id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03932v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03932v2
|
CleanGraph: Human-in-the-loop Knowledge Graph Refinement and Completion
| 2024-05-07T01:40:23 | 2024-05-08T00:18:45 |
Tyler Bikaun, Michael Stewart, Wei Liu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper presents CleanGraph, an interactive web-based tool designed to
facilitate the refinement and completion of knowledge graphs. Maintaining the
reliability of knowledge graphs, which are grounded in high-quality and
error-free facts, is crucial for real-world applications such as
question-answering and information retrieval systems. These graphs are often
automatically assembled from textual sources by extracting semantic triples via
information extraction. However, assuring the quality of these extracted
triples, especially when dealing with large or low-quality datasets, can pose a
significant challenge and adversely affect the performance of downstream
applications. CleanGraph allows users to perform Create, Read, Update, and
Delete (CRUD) operations on their graphs, as well as apply models in the form
of plugins for graph refinement and completion tasks. These functionalities
enable users to enhance the integrity and reliability of their graph data. A
demonstration of CleanGraph and its source code can be accessed at
https://github.com/nlp-tlp/CleanGraph under the MIT License.
|
[
-0.2889229953289032,
-0.6408025622367859,
0.4274471402168274,
-0.32356950640678406,
-0.05811368301510811,
0.5043476819992065,
0.02956147864460945,
-0.5990206003189087,
0.10483773052692413,
0.739742636680603,
-0.3771398961544037,
-0.8403515815734863,
-0.10980840772390366,
0.11250662058591843,
-0.29728126525878906,
0.8327515721321106,
-0.1426180899143219,
-0.3818094730377197,
-0.5625709891319275,
-0.0995749831199646,
-0.45044389367103577,
0.01908053644001484,
-0.6400588154792786,
-0.7239073514938354,
0.42166125774383545,
0.6775525212287903,
0.9918181300163269,
0.6778877973556519,
0.3191875219345093,
0.24785609543323517,
0.2265573889017105,
0.6702450513839722,
-0.8192999362945557,
0.47691798210144043,
-0.49906522035598755,
-0.20714113116264343,
-0.4748540222644806,
-0.001265106606297195,
0.2982676327228546,
0.9952764511108398,
0.057200364768505096,
0.33384695649147034,
0.18738658726215363,
0.7346446514129639,
-0.5290499925613403,
0.39737287163734436,
-0.2891843020915985,
-0.3288651704788208,
-0.23752766847610474,
-0.052010051906108856,
-0.2340010702610016,
-0.9497464895248413,
0.03270750865340233,
-1.1527485847473145,
0.111933134496212,
0.2993967533111572,
1.221792221069336,
0.3384951949119568,
-0.5503349304199219,
-0.053647030144929886,
-0.5130816698074341,
0.2826497256755829,
-0.5496448874473572,
0.4407603442668915,
0.5202012062072754,
0.4661009609699249,
-0.37983423471450806,
-1.1430940628051758,
-0.5574278831481934,
0.13398860394954681,
-0.39687231183052063,
-0.03747709095478058,
-0.11768335103988647,
0.18701104819774628,
0.3664805591106415,
0.22568444907665253,
-0.28447815775871277,
-0.1267661601305008,
-0.6808064579963684,
-0.6543039083480835,
0.5195355415344238,
0.18349601328372955,
0.4482883810997009,
-0.15386304259300232,
-0.2533501982688904,
0.0800984799861908,
-0.6835650205612183,
0.01511414721608162,
0.5940099954605103,
0.3034660816192627,
0.19109869003295898,
0.71662437915802,
-0.9083881974220276,
1.0013092756271362,
-0.44229960441589355,
-0.3060847222805023,
0.542680561542511,
-0.4324072599411011,
-0.00597848417237401,
-0.2579372823238373,
0.8683905601501465,
0.40528014302253723,
0.3627203702926636,
-0.4030461609363556,
-0.19983185827732086,
-0.2960735261440277,
0.2454787790775299,
-0.5060620903968811,
-0.7183681726455688,
0.4964502453804016,
-0.23504269123077393,
-0.40888848900794983,
0.17666922509670258,
-0.6883032321929932,
-0.5888447165489197,
-0.6253514885902405,
0.2493075579404831,
-0.7454046607017517,
-0.11030706763267517,
0.17092712223529816,
-0.5958788990974426,
-0.2134309560060501,
0.7669665217399597,
-0.17224767804145813,
0.43051543831825256,
0.48687633872032166,
0.6096174120903015,
0.21458512544631958,
-0.23644687235355377,
-0.4785556197166443,
0.6282666921615601,
-0.09809180349111557,
0.7344655394554138,
-0.282586932182312,
-0.12442203611135483,
-0.1265682727098465,
-0.2973232865333557,
0.1762760877609253,
-0.3965153694152832,
0.49284324049949646,
-0.8981984257698059,
0.12176547199487686,
-0.47718000411987305,
-0.7991613745689392,
-0.5054023265838623,
0.3751557767391205,
-0.9921126961708069,
1.0369234085083008,
0.4243389368057251,
-1.0580260753631592,
0.5244842171669006,
-0.768778920173645,
-0.43515944480895996,
0.28028663992881775,
0.08895643800497055,
-0.19926828145980835,
-0.6040321588516235,
0.06298220157623291,
0.16677013039588928,
-0.09574570506811142,
0.08681086450815201,
-0.7947075963020325,
-0.4407782256603241,
-0.18342123925685883,
0.3199582099914551,
1.0543525218963623,
0.3548368513584137,
-0.04439985379576683,
0.19879326224327087,
-0.8013227581977844,
0.4636767506599426,
0.09340959787368774,
-0.2353569120168686,
-0.18499569594860077,
-0.015298704616725445,
-0.3884909152984619,
0.3081173896789551,
0.4394564628601074,
-0.7447878122329712,
0.3045607805252075,
-0.06037827208638191,
