722778,
-0.40245339274406433,
-0.5044729709625244,
-0.5270883440971375,
0.026793938130140305,
-0.05596724897623062,
-0.15377163887023926,
0.3983205258846283,
0.6040083765983582,
0.5980364680290222,
-0.7163153886795044,
0.39503490924835205,
-0.5564824938774109,
-0.4007680416107178,
0.7689812779426575,
0.3730495572090149,
0.56656813621521,
0.08257988095283508,
-0.29488620162010193,
-0.12425040453672409,
-0.48672834038734436,
0.267568975687027,
0.6717783212661743,
0.19224680960178375,
-0.21626831591129303,
1.1348081827163696,
-0.4880334138870239,
0.8057299256324768,
0.28129133582115173,
0.0339476652443409,
0.17677105963230133,
-0.45174452662467957,
-0.049562107771635056,
-0.03506983816623688,
0.8806905150413513,
0.4801810681819916,
0.17118754982948303,
0.030103566125035286,
-0.5689244270324707,
0.21201874315738678,
-0.3942968547344208,
-0.6299530267715454,
-0.0052824788726866245,
0.1330920308828354,
-0.4156006872653961,
0.11713878065347672,
0.17578141391277313,
-0.6901715397834778,
-0.19772322475910187,
-0.4108896255493164,
0.37669646739959717,
-0.2435554563999176,
-0.2060040831565857,
0.42086347937583923,
-0.24304185807704926,
0.7026987075805664,
0.05069316551089287,
-0.8528785705566406,
0.5368754863739014,
0.4146701693534851,
0.8845257759094238,
-0.18241961300373077,
-0.13762079179286957,
-0.34701523184776306,
-0.2584826946258545,
-0.4759370982646942,
0.6607256531715393,
-0.3376229405403137,
-0.2717881500720978,
0.09711814671754837,
-0.14246992766857147,
-0.30345210433006287,
-0.3767196536064148,
0.22794650495052338,
-0.5101948976516724,
0.5734763741493225,
0.1883530467748642,
-0.5695171356201172,
-0.5617904663085938,
-0.10384312272071838,
-0.7868548631668091,
0.9190992712974548,
0.2806702256202698,
-0.14192929863929749,
0.7826341986656189,
-0.4379035234451294,
-0.6001021265983582,
-0.1162746399641037,
-0.3325660526752472,
-0.2562761902809143,
0.3411749005317688,
-0.3265669047832489,
0.4639110863208771,
0.03659132495522499,
-0.035939015448093414,
-0.052139945328235626,
-0.05852760747075081,
0.5330107808113098,
-0.22659435868263245,
0.3845072090625763,
0.0790865570306778,
-0.5647613406181335,
0.17568647861480713,
-0.8724503517150879,
-0.10778698325157166,
-0.18588490784168243,
-0.5585513710975647,
-0.15679308772087097,
0.07044663280248642,
-0.10642995685338974,
0.38527101278305054,
0.1564420610666275,
-0.7232463359832764,
-0.057830918580293655,
-0.19279611110687256,
-0.016585364937782288,
0.2886955142021179,
0.26894983649253845,
0.3435727059841156,
-0.19385680556297302,
0.6888982653617859,
0.010503653436899185,
-0.014509711414575577,
0.19926616549491882,
-0.7023586630821228,
-0.9764809012413025,
-0.2608986794948578,
-0.029634499922394753,
0.4921768009662628,
-0.36433976888656616,
0.3972333073616028,
-0.38871273398399353,
-0.21040329337120056,
-0.3374932110309601,
0.08699516206979752,
0.5474685430526733,
0.03827719762921333,
-0.013896866701543331,
-0.8078122138977051,
-0.2580890953540802,
-0.7301498055458069,
-0.17252103984355927,
-0.21320948004722595,
0.05088958144187927,
-0.124170683324337,
0.4446975886821747,
0.25899019837379456,
0.504371702671051,
-0.39435526728630066,
-0.4166860282421112,
-0.31692612171173096,
0.45560336112976074,
0.2621876895427704,
0.18700732290744781,
0.8218186497688293,
-0.7071937322616577,
-0.43763241171836853,
0.04843488335609436,
-0.4572872221469879,
-0.2530010938644409,
-0.12954793870449066,
-0.13007202744483948,
0.3651498854160309,
0.6781575083732605,
-0.7245350480079651,
0.5547034740447998,
0.5785481333732605,
-1.1009513139724731,
0.7005017995834351,
-0.14600186049938202,
0.6420480012893677,
-0.4799412786960602,
-0.18329906463623047,
0.09831466525793076,
-0.23219342529773712,
-0.8985032439231873,
-0.1489713191986084,
-0.32406917214393616,
-0.2553202211856842,
-0.5412424206733704,
0.2221384346485138,
-0.8356000781059265,
-0.3864865303039551,
-0.20284265279769897,
0.18315960466861725,
-0.2507392168045044,
0.7044461369514465,
0.24519838392734528,
0.5253962874412537,
0.6888116598129272,
-0.9164650440216064,
0.4283142685890198,
-0.048354100435972214,
-0.22792232036590576,
0.5830314755439758,
-0.5397521257400513,
-0.12731140851974487,
-0.21031279861927032,
-0.4657525420188904,
-1.1878048181533813,
-0.32049864530563354,
0.5492067337036133,
-0.5751816034317017,
0.6763002276420593,
0.32973894476890564,
-0.11048386245965958,
-0.32933810353279114,
-0.29309895634651184,
0.15720359981060028,
0.5199541449546814,
0.022893568500876427,
0.8321602940559387,
0.21486447751522064,
-0.020594602450728416,
-0.0986623764038086,
-0.7533312439918518,
-0.1331217736005783,
-0.5106251239776611,
-0.6338561773300171,
-0.1611739695072174,
0.27749088406562805,
-0.5282271504402161,
0.07891841232776642,
-0.04813547804951668,
-0.1780070811510086,
-0.11468321084976196,
0.17042216658592224,
0.2968437671661377,
-0.6673980951309204,
-0.30949801206588745,
0.020566074177622795,
-0.1160183846950531,
0.13407838344573975,
0.15857616066932678,
0.2812019884586334,
-0.1329636126756668,
-0.6603105664253235,
-0.918030858039856,
0.5647196769714355,
1.011516809463501,
-0.08700687438249588,
0.6944668292999268,
0.1219821348786354,
-0.22271987795829773,
0.4155295789241791,
-0.2376374900341034,
-0.10594043880701065,
-0.3922584354877472,
0.15767456591129303,
-0.26366207003593445,
-0.5427935719490051,
0.8373092412948608,
0.10307226330041885,
0.3874031603336334,
0.5728603005409241,
0.3167736232280731,
-0.19626326858997345,
0.9242103695869446,
0.43380826711654663,
0.11337565630674362,
0.8270576596260071,
-0.34370625019073486,
0.12943881750106812,
-0.8091965913772583,
0.025686481967568398,
-0.6706087589263916,
-0.69217848777771,
-0.44857996702194214,
-0.3195694386959076,
0.12056722491979599,
-0.10378026962280273,
-0.30967268347740173,
0.7181107997894287,
-0.06383123248815536,
-0.17473161220550537,
0.3899412155151367,
-0.13329990208148956,
0.2676941156387329,
-0.2477409541606903,
0.21170982718467712,
-0.22045058012008667,
-0.3038756549358368,
-0.7724336385726929,
0.8490257859230042,
0.1254117488861084,
0.6917173266410828,
0.5240268111228943,
0.5974581837654114,
0.40940430760383606,
0.05468979477882385,
-0.9254022836685181,
0.9343560338020325,
0.007864035665988922,
-0.578214168548584,
-0.3926016092300415,
-0.10366816818714142,
-0.8466333746910095,
0.4054228663444519,
-0.2923811674118042,
-0.7875841856002808,
0.4389999210834503,
0.374362975358963,
-0.023011723533272743,
0.2793816924095154,
-0.5658366084098816,
0.8231074810028076,
-0.5047886967658997,
0.047341238707304,
-0.14634093642234802,
-0.542661726474762,
0.12351596355438232,
0.1565282940864563,
0.20481471717357635,
-0.39802321791648865,
-0.1740395426750183,
0.8496631979942322,
-0.2576039135456085,
0.9529362320899963,
-0.16475269198417664,
-0.36313673853874207,
0.5257411003112793,
0.4058822691440582,
0.47562262415885925,
-0.8987476229667664,
0.02404644526541233,
0.17155992984771729,
-0.17167773842811584,
0.06729868799448013,
-0.5470311641693115,
0.2579427659511566,
-0.3180914521217346,
-0.4500868320465088,
-0.3529592454433441,
0.036535486578941345,
0.09976202994585037,
0.05725179240107536,
0.6198151707649231,
0.9941684603691101,
-0.35092300176620483,
-0.2614394426345825,
0.2266499102115631,
0.20420752465724945,
0.38655954599380493,
0.6862048506736755,
-0.2776126563549042,
-0.20531167089939117,
0.638908863067627,
0.36843472719192505,
0.7999075055122375,
0.2026018649339676,
0.015085444785654545,
-0.2632973790168762,
-0.5519381761550903,
-0.4439598619937897,
0.5437796711921692,
-0.7350983619689941,
0.08044309169054031,
-0.03359062969684601,
0.2220272719860077,
-0.4613720178604126,
-0.14064617455005646,
-0.22266152501106262,
-0.796135425567627,
-0.179691880941391,
-0.32640594244003296,
0.49586185812950134,
0.508228600025177,
-0.22202518582344055,
0.3130744993686676,
-0.69984370470047,
0.41430139541625977,
-0.08486060798168182,
0.0960058718919754,
-0.31583523750305176,
-0.7173755168914795,
-0.09150601923465729,
-0.0560888908803463,
-0.15806689858436584,
-1.151401400566101,
0.19302795827388763,
0.6249029636383057,
0.6891400218009949,
0.7794737219810486,
-0.09263811260461807,
0.4556630551815033,
-0.2969426214694977,
1.080620527267456,
0.4478931128978729,
-0.8813666701316833,
0.48954975605010986,
-0.31365635991096497,
0.05424632504582405,
0.3128150403499603,
0.26980286836624146,
-0.9098349213600159,
-0.8076216578483582,
-0.5496664643287659,
-0.9122880697250366,
0.5847223401069641,
0.2640036940574646,
0.057535845786333084,
0.053790345788002014,
0.07111938297748566,
0.051317524164915085,
0.1611134558916092,
-0.5642563104629517,
-0.2902429699897766,
0.28405195474624634,
-0.40471622347831726,
0.025879180058836937,
-0.0620487742125988,
-0.12125919759273529,
-0.1148233413696289,
0.5280489325523376,
0.10902950912714005,
0.39170360565185547,
0.14229176938533783,
-0.15919199585914612,
-0.321687251329422,
0.26424795389175415,
0.6982508301734924,
0.20452874898910522,
0.19892866909503937,
0.2566518783569336,
0.11599849164485931,
-0.527865469455719,
0.3311055898666382,
-0.3465830683708191,
-0.4065818786621094,
0.4744921326637268,
0.666283905506134,
1.1622461080551147,
0.24330058693885803,
-0.6062495708465576,
0.41503775119781494,
0.41463702917099,
-0.2210148125886917,
-0.29271769523620605,
0.23314572870731354,
-0.4971310794353485,
0.261748343706131,
-0.2591889202594757,
-0.22965304553508759,
0.37911227345466614,
-0.49335914850234985,
-0.19586102664470673,
0.308723121881485,
-0.40274009108543396,
-0.7554569840431213,
0.7193576693534851,
0.09039158374071121,
-0.3663918375968933,
0.42262113094329834,
0.05511109158396721,
-0.43711721897125244,
0.7214576005935669,
0.2810332775115967,
1.1362733840942383,
-0.26395198702812195,
0.15453532338142395,
0.4242747128009796,
0.10447781533002853,
0.0743657797574997,
0.6767645478248596,
-0.4158223271369934,
-0.7396314740180969,
-0.23183411359786987,
-0.3664601147174835,
-0.2134215384721756,
-0.43013739585876465,
-0.8578492999076843,
0.2903076708316803,
0.10029269754886627,
-0.4979749619960785,
-0.026930194348096848,
-0.637931764125824,
-0.489452064037323,
0.13654747605323792,
0.36118194460868835,
0.5175009369850159,
-1.2871227264404297,
0.10592424124479294,
0.9268165826797485,
-0.42560774087905884,
-0.6507397890090942,
-0.04522279277443886,
0.2021971344947815,
-0.5280147194862366,
0.7546886205673218,
0.07938674092292786,
-0.7080169320106506,
-0.10449468344449997,
-0.32568952441215515,
-1.0928305387496948,
0.7913374304771423,
-0.005492108408361673,
-0.28067317605018616,
0.09992239624261856,
0.3273908793926239,
0.8446281552314758,
-0.2122177630662918,
-0.21981284022331238,
0.6905149221420288,
0.4830370545387268,
0.08418706059455872,
-1.0783624649047852,
-0.04670827463269234,
0.15900179743766785,
-0.004602672532200813,
0.7411590814590454,
-0.31123626232147217,
0.45747193694114685,
-0.3391527533531189,
-0.7968810796737671,
0.13337388634681702,
0.8381193280220032,
0.04523743316531181,
0.32817381620407104,
0.17363403737545013,
0.5349424481391907,
0.4480709135532379,
-0.13214683532714844,
0.928102970123291,
-0.39254167675971985,
0.2700832486152649,
0.4865792691707611,
-0.22281917929649353,
0.8583332300186157,
0.511297881603241,
-0.24533699452877045,
0.5100594758987427,
0.39472588896751404,
0.4051069915294647,
0.3442528545856476,
0.01029132679104805,
-0.3626102805137634,
-0.17736539244651794,
0.27304238080978394,
0.052952852100133896,
0.6006766557693481,
0.5604760050773621,
-0.38213056325912476,
-0.2371455729007721,
0.6198685765266418,
0.2276262491941452,
0.041968658566474915,
-0.4814440906047821,
0.7643067240715027,
0.16009898483753204,
-0.6296442151069641,
0.4757974147796631,
-0.24328522384166718,
0.39679116010665894,
-0.8149484992027283,
0.1515914648771286,
-0.0833667442202568,
0.1148403212428093,
-0.0946311503648758,
-1.2355990409851074,
0.4097044765949249,
0.057042598724365234,
0.14096713066101074,
-0.3212551772594452,
0.48603665828704834,
-0.4514445662498474,
-0.22998076677322388,
0.3117592930793762,
0.17446021735668182,
0.8541299104690552,
0.5544793009757996,
-0.2053322196006775,
-0.11397533863782883,
-0.14938805997371674,
-0.5905917286872864,
-0.24741911888122559,
0.5672870874404907,
-0.13771483302116394,
0.4751669466495514,
0.1865987330675125,
0.43370261788368225,
0.6155564188957214,
0.035128261893987656,
0.42906928062438965,
-0.7475693821907043,
-0.2993225157260895,
-0.48693403601646423,
0.500355064868927,
0.2258305847644806,
-0.6534762382507324,
0.8957652449607849,
0.405561625957489,
0.6663067936897278,
-0.29510724544525146,
0.1727639138698578,
-0.4733886122703552,
0.26201021671295166,
-0.8952112197875977,
0.13734117150306702,
-0.3132574260234833,
-0.2924007773399353,
-0.052506349980831146,
-0.9399667978286743,
-0.2969362437725067,
0.3775196373462677,
-0.33182716369628906,
0.0683869868516922,
0.5374842882156372,
0.5767578482627869,
0.0661698654294014,
-0.28610485792160034,
0.4379677176475525,
-0.06582644581794739,
0.11762585490942001,
0.3798387944698334,
0.6330447793006897,
-0.3269978165626526,
0.088999904692173,
-0.10064700245857239,
-0.2169017642736435,
-0.33875322341918945,
-0.4526137113571167,
-0.5372800827026367,
-0.7280265092849731,
-0.7269445657730103,
-0.13765980303287506,
-0.409005731344223,
0.6129540205001831,
0.37447577714920044,
-0.9491441249847412,
-0.3150738775730133,
0.12278562784194946,
-0.37794166803359985,
-0.5744233727455139,
-0.2256934940814972,
0.4602901041507721,
0.07518516480922699,
-0.7458887100219727,
0.21816295385360718,
0.27798202633857727,
0.7507646679878235,
-0.25000616908073425,
-0.1283464878797531,
0.0610683374106884,
0.18797776103019714,
0.46575653553009033,
0.8063967227935791,
-0.5437178015708923,
-0.39062854647636414,
0.1358330398797989,
-0.24207930266857147,
0.20609740912914276,
0.9119062423706055,
-0.2305135875940323,
0.39962539076805115,
0.8341087102890015,
-0.316769003868103,
0.2950865626335144,
0.12631206214427948,
0.5395130515098572,
-0.5162693858146667,
0.36160001158714294,
0.1800597757101059,
0.6866750121116638,
0.22542151808738708,
-0.4217817783355713,
0.23860107362270355,
0.37057098746299744,
-0.3167611360549927,
-0.26949670910835266,
0.4978870451450348,
-0.9037792682647705,
0.11710088700056076,
1.3113163709640503,
0.11405812203884125,
-0.2627905309200287,
-0.15705923736095428,
-0.35510003566741943,
0.28915050625801086,
-0.2149525135755539,
0.24944348633289337,
0.8816069960594177,
-0.7797618508338928,
0.025298433378338814,
-0.5559720993041992,
0.3120216131210327,
-0.0028778440319001675,
-0.48461711406707764,
-0.011415879242122173,
1.1411815881729126,
0.09529474377632141,
0.27778467535972595,
0.7692385911941528,
-0.27705758810043335,
0.34784528613090515,
0.09368152171373367,
0.31605902314186096,
0.21242409944534302,
-0.33094990253448486,
-0.4656851291656494,
-0.20386672019958496,
0.23831059038639069,
-0.8992685675621033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05116v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05116v2
|
XAMPLER: Learning to Retrieve Cross-Lingual In-Context Examples
| 2024-05-08T15:13:33 | 2024-06-29T13:09:36 |
Peiqin Lin, André F. T. Martins, Hinrich Schütze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent studies indicate that leveraging off-the-shelf or fine-tuned
retrievers, capable of retrieving relevant in-context examples tailored to the
input query, enhances few-shot in-context learning of English. However,
adapting these methods to other languages, especially low-resource ones, poses
challenges due to the scarcity of cross-lingual retrievers and annotated data.
Thus, we introduce XAMPLER: Cross-Lingual Example Retrieval, a method tailored
to tackle the challenge of cross-lingual in-context learning using only
annotated English data. XAMPLER first trains a retriever based on Glot500, a
multilingual small language model, using positive and negative English examples
constructed from the predictions of a multilingual large language model, i.e.,
MaLA500. Leveraging the cross-lingual capacity of the retriever, it can
directly retrieve English examples as few-shot examples for in-context learning
of target languages. Experiments on the multilingual text classification
benchmark SIB200 with 176 languages show that XAMPLER substantially improves
the in-context learning performance across languages. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/cisnlp/XAMPLER}.
|
[
-0.49051421880722046,
-0.5464335083961487,
0.16414883732795715,
0.17728577554225922,
-0.4451153576374054,
-0.1551319658756256,
-0.3387075364589691,
-0.6600174903869629,
0.20911329984664917,
0.0725693479180336,
-0.26718172430992126,
-0.16617245972156525,
-0.43610018491744995,
0.2296770066022873,
-0.4804597496986389,
0.9516516327857971,
-0.06690935045480728,
0.5744429230690002,
-0.08078055083751678,
-0.23598618805408478,
-0.472849041223526,
-0.47886788845062256,
-0.8734810948371887,
-0.48126667737960815,
0.6627095341682434,
0.7362135648727417,
0.22830525040626526,
0.42851781845092773,
0.017725011333823204,
0.23805749416351318,
0.20992816984653473,
0.03145841881632805,
-0.6991822123527527,
0.03500077500939369,
-0.4062604606151581,
-0.6697841882705688,
0.006244626361876726,
-0.15456056594848633,
0.7076361179351807,
0.6759770512580872,
0.12287544459104538,
0.029735993593931198,
0.10206320136785507,
0.10397517681121826,
-0.4087936282157898,
0.24583546817302704,
-0.6760855913162231,
0.18927589058876038,
-0.45555442571640015,
-0.5828157663345337,
-0.5678187012672424,
0.026562891900539398,
0.26158666610717773,
-0.6129017472267151,
0.23215939104557037,
0.6170594096183777,
0.7598651051521301,
-0.2053762525320053,
-0.6187201738357544,
-0.5138171315193176,
-0.24271869659423828,
1.0232940912246704,
-0.41105231642723083,
0.6611841917037964,
0.4525008201599121,
0.683842658996582,
0.02863999828696251,
-0.7038070559501648,
-0.7039280533790588,
0.19906161725521088,
-0.4070570766925812,
-0.1077912300825119,
-0.3190147876739502,
-0.44985029101371765,
0.026673592627048492,
0.46068087220191956,
-0.7575008273124695,
-0.029030922800302505,
-0.3279665410518646,
-0.008794252760708332,
0.5769984126091003,
-0.06788478046655655,
0.3440145254135132,
-0.2939971685409546,
-0.4074800908565521,
-0.23673787713050842,
-0.9617341160774231,
0.14348478615283966,
0.22345156967639923,
0.4386436343193054,
-0.2713997960090637,
0.3100632429122925,
-0.10810680687427521,
0.6045147776603699,
0.12664882838726044,
-0.17143960297107697,
0.43294522166252136,
-0.20321841537952423,
-0.04685865342617035,
0.3062712252140045,
0.4838484525680542,
0.29481351375579834,
0.2756640911102295,
-0.2580386698246002,
-0.09324657917022705,
-0.21966838836669922,
-0.21579532325267792,
-0.8365882039070129,
-0.42439863085746765,
0.04805851727724075,
-0.3449452221393585,
-0.05449158698320389,
-0.17813284695148468,
-0.9266836047172546,
-0.19650566577911377,
0.10044198483228683,
0.4504816234111786,
-0.41867387294769287,
-0.09262359142303467,
0.010590272024273872,
-0.24494770169258118,
0.6054140329360962,
0.010450853034853935,
-0.7357118129730225,
0.1898810863494873,
0.6889276504516602,
0.6051779389381409,
-0.2858247458934784,
-0.648750901222229,
-0.8830034732818604,
0.1138453334569931,
-0.19836640357971191,
0.8363472819328308,
-0.5771401524543762,
-0.388272762298584,
-0.04037697613239288,
0.3545050024986267,
0.12210666388273239,
-0.4649497866630554,
0.456961989402771,
-0.604800283908844,
0.821658194065094,
-0.389329731464386,
-0.6620305776596069,
-0.3712739050388336,
0.4482456147670746,
-0.6054726839065552,
0.9661285281181335,
0.1153462678194046,
-0.7301815748214722,
0.7780072689056396,
-0.47462698817253113,
-0.8127537369728088,
0.03973807767033577,
-0.519665539264679,
-0.20327810943126678,
0.03653211519122124,
0.2804213762283325,
0.36890655755996704,
-0.34476083517074585,
-0.11327478289604187,
-0.009030040353536606,
-0.5035436153411865,
-0.09753098338842392,
-0.4481160640716553,
0.9758986234664917,
-0.07479742914438248,
-0.4578830301761627,
0.03752635046839714,
-0.7980709671974182,
0.2219490259885788,
0.19741632044315338,
-0.36202606558799744,
-0.6802655458450317,
-0.15441904962062836,
0.5434433221817017,
0.7389364242553711,
-0.3337530493736267,
-0.7447150349617004,
-0.0347106009721756,
-0.46761974692344666,
0.09301120787858963,
0.3067058026790619,
0.07425075024366379,
0.4406581223011017,
-0.262225478887558,
0.6561574339866638,
-0.03870585933327675,
-0.5412232279777527,
-0.5944859385490417,
-0.31202802062034607,
-0.49002495408058167,
-0.4475093483924866,
0.4959559738636017,
0.5004683136940002,
-1.0647475719451904,
0.11710453033447266,
-0.5156187415122986,
-0.3687986731529236,
-0.5676636695861816,
0.5469555854797363,
0.6721462607383728,
0.6584405899047852,
0.4946471154689789,
-0.2097478210926056,
-0.759985625743866,
-0.5095380544662476,
-0.2565322518348694,
0.19332218170166016,
-0.06765445321798325,
0.4123914837837219,
0.45849576592445374,
-0.06575825810432434,
0.9676371812820435,
-0.21707554161548615,
-0.4840678572654724,
-0.8761307001113892,
-0.07745124399662018,
-0.08157167583703995,
0.4810357093811035,
0.7639865279197693,
-0.9925671219825745,
-0.849263608455658,
0.31058046221733093,
-0.6695601940155029,
-0.12342043966054916,
-0.02458113245666027,
-0.23172760009765625,
0.43283042311668396,
0.5876585245132446,
-0.23527325689792633,
0.080132856965065,
0.7106968760490417,
-0.30223777890205383,
-0.02832261472940445,
-0.13303571939468384,
0.08014728128910065,
-1.0125759840011597,
-0.14457495510578156,
-0.01998177543282509,
-0.6444978713989258,
-0.36515310406684875,
0.06486763060092926,
0.31846150755882263,
-0.025079449638724327,
-0.8061334490776062,
1.1105760335922241,
-0.5900607705116272,
0.19502504169940948,
-0.27228808403015137,
0.4571620523929596,
0.1690351814031601,
0.4735942780971527,
0.31697797775268555,
0.6991472244262695,
0.5536072850227356,
-0.26112091541290283,
0.17937922477722168,
0.28827252984046936,
-0.38600394129753113,
0.8419414162635803,
-0.5656094551086426,
-0.18332123756408691,
-0.15796425938606262,
0.25041520595550537,
-0.9526073932647705,
-0.2621854841709137,
0.12945950031280518,
-0.21874061226844788,
0.5147281289100647,
-0.23100899159908295,
-0.2798163592815399,
-0.035005416721105576,
-0.4397660791873932,
0.6008235812187195,
0.4534323513507843,
-1.127764344215393,
0.4004208743572235,
0.5376060009002686,
-0.36594343185424805,
-0.45282769203186035,
-0.7747697830200195,
-0.046331871300935745,
-0.1755402833223343,
-0.2693817615509033,
0.3102237582206726,
0.183078795671463,
-0.06077812239527702,
-0.038841065019369125,
-0.21926748752593994,
0.09373317658901215,
-0.3230224549770355,
0.03363162279129028,
0.017370695248246193,
-0.11668889224529266,
0.0007701550493948162,
0.20177531242370605,
-0.3025783896446228,
0.03541572391986847,
-0.25296029448509216,
0.6153894066810608,
0.17934086918830872,
-0.5069719552993774,
0.09362945705652237,
0.7478163838386536,
0.0004553922626655549,
-0.25363603234291077,
0.2609662115573883,
0.5960367918014526,
-0.428313285112381,
-0.5034545063972473,
-0.14548823237419128,
-0.213279590010643,
-0.46238505840301514,
0.5236704349517822,
-0.6484467387199402,
-0.7328166961669922,
0.19948342442512512,
0.19787976145744324,
-0.07586672902107239,
-0.16137062013149261,
0.5685631632804871,
0.014854012057185173,
1.0931020975112915,
0.9297431111335754,
-0.3162062466144562,
0.5689748525619507,
-0.4126376807689667,
0.36403048038482666,
-0.4280734956264496,
-0.031505219638347626,
-0.2819599509239197,
-0.28108590841293335,
-0.6073768138885498,
-0.4469798803329468,
0.16020195186138153,
-0.030299117788672447,
0.1771383434534073,
0.44620850682258606,
0.0014269606908783317,
0.933995246887207,
0.6645856499671936,
-0.07969951629638672,
0.43364477157592773,
0.07179591059684753,
-0.2595428228378296,
-0.17956407368183136,
-0.9864571690559387,
-0.2151595503091812,
0.7368451952934265,
-0.04728083685040474,
0.7998228073120117,
0.04195978119969368,
0.7365642786026001,
-0.014489473775029182,
0.3493135869503021,
-0.740286111831665,
0.3253478407859802,
0.062097761780023575,
-0.892596960067749,
-0.0452335886657238,
-0.37875065207481384,
-1.0955921411514282,
0.7723362445831299,
0.0865129679441452,
-0.6581515073776245,
0.3728312849998474,
0.3231315612792969,
0.06679506599903107,
0.26251471042633057,
-0.6378560662269592,
1.153792142868042,
-0.51451575756073,
-0.5342612266540527,
-0.17193949222564697,
-0.7196937799453735,
0.09539780765771866,
-0.26537981629371643,
0.2804853916168213,
0.1679512858390808,
-0.12141022086143494,
0.29390838742256165,
-0.11204016208648682,
0.8197978734970093,
-0.2902393639087677,
-0.20499640703201294,
0.09024003893136978,
0.056706953793764114,
0.35953155159950256,
0.24375160038471222,
-0.17080943286418915,
0.22152309119701385,
0.011604073457419872,
-0.6552167534828186,
-0.4023871421813965,
0.7897541522979736,
-0.4083716571331024,
-0.3679359257221222,
-0.43340370059013367,
-0.7677629590034485,
-0.1846524327993393,
0.4587446451187134,
0.596867024898529,
0.4874270260334015,
-0.19847926497459412,
0.20090486109256744,
0.31610289216041565,
-0.11119959503412247,
0.5717261433601379,
0.5832712054252625,
-0.4588507115840912,
-0.3329809606075287,
1.096183180809021,
0.13044145703315735,
0.11466391384601593,
0.7541099786758423,
-0.033841151744127274,
-0.34737086296081543,
-0.2801361083984375,
-0.656463086605072,
0.1280805915594101,
-1.0078321695327759,
-0.3034607172012329,
-0.5288832783699036,
0.35944145917892456,
-0.08358599245548248,
-0.41610434651374817,
-0.028386538848280907,
-0.44224977493286133,
0.1553349643945694,
-0.08991988748311996,
0.10359601676464081,
0.26949039101600647,
0.034438543021678925,
0.36664247512817383,
-0.5074911117553711,
0.33548927307128906,
-0.02996058389544487,
0.20189213752746582,
-0.07508470863103867,
-0.384395956993103,
-0.43917417526245117,
-0.025287343189120293,
-0.1683337688446045,
-0.7398515939712524,
0.6525710225105286,
0.5246762633323669,
0.7288897633552551,
0.49393510818481445,
0.020230300724506378,
0.846077561378479,
-0.6527776718139648,
0.47334638237953186,
-0.1894788295030594,
-0.9782018661499023,
0.3113456666469574,
-0.003226661588996649,
0.08668754994869232,
0.5599954724311829,
0.9704345464706421,
-0.8432525396347046,
-0.13051076233386993,
-0.3089028596878052,
-0.976028561592102,
0.6589385867118835,
-0.4079902470111847,
0.11492720991373062,
-0.19792138040065765,
0.002235112013295293,
0.40997907519340515,
0.1807582676410675,
-0.8983322978019714,
-0.10579881072044373,
-0.10659212619066238,
-0.20435810089111328,
-0.4381512701511383,
0.09060293436050415,
-0.0478910468518734,
-0.4366981089115143,
0.7922411561012268,
-0.5479447245597839,
-0.18775574862957,
0.15993598103523254,
-0.8402306437492371,
-0.17480242252349854,
0.4010063707828522,
0.17349974811077118,
0.5078514218330383,
0.02822224609553814,
0.17030294239521027,
0.6000444889068604,
-0.14528819918632507,
0.27386337518692017,
0.29829537868499756,
-0.2344302535057068,
0.21320310235023499,
0.40583503246307373,
0.44714614748954773,
0.7578791379928589,
-0.9763391613960266,
0.7352895736694336,
0.005155391991138458,
0.24442043900489807,
-0.29005056619644165,
-0.22715654969215393,
-0.1549282670021057,
0.2730536162853241,
0.40524551272392273,
-0.3122639060020447,
0.23547998070716858,
-0.47565314173698425,
0.42352575063705444,
0.5969294905662537,
-0.4170421361923218,
-0.30275723338127136,
0.6802107691764832,
0.09144113957881927,
-0.15056905150413513,
0.40107566118240356,
-0.6005352139472961,
-0.5587875843048096,
0.09030906111001968,
1.0740541219711304,
0.572881281375885,
0.16701127588748932,
-0.24264831840991974,
-0.07379046827554703,
0.12904027104377747,
0.15703228116035461,
0.5092043876647949,
-0.41894322633743286,
-0.5558078289031982,
-0.4348417818546295,
-0.22283899784088135,
-0.6371740698814392,
-0.38547661900520325,
-0.698141872882843,
0.5884987711906433,
-0.0027626105584204197,
0.35819560289382935,
-0.0037275291979312897,
0.26601889729499817,
-0.6346338391304016,
0.1295178085565567,
0.19269926846027374,
1.3630226850509644,
-0.9343039393424988,
1.3036102056503296,
0.905088484287262,
-0.4040085971355438,
-0.6080121994018555,
-0.13410942256450653,
0.0878274142742157,
-0.7958676815032959,
0.4160286784172058,
0.20633932948112488,
-0.19165745377540588,
0.06469827890396118,
-0.09216835349798203,
-0.6545788049697876,
1.073262333869934,
0.33048489689826965,
-0.4663052558898926,
-0.04202989861369133,
0.0704784095287323,
0.5125342011451721,
-0.4665296971797943,
0.37866291403770447,
0.4950413405895233,
0.32929494976997375,
-0.2580465078353882,
-0.7109121084213257,
-0.0027342166285961866,
-0.46764591336250305,
-0.1086542010307312,
0.22588205337524414,
-0.5274731516838074,
0.8135575652122498,
-0.2533176839351654,
-0.08123452216386795,
-0.02130281925201416,
0.5074493885040283,
0.25399312376976013,
0.478385329246521,
0.4704243242740631,
0.4293990433216095,
0.6098424196243286,
-0.04332448169589043,
1.3377691507339478,
-0.37610653042793274,
0.3356631100177765,
1.2999157905578613,
-0.6326565742492676,
1.0808169841766357,
0.8142522573471069,
0.26064664125442505,
0.5712359547615051,
0.4092348515987396,
0.0022268311586230993,
0.7111817598342896,
-0.09363976866006851,
-0.17068885266780853,
-0.11666467040777206,
0.07445678114891052,
-0.31425005197525024,
0.5205162167549133,
0.16556593775749207,
-0.3479253053665161,
-0.5749233961105347,
0.4654536545276642,
0.2950670123100281,
-0.0997045636177063,
-0.2804822027683258,
0.5363525748252869,
0.03207187354564667,
-0.38182389736175537,
0.5667334198951721,
-0.05905615910887718,
1.0093144178390503,
-0.6202616095542908,
-0.2212616205215454,
-0.20058633387088776,
0.5112539529800415,
-0.3319775462150574,
-0.5148337483406067,
0.17087644338607788,
-0.08831842243671417,
-0.19917523860931396,
-0.36962786316871643,
0.6105331182479858,
-0.8519189953804016,
-0.46451082825660706,
0.5961365699768066,
0.7706805467605591,
0.23563891649246216,
0.1221020445227623,
-0.33165860176086426,
-0.024358456954360008,
-0.07642523944377899,
-0.26987019181251526,
0.4271433353424072,
0.4631822407245636,
-0.4753562808036804,
0.5492197871208191,
0.3594213128089905,
0.10230985283851624,
0.2240663319826126,
-0.11450008302927017,
0.7735303044319153,
-0.6233439445495605,
-0.5835117101669312,
-0.7250826358795166,
0.26910924911499023,
-0.054827868938446045,
-0.34045344591140747,
1.2650315761566162,
0.9362567067146301,
1.857478380203247,
-0.0627337396144867,
0.8459226489067078,
-0.2562638521194458,
0.5913373827934265,
-0.10746920108795166,
0.7440536618232727,
-0.7827256321907043,
0.20614124834537506,
-0.24996162950992584,
-0.5314881801605225,
-0.4414248764514923,
0.7669817209243774,
-0.48209401965141296,
-0.007030191365629435,
0.6140176653862,
0.8403429388999939,
-0.5945475101470947,
0.02342377044260502,
0.4526537358760834,
-0.1712794154882431,
0.27525579929351807,
0.523923933506012,
0.6605635285377502,
-0.5875587463378906,
0.9678861498832703,
-0.6782923340797424,
-0.183427095413208,
-0.27983570098876953,
-0.9192106127738953,
-0.9027063250541687,
-0.39939361810684204,
-0.039862994104623795,
0.04102398455142975,
0.07603880763053894,
1.2703211307525635,
1.0520098209381104,
-1.142060399055481,
-0.4608524441719055,
0.2584022879600525,
0.3365820050239563,
-0.3963286876678467,
-0.2532796263694763,
0.0042494433000683784,
-0.6061174869537354,
-1.0951614379882812,
0.5356245636940002,
0.01705014333128929,
-0.19708047807216644,
-0.06597167998552322,
-0.13392578065395355,
-0.24401351809501648,
-0.07847082614898682,
0.7617214918136597,
0.495817631483078,
-0.3522832691669464,
-0.2854663133621216,
0.061493873596191406,
-0.08997348695993423,
0.32767215371131897,
0.9646555185317993,
-1.0720826387405396,
0.2662147283554077,
0.6433505415916443,
0.847914457321167,
0.5489053130149841,
-0.1993468552827835,
0.5837090015411377,
-1.2001394033432007,
0.47816652059555054,
0.02944180555641651,
0.8681215643882751,
0.47726526856422424,
-0.021114088594913483,
0.44961199164390564,
-0.0626286193728447,
-0.36602291464805603,
-1.0157907009124756,
0.07377733290195465,
-0.6024697422981262,
-0.13347743451595306,
0.8226272463798523,
-0.4265235662460327,
-0.21691735088825226,
-0.14701196551322937,
-0.5248604416847229,
0.05847428739070892,
-0.1926078498363495,
0.6035009622573853,
0.3346109390258789,
-0.26116514205932617,
-0.4663205146789551,
-0.39978155493736267,
0.22162173688411713,
0.5402572751045227,
-0.8225157856941223,
-0.10272816568613052,
0.26453927159309387,
0.5458017587661743,
0.2117626965045929,
0.414651095867157,
-0.19072599709033966,
0.49262717366218567,
0.09727326035499573,
0.01771381124854088,
0.17690406739711761,
-0.3054562211036682,
-0.7578754425048828,
0.23489166796207428,
-0.022780582308769226,
-0.2208082675933838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05109v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05109v1
|
QFMTS: Generating Query-Focused Summaries over Multi-Table Inputs
| 2024-05-08T15:05:55 | 2024-05-08T15:05:55 |
Weijia Zhang, Vaishali Pal, Jia-Hong Huang, Evangelos Kanoulas, Maarten de Rijke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Table summarization is a crucial task aimed at condensing information from
tabular data into concise and comprehensible textual summaries. However,
existing approaches often fall short of adequately meeting users' information
and quality requirements and tend to overlook the complexities of real-world
queries. In this paper, we propose a novel method to address these limitations
by introducing query-focused multi-table summarization. Our approach, which
comprises a table serialization module, a summarization controller, and a large
language model (LLM), utilizes textual queries and multiple tables to generate
query-dependent table summaries tailored to users' information needs. To
facilitate research in this area, we present a comprehensive dataset
specifically tailored for this task, consisting of 4909 query-summary pairs,
each associated with multiple tables. Through extensive experiments using our
curated dataset, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method
compared to baseline approaches. Our findings offer insights into the
challenges of complex table reasoning for precise summarization, contributing
to the advancement of research in query-focused multi-table summarization.
|
[
-0.41624537110328674,
-0.7813197374343872,
0.6264969706535339,
0.220489501953125,
-0.42803123593330383,
0.10978541523218155,
0.29277747869491577,
0.04333634674549103,
0.4282623529434204,
0.6667564511299133,
-0.5637156963348389,
-0.7040017247200012,
-0.10465822368860245,
0.062047719955444336,
-0.6580684781074524,
1.1836515665054321,
0.027738405391573906,
-0.1523664891719818,
-0.33612799644470215,
-0.10946206003427505,
-0.3913191556930542,
-0.7012540102005005,
0.030980810523033142,
0.1703452616930008,
0.6957595944404602,
0.7766450643539429,
0.5468769669532776,
0.35128533840179443,
0.6087523698806763,
0.10045742243528366,
0.2915014326572418,
0.5896750688552856,
-0.4697265326976776,
0.626295268535614,
0.2306251972913742,
-0.5969336628913879,
-0.7063482403755188,
-0.3687783479690552,
0.6650654673576355,
0.5244107842445374,
-0.18083101511001587,
0.2937111556529999,
0.012903102673590183,
0.7975557446479797,
-0.4523313045501709,
0.3864431083202362,
-0.554347574710846,
0.31740060448646545,
-0.12442901730537415,
-0.4325157105922699,
-0.4246697425842285,
-0.583830714225769,
-0.17007111012935638,
-0.5025774240493774,
0.1970537006855011,
0.10942023992538452,
0.6393975615501404,
0.018473010510206223,
-1.0743651390075684,
-0.0213454719632864,
-0.8370888233184814,
0.24729301035404205,
-0.8437923789024353,
0.48014095425605774,
0.2687928080558777,
0.6100319623947144,
-0.1320466548204422,
-0.9942465424537659,
-0.42999863624572754,
-0.15670642256736755,
-0.5130040645599365,
0.24833831191062927,
0.1620950698852539,
-0.15185248851776123,
0.2802961766719818,
0.2119695246219635,
-0.7833524346351624,
-0.5574955344200134,
-0.031474657356739044,
-0.0708034336566925,
0.4881243109703064,
0.7269645929336548,
0.031138161197304726,
0.005479856859892607,
-0.22416366636753082,
-0.00211512204259634,
-0.5774291753768921,
0.11820896714925766,
-0.08284629881381989,
0.3068277835845947,
0.03416593372821808,
0.7342031598091125,
-0.7635673880577087,
0.6681267619132996,
-0.2310171127319336,
-0.345181405544281,
-0.36041128635406494,
-0.8849225044250488,
0.028754474595189095,
-0.20114798843860626,
0.8049787282943726,
0.7100724577903748,
-0.05839792266488075,
-0.5321451425552368,
-0.32805368304252625,
-0.4580526649951935,
0.1669907420873642,
-1.0620324611663818,
-0.1101539358496666,
0.500254213809967,
-0.11535463482141495,
-0.31618764996528625,
0.4102233946323395,
-0.7267692685127258,
-0.09170577675104141,
-0.34289801120758057,
0.491097092628479,
0.010898859240114689,
-0.18683962523937225,
-0.34592387080192566,
-0.38966771960258484,
0.24622289836406708,
0.32759612798690796,
-0.7583633065223694,
0.29935747385025024,
0.3857972323894501,
0.7611450552940369,
-0.3398856520652771,
-0.14804033935070038,
-0.6394911408424377,
0.8399426937103271,
-0.18019767105579376,
0.9073705077171326,
-0.19070512056350708,
-0.5241672396659851,
-0.04212860018014908,
-0.1582040935754776,
0.07891298085451126,
-0.4277416169643402,
0.43608981370925903,
-0.6012263298034668,
0.06668814271688461,
-0.7530651688575745,
-0.2950323522090912,
-0.007335555739700794,
0.575596272945404,
-0.5204901695251465,
0.9157584309577942,
-0.02191348373889923,
-0.7536896467208862,
0.46362775564193726,
-0.33438757061958313,
-0.9497464895248413,
-0.1946174055337906,
-0.29048100113868713,
-0.5800839066505432,
0.08312655985355377,
0.4967081546783447,
0.7311945557594299,
-0.17337167263031006,
0.5969817638397217,
-0.14937236905097961,
-0.21456082165241241,
0.44600963592529297,
-0.08763354271650314,
0.11785605549812317,
-0.04919782653450966,
-0.14936350286006927,
0.543363094329834,
-0.7556425333023071,
0.10613022744655609,
0.20745663344860077,
-0.5660274624824524,
0.18388456106185913,
0.07092408090829849,
0.07321909815073013,
0.1459117829799652,
0.025315919890999794,
-0.10586759448051453,
0.30069097876548767,
-0.14531584084033966,
0.5718145370483398,
-0.016251010820269585,
0.38600218296051025,
0.36280402541160583,
-0.6695281863212585,
0.764251172542572,
-0.0024591037072241306,
0.26661309599876404,
-0.6115652322769165,
-0.006592028774321079,
-0.4292047917842865,
-0.14115551114082336,
0.10124491155147552,
0.44332244992256165,
-0.8765506148338318,
-0.053994812071323395,
-0.1642467975616455,
-0.5383849740028381,
0.10499738901853561,
-0.3957829177379608,
0.22730694711208344,
0.6495377421379089,
0.4295695424079895,
0.12623001635074615,
-0.28754815459251404,
-0.9911543726921082,
-0.4451727271080017,
0.19468039274215698,
-0.1560363918542862,
0.21120591461658478,
0.2516779601573944,
0.4223511815071106,
1.0400135517120361,
-0.9727452993392944,
-0.5015052556991577,
-0.46919164061546326,
-0.041483525186777115,
0.08511875569820404,
0.4533696472644806,
0.5470282435417175,
-0.7744629383087158,
-0.44788989424705505,
-0.03814283758401871,
-0.6621900200843811,
0.34167277812957764,
-0.241006001830101,
-0.47554293274879456,
-0.3315216898918152,
0.5570208430290222,
-0.8034857511520386,
0.24519586563110352,
-0.17666475474834442,
-0.25765904784202576,
0.8766794204711914,
0.04508235305547714,
0.46216174960136414,
-1.2309311628341675,
0.11969701945781708,
-0.3639361560344696,
-0.36237621307373047,
-0.6476039886474609,
0.3309553265571594,
0.24014946818351746,
-0.2763824164867401,
-0.16780340671539307,
0.08082836866378784,
-0.49096059799194336,
-0.1350758969783783,
0.16972461342811584,
0.20554904639720917,
0.5661813020706177,
0.773491621017456,
-0.3237072825431824,
0.7226358652114868,
-0.005719658453017473,
-0.6219123601913452,
0.3195807635784149,
0.4194033741950989,
0.1331162303686142,
0.3756387531757355,
-0.751401960849762,
-0.1850867122411728,
-0.06860870122909546,
0.45557910203933716,
-1.403876781463623,
-0.5767867565155029,
0.2011851817369461,
-0.5646990537643433,
0.32492795586586,
-0.014035671949386597,
-0.5589017868041992,
-0.09412994980812073,
-0.6416399478912354,
0.20406480133533478,
-0.029761068522930145,
-0.16828513145446777,
1.0201518535614014,
0.4920002520084381,
-0.2796314060688019,
-0.6101168394088745,
-0.855654776096344,
0.18713843822479248,
-0.16017404198646545,
-0.5911614894866943,
0.4767826795578003,
0.11203710734844208,
-0.07332025468349457,
-0.1267504245042801,
-0.46809402108192444,
-0.24673455953598022,
0.044064730405807495,
0.11147729307413101,
-0.11440890282392502,
-0.40511608123779297,
0.2031860500574112,
0.5694999098777771,
0.3021019697189331,
0.24976631999015808,
-0.36372435092926025,
0.4237323999404907,
0.058142468333244324,
-0.22774741053581238,
-0.5689512491226196,
0.6515045762062073,
0.7794982194900513,
-0.7436951994895935,
0.5633401274681091,
0.659598171710968,
-0.2763863205909729,
-0.2484094202518463,
-0.5430741310119629,
-0.41534629464149475,
-0.34700408577919006,
0.5153285264968872,
-0.6987264752388,
-0.8140177130699158,
0.9027210474014282,
0.2635888457298279,
0.49690181016921997,
0.4298618733882904,
0.3934881389141083,
-0.3161816895008087,
1.0487632751464844,
0.24524708092212677,
0.33328670263290405,
0.2016514390707016,
-0.22204042971134186,
0.10196179896593094,
-0.42732322216033936,
-0.5387721657752991,
-0.7467818260192871,
-0.21368727087974548,
-0.11316631734371185,
-0.04636657238006592,
0.6582255363464355,
-0.05073775351047516,
0.05384482443332672,
0.0023901695385575294,
-0.20805174112319946,
0.556396484375,
0.5338287949562073,
0.20455774664878845,
0.6502765417098999,
-0.08355564624071121,
-0.04085830971598625,
0.17934514582157135,
-0.7100487947463989,
-0.23645588755607605,
0.9818172454833984,
-0.21714337170124054,
0.513543426990509,
0.5340746641159058,
0.7482059001922607,
0.3914835751056671,
0.17254307866096497,
-0.6086448431015015,
0.4270118772983551,
0.10037858784198761,
-0.6050059199333191,
-0.4812605679035187,
-0.7278417944908142,
-0.8104825615882874,
0.7344971895217896,
-0.3275367319583893,
-0.15081003308296204,
0.004186177160590887,
0.3635161221027374,
-0.5670260787010193,
0.03591657429933548,
-0.9805483222007751,
1.121121883392334,
-0.09680290520191193,
-0.3607458174228668,
0.016091950237751007,
-0.7955765128135681,
0.8176077604293823,
-0.040547702461481094,
0.2570670545101166,
-0.24464081227779388,
-0.15380443632602692,
0.5794746279716492,
-0.719541609287262,
0.39635735750198364,
-0.1774112731218338,
0.06295838952064514,
0.26008838415145874,
0.29576897621154785,
0.38626500964164734,
0.5483551025390625,
0.15105025470256805,
-0.6186661124229431,
0.42943984270095825,
-0.46467724442481995,
-0.7349768280982971,
0.35481181740760803,
-0.15456919372081757,
-0.6105862855911255,
-0.13980062305927277,
-0.6358336806297302,
-0.6604099273681641,
0.422051340341568,
-0.020989002659916878,
0.8902989625930786,
-0.20678456127643585,
0.03617124259471893,
0.2712758481502533,
-0.01182958111166954,
0.4099951386451721,
0.47644180059432983,
-0.4818599820137024,
-0.4783386290073395,
0.9756092429161072,
0.36700111627578735,
0.07648324966430664,
0.7523981332778931,
0.09117193520069122,
-0.34866851568222046,
-0.5899001955986023,
-0.7618345022201538,
0.1523250788450241,
-0.4521462619304657,
-0.6602551937103271,
-0.86107337474823,
0.2693882882595062,
-0.5093047022819519,
0.02953939326107502,
0.19797556102275848,
-0.8806410431861877,
-0.14583171904087067,
-0.2464836686849594,
0.16399767994880676,
0.6826675534248352,
0.5147570967674255,
0.5987863540649414,
-1.318943977355957,
0.6182695627212524,
0.45459461212158203,
0.3503759503364563,
0.4342661499977112,
-0.2820832431316376,
-0.23637549579143524,
-0.23467731475830078,
-0.2582409083843231,
-1.2567896842956543,
0.4484241306781769,
0.3270508348941803,
0.4880574941635132,
0.2953571677207947,
0.46339213848114014,
0.4463420808315277,
-0.11236664652824402,
0.6374852657318115,
0.05271875858306885,
-0.7403213381767273,
0.606819748878479,
-0.6548320651054382,
0.6586787104606628,
0.7631412148475647,
0.2592073976993561,
-0.23163200914859772,
-0.5203285217285156,
-0.16888630390167236,
-1.143857717514038,
0.8915665149688721,
0.08103901892900467,
-0.10154426842927933,
0.22658079862594604,
0.4158889353275299,
0.18051499128341675,
0.449370801448822,
-0.4784899353981018,
-0.026321694254875183,
-0.11792724579572678,
-0.13393786549568176,
0.2724986672401428,
-0.47082364559173584,
-0.0678163468837738,
-0.0863068699836731,
0.5302334427833557,
-0.1822548508644104,
-0.15533500909805298,
0.19250096380710602,
-0.3636544942855835,
0.28067299723625183,
0.49715885519981384,
0.8467151522636414,
0.8959313035011292,
-0.4195179343223572,
0.18128831684589386,
-0.09701094031333923,
-0.49801474809646606,
-0.038866374641656876,
0.19210989773273468,
-0.26739242672920227,
0.22532348334789276,
0.09474212676286697,
0.3604239225387573,
0.18158894777297974,
-0.7023385167121887,
0.5386756062507629,
-0.5952075719833374,
-0.17542752623558044,
0.024718789383769035,
-0.23786254227161407,
0.4402852952480316,
0.18839424848556519,
0.6249659657478333,
-0.18464894592761993,
0.5645957589149475,
-0.4905852675437927,
0.5055595636367798,
0.301130086183548,
-0.17543134093284607,
-0.23789973556995392,
0.8167496919631958,
0.2391892820596695,
0.128578320145607,
0.46865975856781006,
-0.20313529670238495,
-0.27818235754966736,
0.6564154624938965,
0.24302096664905548,
0.4573378562927246,
-0.0003087732184212655,
0.14740349352359772,
0.4117183983325958,
0.3038557171821594,
0.10477133095264435,
0.5935008525848389,
-0.5757332444190979,
-0.23983831703662872,
-0.4894552230834961,
-0.43862438201904297,
-0.48486992716789246,
-0.4293317198753357,
-0.8577857613563538,
0.03906534984707832,
-0.2873617112636566,
-0.4094060957431793,
0.07455010712146759,
-0.42228326201438904,
-0.11893998086452484,
-0.10344836860895157,
-0.5133065581321716,
0.5740107297897339,
-0.5340270400047302,
0.4688876271247864,
0.39477619528770447,
-0.7899192571640015,
-0.9723374247550964,
-0.04311002790927887,
-0.282134473323822,
-0.4374614655971527,
-0.015848467126488686,
-0.11429961770772934,
0.10774336755275726,
0.034201763570308685,
-0.25255873799324036,
-0.5971291065216064,
1.0193287134170532,
0.3633855879306793,
-0.4868983030319214,
-0.23770742118358612,
0.432535320520401,
0.26831164956092834,
0.044341079890728,
0.24145743250846863,
0.9435381889343262,
0.5057318806648254,
-0.04512111842632294,
-0.6950056552886963,
0.22254902124404907,
-0.062447723001241684,
-0.5469977259635925,
0.6160110831260681,
-0.6203213930130005,
0.5744800567626953,
-0.43795323371887207,
-0.02420492097735405,
-0.5008612871170044,
0.7890889644622803,
0.11235998570919037,
0.6011707782745361,
-0.0577428936958313,
0.29283007979393005,
0.4060367941856384,
-0.36237895488739014,
0.8882313966751099,
-0.22620046138763428,
0.04469401016831398,
1.3253806829452515,
-0.10557608306407928,
0.796169102191925,
0.2907032370567322,
-0.4600040316581726,
-0.29659077525138855,
0.41437724232673645,
0.0349070243537426,
0.26770368218421936,
0.06745417416095734,
-0.013549266383051872,
0.03829092159867287,
-0.16393472254276276,
-0.3764461874961853,
0.2860225439071655,
0.4007977545261383,
-0.1155182272195816,
-0.4107268750667572,
-0.1940196305513382,
0.13446955382823944,
0.03807279095053673,
-0.2858562171459198,
1.2135368585586548,
0.07179555296897888,
-0.5689952969551086,
0.3951277434825897,
0.04538831114768982,
0.3395630121231079,
-0.6697114109992981,
0.003799219150096178,
-0.665336012840271,
-0.34309497475624084,
-0.5174480676651001,
-0.614268958568573,
0.3883989155292511,
-0.14997021853923798,
-0.22273001074790955,
-0.09951388835906982,
0.39832958579063416,
-0.6649677753448486,
-0.06747688353061676,
-0.383969783782959,
0.8841509222984314,
0.008301935158669949,
-0.6029722690582275,
-0.07035006582736969,
-0.17972958087921143,
0.20777156949043274,
-0.2145557552576065,
0.3545893728733063,
0.7058324217796326,
-0.06602267920970917,
0.3945290148258209,
0.5277752876281738,
-0.359279990196228,
0.23715858161449432,
0.35823920369148254,
0.9309597015380859,
-0.8412778973579407,
-0.7894171476364136,
-0.8124432563781738,
0.6004806160926819,
0.14260831475257874,
-0.29173246026039124,
0.6620047688484192,
1.0802416801452637,
0.33343270421028137,
-0.3264499604701996,
0.5739847421646118,
0.27527323365211487,
0.3893129527568817,
-0.4804189205169678,
0.9207460880279541,
-0.7652140855789185,
0.08487416058778763,
-0.1577189415693283,
-0.858795166015625,
-0.5670915842056274,
-0.15406203269958496,
0.23092474043369293,
-0.04769259691238403,
0.47752562165260315,
0.6362021565437317,
0.21667343378067017,
0.07410935312509537,
0.15205323696136475,
0.15601728856563568,
0.4521593451499939,
0.18065765500068665,
0.8898809552192688,
-0.22750546038150787,
1.0667614936828613,
-0.30076757073402405,
0.06998466700315475,
-0.4498026967048645,
-0.4423925578594208,
-0.7087418437004089,
-0.5948896408081055,
-0.0584552139043808,
-0.036959707736968994,
-0.048715971410274506,
0.5930604934692383,
0.5668485760688782,
-0.8167463541030884,
-0.3084881603717804,
0.2799586355686188,
0.26972123980522156,
-0.02941899001598358,
-0.31938642263412476,
0.7782687544822693,
-0.21545512974262238,
-0.18200136721134186,
0.02657506987452507,
0.3365437090396881,
0.1523030698299408,
-0.0653483122587204,
0.4455893039703369,
-0.08501918613910675,
-0.08162114024162292,
0.9731939435005188,
-0.00798093993216753,
-0.493100106716156,
0.3615456819534302,
0.2416805624961853,
-0.15784211456775665,
0.1994570940732956,
0.9724823236465454,
-0.5505421161651611,
0.025901544839143753,
0.6953844428062439,
0.6478566527366638,
0.8689213991165161,
0.3897269368171692,
0.5340515971183777,
-0.9695196151733398,
-0.32660529017448425,
0.5941834449768066,
0.14862649142742157,
0.03378218784928322,
-0.4162246286869049,
0.30967456102371216,
-0.09410601109266281,
-0.3318188190460205,
-1.0301589965820312,
0.10644461959600449,
-1.3133310079574585,
-0.21512942016124725,
0.6002751588821411,
0.10483093559741974,
0.059276431798934937,
-0.1204737201333046,
-0.3673013746738434,
0.23419539630413055,
-0.6997175812721252,
0.6195369958877563,
0.33766087889671326,
-0.5167273283004761,
-0.18802505731582642,
-0.536369800567627,
0.5662861466407776,
0.317680299282074,
-1.2356325387954712,
0.302787721157074,
0.7568596601486206,
-0.12489508092403412,
-0.26440808176994324,
0.5385457277297974,
-0.3040584921836853,
0.2556372582912445,
-0.049288660287857056,
-0.09347616881132126,
-0.32967329025268555,
-0.22257064282894135,
0.11304671317338943,
0.9717347621917725,
0.12226973474025726,
-0.03543219342827797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05060v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05060v1
|
Conversational Topic Recommendation in Counseling and Psychotherapy with Decision Transformer and Large Language Models
| 2024-05-08T13:55:25 | 2024-05-08T13:55:25 |
Aylin Gunal, Baihan Lin, Djallel Bouneffouf
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Given the increasing demand for mental health assistance, artificial
intelligence (AI), particularly large language models (LLMs), may be valuable
for integration into automated clinical support systems. In this work, we
leverage a decision transformer architecture for topic recommendation in
counseling conversations between patients and mental health professionals. The
architecture is utilized for offline reinforcement learning, and we extract
states (dialogue turn embeddings), actions (conversation topics), and rewards
(scores measuring the alignment between patient and therapist) from previous
turns within a conversation to train a decision transformer model. We
demonstrate an improvement over baseline reinforcement learning methods, and
propose a novel system of utilizing our model's output as synthetic labels for
fine-tuning a large language model for the same task. Although our
implementation based on LLaMA-2 7B has mixed results, future work can
undoubtedly build on the design.
|
[
-0.4706166982650757,
-0.792238175868988,
0.8793044090270996,
0.21009616553783417,
-0.18942603468894958,
0.08471813052892685,
-0.26238518953323364,
-0.1934853047132492,
0.40681830048561096,
0.737848699092865,
-0.6137486100196838,
-0.34517061710357666,
-0.7549087405204773,
-0.20656460523605347,
0.055833905935287476,
1.2408244609832764,
-0.07743597775697708,
0.4382520020008087,
-0.17480404675006866,
0.1238907128572464,
-1.0933984518051147,
-0.2727201282978058,
-1.0832971334457397,
-0.8271241188049316,
0.5109902024269104,
0.47060278058052063,
0.5583767890930176,
0.25762611627578735,
0.3713217079639435,
0.47584301233291626,
-0.11368372291326523,
0.26601842045783997,
-0.6937731504440308,
0.111244335770607,
-0.4505387246608734,
-0.5392272472381592,
-0.5821873545646667,
-0.2600645124912262,
0.14463132619857788,
0.4664628803730011,
-0.45357459783554077,
-0.12428033351898193,
-0.26480844616889954,
0.35392332077026367,
-0.2676273584365845,
0.36673688888549805,
-0.6859516501426697,
0.18208196759223938,
0.14153753221035004,
-0.23897011578083038,
-0.4866260886192322,
-0.2977118492126465,
0.44426998496055603,
-0.44736531376838684,
0.01438477449119091,
0.19629688560962677,
0.3689410984516144,
0.5195738673210144,
-0.49209827184677124,
-0.21673598885536194,
-1.0459036827087402,
0.6972690224647522,
-0.45332860946655273,
0.27435576915740967,
0.8594111204147339,
0.4248462915420532,
-0.4034945070743561,
-0.5703402757644653,
-0.3410120904445648,
-0.27297544479370117,
-0.1845080703496933,
-0.034767426550388336,
-0.5670785903930664,
0.2152186632156372,
0.17872583866119385,
0.3061624765396118,
-0.2950094938278198,
0.15299944579601288,
-0.2903067469596863,
-0.045262228697538376,
0.6374234557151794,
0.42867016792297363,
0.11145350337028503,
0.14598603546619415,
0.18461063504219055,
0.052160121500492096,
-0.34334230422973633,
-0.1680316925048828,
-0.11049525439739227,
0.08704983443021774,
0.11385618895292282,
0.49938511848449707,
0.013992472551763058,
0.5318281054496765,
0.5549371838569641,
-0.4607373774051666,
-0.13138023018836975,
0.0755171999335289,
-0.05792958289384842,
0.4520910978317261,
0.5901615619659424,
0.536189615726471,
-0.17560219764709473,
-0.37748831510543823,
0.14042198657989502,
0.1651138812303543,
0.7200645804405212,
-0.7379575967788696,
-0.3493213355541229,
0.07068595290184021,
-0.453139990568161,
-0.05078207328915596,
-0.25242456793785095,
-0.664459764957428,
-0.5527743697166443,
-0.503837525844574,
0.11809955537319183,
-0.4291611611843109,
-0.078011155128479,
0.1335304081439972,
-0.04783819615840912,
0.04413442686200142,
0.39832937717437744,
-0.9434526562690735,
0.3264159858226776,
0.5616229176521301,
0.7467859983444214,
-0.33291229605674744,
-0.006698526907712221,
-0.4417559504508972,
0.202665776014328,
-0.29790806770324707,
1.0725150108337402,
-0.7079622745513916,
-0.6174529194831848,
-0.06433799117803574,
0.2752324044704437,
0.0816388875246048,
-0.501397430896759,
0.5426771640777588,
-0.3195715546607971,
0.35221052169799805,
-0.10493796318769455,
-0.6098520755767822,
0.031154925003647804,
0.3264794945716858,
-0.27752402424812317,
0.6729207038879395,
0.320534884929657,
-0.47054991126060486,
0.20521973073482513,
-0.7830324769020081,
-0.25318220257759094,
0.2226785570383072,
-0.186727836728096,
-0.4362592101097107,
-0.08271094411611557,
0.054648108780384064,
0.2230280339717865,
-0.40758728981018066,
0.7762869000434875,
-0.38418811559677124,
-0.5263181924819946,
0.24028277397155762,
-0.25497573614120483,
0.08123772591352463,
0.13776205480098724,
-0.27759867906570435,
0.6098689436912537,
-0.594304084777832,
-0.22858011722564697,
0.1863926500082016,
-0.22305145859718323,
-0.2538723051548004,
0.01970542222261429,
-0.059304606169462204,
0.17499908804893494,
0.0030667793471366167,
-0.46674567461013794,
0.26344606280326843,
-0.4396970272064209,
0.5829324722290039,
0.5320445895195007,
0.3027249872684479,
0.3523677587509155,
-0.6297187209129333,
0.507001519203186,
0.09170033037662506,
-0.1716897338628769,
0.03962936997413635,
-0.6528979539871216,
-0.8562361001968384,
-0.29561707377433777,
-0.08507101237773895,
0.5111181735992432,
-0.8439007997512817,
0.813862681388855,
0.008484705351293087,
-0.690721869468689,
-0.4329046607017517,
-0.13310836255550385,
0.23537373542785645,
0.26128944754600525,
0.6194309592247009,
-0.034216057509183884,
-0.5515373945236206,
-0.7798608541488647,
0.033483363687992096,
-0.1439017653465271,
0.02581573836505413,
0.5529135465621948,
0.22548282146453857,
-0.6371976733207703,
1.0302613973617554,
-0.9291867017745972,
-0.44758108258247375,
-0.5254267454147339,
0.2142656147480011,
0.17517158389091492,
0.2989611029624939,
0.31781312823295593,
-0.42738109827041626,
-0.4224786162376404,
-0.0988364964723587,
-0.28908976912498474,
0.07659975439310074,
-0.14414818584918976,
-0.3054980933666229,
-0.16557393968105316,
0.3156767189502716,
-0.41585999727249146,
0.3994459807872772,
0.3158312737941742,
-0.5527174472808838,
0.17999368906021118,
-0.6605539917945862,
-0.12822388112545013,
-1.2236560583114624,
-0.33842459321022034,
0.12396129220724106,
-0.33578211069107056,
-0.7045157551765442,
-0.6876739859580994,
-0.5030228495597839,
-0.20079047977924347,
-0.2533842921257019,
0.5510272979736328,
0.271793931722641,
0.1626920849084854,
-0.6321344375610352,
-0.04717203974723816,
-0.3614780604839325,
0.8400916457176208,
0.35319238901138306,
0.6787340641021729,
0.32534852623939514,
-0.40831631422042847,
0.6202241778373718,
0.8572287559509277,
-0.09063007682561874,
0.865619957447052,
-0.6309841871261597,
0.3226674497127533,
-0.12122710794210434,
0.8302263617515564,
-0.7515650391578674,
0.0013216992374509573,
0.3407443165779114,
0.18331344425678253,
0.02622441202402115,
0.026058048009872437,
0.09399744868278503,
-0.26798009872436523,
-0.10795430094003677,
0.16475345194339752,
0.3380424976348877,
-0.3068150281906128,
0.37807515263557434,
0.6053717732429504,
-0.41420334577560425,
0.012626942247152328,
-0.18530578911304474,
0.15551312267780304,
-0.3252820074558258,
-0.07188505679368973,
0.8522251844406128,
-0.2534004747867584,
-0.1164296492934227,
-0.05027247592806816,
0.2902846038341522,
0.11107084900140762,
-0.09459111839532852,
0.6751838326454163,
0.2879461646080017,
-0.09523846954107285,
0.5240798592567444,
0.22213925421237946,
-0.42744284868240356,
0.06483584642410278,
-0.30886322259902954,
0.7958881855010986,
-0.3342956602573395,
-0.415799081325531,
-0.26554492115974426,
0.5114373564720154,
0.4337603449821472,
0.002710642758756876,
0.8553982377052307,
0.63318932056427,
-0.2799355983734131,
-0.12862442433834076,
-0.4526071846485138,
-0.39994147419929504,
-0.4655110538005829,
0.5911129713058472,
-0.07475966960191727,
-0.9691113829612732,
0.05395421385765076,
-0.40934476256370544,
-0.10973706841468811,
0.2318059355020523,
0.9719302654266357,
0.03212423995137215,
1.2461320161819458,
0.586816668510437,
-0.1629631519317627,
0.7777101397514343,
-0.3393222689628601,
0.5708884596824646,
-0.6477914452552795,
-0.1879095584154129,
-0.1684483140707016,
-0.3608565032482147,
-0.7929849624633789,
-0.3205564320087433,
0.38825833797454834,
-0.06258227676153183,
-0.531453013420105,
0.17927247285842896,
-0.49769681692123413,
0.10172384977340698,
0.4933946132659912,
0.4478036165237427,
0.2069585621356964,
-0.18320001661777496,
-0.005361122544854879,
-0.23886165022850037,
-0.5866185426712036,
-0.4952653646469116,
0.7294660806655884,
0.4141916036605835,
0.46246761083602905,
0.0795595571398735,
0.29279080033302307,
0.2864522635936737,
0.4994773864746094,
-1.063503623008728,
0.4311685264110565,
-0.0681355819106102,
-0.27505651116371155,
-0.27107423543930054,
-0.1342737078666687,
-1.1235930919647217,
0.15069261193275452,
-0.43765127658843994,
-0.9795825481414795,
0.09052915126085281,
-0.050614360719919205,
-0.38781827688217163,
0.22391381859779358,
-0.14194168150424957,
0.7856202125549316,
-0.3198242485523224,
-0.07313699275255203,
-0.6435065269470215,
-0.3057953417301178,
0.12497913837432861,
-0.2500509023666382,
-0.1349051594734192,
-0.15644440054893494,
0.36807000637054443,
0.8242318034172058,
-0.3878788948059082,
0.7541654706001282,
-0.04053225368261337,
-0.24000391364097595,
-0.033066973090171814,
-0.09588327258825302,
0.44213342666625977,
0.337296724319458,
-0.07326506078243256,
-0.09875097125768661,
0.19454173743724823,
0.0031227348372340202,
-0.8158209919929504,
0.4488597512245178,
-0.9879692196846008,
-0.8821658492088318,
-0.27859073877334595,
-0.5658483505249023,
-0.7347266674041748,
0.12203096598386765,
0.11536974459886551,
0.4016479253768921,
-0.27913230657577515,
0.09237506240606308,
0.4525778889656067,
-0.3587307333946228,
0.09207211434841156,
0.7261859178543091,
-0.32894375920295715,
-0.5668089985847473,
1.124366283416748,
-0.21205061674118042,
-0.24034307897090912,
0.20747508108615875,
0.3519851565361023,
-0.22527077794075012,
-0.40377339720726013,
-0.19712544977664948,
0.38889259099960327,
-0.7332032918930054,
-0.1775166243314743,
-0.6014923453330994,
-0.2608187794685364,
-0.13831286132335663,
-0.22967758774757385,
-0.3500540554523468,
0.06502065062522888,
-0.28683531284332275,
-0.21013766527175903,
0.6006850600242615,
0.8041078448295593,
0.4490323066711426,
0.5395112633705139,
-0.7793614864349365,
0.21651053428649902,
0.2341403365135193,
0.4851786196231842,
0.027910899370908737,
-0.4899624288082123,
-0.2331140637397766,
0.10109579563140869,
-0.8258873820304871,
-0.7559171319007874,
0.4198185205459595,
0.12359852343797684,
0.6214624643325806,
0.7200642824172974,
0.269913911819458,
0.5739598870277405,
-0.6029929518699646,
0.5421522259712219,
0.1527729034423828,
-0.6449277997016907,
0.7020016312599182,
-0.2771495580673218,
0.22654210031032562,
0.44895657896995544,
0.5073683261871338,
-0.8299242854118347,
-0.41853436827659607,
-0.5294977426528931,
-0.41364824771881104,
1.034127950668335,
-0.07916884124279022,
0.18453508615493774,
-0.1261078417301178,
0.21696610748767853,
0.014137097634375095,
0.20812468230724335,
-0.31268349289894104,
-0.35591599345207214,
-0.09825767576694489,
-0.2070094645023346,
-0.2283107340335846,
-0.1486539989709854,
-0.5026318430900574,
-0.3305343687534332,
0.7483559250831604,
-0.3885931968688965,
0.7362695932388306,
-0.02646758034825325,
0.1772034466266632,
-0.3891007900238037,
0.35926511883735657,
0.5777226090431213,
0.46614784002304077,
-0.10594745725393295,
-0.09431000798940659,
0.583008885383606,
-0.19894474744796753,
0.3411780297756195,
0.04256456345319748,
0.2369866520166397,
-0.22632348537445068,
0.22026652097702026,
1.4353795051574707,
0.36713680624961853,
-0.6711125373840332,
0.14812743663787842,
-0.34929388761520386,
-0.26819804310798645,
-0.21705155074596405,
0.2767735421657562,
0.2018391191959381,
0.4951622188091278,
-0.16689510643482208,
-0.1020379364490509,
0.06372484564781189,
-0.5835251808166504,
0.12161683291196823,
0.2949809432029724,
-0.8829389214515686,
-0.1637839525938034,
0.08348845690488815,
0.14256420731544495,
-0.8210203051567078,
0.6732940673828125,
0.0041037932969629765,
-0.6580359935760498,
0.1701805144548416,
0.9023772478103638,
0.6320611834526062,
-0.016114849597215652,
0.5699709057807922,
-0.03481646627187729,
-0.5320293307304382,
-0.22608166933059692,
0.05359107628464699,
-0.20593878626823425,
-0.7837679982185364,
-0.0945010855793953,
-0.5153137445449829,
-0.7149053812026978,
0.14048022031784058,
-0.5364328622817993,
0.3403625190258026,
-0.36152586340904236,
-0.3863781988620758,
-0.052174024283885956,
0.030146216973662376,
-0.39073947072029114,
0.033884815871715546,
0.37763023376464844,
0.386669784784317,
-0.5679749250411987,
0.9232249855995178,
0.9439878463745117,
-0.18244610726833344,
-0.8161745071411133,
-0.042080193758010864,
-0.0910722091794014,
-0.43326929211616516,
0.4500999450683594,
-0.13634082674980164,
-0.15792913734912872,
-0.12194448709487915,
-0.03607118874788284,
-0.857999861240387,
1.1226470470428467,
0.6222777962684631,
-0.3803479075431824,
-0.13698169589042664,
0.3465806543827057,
0.896024763584137,
-0.40685781836509705,
0.7485607862472534,
0.6481560468673706,
0.4192850887775421,
0.4534597098827362,
-0.8954254388809204,
0.015729354694485664,
-0.1954006403684616,
0.17529603838920593,
0.21586927771568298,
-0.6744495034217834,
0.26319876313209534,
0.029873158782720566,
0.17807571589946747,
-0.033238861709833145,
0.515280544757843,
0.3622110188007355,
0.14274147152900696,
0.5169612169265747,
0.3169935345649719,
0.8064833879470825,
0.00366602442227304,
0.7303128242492676,
-0.4648674428462982,
0.3050110340118408,
1.1056848764419556,
-0.4364933967590332,
0.8028683662414551,
0.2612636089324951,
-0.36736395955085754,
0.620167076587677,
0.8270143866539001,
-0.2423134297132492,
0.55690997838974,
0.2397996187210083,
0.06893778592348099,
-0.18127721548080444,
-0.6503620147705078,
-0.3212028741836548,
0.609755277633667,
0.4613839387893677,
-0.30291497707366943,
-0.14989258348941803,
0.28753164410591125,
0.01894652657210827,
-0.16883106529712677,
-0.14581972360610962,
1.2772643566131592,
0.23784232139587402,
-0.945747435092926,
0.4223270118236542,
0.25918132066726685,
0.3953423500061035,
-0.587587833404541,
-0.2958521246910095,
-0.2606843113899231,
0.5220561027526855,
-0.11546377092599869,
-0.48408961296081543,
0.4415286183357239,
-0.10863933712244034,
-0.20560704171657562,
-0.35933953523635864,
0.6190859079360962,
-0.5743894577026367,
-0.5822457075119019,
0.3308911621570587,
0.35248804092407227,
-0.09618451446294785,
0.12667255103588104,
-0.6605163216590881,
-0.32415175437927246,
-0.21364478766918182,
-0.062009360641241074,
0.5850186347961426,
0.06501031666994095,
-0.2753011882305145,
0.6981322765350342,
0.4407167136669159,
0.175450399518013,
-0.5556915998458862,
-0.003869346110150218,
1.0002132654190063,
-0.5473960041999817,
-0.7828120589256287,
-0.58509361743927,
-0.013112262822687626,
0.0875919759273529,
-0.33656537532806396,
0.45906397700309753,
0.09740515798330307,
0.38997912406921387,
0.20359626412391663,
0.44127506017684937,
0.25804370641708374,
0.2715383768081665,
-0.31856614351272583,
0.5045475959777832,
-0.2644297778606415,
0.32424649596214294,
-0.11270986497402191,
-1.0069184303283691,
0.003395393257960677,
0.5093907117843628,
-0.8264554142951965,
-0.06834261119365692,
0.7253850102424622,
0.6055496335029602,
0.1785200983285904,
0.4699110984802246,
0.37697792053222656,
0.057967409491539,
0.713805079460144,
0.584987223148346,
0.841943085193634,
0.030215110629796982,
0.25176554918289185,
-0.1379694789648056,
-0.11973917484283447,
-0.21110033988952637,
-0.6071562767028809,
-0.8931543231010437,
-0.547532320022583,
-0.305446982383728,
-0.17047731578350067,
0.11348799616098404,
1.5790554285049438,
0.7500706315040588,
-0.930381715297699,
-0.18735085427761078,
-0.08056388050317764,
0.019496021792292595,
-0.1329396814107895,
-0.10800543427467346,
0.30928486585617065,
-0.1749035120010376,
-0.49025484919548035,
0.5477075576782227,
0.329891175031662,
-0.18879415094852448,
-0.4499049186706543,
-0.25002896785736084,
-0.06670777499675751,
0.08015686273574829,
0.4089907705783844,
-0.12782466411590576,
-0.8695544600486755,
-0.011650096625089645,
-0.2846096456050873,
-0.050011247396469116,
0.3198244571685791,
1.1876192092895508,
-0.8696882128715515,
0.24634069204330444,
0.11591660976409912,
0.8125999569892883,
0.6039332747459412,
-0.008747385814785957,
0.9263161420822144,
-0.09590385109186172,
0.07346121221780777,
0.19714151322841644,
0.38737359642982483,
0.10058209300041199,
-0.5684688687324524,
0.14233607053756714,
-0.04112904518842697,
-0.5058632493019104,
-0.5713159441947937,
0.0904458686709404,
-0.5945608019828796,
-0.3685482442378998,
0.9911226034164429,
-0.40340957045555115,
0.16493786871433258,
-0.4005807638168335,
-0.8856946229934692,
0.39893481135368347,
-0.5858306288719177,
0.8898659348487854,
0.5783695578575134,
-0.48621875047683716,
-0.2031358927488327,
-0.12106605619192123,
0.6100617051124573,
0.47582724690437317,
-1.0024175643920898,
-0.20146045088768005,
0.19488279521465302,
-0.03359968960285187,
0.20439332723617554,
0.4874567687511444,
0.35169970989227295,
-0.03044627606868744,
-0.36193329095840454,
-0.2563198506832123,
0.057094473391771317,
-0.19166305661201477,
-0.3869219720363617,
-0.11625738441944122,
0.044397786259651184,
0.2965024709701538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05049v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05049v1
|
Seeds of Stereotypes: A Large-Scale Textual Analysis of Race and Gender Associations with Diseases in Online Sources
| 2024-05-08T13:38:56 | 2024-05-08T13:38:56 |
Lasse Hyldig Hansen, Nikolaj Andersen, Jack Gallifant, Liam G. McCoy, James K Stone, Nura Izath, Marcela Aguirre-Jerez, Danielle S Bitterman, Judy Gichoya, Leo Anthony Celi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Background Advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) hold transformative
potential in healthcare, however, recent work has raised concern about the
tendency of these models to produce outputs that display racial or gender
biases. Although training data is a likely source of such biases, exploration
of disease and demographic associations in text data at scale has been limited.
Methods We conducted a large-scale textual analysis using a dataset
comprising diverse web sources, including Arxiv, Wikipedia, and Common Crawl.
The study analyzed the context in which various diseases are discussed
alongside markers of race and gender. Given that LLMs are pre-trained on
similar datasets, this approach allowed us to examine the potential biases that
LLMs may learn and internalize. We compared these findings with actual
demographic disease prevalence as well as GPT-4 outputs in order to evaluate
the extent of bias representation.
Results Our findings indicate that demographic terms are disproportionately
associated with specific disease concepts in online texts. gender terms are
prominently associated with disease concepts, while racial terms are much less
frequently associated. We find widespread disparities in the associations of
specific racial and gender terms with the 18 diseases analyzed. Most
prominently, we see an overall significant overrepresentation of Black race
mentions in comparison to population proportions.
Conclusions Our results highlight the need for critical examination and
transparent reporting of biases in LLM pretraining datasets. Our study suggests
the need to develop mitigation strategies to counteract the influence of biased
training data in LLMs, particularly in sensitive domains such as healthcare.
|
[
-0.11690080165863037,
-0.5040921568870544,
0.5510130524635315,
0.10151588171720505,
0.07687997072935104,
-0.056060291826725006,
0.05146322771906853,
-0.6093848943710327,
0.6610974073410034,
0.37778905034065247,
-0.3213459849357605,
-0.7109741568565369,
-0.9749510884284973,
0.3618904650211334,
-0.37025293707847595,
1.098761796951294,
-0.040442392230033875,
0.48817434906959534,
-0.3072463274002075,
-0.02877434529364109,
-0.20897109806537628,
-0.834144115447998,
-0.5721805095672607,
-0.08927521109580994,
0.39899569749832153,
-0.00546356663107872,
0.3038940727710724,
0.5758904814720154,
0.5667478442192078,
0.13975746929645538,
-0.2592807114124298,
-0.11581207811832428,
-0.7672163844108582,
0.23518410325050354,
-0.15388622879981995,
-0.3423134684562683,
-0.4139515459537506,
0.39542847871780396,
0.24714331328868866,
1.0011245012283325,
0.2051730901002884,
0.4116639494895935,
0.01408361829817295,
0.6932699680328369,
-0.39096182584762573,
0.16051830351352692,
-0.2934449017047882,
0.529512882232666,
-0.48303526639938354,
-0.3552582263946533,
-0.119544118642807,
-0.6543408632278442,
0.20403076708316803,
-0.7787509560585022,
0.4273480474948883,
0.018931398168206215,
0.6212548017501831,
0.16373887658119202,
-0.838378369808197,
-0.5585567355155945,
-0.6587541699409485,
0.4913344085216522,
-0.5545889139175415,
0.10431469231843948,
0.43957653641700745,
0.14192448556423187,
-0.1933698058128357,
-0.587295651435852,
-0.3668396770954132,
-0.17466402053833008,
-0.27221810817718506,
0.13669170439243317,
-0.32121264934539795,
0.015350623987615108,
0.635202944278717,
0.28110378980636597,
-0.7422755360603333,
0.14072470366954803,
-0.7177891731262207,
-0.26468631625175476,
0.5568615794181824,
0.26583293080329895,
0.7124472260475159,
-0.17371714115142822,
-0.013368362560868263,
0.12440270930528641,
-0.8174039721488953,
-0.2158491462469101,
0.47878018021583557,
0.21264387667179108,
-0.36951279640197754,
0.8096712231636047,
0.0991501733660698,
0.4828825891017914,
-0.07533015310764313,
-0.29047688841819763,
0.5821238160133362,
-0.25445401668548584,
0.09779073297977448,
0.3709002435207367,
0.8493959307670593,
0.7044660449028015,
0.4196028709411621,
-0.29090142250061035,
0.24118053913116455,
0.0426178015768528,
0.09047640860080719,
-0.9519564509391785,
-0.15560512244701385,
0.10842265188694,
-0.7317603826522827,
-0.1094256117939949,
-0.07840772718191147,
-1.195334553718567,
-0.7862259149551392,
-0.03415695205330849,
-0.14376117289066315,
-0.2497604638338089,
-0.3072606325149536,
-0.20580197870731354,
-0.47395288944244385,
-0.1676224023103714,
0.04738565906882286,
-0.8682398796081543,
0.14581923186779022,
0.5107806324958801,
0.8504396080970764,
-0.21435590088367462,
0.28177085518836975,
-0.09581967443227768,
0.2318195104598999,
-0.2713427245616913,
0.3725191056728363,
-0.6192407011985779,
-0.5961286425590515,
0.34870046377182007,
-0.12896230816841125,
-0.08103214204311371,
-0.5893391370773315,
0.3094464838504791,
-0.11303966492414474,
0.16454122960567474,
-0.4344974756240845,
-0.48273032903671265,
0.2734070420265198,
0.08457949757575989,
-0.6871606111526489,
0.8747279644012451,
0.14191029965877533,
-1.1807111501693726,
0.6366250514984131,
-0.2969323694705963,
-0.3745739758014679,
-0.22964805364608765,
-0.5784282684326172,
-0.4464101791381836,
0.08930955827236176,
0.2739257216453552,
0.3541829586029053,
-0.2403617650270462,
0.2233802080154419,
-0.5190374851226807,
-0.1702982783317566,
0.04719777777791023,
-0.07544675469398499,
0.8114588260650635,
0.046547338366508484,
-0.46359536051750183,
0.03466176986694336,
-0.5644924640655518,
-0.6134212613105774,
0.28815338015556335,
0.15158015489578247,
-0.8919401168823242,
0.20893168449401855,
-0.2564748227596283,
0.1856086105108261,
-0.10303696244955063,
-0.500712513923645,
0.46996137499809265,
-0.43547162413597107,
0.21255138516426086,
0.6262513399124146,
0.08193282783031464,
0.3008664846420288,
-0.2896793484687805,
0.6154471635818481,
0.21392866969108582,
0.35255610942840576,
-0.10844825208187103,
-0.773518979549408,
-0.3818937838077545,
-0.19692781567573547,
0.003770591923967004,
0.13024646043777466,
-0.5911170244216919,
0.2771976590156555,
-0.4472866356372833,
-0.26917964220046997,
-0.5740161538124084,
-0.09359384328126907,
0.3198517858982086,
0.3764115869998932,
0.3132140636444092,
-0.24696265161037445,
-0.47708937525749207,
-0.9562191963195801,
-0.18467877805233002,
-0.06014088913798332,
-0.21304422616958618,
0.3969096541404724,
0.6965333223342896,
-0.16733203828334808,
0.8717786073684692,
-0.6539767980575562,
-0.5940479636192322,
0.0457400418817997,
0.32657554745674133,
-0.08153566718101501,
0.3592281639575958,
0.8887737393379211,
-0.5170612335205078,
-0.3723016083240509,
-0.02559913508594036,
-0.7836557626724243,
-0.23011519014835358,
0.2956208884716034,
0.021648390218615532,
-0.21022987365722656,
0.6008726358413696,
-0.28211063146591187,
0.308578759431839,
0.8918125033378601,
-0.4534057676792145,
0.5025903582572937,
0.09924596548080444,
0.02835949696600437,
-1.0533350706100464,
-0.12877331674098969,
0.5487041473388672,
0.09436043351888657,
-0.42222681641578674,
-0.05545572564005852,
-0.22874964773654938,
-0.19956184923648834,
-0.014134751632809639,
0.5128669738769531,
-0.416720986366272,
-0.056346382945775986,
0.1860002875328064,
-0.008290913887321949,
-0.037771712988615036,
-0.14377371966838837,
-0.03288417309522629,
0.7802820801734924,
0.3701513111591339,
-0.3254224359989166,
-0.020155511796474457,
0.1108904555439949,
-0.3032117486000061,
0.3618261516094208,
-0.4960349500179291,
-0.09975431114435196,
-0.35063067078590393,
0.5625409483909607,
-0.791549563407898,
-0.18077543377876282,
0.33174929022789,
-0.49453017115592957,
0.019410770386457443,
0.007536060642451048,
-0.40160253643989563,
-0.5623881816864014,
-0.3109270930290222,
0.5377189517021179,
0.26749634742736816,
-0.19746039807796478,
0.16438812017440796,
0.7041688561439514,
-0.2319568246603012,
-0.42433005571365356,
-0.4874344766139984,
-0.1881442368030548,
-0.34533223509788513,
-0.328246533870697,
0.15712091326713562,
0.28373658657073975,
-0.561109185218811,
-0.18356607854366302,
-0.16144980490207672,
-0.3337411880493164,
-0.01944085769355297,
0.27869319915771484,
0.1862574815750122,
-0.17577101290225983,
0.3748910427093506,
-0.03987102955579758,
0.32401981949806213,
0.3001927137374878,
-0.24792782962322235,
0.42231670022010803,
0.5445857048034668,
-0.3402128219604492,
-0.11903953552246094,
0.6052281260490417,
0.5594487190246582,
-0.04136866331100464,
0.8351910710334778,
0.25984495878219604,
-0.2892865240573883,
-0.08825165033340454,
-0.3504725396633148,
-0.2218339592218399,
-0.33945316076278687,
0.3686942756175995,
-0.006392046809196472,
-0.9815892577171326,
0.4007343053817749,
0.031081803143024445,
0.08094236254692078,
0.49067312479019165,
0.38908272981643677,
-0.3511134386062622,
0.7359820604324341,
0.7352548241615295,
-0.1875801533460617,
0.19330327212810516,
-0.13082166016101837,
0.09889934957027435,
-0.5681536793708801,
-0.33653393387794495,
-0.8095341324806213,
-0.17885279655456543,
-0.9917969703674316,
-0.6716798543930054,
0.5736573934555054,
-0.36981308460235596,
-0.22981280088424683,
-0.297841340303421,
-0.5810755491256714,
0.1070389375090599,
0.20498612523078918,
0.21505172550678253,
0.25941768288612366,
0.04863208159804344,
-0.21782223880290985,
-0.5978565216064453,
-0.7540446519851685,
-0.3455709218978882,
1.5237458944320679,
0.4605758786201477,
0.6425254344940186,
0.03518250957131386,
0.4792289733886719,
0.6063478589057922,
0.7687605023384094,
-0.5006731748580933,
0.04619936645030975,
-0.45175883173942566,
-0.947919487953186,
-0.1434762328863144,
-0.7160525321960449,
-1.0769368410110474,
0.024639228358864784,
-0.24427945911884308,
-0.736248254776001,
0.4193367063999176,
0.3416096270084381,
-0.01659981533885002,
0.4335804581642151,
-0.5526102781295776,
0.6274577975273132,
-0.40965554118156433,
-0.03919067606329918,
0.06594407558441162,
-0.5259807705879211,
0.8728880882263184,
-0.30002906918525696,
0.5405105948448181,
-0.30686748027801514,
0.28120434284210205,
1.070528268814087,
-0.2560585141181946,
1.0180953741073608,
0.03592353314161301,
-0.19301068782806396,
-0.3758755922317505,
-0.13260769844055176,
0.15355566143989563,
-0.1537938117980957,
-0.12960200011730194,
0.4651046693325043,
-0.13195307552814484,
-0.6282921433448792,
-0.24427685141563416,
0.5547709465026855,
-0.9576565027236938,
-0.5788865089416504,
-0.7987741827964783,
-0.34046393632888794,
-0.34787899255752563,
-0.015194940380752087,
0.19631536304950714,
0.45314157009124756,
-0.2611526846885681,
-0.19081591069698334,
0.727070152759552,
-0.7226574420928955,
-0.1575024574995041,
0.32502859830856323,
-0.3092615604400635,
-0.1770896017551422,
0.767833411693573,
0.013602307066321373,
0.4208378493785858,
0.16607560217380524,
0.32221707701683044,
-0.0031034890562295914,
-0.48796284198760986,
-0.043673641979694366,
0.42747992277145386,
-0.38947373628616333,
0.0904943197965622,
-0.7214452624320984,
-0.24168647825717926,
-0.8345561027526855,
0.032413363456726074,
-0.011400417424738407,
-0.10186195373535156,
-0.3288188576698303,
-0.09514223039150238,
0.417871356010437,
1.0315351486206055,
0.3736937642097473,
0.38801148533821106,
-0.4788993000984192,
0.4471360743045807,
0.07793434709310532,
0.17199090123176575,
0.15958483517169952,
-0.37197598814964294,
-0.1592913120985031,
-0.0051230681128799915,
-0.17313644289970398,
-1.1871132850646973,
0.3884679079055786,
-0.08121968805789948,
0.5361390113830566,
0.7568673491477966,
0.15669232606887817,
0.4502064287662506,
-0.484661340713501,
0.6936016082763672,
0.667615532875061,
-0.47167089581489563,
0.33998212218284607,
-0.498645156621933,
0.024111075326800346,
0.437970906496048,
1.129607915878296,
-0.6473481059074402,
-0.6581369638442993,
-0.39947232604026794,
-0.9633819460868835,
0.4658493101596832,
0.19637100398540497,
-0.06360000371932983,
-0.32508277893066406,
0.2419126331806183,
0.1787082552909851,
0.04625745117664337,
-0.7105721831321716,
-0.6988804340362549,
-0.21349743008613586,
-0.18112598359584808,
-0.1556575447320938,
-0.5708246827125549,
-0.3741600513458252,
-0.31072697043418884,
0.3712705969810486,
0.05160145461559296,
0.12249504774808884,
0.2959631383419037,
-0.24368533492088318,
0.049961287528276443,
0.18447904288768768,
0.38213658332824707,
0.8171365261077881,
-0.24015210568904877,
0.22669827938079834,
-0.155893012881279,
-0.7585673332214355,
0.24242903292179108,
0.14831764996051788,
-0.33653125166893005,
0.296008825302124,
0.638317346572876,
0.7355372905731201,
0.26295801997184753,
-0.4990183711051941,
0.6153485774993896,
0.1321287751197815,
-0.16647517681121826,
-0.40129074454307556,
-0.3362201154232025,
0.18722496926784515,
-0.006165496073663235,
0.345952570438385,
-0.28908318281173706,
0.1458446979522705,
-0.5853487253189087,
0.03921646624803543,
0.29346761107444763,
-0.5602203607559204,
-0.24670428037643433,
0.7051199674606323,
0.6529520153999329,
0.08693599700927734,
0.6542355418205261,
0.03793785348534584,
-0.21302556991577148,
0.7545832991600037,
0.35286885499954224,
0.3882736563682556,
-0.09827824681997299,
0.35144877433776855,
0.637278139591217,
0.564835250377655,
0.1248573437333107,
-0.3856215178966522,
0.5675259232521057,
-0.61909019947052,
-0.4637623131275177,
-0.8412436842918396,
-0.05146627873182297,
0.3427116274833679,
-0.5342377424240112,
0.10646119713783264,
-0.22786156833171844,
-0.48113304376602173,
0.2191925048828125,
-0.34184110164642334,
-0.5656660795211792,
0.25376802682876587,
0.4176211953163147,
0.920012891292572,
-1.2725188732147217,
0.5896639823913574,
0.6001715064048767,
-0.5974301099777222,
-0.4744052290916443,
0.5224926471710205,
0.4188227951526642,
-0.6673216819763184,
1.0593751668930054,
0.1832159161567688,
0.3947984576225281,
-0.2449251115322113,
-0.07516860961914062,
-0.8490580916404724,
0.7003592252731323,
0.4519580602645874,
-0.8672022223472595,
-0.38113945722579956,
0.32782498002052307,
0.4127495288848877,
-0.3057318925857544,
0.43550339341163635,
0.655706524848938,
0.47919464111328125,
-0.22726769745349884,
-1.0084902048110962,
0.014435790479183197,
-0.04934723302721977,
0.15155528485774994,
0.06510385870933533,
-0.20390063524246216,
0.7385290861129761,
-0.2143813669681549,
-0.1618129014968872,
-0.19384092092514038,
0.29820936918258667,
0.13972899317741394,
0.2677033841609955,
0.2656239867210388,
0.44348931312561035,
0.771494448184967,
-0.1383344829082489,
1.2467235326766968,
-0.062177106738090515,
0.2691895663738251,
1.00974440574646,
-0.38913965225219727,
0.167139932513237,
0.3717443645000458,
-0.4689571261405945,
0.3217431604862213,
0.7019628286361694,
0.2927898168563843,
0.11718164384365082,
0.7367417812347412,
-0.3126850426197052,
0.13359355926513672,
-0.29730409383773804,
-0.6406152844429016,
0.18758556246757507,
0.41123634576797485,
-0.8582050800323486,
-0.31991544365882874,
0.06210092827677727,
0.19555425643920898,
0.28775647282600403,
-0.2806953191757202,
0.6043645739555359,
0.10159178078174591,
0.004085733089596033,
0.08406039327383041,
-0.28738802671432495,
0.8425442576408386,
-0.826023519039154,
-0.22693270444869995,
-0.28152546286582947,
-0.12184444814920425,
-0.27678966522216797,
-0.40525925159454346,
0.17690590023994446,
0.03131140395998955,
-0.46810585260391235,
-0.07555020600557327,
0.5286563634872437,
-0.34960198402404785,
-0.8407566547393799,
0.4428703784942627,
0.6108012199401855,
0.37554463744163513,
0.04834476485848427,
-0.3064257800579071,
0.12189237028360367,
0.0849212110042572,
0.060586296021938324,
0.6472405195236206,
0.4453575909137726,
-0.4687359631061554,
0.47740697860717773,
0.6578295826911926,
0.8015931844711304,
0.17933855950832367,
0.13365919888019562,
0.696774423122406,
-0.580188512802124,
-0.1627572923898697,
-0.7983320951461792,
0.024705180898308754,
-0.476718008518219,
-0.37043333053588867,
0.8177061080932617,
0.5247847437858582,
0.6771466135978699,
-0.005392842926084995,
1.0622735023498535,
0.08748362213373184,
0.5071203112602234,
-0.3405913710594177,
0.9740430116653442,
-0.5217329263687134,
-0.05073394626379013,
-0.33111467957496643,
-0.5310660004615784,
-0.2733241319656372,
0.3815648555755615,
-0.5801734328269958,
0.00992884673178196,
0.7818664312362671,
0.4192419648170471,
0.04584353417158127,
-0.2778398096561432,
0.10941383987665176,
0.6021832823753357,
0.2844351530075073,
0.0830044075846672,
0.44913163781166077,
0.04465178772807121,
0.2598892152309418,
-0.005337271839380264,
-0.34907782077789307,
-0.20668229460716248,
-0.8122287392616272,
-0.8224711418151855,
-0.3731628954410553,
-0.31907379627227783,
-0.49224185943603516,
0.5575478672981262,
0.8149630427360535,
0.5266746282577515,
-0.8207830786705017,
-0.23080669343471527,
0.43461593985557556,
0.03930402174592018,
-0.06469231098890305,
-0.20117811858654022,
0.37736138701438904,
-0.049173690378665924,
-0.6268829107284546,
-0.2095826119184494,
-0.10641113668680191,
-0.018367812037467957,
-0.3737959861755371,
0.08962324261665344,
-0.07292459905147552,
-0.2620953619480133,
0.7144503593444824,
0.16715706884860992,
-0.5563651323318481,
0.09771448373794556,
-0.36646392941474915,
-0.3302319347858429,
-0.023154443129897118,
1.164762258529663,
-0.5197619795799255,
0.5568233728408813,
0.17709952592849731,
0.40524592995643616,
0.23979119956493378,
-0.10955245047807693,
0.8961153030395508,
-0.5714804530143738,
0.233486145734787,
0.4183901250362396,
0.40074068307876587,
0.36068981885910034,
-0.38164740800857544,
0.2305581420660019,
0.4852934777736664,
-0.11673603951931,
-0.6368445158004761,
-0.04466689005494118,
-0.7268121242523193,
-0.5145226120948792,
1.4266940355300903,
-0.20893830060958862,
-0.039216943085193634,
-0.3594501316547394,
-0.02616969868540764,
0.41983067989349365,
-0.3586195409297943,
1.0010557174682617,
0.4903354346752167,
-0.03357040882110596,
0.2085602730512619,
-1.1020973920822144,
0.752574622631073,
0.05759895592927933,
-0.8812242150306702,
0.041746046394109726,
0.6556673049926758,
0.4590199291706085,
-0.03649992495775223,
0.9127066135406494,
-0.35574662685394287,
0.031590528786182404,
-0.08469948172569275,
0.40725386142730713,
0.19223973155021667,
0.07976292073726654,
-0.012187819927930832,
-0.02488105371594429,
-0.19848619401454926,
0.15649215877056122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05008v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05008v1
|
ADELIE: Aligning Large Language Models on Information Extraction
| 2024-05-08T12:24:52 | 2024-05-08T12:24:52 |
Yunjia Qi, Hao Peng, Xiaozhi Wang, Bin Xu, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) usually fall short on information extraction
(IE) tasks and struggle to follow the complex instructions of IE tasks. This
primarily arises from LLMs not being aligned with humans, as mainstream
alignment datasets typically do not include IE data. In this paper, we
introduce ADELIE (Aligning large language moDELs on Information Extraction), an
aligned LLM that effectively solves various IE tasks, including closed IE, open
IE, and on-demand IE. We first collect and construct a high-quality alignment
corpus IEInstruct for IE. Then we train ADELIE_SFT using instruction tuning on
IEInstruct. We further train ADELIE_SFT with direct preference optimization
(DPO) objective, resulting in ADELIE_DPO. Extensive experiments on various
held-out IE datasets demonstrate that our models (ADELIE_SFT and ADELIE_DPO)
achieve state-of-the-art (SoTA) performance among open-source models. We
further explore the general capabilities of ADELIE, and experimental results
reveal that their general capabilities do not exhibit a noticeable decline. We
will release the code, data, and models to facilitate further research.
|
[
-0.2211163192987442,
-0.5466525554656982,
0.5647277235984802,
-0.04574348405003548,
0.003095924621447921,
-0.25808438658714294,
-0.5028482675552368,
-0.5446011424064636,
0.1841990351676941,
0.3881913423538208,
-0.500852644443512,
-0.6113831996917725,
-0.6477076411247253,
-0.1185966432094574,
-0.34407779574394226,
0.8593700528144836,
-0.28085634112358093,
0.11782317608594894,
-0.14807848632335663,
-0.0880236104130745,
-0.4750511050224304,
-0.1606491059064865,
-0.4315694272518158,
0.028188224881887436,
0.3139510750770569,
0.7075618505477905,
0.6625661849975586,
1.1272037029266357,
0.6089128851890564,
0.18666614592075348,
0.3877413272857666,
0.29727789759635925,
-0.508675217628479,
0.2801762521266937,
-0.2929850220680237,
-0.4180814027786255,
-0.5099236965179443,
0.14706210792064667,
0.408759206533432,
0.4107759892940521,
-0.2889212965965271,
0.4713451564311981,
-0.254398912191391,
0.513806164264679,
-0.7391343116760254,
-0.023024722933769226,
-0.8331519961357117,
-0.46678808331489563,
-0.2831096649169922,
0.1489986777305603,
-0.4818967282772064,
-0.6087777614593506,
0.2273157835006714,
-0.7976897954940796,
-0.17637008428573608,
0.1537279188632965,
1.0238033533096313,
0.3000031113624573,
-0.2784939110279083,
-0.37679043412208557,
-0.7670861482620239,
1.0764336585998535,
-0.6863017678260803,
0.36821943521499634,
-0.021993260830640793,
0.14473611116409302,
-0.12082348018884659,
-0.41166922450065613,
-0.6298959851264954,
0.018684254959225655,
0.12914986908435822,
-0.036239419132471085,
-0.20225872099399567,
-0.1955300122499466,
0.17854899168014526,
0.19133424758911133,
-0.651396632194519,
0.5546020865440369,
-0.17898929119110107,
0.02922886610031128,
0.607908308506012,
-0.12078075855970383,
0.4452987015247345,
0.17791853845119476,
-0.6792036294937134,
-0.06072210520505905,
-0.7288454174995422,
-0.19262264668941498,
0.37983107566833496,
0.15864498913288116,
0.25557294487953186,
0.6747869849205017,
0.2238653004169464,
0.7111623883247375,
-0.007596901152282953,
-0.04470250383019447,
-0.02330503799021244,
0.13918614387512207,
-0.15143974125385284,
0.29138708114624023,
0.7714910507202148,
0.12445304542779922,
0.34025272727012634,
-0.11609970778226852,
-0.2874894440174103,
0.13412201404571533,
0.146060511469841,
-0.8299633264541626,
-0.12334738671779633,
0.2896377742290497,
-0.28746774792671204,
-0.22736668586730957,
0.17231245338916779,
-0.8717966675758362,
-0.30930501222610474,
-0.6389710903167725,
0.42973601818084717,
-0.4376237392425537,
-0.16290950775146484,
0.1807987093925476,
0.22486485540866852,
0.23261332511901855,
0.4107160270214081,
-1.0142356157302856,
0.38443195819854736,
0.6557490229606628,
0.7296569347381592,
-0.4502139687538147,
-0.050673749297857285,
-0.7740528583526611,
0.2790490388870239,
-0.052271317690610886,
0.6512876749038696,
-0.7519137263298035,
0.13358074426651,
-0.11116001009941101,
-0.114137202501297,
-0.43864887952804565,
-0.43222036957740784,
0.8302037119865417,
-0.911109447479248,
0.32688280940055847,
0.035043638199567795,
-0.7007241249084473,
-0.3626116216182709,
0.02147350274026394,
-0.8886316418647766,
0.8959185481071472,
-0.16218343377113342,
-0.7989494800567627,
0.09673550724983215,
-0.9221470952033997,
-0.1761191189289093,
-0.11782951653003693,
-0.2447410672903061,
-0.45195886492729187,
0.014991563744843006,
0.2948184609413147,
0.2002609670162201,
-0.4978037178516388,
0.2883906662464142,
-0.29891836643218994,
-0.2850233018398285,
-0.040936343371868134,
-0.21199098229408264,
1.0354820489883423,
0.37202373147010803,
-0.4065162241458893,
0.014242076314985752,
-0.6988965272903442,
-0.010303325019776821,
0.274139940738678,
-0.41936224699020386,
-0.6384977102279663,
0.15231887996196747,
-0.021653687581419945,
0.14188526570796967,
0.7248765826225281,
-0.8535040020942688,
0.6124995350837708,
-0.42785578966140747,
0.45189133286476135,
0.7617648839950562,
-0.391817569732666,
0.5009397268295288,
-0.009716249071061611,
0.5229282975196838,
-0.19124597311019897,
-0.002844511764124036,
0.24337653815746307,
-0.065517857670784,
-0.6023027300834656,
-0.5393624901771545,
0.7942253351211548,
0.9043364524841309,
-0.3130130469799042,
0.6279313564300537,
-0.7060853242874146,
-0.30739396810531616,
-1.025275468826294,
0.3260434567928314,
0.148419588804245,
0.42266544699668884,
0.29378655552864075,
-0.12500472366809845,
-0.526297390460968,
-1.078932523727417,
0.09566731750965118,
-0.0840284451842308,
-0.05217887461185455,
0.07679712772369385,
0.2652113735675812,
-0.23149004578590393,
1.0435510873794556,
-0.6460461020469666,
-0.17996682226657867,
-0.025189964100718498,
0.13931097090244293,
0.11217751353979111,
0.38173362612724304,
0.4041518270969391,
-0.9733267426490784,
-0.34600335359573364,
0.2728409171104431,
-0.7331990599632263,
-0.22451099753379822,
0.23524850606918335,
-0.35124364495277405,
0.021324235945940018,
0.21534514427185059,
-0.8195240497589111,
0.12783180177211761,
0.5785847902297974,
0.17918650805950165,
0.3106410503387451,
0.10180219262838364,
0.03357520326972008,
-1.1387617588043213,
0.34572237730026245,
0.04548417776823044,
-0.2717365622520447,
-0.5956652760505676,
0.060538243502378464,
0.2168220430612564,
-0.28324493765830994,
-0.3854645788669586,
0.5199929475784302,
-0.6120308637619019,
-0.09675100445747375,
-0.23979346454143524,
0.5349499583244324,
0.28427654504776,
0.24530023336410522,
0.21825064718723297,
0.8599115610122681,
0.4474300146102905,
-0.53057461977005,
0.5072046518325806,
0.3725895285606384,
-0.46156176924705505,
0.1813317984342575,
-0.41605743765830994,
0.3669285178184509,
-0.17703983187675476,
-0.2002304047346115,
-0.8242801427841187,
-0.1404891163110733,
-0.07344797998666763,
-0.1976170837879181,
0.7927873730659485,
0.10549986362457275,
-0.3813703954219818,
-0.26404455304145813,
-0.4212619960308075,
0.42666399478912354,
0.1766931116580963,
-0.7812302112579346,
0.41123026609420776,
0.6645422577857971,
-0.3792387545108795,
-0.8338277339935303,
-0.2846698462963104,
-0.16043689846992493,
-0.4488805830478668,
-0.8524927496910095,
0.3424268960952759,
-0.009090820327401161,
-0.4844900965690613,
0.04953145980834961,
0.011014695279300213,
-0.04113613814115524,
0.09542115777730942,
-0.13808082044124603,
0.4990868866443634,
-0.45880141854286194,
0.3329487442970276,
-0.2737089991569519,
0.051622599363327026,
-0.4014222323894501,
-0.5726213455200195,
0.41304636001586914,
-0.042538296431303024,
-0.32062411308288574,
-0.4130629003047943,
0.4178524911403656,
0.5979326367378235,
-0.5635218024253845,
0.7689778804779053,
0.4569936990737915,
-0.4403292238712311,
0.08962967246770859,
-0.7648128867149353,
-0.033372364938259125,
-0.3521270751953125,
0.44780993461608887,
-0.19362318515777588,
-0.5695956349372864,
0.33315280079841614,
-0.11788463592529297,
0.5095875263214111,
0.4696793258190155,
0.3353557288646698,
0.05010725557804108,
1.2669581174850464,
0.7068579792976379,
-0.3386267423629761,
0.6486092209815979,
-0.017213979735970497,
0.24773558974266052,
-0.8130518794059753,
0.0360410213470459,
-0.5343361496925354,
-0.5272009968757629,
-0.3487708270549774,
0.06558817625045776,
0.19685547053813934,
0.21282729506492615,
-0.0529642254114151,
0.5836111903190613,
-0.5051141381263733,
0.3298555910587311,
0.5187203884124756,
-0.06194407492876053,
0.271951824426651,
0.14332996308803558,
0.23039661347866058,
-0.14955876767635345,
-0.6921438574790955,
-0.9812345504760742,
1.02153742313385,
0.37540265917778015,
0.8953983783721924,
0.29529526829719543,
0.6076096892356873,
0.05688431113958359,
0.35419774055480957,
-0.9499837160110474,
0.4513748586177826,
-0.3613988161087036,
-0.5616299510002136,
-0.3765329122543335,
-0.35472747683525085,
-0.937681257724762,
0.07414993643760681,
-0.13052724301815033,
-0.8786016702651978,
0.35912948846817017,
0.042348261922597885,
-0.36923009157180786,
0.19651587307453156,
-0.871762752532959,
0.9048686623573303,
-0.4270499348640442,
-0.48815831542015076,
0.005141003057360649,
-0.6300771236419678,
0.42963287234306335,
-0.173589825630188,
0.3282438814640045,
-0.2250402420759201,
-0.15484847128391266,
0.8910166025161743,
-0.25705254077911377,
0.40849125385284424,
-0.2058478593826294,
-0.27641722559928894,
0.28996872901916504,
0.10107644647359848,
0.8080217838287354,
-0.24663043022155762,
-0.41273269057273865,
0.08426316827535629,
-0.15389935672283173,
-0.30308347940444946,
-0.558750331401825,
1.0389386415481567,
-0.7905493974685669,
-0.6835907101631165,
-0.19713476300239563,
-0.4763409197330475,
-0.04756085202097893,
0.36249861121177673,
0.1835593730211258,
0.33611923456192017,
-0.29154476523399353,
0.08852455765008926,
0.7625477313995361,
0.026912737637758255,
0.3731772005558014,
0.6261664032936096,
0.08603762090206146,
-0.3599729537963867,
0.936596691608429,
0.0636976808309555,
0.1958850622177124,
0.5850617289543152,
0.05437515676021576,
-0.40744608640670776,
-0.4255983233451843,
-0.6994044184684753,
0.31459710001945496,
-0.5792731046676636,
-0.3464259207248688,
-0.4829655587673187,
-0.04175342619419098,
-0.4360162317752838,
0.16448751091957092,
-0.5237427353858948,
-0.7053288817405701,
-0.3542335629463196,
-0.0442780926823616,
0.20244406163692474,
0.6611061096191406,
0.14144514501094818,
0.22355251014232635,
-0.8934131264686584,
-0.014415010809898376,
0.24424588680267334,
-0.034181077033281326,
-0.21710646152496338,
-0.36501020193099976,
-0.37226876616477966,
0.13205504417419434,
-0.45822909474372864,
-0.7363255620002747,
0.2531239092350006,
0.2271055281162262,
0.4158448278903961,
0.4991280138492584,
0.048555344343185425,
0.6048673987388611,
-0.5351604223251343,
0.46594303846359253,
0.13247498869895935,
-0.8352153301239014,
0.5843369364738464,
-0.2165258377790451,
-0.021133795380592346,
0.7490457892417908,
0.5467607975006104,
-0.1481884866952896,
0.07901246845722198,
-0.3260946571826935,
-0.8182758092880249,
0.7732827663421631,
0.16929496824741364,
-0.32486000657081604,
0.020476946607232094,
0.3919735252857208,
0.2574734389781952,
0.3037380278110504,
-0.809873640537262,
0.03189335763454437,
0.2030058354139328,
-0.7854931354522705,
0.25676536560058594,
-0.19839172065258026,
-0.10624561458826065,
0.20477627217769623,
1.02778959274292,
0.045524727553129196,
-0.0019521829672157764,
0.09756746888160706,
-0.3785632252693176,
-0.37881264090538025,
0.3560662865638733,
0.4468737840652466,
0.7831676602363586,
-0.19028963148593903,
0.0961042121052742,
-0.17498727142810822,
-0.37405848503112793,
0.14246271550655365,
0.42735227942466736,
-0.25877645611763,
-0.19160215556621552,
0.31582847237586975,
0.7019221186637878,
0.02179635316133499,
-0.7216253876686096,
0.7313055396080017,
-0.04637988656759262,
0.027555614709854126,
-0.2567727565765381,
-0.015253939665853977,
-0.1315612643957138,
0.12952351570129395,
0.17252059280872345,
-0.057160161435604095,
0.15791550278663635,
-0.2713603377342224,
0.14960458874702454,
0.7558575868606567,
-0.2707936465740204,
-0.3450284004211426,
0.8664727210998535,
0.18130499124526978,
-0.19158770143985748,
0.6479026675224304,
0.15435142815113068,
-0.31031927466392517,
0.4370000660419464,
0.42808806896209717,
0.766110360622406,
-0.4927670359611511,
-0.1263560801744461,
0.16497786343097687,
0.2659561336040497,
-0.1562802940607071,
-0.019892528653144836,
0.27368250489234924,
-0.7806872725486755,
-0.6484395861625671,
-0.7222612500190735,
-0.09781557321548462,
0.42708727717399597,
-0.8126882314682007,
0.6616607904434204,
0.07364412397146225,
-0.08282550424337387,
0.03535396605730057,
0.14038091897964478,
-0.6188094019889832,
0.12768028676509857,
0.12945635616779327,
0.8589675426483154,
-0.8866440057754517,
0.9931617379188538,
0.9009526371955872,
-0.1538459062576294,
-0.6430060267448425,
-0.022825252264738083,
-0.0187959186732769,
-0.9229701161384583,
0.6363690495491028,
0.25470030307769775,
-0.2299060970544815,
0.32470381259918213,
-0.5840609669685364,
-1.006335735321045,
1.1244988441467285,
0.7515298128128052,
-0.7957426309585571,
-0.1839946061372757,
-0.32608428597450256,
0.23845797777175903,
-0.7017328143119812,
0.21050910651683807,
0.5352072715759277,
0.547519326210022,
-0.03086875006556511,
-0.8012384176254272,
-0.05979052186012268,
-0.14735858142375946,
-0.2099749892950058,
0.48334869742393494,
-0.7183571457862854,
0.5824487805366516,
-0.14613193273544312,
-0.39774271845817566,
0.037567976862192154,
0.503506600856781,
-0.12527793645858765,
-0.04801984131336212,
0.634088933467865,
0.7553413510322571,
0.8552355766296387,
0.14062219858169556,
0.740237295627594,
-0.1804831176996231,
0.20250754058361053,
1.0702673196792603,
-0.6210583448410034,
1.0439683198928833,
0.3494926691055298,
0.0644083023071289,
0.47601720690727234,
0.630916178226471,
0.2034119814634323,
0.4973859190940857,
-0.14606501162052155,
-0.3367886543273926,
-0.35332778096199036,
-0.2441871166229248,
-0.15935064852237701,
0.6460777521133423,
0.38488030433654785,
-0.2569590210914612,
-0.10589655488729477,
-0.09479828923940659,
-0.048570238053798676,
0.1749601513147354,
-0.19750207662582397,
0.8500303030014038,
-0.04994235560297966,
-0.7619547247886658,
0.5323836803436279,
-0.012631223537027836,
0.16911283135414124,
-0.6373080015182495,
-0.11980383098125458,
0.1518019139766693,
0.2796410620212555,
-0.1978704184293747,
-0.3926715552806854,
0.07201437652111053,
0.0010889506665989757,
-0.3749123215675354,
0.033403754234313965,
0.6732580065727234,
-0.6610839366912842,
-0.3260992467403412,
0.4251228868961334,
0.19703979790210724,
0.118923619389534,
0.18667680025100708,
-0.4591456651687622,
0.11176244169473648,
0.2740460932254791,
-0.4738195836544037,
0.3423025608062744,
0.46802568435668945,
-0.14734363555908203,
0.4369570016860962,
0.4729236364364624,
0.33979159593582153,
-0.01743728294968605,
-0.2475493848323822,
0.8092359900474548,
-0.4022395610809326,
-0.18135398626327515,
-1.0933234691619873,
0.3417220711708069,
-0.2621752619743347,
0.12881502509117126,
0.6009311079978943,
0.8263052701950073,
0.5152249932289124,
0.03200995549559593,
0.8854936361312866,
-0.01240955013781786,
0.7139278054237366,
-0.7892799377441406,
0.16166946291923523,
-0.6022658944129944,
0.45101669430732727,
0.09604209661483765,
-1.3501861095428467,
-0.17905215919017792,
0.5413475632667542,
-0.5691969394683838,
-0.4635249674320221,
0.5616814494132996,
0.6641794443130493,
-0.37794989347457886,
0.0718047246336937,
0.027498947456479073,
0.16166484355926514,
0.33762866258621216,
0.6815117001533508,
0.5128127336502075,
-0.38463979959487915,
0.6717770099639893,
0.03548956662416458,
-0.5823171734809875,
-0.21175441145896912,
-0.9256280660629272,
-0.5233521461486816,
-0.270072340965271,
-0.3668304681777954,
0.0842205286026001,
-0.07684832811355591,
1.082574725151062,
0.7760888338088989,
-0.9917948246002197,
-0.11073455214500427,
0.047645196318626404,
0.005463460925966501,
-0.03365132212638855,
-0.2249125838279724,
0.5930712223052979,
-0.1623321920633316,
-1.0535401105880737,
0.5680155158042908,
0.32008326053619385,
0.053499121218919754,
0.0006525592762045562,
0.12065421789884567,
-0.5986997485160828,
-0.0650201365351677,
0.19290775060653687,
0.3534204661846161,
-0.5360556244850159,
-0.29579344391822815,
-0.02483278512954712,
-0.15686450898647308,
0.21528659760951996,
0.6679203510284424,
-0.20489174127578735,
0.5549446940422058,
0.3405616879463196,
0.810880720615387,
0.4307428002357483,
0.5547348260879517,
0.9278122186660767,
-0.8052971959114075,
0.06774557381868362,
0.1597418487071991,
0.3889143466949463,
0.3590798079967499,
-0.5191022157669067,
0.3809111416339874,
-0.09331519901752472,
-0.8177073001861572,
-0.6286305785179138,
0.4056258499622345,
-0.6647520661354065,
-0.09090080112218857,
1.0954797267913818,
-0.2715677320957184,
-0.3613226115703583,
0.11182328313589096,
-0.33248117566108704,
0.24913373589515686,
-0.46068212389945984,
0.6824831366539001,
0.8089659214019775,
-0.07186010479927063,
0.25232428312301636,
-0.7484607696533203,
0.26147404313087463,
0.4216727316379547,
-0.6318690180778503,
0.24226567149162292,
0.5240564346313477,
0.1227758452296257,
0.41234472393989563,
0.31066593527793884,
-0.059219010174274445,
-0.04959094896912575,
-0.48748525977134705,
0.38207903504371643,
0.013144336640834808,
-0.36394864320755005,
-0.38138484954833984,
0.15052686631679535,
0.3709130585193634,
-0.4909323751926422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06702v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06702v1
|
Malayalam Sign Language Identification using Finetuned YOLOv8 and Computer Vision Techniques
| 2024-05-08T11:37:54 | 2024-05-08T11:37:54 |
Abhinand K., Abhiram B. Nair, Dhananjay C., Hanan Hamza, Mohammed Fawaz J., Rahma Fahim K., Anoop V. S
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Technological advancements and innovations are advancing our daily life in
all the ways possible but there is a larger section of society who are deprived
of accessing the benefits due to their physical inabilities. To reap the real
benefits and make it accessible to society, these talented and gifted people
should also use such innovations without any hurdles. Many applications
developed these days address these challenges, but localized communities and
other constrained linguistic groups may find it difficult to use them.
Malayalam, a Dravidian language spoken in the Indian state of Kerala is one of
the twenty-two scheduled languages in India. Recent years have witnessed a
surge in the development of systems and tools in Malayalam, addressing the
needs of Kerala, but many of them are not empathetically designed to cater to
the needs of hearing-impaired people. One of the major challenges is the
limited or no availability of sign language data for the Malayalam language and
sufficient efforts are not made in this direction. In this connection, this
paper proposes an approach for sign language identification for the Malayalam
language using advanced deep learning and computer vision techniques. We start
by developing a labeled dataset for Malayalam letters and for the
identification we use advanced deep learning techniques such as YOLOv8 and
computer vision. Experimental results show that the identification accuracy is
comparable to other sign language identification systems and other researchers
in sign language identification can use the model as a baseline to develop
advanced models.
|
[
-0.12890952825546265,
-0.6791847944259644,
0.2952977120876312,
0.10447980463504791,
-0.6527853608131409,
0.2678050398826599,
-0.019264519214630127,
-0.6644322276115417,
0.3315160870552063,
0.2605234980583191,
-0.41647258400917053,
-0.28461217880249023,
-0.968665361404419,
0.13423298299312592,
-0.22011378407478333,
-0.05455189198255539,
0.033361487090587616,
0.2649921476840973,
0.5670197606086731,
-0.17780624330043793,
-0.9368767142295837,
0.06987844407558441,
-0.6188377141952515,
-0.21461156010627747,
-0.19161614775657654,
0.46171504259109497,
0.40004438161849976,
0.7098555564880371,
0.4469031095504761,
0.4911358654499054,
-0.24282915890216827,
0.3726644814014435,
-0.053147800266742706,
0.29125165939331055,
0.015207632444798946,
-0.2914891242980957,
-0.19769170880317688,
-0.10636278241872787,
0.4135506749153137,
0.5491970181465149,
0.24748019874095917,
0.3114055097103119,
-0.3381587862968445,
0.5282772779464722,
-0.5048473477363586,
0.4174784719944,
-0.24545323848724365,
0.4570743143558502,
-0.5452256798744202,
-0.01618485525250435,
-0.002391914837062359,
-0.6189312934875488,
-0.15462376177310944,
-0.4591972827911377,
-0.021795857697725296,
-0.16506227850914001,
0.5441892147064209,
-0.12035644799470901,
-0.4322408139705658,
-0.5944850444793701,
-0.6820977926254272,
0.7157790064811707,
-0.5737389922142029,
0.535758912563324,
0.5455377101898193,
0.6456655263900757,
-0.2905382812023163,
-0.23347491025924683,
-0.6763154864311218,
-0.1813928782939911,
0.1828766167163849,
-0.09841711074113846,
0.4608019292354584,
-0.1448010802268982,
-0.0382964089512825,
0.7607834339141846,
-0.5748749375343323,
0.1466187685728073,
-1.0522055625915527,
-0.6582256555557251,
0.5177599191665649,
0.16528083384037018,
0.5202065110206604,
-0.28350314497947693,
-0.29270774126052856,
0.08062402158975601,
0.1436878740787506,
0.08627902716398239,
0.3706648647785187,
0.7913087010383606,
-0.10056622326374054,
0.559840977191925,
-0.4050472676753998,
0.883787214756012,
0.4981699287891388,
-0.48404625058174133,
0.4885987937450409,
0.027053970843553543,
-0.4425257444381714,
0.18648353219032288,
0.7669705152511597,
0.01895594224333763,
0.644896924495697,
0.22702132165431976,
-0.2667044997215271,
0.2399439662694931,
-0.24156969785690308,
-0.4437471628189087,
0.14302824437618256,
0.1832161396741867,
-0.4080972373485565,
-0.21931993961334229,
-0.000382717204047367,
-0.7446004152297974,
-1.2766870260238647,
-0.48922181129455566,
0.5820868015289307,
-0.6342239379882812,
-0.859360933303833,
0.254900187253952,
-0.07204747945070267,
0.5419811010360718,
0.3397381603717804,
-0.9543797373771667,
0.175956591963768,
0.6489177942276001,
0.8747200965881348,
-0.12961164116859436,
0.08355847001075745,
-0.5017127990722656,
-0.4913662075996399,
-0.29885244369506836,
0.169844850897789,
-0.6198801398277283,
-0.11846665292978287,
-0.20280924439430237,
-0.05277679115533829,
0.10654108226299286,
-0.4631785750389099,
0.13272686302661896,
-0.5790563225746155,
-0.01332634873688221,
0.3596813678741455,
-0.460201233625412,
-0.06625021249055862,
-0.09423647820949554,
-0.624054491519928,
0.6594696640968323,
0.23993100225925446,
-0.2789205014705658,
0.4036123752593994,
-0.11762368679046631,
-0.5538643598556519,
0.5621722936630249,
-0.431919127702713,
-0.36316555738449097,
0.49384140968322754,
0.04210032522678375,
0.6714712977409363,
-0.009763916954398155,
0.2846498489379883,
0.018564026802778244,
-0.2564951181411743,
0.1569986194372177,
-0.5464778542518616,
1.170658826828003,
0.8390249609947205,
-0.4520424008369446,
-0.22737529873847961,
-1.3173402547836304,
0.08227796852588654,
0.15620632469654083,
-0.2404685765504837,
-0.28792503476142883,
-0.7925044894218445,
0.33413878083229065,
0.27664825320243835,
0.3734672963619232,
-0.7551689743995667,
0.08355718106031418,
-0.5012122392654419,
-0.13629549741744995,
0.7932969331741333,
-0.11982590705156326,
0.2692915201187134,
0.43995651602745056,
0.8099660873413086,
0.27604231238365173,
0.39010101556777954,
0.00570595683529973,
-0.6386461853981018,
-0.6333257555961609,
-0.4472235441207886,
0.16915030777454376,
0.5752933621406555,
-0.2546214461326599,
0.2090744823217392,
0.1907656043767929,
-0.5780064463615417,
-0.8872045874595642,
0.3267415463924408,
0.5957188010215759,
0.3992706835269928,
0.12178786844015121,
-0.7750861048698425,
-0.7610959410667419,
-0.7064881920814514,
-0.21650433540344238,
0.12367381900548935,
0.3573008179664612,
-0.055358387529850006,
0.0625961571931839,
0.03747004270553589,
0.6129899024963379,
-0.2685888409614563,
-0.6433537602424622,
-0.16651511192321777,
-0.42350831627845764,
0.5543177127838135,
0.5243201851844788,
0.16240184009075165,
-0.98411625623703,
-0.778229832649231,
0.2228299230337143,
-0.7326645851135254,
-0.03609572350978851,
0.027092795819044113,
0.2971611022949219,
-0.042140670120716095,
0.5842079520225525,
-0.17782065272331238,
0.5326570868492126,
0.4379589557647705,
-0.7557210326194763,
0.4956604838371277,
-0.0909523218870163,
0.22978736460208893,
-1.0571578741073608,
-0.07899478822946548,
0.09306026250123978,
-0.3205212950706482,
-0.8615227937698364,
-0.05240638554096222,
0.1197458878159523,
-0.48966121673583984,
-0.43429744243621826,
0.6662653088569641,
-0.839945912361145,
0.32631048560142517,
-0.46378010511398315,
0.02982589788734913,
-0.3544613718986511,
0.10915413498878479,
0.1769181191921234,
0.45093899965286255,
0.9951462745666504,
-0.5820538401603699,
0.7098438739776611,
0.20629552006721497,
-0.40356865525245667,
1.0057669878005981,
-0.2448328733444214,
-0.0010285706957802176,
-0.45269709825515747,
-0.4903765916824341,
-0.9783234596252441,
-0.31450554728507996,
0.6648650765419006,
-0.7640618085861206,
0.7473289370536804,
-0.10891883075237274,
0.21548621356487274,
-0.29810845851898193,
0.1043790727853775,
0.2764596939086914,
0.5785563588142395,
-0.3009192943572998,
0.5960969924926758,
0.57933109998703,
0.06169409677386284,
-0.6585513353347778,
-0.6419475078582764,
-0.03259936720132828,
-0.40221261978149414,
-0.18218033015727997,
-0.42053622007369995,
0.2321726530790329,
-0.27074286341667175,
-0.5369805097579956,
-0.3033725619316101,
-0.49970802664756775,
-0.032187797129154205,
0.5010694265365601,
-0.03193887323141098,
-0.2679305374622345,
0.30861714482307434,
-0.2786937952041626,
-0.5358589887619019,
-0.35173583030700684,
-0.4435114860534668,
0.43686652183532715,
-0.320093035697937,
-0.28596314787864685,
-1.1672369241714478,
0.4386208653450012,
0.9399116039276123,
-0.4700647294521332,
0.3927787244319916,
0.8363073468208313,
-0.5654188990592957,
0.2077040821313858,
-0.626750111579895,
0.016094893217086792,
-0.573302686214447,
0.5230612754821777,
-0.7892027497291565,
-0.3810948431491852,
0.3149435818195343,
-0.4291752576828003,
-0.24587012827396393,
0.4064255654811859,
0.5755325555801392,
0.2738111615180969,
0.5635063648223877,
0.7304883003234863,
-0.02962898090481758,
0.6080374121665955,
0.04834229126572609,
0.204694926738739,
-0.5264529585838318,
-0.5507040023803711,
-0.4201141893863678,
-0.33030134439468384,
-0.3959653973579407,
-0.2903435230255127,
-0.15161076188087463,
0.12173546850681305,
0.20363302528858185,
0.922936737537384,
-0.7640531659126282,
0.3597116768360138,
0.48853665590286255,
0.18390923738479614,
0.45338594913482666,
-0.07033132016658783,
-0.3170979917049408,
-0.05881527066230774,
0.02931904047727585,
-0.5271066427230835,
0.9688052535057068,
0.30087584257125854,
0.7864174246788025,
0.2039833515882492,
0.8636297583580017,
0.5044971108436584,
-0.21348799765110016,
-0.7010412216186523,
0.5731087923049927,
0.28510963916778564,
-0.7588856220245361,
-0.4575757384300232,
-0.1397894024848938,
-1.1343765258789062,
0.14855018258094788,
-0.24816496670246124,
-0.8252354860305786,
0.5933877825737,
0.1926812380552292,
-0.10643067955970764,
-0.09817714244127274,
-1.1126688718795776,
0.6396108865737915,
-0.27461034059524536,
-0.057234544306993484,
-0.15420418977737427,
-0.6231779456138611,
0.20793378353118896,
-0.18079781532287598,
0.24081619083881378,
-0.25570759177207947,
0.34383681416511536,
0.6971548795700073,
-0.50273597240448,
0.9645506739616394,
-0.498905211687088,
-0.07655160874128342,
0.18005195260047913,
0.005734538193792105,
0.40323522686958313,
-0.022663097828626633,
-0.26155126094818115,
-0.28386548161506653,
-0.1523168385028839,
-0.6062847375869751,
-0.3296985328197479,
0.7489838004112244,
-0.7627301216125488,
-0.27643030881881714,
-0.5127883553504944,
-0.20555348694324493,
-0.29615792632102966,
0.7105408310890198,
-0.0037715090438723564,
0.7269166111946106,
-0.028695642948150635,
-0.34451746940612793,
0.6026453971862793,
-0.06177429482340813,
0.3319949209690094,
0.42049482464790344,
-0.13881856203079224,
-0.5313855409622192,
1.1152186393737793,
-0.03705258667469025,
0.09639574587345123,
0.042559947818517685,
0.49487388134002686,
-0.4263422191143036,
-0.7146868705749512,
-0.4639705419540405,
0.2817349135875702,
-0.7841007113456726,
0.006030303426086903,
-0.14297810196876526,
0.10573314875364304,
-0.5838014483451843,
0.05702171102166176,
-0.4243088960647583,
-0.5678462982177734,
-0.2690426707267761,
-0.06442788988351822,
0.46183669567108154,
0.7436535954475403,
0.008881323039531708,
0.0168532133102417,
-0.18993963301181793,
0.6428670883178711,
0.4282321035861969,
0.6190771460533142,
0.005825743544846773,
-0.39455536007881165,
-0.07865311950445175,
-0.2816210389137268,
-0.1476430892944336,
-0.9897837042808533,
0.11849533766508102,
0.3642856180667877,
0.46725791692733765,
0.6862893104553223,
0.02995932288467884,
0.7403667569160461,
-0.20972856879234314,
0.15882393717765808,
0.5865551829338074,
-0.7822215557098389,
0.49470946192741394,
-0.02090212143957615,
0.36925533413887024,
0.5960493087768555,
0.4007151126861572,
-0.5590693950653076,
-0.3894674777984619,
-0.3912960886955261,
-0.772458553314209,
0.44974860548973083,
0.07817217707633972,
0.0638575553894043,
0.19943979382514954,
0.22382034361362457,
0.45025870203971863,
0.23162288963794708,
-0.5802193880081177,
-0.3920082151889801,
-0.4062240719795227,
-0.6943302750587463,
0.1050596535205841,
0.1365167498588562,
0.5044687986373901,
-0.3777877986431122,
0.4646730124950409,
0.07402434200048447,
-0.07803751528263092,
0.1071041151881218,
-0.4953745901584625,
0.0009063490433618426,
0.2954848110675812,
0.816470205783844,
0.5088409185409546,
0.077316053211689,
0.3287569284439087,
-0.06754432618618011,
-1.2784035205841064,
0.4969947338104248,
-0.11906754225492477,
0.09742714464664459,
-0.07872550934553146,
0.18388685584068298,
0.8207125067710876,
-0.5444375276565552,
-0.6363728046417236,
0.3864218592643738,
0.0361386202275753,
0.09706839174032211,
-0.5467852354049683,
0.08332045376300812,
-0.040107373148202896,
0.47843798995018005,
0.5154885649681091,
0.1518944948911667,
-0.04457811638712883,
-0.5135179758071899,
0.1562793105840683,
0.40103936195373535,
-1.0271918773651123,
-0.14537712931632996,
0.463666707277298,
0.4489193260669708,
-1.024799108505249,
0.3941570222377777,
-0.1346222311258316,
-0.21961821615695953,
0.6060332655906677,
0.5278725624084473,
0.8708658218383789,
-0.6431875228881836,
0.021019861102104187,
0.32332509756088257,
0.2912226617336273,
0.39114293456077576,
0.6011016964912415,
-0.060257427394390106,
-0.2663496732711792,
-0.1805875301361084,
-0.9254546165466309,
0.03695158660411835,
0.41471344232559204,
-0.38003385066986084,
0.36533457040786743,
-0.7276628017425537,
-0.2784517705440521,
0.10067498683929443,
0.270169198513031,
-0.8127660751342773,
0.5769510269165039,
0.5909683108329773,
0.7372889518737793,
-1.328198790550232,
0.4912813603878021,
0.5082391500473022,
-0.19752858579158783,
-0.5973549485206604,
-0.4103891849517822,
0.3082876205444336,
-1.037989854812622,
0.5816767811775208,
0.39227527379989624,
-0.2590333819389343,
0.31738629937171936,
-0.024267325177788734,
-0.6777487397193909,
0.7606557607650757,
0.24486778676509857,
-0.5298951864242554,
0.5763120055198669,
0.26985979080200195,
0.5586925745010376,
-0.06519755721092224,
0.25320541858673096,
0.42032724618911743,
0.856203556060791,
0.029123777523636818,
-1.133589267730713,
0.26817572116851807,
-0.302874892950058,
-0.03905487060546875,
0.34293845295906067,
-0.49491044878959656,
0.30097484588623047,
-0.2915835976600647,
-0.2756708860397339,
0.019363896921277046,
0.9342272281646729,
0.16111434996128082,
0.199918732047081,
0.3686981797218323,
0.17842739820480347,
0.964939296245575,
0.30608853697776794,
0.4202497899532318,
0.28921884298324585,
0.2834995687007904,
0.3580179810523987,
0.12836217880249023,
0.3937535583972931,
0.7408285737037659,
-0.17730703949928284,
-0.05960117653012276,
0.34224554896354675,
0.018276672810316086,
0.595199465751648,
0.4723067283630371,
-0.20820343494415283,
-0.21642200648784637,
-0.024941159412264824,
-0.23400545120239258,
0.6704195141792297,
0.45920708775520325,
-0.2761715054512024,
-0.13588184118270874,
0.4980899691581726,
-0.18110597133636475,
0.3084283471107483,
-0.515954852104187,
0.46738821268081665,
0.2606305181980133,
-0.30232250690460205,
0.8445140719413757,
-0.14466029405593872,
0.7499274015426636,
-0.6087062954902649,
-0.09606608748435974,
-0.015193520113825798,
0.6775087714195251,
-0.2731385827064514,
-0.5692359805107117,
0.3017144799232483,
-0.33949965238571167,
0.09492721408605576,
-0.07595675438642502,
0.9078083634376526,
-0.38287943601608276,
-0.6776208877563477,
-0.027479397132992744,
0.20051325857639313,
0.42763617634773254,
0.30048248171806335,
-0.5100859999656677,
0.1516209840774536,
-0.17189207673072815,
0.007865319028496742,
0.15835659205913544,
0.33149197697639465,
-0.2852895259857178,
0.6375693082809448,
0.2837076783180237,
0.31332841515541077,
0.34401804208755493,
-0.12267646193504333,
0.22776652872562408,
-0.7071444392204285,
-0.552667498588562,
-0.6231400966644287,
0.3358726501464844,
-0.18278644979000092,
-0.652582049369812,
0.897132933139801,
0.3393775224685669,
0.3921264111995697,
-0.6934023499488831,
0.679530680179596,
-0.23658297955989838,
0.3600606918334961,
-0.25978749990463257,
0.7824065089225769,
-0.2820456027984619,
-0.3144990801811218,
-0.6081286668777466,
-0.47473853826522827,
-0.5234023332595825,
0.6295515298843384,
0.0022533717565238476,
0.12137819826602936,
0.5261515974998474,
0.7727851271629333,
-0.5465929508209229,
-0.37363818287849426,
0.5961964130401611,
0.05210042744874954,
0.08041529357433319,
0.6097288131713867,
0.39691054821014404,
-0.6562036275863647,
0.4732225239276886,
-0.032610371708869934,
-0.5302372574806213,
-0.5854963064193726,
-0.47152411937713623,
-0.8555708527565002,
-0.961279034614563,
-0.48802098631858826,
-0.25893542170524597,
-0.06115255132317543,
0.8922980427742004,
0.605531632900238,
-1.0461918115615845,
-0.13835324347019196,
-0.2373582422733307,
0.06638091057538986,
-0.5535775423049927,
-0.18206873536109924,
0.7111203074455261,
0.17492645978927612,
-0.8862578272819519,
0.5358118414878845,
0.33182623982429504,
0.23062796890735626,
-0.34113582968711853,
-0.2062922567129135,
-0.17317256331443787,
-0.007589905522763729,
0.1673816442489624,
0.8549546599388123,
-0.5881190896034241,
-0.14140979945659637,
-0.12304560095071793,
-0.14314857125282288,
-0.05625500530004501,
0.3740849494934082,
-0.9203424453735352,
0.9557653069496155,
0.7791237831115723,
0.471405029296875,
0.22886282205581665,
-0.01670641452074051,
0.38119983673095703,
-0.4094964861869812,
0.33676856756210327,
0.09413599222898483,
0.11856631189584732,
0.5668609738349915,
-0.29162999987602234,
0.10086043924093246,
0.46174636483192444,
-0.0030402312986552715,
-0.6295594573020935,
0.49245697259902954,
-1.0226212739944458,
0.2941204607486725,
0.864717960357666,
0.17594677209854126,
-0.39855679869651794,
-0.9857255816459656,
-0.5065608620643616,
0.36215880513191223,
-0.09687232226133347,
0.7602053284645081,
0.35858097672462463,
0.1669682264328003,
-0.31722888350486755,
-0.3116645812988281,
0.3827970325946808,
0.05250454321503639,
-0.24114854633808136,
-0.22699254751205444,
0.1756051629781723,
0.30574408173561096,
0.43215829133987427,
0.7833568453788757,
-0.26731905341148376,
0.40267327427864075,
0.015139998868107796,
-0.06285139918327332,
-0.5158384442329407,
-0.1546422690153122,
-0.4960283935070038,
0.3463093340396881,
0.3020346164703369,
-0.7809489369392395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04960v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04960v2
|
P-ICL: Point In-Context Learning for Named Entity Recognition with Large Language Models
| 2024-05-08T11:01:21 | 2024-06-17T09:38:25 |
Guochao Jiang, Zepeng Ding, Yuchen Shi, Deqing Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, the rise of large language models (LLMs) has made it
possible to directly achieve named entity recognition (NER) without any
demonstration samples or only using a few samples through in-context learning
(ICL). However, standard ICL only helps LLMs understand task instructions,
format and input-label mapping, but neglects the particularity of the NER task
itself. In this paper, we propose a new prompting framework P-ICL to better
achieve NER with LLMs, in which some point entities are leveraged as the
auxiliary information to recognize each entity type. With such significant
information, the LLM can achieve entity classification more precisely. To
obtain optimal point entities for prompting LLMs, we also proposed a point
entity selection method based on K-Means clustering. Our extensive experiments
on some representative NER benchmarks verify the effectiveness of our proposed
strategies in P-ICL and point entity selection.
|
[
-0.5812245011329651,
-0.6270720362663269,
0.8865313529968262,
0.2796283960342407,
-0.40791553258895874,
-0.03535623475909233,
-0.3919191360473633,
-0.3234744668006897,
0.07838109880685806,
0.17626942694187164,
-0.3338300585746765,
-0.6367053985595703,
-0.6942052841186523,
0.32768645882606506,
-0.40776193141937256,
0.8501794934272766,
-0.10002950578927994,
0.15093062818050385,
-0.1718415915966034,
0.156861811876297,
-0.33326175808906555,
-0.42603111267089844,
-1.1246066093444824,
-0.3638579249382019,
0.7076483964920044,
0.7863087058067322,
-0.13060006499290466,
0.2932884395122528,
0.2567950189113617,
0.23544730246067047,
-0.06361483037471771,
0.013502866961061954,
-0.25673049688339233,
0.16505882143974304,
-0.07938530296087265,
-0.44191113114356995,
-0.1750306934118271,
-0.309377521276474,
1.113370656967163,
0.8331583738327026,
0.07699067890644073,
0.05534786358475685,
0.19993695616722107,
0.3580916225910187,
-0.6758057475090027,
0.2300754189491272,
-0.8444963693618774,
0.086403027176857,
-0.06346961110830307,
-0.06606458872556686,
-0.7097722887992859,
-0.275395005941391,
0.45565134286880493,
-0.5699268579483032,
-0.09148968011140823,
0.137537881731987,
0.7262333631515503,
0.1482248604297638,
-0.5588423609733582,
-0.4479566812515259,
-0.5952171683311462,
0.7840781807899475,
-0.5154042840003967,
0.6231725811958313,
0.24428440630435944,
0.1894378960132599,
-0.2694894075393677,
-0.6604076027870178,
-0.7615645527839661,
-0.4574087858200073,
-0.05753132700920105,
-0.18334327638149261,
-0.050322238355875015,
-0.052721600979566574,
0.40214669704437256,
-0.06937214732170105,
-0.162441685795784,
0.32538044452667236,
-0.1272607445716858,
0.10986795276403427,
0.2986496686935425,
-0.15825378894805908,
0.1424434930086136,
0.11275482922792435,
-0.6266132593154907,
0.009651066735386848,
-1.2904181480407715,
0.29795852303504944,
-0.21993577480316162,
0.3525615632534027,
0.11879408359527588,
0.3286854922771454,
-0.14268852770328522,
0.5078292489051819,
0.6887513399124146,
-0.37879320979118347,
0.1686238795518875,
0.47116246819496155,
-0.21426711976528168,
0.43661943078041077,
0.5889562368392944,
0.27460384368896484,
0.13959571719169617,
-0.14548435807228088,
-0.25817450881004333,
-0.4772411286830902,
-0.19226257503032684,
-0.8044248223304749,
-0.2615651786327362,
0.025560667738318443,
-0.3549116849899292,
0.15659689903259277,
0.17957262694835663,
-0.6956203579902649,
-0.35134631395339966,
-0.49535059928894043,
0.4365004003047943,
-0.4918265640735626,
-0.34656864404678345,
-0.4306555688381195,
0.20730172097682953,
0.30609607696533203,
0.5486527681350708,
-0.6743760108947754,
0.15452840924263,
0.45335036516189575,
0.7012840509414673,
-0.4523027241230011,
-0.4880181550979614,
-0.8604621887207031,
0.39402759075164795,
-0.16561250388622284,
0.9414832592010498,
-0.6951478123664856,
-0.6566558480262756,
-0.056769393384456635,
0.030967803671956062,
-0.044029831886291504,
-0.723005473613739,
0.17454957962036133,
-0.5992684960365295,
-0.08914806693792343,
-0.5604617595672607,
-0.7071653008460999,
-0.29019755125045776,
0.2623778283596039,
-0.3443107008934021,
1.0662314891815186,
-0.12317470461130142,
-0.538341224193573,
0.9501948952674866,
-0.6547043919563293,
-0.4205607771873474,
0.4430446922779083,
-0.317207008600235,
-0.27232787013053894,
0.14951220154762268,
0.35063064098358154,
0.8024250268936157,
-0.16023141145706177,
0.5126354098320007,
-0.3050927519798279,
-0.31052568554878235,
0.18327774107456207,
-0.04038558900356293,
0.42195719480514526,
-0.06431867182254791,
-0.4052385091781616,
0.098318912088871,
-0.6809068322181702,
-0.12796302139759064,
0.0016735104145482183,
-0.6796339154243469,
-0.5454792976379395,
0.17004521191120148,
-0.21603460609912872,
0.3236016035079956,
0.16360457241535187,
-0.40340086817741394,
0.14914430677890778,
-0.3414747714996338,
0.3311310112476349,
0.4994502067565918,
0.17758619785308838,
0.793860137462616,
0.12683874368667603,
0.21035894751548767,
0.3019244074821472,
-0.21544547379016876,
0.1544569432735443,
-0.36975714564323425,
-0.8173130750656128,
-0.3591611683368683,
0.318170964717865,
0.5485357046127319,
-0.8189722299575806,
0.5699136853218079,
-0.1810227632522583,
-0.35646486282348633,
0.014508743770420551,
-0.13570421934127808,
0.28650081157684326,
0.9581564664840698,
0.43769407272338867,
0.1428578943014145,
-0.4539290964603424,
-0.7654687762260437,
0.039742399007081985,
-0.25770241022109985,
-0.31488293409347534,
0.565162718296051,
0.6252128481864929,
0.04626385122537613,
1.125298261642456,
-0.28986111283302307,
-0.02615414559841156,
-0.40308254957199097,
0.006387254223227501,
0.1154136136174202,
0.3026478886604309,
0.2330898493528366,
-1.003961205482483,
-0.9049566984176636,
-0.18113203346729279,
-0.42049217224121094,
-0.17645949125289917,
0.1779346764087677,
0.20957712829113007,
-0.04016563296318054,
0.7971200942993164,
-0.5664659738540649,
0.18065550923347473,
0.11627866327762604,
-0.09976610541343689,
0.4312223196029663,
-0.11533065885305405,
-0.027152584865689278,
-1.050633192062378,
0.1642272025346756,
0.24479633569717407,
-0.11265145242214203,
-0.6887750029563904,
-0.27712395787239075,
0.39019209146499634,
-0.2900117337703705,
-0.6637603640556335,
0.9547824859619141,
-0.7367411851882935,
-0.1415840983390808,
-0.3976980149745941,
0.35315200686454773,
-0.294933944940567,
0.4518601894378662,
0.4227248728275299,
0.5729832053184509,
0.8293774724006653,
-1.238901972770691,
0.18195289373397827,
0.17490607500076294,
-0.32557210326194763,
1.0144909620285034,
-0.3604305684566498,
0.1229456290602684,
-0.29080894589424133,
0.4676024317741394,
-0.5010961294174194,
-0.20900563895702362,
0.37839293479919434,
-0.2981683313846588,
0.474353551864624,
-0.35842642188072205,
-0.2778109610080719,
-0.19579476118087769,
0.2720984220504761,
0.41761383414268494,
0.284630686044693,
-0.9819177389144897,
0.5159602165222168,
0.5545796751976013,
-0.3129880428314209,
-0.4061160683631897,
-0.3076697885990143,
0.029377585276961327,
-0.6407182216644287,
-0.10534019023180008,
0.5986252427101135,
-0.1848483383655548,
-0.22446304559707642,
-0.018763024359941483,
0.07840611040592194,
-0.19659289717674255,
-0.01378462091088295,
0.262102335691452,
0.147149458527565,
-0.1818770319223404,
0.41707760095596313,
0.09572316706180573,
-0.3857329189777374,
-0.05095638707280159,
-0.4938631057739258,
0.4634476900100708,
-0.12343725562095642,
-0.2484443336725235,
-0.5951007008552551,
0.48068901896476746,
0.17825333774089813,
-0.29080381989479065,
0.6438907980918884,
0.2125622034072876,
-0.7924996614456177,
-0.36796191334724426,
-0.4019635319709778,
-0.3331737816333771,
-0.42630380392074585,
0.2997005879878998,
-0.5851772427558899,
-1.0542110204696655,
0.2074478417634964,
-0.6207723617553711,
-0.1613704115152359,
0.3689838647842407,
0.4808911085128784,
0.09303592890501022,
1.029407262802124,
0.6477181911468506,
-0.25417983531951904,
0.5152745246887207,
0.07418779283761978,
0.5539737343788147,
-0.8963623642921448,
-0.2826820909976959,
-0.4890063405036926,
-0.378429651260376,
-0.15756388008594513,
-0.037513040006160736,
0.5382347106933594,
0.42864248156547546,
-0.22114895284175873,
0.2698044180870056,
-0.34845852851867676,
0.6801263093948364,
0.6494207978248596,
-0.03595923259854317,
0.04638582095503807,
0.028456447646021843,
-0.3440079391002655,
-0.017232583835721016,
-0.3423888683319092,
-0.39604565501213074,
0.6153051257133484,
0.2507595121860504,
0.4749387800693512,
-0.09352179616689682,
0.8442028164863586,
-0.19114170968532562,
0.3485189974308014,
-1.075260877609253,
0.7852373719215393,
0.04492627829313278,
-0.13443630933761597,
-0.332431435585022,
-0.2787245512008667,
-0.8437625765800476,
0.0663081482052803,
-0.2300524115562439,
-1.1830726861953735,
0.5508589744567871,
0.1302645206451416,
-0.5302238464355469,
0.2419845461845398,
-0.5097916722297668,
0.5618044137954712,
-0.13513347506523132,
0.3460429012775421,
-0.062099989503622055,
-0.3669906556606293,
0.06396707147359848,
-0.004266060423105955,
-0.052069902420043945,
-0.060892630368471146,
-0.3113425076007843,
0.4875757396221161,
-0.1008494421839714,
0.7446061372756958,
-0.5697525143623352,
0.04730077087879181,
0.21304509043693542,
0.05408687889575958,
0.8249142169952393,
0.4333634078502655,
0.05668468773365021,
0.04444262012839317,
-0.2806929051876068,
-0.027735769748687744,
-0.5054941177368164,
1.0068782567977905,
-0.4255748987197876,
-0.3361007571220398,
-0.212436243891716,
-0.31770244240760803,
-0.3163882791996002,
0.39822670817375183,
0.5758674740791321,
0.49732667207717896,
0.10158656537532806,
0.3333582580089569,
0.8800851702690125,
-0.17922258377075195,
0.6064989566802979,
0.7707597613334656,
-0.04128023982048035,
-0.33749133348464966,
0.8512742519378662,
0.03647314012050629,
-0.08978058397769928,
0.7885936498641968,
0.10626819729804993,
-0.46603715419769287,
-0.9048801064491272,
-0.3702373802661896,
0.21707509458065033,
-0.8074770569801331,
-0.2878447473049164,
-0.6854143142700195,
-0.08887801319360733,
-0.2068704515695572,
-0.3708271086215973,
-0.09766586869955063,
0.07746988534927368,
-0.36294814944267273,
0.013577505014836788,
-0.04723116010427475,
0.6827777028083801,
0.2704892158508301,
0.4625435173511505,
-0.7070407271385193,
-0.031576987355947495,
0.2332608699798584,
0.27455398440361023,
0.008279162459075451,
-0.23226971924304962,
-0.07166695594787598,
-0.26571589708328247,
0.013849098235368729,
-1.1553136110305786,
0.297206848859787,
0.3726714551448822,
0.6194852590560913,
0.6471505761146545,
0.06753180921077728,
0.531419575214386,
-0.7109264135360718,
0.5826877951622009,
0.13368040323257446,
-1.060232400894165,
0.6709407567977905,
0.005956702865660191,
0.25563615560531616,
0.48780205845832825,
0.8366318941116333,
-0.809626042842865,
-0.08529244363307953,
-0.5726171731948853,
-0.8606781959533691,
0.5621752738952637,
-0.435542494058609,
-0.309619665145874,
-0.41636595129966736,
0.6028258800506592,
-0.0306383166462183,
0.21013036370277405,
-1.0769617557525635,
-0.1695907860994339,
0.473033607006073,
-0.2839567959308624,
0.19954614341259003,
-0.3199189603328705,
0.2479347139596939,
-0.08352181315422058,
0.931662380695343,
-0.35483258962631226,
0.2228192687034607,
0.3410976529121399,
-0.508374810218811,
-0.0902397632598877,
0.2420283854007721,
0.3060704171657562,
0.782697319984436,
0.2343292236328125,
0.12253930419683456,
0.6987900137901306,
-0.13783526420593262,
0.08160676062107086,
0.11696500331163406,
-0.4438213109970093,
0.01356437336653471,
0.013386939652264118,
0.8304792046546936,
0.678374171257019,
-0.6115152835845947,
0.571172833442688,
-0.052516043186187744,
-0.05918450653553009,
-0.5743171572685242,
-0.04895079508423805,
0.048873163759708405,
0.49403902888298035,
0.5335362553596497,
-0.35860538482666016,
0.10047154873609543,
-0.12146653234958649,
0.10960427671670914,
0.4929075241088867,
-0.5270037055015564,
-0.11900994181632996,
0.23804454505443573,
0.016688888892531395,
-0.3905470371246338,
0.6927209496498108,
-0.5887157320976257,
-0.49783992767333984,
0.4114108979701996,
0.8257988691329956,
0.6567115187644958,
-0.5272846817970276,
0.08563540130853653,
0.678029477596283,
-0.15261119604110718,
-0.11221490800380707,
0.09802749007940292,
-0.1567731499671936,
-0.6274874210357666,
-0.3630375862121582,
-0.6951191425323486,
-0.4245513677597046,
0.41104766726493835,
-0.40528562664985657,
0.6552263498306274,
-0.7071418166160583,
0.14808686077594757,
-0.15165932476520538,
-0.022811956703662872,
-0.4287585914134979,
0.3295290470123291,
0.34945520758628845,
0.9241278171539307,
-0.5462854504585266,
0.9523041844367981,
0.9673781991004944,
-0.15153764188289642,
-1.100260853767395,
0.1859429031610489,
0.042007528245449066,
-0.4791047275066376,
0.9494333267211914,
0.42118337750434875,
0.14107365906238556,
0.42476946115493774,
-0.5014544725418091,
-1.1754555702209473,
1.245180368423462,
0.17784814536571503,
-0.7551129460334778,
-0.24297112226486206,
-0.06957370787858963,
0.023210600018501282,
-0.7633218765258789,
0.18473787605762482,
0.36720699071884155,
0.4453766345977783,
0.32247769832611084,
-0.7584794163703918,
0.09550263732671738,
0.057558462023735046,
-0.05673433467745781,
0.6381563544273376,
-0.22209830582141876,
0.8885899186134338,
-0.08866411447525024,
-0.3853095769882202,
-0.09223959594964981,
0.819622814655304,
0.603543221950531,
0.4265957772731781,
1.013452410697937,
0.370717853307724,
0.9977236986160278,
-0.0860821083188057,
0.5963912010192871,
-0.27351492643356323,
0.22492116689682007,
1.1126415729522705,
-0.4643404185771942,
1.2091948986053467,
0.5010681748390198,
-0.13364174962043762,
0.3948845863342285,
0.8331613540649414,
-0.0714661255478859,
0.4688119888305664,
0.182264506816864,
-0.7280073761940002,
-0.23567064106464386,
-0.18349406123161316,
-0.15800227224826813,
0.33493733406066895,
0.7365402579307556,
-0.21781226992607117,
-0.3479090631008148,
0.1672632247209549,
0.04948887974023819,
-0.3139214515686035,
-0.650873601436615,
0.9349966049194336,
0.3725430369377136,
-0.7377457022666931,
0.1340385377407074,
-0.013259454630315304,
0.6573089361190796,
-0.5068999528884888,
-0.09292855113744736,
0.05210757255554199,
-0.028552835807204247,
0.015301176346838474,
-0.5154972076416016,
-0.04851212352514267,
-0.11039241403341293,
-0.34863659739494324,
-0.1047564148902893,
0.9501878023147583,
-0.674756646156311,
-0.28233370184898376,
0.3874242305755615,
0.21427178382873535,
0.34559908509254456,
-0.42859596014022827,
-0.5894011855125427,
-0.6183821558952332,
-0.3379976451396942,
-0.003257866483181715,
0.5393263697624207,
0.4546433687210083,
-0.2459675818681717,
0.6062399744987488,
0.5140419006347656,
0.16460399329662323,
-0.0714808776974678,
0.05163923650979996,
0.539160430431366,
-0.6510524749755859,
-0.7919395565986633,
-0.8648027181625366,
0.3521481454372406,
-0.10177439451217651,
-0.28496062755584717,
0.41766998171806335,
0.26260003447532654,
0.9931457042694092,
-0.0005931741907261312,
0.6283855438232422,
-0.21619465947151184,
0.7107828259468079,
-0.6149919629096985,
0.49087971448898315,
-0.4474775493144989,
-0.012920577079057693,
-0.1410750448703766,
-1.2577811479568481,
-0.3982912003993988,
0.5080047845840454,
-0.6725286841392517,
0.00006329716416075826,
0.8017062544822693,
0.6993780136108398,
-0.13788673281669617,
-0.17458564043045044,
0.29251736402511597,
0.16130194067955017,
0.23994986712932587,
0.7351769804954529,
0.9474822878837585,
0.09461058676242828,
0.41023796796798706,
-0.205149307847023,
-0.24830929934978485,
-0.32005926966667175,
-1.0948374271392822,
-0.8732890486717224,
-0.8759666681289673,
-0.2464393526315689,
0.011642281897366047,
-0.22249138355255127,
1.3457229137420654,
0.7419682145118713,
-0.9633341431617737,
-0.00023519583919551224,
-0.09567093849182129,
0.14442294836044312,
0.03057563491165638,
-0.18919692933559418,
0.48199695348739624,
-0.43057265877723694,
-0.9785468578338623,
0.8301116824150085,
0.45945438742637634,
-0.02101159282028675,
-0.0430152527987957,
-0.1887788325548172,
-0.24432528018951416,
-0.5410457253456116,
0.5680866241455078,
0.43152523040771484,
-0.8024940490722656,
-0.30360594391822815,
-0.25721579790115356,
0.08286242187023163,
0.10003875195980072,
0.9686033129692078,
-0.7474107146263123,
-0.06381417065858841,
0.3706941604614258,
0.7455546855926514,
0.19862006604671478,
-0.3014024794101715,
0.40114152431488037,
-0.7827655673027039,
0.036033745855093,
0.2963893711566925,
0.6353554129600525,
0.4166048467159271,
-0.5110660791397095,
-0.06759095191955566,
0.07238838076591492,
-0.7016420960426331,
-0.4719599783420563,
0.26992103457450867,
-0.5630431175231934,
-0.14561256766319275,
1.081102967262268,
-0.263982892036438,
-0.2675348222255707,
-0.06737901270389557,
-0.17892508208751678,
0.129776731133461,
-0.5185883641242981,
0.4512629508972168,
0.5857250094413757,
-0.12589074671268463,
-0.4058816134929657,
-0.46860170364379883,
0.6102892160415649,
0.21522028744220734,
-0.7174091339111328,
-0.37668848037719727,
0.4715231657028198,
0.4574600160121918,
0.05672081187367439,
0.6560139656066895,
0.13067124783992767,
0.15951840579509735,
-0.4754776358604431,
-0.10910514742136002,
0.2812771499156952,
-0.779110848903656,
-0.4344731271266937,
0.2275467962026596,
0.47184962034225464,
0.22100956737995148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04955v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04955v1
|
Improving Long Text Understanding with Knowledge Distilled from Summarization Model
| 2024-05-08T10:49:39 | 2024-05-08T10:49:39 |
Yan Liu, Yazheng Yang, Xiaokang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Long text understanding is important yet challenging for natural language
processing. A long article or document usually contains many redundant words
that are not pertinent to its gist and sometimes can be regarded as noise. With
recent advances of abstractive summarization, we propose our \emph{Gist
Detector} to leverage the gist detection ability of a summarization model and
integrate the extracted gist into downstream models to enhance their long text
understanding ability. Specifically, Gist Detector first learns the gist
detection knowledge distilled from a summarization model, and then produces
gist-aware representations to augment downstream models. We evaluate our method
on three different tasks: long document classification, distantly supervised
open-domain question answering, and non-parallel text style transfer. The
experimental results show that our method can significantly improve the
performance of baseline models on all tasks.
|
[
-0.4194621741771698,
-0.8373036980628967,
0.8498366475105286,
-0.3282603621482849,
-0.6758820414543152,
0.09352316707372665,
-0.41374877095222473,
-0.7373834252357483,
0.11071465909481049,
0.4617629647254944,
-0.312770277261734,
-0.42815494537353516,
-0.9110981225967407,
0.17650805413722992,
-0.5593165755271912,
1.4428778886795044,
-0.11890633404254913,
-0.2449890673160553,
-0.2630074918270111,
-0.05040102079510689,
-0.3236827850341797,
-0.35996609926223755,
-0.6377155780792236,
-0.46042075753211975,
0.44444626569747925,
0.2693254351615906,
0.33136510848999023,
0.35156163573265076,
0.44132742285728455,
0.2501804232597351,
-0.47646549344062805,
0.15112605690956116,
-0.48677313327789307,
0.28950291872024536,
-0.3212844133377075,
-0.4201854169368744,
-0.5521461367607117,
-0.37988656759262085,
0.46557557582855225,
0.6430555582046509,
0.07285252213478088,
-0.09217095375061035,
0.3265732228755951,
1.0433436632156372,
-0.6341993808746338,
0.3895896077156067,
-0.2971097230911255,
-0.2954881191253662,
-0.12736950814723969,
0.017615320160984993,
-0.22234022617340088,
-0.1743054986000061,
0.37465375661849976,
-0.6147999167442322,
0.2804125249385834,
-0.38233304023742676,
0.6435341835021973,
0.15777625143527985,
-0.6162338852882385,
-0.47571563720703125,
-0.7763795852661133,
0.4065323770046234,
-0.6611706018447876,
0.2352701872587204,
0.39206355810165405,
0.3976176083087921,
0.06382246315479279,
-0.9055877923965454,
-0.41540539264678955,
-0.09949668496847153,
-0.20971783995628357,
0.3453889787197113,
-0.26879099011421204,
0.31973105669021606,
0.271597683429718,
0.5539743900299072,
-0.5411649346351624,
-0.22415105998516083,
-0.5776783227920532,
-0.019901631399989128,
0.4452815055847168,
-0.19438649713993073,
0.06560420244932175,
-0.08106997609138489,
-0.19215679168701172,
0.17422929406166077,
-0.20502997934818268,
-0.04201766103506088,
0.18850946426391602,
0.00584383076056838,
0.06331172585487366,
0.25219598412513733,
-0.5693349242210388,
0.7674369812011719,
0.11190209537744522,
-0.09023290127515793,
0.04749598354101181,
-0.4137060046195984,
-0.09826838225126266,
0.06767677515745163,
0.33879244327545166,
0.2682379484176636,
0.6462118625640869,
-0.10015001147985458,
-0.3162943124771118,
-0.19663912057876587,
0.16042520105838776,
-0.8487165570259094,
-0.4148503839969635,
0.11792071908712387,
-0.38538166880607605,
-0.13822995126247406,
0.15352822840213776,
-0.6274100542068481,
-0.32919684052467346,
-0.4909244477748871,
0.30051159858703613,
-0.6563241481781006,
-0.3800608515739441,
0.28053274750709534,
-0.659248411655426,
-0.03996717929840088,
0.5309215188026428,
-1.0043343305587769,
0.14098632335662842,
0.6787545680999756,
0.9722412824630737,
0.009617634117603302,
-0.13303355872631073,
-0.34148651361465454,
0.3252347707748413,
-0.15161165595054626,
1.0334187746047974,
-0.17947541177272797,
-0.19158649444580078,
-0.16029348969459534,
0.024195503443479538,
0.06275007128715515,
-0.3520633578300476,
0.5324098467826843,
-0.5291197299957275,
0.2787591516971588,
-0.045599907636642456,
-0.7354058027267456,
-0.6096748113632202,
0.408412367105484,
-0.6772955656051636,
0.693876326084137,
0.32862389087677,
-1.0133891105651855,
0.23104161024093628,
-0.928011417388916,
-0.7294178605079651,
0.01422184705734253,
0.34303462505340576,
-0.33648109436035156,
0.3871369957923889,
0.6445260643959045,
0.46792611479759216,
0.1930532157421112,
0.3549076020717621,
-0.011907849460840225,
-0.3219735324382782,
-0.0518314428627491,
-0.2927372455596924,
0.30613717436790466,
0.14550288021564484,
-0.010565433651208878,
0.07013760507106781,
-0.5126550793647766,
-0.3218373656272888,
0.12041721493005753,
-0.23590852320194244,
-0.8184383511543274,
0.0007089788559824228,
-0.21722255647182465,
-0.20868277549743652,
0.34501469135284424,
-0.06934722512960434,
0.14758537709712982,
-0.44190552830696106,
0.48130857944488525,
0.5806562900543213,
0.16691678762435913,
0.7858803868293762,
-0.27675682306289673,
0.47756943106651306,
0.052517056465148926,
-0.09209272265434265,
-0.6207514405250549,
-0.34895482659339905,
-0.7140664458274841,
-0.37866291403770447,
0.32148855924606323,
0.25804823637008667,
-0.8991798758506775,
0.584749698638916,
-0.6036682724952698,
-0.21078798174858093,
-0.017353741452097893,
0.13355247676372528,
0.06508979201316833,
0.6754170656204224,
0.4141152799129486,
-0.1506430059671402,
-0.4426974058151245,
-0.6544095873832703,
-0.3869076669216156,
-0.19567672908306122,
-0.32622984051704407,
-0.21993961930274963,
0.7316678166389465,
-0.13418163359165192,
1.0302462577819824,
-0.7110053896903992,
-0.2921521067619324,
-0.5338255763053894,
0.567165732383728,
0.2730586528778076,
0.13683606684207916,
0.4236166775226593,
-0.6876171827316284,
-0.46874943375587463,
0.12358547002077103,
-0.8194859027862549,
-0.14005601406097412,
0.12473990023136139,
0.04697662219405174,
0.060388319194316864,
0.6967592239379883,
-0.5513147115707397,
0.3508351445198059,
0.32803529500961304,
-0.18389824032783508,
0.45729267597198486,
-0.26241013407707214,
0.1338009089231491,
-1.2974967956542969,
0.12383579462766647,
0.008521371521055698,
-0.6838677525520325,
-0.7657151222229004,
0.13248148560523987,
0.2807212471961975,
-0.1257152408361435,
-0.18608063459396362,
0.35725295543670654,
-0.7049717307090759,
0.041804827749729156,
-0.6736398935317993,
0.2996443808078766,
0.37006232142448425,
0.3007558584213257,
0.072696752846241,
0.8905717730522156,
0.26378053426742554,
-0.6808777451515198,
0.23012210428714752,
0.03375383839011192,
-0.44059985876083374,
0.5809475183486938,
-0.614689290523529,
0.08722775429487228,
-0.6884162425994873,
0.413449764251709,
-0.9357481002807617,
-0.2914732098579407,
0.08767557889223099,
-0.4059734344482422,
0.4339478313922882,
-0.6335237622261047,
-0.37563905119895935,
-0.3198193609714508,
-0.3298134207725525,
0.14046628773212433,
0.5092083215713501,
-0.5008887052536011,
0.6565756797790527,
0.20169521868228912,
-0.5796841382980347,
-0.29386037588119507,
-0.521678626537323,
0.038402922451496124,
-0.3276144862174988,
-0.7232757210731506,
0.2736462354660034,
0.17246048152446747,
-0.14305822551250458,
-0.06885343044996262,
-0.2127654105424881,
-0.2553371489048004,
0.21034575998783112,
-0.09289484471082687,
0.07942953705787659,
-0.30113092064857483,
0.6425440907478333,
0.35160619020462036,
-0.16652092337608337,
0.14932797849178314,
-0.6363003849983215,
0.36915579438209534,
0.01313004083931446,
-0.04525195434689522,
-0.20040637254714966,
0.43968528509140015,
0.8066770434379578,
-0.443058043718338,
0.5027541518211365,
0.6385771632194519,
-0.4424419403076172,
-0.04515556991100311,
-0.40937647223472595,
-0.22415877878665924,
-0.4215306043624878,
0.5752434730529785,
-0.1838088184595108,
-0.8386198282241821,
0.49656227231025696,
-0.2751031517982483,
-0.11148576438426971,
0.5692827105522156,
0.09537594020366669,
-0.2020670771598816,
0.7797822952270508,
0.7709929943084717,
-0.3686060905456543,
0.7338801026344299,
-0.2025490254163742,
0.27194830775260925,
-0.7138464450836182,
0.17345179617404938,
-0.40168482065200806,
-0.09669691324234009,
-0.20617160201072693,
-0.3638281524181366,
0.3129817843437195,
0.567199170589447,
0.03162837773561478,
0.2373606413602829,
-0.47852975130081177,
0.8033859729766846,
0.14322718977928162,
0.38792338967323303,
0.6924035549163818,
0.019228661432862282,
0.33060187101364136,
0.2564377784729004,
-0.3130370080471039,
-0.5197203755378723,
1.0008158683776855,
0.39726847410202026,
0.8655763268470764,
0.12245896458625793,
0.6321468949317932,
0.34830182790756226,
0.21232539415359497,
-1.0070959329605103,
0.19406619668006897,
-0.2559257745742798,
-0.37846970558166504,
-0.3151646554470062,
-0.25394853949546814,
-0.7524722218513489,
0.13408279418945312,
-0.009518478997051716,
-0.6233591437339783,
-0.23464596271514893,
0.008890979923307896,
-0.19327689707279205,
0.19242441654205322,
-0.900878369808197,
0.587762713432312,
0.00043636641930788755,
0.07113289833068848,
-0.27042490243911743,
-0.44223105907440186,
0.5540095567703247,
-0.12942208349704742,
0.20494738221168518,
-0.051609497517347336,
0.0823926106095314,
0.7802223563194275,
-0.17710790038108826,
0.6051796078681946,
-0.1557433009147644,
-0.23280565440654755,
0.4120503067970276,
-0.20995314419269562,
0.7600732445716858,
0.11597064882516861,
-0.04371252655982971,
0.1319839060306549,
-0.32985392212867737,
-0.3276316821575165,
-0.7549366354942322,
0.37047380208969116,
-0.2928037643432617,
-0.6513422727584839,
-0.3718254268169403,
-0.5530701875686646,
0.1996501237154007,
0.30749648809432983,
0.38809266686439514,
0.1855057030916214,
-0.2192770391702652,
0.014676794409751892,
0.8987786769866943,
0.26707905530929565,
0.4930996596813202,
0.3223434090614319,
-0.33946722745895386,
-0.2814335525035858,
0.3849867284297943,
0.07307935506105423,
0.38115549087524414,
0.4474727511405945,
0.25036919116973877,
-0.4600844383239746,
-0.757934033870697,
-0.3231256604194641,
-0.019685285165905952,
-0.9093743562698364,
-0.2617259621620178,
-0.9005084037780762,
-0.40443605184555054,
-0.4747275412082672,
-0.1829601675271988,
0.008429678156971931,
-0.37419143319129944,
-0.5191084742546082,
-0.19924867153167725,
0.6946161389350891,
0.8028482794761658,
0.09300951659679413,
0.5395169258117676,
-1.0403977632522583,
0.5341230630874634,
0.36435386538505554,
0.2629508674144745,
0.03504710644483566,
-0.7123235464096069,
-0.5490972995758057,
0.19427429139614105,
-0.28074121475219727,
-0.8618738651275635,
0.3259280025959015,
0.23651964962482452,
0.33337950706481934,
0.5620386004447937,
0.21502919495105743,
0.6446806788444519,
-0.3312106132507324,
0.4777062237262726,
0.11391022056341171,
-1.1087210178375244,
0.8445209860801697,
-0.4619523286819458,
0.6597290635108948,
0.6367819905281067,
0.42700785398483276,
-0.360988587141037,
-0.5704614520072937,
-0.29452863335609436,
-0.7645307183265686,
0.32160934805870056,
0.12807990610599518,
0.030819403007626534,
0.02708418481051922,
0.27639034390449524,
0.17700715363025665,
0.06636942923069,
-0.6170486807823181,
0.35901471972465515,
-0.04432862997055054,
-0.1687549501657486,
-0.10524013638496399,
-0.290991872549057,
0.0007684633019380271,
-0.2634071111679077,
0.456691175699234,
-0.35734909772872925,
0.1472650170326233,
0.3643719255924225,
-0.566408097743988,
0.2281389981508255,
0.4704553484916687,
0.5415781736373901,
0.8239767551422119,
-0.2826441526412964,
0.1387278139591217,
0.19106191396713257,
-0.527893602848053,
-0.13885121047496796,
0.25102120637893677,
0.08621204644441605,
0.251325786113739,
0.5509036779403687,
0.439373642206192,
-0.03074260614812374,
-0.3692960739135742,
0.6041017174720764,
-0.09976188093423843,
-0.22075971961021423,
-0.32850778102874756,
0.0027806279249489307,
0.22943344712257385,
0.2489871084690094,
0.5094505548477173,
0.011763745918869972,
0.4131198227405548,
-0.5278190970420837,
0.31142374873161316,
0.1996212750673294,
-0.27493205666542053,
-0.15317560732364655,
0.34971317648887634,
0.2781752645969391,
0.19776244461536407,
0.5430159568786621,
-0.2630005478858948,
-0.856681227684021,
0.6743272542953491,
0.4548742175102234,
0.8841676115989685,
0.0350407212972641,
-0.044281333684921265,
0.3526155948638916,
0.15482836961746216,
-0.3003568947315216,
0.048295386135578156,
-0.3099079132080078,
-0.3729352355003357,
-0.6568392515182495,
-0.4857226610183716,
-0.308500736951828,
0.0536331869661808,
-0.6082723140716553,
0.31132736802101135,
-0.12149008363485336,
-0.06249005347490311,
0.22333423793315887,
-0.17985975742340088,
-0.22466811537742615,
-0.08353226631879807,
0.12008635699748993,
0.8426707983016968,
-0.7519034743309021,
0.8664941191673279,
0.4849756360054016,
-0.3552370071411133,
-0.22942562401294708,
0.3129654824733734,
-0.2772287130355835,
-0.48118388652801514,
0.5273082256317139,
0.5594780445098877,
-0.128327876329422,
-0.11275391280651093,
-0.4623567759990692,
-0.5787779092788696,
1.0810317993164062,
0.20339436829090118,
-0.6206232905387878,
-0.026242731139063835,
-0.2699381113052368,
0.6799364686012268,
-0.18002672493457794,
0.3104855418205261,
0.5284078121185303,
0.527097225189209,
0.024021252989768982,
-0.6978707313537598,
-0.11714424192905426,
-0.11003318428993225,
-0.22760090231895447,
0.6164294481277466,
-0.12541411817073822,
0.8794699311256409,
-0.32492148876190186,
-0.3725271224975586,
0.026667693629860878,
0.8284948468208313,
-0.06479538977146149,
0.5855339169502258,
0.5672497153282166,
0.4739229381084442,
0.8127933144569397,
-0.012726150453090668,
0.7975006103515625,
-0.23383890092372894,
0.40758734941482544,
1.281766414642334,
-0.16869792342185974,
0.6289350390434265,
0.35227078199386597,
0.10256531089544296,
0.5021141171455383,
0.4417726695537567,
0.20426258444786072,
0.5691167116165161,
0.21577857434749603,
-0.6285631060600281,
-0.11101429164409637,
-0.027773169800639153,
-0.5497949123382568,
0.46205711364746094,
0.46847259998321533,
-0.49341464042663574,
-0.5753438472747803,
0.20330101251602173,
0.052161455154418945,
0.1600908637046814,
-0.5298529267311096,
1.1276861429214478,
0.09250028431415558,
-0.7506856322288513,
0.5113778114318848,
-0.05982332304120064,
0.8689520359039307,
-0.670414924621582,
-0.14771027863025665,
-0.23968373239040375,
0.2555748224258423,
-0.1738978624343872,
-0.9093140363693237,
0.6082357168197632,
0.09866854548454285,
-0.49729326367378235,
-0.08140242099761963,
1.1849385499954224,
-0.5508162975311279,
-0.43913131952285767,
0.5000352263450623,
0.5635582804679871,
0.11702413856983185,
-0.7076783776283264,
-0.11210507899522781,
-0.5549906492233276,
-0.0866202637553215,
-0.08937184512615204,
0.43753769993782043,
0.7454819679260254,
-0.0837993398308754,
0.5018358826637268,
0.7642683386802673,
-0.2003551721572876,
-0.30369457602500916,
0.01434824988245964,
1.0835891962051392,
-0.6140384078025818,
-0.7265409231185913,
-1.0013607740402222,
0.47339269518852234,
-0.3320915997028351,
0.025033988058567047,
0.3871951699256897,
0.46512654423713684,
0.6816047430038452,
-0.2268889844417572,
0.8813994526863098,
0.12552553415298462,
0.41199955344200134,
-0.6407439708709717,
1.0683544874191284,
-0.43768590688705444,
0.06128361448645592,
-0.05468810722231865,
-0.783916711807251,
-0.20180439949035645,
0.5431068539619446,
-0.3600562810897827,
-0.10317675024271011,
0.7772461771965027,
0.40578436851501465,
-0.22440040111541748,
0.16131144762039185,
0.4239245355129242,
-0.048280730843544006,
0.25276967883110046,
0.5638351440429688,
0.8236076235771179,
-0.40191566944122314,
0.5813453197479248,
-0.22657692432403564,
-0.18917421996593475,
-0.14490169286727905,
-1.0033681392669678,
-1.074317455291748,
-0.4748244285583496,
-0.17620304226875305,
-0.18383675813674927,
0.32789990305900574,
0.3822537064552307,
0.532263994216919,
-0.5457861423492432,
0.10268604755401611,
-0.2247205376625061,
0.4937874972820282,
-0.11835725605487823,
-0.2896966338157654,
0.22246986627578735,
-0.46582427620887756,
-0.7626175880432129,
0.18145456910133362,
0.44930145144462585,
0.3190799951553345,
0.2219112366437912,
0.16748474538326263,
-0.2759033441543579,
-0.09234210848808289,
0.9410496950149536,
0.1184544637799263,
-0.2377389669418335,
-0.34288290143013,
-0.2222863882780075,
0.013546704314649105,
0.13959190249443054,
0.7905059456825256,
-0.6619735956192017,
0.36185362935066223,
0.7962871789932251,
0.5476955771446228,
0.6147932410240173,
0.17152860760688782,
0.6038434505462646,
-0.7756849527359009,
0.08276139199733734,
0.13979150354862213,
0.45290133357048035,
0.22565799951553345,
-0.5471200346946716,
0.5622918009757996,
0.017227141186594963,
-0.5103430151939392,
-0.21924340724945068,
0.21654565632343292,
-0.86537104845047,
-0.6449389457702637,
0.8692289590835571,
-0.3905618190765381,
-0.17885583639144897,
-0.41746076941490173,
-0.1691712886095047,
0.5661423802375793,
-0.538265585899353,
0.5910285711288452,
0.7661116719245911,
0.11149754375219345,
-0.2360081672668457,
-0.41224557161331177,
0.27238044142723083,
0.12167516350746155,
-1.0758123397827148,
0.30474504828453064,
0.4400359094142914,
0.3150852918624878,
0.2139541208744049,
0.5520838499069214,
0.026334814727306366,
0.21585221588611603,
-0.3326975703239441,
-0.048053305596113205,
-0.2075105905532837,
-0.31950393319129944,
-0.54097980260849,
-0.02795547805726528,
-0.05630234628915787,
-0.16465933620929718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04950v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04950v1
|
VisionGraph: Leveraging Large Multimodal Models for Graph Theory Problems in Visual Context
| 2024-05-08T10:42:48 | 2024-05-08T10:42:48 |
Yunxin Li, Baotian Hu, Haoyuan Shi, Wei Wang, Longyue Wang, Min Zhang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) have achieved impressive success in visual
understanding and reasoning, remarkably improving the performance of
mathematical reasoning in a visual context. Yet, a challenging type of visual
math lies in the multimodal graph theory problem, which demands that LMMs
understand the graphical structures accurately and perform multi-step reasoning
on the visual graph. Additionally, exploring multimodal graph theory problems
will lead to more effective strategies in fields like biology, transportation,
and robotics planning. To step forward in this direction, we are the first to
design a benchmark named VisionGraph, used to explore the capabilities of
advanced LMMs in solving multimodal graph theory problems. It encompasses eight
complex graph problem tasks, from connectivity to shortest path problems.