0.3670600354671478,
0.5140299201011658,
0.33406880497932434,
-0.0713583305478096,
-0.3044050633907318,
0.3037009537220001,
-0.142062246799469,
0.29035064578056335,
-0.029681220650672913,
-0.6124184727668762,
-0.6497918367385864,
-0.3457745611667633,
0.6240456700325012,
0.7199785113334656,
-0.9052065014839172,
0.4482667148113251,
-0.47065940499305725,
-0.5992742776870728,
-0.5024981498718262,
0.357806921005249,
0.27882733941078186,
0.8823702931404114,
0.37880080938339233,
-0.22985051572322845,
-0.3192260265350342,
-0.6987297534942627,
-0.21215768158435822,
-0.31752046942710876,
-0.320372611284256,
0.199553981423378,
0.3718334138393402,
-0.32623252272605896,
1.3966866731643677,
-0.9678293466567993,
-0.35317420959472656,
-0.030250726267695427,
0.006059493403881788,
-0.179535910487175,
0.17347723245620728,
0.17857199907302856,
-0.49840131402015686,
-0.2515554130077362,
0.03459939360618591,
-0.9880130290985107,
-0.17989183962345123,
0.547502338886261,
-0.4546492397785187,
-0.2148611694574356,
0.5905795097351074,
-0.41032037138938904,
0.6545854806900024,
0.1154235303401947,
-0.47306978702545166,
0.6734840869903564,
-0.09139066934585571,
0.2517593204975128,
-0.6532648205757141,
0.5379284620285034,
-0.38963064551353455,
-0.8218333721160889,
-0.5214005708694458,
0.15549743175506592,
-0.046403974294662476,
-0.35644614696502686,
-0.16441302001476288,
0.594276487827301,
-0.1917266696691513,
0.024693595245480537,
0.1835705190896988,
0.6495803594589233,
0.506219744682312,
0.28706231713294983,
-0.5105980038642883,
0.41261571645736694,
0.17538009583950043,
-0.43720269203186035,
0.5925358533859253,
0.43447622656822205,
-0.1281375288963318,
0.46068355441093445,
-0.5684972405433655,
0.2299242615699768,
0.007551061455160379,
0.23267444968223572,
-0.928841233253479,
-0.7478036284446716,
0.3322020471096039,
-0.2701457738876343,
0.0737815797328949,
-0.24459625780582428,
-0.8621190786361694,
-0.5459697246551514,
-0.27749860286712646,
0.07441814243793488,
0.2884962260723114,
-0.4562336802482605,
0.3491954803466797,
0.5290049314498901,
0.16660234332084656,
-0.5017693638801575,
-0.12741725146770477,
0.10992354154586792,
0.2649388015270233,
-0.9155420064926147,
0.06357311457395554,
0.2575436234474182,
-0.3904884457588196,
0.30637213587760925,
0.08662502467632294,
-0.17560410499572754,
0.1719374656677246,
0.24835161864757538,
0.028618212789297104,
0.4388701915740967,
0.27914315462112427,
0.007220505736768246,
-0.2080175131559372,
-0.2421438843011856,
-0.5693228244781494,
0.22921687364578247,
-0.1455327719449997,
-0.5868866443634033,
-0.7801923155784607,
-0.0521710105240345,
0.5678390860557556,
-0.27435800433158875,
0.28010255098342896,
0.6287277936935425,
-0.5491089224815369,
-0.09363355487585068,
-0.5042902231216431,
-0.12066033482551575,
-0.4817673861980438,
-0.11113285273313522,
-0.22956523299217224,
-0.7812978625297546,
0.5678334832191467,
-0.29616737365722656,
0.1896773725748062,
0.45101019740104675,
0.01290248241275549,
-0.4216875731945038,
0.7377461791038513,
0.3065958321094513,
0.18255214393138885,
0.12011893093585968,
-0.319145143032074,
0.14193780720233917,
-0.6123162508010864,
-0.4125993549823761,
-0.5489568114280701,
-0.2739575207233429,
-0.19235214591026306,
-0.10301166027784348,
0.19894182682037354,
0.5489587187767029,
-0.49607565999031067,
0.15420353412628174,
-0.6268180012702942,
0.37856200337409973,
0.8128381967544556,
0.3363055884838104,
0.6316762566566467,
-0.1070544570684433,
-0.19478845596313477,
0.2114453762769699,
-0.3631177246570587,
-0.7354022860527039,
0.8747488260269165,
0.10598862171173096,
0.7291626930236816,
0.1373404711484909,
0.9075146913528442,
0.48576417565345764,
0.2413884699344635,
-0.415931761264801,
0.5587911009788513,
0.19977547228336334,
-0.5556589365005493,
-0.5466260313987732,
-0.5886643528938293,
-0.7807494401931763,
-0.053516458719968796,
-0.08495306968688965,
-0.7595004439353943,
-0.0639643594622612,
0.5342956781387329,
-0.17912067472934723,
0.5837700366973877,
-0.8400782346725464,
0.9591875076293945,
0.23325859010219574,
-0.41811293363571167,
-0.05350809916853905,
-0.723231852054596,
0.5142512321472168,
0.15120941400527954,
0.12327890843153,
-0.3703729510307312,
0.12679944932460785,
0.6246069669723511,
-0.9033910632133484,
0.9055414795875549,
-0.41384434700012207,
0.245071679353714,
0.7515920400619507,
0.38386043906211853,
0.6100512146949768,
0.002955061150714755,
-0.13794946670532227,
0.2768756151199341,
0.09925170987844467,
-0.4376518428325653,
-0.6363534331321716,
0.3545910716056824,
-0.8534318804740906,
-0.4125991463661194,
0.16093303263187408,
-0.33692967891693115,
-0.24172906577587128,
0.8769658803939819,
-0.1413698047399521,
0.5872825384140015,
0.0328763946890831,
-0.15462617576122284,
0.36627644300460815,
-0.07835070788860321,
-0.062347669154405594,
-0.05590815097093582,
-0.47073015570640564,
-0.5703731775283813,
0.9144070148468018,
0.08284363895654678,
0.4858008325099945,
0.08682619035243988,
0.05633476749062538,
-0.3194862902164459,
-0.4406590759754181,
-0.25728103518486023,
0.29162362217903137,
-1.069485068321228,
-0.5271081328392029,
-0.7051804661750793,
-0.030880987644195557,
-0.32442522048950195,
-0.050707362592220306,
-0.11475194245576859,
-0.8836187124252319,
-0.2276286482810974,
-0.29030492901802063,