Subsequently, we present a Description-Program-Reasoning (DPR) chain to enhance
the logical accuracy of reasoning processes through graphical structure
description generation and algorithm-aware multi-step reasoning. Our extensive
study shows that 1) GPT-4V outperforms Gemini Pro in multi-step graph
reasoning; 2) All LMMs exhibit inferior perception accuracy for graphical
structures, whether in zero/few-shot settings or with supervised fine-tuning
(SFT), which further affects problem-solving performance; 3) DPR significantly
improves the multi-step graph reasoning capabilities of LMMs and the GPT-4V
(DPR) agent achieves SOTA performance.
|
[
-0.3893209993839264,
-0.7935711145401001,
0.8852396011352539,
0.03470311313867569,
-0.11615210026502609,
0.27002108097076416,
0.18629878759384155,
-0.4819526970386505,
0.028472378849983215,
0.4518669545650482,
-0.518827497959137,
-0.4664982557296753,
-0.5206360816955566,
0.09113223105669022,
-0.13073597848415375,
0.502530574798584,
-0.23122650384902954,
0.17539776861667633,
-0.30883491039276123,
-0.1556699126958847,
-0.33089399337768555,
-0.20506992936134338,
-0.6832076907157898,
-0.3822527527809143,
0.8574537038803101,
0.1380564421415329,
0.7145294547080994,
0.5521166920661926,
0.8007298111915588,
0.3950310945510864,
0.09316609054803848,
0.40302416682243347,
-0.31662485003471375,
-0.11832057684659958,
-0.14647908508777618,
-0.29799917340278625,
-0.7330285906791687,
-0.147187739610672,
0.7295547723770142,
0.7732604146003723,
0.20498627424240112,
0.002403868827968836,
-0.15732648968696594,
0.8165424466133118,
-0.64716637134552,
0.8631364703178406,
-0.13822034001350403,
0.056155022233724594,
-0.06238448619842529,
-0.17602357268333435,
-0.3981531262397766,
-0.12332760542631149,
-0.040015798062086105,
-0.7544171214103699,
-0.03708331659436226,
0.27033036947250366,
0.6199989318847656,
0.1985497772693634,
-0.7023211717605591,
0.11958422511816025,
-0.5996717810630798,
0.3401896357536316,
-0.28586193919181824,
0.44437646865844727,
-0.06124003976583481,
0.6707260608673096,
-0.22388815879821777,
-0.9441913366317749,
-0.5547335743904114,
-0.23728927969932556,
0.018237512558698654,
0.2905183434486389,
-0.14012444019317627,
0.5215780735015869,
0.623406171798706,
0.0507674403488636,
-0.678379237651825,
-0.1925555169582367,
-0.3900229334831238,
-0.43539783358573914,
0.4056284725666046,
0.33153626322746277,
-0.000020332321582827717,
-0.24233566224575043,
-0.44016727805137634,
-0.32431069016456604,
-0.42788875102996826,
0.09196010231971741,
0.1475980579853058,
0.2566782534122467,
0.14135390520095825,
0.5363101959228516,
-0.3604736924171448,
0.9818248748779297,
-0.38167378306388855,
-0.2416643500328064,
0.4071214199066162,
-0.5341630578041077,
-0.1818075180053711,
-0.2534022331237793,
0.6286516785621643,
0.6420917510986328,
0.3712243139743805,
0.221376433968544,
-0.06256688386201859,
0.44888246059417725,
0.05826124921441078,
-0.8556088805198669,
-0.3782525956630707,
0.06800524890422821,
-0.4021667242050171,
-0.11630301177501678,
-0.14323407411575317,
-0.6983029246330261,
-0.4260150194168091,
-0.3647429943084717,
0.5329079627990723,
-0.6254734992980957,
-0.19392041862010956,
0.09629420191049576,
-0.40882882475852966,
-0.10323081910610199,
0.5978173017501831,
-0.4374684989452362,
0.21343810856342316,
0.5331254601478577,
0.7156808376312256,
0.013919527642428875,
-0.5376582145690918,
-0.4620124399662018,
0.3565491735935211,
-0.3736364245414734,
0.6314281225204468,
-0.560850977897644,
-0.07859276980161667,
-0.2905559837818146,
-0.12798576056957245,
-0.24216137826442719,
-0.3344902992248535,
0.2858739495277405,
-0.27782419323921204,
-0.2873818576335907,
-0.3816758990287781,
-0.37933212518692017,
-0.5247704982757568,
0.7479829788208008,
-0.5977944135665894,
0.6939977407455444,
0.06195046007633209,
-0.7650651931762695,
0.34498289227485657,
-0.7070894241333008,
-0.4113159775733948,
0.11242811381816864,
-0.3381754755973816,
-0.16502268612384796,
-0.17127738893032074,
0.30111590027809143,
0.4073525369167328,
-0.08523036539554596,
0.13563299179077148,
-0.4164700210094452,
-0.35628756880760193,
0.12505142390727997,
-0.25555557012557983,
0.5330385565757751,
0.19069834053516388,
-0.09063149988651276,
0.3560963571071625,
-0.7647150158882141,
0.21044571697711945,
0.30250054597854614,
-0.018248628824949265,
-0.0029211738146841526,
-0.06024142727255821,
-0.2367117702960968,
0.24341082572937012,
0.2314205765724182,
-0.4326109290122986,
0.14905180037021637,
0.0020106479059904814,
0.6821731328964233,
0.7697431445121765,
-0.20426584780216217,
0.04459329694509506,
-0.059712085872888565,
0.36256229877471924,
0.12705178558826447,
0.44383886456489563,
-0.5091387629508972,
-0.6325443983078003,
-0.6055119037628174,
-0.3563994765281677,
0.09140538424253464,
0.47605210542678833,
-1.11268949508667,
-0.22185282409191132,
-0.17922039330005646,
-0.40350276231765747,
0.136068657040596,
-0.21791639924049377,
0.5099310278892517,
0.6040329933166504,
0.47865086793899536,
-0.43534544110298157,
-0.2536485195159912,
-0.8073303699493408,
-0.15421074628829956,
-0.21384385228157043,
0.37332218885421753,
0.5028236508369446,
0.6204338669776917,
-0.25964513421058655,
0.797971785068512,
-0.8651949763298035,
-0.32311269640922546,
-0.34286826848983765,
-0.04721301421523094,
0.12350580096244812,
0.1372978240251541,
0.4918992519378662,
-0.805045485496521,
-0.42164257168769836,
-0.058536700904369354,
-0.8593802452087402,
0.1174900084733963,
0.16504794359207153,
-0.012108133174479008,
-0.09785124659538269,
0.46814852952957153,
-0.7348813414573669,
0.32155948877334595,
0.5287305116653442,
-0.402658611536026,
0.5718545317649841,
-0.36823105812072754,
0.16639943420886993,
-0.6338678002357483,
0.014828000217676163,
0.34268125891685486,
-0.38326147198677063,
-0.3694400191307068,
0.16724780201911926,
0.03863802179694176,
-0.45148876309394836,
-0.17618989944458008,
0.3275330662727356,
-0.3845230042934418,
-0.395108163356781,
0.014451193623244762,
0.31930556893348694,
0.161733016371727,
0.6093230247497559,
-0.28659260272979736,
0.5059193968772888,
0.7201958894729614,
-0.4578263759613037,
0.7594122290611267,
0.07485531270503998,
-0.2798197567462921,
0.6195728182792664,
-0.5248812437057495,
-0.1003604605793953,
-0.3599032163619995,
0.513096809387207,
-1.162977933883667,
-0.060209501534700394,
0.3785957992076874,
-0.172041654586792,
0.17359887063503265,
-0.08560729771852493,
-0.565228283405304,
-0.6493016481399536,
0.039943378418684006,
0.42962393164634705,
0.13985706865787506,
-0.24140603840351105,
0.765679121017456,
0.16321539878845215,
0.20596618950366974,
-0.49538448452949524,
-0.24411416053771973,
0.12840156257152557,
0.054809872061014175,
-0.792106032371521,
0.21910430490970612,
-0.013896899297833443,
-0.23951761424541473,
-0.059269730001688004,
-0.1196063756942749,
0.062217626720666885,
-0.18637700378894806,
0.16879479587078094,
0.22634704411029816,
0.16993913054466248,
0.02911754697561264,
-0.22719261050224304,
-0.5357184410095215,
0.046325892210006714,
-0.27867504954338074,
0.44946131110191345,
-0.2843697965145111,
-0.5615801215171814,
-0.35684287548065186,
0.11276096105575562,
0.6390609741210938,
-0.5345338582992554,
0.23294496536254883,
0.693455696105957,
-0.09660811722278595,
-0.10293664783239365,
-0.26535704731941223,
-0.2035786211490631,
-0.4613192081451416,
0.5520333647727966,
-0.745649516582489,
-0.6177987456321716,
0.3233921229839325,
-0.4580782651901245,
-0.2543734312057495,
0.23240864276885986,
0.2506083846092224,
-0.1475963443517685,
1.4247225522994995,
0.5312088131904602,
0.28102561831474304,
0.5526964068412781,
-0.49061331152915955,
0.14226427674293518,
-0.622486412525177,
-0.30201563239097595,
-0.0728401392698288,
-0.4345535337924957,
-0.416171133518219,
-0.6177130937576294,
0.7065848708152771,
-0.04542703181505203,
-0.45138025283813477,
0.2978637218475342,
-0.5441431999206543,
0.3119369447231293,
0.5011965036392212,
0.34225034713745117,
0.4066305458545685,
0.0032121571712195873,
-0.38403818011283875,
0.057008806616067886,
-0.7763316631317139,
-0.15469947457313538,
0.863235354423523,
0.20184804499149323,
0.6994412541389465,
-0.08747947961091995,
0.294762521982193,
0.08431479334831238,
-0.033427391201257706,
-0.5186061859130859,
0.9040100574493408,
-0.16861799359321594,
-0.4804956614971161,
-0.21330636739730835,
-0.6779270172119141,
-0.6889241933822632,
0.48953887820243835,
-0.1741349697113037,
-0.6214287877082825,
-0.06691483408212662,
0.4532321095466614,
-0.041430361568927765,
0.216048002243042,
-0.7155812382698059,
1.2063581943511963,
-0.3221842050552368,
-0.39736807346343994,
-0.32859259843826294,
-0.7568413615226746,
0.23497407138347626,
0.26055702567100525,
0.3350984752178192,
-0.35860076546669006,
0.22159774601459503,
0.3595423102378845,
-0.3996754288673401,
0.7782363295555115,
-0.43789979815483093,
0.1966191828250885,
0.3928481340408325,
0.15833905339241028,
0.5816700458526611,
-0.21160602569580078,
0.20647509396076202,
0.23832890391349792,
0.15004494786262512,
-0.20714057981967926,
-0.6185910105705261,
0.4309464693069458,
-0.618301272392273,
-0.4522831439971924,
-0.31507161259651184,
-0.7696730494499207,
-0.20414911210536957,
0.48876380920410156,
0.01791575737297535,
0.6404227614402771,
0.15493857860565186,
-0.03506975993514061,
0.29309073090553284,
-0.0044649564661085606,
0.292295902967453,
0.12926320731639862,
-0.5200549960136414,
-0.3137141168117523,
0.997017502784729,
0.20137643814086914,
0.3684939742088318,
0.48441529273986816,
0.2899499833583832,
-0.24184563755989075,
-0.4978208541870117,
-0.5837036967277527,
0.13873787224292755,
-1.0088430643081665,
-0.002183235250413418,
-0.5750057101249695,
-0.0773705318570137,
-0.1525244414806366,
0.10569442063570023,
-0.40681615471839905,
-0.37007197737693787,
0.1991739571094513,
0.090878926217556,
0.1771591603755951,
0.4131122827529907,
0.05506683513522148,
0.04865744709968567,
-0.4930184483528137,
0.4373379349708557,
0.46190038323402405,
0.3590085506439209,
-0.12273678928613663,
0.10668821632862091,
-0.16728147864341736,
0.038340792059898376,
-0.4886486530303955,
-0.5698378086090088,
0.028593966737389565,
-0.02874612994492054,
0.493308961391449,
0.3794136047363281,
-0.10827424377202988,
0.9384840726852417,
-0.49498504400253296,
0.48866912722587585,
0.41657567024230957,
-0.8484774827957153,
0.5046187043190002,
-0.4523157775402069,
0.13130328059196472,
0.12751327455043793,
0.11506018042564392,
-0.20573729276657104,
-0.15675587952136993,
-0.3727077841758728,
-0.5392404198646545,
0.35664620995521545,
0.199998676776886,
-0.3176814019680023,
0.13321250677108765,
0.26943641901016235,
-0.2291395366191864,
0.34405267238616943,
-0.5743340849876404,
-0.13237856328487396,
-0.47412988543510437,
-0.21943533420562744,
-0.2619020938873291,
-0.059096042066812515,
-0.368927925825119,
-0.3302340805530548,
0.13387545943260193,
-0.6777986288070679,
0.31094110012054443,
0.17289556562900543,
0.061000797897577286,
-0.01579935848712921,
-0.094121053814888,
0.4923664927482605,
1.2159535884857178,
-0.04224007949233055,
0.40395382046699524,
-0.018593009561300278,
-0.2683916687965393,
-0.047055330127477646,
0.20173250138759613,
0.044899117201566696,
-0.31563130021095276,
0.5558664798736572,
0.8801004886627197,
0.03833428770303726,
-0.7429900169372559,
0.6516963839530945,
0.2324899435043335,
-0.2140488177537918,
-0.06602095812559128,
0.19267435371875763,
0.07416759431362152,
0.6232627630233765,
0.1363310068845749,
0.21719248592853546,
0.17469283938407898,
-0.5604270696640015,
0.013649122789502144,
0.49393385648727417,
-0.3757599890232086,
-0.1930181086063385,
0.8788498640060425,
0.1254575252532959,
-0.03508201241493225,
0.7026171684265137,
0.03370211645960808,
-0.5239953994750977,
0.8467257022857666,
0.512626051902771,
0.32752135396003723,
0.1413906067609787,
0.2462121844291687,
0.39189767837524414,
0.16045448184013367,
-0.07588064670562744,
0.3221375346183777,
0.0031443405896425247,
-0.9655477404594421,
-0.60200434923172,
-0.22321617603302002,
-0.5638108253479004,
-0.574119508266449,
-0.35181304812431335,
0.15579873323440552,
-0.6243444085121155,
-0.390139102935791,
0.1575719565153122,
-0.08622028678655624,
-0.5181546807289124,
0.32516875863075256,
0.17307429015636444,
0.692628800868988,
-0.5757966041564941,
0.5717881917953491,
0.6784096360206604,
-0.4575626850128174,
-0.7655275464057922,
-0.4799266457557678,
0.06009634584188461,
-0.9905228614807129,
0.7996227145195007,
0.3504866063594818,
-0.3524746298789978,
0.12530513107776642,
-0.47731447219848633,
-0.6987614631652832,
1.3256382942199707,
0.40473756194114685,
-0.5716957449913025,
0.12016881257295609,
0.023272912949323654,
0.36723122000694275,
-0.354984849691391,
0.18678230047225952,
0.27197137475013733,
0.6008566617965698,
0.5149064660072327,
-0.9562948942184448,
0.0804126113653183,
-0.05558374524116516,
0.08092725276947021,
0.3547394871711731,
-0.9749563336372375,
1.2450810670852661,
-0.4939972162246704,
0.1137656643986702,
-0.24248580634593964,
0.19234319031238556,
0.500362753868103,
0.5566084980964661,
0.6267107129096985,
0.6123276948928833,
0.5548644661903381,
-0.20660990476608276,
1.0637321472167969,
-0.3852308392524719,
0.30699265003204346,
0.7044944167137146,
-0.4126949906349182,
0.3824792206287384,
0.3422102630138397,
-0.254905104637146,
0.4898746907711029,
0.42581048607826233,
-0.06660120189189911,
0.3977755904197693,
0.1874573826789856,
0.06832973659038544,
-0.4809201955795288,
-0.07039614021778107,
-0.38528895378112793,
0.6518183350563049,
0.27638721466064453,
-0.3399040400981903,
-0.18454204499721527,
0.031832389533519745,
-0.1037970706820488,
-0.16877640783786774,
-0.5283620357513428,
0.39155441522598267,
0.03996976837515831,
-0.4452488124370575,
0.17093978822231293,
0.02734137326478958,
-0.015423699282109737,
-0.6113043427467346,
-0.29728272557258606,
0.011611946858465672,
0.582257866859436,
-0.15191558003425598,
-0.837308943271637,
0.028179310262203217,
-0.46505001187324524,
-0.0028560073114931583,
-0.357209175825119,
0.7014066576957703,
-0.08920817822217941,
-0.5110102295875549,
0.4063122570514679,
0.5171535015106201,
0.08607082813978195,
-0.24547377228736877,
-0.6412084698677063,
0.2608467638492584,
-0.10653288662433624,
-0.0029209780041128397,
0.22841013967990875,
0.47309479117393494,
-0.14847585558891296,
1.054880976676941,
0.6167617440223694,
-0.09717653691768646,
-0.034516215324401855,
0.1729625165462494,
1.0614711046218872,
-0.7205027937889099,
-0.5518590211868286,
-0.8985929489135742,
0.3957890272140503,
-0.1845148503780365,
-0.10511014610528946,
0.8381282687187195,
0.5713618397712708,
0.6968962550163269,
0.09855959564447403,
0.5813961029052734,
-0.05766745284199715,
0.13315999507904053,
-0.5633037686347961,
0.21062681078910828,
-0.7387653589248657,
-0.03152910992503166,
-0.6098302602767944,
-1.064631700515747,
-0.456024169921875,
0.7771397829055786,
-0.24216172099113464,
0.2782934010028839,
0.9029176831245422,
0.6906985640525818,
0.015447701327502728,
-0.15250588953495026,
0.3480619490146637,
0.16693377494812012,
0.5317563414573669,
0.7131829857826233,
0.7926751375198364,
-0.2452818751335144,
0.8566780090332031,
-0.18521372973918915,
-0.30107542872428894,
-0.032608646899461746,
-0.8054354190826416,
-0.8558748364448547,
-0.31908729672431946,
-0.37440618872642517,
-0.27646979689598083,
-0.09657111018896103,
0.40025943517684937,
0.7577740550041199,
-0.19181661307811737,
-0.18113701045513153,
-0.17792321741580963,
0.22582177817821503,
-0.6709485650062561,
-0.15555834770202637,
0.3669322431087494,
-0.020702412351965904,
-0.6106476187705994,
0.3912423253059387,
0.6983368992805481,
-0.0774792805314064,
-0.38812941312789917,
-0.1196589320898056,
0.04397530108690262,
-0.2622152268886566,
0.8522606492042542,
0.06476821005344391,
-0.5444346070289612,
-0.5077379941940308,
-0.15307068824768066,
0.0002849322045221925,
0.1566823422908783,
0.8576573133468628,
-0.7217327356338501,
0.813981831073761,
0.5508228540420532,
0.040813885629177094,
0.9084308743476868,
0.03082481026649475,
0.33661842346191406,
-0.3938080370426178,
0.33431509137153625,
0.03444880247116089,
0.5813579559326172,
0.2093680202960968,
0.038122233003377914,
0.6001484990119934,
0.6066489815711975,
-0.34277984499931335,
-0.5586844086647034,
0.6166302561759949,
-1.1296859979629517,
-0.3060460388660431,
0.893600344657898,
-0.08320238441228867,
-0.21312502026557922,
0.08675714582204819,
-0.3504529297351837,
0.18209458887577057,
-0.12130524963140488,
0.35392332077026367,
0.37791675329208374,
-0.65854412317276,
-0.5822722315788269,
-0.6435752511024475,
0.23254142701625824,
-0.005046856123954058,
-0.7554765939712524,
-0.1539885699748993,
0.7209409475326538,
0.19644895195960999,
0.2378082275390625,
0.8663241267204285,
-0.0152024757117033,
0.0526360459625721,
0.5346211194992065,
-0.13400402665138245,
-0.6481065154075623,
-0.6637641787528992,
0.31700214743614197,
0.46336641907691956,
-0.05100911483168602,
-0.36865687370300293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06701v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06701v1
|
Lightweight Spatial Modeling for Combinatorial Information Extraction From Documents
| 2024-05-08T10:10:38 | 2024-05-08T10:10:38 |
Yanfei Dong, Lambert Deng, Jiazheng Zhang, Xiaodong Yu, Ting Lin, Francesco Gelli, Soujanya Poria, Wee Sun Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Documents that consist of diverse templates and exhibit complex spatial
structures pose a challenge for document entity classification. We propose
KNN-former, which incorporates a new kind of spatial bias in attention
calculation based on the K-nearest-neighbor (KNN) graph of document entities.
We limit entities' attention only to their local radius defined by the KNN
graph. We also use combinatorial matching to address the one-to-one mapping
property that exists in many documents, where one field has only one
corresponding entity. Moreover, our method is highly parameter-efficient
compared to existing approaches in terms of the number of trainable parameters.
Despite this, experiments across various datasets show our method outperforms
baselines in most entity types. Many real-world documents exhibit combinatorial
properties which can be leveraged as inductive biases to improve extraction
accuracy, but existing datasets do not cover these documents. To facilitate
future research into these types of documents, we release a new ID document
dataset that covers diverse templates and languages. We also release enhanced
annotations for an existing dataset.
|
[
-0.4971541464328766,
-0.6524741053581238,
0.5973420143127441,
-0.058995913714170456,
-0.11344918608665466,
-0.28517523407936096,
-0.3466571271419525,
-0.5281904339790344,
0.2986406087875366,
0.5614151358604431,
-0.448234498500824,
-0.6924984455108643,
-0.7404128909111023,
-0.08218345046043396,
-0.34797126054763794,
0.8983710408210754,
-0.06793926656246185,
-0.014454079791903496,
-0.5154734253883362,
-0.47366824746131897,
-0.14763601124286652,
-0.4227154850959778,
-0.0008699272875674069,
-0.18362437188625336,
0.7636439204216003,
0.42339855432510376,
0.5357486605644226,
0.6047572493553162,
0.6696868538856506,
0.39229750633239746,
-0.0153795862570405,
-0.002000784734264016,
-0.5889058709144592,
0.02909175492823124,
-0.2641892731189728,
-0.5396936535835266,
-0.3215174078941345,
0.16378967463970184,
0.7189370393753052,
1.0999994277954102,
0.15587855875492096,
0.02202467806637287,
-0.324505090713501,
0.6155967116355896,
-0.5560935139656067,
0.33244290947914124,
-0.8350630402565002,
0.1787753403186798,
-0.7121057510375977,
-0.032082267105579376,
-0.35203516483306885,
-0.26360973715782166,
0.5193910598754883,
-1.0190168619155884,
0.5552940964698792,
0.2672305107116699,
1.06391179561615,
0.043792419135570526,
-0.5316603183746338,
-0.37495145201683044,
-0.705969512462616,
0.6202452778816223,
-0.3613913953304291,
0.7151979207992554,
0.6439434289932251,
0.2399442195892334,
-0.19249330461025238,
-0.6856886744499207,
-0.42383888363838196,
0.08054108917713165,
-0.16642163693904877,
0.2932770550251007,
0.034536562860012054,
-0.37287813425064087,
0.45460745692253113,
0.16656945645809174,
-0.6195172667503357,
0.09957583993673325,
-0.4731844365596771,
0.17165830731391907,
0.23998887836933136,
0.0204376969486475,
0.25469574332237244,
-0.3876170814037323,
-0.21182452142238617,
-0.08828209340572357,
-0.5149160623550415,
-0.24806708097457886,
0.44301360845565796,
0.3064347803592682,
-0.04934681951999664,
0.5387470722198486,
-0.14456695318222046,
0.5258356928825378,
0.20667734742164612,
-0.37701407074928284,
0.24574242532253265,
-0.32539308071136475,
0.04839580878615379,
0.03408936411142349,
0.5345922112464905,
0.3092013895511627,
-0.07435775548219681,
-0.6782660484313965,
0.09646771103143692,
-0.10784953087568283,
0.44264325499534607,
-0.632845938205719,
-0.5643283724784851,
-0.21854914724826813,
-0.6822707653045654,
-0.25165876746177673,
0.22770000994205475,
-1.168298363685608,
-0.27834492921829224,
-0.39537400007247925,
-0.10166119784116745,
-0.6152799129486084,
-0.14253193140029907,
-0.4010903239250183,
-0.3204008638858795,
0.04865255579352379,
0.4415735900402069,
-0.9309541583061218,
0.2548975944519043,
0.6598562002182007,
0.8836052417755127,
-0.3641701638698578,
-0.36368194222450256,
-0.1302196979522705,
0.299360066652298,
-0.11788593977689743,
1.081849455833435,
-0.86668461561203,
-0.41280627250671387,
-0.20165406167507172,
-0.054296910762786865,
-0.09547664225101471,
-0.5515345931053162,
0.6327024698257446,
-0.7383318543434143,
0.25081002712249756,
-0.5275653004646301,
-0.3619377613067627,
-0.09421630948781967,
0.29698899388313293,
-0.9890544414520264,
1.2797911167144775,
0.8494786024093628,
-1.0842230319976807,
0.8196848630905151,
-0.4676179885864258,
-0.4541410505771637,
0.20409701764583588,
-0.29605168104171753,
-0.6085184812545776,
-0.017698900774121284,
0.214877650141716,
0.009776015765964985,
-0.09022802114486694,
0.08455850929021835,
-0.746238648891449,
-0.11987285315990448,
0.0023958582896739244,
0.10488296300172806,
0.6186491250991821,
0.15591886639595032,
-0.1446680873632431,
-0.026498189195990562,
-0.8852000832557678,
-0.21657578647136688,
0.2599033713340759,
-0.4477466940879822,
-0.8539848327636719,
-0.11745499819517136,
0.12056682258844376,
0.42459210753440857,
0.23108495771884918,
-0.6462793350219727,
0.42232486605644226,
-0.44768470525741577,
0.09668788313865662,
0.6121257543563843,
0.032925624400377274,
1.2637361288070679,
-0.33132076263427734,
0.4534309506416321,
0.162673220038414,
-0.11090395599603653,
0.12283636629581451,
-0.3243730068206787,
-0.4278889298439026,
-0.5851043462753296,
0.517582893371582,
0.3348185122013092,
-0.6508844494819641,
0.503111720085144,
-0.8323391675949097,
-0.633202850818634,
-0.1276175081729889,
0.11609131097793579,
0.08193155378103256,
0.7484594583511353,
-0.11305741220712662,
-0.24121011793613434,
-0.6804604530334473,
-0.8274452686309814,
-0.026866650208830833,
0.11910754442214966,
0.19812551140785217,
0.8207391500473022,
0.529212236404419,
-0.26051661372184753,
1.0127434730529785,
-0.5493432879447937,
-0.32611992955207825,
-0.06883968412876129,
0.23438718914985657,
0.11755754053592682,
0.2655874788761139,
0.8319019079208374,
-1.0658494234085083,
-0.575931966304779,
0.2903837561607361,
-0.7464955449104309,
-0.07880493253469467,
-0.08896256983280182,
-0.6579286456108093,
-0.039225053042173386,
0.3385733664035797,
-0.8146846890449524,
0.5941920876502991,
-0.04184401035308838,
-0.05380980297923088,
0.27025914192199707,
0.010893089696764946,
-0.05691133812069893,
-0.8392382860183716,
0.16073530912399292,
0.06021733582019806,
0.005626368802040815,
-0.3595500886440277,
0.1853780448436737,
0.13589371740818024,
-0.36793583631515503,
-0.08760806918144226,
0.7175507545471191,
-0.5576646327972412,
-0.6234596371650696,
0.04065115004777908,
0.4608428478240967,
0.06905998289585114,
0.6018659472465515,
0.06668456643819809,
0.41055232286453247,
0.2479867786169052,
-0.3318689167499542,
0.07905274629592896,
0.5089799165725708,
-0.5360832810401917,
0.6902070045471191,
-0.08574070036411285,
0.1817333996295929,
-0.4738975465297699,
0.39097487926483154,
-0.7620785236358643,
-0.218349426984787,
0.2557384669780731,
-0.20548832416534424,
0.431047648191452,
-0.3531099557876587,
-0.8195322751998901,
-0.5388157367706299,
-0.2995888590812683,
0.3464600741863251,
-0.04376804828643799,
-0.6941768527030945,
0.8343213796615601,
0.3745654225349426,
-0.3064277172088623,
-0.026412002742290497,
-0.4091953933238983,
-0.3082374036312103,
-0.27922025322914124,
-0.6547257900238037,
0.4099999666213989,
0.04641970247030258,
-0.163019597530365,
0.3992389142513275,
-0.2339174449443817,
-0.30185413360595703,
0.21385417878627777,
0.5630862712860107,
0.3169473707675934,
-0.036687638610601425,
-0.10829854756593704,
0.0033072172664105892,
-0.12622009217739105,
-0.11659218370914459,
-0.44718050956726074,
0.4611952304840088,
0.36762526631355286,
-0.18620270490646362,
0.1318274736404419,
0.8324667811393738,
0.5935542583465576,
-0.40333548188209534,
0.5134937763214111,
0.6810265779495239,
-0.6430550217628479,
-0.2137964367866516,
-0.3085082769393921,
0.013137412257492542,
-0.4108547270298004,
0.5117203593254089,
-0.5499942898750305,
-0.6226449012756348,
0.7272122502326965,
-0.30240169167518616,
0.116180419921875,
0.3203795254230499,
0.3008056879043579,
-0.24559609591960907,
0.732926607131958,
0.4325542747974396,
-0.09014799445867538,
0.8514634966850281,
-0.2987987697124481,
0.4473694860935211,
-0.9337100386619568,
-0.456684410572052,
-0.8633787035942078,
-0.5321491360664368,
-0.33893707394599915,
-0.154121533036232,
0.44442474842071533,
0.2361328899860382,
0.11694664508104324,
0.294149249792099,
-0.5095317363739014,
0.3554261326789856,
0.8265522718429565,
0.04447872191667557,
-0.22930610179901123,
0.333231121301651,
-0.36729684472084045,
-0.5500571727752686,
-0.7779785990715027,
-0.16957396268844604,
1.0839561223983765,
-0.04817228019237518,
0.4421076774597168,
0.29645177721977234,
0.7865424156188965,
0.008455733768641949,
0.6120932102203369,
-0.5034292340278625,
0.3874509036540985,
-0.3108946681022644,
-0.5109468102455139,
-0.22421492636203766,
-0.5894994735717773,
-1.154105544090271,
0.3145614266395569,
-0.21131600439548492,
-1.0187968015670776,
0.40536248683929443,
-0.33699163794517517,
-0.06408772617578506,
0.3113328218460083,
-0.8042869567871094,
0.7653254866600037,
-0.20182110369205475,
-0.10083737969398499,
0.3417273461818695,
-0.3354887366294861,
0.25593823194503784,
-0.28382542729377747,
0.12623611092567444,
0.054413195699453354,
0.16254964470863342,
0.7238540053367615,
-0.5718332529067993,
0.47746574878692627,
-0.17999987304210663,
0.1912088841199875,
0.05612755939364433,
0.18798604607582092,
0.8182240128517151,
-0.09807579964399338,
-0.2468828707933426,
0.18022117018699646,
-0.12584057450294495,
-0.44642770290374756,
-0.8480960726737976,
0.9568373560905457,
-0.8400250673294067,
-0.18468546867370605,
-0.32758572697639465,
-0.869437038898468,
-0.015297156758606434,
0.6766127943992615,
0.5674487352371216,
0.5078381896018982,
0.09162213653326035,
0.18942031264305115,
0.6376421451568604,
0.25503188371658325,
0.2880061864852905,
0.510281503200531,
-0.050279825925827026,
-0.5329726338386536,
0.9428196549415588,
0.7027711868286133,
-0.3832254707813263,
0.5862302780151367,
0.07130082696676254,
-0.4021282196044922,
-0.7246121168136597,
-0.14332853257656097,
0.14767423272132874,
-0.8796422481536865,
-0.19908376038074493,
-1.1231167316436768,
0.017863940447568893,
-0.6320470571517944,
-0.5403692722320557,
-0.06271540373563766,
-0.35544058680534363,
-0.47600576281547546,
-0.17777955532073975,
0.11077003180980682,
0.7128660082817078,
0.2678457796573639,
0.2059045135974884,
-0.6351369023323059,
0.41474926471710205,
0.09573223441839218,
0.36597898602485657,
0.1785997748374939,
-0.20297974348068237,
-0.26960787177085876,
-0.4583152234554291,
-0.0662161260843277,
-0.9905903339385986,
0.2771390378475189,
-0.10625573247671127,
0.8474417924880981,
0.4566572308540344,
0.11506711691617966,
0.6631325483322144,
-0.4092331826686859,
0.41470059752464294,
-0.06584221124649048,
-0.3869435787200928,
0.6041712164878845,
-0.6859138607978821,
0.4428900182247162,
0.8008360862731934,
0.39461883902549744,
-0.28070902824401855,
-0.13078109920024872,
-0.8209099173545837,
-1.0786885023117065,
0.9823740124702454,
0.0896533951163292,
-0.49941912293434143,
-0.12358853220939636,
0.5341958403587341,
0.23667386174201965,
-0.019968267530202866,
-0.643886148929596,
-0.16638870537281036,
-0.15225109457969666,
-0.4024618864059448,
0.4321306645870209,
-0.27338728308677673,
-0.01569523848593235,
-0.07548803091049194,
0.49842315912246704,
0.13043609261512756,
0.2569263279438019,
0.3136485517024994,
-0.45305031538009644,
-0.02461332269012928,
-0.06151958554983139,
0.5759995579719543,
0.5688005685806274,
-0.45425868034362793,
0.1632365882396698,
0.01158708706498146,
-0.5147625207901001,
-0.2627139985561371,
0.44131696224212646,
-0.6860527396202087,
0.22366644442081451,
0.47024857997894287,
0.4635511636734009,
0.6673535704612732,
-0.162494957447052,
0.43695610761642456,
-0.09473800659179688,
-0.2916103005409241,
-0.23261713981628418,
-0.18565410375595093,
-0.16491428017616272,
0.09778081625699997,
0.08198835700750351,
0.29705438017845154,
0.2737133800983429,
-0.2294355034828186,
0.35566484928131104,
0.28992465138435364,
-0.30239138007164,
-0.29082247614860535,
0.4941558241844177,
0.15709160268306732,
-0.27100610733032227,
0.7439782619476318,
-0.6710472702980042,
-0.500159502029419,
0.5890284180641174,
0.5767094492912292,
0.6545953750610352,
0.3481076657772064,
-0.007330203428864479,
0.48144030570983887,
0.17959758639335632,
0.21452341973781586,
0.060988906770944595,
-0.3738833963871002,
-0.49743250012397766,
0.2698977291584015,
-0.4116784632205963,
0.030940428376197815,
0.09608668833971024,
-0.6390242576599121,
-0.009317616932094097,
-0.6413364410400391,
-0.23874932527542114,
0.3137870728969574,
0.2872426211833954,
-0.9041129946708679,
-0.1542118489742279,
-0.030402664095163345,
0.7515527009963989,
-0.5356633067131042,
0.8769249320030212,
0.92603600025177,
-0.3609600365161896,
-0.415151983499527,
-0.28025197982788086,
0.0012028507189825177,
-0.20346149802207947,
0.743631899356842,
0.12036067992448807,
0.35115277767181396,
-0.23305743932724,
-0.4574180841445923,
-1.150233268737793,
1.2672048807144165,
0.09627839922904968,
-0.6435431241989136,
-0.3362220227718353,
-0.06284065544605255,
0.17866526544094086,
-0.4058128297328949,
0.10015806555747986,
0.24117018282413483,
0.5716041326522827,
-0.2564700245857239,
-0.34418579936027527,
-0.19962064921855927,
-0.45326685905456543,
0.15972767770290375,
0.5408350229263306,
-0.48545220494270325,
0.753602921962738,
0.10024101287126541,
-0.36091724038124084,
0.13928693532943726,
0.5822275280952454,
0.22152218222618103,
0.3759361505508423,
0.548852264881134,
1.0450953245162964,
1.0996936559677124,
-0.2469908595085144,
1.264288306236267,
-0.08294888585805893,
0.21952925622463226,
1.5747877359390259,
-0.6720132827758789,
0.48668041825294495,
0.3062410056591034,
-0.1100369244813919,
0.420984148979187,
0.5251944661140442,
-0.18771541118621826,
0.7741920948028564,
0.019788948819041252,
-0.009949380531907082,
0.037401918321847916,
-0.2249521166086197,
-0.1437448263168335,
0.30198946595191956,
0.26671966910362244,
-0.28828057646751404,
-0.4657537639141083,
-0.0456961914896965,
0.008520552888512611,
0.24717845022678375,
-0.07515092939138412,
0.7986558675765991,
-0.21514780819416046,
-0.46389085054397583,
-0.29726091027259827,
0.18907548487186432,
0.4670352637767792,
-0.5361747741699219,
-0.03871290013194084,
-0.2789415121078491,
0.015295601449906826,
-0.16859450936317444,
-0.5000014305114746,
0.04487001523375511,
-0.21709668636322021,
-0.9682436585426331,
-0.05628829076886177,
0.9337354898452759,
-0.49672114849090576,
-0.6401864290237427,
0.261494517326355,
0.11372247338294983,
0.03581655025482178,
0.07667860388755798,
-0.6028663516044617,
0.08026008307933807,
-0.13844868540763855,
0.06173247843980789,
0.49221739172935486,
0.911078691482544,
-0.36923855543136597,
0.30808889865875244,
0.9953832626342773,
0.14644934237003326,
0.4153987169265747,
0.17806828022003174,
0.8677479028701782,
-0.5368449091911316,
-0.8712239265441895,
-0.2984839975833893,
0.11093495786190033,
-0.4367842376232147,
-0.38760316371917725,
0.7591053247451782,
0.8225283622741699,
0.8639246821403503,
0.0483209565281868,
0.6162004470825195,
0.11654813587665558,
0.3849721848964691,
-0.31172242760658264,
0.6323640942573547,
-0.15030530095100403,
0.0018087381031364202,
-0.42387527227401733,
-1.1654455661773682,
-0.15128956735134125,
0.5901706218719482,
-0.6596453189849854,
0.06519150733947754,
0.7387481927871704,
0.5300635099411011,
-0.2786126136779785,
-0.05142168328166008,
0.0680091455578804,
-0.053737103939056396,
0.370802104473114,
0.3654525578022003,
0.5627874732017517,
-0.442819207906723,
0.6169356107711792,
-0.6046386361122131,
0.04530274122953415,
-0.2200697362422943,
-0.6110875606536865,
-0.8511209487915039,
-0.6930053234100342,
-0.3111124038696289,
-0.26786309480667114,
-0.20207224786281586,
0.3916885256767273,
1.1389151811599731,
-0.5352292656898499,
0.6058996319770813,
0.04259872809052467,
0.39178383350372314,
0.18644732236862183,
-0.32529476284980774,
0.6022456884384155,
0.04414113983511925,
-0.5721762776374817,
0.2100512981414795,
0.6047266125679016,
0.06869906187057495,
0.13242483139038086,
-0.009763568639755249,
-0.4448736906051636,
-0.31134530901908875,
0.4097532033920288,
0.22086113691329956,
-0.6106647849082947,
-0.14511558413505554,
-0.1299561709165573,
-0.3629321753978729,
0.2197149097919464,
0.9217590689659119,
-0.43191367387771606,
0.5766630172729492,
0.569523274898529,
0.7322688698768616,
0.6829788684844971,
0.10258235037326813,
0.09278260916471481,
-0.9897254109382629,
0.510502815246582,
0.1851564645767212,
0.5923811197280884,
0.37482690811157227,
-0.6096004247665405,
0.4885018467903137,
0.4582487642765045,
-0.41979947686195374,
-0.6226022243499756,
0.09563241899013519,
-1.2050668001174927,
-0.21830418705940247,
0.8731279969215393,
-0.2610284388065338,
-0.6023954153060913,
-0.263264000415802,
-0.17144592106342316,
-0.03799082711338997,
-0.6129881143569946,
0.5260701775550842,
0.8292691111564636,
0.29277920722961426,
-0.2578578293323517,
-0.35895276069641113,
0.03288542106747627,
0.20652014017105103,
-0.8357818126678467,
-0.17050309479236603,
0.6300318241119385,
0.11730699241161346,
0.5025351643562317,
0.7222161293029785,
-0.4012394845485687,
0.3175126910209656,
0.32774561643600464,
-0.02542242780327797,
0.018991395831108093,
-0.5202664732933044,
-0.01520628947764635,
0.33466964960098267,
-0.13285060226917267,
0.06881370395421982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05294v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05294v1
|
Harmonizing Program Induction with Rate-Distortion Theory
| 2024-05-08T10:03:50 | 2024-05-08T10:03:50 |
Hanqi Zhou, David G. Nagy, Charley M. Wu
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.IT, cs.LG, cs.SC, math.IT, stat.ML
|
Many aspects of human learning have been proposed as a process of
constructing mental programs: from acquiring symbolic number representations to
intuitive theories about the world. In parallel, there is a long-tradition of
using information processing to model human cognition through Rate Distortion
Theory (RDT). Yet, it is still poorly understood how to apply RDT when mental
representations take the form of programs. In this work, we adapt RDT by
proposing a three way trade-off among rate (description length), distortion
(error), and computational costs (search budget). We use simulations on a
melody task to study the implications of this trade-off, and show that
constructing a shared program library across tasks provides global benefits.
However, this comes at the cost of sensitivity to curricula, which is also
characteristic of human learners. Finally, we use methods from partial
information decomposition to generate training curricula that induce more
effective libraries and better generalization.
|
[
-0.5361082553863525,
-0.4479047358036041,
0.25112223625183105,
0.3648333251476288,
-0.13200195133686066,
-0.12005192786455154,
-0.5724257826805115,
-0.6131721138954163,
0.17588946223258972,
0.04255025461316109,
-0.54618901014328,
0.1384698897600174,
-0.3283947706222534,
-0.002764596603810787,
-0.3562825620174408,
0.8981600999832153,
0.04673099145293236,
0.20621536672115326,
-0.1821153163909912,
0.2548890709877014,
-0.7117255926132202,
-0.5345216393470764,
-0.8633692860603333,
-0.6315178275108337,
0.3758006691932678,
0.1481805443763733,
0.43337559700012207,
0.4098561704158783,
0.6345607042312622,
0.08097571134567261,
0.25392067432403564,
-0.14601299166679382,
-0.48431137204170227,
0.004904713947325945,
-0.14122502505779266,
-0.7128656506538391,
-0.25830450654029846,
0.22900183498859406,
0.5910208225250244,
0.8545581698417664,
-0.21286089718341827,
0.0898936539888382,
0.4819728136062622,
0.7846363186836243,
-0.542156457901001,
0.5395878553390503,
-0.4869048595428467,
0.12550993263721466,
-0.12746025621891022,
-0.48213741183280945,
-0.4207442104816437,
-0.29446926712989807,
0.27042460441589355,
-0.7342759966850281,
0.6578097343444824,
-0.2800290584564209,
0.6682904958724976,
0.30769816040992737,
-0.06357168406248093,
-0.2682320475578308,
-0.8013744950294495,
0.9107576608657837,
-0.15203213691711426,
0.2699003219604492,
0.5123840570449829,
0.08233778923749924,
-0.15640495717525482,
-0.3611498475074768,
-0.4279034435749054,
0.04152575880289078,
0.08069083094596863,
0.33750179409980774,
-0.05853164568543434,
0.3052159547805786,
0.545204222202301,
0.5072765946388245,
-0.4714282155036926,
-0.44460105895996094,
-0.6813801527023315,
-0.15844014286994934,
0.5740980505943298,
0.2222125083208084,
0.2816627323627472,
-0.036174576729536057,
-0.22556257247924805,
-0.3503461480140686,
-0.5171088576316833,
0.0064904517494142056,
0.36180001497268677,
0.45100948214530945,
-0.17134268581867218,
0.33965593576431274,
0.013676127418875694,
0.8017549514770508,
0.10864263772964478,
0.13241957128047943,
0.22704732418060303,
-0.43380293250083923,
-0.11253093183040619,
0.08589977025985718,
0.44063466787338257,
0.28050994873046875,
0.21628566086292267,
-0.19453181326389313,
-0.15530836582183838,
0.6512486934661865,
0.7254250645637512,
-0.6598759889602661,
-0.15930233895778656,
-0.04309067502617836,
-0.4054897427558899,
-0.442139595746994,
0.127858966588974,
-0.5620496273040771,
-0.16621549427509308,
-0.6926100254058838,
0.5245282053947449,
-0.4760259687900543,
-0.1008794829249382,
0.4075160324573517,
-0.15216264128684998,
0.17246639728546143,
0.2144029587507248,
-0.9509832262992859,
0.4012572765350342,
0.4726030230522156,
0.920287549495697,
-0.2628859281539917,
-0.317034512758255,
-0.19800731539726257,
0.0799548476934433,
-0.1283000260591507,
0.4900383949279785,
-0.24499107897281647,
-0.524520993232727,
-0.1412835568189621,
-0.38532423973083496,
0.0671234056353569,
-0.5441374182701111,
0.5264416933059692,
-0.44652968645095825,
0.2604285180568695,
-0.47609806060791016,
-0.48196497559547424,
0.05015558376908302,
-0.017820080742239952,
-0.9837127923965454,
0.9630341529846191,
0.5828403234481812,
-1.0581284761428833,
0.39920955896377563,
-1.0480495691299438,
-0.7412082552909851,
-0.23455145955085754,
-0.0158671997487545,
-0.3362686336040497,
0.2205241173505783,
-0.04749014228582382,
0.07652925699949265,
-0.2831820845603943,
0.3698975145816803,
-0.13233239948749542,
-0.9140186309814453,
0.15206381678581238,
-0.5296348333358765,
1.0933377742767334,
0.37319889664649963,
-0.5493268966674805,
-0.3023749887943268,
-0.5898481011390686,
-0.17825524508953094,
-0.04037468880414963,
-0.7839375138282776,
-0.522926390171051,
-0.20401661098003387,
-0.07347992807626724,
0.15527229011058807,
-0.07707974314689636,
-0.38014447689056396,
0.4355192482471466,
-0.48158809542655945,
0.3177846670150757,
0.7312486171722412,
-0.052311353385448456,
0.6277048587799072,
-0.6299228668212891,
0.5222381949424744,
-0.07643809914588928,
0.3090553283691406,
0.2464866042137146,
-0.4619755148887634,
-0.748414933681488,
-0.03308398276567459,
-0.006959119811654091,
0.31630784273147583,
-0.6369429230690002,
0.1169838234782219,
-0.286316841840744,
0.09041015803813934,
-0.7189813256263733,
-0.021088676527142525,
0.23366302251815796,
0.09704211354255676,
0.4341910183429718,
-0.7533437013626099,
-0.862443208694458,
-0.4381486177444458,
-0.47187599539756775,
-0.2359548956155777,
-0.2106124758720398,
-0.041779741644859314,
0.1970479041337967,
0.19556038081645966,
0.782881498336792,
-0.3393101990222931,
-0.29625898599624634,
-0.25505128502845764,
0.1965319663286209,
0.2669229507446289,
0.4489060938358307,
0.24838168919086456,
-0.503160834312439,
-0.4037776589393616,
-0.4113575220108032,
-0.3420937657356262,
-0.1588207334280014,
-0.3537471294403076,
-0.3643086850643158,
0.12755070626735687,
-0.1725732982158661,
-0.5132513642311096,
0.6062279939651489,
0.35161563754081726,
-0.20338431000709534,
0.5701569318771362,
-0.05460098013281822,
0.02287602238357067,
-0.916205883026123,
-0.1480700969696045,
-0.0004905402893200517,
0.20882892608642578,
-0.420377254486084,
0.042633142322301865,
0.09975026547908783,
0.0714448019862175,
-0.0847974345088005,
0.33636295795440674,
-0.36736252903938293,
-0.3505944311618805,
-0.2654411792755127,
0.01676470972597599,
0.15410152077674866,
0.562975287437439,
-0.0628008022904396,
0.9053516983985901,
0.4138936400413513,
-0.6189433932304382,
0.2993105351924896,
0.04717964306473732,
-0.35256844758987427,
0.9021634459495544,
-0.33164462447166443,
-0.13235710561275482,
-0.13022133708000183,
0.34153813123703003,
-0.20104610919952393,
-0.25097328424453735,
0.15970319509506226,
-0.45289433002471924,
0.40103352069854736,
-0.1424952894449234,
-0.1837637573480606,
-0.32593172788619995,
-0.5014836192131042,
0.4965198338031769,
0.6517974734306335,
-0.47671762108802795,
0.2983316481113434,
0.12020418792963028,
0.35464218258857727,
-0.5919967293739319,
-0.7500892877578735,
-0.1537621170282364,
-0.3018365800380707,
-0.5385438799858093,
0.7435660362243652,
-0.19482554495334625,
-0.353298544883728,
0.13090632855892181,
-0.31894543766975403,
-0.10816486924886703,
0.19865985214710236,
0.4263269603252411,
0.5074552297592163,
-0.0032254804391413927,
0.17373546957969666,
-0.16986319422721863,
0.08974221348762512,
0.18449194729328156,
-0.7604517340660095,
0.5583489537239075,
-0.04175823926925659,
-0.4146602749824524,
-0.6070317625999451,
0.15889804065227509,
0.29901084303855896,
-0.1530056744813919,
0.5580028891563416,
0.7215391993522644,
-0.08225309103727341,
-0.26068761944770813,
-0.24123768508434296,
-0.3431238532066345,
-0.3608090877532959,
0.20910333096981049,
-0.2405100017786026,
-0.6295100450515747,
0.2878038287162781,
0.34175243973731995,
-0.020963484421372414,
0.04201404005289078,
0.6804423332214355,
0.08846397697925568,
0.7931317090988159,
0.4665254056453705,
-0.11440274119377136,
0.9719613194465637,
-0.5978088974952698,
0.14208604395389557,
-0.896976888179779,
-0.1320342868566513,
-0.38471344113349915,
-0.4098833501338959,
-0.19021090865135193,
-0.657569944858551,
0.31223204731941223,
0.1725306659936905,
-0.37303629517555237,
0.21417751908302307,
-0.5296233892440796,
0.5858866572380066,
1.1086509227752686,
0.3572935461997986,
0.3539700210094452,
0.4956044852733612,
0.09900977462530136,
0.07229930907487869,
-0.6264669895172119,
-0.009092136286199093,
1.4258922338485718,
-0.12595400214195251,
0.8780933618545532,
-0.059056494385004044,
1.1322963237762451,
0.3763449788093567,
0.413720041513443,
-0.8188040852546692,
0.08488558232784271,
0.0021452712826430798,
-0.6715388298034668,
-0.3264544606208801,
-0.6414167881011963,
-0.8884651064872742,
0.029480749741196632,
-0.09399455040693283,
-0.3790753483772278,
0.040249429643154144,
0.31068935990333557,
-0.20045015215873718,
0.24543441832065582,
-0.49640172719955444,
0.6288532614707947,
-0.07649744302034378,
-0.5006747245788574,
-0.5025410056114197,
-0.35731807351112366,
0.48238927125930786,
-0.17231488227844238,
0.31927743554115295,
0.03722053021192551,
0.5762534737586975,
0.7582249641418457,
-0.10797969251871109,
0.7396427989006042,
-0.3738004267215729,
0.13896219432353973,
0.492794930934906,
0.29953768849372864,
0.4256932735443115,
-0.03625931963324547,
-0.23175013065338135,
-0.055836793035268784,
-0.058093879371881485,
-0.6613264679908752,
-0.6603586673736572,
0.5090586543083191,
-0.936235785484314,
-0.33394119143486023,
-0.25399166345596313,
-0.9601216316223145,
-0.1641317754983902,
-0.03874344751238823,
0.3607865571975708,
0.5227612257003784,
-0.12139070779085159,
-0.2138090878725052,
0.5534481406211853,
-0.165684312582016,
-0.0029801391065120697,
0.06093086302280426,
0.003104638075456023,
-0.06642193347215652,
0.9007239937782288,
-0.04880461096763611,
0.6773287653923035,
0.2359580546617508,
0.17151913046836853,
0.007141721900552511,
-0.18624921143054962,
0.14006265997886658,
0.051377177238464355,
-0.6927289962768555,
-0.11779477447271347,
-0.16156600415706635,
0.025313688442111015,
-0.26067396998405457,
-0.29555314779281616,
-0.11725875735282898,
-0.6047294735908508,
-0.20027966797351837,
-0.16762413084506989,
0.09938275814056396,
0.6407442092895508,
-0.50994873046875,
0.284834623336792,
-0.22610794007778168,
0.2647727131843567,
0.258831262588501,
0.4928916096687317,
0.2963958978652954,
-0.4486371576786041,
-0.5392187237739563,
0.3521251082420349,
-0.58154296875,
-0.6008710265159607,
0.1539415568113327,
0.23892876505851746,
0.5167457461357117,
0.25308844447135925,
0.3471178412437439,
0.7120422720909119,
-0.13376738131046295,
0.704093337059021,
0.3233405649662018,
-0.9413663744926453,
0.45634719729423523,
0.040636587888002396,
-0.02586895227432251,
0.3119637370109558,
0.18493865430355072,
-0.6957526803016663,
-0.5683255195617676,
-0.7017707824707031,
-0.671639084815979,
0.9987836480140686,
0.29986101388931274,
0.21986985206604004,
-0.11091485619544983,
0.21929357945919037,
0.004683562088757753,
-0.29506945610046387,
-0.7298691868782043,
-0.20655880868434906,
-0.38831403851509094,
-0.2395246922969818,
0.19272294640541077,
-0.027468180283904076,
-0.29706400632858276,
-0.2763485312461853,
0.8143385052680969,
0.18336549401283264,
0.498501181602478,
0.17238600552082062,
-0.052226971834897995,
-0.23286235332489014,
0.3685593008995056,
0.41364786028862,
0.3139539659023285,
-0.30665507912635803,
0.4141088128089905,
-0.1522572636604309,
-0.6279150247573853,
0.3830423951148987,
-0.311894029378891,
-0.378104567527771,
-0.15397542715072632,
0.34213635325431824,
0.8579573035240173,
0.19215478003025055,
-0.3321009874343872,
0.520429253578186,
-0.3045436143875122,
-0.1761808842420578,
-0.03743889182806015,
0.3359270691871643,
0.02917637676000595,
0.22858676314353943,
0.01015743799507618,
0.3273874819278717,
0.08342353254556656,
-0.39042195677757263,
0.24297216534614563,
0.3553852140903473,
-0.36282235383987427,
-0.49007028341293335,
0.7081986665725708,
0.12342067807912827,
-0.19955165684223175,
0.9399136304855347,
-0.25889337062835693,
-0.43398189544677734,
0.5593811273574829,
0.8539109826087952,
0.9105200171470642,
0.009949362836778164,
0.28745922446250916,
0.47442618012428284,
0.11774296313524246,
-0.5346580743789673,
0.4843323230743408,
-0.36845242977142334,
-0.7076682448387146,
-0.6134463548660278,
-0.8479745388031006,
-0.1076512485742569,
-0.09309065341949463,
-1.011833906173706,
0.2821788191795349,
-0.12955927848815918,
-0.4725728929042816,
-0.1237967386841774,
-0.008435079827904701,
-0.941535234451294,
-0.24234579503536224,
0.23703314363956451,
0.6552929282188416,
-0.9068987369537354,
1.006779670715332,
0.6160109639167786,
-0.8044527769088745,
-1.165021538734436,
0.03906440734863281,
-0.022695980966091156,
-0.7485985159873962,
0.9328810572624207,
0.04337320849299431,
-0.015202236361801624,
-0.03489337116479874,
-0.28714489936828613,
-0.7631068229675293,
0.8940111398696899,
0.464404433965683,
-0.2071666419506073,
-0.44483742117881775,
-0.06471160054206848,
0.20559649169445038,
-0.19624659419059753,
-0.09136800467967987,
0.8142070770263672,
0.3267475962638855,
0.07237981259822845,
-1.0095903873443604,
-0.07062892615795135,
0.03743909299373627,
0.10472545027732849,
0.20228172838687897,
-0.05428256466984749,
0.9627768993377686,
-0.38022464513778687,
-0.3485722243785858,
-0.20983895659446716,
0.03620251640677452,
0.16286545991897583,
0.2677464187145233,
0.1313839852809906,
0.44290268421173096,
0.6524050831794739,
-0.05764401704072952,
1.1813732385635376,
-0.5237841010093689,
0.7290504574775696,
0.9640320539474487,
-0.01085534505546093,
0.3661939203739166,
0.6919924020767212,
-0.9266627430915833,
0.3643086850643158,
0.5237957239151001,
0.09115155786275864,
0.45215269923210144,
0.5032002329826355,
-0.45416998863220215,
-0.075803741812706,
-0.04007575288414955,
-0.3535042703151703,
0.04762767255306244,
0.3286117613315582,
-0.2684705853462219,
-0.18893656134605408,
0.0717778280377388,
-0.16822808980941772,
-0.0623910166323185,
-0.306707501411438,
0.3667823374271393,
0.13335508108139038,
-0.664918065071106,
0.6663680672645569,
-0.10850892961025238,
0.7137983441352844,
-0.3413558006286621,
-0.08341223001480103,
-0.45519962906837463,
0.12199487537145615,
-0.2928110659122467,
-0.5914140343666077,
0.34570008516311646,
-0.14409761130809784,
-0.4297330379486084,
-0.16798970103263855,
0.5060014128684998,
-0.42926251888275146,
-0.19746440649032593,
0.21801277995109558,
0.19465333223342896,
0.16151763498783112,
-0.06819245219230652,
-0.37111276388168335,
0.1465945541858673,
0.18624967336654663,
-0.039046093821525574,
0.4085337817668915,
0.17970575392246246,
-0.1627615988254547,
0.3556232750415802,
0.6934875249862671,
0.5581167340278625,
0.2866562604904175,
0.21435081958770752,
0.5491567254066467,
-0.5124249458312988,
-0.5789688229560852,
-0.7766424417495728,
0.08797712624073029,
-0.0019509140402078629,
0.2870584726333618,
0.39766791462898254,
0.3663689196109772,
1.420572280883789,
-0.17662428319454193,
1.073094367980957,
-0.18913650512695312,
0.1010570228099823,
-0.4274738132953644,
0.25373151898384094,
-0.35994377732276917,
0.5688903331756592,
-0.3961109220981598,
-1.2181779146194458,
-0.4654628038406372,
0.9136866331100464,
-0.18959040939807892,
-0.1542644053697586,
0.7377201914787292,
0.5606164336204529,
-0.11700360476970673,
0.12059924006462097,
0.12601475417613983,
-0.28410041332244873,
0.2999562621116638,
0.9525489807128906,
0.848386824131012,
-0.18325723707675934,
0.4541780948638916,
-0.7191766500473022,
-0.21478022634983063,
-0.21332037448883057,
-0.520363450050354,
-0.6256716251373291,
-0.5475854277610779,
-0.13560889661312103,
-0.6338108777999878,
0.058813489973545074,
1.1088932752609253,
0.5572429895401001,
-0.49294230341911316,
-0.634775698184967,
-0.20230142772197723,
0.11014047265052795,
-0.6120753288269043,
-0.26668089628219604,
0.469920814037323,
-0.5974743962287903,
-0.564262866973877,
0.0789264589548111,
0.18246333301067352,
0.07910002768039703,
-0.3011140525341034,
-0.3136311173439026,
0.32371169328689575,
-0.053923238068819046,
0.5360137820243835,
0.20371179282665253,
-0.6509402394294739,
-0.34567776322364807,
-0.14498667418956757,
-0.06076033040881157,
0.160746768116951,
1.3353742361068726,
-0.7902107238769531,
0.6808333396911621,
0.3469732999801636,
0.4636509418487549,
0.4807611405849457,
-0.035827554762363434,
0.5942527055740356,
-0.7626101970672607,
0.20138652622699738,
0.02749243564903736,
0.19887588918209076,
0.19026890397071838,
-0.34068161249160767,
0.6967320442199707,
0.49347978830337524,
-0.5273045897483826,
-0.8867135047912598,
0.6013301014900208,
-0.9066065549850464,
-0.21770833432674408,
0.7336302995681763,
0.010454965755343437,
-0.09903726726770401,
-0.1393377035856247,
-0.20591352880001068,
0.5452772378921509,
-0.37507516145706177,
1.2071969509124756,
0.635856568813324,
-0.6287004947662354,
0.3709077835083008,
-0.5438764691352844,
0.6851620078086853,
0.16451238095760345,
-0.45787063241004944,
0.22848621010780334,
0.586472749710083,
0.34681880474090576,
0.23223070800304413,
0.7286164164543152,
-0.18528637290000916,
0.39584845304489136,
0.14636483788490295,
0.4961109459400177,
-0.14594784379005432,
-0.23943114280700684,
-0.32701584696769714,
-0.09710460156202316,
0.45147353410720825,
-0.025939175859093666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04897v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04897v1
|
Machine Learning-based NLP for Emotion Classification on a Cholera X Dataset
| 2024-05-08T09:05:02 | 2024-05-08T09:05:02 |
Paul Jideani, Aurona Gerber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent social media posts on the cholera outbreak in Hammanskraal have
highlighted the diverse range of emotions people experienced in response to
such an event. The extent of people's opinions varies greatly depending on
their level of knowledge and information about the disease. The documented
re-search about Cholera lacks investigations into the classification of
emotions. This study aims to examine the emotions expressed in social media
posts about Chol-era. A dataset of 23,000 posts was extracted and
pre-processed. The Python Nat-ural Language Toolkit (NLTK) sentiment analyzer
library was applied to deter-mine the emotional significance of each text.
Additionally, Machine Learning (ML) models were applied for emotion
classification, including Long short-term memory (LSTM), Logistic regression,
Decision trees, and the Bidirectional En-coder Representations from
Transformers (BERT) model. The results of this study demonstrated that LSTM
achieved the highest accuracy of 75%. Emotion classification presents a
promising tool for gaining a deeper understanding of the impact of Cholera on
society. The findings of this study might contribute to the development of
effective interventions in public health strategies.
|
[
-0.21606193482875824,
-0.5448623895645142,
0.17894338071346283,
0.5172299146652222,
-0.279915988445282,
-0.050532203167676926,
-0.0817955806851387,
-0.6747164130210876,
0.2762320041656494,
0.2870827317237854,
-0.06324686855077744,
-0.792628824710846,
-0.6597813367843628,
0.5522060394287109,
-0.44000309705734253,
0.9681949019432068,
-0.06281594932079315,
0.14246328175067902,
0.05962125584483147,
-0.13144703209400177,
-0.10229876637458801,
-0.6381480693817139,
-0.6906318664550781,
-0.3178790509700775,
0.9529473781585693,
0.15651319921016693,
0.31422510743141174,
0.03764592483639717,
0.2660731375217438,
0.2986305058002472,
-0.14450161159038544,
0.12395579367876053,
-0.6089565753936768,
0.14729377627372742,
-0.2854093611240387,
-0.358682245016098,
-0.29249894618988037,
-0.017552919685840607,
-0.13338781893253326,
0.11207054555416107,
0.008750603534281254,
0.3907971978187561,
0.15171411633491516,
0.8678148984909058,
-0.7448559999465942,
0.5687729716300964,
-0.1799415498971939,
0.4305606782436371,
-0.176870658993721,
-0.5794539451599121,
-0.348140150308609,
-0.4769049882888794,
0.2656022012233734,
-0.3546960949897766,
-0.162555992603302,
0.07552707940340042,
0.7308562994003296,
0.21975813806056976,
-0.6456272006034851,
-0.5739384293556213,
-0.39761245250701904,
0.8045477867126465,
-0.3790300190448761,
-0.12782321870326996,
0.3920574486255646,
0.19447143375873566,
0.03321756795048714,
-0.4543112814426422,
-0.3101551830768585,
0.2983701527118683,
0.22061951458454132,
0.42838340997695923,
-0.24431757628917694,
0.19766145944595337,
0.006175844930112362,
0.274930864572525,
-0.8788652420043945,
-0.24250367283821106,
-0.4811649024486542,
0.26395368576049805,
0.732326090335846,
0.34228333830833435,
0.23391853272914886,
-0.6672083139419556,
-0.3775516450405121,
0.06564789265394211,
-0.3778678774833679,
0.19698834419250488,
0.21541015803813934,
0.2715491056442261,
-0.2759942412376404,
0.39477717876434326,
-0.1675129532814026,
0.34051257371902466,
-0.16846750676631927,
-0.007053305394947529,
0.3381945788860321,
0.13285258412361145,
-0.49445614218711853,
0.30482912063598633,
0.776768147945404,
0.7358751893043518,
0.4822380542755127,
0.4102972745895386,
-0.057808924466371536,
0.32604116201400757,
0.5384535193443298,
-0.7511964440345764,
-0.19248656928539276,
0.4261016845703125,
-0.7772201299667358,
-0.6507323384284973,
0.05664414167404175,
-1.2880985736846924,
-0.7527660131454468,
-0.01881316676735878,
0.02531159482896328,
-0.2542540729045868,
-0.2507191598415375,
0.15330037474632263,
-0.09265591204166412,
0.018875636160373688,
0.45943722128868103,
-0.3735419809818268,
0.0946510061621666,
0.6137399077415466,
0.8097111582756042,
-0.023374415934085846,
0.3496386706829071,
-0.12619569897651672,
-0.1861218959093094,
0.07269728928804398,
0.620840847492218,
-0.40407124161720276,
-0.5606532096862793,
0.4514954388141632,
-0.032358840107917786,
-0.07512286305427551,
-0.6047515869140625,
0.5317152738571167,
-0.7042076587677002,
0.03197455033659935,
0.03376799076795578,
-0.5694090127944946,
-0.46281883120536804,
0.36626365780830383,
-0.4081166684627533,
0.8900952339172363,
0.22590108215808868,
-1.0369288921356201,
-0.009413588792085648,
-0.3843728005886078,
-0.6003268957138062,
-0.03548853471875191,
0.13378368318080902,
-0.5251911878585815,
0.4013479948043823,
0.017373759299516678,
0.49634844064712524,
-0.4369196891784668,
0.19725055992603302,
-0.7989800572395325,
-0.24435247480869293,
0.2367955595254898,
-0.10384371876716614,
0.812957763671875,
0.3303333818912506,
-0.39504826068878174,
0.2224225103855133,
-0.5601299405097961,
0.11343409866094589,
0.09904502332210541,
-0.143540158867836,
-0.5405210852622986,
-0.11360065639019012,
0.25860223174095154,
0.5482273101806641,
0.02884482964873314,
-0.23416996002197266,
0.3597566485404968,
-0.2127271443605423,
0.22730451822280884,
0.6936133503913879,
0.2805600166320801,
-0.013991808518767357,
-0.33344584703445435,
0.731764554977417,
0.14923708140850067,
0.47692620754241943,
0.022799665108323097,
-0.7568367719650269,
-0.6210638284683228,
0.09392908960580826,
0.008545111864805222,
0.817436933517456,
-0.5587639212608337,
0.571361243724823,
-0.1944398432970047,
-0.5172686576843262,
-0.7061067223548889,
-0.12651903927326202,
0.17706327140331268,
0.44083312153816223,
0.4955167770385742,
0.09520339965820312,
-0.9518336057662964,
-0.5386692881584167,
0.048910364508628845,
-0.24024945497512817,
-0.009356250986456871,
0.49325674772262573,
0.5917877554893494,
-0.5166143178939819,
0.7352145314216614,
-0.638824999332428,
-0.19874511659145355,
-0.18740729987621307,
0.6722503304481506,
0.028683844953775406,
0.015884462743997574,
0.3346940279006958,
-1.0628055334091187,
-0.734164834022522,
0.3977707624435425,
-1.1739751100540161,
-0.3063412308692932,
0.22212009131908417,
0.20110948383808136,
0.5533594489097595,
0.02816598489880562,
-0.39622631669044495,
0.8245736360549927,
0.5717868208885193,
0.12342685461044312,
0.6273449063301086,
-0.0594632662832737,
0.2768489122390747,
-0.9363847970962524,
0.0364634245634079,
0.1964598298072815,
-0.19335675239562988,
-0.36836278438568115,
-0.2833538353443146,
0.2729327976703644,
-0.3352891802787781,
-0.48757830262184143,
0.7001129984855652,
-0.13514867424964905,
0.18126477301120758,
-0.6440201997756958,
-0.044127386063337326,
-0.06414738297462463,
0.17007671296596527,
0.17377614974975586,
0.17471203207969666,
0.5316769480705261,
-0.39722004532814026,
0.7202010750770569,
-0.06428239494562149,
-0.28175193071365356,
0.30927717685699463,
-0.30371394753456116,
-0.005573587957769632,
0.042276181280612946,
0.4660763144493103,
-0.5682772994041443,
-0.29362499713897705,
0.29519060254096985,
-0.4680090844631195,
0.11032562702894211,
-0.21782976388931274,
-0.31442925333976746,
-0.7937480211257935,
-0.3792489469051361,
0.12665995955467224,
0.5510658025741577,
-0.34973955154418945,
0.5347949266433716,
0.30574920773506165,
-0.47562047839164734,
-0.3724466860294342,
-0.1962754875421524,
0.2045644223690033,
-0.6157287955284119,
-0.5835520625114441,
-0.2418871968984604,
0.2725902795791626,
-0.4229156970977783,
0.026977313682436943,
-0.048903774470090866,
-0.16196246445178986,
-0.021334553137421608,
0.7319549322128296,
-0.0800255835056305,
-0.08380810916423798,
0.2698279321193695,
-0.014230250380933285,
-0.2602929472923279,
0.15820039808750153,
-0.07955783605575562,
0.6951161026954651,
-0.35286667943000793,
0.10490157455205917,
-0.5617069602012634,
0.3606134355068207,
0.5214964151382446,
-0.005364815704524517,
0.48554450273513794,
0.5423081517219543,
-0.31326502561569214,
-0.14894849061965942,
-0.03849851340055466,
0.15827274322509766,
-0.41050225496292114,
0.31629642844200134,
-0.06495462357997894,
-0.5359151363372803,
0.3491348326206207,
-0.4055285155773163,
-0.5886688828468323,
0.3084719181060791,
0.4849925935268402,
-0.5239831805229187,
0.7915958166122437,
0.37529370188713074,
-0.82435542345047,
0.03786191716790199,
-0.21507734060287476,
0.09488460421562195,
-0.5156700015068054,
0.09456384927034378,
-0.42728808522224426,
-0.3653799295425415,
-0.7881470322608948,
-0.4767284393310547,
0.3290671706199646,
-0.1386060118675232,
-0.0552738718688488,
-0.18185387551784515,
-0.10868742316961288,
-0.07153376936912537,
0.23309355974197388,
0.12413225322961807,
-0.0473320446908474,
-0.14808174967765808,
0.3386741280555725,
0.1480821967124939,
-0.7076135873794556,
-0.5593954920768738,
0.8247638940811157,
0.05219385400414467,
0.9708812832832336,
-0.32422685623168945,
0.9260604381561279,
0.8094080686569214,
0.6098107099533081,
-0.6416465640068054,
0.26726341247558594,
-0.0414990670979023,
-0.41961362957954407,
-0.056907977908849716,
-0.36617276072502136,
-1.2474801540374756,
-0.25234276056289673,
-0.05879923328757286,
-0.6729732751846313,
0.13772866129875183,
-0.0010483877267688513,
-0.400569885969162,
0.21999499201774597,
-0.452123761177063,
0.6152763962745667,
-0.33466529846191406,
-0.17749708890914917,
-0.40116164088249207,
-1.0974096059799194,
0.41679877042770386,
-0.08135314285755157,
0.3695468008518219,
-0.05038481205701828,
0.3247915804386139,
0.22137677669525146,
-0.5352798104286194,
1.1354538202285767,
-0.025157030671834946,
-0.04432443901896477,
0.4168854355812073,
-0.29763689637184143,
0.2420351505279541,
0.15251928567886353,
-0.14773759245872498,
0.25684458017349243,
-0.4560437798500061,
-0.34599003195762634,
-0.5576465725898743,
0.6701090931892395,
-0.7203789949417114,
-0.39577803015708923,
-0.5551272630691528,
-0.3382023572921753,
0.27295711636543274,
-0.1840917319059372,
0.19609172642230988,
0.3021416664123535,
-0.16154910624027252,
-0.026804504916071892,
0.510443389415741,
-0.6182801127433777,
0.18223953247070312,
0.011840867809951305,
-0.5480009317398071,
-0.550132691860199,
1.0402101278305054,
0.0028098702896386385,
-0.036919258534908295,
0.5667116045951843,
0.4502961039543152,
-0.17237471044063568,
-0.008894897066056728,
-0.30996063351631165,
-0.09475024789571762,
-0.4797284007072449,
-0.5266423225402832,
-0.7242453694343567,
-0.24915705621242523,
-0.37881940603256226,
-0.2739028334617615,
-0.08349104970693588,
-0.014945362694561481,
-0.4829185903072357,
-0.06456626206636429,
0.43722617626190186,
0.758243978023529,
0.008205540478229523,
0.15862149000167847,
-1.155731201171875,
0.2000795155763626,
0.11235177516937256,
0.04728327691555023,
0.07280333340167999,
-0.17584656178951263,
-0.38638991117477417,
-0.07560419291257858,
-0.4954281747341156,
-1.174093246459961,
0.9036651849746704,
0.08817093819379807,
-0.26374351978302,
1.1049364805221558,
0.5815212726593018,
0.6740714311599731,
0.02638586051762104,
0.5057067275047302,
-0.03713680058717728,
-0.9064855575561523,
0.7069449424743652,
-0.4100629687309265,
0.26841896772384644,
0.08434843271970749,
0.7786715030670166,
-0.8440015912055969,
-0.41172775626182556,
-0.5360363125801086,
-0.9769718647003174,
0.3692406117916107,
0.038188256323337555,
-0.2932993769645691,
-0.4097718894481659,
0.0991816595196724,
0.1923084557056427,
0.24033944308757782,
-0.372772753238678,
-0.33572816848754883,
-0.14846864342689514,
-0.4615386426448822,
-0.07238730043172836,
-0.3556045889854431,
0.08329043537378311,
-0.12551257014274597,
0.6488660573959351,
0.08760406076908112,
0.04614242911338806,
0.23896469175815582,
-0.4999837577342987,
-0.12721477448940277,
0.3282589316368103,
0.6009978652000427,
0.28196802735328674,
-0.4206162691116333,
0.39855143427848816,
-0.10412946343421936,
-0.2633618712425232,
0.25064894556999207,
0.10272850096225739,
-0.10922647267580032,
0.0028803914319723845,
0.42505258321762085,
0.6538669466972351,
0.36429479718208313,
-0.8045681715011597,
0.4718414545059204,
0.018315432593226433,
0.16434764862060547,
-0.4509187340736389,
-0.22945255041122437,
0.27291786670684814,
0.4785686433315277,
0.48847314715385437,
0.14293694496154785,
0.2964239716529846,
-0.3855864107608795,
0.005885095801204443,
-0.10274610668420792,
-0.5814522504806519,
-0.5751287937164307,
0.22361856698989868,
0.39838671684265137,
-0.12554073333740234,
0.7593733072280884,
-0.3558118939399719,
-0.7161940336227417,
0.6474448442459106,
0.28301793336868286,
0.9148378372192383,
-0.7223053574562073,
0.26860538125038147,
0.41007888317108154,
-0.006997907534241676,
0.11866452544927597,
0.568473756313324,
0.23413217067718506,
-0.4226382076740265,
-0.1922180950641632,
-0.6702333092689514,
-0.041685331612825394,
0.30078089237213135,
-1.08455228805542,
0.24630625545978546,
-0.2909931540489197,
-0.3346453011035919,
-0.31290343403816223,
0.08609968423843384,
-0.5186405181884766,
0.42885902523994446,
0.34959277510643005,
0.7858943939208984,
-1.0370479822158813,
0.7950519323348999,
0.6748749613761902,
-0.18647050857543945,
-0.1878437101840973,
-0.19397196173667908,
0.2185238152742386,
-0.6735038757324219,
0.8832776546478271,
0.6862454414367676,
0.043545372784137726,
-0.27096477150917053,
-0.39361482858657837,
-0.4323388338088989,
0.6751312017440796,
-0.42859360575675964,
-0.468505322933197,
0.31124523282051086,
0.2738063931465149,
0.7384957671165466,
-0.30844205617904663,
0.12864097952842712,
0.14189589023590088,
0.6588314771652222,
-0.4416390061378479,
-0.7207140326499939,
-0.22476764023303986,
-0.6703933477401733,
0.027450362220406532,
0.2893277704715729,
-0.5545103549957275,
0.5577871799468994,
-0.24564942717552185,
-0.22559185326099396,
-0.00105477892793715,
0.773838222026825,
0.21452654898166656,
0.8601610064506531,
0.4296223819255829,
0.5521464347839355,
0.8869975209236145,
0.002313027624040842,
1.3111129999160767,
-0.2737320363521576,
0.5137722492218018,
1.0626791715621948,
-0.640631914138794,
0.7460342049598694,
0.3318827152252197,
-0.2774963676929474,
0.38820716738700867,
1.0399761199951172,
0.07301745563745499,
0.31340324878692627,
0.6849068999290466,
-0.45761001110076904,
-0.07325291633605957,
-0.2553114593029022,
-0.4226378798484802,
0.3949243128299713,
0.6159942150115967,
-0.4811684787273407,
-0.2814841568470001,
0.4147011637687683,
0.08694450557231903,
-0.2650538682937622,
-0.5193142294883728,
0.5540035963058472,
0.2191735953092575,
0.09905476123094559,
0.37617307901382446,
-0.20157228410243988,
0.523296594619751,
-0.47667428851127625,
0.03464433550834656,
-0.11498578637838364,
0.18422575294971466,
-0.21962128579616547,
-0.6863682270050049,
0.2169845700263977,
0.07058153301477432,
-0.5709517002105713,
-0.1687169373035431,
0.8966484665870667,
-0.4804685115814209,
-0.46056318283081055,
0.7173029184341431,
0.39646947383880615,
0.277477890253067,
-0.48299160599708557,
-0.6384185552597046,
0.015624728053808212,
-0.10378436744213104,
-0.3591269552707672,
0.34609997272491455,
0.67232745885849,
-0.3604450225830078,
0.761474609375,
0.20618242025375366,
0.11262519657611847,
0.08674648404121399,
0.13132186233997345,
0.6060546040534973,
-0.8811080455780029,
-0.47572219371795654,
-0.826336681842804,
0.3114513158798218,
-0.28726452589035034,
-0.16264402866363525,
0.6675336360931396,
0.7575539350509644,
0.5646052360534668,
-0.4563972055912018,
1.1949753761291504,
0.062483955174684525,
0.2434951215982437,
-0.006121163722127676,
0.7697790861129761,
-0.5408164262771606,
-0.4069521129131317,
-0.43905502557754517,
-0.2553648352622986,
-0.2482542246580124,
0.5105071663856506,
-0.2866803705692291,
-0.0038172665517777205,
0.6338360905647278,
0.46718505024909973,
0.34264418482780457,
0.365966796875,
0.25407809019088745,
0.5922569632530212,
0.0552603080868721,
0.5687863230705261,
1.087604284286499,
-0.22084856033325195,
0.21372641623020172,
-0.21217213571071625,
-0.22008681297302246,
-0.9204500317573547,
-0.7656921744346619,
-0.5656572580337524,
-0.5086097717285156,
-0.2638988494873047,
-0.29722025990486145,
0.36395692825317383,
1.1282328367233276,
0.3069431483745575,
-0.7136430144309998,
-0.319669634103775,
0.3585738241672516,
0.30155429244041443,
-0.3119205832481384,
-0.30567505955696106,
0.7317206859588623,
-0.2623322606086731,
-0.6218403577804565,
0.13904856145381927,
0.706423282623291,
-0.056259360164403915,
0.1257498562335968,
-0.07130905985832214,
-0.22256529331207275,
-0.21484176814556122,
0.9853754639625549,
0.4231526255607605,
-0.5011489391326904,
-0.12985217571258545,
-0.11943356692790985,
-0.30874162912368774,
0.17736588418483734,
0.6953253746032715,
-0.5189148187637329,
0.5043526887893677,
0.4939877390861511,
0.47576993703842163,
0.5205512642860413,
0.026164963841438293,
0.4739575982093811,
-0.41732266545295715,
-0.030438516288995743,
0.21828772127628326,
0.4778907299041748,
0.17813880741596222,
-0.2329556941986084,
0.4714381694793701,
0.4089496433734894,
-0.6168537139892578,
-0.4385131597518921,
0.03814973309636116,
-1.133013129234314,
-0.28877103328704834,
1.120581030845642,
-0.43675389885902405,
-0.539807915687561,
-0.4053380489349365,
-0.21664005517959595,
0.5386763215065002,
-0.5604630708694458,
1.4446626901626587,
0.5978575348854065,
-0.28305307030677795,
0.05246906355023384,
-0.5105358958244324,
0.2441670149564743,
0.03245436027646065,
-1.0241634845733643,
0.0565071739256382,
0.17067879438400269,
-0.007227170746773481,
0.09147773683071136,
0.38885125517845154,
-0.03541968762874603,
0.1029401570558548,
-0.18670527637004852,
0.4239853620529175,
0.25639188289642334,
-0.21304558217525482,
-0.3158242106437683,
0.4449833929538727,
-0.8092394471168518,
0.06574229151010513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04872v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04872v1
|
Logical Negation Augmenting and Debiasing for Prompt-based Methods
| 2024-05-08T08:05:47 | 2024-05-08T08:05:47 |
Yitian Li, Jidong Tian, Hao He, Yaohui Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LO
|
Prompt-based methods have gained increasing attention on NLP and shown
validity on many downstream tasks. Many works have focused on mining these
methods' potential for knowledge extraction, but few explore their ability to
make logical reasoning. In this work, we focus on the effectiveness of the
prompt-based methods on first-order logical reasoning and find that the
bottleneck lies in logical negation. Based on our analysis, logical negation
tends to result in spurious correlations to negative answers, while
propositions without logical negation correlate to positive answers. To solve
the problem, we propose a simple but effective method, Negation Augmenting and
Negation Debiasing (NAND), which introduces negative propositions to
prompt-based methods without updating parameters. Specifically, these negative
propositions can counteract spurious correlations by providing "not" for all
instances so that models cannot make decisions only by whether expressions
contain a logical negation. Experiments on three datasets show that NAND not
only solves the problem of calibrating logical negation but also significantly
enhances prompt-based methods of logical reasoning without model retraining.
|
[
-0.5886330008506775,
-1.2001324892044067,
0.6952114105224609,
0.2361580729484558,
-0.3958819806575775,
-0.16486606001853943,
0.16387474536895752,
-0.20045889914035797,
0.3276737332344055,
0.40221965312957764,
-0.7341998219490051,
-0.3780858516693115,
-0.6154356002807617,
0.44784823060035706,
-0.2076689898967743,
0.8333428502082825,
0.642329216003418,
0.1426481455564499,
-0.5212716460227966,
-0.1315472573041916,
-1.1009759902954102,
-0.4109930396080017,
-0.6373893022537231,
-0.3302328586578369,
0.3688262403011322,
0.7075492143630981,
0.7905726432800293,
0.28923875093460083,
0.16677257418632507,
0.19213201105594635,
-0.21935726702213287,
0.23228298127651215,
-0.2606484889984131,
0.37465184926986694,
-0.32977721095085144,
-0.5129073858261108,
-0.3614024519920349,
0.19275476038455963,
-0.03372522071003914,
0.766006588935852,
0.07441450655460358,
0.12332915514707565,
-0.07041384279727936,
0.5600362420082092,
-0.6472541689872742,
0.04213116317987442,
-0.5145936012268066,
-0.007905651815235615,
0.13377101719379425,
-0.34688225388526917,
-0.2809373736381531,
-0.5872427225112915,
0.35657867789268494,
-0.7309859991073608,
-0.005749485921114683,
0.04774928465485573,
0.5173149704933167,
0.6633874177932739,
-0.36004865169525146,
-0.1056295856833458,
-0.33408084511756897,
1.0014106035232544,
-0.8939458131790161,
0.09617924690246582,
0.5588013529777527,
0.23927508294582367,
-0.16494633257389069,
0.026020472869277,
-0.6703423261642456,
-0.46735602617263794,
-0.04976876080036163,
-0.009158438071608543,
-0.07512316852807999,
0.12730419635772705,
0.8760214447975159,
-0.07996079325675964,
-0.3858364224433899,
0.17767295241355896,
-0.11657673865556717,
-0.21295198798179626,
0.4649370014667511,
-0.005075415130704641,
0.3788147270679474,
-0.4845297038555145,
-0.7013891339302063,
0.07070034742355347,
-0.6675776839256287,
-0.029637260362505913,
0.1763869822025299,
0.2664816081523895,
0.2108747363090515,
0.601711094379425,
-0.3995492458343506,
0.9168639779090881,
0.3264771103858948,
-0.06901141256093979,
0.3371942639350891,
-0.4330178201198578,
-0.09361997246742249,
0.29852235317230225,
0.33707916736602783,
0.700309157371521,
0.2555125951766968,
-0.14496679604053497,
-0.17034706473350525,
0.38246408104896545,
-0.14323686063289642,
-0.6449373960494995,
-0.09520485252141953,
0.11802772432565689,
-0.21242071688175201,
-0.5304308533668518,
-0.29376229643821716,
-0.8503903746604919,
-0.6911395788192749,
-0.5171065926551819,
0.6815772652626038,
-0.5989964604377747,
-0.1390470713376999,
0.0614013634622097,
-0.4022909998893738,
0.2950381338596344,
0.5468019843101501,
-0.5272197127342224,
0.2989882528781891,
0.567425012588501,
0.681698739528656,
0.026252003386616707,
-0.042010921984910965,
-1.072065830230713,
-0.5615472793579102,
-0.5583370327949524,
0.7301462888717651,
-0.49932369589805603,
-0.31954196095466614,
-0.4569166302680969,
-0.26366010308265686,
0.2400732785463333,
-0.4188952147960663,
0.7372082471847534,
-0.611000120639801,
0.37916597723960876,
-0.7366966009140015,
-0.5417742729187012,
-0.43485376238822937,
0.440910667181015,
-0.6342721581459045,
0.763900876045227,
-0.08958640694618225,
-0.5510343313217163,
0.39761388301849365,
-0.44529321789741516,
-0.5463501214981079,
-0.047884054481983185,
-0.15558941662311554,
0.1301375776529312,
0.13039030134677887,
0.6894600987434387,
0.18259654939174652,
-0.6409974098205566,
0.48969268798828125,
-0.36032727360725403,
-0.14831054210662842,
0.07901553809642792,
-0.6253018379211426,
1.1756757497787476,
0.1522415280342102,
-0.3462744951248169,
-0.1017947643995285,
-0.8091455698013306,
-0.04232216998934746,
-0.14899805188179016,
0.3846346437931061,
-0.6542150378227234,
-0.18214744329452515,
-0.5904068946838379,
0.4061156213283539,
0.21287083625793457,
-0.5760335922241211,
0.04314590245485306,
-0.5639974474906921,
0.06926866620779037,
0.7829954624176025,
0.31474581360816956,
0.6501970291137695,
-0.510349452495575,
0.6054075956344604,
0.14802336692810059,
0.02451835758984089,
-0.3674788773059845,
-0.8137010931968689,
-0.533011257648468,
0.031208232045173645,
0.21195298433303833,
0.8445550799369812,
-1.2293369770050049,
0.5203866958618164,
0.21446636319160461,
-0.4571469724178314,
-0.1254756599664688,
0.07968857139348984,
0.3582456707954407,
1.4790669679641724,
0.8500931262969971,
0.10178843140602112,
-0.2834596633911133,
-0.6547417640686035,
-0.2714115083217621,
-0.12567266821861267,
0.16825777292251587,
-0.13118615746498108,
0.09038840234279633,
0.2285604327917099,
1.1297743320465088,
-0.6715479493141174,
-0.04709187150001526,
0.035118088126182556,
0.2840500771999359,
0.6118290424346924,
0.5770313739776611,
0.5651980042457581,
-0.6913565397262573,
-0.22066064178943634,
-0.5820364356040955,
-0.7796265482902527,
-0.6613653302192688,
-0.4878727197647095,
-0.03207392245531082,
0.12562893331050873,
0.5582299828529358,
-0.5514951944351196,
0.6572301983833313,
-0.1422395408153534,
-0.417079359292984,
0.6992831230163574,
-0.05162936821579933,
0.03977734223008156,
-0.47574731707572937,
-0.26937931776046753,
0.1402786672115326,
-0.058604832738637924,
-0.7041164040565491,
-0.16087931394577026,
-0.030302418395876884,
-0.00787566788494587,
-0.3480745255947113,
0.6965129971504211,
-0.38000553846359253,
0.43882402777671814,
-0.399929016828537,
0.30955207347869873,
0.4457758069038391,
0.2900634706020355,
0.0055612181313335896,
0.5022169351577759,
0.6432352066040039,
-0.941616415977478,
0.31374290585517883,
0.4035068154335022,
-0.11143019050359726,
0.8048936128616333,
-0.7160165309906006,
-0.11035266518592834,
-0.4628441333770752,
-0.002814970910549164,
-0.8832785487174988,
0.3552807867527008,
0.3890499174594879,
-0.48942434787750244,
0.0485987551510334,
-0.012319452129304409,
-0.27093246579170227,
-0.14011764526367188,
-0.40749847888946533,
0.3090858459472656,
0.6175196766853333,
-0.6775136590003967,
0.3227350413799286,
0.00968208909034729,
-0.2275892198085785,
-0.8264460563659668,
-0.609520673751831,
0.13586562871932983,
-0.17986905574798584,
-0.6506317853927612,
0.396381139755249,
-0.0424746572971344,
-0.44907671213150024,
-0.06122962012887001,
-0.43872520327568054,
-0.06515000760555267,
0.3459804654121399,
-0.0346873439848423,
0.4641253352165222,
-0.051597125828266144,
0.3178289830684662,
0.2902214229106903,
-0.6293790936470032,
0.3426550030708313,
-0.2011857032775879,
0.3246591091156006,
0.18954992294311523,
-0.48413535952568054,
-0.3952881991863251,
0.337627112865448,
0.4058031737804413,
-0.08611232042312622,
0.5888500809669495,
0.3523850739002228,
-0.3693165183067322,
-0.281208872795105,
-0.8270336389541626,
-0.6871004700660706,
-0.4019054174423218,
-0.05285997316241264,
-0.2172725349664688,
-0.438824862241745,
0.3116847276687622,
0.0942687913775444,
-0.0708264634013176,
0.41857782006263733,
0.014897515065968037,
0.08261309564113617,
0.7770898938179016,
0.15557387471199036,
0.07342491298913956,
0.3161623179912567,
0.09134593605995178,
0.1827835887670517,
-0.5212705731391907,
-0.04211617261171341,
-0.46664661169052124,
-0.2316480427980423,
-0.2058948278427124,
-0.3613596260547638,
0.27941378951072693,
0.44349390268325806,
-0.17742584645748138,
0.17873378098011017,
-0.4694080054759979,
0.535089910030365,
0.8534955978393555,
0.3386121690273285,
0.4420948326587677,
-0.22320552170276642,
0.029276367276906967,
-0.19825825095176697,
-0.6849012970924377,
-0.3135243058204651,
1.0086616277694702,
-0.24057182669639587,
0.5848734974861145,
0.12852507829666138,
0.6233136653900146,
0.2721679210662842,
-0.09261094033718109,
-0.6606835722923279,
0.782187283039093,
0.1701488196849823,
-0.501799464225769,
-0.35316571593284607,
-0.4448288679122925,
-0.41583916544914246,
0.3050977289676666,
-0.5531529784202576,
-0.34529200196266174,
0.5787843465805054,
-0.008745537139475346,
-0.8266392350196838,
0.07022274285554886,
-0.8740922808647156,
0.6711429953575134,
-0.2872665226459503,
-0.5585905909538269,
-0.153397798538208,
-0.7752804756164551,
0.5155848264694214,
0.008546600118279457,
0.13701999187469482,
-0.14622686803340912,
-0.09377586096525192,
0.5247131586074829,
-0.7371417880058289,
0.6589217782020569,
-0.6141627430915833,
-0.06103457883000374,
0.5784022808074951,
0.1994105577468872,
0.4585568606853485,
0.41518598794937134,
-0.37882938981056213,
0.15890192985534668,
-0.030728016048669815,
-0.33710145950317383,
-1.0935181379318237,
0.5907388925552368,
-0.2731829583644867,
-0.9426964521408081,
-0.5647121667861938,
-0.3408021926879883,
-0.21837899088859558,
0.23685748875141144,
-0.02218296192586422,
0.6930314898490906,
0.08270473033189774,
-0.19342580437660217,
0.6676926612854004,
-0.43404048681259155,
0.49545320868492126,
0.26189762353897095,
-0.25181877613067627,
-0.3705565929412842,
0.663266122341156,
0.25862011313438416,
0.3429267108440399,
0.41363513469696045,
0.5055550336837769,
-0.4830849766731262,
-0.33855587244033813,
-0.34787583351135254,
-0.13346555829048157,
-0.8083131909370422,
-0.3581386208534241,
-0.5474080443382263,
0.05479215458035469,
-0.5231977701187134,
-0.09425239264965057,
0.1465608775615692,
-1.0822844505310059,
-0.527855634689331,
-0.26413944363594055,
0.6161825060844421,
0.0674440786242485,
-0.5222846269607544,
0.16274818778038025,
-0.6727166175842285,
0.8271915316581726,
0.5278124213218689,
-0.20091238617897034,
0.11920043081045151,
-0.327983021736145,
0.37278231978416443,
0.06351549923419952,
-0.20570719242095947,
-1.1822459697723389,
0.3922053873538971,
-0.21172229945659637,
0.4109598994255066,
0.5546875596046448,
0.6517135500907898,
0.6727760434150696,
-0.2695307731628418,
0.6766229271888733,
0.2411181628704071,
-0.9197902679443359,
0.5491318702697754,
-0.15949170291423798,
0.1686156690120697,
0.7632344961166382,
0.29776039719581604,
-0.216398686170578,
0.17687304317951202,
-0.5451827645301819,
-0.7251479625701904,
0.581428587436676,
0.010343980975449085,
-0.06946109980344772,
-0.38291916251182556,
0.2379108965396881,
0.31895512342453003,
0.39876729249954224,
-0.38296592235565186,
-0.3699914216995239,
-0.2302650660276413,
0.2822433114051819,
0.12738412618637085,
-0.2687790095806122,
0.16954153776168823,
-0.3740561604499817,
0.8384017944335938,
-0.013300858438014984,
-0.21371464431285858,
0.538202702999115,
-0.3136182427406311,
0.321367084980011,
0.28356483578681946,
0.30433958768844604,
0.4656350910663605,
-0.2018735110759735,
0.11430762708187103,
0.28802230954170227,
-0.010595588013529778,
0.19651156663894653,
0.11324463039636612,
-0.6671401858329773,
0.054906800389289856,
0.18864698708057404,
0.45903149247169495,
-0.01787608675658703,
-0.4574523866176605,
0.7064398527145386,
0.16179603338241577,
0.06295894831418991,
-0.01997029036283493,
0.16933999955654144,
-0.3575250506401062,
0.06883018463850021,
0.33254727721214294,
0.5632054805755615,
0.2119346410036087,
-0.14105868339538574,
0.23429258167743683,
0.5910401344299316,
-0.2665499150753021,
-0.04894140362739563,
0.5113277435302734,
0.2971297800540924,
-0.16986355185508728,
0.6939978003501892,
-0.6032912731170654,
-0.4858740270137787,
0.8102970123291016,
0.5290996432304382,
0.8507128953933716,
-0.012914041057229042,
0.42721888422966003,
0.6945124268531799,
0.4337124526500702,
0.0456373430788517,
0.4488740563392639,
-0.295514851808548,
-0.732915461063385,
-0.8433274030685425,
-0.20213672518730164,
-0.5682109594345093,
-0.13810980319976807,
-0.5465000867843628,
0.6442431211471558,
-0.5929431915283203,
-0.23660174012184143,
-0.19616273045539856,
-0.024189110845327377,
-0.4960315525531769,
0.17533938586711884,
-0.06522242724895477,
0.9245836138725281,
-0.7670773863792419,
0.36423322558403015,
0.3368704319000244,
-0.5659589171409607,
-0.3914724588394165,
-0.09328848868608475,
0.16670337319374084,
-0.48399755358695984,
0.6851181983947754,
0.37060943245887756,
-0.21068677306175232,
0.01162433810532093,
-0.627219557762146,
-0.7853469252586365,
0.7361714243888855,
0.26857683062553406,
-0.4144294261932373,
-0.024644996970891953,
-0.21114806830883026,
0.2012966126203537,
-0.02700408175587654,
0.6082174181938171,
0.26965755224227905,
0.7371441721916199,
0.07883406430482864,
-0.42485660314559937,
0.5390810370445251,
-0.17938578128814697,
-0.3101443350315094,
-0.09410401433706284,
-0.2872065603733063,
1.0327296257019043,
-0.5984582304954529,
-0.27869004011154175,
0.02889850363135338,
0.48399049043655396,
0.25519493222236633,
0.46696215867996216,
0.7089110016822815,
0.7235622406005859,
1.0072383880615234,
0.0676194354891777,
0.7419527769088745,
-0.16117003560066223,
-0.19589291512966156,
1.348014235496521,
-0.48824384808540344,
0.14785835146903992,
0.6190862059593201,
0.1663263440132141,
0.596138596534729,
0.20626839995384216,
0.10491108149290085,
0.505304753780365,
0.0837039053440094,
-0.1877802014350891,
-0.481829434633255,
-0.25141796469688416,
-0.4726485311985016,
0.14485099911689758,
0.3485710918903351,
0.19334466755390167,
-0.6403606534004211,
0.058693043887615204,
0.05376170948147774,
0.3042462170124054,
-0.19516262412071228,
0.6751422882080078,
0.1885027289390564,
-0.9022164344787598,
0.6323904395103455,
-0.13312196731567383,
0.7226976752281189,
-0.3005386292934418,
-0.27135783433914185,
-0.19954940676689148,
-0.2159196138381958,
-0.30465883016586304,
-0.28348881006240845,
0.3517628610134125,
-0.09016136080026627,
-0.22229573130607605,
-0.3208865821361542,
0.7987322807312012,
-0.004018329083919525,
-0.34615424275398254,
0.1277402639389038,
0.9224183559417725,
-0.22983190417289734,
-0.27540305256843567,
-0.45057132840156555,
-0.6521061658859253,
-0.07486730068922043,
-0.03368910774588585,
0.020290933549404144,
0.5725991129875183,
-0.11672503501176834,
0.47388556599617004,
0.8939337134361267,
-0.040418557822704315,
-0.10771973431110382,
-0.009697635658085346,
0.7854127287864685,
-0.8109117150306702,
-0.4631035029888153,
-1.167232632637024,
0.3318338990211487,
-0.24196524918079376,
-0.28639933466911316,
1.0127836465835571,
0.20110711455345154,
0.4054465591907501,
0.02014162763953209,
0.6802093982696533,
-0.07606228440999985,
0.49263647198677063,
-0.5349293351173401,
0.31560301780700684,
-0.2232356071472168,
0.5105656385421753,
-0.4581078886985779,
-0.8414456248283386,
-0.5450663566589355,
0.5816451907157898,
-0.6881037950515747,
-0.18486087024211884,
0.7444985508918762,
0.843159019947052,
0.23150314390659332,
0.6815061569213867,
0.18507292866706848,
0.24916449189186096,
0.1845756471157074,
0.3887215554714203,
1.0140591859817505,
-0.36263906955718994,
0.16962507367134094,
-0.5470952391624451,
-0.46752169728279114,
0.027908479794859886,
-1.3278348445892334,
-0.9369339346885681,
-0.17848052084445953,
-0.46255314350128174,
-0.5170179605484009,
-0.15031220018863678,
1.0253536701202393,
0.34940293431282043,
-0.6394822597503662,
0.33962732553482056,
-0.5006387829780579,
0.7097901701927185,
-0.3032488524913788,
-0.29196518659591675,
0.14483307301998138,
-0.760379433631897,
-0.3645811080932617,
0.6852461099624634,
0.0524015948176384,
-0.11437901854515076,
-0.06004711985588074,
0.18891006708145142,
-0.44450968503952026,
0.11055183410644531,
0.5824099779129028,
0.20350518822669983,
-0.39618322253227234,
-0.16808173060417175,
0.273014634847641,
0.3756176233291626,
0.011125536635518074,
0.2693457305431366,
-1.5213905572891235,
0.4475840628147125,
0.7796627283096313,
0.7030359506607056,
0.13838739693164825,
0.30772334337234497,
0.471285879611969,
-0.406200110912323,
0.2074545919895172,
0.299492746591568,
0.11704361438751221,
0.2595815658569336,
-0.2786486744880676,
0.38148823380470276,
0.34122219681739807,
-0.30325421690940857,
-0.7395846843719482,
0.2904142439365387,
-0.7597787976264954,
-0.2526882290840149,
0.8978451490402222,
0.2779046893119812,
-0.0623580701649189,
-0.2642979621887207,
-0.27755728363990784,
0.07325258105993271,
-0.6306219696998596,
0.572393536567688,
0.6478849649429321,
-0.15148970484733582,
0.25058743357658386,
-0.4591687023639679,
0.3843218982219696,
0.7666935920715332,
-0.6098730564117432,
-0.1610628366470337,
0.8400703072547913,
-0.04209362715482712,
0.4010780155658722,
0.5856998562812805,
0.105824775993824,
0.32623323798179626,
0.09378554672002792,
-0.43067342042922974,
-0.3706948161125183,
-0.33996838331222534,
-0.5100824236869812,
0.1433514952659607,
-0.2947714626789093,
-0.13576044142246246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06699v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06699v1
|
ChatSOS: Vector Database Augmented Generative Question Answering Assistant in Safety Engineering
| 2024-05-08T07:21:26 | 2024-05-08T07:21:26 |
Haiyang Tang, Dongping Chen, Qingzhao Chu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the rapid advancement of natural language processing technologies,
generative artificial intelligence techniques, represented by large language
models (LLMs), are gaining increasing prominence and demonstrating significant
potential for applications in safety engineering. However, fundamental LLMs
face constraints such as limited training data coverage and unreliable
responses. This study develops a vector database from 117 explosion accident
reports in China spanning 2013 to 2023, employing techniques such as corpus
segmenting and vector embedding. By utilizing the vector database, which
outperforms the relational database in information retrieval quality, we
provide LLMs with richer, more relevant knowledge. Comparative analysis of LLMs
demonstrates that ChatSOS significantly enhances reliability, accuracy, and
comprehensiveness, improves adaptability and clarification of responses. These
results illustrate the effectiveness of supplementing LLMs with an external
database, highlighting their potential to handle professional queries in safety
engineering and laying a foundation for broader applications.
|
[
-0.06758550554513931,
-0.6994798183441162,
0.49453750252723694,
0.3682032525539398,
-0.09457895904779434,
0.4661197364330292,
0.2776985466480255,
-0.3842334747314453,
0.2474229484796524,
0.37326374650001526,
-0.3109050393104553,
-0.5193025469779968,
-0.2751656472682953,
-0.002464503515511751,
-0.7917351126670837,
0.6448473930358887,
0.10487522929906845,
-0.011894075199961662,
-0.24345919489860535,
0.1372295767068863,
-0.361606240272522,
-0.8004862070083618,
-0.9037739634513855,
0.35058310627937317,
0.24082297086715698,
0.214197039604187,
0.8086496591567993,
0.4706358313560486,
0.6896247267723083,
0.48450085520744324,
-0.4002021551132202,
0.41404131054878235,
-0.35109639167785645,
0.28631556034088135,
0.23949839174747467,
-0.3759157061576843,
-0.4915240406990051,
-0.49480944871902466,
0.5792024731636047,
0.6492207050323486,
-0.32540884613990784,
-0.3771189749240875,
0.10027680546045303,
0.42832785844802856,
-0.6007554531097412,
-0.07584615051746368,
-0.5982971787452698,
0.2964085340499878,
0.2392551600933075,
-0.5995071530342102,
-0.49659180641174316,
-0.8006540536880493,
0.3367409110069275,
-0.5503100752830505,
0.07285226881504059,
0.2770650088787079,
0.5411128401756287,
0.32973456382751465,
-0.5552471876144409,
-0.2865011692047119,
-0.7989895343780518,
0.6371922492980957,
-0.2842387855052948,
0.5308724045753479,
0.20810289680957794,
0.36796846985816956,
-0.5476343631744385,
-0.7012946605682373,
-0.2937842011451721,
-0.14751070737838745,
0.05455878749489784,
0.07538437098264694,
0.3530398905277252,
0.28451254963874817,
0.04598810523748398,
0.2839524447917938,
-0.6796855926513672,
-0.032302625477313995,
-0.6040623784065247,
-0.43558961153030396,
0.9373149275779724,
0.5302017331123352,
0.7153259515762329,
-0.3446444272994995,
-0.6037433743476868,
-0.23051828145980835,
-0.9160321950912476,
0.025878679007291794,
0.16969060897827148,
-0.009089167229831219,
-0.10758795589208603,
0.41749340295791626,
-0.2729623019695282,
0.5239292979240417,
-0.6686439514160156,
-0.16724893450737,
0.4581921100616455,
-0.20986786484718323,
-0.35629406571388245,
0.09945471584796906,
1.1630688905715942,
0.34544795751571655,
0.05202817544341087,
-0.42656347155570984,
0.07043907791376114,
-0.3326219618320465,
0.2634172737598419,
-0.6180465817451477,
-0.19121965765953064,
0.5754126310348511,
-0.22647027671337128,
-0.4452041685581207,
0.09001810103654861,
-0.9131324291229248,
-0.6751486659049988,
-0.22686612606048584,
0.18569479882717133,
-0.6457691192626953,
-0.3108850121498108,
0.08491624146699905,
-0.23368459939956665,
0.3706824779510498,
0.2033713012933731,
-0.5994959473609924,
-0.150766521692276,
0.7712854146957397,
0.8941130042076111,
-0.11013677716255188,
-0.08461805433034897,
-0.6808388233184814,
0.2602747678756714,
-0.6984995007514954,
0.929199755191803,
-0.42766693234443665,
-0.8801607489585876,
0.25442296266555786,
0.15525858104228973,
0.0415119007229805,
-0.5192304849624634,
0.9082303643226624,
-0.7081394791603088,
-0.01183388102799654,
-0.16870076954364777,
-0.28696826100349426,
-0.07986262440681458,
0.31191036105155945,
-0.37673792243003845,
1.163679838180542,
-0.2087482213973999,
-0.7551591396331787,
0.0503428615629673,
-0.33488500118255615,
-0.5134660601615906,
0.05431055277585983,
-0.5597344040870667,
-0.46849194169044495,
-0.24688789248466492,
0.2988729178905487,
0.4802404046058655,
-0.2436351627111435,
0.2218499481678009,
-0.20445558428764343,
-0.16966849565505981,
0.4462745189666748,
-0.31639865040779114,
1.0115232467651367,
0.10633089393377304,
0.48973456025123596,
0.41604334115982056,
-0.8275197148323059,
0.03822515904903412,
-0.04708196967840195,
-0.5204492211341858,
-0.4003852903842926,
0.3415370285511017,
-0.07523812353610992,
0.188261941075325,
0.1797904521226883,
-0.7111873626708984,
-0.18814000487327576,
-0.7903273701667786,
0.27342259883880615,
0.5564244985580444,
0.4198415279388428,
0.25254958868026733,
-0.36653563380241394,
0.5218328833580017,
0.06766893714666367,
0.32208359241485596,
-0.03524415194988251,
-0.5899564027786255,
-0.8579966425895691,
0.05216820538043976,
-0.04239858686923981,
0.9812706708908081,
-1.2115038633346558,
0.3029748201370239,
-0.15622204542160034,
-0.46370601654052734,
-0.2644890546798706,
-0.03561509773135185,
0.1290462464094162,
0.6010002493858337,
0.34701111912727356,
0.13327863812446594,
-1.14833664894104,
-0.6886216998100281,
0.09743019193410873,
-0.45183923840522766,
-0.6074010729789734,
0.17455744743347168,
0.04125432297587395,
-0.043449800461530685,
0.8318102955818176,
-0.5464662909507751,
0.05173809826374054,
-0.07739229500293732,
-0.04550650715827942,
0.006187694612890482,
0.33156245946884155,
0.5679782629013062,
-0.7914987206459045,
-0.3707895576953888,
0.20068952441215515,
-1.0828959941864014,
0.3340364396572113,
0.1535186767578125,
-0.45032259821891785,
0.021677549928426743,
0.7574394941329956,
-0.38574203848838806,
0.011048255488276482,
0.5288392901420593,
-0.2528229057788849,
0.41568565368652344,
-0.06166289374232292,
0.30037519335746765,
-1.215341567993164,
-0.17854882776737213,
-0.24728788435459137,
-0.08673093467950821,
-0.8657995462417603,
-0.14472199976444244,
0.11578244715929031,
-0.2320016771554947,
-0.8745620846748352,
-0.02971021644771099,
-0.28703567385673523,
-0.0653872862458229,
-0.15240523219108582,
0.2779737710952759,
-0.12671776115894318,
0.23023974895477295,
0.0059302193112671375,
1.103581428527832,
0.7975093722343445,
-0.8405230641365051,
0.5538821816444397,
0.7319928407669067,
-0.36065810918807983,
0.35718923807144165,
-0.873270571231842,
0.20170822739601135,
-0.5324882864952087,
-0.20330798625946045,
-0.9531357884407043,
-0.544352650642395,
0.13459061086177826,
-0.3725617229938507,
0.08306403458118439,
-0.23570860922336578,
-0.2932617664337158,
-0.3960212469100952,
-0.5407009124755859,
-0.12851934134960175,
0.71123868227005,
-0.6030488014221191,
0.5769671201705933,
0.9191466569900513,
-0.6468618512153625,
-0.6028488278388977,
-0.4101521074771881,
0.03893455117940903,
-0.2620667517185211,
-0.8832708597183228,
0.17521102726459503,
-0.17021963000297546,
-0.32767951488494873,
-0.22847223281860352,
0.019426042214035988,
-0.4218648672103882,
0.15548445284366608,
0.27132776379585266,
0.727355420589447,
-0.3817603588104248,
0.4666869640350342,
0.16166983544826508,
0.15190085768699646,
0.3208981156349182,
0.4876824915409088,
0.39880841970443726,
-0.15758773684501648,
-0.10491890460252762,
-0.16123762726783752,
0.4633947014808655,
0.4178951382637024,
-0.11180117726325989,
0.9621743559837341,
-0.056542351841926575,
-0.316174179315567,
-0.021607279777526855,
-0.14613912999629974,
0.05414293706417084,
-0.6169098019599915,
0.3945241868495941,
-0.10961254686117172,
-0.7962645888328552,
0.33649057149887085,
-0.11130781471729279,
0.4228706657886505,
0.5935831665992737,
0.4388697147369385,
-0.5178825259208679,
1.0158352851867676,
0.3626461625099182,
-0.1991538256406784,
0.27693143486976624,
0.03143388777971268,
-0.035179927945137024,
-0.7674107551574707,
-0.5499224066734314,
-0.709502637386322,
0.15388397872447968,
-0.38282912969589233,
-0.5068297982215881,
0.8724004626274109,
-0.09925424307584763,
-0.3170669376850128,
0.10266631096601486,
-0.7758209109306335,
0.3726276755332947,
0.011213765479624271,
0.23615872859954834,
0.5300511121749878,
-0.04401133209466934,
0.2102166712284088,
0.3093789219856262,
-0.7480402588844299,
-0.5247889757156372,
0.8437632918357849,
0.4695354700088501,
0.8947237133979797,
0.25924134254455566,
0.22352632880210876,
0.029402878135442734,
0.3289088308811188,
-0.5667658448219299,
0.6622990965843201,
0.09788613766431808,
-0.6127641201019287,
-0.5532088279724121,
-0.45141011476516724,
-1.0161683559417725,
0.422299861907959,
-0.38609594106674194,
-0.41583314538002014,
0.15434911847114563,
0.10963547974824905,
-0.5915466547012329,
0.07892222702503204,
-0.7678678631782532,
0.5220001935958862,
-0.4374763071537018,
0.13232608139514923,
0.10235721617937088,
-0.4632077217102051,
0.5479557514190674,
0.05035460740327835,
0.2731058597564697,
-0.3833310008049011,
-0.17096629738807678,
0.9422087073326111,
-0.5356163382530212,
0.722450852394104,
0.133368581533432,
-0.18586726486682892,
0.6412896513938904,
-0.2192704677581787,
0.6047078371047974,
0.19402143359184265,
-0.31191369891166687,
-0.030106132850050926,
0.20359978079795837,
-0.05444963648915291,
-0.4432106912136078,
0.8724003434181213,
-0.7870893478393555,
-0.5275535583496094,
-0.39217108488082886,
-0.5619823336601257,
-0.6511388421058655,
-0.08286770433187485,
0.21223050355911255,
0.42535048723220825,
-0.3867970108985901,
0.3913850784301758,
0.982326328754425,
-0.7078978419303894,
0.5503966212272644,
0.3695331811904907,
-0.15104010701179504,
-0.24900148808956146,
0.9058335423469543,
0.04660002142190933,
-0.10971475392580032,
0.39550960063934326,
-0.033353712409734726,
-0.23647266626358032,
-0.53289794921875,
-0.3676760792732239,
-0.03926907852292061,
-0.6656275391578674,
-0.3869234025478363,
-0.9921189546585083,
-0.9356060028076172,
-0.19448785483837128,
-0.012278764508664608,
-0.3478642404079437,
-0.37820690870285034,
-0.07627581804990768,
-0.27789002656936646,
0.7488818764686584,
0.4630962312221527,
0.30479785799980164,
0.11384348571300507,
-1.019332766532898,
0.3958815038204193,
0.4462757110595703,
0.5333623886108398,
-0.16882939636707306,
-0.2073613405227661,
0.015205075033009052,
-0.05453049764037132,
-0.3941290080547333,
-1.0712379217147827,
0.28923434019088745,
0.09869419038295746,
0.4834986925125122,
0.2967725396156311,
0.40874090790748596,
0.2390436977148056,
-0.624370813369751,
0.5834046006202698,
0.07292746752500534,
-0.41107603907585144,
0.6643495559692383,
-0.43474850058555603,
-0.1891023963689804,
0.12323117256164551,
0.6386229395866394,
-0.4971335232257843,
-0.3450031280517578,
-0.2849695682525635,
-0.8688086867332458,
0.5052306056022644,
0.4409692585468292,
0.1608555018901825,
-0.13593943417072296,
0.021547269076108932,
-0.22328118979930878,
-0.03043488599359989,
-0.17653211951255798,
-0.23038697242736816,
0.093141108751297,
-0.29698440432548523,
0.3855920135974884,
-0.6087111830711365,
-0.21727412939071655,
0.024526657536625862,
0.8903034925460815,
0.09963617473840714,
0.45772892236709595,
0.15730813145637512,
0.16787217557430267,
0.09856291115283966,
0.5348066687583923,
0.34039732813835144,
0.44815853238105774,
-0.25234347581863403,
0.03810877352952957,
0.7285007238388062,
-0.6032580137252808,
0.1458674818277359,
0.19422411918640137,
-0.2039145529270172,
0.19544130563735962,
0.04405750706791878,
0.4603140354156494,
0.005353367887437344,
-1.066338062286377,
0.17590107023715973,
-0.09355036169290543,
-0.029807263985276222,
-0.7086005210876465,
0.4445044696331024,
0.18621951341629028,
-0.019814740866422653,
0.502734363079071,
-0.30372652411460876,
0.5396177172660828,
-0.3184143006801605,
0.10612665861845016,
0.41372278332710266,
-0.3166532516479492,
-0.046884048730134964,
0.8037290573120117,
0.5074055194854736,
-0.27791568636894226,
0.317758172750473,
0.24538473784923553,
-0.24389086663722992,
0.9141497611999512,
-0.030047206208109856,
0.6549556851387024,
-0.6540849208831787,
0.17807437479496002,
0.4630160927772522,
0.6004932522773743,
0.07062261551618576,
0.7507537603378296,
0.47264525294303894,
-0.6626876592636108,
-0.5978679656982422,
-0.5440829396247864,
-0.8395559191703796,
0.14493021368980408,
-0.21805506944656372,
0.238779678940773,
-0.5140010714530945,
0.04121387004852295,
-0.1697065532207489,
-0.6144769191741943,
-0.30740585923194885,
0.3156270980834961,
-0.03813047707080841,
0.8042670488357544,
-0.49246886372566223,
0.5709962248802185,
0.6952471137046814,
-0.39007964730262756,
-0.5393452644348145,
-0.17883381247520447,
-0.20422372221946716,
-0.5930816531181335,
0.29078376293182373,
-0.2001798301935196,
0.1300174593925476,
-0.28631481528282166,
-0.42477160692214966,
-1.0638997554779053,
0.8941701054573059,
0.3873070478439331,
-0.5529271960258484,
-0.22150573134422302,
0.5123200416564941,
0.5360047817230225,
0.2641677260398865,
0.11904548108577728,
0.5479398369789124,
-0.18982835114002228,
0.18723605573177338,
-0.7299965023994446,
-0.022510303184390068,
-0.1137874573469162,
0.0062244045548141,
0.29596713185310364,
-0.5819219350814819,
0.2945482134819031,
0.06649444997310638,
-0.2880098819732666,
-0.007844502106308937,
1.0550634860992432,
0.45089268684387207,
0.23929628729820251,
0.3957381844520569,
-0.0028894515708088875,
0.8177728652954102,
-0.0245969258248806,
1.1236745119094849,
-0.30585965514183044,
0.040673740208148956,
1.053033471107483,
0.07363509386777878,
1.0502185821533203,
0.2895320653915405,
-0.4431358575820923,
0.4441666007041931,
0.39911729097366333,
0.443558007478714,
0.27535417675971985,
-0.31523045897483826,
-0.606976330280304,
-0.20053982734680176,
-0.2592267096042633,
-0.6533253192901611,
0.1791956126689911,
0.6982573866844177,
-0.35067522525787354,
-0.09509432315826416,
0.11772576719522476,
-0.09803150594234467,
-0.24416279792785645,
-0.16567714512348175,
0.601131796836853,
0.15340209007263184,
-0.4499790370464325,
0.4454403221607208,
-0.02246841788291931,
0.3235098719596863,
-0.4367663562297821,
0.008346224203705788,
-0.3323451578617096,
-0.12007573992013931,
-0.28709644079208374,
-1.2003997564315796,
0.6240951418876648,
0.07691756635904312,
0.12175188958644867,
0.05370184779167175,
0.8668996691703796,
-0.31667062640190125,
-0.5199641585350037,
-0.29674574732780457,
0.2034226804971695,
0.15461431443691254,
0.16619031131267548,
-0.2875199615955353,
0.08048317581415176,
-0.20277774333953857,
-0.019774526357650757,
0.19121421873569489,
0.4497899115085602,
0.01713692583143711,
0.8880950808525085,
0.5406426191329956,
-0.33336585760116577,
0.2800094485282898,
-0.23333682119846344,
1.0914382934570312,
-0.5071337223052979,
-0.6916407346725464,
-0.5087631940841675,
0.5338588953018188,
-0.4340481758117676,
-0.05609705299139023,
0.7724129557609558,
0.6322938799858093,
0.22856904566287994,
-0.07834699004888535,
1.137900710105896,
-0.06177273392677307,
0.9730009436607361,
-0.5806439518928528,
0.7127799987792969,
-0.18176649510860443,
0.3868112862110138,
-0.12090052664279938,
-0.4834103286266327,
-0.17270317673683167,
0.3249810039997101,
-0.25234928727149963,
-0.2917817533016205,
0.3055134415626526,
0.8071487545967102,
0.11961346864700317,
0.20029376447200775,
0.3101760745048523,
0.37775537371635437,
0.3930654227733612,
0.660244882106781,
1.2261278629302979,
-0.6444689631462097,
1.1511976718902588,
-0.2427205741405487,
0.00872285570949316,
-0.16553941369056702,
-0.6724348068237305,
-1.038008689880371,
-0.33029359579086304,
-0.34144270420074463,
-0.2393997460603714,
0.16898761689662933,
0.8838605880737305,
0.5053402185440063,
-1.0578500032424927,
0.07431719452142715,
-0.013881833292543888,
0.17839711904525757,
0.3547486662864685,
-0.2082042247056961,
0.5842634439468384,
-0.2809408903121948,
-0.6363331079483032,
0.8391450047492981,
0.4432690143585205,
0.1104411706328392,
-0.2165789157152176,
-0.20516926050186157,
0.009199202060699463,
0.23667366802692413,
0.9044167995452881,
0.5340531468391418,
-0.21237538754940033,
-0.3880400061607361,
0.13759207725524902,
-0.18138234317302704,
0.11559149622917175,
0.4149037301540375,
-0.6054875254631042,
0.3122105300426483,
0.912830114364624,
0.9866962432861328,
-0.03328093886375427,
-0.028960444033145905,
0.5860282182693481,
-0.8365914225578308,
0.459676057100296,
0.11799705773591995,
0.4385206401348114,
0.4466438889503479,
-0.6597228646278381,
0.6085960865020752,
-0.026924794539809227,
-0.6179446578025818,
-0.6935306787490845,
0.04167093336582184,
-0.7391958832740784,
-0.18017101287841797,
1.172471284866333,
0.17781636118888855,
-0.04216965660452843,
-0.6288651823997498,
-0.583156406879425,
0.20727945864200592,
-0.1772790402173996,
0.9043241143226624,
0.33469119668006897,
-0.24919387698173523,
-0.365493506193161,
-0.8218098282814026,
0.7014041543006897,
0.3030312657356262,
-1.372141718864441,
-0.3005944490432739,
0.5942210555076599,
0.12090857326984406,
-0.03511327877640724,
0.5537859201431274,
-0.11239289492368698,
0.5022923946380615,
-0.1302034556865692,
0.02168678119778633,
0.2557689845561981,
-0.29566606879234314,
0.22744722664356232,
0.48828864097595215,
0.014559712260961533,
-0.542969286441803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04829v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04829v2
|
Fine-tuning Pre-trained Named Entity Recognition Models For Indian Languages
| 2024-05-08T05:54:54 | 2024-05-10T12:57:50 |
Sankalp Bahad, Pruthwik Mishra, Karunesh Arora, Rakesh Chandra Balabantaray, Dipti Misra Sharma, Parameswari Krishnamurthy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a useful component in Natural Language
Processing (NLP) applications. It is used in various tasks such as Machine
Translation, Summarization, Information Retrieval, and Question-Answering
systems. The research on NER is centered around English and some other major
languages, whereas limited attention has been given to Indian languages. We
analyze the challenges and propose techniques that can be tailored for
Multilingual Named Entity Recognition for Indian Languages. We present a human
annotated named entity corpora of 40K sentences for 4 Indian languages from two
of the major Indian language families. Additionally,we present a multilingual
model fine-tuned on our dataset, which achieves an F1 score of 0.80 on our
dataset on average. We achieve comparable performance on completely unseen
benchmark datasets for Indian languages which affirms the usability of our
model.
|
[
-0.5804892182350159,
-0.5322869420051575,
0.14088954031467438,
0.14889611303806305,
-0.42375993728637695,
0.0883050188422203,
-0.5687864422798157,
-0.8467845320701599,
0.28189095854759216,
0.4498658776283264,
-0.21610328555107117,
-0.2683160901069641,
-0.5419478416442871,
0.7222841382026672,
-0.3522002696990967,
0.974218487739563,
0.00037268901360221207,
0.038534097373485565,
0.016512971371412277,
-0.2770523130893707,
-0.5689668655395508,
-0.4967033863067627,
-0.9438193440437317,
-0.22427737712860107,
0.34776803851127625,
0.4683479070663452,
0.3068845570087433,
0.4819735288619995,
0.7703610062599182,
0.3032907247543335,
0.04401658475399017,
0.43181827664375305,
-0.15791669487953186,
0.3097427189350128,
-0.23926307260990143,
-0.2947990298271179,
-0.34238243103027344,
-0.38799580931663513,
0.8959213495254517,
0.7280911207199097,
-0.18623840808868408,
0.1928205043077469,
-0.06726306676864624,
0.490268349647522,
-0.6535008549690247,
0.1661507934331894,
-0.8063057661056519,
-0.17111080884933472,
-0.5925742387771606,
-0.11455351859331131,
-0.4269125759601593,
-0.35642823576927185,
0.19434145092964172,
-0.6598612070083618,
0.22044974565505981,
0.15706868469715118,
1.132187008857727,
0.3151431977748871,
-0.27856212854385376,
-0.39463213086128235,
-0.9442619681358337,
0.8002094626426697,
-0.47034186124801636,
0.7460268139839172,
0.41171547770500183,
0.31134918332099915,
-0.015667937695980072,
-0.3446543514728546,
-0.6228060126304626,
-0.04390563443303108,
-0.23559221625328064,
-0.31576237082481384,
-0.10719861090183258,
-0.16739094257354736,
0.2739396095275879,
0.4486730992794037,
-0.4020250737667084,
0.14705072343349457,
-0.3884184956550598,
-0.30136433243751526,
0.5753551721572876,
-0.0202315840870142,
0.514036238193512,
-0.09627427905797958,
-0.2869718074798584,
0.11777441203594208,
-0.6677438616752625,
-0.024944178760051727,
0.3980332612991333,
0.5973061323165894,
0.10134095698595047,
0.47943115234375,
-0.5265774726867676,
0.9372721314430237,
0.18146221339702606,
-0.16172271966934204,
0.29362568259239197,
-0.17356902360916138,
-0.11050296574831009,
0.21179544925689697,
0.48944413661956787,
0.210469052195549,
0.6824607849121094,
-0.34602487087249756,
-0.3443301022052765,
0.07467533648014069,
-0.0455416738986969,
-0.727203905582428,
-0.17531679570674896,
-0.2658548653125763,
-0.1645003855228424,
0.05605098232626915,
-0.26374444365501404,
-0.818393886089325,
-0.3629114627838135,
-0.7074112296104431,
0.18904124200344086,
-0.6152277588844299,
-0.57232266664505,
-0.09233779460191727,
0.16570451855659485,
0.6604216694831848,
0.2168462723493576,
-1.0739896297454834,
0.45251134037971497,
0.5760046243667603,
0.44284260272979736,
-0.15348048508167267,
-0.35472923517227173,
-0.5229614973068237,
0.015956925228238106,
-0.20930537581443787,
1.140871524810791,
-0.9532389044761658,
-0.2982288897037506,
-0.22619614005088806,
-0.0837814211845398,
-0.29367291927337646,
-0.559552013874054,
0.49210667610168457,
-0.6693558692932129,
-0.2115519642829895,
-0.17237889766693115,
-0.6279076337814331,
-0.2541591227054596,
0.4859963655471802,
-0.4939449429512024,
0.7018350958824158,
-0.16198275983333588,
-0.8493525981903076,
0.6210193037986755,
-0.6150574088096619,
-0.6477507948875427,
0.33415859937667847,
-0.13313139975070953,
-0.17237414419651031,
0.2749605178833008,
0.4645415246486664,
0.4580640196800232,
-0.33573421835899353,
0.29858720302581787,
-0.04665350914001465,
-0.21225802600383759,
-0.09135538339614868,
-0.23231424391269684,
0.4520420432090759,
0.25804561376571655,
0.0529792346060276,
-0.020771684125065804,
-1.1873703002929688,
0.30382290482521057,
-0.10169616341590881,
-0.1326703131198883,
-0.7294802665710449,
-0.21910777688026428,
0.28617075085639954,
0.04141481593251228,
0.14215688407421112,
-0.5929997563362122,
0.02005534991621971,
-0.5421622395515442,
0.5112762451171875,
0.24765370786190033,
0.128935769200325,
0.5593688488006592,
0.2433614730834961,
0.4159260094165802,
-0.045177049934864044,
-0.06271903961896896,
-0.09746846556663513,
-0.2742534577846527,
-0.952057421207428,
-0.15172888338565826,
0.9428415298461914,
0.621945858001709,
-0.5080556869506836,
-0.1274547129869461,
-0.40697821974754333,
-0.5196148157119751,
-0.6798493266105652,
0.07736003398895264,
0.4607754051685333,
0.5319268703460693,
0.4771452844142914,
-0.22677256166934967,
-0.7756419777870178,
-1.1761982440948486,
-0.42633530497550964,
0.1352398693561554,
0.3049151301383972,
0.06338523328304291,
0.5327751636505127,
-0.32569488883018494,
0.9227048754692078,
-0.36296120285987854,
-0.3755780756473541,
-0.13620872795581818,
0.2538163959980011,
-0.11423264443874359,
0.517612874507904,
0.09830804914236069,
-1.164193868637085,
-0.5724512338638306,
0.020248016342520714,
-0.5171679258346558,
0.14245067536830902,
-0.00783532951027155,
0.020451417192816734,
0.3150478005409241,
0.7781348824501038,
-0.5378774404525757,
0.35163888335227966,
0.26172274351119995,
-0.02239689975976944,
0.41193926334381104,
-0.3523423373699188,
0.16793420910835266,
-1.3315002918243408,
0.013564462773501873,
0.0033045548480004072,
-0.18098068237304688,
-0.6250208616256714,
0.20157381892204285,
0.24496124684810638,
-0.23796352744102478,
-0.3858991265296936,
0.8856140971183777,
-0.970190167427063,
0.06392379105091095,
-0.2427186518907547,
0.024587657302618027,
-0.361132949590683,
0.25724026560783386,
0.3165968358516693,
0.8439062237739563,
0.6708407998085022,
-0.9001195430755615,
0.06289917230606079,
0.2938752770423889,
-0.2393028736114502,
1.1193959712982178,
-0.6366221904754639,
0.20882998406887054,
-0.22086594998836517,
-0.29850560426712036,
-0.4595702886581421,
-0.44546568393707275,
0.08301270753145218,
-0.47163477540016174,
0.7271754145622253,
-0.2355441004037857,
-0.4552461802959442,
0.06672821193933487,
0.19183044135570526,
0.4762082099914551,
0.12408383190631866,
-0.426893949508667,
0.8256576657295227,
0.7185848951339722,
-0.1711314618587494,
-0.44443172216415405,
-0.743964672088623,
0.2141357660293579,
-0.2928757667541504,
-0.32654473185539246,
0.3780563473701477,
0.02987152524292469,
-0.1407172679901123,
-0.03291948512196541,
-0.06340587139129639,
-0.5148574709892273,
-0.026336027309298515,
0.4792705178260803,
0.07154521346092224,
-0.2741088569164276,
0.26039251685142517,
-0.0469234324991703,
-0.4447462856769562,
-0.32856011390686035,
0.05907630920410156,
0.4010907709598541,
-0.4843628406524658,
-0.13221299648284912,
-0.45995214581489563,
0.3372843861579895,
0.2942178547382355,
-0.8622836470603943,
0.6492012143135071,
0.7030067443847656,
-1.0186959505081177,
0.121403269469738,
-0.712727427482605,
-0.03584962710738182,
-0.34139370918273926,
0.2088756412267685,
-0.6861405372619629,
-0.8203235268592834,
0.580686092376709,
-0.13448311388492584,
-0.19315826892852783,
0.6109971404075623,
0.29411372542381287,
0.26442432403564453,
0.8599851727485657,
0.9729738831520081,
-0.08882627636194229,
0.28256750106811523,
0.044125430285930634,
0.6450956463813782,
-0.9435827136039734,
-0.20565645396709442,
-0.6502986550331116,
-0.1293463408946991,
-0.8846100568771362,
-0.1009054109454155,
-0.12209335714578629,
0.3127783536911011,
0.10415720194578171,
0.5894055366516113,
-0.578374445438385,
0.7616642713546753,
0.4157153069972992,
-0.3814636170864105,
0.37759071588516235,
-0.05714119225740433,
-0.13164901733398438,
-0.27032220363616943,
-0.1321178525686264,
-0.6957816481590271,
0.7620035409927368,
-0.02636263146996498,
0.601091206073761,
0.060308150947093964,
1.006504774093628,
-0.039278507232666016,
0.23588663339614868,
-0.4996260106563568,
0.5489382147789001,
-0.2092917114496231,
-0.795281171798706,
-0.3048580288887024,
-0.24025332927703857,
-0.9704482555389404,
0.07459433376789093,
-0.393586128950119,
-0.7401635050773621,
0.33860036730766296,
0.15726135671138763,
-0.587384045124054,
0.07433580607175827,
-0.9332512021064758,
0.7694911360740662,
-0.26851996779441833,
0.15646904706954956,
-0.05104365199804306,
-0.5091347694396973,
0.28147101402282715,
-0.19226530194282532,
0.19642111659049988,
-0.1279481202363968,
0.05186286196112633,
0.5825425386428833,
-0.1274469494819641,
0.3121134042739868,
-0.07809510082006454,
0.21080994606018066,
-0.013215984217822552,
-0.1552121937274933,
0.27143925428390503,
0.4880046546459198,
-0.1406964212656021,
0.2837582528591156,
0.0008001593523658812,
-0.28322967886924744,
-0.21552392840385437,
1.0141178369522095,
-0.489223837852478,
-0.23307080566883087,
-0.5905709266662598,
-0.3258736729621887,
-0.24674580991268158,
0.6760347485542297,
0.380420982837677,
0.4077335596084595,
-0.2349761724472046,
0.09879448264837265,
0.6808325052261353,
-0.0855545774102211,
0.5699329972267151,
0.6619153022766113,
-0.19706451892852783,
-0.3043260872364044,
1.0691583156585693,
0.327249139547348,
-0.13235490024089813,
0.5201228260993958,
-0.38719308376312256,
-0.2854974567890167,
-0.7544081807136536,
-0.6705759763717651,
0.2346733957529068,
-0.535741925239563,
-0.3382071256637573,
-0.8175908327102661,
-0.26668423414230347,
-0.2849850356578827,
0.08330510556697845,
-0.4789409935474396,
-0.346548467874527,
-0.36904221773147583,
0.06349726021289825,
0.28487443923950195,
0.6542320847511292,
0.10749708116054535,
0.12198632955551147,
-0.7930693626403809,
0.46190744638442993,
0.3309459388256073,
0.7131919860839844,
-0.20682939887046814,
-0.40182164311408997,
-0.00035661429865285754,
-0.06364374607801437,
0.15376117825508118,
-0.7531874775886536,
0.4167611300945282,
0.641882598400116,
0.48613041639328003,
0.1878851354122162,
-0.04654261842370033,
0.9684621691703796,
-0.7743100523948669,
0.330933153629303,
-0.18386778235435486,
-0.7765899896621704,
0.6213011741638184,
-0.014129139482975006,
0.12775416672229767,
0.8973339796066284,
0.45759281516075134,
-0.4902261197566986,
-0.08425538241863251,
-0.3778817653656006,
-0.9200703501701355,
0.3913407623767853,
0.09688177704811096,
0.2101447582244873,
-0.21714240312576294,
0.5480887293815613,
0.14424827694892883,
0.08343036472797394,
-0.5180672407150269,
-0.16705316305160522,
0.23591984808444977,
-0.0939597487449646,
-0.10799839347600937,
-0.2507898509502411,
0.44657236337661743,
-0.18130773305892944,
0.7094815969467163,
0.14260153472423553,
-0.06308083236217499,
0.25219056010246277,
-0.7132772207260132,
0.03238994628190994,
0.6467981338500977,
0.7578506469726562,
0.551935076713562,
-0.15636955201625824,
-0.027141492813825607,
0.4115554690361023,
-0.4606580436229706,
-0.011370444670319557,
0.6407195925712585,
-0.3677070736885071,
0.09326844662427902,
0.035171568393707275,
0.8578097224235535,
0.4046703577041626,
-0.5136895179748535,
0.0017753656720742583,
-0.5534254312515259,
0.2820429801940918,
-0.6908081769943237,
-0.03593134880065918,
0.13615335524082184,
0.18673084676265717,
0.23228168487548828,
0.3594033122062683,
0.24576206505298615,
-0.26028475165367126,
0.08160781115293503,
0.4147772789001465,
-0.44296184182167053,
-0.36889177560806274,
0.6550564765930176,
0.15121598541736603,
-0.6484988331794739,
0.8748964071273804,
-0.6005305647850037,
-0.4819975793361664,
0.3160754144191742,
0.38001883029937744,
0.668194055557251,
-0.3524135947227478,
0.010678695514798164,
0.5995544195175171,
0.4137624502182007,
-0.26240274310112,
0.32493358850479126,
0.14138686656951904,
-0.6387210488319397,
-0.4285469055175781,
-1.0918406248092651,
-0.42857345938682556,
0.06997430324554443,
-0.6877920031547546,
0.6431189775466919,
-0.3391159474849701,
-0.21734197437763214,
0.43432164192199707,
0.03152158111333847,
-1.0925078392028809,
0.4417154788970947,
0.47375577688217163,
0.7205960154533386,
-0.7656947374343872,
0.8678642511367798,
1.069698691368103,
-0.6786730289459229,
-0.9625310301780701,
-0.1824277937412262,
-0.32502585649490356,
-0.4705912470817566,
0.7543408870697021,
0.3628372251987457,
-0.03714269772171974,
0.39964184165000916,
-0.01585284247994423,
-1.2404738664627075,
0.675304651260376,
0.28493955731391907,
-0.8465336561203003,
-0.10523203760385513,
0.11746790260076523,
0.8227378726005554,
-0.540290892124176,
0.2705344259738922,
0.5126488208770752,
0.48356765508651733,
-0.42159804701805115,
-1.0899769067764282,
-0.2172335982322693,
-0.380359023809433,
0.19242452085018158,
0.6234455704689026,
-0.44371503591537476,
0.7952176332473755,
-0.38392117619514465,
-0.3087065815925598,
-0.02789240889251232,
0.7181592583656311,
0.11931140720844269,
0.2698345184326172,
0.6250936985015869,
0.7493334412574768,
0.9594030380249023,
-0.18014152348041534,
0.9646612405776978,
-0.38894957304000854,
0.16499894857406616,
1.4014694690704346,
-0.4771980345249176,
1.1163984537124634,
0.5538088083267212,
-0.029629681259393692,
0.33228012919425964,
0.6863871216773987,
-0.029091261327266693,
0.3805716335773468,
0.1895267516374588,
0.04225945100188255,
-0.3048330545425415,
-0.2937324345111847,
-0.469326913356781,
0.8125630021095276,
0.3522799611091614,
-0.017125023528933525,
-0.29909181594848633,
0.21390296518802643,
-0.057660069316625595,
0.12446262687444687,
-0.362146258354187,
0.748059868812561,
0.06843173503875732,
-0.6617887020111084,
0.5165470838546753,
0.0636308416724205,
0.8694961667060852,
-0.2235482931137085,
-0.2038440853357315,
-0.194827601313591,
0.24673974514007568,
-0.19712840020656586,
-0.2728441655635834,
0.5624759197235107,
0.25822606682777405,
-0.5225106477737427,
-0.025001160800457,
0.9095721244812012,
-0.6445055603981018,
-0.6651288270950317,
0.22721120715141296,
0.27530473470687866,
0.2947661578655243,
-0.2970236837863922,
-0.42091354727745056,
-0.15181377530097961,
-0.28227075934410095,
0.008810881525278091,
0.35573041439056396,
0.341977059841156,
-0.331496924161911,
0.6031748056411743,
0.5742653012275696,
0.1390499472618103,
0.29077965021133423,
0.14855358004570007,
0.3573439121246338,
-0.7831587791442871,
-0.3165207505226135,
-0.7591373920440674,
0.309142142534256,
-0.18603090941905975,
-0.5666090250015259,
0.6215000748634338,
0.654962956905365,
1.2409635782241821,
-0.1123598963022232,
0.4744163155555725,
-0.0034836321137845516,
0.907926082611084,
-0.28941792249679565,
0.8541397452354431,
-0.540087878704071,
0.11065685749053955,
-0.15352071821689606,
-1.0341993570327759,
-0.5509389638900757,
0.530703067779541,
-0.3419201970100403,
-0.08155000954866409,
0.4312751591205597,
0.6561017632484436,
-0.09822715073823929,
0.04941794276237488,
0.12921692430973053,
-0.046598970890045166,
0.09804144501686096,
0.40365397930145264,
0.6584649085998535,
-0.56990647315979,
0.5839712619781494,
-0.38721391558647156,
0.21570350229740143,
-0.13075873255729675,
-1.0132774114608765,
-0.8034636974334717,
-0.6518795490264893,
-0.4647904634475708,
0.20530009269714355,
0.06132164224982262,
0.8768009543418884,
0.796312689781189,
-1.2152169942855835,
0.15516428649425507,
-0.01683572493493557,
0.05755147710442543,
0.051342520862817764,
-0.14529526233673096,
0.21856176853179932,
-0.3660213053226471,
-0.7815501093864441,
0.3237502872943878,
0.29202577471733093,
-0.09269953519105911,
0.10669784992933273,
0.02082369476556778,
-0.5540564060211182,
-0.14059242606163025,
0.4399997293949127,
0.5544818043708801,
-0.7647445797920227,
-0.20255877077579498,
0.02748623676598072,
-0.06519526243209839,
-0.010662551037967205,
0.6106453537940979,
-0.597627580165863,
0.5721122026443481,
0.27006471157073975,
0.8654571175575256,
0.1629326343536377,
-0.2253088802099228,
0.3012527525424957,
-0.7003592848777771,
0.04818665608763695,
0.25918278098106384,
0.43641728162765503,
0.9531689286231995,
-0.2968077063560486,
0.5648844838142395,
-0.04622172191739082,
-0.5655606985092163,
-1.0651737451553345,
0.05136066675186157,
-0.7373219728469849,
0.25558197498321533,
0.8119635581970215,
0.07657957822084427,
-0.04972870647907257,
-0.2074403166770935,
-0.11002074182033539,
0.4449423849582672,
-0.297760933637619,
0.3949260711669922,
0.7826120853424072,
-0.008433273062109947,
-0.30387571454048157,
-0.6969563364982605,
0.5641241073608398,
0.2818711996078491,
-0.8279111385345459,
-0.12981291115283966,
0.2938694953918457,
0.568190336227417,
0.4886525869369507,
0.6450899243354797,
-0.0030971758533269167,
0.1713913083076477,
-0.35063549876213074,
0.26493242383003235,
0.07649026811122894,
-0.46438318490982056,
-0.5168129205703735,
-0.007020346820354462,
0.26161837577819824,
-0.1584717184305191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04828v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04828v1
|
ChuXin: 1.6B Technical Report
| 2024-05-08T05:54:44 | 2024-05-08T05:54:44 |
Xiaomin Zhuang, Yufan Jiang, Qiaozhi He, Zhihua Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this report, we present ChuXin, an entirely open-source language model
with a size of 1.6 billion parameters. Unlike the majority of works that only
open-sourced the model weights and architecture, we have made everything needed
to train a model available, including the training data, the training process,
and the evaluation code. Our goal is to empower and strengthen the open
research community, fostering transparency and enabling a new wave of
innovation in the field of language modeling. Furthermore, we extend the
context length to 1M tokens through lightweight continual pretraining and
demonstrate strong needle-in-a-haystack retrieval performance. The weights for
both models are available at Hugging Face to download and use.
|
[
0.009541711769998074,
-0.6281186938285828,
0.3748132884502411,
0.380855917930603,
-0.4196837544441223,
-0.5265493392944336,
-0.14469371736049652,
-0.5078955292701721,
0.25176942348480225,
0.681534469127655,
-0.27631232142448425,
-0.21428264677524567,
-0.36680909991264343,
-0.29174691438674927,
-0.7573549151420593,
0.8374248147010803,
0.3920295238494873,
0.0317319892346859,
0.03856072202324867,
-0.0876605361700058,
-0.2462887167930603,
-0.3368402123451233,
-0.4979201853275299,
-0.22842812538146973,
0.7020836472511292,
0.4470064640045166,
0.7103872895240784,
0.9873573780059814,
0.35878050327301025,
0.19115090370178223,
0.029170561581850052,
-0.6875641345977783,
-0.5369361042976379,
-0.2857062816619873,
-0.04058733955025673,
-0.41153740882873535,
-0.5312998294830322,
0.36727386713027954,
0.9397573471069336,
0.9825859069824219,
-0.3643482029438019,
0.12462325394153595,
-0.22821557521820068,
0.6997064352035522,
-0.5413150787353516,
0.22779981791973114,
-0.789289116859436,
-0.15178361535072327,
-0.6006115674972534,
0.1649516224861145,
-0.6041502356529236,
-0.24940213561058044,
0.20554834604263306,
-0.6148210763931274,
-0.22274869680404663,
0.044686105102300644,
0.7858590483665466,
0.09002306312322617,
-0.16852737963199615,
-0.04883170127868652,
-0.2591085135936737,
0.8733642101287842,
-0.8320730328559875,
0.7599614262580872,
0.3375469446182251,
0.23500202596187592,
0.16108101606369019,
-1.185605525970459,
-0.1625625044107437,
-0.4540657103061676,
-0.039981018751859665,
-0.010433007031679153,
0.10127180814743042,
0.020849009975790977,
0.1460374891757965,
0.3183683156967163,
-0.49867549538612366,
0.06123780831694603,
-0.6706240773200989,
-0.19293352961540222,
0.6647125482559204,
-0.06362929940223694,
0.09074558317661285,
-0.019595855847001076,
-0.25962957739830017,
0.22666773200035095,
-0.5112022757530212,
-0.08160566538572311,
0.36742809414863586,
0.3644286096096039,
-0.43312397599220276,
0.25422170758247375,
-0.3613389730453491,
0.7521262168884277,
-0.19291150569915771,
0.2920793890953064,
0.2916640341281891,
-0.26208552718162537,
-0.31945979595184326,
0.18885527551174164,
0.8971965909004211,
-0.07551024109125137,
0.12152766436338425,
-0.4512351453304291,
-0.0029353578574955463,
-0.21896836161613464,
0.5202848315238953,
-0.8800931572914124,
-0.09090010821819305,
0.38595595955848694,
-0.5133927464485168,
-0.35795313119888306,
0.39251330494880676,
-0.7145602703094482,
-0.33804604411125183,
-0.1437554955482483,
0.3680393099784851,
-0.6677091717720032,
-0.5479079484939575,
0.38051044940948486,
-0.21701501309871674,
0.450381875038147,
0.2771340608596802,
-0.6513720750808716,
0.29729193449020386,
0.7363681793212891,
0.9779977202415466,
0.042146481573581696,
-0.4386850893497467,
-0.7647063732147217,
-0.33948102593421936,
-0.40142545104026794,
0.39836105704307556,
-0.6534983515739441,
-0.31126752495765686,
0.14355581998825073,
0.08628963679075241,
0.13986946642398834,
-0.23080070316791534,
0.6580580472946167,
-0.4303816258907318,
0.08318319171667099,
-0.08065961301326752,
-0.46421653032302856,
-0.14443974196910858,
-0.18308788537979126,
-0.77757728099823,
0.9739617705345154,
0.5854771733283997,
-0.8692514896392822,
0.08092541247606277,
-0.6796057820320129,
-0.08573053777217865,
0.7074608206748962,
0.20859786868095398,
-0.05449283495545387,
0.2986951172351837,
-0.3983820676803589,
0.04604249820113182,
-0.5268032550811768,
0.25482383370399475,
-0.4130600392818451,
-0.5187144875526428,
0.15124393999576569,
0.008479896001517773,
1.2338768243789673,
0.5673108100891113,
-0.0732044205069542,
0.22362491488456726,
-0.7573829889297485,
0.3250199854373932,
0.11708810180425644,
-0.21690888702869415,
-0.40579694509506226,
-0.026668578386306763,
0.19361186027526855,
0.07243777811527252,
0.42106181383132935,
-0.5855327844619751,
0.15972758829593658,
-0.6907864212989807,
0.6936611533164978,
0.5181574821472168,
-0.5096525549888611,
0.441804438829422,
-0.1557151824235916,
0.3575363755226135,
0.2681092321872711,
0.3472784459590912,
-0.6817354559898376,
-0.26529067754745483,
-0.8969184160232544,
-0.22342820465564728,
0.8573665022850037,
0.1038748174905777,
-0.36492499709129333,
0.45945194363594055,
-0.2231297343969345,
-0.7877094745635986,
-0.8774256706237793,
-0.05855688452720642,
0.24947252869606018,
0.48459669947624207,
0.052271321415901184,
-0.7038003206253052,
-0.477137953042984,
-1.0095624923706055,
-0.24173316359519958,
-0.35982251167297363,
-0.12231555581092834,
-0.023165259510278702,
0.6050274968147278,
-0.3117130696773529,
1.0354701280593872,
-0.3533305823802948,
0.030330777168273926,
-0.15782685577869415,
0.09796042740345001,
0.08710753172636032,
0.49623903632164,
0.6881227493286133,
-0.4493829905986786,
-0.4490775465965271,
0.15898393094539642,
-0.6762100458145142,
-0.3576499819755554,
0.271722674369812,
-0.16979475319385529,
0.2398516833782196,
0.5292754769325256,
-0.39507046341896057,
0.23296251893043518,
0.6145757436752319,
-0.2148638665676117,
0.7071625590324402,
0.05592384561896324,
-0.19894970953464508,
-0.78327876329422,
0.5276085734367371,
0.004857238847762346,
-0.33672261238098145,
-0.6489576101303101,
0.6000936031341553,
0.5078139901161194,
-0.1111728772521019,
-0.8552865982055664,
0.9874733090400696,
-0.14019522070884705,
0.34642985463142395,
-0.052394799888134,
0.22727225720882416,
-0.23579534888267517,
0.2497246116399765,
-0.07755457609891891,
0.5299530625343323,
0.9260172247886658,
-0.5857666730880737,
0.27933469414711,
-0.04345196858048439,
-0.4795086085796356,
0.30158570408821106,
-1.0596673488616943,
0.2960764467716217,
-0.10240938514471054,
-0.037064820528030396,
-0.46759334206581116,
-0.5131677389144897,
0.26583346724510193,
-0.3886287808418274,
-0.04283302277326584,
-0.10512569546699524,
-0.46792978048324585,
-0.2447066605091095,
-0.4075629413127899,
0.31048208475112915,
0.7655866742134094,
-0.3263729214668274,
0.4310136139392853,
0.6215522289276123,
-0.11407673358917236,
-0.3088833689689636,
-0.5291371941566467,
-0.15003889799118042,
-0.08607200533151627,
-0.6735631227493286,
0.12240052968263626,
-0.4351487457752228,
-0.32060325145721436,
-0.12217371165752411,
-0.05478367581963539,
-0.4350474774837494,
0.08491235226392746,
0.20446179807186127,
0.004027973860502243,
-0.2101030796766281,
0.2739453613758087,
-0.2774505019187927,
-0.10350148379802704,
0.15134859085083008,
-0.6472156643867493,
0.5661869645118713,
-0.35257115960121155,
-0.04569102078676224,
-0.18346625566482544,
0.21442362666130066,
0.41472434997558594,
-0.46586254239082336,
0.8677718043327332,
0.25541794300079346,
-0.3867782652378082,
-0.3566824793815613,
-0.3526306450366974,
0.12244043499231339,
-0.5609911680221558,
0.35590603947639465,
-0.05164911970496178,
-0.9525009393692017,
0.491700142621994,
0.11253873258829117,
0.24323661625385284,
0.3283541202545166,
0.5077850818634033,
0.43094220757484436,
0.6827408671379089,
0.8069419860839844,
-0.14718368649482727,
0.48249363899230957,
0.37474876642227173,
0.032320182770490646,
-0.40608683228492737,
-0.26070961356163025,
-0.8122241497039795,
0.09468311816453934,
-0.21598777174949646,
-0.33706143498420715,
0.14992831647396088,
0.17956583201885223,
-0.402573823928833,
0.4733606278896332,
-0.3694896697998047,
0.471900999546051,
0.7579048871994019,
-0.06290804594755173,
0.18209907412528992,
-0.31124505400657654,
-0.31028953194618225,
0.02978186123073101,
-0.6166825294494629,
-0.26895710825920105,
0.8453512191772461,
0.6325650811195374,
0.9689399003982544,
-0.2101029008626938,
0.3482983708381653,
0.02301180362701416,
0.1771540641784668,
-0.9266477227210999,
0.6863115429878235,
-0.05008123815059662,
-0.8401597142219543,
-0.1794891059398651,
-0.6297911405563354,
-0.8725970983505249,
-0.057913560420274734,
0.3212122619152069,
-0.747350811958313,
-0.49005767703056335,
0.16197872161865234,
0.11304423213005066,
0.007751747500151396,
-0.8387491106987,
1.0015051364898682,
-0.3512600064277649,
-0.3202286958694458,
-0.12151144444942474,
-0.8317676782608032,
0.5055628418922424,
-0.4629487097263336,
0.1686769425868988,
0.05102895572781563,
0.007877103984355927,
0.7517747282981873,
-0.27099472284317017,
0.6003931164741516,
-0.11914363503456116,
-0.13180294632911682,
0.4618270695209503,
0.08855253458023071,
0.10427235811948776,
0.09890257567167282,
-0.34975147247314453,
0.7425159811973572,
0.1394633948802948,
-0.45969870686531067,
-0.20863616466522217,
0.7145237326622009,
-0.6421242952346802,
-0.2611248195171356,
-0.48922714591026306,
-0.6734894514083862,
0.0762154683470726,
0.5609850287437439,
0.05223552882671356,
0.3980533480644226,
-0.31378456950187683,
0.8104153871536255,
0.5147556662559509,
-0.4149022698402405,
0.43927910923957825,
0.8103116750717163,
-0.5575444102287292,
-0.19081877171993256,
0.7719468474388123,
0.1841573715209961,
0.22976604104042053,
0.1816079020500183,
0.287965327501297,
-0.10811352729797363,
-0.28410303592681885,
-0.06943164020776749,
0.46822357177734375,
-0.5710542798042297,
0.1555097997188568,
-0.6161853075027466,
-0.6586256623268127,
-0.6363629102706909,
0.0655859112739563,
-0.8026427030563354,
-0.3997375965118408,
0.026249606162309647,
0.13500691950321198,
0.03278331458568573,
0.6856523156166077,
0.16935525834560394,
0.8383195400238037,
-0.9498284459114075,
-0.0789145901799202,
0.12541161477565765,
1.1493571996688843,
-0.02560759149491787,
-0.6256205439567566,
-0.8219454884529114,
0.17819850146770477,
-0.3629448711872101,
-0.6055992245674133,
0.38942790031433105,
0.09689593315124512,
0.4769120514392853,
0.49374720454216003,
0.01678476296365261,
0.44717568159103394,
-0.6146044731140137,
1.000784158706665,
0.3161994516849518,
-1.1547112464904785,
0.5382455587387085,
-0.5255969762802124,
0.6571815013885498,
0.4108911156654358,
0.5504136681556702,
-0.7274267077445984,
-0.22443512082099915,
-0.6170851588249207,
-0.6363821625709534,
1.0613104104995728,
0.22080519795417786,
0.1225464716553688,
0.06601633876562119,
0.4361152946949005,
0.406045526266098,
0.3148692548274994,
-0.8192945122718811,
-0.08494266867637634,
-0.5157304406166077,
-0.338107705116272,
0.1407957524061203,
-0.1082686185836792,
-0.0028675049543380737,
-0.39073818922042847,
0.6881588697433472,
-0.1813807636499405,
0.34414342045783997,
-0.1977875530719757,
-0.1502498984336853,
-0.206280916929245,
0.13925674557685852,
0.26596105098724365,
0.6723502278327942,
-0.31075334548950195,
-0.09091178327798843,
-0.11515600234270096,
-0.5778791308403015,
-0.35488688945770264,
0.2440102994441986,
-0.20039178431034088,
-0.022382153198122978,
0.2655450403690338,
0.6328966617584229,
0.17150361835956573,
-1.0110465288162231,
0.4517393708229065,
-0.15507999062538147,
-0.3697090744972229,
-0.34905704855918884,
0.3553527295589447,
0.13637343049049377,
-0.11568017303943634,
0.21044933795928955,
-0.44246402382850647,
-0.06762374937534332,
-0.5027719140052795,
0.4450906217098236,
0.3614956736564636,
-0.9913783073425293,
-0.7604424953460693,
0.8721564412117004,
0.37387725710868835,
-0.348903626203537,
0.7931742072105408,
-0.077165387570858,
-0.21285976469516754,
0.313633531332016,
0.3971232771873474,
0.8383287787437439,
-0.2446468323469162,
0.33510687947273254,
0.601203441619873,
0.4836595952510834,
-0.2520156502723694,
0.09669315069913864,
0.4228654205799103,
-0.24021710455417633,
-0.18322496116161346,
-1.043331503868103,
-0.4123014211654663,
0.43391841650009155,
-0.41431257128715515,
0.8045011162757874,
-0.5022082924842834,
0.22142352163791656,
-0.03793859854340553,
-0.05432736873626709,
-0.4268295466899872,
0.1383402794599533,
0.01495879516005516,
1.3566808700561523,
-0.39532557129859924,
1.1088627576828003,
0.6517491340637207,
-0.6000419855117798,
-0.7156820893287659,
-0.24257925152778625,
0.07670043408870697,
-0.6476500630378723,
0.3896787464618683,
0.5444483757019043,
0.21811522543430328,
0.19518841803073883,
-1.220158338546753,
-0.8562451004981995,
0.8070704340934753,
0.623895525932312,
-0.5154882073402405,
-0.2693325877189636,
0.07336526364088058,
0.358933687210083,
-0.5060076713562012,
0.4088335335254669,
0.4426601827144623,
0.44810160994529724,
-0.1448492556810379,
-1.1278791427612305,
-0.17545869946479797,
-0.4493323564529419,
-0.09525591880083084,
0.2755798399448395,
-1.0459188222885132,
1.1119219064712524,
0.16399288177490234,
-0.2749446630477905,
0.31911250948905945,
0.5199549198150635,
-0.0536537766456604,
-0.08810538053512573,
0.47031790018081665,
0.4814664125442505,
0.4093661606311798,
-0.08255407959222794,
1.139400839805603,
-0.5330662131309509,
0.2942034900188446,
1.0713673830032349,
-0.4231404662132263,
0.6289268732070923,
0.2920798361301422,
0.16041940450668335,
0.46362775564193726,
0.3597862422466278,
0.1982172280550003,
0.3234732449054718,
0.06558354198932648,
0.02707982435822487,
-0.10788445174694061,
-0.40294989943504333,
-0.31060299277305603,
0.5067600607872009,
0.20286455750465393,
-0.2571895718574524,
-0.16686692833900452,
-0.39181435108184814,
0.005138108506798744,
-0.295450359582901,
-0.2792591154575348,
0.4492657780647278,
0.320284903049469,
-0.8979737162590027,
0.35941654443740845,
0.11685997247695923,
0.5256250500679016,
-1.3949028253555298,
0.11145603656768799,
-0.1067618727684021,
0.2856939733028412,
0.06517772376537323,
-0.4805871844291687,
0.30253687500953674,
-0.17998896539211273,
0.19901227951049805,
-0.05146615952253342,
0.7863659262657166,
-0.43186551332473755,
-0.29764965176582336,
0.5195235013961792,
0.25109225511550903,
0.13485188782215118,
-0.19244816899299622,
-0.6212148666381836,
0.3155317008495331,
-0.2556752860546112,
-0.2649696469306946,
0.36635443568229675,
0.39161306619644165,
0.0817398726940155,
0.789624810218811,
0.3273574113845825,
0.09883666783571243,
0.21901175379753113,
0.012937706895172596,
0.8008016347885132,
-0.9092212915420532,
-0.5709924101829529,
-0.3960520327091217,
0.9465004205703735,
-0.03383153676986694,
-0.42459776997566223,
0.7182774543762207,
0.4835142493247986,
1.0168912410736084,
-0.1257389783859253,
0.9698529839515686,
-0.4664967656135559,
0.477382630109787,
-0.1526632010936737,
0.8403895497322083,
-0.8455750346183777,
-0.03488145023584366,
-0.10875590145587921,
-0.7214080691337585,
-0.11046506464481354,
0.5059854388237,
0.298597514629364,
0.12938308715820312,
0.9456368088722229,
0.7446832060813904,
-0.15355518460273743,
0.08655975759029388,
0.3330935537815094,
0.4779126048088074,
0.25272607803344727,
0.431147962808609,
0.4229322373867035,
-0.5393485426902771,
0.5780999660491943,
-0.19461695849895477,
-0.39755263924598694,
-0.25310030579566956,
-1.0036547183990479,
-0.9585157036781311,
-0.7553987503051758,
-0.29913529753685,
-0.18786634504795074,
-0.041922181844711304,
0.8932135701179504,
1.0001620054244995,
-0.522832453250885,
-0.5251420140266418,
-0.0024196873418986797,
-0.31943005323410034,
-0.1796664595603943,
-0.23640747368335724,
-0.23976624011993408,
-0.5287646055221558,
-0.6951845288276672,
0.23704004287719727,
0.3826362192630768,
-0.4139082729816437,
-0.46714287996292114,
-0.3677520155906677,
-0.3207620680332184,
0.4249906539916992,
0.5425707101821899,
0.18438440561294556,
-0.5671489238739014,
-0.42550089955329895,
0.1437341421842575,
-0.22368453443050385,
0.001136137405410409,
0.5909327864646912,
-0.6954028606414795,
0.6478105783462524,
0.5660155415534973,
0.6195289492607117,
0.13278014957904816,
-0.221492737531662,
0.6637666821479797,
-0.8802149891853333,
0.4298483431339264,
0.1081005111336708,
0.3521566092967987,
0.07933218032121658,
0.08917451649904251,
0.7726426124572754,
0.10048837214708328,
-0.675747275352478,
-0.8023858070373535,
0.2910645008087158,
-1.3141247034072876,
-0.347507119178772,
1.0015302896499634,
-0.14307758212089539,
-0.4066803455352783,
0.08914254605770111,
-0.21813008189201355,
0.1537674516439438,
-0.3826601207256317,
0.7153769135475159,
0.8911153078079224,
0.49081674218177795,
-0.2986753284931183,
-0.8037128448486328,
0.13940264284610748,
0.18888753652572632,
-0.8299532532691956,
0.1164248064160347,
0.45337584614753723,
0.31193751096725464,
0.0897563099861145,
0.8309046030044556,
-0.3566056489944458,
0.31372037529945374,
0.307817667722702,
0.0836755558848381,
-0.19775670766830444,
-0.5355966091156006,
-0.30992916226387024,
0.1269693374633789,
0.1870308816432953,
0.3140704333782196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04820v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04820v1
|
APrompt4EM: Augmented Prompt Tuning for Generalized Entity Matching
| 2024-05-08T05:38:56 | 2024-05-08T05:38:56 |
Yikuan Xia, Jiazun Chen, Xinchi Li, Jun Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Generalized Entity Matching (GEM), which aims at judging whether two records
represented in different formats refer to the same real-world entity, is an
essential task in data management. The prompt tuning paradigm for pre-trained
language models (PLMs), including the recent PromptEM model, effectively
addresses the challenges of low-resource GEM in practical applications,
offering a robust solution when labeled data is scarce. However, existing
prompt tuning models for GEM face the challenges of prompt design and
information gap. This paper introduces an augmented prompt tuning framework for
the challenges, which consists of two main improvements. The first is an
augmented contextualized soft token-based prompt tuning method that extracts a
guiding soft token benefit for the PLMs' prompt tuning, and the second is a
cost-effective information augmentation strategy leveraging large language
models (LLMs). Our approach performs well on the low-resource GEM challenges.
Extensive experiments show promising advancements of our basic model without
information augmentation over existing methods based on moderate-size PLMs
(average 5.24%+), and our model with information augmentation achieves
comparable performance compared with fine-tuned LLMs, using less than 14% of
the API fee.
|
[
-0.49005547165870667,
-0.8579152226448059,
0.6579532623291016,
0.14152906835079193,
-0.4947875440120697,
0.06100701540708542,
-0.32352808117866516,
-0.32073768973350525,
-0.007051069289445877,
0.646238386631012,
-0.8812333345413208,
-0.48992058634757996,
-0.1409059762954712,
0.44748327136039734,
0.22256632149219513,
1.0008800029754639,
-0.04188850522041321,
-0.09696941822767258,
-0.026910796761512756,
-0.14638195931911469,
-1.1186692714691162,
-0.3621665835380554,
-0.9955453872680664,
0.2154565453529358,
0.3051375448703766,
0.5312362313270569,
0.6860253810882568,
0.9298211932182312,
0.5184577107429504,
0.3475727438926697,
-0.10742664337158203,
0.6173599362373352,
-0.10794109851121902,
0.24914047122001648,
-0.1071939617395401,
-0.38762637972831726,
-0.8160621523857117,
0.1027236357331276,
0.5349550247192383,
0.37497955560684204,
-0.24817538261413574,
0.19716376066207886,
-0.02907356433570385,
0.41903936862945557,
-0.4072590172290802,
0.16744095087051392,
-0.8581149578094482,
-0.286537766456604,
-0.3884773850440979,
-0.5482622981071472,
-0.3811129927635193,
-0.4032096266746521,
-0.12958697974681854,
-1.0649062395095825,
0.6174389719963074,
0.8499438762664795,
0.8116347193717957,
0.29946377873420715,
-0.32189902663230896,
-0.3664422631263733,
-0.2591264545917511,
0.49947699904441833,
-0.42996105551719666,
0.16487963497638702,
0.2740931808948517,
0.12366241216659546,
-0.24134548008441925,
-0.5282071232795715,
-0.6447176337242126,
-0.23053298890590668,
-0.21040835976600647,
-0.29045653343200684,
0.03630489483475685,
0.3491051197052002,
0.666864812374115,
0.6882301568984985,
-0.7440746426582336,
0.11865286529064178,
0.26551613211631775,
-0.2935926616191864,
0.2618832588195801,
0.339679479598999,
0.6486966609954834,
0.04324176535010338,
-0.5007562637329102,
-0.006245977245271206,
-0.9060003757476807,
-0.11133141815662384,
0.6270288825035095,
0.7659390568733215,
-0.18374547362327576,
0.3728121817111969,
0.00014645543706137687,
1.1767935752868652,
0.3514357805252075,
-0.019589534029364586,
0.32399827241897583,
-0.7303601503372192,
-0.14969420433044434,
0.22480209171772003,
0.30089449882507324,
0.40776515007019043,
0.08639756590127945,
-0.15704454481601715,
-0.4509665369987488,
0.15668939054012299,
-0.08721146732568741,
-0.6137987971305847,
-0.24821063876152039,
-0.15124772489070892,
-0.10297378152608871,
0.1872670203447342,
-0.37489554286003113,
-0.6130331754684448,
-0.5071064829826355,
-0.749528706073761,
0.5568268895149231,
-0.3922969400882721,
-0.2625560760498047,
-0.07829832285642624,
-0.02081339620053768,
0.14773239195346832,
0.35474199056625366,
-1.035232663154602,
0.049171365797519684,
0.8301398158073425,
1.0899252891540527,
-0.08797719329595566,
0.025427524000406265,
-1.1015946865081787,
-0.010175892151892185,
-0.35454893112182617,
0.9089569449424744,
-0.7994491457939148,
-0.606974720954895,
-0.12069299072027206,
0.14335419237613678,
-0.1191442608833313,
-0.5007662177085876,
0.8825547099113464,
-0.6292538642883301,
0.28249695897102356,
-0.6353529095649719,
-0.5433027744293213,
0.14136619865894318,
0.2603279948234558,
-0.7410082817077637,
0.8152266144752502,
0.25917887687683105,
-0.43020302057266235,
0.6566063761711121,
-0.6559809446334839,
-0.30326247215270996,
0.49978870153427124,
-0.06760153919458389,
-0.4184907078742981,
-0.013560516759753227,
0.6393735408782959,
0.03031010739505291,
-0.5811004638671875,
0.2921348512172699,
-0.1032666265964508,
-0.5388044118881226,
-0.3174995183944702,
-0.11120305210351944,
0.4038269519805908,
0.24905547499656677,
0.05934843420982361,
0.30053648352622986,
-0.8358992338180542,
-0.0902436226606369,
-0.085235096514225,
-0.222102090716362,
-0.4963996112346649,
-0.20536446571350098,
-0.08896953612565994,
-0.05929437279701233,
0.29548919200897217,
-0.43505486845970154,
0.5538545846939087,
-0.5167055726051331,
0.4564465880393982,
0.9450479745864868,
0.13229693472385406,
0.7388536334037781,
-0.2567051649093628,
0.4977792203426361,
-0.03441052883863449,
0.2559155225753784,
-0.5652515888214111,
-0.41670382022857666,
-0.5012555122375488,
-0.561577320098877,
0.5566139817237854,
0.6039668321609497,
-0.9589486718177795,
0.4875863790512085,
-0.22654934227466583,
0.026839667931199074,
-0.9206453561782837,
0.13430677354335785,
0.17180994153022766,
0.9788451194763184,
0.6006680130958557,
-0.14438943564891815,
-0.5209951996803284,
-0.8297812938690186,
-0.588530421257019,
-0.059955377131700516,
-0.07133481651544571,
0.5777068138122559,
-0.12881381809711456,
-0.08648140728473663,
0.9832102060317993,
-0.18976806104183197,
-0.45714086294174194,
-0.09931815415620804,
0.19601009786128998,
0.7018535733222961,
0.5560619831085205,
0.48910173773765564,
-0.7472736835479736,
-0.3362041711807251,
-0.11244124919176102,
-0.3725418150424957,
-0.44226059317588806,
-0.1557624787092209,
-0.17496725916862488,
-0.018939964473247528,
0.058754466474056244,
-0.6571176648139954,
-0.036905866116285324,
0.3556847870349884,
-0.6804720163345337,
0.24323318898677826,
-0.3859359622001648,
0.6162781715393066,
-0.9705488681793213,
-0.03882153332233429,
0.07147790491580963,
-0.3335922360420227,
-0.5530025362968445,
-0.08704089373350143,
0.4056154787540436,
-0.42179131507873535,
-0.11085105687379837,
0.803947389125824,
-0.8512080907821655,
0.17017711699008942,
-0.440753310918808,
0.2763635218143463,
0.00027362717082723975,
0.3172679841518402,
-0.08958467096090317,
1.429278016090393,
0.6851164698600769,
-0.8100407123565674,
0.493450790643692,
0.39760905504226685,
-0.366051584482193,
0.9368992447853088,
-0.6068483591079712,
0.2056787759065628,
-0.17933423817157745,
0.118730828166008,
-0.6570122241973877,
-0.15837207436561584,
0.2826041281223297,
-0.236673042178154,
0.5567941069602966,
-0.527319610118866,
-0.5793448686599731,
-0.22724361717700958,
-0.1959153413772583,
0.45573022961616516,
0.5855289101600647,
-0.8656861782073975,
0.9060447216033936,
0.037749871611595154,
-0.4781699478626251,
-0.43936339020729065,
-0.21753467619419098,
0.258293092250824,
-0.37943974137306213,
-0.8148030638694763,
0.42319539189338684,
-0.17431192100048065,
0.029399294406175613,
-0.12997464835643768,
-0.14884790778160095,
0.31172290444374084,
0.12600797414779663,
0.03131489083170891,
0.5404356122016907,
-0.3283619284629822,
0.3762251138687134,
0.06163335591554642,
-0.3430115580558777,
-0.29070574045181274,
-0.1961091011762619,
0.4146542251110077,
0.12490200996398926,
-0.2671007812023163,
-0.2535434067249298,
0.1931050568819046,
0.0056066266261041164,
-0.27249523997306824,
0.6593961715698242,
0.4114207625389099,
-0.08811398595571518,
-0.1369994580745697,
-0.6956981420516968,
-0.13638009130954742,
-0.5541489720344543,
0.03099658153951168,
-0.5814259648323059,
-0.9278983473777771,
0.5104036927223206,
-0.2554081976413727,
-0.010637542232871056,
0.3646964728832245,
0.35495179891586304,
0.2934451103210449,
1.2715423107147217,
0.6507483124732971,
-0.19983281195163727,
0.6266507506370544,
0.3694291412830353,
0.2987656593322754,
-0.9262564778327942,
-0.026933899149298668,
-0.6780922412872314,
-0.1310911327600479,
-0.6024374961853027,
-0.15345866978168488,
0.49360179901123047,
0.178548201918602,
-0.41104355454444885,
0.1523771435022354,
-0.6665958166122437,
0.5473117232322693,
0.5981242656707764,
-0.027409587055444717,
0.39341452717781067,
-0.16662466526031494,
0.16398993134498596,
0.10604248940944672,
-0.49817731976509094,
-0.44159889221191406,
0.855534553527832,
0.0586443729698658,
0.7840372323989868,
0.18332137167453766,
0.09818804264068604,
0.5278217196464539,
0.13464517891407013,
-0.24725979566574097,
0.4808768332004547,
0.21541358530521393,
-0.4699602425098419,
0.04331199824810028,
-0.7030372023582458,
-0.8019125461578369,
0.017239684239029884,
-0.405634343624115,
-0.4546160399913788,
0.264766663312912,
0.74198317527771,
-0.4512077271938324,
0.19143827259540558,
-1.0337822437286377,
0.6887460947036743,
-0.2084398716688156,
-0.23619097471237183,
0.16384632885456085,
-0.5664868950843811,
0.2786544859409332,
-0.07417887449264526,
0.14297835528850555,
-0.36086878180503845,
-0.1434428095817566,
0.4965656101703644,
-0.5316352248191833,
0.2460329532623291,
-0.47172194719314575,
-0.07040833681821823,
0.12203405797481537,
-0.1591036170721054,
1.0532771348953247,
0.5456318855285645,
-0.04928213730454445,
-0.14405806362628937,
-0.39205703139305115,
-0.4897988736629486,
-0.495178759098053,
0.9863361716270447,
-0.5033195614814758,
-0.8084909915924072,
-0.37176987528800964,
-0.3946498930454254,
-0.41016608476638794,
0.03973926231265068,
0.35144051909446716,
0.5084289312362671,
0.16593241691589355,
-0.32206469774246216,
0.9617571830749512,
-0.17008590698242188,
0.47828006744384766,
0.7719992399215698,
0.1589999496936798,
-0.4215395748615265,
0.7918976545333862,
-0.4219604432582855,
-0.09783844649791718,
0.22171488404273987,
-0.29053911566734314,
-0.6454402804374695,
-0.46103498339653015,
-0.9746542572975159,
0.24582552909851074,
-0.40286317467689514,
-0.5521324276924133,
-0.4409596621990204,
0.38732782006263733,
-0.4692096710205078,
0.04677151143550873,
0.0468672513961792,
0.032334715127944946,
-0.6060770153999329,
0.035917334258556366,
0.8866994976997375,
0.19044537842273712,
0.025102807208895683,
0.530023992061615,
-0.8447957038879395,
0.3968595266342163,
0.3148854672908783,
0.7337878942489624,
-0.4469594657421112,
-0.5422133803367615,
-0.018752682954072952,
-0.03724827244877815,
0.053059373050928116,
-0.8386136889457703,
0.10185571014881134,
0.4998168349266052,
0.543243408203125,
0.06543862819671631,
-0.011570512317121029,
0.8103369474411011,
-0.7139692902565002,
0.9020771384239197,
-0.0359375961124897,
-1.011946678161621,
0.8073335289955139,
-0.3226846754550934,
0.04339359328150749,
0.680353581905365,
-0.016767695546150208,
-0.3494144082069397,
0.21750015020370483,
-0.3266061246395111,
-0.9259315133094788,
0.9444689154624939,
0.092589370906353,
0.12629932165145874,
-0.25424978137016296,
0.7047720551490784,
0.11384185403585434,
0.3435162901878357,
-0.41079914569854736,
-0.2681109309196472,
0.10138878971338272,
-0.33652183413505554,
-0.3291538953781128,
-0.23947155475616455,
0.05938147380948067,
0.09458588808774948,
0.7773738503456116,
-0.1381908357143402,
0.237117737531662,
0.0840458944439888,
-0.35270220041275024,
-0.29231399297714233,
0.3599448502063751,
0.5219972133636475,
0.3902454674243927,
-0.18762247264385223,
-0.040996842086315155,
0.3374476432800293,
-0.39585575461387634,
0.22063705325126648,
0.3398549556732178,
-0.09863230586051941,
0.08121493458747864,
0.11206813901662827,
1.459266185760498,
-0.09804106503725052,
-0.5648209452629089,
0.4611523151397705,
-0.23930583894252777,
0.18290291726589203,
0.1038149744272232,
0.32963380217552185,
-0.44158637523651123,
0.134055033326149,
0.36234962940216064,
0.06703060120344162,
0.13156758248806,
-0.4366874694824219,
-0.09448651224374771,
0.6245020627975464,
-0.10524871945381165,
-0.43015703558921814,
0.741589367389679,
0.3847503662109375,
-0.5321876406669617,
0.6817190051078796,
-0.3362085521221161,
-0.10949995368719101,
0.2370978146791458,
0.5924487113952637,
0.6059720516204834,
-0.4435081481933594,
-0.22495552897453308,
0.25437334179878235,
0.3032882511615753,
-0.23712623119354248,
0.4409569799900055,
-0.22087503969669342,
-0.30746322870254517,
-0.6663894653320312,
-0.6320748925209045,
-0.30337366461753845,
-0.026867680251598358,
-0.5510806441307068,
0.6694060564041138,
-0.16369479894638062,
-0.24430640041828156,
-0.3972874879837036,
0.018550220876932144,
-0.8335467576980591,
0.2152482122182846,
-0.027343550696969032,
0.9925412535667419,
-0.8473772406578064,
0.4744592010974884,
0.7547183036804199,
-0.23616667091846466,
-0.7850942611694336,
-0.38589808344841003,
-0.36072179675102234,
-0.768479585647583,
0.016810445114970207,
-0.013165796175599098,
0.19950531423091888,
0.49471765756607056,
-0.3992709219455719,
-0.8461853265762329,
0.9168654680252075,
0.44033193588256836,
-0.7902132272720337,
-0.20901942253112793,
-0.21123799681663513,
0.2928849756717682,
-0.327094703912735,
0.40555766224861145,
0.7083306908607483,
0.5262014865875244,
0.015374443493783474,
-0.8366820812225342,
0.11387260258197784,
-0.24873925745487213,
0.18896178901195526,
0.7617449164390564,
-0.3243195414543152,
0.9241625666618347,
0.027585113421082497,
-0.5586773157119751,
0.20519161224365234,
0.516730785369873,
0.3951268494129181,
0.3066096305847168,
0.7011657953262329,
0.6546440124511719,
0.9733449816703796,
-0.4312886595726013,
0.9912921190261841,
-0.5054926872253418,
0.32125604152679443,
0.9380739331245422,
-0.45938512682914734,
0.10386922955513,
0.20109140872955322,
0.050435617566108704,
0.26201191544532776,
0.8758105039596558,
-0.0035343258641660213,
0.6599733233451843,
-0.02310558781027794,
-0.3676420748233795,
-0.48397698998451233,
-0.2425679862499237,
-0.7595035433769226,
-0.13529840111732483,
0.4459242522716522,
-0.23626896739006042,
-0.19792993366718292,
0.25551846623420715,
-0.31287142634391785,
-0.02504141815006733,
-0.8003233671188354,
1.004585862159729,
-0.18162374198436737,
-0.6066243648529053,
0.3605155348777771,
0.04986691102385521,
0.6054404377937317,
-0.4952223598957062,
-0.17833006381988525,
-0.3535749912261963,
-0.1934688240289688,
0.1137021854519844,
-0.47216200828552246,
-0.1929837018251419,
0.10866674035787582,
-0.31906938552856445,
-0.21071308851242065,
0.7785786390304565,
-0.38841691613197327,
-0.03960587829351425,
-0.1764763593673706,
0.42422568798065186,
-0.2517774999141693,
-0.2039104551076889,
-0.6234416961669922,
0.010258487425744534,
-0.18336942791938782,
-0.08612687885761261,
0.23138031363487244,
0.6045560836791992,
-0.08646713197231293,
0.4111296236515045,
0.7196335196495056,
0.23401297628879547,
-0.09098055958747864,
0.107577845454216,
0.8166401386260986,
-0.8215433955192566,
-0.9043062925338745,
-0.9176362752914429,
0.3424507677555084,
-0.2438669353723526,
-0.4578620493412018,
0.6810066103935242,
0.6187795996665955,
0.2921590805053711,
0.08638955652713776,
0.6315898299217224,
0.23107433319091797,
0.8847075700759888,
-0.7720973491668701,
0.14178407192230225,
-0.42990556359291077,
0.5883303284645081,
-0.08609258383512497,
-1.2283872365951538,
-0.10845976322889328,
0.21707776188850403,
-0.24209609627723694,
0.11482934653759003,
0.34158340096473694,
0.8408502340316772,
-0.12670518457889557,
0.11760066449642181,
0.03268956393003464,
-0.0634639710187912,
0.1427324414253235,
0.4527498185634613,
0.7580947875976562,
-0.2146146148443222,
0.20210790634155273,
0.36500808596611023,
-0.30892646312713623,
-0.27891379594802856,
-0.9037355780601501,
-0.7767341136932373,
-0.4043978154659271,
-0.23300373554229736,
-0.22840474545955658,
0.26428598165512085,
1.2176066637039185,
0.4749687612056732,
-0.6867901086807251,
0.5582325458526611,
-0.1836267113685608,
0.13343767821788788,
0.07688392698764801,
-0.1631351113319397,
0.34115517139434814,
-0.6581545472145081,
-0.6846194863319397,
0.6110860109329224,
0.37699514627456665,
0.1525445580482483,
0.3570406138896942,
0.10389885306358337,
0.13428689539432526,
0.10453452169895172,
0.20509456098079681,
0.1964339315891266,
-0.633083164691925,
-0.27630850672721863,
0.1605268269777298,
0.053367651998996735,
0.21324655413627625,
1.0388331413269043,
-0.8878881335258484,
0.5444135069847107,
0.23466672003269196,
0.522179901599884,
0.21410880982875824,
0.5621638298034668,
0.49532073736190796,
-1.2466415166854858,
0.2112845629453659,
0.19807256758213043,
0.37910690903663635,
0.4702751934528351,
-0.6005083918571472,
0.3100886046886444,
0.25232213735580444,
-0.7750251293182373,
-1.0069069862365723,
0.22365538775920868,
-0.9574754238128662,
0.08751479536294937,
0.9693609476089478,
0.20362690091133118,
-0.01768391765654087,
-0.27260762453079224,
-0.43540748953819275,
0.31747761368751526,
-0.5649734139442444,
0.3620902895927429,
0.3832349479198456,
0.043023914098739624,
-0.24606357514858246,
-0.26410210132598877,
0.8285835385322571,
0.2935154438018799,
-0.6119629144668579,
-0.13954387605190277,
0.581760048866272,
0.13215644657611847,
-0.12322311103343964,
0.6278659701347351,
0.39587196707725525,
0.30486994981765747,
-0.345199316740036,
0.07218703627586365,
-0.2624138295650482,
-0.07343734055757523,
-0.4309309720993042,
0.05057164654135704,
0.2626386284828186,
-0.18237046897411346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04819v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04819v2
|
DALK: Dynamic Co-Augmentation of LLMs and KG to answer Alzheimer's Disease Questions with Scientific Literature
| 2024-05-08T05:38:20 | 2024-05-12T08:39:24 |
Dawei Li, Shu Yang, Zhen Tan, Jae Young Baik, Sukwon Yun, Joseph Lee, Aaron Chacko, Bojian Hou, Duy Duong-Tran, Ying Ding, Huan Liu, Li Shen, Tianlong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have achieved promising
performances across various applications. Nonetheless, the ongoing challenge of
integrating long-tail knowledge continues to impede the seamless adoption of
LLMs in specialized domains. In this work, we introduce DALK, a.k.a. Dynamic
Co-Augmentation of LLMs and KG, to address this limitation and demonstrate its
ability on studying Alzheimer's Disease (AD), a specialized sub-field in
biomedicine and a global health priority. With a synergized framework of LLM
and KG mutually enhancing each other, we first leverage LLM to construct an
evolving AD-specific knowledge graph (KG) sourced from AD-related scientific
literature, and then we utilize a coarse-to-fine sampling method with a novel
self-aware knowledge retrieval approach to select appropriate knowledge from
the KG to augment LLM inference capabilities. The experimental results,
conducted on our constructed AD question answering (ADQA) benchmark, underscore
the efficacy of DALK. Additionally, we perform a series of detailed analyses
that can offer valuable insights and guidelines for the emerging topic of
mutually enhancing KG and LLM. We will release the code and data at
https://github.com/David-Li0406/DALK.