0.5193801522254944,
0.9657878875732422,
0.09029943495988846,
-0.0023014801554381847,
-0.7196078896522522,
0.42594900727272034,
0.38773462176322937,
0.66911381483078,
-0.14148004353046417,
0.13559506833553314,
-0.26412519812583923,
0.15922166407108307,
-0.4762234389781952,
-0.8220791816711426,
0.0651712715625763,
0.03839730843901634,
0.3140040636062622,
0.40801486372947693,
0.3764592111110687,
0.6908061504364014,
-0.11928017437458038,
0.5927965641021729,
-0.0011401604861021042,
-0.7266072630882263,
0.5512405633926392,
-0.6196471452713013,
0.28303441405296326,
1.1245951652526855,
0.021007807925343513,
-0.47009381651878357,
-0.7215901017189026,
-0.5659748315811157,
-0.7786815166473389,
0.5539510250091553,
0.12538154423236847,
-0.5887373685836792,
0.12580697238445282,
0.6006002426147461,
0.03418063372373581,
0.23188947141170502,
-0.12547264993190765,
-0.13937029242515564,
-0.5894145369529724,
-0.23729874193668365,
0.6670450568199158,
-0.07444551587104797,
-0.5439294576644897,
-0.168398916721344,
0.7989852428436279,
-0.47106823325157166,
-0.03225194662809372,
0.20450322329998016,
-0.254051148891449,
0.03157878667116165,
0.023182470351457596,
0.08918356895446777,
1.038643717765808,
-0.4285382032394409,
0.18460264801979065,
0.06524765491485596,
-0.4920247793197632,
-0.17552614212036133,
0.15593796968460083,
-0.3821503818035126,
-0.2791407108306885,
0.5297847390174866,
0.22296187281608582,
0.1676691621541977,
-0.6067854762077332,
0.5157999396324158,
0.03736526891589165,
-0.0023361279163509607,
-0.2790241837501526,
0.3056313693523407,
0.1531522423028946,
-0.0986604243516922,
0.07862671464681625,
0.1772657334804535,
0.20105156302452087,
-0.17217428982257843,
0.472395122051239,
-0.033612873405218124,
-0.7370457649230957,
-0.14998741447925568,
0.8706591725349426,
0.45756062865257263,
-0.12041376531124115,
1.366655945777893,
-0.6581189632415771,
-0.5136418342590332,
0.23215016722679138,
0.11687955260276794,
0.5701199769973755,
0.318348228931427,
0.07696013152599335,
0.5150661468505859,
-0.009310574270784855,
0.31246328353881836,
0.49701112508773804,
0.12532372772693634,
-0.7492672801017761,
-0.49473002552986145,
-0.41194412112236023,
-0.4877528250217438,
-0.3980564475059509,
-0.49368640780448914,
0.525596022605896,
-0.26415666937828064,
-0.34728705883026123,
-0.13451926410198212,
0.21629714965820312,
-0.8018951416015625,
0.19223399460315704,
-0.22138239443302155,
1.1685117483139038,
-0.4641106128692627,
0.8528095483779907,
0.5873587131500244,
-0.594584047794342,
-0.923607349395752,
-0.381676584482193,
0.29832956194877625,
-0.4262045919895172,
0.5857288241386414,
-0.0041037071496248245,
-0.2963806688785553,
0.19730068743228912,
-0.49566686153411865,
-0.8389236927032471,
1.420595407485962,
0.44469383358955383,
0.04506407305598259,
-0.113630011677742,
0.06846655905246735,
0.34704428911209106,
0.06863252073526382,
0.19649508595466614,
0.4661458730697632,
0.8334042429924011,
0.09102390706539154,
-0.9086132049560547,
0.29569652676582336,
-0.19007715582847595,
-0.4349631369113922,
0.2383633404970169,
-0.6031745076179504,
0.29743438959121704,
-0.5397088527679443,
-0.38379091024398804,
-0.3192378282546997,
0.6138137578964233,
0.36857980489730835,
0.07980387657880783,
0.7533961534500122,
0.8900432586669922,
1.3601480722427368,
-0.41169482469558716,
1.1403237581253052,
-0.42998167872428894,
0.3375264108181,
1.1212884187698364,
-0.32369256019592285,
0.40766409039497375,
0.005554260686039925,
-0.1399674415588379,
0.7803788185119629,
0.547441840171814,
0.06279228627681732,
0.10507172346115112,
0.061967089772224426,
-0.2157510370016098,
-0.33404794335365295,
-0.17401526868343353,
-0.022130092605948448,
0.2944302558898926,
0.24982194602489471,
0.12091904878616333,
-0.34670698642730713,
-0.4603094160556793,
0.3624209761619568,
-0.08064763993024826,
-0.117853544652462,
0.6089876294136047,
-0.27198103070259094,
-0.6101655960083008,
0.17733359336853027,
-0.2491280436515808,
0.0007787946378812194,
-0.5665382742881775,
-0.32455161213874817,
0.13327378034591675,
-0.059303589165210724,
-0.683012843132019,
-1.0882971286773682,
0.3077922463417053,
-0.548176646232605,
-0.04633888229727745,
-0.22468091547489166,
1.0387952327728271,
-0.3105842173099518,
-0.016888640820980072,
0.33294370770454407,
0.43336471915245056,
0.022616049274802208,
0.10994918644428253,
-0.5145167112350464,
-0.08980279415845871,
0.2380639910697937,
-0.24099774658679962,
-0.26819247007369995,
0.39523664116859436,
-0.20495730638504028,
1.082141399383545,
0.9380084276199341,
-0.03181784600019455,
-0.05439327657222748,
0.3560444116592407,
0.9905250668525696,
-0.6545889973640442,
-0.3595685064792633,
-0.34133028984069824,
0.7329531908035278,
-0.6362839937210083,
-0.1159825250506401,
0.6986820697784424,
0.7434890866279602,
0.8458099961280823,
0.3121132552623749,
0.9613872766494751,
-0.17883189022541046,
0.7093920111656189,
-0.1651087999343872,
0.9744635820388794,
-0.2530873715877533,
0.07508876919746399,
-0.1793603152036667,
-0.5166652798652649,
-0.4625517427921295,
0.020182505249977112,
-0.008332489058375359,
0.022410541772842407,
0.6152969002723694,
0.5978209972381592,
0.04107464849948883,
0.16328532993793488,
0.016791963949799538,
0.09710629284381866,
0.7594282627105713,
0.03670245036482811,
0.5986343622207642,
-0.18073470890522003,
0.7428427338600159,
-0.4678983986377716,
-0.24223925173282623,
-0.05584392324090004,
-0.7632079720497131,
-0.5830767154693604,
-0.41765284538269043,
-0.4836394488811493,
-0.7134881019592285,
-0.23187091946601868,
0.5882211327552795,
0.7237026691436768,
-0.5375606417655945,
0.02441263571381569,
0.23875989019870758,
0.7913127541542053,
-0.27280181646347046,
-0.3152412474155426,
0.5187055468559265,
-0.6160641312599182,
-0.2568860650062561,
0.1688346415758133,
0.2868589162826538,
-0.19746659696102142,
-0.06473518908023834,
0.1811121553182602,
-0.08006177097558975,
-0.3349344730377197,
0.33918634057044983,
0.5121065378189087,
-0.42531219124794006,
-0.6810300946235657,
-0.31198033690452576,
-0.13923189043998718,
0.0001135066122515127,
0.7465307116508484,
-0.9584835767745972,
0.9489156603813171,
0.7322633862495422,
0.24224445223808289,
0.5111852288246155,
0.30993741750717163,
0.6967198848724365,
-0.7891989946365356,
-0.20616774260997772,
0.061351001262664795,
0.4898488521575928,
0.49344509840011597,
-0.3702283501625061,
0.8726515769958496,
0.37816083431243896,
-0.6108182072639465,
-0.6943139433860779,
0.24407996237277985,
-0.8933563828468323,
-0.1829293966293335,
0.9046713709831238,
-0.1807078868150711,
-0.24297980964183807,
-0.9719589352607727,
-0.218022421002388,
0.48309698700904846,
-0.41406944394111633,
0.4909294545650482,
0.584283709526062,
-0.4190520942211151,
0.44556695222854614,
-0.5948975086212158,
0.5717831254005432,
-0.6177883148193359,
-1.0796334743499756,
0.24672645330429077,
0.8039665818214417,
0.6811293959617615,
0.4128103256225586,
0.7087435722351074,
-0.3240368068218231,
0.14363741874694824,
-0.10939550399780273,
0.5868059992790222,
-0.648927628993988,
-0.14138208329677582,
0.3101918399333954,
0.46985235810279846,
0.1098620593547821,
0.1951175183057785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03920v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03920v1
|
A Roadmap for Multilingual, Multimodal Domain Independent Deception Detection
| 2024-05-07T00:38:34 | 2024-05-07T00:38:34 |
Dainis Boumber, Rakesh M. Verma, Fatima Zahra Qachfar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM, I.2.6; I.2.7; I.2.10; K.4.4
|
Deception, a prevalent aspect of human communication, has undergone a
significant transformation in the digital age. With the globalization of online
interactions, individuals are communicating in multiple languages and mixing
languages on social media, with varied data becoming available in each language
and dialect. At the same time, the techniques for detecting deception are
similar across the board. Recent studies have shown the possibility of the
existence of universal linguistic cues to deception across domains within the
English language; however, the existence of such cues in other languages
remains unknown. Furthermore, the practical task of deception detection in
low-resource languages is not a well-studied problem due to the lack of labeled
data. Another dimension of deception is multimodality. For example, a picture
with an altered caption in fake news or disinformation may exist. This paper
calls for a comprehensive investigation into the complexities of deceptive
language across linguistic boundaries and modalities within the realm of
computer security and natural language processing and the possibility of using
multilingual transformer models and labeled data in various languages to
universally address the task of deception detection.
|
[
-0.5819557905197144,
-0.8886193633079529,
0.3486175835132599,
0.4460742175579071,
-0.016810035333037376,
0.29478374123573303,
-0.1348806470632553,
-0.7196395397186279,
0.20632261037826538,
0.621803343296051,
-0.8963479399681091,
-0.3271118998527527,
-0.7351898550987244,
0.16743187606334686,
-0.058327123522758484,
0.79339599609375,
-0.06936492770910263,
0.21988703310489655,
-0.31524696946144104,
-0.23072829842567444,
-0.4008564352989197,
-0.6732646226882935,
-0.4975273609161377,
-0.3519587814807892,
0.36363744735717773,
0.21344584226608276,
0.7141097784042358,
0.1757308691740036,
0.6103641390800476,
0.39459389448165894,
0.424730122089386,
0.3546846807003021,
-0.2026117593050003,
0.09442020952701569,
-0.27058687806129456,
-0.46238476037979126,
-0.16721639037132263,
0.1792437732219696,
0.3533245623111725,
0.4978700876235962,
0.09502589702606201,
-0.026642469689249992,
-0.24963748455047607,
0.3920215666294098,
-0.7184668779373169,
0.32259055972099304,
-0.4537828266620636,
-0.20958498120307922,
-0.19936637580394745,
-0.24754996597766876,
-0.5927378535270691,
-0.20866979658603668,
-0.1463690996170044,
-0.5551708340644836,
0.2694908082485199,
-0.10344691574573517,
0.6340277194976807,
0.10779069364070892,
-1.0458627939224243,
-0.5325653553009033,
-0.8252648115158081,
0.8368018865585327,
-0.19189462065696716,
0.5991595387458801,
0.48720264434814453,
0.49302154779434204,
0.011263527907431126,
-0.6731656193733215,
-0.645528256893158,
-0.15138208866119385,
-0.21915371716022491,
-0.004277312662452459,
-0.4064719080924988,
-0.12207907438278198,
0.027565689757466316,
0.025140805169939995,
-0.48251569271087646,
-0.10570976883172989,
-0.1303764283657074,
-0.7071332931518555,
0.6380961537361145,
-0.08945375680923462,