|
[
-0.1851295381784439,
-1.154636025428772,
0.9091653823852539,
0.029407721012830734,
-0.2516855299472809,
0.5034698843955994,
0.009894602932035923,
-0.7713953256607056,
0.5279179811477661,
0.20983603596687317,
-0.6264937520027161,
-0.6002143621444702,
-0.6004253625869751,
0.06291108578443527,
-0.041744738817214966,
0.9938948154449463,
-0.1490856409072876,
0.2527995705604553,
-0.8683597445487976,
-0.3217325210571289,
-0.30880260467529297,
-0.20610782504081726,
-0.8648529648780823,
-0.471694678068161,
0.5999253392219543,
0.298250287771225,
0.5605157613754272,
0.39493250846862793,
0.5207144021987915,
0.266230046749115,
-0.3208276629447937,
0.34683892130851746,
-0.35893601179122925,
0.5317580699920654,
0.1231485977768898,
-0.29763391613960266,
-1.2367103099822998,
0.14251765608787537,
0.3496227264404297,
0.8691794276237488,
-0.08347960561513901,
-0.1340034455060959,
-0.033820003271102905,
0.7822366952896118,
-0.6389621496200562,
0.21392183005809784,
-0.14285928010940552,
0.07393305748701096,
-0.15916481614112854,
-0.027055105194449425,
-0.002615300239995122,
-0.19549864530563354,
0.2945365011692047,
-0.9302685856819153,
-0.17233064770698547,
-0.1457664519548416,
0.49685773253440857,
0.5334829688072205,
-0.8036420941352844,
-0.5721158981323242,
-0.38307538628578186,
0.6781056523323059,
-0.4778309464454651,
0.25370556116104126,
0.5434184074401855,
0.31355223059654236,
-0.416755348443985,
-0.8909804224967957,
-0.3589637577533722,
-0.6113446950912476,
-0.13846422731876373,
0.4488855004310608,
-0.005677184090018272,
0.2676680386066437,
-0.18038520216941833,
0.5791584253311157,
-0.4400095045566559,
0.07690898329019547,
-0.21981048583984375,
-0.34240275621414185,
0.6613386273384094,
0.24873848259449005,
0.5983946323394775,
0.11258047819137573,
-0.2674950659275055,
0.15845848619937897,
-0.4087003171443939,
-0.08780243247747421,
0.18783223628997803,
-0.2578047215938568,
-0.198719322681427,
0.6262032389640808,
-0.31046944856643677,
0.6880390644073486,
0.2911151051521301,
0.0814545750617981,
0.23572799563407898,
-0.5167695879936218,
0.10198203474283218,
0.40906593203544617,
0.4436938762664795,
0.32923799753189087,
-0.3923282027244568,
-0.34353873133659363,
0.18365493416786194,
0.1756175458431244,
0.034741513431072235,
-0.5106319785118103,
-0.6078534126281738,
0.5543056726455688,
-0.18303272128105164,
-0.2269037961959839,
-0.3761345148086548,
-0.7386634349822998,
-0.485476016998291,
0.015986358746886253,
0.4436655342578888,
-0.3084008991718292,
-0.3076198399066925,
0.21875619888305664,
-0.06304589658975601,
-0.06847310066223145,
0.39035555720329285,
-0.5841467976570129,
0.1390453577041626,
0.6015883684158325,
0.4518488645553589,
-0.6952720880508423,
-0.009814794175326824,
-0.7358206510543823,
0.610623836517334,
-0.3660873472690582,
0.8322068452835083,
-0.530369222164154,
-0.42596083879470825,
-0.3647705614566803,
-0.21234066784381866,
0.1552051454782486,
-0.5313913226127625,
0.510441243648529,
-0.9966105818748474,
-0.052072517573833466,
-0.27521955966949463,
-0.444113552570343,
-0.04372818395495415,
0.350256085395813,
-0.8557907938957214,
1.0914908647537231,
0.0345478355884552,
-0.652362048625946,
0.27378007769584656,
-0.6986570954322815,
-0.5302369594573975,
0.37455710768699646,
-0.18628807365894318,
-0.22622394561767578,
-0.06159224361181259,
0.33814793825149536,
0.33400580286979675,
-0.00891530979424715,
0.31704649329185486,
-0.5544593930244446,
0.17113079130649567,
0.06540616601705551,
-0.1379234343767166,
0.49707603454589844,
0.23371250927448273,
0.32678112387657166,
0.021684177219867706,
-0.7438408732414246,
0.049265485256910324,
0.015101213939487934,
-0.6115608215332031,
-0.7570866942405701,
-0.30604609847068787,
-0.8276312351226807,
-0.1934877336025238,
0.7753507494926453,
-0.5099736452102661,
0.3116965889930725,
-0.19571997225284576,
0.12069899588823318,
0.5197696089744568,
0.1765269786119461,
0.7345449924468994,
-0.36765119433403015,
0.5456190705299377,
-0.011214543133974075,
0.052930667996406555,
-0.10463329404592514,
-0.4303373694419861,
-0.3841998279094696,
-0.642204999923706,
0.3476791977882385,
0.41875311732292175,
-0.7346173524856567,
0.2259642630815506,
-0.20549030601978302,
-0.19866354763507843,
-0.5654398202896118,
-0.08378975093364716,
0.07220213860273361,
0.5414196252822876,
0.525681734085083,
-0.5317326784133911,
-0.3562202453613281,
-0.5719554424285889,
-0.2357434332370758,
-0.04327898100018501,
0.30698999762535095,
0.5894817113876343,
-0.043704066425561905,
-0.50075763463974,
0.7882161140441895,
-0.7426514029502869,
-0.3077794313430786,
-0.013322504237294197,
0.25570985674858093,
-0.11983399093151093,
0.14469799399375916,
0.011752884835004807,
-0.730798065662384,
-0.7118214964866638,
0.05631067976355553,
-0.9356799721717834,
-0.3903945982456207,
0.3204520344734192,
-0.04875862970948219,
-0.025767328217625618,
0.6452873349189758,
-0.6193753480911255,
0.21024353802204132,
0.8201500773429871,
-0.41904789209365845,
0.8025819063186646,
-0.7047582864761353,
0.19163468480110168,
-0.9699212908744812,
-0.13866668939590454,
-0.39182770252227783,
-0.1346515715122223,
-0.6055902242660522,
-0.004810615908354521,
-0.23760885000228882,
0.056416675448417664,
0.039075642824172974,
0.747564435005188,
-0.5664213299751282,
0.0450035035610199,
-0.3830885887145996,
0.13323873281478882,
0.00045526999747380614,
0.004288666881620884,
-0.3919028341770172,
0.6171080470085144,
0.7781350612640381,
-0.6777776479721069,
0.630340576171875,
0.08007971942424774,
-0.49167701601982117,
0.3987455368041992,
-0.4107038676738739,
0.21366310119628906,
-0.05895741656422615,
0.4717976152896881,
-1.0087683200836182,
-0.27420327067375183,
0.31076642870903015,
-0.3697786331176758,
0.2796895205974579,
-0.05422700196504593,
-0.32442179322242737,
-0.18635119497776031,
-0.14034511148929596,
0.7406818270683289,
0.42617785930633545,
-0.42730942368507385,
0.8393352031707764,
0.8026372194290161,
-0.5165371894836426,
-0.6875738501548767,
-0.49311205744743347,
0.13075003027915955,
-0.09074991941452026,
-1.0237948894500732,
0.6599485278129578,
-0.35449621081352234,
-0.20093965530395508,
0.4681381285190582,
-0.5428040027618408,
-0.0021295822225511074,
-0.1322297900915146,
-0.011219167150557041,
-0.047628238797187805,
-0.16654573380947113,
0.18876098096370697,
0.2359032928943634,
-0.277561217546463,
-0.17221902310848236,
-0.0412355400621891,
0.4782150685787201,
0.06389206647872925,
-0.3264429569244385,
-0.2353498488664627,
0.30479592084884644,
0.673827052116394,
-0.24949635565280914,
0.33901265263557434,
0.4325885772705078,
0.08428703993558884,
-0.1565408706665039,
-0.3117515742778778,
-0.34787410497665405,
-0.5138013362884521,
0.5469433665275574,
-0.5223730206489563,
-0.9901289343833923,
0.5129894614219666,
-0.6526955962181091,
-0.3516828715801239,
0.11873481422662735,
0.5314444303512573,
-0.22330713272094727,
0.896481454372406,
0.6294188499450684,
0.17568650841712952,
0.23865018784999847,
-0.20434390008449554,
0.14808791875839233,
-1.1698427200317383,
-0.3447192311286926,
0.18319988250732422,
-0.30753156542778015,
-0.20985715091228485,
-0.5885005593299866,
0.6919952034950256,
0.06954418867826462,
0.34941163659095764,
-0.33645883202552795,
-0.05935007333755493,
0.24400272965431213,
0.1339493840932846,
0.3268619179725647,
0.514954149723053,
-0.1620471179485321,
-0.6619288921356201,
0.22709009051322937,
-0.8348721265792847,
-0.21393217146396637,
0.9908280372619629,
0.09345689415931702,
0.9190885424613953,
-0.0028513402212411165,
0.4731296896934509,
0.6245665550231934,
0.06454159319400787,
-0.7865117788314819,
0.8547730445861816,
-0.31835243105888367,
-0.40980827808380127,
-0.2877829670906067,
-0.401138573884964,
-1.139493465423584,
-0.04652553051710129,
-0.003259244840592146,
-0.38809749484062195,
0.13450387120246887,
0.497942715883255,
-0.6193519830703735,
0.0716027095913887,
-0.6244751811027527,
0.7136878967285156,
-0.5532371401786804,
-0.4939831495285034,
-0.6138901710510254,
-0.47243526577949524,
0.3946956992149353,
-0.3360055387020111,
0.19705405831336975,
-0.24130700528621674,
-0.3986930251121521,
0.8357345461845398,
-0.11098217964172363,
0.623715341091156,
0.11698537319898605,
-0.4797613024711609,
0.19721780717372894,
0.19631768763065338,
0.6216608881950378,
0.14788733422756195,
-0.09127224236726761,
0.07055753469467163,
0.09130100160837173,
-0.4114866256713867,
-0.8157366514205933,
1.00148606300354,
-0.6158477663993835,
-0.7746187448501587,
-0.5925118327140808,
-1.0309808254241943,
-0.32758620381355286,
0.10763641446828842,
-0.6200581192970276,
0.09393617510795593,
-0.09137626737356186,
-0.10735976696014404,
0.42781057953834534,
-0.22361069917678833,
0.07571818679571152,
0.8191249966621399,
-0.1074613705277443,
-0.4644489884376526,
0.9002723097801208,
0.09910345822572708,
0.37803661823272705,
0.014005033299326897,
0.3358834385871887,
-0.20337526500225067,
-0.454058438539505,
-0.08344842493534088,
0.3616214990615845,
-0.6531354188919067,
0.2196599692106247,
-0.8441565632820129,
-0.12288592010736465,
-0.27419406175613403,
-0.0824468657374382,
-0.25596025586128235,
-0.456138551235199,
-0.036947838962078094,
-0.04433075338602066,
0.5636333227157593,
0.6896505355834961,
-0.44161874055862427,
0.1959867924451828,
-0.7777795195579529,
0.6384813189506531,
0.5247154831886292,
0.30253866314888,
0.1550210565328598,
-0.1891300231218338,
-0.44020920991897583,
0.24301385879516602,
-0.18206609785556793,
-0.7158193588256836,
0.28188201785087585,
0.1781010925769806,
0.7385983467102051,
0.2353123277425766,
0.3060097396373749,
0.781276285648346,
-0.4077163636684418,
0.559343159198761,
-0.02686796337366104,
-0.2180178314447403,
0.299125611782074,
-0.1417292356491089,
0.2425214797258377,
0.2845059037208557,
0.49347296357154846,
-0.4557287395000458,
-0.3318641781806946,
-0.5285876393318176,
-1.0876359939575195,
0.7046153545379639,
0.05350891873240471,
-0.06004029139876366,
0.25856971740722656,
0.5587102174758911,
0.1861027628183365,
-0.14624103903770447,
-0.11859437078237534,
-0.25524699687957764,
0.33457961678504944,
-0.36527135968208313,
-0.16015586256980896,
-0.2883221507072449,
-0.33803945779800415,
-0.3569420874118805,
0.6998953223228455,
0.02824380062520504,
0.30039018392562866,
0.26114901900291443,
-0.10173225402832031,
-0.31464314460754395,
-0.08072831481695175,
0.18836362659931183,
0.41113993525505066,
-0.2751290500164032,
0.4242258369922638,
0.22807221114635468,
-0.8236852884292603,
0.08995575457811356,
0.25144070386886597,
-0.1358160376548767,
-0.48862794041633606,
0.23045043647289276,
0.42060139775276184,
-0.0678478255867958,
-0.681662917137146,
-0.012924266047775745,
-0.16343475878238678,
0.17543557286262512,
-0.1662028282880783,
0.1995393931865692,
0.3259148895740509,
0.5777105093002319,
0.5083397626876831,
-0.11362793296575546,
-0.09333198517560959,
-0.5438340306282043,
0.5395122170448303,
0.7193432450294495,
-0.3100643455982208,
-0.4295336604118347,
0.5180130004882812,
0.37551748752593994,
-0.23530544340610504,
0.2684156000614166,
-0.2762433588504791,
-0.3433789312839508,
0.671744167804718,
0.4435243010520935,
0.4504922330379486,
-0.1838407665491104,
0.018427418544888496,
-0.0057610198855400085,
-0.16260574758052826,
0.1020146980881691,
0.21386970579624176,
-0.20768392086029053,
-0.7187038064002991,
-0.5290352702140808,
-0.4813591539859772,
-0.23634234070777893,
0.3478432893753052,
-0.3162713944911957,
0.22392286360263824,
0.17862379550933838,
-0.26108118891716003,
0.1984422206878662,
0.47361019253730774,
-0.05329604819417,
0.08473769575357437,
-0.07359839230775833,
0.6485260128974915,
-0.5916826725006104,
1.001523733139038,
1.229386568069458,
-0.16306498646736145,
-0.0575697235763073,
0.3688044250011444,
-0.16268561780452728,
-0.9065172076225281,
0.8076273202896118,
-0.2427375763654709,
-0.08838313072919846,
0.3397804796695709,
-0.5163182020187378,
-1.1007153987884521,
1.3936138153076172,
0.15871302783489227,
-0.12600190937519073,
0.03313310071825981,
0.14322257041931152,
0.45080676674842834,
-0.32307949662208557,
-0.11567717790603638,
0.2679833769798279,
0.49194687604904175,
0.506094753742218,
-0.6680706143379211,
0.06512489169836044,
0.04469458758831024,
-0.5914239287376404,
0.10727104544639587,
-0.7185119390487671,
0.49780502915382385,
-0.508109450340271,
-0.08708498626947403,
0.05818222463130951,
0.771575391292572,
0.4118362367153168,
0.6042483448982239,
0.3644765317440033,
1.0799881219863892,
1.0007742643356323,
0.2831803262233734,
0.8948644399642944,
-0.5951764583587646,
0.11093200743198395,
0.9982209205627441,
-0.2963534891605377,
0.2867302894592285,
0.45333659648895264,
-0.17247414588928223,
0.307285338640213,
0.6816973090171814,
0.23975379765033722,
0.83529132604599,
0.04060394689440727,
-0.839108407497406,
-0.3317464590072632,
-0.11987582594156265,
-0.12476111203432083,
0.21288572251796722,
0.6986992359161377,
0.10663599520921707,
-0.4065144658088684,
-0.012723937630653381,
-0.09088172763586044,
-0.28580978512763977,
-0.1587400883436203,
0.7385575771331787,
0.44404545426368713,
-0.4958476424217224,
0.3947565257549286,
0.04130307585000992,
0.5000805258750916,
-0.7998905777931213,
-0.1792416125535965,
-0.3606044352054596,
0.19631913304328918,
0.11256230622529984,
-0.7783291935920715,
0.24297595024108887,
-0.2831519842147827,
-0.22730028629302979,
0.30596232414245605,
0.8803373575210571,
-0.6555348634719849,
-0.33036163449287415,
0.4172077178955078,
0.6230896711349487,
0.19317269325256348,
0.3808726668357849,
-0.6036427617073059,
0.1116328090429306,
-0.3307701349258423,
-0.013745411299169064,
0.4561108350753784,
0.5786219835281372,
-0.2375984638929367,
1.0213849544525146,
0.6662904620170593,
0.28998905420303345,
0.1694088578224182,
-0.4058888852596283,
0.8523063659667969,
-0.22376640141010284,
-0.24985508620738983,
-0.7552494406700134,
0.218282088637352,
-0.07075372338294983,
0.19126315414905548,
0.7656777501106262,
0.4500075876712799,
0.4282061755657196,
0.1368538737297058,
0.7997418642044067,
-0.12158770114183426,
0.17020079493522644,
-0.302473783493042,
0.956942081451416,
-0.7871692776679993,
0.2691446840763092,
0.21204335987567902,
-0.36748290061950684,
-0.21434125304222107,
0.22353555262088776,
-0.6159218549728394,
0.13096708059310913,
0.7027884125709534,
0.8177395462989807,
-0.25273776054382324,
-0.2420315444469452,
0.26110953092575073,
0.7503113746643066,
0.22786328196525574,
0.4971071481704712,
0.6894972324371338,
-0.20029769837856293,
0.5644181966781616,
-0.1869429051876068,
-0.39112141728401184,
-0.2498127967119217,
-1.0174062252044678,
-0.523147702217102,
-0.5182120203971863,
-0.6386131048202515,
-0.32929301261901855,
0.5352810621261597,
0.51413893699646,
0.575126588344574,
-0.536564290523529,
0.016580387949943542,
0.084332175552845,
0.21602725982666016,
-0.2453610897064209,
-0.11412667483091354,
0.9355784058570862,
-0.3207193911075592,
-0.6012403964996338,
0.5961987376213074,
0.25867417454719543,
0.13043083250522614,
-0.14351224899291992,
-0.3588223159313202,
-0.5599698424339294,
0.132269486784935,
0.7175281643867493,
0.2883078157901764,
-0.3221008777618408,
0.17091414332389832,
0.07225879281759262,
-0.01937403343617916,
-0.031039675697684288,
0.5608705282211304,
-1.111433744430542,
0.6840592622756958,
0.4419037699699402,
0.7397516369819641,
0.485094279050827,
0.09202393889427185,
0.6544583439826965,
-0.49996113777160645,
-0.23449839651584625,
0.33737772703170776,
-0.09628346562385559,
0.1573755443096161,
-0.5556297302246094,
0.23121866583824158,
0.46394258737564087,
-0.6124460101127625,
-0.7021286487579346,
0.2763318419456482,
-1.177947998046875,
-0.3651690185070038,
1.1960134506225586,
-0.002315166871994734,
-0.2989234924316406,
-0.3942077159881592,
-0.20678207278251648,
0.5412896871566772,
-0.4142926037311554,
1.1491388082504272,
0.7301340699195862,
-0.6337356567382812,
-0.08868946880102158,
-0.49765750765800476,
0.6362668871879578,
0.5763894319534302,
-0.6489996910095215,
0.04150771349668503,
0.2740546464920044,
0.22578616440296173,
-0.1103377714753151,
0.7923277020454407,
-0.1776062697172165,
0.17589543759822845,
-0.2587524652481079,
-0.06418294459581375,
-0.3015359342098236,
-0.11261339485645294,
-0.10601111501455307,
0.016415545716881752,
-0.031688764691352844,
-0.06014151871204376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04818v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04818v1
|
ACORN: Aspect-wise Commonsense Reasoning Explanation Evaluation
| 2024-05-08T05:36:52 | 2024-05-08T05:36:52 |
Ana Brassard, Benjamin Heinzerling, Keito Kudo, Keisuke Sakaguchi, Kentaro Inui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Evaluating free-text explanations is a multifaceted, subjective, and
labor-intensive task. Large language models (LLMs) present an appealing
alternative due to their potential for consistency, scalability, and
cost-efficiency. In this work, we present ACORN, a new dataset of 3,500
free-text explanations and aspect-wise quality ratings, and use it to gain
insights into how LLMs evaluate explanations. We observed that replacing one of
the human ratings sometimes maintained, but more often lowered the
inter-annotator agreement across different settings and quality aspects,
suggesting that their judgments are not always consistent with human raters. We
further quantified this difference by comparing the correlation between
LLM-generated ratings with majority-voted human ratings across different
quality aspects. With the best system, Spearman's rank correlation ranged
between 0.53 to 0.95, averaging 0.72 across aspects, indicating moderately high
but imperfect alignment. Finally, we considered the alternative of using an LLM
as an additional rater when human raters are scarce, and measured the
correlation between majority-voted labels with a limited human pool and LLMs as
an additional rater, compared to the original gold labels. While GPT-4 improved
the outcome when there were only two human raters, in all other observed cases,
LLMs were neutral to detrimental when there were three or more human raters. We
publicly release the dataset to support future improvements in LLM-in-the-loop
evaluation here: https://github.com/a-brassard/ACORN.
|
[
-0.37479883432388306,
-0.6119979023933411,
0.6584381461143494,
0.059812501072883606,
-0.4805339276790619,
-0.3854731619358063,
-0.3632895052433014,
-0.5190469622612,
-0.024736354127526283,
0.4579489529132843,
-0.4213256239891052,
-0.6081668138504028,
-0.49523836374282837,
0.31364762783050537,
-0.4301687777042389,
1.267449975013733,
0.039274346083402634,
-0.21464700996875763,
-0.537877082824707,
-0.43717217445373535,
-0.41347232460975647,
-0.33965280652046204,
-0.7388463616371155,
-0.6264679431915283,
0.6075376868247986,
0.6217979788780212,
1.2320715188980103,
0.8166046142578125,
0.46550917625427246,
0.2665308117866516,
-0.32025110721588135,
0.1146811842918396,
-0.10454407334327698,
0.030417706817388535,
-0.3106524348258972,
-0.18039612472057343,
-0.702567994594574,
0.14682699739933014,
0.4068479835987091,
0.6149000525474548,
-0.20366689562797546,
0.08499725908041,
0.07843372225761414,
0.7529515624046326,
-0.4401155710220337,
0.20862925052642822,
-0.6566239595413208,
-0.19147947430610657,
-0.01946335844695568,
-0.16082970798015594,
-0.2501397132873535,
-0.24009235203266144,
0.32053762674331665,
-1.078432559967041,
0.374803751707077,
0.5363742709159851,
0.9053781628608704,
0.2543278932571411,
-0.2626895308494568,
-0.3806670904159546,
-0.3506796658039093,
0.8282439112663269,
-1.0793699026107788,
0.17122887074947357,
0.4827674925327301,
0.1942550390958786,
0.007243798114359379,
-0.29833877086639404,
-0.7585150599479675,
-0.23835907876491547,
-0.37913206219673157,
0.10049964487552643,
-0.3732565641403198,
0.226502925157547,
0.011807921342551708,
0.911879301071167,
-0.7199193239212036,
0.19563022255897522,
-0.1322234570980072,
-0.4247438311576843,
0.8483617901802063,
0.2620147466659546,
0.002514143707230687,
-0.4529491066932678,
-0.15819868445396423,
-0.24576038122177124,
-0.6166930794715881,
-0.00007315641414606944,
0.5539460778236389,
0.19299399852752686,
-0.11874698102474213,
0.6598577499389648,
-0.2662999629974365,
0.8601190447807312,
0.1963679939508438,
0.03574405238032341,
0.13447144627571106,
-0.20264242589473724,
-0.3326164186000824,
0.07344833016395569,
1.0299639701843262,
0.5213882923126221,
-0.07485819607973099,
-0.01883152313530445,
-0.2758503556251526,
0.14715668559074402,
-0.06821009516716003,
-0.5068836808204651,
-0.5344261527061462,
0.5526066422462463,
-0.5967512130737305,
-0.33943766355514526,
-0.07267195731401443,
-0.4751867651939392,
-0.769241988658905,
-0.5044326782226562,
0.3317958116531372,
-0.5070047378540039,
-0.450977087020874,
0.16484004259109497,
-0.04858774319291115,
0.22941401600837708,
0.6079201698303223,
-0.7568638324737549,
0.16589245200157166,
0.8715720772743225,
0.8263523578643799,
-0.4153518080711365,
-0.16346095502376556,
-0.48229673504829407,
-0.29804444313049316,
-0.2839008867740631,
0.9779680371284485,
-0.6410802602767944,
-0.24443663656711578,
-0.3522578477859497,
-0.05756736546754837,
0.16238188743591309,
-0.6061100959777832,
0.6914472579956055,
-0.5148543119430542,
0.3141288459300995,
-0.3335611820220947,
-0.5047418475151062,
-0.5255438089370728,
0.5008268356323242,
-0.7457652688026428,
0.818673849105835,
0.006083209067583084,
-0.8631138801574707,
0.4621953070163727,
-0.8393411040306091,
-0.18767140805721283,
0.08540452271699905,
0.02268277481198311,
-0.26348453760147095,
0.14896172285079956,
0.6754995584487915,
0.34778356552124023,
-0.2692515552043915,
0.260347455739975,
-0.403702050447464,
-0.26188498735427856,
0.6445010900497437,
-0.7934184074401855,
0.6641271710395813,
0.2769834101200104,
-0.08691704273223877,
0.344356894493103,
-0.453223317861557,
-0.2537108063697815,
-0.14738792181015015,
-0.15699075162410736,
-0.48166295886039734,
-0.03354056179523468,
-0.15517665445804596,
0.1747407168149948,
0.18302246928215027,
-0.5430118441581726,
0.12424056231975555,
-0.5428381562232971,
0.29343539476394653,
0.7750181555747986,
0.14549238979816437,
0.39131999015808105,
-0.5270752310752869,
0.4599412977695465,
0.19096523523330688,
0.23840077221393585,
-0.1871778517961502,
-0.4950224757194519,
-0.7659538984298706,
-0.012144636362791061,
-0.09833454340696335,
0.16605526208877563,
-0.6610830426216125,
0.09196915477514267,
-0.2641344368457794,
-0.2972019910812378,
-0.6246976852416992,
0.2601564824581146,
0.5750531554222107,
0.3560323715209961,
0.37182629108428955,
-0.4426955580711365,
-0.04189147427678108,
-0.7985155582427979,
-0.6559212803840637,
-0.5380591154098511,
0.06800668686628342,
0.46227678656578064,
0.3980594575405121,
0.2133447825908661,
1.023284673690796,
-0.20322377979755402,
-0.06230151653289795,
-0.2178255319595337,
0.19424131512641907,
0.5321562886238098,
0.20188771188259125,
0.16449806094169617,
-0.525296688079834,
-0.04497753456234932,
0.11113495379686356,
-0.48942747712135315,
-0.17435261607170105,
-0.10600795596837997,
0.018356941640377045,
0.42145633697509766,
0.11832186579704285,
-0.3000672161579132,
0.34706875681877136,
0.8639795184135437,
-0.5944622159004211,
0.834267795085907,
-0.2802671492099762,
0.16497564315795898,
-0.6793845891952515,
0.037200815975666046,
0.2898125648498535,
-0.08339056372642517,
-0.27860888838768005,
0.04138033464550972,
-0.12554557621479034,
0.01290225237607956,
-0.5493179559707642,
0.8838157057762146,
-0.43912506103515625,
-0.15160351991653442,
-0.24188034236431122,
0.4419057369232178,
0.27694472670555115,
0.40706583857536316,
-0.05605842545628548,
0.7354462146759033,
0.3885412812232971,
-0.6197169423103333,
0.49100470542907715,
0.19749188423156738,
-0.4767535626888275,
0.686718761920929,
-0.6921513676643372,
0.14968925714492798,
-0.21064141392707825,
0.3160167336463928,
-1.115126371383667,
-0.5214360952377319,
0.35978540778160095,
-0.49401530623435974,
0.021701226010918617,
-0.14053630828857422,
-0.448702871799469,
-0.38494935631752014,
-0.29685673117637634,
0.532329797744751,
-0.11280758678913116,
-0.7119869589805603,
0.3553929328918457,
0.10353345423936844,
-0.046667784452438354,
-0.5205160975456238,
-0.6173323392868042,
0.18669502437114716,
-0.45501193404197693,
-0.5032678246498108,
0.02955314889550209,
-0.03484715148806572,
-0.6100760698318481,
0.19280852377414703,
-0.35775306820869446,
0.1661125272512436,
0.04237932711839676,
0.2621251046657562,
0.26228106021881104,
-0.26323509216308594,
0.2977800965309143,
0.18028396368026733,
-0.22635366022586823,
0.12964673340320587,
-0.14873775839805603,
0.19703978300094604,
-0.4968729317188263,
-0.6152763366699219,
-0.6938187479972839,
0.06404872238636017,
0.5390656590461731,
-0.234755277633667,
0.5058954358100891,
0.3063717782497406,
-0.05156605690717697,
0.1265665739774704,
-0.5454469919204712,
-0.05804682523012161,
-0.43743565678596497,
0.20063993334770203,
-0.14033645391464233,
-0.8558878898620605,
0.408501535654068,
0.37961822748184204,
0.5464387536048889,
0.881381630897522,
0.29626357555389404,
0.10269767791032791,
1.133093237876892,
0.11324967443943024,
-0.06405975669622421,
0.28222060203552246,
-0.14385570585727692,
0.15962353348731995,
-1.11235511302948,
-0.20981234312057495,
-0.3694591522216797,
-0.2241208255290985,
-0.44780775904655457,
-0.4056466519832611,
0.4645208716392517,
0.17527759075164795,
-0.3812877833843231,
0.1805853247642517,
-0.8136645555496216,
0.5247562527656555,
0.26478034257888794,
0.06262184679508209,
0.7436278462409973,
-0.14094075560569763,
0.1354343146085739,
0.22141319513320923,
-0.6150376200675964,
-0.6635589003562927,
1.130562663078308,
0.42734992504119873,
0.7970001697540283,
0.21293982863426208,
0.39208152890205383,
0.33405327796936035,
0.9265733361244202,
-1.0133442878723145,
0.4140400290489197,
-0.3599065840244293,
-0.8035885095596313,
-0.476107120513916,
-0.5184685587882996,
-0.7824946045875549,
0.48055198788642883,
-0.2723711133003235,
-0.6374018788337708,
-0.030352676287293434,
0.6066826581954956,
-0.3717971742153168,
0.2627989649772644,
-0.48261094093322754,
0.8169203400611877,
-0.5363966226577759,
-0.3082333505153656,
-0.31472277641296387,
-0.3450162410736084,
0.6785475611686707,
0.06997007131576538,
0.5933954119682312,
-0.3741770088672638,
0.0948999747633934,
0.8992164134979248,
-0.5609331130981445,
0.6156915426254272,
-0.17748072743415833,
-0.12447521835565567,
0.2774302065372467,
0.12056120485067368,
0.32166457176208496,
0.31910139322280884,
-0.5493271350860596,
0.2808000147342682,
-0.02549615316092968,
-0.18532295525074005,
-0.6426025629043579,
0.8523606657981873,
-0.8692730665206909,
-0.7185043692588806,
-0.5558355450630188,
-0.7326589226722717,
-0.09278638660907745,
-0.04766669496893883,
0.13225731253623962,
0.679835319519043,
-0.0005338156479410827,
0.15037457644939423,
0.29596060514450073,
-0.46634092926979065,
0.3367847502231598,
0.3261418640613556,
-0.3072357177734375,
-0.6406399607658386,
0.820562481880188,
-0.47266021370887756,
0.2611328363418579,
0.18286655843257904,
0.5752511620521545,
-0.5592653751373291,
-0.5774234533309937,
-0.6780489683151245,
0.3549124300479889,
-0.7781296372413635,
-0.34556975960731506,
-0.46731364727020264,
0.15973258018493652,
-0.16151219606399536,
-0.016387198120355606,
-0.015942372381687164,
-0.6078641414642334,
-0.32438385486602783,
-0.026773683726787567,
0.7122792601585388,
0.8754725456237793,
-0.0236076470464468,
0.6203982830047607,
-0.5254009962081909,
0.1299215406179428,
0.18691283464431763,
0.40862125158309937,
0.3044525384902954,
-0.7366705536842346,
-0.17039889097213745,
0.18981394171714783,
-0.582439661026001,
-0.7390764951705933,
0.29325973987579346,
0.21157105267047882,
0.5663806796073914,
0.7478474378585815,
0.07986687868833542,
0.8457268476486206,
0.1316382884979248,
1.1078147888183594,
0.29841288924217224,
-0.9758490324020386,
0.25861427187919617,
-0.3256940543651581,
0.4277501404285431,
0.4766404628753662,
-0.1424901932477951,
-0.7958460450172424,
-0.7172091007232666,
-0.6399085521697998,
-1.1080729961395264,
0.8345401883125305,
0.13431982696056366,
-0.04270140081644058,
-0.009187030605971813,
0.49454185366630554,
0.42200717329978943,
0.023655738681554794,
-0.6637029647827148,
-0.3561897873878479,
-0.45101672410964966,
-0.11310423910617828,
-0.21607542037963867,
0.0400259830057621,
-0.17670407891273499,
-0.28414076566696167,
0.8092871904373169,
-0.14293284714221954,
0.06795430928468704,
0.2588998079299927,
-0.08745897561311722,
-0.11867489665746689,
0.6454755067825317,
0.5546277165412903,
0.745232343673706,
-0.013807804323732853,
0.27463674545288086,
0.28075847029685974,
-0.15585625171661377,
-0.14390014111995697,
0.122227244079113,
0.27657490968704224,
-0.0009531833929941058,
0.6469457745552063,
0.9780078530311584,
0.08572711795568466,
-0.29734674096107483,
0.5867053866386414,
-0.04777902737259865,
-0.2215462625026703,
-0.022634726017713547,
0.07594496011734009,
0.0194679144769907,
0.05724150687456131,
0.33612650632858276,
-0.037056419998407364,
0.10019484162330627,
-0.4610457420349121,
0.007682918570935726,
0.4836329221725464,
-0.313822478055954,
-0.43534860014915466,
0.6591072678565979,
0.20672102272510529,
-0.0781480148434639,
0.598432719707489,
-0.23446038365364075,
-0.3813204765319824,
0.5380821228027344,
0.34751176834106445,
0.7407348155975342,
-0.09700439125299454,
0.34167659282684326,
0.3531796932220459,
0.2790430784225464,
-0.16023942828178406,
-0.04373471438884735,
-0.22679181396961212,
-0.596479058265686,
-0.628588080406189,
-0.7724044322967529,
-0.8478009104728699,
0.31482478976249695,
-0.7470263242721558,
-0.018970200791954994,
-0.18786227703094482,
0.01931026205420494,
0.06404461711645126,
0.15645499527454376,
-0.719835638999939,
0.23412677645683289,
-0.023441201075911522,
1.004656195640564,
-1.0473098754882812,
0.4586780369281769,
0.8856760859489441,
-0.2144855260848999,
-0.9841951727867126,
0.016261955723166466,
0.3118687570095062,
-0.7123537063598633,
0.05185666307806969,
0.17114125192165375,
0.0009114425047300756,
-0.5146185755729675,
-0.5809307098388672,
-0.8412156105041504,
1.0767053365707397,
0.1136382520198822,
-0.5010451078414917,
0.147397980093956,
-0.07652542740106583,
0.5888016819953918,
-0.24420380592346191,
0.5501559376716614,
0.6537085175514221,
0.7526618838310242,
0.28448188304901123,
-0.9218074679374695,
0.16139693558216095,
-0.03286673128604889,
-0.10076487809419632,
0.17609070241451263,
-0.3949211537837982,
0.7191495895385742,
-0.24808673560619354,
-0.15306052565574646,
0.11942442506551743,
0.7583805918693542,
0.6208585500717163,
0.7162845134735107,
0.7734362483024597,
0.46153756976127625,
0.8133068084716797,
-0.03885166347026825,
1.1118084192276,
-0.20249207317829132,
0.3473189175128937,
0.9872355461120605,
0.11132742464542389,
0.703626275062561,
0.5699050426483154,
-0.08105231821537018,
0.6326358914375305,
0.8124327063560486,
0.429657518863678,
0.18032757937908173,
0.1388615071773529,
-0.18875333666801453,
-0.38348880410194397,
-0.015155738219618797,
-0.15255321562290192,
0.38068887591362,
0.5178836584091187,
-0.30878403782844543,
-0.37861600518226624,
-0.1743668019771576,
0.1217840388417244,
-0.09915316104888916,
-0.5312262773513794,
0.7903611063957214,
0.23715920746326447,
-0.9036204218864441,
0.4636261761188507,
-0.12295481562614441,
0.6151776313781738,
-0.2135080248117447,
0.05093307048082352,
-0.344579815864563,
0.11902758479118347,
-0.6203678250312805,
-1.194557547569275,
0.38562387228012085,
0.15461431443691254,
-0.04168351739645004,
-0.1717996746301651,
0.34544724225997925,
-0.33795085549354553,
-0.4046422243118286,
-0.1853475570678711,
0.13672839105129242,
0.5485646724700928,
-0.1160561814904213,
-0.7259823679924011,
0.196500763297081,
-0.11723504960536957,
-0.42331835627555847,
0.010568346828222275,
0.5821060538291931,
-0.3639114201068878,
0.46417516469955444,
0.8201553821563721,
0.08775690197944641,
-0.5005428791046143,
-0.056816693395376205,
0.8504105806350708,
-0.5959641337394714,
-0.34194010496139526,
-0.8037887811660767,
0.45853301882743835,
-0.11123418062925339,
-0.6557790040969849,
0.6838986873626709,
0.5447903871536255,
0.6001750230789185,
0.42333897948265076,
0.6989046335220337,
0.07146346569061279,
0.37212511897087097,
-0.38844525814056396,
0.7323697805404663,
-0.7299858927726746,
0.6310080885887146,
-0.4477905035018921,
-0.9727322459220886,
-0.4893695116043091,
0.5735816955566406,
-0.5981569886207581,
-0.027698060497641563,
0.7850052118301392,
0.7477208375930786,
-0.2101580649614334,
0.3671746253967285,
0.1606917381286621,
0.2657589614391327,
0.4776979684829712,
0.4266011714935303,
0.7797232270240784,
-0.14403170347213745,
0.7539351582527161,
-0.13882966339588165,
-0.369071900844574,
-0.16491737961769104,
-1.1038612127304077,
-0.6263260841369629,
-0.4160219132900238,
-0.27800366282463074,
-0.38591039180755615,
-0.061324480921030045,
0.8038713932037354,
0.48469114303588867,
-0.8450559377670288,
-0.19732925295829773,
-0.01492343284189701,
0.24431000649929047,
-0.47792088985443115,
-0.3032796382904053,
0.5596871376037598,
-0.061240680515766144,
-0.3789353370666504,
0.17121462523937225,
0.252302348613739,
-0.4633498191833496,
-0.21117785573005676,
-0.34898027777671814,
0.3464016318321228,
0.004007520154118538,
0.5313788056373596,
0.21236661076545715,
-1.190849781036377,
-0.6305000185966492,
-0.05586841329932213,
0.16618140041828156,
0.07053439319133759,
0.7747300863265991,
-0.7515226602554321,
0.597184419631958,
0.3958387076854706,
0.19905008375644684,
0.36351266503334045,
0.40082427859306335,
0.38932493329048157,
-0.41669926047325134,
-0.23695896565914154,
0.2115912139415741,
0.24083393812179565,
0.7256001830101013,
-0.2572876214981079,
0.09174975752830505,
-0.04392068833112717,
-0.7846843004226685,
-0.5812671184539795,
0.18603192269802094,
-1.1160986423492432,
-0.09220673143863678,
1.5590763092041016,
-0.1007821261882782,
-0.3258604109287262,
-0.24592073261737823,
-0.28214529156684875,
0.1901894360780716,
-0.7719249129295349,
0.7700047492980957,
0.8478672504425049,
-0.5665159821510315,
-0.3092647194862366,
-0.2232540100812912,
0.42179974913597107,
0.3998905122280121,
-0.8299143314361572,
0.4357335567474365,
0.7499701380729675,
0.3642047345638275,
0.01157650537788868,
0.5481821298599243,
-0.251964271068573,
0.3040800094604492,
-0.4365641474723816,
-0.1472950279712677,
-0.23084475100040436,
-0.0692763552069664,
-0.6752045154571533,
-0.18561580777168274,
0.37448275089263916,
-0.08287425339221954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06697v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06697v1
|
Automated Conversion of Static to Dynamic Scheduler via Natural Language
| 2024-05-08T04:07:38 | 2024-05-08T04:07:38 |
Paul Mingzheng Tang, Kenji Kah Hoe Leong, Nowshad Shaik, Hoong Chuin Lau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper, we explore the potential application of Large Language Models
(LLMs) that will automatically model constraints and generate code for dynamic
scheduling problems given an existing static model. Static scheduling problems
are modelled and coded by optimization experts. These models may be easily
obsoleted as the underlying constraints may need to be fine-tuned in order to
reflect changes in the scheduling rules. Furthermore, it may be necessary to
turn a static model into a dynamic one in order to cope with disturbances in
the environment. In this paper, we propose a Retrieval-Augmented Generation
(RAG) based LLM model to automate the process of implementing constraints for
Dynamic Scheduling (RAGDyS), without seeking help from an optimization modeling
expert. Our framework aims to minimize technical complexities related to
mathematical modelling and computational workload for end-users, thereby
allowing end-users to quickly obtain a new schedule close to the original
schedule with changes reflected by natural language constraint descriptions.
|
[
-0.2399531900882721,
-0.4917818605899811,
0.5906018614768982,
0.19788113236427307,
-0.2287617176771164,
0.1710345298051834,
-0.23642413318157196,
-0.6861298084259033,
0.1561335325241089,
0.947180986404419,
-0.9954229593276978,
-0.00805763341486454,
-0.1546218991279602,
0.46165794134140015,
-0.446617990732193,
0.8746935725212097,
-0.6416301727294922,
-0.3384625017642975,
-0.2576213479042053,
0.14752034842967987,
-0.4458014667034149,
-0.2835996150970459,
-0.31152093410491943,
-0.42152395844459534,
-0.04342685639858246,
0.11434199661016464,
0.5894498229026794,
0.829305112361908,
0.5606724619865417,
0.4320827126502991,
-0.3494240939617157,
0.6869310736656189,
-0.4225674569606781,
0.45045775175094604,
-0.2914241850376129,
-0.24262350797653198,
-0.389809787273407,
-0.13202998042106628,
0.7570250630378723,
0.7004098296165466,
-0.5329620838165283,
0.5973995327949524,
-0.00344825373031199,
0.6407536268234253,
-0.5218689441680908,
0.4366239011287689,
-0.8436071872711182,
0.1827036291360855,
0.022328082472085953,
-0.5315414071083069,
-0.21733234822750092,
-0.7247375249862671,
-0.22253979742527008,
-0.6120853424072266,
0.08494162559509277,
-0.03959011286497116,
1.0052523612976074,
1.0065699815750122,
-0.5097091197967529,
-0.39098310470581055,
-1.1977777481079102,
0.886448085308075,
-0.6181429624557495,
0.18630962073802948,
0.10483396053314209,
0.6393107771873474,
-0.4519219994544983,
-0.6027053594589233,
-0.49573951959609985,
-0.6275404691696167,
-0.22233547270298004,
0.03754003718495369,
0.4419332444667816,
-0.08980157971382141,
0.4132549464702606,
0.3416345417499542,
-0.14953072369098663,
-0.1569877713918686,
-0.1630672961473465,
0.3192293047904968,
0.6832666397094727,
0.6991413831710815,
0.2584185302257538,
-0.2882124185562134,
-0.17245715856552124,
0.38938674330711365,
-0.4596424102783203,
-0.3028263449668884,
0.3928822875022888,
0.1935146003961563,
-0.18418775498867035,
0.5911767482757568,
-0.3681938648223877,
0.7110969424247742,
0.22464905679225922,
-0.4325858950614929,
-0.07098175585269928,
-0.1887996643781662,
-0.27106717228889465,
-0.2288086861371994,
0.07040376216173172,
0.24115164577960968,
0.15849900245666504,
-0.3237181305885315,
-0.564903974533081,
-0.01274383720010519,
0.49149081110954285,
-0.6606970429420471,
0.1194799616932869,
-0.2781006395816803,
-0.19897139072418213,
-0.6591810584068298,
-0.12059888243675232,
-0.5850251913070679,
-0.4226849675178528,
-0.9730209112167358,
0.02694912813603878,
-0.23158012330532074,
0.013872597366571426,
0.050893913954496384,
0.1468266099691391,
0.2563260495662689,
0.5125910639762878,
-0.403801828622818,
0.33751651644706726,
0.5809781551361084,
0.49180546402931213,
-0.20684699714183807,
0.12290195375680923,
-0.5895023345947266,
0.6716599464416504,
-0.28916338086128235,
0.4819222092628479,
-0.34663400053977966,
-0.4480353593826294,
-0.024424545466899872,
0.08958412706851959,
0.004192770924419165,
-0.6425076127052307,
0.5084609985351562,
-0.8858659267425537,
-0.010306047275662422,
0.29911312460899353,
-0.3900727927684784,
-0.010342337191104889,
0.3119482696056366,
-0.6269272565841675,
1.0096662044525146,
0.3077446222305298,
-0.4664272964000702,
-0.01126435212790966,
-0.6319702863693237,
-0.3561527729034424,
0.3899723291397095,
-0.2581441104412079,
-0.29803159832954407,
0.14903585612773895,
-0.09933502972126007,
0.07318287342786789,
-0.6614229083061218,
0.8908012509346008,
0.005717842373996973,
-0.03486906737089157,
0.23622851073741913,
-0.1873045116662979,
0.5588966012001038,
0.463492751121521,
-0.2815432548522949,
-0.025072205811738968,
-0.8462277054786682,
0.1402730643749237,
0.17383669316768646,
-0.7738000750541687,
0.12049943953752518,
0.4782797396183014,
-0.004320316482335329,
0.15167875587940216,
0.6763794422149658,
-0.2656387686729431,
0.4864669144153595,
-0.4584258198738098,
0.04067375883460045,
0.6089087724685669,
0.07527095079421997,
0.43629762530326843,
-0.3979306221008301,
0.9123708605766296,
-0.7564507722854614,
0.1409931629896164,
0.16954131424427032,
0.05331147834658623,
-0.6538584232330322,
-0.08947750180959702,
-0.04654368385672569,
0.8220041394233704,
-0.8190675973892212,
0.5304411053657532,
-0.35767707228660583,
-0.32505130767822266,
-0.09532085061073303,
0.2667287290096283,
0.3518657684326172,
0.644330620765686,
0.17543131113052368,
0.1967698484659195,
-0.8813123106956482,
-0.7946591973304749,
-0.16357636451721191,
0.207670196890831,
0.03777572140097618,
0.5708009600639343,
0.28519636392593384,
-0.5760663151741028,
0.9059669971466064,
-0.7235137224197388,
-0.29669126868247986,
-0.4003966450691223,
0.2602996230125427,
0.6049927473068237,
0.42301028966903687,
0.3935871720314026,
-0.8278467059135437,
-0.7694904208183289,
0.08064446598291397,
-0.701341450214386,
-0.5887954235076904,
-0.2682137191295624,
-0.11452924460172653,
0.5335689783096313,
0.6875811219215393,
-0.47978872060775757,
0.5557696223258972,
0.6191991567611694,
-0.0832289308309555,
1.003946304321289,
-0.17120273411273956,
-0.21017400920391083,
-1.0321022272109985,
0.3644060790538788,
-0.42811813950538635,
-0.5612791180610657,
-0.3919081389904022,
0.41848236322402954,
-0.2152588814496994,
-0.5180784463882446,
-0.2241571694612503,
0.654948353767395,
-0.7786905169487,
0.09405899792909622,
-0.3652474284172058,
-0.3244600296020508,
-0.09206339716911316,
0.24476227164268494,
-0.11925050616264343,
0.9580766558647156,
0.06891608238220215,
-0.8996495604515076,
0.5176170468330383,
0.23644502460956573,
-0.34251275658607483,
0.11807872354984283,
-0.5042403936386108,
0.017431560903787613,
-0.19119934737682343,
0.3963564932346344,
-0.3994899392127991,
-0.5463197231292725,
0.12412899732589722,
0.1446475386619568,
0.6995210647583008,
-0.5419146418571472,
-0.6535900235176086,
-0.4194350242614746,
0.07171668112277985,
0.1935504972934723,
0.6907033920288086,
-0.4209093749523163,
0.8195288777351379,
0.4382295310497284,
-0.07627324759960175,
-0.13176584243774414,
-0.46310868859291077,
0.241706982254982,
0.005855974275618792,
-0.4269658327102661,
0.8996161818504333,
-0.09732354432344437,
-0.2667228579521179,
0.1250305324792862,
-0.16378922760486603,
-0.08330567926168442,
0.21866025030612946,
0.19821402430534363,
0.5540026426315308,
0.014582677744328976,
-0.22308848798274994,
-0.1832786202430725,
-0.1859082728624344,
-0.04115938022732735,
-0.25854194164276123,
0.6032223701477051,
0.12245452404022217,
-0.29452115297317505,
-0.5767892003059387,
0.3506060838699341,
0.7193276286125183,
-0.40024498105049133,
0.7492266297340393,
0.41183239221572876,
-0.4439575970172882,
-0.3499026596546173,
-0.6657406687736511,
0.02281746082007885,
-0.6174370050430298,
0.3073429465293884,
-0.4135828912258148,
-0.37711477279663086,
0.32773181796073914,
-0.39196255803108215,
0.05824105441570282,
0.2636854350566864,
0.6268423199653625,
0.17047587037086487,
1.1376382112503052,
0.7695760726928711,
0.3302260637283325,
0.5374492406845093,
-0.27476632595062256,
0.10020776838064194,
-0.7216976284980774,
-0.10023753345012665,
-0.40531519055366516,
-0.23154617846012115,
-0.6408077478408813,
-0.6239535808563232,
0.5870674252510071,
-0.0871342271566391,
-0.23573186993598938,
0.23722516000270844,
-0.8597744107246399,
0.5197998285293579,
0.21188399195671082,
-0.2520592212677002,
-0.01633516140282154,
-0.1757054626941681,
-0.1250976175069809,
-0.07021206617355347,
-0.35435861349105835,
-0.7431900501251221,
0.5057493448257446,
-0.03535083308815956,
0.9977102279663086,
0.32560914754867554,
0.8200617432594299,
0.05806339532136917,
0.3950885236263275,
-0.5733876824378967,
0.7688232660293579,
-0.34495002031326294,
-0.6131354570388794,
-0.27949121594429016,
-0.5537710189819336,
-0.6684245467185974,
-0.3287697732448578,
-0.16339348256587982,
-0.7499861121177673,
0.06311196833848953,
0.19515033066272736,
-0.23603440821170807,
0.49192383885383606,
-0.467089980840683,
0.36321455240249634,
-0.48233017325401306,
-0.5856752991676331,
-0.0838327705860138,
-0.387709379196167,
0.4449908137321472,
-0.29038235545158386,
0.18944375216960907,
-0.42263248562812805,
-0.1749308556318283,
0.5059000253677368,
-0.6545917391777039,
0.7664862275123596,
-0.20272314548492432,
-0.042517565190792084,
0.32494357228279114,
0.5749465823173523,
0.7846747040748596,
0.15538977086544037,
-0.5359866619110107,
-0.5967622399330139,
0.05007050931453705,
0.07490377873182297,
-0.4758249521255493,
0.6792490482330322,
-0.7189279198646545,
-0.7684372067451477,
-0.368624746799469,
-0.9185940027236938,
-0.14403250813484192,
0.3248925507068634,
-0.17943257093429565,
0.493114709854126,
0.004180090967565775,
-0.015686500817537308,
0.2855757772922516,
-0.3618951439857483,
0.2625225782394409,
0.6788447499275208,
-0.3714955449104309,
-0.05895822122693062,
0.6448467969894409,
0.08444397896528244,
0.022865869104862213,
0.6496716737747192,
0.1774844229221344,
-0.30451229214668274,
-0.40902355313301086,
-0.2837342917919159,
0.37536606192588806,
-0.451530784368515,
-0.42946478724479675,
-0.5574458241462708,
-0.3400467038154602,
-0.528825581073761,
-0.5421706438064575,
-0.48451027274131775,
-0.5278936624526978,
-0.4397335946559906,
0.39577633142471313,
0.4121582806110382,
0.9068506360054016,
0.10631515830755234,
-0.08053520321846008,
-0.8467342853546143,
0.6002926230430603,
0.25470271706581116,
0.5359224677085876,
-0.24952654540538788,
-0.5652916431427002,
-0.28090009093284607,
-0.18934381008148193,
-0.5112858414649963,
-0.905663013458252,
0.9986978769302368,
0.047812119126319885,
0.6074162721633911,
0.07463786005973816,
0.2511051893234253,
0.7209274172782898,
-0.936679482460022,
0.29526644945144653,
-0.20645596086978912,
-0.8218355774879456,
0.45796531438827515,
-0.4630562663078308,
0.24707362055778503,
0.5308009386062622,
0.17474676668643951,
-0.42034319043159485,
-0.16486985981464386,
-0.3729080855846405,
-0.8813525438308716,
0.8343750834465027,
-0.025421256199479103,
0.11014802008867264,
0.14181894063949585,
0.5956692695617676,
-0.03870757296681404,
0.2813570499420166,
-0.4532443583011627,
-0.09094361215829849,
0.20686104893684387,
-0.06071438267827034,
0.1265655755996704,
-0.5307350158691406,
-0.11912833899259567,
-0.3423050343990326,
0.7428061366081238,
-0.030412504449486732,
0.3688841164112091,
-0.07940862327814102,
-0.07771650701761246,
-0.34069618582725525,
0.28794053196907043,
0.7685846090316772,
0.7295908331871033,
-0.6330456137657166,
-0.1729462891817093,
0.4259493947029114,
-0.10760680586099625,
0.2042882889509201,
0.46712061762809753,
-0.3509180545806885,
0.22756923735141754,
-0.1426895260810852,
0.4456295967102051,
0.29703566431999207,
-0.6741781234741211,
-0.15406492352485657,
0.1932164579629898,
0.10438206046819687,
-0.9436494708061218,
0.0582679882645607,
0.10957252234220505,
0.011187118478119373,
0.32945716381073,
-0.06724303215742111,
0.03495241329073906,
-0.311105877161026,
0.16357308626174927,
0.24143853783607483,
0.14947661757469177,
-0.23080910742282867,
1.0656070709228516,
0.2911398112773895,
-0.5610231757164001,
0.17702050507068634,
-0.5666751861572266,
-0.7373469471931458,
0.7734498977661133,
0.762190580368042,
0.917866051197052,
-0.23448798060417175,
-0.06984270364046097,
0.38445472717285156,
0.10248815268278122,
0.1295100301504135,
0.41969403624534607,
0.258321613073349,
-0.4570309817790985,
-0.6220341324806213,
-1.1059445142745972,
-0.5694732069969177,
0.04080268740653992,
-0.6280103921890259,
0.733151376247406,
-0.4946966767311096,
-0.11873193830251694,
-0.07591839134693146,
0.03066541627049446,
-0.8149054050445557,
0.016982585191726685,
0.38562145829200745,
0.7645378708839417,
-0.32854169607162476,
0.6728322505950928,
1.2403090000152588,
-0.33196118474006653,
-0.8129416704177856,
-0.13101443648338318,
0.08969304710626602,
-0.5592892169952393,
1.0352011919021606,
-0.09045208990573883,
-0.2985176146030426,
0.025390831753611565,
-0.4082546532154083,
-1.2621949911117554,
1.0755560398101807,
0.5264360308647156,
-0.4683223366737366,
-0.5144448280334473,
0.1382681280374527,
0.47265931963920593,
-0.41199034452438354,
-0.17072921991348267,
0.11799442768096924,
0.5690135359764099,
0.10957346111536026,
-1.0778188705444336,
0.14343075454235077,
-0.25322380661964417,
0.20633971691131592,
0.5889070630073547,
-0.32756778597831726,
0.961344838142395,
-0.004759179428219795,
-0.3721023201942444,
0.13757775723934174,
0.4095653295516968,
0.20269586145877838,
0.002368832938373089,
0.4695543646812439,
0.2354983687400818,
0.5209150910377502,
0.30375194549560547,
1.310179352760315,
-0.7637073993682861,
0.36455589532852173,
1.116027593612671,
-0.7762192487716675,
0.4996092915534973,
0.48342880606651306,
-0.21887846291065216,
0.4820256233215332,
-0.031021911650896072,
-0.009651980362832546,
0.3607720136642456,
0.3156873285770416,
-0.27758079767227173,
-0.2988870441913605,
-0.37742626667022705,
-0.18964135646820068,
0.41951775550842285,
0.33458828926086426,
-0.06699465960264206,
-0.5034212470054626,
-0.23666006326675415,
0.1012357696890831,
0.5005894303321838,
-0.0431225411593914,
0.6995746493339539,
-0.039280835539102554,
-0.7109280824661255,
0.9059322476387024,
0.4214418828487396,
0.6239156723022461,
-0.49193963408470154,
-0.007701268419623375,
-0.06092020496726036,
0.2680734395980835,
-0.0905633345246315,
-0.3781994879245758,
0.8172788619995117,
0.2022840827703476,
-0.2776346802711487,
-0.6775899529457092,
0.8296388983726501,
-0.2717761993408203,
-0.8217716217041016,
0.060375627130270004,
0.3398725688457489,
-0.05387837439775467,
0.35984352231025696,
-0.6569523811340332,
-0.06944110989570618,
0.04804903268814087,
-0.1432035267353058,
0.09042368084192276,
0.3033429682254791,
-0.1340322345495224,
0.9059056639671326,
0.5710703134536743,
0.34521573781967163,
0.22307638823986053,
-0.15937314927577972,
0.8972207903862,
-0.6151750087738037,
-0.6768908500671387,
-0.4964124858379364,
0.3077909052371979,
-0.03919904679059982,
0.1682746708393097,
0.24322785437107086,
0.535097599029541,
0.36168861389160156,
-0.35235050320625305,
0.5485192537307739,
-0.10518233478069305,
0.9379816651344299,
-0.61846923828125,
0.7189019322395325,
-0.8166788816452026,
0.5084112286567688,
0.08702199906110764,
-0.7003867626190186,
-0.10519237071275711,
0.28059402108192444,
-0.38888970017433167,
-0.17282293736934662,
0.44617176055908203,
0.7756168842315674,
-0.1520548164844513,
-0.4310867488384247,
0.14588606357574463,
0.03488469123840332,
0.5224514603614807,
0.3008047938346863,
0.7948533296585083,
0.22420839965343475,
0.5563639402389526,
-0.5227803587913513,
-0.025964826345443726,
-0.45761165022850037,
-1.2595670223236084,
-0.48120778799057007,
-0.35591351985931396,
-0.5370293855667114,
-0.18013721704483032,
0.08419289439916611,
1.2446576356887817,
0.3685406744480133,
-0.6813542246818542,
-0.47607073187828064,
-0.06597457826137543,
-0.09914955496788025,
0.1476118564605713,
-0.3228651285171509,
0.15645846724510193,
-0.7057774662971497,
-0.8296822309494019,
0.42151305079460144,
-0.038017429411411285,
0.07365650683641434,
-0.1168256402015686,
0.0699860081076622,
-0.26846057176589966,
0.21558022499084473,
0.40960219502449036,
0.3659777045249939,
-0.5913015604019165,
-0.06636743247509003,
-0.024315902963280678,
-0.3040882349014282,
-0.2636009454727173,
0.7204932570457458,
-0.7449763417243958,
0.13844607770442963,
0.470838725566864,
0.8620152473449707,
0.527592658996582,
-0.01925288699567318,
0.6795124411582947,
-0.8998393416404724,
0.3722478449344635,
0.47688671946525574,
0.36199674010276794,
0.22344514727592468,
-0.4931703805923462,
0.6466506719589233,
0.21036061644554138,
-0.6771524548530579,
-1.173619270324707,
0.44121038913726807,
-0.8441038727760315,
-0.08903272449970245,
1.3686931133270264,
0.37314754724502563,
-0.20137947797775269,
-0.12962529063224792,
-0.059502605348825455,
0.46178123354911804,
0.016572602093219757,
0.8611792922019958,
0.14386086165905,
-0.07915288954973221,
0.3012741804122925,
-0.9440140724182129,
0.6684457659721375,
0.22833964228630066,
-0.8696921467781067,
0.11439543962478638,
0.4286438226699829,
0.17633414268493652,
0.20545168220996857,
0.4265725612640381,
0.004276133142411709,
0.06417504698038101,
-0.48112231492996216,
0.45663321018218994,
-0.33027273416519165,
0.13861031830310822,
0.1032719537615776,
-0.1376766711473465,
0.030945679172873497,
-0.07751236855983734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04793v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04793v1
|
Zero-shot LLM-guided Counterfactual Generation for Text
| 2024-05-08T03:57:45 | 2024-05-08T03:57:45 |
Amrita Bhattacharjee, Raha Moraffah, Joshua Garland, Huan Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Counterfactual examples are frequently used for model development and
evaluation in many natural language processing (NLP) tasks. Although methods
for automated counterfactual generation have been explored, such methods depend
on models such as pre-trained language models that are then fine-tuned on
auxiliary, often task-specific datasets. Collecting and annotating such
datasets for counterfactual generation is labor intensive and therefore,
infeasible in practice. Therefore, in this work, we focus on a novel problem
setting: \textit{zero-shot counterfactual generation}. To this end, we propose
a structured way to utilize large language models (LLMs) as general purpose
counterfactual example generators. We hypothesize that the
instruction-following and textual understanding capabilities of recent LLMs can
be effectively leveraged for generating high quality counterfactuals in a
zero-shot manner, without requiring any training or fine-tuning. Through
comprehensive experiments on various downstream tasks in natural language
processing (NLP), we demonstrate the efficacy of LLMs as zero-shot
counterfactual generators in evaluating and explaining black-box NLP models.
|
[
-0.17167484760284424,
-1.3197418451309204,
0.9337997436523438,
-0.000959776749368757,
-0.522316575050354,
-0.3824240565299988,
0.12750345468521118,
-0.19961634278297424,
0.003711435943841934,
0.713387131690979,
-0.8641806840896606,
-0.4756717085838318,
-0.35442623496055603,
0.1295194774866104,
-0.6660206317901611,
1.2933480739593506,
-0.09118273109197617,
-0.1399853229522705,
-0.2689003348350525,
-0.05538513883948326,
-0.6625891923904419,
-0.42831283807754517,
-0.38892656564712524,
-0.6189696788787842,
0.5384520888328552,
0.39526161551475525,
0.4665452539920807,
0.5226060152053833,
-0.03986511006951332,
0.2131989300251007,
0.4260815978050232,
0.041614633053541183,
-0.5176870822906494,
0.3296624720096588,
-0.3121463656425476,
-0.3554943799972534,
-0.24327966570854187,
0.21777582168579102,
0.4150564968585968,
0.4677232801914215,
-0.051863640546798706,
0.32100337743759155,
-0.31836840510368347,
0.11869501322507858,
-0.5602275133132935,
-0.12098866701126099,
-0.9493340253829956,
0.16778983175754547,
0.009347757324576378,
-0.4415983259677887,
-0.5301859378814697,
0.05212551727890968,
0.00428297882899642,
-0.47226935625076294,
0.4867337942123413,
-0.09689141064882278,
0.7465707063674927,
0.3332523703575134,
-0.4240407943725586,
-0.39893385767936707,
-0.7798874378204346,
0.8178212642669678,
-0.8592832088470459,
-0.06042316555976868,
0.09524156898260117,
-0.04355931282043457,
-0.22842881083488464,
-0.436949223279953,
-1.0094853639602661,
-0.19117595255374908,
-0.07411032170057297,
0.21285197138786316,
-0.48423323035240173,
-0.29365283250808716,
0.351761132478714,
-0.0017695189453661442,
-0.8537063002586365,
0.2594156861305237,
0.09083300828933716,
0.09773417562246323,
0.61628258228302,
0.2878029942512512,
0.19696266949176788,
-0.18656425178050995,
-0.3246707320213318,
0.14582957327365875,
-0.9606923460960388,
-0.43461501598358154,
0.24222838878631592,
0.2590774893760681,
0.0006039832951501012,
0.7862221002578735,
-0.32182106375694275,
0.9416195154190063,
0.16352523863315582,
0.237557515501976,
-0.05015074834227562,
-0.3279739320278168,
-0.5556343793869019,
0.09119965136051178,
0.7795446515083313,
0.3669023811817169,
0.5163187384605408,
-0.15076208114624023,
-0.14391687512397766,
0.4739009737968445,
0.5116633772850037,
-1.1890565156936646,
0.025577818974852562,
0.26372843980789185,
-0.026387762278318405,
-0.7642540335655212,
-0.6037909388542175,
-0.6440905332565308,
-0.1184215247631073,
-0.19538316130638123,
0.7546238899230957,
-0.14832453429698944,
0.03550099581480026,
0.08565782755613327,
0.04401147738099098,
0.2015850841999054,
0.03971826285123825,
-0.7218010425567627,
-0.030995214357972145,
0.4423823356628418,
0.7986865043640137,
0.08617941290140152,
-0.0966220423579216,
-0.8962994813919067,
0.38494569063186646,
-0.634183943271637,
0.8390305638313293,
-0.6159327626228333,
-0.44473913311958313,
0.11643560230731964,
-0.14914104342460632,
0.20111241936683655,
-0.20317760109901428,
0.2190781533718109,
-0.21072225272655487,
0.46867334842681885,
-0.00016744797176215798,
-0.6394093632698059,
-0.05087542161345482,
0.5388040542602539,
-0.23910216987133026,
0.9431893825531006,
-0.20070868730545044,
-0.5448883771896362,
0.4302438497543335,
-0.6295187473297119,
-0.40962132811546326,
0.30562615394592285,
-0.5358595252037048,
-0.6151324510574341,
0.35477784276008606,
0.1795681267976761,
0.6806589961051941,
-0.1475890427827835,
0.5627772212028503,
-0.21959134936332703,
-0.41935378313064575,
0.12763641774654388,
-0.6804108023643494,
0.5824894905090332,
-0.1912223994731903,
-0.558352530002594,
-0.017564263194799423,
-0.6850234866142273,
-0.26972246170043945,
0.4309478998184204,
-0.016715768724679947,
-0.42486095428466797,
-0.05504327267408371,
-0.22030122578144073,
0.3403075933456421,
0.1165832057595253,
-0.8095463514328003,
0.1746399700641632,
-0.4034392237663269,
0.05763832479715347,
0.47805020213127136,
0.3020002245903015,
0.15775631368160248,
-0.33589112758636475,
0.4620015621185303,
0.019478047266602516,
-0.09707289934158325,
-0.7693808674812317,
-0.41864046454429626,
-0.7478297352790833,
-0.13891932368278503,
-0.10679953545331955,
0.6228255033493042,
-1.0855668783187866,
0.30716007947921753,
0.14647406339645386,
-0.5036333203315735,
-0.17255008220672607,
0.14720778167247772,
0.6579077839851379,
1.1745418310165405,
0.45881029963493347,
0.00861759390681982,
-0.4575415849685669,
-0.8609582185745239,
-0.24885909259319305,
-0.06291575729846954,
-0.2004808634519577,
0.2741639316082001,
0.6226462721824646,
-0.21052730083465576,
1.0334783792495728,
-0.7786512970924377,
-0.04501724615693092,
-0.14789733290672302,
0.779757559299469,
0.2681782841682434,
0.3383257985115051,
0.6789156198501587,
-0.5062125325202942,
-0.3153946101665497,
-0.34570613503456116,
-0.9308496117591858,
-0.5044072270393372,
-0.5367071032524109,
-0.15952377021312714,
0.5616664290428162,
0.7761701941490173,
-0.8012062907218933,
0.586868941783905,
0.3997596800327301,
-0.45349857211112976,
0.8433692455291748,
-0.19597075879573822,
-0.13218200206756592,
-1.040085792541504,
0.15033075213432312,
0.16726164519786835,
-0.3573644757270813,
-1.0855618715286255,
0.18984700739383698,
-0.17735588550567627,
-0.09844481945037842,
-0.565962553024292,
0.7019911408424377,
-0.15644961595535278,
0.1852119117975235,
-0.39675650000572205,
0.30477315187454224,
0.015405895188450813,
0.5593881607055664,
0.37812167406082153,
0.3928850591182709,
0.32755500078201294,
-0.390923410654068,
0.19300274550914764,
-0.020574983209371567,
-0.10732895135879517,
0.8199386596679688,
-0.750437319278717,
0.12055319547653198,
-0.2868514955043793,
0.2287338376045227,
-0.9327074289321899,
0.09735254943370819,
0.159971222281456,
-0.25236234068870544,
0.25207990407943726,
-0.1642974466085434,
-0.4646022617816925,
-0.05692340433597565,
-0.4157329797744751,
0.20923176407814026,
0.4318452775478363,
-0.29574742913246155,
0.3813827931880951,
-0.1392793357372284,
-0.22721847891807556,
-0.6169279217720032,
-0.8321651816368103,
0.24474021792411804,
-0.10293155163526535,
0.023737573996186256,
0.06765060126781464,
-0.2981553077697754,
-0.16642186045646667,
-0.07124306261539459,
-0.07463464140892029,
0.17246223986148834,
0.03987985476851463,
0.38448989391326904,
0.5446433424949646,
-0.2447454184293747,
0.08908441662788391,
0.1082724928855896,
-0.06931433826684952,
0.04259860888123512,
-0.33303579688072205,
0.491643488407135,
0.28835177421569824,
-0.42826464772224426,
-0.016311516985297203,
0.5951076149940491,
0.15629802644252777,
0.06746403127908707,
0.6613713502883911,
0.6387467384338379,
-0.3391604721546173,
-0.4456830322742462,
-0.4601079523563385,
-0.09172584861516953,
-0.4384814500808716,
0.4517182409763336,
-0.06777903437614441,
-0.8117071390151978,
0.205036923289299,
0.11472855508327484,
0.478721559047699,
0.32382047176361084,
0.8314640522003174,
-0.16099561750888824,
0.7722887396812439,
0.5899399518966675,
0.34250056743621826,
0.4232472777366638,
-0.020209839567542076,
0.18279112875461578,
-0.19310276210308075,
0.0651998519897461,
-0.3648381233215332,
-0.05952994152903557,
-0.3742332458496094,
-0.43120649456977844,
0.08117137104272842,
-0.005463947542011738,
-0.40885117650032043,
0.27644771337509155,
-0.22954128682613373,
0.5972082018852234,
0.44764837622642517,
-0.06240413337945938,
0.3217238783836365,
0.12404828518629074,
-0.3314400315284729,
0.04193997383117676,
-0.6507216095924377,
-0.6162810325622559,
1.0585180521011353,
0.0012173210270702839,
0.3408258855342865,
-0.03910655155777931,
0.7871253490447998,
0.36853861808776855,
0.7025432586669922,
-0.7829222083091736,
0.6298564672470093,
-0.5878081321716309,
-0.5326324701309204,
-0.4206991493701935,
-0.3763151466846466,
-0.755761981010437,
0.09483112394809723,
-0.4716789424419403,
-0.5443822741508484,
0.037120770663022995,
0.35524868965148926,
-0.4100872576236725,
0.10557995736598969,
-0.6477941274642944,
0.879158079624176,
-0.05519845709204674,
-0.37772807478904724,
-0.11511492729187012,
-0.19816426932811737,
0.5031201839447021,
-0.38503092527389526,
0.05496629327535629,
0.10787470638751984,
0.05506405234336853,
0.28799688816070557,
-0.21382805705070496,
1.0382860898971558,
-0.30374911427497864,
-0.3306664526462555,
0.1773100197315216,
0.560980498790741,
0.4416515529155731,
-0.002048719907179475,
-0.12218736857175827,
0.3122844398021698,
-0.3010052442550659,
-0.2804708182811737,
-0.5285223722457886,
0.7302401661872864,
-0.380126416683197,
-0.659077525138855,
-0.2506396770477295,
-0.7724568247795105,
-0.24398495256900787,
0.3080196976661682,
0.1789788454771042,
0.6751774549484253,
-0.43855321407318115,
0.0319509282708168,
0.6256508827209473,
-0.5206713676452637,
0.8053900599479675,
1.1194230318069458,
-0.23008495569229126,
0.008507076650857925,
0.9233516454696655,
0.20532317459583282,
0.22150039672851562,
0.5016036629676819,
0.11772420257329941,
-0.2666817009449005,
-0.6074451804161072,
-0.7473348379135132,
0.04980650544166565,
-0.23639510571956635,
-0.3701351583003998,
-0.5036842226982117,
-0.13695208728313446,
-0.17434784770011902,
-0.4984588623046875,
-0.10155362635850906,
-0.3174293041229248,
-0.5088707208633423,
-0.1569415181875229,
0.19829635322093964,
0.8223304152488708,
0.09266255050897598,
0.5228423476219177,
-0.5966132283210754,
0.7962602972984314,
0.6150233149528503,
0.26921147108078003,
-0.04365096241235733,
-0.43822962045669556,
-0.23362606763839722,
0.023099763318896294,
-0.3094325661659241,
-0.9240745902061462,
0.597844660282135,
0.03430824726819992,
0.2929520010948181,
0.2578239440917969,
0.16028495132923126,
0.6270983219146729,
-0.870703399181366,
0.8223994374275208,
0.24094828963279724,
-0.9349510073661804,
0.583585262298584,
-0.554315984249115,
0.679847240447998,
0.252902090549469,
0.38236334919929504,
-0.5213475823402405,
-0.6391814351081848,
-0.46157366037368774,
-0.8230464458465576,
0.6053500175476074,
0.1581781953573227,
0.2810502052307129,
-0.181108757853508,
0.4872666001319885,
0.19534291326999664,
0.2879660129547119,
-0.902987539768219,
-0.09031222015619278,
-0.5333752632141113,
-0.35077551007270813,
-0.38672876358032227,
-0.3701099753379822,
-0.19031789898872375,
0.31719696521759033,
0.6284433603286743,
-0.2820585072040558,
-0.11128243058919907,
0.26792311668395996,
-0.40592721104621887,
-0.35205915570259094,
0.39466220140457153,
0.9307360649108887,
0.3637116849422455,
-0.28501829504966736,
0.12131701409816742,
0.20968811213970184,
-0.24893547594547272,
0.12839213013648987,
0.09972409904003143,
-0.7569741606712341,
0.16314955055713654,
0.47512638568878174,
0.6510539650917053,
0.09270074218511581,
-0.6547781229019165,
0.44100266695022583,
0.0901465117931366,
-0.48402586579322815,
-0.23583391308784485,
0.035022590309381485,
0.1390991508960724,
0.20488816499710083,
0.5204039216041565,
-0.37179818749427795,
-0.1043383926153183,
-0.6498525738716125,
0.3861682713031769,
0.6792464256286621,
-0.21571561694145203,
-0.21231520175933838,
0.520455002784729,
0.13809551298618317,
-0.44159069657325745,
0.4260960519313812,
-0.2832324802875519,
-0.2161349654197693,
0.4209889769554138,
0.7797563076019287,
1.0233964920043945,
-0.04413330927491188,
0.5404365658760071,
0.2100844532251358,
0.29646235704421997,
0.16265900433063507,
0.14685438573360443,
-0.12860402464866638,
-0.7801470160484314,
-0.7382594347000122,
-0.6882914304733276,
-0.506420373916626,
0.4618794918060303,
-0.3708820044994354,
0.23978327214717865,
-0.40012210607528687,
0.09597700834274292,
0.12880508601665497,
-0.07932137697935104,
-0.5602403879165649,
0.33142372965812683,
0.28031474351882935,
0.5924946069717407,
-1.091615080833435,
0.7912311553955078,
0.4444776177406311,
-0.3851495683193207,
-0.20897100865840912,
0.09261738508939743,
-0.008579724468290806,
-0.8620309829711914,
0.5872160196304321,
0.12944692373275757,
-0.35006263852119446,
-0.31919077038764954,
-0.8225080966949463,
-0.18832539021968842,
0.8826615214347839,
0.5939965844154358,
-0.9150096774101257,
-0.015927860513329506,
0.4333876371383667,
0.8015523552894592,
-0.5686995387077332,
0.32494959235191345,
0.34485501050949097,
0.282177209854126,
0.10877498984336853,
-0.5528687238693237,
0.2893286645412445,
-0.17370210587978363,
-0.17732518911361694,
-0.027504684403538704,
-0.38010159134864807,
0.7935983538627625,
-0.004557863809168339,
-0.04104093462228775,
-0.10281148552894592,
0.3093780279159546,
0.4448108971118927,
0.5235422849655151,
0.5506085157394409,
0.6840283274650574,
0.023642320185899734,
0.210963174700737,
0.8382083177566528,
-0.02322174236178398,
0.09054195135831833,
1.5660922527313232,
-0.41217243671417236,
0.8434553742408752,
0.4205367863178253,
0.3972095847129822,
0.6051570773124695,
0.0785120502114296,
-0.26007142663002014,
0.177216574549675,
0.10589882731437683,
-0.23369671404361725,
-0.5434194803237915,
-0.35891446471214294,
0.11096081137657166,
0.6436776518821716,
0.26289913058280945,
-0.313789427280426,
-0.5436506867408752,
-0.32024121284484863,
0.3043327331542969,
0.1708890199661255,
-0.3122403919696808,
0.7771990299224854,
-0.02949807234108448,
-0.5057170391082764,
0.5129004716873169,
-0.059256602078676224,
0.8054368495941162,
-0.534824788570404,
-0.4506656527519226,
-0.288965106010437,
-0.1284574419260025,
-0.05011845752596855,
-0.7212408185005188,
0.4273415207862854,
0.5843197703361511,
-0.1874718964099884,
-0.47169697284698486,
0.5793474316596985,
-0.5788055658340454,
-0.7733885645866394,
0.12068735808134079,
0.5329164862632751,
0.13314548134803772,
-0.08808635175228119,
-0.4295075833797455,
-0.3267579674720764,
0.007711570709943771,
-0.3617517650127411,
0.28693515062332153,
0.47372308373451233,
-0.03838610276579857,
0.36246219277381897,
0.6671186089515686,
0.16447581350803375,
-0.15315456688404083,
0.21084150671958923,
0.5570152997970581,
-0.847705602645874,
-0.22730876505374908,
-1.1040204763412476,
0.39781680703163147,
0.00355402659624815,
-0.23846063017845154,
0.6917102932929993,
0.295730322599411,
0.8002437353134155,
-0.00777518330141902,
0.711713433265686,
0.23217450082302094,
0.4420483410358429,
-0.35153916478157043,
0.6662347316741943,
-0.5697963833808899,
0.0835527777671814,
-0.2991027534008026,
-0.6276058554649353,
-0.5119615793228149,
0.3980083763599396,
-0.1841728836297989,
-0.17752455174922943,
0.3274356722831726,
0.8393668532371521,
0.06883494555950165,
-0.2880702614784241,
0.6409435868263245,
0.5342383980751038,
0.4607197344303131,
0.4674954116344452,
0.4751787781715393,
-0.20229898393154144,
0.7386341094970703,
-0.040406033396720886,
0.06976667046546936,
-0.0845990926027298,
-1.3442968130111694,
-1.072245717048645,
-0.2133801132440567,
-0.37719032168388367,
0.19931335747241974,
0.05876016244292259,
0.6114144921302795,
0.5279309153556824,
-0.8096820712089539,
-0.08314558863639832,
-0.18522801995277405,
0.0896100103855133,
0.1361798644065857,
-0.24297213554382324,
-0.03831372782588005,
-0.2302851676940918,
-0.6650081276893616,
0.6072286367416382,
0.4060942530632019,
0.2060251086950302,
-0.45786723494529724,
0.17401516437530518,
-0.5372852683067322,
0.6831234693527222,
0.8570559620857239,
0.25040629506111145,
-0.5001528859138489,
-0.45863470435142517,
-0.1830338090658188,
0.1929498314857483,
-0.36488258838653564,
0.7991102933883667,
-1.045383095741272,
0.3988583981990814,
0.2250124216079712,
0.3303743600845337,
0.7133815288543701,
-0.04052095487713814,
0.7546316981315613,
-1.104489803314209,
0.15686780214309692,
0.05656694248318672,
0.17453885078430176,
0.23960326611995697,
-0.29189589619636536,
0.3100191056728363,
0.1125890463590622,
-0.27412259578704834,
-1.0990281105041504,
0.4140990972518921,
-0.7066439390182495,
-0.6086248755455017,
0.9709477424621582,
-0.20704209804534912,
0.2158271074295044,
-0.17863799631595612,
0.09653961658477783,
0.45815014839172363,
-0.3035240173339844,
0.7985809445381165,
0.5534408688545227,
-0.24040576815605164,
-0.2074582576751709,
-0.5769162774085999,
0.15496449172496796,
0.5610118508338928,
-0.7896012663841248,
0.10873688012361526,
0.6930524706840515,
0.22199657559394836,
0.17821602523326874,
0.46895352005958557,
0.13838867843151093,
0.09515152871608734,
0.21003739535808563,
0.07713248580694199,
-0.3514760136604309,
-0.2530560791492462,
-0.4552520215511322,
0.2286510467529297,
-0.3596978783607483,
-0.08307800441980362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06696v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06696v1
|
Multi-level Shared Knowledge Guided Learning for Knowledge Graph Completion
| 2024-05-08T03:27:46 | 2024-05-08T03:27:46 |
Yongxue Shan, Jie Zhou, Jie Peng, Xin Zhou, Jiaqian Yin, Xiaodong Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the task of Knowledge Graph Completion (KGC), the existing datasets and
their inherent subtasks carry a wealth of shared knowledge that can be utilized
to enhance the representation of knowledge triplets and overall performance.
However, no current studies specifically address the shared knowledge within
KGC. To bridge this gap, we introduce a multi-level Shared Knowledge Guided
learning method (SKG) that operates at both the dataset and task levels. On the
dataset level, SKG-KGC broadens the original dataset by identifying shared
features within entity sets via text summarization. On the task level, for the
three typical KGC subtasks - head entity prediction, relation prediction, and
tail entity prediction - we present an innovative multi-task learning
architecture with dynamically adjusted loss weights. This approach allows the
model to focus on more challenging and underperforming tasks, effectively
mitigating the imbalance of knowledge sharing among subtasks. Experimental
results demonstrate that SKG-KGC outperforms existing text-based methods
significantly on three well-known datasets, with the most notable improvement
on WN18RR.
|
[
-0.4001217782497406,
-0.4523793160915375,
0.5419993996620178,
-0.129177063703537,
-0.26880303025245667,
0.5317264795303345,
0.02475944720208645,
-0.3527001738548279,
0.16908180713653564,
0.2975006103515625,
-0.8379305601119995,
-1.0417766571044922,
-0.9387102127075195,
0.06965195387601852,
0.11911562085151672,
1.0914831161499023,
-0.29483988881111145,
-0.03335511311888695,
-0.6167861223220825,
-0.26722994446754456,
-0.7978595495223999,
-0.15963079035282135,
-0.7055374979972839,
-0.7876613736152649,
0.9148858189582825,
0.5034929513931274,
0.12124035507440567,
0.47763797640800476,
0.1664329618215561,
0.12286587804555893,
-0.08188182860612869,
0.6285635828971863,
-0.6664496064186096,
0.12609314918518066,
0.11940904706716537,
-0.3261851668357849,
-0.5279472470283508,
-0.12493512779474258,
0.38079074025154114,
1.0787813663482666,
-0.2506665885448456,
0.06108561530709267,
0.5131435990333557,
0.8634589314460754,
-0.6264087557792664,
0.858629584312439,
-0.35779136419296265,
0.301682710647583,
-0.12612712383270264,
-0.08143823593854904,
-0.42667025327682495,
-0.10006295144557953,
0.39653173089027405,
-1.1982157230377197,
0.05499941110610962,
-0.15262004733085632,
0.3923287093639374,
0.4000667333602905,
-1.1081358194351196,
-0.44397178292274475,
-0.22202810645103455,
0.6904757022857666,
-0.3340032696723938,
0.5444507598876953,
0.21816931664943695,
0.05041766166687012,
-0.09976579248905182,
-0.592084527015686,
-0.2878148555755615,
0.033797238022089005,
-0.3131871521472931,
0.3811628222465515,
0.186712846159935,
0.3054247200489044,
0.33659806847572327,
0.15362030267715454,
-0.35100188851356506,
-0.3840996026992798,
-0.39256903529167175,
-0.2802237570285797,
0.3531140387058258,
0.0566251277923584,
0.041892338544130325,
-0.33952486515045166,
-0.39489856362342834,
-0.02926649898290634,
-0.5231798887252808,
0.06544128060340881,
0.21123121678829193,
0.36852169036865234,
0.2939436435699463,
0.41068416833877563,
-0.5922698974609375,
0.6693758368492126,
-0.03597354143857956,
-0.3741718530654907,
0.6143560409545898,
-0.38570842146873474,
0.05675578862428665,
0.19752122461795807,
0.3794976472854614,
0.4146699011325836,
0.2077103555202484,
-0.35930997133255005,
0.04537827521562576,
-0.2056356966495514,
0.41241058707237244,
-0.41848331689834595,
-0.4007357656955719,
-0.18318575620651245,
-0.470559686422348,
-0.2133004516363144,
-0.110246442258358,
-0.49331027269363403,
-0.5304804444313049,
-0.47585490345954895,
0.4952746033668518,
-0.5346882939338684,
-0.25966304540634155,
-0.044398222118616104,
-0.2166261076927185,
-0.24849198758602142,
0.5485175848007202,
-0.5219889879226685,
0.29695263504981995,
0.5621381998062134,
0.8363551497459412,
-0.2560291290283203,
-0.45357394218444824,
-0.306602418422699,
0.7276395559310913,
-0.24885685741901398,
0.5191378593444824,
-0.35799893736839294,
-0.39149269461631775,
-0.3226757347583771,
-0.1116390973329544,
-0.23795822262763977,
-0.3707810640335083,
0.2157115787267685,
-0.5747300982475281,
0.030159709975123405,
-0.6981546878814697,
-0.7174241542816162,
-0.7160905003547668,
0.4219696521759033,
-0.6295391917228699,
1.32931387424469,
0.2620464265346527,
-1.06751549243927,
0.9251108169555664,
-0.6375820636749268,
-0.7740134596824646,
0.12591257691383362,
-0.18759730458259583,
-0.29214900732040405,
-0.2567964196205139,
0.4430776536464691,
0.8283565044403076,
0.12126301974058151,
0.23595227301120758,
-0.38231366872787476,
-0.10065389424562454,
-0.7800090909004211,
0.23702292144298553,
0.4356043040752411,
-0.016042614355683327,
-0.08002889156341553,
0.1547902673482895,
-0.7399216294288635,
0.12111451476812363,
-0.03392835706472397,
-0.4159714877605438,
-0.6734311580657959,
-0.1546114683151245,
-0.666144847869873,
0.2195715457201004,
0.31624457240104675,
-0.4358120560646057,
0.5346259474754333,
0.03702564164996147,
0.1740679144859314,
0.6355893611907959,
0.23570282757282257,
0.4028698801994324,
-0.21763873100280762,
0.44159090518951416,
0.1547524333000183,
0.0751630961894989,
0.1537475734949112,
-0.6220278739929199,
-0.3169253170490265,
-0.25797468423843384,
0.2750883400440216,
0.5591933727264404,
-1.0646437406539917,
0.13519111275672913,
-0.3605280816555023,
-0.6292633414268494,
-0.18810898065567017,
0.21927562355995178,
0.4496050477027893,
0.7446997165679932,
0.4962211847305298,
-0.2855335772037506,
-0.4266500473022461,
-0.6528224349021912,
-0.22694379091262817,
0.06976672261953354,
0.043008677661418915,
0.8451808094978333,
0.3484760820865631,
-0.14472870528697968,
0.607362687587738,
-0.9613789916038513,
-0.6429830193519592,
-0.5103474855422974,
0.5877468585968018,
0.03843747451901436,
0.32725417613983154,
0.38240447640419006,
-0.7646533250808716,
-0.7623146176338196,
0.17451557517051697,
-0.7347245812416077,
0.13227878510951996,
0.18435053527355194,
-0.1844775229692459,
-0.15973487496376038,
0.39994585514068604,
-0.5220731496810913,
0.27458831667900085,
0.4039696753025055,
-0.04517589882016182,
0.2849792540073395,
-0.29846030473709106,
0.45020392537117004,
-1.277220606803894,
-0.2489413470029831,
-0.17058256268501282,
-0.31262558698654175,
-0.5198280811309814,
-0.34674927592277527,
0.24341917037963867,
0.014340292662382126,
0.0267762653529644,
0.29616889357566833,
-0.32697010040283203,
-0.03968548774719238,
-0.10807477682828903,
0.12791430950164795,
-0.0368138812482357,
0.8633171319961548,
-0.20769426226615906,
0.4536738693714142,
0.6815145015716553,
-0.7347562313079834,
0.4529954195022583,
0.39493528008461,
-0.21855176985263824,
0.5822190046310425,
-0.3021503686904907,
0.006161552853882313,
-0.3555568754673004,
0.530942976474762,
-0.7866498231887817,
-0.39013388752937317,
0.2591155469417572,
-0.4345480799674988,
0.35258617997169495,
-0.3639214336872101,
-0.4002889394760132,
-0.3519042432308197,
0.029602287337183952,
0.47085732221603394,
0.15172064304351807,
-0.5072940587997437,
1.097822904586792,
0.35703572630882263,
-0.07021516561508179,
-1.0032241344451904,
-0.48638808727264404,
-0.16640439629554749,
0.014552542939782143,
-0.5893826484680176,
0.5153481364250183,
0.21670174598693848,
0.41831767559051514,
0.19424515962600708,
-0.6575155258178711,
0.017452655360102654,
-0.05434856936335564,
0.4373684823513031,
-0.04990629106760025,
0.11313465982675552,
0.3096157908439636,
0.3435792624950409,
-0.13683204352855682,
-0.21850982308387756,
-0.6152943968772888,
0.5106695294380188,
0.28118276596069336,
-0.28223174810409546,
-0.20417435467243195,
0.25616082549095154,
0.3460228145122528,
-0.25000742077827454,
0.9699499011039734,
0.6834378838539124,
-0.603387713432312,
-0.26340651512145996,
-0.32446926832199097,
-0.06731025129556656,
-0.3989936113357544,
0.4907427132129669,
-0.4425012767314911,
-0.9851894974708557,
0.6348824501037598,
-0.4815494418144226,
0.023631781339645386,
0.503420889377594,
0.0738530382514,
-0.17977285385131836,
0.9830284118652344,
0.7033026814460754,
0.08959401398897171,
0.37770941853523254,
-0.4658944308757782,
0.24643006920814514,
-0.7423366904258728,
-0.8024148344993591,
-0.08536306023597717,
-0.4356968402862549,
-0.28881213068962097,
-0.18119484186172485,
0.5813025832176208,
0.4501055181026459,
0.008623900823295116,
0.41080033779144287,
-0.3948664665222168,
0.4223211109638214,
0.778239905834198,
0.4765487313270569,
0.3742621839046478,
-0.29322558641433716,
-0.5436798334121704,
0.2397947609424591,
-0.9331718683242798,
0.04814746230840683,
1.170709252357483,
-0.07190031558275223,
0.49787747859954834,
-0.3568572700023651,
0.958634078502655,
0.48705658316612244,
0.16013175249099731,
-0.5918422937393188,
0.5884000062942505,
-0.33001160621643066,
-0.2770274579524994,
-0.3790358603000641,
-0.8948731422424316,
-0.5533322691917419,
0.10180790722370148,
-0.18790780007839203,
-0.5618299245834351,
-0.1024097353219986,
0.40516507625579834,
-0.2539566457271576,
0.33356958627700806,
-0.7818606495857239,
1.0280909538269043,
0.14079318940639496,
0.1837807446718216,
-0.5370762348175049,
-0.6144750118255615,
0.28013876080513,
-0.04196813702583313,
0.09171682596206665,
-0.05733002722263336,
0.09435541927814484,
1.0129477977752686,
-0.17550328373908997,
0.7079111337661743,
-0.5670437216758728,
0.0248735174536705,
0.11800124496221542,
-0.1321842074394226,
0.7793208360671997,
0.07618669420480728,
0.20665773749351501,
0.057843681424856186,
-0.10240241885185242,
-0.4712171256542206,
-0.7439504861831665,
0.7211332321166992,
-0.6015775799751282,
-0.24641484022140503,
-0.19899067282676697,
-0.907049834728241,
-0.4944062829017639,
0.5227037668228149,
-0.00043546236702241004,
0.4780538082122803,
0.2733338177204132,
0.3226773142814636,
0.7691227793693542,
-0.11371766030788422,
0.026467634364962578,
0.122862309217453,
0.1663719266653061,
-0.7264639735221863,
0.9277338981628418,
0.39708858728408813,
0.28066059947013855,
0.497588574886322,
0.09134022146463394,
-0.26976823806762695,
-0.6419833898544312,
-0.21373692154884338,
0.026937536895275116,
-0.8998093008995056,
-0.3147227168083191,
-1.1096317768096924,
-0.11196059733629227,
-0.580260694026947,
-0.06326624006032944,
-0.19752302765846252,
-0.20408156514167786,
-0.03366768732666969,
-0.332492858171463,
0.35947397351264954,
1.0514512062072754,
0.006535283289849758,
0.3730592131614685,
-0.8443311452865601,
0.46329909563064575,
0.4143785834312439,
0.48763203620910645,
0.38711464405059814,
0.23174694180488586,
-0.4514104127883911,
0.03556602820754051,
-0.2316834181547165,
-0.8226896524429321,
-0.009674301370978355,
0.08159744739532471,
0.7273354530334473,
0.1227567121386528,
0.1993168443441391,
0.8131271600723267,
-0.40061330795288086,
0.5159003138542175,
0.29030168056488037,
-0.8007292151451111,
0.38840579986572266,
-0.44231754541397095,
0.317078173160553,
0.5300534963607788,
0.7450559735298157,
-0.7255005836486816,
-0.33174535632133484,
-0.48342153429985046,
-0.9485247731208801,
0.8354290723800659,
-0.04180050268769264,
-0.3894314765930176,
0.32501354813575745,
0.48505789041519165,
0.31819382309913635,
0.5517647862434387,
-0.6801773905754089,
-0.34235140681266785,
-0.30124709010124207,
-0.5474439859390259,
0.17727914452552795,
-0.048252154141664505,
-0.17604877054691315,
-0.16388168931007385,
0.8225437998771667,
-0.3950396776199341,
0.01588224619626999,
0.04857766628265381,
-0.17338624596595764,
0.09886733442544937,
0.04916634038090706,
0.18047261238098145,
0.7168607115745544,
-0.09797666221857071,
0.04769780859351158,
0.49819278717041016,
-0.5316706895828247,
-0.1896858662366867,
0.1794726848602295,
-0.17250269651412964,
-0.3472153842449188,
0.4618380665779114,
0.771701991558075,
0.2709767818450928,
-0.2435094714164734,
0.39858153462409973,
0.0889769122004509,
-0.5186002254486084,
0.2388773113489151,
0.06818157434463501,
0.198591411113739,
0.4046536684036255,
0.564957320690155,
0.24774082005023956,
-0.0343419648706913,
-0.174076646566391,
0.32279452681541443,
0.35020023584365845,
-0.40915584564208984,
0.16321876645088196,
0.3790706992149353,
0.1315995305776596,
0.33734360337257385,
0.4866671860218048,
-0.35553818941116333,
-0.7544545531272888,
0.4650426208972931,
0.016978098079562187,
0.40483608841896057,
0.01840118132531643,
0.30971845984458923,
0.4172978699207306,
0.17919641733169556,
-0.19023194909095764,
0.41515693068504333,
-0.3785017430782318,
-0.4962497353553772,
-0.6883439421653748,
-0.4025759994983673,
-0.09385862201452255,
-0.061405666172504425,
-0.667824387550354,
0.025904817506670952,
-0.16779637336730957,
0.015404082834720612,
-0.11630017310380936,
0.4467380940914154,
-0.6120507121086121,
0.24994686245918274,
-0.22556181252002716,
0.6328598856925964,
-0.7642412781715393,
0.8427339196205139,
0.5986457467079163,
-0.2969176769256592,
-0.97016841173172,
0.06994311511516571,
-0.05103104189038277,
-0.6726451516151428,
0.6050621867179871,
0.15214000642299652,
0.001910251216031611,
0.18069234490394592,
-0.14230339229106903,
-0.9342629909515381,
1.550670862197876,
0.1459534466266632,
-0.25214138627052307,
-0.44235163927078247,
0.2011331170797348,
0.18029023706912994,
-0.3184848427772522,
-0.14830531179904938,
0.05228535085916519,
0.4763711094856262,
0.4679677486419678,
-0.9683164358139038,
-0.026242639869451523,
0.20089222490787506,
-0.3021021783351898,
0.4995819330215454,
-0.6108046174049377,
0.5984813570976257,
-0.2589670717716217,
-0.08506187796592712,
-0.43570446968078613,
0.7663748860359192,
0.19479182362556458,
0.5185880064964294,
0.7968136072158813,
0.8156953454017639,
1.048007845878601,
-0.1736864298582077,
0.6530749201774597,
-0.23531074821949005,
0.4634200632572174,
1.0494303703308105,
-0.13313516974449158,
0.2502710819244385,
0.13297219574451447,
0.1128087118268013,
0.3343379497528076,
0.7242783308029175,
0.14514735341072083,
0.816162645816803,
0.056183118373155594,
-0.2384640872478485,
-0.40141037106513977,
-0.29832911491394043,
-0.23820760846138,
0.08535170555114746,
0.2669103443622589,
-0.07115975022315979,
-0.34381115436553955,
0.4224827289581299,
-0.08960852771997452,
-0.3322221636772156,
-0.7057170867919922,
0.975115954875946,
-0.10036346316337585,
-0.5928029417991638,
0.04410005360841751,
-0.287069171667099,
0.6312829256057739,
-0.8084679841995239,
-0.19382700324058533,
0.07102495431900024,
0.1422995924949646,
-0.3539727032184601,
-0.8407353162765503,
0.17975759506225586,
-0.458683043718338,
-0.3837924599647522,
-0.5099577903747559,
0.960330069065094,
-0.7468832731246948,
-0.20418503880500793,
0.5595363974571228,
0.5047377347946167,
-0.3249642252922058,
-0.13937433063983917,
-0.4889049828052521,
-0.5076648592948914,
0.11216738820075989,
-0.08466003835201263,
0.20487692952156067,
0.6095410585403442,
0.07122716307640076,
0.8630584478378296,
0.3616275191307068,
-0.05117268115282059,
0.30095145106315613,
0.14461715519428253,
0.8906894326210022,
-0.31633883714675903,
-0.4384051263332367,
-0.25698965787887573,
0.2993384897708893,
-0.16454093158245087,
-0.05692818760871887,
0.6785249710083008,
0.5872353911399841,
1.376341700553894,
-0.033554285764694214,
0.8484355807304382,
-0.2921490967273712,
0.705249547958374,
-0.4459809958934784,
0.747418224811554,
-0.7678318619728088,
-0.10124727338552475,
-0.41491156816482544,
-0.6183247566223145,
-0.14566728472709656,
0.246560737490654,
-0.1878926306962967,
0.31167614459991455,
0.7922893166542053,
0.38917309045791626,
-0.15194103121757507,
0.03999791666865349,
0.1870255023241043,
-0.05792948231101036,
0.22761619091033936,
0.6550570726394653,
0.5146428942680359,
-0.24120044708251953,
0.944654643535614,
-0.5435510873794556,
-0.22055579721927643,
0.24705453217029572,
-0.8218698501586914,
-1.017608404159546,
-0.7989791035652161,
-0.4256899654865265,
-0.1668815165758133,
0.2909281849861145,
0.7152109146118164,
0.8192760944366455,
-0.6183586716651917,
0.22627002000808716,
-0.16297253966331482,
0.302784264087677,
-0.5725964307785034,
-0.19105570018291473,
0.5188877582550049,
-0.1450614482164383,
-0.4236469268798828,
0.2588610351085663,
0.11360455304384232,
-0.19466537237167358,
0.12626555562019348,
-0.19423291087150574,
-0.3202522099018097,
-0.49135199189186096,
0.46389275789260864,
-0.15570098161697388,
-0.47959187626838684,
-0.24851065874099731,
0.033797282725572586,
0.08935932070016861,
-0.10591384023427963,
1.0351183414459229,
-0.8213371634483337,
0.18375976383686066,
0.6466590762138367,
0.7198163270950317,
0.6098993420600891,
-0.1188153401017189,
0.5544438362121582,
-1.2222384214401245,
-0.3649207353591919,
0.10904601216316223,
0.29284611344337463,
0.03147958219051361,
-0.5377683639526367,
0.46183061599731445,
0.5555561184883118,
-0.36486881971359253,
-0.47488483786582947,
0.1397363394498825,
-1.065908670425415,
-0.23319245874881744,
0.8229806423187256,
-0.3482936918735504,
0.06857898831367493,
-0.15667608380317688,
-0.14795562624931335,
0.8733275532722473,
-0.48334845900535583,
0.7088497877120972,
0.9570791721343994,
-0.26975980401039124,
-0.07942403107881546,
-0.5581187009811401,
0.5812580585479736,
0.14698176085948944,
-0.7417657375335693,
0.18566380441188812,
0.362325519323349,
0.272331565618515,
0.13822804391384125,
0.40205463767051697,
0.2307683527469635,
-0.03294888511300087,
-0.21286065876483917,
0.07139921188354492,
-0.40077659487724304,
-0.7612553834915161,
0.31230825185775757,
0.4179970920085907,
-0.32958748936653137,
-0.1528395712375641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06695v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06695v1
|
Utilizing Large Language Models to Generate Synthetic Data to Increase the Performance of BERT-Based Neural Networks
| 2024-05-08T03:18:12 | 2024-05-08T03:18:12 |
Chancellor R. Woolsey, Prakash Bisht, Joshua Rothman, Gondy Leroy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
An important issue impacting healthcare is a lack of available experts.
Machine learning (ML) models could resolve this by aiding in diagnosing
patients. However, creating datasets large enough to train these models is
expensive. We evaluated large language models (LLMs) for data creation. Using
Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD), we prompted ChatGPT and GPT-Premium to
generate 4,200 synthetic observations to augment existing medical data. Our
goal is to label behaviors corresponding to autism criteria and improve model
accuracy with synthetic training data. We used a BERT classifier pre-trained on
biomedical literature to assess differences in performance between models. A
random sample (N=140) from the LLM-generated data was evaluated by a clinician
and found to contain 83% correct example-label pairs. Augmenting data increased
recall by 13% but decreased precision by 16%, correlating with higher quality
and lower accuracy across pairs. Future work will analyze how different
synthetic data traits affect ML outcomes.
|
[
-0.25804588198661804,
-0.6108397841453552,
0.31624114513397217,
0.1682988554239273,
0.19871513545513153,
0.2275913804769516,
-0.327583372592926,
-0.8723021149635315,
0.2932060956954956,
0.4642435908317566,
-0.337320476770401,
-0.3205937147140503,
-0.611484169960022,
0.19292959570884705,
-0.38832420110702515,
1.0098685026168823,
0.24123626947402954,
0.3982052206993103,
-0.13710226118564606,
0.09798530489206314,
-0.09494125097990036,
-0.7185906767845154,
-1.225961685180664,
-0.5025884509086609,
0.7289655804634094,
0.222242072224617,
0.8215299248695374,
0.5117075443267822,
0.38912245631217957,
0.357235312461853,
-0.12265373021364212,
0.4822256565093994,
-0.32105159759521484,
0.12244246900081635,
-0.01992129161953926,
-0.1244550496339798,
-0.763738214969635,
-0.12048106640577316,
0.5701308250427246,
1.0160123109817505,
0.1695520430803299,
-0.1312333047389984,
-0.06467287987470627,
0.662815511226654,
0.007143923547118902,
0.394523561000824,
-0.3622797429561615,
0.24669155478477478,
-0.005034100729972124,
0.10048314929008484,
-0.31618690490722656,
-0.2762369215488434,
0.41054567694664,
-0.566324770450592,
0.45843270421028137,
-0.028570247814059258,
0.7064064145088196,
0.07421910017728806,
-0.3705631494522095,
-0.2817683219909668,
-0.7149580121040344,
0.5097070932388306,
-0.9737645387649536,
0.3644219934940338,
0.4533064663410187,
0.22249573469161987,
-0.46228769421577454,
-0.7556869983673096,
-0.5418818593025208,
-0.5493163466453552,
-0.013926643878221512,
-0.015611512586474419,
-0.11976403743028641,
0.22047728300094604,
0.5017542243003845,
0.06526938825845718,
-0.608732283115387,
0.4062969982624054,
-0.6303930282592773,
-0.26471900939941406,
1.014311671257019,
0.16559067368507385,
0.4028552174568176,
0.019402991980314255,
0.21280917525291443,
-0.09707125276327133,
-0.659347653388977,
-0.04953629523515701,
0.28158578276634216,
0.4596334397792816,
0.29187288880348206,
0.5873003602027893,
-0.03351878374814987,
0.47664883732795715,
0.19211940467357635,
0.05865410715341568,
0.5588456392288208,
-0.14709541201591492,
-0.12710973620414734,
0.2246943563222885,
0.5511338710784912,
0.17561732232570648,
0.4244258999824524,
-0.23572824895381927,
-0.2525632977485657,
-0.02953302673995495,
0.5736560821533203,
-0.7273696660995483,
-0.46166038513183594,
0.27153006196022034,
-0.37713393568992615,
-0.2507631778717041,
-0.2949974834918976,
-0.3769414722919464,
-0.5120732188224792,
-0.6314629912376404,
0.3104589581489563,
-0.8254438042640686,
-0.2033749222755432,
0.023252535611391068,
-0.055373240262269974,
-0.07155705988407135,
0.20311488211154938,
-0.9558237791061401,
0.29003939032554626,
0.6663892865180969,
0.539454460144043,
-0.07812553644180298,
-0.03363252803683281,
-0.4031358063220978,
0.12820616364479065,
-0.555454432964325,
0.5726732015609741,
-0.3733726739883423,
-0.349465012550354,
-0.1560215801000595,
0.056751128286123276,
-0.06551153212785721,
-0.706321656703949,
0.46462297439575195,
-0.3095848858356476,
-0.14869515597820282,
-0.2575523853302002,
-0.7635565400123596,
-0.012960439547896385,
0.017794383689761162,
-0.6970183849334717,
0.8438611030578613,
0.3716915249824524,
-0.3123895525932312,
0.5293968915939331,
-0.8572622537612915,
-0.848743200302124,
0.3078595995903015,
-0.16922305524349213,
-0.6021056175231934,
0.1039230078458786,
0.4886641204357147,
0.4923797845840454,
0.008953440934419632,
0.4945955276489258,
-0.18229517340660095,
-0.2514178156852722,
0.6030696630477905,
-0.2223735749721527,
0.6380018591880798,
0.13535578548908234,
-0.04939737915992737,
0.06855011731386185,
-0.7883153557777405,
0.04951581358909607,
-0.13150149583816528,
-0.5756909847259521,
-0.1663917601108551,
0.13755522668361664,
0.17100559175014496,
0.10032574087381363,
-0.03636889532208443,
-0.6910089254379272,
0.0342976376414299,
-0.7560111284255981,
0.5172294974327087,
0.7582579255104065,
-0.06917652487754822,
0.032842837274074554,
-0.6460285186767578,
0.39715468883514404,
0.08689162135124207,
0.07625553756952286,
0.029997816309332848,
-0.7858410477638245,
-0.6376703977584839,
-0.418974906206131,
0.6770145893096924,
0.141047865152359,
-0.692319929599762,
0.6760179400444031,
-0.29784271121025085,
-0.2590979039669037,
-0.796196699142456,
-0.06755758821964264,
0.22056575119495392,
0.6810087561607361,
0.3805328905582428,
-0.3897556662559509,
-0.6829429268836975,
-1.0688362121582031,
-0.014484547078609467,
0.06945051997900009,
-0.2701681852340698,
0.5601698756217957,
0.3875032067298889,
-0.6234463453292847,
0.8034818768501282,
-0.09077336639165878,
-0.12849710881710052,
-0.2636074125766754,
0.22165869176387787,
0.0629519373178482,
0.6780834794044495,
0.584670901298523,
-0.4765588939189911,
-0.44423556327819824,
0.13999326527118683,
-0.5787429213523865,
-0.04409118741750717,
-0.049988217651844025,
0.1628447324037552,
0.5696007013320923,
0.22795778512954712,
-0.517698347568512,
0.2723100483417511,
0.46580082178115845,
-0.11849132180213928,
0.454353392124176,
-0.4877106249332428,
0.032243818044662476,
-0.8531995415687561,
0.20835161209106445,
0.10128118097782135,
-0.21923001110553741,
-0.6696166396141052,
-0.2280043065547943,
-0.10668281465768814,
-0.34611210227012634,
-0.14492270350456238,
0.37561699748039246,
-0.15933863818645477,
-0.13535809516906738,
0.007050893269479275,
-0.30938154458999634,
-0.11011876165866852,
0.15341342985630035,
0.044665150344371796,
0.6957597136497498,
0.48769426345825195,
-0.42742297053337097,
0.36543938517570496,
0.26783648133277893,
-0.5235702991485596,
0.19303297996520996,
-0.7561439871788025,
0.03302304819226265,
-0.07023628801107407,
0.4577689468860626,
-0.9535519480705261,
-0.5992014408111572,
0.05565911903977394,
-0.6630667448043823,
0.521613359451294,
0.1467743068933487,
-0.6620039343833923,
-0.6963896155357361,
-0.05285877361893654,
0.22699615359306335,
0.6918397545814514,
-0.4927290081977844,
0.48578765988349915,
0.46732065081596375,
-0.29975956678390503,
-0.3474977910518646,
-0.8560516238212585,
0.192695751786232,
0.08240322768688202,
-0.7858631610870361,
0.2830883860588074,
0.1345347911119461,
0.1506258249282837,
0.06225327402353287,
-0.04642052575945854,
-0.019854867830872536,
0.03266739845275879,
0.08011093735694885,
0.13616891205310822,
-0.36696967482566833,
0.6288998126983643,
0.20406264066696167,
-0.08322000503540039,
0.2910877764225006,
-0.12730202078819275,
0.4172249138355255,
0.19643054902553558,
-0.30951398611068726,
-0.2588830292224884,
0.4791528880596161,
0.4558272659778595,
-0.11320745199918747,
0.793082058429718,
0.5036424994468689,
-0.47133663296699524,
-0.4016094505786896,
-0.32459756731987,
-0.4482453167438507,
-0.4803970754146576,
0.5125552415847778,
-0.07310792803764343,
-0.6625064611434937,
0.43441295623779297,
-0.042638666927814484,
-0.021720414981245995,
0.3156373202800751,
0.6139434576034546,
-0.43041637539863586,
1.3704158067703247,
0.1365342140197754,
0.09085556119680405,
0.2743884027004242,
-0.23831380903720856,
0.42615216970443726,
-0.7629833221435547,
-0.13600848615169525,
-0.1538640558719635,
-0.5193997621536255,
-0.6440483331680298,
-0.369667649269104,
0.7926220297813416,
-0.5716220140457153,
-0.4427475929260254,
-0.10030117630958557,
-0.583220899105072,
0.2315817028284073,
0.6400386691093445,
0.6396212577819824,
0.028100155293941498,
0.05630229786038399,
0.06979301571846008,
0.03718084841966629,
-0.8521454930305481,
-0.3372112214565277,
1.7200655937194824,
0.41644999384880066,
0.4017786383628845,
-0.08223693072795868,
0.5132563710212708,
0.4439879357814789,
0.5999701023101807,
-0.7472172975540161,
0.4690389633178711,
-0.5352221727371216,
-0.5990408658981323,
-0.22488678991794586,
-0.5577214360237122,
-1.2579892873764038,
-0.15383639931678772,
-0.41168278455734253,
-0.4435286223888397,
0.136018767952919,
0.2971740961074829,
-0.5742453932762146,
-0.02667427621781826,
-0.7671859264373779,
0.5627772212028503,
-0.4144367277622223,
-0.006229523569345474,
-0.21577419340610504,
-0.5436796545982361,
0.4607613682746887,
-0.6155098676681519,
-0.014408117160201073,
0.011998092755675316,
0.24211636185646057,
0.7332238554954529,
-0.5718809962272644,
0.903750479221344,
-0.04985757917165756,
-0.03150614723563194,
-0.07159992307424545,
-0.39317435026168823,
0.26829731464385986,
-0.1368846595287323,
-0.38700172305107117,
0.17270924150943756,
-0.12658584117889404,
-0.3760458827018738,
-0.4594016969203949,
0.7109625935554504,
-0.9628996849060059,
-0.4010829031467438,
-0.44514262676239014,
-0.8307974338531494,
-0.7196592688560486,
-0.15876810252666473,
0.006040139589458704,
0.4666142761707306,
-0.06458829343318939,
0.29050111770629883,
0.6455585360527039,
-0.6019120812416077,
0.0849175825715065,
0.5266256928443909,
-0.0285114124417305,
-0.2987254559993744,
0.8769890069961548,
0.4135957956314087,
0.2166384905576706,
-0.20393265783786774,
0.16778142750263214,
-0.2190214842557907,
-0.5381628274917603,
-0.3083617091178894,
0.26668423414230347,
-0.3126069903373718,
-0.12820403277873993,
-0.6719105243682861,
-0.7447681427001953,
-0.6467514634132385,
-0.0811990424990654,
-0.18925584852695465,
-0.5434123277664185,
-0.16700509190559387,
-0.060268353670835495,
0.569463849067688,
0.46880489587783813,
-0.3119904100894928,
0.40398555994033813,
-0.737675130367279,
0.4125696122646332,
0.1282527893781662,
0.329998642206192,
0.1298605501651764,
-0.4210044741630554,
-0.3695378303527832,
0.4119468927383423,
-0.3301031291484833,
-0.5757899880409241,
0.6293781995773315,
0.3918023705482483,
0.5717434287071228,
0.2666333317756653,
-0.038728248327970505,
0.48326560854911804,
-0.5177277326583862,
0.6548150181770325,
0.08448005467653275,
-0.6959669589996338,
0.4664735794067383,
-0.44481781125068665,
0.0039116013795137405,
0.02084955759346485,
0.39944425225257874,
-0.33128654956817627,
-0.42380401492118835,
-0.7381395697593689,
-0.9574329853057861,
0.7750725150108337,
0.25067952275276184,
0.15907572209835052,
-0.06121547147631645,
0.3443201780319214,
-0.030938612297177315,
0.009060797281563282,
-0.3083002269268036,
-0.2073584794998169,
0.16978822648525238,
-0.4262075126171112,
-0.20412281155586243,
-0.043998315930366516,
-0.2517581284046173,
-0.7166423797607422,
0.7345798015594482,
-0.10282044112682343,
0.446637362241745,
0.13671329617500305,
0.3016427159309387,
-0.19673971831798553,
-0.07836876809597015,
0.3793017268180847,
0.44768330454826355,
-0.0797947496175766,
-0.3420299291610718,
0.025257866829633713,
-0.3991931080818176,
-0.09273044019937515,
0.3751428425312042,
-0.03311307355761528,
0.03481310233473778,
0.4360550343990326,
0.6436441540718079,
-0.10239238291978836,
-1.097208023071289,
0.20889912545681,
0.16548587381839752,
-0.34492072463035583,
-0.29225608706474304,
0.31686723232269287,
0.33530810475349426,
0.23969846963882446,
0.19653072953224182,
0.197356179356575,
0.12185481935739517,
-0.5393388271331787,
0.4747084975242615,
0.42931389808654785,
0.1534462720155716,
-0.20349565148353577,
0.3900875449180603,
0.3118273913860321,
-0.40611618757247925,
0.9555821418762207,
0.1652442365884781,
-0.34908920526504517,
1.0083484649658203,
0.6457407474517822,
0.41870540380477905,
-0.39926618337631226,
0.27196112275123596,
0.25867778062820435,
0.07514211535453796,
-0.02383221685886383,
0.3447250723838806,
0.24303598701953888,
-0.8315155506134033,
-0.6215370297431946,
-0.5138537883758545,
-0.4511759877204895,
0.4296010732650757,
-0.4874841272830963,
0.11756132543087006,
-0.49706971645355225,
-0.40110719203948975,
0.49333372712135315,
-0.06695210933685303,
-0.6475390195846558,
0.47811880707740784,
0.13347837328910828,
0.5233616232872009,
-0.7587260603904724,
0.9913412928581238,
0.6763108968734741,
-0.3039088845252991,
-0.9385519623756409,
-0.19832822680473328,
-0.23908206820487976,
-0.8854087591171265,
0.7762593626976013,
0.04683303460478783,
0.3558254539966583,
-0.12204921245574951,
-0.488031268119812,
-0.7152851223945618,
0.632693886756897,
0.38311630487442017,
-0.7126461267471313,
-0.06814797222614288,
0.444842129945755,
1.1573041677474976,
-0.37589508295059204,
0.035586412996053696,
0.7289085388183594,
0.4533761143684387,
0.21555085480213165,
-1.0355262756347656,
-0.09318295121192932,
-0.2884565591812134,
-0.10604613274335861,
0.05590515211224556,
-0.11001154035329819,
0.9042792320251465,
-0.303986132144928,
0.0443962886929512,
0.03038775734603405,
0.16794392466545105,
0.28910768032073975,
0.34129631519317627,
0.18740923702716827,
0.4799647629261017,
1.0772688388824463,
-0.02270381897687912,
1.0355592966079712,
-0.3100303113460541,
0.031912676990032196,
0.9236012697219849,
-0.3097779452800751,
0.607304036617279,
0.18316352367401123,
-0.17057137191295624,
0.12444853037595749,
0.776286780834198,
-0.144957035779953,
0.18833477795124054,
0.5352802276611328,
-0.38455405831336975,
-0.2339402288198471,
-0.03310670703649521,
-0.5493563413619995,
0.31749027967453003,
0.7855751514434814,
-0.864136278629303,
0.04234934225678444,
0.2355232983827591,
-0.06992735713720322,
-0.10416591167449951,
-0.26641881465911865,
0.7790777683258057,
0.0030113442335277796,
-0.426725834608078,
0.687890887260437,
-0.05427742749452591,
0.2722146809101105,
-0.46788743138313293,
0.03187154233455658,
-0.1546061486005783,
0.35220253467559814,
-0.18617679178714752,
-0.6339742541313171,
0.4488973617553711,
0.013356322422623634,
-0.1581522524356842,
-0.12314285337924957,
0.47403857111930847,
-0.42088112235069275,
-1.044045329093933,
-0.00852343998849392,
0.48831045627593994,
0.34137576818466187,
0.18533733487129211,
-0.6335904002189636,
-0.20478133857250214,
-0.09944390505552292,
-0.12765911221504211,
0.4244708716869354,
0.44734349846839905,
-0.18555502593517303,
0.6723747849464417,
0.884918749332428,
0.5284545421600342,
-0.09478698670864105,
0.00478164991363883,
1.0012301206588745,
-0.33077600598335266,
-0.24466343224048615,
-0.5835847854614258,
0.2159581482410431,
-0.15914303064346313,
-0.12982995808124542,
0.3383304476737976,
0.477165549993515,
0.5027816295623779,
-0.17077744007110596,
0.9816405773162842,
0.04405767098069191,
0.8692248463630676,
-0.2834130823612213,
0.9969350695610046,
-0.5050173401832581,
0.23679150640964508,
-0.007414484396576881,
-0.4271516501903534,
-0.42552968859672546,
0.6936424374580383,
-0.37352046370506287,
0.15196366608142853,
0.3588862121105194,
0.8487411737442017,
-0.12223228812217712,
0.13124972581863403,
0.24750842154026031,
0.5006770491600037,
0.6991139650344849,
0.6924154758453369,
0.5838084816932678,
-0.21958549320697784,
-0.02503654547035694,
-0.055743955075740814,
-0.1770848035812378,
-0.14415423572063446,
-0.6137651205062866,
-0.9041560292243958,
-0.42803263664245605,
-0.31198927760124207,
-0.3873421847820282,
0.37567368149757385,
1.1104141473770142,
0.9064667224884033,
-0.9779477119445801,
0.10000541061162949,
-0.05309176445007324,
-0.24870868027210236,
-0.296831876039505,
-0.18705670535564423,
0.579397976398468,
-0.6116923689842224,
-0.7094390988349915,
0.5052343606948853,
-0.20444293320178986,
0.09639223664999008,
-0.1100730374455452,
-0.00911144819110632,
0.0876849964261055,
0.2791673541069031,
0.6986697316169739,
0.20988008379936218,
-0.6420996189117432,
-0.4219108819961548,
-0.22204148769378662,
-0.08613895624876022,
0.12429135292768478,
0.5288112759590149,
-0.921326756477356,
0.4385659992694855,
0.1344752162694931,
1.0227442979812622,
0.3092682659626007,
0.09196817129850388,
0.9357905387878418,
-0.7053834199905396,
-0.23506751656532288,
0.6289233565330505,
0.20835813879966736,
0.341452956199646,
-0.4844149351119995,
0.4707408845424652,
0.07041533291339874,
-0.6651530861854553,
-0.8439728617668152,
-0.10153402388095856,
-0.902258038520813,
-0.28773537278175354,
1.1614785194396973,
-0.10551819950342178,
-0.014628509990870953,
-0.23403029143810272,
-0.36229079961776733,
0.21844497323036194,
-0.5921595692634583,
1.0666790008544922,
0.5089556574821472,
-0.6421316862106323,
0.1438194066286087,
-0.5168616771697998,
0.6967921853065491,
0.49504896998405457,
-0.7991939783096313,
-0.15024961531162262,
0.6478040218353271,
0.3380734622478485,
-0.08201538026332855,
0.40453919768333435,
0.06436116248369217,
0.33109527826309204,
-0.19840364158153534,
0.023196926340460777,
-0.1916353404521942,
-0.13254481554031372,
-0.15865293145179749,
-0.04624687507748604,
-0.24228648841381073,
-0.13458821177482605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04781v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04781v1
|
CourseGPT-zh: an Educational Large Language Model Based on Knowledge Distillation Incorporating Prompt Optimization
| 2024-05-08T03:11:12 | 2024-05-08T03:11:12 |
Zheyan Qu, Lu Yin, Zitong Yu, Wenbo Wang, Xing zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated astonishing capabilities in
natural language processing (NLP) tasks, sparking interest in their application
to professional domains with higher specialized requirements. However,
restricted access to closed-source LLMs via APIs and the difficulty in
collecting massive high-quality datasets pose obstacles to the development of
large language models in education fields of various courses. Given these
challenges, we propose CourseGPT-zh, a course-oriented education LLM that
supports customization and low-cost deployment. To address the
comprehensiveness and diversity requirements of course-specific corpora, we
design a high-quality question-answering corpus distillation framework
incorporating prompt optimization, which effectively mines textbook knowledge
and enhances its diversity. Moreover, considering the alignment of LLM
responses with user needs, a novel method for discrete prompt optimization
based on LLM-as-Judge is introduced. During optimization, this framework
leverages the LLM's ability to reflect on and exploit error feedback and
patterns, allowing for prompts that meet user needs and preferences while
saving response length. Lastly, we obtain CourseGPT-zh based on the open-source
LLM using parameter-efficient fine-tuning. Experimental results show that our
discrete prompt optimization framework effectively improves the response
quality of ChatGPT, and CourseGPT-zh exhibits strong professional capabilities
in specialized knowledge question-answering, significantly outperforming
comparable open-source models.
|
[
-0.5211777687072754,
-1.0484932661056519,
0.6958543062210083,
-0.02179676480591297,
-0.29035666584968567,
0.2073487490415573,
-0.5751963257789612,
0.017418544739484787,
-0.1046539917588234,
0.2569364011287689,
-0.7015398144721985,
-0.7148693203926086,
-0.3978464603424072,
0.1126391664147377,
-0.0797586664557457,
1.0318083763122559,
0.22777749598026276,
0.06282204389572144,
-0.16948941349983215,
0.23411259055137634,
-0.5500461459159851,
-0.5260806083679199,
-0.7524692416191101,
-0.14898844063282013,
0.7052295804023743,
0.502918541431427,
0.5873254537582397,
0.6114853620529175,
0.30297765135765076,
0.1816873401403427,
-0.16840589046478271,
-0.03655436635017395,
-0.3135286271572113,
0.15172818303108215,
-0.2908281981945038,
-0.26284757256507874,
-0.30962762236595154,
-0.2365683615207672,
0.5097917914390564,
0.7811325788497925,
-0.4744132161140442,
0.1844535619020462,
0.22982800006866455,
0.6539658308029175,
-0.6500664353370667,
0.14088459312915802,
-0.42065486311912537,
-0.0791444256901741,
-0.011141600087285042,
-0.08430291712284088,
-0.279923677444458,
-0.6571879386901855,
0.48566555976867676,
-0.48834025859832764,
0.14591814577579498,
-0.010792339220643044,
0.3176461160182953,
0.31758397817611694,
-0.11785271018743515,
-0.5218124985694885,
-0.5542526245117188,
0.6787896752357483,
-0.851235568523407,
0.17770187556743622,
0.14570343494415283,
0.6486152410507202,
-0.1182909607887268,
-0.6814026236534119,
-0.476223349571228,
-0.170693501830101,
0.17050080001354218,
0.16227364540100098,
0.04443522170186043,
0.410256952047348,
0.19588693976402283,
0.480124294757843,
-0.6924532651901245,
0.22500550746917725,
-0.23733872175216675,
-0.0896809995174408,
0.2741999328136444,
0.2307569533586502,
0.4117316007614136,
-0.05454503372311592,
-0.3107936978340149,
0.07991264760494232,
-0.44899794459342957,
0.07796604931354523,
0.42963194847106934,
0.5020619034767151,
0.20939020812511444,
0.4483237862586975,
-0.350015789270401,
0.8539517521858215,
-0.13253521919250488,
-0.14503484964370728,
-0.1156814768910408,
0.05449678748846054,
-0.1862809807062149,
0.18409381806850433,
0.7062479853630066,
0.08987986296415329,
0.15239392220973969,
0.07137531787157059,
-0.22147540748119354,
-0.025508694350719452,
-0.04096580296754837,
-1.0176177024841309,
-0.28278398513793945,
0.33556002378463745,
-0.0801144689321518,
-0.2038591355085373,
-0.42342302203178406,
-0.9394141435623169,
-0.2525186240673065,
-0.5274206399917603,
0.34154292941093445,
-0.4544594883918762,
-0.07012802362442017,
0.4420434236526489,
-0.0050613414496183395,
-0.1257878541946411,
0.4856448471546173,
-1.1904925107955933,
0.10914987325668335,
0.611626148223877,
0.7984697222709656,
-0.21804198622703552,
-0.04169238731265068,
-0.6888489127159119,
-0.20744457840919495,
-0.054794538766145706,
0.41985413432121277,
-0.7281315922737122,
-0.367816299200058,
0.18822269141674042,
-0.32436564564704895,
0.04644531011581421,
-0.4025112986564636,
0.801403820514679,
-0.8592898845672607,
0.43733498454093933,
-0.2699680030345917,
-0.6718650460243225,
-0.2375175952911377,
0.4524376392364502,
-0.3729782700538635,
0.8592252135276794,
0.3679107427597046,
-0.6849008202552795,
0.08018820732831955,
-0.6611121892929077,
-0.2052922546863556,
0.46078693866729736,
-0.17199477553367615,
-0.08868447691202164,
-0.16503824293613434,
0.24773404002189636,
0.2352285087108612,
-0.6262528300285339,
0.7235261797904968,
-0.10052778571844101,
-0.4075477123260498,
-0.1786404401063919,
-0.48075544834136963,
0.958607017993927,
0.17902518808841705,
-0.3376975655555725,
0.23053106665611267,
-0.9201621413230896,
0.008229067549109459,
-0.06904912739992142,
-0.766828179359436,
-0.5039209127426147,
0.0478225015103817,
-0.1869356334209442,
0.30284157395362854,
0.5169498920440674,
-0.3151763081550598,
0.32331016659736633,
-0.29884132742881775,
0.5162649154663086,
0.8262905478477478,
-0.02162991464138031,
0.4115076959133148,
-0.05701819434762001,
0.6801106333732605,
-0.2358744740486145,
0.3752747178077698,
-0.0893968939781189,
-0.5226431488990784,
-0.5671728849411011,
-0.31928810477256775,
0.07121080160140991,
0.5856741070747375,
-0.7291862964630127,
0.46140700578689575,
-0.11475057899951935,
-0.43347638845443726,
-0.440530002117157,
0.15057983994483948,
0.24207833409309387,
0.8422022461891174,
0.4316786527633667,
-0.003603721735998988,
-0.17414577305316925,
-0.6646418571472168,
-0.04306618869304657,
-0.19779440760612488,
-0.1680147349834442,
0.20943178236484528,
0.18564383685588837,
-0.25117138028144836,
1.0098674297332764,
-0.7959645986557007,
-0.0220954492688179,
-0.27728840708732605,
-0.12216696888208389,
0.4942404627799988,
0.15919241309165955,
0.5306649804115295,
-0.6274385452270508,
-0.5955055356025696,
-0.12161584943532944,
-0.48533254861831665,
-0.35528984665870667,
0.2156522274017334,
-0.3727012574672699,
-0.037318598479032516,
0.05970213562250137,
-0.5905182957649231,
-0.04858080670237541,
0.3740919530391693,
-0.22374872863292694,
0.7939978241920471,
-0.2637452185153961,
0.029132956638932228,
-0.9926450848579407,
-0.09245868027210236,
-0.11721061915159225,
0.08723849803209305,
-0.40766599774360657,
0.1791633665561676,
-0.0043855090625584126,
-0.2847983241081238,
-0.3103586733341217,
0.5466424822807312,
-0.20197495818138123,
0.15734614431858063,
-0.40154051780700684,
0.5350748896598816,
0.019192704930901527,
0.7922111749649048,
0.08470256626605988,
0.660574197769165,
0.5971241593360901,
-0.729739785194397,
0.639713704586029,
0.46128687262535095,
-0.4235283434391022,
0.6055877208709717,
-0.6235848069190979,
0.08672399818897247,
-0.15096968412399292,
-0.06503947824239731,
-0.7325251698493958,
-0.2534075677394867,
0.21948669850826263,
-0.14181140065193176,
0.10807068645954132,
-0.3071438670158386,
-0.3933778405189514,
-0.3971533179283142,
-0.22925108671188354,
0.019803643226623535,
0.8261524438858032,
-0.7315466403961182,
0.4096837639808655,
-0.14725998044013977,
-0.4337775409221649,
-0.8506149053573608,
-0.20823384821414948,
-0.11961016803979874,
-0.28266283869743347,
-0.5934187769889832,
-0.01256952341645956,
-0.4806264340877533,
-0.23392419517040253,
-0.18394728004932404,
-0.1442560851573944,
-0.046737782657146454,
0.19923198223114014,
-0.15519656240940094,
0.5237327814102173,
-0.4408350884914398,
0.31397590041160583,
0.39255085587501526,
0.1621580570936203,
0.1699909269809723,
-0.6894567608833313,
0.6860054135322571,
0.07651406526565552,
-0.37327316403388977,
-0.23764659464359283,
0.23136945068836212,
0.4206783175468445,
-0.17778253555297852,
0.5376577973365784,
0.41500747203826904,
-0.1287899911403656,
-0.588996946811676,
-0.4812403619289398,
-0.39670953154563904,
-0.5445094704627991,
0.47788625955581665,
-0.16764435172080994,
-1.174434781074524,
0.21430502831935883,
-0.14610624313354492,
0.3096603751182556,
0.10945647954940796,
0.5540837645530701,
0.18568174540996552,
0.576818585395813,
0.446885347366333,
-0.18307937681674957,
0.5886857509613037,
0.1595536172389984,
0.21636302769184113,
-0.5555298328399658,
-0.03586707264184952,
-0.5275754928588867,
-0.13087323307991028,
-0.36456555128097534,
-0.2541933059692383,
0.29249367117881775,
0.20910793542861938,
-0.6149773597717285,
0.03307867795228958,
-0.5176191329956055,
0.40672558546066284,
0.8958538770675659,
0.04876382276415825,
0.4940531253814697,
0.011428696103394032,
-0.05467138811945915,
0.0512704998254776,
-0.7532417178153992,
-0.5979388952255249,
0.9246660470962524,
0.2245335876941681,
0.6550801992416382,
0.15836437046527863,
0.6825599074363708,
0.11147095263004303,
0.07504680007696152,
-0.8364839553833008,
0.6404510140419006,
-0.25055643916130066,
-0.5650023221969604,
-0.5676076412200928,
-0.5442573428153992,
-0.39305630326271057,
0.2422938346862793,
0.06198802590370178,
-0.4413028061389923,
-0.050216153264045715,
0.12315455079078674,
-0.50750333070755,
0.3341827094554901,
-0.5977624654769897,
0.9227997660636902,
-0.19199123978614807,
-0.35811328887939453,
0.021980183199048042,
-0.756110668182373,
0.3501361608505249,
-0.34444162249565125,
0.24946902692317963,
-0.30430978536605835,
0.04596951603889465,
0.4699583947658539,
-0.4611245393753052,
0.8361154198646545,
-0.4221968650817871,
-0.37194114923477173,
0.5895840525627136,
0.052389685064554214,
0.5144774317741394,
0.27055665850639343,
-0.2045053243637085,
-0.1981448531150818,
-0.1559830605983734,
-0.19819436967372894,
-0.8027583956718445,
0.6845734119415283,
-0.728073000907898,
-0.9412615299224854,
-0.059888508170843124,
-0.3291780948638916,
-0.3067103326320648,
0.2519948482513428,
0.2626616656780243,
0.4757407307624817,
-0.19553986191749573,
-0.10907591134309769,
0.9583176970481873,
-0.5292676687240601,
0.5141831636428833,
0.6678500771522522,
-0.16737984120845795,
-0.29523929953575134,
0.8983645439147949,
-0.17147612571716309,
0.4615412950515747,
0.5327121019363403,
0.5883665680885315,
-0.3274139165878296,
-0.6980488896369934,
-0.6329332590103149,
-0.06075237691402435,
-0.8648980855941772,
-0.09101314842700958,
-0.6217582821846008,
-0.24817973375320435,
-0.34884655475616455,
-0.13800150156021118,
-0.14289627969264984,
-0.3335544168949127,
-0.5162251591682434,
-0.03656851127743721,
0.4228222966194153,
0.21445195376873016,
0.09512583911418915,
0.5715928673744202,
-0.9022982120513916,
0.10449854284524918,
0.6586822867393494,
0.3211556673049927,
-0.0184989795088768,
-0.7303076386451721,
-0.06388405710458755,
0.05323489010334015,
-0.21307489275932312,
-0.5199434161186218,
0.3513162434101105,
0.3788459002971649,
0.40041711926460266,
0.4412758946418762,
0.4153940677642822,
0.15144731104373932,
-0.6203708052635193,
0.7917659282684326,
0.17989115417003632,
-0.7832428812980652,
0.7290186285972595,
-0.5988031029701233,
0.23546725511550903,
0.5315667390823364,
0.5219936370849609,
-0.621406078338623,
-0.34668365120887756,
-0.1439843326807022,
-0.9487691521644592,
0.6841847896575928,
-0.06752320379018784,
0.3754512071609497,
-0.1375139206647873,
0.5040581822395325,
0.2968136966228485,
0.3381246328353882,
-0.4730910062789917,
-0.288722962141037,
-0.10996101796627045,
-0.37967953085899353,
-0.07870960235595703,
-0.47212618589401245,
-0.043647490441799164,
-0.04554101079702377,
0.8655857443809509,
-0.13837596774101257,
-0.22780387103557587,
-0.05405963212251663,
0.027480488643050194,
0.2441374659538269,
0.7429835796356201,
0.47209686040878296,
0.5577391386032104,
-0.3327895700931549,
-0.03701562434434891,
-0.031716447323560715,
-0.7779565453529358,
0.2230609953403473,
0.11557726562023163,
-0.2185559868812561,
0.09602712094783783,
0.0397162139415741,
0.7255037426948547,
0.17791767418384552,
-0.8172413110733032,
0.49081161618232727,
0.03057531639933586,
-0.08214345574378967,
-0.2586199939250946,
0.43895629048347473,
0.1166098341345787,
0.4629918038845062,
0.42143672704696655,
-0.32212939858436584,
0.31849101185798645,
-0.21618108451366425,
-0.013344092294573784,
0.04665829613804817,
-0.15856187045574188,
-0.14840799570083618,
0.8623431921005249,
0.30068060755729675,
-0.2786029279232025,
0.8541863560676575,
-0.14487747848033905,
-0.29981598258018494,
0.45510831475257874,
0.40222033858299255,
0.8432317972183228,
-0.37182098627090454,
0.4541667401790619,
0.6446809768676758,
0.02748773992061615,
-0.3704913854598999,
0.20413395762443542,
-0.08629747480154037,
-0.5509858727455139,
-0.4260677099227905,
-0.9631831645965576,
-0.5426473021507263,
-0.0022625336423516273,
-0.5494183301925659,
0.5644146203994751,
-0.6085924506187439,
-0.18489763140678406,
-0.21054233610630035,
-0.10249491035938263,
-0.32755860686302185,
0.314754456281662,
-0.03512109816074371,
0.8968178629875183,
-0.4700625538825989,
0.8040214776992798,
0.4742070138454437,
-0.3673575222492218,
-0.7437514662742615,
-0.2619442045688629,
-0.18988990783691406,
-0.6032223105430603,
0.6757426857948303,
-0.08902771770954132,
0.03058849833905697,
0.34565258026123047,
-0.46490973234176636,
-0.5326265692710876,
0.9735866785049438,
0.6664112210273743,
-1.1708060503005981,
-0.4510763883590698,
0.14050985872745514,
0.4434058666229248,
-0.05754227563738823,
0.002354528522118926,
0.5585616230964661,
0.25482913851737976,
0.2114216685295105,
-0.586478054523468,
-0.08064986020326614,
0.014302918687462807,
0.038889408111572266,
0.1066855788230896,
-0.5783195495605469,
0.8127690553665161,
-0.14686396718025208,
-0.13577979803085327,
-0.2212039977312088,
0.5066332221031189,
0.4301358163356781,
0.21375031769275665,
0.1958865374326706,
0.3136310875415802,
0.8612916469573975,
-0.08859346061944962,
0.6540493965148926,
-0.28204888105392456,
0.3530445694923401,
1.3478845357894897,
-0.12970101833343506,
0.6387794017791748,
0.3523530662059784,
-0.2512231469154358,
0.4212166965007782,
0.8560131788253784,
-0.0127125084400177,
0.6621355414390564,
0.45860275626182556,
-0.7493605613708496,
-0.2197888195514679,
0.15744821727275848,
-0.33405306935310364,
0.14864428341388702,
0.23236490786075592,
-0.2884252369403839,
-0.28951093554496765,
0.10893478989601135,
-0.12801489233970642,
0.15660837292671204,
-0.4137994945049286,
0.5979588031768799,
0.09262552857398987,
-0.5546968579292297,
0.5008721351623535,
0.006182053592056036,
0.8419482111930847,
-0.6323004961013794,
0.2221565842628479,
-0.4533594250679016,
-0.14974236488342285,
-0.08866456896066666,
-0.4881809949874878,
0.032778315246105194,
0.031137946993112564,
-0.22700151801109314,
0.024174954742193222,
0.4144633114337921,
-0.5753024816513062,
-0.29405051469802856,
0.2307935208082199,
0.48824557662010193,
0.15865913033485413,
-0.16716566681861877,
-0.3381653428077698,
-0.1021452322602272,
-0.11055098474025726,
-0.3404235541820526,
0.3337688148021698,
0.6606582999229431,
-0.007824883796274662,
0.6444777846336365,
0.4685121178627014,
0.05591372773051262,
0.0872410461306572,
0.3654167354106903,
0.8777828812599182,
-0.3918164074420929,
-0.5790843963623047,
-1.0240682363510132,
0.37463992834091187,
0.10518139600753784,
-0.16874350607395172,
0.4030570983886719,
0.5836080312728882,
0.7491394877433777,
-0.2975168228149414,
1.04820716381073,
0.0064263492822647095,
0.4470096528530121,
-0.4964892268180847,
0.7190375924110413,
-0.3566740155220032,
0.41311168670654297,
-0.25977736711502075,
-1.193630337715149,
-0.06834182888269424,
0.3721984922885895,
-0.35612380504608154,
0.025118714198470116,
0.5003430247306824,
0.40056777000427246,
0.07729104161262512,
0.11010117828845978,
0.44873932003974915,
-0.18333587050437927,
0.35391145944595337,
0.7701658010482788,
0.9196843504905701,
0.008466082625091076,
0.5236606001853943,
-0.19220316410064697,
-0.35534292459487915,
-0.266223281621933,
-0.7172282338142395,
-1.1900593042373657,
-0.6263058185577393,
-0.5183046460151672,
-0.08212408423423767,
0.16582486033439636,
1.1561521291732788,
0.24873077869415283,
-0.5331631302833557,
-0.05711203068494797,
-0.1846124231815338,
0.09845224767923355,
0.0768025815486908,
-0.2452453225851059,
0.5313504338264465,
-0.657265305519104,
-0.8985575437545776,
0.27023541927337646,
0.21866920590400696,
0.07844169437885284,
-0.27347204089164734,
0.07050018012523651,
0.10802000015974045,
-0.010466723702847958,
0.7516403794288635,
0.04846033826470375,
-0.476627379655838,
-0.18705877661705017,
0.1917285919189453,
-0.2095593512058258,
0.0533546544611454,
0.6978836059570312,
-0.361304372549057,
0.37674710154533386,
0.4362780451774597,
0.901370644569397,
0.15707243978977203,
-0.1595069169998169,
0.4998133182525635,
-0.6285394430160522,
0.01504392921924591,
0.4562489092350006,
0.14556042850017548,
0.28040045499801636,
-0.5791934728622437,
0.39877426624298096,
0.15242278575897217,
-0.48048579692840576,
-0.5578641891479492,
0.24592003226280212,
-0.9136509299278259,
-0.38705170154571533,
1.1970667839050293,
-0.33173519372940063,
-0.11900974810123444,
-0.11972635239362717,
-0.3881340026855469,
0.3478005528450012,
-0.4894208014011383,
0.9874588847160339,
0.8755424618721008,
0.12968353927135468,
-0.20108109712600708,
-0.8092945218086243,
0.620608925819397,
0.024003518745303154,
-0.8500651121139526,
0.12138165533542633,
0.7049456834793091,
0.49273228645324707,
-0.13363495469093323,
0.5495281219482422,
-0.0017768144607543945,
0.18901373445987701,
-0.257240355014801,
0.1702558547258377,
-0.22611753642559052,
-0.12836046516895294,
-0.2197299748659134,
0.3996888995170593,
0.2523580491542816,
-0.1518181711435318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04777v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04777v1
|
Empathy Through Multimodality in Conversational Interfaces
| 2024-05-08T02:48:29 | 2024-05-08T02:48:29 |
Mahyar Abbasian, Iman Azimi, Mohammad Feli, Amir M. Rahmani, Ramesh Jain
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Agents represent one of the most emerging applications of Large Language
Models (LLMs) and Generative AI, with their effectiveness hinging on multimodal
capabilities to navigate complex user environments. Conversational Health
Agents (CHAs), a prime example of this, are redefining healthcare by offering
nuanced support that transcends textual analysis to incorporate emotional
intelligence. This paper introduces an LLM-based CHA engineered for rich,
multimodal dialogue-especially in the realm of mental health support. It
adeptly interprets and responds to users' emotional states by analyzing
multimodal cues, thus delivering contextually aware and empathetically resonant
verbal responses. Our implementation leverages the versatile openCHA framework,
and our comprehensive evaluation involves neutral prompts expressed in diverse
emotional tones: sadness, anger, and joy. We evaluate the consistency and
repeatability of the planning capability of the proposed CHA. Furthermore,
human evaluators critique the CHA's empathic delivery, with findings revealing
a striking concordance between the CHA's outputs and evaluators' assessments.
These results affirm the indispensable role of vocal (soon multimodal) emotion
recognition in strengthening the empathetic connection built by CHAs, cementing
their place at the forefront of interactive, compassionate digital health
solutions.
|
[
-0.33164891600608826,
-0.7053635120391846,
0.8580527901649475,
0.3674394488334656,
0.030301008373498917,
0.10387802869081497,
-0.14698487520217896,
-0.3722410202026367,
0.6852150559425354,
0.152017742395401,
-0.7784697413444519,
-0.4063810706138611,
-0.39454182982444763,
0.0977822095155716,
0.2018676996231079,
0.8587026000022888,
0.2618681788444519,
0.04826036095619202,
0.00712297298014164,
-0.3735336661338806,
-0.13345171511173248,
-0.3501196801662445,
-0.6752166152000427,
-0.4378545880317688,
0.9592397212982178,
0.4115142226219177,
0.9721565246582031,
-0.07110895216464996,
0.2640344500541687,
0.3358342945575714,
0.2260032743215561,
0.5924277305603027,
-0.2294575721025467,
0.40306559205055237,
0.121505506336689,
-0.0795818492770195,
-0.945801854133606,
-0.15597471594810486,
0.10957954078912735,
0.24531909823417664,
-0.3227687180042267,
-0.3404420018196106,
-0.08720003813505173,
0.4855051338672638,
-0.5524551868438721,
0.29444432258605957,
-0.1787296086549759,
0.3004513084888458,
0.16093334555625916,
-0.49901390075683594,
-0.4992218613624573,
-0.08403140306472778,
-0.00879932101815939,
-0.6722748279571533,
-0.47082018852233887,
-0.06424739211797714,
0.4692327380180359,
0.41142863035202026,
-0.7636213898658752,
-0.30112266540527344,
-0.5602233409881592,
0.5638934969902039,
-0.6229290962219238,
0.4720933139324188,
0.43404853343963623,
0.3748317062854767,
0.04240812361240387,
-0.6440495848655701,
-0.7975487112998962,
-0.2264413833618164,
-0.03507577255368233,
0.6511911153793335,
-0.5290586948394775,
0.4836452603340149,
0.0733465775847435,
0.16979601979255676,
-0.4601293206214905,
0.044620268046855927,
0.28307798504829407,
-0.13278616964817047,
0.6023206114768982,
0.5077452063560486,
0.5854837894439697,
-0.1396866738796234,
-0.18620291352272034,
0.02384142391383648,
-0.030857356265187263,
0.056939419358968735,
-0.09843206405639648,
0.32236605882644653,
-0.7435585856437683,
0.6199859976768494,
-0.05140393599867821,
0.21906934678554535,
-0.20668424665927887,
-0.31879568099975586,
0.5406563878059387,
-0.06404080241918564,
-0.3101080656051636,
0.04043969884514809,
0.7538986206054688,
0.615792453289032,
0.2054867446422577,
0.08944227546453476,
-0.04509289935231209,
0.28805309534072876,
0.5888633728027344,
-0.6158285737037659,
0.03049628436565399,
0.68404221534729,
-0.6487870216369629,
0.06961825489997864,
-0.17864970862865448,
-0.9866751432418823,
-0.8723483681678772,
-0.3515527844429016,
0.019312912598252296,
-0.5701344013214111,
-0.3844338059425354,
0.20307119190692902,
0.023897575214505196,
0.11231992393732071,
0.49516522884368896,
-0.5173479318618774,
0.19917482137680054,
0.5107159614562988,
0.9065972566604614,
0.4356437921524048,
-0.17221632599830627,
-0.585533618927002,
0.07998466491699219,
-0.025439033284783363,
0.5803304314613342,
-0.8070793151855469,
-0.3316083550453186,
0.09611587971448898,
-0.007264988962560892,
0.019006993621587753,
-0.10101843625307083,
0.6345732808113098,
-0.1287064105272293,
-0.08285544067621231,
-0.3157939910888672,
0.007252893876284361,
0.025941504165530205,
0.42774146795272827,
-0.5612636804580688,
0.3302496373653412,
0.37821587920188904,
-0.5788208246231079,
-0.00027416099328547716,
-1.0604130029678345,
-0.5250554084777832,
0.04664752632379532,
-0.05940853804349899,
-0.30743998289108276,
0.32053905725479126,
0.20130468904972076,
0.4062158465385437,
-0.35961392521858215,
-0.19525976479053497,
-0.6944035291671753,
-0.07813215255737305,
0.4324566721916199,
-0.4571049213409424,
0.4640306532382965,
0.4391724765300751,
-0.24648872017860413,
0.48659706115722656,
-0.6269360780715942,
0.17866937816143036,
0.13522319495677948,
0.027680665254592896,
-0.2935052514076233,
-0.11234790831804276,
0.3468937873840332,
0.4069750905036926,
-0.1624729037284851,
-0.4928387999534607,
-0.15099897980690002,
-0.17803329229354858,
0.5518882274627686,
0.8268375396728516,
-0.14438308775424957,
0.16767607629299164,
-0.4500778913497925,
0.7315993905067444,
0.05890202522277832,
0.426293283700943,
-0.39364150166511536,
-0.5304329991340637,
-0.49138277769088745,
-0.9983103275299072,
-0.5972738862037659,
0.3711303770542145,
-0.6942146420478821,
0.27832940220832825,
-0.09436273574829102,
-0.673493504524231,
-1.0634326934814453,
-0.20609137415885925,
0.45025762915611267,
0.4067257046699524,
0.4420805871486664,
-0.4874507486820221,
-0.16786374151706696,
-0.865584671497345,
-0.07725532352924347,
-0.27656257152557373,
0.06876786053180695,
0.7365694046020508,
0.01962076872587204,
-0.9049103260040283,
0.6065331697463989,
-0.26893848180770874,
-0.23481294512748718,
-0.1455778330564499,
0.19296251237392426,
-0.39748892188072205,
0.13516174256801605,
0.3014092743396759,
-0.6958420872688293,
-0.3478170931339264,
0.28518444299697876,
-0.9042285680770874,
-0.41152146458625793,
-0.16511057317256927,
-0.10299664735794067,
-0.04806026816368103,
-0.05701841041445732,
-0.7619223594665527,
0.35469239950180054,
0.6723830699920654,
-0.5112496614456177,
0.21617798507213593,
-0.13035789132118225,
0.5447511672973633,
-1.130056619644165,
0.12564118206501007,
0.04673132672905922,
-0.13748303055763245,
-0.9248918294906616,
-0.20653840899467468,
-0.017443032935261726,
-0.2888556122779846,
-0.6511756777763367,
0.7609156370162964,
-0.2530483603477478,
-0.03770339861512184,
-0.14818988740444183,
0.1891784369945526,
0.2559067904949188,
0.5537463426589966,
-0.1790049821138382,
0.3774782121181488,
0.4198858439922333,
-0.2296895831823349,
0.8602423071861267,
0.4665357768535614,
0.2274700403213501,
1.4370105266571045,
-0.5104327201843262,
0.2679954767227173,
-0.20189954340457916,
0.479199081659317,
-0.883523166179657,
-0.3949985206127167,
0.4458010792732239,
-0.3797098994255066,
-0.004317665006965399,
0.5333293080329895,
-0.2342493087053299,
-0.2890184223651886,
-0.2686000466346741,
0.6133628487586975,
0.3048692047595978,
-0.24821843206882477,
1.0188740491867065,
0.5468961596488953,
-0.433976948261261,
-0.1868424117565155,
-0.758403480052948,
0.1718980222940445,
-0.15186180174350739,
-0.6564599871635437,
-0.07386306673288345,
-0.22109507024288177,
-0.5864192247390747,
-0.16468504071235657,
0.24920566380023956,
-0.1457684189081192,
0.006066828966140747,
0.5586075186729431,
0.02649238519370556,
0.020099636167287827,
0.54072105884552,
0.20985770225524902,
-0.17290738224983215,
0.03878447040915489,
0.2028850018978119,
0.5217592120170593,
-0.4769274890422821,
-0.8516292572021484,
-0.7705396413803101,
0.6771013736724854,
1.1478686332702637,
-0.47586438059806824,
0.5379090309143066,
0.6768477559089661,
-0.45602861046791077,
0.1472044587135315,
-0.47550633549690247,
-0.1421673595905304,
-0.419961154460907,
0.2767878770828247,
-0.3679582476615906,
-0.5939705967903137,
0.5383487939834595,
0.030534585937857628,
-0.08229897171258926,
-0.006491081323474646,
0.7944654822349548,
-0.11437428742647171,
1.2697497606277466,
0.05548885464668274,
-0.08039616793394089,
0.32813015580177307,
0.22296056151390076,
0.3197495937347412,
-0.9190729856491089,
-0.5082714557647705,
-0.3523249328136444,
-0.3669799268245697,
-0.4509488344192505,
-0.30645692348480225,
0.6739159822463989,
-0.735924482345581,
-0.36253827810287476,
-0.28403884172439575,
-0.23951254785060883,
-0.3722655177116394,
0.377520889043808,
0.7301869988441467,
0.00503113865852356,
-0.3185510039329529,
0.12956906855106354,
-0.14764201641082764,
-0.3043942451477051,
-0.46406155824661255,
0.4075428545475006,
0.5638267397880554,
0.9972710013389587,
0.29565656185150146,
0.33709102869033813,
0.4527084231376648,
0.4804452061653137,
-0.9404613971710205,
0.44661715626716614,
0.18064983189105988,
-0.2120107263326645,
-0.2051054686307907,
-0.30655255913734436,
-1.0221596956253052,
0.21916310489177704,
-0.32860493659973145,
-0.6438714265823364,
0.1357535570859909,
0.12173706293106079,
-0.4470715820789337,
-0.019671618938446045,
-0.7582531571388245,
0.7328877449035645,
-0.45682182908058167,
-0.42570799589157104,
-0.4427540600299835,
-0.7515730857849121,
-0.028723986819386482,
0.09823080152273178,
0.3199390769004822,
-0.22088801860809326,
0.0031314257066696882,
0.07774911820888519,
-0.2801763117313385,
0.9637971520423889,
-0.1563882827758789,
-0.1430691033601761,
0.03311397507786751,
0.12970857322216034,
0.14116065204143524,
0.0677308589220047,
-0.2039647102355957,
0.12141778320074081,
-0.21283888816833496,
-0.5569831132888794,
-0.9379282593727112,
0.6411161422729492,
-0.8104211688041687,
-0.42316439747810364,
-0.24651356041431427,
-0.714199960231781,
-0.5155459642410278,
0.021899988874793053,
-0.47390276193618774,
0.4570998251438141,
-0.37003493309020996,
0.09249819070100784,
0.3691989481449127,
-0.651549220085144,
0.15700018405914307,
0.5692010521888733,
0.07102217525243759,
-0.5602110624313354,
0.8659773468971252,
-0.41098353266716003,
0.3347991406917572,
0.3639701306819916,
0.4680730104446411,
-0.21837745606899261,
0.356472373008728,
-0.18492142856121063,
0.37370720505714417,
-0.5598982572555542,
-0.15962886810302734,
-0.8827439546585083,
-0.14208155870437622,
-0.5052899122238159,
-0.5133896470069885,
-0.33848780393600464,
0.10340046137571335,
-0.19222912192344666,
-0.194294735789299,
0.30436190962791443,
0.617347240447998,
-0.09634022414684296,
0.13546423614025116,
-0.9394482970237732,
0.41065627336502075,
0.4699248671531677,
0.30855345726013184,
0.1684548258781433,
0.04752398282289505,
-0.12790758907794952,
0.2533392906188965,
-0.4062236547470093,
-1.194117784500122,
0.503230094909668,
0.19629521667957306,
0.4078631103038788,
0.7092387676239014,
0.26119494438171387,
0.5545171499252319,
-0.323329895734787,
0.6888571381568909,
0.49835655093193054,
-0.9949951171875,
0.5616645216941833,
-0.3160558044910431,
0.3367718458175659,
0.2910260856151581,
0.16725696623325348,
-0.8145370483398438,
-0.42380911111831665,
-0.45065632462501526,
-0.6196478009223938,
0.5023345351219177,
0.15087255835533142,
0.303896963596344,
-0.25450754165649414,
-0.20897671580314636,
0.007567714434117079,
0.325935423374176,
-0.4977685809135437,
-0.06330419331789017,
-0.4583294987678528,
-0.620229184627533,
-0.0816943496465683,
-0.37646353244781494,
-0.4171142578125,
0.3255733549594879,
0.2984367907047272,
-0.4664500951766968,
0.5084900856018066,
0.2943805754184723,
0.15573306381702423,
-0.28824347257614136,
0.5375296473503113,
0.5324748158454895,
0.040074512362480164,
0.13891112804412842,
0.36889100074768066,
-0.10741429775953293,
-0.1371152251958847,
0.05071179196238518,
0.004291032440960407,
0.48518338799476624,
-0.2088782638311386,
0.4074931740760803,
0.8301665782928467,
0.21997177600860596,
-0.9794092774391174,
0.5616211891174316,
-0.038790009915828705,
0.4462287724018097,
0.05558602884411812,
-0.23816117644309998,
0.08745525777339935,
0.6027519702911377,
-0.22055800259113312,
-0.20625446736812592,
0.3817540109157562,
-0.7741611003875732,
0.22004473209381104,
0.4952763617038727,
-0.8165834546089172,
-0.5124729871749878,
0.4710742235183716,
0.4651497006416321,
-0.6692129373550415,
0.7014923691749573,
0.2634468078613281,
-0.39803779125213623,
0.41495993733406067,
0.4570769667625427,
1.0972195863723755,
-0.6457631587982178,
0.43800151348114014,
-0.15635551512241364,
0.1055673360824585,
0.40740349888801575,
0.5662088394165039,
-0.02531614527106285,
-0.7385553121566772,
0.2926103472709656,
-0.1501728892326355,
-0.6339690685272217,
-0.44174617528915405,
-0.749511182308197,
-0.050271909683942795,
-0.2921466827392578,
-0.433028906583786,
-0.014789778739213943,
-0.41216394305229187,
-0.9000073671340942,
0.3769751489162445,
0.24910889565944672,
0.5815419554710388,
-0.8701614737510681,
0.4912610948085785,
0.7349241971969604,
-0.5665493607521057,
-0.601672887802124,
-0.00445453729480505,
0.42850807309150696,
-1.0651230812072754,
0.32854163646698,
0.22673676908016205,
-0.35837164521217346,
-0.31537383794784546,
-0.048409491777420044,
-0.08520941436290741,
1.1682617664337158,
0.4869888722896576,
-0.23614512383937836,
0.06235767528414726,
0.17451144754886627,
0.839566171169281,
-0.4352763295173645,
0.9666642546653748,
0.26006871461868286,
0.6974049210548401,
-0.01054490078240633,
-1.0799270868301392,
0.15740080177783966,
-0.6104945540428162,
-0.16157233715057373,
-0.20205606520175934,
-1.1051225662231445,
0.5746428966522217,
-0.3041561245918274,
-0.11310701072216034,
-0.15476243197917938,
0.29184284806251526,
0.31228721141815186,
0.7889779806137085,
0.606529712677002,
0.46120524406433105,
0.9703454971313477,
0.10849728435277939,
1.1412901878356934,
-0.2679068148136139,
-0.08547897636890411,
0.8316981196403503,
-0.6917027831077576,
0.5191149115562439,
0.48227745294570923,
-0.02237674780189991,
0.49536022543907166,
0.3782186806201935,
0.491031676530838,
0.3234996795654297,
-0.07789364457130432,
-0.7881103157997131,
-0.12318588048219681,
-1.0254703760147095,
-0.2962931990623474,
0.5089699029922485,
0.3632441461086273,
-0.24607783555984497,
0.09182121604681015,
0.3251478374004364,
0.17088869214057922,
0.1107785552740097,
-0.2746540606021881,
0.7484813928604126,
0.49588170647621155,
-0.34348317980766296,
0.03531833365559578,
-0.3490046262741089,
0.20421338081359863,
-0.7894391417503357,
-0.12077438831329346,
-0.1475396603345871,
-0.017831124365329742,
-0.3160710334777832,
-0.6728206276893616,
0.12528733909130096,
-0.17412444949150085,
0.02502121962606907,
-0.41637369990348816,
0.6303851008415222,
-0.3933286964893341,
-0.16159100830554962,
0.7886872291564941,
0.6125835180282593,
0.05843277648091316,
-0.0823683962225914,
-0.6386433839797974,
0.37623926997184753,
-0.40783071517944336,
-0.43118175864219666,
0.1859133094549179,
0.7670919895172119,
0.2566973567008972,
0.9367581605911255,
0.40318456292152405,
0.036530762910842896,
-0.38631224632263184,
0.4091653823852539,
0.9114030599594116,
-0.6835193037986755,
-0.5173540115356445,
-0.7642759680747986,
0.8609316349029541,
0.09152795374393463,
-0.20962214469909668,
0.4550497531890869,
0.09343186020851135,
0.11949846893548965,
0.13325421512126923,
0.8302775025367737,
-0.01261457335203886,
0.07448489218950272,
-0.25526317954063416,
0.6546658873558044,
-0.9493658542633057,
-0.2001492977142334,
-0.5455540418624878,
-0.37444669008255005,
-0.24124230444431305,
0.5950832962989807,
0.016461225226521492,
0.11540061980485916,
0.520630419254303,
0.8278533816337585,
0.24602003395557404,
0.2524811923503876,
0.6703500747680664,
0.3033074140548706,
0.5877092480659485,
0.8428061008453369,
0.9077487587928772,
0.1680344194173813,
-0.07424452900886536,
0.02386227436363697,
-0.5323562026023865,
-0.21005702018737793,
-0.6876978874206543,
-0.6548203825950623,
-0.545326292514801,
-0.00811847485601902,
-0.5585489869117737,
0.08920609951019287,
1.4045063257217407,
0.584889829158783,
-0.4486827254295349,
0.023319879546761513,
0.3852561414241791,
-0.0256140548735857,
-0.25373122096061707,
-0.23392890393733978,
0.0326792411506176,
-0.10933127999305725,
-0.6803235411643982,
0.4182632863521576,
0.8215696215629578,
-0.16216720640659332,
-0.392559289932251,
-0.4604990482330322,
0.23078857362270355,
0.46431609988212585,
0.807847261428833,
0.23118248581886292,
-0.8165189027786255,
-0.40237826108932495,
0.06345050781965256,
-0.4198843836784363,
0.14307533204555511,
0.7906443476676941,
-0.3985966742038727,
0.9824822545051575,
0.09140920639038086,
0.877728283405304,
-0.14762745797634125,
-0.12399692833423615,
0.5899994969367981,
-0.2279941588640213,
0.17360348999500275,
0.48798102140426636,
0.45180949568748474,
0.2965109348297119,
-0.4798995554447174,
0.38947775959968567,
0.04717317596077919,
-0.4154508411884308,
-0.7502309083938599,
0.4739658832550049,
-1.3595542907714844,
0.12313216924667358,
1.2877432107925415,
-0.4097081422805786,
0.03114921599626541,
-0.07766126096248627,
-0.6633332967758179,
0.3606277406215668,
-0.727697491645813,
0.8387599587440491,
0.4299320876598358,
-0.4746675491333008,
-0.363785058259964,
-0.22297529876232147,
0.021350640803575516,
0.3288794457912445,
-1.2010383605957031,
0.15715116262435913,
0.6930390000343323,
-0.4083532392978668,
0.09879454970359802,
1.079288363456726,
0.03120865672826767,
0.2170857936143875,
0.027815481647849083,
0.38535600900650024,
-0.031623516231775284,
-0.20579247176647186,
-0.28161394596099854,
0.15747809410095215,
-0.06456013768911362,
-0.034968167543411255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04758v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04758v2
|
Honeyfile Camouflage: Hiding Fake Files in Plain Sight
| 2024-05-08T02:01:17 | 2024-05-10T05:12:47 |
Roelien C. Timmer, David Liebowitz, Surya Nepal, Salil S. Kanhere
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Honeyfiles are a particularly useful type of honeypot: fake files deployed to
detect and infer information from malicious behaviour. This paper considers the
challenge of naming honeyfiles so they are camouflaged when placed amongst real
files in a file system. Based on cosine distances in semantic vector spaces, we
develop two metrics for filename camouflage: one based on simple averaging and
one on clustering with mixture fitting. We evaluate and compare the metrics,
showing that both perform well on a publicly available GitHub software
repository dataset.
|
[
-0.25066077709198,
-0.5942836999893188,
0.3924632966518402,
0.0807402953505516,
-0.2776108980178833,
0.48957350850105286,
-0.02051672898232937,
-0.6834791898727417,
0.6355093717575073,
0.3509643077850342,
-0.6728085279464722,
-0.6649393439292908,
-0.8493176102638245,
-0.07048142701387405,
-1.0699992179870605,
0.5807797908782959,
0.22987134754657745,
-0.35218361020088196,
-0.4461112320423126,
-0.3118995428085327,
-0.6153624057769775,
-0.5372387170791626,
-0.19477549195289612,
0.2437354475259781,
0.7903026342391968,
-0.02963264100253582,
0.6965864300727844,
0.8897623419761658,
0.8784599304199219,
0.4093983769416809,
0.2570360600948334,
-0.14407582581043243,
-0.2783663272857666,
0.09964586049318314,
0.10640130192041397,
-0.6193569302558899,
0.382163941860199,
0.19097621738910675,
0.233950674533844,
0.24024051427841187,
-0.04705866053700447,
0.3085191547870636,
-0.40537747740745544,
0.4790302813053131,
-0.945644199848175,
-0.07374995946884155,
-0.3055609166622162,
0.12028304487466812,
-0.6359602212905884,
0.03416779637336731,
-0.04162744805216789,
-0.4360477328300476,
0.3486776053905487,
-0.9599149823188782,
0.5978593230247498,
0.38503479957580566,
0.8884283900260925,
0.23470304906368256,
0.318108469247818,
-0.34275633096694946,
-0.8619824051856995,
0.8169731497764587,
-0.5659192800521851,
-0.26828303933143616,
0.3995487689971924,
0.9487795233726501,
-0.7346013188362122,
-0.3196381628513336,
-0.43893659114837646,
0.13687579333782196,
-0.5035882592201233,
-0.21035204827785492,
-0.5616791248321533,
-0.23493054509162903,
0.09533967077732086,
0.31404006481170654,
-0.7787208557128906,
-0.25401169061660767,
-0.16419346630573273,
-0.6714629530906677,
0.3535986840724945,
-0.1593213528394699,
0.3890840411186218,
0.09671380370855331,
-0.5665549635887146,
-0.45037218928337097,
-0.2616273760795593,
0.1707088202238083,
0.8323134779930115,
0.01963116228580475,
-0.324025958776474,
0.37005677819252014,
-0.21397176384925842,
0.511043906211853,
-0.01768414117395878,
-0.5021676421165466,
0.04798439145088196,
-0.012869314290583134,
-0.548294186592102,
-0.3101339638233185,
0.2192949652671814,
0.07579576224088669,
-0.325743705034256,
-0.45792749524116516,
-0.40905165672302246,
0.5321998596191406,
0.40179726481437683,
-0.49895572662353516,
-0.6752573251724243,
0.28133901953697205,
-0.44543126225471497,
-0.7097144722938538,
0.5865626335144043,
-0.6136496067047119,
-0.5984082818031311,
-0.22594432532787323,
0.9781790971755981,
-0.6019474267959595,
-0.3334200084209442,
-0.19864709675312042,
-0.9252675175666809,
0.46391403675079346,
0.6866582632064819,
-0.16027653217315674,
0.3500683605670929,
1.008086085319519,
0.633059561252594,
-0.17198984324932098,
-0.11150035262107849,
-0.10942785441875458,
0.2585434317588806,
-0.43311193585395813,
0.9785733819007874,
-0.4043142795562744,
-0.23578642308712006,
-0.2727501392364502,
0.29301875829696655,
0.043507929891347885,
-0.7294579148292542,
-0.031518299132585526,
-0.3493803143501282,
0.24019914865493774,
-0.22696365416049957,
-0.5975375771522522,
-0.6825341582298279,
0.35274791717529297,
-0.6190160512924194,
0.8038359880447388,
0.5259164571762085,
-0.5794684886932373,
0.6696193218231201,
-0.3093247711658478,
-0.25913795828819275,
0.45482930541038513,
-0.1636294722557068,
-0.5581773519515991,
-0.07060175389051437,
-0.44105401635169983,
0.5031207799911499,
0.3349824547767639,
-0.0005680514732375741,
-0.31276652216911316,
-0.37919482588768005,
0.5852183699607849,
0.0036556702107191086,
0.38332295417785645,
0.11591150611639023,
-0.28776341676712036,
-0.007035614922642708,
-0.7751867771148682,
-0.2179180532693863,
0.0047223432920873165,
-0.10902447253465652,
-0.7328184247016907,
-0.1641448438167572,
-0.15699495375156403,
-0.46053430438041687,
0.02396242506802082,
-0.8052638173103333,
-0.1674233376979828,
-0.2200075089931488,
0.012026564218103886,
0.5269224643707275,
-0.1313856989145279,
0.7122178673744202,
-0.6529857516288757,
0.4630976617336273,
0.4065264165401459,
0.5028992891311646,
-0.18315640091896057,
-0.5738646388053894,
-0.5920711159706116,
-0.7977793216705322,
0.2995665371417999,
0.38335153460502625,
-0.6363833546638489,
0.26667535305023193,
0.059631071984767914,
-0.7117879986763,
-0.21224844455718994,
-0.05113266780972481,
0.6265313625335693,
0.3190931975841522,
0.27461326122283936,
-0.324902206659317,
-0.3300042748451233,
-1.0056207180023193,
-0.35960525274276733,
0.14429479837417603,
-0.1938086897134781,
0.3152187466621399,
0.6823629140853882,
-0.22497251629829407,
0.9947769641876221,
-0.19543668627738953,
-0.37501469254493713,
0.2951943278312683,
0.27616727352142334,
0.10722646117210388,
0.4824010729789734,
1.1617552042007446,
-0.99503093957901,
-0.5026016235351562,
-0.34851181507110596,
-0.35282108187675476,
0.07493265718221664,
0.10606791079044342,
-0.3641771674156189,
0.1730090081691742,
0.32132986187934875,
-0.5775274038314819,
0.7129574418067932,
0.6765162348747253,
-0.607384443283081,
0.5386769771575928,
0.07604790478944778,
0.2622659206390381,
-0.5147985219955444,
0.05708029866218567,
-0.0634450614452362,
-0.6055358052253723,
-0.7214308977127075,
0.5424001812934875,
-0.12786252796649933,
-0.02735314704477787,
-0.6242150068283081,
0.3352709412574768,
-0.4031303822994232,
-0.1465044766664505,
0.07301449030637741,
-0.24071477353572845,
-0.19208677113056183,
0.25504177808761597,
-0.2713753581047058,
0.4540133774280548,
0.7844327688217163,
-0.2515556216239929,
0.8400973677635193,
-0.16749194264411926,
-0.38912975788116455,
0.6014374494552612,
-0.14333376288414001,
0.11098609119653702,
0.009388407692313194,
0.34837606549263,
-1.0780246257781982,
-0.708005964756012,
0.5260459184646606,
-0.6007702350616455,
0.33831194043159485,
-0.7313655614852905,
-0.24447165429592133,
-0.5070420503616333,
-0.5804505944252014,
0.25801634788513184,
0.59259033203125,
-0.4308185875415802,
0.6109002828598022,
0.268379807472229,
0.33586227893829346,
-0.4073407053947449,
-0.5905510783195496,
-0.005623253993690014,
-0.5621092915534973,
-0.6630904078483582,
0.16173025965690613,
-0.033320456743240356,
-0.4210871458053589,
0.179227814078331,
-0.3375388979911804,
-0.34726482629776,
0.04293054714798927,
0.7885698676109314,
0.19843067228794098,
-0.4962291121482849,
-0.17686833441257477,
-0.43333202600479126,
-0.13886526226997375,
-0.01108698733150959,
-0.2992270886898041,
0.08962459117174149,
-0.0750361755490303,
-0.33722320199012756,
-0.14463239908218384,
0.6318690776824951,
0.446410596370697,
0.4304065406322479,
0.8782057166099548,
0.6206075549125671,
-0.4212745130062103,
-0.3922691345214844,
-0.6262218952178955,
0.04828410968184471,
-0.5293675065040588,
-0.31332919001579285,
-0.08810221403837204,
-0.5427433252334595,
0.7559746503829956,
-0.018047967925667763,
0.051799897104501724,
0.315411776304245,
0.008798842318356037,
-0.5968443155288696,
0.08570380508899689,
0.9276517033576965,
-0.010615706443786621,
0.3521463871002197,
-0.3464777171611786,
0.10112345963716507,
-0.08692137897014618,
-0.5842453837394714,
-0.6049824953079224,
-0.6362902522087097,
-0.34213367104530334,
-0.7206515669822693,
0.23678381741046906,
-0.002219186630100012,
0.14706972241401672,
0.803068995475769,
-0.7146291136741638,
0.9844226837158203,
0.7603897452354431,
0.3002823293209076,
-0.2415681630373001,
0.17275740206241608,
-0.036139532923698425,
0.16277119517326355,
-0.445324569940567,
-0.3607725501060486,
0.6310921907424927,
0.2449672967195511,
0.5142655372619629,
0.3815033733844757,
0.8810843825340271,
0.6944717764854431,
0.16086876392364502,
-0.825652003288269,
0.4751564860343933,
-0.1789640635251999,
-0.5663820505142212,
-0.6485790014266968,
-0.08487012982368469,
-1.085648775100708,
0.02710384875535965,
-0.2050810158252716,
-0.4085352122783661,
0.040909767150878906,
0.13212409615516663,
-0.4109523296356201,
0.302530974149704,
-0.953791081905365,
0.705337405204773,
0.2534339427947998,
0.1696581244468689,
-0.16472457349300385,
-0.756548285484314,
0.3898002505302429,
-0.12736502289772034,
0.43346861004829407,
-0.48465096950531006,
0.05416140705347061,
1.0176752805709839,
-0.8534397482872009,
0.7756724953651428,
-0.40162593126296997,
0.433274507522583,
0.4135581851005554,
0.6522387862205505,
0.33496832847595215,
-0.41320011019706726,
0.3736048638820648,
0.3047959506511688,
0.7253183722496033,
-0.783768892288208,
-0.4081432521343231,
0.6003313660621643,
-0.4798795282840729,
-0.4842629134654999,
-0.3563140034675598,
-0.19393911957740784,
0.17060723900794983,
0.28308025002479553,
0.1852492392063141,
0.4777245819568634,
0.0537840873003006,
0.49804219603538513,
0.8497297763824463,
-0.5453530550003052,
0.5655445456504822,
0.6884140372276306,
0.06880885362625122,
-0.009765559807419777,
0.9414986371994019,
0.04371616989374161,
0.0025276050437241793,
0.565575122833252,
0.5831639766693115,
-0.002402213402092457,
-0.45789504051208496,
-0.6429749727249146,
0.010938487015664577,
-0.7052420973777771,
-0.5420709848403931,
-0.3472747206687927,
-0.2982988953590393,
-0.3052387237548828,
-0.5143793225288391,
-0.08263099938631058,
-0.453726589679718,
-0.1902841031551361,
0.37225162982940674,
0.8847274780273438,
0.8620603084564209,
0.08989979326725006,
0.38091591000556946,
-0.6608010530471802,
0.5574185252189636,
0.12057818472385406,
0.5827235579490662,
-0.19338230788707733,
-0.3929654359817505,
-0.23053833842277527,
-0.06705977022647858,
0.009005429223179817,
-0.7990893125534058,
0.4586140513420105,
-0.005584537982940674,
0.615285336971283,
0.22911357879638672,
0.15767672657966614,
0.7455927729606628,
0.107847198843956,
0.8704490661621094,
0.20889794826507568,
-0.3308527171611786,
0.43287062644958496,
-0.8075389862060547,
0.12059786915779114,
0.38561826944351196,
0.14601606130599976,
-0.20406678318977356,
-0.6510356664657593,
-0.7029138207435608,
-0.6127575635910034,
0.6071517467498779,
0.5156933665275574,
-0.04292404279112816,
0.583254337310791,
0.17197811603546143,
0.4242021143436432,
0.3463227450847626,
-0.4611642062664032,
-0.2197977602481842,
-0.14742211997509003,
-0.18941016495227814,
0.05776677653193474,
0.10308341681957245,
-0.6467005610466003,
-0.19737520813941956,
0.3297513425350189,
0.3364139795303345,
0.541049599647522,
0.047057271003723145,
-0.03354893997311592,
-0.2008504718542099,
0.02777601033449173,
0.5556068420410156,
0.09875625371932983,
-0.24462977051734924,
0.3312842547893524,
-0.31949520111083984,
-0.8441901803016663,
0.14186345040798187,
-0.3534103035926819,
0.10337868332862854,
0.2819700241088867,
0.3619048595428467,
-0.09126743674278259,
0.2661132216453552,
-0.2953195869922638,
0.9074514508247375,
0.020009638741612434,
-0.3445659279823303,
-0.5431634187698364,
0.5532532930374146,
-0.01848585344851017,
0.22115033864974976,
0.2504553198814392,
0.6931391954421997,
0.12156662344932556,
-0.6919808387756348,
0.053305454552173615,
0.5177134871482849,
-0.02428661473095417,
-0.3203701376914978,
0.15085439383983612,
0.10389038920402527,
-0.5922529697418213,
0.054231930524110794,
-0.24394415318965912,
-0.5157598853111267,
1.2421249151229858,
0.20568624138832092,
0.8755463361740112,
-0.11705067753791809,
0.20134012401103973,
0.09505892544984818,
0.3998725116252899,
-0.12438357621431351,
-0.022322997450828552,
-0.3184592127799988,
-0.335449755191803,
0.3823394179344177,
-1.0270236730575562,
-0.5285294651985168,
0.22188928723335266,
-0.22957120835781097,
0.18022295832633972,
-0.6171833276748657,
0.1120951697230339,
0.2954082190990448,
-0.19660399854183197,
-0.5992617607116699,
0.00713333860039711,
0.30900952219963074,
1.1075608730316162,
-1.0197519063949585,
0.6616914868354797,
0.44668424129486084,
0.17458675801753998,
-0.8531792163848877,
-0.2087828814983368,
0.4574858546257019,
-0.3481242060661316,
-0.13809515535831451,
0.1851079910993576,
-0.262685090303421,
-0.2773881256580353,
-0.6512496471405029,
-1.2961527109146118,
1.1516468524932861,
0.07364173233509064,
-0.2901536524295807,
0.41019779443740845,
0.2830556333065033,
0.684156060218811,
-0.10190914571285248,
-0.14202913641929626,
0.43716180324554443,
0.8847047686576843,
0.25736087560653687,
-0.3878268897533417,
-0.30663448572158813,
-0.26816126704216003,
-0.18965962529182434,
0.2634109854698181,
-0.48671239614486694,
0.5255672931671143,
0.2674023509025574,
-0.4762621819972992,
0.4639488756656647,
0.07443419843912125,
-0.0023026850540190935,
0.7896749377250671,
0.3624632954597473,
0.5712931752204895,
0.4914560317993164,
-0.4986925721168518,
0.9489632844924927,
0.20680268108844757,
-0.02469547651708126,
0.6257047057151794,
0.35108453035354614,
0.54851233959198,
0.4769684672355652,
-0.4246159791946411,
0.6656449437141418,
0.7638648748397827,
-0.5754252672195435,
0.5840107202529907,
0.3091917335987091,
-0.111012764275074,
0.07672079652547836,
0.4116133153438568,
0.015587718226015568,
0.12312878668308258,
0.5163109302520752,
0.018937738612294197,
-0.10307136923074722,
-0.000511189631652087,
-0.22476093471050262,
-0.009598962962627411,
-0.0047941007651388645,
0.7523117661476135,
-0.19691818952560425,
-0.30605098605155945,
0.20734666287899017,
0.20957531034946442,
0.800792396068573,
-0.646518886089325,
-0.0278690904378891,
-0.09451057016849518,
-0.06329509615898132,
-0.5108138918876648,
-0.7932376265525818,
0.6123775839805603,
-0.1111900731921196,
-0.3948100507259369,
0.018103722482919693,
0.9967930912971497,
-0.0889599397778511,
-0.3392146825790405,
0.3479461669921875,
-0.08173102140426636,
0.36612334847450256,
-0.17641900479793549,
-0.6990759372711182,
-0.23750877380371094,
-0.5601432919502258,
-0.22806479036808014,
0.5345197916030884,
0.35162702202796936,
-0.17564775049686432,
0.7323026061058044,
0.9648986458778381,
-0.06816761940717697,
0.5295583605766296,
-0.384564071893692,
0.6219217777252197,
-0.4582458436489105,
-0.8242213726043701,
-0.5542789697647095,
0.05184860900044441,
-0.007622579578310251,
0.31650108098983765,
1.2068029642105103,
0.5999571681022644,
0.6727217435836792,
-0.5280011296272278,
0.3701446056365967,
-0.4529905915260315,
0.8756890892982483,
-0.14760752022266388,
0.7746855616569519,
-0.27652084827423096,
0.20826342701911926,
-0.3145514726638794,
-0.6336126923561096,
-0.3182889223098755,
0.18141044676303864,
0.026635393500328064,
-0.47335517406463623,
0.26682597398757935,
1.3092706203460693,
-0.5201457738876343,
-0.3054291307926178,
0.7414411902427673,
0.017991600558161736,
-0.1345420926809311,
0.25029465556144714,
1.0206815004348755,
-0.4454461336135864,
0.28118541836738586,
-0.483062744140625,
-0.20832578837871552,
-0.4560156762599945,
-0.8166928291320801,
-0.8412805795669556,
-0.3273693025112152,
-0.14353422820568085,
-0.16854000091552734,
-0.030676372349262238,
0.44829535484313965,
1.2137197256088257,
-0.9787450432777405,
0.009037102572619915,
0.03275499492883682,
0.3410509526729584,
-0.00602687569335103,
-0.28101468086242676,
-0.07518640905618668,
0.3643738031387329,
0.006617072969675064,
0.3555583655834198,
0.4160033166408539,
0.6710436344146729,
-0.4025213122367859,
-0.01093166321516037,
0.23945794999599457,
0.5098958015441895,
0.2802087068557739,
0.42711004614830017,
-0.9592109322547913,
-0.4077492356300354,
-0.10984716564416885,
-0.23729367554187775,
-0.21253637969493866,
0.7808239459991455,
-1.0214142799377441,
0.23576249182224274,
0.506645679473877,
-0.043334681540727615,
0.064441978931427,
0.1837371587753296,
0.11121062189340591,
-1.0621610879898071,
0.5191344022750854,
0.01784808747470379,
0.03638759255409241,
0.30423033237457275,
-0.7150641679763794,
0.2764446437358856,
0.7326568365097046,
-0.1144896000623703,
-0.7131341099739075,
-0.10578567534685135,
-1.0118552446365356,
-0.5913491249084473,
1.0360536575317383,
-0.44045159220695496,
-0.5086789727210999,
-0.38962075114250183,
0.026952585205435753,
0.010435277596116066,
-0.33353546261787415,
0.7684701085090637,
0.5732792615890503,
0.1373686045408249,
0.2051805853843689,
-0.44310232996940613,
0.8855425119400024,
-0.1534264236688614,
-0.5138625502586365,
-0.16521376371383667,
0.2877395749092102,
0.7881367802619934,
0.5011032223701477,
0.19352546334266663,
-0.26963895559310913,
0.4796414077281952,
0.3835868835449219,
-0.5395001769065857,
0.023033225908875465,
-0.6506994366645813,
-0.21813111007213593,
0.09647268801927567,
-0.6455438733100891,
-0.4422770142555237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04756v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04756v1
|
BiasKG: Adversarial Knowledge Graphs to Induce Bias in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-08T01:51:29 | 2024-05-08T01:51:29 |
Chu Fei Luo, Ahmad Ghawanmeh, Xiaodan Zhu, Faiza Khan Khattak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Modern large language models (LLMs) have a significant amount of world
knowledge, which enables strong performance in commonsense reasoning and
knowledge-intensive tasks when harnessed properly. The language model can also
learn social biases, which has a significant potential for societal harm. There
have been many mitigation strategies proposed for LLM safety, but it is unclear
how effective they are for eliminating social biases. In this work, we propose
a new methodology for attacking language models with knowledge graph augmented
generation. We refactor natural language stereotypes into a knowledge graph,
and use adversarial attacking strategies to induce biased responses from
several open- and closed-source language models. We find our method increases
bias in all models, even those trained with safety guardrails. This
demonstrates the need for further research in AI safety, and further work in
this new adversarial space.
|
[
-0.5451194643974304,
-1.2107770442962646,
0.20316438376903534,
-0.22670133411884308,
0.08129820227622986,
-0.012956849299371243,
-0.0376511812210083,
-0.39471083879470825,
0.10209957510232925,
0.9469798803329468,
-0.32736334204673767,
-0.4997432827949524,
-0.7926183342933655,
-0.20634865760803223,
-0.27212512493133545,
1.059053659439087,
0.04680820554494858,
0.24299506843090057,
-0.14655916392803192,
0.046842966228723526,
-0.19960767030715942,
-0.7186912894248962,
-0.647376537322998,
-0.43704959750175476,
0.4706345796585083,
-0.0544210709631443,
0.908172070980072,
0.5777616500854492,
0.20482170581817627,
0.27300024032592773,
-0.2795351445674896,
0.18993934988975525,
-0.5666694641113281,
0.26215463876724243,
-0.04911915957927704,
-0.396471232175827,
-0.5588915348052979,
0.08878999948501587,
0.4478452205657959,
0.7170621752738953,
0.2923743426799774,
-0.13982948660850525,
0.21571852266788483,
0.7395590543746948,
-0.6224982142448425,
0.3040589690208435,
-0.8689917325973511,
0.05200657621026039,
-0.2169645130634308,
0.018849529325962067,
-0.6461817622184753,
-0.6900202631950378,
0.04988948628306389,
-0.621789276599884,
0.17587019503116608,
0.1489063799381256,
0.5840970873832703,
0.3847573697566986,
-0.539324164390564,
-0.269376277923584,
-0.4425387382507324,
0.569495677947998,
-0.6748367547988892,
0.11099714040756226,
0.2190200686454773,
0.2442375272512436,
-0.4969917833805084,
-0.3830028176307678,
-0.41884860396385193,
-0.28264933824539185,
-0.0766395777463913,
-0.13922734558582306,
-0.10516062378883362,
0.28790563344955444,
0.3899795114994049,
-0.20470422506332397,
-0.4351540505886078,
0.05460774526000023,
-0.2911469638347626,
-0.3887471556663513,
0.6811425685882568,
-0.0241068284958601,
0.6672205328941345,
-0.15892402827739716,
-0.2517157793045044,
-0.19971996545791626,
-0.9216562509536743,
-0.3420611619949341,
1.0111210346221924,
0.3852250576019287,
0.09251447021961212,
0.5727071762084961,
-0.17728611826896667,
0.660790205001831,
0.07360740751028061,
-0.0480467788875103,
0.09584669023752213,
-0.06846451014280319,
-0.02864428050816059,
0.33862948417663574,
0.8624260425567627,
0.5127815008163452,
0.5895054936408997,
-0.344893217086792,
0.0783303901553154,
0.30385836958885193,
0.41284051537513733,
-0.531711220741272,
-0.27592194080352783,
-0.06673599034547806,
-0.059187520295381546,
-0.9795961380004883,
-0.4280640780925751,
-1.0517994165420532,
-0.9035863876342773,
0.14742280542850494,
0.16833342611789703,
-0.6037665605545044,
-0.23147375881671906,
-0.032668646425008774,
-0.33544400334358215,
0.15349014103412628,
0.15119409561157227,
-0.7196606397628784,
0.13056224584579468,
0.5149654746055603,
0.49198096990585327,
0.24572721123695374,
-0.237558513879776,
-0.4417892396450043,
0.35699087381362915,
-0.3626410663127899,
0.5716285109519958,
-0.40368422865867615,
-0.39850717782974243,
0.2664608359336853,
-0.2605941891670227,
0.18798765540122986,
-0.39281386137008667,
0.5291135311126709,
-0.8807975649833679,
0.2082200050354004,
-0.4691084921360016,
-0.431451678276062,
-0.1347506046295166,
0.47549811005592346,
-0.7266088128089905,
0.8184662461280823,
-0.17980414628982544,
-1.332855224609375,
0.2435624599456787,
-0.6879898905754089,
-0.7479888796806335,
-0.2586774230003357,
-0.0923454537987709,
-0.40703529119491577,
-0.3802339434623718,
0.6664633750915527,
0.31240344047546387,
-0.10988013446331024,
0.32985803484916687,
-0.8280027508735657,
0.11679532378911972,
0.05346507206559181,
-0.49479636549949646,
1.146062970161438,
0.12978701293468475,
-0.330969899892807,
0.1014045998454094,
-0.397958368062973,
-0.10889586061239243,
0.42377644777297974,
-0.19395506381988525,
-0.6385415196418762,
0.017559714615345,
-0.36604177951812744,
0.12847669422626495,
0.3058812618255615,
-0.5285333395004272,
0.08069740980863571,
-0.5976644158363342,
0.21522580087184906,
1.2040191888809204,
0.1277124136686325,
0.603014349937439,
-0.11494652926921844,
0.38030117750167847,
-0.030223418027162552,
0.28116029500961304,
0.2457481026649475,
-0.3682825267314911,
-0.6656471490859985,
-0.017508674412965775,
-0.05318526551127434,
0.3079143762588501,
-1.174617886543274,
0.4072953164577484,
-0.03829587250947952,
-0.3275725841522217,
-0.40767738223075867,
0.23525020480155945,
0.5725024342536926,
0.7188537120819092,
0.12607495486736298,
-0.009656507521867752,
-0.5849275588989258,
-0.7769354581832886,
-0.6175071597099304,
-0.29507601261138916,
0.07442343980073929,
0.40889108180999756,
0.2530636489391327,
-0.25169244408607483,
0.8088374137878418,
-0.6820653676986694,
0.03876953944563866,
-0.2543545961380005,
-0.08572681993246078,
-0.23799936473369598,
0.24607571959495544,
0.7894464731216431,
-0.5035853385925293,
-0.4055173993110657,
-0.3135784864425659,
-0.932054340839386,
-0.22063425183296204,
0.3489324748516083,
-0.42041441798210144,
0.14602714776992798,
0.6939617991447449,
-0.6357889175415039,
0.08264923095703125,
0.3590879738330841,
-0.3088919222354889,
0.6546671986579895,
0.21269491314888,
-0.14833924174308777,
-1.080019235610962,
-0.1719369888305664,
0.11447926610708237,
-0.12542986869812012,
-0.891877293586731,
0.22430935502052307,
-0.1937115341424942,
-0.20990392565727234,
-0.5451919436454773,
0.6667821407318115,
-0.2195967137813568,
0.22983750700950623,
-0.27623024582862854,
0.43168753385543823,
-0.0018978603184223175,
0.3514135479927063,
-0.2490232288837433,
0.3642597496509552,
0.6152080297470093,
-0.523489236831665,
0.5669057369232178,
0.16843633353710175,
-0.19022633135318756,
0.32378727197647095,
-0.449487566947937,
0.5288470387458801,
-0.4037959575653076,
0.4915718138217926,
-0.7161039710044861,
-0.3456355333328247,
0.3597203493118286,
-0.46347227692604065,
0.4642983078956604,
-0.2768959701061249,
-0.42065924406051636,
-0.43403080105781555,
-0.4230707585811615,
0.23938412964344025,
0.3498299717903137,
-0.7621909976005554,
0.5489673018455505,
0.7834733128547668,
0.06817116588354111,
-0.943742573261261,
-0.35198065638542175,
0.020471904426813126,
-0.38502421975135803,
-0.7899925708770752,
-0.17756079137325287,
0.10025209188461304,
-0.6057471632957458,
-0.06411419063806534,
0.11137185990810394,
0.2716657519340515,
0.2449510395526886,
0.05556260421872139,
0.324925035238266,
0.06721313297748566,
-0.17542020976543427,
-0.0813547819852829,
-0.06396488845348358,
0.4651137590408325,
-0.541070282459259,
0.7495248913764954,
0.1818324774503708,
-0.34187304973602295,
0.08929935097694397,
0.09681026637554169,
0.6039164662361145,
-0.0664023756980896,
0.7934510111808777,
0.5462616086006165,
-0.4231173098087311,
-0.2819873094558716,
-0.47229763865470886,
-0.31299060583114624,
-0.5423477292060852,
0.8349025845527649,
0.06814433634281158,
-0.9731937646865845,
0.22854596376419067,
0.003768639173358679,
0.12608645856380463,
0.21599076688289642,
0.604320764541626,
0.2360817790031433,
1.3719382286071777,
0.3517031967639923,
-0.7444426417350769,
0.4455026090145111,
-0.004611114505678415,
0.40894022583961487,
-0.6503263115882874,
-0.04902632534503937,
-0.43287765979766846,
-0.011469274759292603,
-0.5250371098518372,
-0.3558942973613739,
0.5187073349952698,
-0.027908720076084137,
-0.4038732945919037,
-0.0036945960018783808,
-0.4109816551208496,
0.5005158185958862,
0.6269594430923462,
0.28474941849708557,
-0.10293307900428772,
0.08148367702960968,
-0.26972997188568115,
0.17974285781383514,
-0.7955542206764221,
-0.4252583086490631,
1.5154331922531128,
0.42940983176231384,
0.952058732509613,
-0.032880187034606934,
0.5193920135498047,
0.376825749874115,
0.46462419629096985,
-0.4305579960346222,
0.653950572013855,
-0.11294408142566681,
-0.785936176776886,
-0.3330330550670624,
-0.507643461227417,
-0.5441170930862427,
0.1153099462389946,
-0.10383373498916626,
-0.7053169012069702,
-0.29929813742637634,
0.5074511766433716,
-0.04051873832941055,
0.6628357768058777,
-0.7495214939117432,
0.6409636735916138,
-0.31472623348236084,
-0.2579459547996521,
-0.0317053496837616,
-0.5365467667579651,
0.7943593859672546,
0.08316420763731003,
0.34462788701057434,
0.06888382881879807,
0.44146856665611267,
0.8310286402702332,
-0.2633045017719269,
1.1812403202056885,
-0.46698203682899475,
-0.10960543155670166,
0.24349676072597504,
0.21370625495910645,
1.0321098566055298,
-0.16664394736289978,
-0.09342507272958755,
0.0892588198184967,
-0.5781337022781372,
-0.6216822862625122,
-0.5493760704994202,
0.6943820118904114,
-0.9728253483772278,
-0.7758437395095825,
-0.16080959141254425,
-0.8148441910743713,
-0.41970622539520264,
0.26731520891189575,
0.1365342140197754,
0.15313580632209778,
-0.4588649272918701,
-0.30304011702537537,
0.8148437142372131,
-0.5907942652702332,
0.0401373989880085,
0.24743719398975372,
-0.14063739776611328,
-0.5493786931037903,
0.7406185269355774,
-0.035926930606365204,
0.6850749850273132,
-0.02796054445207119,
0.12509021162986755,
-0.24997982382774353,
-0.444192111492157,
-0.19981050491333008,
0.016697833314538002,
-0.7757656574249268,
-0.1538955420255661,
-0.7941164970397949,
-0.30712559819221497,
-0.957523763179779,
-0.3081355392932892,
-0.293057382106781,
-0.31040453910827637,
0.16725243628025055,
-0.40488573908805847,
0.44878295063972473,
0.9343302845954895,
-0.031061995774507523,
0.35038429498672485,
-0.1845591962337494,
0.21077510714530945,
0.44341668486595154,
0.19677062332630157,
0.08675041794776917,
-0.16541239619255066,
-0.18729408085346222,
0.1269594430923462,
-0.2644508183002472,
-0.9674309492111206,
0.38657599687576294,
-0.42167097330093384,
0.6215607523918152,
0.5548236966133118,
0.3152342736721039,
0.1442328244447708,
-0.6003606915473938,
0.5268462896347046,
0.27079516649246216,
-0.5369604229927063,
0.4783455431461334,
-0.5519863367080688,
0.05506729334592819,
0.06099759042263031,
0.27629461884498596,
-0.3434932827949524,
-0.7112373113632202,
-0.7582592368125916,
-0.8452339172363281,
0.5944046378135681,
-0.00025272913626395166,
0.07150492072105408,
-0.13250789046287537,
0.3660725951194763,
-0.27668702602386475,
0.1582336574792862,
-0.7643479704856873,
-0.3511461615562439,
-0.4171781837940216,
-0.2328988015651703,
0.019076494500041008,
-0.3198842406272888,
-0.5320214629173279,
0.08695466071367264,
0.925250232219696,
-0.2719026207923889,
0.04919758811593056,
-0.08211823552846909,
-0.10443367809057236,
-0.035640817135572433,
0.22881318628787994,
0.22526352107524872,
0.08169291168451309,
-0.06509086489677429,
0.564099907875061,
0.2691751718521118,
-0.45961377024650574,
0.09290264546871185,
0.21914350986480713,
-0.5369546413421631,
-0.3705838918685913,
0.31052106618881226,
0.6947678327560425,
-0.2308620661497116,
-0.355733722448349,
0.3209686279296875,
0.10996268689632416,
-0.0958552286028862,
-0.19534966349601746,
0.16896174848079681,
0.05174523591995239,
0.2640146017074585,
0.00943192932754755,
0.08122199028730392,
-0.2705066502094269,
-0.32817578315734863,
0.26532167196273804,
0.9483410716056824,
-0.5829361081123352,
-0.16898396611213684,
0.7308722138404846,
0.3053393065929413,
-0.19969648122787476,
0.23250029981136322,
-0.29553377628326416,
-1.02325439453125,
0.569584310054779,
0.5456491708755493,
0.844449520111084,
-0.27477550506591797,
0.1646009385585785,
0.27544569969177246,
0.7981237173080444,
0.16684362292289734,
-0.22784167528152466,
0.37763017416000366,
-1.1657299995422363,
-0.1850602775812149,
-0.5169166922569275,
-0.18837517499923706,
0.4153803586959839,
-0.2712966799736023,
0.09369003772735596,
-0.7138030529022217,
-0.10703213512897491,
-0.08632460236549377,
-0.1802307367324829,
-0.3697212338447571,
0.04232809692621231,
0.23899981379508972,
0.7199681997299194,
-1.0334604978561401,
0.8125113844871521,
0.5361090302467346,
-0.280988872051239,
-0.6400241255760193,
0.22303298115730286,
0.2982288897037506,
-0.9194791316986084,
0.7252861261367798,
-0.12932462990283966,
-0.1346796303987503,
-0.08220132440328598,
-0.9069823622703552,
-0.7713279128074646,
0.6043561100959778,
0.6015045046806335,
-0.1633022278547287,
-0.12945222854614258,
0.32947349548339844,
0.3000698685646057,
-0.22808688879013062,
0.10694357752799988,
0.5852404236793518,
0.4673624038696289,
-0.3977194130420685,
-0.38893234729766846,
0.3051362931728363,
-0.17414461076259613,
-0.1366102695465088,
0.16135497391223907,
-0.6607056260108948,
0.48595985770225525,
-0.0995749980211258,
0.10628717392683029,
-0.434371680021286,
0.5346417427062988,
0.3506031036376953,
0.019981708377599716,
0.6502805352210999,
0.6241281032562256,
0.7597349286079407,
0.06630439311265945,
1.0655012130737305,
-0.42191264033317566,
0.08378966152667999,
0.9549160003662109,
-0.379011869430542,
0.06741560250520706,
0.3600304424762726,
-0.004472694825381041,
0.18025840818881989,
0.2497503161430359,
0.2448604851961136,
0.482390820980072,
0.19406665861606598,
-0.3583337664604187,
-0.14343507587909698,
-0.20453856885433197,
-0.32092949748039246,
0.028480425477027893,
0.3308178186416626,
-0.4043876826763153,
-0.25091618299484253,
-0.02565244399011135,
0.7469965815544128,
0.1484818011522293,
-0.21518217027187347,
0.6906668543815613,
-0.036611005663871765,
-0.5634493231773376,
0.45566633343696594,
-0.06451047956943512,
0.5627435445785522,
-0.5814312100410461,
0.22536002099514008,
-0.1180499866604805,
0.38789403438568115,
0.03306329622864723,
-0.4403764307498932,
0.09821661561727524,
0.16527175903320312,
-0.13334912061691284,
-0.06777465343475342,
1.0258734226226807,
-0.2873938977718353,
-0.47996506094932556,
0.6050617694854736,
0.24586065113544464,
-0.2809496223926544,
0.05267288535833359,
-0.6314370632171631,
-0.20496200025081635,
0.19559116661548615,
-0.30239060521125793,
0.6087977290153503,
0.2661409080028534,
-0.016795305535197258,
0.7534283399581909,
0.6501573324203491,
0.17663323879241943,
0.33482494950294495,
0.1530897319316864,
1.1647658348083496,
-0.2861988842487335,
-0.5040856599807739,
-0.9494059681892395,
0.159591943025589,
-0.42523863911628723,
0.2151152342557907,
1.0345983505249023,
0.4119487404823303,
0.8672559857368469,
0.14290833473205566,
1.3808939456939697,
-0.042275018990039825,
0.3558310866355896,
-0.541010320186615,
0.9874057769775391,
-0.12712247669696808,
0.3028920888900757,
-0.6524237394332886,
-0.5125130414962769,
-0.16635246574878693,
0.21915006637573242,
-0.7004523873329163,
0.052610378712415695,
0.419403076171875,
1.054732084274292,
0.1278187483549118,
-0.0635160580277443,
0.13917383551597595,
0.7380678057670593,
0.6213585138320923,
0.4817548990249634,
0.7691349983215332,
-0.20799832046031952,
0.8384291529655457,
-0.31192338466644287,
-0.3454837203025818,
-0.0045418087393045425,
-0.6857318878173828,
-1.3137081861495972,
-0.05439388379454613,
-0.2263791263103485,
-1.0229127407073975,
0.5663564205169678,
0.6338364481925964,
0.4717392027378082,
-0.690097451210022,
0.06523139774799347,
-0.12450767308473587,
0.44119951128959656,
0.2401343435049057,
-0.2770555317401886,
0.4535595774650574,
-0.42136526107788086,
-0.5321806073188782,
0.44523075222969055,
-0.06292746961116791,
-0.07237925380468369,
-0.6367824077606201,
-0.25260233879089355,
-0.1383305788040161,
0.08049793541431427,
0.342843234539032,
0.1570429801940918,
-0.517666220664978,
-0.5736698508262634,
-0.1783932000398636,
-0.07730306684970856,
-0.25941112637519836,
0.7400652170181274,
-0.5693076848983765,
0.4822289049625397,
0.5012063384056091,
0.6124104261398315,
0.20308133959770203,
-0.11347681283950806,
0.9706979990005493,
-0.9081379771232605,
0.41413405537605286,
0.09423237293958664,
0.4451259970664978,
0.36557886004447937,
-0.5406951308250427,
0.3522593379020691,
0.4235130846500397,
-0.41166579723358154,
-0.9139717817306519,
0.5920475721359253,
-0.2783883810043335,
-0.3680564761161804,
1.4211690425872803,
-0.03238220512866974,
-0.37733224034309387,
-0.2631789743900299,
-0.19127978384494781,
0.5954198837280273,
-0.31006041169166565,
1.0834205150604248,
0.5493991374969482,
0.21132664382457733,
0.3156904876232147,
-0.5654719471931458,
0.770115315914154,
0.2621326148509979,
-0.7586618661880493,
0.22738763689994812,
0.5284801721572876,
0.36956721544265747,
0.1305212825536728,
0.46447595953941345,
-0.19019286334514618,
0.013823607005178928,
0.1678488701581955,
0.2733789384365082,
-0.1369854360818863,
-0.10869248956441879,
-0.06575238704681396,
0.2727363705635071,
0.005061948671936989,
0.02679748274385929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04726v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04726v1
|
Learning Phonotactics from Linguistic Informants
| 2024-05-08T00:18:56 | 2024-05-08T00:18:56 |
Canaan Breiss, Alexis Ross, Amani Maina-Kilaas, Roger Levy, Jacob Andreas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose an interactive approach to language learning that utilizes
linguistic acceptability judgments from an informant (a competent language
user) to learn a grammar. Given a grammar formalism and a framework for
synthesizing data, our model iteratively selects or synthesizes a data-point
according to one of a range of information-theoretic policies, asks the
informant for a binary judgment, and updates its own parameters in preparation
for the next query. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our model in the domain
of phonotactics, the rules governing what kinds of sound-sequences are
acceptable in a language, and carry out two experiments, one with
typologically-natural linguistic data and another with a range of
procedurally-generated languages. We find that the information-theoretic
policies that our model uses to select items to query the informant achieve
sample efficiency comparable to, and sometimes greater than, fully supervised
approaches.