0.5857635140419006,
0.054748401045799255,
-0.5933274626731873,
-0.1217818334698677,
-0.4535876512527466,
-0.142255961894989,
0.5389586687088013,
0.2272287905216217,
-0.31695619225502014,
0.1236075609922409,
-0.15506865084171295,
0.6127697229385376,
-0.05441972613334656,
-0.580234706401825,
0.26298072934150696,
-0.5619019865989685,
0.0986318290233612,
-0.06407691538333893,
0.6999540328979492,
0.3856201171875,
0.17263227701187134,
0.043865956366062164,
-0.2294016182422638,
0.6941063404083252,
0.13872750103473663,
-0.5960474014282227,
-0.27983519434928894,
0.08124483376741409,
-0.47169041633605957,
-0.22061356902122498,
0.040451787412166595,
-0.8588126301765442,
-0.6528132557868958,
-0.37535974383354187,
0.35242393612861633,
-0.5115005373954773,
-0.5859286189079285,
0.13108164072036743,
-0.06094665080308914,
0.24967265129089355,
0.33195042610168457,
-0.4258383810520172,
0.1626945436000824,
0.42305395007133484,
0.3697255849838257,
-0.237791046500206,
-0.30582481622695923,
-0.3322172164916992,
0.0445723831653595,
-0.13487161695957184,
0.699560284614563,
-0.7611092925071716,
-0.15706059336662292,
0.1506011039018631,
0.3051605224609375,
-0.11805921792984009,
-0.2832193374633789,
0.8264561295509338,
-0.6438432335853577,
0.48136094212532043,
-0.10854579508304596,
-0.12239236384630203,
-0.5673338770866394,
0.6983768939971924,
-0.9379057884216309,
0.4905918538570404,
-0.15185752511024475,
-0.5564974546432495,
0.07808727771043777,
-0.596870481967926,
-0.6146556735038757,
0.06316065043210983,
-0.12914922833442688,
-0.4755043089389801,
-0.03713253140449524,
0.37904301285743713,
0.3075406551361084,
-0.24713367223739624,
0.2604101300239563,
-0.012119828723371029,
-0.0855899453163147,
0.7692883610725403,
-1.030887484550476,
0.9828989505767822,
0.20329198241233826,
-0.5185873508453369,
-0.20116746425628662,
-0.6907545924186707,
0.025304622948169708,
0.1479983627796173,
-0.25813084840774536,
-0.4405990540981293,
-0.27724453806877136,
0.4053230583667755,
0.26997849345207214,
0.3979398310184479,
-0.5606318712234497,
0.1187744066119194,
0.08283097296953201,
0.0845426395535469,
0.47096118330955505,
0.08143659681081772,
0.2665625512599945,
-0.17732293903827667,
0.7207319736480713,
0.42346706986427307,
0.4915943443775177,
-0.5432764291763306,
-0.6214625835418701,
-0.6824284195899963,
-0.45145392417907715,
0.31387069821357727,
0.6008442044258118,
-1.226431131362915,
0.05880066007375717,
-0.2479260116815567,
-0.11180323362350464,
-0.668266236782074,
-0.18624141812324524,
0.586567223072052,
0.028048338368535042,
0.31307297945022583,
-0.08917630463838577,
-0.4858117997646332,
-1.156882405281067,
-0.4732001721858978,
-0.01782175898551941,
0.2082381546497345,
-0.23854902386665344,
0.4457768499851227,
-0.5196016430854797,
0.6189932227134705,
-0.3519558906555176,
-0.6669905185699463,
-0.17352212965488434,
0.23089419305324554,
-0.19006295502185822,
0.33331233263015747,
0.448852002620697,
-1.546645164489746,
-0.7190378308296204,
0.07853218168020248,
-0.8046755194664001,
0.015988050028681755,
-0.3627965748310089,
0.2020803689956665,
0.3051820397377014,
0.38962459564208984,
-0.5294772982597351,
0.34032100439071655,
0.8256126642227173,
-0.41026464104652405,
0.5223671197891235,
-0.0886218249797821,
0.6507484912872314,
-0.8170397877693176,
-0.23577167093753815,
0.11245473474264145,
-0.15318283438682556,
-1.1308153867721558,
0.41331377625465393,
0.26230311393737793,
0.0038667519111186266,
-0.49642467498779297,
0.3571353554725647,
-0.8866090774536133,
0.37489452958106995,
-0.22164028882980347,
0.05158441141247749,
0.0613333061337471,
0.5052202939987183,
-0.052997566759586334,
0.5603150129318237,
0.7237191796302795,
-0.4110918343067169,
0.5179674625396729,
0.12172296643257141,
-0.2732928991317749,
1.0942754745483398,
-0.10985564440488815,
0.14805744588375092,
-0.3481276333332062,
0.23824404180049896,
-1.0780938863754272,
-0.28457513451576233,
0.5222212076187134,
-0.6528567671775818,
0.3918396234512329,
-0.15967726707458496,
-0.41409987211227417,
-0.12032042443752289,
-0.25090792775154114,
0.5391754508018494,
0.11759316921234131,
-0.5459721088409424,
0.9457383751869202,
0.28392839431762695,
0.18842464685440063,
-0.7873255014419556,
-0.8088752031326294,
0.383361279964447,
-0.1425197422504425,
-0.8531439900398254,
0.32425224781036377,
-0.21098744869232178,
-0.4263325333595276,
-0.2821245789527893,
0.03272198140621185,
-0.38161399960517883,
-0.02035246603190899,
0.20709623396396637,
0.2527022957801819,
0.09140115976333618,
-0.08229231089353561,
-0.17967884242534637,
-0.295910507440567,
0.17333073914051056,
-0.08152756839990616,
0.3582327365875244,
-0.07930703461170197,
-0.5990830063819885,
-0.6389833092689514,
0.6753940582275391,
0.7648409008979797,
-0.3998277187347412,
0.6195372343063354,
0.8720518946647644,
-0.520945131778717,
-0.13481691479682922,
-0.7391550540924072,
-0.20548969507217407,
-0.5136721134185791,
0.00936934258788824,
-0.6542924046516418,
-0.6498355269432068,
0.5644233226776123,
-0.20603355765342712,
-0.3699405789375305,
0.11823585629463196,
0.5425951480865479,
0.37075042724609375,
1.20598566532135,
0.9815095663070679,
0.12483369559049606,
0.1374678760766983,
0.04826026409864426,
0.5738836526870728,
-0.1958562284708023,
-0.5308012962341309,
-0.24664346873760223,