|
[
-0.21609090268611908,
-0.736537754535675,
0.8090426325798035,
0.09703807532787323,
-0.1733710765838623,
-0.12543222308158875,
-0.6504380106925964,
-0.5134933590888977,
0.2199079841375351,
0.334136039018631,
-0.34303298592567444,
-0.605553150177002,
-0.4815528988838196,
-0.018600013107061386,
-0.24394762516021729,
0.5992432236671448,
0.26041942834854126,
0.1262059509754181,
0.3248326778411865,
0.06129400059580803,
-0.20473678410053253,
-0.3326573669910431,
-0.5502504110336304,
-0.14538785815238953,
0.32432854175567627,
0.5768370628356934,
0.9014897346496582,
0.8953028321266174,
-0.07922551035881042,
0.3579117953777313,
-0.09839055687189102,
0.17013143002986908,
-0.21761250495910645,
0.41285282373428345,
-0.371615469455719,
-0.614361584186554,
0.20196200907230377,
0.11329870671033859,
0.582027792930603,
1.0955408811569214,
-0.46890392899513245,
0.008554751984775066,
-0.11646918952465057,
0.2913203239440918,
-0.4301244020462036,
0.6453021764755249,
-0.6607120633125305,
0.1160179153084755,
-0.17123696208000183,
-0.22029951214790344,
-0.8207854628562927,
-0.6763631701469421,
0.3798544704914093,
-0.8943620920181274,
-0.1570242941379547,
-0.25429871678352356,
0.4582805931568146,
-0.14799785614013672,
-0.20027655363082886,
-0.7363896369934082,
-0.7595838904380798,
0.5705226063728333,
-0.4778626263141632,
0.7636022567749023,
1.1120527982711792,
0.35751453042030334,
-0.15250572562217712,
-0.6872366070747375,
-0.47243812680244446,
-0.4491095244884491,
-0.2156173437833786,
0.006141825579106808,
0.17036780714988708,
0.10440738499164581,
0.25244373083114624,
0.3828713893890381,
-0.40650883316993713,
-0.13294194638729095,
-0.39853858947753906,
-0.047564201056957245,
0.4030625522136688,
-0.028950508683919907,
0.37423598766326904,
-0.3867080509662628,
0.1164775937795639,
-0.033070679754018784,
-0.41526591777801514,
0.18309302628040314,
0.5502150058746338,
0.9470412135124207,
-0.10745254904031754,
0.6834532618522644,
-0.2185458391904831,
0.9971417784690857,
0.2780402600765228,
-0.3537648618221283,
0.25148728489875793,
-0.3287949562072754,
0.1516387015581131,
0.08344238996505737,
0.5428886413574219,
-0.019096488133072853,
0.4841662347316742,
-0.25021252036094666,
-0.10842154920101166,
-0.18879394233226776,
0.31430891156196594,
-0.4076858162879944,
-0.3379606604576111,
0.2271776646375656,
-0.39193016290664673,
-0.1143994852900505,
0.23264698684215546,
-0.6525933146476746,
-0.08422058820724487,
-0.6705768704414368,
0.320004403591156,
-0.8839617371559143,
-0.4076492190361023,
0.0779763013124466,
-0.05743705853819847,
0.24572435021400452,
0.09202059358358383,
-1.4502075910568237,
0.4556591212749481,
0.5072625875473022,
0.6394127011299133,
0.19038636982440948,
-0.6569303870201111,
-0.7922718524932861,
0.20798227190971375,
-0.36287811398506165,
0.609091579914093,
-0.8407281637191772,
-0.7674165368080139,
0.22901000082492828,
-0.2516580820083618,
-0.1500241607427597,
-0.6840750575065613,
0.1478094458580017,
-0.358245313167572,
0.1665094792842865,
-0.17771048843860626,
-0.4614598751068115,
-0.06867664307355881,
-0.12025586515665054,
-0.7634525299072266,
1.0349596738815308,
0.6990630030632019,
-0.2749961316585541,
0.6797464489936829,
-0.19781054556369781,
-0.5736644864082336,
0.04422282055020332,
-0.3286384046077728,
-0.12378603219985962,
0.18659158051013947,
-0.2683408558368683,
0.12290031462907791,
0.2592930197715759,
0.5596097111701965,
-0.12222464382648468,
-0.19036436080932617,
0.28783220052719116,
-0.16081982851028442,
1.0810225009918213,
0.26117703318595886,
-0.2776186168193817,
-0.13860014081001282,
-0.955990195274353,
0.11614757031202316,
-0.17045234143733978,
-0.7584937810897827,
-0.25763195753097534,
0.025054937228560448,
-0.22390113770961761,
0.08855782449245453,
-0.17316080629825592,
-0.37691083550453186,
0.29047706723213196,
-0.6140736937522888,
0.29928848147392273,
0.5625513195991516,
0.10932568460702896,
0.753387987613678,
-0.3339196741580963,
0.20913152396678925,
-0.4373553991317749,
0.16550439596176147,
-0.2826496362686157,
-0.20780514180660248,
-0.6042026281356812,
-0.3573632538318634,
0.406390517950058,
0.48477208614349365,
-0.6922435164451599,
0.40241071581840515,
0.3500664532184601,
-0.2933400571346283,
-0.679226815700531,
0.21739304065704346,
0.39121130108833313,
0.37245890498161316,
0.2615760266780853,
-0.31392353773117065,
-0.7097451090812683,
-0.4881255328655243,
-0.26723021268844604,
-0.8068750500679016,
-0.09495888650417328,
0.36872437596321106,
-0.064901202917099,
0.25553780794143677,
0.822539746761322,
-0.1672036200761795,
-0.05703279748558998,
-0.15144717693328857,
0.24903930723667145,
0.2726922333240509,
0.3655615448951721,
0.5638906359672546,
-0.728981614112854,
-0.4673030972480774,
-0.05663251504302025,
-0.7343285083770752,
-0.10971330851316452,
0.2735553979873657,
-0.06620583683252335,
0.20032010972499847,
0.4634379744529724,
-0.8358255624771118,
0.3182094991207123,
0.14539660513401031,
-0.4842633605003357,
0.4103037714958191,
-0.016040749847888947,
0.007668815553188324,
-0.9288736581802368,
-0.2530260384082794,
-0.1597127616405487,
-0.3579980432987213,
-0.8326720595359802,
0.3799894452095032,
-0.3280884325504303,
-0.05606546252965927,
-0.5709280371665955,
0.27843979001045227,
-0.3478516936302185,
-0.22017350792884827,
-0.036431003361940384,
0.035457778722047806,
-0.1822938621044159,
0.5348900556564331,
0.5001014471054077,
0.43674376606941223,
0.5629348158836365,
-0.793998658657074,
0.23446962237358093,
0.2558923661708832,
-0.5429930090904236,
0.6060124635696411,
-0.22188958525657654,
0.03991398587822914,
-0.22314749658107758,
-0.1497025489807129,
-0.824393630027771,
-0.33012840151786804,
0.4185466766357422,
-0.584027111530304,
0.41169092059135437,
-0.2628811299800873,
-0.2278229147195816,
0.3255525231361389,
0.0990964025259018,
0.4485648572444916,
0.5071851015090942,
-0.6609103083610535,
0.9890227317810059,
0.6554712057113647,
-0.3363890051841736,
-0.383137047290802,
-0.4437845051288605,
-0.2574481964111328,
-0.09909915179014206,
-0.08770179748535156,
0.034567493945360184,
-0.19284053146839142,
-0.8450395464897156,
0.051243364810943604,
0.1412534862756729,
-0.30242595076560974,
0.09023777395486832,
0.07582557201385498,
-0.06680124253034592,
-0.14623819291591644,
0.25478941202163696,
-0.3114932179450989,
-0.13798505067825317,
0.05080871656537056,
-0.6133893728256226,
0.503409743309021,
0.03405838459730148,
-0.330889493227005,
-0.26876547932624817,
0.35367998480796814,
0.23176386952400208,
-0.20387575030326843,
0.32589027285575867,
0.12323500961065292,
-0.3545669615268707,
-0.48272743821144104,
-0.26115745306015015,
-0.23450703918933868,
-0.4233706593513489,
-0.025657087564468384,
-0.5620988607406616,
-0.5635671019554138,
0.25117242336273193,
0.21738576889038086,
0.04006687179207802,
0.001801098114810884,
0.6262139678001404,
0.01940816082060337,
0.7387036681175232,
0.5468201637268066,
0.23636499047279358,
0.7119958996772766,
-0.13661091029644012,
-0.08222624659538269,
-0.20062237977981567,
-0.44858965277671814,
-0.681786060333252,
0.3688633143901825,
-0.6494307518005371,
-0.330416202545166,
0.2013038694858551,
-0.05963394418358803,
-0.03729173168540001,
0.368425190448761,
-0.04054594784975052,
0.47449642419815063,
0.8824836015701294,
0.423657089471817,
0.48201632499694824,
-0.12327873706817627,
-0.40173324942588806,
0.003141459310427308,
-0.5294915437698364,
-0.30334678292274475,
0.8472685813903809,
0.02681201696395874,
0.5870531797409058,
0.5017672181129456,
0.6562348008155823,
0.11385344713926315,
0.03403041884303093,
-1.116284966468811,
0.30800148844718933,
0.1329987645149231,
-0.3542635440826416,
-0.541893482208252,
-0.39636367559432983,
-0.6823077201843262,
0.3665526807308197,
-0.29186248779296875,
-0.7975671887397766,
0.4289403259754181,
0.30755725502967834,
-0.08214881271123886,
-0.04678011313080788,
-0.8270003795623779,
0.5986832976341248,
-0.14958272874355316,
-0.41448184847831726,
0.032950203865766525,
-0.6903862953186035,
0.11541902273893356,
0.013610887341201305,
0.3973968029022217,
-0.046054307371377945,
0.04137555882334709,
0.3154805302619934,
-0.6446830034255981,
0.9429001808166504,
-0.4869811236858368,
0.14202246069908142,
0.608955979347229,
0.5179646611213684,
0.18336427211761475,
0.2099187970161438,
-0.42476341128349304,
-0.1757918894290924,
-0.22606708109378815,
-0.30693843960762024,
-0.8689841032028198,
0.08269330114126205,
-0.6362292766571045,
-0.4296688437461853,
-0.2606334090232849,
-0.4762345552444458,
-0.40088939666748047,
0.3941457271575928,
0.2383837252855301,
0.687904417514801,
-0.32308429479599,
-0.05052271857857704,
0.535885214805603,
0.06611212342977524,
0.2960927486419678,
0.993901252746582,
-0.3132227659225464,
-0.11918803304433823,
0.923858642578125,
0.3054967522621155,
0.39317330718040466,
0.536760687828064,
0.42913010716438293,
-0.2763102650642395,
-0.658513069152832,
-0.28012752532958984,
0.2649736702442169,
-0.774174690246582,
0.11181194335222244,
-0.324696809053421,
-0.018768392503261566,
-0.24463880062103271,
0.10334741324186325,
-0.24068604409694672,
-0.5706168413162231,
-0.16388021409511566,
-0.5339395999908447,
0.3737507462501526,
0.8630026578903198,
-0.30394840240478516,
0.28679928183555603,
-0.4709673225879669,
0.3142644166946411,
0.41922885179519653,
0.5074405074119568,
-0.2829897105693817,
-0.5871601104736328,
0.02763770893216133,
0.05863345041871071,
0.16191816329956055,
-0.9258213043212891,
0.19588816165924072,
0.44938594102859497,
0.7940620183944702,
0.25352418422698975,
0.0032990206964313984,
0.44243866205215454,
-0.719206690788269,
0.591513991355896,
-0.2651558518409729,
-1.2171380519866943,
0.618267834186554,
-0.5072612166404724,
0.21672073006629944,
0.9725009202957153,
0.6254903078079224,
-0.4358089864253998,
-0.8445360064506531,
-0.6546144485473633,
-0.8340267539024353,
0.7215374708175659,
-0.058087944984436035,
0.01960182376205921,
-0.4034412205219269,
0.4484860897064209,
0.36547455191612244,
0.360453724861145,
-0.5956816673278809,
0.052846986800432205,
-0.3511492908000946,
-0.38753947615623474,
0.044754065573215485,
-0.24795110523700714,
0.23686076700687408,
-0.0979856550693512,
0.6659529805183411,
-0.15616174042224884,
-0.08142264187335968,
0.07194501906633377,
-0.43454986810684204,
-0.09213508665561676,
0.13659846782684326,
0.2549554705619812,
1.191884160041809,
-0.3485768437385559,
0.4029054045677185,
-0.27422353625297546,
-0.4180698096752167,
0.06496629863977432,
0.147367462515831,
-0.4192485809326172,
0.19955331087112427,
0.5101693272590637,
0.6735696196556091,
0.6543718576431274,
-0.7391798496246338,
0.5069395899772644,
-0.13460271060466766,
-0.3111550509929657,
-0.5080153942108154,
0.04413418471813202,
-0.12255047261714935,
0.22080355882644653,
0.14806774258613586,
-0.35642173886299133,
0.2866993248462677,
-1.010888695716858,
0.6573054790496826,
0.10473009198904037,
-0.3977724015712738,
-0.4583452343940735,
0.3472386598587036,
-0.0020142619032412767,
-0.7392907738685608,
0.8226422071456909,
-0.20952367782592773,
-0.21379120647907257,
0.29883429408073425,
0.6140086054801941,
0.5290588140487671,
-0.8671387434005737,
0.4734075367450714,
0.39170145988464355,
0.1708260327577591,
-0.0859372690320015,
0.5093973875045776,
-0.5045671463012695,
-0.7898969650268555,
-0.2847941517829895,
-0.5199078321456909,
-0.7461183071136475,
-0.06625758856534958,
-0.9594417810440063,
0.3047349154949188,
-0.4627397656440735,
0.07367247343063354,
0.22403313219547272,
-0.28589126467704773,
-0.47393372654914856,
-0.06318454444408417,
-0.16605448722839355,
0.9162627458572388,
-1.0416592359542847,
0.659887433052063,
0.41435471177101135,
-0.6994874477386475,
-1.2018263339996338,
-0.04479038342833519,
0.018585622310638428,
-1.045127511024475,
0.43263110518455505,
-0.19308772683143616,
0.011653811670839787,
-0.0498536042869091,
-0.30716368556022644,
-0.7445604205131531,
0.5352889895439148,
0.557863175868988,
-0.0403670035302639,
-0.1633717119693756,
-0.04783911630511284,
0.5260939598083496,
-0.30405354499816895,
0.4252963066101074,
0.8991501331329346,
0.5074142217636108,
0.12071677297353745,
-1.0189908742904663,
-0.2742154896259308,
-0.3124390244483948,
-0.2621457874774933,
0.19936726987361908,
-0.37289735674858093,
0.9632745385169983,
-0.13598893582820892,
-0.21495401859283447,
0.12544092535972595,
0.6173904538154602,
0.18378107249736786,
0.14990808069705963,
0.5871575474739075,
0.33189886808395386,
0.9619631171226501,
0.0037956482265144587,
1.0970038175582886,
-0.20736895501613617,
0.08626317977905273,
1.253233790397644,
-0.24796520173549652,
0.893667995929718,
0.4624871611595154,
-0.19942307472229004,
0.5072610974311829,
0.7297617793083191,
0.2980676293373108,
0.6682460308074951,
0.115626260638237,
-0.4515911042690277,
-0.10307799279689789,
-0.5431350469589233,
0.14608898758888245,
0.9392951130867004,
0.5543208122253418,
-0.3812725245952606,
-0.31492137908935547,
0.03276937082409859,
-0.01608722284436226,
0.5548752546310425,
-0.3718947172164917,
1.0893912315368652,
0.05359888821840286,
-0.9311766028404236,
0.49316710233688354,
-0.052636001259088516,
-0.04373784735798836,
-0.7037214636802673,
-0.4844190776348114,
-0.01253771036863327,
-0.15742433071136475,
-0.28538984060287476,
-0.7240853905677795,
0.3285791277885437,
-0.24491088092327118,
-0.21068774163722992,
-0.05648430064320564,
0.4501756429672241,
-0.9480909705162048,
-0.24412210285663605,
0.2820017337799072,
0.5994279384613037,
0.3381236493587494,
0.49055251479148865,
-0.2897985279560089,
0.05571299046278,
-0.18350467085838318,
-0.14139002561569214,
0.15873514115810394,
0.3940313756465912,
0.016703201457858086,
0.2822086215019226,
0.43427881598472595,
0.480268657207489,
0.06999585032463074,
0.24354754388332367,
0.7334698438644409,
-0.5320982336997986,
-0.8645962476730347,
-0.643037736415863,
0.301876038312912,
0.16989769041538239,
-0.08372960239648819,
0.6701580286026001,
0.43002989888191223,
1.3584939241409302,
0.1614474058151245,
0.9436187148094177,
0.02489505708217621,
0.7530671954154968,
-1.033660888671875,
-0.02501261606812477,
0.1390722692012787,
0.10663088411092758,
-0.11369747668504715,
-0.9341080784797668,
-0.1934010088443756,
1.0806238651275635,
-0.26751941442489624,
0.22761055827140808,
0.6748379468917847,
0.614690363407135,
-0.1303098052740097,
0.22556938230991364,
0.15299847722053528,
0.23862077295780182,
0.06756521016359329,
0.3758506178855896,
0.965578556060791,
0.13033927977085114,
0.33466070890426636,
-0.4880545139312744,
-0.33856070041656494,
0.057049114257097244,
-0.7318459749221802,
-0.7348313331604004,
-0.722146213054657,
0.17634250223636627,
-0.46237441897392273,
0.2635939121246338,
1.3578513860702515,
0.7170423269271851,
-0.5148661732673645,
-0.72529137134552,
-0.04585370421409607,
0.2750263810157776,
-0.1301324963569641,
-0.2579447627067566,
0.23773281276226044,
-0.46292808651924133,
-0.9275186061859131,
0.709848165512085,
0.059563446789979935,
-0.055437784641981125,
-0.07199682295322418,
-0.001749698189087212,
-0.25715672969818115,
-0.01623404026031494,
0.6020638346672058,
0.7161971926689148,
-0.5198019742965698,
-0.5349836349487305,
-0.130390465259552,
0.055908240377902985,
0.09983966499567032,
1.1428247690200806,
-0.6798547506332397,
0.8283284902572632,
0.3345857560634613,
0.57886803150177,
0.4413841962814331,
0.16449588537216187,
0.796908974647522,
-0.8546844124794006,
0.4413871169090271,
0.26998424530029297,
0.20285283029079437,
0.20901049673557281,
-0.3121332824230194,
0.40429580211639404,
0.14295193552970886,
-0.23466451466083527,
-0.7826430797576904,
0.5598922967910767,
-0.6516035199165344,
-0.28809821605682373,
1.1444615125656128,
-0.12426012009382248,
-0.3813970685005188,
-0.45182710886001587,
-0.13751886785030365,
0.16148877143859863,
-0.4575081169605255,
0.5482940077781677,
0.6234972476959229,
-0.13341926038265228,
-0.09949713200330734,
-0.32724452018737793,
0.7365195751190186,
-0.06772759556770325,
-0.5306447744369507,
0.09349936991930008,
0.6472555994987488,
0.17124564945697784,
0.09242767095565796,
1.0939629077911377,
-0.1953066885471344,
0.5583678483963013,
0.15506188571453094,
-0.14972513914108276,
-0.1271115243434906,
-0.6968661546707153,
-0.5592262744903564,
0.06411857157945633,
0.8539543747901917,
0.10616367310285568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04685v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04685v1
|
Bridging the Bosphorus: Advancing Turkish Large Language Models through Strategies for Low-Resource Language Adaptation and Benchmarking
| 2024-05-07T21:58:45 | 2024-05-07T21:58:45 |
Emre Can Acikgoz, Mete Erdogan, Deniz Yuret
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are becoming crucial across various fields,
emphasizing the urgency for high-quality models in underrepresented languages.
This study explores the unique challenges faced by low-resource languages, such
as data scarcity, model selection, evaluation, and computational limitations,
with a special focus on Turkish. We conduct an in-depth analysis to evaluate
the impact of training strategies, model choices, and data availability on the
performance of LLMs designed for underrepresented languages. Our approach
includes two methodologies: (i) adapting existing LLMs originally pretrained in
English to understand Turkish, and (ii) developing a model from the ground up
using Turkish pretraining data, both supplemented with supervised fine-tuning
on a novel Turkish instruction-tuning dataset aimed at enhancing reasoning
capabilities. The relative performance of these methods is evaluated through
the creation of a new leaderboard for Turkish LLMs, featuring benchmarks that
assess different reasoning and knowledge skills. Furthermore, we conducted
experiments on data and model scaling, both during pretraining and fine-tuning,
simultaneously emphasizing the capacity for knowledge transfer across languages
and addressing the challenges of catastrophic forgetting encountered during
fine-tuning on a different language. Our goal is to offer a detailed guide for
advancing the LLM framework in low-resource linguistic contexts, thereby making
natural language processing (NLP) benefits more globally accessible.
|
[
-0.5329179167747498,
-0.6076033115386963,
0.38693127036094666,
0.13845700025558472,
-0.43655091524124146,
0.08603272587060928,
-0.6490699052810669,
-0.4355803430080414,
-0.39528703689575195,
0.47896072268486023,
-0.46225857734680176,
-0.37141409516334534,
-0.6946881413459778,
0.24741730093955994,
0.0688474103808403,
0.9085831046104431,
-0.22213703393936157,
0.03718503192067146,
-0.3225526213645935,
-0.349776029586792,
-0.7206920385360718,
-0.42748668789863586,
-0.5773484706878662,
-0.38289374113082886,
0.3954635560512543,
0.5994616746902466,
0.45086470246315,
0.47859400510787964,
0.5989259481430054,
0.18203246593475342,
-0.3908030092716217,
0.11691213399171829,
-0.37272998690605164,
-0.002086175139993429,
-0.6449205279350281,
-0.2818790674209595,
-0.2877347469329834,
-0.11621168255805969,
0.8171613812446594,
1.0731950998306274,
-0.22526143491268158,
0.6897695660591125,
0.39341118931770325,
0.7519409656524658,
-0.7950372695922852,
0.0356464684009552,
-0.693189799785614,
-0.19314448535442352,
-0.44724398851394653,
0.09820014238357544,
-0.0739138126373291,
-0.18471691012382507,
0.2861502766609192,
-0.32621464133262634,
-0.008794278837740421,
0.10029131174087524,
0.5490697622299194,
0.2060548961162567,
-0.384134441614151,
-0.29664790630340576,
-0.7767101526260376,
0.8126906156539917,
-0.7218611240386963,
0.3687012493610382,
0.34186825156211853,
0.32416027784347534,
-0.3503062427043915,
-0.5380931496620178,
-0.20755697786808014,
-0.09254789352416992,
0.07083471864461899,
-0.025415096431970596,
-0.13237743079662323,
-0.06028617173433304,
0.258468896150589,
0.5542644262313843,
-0.457744836807251,
0.3030779957771301,
-0.6154178380966187,
0.16642627120018005,
0.582903265953064,
0.10762082785367966,
-0.1545594483613968,
0.1347227245569229,
0.006587807554751635,
0.0644054040312767,
-0.6971743106842041,
0.26877859234809875,
0.13722562789916992,
0.6913836002349854,
-0.271038293838501,
0.5523603558540344,
-0.4080338478088379,
0.789226233959198,
-0.17003490030765533,
-0.060245923697948456,
-0.06525280326604843,
-0.21803416311740875,
-0.387015700340271,
0.11991147696971893,
0.39580658078193665,
-0.1668441742658615,
-0.03763873130083084,
-0.10191858559846878,
-0.18698909878730774,
-0.14586126804351807,
0.11149774491786957,
-0.6878963112831116,
0.06693647056818008,
0.006891264580190182,
-0.3965463936328888,
0.0333373136818409,
-0.349699467420578,
-0.6792738437652588,
-0.6698896884918213,
-0.17152416706085205,
0.5065678358078003,
-0.2579754590988159,
-0.22123531997203827,
0.3749009072780609,
0.13998523354530334,
0.20677471160888672,
0.40642204880714417,
-0.9643014073371887,
0.4492201507091522,
0.7275517582893372,
0.9055498838424683,
0.08386163413524628,
-0.15377558767795563,
-0.411975234746933,
0.14436151087284088,
-0.46531498432159424,
0.5685176253318787,
-0.5159729719161987,
-0.32531821727752686,
0.13332071900367737,
0.03442730754613876,
0.047144025564193726,
-0.5781553387641907,
0.9558265805244446,
-0.2139878123998642,
0.15032275021076202,
-0.5361958146095276,
-0.435505747795105,
-0.29886043071746826,
0.24427436292171478,
-0.639241635799408,
0.9784228801727295,
0.04430294781923294,
-0.878430962562561,
0.16685141623020172,
-0.4987819492816925,
-0.4756150543689728,
0.13548167049884796,
-0.10470866411924362,
-0.13502687215805054,
0.5358094573020935,
0.22945286333560944,
0.45973944664001465,
-0.6620832681655884,
-0.2646287977695465,
-0.2186744064092636,
-0.5479180812835693,
-0.14808203279972076,
-0.1654578149318695,
0.70147305727005,
0.2733631134033203,
-0.1050843596458435,
-0.18221479654312134,
-0.6587035059928894,
-0.2941361367702484,
0.1856692135334015,
-0.6235709190368652,
-0.3680838644504547,
0.1239972934126854,
-0.24778002500534058,
0.23555152118206024,
0.45376092195510864,
-0.4270378053188324,
0.12045872956514359,
-0.5072184801101685,
0.27146628499031067,
0.604265570640564,
-0.16938640177249908,
0.477571964263916,
-0.4689648747444153,
0.5130845904350281,
-0.034462250769138336,
-0.08232510834932327,
-0.13180804252624512,
-0.13445651531219482,
-0.9976884722709656,
-0.18444553017616272,
0.17780360579490662,
0.5727147459983826,
-0.3313274383544922,
0.1578335016965866,
-0.28467270731925964,
-0.6900716423988342,
-0.7769639492034912,
0.4716376066207886,
0.09110578894615173,
0.4782969057559967,
0.3185610771179199,
-0.25743725895881653,
-0.6402645111083984,
-0.7896599173545837,
-0.3244428038597107,
-0.08315759897232056,
-0.018227871507406235,
0.1729479730129242,
0.4490010440349579,
-0.017654255032539368,
0.5313514471054077,
0.14837080240249634,
-0.34181883931159973,
-0.6575137972831726,
-0.05593933165073395,
0.5858982801437378,
0.46032944321632385,
0.20853619277477264,
-0.1826406717300415,
-0.3731366991996765,
0.40802302956581116,
-0.5394237041473389,
-0.15310636162757874,
0.17461998760700226,
-0.10298154503107071,
0.5131365656852722,
0.4370444416999817,
-0.6047807931900024,
0.20487606525421143,
0.7485027313232422,
-0.12928996980190277,
0.6710832118988037,
-0.31653282046318054,
-0.03037749044597149,
-0.895252525806427,
0.1649155169725418,
0.13814929127693176,
0.08024774491786957,
-0.5235303640365601,
0.14680980145931244,
-0.3276214301586151,
-0.22081930935382843,
-0.2598448097705841,
0.6928359866142273,
-0.4974428117275238,
-0.181278258562088,
-0.21627533435821533,
-0.03978410363197327,
-0.10540788620710373,
0.22765754163265228,
0.12285956740379333,
0.6950188875198364,
0.48791059851646423,
-0.4365532100200653,
0.3034866750240326,
0.18636438250541687,
-0.7759444117546082,
0.4270631968975067,
-0.5442890524864197,
-0.02014479786157608,
-0.025911975651979446,
0.025654496625065804,
-0.6595257520675659,
0.07272134721279144,
0.0671439841389656,
-0.05597388371825218,
0.13830743730068207,
-0.4794636070728302,
-0.5376225709915161,
-0.1959044486284256,
0.19522066414356232,
0.4174222946166992,
0.5563942193984985,
-0.35136574506759644,
0.6247532963752747,
0.09641735255718231,
-0.5057247877120972,
-0.49651476740837097,
-0.6105413436889648,
-0.023266857489943504,
-0.48008403182029724,
-0.6174399256706238,
0.11214082688093185,
0.3355973958969116,
-0.4159278869628906,
-0.2792082130908966,
-0.3422447144985199,
0.06773221492767334,
0.3573543429374695,
0.05772612988948822,
0.0024599889293313026,
-0.4245176613330841,
0.1250990927219391,
0.13367077708244324,
0.10260310024023056,
0.1444479525089264,
-0.5914889574050903,
0.4265691339969635,
-0.438962459564209,
-0.31328803300857544,
-0.3548767864704132,
0.11917299032211304,
0.3591543138027191,
-0.5623279213905334,
0.9105233550071716,
0.6008630990982056,
-0.4445711374282837,
-0.26481589674949646,
-0.6405452489852905,
-0.12578879296779633,
-0.45756301283836365,
0.5289117097854614,
-0.3951895534992218,
-0.9622346758842468,
0.5001690983772278,
-0.44915860891342163,
0.33743855357170105,
0.007095972541719675,
0.765884280204773,
-0.39709803462028503,
0.6129894852638245,
0.8644161820411682,
-0.11260844022035599,
0.30068325996398926,
0.0057342443615198135,
0.21119478344917297,
-0.5989143252372742,
-0.06349918991327286,
-0.6062369346618652,
-0.2413076013326645,
-0.7042489647865295,
-0.5099470019340515,
0.24165530502796173,
0.4034569263458252,
-0.3768458068370819,
0.08847662061452866,
0.09533592313528061,
0.2890406548976898,
0.5478147864341736,
-0.03982505202293396,
0.327421635389328,
0.35200947523117065,
-0.18953447043895721,
0.033310599625110626,
-0.9022745490074158,
-0.7669107913970947,
0.9870384335517883,
0.43661433458328247,
0.6687120795249939,
0.19557900726795197,
0.4520297646522522,
0.21906636655330658,
-0.10601402819156647,
-0.38576310873031616,
0.49876677989959717,
-0.265031635761261,
-0.5778287053108215,
-0.4660830497741699,
-0.305706262588501,
-0.8767797946929932,
0.460357666015625,
-0.472125768661499,
-0.7772560715675354,
-0.1331295520067215,
0.11835630238056183,
-0.29644301533699036,
0.3379805386066437,
-0.5557280778884888,
1.021859884262085,
-0.18694435060024261,
-0.6400901675224304,
-0.657922089099884,
-0.2905491292476654,
0.1928723156452179,
-0.2317226380109787,
0.48353293538093567,
-0.19938650727272034,
0.08597909659147263,
0.6945032477378845,
-0.14993351697921753,
0.5966294407844543,
-0.11737001687288284,
-0.09944264590740204,
0.15100526809692383,
0.15023112297058105,
0.42452195286750793,
-0.10564465075731277,
-0.3152085244655609,
0.3096880614757538,
0.13810843229293823,
-0.9456154108047485,
-0.3937549889087677,
0.44285592436790466,
-0.8345299363136292,
-0.8450554609298706,
-0.33572670817375183,
-0.5868847370147705,
-0.4934467375278473,
0.10488421469926834,
-0.16893772780895233,
0.1301003396511078,
-0.25008127093315125,
0.1560356169939041,
0.5152385234832764,
-0.479298859834671,
0.28869369626045227,
0.5132408142089844,
-0.02402004972100258,
-0.2240036129951477,
0.7854387164115906,
0.16464170813560486,
0.18877921998500824,
0.2323588877916336,
0.2167150229215622,
-0.11073744297027588,
-0.9118385314941406,
-0.2705889344215393,
0.3723970055580139,
-0.5779844522476196,
0.24091465771198273,
-0.0856705829501152,
-0.14451569318771362,
-0.33125776052474976,
-0.11052946001291275,
-0.41587600111961365,
-0.21807780861854553,
-0.04193875193595886,
-0.055332377552986145,
0.24069121479988098,
0.5144637823104858,
-0.08236131072044373,
0.4525083303451538,
-0.6684660315513611,
-0.2749330997467041,
0.12840181589126587,
0.38375788927078247,
0.15590116381645203,
-0.888005256652832,
-0.8323256373405457,
-0.006173048168420792,
-0.11247747391462326,
-0.41509175300598145,
0.10988139361143112,
0.026436185464262962,
0.6551047563552856,
0.10940539091825485,
0.0025989587884396315,
0.7549918293952942,
-0.402985155582428,
0.39576825499534607,
-0.1990300416946411,
-0.8515692949295044,
0.5746882557868958,
-0.3802342712879181,
0.369047611951828,
0.5622355937957764,
0.40375134348869324,
-0.674266517162323,
-0.09234196692705154,
-0.2660830020904541,
-0.6701264381408691,
0.8106182813644409,
0.13711658120155334,
0.08200540393590927,
0.44841745495796204,
0.4504951536655426,
0.21862618625164032,
0.22613590955734253,
-0.5556657314300537,
0.15144096314907074,
0.023173263296484947,
-0.11189107596874237,
-0.2290632277727127,
-0.30654236674308777,
-0.050773389637470245,
-0.24366281926631927,
0.7981475591659546,
0.046486739069223404,
-0.25172188878059387,
-0.14542172849178314,
-0.36745890974998474,
-0.09741248190402985,
0.3612269163131714,
0.43976858258247375,
0.7234732508659363,
-0.31832602620124817,
0.024844251573085785,
0.6882418990135193,
-0.33944493532180786,
0.038557812571525574,
0.3178953528404236,
0.12042788416147232,
-0.23759068548679352,
0.6457868218421936,
0.895370602607727,
-0.06440803408622742,
-0.8115256428718567,
0.10676290839910507,
0.08876383304595947,
0.06702569872140884,
-0.2379647046327591,
-0.027911335229873657,
0.1893269270658493,
0.5110519528388977,
0.49085748195648193,
-0.3326796889305115,
-0.38283097743988037,
-0.32117632031440735,
-0.07147149741649628,
0.3299475610256195,
-0.21173551678657532,
-0.2868712544441223,
0.2998049259185791,
0.28094908595085144,
-0.09809425473213196,
0.5460191965103149,
0.13811512291431427,
-0.10343383997678757,
0.2561860978603363,
0.3085104525089264,
0.3992198407649994,
-0.2871711552143097,
-0.034522999078035355,
0.37526339292526245,
0.7089676260948181,
-0.0723859891295433,
0.1702890694141388,
-0.11622625589370728,
-0.6372125148773193,
-0.5795832872390747,
-0.8039225935935974,
-0.3360331654548645,
0.45171451568603516,
-0.729007363319397,
0.5762098431587219,
-0.7481423020362854,
-0.07757943123579025,
-0.3391266465187073,
0.5909387469291687,
-0.729615330696106,
0.11677993834018707,
0.4597078263759613,
1.2903733253479004,
-1.0689588785171509,
0.7780642509460449,
1.1070709228515625,
-0.28428077697753906,
-0.3679008185863495,
-0.16455286741256714,
-0.21103601157665253,
-0.6939638257026672,
0.5010466575622559,
-0.037189781665802,
0.10770311206579208,
0.035255782306194305,
-0.16681499779224396,
-0.8877276182174683,
0.8982934951782227,
0.586470901966095,
-0.5327951312065125,
0.04420899972319603,
0.4579448699951172,
0.531828761100769,
-0.20656371116638184,
0.15455873310565948,
0.9180688858032227,
0.30354687571525574,
-0.007497500628232956,
-1.0444133281707764,
0.071017324924469,
0.08642057329416275,
0.0864713117480278,
-0.0971694141626358,
-0.6127327680587769,
0.6483767628669739,
-0.10372599214315414,
-0.17628686130046844,
0.1184835135936737,
0.8524035215377808,
0.510980486869812,
0.09279292076826096,
0.2742897868156433,
0.6604353785514832,
0.6144521832466125,
0.06465976685285568,
0.5802760720252991,
-0.18467797338962555,
0.03791731223464012,
1.0609554052352905,
-0.3260904550552368,
0.9933899641036987,
0.5663577914237976,
-0.21377262473106384,
0.5713247060775757,
0.8301154971122742,
0.14084428548812866,
0.4641387164592743,
0.26889902353286743,
-0.34006479382514954,
-0.44808220863342285,
-0.24771936237812042,
-0.30672207474708557,
0.5119155049324036,
0.5834318399429321,
-0.005012982990592718,
-0.5521764755249023,
-0.01652814820408821,
-0.10408800095319748,
0.11539708822965622,
-0.5584844350814819,
0.608670711517334,
0.17179229855537415,
-0.3303145170211792,
0.7684535384178162,
0.1825302690267563,
0.33994320034980774,
-0.4466954171657562,
0.20395416021347046,
-0.5500874519348145,
0.19826750457286835,
-0.1071932315826416,
-0.5179294943809509,
0.26663869619369507,
0.1266220360994339,
-0.15055838227272034,
-0.030135612934827805,
0.5098232626914978,
-0.3752494752407074,
-0.6699636578559875,
0.25144320726394653,
0.6819431781768799,
0.23694147169589996,
0.06850198656320572,
-0.6323480010032654,
0.3781108558177948,
-0.24262888729572296,
-0.07395201176404953,
0.5056928992271423,
0.740081787109375,
-0.37894967198371887,
0.8583860993385315,
0.5323061943054199,
0.40472280979156494,
-0.010886762291193008,
-0.11404933780431747,
0.6420677900314331,
-0.562240719795227,
-0.4384068548679352,
-0.8711259365081787,
0.3643614947795868,
0.19664791226387024,
-0.14452646672725677,
0.7340474724769592,
0.6085146069526672,
1.0314850807189941,
0.025016678497195244,
0.9492961168289185,
0.18130718171596527,
0.6090903878211975,
-0.3746590316295624,
0.6804796457290649,
-0.6431647539138794,
0.36497294902801514,
-0.19021089375019073,
-0.8299040198326111,
0.011792650446295738,
0.6420268416404724,
-0.5298168063163757,
-0.13219666481018066,
0.3781374394893646,
0.5502234101295471,
-0.10262472927570343,
-0.18324708938598633,
0.2183237224817276,
0.30785590410232544,
0.1343354731798172,
0.6376008987426758,
0.8094099164009094,
-0.1953532099723816,
0.5276041626930237,
-0.19844409823417664,
-0.17525909841060638,
-0.26024502515792847,
-0.9004993438720703,
-1.2118263244628906,
-0.4731987714767456,
-0.1898423284292221,
-0.2343391478061676,
0.3226062059402466,
0.9969703555107117,
0.576738715171814,
-0.8254384398460388,
-0.779139518737793,
-0.07766180485486984,
0.19815167784690857,
-0.1756592094898224,
-0.06407424807548523,
0.2892325520515442,
-0.38637399673461914,
-0.5243980288505554,
0.26720887422561646,
0.21661025285720825,
0.12174651026725769,
-0.34256765246391296,
-0.11082819849252701,
-0.07049937546253204,
0.07464183866977692,
0.5230126976966858,
0.46052655577659607,
-0.6959941983222961,
0.0038125126156955957,
-0.3070223033428192,
0.04833609610795975,
-0.23738634586334229,
0.5979171395301819,
-0.7840039730072021,
0.1809699386358261,
0.4085055887699127,
0.9677271842956543,
0.45546528697013855,
-0.1416199803352356,
0.7429507374763489,
-0.5373773574829102,
0.5116488337516785,
0.05503755435347557,
0.36875391006469727,
0.4508599638938904,
0.15698710083961487,
0.38529014587402344,
0.18277288973331451,
-0.36587390303611755,
-1.1554497480392456,
0.1271914541721344,
-0.5713179111480713,
-0.34428200125694275,
1.0103775262832642,
-0.10895519703626633,
-0.09419211000204086,
-0.16930578649044037,
-0.08165876567363739,
0.2612549662590027,
-0.0344187393784523,
0.9821073412895203,
0.9030009508132935,
0.11338578164577484,
-0.4007631242275238,
-0.6646703481674194,
0.5135059952735901,
0.5667645931243896,
-0.5665370225906372,
0.33814987540245056,
0.20761768519878387,
0.23284655809402466,
-0.22337979078292847,
0.35513952374458313,
0.2084563821554184,
0.0916474312543869,
-0.1903889775276184,
0.025288786739110947,
-0.05139081925153732,
-0.16015781462192535,
-0.5511034727096558,
-0.136696457862854,
0.4430302083492279,
-0.04988305643200874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04669v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04669v1
|
Towards a Theoretical Understanding of the 'Reversal Curse' via Training Dynamics
| 2024-05-07T21:03:51 | 2024-05-07T21:03:51 |
Hanlin Zhu, Baihe Huang, Shaolun Zhang, Michael Jordan, Jiantao Jiao, Yuandong Tian, Stuart Russell
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Auto-regressive large language models (LLMs) show impressive capacities to
solve many complex reasoning tasks while struggling with some simple logical
reasoning tasks such as inverse search: when trained on ''A is B'', LLM fails
to directly conclude ''B is A'' during inference, which is known as the
''reversal curse'' (Berglund et al., 2023). In this paper, we theoretically
analyze the reversal curse via the training dynamics of (stochastic) gradient
descent for two auto-regressive models: (1) a bilinear model that can be viewed
as a simplification of a one-layer transformer; (2) one-layer transformers
using the framework of Tian et al. (2023a). Our analysis reveals a core reason
why the reversal curse happens: the (effective) weights of both auto-regressive
models show asymmetry, i.e., the increase of weights from a token $A$ to token
$B$ during training does not necessarily cause the increase of the weights from
$B$ to $A$. Moreover, our analysis can be naturally applied to other logical
reasoning tasks such as chain-of-thought (COT) (Wei et al., 2022b). We show the
necessity of COT, i.e., a model trained on ''$A \to B$'' and ''$B \to C$''
fails to directly conclude ''$A \to C$'' without COT (also empirically observed
by Allen-Zhu and Li (2023)), for one-layer transformers via training dynamics,
which provides a new perspective different from previous work (Feng et al.,
2024) that focuses on expressivity. Finally, we also conduct experiments to
validate our theory on multi-layer transformers under different settings.
|
[
-0.28086909651756287,
-0.7639583945274353,
0.14952495694160461,
0.033752333372831345,
-0.19069385528564453,
0.2718028426170349,
-0.1394956260919571,
-0.4181964099407196,
0.2238316684961319,
0.644179105758667,
-0.691345751285553,
0.1429908275604248,
-0.8913235068321228,
0.08094698935747147,
-0.8215975761413574,
1.2868837118148804,
-0.028228651732206345,
0.30444738268852234,
0.08852912485599518,
0.13380399346351624,
-0.47993820905685425,
-0.34902068972587585,
-0.8451752662658691,
-0.5648457407951355,
0.3793860375881195,
0.08235206454992294,
0.8453397154808044,
0.5832085609436035,
0.2964837849140167,
0.2626691162586212,
0.15518082678318024,
-0.10163064301013947,
-0.7810371518135071,
0.3461329936981201,
-0.2421651929616928,
-0.7967483997344971,
0.017327258363366127,
0.22748738527297974,
0.5739023685455322,
0.7394781112670898,
-0.1958661675453186,
0.0901879072189331,
0.15883634984493256,
0.6171975135803223,
-0.4703933298587799,
-0.19865141808986664,
-0.8992131352424622,
0.172784224152565,
0.11665863543748856,
-0.4660187065601349,
-0.2823518216609955,
-0.31138816475868225,
0.18659457564353943,
-0.3403222858905792,
0.4662245512008667,
0.1464778631925583,
1.1937705278396606,
0.5377749800682068,
-0.522280216217041,
-0.3025681674480438,
-0.9653997421264648,
0.8159286975860596,
-0.41113990545272827,
0.40301403403282166,
0.06620093435049057,
0.4726848602294922,
-0.19978737831115723,
-0.6248998641967773,
-0.7860867977142334,
-0.1750643104314804,
0.0022060000337660313,
0.4004824459552765,
-0.018907899037003517,
-0.06430239230394363,
0.47350621223449707,
0.4395753741264343,
-0.19593572616577148,
0.4404264986515045,
-0.5410970449447632,
0.023980995640158653,
0.3856711685657501,
0.33674001693725586,
0.305422842502594,
0.08383448421955109,
-0.9718036651611328,
-0.10294129699468613,
-0.8002792000770569,
0.2520313262939453,
0.6505355834960938,
0.2557106912136078,
-0.17069722712039948,
0.29752451181411743,
0.32552722096443176,
0.5001082420349121,
0.17598403990268707,
-0.03651602566242218,
-0.015786143019795418,
-0.1856272965669632,
-0.2705840766429901,
0.05725057050585747,
0.6585667729377747,
0.11743292957544327,
0.4420150816440582,
-0.27703285217285156,
-0.2666102945804596,
0.17348727583885193,
0.534067690372467,
-0.6897352933883667,
-0.26504677534103394,
-0.1736772209405899,
-0.440034955739975,
-0.3639043867588043,
0.06079460307955742,
-0.7456825375556946,
-0.5931117534637451,
-0.5098199844360352,
0.5965156555175781,
-0.2114000767469406,
-0.41728779673576355,
0.2953629791736603,
-0.17558497190475464,
0.44558215141296387,
0.28368842601776123,
-0.7339525818824768,
0.3217715620994568,
0.5274229049682617,
0.3748098611831665,
-0.16103151440620422,
-0.612343430519104,
-0.2773899734020233,
-0.2462863177061081,
-0.38941362500190735,
0.5063419342041016,
-0.5822069644927979,
-0.23905391991138458,
-0.07704421132802963,
0.11150440573692322,
-0.4425194263458252,
-0.39762580394744873,
0.3399224281311035,
-0.5482895374298096,
0.25190556049346924,
-0.1739601492881775,
-0.2149258553981781,
-0.19457373023033142,
0.09575045108795166,
-0.41419199109077454,
0.7684469223022461,
-0.1963295191526413,
-0.6446241140365601,
0.5129989981651306,
0.0741162896156311,
-0.46840769052505493,
-0.4681757986545563,
-0.19713866710662842,
-0.5727787613868713,
0.1877591907978058,
-0.1625184416770935,
-0.05856863781809807,
-0.8654365539550781,
0.26255789399147034,
-0.28156837821006775,
-0.4763256907463074,
0.26822251081466675,
-0.7602525353431702,
1.1954840421676636,
0.07473354041576385,
-0.8054680228233337,
-0.3993525207042694,
-0.7158839702606201,
-0.22454716265201569,
0.1134856715798378,
-0.08239676803350449,
-0.2509642243385315,
0.15679676830768585,
-0.6788231730461121,
0.5465421080589294,
-0.09537743031978607,
-0.5109489560127258,
0.426225870847702,
-0.5790396332740784,
0.23090140521526337,
0.8080261945724487,
-0.12891238927841187,
0.37969592213630676,
-0.03889841213822365,
0.7299206256866455,
0.3600711226463318,
0.23203355073928833,
-0.005822294857352972,
-0.4970364570617676,
-0.9622270464897156,
-0.06499381363391876,
0.11642829328775406,
0.6891732215881348,
-0.7237257361412048,
0.13566553592681885,
-0.21142612397670746,
-0.17278969287872314,
-0.7710869908332825,
0.16024044156074524,
0.7161074876785278,
0.7307059168815613,
0.5959218740463257,
-0.3599201440811157,
-0.621814489364624,
-1.1453187465667725,
-0.6356998682022095,
-0.16859214007854462,
0.2674619257450104,
0.06835786253213882,
0.5175520777702332,
-0.11653531342744827,
0.8200365304946899,
-0.2505144774913788,
-0.17228490114212036,
-0.15122950077056885,
0.47977086901664734,
0.3553391098976135,
0.716477632522583,
0.37318116426467896,
-0.6759845018386841,
-0.10496525466442108,
-0.21840515732765198,
-0.6963179707527161,
-0.2499592900276184,
-0.4886602461338043,
-0.08807393163442612,
0.3651413023471832,
0.5051772594451904,
-0.6380407810211182,
0.9175248146057129,
0.29571500420570374,
-0.4500983953475952,
0.9264588952064514,
0.07640576362609863,
-0.05138181522488594,
-0.6306080222129822,
0.03497026115655899,
-0.324351042509079,
0.056762341409921646,
-0.5284116268157959,
0.060668088495731354,
-0.25872182846069336,
0.35214462876319885,
0.05830571800470352,
0.4685535728931427,
-0.45478904247283936,
-0.22998730838298798,
-0.35891667008399963,
0.13742303848266602,
0.07413747906684875,
0.4356152415275574,
-0.14334632456302643,
0.5999122858047485,
0.8838223814964294,
-0.8658236861228943,
0.24018768966197968,
-0.04662216454744339,
0.009694783017039299,
0.4633166491985321,
-0.36672893166542053,
-0.01970430091023445,
-0.38222211599349976,
0.17121508717536926,
-1.1707568168640137,
0.4849480986595154,
0.16690687835216522,
-0.5673046112060547,
0.5662882924079895,
-0.11449216306209564,
-0.3912523090839386,
-0.7972537279129028,
-0.13789503276348114,
0.4088424742221832,
0.5210669636726379,
-0.8468538522720337,
0.7348721623420715,
-0.0013703897129744291,
0.3172305226325989,
-1.1791269779205322,
-0.9621930122375488,
0.17990684509277344,
-0.12991909682750702,
-0.3351678252220154,
0.14881858229637146,
0.02607106976211071,
-0.3245251476764679,
-0.0925668254494667,
-0.36610907316207886,
0.19849719107151031,
0.39038699865341187,
0.17917373776435852,
0.37194058299064636,
-0.25225475430488586,
0.09797264635562897,
0.1733282506465912,
-0.20226912200450897,
0.3616361916065216,
-0.5460256338119507,
0.5255643129348755,
-0.2049998641014099,
-0.3591805398464203,
-0.2697083353996277,
-0.24311396479606628,
0.3906251788139343,
-0.005493031349033117,
0.862875759601593,
0.5395054221153259,
-0.18384648859500885,
-0.3865451216697693,
-0.6912118792533875,
-0.3423025608062744,
-0.45969462394714355,
0.05144595354795456,
-0.42321479320526123,
-0.4585094153881073,
0.8951289653778076,
0.1975628137588501,
-0.09707722812891006,
0.5730429887771606,
0.5637767314910889,
0.043996669352054596,
1.1923882961273193,
0.23858509957790375,
-0.08077937364578247,
0.2297535538673401,
-0.7024995684623718,
0.6052030324935913,
-0.7361366748809814,
-0.20206336677074432,
-0.4523707926273346,
-0.547394871711731,
-0.7176429033279419,
-0.06717907637357712,
0.15266776084899902,
0.6021717190742493,
-0.5548437237739563,
0.3451223075389862,
-0.44104111194610596,
0.4457954168319702,
0.41518887877464294,
0.04504223167896271,
0.3451695144176483,
-0.24770528078079224,
-0.46716219186782837,
0.24132922291755676,
-0.6438475847244263,
-0.2634808421134949,
0.8324015736579895,
0.22612181305885315,
0.9430015087127686,
-0.01043773628771305,
0.4947340786457062,
-0.12958240509033203,
0.4355684518814087,
-0.6392063498497009,
0.5417203307151794,
-0.041638389229774475,
-0.7616812586784363,
-0.22668598592281342,
-0.47860246896743774,
-1.1236780881881714,
0.4455397427082062,
-0.2026151716709137,
-0.7022503614425659,
0.4472825527191162,
0.3512943983078003,
-0.16163383424282074,
0.7500871419906616,
-0.6378964185714722,
0.6497793793678284,
-0.3454950749874115,
-0.7583106756210327,
-0.42668387293815613,
-0.936011552810669,
0.5837470293045044,
0.17542119324207306,
0.10146096348762512,
0.28835299611091614,
0.23976539075374603,
0.33429470658302307,
-0.4986085295677185,
0.9456708431243896,
-0.429935097694397,
-0.4067702889442444,
0.2799994945526123,
0.5129982829093933,
0.5745978951454163,
0.06440874934196472,
0.15207593142986298,
-0.19371384382247925,
-0.18861648440361023,
-0.3276728391647339,
-0.8047480583190918,
0.7160281538963318,
-0.7403025031089783,
-0.9780723452568054,
-0.4713461995124817,
-0.38366562128067017,
-0.12577511370182037,
0.22416910529136658,
0.3992520868778229,
0.5080848336219788,
0.30665937066078186,
-0.2128770500421524,
0.49064135551452637,
-0.4546433687210083,
0.2523435056209564,
0.5206199288368225,
-0.45870667695999146,
-0.05414096638560295,
0.7898730039596558,
0.24092580378055573,
0.5243629813194275,
0.18276704847812653,
0.289874404668808,
0.021674348041415215,
-0.3515688478946686,
-0.35777145624160767,
0.3984128534793854,
-0.6912099719047546,
-0.2877734899520874,
-0.4541666805744171,
-0.2904060184955597,
-0.13180607557296753,
-0.04805837199091911,
-0.4112916886806488,
-0.6260138750076294,
-0.2635616064071655,
-0.3352431356906891,
0.0568852573633194,
0.6465664505958557,
-0.05737518519163132,
0.02344873547554016,
-0.25525039434432983,
0.3342093527317047,
0.36121079325675964,
0.47307127714157104,
0.5618137717247009,
-0.8565016388893127,
-0.2533189654350281,
0.20601050555706024,
-0.3748888373374939,
-0.5979077219963074,
0.3445780873298645,
-0.09740212559700012,
0.48901063203811646,
0.690789520740509,
-0.17171289026737213,
0.7644386887550354,
-0.43678954243659973,
0.8292513489723206,
0.28053054213523865,
-0.8245607018470764,
0.13766834139823914,
-0.23903173208236694,
-0.1403598189353943,
0.4998370409011841,
0.3464159369468689,
-0.2552517056465149,
-0.6488284468650818,
-0.7090059518814087,
-0.7474831938743591,
0.58771151304245,
-0.024901479482650757,
0.17183057963848114,
-0.06984326243400574,
0.5167949199676514,
0.5233167409896851,
0.3729404807090759,
-0.7043742537498474,
-0.5567845106124878,
-0.5946733951568604,
0.19551700353622437,
0.031148452311754227,
0.054151132702827454,
0.032266512513160706,
-0.4858554005622864,
0.7790589332580566,
0.09645646810531616,
0.5557867288589478,
0.19807755947113037,
-0.3099333643913269,
-0.2721053957939148,
-0.01103336550295353,
0.5292109847068787,
0.557936429977417,
0.006659017875790596,
0.43568551540374756,
0.1394074261188507,
-0.3095070421695709,
-0.04762155935168266,
0.07491263747215271,
-0.1990583837032318,
-0.3978363871574402,
0.3369007408618927,
1.184170126914978,
0.34958475828170776,
-0.2838764190673828,
0.5485056638717651,
0.29493090510368347,
-0.2081104964017868,
-0.6001486778259277,
-0.08507171273231506,
-0.23417700827121735,
0.2936914265155792,
0.4693801999092102,
0.3735142946243286,
0.11517592519521713,
-0.6453686952590942,
-0.022573934867978096,
0.60430508852005,
-0.3985098600387573,
-0.6324397921562195,
0.8627525568008423,
-0.2160322517156601,
-0.26127317547798157,
0.6952773928642273,
-0.17733319103717804,
-0.9292811751365662,
0.7392023801803589,
0.7003008127212524,
1.0106956958770752,
-0.2670685350894928,
0.1082393154501915,
0.3481070101261139,
0.4408840835094452,
-0.1916421353816986,
0.12873351573944092,
-0.011725697666406631,
-1.0135903358459473,
-0.3001849949359894,
-0.5090951919555664,
-0.11803103238344193,
-0.1810588389635086,
-0.8095074892044067,
0.23661403357982635,
-0.3510880768299103,
-0.09051601588726044,
-0.25638288259506226,
-0.34723716974258423,
-0.8684194087982178,
0.21893155574798584,
0.024758966639637947,
0.7740795016288757,
-0.5847819447517395,
0.7221561670303345,
0.23957304656505585,
-0.6730185151100159,
-0.694136917591095,
0.07466324418783188,
-0.07703874260187149,
-1.156126618385315,
1.1524947881698608,
0.03932908549904823,
-0.6275270581245422,
0.11889305710792542,
-0.7381995320320129,
-0.8197710514068604,
0.9911051988601685,
0.3684825003147125,
-0.29550525546073914,
-0.39193105697631836,
0.1219070628285408,
0.8624290227890015,
-0.32157543301582336,
0.32728421688079834,
0.6816120743751526,
0.43271926045417786,
-0.20844724774360657,
-0.97803795337677,
0.048875898122787476,
-0.12532934546470642,
-0.11505697667598724,
0.3317911922931671,
-0.7377792000770569,
0.9887987375259399,
-0.4223726987838745,
-0.3602617383003235,
0.0734342634677887,
0.2549709677696228,
-0.036068256944417953,
0.1295207440853119,
0.5540823936462402,
0.6685821413993835,
0.3870532214641571,
0.014692358672618866,
1.2879453897476196,
-0.4555060565471649,
0.4668772518634796,
0.9266105890274048,
-0.2085588276386261,
0.40119755268096924,
0.5406737327575684,
-0.07740151137113571,
1.0675461292266846,
0.006848893593996763,
-0.0819697380065918,
0.30956998467445374,
0.5247287750244141,
0.2779698967933655,
-0.35085755586624146,
0.18754176795482635,
-0.13083027303218842,
0.39325565099716187,
0.25435206294059753,
-0.5537556409835815,
-0.05519280210137367,
0.33712589740753174,
0.08498487621545792,
0.05365703999996185,
-0.5097610950469971,
0.3899786174297333,
0.31526774168014526,
-0.8090898990631104,
0.9219099879264832,
-0.4107191264629364,
0.588293194770813,
-0.34726500511169434,
0.12717631459236145,
-0.22116899490356445,
0.3564870357513428,
-0.1191156730055809,
-0.5558398365974426,
0.17406897246837616,
-0.3385166823863983,
0.034616466611623764,
-0.3700270652770996,
0.7796511054039001,
-0.3726947605609894,
-0.21260832250118256,
0.737892746925354,
0.33751410245895386,
-0.043667860329151154,
0.47124791145324707,
-0.66693514585495,
-0.31658560037612915,
-0.28222763538360596,
-0.5681188702583313,
0.08510149270296097,
0.35624924302101135,
0.10378320515155792,
0.9669965505599976,
0.26140618324279785,
0.38106319308280945,
0.35698848962783813,
0.2678565979003906,
0.8619874119758606,
-0.6536198258399963,
-0.3468736708164215,
-0.8232656121253967,
0.43707698583602905,
0.14007529616355896,
-0.3461427092552185,
0.7017838954925537,
0.4338541030883789,
0.8056346774101257,
-0.09288879483938217,
0.6831265091896057,
0.19176188111305237,
0.6464516520500183,
-0.7387124300003052,
0.5378949046134949,
-0.5913925170898438,
0.5104551315307617,
-0.24264812469482422,
-0.6914980411529541,
-0.09269682317972183,
0.6209793090820312,
-0.6627423167228699,
0.19232231378555298,
0.9287989139556885,
0.6972709894180298,
0.1428617238998413,
0.154047429561615,
-0.02812933176755905,
0.832785427570343,
0.16983237862586975,
0.4375922977924347,
1.0297633409500122,
-0.5392119288444519,
0.5919995307922363,
-0.061040714383125305,
0.050894223153591156,
-0.027039431035518646,
-0.5738391876220703,
-0.8359088897705078,
-0.6200097799301147,
-0.08188359439373016,
-0.8111248016357422,
0.10508346557617188,
0.8894158005714417,
0.16829153895378113,
-0.8089256286621094,
-0.2952912449836731,
-0.5006501078605652,
0.2362668365240097,
-0.5862612724304199,
-0.301809161901474,
0.27855634689331055,
-0.4994698464870453,
-0.351627916097641,
0.05129431188106537,
0.09739868342876434,
0.016333136707544327,
-0.6042377352714539,
0.008386251516640186,
-0.23256102204322815,
0.2101508527994156,
0.3253059983253479,
0.4832614064216614,
-0.8367737531661987,
-0.4452708959579468,
-0.08588392287492752,
-0.023846730589866638,
0.09903709590435028,
1.0623142719268799,
-1.274380087852478,
0.4930188059806824,
0.42610621452331543,
0.5907782912254333,
0.6289474964141846,
0.012841829098761082,
0.7708622217178345,
-0.44552066922187805,
-0.04245434328913689,
0.18734987080097198,
0.3212011456489563,
0.02917659841477871,
-0.19405317306518555,
0.4388778805732727,
0.50235915184021,
-0.5046671032905579,
-1.1035505533218384,
0.5203893184661865,
-0.6080163717269897,
-0.35428720712661743,
0.9241256713867188,
0.10034075379371643,
0.053386129438877106,
-0.05405931547284126,
-0.006451972294598818,
0.40742459893226624,
0.011168496683239937,
1.2232574224472046,
0.5325256586074829,
-0.14029031991958618,
-0.2327205389738083,
-0.47157201170921326,
0.6736951470375061,
0.6888987421989441,
-0.1755758821964264,
0.3330284059047699,
0.017920635640621185,
0.1408335566520691,
0.2600497603416443,
0.14181692898273468,
-0.0662013366818428,
0.13739871978759766,
-0.09918290376663208,
-0.007613257970660925,
-0.1310391128063202,
-0.45549529790878296,
-0.4374251067638397,
-0.2945109009742737,
-0.1317628175020218,
0.19341769814491272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04655v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04655v1
|
Understanding the Capabilities and Limitations of Large Language Models for Cultural Commonsense
| 2024-05-07T20:28:34 | 2024-05-07T20:28:34 |
Siqi Shen, Lajanugen Logeswaran, Moontae Lee, Honglak Lee, Soujanya Poria, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated substantial commonsense
understanding through numerous benchmark evaluations. However, their
understanding of cultural commonsense remains largely unexamined. In this
paper, we conduct a comprehensive examination of the capabilities and
limitations of several state-of-the-art LLMs in the context of cultural
commonsense tasks. Using several general and cultural commonsense benchmarks,
we find that (1) LLMs have a significant discrepancy in performance when tested
on culture-specific commonsense knowledge for different cultures; (2) LLMs'
general commonsense capability is affected by cultural context; and (3) The
language used to query the LLMs can impact their performance on
cultural-related tasks. Our study points to the inherent bias in the cultural
understanding of LLMs and provides insights that can help develop culturally
aware language models.
|
[
-0.43997442722320557,
-0.46143025159835815,
0.5823364853858948,
0.22748823463916779,
-0.08700484782457352,
-0.025078091770410538,
-0.5542868971824646,
-0.6663244366645813,
-0.18488262593746185,
0.6358373761177063,
-0.5414029955863953,
-0.3232884705066681,
-0.701148509979248,
0.391483336687088,
-0.02301768586039543,
0.7931388020515442,
-0.03733799234032631,
0.19404956698417664,
-0.4576346278190613,
-0.5173514485359192,
-0.5611616373062134,
-0.3909249007701874,
-0.10619083046913147,
-0.29245471954345703,
0.11728692799806595,
0.4428873360157013,
0.7360528707504272,
0.4043694734573364,
0.4678225517272949,
0.35227468609809875,
-0.4754473567008972,
0.116080142557621,
-0.7179896831512451,
0.06147550418972969,
-0.4977703094482422,
-0.36418139934539795,
-0.2094321995973587,
0.025983145460486412,
0.7295749187469482,
0.8094611763954163,
0.12085367739200592,
0.3829093277454376,
-0.021064121276140213,
0.46679818630218506,
-0.6767062544822693,
0.000024702954760869034,
-0.7742265462875366,
0.04968113452196121,
-0.35181277990341187,
0.16364029049873352,
-0.2862188220024109,
-0.11080700159072876,
0.2283705621957779,
-0.5334450602531433,
0.05713392421603203,
-0.1505749374628067,
0.5048894882202148,
0.27973291277885437,
-0.8267883658409119,
-0.42599600553512573,
-0.6057162880897522,
1.176008701324463,
-0.6590086221694946,
0.43368005752563477,
0.3413514792919159,
0.33063751459121704,
-0.007166804745793343,
-0.5441159009933472,
-0.5501367449760437,
-0.45546889305114746,
-0.11252961307764053,
-0.18311063945293427,
-0.1300429254770279,
-0.22719451785087585,
0.4433177411556244,
0.49441999197006226,
-0.36246466636657715,
0.5654602646827698,
-0.3980232775211334,
-0.13575699925422668,
0.5691371560096741,
0.29912689328193665,
0.46089860796928406,
-0.3258052468299866,
-0.5601738691329956,
0.2462455928325653,
-0.7298697829246521,
-0.06524088233709335,
0.06539133191108704,
0.10576244443655014,
-0.19216138124465942,
0.3006567060947418,
-0.27751362323760986,
0.7339221239089966,
-0.46145474910736084,
-0.3000698983669281,
-0.0018266591941937804,
-0.11623160541057587,
-0.19108493626117706,
-0.39275503158569336,
0.5080683827400208,
0.3520343005657196,
0.5156615376472473,
-0.12150318920612335,
-0.1595163196325302,
-0.14173899590969086,
-0.08546308428049088,
-0.47123199701309204,
0.2776576280593872,
0.23390395939350128,
-0.39403286576271057,
-0.11796180158853531,
-0.2610511779785156,
-0.4671045243740082,
-0.7244494557380676,
-0.22940517961978912,
0.1889425367116928,
0.016062941402196884,
-0.5520594716072083,
-0.07756280153989792,
-0.2780040502548218,
0.1502780169248581,
0.19450227916240692,
-0.8926223516464233,
0.16492226719856262,
0.8460728526115417,
0.620022177696228,
-0.32806652784347534,
-0.34487155079841614,
-0.14120563864707947,
0.1481200009584427,
-0.20073571801185608,
0.3188299536705017,
-0.7048691511154175,
-0.5007117390632629,
0.09128688275814056,
0.006643910426646471,
0.17224861681461334,
-0.8669010996818542,
0.5873569250106812,
-0.5392482876777649,
-0.27117595076560974,
-0.8196382522583008,
-0.4254365861415863,
-0.22977884113788605,
0.21462982892990112,
-0.8466211557388306,
0.40196678042411804,
-0.04549897089600563,
-0.6284383535385132,
0.34718528389930725,
-0.3639436960220337,
-0.4132121801376343,
0.2619975507259369,
-0.205819234251976,
0.28062450885772705,
0.37057000398635864,
0.0920720100402832,
0.5541021227836609,
-0.44417962431907654,
0.27304184436798096,
-0.36300668120384216,
-0.6416266560554504,
0.6437219977378845,
-0.6254923343658447,
1.0609136819839478,
0.5939522981643677,
-0.15866857767105103,
-0.23255237936973572,
-0.5736210942268372,
-0.39746904373168945,
0.23642154037952423,
-0.337975412607193,
-0.3334074914455414,
0.005253537558019161,
0.05692947655916214,
0.11174512654542923,
0.3730103373527527,
-0.3662063479423523,
-0.08606144785881042,
0.1369987279176712,
0.712256669998169,
0.827948808670044,
-0.5306210517883301,
0.3887956142425537,
-0.2408689558506012,
0.6035349369049072,
-0.1100945994257927,
0.038320817053318024,
-0.0125657320022583,
-0.1224944069981575,
-0.3794668912887573,
-0.232641339302063,
-0.0851747915148735,
0.500878632068634,
-0.6030046939849854,
-0.18481680750846863,
-0.3180854618549347,
-0.35154956579208374,
-0.22130300104618073,
0.4538745582103729,
0.414673388004303,
0.3407699465751648,
0.048690035939216614,
-0.35106000304222107,
-0.2694784998893738,
-1.0446875095367432,
-0.4099671244621277,
0.04724884033203125,
-0.0028321666177362204,
0.4152853488922119,
0.5067226886749268,
0.15060560405254364,
0.7042644023895264,
-0.3497236669063568,
-0.2710374593734741,
-0.3976150155067444,
-0.1316879838705063,
0.3261203169822693,
0.2553243339061737,
0.3998238146305084,
-0.7464583516120911,
-0.317912757396698,
0.0985015332698822,
-0.717265248298645,
-0.2665894329547882,
0.056820373982191086,
0.2801872193813324,
0.3449702560901642,
0.5104027390480042,
-0.4434730112552643,
0.020718859508633614,
0.9373719096183777,
-0.1517173945903778,
0.6810026168823242,
-0.12066789716482162,
0.028996072709560394,
-0.7514930963516235,
-0.01441486831754446,
0.26932695508003235,
0.16594678163528442,
-0.7475384473800659,
0.32126834988594055,
0.3061751425266266,
-0.12745895981788635,
-0.7320829629898071,
0.7125722765922546,
-0.5961803793907166,
-0.34326231479644775,
-0.1742425411939621,
0.34707504510879517,
0.03862195834517479,
0.16172833740711212,
0.4154624044895172,
0.6264356374740601,
0.4626193344593048,
-0.5907180309295654,
0.25181323289871216,
-0.02121034264564514,
-0.7580498456954956,
0.9059717655181885,
-0.5422530174255371,
0.004803463350981474,
-0.1711747646331787,
0.3589816093444824,
-0.9305799603462219,
-0.20571422576904297,
-0.17436930537223816,
-0.1641041785478592,
0.19095571339130402,
-0.3531019389629364,
-0.4976513981819153,
-0.4365653097629547,
0.13008590042591095,
0.6973196268081665,
0.3751559853553772,
-0.6576838493347168,
0.4473223090171814,
0.2977369725704193,
0.03496274724602699,
-1.0283639430999756,
-0.8327180743217468,
0.04710954800248146,
-0.4881846308708191,
-0.815662682056427,
-0.14803265035152435,
0.17972829937934875,
-0.6798200011253357,
-0.3022218346595764,
-0.07549312710762024,
-0.009428467601537704,
0.3572583794593811,
0.00003028803621418774,
0.027836259454488754,
-0.20543642342090607,
0.30462121963500977,
-0.36369478702545166,
0.22085334360599518,
0.13007596135139465,
-0.09383594989776611,
0.3965369164943695,
-0.3392808735370636,
-0.5397458672523499,
-0.21604575216770172,
0.20293352007865906,
0.8433443307876587,
-0.4996914267539978,
0.6223605275154114,
0.5939458608627319,
-0.16507475078105927,
-0.13360358774662018,
-0.8831791877746582,
-0.08521373569965363,
-0.5277302265167236,
0.6921821236610413,
-0.39683797955513,
-1.05695378780365,
0.7145596146583557,
0.06317724287509918,
-0.02313382551074028,
0.2794375419616699,
0.4308196008205414,
-0.038921650499105453,
0.5309574007987976,
0.23700807988643646,
-0.0027668881230056286,
0.06093137711286545,
0.00806285347789526,
0.05897412449121475,
-0.9860236048698425,
-0.18822737038135529,
-0.5592963695526123,
-0.4089530110359192,
-0.9378626942634583,
-0.45539551973342896,
0.33183127641677856,
-0.19342614710330963,
-0.4193427860736847,
-0.17609824240207672,
-0.054374609142541885,
0.7094545364379883,
0.3799811899662018,
-0.14202122390270233,
0.532941997051239,
-0.116981640458107,
0.08396481722593307,
-0.04204467684030533,
-0.6140698790550232,
-0.6654256582260132,
0.9456874132156372,
0.6123210191726685,
0.8527928590774536,
0.5100167989730835,
0.1741265058517456,
0.13998179137706757,
0.21156007051467896,
-0.5335168838500977,
0.6209627389907837,
-0.6568741202354431,
-0.9576159715652466,
-0.23854243755340576,
-0.4072011709213257,
-0.6859764456748962,
0.41807475686073303,
-0.10959676653146744,
-0.8060289621353149,
0.04820820689201355,
0.06258189678192139,
-0.015132131986320019,
0.5679541826248169,
-0.7391694188117981,
0.7930353879928589,
-0.4148784875869751,
-0.5112998485565186,
-0.23525215685367584,
-0.36642634868621826,
0.631324827671051,
-0.04033549502491951,
0.4557686150074005,
-0.35373803973197937,
-0.08802174776792526,
0.47641798853874207,
0.05296552926301956,
1.0519561767578125,
-0.08363068103790283,
-0.3931402564048767,
0.09694432467222214,
0.2570402920246124,
0.35724642872810364,
-0.026389773935079575,
-0.24114884436130524,
0.4327910542488098,
0.04191833734512329,
-0.6810639500617981,
-0.25337234139442444,
1.0047838687896729,
-0.7259349226951599,
-1.0710793733596802,
-0.24498462677001953,
-0.8743414282798767,
-0.5293517708778381,
0.0032269181683659554,
-0.05282653495669365,
0.43445318937301636,
-0.3194032609462738,
0.18598544597625732,
0.6385663151741028,
-0.7472280263900757,
0.33601847290992737,
0.7088782787322998,
0.030237136408686638,
0.14135690033435822,
0.6689890027046204,
0.2010699361562729,
0.6068819761276245,
0.18919284641742706,
0.24377481639385223,
-0.44974595308303833,
-0.6313815712928772,
-0.3689132332801819,
0.28672677278518677,
-1.0418951511383057,
0.30054429173469543,
-0.2441757619380951,
0.2727801501750946,
-0.4569433033466339,
-0.18473714590072632,
-0.09026893973350525,
-0.26713913679122925,
-0.1752414107322693,
0.0026554781943559647,
0.20649774372577667,
1.073416829109192,
-0.08716689795255661,
0.15253017842769623,
-0.6034442782402039,
-0.044840648770332336,
0.36463311314582825,
0.5234968662261963,
0.3935129642486572,
-0.5815613269805908,
-0.12029045075178146,
-0.14453348517417908,
-0.016303736716508865,
-0.813734233379364,
-0.026140710338950157,
-0.1816122829914093,
0.7852684259414673,
0.7317492961883545,
0.08272157609462738,
0.39670100808143616,
-0.2931954264640808,
1.062636375427246,
-0.012171595357358456,
-0.8691862225532532,
0.16549457609653473,
-0.5011917948722839,
0.7263485789299011,
0.2182370275259018,
0.561672031879425,
-0.8696060180664062,
-0.40948620438575745,
-0.29815974831581116,
-0.543842613697052,
0.6074302196502686,
-0.22292457520961761,
0.638823390007019,
-0.25535663962364197,
-0.09661772102117538,
0.18742671608924866,
-0.01343159843236208,
-0.7787379026412964,
-0.09175073355436325,
-0.00967404805123806,
0.3216860294342041,
-0.18250282108783722,
-0.5084009170532227,
-0.24639663100242615,
-0.03836137056350708,
0.338664710521698,
0.13255317509174347,
-0.21526426076889038,
-0.142548605799675,
-0.36158427596092224,
-0.023771999403834343,
0.5820977091789246,
0.9353132843971252,
1.0951745510101318,
-0.0811782255768776,
0.10108288377523422,
0.7982981204986572,
-0.3010993003845215,
-0.10847534239292145,
-0.1654680222272873,
0.157974511384964,
-0.31228160858154297,
0.45172521471977234,
0.7068461179733276,
0.07309197634458542,
-0.8501089215278625,
0.23191046714782715,
0.09646379947662354,
0.020049087703227997,
-0.33409732580184937,
-0.050718195736408234,
0.3930289149284363,
0.294415682554245,
0.4111831486225128,
-0.28402599692344666,
-0.2046457678079605,
-0.7846609950065613,
-0.12682509422302246,
0.7779626846313477,
-0.11597238481044769,
0.1117168515920639,
0.4768456816673279,
0.35986024141311646,
0.034174371510744095,
0.7027671337127686,
0.08199414610862732,
-0.580878496170044,
0.6894103288650513,
0.5367347598075867,
0.40041983127593994,
-0.13180658221244812,
0.21130013465881348,
0.21098078787326813,
0.38164666295051575,
0.22168093919754028,
-0.09761188179254532,
-0.09581532329320908,
-0.9634578824043274,
-0.609470784664154,
-0.4513459801673889,
-0.41059064865112305,
0.3744502365589142,
-0.644259512424469,
-0.0004370307724457234,
-0.36334988474845886,
-0.01045216340571642,
-0.25331977009773254,
0.10533268004655838,
-0.8622046113014221,
0.2890388071537018,
0.33112987875938416,
1.0763423442840576,
-0.9364709258079529,
0.5584875345230103,
0.6315991282463074,
-0.09161226451396942,
-0.5263683795928955,
-0.05898680537939072,
0.33756929636001587,
-1.1387181282043457,
1.0364837646484375,
-0.036120012402534485,
-0.02721140719950199,
-0.4331897497177124,
-0.26524102687835693,
-0.8156816363334656,
1.024068832397461,
0.08912772685289383,
-0.5247665047645569,
0.23956987261772156,
0.5045815110206604,
0.5674479603767395,
-0.2076488584280014,
0.30285900831222534,
0.7325474619865417,
0.4898546040058136,
0.09725145250558853,
-1.256322979927063,
0.3141076862812042,
0.08462990820407867,
0.16899551451206207,
-0.11509961634874344,
-0.844059944152832,
0.6774942278862,
-0.2551892399787903,
-0.06056308373808861,
0.03578070178627968,
0.5857158899307251,
0.3493494987487793,
0.3321981430053711,
0.5150094032287598,
0.4369920492172241,
0.7564986944198608,
-0.19883345067501068,
1.1070001125335693,
-0.03823878988623619,
0.00835750438272953,
0.958246648311615,
-0.3463095724582672,
0.8090393543243408,
0.3424449563026428,
-0.1281527429819107,
0.18436665832996368,
0.4939403831958771,
-0.0497567281126976,
-0.028354713693261147,
0.5823495984077454,
-0.44622036814689636,
-0.2559327781200409,
-0.5168473124504089,
-0.401210755109787,
0.8312568664550781,
0.4436485469341278,
-0.4383973479270935,
-0.2105637639760971,
-0.015080850571393967,
0.22753475606441498,
0.2361169010400772,
-0.5409851670265198,
0.42747336626052856,
0.07527991384267807,
-0.7903198599815369,
0.7013677954673767,
-0.06063909828662872,
0.8237319588661194,
-0.47075155377388,
0.3099024295806885,
-0.4169863164424896,
-0.04744841158390045,
-0.15899886190891266,
-1.0290433168411255,
0.20453189313411713,
0.11267145723104477,
0.1893204003572464,
-0.15455348789691925,
0.6693181991577148,
-0.11338984966278076,
-0.24360941350460052,
0.11819037795066833,
0.49713239073753357,
0.21242231130599976,
0.11083019524812698,
-0.28275907039642334,
0.5428947806358337,
-0.05623873695731163,
0.04261968657374382,
0.3265698552131653,
0.5316100120544434,
-0.18846668303012848,
0.7419249415397644,
0.3478626012802124,
0.12197022885084152,
-0.19183725118637085,
0.05811809375882149,
0.31646040081977844,
-0.5234484672546387,
-0.16205817461013794,
-0.7352489829063416,
0.23461247980594635,
-0.034880153834819794,
-0.4176618754863739,
0.6584091782569885,
0.09867104142904282,
1.1451468467712402,
-0.19507162272930145,
0.8128386735916138,
0.042584359645843506,
0.125740647315979,
-0.6066641211509705,
0.7497924566268921,
-0.6927353143692017,
0.5003170967102051,
-0.14440055191516876,
-0.7350079417228699,
-0.006467410828918219,
0.30447855591773987,
-0.6880953907966614,
0.3020328879356384,
0.5737011432647705,
0.746025562286377,
0.0677131861448288,
0.32488110661506653,
0.5766671299934387,
0.35092148184776306,
0.13650764524936676,
0.5718905925750732,
1.1642073392868042,
0.4365265965461731,
0.5523382425308228,
-0.2858024835586548,
-0.09252245724201202,
-0.016304994001984596,
-1.1153240203857422,
-0.8229267001152039,
-0.6283386945724487,
-0.09047727286815643,
-0.11759531497955322,
-0.15263225138187408,
0.6758721470832825,
0.5548246502876282,
-0.6398867964744568,
-0.45728325843811035,
0.601215660572052,
0.2458580881357193,
-0.06784500926733017,
-0.23188693821430206,
0.1727706491947174,
-0.14485672116279602,
-0.9444338083267212,
0.1292775571346283,
0.020833857357501984,
-0.03662480041384697,
-0.5104944109916687,
-0.09247355908155441,
0.11127359420061111,
0.0653303787112236,
0.6774986982345581,
0.4031761586666107,
-1.0276813507080078,
-0.28662365674972534,
-0.029819335788488388,
0.02360629476606846,
-0.335330069065094,
0.8960978984832764,
-0.3920261263847351,
0.35682231187820435,
0.5212221145629883,
0.5552124381065369,
0.15248824656009674,
-0.2581060230731964,
0.603638768196106,
-0.5910615921020508,
0.06306049972772598,
0.10186130553483963,
0.3791836202144623,
0.5154962539672852,
-0.17226243019104004,
0.3586423695087433,
-0.003981639631092548,
-0.5598741769790649,
-0.5499492287635803,
0.6143329739570618,
-0.8921814560890198,
-0.6722171902656555,
1.4881901741027832,
0.05766981095075607,
0.10642475634813309,
-0.15689390897750854,
0.09689198434352875,
-0.03341593220829964,
0.061656828969717026,
0.5676376819610596,
0.9589016437530518,
0.22410421073436737,
-0.16307739913463593,
-0.8837143182754517,
0.31569167971611023,
0.5780308842658997,
-0.18341495096683502,
0.13943953812122345,
0.6154568791389465,
0.618269145488739,
-0.007224140223115683,
0.5123317241668701,
-0.11035273969173431,
0.32310909032821655,
-0.4178381860256195,
-0.3234083652496338,
-0.16488797962665558,
0.18280012905597687,
-0.27852755784988403,
0.06938797980546951,
0.44301506876945496,
0.20743416249752045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06694v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06694v1
|
SUTRA: Scalable Multilingual Language Model Architecture
| 2024-05-07T20:11:44 | 2024-05-07T20:11:44 |
Abhijit Bendale, Michael Sapienza, Steven Ripplinger, Simon Gibbs, Jaewon Lee, Pranav Mistry
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper, we introduce SUTRA, multilingual Large Language Model
architecture capable of understanding, reasoning, and generating text in over
50 languages. SUTRA's design uniquely decouples core conceptual understanding
from language-specific processing, which facilitates scalable and efficient
multilingual alignment and learning. Employing a Mixture of Experts framework
both in language and concept processing, SUTRA demonstrates both computational
efficiency and responsiveness. Through extensive evaluations, SUTRA is
demonstrated to surpass existing models like GPT-3.5, Llama2 by 20-30% on
leading Massive Multitask Language Understanding (MMLU) benchmarks for
multilingual tasks. SUTRA models are also online LLMs that can use knowledge
from the internet to provide hallucination-free, factual and up-to-date
responses while retaining their multilingual capabilities. Furthermore, we
explore the broader implications of its architecture for the future of
multilingual AI, highlighting its potential to democratize access to AI
technology globally and to improve the equity and utility of AI in regions with
predominantly non-English languages. Our findings suggest that SUTRA not only
fills pivotal gaps in multilingual model capabilities but also establishes a
new benchmark for operational efficiency and scalability in AI applications.
|
[
0.04617435857653618,
-0.5639147162437439,
0.304000586271286,
0.6509858965873718,
-0.1682915836572647,
-0.002353150863200426,
-0.3817199170589447,
-0.4568975567817688,
-0.02003237046301365,
0.35369575023651123,
-0.39457571506500244,
-0.5457547307014465,
-0.3365929424762726,
0.06246097758412361,
-0.2455911487340927,
0.5469778776168823,
0.06970135867595673,
0.36534035205841064,
-0.5141058564186096,
-0.26434141397476196,
-0.6424142718315125,
-0.3852916955947876,
-0.6422294974327087,
-0.04935932159423828,
0.3313713073730469,
0.2960420548915863,
0.4007784426212311,
0.722987174987793,
0.5016832947731018,
0.3768177032470703,
0.12492617964744568,
0.204107403755188,
-0.22240526974201202,
0.14269722998142242,
0.1760566234588623,
-0.7175219058990479,
-0.794585645198822,
-0.4450681209564209,
0.8882284760475159,
0.5269963145256042,
-0.38824132084846497,
0.026126965880393982,
-0.26931634545326233,
0.6637442708015442,
-0.5561345219612122,
0.47837427258491516,
-0.6145229935646057,
0.01652098074555397,
-0.1684156060218811,
0.035801347345113754,
-0.7277636528015137,
0.006051279604434967,
-0.1928575038909912,
-0.8700896501541138,
-0.3966975510120392,
-0.1889876127243042,
0.4519360363483429,
0.4498286247253418,
-0.3722909390926361,
-0.3349792957305908,
-0.5774660110473633,
0.820551872253418,
-0.5514448285102844,
0.7090461850166321,
0.4294261336326599,
0.4010678231716156,
0.19775745272636414,
-0.6662444472312927,
-0.5863093137741089,
-0.29111143946647644,
-0.09581661224365234,
0.12743832170963287,
0.20770609378814697,
-0.15838105976581573,
-0.025691388174891472,
0.39101314544677734,
-0.8056929707527161,
0.22280429303646088,
-0.34352362155914307,
-0.2034863829612732,
0.6578922867774963,
0.1387690007686615,
0.7495855689048767,
-0.26713284850120544,
-0.2543921172618866,
0.08094477653503418,
-0.8844738602638245,
0.07864045351743698,
0.3214776813983917,
0.38057905435562134,
-0.2357919067144394,
0.4332820475101471,
-0.019059762358665466,
0.8983221650123596,
-0.6552662253379822,
-0.533947229385376,
0.19107766449451447,
-0.5002118349075317,
-0.21821610629558563,
0.05056055635213852,
0.8032681941986084,
-0.11828362941741943,
0.1659853309392929,
-0.0878334566950798,
0.11735305935144424,
0.008429656736552715,
0.3366631865501404,
-0.8455039262771606,
-0.00004653052383218892,
0.47529181838035583,
-0.3704901337623596,
-0.17098598182201385,
-0.3936459422111511,
-0.5388085842132568,
-0.47558078169822693,
-0.3022400438785553,
0.008517366833984852,
-0.7383477687835693,
-0.5201491713523865,
0.20766274631023407,
0.21138028800487518,
0.38863441348075867,
0.38641202449798584,
-0.8417930603027344,
0.10138421505689621,
0.8796106576919556,
0.8713394403457642,
-0.1279679387807846,
-0.5681983828544617,
-0.16593798995018005,
0.34534716606140137,
-0.6017763018608093,
0.6002439260482788,
-0.6315788626670837,
-0.28616198897361755,
0.14867688715457916,
-0.1311129778623581,
-0.01898578554391861,
-0.1440991461277008,
0.4702689051628113,
-0.5761575102806091,
0.1030365377664566,
-0.022053640335798264,
-0.5251139402389526,
-0.3475194275379181,
0.4851486086845398,
-0.7099720239639282,
0.5489968061447144,
-0.3856962323188782,
-0.5030051469802856,
0.27760443091392517,
-0.8531530499458313,
-0.5005108118057251,
0.3008597195148468,
-0.27956080436706543,
-0.3319883942604065,
-0.2658659815788269,
0.23131783306598663,
0.3553837835788727,
-0.30305641889572144,
0.26983439922332764,
-0.21947719156742096,
-0.2827633023262024,
0.12000808864831924,
-0.3807496130466461,
0.8845866918563843,
0.22598831355571747,
0.012204027734696865,
0.3798322081565857,
-0.9779208898544312,
-0.005299370735883713,
0.12281704694032669,
-0.37003225088119507,
-0.4510938823223114,
0.1495523303747177,
0.054419636726379395,
0.23185330629348755,
0.42534908652305603,
-0.3386566638946533,
0.3948281407356262,
-0.17728069424629211,
0.5917426943778992,
0.6649490594863892,
-0.41826024651527405,
0.43821173906326294,
0.05405560880899429,
0.5408604741096497,
0.10954321920871735,
-0.010373410768806934,
-0.6943135261535645,
-0.4369831085205078,
-0.8275353908538818,
-0.7183994054794312,
0.16696520149707794,
0.5450940728187561,
-0.6491907238960266,
-0.11441495269536972,
-0.5563827753067017,
-0.6363746523857117,
-0.9083437323570251,
0.20249652862548828,
0.6210805177688599,
0.10171724110841751,
0.33543336391448975,
0.03626929968595505,
-0.2822021543979645,
-0.8923853635787964,
-0.4681299924850464,
-0.16770271956920624,
0.17516157031059265,
0.4639255106449127,
0.1714208722114563,
-0.294291615486145,
0.473537415266037,
-0.48070669174194336,
-0.33220043778419495,
-0.32253536581993103,
0.07517489045858383,
0.0738104060292244,
0.4048677980899811,
0.281507670879364,
-1.1321897506713867,
-0.6064566969871521,
0.4062053859233856,
-1.0165289640426636,
0.4341200292110443,
-0.09393288940191269,
-0.14393535256385803,
0.2238113433122635,
0.5366625189781189,
-0.8847004771232605,
-0.03214653208851814,
0.35738205909729004,
-0.03623524680733681,
0.395525723695755,
-0.4318995773792267,
0.1310015618801117,
-1.5254898071289062,
0.1354147046804428,
-0.25673359632492065,
-0.08787565678358078,
-0.7522968053817749,
0.598761260509491,
0.5075671076774597,
-0.2748224139213562,
-0.5156964063644409,
0.4517412781715393,
-0.505696713924408,
-0.35914283990859985,
-0.09985845535993576,
0.27428850531578064,
-0.12899337708950043,
0.5506342649459839,
-0.053547076880931854,
0.9882232546806335,
0.6055426001548767,
-0.7416423559188843,
0.36739230155944824,
0.2841925024986267,
-0.5124818682670593,
0.509675920009613,
-0.5742747783660889,
0.13262909650802612,
-0.1748242974281311,
0.3157145082950592,
-0.9991737008094788,
-0.4599917531013489,
-0.150746688246727,
-0.5420129895210266,
0.3523469865322113,
-0.11382104456424713,
-0.32588088512420654,
-0.11586181074380875,
-0.04811131954193115,
0.7749356627464294,
0.19734524190425873,
-0.2558943033218384,
0.7079969644546509,
0.4967632293701172,
-0.22737206518650055,
-1.0303081274032593,
-0.6616663336753845,
0.1667007952928543,
-0.12074516713619232,
-0.6085399985313416,
0.23773513734340668,
-0.044234514236450195,
-0.3757375478744507,
-0.06217438355088234,
0.4835019111633301,
-0.3154972195625305,
0.12219267338514328,
0.11950625479221344,
0.29410886764526367,
-0.3655215799808502,
0.6147748231887817,
0.09477383643388748,
-0.2793613374233246,
-0.13049377501010895,
-0.6752633452415466,
0.6758938431739807,
-0.3750031888484955,
-0.5029205679893494,
-0.5485008358955383,
0.2608312666416168,
0.9971691966056824,
-0.7281202077865601,
0.8491816520690918,
0.57359379529953,
-0.4910206198692322,
-0.09531394392251968,
-0.2132846713066101,
0.4236701428890228,
-0.4056183099746704,
0.7524142861366272,
-0.6590469479560852,
-0.7151018977165222,
0.4751700162887573,
0.07377228140830994,
0.3008994460105896,
0.48481234908103943,
0.8821989893913269,
0.2602477967739105,
0.7229625582695007,
0.8137791156768799,
-0.2014864832162857,
0.17095638811588287,
-0.09247885644435883,
0.3717890679836273,
-0.7009134888648987,
-0.26336851716041565,
-0.40197983384132385,
0.02673589624464512,
-0.8360832333564758,
-0.5950848460197449,
0.1791101098060608,
-0.0940244048833847,
-0.07183347642421722,
0.3118930160999298,
-0.3519155979156494,
0.4494037628173828,
0.28989389538764954,
-0.2997840344905853,
0.4921340346336365,
-0.29843199253082275,
-0.20178371667861938,
0.0038069996517151594,
-0.44393351674079895,
-0.4817091226577759,
1.204099178314209,
0.14425982534885406,
0.39132601022720337,
0.5287577509880066,
0.15069736540317535,
0.1668025255203247,
0.2550100088119507,
-0.7901426553726196,
0.4529469907283783,
-0.1834242194890976,
-0.5780371427536011,
-0.49047350883483887,
-0.3232782781124115,
-0.5997268557548523,
0.6799991130828857,
0.14903128147125244,
-0.45960578322410583,
-0.26545023918151855,
-0.11259271949529648,
-0.17551228404045105,
0.27691468596458435,
-0.6166269183158875,
0.9138041138648987,
-0.19581842422485352,
-0.38806796073913574,
-0.7466977834701538,
-0.32416945695877075,
0.6660282611846924,
-0.2081688493490219,
0.5198515057563782,
-0.08640233427286148,
-0.27078762650489807,
0.3507324159145355,
-0.1311837136745453,
0.6245141625404358,
0.047523513436317444,
-0.2546590268611908,
0.07939600944519043,
-0.0020298638846725225,
0.12414109706878662,
0.22746135294437408,
-0.23564152419567108,
0.2612683176994324,
-0.27646034955978394,
-0.5682412981987,
-0.541498064994812,
0.8619965314865112,
-1.0339269638061523,
-0.4125158190727234,
-0.14632189273834229,
-0.7336719036102295,
-0.16399823129177094,
0.40720388293266296,
-0.05871623754501343,
0.49234718084335327,
-0.2908335030078888,
0.10187622159719467,
0.4996415376663208,
-0.5690978765487671,
0.4609825015068054,
0.6515948176383972,
-0.3390534222126007,
-0.40713486075401306,
1.1910971403121948,
0.10241647809743881,
0.22211314737796783,
0.8725839257240295,
-0.09587885439395905,
-0.3096061050891876,
-0.3832988142967224,
-0.8453864455223083,
0.1762995719909668,
-0.8491644263267517,
0.07255344092845917,
-0.8938260674476624,
-0.11551494896411896,
-0.4425312876701355,
0.0379602275788784,
-0.5965442061424255,
-0.43988096714019775,
0.09072115272283554,
-0.11106672137975693,
0.11154250800609589,
0.9565139412879944,
0.2529628574848175,
0.05245267599821091,
-0.6811380386352539,
0.18791989982128143,
0.3391242027282715,
0.36479052901268005,
0.18966254591941833,
-0.22105571627616882,
-0.3641016483306885,
-0.013233767822384834,
-0.13753218948841095,
-0.5226245522499084,
0.3407958745956421,
0.28973448276519775,
0.3762385845184326,
0.48037007451057434,
-0.2625763416290283,
0.8471038937568665,
-0.8527867794036865,
0.8355681896209717,
0.02222263813018799,
-1.026042103767395,
0.30173808336257935,
-0.4993589520454407,
0.20399156212806702,
0.17806603014469147,
0.47055965662002563,
-0.8437319993972778,
-0.20313377678394318,
-0.15887996554374695,
-0.8442947268486023,
0.5990849137306213,
-0.07687053829431534,
0.26939907670021057,
0.201024129986763,
0.35748937726020813,
0.27310794591903687,
0.398281455039978,
-0.9910022020339966,
-0.09866982698440552,
-0.18284845352172852,
-0.1107177585363388,
-0.22476573288440704,
-0.2334609478712082,
0.1339331418275833,
-0.18869240581989288,
0.6290246844291687,
-0.2778097689151764,
0.4047195315361023,
-0.2266666144132614,
-0.4395695924758911,
0.2142612636089325,
0.2417880743741989,
1.1355457305908203,
0.8931222558021545,
0.33281210064888,
-0.04478517919778824,
0.13142554461956024,
-0.3647244870662689,
0.13557370007038116,
-0.14013978838920593,
-0.01604016125202179,
-0.32571303844451904,
0.6875195503234863,
0.8510798811912537,
0.25723445415496826,
-0.7232377529144287,
0.44149863719940186,
-0.314383327960968,
0.1491776704788208,
-0.6091238260269165,
-0.06501898169517517,
0.49727684259414673,
0.0023053938057273626,
0.06639496982097626,
-0.0062742638401687145,
-0.014223411679267883,
-0.39637577533721924,
0.16146937012672424,
0.4247928261756897,
-0.36522170901298523,
-0.28074976801872253,
0.6807149052619934,
0.11582958698272705,
-0.3977928161621094,
0.7951740026473999,
-0.13506834208965302,
-0.41241177916526794,
0.4729539752006531,
0.5933388471603394,
0.7471498847007751,
-0.3602646291255951,
0.22443516552448273,
0.42790353298187256,
0.2742641866207123,
0.2541303336620331,
0.15257351100444794,
-0.18353717029094696,
-0.6898700594902039,
-0.7283340096473694,
-0.6398224830627441,
-0.4150843024253845,
-0.038200248032808304,
-0.42307737469673157,
0.2888769209384918,
-0.24637265503406525,
0.4512580335140228,
-0.06991088390350342,
-0.09062010794878006,
-0.35902538895606995,
0.06091250479221344,
0.08586402237415314,
0.871894896030426,
-0.6870478987693787,
1.0336949825286865,
0.7434076070785522,
-0.4847885072231293,
-0.7480461001396179,
-0.019461121410131454,
-0.058491356670856476,
-1.0034866333007812,
0.5919020175933838,
0.35884538292884827,
-0.10143931955099106,
-0.08364152908325195,
-0.17137716710567474,
-0.7976486086845398,
1.1504853963851929,
0.3902044892311096,
-0.2584257423877716,
0.13367007672786713,
0.3283577561378479,
0.6312158107757568,
-0.35084041953086853,
0.4623717963695526,
0.22236603498458862,
0.34211859107017517,
0.0696321427822113,
-0.6963021755218506,
-0.24801041185855865,
-0.5767125487327576,
0.006558941211551428,
0.2062629908323288,
-0.9813618063926697,
1.1084336042404175,
-0.1893678605556488,
0.0024524645414203405,
0.07259698957204819,
0.7521730661392212,
0.10856827348470688,
-0.04107900708913803,
0.18356773257255554,
0.5899276733398438,
1.079712152481079,
-0.02249663509428501,
1.3211536407470703,
-0.6348685622215271,
0.1037067323923111,
0.8471406698226929,
-0.2546442449092865,
1.0929551124572754,
0.06855849921703339,
-0.2263800948858261,
0.722294807434082,
0.6854733228683472,
0.4816993772983551,
0.42788010835647583,
0.04807183891534805,
-0.3101247549057007,
-0.36757931113243103,
-0.16193637251853943,
-0.4167696237564087,
0.7147934436798096,
0.4722476601600647,
0.10402650386095047,
0.14675886929035187,
-0.05276503786444664,
0.021081825718283653,
-0.06603235751390457,
-0.2695992887020111,
0.8329360485076904,
0.09312884509563446,
-0.843424379825592,
0.4014107584953308,
0.26088306307792664,
0.35402214527130127,
-0.736397385597229,
-0.05296935513615608,
-0.20980693399906158,
0.537567675113678,
-0.10302392393350601,
-0.390983521938324,
0.21057599782943726,
-0.05065499246120453,
-0.01715768314898014,
-0.28100699186325073,
0.6888543963432312,
-0.6416382193565369,
-0.7457424402236938,
0.34310826659202576,
0.5173197388648987,
0.14298966526985168,
0.20188771188259125,
-0.6127412915229797,
0.06521473079919815,
-0.08283790200948715,
0.012264763005077839,
0.2663658559322357,
0.5340483784675598,
-0.0633312538266182,
1.0594741106033325,
0.7337026596069336,
0.04572223871946335,
0.04483368620276451,
0.0772603303194046,
0.6166250109672546,
-0.5556378960609436,
-0.7895931005477905,
-0.9950284361839294,
0.6131696105003357,
-0.16535314917564392,
-0.36645132303237915,
0.8061175346374512,
0.513496458530426,
0.7994452118873596,
-0.03741201013326645,
0.7698626518249512,
0.19479043781757355,
0.10832908749580383,
-0.4371092915534973,
0.9691618084907532,
-0.9106525778770447,
0.21041087806224823,
-0.22690723836421967,
-0.6390864849090576,
-0.4327230155467987,
0.6851276755332947,
-0.18815958499908447,
0.007671714760363102,
0.5695923566818237,
0.4328085482120514,
0.0456087663769722,
0.1748785674571991,
0.4732186198234558,
0.3137441873550415,
0.6008052229881287,
0.47899556159973145,
0.6154669523239136,
-0.2796258330345154,
0.3126222491264343,
0.10331092774868011,
-0.1840018332004547,
-0.18119585514068604,
-0.6873041391372681,
-0.7436164021492004,
-0.7066340446472168,
0.006680532358586788,
0.07340197265148163,
-0.145788311958313,
0.7929097414016724,
0.5890244841575623,
-0.7121807336807251,
-0.5257900953292847,
-0.2157493531703949,
0.4424280524253845,
-0.2964635491371155,
-0.12931928038597107,
0.3864091634750366,
-0.7862910628318787,
-0.8705609440803528,
0.4544757902622223,
0.736799955368042,
-0.3669644296169281,
-0.7285264730453491,
-0.251380056142807,
-0.21979521214962006,
0.06440295279026031,
0.6893579363822937,
0.000028378181013977155,
-0.7361993789672852,
0.1942577362060547,
0.22460757195949554,
-0.33317893743515015,
0.052380602806806564,
0.8138099908828735,
-0.37438929080963135,
0.645171046257019,
0.3188501298427582,
0.9419835209846497,
0.32356521487236023,
-0.3483896553516388,
0.7388357520103455,
-0.4833530783653259,
0.47824645042419434,
0.014082567766308784,
0.5008646845817566,
0.5475926995277405,
-0.3466006815433502,
0.35883358120918274,
0.09606633335351944,
-0.33838218450546265,
-0.758875846862793,
0.43995147943496704,
-0.5141170620918274,
-0.42582473158836365,
1.0361089706420898,
-0.3987855911254883,
-0.30401721596717834,
-0.02778736688196659,
0.0639614686369896,
0.23889273405075073,
0.07054761797189713,
0.673212468624115,
1.010980248451233,
0.18373386561870575,
-0.19064441323280334,
-0.6079826354980469,
0.478259801864624,
0.4867192804813385,
-1.0414793491363525,
0.22518843412399292,
0.25908514857292175,
-0.0691421627998352,
0.40583810210227966,
0.8005232214927673,
-0.15812928974628448,
0.36339160799980164,
0.09044389426708221,
0.16261602938175201,
-0.07182932645082474,
-0.6255201697349548,
-0.26572179794311523,
0.21870294213294983,
0.09821875393390656,
-0.178622305393219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04620v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04620v2
|
Folded context condensation in Path Integral formalism for infinite context transformers
| 2024-05-07T19:05:26 | 2024-05-10T02:18:27 |
Won-Gi Paeng, Daesuk Kwon
|
hep-ph
|
hep-ph, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.NE
|
This short note is written for rapid communication of long context training
and to share the idea of how to train it with low memory usage. In the note, we
generalize the attention algorithm and neural network of Generative Pre-Trained
Transformers and reinterpret it in Path integral formalism. First, the role of
the transformer is understood as the time evolution of the token state and
second, it is suggested that the all key-token states in the same time as the
query-token can attend to the attention with the query token states. As a
result of the repetitive time evolution, it is discussed that the token states
in the past sequence meats the token states in the present sequence so that the
attention between separated sequences becomes possible for maintaining infinite
contextual information just by using low memory for limited size of sequence.
For the experiment, the $12$ input token window size was taken and one GPU with
$24$GB memory was used for the pre-training. It was confirmed that more than
$150$ length context is preserved. The sampling result of the training, the
code and the other details will be included in the revised version of this note
later.
|
[
-0.27734291553497314,
-0.48050037026405334,
0.6237921118736267,
0.31377875804901123,
-0.46695101261138916,
-0.4277258515357971,
-0.3255341351032257,
-0.20223721861839294,
0.3762533962726593,
0.49291205406188965,
-0.6598625779151917,
-0.22189153730869293,
-0.2660202980041504,
-0.2090054154396057,
-0.5036421418190002,
1.1917706727981567,
-0.1211504340171814,
-0.0853821188211441,
-0.21488246321678162,
-0.3767279088497162,
-0.24826988577842712,
-0.4895329773426056,
-0.6894252300262451,
-0.07255282253026962,
0.6096028685569763,
0.07148771733045578,
0.18971045315265656,
0.44475075602531433,
0.4323248267173767,
0.2225489616394043,
-0.014027387835085392,
-0.318302184343338,
-0.6577007174491882,
0.04192226752638817,
-0.11522582918405533,
-0.42081841826438904,
-0.592840850353241,
0.07934894412755966,
0.8446258306503296,
0.6256873607635498,
0.06102852150797844,
0.29579952359199524,
0.18048755824565887,
0.49578845500946045,
-0.8081212043762207,
0.1571579873561859,
-0.43328529596328735,
0.2314728945493698,
-0.134014293551445,
-0.5287296772003174,
-0.6313022971153259,
0.0902305319905281,
-0.011362285353243351,
-0.5312109589576721,
0.422313392162323,
-0.09807972609996796,
0.3734894394874573,
0.5316534042358398,
-0.4366931915283203,
-0.04723353683948517,
-1.2403919696807861,
0.5978266000747681,
-0.3314029574394226,
0.3308737874031067,
-0.1384536772966385,
0.5866712331771851,
-0.0059801447205245495,
-1.1013374328613281,
-0.5715473294258118,
-0.17906180024147034,
-0.14503662288188934,
0.41993674635887146,
0.24860791862010956,
0.4937892258167267,
0.6546919941902161,
0.48481929302215576,
-0.25471892952919006,
-0.2108396738767624,
-0.501238226890564,
-0.2450946569442749,
0.3135109543800354,
0.1060001328587532,
0.014162971638143063,
-0.017886489629745483,
-0.7507307529449463,
-0.012647468596696854,
-0.7584539651870728,
0.0856809988617897,
0.020613709464669228,
-0.1038438081741333,
-0.3809381127357483,
0.29819974303245544,
-0.12872856855392456,
0.6698876619338989,
-0.10555492341518402,
0.022601721808314323,
0.048691075295209885,
-0.39136964082717896,
-0.3669307231903076,
-0.003988849464803934,
0.6516759395599365,
0.17178551852703094,
0.12032242119312286,
-0.4789953827857971,
-0.030138524249196053,
0.010665211826562881,
0.6582303643226624,
-0.7589418292045593,
0.012823852710425854,
0.012227339670062065,
-0.35499271750450134,
0.23359106481075287,
0.19026945531368256,
-0.6035808324813843,
0.302168071269989,
-0.25908276438713074,
0.15433336794376373,
-0.16345684230327606,
0.3110928535461426,
0.009225615300238132,
-0.06781352311372757,
0.5381535887718201,
0.32006266713142395,
-1.0615973472595215,
0.5673877596855164,
0.7398048043251038,
0.8477516770362854,
-0.12093997001647949,
-0.28135788440704346,
-0.5140102505683899,
0.3424704372882843,
-0.12313990294933319,
0.5404295921325684,
-0.266152024269104,
-0.45930901169776917,
0.010045305825769901,
0.04683298245072365,
-0.2634585201740265,
-0.15242403745651245,
0.7121966481208801,
-0.713304340839386,
0.25068923830986023,
0.058986637741327286,
-0.31523749232292175,
-0.17154692113399506,
0.16348040103912354,
-0.5781142115592957,
0.7286759614944458,
0.36744463443756104,
-0.7499883770942688,
0.41741180419921875,
-1.045451045036316,
-0.634375810623169,
0.2552802562713623,
-0.23900742828845978,
-0.33553263545036316,
0.1744372844696045,
0.12148376554250717,
0.2956084907054901,
-0.08057421445846558,
0.11379847675561905,
-0.15309171378612518,
-0.8882724642753601,
-0.021884847432374954,
-0.44794973731040955,
0.808222234249115,
-0.07547715306282043,
-0.539995551109314,
0.29025745391845703,
-0.5011182427406311,
-0.1726410984992981,
-0.007832285016775131,
-0.3600073456764221,
-0.04502132162451744,
-0.06886899471282959,
0.16134116053581238,
0.24195826053619385,
0.13735447824001312,
-0.4971316158771515,
0.40887153148651123,
-0.5978862643241882,
0.79323410987854,
0.6624625325202942,
0.0884656310081482,
0.7168554663658142,
0.20563092827796936,
0.5425968170166016,
0.26924288272857666,
0.607738196849823,
-0.4983806312084198,
-0.2364160269498825,
-1.1119681596755981,
0.03264198824763298,
0.19876042008399963,
0.2653471827507019,
-0.3071691393852234,
0.5523510575294495,
-0.6004611253738403,
-0.04029180109500885,
-0.04676898568868637,
-0.24742119014263153,
0.1295248419046402,
0.6071252822875977,
0.5029879808425903,
-0.40899893641471863,
-0.6027546525001526,
-0.9424447417259216,
-0.026314927265048027,
0.026862172409892082,
-0.1945217251777649,
0.6162877082824707,
0.545528769493103,
-0.5076316595077515,
1.2812633514404297,
-0.4963623881340027,
-0.25636884570121765,
-0.011246057227253914,
-0.020089762285351753,
0.13977937400341034,
0.5950210690498352,
0.5996213555335999,
-0.8405740261077881,
-0.2641233503818512,
-0.21703840792179108,
-0.5117996335029602,
0.5337622761726379,
-0.28578612208366394,
-0.2983010709285736,
0.13942809402942657,
0.6311185359954834,
-0.767977237701416,
0.7361550331115723,
0.26724356412887573,
0.006835991982370615,
0.10729173570871353,
-0.2140514850616455,
-0.06849393248558044,
-1.3933433294296265,
0.2311020940542221,
-0.20234568417072296,
-0.31248271465301514,
-0.48673152923583984,
-0.01603749953210354,
0.35067859292030334,
-0.14135460555553436,
-0.6050618290901184,
0.6501075625419617,
-0.4791911840438843,
-0.1678147315979004,
-0.2268466055393219,
0.09026427567005157,
-0.3996264934539795,
0.887839674949646,
-0.20122183859348297,
0.5640396475791931,
0.6017302870750427,
-0.788583517074585,
0.3246769905090332,
0.1294754445552826,
0.08614541590213776,
0.3078179657459259,
-0.5218020081520081,
0.4067438244819641,
-0.3765624463558197,
0.7153672575950623,
-0.9230735301971436,
-0.04427620768547058,
0.6246240139007568,
-0.15461134910583496,
0.45282116532325745,
-0.2414272129535675,
-0.14683525264263153,
-0.619689404964447,
-0.1606583595275879,
0.8152820467948914,
0.500568151473999,
-0.48708295822143555,
0.7271746397018433,
0.13336727023124695,
0.34753450751304626,
-0.6605472564697266,
-0.5504544377326965,
0.03881978243589401,
-0.313447505235672,
-0.3339909017086029,
0.523396372795105,
-0.23150429129600525,
0.18333490192890167,
0.0026613723021000624,
-0.31544265151023865,
-0.0066145495511591434,
-0.044492438435554504,
0.39853090047836304,
0.11674661934375763,
-0.34500133991241455,
0.05782098323106766,
0.1533309519290924,
-0.30609726905822754,
0.1645885407924652,
-0.7620789408683777,
0.5791080594062805,
-0.13465559482574463,
-0.2664199471473694,
-0.17952324450016022,
0.32161110639572144,
0.6169659495353699,
-0.03051580861210823,
0.6782919764518738,
0.6382028460502625,
-0.4090471863746643,
-0.06200907751917839,
-0.3921969532966614,
-0.2553202509880066,
-0.4641396701335907,
0.30786243081092834,
-0.25485265254974365,
-0.9613355398178101,
0.827813446521759,
-0.09803817421197891,
-0.040714431554079056,
0.7811743021011353,
0.254261314868927,
0.01030751969665289,
0.6670995950698853,
0.9692087173461914,
-0.2283196896314621,
0.5637591481208801,
-0.641515851020813,
0.4470739960670471,
-1.3132538795471191,
-0.138501837849617,
-0.15608060359954834,
-0.5649817585945129,
-0.4918452501296997,
-0.393023282289505,
0.3680981993675232,
0.24376823008060455,
-0.23734702169895172,
0.23695752024650574,
-0.4596478044986725,
0.47994694113731384,
0.3334978222846985,
0.13622848689556122,
-0.2646248936653137,
-0.10810437798500061,
0.029090188443660736,
0.19437170028686523,
-0.8202007412910461,
-0.04620029032230377,
1.0339432954788208,
0.266477108001709,
0.7185405492782593,
-0.2166549265384674,
0.8392610549926758,
0.08203446120023727,
0.5600271821022034,
-1.1028387546539307,
0.5612847805023193,
0.19099164009094238,
-0.44629472494125366,
-0.36170753836631775,
-0.2375270575284958,
-0.6985269784927368,
-0.09770576655864716,
0.28552737832069397,
-0.7636428475379944,
-0.03293602168560028,
0.3585537075996399,
-0.4080461859703064,
0.08284436166286469,
-0.5298128128051758,
0.9775213599205017,
-0.1279987096786499,
-0.2710539996623993,
-0.15377724170684814,
-1.0661317110061646,
0.32324644923210144,
0.15795502066612244,
-0.4273257255554199,
0.4856310784816742,
-0.09136959910392761,
1.061659812927246,
-0.18652962148189545,
0.8186520934104919,
-0.2405223399400711,
0.22223936021327972,
0.3636447787284851,
-0.5030062794685364,
0.43406254053115845,
0.2597382962703705,
0.5798848271369934,
0.08003169298171997,
-0.4425545632839203,
-0.5573148131370544,
-0.6671107411384583,
0.4913785755634308,
-0.49145862460136414,
-0.7672854661941528,
-0.28336066007614136,
-0.35576146841049194,
-0.21587306261062622,
0.40152573585510254,
0.558438777923584,
0.5787995457649231,
-0.2689475119113922,
0.45151466131210327,
0.5699588060379028,
0.3786184787750244,
0.8304861187934875,
-0.05194511637091637,
0.26859238743782043,
-0.2166106402873993,
0.21840541064739227,
-0.044500987976789474,
0.005511963739991188,
0.5952373743057251,
0.13094700872898102,
-0.30979007482528687,
-0.2361762672662735,
-0.2912617325782776,
0.2955978214740753,
-0.8674781322479248,
-0.01716409996151924,
-0.7121755480766296,
-0.5555387735366821,
-0.38068968057632446,
-0.1013108566403389,
-0.4100271165370941,
-0.2567446529865265,
-0.28665852546691895,
-0.025708941742777824,
0.11979518830776215,
0.6434684991836548,
0.41204777359962463,
0.6539773344993591,
-0.6944409012794495,
0.2200925350189209,
0.19077140092849731,
0.5310479998588562,
0.21491999924182892,
-0.4842735826969147,
-0.673477053642273,
0.03043547086417675,
-0.26492777466773987,
-0.6214247345924377,
-0.102119080722332,
0.24752706289291382,
0.752103865146637,
0.708224356174469,
-0.10973895341157913,
0.5808953046798706,
-0.7439256906509399,
0.8897700309753418,
0.3048226833343506,
-0.8146899342536926,
0.4119192659854889,
-0.16828596591949463,
0.5248813033103943,
0.46640992164611816,
0.48057815432548523,
-0.6986035704612732,
-0.14517858624458313,
-0.7532593607902527,
-1.0737049579620361,
0.8346653580665588,
-0.0039101652801036835,
0.5504107475280762,
-0.06256348639726639,
0.6432288885116577,
0.0005899554817005992,
0.0849306657910347,
-0.7620913982391357,
-0.40472689270973206,
-0.37360623478889465,
-0.09370586276054382,
-0.3133603632450104,
-0.610659122467041,
-0.49678292870521545,
-0.4918380081653595,
0.23458202183246613,
-0.3109623193740845,
0.7356482148170471,
0.25662535429000854,
-0.2050134539604187,
0.12787286937236786,
0.24134133756160736,
1.0808675289154053,
0.7622560262680054,
-0.09518112987279892,
0.16912882030010223,
0.21889716386795044,
-0.847362756729126,
0.18443724513053894,
-0.09743628650903702,
-0.11189143359661102,
-0.31513404846191406,
0.28469836711883545,
1.2033973932266235,
0.5419681072235107,
-0.04043552652001381,
0.559269368648529,
-0.2513520121574402,
-0.1454363465309143,
-0.3945430815219879,
0.05818141624331474,
0.11067472398281097,
-0.014352048747241497,
0.41885367035865784,
0.36723601818084717,
0.23513087630271912,
-0.3578638434410095,
0.2945801913738251,
0.3267146944999695,
-0.688447892665863,
-0.4542331397533417,
0.8233209848403931,
0.30318981409072876,
-0.45639392733573914,
0.7001911401748657,
-0.05134505778551102,
-0.6487639546394348,
0.4289105236530304,
0.7155146598815918,
1.2979063987731934,
-0.06272546947002411,
-0.16434116661548615,
0.30867093801498413,
0.1085033193230629,
0.058185745030641556,
-0.2551112473011017,
-0.9546724557876587,
-0.44494274258613586,
-0.3708980083465576,
-0.6130289435386658,
-0.1067563071846962,
0.22161167860031128,
-0.4934055507183075,
0.00717094587162137,
-0.41959163546562195,
-0.06068313866853714,
-0.3769456148147583,
-0.32249873876571655,
-0.6168613433837891,
0.2969107925891876,
-0.024137554690241814,
0.8897634744644165,
-0.7631329894065857,
0.8639338612556458,
0.5016543865203857,
-0.21476447582244873,
-0.625194251537323,
0.5483574271202087,
-0.6450127363204956,
-0.45707449316978455,
0.7602131366729736,
0.53376704454422,
-0.37855780124664307,
0.1368253082036972,
-0.423892617225647,
-0.872970700263977,
1.0410312414169312,
0.24806223809719086,
-0.47094032168388367,
-0.2892035245895386,
-0.0026347062084823847,
0.5172412395477295,
-0.4630530774593353,
0.1505371332168579,
0.42848101258277893,
0.07297761738300323,
0.19244343042373657,
-0.39498454332351685,
0.0192012470215559,
-0.2744966745376587,
0.14556904137134552,
0.2718616724014282,
-0.6650068759918213,
0.8155386447906494,
0.02338254451751709,
-0.49470484256744385,
0.002753686625510454,
0.8831546902656555,
-0.26749086380004883,
0.18046025931835175,
0.4935068190097809,
0.5920577049255371,
0.1287728250026703,
-0.11496159434318542,
1.0844309329986572,
-0.47274109721183777,
0.548466682434082,
0.8000210523605347,
-0.0037915592547506094,
0.4252266585826874,
0.7416752576828003,
-0.06745850294828415,
0.28663405776023865,
0.548564076423645,
0.3097078502178192,
0.5589418411254883,
0.12891224026679993,
-0.3253687620162964,
0.18850067257881165,
0.3599992096424103,
-0.4142514169216156,
0.3585466742515564,
0.18230865895748138,
-0.37602463364601135,
-0.19914111495018005,
0.21446102857589722,
-0.3323115408420563,
-0.4885837435722351,
-0.4562867283821106,
0.6290613412857056,
0.2832432985305786,
-0.89671790599823,
0.48578590154647827,
-0.2728550434112549,
0.5570618510246277,
-0.5619896650314331,
0.09551895409822464,
-0.19346055388450623,
0.27392494678497314,
-0.10057996213436127,
-0.46465441584587097,
0.3835988938808441,
-0.3392326533794403,
-0.30201828479766846,
-0.2603977620601654,
0.44792523980140686,
-0.2305089235305786,
-0.263380765914917,
0.2544132173061371,
-0.22123268246650696,
-0.05024554952979088,
0.01064770482480526,
-0.35437729954719543,
-0.20087163150310516,
-0.3421635627746582,
-0.42732077836990356,
0.09786912053823471,
0.05842291936278343,
-0.14715659618377686,
0.3711952865123749,
0.21729949116706848,
-0.11451473832130432,
0.3905734419822693,
0.1762446165084839,
0.8775042295455933,
-0.8420498371124268,
-0.9831966161727905,
-0.8507611155509949,
0.5661265850067139,
-0.09245512634515762,
-0.3423460125923157,
0.5382871627807617,
0.7011092305183411,
0.8542061448097229,
-0.28325337171554565,
0.46731144189834595,
0.10482207685709,
-0.06343105435371399,
-0.7085021138191223,
0.5419447422027588,
-0.43885764479637146,
-0.1671765297651291,
-0.035004716366529465,
-1.3567848205566406,
-0.19279523193836212,
0.3957899510860443,
-0.4111739695072174,
0.38501471281051636,
1.0720323324203491,
0.22584842145442963,
-0.42442435026168823,
-0.15992124378681183,
0.17141343653202057,
-0.15567505359649658,
0.3643188774585724,
0.6328775882720947,
0.5159618258476257,
-0.5944257378578186,
0.2306463122367859,
-0.1780136525630951,
-0.23314420878887177,
-0.5033063888549805,
-0.6702295541763306,
-0.6031013131141663,
-0.8671736717224121,
-0.08513622730970383,
-0.12910038232803345,
-0.17365245521068573,
0.2661704123020172,
1.0194107294082642,
-0.47053515911102295,
-0.14460931718349457,
-0.47561225295066833,
-0.2155153602361679,
-0.14303630590438843,
-0.23801098763942719,
0.4375287890434265,
-0.2897690534591675,
-0.576688289642334,
0.13458235561847687,
0.6466280221939087,
0.0016031350241973996,
-0.38788139820098877,
-0.1111537367105484,
0.06021470949053764,
0.015957804396748543,
0.680972158908844,
0.4356415569782257,
-0.6523773670196533,
-0.525870680809021,
-0.0517156645655632,
-0.26109740138053894,
0.4692155420780182,
1.355587124824524,
-0.7615833282470703,
0.36771106719970703,
0.264573872089386,
0.44036248326301575,
1.1287347078323364,
0.04291985183954239,
0.44648098945617676,
-0.897578775882721,
0.6975175738334656,
0.40320900082588196,
0.5157724618911743,
0.1839326024055481,
-0.6078128218650818,
0.282881498336792,
0.25726744532585144,
-0.46884751319885254,
-0.44549867510795593,
0.5905694961547852,
-1.5068416595458984,
0.15834368765354156,
0.7586542367935181,
-0.0010939454659819603,
-0.6393002271652222,
0.31781917810440063,
-0.127267986536026,
0.6907181739807129,
0.036761436611413956,
0.6477577686309814,
0.44073739647865295,
-0.32063472270965576,
-0.09755752235651016,
-0.2278861552476883,
0.7095194458961487,
0.17005757987499237,
-0.5973713994026184,
-0.04632953181862831,
0.16773156821727753,
0.06757914274930954,
0.5489737391471863,
0.7725162506103516,
-0.07317712903022766,
0.4681415557861328,
-0.05051695182919502,
-0.1753588616847992,
0.067673459649086,
-0.5973910093307495,
-0.5269333720207214,
0.14719416201114655,
-0.22629137337207794,
-0.48284587264060974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04590v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04590v1
|
Language Modeling Using Tensor Trains
| 2024-05-07T18:09:47 | 2024-05-07T18:09:47 |
Zhan Su, Yuqin Zhou, Fengran Mo, Jakob Grue Simonsen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
We propose a novel tensor network language model based on the simplest tensor
network (i.e., tensor trains), called `Tensor Train Language Model' (TTLM).
TTLM represents sentences in an exponential space constructed by the tensor
product of words, but computing the probabilities of sentences in a
low-dimensional fashion. We demonstrate that the architectures of Second-order
RNNs, Recurrent Arithmetic Circuits (RACs), and Multiplicative Integration RNNs
are, essentially, special cases of TTLM. Experimental evaluations on real
language modeling tasks show that the proposed variants of TTLM (i.e.,
TTLM-Large and TTLM-Tiny) outperform the vanilla Recurrent Neural Networks
(RNNs) with low-scale of hidden units. (The code is available at
https://github.com/shuishen112/tensortrainlm.)
|
[
-0.04277344420552254,
-1.0019009113311768,
0.4522782266139984,
0.207907572388649,
-0.1242157444357872,
0.18804967403411865,
-0.13793863356113434,
-0.4747354984283447,
0.28735679388046265,
0.288411945104599,
-0.3821341097354889,
-0.3221605718135834,
-0.476925790309906,
-0.1261218786239624,
-0.5327919721603394,
0.7442260384559631,
0.00949905440211296,
0.3150591254234314,
0.1117229089140892,
-0.41446352005004883,
-0.2506891191005707,
-0.5747880935668945,
-1.0037837028503418,
-0.542651891708374,
0.7531423568725586,
0.19235455989837646,
0.619815468788147,
0.5541321039199829,
0.4593021273612976,
0.33278506994247437,
-0.22156402468681335,
-0.12815748155117035,
-0.33358344435691833,
-0.1105743870139122,
0.535422146320343,
-0.6267207264900208,
-0.4561890959739685,
-0.21866244077682495,
0.6523987054824829,
0.881548285484314,
-0.13571381568908691,
0.15876753628253937,
-0.24932442605495453,
0.475570946931839,
-0.1785522699356079,
0.24440830945968628,
-0.255126416683197,
0.17505696415901184,
-0.014172242023050785,
-0.1419478803873062,
-0.6415056586265564,
-0.3828717768192291,
0.12874048948287964,
-0.2438839226961136,
0.26058828830718994,
0.2674190104007721,
0.47953858971595764,
-0.020489471033215523,
-0.4808506965637207,
-0.10864342004060745,
-0.7776622772216797,
0.6789090633392334,
-0.6641294956207275,
0.6026502251625061,
0.27594423294067383,
0.29746487736701965,
-0.13085228204727173,
-0.8876186013221741,
-0.3666878938674927,
-0.5972678065299988,
-0.33762630820274353,
-0.2621520459651947,
-0.2621902823448181,
0.25602033734321594,
0.11256008595228195,
0.2844778001308441,
-0.7701733112335205,
0.21755538880825043,
-0.4932693839073181,
0.09675586968660355,
0.3044143617153168,
0.4819168150424957,
0.3128335177898407,
0.06884562969207764,
-0.4640529155731201,
0.13092570006847382,
-0.7883085012435913,
-0.21064673364162445,
0.19272565841674805,
0.2922973930835724,
-0.18564875423908234,
0.6496849656105042,
-0.09210986644029617,
0.8066015839576721,
-0.6973733305931091,
0.26146915555000305,
0.1838097721338272,
0.02888205647468567,
-0.5123796463012695,
-0.10878525674343109,
0.9109575152397156,
-0.14234529435634613,
0.2662465274333954,
-0.5100015997886658,
-0.5319189429283142,
0.25001686811447144,
0.15915632247924805,
-0.6563396453857422,
-0.1671065092086792,
0.026086967438459396,
-0.6113805770874023,
-0.6235423684120178,
-0.4642687141895294,
-0.554368793964386,
-0.08630809932947159,
-0.24669180810451508,
0.6216518878936768,
-0.6700811386108398,
-0.4781429171562195,
0.21117177605628967,
0.01787634566426277,
0.010568417608737946,
-0.06718980520963669,
-0.8425026535987854,
0.5119966864585876,
0.7300905585289001,
1.0500848293304443,
0.08767056465148926,
-0.4647168517112732,
-0.4159145653247833,
-0.2502842843532562,
-0.2732032835483551,
0.5742323994636536,
-0.3781537413597107,
-0.4479711949825287,
0.05897144600749016,
-0.30629825592041016,
0.1400781124830246,
-0.19933515787124634,
0.29640087485313416,
-0.739452064037323,
0.30211901664733887,
0.3540721833705902,
-0.42807015776634216,
0.09069923311471939,
0.06932186335325241,
-0.8678941130638123,
1.066434621810913,
0.14395374059677124,
-0.6110843420028687,
-0.20401999354362488,
-1.0339821577072144,
-0.6484525799751282,
0.05409763753414154,
-0.031085144728422165,
-0.47025004029273987,
0.43188154697418213,
-0.24103519320487976,
0.17767493426799774,
-0.37637847661972046,
0.30422571301460266,
-0.3159922659397125,
-0.41039806604385376,
0.4479702115058899,
-0.6757015585899353,
0.9253524541854858,
0.5493928790092468,
-0.037323012948036194,
0.10678894072771072,
-0.7879098057746887,
0.17533592879772186,
0.1872604638338089,
-0.362702876329422,
-0.409270703792572,
-0.17160919308662415,
0.39275264739990234,
0.2183200567960739,
0.12509797513484955,
-0.5103600025177002,
0.27666857838630676,
-0.5154587030410767,
0.9154670834541321,
0.5709591507911682,
-0.2542985677719116,
0.6425899863243103,
-0.34805828332901,
0.5238680243492126,
0.018217869102954865,
0.02675202302634716,
-0.1210780218243599,
-0.7383791208267212,
-0.8999239206314087,
-0.08034214377403259,
0.5436212420463562,
0.15559996664524078,
-0.8529758453369141,
0.12160895764827728,
-0.45933040976524353,
-0.35797423124313354,
-0.48632580041885376,
-0.37144777178764343,
0.4807734489440918,
0.22112251818180084,
0.18356727063655853,
-0.03365153819322586,
-0.7555475831031799,
-0.8105614185333252,
-0.41104593873023987,
-0.5635866522789001,
0.01892615482211113,
-0.09161579608917236,
0.3684772253036499,
-0.1052691787481308,
1.0926483869552612,
-0.5314270853996277,
-0.05366160720586777,
-0.5078933835029602,
0.5266848802566528,
-0.042395900934934616,
0.5367228984832764,
0.4465246796607971,
-0.6221472024917603,
-0.1322740763425827,
-0.08966511487960815,
-0.6202569007873535,
0.18926171958446503,
0.0663054883480072,
0.08499112725257874,
0.22970564663410187,
0.5648359060287476,
-0.7100505828857422,
0.41317543387413025,
0.4751369059085846,
-0.4547696113586426,
0.24121271073818207,
-0.3649982511997223,
-0.2739127278327942,
-1.2245655059814453,
-0.05774138495326042,
0.15649452805519104,
-0.3993054926395416,
-0.9595831632614136,
0.17013677954673767,
-0.03199905529618263,
-0.26548337936401367,
-0.4701060354709625,
0.7321398854255676,
-0.42383477091789246,
-0.285567969083786,
-0.13051262497901917,
-0.14801423251628876,
-0.10765930265188217,
0.7688503265380859,
0.18130868673324585,
0.4931325912475586,
0.3740454614162445,
-0.28629183769226074,
0.20206326246261597,
-0.03310200572013855,
-0.4841793477535248,
-0.09569555521011353,
-0.7244899272918701,
0.12816829979419708,
-0.15456928312778473,
-0.06176244094967842,
-1.0325459241867065,
0.040040649473667145,
-0.19241608679294586,
-0.5830738544464111,
0.38244864344596863,
-0.25085845589637756,
-0.7387808561325073,
-0.46521034836769104,
0.0008547593606635928,
0.5145182013511658,
0.6264402866363525,
-0.3369661271572113,
0.6180860996246338,
0.35183608531951904,
0.04384240880608559,
-0.3910486400127411,
-1.14328932762146,
0.24450339376926422,
-0.1628929078578949,
-0.5454097390174866,
0.13666310906410217,
0.03961479663848877,
-0.16567771136760712,
0.23747029900550842,
0.2826822102069855,
-0.23756396770477295,
0.26983651518821716,
0.09313070774078369,
0.3208984434604645,
-0.816036581993103,
0.2676827609539032,
-0.2466965913772583,
-0.17926333844661713,
0.007832075469195843,
-0.5288254022598267,
0.8751011490821838,
-0.6174211502075195,
-0.0959547609090805,
-0.316583514213562,
0.4722258150577545,
0.6385636329650879,
0.011092804372310638,
0.7988307476043701,
0.5617269277572632,
-0.6659590005874634,
-0.11174318194389343,
-0.19825004041194916,
-0.30246302485466003,
-0.4915030896663666,
0.6993914842605591,
-0.49394556879997253,
-1.0761682987213135,
0.2760133147239685,
0.16708768904209137,
-0.07546676695346832,
0.22638531029224396,
0.7932288646697998,
-0.06646184623241425,
0.9267151951789856,
0.9057656526565552,
-0.027963485568761826,
0.6544225811958313,
-0.36898425221443176,
0.4950666129589081,
-0.5675780773162842,
0.04167846217751503,
-0.427844762802124,
-0.49777957797050476,
-0.6898801326751709,
-0.2672974169254303,
0.1568557769060135,
-0.03260921314358711,
-0.5587595105171204,
0.5259907245635986,
-0.17515359818935394,
0.5237228274345398,
0.6951455473899841,
-0.13446253538131714,
0.3888269364833832,
0.198515385389328,
-0.3852023482322693,
0.05258864536881447,
-0.8412554860115051,
-0.4717358946800232,
0.9176633954048157,
0.6547694206237793,
0.9129939079284668,
0.06937843561172485,
0.6795651316642761,
0.30030375719070435,
0.6917818188667297,
-0.871164083480835,
0.5919095277786255,
-0.25911349058151245,
-0.7352896332740784,
-0.3069416880607605,
-0.7490183115005493,
-0.8780849575996399,
0.1674446165561676,
-0.05687516927719116,
-0.7217498421669006,
-0.14782856404781342,
-0.05926897004246712,
-0.4137248694896698,
0.4676099419593811,
-1.2306290864944458,
0.6623947024345398,
-0.41198912262916565,
0.03043857030570507,
-0.11096575111150742,
-0.5852595567703247,
0.2867528200149536,
0.21015091240406036,
0.10821876674890518,
0.11719318479299545,
0.16152358055114746,
0.7677823305130005,
-0.5758302211761475,
0.9289592504501343,
0.0055840532295405865,
0.2059166431427002,
0.18590207397937775,
0.3734535574913025,
0.34728145599365234,
0.05466156080365181,
0.0785568356513977,
0.15382786095142365,
-0.3231688141822815,
-0.2811005711555481,
-0.5953536033630371,
0.8161460757255554,
-0.9779877066612244,
-0.2811122238636017,
-0.2535058557987213,
-0.568854033946991,
-0.38049498200416565,
0.4450361430644989,
0.1542559713125229,
0.7683438062667847,
-0.3098028600215912,
0.16225972771644592,
0.36352023482322693,
-0.04282234609127045,
0.7460803985595703,
0.5033348202705383,
-0.3998582065105438,
-0.5256062150001526,
0.8605653643608093,
0.07658988982439041,
0.26239797472953796,
0.767962634563446,
0.203500434756279,
-0.30746960639953613,
-0.44604358077049255,
-0.49182167649269104,
0.17934173345565796,
-0.5345544219017029,
-0.1940540373325348,
-0.7616420388221741,
-0.45499521493911743,
-0.2726856768131256,
0.10964365303516388,
-0.379874587059021,
-0.8212854266166687,
-0.05421104654669762,
-0.2058744579553604,
0.5657660961151123,
1.0528103113174438,
0.13730505108833313,
0.6998536586761475,
-0.6038169860839844,
0.35377222299575806,
0.2732694745063782,
0.7832522988319397,
0.09125174582004547,
-0.4121372699737549,
-0.49446046352386475,
0.15033359825611115,
-0.0807914063334465,
-0.491453617811203,
0.5822126865386963,
-0.05165017023682594,
0.28353166580200195,
-0.04604034498333931,
-0.270101934671402,
0.47752708196640015,
-0.8198952674865723,
0.6021402478218079,
0.5862085223197937,
-0.7371159791946411,
0.06751354783773422,
-0.16502876579761505,
-0.01811571791768074,
0.07075619697570801,
0.07419873028993607,
-0.7169293165206909,
-0.42501556873321533,
-0.711380660533905,
-0.5656507611274719,
0.7867341041564941,
0.4419940710067749,
0.1248289942741394,
-0.0204628799110651,
0.1551828533411026,
-0.2550075948238373,
0.24711795151233673,
-0.8402521014213562,
-0.6471260190010071,
-0.13752372562885284,
-0.6408928036689758,
-0.16291989386081696,
-0.4194689989089966,
0.19079235196113586,
0.0014052053447812796,
0.2784724235534668,
0.10756378620862961,
0.7745555639266968,
-0.13644330203533173,
-0.16739659011363983,
-0.13710732758045197,
0.21220269799232483,
0.9659254550933838,
0.22262224555015564,
-0.2448626309633255,
0.31561577320098877,
0.10577251017093658,
-0.5575847625732422,
0.25453782081604004,
-0.08767078816890717,
0.017380261793732643,
0.2617820203304291,
0.39107418060302734,
1.0786199569702148,
0.32787764072418213,
-0.2887443006038666,
0.2735201120376587,
-0.4255101680755615,
-0.05771223083138466,
-0.35020992159843445,
-0.17278911173343658,
0.4955019950866699,
0.18755513429641724,
0.17837542295455933,
0.3512818515300751,
-0.2011902928352356,
-0.4247078597545624,
0.15947559475898743,
0.17169398069381714,
-0.5517340302467346,
-0.45505842566490173,
0.878486692905426,
0.03135956823825836,
-0.8858282566070557,
0.6973404288291931,
0.03299061954021454,
-0.4496065080165863,
0.6216908097267151,
0.773277759552002,
1.0453271865844727,
-0.014087572693824768,
0.05599181354045868,
0.015845254063606262,
0.5429960489273071,
-0.20334644615650177,
0.22865594923496246,
0.2515682876110077,
-0.6861354112625122,
-0.5554408431053162,
-0.7282714247703552,
-0.15711195766925812,
0.29722562432289124,
-0.37259697914123535,
0.518663227558136,
-0.45526033639907837,
-0.2312621921300888,
0.1024193987250328,
-0.1835797280073166,
-0.5941798686981201,
0.15008105337619781,
0.31869134306907654,
1.1074137687683105,
-0.8549680709838867,
1.5275107622146606,
0.6283804774284363,
-0.4837985932826996,
-0.6465737223625183,
-0.4140842854976654,
-0.3646024763584137,
-0.9138471484184265,
0.9688469171524048,
-0.029898228123784065,
-0.17803660035133362,
0.19547197222709656,
-0.27359244227409363,
-0.6152897477149963,
0.9322330951690674,
0.44718050956726074,
-0.42911291122436523,
-0.4759090542793274,
0.6747291684150696,
0.8811450600624084,
-0.5267625451087952,
0.32464393973350525,
0.3594624996185303,
-0.008288920857012272,
-0.05832115188241005,
-0.44960662722587585,
-0.412116676568985,
-0.4485219120979309,
0.45136407017707825,
0.2924438416957855,
-0.5151119232177734,
1.0159333944320679,
-0.12279018759727478,
-0.0630464106798172,
0.35292935371398926,
0.7825522422790527,
0.11408744752407074,
0.16937847435474396,
0.29867810010910034,
0.752698540687561,
0.42775771021842957,
-0.22621607780456543,
1.0763169527053833,
-0.2591567933559418,
0.617164134979248,
1.2002631425857544,
-0.06807578355073929,
0.8945100903511047,
0.49178576469421387,
-0.18611612915992737,
0.4426460564136505,
0.34333083033561707,
0.3946973383426666,
0.5053108930587769,
0.32369375228881836,
-0.28046080470085144,
-0.10284467041492462,
0.30407053232192993,
-0.17251521348953247,
0.14784595370292664,
0.5166077613830566,
-0.2804146111011505,
-0.19031044840812683,
0.15665403008460999,
-0.17673799395561218,
-0.25263747572898865,
-0.1523340344429016,
0.6049792766571045,
0.4211055040359497,
-0.3092215359210968,
0.6097128391265869,
0.3182124197483063,
0.5967847108840942,
-0.47095850110054016,
0.12551838159561157,
-0.4649089574813843,
0.23304036259651184,
0.07809211313724518,
-0.7579042315483093,
0.4346734285354614,
0.12995094060897827,
-0.08334898948669434,
-0.41385146975517273,
0.6509477496147156,
-0.6014394760131836,
-0.6168160438537598,
0.192155122756958,
0.42223644256591797,
-0.1334468275308609,
0.4520377218723297,
-0.42458125948905945,
-0.09365386515855789,
-0.34975945949554443,
-0.2917884886264801,
0.3586558401584625,
0.6382209062576294,
-0.05988682061433792,
0.7647672295570374,
0.5255067348480225,
0.12009193003177643,
0.44903966784477234,
0.25524184107780457,
0.5564871430397034,
-0.879568338394165,
-0.6618636846542358,
-0.9092118740081787,
0.31437671184539795,
0.14090152084827423,
-0.2869572341442108,
0.30008015036582947,
0.7201780080795288,
0.5788595676422119,
-0.27499163150787354,
0.7018048763275146,
-0.016732029616832733,
0.27822989225387573,
-0.43069589138031006,
0.8777284026145935,
-0.5700371861457825,
0.2814638912677765,
0.19462642073631287,
-0.49422958493232727,
-0.6417767405509949,
0.5073007941246033,
-0.17368851602077484,
-0.00482799019664526,
0.8898674249649048,
0.7859671711921692,
-0.15897540748119354,
0.28209832310676575,
0.5928650498390198,
0.41665589809417725,
0.31438499689102173,
0.6677437424659729,
1.0188660621643066,
-0.612629234790802,
0.5532333254814148,
-0.24683122336864471,
0.20093394815921783,
-0.3349887728691101,
-0.7033686637878418,
-0.8721566796302795,
-0.7334163784980774,
-0.21078218519687653,
-0.5051590204238892,
-0.0691678524017334,
0.9805358648300171,
0.5950154662132263,
-0.7717435359954834,
-0.42345255613327026,
-0.61918705701828,
0.2874467968940735,
0.07055080682039261,
-0.2018779069185257,
0.29192373156547546,
-0.43920835852622986,
-0.6620793342590332,
0.19139117002487183,
0.2697504162788391,
0.2020614594221115,
-0.4405806362628937,
-0.08521869778633118,
-0.050961244851350784,
-0.07192129641771317,
0.7369000315666199,
0.13570137321949005,
-0.5233073234558105,
-0.237375870347023,
0.30476388335227966,
-0.5557310581207275,
0.11797723174095154,
1.186339259147644,
-0.8791654706001282,
0.16560745239257812,
0.5550895929336548,
0.6452075242996216,
0.545477032661438,
-0.64188551902771,
0.7170364260673523,
-0.9747254848480225,
0.3748151361942291,
0.30651965737342834,
0.6386092901229858,
0.17571209371089935,
-0.012373355217278004,
0.505674421787262,
0.24799001216888428,
-0.24687407910823822,
-1.0573062896728516,
0.2819684147834778,
-0.7874814867973328,
-0.01966708153486252,
1.181646466255188,
-0.029087454080581665,
-0.503176212310791,
-0.07999173551797867,
0.03804977238178253,
0.3371359705924988,
-0.020361967384815216,
0.6978762745857239,
0.46399083733558655,
0.22773590683937073,
-0.1294787973165512,
-0.5573359727859497,
0.37054699659347534,
0.3806176781654358,
-0.39771735668182373,
0.024255458265542984,
0.06351420283317566,
0.28878235816955566,
0.061917614191770554,
0.5967544913291931,
-0.23634055256843567,
0.1543518304824829,
-0.029404757544398308,
0.04698416590690613,
-0.15122199058532715,
-0.3223094344139099,
-0.5933458805084229,
0.1830921620130539,
0.2732454538345337,
-0.18291075527668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04532v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04532v2
|
QServe: W4A8KV4 Quantization and System Co-design for Efficient LLM Serving
| 2024-05-07T17:59:30 | 2024-05-10T15:58:26 |
Yujun Lin, Haotian Tang, Shang Yang, Zhekai Zhang, Guangxuan Xiao, Chuang Gan, Song Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PF
|
Quantization can accelerate large language model (LLM) inference. Going
beyond INT8 quantization, the research community is actively exploring even
lower precision, such as INT4. Nonetheless, state-of-the-art INT4 quantization
techniques only accelerate low-batch, edge LLM inference, failing to deliver
performance gains in large-batch, cloud-based LLM serving. We uncover a
critical issue: existing INT4 quantization methods suffer from significant
runtime overhead (20-90%) when dequantizing either weights or partial sums on
GPUs. To address this challenge, we introduce QoQ, a W4A8KV4 quantization
algorithm with 4-bit weight, 8-bit activation, and 4-bit KV cache. QoQ stands
for quattuor-octo-quattuor, which represents 4-8-4 in Latin. QoQ is implemented
by the QServe inference library that achieves measured speedup. The key insight
driving QServe is that the efficiency of LLM serving on GPUs is critically
influenced by operations on low-throughput CUDA cores. Building upon this
insight, in QoQ algorithm, we introduce progressive quantization that can allow
low dequantization overhead in W4A8 GEMM. Additionally, we develop
SmoothAttention to effectively mitigate the accuracy degradation incurred by
4-bit KV quantization. In the QServe system, we perform compute-aware weight
reordering and take advantage of register-level parallelism to reduce
dequantization latency. We also make fused attention memory-bound, harnessing
the performance gain brought by KV4 quantization. As a result, QServe improves
the maximum achievable serving throughput of Llama-3-8B by 1.2x on A100, 1.4x
on L40S; and Qwen1.5-72B by 2.4x on A100, 3.5x on L40S, compared to
TensorRT-LLM. Remarkably, QServe on L40S GPU can achieve even higher throughput
than TensorRT-LLM on A100. Thus, QServe effectively reduces the dollar cost of
LLM serving by 3x. Code is available at https://github.com/mit-han-lab/qserve.
|
[
-0.3181830942630768,
-0.6693650484085083,
0.7619724869728088,
0.04539351910352707,
-0.2762410044670105,
0.22777977585792542,
0.07904992997646332,
-0.3708037734031677,
-0.3471616208553314,
0.4004688560962677,
-0.32057809829711914,
-0.3156653344631195,
-0.39904963970184326,
-0.0450337678194046,
0.001455936930142343,
0.49727705121040344,
0.09368959814310074,
0.022567734122276306,
-0.4698241949081421,
-0.2725297510623932,
-0.38241341710090637,
-0.4187564253807068,
-0.8434470295906067,
-0.18755057454109192,
0.2696739137172699,
0.45676010847091675,
0.7293024063110352,
0.44991958141326904,
0.5658531188964844,
0.3756665587425232,
-0.009290424175560474,
0.02026759646832943,
-0.6671264171600342,
0.43300002813339233,
0.44912248849868774,
-0.800513505935669,
-0.6685337424278259,
-0.30159685015678406,
0.7350083589553833,
0.14184394478797913,
-0.2373759001493454,
0.10728372633457184,
-0.2443912923336029,
0.8096705079078674,
-0.9217585325241089,
0.1035495474934578,
-0.16210778057575226,
0.0932430624961853,
-0.3986050486564636,
0.22754736244678497,
-0.20886972546577454,
-0.5791510343551636,
-0.1491043120622635,
-0.8477477431297302,
0.11923182010650635,
0.21033528447151184,
0.6895021200180054,
0.5380891561508179,
-0.18427643179893494,
0.3633859157562256,
-0.6123511791229248,
0.9159486293792725,
-0.9438878893852234,
0.7999231219291687,
0.25009915232658386,
0.3023822009563446,
0.01325189508497715,
-1.0376170873641968,
-0.49416282773017883,
0.17225034534931183,
0.3416341245174408,
0.08212745189666748,
-0.3544010519981384,
0.3694787919521332,
0.6689168214797974,
0.7801132798194885,
-0.5517029166221619,
-0.01127228420227766,
-0.03816374018788338,
-0.20023274421691895,
0.23742465674877167,
0.2378206104040146,
-0.0426325798034668,
0.2599273920059204,
-0.29138466715812683,
-0.07794361561536789,
-0.938694417476654,
0.20063668489456177,
0.27297818660736084,
-0.48359042406082153,
0.050961531698703766,
0.24476513266563416,
-0.5840194821357727,
0.6204421520233154,
0.13890030980110168,
-0.16153617203235626,
0.17434079945087433,
-0.30177372694015503,
-0.5428240895271301,
-0.01564186066389084,
0.7056196331977844,
0.05706210434436798,
-0.17976832389831543,
-0.16010954976081848,
-0.37529611587524414,
0.197146475315094,
0.12266978621482849,
-1.1780178546905518,
-0.31146323680877686,
0.3415036201477051,
-0.14203499257564545,
0.008106697350740433,
-0.4452766478061676,
-0.4681001901626587,
-0.11127185076475143,
0.053697895258665085,
0.56156325340271,
-0.5152765512466431,
-0.03801222890615463,
0.05571504682302475,
-0.23053716123104095,
0.47949060797691345,
0.32714033126831055,
-0.7362006306648254,
0.5993303060531616,
0.779197096824646,
0.618126630783081,
-0.06022230163216591,
0.28627535700798035,
-0.9331560730934143,
0.07324634492397308,
-0.2660512626171112,
0.46914243698120117,
-0.40582969784736633,
-0.21968604624271393,
-0.3177497088909149,
-0.14685922861099243,
0.5969108939170837,
-0.4546741843223572,
0.6415547132492065,
-0.9018515944480896,
0.056912656873464584,
-0.3155822455883026,
-0.6742521524429321,
-0.1908508539199829,
0.18535339832305908,
-0.725784182548523,
1.2296005487442017,
0.1608596295118332,
-0.6574834585189819,
0.032745689153671265,
-0.2780522108078003,
-0.29595330357551575,
0.561627984046936,
-0.142927348613739,
-0.7163457274436951,
0.3233398199081421,
0.2712324559688568,
0.18777282536029816,
-0.57340008020401,
0.05486892908811569,
-0.2879752218723297,
-0.6830272674560547,
-0.03925471380352974,
-0.30422312021255493,
0.5333432555198669,
0.17460738122463226,
-0.46149688959121704,
0.2711103856563568,
-0.482634574174881,
0.2268693596124649,
0.04668775200843811,
-0.005878233816474676,
-0.4509128928184509,
-0.11365611106157303,
-0.31924280524253845,
-0.1804264783859253,
0.3507769703865051,
-0.5356462597846985,
0.2665764093399048,
-0.4930272102355957,
0.8547060489654541,
0.6307862401008606,
-0.17823907732963562,
0.6478012204170227,
0.03130301460623741,
0.8152924180030823,
-0.3687753975391388,
0.6804788708686829,
-0.005270260851830244,
-0.6936842203140259,
-0.6055154800415039,
-0.4846617877483368,
0.20880256593227386,
0.313069611787796,
-1.1724755764007568,
-0.1570109724998474,
-0.19869273900985718,
-0.18836678564548492,
-0.7640591859817505,
-0.1377495378255844,
0.6186768412590027,
0.6332487463951111,
0.3013383746147156,
-0.04003065824508667,
-0.3847719132900238,
-1.09170663356781,
0.05676678195595741,
-0.006202227436006069,
0.10927750915288925,
0.12191142141819,
0.08258239179849625,
-0.13272662460803986,
0.48589885234832764,
-0.7109717130661011,
0.03868553042411804,
0.1857938915491104,
-0.10425888001918793,
0.2105075716972351,
0.3339875042438507,
0.15421271324157715,
-0.790793240070343,
-0.3346407115459442,
-0.17710311710834503,
-0.5216336846351624,
-0.04295290261507034,
0.4498732089996338,
-0.47625187039375305,
0.17721526324748993,
0.3967433571815491,
-0.5235636234283447,
0.31452807784080505,
0.6434720754623413,
-0.10994426161050797,
0.5338297486305237,
-0.3372078835964203,
0.33519047498703003,
-0.8587726950645447,
-0.22347383201122284,
-0.2211207002401352,
-0.5948753356933594,
-0.3847357928752899,
0.21405470371246338,
0.35740581154823303,
-0.03947385028004646,
-0.37996917963027954,
0.42375317215919495,
-0.5600867867469788,
-0.3320765197277069,
-0.1400708258152008,
-0.05879635363817215,
0.527411162853241,
0.5171982049942017,
-0.3492247760295868,
1.1718918085098267,
0.4120566248893738,
-0.5493677258491516,
0.5257316827774048,
0.08008528500795364,
-0.1820048987865448,
0.5611118078231812,
-0.7452079057693481,
0.12876835465431213,
0.14868015050888062,
0.16536590456962585,
-0.9371917247772217,
0.3333202600479126,
0.10194222629070282,
-0.3660639226436615,
0.17315621674060822,
-0.1592015027999878,
-0.4326338768005371,
-0.3327946960926056,
-0.5358960032463074,
0.8303756713867188,
0.800387442111969,
-0.4201142191886902,
0.6487166285514832,
0.479927659034729,
0.14790897071361542,
-0.5781373381614685,
-0.5756831765174866,
0.05801963433623314,
-0.2257946878671646,
-0.6841610670089722,
0.625806987285614,
-0.2228696346282959,
-0.25536978244781494,
0.06395412981510162,
-0.19508053362369537,
0.03630484640598297,
0.14205612242221832,
0.3507622480392456,
0.21969032287597656,
-0.26117151975631714,
0.09721694141626358,
0.09301990270614624,
-0.034298550337553024,
0.09554511308670044,
-0.5450495481491089,
0.351535826921463,
-0.33611616492271423,
0.046203237026929855,
-0.5187849998474121,
0.21956637501716614,
0.47243940830230713,
-0.3011290431022644,
0.25806277990341187,
0.8154501914978027,
-0.42870232462882996,
-0.011733376421034336,
-0.6659032702445984,
-0.21327145397663116,
-0.5091065168380737,
0.21888689696788788,
-0.7631363868713379,
-1.1542975902557373,
0.36532896757125854,
0.11941858381032944,
0.11458520591259003,
0.37792664766311646,
0.6380549669265747,
-0.1594390571117401,
1.0261603593826294,
0.41081222891807556,
0.052295997738838196,
0.5964851379394531,
-0.5679683685302734,
0.14601580798625946,
-1.1228476762771606,
0.10846342891454697,
-0.2985185980796814,
-0.31412991881370544,
-0.7069287300109863,
-0.6785014867782593,
0.5061233043670654,
-0.026551373302936554,
-0.3352309465408325,
0.017192279919981956,
-0.5613910555839539,
0.2311817854642868,
0.6631863117218018,
0.06913624703884125,
0.38075336813926697,
-0.1299969106912613,
0.09348376840353012,
-0.07448974251747131,
-0.7360748648643494,
0.04651087522506714,
0.8707723617553711,
0.1581956148147583,
0.9568677544593811,
0.2141612023115158,
0.6457642316818237,
0.5865342020988464,
0.25499409437179565,
-0.8148679733276367,
0.48022377490997314,
-0.01579304039478302,
0.0055662184022367,
-0.44502517580986023,
-0.6199270486831665,
-0.8288564682006836,
0.37938186526298523,
0.01045442558825016,
-0.26959648728370667,
0.16728052496910095,
0.21771861612796783,
-0.5392292141914368,
0.08358324319124222,
-0.8997766375541687,
0.7670328617095947,
-0.05924360081553459,
-0.6888570189476013,
-0.3233035206794739,
-0.39055198431015015,
0.6221218705177307,
0.23327718675136566,
0.0488421730697155,
-0.16703486442565918,
-0.2000272572040558,
0.6708004474639893,
-0.5727812051773071,
0.37757325172424316,
-0.15888239443302155,
-0.25223836302757263,
0.2276047021150589,
-0.02604466862976551,
0.7565860748291016,
0.26035773754119873,
0.1566653698682785,
0.1017555296421051,
0.20663438737392426,
-0.5710646510124207,
-0.7099552154541016,
1.0819523334503174,
-0.9115891456604004,
-0.728626012802124,
-0.3430676758289337,
-0.4939703047275543,
-0.3511277437210083,
0.05596549063920975,
0.07106220722198486,
0.6476291418075562,
0.07701534777879715,
-0.04208811745047569,
1.084072232246399,
-0.013565094210207462,
0.4595078229904175,
0.24865815043449402,
-0.08019959926605225,
-0.6915320158004761,
0.9319232702255249,
-0.09276722371578217,
0.343382865190506,
0.6530525088310242,
0.20871463418006897,
-0.5434869527816772,
-0.560974657535553,
-0.5040326118469238,
0.3021937310695648,
-0.46920907497406006,
-0.5676819682121277,
-0.5127588510513306,
-0.007638310082256794,
-0.46230167150497437,
0.1648828238248825,
-0.4898243546485901,
-0.5986300110816956,
-0.23165073990821838,
0.21049144864082336,
0.5292642712593079,
0.3989917039871216,
0.2534938156604767,
0.5682487487792969,
-0.7563985586166382,
0.505422830581665,
0.5490150451660156,
0.2417355328798294,
0.030155349522829056,
-0.5212461948394775,
-0.4636673927307129,
-0.1323815882205963,
-0.32854604721069336,
-0.6003871560096741,
0.3656233847141266,
0.14384543895721436,
0.36261484026908875,
0.5353067517280579,
0.08360284566879272,
0.7930238842964172,
-0.4696561098098755,
0.5585092306137085,
0.021485768258571625,
-1.0001401901245117,
0.24173541367053986,
0.0879417210817337,
0.5646640062332153,
0.32580599188804626,
0.2888071835041046,
-0.49296534061431885,
-0.29920193552970886,
-0.5954771041870117,
-0.8523092269897461,
0.46766895055770874,
0.20924752950668335,
-0.3534148037433624,
0.1920177936553955,
0.5211374163627625,
-0.11989358067512512,
0.27970048785209656,
-0.2298041135072708,
-0.18817134201526642,
-0.050289757549762726,
-0.19663602113723755,
0.04053439944982529,
-0.3472716510295868,
-0.007625269237905741,
-0.14759746193885803,
0.7059363722801208,
-0.22459110617637634,
0.41009190678596497,
0.137593075633049,
-0.1555074155330658,
0.07262162119150162,
0.08948579430580139,
0.5177208781242371,
0.5687545537948608,
-0.2477298229932785,
0.38625937700271606,
-0.07096219062805176,
-0.6931018233299255,
0.16715334355831146,
0.1593223363161087,
-0.22124452888965607,
-0.41426461935043335,
-0.10543638467788696,
1.0743271112442017,
0.27228906750679016,
-0.5900031328201294,
0.40542978048324585,
-0.6693928837776184,
-0.13077542185783386,
-0.1970752775669098,
0.11341231316328049,
0.11771251261234283,
0.6296087503433228,
0.2733762860298157,
-0.40510374307632446,
0.5508309006690979,
-0.11514072120189667,
-0.08777038753032684,
0.6209591031074524,
-0.17337334156036377,
-0.40794476866722107,
0.85978764295578,
0.2437826544046402,
-0.09648394584655762,
0.7749714851379395,
-0.39956486225128174,
-0.46634772419929504,
0.5298589468002319,
0.22902056574821472,
0.843644380569458,
-0.2580735385417938,
-0.17870411276817322,
0.24984249472618103,
0.04937698319554329,
-0.1589682251214981,
0.5380376577377319,
-0.4000183641910553,
-0.615206778049469,
-0.9807136058807373,
-0.7501355409622192,
-0.5241539478302002,
-0.04445687308907509,
-0.6434153318405151,
0.00936858355998993,
-0.28156203031539917,
-0.41942936182022095,
-0.18609637022018433,
0.24645447731018066,
-0.6866759061813354,
0.11049354076385498,
0.252575159072876,
0.528681755065918,
-0.43327009677886963,
1.0897525548934937,
0.4689632058143616,
0.010179601609706879,
-0.43584510684013367,
-0.40907347202301025,
-0.415272980928421,
-0.9197649359703064,
0.5219501852989197,
-0.204020693898201,
-0.04346087574958801,
0.5596755743026733,
-0.38121476769447327,
-0.9094487428665161,
1.3519973754882812,
0.22069890797138214,
-0.8625020980834961,
-0.051026225090026855,
-0.18719162046909332,
0.175811767578125,
0.08950094133615494,
0.42424866557121277,
0.5905197858810425,
0.368625670671463,
0.18933476507663727,
-0.4882074296474457,
0.3012715280056,
0.12455353885889053,
0.2856694161891937,
0.7091372609138489,
-0.7330764532089233,
0.83408123254776,
-0.33368992805480957,
-0.018362758681178093,
-0.03251981362700462,
0.9098528623580933,
0.36201250553131104,
0.04155218228697777,
0.42180192470550537,
1.1044602394104004,
0.8145021200180054,
-0.20192839205265045,
1.078058123588562,
-0.31662455201148987,
0.26639243960380554,
0.8522933125495911,
-0.13928242027759552,
0.7542449831962585,
0.7098157405853271,
-0.5088546872138977,
0.10876073688268661,
0.7055856585502625,
0.3008041977882385,
0.5450537204742432,
0.2039022296667099,
-0.573283314704895,
-0.2728515565395355,
0.10313915461301804,
-0.18278025090694427,
0.018639935180544853,
0.4659443795681,
0.2732790410518646,
0.01966368593275547,
0.13650262355804443,
-0.06523517519235611,
-0.5680820345878601,
-0.5193827748298645,
0.6093644499778748,
0.1805863380432129,
-0.544276237487793,
0.8790726065635681,
0.0012834433000534773,
0.6587967276573181,
-0.48063725233078003,
-0.24206224083900452,
-0.4636336863040924,
0.22837375104427338,
-0.03886876627802849,
-0.4965951442718506,
0.01760886423289776,
-0.3474905788898468,
-0.2275613397359848,
-0.28053367137908936,
0.49800029397010803,
-0.14574651420116425,
-0.27945777773857117,
-0.09169965237379074,
0.38919150829315186,
0.01832958310842514,
-0.42611804604530334,
-0.4471076726913452,
0.4852515161037445,
-0.008192764595150948,
-0.25720563530921936,
0.6093884706497192,
0.6081846952438354,
-0.39250731468200684,
0.7145687937736511,
0.5373778939247131,
-0.0009459031280130148,
0.22943875193595886,
0.1462562531232834,
0.9510168433189392,
-0.5691350102424622,
-0.5119032263755798,
-0.6993057131767273,
0.06951431185007095,
0.17931263148784637,
-0.0491340234875679,
0.6329066157341003,
0.6579087972640991,
0.5418899655342102,
0.21177056431770325,
0.5171078443527222,
0.12981195747852325,
-0.07991914451122284,
-0.48819732666015625,
0.32403817772865295,
-0.6230095028877258,
0.12360663712024689,
0.27150121331214905,
-0.7826656699180603,
-0.11528848856687546,
0.3509455621242523,
-0.3265160322189331,
-0.20867885649204254,
0.561050295829773,
0.563858687877655,
0.1805606186389923,
-0.15330927073955536,
0.7139071822166443,
0.39891549944877625,
0.538884162902832,
0.7409281730651855,
0.6524336934089661,
-0.6935561299324036,
0.544312059879303,
-0.3219395577907562,
-0.3194291591644287,
-0.200080007314682,
-0.6796498894691467,
-0.3598519563674927,
-0.4859631359577179,
-0.4492514133453369,
-0.3057902455329895,
0.24087773263454437,
0.2791733741760254,
0.705528736114502,
-0.42332205176353455,
-0.07748693972826004,
-0.10688821971416473,
0.27478739619255066,
-0.3058744966983795,
-0.27275705337524414,
0.4028330445289612,
-0.41946354508399963,
-0.9493537545204163,
0.25003814697265625,
0.4760865569114685,
-0.18411855399608612,
-0.5454795360565186,
-0.23280863463878632,
0.00019184929260518402,
-0.21274793148040771,
0.820533037185669,
0.2933308780193329,
-0.6360695362091064,
0.00013915731688030064,
0.1253640055656433,
-0.17807327210903168,
0.32258448004722595,
0.7912479043006897,
-1.0773537158966064,
0.32532474398612976,
0.6146621704101562,
0.8610639572143555,
1.1079286336898804,
0.03989021107554436,
0.37963125109672546,
-0.5016115307807922,
0.11044204980134964,
0.6119312047958374,
0.2938510477542877,
0.31022435426712036,
-0.5467166304588318,
0.23239600658416748,
0.3885156512260437,
-0.9561039805412292,
-0.7027783989906311,
0.08609343320131302,
-1.0265424251556396,
-0.05543680861592293,
0.9099096655845642,
-0.08172404766082764,
-0.7172903418540955,
0.09065510332584381,
-0.052957113832235336,
0.10915884375572205,
-0.6266372799873352,
0.33764246106147766,
0.31760334968566895,
-0.4210922420024872,
-0.6331931948661804,
-0.7754417061805725,
0.719816267490387,
0.29741373658180237,
-0.726585328578949,
-0.11263860017061234,
0.5237686038017273,
0.24914062023162842,
-0.5005380511283875,
0.8529937267303467,
-0.002159564755856991,
0.2838536202907562,
-0.194220170378685,
0.6531331539154053,
-0.024058982729911804,
0.21135158836841583,
-0.2436121702194214,
0.06615922600030899,
0.2616250813007355,
-0.4378221035003662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04520v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04520v1
|
NaturalCodeBench: Examining Coding Performance Mismatch on HumanEval and Natural User Prompts
| 2024-05-07T17:52:51 | 2024-05-07T17:52:51 |
Shudan Zhang, Hanlin Zhao, Xiao Liu, Qinkai Zheng, Zehan Qi, Xiaotao Gu, Xiaohan Zhang, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SE
|
Large language models (LLMs) have manifested strong ability to generate codes
for productive activities. However, current benchmarks for code synthesis, such
as HumanEval, MBPP, and DS-1000, are predominantly oriented towards
introductory tasks on algorithm and data science, insufficiently satisfying
challenging requirements prevalent in real-world coding. To fill this gap, we
propose NaturalCodeBench (NCB), a challenging code benchmark designed to mirror
the complexity and variety of scenarios in real coding tasks. NCB comprises 402
high-quality problems in Python and Java, meticulously selected from natural
user queries from online coding services, covering 6 different domains. Noting
the extraordinary difficulty in creating testing cases for real-world queries,
we also introduce a semi-automated pipeline to enhance the efficiency of test
case construction. Comparing with manual solutions, it achieves an efficiency
increase of more than 4 times. Our systematic experiments on 39 LLMs find that
performance gaps on NCB between models with close HumanEval scores could still
be significant, indicating a lack of focus on practical code synthesis
scenarios or over-specified optimization on HumanEval. On the other hand, even
the best-performing GPT-4 is still far from satisfying on NCB. The evaluation
toolkit and development set are available at
https://github.com/THUDM/NaturalCodeBench.
|
[
-0.6912478804588318,
-0.6455473899841309,
0.05075526237487793,
0.3823740780353546,
-0.0880553349852562,
0.3451424837112427,
-0.24139304459095,
-0.6289373636245728,
-0.1700717806816101,
0.430743008852005,
-0.5876238346099854,
-0.5080717206001282,
-0.04730895534157753,
0.6086933016777039,
-0.18284793198108673,
0.7855319976806641,
-0.03550058603286743,
0.02796325832605362,
-0.2401236742734909,
-0.22873426973819733,
-0.5602629780769348,
-0.5757954120635986,
-0.3683284521102905,
0.13937313854694366,
0.13445931673049927,
0.23971661925315857,
0.5615409016609192,
0.4004083275794983,
0.658453106880188,
0.24507871270179749,
0.0759458988904953,
0.3373720049858093,
-0.4431060552597046,
0.1560976207256317,
-0.20790177583694458,
-0.4096774756908417,
-0.2607232630252838,
0.05220853164792061,
0.36444154381752014,
0.5653016567230225,
-0.20341555774211884,
0.2322099357843399,
0.07561036944389343,
0.7096132636070251,
-0.5472841262817383,
-0.07246864587068558,
-0.42500314116477966,
0.20198926329612732,
-0.10265232622623444,
-0.3117993175983429,
-0.17847411334514618,
-1.0210281610488892,
-0.2895837426185608,
-0.2810523509979248,
0.39889222383499146,
0.21026743948459625,
0.7602843046188354,
0.5129417777061462,
-0.3344932496547699,
-0.26877957582473755,
-0.5147963166236877,
0.7326416969299316,
-0.9477065801620483,
0.2524917721748352,
0.3111576735973358,
0.6050467491149902,
-0.5276705026626587,
-0.4810793697834015,
-0.5536420941352844,
-0.49453455209732056,
0.35227885842323303,
-0.16897855699062347,
-0.4028080403804779,
0.03683627396821976,
0.7047438621520996,
0.6468136310577393,
-0.882798969745636,
0.07027494162321091,
-0.40146008133888245,
-0.5965244174003601,
0.6025012731552124,
0.565362811088562,
0.4226950705051422,
-0.5009245276451111,
0.07837120443582535,
-0.14350080490112305,
-0.7502181529998779,
0.17574451863765717,
0.6619953513145447,
0.3327101767063141,
-0.1670556515455246,
0.512471079826355,
-0.4416067600250244,
1.1428197622299194,
-0.342006117105484,
0.1833857297897339,
0.23893135786056519,
-0.6582152247428894,
-0.012881094589829445,
-0.08456362038850784,
0.5904150605201721,
0.7560462355613708,
0.29831981658935547,
-0.060881562530994415,
-0.2733340263366699,
0.5045568943023682,
0.5876022577285767,
-0.985458493232727,
-0.3346884250640869,
0.11044475436210632,
-0.2194766104221344,
-0.3711444139480591,
-0.21502390503883362,
-0.7789927124977112,
-0.2615659534931183,
-0.41923150420188904,
0.007599095348268747,
-0.14423656463623047,
-0.06588810682296753,
0.059304747730493546,
0.03234554082155228,
0.3739229440689087,
0.06876182556152344,
-0.5292069911956787,
0.2986657917499542,
0.6717657446861267,
0.9348840713500977,
-0.13578130304813385,
-0.052914757281541824,
-0.8721661567687988,
-0.5680648684501648,
-0.4980918765068054,
0.7409812808036804,
-0.5134996175765991,
-0.20237813889980316,
-0.15861086547374725,
-0.17918752133846283,
0.23897092044353485,
-0.7622690200805664,
0.5986298322677612,
-0.3944784700870514,
0.009304797276854515,
-0.41884276270866394,
-0.4203232228755951,
0.0929463803768158,
0.5510410070419312,
-0.7686885595321655,
1.3340002298355103,
0.3869835138320923,
-0.6742362976074219,
0.27393215894699097,
-0.5220376253128052,
-0.28710731863975525,
-0.017252471297979355,
-0.21198686957359314,
-0.18593619763851166,
0.10220716893672943,
-0.03941260650753975,
0.2817903757095337,
-0.6445051431655884,
0.3850233554840088,
-0.4562784433364868,
-0.6874837875366211,
0.21999932825565338,
-0.21204259991645813,
0.6972772479057312,
0.4240208566188812,
-0.3826768398284912,
-0.05119553580880165,
-0.9309243559837341,
0.35616084933280945,
0.07874961942434311,
-0.5833752155303955,
-0.0982314869761467,
-0.32229262590408325,
0.11937656998634338,
0.4124630391597748,
-0.2800438702106476,
-0.40286996960639954,
0.5355698466300964,
-0.532473623752594,
0.5276352763175964,
0.6028181910514832,
0.014512119814753532,
0.07629997283220291,
-0.3525879383087158,
0.704789936542511,
-0.46345949172973633,
0.04721812158823013,
0.2355937510728836,
-0.5262166261672974,
-0.4155179262161255,
-0.12676867842674255,
0.5801462531089783,
0.41566306352615356,
-0.7663516402244568,
0.2982437014579773,
-0.08688675612211227,
-0.47352519631385803,
-0.7890344262123108,
0.23772023618221283,
0.5792160630226135,
0.4520483911037445,
0.3825269043445587,
-0.7002535462379456,
-0.7684186697006226,
-0.891143798828125,
-0.4957984983921051,
0.08310860395431519,
-0.23534807562828064,
0.2661267817020416,
0.36626559495925903,
-0.4674924314022064,
0.9508737921714783,
-0.32295000553131104,
0.04514686390757561,
-0.16129134595394135,
0.30374887585639954,
0.6692332029342651,
0.47277477383613586,
0.494295209646225,
-0.48778170347213745,
-0.27340513467788696,
-0.23512999713420868,
-0.5966901779174805,
-0.4498574733734131,
-0.011982140131294727,
-0.1725667119026184,
0.514340341091156,
0.48453834652900696,
-0.1778837889432907,
0.33135777711868286,
0.7157711386680603,
-0.12000251561403275,
0.9145746231079102,
-0.21060699224472046,
0.4314393401145935,
-0.7052916288375854,
0.4387587606906891,
-0.20090849697589874,
-0.12874431908130646,
-0.4311169981956482,
0.3882463574409485,
0.22455942630767822,
-0.18601873517036438,
-0.3604312539100647,
0.33062389492988586,
-0.3868047297000885,
-0.30267053842544556,
-0.20079606771469116,
-0.16182832419872284,
-0.030190611258149147,
0.5710667371749878,
-0.22946330904960632,
1.055840253829956,
0.29183632135391235,
-0.7077288627624512,
0.6040596961975098,
0.051567766815423965,
-0.5428618788719177,
0.4393356740474701,
-0.6389528512954712,
0.37222641706466675,
0.41316407918930054,
0.3013729155063629,
-0.6055212616920471,
-0.4434281289577484,
-0.016588954254984856,
-0.2838502526283264,
-0.043882809579372406,
-0.33680739998817444,
-0.8057922124862671,
-0.6304846405982971,
-0.4860900342464447,
0.4713066518306732,
0.69478839635849,
-0.4762973189353943,
0.13581907749176025,
0.04339451715350151,
-0.05234595388174057,
-0.2140512615442276,
-0.6991056799888611,
0.4491085112094879,
-0.06297963112592697,
-0.6372843384742737,
0.2500210106372833,
-0.3608112633228302,
0.04753034934401512,
-0.12002060562372208,
-0.38388708233833313,
-0.02790287882089615,
0.26439499855041504,
0.12574881315231323,
0.22824203968048096,
-0.16218475997447968,
-0.241752028465271,
-0.18576562404632568,
-0.20316357910633087,
0.2569163739681244,
-0.028507057577371597,
0.3021663427352905,
-0.46835240721702576,
-0.5171343684196472,
-0.11076174676418304,
0.09748497605323792,
0.28860345482826233,
-0.25673484802246094,
0.17900411784648895,
0.37814825773239136,
-0.4280546307563782,
-0.44235074520111084,
-0.6095706224441528,
-0.06430259346961975,
-0.44619977474212646,
0.014484011568129063,
-0.307686448097229,
-0.8440475463867188,
0.45731958746910095,
-0.12136185169219971,
0.04700382426381111,
0.020365789532661438,
0.4966399371623993,
0.19418387115001678,
0.9279727935791016,
0.37553030252456665,
0.06189172342419624,
0.07976100593805313,
-0.14547576010227203,
0.3847935199737549,
-0.6269754767417908,
0.01606239192187786,
-0.7287639379501343,
-0.3136903941631317,
-0.7271812558174133,
-0.5986104011535645,
0.27777671813964844,
0.13256485760211945,
-0.15397924184799194,
0.6068792343139648,
-0.7894535064697266,
0.6993280053138733,
0.6385074853897095,
-0.19128336012363434,
0.3121265769004822,
-0.15942910313606262,
-0.4980021119117737,
-0.267859548330307,
-0.6872072219848633,
-0.49959129095077515,
1.1388641595840454,
-0.09632508456707001,
0.6114189624786377,
0.25600385665893555,
0.6983312964439392,
0.36148151755332947,
0.1497349888086319,
-0.3877922296524048,
0.4890664517879486,
0.25169727206230164,
-0.7137634754180908,
0.2586778402328491,
-0.8183102011680603,
-0.7704477310180664,
0.12219521403312683,
-0.15519839525222778,
-0.401928186416626,
-0.143348827958107,
0.19347645342350006,
-0.5953516364097595,
0.04985939338803291,
-0.6591312289237976,
1.184853196144104,
-0.13668733835220337,
-0.8470326662063599,
-0.017282620072364807,
-0.6726951003074646,
0.43720710277557373,
-0.07788126915693283,
0.31925421953201294,
-0.1251615732908249,
0.3685813546180725,
0.4262503981590271,
-0.4199967384338379,
0.5676085948944092,
-0.15874941647052765,
0.07030246406793594,
0.3294280767440796,
0.5497708916664124,
0.343792587518692,
0.08033762872219086,
-0.3675828278064728,
-0.002523212693631649,
0.06023057550191879,
-0.5206237435340881,
-0.380389004945755,
0.7367019057273865,
-0.20026123523712158,
-0.30350586771965027,
-0.4713743031024933,
-0.3075107932090759,
-0.3843907117843628,
0.22459489107131958,
0.1695622205734253,
0.8368005156517029,
-0.2848231792449951,
0.09426984935998917,
0.4654250741004944,
-0.5701132416725159,
0.24183432757854462,
0.3623087704181671,
-0.04949207603931427,
-0.16735216975212097,
0.8963791728019714,
-0.2576366066932678,
0.19016888737678528,
-0.034568678587675095,
0.06694350391626358,
-0.24455729126930237,
-0.6570974588394165,
-0.5343546867370605,
-0.15650302171707153,
-0.6202263832092285,
-0.5898339152336121,
-0.3934122323989868,
0.05389920994639397,
-0.15070265531539917,
-0.3265567719936371,
-0.3239279091358185,
-0.09907777607440948,
0.024790123105049133,
0.02766362763941288,
0.33712655305862427,
0.5524118542671204,
-0.24932904541492462,
-0.49993568658828735,
-1.022542953491211,
0.631076455116272,
0.2110505849123001,
0.6621514558792114,
-0.1123749390244484,
-0.36411017179489136,
0.027438679710030556,
-0.022009002044796944,
-0.4095502495765686,
-0.6739124059677124,
0.35892122983932495,
-0.027007391676306725,
0.5601707696914673,
0.00017030767048709095,
0.5418309569358826,
0.7448192834854126,
-0.25885310769081116,
0.6099783778190613,
-0.027983371168375015,
-0.9245520234107971,
0.4299764931201935,
-0.34978482127189636,
0.44968822598457336,
0.9595439434051514,
0.27281880378723145,
-0.6077771186828613,
-0.570676863193512,
-0.4153794050216675,
-0.7472277879714966,
0.7512421011924744,
0.5081188082695007,
0.0022014130372554064,
-0.034884240478277206,
0.09439612179994583,
0.06177429109811783,
0.14235694706439972,
-0.5298196077346802,
0.20261166989803314,
-0.08933919668197632,
-0.12712110579013824,
0.15402787923812866,
0.06223412975668907,
0.0016513823065906763,
-0.3090628385543823,
0.29097655415534973,
-0.32744300365448,
0.32989075779914856,
0.15287119150161743,
-0.2387232929468155,
-0.028375955298542976,
0.23444466292858124,
0.5606632232666016,
0.540613055229187,
-0.49057313799858093,
0.12777909636497498,
0.23015441000461578,
-0.1513422727584839,
-0.06334716081619263,
0.06945644319057465,
0.2943882644176483,
-0.22256024181842804,
0.571937084197998,
0.45114898681640625,
0.5678155422210693,
-1.0655152797698975,
0.4371892809867859,
-0.2976677417755127,
-0.18649660050868988,
0.07674118876457214,
0.3981039822101593,
0.1460723727941513,
0.01612008735537529,
0.15189139544963837,
0.23845095932483673,
0.45525696873664856,
-0.5910013914108276,
0.1968793421983719,
0.1659563034772873,
-0.13704027235507965,
-0.213589608669281,
0.5749583840370178,
0.4632880687713623,
-0.3960958421230316,
0.9790733456611633,
-0.7908899784088135,
-0.6900818347930908,
0.849397599697113,
0.27458763122558594,
0.5811116099357605,
0.06743129342794418,
-0.10397359728813171,
0.6960462927818298,
0.2826484739780426,
-0.08536917716264725,
0.3986828625202179,
-0.15967491269111633,
-0.19141648709774017,
-0.5264596343040466,
-0.6716788411140442,
-0.6171011924743652,
-0.33150872588157654,
-0.7171446681022644,
0.32984212040901184,
-0.5781338810920715,
0.03466438874602318,
-0.16660398244857788,
0.21033410727977753,
-0.833574116230011,
-0.179595485329628,
0.08583942800760269,
0.9827595353126526,
-0.6044594049453735,
0.5990774035453796,
0.6341180801391602,
-0.2618010938167572,
-0.7199875712394714,
-0.3074361979961395,
0.22296841442584991,
-0.3446751534938812,
0.2791922092437744,
0.5920917391777039,
-0.007559743709862232,
-0.06543850898742676,
-0.6109763979911804,
-0.2685442268848419,
0.6484830975532532,
0.46176695823669434,
-0.5391033887863159,
0.15900035202503204,
0.07825496047735214,
0.7766666412353516,
0.05692080780863762,
0.39129772782325745,
0.6943616271018982,
0.4903082251548767,
-0.12995031476020813,
-1.0081098079681396,
0.24474374949932098,
-0.5416385531425476,
-0.00742350472137332,
0.2718668580055237,
-0.2667703628540039,
0.5240744948387146,
-0.2502121925354004,
-0.286038875579834,
0.07853347063064575,
0.17456407845020294,
0.49759048223495483,
0.4346347153186798,
0.19075776636600494,
0.4201543927192688,
0.6956820487976074,
-0.21099448204040527,
1.2534292936325073,
-0.17340444028377533,
0.4199225902557373,
0.8125494718551636,
-0.4911190867424011,
0.5729986429214478,
0.3600153625011444,
-0.5417688488960266,
0.30697259306907654,
0.7385036945343018,
-0.18302081525325775,
0.4029213786125183,
0.8455394506454468,
0.06689169257879257,
-0.4922272861003876,
0.09225638210773468,
-0.601499617099762,
0.18632632493972778,
-0.04793497547507286,
0.37559974193573,
-0.3601830005645752,
-0.2148822546005249,
-0.2912207543849945,
0.2739994525909424,
0.13071976602077484,
0.5255378484725952,
0.0948135033249855,
-0.6958977580070496,
1.1462773084640503,
0.2932071387767792,
0.8070133924484253,
-0.4532567858695984,
-0.29042601585388184,
-0.5981535315513611,
-0.023022634908556938,
-0.22231492400169373,
-0.48958417773246765,
0.6122618317604065,
0.40255817770957947,
0.1837938129901886,
-0.11585002392530441,
0.3392966687679291,
0.2225790023803711,
-0.23010414838790894,
0.21843872964382172,
0.14203566312789917,
0.19450289011001587,
-0.22365424036979675,
-0.9100069403648376,
0.3756522238254547,
0.18323248624801636,
-0.10512424260377884,
0.26808780431747437,
0.35134780406951904,
-0.1354527324438095,
0.6268392205238342,
1.0689948797225952,
-0.22712861001491547,
0.10381051152944565,
-0.15271683037281036,
0.9407742023468018,
-1.0163651704788208,
-0.47224363684654236,
-0.6920760273933411,
0.15897183120250702,
-0.07328616827726364,
-0.4848520755767822,
0.6043451428413391,
0.6309142708778381,
0.8809773325920105,
-0.1518353521823883,
0.43504446744918823,
-0.2718523144721985,
0.3067338168621063,
-0.6024379730224609,
0.4483967125415802,
-0.4016089141368866,
0.32422637939453125,
-0.4645678699016571,
-1.149336338043213,
-0.46814706921577454,
0.5610107779502869,
-0.046231288462877274,
-0.16482333838939667,
0.714996337890625,
1.083419919013977,
-0.17271502315998077,
0.08462276309728622,
0.15242531895637512,
-0.014759997837245464,
0.45350217819213867,
0.9834023118019104,
0.9969750642776489,
-0.27463430166244507,
0.560837984085083,
-0.2139415293931961,
-0.17279493808746338,
-0.5549699664115906,
-1.2651121616363525,
-0.872683048248291,
-0.2273523509502411,
-0.35289865732192993,
-0.3022480905056,
0.04819730296730995,
1.1563011407852173,
0.5501280426979065,
-0.8972387313842773,
-0.16903367638587952,
-0.43330445885658264,
0.047036297619342804,
-0.27203336358070374,
-0.20061556994915009,
-0.01199075672775507,
-0.20155999064445496,
-0.5636743903160095,
0.5458689332008362,
-0.004807549063116312,
-0.12896978855133057,
-0.11695537716150284,
-0.19599047303199768,
0.019387036561965942,
-0.0025861982721835375,
0.205385223031044,
0.5582857728004456,
-0.3961586356163025,
-0.002836225787177682,
-0.013873372226953506,
-0.3826836049556732,
-0.04313132166862488,
0.8796352744102478,
-0.8273531198501587,
0.5922935009002686,
0.578528106212616,
1.0722157955169678,
0.34424373507499695,
0.04232971370220184,
0.5442649126052856,
-0.6665319204330444,
-0.07306434214115143,
0.4759916365146637,
0.09671419858932495,
0.46033304929733276,
-0.06586276739835739,
0.725375771522522,
0.12446226924657822,
-0.40092673897743225,
-1.3256016969680786,
0.038883473724126816,
-0.9710410833358765,
-0.19198666512966156,
1.1275067329406738,
0.17367000877857208,
-0.14661777019500732,
-0.2981201708316803,
-0.279262512922287,
0.017185911536216736,
-0.2989600896835327,
0.7194647192955017,
0.7031865119934082,
-0.05524970591068268,
0.30457788705825806,
-1.0266436338424683,
0.5196072459220886,
0.5233117938041687,
-0.9252495765686035,
0.07339143007993698,
0.7384480834007263,
0.3034224212169647,
-0.16570362448692322,
0.4019196033477783,
-0.10584376007318497,
0.6151469349861145,
-0.01883762702345848,
0.4761550724506378,
-0.38608309626579285,
-0.059998754411935806,
-0.4516427516937256,
0.03911060094833374,
0.26905396580696106,
0.20406848192214966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04515v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04515v2
|
A Transformer with Stack Attention
| 2024-05-07T17:47:57 | 2024-05-13T18:56:18 |
Jiaoda Li, Jennifer C. White, Mrinmaya Sachan, Ryan Cotterell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural languages are believed to be (mildly) context-sensitive. Despite
underpinning remarkably capable large language models, transformers are unable
to model many context-free language tasks. In an attempt to address this
limitation in the modeling power of transformer-based language models, we
propose augmenting them with a differentiable, stack-based attention mechanism.
Our stack-based attention mechanism can be incorporated into any
transformer-based language model and adds a level of interpretability to the
model. We show that the addition of our stack-based attention mechanism enables
the transformer to model some, but not all, deterministic context-free
languages.
|
[
-0.5048229098320007,
-0.42667198181152344,
0.2180909514427185,
0.5269899368286133,
0.059228360652923584,
-0.09761323779821396,
-0.07700028270483017,
-0.6299229860305786,
0.08573392778635025,
0.6576192378997803,
-0.5865438580513,
0.15853780508041382,
-0.6303611397743225,
0.18247991800308228,
-0.7023941278457642,
1.2944912910461426,
0.10792551934719086,
-0.48398256301879883,
-0.09751259535551071,
-0.007513660937547684,
-0.39241474866867065,
-0.3677281439304352,
-0.5084835886955261,
-0.44646817445755005,
0.5325339436531067,
0.12269171327352524,
0.9027133584022522,
0.3866225779056549,
0.7677325010299683,
0.25616541504859924,
-0.20713937282562256,
-0.4142049551010132,
-0.6365723609924316,
-0.12554752826690674,
-0.33439382910728455,
-0.9268414378166199,
-0.5237207412719727,
-0.08721131086349487,
0.7157540321350098,
0.681053638458252,
0.25045397877693176,
0.01606760360300541,
-0.3020051121711731,
0.6818017363548279,
-0.550081193447113,
0.2112867534160614,
-0.7058748602867126,
0.09013920277357101,
0.049552809447050095,
-0.0013871039263904095,
-0.7727272510528564,
-0.14107786118984222,
0.23798798024654388,
-0.2774735689163208,
0.5162065625190735,
0.25557219982147217,
0.6705159544944763,
0.7022236585617065,
-0.44490399956703186,
0.16517260670661926,
-1.0963995456695557,
1.0483359098434448,
-0.4472997784614563,
0.5963836908340454,
0.26749730110168457,
0.5229814052581787,
0.1951451599597931,
-0.5770789384841919,
-0.6164911389350891,
-0.3300483822822571,
-0.54702228307724,
0.23146823048591614,
-0.5921001434326172,
-0.09545048326253891,
0.5552222728729248,
0.7497640252113342,
-0.08627057820558548,
-0.04143764451146126,
-0.2797052562236786,
-0.06725705415010452,
0.2524064779281616,
0.24240072071552277,
0.6071265339851379,
-0.2637326121330261,
-0.5504454374313354,
0.06430923193693161,
-0.6986515522003174,
0.31438198685646057,
0.20400623977184296,
0.4312523305416107,
-0.4646630883216858,
0.5545728802680969,
-0.15594632923603058,
0.7694834470748901,
0.42621171474456787,
0.3059588372707367,
-0.17342215776443481,
-0.0712612196803093,
-0.2893621325492859,
-0.08056167513132095,
0.29964008927345276,
0.18073499202728271,
0.2327968031167984,
-0.4603739082813263,
-0.26737073063850403,
0.24233420193195343,
0.6312442421913147,
-0.7607404589653015,
-0.33818140625953674,
0.3239399194717407,
-0.1796448528766632,
-0.5134785771369934,
-0.15617959201335907,
-0.34221702814102173,
0.23056727647781372,
0.013641438446938992,
0.21080446243286133,
-0.32985037565231323,
-0.2020416110754013,
-0.011056301183998585,
-0.11736395955085754,
0.3650072515010834,
-0.07587309926748276,
-1.5364514589309692,
0.6183664798736572,
0.6937001347541809,
0.6568459272384644,
-0.1386536806821823,
-0.19566451013088226,
-0.6042801737785339,
0.3100701868534088,
-0.25047996640205383,
1.0886013507843018,
-0.9224610328674316,
-0.3544200360774994,
-0.3232543170452118,
0.29326412081718445,
-0.3855970799922943,
-0.30660131573677063,
0.7033932209014893,
-0.7501803040504456,
0.6786149144172668,
-0.10318461805582047,
-0.13369198143482208,
-0.23187801241874695,
0.056811586022377014,
-1.0095843076705933,
1.1113204956054688,
0.4379619359970093,
-1.0367857217788696,
0.002247183583676815,
-0.9034159779548645,
-0.719086229801178,
0.3084914982318878,
0.18222010135650635,
-0.16070003807544708,
0.3668633699417114,
0.281488299369812,
0.12307977676391602,
-0.35436996817588806,
0.18184295296669006,
0.13851390779018402,
-0.4354495406150818,
0.04734678938984871,
-0.48579201102256775,
1.048716425895691,
-0.09432952851057053,
-0.22467829287052155,
0.22205929458141327,
-0.8482833504676819,
-0.24779967963695526,
-0.03100155107676983,
-0.3768250048160553,
-0.40462714433670044,
0.01791021227836609,
0.24974322319030762,
0.46009641885757446,
0.15403392910957336,
-0.44119009375572205,
0.3059716820716858,
-1.2110868692398071,
0.4108734130859375,
0.35543006658554077,
-0.2862338125705719,
0.7927265763282776,
-0.3769289255142212,
0.6352337002754211,
0.05703844502568245,
-0.08790513873100281,
-0.14278221130371094,
-0.43323004245758057,
-1.0085903406143188,
-0.3778344392776489,
-0.06449239701032639,
0.5509434342384338,
-0.5072304010391235,
0.33368566632270813,
-0.35855329036712646,
-0.34173497557640076,
-0.7153292298316956,
-0.0520508848130703,
0.6100666522979736,
0.6587582230567932,
0.36456504464149475,
-0.37964728474617004,
-0.5394938588142395,
-1.2154600620269775,
-0.32330724596977234,
0.0711868554353714,
-0.3955122232437134,
0.279045432806015,
0.43609070777893066,
-0.3065727651119232,
1.0282601118087769,
-0.4575416147708893,
-0.17269444465637207,
-0.3828376531600952,
-0.02126145362854004,
0.3330346643924713,
0.17412161827087402,
0.5462002158164978,
-0.8787192106246948,
-0.3596210479736328,
0.009109552018344402,
-0.34928277134895325,
-0.09569958597421646,
0.07182639837265015,
-0.025903673842549324,
-0.03726857155561447,
0.41325101256370544,
-0.6610736846923828,
0.21082687377929688,
0.5956303477287292,
-0.11145266890525818,
0.33836138248443604,
0.020015014335513115,
-0.13733124732971191,
-1.1893457174301147,
0.15870530903339386,
-0.1595424860715866,
-0.11022255569696426,
-1.1306266784667969,
0.12889228761196136,
0.22927911579608917,
-0.17349889874458313,
-0.9401025176048279,
0.8756498098373413,
-0.3023453950881958,
-0.19437582790851593,
-0.4672500193119049,
0.06213942915201187,
0.10948830842971802,
0.5946308970451355,
0.26881974935531616,
0.45862874388694763,
0.665951669216156,
-0.665346086025238,
0.24513043463230133,
0.49926888942718506,
-0.17653381824493408,
0.75185227394104,
-0.9551441669464111,
0.04883052781224251,
-0.26870205998420715,
0.31953510642051697,
-1.1583033800125122,
-0.5691519379615784,
0.051113251596689224,
0.04197079688310623,
0.2299848347902298,
-0.18505312502384186,
-0.06017416715621948,
-0.6489171981811523,
-0.3197377920150757,
0.4120115041732788,
0.18279488384723663,
-0.6582570672035217,
0.6452531218528748,
0.04608478024601936,
-0.010971665382385254,
-0.5205321311950684,
-0.8440458178520203,
-0.02895481325685978,
-0.08579356223344803,
-0.7015536427497864,
0.5343710780143738,
-0.06432041525840759,
-0.3298359513282776,
0.07134685665369034,
-0.12110503017902374,
-0.08599384874105453,
0.26452258229255676,
0.3006596565246582,
0.2751208245754242,
-0.38236144185066223,
0.13724598288536072,
-0.062134865671396255,
-0.6614406704902649,
-0.0019663043785840273,
-0.14312832057476044,
0.3605029284954071,
-0.37227216362953186,
-0.37314385175704956,
-0.3436981737613678,
0.4824638366699219,
0.8294159173965454,
-0.46391692757606506,
0.673434317111969,
0.4055984914302826,
-0.5614039301872253,
-0.17140276730060577,
-0.370518296957016,
-0.46979668736457825,
-0.4893871247768402,
0.22223564982414246,
-0.46210283041000366,
-1.109423041343689,
0.6844450831413269,
0.3367733061313629,
0.09851029515266418,
0.6961433291435242,
0.7680372595787048,
0.18851542472839355,
1.1455084085464478,
1.0063985586166382,
-0.22944989800453186,
0.5517891049385071,
0.3951708972454071,
0.6277239918708801,
-1.1363441944122314,
0.14973077178001404,
-0.6109985709190369,
-0.38829660415649414,
-0.7034056782722473,
-0.1373426914215088,
-0.006599516607820988,
-0.15566106140613556,
-0.016029348596930504,
0.7954403758049011,
-0.8243564963340759,
0.7201483845710754,
0.4711499810218811,
-0.36844226717948914,
0.4653056561946869,
-0.2596973180770874,
0.1715366691350937,
-0.10672882199287415,
-0.7243483066558838,
-0.4719473719596863,
0.4387553632259369,
0.3364395499229431,
0.8485111594200134,
0.3014879524707794,
0.19659961760044098,
-0.14526818692684174,
0.5687321424484253,
-0.7976179122924805,
0.29320859909057617,
-0.29638513922691345,
-0.9500202536582947,
-0.25189152359962463,
-0.19783928990364075,
-0.7218882441520691,
0.23715518414974213,
0.22233986854553223,
-1.0740900039672852,
0.1043793335556984,
0.1437087059020996,
-0.45676732063293457,
0.1782197207212448,
-1.0662304162979126,
0.8753531575202942,
-0.09379244595766068,
-0.12757596373558044,
0.10777124762535095,
-0.6916662454605103,
0.519592821598053,
-0.03135501593351364,
0.25036612153053284,
-0.10960524529218674,
0.15637509524822235,
0.44040918350219727,
-0.0995851457118988,
1.108180046081543,
0.2899338901042938,
-0.44254937767982483,
0.104194276034832,
0.2484620213508606,
0.6666441559791565,
-0.16320545971393585,
0.024218430742621422,
-0.172235906124115,
-0.3248036503791809,
-0.46384212374687195,
-0.6249619722366333,
0.7044106721878052,
-0.5177478194236755,
-0.8754573464393616,
0.052776698023080826,
-1.0266081094741821,
-0.22244732081890106,
0.32096269726753235,
0.3280015289783478,
0.3108024597167969,
-0.06665357947349548,
0.20247367024421692,
0.4529559016227722,
0.09560859203338623,
0.7896284461021423,
0.5217185020446777,
-0.1699494570493698,
0.2687559425830841,
0.9037245512008667,
-0.1540023535490036,
0.4348706007003784,
0.9512082934379578,
0.3210718631744385,
-0.2936002314090729,
-0.009022876620292664,
-0.06443805247545242,
-0.023339752107858658,
-0.5390461683273315,
0.27801117300987244,
-0.9772846698760986,
-0.3043789565563202,
-0.2821182608604431,
-0.350956529378891,
-0.347825825214386,
-0.843062698841095,
-0.07191416621208191,
-0.18153437972068787,
0.5026743412017822,
0.6871058940887451,
0.2861612141132355,
0.4544093906879425,
-0.5994709134101868,
0.6357597708702087,
0.6834549307823181,
0.6587495803833008,
0.05411841347813606,
-0.7102595567703247,
-0.015130885876715183,
-0.311105877161026,
-0.10394052416086197,
-0.49350297451019287,
0.49325066804885864,
0.12915556132793427,
0.5538093447685242,
0.41960668563842773,
0.020394716411828995,
0.17580972611904144,
-0.5411584973335266,
0.5088650584220886,
0.044869210571050644,
-1.0866410732269287,
0.7352640628814697,
-0.4650772213935852,
0.6964346170425415,
0.1537269502878189,
0.34175464510917664,
-0.5148547887802124,
-0.947479248046875,
-0.6352046132087708,
-0.7642003297805786,
1.055578351020813,
0.30661740899086,
0.5613652467727661,
-0.11437909305095673,
-0.054502759128808975,
0.06334766000509262,
0.018971839919686317,
-1.0953847169876099,
-0.0015421368880197406,
-0.29150834679603577,
-0.07951939851045609,
0.09806837141513824,
-0.3466370701789856,
-0.1599128097295761,
0.039642333984375,
0.5596829056739807,
-0.061267219483852386,
0.29622501134872437,
-0.12635013461112976,
-0.20202042162418365,
-0.2793152928352356,
0.6105741858482361,
0.772426426410675,
0.11278186738491058,
-0.22030818462371826,
0.6129750609397888,
0.28605836629867554,
-0.4287039637565613,
0.0018041398143395782,
-0.03300050273537636,
-0.35134637355804443,
-0.2781583070755005,
0.26398754119873047,
0.9807637929916382,
0.8845351338386536,
-0.33461058139801025,
0.1708841472864151,
-0.026544369757175446,
0.0649779736995697,
0.3113980293273926,
0.2334093302488327,
0.47501128911972046,
0.13097073137760162,
0.30065682530403137,
0.22974646091461182,
0.025347962975502014,
-0.3287810981273651,
0.40925315022468567,
0.30913248658180237,
-0.9474600553512573,
-0.5484075546264648,
0.9913867115974426,
0.4488297700881958,
-0.7558667659759521,
0.23456856608390808,
0.04113081842660904,
-0.6630176305770874,
0.6593577265739441,
0.9672012329101562,
0.9118912816047668,
-0.48295414447784424,
0.0014730760594829917,
0.18894758820533752,
0.5313037037849426,
0.05679590255022049,
-0.07533470541238785,
-0.01719481311738491,
-0.8349226117134094,
-0.4314654767513275,
-0.40940380096435547,
-0.5687923431396484,
-0.10506119579076767,
-0.5925213098526001,
0.1525776982307434,
-0.2114247828722,
0.03699641674757004,
0.1970447301864624,
-0.43774235248565674,
-0.5039074420928955,
0.46518439054489136,
-0.13251225650310516,
0.480948269367218,
-0.8056466579437256,
0.7518443465232849,
0.5766710638999939,
-0.33312535285949707,
-0.36046281456947327,
0.07725824415683746,
-0.316069096326828,
-0.7670299410820007,
0.7340061664581299,
0.47590768337249756,
-0.5125477313995361,
0.1830163449048996,
-0.27114421129226685,
-0.9418315291404724,
0.523730456829071,
0.5253828763961792,
-0.6421340107917786,
-0.03295950964093208,
-0.002915050834417343,
0.804966926574707,
-0.3891032636165619,
0.4455723762512207,
0.36822882294654846,
0.28832635283470154,
-0.07633409649133682,
-0.5967949032783508,
0.23892192542552948,
-0.350848525762558,
-0.013975693844258785,
0.38639014959335327,
-0.8036013841629028,
0.8347793817520142,
-0.3388359844684601,
-0.5848398208618164,
-0.5189552903175354,
0.48444023728370667,
-0.2630135416984558,
-0.10424811393022537,
0.45644405484199524,
0.471612811088562,
0.5219901204109192,
-0.0180515144020319,
1.5090019702911377,
-0.5231167674064636,
0.4091738164424896,
1.2513301372528076,
-0.33868059515953064,
0.8626230359077454,
0.5764843821525574,
-0.20939631760120392,
0.6530498266220093,
0.11592845618724823,
0.0031093743164092302,
0.543079137802124,
-0.09813406318426132,
-0.3927723169326782,
-0.28337621688842773,
-0.20388834178447723,
-0.10285993665456772,
0.20989489555358887,
-0.031838078051805496,
-0.3267761170864105,
-0.2783188819885254,
0.03322970122098923,
-0.40708696842193604,
-0.05476270988583565,
-0.09411786496639252,
0.583192765712738,
0.07248792797327042,
-0.7122109532356262,
0.5323067903518677,
-0.06408815830945969,
0.6126728653907776,
-0.20316053926944733,
0.27988895773887634,
-0.04688209667801857,
0.05360623821616173,
-0.3095199167728424,
-0.5840004086494446,
0.8380244374275208,
0.11673428863286972,
-0.7889233231544495,
-0.30280908942222595,
0.8661934733390808,
-0.2705153822898865,
-0.675643801689148,
0.28067463636398315,
0.3382132649421692,
-0.020404314622282982,
-0.09385304898023605,
-0.19021421670913696,
-0.26232606172561646,
-0.02326095476746559,
-0.4179062843322754,
0.1759042590856552,
0.16047057509422302,
-0.2938186824321747,
0.8435128927230835,
0.6466113328933716,
-0.5664705038070679,
-0.09574087709188461,
0.44998323917388916,
0.6725481748580933,
-0.6584030985832214,
-0.5672578811645508,
-0.8504120707511902,
0.6415346264839172,
0.2161247879266739,
-0.25210464000701904,
0.5754535794258118,
0.3598707616329193,
0.5325788855552673,
-0.2850613594055176,
0.8061966300010681,
-0.08080989867448807,
0.3942714035511017,
-0.08095642924308777,
0.6138886213302612,
-0.29842609167099,
0.22041583061218262,
-0.09056942909955978,
-0.961946427822113,
-0.48730507493019104,
0.6022763252258301,
-0.7257275581359863,
-0.14555144309997559,
0.7819058299064636,
0.6380454897880554,
-0.21110349893569946,
0.2164141982793808,
0.529180109500885,
0.23095457255840302,
0.17866040766239166,
0.9195401072502136,
0.8099995851516724,
-0.37762880325317383,
0.5518749356269836,
-0.1503414362668991,
-0.17193487286567688,
-0.34675031900405884,
-1.0896445512771606,
-1.10532808303833,
-0.5001267194747925,
-0.16054637730121613,
0.1033017635345459,
-0.3509078919887543,
0.3856336176395416,
0.5318878889083862,
-1.0586885213851929,
0.23764054477214813,
-0.3537108302116394,
0.4726487398147583,
-0.2766096889972687,
-0.3088160753250122,
0.1837310492992401,
-0.27593278884887695,
-1.0276750326156616,
0.4500292241573334,
0.6294571757316589,
0.20116209983825684,
-0.23748548328876495,
0.366976261138916,
0.1339036077260971,
0.3108268678188324,
0.7804683446884155,
0.3360956311225891,
-0.8133546710014343,
-0.6542543768882751,
0.19029073417186737,
-0.2949991226196289,
0.23738788068294525,
0.6750831604003906,
-0.6444934010505676,
0.45407482981681824,
0.491903156042099,
0.5274636149406433,
0.6396921277046204,
-0.026199396699666977,
0.6907323598861694,
-1.0536980628967285,
0.4973140060901642,
0.28225579857826233,
0.24114423990249634,
0.4496828615665436,
-0.4872530698776245,
0.3932822048664093,
-0.033329833298921585,
-0.21944086253643036,
-0.6190809607505798,
0.6559218764305115,
-1.1519606113433838,
0.16590188443660736,
0.8504299521446228,
0.16561228036880493,
-0.3572949767112732,
-0.22284355759620667,
-0.3380596935749054,
0.10009414702653885,
-0.2225179523229599,
0.8730457425117493,
0.8406949639320374,
-0.09238361567258835,
-0.29242825508117676,
-0.4566531479358673,
0.3514736294746399,
0.6335439085960388,
-0.9158042073249817,
0.31814077496528625,
-0.00025622843531891704,
0.14371106028556824,
0.5344916582107544,
0.3497723937034607,
-0.06526497006416321,
0.3356715738773346,
0.04466189444065094,
-0.06662465631961823,
0.20574675500392914,
-0.29326024651527405,
-0.309814989566803,
0.4083126187324524,
-0.18391714990139008,
0.18149641156196594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06692v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06692v1
|
Analyzing Language Bias Between French and English in Conventional Multilingual Sentiment Analysis Models
| 2024-05-07T17:46:36 | 2024-05-07T17:46:36 |
Ethan Parker Wong, Faten M'hiri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Inspired by the 'Bias Considerations in Bilingual Natural Language
Processing' report by Statistics Canada, this study delves into potential
biases in multilingual sentiment analysis between English and French. Given a
50-50 dataset of French and English, we aim to determine if there exists a
language bias and explore how the incorporation of more diverse datasets in the
future might affect the equity of multilingual Natural Language Processing
(NLP) systems. By employing Support Vector Machine (SVM) and Naive Bayes models
on three balanced datasets, we reveal potential biases in multilingual
sentiment classification. Utilizing Fairlearn, a tool for assessing bias in
machine learning models, our findings indicate nuanced outcomes. With French
data outperforming English across accuracy, recall, and F1 score metrics in
both models, hinting at a language bias favoring French. However, Fairlearn's
metrics suggest that the SVM approaches equitable levels with a demographic
parity ratio of 0.963, 0.989, and 0.985 for the three separate datasets,
indicating near-equitable treatment across languages. In contrast, Naive Bayes
demonstrates greater disparities, evidenced by a demographic parity ratio of
0.813, 0.908, and 0.961. These findings reveal the importance of developing
equitable multilingual NLP systems, particularly as we anticipate the inclusion
of more datasets in various languages in the future.
|
[
-0.4826180636882782,
-0.1278681457042694,
0.15697400271892548,
0.773665726184845,
0.23418334126472473,
0.11572103202342987,
-0.19016122817993164,
-0.4050523340702057,
0.05708298087120056,
0.24930541217327118,
-0.3598627746105194,
-0.4752010703086853,
-0.914883017539978,
0.1825452297925949,
0.019580060616135597,
1.0708197355270386,
0.20480841398239136,
0.9404059648513794,
-0.17273946106433868,
-0.6180825233459473,
-0.5880146026611328,
-0.9299772381782532,
-0.6727597713470459,
-0.2342803180217743,
0.5545752048492432,
0.22249123454093933,
0.694957971572876,
0.02079511061310768,
0.30720776319503784,
0.2063167691230774,
0.05418872833251953,
-0.20933431386947632,
-0.16505423188209534,
-0.005205783061683178,
-0.23714840412139893,
-0.7106350064277649,
-0.604863703250885,
0.13465239107608795,
0.497538298368454,
0.8785809874534607,
0.10257428139448166,
-0.0562942773103714,
0.34242668747901917,
0.9756481051445007,
-0.6274906396865845,
0.21228249371051788,
-0.3424955904483795,
0.34542521834373474,
-0.21247854828834534,
-0.017218222841620445,
-0.319665789604187,
-0.3539000153541565,
0.11509797722101212,
-0.09853831678628922,
0.2641356289386749,
-0.181972935795784,
0.49004918336868286,
0.0485268197953701,
-0.6576038599014282,
-0.03621843829751015,
-0.29874157905578613,
1.3858529329299927,
-0.5486717820167542,
0.7224750518798828,
0.13613277673721313,
0.19653502106666565,
0.21561160683631897,
-0.12424440681934357,
-0.5065467357635498,
0.20313510298728943,
0.11475220322608948,
0.30208536982536316,
-0.2200368195772171,
-0.28523799777030945,
0.25457894802093506,
0.059573911130428314,
-0.631777286529541,
0.12924452126026154,
-0.2575199604034424,
-0.29575487971305847,
0.6088710427284241,
-0.248866468667984,
0.39088794589042664,
-0.4682219326496124,
-0.2591223120689392,
-0.10170619934797287,
-0.43893304467201233,
0.3854973316192627,
0.78033447265625,
0.5253984928131104,
-0.3065590560436249,
0.5959500670433044,
0.08048924058675766,
0.5413304567337036,
-0.6133687496185303,
0.03144528716802597,
0.7641989588737488,
-0.22301547229290009,
-0.04968872666358948,
-0.049828942865133286,
1.0217610597610474,
1.0332508087158203,
0.8118259906768799,
0.07251115143299103,
-0.25791218876838684,
0.42980316281318665,
-0.07925987243652344,
-0.32264280319213867,
-0.05253712460398674,
0.28706544637680054,
-0.4516671597957611,
-0.021086078137159348,
0.07771091908216476,
-1.156818151473999,
-0.3836246132850647,
-0.42199447751045227,
-0.1734752357006073,
-0.22877494990825653,
-0.33098024129867554,
0.20499765872955322,
-0.42514151334762573,
0.3364779055118561,
0.22588291764259338,
-0.5387511253356934,
0.27724969387054443,
0.5690801739692688,
0.7277631759643555,
-0.30022644996643066,
-0.2382041960954666,
-0.5001609921455383,
-0.33543860912323,
-0.062052249908447266,
0.6929465532302856,
-0.6309201717376709,
-0.515454113483429,
0.3692411184310913,
0.19674590229988098,
-0.13267865777015686,
-0.4359464645385742,
0.7928898930549622,
-0.2633588910102844,
0.5222675800323486,
-0.5383827090263367,
-0.22356878221035004,
-0.1762571483850479,
0.3021855652332306,
-0.991562008857727,
0.9046502709388733,
-0.12551580369472504,
-1.072961688041687,
0.7004493474960327,
-0.4302380383014679,
-0.5004999041557312,
-0.3600425124168396,
-0.4825078845024109,
-0.23908793926239014,
-0.045384399592876434,
0.7093735933303833,
0.518612265586853,
-0.2708652913570404,
0.4460512399673462,
-0.5385140180587769,
0.1552143096923828,
0.29572078585624695,
-0.7886004447937012,
1.1596534252166748,
0.10639803111553192,
-0.2239832729101181,
-0.43706899881362915,
-0.5422593951225281,
-0.15683609247207642,
-0.03171618655323982,
-0.15618570148944855,
-0.40654778480529785,
0.16402265429496765,
0.436832994222641,
0.5909117460250854,
0.12956687808036804,
-0.5830230712890625,
-0.08291083574295044,
-0.5832491517066956,
0.12533269822597504,
0.8048795461654663,
-0.2645644545555115,
0.8079904913902283,
-0.24675573408603668,
0.6945360898971558,
0.17747417092323303,
0.2442941963672638,
0.03149839863181114,
-0.8475820422172546,
-0.5782122015953064,
-0.2593168020248413,
0.37949588894844055,
0.8524339199066162,
-0.5783597230911255,
0.15697096288204193,
-0.34141331911087036,
0.3291150629520416,
-0.7068637013435364,
0.15323404967784882,
0.17482367157936096,
0.3253682255744934,
0.3839705288410187,
-0.4004417359828949,
-0.371267169713974,
-1.430449366569519,
-0.6625297665596008,
0.030349230393767357,
0.021058043465018272,
0.16229818761348724,
0.21283964812755585,
-0.14353960752487183,
0.955490231513977,
-0.1725352555513382,
-0.3176546096801758,
-0.3014933168888092,
0.048119328916072845,
0.2528568208217621,
0.3346140384674072,
1.0192407369613647,
-0.9576193690299988,
-0.656668484210968,
-0.06613607704639435,
-0.673782467842102,
-0.2510000169277191,
0.2642067074775696,
-0.11496852338314056,
0.3522510826587677,
0.1422126293182373,
-0.25176024436950684,
0.20663487911224365,
0.6015554070472717,
-0.12670066952705383,
-0.015222428366541862,
0.3118157684803009,
0.2641441524028778,
-1.0614124536514282,
-0.17604218423366547,
0.6525828242301941,
-0.1825553923845291,
-0.4092354476451874,
-0.33283117413520813,
0.11588885635137558,
0.17068392038345337,
-0.495438814163208,
0.5844854116439819,
-0.18698401749134064,
0.10571002960205078,
0.10924842953681946,
0.10649839043617249,
0.14254222810268402,
0.3246862590312958,
0.1938324272632599,
0.30468541383743286,
0.6276151537895203,
-0.20012205839157104,
0.07971855252981186,
-0.09504434466362,
-0.03569502755999565,
0.7561702132225037,
-0.2705860733985901,
-0.2028862088918686,
-0.4871772825717926,
0.11702662706375122,
-0.8744568228721619,
0.14649422466754913,
0.24993079900741577,
-0.7256647348403931,
0.3307036757469177,
-0.2741057872772217,
-0.3130704164505005,
-0.29827335476875305,
-0.6140413880348206,
0.417439728975296,
0.29003551602363586,
-0.4368789494037628,
0.45305049419403076,
0.7263514399528503,
-0.653759241104126,
-1.225106120109558,
-0.9630246758460999,
-0.05001245439052582,
-0.09327645599842072,
-0.5593495965003967,
-0.1188494861125946,
0.01528520043939352,
-0.6218509674072266,
-0.1700485199689865,
0.0640774592757225,
-0.12138884514570236,
-0.2061251699924469,
0.08710524439811707,
0.4153648316860199,
0.027383865788578987,
0.16285662353038788,
0.3163929283618927,
0.0004527186101768166,
0.17931653559207916,
-0.33978691697120667,
0.41246870160102844,
-0.038945022970438004,
-0.3308732211589813,
-0.09563273191452026,
0.5397657752037048,
0.5391077995300293,
-0.230715811252594,
0.6724352836608887,
0.6107354164123535,
-0.46252506971359253,
-0.27408671379089355,
-0.6552820801734924,
0.035919129848480225,
-0.3129364252090454,
0.3265245854854584,
-0.1628689467906952,
-0.8228563666343689,
0.4673070013523102,
0.5532262921333313,
0.20615434646606445,
0.6707929372787476,
0.6727767586708069,
0.007621544413268566,
1.4239579439163208,
0.553356945514679,
-0.8090985417366028,
0.18684804439544678,
-0.19379819929599762,
0.3392002582550049,
-0.3249402642250061,
-0.30275222659111023,
-0.8273683786392212,
-0.3120352327823639,
-0.8931674957275391,
-0.47689706087112427,
0.09774313122034073,
-0.04011417180299759,
0.10533416271209717,
-0.2140662521123886,
-0.3610614836215973,
0.2902756631374359,
0.4892784357070923,
-0.26061972975730896,
0.029120760038495064,
0.3014499545097351,
-0.4228900372982025,
-0.574521541595459,
-0.965613842010498,
-0.7119991183280945,
1.318077802658081,
0.5325177907943726,
0.4296572506427765,
-0.029248319566249847,
0.4796158969402313,
0.42846864461898804,
0.424480676651001,
-0.7251144051551819,
0.16404631733894348,
-0.40183785557746887,
-0.5784507393836975,
-0.10077441483736038,
-0.5859604477882385,
-0.7502080798149109,
0.46535709500312805,
-0.21756741404533386,
-0.34865888953208923,
0.4706135392189026,
-0.02355060540139675,
-0.1315990537405014,
0.24286533892154694,
-0.7200084924697876,
0.826230525970459,
-0.2090449184179306,
-0.47248539328575134,
-0.07795499265193939,
-0.537438690662384,
0.4360106289386749,
-0.13698959350585938,
1.1345582008361816,
-0.20000387728214264,
0.12377548217773438,
0.7235827445983887,
-0.13735024631023407,
0.8098620176315308,
-0.3941677212715149,
-0.33827999234199524,
-0.021748296916484833,
-0.26943597197532654,
-0.011808151379227638,
0.5250153541564941,
-0.37643909454345703,
0.48394331336021423,
-0.027211589738726616,
-0.6754569411277771,
-0.2148095816373825,
0.9323245286941528,
-0.9842092394828796,
-0.11241693794727325,
-0.7776663303375244,
-0.43362298607826233,
-0.43899455666542053,
-0.21064791083335876,
0.3098595440387726,
0.2482990175485611,
-0.3045639097690582,
-0.188247948884964,
0.5231300592422485,
-0.7154514789581299,
0.47258612513542175,
0.4360712766647339,
-0.2066127210855484,
-0.25678789615631104,
0.9638306498527527,
0.30299484729766846,
-0.00227772886864841,
0.5704026222229004,
0.1069285050034523,
-0.49517351388931274,
-0.04854089394211769,
-0.48745882511138916,
0.05643947049975395,
-0.7711006999015808,
-0.16012217104434967,
-0.8972445130348206,
0.012009670957922935,
-0.6056718230247498,
-0.1919282227754593,
-0.29832178354263306,
-0.5404248833656311,
0.150327667593956,
-0.13610926270484924,
0.1790415644645691,
0.4981454014778137,
-0.0829647034406662,
-0.019334718585014343,
-0.8507066965103149,
0.4120328426361084,
0.22783051431179047,
0.29456543922424316,
-0.08487790822982788,
-0.29521089792251587,
-0.07197950780391693,
0.30681055784225464,
-0.2245396077632904,
-0.932296872138977,
0.6514127254486084,
0.05089118331670761,
0.679495632648468,
0.16960516571998596,
-0.29163506627082825,
0.049750328063964844,
-0.6468981504440308,
1.0264167785644531,
0.42043426632881165,
-0.7690207362174988,
0.3299434185028076,
-0.3395581543445587,
0.2564505338668823,
0.3131166994571686,
0.5988327860832214,
-0.7320477366447449,
-0.6158410310745239,
-0.3031354248523712,
-0.8923937678337097,
0.7624237537384033,
-0.08483728021383286,
0.2848697304725647,
-0.2425469309091568,
-0.02724701166152954,
0.32515963912010193,
0.35073015093803406,
-1.2956026792526245,
-0.4653080105781555,
-0.2744685709476471,
-0.3190602958202362,
-0.43946588039398193,
-0.09693992137908936,
-0.043290652334690094,
-0.26563653349876404,
0.5601661205291748,
-0.07703273743391037,
0.23436374962329865,
-0.11900118738412857,
-0.28509584069252014,
0.013567632995545864,
0.5710075497627258,
0.12377440184354782,
0.5317301154136658,
-0.0316959023475647,
0.0451103039085865,
0.24731498956680298,
-0.35392770171165466,
0.08948695659637451,
0.21321824193000793,
-0.039847712963819504,
0.2733820080757141,
0.46320822834968567,
0.5188990831375122,
-0.12450630217790604,
-0.5412742495536804,
0.958767294883728,
-0.2707119286060333,
-0.341285765171051,
-0.10898488759994507,
-0.34630483388900757,
0.038302551954984665,
0.0922476202249527,
0.2570255398750305,
0.43817099928855896,
0.2084885537624359,
-0.37778440117836,
0.0560988187789917,
0.569928765296936,
-0.6197542548179626,
-0.3384976089000702,
0.5176340937614441,
0.2226678878068924,
0.06352771818637848,
0.44932660460472107,
-0.21076972782611847,
-0.7390328645706177,
0.5479744076728821,
-0.06919343024492264,
0.832708477973938,
-0.45148831605911255,
0.4016602039337158,
0.26406174898147583,
0.6467406153678894,
-0.18523897230625153,
0.6332859992980957,
0.49960756301879883,
-0.9370267987251282,
-0.6767810583114624,
-0.823724627494812,
-0.00002345442771911621,
-0.11542847752571106,
-0.7762063145637512,
0.4394300580024719,
-0.07425645738840103,
-0.2726995348930359,
0.009512931108474731,
-0.45806074142456055,
-1.2027051448822021,
0.3816910684108734,
0.3470083773136139,
0.7495244145393372,
-1.3232505321502686,
0.6354861259460449,
0.8517870306968689,
-0.292674720287323,
-0.47855034470558167,
-0.05760237202048302,
0.20605236291885376,
-0.6900259852409363,
0.7527217864990234,
0.3090870976448059,
-0.014866643585264683,
-0.5226178765296936,
-0.2594810724258423,
-0.2944211959838867,
0.31451016664505005,
0.41602447628974915,
-0.7530067563056946,
0.24922001361846924,
0.5289028882980347,
0.5191760063171387,
-0.2447693645954132,
0.2718506157398224,
0.4524763524532318,
0.4838869869709015,
-0.5883492827415466,
-0.848846435546875,
-0.5640019774436951,
-0.4079563617706299,
-0.1909254789352417,
0.23427285254001617,
-0.4989165663719177,
0.8819875717163086,
0.24855215847492218,
0.03620518743991852,
-0.7467421293258667,
0.33092448115348816,
-0.16662278771400452,
0.3932245969772339,
0.47814908623695374,
0.6209765672683716,
0.5895827412605286,
-0.20694157481193542,
1.1030908823013306,
-0.43683022260665894,
0.14082801342010498,
0.7414995431900024,
-0.5048732757568359,
0.7653540372848511,
0.6637771129608154,
-0.44639602303504944,
0.39734330773353577,
0.3515757918357849,
0.3098689317703247,
0.2734643518924713,
0.1117674708366394,
-0.38007408380508423,
-0.018470561131834984,
-0.13313685357570648,
-0.27413758635520935,
0.1614195853471756,
0.3459444046020508,
-0.36848846077919006,
-0.11065544188022614,
0.39894020557403564,
-0.011087030172348022,
0.3398691415786743,
-0.442782461643219,
0.46123796701431274,
0.40395388007164,
-0.5419011116027832,
0.05007569119334221,
0.28063568472862244,
0.959176778793335,
-0.42952093482017517,
0.14088985323905945,
-0.3250885605812073,
0.07670726627111435,
-0.3729321360588074,
-0.8394275903701782,
0.10920710861682892,
0.23894159495830536,
-0.46959492564201355,
-0.46261805295944214,
0.47779959440231323,
-0.4602363109588623,
-0.8879163861274719,
0.7990638017654419,
0.9757307767868042,
-0.1851671189069748,
-0.03422188013792038,
-1.0372687578201294,
0.03437159210443497,
0.2828751504421234,
-0.22737333178520203,
0.48170188069343567,
0.4634869396686554,
-0.20731563866138458,
0.4978528320789337,
0.3199687600135803,
0.2594691514968872,
0.31655019521713257,
0.7955843210220337,
0.6085394620895386,
-0.4102681577205658,
-0.470880389213562,
-0.9574570655822754,
0.7069276571273804,
-0.07356660068035126,
-0.06963661313056946,
1.0285608768463135,
0.7669230103492737,
1.1640516519546509,
-0.08998443931341171,
1.3757272958755493,
0.21746110916137695,
0.6759200692176819,
-0.38589492440223694,
0.3463900089263916,
-0.6081570386886597,
0.26614630222320557,
-0.5081170201301575,
-1.2155226469039917,
-0.44836342334747314,
0.772538959980011,
-0.45570480823516846,
0.20343759655952454,
0.5314391255378723,
0.6885433793067932,
-0.07640980929136276,
0.16832157969474792,
0.03796803578734398,
-0.08781824260950089,
0.15872475504875183,
0.35246342420578003,
0.8221737146377563,
-0.28009817004203796,
0.16371393203735352,
-0.2476574182510376,
-0.39617595076560974,
0.2381487488746643,
-0.8310620188713074,
-0.8398033380508423,
-0.1687929630279541,
-0.27773627638816833,
-0.3421967923641205,
-0.015356254763901234,
0.9977273941040039,
0.25269293785095215,
-1.1062090396881104,
-0.5124936699867249,
0.23396176099777222,
0.17992478609085083,
0.07915238291025162,
-0.29683825373649597,
0.036140792071819305,
-0.6289578676223755,
-1.1420127153396606,
-0.003537985263392329,
0.38597166538238525,
-0.1417863965034485,
-0.26108935475349426,
-0.19373449683189392,
-0.1722031831741333,
-0.11982423067092896,
0.7665361166000366,
-0.06909872591495514,
-0.5376759767532349,
-0.01949201710522175,
0.17975950241088867,
-0.17070044577121735,
0.07017721980810165,
0.80777907371521,
-0.4714065492153168,
0.6851289868354797,
0.4593701660633087,
0.3580411672592163,
0.0773252323269844,
-0.3738810122013092,
0.9428119659423828,
-0.9657918810844421,
0.3334810435771942,
0.4569222629070282,
0.6331911683082581,
0.5679881572723389,
0.036455146968364716,
0.19931091368198395,
0.23088979721069336,
-0.36444219946861267,
-0.7305213212966919,
0.11736589670181274,
-0.6955947279930115,
-0.3616175651550293,
1.0872052907943726,
0.1542222797870636,
0.13052062690258026,
-0.2649666965007782,
-0.2602071464061737,
0.09693661332130432,
-0.5285736918449402,
0.31802937388420105,
1.047332763671875,
0.11054196953773499,
-0.10681454092264175,
-1.044128179550171,
0.5708150863647461,
0.6890775561332703,
-0.2911152243614197,
-0.09947734326124191,
0.5815008878707886,
0.0553884394466877,
0.031306952238082886,
0.5881152749061584,
-0.2718554139137268,
0.08031196147203445,
-0.38700371980667114,
0.4110841155052185,
0.8511333465576172,
-0.21542419493198395,
-0.6822314858436584,
0.24881407618522644,
0.07039587199687958,
0.18495646119117737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04513v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04513v1
|
Switchable Decision: Dynamic Neural Generation Networks
| 2024-05-07T17:44:54 | 2024-05-07T17:44:54 |
Shujian Zhang, Korawat Tanwisuth, Chengyue Gong, Pengcheng He, Mingyuan Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Auto-regressive generation models achieve competitive performance across many
different NLP tasks such as summarization, question answering, and
classifications. However, they are also known for being slow in inference,
which makes them challenging to deploy in real-time applications. We propose a
switchable decision to accelerate inference by dynamically assigning
computation resources for each data instance. Automatically making decisions on
where to skip and how to balance quality and computation cost with constrained
optimization, our dynamic neural generation networks enforce the efficient
inference path and determine the optimized trade-off. Experiments across
question answering, summarization, and classification benchmarks show that our
method benefits from less computation cost during inference while keeping the
same accuracy. Extensive experiments and ablation studies demonstrate that our
method can be general, effective, and beneficial for many NLP tasks.
|
[
-0.26965999603271484,
-0.7219988703727722,
0.23255862295627594,
0.5116861462593079,
-0.04367538541555405,
0.41389361023902893,
-0.07549650222063065,
-0.5225388407707214,
0.08908747881650925,
0.4486522376537323,
-0.5107647776603699,
0.4428468346595764,
-0.46914294362068176,
0.09686288982629776,
-0.6426661610603333,
0.6161462068557739,
-0.023019686341285706,
-0.23875194787979126,
-0.09904085844755173,
-0.033606529235839844,
-0.17825114727020264,
-0.038226429373025894,
-1.183955430984497,
-0.6019847989082336,
0.6544771790504456,
0.020421378314495087,
0.9631010293960571,
0.8014116883277893,
0.3244934380054474,
0.44072040915489197,
-0.24617724120616913,
0.37031739950180054,
-0.0806271880865097,
0.5848339796066284,
-0.28014323115348816,
-0.5720622539520264,
-0.2626197636127472,
-0.20875301957130432,
0.5683926343917847,
0.7889242172241211,
-0.2936587929725647,
0.1831996738910675,
-0.23700757324695587,
0.6052273511886597,
-0.5965266823768616,
0.020603245124220848,
-0.9653301239013672,
0.6979828476905823,
0.138126939535141,
-0.15708759427070618,
-0.367563396692276,
-0.5486886501312256,
0.21861869096755981,
-0.3233529329299927,
0.5144496560096741,
-0.2375555783510208,
0.8182037472724915,
0.8533597588539124,
-0.3418125510215759,
0.12758149206638336,
-0.9434138536453247,
0.8290277719497681,
-0.7481125593185425,
0.3137502670288086,
-0.032504621893167496,
0.3402433693408966,
0.0011343476362526417,
-1.1338776350021362,
-0.42235004901885986,
-0.14493709802627563,
0.08263969421386719,
0.3061137795448303,
-0.3369310796260834,
0.09930967539548874,
0.41383233666419983,
0.18576987087726593,
-0.06278320401906967,
0.18252632021903992,
0.05731290578842163,
0.012282554991543293,
0.8358020782470703,
0.2261481136083603,
0.08020752668380737,
-0.16236315667629242,
0.0694737359881401,
-0.05165551230311394,
-0.3818816840648651,
-0.22064150869846344,
0.5849042534828186,
0.43049702048301697,
0.3260597288608551,
0.2763891816139221,
-0.14013586938381195,
0.9143534302711487,
0.39499396085739136,
0.2604004740715027,
0.1561327874660492,
-0.32848092913627625,
-0.3873094320297241,
0.019126717001199722,
0.7460290789604187,
0.015087755396962166,
-0.012869705446064472,
-0.3235119879245758,
-0.0495457723736763,
-0.21901071071624756,
0.547084391117096,
-0.7509154677391052,
-0.42898309230804443,
0.21542102098464966,
-0.595424473285675,
-0.546024739742279,
-0.4836284816265106,
-1.0336798429489136,
-0.14459550380706787,
-0.14193078875541687,
0.1590927243232727,
-0.12496600300073624,
-0.3459450304508209,
-0.014940217137336731,
-0.24979320168495178,
-0.2751118838787079,
0.49177026748657227,
-1.1368188858032227,
0.0525595024228096,
0.058440111577510834,
0.9496105909347534,
-0.4544495940208435,
-0.0819445550441742,
-0.30433765053749084,
-0.09844296425580978,
-0.30192795395851135,
0.6649754643440247,
-0.28975722193717957,
-0.1803000569343567,
-0.15595737099647522,
-0.14298732578754425,
-0.46262410283088684,
-0.6147834658622742,
0.27809983491897583,
-0.8430847525596619,
0.11041675508022308,
0.046936340630054474,
-0.23922589421272278,
-0.33818376064300537,
0.024360254406929016,
-0.9230238199234009,
0.9064468145370483,
0.1398104429244995,
-0.508826732635498,
0.4769173860549927,
-0.6894128918647766,
-0.4887903034687042,
-0.06440772861242294,
0.026290398091077805,
-0.5488059520721436,
0.003152112942188978,
-0.06291544437408447,
0.3626064658164978,
-0.182824969291687,
0.36888250708580017,
-0.05267278105020523,
0.08448569476604462,
0.1223607286810875,
-0.802293062210083,
0.8271828293800354,
0.5828658938407898,
-0.7271653413772583,
0.10395587980747223,
-1.026450276374817,
0.05750640109181404,
0.10658995807170868,
-0.7668565511703491,
0.012339112348854542,
0.5994724631309509,
-0.20495639741420746,
0.17402172088623047,
-0.17691268026828766,
-0.245030477643013,
0.36346620321273804,
-0.2783961296081543,
0.5800289511680603,
0.4152265787124634,
-0.10171449184417725,
0.3849426507949829,
-0.08232840895652771,
0.7423579096794128,
-0.17627978324890137,
0.05148031935095787,
0.1797274351119995,
-0.4476114809513092,
-1.0650032758712769,
0.010807140730321407,
0.6336164474487305,
0.7949122190475464,
-1.03519606590271,
0.4489229619503021,
0.27710843086242676,
-0.42751580476760864,
-0.4348313808441162,
-0.15949656069278717,
0.15190215408802032,
0.7338556051254272,
0.47958454489707947,
0.28476741909980774,
-0.4105989634990692,
-0.8294134736061096,
-0.5482093095779419,
-0.30852043628692627,
0.17242372035980225,
0.3778095543384552,
0.11741679906845093,
-0.039828937500715256,
0.6810518503189087,
-0.37447452545166016,
0.5009609460830688,
-0.45260119438171387,
0.5927755832672119,
0.3217332065105438,
0.4030354917049408,
0.578616201877594,
-0.9797606468200684,
-0.4111924171447754,
-0.2233639806509018,
-0.5005673170089722,
-0.43731412291526794,
-0.9350431561470032,
-0.14711716771125793,
-0.08219590783119202,
0.6654024124145508,
-0.5575891733169556,
0.16581347584724426,
0.5070278644561768,
-0.43106043338775635,
0.5163131356239319,
-0.223230242729187,
0.020096121355891228,
-0.5912895202636719,
-0.16288408637046814,
-0.31241387128829956,
-0.40979304909706116,
-0.3728454113006592,
-0.07399028539657593,
-0.039419595152139664,
0.1975518763065338,
-0.4156359136104584,
0.3402794897556305,
-0.535275936126709,
-0.05330139771103859,
-0.10609152913093567,
-0.20441658794879913,
0.09508857876062393,
0.10905961692333221,
0.06395187228918076,
0.7631862759590149,
0.2381470650434494,
-0.9198326468467712,
0.6090049743652344,
0.33809587359428406,
-0.4914478361606598,
-0.13269075751304626,
-0.42879965901374817,
-0.24086156487464905,
0.13317547738552094,
0.25515928864479065,
-0.6232532858848572,
-0.023249372839927673,
-0.005050053820014,
-0.1654275506734848,
0.2825392484664917,
-0.07707323879003525,
-0.25737786293029785,
-0.3240790367126465,
0.2659585475921631,
0.4396035075187683,
0.4331965446472168,
-0.7529531121253967,
0.7459894418716431,
0.14290174841880798,
-0.09871269762516022,
-0.645862877368927,
-1.0872317552566528,
0.266508549451828,
-0.10655055195093155,
-0.4111303687095642,
0.6525370478630066,
0.08765945583581924,
-0.24042652547359467,
0.12566997110843658,
0.2995694577693939,
0.029506901279091835,
0.24788331985473633,
-0.16432328522205353,
0.02417587861418724,
-0.22912584245204926,
0.22525274753570557,
0.3868785798549652,
-0.13880887627601624,
-0.0038830109406262636,
-0.07030149549245834,
0.3683168590068817,
0.09188475459814072,
-0.3986298441886902,
-0.0983182042837143,
0.16007694602012634,
0.5391644239425659,
-0.17275939881801605,
0.46391797065734863,
0.4255642294883728,
-0.16081255674362183,
-0.6018785238265991,
-0.4271804392337799,
0.059947993606328964,
-0.4607412815093994,
0.509760320186615,
-0.19194436073303223,
-0.39323890209198,
0.5222679376602173,
-0.410311758518219,
0.40927839279174805,
0.6190474629402161,
0.7622098922729492,
0.13876372575759888,
1.1575398445129395,
0.15619677305221558,
0.37939029932022095,
0.8706528544425964,
-0.3879331648349762,
0.35411643981933594,
-0.5025413036346436,
-0.13572636246681213,
-0.33852431178092957,
-0.734791100025177,
-0.7069970369338989,
-0.4090142548084259,
0.10080265253782272,
0.004847382195293903,
-0.1718290001153946,
0.17594198882579803,
-0.7350945472717285,
0.25093308091163635,
0.628256618976593,
-0.047935761511325836,
0.1683107316493988,
-0.25246015191078186,
-0.07103490829467773,
0.1397024691104889,
-1.2184057235717773,
-0.04472464323043823,
0.706363320350647,
0.19473294913768768,
0.622507631778717,
0.12530367076396942,
0.3620348274707794,
0.37536534667015076,
0.07214339077472687,
-0.7851570844650269,
0.683949887752533,
-0.30335161089897156,
-0.5623090267181396,
-0.4171094596385956,
-0.7054795026779175,
-1.1367048025131226,
0.48820778727531433,
-0.5196739435195923,
-0.3332143723964691,
0.5145625472068787,
0.45848411321640015,
-0.7941581606864929,
0.8665827512741089,
-0.6351996064186096,
0.530940055847168,
-0.5437790155410767,
-0.6004937887191772,
-0.31375840306282043,
-0.5024142265319824,
0.29218873381614685,
-0.06802711635828018,
-0.43003401160240173,
-0.17587138712406158,
-0.14114665985107422,
0.6598414182662964,
-0.41265803575515747,
0.5303528308868408,
-0.23906882107257843,
0.4250675439834595,
0.2662285268306732,
0.09545432031154633,
0.2926381528377533,
-0.017751013860106468,
-0.6569352149963379,
-0.09691038727760315,
-0.2940112352371216,
-0.0989353358745575,
-0.7395294308662415,
0.637021541595459,
-0.42199021577835083,
-0.3216148316860199,
-0.5046346783638,
-0.7174963355064392,
-0.2635897397994995,
0.2738530933856964,
0.3921618163585663,
0.11437384784221649,
-0.17478185892105103,
0.07182233035564423,
0.7133316397666931,
-0.42836830019950867,
0.9650042057037354,
0.32539328932762146,
-0.050340015441179276,
-0.28752291202545166,
0.8016799092292786,
0.39125698804855347,
0.3680052161216736,
0.22167819738388062,
0.25430822372436523,
-0.30831795930862427,
-0.8374535441398621,
-0.7900253534317017,
-0.044286735355854034,
-0.2550049126148224,
-0.2068919539451599,
-0.8381314873695374,
-0.28533339500427246,
-0.0016918778419494629,
-0.31311535835266113,
-0.6156156063079834,
-0.818678081035614,
-0.3668094873428345,
-0.26932692527770996,
0.27928072214126587,
0.34353119134902954,
-0.32382455468177795,
0.32397904992103577,
-0.6050693988800049,
0.5897156000137329,
0.6994251608848572,
0.20762620866298676,
0.23926085233688354,
-0.35726213455200195,
-0.012901091016829014,
-0.33936259150505066,
-0.34939369559288025,
-0.8378835320472717,
0.5399222373962402,
0.3752012848854065,
0.6375982165336609,
0.48033085465431213,
0.11017408967018127,
0.4483072757720947,
-0.5235278606414795,
0.6762242317199707,
0.27066370844841003,
-0.7065298557281494,
0.2762414216995239,
-0.22196438908576965,
0.501801073551178,
0.6662606000900269,
0.12319349497556686,
-0.31420013308525085,
-0.23332634568214417,
-0.9195716381072998,
-1.174519419670105,
0.6117757558822632,
0.27980971336364746,
0.16938383877277374,
-0.09012621641159058,
0.453084796667099,
0.041877467185258865,
0.4085296392440796,
-0.31704625487327576,
-0.3298116624355316,
-0.3216334581375122,
0.12817613780498505,
0.2692905366420746,
-0.028723353520035744,
-0.13582450151443481,
-0.5395718812942505,
0.79306960105896,
-0.1607949584722519,
0.49080419540405273,
0.016861509531736374,
0.15826354920864105,
0.07962818443775177,
-0.07490400224924088,
0.3875138759613037,
0.8018926382064819,
-0.19664260745048523,
0.07424577325582504,
0.3423948585987091,
-0.2942901849746704,
0.20621632039546967,
0.3389182984828949,
-0.6936511993408203,
0.3628891408443451,
0.16707298159599304,
1.2569581270217896,
0.20431648194789886,
-0.4365936517715454,
0.018515998497605324,
-0.2508235573768616,
-0.32678690552711487,
-0.1867191344499588,
0.5014219284057617,
0.21110451221466064,
0.4336808919906616,
0.037471916526556015,
0.554060161113739,
0.1787603497505188,
-0.31097596883773804,
0.1951010376214981,
0.3657114505767822,
-0.1715444177389145,
0.017129817977547646,
0.900892436504364,
0.5848506093025208,
-0.5605781078338623,
0.899651050567627,
-0.07836497575044632,
-0.3669203519821167,
0.9805546402931213,
0.5084031820297241,
1.1905193328857422,
-0.39533019065856934,
0.44780781865119934,
0.3741724491119385,
0.1256377398967743,
-0.17734940350055695,
0.2703290283679962,
-0.04434759169816971,
-0.993176281452179,
-0.5220460891723633,
-0.5618978142738342,
-0.5987968444824219,
0.0983796939253807,
-0.6769435405731201,
-0.03148368373513222,
-0.5125110149383545,
-0.503537118434906,
0.33831074833869934,
-0.3292733430862427,
-0.4480281472206116,
0.6100854277610779,
0.04413887485861778,
1.0701738595962524,
-0.6300312876701355,
0.5452733635902405,
0.4497565031051636,
-0.12493514269590378,
-0.39789271354675293,
-0.1255200356245041,
-0.2361864596605301,
-0.6438591480255127,
0.6846640110015869,
-0.44411441683769226,
-0.17981170117855072,
-0.06057141348719597,
-0.28658702969551086,
-0.7642315626144409,
0.9127707481384277,
0.5625749230384827,
-0.5556256771087646,
-0.2880505621433258,
-0.31051039695739746,
0.45718103647232056,
-0.24355162680149078,
0.6004177927970886,
0.5617712140083313,
0.6082701086997986,
0.07717037945985794,
-0.584770917892456,
-0.18332363665103912,
-0.301700621843338,
-0.1890150010585785,
0.37369370460510254,
-1.0178349018096924,
0.9006490111351013,
-0.20564602315425873,
0.14227837324142456,
-0.2174137532711029,
0.7766892313957214,
0.03231405094265938,
0.2061494141817093,
0.9064844250679016,
0.371425986289978,
0.7961410880088806,
-0.2021264284849167,
0.9143083691596985,
-0.2966814935207367,
0.10483840852975845,
0.9056410193443298,
0.08409383147954941,
0.7407355308532715,
0.41009512543678284,
-0.2501582205295563,
0.547452986240387,
0.8416650891304016,
-0.3616993725299835,
0.4852484166622162,
0.2963784337043762,
-0.5277724862098694,
-0.5779111385345459,
0.136194109916687,
-0.2240443229675293,
0.440628319978714,
0.13806621730327606,
-0.6054696440696716,
-0.21316948533058167,
-0.27928411960601807,
0.07724134624004364,
-0.20113947987556458,
-0.1187211349606514,
0.5101234912872314,
-0.09955809265375137,
-0.9556282758712769,
0.4982099235057831,
-0.14910174906253815,
0.5409406423568726,
-0.7785478830337524,
-0.2125299721956253,
-0.11134391278028488,
0.14860770106315613,
-0.4083108901977539,
-0.5151394009590149,
0.4858812689781189,
-0.20062370598316193,
-0.4939301013946533,
-0.9100494980812073,
0.7119248509407043,
-0.3306357264518738,
-0.6453937292098999,
0.37516462802886963,
0.4292859435081482,
-0.042629554867744446,
0.32092422246932983,
-1.1008731126785278,
-0.4170496165752411,
0.20532232522964478,
-0.6666008830070496,
0.32872334122657776,
0.20461244881153107,
0.055282991379499435,
0.8267573714256287,
0.5941144824028015,
0.6136060953140259,
0.2720092833042145,
0.17733797430992126,
0.6218883991241455,
-0.5179964303970337,
-0.5076087713241577,
-0.5415837168693542,
0.3950028121471405,
-0.3326408565044403,
-0.4727126657962799,
0.4148975908756256,
0.29658910632133484,
0.3686160445213318,
0.0886823758482933,
1.005975365638733,
-0.16802416741847992,
0.5733551383018494,
-0.6126516461372375,
0.9902586936950684,
-0.5650476217269897,
0.11089184880256653,
0.14477914571762085,
-0.8252114057540894,
-0.31340861320495605,
0.7171470522880554,
-0.2010110765695572,
0.11873596906661987,
0.5444080829620361,
0.3543437719345093,
-0.21290002763271332,
-0.03823892027139664,
0.2051040083169937,
0.2868717610836029,
0.4378279745578766,
0.2716408669948578,
0.6657548546791077,
-0.13304057717323303,
0.3587125241756439,
-0.25125545263290405,
-0.28260114789009094,
-0.16906513273715973,
-1.3451651334762573,
-0.41718196868896484,
-0.23630928993225098,
-0.712813675403595,
-0.41102659702301025,
0.0781719908118248,
0.5541089773178101,
0.7629616260528564,
-0.8087165355682373,
-0.13706018030643463,
-0.4862867593765259,
0.31939560174942017,
-0.5552507638931274,
-0.28673818707466125,
0.2409164309501648,
-0.4772798717021942,
-0.860137939453125,
0.722034752368927,
0.11811023950576782,
-0.1915007084608078,
-0.22993512451648712,
0.22758890688419342,
-0.6463853716850281,
0.39483642578125,
0.5707506537437439,
0.7454209923744202,
-0.4065602123737335,
-0.009881899692118168,
-0.16671353578567505,
0.2925753891468048,
-0.10134138911962509,
0.9478055238723755,
-0.9177170991897583,
0.6323045492172241,
0.9932818412780762,
1.0525120496749878,
0.7659837007522583,
-0.009907621890306473,
0.8583040237426758,
-0.18608532845973969,
0.09775999188423157,
0.5796531438827515,
0.32012075185775757,
0.14314818382263184,
-0.4042852818965912,
0.5185971260070801,
0.27879098057746887,
-0.8956664204597473,
-0.6669102311134338,
0.2830201983451843,
-0.8113793730735779,
-0.3815057575702667,
1.0431339740753174,
-0.10886901617050171,
0.03443711996078491,
-0.206093892455101,
0.17332032322883606,
0.4993040859699249,
-0.21508577466011047,
0.982174277305603,
0.39100784063339233,
-0.9762203693389893,
-0.20621803402900696,
-0.6242548227310181,
0.7977502942085266,
0.9464165568351746,
-0.8431261777877808,
-0.0026189449708908796,
0.3477919101715088,
-0.25534242391586304,
0.23757171630859375,
0.34012964367866516,
0.31512510776519775,
0.018917972221970558,
0.1699947565793991,
-0.08133269846439362,
-0.1541866958141327,
-0.2443978637456894,
-0.23153813183307648,
0.2704322338104248,
-0.25897613167762756,
-0.38183149695396423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04495v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04495v1
|
Toward In-Context Teaching: Adapting Examples to Students' Misconceptions
| 2024-05-07T17:05:27 | 2024-05-07T17:05:27 |
Alexis Ross, Jacob Andreas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
When a teacher provides examples for a student to study, these examples must
be informative, enabling a student to progress from their current state toward
a target concept or skill. Good teachers must therefore simultaneously infer
what students already know and adapt their teaching to students' changing state
of knowledge. There is increasing interest in using computational models,
particularly large language models, as pedagogical tools. As students, language
models in particular have shown a remarkable ability to adapt to new tasks
given small numbers of examples. But how effectively can these models adapt as
teachers to students of different types? To study this question, we introduce a
suite of models and evaluation methods we call AdapT. AdapT has two components:
(1) a collection of simulated Bayesian student models that can be used for
evaluation of automated teaching methods; (2) a platform for evaluation with
human students, to characterize the real-world effectiveness of these methods.
We additionally introduce (3) AToM, a new probabilistic model for adaptive
teaching that jointly infers students' past beliefs and optimizes for the
correctness of future beliefs. In evaluations of simulated students across
three learning domains (fraction arithmetic, English morphology, function
learning), AToM systematically outperforms LLM-based and standard Bayesian
teaching models. In human experiments, both AToM and LLMs outperform
non-adaptive random example selection. Our results highlight both the
difficulty of the adaptive teaching task and the potential of learned adaptive
models for solving it.
|
[
-0.2333105355501175,
-0.9998414516448975,
0.7293007373809814,
0.007704386953264475,
-0.037028733640909195,
0.15720206499099731,
-0.34875693917274475,
0.005625697784125805,
-0.50185227394104,
0.24365423619747162,
-0.18571026623249054,
-0.34857916831970215,
-0.2671886086463928,
-0.013577522709965706,
-0.3664241135120392,
0.8422017693519592,
-0.005597700830549002,
0.25129234790802,
-0.5168271064758301,
-0.013183503411710262,
-0.7450157999992371,
-0.2893487513065338,
-0.5103572607040405,
-0.33372917771339417,
-0.2724711000919342,
0.7864377498626709,
0.8052260875701904,
0.15302398800849915,
0.21689558029174805,
0.2452870011329651,
0.30463698506355286,
-0.3077643811702728,
-0.13795986771583557,
-0.16154849529266357,
-0.7850773930549622,
-0.7479019165039062,
-0.03262656182050705,
-0.10803923010826111,
1.0115242004394531,
1.0881906747817993,
-0.22916372120380402,
-0.015805063769221306,
0.10239898413419724,
0.2220558375120163,
-0.6552665829658508,
-0.1836262345314026,
-0.7121267318725586,
-0.009462881833314896,
0.33455121517181396,
0.11296369135379791,
-0.6887099742889404,
-0.3757610321044922,
0.3327960968017578,
-0.803443968296051,
0.07112772017717361,
-0.15992437303066254,
0.21823206543922424,
-0.041485391557216644,
-0.4962834417819977,
-0.43425363302230835,
-0.7398328185081482,
0.7394347786903381,
-0.7735625505447388,
0.4288366436958313,
0.2903023064136505,
0.7583250403404236,
-0.6038287281990051,
-0.6780520081520081,
-0.6432433724403381,
-0.24774841964244843,
0.30071696639060974,
0.37954744696617126,
-0.08642499148845673,
-0.13712337613105774,
0.1445741504430771,
-0.019507212564349174,
-0.273453027009964,
0.13378985226154327,
-0.2175973802804947,
0.07574523240327835,
0.3880727291107178,
0.05678703635931015,
0.49615803360939026,
0.03684736043214798,
-0.38607874512672424,
-0.38707321882247925,
-0.49217844009399414,
0.14312876760959625,
0.21759973466396332,
0.399260938167572,
-0.21763572096824646,
0.06263561546802521,
0.09760794788599014,
1.0608144998550415,
-0.055961646139621735,
-0.2308570295572281,
-0.3738751709461212,
0.020672330632805824,
-0.17790792882442474,
-0.05827145650982857,
0.027544615790247917,
0.40896034240722656,
0.3496531546115875,
-0.1224711537361145,
0.21349363029003143,
0.20275698602199554,
0.3512769639492035,
-0.6155282258987427,
-0.459273099899292,
-0.11982064694166183,
-0.2383282482624054,
-0.067913718521595,
-0.2501234710216522,
-0.8951172232627869,
-0.29967960715293884,
-0.2838427424430847,
0.9779475927352905,
-0.5193354487419128,
-0.3419635593891144,
0.229863703250885,
-0.3039519190788269,
-0.1262250691652298,
0.7060666084289551,
-0.6880126595497131,
0.763332724571228,
0.4578162729740143,
0.5995582938194275,
-0.029626144096255302,
-0.6594734191894531,
-0.13602875173091888,
0.09854641556739807,
-0.42826804518699646,
0.8780277371406555,
-0.8482016324996948,
-0.5241273045539856,
-0.14562515914440155,
0.013706693425774574,
-0.26366135478019714,
-0.492042601108551,
0.29180845618247986,
-0.1498393416404724,
0.3126736283302307,
-0.24445287883281708,
-0.789355456829071,
-0.49111613631248474,
0.11761089414358139,
-0.28500932455062866,
0.707459568977356,
0.767230749130249,
-0.46792200207710266,
0.2762885093688965,
-0.7205950021743774,
-0.2331186681985855,
-0.14389070868492126,
0.009804674424231052,
-0.10652849078178406,
0.25283318758010864,
0.04110553860664368,
0.3165954053401947,
-0.23357100784778595,
0.10468430072069168,
-0.46207961440086365,
-0.537815511226654,
0.5305277705192566,
-0.38461431860923767,
0.7506141662597656,
0.14607591927051544,
-0.12922191619873047,
0.160057932138443,
-0.5469826459884644,
-0.14784562587738037,
-0.03761366009712219,
-0.26000115275382996,
-0.7122421264648438,
0.21472065150737762,
0.02167322114109993,
0.17254865169525146,
-0.35400864481925964,
-0.2616143524646759,
0.44657954573631287,
-0.37932443618774414,
0.6270862221717834,
0.8519260287284851,
0.10666963458061218,
0.6775394678115845,
-0.5282750129699707,
0.6175678968429565,
0.02664928324520588,
-0.05625493451952934,
-0.16737274825572968,
-0.2629784643650055,
-0.5873124003410339,
0.1254739612340927,
0.3662925660610199,
0.2812972366809845,
-0.8685793876647949,
-0.23924270272254944,
-0.20916268229484558,
-0.49765855073928833,
-0.3725367784500122,
0.17355035245418549,
0.07981498539447784,
0.775969386100769,
0.3535006046295166,
-0.42442819476127625,
-0.33169999718666077,
-0.6543155312538147,
-0.6998528838157654,
-0.23594358563423157,
-0.00008549330232199281,
0.16507656872272491,
0.7223008871078491,
-0.09185004234313965,
1.0629968643188477,
-0.2609860301017761,
0.5080445408821106,
-0.0748395174741745,
-0.11670681089162827,
0.059561245143413544,
0.6839789152145386,
0.6710377335548401,
-0.6879571676254272,
-0.5335814356803894,
-0.1284671574831009,
-0.4732668399810791,
0.1882694959640503,
-0.42436549067497253,
-0.202059805393219,
0.12493416666984558,
0.18012548983097076,
-0.04221155494451523,
0.3975593149662018,
0.2662481367588043,
-0.6169347167015076,
0.6148623824119568,
-0.2568764090538025,
0.06854892522096634,
-1.1484297513961792,
-0.4523266851902008,
0.08789543807506561,
-0.34680575132369995,
-0.49998676776885986,
0.09464015811681747,
0.11211059242486954,
-0.18118174374103546,
-0.4015355408191681,
0.8484906554222107,
-0.23546156287193298,
-0.3128945529460907,
-0.5770455002784729,
0.08029048889875412,
-0.11743181943893433,
0.12171202152967453,
0.15724122524261475,
0.7479684352874756,
0.6858940720558167,
-0.7297643423080444,
0.02284288965165615,
0.0682167336344719,
-0.6821041703224182,
0.8946797847747803,
-0.22026805579662323,
0.08413644134998322,
-0.023482469841837883,
0.5488641858100891,
-0.7984837889671326,
-0.19542630016803741,
0.23089803755283356,
-0.3185049593448639,
-0.030955780297517776,
-0.27783262729644775,
-0.164783775806427,
-0.223154217004776,
-0.05058688670396805,
0.4290156364440918,
0.6291619539260864,
-0.7829421162605286,
0.6761547327041626,
0.03520447388291359,
-0.10845930129289627,
-0.2641623020172119,
-0.5351020097732544,
0.013991979882121086,
-0.3345337510108948,
-0.19991862773895264,
0.45921772718429565,
-0.409906268119812,
-0.5255936980247498,
0.3200610876083374,
-0.2840295732021332,
-0.3676787316799164,
0.6806216239929199,
0.2629658579826355,
0.22666755318641663,
-0.23455266654491425,
0.06967920064926147,
0.4778933823108673,
0.1435539871454239,
0.040730029344558716,
-0.3639615476131439,
0.13081374764442444,
-0.17532432079315186,
-0.5061119794845581,
-0.09881637245416641,
0.09763576090335846,
0.32999348640441895,
0.4999328851699829,
0.5201528072357178,
0.3367191553115845,
-0.7348169684410095,
-0.6916863322257996,
-0.2808411121368408,
-0.49048763513565063,
-0.3841349482536316,
0.7062872052192688,
-0.4320184886455536,
-0.628562331199646,
0.21508359909057617,
-0.34249457716941833,
0.039016008377075195,
0.1267787218093872,
0.5098598599433899,
-0.04808752238750458,
0.6297221183776855,
0.6865211725234985,
0.23655815422534943,
0.4299989640712738,
-0.061210453510284424,
0.040749311447143555,
-0.8502545356750488,
0.250306636095047,
-0.33911430835723877,
0.00004096001066500321,
-0.35514384508132935,
-0.5864089131355286,
0.224667027592659,
0.5616406798362732,
-0.336167573928833,
0.3689413368701935,
-0.24650608003139496,
0.41585612297058105,
0.3751542568206787,
0.14894236624240875,
0.0030006207525730133,
0.07008251547813416,
0.008929635398089886,
0.11215857416391373,
-0.8941769599914551,
-0.662224531173706,
1.3874809741973877,
0.1841384917497635,
0.4628567397594452,
0.40204063057899475,
0.21776840090751648,
0.3351103663444519,
0.8751349449157715,
-0.6427077651023865,
0.38957691192626953,
-0.00438527949154377,
-0.6805842518806458,
-0.10488936305046082,
-0.14243309199810028,
-0.6151814460754395,
0.5458595752716064,
-0.33467257022857666,
-0.771767795085907,
0.13054533302783966,
0.08657620847225189,
-0.34456753730773926,
0.39790838956832886,
-0.9432805180549622,
0.9635950922966003,
-0.26138126850128174,
-0.4552476108074188,
-0.3507467806339264,
-0.39107176661491394,
0.011122394353151321,
-0.31633031368255615,
0.773277223110199,
0.06305957585573196,
0.17468689382076263,
0.8193856477737427,
-0.0799805298447609,
0.8863492012023926,
-0.3895421028137207,
0.25611865520477295,
0.5263543128967285,
0.41488590836524963,
0.10939005762338638,
0.13181430101394653,
-0.3534420132637024,
-0.22474437952041626,
0.3855574429035187,
-0.570012092590332,
-0.9320562481880188,
0.5625857710838318,
-0.7542881965637207,
-0.7192777395248413,
-0.3968051075935364,
-0.9125419855117798,
-0.3778240382671356,
-0.0023408611305058002,
-0.08525553345680237,
0.26114150881767273,
-0.14294616878032684,
0.06953129917383194,
0.22761665284633636,
-0.41678759455680847,
0.43481943011283875,
0.7876212000846863,
-0.24825718998908997,
-0.27168092131614685,
0.9128842353820801,
0.1758655160665512,
0.6003835201263428,
0.20002926886081696,
0.5673971176147461,
-0.13668973743915558,
-0.4533647298812866,
-0.38706669211387634,
-0.07929140329360962,
-1.1650959253311157,
-0.047797057777643204,
-0.217770054936409,
0.17703908681869507,
-0.6137696504592896,
-0.7434585690498352,
-0.06660950183868408,
-0.4787546694278717,
-0.253335565328598,
0.02043246105313301,
0.08949201554059982,
0.6184127926826477,
-0.07191823422908783,
0.7330887913703918,
-0.3507840931415558,
-0.028270510956645012,
0.5241380333900452,
0.04793541878461838,
0.09768204391002655,
-0.9528119564056396,
-0.14589586853981018,
0.2991220951080322,
-0.5760458707809448,
-0.9561070799827576,
0.21215681731700897,
0.46492061018943787,
0.7704131007194519,
0.11567068845033646,
0.002979056676849723,
0.6625484228134155,
-0.4077911376953125,
0.6122784614562988,
-0.020676955580711365,
-1.1438775062561035,
0.6047854423522949,
-0.1887168139219284,
0.04839266836643219,
0.47293564677238464,
0.5067527890205383,
-0.49853476881980896,
-0.032532867044210434,
-0.6262177228927612,
-0.4888496696949005,
0.5903632044792175,
-0.24806751310825348,
0.33102062344551086,
0.17525534331798553,
0.8058487772941589,
0.49377337098121643,
0.09584558755159378,
-0.78009033203125,
0.16238026320934296,
-0.5173695087432861,
-0.6700106263160706,
-0.20663319528102875,
-0.17106060683727264,
-0.01763250306248665,
-0.4656432867050171,
0.5462242364883423,
-0.40526720881462097,
0.26759961247444153,
0.0467592254281044,
-0.47685596346855164,
0.10402567684650421,
0.4600467383861542,
0.6302613615989685,
1.1285016536712646,
-0.1920684278011322,
0.25387075543403625,
0.6554152965545654,
-0.28112199902534485,
0.205732524394989,
-0.19810910522937775,
0.012181770987808704,
-0.20458190143108368,
0.5554054975509644,
0.6671956181526184,
0.6767439842224121,
-0.6564889550209045,
0.45706623792648315,
0.003428567200899124,
0.036078471690416336,
-0.3918973207473755,
0.4267778694629669,
0.03942388668656349,
0.20169799029827118,
0.31841763854026794,
0.07669790089130402,
0.17209169268608093,
-0.8804687857627869,
0.06068626791238785,
0.2332826554775238,
-0.29579731822013855,
-0.6293983459472656,
0.3683302402496338,
-0.08171428740024567,
-0.5770076513290405,
0.3484768271446228,
0.1989140510559082,
-0.5059385895729065,
0.8353090882301331,
1.4489079713821411,
0.6131027936935425,
-0.5359804034233093,
0.11651799827814102,
0.2957246005535126,
0.15173058211803436,
-0.25735023617744446,
0.05747165158390999,
-0.21271325647830963,
-0.9144266843795776,
-0.12558682262897491,
-0.4446153938770294,
-0.8828052878379822,
-0.339693158864975,
-0.6246380805969238,
0.28611356019973755,
-0.5956850647926331,
-0.06470872461795807,
0.10271459817886353,
-0.2685662806034088,
-0.5194408297538757,
0.2837948203086853,
-0.19619335234165192,
0.99180668592453,
-1.326730489730835,
0.9833495020866394,
1.1910383701324463,
-0.07027953863143921,
-0.5346872806549072,
0.13592185080051422,
-0.16851991415023804,
-0.59299635887146,
0.3180288076400757,
-0.013104490004479885,
0.2924943268299103,
0.08818476647138596,
-0.49469614028930664,
-0.6965581774711609,
0.8848768472671509,
0.5342462658882141,
-0.46829894185066223,
0.09432978928089142,
-0.19019117951393127,
0.3914933204650879,
-0.6287593245506287,
0.47097527980804443,
0.35337528586387634,
0.26032695174217224,
-0.16938245296478271,
-0.5547229647636414,
-0.06537380814552307,
0.0180223286151886,
0.12691719830036163,
-0.3051154315471649,
-0.3158716857433319,
1.013838529586792,
-0.19604964554309845,
0.06764832884073257,
-0.16486267745494843,
0.5042968392372131,
0.3315497040748596,
0.5684693455696106,
0.6028236746788025,
0.3118855357170105,
0.5490288138389587,
0.08238743245601654,
0.9271082878112793,
-0.05926177278161049,
0.3770841062068939,
1.2356237173080444,
-0.14263930916786194,
0.9183462858200073,
0.41362854838371277,
-0.5238178372383118,
0.8909213542938232,
0.8100425004959106,
0.10459144413471222,
0.37228068709373474,
0.2656373679637909,
-0.08978884667158127,
-0.4507834017276764,
0.1738201230764389,
-0.3838435113430023,
0.3174116909503937,
0.6083070635795593,
0.03619634732604027,
-0.33613845705986023,
0.55379718542099,
-0.14763204753398895,
0.5174837708473206,
-0.4655567407608032,
0.4185065031051636,
-0.03355608135461807,
-0.743267297744751,
0.3655138909816742,
0.20011885464191437,
0.4013218283653259,
-0.1814454048871994,
-0.20957797765731812,
0.013701707124710083,
0.21082641184329987,
-0.16079995036125183,
-0.5994570851325989,
0.14632752537727356,
-0.30859264731407166,
-0.15141920745372772,
0.16391322016716003,
0.7039453983306885,
-0.22847586870193481,
-0.8073331117630005,
0.00200239522382617,
0.026112014427781105,
0.1707204282283783,
0.22329536080360413,
-0.6494675874710083,
0.03704436495900154,
-0.08882767707109451,
0.12103713303804398,
0.4037635922431946,
0.03249624744057655,
-0.33358412981033325,
0.6893981099128723,
0.5093142986297607,
-0.010534275323152542,
-0.07484763860702515,
-0.08190399408340454,
0.6190245747566223,
-0.5502970814704895,
-0.39704838395118713,
-0.746446430683136,
0.45154109597206116,
0.3305673599243164,
-0.18104273080825806,
0.8844823241233826,
0.23088447749614716,
1.183830738067627,
-0.13956119120121002,
0.9661935567855835,
0.29811474680900574,
0.47000569105148315,
-0.4643082022666931,
0.39004766941070557,
-0.4210091829299927,
0.16751445829868317,
-0.5969206690788269,
-0.8364992737770081,
-0.03664854168891907,
1.0569216012954712,
-0.5689927339553833,
0.2321791797876358,
0.7430251240730286,
0.16612133383750916,
-0.14544682204723358,
0.17544087767601013,
0.2713143229484558,
0.1444316804409027,
0.2830754518508911,
0.7019822597503662,
0.9015315771102905,
-0.537216067314148,
-0.1569477766752243,
-0.4027259945869446,
-0.3749963045120239,
-0.33335790038108826,
-0.8165236115455627,
-0.818614661693573,
-0.5481172204017639,
-0.5657283663749695,
-0.35714033246040344,
0.22536638379096985,
0.8996315002441406,
0.6670101881027222,
-0.610482931137085,
-0.4378396272659302,
-0.2207867056131363,
0.36176884174346924,
-0.3409985601902008,
-0.21581405401229858,
0.34593531489372253,
-0.21227197349071503,
-0.7093222141265869,
0.5278312563896179,
-0.07241123169660568,
0.2365521788597107,
-0.005772641394287348,
-0.027733713388442993,
-0.07332734018564224,
0.25117388367652893,
0.4543623626232147,
0.2206161767244339,
-0.7106280326843262,
-0.5524381399154663,
-0.34429970383644104,
0.30914878845214844,
-0.19799219071865082,
0.5709525942802429,
-0.8414559960365295,
0.6829928159713745,
0.005770722404122353,
0.7836564779281616,
0.3091927170753479,
0.04283580183982849,
0.354657381772995,
-0.0795152559876442,
0.38870614767074585,
0.28569135069847107,
0.19543330371379852,
0.34164127707481384,
-0.11127359420061111,
0.27136489748954773,
0.41924750804901123,
-0.4309278726577759,
-1.195173978805542,
0.21906904876232147,
-0.6641034483909607,
-0.9187681674957275,
0.9564204216003418,
-0.31800177693367004,
-0.2773745357990265,
-0.12147308140993118,
0.05418141186237335,
0.20413747429847717,
0.09837321192026138,
0.8764379024505615,
0.8873952031135559,
-0.01663649082183838,
0.10282520949840546,
-0.8504123091697693,
0.24254533648490906,
0.5832451581954956,
-0.7970899939537048,
-0.14695023000240326,
0.26813986897468567,
0.9312552213668823,
-0.1652289628982544,
0.4471244215965271,
0.18757207691669464,
0.5570130944252014,
0.12468265742063522,
0.0030332154128700495,
0.11951151490211487,
-0.4732181429862976,
-0.44382381439208984,
0.061716847121715546,
0.34834328293800354,
0.08954134583473206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04435v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04435v1
|
Fast Exact Retrieval for Nearest-neighbor Lookup (FERN)
| 2024-05-07T15:57:39 | 2024-05-07T15:57:39 |
Richard Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DS
|
Exact nearest neighbor search is a computationally intensive process, and
even its simpler sibling -- vector retrieval -- can be computationally complex.
This is exacerbated when retrieving vectors which have high-dimension $d$
relative to the number of vectors, $N$, in the database. Exact nearest neighbor
retrieval has been generally acknowledged to be a $O(Nd)$ problem with no
sub-linear solutions. Attention has instead shifted towards Approximate
Nearest-Neighbor (ANN) retrieval techniques, many of which have sub-linear or
even logarithmic time complexities. However, if our intuition from binary
search problems (e.g. $d=1$ vector retrieval) carries, there ought to be a way
to retrieve an organized representation of vectors without brute-forcing our
way to a solution. For low dimension (e.g. $d=2$ or $d=3$ cases),
\texttt{kd-trees} provide a $O(d\log N)$ algorithm for retrieval. Unfortunately
the algorithm deteriorates rapidly to a $O(dN)$ solution at high dimensions
(e.g. $k=128$), in practice. We propose a novel algorithm for logarithmic Fast
Exact Retrieval for Nearest-neighbor lookup (FERN), inspired by
\texttt{kd-trees}. The algorithm achieves $O(d\log N)$ look-up with 100\%
recall on 10 million $d=128$ uniformly randomly generated
vectors.\footnote{Code available at https://github.com/RichardZhu123/ferns}
|
[
-0.3024483919143677,
-0.8187835216522217,
0.6749657988548279,
0.2730656862258911,
-0.24504390358924866,
0.16092164814472198,
0.37342873215675354,
-0.37303635478019714,
0.5544459819793701,
-0.028090672567486763,
-0.5226847529411316,
-0.45865005254745483,
-0.13667450845241547,
0.10496555268764496,
-0.20965290069580078,
0.4184124171733856,
0.12775002419948578,
-0.04821152240037918,
0.16959276795387268,
-0.31089794635772705,
-0.05135665461421013,
-0.5061257481575012,
-0.7721630334854126,
0.2243119776248932,
0.8602293133735657,
0.42179763317108154,
0.7325526475906372,
0.9707993865013123,
0.9408237934112549,
0.20266734063625336,
-0.6213242411613464,
0.1981249898672104,
-0.8776543736457825,
0.07708284258842468,
-0.2572862505912781,
-0.4853527545928955,
-0.3959368169307709,
-0.5057840347290039,
1.0610567331314087,
0.8811356425285339,
0.35146769881248474,
0.3100752830505371,
-0.6252206563949585,
1.02205491065979,
-0.7295552492141724,
0.14475411176681519,
-0.7351112961769104,
0.5449961423873901,
-0.5725820064544678,
-0.6302832365036011,
-0.3234758675098419,
-0.6711662411689758,
0.28167903423309326,
-0.730625331401825,
0.3814997673034668,
0.3596981167793274,
0.9619687795639038,
0.05356183275580406,
-0.25570788979530334,
0.1118164137005806,
-0.6366713643074036,
0.6366569995880127,
-0.3306981027126312,
0.04059337452054024,
0.5280333161354065,
0.4479893147945404,
-0.6700331568717957,
-0.4871584177017212,
-0.2851950228214264,
0.2257590889930725,
0.10003062337636948,
-0.39056622982025146,
-0.1443580985069275,
0.03496802970767021,
0.7347005009651184,
0.6905441284179688,
-0.6066974997520447,
0.06360795348882675,
-0.06363829970359802,
0.056068189442157745,
0.5909523963928223,
0.14175273478031158,
0.18429034948349,
-0.3336610496044159,
-0.36418822407722473,
-0.18963734805583954,
-0.6451287865638733,
-0.10590512305498123,
0.3003976345062256,
0.29871347546577454,
0.44012725353240967,
0.43439942598342896,
-0.5766772627830505,
0.689713180065155,
0.033203352242708206,
-0.14877691864967346,
0.5301585793495178,
-0.12692375481128693,
-0.04736647754907608,
0.12774890661239624,
0.5131773948669434,
0.03967178240418434,
0.23816922307014465,
0.22006826102733612,
-0.20836399495601654,
-0.31390655040740967,
-0.10690512508153915,
-1.1161632537841797,
-0.6327764987945557,
0.10150375217199326,
-0.9110058546066284,
-0.4572291374206543,
-0.07262814044952393,
-0.850527822971344,
-0.1123441681265831,
0.05768688768148422,
0.7012046575546265,
-0.5999657511711121,
-0.4325200319290161,
-0.21217326819896698,
-0.12531259655952454,
0.2511642277240753,
0.10612130910158157,
-0.38247156143188477,
0.2560821771621704,
0.7361520528793335,
1.3759591579437256,
-0.2920016050338745,
0.09779304265975952,
-1.080237627029419,
-0.11588531732559204,
-0.5689957141876221,
0.3820744454860687,
-0.5895981192588806,
-0.5121864676475525,
-0.16670848429203033,
-0.08380192518234253,
0.24762243032455444,
-0.4521907567977905,
0.45759493112564087,
-0.794405460357666,
-0.27721232175827026,
-0.556702196598053,
-0.26551711559295654,
-0.3369792401790619,
-0.07004617899656296,
-0.8603851795196533,
1.2965487241744995,
-0.04314585030078888,
-1.201849102973938,
0.051228493452072144,
-0.7691946029663086,
-0.19968070089817047,
0.16785916686058044,
-0.11825793236494064,
-0.6128966808319092,
0.3208636939525604,
0.3603997230529785,
0.39368531107902527,
-0.021995967254042625,
-0.2638860046863556,
-0.7527866959571838,
-0.5908282995223999,
-0.118572898209095,
-0.4437471330165863,
1.1242246627807617,
0.37772879004478455,
-0.14446838200092316,
-0.0075854104943573475,
-0.7727609872817993,
0.2302844524383545,
0.503606379032135,
0.1481577605009079,
-0.8742043972015381,
-0.13893486559391022,
-0.32646358013153076,
-0.07449574768543243,
0.2943260073661804,
-1.033094882965088,
0.3766527473926544,
-0.31785497069358826,
0.347143292427063,
0.7959394454956055,
0.32806673645973206,
0.3025890588760376,
-0.47072166204452515,
0.16225172579288483,
-0.007351101841777563,
0.06428758054971695,
-0.41029036045074463,
-0.5437901616096497,
-0.4255446195602417,
-0.5660756826400757,
0.6032641530036926,
0.007220436353236437,
-0.7986869812011719,
0.1843719333410263,
-0.4535214602947235,
-0.6822381615638733,
-0.48258453607559204,
-0.35009458661079407,
0.6045778393745422,
0.1719607561826706,
0.33633118867874146,
-0.5664464831352234,
-0.34676605463027954,
-0.5611737370491028,
0.1900774985551834,
-0.28050562739372253,
0.17593666911125183,
0.40673425793647766,
0.5101615190505981,
-0.1920221596956253,
1.1953082084655762,
-1.1845765113830566,
-0.40033915638923645,
0.5743381977081299,
0.2987518012523651,
0.3246796727180481,
0.4363137185573578,
0.8182644844055176,
-1.1829744577407837,
-0.6632398366928101,
0.09638253599405289,
-0.4370301365852356,
0.11678136885166168,
0.3205265998840332,
-0.5829655528068542,
0.2021264284849167,
0.3123761713504791,
-0.8348807692527771,
0.844577968120575,
0.00998664926737547,
-0.11873670667409897,
0.4298788905143738,
-0.45063161849975586,
0.044440869241952896,
-0.6244150400161743,
0.3668874204158783,
-0.42000725865364075,
-0.39490020275115967,
-0.3661237061023712,
0.39033132791519165,
0.17892366647720337,
-0.12317652255296707,
-0.3304656147956848,
0.20318607985973358,
-0.6601434350013733,
-0.46061137318611145,
0.14879468083381653,
-0.17068107426166534,
-0.20870539546012878,
0.508457362651825,
0.06091959401965141,
0.6609072685241699,
0.44459661841392517,
-0.6709955930709839,
0.37639209628105164,
0.11782576888799667,
-0.14079441130161285,
0.8722988963127136,
-0.36782145500183105,
0.17767788469791412,
-0.5946043133735657,
0.30918991565704346,
-0.864295482635498,
-0.14461177587509155,
-0.2827739119529724,
-0.48741915822029114,
0.19209550321102142,
-0.11485391855239868,
-0.515371561050415,
-0.521949291229248,
-0.71854567527771,
1.079217791557312,
0.41654375195503235,
-1.3562742471694946,
0.4862000346183777,
0.2621839940547943,
-0.15182361006736755,
-0.5280174612998962,
-0.22050492465496063,
-0.2209976315498352,
0.0010093480814248323,
-0.3786461353302002,
0.45030155777931213,
-0.22548320889472961,
-0.14585936069488525,
0.3713095188140869,
-0.29250073432922363,
-0.31466051936149597,
-0.17309938371181488,
0.23389922082424164,
0.009710120968520641,
-0.2923642694950104,
0.2450508028268814,
-0.2688163220882416,
-0.17448118329048157,
-0.08547825366258621,
-0.3127816617488861,
0.5227864384651184,
-0.10979705303907394,
-0.55979984998703,
-0.19635604321956635,
0.358816534280777,
0.7630797028541565,
-0.4330786168575287,
0.3286057114601135,
0.5038259029388428,
-0.6503576040267944,
-0.11177052557468414,
-0.4306403696537018,
0.11168714612722397,
-0.42677628993988037,
0.45713651180267334,
-1.0522222518920898,
-0.41969138383865356,
0.3575461208820343,
-0.06003053858876228,
0.06883203983306885,
0.5905835032463074,
0.18110665678977966,
-0.062351375818252563,
1.132083773612976,
0.33291155099868774,
-0.1163061261177063,
0.41740742325782776,
-0.3681468367576599,
0.3553667366504669,
-0.6250429153442383,
-0.4858718514442444,
-0.6884311437606812,
-0.43759265542030334,
-0.3474996089935303,
-0.7734116911888123,
0.230105921626091,
0.13394658267498016,
-0.3109978437423706,
0.44821158051490784,
-0.6341409683227539,
0.638914942741394,
0.5357888340950012,
-0.008012659847736359,
0.5176164507865906,
0.26929447054862976,
-0.5927247405052185,
-0.22428224980831146,
-0.8621211647987366,
0.36583900451660156,
0.9281090497970581,
0.4425241947174072,
0.5740949511528015,
0.3813569247722626,
0.869804322719574,
0.23007161915302277,
-0.0191970095038414,
-0.9033181667327881,
0.6059461832046509,
-0.09071305394172668,
-0.3903105556964874,
-0.41062551736831665,
-0.9091717600822449,
-1.055553913116455,
0.20467913150787354,
0.0472237654030323,
-0.45836231112480164,
0.36145010590553284,
-0.24898867309093475,
-0.41067227721214294,
0.7786540389060974,
-0.4598864018917084,
0.45734333992004395,
-0.24708788096904755,
-0.07015763968229294,
-0.050340112298727036,
-0.5440053939819336,
0.23885349929332733,
-0.5526748895645142,
0.20103943347930908,
-0.314378947019577,
0.04119672253727913,
0.5543403625488281,
-0.8239932656288147,
0.2127280831336975,
-0.27773812413215637,
0.1444924920797348,
0.11120817065238953,
0.561474084854126,
0.4658801555633545,
-0.11233747750520706,
-0.10986215621232986,
0.056318774819374084,
0.343136191368103,
-0.6365490555763245,
-0.6088094711303711,
1.1929514408111572,
-0.8022510409355164,
-0.20020617544651031,
-0.7544849514961243,
-0.3616224527359009,
0.26773911714553833,
0.3479214906692505,
0.13187173008918762,
0.6059612035751343,
-0.04392259940505028,
0.30109331011772156,
1.0659948587417603,
0.07144340127706528,
0.6876065135002136,
0.48429805040359497,
-0.809855043888092,
-0.28476324677467346,
1.481941819190979,
0.4802509844303131,
0.15329653024673462,
0.7065951824188232,
0.13527725636959076,
-0.21500848233699799,
-0.22356079518795013,
-0.3507612943649292,
0.28322431445121765,
-0.41402876377105713,
-0.5873622298240662,
-0.6136308312416077,
-0.34186071157455444,
0.2703235149383545,
0.05308886989951134,
-0.3349165916442871,
-0.5944340229034424,
-0.2869170606136322,
0.010135185904800892,
0.8957955241203308,
0.8236364126205444,
-0.11663271486759186,
-0.08222252130508423,
-0.6667425036430359,
0.6484230756759644,
0.15799590945243835,
0.5985418558120728,
0.30725204944610596,
-0.26118865609169006,
0.30196452140808105,
0.00629429379478097,
0.09764717519283295,
-0.7672997713088989,
0.31492164731025696,
0.4473889470100403,
0.17294147610664368,
0.5297249555587769,
0.4070156216621399,
1.148118495941162,
-0.622913122177124,
0.38259127736091614,
0.054219458252191544,
-0.641115665435791,
0.3664853274822235,
-0.2394380122423172,
0.3949533998966217,
0.47147613763809204,
0.9568765163421631,
-0.14772281050682068,
0.3666057884693146,
-0.7189990878105164,
-0.8518300652503967,
0.5651699304580688,
0.4778447449207306,
-0.3262960910797119,
-0.11176854372024536,
0.4083247184753418,
-0.12638312578201294,
-0.19977790117263794,
-0.04837895184755325,
-0.3058851659297943,
0.188945934176445,
-0.09268521517515182,
0.07808684557676315,
-0.44958725571632385,
0.20784804224967957,
-0.4202187657356262,
0.6611003875732422,
-0.061136774718761444,
0.5557848215103149,
0.5076830983161926,
0.14766405522823334,
-0.44663459062576294,
-0.4177093207836151,
0.09498059749603271,
0.35794785618782043,
-0.8366095423698425,
0.3842170238494873,
0.2725639045238495,
-0.4750276803970337,
0.1333622932434082,
-0.03725794702768326,
-0.38888639211654663,
0.5788434147834778,
-0.006036301609128714,
0.3775218427181244,
0.2740655541419983,
-0.39500951766967773,
0.8053058981895447,
-0.11723245680332184,
-0.28800517320632935,
-0.6304194331169128,
-0.4414973855018616,
-0.14233596622943878,
-0.15591612458229065,
0.6533939838409424,
0.18577004969120026,
0.06094849854707718,
-0.6417791247367859,
0.40196019411087036,
0.661132276058197,
-0.46783676743507385,
0.0035568473394960165,
0.47279131412506104,
0.03887123987078667,
-0.6853368282318115,
0.46829864382743835,
-0.521616518497467,
-0.4415758550167084,
0.4816647171974182,
0.34645599126815796,
0.7427374720573425,
-0.1678752303123474,
0.158803790807724,
0.6152791976928711,
-0.17744745314121246,
-0.24743318557739258,
0.3880208730697632,
-0.0682428628206253,
-0.04041704162955284,
-0.4080600142478943,
-0.889885663986206,
-0.12065935879945755,
-0.09003669768571854,
-0.6124417781829834,
0.18998722732067108,
-0.7636244297027588,
-0.18727216124534607,
0.06782276928424835,
0.20156033337116241,
-0.48843666911125183,
0.05169150233268738,
-0.4243992269039154,
1.246201992034912,
-0.3429597020149231,
0.8236062526702881,
0.4386756420135498,
-0.2997185289859772,
-0.6705050468444824,
0.12478266656398773,
-0.013927243649959564,
-0.483696848154068,
0.8775636553764343,
0.20144416391849518,
-0.15642844140529633,
0.11888563632965088,
-0.3029528558254242,
-1.2716014385223389,
1.0941424369812012,
-0.0857563465833664,
-0.6987737417221069,
-0.23484298586845398,
-0.19673840701580048,
0.5360623598098755,
-0.3031708002090454,
0.5461374521255493,
0.4929195046424866,
0.2949259579181671,
0.4198613464832306,
-0.8643454909324646,
-0.042800549417734146,
-0.2889886200428009,
0.6261902451515198,
0.5142409205436707,
-0.5422971844673157,
0.9531114101409912,
-0.21597857773303986,
-0.1984550654888153,
0.4753250479698181,
0.7407506704330444,
0.04725288972258568,
0.15516486763954163,
0.5471705198287964,
0.6906121373176575,
1.0246652364730835,
0.0016314188251271844,
0.9082338809967041,
-0.16199001669883728,
0.4590713083744049,
0.7684247493743896,
-0.030263476073741913,
1.3008365631103516,
0.32708296179771423,
-0.1978127658367157,
0.29839271306991577,
0.5415695905685425,
0.4405813217163086,
0.5941457748413086,
0.4933861494064331,
-0.3521984815597534,
-0.17167891561985016,
-0.3493431806564331,
-0.5147667527198792,
0.1575310081243515,
0.22586965560913086,
-0.14828701317310333,
-0.21931138634681702,
-0.28810375928878784,
-0.20524774491786957,
0.1998758465051651,
-0.7066519856452942,
0.5154238343238831,
0.08486273139715195,
-0.1357208788394928,
0.7086357474327087,
-0.02280077151954174,
0.5688648223876953,
-0.5371818542480469,
-0.5360269546508789,
-0.04543566331267357,
0.28481602668762207,
-0.5714728236198425,
-0.5960491895675659,
0.18591156601905823,
-0.32651615142822266,
-0.31404754519462585,
0.10379783809185028,
0.6385144591331482,
-0.2921035587787628,
-0.43502798676490784,
0.3531125783920288,
-0.030194204300642014,
0.44852906465530396,
-0.07062503695487976,
-0.2408483624458313,
0.33698487281799316,
-0.0381789430975914,
0.11059853434562683,
0.31168830394744873,
0.6237897276878357,
-0.3758772313594818,
0.7302712798118591,
0.8298254609107971,
0.09634856879711151,
0.20310239493846893,
-0.5219628810882568,
0.7799338698387146,
-0.5488570332527161,
-0.2632366716861725,
-0.4255109429359436,
-0.12942425906658173,
-0.2907785177230835,
-0.19199933111667633,
0.7177236676216125,
0.8291799426078796,
0.8166084885597229,
-0.05902181193232536,
0.31961512565612793,
-0.14213711023330688,
0.8690023422241211,
-0.23101042211055756,
0.49260008335113525,
-0.6072211265563965,
-0.004764524754136801,
-0.4662359356880188,
-1.4989749193191528,
-0.3945918083190918,
0.9011640548706055,
-0.21118125319480896,
-0.29223576188087463,
0.7685813307762146,
0.8542958498001099,
-0.32686591148376465,
0.14785976707935333,
0.21338653564453125,
0.2805194556713104,
0.4248737096786499,
0.5983000993728638,
0.3939127027988434,
-0.32742780447006226,
0.596983015537262,
-0.3443685472011566,
-0.4064595103263855,
-0.6758685111999512,
-0.9518887400627136,
-0.7184670567512512,
-0.548403799533844,
-0.25183117389678955,
-0.22564834356307983,
0.155798077583313,
1.1647416353225708,
0.5150331854820251,
-0.6935381889343262,
0.21100710332393646,
-0.04585465043783188,
0.10598340630531311,
-0.2048531472682953,
-0.257901132106781,
0.7148386836051941,
-0.1603710949420929,
-0.531682550907135,
0.29620933532714844,
0.38469743728637695,
-0.0798279345035553,
-0.3318132758140564,
-0.1399485468864441,
-0.48284584283828735,
-0.00854706484824419,
0.5318906307220459,
0.689440906047821,
-0.4054954946041107,
-0.48616188764572144,
-0.10168789327144623,
-0.2762140929698944,
0.0036701741628348827,
0.6683862805366516,
-0.9118437170982361,
0.7582603693008423,
0.969531774520874,
0.9325035810470581,
0.9926039576530457,
0.19450008869171143,
0.25573810935020447,
-0.700153648853302,
0.04443082585930824,
0.2399042397737503,
0.022616809234023094,
0.18416336178779602,
-0.29924049973487854,
0.7342773675918579,
0.508171796798706,
-0.4147690236568451,
-0.9575679898262024,
0.41385841369628906,
-0.9291316866874695,
-0.1476229876279831,
0.9979029297828674,
-0.39656832814216614,
-0.547554075717926,
-0.09399061650037766,
-0.6712064146995544,
-0.22587314248085022,
-0.4422297179698944,
0.2711840867996216,
0.053436338901519775,
0.04089495912194252,
0.3199009895324707,
-0.406108558177948,
0.5797096490859985,
0.6753591299057007,
-0.14403611421585083,
-0.23323580622673035,
0.15442746877670288,
0.3475210666656494,
0.485784649848938,
0.8701346516609192,
-0.27514493465423584,
0.2299898862838745,
0.004103460349142551,
-0.21319648623466492,
-0.2070631980895996,
-0.54679274559021,
-0.28721916675567627,
0.4131060242652893,
0.1635756492614746,
-0.4202626943588257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04434v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04434v5
|
DeepSeek-V2: A Strong, Economical, and Efficient Mixture-of-Experts Language Model
| 2024-05-07T15:56:43 | 2024-06-19T06:04:17 |
DeepSeek-AI, Aixin Liu, Bei Feng, Bin Wang, Bingxuan Wang, Bo Liu, Chenggang Zhao, Chengqi Dengr, Chong Ruan, Damai Dai, Daya Guo, Dejian Yang, Deli Chen, Dongjie Ji, Erhang Li, Fangyun Lin, Fuli Luo, Guangbo Hao, Guanting Chen, Guowei Li, H. Zhang, Hanwei Xu, Hao Yang, Haowei Zhang, Honghui Ding, Huajian Xin, Huazuo Gao, Hui Li, Hui Qu, J. L. Cai, Jian Liang, Jianzhong Guo, Jiaqi Ni, Jiashi Li, Jin Chen, Jingyang Yuan, Junjie Qiu, Junxiao Song, Kai Dong, Kaige Gao, Kang Guan, Lean Wang, Lecong Zhang, Lei Xu, Leyi Xia, Liang Zhao, Liyue Zhang, Meng Li, Miaojun Wang, Mingchuan Zhang, Minghua Zhang, Minghui Tang, Mingming Li, Ning Tian, Panpan Huang, Peiyi Wang, Peng Zhang, Qihao Zhu, Qinyu Chen, Qiushi Du, R. J. Chen, R. L. Jin, Ruiqi Ge, Ruizhe Pan, Runxin Xu, Ruyi Chen, S. S. Li, Shanghao Lu, Shangyan Zhou, Shanhuang Chen, Shaoqing Wu, Shengfeng Ye, Shirong Ma, Shiyu Wang, Shuang Zhou, Shuiping Yu, Shunfeng Zhou, Size Zheng, T. Wang, Tian Pei, Tian Yuan, Tianyu Sun, W. L. Xiao, Wangding Zeng, Wei An, Wen Liu, Wenfeng Liang, Wenjun Gao, Wentao Zhang, X. Q. Li, Xiangyue Jin, Xianzu Wang, Xiao Bi, Xiaodong Liu, Xiaohan Wang, Xiaojin Shen, Xiaokang Chen, Xiaosha Chen, Xiaotao Nie, Xiaowen Sun, Xiaoxiang Wang, Xin Liu, Xin Xie, Xingkai Yu, Xinnan Song, Xinyi Zhou, Xinyu Yang, Xuan Lu, Xuecheng Su, Y. Wu, Y. K. Li, Y. X. Wei, Y. X. Zhu, Yanhong Xu, Yanping Huang, Yao Li, Yao Zhao, Yaofeng Sun, Yaohui Li, Yaohui Wang, Yi Zheng, Yichao Zhang, Yiliang Xiong, Yilong Zhao, Ying He, Ying Tang, Yishi Piao, Yixin Dong, Yixuan Tan, Yiyuan Liu, Yongji Wang, Yongqiang Guo, Yuchen Zhu, Yuduan Wang, Yuheng Zou, Yukun Zha, Yunxian Ma, Yuting Yan, Yuxiang You, Yuxuan Liu, Z. Z. Ren, Zehui Ren, Zhangli Sha, Zhe Fu, Zhen Huang, Zhen Zhang, Zhenda Xie, Zhewen Hao, Zhihong Shao, Zhiniu Wen, Zhipeng Xu, Zhongyu Zhang, Zhuoshu Li, Zihan Wang, Zihui Gu, Zilin Li, Ziwei Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present DeepSeek-V2, a strong Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) language model
characterized by economical training and efficient inference. It comprises 236B
total parameters, of which 21B are activated for each token, and supports a
context length of 128K tokens. DeepSeek-V2 adopts innovative architectures
including Multi-head Latent Attention (MLA) and DeepSeekMoE. MLA guarantees
efficient inference through significantly compressing the Key-Value (KV) cache
into a latent vector, while DeepSeekMoE enables training strong models at an
economical cost through sparse computation. Compared with DeepSeek 67B,
DeepSeek-V2 achieves significantly stronger performance, and meanwhile saves
42.5% of training costs, reduces the KV cache by 93.3%, and boosts the maximum
generation throughput to 5.76 times. We pretrain DeepSeek-V2 on a high-quality
and multi-source corpus consisting of 8.1T tokens, and further perform
Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning (RL) to fully unlock
its potential. Evaluation results show that, even with only 21B activated
parameters, DeepSeek-V2 and its chat versions still achieve top-tier
performance among open-source models.
|
[
-0.3019212782382965,
-0.6952128410339355,
0.4170688986778259,
0.5242905020713806,
-0.39820533990859985,
0.20824773609638214,
-0.40474486351013184,
-0.5926955342292786,
-0.14149662852287292,
0.4697245657444,
-0.48513972759246826,
-0.20682944357395172,
-0.6512636542320251,
-0.35432741045951843,
-0.22685138881206512,
0.4090518355369568,
0.2775401473045349,
-0.054100919514894485,
-0.03328307345509529,
0.1526741236448288,
-0.579725980758667,
-0.22461368143558502,
-0.7348915934562683,
-0.16342024505138397,
0.37645745277404785,
0.6927839517593384,
0.6110406517982483,
0.45905908942222595,
0.35927310585975647,
0.29676032066345215,
-0.08709268271923065,
0.08335962146520615,
-0.6495804190635681,
0.30784428119659424,
-0.143335223197937,
-0.36688098311424255,
-0.5919595956802368,
-0.02280525676906109,
0.2553923428058624,
0.49530550837516785,
-0.1302928924560547,
-0.2248087376356125,
0.044942378997802734,
0.7151784896850586,
-0.8490126729011536,
0.18531042337417603,
-1.036665439605713,
-0.1338910162448883,
-0.20967434346675873,
0.17279492318630219,
-0.3643074035644531,
0.2023780792951584,
0.24067458510398865,
-0.41041406989097595,
-0.07365924119949341,
-0.26265949010849,
0.738714337348938,
0.4192376136779785,
-0.27929145097732544,
0.025370923802256584,
-0.674048900604248,
1.081505298614502,
-0.9263497591018677,
0.7290969491004944,
0.5680655241012573,
0.45632079243659973,
-0.12119202315807343,
-0.6963939070701599,
-0.533016562461853,
-0.10595501214265823,
0.28708168864250183,
0.34022653102874756,
-0.09824150800704956,
-0.05191503092646599,
-0.3040826618671417,
0.45626673102378845,
-0.39584261178970337,
0.611309289932251,
-0.4522528648376465,
-0.09442945569753647,
0.5850000381469727,
0.030476167798042297,
-0.06758326292037964,
0.09532611817121506,
-0.36484295129776,
-0.027679506689310074,
-0.643238365650177,
-0.08310241252183914,
0.3215951919555664,
0.04022101312875748,
-0.03784693032503128,
0.43557724356651306,
-0.49419596791267395,
0.535089373588562,
0.0938357412815094,
-0.09270674735307693,
0.15048302710056305,
-0.37484073638916016,
-0.10426570475101471,
-0.1947973072528839,
0.8945597410202026,
0.22914394736289978,
0.15708613395690918,
-0.15377496182918549,
-0.20021523535251617,
-0.1916971057653427,
0.15773525834083557,
-0.9165453910827637,
-0.47050783038139343,
0.3708389103412628,
-0.2756895124912262,
-0.4092117249965668,
-0.23408447206020355,
-0.7649846076965332,
-0.42714717984199524,
-0.469798743724823,
0.2147412896156311,
-0.6402469873428345,
-0.7325374484062195,
0.12092934548854828,
0.16044682264328003,
0.25435519218444824,
0.6946200132369995,
-0.9345830678939819,
0.3554232120513916,
0.9986543655395508,
0.6972382664680481,
-0.2351263165473938,
-0.18076744675636292,
-0.5033104419708252,
-0.15131600201129913,
-0.4732339680194855,
0.6987907290458679,
-0.7084228992462158,
-0.21690057218074799,
-0.153455451130867,
-0.4784928560256958,
0.12410816550254822,
-0.6305276155471802,
0.4295963943004608,
-0.5756540298461914,
0.16377079486846924,
-0.1390751749277115,
-0.7123975157737732,
-0.1260583996772766,
0.019993700087070465,
-0.5378484129905701,
1.3108974695205688,
0.2966275215148926,
-0.6522849202156067,
0.48459938168525696,
-0.28730982542037964,
-0.37550288438796997,
0.24237214028835297,
-0.2804291844367981,
-0.06398927420377731,
0.1370812952518463,
0.36164629459381104,
0.6479654312133789,
-0.36947453022003174,
0.1940445750951767,
-0.4826482832431793,
-0.12075995653867722,
0.07331735640764236,
-0.5314843654632568,
0.6203165054321289,
0.4293641746044159,
-0.27172285318374634,
0.11894706636667252,
-0.7655771970748901,
-0.08139152824878693,
0.058328378945589066,
-0.4584156274795532,
-0.34681782126426697,
0.17169328033924103,
0.16625629365444183,
0.4561525285243988,
0.3069781959056854,
-0.4145844578742981,
0.00598796596750617,
-0.5102519989013672,
0.5165566205978394,
0.7050217986106873,
-0.19563782215118408,
0.4759349822998047,
0.4132199287414551,
0.31579965353012085,
0.28199273347854614,
0.03818279132246971,
-0.09447508305311203,
-0.6323362588882446,
-0.9092987775802612,
-0.5123728513717651,
0.4541572034358978,
0.6626763343811035,
-0.6244229674339294,
0.6902009844779968,
-0.07088132202625275,
-0.6757142543792725,
-0.7697167992591858,
0.32357048988342285,
0.38218575716018677,
0.5810802578926086,
0.22540566325187683,
-0.21702271699905396,
-0.5235118865966797,
-1.0929874181747437,
-0.2028099000453949,
-0.20914095640182495,
-0.007432779297232628,
0.4783734977245331,
0.37014248967170715,
-0.2784510552883148,
0.9125688076019287,
-0.2214750349521637,
0.02066940814256668,
-0.4418399930000305,
0.010546904057264328,
0.13498209416866302,
0.544611930847168,
0.6796329021453857,
-0.6561577320098877,
-0.6741000413894653,
0.1345716267824173,
-0.4924375116825104,
0.024981653317809105,
0.1584721803665161,
-0.24147485196590424,
0.19290512800216675,
0.539741575717926,
-0.637466311454773,
0.057681575417518616,
0.6895678639411926,
-0.2868373692035675,
0.32351505756378174,
-0.12167339771986008,
-0.14900973439216614,
-1.2360730171203613,
-0.0782577320933342,
-0.16431444883346558,
-0.2703595757484436,
-0.4431803226470947,
0.10699246823787689,
0.11032413691282272,
-0.06804709136486053,
-0.6261495351791382,
0.7305934429168701,
-0.2659018933773041,
0.10207244753837585,
-0.4059981107711792,
-0.08311168104410172,
-0.17446193099021912,
0.5488841533660889,
0.1300189048051834,
0.9592186808586121,
0.719761312007904,
-0.5338572859764099,
0.38757285475730896,
0.02260257862508297,
-0.5236119031906128,
0.300762414932251,
-0.7104087471961975,
0.4519246220588684,
0.14350943267345428,
0.08355532586574554,
-1.0419000387191772,
-0.36119651794433594,
0.24461214244365692,
-0.5536214709281921,
0.39887431263923645,
-0.23073314130306244,
-0.5418532490730286,
-0.30479684472084045,
-0.25246763229370117,
0.10620054602622986,
0.7660478353500366,
-0.3223394751548767,
0.44186723232269287,
0.4323750436306,
-0.4707184433937073,
-0.5853174328804016,
-0.6559078097343445,
0.2245408147573471,
0.06773978471755981,
-0.7007205486297607,
-0.008617292158305645,
0.132987841963768,
-0.21313445270061493,
0.11796308308839798,
-0.13922041654586792,
-0.21222247183322906,
0.3849490284919739,
0.08107031881809235,
-0.22503843903541565,
-0.4405323565006256,
-0.004564856179058552,
0.3297032415866852,
-0.43894505500793457,
-0.3003630042076111,
-0.6190401911735535,
0.6353994607925415,
-0.1518414169549942,
-0.1681324988603592,
-0.5247014760971069,
0.5956779718399048,
0.6013416647911072,
-0.6067844033241272,
0.9000180959701538,
0.7378894686698914,
-0.36103805899620056,
-0.00692059937864542,
-0.7461263537406921,
-0.28134244680404663,
-0.4689607620239258,
0.812833309173584,
-0.5985174775123596,
-0.972787618637085,
0.3329470157623291,
-0.08420860767364502,
0.26416462659835815,
0.6163903474807739,
0.869236409664154,
-0.047053590416908264,
1.022316575050354,
0.42609354853630066,
-0.253006249666214,
0.417865514755249,
0.018885815516114235,
0.10908915102481842,
-0.5518755912780762,
-0.1773497611284256,
-0.44487959146499634,
-0.18084634840488434,
-0.24454516172409058,
-0.5570112466812134,
-0.11086637526750565,
0.45788198709487915,
-0.12295645475387573,
0.20197848975658417,
-0.12030286341905594,
0.4817419946193695,
0.9251702427864075,
0.1279260367155075,
-0.1230292022228241,
0.11895416676998138,
0.0811040922999382,
-0.14409592747688293,
-0.6254584193229675,
-0.4763140380382538,
1.1460987329483032,
0.6177802681922913,
0.676963746547699,
0.21656067669391632,
0.549959123134613,
0.0377974659204483,
-0.20417116582393646,
-0.6955479979515076,
0.5163128972053528,
-0.2703866958618164,
-0.7274765968322754,
-0.2335832118988037,
-0.2513081729412079,
-0.6117296814918518,
0.30174559354782104,
-0.18683436512947083,
-0.8004674911499023,
0.30144140124320984,
0.39959779381752014,
-0.4188596308231354,
0.13538013398647308,
-1.0247435569763184,
0.9855323433876038,
-0.271865576505661,
-0.44681793451309204,
-0.6448498368263245,
-0.5393019914627075,
0.39647242426872253,
-0.1949177384376526,
-0.1365348994731903,
-0.25672653317451477,
-0.151670902967453,
0.732245683670044,
-0.4344601035118103,
0.7639579772949219,
-0.25590983033180237,
-0.09450715780258179,
0.34622329473495483,
0.17102843523025513,
0.6891907453536987,
0.2739497125148773,
-0.12191709131002426,
0.19833041727542877,
-0.525351345539093,
-0.5707560777664185,
-0.47850775718688965,
0.7705497145652771,
-0.9725612998008728,
-0.4054654538631439,
0.050304729491472244,
-0.2480391412973404,
-0.395137757062912,
0.2779015898704529,
0.2237347662448883,
0.2145020216703415,
0.04446844011545181,
0.8312575817108154,
0.7827751636505127,
-0.3671990633010864,
0.18088001012802124,
0.5452488660812378,
-0.06484954804182053,
-0.47043976187705994,
1.0321539640426636,
-0.04305903986096382,
0.2285316437482834,
0.4605805277824402,
0.24125227332115173,
-0.1989380270242691,
-0.7183820605278015,
-0.3361406922340393,
-0.0956549197435379,
-0.4598301947116852,
-0.0020296445582062006,
-1.1729055643081665,
-0.1060771644115448,
-0.5625646710395813,
0.14325782656669617,
-1.063793420791626,
-0.3147822916507721,
-0.20510761439800262,
-0.18372297286987305,
0.37809988856315613,
0.45862439274787903,
-0.15851598978042603,
0.5086373090744019,
-0.5284789204597473,
0.29478296637535095,
0.7016640901565552,
0.4713267385959625,
0.07739534229040146,
-0.4707096815109253,
-0.3944055140018463,
-0.07601121068000793,
-0.04444136098027229,
-0.7740281224250793,
0.13585369288921356,
0.24088338017463684,
0.4727707803249359,
0.7939273715019226,
-0.18174178898334503,
0.453464537858963,
-0.4687100946903229,
0.8114429116249084,
0.07128595560789108,
-0.6535654067993164,
0.46598273515701294,
-0.44853082299232483,
0.06964575499296188,
0.724789023399353,
-0.07643920928239822,
-0.3190043270587921,
-0.48498979210853577,
-0.573523998260498,
-1.1840486526489258,
0.8461816906929016,
0.4994935095310211,
0.23353898525238037,
0.18503563106060028,
0.11736136674880981,
0.40528199076652527,
0.22013309597969055,
-0.12389922887086868,
-0.10947033017873764,
-0.34280624985694885,
-0.3331434726715088,
-0.1728859692811966,
-0.82305508852005,
0.23484693467617035,
-0.426869660615921,
0.7370505332946777,
0.1276034116744995,
0.25939980149269104,
-0.2448517382144928,
-0.16791364550590515,
0.07826433330774307,
0.18044842779636383,
0.777531623840332,
0.6342477798461914,
-0.36458900570869446,
0.18260008096694946,
-0.0079385070130229,
-0.48331448435783386,
-0.2461312860250473,
0.30220532417297363,
0.008717195130884647,
-0.10780466347932816,
0.4594370722770691,
1.2427200078964233,
0.2744045555591583,
-0.5516277551651001,
0.4321930408477783,
-0.09984268993139267,
-0.13287705183029175,
-0.13355574011802673,
0.28754723072052,
0.3872917592525482,
0.35407352447509766,
0.35165274143218994,
0.060231879353523254,
0.1198914498090744,
-0.2266218662261963,
0.23280225694179535,
0.17908351123332977,
-0.37398770451545715,
-0.3574458360671997,
0.7936223149299622,
0.7076517939567566,
-0.21291129291057587,
0.6146296262741089,
-0.010190348140895367,
-0.41092032194137573,
0.49805769324302673,
0.08077362179756165,
0.9486693143844604,
-0.2583763003349304,
-0.14428122341632843,
0.16802267730236053,
0.38134416937828064,
0.06843364238739014,
0.32012391090393066,
-0.08011194318532944,
-0.5889440774917603,
-0.589317262172699,
-0.4648844003677368,
-0.3885669410228729,
0.4557250142097473,
-0.28301993012428284,
0.13411934673786163,
-0.34500357508659363,
0.12314055114984512,
0.005649648606777191,
0.13704849779605865,
-0.8667364120483398,
0.23481346666812897,
0.30714860558509827,
1.04796302318573,
-0.6905621886253357,
1.0298871994018555,
0.6828599572181702,
-0.25700950622558594,
-0.8213275074958801,
-0.2517601251602173,
-0.05591754987835884,
-0.8358757495880127,
0.536129891872406,
0.15620356798171997,
0.1819823533296585,
0.023398203775286674,
-0.6004929542541504,
-0.7290958762168884,
0.8037384152412415,
0.39239972829818726,
-0.8622135519981384,
0.2066931128501892,
-0.02136092819273472,
0.36659911274909973,
-0.0780901163816452,
0.31455370783805847,
0.516057550907135,
0.46224674582481384,
0.06282125413417816,
-0.8050497770309448,
-0.4152164161205292,
-0.35245004296302795,
-0.061238404363393784,
0.005335070658475161,
-0.6865800023078918,
0.972044825553894,
-0.04491289332509041,
0.12983261048793793,
-0.09426327794790268,
1.2513405084609985,
0.055292077362537384,
-0.07564067840576172,
0.46384578943252563,
0.5968126654624939,
0.5760367512702942,
-0.029104338958859444,
0.9496558308601379,
-0.40728381276130676,
0.2227463275194168,
1.2263518571853638,
-0.22830970585346222,
1.0186623334884644,
0.45634666085243225,
-0.26482221484184265,
0.24264512956142426,
0.7051847577095032,
0.2742718756198883,
0.6878979802131653,
-0.3871849477291107,
-0.1786288022994995,
-0.7032333612442017,
0.2641473412513733,
-0.6056761145591736,
0.46575045585632324,
0.3507617115974426,
-0.10950206965208054,
-0.20246107876300812,
-0.26792559027671814,
0.007642516400665045,
-0.1911367028951645,
0.029818151146173477,
0.8348965048789978,
0.2920728623867035,
-0.6058710813522339,
0.18980666995048523,
0.21988511085510254,
0.6194927096366882,
-0.5930090546607971,
0.10747815668582916,
-0.44372427463531494,
0.5392351746559143,
0.16185468435287476,
-0.9074300527572632,
-0.163277730345726,
-0.033280327916145325,
-0.10308248549699783,
0.030472250655293465,
0.8803073167800903,
-0.5207415819168091,
-0.5677329301834106,
0.19862747192382812,
0.3671305179595947,
0.10955257713794708,
-0.4739466607570648,
-0.8572288155555725,
-0.07003703713417053,
-0.17165204882621765,
-0.59473717212677,
0.23013590276241302,
0.6105653643608093,
0.22479066252708435,
0.5469876527786255,
0.5301494598388672,
-0.06236814334988594,
0.28197184205055237,
-0.022280268371105194,
0.7901426553726196,
-0.3788175582885742,
-0.6492405533790588,
-0.7009219527244568,
0.7037596106529236,
-0.2506287395954132,
-0.49653953313827515,
0.67936110496521,
0.605876624584198,
0.7573843598365784,
-0.14491567015647888,
0.8954117298126221,
0.06574106216430664,
0.5280389785766602,
-0.4689866900444031,
0.6474884152412415,
-0.7121423482894897,
-0.05990986153483391,
-0.2453380972146988,
-0.8690801858901978,
-0.07586164027452469,
0.4768742322921753,
-0.18442240357398987,
0.1590442806482315,
0.22689829766750336,
0.5615401268005371,
-0.301457941532135,
-0.2671777904033661,
0.299356073141098,
0.32661890983581543,
0.4492732286453247,
0.6982063055038452,
0.6806802153587341,
-0.3315456509590149,
0.40436694025993347,
-0.38562387228012085,
-0.2908875644207001,
-0.6413870453834534,
-0.6099613904953003,
-0.9223474264144897,
-0.3416217267513275,
-0.36030495166778564,
-0.19329263269901276,
0.030279060825705528,
0.9270212650299072,
0.9478740692138672,
-0.9428519606590271,
0.12472929060459137,
-0.24404102563858032,
-0.02917972393333912,
-0.20029209554195404,
-0.19090856611728668,
0.3598034083843231,
-0.4916362762451172,
-0.7614523768424988,
0.6264470219612122,
0.4010169804096222,
-0.14884230494499207,
-0.4343646168708801,
-0.4406386613845825,
-0.04348062723875046,
0.11621861904859543,
0.7889416217803955,
0.1579315960407257,
-0.7168914675712585,
0.048721615225076675,
-0.013494247570633888,
-0.2723315954208374,
-0.07347618788480759,
0.619347333908081,
-0.7907242774963379,
0.5332323312759399,
0.7447203397750854,
0.9250314831733704,
0.30699726939201355,
-0.2903609573841095,
0.6928966641426086,
-0.6329293251037598,
0.5504682660102844,
0.3052898049354553,
0.2853986620903015,
0.16230005025863647,
-0.09894179552793503,
0.3832172155380249,
0.2476595640182495,
-0.21534650027751923,
-0.8219965100288391,
0.17575983703136444,
-0.9192662239074707,
-0.4753013551235199,
1.3795572519302368,
0.08206826448440552,
-0.02116049826145172,
-0.024518530815839767,
-0.3926340639591217,
0.09222877025604248,
-0.6612038016319275,
0.4235342741012573,
0.6005182266235352,
0.4104765057563782,
-0.46458470821380615,
-0.5960738658905029,
0.346001535654068,
0.5437478423118591,
-0.5416900515556335,
-0.051034994423389435,
0.20314538478851318,
0.22715730965137482,
-0.23011137545108795,
0.6369857788085938,
0.1254217028617859,
0.2169315665960312,
0.21365651488304138,
0.10415659844875336,
-0.28109362721443176,
-0.4312921166419983,
0.04781690612435341,
0.05965190753340721,
0.21166399121284485,
-0.253192275762558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04412v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04412v2
|
The Silicon Ceiling: Auditing GPT's Race and Gender Biases in Hiring
| 2024-05-07T15:39:45 | 2024-05-09T18:20:08 |
Lena Armstrong, Abbey Liu, Stephen MacNeil, Danaë Metaxa
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being introduced in workplace
settings, with the goals of improving efficiency and fairness. However,
concerns have arisen regarding these models' potential to reflect or exacerbate
social biases and stereotypes. This study explores the potential impact of LLMs
on hiring practices. To do so, we conduct an algorithm audit of race and gender
biases in one commonly-used LLM, OpenAI's GPT-3.5, taking inspiration from the
history of traditional offline resume audits. We conduct two studies using
names with varied race and gender connotations: resume assessment (Study 1) and
resume generation (Study 2). In Study 1, we ask GPT to score resumes with 32
different names (4 names for each combination of the 2 gender and 4 racial
groups) and two anonymous options across 10 occupations and 3 evaluation tasks
(overall rating, willingness to interview, and hireability). We find that the
model reflects some biases based on stereotypes. In Study 2, we prompt GPT to
create resumes (10 for each name) for fictitious job candidates. When
generating resumes, GPT reveals underlying biases; women's resumes had
occupations with less experience, while Asian and Hispanic resumes had
immigrant markers, such as non-native English and non-U.S. education and work
experiences. Our findings contribute to a growing body of literature on LLM
biases, in particular when used in workplace contexts.
|
[
0.11501508951187134,
-0.15086911618709564,
0.8102129101753235,
0.148634672164917,
0.15566611289978027,
-0.011083018034696579,
0.16502226889133453,
-0.4842967987060547,
0.17082571983337402,
0.3947717845439911,
-0.47989383339881897,
-0.49434229731559753,
-0.698624312877655,
0.06826170533895493,
-0.32059159874916077,
1.221221685409546,
-0.09132326394319534,
0.23823118209838867,
-0.013346808031201363,
0.1591285765171051,
-0.9918389320373535,
-0.4681580364704132,
-0.510685920715332,
-0.17931655049324036,
0.33603280782699585,
0.19826140999794006,
0.6784465312957764,
0.7040438055992126,
0.2526492476463318,
0.21247126162052155,
-0.13397623598575592,
-0.1255730539560318,
-0.45161888003349304,
-0.08005267381668091,
-0.1598014533519745,
-0.6406242251396179,
-0.3297647535800934,
0.5654288530349731,
0.6289858222007751,
0.9037693738937378,
-0.14178809523582458,
0.5310472846031189,
-0.019300587475299835,
0.7133975625038147,
-0.7548142671585083,
0.20028065145015717,
-0.8279440999031067,
0.16748087108135223,
-0.3185996413230896,
0.03785622492432594,
-0.15964704751968384,
-0.5897521376609802,
0.07245157659053802,
-0.20919965207576752,
0.46320366859436035,
0.01654690131545067,
0.6405104994773865,
0.11450032889842987,
-0.6455327868461609,
-0.27787935733795166,
-0.9486186504364014,
0.7962499856948853,
-0.5004571676254272,
0.4351691007614136,
0.37732774019241333,
0.37971726059913635,
-0.13386626541614532,
-0.2095979005098343,
-0.2961309254169464,
-0.25410017371177673,
0.0456884540617466,
0.2407008558511734,
0.2892327308654785,
-0.0012220743810757995,
0.4737159311771393,
0.41758912801742554,
-0.5215758681297302,
0.27556928992271423,
-0.9870335459709167,
-0.15658950805664062,
0.3864666819572449,
0.181661918759346,
0.40909695625305176,
0.03863609954714775,
-0.025090856477618217,
0.061008140444755554,
-1.0049386024475098,
-0.162618026137352,
0.7241109609603882,
0.3571908175945282,
-0.0406830720603466,
0.6736019253730774,
-0.06261704862117767,
0.476175993680954,
-0.35592564940452576,
-0.19892951846122742,
0.13957582414150238,
-0.07686127722263336,
-0.2126753032207489,
0.3595012128353119,
0.3058936893939972,
0.5200057625770569,
0.3407272696495056,
-0.18751639127731323,
-0.19173556566238403,
0.287543922662735,
0.36525222659111023,
-0.6405584812164307,
-0.04574981704354286,
-0.1103288009762764,
-0.42188310623168945,
-0.10164866596460342,
0.41195687651634216,
-0.5784531831741333,
-0.730813205242157,
-0.21108973026275635,
0.018748272210359573,
0.05861496925354004,
-0.24924501776695251,
-0.27068352699279785,
-0.38399362564086914,
0.16889728605747223,
0.31820258498191833,
-0.8111538887023926,
0.07093390822410583,
1.0227742195129395,
0.8132525086402893,
-0.10861826688051224,
-0.1003991961479187,
-0.507576048374176,
0.16042375564575195,
-0.4424085021018982,
0.17730972170829773,
-0.6839090585708618,
-0.3734014332294464,
0.1672694981098175,
0.09653966873884201,
-0.05212333798408508,
-0.702743411064148,
0.34687796235084534,
-0.39523929357528687,
0.258256196975708,
-0.35939642786979675,
-0.3102472722530365,
-0.11458835005760193,
0.0005708940443582833,
-0.3934098184108734,
0.8506744503974915,
0.23144575953483582,
-0.6417315602302551,
0.7700406908988953,
-0.6258363723754883,
-0.031704727560281754,
0.05862613767385483,
-0.9021754264831543,
-0.2155587375164032,
0.25463783740997314,
-0.00295013515278697,
0.2654308080673218,
-0.20526155829429626,
0.2816442549228668,
-0.12042658030986786,
-0.9196761250495911,
-0.01301252469420433,
-0.29285094141960144,
0.9444767832756042,
-0.00903086457401514,
-0.4528595209121704,
-0.27613893151283264,
-0.20676414668560028,
-0.5777670741081238,
0.04538087546825409,
-0.24360263347625732,
-0.4371688663959503,
-0.04750440642237663,
-0.42123356461524963,
0.1532365083694458,
-0.04536687210202217,
-0.8761082291603088,
-0.056078940629959106,
-0.262151300907135,
0.1884639412164688,
1.1742358207702637,
-0.22442586719989777,
0.24943511188030243,
-0.5082798600196838,
0.7722131609916687,
0.010662991553544998,
-0.11171302199363708,
-0.07971322536468506,
-0.7380878329277039,
-0.19934262335300446,
-0.21097053587436676,
0.1603979915380478,
0.7475154995918274,
-0.3742220997810364,
0.01093071885406971,
-0.1390678882598877,
-0.6390583515167236,
-0.4803491532802582,
0.22371906042099,
0.36722588539123535,
0.543357253074646,
-0.21568840742111206,
-0.3059576153755188,
-0.37571612000465393,
-1.093080997467041,
-0.7403741478919983,
-0.3486023545265198,
-0.3633180558681488,
0.7077126502990723,
0.5954277515411377,
-0.3275390565395355,
1.0253503322601318,
-0.5555027723312378,
-0.36620473861694336,
0.30031511187553406,
0.016917187720537186,
0.8083615303039551,
0.4828837215900421,
0.47626423835754395,
-0.7933168411254883,
-0.3006567656993866,
-0.19685441255569458,
-0.7176443338394165,
-0.13091595470905304,
-0.11090858280658722,
-0.13795606791973114,
0.07722224295139313,
0.30811384320259094,
-0.47704458236694336,
0.4978697896003723,
0.5777895450592041,
-0.3517766296863556,
0.8550940155982971,
-0.01301497220993042,
0.09628574550151825,
-0.6916850805282593,
-0.1304309368133545,
0.5609862804412842,
0.010030404664576054,
-0.30864113569259644,
-0.12870652973651886,
0.023849105462431908,
-0.2220323234796524,
-0.7310853004455566,
0.5288563370704651,
-0.5880151987075806,
-0.5395436882972717,
0.05417301878333092,
0.11009176075458527,
-0.2597162127494812,
0.1904248595237732,
-0.19629181921482086,
1.0626795291900635,
0.15821455419063568,
-0.5302016735076904,
0.16891133785247803,
0.13657090067863464,
-0.5427954792976379,
0.5356324911117554,
-0.3661046326160431,
0.400749146938324,
-0.31530094146728516,
0.45739495754241943,
-1.110962986946106,
-0.04539098963141441,
0.005558067001402378,
-0.17996829748153687,
0.043740686029195786,
-0.202985018491745,
-0.5323952436447144,
-0.6747601628303528,
-0.5610454082489014,
0.7082710266113281,
0.5996752381324768,
-0.4524663984775543,
0.2362270951271057,
0.5620502233505249,
-0.41515737771987915,
-0.5594255328178406,
-0.9351953268051147,
-0.006387216039001942,
-0.3165850341320038,
-0.5049034953117371,
0.41876527667045593,
0.10920107364654541,
-0.46199774742126465,
-0.43727779388427734,
-0.262882262468338,
-0.4036158621311188,
0.020063461735844612,
0.38860780000686646,
0.7864342927932739,
-0.04469544067978859,
-0.20194898545742035,
-0.11796704679727554,
0.14031170308589935,
0.014897915534675121,
-0.13825708627700806,
0.18986600637435913,
-0.07679031044244766,
-0.4714011549949646,
-0.2954385578632355,
0.09566023200750351,
0.593917965888977,
0.29447659850120544,
0.7557877898216248,
0.6413173079490662,
-0.4530981183052063,
0.2532048523426056,
-0.9379606246948242,
-0.2868734300136566,
-0.49849507212638855,
0.4478219151496887,
-0.12327166646718979,
-1.2308290004730225,
0.5762127041816711,
-0.06772817671298981,
0.24382156133651733,
0.3447858989238739,
0.7194651961326599,
0.0018810618203133345,
1.0587294101715088,
0.8236769437789917,
-0.24575670063495636,
0.5316829085350037,
0.18295074999332428,
0.3927115499973297,
-0.9610049724578857,
-0.008956429548561573,
-0.4855648875236511,
-0.23493914306163788,
-0.9998906254768372,
-0.24270248413085938,
0.575302004814148,
-0.3944096565246582,
-0.33288002014160156,
0.023049132898449898,
-0.740974485874176,
0.6623062491416931,
0.6073169708251953,
0.006103435531258583,
0.2270379215478897,
-0.1747441440820694,
-0.06487945467233658,
-0.33701804280281067,
-0.3898352384567261,
-0.7213494181632996,
1.1274373531341553,
0.5858060717582703,
0.4318251609802246,
-0.04886426404118538,
0.5199214220046997,
0.43699342012405396,
0.5988051295280457,
-0.2894083261489868,
0.4310125410556793,
-0.36489737033843994,
-0.9289588928222656,
-0.29521510004997253,
-0.5504967570304871,
-0.6754468679428101,
0.27150118350982666,
0.2305058240890503,
-1.0976215600967407,
0.22486455738544464,
0.04044712707400322,
-0.3065425157546997,
0.4381447434425354,
-0.6658453941345215,
0.7526496052742004,
-0.2022717148065567,
-0.04685792326927185,
0.06641639024019241,
-0.23653198778629303,
1.0126153230667114,
-0.5668700337409973,
0.4772167205810547,
-0.34875014424324036,
-0.005483638495206833,
0.9208873510360718,
-0.4014194905757904,
0.9775208830833435,
-0.43524372577667236,
-0.12521792948246002,
-0.046417608857154846,
0.22044895589351654,
0.5576954483985901,
-0.13318003714084625,
-0.6153885126113892,
0.6111077070236206,
0.17945323884487152,
-0.1692868322134018,
-0.24196676909923553,
0.5983266234397888,
-0.79932701587677,
-0.6251437067985535,
-0.4564201831817627,
-0.6547161340713501,
-0.10581500828266144,
0.10352309048175812,
0.15188494324684143,
0.12115255743265152,
-0.12676313519477844,
-0.07076281309127808,
0.09963003545999527,
-0.7501387596130371,
-0.29241427779197693,
0.2866668105125427,
-0.21103817224502563,
0.17604589462280273,
0.8574444055557251,
0.4785059094429016,
-0.07178954780101776,
-0.2752567231655121,
0.13496708869934082,
0.00038311645039357245,
-0.2284335494041443,
-0.2983008325099945,
0.5801593065261841,
-0.4407067596912384,
0.11114088445901871,
-0.38412830233573914,
-0.2505700886249542,
-0.7005933523178101,
-0.13415217399597168,
-0.2477540224790573,
-0.2171444445848465,
0.06855544447898865,
-0.033062927424907684,
0.00707650650292635,
0.9485472440719604,
0.15807588398456573,
0.3041352927684784,
-0.3668588101863861,
0.32640311121940613,
0.3757467269897461,
0.4217006266117096,
-0.1829967498779297,
-0.4312543272972107,
-0.23686832189559937,
0.0890984758734703,
-0.2892630100250244,
-0.8836941123008728,
0.21114790439605713,
-0.18192996084690094,
0.5543209314346313,
0.2959538400173187,
-0.09446954727172852,
0.277474969625473,
-0.55836021900177,
1.1199736595153809,
0.20301859080791473,
-0.6479107141494751,
0.5196342468261719,
-0.6816799640655518,
0.12559638917446136,
0.6843395829200745,
0.42975205183029175,
-0.7393620610237122,
-0.7018436789512634,
-0.34144800901412964,
-0.8100326061248779,
0.9262810945510864,
0.20917728543281555,
0.2769292891025543,
-0.2452544867992401,
0.5390114188194275,
0.25831690430641174,
0.5522239208221436,
-0.7190564870834351,
-0.23123277723789215,
0.18901920318603516,
0.020018035545945168,
0.2570231556892395,
-0.5251978635787964,
-0.014621011912822723,
-0.2516648471355438,
0.5782880783081055,
0.23768335580825806,
0.4908405542373657,
-0.11620744317770004,
0.03857843205332756,
0.057949088513851166,
0.20218151807785034,
0.5247902274131775,
0.8120970129966736,
-0.4149031639099121,
-0.13226361572742462,
0.4939291477203369,
-0.5207549929618835,
0.05273683741688728,
-0.2787206172943115,
-0.1437530219554901,
0.10831242054700851,
-0.0939582884311676,
0.5007607340812683,
-0.08538518846035004,
-0.5817827582359314,
0.6396124958992004,
-0.036701712757349014,
-0.31036457419395447,
-0.6365297436714172,
0.05483496934175491,
-0.19764859974384308,
0.3207097351551056,
0.45485058426856995,
-0.26883766055107117,
0.16277220845222473,
-0.7791861891746521,
-0.2763233184814453,
0.6544620394706726,
-0.4205020070075989,
0.02608579397201538,
0.8024555444717407,
0.09096774458885193,
-0.5351336598396301,
0.8621721267700195,
-0.08204568922519684,
-0.5799855589866638,
0.7001076340675354,
0.5513027906417847,
0.9722496867179871,
-0.223613902926445,
0.019652096554636955,
0.0822482630610466,
0.48818567395210266,
-0.2815675735473633,
-0.10702149569988251,
0.07548262178897858,
-0.7937167882919312,
-0.4340647757053375,
-0.5010079145431519,
-0.8215222358703613,
-0.016167452558875084,
-0.46621987223625183,
0.14697296917438507,
-0.5272019505500793,
-0.33581700921058655,
-0.26378557085990906,
-0.2915414571762085,
-0.9064105749130249,
0.1051860973238945,
0.47176575660705566,
0.700630784034729,
-1.0860803127288818,
0.3530412018299103,
0.6756408214569092,
-0.250226229429245,
-0.6375018954277039,
0.03156770393252373,
0.4659183919429779,
-1.0049251317977905,
1.0419385433197021,
0.5021684765815735,
0.0672447681427002,
-0.4549935758113861,
-0.11014528572559357,
-0.7171081304550171,
1.262352466583252,
0.7184610366821289,
-0.5589234828948975,
-0.4666147530078888,
0.35645195841789246,
0.12809188663959503,
-0.4271204173564911,
0.6795373558998108,
0.9165975451469421,
0.5594752430915833,
-0.22068916261196136,
-1.4443703889846802,
0.02210826240479946,
-0.17638124525547028,
0.32654765248298645,
-0.09134474396705627,
-0.572318434715271,
0.9969561100006104,
-0.056178271770477295,
-0.233808696269989,
-0.1298777014017105,
0.28619521856307983,
0.6756699085235596,
0.2849741280078888,
0.7352341413497925,
0.03776147589087486,
1.1928961277008057,
-0.06230597198009491,
1.2132065296173096,
-0.2649703919887543,
-0.007024634629487991,
0.9224755167961121,
-0.612080991268158,
0.27227649092674255,
0.3718410134315491,
-0.38495057821273804,
0.7200354337692261,
0.6573315858840942,
-0.19765503704547882,
0.0808246061205864,
0.4229452908039093,
-0.09460762143135071,
0.18668565154075623,
-0.3943597972393036,
-0.43849509954452515,
0.4600384533405304,
0.14470265805721283,
-0.5844265818595886,
-0.1668063998222351,
-0.06331723183393478,
0.10755849629640579,
-0.22245262563228607,
-0.4048158526420593,
0.32910969853401184,
0.31351470947265625,
-0.5869930982589722,
0.04419289901852608,
0.13055111467838287,
0.911392092704773,
-0.2020309567451477,
-0.16561594605445862,
-0.04443645477294922,
0.21103568375110626,
-0.38736337423324585,
-0.6980763077735901,
0.32672253251075745,
0.2261030077934265,
-0.22722549736499786,
-0.26371586322784424,
0.5592066049575806,
-0.14856353402137756,
-0.5494007468223572,
0.20339205861091614,
0.5874075293540955,
0.6042534112930298,
-0.36909574270248413,
-0.49331143498420715,
-0.014093371108174324,
0.043248437345027924,
-0.04952133446931839,
0.4850803017616272,
0.22768911719322205,
-0.17208842933177948,
0.34145811200141907,
0.5932202339172363,
0.5023428797721863,
0.027809523046016693,
0.14308138191699982,
0.3663051128387451,
-0.6822291016578674,
-0.830159604549408,
-1.0540757179260254,
0.30408820509910583,
-0.06737813353538513,
-0.09234266728162766,
0.7558269500732422,
0.6467469930648804,
0.7766339778900146,
0.16851630806922913,
0.8032793402671814,
0.608508288860321,
0.651046633720398,
-0.3945484161376953,
0.680781364440918,
-0.391652375459671,
0.47323793172836304,
-0.7912333011627197,
-1.472181797027588,
-0.018350455909967422,
0.5693402290344238,
-0.7533915042877197,
0.6105587482452393,
0.4795297086238861,
0.8835296630859375,
0.07785601913928986,
0.14369995892047882,
0.1914099007844925,
0.1925797313451767,
0.4481109380722046,
0.45275411009788513,
0.6026911735534668,
-0.16040128469467163,
0.4344114363193512,
0.16571727395057678,
-0.42281773686408997,
-0.24623437225818634,
-1.0229132175445557,
-0.5409706234931946,
-0.11985534429550171,
-0.5100105404853821,
-0.3119872510433197,
0.04836922883987427,
0.6508793830871582,
0.6269132494926453,
-0.4480712115764618,
-0.5026993751525879,
0.2854338586330414,
0.25318682193756104,
0.04763085022568703,
-0.31540122628211975,
0.03319671005010605,
0.011087324470281601,
-0.6039876937866211,
0.41925153136253357,
0.2734558582305908,
-0.1694081425666809,
-0.31477656960487366,
-0.01828243024647236,
0.16318194568157196,
0.029546279460191727,
0.357005774974823,
0.27729249000549316,
-0.639266848564148,
-0.37280410528182983,
-0.44642215967178345,
-0.1825694739818573,
-0.0691588819026947,
0.7623121738433838,
-0.6340366005897522,
0.2267301082611084,
0.12002703547477722,
0.6263664960861206,
0.5447725653648376,
-0.08893149346113205,
0.9200998544692993,
-0.7395321726799011,
0.013415000401437283,
0.08971938490867615,
0.557427704334259,
0.30898475646972656,
-0.6226897835731506,
0.7762505412101746,
0.3579755425453186,
-0.6360495686531067,
-1.2150005102157593,
-0.09664230793714523,
-0.4758007824420929,
-0.0955272912979126,
1.1596431732177734,
0.3260525166988373,
-0.08064109086990356,
-0.14387671649456024,
-0.029389774426817894,
0.26841992139816284,
-0.3386757969856262,
0.9064701795578003,
0.7046351432800293,
-0.020401908084750175,
0.14228133857250214,
-1.2583316564559937,
0.25051525235176086,
0.39721736311912537,
-0.34742847084999084,
0.04471983388066292,
0.46269965171813965,
0.37365567684173584,
0.11716742068529129,
1.1225666999816895,
-0.22327964007854462,
0.4955140948295593,
-0.2493698000907898,
-0.08473721146583557,
-0.059925634413957596,
-0.140009805560112,
-0.20149095356464386,
-0.06067227944731712,
0.05798470228910446,
-0.03452569618821144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04404v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04404v1
|
Vision Mamba: A Comprehensive Survey and Taxonomy
| 2024-05-07T15:30:14 | 2024-05-07T15:30:14 |
Xiao Liu, Chenxu Zhang, Lei Zhang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
State Space Model (SSM) is a mathematical model used to describe and analyze
the behavior of dynamic systems. This model has witnessed numerous applications
in several fields, including control theory, signal processing, economics and
machine learning. In the field of deep learning, state space models are used to
process sequence data, such as time series analysis, natural language
processing (NLP) and video understanding. By mapping sequence data to state
space, long-term dependencies in the data can be better captured. In
particular, modern SSMs have shown strong representational capabilities in NLP,
especially in long sequence modeling, while maintaining linear time complexity.
Notably, based on the latest state-space models, Mamba merges time-varying
parameters into SSMs and formulates a hardware-aware algorithm for efficient
training and inference. Given its impressive efficiency and strong long-range
dependency modeling capability, Mamba is expected to become a new AI
architecture that may outperform Transformer. Recently, a number of works have
attempted to study the potential of Mamba in various fields, such as general
vision, multi-modal, medical image analysis and remote sensing image analysis,
by extending Mamba from natural language domain to visual domain. To fully
understand Mamba in the visual domain, we conduct a comprehensive survey and
present a taxonomy study. This survey focuses on Mamba's application to a
variety of visual tasks and data types, and discusses its predecessors, recent
advances and far-reaching impact on a wide range of domains. Since Mamba is now
on an upward trend, please actively notice us if you have new findings, and new
progress on Mamba will be included in this survey in a timely manner and
updated on the Mamba project at
https://github.com/lx6c78/Vision-Mamba-A-Comprehensive-Survey-and-Taxonomy.
|
[
-0.5903410315513611,
-0.821297824382782,
0.5310719013214111,
-0.05999566987156868,
-0.4304649829864502,
0.10762809962034225,
0.2713814973831177,
-0.2895964980125427,
0.4511283338069916,
0.5764468312263489,
-0.48053494095802307,
-0.5133833885192871,
-0.7473549842834473,
-0.2666225731372833,
-0.3513696491718292,
0.3298560082912445,
-0.18104368448257446,
0.02713242545723915,
-0.32724493741989136,
-0.3751836121082306,
-0.7679114937782288,
-0.7248923778533936,
-0.20623639225959778,
0.031074192374944687,
0.31717216968536377,
-0.07598734647035599,
0.6415659785270691,
0.33732616901397705,
0.6795591115951538,
0.35627517104148865,
-0.2491065412759781,
0.40772250294685364,
-0.22611556947231293,
0.06213622912764549,
-0.1014825701713562,
-0.6010070443153381,
-0.367645263671875,
-0.10778580605983734,
0.7680217623710632,
1.0250872373580933,
-0.41798827052116394,
0.2673126459121704,
-0.007000243291258812,
0.9741724729537964,
-0.9934477806091309,
0.294459730386734,
-0.3669944703578949,
0.33816859126091003,
-0.27669376134872437,
-0.0023794881999492645,
-0.10953966528177261,
-0.3527177572250366,
-0.02767477184534073,
-0.5498723983764648,
-0.23850186169147491,
0.06890887767076492,
1.0806533098220825,
0.5698217749595642,
-0.7693344354629517,
-0.029769225046038628,
-0.8799130916595459,
0.9254486560821533,
-0.4875744581222534,
0.3269823491573334,
-0.04518310725688934,
0.8471094965934753,
-0.39000123739242554,
-0.3621121346950531,
-0.5224295258522034,
-0.11156591773033142,
0.38192638754844666,
0.3497330844402313,
-0.2771291434764862,
-0.17400774359703064,
0.08564623445272446,
0.4262305498123169,
-0.24900667369365692,
0.12576644122600555,
-0.6971532106399536,
-0.17992879450321198,
0.4611997604370117,
0.6627612709999084,
0.34183448553085327,
-0.4616415202617645,
-0.7141633629798889,
0.21872879564762115,
-0.5996120572090149,
0.3906312584877014,
0.061081431806087494,
0.16791388392448425,
-0.1016547754406929,
0.80518639087677,
-0.1751202493906021,
1.1672767400741577,
-0.4552808701992035,
-0.2349950522184372,
0.023947210982441902,
-0.35043272376060486,
-0.5451812744140625,
-0.27499082684516907,
0.6485877633094788,
0.6108982563018799,
-0.0035026627592742443,
0.26180076599121094,
0.0021677950862795115,
0.38300246000289917,
0.7358148694038391,
-0.4705308973789215,
0.2471495270729065,
-0.04134966805577278,
-0.733923077583313,
-0.2048676759004593,
0.05866816267371178,
-1.0214672088623047,
-0.6468954086303711,
-0.6149934530258179,
0.29758796095848083,
-0.6066621541976929,
-0.41946282982826233,
0.17975489795207977,
0.16931116580963135,
0.34418973326683044,
0.4189164340496063,
-0.4584483802318573,
0.33475011587142944,
0.5464327335357666,
1.1379655599594116,
-0.3389764428138733,
-0.12144292891025543,
0.05627788230776787,
0.09390587359666824,
-0.7984366416931152,
0.613429605960846,
-0.5335233211517334,
-0.626781165599823,
-0.036104071885347366,
0.10324371606111526,
-0.1547096073627472,
-0.6349399089813232,
-0.03157191351056099,
-0.43069902062416077,
-0.2298298329114914,
-0.0881485641002655,
-0.6423409581184387,
-0.6957268118858337,
0.2105056494474411,
-0.6298568844795227,
0.891937255859375,
0.156845360994339,
-0.12323593348264694,
0.7061804533004761,
-0.868816077709198,
-0.36053401231765747,
0.12032844126224518,
-0.12089217454195023,
-0.32525715231895447,
0.15403589606285095,
0.03582453355193138,
0.7626058459281921,
-0.14331994950771332,
0.4048348665237427,
-0.44234776496887207,
-0.41340968012809753,
0.2571139633655548,
0.273711621761322,
0.525765597820282,
0.633280873298645,
-0.06183178350329399,
0.21443119645118713,
-0.9863110184669495,
-0.3389921188354492,
0.21936456859111786,
-0.23023934662342072,
-0.5147262811660767,
0.5163205862045288,
-0.38823121786117554,
0.18776528537273407,
0.1120753213763237,
-0.3937351405620575,
0.26422134041786194,
-0.38704487681388855,
0.470745712518692,
0.6302862763404846,
0.23311710357666016,
0.628142237663269,
0.2783876359462738,
0.812211275100708,
0.4043704867362976,
0.47789013385772705,
-0.42461922764778137,
-0.5882341861724854,
-0.7813534736633301,
-0.31920310854911804,
-0.019125550985336304,
0.4987313747406006,
-0.8175118565559387,
0.43129095435142517,
-0.07563728094100952,
-0.6384326219558716,
-0.34365832805633545,
-0.023220369592308998,
-0.06924440711736679,
0.52256178855896,
0.3940403461456299,
-0.3776600658893585,
-0.5467406511306763,
-1.1281527280807495,
0.10592838376760483,
0.16029229760169983,
0.3002716302871704,
0.411455899477005,
0.5501115918159485,
-0.3156612515449524,
1.0261590480804443,
-0.6630176305770874,
-0.4615514278411865,
-0.27598556876182556,
-0.3138583302497864,
0.3011261820793152,
0.32521045207977295,
0.7904486060142517,
-0.8634169101715088,
0.18531478941440582,
-0.24548332393169403,
-1.0471482276916504,
0.4409518837928772,
-0.003318858565762639,
-0.24236229062080383,
0.21790075302124023,
0.27726635336875916,
-0.37888821959495544,
0.7890958786010742,
0.5235962271690369,
-0.17088142037391663,
0.25086861848831177,
0.1342872828245163,
0.23356536030769348,
-1.3293266296386719,
0.15637898445129395,
0.1076074168086052,
0.09311732649803162,
-0.5691439509391785,
0.3933160901069641,
0.0064799669198691845,
-0.47988155484199524,
-0.6361144185066223,
0.3301048278808594,
-0.47584015130996704,
-0.4911501109600067,
-0.37077465653419495,
0.022580424323678017,
-0.2239854782819748,
0.4607245922088623,
-0.22653038799762726,
0.5592712163925171,
0.9165174961090088,
-1.1320619583129883,
0.6173570156097412,
0.1223972961306572,
-0.6412000060081482,
0.5833385586738586,
-0.3221544325351715,
-0.2978462874889374,
-0.06565050780773163,
0.11435875296592712,
-1.0842841863632202,
-0.03589365631341934,
0.37118324637413025,
-0.35218724608421326,
0.23624496161937714,
-0.2730006277561188,
-0.4982539415359497,
-0.6136074066162109,
0.08764977008104324,
0.14042045176029205,
0.48312366008758545,
-0.37020403146743774,
0.8243727684020996,
0.8584528565406799,
0.1481277048587799,
-0.5641873478889465,
-0.6708915829658508,
0.22083397209644318,
-0.15310032665729523,
-0.45627182722091675,
-0.10142073035240173,
0.39651185274124146,
-0.13618792593479156,
-0.052727896720170975,
-0.2417810708284378,
-0.017691265791654587,
0.3815726339817047,
0.7210345268249512,
0.8398120403289795,
-0.2545803189277649,
-0.040032871067523956,
-0.03319716826081276,
-0.09070692211389542,
0.0283192191272974,
-0.11063734441995621,
0.6189482808113098,
-0.2760864198207855,
-0.45979321002960205,
-0.2631373107433319,
0.24477626383304596,
0.49516284465789795,
-0.28765419125556946,
0.8666324019432068,
0.22687272727489471,
-0.4898794889450073,
-0.04494441673159599,
-0.12953507900238037,
0.2981049418449402,
-0.4295501708984375,
0.49191299080848694,
-0.44354623556137085,
-0.8736688494682312,
0.5131337642669678,
-0.4871867597103119,
-0.0639662891626358,
0.4929070472717285,
0.5811780691146851,
-0.3042992651462555,
0.8733267784118652,
0.9070013165473938,
-0.1805768609046936,
0.4173973500728607,
-0.490921288728714,
0.26445648074150085,
-0.8411315083503723,
-0.6651101112365723,
-0.18616484105587006,
-0.6629796624183655,
-0.24431759119033813,
-0.5316117405891418,
0.20718224346637726,
0.06923048198223114,
-0.03985212370753288,
0.3219923973083496,
-0.5710398554801941,
0.08628144860267639,
0.3292063772678375,
0.12585106492042542,
-0.2492072880268097,
-0.11198973655700684,
-0.36538782715797424,
-0.16338135302066803,
-0.5900577902793884,
-0.5061050653457642,
0.9445878863334656,
0.19959600269794464,
0.8273018002510071,
0.059441208839416504,
0.3175913691520691,
0.2487782984972,
-0.2552604675292969,
-1.0648115873336792,
1.0058118104934692,
-0.14142780005931854,
-0.5086556673049927,
-0.12006781995296478,
-0.21292434632778168,
-1.0629546642303467,
0.2452169507741928,
-0.18724124133586884,
-0.6060432195663452,
0.3451128304004669,
0.14418305456638336,
-0.3621882498264313,
0.6104715466499329,
-0.37218567728996277,
0.5619248747825623,
-0.1435810625553131,
-0.024743562564253807,
-0.42624127864837646,
-0.7113044857978821,
0.5857576727867126,
-0.02703399583697319,
0.10816548019647598,
-0.3363271653652191,
-0.26576003432273865,
0.6955104470252991,
-0.4714658260345459,
0.8671736121177673,
-0.5344117283821106,
-0.03067241981625557,
0.5192016363143921,
0.25983697175979614,
-0.1270342916250229,
-0.31433507800102234,
0.19136211276054382,
0.5275731682777405,
-0.07868625968694687,
-0.5337072014808655,
-0.4714249074459076,
0.5121995210647583,
-0.6709978580474854,
-0.2930600941181183,
-0.5906792283058167,
-0.29283177852630615,
-0.3604452311992645,
0.10600444674491882,
-0.14103516936302185,
0.3088962435722351,
-0.15579593181610107,
0.2922007441520691,
0.312280535697937,
-0.5057774186134338,
0.38430193066596985,
0.36554965376853943,
-0.7443734407424927,
-0.1756841391324997,
0.7873098254203796,
0.29365918040275574,
-0.018499501049518585,
0.2820959985256195,
-0.24275679886341095,
-0.1509484201669693,
-0.5068418383598328,
-0.5450859665870667,
-0.09066391736268997,
-0.794840931892395,
-0.2172652930021286,
-0.2517942786216736,
-0.2851506173610687,
-0.05524326488375664,
-0.07545743137598038,
-0.4611501395702362,
-0.3783743381500244,
-0.21804071962833405,
-0.07280328124761581,
0.21676628291606903,
0.7331115007400513,
0.33125758171081543,
0.30674323439598083,
-0.6280840039253235,
0.5916993021965027,
0.04963783919811249,
0.40542173385620117,
0.007600113749504089,
-0.2108873724937439,
-0.31864237785339355,
-0.10794951021671295,
-0.32994306087493896,
-0.9408031702041626,
0.3348228335380554,
-0.019456518813967705,
0.8932141065597534,
0.4218078851699829,
-0.3345639705657959,
0.9714720845222473,
-0.40430495142936707,
1.2749935388565063,
0.5057702660560608,
-0.753960907459259,
1.1049609184265137,
0.007500409614294767,
0.3348173201084137,
0.18769866228103638,
0.4770619571208954,
-0.4124533534049988,
-0.1591026932001114,
-0.12983204424381256,
-0.8447211980819702,
0.44153913855552673,
-0.12703324854373932,
0.03906713053584099,
0.2948853671550751,
0.5183959007263184,
0.10740050673484802,
0.3261971175670624,
-0.06219181790947914,
-0.37099379301071167,
-0.5435462594032288,
-0.0055323694832623005,
-0.12611927092075348,
-0.03368132933974266,
-0.10493563115596771,
-0.26016536355018616,
0.2941994071006775,
-0.22454166412353516,
0.4300205409526825,
-0.11738504469394684,
-0.32869651913642883,
0.08145339787006378,
0.20715279877185822,
0.5658650994300842,
0.8676140308380127,
0.18596744537353516,
-0.09468603134155273,
0.24652038514614105,
-0.4526619017124176,
0.27192145586013794,
-0.09151870757341385,
-0.3057402968406677,
-0.025309860706329346,
-0.04414711520075798,
0.9847283959388733,
0.3679274916648865,
-0.4375896155834198,
0.41477689146995544,
0.4327366054058075,
-0.29163771867752075,
-0.2439940869808197,
0.4408310651779175,
0.03060402348637581,
0.2683160901069641,
0.49855655431747437,
0.6451348662376404,
0.2806321680545807,
-0.5985485315322876,
-0.14022782444953918,
0.38178709149360657,
-0.348090261220932,
-0.10176043212413788,
0.8126732110977173,
-0.03611326217651367,
0.0241247545927763,
0.42002272605895996,
0.2660233974456787,
-0.3704628646373749,
0.8875213265419006,
0.24293720722198486,
0.43104299902915955,
-0.24938812851905823,
0.12590323388576508,
0.44105833768844604,
0.20362386107444763,
0.15715263783931732,
0.5536848902702332,
-0.11149332672357559,
-0.6862027049064636,
-0.3315408527851105,
-0.9149535894393921,
-0.4600696265697479,
0.005292794667184353,
-0.8521962761878967,
0.11192243546247482,
-0.762861430644989,
-0.5962939858436584,
-0.03952176868915558,
-0.03241856396198273,
-0.49423420429229736,
0.45881640911102295,
0.49441272020339966,
0.9187642335891724,
-0.5598906874656677,
0.8217232823371887,
0.9465848803520203,
-0.45933935046195984,
-0.5497146248817444,
-0.533513605594635,
0.4111648201942444,
-1.0162450075149536,
0.6409553289413452,
0.025927307084202766,
-0.45890143513679504,
-0.38140538334846497,
-0.7975422739982605,
-0.9528468251228333,
1.2276191711425781,
0.1074475646018982,
-0.7078194618225098,
0.22051088511943817,
0.04752297326922417,
0.4408482015132904,
-0.35534337162971497,
-0.5913840532302856,
0.3257262110710144,
0.3167390823364258,
0.12940643727779388,
-0.3834751546382904,
0.018589593470096588,
-0.29375767707824707,
0.5178837776184082,
0.5644209980964661,
-0.8594983816146851,
0.51247239112854,
-0.3441224992275238,
-0.19417224824428558,
0.2875244915485382,
0.847131609916687,
0.41467490792274475,
0.38790783286094666,
0.6332062482833862,
0.4626668691635132,
0.6579530239105225,
-0.33365172147750854,
0.9250186085700989,
-0.22832752764225006,
0.2607818841934204,
0.6071121096611023,
-0.4997592270374298,
0.9284589886665344,
0.4928516149520874,
-0.5263321399688721,
0.4764987826347351,
0.9003475904464722,
-0.6635467410087585,
0.49773162603378296,
0.17856259644031525,
0.15326622128486633,
-0.24529576301574707,
0.17743302881717682,
-0.39341697096824646,
0.5393362045288086,
0.4157603979110718,
-0.2538567781448364,
0.12765979766845703,
0.3791325092315674,
-0.19647641479969025,
-0.01289194542914629,
-0.7673909664154053,
0.5719027519226074,
0.264007031917572,
-0.4532073736190796,
0.2676036059856415,
-0.1887340098619461,
0.623403012752533,
-0.8492040038108826,
0.008891046978533268,
-0.1883474886417389,
0.17020316421985626,
-0.20304562151432037,
-1.0343188047409058,
0.4957590699195862,
-0.15553182363510132,
-0.09294673055410385,
0.07984637469053268,
0.9085789918899536,
0.17467227578163147,
-0.5987560749053955,
0.39105522632598877,
0.43734467029571533,
0.3404713571071625,
0.1329982727766037,
-0.7287584543228149,
-0.06277986615896225,
-0.3627677857875824,
-0.10471327602863312,
0.2933860123157501,
0.05766425281763077,
0.025532865896821022,
0.979188084602356,
0.5876580476760864,
0.17524203658103943,
0.39908894896507263,
0.11306068301200867,
0.7293240427970886,
-1.0345202684402466,
-0.6583889126777649,
-0.7787629961967468,
0.3498879373073578,
-0.04511954262852669,
-0.235378235578537,
0.8026502132415771,
0.6806968450546265,
0.4099991023540497,
-0.1873936951160431,
0.6593919992446899,
-0.01654953323304653,
0.48705679178237915,
-0.6988323330879211,
0.7779462337493896,
-1.029348373413086,
-0.11392488330602646,
-0.23162370920181274,
-0.8467869162559509,
-0.3293626308441162,
0.43370890617370605,
-0.2441440224647522,
-0.02951235882937908,
0.4519425332546234,
0.4727459251880646,
-0.009412473067641258,
0.01526337955147028,
0.5085420608520508,
0.09101533889770508,
-0.035757698118686676,
0.43854808807373047,
1.1548138856887817,
-0.19591230154037476,
0.5335721969604492,
-0.03556142374873161,
-0.10638616979122162,
-0.4147647023200989,
-0.4952682554721832,
-0.5307549834251404,
-0.8058722019195557,
-0.19999749958515167,
-0.19394074380397797,
-0.0708538070321083,
0.38672569394111633,
1.027141809463501,
-0.6639873385429382,
-0.2234085351228714,
0.3160061240196228,
-0.061183489859104156,
-0.3082294762134552,
-0.22309255599975586,
0.08540410548448563,
-0.15316884219646454,
-0.5292075872421265,
0.5296437740325928,
0.7789896130561829,
0.05889401212334633,
-0.5204676389694214,
-0.04432849958539009,
-0.17487762868404388,
0.02645016461610794,
0.8968419432640076,
0.2623359262943268,
-0.9208537340164185,
0.1129213199019432,
0.14068929851055145,
-0.07614639401435852,
0.3119909465312958,
0.7011452317237854,
-0.8514195084571838,
0.4885242283344269,
0.17289023101329803,
0.6506451368331909,
0.6132774949073792,
-0.291841596364975,
0.549547016620636,
-0.3259470760822296,
0.13610580563545227,
-0.06531218439340591,
0.8127328753471375,
0.2535868287086487,
-0.23949749767780304,
0.7892682552337646,
0.375858873128891,
-0.23451873660087585,
-0.5725113153457642,
0.2570202350616455,
-1.4579917192459106,
-0.6464536190032959,
0.8349369764328003,
-0.06418328732252121,
-0.48760056495666504,
0.14237993955612183,
-0.29947930574417114,
0.36507081985473633,
-0.11650703847408295,
0.5776800513267517,
0.656782329082489,
-0.16676658391952515,
-0.3462330102920532,
-0.7152881622314453,
-0.019383003935217857,
0.10215446352958679,
-0.8900832533836365,
-0.5483762621879578,
0.5882187485694885,
0.20033182203769684,
0.3292630910873413,
0.21764908730983734,
-0.29474937915802,
0.28470903635025024,
-0.07721829414367676,
0.1150260791182518,
-0.15322546660900116,
-0.31081974506378174,
-0.5217092633247375,
0.49959468841552734,
-0.49896514415740967,
-0.7303978800773621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04403v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04403v1
|
Learning To See But Forgetting To Follow: Visual Instruction Tuning Makes LLMs More Prone To Jailbreak Attacks
| 2024-05-07T15:29:48 | 2024-05-07T15:29:48 |
Georgios Pantazopoulos, Amit Parekh, Malvina Nikandrou, Alessandro Suglia
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Augmenting Large Language Models (LLMs) with image-understanding capabilities
has resulted in a boom of high-performing Vision-Language models (VLMs). While
studying the alignment of LLMs to human values has received widespread
attention, the safety of VLMs has not received the same attention. In this
paper, we explore the impact of jailbreaking on three state-of-the-art VLMs,
each using a distinct modeling approach. By comparing each VLM to their
respective LLM backbone, we find that each VLM is more susceptible to
jailbreaking. We consider this as an undesirable outcome from visual
instruction-tuning, which imposes a forgetting effect on an LLM's safety
guardrails. Therefore, we provide recommendations for future work based on
evaluation strategies that aim to highlight the weaknesses of a VLM, as well as
take safety measures into account during visual instruction tuning.
|
[
-0.3096264898777008,
-0.37948375940322876,
0.5892661213874817,
0.1770734041929245,
-0.3340192437171936,
0.10249554365873337,
0.15043911337852478,
-0.3981908857822418,
-0.1757981777191162,
0.8613527417182922,
-0.39375612139701843,
-0.5383488535881042,
-0.7976272106170654,
-0.293785959482193,
-0.4580160081386566,
0.818086564540863,
-0.2639884650707245,
0.04476811736822128,
-0.16398631036281586,
-0.1521155834197998,
-1.0590603351593018,
-0.5350134968757629,
-0.21425782144069672,
0.09643720090389252,
0.5657786130905151,
0.2631235420703888,
0.4977249205112457,
0.913884162902832,
0.7006687521934509,
0.24394844472408295,
-0.21861538290977478,
0.10876385867595673,
-0.6604776978492737,
-0.07945071160793304,
-0.09869736433029175,
-0.5271585583686829,
-0.30978459119796753,
-0.0909949392080307,
0.2825760543346405,
0.30308225750923157,
-0.047089945524930954,
0.038963016122579575,
0.008613952435553074,
1.0443203449249268,
-0.8897263407707214,
-0.08968228846788406,
-0.8528096079826355,
0.01943494938313961,
-0.23101921379566193,
-0.015089945867657661,
-0.488674134016037,
-0.18430157005786896,
0.1164417639374733,
-0.2650546431541443,
0.030812470242381096,
0.41907137632369995,
0.8698098659515381,
0.5195375084877014,
-0.11534366756677628,
-0.19838401675224304,
-0.34040069580078125,
0.6350419521331787,
-0.40597617626190186,
0.36302340030670166,
0.3492984473705292,
0.28148287534713745,
-0.18867430090904236,
-0.27129122614860535,
-0.17628253996372223,
-0.15372715890407562,
0.1298227459192276,
0.17926588654518127,
-0.10808897018432617,
0.09721731394529343,
0.3767869472503662,
-0.006379324477165937,
-0.32636621594429016,
0.3817369043827057,
-0.7687995433807373,
-0.08581327646970749,
0.33841484785079956,
0.44754061102867126,
0.3578503727912903,
-0.0016584678087383509,
-0.5984761714935303,
-0.1931135058403015,
-1.1075215339660645,
0.028360875323414803,
0.3670748472213745,
0.14320775866508484,
-0.15046651661396027,
0.5928634405136108,
0.22342456877231598,
0.9027501344680786,
-0.12827177345752716,
-0.13074864447116852,
-0.15063902735710144,
-0.17280420660972595,
-0.3759647607803345,
-0.06513828039169312,
0.49198493361473083,
0.8271576762199402,
0.6655716300010681,
-0.10403729230165482,
-0.19638194143772125,
0.11537835001945496,
0.7062728404998779,
-0.5309588313102722,
-0.2893873155117035,
-0.17242319881916046,
-0.39558976888656616,
-0.4838120937347412,
0.07632613927125931,
-0.653803825378418,
-0.8452854752540588,
-0.054885219782590866,
0.44596773386001587,
-0.5876815915107727,
0.17762260138988495,
0.07863539457321167,
-0.25026002526283264,
0.3928588032722473,
0.5148032307624817,
-1.0264348983764648,
0.0806155651807785,
0.644740641117096,
0.8735452890396118,
-0.07257670164108276,
-0.5874567031860352,
-0.4852219820022583,
0.14894481003284454,
-0.545994758605957,
0.5817093253135681,
-0.23888638615608215,
-0.5555819869041443,
-0.10003245621919632,
0.08304915577173233,
-0.22929953038692474,
-0.7161424160003662,
0.1288536638021469,
-0.5928266048431396,
-0.40047094225883484,
-0.3431159257888794,
-0.4767710268497467,
-0.18184515833854675,
0.08894713222980499,
-0.634632408618927,
0.2983548045158386,
-0.0708194449543953,
-0.6813594698905945,
0.5784410834312439,
-0.19959527254104614,
-0.4013778269290924,
-0.13069939613342285,
-0.14581948518753052,
-0.7739906311035156,
0.4116980731487274,
0.15174449980258942,
0.31396031379699707,
0.2426338493824005,
0.050982847809791565,
-0.4481756389141083,
-0.7045645713806152,
0.07609875500202179,
-0.39406755566596985,
0.7160207629203796,
0.02200840786099434,
-0.2659654915332794,
0.1631011813879013,
-0.47722819447517395,
-0.1794804483652115,
0.16350656747817993,
-0.3888373076915741,
-0.5189213156700134,
0.5030244588851929,
-0.17789803445339203,
0.1291653960943222,
0.05959033966064453,
-0.32928740978240967,
0.012404750101268291,
-0.3363712728023529,
0.4327844977378845,
1.163011908531189,
0.04359673708677292,
0.10626427829265594,
-0.15634876489639282,
0.2738259434700012,
0.23659351468086243,
0.4433237612247467,
-0.48787856101989746,
-0.2785266041755676,
-0.9764317274093628,
0.055579155683517456,
-0.10642833262681961,
0.8440572023391724,
-0.6397060751914978,
-0.09971693158149719,
0.05951875448226929,
-0.38310348987579346,
-0.50124591588974,
0.49974873661994934,
0.8825680017471313,
0.39823901653289795,
0.2934514880180359,
-0.48032069206237793,
-0.6930924654006958,
-0.6957991123199463,
-0.5657602548599243,
-0.21539373695850372,
0.436352401971817,
0.20711994171142578,
0.6454370617866516,
-0.08634055405855179,
0.4336790144443512,
-0.321686714887619,
-0.3570936918258667,
-0.06936332583427429,
-0.6957222819328308,
-0.0939815416932106,
0.5750280022621155,
0.7742504477500916,
-0.4285883903503418,
-0.2102833092212677,
-0.11162634938955307,
-0.9099311232566833,
0.2560757100582123,
-0.005746930837631226,
0.08163884282112122,
0.27068036794662476,
0.6994467973709106,
-0.2843363881111145,
1.0402284860610962,
0.26350972056388855,
-0.402460515499115,
0.6511169075965881,
-0.18333442509174347,
-0.05340886116027832,
-0.5882164835929871,
-0.5266926288604736,
0.07574419677257538,
-0.03989328444004059,
-0.4728272557258606,
0.1769041270017624,
0.4579615294933319,
-0.0541653148829937,
-0.6782822012901306,
0.37593626976013184,
-0.5903348326683044,
-0.2375897467136383,
-0.29300233721733093,
0.2526484727859497,
-0.034673530608415604,
0.20769226551055908,
-0.0881984531879425,
0.8424856066703796,
0.7586284875869751,
-0.3531756103038788,
0.2862536311149597,
0.110692098736763,
-0.7179519534111023,
0.3199261724948883,
-0.5034744143486023,
-0.01752299629151821,
-0.203576922416687,
-0.5174668431282043,
-0.5406273603439331,
-0.18785829842090607,
0.14456668496131897,
-0.1313801109790802,
0.4544324576854706,
-0.4119483530521393,
-0.359752357006073,
-0.4519178867340088,
-0.4481664299964905,
-0.121169812977314,
0.538037121295929,
-0.692742645740509,
0.16163702309131622,
0.2505002021789551,
0.1540183424949646,
-0.7012181282043457,
-0.6384224891662598,
0.32326674461364746,
-0.534558117389679,
-0.5365682244300842,
-0.05169403925538063,
0.1726057529449463,
-0.38547009229660034,
-0.018621357157826424,
-0.3745599091053009,
0.18494336307048798,
0.559550940990448,
0.58744215965271,
0.6746346354484558,
-0.10866077244281769,
-0.03824412077665329,
-0.4221569299697876,
-0.00794148538261652,
0.14378078281879425,
-0.3037085235118866,
0.22209803760051727,
-0.5402351021766663,
-0.5830661654472351,
-0.2229553461074829,
0.3010469079017639,
0.6479769349098206,
-0.2565508186817169,
0.9542450308799744,
0.03539576008915901,
-0.030355961993336678,
-0.100084088742733,
-0.4353002607822418,
0.04179903864860535,
-0.5342010855674744,
0.48470717668533325,
-0.11832749843597412,
-0.9209054112434387,
0.2897762656211853,
-0.004032802302390337,
0.14055579900741577,
-0.14048175513744354,
0.4073649048805237,
-0.6226012110710144,
0.9012967944145203,
1.1969839334487915,
-0.18383798003196716,
0.9478954076766968,
0.1445344239473343,
0.21126270294189453,
-0.8770256638526917,
-0.3144906461238861,
-0.11773000657558441,
-0.16586774587631226,
-0.6086501479148865,
-0.1398647278547287,
0.3148311674594879,
0.2825464904308319,
-0.22271177172660828,
0.4428670406341553,
-0.17852777242660522,
0.7817758321762085,
0.4650079309940338,
0.134225532412529,
0.1556747406721115,
0.1506890207529068,
-0.21226847171783447,
-0.10765718668699265,
-0.6834983825683594,
-0.6542670130729675,
1.2086610794067383,
0.15997867286205292,
1.3159879446029663,
0.0027907993644475937,
0.8440618515014648,
0.05867764353752136,
0.1619766652584076,
-0.6251381039619446,
0.517358660697937,
-0.2834142744541168,
-0.3558667302131653,
-0.026627682149410248,
-0.14353039860725403,
-0.682255744934082,
0.3043316602706909,
-0.07904006540775299,
-1.1256680488586426,
0.02191285789012909,
0.5223113298416138,
-0.37355589866638184,
0.4933778941631317,
-0.9971413612365723,
0.9933934211730957,
-0.7840648293495178,
-0.5626564025878906,
-0.09785182774066925,
-0.7105613350868225,
0.6332823634147644,
-0.1201772540807724,
0.2228194773197174,
-0.12663261592388153,
0.16410452127456665,
0.4999162256717682,
-0.46832504868507385,
1.0695395469665527,
-0.16155460476875305,
0.18764929473400116,
0.190260648727417,
-0.1797754168510437,
0.41992875933647156,
-0.24542981386184692,
0.3749188184738159,
-0.04116804152727127,
-0.26263439655303955,
-0.4663965404033661,
-0.45190879702568054,
0.7686612606048584,
-0.6435795426368713,
-1.162522315979004,
-0.2770737409591675,
-0.36528974771499634,
-0.17196300625801086,
0.13690298795700073,
0.2124229222536087,
0.15951596200466156,
0.06545689702033997,
-0.13516108691692352,
1.112770438194275,
-0.3712432086467743,
0.6177631616592407,
0.33403173089027405,
-0.5098641514778137,
-0.32259178161621094,
1.0054508447647095,
0.2478170543909073,
0.5336951613426208,
-0.1750635802745819,
-0.2641903758049011,
0.2947862148284912,
-0.9285102486610413,
-0.6883262991905212,
0.14912888407707214,
-0.7747201919555664,
-0.10685256123542786,
-0.09788807481527328,
-0.2689949870109558,
-0.18438217043876648,
-0.35862839221954346,
-0.2796553373336792,
-0.007812293246388435,
-0.44204485416412354,
-0.2804289758205414,
0.545464813709259,
0.6633156538009644,
0.21826578676700592,
0.4848393201828003,
-0.7160273790359497,
0.28808921575546265,
0.3856251835823059,
0.6376137733459473,
-0.024068864062428474,
-0.4323982000350952,
-0.48391398787498474,
-0.49311205744743347,
-0.3975517451763153,
-0.8706244826316833,
0.16959913074970245,
0.029845401644706726,
0.6203454732894897,
0.5959861874580383,
-0.29311537742614746,
1.0062978267669678,
-0.8733857274055481,
0.3719542920589447,
0.36779487133026123,
-0.6595402359962463,
0.8574656844139099,
-0.013502610847353935,
0.1324400156736374,
0.5182870030403137,
-0.142703115940094,
-0.35826683044433594,
-0.4030546247959137,
-0.24226778745651245,
-0.8402974605560303,
0.5527287721633911,
-0.133103609085083,
0.1503240168094635,
0.0674394965171814,
0.2645851969718933,
-0.10602026432752609,
0.08879439532756805,
-0.8019039034843445,
-0.22817054390907288,
-0.3684258759021759,
0.1268019825220108,
0.0996500700712204,
-0.28232675790786743,
-0.05708915740251541,
-0.161113902926445,
0.34120094776153564,
0.2320101410150528,
-0.11634530127048492,
-0.1261490285396576,
-0.4521423876285553,
-0.06000722199678421,
0.18975329399108887,
0.7333213686943054,
0.4773332178592682,
-0.14622633159160614,
0.18128159642219543,
0.22169916331768036,
-0.7239814400672913,
0.07100839167833328,
-0.43300020694732666,
-0.458448588848114,
-0.30203285813331604,
0.528576672077179,
1.376074194908142,
0.2378418892621994,
-0.9853554368019104,
0.539039671421051,
0.0689176693558693,
-0.020374588668346405,
-0.28409987688064575,
0.6155464053153992,
0.11795010417699814,
0.3060722351074219,
-0.07559283822774887,
0.6738715171813965,
-0.35996213555336,
-0.6531559824943542,
0.11019957810640335,
0.4984453618526459,
-0.7342268228530884,
-0.0993691086769104,
0.8346595168113708,
-0.12583132088184357,
-0.45123225450515747,
0.5831899642944336,
0.33341509103775024,
-0.5329053401947021,
0.7456182241439819,
0.46366530656814575,
0.822614848613739,
-0.11947222799062729,
-0.28015831112861633,
-0.014275691471993923,
1.133022427558899,
-0.1547672152519226,
0.19251500070095062,
0.1667957603931427,
-0.5748938918113708,
-0.23444636166095734,
-0.5388307571411133,
-0.17532148957252502,
-0.09874008595943451,
-0.7605952024459839,
0.29613855481147766,
-0.8826809525489807,
-0.17477943003177643,
-0.3440350592136383,
-0.6184189915657043,
-0.5598485469818115,
0.08507870137691498,
0.4021516442298889,
0.9739528894424438,
-0.8922886848449707,
0.8489546179771423,
0.5474587082862854,
-0.16530758142471313,
-0.7031592130661011,
-0.0165927205234766,
0.36982783675193787,
-1.0347791910171509,
0.5039783120155334,
0.4171377718448639,
-0.3158029019832611,
-0.21178896725177765,
-0.6102539896965027,
-0.7820578813552856,
0.9916589260101318,
0.3540825843811035,
-0.9491729140281677,
0.020926309749484062,
-0.17240601778030396,
0.34249913692474365,
-0.15432775020599365,
-0.40184715390205383,
0.8811846375465393,
0.2859039902687073,
-0.14179278910160065,
-0.7803014516830444,
-0.22772285342216492,
-0.05402098968625069,
0.14049795269966125,
0.4328959584236145,
-0.7319789528846741,
0.5622673034667969,
-1.02029287815094,
-0.22869347035884857,
0.026280954480171204,
0.252631276845932,
0.5019265413284302,
0.36726728081703186,
0.1503371000289917,
0.8166583776473999,
0.3881743550300598,
-0.06419187784194946,
1.0019129514694214,
0.13645268976688385,
-0.07906071096658707,
1.2651770114898682,
-0.1925164759159088,
0.7985079884529114,
0.8407943844795227,
0.025633573532104492,
0.15094560384750366,
0.43145161867141724,
-0.42744114995002747,
0.8575507998466492,
0.23155726492404938,
-0.0419158935546875,
-0.20942668616771698,
0.4889370799064636,
-0.16663773357868195,
0.3416152894496918,
0.5169551372528076,
-0.5150662064552307,
-0.15822352468967438,
0.39206260442733765,
0.15225645899772644,
0.08283758908510208,
-0.7536287307739258,
0.8046298623085022,
0.3576970100402832,
-0.38876059651374817,
0.6854172945022583,
-0.18991459906101227,
0.39419105648994446,
-0.2758995592594147,
0.11247232556343079,
-0.2955194413661957,
0.12573257088661194,
-0.14675645530223846,
-0.7829540967941284,
0.22268329560756683,
0.5688570737838745,
-0.17428910732269287,
-0.16484704613685608,
0.6790387630462646,
0.09486708790063858,
-0.5076244473457336,
0.5770946145057678,
0.4108768701553345,
0.10066686570644379,
0.24136684834957123,
-0.45745745301246643,
0.33466145396232605,
0.09402703493833542,
-0.24855363368988037,
0.7131829261779785,
0.06776556372642517,
-0.42661041021347046,
1.0482393503189087,
0.254955917596817,
0.10652023553848267,
0.6731029152870178,
0.032554179430007935,
1.0475072860717773,
-0.9989117383956909,
-0.10591190308332443,
-1.3253834247589111,
0.4898636043071747,
-0.05611376464366913,
-0.22368411719799042,
0.9113292098045349,
0.3506152629852295,
0.9199660420417786,
-0.22846587002277374,
0.8336764574050903,
0.23565472662448883,
-0.0020661167800426483,
-0.8850801587104797,
0.9748891592025757,
-0.46840476989746094,
0.7670897841453552,
-0.39520183205604553,
-0.5661917924880981,
-0.32415342330932617,
0.4071888327598572,
-0.47687098383903503,
-0.2891045808792114,
0.5410646200180054,
0.7513523697853088,
0.1787908971309662,
-0.37174102663993835,
0.6781723499298096,
0.2428262084722519,
0.05040967836976051,
0.7731925249099731,
1.101071834564209,
-0.40589749813079834,
0.6484584212303162,
-0.07567103952169418,
-0.02978937327861786,
-0.37224701046943665,
-0.743537425994873,
-1.0930439233779907,
-0.13713955879211426,
-0.19047963619232178,
-0.08881703019142151,
0.38319656252861023,
0.20727261900901794,
0.49923601746559143,
-0.6184218525886536,
-0.14600786566734314,
-0.1716180145740509,
0.5370335578918457,
-0.1974114626646042,
-0.07435744255781174,
0.24855376780033112,
-0.2769556939601898,
-0.2245136946439743,
0.5878143906593323,
0.8453564047813416,
0.35812908411026,
-0.14422792196273804,
0.01100874412804842,
0.2887594699859619,
-0.03524190932512283,
0.55059415102005,
0.34528788924217224,
-1.0609933137893677,
-0.4735625982284546,
-0.09845586866140366,
-0.14372116327285767,
0.2706567645072937,
0.5065575242042542,
-0.9049556851387024,
0.6726809144020081,
-0.06407491117715836,
0.3562973439693451,
0.40272074937820435,
-0.15832126140594482,
0.3463294506072998,
-0.41021326184272766,
0.1116490364074707,
-0.14638212323188782,
0.6273224949836731,
0.2801935374736786,
-0.08778475970029831,
0.20755057036876678,
0.25360384583473206,
-0.35508352518081665,
-0.8649756908416748,
0.596213698387146,
-0.7491154074668884,
-0.2658626437187195,
0.4974960386753082,
-0.37190842628479004,
-0.5440988540649414,
-0.1364411562681198,
-0.22973217070102692,
-0.1390935331583023,
0.004470611922442913,
0.9801704287528992,
0.6840487122535706,
0.09077044576406479,
-0.5667294263839722,
-0.9948559403419495,
0.37862223386764526,
0.2632654905319214,
-0.6324059963226318,
0.20077788829803467,
0.4512006938457489,
0.5633863210678101,
-0.25449055433273315,
0.029313718900084496,
-0.19742394983768463,
0.6120949983596802,
0.07500500231981277,
-0.10597141832113266,
-0.3042461574077606,
-0.5178689360618591,
-0.39615970849990845,
0.1865091174840927,
0.3470635414123535,
-0.1828938126564026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04346v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04346v1
|
Revisiting character-level adversarial attacks
| 2024-05-07T14:23:22 | 2024-05-07T14:23:22 |
Elias Abad Rocamora, Yongtao Wu, Fanghui Liu, Grigorios G. Chrysos, Volkan Cevher
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Adversarial attacks in Natural Language Processing apply perturbations in the
character or token levels. Token-level attacks, gaining prominence for their
use of gradient-based methods, are susceptible to altering sentence semantics,
leading to invalid adversarial examples. While character-level attacks easily
maintain semantics, they have received less attention as they cannot easily
adopt popular gradient-based methods, and are thought to be easy to defend.