-0.1788732409477234,
-0.8734639286994934,
-0.5510113835334778,
0.6095736622810364,
-0.2573823630809784,
0.48925939202308655,
0.31477200984954834,
-0.4957990050315857,
0.6152467131614685,
0.43522459268569946,
-0.08850453048944473,
0.6566803455352783,
0.13457438349723816,
0.10285088419914246,
-0.29654067754745483,
-0.30974966287612915,
-0.3607639968395233,
0.830669105052948,
0.2557501792907715,
0.7537790536880493,
0.3275177776813507,
0.2713482677936554,
0.4925979673862457,
0.27584129571914673,
-0.6110614538192749,
0.493208646774292,
0.09405354410409927,
-0.9388599395751953,
-0.017612960189580917,
-0.22935374081134796,
-1.0147173404693604,
0.6083604693412781,
-0.059005577117204666,
-0.4485073387622833,
0.23885422945022583,
-0.16346949338912964,
0.1421947330236435,
0.18282359838485718,
-0.7067336440086365,
0.8222145438194275,
-0.32983165979385376,
-0.12436576187610626,
-0.25375795364379883,
-0.8232671022415161,
0.5801377296447754,
-0.2948555052280426,
0.6599794626235962,
-0.18809983134269714,
-0.03664742410182953,
0.37016230821609497,
0.14311537146568298,
1.1372517347335815,
-0.20817744731903076,
-0.39595353603363037,
0.10260191559791565,
0.4026598632335663,
0.4856370985507965,
-0.10678605735301971,
0.4249487817287445,
0.3813769519329071,
0.09708905220031738,
-0.31951144337654114,
-0.3654303550720215,
0.6698352694511414,
-0.43741676211357117,
-0.3644908666610718,
-0.4937417209148407,
-0.5124897956848145,
-0.46859779953956604,
0.16533079743385315,
0.2562114894390106,
0.34467947483062744,
-0.41326671838760376,
-0.06629524379968643,
0.8458285927772522,
-0.32264089584350586,
0.35005512833595276,
0.8109225630760193,
-0.10893664509057999,
-0.21951636672019958,
1.1394970417022705,
-0.23778389394283295,
0.23448964953422546,
0.46637508273124695,
0.11467000097036362,
-0.38048046827316284,
-0.15398189425468445,
-0.32444706559181213,
0.42608827352523804,
-1.0399776697158813,
-0.1654556691646576,
-0.4053031802177429,
0.032029010355472565,
-0.4439528286457062,
-0.0406247153878212,
-0.2253120392560959,
-0.2229475975036621,
0.023802701383829117,
0.14496207237243652,
0.053365159779787064,
0.6385094523429871,
-0.14719532430171967,
0.2626572251319885,
-0.716759204864502,
0.6669833660125732,
0.16442370414733887,
0.15093262493610382,
-0.31933024525642395,
-0.16694483160972595,
-0.0806078091263771,
0.40922221541404724,
-0.2895562946796417,
-0.9149090647697449,
0.36756575107574463,
0.09449296444654465,
0.7102901935577393,
0.48950693011283875,
0.08248898386955261,
0.3395432233810425,
-0.32789549231529236,
0.6748968362808228,
0.45472997426986694,
-0.847978413105011,
0.38352805376052856,
-0.22564886510372162,
0.11931214481592178,
0.20610375702381134,
0.9489167928695679,
-0.9620906710624695,
-0.3512240946292877,
-0.4976668953895569,
-0.3747711777687073,
0.5267780423164368,
0.10840754210948944,
0.2544514238834381,
0.2033168226480484,
-0.3303418457508087,
0.4384421110153198,
0.2950590252876282,
-1.1906369924545288,
-0.5197901725769043,
-0.03291931003332138,
-0.10844847559928894,
0.013364461250603199,
-0.013855082914233208,
-0.4654649496078491,
0.0030032978393137455,
0.46331241726875305,
-0.403034508228302,
0.40625277161598206,
-0.10106731951236725,
-0.31374308466911316,
-0.01106449868530035,
0.3200574517250061,
0.6388680934906006,
0.7277094721794128,
0.464175283908844,
0.4200461208820343,
-0.3677099049091339,
-0.4194124639034271,
0.316094309091568,
0.07400697469711304,
-0.22882521152496338,
0.18638542294502258,
0.5044500231742859,
0.5685383677482605,
-0.11578786373138428,
-0.6164999008178711,
0.8804559707641602,
-0.018400972709059715,
-0.32395023107528687,
-0.40585097670555115,
-0.40152496099472046,
-0.12893718481063843,
0.22888927161693573,
0.4830228388309479,
0.21821320056915283,
0.14163759350776672,
-0.7173863053321838,
0.21314990520477295,
0.6220381855964661,
-0.3165430724620819,
-0.5769709944725037,
0.6191255450248718,
0.24709922075271606,
-0.2533479630947113,
0.46750521659851074,
-0.35744282603263855,
-0.8561440706253052,
0.25358328223228455,
0.5721908211708069,
0.6823544502258301,
-0.6608846783638,
0.6420847773551941,
-0.17284661531448364,
0.7698800563812256,
0.0008934570359997451,
0.31596723198890686,
-0.017941629514098167,
-1.05942964553833,
-0.3051953613758087,
-0.27165842056274414,
-0.13165748119354248,
0.18122489750385284,
-0.44017475843429565,
0.10293696075677872,
-0.14330077171325684,
-0.06797698140144348,
0.20239593088626862,
-0.3756677806377411,
-0.7008391618728638,
0.26130610704421997,
0.502500593662262,
0.5668623447418213,
-0.887965202331543,
0.7111926674842834,
0.530366063117981,
-0.34291383624076843,
0.0026580130215734243,
0.002965999534353614,
0.5202732086181641,
-0.9354602098464966,
0.5806629657745361,
0.282148540019989,
-0.45156922936439514,
-0.28929993510246277,
-0.6409955024719238,
-0.5858732461929321,
0.5991911292076111,
0.37535107135772705,
-0.17361056804656982,
0.13769404590129852,
0.7467081546783447,
0.5430380702018738,
-0.273044228553772,
-0.07954252511262894,
0.5291701555252075,
0.8019471168518066,
-0.05488653853535652,
-0.8650632500648499,
0.11547143012285233,
-0.10216221958398819,
-0.1736152321100235,
0.3827710747718811,
-0.6665833592414856,
0.8756097555160522,
0.09525447338819504,
-0.5785059928894043,
-0.2694756090641022,