Challenging these beliefs, we introduce Charmer, an efficient query-based
adversarial attack capable of achieving high attack success rate (ASR) while
generating highly similar adversarial examples. Our method successfully targets
both small (BERT) and large (Llama 2) models. Specifically, on BERT with SST-2,
Charmer improves the ASR in 4.84% points and the USE similarity in 8% points
with respect to the previous art. Our implementation is available in
https://github.com/LIONS-EPFL/Charmer.
|
[
-0.2339506596326828,
-1.0536404848098755,
0.09459095448255539,
0.06461028754711151,
0.01473673153668642,
0.27169033885002136,
-0.09529221057891846,
-0.27144789695739746,
0.3375910520553589,
0.5825464725494385,
-0.42582860589027405,
-0.154796302318573,
-0.730390727519989,
0.13602140545845032,
-0.700268566608429,
1.1374152898788452,
0.20850811898708344,
0.2083791047334671,
0.4110254645347595,
0.12416654080152512,
-0.24859733879566193,
-0.911867618560791,
-1.3206448554992676,
-0.09724719077348709,
0.8053498864173889,
-0.05773623660206795,
0.936687707901001,
0.3359428346157074,
0.7698309421539307,
0.25015735626220703,
-0.39342162013053894,
0.0867486223578453,
-0.988226056098938,
0.5111162662506104,
-0.13987299799919128,
-0.827077329158783,
-0.1769067794084549,
-0.20420299470424652,
0.4248271882534027,
0.28302544355392456,
0.17301107943058014,
-0.583893895149231,
-0.11621548235416412,
0.788407027721405,
-0.5314740538597107,
-0.14592227339744568,
-1.1962192058563232,
0.06350301206111908,
-0.4081600606441498,
-0.22051918506622314,
-0.43616023659706116,
-0.24175138771533966,
-0.13405568897724152,
-0.48886623978614807,
0.533566951751709,
0.16287864744663239,
0.9688795208930969,
0.25593361258506775,
-0.3627724349498749,
-0.5632222294807434,
-0.2835140526294708,
0.5903877019882202,
-0.5873845815658569,
-0.048133764415979385,
0.34240034222602844,
0.3690797984600067,
-0.8847231268882751,
-0.6591354012489319,
-0.6776103973388672,
-0.357149213552475,
-0.06978268921375275,
-0.006348185241222382,
-0.6028681397438049,
0.14392074942588806,
0.32570600509643555,
0.4666249454021454,
-0.43860360980033875,
-0.0113111836835742,
-0.04586642235517502,
-0.26543760299682617,
0.617750346660614,
0.145065039396286,
0.6014035940170288,
-0.2903928756713867,
-0.31919944286346436,
-0.4171573519706726,
-0.6122274398803711,
0.12717297673225403,
0.6509270668029785,
0.5703774094581604,
0.48073458671569824,
0.6392971873283386,
0.08709350228309631,
0.3297986686229706,
0.44514086842536926,
0.3609429597854614,
-0.238114133477211,
-0.19799168407917023,
-0.008992308750748634,
0.10138429701328278,
0.8598459959030151,
0.20607666671276093,
0.2341214418411255,
-0.215934157371521,
-0.33568865060806274,
0.12468059360980988,
0.5640127062797546,
-0.9300549030303955,
-0.5664023756980896,
0.004248820710927248,
-0.18460403382778168,
-0.5347996950149536,
0.05797131359577179,
-0.8588680624961853,
-1.0067745447158813,
0.29941675066947937,
0.3072327971458435,
-0.7318392992019653,
0.1809367537498474,
-0.1486385464668274,
-0.25034409761428833,
0.45800673961639404,
0.31717297434806824,
-0.8740825653076172,
0.34485289454460144,
0.9365719556808472,
0.6661462187767029,
0.16857460141181946,
-0.10565990209579468,
-0.9990671873092651,
-0.21610942482948303,
-0.525924026966095,
0.5228554606437683,
-0.6185834407806396,
-0.6249024271965027,
-0.027882708236575127,
-0.08282940089702606,
-0.2837962210178375,
-0.3518814444541931,
0.7467882037162781,
-0.915386974811554,
0.12956222891807556,
-0.4480862319469452,
-0.4517156779766083,
0.097373828291893,
0.4901845157146454,
-0.8538377285003662,
0.8556220531463623,
-0.15423928201198578,
-1.0434843301773071,
0.15703532099723816,
-0.5986078977584839,
-0.8153598308563232,
-0.37405312061309814,
0.04945974797010422,
-0.42131859064102173,
0.3821415901184082,
0.5555263161659241,
0.16853174567222595,
-0.08077868074178696,
-0.3317301273345947,
-0.17454500496387482,
-0.5167459845542908,
0.4661334455013275,
-0.5962977409362793,
0.6569791436195374,
0.26600196957588196,
-0.16652482748031616,
0.17140479385852814,
-0.7392594218254089,
-0.24601112306118011,
0.47045502066612244,
-0.20662344992160797,
-0.4374653697013855,
0.15819847583770752,
-0.053028278052806854,
0.043855927884578705,
0.3362630605697632,
-0.6131137013435364,
0.4603104889392853,
-0.6887999176979065,
0.3973899483680725,
0.5749872922897339,
0.16409911215305328,
0.29460087418556213,
-0.16637031733989716,
0.471151202917099,
-0.23218515515327454,
0.02344691753387451,
-0.15759174525737762,
-0.31396111845970154,
-1.0533759593963623,
-0.5100370645523071,
0.3027341067790985,
0.5000377893447876,
-1.1563150882720947,
0.23653943836688995,
-0.06382063776254654,
-0.4241046607494354,
-0.7173119783401489,
-0.12840840220451355,
0.5516467690467834,
0.14108289778232574,
0.5054476261138916,
-0.1375935822725296,
-0.4605008363723755,
-0.6865313053131104,
-0.9593950510025024,
-0.3183358609676361,
-0.13042524456977844,
0.10755165666341782,
0.4298417270183563,
-0.21127235889434814,
0.7421796917915344,
-0.5632231831550598,
-0.28241023421287537,
-0.2370237559080124,
0.23398122191429138,
0.13613176345825195,
0.31411826610565186,
0.5995325446128845,
-0.6869121789932251,
-0.6157137155532837,
-0.04836408793926239,
-0.5348055958747864,
0.2595670223236084,
-0.2246355414390564,
-0.23186244070529938,
0.1191219836473465,
0.3832080662250519,
-0.5485573410987854,
0.5517393946647644,
0.05295412987470627,
-0.44657137989997864,
0.2892589569091797,
-0.10850576311349869,
0.5189118981361389,
-1.0464808940887451,
-0.17751243710517883,
0.0752369835972786,
-0.24608087539672852,
-1.1887632608413696,
0.5601568222045898,
-0.02021629735827446,
-0.16398930549621582,
-0.24126847088336945,
0.4654410481452942,
-0.035419803112745285,
0.22858291864395142,
-0.41481903195381165,
-0.1763373464345932,
0.06292776018381119,
0.31035736203193665,
-0.4288973808288574,
0.8856512904167175,
0.4681911766529083,
-0.10326547175645828,
0.331202894449234,
0.2044389247894287,
0.08116282522678375,
0.8485652208328247,
-0.8025610446929932,
0.4110029339790344,
-0.13248831033706665,
0.375237375497818,
-0.9756421446800232,
-0.23450225591659546,
0.35286056995391846,
-0.8076756000518799,
0.6520056128501892,
-0.2292180359363556,
-0.6512846350669861,
-0.38660943508148193,
-0.8463104367256165,
-0.09918589890003204,
0.22119273245334625,
-0.8481398224830627,
0.4574300944805145,
-0.05624787136912346,
-0.02504095248878002,
-0.7591808438301086,
-0.8198214173316956,
0.5739901661872864,
-0.19501368701457977,
-0.6637420654296875,
0.1789603978395462,
0.13077935576438904,
-0.21178436279296875,
-0.2607864439487457,
-0.09583822637796402,
-0.04247131571173668,
0.2613601088523865,
-0.0676410123705864,
-0.005315027199685574,
-0.05425266921520233,
-0.3732846975326538,
-0.30969610810279846,
0.1811472773551941,
0.10485439002513885,
0.01107592973858118,
0.6442723274230957,
-0.08554256707429886,
-0.5200740098953247,
-0.6170154809951782,
0.3158992528915405,
0.7210243940353394,
-0.13530369102954865,
0.9586564302444458,
0.6518682241439819,
-0.45324864983558655,
-0.015228395350277424,
-0.3612646162509918,
-0.3096449375152588,
-0.4626392424106598,
0.6670466661453247,
-0.7476415634155273,
-0.8513473868370056,
0.6039456129074097,
0.5923058986663818,
0.019065987318754196,
0.49021482467651367,
0.1162891685962677,
-0.030122671276330948,
1.2733808755874634,
0.08286414295434952,
-0.4650321304798126,
0.6015728116035461,
-0.029807202517986298,
0.40438807010650635,
-0.830430805683136,
-0.1031559631228447,
-0.6317287683486938,
-0.17677626013755798,
-0.7161359190940857,
-0.3820248544216156,
0.056716188788414,
0.3777035176753998,
-0.33829712867736816,
0.5681145191192627,
-0.2068602740764618,
0.217557892203331,
0.5694661140441895,
0.17304691672325134,
0.05534810200333595,
0.17533211410045624,
0.1322660595178604,
-0.11105630546808243,
-0.4524463713169098,
-0.23174460232257843,
1.0876271724700928,
0.369393914937973,
1.0358877182006836,
0.31382086873054504,
0.6788415312767029,
0.5811759829521179,
0.048309843987226486,
-0.6677823662757874,
0.5216291546821594,
-0.5148104429244995,
-0.5131279826164246,
-0.2515083849430084,
-0.5132022500038147,
-0.9790187478065491,
0.4515591263771057,
-0.08965836465358734,
-0.828434407711029,
0.006629195995628834,
0.07610423862934113,
-0.05002158507704735,
0.6176202297210693,
-0.49974074959754944,
0.5262903571128845,
-0.17138515412807465,
-0.25153204798698425,
-0.12917737662792206,
-0.5437812209129333,
0.24497149884700775,
-0.1965133398771286,
-0.09973522275686264,
0.288718581199646,
0.36107948422431946,
0.6025901436805725,
-0.8032426238059998,
0.6231399774551392,
-0.20943903923034668,
-0.18399757146835327,
0.13838331401348114,
0.22198736667633057,
1.1534956693649292,
-0.025262175127863884,
-0.36670342087745667,
-0.15914347767829895,
-0.18126313388347626,
-0.6108782291412354,
-0.9838120341300964,
0.8011702299118042,
-0.6838445663452148,
-0.7708753347396851,
-0.6767077445983887,
-0.47348400950431824,
-0.11017841100692749,
-0.04683190584182739,
0.09481162577867508,
0.4215817451477051,
-0.35252174735069275,
0.14058566093444824,
0.6525881290435791,
-0.29634860157966614,
0.19141921401023865,
0.37256762385368347,
0.04218137264251709,
-0.5027794241905212,
1.2915574312210083,
-0.24056294560432434,
0.3170627951622009,
0.6242684125900269,
-0.10086163133382797,
-0.23556624352931976,
-0.49627164006233215,
-0.25273942947387695,
-0.0007000530022196472,
-0.648888111114502,
-0.16462448239326477,
-0.634623646736145,
-0.3822127878665924,
-0.34392914175987244,
-0.3123885691165924,
-0.3771688938140869,
-0.3592456877231598,
-0.373129278421402,
0.25209692120552063,
0.41963455080986023,
0.7961177825927734,
0.24794569611549377,
0.4740886688232422,
-0.24260658025741577,
0.26888373494148254,
0.43624040484428406,
-0.08087223023176193,
0.05701828747987747,
-0.573567807674408,
0.04288201034069061,
0.11995436251163483,
-0.2606445848941803,
-0.8275262117385864,
0.39553385972976685,
0.1303185522556305,
0.34910252690315247,
0.4186297655105591,
0.22885335981845856,
0.5565127730369568,
-0.5542333126068115,
0.8989533185958862,
0.38030093908309937,
-0.8141895532608032,
0.5791870951652527,
-0.27075648307800293,
0.13932298123836517,
0.643112063407898,
0.06880632787942886,
-0.5098209381103516,
-0.5474726557731628,
-0.5017063021659851,
-0.8208845257759094,
0.6885943412780762,
0.589950442314148,
0.17475682497024536,
-0.2282230257987976,
0.28551363945007324,
-0.3084365427494049,
0.08223041892051697,
-0.371418297290802,
-0.46311622858047485,
-0.4481606185436249,
-0.17561432719230652,
0.08731987327337265,
-0.31478965282440186,
-0.0365164652466774,
0.16605563461780548,
0.6866289973258972,
-0.06983885169029236,
0.25023338198661804,
0.13543064892292023,
-0.2606153190135956,
0.17185534536838531,
0.504592776298523,
0.2604843080043793,
-0.024841105565428734,
-0.1920042484998703,
0.2164616733789444,
0.19432909786701202,
-0.5420385003089905,
-0.018377352505922318,
0.49911409616470337,
-0.19204159080982208,
-0.4272644817829132,
0.4532317817211151,
0.7011842131614685,
0.1810581386089325,
-0.3653036653995514,
0.5772101283073425,
-0.5704008340835571,
0.04048437625169754,
0.10235685110092163,
0.13715733587741852,
-0.3261234760284424,
0.3506324589252472,
0.4598589539527893,
0.1625596433877945,
0.1852511614561081,
-0.5927004814147949,
0.23677700757980347,
0.7076465487480164,
-0.8532394170761108,
-0.22231024503707886,
0.8064863681793213,
0.033100832253694534,
-0.37511518597602844,
0.4837217926979065,
-0.3583158850669861,
-1.0306758880615234,
0.608611524105072,
0.7486178874969482,
0.6697889566421509,
-0.0994059219956398,
0.008504625409841537,
0.02790648676455021,
0.44897961616516113,
0.09402815252542496,
0.261119544506073,
0.2971716821193695,
-0.4624328315258026,
0.020594896748661995,
-0.5265495181083679,
-0.3375008702278137,
0.051748014986515045,
-0.7219510674476624,
-0.010167823173105717,
-0.5997439026832581,
-0.05629373714327812,
0.03883091360330582,
0.33081361651420593,
-0.4668913781642914,
0.1796807050704956,
0.0878630131483078,
0.7474991679191589,
-0.357618510723114,
0.6327177882194519,
0.6878028512001038,
-0.568111002445221,
-0.3671437203884125,
0.4211520850658417,
0.18384034931659698,
-0.807542085647583,
0.6637537479400635,
0.025492040440440178,
-0.13428685069084167,
-0.13648231327533722,
-0.36645206809043884,
-0.7122890949249268,
0.743191123008728,
0.20369699597358704,
-0.4396430552005768,
-0.027348723262548447,
0.060192205011844635,
0.6822026371955872,
-0.020496241748332977,
0.416922926902771,
0.6719632744789124,
0.23882439732551575,
0.23800194263458252,
-0.580877423286438,
0.2052597850561142,
-0.3214341700077057,
0.21602566540241241,
0.13230958580970764,
-0.7827314734458923,
0.8328766226768494,
-0.012567687779664993,
-0.11906390637159348,
0.3691406548023224,
1.0020962953567505,
0.23693345487117767,
-0.03298520669341087,
0.44553589820861816,
0.5656914114952087,
0.9320160746574402,
-0.16033898293972015,
1.272861123085022,
-0.3068249821662903,
0.2037210613489151,
0.8532394170761108,
-0.33616313338279724,
0.7673445343971252,
0.2689706087112427,
-0.31367385387420654,
0.3724342882633209,
0.4351547658443451,
-0.05995277687907219,
0.5787431597709656,
0.6254023313522339,
-0.31123265624046326,
0.15293356776237488,
-0.08327443897724152,
-0.3839055299758911,
0.26564934849739075,
0.41430336236953735,
-0.12119173258543015,
-0.045939698815345764,
0.014646624214947224,
0.6096540689468384,
0.19384756684303284,
-0.4752969741821289,
0.5415408611297607,
-0.0857921838760376,
-0.4200218617916107,
0.5343407392501831,
0.11115681380033493,
0.8572905659675598,
-0.739071786403656,
0.11329425871372223,
-0.4016469419002533,
0.31793898344039917,
0.005614507012069225,
-0.5167454481124878,
-0.008127161301672459,
0.3162684738636017,
-0.2907991409301758,
0.275579571723938,
0.9026943445205688,
-0.22326599061489105,
-0.4905667304992676,
0.22015099227428436,
-0.04593799635767937,
0.044485874474048615,
-0.17547564208507538,
-0.6729378700256348,
0.059949249029159546,
0.09734246134757996,
-0.3095977008342743,
0.5003150105476379,
0.2867782413959503,
0.16740059852600098,
0.6242120265960693,
0.6595503091812134,
0.16546133160591125,
0.06833011656999588,
0.3821425139904022,
1.1108143329620361,
-0.6253232955932617,
-0.4211975038051605,
-0.8321988582611084,
0.08009615540504456,
-0.49784186482429504,
-0.061697911471128464,
1.0499863624572754,
0.5102834105491638,
0.5437048077583313,
0.291401207447052,
0.932901918888092,
-0.011635939590632915,
0.37341105937957764,
-0.47117581963539124,
0.8768049478530884,
-0.47965389490127563,
0.4676320254802704,
-0.4123513102531433,
-0.5888572931289673,
-0.43411785364151,
0.4550780653953552,
-0.46934908628463745,
-0.12198781967163086,
0.6561102271080017,
0.9350228309631348,
0.24863167107105255,
0.20914609730243683,
0.2601431608200073,
0.32253122329711914,
0.8188105225563049,
0.5539155006408691,
1.083807110786438,
-0.6957582831382751,
0.6218484044075012,
0.16052348911762238,
-0.10194437950849533,
-0.3620029389858246,
-0.5449866652488708,
-1.4191479682922363,
-0.00874208565801382,
-0.0991939827799797,
-0.6595165133476257,
0.7818865776062012,
0.8461312651634216,
0.3926491141319275,
-1.036789894104004,
0.2910386323928833,
-0.10095735639333725,
0.09088174998760223,
0.018984152004122734,
-0.25710952281951904,
0.560551106929779,
-0.6184625029563904,
-0.7054632306098938,
0.7477275729179382,
-0.019378839060664177,
-0.1790759265422821,
-0.25391146540641785,
0.03620504215359688,
-0.1828508824110031,
0.5197707414627075,
0.3249764144420624,
0.4106433391571045,
-0.8086261749267578,
-0.33638468384742737,
-0.10313725471496582,
-0.38044410943984985,
-0.10713770985603333,
0.8147067427635193,
-0.5229414701461792,
0.5773648619651794,
0.36105820536613464,
1.0003578662872314,
0.23705077171325684,
0.17322519421577454,
0.5941493511199951,
-0.7550737857818604,
-0.1922675222158432,
0.0643342137336731,
0.41565680503845215,
0.5768710374832153,
-0.5141836404800415,
0.28386417031288147,
0.18912440538406372,
-0.4127964377403259,
-0.7757735848426819,
0.28168871998786926,
-0.6064220666885376,
-0.32540926337242126,
1.1062602996826172,
-0.2955058813095093,
-0.22031860053539276,
0.10377846658229828,
-0.37633758783340454,
0.18017904460430145,
-0.6080165505409241,
0.6625989079475403,
0.5202755331993103,
-0.017367204651236534,
0.28069183230400085,
-0.2144310623407364,
0.6121509671211243,
0.3894903361797333,
-0.6335419416427612,
-0.011815907433629036,
0.1443156898021698,
0.04289909079670906,
-0.006871773395687342,
0.34022092819213867,
-0.07080152630805969,
-0.07244740426540375,
0.3052214980125427,
-0.26930034160614014,
0.08997621387243271,
-0.22935084998607635,
-0.3758517801761627,
0.3771447539329529,
0.10205205529928207,
-0.19184234738349915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04325v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04325v1
|
Deception in Reinforced Autonomous Agents: The Unconventional Rabbit Hat Trick in Legislation
| 2024-05-07T13:55:11 | 2024-05-07T13:55:11 |
Atharvan Dogra, Ameet Deshpande, John Nay, Tanmay Rajpurohit, Ashwin Kalyan, Balaraman Ravindran
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent developments in large language models (LLMs), while offering a
powerful foundation for developing natural language agents, raise safety
concerns about them and the autonomous agents built upon them. Deception is one
potential capability of AI agents of particular concern, which we refer to as
an act or statement that misleads, hides the truth, or promotes a belief that
is not true in its entirety or in part. We move away from the conventional
understanding of deception through straight-out lying, making objective selfish
decisions, or giving false information, as seen in previous AI safety research.
We target a specific category of deception achieved through obfuscation and
equivocation. We broadly explain the two types of deception by analogizing them
with the rabbit-out-of-hat magic trick, where (i) the rabbit either comes out
of a hidden trap door or (ii) (our focus) the audience is completely distracted
to see the magician bring out the rabbit right in front of them using sleight
of hand or misdirection. Our novel testbed framework displays intrinsic
deception capabilities of LLM agents in a goal-driven environment when directed
to be deceptive in their natural language generations in a two-agent
adversarial dialogue system built upon the legislative task of "lobbying" for a
bill. Along the lines of a goal-driven environment, we show developing
deceptive capacity through a reinforcement learning setup, building it around
the theories of language philosophy and cognitive psychology. We find that the
lobbyist agent increases its deceptive capabilities by ~ 40% (relative) through
subsequent reinforcement trials of adversarial interactions, and our deception
detection mechanism shows a detection capability of up to 92%. Our results
highlight potential issues in agent-human interaction, with agents potentially
manipulating humans towards its programmed end-goal.
|
[
-0.37138494849205017,
-1.1598950624465942,
0.4364955723285675,
0.056750308722257614,
0.08359623700380325,
0.41269317269325256,
-0.13415853679180145,
-0.49112701416015625,
0.2965833842754364,
0.948559045791626,
-0.6781073808670044,
-0.18957816064357758,
-0.5619581937789917,
0.04163571074604988,
-0.23201677203178406,
0.7724112272262573,
0.24240289628505707,
-0.16001823544502258,
-0.3195341229438782,
0.1264028400182724,
-0.35716259479522705,
-0.4864727258682251,
-0.4682978093624115,
-0.8299931287765503,
0.20449887216091156,
0.218806654214859,
0.8000330328941345,
0.7148061394691467,
0.2650444507598877,
0.4023253321647644,
0.36525750160217285,
0.17982949316501617,
-0.43791213631629944,
0.12511956691741943,
-0.22495850920677185,
-0.7928277850151062,
-0.04196060448884964,
0.47095978260040283,
0.19019152224063873,
0.4084808826446533,
-0.36833110451698303,
-0.3320213854312897,
-0.010359427891671658,
0.41441580653190613,
-0.5765426158905029,
0.6408359408378601,
-0.757610559463501,
-0.31835535168647766,
-0.04681951180100441,
-0.17780205607414246,
-0.5760024785995483,
-0.12311941385269165,
0.01917550340294838,
-0.7780296802520752,
0.002704580081626773,
0.25716084241867065,
0.8890717625617981,
0.6304957866668701,
-0.583533525466919,
-0.6957080960273743,
-0.7594929337501526,
0.765998125076294,
-0.31145334243774414,
0.001282061217352748,
0.6172704696655273,
0.35366836190223694,
-0.15302403271198273,
-0.4691462814807892,
-0.7008011341094971,
-0.8193188309669495,
-0.23008200526237488,
0.14304524660110474,
-0.44716131687164307,
0.1821901649236679,
0.20436523854732513,
0.1741664558649063,
-0.4501323401927948,
0.0016866581281647086,
-0.03757696971297264,
-0.46862006187438965,
0.6737202405929565,
0.17696751654148102,
0.14902913570404053,
0.21955642104148865,
-0.4397951662540436,
-0.6328138709068298,
-0.48422935605049133,
0.20290011167526245,
0.8433095216751099,
0.2568453550338745,
0.02259601093828678,
0.4934118390083313,
-0.2612030506134033,
0.48586511611938477,
0.2667066156864166,
0.015743469819426537,
0.034205589443445206,
-0.26002633571624756,
-0.18519265949726105,
0.1704038381576538,
0.6061655879020691,
0.11456173658370972,
0.2996624708175659,
-0.0631064623594284,
-0.4510670006275177,
0.635698676109314,
0.3559444844722748,
-0.35081905126571655,
-0.2105289101600647,
0.10370682179927826,
-0.1399253010749817,
-0.5608126521110535,
0.27184826135635376,
-0.4635442793369293,
-0.5608919262886047,
-0.23559416830539703,
0.44280481338500977,
-0.4929368793964386,
-0.18336807191371918,
0.44214972853660583,
-0.12886148691177368,
0.5436478853225708,
0.16302943229675293,
-0.7245557904243469,
0.6040252447128296,
0.8543659448623657,
0.07210741937160492,
0.1034495010972023,
-0.24176982045173645,
-0.7264179587364197,
0.12059532850980759,
-0.5164395570755005,
0.6002559065818787,
-0.5640113353729248,
-0.21564573049545288,
0.23686924576759338,
0.11384114623069763,
0.10646121948957443,
-0.5420099496841431,
0.37116700410842896,
-0.4811963140964508,
0.09189546853303909,
-0.019018277525901794,
-0.207469642162323,
-0.40008649230003357,
0.4353068470954895,
-0.6122741103172302,
0.49564164876937866,
0.14536064863204956,
-0.14499928057193756,
0.29576075077056885,
-0.6552292704582214,
-0.5109598636627197,
-0.011540662497282028,
-0.3460873067378998,
-0.45404312014579773,
-0.19035059213638306,
0.11295599490404129,
0.04517939314246178,
-0.10865843296051025,
-0.051136843860149384,
-0.1339063197374344,
-0.29605942964553833,
0.7144612073898315,
-0.7146353125572205,
1.1305723190307617,
-0.052480366080999374,
-0.4849177896976471,
-0.10357902199029922,
-0.39888179302215576,
-0.09814710170030594,
0.25859373807907104,
-0.20899108052253723,
-0.39733782410621643,
-0.2298329472541809,
-0.45089924335479736,
-0.01680080220103264,
0.3230893313884735,
-0.5784021019935608,
0.14110367000102997,
-0.7885251045227051,
0.29351046681404114,
0.7376528382301331,
0.1713850051164627,
0.7358375191688538,
-0.7602784633636475,
0.50532066822052,
-0.006211708299815655,
0.3571702539920807,
-0.11107216775417328,
-0.5616862177848816,
-0.685164749622345,
-0.14067767560482025,
-0.0034512225538492203,
0.5292237401008606,
-1.092472791671753,
0.4150007963180542,
-0.08308620750904083,
-0.3445604145526886,
-0.7476730942726135,
-0.02827158011496067,
0.5878949165344238,
0.28370603919029236,
0.0830383449792862,
-0.10238675028085709,
-0.03781892731785774,
-0.9696197509765625,
-0.4067433178424835,
-0.6043466329574585,
0.12008080631494522,
-0.03995683044195175,
0.6388342976570129,
-0.20341160893440247,
0.930523157119751,
-0.22981762886047363,
-0.638403594493866,
-0.07055959850549698,
0.3341696262359619,
-0.11159598082304001,
0.5105693936347961,
0.37796029448509216,
-0.8679934144020081,
-0.2658708691596985,
-0.14237335324287415,
-0.5040102601051331,
0.07728656381368637,
-0.45984455943107605,
0.17998476326465607,
0.3540596067905426,
0.20809908211231232,
-0.8328513503074646,
0.6201187372207642,
0.16496925055980682,
-0.4591521918773651,
0.5604373812675476,
-0.2434723824262619,
0.09049461036920547,
-0.2643197774887085,
-0.44869986176490784,
-0.32077357172966003,
-0.2133285254240036,
-0.7177179455757141,
0.17170913517475128,
-0.13125641644001007,
0.3863912522792816,
-0.5760108232498169,
0.34368300437927246,
-0.5584598779678345,
0.2942398488521576,
-0.46661853790283203,
0.19543041288852692,
0.12340936064720154,
0.4944673478603363,
-0.10623907297849655,
0.5557072758674622,
0.6748315095901489,
-0.6278858780860901,
0.6837716102600098,
0.40493321418762207,
-0.053765371441841125,
0.6551498174667358,
-0.28513389825820923,
0.13018493354320526,
-0.13786755502223969,
0.31154298782348633,
-0.7355271577835083,
-0.35836631059646606,
0.7918516993522644,
-0.7483930587768555,
0.43871089816093445,
0.33633339405059814,
-0.5069283843040466,
-0.16128157079219818,
-0.41176891326904297,
0.06387103348970413,
0.6456149220466614,
-0.3516828715801239,
0.6999768614768982,
0.20705805718898773,
0.5184468626976013,
-0.7648399472236633,
-1.1153817176818848,
0.13030998408794403,
-0.19598330557346344,
-0.47605589032173157,
0.26609373092651367,
-0.11112307012081146,
-0.7121149897575378,
0.1343122273683548,
0.06446202099323273,
0.1342656910419464,
0.14139074087142944,
0.31151747703552246,
-0.0183691568672657,
-0.07614699006080627,
0.0703190341591835,
-0.2249554693698883,
-0.19762904942035675,
0.39397066831588745,
-0.092719167470932,
0.33146339654922485,
-0.5044350028038025,
-0.7612156271934509,
-0.5186027884483337,
0.32265782356262207,
0.39154648780822754,
-0.10881799459457397,
0.7012677788734436,
0.4006003737449646,
-0.27339968085289,
-0.3233625292778015,
-0.6156050562858582,
-0.5775962471961975,
-0.5154474377632141,
0.27696385979652405,
-0.2935138940811157,
-0.5603099465370178,
0.3023802638053894,
0.038769789040088654,
0.1579919308423996,
0.14811742305755615,
0.46471357345581055,
0.0346626415848732,
0.9547683596611023,
0.7121706604957581,
0.08578509092330933,
0.32045072317123413,
-0.23913851380348206,
0.1290467083454132,
-0.3395608067512512,
-0.38776400685310364,
-0.43327459692955017,
-0.00724601186811924,
-0.675514817237854,
-0.336463987827301,
0.1336142122745514,
-0.12499209493398666,
-0.35278868675231934,
0.34114930033683777,
-0.7591787576675415,
0.5897974967956543,
0.8042274117469788,
0.063740573823452,
0.3630697727203369,
-0.11825148016214371,
0.3557049334049225,
0.17471803724765778,
-0.4958775043487549,
-0.6745855808258057,
1.0689243078231812,
0.36702078580856323,
0.844200849533081,
0.23131254315376282,
0.6756576299667358,
0.42334744334220886,
0.4012507200241089,
-0.8490105867385864,
0.7841758728027344,
0.5300096273422241,
-0.598764955997467,
-0.5947937369346619,
-0.07449650764465332,
-1.117175579071045,
0.1416422724723816,
-0.25871485471725464,
-0.5172107219696045,
0.047542501240968704,
-0.057813696563243866,
-0.1966601312160492,
0.17727842926979065,
-0.4125325083732605,
0.47453993558883667,
-0.3969962000846863,
-0.2650394141674042,
-0.3651996850967407,
-0.7386358380317688,
0.5799793004989624,
-0.0333772748708725,
0.06012597680091858,
-0.05510236322879791,
-0.42866000533103943,
0.5495482683181763,
-0.2577012777328491,
1.082563877105713,
-0.052059371024370193,
-0.09017053246498108,
0.38095489144325256,
0.28754985332489014,
0.8245616555213928,
-0.007492063567042351,
0.05234244838356972,
0.03826002776622772,
-0.05538215860724449,
-0.44500842690467834,
-0.7692146301269531,
0.38773810863494873,
-0.707336962223053,
-1.1030347347259521,
-0.6691124439239502,
-0.5469645857810974,
-0.24416981637477875,
0.06081478297710419,
0.05864467844367027,
0.24074509739875793,
-0.3050965368747711,
0.22761039435863495,
0.7960740923881531,
-0.1920604258775711,
0.3413197696208954,
0.8421687483787537,
-0.02763385698199272,
-0.25489503145217896,
0.9680831432342529,
-0.20698842406272888,
0.501672625541687,
0.3641229569911957,
0.22166204452514648,
-0.5098852515220642,
-0.2813619077205658,
0.005869767162948847,
0.45128604769706726,
-0.8343815803527832,
-0.09936141967773438,
-0.13214246928691864,
-0.12446458637714386,
-0.46154171228408813,
-0.2417864054441452,
-0.25866463780403137,
-0.15695929527282715,
-0.31470030546188354,
0.01438040193170309,
0.10632474720478058,
0.9031558632850647,
-0.15375274419784546,
0.465816855430603,
-0.2834198772907257,
0.14423663914203644,
0.44393908977508545,
-0.06404699385166168,
-0.36738038063049316,
-0.22264845669269562,
0.014169713482260704,
0.3217449188232422,
-0.6085832118988037,
-0.8520500659942627,
0.2537817060947418,
-0.16220207512378693,
0.8766953349113464,
0.7351844310760498,
0.6448100209236145,
0.19163842499256134,
-0.0677022933959961,
0.8817464709281921,
0.3067101240158081,
-0.6457650065422058,
0.23581744730472565,
-0.20090819895267487,
-0.09449081122875214,
0.29342716932296753,
-0.014754264615476131,
-0.15864023566246033,
-0.8789523243904114,
-0.9438257217407227,
-0.386825829744339,
0.7072077989578247,
0.39559710025787354,
0.26587849855422974,
-0.05630085617303848,
-0.06104486435651779,
0.23592741787433624,
0.4126589596271515,
-0.854910135269165,
-0.4139760732650757,
-0.10206563770771027,
-0.007795384153723717,
-0.14191298186779022,
0.07286830991506577,
-0.6447205543518066,
0.25044092535972595,
0.7109793424606323,
-0.2788272798061371,
0.3750734329223633,
0.21790263056755066,
-0.13723133504390717,
-0.23101988434791565,
0.22248445451259613,
0.7428860664367676,
0.509684681892395,
0.17351621389389038,
0.26309657096862793,
-0.139845609664917,
-0.22036652266979218,
0.23250973224639893,
-0.058716218918561935,
-0.06759580969810486,
-0.15983819961547852,
0.5578877329826355,
0.5971826910972595,
-0.05250304192304611,
-0.7743193507194519,
0.8290721774101257,
0.19418682157993317,
-0.4367705285549164,
-0.5336984992027283,
0.13512921333312988,
-0.20109792053699493,
0.507929801940918,
0.39969468116760254,
0.27083131670951843,
0.011327811516821384,
-0.8534568548202515,
0.3063574433326721,
0.9139714241027832,
-0.40073904395103455,
-0.21748055517673492,
0.6775827407836914,
0.08414458483457565,
-0.7932192087173462,
0.3938014805316925,
-0.388003408908844,
-0.6092427372932434,
0.7174251675605774,
0.30910006165504456,
0.8649852275848389,
-0.22024387121200562,
0.5248846411705017,
-0.23598328232765198,
0.8726868629455566,
0.06987756490707397,
-0.12775857746601105,
-0.2774773836135864,
-0.7916673421859741,
-0.11190099269151688,
-0.12431719154119492,
-0.4924229681491852,
0.1624757945537567,
-0.5719123482704163,
-0.026866870000958443,
-0.17937354743480682,
-0.11160802841186523,
-0.37166208028793335,
0.29613083600997925,
-0.48954612016677856,
-0.15363521873950958,
0.1670573651790619,
0.8025168776512146,
-0.6296426057815552,
0.6080669164657593,
0.4154285788536072,
-0.4854106605052948,
-0.5358720421791077,
0.3323972821235657,
0.04513125494122505,
-0.992219865322113,
0.541007936000824,
0.1041988730430603,
-0.3983030915260315,
-0.11967246234416962,
-0.868798553943634,
-0.4281778633594513,
0.923288106918335,
0.39895808696746826,
-0.09985306113958359,
-0.20025061070919037,
0.6143672466278076,
0.45583316683769226,
-0.46604782342910767,
0.2247942090034485,
0.6629972457885742,
0.7985305190086365,
-0.03284279629588127,
-0.800143301486969,
0.2723236382007599,
0.30013173818588257,
-0.24001038074493408,
-0.1206066906452179,
-0.9182057976722717,
0.8266980051994324,
-0.07168062776327133,
-0.26528018712997437,
0.19453997910022736,
0.6447041630744934,
0.17122121155261993,
0.5080969333648682,
0.6340761184692383,
0.13278761506080627,
0.7130327820777893,
-0.22084766626358032,
0.9823234677314758,
-0.2219860702753067,
0.08649740368127823,
0.5845203399658203,
-0.21516576409339905,
0.32513725757598877,
0.5090452432632446,
0.15585681796073914,
0.5131444334983826,
0.23519417643547058,
0.11121531575918198,
0.5979713797569275,
0.279553085565567,
-0.12820443511009216,
-0.54916912317276,
-0.10921210050582886,
0.054490406066179276,
0.6090083718299866,
0.5793798565864563,
-0.0016122242668643594,
-0.17247551679611206,
0.34416207671165466,
-0.1302456110715866,
0.446938157081604,
-0.07106413692235947,
0.74446040391922,
0.11302167922258377,
-0.8716769814491272,
0.5261438488960266,
-0.1640525460243225,
0.4066073000431061,
-0.624652087688446,
-0.28271976113319397,
0.18938998878002167,
0.2562240660190582,
0.1612647920846939,
-0.9114198088645935,
0.17888452112674713,
-0.7046353220939636,
0.2575445771217346,
-0.6806417107582092,
0.6097990870475769,
-0.4533350169658661,
0.11587264388799667,
0.20273958146572113,
0.4124971926212311,
0.1682782918214798,
-0.09366746991872787,
-0.969903826713562,
0.03908968344330788,
-0.10652174800634384,
-0.43681806325912476,
0.22494742274284363,
0.3264594078063965,
-0.07386001944541931,
1.0296332836151123,
0.5832340717315674,
0.08119194954633713,
-0.13429544866085052,
-0.35891076922416687,
0.8022306561470032,
-0.3209077715873718,
-0.7567878365516663,
-0.623466432094574,
0.2668752372264862,
-0.19095663726329803,
0.1155226081609726,
0.7509021162986755,
0.34866663813591003,
0.8306690454483032,
-0.08582014590501785,
0.7120115756988525,
0.21726083755493164,
0.3895083963871002,
-0.4745680093765259,
0.7005235552787781,
-0.38374820351600647,
0.3825037181377411,
0.16106893122196198,
-0.5511793494224548,
0.018295900896191597,
0.35587504506111145,
-0.47340327501296997,
0.011763213202357292,
0.7048725485801697,
1.02483069896698,
0.26778271794319153,
0.019955607131123543,
0.7168010473251343,
0.3117929697036743,
0.3409544825553894,
0.6977695822715759,
1.2309088706970215,
-0.328018456697464,
0.8946136832237244,
-0.2759096920490265,
-0.2487799972295761,
-0.41404658555984497,
-0.3219759166240692,
-1.043129563331604,
-0.6226959824562073,
-0.5890077352523804,
-0.508180558681488,
0.006727985572069883,
0.6007490158081055,
0.5899683833122253,
-0.45463240146636963,
-0.09815625101327896,
-0.18234434723854065,
0.23027272522449493,
-0.5028001070022583,
-0.29167211055755615,
-0.09050928056240082,
-0.14918255805969238,
-0.9123295545578003,
0.5337032079696655,
0.2595069408416748,
0.10611750930547714,
-0.7572459578514099,
-0.3797091543674469,
0.04648754000663757,
0.6417750716209412,
0.12386316061019897,
0.44285300374031067,
-1.2320808172225952,
-0.3803490996360779,
-0.14382657408714294,
-0.311071515083313,
-0.05020301043987274,
0.6796980500221252,
-1.018196702003479,
0.5112366676330566,
0.08058373630046844,
0.5451200604438782,
0.1352933794260025,
0.2675383687019348,
0.33400994539260864,
-0.5204272866249084,
0.14577610790729523,
0.6581241488456726,
-0.08021136373281479,
0.055413272231817245,
-0.5799688696861267,
0.21069009602069855,
0.322628378868103,
-0.45258069038391113,
-0.9097875952720642,
0.5180344581604004,
-0.8833158016204834,
-0.3981114625930786,
1.0527547597885132,
0.11187687516212463,
-0.4526352286338806,
-0.465090274810791,
-0.2504260241985321,
0.10785626620054245,
-0.5139123797416687,
0.7360276579856873,
0.5868257284164429,
-0.2474519908428192,
0.03451528027653694,
-0.531688928604126,
0.7353991270065308,
0.25427234172821045,
-0.553821325302124,
0.14306874573230743,
0.30722948908805847,
0.08430837839841843,
0.441660612821579,
0.5477946996688843,
0.2626897394657135,
0.3034510016441345,
0.41035890579223633,
-0.16711799800395966,
-0.46939465403556824,
-0.24058452248573303,
-0.40288418531417847,
0.16412249207496643,
-0.13869953155517578,
-0.4426712095737457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04324v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04324v1
|
Granite Code Models: A Family of Open Foundation Models for Code Intelligence
| 2024-05-07T13:50:40 | 2024-05-07T13:50:40 |
Mayank Mishra, Matt Stallone, Gaoyuan Zhang, Yikang Shen, Aditya Prasad, Adriana Meza Soria, Michele Merler, Parameswaran Selvam, Saptha Surendran, Shivdeep Singh, Manish Sethi, Xuan-Hong Dang, Pengyuan Li, Kun-Lung Wu, Syed Zawad, Andrew Coleman, Matthew White, Mark Lewis, Raju Pavuluri, Yan Koyfman, Boris Lublinsky, Maximilien de Bayser, Ibrahim Abdelaziz, Kinjal Basu, Mayank Agarwal, Yi Zhou, Chris Johnson, Aanchal Goyal, Hima Patel, Yousaf Shah, Petros Zerfos, Heiko Ludwig, Asim Munawar, Maxwell Crouse, Pavan Kapanipathi, Shweta Salaria, Bob Calio, Sophia Wen, Seetharami Seelam, Brian Belgodere, Carlos Fonseca, Amith Singhee, Nirmit Desai, David D. Cox, Ruchir Puri, Rameswar Panda
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) trained on code are revolutionizing the software
development process. Increasingly, code LLMs are being integrated into software
development environments to improve the productivity of human programmers, and
LLM-based agents are beginning to show promise for handling complex tasks
autonomously. Realizing the full potential of code LLMs requires a wide range
of capabilities, including code generation, fixing bugs, explaining and
documenting code, maintaining repositories, and more. In this work, we
introduce the Granite series of decoder-only code models for code generative
tasks, trained with code written in 116 programming languages. The Granite Code
models family consists of models ranging in size from 3 to 34 billion
parameters, suitable for applications ranging from complex application
modernization tasks to on-device memory-constrained use cases. Evaluation on a
comprehensive set of tasks demonstrates that Granite Code models consistently
reaches state-of-the-art performance among available open-source code LLMs. The
Granite Code model family was optimized for enterprise software development
workflows and performs well across a range of coding tasks (e.g. code
generation, fixing and explanation), making it a versatile all around code
model. We release all our Granite Code models under an Apache 2.0 license for
both research and commercial use.
|
[
-0.14718736708164215,
-0.35539671778678894,
0.5081018209457397,
0.2841523587703705,
-0.004738700110465288,
0.09823718667030334,
-0.4550005793571472,
-0.2159142941236496,
-0.15428674221038818,
1.14677095413208,
-0.5898206830024719,
-0.7222254276275635,
-0.5350874662399292,
0.07606656849384308,
-0.30230405926704407,
1.0515131950378418,
-0.1900634914636612,
0.0644337460398674,
-0.2880115807056427,
0.16273288428783417,
-0.28028178215026855,
-0.4821769595146179,
-0.22201399505138397,
-0.32757046818733215,
0.22409431636333466,
0.31039559841156006,
0.7661420106887817,
0.7725980281829834,
0.6984763145446777,
0.26338431239128113,
0.2833873927593231,
0.13213558495044708,
-0.6237974762916565,
0.21457363665103912,
-0.04528392478823662,
-0.5564552545547485,
-0.6904416680335999,
-0.23737122118473053,
0.1081739217042923,
0.6843680739402771,
-0.1654207855463028,
0.5268968939781189,
-0.03234195336699486,
0.5234482884407043,
-0.5210824608802795,
0.4441341757774353,
-0.6401609778404236,
-0.0903351753950119,
-0.15381330251693726,
-0.32368168234825134,
-0.690528929233551,
-0.4330575466156006,
-0.4636176526546478,
-0.41036146879196167,
0.08867035061120987,
-0.185106560587883,
0.297417014837265,
0.5209741592407227,
-0.20523427426815033,
-0.49696576595306396,
-0.9911085963249207,
0.9579476714134216,
-0.5053091645240784,
0.2230832576751709,
0.3263932764530182,
0.09162866324186325,
-0.33084219694137573,
-0.7737624645233154,
-0.11817188560962677,
-0.16742786765098572,
0.2702828347682953,
-0.09819936007261276,
0.0006141593330539763,
-0.07948664575815201,
0.15392515063285828,
0.6788931488990784,
-0.7659317255020142,
-0.04064677655696869,
-0.18198278546333313,
0.2300616055727005,
0.5372278094291687,
0.4539225995540619,
0.48246076703071594,
0.22304515540599823,
-0.0796155110001564,
0.09121455252170563,
-1.0117312669754028,
-0.120457224547863,
-0.07509700953960419,
0.35021379590034485,
-0.21253959834575653,
0.6563491225242615,
-0.10809285193681717,
0.6565902829170227,
-0.391669362783432,
-0.2431086301803589,
-0.013581686653196812,
0.08234838396310806,
-0.5969602465629578,
-0.43565136194229126,
0.40189382433891296,
-0.14232683181762695,
0.37858664989471436,
-0.6250591278076172,
-0.36164453625679016,
0.337848424911499,
0.41457319259643555,
-0.8016363978385925,
-0.3176758885383606,
0.3162185847759247,
-0.6637383103370667,
-0.5068009495735168,
-0.24637249112129211,
-0.41861239075660706,
-0.5776535868644714,
-0.271622896194458,
0.05590174347162247,
-0.22317534685134888,
-0.5219489932060242,
0.3107292354106903,
0.057726431638002396,
0.13879261910915375,
0.31988781690597534,
-0.8919677734375,
0.34918272495269775,
0.8696831464767456,
0.5676003694534302,
0.060656577348709106,
-0.21864253282546997,
-0.46071577072143555,
0.14325855672359467,
-0.6001012921333313,
0.4983508884906769,
-0.7618458867073059,
-0.4816937744617462,
0.05340420454740524,
-0.08010304719209671,
0.03127792105078697,
-0.6949371099472046,
0.2844727635383606,
-0.8466415405273438,
-0.3673955500125885,
0.15653923153877258,
-0.2660343647003174,
-0.21021445095539093,
0.2494419664144516,
-0.7468553185462952,
0.9499202370643616,
0.5830276012420654,
-0.31663602590560913,
0.03200019150972366,
-0.6012858748435974,
-0.2656579911708832,
0.564100444316864,
-0.43382346630096436,
-0.3702090084552765,
0.38790443539619446,
-0.11034760624170303,
0.4923816919326782,
-0.8359771370887756,
0.18443003296852112,
-0.1280406266450882,
-0.3614358901977539,
-0.05095171928405762,
0.041450127959251404,
0.9835410118103027,
0.3797665238380432,
-0.4438171982765198,
0.17769773304462433,
-0.36041200160980225,
0.24225153028964996,
0.19785399734973907,
-0.5184015035629272,
-0.0704454630613327,
0.10537746548652649,
-0.13145554065704346,
0.19067160785198212,
-0.014347597025334835,
-0.33842799067497253,
0.2333696335554123,
0.006306441500782967,
0.32974380254745483,
0.6147592067718506,
-0.14966098964214325,
0.27601158618927,
-0.5119139552116394,
0.7113168835639954,
-0.25691139698028564,
0.2017573118209839,
-0.34890905022621155,
-0.48416510224342346,
-0.43201643228530884,
-0.6356129050254822,
0.2107991725206375,
0.5859459638595581,
-0.7380672693252563,
0.044265016913414,
-0.6528214812278748,
-0.4343773424625397,
-0.2926008701324463,
0.39826902747154236,
0.5889332294464111,
-0.10013371706008911,
0.013732880353927612,
-0.2750135660171509,
-0.3593970537185669,
-0.5400587320327759,
-0.250068336725235,
0.003720458596944809,
0.011074965819716454,
0.2853873372077942,
0.6497312784194946,
-0.3608526885509491,
0.8763473033905029,
-0.5098142623901367,
-0.12358399480581284,
-0.41262879967689514,
0.04668920859694481,
0.25894981622695923,
0.36280450224876404,
0.4522567093372345,
-1.0382736921310425,
-0.41188254952430725,
0.14968429505825043,
-0.8645365834236145,
0.1652471274137497,
0.0017748294631019235,
-0.15965108573436737,
0.27411913871765137,
0.34395986795425415,
-0.4293989837169647,
0.4472961723804474,
0.7133073806762695,
-0.11781571805477142,
0.41032272577285767,
-0.028049223124980927,
0.09879277646541595,
-0.9803269505500793,
0.026617608964443207,
-0.028612220659852028,
-0.29825371503829956,
-0.6559260487556458,
0.7498114705085754,
0.19970059394836426,
-0.3410702347755432,
-0.35127222537994385,
0.4239199757575989,
-0.8693121075630188,
-0.32925915718078613,
-0.3205317556858063,
-0.3298186957836151,
-0.19378937780857086,
0.7032831311225891,
0.17591384053230286,
0.9334068894386292,
0.6355351805686951,
-0.8033707737922668,
0.5391504168510437,
0.33476579189300537,
-0.5254217982292175,
0.26605191826820374,
-0.36833733320236206,
0.290566086769104,
0.06499701738357544,
-0.0085707176476717,
-0.4265371263027191,
-0.3214820325374603,
-0.13367918133735657,
-0.591323971748352,
0.10972391813993454,
-0.5145639777183533,
-0.729590892791748,
-0.41145551204681396,
-0.22694742679595947,
0.2990616261959076,
0.8871606588363647,
-0.6291611790657043,
0.9440863728523254,
0.4263244867324829,
-0.2422950267791748,
-0.3641805350780487,
-0.9123353362083435,
0.14110806584358215,
0.15493135154247284,
-0.9258650541305542,
0.3201180398464203,
-0.20238469541072845,
-0.4277074635028839,
0.23284918069839478,
-0.008106817491352558,
-0.30071577429771423,
0.09070471674203873,
0.588122546672821,
0.3222290873527527,
-0.3570796251296997,
0.10913417488336563,
-0.36818015575408936,
-0.12088709324598312,
-0.031971219927072525,
-0.5357610583305359,
0.5637335777282715,
-0.10923067480325699,
-0.36641213297843933,
0.09750670194625854,
0.2703584134578705,
0.7058497071266174,
-0.696974515914917,
0.8237364888191223,
-0.00369570916518569,
-0.6645157933235168,
-0.6288138628005981,
-0.39991217851638794,
0.16650603711605072,
-0.4291074573993683,
0.5435390472412109,
-0.7357361316680908,
-0.859748899936676,
0.6120893955230713,
-0.3999077379703522,
0.292781263589859,
0.20011217892169952,
0.8221395611763,
0.38344427943229675,
0.9797554016113281,
1.0462138652801514,
0.03354596346616745,
0.10792016983032227,
-0.43001416325569153,
0.29170647263526917,
-0.8402169942855835,
-0.18163304030895233,
-0.6409032344818115,
0.271207332611084,
-0.38397565484046936,
-0.560624361038208,
0.19877906143665314,
0.05694979801774025,
-0.403999924659729,
0.18231792747974396,
-0.5375518798828125,
0.7088114023208618,
0.3225157558917999,
0.009207016788423061,
0.2647436261177063,
0.06154579296708107,
0.27816981077194214,
0.2685595750808716,
-0.47701969742774963,
-0.6262093186378479,
1.2354744672775269,
0.43008121848106384,
1.061037540435791,
0.3419015109539032,
0.7095004320144653,
0.5714178085327148,
0.5238603353500366,
-0.654040515422821,
0.5306038856506348,
-0.5414559841156006,
-0.5981492400169373,
-0.08344411849975586,
-0.5062041282653809,
-0.5716050863265991,
-0.07233086228370667,
-0.004217671696096659,
-0.4143925607204437,
-0.04975803196430206,
0.00012029734352836385,
-0.358433336019516,
0.7202363610267639,
-0.35043781995773315,
0.9549193382263184,
-0.23900043964385986,
-0.27722296118736267,
-0.11528021842241287,
-0.11855081468820572,
0.37884947657585144,
-0.20305493474006653,
0.31440791487693787,
-0.06763806194067001,
0.09720151126384735,
0.17707037925720215,
-0.3796670138835907,
0.7403541803359985,
-0.07642267644405365,
-0.11273398995399475,
0.302736759185791,
0.6165792346000671,
0.7571636438369751,
-0.17842808365821838,
-0.321307510137558,
0.044466130435466766,
-0.34754228591918945,
-0.33518847823143005,
-0.3700161278247833,
0.8510643243789673,
-0.7847649455070496,
-0.42009273171424866,
-0.18621200323104858,
-0.5570087432861328,
0.0190255269408226,
0.2491295486688614,
0.05017964169383049,
0.8212233781814575,
-0.12053054571151733,
0.2742981016635895,
1.021252155303955,
-0.1070229634642601,
0.45568111538887024,
0.33826184272766113,
-0.2697392702102661,
-0.24989940226078033,
0.8864002227783203,
-0.36808905005455017,
0.29526737332344055,
0.23325569927692413,
-0.4242680072784424,
0.15348663926124573,
-0.8846182227134705,
-0.730857253074646,
0.1156478151679039,
-0.7769037485122681,
-0.4060973823070526,
-0.49534934759140015,
-0.19535742700099945,
-0.42806220054626465,
-0.4690738618373871,
-0.3657448887825012,
-0.17558343708515167,
-0.15818531811237335,
0.15526923537254333,
0.3195013999938965,
1.1907821893692017,
0.4035743176937103,
0.10079310834407806,
-0.983302891254425,
0.4830169677734375,
0.08131345361471176,
0.7177577018737793,
-0.18195493519306183,
-0.2040126472711563,
-0.5103827118873596,
0.0438259057700634,
-0.11807990074157715,
-0.7573068141937256,
0.48275500535964966,
-0.1976223886013031,
0.5404588580131531,
-0.14188113808631897,
0.10599170625209808,
0.2301129549741745,
-0.42192327976226807,
0.8270426988601685,
-0.06545503437519073,
-0.9405881762504578,
0.2252737134695053,
-0.5723474025726318,
0.11937420815229416,
0.4254225194454193,
0.2105037271976471,
-0.28875383734703064,
-0.29699164628982544,
-0.12078395485877991,
-0.63893061876297,
0.9846751689910889,
0.2891204357147217,
0.22083155810832977,
-0.07841498404741287,
0.6154850125312805,
0.005728788673877716,
0.19471663236618042,
-0.9368304014205933,
-0.045724689960479736,
-0.15763133764266968,
-0.5533635020256042,
0.2384577840566635,
-0.1687697321176529,
-0.25680428743362427,
0.40674084424972534,
0.8144173622131348,
-0.1989755481481552,
0.3599492013454437,
-0.15375493466854095,
-0.49970465898513794,
-0.35151493549346924,
0.17361488938331604,
0.5600330233573914,
0.8718485832214355,
-0.10764738917350769,
-0.010164640843868256,
-0.07392346858978271,
-0.5473596453666687,
-0.01655356027185917,
-0.12422603368759155,
-0.05053071677684784,
-0.46355655789375305,
0.1670176386833191,
0.6781532764434814,
-0.0878058671951294,
-0.6126177310943604,
0.4983973801136017,
-0.03320883959531784,
-0.16723400354385376,
-0.737182080745697,
0.3162875473499298,
0.12552312016487122,
0.37508541345596313,
0.22224684059619904,
0.20370915532112122,
0.005280830431729555,
-0.6275870203971863,
-0.020620131865143776,
0.47445112466812134,
-0.3055359721183777,
-0.05527166649699211,
0.6001397967338562,
0.3589586317539215,
-0.5146100521087646,
0.8968304991722107,
-0.3868616223335266,
-0.4108226001262665,
0.9088004231452942,
0.7041369080543518,
1.2135140895843506,
-0.22389817237854004,
0.11837391555309296,
0.0776703804731369,
0.5201638340950012,
-0.1503543108701706,
0.5272571444511414,
0.17261023819446564,
-0.5147930979728699,
-0.4968438744544983,
-0.7137848734855652,
-0.2846134305000305,
0.02126818522810936,
-0.5731457471847534,
0.3026835322380066,
-0.46639594435691833,
-0.0595623143017292,
-0.32458966970443726,
-0.0960136353969574,
-0.5577163100242615,
0.34993594884872437,
0.2363579273223877,
1.1809322834014893,
-0.6516373157501221,
0.9331738352775574,
0.7953383326530457,
-0.530796468257904,
-0.6910310387611389,
-0.08772736042737961,
-0.044194601476192474,
-0.735292375087738,
0.6582886576652527,
-0.06457830220460892,
-0.44137394428253174,
0.2314371019601822,
-0.5626245737075806,
-0.7679569125175476,
1.2633761167526245,
0.3328971266746521,
-0.14450936019420624,
-0.15821346640586853,
0.3301413655281067,
0.29171323776245117,
-0.9446796178817749,
0.3096621334552765,
0.30375203490257263,
0.11607600748538971,
0.11911973357200623,
-0.7116370797157288,
0.019185129553079605,
-0.63349449634552,
0.5192499756813049,
0.5840485692024231,
-0.49149125814437866,
1.0750186443328857,
-0.3554854989051819,
-0.087018683552742,
0.4215288758277893,
0.2374342828989029,
0.3463711738586426,
-0.04365244880318642,
0.22761505842208862,
0.48387494683265686,
0.40655773878097534,
-0.21661226451396942,
1.4299347400665283,
-0.7429472804069519,
0.20744454860687256,
0.9171153903007507,
-0.4398183226585388,
0.822915256023407,
-0.1582426130771637,
-0.00006461967132054269,
0.6932008266448975,
0.5875021815299988,
-0.06816297024488449,
0.4181424081325531,
0.3323061168193817,
-0.3307926654815674,
-0.38985493779182434,
0.15605607628822327,
-0.2091008424758911,
0.08361327648162842,
0.2824558913707733,
-0.31775784492492676,
0.0654819905757904,
-0.0762360468506813,
0.20144745707511902,
0.1868848353624344,
-0.5501481294631958,
0.6985543966293335,
-0.017788102850317955,
-0.6621906161308289,
0.5407350659370422,
0.396335631608963,
0.4402308166027069,
-0.6921133995056152,
-0.18084166944026947,
-0.2468394935131073,
0.4689052402973175,
-0.4375074803829193,
-0.6489287614822388,
0.3755141794681549,
0.2581363618373871,
-0.5545001029968262,
-0.2180500030517578,
0.47642233967781067,
-0.19511111080646515,
-0.25049617886543274,
0.3948362171649933,
0.1951819211244583,
0.09140212833881378,
-0.27937740087509155,
-0.4699717164039612,
0.23274263739585876,
0.11686591058969498,
-0.10728531330823898,
0.13333149254322052,
0.3040599822998047,
-0.2082991600036621,
0.6797661185264587,
0.6087703704833984,
0.06290142983198166,
0.3555949628353119,
0.010859834961593151,
0.997566819190979,
-0.7430423498153687,
-0.33368557691574097,
-0.5960050821304321,
0.6877673268318176,
0.19001571834087372,
-0.025900378823280334,
0.4871053695678711,
0.7837303280830383,
0.7045395374298096,
-0.40569430589675903,
1.0148931741714478,
-0.052550021559000015,
0.47089922428131104,
-0.49810609221458435,
0.44832631945610046,
-0.41001492738723755,
0.37676453590393066,
-0.06689843535423279,
-1.1208126544952393,
-0.4946017265319824,
0.19387474656105042,
-0.30000847578048706,
0.35715627670288086,
0.6373336911201477,
0.8640924692153931,
-0.09538554400205612,
0.2616158723831177,
0.21360336244106293,
-0.017521191388368607,
0.31473302841186523,
0.7720752954483032,
0.7342942953109741,
-0.2500508427619934,
0.5422053933143616,
-0.047118011862039566,
-0.6029329895973206,
-0.17777691781520844,
-0.794062077999115,
-0.9265726804733276,
-0.3658064007759094,
-0.3318300247192383,
-0.30557000637054443,
0.12512877583503723,
0.9571456909179688,
0.9314159154891968,
-0.6772993206977844,
-0.5931903123855591,
-0.3608027398586273,
-0.08661013841629028,
-0.09248312562704086,
-0.12507879734039307,
0.011399848386645317,
-0.4472537040710449,
-0.47045615315437317,
0.28343290090560913,
0.4796433746814728,
-0.143998920917511,
-0.24404118955135345,
-0.5696097016334534,
0.3279910087585449,
0.252413272857666,
0.4961768686771393,
0.34236007928848267,
-0.5542712211608887,
0.22897548973560333,
0.31911560893058777,
-0.46847468614578247,
0.029581541195511818,
1.0033899545669556,
-0.5391930937767029,
0.2841540575027466,
0.3595527112483978,
0.6992331147193909,
0.43574726581573486,
-0.23899827897548676,
0.45257359743118286,
-0.506862223148346,
-0.0023413156159222126,
0.2866169214248657,
0.3198447525501251,
0.21215754747390747,
-0.5936434268951416,
0.7763205766677856,
-0.13546420633792877,
-0.7040977478027344,
-0.9043560028076172,
0.5187894701957703,
-0.5320003032684326,
-0.37066295742988586,
0.9870210289955139,
-0.23228996992111206,
-0.29902103543281555,
-0.13012978434562683,
0.15634186565876007,
-0.001604876946657896,
0.1049060970544815,
0.48777100443840027,
0.4307861328125,
-0.22408249974250793,
-0.35519659519195557,
-0.6395434141159058,
0.5676113367080688,
0.004405873827636242,
-1.1111955642700195,
0.31247711181640625,
0.5546923279762268,
0.39054059982299805,
0.23246805369853973,
0.9316217303276062,
-0.5050185322761536,
0.4749845862388611,
0.13897961378097534,
0.7971030473709106,
-0.3883857727050781,
-0.7122712135314941,
-0.3452608287334442,
0.17192421853542328,
0.5216761231422424,
0.03574057295918465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04304v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04304v4
|
Dynamic Speculation Lookahead Accelerates Speculative Decoding of Large Language Models
| 2024-05-07T13:27:52 | 2024-06-23T13:46:23 |
Jonathan Mamou, Oren Pereg, Daniel Korat, Moshe Berchansky, Nadav Timor, Moshe Wasserblat, Roy Schwartz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Speculative decoding is commonly used for reducing the inference latency of
large language models. Its effectiveness depends highly on the speculation
lookahead (SL)-the number of tokens generated by the draft model at each
iteration. In this work we show that the common practice of using the same SL
for all iterations (static SL) is suboptimal. We introduce DISCO (DynamIc
SpeCulation lookahead Optimization), a novel method for dynamically selecting
the SL. Our experiments with four datasets show that DISCO reaches an average
speedup of 10% compared to the best static SL baseline, while generating the
exact same text.
|
[
-0.438262403011322,
-0.8916336297988892,
0.22936369478702545,
0.1405378133058548,
-0.3981555700302124,
0.6649917364120483,
0.13081778585910797,
-0.7666717171669006,
0.6946315765380859,
0.5778469443321228,
-0.9390655755996704,
-0.3509756028652191,
-0.1343526840209961,
-0.03229261562228203,
-0.7687771916389465,
0.6735960245132446,
0.05254112929105759,
-0.5587634444236755,
0.1571502387523651,
0.16552212834358215,
-0.07512527704238892,
-0.33062469959259033,
-0.5381552577018738,
-0.01731235347688198,
0.6858935356140137,
0.1884278953075409,
0.8895953893661499,
0.5879818201065063,
0.38428664207458496,
0.28077828884124756,
-0.43822625279426575,
0.4449208080768585,
-0.9292594194412231,
0.5635493397712708,
0.1864061951637268,
-0.664135217666626,
-0.1270417869091034,
-0.27044400572776794,
0.5558528304100037,
0.4531202018260956,
-0.3126200735569,
0.2609556019306183,
-0.5018582344055176,
0.865095317363739,
-1.1006584167480469,
-0.34850215911865234,
-0.8512195348739624,
0.17217926681041718,
-0.37451326847076416,
-0.36959487199783325,
-0.644673228263855,
-0.7137119174003601,
0.46798425912857056,
-0.6938542723655701,
0.4723072052001953,
0.22875557839870453,
0.7638071775436401,
0.3670836091041565,
-0.07430252432823181,
-0.0930410847067833,
-0.8352486491203308,
0.6646808981895447,
-0.8680907487869263,
0.5642555952072144,
0.20107640326023102,
0.23058848083019257,
-0.23444372415542603,
-0.8232022523880005,
-0.43802422285079956,
-0.3161640763282776,
0.25850576162338257,
0.045308180153369904,
-0.09031479805707932,
0.14159829914569855,
0.45482656359672546,
0.20640884339809418,
-0.34471395611763,
0.2720932364463806,
-0.07982340455055237,
-0.3666802644729614,
0.49289512634277344,
0.21954070031642914,
0.10276999324560165,
0.14754384756088257,
-0.01726636104285717,
-0.02984684891998768,
-0.7591686248779297,
-0.09981594979763031,
0.6087068915367126,
-0.058872517198324203,
-0.16827386617660522,
0.4461069703102112,
-0.37924623489379883,
0.6780288219451904,
0.20199896395206451,
-0.14074911177158356,
0.2973376214504242,
-0.44114845991134644,
-0.03991945460438728,
0.18836520612239838,
0.5346740484237671,
0.3132127821445465,
0.06419841945171356,
-0.0709977075457573,
-0.11698366701602936,
0.1905043125152588,
0.35093429684638977,
-0.6454042792320251,
-0.4070470333099365,
0.28608354926109314,
-0.5067747831344604,
-0.5839532613754272,
-0.1935703307390213,
-1.4008132219314575,
-0.2692622244358063,
0.04666145145893097,
-0.2682598829269409,
-0.5129751563072205,
-0.3714379072189331,
0.36539092659950256,
-0.3818163275718689,
-0.11488551646471024,
0.5110906958580017,
-0.7107049822807312,
0.22951647639274597,
0.32219448685646057,
0.9090161323547363,
-0.22227677702903748,
-0.16318172216415405,
-0.3422184884548187,
0.15939947962760925,
-0.8863618969917297,
0.9084828495979309,
-0.5947247743606567,
-0.34345370531082153,
0.1265096366405487,
-0.6506059169769287,
0.12343590706586838,
-0.22044792771339417,
0.31192293763160706,
-0.9486947655677795,
-0.26187101006507874,
-0.38934630155563354,
-0.37989571690559387,
-0.008909616619348526,
-0.12273494154214859,
-1.0290015935897827,
1.2398524284362793,
0.030460305511951447,
-1.13235604763031,
0.5626541376113892,
-0.4052368700504303,
-0.24927012622356415,
0.2438509166240692,
0.05830317363142967,
-0.09557503461837769,
0.5766845345497131,
-0.03453528508543968,
-0.19589613378047943,
-0.285812646150589,
-0.09390685707330704,
-0.18939967453479767,
-0.9289961457252502,
0.6113561391830444,
-0.6006556749343872,
0.20283691585063934,
0.5466182827949524,
-0.5785971283912659,
-0.10649704188108444,
-0.8956153392791748,
0.08051865547895432,
-0.03684278205037117,
-0.23071704804897308,
-0.524877667427063,
0.4435409605503082,
-0.13197381794452667,
-0.029853928834199905,
0.21460074186325073,
-0.39906781911849976,
0.11927980929613113,
-0.6850361824035645,
0.23057562112808228,
0.5862835049629211,
-0.006046917289495468,
0.03102969191968441,
-0.1514546424150467,
0.8635970950126648,
-0.04483896866440773,
-0.15744686126708984,
-0.1997765153646469,
-0.07559798657894135,
-0.9565795063972473,
-0.2695614695549011,
0.6442258954048157,
0.19271431863307953,
-1.1539099216461182,
0.1368079036474228,
0.14160048961639404,
-0.6715448498725891,
-0.9636160135269165,
-0.47205498814582825,
0.563547670841217,
0.08538559824228287,
0.1403268426656723,
0.07457361370325089,
-0.722108781337738,
-0.9750329256057739,
-0.36296799778938293,
-0.17698654532432556,
0.6540904641151428,
0.04030660167336464,
0.06796657294034958,
-0.2798636555671692,
0.5329350829124451,
-0.6460762023925781,
0.4443106949329376,
-0.27947065234184265,
0.4487195312976837,
0.18885888159275055,
0.24912141263484955,
0.7410847544670105,
-0.615216851234436,
-0.41220688819885254,
-0.13433505594730377,
-0.44898244738578796,
-0.09453386813402176,
-0.3123391568660736,
-0.3893198072910309,
0.646206259727478,
0.8444049954414368,
-0.610776960849762,
0.3745156228542328,
0.6345248222351074,
-0.3599342107772827,
0.8670477271080017,
-0.19676701724529266,
0.0982394739985466,
-0.5477491021156311,
0.11208448559045792,
-0.16667594015598297,
-0.21637871861457825,
-0.5745278596878052,
0.5021877884864807,
-0.09308550506830215,
0.18555974960327148,
-0.6393002271652222,
0.18211020529270172,
-0.6366274356842041,
0.08921802043914795,
-0.1372087597846985,
0.1770545244216919,
-0.33264002203941345,
0.08475718647241592,
-0.1426738053560257,
1.1635335683822632,
0.5807210206985474,
-0.6695895195007324,
0.11352179944515228,
-0.1306489109992981,
-0.7672758102416992,
-0.2650390565395355,
-0.34008461236953735,
0.2604871690273285,
-0.26053720712661743,
0.3933115005493164,
-1.0447982549667358,
-0.027369782328605652,
-0.18240207433700562,
-0.030197281390428543,
0.05980059504508972,
0.11944331228733063,
-0.5736191868782043,
-0.7664957642555237,
-0.4948519468307495,
0.7878786325454712,
0.7191272974014282,
-0.3384757936000824,
0.26558953523635864,
0.44899871945381165,
0.21076802909374237,
-1.0512555837631226,
-0.6054556369781494,
0.048691119998693466,
-0.1984722763299942,
-0.16677455604076385,
0.3809396028518677,
-0.12483761459589005,
-0.27547013759613037,
-0.09297353029251099,
-0.3193703591823578,
0.1522083878517151,
0.13787676393985748,
-0.1168886125087738,
0.09222115576267242,
-0.05628766864538193,
-0.27528998255729675,
0.24531349539756775,
-0.16567830741405487,
-0.09688188880681992,
-0.2387397289276123,
1.0828287601470947,
0.2572069466114044,
-0.17412890493869781,
-0.6358599662780762,
0.24615436792373657,
0.7014039158821106,
-0.0029873682651668787,
0.6445831060409546,
0.31462836265563965,
-0.10973390936851501,
-0.5979430079460144,
-0.791421115398407,
0.08336691558361053,
-0.5997219681739807,
0.44225049018859863,
-0.6666731238365173,
-0.774139404296875,
0.8441765308380127,
-0.1624932736158371,
0.33753901720046997,
0.44095006585121155,
0.648552656173706,
0.01078246533870697,
0.9692700505256653,
0.6230010390281677,
0.2178388386964798,
0.48476114869117737,
-0.2506115436553955,
0.3526774048805237,
-0.4373433589935303,
-0.423857182264328,
-0.6275623440742493,
-0.449891597032547,
-0.8117181658744812,
-0.514680027961731,
-0.05908150598406792,
-0.044160231947898865,
0.024301676079630852,
0.23574715852737427,
-0.4733416438102722,
0.7515437602996826,
0.7042142152786255,
0.12409409880638123,
0.3041521906852722,
-0.00836921762675047,
-0.5138583183288574,
-0.2866317927837372,
-0.7771314382553101,
-0.05510706827044487,
0.7676510214805603,
0.2418583631515503,
1.2004483938217163,
0.020070970058441162,
0.7676181197166443,
0.3152383863925934,
-0.1651710420846939,
-0.6206075549125671,
0.8086073398590088,
-0.21448685228824615,
-0.44083070755004883,
-0.1699129343032837,
-0.4247434139251709,
-0.6806787252426147,
0.19683828949928284,
-0.1757885366678238,
-0.7074516415596008,
0.35150784254074097,
0.4473991096019745,
-0.35519886016845703,
0.21494007110595703,
-0.23294135928153992,
0.31667861342430115,
0.1882314234972,
-0.029577333480119705,
-0.544179379940033,
-0.2808491885662079,
0.5372278690338135,
-0.5657066106796265,
0.06260564178228378,
-0.03149864077568054,
-0.0016295160166919231,
0.8695248961448669,
-0.2751297056674957,
0.6285344958305359,
-0.015169990248978138,
-0.36990323662757874,
0.47601282596588135,
0.7399216890335083,
0.7039933204650879,
-0.07547246664762497,
-0.4710679054260254,
0.1833670288324356,
0.1898398995399475,
-0.08501794189214706,
-0.4508127272129059,
0.6240554451942444,
-0.6383506655693054,
-0.5349143147468567,
-0.47247281670570374,
-0.6330475807189941,
-0.031156832352280617,
0.2631494998931885,
0.5863580703735352,
0.4392217695713043,
-0.2820003628730774,
0.03914644941687584,
0.5627622604370117,
-0.28355902433395386,
0.47846922278404236,
0.35606685280799866,
-0.4451422393321991,
-0.11698625236749649,
0.7637082934379578,
0.18817491829395294,
0.4603821933269501,
0.3079497814178467,
-0.06775765120983124,
-0.3828822374343872,
-0.8771980404853821,
-0.07466844469308853,
0.34402039647102356,
-0.559256374835968,
-0.009272326715290546,
-0.7636178731918335,
-0.25479960441589355,
-0.08553753793239594,
-0.35853299498558044,
-0.7094603180885315,
-0.5158177018165588,
-0.11504489928483963,
-0.16611452400684357,
0.3358009457588196,
0.4163159728050232,
0.09059787541627884,
0.45029371976852417,
-0.5070546269416809,
0.4593186378479004,
-0.1875530630350113,
0.3965318500995636,
0.22273217141628265,
-0.4832984209060669,
-0.4558081328868866,
0.15757913887500763,
0.06180654093623161,
-0.6740644574165344,
0.5654426217079163,
-0.15694865584373474,
0.5920538306236267,
0.5557096004486084,
0.4024830162525177,
1.1030672788619995,
-0.8675708770751953,
0.7567596435546875,
0.31395119428634644,
-0.9638063907623291,
0.4138900935649872,
-0.3428157567977905,
0.422629177570343,
0.8556912541389465,
0.22642108798027039,
-0.49457859992980957,
-0.7625205516815186,
-0.6643505692481995,
-0.9381282329559326,
0.7741634249687195,
0.19205322861671448,
0.07518131285905838,
-0.154960498213768,
0.4915880262851715,
0.3302530348300934,
0.34368690848350525,
-0.2412939965724945,
-0.446372926235199,
0.0740233063697815,
-0.05134538561105728,
0.10793028026819229,
-0.7144425511360168,
-0.11671839654445648,
-0.11895798146724701,
0.3414996266365051,
-0.12222730368375778,
0.5576110482215881,
-0.11107934266328812,
0.10399679839611053,
-0.6031124591827393,
-0.2985185384750366,
0.5387486815452576,
0.9616157412528992,
-0.4980173707008362,
0.2602533996105194,
0.13217850029468536,
-0.6180006265640259,
0.015658490359783173,
-0.40517011284828186,
-0.5515981912612915,
0.4584563672542572,
0.3593606948852539,
1.0115946531295776,
0.5670472383499146,
-1.0183334350585938,
-0.25056952238082886,
-0.17318607866764069,
-0.4703647494316101,
-0.3116386830806732,
0.3405418395996094,
-0.08495257794857025,
0.21065695583820343,
0.21814778447151184,
0.0325675830245018,
0.16637012362480164,
-0.5639067888259888,
0.3083919882774353,
0.3505016565322876,
0.11025399714708328,
-0.33883216977119446,
0.6630897521972656,
0.02675366960465908,
-0.4459160566329956,
0.5160296559333801,
0.06367042660713196,
-0.38895493745803833,
0.7244256138801575,
0.7895299792289734,
0.9412599802017212,
-0.1591566801071167,
0.5658330321311951,
0.16245965659618378,
0.21639665961265564,
-0.4415735602378845,
0.5984743237495422,
0.35479944944381714,
-0.6529331803321838,
-0.6037611365318298,
-0.8860942125320435,
-0.5809748768806458,
0.18669553101062775,
-0.6498808860778809,
0.3071889281272888,
-0.3755377233028412,
-0.24671317636966705,
0.12885154783725739,
-0.11918351799249649,
-0.576687753200531,
-0.06630373001098633,
0.04852791875600815,
1.2416781187057495,
-0.40434977412223816,
0.8862510919570923,
0.43668657541275024,
0.02887704037129879,
-0.5401512980461121,
0.47972339391708374,
0.05579564347863197,
-0.6858912706375122,
0.6784166097640991,
0.10239478945732117,
-0.30359411239624023,
0.1568528264760971,
-0.4697485566139221,
-1.4466224908828735,
0.752114474773407,
0.4319947063922882,
-1.0433558225631714,
-0.40676653385162354,
-0.1840781271457672,
0.6623672246932983,
-0.2427719682455063,
0.25441938638687134,
0.7831807136535645,
0.3479762375354767,
0.5409655570983887,
-0.6425392627716064,
0.01608378440141678,
0.02142738178372383,
0.14594170451164246,
0.45946070551872253,
-0.7550340294837952,
0.8119174242019653,
-0.18489600718021393,
-0.24623581767082214,
0.1519542634487152,
0.6240674257278442,
0.4718259572982788,
0.10843391716480255,
0.5790967345237732,
0.532477617263794,
0.9307001829147339,
0.1299925148487091,
1.0806068181991577,
-0.4768545627593994,
0.3443513810634613,
0.8042142987251282,
-0.33194515109062195,
0.777814507484436,
0.2590476870536804,
-0.25952768325805664,
0.7055274844169617,
0.9472418427467346,
0.22470048069953918,
0.9433771371841431,
0.3331907093524933,
-0.13179931044578552,
-0.21747790277004242,
0.1375492364168167,
-0.3487327992916107,
0.45720914006233215,
0.47316330671310425,
-0.06684067845344543,
-0.20960712432861328,
-0.4243570864200592,
-0.011417616158723831,
-0.20089149475097656,
-0.08096259832382202,
0.6369515061378479,
-0.00035280041629448533,
-0.8403623104095459,
1.075910210609436,
-0.1316881775856018,
0.6108549237251282,
-0.5517414808273315,
0.15236946940422058,
-0.3157860040664673,
0.16216322779655457,
0.18220794200897217,
-0.3913141191005707,
0.24338404834270477,
-0.14854392409324646,
-0.10537217557430267,
0.12556017935276031,
0.5685386657714844,
-0.33360835909843445,
-0.5419055819511414,
0.40342286229133606,
0.3795049488544464,
0.1541168987751007,
0.38636836409568787,
-0.672631025314331,
0.4770381450653076,
0.27598121762275696,
-0.44166669249534607,
0.3179984986782074,
0.778056263923645,
0.014766897074878216,
0.8588236570358276,
0.9721274375915527,
0.4698818325996399,
0.1954842358827591,
0.0731167122721672,
1.1315232515335083,
-0.9127177000045776,
-0.92962646484375,
-1.0357433557510376,
0.23193953931331635,
-0.002590036019682884,
-0.3502330780029297,
0.6750396490097046,
0.3370683491230011,
0.4626854658126831,
0.06940039992332458,
0.7421521544456482,
0.1280246376991272,
0.4149051308631897,
-0.8445762395858765,
0.6648103594779968,
-0.5308467745780945,
0.26489052176475525,
-0.5614181756973267,
-1.0932570695877075,
-0.037238556891679764,
0.6490137577056885,
0.28520363569259644,
-0.2278841733932495,
1.1032756567001343,
0.6291248202323914,
0.19824092090129852,
0.20691920816898346,
0.25440922379493713,
0.3910406231880188,
0.24731087684631348,
0.11648684740066528,
0.733394205570221,
-0.053940217941999435,
0.13755707442760468,
-0.2505604326725006,
-0.24179990589618683,
-0.5043013691902161,
-0.8776696920394897,
-1.012877106666565,
-0.3055737316608429,
-0.2792038321495056,
-0.7043989300727844,
0.2811347544193268,
0.682813823223114,
0.5236576199531555,
-0.5395269989967346,
-0.14056994020938873,
-0.14501141011714935,
0.0896400660276413,
-0.4562639892101288,
-0.21537728607654572,
0.43200328946113586,
-0.4543352723121643,
-0.6734896302223206,
0.5895092487335205,
0.16633440554141998,
-0.07654355466365814,
-0.44627633690834045,
0.23450075089931488,
-0.40510618686676025,
0.5406903028488159,
0.5621403455734253,
0.23384980857372284,
-0.6991241574287415,
-0.10768724977970123,
-0.08047305792570114,
0.047972217202186584,
-0.27476438879966736,
0.9730343818664551,
-1.0126756429672241,
0.4382166266441345,
0.60322505235672,
0.6302944421768188,
0.7587733864784241,
0.12624578177928925,
0.6511414647102356,
-0.5123841166496277,
0.7329696416854858,
0.27025896310806274,
0.04562864080071449,
-0.4596625566482544,
-0.5493177771568298,
0.4638005197048187,
0.3772386610507965,
-0.403575599193573,
-1.3146604299545288,
0.27963992953300476,
-1.037869930267334,
-0.5244712829589844,
1.220720648765564,
0.1136973574757576,
-0.2655714154243469,
-0.21984218060970306,
-0.13537254929542542,
0.05088808387517929,
-0.766542375087738,
1.004541277885437,
0.48898032307624817,
-0.02490297146141529,
-0.37638041377067566,
-0.6016976237297058,
0.7778183221817017,
0.38147929310798645,
-0.5417206287384033,
0.3203525245189667,
0.46747714281082153,
-0.12698206305503845,
0.26571643352508545,
0.7560054063796997,
0.09817896038293839,
0.18567045032978058,
0.3553912341594696,
-0.17094798386096954,
0.09805670380592346,
-0.5467680096626282,
0.13705910742282867,
0.2240351438522339,
-0.09020335972309113,
0.08750517666339874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04296v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04296v1
|
Open Implementation and Study of BEST-RQ for Speech Processing
| 2024-05-07T13:11:37 | 2024-05-07T13:11:37 |
Ryan Whetten, Titouan Parcollet, Marco Dinarelli, Yannick Estève
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Self-Supervised Learning (SSL) has proven to be useful in various speech
tasks. However, these methods are generally very demanding in terms of data,
memory, and computational resources. BERT-based Speech pre-Training with
Random-projection Quantizer (BEST-RQ), is an SSL method that has shown great
performance on Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) while being simpler than
other SSL methods, such as wav2vec 2.0. Despite BEST-RQ's great performance,
details are lacking in the original paper, such as the amount of GPU/TPU hours
used in pre-training, and there is no official easy-to-use open-source
implementation. Furthermore, BEST-RQ has not been evaluated on other downstream
tasks aside from ASR and speech translation. In this work, we describe a
re-implementation of a Random-projection quantizer and perform a preliminary
study with a comparison to wav2vec 2.0 on four downstream tasks. We discuss the
details and differences of our implementation. We show that a random projection
quantizer can achieve similar downstream performance as wav2vec 2.0 while
decreasing training time by over a factor of two.
|
[
-0.21987642347812653,
-0.3441162109375,
0.3528881072998047,
0.15845243632793427,
-0.4986112713813782,
0.03632688894867897,
-0.1803034245967865,
-0.4312587380409241,
-0.0201247651129961,
0.03105918876826763,
-0.5252081155776978,
-0.44087499380111694,
-0.5377143025398254,
-0.06272492557764053,
-0.4783758223056793,
0.8166868090629578,
0.2640155255794525,
0.364427387714386,
0.084598109126091,
-0.01103337574750185,
0.015806635841727257,
-0.7633205056190491,
-0.710785984992981,
-0.07592249661684036,
0.30300211906433105,
0.16876156628131866,
0.31196749210357666,
0.2750924229621887,
0.6245957612991333,
0.2874607443809509,
0.10304833203554153,
-0.07255440205335617,
-0.6207038760185242,
0.01699657179415226,
-0.048629388213157654,
-0.08932485431432724,
-0.1837914139032364,
-0.014210197143256664,
0.837342381477356,
0.09337655454874039,
-0.6180937886238098,
0.3895971179008484,
0.06379960477352142,
0.7152997851371765,
-0.8457523584365845,
0.0980735719203949,
-0.5923749804496765,
0.19042007625102997,
-0.4185468554496765,
-0.26098135113716125,
-0.4899957478046417,
-0.3936389684677124,
0.2422458529472351,
-0.5721986889839172,
0.28536054491996765,
-0.024493981152772903,
0.8324941396713257,
0.5992463827133179,
-0.31114184856414795,
-0.1255984902381897,
-1.0797224044799805,
1.0597056150436401,
-0.5533192753791809,
0.7431142926216125,
0.3605826497077942,
0.5829116106033325,
0.010536798276007175,
-1.0223017930984497,
-0.37294378876686096,
0.012937898747622967,
0.290627658367157,
0.33626851439476013,
-0.46926677227020264,
0.3291332423686981,
0.19833339750766754,
0.442972868680954,
-0.6316518187522888,
-0.05072162300348282,
-0.46201667189598083,
-0.39063653349876404,
0.5149375796318054,
-0.21339361369609833,
-0.2895548939704895,
-0.06966497749090195,
-0.35785892605781555,
-0.32547619938850403,
-0.5552850961685181,
0.18603016436100006,
0.08096359670162201,
0.26028555631637573,
0.13813404738903046,
0.30196887254714966,
-0.30496999621391296,
0.6456335186958313,
-0.04751955717802048,
0.15672019124031067,
0.34291523694992065,
-0.09622768312692642,
-0.2561872601509094,
-0.04318094253540039,
0.8951841592788696,
-0.279920756816864,
0.2933200001716614,
0.08333270996809006,
-0.37819936871528625,
-0.2723829746246338,
0.24409888684749603,
-0.461752712726593,
-0.41582897305488586,
0.2494216412305832,
-0.6040067672729492,
0.014901148155331612,
-0.28981906175613403,
0.01202085055410862,
0.2684709131717682,
-0.3364078104496002,
0.6036893725395203,
-0.5857580900192261,
-0.06701099127531052,
-0.41091668605804443,
-0.08202552050352097,
0.4079412519931793,
0.26908448338508606,
-0.8172453045845032,
0.2959849238395691,
0.6433636546134949,
0.7669326066970825,
-0.11632522195577621,
-0.01731945015490055,
-0.9478527903556824,
0.0511978343129158,
-0.3429376780986786,
0.769088625907898,
-0.17538893222808838,
-0.29607653617858887,
-0.08943536132574081,
-0.6576342582702637,
0.028072187677025795,
-0.4414208233356476,
0.8488994836807251,
-0.6125602126121521,
0.35430431365966797,
-0.14742864668369293,
-0.6512110829353333,
0.12020611017942429,
-0.4356967508792877,
-0.35392478108406067,
0.9294410347938538,
0.21830585598945618,
-0.6846821308135986,
0.4517423212528229,
-0.3913128674030304,
-0.36957797408103943,
0.21578441560268402,
-0.1333673596382141,
-0.427776038646698,
0.20937439799308777,
0.22124038636684418,
0.2061108946800232,
0.017363792285323143,
-0.05469999834895134,
-0.08734802901744843,
-0.6454502940177917,
0.10479956120252609,
-0.2839549481868744,
0.8950443267822266,
0.7733900547027588,
-0.17735596001148224,
0.324103444814682,
-0.917657196521759,
0.4712637960910797,
-0.15769141912460327,
-0.15878558158874512,
-0.2834683954715729,
0.26772376894950867,
0.0780511125922203,
0.06773641705513,
0.28601303696632385,
-0.789604663848877,
-0.2599240243434906,
-0.34549301862716675,
0.600313663482666,
0.7609955668449402,
-0.19629788398742676,
0.20605050027370453,
-0.061009135097265244,
0.1203266978263855,
-0.38733968138694763,
0.5108751654624939,
0.3484050929546356,
-0.5664427876472473,
-0.6624248027801514,
-0.49610435962677,
0.618196964263916,
0.4099721610546112,
-0.6267104744911194,
0.13521400094032288,
0.08990319073200226,
-0.24443991482257843,
-1.0284823179244995,
-0.09785344451665878,
0.7215796113014221,
0.4129699170589447,
0.5112181901931763,
-0.3671583831310272,
-0.8401554822921753,
-0.9765072464942932,
-0.23145215213298798,
-0.39113667607307434,
-0.30345016717910767,
0.017588157206773758,
-0.01673652045428753,
0.2140827775001526,
0.9800300002098083,
-0.3365108072757721,
-0.653577983379364,
-0.005198856815695763,
0.4357159733772278,
0.042641621083021164,
0.5339788794517517,
0.28099921345710754,
-0.7043387293815613,
-0.5402972102165222,
-0.4712630808353424,
-0.48181813955307007,
0.10949396342039108,
0.2120898813009262,
-0.009592647664248943,
0.35607877373695374,
0.2052667886018753,
-0.18488916754722595,
0.3989699184894562,
0.7502446174621582,
0.31807413697242737,
0.41179177165031433,
-0.452832967042923,
0.06969953328371048,
-0.716633677482605,
-0.08418180048465729,
-0.027390766888856888,
-0.22409330308437347,
-0.8578373789787292,
0.11027957499027252,
0.13108588755130768,
-0.10850037634372711,
-0.6008251905441284,
0.17580854892730713,
-0.08798301219940186,
-0.40412086248397827,
-0.21471090614795685,
-0.13010857999324799,
-0.41316136717796326,
0.3658876121044159,
0.4392278790473938,
1.0184543132781982,
0.3862397372722626,
-0.5629964470863342,
0.00451870309188962,
0.12655040621757507,
-0.44560620188713074,
0.016365187242627144,
-0.683922529220581,
0.48727452754974365,
0.04567869007587433,
0.22339394688606262,
-1.0015429258346558,
-0.031708694994449615,
0.11221496015787125,
-0.8904021382331848,
0.23609137535095215,
-0.06584563106298447,
-0.3333585858345032,
-0.4510979950428009,
-0.16255369782447815,
0.3435623049736023,
0.9946959614753723,
-0.6479848027229309,
0.40849605202674866,
0.35952746868133545,
0.00893322005867958,
-0.6597535610198975,
-0.798823893070221,
-0.2112772911787033,
0.1491856724023819,
-0.4525328278541565,
0.3758334219455719,
-0.03061399795114994,
-0.02314189076423645,
-0.06716954708099365,
-0.06664665043354034,
-0.4265124499797821,
-0.21807371079921722,
0.03904448449611664,
-0.03080848418176174,
-0.08764774352312088,
-0.01790747232735157,
-0.02912476286292076,
-0.19463814795017242,
0.04429921507835388,
-0.3302568197250366,
0.19958029687404633,
-0.25040796399116516,
-0.293136328458786,
-0.9853857755661011,
0.2729934751987457,
0.02337094396352768,
-0.3913801610469818,
0.4095704257488251,
0.7064950466156006,
-0.17719261348247528,
-0.22537216544151306,
-0.6866823434829712,
-0.013276485726237297,
-0.5209971070289612,
0.18604423105716705,
-0.51919025182724,
-1.035751461982727,
0.2491433024406433,
0.20126132667064667,
0.1481381356716156,
0.39346712827682495,
0.5328227877616882,
-0.7407444715499878,
0.96024489402771,
0.5271755456924438,
0.10783106833696365,
0.7805347442626953,
-0.26751455664634705,
0.10026058554649353,
-0.8298207521438599,
-0.023900622501969337,
-0.45065799355506897,
0.003152230754494667,
-0.4865979552268982,
-0.5662078857421875,
0.3247582018375397,
-0.04485044628381729,
-0.26763173937797546,
0.14068269729614258,
-0.691608190536499,
0.07118158042430878,
1.0532912015914917,
0.02485492452979088,
0.18744030594825745,
0.24283172190189362,
-0.0012364827562123537,
-0.19688959419727325,
-0.7713882327079773,
-0.16229228675365448,
1.144892930984497,
0.2503119111061096,
0.6458832025527954,
-0.17444051802158356,
1.135474443435669,
0.46704068779945374,
0.0176540594547987,
-0.5740498304367065,
0.45933103561401367,
-0.5014269351959229,
-0.4284152686595917,
-0.706484854221344,
-0.5613714456558228,
-0.8069543838500977,
0.2512068748474121,
-0.09715079516172409,
-0.48893675208091736,
-0.013083916157484055,
0.592108964920044,
-0.4265708923339844,
0.13237133622169495,
-0.6644004583358765,
0.3081500232219696,
-0.040421392768621445,
-0.21925990283489227,
-0.5082286596298218,
-0.7022683024406433,
0.1697281301021576,
-0.011608256958425045,
0.2054251879453659,
0.0893746018409729,
0.36573097109794617,
0.8649978637695312,
-0.5415077209472656,
0.27762386202812195,
-0.641633152961731,
-0.001303573022596538,
0.8367648124694824,
-0.24916401505470276,
0.42201218008995056,
-0.2822577953338623,
-0.03111572377383709,
0.41358649730682373,
0.07917606830596924,
-0.35982784628868103,
-0.5169717073440552,
0.34273409843444824,
-0.9333114624023438,
-0.5329765677452087,
-0.6759769916534424,
-0.17014367878437042,
-0.3134703040122986,
-0.07426487654447556,
0.3538062870502472,
0.38245147466659546,
-0.2951417863368988,
0.2536306083202362,
0.5963903069496155,
-0.2115766555070877,
0.378536194562912,
0.521949291229248,
0.08221716433763504,
-0.5920893549919128,
1.1395610570907593,
0.17539839446544647,
0.20402181148529053,
0.6997897028923035,
0.3226037919521332,
-0.45670458674430847,
-0.798055112361908,
-0.3055156469345093,
-0.02671576477587223,
-0.244182288646698,
-0.021317047998309135,
-0.37311241030693054,
-0.691923975944519,
-0.6401041746139526,
0.18992184102535248,
-0.7096631526947021,
-0.6933512091636658,
-0.1536894589662552,
0.1453002542257309,
0.10731009393930435,
0.37867745757102966,
-0.6977854371070862,
0.2163369506597519,
-0.6933608651161194,
0.4799751043319702,
0.6547530293464661,
0.13610322773456573,
0.03637482225894928,
-0.663445234298706,
-0.3068857789039612,
0.18145377933979034,
-0.08523931354284286,
-0.20129084587097168,
0.3460916578769684,
0.5569521188735962,
0.44988369941711426,
0.4015025496482849,
0.20378077030181885,
0.7873049974441528,
-0.6185395121574402,
0.7506698966026306,
0.18399852514266968,
-1.053737759590149,
0.7478832006454468,
-0.14488691091537476,
0.2967844009399414,
0.5193979740142822,
0.2982761859893799,
-0.16968382894992828,
-0.5520725250244141,
-0.3907524347305298,
-0.6736198663711548,
0.6926206350326538,
0.7586221694946289,
-0.2604740858078003,
0.14393919706344604,
0.22476759552955627,
-0.07438712567090988,
0.13521064817905426,
-0.420326828956604,
-0.2544673681259155,
-0.4865424335002899,
-0.051161374896764755,
-0.1565408557653427,
-0.4405490458011627,
0.00039418478263542056,
-0.2581290304660797,
0.6230289936065674,
0.2263074368238449,
0.7391428351402283,
0.3387662172317505,
-0.05394268035888672,
-0.18197643756866455,
0.3649369180202484,
0.4419342279434204,
0.46174126863479614,
-0.6930139660835266,
-0.14082607626914978,
0.19567377865314484,
-0.48852434754371643,
-0.013198955915868282,
0.004991116467863321,
-0.17974595725536346,
-0.08473532646894455,
0.3625265657901764,
0.7224937081336975,
0.15927976369857788,
-0.5227497816085815,
0.6078891754150391,
-0.359526127576828,
-0.4028923213481903,
-0.5936325192451477,
0.08493311703205109,
-0.2753899097442627,
0.36338749527931213,
0.7383274435997009,
-0.10230159759521484,
0.5472254753112793,
-0.35986822843551636,
0.3910483717918396,
0.3787388205528259,
-0.3674803078174591,
-0.13166852295398712,
0.8551791310310364,
0.15582729876041412,
-0.42652806639671326,
0.9390851855278015,
-0.20413291454315186,
-0.2851424813270569,
0.229519322514534,
0.47285962104797363,
0.9489516615867615,
-0.6038569211959839,
0.09435129910707474,
0.3802778124809265,
-0.017490271478891373,
0.20176979899406433,
0.7634583711624146,
-0.509245753288269,
-0.45965251326560974,
-0.845154881477356,
-0.6086544394493103,
-0.530368447303772,
-0.21535003185272217,
-1.125138521194458,
-0.040321145206689835,
-0.3230435848236084,
-0.35638755559921265,
-0.27861252427101135,
-0.12104232609272003,
-0.6157393455505371,
0.36092451214790344,
0.3402308523654938,
0.7240239381790161,
-0.41214004158973694,
1.4045233726501465,
0.48965373635292053,
-0.050667211413383484,
-0.8510076999664307,
-0.12884679436683655,
-0.1322149634361267,
-0.8391913771629333,
0.9058678150177002,
-0.40079933404922485,
-0.3909272849559784,
0.30510780215263367,
-0.4106655418872833,
-1.1039317846298218,
0.9860436320304871,
0.2571619153022766,
-0.8413681387901306,
-0.18780279159545898,
0.10656572133302689,
0.8356059193611145,
0.1373818963766098,
0.246922105550766,
0.17654019594192505,
0.029338840395212173,
0.3666757643222809,
-1.019167423248291,
-0.428103506565094,
0.05776732414960861,
0.17181310057640076,
-0.0651034265756607,
-0.9988876581192017,
0.7166987657546997,
-0.3569309413433075,
-0.318008691072464,
0.2482939511537552,
1.2360659837722778,
0.4487796127796173,
0.39329710602760315,
0.5694580078125,
0.5922641158103943,
0.7702252864837646,
-0.05940654128789902,
0.7808027267456055,
-0.3580052852630615,
0.5665895342826843,
1.4142999649047852,
-0.0922083705663681,
1.4330980777740479,
0.41078612208366394,
-0.4427414834499359,
0.35759425163269043,
0.5722764730453491,
0.07839551568031311,
1.1171408891677856,
0.24442560970783234,
-0.23937183618545532,
-0.1714128702878952,
0.03364516794681549,
-0.4754349887371063,
0.48490941524505615,
0.19155366718769073,
-0.13059723377227783,
0.0016610728343948722,
0.13755151629447937,
-0.6908613443374634,
-0.2627350986003876,
-0.3377305865287781,
0.7171539068222046,
0.34591925144195557,
-0.3402003049850464,
0.6663826704025269,
-0.10717729479074478,
0.4967075288295746,
-0.8229937553405762,
-0.08442071825265884,
0.04613086208701134,
0.10102535784244537,
-0.16173787415027618,
-0.5648804903030396,
0.32217171788215637,
0.18251165747642517,
0.04467584192752838,
-0.5162647366523743,
0.6687508225440979,
-0.1999475508928299,
-0.08401792496442795,
0.24266107380390167,
0.31492799520492554,
0.3702757954597473,
-0.028646431863307953,
-0.5388049483299255,
0.014313294552266598,
0.18221546709537506,
-0.1398312747478485,
0.4388178884983063,
0.2962806522846222,
0.2987995445728302,
0.7508301734924316,
0.577909529209137,
0.17148849368095398,
0.34041541814804077,
0.29581889510154724,
0.6392397284507751,
-0.5367064476013184,
-0.5436017513275146,
-0.2958014905452728,
0.27026569843292236,
0.14979088306427002,
-0.2888721227645874,
0.720518946647644,
0.7254678010940552,
1.161204218864441,
-0.014931656420230865,
0.674372136592865,
-0.06535468995571136,
0.7857771515846252,
-0.5777558088302612,
0.58942711353302,
-0.4733986258506775,
-0.0006840711575932801,
-0.3812435567378998,
-0.7832402586936951,
-0.12954211235046387,
1.0694900751113892,
-0.21703621745109558,
-0.09500346332788467,
0.8510094881057739,
0.33938053250312805,
0.2576890289783478,
0.17807413637638092,
0.38282883167266846,
0.1849754899740219,
0.2732071876525879,
0.6548612117767334,
0.981033980846405,
-0.3657311201095581,
0.68796706199646,
-0.5102812647819519,
-0.2751372158527374,
-0.018259312957525253,
-0.4800930917263031,
-0.5891625881195068,
-0.8862392902374268,
-0.44201111793518066,
-0.1371920108795166,
0.5966721177101135,
0.8416558504104614,
0.9326567649841309,
-1.0153052806854248,
-0.34685519337654114,
-0.11104915291070938,
-0.2866913676261902,
-0.33379310369491577,
-0.18345968425273895,
0.560928225517273,
-0.44684380292892456,
-0.6970869302749634,
0.5497461557388306,
0.08168310672044754,
-0.17731399834156036,
-0.07387012243270874,
-0.19368058443069458,
0.06263444572687149,
-0.24211034178733826,
0.6065514087677002,
0.4272260367870331,
-0.7002274394035339,
-0.39015209674835205,
-0.32338449358940125,
-0.03735317662358284,
0.292206346988678,
0.8598763942718506,
-0.9521146416664124,
0.6472824215888977,
0.3536430299282074,
0.3251359164714813,
0.8342467546463013,
0.23599432408809662,
0.5464239716529846,
-0.605218768119812,
-0.07710832357406616,
0.5730583667755127,
0.10529104620218277,
0.003340800991281867,
-0.1555163562297821,
0.5101998448371887,
-0.03672926872968674,
-0.7836857438087463,
-0.6649890542030334,
0.03642193228006363,
-1.0416157245635986,
0.03731520473957062,
0.927078127861023,
-0.16502191126346588,
-0.03375371918082237,
0.051505185663700104,
0.008273199200630188,
0.6019662618637085,
-0.8069978356361389,
0.82077556848526,
0.47682154178619385,
-0.6320755481719971,
-0.1245446428656578,
-0.33455008268356323,
0.619179368019104,
0.38140347599983215,
-0.21712958812713623,
-0.21668073534965515,
0.2886272370815277,
0.2578895390033722,
-0.1446855515241623,
0.9882426261901855,
-0.10174710303544998,
0.21335355937480927,
0.05442359670996666,
0.25134217739105225,
-0.13397721946239471,
-0.3178291320800781,
-0.5099992752075195,
0.2677918076515198,
0.28840839862823486,
-0.5477675199508667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04292v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04292v1
|
Mitigating Clickbait: An Approach to Spoiler Generation Using Multitask Learning
| 2024-05-07T13:09:25 | 2024-05-07T13:09:25 |
Sayantan Pal, Souvik Das, Rohini K. Srihari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study introduces 'clickbait spoiling', a novel technique designed to
detect, categorize, and generate spoilers as succinct text responses,
countering the curiosity induced by clickbait content. By leveraging a
multi-task learning framework, our model's generalization capabilities are
significantly enhanced, effectively addressing the pervasive issue of
clickbait. The crux of our research lies in generating appropriate spoilers, be
it a phrase, an extended passage, or multiple, depending on the spoiler type
required. Our methodology integrates two crucial techniques: a refined spoiler
categorization method and a modified version of the Question Answering (QA)
mechanism, incorporated within a multi-task learning paradigm for optimized
spoiler extraction from context. Notably, we have included fine-tuning methods
for models capable of handling longer sequences to accommodate the generation
of extended spoilers. This research highlights the potential of sophisticated
text processing techniques in tackling the omnipresent issue of clickbait,
promising an enhanced user experience in the digital realm.
|
[
-0.36905330419540405,
-0.7275840640068054,
0.5094984173774719,
0.1683272421360016,
-0.4660213887691498,
0.05372856929898262,
0.055607300251722336,
-0.3000258505344391,
0.3730367124080658,
0.4740116596221924,
-1.0455247163772583,
-0.1651201695203781,
-0.4967273771762848,
0.33060529828071594,
-0.09880490601062775,
1.546311855316162,
0.25756555795669556,
-0.05283091589808464,
-0.6866009831428528,
0.4408308267593384,
-0.43212324380874634,
-0.35622891783714294,
-0.9435831904411316,
0.04182128608226776,
0.9496375918388367,
0.42269113659858704,
0.453291118144989,
0.6868096590042114,
0.42166444659233093,
0.15643171966075897,
0.05567575618624687,
0.3754686415195465,
-0.7293351292610168,
0.3368166983127594,
-0.14160357415676117,
-0.3375600576400757,
-0.22469381988048553,
0.030226869508624077,
0.21493761241436005,
0.30232536792755127,
0.07194000482559204,
0.2628013789653778,
0.1822173297405243,
0.6649847030639648,
-0.9847122430801392,
0.2154572755098343,
-0.4617997705936432,
0.0006013524834997952,
-0.20235340297222137,
-0.7104940414428711,
-0.5772178173065186,
-0.1548195779323578,
0.13715268671512604,
-0.8714905977249146,
0.424778014421463,
0.11811050027608871,
0.5125406384468079,
0.7637627720832825,
-0.5802233219146729,
-0.15711058676242828,
-0.7017372846603394,
0.8944782614707947,
-0.511996328830719,
0.15176180005073547,
0.30102428793907166,
0.17217706143856049,
0.0008638969738967717,
-0.5657925605773926,
-0.45308542251586914,
-0.08756851404905319,
0.03412103280425072,
0.31558191776275635,
0.242404967546463,
-0.07326662540435791,
0.32205915451049805,
0.04006287828087807,
-0.7689341306686401,
-0.07132886350154877,
-0.38243263959884644,
-0.2315569669008255,
0.5518710613250732,
0.3211606442928314,
0.42792680859565735,
-0.42148420214653015,
-0.782763659954071,
-0.08400943875312805,
-0.46715590357780457,
0.3109274208545685,
0.6174567341804504,
0.10431431233882904,
0.3444686830043793,
0.19479377567768097,
-0.397329717874527,
0.4759071171283722,
0.15285556018352509,
-0.18257521092891693,
0.0804578885436058,
-0.494750440120697,
0.03483780100941658,
0.008950087241828442,
0.6581135988235474,
0.8126277923583984,
0.18554991483688354,
-0.20146560668945312,
0.25554654002189636,
0.10624660551548004,
0.7802432179450989,
-0.8068767786026001,
-0.25214481353759766,
0.42414677143096924,
-0.5373467206954956,
-0.6309171319007874,
0.10568291693925858,
-1.1178430318832397,
-0.5028795599937439,
-0.12975436449050903,
0.282349556684494,
-0.3312762975692749,
-0.10156489163637161,
-0.18953755497932434,
-0.46209055185317993,
0.09356957674026489,
0.34066838026046753,
-0.81244295835495,
0.16088633239269257,
0.35256004333496094,
0.3440370559692383,
-0.6174975633621216,
-0.5134367942810059,
-0.639065146446228,
0.3576255440711975,
-0.13746678829193115,
1.1043891906738281,
-0.6395853161811829,
-0.2715505361557007,
-0.10985350608825684,
0.06626288592815399,
-0.1941916048526764,
-0.3107183277606964,
0.7048651576042175,
-0.8491935729980469,
0.18082046508789062,
-0.44266679883003235,
-0.27303221821784973,
-0.6588594317436218,
0.5010919570922852,
-0.9220029711723328,
0.836015522480011,
-0.46382907032966614,
-0.840002715587616,
0.714735746383667,
-0.9464669823646545,
-0.5659894943237305,
0.013443888165056705,
0.22273516654968262,
-0.46161070466041565,
0.04530749097466469,
0.5109928250312805,
0.47527530789375305,
-0.14082768559455872,
0.23278705775737762,
-0.005354394670575857,
-0.3446487784385681,
0.28354182839393616,
-0.5244409441947937,
0.005236300639808178,
0.09048821032047272,
-0.24155662953853607,
0.3230505585670471,
-0.0842766985297203,
-0.07329186797142029,
0.25840359926223755,
-0.7035485506057739,
-0.40143129229545593,
0.2703508138656616,
0.204170823097229,
0.42739537358283997,
0.4438494145870209,
-0.3963276147842407,
0.13284586369991302,
-0.2907032072544098,
-0.004405337385833263,
0.41252341866493225,
0.2892596125602722,
0.24789884686470032,
-0.6309354901313782,
0.6625893712043762,
0.31971320509910583,
0.5107434988021851,
-0.7772075533866882,
-0.47589895129203796,
-0.5041511058807373,
0.2001892775297165,
0.26661762595176697,
0.4650292694568634,
-0.8907174468040466,
-0.01142245251685381,
-0.14688768982887268,
-0.28979530930519104,
-0.24259774386882782,
-0.008271120488643646,
0.6048593521118164,
0.21727406978607178,
0.7066192626953125,
-0.16136962175369263,
-0.3397941291332245,
-0.5947733521461487,
-0.5906763672828674,
0.5022422075271606,
0.08736280351877213,
0.07170616090297699,
0.5831735134124756,
0.07695164531469345,
0.8610498905181885,
-0.8074635863304138,
-0.3651774823665619,
-0.2793147563934326,
0.20694425702095032,
-0.39378249645233154,
0.3958384096622467,
0.3301307260990143,
-1.4829049110412598,
-0.6636641621589661,
-0.3649420738220215,
-0.7262924313545227,
0.3080853819847107,
-0.17629152536392212,
0.3619026839733124,
0.05022373050451279,
0.6598141193389893,
-0.4235714077949524,
0.5638989806175232,
0.08998319506645203,
-0.27665576338768005,
0.9914494752883911,
-0.0038053051102906466,
0.4911681115627289,
-1.1591148376464844,
0.0680423304438591,
-0.005240431521087885,
-0.03466132655739784,
-0.770430862903595,
0.13814346492290497,
0.13347093760967255,
-0.12264332920312881,
-0.6455544233322144,
0.49873581528663635,
-0.400454044342041,
0.4980427622795105,
-0.636551558971405,
0.00932485144585371,
0.07585795968770981,
0.7179367542266846,
0.05514600872993469,
0.7786679863929749,
0.16182072460651398,
-0.7479365468025208,
0.13557401299476624,
0.14960017800331116,
0.33411574363708496,
0.5060760974884033,
-0.3653896450996399,
0.05657064542174339,
-0.5409670472145081,
0.3962663412094116,
-1.1426652669906616,
-0.4425950348377228,
0.46956202387809753,
-0.5557571649551392,
0.13929776847362518,
-0.25047069787979126,
-0.5290266871452332,
-0.36505380272865295,
-0.8399727940559387,
0.4984804391860962,
0.06699473410844803,
-0.29709094762802124,
0.6727749705314636,
0.15377920866012573,
-0.5948123931884766,
-0.69542396068573,
-0.14406676590442657,
-0.08637697994709015,
-0.3843802809715271,
-0.2470187097787857,
0.32536816596984863,
-0.5460970401763916,
0.3414001166820526,
-0.16326582431793213,
-0.25984978675842285,
-0.10923252254724503,
0.08294884115457535,
0.3275487422943115,
0.054137665778398514,
0.1950986087322235,
0.19677706062793732,
0.48936498165130615,
-0.41532862186431885,
0.11870834976434708,
-0.12978066504001617,
0.557925283908844,
0.5274363160133362,
-0.26288270950317383,
-0.4612894654273987,
0.642235279083252,
0.6087815165519714,
-0.5287559628486633,
0.7078644037246704,
0.7879824042320251,
-0.31238746643066406,
-0.2705551087856293,
-0.5190111994743347,
-0.49779269099235535,
-0.45225125551223755,
0.23861180245876312,
-0.30490198731422424,
-0.6150401830673218,
0.39585769176483154,
-0.4194529056549072,
-0.10384897142648697,
0.575402021408081,
0.1846097707748413,
0.032955072820186615,
1.1995315551757812,
0.9396912455558777,
0.09302949160337448,
0.35482481122016907,
-0.0510936863720417,
0.14406608045101166,
-0.9382860660552979,
-0.47223711013793945,
-0.28237006068229675,
-0.37748003005981445,
-0.38965660333633423,
-0.3986847698688507,
0.4036208987236023,
-0.031593408435583115,
0.1100219264626503,
0.19675087928771973,
-0.517536997795105,
0.7589377164840698,
0.7205987572669983,
0.25567370653152466,
0.4784500300884247,
-0.16774797439575195,
-0.2726564109325409,
-0.07522812485694885,
-0.4401577413082123,
-0.42685064673423767,
1.2676682472229004,
0.07366558909416199,
0.6737970113754272,
-0.018458569422364235,
0.6016744375228882,
0.4692891538143158,
0.026548558846116066,
-0.634647011756897,
0.34065425395965576,
-0.12908457219600677,
-0.7564741969108582,
-0.32064783573150635,
-0.18827080726623535,
-0.926796555519104,
0.14022690057754517,
-0.18011774122714996,
-0.770660936832428,
-0.1458713561296463,
-0.018369607627391815,
-0.6536386013031006,
0.22437076270580292,
-0.6197760701179504,
1.056416392326355,
-0.13834066689014435,
-0.42719823122024536,
-0.3474962115287781,
-0.7313348650932312,
0.26680004596710205,
-0.2156228870153427,
0.11460491269826889,
0.07838821411132812,
-0.2073218673467636,
1.0231908559799194,
0.12405736744403839,
1.0694350004196167,
-0.0630057156085968,
0.12656480073928833,
0.1436743140220642,
0.3479684591293335,
0.3268512785434723,
0.20038506388664246,
0.2665484547615051,
-0.2625398635864258,
-0.008584038354456425,
-0.5017430782318115,
-0.2906748950481415,
0.6103995442390442,
-0.38421982526779175,
-0.31131279468536377,
-0.5715290904045105,
-0.8331873416900635,
-0.11743389070034027,
0.4215568006038666,
0.4270137548446655,
0.35201317071914673,
-0.16290099918842316,
-0.06622239947319031,
0.800081729888916,
-0.19134877622127533,
0.8434761166572571,
0.5447865724563599,
0.0672445073723793,
-0.3598996698856354,
1.0770385265350342,
-0.2005985677242279,
0.04524882882833481,
0.5124226808547974,
0.2577037513256073,
-0.4926955997943878,
-0.6396811008453369,
-0.3321778476238251,
0.2597103416919708,
-0.5719907283782959,
-0.2443688064813614,
-0.905086874961853,
-0.03998333588242531,
-0.28428009152412415,
-0.09796645492315292,
-0.03926006332039833,
0.13192960619926453,
-0.4440397024154663,
-0.13007137179374695,
0.28528037667274475,
1.109026551246643,
0.17099668085575104,
0.40235504508018494,
-1.0624971389770508,
0.4871876537799835,
0.28392618894577026,
0.059974826872348785,
0.21994909644126892,
-0.004205825738608837,
-0.33535075187683105,
-0.14812114834785461,
-0.8267669677734375,
-0.9294200539588928,
0.3311641216278076,
-0.05568293109536171,
0.5092937350273132,
0.756502628326416,
0.48323312401771545,
0.3128419518470764,
-0.4065290689468384,
1.0979478359222412,
0.21058721840381622,
-0.6684318780899048,
0.5974845886230469,
-0.6480077505111694,
0.4452737271785736,
0.4975605607032776,
0.9236742258071899,
-0.5009153485298157,
-0.23316116631031036,
-0.6039506793022156,
-1.0332746505737305,
0.5399212837219238,
0.11284811794757843,
0.11368485540151596,
0.055954430252313614,
0.056372255086898804,
0.5335365533828735,
0.8685110807418823,
-0.7990157604217529,
-0.24848473072052002,
-0.061556749045848846,
0.017842289060354233,
-0.2582007646560669,
-0.5458276271820068,
0.07939797639846802,
0.16959472000598907,
0.47473832964897156,
-0.42061594128608704,
-0.029909463599324226,
0.02037452906370163,
-0.3585034906864166,
-0.05520503968000412,
0.287308931350708,
0.8296732306480408,
0.6991857290267944,
-0.1787741482257843,
-0.07109084725379944,
-0.23573026061058044,
-0.5717294812202454,
-0.11515257507562637,
0.3087581396102905,
-0.1956380158662796,
-0.3352457582950592,
0.14772307872772217,
0.4382801651954651,
0.41233521699905396,
-0.542921245098114,
0.46563372015953064,
-0.03603404387831688,
-0.01204441674053669,
-0.04139247164130211,
-0.04632560908794403,
0.042068976908922195,
0.019483288750052452,
0.7431108951568604,
0.2131156176328659,
0.4657781422138214,
-0.2239808738231659,
0.4209209382534027,
0.12663961946964264,
-0.23739120364189148,
-0.16861657798290253,
0.9813276529312134,
0.43702298402786255,
0.014831787906587124,
0.32682353258132935,
-0.3557411730289459,
-0.6216776967048645,
0.6403799653053284,
0.3366662263870239,
0.8284983038902283,
-0.42395904660224915,
0.36878150701522827,
0.2221975177526474,
0.25705793499946594,
0.07079821079969406,
0.3067563474178314,
-0.25201600790023804,
-0.4607613682746887,
-0.6793803572654724,
-0.6007040143013,
-0.4574167728424072,
0.12099970877170563,
-0.7349357008934021,
-0.049568966031074524,
-0.20266972482204437,
-0.12045235931873322,
0.14152319729328156,
0.013635189272463322,
-0.6329821348190308,
0.33976393938064575,
0.14451418817043304,
0.7460508942604065,
-0.9639800786972046,
0.27939799427986145,
0.8772137761116028,
-0.6962235569953918,
-0.4676017165184021,
0.7681748867034912,
0.13226135075092316,
-0.18846692144870758,
0.4249804615974426,
0.5792253017425537,
-0.08403701335191727,
0.1717870533466339,
-0.45057329535484314,
-0.6831412315368652,
0.7261478304862976,
-0.0873408317565918,
-0.04746043682098389,
-0.36048611998558044,
0.17130176723003387,
0.2567425072193146,
-0.0772496834397316,
0.39555197954177856,
0.3663523495197296,
0.54802006483078,
-0.12308172881603241,
-0.9123496413230896,
0.3409050703048706,
-0.2804858386516571,
-0.15515141189098358,
0.2226446270942688,
-0.5466977953910828,
0.6376431584358215,
-0.3521483242511749,
-0.030598875135183334,
0.07412740588188171,
0.2184351533651352,
0.022376712411642075,
0.6903620362281799,
0.40896841883659363,
0.5188595056533813,
0.4289259612560272,
-0.14596866071224213,
0.8655946850776672,
-0.11372226476669312,
0.3481743037700653,
0.898651123046875,
-0.10559097677469254,
0.6032450795173645,
0.5834671258926392,
0.16543787717819214,
0.5330869555473328,
0.6378081440925598,
0.11128392070531845,
0.7748289108276367,
0.13201968371868134,
-0.18251925706863403,
-0.4507065415382385,
-0.3441353142261505,
-0.06911084055900574,
0.3632851839065552,
0.34830525517463684,
-0.022463694214820862,
-0.5299527645111084,
0.49371907114982605,
0.24329453706741333,
0.13549496233463287,
-0.3579752743244171,
1.0553818941116333,
-0.12632744014263153,
-0.7093791365623474,
0.12429187446832657,
-0.18235957622528076,
0.9578849673271179,
-0.6704128384590149,
-0.08526702225208282,
0.0902513712644577,
-0.05550378933548927,
-0.3063328266143799,
-0.46374115347862244,
0.0774550661444664,
-0.2887211740016937,
-0.7030622363090515,
-0.15543830394744873,
0.7892417311668396,
-0.368074506521225,
-0.14860498905181885,
0.19827419519424438,
0.6451953053474426,
0.1515982449054718,
-0.6891001462936401,
-0.6784440279006958,
0.016274847090244293,
-0.09350939840078354,
-0.16091464459896088,
0.3342849016189575,
0.0701557919383049,
0.051358066499233246,
0.6739094257354736,
0.9264559745788574,
-0.2693030834197998,
0.13581344485282898,
-0.2103089839220047,
0.9186266660690308,
-0.8558948040008545,
-1.1333390474319458,
-0.5903735160827637,
0.9620072245597839,
-0.15317395329475403,
-0.14257025718688965,
0.8890892863273621,
0.6481838226318359,
0.781005322933197,
-0.7328205108642578,
0.9395123720169067,
0.16084475815296173,
0.5686662793159485,
-0.44659650325775146,
0.7409200668334961,
-0.7693458199501038,
-0.09951639920473099,
-0.38576003909111023,
-0.7248965501785278,
-0.11376164108514786,
-0.16250747442245483,
-0.33073750138282776,
0.3287319540977478,
1.0743017196655273,
0.32513293623924255,
-0.08282102644443512,
0.03702578693628311,
0.33923208713531494,
-0.28964802622795105,
0.11100403219461441,
0.4629545211791992,
0.808941662311554,
-0.41410472989082336,
0.7318581938743591,
-0.24627099931240082,
-0.1624232828617096,
-0.5765981078147888,
-0.9427191019058228,
-0.963935375213623,
-0.7497971653938293,
-0.3056168556213379,
0.1413990706205368,
0.12615159153938293,
0.39275991916656494,
0.7563740015029907,
-0.7630088329315186,
0.19882498681545258,
0.313890665769577,
0.1256195306777954,
-0.6433687210083008,
-0.36624667048454285,
0.30894649028778076,
-0.5157841444015503,
-0.900078296661377,
0.5940898060798645,
0.12527969479560852,
-0.18741336464881897,
-0.14582324028015137,
0.2329167276620865,
-0.30623120069503784,
0.12443613260984421,
0.6248331069946289,
0.19120681285858154,
-0.4778875708580017,
-0.005249495152384043,
0.17288872599601746,
0.28962042927742004,
-0.16925407946109772,
0.8879992961883545,
-0.9299606680870056,
0.3982647955417633,
0.4241463243961334,
0.4715566635131836,
0.2586953043937683,
0.3662513196468353,
0.42122605443000793,
-0.8631606101989746,
-0.26784569025039673,
0.13242566585540771,
-0.036312900483608246,
0.23307286202907562,
-0.8961336612701416,
0.07545840740203857,
0.16513517498970032,
-0.5893638730049133,
-0.60793137550354,
0.29578253626823425,
-0.9573065638542175,
-0.5090482831001282,
0.9500133991241455,
0.1356714367866516,
-0.07607239484786987,
-0.3656604588031769,
-0.24686340987682343,
0.4033161401748657,
-0.7474876046180725,
0.762203574180603,
0.41031843423843384,
-0.18610267341136932,
0.09863094240427017,
-0.6856813430786133,
0.8580967783927917,
0.21136808395385742,
-1.1250466108322144,
-0.11040130257606506,
0.2818281948566437,
0.6385277509689331,
0.5588191747665405,
0.3297158479690552,
0.10853928327560425,
0.583062469959259,
-0.13257859647274017,
0.0811476856470108,
-0.35074034333229065,
-0.9459308981895447,
-0.2937178909778595,
0.48437198996543884,
-0.34331098198890686,
-0.5398489236831665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04286v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04286v1
|
Who Wrote This? The Key to Zero-Shot LLM-Generated Text Detection Is GECScore
| 2024-05-07T12:57:01 | 2024-05-07T12:57:01 |
Junchao Wu, Runzhe Zhan, Derek F. Wong, Shu Yang, Xuebo Liu, Lidia S. Chao, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The efficacy of an large language model (LLM) generated text detector depends
substantially on the availability of sizable training data. White-box zero-shot
detectors, which require no such data, are nonetheless limited by the
accessibility of the source model of the LLM-generated text. In this paper, we
propose an simple but effective black-box zero-shot detection approach,
predicated on the observation that human-written texts typically contain more
grammatical errors than LLM-generated texts. This approach entails computing
the Grammar Error Correction Score (GECScore) for the given text to distinguish
between human-written and LLM-generated text. Extensive experimental results
show that our method outperforms current state-of-the-art (SOTA) zero-shot and
supervised methods, achieving an average AUROC of 98.7% and showing strong
robustness against paraphrase and adversarial perturbation attacks.
|
[
0.07342126220464706,
-0.9597049355506897,
0.9078536033630371,
-0.3739490211009979,
-0.16890347003936768,
0.08242201805114746,
-0.19646234810352325,
-0.40576788783073425,
-0.032305892556905746,
0.32794156670570374,
-0.47970065474510193,
-1.1345984935760498,
-0.57158362865448,
0.3049490749835968,
-0.557874321937561,
1.094653844833374,
0.11924721300601959,
-0.3924780488014221,
-0.12842661142349243,
0.22914564609527588,
-0.17184612154960632,
-0.6704895496368408,
-0.4786056876182556,
-0.21020862460136414,
0.35471057891845703,
0.6089071035385132,
0.34681078791618347,
0.5106777548789978,
0.14613433182239532,
0.14149071276187897,
-0.32883667945861816,
0.237627774477005,
-0.443336546421051,
0.0953824371099472,
-0.037620749324560165,
-0.4562769830226898,
-0.4535183012485504,
-0.2579018771648407,
0.49871209263801575,
-0.030779721215367317,
-0.028856340795755386,
0.07908029109239578,
-0.03716738149523735,
0.16269083321094513,
-0.9675250053405762,
-0.11636310815811157,
-0.8696932196617126,
0.22080518305301666,
-0.44968533515930176,
-0.3713623583316803,
-0.8069114685058594,
0.13964985311031342,
-0.6507728695869446,
-0.2594943344593048,
0.43351978063583374,
-0.3633072078227997,
0.7558900117874146,
-0.019653765484690666,
-0.2502650022506714,
-0.4680423140525818,
-0.6075747609138489,
0.7411981821060181,
-0.8574726581573486,
-0.15958532691001892,
0.2443428933620453,
0.05060607194900513,
-0.15809674561023712,
-0.20854054391384125,
-0.7560046315193176,
-0.195853590965271,
0.07127027213573456,
0.2968289852142334,
-0.46664416790008545,
0.04169772192835808,
0.24223853647708893,
0.23214095830917358,
-0.7381778359413147,
-0.045014411211013794,
-0.04313123598694801,
-0.35712212324142456,
0.4982832372188568,
0.10231872648000717,
0.5606590509414673,
-0.4009132981300354,
-0.008078469894826412,
0.1917143017053604,
-0.7142336368560791,
0.0022497072350233793,
0.43349382281303406,
0.2863699197769165,
0.01375188771635294,
0.624813437461853,
-0.42221733927726746,
0.7147639989852905,
-0.015346217900514603,
-0.3141620457172394,
0.0734676942229271,
-0.22946015000343323,
-0.2177659273147583,
0.3281063139438629,
0.9146022200584412,
0.2843898832798004,
0.46708962321281433,
-0.3612426519393921,
-0.11662407964468002,
0.5699918270111084,
0.2514100968837738,
-0.6915943622589111,
0.009483004920184612,
-0.03906949609518051,
0.09882893413305283,
-0.7731332182884216,
0.12035603821277618,
-0.4463602602481842,
-0.1815580278635025,
0.15429309010505676,
0.3187542259693146,
-0.16543664038181305,
0.12800341844558716,
0.2679603695869446,
0.000018915294276666827,
0.12105413526296616,
0.10544034838676453,
-0.808053195476532,
0.1744900345802307,
0.576109766960144,
0.8760808706283569,
0.06284746527671814,
-0.22031238675117493,
-0.8838837146759033,
0.2965486943721771,
-0.48883652687072754,
1.2937684059143066,
-0.2539199888706207,
-0.4794299900531769,
0.010170988738536835,
-0.1281188726425171,
0.26006975769996643,
-0.18757843971252441,
0.7660776972770691,
-0.13052445650100708,
0.06020749360322952,
-0.023800864815711975,
-0.47297754883766174,
0.12844091653823853,
0.40884098410606384,
-0.06904035806655884,
1.1068265438079834,
-0.07941530644893646,
-0.6379494071006775,
0.21736736595630646,
-0.3319756090641022,
-0.751592218875885,
0.21299830079078674,
-0.40416812896728516,
-0.6844438314437866,
0.3680957555770874,
0.5733356475830078,
0.6769905090332031,
-0.06892962008714676,
0.33445417881011963,
-0.2772181034088135,
-0.6476873159408569,
0.26832789182662964,
-0.602340579032898,
0.6199259161949158,
-0.0459880568087101,
-0.4737012982368469,
-0.21275515854358673,
-0.9006462097167969,
0.02896788716316223,
0.3076106011867523,
-0.34511885046958923,
-0.16576208174228668,
-0.011134269647300243,
-0.17204223573207855,
0.1864922195672989,
0.11377153545618057,
-0.9280877113342285,
-0.05719367414712906,
-0.29255741834640503,
0.1784113645553589,
0.6871331930160522,
0.07706564664840698,
0.40961697697639465,
-0.10146535933017731,
0.6745697855949402,
-0.24534223973751068,
-0.04663582146167755,
-0.591728150844574,
-0.4054412245750427,
-0.7374361753463745,
-0.20408950746059418,
0.04392467811703682,
0.7617530822753906,
-0.601327121257782,
0.6893279552459717,
0.001563997007906437,
-0.5543801188468933,
-0.25678980350494385,
0.37997162342071533,
0.8174625039100647,
0.6736400723457336,
0.32724571228027344,
-0.199466735124588,
-0.28874871134757996,
-0.640964150428772,
-0.47491082549095154,
-0.2512994706630707,
-0.059152815490961075,
0.3272388279438019,
0.4645277261734009,
-0.017938461154699326,
0.8086880445480347,
-0.9565615057945251,
-0.371035635471344,
-0.27428969740867615,
0.07411734759807587,
0.0884704738855362,
0.15432296693325043,
0.5461614727973938,
-0.019197789952158928,
-0.7239557504653931,
0.056424032896757126,
-1.1652114391326904,
-0.5732556581497192,
-0.06904253363609314,
-0.13727883994579315,
0.1839669644832611,
0.7639691829681396,
-0.4784259796142578,
0.5754116177558899,
0.4534801244735718,
-0.4531911611557007,
0.6598758101463318,
-0.21157623827457428,
0.07425329834222794,
-0.9589860439300537,
-0.08082281053066254,
0.2513035833835602,
-0.5721551775932312,
-0.774060845375061,
0.12521454691886902,
0.3018687963485718,
-0.3199447691440582,
-0.509066641330719,
0.40531662106513977,
-0.5389978885650635,
0.08682247996330261,
-0.34251269698143005,
0.26949313282966614,
0.1271604597568512,
0.506250262260437,
-0.2984353303909302,
0.7529025673866272,
0.447165310382843,
-0.25040268898010254,
-0.046703584492206573,
0.12863458693027496,
-0.18649333715438843,
1.0256314277648926,
-0.6281297206878662,
0.4484221041202545,
-0.28135359287261963,
0.17803499102592468,
-1.0645661354064941,
-0.1696670800447464,
0.24000389873981476,
-0.7314243912696838,
0.3469861149787903,
-0.1360636055469513,
-0.5406623482704163,
-0.10488872975111008,
-0.4550389349460602,
0.05255906283855438,
0.4655148983001709,
-0.3720392882823944,
0.3514520227909088,
0.24288231134414673,
-0.15954266488552094,
-0.5910221934318542,
-0.8983556628227234,
0.4905330538749695,
0.3309153914451599,
-0.590847909450531,
0.2711199223995209,
-0.07641509920358658,
0.08093789964914322,
0.09267890453338623,
-0.11882327497005463,
0.12793204188346863,
0.3258894085884094,
0.20342044532299042,
0.4035395681858063,
-0.32166191935539246,
-0.11576024442911148,
0.0543128065764904,
-0.45931246876716614,
-0.18859022855758667,
-0.2573354244232178,
0.3472391664981842,
0.0453292578458786,
-0.4534302055835724,
-0.5872265696525574,
0.38575518131256104,
0.5091254711151123,
-0.0015076047275215387,
0.48271021246910095,
0.28279349207878113,
-0.45540904998779297,
-0.5285494327545166,
-0.280774861574173,
0.11028903722763062,
-0.4192989468574524,
0.20049792528152466,
-0.03580716997385025,
-0.8128325939178467,
0.14581894874572754,
0.4534234404563904,
-0.2503904700279236,
0.3478583097457886,
0.5933808088302612,
-0.15255407989025116,
0.8835709691047668,
0.4890665113925934,
-0.24241887032985687,
0.3993262052536011,
-0.014653188176453114,
0.33218660950660706,
-0.522331953048706,
0.11266911774873734,
-0.5417394638061523,
-0.11299274861812592,
-0.15089641511440277,
-0.21911458671092987,
0.14953789114952087,
0.0678924173116684,
-0.05464036390185356,
0.45899027585983276,
-0.7167001962661743,
0.897990882396698,
0.4089690148830414,
0.15726689994335175,
0.5970103740692139,
0.25051239132881165,
-0.2632855474948883,
0.09717713296413422,
-0.3694237172603607,
-0.6215782165527344,
1.2905062437057495,
0.08037284016609192,
0.60163813829422,
-0.0893472209572792,
0.9959489107131958,
0.477134644985199,
0.34964075684547424,
-0.6592729091644287,
0.6042981147766113,
-0.4903213381767273,
-0.6405985355377197,
0.04033747315406799,
-0.22585497796535492,
-0.48290783166885376,
0.16965724527835846,
-0.32895392179489136,
-0.7224618196487427,
-0.2166835516691208,
0.2077961564064026,
-0.4165430963039398,
0.3774745762348175,
-0.7864912748336792,
0.9535419940948486,
-0.21124115586280823,
-0.17670714855194092,
0.27774283289909363,
-0.20241473615169525,
0.3632999658584595,
-0.04306582733988762,
0.17875191569328308,
-0.3210521936416626,
0.1068715825676918,
0.3276994526386261,
-0.34146735072135925,
0.9321246147155762,
-0.15757542848587036,
-0.11510586738586426,
0.5278605818748474,
0.3073602616786957,
0.5997894406318665,
-0.03144611418247223,
0.054159220308065414,
0.26364666223526,
-0.5506711006164551,
-0.41657495498657227,
-0.4156401455402374,
0.6317059993743896,
-0.6210947036743164,
-0.39778006076812744,
-0.682009756565094,
-0.4627508819103241,
0.06684605777263641,
0.09110153466463089,
0.5266740918159485,
0.5054582357406616,
-0.3935326039791107,
0.051254019141197205,
0.29617875814437866,
-0.1264849305152893,
0.4592970311641693,
0.7973448634147644,
-0.0073565272614359856,
-0.47681325674057007,
0.7848371863365173,
0.06547161936759949,
0.24368374049663544,
0.4639374017715454,
0.00623420812189579,
-0.0007347213104367256,
-0.7761827111244202,
-0.5699318051338196,
0.22708551585674286,
-0.5678752660751343,
-0.5507490038871765,
-0.732065737247467,
-0.32730725407600403,
-0.3184804320335388,
-0.7670358419418335,
-0.1216706857085228,
-0.13672350347042084,
-0.6425724029541016,
-0.3207375109195709,
0.23049594461917877,
0.5176455974578857,
0.016127100214362144,
0.7509751915931702,
-0.6395981907844543,
0.4995678961277008,
0.16381682455539703,
0.021021883934736252,
-0.1882050484418869,
-0.6012383699417114,
-0.009207234717905521,
-0.12418555468320847,
-0.4571349620819092,
-0.8921682834625244,
0.4380549490451813,
0.1302603781223297,
0.24700477719306946,
0.2816215455532074,
-0.11318434029817581,
0.5634311437606812,
-0.5664739608764648,
0.757489800453186,
0.3524361848831177,
-1.1725132465362549,
0.6867434978485107,
-0.2935263216495514,
0.5478782653808594,
0.5377110242843628,
-0.2131531685590744,
-0.6564334630966187,
-0.7977088689804077,
-0.6449002027511597,
-0.5168418884277344,
0.8567017316818237,
0.2977834641933441,
0.2674263119697571,
-0.24551920592784882,
0.47986331582069397,
-0.24414801597595215,
0.07527830451726913,
-0.9432491064071655,
-0.13324953615665436,
0.1043388694524765,
-0.5506346821784973,
-0.3084591031074524,
-0.5815505385398865,
0.34581008553504944,
0.16497115790843964,
0.7077164053916931,
-0.2493593841791153,
0.1008334830403328,
0.35819822549819946,
-0.45440447330474854,
-0.2683532238006592,
0.5918073058128357,
0.5839005708694458,
0.11401350051164627,
-0.23579134047031403,
0.40473660826683044,
0.21810652315616608,
-0.5248467922210693,
0.4126398265361786,
-0.06581628322601318,
-0.955766499042511,
0.2072312980890274,
0.4944688677787781,
0.44628679752349854,
0.2767288386821747,
-0.6148192286491394,
0.8071942329406738,
0.0664403960108757,
-0.3865427076816559,
-0.16354164481163025,
0.25013014674186707,
0.03401068598031998,
0.07063635438680649,
0.33216312527656555,
0.03899762034416199,
-0.13647820055484772,
-0.5093737244606018,
0.35909324884414673,
0.5487291812896729,
-0.5196160674095154,
-0.3612889349460602,
0.6256688833236694,
0.06444912403821945,
-0.42712727189064026,
0.2527831792831421,
-0.6391514539718628,
-0.5963150858879089,
0.49465566873550415,
0.8617987632751465,
1.012588381767273,
-0.2126326858997345,
0.6904754638671875,
0.24684195220470428,
0.4037657380104065,
-0.01806737668812275,
0.24433383345603943,
-0.054676275700330734,
-0.919702410697937,
-0.407382071018219,
-0.6140275597572327,
-0.26176881790161133,
0.1910039782524109,
-0.3459339141845703,
0.47601065039634705,
-0.6237561106681824,
-0.014034303836524487,
0.19155891239643097,
-0.08574701845645905,
-0.2619321346282959,
0.17752298712730408,
0.5018036365509033,
0.5556585788726807,
-1.0698455572128296,
0.5837357640266418,
0.43915173411369324,
-0.3291515111923218,
-0.5095646381378174,
0.07697966694831848,
0.3522399365901947,
-0.9138666391372681,
0.23837459087371826,
0.1925429403781891,
-0.3435188829898834,
0.09072616696357727,
-0.6621354818344116,
-0.32915863394737244,
1.050551176071167,
0.6686253547668457,
-0.5718130469322205,
-0.01894470676779747,
0.06460773199796677,
0.6385993361473083,
-0.2787919342517853,
0.26070499420166016,
0.6372333765029907,
0.13933740556240082,
0.03263930231332779,
-0.35172536969184875,
-0.01228894293308258,
-0.1790991872549057,
-0.17511612176895142,
0.38766011595726013,
-0.16649790108203888,
0.8124669790267944,
-0.08374077081680298,
-0.4530872404575348,
-0.03653769940137863,
0.45236480236053467,
0.2256452888250351,
0.5233040452003479,
0.2375878244638443,
0.8629991412162781,
0.6397799849510193,
0.1465374380350113,
1.1081514358520508,
-0.10531899333000183,
0.48297515511512756,
1.0872377157211304,
-0.42814263701438904,
0.820299506187439,
0.09828122705221176,
-0.12340487539768219,
0.48459917306900024,
-0.0024864538572728634,
-0.23287922143936157,
0.2942139506340027,
0.10400666296482086,
-0.6333957314491272,
-0.355519562959671,
-0.1112930029630661,
0.05877547338604927,
0.5037400722503662,
0.11565875262022018,
-0.3963233232498169,
-0.6585500240325928,
-0.2696777880191803,
0.5647755265235901,
0.5077419281005859,
-0.33267149329185486,
0.7744451761245728,
0.007631373126059771,
-0.48354050517082214,
0.5964767932891846,
0.1463250070810318,
0.8896920680999756,
-0.5122332572937012,
0.1258019357919693,
-0.2311318963766098,
0.44739919900894165,
-0.3550792932510376,
-0.92839515209198,
0.12370282411575317,
0.7854146361351013,
-0.15455932915210724,
-0.06977743655443192,
1.1520650386810303,
-0.4394250214099884,
-0.9022282361984253,
0.32411614060401917,
0.520147442817688,
0.14645706117153168,
-0.38621535897254944,
-0.4046500623226166,
-0.06978616118431091,
0.12950463593006134,
0.17202329635620117,
0.21671082079410553,
0.35639649629592896,
0.21401463449001312,
0.0981651246547699,
0.8776949644088745,
0.25323286652565,
-0.020471494644880295,
-0.07936922460794449,
0.5239890813827515,
-0.737147331237793,
-0.5014856457710266,
-1.254525899887085,
0.4501038193702698,
-0.23614725470542908,
-0.2999297082424164,
0.7201206684112549,
0.5442615747451782,
0.8133567571640015,
-0.11225159466266632,
1.0730717182159424,
0.1325289011001587,
0.3555257320404053,
-0.45565319061279297,
0.6011670231819153,
-0.4000791311264038,
0.09971266239881516,
-0.5420095324516296,
-0.7626330256462097,
-0.7711463570594788,
0.6769194602966309,
-0.29903852939605713,
-0.36956140398979187,
0.8020619750022888,
1.1606308221817017,
-0.06835517287254333,
-0.25788614153862,
0.7023001313209534,
0.11947251111268997,
0.47207891941070557,
0.8480757474899292,
0.7740690112113953,
-0.6984285712242126,
0.954328179359436,
-0.16753295063972473,
-0.28113001585006714,
-0.308697372674942,
-1.1102761030197144,
-1.049383521080017,
-0.007845824584364891,
-0.4090205132961273,
-0.3118921220302582,
0.22291076183319092,
0.362039178609848,
0.36932748556137085,
-0.8982227444648743,
-0.005676082335412502,
-0.27912941575050354,
0.14992935955524445,
-0.04045182093977928,
-0.1836075633764267,
0.2018471509218216,
-0.3348010182380676,
-0.5446984767913818,
0.469245970249176,
0.8033700585365295,
0.11194644123315811,
-0.045069511979818344,
0.021564971655607224,
-0.2175520807504654,
0.2897202670574188,
0.5876193046569824,
0.4060097932815552,
-0.5241780877113342,
-0.42515578866004944,
0.19508011639118195,
-0.408121258020401,
0.18291649222373962,
0.7604945302009583,
-0.5267128348350525,
0.43345171213150024,
0.4164072275161743,
0.5421937108039856,
0.5213931798934937,
0.034888070076704025,
0.3061915636062622,
-1.0181610584259033,
0.12039810419082642,
0.03596533462405205,
0.3706629276275635,
0.46850821375846863,
-0.6087557673454285,
0.32264676690101624,
0.5690163969993591,
-0.4661308526992798,
-0.8023583292961121,
0.14119935035705566,
-1.0508331060409546,
-0.32972729206085205,
1.2060632705688477,
-0.1105227991938591,
-0.5167223215103149,
-0.049425505101680756,
-0.4163629114627838,
0.09738429635763168,
-0.5261795520782471,
0.5433271527290344,
0.7053582668304443,
0.28183165192604065,
-0.0431300550699234,
-0.47402042150497437,
0.16026245057582855,
0.17698420584201813,
-1.0040581226348877,
0.05825335532426834,
0.6214407086372375,
0.43643075227737427,
0.18072497844696045,
0.9579397439956665,
-0.15821883082389832,
0.445505291223526,
0.05005357787013054,
0.26586848497390747,
-0.31922322511672974,
-0.41897621750831604,
-0.4096505343914032,
0.3366546928882599,
-0.0675867572426796,
-0.1768946349620819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04271v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04271v1
|
Generating Feature Vectors from Phonetic Transcriptions in Cross-Linguistic Data Formats
| 2024-05-07T12:40:59 | 2024-05-07T12:40:59 |
Arne Rubehn, Jessica Nieder, Robert Forkel, Johann-Mattis List
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
When comparing speech sounds across languages, scholars often make use of
feature representations of individual sounds in order to determine fine-grained
sound similarities. Although binary feature systems for large numbers of speech
sounds have been proposed, large-scale computational applications often face
the challenges that the proposed feature systems -- even if they list features
for several thousand sounds -- only cover a smaller part of the numerous speech
sounds reflected in actual cross-linguistic data. In order to address the
problem of missing data for attested speech sounds, we propose a new approach
that can create binary feature vectors dynamically for all sounds that can be
represented in the the standardized version of the International Phonetic
Alphabet proposed by the Cross-Linguistic Transcription Systems (CLTS)
reference catalog. Since CLTS is actively used in large data collections,
covering more than 2,000 distinct language varieties, our procedure for the
generation of binary feature vectors provides immediate access to a very large
collection of multilingual wordlists. Testing our feature system in different
ways on different datasets proves that the system is not only useful to provide
a straightforward means to compare the similarity of speech sounds, but also
illustrates its potential to be used in future cross-linguistic machine
learning applications.
|
[
-0.6127010583877563,
-0.13099370896816254,
0.22022007405757904,
0.28235533833503723,
-0.35737574100494385,
0.13146504759788513,
-0.3832012414932251,
-0.5699559450149536,
0.7122128009796143,
0.4434104859828949,
-0.4077393412590027,
-0.6055784821510315,
-0.41876518726348877,
0.26813235878944397,
-0.7813211679458618,
0.8084457516670227,
0.0725148394703865,
0.05262567102909088,
0.015600831247866154,
-0.25230324268341064,
-0.44517409801483154,
-0.7595933675765991,
0.01499074324965477,
0.005056117195636034,
0.6557287573814392,
0.4268147647380829,
0.5241712927818298,
0.5398412346839905,
0.3762821555137634,
0.2496248483657837,
-0.062297072261571884,
0.035740356892347336,
-0.21153084933757782,
0.38747504353523254,
-0.13681219518184662,
-0.3907652199268341,
-0.2308080941438675,
-0.1220359057188034,
0.9071641564369202,
0.8212997317314148,
0.16551321744918823,
0.4389486610889435,
0.056894950568675995,
0.38489019870758057,
-0.2646702826023102,
0.22411343455314636,
-0.8178810477256775,
0.2386067807674408,
-0.521504819393158,
-0.3443918526172638,
-0.04580952599644661,
-0.39984309673309326,
0.4196130335330963,
-0.34847337007522583,
0.43052518367767334,
-0.20413874089717865,
0.547650158405304,
-0.10171004384756088,
-0.02244037203490734,
-0.5393034815788269,
-1.0666438341140747,
0.6587740778923035,
-0.4197489023208618,
0.8241758942604065,
-0.11084672063589096,
0.3099673390388489,
-0.3697633743286133,
-0.5156291127204895,
-0.4272569715976715,
-0.2045271247625351,
0.08641437441110611,
-0.12314587086439133,
-0.08766008913516998,
-0.5197834372520447,
0.207919642329216,
0.18722102046012878,
-0.7950912714004517,
-0.048749543726444244,
-0.46912071108818054,
-0.49139541387557983,
0.6364860534667969,
-0.20878168940544128,
0.242322638630867,
-0.11614223569631577,
-0.24344636499881744,
-0.4727391004562378,
-0.8749994039535522,
0.21506524085998535,
0.6238054633140564,
0.8417075872421265,
-0.13676100969314575,
0.7490411996841431,
0.16327768564224243,
0.3475257158279419,
-0.03375835716724396,
-0.3809577524662018,
0.6055771708488464,
-0.31142133474349976,
0.15683649480342865,
0.689860999584198,
0.7008625864982605,
-0.197201669216156,
0.2148541361093521,
-0.2489168643951416,
-0.4361289143562317,
0.21557152271270752,
-0.15081022679805756,
-0.600257158279419,
-0.20944960415363312,
0.13437888026237488,
-0.32148900628089905,
-0.06569868326187134,
0.17743344604969025,
-0.5554731488227844,
-0.1601962000131607,
-0.5421833992004395,
0.2588264048099518,
-0.6716213226318359,
-0.35345643758773804,
-0.19495689868927002,
-0.47486793994903564,
0.10259999334812164,
-0.27001217007637024,
-0.8591315150260925,
0.03841046243906021,
0.7097921967506409,
0.6803995966911316,
-0.24883432686328888,
-0.2645065188407898,
-0.7123963236808777,
0.008436505682766438,
-0.3024279773235321,
0.6748732328414917,
-0.9369807839393616,
-0.5998160243034363,
0.1406891942024231,
-0.09559772908687592,
0.36931726336479187,
-0.8926753997802734,
0.41419142484664917,
-0.17971689999103546,
-0.2252189666032791,
-0.5407780408859253,
-0.4755190312862396,
-0.1309845894575119,
0.0783810168504715,
-0.5255576372146606,
1.189349889755249,
0.11231504380702972,
-0.6510084271430969,
0.44212740659713745,
-0.1857825368642807,
-0.592420220375061,
0.11089439690113068,
-0.7828244566917419,
-0.5194472670555115,
0.05462214723229408,
0.12594518065452576,
0.41021478176116943,
-0.20861788094043732,
0.05670781433582306,
-0.36363357305526733,
-0.48435652256011963,
0.5569270253181458,
-0.37726667523384094,
0.7669304013252258,
0.013230296783149242,
-0.48372697830200195,
-0.05845354497432709,
-1.0602442026138306,
-0.030027300119400024,
0.0006692525930702686,
-0.46390360593795776,
-0.4093649983406067,
-0.11906096339225769,
0.14768804609775543,
0.038976460695266724,
0.27102217078208923,
-0.7616157531738281,
0.052482955157756805,
-0.18589282035827637,
0.2487303614616394,
0.4482567310333252,
-0.03433491289615631,
0.12848970293998718,
-0.27814802527427673,
0.6073258519172668,
0.3334668278694153,
-0.19305306673049927,
-0.16600222885608673,
-0.565534234046936,
-0.4825877249240875,
-0.5904462933540344,
0.7769067883491516,
0.6799161434173584,
-0.5548787713050842,
0.769405722618103,
-0.3646051585674286,
-0.5774927139282227,
-0.5859769582748413,
0.09232756495475769,
0.45789578557014465,
0.17972755432128906,
0.34774845838546753,
-0.6453865170478821,
-0.8223834037780762,
-0.852059543132782,
-0.05531427636742592,
-0.22302086651325226,
-0.21947410702705383,
0.2814318537712097,
0.1603238880634308,
-0.022447898983955383,
0.8379983305931091,
0.001210995251312852,
-0.24857690930366516,
-0.12571240961551666,
0.07878284901380539,
0.05409742519259453,
0.4621550142765045,
0.6988545060157776,
-0.5788108110427856,
-0.2581278383731842,
0.10365841537714005,
-0.5271550416946411,
-0.19499735534191132,
0.10399152338504791,
-0.09409978240728378,
0.2484055757522583,
0.4302859604358673,
-0.2566227614879608,
0.31024980545043945,
0.6096958518028259,
-0.08112265914678574,
0.6201339364051819,
-0.1042790561914444,
0.07312529534101486,
-0.7556284666061401,
0.22592978179454803,
-0.23379260301589966,
-0.19122859835624695,
-0.4393671154975891,
-0.46806925535202026,
-0.10046850889921188,
-0.3663228452205658,
-0.5297520160675049,
0.2612566351890564,
-0.4536515772342682,
-0.7544002532958984,
0.05726725980639458,
0.3053094744682312,
-0.31774187088012695,
0.3196193277835846,
0.10713768005371094,
0.5555882453918457,
0.7667653560638428,
-0.5878771543502808,
0.5598395466804504,
0.3938257694244385,
-0.2772860527038574,
0.4660666882991791,
-0.32156866788864136,
0.08715589344501495,
-0.21270495653152466,
0.3444879949092865,
-0.7220078706741333,
0.10552401840686798,
0.2195238620042801,
-0.7078293561935425,
0.1542002260684967,
-0.33687731623649597,
-0.43255168199539185,
-0.3266463577747345,
-0.13415490090847015,
0.5787546634674072,
0.8075292706489563,
-0.46724727749824524,
0.5160739421844482,
0.6929978728294373,
-0.43953272700309753,
-0.5399569272994995,
-0.5977823138237,
0.055410418659448624,
-0.2502290904521942,
-0.573569655418396,
0.23016853630542755,
0.193752259016037,
0.07403767853975296,
0.09201069176197052,
-0.02952103316783905,
0.2266598790884018,
-0.17477592825889587,
0.22093616425991058,
0.07087963074445724,
-0.48712390661239624,
0.1164918914437294,
0.03601705655455589,
-0.06863480061292648,
-0.00910620391368866,
-0.8711243867874146,
0.6392211318016052,
0.1895936280488968,
-0.4522536098957062,
-0.1255165934562683,
0.6773562431335449,
0.6043828129768372,
-0.4944607615470886,
-0.019818691536784172,
0.8022144436836243,
-0.35683271288871765,
-0.3653903305530548,
-0.32784074544906616,
-0.15528200566768646,
-0.3922949731349945,
0.24033835530281067,
-0.5264350175857544,
-0.738241970539093,
0.7897577881813049,
0.0722658559679985,
0.24515128135681152,
0.32492175698280334,
0.6361218094825745,
0.002876455197110772,
0.6853874921798706,
0.4489339292049408,
-0.13463477790355682,
0.5293891429901123,
-0.011689065024256706,
0.17661990225315094,
-0.5605165958404541,
-0.22625766694545746,
-0.8229684233665466,
-0.6853799819946289,
-1.0123027563095093,
-0.4651079475879669,
0.5025607347488403,
-0.15562768280506134,
0.013563904911279678,
0.5665386915206909,
-0.6127151250839233,
0.054255273193120956,
1.0202263593673706,
0.08701854944229126,
0.05980454385280609,
0.34533724188804626,
-0.6504621505737305,
-0.07637752592563629,
-0.6020907163619995,
-0.28019967675209045,
0.9651691913604736,
0.20330369472503662,
0.6012513637542725,
0.10640657693147659,
1.1283799409866333,
0.1918153613805771,
-0.32426705956459045,
-0.7002548575401306,
0.6954168081283569,
-0.6690224409103394,
-0.20602400600910187,
-0.4735981523990631,
-0.3149864375591278,
-0.9263663291931152,
-0.020948883146047592,
-0.5447638630867004,
-0.3818606734275818,
0.5074579119682312,
0.17573750019073486,
-0.3018622398376465,
0.11228340864181519,
-0.4168446660041809,
0.5457354784011841,
-0.23928596079349518,
0.260143905878067,
0.0962863638997078,
-0.5952976942062378,
0.1619352549314499,
-0.34536299109458923,
-0.0661240965127945,
-0.2593948245048523,
0.21055330336093903,
0.902971088886261,
-0.5147457718849182,
0.7468331456184387,
-0.20386222004890442,
-0.3136007785797119,
0.3255029022693634,
0.15362310409545898,
0.23545897006988525,
-0.09596796333789825,
-0.0490051805973053,
0.3953567445278168,
0.09230159968137741,
-0.111887127161026,
-0.47444507479667664,
0.7116256952285767,
-0.5901817679405212,
-0.3018692433834076,
-0.30020350217819214,
-0.5052780508995056,
-0.21312281489372253,
0.17725396156311035,
0.1962977945804596,
0.638396143913269,
-0.19635550677776337,
0.13552406430244446,
0.7379074096679688,
-0.5091431140899658,
0.3533630669116974,
0.3825010359287262,
-0.37953126430511475,
-0.38366612792015076,
1.1983654499053955,
0.4355487525463104,
0.020743709057569504,
0.3659921884536743,
0.2725299298763275,
-0.29595747590065,
-0.6003545522689819,
-0.6270928978919983,
0.1024603620171547,
-0.5511282086372375,
-0.05238610506057739,
-0.4717665910720825,
-0.37062937021255493,
-0.6241288185119629,
0.159568190574646,
-0.35148346424102783,
-0.5743833184242249,
0.0015774039784446359,
0.27112868428230286,
0.6707321405410767,
0.6815952062606812,
-0.37733954191207886,
-0.2774603068828583,
-1.2201248407363892,
0.5270248651504517,
0.14475421607494354,
0.28214773535728455,
-0.17328611016273499,
-0.5363989472389221,
-0.1789623349905014,
-0.02215905673801899,
0.03906535357236862,
-0.613599956035614,
0.45332959294319153,
0.20370781421661377,
0.6416908502578735,
0.0591401681303978,
-0.003746932139620185,
0.6643632650375366,
-0.9309482574462891,
0.7173165678977966,
0.11132507771253586,
-0.8693459630012512,
0.4160609245300293,
-0.2189449816942215,
0.11576807498931885,
0.09460148960351944,
0.3633456528186798,
-0.7417814135551453,
-0.7742083668708801,
-0.6616106033325195,
-0.9121795296669006,
0.4619530141353607,
0.302519828081131,
-0.2215171754360199,
-0.12492994219064713,
0.18476936221122742,
0.5536149740219116,
0.10069535672664642,
-0.02254500240087509,
-0.4072825312614441,
-0.27950170636177063,
-0.45515376329421997,
-0.028343677520751953,
-0.019177839159965515,
-0.030781110748648643,
-0.011226645670831203,
0.7156810164451599,
0.07009068131446838,
0.4522199332714081,
0.30686742067337036,
-0.09103697538375854,
0.10605274140834808,
0.2834976017475128,
0.7164543271064758,
0.4136850833892822,
-0.06407953053712845,
0.2758656442165375,
-0.1354730725288391,
-0.8043034076690674,
0.15788784623146057,
0.4450678527355194,
-0.3269161880016327,
0.5398784875869751,
0.13050667941570282,
0.8034821152687073,
0.3406667113304138,
-0.6290513277053833,
0.39273175597190857,
0.11186431348323822,
-0.15634261071681976,
-0.6159060597419739,
-0.06319262832403183,
0.28482359647750854,
0.3569037914276123,
0.2755088806152344,
0.10163245350122452,
0.05648596212267876,
-0.6681321263313293,
0.6793776750564575,
0.38938388228416443,
-0.30103427171707153,
-0.32096895575523376,
0.46507683396339417,
0.192048579454422,
-0.38716161251068115,
0.46006205677986145,
0.02109619602560997,
-0.5489416122436523,
0.6344249844551086,
0.4588206708431244,
0.9315160512924194,
-0.3617843687534332,
-0.055954352021217346,
0.245928093791008,
0.10020860284566879,
-0.15723763406276703,
0.5997606515884399,
0.13020247220993042,
-0.5186240077018738,
-0.05181489139795303,
-0.7178434133529663,
-0.4704988896846771,
0.0045631579123437405,
-0.5217498540878296,
0.5796394944190979,
-0.32579055428504944,
0.03445969894528389,
0.3348800241947174,
-0.4135044813156128,
-0.8887187838554382,
-0.046258632093667984,
0.7309681177139282,
0.7448567748069763,
-0.8439986109733582,
0.8929348587989807,
0.3305978775024414,
-0.3602747321128845,
-0.8645058274269104,
-0.09524572640657425,
-0.02966795302927494,
-0.8493823409080505,
0.8205360770225525,
0.016752397641539574,
-0.1729765236377716,
-0.41248324513435364,
-0.03941867873072624,
-1.0769518613815308,
0.7911743521690369,
0.5389896631240845,
-0.920451283454895,
0.07069514691829681,
0.8592569231987,
0.40195250511169434,
-0.5160962343215942,
-0.04157774895429611,
0.692959189414978,
0.39456453919410706,
0.2227243185043335,
-1.1416821479797363,
0.04960000514984131,
-0.02498720772564411,
0.08652880042791367,
0.2284676730632782,
-0.2585025727748871,
0.814099907875061,
0.12672150135040283,
-0.19232508540153503,
-0.08279228210449219,
0.7771742939949036,
0.4174708127975464,
-0.12277624011039734,
0.62520432472229,
0.40008246898651123,
0.971518874168396,
0.014360628090798855,
0.421585351228714,
-0.385749489068985,
0.01789752207696438,
1.106502890586853,
-0.4645105302333832,
1.0949833393096924,
0.18567107617855072,
-0.05756118521094322,
0.38186511397361755,
0.4797617197036743,
-0.2603667676448822,
0.2558151185512543,
0.6000880599021912,
-0.4337671995162964,
-0.16622263193130493,
-0.009358104318380356,
-0.42127418518066406,
0.726248025894165,
0.43884560465812683,
-0.3272183835506439,
-0.19192790985107422,
0.1976250857114792,
-0.5162237286567688,
-0.1256266087293625,
-0.19853633642196655,
0.6702609658241272,
0.06254303455352783,
-0.4528004229068756,
0.7205969095230103,
-0.2608417570590973,
0.7208153605461121,
-0.6213059425354004,
-0.35947927832603455,
-0.1823553591966629,
-0.01724148355424404,
-0.11011911928653717,
-0.8956978917121887,
0.21143732964992523,
0.1575213521718979,
-0.2848566472530365,
-0.05818622559309006,
0.4091393053531647,
-0.8847302794456482,
-0.7852351665496826,
0.31594017148017883,
0.28912293910980225,
0.5545881390571594,
0.20195049047470093,
-0.3930392563343048,
0.27984482049942017,
0.009707148186862469,
0.18319810926914215,
0.14737702906131744,
0.7831937670707703,
-0.36861714720726013,
0.34761539101600647,
0.6815446615219116,
0.40411651134490967,
0.5109914541244507,
0.24517002701759338,
0.530267596244812,
-0.9081576466560364,
-0.7159734964370728,
-0.4213857650756836,
0.22539004683494568,
0.2114313840866089,
-0.15430191159248352,
0.5296390652656555,
0.8255330920219421,
1.112528681755066,
-0.13742278516292572,
1.3448078632354736,
-0.14635595679283142,
1.0874351263046265,
-0.4462864100933075,
0.5484350323677063,
-0.23639483749866486,
0.2711811661720276,
-0.1587238311767578,
-0.935203492641449,
-0.35416173934936523,
0.15208573639392853,
0.3491230309009552,
-0.19034814834594727,
0.6292722225189209,
0.8611000180244446,
-0.18879388272762299,
-0.06382777541875839,
0.3947056233882904,
0.14732933044433594,
0.3804684281349182,
0.35743969678878784,
0.44496598839759827,
-0.36465027928352356,
0.8882347345352173,
-0.30382266640663147,
-0.03406718000769615,
-0.15604209899902344,
-0.8165705800056458,
-0.7263604998588562,
-0.8271308541297913,
-0.14777348935604095,
-0.4122861325740814,
-0.10606836527585983,
1.1604501008987427,
0.3159292936325073,
-1.1491338014602661,
-0.21618002653121948,
0.5371788740158081,
-0.04797283187508583,
-0.3419177830219269,
-0.14015346765518188,
0.5450246930122375,
-0.24654795229434967,
-0.7497560977935791,
0.5871775150299072,
0.18880975246429443,
0.23933371901512146,
-0.4664985239505768,
0.11143717169761658,
0.11550147086381912,
0.0284198559820652,
0.4066661298274994,
0.6250668168067932,
-0.7124009132385254,
-0.6552586555480957,
0.0518428198993206,
0.04494509473443031,
0.2739682197570801,
1.161328911781311,
-0.9032158255577087,
0.3238736391067505,
0.6986733078956604,
0.733102023601532,
0.31205207109451294,
-0.40679678320884705,
0.6197517514228821,
-0.9485727548599243,
0.31395187973976135,
0.2912931740283966,
0.563116192817688,
0.40467536449432373,
-0.10971134155988693,
0.025256775319576263,
0.27006325125694275,
-0.14514799416065216,
-0.7421013712882996,
0.2611042261123657,
-1.377738118171692,
0.10184167325496674,
1.0954393148422241,
-0.16230955719947815,
-0.2348235845565796,
-0.15380172431468964,
-0.11736105382442474,
0.42474594712257385,
-0.4622251093387604,
0.6119228601455688,
0.4357627034187317,
-0.01997922547161579,
0.2063462734222412,
-0.17662113904953003,
0.5203261375427246,
0.058503180742263794,
-0.2671942710876465,
0.2168462723493576,
0.4099145233631134,
0.5272356271743774,
0.439571350812912,
0.3317315876483917,
-0.44195806980133057,
0.28426098823547363,
0.10473482310771942,
0.38663405179977417,
0.15229563415050507,
-0.44367823004722595,
-0.15444669127464294,
0.19251646101474762,
-0.11661694198846817,
-0.3925962448120117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04219v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04219v1
|
Iterative Experience Refinement of Software-Developing Agents
| 2024-05-07T11:33:49 | 2024-05-07T11:33:49 |
Chen Qian, Jiahao Li, Yufan Dang, Wei Liu, YiFei Wang, Zihao Xie, Weize Chen, Cheng Yang, Yingli Zhang, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MA, cs.SE
|
Autonomous agents powered by large language models (LLMs) show significant
potential for achieving high autonomy in various scenarios such as software
development. Recent research has shown that LLM agents can leverage past
experiences to reduce errors and enhance efficiency. However, the static
experience paradigm, reliant on a fixed collection of past experiences acquired
heuristically, lacks iterative refinement and thus hampers agents'
adaptability. In this paper, we introduce the Iterative Experience Refinement
framework, enabling LLM agents to refine experiences iteratively during task
execution. We propose two fundamental patterns: the successive pattern,
refining based on nearest experiences within a task batch, and the cumulative
pattern, acquiring experiences across all previous task batches. Augmented with
our heuristic experience elimination, the method prioritizes high-quality and
frequently-used experiences, effectively managing the experience space and
enhancing efficiency. Extensive experiments show that while the successive
pattern may yield superior results, the cumulative pattern provides more stable
performance. Moreover, experience elimination facilitates achieving better
performance using just 11.54% of a high-quality subset.
|
[
-0.08722034841775894,
-0.3823271691799164,
0.6499677300453186,
0.45849597454071045,
-0.13388127088546753,
0.5331466794013977,
-0.5141202211380005,
-0.30404379963874817,
-0.06216874346137047,
0.7080149054527283,
-0.7140645384788513,
-0.8551783561706543,
-0.2664100229740143,
-0.1312425285577774,
-0.1314222812652588,
0.8117060661315918,
-0.3780822455883026,
-0.4979000985622406,
-0.2645971179008484,
0.014658111147582531,
-0.41176390647888184,
-0.2102615088224411,
-0.7912421226501465,
-0.7972027659416199,
0.3272382318973541,
0.6143710613250732,
0.46422988176345825,
0.7390509843826294,
0.1421080380678177,
0.3770744800567627,
0.1529824137687683,
0.33841389417648315,
-0.6804155111312866,
0.10681375861167908,
-0.189461812376976,
-0.40526023507118225,
-0.3085087537765503,
-0.07973988354206085,
0.49303457140922546,
0.6333797574043274,
-0.4653298854827881,
-0.10318762063980103,
0.2419952005147934,
0.6513404250144958,
-0.5057922601699829,
0.4468141496181488,
-0.4471994936466217,
0.17284050583839417,
0.18999123573303223,
-0.6679078340530396,
-0.5981683731079102,
-0.16894382238388062,
-0.1995590329170227,
-1.0864942073822021,
0.16241295635700226,
-0.023684164509177208,
0.7450695633888245,
0.38543012738227844,
0.0012600604677572846,
-0.20668554306030273,
-1.0656096935272217,
0.8566862344741821,
-0.8414894938468933,
0.2934171259403229,
0.11730577051639557,
0.1807667315006256,
-0.350658118724823,
-0.7882724404335022,
-0.3096640706062317,
-0.6186907887458801,
-0.12701378762722015,
0.029008034616708755,
0.08150165528059006,
0.044144026935100555,
0.060689277946949005,
0.37068822979927063,
-0.3840354382991791,
0.3298361003398895,
-0.5306523442268372,
0.08319306373596191,
0.5486348867416382,
0.3885621428489685,
-0.12188155949115753,
0.4637417197227478,
-0.5337767601013184,
0.027088599279522896,
-0.7545892596244812,
0.3856693208217621,
0.20525717735290527,
0.4119403660297394,
0.13106222450733185,
0.2999729812145233,
-0.4867993891239166,
0.48986974358558655,
-0.10392338037490845,
-0.2644432783126831,
0.478547602891922,
-0.13550327718257904,
-0.17149309813976288,
-0.3718361258506775,
0.19892019033432007,
0.34335246682167053,
0.22994516789913177,
-0.5746387243270874,
-0.4554397761821747,
-0.01527609396725893,
0.9500744938850403,
-0.606356680393219,
-0.039415158331394196,
0.280721515417099,
-0.5046600103378296,
-0.2367725670337677,
-0.0318504236638546,
-0.3208730220794678,
-0.7395681738853455,
-0.4797680079936981,
0.229221910238266,
-0.5634123086929321,
-0.43396830558776855,
0.15605777502059937,
-0.3317849338054657,
0.19826346635818481,
0.6224139928817749,
-0.20562627911567688,
0.571645975112915,
0.9785427451133728,
0.4355148673057556,
-0.22740617394447327,
-0.6243382096290588,
-0.5222666263580322,
0.07879050821065903,
-0.4839273691177368,
0.5593451857566833,
-0.6484174728393555,
-0.42656731605529785,
0.018321460112929344,
0.020430652424693108,
0.25590217113494873,
-0.7886807322502136,
0.10993736237287521,
-0.48755401372909546,
-0.2207237184047699,
-0.10124582797288895,
-0.48576194047927856,
-0.3969343900680542,
0.2888678014278412,
-0.4242366850376129,
0.8876473307609558,
0.38124245405197144,
0.09609478712081909,
0.7491768598556519,
-0.7998682260513306,
-0.2994910776615143,
0.1493547111749649,
-0.23402035236358643,
-0.08246514946222305,
0.34035593271255493,
-0.1443977653980255,
0.020198523998260498,
-0.33399030566215515,
-0.05155647173523903,
-0.03409350663423538,
-0.616233229637146,
0.018517563119530678,
0.07554829120635986,
0.24987968802452087,
0.3042405843734741,
-0.5566444993019104,
0.44686266779899597,
-0.9629500508308411,
0.22163628041744232,
-0.07023526728153229,
-0.22917291522026062,
-0.2162015438079834,
0.186035618185997,
-0.1811947375535965,
0.47841665148735046,
0.11045726388692856,
-0.4780450165271759,
0.4063054919242859,
-0.3464173972606659,
0.10536970943212509,
1.2267271280288696,
0.06626825779676437,
0.6198327541351318,
-0.5282235145568848,
0.5240675806999207,
0.3124649226665497,
0.2004145383834839,
-0.35887423157691956,
-0.07832375168800354,
-0.7148534655570984,
-0.3083433508872986,
-0.19954350590705872,
0.19424663484096527,
-0.9995409250259399,
0.2658641040325165,
-0.07296326756477356,
-0.5040368437767029,
-0.4348844885826111,
0.6919083595275879,
0.43071961402893066,
0.24957911670207977,
0.16896873712539673,
-0.6385774612426758,
-0.24572183191776276,
-0.6332037448883057,
-0.3201369643211365,
-0.04890495911240578,
0.09494787454605103,
0.3555968701839447,
0.2752167582511902,
-0.1582779884338379,
0.9085795283317566,
-0.33139872550964355,
-0.45121219754219055,
-0.061635103076696396,
0.2511046528816223,
0.24485404789447784,
0.7317429184913635,
0.28059127926826477,
-0.5384502410888672,
-0.020111197605729103,
0.07746827602386475,
-0.7516907453536987,
0.05310934782028198,
-0.3664052486419678,
0.06298565119504929,
0.5023003816604614,
0.5622071623802185,
-0.19109562039375305,
0.6022968292236328,
0.09073863923549652,
-0.5234448909759521,
0.19098924100399017,
-0.5779874920845032,
0.1415206640958786,
-0.4046899080276489,
-0.059969864785671234,
-0.06619465351104736,
-0.18945646286010742,
-0.33968740701675415,
0.44447508454322815,
-0.045940984040498734,
0.24430876970291138,
-0.21773262321949005,
0.7029911279678345,
-0.80018150806427,
-0.357173353433609,
-0.641890823841095,
0.01157735288143158,
0.016852255910634995,
0.7129489183425903,
0.13801272213459015,
0.5699746608734131,
0.3236144483089447,
-0.6734543442726135,
0.292385071516037,
-0.35499417781829834,
-0.18982675671577454,
0.3031481206417084,
-0.37064626812934875,
0.3863060176372528,
-0.27259528636932373,
0.0930769070982933,
-1.0462716817855835,
0.2880133390426636,
0.07043103873729706,
-0.12522542476654053,
0.11665994673967361,
0.17610372602939606,
-0.5563584566116333,
-0.25849711894989014,
-0.44341254234313965,
0.2609252631664276,
0.7715723514556885,
-0.4455515444278717,
0.8025279641151428,
-0.31129905581474304,
-0.09447050839662552,
-0.7341840267181396,
-0.24911464750766754,
0.028258681297302246,
-0.05830958113074303,
-0.46976515650749207,
0.34694987535476685,
-0.08409065753221512,
-0.5462266206741333,
0.15261007845401764,
-0.23758564889431,
0.110024593770504,
0.21310435235500336,
0.6557953357696533,
-0.2082715481519699,
-0.17621207237243652,
0.0836341381072998,
-0.20866794884204865,
-0.36890363693237305,
-0.340758353471756,
-0.327228307723999,
0.670673668384552,
-0.008351963013410568,
-0.4606417715549469,
-0.2803078889846802,
0.2453840970993042,
0.4662715196609497,
-0.3419499099254608,
0.5347740054130554,
0.3873783051967621,
-0.42292866110801697,
-0.5568045377731323,
-0.6214402318000793,
-0.1326783150434494,
-0.534038245677948,
0.18236690759658813,
-0.5233488082885742,
-0.7670466899871826,
0.5329310894012451,
-0.2737295925617218,
0.56449294090271,
0.0031545660458505154,
0.32926517724990845,
0.023555967956781387,
0.44417858123779297,
1.1663563251495361,
0.10142756998538971,
0.4089968502521515,
-0.39999473094940186,
0.020709870383143425,
-0.598731517791748,
-0.21009299159049988,
-0.36633193492889404,
-0.24274477362632751,
-0.44937026500701904,
-0.5937464833259583,
0.1619153469800949,
-0.09550513327121735,
-0.4439947009086609,
0.10883177071809769,
-0.4248374104499817,
0.38951653242111206,
0.42185652256011963,
0.2142144739627838,
0.47117429971694946,
-0.10694575309753418,
0.07366616278886795,
0.048153478652238846,
-0.3392527997493744,
-0.5381594300270081,
0.9497970342636108,
0.2735234797000885,
0.8475773334503174,
-0.021739043295383453,
0.7790989875793457,
0.6292107105255127,
0.5078752636909485,
-0.31589803099632263,
0.39072149991989136,
-0.047586001455783844,
0.16360312700271606,
-0.33301275968551636,
-0.10371875017881393,
-0.8725412487983704,
-0.06648005545139313,
0.16505545377731323,
-0.9321287274360657,
0.16090261936187744,
0.12486568838357925,
-0.5161435008049011,
-0.010665848851203918,
-0.4809018671512604,
0.5952244997024536,
0.17817983031272888,
-0.6821324825286865,
-0.5821677446365356,
-0.33632317185401917,
0.11075682938098907,
0.09750237315893173,
0.26301780343055725,
0.007970700040459633,
-0.3619229793548584,
0.22404654324054718,
-0.5742679238319397,
0.7869948148727417,
-0.3778970539569855,
-0.44579267501831055,
0.08984711021184921,
0.07873940467834473,
0.8258787393569946,
-0.07556892186403275,
-0.4514208137989044,
-0.26610708236694336,
-0.49556729197502136,
-0.5452312231063843,
-0.6420773863792419,
0.7750452160835266,
-0.7854521870613098,
-0.7083408236503601,
-0.03816551715135574,
-0.6406125426292419,
-0.13938911259174347,
-0.01188743207603693,
0.03573046624660492,
0.33394521474838257,
-0.13388708233833313,
-0.1135750561952591,
0.316665381193161,
-0.40852436423301697,
0.6422796845436096,
0.884486198425293,
-0.39736858010292053,
0.10022805631160736,
0.7567921876907349,
0.11022960394620895,
0.26581957936286926,
0.0027829636819660664,
-0.33981773257255554,
0.01615568809211254,
-0.7609119415283203,
-0.193875253200531,
0.019280824810266495,
-0.8166511058807373,
0.05146762728691101,
-0.44756224751472473,
-0.22094283998012543,
-0.26993387937545776,
-0.44595959782600403,
-0.534967839717865,
-0.14635233581066132,
0.052865177392959595,
-0.15858115255832672,
0.4114452302455902,
0.8128414750099182,
-0.02764183096587658,
0.5663319230079651,
-0.434783011674881,
0.46456822752952576,
-0.09904160350561142,
0.4340585172176361,
-0.05377527326345444,
-0.29161739349365234,
-0.2978748381137848,
-0.29498761892318726,
-0.16715136170387268,
-0.41068097949028015,
0.47667208313941956,
-0.008502429351210594,
0.724588930606842,
0.2249719500541687,
0.018240706995129585,
0.7983947992324829,
-0.29645490646362305,
0.8831641674041748,
-0.2988491356372833,
-0.6815847158432007,
0.2712007761001587,
-0.14458975195884705,
0.2528441250324249,
0.5291800498962402,
-0.0005542673752643168,
-0.29165831208229065,
-0.6226637363433838,
-0.8537971377372742,
-1.2506877183914185,
0.6849088072776794,
0.14478930830955505,
0.007020424585789442,
0.36646386981010437,
0.7254310846328735,
0.43899622559547424,
0.6077329516410828,
-0.3796346187591553,
-0.2982431650161743,
0.04633471369743347,
0.2053404450416565,
-0.3534955382347107,
-0.07816225290298462,
-0.2747883200645447,
-0.10526302456855774,
0.8561718463897705,
-0.14171087741851807,
0.2628995478153229,
-0.03624170273542404,
-0.3189737796783447,
-0.21296294033527374,
0.2267550677061081,
0.6483356952667236,
1.2291876077651978,
-0.0610249787569046,
-0.03897129371762276,
-0.08573505282402039,
-0.08043507486581802,
0.3652178943157196,
0.04985076189041138,
0.12668319046497345,
-0.18988977372646332,
0.19083672761917114,
0.3904927968978882,
-0.11196320503950119,
-0.6669347286224365,
0.2054154872894287,
-0.022488556802272797,
0.21828126907348633,
-0.6875529289245605,
0.46594080328941345,
-0.18845409154891968,
0.5440852642059326,
0.6793947815895081,
0.029756302013993263,
0.14678576588630676,
-0.7593678832054138,
0.46144217252731323,
0.07527567446231842,
-0.22428570687770844,
-0.0017646003980189562,
0.11586694419384003,
0.18325109779834747,
-0.4389992654323578,
0.6057703495025635,
-0.5698494911193848,
-0.07769157737493515,
0.9598585963249207,
0.5602337718009949,
0.9478532671928406,
-0.10260884463787079,
0.12947359681129456,
0.22179828584194183,
0.38423168659210205,
-0.0425167940557003,
0.39253559708595276,
-0.332060843706131,
-0.7338417768478394,
-0.3967554569244385,
-0.46089839935302734,
-0.33785247802734375,
0.02341810241341591,
-0.5116679668426514,
0.08771941810846329,
-0.8128904104232788,
0.24730773270130157,
-0.25608518719673157,
0.15149782598018646,
-0.7316255569458008,
0.36455345153808594,
-0.005819177720695734,
0.8785037398338318,
-0.6483278274536133,
0.7531755566596985,
0.7012585997581482,
-0.31558358669281006,
-0.779991626739502,
-0.010998195968568325,
0.05276617035269737,
-0.9590888619422913,
0.5273883938789368,
0.11169642210006714,
-0.2856137454509735,
0.08834332972764969,
-0.30017104744911194,
-0.5768468379974365,
1.2772512435913086,
0.05195743590593338,
-0.6070818901062012,
-0.13101327419281006,
-0.006197777576744556,
0.5967162251472473,
-0.7189298868179321,
0.3374592959880829,
0.7053607106208801,
0.4431946575641632,
0.03180529177188873,
-0.6811370253562927,
0.26366493105888367,
-0.7108725309371948,
0.35532987117767334,
-0.08152177929878235,
-0.7517131567001343,
0.8383682370185852,
-0.3272671401500702,
0.059518322348594666,
0.36578255891799927,
0.710931658744812,
0.5628631711006165,
0.49267828464508057,
0.5915402173995972,
0.3045633137226105,
0.6959741711616516,
0.006554838735610247,
0.8696686625480652,
-0.4608180820941925,
-0.015532434917986393,
1.2482701539993286,
-0.5705865025520325,
0.39092370867729187,
0.48330849409103394,
0.2255192995071411,
0.7616439461708069,
0.4554477632045746,
0.2904285490512848,
0.5587168335914612,
0.6613879799842834,
-0.28176334500312805,
-0.3138318657875061,
0.019943587481975555,
-0.34347814321517944,
0.5074331760406494,
0.28485360741615295,
-0.40881505608558655,
-0.3980069160461426,
0.3276197910308838,
0.07685374468564987,
0.4451351463794708,
-0.40560832619667053,
0.8747385740280151,
-0.002180032432079315,
-0.7196870446205139,
0.5523629784584045,
0.030448252335190773,
0.5700699090957642,
-0.46884316205978394,
-0.3514379858970642,
-0.36763548851013184,
0.5249258875846863,
-0.3389100134372711,
-0.5367065668106079,
0.16182725131511688,
0.034404054284095764,
-0.1688212752342224,
-0.48636287450790405,
0.6378920078277588,
-0.07817325741052628,
-0.029826683923602104,
0.41088539361953735,
0.6572074294090271,
0.13686496019363403,
-0.17577601969242096,
-0.30041781067848206,
0.2326955944299698,
-0.18744529783725739,
-0.45566654205322266,
0.14794394373893738,
0.6063010096549988,
-0.16134624183177948,
0.8055365085601807,
0.41704919934272766,
-0.024919267743825912,
-0.16180168092250824,
0.09377533197402954,
1.0257987976074219,
-1.000535249710083,
-0.5447506308555603,
-0.7041736245155334,
0.779161810874939,
-0.12433480471372604,
-0.19983084499835968,
0.5038936734199524,
0.5224162936210632,
0.743772029876709,
0.03103204257786274,
0.8549709916114807,
0.1292995810508728,
0.20326824486255646,
-0.47467607259750366,
0.5931590795516968,
-0.6052069664001465,
0.6954823732376099,
-0.3751056492328644,
-0.664770245552063,
0.15894697606563568,
0.3790608048439026,
-0.1274767369031906,
0.44090744853019714,
0.4694747030735016,
0.8890007734298706,
0.34191954135894775,
-0.18005794286727905,
0.45996931195259094,
0.3316173553466797,
0.5316019058227539,
0.5921175479888916,
0.9741976261138916,
-0.02120729722082615,
0.08039559423923492,
-0.4297204315662384,
-0.3341104984283447,
0.003124260576441884,
-0.9827567338943481,
-0.35727518796920776,
-0.5803003907203674,
-0.3222108483314514,
-0.34369391202926636,
0.42091357707977295,
1.2859134674072266,
0.5385146737098694,
-0.34442394971847534,
-0.5263440012931824,
-0.2733634412288666,
0.09982755780220032,
-0.7954895496368408,
-0.2357219010591507,
-0.24671314656734467,
-0.813916027545929,
-0.4661671817302704,
0.5456632971763611,
0.34796297550201416,
-0.3903046250343323,
-0.25812670588493347,
-0.30926185846328735,
0.2752407193183899,
-0.12234953790903091,
0.4767865836620331,
0.40038517117500305,
-0.5870780348777771,
-0.2683439552783966,
0.13811275362968445,
-0.13657110929489136,
0.30461424589157104,
1.0475678443908691,
-1.2753263711929321,
0.2913433909416199,
-0.07946155965328217,
0.40258896350860596,
0.6028462648391724,
-0.06800790876150131,
0.9703460931777954,
-0.9214673638343811,
0.40294426679611206,
0.17111366987228394,
0.15501855313777924,
0.07433580607175827,
-0.5850121974945068,
0.6904506087303162,
-0.03332960605621338,
-0.25812283158302307,
-0.8783621191978455,
-0.046810708940029144,
-0.9123162627220154,
-0.4369354844093323,
1.1899006366729736,
-0.462362676858902,
-0.0724363699555397,
-0.1221654936671257,
-0.25111839175224304,
0.1707267165184021,
-0.5188657641410828,
0.9645165801048279,
0.4133566915988922,
-0.3183494806289673,
-0.49798229336738586,
-0.2654813528060913,
0.6128482222557068,
0.32396748661994934,
-0.8632734417915344,
0.27819764614105225,
0.5316087603569031,
0.33383336663246155,
0.18507994711399078,
1.0598572492599487,
-0.07485331594944,
0.6480799913406372,
0.13051661849021912,
0.4589068293571472,
-0.47830870747566223,
-0.6692959666252136,
-0.48865723609924316,
0.402969092130661,
0.6423758268356323,
-0.03800271078944206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04170v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04170v1
|
D-NLP at SemEval-2024 Task 2: Evaluating Clinical Inference Capabilities of Large Language Models
| 2024-05-07T10:11:14 | 2024-05-07T10:11:14 |
Duygu Altinok
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have garnered significant attention and
widespread usage due to their impressive performance in various tasks. However,
they are not without their own set of challenges, including issues such as
hallucinations, factual inconsistencies, and limitations in
numerical-quantitative reasoning. Evaluating LLMs in miscellaneous reasoning
tasks remains an active area of research. Prior to the breakthrough of LLMs,
Transformers had already proven successful in the medical domain, effectively
employed for various natural language understanding (NLU) tasks. Following this
trend, LLMs have also been trained and utilized in the medical domain, raising
concerns regarding factual accuracy, adherence to safety protocols, and
inherent limitations. In this paper, we focus on evaluating the natural
language inference capabilities of popular open-source and closed-source LLMs
using clinical trial reports as the dataset. We present the performance results
of each LLM and further analyze their performance on a development set,
particularly focusing on challenging instances that involve medical
abbreviations and require numerical-quantitative reasoning. Gemini, our leading
LLM, achieved a test set F1-score of 0.748, securing the ninth position on the
task scoreboard. Our work is the first of its kind, offering a thorough
examination of the inference capabilities of LLMs within the medical domain.
|
[
-0.032370954751968384,
-0.8942101001739502,
0.9508895874023438,
0.39439263939857483,
-0.1971535086631775,
-0.2258751541376114,
-0.2722180187702179,
-0.3706473410129547,
0.04923407733440399,
0.7703892588615417,
-0.39720869064331055,
-0.7908213138580322,
-0.8459141254425049,
0.41621971130371094,
-0.25493863224983215,
0.6110983490943909,
-0.043072789907455444,
0.46917492151260376,
-0.37378332018852234,
-0.09998960793018341,
-0.4167618155479431,
-0.6067063808441162,
-0.6004566550254822,
-0.27886101603507996,
0.4499525725841522,
0.20898084342479706,
0.6181130409240723,
0.30347391963005066,
0.8395653367042542,
0.3199123740196228,
-0.18465347588062286,
0.07874654978513718,
-0.18286634981632233,
0.15530888736248016,
-0.09888865053653717,
-0.4166507124900818,
-0.6003595590591431,
-0.09090083837509155,
0.40158161520957947,
0.9948437213897705,
-0.11300919950008392,
-0.018005454912781715,
-0.1987733393907547,
0.5225661993026733,
-0.4391149878501892,
0.12342749536037445,
-0.6988918781280518,
0.21309778094291687,
-0.00899843592196703,
-0.05052817240357399,
-0.5874302983283997,
-0.49743932485580444,
0.2705196142196655,
-0.4856054484844208,
0.07147759944200516,
-0.018128912895917892,
0.5455055236816406,
0.5323907136917114,
-0.5390741229057312,
-0.6568199396133423,
-0.476976603269577,
0.8286596536636353,
-1.1461273431777954,
0.2202141135931015,
0.5449029207229614,
0.43793952465057373,
-0.34994736313819885,
-1.0040733814239502,
-0.2892855405807495,
-0.34587690234184265,
0.011696363799273968,
0.11624157428741455,
-0.1824825257062912,
0.16988250613212585,
0.3778132200241089,
0.3568771481513977,
-0.5834071636199951,
0.4452683925628662,
-0.24054338037967682,
-0.1250324249267578,
0.6350213885307312,
0.2492072433233261,
0.208670511841774,
-0.17325398325920105,
-0.17290036380290985,
0.23132720589637756,
-0.6112690567970276,
-0.5641247034072876,
-0.2116830199956894,
0.028158225119113922,
-0.11125507205724716,
0.7100833058357239,
-0.03909321874380112,
0.5253134965896606,
-0.3510022759437561,
-0.12505099177360535,
0.4519538879394531,
-0.2541698217391968,
-0.5646683573722839,
0.027011580765247345,
0.8195825219154358,
0.399882435798645,
0.1331038922071457,
-0.2699267864227295,
-0.0051709553226828575,
0.06255003809928894,
0.32936179637908936,
-0.7452189326286316,
0.11320605874061584,
0.40459176898002625,
-0.47884830832481384,
-0.2998005747795105,
-0.4306351840496063,
-0.8182291388511658,
-0.6511668562889099,
-0.37688136100769043,
0.5481771230697632,
-0.48026546835899353,
-0.0033332689199596643,
0.3999657928943634,
-0.07569440454244614,
0.13392318785190582,
0.5062679648399353,
-0.6530517339706421,
0.3764054775238037,
0.7990339994430542,
0.6674540638923645,
-0.32356002926826477,
-0.05257363244891167,
-0.46622389554977417,
-0.2618524432182312,
-0.3085348904132843,
0.591788113117218,
-0.3186686336994171,
-0.4341041147708893,
0.05728501081466675,
0.15338006615638733,
-0.29967203736305237,
-0.6801300048828125,
1.0363582372665405,
-0.3344169557094574,
0.1399570107460022,
-0.14683212339878082,
-0.7972331643104553,
-0.05308397486805916,
0.3036535978317261,
-0.4762725234031677,
0.7062419652938843,
0.03131759539246559,
-0.5915030837059021,
0.2667251527309418,
-0.35013484954833984,
-0.41282254457473755,
0.24385760724544525,
-0.37755510210990906,
-0.38418519496917725,
0.2724727690219879,
0.28891831636428833,
0.5322239398956299,
-0.5948522090911865,
0.44175440073013306,
-0.4196122884750366,
-0.35793933272361755,
0.2935154438018799,
-0.4539932310581207,
0.6278534531593323,
0.1813633292913437,
-0.3306930661201477,
-0.052360016852617264,
-0.7346497774124146,
-0.04188195616006851,
0.13151009380817413,
-0.08230721205472946,
-0.38180091977119446,
-0.06554176658391953,
-0.30018875002861023,
0.09220322221517563,
0.04311991110444069,
-0.48616594076156616,
0.14991645514965057,
-0.7168149948120117,
0.3977351188659668,
0.43738889694213867,
0.16512446105480194,
0.1830056756734848,
-0.12677989900112152,
0.6791144013404846,
-0.26808321475982666,
0.2419746071100235,
-0.08100514858961105,
-0.5661255121231079,
-0.5916257500648499,
-0.4459301829338074,
0.43657293915748596,
0.4218076169490814,
-0.7634398341178894,
0.35486382246017456,
-0.12876386940479279,
-0.4414389133453369,
-0.5146846771240234,
-0.17111259698867798,
0.22654324769973755,
0.6531636714935303,
0.4237769842147827,
0.09797139465808868,
-0.5030648112297058,
-1.0276141166687012,
-0.24295151233673096,
-0.030741028487682343,
-0.16885143518447876,
0.45920073986053467,
0.8560327887535095,
-0.5372743010520935,
0.5241096019744873,
-0.36111289262771606,
-0.11250719428062439,
-0.22045809030532837,
0.12112576514482498,
0.48295554518699646,
0.2283206582069397,
0.3673882484436035,
-0.4285047650337219,
-0.11808539927005768,
-0.2003946304321289,
-0.9727798104286194,
-0.5165334343910217,
-0.11854593455791473,
-0.0019379841396585107,
0.2908249795436859,
0.5344167351722717,
-0.39885058999061584,
0.5276306867599487,
0.793091893196106,
-0.4108147919178009,
0.5274527668952942,
-0.37255844473838806,
0.30573803186416626,
-0.8120396137237549,
0.04525570198893547,
-0.018289130181074142,
-0.07898258417844772,
-0.573355495929718,
-0.25214430689811707,
-0.07217849791049957,
0.11433599144220352,
-0.3624880313873291,
0.6349230408668518,
-0.2209824174642563,
-0.11180298775434494,
-0.14246249198913574,
0.2355310618877411,
-0.060766953974962234,
0.10727745294570923,
0.12837593257427216,
0.47153937816619873,
0.43838733434677124,
-0.5035163760185242,
0.1489335000514984,
0.4410625398159027,
-0.38010868430137634,
0.3245410621166229,
-0.8412767052650452,
0.10715306550264359,
0.04459427297115326,
0.12206026911735535,
-0.7004809975624084,
-0.19897307455539703,
-0.08078209310770035,
-0.4219309687614441,
0.05548763647675514,
-0.032327789813280106,
-0.6539852619171143,
-0.46599727869033813,
-0.0011343058431521058,
0.14980493485927582,
0.5240615606307983,
-0.4023453891277313,
0.4217212498188019,
0.4632337987422943,
-0.23744773864746094,
-0.42035433650016785,
-0.864955723285675,
0.24854949116706848,
-0.19453759491443634,
-0.731407105922699,
0.30408406257629395,
0.02456205151975155,
-0.5365915298461914,
-0.32473379373550415,
-0.09653519093990326,
-0.06774429231882095,
0.19672338664531708,
0.2854781746864319,
0.3924815356731415,
-0.2745205760002136,
0.2549327611923218,
0.22420696914196014,
-0.11657577008008957,
0.4591004550457001,
0.1832657754421234,
0.22860188782215118,
-0.15019753575325012,
-0.7877638936042786,
-0.3339894413948059,
0.04251115024089813,
0.5685305595397949,
-0.03053879551589489,
0.7454051375389099,
0.30172690749168396,
-0.5695926547050476,
-0.2122410088777542,
-0.6501908898353577,
-0.19620545208454132,
-0.40331852436065674,
0.34698888659477234,
-0.10316099226474762,
-0.997168779373169,
0.3779423236846924,
-0.22710494697093964,
0.10331450402736664,
0.5839170813560486,
0.927733302116394,
0.05328483134508133,
0.9858269095420837,
-0.12680621445178986,
0.40131229162216187,
-0.2575241029262543,
-0.08446665853261948,
0.10177524387836456,
-0.7280073165893555,
-0.3225420117378235,
-0.63328617811203,
-0.02649415098130703,
-0.49375608563423157,
-0.9082668423652649,
0.5948166251182556,
-0.04910552129149437,
-0.15889672935009003,
-0.014151927083730698,
-0.2801222503185272,
0.15317882597446442,
0.1550285369157791,
0.11817248910665512,
0.4928821325302124,
-0.18774761259555817,
-0.2991205155849457,
-0.2619045078754425,
-0.5282852649688721,
-0.6960367560386658,
1.188678503036499,
0.7393115758895874,
0.7257053256034851,
0.12920443713665009,
0.5235875248908997,
0.32044604420661926,
0.41083309054374695,
-0.8522117733955383,
0.5747563242912292,
-0.31514787673950195,
-0.5152295827865601,
-0.1605835109949112,
-0.4428638815879822,
-0.8861402273178101,
0.3837512731552124,
-0.14135263860225677,
-0.5629923343658447,
-0.16207744181156158,
-0.25076809525489807,
-0.3251284956932068,
-0.06915634870529175,
-0.4784623682498932,
0.9405806660652161,
-0.5007640719413757,
-0.2032359540462494,
-0.1655634194612503,
-0.6371135115623474,
0.42605987191200256,
-0.29401761293411255,
0.2974291741847992,
-0.3098967373371124,
-0.22955825924873352,
0.5582816004753113,
-0.4163004755973816,
0.7564893960952759,
-0.1023838222026825,
-0.12574677169322968,
0.06458055973052979,
-0.09814874082803726,
0.23890092968940735,
0.40065428614616394,
-0.4498406946659088,
0.362858384847641,
0.2693285048007965,
-0.16680260002613068,
-0.5219606757164001,
0.6092554926872253,
-0.41849485039711,
-0.49069100618362427,
-0.6260770559310913,
-0.3730084300041199,
-0.5559327602386475,
0.1459517627954483,
-0.01921156421303749,
0.5507996678352356,
-0.440763384103775,
0.35996386408805847,
0.548554539680481,
-0.8577101826667786,
0.15498337149620056,
0.8131966590881348,
-0.2879987955093384,
-0.5409426689147949,
0.3371647298336029,
-0.3116558790206909,
0.35905611515045166,
0.2185589224100113,
0.3159944415092468,
-0.5646577477455139,
-0.9604074954986572,
-0.36097171902656555,
0.46948280930519104,
-0.7107818126678467,
0.02639314904808998,
-0.645122766494751,
-0.3805455267429352,
-0.48622092604637146,
-0.06613219529390335,
-0.3154717981815338,
-0.41736406087875366,
-0.3453758656978607,
0.06531485915184021,
0.11105301976203918,
0.7208825945854187,
0.27538302540779114,
-0.006785527337342501,
-0.9076250195503235,
0.23817066848278046,
-0.047213293612003326,
0.16238616406917572,
-0.3122779428958893,
-0.847893238067627,
0.048190079629421234,
-0.14561745524406433,
-0.11667826026678085,
-0.7707745432853699,
0.5226700901985168,
0.0064653693698346615,
0.7743551135063171,
0.24661187827587128,
-0.01124811265617609,
0.5685574412345886,
-0.4918312132358551,
0.7123345732688904,
0.01144084520637989,
-0.7110358476638794,
0.6395297646522522,
-0.36581775546073914,
0.3589336574077606,
0.7136692404747009,
0.3422830402851105,
-0.4191087484359741,
-0.42842912673950195,
-0.5959102511405945,
-0.6826348304748535,
0.388762503862381,
0.5579796433448792,
-0.09879035502672195,
-0.2825896441936493,
0.4876452386379242,
0.24023637175559998,
0.22705310583114624,
-0.2669673562049866,
-0.18064256012439728,
0.4739871621131897,
-0.344818115234375,
-0.05021579563617706,
-0.27732357382774353,
-0.05018052086234093,
-0.23036953806877136,
0.5388683676719666,
-0.19703297317028046,
0.18445727229118347,
0.40128928422927856,
-0.04318486526608467,
0.2524900436401367,
0.3872561752796173,
0.7096138000488281,
0.8344010710716248,
-0.22323204576969147,
0.07337545603513718,
0.4797666370868683,
-0.5393887162208557,
-0.14644034206867218,
0.3105464279651642,
0.1084991991519928,
0.11844533681869507,
0.6751108765602112,
0.673425018787384,
0.29107537865638733,
-1.0539883375167847,
0.6066685318946838,
-0.38881999254226685,
-0.40892696380615234,
-0.5691337585449219,
-0.1602974385023117,
0.1236000582575798,
0.24906004965305328,
0.05734596028923988,
-0.049453914165496826,
0.2489856630563736,
-0.3590100407600403,
0.24322406947612762,
0.2963683605194092,
-0.4841480553150177,
-0.22074081003665924,
0.6085495948791504,
0.2733200788497925,
-0.12280941009521484,
0.6732932329177856,
-0.06639555841684341,
-0.40049368143081665,
0.8498752117156982,
0.5561965107917786,
0.7475849986076355,
-0.056064672768116,
0.10622451454401016,
0.4835132360458374,
0.3434625267982483,
-0.1490744948387146,
0.38608407974243164,
0.4755464196205139,
-0.6118284463882446,
-0.8061492443084717,
-0.7391467690467834,
-0.6445273756980896,
0.3773209750652313,
-0.5650732517242432,
0.5355666279792786,
-0.258462131023407,
-0.2319829761981964,
0.03936626762151718,
-0.13425256311893463,
-0.4533587396144867,
0.23689143359661102,
0.3466397523880005,
1.1250196695327759,
-0.5425573587417603,
0.5782099962234497,
0.6299967169761658,
0.015161693096160889,
-0.4176340401172638,
-0.31251928210258484,
0.29369381070137024,
-0.8620390892028809,
0.6878228187561035,
0.2213074117898941,
0.09620660543441772,
-0.2657058835029602,
-0.3009189963340759,
-0.45906558632850647,
1.130228877067566,
0.40450119972229004,
-0.6905418634414673,
-0.05917193368077278,
0.42551180720329285,
0.8263488411903381,
-0.33831411600112915,
0.5080381035804749,
0.874929666519165,
0.3992421627044678,
0.31926241517066956,
-1.105483889579773,
0.084224633872509,
0.030813422054052353,
-0.20636798441410065,
0.0765690803527832,
-0.30258500576019287,
0.4458751678466797,
-0.3188476264476776,
0.07921897619962692,
0.2609771490097046,
0.3599873483181,
0.6201383471488953,
0.73248291015625,
0.4254553020000458,
0.6477389335632324,
0.7823178172111511,
-0.11497005820274353,
1.0138179063796997,
-0.18164080381393433,
0.26756522059440613,
1.1112302541732788,
-0.5104687809944153,
0.6978614926338196,
0.47348082065582275,
-0.30800676345825195,
0.1551508754491806,
0.39036768674850464,
-0.08737519383430481,
0.21373453736305237,
0.3856201767921448,
-0.30790820717811584,
-0.19548730552196503,
-0.07745914161205292,
-0.43364325165748596,
0.5210248231887817,
0.6599851250648499,
-0.7408661246299744,
-0.04366886988282204,
-0.0822024792432785,
0.062405772507190704,
-0.032674603164196014,
-0.1204981729388237,
0.7517037391662598,
0.4786742031574249,
-0.7329963445663452,
0.3984789550304413,
-0.022936668246984482,
0.2433975487947464,
-0.6058693528175354,
-0.23017099499702454,
-0.06356446444988251,
0.3883571922779083,
-0.08566085994243622,
-0.6243210434913635,
0.5248382687568665,
0.1253150850534439,
0.3949763774871826,
-0.06989779323339462,
0.6500123143196106,
0.011146522127091885,
-0.6490004658699036,
0.2936539351940155,
0.4482773542404175,
0.3242664039134979,
-0.16701360046863556,
-0.715668797492981,
0.14502401649951935,
-0.05544477701187134,
-0.22437132894992828,
0.26951539516448975,
0.5341222882270813,
0.1388179510831833,
0.6744182109832764,
0.4182604253292084,
0.3167598247528076,
-0.15714223682880402,
0.5318617224693298,
0.6627326607704163,
-0.6670318841934204,
-0.09307362139225006,
-0.9837633371353149,
0.2985130846500397,
-0.10674312710762024,
-0.38947203755378723,
0.8172022104263306,
0.5448119640350342,
0.14924900233745575,
0.01887483149766922,
0.6451219916343689,
0.10259835422039032,
0.6469932198524475,
-0.7010785937309265,
0.5300410985946655,
-0.503466784954071,
0.5515406131744385,
-0.1333470493555069,
-0.44086953997612,
-0.47330963611602783,
0.526357889175415,
-0.4893646836280823,
-0.13124875724315643,
1.0073802471160889,
0.5443751811981201,
0.30621644854545593,
0.42831265926361084,
0.4053371250629425,
0.42666760087013245,
0.3385322391986847,
0.5262889862060547,
0.8547379970550537,
-0.4585610628128052,
0.256154328584671,
-0.16559049487113953,
-0.3030589520931244,
-0.1561785787343979,
-0.9841998815536499,
-1.0997589826583862,
-0.18442174792289734,
-0.34223347902297974,
-0.5130586624145508,
-0.003287260653451085,
0.8695018291473389,
0.35031744837760925,
-0.8872061967849731,
0.08510855585336685,
-0.12324091047048569,
-0.09895861148834229,
0.015245514921844006,
-0.1641932725906372,
0.42496249079704285,
-0.20261798799037933,
-0.6817064881324768,
0.5285341739654541,
0.36578696966171265,
-0.13437646627426147,
-0.27197712659835815,
-0.13691353797912598,
-0.08623022586107254,
0.08472730219364166,
0.6717036366462708,
-0.1692298948764801,
-0.7780877351760864,
0.0009362049167975783,
0.1925136148929596,
-0.24821215867996216,
-0.17903196811676025,
0.6646980047225952,
-0.6362695097923279,
0.43591538071632385,
0.5182320475578308,
0.8706398010253906,
0.41349002718925476,
-0.011045464314520359,
0.6753722429275513,
-0.19812734425067902,
-0.07527163624763489,
0.7557681202888489,
0.47001442313194275,
0.18738645315170288,
-0.05758073925971985,
0.775956928730011,
0.2110939919948578,
-0.9846422076225281,
-0.8563286662101746,
-0.09126102179288864,
-0.9726439714431763,
-0.23329219222068787,
1.3723021745681763,
-0.04563794657588005,
-0.037062130868434906,
-0.27406826615333557,
-0.2766360640525818,
0.03013397939503193,
-0.059181928634643555,
0.6519644856452942,
0.634336531162262,
-0.23327820003032684,
0.06993764638900757,
-1.2237557172775269,
0.4532197415828705,
0.6266193389892578,
-1.0906912088394165,
-0.1912682205438614,
0.40603703260421753,
0.1639799177646637,
-0.1327446848154068,
0.7503834366798401,
-0.45834049582481384,
0.12653286755084991,
-0.18638876080513,
-0.1488376408815384,
0.22017231583595276,
0.028995240107178688,
-0.5510584115982056,
-0.10771050304174423,
0.09492609649896622,
0.061095818877220154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04165v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04165v1
|
LingML: Linguistic-Informed Machine Learning for Enhanced Fake News Detection
| 2024-05-07T10:03:19 | 2024-05-07T10:03:19 |
Jasraj Singh, Fang Liu, Hong Xu, Bee Chin Ng, Wei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Nowadays, Information spreads at an unprecedented pace in social media and
discerning truth from misinformation and fake news has become an acute societal
challenge. Machine learning (ML) models have been employed to identify fake
news but are far from perfect with challenging problems like limited accuracy,
interpretability, and generalizability. In this paper, we enhance ML-based
solutions with linguistics input and we propose LingML, linguistic-informed ML,
for fake news detection. We conducted an experimental study with a popular
dataset on fake news during the pandemic. The experiment results show that our
proposed solution is highly effective. There are fewer than two errors out of
every ten attempts with only linguistic input used in ML and the knowledge is
highly explainable. When linguistics input is integrated with advanced
large-scale ML models for natural language processing, our solution outperforms
existing ones with 1.8% average error rate. LingML creates a new path with
linguistics to push the frontier of effective and efficient fake news
detection. It also sheds light on real-world multi-disciplinary applications
requiring both ML and domain expertise to achieve optimal performance.
|
[
-0.3151932656764984,
-1.31033194065094,
0.485252320766449,
0.3703773617744446,
-0.37381473183631897,
0.24545103311538696,
-0.249027818441391,
-0.4907679557800293,
0.3203677535057068,
0.3983081579208374,
-0.4166911244392395,
-0.42554327845573425,
-0.8474363684654236,
0.08442814648151398,
-0.5026432275772095,
0.9031527638435364,
0.20814186334609985,
0.26586273312568665,
-0.0662953108549118,
0.09885532408952713,
-0.37204086780548096,
-0.4994684159755707,
-0.5886927247047424,
-0.22008702158927917,
0.40016284584999084,
0.4945204555988312,
0.728147029876709,
0.46634724736213684,
0.18780517578125,
0.1869264394044876,
0.1868264377117157,
0.6604046821594238,
-0.6107105016708374,
-0.22680775821208954,
-0.0008690723916515708,
-0.4384680390357971,
-0.3780690133571625,
0.05867132171988487,
0.5137770771980286,
0.4470060467720032,
0.06828411668539047,
-0.007713578175753355,
-0.2396623194217682,
0.45512738823890686,
-0.3717045485973358,
0.07063450664281845,
-0.9627536535263062,
0.11294538527727127,
-0.21071435511112213,
-0.43248188495635986,
-0.6175097227096558,
-0.26172199845314026,
-0.03968361020088196,
-1.0369373559951782,
0.20459739863872528,
0.08596300333738327,
0.9376088380813599,
0.1435544490814209,
-0.5224503874778748,
-0.369567334651947,
-0.5064220428466797,
0.6072536706924438,
-0.7813270688056946,
0.4488450288772583,
0.41498875617980957,
0.40188246965408325,
-0.3374449908733368,
-0.5494245886802673,
-0.8594310879707336,
-0.13589908182621002,
-0.13216717541217804,
0.12366078048944473,
-0.0635758563876152,
-0.2198491394519806,
-0.0349673368036747,
0.10047155618667603,
-0.958516001701355,
0.18207326531410217,
-0.2720954716205597,
-0.4465038776397705,
0.34531170129776,
-0.2262171506881714,
0.741733968257904,
-0.09480264037847519,
-0.4265693724155426,
0.12995092570781708,
-0.799310564994812,
-0.3839207887649536,
0.2608965039253235,
0.30934104323387146,
-0.006715708412230015,
0.28287145495414734,
-0.19889487326145172,
0.8096398115158081,
0.022658780217170715,
-0.17648044228553772,
0.24848438799381256,
0.024258052930235863,
-0.2742713987827301,
0.3272535502910614,
0.5569794774055481,
0.24551095068454742,
0.3323979377746582,
0.03580109402537346,
-0.22895440459251404,
0.2887905538082123,
0.30498719215393066,
-0.6177492737770081,
-0.38338732719421387,
0.08299774676561356,
-0.3305080831050873,
-0.6122419834136963,
0.26033255457878113,
-0.8230167627334595,
-0.6909675002098083,
-0.35257408022880554,
0.5116128325462341,
-0.4442276358604431,
-0.6758999228477478,
0.16117212176322937,
-0.22441889345645905,
0.1424444168806076,
0.443205326795578,
-0.3937488794326782,
0.01764543168246746,
0.9999116659164429,
0.5899401307106018,
0.02870897203683853,
-0.2555690109729767,
-1.069553017616272,
-0.02813747152686119,
-0.660922110080719,
0.7444204688072205,
-0.4265059232711792,
-0.0769960880279541,
-0.005359488073736429,
-0.09016754478216171,
0.14090153574943542,
-0.6526719927787781,
0.5181369185447693,
-0.9153895974159241,
0.4995375871658325,
-0.014100488275289536,
-0.7440977692604065,
-0.31056392192840576,
0.33108362555503845,
-0.6773104667663574,
1.0211951732635498,
-0.05391629412770271,
-0.6788179278373718,
0.5788655281066895,
-0.7804358601570129,
-0.7293044328689575,
0.29547762870788574,
0.3507525622844696,
-0.5022523999214172,
-0.04598374664783478,
0.5466582179069519,
0.49089449644088745,
0.10780694335699081,
0.6518763899803162,
-0.35478752851486206,
-0.18682871758937836,
0.3089742660522461,
-0.5249931812286377,
1.0011169910430908,
0.19897900521755219,
-0.49449262022972107,
0.09756439179182053,
-0.7916164994239807,
-0.10796643793582916,
0.20197898149490356,
-0.4341070055961609,
-0.49906161427497864,
-0.3401931822299957,
0.2401459664106369,
0.15873628854751587,
0.11762702465057373,
-0.533130943775177,
-0.06597200036048889,
-0.5450839400291443,
0.043511684983968735,
0.6956355571746826,
-0.08994268625974655,
0.4261443018913269,
-0.2784271240234375,
0.19418072700500488,
0.20886702835559845,
0.17513903975486755,
0.12116428464651108,
-0.7506145238876343,
-0.8080427646636963,
-0.2813042402267456,
0.5646123290061951,
0.7088080048561096,
-1.1204922199249268,
0.3665124773979187,
-0.15791215002536774,
-0.3527708649635315,
-0.7740257382392883,
0.31013840436935425,
0.24929361045360565,
0.5998420119285583,
0.6134411692619324,
0.13243985176086426,
-0.9593585133552551,
-0.596235454082489,
-0.7964778542518616,
-0.18396686017513275,
-0.12332876026630402,
0.16984902322292328,
0.3866002559661865,
-0.40928754210472107,
1.1896741390228271,
-0.18638169765472412,
-0.21857725083827972,
-0.38206225633621216,
0.2602819800376892,
0.21703533828258514,
0.05518365278840065,
0.4599032700061798,
-1.2814068794250488,
-0.6976028084754944,
0.17942194640636444,
-0.8222189545631409,
-0.5327654480934143,
-0.25263240933418274,
-0.040783125907182693,
0.5612539649009705,
0.22468045353889465,
-0.5902256965637207,
0.2544630467891693,
0.4857824444770813,
-0.4667259752750397,
0.734308123588562,
-0.10956501215696335,
-0.020607953891158104,
-0.9040679931640625,
-0.04516422748565674,
0.047492727637290955,
-0.5978456139564514,
-1.1431870460510254,
-0.025161603465676308,
0.3776512145996094,
-0.08371596038341522,
-0.4590259790420532,
0.9196144342422485,
-0.46377602219581604,
-0.01535091083496809,
-0.48069530725479126,
0.2852840721607208,
0.2077101767063141,
0.17832790315151215,
0.12214741110801697,
0.33750033378601074,
0.6991503238677979,
-0.6205517649650574,
0.6955481171607971,
-0.13450147211551666,
-0.5129417181015015,
0.4203025996685028,
-0.47128233313560486,
-0.03771771490573883,
-0.14177589118480682,
0.3845286965370178,
-0.587246835231781,
-0.4713602662086487,
0.5226796865463257,
-0.8153306841850281,
0.15505756437778473,
0.027362288907170296,
-0.6182324886322021,
-0.14691205322742462,
-0.021235935389995575,
0.04466468095779419,
0.38344085216522217,
-0.9803916215896606,
0.4851939380168915,
0.6177113652229309,
0.19119709730148315,
-0.6396385431289673,
-0.6313548684120178,
0.4186221957206726,
-0.14257942140102386,
-0.6507548689842224,
0.07839101552963257,
0.08765310794115067,
-0.48012062907218933,
0.21477042138576508,
-0.04627209156751633,
-0.3414541780948639,
0.12535731494426727,
0.024602729827165604,
0.3240634799003601,
-0.5328055620193481,
0.2553267776966095,
0.017753785476088524,
-0.028147142380475998,
0.07659891247749329,
-0.309685617685318,
0.4240877032279968,
-0.1616019308567047,
-0.1749923974275589,
-0.49019068479537964,
0.2160176783800125,
0.7357611656188965,
-0.09523118287324905,
0.8305714130401611,
0.9168450236320496,
-0.5187796950340271,
-0.5983809232711792,
-0.5662943124771118,
-0.314596027135849,
-0.46138158440589905,
0.2814493477344513,
-0.010331613011658192,
-0.624613881111145,
-0.02171953395009041,
-0.1486532986164093,
-0.12416142225265503,
0.45119693875312805,
0.520662248134613,
0.14061403274536133,
0.8846873044967651,
0.5273709297180176,
-0.3108672797679901,
0.12743915617465973,
0.1087627187371254,
0.4976046085357666,
-0.004609470255672932,
0.014866285026073456,
0.07725461572408676,
-0.030891919508576393,
-0.06348059326410294,
-0.5628796219825745,
0.4098378121852875,
-0.14215104281902313,
0.2153269350528717,
0.1523153930902481,
-0.31074437499046326,
0.4886905550956726,
0.6252532601356506,
0.09400121122598648,
0.38955819606781006,
-0.012485913932323456,
-0.018382130190730095,
0.2086266577243805,
-0.8394102454185486,
-0.2563321590423584,
0.7930035591125488,
0.3269757628440857,
0.4067468047142029,
0.13711611926555634,
0.24133963882923126,
0.618092954158783,
0.4828525185585022,
-0.7055361270904541,
0.5369734764099121,
-0.033606238663196564,
-0.6936284303665161,
-0.2872653901576996,
-0.6143233180046082,
-0.7115999460220337,
0.3429352641105652,
-0.3847620189189911,
0.09347474575042725,
-0.12768591940402985,
0.08836855739355087,
0.02228608727455139,
0.3921346068382263,
-0.7038672566413879,
0.802740216255188,
-0.3023807406425476,
0.23073913156986237,
-0.3735400140285492,
-0.5777305960655212,
0.4468592405319214,
-0.35055112838745117,
0.621222198009491,
-0.033672962337732315,
0.11262186616659164,
0.42480048537254333,
-0.4234232008457184,
1.1876274347305298,
-0.3865804672241211,
0.03411557152867317,
0.03851576894521713,
-0.059507228434085846,
0.5681019425392151,
0.06473752856254578,
0.06048177182674408,
0.34009164571762085,
-0.41141828894615173,
-0.36167848110198975,
-0.5170199275016785,
0.7166315317153931,
-0.5063883066177368,
-0.5527194142341614,
-0.2529411315917969,
-0.5726296901702881,
-0.24488212168216705,
0.29010337591171265,
0.23831704258918762,
0.4483749270439148,
-0.3283991515636444,
0.008334302343428135,
0.6717259287834167,
-0.4955652356147766,
0.022029228508472443,
0.747197687625885,
-0.5155214667320251,
-0.06208612024784088,
1.1979786157608032,
-0.00181272451300174,
-0.11517146974802017,
0.4131503105163574,
0.4150376617908478,
-0.22072331607341766,
-0.0977630764245987,
-0.8972738981246948,
0.17651665210723877,
-0.7032785415649414,
-0.08214116841554642,
-0.7044661045074463,
-0.2978127896785736,
-0.6813769936561584,
-0.2387937307357788,
-0.11622001230716705,
-0.32227981090545654,
-0.37449583411216736,
-0.04862866550683975,
0.37417319416999817,
0.5564695000648499,
-0.21334201097488403,
0.07106942683458328,
-0.657412588596344,
0.7860662341117859,
0.18838009238243103,
0.17814750969409943,
-0.308790922164917,
-0.5347323417663574,
-0.23831357061862946,
0.308012455701828,
0.29335859417915344,
-1.0583806037902832,
0.6528921723365784,
0.3889855444431305,
0.5690837502479553,
0.5906437039375305,
0.14203359186649323,
0.45428410172462463,
-0.3872503936290741,
0.6528999209403992,
-0.038261983543634415,
-0.8938814401626587,
0.5952634811401367,
-0.30985185503959656,
0.2302161455154419,
-0.11043906211853027,
0.5046627521514893,
-0.7276042103767395,
-0.519667387008667,
-0.4986546039581299,
-0.5018215775489807,
0.405843049287796,
-0.1289035826921463,
-0.019669296219944954,
0.08063101768493652,
-0.09312685579061508,
0.33137840032577515,
-0.04226714372634888,
-0.9321238994598389,
-0.16747836768627167,
-0.33910664916038513,
-0.06372985988855362,
0.09689568728208542,
-0.2544994056224823,
0.08549971133470535,
-0.32249903678894043,
1.1229273080825806,
-0.04287894442677498,
-0.1454543024301529,
0.044324394315481186,
-0.7082923650741577,
0.027949592098593712,
-0.0015534179983660579,
0.731429398059845,
0.6857950091362,
0.30620551109313965,
0.2097223401069641,
0.14749348163604736,
-0.4571821689605713,
-0.16275286674499512,
-0.22990216314792633,
-0.2417488694190979,
0.7031807899475098,
0.3470146656036377,
0.8010002374649048,
0.010518974624574184,
-0.8064008951187134,
0.7623732089996338,
0.1573704481124878,
-0.3334936201572418,
-0.36279481649398804,
-0.10211550444364548,
0.006635521538555622,
0.01805482618510723,
0.5552946329116821,
0.2588583528995514,
0.2174491584300995,
-0.3778893053531647,
0.3662152886390686,
0.5305024981498718,
-0.2564797103404999,
-0.2272423505783081,
0.41217848658561707,
0.2002163678407669,
-0.31242260336875916,
0.29269224405288696,
-0.2661176323890686,
-0.9175570607185364,
0.6787691712379456,
0.735771894454956,
0.5000355243682861,
-0.4847571551799774,
0.6554415225982666,
0.07975991815328598,
0.4933026432991028,
-0.15937525033950806,
-0.058111969381570816,
0.2176266461610794,
-0.9661346077919006,
-0.4810142517089844,
-0.5842317938804626,
-0.3852024972438812,
0.3967239260673523,
-0.18245665729045868,
0.4405554533004761,
-0.25391167402267456,
0.2094632387161255,
0.04085729271173477,
-0.16488592326641083,
-0.2106362134218216,
0.21539387106895447,
0.33034732937812805,
0.9217620491981506,
-0.9203494191169739,
0.8696434497833252,
0.6075789332389832,
0.2843855619430542,
-0.4231717884540558,
0.028524557128548622,
0.4636181592941284,
-0.8227009773254395,
0.6736945509910583,
0.3994186520576477,
0.07639965415000916,
-0.12548348307609558,
-0.529347836971283,
-0.47349345684051514,
0.3044711947441101,
0.4398837387561798,
-0.2189345806837082,
0.39713549613952637,
0.47658830881118774,
0.48259425163269043,
-0.28969693183898926,
-0.22751355171203613,
0.31270939111709595,
0.8703303933143616,
-0.1567959487438202,
-0.8336172699928284,
-0.16968229413032532,
-0.5325524806976318,
-0.2924059331417084,
0.2194717675447464,
-0.1272854506969452,
0.6105806827545166,
-0.0496804304420948,
-0.34399518370628357,
-0.4781012237071991,
0.6982240080833435,
0.04327237233519554,
0.8471527695655823,
0.6521341800689697,
0.5137097239494324,
1.0728143453598022,
-0.002177625196054578,
0.851679265499115,
-0.18819013237953186,
0.10038689523935318,
0.8939751982688904,
-0.1047901138663292,
0.6169529557228088,
0.10962264239788055,
0.2721482813358307,
0.5508414506912231,
0.7142696976661682,
-0.09561505913734436,
0.37494876980781555,
0.17584945261478424,
-0.5292935967445374,
-0.22052448987960815,
-0.02911960706114769,
-0.15475815534591675,
0.38038790225982666,
0.6292166113853455,
-0.2762329578399658,
-0.20102015137672424,
0.5060657858848572,
0.2232799381017685,
0.0682377889752388,
-0.5257882475852966,
0.5801489949226379,
-0.14733552932739258,
-0.445586234331131,
0.606273889541626,
0.1516682356595993,
0.8619480133056641,
-0.32157567143440247,
-0.050734780728816986,
-0.14230860769748688,
0.03465316444635391,
-0.2953377664089203,
-0.5009304285049438,
0.4269999861717224,
0.09381536394357681,
-0.26911500096321106,
-0.30293914675712585,
1.3878859281539917,
-0.6948348879814148,
-0.4113020896911621,
0.23705866932868958,
0.6042678356170654,
0.3152075409889221,
-0.4307609796524048,
-0.5213614106178284,
-0.15783753991127014,
-0.16546274721622467,
-0.23229224979877472,
0.22833359241485596,
0.5555456876754761,
-0.07381870597600937,
0.6413165926933289,
1.0786129236221313,
0.3112291097640991,
0.3056575357913971,
-0.019441187381744385,
0.6338620781898499,
-0.14200283586978912,
-0.6206353306770325,
-0.9059441685676575,
0.23979082703590393,
-0.5200104117393494,
-0.19191649556159973,
0.8239400386810303,
0.5818908214569092,
0.8110997676849365,
-0.30195683240890503,
0.926939070224762,
0.10274871438741684,
0.737891674041748,
-0.5496968626976013,
1.078303575515747,
-0.5594508051872253,
0.26286742091178894,
0.09898020327091217,
-0.6591986417770386,
-0.6719993352890015,
0.4195956587791443,
-0.3314124345779419,
-0.31601694226264954,
0.47927817702293396,
0.9258792996406555,
-0.2147676795721054,
0.00843748264014721,
0.6320875287055969,
0.4422440230846405,
0.08949246257543564,
0.2293291538953781,
0.7755550146102905,
-0.05027638375759125,
0.40978890657424927,
-0.08275596052408218,
-0.34397876262664795,
-0.7298217415809631,
-0.7107317447662354,
-0.8692007660865784,
-0.5962533354759216,
-0.2150496542453766,
-0.21486440300941467,
0.1827719360589981,
0.6187713742256165,
0.787527859210968,
-0.7766075730323792,
0.21110619604587555,
-0.008220002986490726,
0.35866230726242065,
-0.2294253259897232,
-0.39076557755470276,
0.24284429848194122,
-0.45250535011291504,
-0.617630660533905,
0.7699975967407227,
0.29827040433883667,
-0.3384998142719269,
-0.2941732406616211,
-0.10162651538848877,
-0.1639389991760254,
0.35357022285461426,
0.7508652210235596,
0.35902348160743713,
-0.8457119464874268,
-0.22000561654567719,
0.05918578803539276,
-0.24650126695632935,
-0.17717568576335907,
0.6938779354095459,
-1.084465742111206,
0.3756677508354187,
0.427438884973526,
1.0044270753860474,
0.21968311071395874,
-0.065114326775074,
0.5209684371948242,
-0.8182194232940674,
0.11286675184965134,
0.17380550503730774,
0.2996622622013092,
0.4224541187286377,
-0.8251973986625671,
0.3800289034843445,
0.5168031454086304,
-0.40551942586898804,
-0.8941156268119812,
0.0767713263630867,
-0.6902757287025452,
-0.8016767501831055,
1.376172423362732,
0.1508406698703766,
-0.3105202615261078,
-0.49811044335365295,
-0.22353732585906982,
0.32368403673171997,
-0.22348231077194214,
0.9132686853408813,
0.688068151473999,
0.2114337831735611,
-0.16079950332641602,
-0.6011329889297485,
0.6314859390258789,
0.5280686020851135,
-0.9269804954528809,
-0.18901604413986206,
0.620996356010437,
0.2702667713165283,
0.01146661676466465,
0.4505387544631958,
0.14329001307487488,
0.623938798904419,
-0.1243433728814125,
-0.09021973609924316,
-0.1270596832036972,
-0.5166453719139099,
-0.2241821587085724,
0.15166409313678741,
-0.4073621332645416,
0.06663979589939117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04163v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04163v1
|
MEDVOC: Vocabulary Adaptation for Fine-tuning Pre-trained Language Models on Medical Text Summarization
| 2024-05-07T10:00:00 | 2024-05-07T10:00:00 |
Gunjan Balde, Soumyadeep Roy, Mainack Mondal, Niloy Ganguly
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This work presents a dynamic vocabulary adaptation strategy, MEDVOC, for
fine-tuning pre-trained language models (PLMs) like BertSumAbs, BART, and
PEGASUS for improved medical text summarization. In contrast to existing domain
adaptation approaches in summarization, MEDVOC treats vocabulary as an
optimizable parameter and optimizes the PLM vocabulary based on fragment score
conditioned only on the downstream task's reference summaries. Unlike previous
works on vocabulary adaptation (limited only to classification tasks),
optimizing vocabulary based on summarization tasks requires an extremely costly
intermediate fine-tuning step on large summarization datasets. To that end, our
novel fragment score-based hyperparameter search very significantly reduces
this fine-tuning time -- from 450 days to less than 2 days on average.
Furthermore, while previous works on vocabulary adaptation are often primarily
tied to single PLMs, MEDVOC is designed to be deployable across multiple PLMs
(with varying model vocabulary sizes, pre-training objectives, and model sizes)
-- bridging the limited vocabulary overlap between the biomedical literature
domain and PLMs. MEDVOC outperforms baselines by 15.74% in terms of Rouge-L in
zero-shot setting and shows gains of 17.29% in high Out-Of-Vocabulary (OOV)
concentrations. Our human evaluation shows MEDVOC generates more faithful
medical summaries (88% compared to 59% in baselines). We make the codebase
publicly available at https://github.com/gb-kgp/MEDVOC.
|
[
-0.37910962104797363,
-0.47433018684387207,
0.42020922899246216,
0.08730464428663254,
-0.8167591094970703,
0.1891990602016449,
-0.16693072021007538,
-0.07302618771791458,
0.34062692523002625,
0.5497556328773499,
-0.40543413162231445,
-0.727695107460022,
-0.6217050552368164,
0.1834203153848648,
0.07744824141263962,
1.3501402139663696,
-0.028601858764886856,
0.17195406556129456,
-0.3813492953777313,
-0.48790454864501953,
-0.453403502702713,
-0.5894489288330078,
-0.5722965598106384,
-0.23704089224338531,
0.7387726902961731,
0.2843579351902008,
0.5660282969474792,
0.542579174041748,
0.8040503859519958,
0.20705319941043854,
-0.09633053839206696,
0.4951016306877136,
-0.5983585715293884,
0.2424129992723465,
-0.27795860171318054,
-0.4424610435962677,
-0.6178331971168518,
-0.3029729425907135,
0.5384829044342041,
0.5513521432876587,
-0.41806119680404663,
-0.03941437229514122,
0.036248769611120224,
1.0471243858337402,
-0.8133716583251953,
0.12036260217428207,
-0.7615867257118225,
-0.10394473373889923,
-0.0908626839518547,
-0.6107860207557678,
-0.33093321323394775,
-0.26404011249542236,
0.20949384570121765,
-0.8928496837615967,
0.07397452741861343,
-0.07368957251310349,
0.9903016090393066,
0.3609412610530853,
-0.1857670098543167,
-0.1436537504196167,
-0.3549695312976837,
0.6530562043190002,
-0.700694739818573,
-0.026599671691656113,
0.4575101435184479,
0.36053013801574707,
-0.23808149993419647,
-0.9048479199409485,
-0.14299972355365753,
-0.21562978625297546,
0.39452382922172546,
0.6849493980407715,
0.045155320316553116,
0.31313472986221313,
-0.3840465843677521,
0.28721341490745544,
-0.4274574816226959,
0.0953221395611763,
-0.36994650959968567,
-0.14220771193504333,
0.26102596521377563,
0.39431390166282654,
0.006617017090320587,
0.07237408310174942,
-0.3155079782009125,
0.087955541908741,
-0.6221021413803101,
-0.1692919284105301,
-0.04352403059601784,
0.21522557735443115,
-0.19109903275966644,
0.3933373689651489,
-0.08408727496862411,
0.8916542530059814,
-0.06626010686159134,
-0.06902524828910828,
0.47121676802635193,
-0.549651563167572,
-0.2356332689523697,
0.07292623817920685,
0.4878753423690796,
0.6545185446739197,
0.24381324648857117,
0.1630244255065918,
-0.07110711187124252,
-0.2848180830478668,
0.8429258465766907,
-0.973139226436615,
-0.46191516518592834,
0.1265724003314972,
-0.763991117477417,
-0.5479143261909485,
-0.1793351173400879,
-0.4838525056838989,
-0.4946815073490143,
-0.17607249319553375,
0.6720900535583496,
-0.34507885575294495,
0.1861346811056137,
0.4886425733566284,
0.008051007986068726,
0.050479672849178314,
0.5312787890434265,
-0.641115128993988,
0.6444364786148071,
0.5179415345191956,
1.3041268587112427,
-0.4469524621963501,
-0.3478078544139862,
-0.6303677558898926,
-0.11232315003871918,
-0.5168030261993408,
1.0527429580688477,
-0.19347402453422546,
-0.5320374369621277,
-0.09870044887065887,
0.16113772988319397,
-0.10002131760120392,
-0.6883342862129211,
0.36894503235816956,
-0.328774094581604,
0.2683941721916199,
0.008033493533730507,
-0.6051384806632996,
-0.07399649918079376,
0.21883347630500793,
-0.4875269830226898,
0.6089237332344055,
0.32126399874687195,
-0.804568350315094,
0.3250359892845154,
-0.8060855865478516,
-0.6285136342048645,
0.14052942395210266,
0.042686354368925095,
-0.4504866898059845,
0.26428741216659546,
0.2747453451156616,
0.5891567468643188,
-0.2469191998243332,
-0.028752001002430916,
-0.12605427205562592,
-0.2713373601436615,
0.24501527845859528,
-0.14483408629894257,
0.40339934825897217,
0.3037419617176056,
0.23320741951465607,
0.3776111900806427,
-0.6710693836212158,
-0.21023255586624146,
0.08429603278636932,
-0.5650250315666199,
-0.6157042980194092,
0.30720242857933044,
-0.03167352452874184,
0.08596863597631454,
0.09479366987943649,
-0.208455890417099,
0.3904763162136078,
-0.9820308089256287,
0.21894384920597076,
0.5180051326751709,
0.23303793370723724,
0.35181674361228943,
-0.6894501447677612,
0.5323200225830078,
-0.0034824234899133444,
0.35565224289894104,
-0.16738328337669373,
-0.4565295875072479,
-0.49546077847480774,
-0.6002375483512878,
0.6224157214164734,
0.6295982599258423,
-1.1184483766555786,
0.6477243900299072,
-0.3312523663043976,
-0.5566410422325134,
-0.7638847827911377,
-0.14897829294204712,
0.33307352662086487,
0.6501321196556091,
0.5387229323387146,
-0.7464873194694519,
-0.40903612971305847,
-0.716490626335144,
-0.2524929940700531,
-0.05848640203475952,
-0.22334250807762146,
0.4548022747039795,
0.4702942669391632,
-0.05990569666028023,
0.5034184455871582,
-0.6038604378700256,
-0.5988033413887024,
-0.4371039569377899,
0.1411656141281128,
0.4385945200920105,
0.21262654662132263,
0.7546337246894836,
-0.6319897174835205,
-0.3736649453639984,
-0.04604654014110565,
-0.18511752784252167,
-0.24790847301483154,
-0.31122201681137085,
-0.055069901049137115,
0.019891532137989998,
0.5414862036705017,
-0.07314476370811462,
0.29941287636756897,
0.8940733075141907,
-0.39601945877075195,
0.5300565361976624,
-0.9963951706886292,
0.2026538997888565,
-1.5279346704483032,
0.015469652600586414,
-0.23763202130794525,
-0.4397408068180084,
-0.4991382956504822,
-0.17074525356292725,
0.016672775149345398,
0.26003560423851013,
-0.6693092584609985,
0.549935519695282,
-0.4093300998210907,
0.3109649419784546,
-0.5550459027290344,
0.08859016001224518,
0.11123234033584595,
0.2073153555393219,
-0.124754898250103,
0.7607086896896362,
0.6355075836181641,
-0.8432568311691284,
0.27008113265037537,
0.31203576922416687,
-0.47834330797195435,
0.2996532618999481,
-0.5674754977226257,
-0.2300543189048767,
-0.16572512686252594,
0.30700352787971497,
-0.6065894365310669,
-0.20464682579040527,
0.018998850136995316,
-0.5451995134353638,
0.2444816380739212,
-0.2587646245956421,
-0.28236594796180725,
-0.003932402469217777,
-0.4778772294521332,
0.3988218903541565,
0.589702308177948,
-0.30285897850990295,
0.7104003429412842,
0.5998725295066833,
-0.39321398735046387,
-0.30314990878105164,
-0.6527584791183472,
0.17682930827140808,
0.214689239859581,
-0.1480712741613388,
0.6051430702209473,
-0.15012453496456146,
0.10759688168764114,
-0.23206941783428192,
-0.13424775004386902,
-0.18989910185337067,
0.13758668303489685,
0.13993790745735168,
0.36673083901405334,
-0.21198293566703796,
0.3383252024650574,
0.3956558108329773,
-0.08187709003686905,
-0.27172937989234924,
-0.2796940803527832,
0.5329120755195618,
0.07457134872674942,
-0.06205035746097565,
-0.1577301025390625,
0.177106112241745,
0.8964666128158569,
-0.2880084216594696,
1.042197585105896,
0.2937546968460083,
-0.24242959916591644,
-0.0051839351654052734,
-0.33442774415016174,
-0.07455793768167496,
-0.39027050137519836,
0.7847766876220703,
-0.2133524864912033,
-0.6535807847976685,
0.5939379334449768,
-0.29545658826828003,
0.12758636474609375,
0.4970158040523529,
1.0964053869247437,
-0.11321194469928741,
0.7444037199020386,
0.4670155644416809,
-0.1794227808713913,
0.476954847574234,
0.037868648767471313,
-0.36294782161712646,
-0.6489396691322327,
-0.09260597825050354,
-0.40702447295188904,
-0.19308966398239136,
-0.38403260707855225,
-0.6653630137443542,
0.5663313865661621,
-0.25676873326301575,
0.18704797327518463,
0.02904698997735977,
-0.5126296281814575,
0.5268909335136414,
0.27311697602272034,
0.1616620272397995,
0.14080117642879486,
-0.08282241225242615,
-0.3318009674549103,
0.10470467805862427,
-0.7598906755447388,
-0.06127539649605751,
1.1435344219207764,
0.2909877598285675,
0.7693723440170288,
-0.03440281003713608,
0.6206876635551453,
0.23646026849746704,
0.3236735463142395,
-1.0322580337524414,
0.28258779644966125,
-0.7186598777770996,
-0.43293526768684387,
-0.07536465674638748,
-0.3546724021434784,
-1.2074021100997925,
0.3096899688243866,
-0.45151203870773315,
-0.16725747287273407,
0.11775168031454086,
0.17881740629673004,
-0.6998055577278137,
0.16369672119617462,
-0.6452576518058777,
0.7337691187858582,
-0.0900459960103035,
-0.015461520291864872,
-0.34708601236343384,
-0.7360683083534241,
-0.12755565345287323,
-0.40743333101272583,
0.23892295360565186,
-0.2524261772632599,
-0.5828405022621155,
0.8010851144790649,
-0.5798258185386658,
0.6102167367935181,
-0.15253321826457977,
0.23127061128616333,
-0.01847861334681511,
-0.020185306668281555,
0.3232537806034088,
-0.09176800400018692,
0.012929457239806652,
0.1821717619895935,
0.23815466463565826,
-0.6495273113250732,
-0.47482067346572876,
0.5450022220611572,
-0.5163142085075378,
-0.1679680198431015,
-0.4537402391433716,
-0.6850489974021912,
-0.27775347232818604,
0.2243577539920807,
0.39571672677993774,
0.5185139775276184,
-0.37668323516845703,
0.4647504389286041,
0.6782855987548828,
-0.4175426959991455,
0.10205424576997757,
0.7042236328125,
-0.03632130101323128,
-0.629772424697876,
0.7910598516464233,
-0.013783693313598633,
0.3082931637763977,
0.5560290813446045,
0.2746262848377228,
0.011033161543309689,
-1.067604660987854,
-0.3005496561527252,
0.2976822257041931,
-0.3386070132255554,
-0.35882845520973206,
-0.46041175723075867,
-0.25049614906311035,
-0.2789255976676941,
-0.31278589367866516,
-0.5881029963493347,
-0.20256055891513824,
-0.5452249050140381,
0.17360545694828033,
0.5250706076622009,
0.479856938123703,
0.25550156831741333,
0.3884628415107727,
-0.9877031445503235,
0.5200730562210083,
-0.08750388026237488,
0.41698944568634033,
-0.5986930727958679,
-1.0396537780761719,
-0.5846855044364929,
-0.3599303960800171,
0.02622830495238304,
-0.7645717263221741,
0.5482096076011658,
0.5197708606719971,
0.30429965257644653,
0.3110862076282501,
0.08931796252727509,
0.6021039485931396,
-0.7660726308822632,
0.6507574319839478,
0.2983108460903168,
-0.5443479418754578,
0.5114765167236328,
-0.2943181097507477,
0.7312219738960266,
0.8803452253341675,
0.32630565762519836,
-0.3531481623649597,
-0.33389851450920105,
-0.363796204328537,
-0.9235544800758362,
0.43427774310112,
0.2634528577327728,
0.0858101025223732,
0.2540963292121887,
0.5142159461975098,
0.18528927862644196,
0.08657374978065491,
-0.01625729911029339,
-0.3315114676952362,
-0.1206449419260025,
-0.6071139574050903,
-0.31708019971847534,
-0.24422495067119598,
-0.1897123157978058,
-0.570302426815033,
0.6601950526237488,
-0.3241032361984253,
0.1040450930595398,
0.4118136167526245,
-0.04774686321616173,
0.17173390090465546,
0.12293697893619537,
0.9550759196281433,
0.6157468557357788,
-0.2791803479194641,
-0.0653502568602562,
0.43206679821014404,
-1.111050009727478,
-0.15505261719226837,
0.39074012637138367,
0.18873156607151031,
0.2784527838230133,
0.3697730004787445,
0.7595435380935669,
0.3727816045284271,
-0.8165844082832336,
0.7679079174995422,
-0.37981024384498596,
-0.5870655179023743,
0.024619590491056442,
0.06788023561239243,
-0.0631360337138176,
0.03886619955301285,
0.11544611304998398,
0.2756567597389221,
0.07234150171279907,
-0.22727449238300323,
0.2305869609117508,
0.019364871084690094,
-0.43822282552719116,
-0.24373838305473328,
0.4715086817741394,
0.2880239188671112,
-0.025836296379566193,
0.006278305780142546,
0.1864081770181656,
-0.16807179152965546,
0.3804205656051636,
0.29289761185646057,
0.8161444664001465,
-0.49042433500289917,
0.09783871471881866,
0.05525674298405647,
0.18758149445056915,
-0.11486402899026871,
0.35054469108581543,
0.18416208028793335,
-0.6260567307472229,
-0.6268008947372437,
-0.6151279807090759,
-0.38666149973869324,
0.007948694750666618,
-0.612830638885498,
0.2522415816783905,
-0.33187708258628845,
-0.2384713888168335,
0.17037378251552582,
-0.06529708951711655,
-0.25088998675346375,
0.20454950630664825,
-0.0726592093706131,
1.1396220922470093,
-0.5855434536933899,
1.1369901895523071,
0.9036012887954712,
-0.2167181521654129,
-0.44823867082595825,
-0.1280711144208908,
-0.11097563803195953,
-0.8503741025924683,
0.009269250556826591,
-0.33316493034362793,
-0.16074706614017487,
0.04902388155460358,
-0.37517401576042175,
-0.5971542000770569,
0.9992440938949585,
0.2214713841676712,
-0.6195089221000671,
-0.11869294196367264,
-0.40288057923316956,
0.8366945385932922,
-0.5439574122428894,
-0.10533356666564941,
0.504219114780426,
0.10878502577543259,
0.044899120926856995,
-1.0572468042373657,
-0.23726433515548706,
-0.16766759753227234,
-0.12444449216127396,
0.19274206459522247,
-0.38837334513664246,
0.5626680850982666,
-0.23337015509605408,
0.2644153833389282,
0.20518869161605835,
0.4642110764980316,
0.10099471360445023,
0.28067272901535034,
0.41573160886764526,
0.22500546276569366,
0.6274553537368774,
0.09478283673524857,
1.154759168624878,
-0.254736989736557,
0.2947474420070648,
1.173891305923462,
-0.15098269283771515,
0.7811069488525391,
0.5014169812202454,
-0.0985826626420021,
0.4897148907184601,
0.5809764266014099,
-0.08645888417959213,
0.8840647339820862,
0.28934040665626526,
-0.33780115842819214,
-0.1865699589252472,
0.01731041632592678,
-0.37828174233436584,
0.46589571237564087,
0.5230026245117188,
-0.5259436368942261,
-0.19394944608211517,
0.2718891501426697,
0.041431911289691925,
-0.043850384652614594,
-0.5855062007904053,
1.1684095859527588,
0.12116803228855133,
-0.575255274772644,
0.9056003093719482,
-0.07638894766569138,
0.5138116478919983,
-0.8644431233406067,
0.13973094522953033,
-0.08435312658548355,
0.422580748796463,
-0.07597484439611435,
-0.489374577999115,
0.07995986193418503,
-0.13354092836380005,
-0.229530930519104,
0.14387823641300201,
0.8486276865005493,
-0.35792669653892517,
-0.38664060831069946,
0.0930253267288208,
0.6048796772956848,
0.326388418674469,
-0.20513607561588287,
-0.9398087859153748,
-0.13010916113853455,
-0.009824169799685478,
-0.25889575481414795,
0.5624334812164307,
0.3033211827278137,
0.20220282673835754,
0.6120813488960266,
0.5982952117919922,
0.7241389155387878,
-0.15758992731571198,
0.5294622182846069,
1.00629723072052,
-0.4765367805957794,
-0.5002608299255371,
-0.7172869443893433,
0.40441465377807617,
0.043210264295339584,
-0.522383451461792,
0.2712273895740509,
0.6332722306251526,
0.45461583137512207,
-0.3880932331085205,
0.5920154452323914,
0.41471344232559204,
0.6562055349349976,
-0.6601209044456482,
1.1945761442184448,
-0.7997866868972778,
-0.08846696466207504,
-0.04456878453493118,
-0.5088580846786499,
-0.7198957204818726,
0.3381504714488983,
0.02402542158961296,
-0.11937728524208069,
0.9009795188903809,
0.7549761533737183,
0.08503081649541855,
-0.4933220446109772,
0.6180135607719421,
0.3362674117088318,
0.07616449147462845,
0.38501492142677307,
0.42712831497192383,
-0.2523626983165741,
0.5457049608230591,
0.016503607854247093,
-0.4656183123588562,
-0.5296809077262878,
-0.8252725601196289,
-0.8940337300300598,
-0.5762124061584473,
-0.3711143732070923,
-0.4108812212944031,
0.39641571044921875,
0.9533367156982422,
0.6954987049102783,
-0.9698882102966309,
0.0968150645494461,
0.0037922377232462168,
-0.24391740560531616,
-0.41564297676086426,
-0.1259484887123108,
0.44718074798583984,
-0.5269637703895569,
-0.3968799412250519,
0.46680545806884766,
0.5937893986701965,
-0.01655357889831066,
0.10102350264787674,
-0.13576623797416687,
-0.22248531877994537,
0.354937344789505,
0.6972756385803223,
0.1384960412979126,
-0.5281381607055664,
0.005532511044293642,
-0.14965635538101196,
-0.22022745013237,
0.281351238489151,
1.0125654935836792,
-0.8376491665840149,
0.8561081886291504,
0.5036790370941162,
0.7081615924835205,
0.2823781669139862,
0.040701791644096375,
0.5224249958992004,
-0.6672850251197815,
0.08873111009597778,
0.5433403849601746,
0.27057379484176636,
-0.08601053804159164,
-0.038781195878982544,
0.20488958060741425,
0.20533351600170135,
-0.6431427597999573,
-0.710922122001648,
-0.11551143229007721,
-1.2626744508743286,
-0.5802711844444275,
0.9893653392791748,
-0.08168234676122665,
-0.3650282919406891,
-0.41926857829093933,
-0.6391245722770691,
0.4128948450088501,
-0.28205356001853943,
0.8515284061431885,
0.49588167667388916,
0.000481874099932611,
0.29446107149124146,
-0.5581552982330322,
0.6929113268852234,
0.4832872450351715,
-0.9866732358932495,
-0.032419558614492416,
0.20717492699623108,
0.345889151096344,
-0.07158456742763519,
0.692935585975647,
-0.25767791271209717,
0.513924777507782,
-0.3687634766101837,
0.2617463171482086,
-0.1795123815536499,
-0.2552299201488495,
-0.6531530618667603,
0.09143359959125519,
0.03799695521593094,
-0.5166105031967163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04160v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04160v1
|
A Causal Explainable Guardrails for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-07T09:55:05 | 2024-05-07T09:55:05 |
Zhixuan Chu, Yan Wang, Longfei Li, Zhibo Wang, Zhan Qin, Kui Ren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown impressive performance in natural
language tasks, but their outputs can exhibit undesirable attributes or biases.
Existing methods for steering LLMs towards desired attributes often assume
unbiased representations and rely solely on steering prompts. However, the
representations learned from pre-training can introduce semantic biases that
influence the steering process, leading to suboptimal results. We propose
LLMGuardaril, a novel framework that incorporates causal analysis and
adversarial learning to obtain unbiased steering representations in LLMs.
LLMGuardaril systematically identifies and blocks the confounding effects of
biases, enabling the extraction of unbiased steering representations.
Additionally, it includes an explainable component that provides insights into
the alignment between the generated output and the desired direction.
Experiments demonstrate LLMGuardaril's effectiveness in steering LLMs towards
desired attributes while mitigating biases. Our work contributes to the
development of safe and reliable LLMs that align with desired attributes. We
discuss the limitations and future research directions, highlighting the need
for ongoing research to address the ethical implications of large language
models.
|
[
-0.34804174304008484,
-0.8920368552207947,
0.7571880221366882,
0.3008507788181305,
-0.20613178610801697,
-0.09970441460609436,
-0.25714993476867676,
-0.14593090116977692,
0.08264194428920746,
0.7523263692855835,
-0.5336758494377136,
-0.30187222361564636,
-0.9640290141105652,
-0.32576173543930054,
-0.49649477005004883,
1.1869940757751465,
-0.048711784183979034,
0.17852334678173065,
0.06090162694454193,
-0.09108173847198486,
-0.43976229429244995,
-0.4331793189048767,
-0.714556872844696,
-0.820083498954773,
0.8704832792282104,
0.20077702403068542,
0.9776328206062317,
0.7616670727729797,
0.19704613089561462,
0.230178564786911,
0.005106679163873196,
-0.03399559482932091,
-0.567937433719635,
0.0529659129679203,
-0.28614377975463867,
-0.2613673508167267,
-0.46312037110328674,
0.15585950016975403,
0.6148120760917664,
0.7005442380905151,
-0.2615303695201874,
-0.1594497114419937,
0.22727473080158234,
0.5674935579299927,
-0.556540846824646,
0.13889138400554657,
-0.618576169013977,
-0.1961095631122589,
-0.4187197685241699,
-0.3677637279033661,
-0.44442227482795715,
-0.4155537486076355,
0.0466429628431797,
-0.6035520434379578,
-0.11752033233642578,
0.2505221366882324,
0.8966699242591858,
0.2947271466255188,
-0.69887775182724,
-0.3343890905380249,
-0.7514739036560059,
0.8937092423439026,
-0.7505821585655212,
0.30663737654685974,
0.18129119277000427,
0.28573325276374817,
-0.6180751919746399,
-0.184083491563797,
-0.5413481593132019,
-0.3630863428115845,
-0.13790394365787506,
-0.09873881191015244,
-0.4175993502140045,
0.0858597531914711,
-0.005213018506765366,
-0.07757837325334549,
-0.49327385425567627,
0.7902489900588989,
-0.23464341461658478,
-0.15962113440036774,
0.6965702772140503,
0.03379693254828453,
0.40942949056625366,
-0.06630214303731918,
-0.4195544719696045,
-0.13901929557323456,
-1.1207540035247803,
-0.0919567123055458,
0.7534081935882568,
0.37261608242988586,
-0.0738833099603653,
0.5379008650779724,
0.009254418313503265,
0.587968111038208,
0.16628903150558472,
-0.06088357791304588,
-0.05222047120332718,
0.33843010663986206,
-0.20851176977157593,
0.32012954354286194,
1.064522385597229,
0.12985777854919434,
0.3989737927913666,
-0.4024944007396698,
-0.016509084030985832,
0.05358723923563957,
0.36450138688087463,
-0.6805601119995117,
-0.1823175847530365,
0.2381829023361206,
-0.12959709763526917,
-0.6389746069908142,
-0.028180429711937904,
-1.0550785064697266,
-0.6475550532341003,
-0.442469984292984,
0.3739955425262451,
-0.2329477220773697,
-0.2046155482530594,
0.07973796874284744,
0.16655683517456055,
0.273266464471817,
0.2211151272058487,
-0.9343059062957764,
-0.0010995903285220265,
0.7440089583396912,
0.4341775178909302,
-0.3723524212837219,
-0.36484000086784363,
-0.6062645316123962,
0.4362240731716156,
-0.3614457845687866,
0.6006425619125366,
-0.4768696129322052,
-0.2622506022453308,
0.09147212654352188,
0.03893711790442467,
0.11940816044807434,
-0.20853663980960846,
0.6547063589096069,
-0.6838972568511963,
0.11715155839920044,
-0.2620641589164734,
-0.23131966590881348,
-0.30906644463539124,
-0.07601824402809143,
-0.6278184056282043,
0.6877121925354004,
-0.33929815888404846,
-0.9117349982261658,
0.31545189023017883,
-0.36895671486854553,
-0.5769590735435486,
-0.41202113032341003,
-0.27147531509399414,
-0.5211473703384399,
0.1630898416042328,
0.3561421036720276,
0.5800532698631287,
-0.6535553336143494,
1.0793743133544922,
-0.4972650110721588,
0.05037105828523636,
0.28552332520484924,
-0.9546392560005188,
0.8758994340896606,
0.08366461843252182,
-0.46473097801208496,
0.47194772958755493,
-0.7007125616073608,
-0.34449103474617004,
0.12570296227931976,
-0.11023658514022827,
-0.5153397917747498,
0.12274347245693207,
-0.1691252440214157,
0.18458880484104156,
0.13236086070537567,
-0.314384788274765,
-0.05936957150697708,
-0.2598166763782501,
0.10731882601976395,
1.3308261632919312,
-0.178081214427948,
0.8055463433265686,
-0.04325539991259575,
0.4480147659778595,
-0.06680706143379211,
0.19118693470954895,
0.42129048705101013,
-0.29053908586502075,
-0.84328293800354,
-0.2510809004306793,
-0.047065526247024536,
0.32175466418266296,
-0.7725976705551147,
0.32950064539909363,
-0.28903675079345703,
-0.38987308740615845,
-0.414554238319397,
0.35986417531967163,
0.6553156971931458,
0.5510163307189941,
0.1962137073278427,
-0.06811042129993439,
-0.32082411646842957,
-1.1302475929260254,
-0.26717981696128845,
-0.24504071474075317,
0.00889463722705841,
-0.08810386061668396,
0.4468144476413727,
-0.08354421705007553,
0.5545963048934937,
-0.4993581175804138,
-0.19223915040493011,
-0.414358526468277,
0.411822646856308,
0.19352905452251434,
0.4023939371109009,
0.5368615984916687,
-0.8746591210365295,
0.11583481729030609,
0.05921074375510216,
-0.8484324216842651,
-0.4851648807525635,
-0.155491903424263,
-0.5873017907142639,
-0.16591349244117737,
0.5461556315422058,
-0.6071563363075256,
0.18565227091312408,
0.5992231965065002,
-0.34046727418899536,
0.526382565498352,
-0.16204462945461273,
-0.08626285940408707,
-0.8151184916496277,
0.07266201078891754,
0.10504268109798431,
-0.07204502075910568,
-0.7196070551872253,
0.0729759931564331,
-0.05538340285420418,
0.2806728184223175,
-0.33989396691322327,
0.6149753928184509,
-0.28083547949790955,
0.04283876717090607,
-0.3203056752681732,
0.23957698047161102,
0.00563471857458353,
0.611622154712677,
-0.16124345362186432,
0.42904365062713623,
0.492011159658432,
-0.7087487578392029,
0.34591570496559143,
0.21064120531082153,
-0.05250433087348938,
0.7286871075630188,
-0.692494809627533,
-0.3057857155799866,
-0.4887891709804535,
0.1877380758523941,
-0.714967668056488,
-0.3428753912448883,
0.18593433499336243,
-0.3299944996833801,
0.624539852142334,
-0.0922393947839737,
-0.13202321529388428,
-0.19190895557403564,
-0.23391962051391602,
-0.00484045222401619,
0.39980846643447876,
-0.7275432348251343,
0.7420041561126709,
0.617011308670044,
-0.09842253476381302,
-0.6478003859519958,
-0.5333348512649536,
-0.04486999660730362,
-0.6468170881271362,
-0.32832905650138855,
0.19983676075935364,
0.4047463536262512,
-0.32573965191841125,
-0.08166133612394333,
0.13922791182994843,
0.02668178826570511,
0.3906398117542267,
0.38522812724113464,
0.5045286417007446,
-0.0010477524483576417,
0.09645269066095352,
-0.027554383501410484,
-0.3190530240535736,
0.38742268085479736,
-0.40044260025024414,
0.40942585468292236,
0.2656457722187042,
-0.4112645387649536,
-0.14181800186634064,
0.3327106237411499,
0.6790680885314941,
-0.23954856395721436,
0.9500852823257446,
0.6705944538116455,
-0.12103649973869324,
-0.3448227345943451,
-0.46211448311805725,
-0.022610032930970192,
-0.4639289379119873,
0.5458043217658997,
0.1658383011817932,
-1.031502604484558,
0.3401632308959961,
0.09781157970428467,
0.16716426610946655,
0.40860339999198914,
0.6504740715026855,
0.11671768873929977,
1.1324092149734497,
0.703357994556427,
-0.5157507658004761,
0.4004027843475342,
0.15124650299549103,
0.47501224279403687,
-0.7280056476593018,
-0.29295092821121216,
-0.5631074905395508,
-0.07213147729635239,
-0.7562383413314819,
-0.25074565410614014,
0.4421331584453583,
0.0498381108045578,
-0.6059414148330688,
0.13660025596618652,
-0.19356659054756165,
0.23605398833751678,
0.6784025430679321,
-0.025814281776547432,
0.17080672085285187,
-0.20049944519996643,
-0.18121805787086487,
0.05910090357065201,
-0.6281688809394836,
-0.5690078735351562,
0.8893967866897583,
0.3019016981124878,
1.278509259223938,
0.1753818392753601,
0.31052473187446594,
0.18389855325222015,
0.5069909691810608,
-0.5535587072372437,
0.5352694988250732,
-0.08794844150543213,
-0.649479329586029,
-0.3815067708492279,
-0.5260919332504272,
-0.8624847531318665,
0.43182599544525146,
-0.29757124185562134,
-0.9121766090393066,
-0.0061746276915073395,
0.3797956705093384,
0.010213486850261688,
0.3775666654109955,
-0.4289654791355133,
0.9224546551704407,
-0.6971079707145691,
-0.7114664316177368,
-0.1017594262957573,
-0.5387617349624634,
0.7477036118507385,
-0.1470617651939392,
0.292675256729126,
-0.22888582944869995,
0.31250128149986267,
0.7871315479278564,
-0.3108750581741333,
0.9070833325386047,
-0.14524197578430176,
-0.3804747760295868,
-0.02150757424533367,
0.18874244391918182,
0.734573245048523,
-0.18371842801570892,
0.052857618778944016,
0.05549135059118271,
-0.5966588854789734,
-0.2716493606567383,
-0.6476073265075684,
1.1063112020492554,
-0.6483718156814575,
-0.9626808762550354,
-0.36698728799819946,
-0.5058122873306274,
-0.36724400520324707,
0.11966270208358765,
0.10710308700799942,
0.2833384573459625,
-0.30652907490730286,
-0.09879375994205475,
0.7610408663749695,
-0.44317859411239624,
0.327554851770401,
0.5296111702919006,
-0.39068061113357544,
-0.11562605947256088,
0.7809048891067505,
-0.028090134263038635,
0.28589072823524475,
0.32954609394073486,
0.3377705514431,
-0.31532931327819824,
-0.6749288439750671,
-0.44247230887413025,
0.20598384737968445,
-0.5098419785499573,
-0.09601868689060211,
-0.4866641163825989,
-0.09298563748598099,
-0.2021009624004364,
-0.31657689809799194,
-0.45311641693115234,
-0.26511678099632263,
-0.3475402593612671,
-0.37191587686538696,
0.42513585090637207,
0.8686559796333313,
-0.08039955794811249,
0.6474633812904358,
-0.3264251947402954,
0.17056149244308472,
0.2958836257457733,
0.15484195947647095,
0.43225449323654175,
-0.5429216623306274,
-0.03342870995402336,
-0.04445406049489975,
-0.4003444314002991,
-0.8293465971946716,
0.5405140519142151,
-0.2665152847766876,
0.7573060393333435,
0.7009475827217102,
0.007316994946449995,
0.5709596872329712,
-0.6981189250946045,
0.44245973229408264,
0.2541963756084442,
-0.8103820085525513,
0.44204381108283997,
-0.4909442365169525,
0.003862930927425623,
0.2326834797859192,
0.6659340858459473,
-0.10036299377679825,
-0.6113611459732056,
-0.40363937616348267,
-1.0010992288589478,
0.4502210319042206,
0.28194794058799744,
-0.06101222708821297,
0.1656709909439087,
0.11798032373189926,
-0.0018077024724334478,
0.1387181133031845,
-0.7659119367599487,
-0.13195361196994781,
0.036529649049043655,
-0.1708994358778,
-0.3654935359954834,
-0.34313908219337463,
-0.1308765411376953,
0.06549754738807678,
1.0213090181350708,
0.013959221541881561,
-0.009796524420380592,
-0.1016211062669754,
-0.08473239094018936,
0.07084643095731735,
0.550143301486969,
0.44220107793807983,
0.5772358775138855,
0.0637844130396843,
0.4837982654571533,
0.03694988042116165,
-0.18227295577526093,
0.21153952181339264,
0.20953074097633362,
-0.35995185375213623,
-0.28306564688682556,
0.5130287408828735,
0.8162598013877869,
0.37070783972740173,
-0.3124077022075653,
0.5445435643196106,
0.21688880026340485,
0.15692096948623657,
-0.24654139578342438,
-0.12632308900356293,
0.0860244631767273,
0.13996818661689758,
0.18672175705432892,
-0.24291980266571045,
-0.03902284428477287,
-0.2689618170261383,
0.04748626425862312,
0.7784921526908875,
-0.6683148741722107,
-0.37710174918174744,
1.0408707857131958,
0.11310922354459763,
0.2004910707473755,
0.21320077776908875,
-0.012246317230165005,
-0.6916497945785522,
0.2919311225414276,
0.3454223871231079,
0.8090991377830505,
-0.2907494008541107,
0.4070899486541748,
0.06401250511407852,
0.40414369106292725,
-0.25805777311325073,
-0.1425958126783371,
0.2228829562664032,
-0.7047273516654968,
-0.33567002415657043,
-0.8151412606239319,
-0.24344778060913086,
0.16460897028446198,
-0.6186537146568298,
0.09603679180145264,
-0.37151533365249634,
-0.07762304693460464,
0.18862125277519226,
-0.6333252191543579,
-0.3963860869407654,
0.09165564179420471,
-0.05852625519037247,
0.40816015005111694,
-1.1725609302520752,
0.7389504313468933,
0.1661372035741806,
-0.41004806756973267,
-0.9054973721504211,
-0.1252041906118393,
0.2997496426105499,
-1.0516993999481201,
0.7046281099319458,
-0.1679653376340866,
-0.31322816014289856,
-0.42517608404159546,
-0.6507012844085693,
-0.689978301525116,
0.8429341316223145,
0.6254133582115173,
-0.42090246081352234,
-0.16376888751983643,
0.22396595776081085,
0.30200251936912537,
-0.1618022918701172,
-0.0003314512432552874,
0.6953537464141846,
0.5635672807693481,
0.16242869198322296,
-0.5930814146995544,
0.29806777834892273,
0.04297668859362602,
0.06816518306732178,
0.4068273603916168,
-0.5119718909263611,
0.6833029985427856,
-0.1838267296552658,
0.02771182544529438,
-0.07777594029903412,
0.6256786584854126,
0.20685195922851562,
-0.026482876390218735,
0.19403815269470215,
0.42028042674064636,
0.707807719707489,
-0.18947333097457886,
1.2112849950790405,
-0.00356982066296041,
-0.00788430217653513,
1.2032371759414673,
-0.25160565972328186,
0.5925263166427612,
0.8441279530525208,
0.04066890850663185,
0.3543650209903717,
0.16339989006519318,
0.22496479749679565,
0.6300798058509827,
0.41428473591804504,
-0.190456360578537,
-0.3754429519176483,
-0.40110647678375244,
0.003927747718989849,
0.5389552712440491,
0.18328678607940674,
-0.5229487419128418,
-0.37236273288726807,
0.07760056853294373,
0.6787813901901245,
0.15159745514392853,
-0.3548736274242401,
0.4477787911891937,
0.16672800481319427,
-0.719935953617096,
0.21896785497665405,
0.03024427406489849,
0.7423881888389587,
-0.8487045168876648,
0.03984465077519417,
-0.04584118723869324,
0.3089335858821869,
-0.039869628846645355,
-0.8003093004226685,
0.2187623232603073,
0.14345397055149078,
0.10730579495429993,
-0.48111987113952637,
0.6363696455955505,
-0.4013574421405792,
-0.5712571144104004,
0.5432150363922119,
0.40398460626602173,
-0.16146256029605865,
0.18908199667930603,
-0.2759608030319214,
0.01382489688694477,
0.015515984036028385,
-0.32955703139305115,
0.4169711172580719,
0.6231581568717957,
-0.3528217673301697,
0.8534560203552246,
0.6839256882667542,
0.3230714499950409,
-0.12301702052354813,
0.0927894189953804,
0.9978415966033936,
-0.4564274251461029,
-0.38868844509124756,
-1.1364113092422485,
0.3734104633331299,
-0.04040363058447838,
-0.2327834814786911,
0.9793513417243958,
0.22364994883537292,
0.49825534224510193,
0.10042477399110794,
0.6813451051712036,
0.21066392958164215,
0.1305294781923294,
-0.933931291103363,
1.0363770723342896,
-0.3961893320083618,
0.3525073826313019,
-0.34919559955596924,
-0.6085684299468994,
-0.3412655293941498,
0.45867812633514404,
-0.45843371748924255,
-0.13698700070381165,
0.4651017189025879,
0.9027401208877563,
-0.03357473015785217,
-0.09140259027481079,
0.3645906150341034,
0.4365801513195038,
0.5849263072013855,
0.6756823658943176,
0.9350156188011169,
-0.06001144275069237,
0.45236900448799133,
0.06966663897037506,
-0.3242609202861786,
0.020698307082057,
-1.1755934953689575,
-1.1478464603424072,
-0.27971503138542175,
-0.09322377294301987,
-0.3845701217651367,
0.3457968533039093,
0.614967942237854,
0.5903431177139282,
-0.7790371775627136,
-0.22415703535079956,
-0.059657152742147446,
0.538964033126831,
0.22656556963920593,
-0.17760738730430603,
0.4369543194770813,
-0.055367257446050644,
-0.413846492767334,
0.2131078839302063,
0.24524341523647308,
0.0785851925611496,
-0.5527933835983276,
-0.2634263336658478,
-0.20671211183071136,
0.07926598191261292,
0.3023776710033417,
0.3552868366241455,
-0.8050292134284973,
-0.3847264051437378,
-0.40058016777038574,
-0.0726146548986435,
-0.252156138420105,
0.7359902262687683,
-0.44767704606056213,
0.03976788744330406,
0.3238202631473541,
0.5757107734680176,
0.24051861464977264,
-0.22934302687644958,
1.1079401969909668,
-0.49006032943725586,
0.23659273982048035,
-0.07444082200527191,
0.5596476197242737,
0.44620832800865173,
-0.3066178858280182,
0.2876710593700409,
-0.2519788444042206,
-0.48360544443130493,
-0.5761537551879883,
0.2689617872238159,
-0.8141597509384155,
-0.14555393159389496,
1.277604341506958,
-0.13319732248783112,
-0.3445305824279785,
0.03614964708685875,
-0.1067362055182457,
0.2514166533946991,
-0.4339117407798767,
0.6418834924697876,
0.6253777742385864,
0.0036739546339958906,
0.09862427413463593,
-0.7321361899375916,
0.5384076833724976,
0.31591370701789856,
-0.8336957693099976,
0.3851866126060486,
0.6722339391708374,
0.126737579703331,
-0.10953029990196228,
0.24721522629261017,
-0.29812732338905334,
-0.046505097299814224,
-0.34542012214660645,
-0.06318914890289307,
-0.0394357405602932,
-0.437824010848999,
-0.43643882870674133,
0.00015529675874859095,
0.1762966364622116,
0.17223688960075378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06691v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06691v1
|
Fleet of Agents: Coordinated Problem Solving with Large Language Models using Genetic Particle Filtering
| 2024-05-07T09:36:23 | 2024-05-07T09:36:23 |
Akhil Arora, Lars Klein, Nearchos Potamitis, Roland Aydin, Caglar Gulcehre, Robert West
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE
|
Large language models (LLMs) have significantly evolved, moving from simple
output generation to complex reasoning and from stand-alone usage to being
embedded into broader frameworks. In this paper, we introduce \emph{Fleet of
Agents (FoA)}, a novel framework utilizing LLMs as agents to navigate through
dynamic tree searches, employing a genetic-type particle filtering approach.
FoA spawns a multitude of agents, each exploring autonomously, followed by a
selection phase where resampling based on a heuristic value function optimizes
the balance between exploration and exploitation. This mechanism enables
dynamic branching, adapting the exploration strategy based on discovered
solutions. We experimentally validate FoA using two benchmark tasks, "Game of
24" and "Mini-Crosswords". FoA outperforms the previously proposed
Tree-of-Thoughts method in terms of efficacy and efficiency: it significantly
decreases computational costs (by calling the value function less frequently)
while preserving comparable or even superior accuracy.
|
[
-0.3116406798362732,
-0.9223421812057495,
1.0292233228683472,
0.029716849327087402,
-0.0750243067741394,
1.009764313697815,
-0.01274806261062622,
-0.5173316597938538,
0.3423534333705902,
0.4292186498641968,
-0.8878746628761292,
-0.31986933946609497,
-0.4832168519496918,
0.11292875558137894,
-0.3614867031574249,
0.38439637422561646,
-0.02169671282172203,
-0.4030536711215973,
-0.09147237241268158,
-0.12999093532562256,
-0.20122693479061127,
-0.36751410365104675,
-1.0026870965957642,
-0.4106917679309845,
0.6643323302268982,
0.4795398414134979,
1.0150552988052368,
0.6576148867607117,
0.7120503187179565,
0.4330770671367645,
-0.43635129928588867,
0.4052594006061554,
-0.7923085689544678,
0.42602893710136414,
-0.45968717336654663,
-0.5164809823036194,
-0.5090112090110779,
-0.42847150564193726,
0.6883975267410278,
0.5515187978744507,
-0.48094213008880615,
-0.19443698227405548,
-0.2059108018875122,
0.5805969834327698,
-0.5111706256866455,
0.13418735563755035,
-0.9219005703926086,
0.29265400767326355,
-0.21872206032276154,
-0.2468881458044052,
-0.27740874886512756,
0.1402600258588791,
0.19804899394512177,
-1.0364015102386475,
-0.025221003219485283,
0.30311670899391174,
0.527915358543396,
0.3279780149459839,
-0.48542043566703796,
-0.44466137886047363,
-0.8686462044715881,
0.9713572263717651,
-0.4648621380329132,
0.1650906205177307,
0.2225968837738037,
0.3136413097381592,
-0.6973924040794373,
-0.7071928977966309,
-0.544623851776123,
-0.1513005942106247,
0.31452542543411255,
-0.03178749606013298,
-0.3607969582080841,
0.10852771997451782,
-0.1275685578584671,
0.24990394711494446,
-0.3367551565170288,
0.32080158591270447,
-0.10413529723882675,
0.01663323864340782,
0.8161405920982361,
0.1810813993215561,
0.4530408978462219,
0.44496873021125793,
-0.12567782402038574,
-0.30613625049591064,
-0.47985267639160156,
0.07875389605760574,
0.02772981859743595,
0.37205877900123596,
0.2183324694633484,
0.36058762669563293,
-0.35976681113243103,
0.48128390312194824,
0.04893694445490837,
-0.14467312395572662,
0.08443091809749603,
-0.2799934446811676,
-0.2607879042625427,
0.013315479271113873,
0.6596460938453674,
-0.12802982330322266,
0.14419786632061005,
-0.23862764239311218,
-0.44815585017204285,
-0.026141518726944923,
0.36412152647972107,
-0.4979730546474457,
0.06364424526691437,
0.08435826003551483,
-0.3876424729824066,
-0.6988629102706909,
-0.20572654902935028,
-0.8457584381103516,
-0.29391705989837646,
0.17933283746242523,
0.09741149842739105,
-0.23993217945098877,
-0.2506687641143799,
0.14655841886997223,
-0.07052953541278839,
0.04605691879987717,
0.2505105137825012,
-0.7582996487617493,
0.29393988847732544,
0.6740208268165588,
0.7885350584983826,
-0.09491465240716934,
-0.28485020995140076,
-0.8270630240440369,
0.17206653952598572,
-0.4464855492115021,
0.7265947461128235,
-0.8358628749847412,
-0.7929781675338745,
-0.18679136037826538,
-0.044541314244270325,
0.07026718556880951,
-0.3561825454235077,
0.37902921438217163,
-0.8079226016998291,
-0.2074795961380005,
-0.31411102414131165,
-0.3481293320655823,
-0.31103265285491943,
0.2192848175764084,
-0.5784867405891418,
0.910872757434845,
0.04016411304473877,
-0.161593958735466,
0.17577652633190155,
-0.640114426612854,
-0.32155683636665344,
0.45041435956954956,
-0.24139462411403656,
-0.2705623209476471,
0.045901983976364136,
0.23491667211055756,
0.13852667808532715,
-0.4176388680934906,
0.3857359290122986,
-0.4358159899711609,
-0.1898883730173111,
-0.10956083238124847,
-0.11091330647468567,
0.5811349749565125,
0.5176056027412415,
-0.3538892865180969,
0.42925336956977844,
-0.33359894156455994,
0.02488468401134014,
0.4745462238788605,
-0.2729298174381256,
-0.35613808035850525,
0.5867400765419006,
-0.4176467955112457,
0.02059684693813324,
0.28452572226524353,
-0.45346885919570923,
0.38168373703956604,
-0.25724953413009644,
0.607570469379425,
0.5949025750160217,
-0.02436266466975212,
0.30054453015327454,
-0.4288440942764282,
0.7964708805084229,
-0.2516098618507385,
0.12353912740945816,
-0.10664544999599457,
-0.6912999749183655,
-0.4745854437351227,
-0.21668954193592072,
-0.26117804646492004,
0.503362238407135,
-1.0190484523773193,
0.41613081097602844,
-0.2567885220050812,
-0.6131858825683594,
0.07935010641813278,
0.13998189568519592,
0.2400757074356079,
-0.014706694521009922,
0.1876533180475235,
-0.2875528335571289,
-0.08575490117073059,
-0.4411394000053406,
0.09826549887657166,
-0.3369101881980896,
0.5165418386459351,
0.35334599018096924,
0.3819507956504822,
-0.6143007278442383,
0.9359562397003174,
-0.4066159725189209,
-0.1676226407289505,
-0.3360302150249481,
0.07355397939682007,
0.08213362097740173,
0.1518290787935257,
0.5630889534950256,
-0.7634879946708679,
-0.27983468770980835,
0.3303889334201813,
-0.7929062247276306,
0.023144546896219254,
-0.0466887429356575,
-0.24290359020233154,
-0.06923382729291916,
0.9044406414031982,
-0.7399226427078247,
0.05294644832611084,
0.6883059740066528,
-0.5320193767547607,
0.033980440348386765,
-0.4969853162765503,
-0.20875653624534607,
-0.7222052216529846,
0.007614603731781244,
-0.24665918946266174,
-0.4969322085380554,
-0.35474663972854614,
0.5912153124809265,
-0.5311424136161804,
-0.08153597265481949,
-0.2751465439796448,
0.5241630673408508,
-0.5627335906028748,
-0.21891362965106964,
-0.5335110425949097,
0.5766313076019287,
-0.1130436584353447,
0.3645588457584381,
-0.43542343378067017,
0.6263787150382996,
0.5945344567298889,
-0.5160842537879944,
0.7915523052215576,
0.2624831795692444,
0.030858483165502548,
0.19256262481212616,
-0.28666993975639343,
0.3504835069179535,
-0.3533037006855011,
0.5006863474845886,
-0.9559032917022705,
0.17554040253162384,
-0.028127333149313927,
-0.012949120253324509,
0.08905984461307526,
0.0969969630241394,
-0.4603291451931,
-0.6250841617584229,
-0.18014982342720032,
0.5861310362815857,
0.39172181487083435,
-0.38984623551368713,
0.8643336892127991,
0.6571176052093506,
-0.14777745306491852,
-0.5533771514892578,
-0.517882227897644,
0.13707301020622253,
-0.07227902859449387,
-0.5136886835098267,
0.43070513010025024,
0.2135365605354309,
-0.35616248846054077,
0.3362601697444916,
-0.2702285051345825,
0.03751090541481972,
0.3676496148109436,
-0.011804562993347645,
-0.056277330964803696,
-0.22774286568164825,
0.17617924511432648,
0.16224409639835358,
0.1630687117576599,
-0.07712878286838531,
-0.44448769092559814,
0.7152296900749207,
-0.31054338812828064,
-0.4004395604133606,
0.2188161015510559,
0.2676921486854553,
0.8888881206512451,
-0.6760761141777039,
0.5519378185272217,
0.21156328916549683,
-0.17347346246242523,
-0.618824303150177,
-0.1836664080619812,
-0.20774468779563904,
-0.6073079109191895,
0.6576318144798279,
-0.42233383655548096,
-1.0216094255447388,
0.5064236521720886,
-0.23378896713256836,
0.14347009360790253,
0.4284096360206604,
0.3666004538536072,
-0.05232633650302887,
0.8286373615264893,
0.6491319537162781,
-0.18673008680343628,
0.562384307384491,
-0.3124099671840668,
0.36925384402275085,
-0.35764139890670776,
-0.16234038770198822,
-0.3214479684829712,
-0.5103222131729126,
-0.6926534175872803,
-0.7424931526184082,
0.49274399876594543,
-0.030276136472821236,
-0.19106239080429077,
-0.03460800647735596,
-0.556022047996521,
0.622225284576416,
0.5618160367012024,
-0.06563346832990646,
0.4095556437969208,
0.08575120568275452,
-0.4441588819026947,
0.5815231204032898,
-1.1237486600875854,
-0.3401302397251129,
0.9364794492721558,
0.3363010287284851,
0.5336436033248901,
0.13780735433101654,
0.608377993106842,
0.407207727432251,
0.17528152465820312,
-0.9258254766464233,
1.090726375579834,
-0.5109233260154724,
-0.5700651407241821,
-0.7631655335426331,
-0.5371888279914856,
-1.5849533081054688,
0.3928558826446533,
-0.3159557282924652,
-0.7731181979179382,
0.030629506334662437,
-0.05721099302172661,
-0.6446776986122131,
0.6670824289321899,
-0.22023214399814606,
0.5049789547920227,
-0.6597737073898315,
-0.37728720903396606,
-0.8812147974967957,
-0.4169224798679352,
0.19089548289775848,
-0.3452449142932892,
0.4071555435657501,
-0.3244466483592987,
-0.06915721297264099,
0.553124189376831,
-0.48275524377822876,
0.5322482585906982,
-0.005318471696227789,
-0.043426692485809326,
0.6099457144737244,
0.19437472522258759,
0.7408901453018188,
-0.41496542096138,
0.02631656639277935,
-0.23831026256084442,
-0.012830761261284351,
-0.1900521069765091,
-0.36296290159225464,
0.9098573923110962,
-0.7879480719566345,
-0.6368653178215027,
-0.6833105087280273,
-0.6117902994155884,
-0.1713346689939499,
0.6027088165283203,
-0.3815099000930786,
0.2431628406047821,
-0.15556500852108002,
0.2439621388912201,
0.41331082582473755,
-0.3796769976615906,
0.6784124374389648,
0.5494317412376404,
-0.69707852602005,
-0.12554572522640228,
0.802160382270813,
0.03082055039703846,
0.11776252835988998,
0.5063429474830627,
0.3144047260284424,
-0.2659328877925873,
-0.6557906866073608,
-0.22341236472129822,
0.4008430242538452,
-0.6262614727020264,
-0.007530823815613985,
-0.4239225387573242,
-0.1383330225944519,
0.11533428728580475,
-0.11880277097225189,
-0.36447104811668396,
-0.05906658619642258,
-0.05466332286596298,
0.04316471517086029,
0.43939530849456787,
0.8657142519950867,
0.2713356614112854,
0.620242178440094,
-0.8062295913696289,
0.3462871015071869,
0.4604284167289734,
0.28583022952079773,
0.08041391521692276,
-0.043745849281549454,
-0.21025314927101135,
0.1221381202340126,
-0.5552000999450684,
-0.8377136588096619,
0.3939773142337799,
0.08201232552528381,
0.8153988718986511,
0.143694207072258,
-0.07536757737398148,
0.5113463997840881,
-0.3024930953979492,
0.44904953241348267,
-0.2335325926542282,
-1.0337618589401245,
0.22714999318122864,
-0.6446195244789124,
0.20628118515014648,
0.45965659618377686,
0.04958542436361313,
-0.4146774709224701,
-0.49168500304222107,
-0.6151211261749268,
-0.9744593501091003,
0.858853280544281,
0.4142712950706482,
-0.2856842875480652,
0.27106973528862,
0.5380895733833313,
-0.6420189738273621,
0.2917969226837158,
-0.20952856540679932,
-0.060460805892944336,
0.323293536901474,
-0.2926182150840759,
-0.3526840806007385,
-0.03276097774505615,
0.15176227688789368,
-0.00423876428976655,
0.8633740544319153,
-0.21693898737430573,
0.22512395679950714,
0.2837303876876831,
0.08436519652605057,
-0.6781099438667297,
-0.09552694112062454,
0.4913232922554016,
0.4585186243057251,
-0.10830524563789368,
0.0575210377573967,
0.06933628022670746,
-0.4265044033527374,
0.3711352050304413,
0.005110498983412981,
-0.12053009867668152,
-0.21031345427036285,
0.2893032133579254,
0.828398585319519,
0.00282974517904222,
-1.0102438926696777,
0.15204055607318878,
0.13366830348968506,
-0.22410130500793457,
-0.16014282405376434,
0.31648990511894226,
0.15169639885425568,
0.5414566397666931,
0.46897682547569275,
-0.007478162180632353,
0.051906123757362366,
-0.8542768359184265,
0.17913717031478882,
0.7301397323608398,
-0.0257486030459404,
-0.018793338909745216,
0.6461941003799438,
0.4641115963459015,
-0.5633704662322998,
0.6132339835166931,
-0.5604391694068909,
-0.652789294719696,
0.8801738023757935,
0.1922900527715683,
0.9514600038528442,
-0.3102298974990845,
0.30017000436782837,
-0.07370640337467194,
0.461252897977829,
-0.37952834367752075,
0.34542977809906006,
0.06434272974729538,
-1.060916543006897,
-0.7112001776695251,
-0.431564062833786,
-0.5521240830421448,
0.11441017687320709,
-0.06913899630308151,
0.2127411663532257,
-0.5981361865997314,
-0.3290727138519287,
-0.002579192630946636,
0.16933615505695343,
-0.3266609013080597,
0.12143012881278992,
0.6058122515678406,
0.7483927607536316,
-0.4867297410964966,
0.8835403323173523,
1.0067341327667236,
0.06623221933841705,
-0.9117048382759094,
0.10079362243413925,
0.08326537162065506,
-0.8841072916984558,
0.4177994728088379,
-0.01918799988925457,
-0.7752703428268433,
0.2836040258407593,
-0.19348403811454773,
-1.3796178102493286,
1.2454074621200562,
0.2532937526702881,
-1.0923367738723755,
-0.18365293741226196,
0.03956767916679382,
0.5608775019645691,
-0.43148866295814514,
0.07977014780044556,
0.5897098779678345,
0.4474194347858429,
0.3323514461517334,
-1.0214049816131592,
0.08208994567394257,
-0.19932454824447632,
-0.048807092010974884,
0.2979101538658142,
-0.9761752486228943,
0.8182435631752014,
-0.08266768604516983,
-0.11920454353094101,
0.00390773918479681,
0.386277973651886,
0.5948045253753662,
0.5279403924942017,
0.8963530659675598,
0.3429087698459625,
1.0663882493972778,
0.06989201158285141,
0.9538952112197876,
-0.4214528501033783,
0.5152016282081604,
0.8105770349502563,
-0.5789719820022583,
0.6218908429145813,
0.42533233761787415,
-0.20792442560195923,
0.4969095289707184,
0.3727872371673584,
0.11387068033218384,
0.5557806491851807,
0.5198789238929749,
-0.25430938601493835,
-0.2107342928647995,
-0.016001878306269646,
0.2179238498210907,
0.5038341879844666,
0.3964642286300659,
-0.05210021510720253,
-0.24313943088054657,
0.008369413204491138,
-0.011424404568970203,
0.22345273196697235,
-0.45125582814216614,
0.6515722870826721,
0.05565476045012474,
-0.9658087491989136,
0.4434716999530792,
0.18283799290657043,
0.42936742305755615,
-0.6615749001502991,
0.27331963181495667,
-0.14279335737228394,
0.5160430669784546,
-0.027168892323970795,
-0.7096721529960632,
0.2681032419204712,
-0.09504012763500214,
0.11734462529420853,
-0.3370084762573242,
0.5950713753700256,
-0.37246251106262207,
-0.542853593826294,
0.5640473961830139,
0.7456863522529602,
-0.10705430805683136,
-0.1152375116944313,
-0.6668090224266052,
0.27979251742362976,
0.04536275193095207,
-0.17065274715423584,
-0.08882637321949005,
0.6369181871414185,
-0.46349766850471497,
1.0923089981079102,
0.5984534025192261,
0.1255328208208084,
0.13673247396945953,
-0.27875086665153503,
0.7971617579460144,
-0.7089130282402039,
-0.9101487398147583,
-0.8812199831008911,
0.021320635452866554,
0.0945664793252945,
0.07053464651107788,
0.45172595977783203,
0.30872365832328796,
0.5240556597709656,
0.13201206922531128,
0.7183529734611511,
0.12045283615589142,
0.28700101375579834,
-0.42989352345466614,
0.5384286642074585,
-0.7799451947212219,
0.33447694778442383,
-0.2430204600095749,
-0.9907165169715881,
-0.21961627900600433,
0.6397923827171326,
-0.3017892837524414,
0.08544515073299408,
0.724776566028595,
0.659598171710968,
-0.19934432208538055,
0.056407831609249115,
0.2829347848892212,
0.30287209153175354,
0.8409177660942078,
0.7969743609428406,
0.9589118361473083,
0.0803462415933609,
0.36447659134864807,
0.001984433038160205,
-0.17671149969100952,
-0.3793848156929016,
-0.858306884765625,
-0.6307505369186401,
-0.2983607053756714,
-0.25005075335502625,
0.06349395960569382,
0.12238457053899765,
1.0827224254608154,
0.7737549543380737,
-0.5381412506103516,
-0.5452039837837219,
-0.6625891327857971,
0.2487196922302246,
-0.2610926628112793,
-0.09274745732545853,
-0.06429217010736465,
-0.43069595098495483,
-0.6360312104225159,
0.896049976348877,
0.2862214744091034,
0.08775648474693298,
-0.40513575077056885,
-0.24607643485069275,
-0.28745758533477783,
0.3574165403842926,
0.44549617171287537,
0.25726211071014404,
-0.666786789894104,
-0.04677360877394676,
0.07864010334014893,
0.030360788106918335,
-0.1366036981344223,
0.8571241497993469,
-0.8135436773300171,
0.578701376914978,
0.39691755175590515,
0.8612695336341858,
0.7593665719032288,
-0.15258455276489258,
0.5917445421218872,
-0.4069553315639496,
0.3892214596271515,
0.3150715231895447,
0.4709338843822479,
0.04405079409480095,
-0.3739675283432007,
0.3916381299495697,
0.3888835906982422,
-0.5945025682449341,
-0.8514717221260071,
0.20511677861213684,
-1.0587259531021118,
-0.4138425290584564,
1.0649077892303467,
0.0665217861533165,
-0.2531648874282837,
0.07148794829845428,
-0.2906135022640228,
0.21100226044654846,
-0.633141279220581,
0.5445102453231812,
0.744964063167572,
0.06097990274429321,
-0.015449055470526218,
-0.19265611469745636,
0.35680025815963745,
0.6534773111343384,
-0.7559654712677002,
-0.1554938554763794,
0.2786082923412323,
-0.09275483340024948,
0.4460285007953644,
0.673753023147583,
0.2788812816143036,
-0.09804833680391312,
-0.23643885552883148,
-0.2647351026535034,
-0.11521189659833908,
-0.5880991816520691,
-0.18786902725696564,
0.19334660470485687,
0.24692054092884064,
-0.1937466263771057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06690v1
|
DrugLLM: Open Large Language Model for Few-shot Molecule Generation
| 2024-05-07T09:18:13 | 2024-05-07T09:18:13 |
Xianggen Liu, Yan Guo, Haoran Li, Jin Liu, Shudong Huang, Bowen Ke, Jiancheng Lv
|
q-bio.BM
|
q-bio.BM, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have made great strides in areas such as
language processing and computer vision. Despite the emergence of diverse
techniques to improve few-shot learning capacity, current LLMs fall short in
handling the languages in biology and chemistry. For example, they are
struggling to capture the relationship between molecule structure and
pharmacochemical properties. Consequently, the few-shot learning capacity of
small-molecule drug modification remains impeded. In this work, we introduced
DrugLLM, a LLM tailored for drug design. During the training process, we
employed Group-based Molecular Representation (GMR) to represent molecules,
arranging them in sequences that reflect modifications aimed at enhancing
specific molecular properties. DrugLLM learns how to modify molecules in drug
discovery by predicting the next molecule based on past modifications.
Extensive computational experiments demonstrate that DrugLLM can generate new
molecules with expected properties based on limited examples, presenting a
powerful few-shot molecule generation capacity.
|
[
-0.1059819906949997,
-0.8316575288772583,
0.5659307837486267,
-0.3643493056297302,
-0.07560525834560394,
0.19829584658145905,
-0.35305365920066833,
-0.21348848938941956,
0.09007567912340164,
0.6231374740600586,
-0.4054321348667145,
-0.7182205319404602,
-0.6830462217330933,
0.27076461911201477,
0.21296289563179016,
0.9888418912887573,
0.023849643766880035,
0.46499374508857727,
0.013322114013135433,
-0.0074836863204836845,
-0.1304943859577179,
-0.25386694073677063,
-0.6016532778739929,
-0.7075684666633606,
0.6665378212928772,
0.42928317189216614,
0.4231322705745697,
0.5220060348510742,
0.8278908729553223,
0.2591300904750824,
-0.11261404305696487,
-0.07035980373620987,
-0.7798519134521484,
-0.053563669323921204,
-0.12679840624332428,
-0.5985342264175415,
-0.67160564661026,
-0.045313894748687744,
0.5079131722450256,
0.9691081643104553,
-0.06528637558221817,
-0.006610743701457977,
-0.08025898039340973,
0.6059370636940002,
-0.417926549911499,
0.019880829378962517,
-0.9979456663131714,
0.20863014459609985,
-0.20154708623886108,
0.028542978689074516,
-0.2702256441116333,
-0.11823946982622147,
0.05561423674225807,
-0.47174209356307983,
0.44355398416519165,
0.10893810540437698,
0.5634315013885498,
0.07330857217311859,
-0.23366333544254303,
-0.40817293524742126,
-0.6774179935455322,
0.7697688341140747,
-0.9803592562675476,
0.0689137727022171,
0.23801055550575256,
0.5912624001502991,
-0.8649797439575195,
-0.7296701073646545,
-0.35054251551628113,
-0.4131557047367096,
0.04003959149122238,
-0.17196618020534515,
0.22474421560764313,
0.27059924602508545,
0.06238558143377304,
0.36841920018196106,
-0.7429280877113342,
0.19388021528720856,
-0.5306545495986938,
-0.09967564046382904,
0.42231452465057373,
0.46331581473350525,
0.16955231130123138,
-0.10939676314592361,
-0.5379123687744141,
0.16316214203834534,
-1.0404633283615112,
-0.34403085708618164,
-0.06961269676685333,
0.8156237006187439,
0.1315833181142807,
0.9377329349517822,
0.07523354887962341,
0.5966751575469971,
-0.05378911271691322,
-0.32236018776893616,
-0.016280964016914368,
-0.3124406337738037,
-0.6236001253128052,
0.35517826676368713,
0.8491954803466797,
0.2056543081998825,
-0.08838119357824326,
0.2519984841346741,
-0.004224877338856459,
-0.21565604209899902,
-0.006460371892899275,
-1.3273789882659912,
-0.3033475875854492,
0.35747358202934265,
-0.5456085801124573,
-0.365374356508255,
-0.08431847393512726,
-0.8256465792655945,
-0.5225487947463989,
0.2266317903995514,
0.5406978130340576,
-0.5240929126739502,
0.15721286833286285,
0.24365226924419403,
-0.19853435456752777,
0.08203523606061935,
0.2120872139930725,
-1.0039958953857422,
0.20949093997478485,
0.4562501311302185,
0.9011643528938293,
-0.40408065915107727,
-0.33967307209968567,
-0.6537755727767944,
0.6644917130470276,
-0.2703205347061157,
0.8521332740783691,
-0.6368974447250366,
-0.682597279548645,
-0.24510930478572845,
-0.23290970921516418,
0.26340973377227783,
-0.9104195833206177,
-0.2685341536998749,
-0.2785624861717224,
0.1741141676902771,
0.160551056265831,
-0.9428028464317322,
0.18324865400791168,
0.19502083957195282,
-0.5538885593414307,
0.3128635585308075,
0.2707141041755676,
-0.425528347492218,
0.6952149271965027,
-0.8105176687240601,
-0.1637984812259674,
0.30409660935401917,
-0.5235969424247742,
-0.7672540545463562,
0.34746989607810974,
0.05334204435348511,
0.43432119488716125,
-0.1691078096628189,
0.04787971079349518,
-0.33359548449516296,
-0.2780715525150299,
0.4222239553928375,
0.12611457705497742,
0.34178534150123596,
0.29095491766929626,
0.13881798088550568,
0.31569045782089233,
-0.7409257292747498,
-0.013144484721124172,
0.04299471899867058,
-0.7883482575416565,
0.07004760950803757,
-0.44025951623916626,
0.19274461269378662,
0.25731733441352844,
0.09684035927057266,
-0.43150845170021057,
0.6450160145759583,
-0.6087612509727478,
0.29809725284576416,
0.6765872240066528,
0.38767898082733154,
0.6060406565666199,
-0.2145776003599167,
0.601574718952179,
0.14221420884132385,
-0.07074557989835739,
-0.23331870138645172,
-0.5162282586097717,
-0.5160232186317444,
-0.502732515335083,
0.22977016866207123,
0.20668751001358032,
-0.3574213683605194,
0.08399176597595215,
-0.06478044390678406,
-0.22827018797397614,
-0.05900491774082184,
0.8598594665527344,
0.22107180953025818,
0.0774475485086441,
0.3513810932636261,
-0.2557010054588318,
-0.6250972747802734,
-0.7357030510902405,
-0.36000123620033264,
-0.24018017947673798,
-0.17894917726516724,
0.22455309331417084,
0.7206147909164429,
-0.5734279155731201,
0.8987823128700256,
-0.7904833555221558,
-0.7416054010391235,
-0.7220277190208435,
0.05780902877449989,
0.39758846163749695,
0.33189496397972107,
0.30484694242477417,
-0.29018834233283997,
-0.3713565468788147,
-0.021448418498039246,
-0.5582575798034668,
-0.03875909373164177,
-0.05313486605882645,
-0.2904699444770813,
-0.006649821065366268,
0.56901615858078,
-0.4907352924346924,
0.2590482532978058,
0.28140661120414734,
-0.15492241084575653,
0.23341916501522064,
-0.15917043387889862,
-0.24180251359939575,
-1.1968512535095215,
-0.20467998087406158,
-0.06027653068304062,
-0.2507938742637634,
-0.7371689081192017,
-0.17639271914958954,
-0.33363041281700134,
-0.39687204360961914,
-1.022518515586853,
0.8373133540153503,
-0.41509702801704407,
0.07573491334915161,
-0.669891893863678,
-0.24997875094413757,
-0.0948127880692482,
0.3552248775959015,
0.03917204961180687,
0.5318534970283508,
0.5153020620346069,
-0.5333138108253479,
0.1496122181415558,
0.265266478061676,
-0.15636548399925232,
0.37164634466171265,
-0.5733758807182312,
0.11208797991275787,
-0.03179154545068741,
0.1595594435930252,
-0.5185399651527405,
-0.7748424410820007,
0.1720537394285202,
-0.2052965611219406,
0.5839940309524536,
-0.4320109784603119,
-0.31258827447891235,
-0.2909765839576721,
-0.20197705924510956,
0.23668523132801056,
0.48767542839050293,
-0.35252079367637634,
0.5731642842292786,
0.3713325560092926,
0.04744134470820427,
0.05962905287742615,
-0.8379328846931458,
-0.03631819412112236,
-0.2625638544559479,
-0.5119236707687378,
0.18233826756477356,
-0.11700186878442764,
-0.2543473243713379,
-0.14463749527931213,
0.11210660636425018,
-0.12478259950876236,
-0.34238043427467346,
0.34218382835388184,
0.24575172364711761,
-0.2982414960861206,
0.26099205017089844,
-0.15324093401432037,
-0.10593703389167786,
-0.20364674925804138,
-0.41625282168388367,
0.3343102037906647,
0.03495341166853905,
-0.10482577234506607,
0.18112199008464813,
0.4145090579986572,
0.2972131371498108,
-0.028917860239744186,
0.7014476656913757,
0.4133601188659668,
-0.3952137231826782,
-0.5717126727104187,
0.13987331092357635,
-0.44442248344421387,
-0.5215295553207397,
0.5767088532447815,
-0.3694252669811249,
-0.9942400455474854,
0.21651433408260345,
-0.48173433542251587,
-0.3519081473350525,
0.0368470698595047,
1.0915768146514893,
0.026724493131041527,
0.538611650466919,
0.6127541065216064,
0.12000931799411774,
0.3227682411670685,
-0.309157133102417,
0.0026875233743339777,
-0.6226722598075867,
-0.16745111346244812,
-0.04053281992673874,
-0.368620902299881,
-0.37690451741218567,
-0.7304955124855042,
0.7358289957046509,
0.30304810404777527,
-0.225579634308815,
0.24016697704792023,
-0.21652846038341522,
0.6290199756622314,
0.3717302978038788,
0.16289961338043213,
0.18313714861869812,
0.33509963750839233,
-0.2965415418148041,
0.03663497045636177,
-0.7660145163536072,
-0.6375117897987366,
1.3367784023284912,
0.20966534316539764,
1.2680062055587769,
0.19793285429477692,
0.9886831641197205,
-0.040308061987161636,
0.29334864020347595,
-0.8551084995269775,
0.7054790258407593,
-0.13822726905345917,
-0.5972192883491516,
-0.1706939935684204,
-0.4970894753932953,
-1.0828977823257446,
-0.07654719054698944,
-0.523190438747406,
-0.5942319631576538,
-0.0726081132888794,
0.18951182067394257,
-0.3171883821487427,
0.40324679017066956,
-0.5508795380592346,
0.778939962387085,
-0.2023143619298935,
-0.551724910736084,
-0.10940127819776535,
-0.6075201630592346,
0.49971893429756165,
-0.27283015847206116,
0.057624854147434235,
-0.12623204290866852,
0.06245150417089462,
0.3533826172351837,
-0.772005021572113,
0.7388133406639099,
0.03286858648061752,
-0.14158421754837036,
0.30006706714630127,
0.23721490800380707,
0.32600241899490356,
0.011354310438036919,
0.07001850008964539,
0.15437233448028564,
-0.5650826692581177,
-0.37971624732017517,
-0.4890292286872864,
0.8628693222999573,
-0.23053839802742004,
-0.5503392815589905,
-0.3368741571903229,
-0.4919820725917816,
-0.08372949808835983,
0.3751804530620575,
0.47113892436027527,
0.13499265909194946,
-0.500757098197937,
-0.16016094386577606,
0.3930771052837372,
-0.5288149118423462,
0.35230186581611633,
0.5856644511222839,
-0.7709097266197205,
-0.43017691373825073,
0.7339372634887695,
-0.04306604340672493,
0.5555459856987,
0.428739994764328,
0.29407814145088196,
0.04888308048248291,
-0.6851336359977722,
-0.2927177846431732,
0.16252730786800385,
-0.5245184302330017,
-0.1849888563156128,
-0.21824052929878235,
0.004935076925903559,
-0.37090280652046204,
-0.16068421304225922,
-0.3887404799461365,
-0.3790222704410553,
-0.2541212737560272,
-0.11344300955533981,
0.5763410925865173,
0.9231492280960083,
-0.3067200481891632,
0.3662358224391937,
-0.8842511177062988,
0.6797058582305908,
0.48431098461151123,
0.513264536857605,
-0.6184170246124268,
-0.19622138142585754,
-0.6034647226333618,
-0.1392878293991089,
-0.3800252676010132,
-0.78801429271698,
0.29160282015800476,
0.484540194272995,
0.36905014514923096,
0.2904985547065735,
-0.5323944091796875,
0.2431691288948059,
-0.82474684715271,
0.7006162405014038,
0.27380648255348206,
-0.5110707879066467,
1.0761088132858276,
-0.3181664049625397,
0.4512909948825836,
0.33044084906578064,
0.03573811426758766,
-0.10255575180053711,
-0.4099556803703308,
-0.20711185038089752,
-0.640364408493042,
0.3660144805908203,
0.4336940348148346,
-0.09686781466007233,
-0.013059298507869244,
0.27520567178726196,
0.26094552874565125,
0.10861761122941971,
-0.4679555594921112,
-0.35742437839508057,
-0.13719294965267181,
-0.32754969596862793,
0.004833068232983351,
0.009166647680103779,
-0.08912655711174011,
-0.04708367586135864,
0.5715952515602112,
-0.26163774728775024,
0.21237488090991974,
-0.05607382580637932,
-0.006129816640168428,
-0.26573479175567627,
0.5881177186965942,
0.6028656363487244,
0.4881523847579956,
-0.6121951937675476,
0.15032976865768433,
0.029679112136363983,
-0.6683357954025269,
0.4257758557796478,
0.06454133242368698,
-0.06121983379125595,
-0.040808845311403275,
0.16265474259853363,
0.6652228236198425,
-0.28291431069374084,
-0.8228193521499634,
0.27293962240219116,
0.11433239281177521,
-0.07314927130937576,
0.2004566639661789,
0.4448755383491516,
-0.012798432260751724,
0.406462162733078,
0.3296886682510376,
0.08087621629238129,
0.04973341524600983,
-0.7068232297897339,
0.3534257411956787,
0.5090588927268982,
-0.30747777223587036,
-0.09813077747821808,
0.8107631802558899,
-0.02934611216187477,
-0.24284151196479797,
0.06467825174331665,
-0.1859060674905777,
-0.3397892713546753,
0.4135880470275879,
0.63698410987854,
0.8657973408699036,
-0.2982693016529083,
0.11209537833929062,
0.45180267095565796,
0.13718700408935547,
0.09972479194402695,
0.13993202149868011,
0.44368961453437805,
-0.6922419667243958,
0.03340810164809227,
-0.7250659465789795,
-0.3834359347820282,
0.26047980785369873,
-0.01131129264831543,
0.5632613897323608,
-0.6616211533546448,
-0.27330732345581055,
0.136210635304451,
-0.06438318639993668,
-0.48925548791885376,
0.11671976000070572,
0.11532076448202133,
0.5360689163208008,
-0.6058276891708374,
1.045432686805725,
0.7584350109100342,
-0.5767326951026917,
-0.4725523889064789,
-0.1703265756368637,
0.25201061367988586,
-0.5118604302406311,
0.8495034575462341,
0.028221143409609795,
-0.010835165157914162,
-0.1844443678855896,
-0.7089866399765015,
-0.500701367855072,
0.998075544834137,
0.3548179566860199,
-0.7409284710884094,
0.1317698061466217,
0.6778717637062073,
0.5696736574172974,
-0.7109190225601196,
-0.19697034358978271,
0.4330822229385376,
0.22001734375953674,
0.2442355453968048,
-0.6185040473937988,
-0.03942197188735008,
-0.11126431822776794,
0.23855768144130707,
0.17863158881664276,
-0.3016678988933563,
1.0020132064819336,
-0.7231713533401489,
0.021533984690904617,
0.22552381455898285,
0.46041953563690186,
0.7957726120948792,
0.2063283622264862,
-0.02989179641008377,
0.4189552664756775,
0.6142327785491943,
0.058694180101156235,
0.8938105702400208,
-0.08218522369861603,
0.36822226643562317,
1.3550435304641724,
-0.4145243167877197,
0.8492724895477295,
0.6817046999931335,
-0.295284628868103,
0.273627907037735,
0.3571847081184387,
-0.4138527810573578,
0.6189877390861511,
0.7333284616470337,
-0.46212753653526306,
-0.14195463061332703,
0.11406366527080536,
-0.26573580503463745,
0.3818700909614563,
0.625417172908783,
-0.6443421244621277,
-0.17535918951034546,
0.413694828748703,
-0.16536566615104675,
-0.10262054204940796,
-0.4948907494544983,
0.8436169624328613,
0.39751148223876953,
0.0062324851751327515,
0.5398774147033691,
0.0927734449505806,
0.5212094187736511,
-0.6492874026298523,
-0.3388936519622803,
-0.2863524258136749,
0.33218348026275635,
-0.046974148601293564,
-0.6701834797859192,
-0.0382494255900383,
-0.005076456815004349,
-0.3039974570274353,
0.18509478867053986,
0.9400420784950256,
-0.6659455895423889,
-0.9056736826896667,
0.10937774926424026,
0.46241989731788635,
0.28057923913002014,
0.21805229783058167,
-0.6285276412963867,
-0.005230078008025885,
-0.1810840666294098,
0.004470836836844683,
0.324724942445755,
0.3834236264228821,
0.29293176531791687,
0.5522802472114563,
0.46503862738609314,
0.35868799686431885,
0.2118309885263443,
0.1312330663204193,
0.7731500267982483,
-0.8414225578308105,
0.06829611957073212,
-0.9337582588195801,
0.17801806330680847,
0.32535696029663086,
-0.18503910303115845,
0.5950546264648438,
0.9128633737564087,
0.6488671898841858,
-0.45948314666748047,
0.7944774627685547,
0.3190098702907562,
0.2873435914516449,
-0.9299086332321167,
0.7470141649246216,
-0.4665881395339966,
0.5149000287055969,
-0.260078102350235,
-0.9431159496307373,
-0.6579163074493408,
0.5828120708465576,
0.08330216258764267,
0.0771094262599945,
0.6106528639793396,
1.2248293161392212,
-0.06810905784368515,
-0.2404504120349884,
0.344970703125,
0.6063002347946167,
0.5376259088516235,
1.0497714281082153,
0.6514328718185425,
-0.4021075963973999,
0.40716320276260376,
0.06830846518278122,
0.13571929931640625,
-0.26550450921058655,
-0.7713304162025452,
-1.2863086462020874,
0.09194935113191605,
-0.21762986481189728,
-0.40874454379081726,
-0.11965120583772659,
1.3654462099075317,
0.6390631198883057,
-0.9736573100090027,
-0.415048211812973,
-0.43972480297088623,
0.02959401160478592,
0.2525343894958496,
-0.16109304130077362,
0.22414757311344147,
-0.19455330073833466,
-0.6889626979827881,
0.83465176820755,
0.669519305229187,
0.6288241147994995,
-0.5370675921440125,
-0.402312308549881,
-0.09374408423900604,
0.03217342123389244,
0.5846395492553711,
0.3304678499698639,
-0.5679076313972473,
0.05807063728570938,
-0.07687211036682129,
-0.3719158470630646,
0.3807046413421631,
1.0316003561019897,
-0.802238404750824,
0.5768734216690063,
0.44221949577331543,
0.377956360578537,
0.7167308926582336,
-0.4309300482273102,
0.8137757182121277,
-0.7389811873435974,
0.1673383116722107,
0.05652797967195511,
0.3805001378059387,
0.35373979806900024,
-0.1684534251689911,
0.47472724318504333,
0.12309394031763077,
-0.5077464580535889,
-0.5961187481880188,
0.3388558030128479,
-0.9326466917991638,
-0.674265444278717,
1.2254743576049805,
0.013548360206186771,
-0.4582411050796509,
0.10500186681747437,
-0.4335390031337738,
0.07182961702346802,
-0.4902064800262451,
0.49566271901130676,
0.4303232729434967,
-0.30713531374931335,
-0.07393176108598709,
-0.3302900493144989,
0.6840099096298218,
0.04049481451511383,
-1.041369915008545,
-0.17441490292549133,
0.7058408260345459,
0.24438272416591644,
-0.059728872030973434,
0.7581189870834351,
-0.12385816127061844,
0.00006034178295521997,
-0.046989116817712784,
-0.1771198958158493,
0.003576640272513032,
-0.25808823108673096,
-0.3537611663341522,
0.1498737633228302,
0.1846223920583725,
-0.03655651584267616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04136v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04136v1
|
Enriched BERT Embeddings for Scholarly Publication Classification
| 2024-05-07T09:05:20 | 2024-05-07T09:05:20 |
Benjamin Wolff, Eva Seidlmayer, Konrad U. Förstner
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the rapid expansion of academic literature and the proliferation of
preprints, researchers face growing challenges in manually organizing and
labeling large volumes of articles. The NSLP 2024 FoRC Shared Task I addresses
this challenge organized as a competition. The goal is to develop a classifier
capable of predicting one of 123 predefined classes from the Open Research
Knowledge Graph (ORKG) taxonomy of research fields for a given article.This
paper presents our results. Initially, we enrich the dataset (containing
English scholarly articles sourced from ORKG and arXiv), then leverage
different pre-trained language Models (PLMs), specifically BERT, and explore
their efficacy in transfer learning for this downstream task. Our experiments
encompass feature-based and fine-tuned transfer learning approaches using
diverse PLMs, optimized for scientific tasks, including SciBERT, SciNCL, and
SPECTER2. We conduct hyperparameter tuning and investigate the impact of data
augmentation from bibliographic databases such as OpenAlex, Semantic Scholar,
and Crossref. Our results demonstrate that fine-tuning pre-trained models
substantially enhances classification performance, with SPECTER2 emerging as
the most accurate model. Moreover, enriching the dataset with additional
metadata improves classification outcomes significantly, especially when
integrating information from S2AG, OpenAlex and Crossref. Our best-performing
approach achieves a weighted F1-score of 0.7415. Overall, our study contributes
to the advancement of reliable automated systems for scholarly publication
categorization, offering a potential solution to the laborious manual curation
process, thereby facilitating researchers in efficiently locating relevant
resources.
|
[
-0.4026065170764923,
-0.094902902841568,
0.47480469942092896,
0.02419925108551979,
-0.353516548871994,
0.19364528357982635,
-0.29227277636528015,
-0.879650354385376,
0.1413351595401764,
0.42605772614479065,
-0.05127404257655144,
-0.5846099853515625,
-0.6357756853103638,
0.2699662446975708,
-0.25994712114334106,
1.3700603246688843,
0.05198613181710243,
0.04835350438952446,
-0.5070855021476746,
-0.15451867878437042,
-0.12229187041521072,
-0.4531758427619934,
-0.1437099426984787,
-0.3229559361934662,
0.8037369847297668,
0.158605694770813,
0.3682461678981781,
0.5772193074226379,
0.6474004983901978,
0.2651970386505127,
0.109941765666008,
0.4813620448112488,
-0.38576218485832214,
0.0552615188062191,
-0.2881143093109131,
-0.34176918864250183,
-0.4244343042373657,
0.04076189920306206,
0.5670085549354553,
0.7349706888198853,
0.20711742341518402,
0.17240051925182343,
0.24254460632801056,
0.31327688694000244,
-0.5448421239852905,
0.546140730381012,
-0.4716421365737915,
-0.016160475090146065,
-0.5631573796272278,
-0.3042987883090973,
-0.6530497670173645,
-0.5172867178916931,
0.31825852394104004,
-0.7402404546737671,
0.3741290867328644,
0.21335771679878235,
0.8091346025466919,
0.09190899133682251,
-0.24984577298164368,
-0.33416256308555603,
-0.4737725853919983,
0.6624588966369629,
-0.4017341434955597,
0.6573272943496704,
0.24549344182014465,
-0.13144461810588837,
0.023694321513175964,
-1.0652799606323242,
-0.22729258239269257,
-0.016480827704072,
-0.1259973794221878,
0.22283345460891724,
-0.025637516751885414,
0.09364435821771622,
-0.00009989602403948084,
0.19317077100276947,
-0.6812351942062378,
0.1452653557062149,
-0.48643505573272705,
-0.20260365307331085,
0.6112177968025208,
-0.0277499221265316,
-0.20838268101215363,
-0.11162376403808594,
-0.20314888656139374,
-0.28211504220962524,
-0.3349887430667877,
-0.08024325221776962,
0.36599600315093994,
0.3603333830833435,
0.44739440083503723,
0.4415026903152466,
0.17043553292751312,
0.7360273003578186,
0.0600886195898056,
0.2650202512741089,
0.4426044523715973,
-0.47691553831100464,
0.06066363677382469,
0.18947093188762665,
0.6917369961738586,
0.09409789741039276,
-0.19040600955486298,
-0.26511815190315247,
0.07947432994842529,
-0.35357993841171265,
0.41613373160362244,
-0.6122477650642395,
-0.49875757098197937,
-0.19497883319854736,
-0.40564125776290894,
-0.1961863934993744,
0.28282812237739563,
-0.681959331035614,
-0.3879425823688507,
-0.29381227493286133,
0.25789621472358704,
-0.46750959753990173,
0.21775446832180023,
0.1247996985912323,
0.01881656050682068,
-0.07391121983528137,
0.5825387239456177,
-0.6586788892745972,
0.15730704367160797,
0.7316619753837585,
0.9509889483451843,
-0.4060242474079132,
-0.15539498627185822,
-0.1672583818435669,
0.36772722005844116,
-0.30516964197158813,
0.7359786629676819,
-0.5013492107391357,
-0.1457226276397705,
0.08931896835565567,
0.044044073671102524,
0.14364741742610931,
-0.21053048968315125,
0.8078611493110657,
-0.8468641638755798,
0.1840386539697647,
-0.41657131910324097,
-0.7492631077766418,
-0.2302403450012207,
0.12378895282745361,
-0.693970263004303,
0.9350926280021667,
0.20796027779579163,
-0.9660850167274475,
0.5240314602851868,
-0.8532770872116089,
-0.40100011229515076,
0.4520459771156311,
0.11773928999900818,
-0.37677791714668274,
-0.03202379122376442,
-0.09832534939050674,
0.4823651611804962,
-0.06168327480554581,
0.3012751638889313,
-0.5117194652557373,
-0.09326204657554626,
0.09775833040475845,
0.19522526860237122,
0.7280285358428955,
0.2398715615272522,
0.13376468420028687,
-0.023339295759797096,
-0.5502890348434448,
-0.014504865743219852,
-0.2726043164730072,
-0.47804921865463257,
-0.6484370827674866,
-0.1593693047761917,
0.15908724069595337,
-0.15038974583148956,
0.2547108232975006,
-0.8056832551956177,
0.351725697517395,
-0.14171674847602844,
0.2450183928012848,
0.6462101340293884,
-0.08836334943771362,
0.5654345750808716,
-0.20481793582439423,
0.1927713304758072,
-0.4203924536705017,
0.09484955668449402,
0.177942156791687,
-0.6426185369491577,
-0.6472880244255066,
-0.2989968955516815,
0.9671724438667297,
0.2832154631614685,
-0.7141171097755432,
0.7626705765724182,
-0.4713326692581177,
-0.5924962759017944,
-0.5896332263946533,
-0.03816298395395279,
0.16928906738758087,
0.5715798139572144,
0.5462180972099304,
-0.4433518350124359,
-0.6516045928001404,
-0.5353493690490723,
-0.022573135793209076,
-0.1564352810382843,
0.035197071731090546,
0.27659422159194946,
0.4031091332435608,
-0.2387210577726364,
0.6647756695747375,
-0.4420616030693054,
-0.48068925738334656,
0.08869395405054092,
0.6062822937965393,
0.09316429495811462,
0.47127050161361694,
0.4516129791736603,
-0.7481431365013123,
-0.503378689289093,
0.16128498315811157,
-0.7061144113540649,
-0.27945247292518616,
0.07657448947429657,
-0.2412683516740799,
0.18636387586593628,
0.5160393118858337,
-0.19823920726776123,
0.24773581326007843,
0.20290924608707428,
-0.11211181432008743,
0.4892555773258209,
-0.11501168459653854,
0.058846615254879,
-0.5920624732971191,
0.12049377709627151,
-0.03167545422911644,
-0.11467437446117401,
-0.5248274803161621,
-0.16571228206157684,
0.1778901070356369,
-0.014337419532239437,
-0.2174471616744995,
0.5008498430252075,
-0.36581146717071533,
-0.17438730597496033,
-0.02056013233959675,
-0.20665091276168823,
0.04706289991736412,
0.06066569313406944,
0.3534068465232849,
0.4912128150463104,
0.2759091556072235,
-0.4643431603908539,
0.061513226479291916,
0.6116212606430054,
-0.5378673672676086,
0.005406968295574188,
-0.3929881155490875,
0.12806960940361023,
-0.023332517594099045,
0.5278304815292358,
-0.6053234934806824,
-0.1774238795042038,
0.17594791948795319,
-0.39782893657684326,
0.6210781931877136,
-0.012760497629642487,
-0.8130242228507996,
-0.31757187843322754,
-0.23773211240768433,
0.20404522120952606,
0.217894047498703,
-0.5689946413040161,
0.5627931356430054,
0.06784393638372421,
-0.3751080334186554,
-0.5790695548057556,
-0.6688473224639893,
-0.06379853188991547,
0.11823955923318863,
-0.5223599672317505,
0.7783408761024475,
0.007354575674980879,
0.20065981149673462,
0.3229840397834778,
0.12886787950992584,
0.07568668574094772,
-0.22260454297065735,
0.23402447998523712,
0.3930528163909912,
0.01810513623058796,
0.4938903748989105,
0.18948645889759064,
0.10267053544521332,
-0.06322894245386124,
-0.4655689299106598,
0.4284602105617523,
-0.2857553958892822,
-0.23847778141498566,
0.00015511921083088964,
0.11165592819452286,
0.3374430239200592,
-0.3617253303527832,
0.6418203115463257,
0.8565526604652405,
0.024303879588842392,
-0.10522037744522095,
-0.42511260509490967,
-0.25171127915382385,
-0.4208891987800598,
0.2621178925037384,
-0.03347066044807434,
-1.041932225227356,
0.44169163703918457,
-0.024714646860957146,
0.33848118782043457,
0.3165561854839325,
0.2955838143825531,
-0.33542096614837646,
0.7039722800254822,
0.6610418558120728,
0.07127135992050171,
0.4941583275794983,
-0.3245214819908142,
0.2315363585948944,
-0.7663708329200745,
-0.5152700543403625,
-0.7229981422424316,
-0.36474278569221497,
-0.5639132857322693,
-0.5580480694770813,
0.3549366593360901,
0.0012977375881746411,
-0.2055664211511612,
0.21900007128715515,
-0.6369645595550537,
0.34236618876457214,
0.6256047487258911,
0.1729799062013626,
0.2264045923948288,
0.12170301377773285,
0.0572948083281517,
-0.1477450132369995,
-0.7576939463615417,
-0.378449022769928,
1.2235023975372314,
0.3684394061565399,
0.6838993430137634,
-0.08379290997982025,
1.0235191583633423,
0.5619739294052124,
0.6375454068183899,
-0.6522475481033325,
0.4318585991859436,
-0.5376540422439575,
-0.5423891544342041,
-0.19248221814632416,
-0.179587721824646,
-0.7999899983406067,
-0.1111963540315628,
-0.34499943256378174,
-0.398044615983963,
0.6950372457504272,
-0.1103997603058815,
-0.24373790621757507,
0.15627732872962952,
-0.2990661561489105,
0.5374218225479126,
-0.39864280819892883,
-0.4178728461265564,
0.06846342980861664,
-0.7036615014076233,
0.27403712272644043,
-0.39118337631225586,
0.051486074924468994,
0.15755119919776917,
-0.16665391623973846,
0.8995662927627563,
-0.07271013408899307,
0.5625609159469604,
-0.11315915733575821,
0.2581480145454407,
0.033798545598983765,
-0.14760644733905792,
0.3514818847179413,
-0.003971943166106939,
-0.28299206495285034,
0.24469755589962006,
-0.18029077351093292,
-0.30359628796577454,
-0.45102566480636597,
0.4869963824748993,
-0.8107136487960815,
-0.21257159113883972,
-0.734081506729126,
-0.6229033470153809,
-0.23253683745861053,
0.2031945437192917,
0.3309079110622406,
0.20138584077358246,
0.12456651031970978,
0.5308670997619629,
0.8530686497688293,
-0.21637311577796936,
0.11860887706279755,
0.622434139251709,
-0.08456379920244217,
-0.3782936632633209,
0.9301677346229553,
0.23207086324691772,
-0.07902602851390839,
0.39078015089035034,
0.08826343715190887,
-0.568889319896698,
-0.9755394458770752,
0.009103391319513321,
0.289375901222229,
-0.7905887365341187,
-0.6148248910903931,
-0.9519811868667603,
-0.3359926640987396,
-0.7419552206993103,
-0.31114235520362854,
0.041641514748334885,
-0.2787364721298218,
-0.7167905569076538,
-0.1541682928800583,
0.33748766779899597,
0.6423927545547485,
-0.3570452332496643,
0.1092955693602562,
-0.8781200051307678,
-0.2993868291378021,
0.1123003289103508,
0.36708399653434753,
-0.09172075241804123,
-0.6559768915176392,
-0.26504260301589966,
-0.433292418718338,
-0.24137243628501892,
-0.5683576464653015,
0.5181246995925903,
0.6048513054847717,
0.6444877982139587,
0.43715330958366394,
0.42623767256736755,
0.4906107783317566,
-0.5111122727394104,
0.556669294834137,
0.17164938151836395,
-0.7089385390281677,
0.5175750851631165,
-0.375912070274353,
-0.19681693613529205,
0.8945101499557495,
0.9643867611885071,
-0.01227725949138403,
-0.26758265495300293,
-0.6410818696022034,
-0.8538984060287476,
0.6755703687667847,
-0.12809646129608154,
-0.15337051451206207,
-0.016133910045027733,
0.3649260699748993,
0.4347206652164459,
0.06104506179690361,
-0.6989280581474304,
0.18489892780780792,
-0.2998534142971039,
-0.14754033088684082,
-0.1457671970129013,
-0.09027177840471268,
-0.11993756890296936,
-0.4493059515953064,
0.8270171880722046,
-0.21648429334163666,
0.36397138237953186,
0.22249838709831238,
-0.1431148499250412,
0.04020009562373161,
-0.00607274891808629,
0.4782123267650604,
0.5604753494262695,
-0.645583987236023,
0.19012296199798584,
-0.11866225302219391,
-0.4129544496536255,
-0.12305426597595215,
0.43145552277565,
-0.24662624299526215,
0.21392133831977844,
0.5632782578468323,
0.5251886248588562,
0.06977768242359161,
-0.4520016014575958,
0.27636462450027466,
0.078057661652565,
-0.43600979447364807,
0.01650010608136654,
-0.1429903507232666,
-0.20894448459148407,
0.3434222936630249,
0.4790138602256775,
0.10888518393039703,
0.45941925048828125,
-0.4426877200603485,
0.3599530756473541,
0.21034292876720428,
-0.21138674020767212,
-0.3276595175266266,
0.261543869972229,
0.21636953949928284,
0.0388224795460701,
0.4492378532886505,
-0.37655404210090637,
-0.7254580855369568,
0.24755451083183289,
0.37528833746910095,
0.4373297095298767,
-0.04478220269083977,
0.28331074118614197,
0.24745099246501923,
0.10783791542053223,
-0.15281720459461212,
0.0034724222496151924,
-0.019178055226802826,
-0.6473924517631531,
-0.4110783636569977,
-1.0116868019104004,
-0.41844847798347473,
0.0993371233344078,
-0.783526599407196,
0.2281995564699173,
-0.3765508532524109,
-0.22173233330249786,
0.5175969004631042,
0.3448083698749542,
-0.6410325169563293,
-0.16167040169239044,
0.19323472678661346,
0.9778826236724854,
-1.0335140228271484,
0.9633213877677917,
0.8392843008041382,
-0.36435666680336,
-0.5323154926300049,
-0.370952308177948,
-0.2275630384683609,
-0.2975906431674957,
1.0219839811325073,
-0.026933005079627037,
0.17935746908187866,
0.004615507088601589,
-0.6171379685401917,
-0.773534893989563,
0.9383760094642639,
0.1551654040813446,
-0.484709769487381,
-0.05798516795039177,
-0.08942244201898575,
0.7472254037857056,
-0.4100095331668854,
0.027193870395421982,
0.25058475136756897,
0.7278140783309937,
0.19845397770404816,
-0.7537807822227478,
-0.2115047574043274,
-0.15061530470848083,
-0.08448468148708344,
0.22188006341457367,
-0.3132787048816681,
0.7435432076454163,
0.1759619265794754,
0.07953405380249023,
0.07443662732839584,
0.8355914950370789,
0.1080312430858612,
0.5194569826126099,
0.2875211834907532,
0.7256823778152466,
0.8366235494613647,
-0.242507666349411,
0.8366643190383911,
-0.055259305983781815,
0.33152759075164795,
1.0782685279846191,
-0.387484610080719,
0.7060273885726929,
0.22316859662532806,
-0.2512980103492737,
0.6159703731536865,
0.8728610873222351,
-0.5123594403266907,
0.7617326974868774,
0.037829574197530746,
-0.1967717707157135,
-0.1347811073064804,
-0.43497392535209656,
-0.5526460409164429,
0.5127065777778625,
0.49897992610931396,
-0.5659214854240417,
-0.20230408012866974,
0.3893681466579437,
-0.23130172491073608,
0.044602759182453156,
-0.34086790680885315,
0.7380163669586182,
-0.24888083338737488,
-0.4939105212688446,
0.21695837378501892,
-0.10096011310815811,
0.7826641201972961,
-0.6024788618087769,
0.05418568104505539,
-0.02120807394385338,
0.05680733919143677,
-0.39136892557144165,
-1.0156986713409424,
0.43334463238716125,
-0.17529574036598206,
-0.32269972562789917,
-0.4193341135978699,
1.0679068565368652,
-0.5205098390579224,
-0.40072789788246155,
0.22721539437770844,
0.23683218657970428,
0.3302355408668518,
0.3045927584171295,
-0.6288178563117981,
0.1878044605255127,
-0.002633157419040799,
0.02127457782626152,
0.6121603846549988,
0.5102037787437439,
-0.11595582962036133,
0.3511265516281128,
0.8576374053955078,
0.2843252122402191,
0.15604490041732788,
-0.031283579766750336,
0.9037613272666931,
-0.13075530529022217,
-0.3204701542854309,
-0.17471690475940704,
0.08705828338861465,
-0.22672690451145172,
-0.11729955673217773,
0.7683109045028687,
0.676284670829773,
0.9842694997787476,
-0.290866881608963,
0.6688780188560486,
-0.2610210180282593,
0.5715665221214294,
-0.17904096841812134,
0.7505639791488647,
-0.4346703588962555,
0.08113886415958405,
-0.12969201803207397,
-0.8325883150100708,
-0.5321150422096252,
0.5690381526947021,
-0.3927951157093048,
-0.12187828868627548,
0.41911908984184265,
0.3866800367832184,
-0.006664695218205452,
0.07743337005376816,
-0.044077012687921524,
-0.20606741309165955,
0.37365269660949707,
0.0930231511592865,
0.5631961822509766,
-0.06692536175251007,
0.46530911326408386,
-0.3913021981716156,
-0.2751465439796448,
-0.5088000297546387,
-1.0230003595352173,
-0.735156238079071,
-0.7102570533752441,
-0.47926509380340576,
-0.31469279527664185,
0.3228392004966736,
0.7558855414390564,
0.8175193667411804,
-0.8967662453651428,
0.13912954926490784,
-0.05095062404870987,
-0.16745056211948395,
-0.03190155327320099,
-0.2507341802120209,
0.579358696937561,
-0.5620619654655457,
-0.5435096025466919,
0.12102407962083817,
0.12094207853078842,
-0.10159925371408463,
-0.02473778836429119,
-0.06159842386841774,
-0.5111238956451416,
-0.27622345089912415,
0.6276766657829285,
0.3737987279891968,
-0.4912577271461487,
-0.3193613886833191,
0.09590493142604828,
0.09836116433143616,
-0.1450502723455429,
0.8016052842140198,
-0.6135788559913635,
0.6462631225585938,
0.6416281461715698,
0.9805538654327393,
0.5408469438552856,
0.052568502724170685,
0.3016389310359955,
-0.8338240385055542,
-0.20799697935581207,
0.9338556528091431,
0.16335146129131317,
0.14708870649337769,
-0.38215720653533936,
0.7554223537445068,
0.18598923087120056,
-0.8044462203979492,
-1.02260422706604,
-0.19192121922969818,
-1.1245278120040894,
-0.33623558282852173,
0.785216212272644,
-0.438691109418869,
-0.010563933290541172,
-0.38788923621177673,
0.21358759701251984,
0.33566978573799133,
-0.47122880816459656,
0.7245623469352722,
0.670257031917572,
-0.4229695200920105,
-0.2725459039211273,
-0.48564767837524414,
0.602340042591095,
0.19309291243553162,
-0.8750892281532288,
-0.09790398925542831,
0.333518922328949,
0.01298114750534296,
0.7445653676986694,
0.16463419795036316,
-0.1641334593296051,
0.2525399923324585,
-0.415409117937088,
0.30450379848480225,
-0.4172937870025635,
-0.44836747646331787,
-0.13145694136619568,
0.20688877999782562,
-0.06484423577785492,
0.1351434290409088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04128v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04128v1
|
Fine-grained Speech Sentiment Analysis in Chinese Psychological Support Hotlines Based on Large-scale Pre-trained Model
| 2024-05-07T08:53:25 | 2024-05-07T08:53:25 |
Zhonglong Chen, Changwei Song, Yining Chen, Jianqiang Li, Guanghui Fu, Yongsheng Tong, Qing Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Suicide and suicidal behaviors remain significant challenges for public
policy and healthcare. In response, psychological support hotlines have been
established worldwide to provide immediate help to individuals in mental
crises. The effectiveness of these hotlines largely depends on accurately
identifying callers' emotional states, particularly underlying negative
emotions indicative of increased suicide risk. However, the high demand for
psychological interventions often results in a shortage of professional
operators, highlighting the need for an effective speech emotion recognition
model. This model would automatically detect and analyze callers' emotions,
facilitating integration into hotline services. Additionally, it would enable
large-scale data analysis of psychological support hotline interactions to
explore psychological phenomena and behaviors across populations. Our study
utilizes data from the Beijing psychological support hotline, the largest
suicide hotline in China. We analyzed speech data from 105 callers containing
20,630 segments and categorized them into 11 types of negative emotions. We
developed a negative emotion recognition model and a fine-grained multi-label
classification model using a large-scale pre-trained model. Our experiments
indicate that the negative emotion recognition model achieves a maximum
F1-score of 76.96%. However, it shows limited efficacy in the fine-grained
multi-label classification task, with the best model achieving only a 41.74%
weighted F1-score. We conducted an error analysis for this task, discussed
potential future improvements, and considered the clinical application
possibilities of our study. All the codes are public available.
|
[
-0.5206272006034851,
-0.7063646912574768,
0.38668763637542725,
0.7209177017211914,
-0.229547917842865,
-0.48771145939826965,
-0.4259600043296814,
-0.2661316692829132,
0.013035725802183151,
0.22643011808395386,
-0.5289275050163269,
-0.603969931602478,
-0.49495041370391846,
0.09406506270170212,
-0.20812886953353882,
1.2422471046447754,
0.2831876277923584,
0.4461689591407776,
0.2698113024234772,
-0.042035795748233795,
-0.033364247530698776,
-0.7063187956809998,
-0.763815701007843,
-0.18203860521316528,
0.630484938621521,
0.25618237257003784,
0.4890240430831909,
-0.051099058240652084,
0.5112084746360779,
0.2721487581729889,
-0.2842073440551758,
-0.15733163058757782,
-0.3397108018398285,
-0.34422698616981506,
0.20918862521648407,
-0.20986400544643402,
-0.8125318884849548,
0.21500840783119202,
0.25898486375808716,
0.33700764179229736,
-0.3299541473388672,
0.3689129650592804,
0.3444496989250183,
0.3488350510597229,
-0.5262452363967896,
0.0754619687795639,
-0.31569501757621765,
0.5097081661224365,
-0.4376414716243744,
0.13894018530845642,
-0.3231251537799835,
-0.6166158318519592,
0.4690205454826355,
-0.26466554403305054,
0.08700032532215118,
-0.39647963643074036,
0.665999710559845,
0.16883698105812073,
-0.2693119943141937,
-0.24811822175979614,
-0.6957980394363403,
0.9391666054725647,
-1.1351125240325928,
0.03458648547530174,
0.24992817640304565,
0.2257525473833084,
-0.023969952017068863,
-0.12598146498203278,
-0.4636731743812561,
-0.24237655103206635,
0.07350999861955643,
0.22622264921665192,
-0.21809063851833344,
0.4948243200778961,
0.33455920219421387,
0.4112395644187927,
-0.5108514428138733,
0.23240350186824799,
-0.16356492042541504,
-0.29493650794029236,
0.6586242914199829,
0.25159308314323425,
0.26624152064323425,
-0.313470721244812,
-0.2709081172943115,
0.04530254751443863,
0.09134356677532196,
0.22470107674598694,
0.03371896594762802,
0.4949319660663605,
-0.31306490302085876,
0.16569113731384277,
-0.11803088337182999,
0.5138131380081177,
-0.00315632252022624,
-0.13225655257701874,
0.5905296206474304,
0.2056385725736618,
-0.4381149411201477,
0.12329913675785065,
1.1157587766647339,
0.4459310472011566,
0.3872515857219696,
0.2090320885181427,
-0.11015207320451736,
0.03542181849479675,
0.16034351289272308,
-0.8514599204063416,
-0.05792958661913872,
0.5768258571624756,
-0.7167025208473206,
-0.18679536879062653,
-0.1909054070711136,
-0.9741438031196594,
-0.8536199331283569,
-0.2579788267612457,
0.22767336666584015,
-0.31895649433135986,
-0.45656517148017883,
0.09056906402111053,
-0.04842732474207878,
0.35394954681396484,
0.3691881000995636,
-0.33370211720466614,
0.0008889695163816214,
0.5144636631011963,
1.1681088209152222,
0.1227957233786583,
-0.22445468604564667,
-0.5797920823097229,
-0.41932329535484314,
-0.12656468152999878,
0.7397345304489136,
-0.298518568277359,
-0.23139968514442444,
0.15419219434261322,
0.11366305500268936,
-0.016357453539967537,
-0.4138019382953644,
0.8778292536735535,
-0.025354569777846336,
0.1948031485080719,
-0.366058349609375,
-0.33444705605506897,
0.03757926821708679,
0.4505504071712494,
-0.46896854043006897,
0.5525760650634766,
-0.1786297708749771,
-0.7930534482002258,
-0.0031293132342398167,
-0.712995707988739,
-0.3667754530906677,
-0.010927299968898296,
0.11686572432518005,
-0.55945885181427,
0.13872969150543213,
0.011635467410087585,
0.8112514615058899,
-0.3594873249530792,
0.22161783277988434,
-0.9429410099983215,
-0.40213528275489807,
0.32147881388664246,
-0.6202877163887024,
0.732382595539093,
0.396257609128952,
-0.24090778827667236,
0.08515793830156326,
-0.7822960019111633,
0.13468047976493835,
-0.029648669064044952,
-0.30047494173049927,
-0.46944770216941833,
0.010933445766568184,
0.39806249737739563,
0.6362881064414978,
0.2487652748823166,
-0.7015021443367004,
-0.0928560122847557,
-0.4480080008506775,
0.1736426204442978,
0.6477261185646057,
-0.07356729358434677,
0.1045776903629303,
0.2680913209915161,
0.450421005487442,
0.17475830018520355,
0.5285999178886414,
0.2154272496700287,
-0.4392785131931305,
-0.31507408618927,
-0.04495246335864067,
-0.2708984911441803,
0.7943999767303467,
-0.24470649659633636,
0.4695952236652374,
0.3463688790798187,
-0.7445898652076721,
-0.4781171977519989,
-0.1392488032579422,
0.4487972855567932,
0.6120429635047913,
0.491047739982605,
0.10418566316366196,
-0.546620786190033,
-0.8599121570587158,
-0.1865926831960678,
0.026770468801259995,
-0.12986299395561218,
0.24913640320301056,
-0.038346514105796814,
-0.3032183051109314,
0.6959173679351807,
-0.8291606903076172,
-0.6943066716194153,
-0.1081189289689064,
0.5075798630714417,
0.28640690445899963,
0.283182829618454,
0.4223920702934265,
-0.8815413117408752,
-0.47492435574531555,
-0.03359275683760643,
-0.7614894509315491,
-0.25463545322418213,
0.12588466703891754,
-0.054667968302965164,
-0.05735879763960838,
0.08177454024553299,
-0.3598339259624481,
0.3980534076690674,
0.5622074604034424,
-0.13577120006084442,
0.7253098487854004,
-0.03415160998702049,
0.08688391000032425,
-1.034019947052002,
0.11368969082832336,
0.5388466715812683,
0.36163094639778137,
-1.021692156791687,
-0.5866873860359192,
-0.10982766002416611,
-0.44073736667633057,
-0.5684630274772644,
0.2120729237794876,
-0.05420081317424774,
0.12305152416229248,
-0.43751323223114014,
0.11549272388219833,
-0.4235740303993225,
0.6427785158157349,
0.21391385793685913,
0.37552401423454285,
0.4969441294670105,
-0.30892327427864075,
0.4686936140060425,
0.258248507976532,
-0.11877472698688507,
0.6120499968528748,
-0.610696017742157,
-0.006722519639879465,
-0.14074361324310303,
0.3188856840133667,
-1.0930157899856567,
-0.22415609657764435,
0.11329356580972672,
-0.1985204964876175,
-0.2813204228878021,
-0.07267924398183823,
-0.00980428233742714,
-0.5916435122489929,
-0.3433913588523865,
0.17994844913482666,
0.1999281644821167,
0.08768988400697708,
0.2658628523349762,
0.4568750858306885,
-0.37269458174705505,
-0.5030620098114014,
-0.5552502870559692,
-0.09010697156190872,
-0.48694470524787903,
-0.25258100032806396,
-0.007974929176270962,
0.0067250593565404415,
-0.04338596388697624,
-0.40508583188056946,
0.1703357994556427,
-0.301695317029953,
0.06930927187204361,
0.39332282543182373,
0.16984327137470245,
-0.22332359850406647,
0.24334849417209625,
-0.0674213245511055,
-0.14367438852787018,
0.2029379904270172,
0.16330118477344513,
0.6500965356826782,
-0.5216283202171326,
0.0010267662582919002,
-0.7756128311157227,
0.43647095561027527,
0.8175678253173828,
-0.39755314588546753,
0.6423689723014832,
1.123853325843811,
-0.6510797142982483,
0.12595024704933167,
-0.4408446252346039,
0.12336018681526184,
-0.449928343296051,
0.4750363230705261,
0.13942980766296387,
-0.5638051629066467,
0.5218766331672668,
-0.07689721137285233,
-0.0013853284763172269,
0.0738767683506012,
0.4811108410358429,
-0.16422230005264282,
1.3902215957641602,
0.5013540983200073,
-0.42775484919548035,
0.623360812664032,
-0.048373740166425705,
0.2111058235168457,
-0.5767621397972107,
0.06819340586662292,
-0.3857177495956421,
-0.19042983651161194,
-0.3985573947429657,
0.07465177029371262,
0.7264130711555481,
0.06068047508597374,
-0.4353674352169037,
0.06156718730926514,
-0.6159020662307739,
0.08954184502363205,
0.20686057209968567,
0.2663988471031189,
-0.19701610505580902,
-0.25371456146240234,
0.4266454577445984,
-0.12688709795475006,
-0.0689295306801796,
-0.5116415619850159,
0.4727434515953064,
0.5183755159378052,
0.6636892557144165,
-0.1287052482366562,
0.611108124256134,
0.3537500500679016,
0.5956068634986877,
-0.9285591244697571,
0.574672281742096,
-0.7422517538070679,
-0.338657408952713,
-0.4746924340724945,
-0.36633020639419556,
-0.5650909543037415,
0.05043472349643707,
-0.22903777658939362,
-1.0642213821411133,
0.1525263637304306,
0.25641000270843506,
-0.8675857782363892,
-0.0026927446015179157,
-0.9554108381271362,
1.0713571310043335,
-0.20797429978847504,
0.16507983207702637,
-0.07168396562337875,
-0.44164595007896423,
0.44454658031463623,
-0.16447341442108154,
0.2239440232515335,
-0.27105557918548584,
0.6578221321105957,
1.0680900812149048,
-0.49546119570732117,
0.8746702671051025,
-0.7298099398612976,
-0.5504761934280396,
0.24078789353370667,
-0.2913397550582886,
0.35941648483276367,
-0.1723763346672058,
-0.3882197439670563,
0.10740615427494049,
0.1299731433391571,
-0.25966116786003113,
-0.5625367760658264,
0.47507545351982117,
-0.8189535140991211,
-0.4622795879840851,
0.013996145687997341,
-0.38510745763778687,
-0.45016416907310486,
0.3188641667366028,
0.38926586508750916,
0.5624749660491943,
-0.0537058562040329,
-0.0069261593744158745,
0.4358428716659546,
-0.5748412013053894,
0.39521080255508423,
0.27753910422325134,
-0.08706428110599518,
-0.3919098377227783,
0.9878926277160645,
0.5286312699317932,
0.07272518426179886,
0.05765056610107422,
0.5414183735847473,
-0.06720027327537537,
-0.2298743575811386,
-0.13863058388233185,
0.10236083716154099,
-0.3421652615070343,
-0.1771503984928131,
-0.6228834986686707,
-0.2959992587566376,
-0.4918387234210968,
0.04022502154111862,
-0.4882166385650635,
0.2328946590423584,
-0.21860793232917786,
0.03004150092601776,
0.3238702714443207,
0.37986597418785095,
-0.10824226588010788,
0.413379430770874,
-1.0833114385604858,
0.28390902280807495,
0.12863397598266602,
0.277946799993515,
0.36735451221466064,
-0.06909776479005814,
-0.5265138745307922,
0.17841990292072296,
-0.4128115773200989,
-1.1413313150405884,
0.3808160722255707,
0.10304731130599976,
0.07137640565633774,
0.9753345251083374,
0.42431795597076416,
0.977300226688385,
-0.4138912856578827,
0.9107518196105957,
0.3019312620162964,
-1.108371376991272,
0.6259180903434753,
-0.5514636635780334,
0.12029396742582321,
0.33829861879348755,
0.423075795173645,
-0.8697797656059265,
-0.3387719690799713,
-0.2755679190158844,
-0.6679475903511047,
0.8587484955787659,
-0.15097089111804962,
0.10301048308610916,
0.09692101180553436,
0.19593921303749084,
-0.21690721809864044,
0.16815951466560364,
-0.6164485216140747,
-0.31706127524375916,
-0.18912121653556824,
-0.5425823330879211,
-0.09821200370788574,
-0.05844895914196968,
-0.057198718190193176,
-0.08109772205352783,
0.411088764667511,
-0.1273554116487503,
0.5452796816825867,
0.1365559995174408,
0.4387938976287842,
-0.20399682223796844,
0.4970606565475464,
0.4771411716938019,
-0.009646210819482803,
-0.41562792658805847,
-0.17837674915790558,
0.3644145429134369,
-0.69028639793396,
0.183397576212883,
0.39559975266456604,
0.2918700575828552,
-0.16708451509475708,
0.2056121826171875,
0.6419758796691895,
-0.04563445225358009,
-0.6112237572669983,
0.8449687957763672,
-0.0032620823476463556,
0.0008617352577857673,
-0.48654869198799133,
-0.03823398798704147,
-0.1089622974395752,
0.39581167697906494,
0.40909817814826965,
0.018478160724043846,
0.5260552763938904,
-0.2974182665348053,
0.20708511769771576,
0.5069996118545532,
-0.619551956653595,
-0.5370438098907471,
0.17664270102977753,
0.20927558839321136,
-0.3851300776004791,
0.5196318030357361,
-0.2730158865451813,
-0.7386202216148376,
0.4566507041454315,
0.3090457022190094,
0.9939095973968506,
-0.6110631227493286,
0.5758075714111328,
0.16175685822963715,
-0.3042115867137909,
-0.1135014072060585,
0.3116529881954193,
0.0815635621547699,
-0.760433554649353,
-0.2494288831949234,
-0.6008104681968689,
-0.4338083267211914,
0.5491402745246887,
-1.2073949575424194,
0.35394325852394104,
-0.5531706809997559,
-0.4707876145839691,
0.1219831183552742,
0.10223168879747391,
-0.4652697443962097,
0.626588761806488,
0.9059476256370544,
0.7849908471107483,
-0.9942272305488586,
0.7046135663986206,
0.6767734289169312,
-0.1707553118467331,
-0.9001701474189758,
0.27580398321151733,
0.19738532602787018,
-0.43397030234336853,
0.3759795129299164,
0.5856719017028809,
-0.18738791346549988,
-0.1386880725622177,
-0.5313063263893127,
-0.48742878437042236,
0.7628439664840698,
0.27945849299430847,
-0.46373093128204346,
-0.29089662432670593,
0.23368622362613678,
0.854120671749115,
-0.11086305975914001,
0.37124207615852356,
0.4002148509025574,
0.35326430201530457,
-0.20596161484718323,
-0.9574729800224304,
-0.07313181459903717,
-0.35271912813186646,
-0.20440420508384705,
0.18531838059425354,
-0.9837940335273743,
0.912221372127533,
0.05712416023015976,
-0.22034449875354767,
-0.12000148743391037,
0.4114844799041748,
0.18827001750469208,
0.6321033239364624,
0.7309656739234924,
0.29777294397354126,
0.8550474047660828,
0.12580245733261108,
0.4699009656906128,
0.002711931010708213,
0.7051389813423157,
0.7165493369102478,
-0.4091077744960785,
0.9751303791999817,
0.15371482074260712,
-0.20891441404819489,
0.42256811261177063,
0.4856220781803131,
0.03247842937707901,
0.40285027027130127,
0.0884862020611763,
-0.23550419509410858,
-0.36974161863327026,
-0.3203311860561371,
-0.2038128525018692,
0.42056116461753845,
0.5637075901031494,
-0.1793951690196991,
-0.39647719264030457,
0.7071905732154846,
0.009004096500575542,
-0.4116973876953125,
-0.5018973350524902,
0.7087293863296509,
0.24721631407737732,
-0.25450217723846436,
0.6545301079750061,
-0.19959160685539246,
0.7695749402046204,
-0.468404084444046,
0.15202850103378296,
-0.002849656855687499,
0.5345231890678406,
-0.4817114770412445,
-0.7549223303794861,
0.2514394521713257,
0.4104459881782532,
-0.13078245520591736,
0.07774163782596588,
0.6032248139381409,
-0.43985676765441895,
-0.29764455556869507,
0.4738355278968811,
0.22081749141216278,
0.17661364376544952,
-0.4284883439540863,
-1.0656384229660034,
-0.06768979132175446,
-0.016458967700600624,
-0.4829985797405243,
0.33677616715431213,
0.5712406635284424,
0.06546756625175476,
0.4510432481765747,
0.4116954505443573,
0.1874414086341858,
-0.243670254945755,
0.26636990904808044,
0.6897716522216797,
-0.8043466806411743,
-0.6816684603691101,
-1.017996072769165,
0.485093891620636,
-0.17527465522289276,
-0.4813224673271179,
0.7655162215232849,
0.11523745208978653,
0.34613358974456787,
-0.1233242005109787,
0.7705127000808716,
0.09430820494890213,
0.4841296970844269,
-0.17643657326698303,
0.7449482083320618,
-0.4876185953617096,
-0.16954749822616577,
-0.9417479038238525,
-0.5683369040489197,
-0.432880699634552,
0.4619552493095398,
-0.822029709815979,
-0.2406790554523468,
0.10179301351308823,
0.733273446559906,
0.046187300235033035,
0.28880614042282104,
0.22716280817985535,
0.3733367323875427,
0.4962722063064575,
0.7391071319580078,
0.8767720460891724,
-0.36681029200553894,
0.5752734541893005,
-0.20504936575889587,
-0.4390057921409607,
-0.12245859205722809,
-0.5503561496734619,
-0.7381806373596191,
-0.5844008326530457,
-0.1968582421541214,
-0.3892485499382019,
-0.3829050064086914,
1.211089015007019,
0.5633352994918823,
-0.8530319929122925,
-0.195222407579422,
0.1948564201593399,
-0.316608190536499,
-0.2697909474372864,
-0.3435983657836914,
0.4972456097602844,
-0.21304456889629364,
-0.5566293001174927,
-0.12311901897192001,
0.14855057001113892,
0.06097706779837608,
-0.12953253090381622,
0.03731992095708847,
0.1289413571357727,
0.05171561986207962,
0.6964192390441895,
0.2924589216709137,
-0.5727595090866089,
-0.10031207650899887,
-0.10673318803310394,
-0.188209667801857,
-0.06509888172149658,
0.7509597539901733,
-0.3219059109687805,
0.0689755231142044,
0.2156631350517273,
0.5489710569381714,
-0.24565880000591278,
0.20664986968040466,
0.3551328778266907,
-0.5076548457145691,
0.0631408542394638,
0.15659037232398987,
0.3255586624145508,
0.22578434646129608,
-0.7073363065719604,
-0.12855014204978943,
0.030807413160800934,
-0.5455845594406128,
-0.8970018029212952,
0.016841407865285873,
-0.888213038444519,
-0.15969489514827728,
1.1094727516174316,
-0.512022852897644,
-0.16088701784610748,
-0.054496027529239655,
-0.6205273866653442,
0.4619438052177429,
-0.5526300072669983,
0.7833660244941711,
0.6799077987670898,
-0.4077968895435333,
-0.06635711342096329,
-0.2319730669260025,
0.7069655656814575,
0.24265892803668976,
-0.6952386498451233,
0.496632844209671,
0.37909555435180664,
0.06902109086513519,
0.510069727897644,
0.660537600517273,
0.10069210827350616,
0.22858405113220215,
-0.5726917386054993,
0.07152140885591507,
0.25319015979766846,
-0.09213066101074219,
-0.6286965608596802,
0.43916982412338257,
-0.34870705008506775,
-0.21409273147583008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04118v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04118v1
|
Policy Learning with a Language Bottleneck
| 2024-05-07T08:40:21 | 2024-05-07T08:40:21 |
Megha Srivastava, Cedric Colas, Dorsa Sadigh, Jacob Andreas
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Modern AI systems such as self-driving cars and game-playing agents achieve
superhuman performance, but often lack human-like features such as
generalization, interpretability and human inter-operability. Inspired by the
rich interactions between language and decision-making in humans, we introduce
Policy Learning with a Language Bottleneck (PLLB), a framework enabling AI
agents to generate linguistic rules that capture the strategies underlying
their most rewarding behaviors. PLLB alternates between a rule generation step
guided by language models, and an update step where agents learn new policies
guided by rules. In a two-player communication game, a maze solving task, and
two image reconstruction tasks, we show that PLLB agents are not only able to
learn more interpretable and generalizable behaviors, but can also share the
learned rules with human users, enabling more effective human-AI coordination.
|
[
-0.5472243428230286,
-0.723695695400238,
0.3284788727760315,
0.3968561291694641,
0.24972088634967804,
0.2966199815273285,
-0.17937599122524261,
-0.2809905707836151,
-0.1331627070903778,
0.8144832253456116,
-0.7344130873680115,
-0.08048664778470993,
-0.25191980600357056,
-0.09442274272441864,
0.13913807272911072,
1.317594051361084,
0.149860680103302,
-0.17766550183296204,
-0.376803457736969,
-0.029683873057365417,
-0.6503638029098511,
-0.179489403963089,
-0.8211032748222351,
-0.723768413066864,
0.1933862715959549,
0.49063634872436523,
1.0497418642044067,
0.8635318875312805,
0.22081872820854187,
0.40578389167785645,
0.14123781025409698,
0.23070411384105682,
-0.5864019393920898,
0.0366138257086277,
-0.4589898884296417,
-0.5371122360229492,
-0.20292669534683228,
-0.1048724353313446,
0.48535722494125366,
0.6358174681663513,
-0.34243661165237427,
-0.34060442447662354,
0.014026853255927563,
0.6851748824119568,
-0.23626482486724854,
0.6919878125190735,
-0.37053123116493225,
0.035078149288892746,
0.015103732235729694,
-0.03250207379460335,
-0.009777997620403767,
-0.2591456174850464,
0.44207102060317993,
-0.9340457320213318,
0.1702052503824234,
0.29419150948524475,
0.9483886957168579,
0.41765448451042175,
-0.22273525595664978,
-0.7560648322105408,
-0.4168541431427002,
0.6211660504341125,
-0.20127633213996887,
0.14402928948402405,
0.4858402609825134,
0.20076532661914825,
-0.4607976973056793,
-0.34248682856559753,
-0.7124600410461426,
-0.3943440318107605,
-0.09675949066877365,
-0.20545673370361328,
-0.20095035433769226,
0.38920360803604126,
0.3216390609741211,
0.01117932703346014,
-0.6102969646453857,
0.2705000042915344,
-0.6093404293060303,
-0.4833531081676483,
0.884739339351654,
0.1802671253681183,
0.28780582547187805,
0.1601846069097519,
-0.49994295835494995,
-0.39345499873161316,
-0.8076126575469971,
0.4422755539417267,
0.40952268242836,
0.12222348153591156,
-0.25238537788391113,
-0.04592422395944595,
-0.22434507310390472,
0.4789831340312958,
-0.1638372540473938,
-0.0023307912051677704,
0.3741205334663391,
0.007779564242810011,
0.15331175923347473,
-0.12129313498735428,
0.7650759220123291,
0.2303384244441986,
0.5723225474357605,
-0.27781444787979126,
-0.25905877351760864,
0.01609618589282036,
0.16901136934757233,
-0.3918842673301697,
-0.3251166343688965,
-0.08354233205318451,
-0.15669061243534088,
-0.09899351745843887,
-0.077858567237854,
-0.9988123178482056,
-0.49848219752311707,
-0.15173669159412384,
0.3179183006286621,
-0.314261794090271,
-0.3750363886356354,
0.13381321728229523,
-0.16657567024230957,
0.5625069737434387,
0.13823626935482025,
-0.9096326231956482,
0.3674534857273102,
0.6826294660568237,
0.6729855537414551,
-0.19436578452587128,
-0.7866037487983704,
-0.3231426179409027,
0.04529137536883354,
-0.5486430525779724,
0.6970720291137695,
-0.2155706286430359,
-0.7133182287216187,
-0.05671241134405136,
-0.18520192801952362,
0.16733424365520477,
-0.7892667651176453,
0.050507862120866776,
-0.3164547085762024,
-0.06998427957296371,
-0.36888161301612854,
-0.4078998565673828,
-0.07708238810300827,
0.07926344126462936,
-0.7558738589286804,
0.6455511450767517,
0.02308754250407219,
-0.008902806788682938,
0.4036761522293091,
-1.0110039710998535,
-0.8842303156852722,
0.38471242785453796,
-0.38468000292778015,
-0.4490261673927307,
0.01161399856209755,
-0.12500068545341492,
0.16451430320739746,
-0.27916762232780457,
0.3651091754436493,
-0.017528263852000237,
-0.16259321570396423,
0.09921692311763763,
-0.2974856495857239,
0.7797761559486389,
0.30969130992889404,
-0.35151517391204834,
0.09635478258132935,
-0.4476185441017151,
-0.1912020742893219,
0.11323552578687668,
-0.6541827917098999,
0.020304987207055092,
0.26879385113716125,
-0.41102075576782227,
0.17847532033920288,
0.4381493330001831,
-0.206130251288414,
0.41084620356559753,
-0.3057427704334259,
0.5414355993270874,
0.8805893063545227,
-0.024628154933452606,
0.606611967086792,
-0.5978415608406067,
0.43921107053756714,
-0.19194181263446808,
0.043011099100112915,
-0.09240837395191193,
-0.49579644203186035,
-0.8050207495689392,
0.030482802540063858,
-0.30096909403800964,
0.6349196434020996,
-1.0669468641281128,
0.1694829761981964,
0.01161460392177105,
-0.022693490609526634,
-0.7901756167411804,
0.5245109796524048,
0.7066699862480164,
0.2795102298259735,
0.2502393424510956,
-0.5428541898727417,
-0.3024175763130188,
-0.6667388081550598,
-0.391901433467865,
-0.436922162771225,
0.16480332612991333,
0.6596924066543579,
0.6617808938026428,
-0.10538391023874283,
0.884663999080658,
-0.34898391366004944,
-0.5674008131027222,
-0.5177246332168579,
0.7174631953239441,
-0.1699691265821457,
0.5819154381752014,
0.08965811133384705,
-0.8920438289642334,
-0.5010409951210022,
-0.05344231426715851,
-0.7133699059486389,
-0.21272152662277222,
-0.4033706784248352,
0.16333520412445068,
0.32363957166671753,
0.6525205373764038,
-0.43514397740364075,
0.18650220334529877,
0.22203880548477173,
-0.5584102869033813,
0.6193041205406189,
-0.6631418466567993,
-0.25596433877944946,
-0.1644590049982071,
-0.2846449613571167,
-0.21949762105941772,
-0.3167100250720978,
-0.7745420336723328,
0.1849963515996933,
-0.3439745604991913,
-0.14048704504966736,
-0.39173948764801025,
0.5022992491722107,
-0.4790610671043396,
-0.13926105201244354,
-0.35008302330970764,
0.04974360018968582,
-0.1316099911928177,
0.8041950464248657,
0.21135757863521576,
1.1168111562728882,
0.6793662309646606,
-0.7675395011901855,
0.32865747809410095,
0.0743074119091034,
-0.317525178194046,
0.6086797118186951,
-0.531855583190918,
0.04521336406469345,
-0.3529983162879944,
0.06815720349550247,
-0.4378063380718231,
-0.23093701899051666,
-0.04555902257561684,
-0.1891050487756729,
0.2061978131532669,
0.53384929895401,
-0.18716782331466675,
-0.33083075284957886,
-0.07761738449335098,
0.20736892521381378,
0.7052530646324158,
-0.18301215767860413,
0.5079307556152344,
0.6597272753715515,
0.1718718260526657,
-0.5677074790000916,
-0.5444634556770325,
-0.04917420074343681,
0.006952167022973299,
-0.0711057037115097,
0.1716150939464569,
-0.012485579587519169,
-0.23559804260730743,
0.1580115109682083,
0.17094925045967102,
-0.24973149597644806,
0.3199562132358551,
0.3751663863658905,
-0.13727053999900818,
0.07575124502182007,
0.20558024942874908,
-0.30516374111175537,
-0.04172517731785774,
0.0774112269282341,
-0.21127068996429443,
0.5688728094100952,
-0.6221996545791626,
0.10111664235591888,
-0.4305063784122467,
0.28662216663360596,
0.49346429109573364,
-0.06816641241312027,
0.43357622623443604,
0.4919584393501282,
0.05390717089176178,
-0.5420201420783997,
-0.3637653589248657,
-0.14268577098846436,
-0.513481080532074,
0.6489814519882202,
-0.6074370741844177,
-0.9689428806304932,
0.28950220346450806,
-0.3217129409313202,
0.051389891654253006,
0.20341481268405914,
0.5423333644866943,
-0.4348982870578766,
0.8711988925933838,
0.9420364499092102,
-0.28083616495132446,
0.41569918394088745,
-0.2617734968662262,
-0.06707344204187393,
-0.20693433284759521,
-0.3782975971698761,
-0.19814197719097137,
-0.13970035314559937,
-0.8337454795837402,
-0.5134273171424866,
0.4183439314365387,
0.22317156195640564,
-0.521144449710846,
0.3706507980823517,
-0.13219156861305237,
0.7166558504104614,
1.0755691528320312,
0.042802002280950546,
0.17214052379131317,
-0.13654503226280212,
-0.14786304533481598,
0.18646182119846344,
-0.7994201183319092,
-0.09015005826950073,
0.7585814595222473,
0.2759200632572174,
0.7230837345123291,
0.07363130152225494,
0.6394633650779724,
0.5919249653816223,
0.11400569975376129,
-0.37893226742744446,
0.6088622212409973,
-0.07391457259654999,
-0.5431647896766663,
-0.629625678062439,
-0.750126838684082,
-1.1315666437149048,
0.08852420747280121,
-0.3461855947971344,
-0.729500949382782,
0.021792948246002197,
0.42253395915031433,
-0.3282068073749542,
0.08877257257699966,
-0.4515383243560791,
1.1386709213256836,
-0.5874418020248413,
-0.4531833529472351,
-0.6547693610191345,
-0.7309131622314453,
0.12216714769601822,
0.15861093997955322,
0.4943945109844208,
-0.2651664614677429,
-0.043417420238256454,
0.5238454937934875,
-0.2549625635147095,
0.8596611618995667,
-0.31766799092292786,
0.09193776547908783,
0.5004173517227173,
0.25496217608451843,
0.4978157877922058,
-0.3944694995880127,
0.2968544065952301,
0.24090613424777985,
-0.2309269905090332,
-0.344448059797287,
-0.46814945340156555,
0.3686801791191101,
-1.0272631645202637,
-0.7406425476074219,
-0.2814211845397949,
-0.9068402647972107,
-0.03306444361805916,
0.06557538360357285,
0.08208081871271133,
-0.0875554010272026,
-0.29323482513427734,
-0.047470785677433014,
0.539876401424408,
-0.5499042868614197,
0.520153284072876,
0.6727727055549622,
-0.08627324551343918,
-0.023737749084830284,
1.55682373046875,
-0.05048421025276184,
0.3505411744117737,
0.3870713710784912,
0.34029731154441833,
-0.3493536710739136,
-0.2570532262325287,
-0.2292190045118332,
0.15437959134578705,
-0.303946316242218,
0.0832425057888031,
-0.0785629153251648,
-0.2334272265434265,
-0.2598714232444763,
-0.2204599380493164,
-0.33693212270736694,
0.027776343747973442,
-0.20705080032348633,
0.21034878492355347,
0.07979412376880646,
0.982733964920044,
-0.4497792422771454,
0.6687590479850769,
-0.16470782458782196,
0.22642137110233307,
0.4537679851055145,
0.3006344735622406,
-0.07213784754276276,
0.0742291584610939,
-0.048289429396390915,
-0.2276056706905365,
-0.7160866260528564,
-0.7319057583808899,
0.36882489919662476,
0.6505607962608337,
0.5793914794921875,
0.5935594439506531,
-0.02427920699119568,
0.616895318031311,
-0.5743118524551392,
0.5173547267913818,
0.3546498715877533,
-0.9233474135398865,
0.2580382823944092,
0.06259991973638535,
0.3015219569206238,
0.4850673973560333,
0.3713981807231903,
-0.5054531097412109,
-0.30677130818367004,
-0.32050538063049316,
-0.702579915523529,
0.5174956917762756,
-0.0405641607940197,
0.0412643663585186,
0.10572584718465805,
0.16697748005390167,
0.024351177737116814,
0.6488856673240662,
-0.81944340467453,
-0.07753924280405045,
-0.09480960667133331,
-0.10502780973911285,
-0.12889669835567474,
-0.0019798194989562035,
0.15950843691825867,
-0.033263180404901505,
0.4805087447166443,
-0.23901796340942383,
0.08484429866075516,
0.1339128613471985,
-0.2555871903896332,
-0.05673421919345856,
0.19675226509571075,
0.5001364350318909,
0.408457487821579,
0.06699912995100021,
0.04354308173060417,
0.07691347599029541,
-0.2485160380601883,
0.1668122261762619,
-0.11844839155673981,
-0.3911195397377014,
-0.6071857213973999,
0.4469986855983734,
1.15511155128479,
0.12083565443754196,
-1.3075038194656372,
0.5606562495231628,
0.13205969333648682,
-0.4208953380584717,
-0.15277869999408722,
0.28031548857688904,
-0.31464332342147827,
0.6629736423492432,
0.34470880031585693,
-0.12407141178846359,
-0.011288507841527462,
-0.8505694270133972,
0.5449510812759399,
0.6800795793533325,
-0.3986265957355499,
-0.18883956968784332,
0.6300559639930725,
0.37671399116516113,
-0.6904522180557251,
0.4948605000972748,
-0.8425271511077881,
-0.8649622797966003,
0.591256320476532,
0.3867684006690979,
0.5705934166908264,
0.013979878276586533,
0.5904950499534607,
-0.04111776873469353,
0.36400383710861206,
-0.16054849326610565,
0.3123157322406769,
-0.36605626344680786,
-0.8571181893348694,
-0.4174363911151886,
-0.6304295659065247,
-0.3863216042518616,
0.04720621183514595,
-0.3893689811229706,
-0.0823649987578392,
-0.5777269005775452,
-0.04633914306759834,
-0.41489794850349426,
0.23671843111515045,
-0.8494443893432617,
-0.1704462617635727,
0.047389473766088486,
0.45254966616630554,
-0.6885640025138855,
0.7588791251182556,
0.4814390540122986,
-0.5067326426506042,
-0.5788408517837524,
-0.16345694661140442,
-0.0182891134172678,
-1.015480875968933,
0.7115471959114075,
0.0924583300948143,
0.06539244949817657,
0.00937140453606844,
-0.47628065943717957,
-0.5441172122955322,
0.9233673810958862,
0.2083008587360382,
-0.6726458072662354,
-0.5041237473487854,
0.33257243037223816,
0.5643801093101501,
-0.3259463608264923,
-0.0054284874349832535,
0.8856726288795471,
0.32812684774398804,
-0.10336810350418091,
-1.0748940706253052,
-0.09506784379482269,
0.29743725061416626,
-0.16803808510303497,
0.1599806696176529,
-0.7656672596931458,
0.958781898021698,
-0.44561925530433655,
-0.3568594753742218,
-0.007206952199339867,
0.6379802823066711,
0.02400088682770729,
0.37415292859077454,
0.7322658896446228,
0.5386661291122437,
0.7741753458976746,
-0.11266975104808807,
0.8556355237960815,
-0.3807455599308014,
0.408016175031662,
0.994539201259613,
-0.32603582739830017,
0.6596619486808777,
0.4124546945095062,
-0.20438432693481445,
0.6802924275398254,
0.14667002856731415,
-0.06371332705020905,
0.6491564512252808,
0.4506909251213074,
-0.12826445698738098,
-0.24452273547649384,
-0.4204322397708893,
0.1769416630268097,
0.7184163331985474,
0.5074256658554077,
-0.006897043436765671,
-0.3664567172527313,
0.273084431886673,
-0.0040922160260379314,
0.264153391122818,
-0.5609893202781677,
1.1343947649002075,
-0.06559397280216217,
-0.9705852270126343,
0.4588146209716797,
-0.2862844467163086,
0.6976978778839111,
-0.48635104298591614,
-0.36015674471855164,
0.021565720438957214,
0.2980373501777649,
0.20691943168640137,
-0.8704067468643188,
0.19205622375011444,
-0.2853949964046478,
0.08083101361989975,
-0.4040167033672333,
0.43594565987586975,
-0.6958689093589783,
0.008009379729628563,
0.3784335255622864,
0.5692671537399292,
0.511243999004364,
0.2536346912384033,
-0.9316917657852173,
-0.03202812746167183,
0.047299355268478394,
-0.006434643175452948,
0.3153199851512909,
0.20369379222393036,
-0.20737916231155396,
1.0709789991378784,
0.35782331228256226,
0.5529429912567139,
0.09313366562128067,
-0.3783179819583893,
0.5121631026268005,
-0.5732284188270569,
-0.6814329028129578,
-0.7461585402488708,
0.18990667164325714,
-0.1355496495962143,
-0.3082735240459442,
0.3629453778266907,
0.2370826005935669,
1.1463170051574707,
0.14956693351268768,
0.8612871170043945,
-0.22118109464645386,
0.13618093729019165,
-0.36664319038391113,
0.6760716438293457,
-0.47950929403305054,
0.1541634202003479,
0.329698771238327,
-0.2804831564426422,
-0.02775830402970314,
0.8368380069732666,
-0.2927505373954773,
-0.18691103160381317,
0.29643937945365906,
0.9658564329147339,
0.43645355105400085,
-0.27025893330574036,
0.5423351526260376,
0.25774067640304565,
0.3121345043182373,
0.9847980737686157,
0.6646439433097839,
0.16990511119365692,
0.633493959903717,
-0.18638542294502258,
-0.40528810024261475,
-0.08289162069559097,
-0.6885806918144226,
-0.9705411195755005,
-0.7218789458274841,
-0.08956143260002136,
-0.3060920238494873,
0.47201138734817505,
0.9951290488243103,
0.731781005859375,
-0.6466572284698486,
-0.7716081738471985,
-0.6552754640579224,
0.5863332748413086,
-0.4185670018196106,
-0.3161552846431732,
0.15531718730926514,
-0.7489796876907349,
-0.600451648235321,
0.29409369826316833,
0.1027393788099289,
-0.07848268747329712,
-0.4949730634689331,
-0.6108658909797668,
-0.07990433275699615,
-0.011293531395494938,
0.12964867055416107,
0.9733914136886597,
-0.7392631769180298,
-0.06457018852233887,
-0.6421110033988953,
0.02505357190966606,
-0.02097286283969879,
1.1864014863967896,
-0.753516674041748,
0.7197765111923218,
0.2162313014268875,
0.8499770164489746,
0.4453473389148712,
0.0020936394575983286,
0.6838179230690002,
-0.7412272691726685,
0.34538546204566956,
0.20529232919216156,
-0.08385442197322845,
0.1134052574634552,
-0.170084148645401,
0.20902788639068604,
0.3468969464302063,
-0.7884831428527832,
-0.7112460732460022,
0.5160054564476013,
-0.2978575825691223,
-0.5549859404563904,
0.7594157457351685,
-0.3590066730976105,
-0.3961944580078125,
-0.2952798008918762,
-0.13567470014095306,
0.04933043569326401,
-0.711802065372467,
0.724210798740387,
0.39319828152656555,
-0.29259100556373596,
-0.23888204991817474,
-0.7375312447547913,
1.071516752243042,
0.308144211769104,
-0.6058299541473389,
0.005137934815138578,
0.3784111738204956,
0.10922987759113312,
0.18840475380420685,
0.672616183757782,
0.4523155391216278,
0.3921370506286621,
0.089035764336586,
0.22274619340896606,
-0.10577181726694107,
-0.7543882727622986,
-0.22003544867038727,
0.19688159227371216,
0.07510656118392944,
-0.07762423157691956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04086v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04086v1
|
Optimizing Language Model's Reasoning Abilities with Weak Supervision
| 2024-05-07T07:39:15 | 2024-05-07T07:39:15 |
Yongqi Tong, Sizhe Wang, Dawei Li, Yifan Wang, Simeng Han, Zi Lin, Chengsong Huang, Jiaxin Huang, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated proficiency in handling
complex queries, much of the past work has depended on extensively annotated
datasets by human experts. However, this reliance on fully-supervised
annotations poses scalability challenges, particularly as models and data
requirements grow. To mitigate this, we explore the potential of enhancing
LLMs' reasoning abilities with minimal human supervision. In this work, we
introduce self-reinforcement, which begins with Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) of
the model using a small collection of annotated questions. Then it iteratively
improves LLMs by learning from the differences in responses from the SFT and
unfinetuned models on unlabeled questions. Our approach provides an efficient
approach without relying heavily on extensive human-annotated explanations.