0.3414115607738495,
-0.292474627494812,
0.4468764066696167,
0.4054611325263977,
0.31570446491241455,
0.5280117988586426,
-0.3971174359321594,
0.774436354637146,
-0.2204190045595169,
0.1627780795097351,
0.5823411345481873,
-0.18650273978710175,
0.31732600927352905,
0.41899406909942627,
-0.0004505635879468173,
0.6542598605155945,
0.39114415645599365,
-0.02428782545030117,
0.5073444843292236,
-0.07097578048706055,
-0.49134668707847595,
-0.510190486907959,
-0.3329247534275055,
-0.017295612022280693,
0.6511009931564331,
0.6880905032157898,
-0.15474127233028412,
-0.2432267665863037,
0.5529052019119263,
0.10293971747159958,
0.2542775869369507,
-0.1910533756017685,
0.5155604481697083,
-0.10317294299602509,
-0.6353487372398376,
0.6501986980438232,
0.40803858637809753,
0.9101462960243225,
-0.7313107252120972,
0.017249930649995804,
-0.09927515685558319,
0.4153309464454651,
-0.20412546396255493,
-0.6564902663230896,
0.18511615693569183,
-0.4344121515750885,
0.08745022863149643,
-0.5326852798461914,
0.9726404547691345,
-0.6343609690666199,
-0.3510963022708893,
0.4850177764892578,
0.7248262166976929,
0.00926284957677126,
-0.32633036375045776,
-0.8935636878013611,
0.3018036484718323,
0.1484609991312027,
-0.08273256570100784,
0.27397650480270386,
0.4907609522342682,
-0.2358366847038269,
0.9921531081199646,
0.7087337374687195,
-0.3845050632953644,
0.2227061241865158,
0.16904430091381073,
0.582852303981781,
-0.39905574917793274,
-0.6332576274871826,
-0.5772259831428528,
0.506879448890686,
-0.15571512281894684,
-0.14260832965373993,
1.198089838027954,
0.3818987011909485,
1.0596721172332764,
-0.22544552385807037,
0.8339982628822327,
-0.008672832511365414,
0.26113200187683105,
-0.4209239184856415,
0.37108153104782104,
-0.4500935971736908,
-0.08681720495223999,
-0.048321619629859924,
-0.7655394077301025,
-0.3536744713783264,
0.3321034908294678,
0.08746374398469925,
-0.07764162868261337,
0.8097212314605713,
0.8491393327713013,
-0.20628498494625092,
0.12638802826404572,
0.5050641298294067,
-0.05580104887485504,
0.29719460010528564,
0.34848156571388245,
0.9462233185768127,
-0.6121772527694702,
0.6326315402984619,
-0.22188806533813477,
-0.16421836614608765,
-0.10173450410366058,
-0.6843002438545227,
-0.9683205485343933,
-0.8679669499397278,
-0.5433788895606995,
-0.19723759591579437,
-0.27093830704689026,
0.38758695125579834,
0.6204193234443665,
-0.8238997459411621,
-0.1676386296749115,
0.40924006700515747,
0.15615956485271454,
-0.39572957158088684,
-0.28157922625541687,
-0.07649609446525574,
-0.020734921097755432,
-0.8664031028747559,
0.5271175503730774,
0.3408333957195282,
0.28477004170417786,
-0.7965272068977356,
0.05029493570327759,
-0.27202308177948,
0.3230009078979492,
0.7265409827232361,
0.08422185480594635,
-0.845301628112793,
-0.25374385714530945,
0.07843777537345886,
-0.05663770064711571,
0.02470792829990387,
1.0898114442825317,
-0.49192988872528076,
0.6898692846298218,
0.19482389092445374,
0.5166056752204895,
0.35765668749809265,
-0.15127083659172058,
0.3587481379508972,
-1.1818349361419678,
0.22243982553482056,
0.21731063723564148,
0.14219726622104645,
0.6489704847335815,
-0.40751931071281433,
0.404231458902359,
0.5951033234596252,
-0.24908293783664703,
-0.722937285900116,
0.6134320497512817,
-0.8218920230865479,
-0.6444668173789978,
1.0631523132324219,
0.1633407175540924,
-0.03207932785153389,
-0.5484874248504639,
-0.16828468441963196,
-0.1125776395201683,
-0.08534375578165054,
0.6374285221099854,
0.8642436861991882,
0.034116096794605255,
-0.05501784011721611,
-0.42758306860923767,
0.5997536182403564,
-0.10122326761484146,
-0.8648535013198853,
0.14901357889175415,
0.7165055274963379,
0.16846323013305664,
0.755945086479187,
0.6173361539840698,
-0.04295241832733154,
0.17531216144561768,
0.1523100733757019,
0.06607640534639359,
0.12194399535655975,
-0.5528153777122498,
-0.3285250961780548,
0.29874688386917114,
-0.4919278621673584,
-0.27063998579978943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03862v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03862v1
|
Conformity, Confabulation, and Impersonation: Persona Inconstancy in Multi-Agent LLM Collaboration
| 2024-05-06T21:20:35 | 2024-05-06T21:20:35 |
Razan Baltaji, Babak Hemmatian, Lav R. Varshney
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7
|
This study explores the sources of instability in maintaining cultural
personas and opinions within multi-agent LLM systems. Drawing on simulations of
inter-cultural collaboration and debate, we analyze agents' pre- and
post-discussion private responses alongside chat transcripts to assess the
stability of cultural personas and the impact of opinion diversity on group
outcomes. Our findings suggest that multi-agent discussions can encourage
collective decisions that reflect diverse perspectives, yet this benefit is
tempered by the agents' susceptibility to conformity due to perceived peer
pressure and challenges in maintaining consistent personas and opinions.
Counterintuitively, instructions that encourage debate in support of one's
opinions increase the rate of inconstancy. Without addressing the factors we
identify, the full potential of multi-agent frameworks for producing more
culturally diverse AI outputs will remain untapped.