However, current reasoning benchmarks typically only include golden-reference
answers or rationales. Therefore, we present \textsc{PuzzleBen}, a weakly
supervised benchmark that comprises 25,147 complex questions, answers, and
human-generated rationales across various domains, such as brainteasers,
puzzles, riddles, parajumbles, and critical reasoning tasks. A unique aspect of
our dataset is the inclusion of 10,000 unannotated questions, enabling us to
explore utilizing fewer supersized data to boost LLMs' inference capabilities.
Our experiments underscore the significance of \textsc{PuzzleBen}, as well as
the effectiveness of our methodology as a promising direction in future
endeavors. Our dataset and code will be published soon on \texttt{Anonymity
Link}.
|
[
-0.5378361344337463,
-0.8934841156005859,
0.6985551714897156,
0.24458111822605133,
-0.09844676405191422,
-0.2843809723854065,
-0.5288851857185364,
-0.3252702057361603,
-0.057850055396556854,
0.7950841784477234,
-0.6945804953575134,
-0.35662218928337097,
-0.379924476146698,
0.15545159578323364,
-0.2598497271537781,
0.9575903415679932,
0.08403418958187103,
-0.1484156847000122,
-0.36220455169677734,
-0.07401492446660995,
-0.11845588684082031,
-0.3628612756729126,
-0.6362825036048889,
-0.5249762535095215,
0.5905952453613281,
0.6789900660514832,
0.6321572065353394,
0.7552659511566162,
0.3880545496940613,
0.33843305706977844,
-0.23211026191711426,
0.4875345528125763,
-0.5017930269241333,
0.25966140627861023,
-0.49699270725250244,
-0.566952645778656,
-0.2944597005844116,
-0.18383881449699402,
0.31179577112197876,
0.8895311951637268,
-0.0916227251291275,
0.14321398735046387,
-0.053237318992614746,
0.5342143774032593,
-0.6048822999000549,
0.2146247923374176,
-0.6823962330818176,
-0.14401230216026306,
-0.1493542194366455,
-0.10492110997438431,
-0.3233644664287567,
-0.091737300157547,
-0.16436472535133362,
-0.43586409091949463,
0.18561474978923798,
0.1683954894542694,
0.8133284449577332,
0.6748675107955933,
-0.41302618384361267,
-0.02970709837973118,
-0.5565303564071655,
0.7203543782234192,
-0.7446298003196716,
0.1273164451122284,
0.6608760356903076,
0.2281101495027542,
-0.5536611676216125,
-0.478262722492218,
-0.15769116580486298,
-0.2706667184829712,
-0.1788489669561386,
0.03489883989095688,
-0.18800492584705353,
0.12134703248739243,
0.6021944880485535,
0.20331533253192902,
-0.39060789346694946,
0.1923762410879135,
-0.30462339520454407,
-0.14123466610908508,
0.8714351058006287,
0.23305635154247284,
-0.056641075760126114,
-0.3223970830440521,
-0.06360555440187454,
0.010336869396269321,
-0.48313573002815247,
0.09367264807224274,
0.3724616467952728,
0.3347858488559723,
0.17464478313922882,
0.5978714227676392,
-0.5953297019004822,
0.6193341612815857,
0.3576359152793884,
0.09059367328882217,
0.0423843115568161,
-0.32249823212623596,
-0.05503552407026291,
-0.035912591964006424,
0.8580129146575928,
0.08613976091146469,
0.5246288180351257,
-0.34293702244758606,
-0.36220869421958923,
0.1568431705236435,
0.2534184455871582,
-0.6885137557983398,
-0.6176156997680664,
0.1217435747385025,
-0.1745690405368805,
-0.10531806200742722,
-0.29302534461021423,
-0.520529568195343,
-0.4504818022251129,
-0.3840164840221405,
0.2695039212703705,
-0.34414389729499817,
-0.2889939546585083,
0.301717609167099,
0.08862876892089844,
-0.0761881172657013,
0.3594924807548523,
-1.0387991666793823,
0.34187132120132446,
0.4071832597255707,
0.3128889799118042,
-0.18047815561294556,
-0.11663216352462769,
-0.5710151791572571,
0.154165580868721,
-0.42401763796806335,
0.8912971019744873,
-0.3605002462863922,
-0.13826921582221985,
-0.24259696900844574,
0.14588791131973267,
0.07120903581380844,
-0.656995415687561,
0.7201371192932129,
-0.2796444892883301,
0.0715307667851448,
-0.355421781539917,
-0.6310349702835083,
0.049711499363183975,
0.35164257884025574,
-0.5167828798294067,
1.131339430809021,
-0.11228308081626892,
-0.7520714998245239,
0.06323421746492386,
-0.4433966875076294,
-0.594231128692627,
-0.08336281776428223,
-0.2829684913158417,
-0.420489639043808,
0.20223654806613922,
0.6576091051101685,
0.487061083316803,
-0.3085874617099762,
0.4146479368209839,
-0.5629733204841614,
-0.4814314544200897,
0.10590141266584396,
-0.2739599943161011,
0.6110038757324219,
0.11125198751688004,
-0.39821627736091614,
0.17409370839595795,
-0.7433464527130127,
0.2414514124393463,
0.29638728499412537,
-0.24211502075195312,
-0.3716643750667572,
0.0620851032435894,
-0.33935436606407166,
0.2287747859954834,
0.17520743608474731,
-0.29498419165611267,
0.3006686866283417,
-0.5319855213165283,
0.281012624502182,
0.759378969669342,
0.20152264833450317,
0.3990824222564697,
-0.19414378702640533,
0.47110214829444885,
-0.04789029434323311,
0.16969405114650726,
-0.038114868104457855,
-0.19079594314098358,
-1.0493098497390747,
-0.10884492099285126,
0.2184559851884842,
0.41470861434936523,
-0.794380247592926,
0.2674207091331482,
0.008426020853221416,
-0.3196304440498352,
-0.5665480494499207,
0.6652259826660156,
0.49483415484428406,
0.4279036223888397,
0.6929264068603516,
-0.0658692792057991,
-0.44147539138793945,
-1.1282519102096558,
-0.3041622042655945,
-0.11585148423910141,
-0.13404373824596405,
0.3204766511917114,
0.47378841042518616,
-0.15851391851902008,
0.7851231098175049,
-0.45105835795402527,
-0.2817299962043762,
-0.3790811002254486,
0.27327388525009155,
0.3037986755371094,
0.5535141229629517,
0.20560450851917267,
-0.5785008072853088,
-0.16744107007980347,
-0.29986923933029175,
-0.8188571929931641,
-0.43447887897491455,
-0.3107664883136749,
-0.3375263512134552,
0.02413228526711464,
0.8200312256813049,
-0.6381027102470398,
0.1736585944890976,
0.2908800542354584,
-0.2668398320674896,
0.4048987925052643,
-0.18740390241146088,
-0.15460529923439026,
-0.6934877634048462,
-0.20813296735286713,
0.041724007576704025,
-0.2875048816204071,
-0.3114564120769501,
-0.09619540721178055,
0.11853686720132828,
0.276169091463089,
-0.1640036702156067,
0.4383637011051178,
-0.48738667368888855,
0.09649494290351868,
-0.19759346544742584,
0.19563423097133636,
-0.16307272017002106,
0.8060373067855835,
0.03955458849668503,
0.5563916563987732,
0.4585970938205719,
-0.5667852759361267,
0.25612714886665344,
0.032698262482881546,
-0.182290717959404,
0.505370557308197,
-0.7886677980422974,
0.09501447528600693,
-0.13501673936843872,
0.06604138761758804,
-0.8599980473518372,
-0.3223874270915985,
0.1958955079317093,
-0.2344007045030594,
0.2897857129573822,
-0.2789915204048157,
-0.8938360214233398,
-0.3002568483352661,
-0.09260702133178711,
0.08336191624403,
0.33295658230781555,
-0.6469250917434692,
0.5264410972595215,
0.2592540979385376,
0.008340752683579922,
-0.3861803412437439,
-0.7088323831558228,
0.03283368796110153,
-0.2222631573677063,
-0.4921600818634033,
-0.001419858424924314,
-0.14219988882541656,
-0.25015485286712646,
0.18044498562812805,
-0.502127468585968,
-0.05885444954037666,
0.3250960409641266,
0.2752869427204132,
-0.009941907599568367,
-0.19451862573623657,
0.38026535511016846,
0.2742290496826172,
-0.18195335566997528,
0.273314505815506,
-0.15074805915355682,
0.10848667472600937,
-0.5070168972015381,
-0.4573934078216553,
-0.2125588059425354,
0.10187631845474243,
0.15519866347312927,
-0.26236963272094727,
0.5111421942710876,
0.5443177819252014,
-0.19655507802963257,
-0.5270453095436096,
-0.7165185809135437,
-0.4460482597351074,
-0.5073005557060242,
0.12510626018047333,
-0.4515214264392853,
-1.2352961301803589,
0.439065158367157,
-0.3097095787525177,
-0.09661523252725601,
0.3546183705329895,
0.5960670709609985,
-0.2382354736328125,
1.3498060703277588,
0.259890079498291,
0.025239121168851852,
0.2670927941799164,
-0.0829305350780487,
-0.008750700391829014,
-0.597249448299408,
-0.0814327746629715,
-0.2561444342136383,
-0.14625632762908936,
-0.581769585609436,
-0.5067641139030457,
0.21949616074562073,
0.38569220900535583,
-0.34352168440818787,
0.21591655910015106,
-0.5483813285827637,
0.7138724327087402,
0.6711327433586121,
0.12452708929777145,
0.44822031259536743,
-0.288838654756546,
-0.26466262340545654,
0.04261702671647072,
-0.8084896802902222,
-0.380129873752594,
1.0075939893722534,
0.19136092066764832,
1.1298089027404785,
0.06956373155117035,
0.7688762545585632,
0.07668232172727585,
0.21035592257976532,
-0.45687830448150635,
0.6922252178192139,
0.1427900195121765,
-0.8684890866279602,
-0.43599700927734375,
-0.7448166012763977,
-0.9641544818878174,
0.49885520339012146,
-0.2764860689640045,
-0.8840185403823853,
-0.028281206265091896,
0.3652576506137848,
-0.2564459443092346,
0.048376426100730896,
-0.8677851557731628,
1.000348448753357,
-0.427200049161911,
-0.7299903631210327,
-0.08870723843574524,
-0.5833457112312317,
0.6097381114959717,
-0.011455328203737736,
0.06991631537675858,
-0.2804955840110779,
0.16664227843284607,
0.40868279337882996,
-0.259835422039032,
0.9175714254379272,
-0.051344677805900574,
0.014211340807378292,
0.3360467255115509,
0.2283787578344345,
0.542447566986084,
0.370670348405838,
0.10561750084161758,
-0.15240365266799927,
0.004928329959511757,
-0.577267587184906,
-0.744153618812561,
0.7347072958946228,
-0.4899296760559082,
-0.96685391664505,
-0.24981427192687988,
-0.7122724652290344,
-0.586242139339447,
0.2806665599346161,
-0.10709744691848755,
0.03979070857167244,
0.20769666135311127,
0.3750387132167816,
0.9131304025650024,
0.025132907554507256,
0.23406526446342468,
0.5380253195762634,
-0.19800834357738495,
-0.022522827610373497,
0.5861160159111023,
0.003895652014762163,
0.2204742282629013,
0.0907721072435379,
0.2533681094646454,
-0.35762572288513184,
-0.46222206950187683,
-0.37444233894348145,
0.33705636858940125,
-0.7714863419532776,
-0.2777046263217926,
-0.6068423986434937,
-0.014656885527074337,
-0.1880081444978714,
0.09022090584039688,
-0.5512061715126038,
-0.4759279489517212,
-0.08515369892120361,
-0.22858259081840515,
0.30990758538246155,
0.4770379066467285,
-0.11951632052659988,
0.12019909173250198,
-0.2831829786300659,
0.4359344244003296,
0.4477207362651825,
0.4165083169937134,
-0.11956708878278732,
-0.3980311453342438,
-0.25420960783958435,
-0.07674272358417511,
-0.0647120475769043,
-0.7008332014083862,
-0.0016062066424638033,
-0.08657083660364151,
0.7043762803077698,
0.2912095785140991,
0.45734772086143494,
0.6712622046470642,
-0.2913288176059723,
0.3627048432826996,
-0.09713809937238693,
-0.793874204158783,
0.7580506205558777,
-0.5177997946739197,
0.5561770796775818,
0.7966156601905823,
0.22570309042930603,
0.035148538649082184,
-0.7930472493171692,
-0.7011305689811707,
-0.8007992506027222,
0.7362104654312134,
0.2958853840827942,
0.03843321278691292,
-0.16139979660511017,
0.4688105881214142,
-0.32345685362815857,
0.06828216463327408,
-0.7100678086280823,
-0.13194525241851807,
-0.02059151418507099,
-0.12898218631744385,
0.003955427557229996,
-0.19048476219177246,
-0.23113451898097992,
-0.4617381989955902,
0.7102936506271362,
-0.3803563714027405,
-0.08989822864532471,
0.0836246907711029,
-0.21303397417068481,
-0.20708990097045898,
0.33449211716651917,
0.26136496663093567,
0.44766706228256226,
-0.29601138830184937,
0.44436293840408325,
0.47729361057281494,
0.23832662403583527,
0.006318556610494852,
0.1976800411939621,
-0.21976155042648315,
-0.25599056482315063,
0.4100271761417389,
0.6919902563095093,
0.40841004252433777,
-0.8871034979820251,
0.3472927510738373,
-0.12493909895420074,
-0.2843461334705353,
-0.18193110823631287,
0.45457741618156433,
0.37375834584236145,
0.5883930325508118,
0.08228547126054764,
-0.2067534625530243,
0.05223359540104866,
-0.2669510841369629,
0.2282267063856125,
0.2908826470375061,
-0.3014087677001953,
-0.06552612781524658,
0.864112913608551,
-0.04139632359147072,
0.051033273339271545,
0.574505090713501,
-0.3940344452857971,
-0.3695904612541199,
0.3922535479068756,
0.5012291073799133,
0.40904614329338074,
-0.0016849995590746403,
0.025670038536190987,
0.4058835208415985,
0.5641602873802185,
-0.39231494069099426,
0.21839836239814758,
-0.2500368356704712,
-0.614234209060669,
-0.5532537698745728,
-0.4474600553512573,
-0.40844884514808655,
0.12099077552556992,
-0.5992512702941895,
0.07406066358089447,
-0.550015926361084,
-0.1144319400191307,
-0.01889570616185665,
0.06892082095146179,
-0.5252962708473206,
0.2128501683473587,
0.04451782628893852,
0.6892797946929932,
-0.8324141502380371,
0.8902423977851868,
0.6375545263290405,
-0.6375728845596313,
-0.8749950528144836,
-0.12974578142166138,
-0.059418343007564545,
-0.5598077178001404,
0.5324311256408691,
0.0934624969959259,
-0.15272091329097748,
-0.030703125521540642,
-0.7457104921340942,
-0.7787920236587524,
0.7439079284667969,
0.5748857259750366,
-0.46284642815589905,
0.1394675225019455,
-0.0002279226464452222,
0.7624324560165405,
-0.1173507571220398,
0.2056768834590912,
0.6861666440963745,
0.5100945234298706,
0.15525685250759125,
-0.7307980060577393,
0.19692838191986084,
-0.29172343015670776,
-0.1638370305299759,
0.10702104866504669,
-0.5501335859298706,
0.6460126042366028,
-0.2934283912181854,
0.008635101839900017,
-0.07374510914087296,
0.7581861019134521,
0.2735682725906372,
0.09785035997629166,
0.6331581473350525,
0.7032451629638672,
0.8188635110855103,
-0.10515204071998596,
0.9928162097930908,
-0.12921911478042603,
0.42571017146110535,
1.5594993829727173,
0.020154716446995735,
0.6174653172492981,
0.5597385168075562,
0.05419537052512169,
0.4230756461620331,
0.6418402194976807,
-0.21749670803546906,
0.3331174850463867,
0.5245358943939209,
0.11981426924467087,
-0.9920362234115601,
-0.2892151474952698,
-0.02324995957314968,
0.39248913526535034,
0.3325957953929901,
-0.14141790568828583,
-0.3950980007648468,
-0.2734966278076172,
0.07490365207195282,
0.3734161853790283,
-0.22700361907482147,
0.7291362285614014,
0.20432351529598236,
-0.7705969214439392,
0.7074432969093323,
0.03475285694003105,
0.4517313241958618,
-0.5514104962348938,
0.17707936465740204,
-0.47286131978034973,
0.39523252844810486,
-0.17821630835533142,
-0.7115704417228699,
0.1133696585893631,
0.10103671997785568,
-0.032571546733379364,
-0.2796589732170105,
0.7757110595703125,
-0.5167073011398315,
-0.5141796469688416,
0.3858221769332886,
0.6908633708953857,
0.10660070180892944,
-0.11577916890382767,
-0.7895539402961731,
-0.11541911959648132,
-0.20215877890586853,
-0.5167436599731445,
0.4541534185409546,
0.7389388680458069,
-0.27963146567344666,
0.9128750562667847,
0.5238794088363647,
-0.04661686345934868,
-0.03894925117492676,
0.23915275931358337,
1.0682789087295532,
-0.6393528580665588,
-0.22401048243045807,
-0.7665653228759766,
0.3737766444683075,
-0.23244397342205048,
-0.2244875282049179,
0.955691397190094,
0.5022232532501221,
0.871454656124115,
0.151238352060318,
0.5398460626602173,
0.20187470316886902,
0.45933622121810913,
-0.4684641361236572,
0.2825794219970703,
-0.7407873272895813,
0.33669552206993103,
-0.26142242550849915,
-0.6892087459564209,
-0.3739317059516907,
0.7785429358482361,
-0.49196383357048035,
-0.05968034267425537,
0.5426406264305115,
0.8655027747154236,
-0.2112434208393097,
-0.061783067882061005,
0.19049684703350067,
0.24100127816200256,
0.1893860101699829,
0.780880868434906,
0.9366028308868408,
-0.07655483484268188,
0.7196981906890869,
-0.3910118043422699,
0.03280166909098625,
-0.14315804839134216,
-0.7837629318237305,
-1.4681575298309326,
-0.1777522712945938,
-0.3646579384803772,
-0.3430028557777405,
0.08990275859832764,
0.9688919186592102,
0.6682211756706238,
-0.7604274153709412,
-0.1089896708726883,
-0.2525542676448822,
0.29761213064193726,
-0.16832029819488525,
-0.1963859349489212,
0.3383713960647583,
-0.6758987307548523,
-0.5751823782920837,
0.5814610719680786,
0.18752261996269226,
-0.11184051632881165,
-0.3124893307685852,
0.0014829118736088276,
-0.35198020935058594,
0.1297648549079895,
0.25975456833839417,
0.3317405879497528,
-0.7436953783035278,
-0.3038303554058075,
-0.11980321258306503,
-0.14285221695899963,
-0.19439320266246796,
0.4741249680519104,
-0.6330485939979553,
0.509107232093811,
0.1839965283870697,
0.8184533715248108,
0.8805603981018066,
0.23309840261936188,
0.3383926451206207,
-0.8352648615837097,
0.10307151824235916,
0.3532412648200989,
0.3048502206802368,
0.274705708026886,
-0.26702681183815,
0.8622158765792847,
0.14045387506484985,
-0.51048743724823,
-0.8312907814979553,
0.22582022845745087,
-0.8372305035591125,
-0.4339739978313446,
1.2467025518417358,
-0.14724992215633392,
-0.21425406634807587,
-0.0995444729924202,
-0.1575120985507965,
0.047993794083595276,
-0.2992967367172241,
0.8601105213165283,
0.7237706780433655,
-0.4501609206199646,
-0.4708307087421417,
-0.6799842715263367,
0.5339719653129578,
0.8571584820747375,
-0.8870745301246643,
0.19205006957054138,
0.596066951751709,
0.16169685125350952,
-0.12332949042320251,
0.6430476307868958,
0.15275999903678894,
0.14207741618156433,
-0.06887335330247879,
-0.08218854665756226,
-0.23873212933540344,
-0.32251399755477905,
-0.07200945913791656,
0.204085111618042,
0.17028802633285522,
0.1811857968568802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04065v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04065v3
|
FlashBack:Efficient Retrieval-Augmented Language Modeling for Long Context Inference
| 2024-05-07T07:14:38 | 2024-05-16T12:04:30 |
Runheng Liu, Xingchen Xiao, Heyan Huang, Zewen Chi, Zhijing Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-Augmented Language Modeling (RALM) by integrating large language
models (LLM) with relevant documents from an external corpus is a proven method
for enabling the LLM to generate information beyond the scope of its
pre-training corpus. Previous work utilizing retrieved content by simply
prepending it to the input poses a high runtime issue, which degrades the
inference efficiency of the LLMs because they fail to use the Key-Value (KV)
cache efficiently. In this paper, we propose FlashBack, a modular RALM designed
to improve the inference efficiency of RALM with appending context pattern
while maintaining decent performance after fine-tuning by Low-Rank Adaption.
FlashBack appends retrieved documents at the end of the context for efficiently
utilizing the KV cache instead of prepending them. And we introduce Marking
Token as two special prompt tokens for marking the boundary of the appending
context during fine-tuning. Our experiments on testing generation quality show
that FlashBack can remain decent generation quality in perplexity. And the
inference speed of FlashBack is up to $4\times$ faster than the prepending
counterpart on a 7B LLM (Llama 2) in the runtime test. Via bypassing
unnecessary re-computation, it demonstrates an advancement by achieving
significantly faster inference speed, and this heightened efficiency will
substantially reduce inferential cost.
|
[
-0.21843089163303375,
-0.826614260673523,
0.3922179639339447,
0.15763334929943085,
-0.4219467043876648,
0.08625626564025879,
-0.15580575168132782,
-0.24720357358455658,
0.09309305250644684,
0.7233010530471802,
-0.4856467843055725,
-0.4228081703186035,
-0.1502414047718048,
-0.03737378865480423,
-0.5267293453216553,
0.7314276099205017,
0.3466588854789734,
-0.455740362405777,
-0.16994419693946838,
-0.18481650948524475,
-0.6421181559562683,
-0.6134769320487976,
-0.4060533344745636,
-0.2677047848701477,
0.45634132623672485,
0.5402474999427795,
0.4646552801132202,
0.7163164615631104,
0.012774362228810787,
0.20362219214439392,
-0.04275256395339966,
0.27120769023895264,
-0.6674108505249023,
0.6505354046821594,
-0.3699035048484802,
-0.29026126861572266,
-0.6046301126480103,
-0.48815324902534485,
0.8031415939331055,
0.4494072198867798,
0.05699830874800682,
0.2632676064968109,
-0.11101128906011581,
0.6051167845726013,
-0.9167715907096863,
-0.13173753023147583,
-0.7977369427680969,
-0.34318283200263977,
-0.26045238971710205,
-0.4277254343032837,
-0.8939398527145386,
-0.19320999085903168,
-0.2843795120716095,
-0.41305264830589294,
0.2940619885921478,
0.2827128767967224,
0.6566655039787292,
0.13919299840927124,
-0.27549371123313904,
0.04890607297420502,
-0.708061158657074,
0.7280908226966858,
-0.781404972076416,
0.340896338224411,
0.23189033567905426,
0.2901575565338135,
-0.38352739810943604,
-1.0789614915847778,
-0.7011545300483704,
-0.01915368251502514,
-0.09871812909841537,
-0.0507386215031147,
0.05260163173079491,
-0.10199567675590515,
0.2622321844100952,
0.31418782472610474,
-0.37313827872276306,
0.03819967061281204,
-0.08093388378620148,
-0.24885545670986176,
0.33521872758865356,
0.4701572358608246,
0.0710185244679451,
-0.1236903965473175,
-0.3056377172470093,
-0.30099618434906006,
-1.120059609413147,
0.014726239256560802,
0.1709163933992386,
0.6045823097229004,
0.2709924578666687,
0.37476372718811035,
-0.27290698885917664,
0.8489787578582764,
0.0941813588142395,
-0.1376332938671112,
0.283692330121994,
-0.5137199759483337,
-0.14252550899982452,
0.01370498538017273,
0.2584197223186493,
0.08609291166067123,
-0.03285612910985947,
0.01280288491398096,
-0.32596901059150696,
-0.11413715779781342,
0.2577506899833679,
-0.9541796445846558,
-0.08154294639825821,
-0.0021171553526073694,
-0.32517555356025696,
0.12554118037223816,
-0.0749070942401886,
-0.6855586767196655,
-0.17565101385116577,
-0.10782764852046967,
0.39309626817703247,
-0.666621744632721,
-0.11531611531972885,
0.04744398593902588,
0.11814283579587936,
0.30142953991889954,
0.42292308807373047,
-0.8378608822822571,
0.11525775492191315,
0.835656464099884,
0.5591426491737366,
-0.26265090703964233,
-0.18883612751960754,
-1.0040383338928223,
0.23225896060466766,
-0.2335483729839325,
0.9117285013198853,
-0.8177744150161743,
-0.5852734446525574,
0.08959802985191345,
0.038365524262189865,
-0.06461527198553085,
-0.5099355578422546,
0.43260496854782104,
-0.8124290704727173,
0.023330165073275566,
-0.1480274200439453,
-0.5690338611602783,
-0.029375895857810974,
0.24741098284721375,
-0.49246954917907715,
1.4049155712127686,
0.22177548706531525,
-0.5842187404632568,
0.25503888726234436,
-0.2518186867237091,
-0.7696577906608582,
0.05444774776697159,
-0.07918424159288406,
-0.35456717014312744,
0.10249897837638855,
0.42796605825424194,
0.3276471197605133,
-0.12054385989904404,
0.3596573770046234,
-0.17345160245895386,
-0.8096588850021362,
-0.14126864075660706,
-0.2435164600610733,
0.4949125647544861,
0.18456925451755524,
-0.243454247713089,
0.2698329985141754,
-0.8019652962684631,
-0.039810750633478165,
-0.11886784434318542,
-0.4631121754646301,
-0.6418478488922119,
-0.021230870857834816,
-0.1345401257276535,
0.11910069733858109,
0.015123116783797741,
-0.34634092450141907,
0.4104432165622711,
-0.3852681517601013,
0.10717237740755081,
0.6347720623016357,
0.17757548391819,
0.4262468218803406,
-0.23779655992984772,
0.47723886370658875,
-0.04343116655945778,
-0.08017663657665253,
-0.8656563758850098,
-0.34051620960235596,
-0.832496702671051,
-0.5373712778091431,
0.17218662798404694,
0.4263264536857605,
-0.6580042243003845,
0.405211478471756,
-0.6981933116912842,
-0.04180152341723442,
-0.4184582531452179,
-0.052474137395620346,
0.5303691029548645,
0.8968629240989685,
0.3747536242008209,
-0.16051959991455078,
-0.7178381681442261,
-0.7390620112419128,
-0.37314170598983765,
-0.0843372717499733,
0.0074617210775613785,
0.4409477710723877,
0.4002276360988617,
-0.2088215947151184,
1.1328613758087158,
-0.3911515474319458,
0.12263314425945282,
-0.31246551871299744,
0.052634481340646744,
0.3724904954433441,
0.38134491443634033,
0.34277328848838806,
-0.4013984203338623,
-0.310881644487381,
-0.2654695212841034,
-0.44032567739486694,
-0.19510520994663239,
0.004121310543268919,
-0.18908873200416565,
0.2817607820034027,
0.6154006123542786,
-0.30527833104133606,
0.34499821066856384,
0.2517794370651245,
-0.47059690952301025,
0.5996828675270081,
-0.26871752738952637,
0.3622960150241852,
-1.0395500659942627,
0.2940264344215393,
-0.7798040509223938,
-0.37020689249038696,
-0.6022772789001465,
0.03592415526509285,
0.4729735255241394,
-0.14133550226688385,
-0.45005011558532715,
1.0522234439849854,
-0.551198422908783,
-0.28633254766464233,
-0.32327067852020264,
0.12771070003509521,
0.14644275605678558,
0.34328916668891907,
-0.03075355477631092,
1.0185267925262451,
0.20461799204349518,
-0.5790823101997375,
-0.08456727862358093,
0.18272949755191803,
-0.46466493606567383,
0.3291347622871399,
-0.14241452515125275,
0.45967283844947815,
-0.14018599689006805,
0.5180124044418335,
-1.046411395072937,
-0.03934897854924202,
-0.22113312780857086,
-0.19200706481933594,
0.5554530620574951,
-0.11278878152370453,
-0.48711439967155457,
-0.10782520473003387,
-0.36578646302223206,
0.643718957901001,
0.7138938903808594,
-0.7591731548309326,
0.6660040616989136,
0.004506652243435383,
-0.026402734220027924,
-0.85162353515625,
-0.5343590974807739,
0.23052464425563812,
-0.341000497341156,
-0.6226537823677063,
0.40191584825515747,
0.17868772149085999,
-0.1443154215812683,
-0.17890410125255585,
-0.08997135609388351,
0.16147686541080475,
0.010806722566485405,
0.18350565433502197,
0.1304795891046524,
-0.48185452818870544,
0.2867564558982849,
0.21126632392406464,
-0.2598962187767029,
-0.4091300666332245,
-0.14052674174308777,
0.5114443302154541,
-0.033432815223932266,
-0.3261737525463104,
-0.054181717336177826,
0.37141504883766174,
0.5028289556503296,
-0.06586465984582901,
0.7116187214851379,
0.2144250124692917,
-0.26680988073349,
-0.34535348415374756,
-0.8908758759498596,
-0.502231776714325,
-0.45948460698127747,
0.33268624544143677,
-0.4465738534927368,
-0.9879844188690186,
0.6482150554656982,
-0.07584450393915176,
0.05370418354868889,
0.2941201329231262,
0.46987637877464294,
0.1887131631374359,
0.47451135516166687,
0.36388713121414185,
-0.12142031639814377,
0.587156355381012,
-0.016675172373652458,
0.14528465270996094,
-1.0483417510986328,
-0.14461708068847656,
-0.45803511142730713,
-0.055971596390008926,
-0.030007509514689445,
-0.5393417477607727,
0.18874748051166534,
0.2565818130970001,
-0.3527141809463501,
0.287580668926239,
-0.14054524898529053,
0.29369956254959106,
0.4391928017139435,
0.11453811824321747,
0.6813086271286011,
-0.13648530840873718,
-0.03338790312409401,
0.04012862592935562,
-0.6877147555351257,
-0.35692137479782104,
0.9591428637504578,
-0.02740337699651718,
0.8349752426147461,
0.024031013250350952,
0.6062871217727661,
0.23930664360523224,
0.5578325390815735,
-0.3529037535190582,
0.6460179090499878,
-0.06707113981246948,
-0.586524486541748,
-0.14266729354858398,
-0.011607123538851738,
-0.8585945963859558,
0.40549740195274353,
-0.10993427783250809,
-0.680288553237915,
0.22157613933086395,
0.523844301700592,
-0.57494056224823,
0.1478433609008789,
-0.4913344085216522,
0.5698010921478271,
0.20571260154247284,
-0.5706979036331177,
-0.34609729051589966,
-0.6975712180137634,
0.6282468438148499,
-0.10135843604803085,
0.20743882656097412,
-0.03270436078310013,
-0.06236867234110832,
0.5001969933509827,
-0.5095767378807068,
0.7046362161636353,
-0.09080196917057037,
0.07059339433908463,
0.36250409483909607,
0.168920636177063,
0.876288890838623,
0.0715249627828598,
-0.30383580923080444,
-0.1835837960243225,
-0.23468326032161713,
-0.22911213338375092,
-0.7761967182159424,
0.8973501324653625,
-0.09113539010286331,
-0.7231410145759583,
-0.17175501585006714,
-0.6092926263809204,
-0.23071594536304474,
0.1910480558872223,
0.14936676621437073,
0.6582764983177185,
-0.03668917715549469,
0.3670217990875244,
0.6992275714874268,
-0.41941210627555847,
0.4821736216545105,
0.6732494831085205,
-0.20119920372962952,
-0.16432498395442963,
0.6567209959030151,
-0.21134236454963684,
0.3591265082359314,
0.6235438585281372,
0.10322171449661255,
-0.2943442165851593,
-0.5865111351013184,
-0.33054494857788086,
0.16349674761295319,
-0.789374828338623,
-0.306299090385437,
-0.7117701768875122,
-0.007951576262712479,
-0.48298919200897217,
-0.21914510428905487,
-0.4598808288574219,
-0.48185622692108154,
-0.1273271143436432,
0.014009327627718449,
0.5296234488487244,
0.18032829463481903,
0.1461545079946518,
0.26423579454421997,
-0.7307844161987305,
0.2467881292104721,
0.09401445090770721,
0.07461840659379959,
0.14456959068775177,
-0.8582240343093872,
-0.18014033138751984,
-0.29488226771354675,
0.00046944452333264053,
-0.5396537184715271,
0.17629803717136383,
0.3692866563796997,
0.3185160756111145,
0.23862780630588531,
0.2615400552749634,
1.00653874874115,
-0.6264114379882812,
0.7725076675415039,
-0.33472007513046265,
-0.7591258883476257,
0.44722795486450195,
-0.37692317366600037,
0.5317133069038391,
0.6411877274513245,
-0.31044822931289673,
-0.36524897813796997,
-0.32627516984939575,
-0.3348909914493561,
-1.190535306930542,
0.49000436067581177,
-0.016271620988845825,
0.23101964592933655,
-0.4862787127494812,
0.6810983419418335,
0.26399722695350647,
-0.07469815015792847,
-0.2157963216304779,
-0.2629046142101288,
-0.056254997849464417,
0.02986845001578331,
-0.07961208373308182,
-0.5567606091499329,
0.20976801216602325,
-0.34032759070396423,
0.5692600011825562,
-0.07613468170166016,
0.13898663222789764,
0.24897977709770203,
-0.4573812484741211,
0.17053088545799255,
0.3088265359401703,
0.7707579135894775,
0.796025812625885,
-0.3133354187011719,
0.32516518235206604,
0.432782918214798,
-0.4386592507362366,
0.11727841198444366,
-0.23366811871528625,
-0.05922093987464905,
0.04746710881590843,
0.6338885426521301,
0.6962246894836426,
0.7468351125717163,
-0.8063027858734131,
0.34283578395843506,
0.07592148333787918,
0.13313999772071838,
-0.16324421763420105,
0.17942392826080322,
0.10331655293703079,
0.25772708654403687,
0.5963356494903564,
-0.2955060601234436,
-0.016856353729963303,
-0.6157246232032776,
0.45803409814834595,
0.34635448455810547,
0.032231882214546204,
-0.26889270544052124,
0.5825580954551697,
0.1336737722158432,
-0.3779884874820709,
0.979930579662323,
0.20921239256858826,
-0.28809747099876404,
0.25840410590171814,
0.8773289322853088,
0.7110772728919983,
-0.4455656111240387,
-0.403838187456131,
0.5045226216316223,
0.016341134905815125,
-0.17767827212810516,
0.14978598058223724,
-0.23830239474773407,
-0.5581314563751221,
-0.6101627349853516,
-0.6134352087974548,
-0.12892641127109528,
0.02513495460152626,
-0.7008259892463684,
0.13102641701698303,
-0.21397356688976288,
0.06562010943889618,
-0.5429834723472595,
-0.32534119486808777,
-0.5349327921867371,
0.10231660306453705,
-0.2695605456829071,
1.2481858730316162,
-0.6625293493270874,
1.2333470582962036,
0.1475612372159958,
-0.03601905331015587,
-0.42557036876678467,
-0.12279439717531204,
-0.1993291974067688,
-0.9304712414741516,
0.7607911229133606,
0.1817973405122757,
-0.35529956221580505,
0.22135773301124573,
-0.16727639734745026,
-0.8308368921279907,
1.147359013557434,
0.45587751269340515,
-0.5227013230323792,
-0.03837526962161064,
-0.32668036222457886,
0.39695385098457336,
-0.4943001866340637,
0.2301797717809677,
0.7653864026069641,
0.41238826513290405,
0.2712837755680084,
-0.5393152832984924,
0.44182005524635315,
-0.18060706555843353,
0.056098323315382004,
0.37467584013938904,
-0.19280461966991425,
0.7305048108100891,
-0.34508609771728516,
-0.4030601382255554,
0.36088427901268005,
0.840250551700592,
0.3930526673793793,
0.18620888888835907,
0.4072437882423401,
0.5142582654953003,
0.5957819819450378,
-0.01112861093133688,
1.2971962690353394,
-0.27521950006484985,
0.2029222995042801,
1.4828509092330933,
-0.30904459953308105,
1.0589076280593872,
0.582298755645752,
0.11553005874156952,
0.6386823058128357,
0.3584512174129486,
0.4491170644760132,
0.7638856172561646,
0.06393054872751236,
-0.4460558295249939,
-0.24955511093139648,
0.236845001578331,
-0.5160014629364014,
0.1387786567211151,
0.31995272636413574,
-0.33215266466140747,
-0.2511065602302551,
-0.00646501500159502,
0.034255292266607285,
0.08778562396764755,
-0.11056608706712723,
0.638655424118042,
0.020617835223674774,
-0.9449617266654968,
0.6680353283882141,
-0.15970849990844727,
0.5267199277877808,
-0.6378239393234253,
-0.09259781986474991,
-0.6832509636878967,
0.40721502900123596,
-0.007012607529759407,
-0.424326092004776,
0.48489946126937866,
-0.2242213934659958,
-0.21230348944664001,
-0.3261009156703949,
0.6723024845123291,
-0.4215303957462311,
-0.15562458336353302,
0.10227935761213303,
0.1770567148923874,
0.10673819482326508,
-0.04767193645238876,
-0.22394220530986786,
0.24717126786708832,
-0.27664074301719666,
-0.5834018588066101,
0.5120809078216553,
0.2565223276615143,
-0.3304254710674286,
0.6421775817871094,
0.6103288531303406,
-0.2584591507911682,
0.14410044252872467,
0.14194388687610626,
0.9683535695075989,
-0.9398266077041626,
-0.4956446588039398,
-1.0067870616912842,
0.7248177528381348,
0.013002641499042511,
-0.24215348064899445,
0.7429248690605164,
0.7137466073036194,
0.3992260694503784,
-0.08647356182336807,
0.5005033016204834,
0.13873738050460815,
0.4671834707260132,
-0.6913443803787231,
0.5308118462562561,
-0.334453284740448,
0.40668919682502747,
-0.2263822853565216,
-0.9426377415657043,
-0.4197946786880493,
0.3289251923561096,
-0.04721632972359657,
0.022931991145014763,
0.7673755884170532,
0.8476926684379578,
-0.16330887377262115,
-0.18119512498378754,
0.30012843012809753,
0.28134018182754517,
0.43309468030929565,
0.5435594916343689,
0.6072112917900085,
-0.40771815180778503,
0.3454523980617523,
0.004306679591536522,
-0.15913723409175873,
-0.5433827042579651,
-1.2529274225234985,
-0.8012298941612244,
-0.5532700419425964,
0.0352097749710083,
-0.46464255452156067,
0.29906728863716125,
0.5193141102790833,
0.6793898344039917,
-0.6883177757263184,
0.00998243223875761,
0.123663529753685,
0.12081865221261978,
-0.15660445392131805,
-0.2491668164730072,
0.5483018755912781,
-0.3006186783313751,
-0.5213981866836548,
0.8143172860145569,
0.46386006474494934,
-0.3335852324962616,
-0.028507782146334648,
-0.10731586813926697,
-0.26009511947631836,
-0.019224490970373154,
0.7382992506027222,
0.45223912596702576,
-0.7745920419692993,
-0.6895068287849426,
0.03709392622113228,
0.16129638254642487,
0.16919732093811035,
1.1620413064956665,
-1.1610443592071533,
0.6404133439064026,
0.5691673755645752,
0.7862988114356995,
0.8745843172073364,
0.3652297854423523,
0.7638795375823975,
-0.8543258309364319,
0.39763975143432617,
0.27417299151420593,
0.3748268485069275,
0.3433414399623871,
-0.2992118000984192,
0.30714544653892517,
0.06716207414865494,
-0.35741910338401794,
-1.0882939100265503,
0.2455146163702011,
-0.7201271057128906,
-0.2871992886066437,
1.0888569355010986,
-0.2066165804862976,
-0.11096085608005524,
-0.1910877376794815,
-0.08059901744127274,
0.19093216955661774,
-0.34373795986175537,
0.7111756801605225,
0.4213285744190216,
-0.16364093124866486,
-0.17998510599136353,
-0.3677752912044525,
0.4033987820148468,
0.37356775999069214,
-0.5961383581161499,
0.25563251972198486,
0.4654289782047272,
0.335432767868042,
-0.13401855528354645,
0.7864185571670532,
-0.13224291801452637,
0.18716490268707275,
-0.02189011499285698,
-0.17527715861797333,
-0.39565396308898926,
-0.3614836633205414,
-0.3467090427875519,
0.15728767216205597,
-0.06127180904150009,
-0.09775552153587341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04053v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04053v1
|
Evaluating Text Summaries Generated by Large Language Models Using OpenAI's GPT
| 2024-05-07T06:52:34 | 2024-05-07T06:52:34 |
Hassan Shakil, Atqiya Munawara Mahi, Phuoc Nguyen, Zeydy Ortiz, Mamoun T. Mardini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This research examines the effectiveness of OpenAI's GPT models as
independent evaluators of text summaries generated by six transformer-based
models from Hugging Face: DistilBART, BERT, ProphetNet, T5, BART, and PEGASUS.
We evaluated these summaries based on essential properties of high-quality
summary - conciseness, relevance, coherence, and readability - using
traditional metrics such as ROUGE and Latent Semantic Analysis (LSA). Uniquely,
we also employed GPT not as a summarizer but as an evaluator, allowing it to
independently assess summary quality without predefined metrics. Our analysis
revealed significant correlations between GPT evaluations and traditional
metrics, particularly in assessing relevance and coherence. The results
demonstrate GPT's potential as a robust tool for evaluating text summaries,
offering insights that complement established metrics and providing a basis for
comparative analysis of transformer-based models in natural language processing
tasks.
|
[
-0.38992589712142944,
-0.6631342768669128,
0.4989251494407654,
0.2390567660331726,
-0.3213397264480591,
-0.2208987921476364,
-0.22628018260002136,
-0.46038568019866943,
0.35846593976020813,
0.23519258201122284,
-0.1359071433544159,
-0.27611157298088074,
-0.8018457889556885,
0.22399954497814178,
-0.7095533013343811,
1.587970495223999,
-0.16069267690181732,
-0.47759202122688293,
-0.00702341552823782,
-0.17585811018943787,
-0.16739879548549652,
-0.38579225540161133,
-0.3750784993171692,
-0.49253708124160767,
0.39534276723861694,
-0.32516348361968994,
1.1951040029525757,
0.2071235626935959,
0.9174332618713379,
0.3103651702404022,
-0.38798072934150696,
-0.22469229996204376,
-0.45714184641838074,
-0.0471302755177021,
-0.18415290117263794,
-0.04796665534377098,
-0.7958576679229736,
0.16453738510608673,
0.772459089756012,
0.4870103597640991,
0.10789032280445099,
0.18108461797237396,
0.34413251280784607,
0.6595895290374756,
-0.4418686330318451,
0.3311798870563507,
-0.31307509541511536,
-0.09484334290027618,
0.015766067430377007,
0.2571360170841217,
-0.29865071177482605,
-0.5868584513664246,
0.5496943593025208,
-0.27864325046539307,
0.38606834411621094,
-0.4870581328868866,
1.1066011190414429,
0.20080791413784027,
-0.3250710666179657,
-0.36322274804115295,
-0.5608257055282593,
0.5274863839149475,
-0.7458432912826538,
0.23032359778881073,
0.22069790959358215,
0.45715397596359253,
0.2076253890991211,
-0.8098750114440918,
-0.7028255462646484,
-0.2614642083644867,
-0.4656074345111847,
0.6273453831672668,
-0.4189561605453491,
-0.06201890856027603,
-0.083774134516716,
0.9524582028388977,
-0.7036855220794678,
-0.1541200429201126,
-0.1976172775030136,
-0.15611450374126434,
0.540237545967102,
0.012632478959858418,
0.5101069808006287,
-0.35061290860176086,
-0.208670973777771,
-0.14972898364067078,
-0.29812562465667725,
0.006788118742406368,
0.3323359191417694,
0.09766950458288193,
-0.42152801156044006,
0.6895290017127991,
-0.22736476361751556,
0.46074235439300537,
-0.23595574498176575,
-0.3357253968715668,
0.04093579947948456,
-0.6207789182662964,
-0.4333181381225586,
-0.3831011950969696,
1.291788101196289,
0.4047102928161621,
0.3339003622531891,
-0.4367314279079437,
-0.3680132031440735,
0.03621383756399155,
0.08191602677106857,
-1.034052848815918,
-0.3310370147228241,
0.10264365375041962,
-0.7813257575035095,
-0.36687105894088745,
0.31301945447921753,
-0.7080089449882507,
-0.06930197030305862,
-0.26316097378730774,
0.4759219288825989,
-0.2886689007282257,
-0.6290524005889893,
-0.15615591406822205,
-0.40081366896629333,
0.22342424094676971,
0.38306498527526855,
-0.8898860216140747,
0.36737504601478577,
0.8003886342048645,
1.2130986452102661,
-0.33222755789756775,
-0.25770971179008484,
-0.3261696994304657,
-0.1319020688533783,
-0.024353375658392906,
0.7825866937637329,
-0.4459417462348938,
-0.32038864493370056,
-0.23059524595737457,
-0.12974368035793304,
-0.20563459396362305,
-0.3737163245677948,
0.6351070404052734,
-0.4030457139015198,
0.3894871771335602,
-0.21854865550994873,
-0.29447758197784424,
-0.300400972366333,
0.19879336655139923,
-0.9988071918487549,
0.8773436546325684,
0.3982100784778595,
-0.917107343673706,
0.4229287803173065,
-0.7439669370651245,
-0.5011101365089417,
0.02576838992536068,
-0.07661563158035278,
-0.5217354893684387,
0.3499301075935364,
0.5005208253860474,
0.6094653606414795,
-0.36986562609672546,
0.40636762976646423,
0.12549908459186554,
-0.20045197010040283,
0.09813601523637772,
-0.5898522138595581,
0.6038669943809509,
-0.026025347411632538,
-0.22756367921829224,
0.3883724510669708,
-0.41979914903640747,
-0.3020663559436798,
0.1897766888141632,
-0.07504032552242279,
-0.3778718411922455,
-0.23481734097003937,
0.3092679977416992,
0.056939497590065,
0.07337385416030884,
-0.323067843914032,
0.17673282325267792,
-0.327630877494812,
0.3937014639377594,
0.39412379264831543,
0.046609848737716675,
0.11071756482124329,
-0.3597533106803894,
0.46427661180496216,
-0.1901019662618637,
-0.013641591183841228,
-0.6194563508033752,
-0.657798707485199,
-0.4046669900417328,
-0.45892658829689026,
0.2911646068096161,
0.36392754316329956,
-0.853991687297821,
0.40187111496925354,
-0.45813044905662537,
-0.8768010139465332,
-0.473725825548172,
-0.25721287727355957,
0.45171019434928894,
0.4350244104862213,
0.29596883058547974,
-0.3880900740623474,
0.07210259139537811,
-0.7968512773513794,
-0.5186598896980286,
-0.3675110340118408,
-0.3055994212627411,
-0.0809328705072403,
0.8408589959144592,
-0.05756095424294472,
1.122211217880249,
-0.30543607473373413,
-0.10196194797754288,
-0.3614257872104645,
0.30251529812812805,
0.313231498003006,
0.00037209721631370485,
0.8135899305343628,
-0.8736183047294617,
-0.5505677461624146,
0.04683031141757965,
-0.8340301513671875,
-0.006366634741425514,
-0.15661202371120453,
0.15147744119167328,
-0.007906774058938026,
-0.01850925385951996,
-0.6861626505851746,
0.5695920586585999,
0.784892737865448,
-0.4390374422073364,
0.8579707741737366,
-0.1934003084897995,
0.4187502861022949,
-1.0299454927444458,
0.4305505156517029,
0.07541121542453766,
-0.3313942551612854,
-0.6477804183959961,
0.18237018585205078,
0.08706192672252655,
-0.19796985387802124,
-0.1651511937379837,
0.682880699634552,
-0.2891601622104645,
-0.038446467369794846,
-0.23906660079956055,
0.43538007140159607,
-0.043535780161619186,
0.3227401077747345,
0.06995147466659546,
0.9744194746017456,
0.07986781001091003,
-0.4237242341041565,
0.2294214516878128,
0.4263629615306854,
-0.4627482295036316,
0.4472063481807709,
-0.9937001466751099,
-0.000385297869797796,
-0.04003855213522911,
0.22933273017406464,
-1.032734751701355,
-0.35042688250541687,
0.02939816750586033,
-0.5296866297721863,
0.05036495625972748,
-0.0068597132340073586,
-0.4684869349002838,
-0.2135239988565445,
-0.38566064834594727,
0.29280197620391846,
0.5606511235237122,
-0.5057254433631897,
0.6963602900505066,
0.2750317454338074,
-0.4919619858264923,
-0.32323893904685974,
-0.5760591626167297,
0.1739044487476349,
-0.08117406815290451,
-0.5690668225288391,
0.18366402387619019,
0.12764257192611694,
-0.32344597578048706,
0.06786249577999115,
-0.09199324995279312,
0.011440674774348736,
0.042021505534648895,
-0.009236665442585945,
0.19010110199451447,
-0.23597288131713867,
-0.3266282379627228,
0.15336087346076965,
-0.26219576597213745,
-0.072501540184021,
-0.07264740020036697,
0.35888224840164185,
-0.3274455666542053,
-0.349418967962265,
-0.5753917694091797,
0.16315701603889465,
0.6622880101203918,
-0.39395609498023987,
0.6825509071350098,
0.600383460521698,
-0.24572983384132385,
0.25576984882354736,
-0.33184367418289185,
0.08134495466947556,
-0.33774471282958984,
0.32255685329437256,
-0.3928532302379608,
-0.8608899116516113,
0.7271692156791687,
0.3802729547023773,
0.13938312232494354,
1.021654486656189,
0.7288527488708496,
0.4215443730354309,
0.7049462199211121,
0.7890688180923462,
-0.4344163239002228,
0.5014514327049255,
0.009277534671127796,
0.20223331451416016,
-0.674697756767273,
0.11519875377416611,
-0.5464222431182861,
-0.0714685469865799,
-0.7251676917076111,
-0.15951552987098694,
0.5788264274597168,
0.03948763385415077,
-0.010575585067272186,
0.446613609790802,
-0.5085310935974121,
0.604995608329773,
0.31042003631591797,
-0.09827808290719986,
0.6935839056968689,
-0.09033244103193283,
0.11627363413572311,
0.18228264153003693,
-0.1479925513267517,
-0.7578745484352112,
0.833700954914093,
0.6625512838363647,
0.6387660503387451,
0.34757524728775024,
0.39297452569007874,
0.19523966312408447,
0.7433909177780151,
-0.7582007050514221,
0.29882490634918213,
-0.29685312509536743,
-0.29041850566864014,
-0.5154837965965271,
-0.6818811297416687,
-0.7299473881721497,
0.6028513312339783,
0.11036897450685501,
-0.853054940700531,
-0.25292035937309265,
-0.09063149243593216,
-0.2866002321243286,
0.3243395686149597,
-0.5731842517852783,
0.8971349000930786,
0.10488917678594589,
0.16936200857162476,
0.026633799076080322,
-0.4326554238796234,
0.6298551559448242,
-0.07317730039358139,
-0.13479295372962952,
-0.049385372549295425,
-0.12117846310138702,
0.7432863116264343,
-0.36377227306365967,
0.5354170203208923,
-0.003653655294328928,
-0.45429280400276184,
0.3695433437824249,
0.09370199590921402,
0.29374924302101135,
0.023468121886253357,
-0.10553635656833649,
0.5154938697814941,
0.09544569998979568,
-0.19195272028446198,
-0.7951747179031372,
0.37421101331710815,
-0.7693737149238586,
-0.11867152899503708,
-0.29406818747520447,
-0.3563905954360962,
0.07382182776927948,
0.4052802324295044,
0.36552003026008606,
0.5649012327194214,
-0.5259600877761841,
0.07964644581079483,
0.1282266080379486,
-0.28545358777046204,
0.5580564141273499,
0.22430384159088135,
-0.46577370166778564,
-0.7305319309234619,
0.8229931592941284,
0.03887864574790001,
0.5293583273887634,
0.485980361700058,
0.40186548233032227,
-0.14819708466529846,
-0.4482751786708832,
-0.7132608294487,
0.29733455181121826,
-0.4967207908630371,
-0.10176467895507812,
-0.7315977811813354,
-0.35663193464279175,
-0.40817132592201233,
0.055113889276981354,
-0.21761086583137512,
-0.4204195439815521,
0.3682838976383209,
0.17400765419006348,
0.17647923529148102,
1.109435796737671,
0.5250080227851868,
0.6442904472351074,
-0.903417706489563,
0.49376577138900757,
0.164479061961174,
0.522813618183136,
0.017081936821341515,
-0.4288814067840576,
-0.169353649020195,
-0.10490143299102783,
-0.38632577657699585,
-0.8927057385444641,
0.38519537448883057,
0.04605884104967117,
0.3674808442592621,
0.27802398800849915,
-0.04143008217215538,
0.2381281554698944,
-0.31138789653778076,
1.1169456243515015,
0.26174506545066833,
-1.115385890007019,
0.4000682532787323,
-0.7550712823867798,
0.6381973624229431,
0.5176447033882141,
0.3145211338996887,
-0.5758538842201233,
-0.729236900806427,
-0.5154049396514893,
-0.733462929725647,
0.4123760759830475,
0.8562266826629639,
0.08578810095787048,
0.15191340446472168,
0.26676252484321594,
0.28341397643089294,
0.24771900475025177,
-0.6908056139945984,
-0.1158536896109581,
-0.3147927224636078,
-0.39950284361839294,
-0.22900597751140594,
-0.15446977317333221,
0.22393757104873657,
0.12938900291919708,
0.584338366985321,
-0.23258662223815918,
0.3285895586013794,
0.30721357464790344,
-0.221559077501297,
0.2131589949131012,
0.3314613103866577,
0.5950273871421814,
0.6320235729217529,
-0.10230547934770584,
-0.11109121888875961,
0.045662377029657364,
-0.9872722625732422,
-0.2439955323934555,
0.16551946103572845,
-0.3833564221858978,
0.30764105916023254,
0.7185813188552856,
0.758688747882843,
-0.018119795247912407,
-0.3709833025932312,
0.8221732378005981,
-0.5675889253616333,
-0.010675924830138683,
0.0473296083509922,
-0.14917705953121185,
-0.23407237231731415,
0.05295643210411072,
0.19569706916809082,
-0.03271421045064926,
0.2892299294471741,
-0.3786763548851013,
0.1387195587158203,
0.23864951729774475,
-0.42681223154067993,
-0.6637179851531982,
0.5128284096717834,
0.1306028962135315,
-0.08153729140758514,
0.5327494144439697,
0.009442329406738281,
-0.5583491921424866,
0.5251812934875488,
0.40029892325401306,
1.282331943511963,
-0.26431193947792053,
0.17345911264419556,
0.2989274859428406,
0.5738314986228943,
-0.08533170074224472,
-0.025939777493476868,
-0.16481101512908936,
-0.5266974568367004,
-0.7474435567855835,
-0.6440336108207703,
-0.7798359394073486,
0.14407579600811005,
-0.7262763381004333,
0.1541489213705063,
0.030216066166758537,
-0.16074210405349731,
0.19261227548122406,
-0.19881170988082886,
-0.6690291166305542,
0.12491409480571747,
-0.247283473610878,
0.9434111714363098,
-0.9297481179237366,
0.434623122215271,
0.550836980342865,
-0.8317505121231079,
-0.6262405514717102,
0.5268545746803284,
-0.139299675822258,
-0.39220696687698364,
0.1830841451883316,
0.28764116764068604,
-0.08906091749668121,
-0.34243181347846985,
-0.06686975806951523,
-0.5501158237457275,
0.9900243878364563,
0.4409361481666565,
-0.2668120265007019,
-0.29161787033081055,
0.07490057498216629,
0.654438316822052,
0.10769595950841904,
1.0053472518920898,
0.7789095640182495,
0.40491369366645813,
-0.026763295754790306,
-1.6423933506011963,
0.009366273880004883,
-0.43863022327423096,
-0.09348542243242264,
0.39113637804985046,
-0.7801998853683472,
0.7090398073196411,
-0.1125035211443901,
-0.3270282447338104,
0.2728652060031891,
0.8750078678131104,
-0.20189908146858215,
0.15820840001106262,
0.3066786229610443,
0.30479827523231506,
0.559477686882019,
-0.2329961657524109,
1.3603466749191284,
-0.059322331100702286,
0.6827702522277832,
1.1024088859558105,
0.021929007023572922,
0.7989306449890137,
0.05052870139479637,
-0.3869672417640686,
0.3430944085121155,
0.202170267701149,
0.1399192214012146,
0.32963305711746216,
-0.024550622329115868,
-0.08558392524719238,
0.3168582022190094,
0.0496332086622715,
-0.3343917727470398,
0.5409861207008362,
-0.05716687813401222,
-0.3874216079711914,
-0.5508015751838684,
-0.020861277356743813,
0.22147411108016968,
-0.01650247909128666,
-0.27855247259140015,
1.1053835153579712,
0.11468493193387985,
-0.8174223303794861,
0.31906673312187195,
0.008303467184305191,
0.6260301470756531,
-0.5824303030967712,
0.19302624464035034,
-0.1902398318052292,
0.3281181752681732,
-0.16802147030830383,
-0.9526106715202332,
0.591613233089447,
0.4723256230354309,
-0.1161252036690712,
-0.206369087100029,
0.6530900001525879,
-0.34147724509239197,
-0.3812299370765686,
0.21378444135189056,
0.5124252438545227,
0.36271634697914124,
-0.45181697607040405,
-0.3294104039669037,
-0.0740126222372055,
-0.2658032774925232,
-0.5948746800422668,
0.26095104217529297,
0.502697765827179,
-0.057022519409656525,
0.32487133145332336,
0.35211411118507385,
0.09205980598926544,
-0.5770808458328247,
0.3777247369289398,
0.8939322233200073,
-0.6681678891181946,
-0.6274713277816772,
-1.1408051252365112,
0.6264186501502991,
0.00023690595116931945,
-0.4987196922302246,
0.8644492626190186,
0.6098752617835999,
0.6150668859481812,
0.013953818939626217,
1.0554229021072388,
-0.05044263228774071,
0.47650882601737976,
-0.4701940715312958,
1.1556662321090698,
-0.14843471348285675,
-0.22646057605743408,
-0.8566932082176208,
-1.084260106086731,
-0.26668214797973633,
0.5240029096603394,
-0.42649468779563904,
0.3263486623764038,
0.5853989124298096,
0.2991894781589508,
-0.24764323234558105,
0.4675199091434479,
0.290475457906723,
0.04196695238351822,
0.6144459843635559,
0.3010289967060089,
0.714030921459198,
-0.678566575050354,
0.33568263053894043,
0.05277619510889053,
-0.5727064609527588,
0.12110815197229385,
-1.093458890914917,
-1.1831661462783813,
-0.6378580331802368,
-0.21373161673545837,
-0.2669728696346283,
-0.25565654039382935,
0.5482075214385986,
0.4183989465236664,
-0.8092559576034546,
-0.04084863141179085,
0.26203370094299316,
-0.10043448209762573,
-0.25020480155944824,
-0.2510380744934082,
0.8118365406990051,
-0.2389875054359436,
-0.7379730343818665,
0.07722251862287521,
0.2874063551425934,
0.13666364550590515,
-0.35248854756355286,
0.08352722972631454,
0.4399620294570923,
-0.013774607330560684,
0.8926875591278076,
-0.1622776985168457,
-0.7433945536613464,
-0.25891152024269104,
-0.07853376865386963,
-0.11287477612495422,
-0.20655487477779388,
0.9093222618103027,
-0.6383873820304871,
0.3146621286869049,
0.7121434211730957,
0.6656642556190491,
0.36117205023765564,
0.18207140266895294,
0.6180723905563354,
-0.4603274464607239,
-0.10830996930599213,
0.05551008880138397,
0.3525570034980774,
0.2536673843860626,
-0.14777807891368866,
0.5983593463897705,
0.03557208180427551,
-0.5940097570419312,
-0.657929539680481,
-0.043601445853710175,
-0.8412933945655823,
0.18688178062438965,
0.996487021446228,
-0.37456515431404114,
-0.12279146909713745,
0.10205992311239243,
-0.24206200242042542,
0.2574254274368286,
-0.3441528081893921,
0.5957096815109253,
0.7193004488945007,
-0.1026262491941452,
-0.0595674104988575,
-0.6405687928199768,
0.430513471364975,
0.05344030261039734,
-1.0984033346176147,
0.2041662484407425,
0.2531435191631317,
0.1288682520389557,
0.34511813521385193,
0.5959580540657043,
-0.3884330987930298,
0.031364891678094864,
-0.1414068341255188,
-0.054574836045503616,
-0.011350452899932861,
-0.24203254282474518,
-0.4714968204498291,
0.2549859583377838,
-0.22781473398208618,
0.1642358899116516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04048v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04048v1
|
Philosophy of Cognitive Science in the Age of Deep Learning
| 2024-05-07T06:39:47 | 2024-05-07T06:39:47 |
Raphaël Millière
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Deep learning has enabled major advances across most areas of artificial
intelligence research. This remarkable progress extends beyond mere engineering
achievements and holds significant relevance for the philosophy of cognitive
science. Deep neural networks have made significant strides in overcoming the
limitations of older connectionist models that once occupied the centre stage
of philosophical debates about cognition. This development is directly relevant
to long-standing theoretical debates in the philosophy of cognitive science.
Furthermore, ongoing methodological challenges related to the comparative
evaluation of deep neural networks stand to benefit greatly from
interdisciplinary collaboration with philosophy and cognitive science. The time
is ripe for philosophers to explore foundational issues related to deep
learning and cognition; this perspective paper surveys key areas where their
contributions can be especially fruitful.
|
[
-0.47105732560157776,
-0.41538482904434204,
0.8552976846694946,
-0.023496298119425774,
0.10714088380336761,
0.32279977202415466,
-0.6462281942367554,
-0.803753674030304,
0.03168671578168869,
0.4519256353378296,
-0.5596222877502441,
0.15696947276592255,
-0.6716631054878235,
-0.31739288568496704,
-0.2377740740776062,
0.47847098112106323,
0.4571557641029358,
0.3696831166744232,
-0.06572572141885757,
-0.24157996475696564,
-0.7363003492355347,
-0.37958091497421265,
-1.0788530111312866,
-0.7930489182472229,
0.4081239700317383,
0.004703813698142767,
0.5054753422737122,
-0.006780876778066158,
0.8385507464408875,
0.3728800415992737,
-0.14670304954051971,
-0.049559544771909714,
0.046271227300167084,
0.34958750009536743,
-0.46794334053993225,
-0.675221860408783,
-0.1130056083202362,
0.024241099134087563,
0.4922749698162079,
1.194238543510437,
-0.06154879555106163,
-0.19007760286331177,
0.06703393161296844,
0.9975299835205078,
-0.5012452602386475,
0.16980403661727905,
-0.670713484287262,
0.5167018175125122,
-0.12546175718307495,
0.15077120065689087,
-0.29510024189949036,
-0.3416878283023834,
0.49285629391670227,
-0.5337991118431091,
0.10955923795700073,
-0.35014742612838745,
0.3641830384731293,
0.3959904611110687,
-0.21013304591178894,
-0.3555372655391693,
-1.1010280847549438,
1.0055382251739502,
-0.6644092798233032,
0.47710418701171875,
0.07690348476171494,
0.499659925699234,
-0.1850956678390503,
-0.8418222069740295,
-0.5233551859855652,
-0.4699840247631073,
0.29908668994903564,
0.19354411959648132,
0.004972606897354126,
0.06754934042692184,
0.27053123712539673,
0.6252161264419556,
-0.09454163908958435,
0.2676450312137604,
-0.6498363018035889,
-0.18702921271324158,
0.7200776934623718,
0.3440047800540924,
0.18033622205257416,
0.3000941872596741,
0.022205708548426628,
0.10388826578855515,
-0.20597954094409943,
0.3135845959186554,
0.19632168114185333,
-0.08054473251104355,
0.36672163009643555,
0.22738532721996307,
-0.460780531167984,
0.4178771376609802,
-0.12285877019166946,
0.5000024437904358,
0.07219211012125015,
-0.28311771154403687,
-0.1594478189945221,
0.18723410367965698,
0.6583237051963806,
0.00006337415106827393,
0.3853646516799927,
0.014131318777799606,
0.15928524732589722,
0.6022538542747498,
0.31991973519325256,
-0.46984484791755676,
-0.5172194838523865,
0.08066895604133606,
-0.34035077691078186,
-0.20383131504058838,
-0.12780629098415375,
-0.4047824740409851,
-0.5810942053794861,
-0.6655535697937012,
-0.27278393507003784,
-0.38145795464515686,
-0.32757148146629333,
0.5954106450080872,
-0.23323552310466766,
0.21345964074134827,
0.6669754385948181,
-0.8111169934272766,
0.24133189022541046,
1.0784435272216797,
0.3179756700992584,
0.06626126915216446,
-0.19461560249328613,
0.21595516800880432,
0.14801204204559326,
-0.7050882577896118,
0.585740327835083,
-0.7473047971725464,
-0.17323721945285797,
-0.2811967730522156,
-0.18775910139083862,
0.09542302042245865,
-0.3568195402622223,
0.5626509189605713,
-0.6138441562652588,
0.33594027161598206,
-0.5331987738609314,
-0.6512385606765747,
-0.4551393687725067,
0.31069865822792053,
-0.425117552280426,
0.6178277730941772,
-0.3327445685863495,
-0.21620988845825195,
0.3914346992969513,
-0.9764146208763123,
-0.6103531122207642,
0.31402525305747986,
-0.5108894109725952,
-0.1506730318069458,
0.38573095202445984,
-0.07426903396844864,
0.46066877245903015,
-0.5147359371185303,
0.434094101190567,
-0.6520969867706299,
-0.00747502688318491,
0.7155112624168396,
-0.43781501054763794,
1.128375768661499,
0.4122130274772644,
-0.5195280313491821,
-0.22167828679084778,
-0.5924785137176514,
0.21138229966163635,
0.08487541228532791,
-0.21299928426742554,
-0.3028712570667267,
0.40588730573654175,
-0.6826191544532776,
0.16673168540000916,
0.1939251869916916,
-0.7266806960105896,
0.20317277312278748,
-0.596491277217865,
1.3884226083755493,
0.7455642819404602,
-0.2116663008928299,
0.5729100704193115,
-0.060198940336704254,
-0.16192135214805603,
-0.13246269524097443,
0.4393788278102875,
0.17303086817264557,
-0.642427384853363,
-0.7356942296028137,
0.2440093606710434,
0.139755517244339,
0.4441608190536499,
-0.2403121441602707,
0.30798208713531494,
-0.24063803255558014,
-0.367635041475296,
-0.17238642275333405,
0.04956454783678055,
0.0819278135895729,
0.5141114592552185,
0.23935624957084656,
-0.661220133304596,
-0.20154103636741638,
-0.7442944049835205,
-0.2295432984828949,
-0.050634339451789856,
0.12353231757879257,
0.7106928825378418,
0.5314168930053711,
0.14191369712352753,
0.5582839846611023,
-0.591239869594574,
-0.1241697445511818,
0.19104737043380737,
-0.12680141627788544,
0.12049495428800583,
0.8397091031074524,
0.30562567710876465,
-0.803860604763031,
0.15076248347759247,
0.09817870706319809,
-1.1431273221969604,
0.653168797492981,
0.0916157066822052,
-0.047679975628852844,
-0.36527419090270996,
0.38952964544296265,
-0.8293463587760925,
0.3021365702152252,
-0.20071819424629211,
-0.008441164158284664,
0.1930714100599289,
-0.10021563619375229,
-0.05730210244655609,
-0.47692492604255676,
-0.09775692969560623,
-0.30482128262519836,
0.3493848443031311,
-0.4332171082496643,
-0.12932953238487244,
-0.32565099000930786,
-0.2751432955265045,
-0.22805866599082947,
0.16773755848407745,
-0.022514481097459793,
-0.2279500812292099,
-0.27180835604667664,
-0.0460934191942215,
0.17433807253837585,
-0.11242133378982544,
0.0393284372985363,
0.15009143948554993,
0.7623645663261414,
-0.90915447473526,
0.649932324886322,
0.052557267248630524,
-0.32703864574432373,
0.32045218348503113,
-0.41998082399368286,
0.31959235668182373,
-0.07027740031480789,
0.5256569981575012,
-0.7174767851829529,
-0.11385191977024078,
0.3428681492805481,
-0.6039143204689026,
0.04931733012199402,
0.45987382531166077,
0.140181764960289,
-0.6999743580818176,
-0.19208785891532898,
0.5763919353485107,
0.4179133474826813,
0.0919528529047966,
0.5682320594787598,
0.09341982007026672,
0.13589002192020416,
-0.7034212350845337,
-1.141424298286438,
0.22380784153938293,
0.029022755101323128,
-0.6829814314842224,
0.26230692863464355,
-0.0029001599177718163,
-0.5475947260856628,
0.02132476679980755,
-0.032321419566869736,
-0.07118681073188782,
0.4928536117076874,
0.050289902836084366,
0.04627795144915581,
-0.5659428238868713,
0.2710604965686798,
-0.1575385332107544,
-0.3458554446697235,
0.5457887053489685,
-0.9209358096122742,
0.47435346245765686,
-0.24461330473423004,
-0.3434283137321472,
-0.5631093978881836,
0.11969547718763351,
0.4200786054134369,
-0.5036360025405884,
0.32843270897865295,
0.4132591784000397,
-0.4692821204662323,
-0.2447003871202469,
-0.6224063038825989,
-0.5642340183258057,
-0.4364267587661743,
0.05800242722034454,
-0.08010198920965195,
-0.8595118522644043,
0.25139883160591125,
-0.5887081027030945,
-0.032954320311546326,
0.470800518989563,
0.18966516852378845,
-0.556175708770752,
0.44234052300453186,
0.5471625328063965,
0.061419181525707245,
0.5468971133232117,
-0.6615214943885803,
0.357622891664505,
-0.9989538192749023,
-0.35681024193763733,
-0.34658104181289673,
-0.5710145831108093,
-0.3493629992008209,
-0.056345365941524506,
-0.06509869545698166,
0.037857022136449814,
-0.4493435025215149,
-0.15607166290283203,
-0.8839665055274963,
0.3542206883430481,
0.5376290082931519,
0.40547019243240356,
0.09683606773614883,
-0.10876007378101349,
-0.023829936981201172,
0.04995139315724373,
-0.39345061779022217,
-0.28912338614463806,
0.9214361906051636,
0.24036607146263123,
0.45996010303497314,
-0.05803173780441284,
0.22834201157093048,
0.5369837284088135,
-0.164286807179451,
-0.6923931241035461,
0.6951729655265808,
-0.24377144873142242,
-0.9383969902992249,
-0.41496771574020386,
-0.10486536473035812,
-0.983314573764801,
-0.03540932759642601,
-0.126469686627388,
-0.6151109933853149,
0.6290825009346008,
-0.028637709096074104,
-0.61448734998703,
0.4952317774295807,
-0.31387755274772644,
0.40220049023628235,
-0.4394538104534149,
-0.13399042189121246,
-0.9606336951255798,
-0.8864234685897827,
0.4218626916408539,
0.23082004487514496,
-0.16404855251312256,
-0.399284690618515,
0.051287081092596054,
0.8976466655731201,
-0.04394589364528656,
0.780852198600769,
0.0056092701852321625,
0.057913973927497864,
0.4970792829990387,
0.05982485041022301,
-0.13383272290229797,
0.23461584746837616,
-0.04269961640238762,
0.18196821212768555,
-0.3164176046848297,
-0.657724142074585,
-0.5295618176460266,
0.79543137550354,
-0.7735986709594727,
-0.7403352856636047,
-0.3865898549556732,
-0.4784575402736664,
-0.2365102767944336,
0.2849208414554596,
0.09752172231674194,
0.2670029401779175,
0.005800251848995686,
0.36050131916999817,
1.2229609489440918,
-0.09961997717618942,
0.8194868564605713,
0.0736590176820755,
-0.03451719507575035,
-0.35966262221336365,
0.7990345358848572,
0.2830613851547241,
0.07202791422605515,
0.19246089458465576,
0.18698158860206604,
0.09486551582813263,
-0.7171525359153748,
-0.2718580365180969,
-0.1252061426639557,
-0.9792742729187012,
0.17498593032360077,
-0.4906691014766693,
-0.46864059567451477,
-0.05392267182469368,
-0.2845679819583893,
-0.5780015587806702,
-0.6007598042488098,
-0.12107288092374802,
-0.05618054419755936,
0.11595872044563293,
0.7842509746551514,
0.01308845542371273,
0.02898978814482689,
-0.3183426558971405,
0.1629503071308136,
0.7432845234870911,
0.1393718272447586,
0.4426840841770172,
0.1506412774324417,
0.10944666713476181,
-0.01064375601708889,
-0.42597952485084534,
-0.40605998039245605,
-0.5635274648666382,
0.04234008491039276,
0.43448373675346375,
0.5091304183006287,
-0.24101486802101135,
0.3294870853424072,
-0.2600773274898529,
1.1069731712341309,
0.31837135553359985,
-0.7088866829872131,
0.7119457721710205,
-0.11146871745586395,
-0.12838545441627502,
0.4139014780521393,
0.294697105884552,
-0.16998101770877838,
0.25155752897262573,
-0.6427084803581238,
-0.5689199566841125,
0.15258769690990448,
0.15414559841156006,
0.4423389434814453,
0.3606380522251129,
0.7143086791038513,
-0.021280135959386826,
0.3353025019168854,
-0.33460533618927,
-0.07719948887825012,
-0.3025163412094116,
0.08974068611860275,
-0.003988088574260473,
0.3471145033836365,
-0.3653421998023987,
-0.6749334931373596,
0.36338186264038086,
-0.07971571385860443,
0.27058327198028564,
0.27054211497306824,
0.18653111159801483,
0.10816527903079987,
0.33195406198501587,
0.552416205406189,
0.971987247467041,
0.26560211181640625,
0.14320962131023407,
0.3914088010787964,
-0.39016151428222656,
0.2655388116836548,
0.008925464935600758,
-0.1914179027080536,
-0.5146806240081787,
0.49364057183265686,
0.7798948884010315,
-0.06887807697057724,
-0.2890164852142334,
0.17413216829299927,
-0.0134047232568264,
-0.2407933622598648,
-0.5824174880981445,
0.36992117762565613,
0.02770470641553402,
0.6623278260231018,
0.6268468499183655,
0.755988359451294,
0.24350778758525848,
-0.7591075301170349,
0.024910418316721916,
0.5413799285888672,
-0.5415138006210327,
-0.2716933488845825,
0.5143665075302124,
-0.06549756228923798,
-0.1685018092393875,
0.9103068709373474,
0.35210925340652466,
-0.5611193776130676,
0.9245030879974365,
0.03221455216407776,
0.8331999778747559,
-0.025743139907717705,
-0.07443977892398834,
-0.06866682320833206,
0.32800722122192383,
0.09948787838220596,
0.2949877679347992,
-0.37616002559661865,
-0.8339628577232361,
-0.46977728605270386,
-0.43481695652008057,
-0.34161508083343506,
0.16168534755706787,
-0.38133704662323,
-0.16648724675178528,
-0.9499017000198364,
-0.5661302804946899,
0.3762265741825104,
0.34736526012420654,
-0.7572543621063232,
0.5474202632904053,
0.5576092004776001,
0.6632194519042969,
-0.5295477509498596,
0.6409897208213806,
0.6056370139122009,
-0.26133960485458374,
-0.4862216114997864,
-0.39024433493614197,
-0.34801965951919556,
-0.6858286261558533,
0.9579851031303406,
0.0939309298992157,
-0.2568973898887634,
-0.03268495202064514,
-0.887511134147644,
-0.7511591911315918,
0.9998010396957397,
0.41335147619247437,
-0.4457189440727234,
-0.057132478803396225,
-0.04831733927130699,
0.5140637159347534,
-0.4018617868423462,
0.060210734605789185,
0.34698066115379333,
0.5171819925308228,
-0.09861963987350464,
-0.38086777925491333,
-0.003792789299041033,
-0.03195175155997276,
0.017528826370835304,
0.27290964126586914,
-0.9787278771400452,
1.093562364578247,
-0.07097966969013214,
0.140071302652359,
-0.032301053404808044,
1.0787925720214844,
-0.061857130378484726,
0.6782729029655457,
0.07119295001029968,
0.8407382369041443,
0.8733082413673401,
-0.12010329961776733,
0.6682188510894775,
-0.13839207589626312,
0.12163367867469788,
0.7234047055244446,
-0.3268389403820038,
0.4253407418727875,
0.20643004775047302,
-0.37189459800720215,
0.5112247467041016,
0.4834831953048706,
-0.19552217423915863,
0.41876494884490967,
0.26337572932243347,
-0.4205687344074249,
-0.4764178991317749,
-0.14244064688682556,
-0.7040899395942688,
0.2671598196029663,
0.8469091653823853,
-0.4071429669857025,
0.19192592799663544,
0.47040030360221863,
-0.16053399443626404,
0.008934656158089638,
-0.5364303588867188,
0.6107776761054993,
0.4123162031173706,
-0.4705311954021454,
-0.10351253300905228,
-0.3821001946926117,
0.5114893913269043,
-0.40832632780075073,
0.02321079932153225,
0.09148222208023071,
0.5789021253585815,
-0.1370524913072586,
-0.9647864103317261,
0.24966560304164886,
-0.6840408444404602,
-0.15720152854919434,
0.08219381421804428,
0.9698710441589355,
0.3656441867351532,
-0.358309805393219,
0.4867987036705017,
0.36609986424446106,
0.09919407218694687,
0.1269262284040451,
-0.9181321263313293,
0.08323095738887787,
-0.20276467502117157,
-0.17888474464416504,
0.2260778397321701,
0.4548977017402649,
-0.034607913345098495,
0.9358415007591248,
0.8597810864448547,
0.02285589650273323,
0.3191520869731903,
-0.28273293375968933,
1.010317087173462,
-0.9723970293998718,
-0.11587370932102203,
-1.0624099969863892,
0.042821016162633896,
-0.13845299184322357,
-0.5297700762748718,
0.4688877761363983,
0.18774177134037018,
0.860810399055481,
0.1116982102394104,
0.8523321151733398,
-0.17066647112369537,
-0.1838429719209671,
-0.4553823173046112,
0.546582818031311,
-0.2718599736690521,
0.09765905141830444,
-0.09535789489746094,
-0.6940291523933411,
-0.42697256803512573,
0.5494197010993958,
-0.741628885269165,
0.1437959522008896,
0.6139310002326965,
-0.03160660341382027,
-0.12048734724521637,
0.5731122493743896,
0.03897356614470482,
-0.08611517399549484,
0.4102848768234253,
0.8851324319839478,
1.1702730655670166,
-0.3364507555961609,
0.0032347459346055984,
-0.6513999104499817,
0.18393848836421967,
-0.07376102358102798,
-0.718327522277832,
-0.6253882050514221,
-0.4857740104198456,
-0.3405672311782837,
-0.2679152190685272,
0.060502007603645325,
0.6274885535240173,
0.7265965938568115,
-0.7615889310836792,
-0.09296251088380814,
-0.5528382062911987,
0.1172712966799736,
-0.4799443781375885,
-0.2051185965538025,
0.2907414138317108,
-0.40134501457214355,
-0.2960732877254486,
0.4399127960205078,
0.5110365748405457,
-0.1880912333726883,
-0.5028336644172668,
-0.08124938607215881,
-0.1628044694662094,
0.1500159054994583,
0.6822532415390015,
0.5576872825622559,
-0.7528126239776611,
-0.2882310748100281,
-0.009669626131653786,
-0.057969313114881516,
0.19314411282539368,
0.8720224499702454,
-0.9688063263893127,
0.27928590774536133,
0.4889287054538727,
1.0927037000656128,
0.3542128801345825,
-0.6772010326385498,
0.18204425275325775,
0.030642695724964142,
0.29803887009620667,
0.8269532918930054,
0.3221960663795471,
0.21854953467845917,
-0.380328506231308,
0.6829211711883545,
0.4673596918582916,
-0.5807952880859375,
-0.7241108417510986,
0.4828299283981323,
-0.7973875999450684,
-0.5489099025726318,
0.18626810610294342,
-0.17690005898475647,
-0.23003339767456055,
-0.021251464262604713,
0.07153730094432831,
0.2611774802207947,
-0.17263200879096985,
0.5969842672348022,
0.8685259819030762,
-0.6720256805419922,
-0.16711893677711487,
-0.8916459679603577,
0.39406824111938477,
0.9841545820236206,
-0.474450945854187,
-0.32717451453208923,
0.08352754265069962,
0.03362955525517464,
0.5837295651435852,
0.20754970610141754,
0.11935894936323166,
0.26463449001312256,
-0.08552039414644241,
-0.3353743851184845,
0.04832068085670471,
-0.4359000623226166,
-0.24069954454898834,
0.29174017906188965,
0.09396333992481232,
-0.09146203100681305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04039v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04039v1
|
Utilizing GPT to Enhance Text Summarization: A Strategy to Minimize Hallucinations
| 2024-05-07T06:23:02 | 2024-05-07T06:23:02 |
Hassan Shakil, Zeydy Ortiz, Grant C. Forbes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this research, we uses the DistilBERT model to generate extractive summary
and the T5 model to generate abstractive summaries. Also, we generate hybrid
summaries by combining both DistilBERT and T5 models. Central to our research
is the implementation of GPT-based refining process to minimize the common
problem of hallucinations that happens in AI-generated summaries. We evaluate
unrefined summaries and, after refining, we also assess refined summaries using
a range of traditional and novel metrics, demonstrating marked improvements in
the accuracy and reliability of the summaries. Results highlight significant
improvements in reducing hallucinatory content, thereby increasing the factual
integrity of the summaries.
|
[
-0.3949236273765564,
-0.8600032329559326,
0.7712273597717285,
-0.0553286075592041,
-0.48516973853111267,
0.17097961902618408,
-0.23566845059394836,
-0.6246006488800049,
0.37958621978759766,
0.4703780710697174,
-0.28871452808380127,
-0.4481581747531891,
-0.6457133889198303,
0.4544752538204193,
-0.505618691444397,
1.4483143091201782,
0.04658462479710579,
-0.19902360439300537,
0.26558011770248413,
0.30098146200180054,
-0.2982851266860962,
-0.7643723487854004,
-0.4860807955265045,
-0.3373081684112549,
0.3097207546234131,
-0.026521645486354828,
0.8256365656852722,
0.3490579128265381,
0.7822293639183044,
0.33840909600257874,
-0.21633611619472504,
0.2812870740890503,
-0.6631913781166077,
0.24380245804786682,
0.039225928485393524,
-0.04123350977897644,
-0.6654171943664551,
-0.10763027518987656,
0.36290714144706726,
0.6431611776351929,
-0.3203849792480469,
-0.11404991149902344,
0.2384374439716339,
0.6571242213249207,
-0.47163835167884827,
0.1306668072938919,
-0.621146023273468,
0.2018696665763855,
0.10108498483896255,
-0.4991435110569,
-0.40349191427230835,
-0.5788418054580688,
0.3631672263145447,
-0.5728683471679688,
0.6766690015792847,
-0.133419007062912,
0.8286858797073364,
0.4491736888885498,
-0.2136419117450714,
-0.24061930179595947,
-0.9727757573127747,
0.6169648766517639,
-0.6799376010894775,
-0.004435376729816198,
0.37743431329727173,
0.34896689653396606,
0.04158124700188637,
-0.9471922516822815,
-0.4847773015499115,
-0.45201051235198975,
-0.46058934926986694,
0.2703816890716553,
0.02814462035894394,
0.3750731348991394,
0.3761838376522064,
0.6679189205169678,
-0.7401894330978394,
-0.3103092312812805,
-0.7934861183166504,
-0.43263861536979675,
0.8361116051673889,
0.3249253034591675,
0.25314420461654663,
-0.08305150270462036,
-0.06369887292385101,
0.061965424567461014,
-0.2517641484737396,
-0.5576865077018738,
0.2732599377632141,
0.05994772911071777,
0.42269548773765564,
0.7176012396812439,
-0.1769195944070816,
0.2705673277378082,
0.02243458293378353,
-0.403278112411499,
0.21746540069580078,
-0.5079968571662903,
-0.4335381090641022,
0.3688383102416992,
0.5545300245285034,
0.9397643804550171,
0.3155735433101654,
-0.5595423579216003,
-0.36658787727355957,
0.3225759267807007,
0.6156973242759705,
-0.9321187138557434,
-0.6784119606018066,
0.29845723509788513,
-0.7348090410232544,
-0.5341010093688965,
0.13430556654930115,
-0.9010103344917297,
-0.4406503438949585,
-0.6222941279411316,
0.5432803630828857,
-0.6083879470825195,
-0.314548134803772,
-0.027363013476133347,
-0.7468811273574829,
-0.009179825894534588,
0.5642497539520264,
-1.2201865911483765,
0.5517427325248718,
0.4961247146129608,
1.160828948020935,
-0.4803389012813568,
-0.11800607293844223,
-0.16260115802288055,
0.4513784646987915,
-0.20681388676166534,
0.8938298225402832,
-0.2859821915626526,
-0.7309972047805786,
-0.35592296719551086,
-0.24846021831035614,
0.13642780482769012,
-0.8438734412193298,
0.39358460903167725,
-0.12312986701726913,
0.3689716160297394,
-0.3276415169239044,
-0.38055071234703064,
-0.5755743980407715,
0.1685204803943634,
-0.7152594923973083,
1.0047310590744019,
0.19714534282684326,
-0.7747535705566406,
0.4996524155139923,
-0.762331485748291,
-0.6710564494132996,
-0.10994070768356323,
-0.10628925263881683,
-0.3598122000694275,
0.623029887676239,
0.5505642890930176,
0.2280413806438446,
0.26741278171539307,
0.19417120516300201,
0.2538812756538391,
-0.6526581048965454,
-0.16113848984241486,
-0.334271639585495,
0.48832276463508606,
0.335587739944458,
-0.5230625867843628,
0.22521942853927612,
-0.6890869736671448,
-0.20920345187187195,
-0.08072778582572937,
0.05645481124520302,
-0.3527497351169586,
-0.12327419966459274,
0.26581433415412903,
-0.12090527266263962,
0.004223265219479799,
-0.049024276435375214,
0.33808159828186035,
-0.37587985396385193,
0.221700057387352,
0.7356517314910889,
0.34446972608566284,
0.2246512472629547,
-0.5656484961509705,
0.3980685770511627,
0.014331384561955929,
-0.028223367407917976,
-0.21830646693706512,
-0.2602098882198334,
-0.5684449076652527,
-0.27779942750930786,
0.10833124816417694,
0.5762238502502441,
-0.8062213063240051,
0.4310591220855713,
-0.07335259020328522,
-0.3877720534801483,
-0.4073074758052826,
-0.20421293377876282,
0.00010490595013834536,
0.5958062410354614,
0.5794827938079834,
-0.255131334066391,
-0.47121724486351013,
-0.8382370471954346,
-0.16692201793193817,
-0.16140682995319366,
-0.13070710003376007,
-0.3184283673763275,
0.5427416563034058,
-0.11017463356256485,
0.6904712915420532,
-0.6948900818824768,
-0.4275725185871124,
-0.5632123351097107,
0.41571420431137085,
-0.04198542982339859,
0.3470325767993927,
0.677836537361145,
-0.7908331751823425,
-0.581215500831604,
-0.08093728125095367,
-0.9946240186691284,
0.007803692482411861,
-0.3646891117095947,
0.17705930769443512,
0.3591288924217224,
0.3311316967010498,
-0.6559356451034546,
0.7891882061958313,
0.0412374809384346,
-0.24932891130447388,
0.6548057794570923,
-0.49058064818382263,
0.6065415740013123,
-1.1425597667694092,
0.0874311551451683,
-0.19266076385974884,
-0.32462483644485474,
-0.6392248868942261,
-0.10705935209989548,
-0.3561843931674957,
-0.024815872311592102,
0.0858030915260315,
-0.036989711225032806,
-0.5273637175559998,
0.13228923082351685,
-0.6218377947807312,
0.09868763387203217,
0.0006306561408564448,
0.4116450846195221,
0.2745664417743683,
0.9683100581169128,
0.29719531536102295,
-0.6105507016181946,
0.25878289341926575,
0.14792338013648987,
-0.021288443356752396,
0.24260976910591125,
-0.7922112345695496,
0.19736866652965546,
-0.48407530784606934,
0.11460284143686295,
-0.9439123868942261,
-0.29732170701026917,
0.22042477130889893,
-0.4581156373023987,
0.20131197571754456,
0.3927775025367737,
-0.48437926173210144,
-0.13417676091194153,
-0.7180841565132141,
-0.015407152473926544,
0.7886266112327576,
-0.3302775025367737,
0.7653073072433472,
0.33166036009788513,
-0.4828367829322815,
-0.3442060649394989,
-0.882981538772583,
0.32025346159935,
-0.5236849784851074,
-0.30617251992225647,
0.6961288452148438,
0.02305379882454872,
-0.5276678800582886,
-0.014886045828461647,
-0.13731014728546143,
0.12083163857460022,
0.0410945825278759,
0.037493471056222916,
0.31899920105934143,
0.035734742879867554,
-0.07778890430927277,
0.28915008902549744,
-0.27860602736473083,
0.1316351294517517,
-0.2563024163246155,
0.4123123586177826,
0.06366189569234848,
0.13888920843601227,
-0.8653349280357361,
0.6448929905891418,
0.557671070098877,
0.12646058201789856,
0.642267107963562,
0.5868884325027466,
-0.4586033225059509,
-0.0385521836578846,
-0.5731123089790344,
-0.624017059803009,
-0.4533884525299072,
0.4616560637950897,
-0.45983490347862244,
-0.6510860919952393,
0.7095592617988586,
0.17816971242427826,
-0.015599071979522705,
0.6908534169197083,
0.6060677170753479,
-0.013886598870158195,
1.0709552764892578,
0.8231664299964905,
-0.1819847822189331,
0.3867115378379822,
-0.18176902830600739,
0.32594913244247437,
-0.6153442859649658,
-0.28946545720100403,
-0.3320842981338501,
-0.20183570683002472,
-0.5625258684158325,
0.07209834456443787,
0.5833548307418823,
-0.007228461094200611,
0.3268684446811676,
0.10660071671009064,
-1.0470001697540283,
0.8661315441131592,
0.6234023571014404,
0.1905692219734192,
0.8187581300735474,
0.3497603237628937,
0.08376795053482056,
-0.3190920948982239,
-0.23276810348033905,
-0.7838737964630127,
1.1347354650497437,
0.10390444099903107,
0.6039537191390991,
0.0830044373869896,
0.838769257068634,
0.5635231733322144,
0.29415765404701233,
-0.49404749274253845,
0.37912601232528687,
0.09044697880744934,
-0.4349686801433563,
-0.36272993683815,
-0.4983927309513092,
-0.5259032249450684,
0.48025020956993103,
-0.0040024276822805405,
-1.0590859651565552,
-0.21123327314853668,
0.06788621097803116,
-0.43380868434906006,
0.3501462936401367,
-0.8394256830215454,
0.4269702136516571,
0.010856357403099537,
-0.0591154508292675,
-0.39651960134506226,
-0.5030742883682251,
0.47380614280700684,
0.009615801274776459,
-0.29414114356040955,
0.29412227869033813,
0.07272987812757492,
0.5293038487434387,
-0.6016700863838196,
0.4978029131889343,
-0.1271073967218399,
-0.1560101956129074,
0.3887418210506439,
0.046784672886133194,
0.5453418493270874,
0.14756610989570618,
0.07518826425075531,
0.09651006013154984,
-0.18719936907291412,
-0.23694947361946106,
-0.6759892702102661,
0.3961106240749359,
-0.6805286407470703,
-0.6879904270172119,
-0.6995863318443298,
-0.6979894042015076,
0.09831510484218597,
0.02259625494480133,
0.6436401605606079,
0.23198029398918152,
-0.23334671556949615,
-0.23048441112041473,
0.5974818468093872,
-0.09146863222122192,
0.5759942531585693,
-0.1655152589082718,
-0.3783450424671173,
-0.6872588396072388,
0.8575312495231628,
0.2577493488788605,
0.20130065083503723,
0.16454856097698212,
0.08743257820606232,
-0.4642021954059601,
-1.0803555250167847,
-0.19397643208503723,
0.20448611676692963,
-0.6874780058860779,
0.21659256517887115,
-0.9952682256698608,
-0.3567522466182709,
-0.8146489262580872,
-0.1845223754644394,
0.04399772733449936,
-0.6672850847244263,
-0.18653909862041473,
-0.47889336943626404,
0.37974950671195984,
0.9622904658317566,
0.02841540426015854,
0.3719058632850647,
-0.7176962494850159,
0.6861369609832764,
0.13744337856769562,
0.021912703290581703,
0.0880887359380722,
-0.48347774147987366,
-0.06075455620884895,
-0.1986234486103058,
-0.6299576163291931,
-0.8866955041885376,
0.6720162630081177,
-0.07056287676095963,
0.4441867470741272,
0.46198785305023193,
0.17946182191371918,
0.8377233147621155,
-0.16719681024551392,
1.112816572189331,
0.15030059218406677,
-1.0156625509262085,
0.6425368785858154,
-0.5007235407829285,
0.09908970445394516,
0.8502677083015442,
0.36676403880119324,
-0.2300308495759964,
-0.7880762219429016,
-0.664715588092804,
-0.9109559655189514,
0.43858760595321655,
0.7914694547653198,
-0.1390414983034134,
0.25533223152160645,
0.40557539463043213,
0.49691617488861084,
0.4274744689464569,
-0.7938355803489685,
-0.11816760152578354,
-0.4420009255409241,
-0.23381464183330536,
-0.15187442302703857,
-0.23282285034656525,
-0.09292774647474289,
-0.460895299911499,
0.80120450258255,
0.09099487215280533,
0.19645048677921295,
0.4669547379016876,
-0.19407108426094055,
0.28588104248046875,
-0.12388350069522858,
0.9898402094841003,
0.8339333534240723,
-0.49547553062438965,
0.1580735445022583,
0.26475661993026733,
-1.0428117513656616,
-0.0355549231171608,
0.1463574916124344,
-0.320263147354126,
0.4435749053955078,
0.3424735963344574,
0.5864241719245911,
-0.6273419260978699,
-0.4390394985675812,
-0.0029449646826833487,
-0.34637853503227234,
-0.49216073751449585,
-0.42411091923713684,
0.1308499127626419,
-0.3928166925907135,
0.19160833954811096,
0.6674306988716125,
0.03923724219202995,
0.7484704852104187,
-0.5074688196182251,
0.1749511957168579,
0.02675822749733925,
-0.20493632555007935,
-0.25993093848228455,
0.8616623878479004,
0.1487327516078949,
-0.08441591262817383,
0.8301480412483215,
-0.25777044892311096,
-0.43524056673049927,
0.4723239243030548,
0.5594909191131592,
1.273840069770813,
-0.02321096882224083,
0.22027379274368286,
0.3775593340396881,
0.6951748728752136,
-0.1519698202610016,
0.21795068681240082,
-0.22791731357574463,
-0.24257472157478333,
-0.3844696283340454,
-0.31206944584846497,
-0.45750898122787476,
0.3745884299278259,
-0.5737366676330566,
0.12455881386995316,
-0.3216572105884552,
-0.18932926654815674,
0.10527407377958298,
0.012150523252785206,
0.17365653812885284,
0.09153681993484497,
-0.08054015040397644,
0.3566758334636688,
-0.69393390417099,
0.5783646702766418,
0.3375345766544342,
-0.6921799182891846,
-0.6300322413444519,
0.3402315080165863,
-0.01122416090220213,
-0.1913508027791977,
0.22282850742340088,
0.33708709478378296,
-0.1283167451620102,
-0.03396109864115715,
-0.2511352598667145,
-0.3799290955066681,
1.1941190958023071,
0.24985837936401367,
-0.47592052817344666,
-0.2906210124492645,
0.18223290145397186,
0.7210553288459778,
-0.06906004250049591,
0.4295268654823303,
0.6929385662078857,
0.5961090326309204,
0.1468265801668167,
-0.9186499714851379,
0.12211983650922775,
-0.4003673791885376,
0.10862444341182709,
0.18133315443992615,
-0.4235815405845642,
0.6987643241882324,
-0.4578183889389038,
-0.2863297462463379,
-0.1344427466392517,
0.8129170536994934,
0.15717780590057373,
0.5113850831985474,
0.2840350568294525,
0.471834272146225,
1.1312795877456665,
-0.2075902372598648,
1.0975825786590576,
-0.07747212797403336,
0.28475165367126465,
1.1235564947128296,
-0.28810399770736694,
0.18947814404964447,
0.6369918584823608,
0.07989737391471863,
0.22790201008319855,
0.6818881034851074,
-0.2231173813343048,
0.8427866697311401,
0.15066473186016083,
-0.31387338042259216,
0.1540030539035797,
0.11895495653152466,
-0.7182919383049011,
0.16020698845386505,
0.17340800166130066,
-0.5004256963729858,
-0.2893018424510956,
0.14341942965984344,
0.05893022567033768,
0.2953110635280609,
-0.21013176441192627,
1.1693605184555054,
0.07517822831869125,
-0.7036490440368652,
0.5209000706672668,
-0.18055741488933563,
0.7535290718078613,
-0.3172413110733032,
-0.12301451712846756,
-0.3126649558544159,
0.23708906769752502,
-0.31132015585899353,
-0.182048499584198,
0.8086760640144348,
0.0936564952135086,
-0.3260725736618042,
-0.12424857169389725,
0.5735489726066589,
-0.535250186920166,
-0.5793099403381348,
0.052103154361248016,
0.2195911407470703,
0.20251841843128204,
-0.41531258821487427,
-0.16207914054393768,
-0.15805689990520477,
0.06901609897613525,
-0.29908543825149536,
0.10381288826465607,
0.6462640166282654,
-0.0075400955975055695,
0.30437323451042175,
0.5193398594856262,
0.3460027873516083,
-0.253016859292984,
0.22525647282600403,
0.9421982765197754,
-0.911977231502533,
-0.776152491569519,
-1.2690964937210083,
0.488815039396286,
-0.4614684283733368,
-0.2500564157962799,
0.826937735080719,
0.842689037322998,
0.5949978828430176,
-0.3090497553348541,
1.2018060684204102,
0.0331932008266449,
0.31885698437690735,
-0.72543865442276,
1.1329987049102783,
-0.37147560715675354,
0.2379593551158905,
-0.5386568903923035,
-1.1472270488739014,
-0.3202688992023468,
0.7900577783584595,
-0.12776347994804382,
0.20179657638072968,
1.1128331422805786,
0.8487893342971802,
0.1835518628358841,
0.27441027760505676,
0.2003934681415558,
0.12641195952892303,
0.38539013266563416,
0.37480124831199646,
0.8352588415145874,
-0.5427056550979614,
0.39090877771377563,
-0.34621530771255493,
-0.2274360954761505,
-0.1318943202495575,
-0.7596146464347839,
-1.3292232751846313,
-0.5071601867675781,
-0.45120030641555786,
-0.4667850136756897,
0.11117716878652573,
0.6611177921295166,
0.342468798160553,
-0.8386284708976746,
-0.08471393585205078,
-0.17121627926826477,
-0.07140323519706726,
-0.38943448662757874,
-0.3143647015094757,
0.5249648094177246,
-0.4661341607570648,
-0.8730586171150208,
-0.029809262603521347,
0.38461917638778687,
0.5409284830093384,
-0.15690189599990845,
0.14015372097492218,
0.2739507257938385,
-0.0898672491312027,
0.5960595011711121,
-0.48035308718681335,
-0.6110918521881104,
-0.19622604548931122,
0.00113209942355752,
-0.0002150698855984956,
0.13411974906921387,
0.9207828044891357,
-0.6101676225662231,
0.26019537448883057,
0.4297885000705719,
0.34287676215171814,
0.7052245140075684,
0.1942846179008484,
0.8205254673957825,
-0.36825165152549744,
0.297987699508667,
0.3745346665382385,
0.018853891640901566,
0.13663871586322784,
-0.7869520783424377,
0.5788414478302002,
0.27170300483703613,
-0.43173494935035706,
-0.8589593172073364,
-0.2385873794555664,
-1.0256696939468384,
-0.30420640110969543,
0.7891690135002136,
0.25689178705215454,
0.05333835631608963,
-0.29811009764671326,
-0.5447019338607788,
0.2441750019788742,
-0.5233351588249207,
1.637774109840393,
0.8242846131324768,
-0.244686096906662,
-0.06894785910844803,
-0.42131736874580383,
0.9739990234375,
0.25800901651382446,
-1.04761803150177,
0.17715996503829956,
0.6129610538482666,
-0.03518766537308693,
0.22081100940704346,
0.66559237241745,
-0.2820991277694702,
0.1445349007844925,
0.24721457064151764,
-0.0782623142004013,
-0.29339146614074707,
-0.536864161491394,
-0.2957504689693451,
0.45857176184654236,
-0.3128952383995056,
-0.007346487604081631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03998v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03998v2
|
Sketch Then Generate: Providing Incremental User Feedback and Guiding LLM Code Generation through Language-Oriented Code Sketches
| 2024-05-07T04:21:07 | 2024-05-10T22:11:24 |
Chen Zhu-Tian, Zeyu Xiong, Xiaoshuo Yao, Elena Glassman
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Crafting effective prompts for code generation or editing with Large Language
Models (LLMs) is not an easy task. Particularly, the absence of immediate,
stable feedback during prompt crafting hinders effective interaction, as users
are left to mentally imagine possible outcomes until the code is generated. In
response, we introduce Language-Oriented Code Sketching, an interactive
approach that provides instant, incremental feedback in the form of code
sketches (i.e., incomplete code outlines) during prompt crafting. This approach
converts a prompt into a code sketch by leveraging the inherent linguistic
structures within the prompt and applying classic natural language processing
techniques. The sketch then serves as an intermediate placeholder that not only
previews the intended code structure but also guides the LLM towards the
desired code, thereby enhancing human-LLM interaction. We conclude by
discussing the approach's applicability and future plans.
|
[
-0.32514530420303345,
-0.7580049633979797,
0.6309139132499695,
0.7915092706680298,
-0.14860965311527252,
0.4689035415649414,
-0.11467432230710983,
-0.4987087845802307,
0.6082814931869507,
0.5885872840881348,
-0.6958454251289368,
-0.4778663218021393,
0.016563020646572113,
0.1260543167591095,
-0.3067229390144348,
0.7823446393013,
-0.10934541374444962,
-0.09556831419467926,
-0.14335507154464722,
0.2577532231807709,
-0.48001572489738464,
-0.6360975503921509,
-1.0619298219680786,
-0.29124048352241516,
0.5794761776924133,
0.57069331407547,
0.5508199334144592,
0.49089646339416504,
0.12594428658485413,
0.33214280009269714,
0.04513152688741684,
0.03686489537358284,
-0.28358232975006104,
0.1543189287185669,
0.19589881598949432,
-0.5731344819068909,
-0.527140200138092,
-0.011522123590111732,
0.16985540091991425,
0.7225348353385925,
-0.03852434828877449,
0.006361463572829962,
-0.05387801304459572,
0.5856642723083496,
-0.08491458743810654,
0.1964040845632553,
-0.46924203634262085,
0.14451925456523895,
-0.29043200612068176,
-0.5637906193733215,
-0.45292556285858154,
-0.7818881273269653,
-0.23362553119659424,
-0.37922894954681396,
0.08395759761333466,
-0.08216603845357895,
0.45683273673057556,
-0.11863793432712555,
0.07144467532634735,
-0.5500873923301697,
-0.5187487006187439,
0.33298712968826294,
-0.838574230670929,
-0.1755642145872116,
0.19427476823329926,
0.22640414535999298,
-0.45760205388069153,
-0.9983649849891663,
-0.8381189107894897,
-0.5628839731216431,
0.04630954936146736,
0.031055886298418045,
0.4036896526813507,
0.19915030896663666,
0.49389779567718506,
0.15686757862567902,
-0.20515020191669464,
0.006328709423542023,
-0.22380441427230835,
-0.23135235905647278,
0.7615011930465698,
0.24258272349834442,
0.7647905945777893,
-0.20365606248378754,
-0.38551804423332214,
0.18939447402954102,
-1.1828783750534058,
0.4183712601661682,
0.7157799005508423,
0.3179713189601898,
-0.1726737767457962,
0.821034848690033,
-0.08911930024623871,
0.6410250067710876,
0.10628723353147507,
-0.1906764954328537,
-0.0014083490241318941,
-0.27683037519454956,
0.052318453788757324,
0.04619007930159569,
0.5111053586006165,
0.4399023652076721,
0.20701061189174652,
0.13783293962478638,
-0.3612199127674103,
-0.1542021781206131,
0.2880506217479706,
-0.5943359136581421,
-0.49248674511909485,
0.2787967324256897,
-0.5837403535842896,
-0.5386741161346436,
0.1846279352903366,
-0.6216074824333191,
-0.4989953637123108,
-0.4745256006717682,
0.10401850193738937,
-0.0548015721142292,
-0.24886201322078705,
-0.07204664498567581,
-0.2830595076084137,
0.17501290142536163,
0.7181857824325562,
-0.7759603261947632,
0.0308772474527359,
0.44290927052497864,
0.8014035224914551,
-0.18818168342113495,
-0.25836387276649475,
-0.705755889415741,
0.12551456689834595,
-0.4957959055900574,
0.8081983327865601,
-0.5675010681152344,
-0.7374738454818726,
0.0951949954032898,
-0.11811134219169617,
0.3349860906600952,
-0.5769670605659485,
0.15227635204792023,
-0.47022268176078796,
0.05396006628870964,
-0.10884727537631989,
-0.34943318367004395,
0.23367345333099365,
0.05800989642739296,
-0.6651992201805115,
1.2336246967315674,
0.3297947347164154,
-0.5958571434020996,
0.2741566300392151,
-0.741255521774292,
-0.31345877051353455,
0.5077047348022461,
-0.5642417669296265,
-0.10413999855518341,
0.2288290560245514,
0.04187231883406639,
0.40363261103630066,
0.11519928276538849,
0.264422208070755,
-0.36182329058647156,
-0.32968735694885254,
0.3407221734523773,
0.027970287948846817,
0.7768721580505371,
0.2946806848049164,
-0.41763949394226074,
0.458237886428833,
-0.690068781375885,
0.32653194665908813,
0.20669712126255035,
-0.5992401838302612,
0.10675594955682755,
-0.026235409080982208,
0.2600522041320801,
0.2901325821876526,
0.12215666472911835,
-0.36359819769859314,
0.5982142686843872,
-0.44408389925956726,
0.43297967314720154,
0.841003954410553,
0.0636008158326149,
0.4173413813114166,
-0.4267711043357849,
0.8467136025428772,
-0.3728456497192383,
-0.174747496843338,
-0.6930385828018188,
-0.5928637385368347,
-0.8685598373413086,
-0.0836392194032669,
0.01913508214056492,
0.45489129424095154,
-1.280821681022644,
0.27782130241394043,
0.06611756235361099,
-0.3237112760543823,
-0.35689982771873474,
0.42351192235946655,
0.44841185212135315,
0.163793683052063,
-0.170084610581398,
-0.5575314164161682,
-0.5671984553337097,
-0.4916854500770569,
-0.3093373775482178,
-0.41444990038871765,
-0.15417036414146423,
-0.06541638821363449,
0.11941046267747879,
-0.04637949541211128,
0.9671706557273865,
-0.27837833762168884,
0.08469667285680771,
-0.8806320428848267,
0.18403925001621246,
0.11421903222799301,
0.5822860598564148,
0.5527577996253967,
-0.41035088896751404,
-0.8150033950805664,
0.07000329345464706,
-0.5638395547866821,
-0.4603535830974579,
-0.34005165100097656,
-0.06678555905818939,
0.35085996985435486,
0.9163937568664551,
-0.47218751907348633,
0.5846229195594788,
0.2981795072555542,
-0.2584393620491028,
0.5594073534011841,
-0.17464762926101685,
0.051512978971004486,
-0.8066627383232117,
0.17194481194019318,
-0.44100427627563477,
-0.3232651948928833,
-0.5572429299354553,
0.26081979274749756,
-0.09347259998321533,
-0.5396866798400879,
-0.33058345317840576,
0.8829185962677002,
-0.6804661154747009,
0.016052350401878357,
-0.5688329339027405,
0.003983934409916401,
0.034384626895189285,
0.502196729183197,
0.19274768233299255,
0.825526237487793,
0.2502354383468628,
-0.3891284167766571,
0.24595926702022552,
-0.19796209037303925,
-0.4026735723018646,
0.38041311502456665,
-0.6773756146430969,
0.5459945797920227,
0.09922008961439133,
0.15417692065238953,
-1.0759646892547607,
-0.4165225923061371,
0.14177660644054413,
-0.4367140233516693,
0.473057359457016,
-0.1772909015417099,
-0.5512829422950745,
-0.5262858867645264,
-0.7230377793312073,
0.17317309975624084,
0.5525997281074524,
-0.5754231810569763,
0.4128667414188385,
0.38017958402633667,
-0.7848696112632751,
-0.17990908026695251,
-0.3185257315635681,
0.26941579580307007,
0.04877869039773941,
-0.7571755647659302,
0.1729145348072052,
-0.37143173813819885,
-0.39218801259994507,
-0.19356347620487213,
0.09181991219520569,
0.04468485713005066,
0.005521755665540695,
0.2639303505420685,
0.2839803993701935,
-0.04339710250496864,
-0.14505477249622345,
0.08161742240190506,
-0.3668646216392517,
0.1484062224626541,
-0.10591690987348557,
0.6905691623687744,
0.2296372950077057,
-0.6410858631134033,
-0.3675336241722107,
0.49774169921875,
0.3530220687389374,
0.1014612466096878,
0.04640968516469002,
0.3520420789718628,
-0.2053084820508957,
-0.399209588766098,
-0.5400123000144958,
0.051063090562820435,
-0.553912878036499,
0.15541483461856842,
-0.5384136438369751,
-0.8180744647979736,
0.5616647005081177,
-0.34820935130119324,
0.25296708941459656,
0.04251242056488991,
0.7329537272453308,
-0.2310868352651596,
0.9525262117385864,
1.150720477104187,
0.22470854222774506,
0.7033137083053589,
-0.15488754212856293,
0.348894327878952,
-0.5906348824501038,
-0.3553917407989502,
-0.4979391098022461,
-0.18881943821907043,
-0.14600326120853424,
-0.5406522750854492,
0.14650869369506836,
0.44026440382003784,
0.13793985545635223,
0.11941759288311005,
-0.3403421938419342,
0.7680659890174866,
0.6418523192405701,
0.06099742650985718,
0.17571833729743958,
0.02437196671962738,
-0.2453881949186325,
-0.10772688686847687,
-0.633608877658844,
-0.684059202671051,
0.8035561442375183,
0.1826486587524414,
0.9009596109390259,
-0.22235307097434998,
0.8026626110076904,
0.34260815382003784,
0.6254709362983704,
-0.7235486507415771,
0.7132591605186462,
0.3557640612125397,
-0.12920595705509186,
-0.24545136094093323,
-0.1614150106906891,
-0.6042680740356445,
-0.10869105905294418,
0.10119058191776276,
-0.6270808577537537,
-0.03812281787395477,
0.33370429277420044,
-0.20426134765148163,
0.28384438157081604,
-0.9095338582992554,
0.6584494709968567,
-0.17451362311840057,
-0.31574228405952454,
0.0815415158867836,
-0.6451323628425598,
0.15772545337677002,
0.044596415013074875,
0.23141202330589294,
0.0067438650876283646,
0.01830677129328251,
0.2788969874382019,
-0.8722400069236755,
1.0604934692382812,
-0.48539578914642334,
-0.35557371377944946,
0.6177582144737244,
0.4189485013484955,
0.5192102789878845,
0.12801574170589447,
-0.14070221781730652,
-0.21006177365779877,
-0.3768329918384552,
-0.27376940846443176,
-0.5836740732192993,
0.6524022817611694,
-0.5054349303245544,
-0.5993885397911072,
0.03445175290107727,
-0.4834047555923462,
-0.008382068946957588,
0.1404920369386673,
0.23471137881278992,
0.7061718702316284,
0.010649862699210644,
-0.40579211711883545,
0.2637138366699219,
-0.4390448331832886,
0.6885905265808105,
0.18986055254936218,
-0.6949040293693542,
-0.3843270540237427,
0.8118433356285095,
-0.26052218675613403,
0.33756932616233826,
0.1801004707813263,
-0.11525401473045349,
-0.2735234498977661,
-0.5131334662437439,
-0.655124843120575,
0.18119779229164124,
-0.9936507940292358,
-0.1260605752468109,
-0.48798128962516785,
-0.219559907913208,
-0.1556471437215805,
-0.7879138588905334,
-0.10280372947454453,
-0.5881878137588501,
0.011711979284882545,
-0.06764869391918182,
0.415971964597702,
1.0690441131591797,
0.0751848816871643,
0.3564170300960541,
-0.6952127814292908,
0.2996863126754761,
0.24753673374652863,
0.4300977885723114,
0.10826398432254791,
-0.05781528353691101,
-0.21733734011650085,
-0.14214988052845,
-0.24352101981639862,
-0.6585888266563416,
0.38615307211875916,
-0.04776135832071304,
0.4914769232273102,
0.2160743772983551,
-0.2144256979227066,
0.8909980654716492,
-0.683790385723114,
1.0154716968536377,
0.4291895925998688,
-1.0625494718551636,
0.8216763138771057,
-0.2603367865085602,
0.3433896005153656,
0.40997061133384705,
0.007947786711156368,
-0.5791773796081543,
-0.81485915184021,
-0.34045669436454773,
-0.9511826038360596,
0.7601255178451538,
0.06746986508369446,
0.4030377268791199,
-0.2781972885131836,
0.6168825030326843,
0.22291751205921173,
0.3916984498500824,
-0.9367391467094421,
-0.24256157875061035,
-0.19335995614528656,
-0.06425097584724426,
0.22909891605377197,
-0.3731469511985779,
-0.02336524799466133,
-0.20154668390750885,
0.347316175699234,
-0.3242782652378082,
0.3998810648918152,
0.15285181999206543,
-0.04014258086681366,
-0.34142082929611206,
0.18162865936756134,
0.5582106709480286,
0.9238379001617432,
0.08367152512073517,
0.04904526472091675,
-0.2092389315366745,
-0.47640517354011536,
0.11956040561199188,
-0.22970253229141235,
-0.21504467725753784,
0.09665900468826294,
0.31132930517196655,
0.6422386169433594,
0.09494572132825851,
-0.8371174931526184,
0.47387272119522095,
-0.06560219824314117,
-0.07108906656503677,
-0.3807298243045807,
0.23288016021251678,
0.12879382073879242,
0.12278075516223907,
0.28370359539985657,
0.0615122951567173,
-0.11954604089260101,
-0.6641578674316406,
0.1103450283408165,
0.27745765447616577,
-0.17520155012607574,
-0.5391692519187927,
0.8510844707489014,
0.5384021401405334,
-0.6858792901039124,
0.5022227168083191,
-0.34730565547943115,
-0.4832734763622284,
0.8414728045463562,
0.7288867235183716,
1.2216159105300903,
0.027291538193821907,
0.24998250603675842,
0.29246070981025696,
0.09324073791503906,
0.13087542355060577,
0.7474462985992432,
-0.25301307439804077,
-0.33454835414886475,
-0.7988198399543762,
-0.4226597547531128,
-0.48878318071365356,
-0.1366458684206009,
-0.45407548546791077,
0.6679003238677979,
-0.5925851464271545,
0.07087011635303497,
-0.3278948664665222,
-0.21341443061828613,
-0.46359166502952576,
-0.18412914872169495,
0.13765427470207214,
1.012173056602478,
-0.42245423793792725,
0.9932094812393188,
1.0657830238342285,
-0.510664165019989,
-0.9526293277740479,
0.14715728163719177,
0.08619273453950882,
-0.89821857213974,
0.8557409048080444,
0.43262979388237,
-0.18687236309051514,
0.0837293490767479,
-0.7708228826522827,
-0.5417348742485046,
0.9293966889381409,
0.3914141356945038,
-0.27898260951042175,
0.02577759139239788,
0.005435193423181772,
0.5005333423614502,
-0.3464512526988983,
0.2951940596103668,
0.14854060113430023,
0.22990170121192932,
0.3171968162059784,
-0.9240158200263977,
0.13636808097362518,
-0.8158413171768188,
0.38676556944847107,
0.2040388286113739,
-0.3511979281902313,
0.8041611909866333,
-0.4885180592536926,
-0.4134710133075714,
0.42070502042770386,
0.5528871417045593,
0.3381841480731964,
0.22031748294830322,
0.44902026653289795,
0.35981783270835876,
0.5305724740028381,
-0.009590886533260345,
1.1730380058288574,
-0.48307526111602783,
-0.10516970604658127,
1.0143040418624878,
-0.4494519531726837,
0.689816951751709,
0.5713319182395935,
-0.24657250940799713,
0.5948873162269592,
0.47686949372291565,
0.4707825183868408,
0.3523520231246948,
0.3634715676307678,
-0.33539488911628723,
0.019504044204950333,
0.012714915908873081,
-0.43590274453163147,
-0.05628499388694763,
0.24234166741371155,
0.17039087414741516,
-0.12721508741378784,
-0.09378677606582642,
0.10423652827739716,
0.19936013221740723,
-0.36684176325798035,
0.9407617449760437,
0.13293427228927612,
-0.5778748393058777,
0.28791022300720215,
0.10079806298017502,
0.6065049171447754,
-0.8277649879455566,
-0.5330570340156555,
-0.5081656575202942,
-0.18262915313243866,
-0.35494738817214966,
-0.8841517567634583,
0.36908602714538574,
0.19179190695285797,
-0.1200760155916214,
-0.6014435291290283,
0.76405930519104,
-0.5213436484336853,
-0.16843503713607788,
0.13897064328193665,
0.6250145435333252,
0.16419857740402222,
0.1446070522069931,
-0.5394026637077332,
0.22473353147506714,
0.1630346179008484,
-0.3536567986011505,
0.35316574573516846,
0.7326783537864685,
-0.08665386587381363,
0.7373267412185669,
0.907795250415802,
0.3111916184425354,
0.21109607815742493,
0.3730315864086151,
1.0490670204162598,
-0.8119451999664307,
-0.7465357184410095,
-0.7819811701774597,
0.7968970537185669,
-0.008658196777105331,
-0.04302491992712021,
0.7585458755493164,
0.29790619015693665,
1.0342319011688232,
-0.3439118266105652,
0.9354341626167297,
-0.45972740650177,
0.3135419487953186,
-0.8232388496398926,
0.620731770992279,
-0.2953791320323944,
0.5606301426887512,
-0.3766801357269287,
-0.9736139178276062,
-0.3776434659957886,
0.6292436718940735,
0.12451403588056564,
0.08768077939748764,
0.6721883416175842,
0.7586140632629395,
0.24056388437747955,
-0.21273909509181976,
0.11272844672203064,
-0.17662398517131805,
0.5164124965667725,
0.180380180478096,
1.198489785194397,
0.1873815804719925,
0.274687796831131,
-0.42179763317108154,
-0.14960496127605438,
-0.06302793323993683,
-1.070164680480957,
-1.039035677909851,
-0.31930312514305115,
-0.20549210906028748,
-0.3781944215297699,
-0.3604094088077545,
1.211013674736023,
0.5113846659660339,
-0.6432445049285889,
-0.668168842792511,
-0.39333924651145935,
0.17514847218990326,
0.013055657967925072,
-0.3365311324596405,
0.2339463084936142,
-0.837806224822998,
-0.7335646748542786,
0.19623318314552307,
0.6726328134536743,
0.12948474287986755,
-0.4755092263221741,
-0.2078632265329361,
0.35367709398269653,
-0.07936616241931915,
0.8334464430809021,
0.4015462398529053,
-0.6850008964538574,
-0.13777905702590942,
-0.07114878296852112,
-0.043353863060474396,
0.15537312626838684,
1.4052890539169312,
-0.6845586895942688,
0.8138045072555542,
0.3841038644313812,
0.5998547673225403,
0.13197769224643707,
0.004784389864653349,
0.8484451174736023,
-1.02315092086792,
0.5071064829826355,
0.07648561149835587,
0.2528563141822815,
0.21758727729320526,
-0.3354058265686035,
0.4933067560195923,
0.08247053623199463,
-0.3626219928264618,
-0.8516153693199158,
0.2973763942718506,
-0.9189403057098389,
-0.07298462837934494,
0.9553653001785278,
-0.2460828423500061,
0.00229984731413424,
-0.3699702322483063,
-0.8577015399932861,
-0.2477695196866989,
-0.38125696778297424,
0.7582735419273376,
0.5417723655700684,
-0.43222588300704956,
-0.14070622622966766,
-0.4763046205043793,
0.727501630783081,
0.0232553668320179,
-1.1460669040679932,
0.012588749639689922,
0.5040979981422424,
0.01814289577305317,
0.09539750963449478,
1.429870843887329,
-0.20553545653820038,
0.4174615144729614,
0.07412659376859665,
0.4688744843006134,
-0.05307069048285484,
-0.46276360750198364,
-0.33288031816482544,
0.0760870948433876,
0.7096006870269775,
0.36235514283180237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03960v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03960v1
|
ESIHGNN: Event-State Interactions Infused Heterogeneous Graph Neural Network for Conversational Emotion Recognition
| 2024-05-07T02:46:11 | 2024-05-07T02:46:11 |
Xupeng Zha, Huan Zhao, Zixing Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Conversational Emotion Recognition (CER) aims to predict the emotion
expressed by an utterance (referred to as an ``event'') during a conversation.
Existing graph-based methods mainly focus on event interactions to comprehend
the conversational context, while overlooking the direct influence of the
speaker's emotional state on the events. In addition, real-time modeling of the
conversation is crucial for real-world applications but is rarely considered.
Toward this end, we propose a novel graph-based approach, namely Event-State
Interactions infused Heterogeneous Graph Neural Network (ESIHGNN), which
incorporates the speaker's emotional state and constructs a heterogeneous
event-state interaction graph to model the conversation. Specifically, a
heterogeneous directed acyclic graph neural network is employed to dynamically
update and enhance the representations of events and emotional states at each
turn, thereby improving conversational coherence and consistency. Furthermore,
to further improve the performance of CER, we enrich the graph's edges with
external knowledge. Experimental results on four publicly available CER
datasets show the superiority of our approach and the effectiveness of the
introduced heterogeneous event-state interaction graph.
|
[
-0.4049004316329956,
-1.0040191411972046,
0.3834259808063507,
0.14642424881458282,
-0.19778484106063843,
0.20525316894054413,
-0.33383598923683167,
-0.6744704246520996,
0.6254698038101196,
-0.10097698867321014,
-0.5712525844573975,
-0.4995262622833252,
-0.34631747007369995,
0.03477858006954193,
-0.050962064415216446,
0.6959023475646973,
0.04591616988182068,
-0.15600383281707764,
-0.14748239517211914,
-0.24043859541416168,
-0.010732118040323257,
-0.6268091201782227,
-0.6913842558860779,
-0.7623159885406494,
0.5825390815734863,
0.2530929446220398,
0.44759589433670044,
0.24031226336956024,
0.006743485573679209,
0.39761805534362793,
-0.3551674485206604,
0.1818085014820099,
-0.6545705795288086,
0.13872110843658447,
0.42133188247680664,
-0.01990470103919506,
-0.34290167689323425,
-0.24350057542324066,
0.3571840226650238,
0.33709970116615295,
-0.37354978919029236,
-0.3376481831073761,
0.07643674314022064,
0.1977473795413971,
-0.675544261932373,
0.5976279377937317,
-0.4984966814517975,
0.7339493632316589,
0.09970446676015854,
-0.14096076786518097,
-0.402960866689682,
-0.5525235533714294,
0.24568694829940796,
-0.4459877610206604,
-0.029651368036866188,
-0.11878474801778793,
0.8850038051605225,
-0.03859345614910126,
-0.5336030125617981,
-0.05982711911201477,
-0.7071648240089417,
0.1942490041255951,
-0.6173615455627441,
0.59321528673172,
0.054845888167619705,
0.12365788221359253,
0.07267846167087555,
-0.7264556884765625,
-0.8058386445045471,
-0.08778946101665497,
-0.057956546545028687,
0.4728514850139618,
-0.617183268070221,
0.4323039650917053,
0.2301803082227707,
0.054053355008363724,
-0.3098151981830597,
0.01833723857998848,
-0.00076440314296633,
-0.37398260831832886,
0.42951637506484985,
0.465364009141922,
0.4716789722442627,
-0.2861703932285309,
-0.18508988618850708,
0.0021315282210707664,
-0.25731170177459717,
-0.0014085572911426425,
0.41069740056991577,
0.47732678055763245,
-0.2224019467830658,
0.45663678646087646,
-0.35288071632385254,
0.37451109290122986,
0.34849104285240173,
0.1832417994737625,
0.34121426939964294,
0.1252235621213913,
-0.14269766211509705,
0.6317801475524902,
0.9123820662498474,
0.5192425847053528,
0.005147815216332674,
0.004550442565232515,
0.27870437502861023,
0.3489493429660797,
-0.049043744802474976,
-0.980624794960022,
-0.39990073442459106,
0.25964680314064026,
-0.2101893126964569,
-0.25379258394241333,
-0.2649945318698883,
-1.0287383794784546,
-0.5002544522285461,
-0.2290896326303482,
0.016252294182777405,
-0.31084102392196655,
-0.3499044179916382,
-0.22646284103393555,
-0.0689215287566185,
-0.08152888715267181,
0.5156097412109375,
-0.5317977070808411,
0.43774351477622986,
0.5334510207176208,
0.7532347440719604,
0.12778054177761078,
-0.14244794845581055,
-0.49997442960739136,
0.0078642088919878,
0.03145173192024231,
0.572585940361023,
-0.6815745234489441,
-0.5629498362541199,
0.2848675549030304,
0.03186369687318802,
-0.094698466360569,
-0.1105000302195549,
0.33832740783691406,
-0.5023267269134521,
0.06070474162697792,
-0.12232955545186996,
-0.5931248664855957,
-0.13299082219600677,
0.47504985332489014,
-0.5698198080062866,
0.8560616970062256,
-0.3788716793060303,
-0.8651672601699829,
-0.1652841418981552,
-0.7317336201667786,
-0.6163144111633301,
0.25101345777511597,
-0.3106253445148468,
-0.5055420994758606,
-0.004859486129134893,
0.049067795276641846,
0.3880947530269623,
0.32637152075767517,
0.008244109340012074,
-0.6439226269721985,
-0.23426364362239838,
0.308097243309021,
-0.4865061938762665,
0.26060548424720764,
0.29542484879493713,
-0.24615688621997833,
0.01600300520658493,
-0.8456307053565979,
0.14023511111736298,
0.054725538939237595,
-0.3198859989643097,
-0.13869012892246246,
0.024104109033942223,
0.2063024938106537,
0.17943075299263,
0.17220020294189453,
-0.9606866240501404,
-0.35894501209259033,
-0.2856127619743347,
0.3955889344215393,
0.6126090288162231,
0.11785365641117096,
0.26558512449264526,
0.2966347336769104,
0.2853226959705353,
0.057076092809438705,
0.029439222067594528,
-0.01564563252031803,
-0.5148545503616333,
-0.7587666511535645,
0.10475010424852371,
-0.16667529940605164,
0.6813923716545105,
-0.4203979969024658,
0.36987483501434326,
-0.18735986948013306,
-0.5382316708564758,
-0.18925900757312775,
-0.5291135311126709,
0.4272741675376892,
0.8877502679824829,
0.19996201992034912,
-0.11229893565177917,
-0.5750240683555603,
-0.44098085165023804,
-0.24520666897296906,
-0.25486382842063904,
0.36315426230430603,
0.9116312265396118,
0.04347687214612961,
-0.22910580039024353,
0.7329097390174866,
-0.6521410942077637,
0.04632063955068588,
-0.14348898828029633,
0.5352859497070312,
-0.06117498129606247,
0.3847837448120117,
0.0023400539066642523,
-0.792783260345459,
-0.6712357997894287,
0.4746451675891876,
-0.6830762028694153,
-0.05301865562796593,
0.19575661420822144,
0.1603260189294815,
0.283744215965271,
0.45715826749801636,
-0.1853783279657364,
0.729760468006134,
0.5721855759620667,
-0.41677403450012207,
0.10310875624418259,
-0.29073137044906616,
0.24527597427368164,
-0.78402179479599,
-0.2585862874984741,
0.07639244943857193,
-0.19938123226165771,
-0.8499855995178223,
-0.6702216863632202,
0.08248904347419739,
-0.6644100546836853,
-0.6149803996086121,
0.3622877299785614,
-0.3317004144191742,
-0.20978564023971558,
-0.1675553023815155,
0.22947868704795837,
0.10479362308979034,
0.8111750483512878,
0.2929809093475342,
0.050787217915058136,
0.25170090794563293,
-0.4378640651702881,
0.7312527894973755,
0.5283050537109375,
-0.03792750835418701,
0.940762996673584,
-0.592128336429596,
0.5069634318351746,
-0.1563185453414917,
0.5488787293434143,
-0.9072322845458984,
-0.1226004883646965,
0.2492881715297699,
-0.3312569856643677,
0.2179611176252365,
-0.30940407514572144,
-0.05358453094959259,
-0.3231161832809448,
0.2338714599609375,
0.2693694531917572,
0.33013680577278137,
-0.5556926131248474,
1.5092445611953735,
0.1356942355632782,
-0.4169692397117615,
-0.3729967772960663,
-0.7479480504989624,
0.18962247669696808,
0.008498424664139748,
-0.6607663035392761,
0.31173285841941833,
0.04153714329004288,
0.16087494790554047,
0.2707546353340149,
0.11132551729679108,
0.21436256170272827,
-0.08367549628019333,
0.6176632642745972,
0.28737330436706543,
0.016161682084202766,
0.10221634060144424,
0.12882331013679504,
-0.14094248414039612,
0.05865515395998955,
0.2288222759962082,
0.6711354851722717,
-0.39104190468788147,
-0.4841976761817932,
-1.079475998878479,
0.3883616328239441,
0.3369690477848053,
-0.31059300899505615,
0.46472734212875366,
0.7110637426376343,
-0.588027834892273,
0.14586606621742249,
-0.2718328535556793,
-0.15623582899570465,
-0.45062002539634705,
0.8218693733215332,
-0.551479160785675,
-0.7834649682044983,
0.7421164512634277,
-0.441380113363266,
-0.49995023012161255,
0.1965080201625824,
0.52116858959198,
-0.18881744146347046,
1.3753358125686646,
0.1892184615135193,
-0.09544623643159866,
0.9065970778465271,
-0.04833404719829559,
0.4033218324184418,
-1.010055422782898,
-0.4788856506347656,
-0.34771856665611267,
-0.44716715812683105,
-0.5572677850723267,
-0.10972508043050766,
0.42812758684158325,
-0.466460645198822,
-0.460473895072937,
0.07852896302938461,
-0.20870646834373474,
0.40225109457969666,
0.001344954245723784,
0.3638702929019928,
0.07364938408136368,
-0.041305482387542725,
-0.04146425426006317,
-0.053625572472810745,
-0.7970907688140869,
0.022968770936131477,
0.39653927087783813,
0.3737812936306,
0.6981260776519775,
-0.10770077258348465,
0.7245633006095886,
0.144336998462677,
0.34504833817481995,
-0.7601771354675293,
0.6049765944480896,
0.01187941711395979,
-0.20121824741363525,
-0.27306434512138367,
-0.6810892224311829,
-0.7315497398376465,
0.18540821969509125,
-0.4331552982330322,
-1.3103865385055542,
0.48829352855682373,
0.14731758832931519,
-0.24844741821289062,
0.39662015438079834,
-0.626393735408783,
0.7859082221984863,
-0.11662779748439789,
-0.18896658718585968,
-0.16714909672737122,
-0.6569699048995972,
-0.22168371081352234,
0.5007081031799316,
0.04395919293165207,
-0.3021329641342163,
0.4757206439971924,
0.6804352402687073,
-0.5226343870162964,
0.9303353428840637,
-0.30450955033302307,
0.05052986368536949,
0.31855812668800354,
0.07311011850833893,
1.1536121368408203,
-0.07701339572668076,
-0.23978006839752197,
0.07426613569259644,
-0.29572948813438416,
-0.08887781947851181,
-0.6781728863716125,
0.6883600354194641,
-0.8199906349182129,
-0.07781952619552612,
-0.22710005939006805,
-0.4835664629936218,
-0.3913361430168152,
-0.020480962470173836,
0.3463330864906311,
0.8763304352760315,
-0.8622650504112244,
-0.07879512757062912,
0.5445554256439209,
-0.22960878908634186,
0.2654329240322113,
0.27576637268066406,
-0.10574188828468323,
-0.6778481006622314,
1.0239408016204834,
0.08608519285917282,
0.24375629425048828,
0.17047877609729767,
0.24816389381885529,
-0.22624225914478302,
0.07233817875385284,
-0.26252949237823486,
0.02406151033937931,
-0.9019899368286133,
-0.1559910625219345,
-1.1034138202667236,
-0.06715936958789825,
-0.2715452313423157,
-0.2353777289390564,
-0.4616377651691437,
-0.18147048354148865,
-0.399248331785202,
-0.3857194781303406,
0.6543141603469849,
0.46001338958740234,
-0.14515471458435059,
0.28744545578956604,
-0.7729081511497498,
0.0719427615404129,
0.5444493293762207,
0.377248078584671,
0.09189774841070175,
-0.1462153196334839,
-0.12267530709505081,
0.13848327100276947,
-0.014897515065968037,
-0.934342086315155,
0.2869078516960144,
0.4976317584514618,
0.21723322570323944,
0.614763617515564,
0.20194494724273682,
0.6859678626060486,
-0.4788336455821991,
0.47535240650177,
0.6221888065338135,
-1.1456674337387085,
0.4863872528076172,
-0.1811843365430832,
0.16932357847690582,
0.29617658257484436,
0.24079720675945282,
-1.0794647932052612,
-0.1496274471282959,
-0.8091546893119812,
-0.8661004304885864,
0.8400652408599854,
0.04565318301320076,
0.3857501447200775,
0.08090545982122421,
-0.006981468293815851,
-0.5046777129173279,
0.0857849046587944,
-0.3523653447628021,
-0.23258435726165771,
-0.500770092010498,
-0.6499186158180237,
0.1935703307390213,
-0.015132460743188858,
-0.3408089578151703,
-0.07627338171005249,
0.48371320962905884,
-0.42341411113739014,
0.5687951445579529,
0.19866575300693512,
0.16117636859416962,
-0.23336973786354065,
0.1996421366930008,
0.13557282090187073,
-0.16220301389694214,
-0.38818421959877014,
0.2452664077281952,
0.6141874194145203,
-0.4177378714084625,
-0.09977062046527863,
0.6503443121910095,
0.19381152093410492,
-0.03668932244181633,
-0.09979448467493057,
1.3738799095153809,
0.1661398559808731,
-0.35606446862220764,
0.4314687252044678,
-0.3190719187259674,
0.08022564649581909,
-0.015935199335217476,
-0.2258186787366867,
0.18658103048801422,
0.5775233507156372,
0.018715640529990196,
-0.13619869947433472,
0.26448169350624084,
-0.7831458449363708,
0.03491543233394623,
0.026115000247955322,
-1.0231566429138184,
-0.3442972004413605,
0.33720171451568604,
0.5198005437850952,
-0.4815751314163208,
0.7497531771659851,
-0.24663305282592773,
-1.1689051389694214,
0.7285885810852051,
0.8577995300292969,
0.6962670087814331,
-0.25046151876449585,
0.3054465651512146,
0.38942694664001465,
-0.4364064037799835,
0.3784533739089966,
0.6741401553153992,
-0.05236266553401947,
-1.026871919631958,
0.0679699033498764,
-0.2370784729719162,
-0.7538119554519653,
-0.39144638180732727,
-0.5910921692848206,
-0.10719527304172516,
-0.32113322615623474,
-0.2726714015007019,
-0.1415795534849167,
-0.059522613883018494,
-0.6425293684005737,
0.5098899602890015,
0.5992166996002197,
0.34501758217811584,
-0.9067538380622864,
0.3037880063056946,
0.4144100248813629,
-0.13904079794883728,
-0.9275931715965271,
-0.37733176350593567,
0.23020385205745697,
-0.5340304374694824,
0.2796262502670288,
0.036006003618240356,
-0.27827611565589905,
0.1777985394001007,
-0.2768474519252777,
-0.40949463844299316,
1.016120433807373,
0.0933547094464302,
-0.6249778866767883,
0.344015508890152,
0.08177616447210312,
0.5915612578392029,
-0.40648242831230164,
0.33502763509750366,
0.14691950380802155,
0.34561946988105774,
0.42051365971565247,
-0.4238823652267456,
0.041657704859972,
-0.6105477213859558,
0.11460119485855103,
0.46937912702560425,
-0.697096586227417,
0.5896632671356201,
-0.09796983003616333,
-0.4923528730869293,
-0.26235175132751465,
1.034751534461975,
0.23353944718837738,
0.7695543169975281,
0.5668370723724365,
0.666563868522644,
1.1963659524917603,
-0.4447309672832489,
0.9129681587219238,
-0.3393077254295349,
0.4000851809978485,
1.1558774709701538,
-0.7218613028526306,
0.8429303765296936,
0.14790749549865723,
-0.17994818091392517,
0.7760947942733765,
0.5657253861427307,
0.14817467331886292,
0.31883034110069275,
0.28965359926223755,
-0.6304407715797424,
-0.1671653538942337,
-0.510104238986969,
-0.3246217966079712,
0.19273196160793304,
0.40465909242630005,
0.0646626204252243,
0.025245746597647667,
0.3266022205352783,
0.2832072973251343,
-0.1482682079076767,
-0.3269593417644501,
0.9570002555847168,
0.0016599639784544706,
-0.054002899676561356,
0.10962538421154022,
-0.3581814467906952,
0.5114501118659973,
-0.452886700630188,
0.0081911226734519,
-0.06419126689434052,
-0.005655092187225819,
-0.4921456575393677,
-0.634638249874115,
0.13557349145412445,
0.19054725766181946,
0.32039400935173035,
0.23090629279613495,
1.0658515691757202,
-0.6070622801780701,
-0.3456093370914459,
0.46253451704978943,
0.23023927211761475,
0.06212291121482849,
-0.0647389143705368,
-0.4729273319244385,
0.3781154751777649,
-0.38074079155921936,
-0.3691176772117615,
0.128091499209404,
0.7773714065551758,
0.38102230429649353,
0.41092976927757263,
0.4523956775665283,
-0.1171988770365715,
-0.1845533847808838,
0.46905460953712463,
0.8389552235603333,
-0.5331476330757141,
-0.877128541469574,
-0.5816482305526733,
0.48858171701431274,
-0.2849639058113098,
-0.15914148092269897,
0.33584797382354736,
0.3451797366142273,
0.37823882699012756,
0.36824947595596313,
0.7394896745681763,
-0.0896436870098114,
-0.07176370918750763,
-0.20446039736270905,
0.6741007566452026,
-0.4246797561645508,
-0.33551475405693054,
-0.5500430464744568,
-0.40973880887031555,
-0.02135099656879902,
0.38358938694000244,
-0.4305979907512665,
-0.06403912603855133,
0.35659241676330566,
0.70272296667099,
-0.07701126486063004,
0.6210805177688599,
0.31622958183288574,
0.32240810990333557,
0.26843783259391785,
0.6588484644889832,
1.1990429162979126,
-0.3381761610507965,
0.5323927402496338,
-0.18468250334262848,
-0.04437527805566788,
-0.527750551700592,
-0.9571120142936707,
-0.3014926612377167,
-0.5680782198905945,
-0.6300582885742188,
-0.6603078842163086,
0.19803236424922943,
1.055294156074524,
0.5375064015388489,
-0.5544615983963013,
0.04812787473201752,
-0.1490803211927414,
-0.03311758115887642,
0.04620959237217903,
-0.20357604324817657,
0.2805776000022888,
0.043359071016311646,
-0.758469820022583,
0.34879446029663086,
0.30322712659835815,
0.13281774520874023,
0.4289616048336029,
-0.42015379667282104,
-0.10972393304109573,
0.3819650113582611,
0.4972628355026245,
0.44579043984413147,
-0.24644835293293,
-0.3534068465232849,
-0.27430063486099243,
-0.15233400464057922,
0.4280707836151123,
0.48719412088394165,
-0.45854246616363525,
0.6714039444923401,
0.487390398979187,
0.7071666717529297,
0.8498088717460632,
-0.07209963351488113,
0.4429066479206085,
-0.5942823886871338,
0.06776005029678345,
0.3100539743900299,
0.49334385991096497,
0.4339134395122528,
-0.650992214679718,
0.1681434065103531,
0.35779523849487305,
-0.38522234559059143,
-0.6047400236129761,
0.49561429023742676,
-1.2605801820755005,
0.08705157041549683,
0.9569889307022095,
-0.3358791470527649,
-0.3116620182991028,
0.04269098863005638,
-0.3504953682422638,
0.7272977232933044,
-0.7168538570404053,
0.38316938281059265,
0.3949849307537079,
-0.5376695990562439,
-0.1880638152360916,
0.18716762959957123,
0.22730432450771332,
0.07812872529029846,
-1.0950030088424683,
0.08005606383085251,
0.6149663329124451,
-0.027998002246022224,
0.25613662600517273,
0.6685542464256287,
0.051916733384132385,
0.13047729432582855,
0.1987420618534088,
0.14289863407611847,
-0.10997775197029114,
-0.19596914947032928,
-0.5154585242271423,
0.16583430767059326,
-0.4178225100040436,
-0.12884145975112915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03952v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03952v1
|
HAFFormer: A Hierarchical Attention-Free Framework for Alzheimer's Disease Detection From Spontaneous Speech
| 2024-05-07T02:19:16 | 2024-05-07T02:19:16 |
Zhongren Dong, Zixing Zhang, Weixiang Xu, Jing Han, Jianjun Ou, Björn W. Schuller
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Automatically detecting Alzheimer's Disease (AD) from spontaneous speech
plays an important role in its early diagnosis. Recent approaches highly rely
on the Transformer architectures due to its efficiency in modelling long-range
context dependencies. However, the quadratic increase in computational
complexity associated with self-attention and the length of audio poses a
challenge when deploying such models on edge devices. In this context, we
construct a novel framework, namely Hierarchical Attention-Free Transformer
(HAFFormer), to better deal with long speech for AD detection. Specifically, we
employ an attention-free module of Multi-Scale Depthwise Convolution to replace
the self-attention and thus avoid the expensive computation, and a GELU-based
Gated Linear Unit to replace the feedforward layer, aiming to automatically
filter out the redundant information. Moreover, we design a hierarchical
structure to force it to learn a variety of information grains, from the frame
level to the dialogue level. By conducting extensive experiments on the
ADReSS-M dataset, the introduced HAFFormer can achieve competitive results
(82.6% accuracy) with other recent work, but with significant computational
complexity and model size reduction compared to the standard Transformer. This
shows the efficiency of HAFFormer in dealing with long audio for AD detection.
|
[
-0.37442031502723694,
-0.9175388216972351,
0.37323471903800964,
-0.04232601821422577,
-0.1722925901412964,
-0.32353532314300537,
0.049842167645692825,
-0.6111707091331482,
0.35906484723091125,
0.0997859537601471,
-0.536191999912262,
-0.33240318298339844,
-0.803194522857666,
-0.228578120470047,
-0.3828224539756775,
0.6445344090461731,
0.08651243150234222,
-0.33506500720977783,
0.09223116934299469,
-0.26977723836898804,
-0.20291411876678467,
0.01845361851155758,
-1.3390851020812988,
-0.40298596024513245,
0.4891499876976013,
0.4729357361793518,
0.8923524618148804,
0.8382314443588257,
0.2405477911233902,
0.2691326141357422,
-0.35408326983451843,
0.02800416387617588,
-0.44297724962234497,
0.1485009342432022,
0.16093946993350983,
0.06768537312746048,
-1.006179928779602,
-0.11303237825632095,
0.504923403263092,
0.34463736414909363,
-0.3171597421169281,
-0.12712155282497406,
0.19826945662498474,
0.6998125314712524,
-0.6512022614479065,
0.2062467634677887,
-0.05095338821411133,
0.43496769666671753,
-0.17207424342632294,
0.07697535306215286,
-0.38145190477371216,
0.09519252926111221,
0.17464181780815125,
-0.668596088886261,
0.3518421947956085,
0.16889014840126038,
0.8379274606704712,
0.46864527463912964,
-0.6195021867752075,
-0.2275400459766388,
-0.7502343058586121,
0.48407354950904846,
-0.43635955452919006,
0.4631977677345276,
0.4334329068660736,
0.5151098966598511,
-0.2327945977449417,
-0.6676074266433716,
-0.30954718589782715,
-0.09827291965484619,
-0.15486349165439606,
0.19542062282562256,
-0.94307941198349,
0.49632561206817627,
-0.10352864861488342,
0.6697719693183899,
-0.6396176815032959,
0.11787604540586472,
-0.14481893181800842,
-0.5937027931213379,
0.21413445472717285,
-0.08580518513917923,
0.2312336564064026,
-0.2370479702949524,
-0.2050151377916336,
0.07721864432096481,
-0.19095876812934875,
-0.0812751054763794,
-0.2300381064414978,
-0.04186198115348816,
-0.27606362104415894,
0.09471771121025085,
-0.11077848821878433,
0.5959595441818237,
0.44133418798446655,
-0.20879776775836945,
0.21222497522830963,
0.1705797165632248,
-0.3136245310306549,
0.6095223426818848,
0.6949556469917297,
-0.13809603452682495,
0.028357798233628273,
-0.02654144912958145,
-0.08846496790647507,
0.23418354988098145,
0.062195297330617905,
-0.7773850560188293,
-0.4439634084701538,
0.5039344429969788,
-0.5657206177711487,
-0.07865060865879059,
-0.36839327216148376,
-0.7619097232818604,
-0.058067090809345245,
0.14416567981243134,
0.5563400387763977,
-0.3113389015197754,
-0.1184898167848587,
0.28673461079597473,
0.2444242388010025,
0.0598665289580822,
0.19324880838394165,
-0.6940861940383911,
0.3286891281604767,
0.4033411145210266,
0.774340033531189,
-0.648180365562439,
0.039881691336631775,
-1.338992714881897,
0.45681798458099365,
-0.21772640943527222,
0.8620068430900574,
-0.18191203474998474,
-0.375224232673645,
-0.41889306902885437,
0.019824227318167686,
-0.16818827390670776,
-0.47970810532569885,
0.7906335592269897,
-0.3807975947856903,
0.4152509868144989,
0.4496900737285614,
-0.2787611186504364,
-0.1684277057647705,
-0.0052107227966189384,
-0.9464883208274841,
0.8750720024108887,
0.1962236613035202,
-0.6512535214424133,
0.22472639381885529,
-0.7705171704292297,
-0.7851975560188293,
0.3389627933502197,
-0.09999524056911469,
-0.631230890750885,
-0.08644261211156845,
0.3995950222015381,
0.19259724020957947,
-0.1576937437057495,
0.3484664559364319,
-0.01126638613641262,
-0.172962948679924,
-0.3917562961578369,
-0.6002839803695679,
0.3174629211425781,
0.43872421979904175,
-0.5012550950050354,
0.4928349554538727,
-0.7573244571685791,
-0.26080864667892456,
-0.09635414928197861,
-0.26758715510368347,
0.015480049885809422,
-0.014878859743475914,
-0.27273276448249817,
0.22005771100521088,
0.011123617179691792,
-0.5244224667549133,
-0.29329004883766174,
-0.38121336698532104,
0.32385843992233276,
0.5743143558502197,
0.06631864607334137,
0.5910305976867676,
-0.5168749690055847,
0.6352093815803528,
0.35933879017829895,
0.34555524587631226,
-0.26589682698249817,
-0.5286863446235657,
-0.6169666647911072,
-1.0047905445098877,
0.02364693023264408,
0.6646299362182617,
-0.26645201444625854,
0.6686974763870239,
-0.3486061990261078,
-0.09483443945646286,
-0.6953133940696716,
-0.07648463547229767,
0.0743621364235878,
0.6399931907653809,
0.47559577226638794,
-0.24376091361045837,
-0.23227888345718384,
-0.8523586392402649,
0.06560923159122467,
0.1414555311203003,
-0.18673229217529297,
0.49267977476119995,
0.016685957089066505,
-0.5361196398735046,
0.9137624502182007,
-0.6906387209892273,
-1.1580157279968262,
-0.06400672346353531,
0.08390776813030243,
0.10402988642454147,
0.3157517910003662,
0.04522787407040596,
-0.4339349865913391,
-0.0723680630326271,
0.07075215876102448,
-0.6984929442405701,
-0.01608467474579811,
0.23382985591888428,
-0.04706031084060669,
0.21373867988586426,
0.5154027342796326,
-0.8517834544181824,
0.6262328624725342,
0.5237513184547424,
-0.2533053457736969,
0.12922503054141998,
-0.6047001481056213,
-0.014127057045698166,
-0.7920198440551758,
-0.03401830792427063,
0.10594653338193893,
-0.25571319460868835,
-0.7221853733062744,
-0.41468656063079834,
-0.15358926355838776,
-0.40153372287750244,
-0.42685240507125854,
0.6724792718887329,
-0.44594261050224304,
0.28956732153892517,
-0.4333110749721527,
0.11339621245861053,
0.07886318117380142,
0.4412062466144562,
-0.08088728040456772,
0.40625813603401184,
0.7669447660446167,
-0.5475950241088867,
0.24150030314922333,
0.087564617395401,
-0.31747037172317505,
0.35607483983039856,
-0.7312589883804321,
0.10390567034482956,
-0.16918961703777313,
0.46969497203826904,
-1.1480402946472168,
-0.366670161485672,
0.4641719460487366,
-0.33550482988357544,
0.2398279905319214,
-0.13888975977897644,
-0.29679515957832336,
-0.39778977632522583,
-0.05697595328092575,
0.7345627546310425,
0.52892005443573,
-0.4778060019016266,
1.2196325063705444,
0.5700698494911194,
-0.1632615029811859,
-0.26699063181877136,
-0.5887419581413269,
0.006043568719178438,
-0.21910403668880463,
-0.9875628352165222,
0.4540592432022095,
0.10319726914167404,
0.16072310507297516,
0.11525695770978928,
-0.41025692224502563,
0.006521141622215509,
-0.036368224769830704,
0.1984468549489975,
-0.07795852422714233,
-0.4455486536026001,
0.06508580595254898,
0.165928453207016,
-0.4289914071559906,
-0.15939004719257355,
-0.22053833305835724,
0.37761834263801575,
-0.025558028370141983,
-0.31406670808792114,
-0.7303176522254944,
0.5984401702880859,
0.7678304314613342,
-0.4123061001300812,
0.04895168915390968,
0.5898751616477966,
-0.7123469710350037,
-0.3688289523124695,
-0.19533945620059967,
-0.20853817462921143,
-0.5423718094825745,
0.22851355373859406,
-0.1666378378868103,
-1.1253952980041504,
0.46794140338897705,
0.1402544528245926,
-0.4337809979915619,
0.2021089494228363,
0.3201884925365448,
0.24474047124385834,
1.2428480386734009,
0.6678183674812317,
-0.40976956486701965,
0.29950565099716187,
0.004427919629961252,
0.43674835562705994,
-0.6424640417098999,
-0.14845813810825348,
-0.043810758739709854,
-0.1491210013628006,
-0.22885636985301971,
-0.22237348556518555,
0.7584676742553711,
-0.26659640669822693,
0.022465933114290237,
-0.1490854173898697,
-0.6686995029449463,
0.21818162500858307,
0.07583513855934143,
0.1258477419614792,
0.2393835037946701,
-0.04767003282904625,
0.13460059463977814,
0.15791794657707214,
-0.8759883642196655,
-0.18217647075653076,
0.33027637004852295,
0.45669034123420715,
0.9148638248443604,
-0.006728385109454393,
0.3697628974914551,
0.6021005511283875,
0.11094410717487335,
-1.1593012809753418,
0.39509356021881104,
-0.06723169982433319,
-0.35773009061813354,
-0.4573337137699127,
-0.253333181142807,
-1.2848505973815918,
0.4238811433315277,
0.25269994139671326,
-0.5829935669898987,
0.3437059819698334,
0.49237188696861267,
-0.7574571967124939,
0.2500550150871277,
-0.43013617396354675,
0.9045909643173218,
-0.024454539641737938,
-0.38805127143859863,
-0.26555901765823364,
-0.686811625957489,
0.28230881690979004,
-0.04597723111510277,
0.5828080773353577,
-0.15170660614967346,
0.18187321722507477,
1.0673733949661255,
-0.09024369716644287,
0.5270218253135681,
-0.11535456031560898,
-0.514082133769989,
0.23245494067668915,
0.30608540773391724,
0.3180931806564331,
0.013308228924870491,
0.15782421827316284,
-0.1933794915676117,
-0.3494706153869629,
-0.3292900323867798,
-0.30221864581108093,
0.6672478914260864,
-0.3938181400299072,
-0.7851830720901489,
-0.5298639535903931,
-0.646086573600769,
-0.035203687846660614,
0.4593672752380371,
0.12506717443466187,
0.640903890132904,
-0.2273210734128952,
-0.08435607701539993,
0.9578413963317871,
0.2606954872608185,
0.33911752700805664,
0.19823309779167175,
-0.15187938511371613,
-0.3956093490123749,
0.7275246381759644,
-0.04892294853925705,
-0.0036790678277611732,
0.2353999763727188,
0.34949570894241333,
0.010715652257204056,
-0.1809036284685135,
-0.20807060599327087,
0.26351022720336914,
-0.6152153611183167,
-0.0752812847495079,
-0.8510928153991699,
-0.2905709445476532,
-0.3978036344051361,
0.034216493368148804,
-0.3677002787590027,
-0.23364058136940002,
-0.4554104804992676,
-0.03141460940241814,
0.2974264323711395,
0.5514242649078369,
-0.40127891302108765,
0.6607398986816406,
-0.572713315486908,
0.8323817253112793,
0.5660709142684937,
0.1891668289899826,
0.24026384949684143,
-0.6471827626228333,
-0.1507357954978943,
0.0731419026851654,
-0.3355776071548462,
-0.5881824493408203,
0.405186265707016,
0.5671804547309875,
0.5988569259643555,
0.7755200862884521,
0.07750479131937027,
0.4404490292072296,
-0.3875102400779724,
0.31771230697631836,
-0.12820550799369812,
-0.8641852736473083,
0.5081480741500854,
-0.14750249683856964,
0.6882765889167786,
0.20973564684391022,
0.3371546268463135,
-0.558181881904602,
-0.26216134428977966,
-0.5712999701499939,
-1.141585350036621,
0.8850428462028503,
0.10197681933641434,
-0.24576815962791443,
-0.10504243522882462,
-0.010107235983014107,
-0.15559010207653046,
-0.2600610852241516,
-0.20541055500507355,
-0.4023890793323517,
-0.011631820350885391,
-0.11257579922676086,
-0.28557971119880676,
-0.2153373658657074,
-0.21525026857852936,
-0.3897522985935211,
0.4845016896724701,
0.12892000377178192,
0.5619969964027405,
0.3726150691509247,
-0.2388962209224701,
-0.4211960732936859,
0.29939302802085876,
0.35527533292770386,
0.24134406447410583,
-0.2678731381893158,
0.34603697061538696,
0.10537830740213394,
-0.5211257934570312,
0.23635488748550415,
0.3163524866104126,
0.204044908285141,
0.12959066033363342,
0.21750231087207794,
0.7728397250175476,
0.2168222814798355,
-0.3776099681854248,
0.7206605076789856,
0.008903952315449715,
-0.08157379925251007,
-0.35993197560310364,
0.05888582020998001,
0.08389101922512054,
-0.0752517506480217,
0.6168524026870728,
0.032822538167238235,
0.35329753160476685,
-0.06673392653465271,
0.7856221795082092,
0.27310118079185486,
-0.8934482336044312,
-0.16961772739887238,
0.7675561308860779,
0.08763144910335541,
-0.4718294143676758,
0.616353452205658,
-0.12828712165355682,
-0.34256044030189514,
0.5305749177932739,
0.40636828541755676,
0.7428032755851746,
-0.7177653312683105,
-0.025725526735186577,
-0.1610027253627777,
0.008693432435393333,
-0.029808668419718742,
-0.05050770938396454,
-0.3742530643939972,
-0.5424360632896423,
-0.2785898745059967,
-0.24538254737854004,
-0.12224392592906952,
0.4231010973453522,
-0.7137183547019958,
0.24397259950637817,
-0.11603105068206787,
-0.1532144844532013,
0.2961806356906891,
-0.4081340432167053,
-0.1480056494474411,
0.2890223562717438,
0.28420117497444153,
0.8350870609283447,
-0.7062734961509705,
0.897576630115509,
0.4175243079662323,
0.36157163977622986,
-0.263651579618454,
0.062352489680051804,
0.09251483529806137,
-0.5317415595054626,
0.3439367115497589,
0.47961968183517456,
-0.818463146686554,
0.3733777403831482,
-0.211432084441185,
-0.8013862371444702,
1.085084080696106,
0.1999945491552353,
-0.2332272082567215,
-0.3025784492492676,
-0.18717999756336212,
0.34275108575820923,
-0.40205076336860657,
-0.03217144310474396,
0.5384875535964966,
0.31724274158477783,
0.37585359811782837,
-0.8573968410491943,
0.0064019509591162205,
-0.1668338030576706,
-0.4484267830848694,
0.44147855043411255,
-0.40244996547698975,
0.6075488924980164,
-0.24294257164001465,
-0.5558914542198181,
-0.31080520153045654,
1.002170443534851,
0.26125505566596985,
0.3487335741519928,
0.5953681468963623,
0.6378324031829834,
0.7032887935638428,
0.2162279337644577,
0.751503586769104,
-0.4927525520324707,
0.20913076400756836,
0.6347841024398804,
-0.18412627279758453,
0.3865531384944916,
0.2285332977771759,
0.39576590061187744,
0.31148046255111694,
0.35433486104011536,
0.2862509489059448,
0.6280953288078308,
0.26824265718460083,
-0.5323788523674011,
-0.27687913179397583,
0.0008829180151224136,
-0.21989090740680695,
0.2811620235443115,
0.5690711736679077,
0.011421584524214268,
-0.6529328227043152,
0.3413069248199463,
0.24671050906181335,
-0.34055060148239136,
-0.24642877280712128,
0.6850338578224182,
0.3560185432434082,
-0.4347754418849945,
0.8194841146469116,
-0.021980777382850647,
0.8953695893287659,
-0.6149318814277649,
0.02318676933646202,
-0.2309849113225937,
0.48606589436531067,
-0.14283744990825653,
-0.36975449323654175,
0.21619270741939545,
-0.38034698367118835,
-0.22068898379802704,
0.1100648045539856,
0.7207753658294678,
-0.4775342345237732,
-0.22169844806194305,
0.4272371232509613,
0.47441238164901733,
0.1658957153558731,
-0.015466617420315742,
-0.36988767981529236,
0.09049135446548462,
-0.36145922541618347,
-0.33024299144744873,
0.18510761857032776,
0.43858587741851807,
-0.20374229550361633,
0.9086613059043884,
0.2964326739311218,
-0.1024429202079773,
-0.15088264644145966,
-0.23838436603546143,
0.5978426337242126,
-0.2608013153076172,
-0.7915852665901184,
-0.6201748847961426,
0.06091911345720291,
0.24488836526870728,
-0.1143207773566246,
0.38760054111480713,
0.7054941058158875,
0.25498223304748535,
0.15825696289539337,
0.4519423544406891,
0.07340946048498154,
0.18882118165493011,
-0.2048252373933792,
0.9422041773796082,
-0.4778330624103546,
-0.06549737602472305,
-0.00928957387804985,
-0.42728155851364136,
-0.5356318950653076,
0.6210485696792603,
-0.11992070078849792,
0.2145414799451828,
0.8072658777236938,
0.9155758023262024,
-0.4902556538581848,
-0.027532944455742836,
0.39060693979263306,
0.3249398469924927,
0.3798213601112366,
0.7686010003089905,
0.5549226999282837,
-0.30591562390327454,
0.5689183473587036,
-0.1606314331293106,
-0.6199275851249695,
-0.15842993557453156,
-0.843851625919342,
-0.5106637477874756,
-0.47188183665275574,
-0.4392957389354706,
-0.2561250627040863,
0.20764170587062836,
0.6563574075698853,
0.9136282205581665,
-0.7233895063400269,
-0.36777693033218384,
0.26002421975135803,
0.0071348086930811405,
-0.2821629047393799,
-0.21276076138019562,
0.8624655604362488,
0.02247379720211029,
-0.35477593541145325,
0.6577010750770569,
0.4014754295349121,
0.23784807324409485,
0.20327149331569672,
0.05240124091506004,
-0.1601763218641281,
-0.07967060059309006,
0.8214175701141357,
0.40062645077705383,
-0.43804723024368286,
-0.2600385844707489,
-0.07189244031906128,
-0.2177780419588089,
0.46006837487220764,
0.5932215452194214,
-0.8235083818435669,
0.13836829364299774,
0.36365050077438354,
0.276729553937912,
0.5712632536888123,
0.21051697432994843,
0.23933739960193634,
-0.19718478620052338,
0.21552380919456482,
0.3310604393482208,
0.2764158844947815,
0.2811954915523529,
-0.6870040893554688,
-0.19935177266597748,
0.1312074363231659,
-0.6719655990600586,
-0.5781168937683105,
0.2653118968009949,
-1.2116419076919556,
-0.20575328171253204,
1.122595191001892,
0.10470562428236008,
-0.6203727126121521,
-0.4738909900188446,
-0.3135184049606323,
0.3686363399028778,
-0.712784469127655,
0.7151257395744324,
0.36686283349990845,
-0.6668142676353455,
-0.1462147980928421,
-0.14491507411003113,
0.7089580297470093,
0.3996206223964691,
-0.5038044452667236,
0.18924793601036072,
0.4348641633987427,
0.12858927249908447,
-0.051862213760614395,
0.8103992342948914,
-0.2898659110069275,
0.45785656571388245,
-0.3556987941265106,
0.05060752108693123,
-0.11504252254962921,
-0.5592585206031799,
-0.8015848398208618,
0.3441073000431061,
-0.07360780984163284,
-0.2792809009552002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03939v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03939v1
|
Long Context Alignment with Short Instructions and Synthesized Positions
| 2024-05-07T01:56:22 | 2024-05-07T01:56:22 |
Wenhao Wu, Yizhong Wang, Yao Fu, Xiang Yue, Dawei Zhu, Sujian Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Effectively handling instructions with extremely long context remains a
challenge for Large Language Models (LLMs), typically necessitating
high-quality long data and substantial computational resources. This paper
introduces Step-Skipping Alignment (SkipAlign), a new technique designed to
enhance the long-context capabilities of LLMs in the phase of alignment without
the need for additional efforts beyond training with original data length.
SkipAlign is developed on the premise that long-range dependencies are
fundamental to enhancing an LLM's capacity of long context. Departing from
merely expanding the length of input samples, SkipAlign synthesizes long-range
dependencies from the aspect of positions indices. This is achieved by the
strategic insertion of skipped positions within instruction-following samples,
which utilizes the semantic structure of the data to effectively expand the
context. Through extensive experiments on base models with a variety of context
window sizes, SkipAlign demonstrates its effectiveness across a spectrum of
long-context tasks. Particularly noteworthy is that with a careful selection of
the base model and alignment datasets, SkipAlign with only 6B parameters
achieves it's best performance and comparable with strong baselines like
GPT-3.5-Turbo-16K on LongBench.
|
[
-0.34282881021499634,
-0.6064820885658264,
0.6331716179847717,
0.35287222266197205,
-0.27133244276046753,
-0.02171514928340912,
-0.29475414752960205,
-0.4578012228012085,
-0.027726760134100914,
0.36696672439575195,
-0.7485226988792419,
-0.6005906462669373,
-0.5559757947921753,
-0.12048781663179398,
-0.4427545666694641,
0.8290835618972778,
-0.1470470428466797,
-0.0897359624505043,
-0.20464839041233063,
-0.03144827485084534,
-0.7122256755828857,
-0.041521359235048294,
-0.5752201676368713,
-0.3189983665943146,
0.6455809473991394,
0.6326413750648499,
0.8592407703399658,
1.2568439245224,
0.09057503193616867,
0.18578380346298218,
-0.2389862835407257,
0.05518636852502823,
-0.4900515675544739,
0.2765502333641052,
-0.2791553735733032,
-0.1013040542602539,
-0.8293242454528809,
-0.03751266747713089,
0.8001537919044495,
0.9337638020515442,
-0.012376831844449043,
-0.11901813745498657,
0.4046684205532074,
0.8999696373939514,
-0.6398053765296936,
-0.01624642312526703,
-0.13477836549282074,
-0.14125099778175354,
-0.49995866417884827,
-0.13190005719661713,
-0.49716854095458984,
-0.12095165997743607,
0.11519625037908554,
-0.6745531558990479,
-0.05983857065439224,
-0.017090177163481712,
0.4898819625377655,
0.5374945402145386,
-0.4303258955478668,
-0.19318504631519318,
-0.7070677876472473,
0.7898251414299011,
-0.5892045497894287,
0.798564076423645,
0.41924816370010376,
0.1974121630191803,
-0.5309950113296509,
-0.362511545419693,
-0.2931629419326782,
0.06083587929606438,
-0.009543855674564838,
-0.04576858505606651,
0.3175381124019623,
0.15877853333950043,
0.32097068428993225,
-0.1290958970785141,
-0.6329387426376343,
0.4819079041481018,
-0.41106075048446655,
-0.17120486497879028,
0.28046464920043945,
0.052947744727134705,
0.17256785929203033,
-0.05096627026796341,
-0.46682509779930115,
0.12787176668643951,
-1.1709320545196533,
-0.06889490783214569,
0.22429797053337097,
0.48499825596809387,
-0.1771034598350525,
0.49664703011512756,
-0.2357155829668045,
1.1076897382736206,
0.442426472902298,
-0.23115123808383942,
0.21369878947734833,
-0.4313279688358307,
-0.2969838082790375,
0.4987812936306,
0.5056561231613159,
0.24512650072574615,
0.01801668293774128,
-0.07230032980442047,
-0.09995841234922409,
-0.3090097904205322,
0.01798909902572632,
-0.7324499487876892,
0.0700497105717659,
0.286600798368454,
-0.1571250706911087,
0.04289435222744942,
-0.3312322199344635,
-0.5643657445907593,
-0.18853816390037537,
-0.7148795127868652,
0.09538104385137558,
-0.6256446838378906,
0.23934508860111237,
0.0834636315703392,
0.30749237537384033,
0.5089519023895264,
0.5383229851722717,
-0.7893617749214172,
0.20751136541366577,
1.0285378694534302,
0.828952968120575,
-0.4394959509372711,
-0.6314780712127686,
-0.9852275252342224,
0.5014793872833252,
-0.4306812286376953,
0.24299931526184082,
-0.699238121509552,
-0.4457933008670807,
-0.1875663697719574,
0.20169246196746826,
0.06434160470962524,
-0.2895384430885315,
0.4375137388706207,
-0.4916778802871704,
0.4020865559577942,
-0.1653304547071457,
-0.7312452793121338,
-0.0424116887152195,
0.1785012185573578,
-0.714874267578125,
1.0702203512191772,
0.09008555114269257,
-0.4787573516368866,
0.4440977871417999,
-0.7546995282173157,
-0.7667434811592102,
-0.09535299986600876,
-0.00598912825807929,
-0.07219162583351135,
-0.06857965141534805,
0.4130561947822571,
0.4618399739265442,
0.1326134353876114,
0.07832440733909607,
-0.17365267872810364,
-0.6525123715400696,
-0.06351000815629959,
-0.4344514012336731,
0.646975576877594,
-0.1302318423986435,
-0.579304039478302,
0.0653209239244461,
-0.8445329666137695,
-0.18204425275325775,
-0.21290186047554016,
-0.5804004669189453,
-0.5008106231689453,
0.1418684422969818,
-0.29004544019699097,
0.4329705834388733,
0.33878928422927856,
-0.1669018566608429,
0.29722851514816284,
-0.34597498178482056,
0.06735391914844513,
0.8591398596763611,
-0.2429220825433731,
0.9041979908943176,
-0.08104564249515533,
0.605475127696991,
0.016251277178525925,
-0.02412903495132923,
-0.2835477590560913,
-0.09224409610033035,
-0.7249324917793274,
-0.35503172874450684,
0.40000322461128235,
0.7398298382759094,
-0.5731866359710693,
0.7683975696563721,
-0.7395591735839844,
0.09450121223926544,
-0.48862138390541077,
0.37870752811431885,
0.42961135506629944,
0.7284380793571472,
0.5424103140830994,
-0.1712939590215683,
-0.5431395173072815,
-0.5992923378944397,
-0.05367473140358925,
0.30762049555778503,
0.1550365537405014,
-0.17393909394741058,
0.32396459579467773,
-0.09862405061721802,
0.8521066904067993,
-0.3680992126464844,
-0.04368457943201065,
-0.017215706408023834,
-0.0024421087000519037,
0.146867573261261,
0.6980300545692444,
0.0393647737801075,
-0.46251603960990906,
-0.41192197799682617,
-0.057821016758680344,
-0.4742909073829651,
0.01864539459347725,
-0.10658681392669678,
-0.5648210644721985,
0.5191597938537598,
0.9712479710578918,
-0.810200572013855,
0.49284660816192627,
0.5403518676757812,
-0.14745785295963287,
0.2912086546421051,
0.09541517496109009,
0.008508630096912384,
-1.217308759689331,
0.2093902826309204,
-0.20656035840511322,
-0.5901702046394348,
-0.6906498074531555,
-0.07636677473783493,
0.3039420247077942,
0.059576377272605896,
-0.6952335834503174,
0.6677868366241455,
-0.7865203619003296,
0.04637139290571213,
-0.3436349928379059,
0.14240410923957825,
-0.019501162692904472,
0.40556976199150085,
0.10282008349895477,
0.7901726365089417,
0.5200321078300476,
-0.7448005080223083,
0.053119175136089325,
0.1391015648841858,
-0.3247242569923401,
0.7067963480949402,
-0.2899872362613678,
0.37731343507766724,
-0.23020043969154358,
0.6178990006446838,
-0.7475000619888306,
-0.39637622237205505,
0.47894176840782166,
-0.21072033047676086,
0.7478859424591064,
-0.5323266983032227,
-0.28024667501449585,
-0.09450191259384155,
-0.1280101090669632,
0.7447062134742737,
0.4889780580997467,
-0.6866926550865173,
0.422930508852005,
-0.03359222784638405,
-0.3344314694404602,
-1.151175856590271,
-0.6502048373222351,
-0.02392134815454483,
-0.4586777985095978,
-0.515842616558075,
0.49188700318336487,
-0.09140364825725555,
0.019043076783418655,
-0.31705155968666077,
-0.2946030795574188,
0.2394169121980667,
-0.1241619810461998,
0.36681053042411804,
0.21015851199626923,
-0.18817074596881866,
0.1427476406097412,
0.13636226952075958,
-0.2758025527000427,
-0.09740065783262253,
-0.4807851314544678,
0.7088611125946045,
0.35633406043052673,
-0.5196518301963806,
-0.32617121934890747,
0.3594125807285309,
0.6185590624809265,
-0.014595627784729004,
0.48744750022888184,
0.379155695438385,
-0.3652869760990143,
-0.32715731859207153,
-0.2652674615383148,
0.1563950479030609,
-0.5093805193901062,
0.42022475600242615,
-0.14438177645206451,
-0.8255808353424072,
0.20607659220695496,
0.030238918960094452,
0.22664818167686462,
0.019580010324716568,
0.17295680940151215,
-0.17205560207366943,
0.9037323594093323,
0.6244882345199585,
-0.33022263646125793,
0.5179598927497864,
0.21560277044773102,
0.20790962874889374,
-0.9649445414543152,
-0.03711215779185295,
-0.30718135833740234,
-0.5532325506210327,
-0.3109511733055115,
-0.9310855865478516,
0.11137855798006058,
0.29271355271339417,
-0.3886178731918335,
0.2798927128314972,
-0.2861914038658142,
0.7698414921760559,
0.24439774453639984,
0.07973502576351166,
0.08136477321386337,
-0.034617647528648376,
-0.014272772707045078,
0.0025567524135112762,
-0.33150413632392883,
-0.13970132172107697,
0.791710376739502,
0.38739335536956787,
0.8811241388320923,
0.07156917452812195,
1.0527454614639282,
-0.08003067970275879,
0.06014347821474075,
-1.1550076007843018,
0.7424451112747192,
-0.13396719098091125,
-0.34545400738716125,
-0.5886670351028442,
-0.28305527567863464,
-0.9783111214637756,
-0.030762124806642532,
0.38426637649536133,
-0.6891342401504517,
-0.02573438547551632,
0.22575414180755615,
-0.508233904838562,
-0.10269932448863983,
-0.38287150859832764,
0.6562545895576477,
-0.3804490268230438,
-0.454777330160141,
0.007322625257074833,
-0.9700857996940613,
0.32841747999191284,
-0.02909994311630726,
0.22036448121070862,
-0.06589928269386292,
-0.3067132234573364,
0.7143443822860718,
-0.5153231024742126,
0.8580821752548218,
-0.2561711072921753,
-0.4169207215309143,
0.0542520172894001,
0.24039417505264282,
0.7738037705421448,
-0.3405155539512634,
0.030095571652054787,
-0.16147130727767944,
-0.45487672090530396,
-0.45750555396080017,
-0.6015672087669373,
0.8875453472137451,
-0.1782921850681305,
-0.6378173828125,
-0.2641626000404358,
-0.7821486592292786,
-0.4320259988307953,
0.5900636315345764,
0.14011657238006592,
0.30970528721809387,
-0.2196379154920578,
0.08070876449346542,
0.7215709686279297,
-0.07518425583839417,
0.7526351809501648,
0.24195308983325958,
-0.14941677451133728,
-0.36394181847572327,
0.6198503375053406,
0.09880080819129944,
0.35109615325927734,
0.5298298597335815,
-0.12523922324180603,
-0.44809240102767944,
-0.5471847653388977,
-0.5207737684249878,
0.16968387365341187,
-0.9469910264015198,
-0.09893131256103516,
-0.29952263832092285,
-0.18903100490570068,
-0.4194117784500122,
-0.3797283172607422,
-0.4406202435493469,
-0.498218297958374,
-0.3101636469364166,
-0.18848243355751038,
0.18754643201828003,
0.5307539105415344,
0.10189923644065857,
0.39067167043685913,
-0.9540077447891235,
0.05758256837725639,
0.11039222031831741,
0.5389856100082397,
0.04523497447371483,
-0.4981391429901123,
-0.40526333451271057,
-0.0674450621008873,
-0.19530779123306274,
-0.5810908675193787,
0.2165563702583313,
0.061375848948955536,
0.3822949230670929,
0.38936248421669006,
-0.2507350742816925,
1.3519206047058105,
-0.7481338381767273,
0.6505118012428284,
0.22138972580432892,
-1.0903642177581787,
0.519919753074646,
-0.5649377703666687,
0.8061990141868591,
0.7097380757331848,
0.5579521656036377,
-0.43072861433029175,
-0.0774134173989296,
-0.15020589530467987,
-1.1589206457138062,
0.7513068318367004,
-0.13744807243347168,
-0.18187518417835236,
0.017000969499349594,
0.38426193594932556,
0.12891656160354614,
-0.19478796422481537,
-0.5899592041969299,
-0.047736361622810364,
0.18532134592533112,
-0.46388259530067444,
-0.12082767486572266,
0.013687520287930965,
-0.2695492208003998,
-0.14661826193332672,
0.7021421194076538,
-0.21863478422164917,
0.022840742021799088,
-0.056177955120801926,
-0.5078980922698975,
-0.008257074281573296,
0.2649945020675659,
0.900170087814331,
0.9983720183372498,
0.013044112361967564,
0.03472314029932022,
0.1792750209569931,
-0.30539974570274353,
0.18079470098018646,
0.17482605576515198,
0.004533668980002403,
-0.05790214240550995,
0.36858460307121277,
0.6133621335029602,
0.49403902888298035,
-0.2995309829711914,
0.3067184388637543,
0.304375559091568,
-0.01479251030832529,
-0.3286516070365906,
0.057075437158346176,
0.4927993714809418,
0.05640193447470665,
0.06260395795106888,
-0.06923536956310272,
-0.028998708352446556,
-0.25379255414009094,
0.38194194436073303,
0.28211885690689087,
-0.48056432604789734,
-0.1499520093202591,
0.3294021487236023,
0.1342410147190094,
-0.19697785377502441,
0.7898833751678467,
0.1362343281507492,
-0.1720840483903885,
0.4220559895038605,
0.5528649091720581,
0.6437748074531555,
-0.3880572021007538,
-0.1379408836364746,
0.17324461042881012,
-0.07137802988290787,
-0.5944339632987976,
0.08279699087142944,
-0.15436528623104095,
-0.3121722936630249,
-0.8987433314323425,
-0.45255064964294434,
-0.16256771981716156,
0.2498338520526886,
-0.7418637871742249,
0.5480129718780518,
-0.5252394080162048,
0.12912997603416443,
-0.24933773279190063,
-0.32465800642967224,
-0.628200888633728,
0.20426268875598907,
0.31230437755584717,
0.949234664440155,
-0.5367412567138672,
1.1079784631729126,
0.3765980005264282,
0.13103839755058289,
-0.7571556568145752,
0.31696170568466187,
0.3312426507472992,
-0.8125326037406921,
0.6298056840896606,
0.42219024896621704,
-0.3519706130027771,
-0.23579274117946625,
-0.6008493304252625,
-1.1423176527023315,
1.1691558361053467,
0.08571396768093109,
-0.8804541826248169,
-0.41917476058006287,
0.12170161306858063,
0.15327724814414978,
-0.40203067660331726,
-0.2974088191986084,
0.8073531985282898,
0.49017778038978577,
0.3080049455165863,
-0.8287242650985718,
0.4516879618167877,
-0.013863536529242992,
-0.09071231633424759,
0.5836663842201233,
-0.4311085343360901,
0.4550468325614929,
-0.05071679875254631,
-0.14653503894805908,
0.346113920211792,
0.7558030486106873,
0.3748704195022583,
0.10263801366090775,
0.612514853477478,
0.6083221435546875,
0.5715246200561523,
0.07599586993455887,
0.6733793020248413,
-0.4761262834072113,
-0.03804375231266022,
1.6917320489883423,
-0.3637911081314087,
0.89621901512146,
0.6806765198707581,
0.1649826169013977,
0.44655099511146545,
0.6348555088043213,
0.4370690882205963,
0.4249160587787628,
0.1599271446466446,
-0.09381256997585297,
-0.1847265511751175,
0.34979283809661865,
-0.22032305598258972,
0.518693745136261,
0.5376876592636108,
-0.43873441219329834,
-0.24664169549942017,
-0.24570997059345245,
0.35761764645576477,
-0.3152841329574585,
-0.2813705801963806,
0.6262693405151367,
0.21746112406253815,
-1.016602635383606,
0.8516106009483337,
-0.19502593576908112,
0.6889081001281738,
-0.5953829884529114,
-0.11258047819137573,
-0.3078346252441406,
0.024287618696689606,
-0.23046720027923584,
-0.8138459324836731,
0.17783717811107635,
-0.15479181706905365,
-0.17992271482944489,
-0.4549984931945801,
0.3903818130493164,
-0.5949233770370483,
-0.30042845010757446,
0.2820647060871124,
0.32897332310676575,
0.05875672399997711,
0.3360747992992401,
-0.5474687814712524,
-0.04676128551363945,
-0.0916065201163292,
-0.36241522431373596,
0.44674167037010193,
0.42813313007354736,
-0.36924391984939575,
0.5225429534912109,
0.4374223053455353,
0.03359522297978401,
-0.07696561515331268,
0.042057160288095474,
0.6252312660217285,
-1.0881879329681396,
-0.6150718927383423,
-1.0085060596466064,
0.6536729335784912,
0.018239455297589302,
-0.17108610272407532,
0.5398711562156677,
0.5425534844398499,
0.8788607120513916,
0.19436827301979065,
0.6612905263900757,
0.05290199816226959,
0.4494883716106415,
-0.955829381942749,
0.45373648405075073,
-0.5010085701942444,
0.30537310242652893,
-0.2301863580942154,
-1.0904080867767334,
-0.4550911784172058,
0.3958796262741089,
-0.3754299581050873,
0.1378912329673767,
0.7013528347015381,
0.8954039216041565,
-0.5037379860877991,
-0.27482253313064575,
0.15132905542850494,
0.13148419559001923,
0.32673516869544983,
0.6189045310020447,
0.9112486243247986,
-0.06683064997196198,
0.445573091506958,
-0.11616447567939758,
-0.12877854704856873,
-0.09751193970441818,
-1.1714810132980347,
-0.6820518374443054,
-0.30019649863243103,
-0.27180591225624084,
-0.4864000380039215,
-0.019788525998592377,
1.1522890329360962,
0.9636365175247192,
-0.5094802975654602,
-0.2739233374595642,
0.057157836854457855,
0.16685688495635986,
-0.2292528599500656,
-0.24015945196151733,
0.4336782693862915,
-0.2722748816013336,
-0.8806233406066895,
0.9240856766700745,
0.3718298077583313,
0.3768613934516907,
0.0633726641535759,
-0.34831807017326355,
-0.1415446698665619,
-0.06310585141181946,
0.5858070254325867,
0.47588595747947693,
-0.7731052041053772,
-0.5060727596282959,
0.050028394907712936,
-0.17131993174552917,
0.2955750823020935,
0.7306717038154602,
-0.6495484113693237,
0.1928783655166626,
0.651442289352417,
0.5185843706130981,
0.2647870182991028,
0.31663796305656433,
0.8134640455245972,
-0.9781439900398254,
0.19603069126605988,
0.14857202768325806,
0.41315680742263794,
0.5205435156822205,
-0.4790242910385132,
0.38121646642684937,
-0.29713818430900574,
-0.48729708790779114,
-0.6867566704750061,
0.3652593195438385,
-1.1521819829940796,
-0.29106172919273376,
1.31792151927948,
-0.08457279950380325,
-0.405763179063797,
-0.15081049501895905,
-0.10229571908712387,
0.3070200979709625,
-0.46164795756340027,
0.5061275959014893,
0.8262736201286316,
-0.33745530247688293,
-0.14814096689224243,
-0.4197852313518524,
0.5697690844535828,
0.6292173862457275,
-0.6889443397521973,
0.2658184766769409,
0.7873674035072327,
0.5777338743209839,
0.10562369227409363,
0.6124164462089539,
-0.24915097653865814,
0.34375911951065063,
-0.4167487621307373,
-0.20448440313339233,
-0.09017287939786911,
-0.6321564316749573,
-0.5744000673294067,
-0.012310544960200787,
0.014075513929128647,
-0.2753962576389313
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.