|
[
-0.6637756824493408,
-0.3065388798713684,
0.42237088084220886,
0.4066750705242157,
0.24313750863075256,
0.5443357825279236,
-0.06664680689573288,
-0.6259700655937195,
0.33138856291770935,
0.39186468720436096,
-0.5949845910072327,
-0.020732564851641655,
-0.6186644434928894,
0.17662565410137177,
0.1256762593984604,
1.2103217840194702,
0.10485119372606277,
0.21386736631393433,
-0.31042909622192383,
-0.8850671052932739,
-0.6157105565071106,
-0.7845466732978821,
-0.6514087915420532,
-0.4687860310077667,
0.39696887135505676,
0.5755235552787781,
0.9749951958656311,
-0.03384128957986832,
0.4200197160243988,
0.45688796043395996,
0.33808183670043945,
0.20702189207077026,
-0.7228113412857056,
0.7419463992118835,
-0.2516934275627136,
-0.3752744793891907,
-0.16974188387393951,
0.3836449980735779,
0.5052049160003662,
0.4830557703971863,
-0.13864411413669586,
0.0502646341919899,
0.1287255883216858,
0.5072078704833984,
-0.18766972422599792,
0.1799059957265854,
-0.6154846549034119,
-0.11551012843847275,
-0.050797201693058014,
0.07490376383066177,
-0.39795631170272827,
-0.6258167624473572,
0.39567381143569946,
-0.3304380178451538,
-0.01941267028450966,
-0.18830722570419312,
0.5928534269332886,
0.3850691318511963,
-0.38633471727371216,
-0.39688950777053833,
-1.1198241710662842,
0.3792857825756073,
-0.21946123242378235,
0.01931675709784031,
0.12949596345424652,
0.32418346405029297,
-0.2644118368625641,
-0.6054140329360962,
-0.6743747591972351,
-0.32744768261909485,
-0.14360113441944122,
0.383417010307312,
0.07254205644130707,
-0.14801453053951263,
0.07633715867996216,
0.04975029081106186,
-0.25352346897125244,
0.06115671247243881,
-0.16065527498722076,
-0.21575157344341278,
0.6163429021835327,
0.3403506875038147,
0.3215741515159607,
0.47286784648895264,
-0.2947538197040558,
-0.15126533806324005,
-0.6389359831809998,
0.23685427010059357,
0.5822376012802124,
-0.03720954433083534,
-0.20283885300159454,
0.14972810447216034,
0.021755866706371307,
-0.2088683843612671,
0.536972165107727,
-0.037362419068813324,
0.2572334408760071,
-0.23953330516815186,
-0.015613398514688015,
-0.17615090310573578,
0.7038897275924683,
0.46291211247444153,
0.3088933229446411,
-0.15224270522594452,
0.37087181210517883,
0.15964330732822418,
0.3709509074687958,
-0.6404180526733398,
-0.22969548404216766,
0.47949376702308655,
-0.43239226937294006,
0.10906805843114853,
0.5073928236961365,
-0.6420201063156128,
-0.803469717502594,
-0.27695608139038086,
0.017310835421085358,
-0.38167962431907654,
-0.31719353795051575,
-0.44672706723213196,
-0.2735464870929718,
0.22824454307556152,
0.9507884979248047,
-0.48824089765548706,
0.15259143710136414,
0.5804983973503113,
0.5057161450386047,
-0.1754230409860611,
-0.8199265599250793,
-0.1791854053735733,
0.3711361587047577,
-0.3332091271877289,
0.7888162732124329,
-0.5864576697349548,
-0.5643571019172668,
-0.1607358604669571,
0.24388571083545685,
-0.2794557511806488,
-0.5852463841438293,
0.03994791582226753,
-0.21928785741329193,
0.15529030561447144,
-0.43321484327316284,
-0.37105491757392883,
-0.003971925470978022,
0.5208866000175476,
-0.4778055250644684,
0.4034595787525177,
0.02311566472053528,
-0.4198072850704193,
0.3598800599575043,
-0.4283089339733124,
-0.08857905119657516,
0.3118809461593628,
-0.5724193453788757,
-0.16467638313770294,
-0.025152791291475296,
-0.3463870584964752,
0.10893670469522476,
-0.04420941695570946,
-0.14524726569652557,
-0.4825195074081421,
-0.3822038173675537,
0.7365496754646301,
-0.17145222425460815,
0.6261129379272461,
0.27064183354377747,
-0.3293391168117523,
0.2405661791563034,
-0.2435356229543686,
-0.13010680675506592,
-0.20406591892242432,
-0.2737906873226166,
-0.03323037922382355,
-0.0007076721522025764,
-0.3726489543914795,
0.42192551493644714,
0.13294851779937744,
-0.3167684078216553,
0.32361316680908203,
-0.15086573362350464,
0.2276938408613205,
1.0440183877944946,
0.29391056299209595,
0.5421403646469116,
-0.9792914390563965,
0.6712079644203186,
0.208146870136261,
0.3627750873565674,
-0.10830006003379822,
-0.6541973948478699,
-0.733340322971344,
0.006033816374838352,
-0.5320093631744385,
0.5682372450828552,
-0.9616928696632385,
-0.26177725195884705,
-0.23533901572227478,
-0.7597835063934326,
-0.589199423789978,
-0.06841067224740982,
0.40491846203804016,
0.11735023558139801,
-0.09475626796483994,
-0.4434109330177307,
-0.26300543546676636,
-0.8717749714851379,
-0.08589673787355423,
-0.6775941252708435,
0.2110844850540161,
0.2683265507221222,
0.4018498659133911,
-0.30219706892967224,
0.6783601641654968,
0.18261925876140594,
-0.20363914966583252,
-0.16407375037670135,
0.2560003399848938,
-0.10313374549150467,
0.7162927389144897,
0.7575398683547974,
-0.721627950668335,
-0.8781282305717468,
-0.03595397621393204,
-0.6175963878631592,
0.27639785408973694,
-0.2395940124988556,
-0.029664160683751106,
0.6622748970985413,
0.2981509864330292,
-0.46792489290237427,
0.3771672546863556,
0.5085012316703796,
-0.19252662360668182,
0.49234825372695923,
-0.11708150058984756,
0.613398551940918,
-0.9719690680503845,
-0.3660523593425751,
-0.11712416261434555,
-0.02885196916759014,
-0.7009928822517395,
0.10349074006080627,
-0.4867522716522217,
0.19591262936592102,
-0.33907991647720337,
0.22121208906173706,
-0.3286568820476532,
0.42085516452789307,
-0.21232333779335022,
0.008086283691227436,
-0.060432951897382736,
0.42798691987991333,
0.04403579235076904,
0.8612169027328491,
0.2589532434940338,
-0.5364083051681519,
0.3255549371242523,
0.5103780031204224,
-0.0006253931205719709,
1.0566072463989258,
-0.32090044021606445,
0.7072965502738953,
-0.39097440242767334,
0.3873511254787445,
-1.1177717447280884,
-0.3769683837890625,
0.4434506297111511,
-0.41790422797203064,
0.1876581311225891,
-0.17367206513881683,
-0.3588625490665436,
0.09315549582242966,
-0.5992668867111206,
0.3748152554035187,
0.18091537058353424,
-0.10148943215608597,
0.6750620603561401,
0.7109993696212769,
-0.16308556497097015,
-0.5686123371124268,
-0.8761747479438782,
0.14698533713817596,
-0.26480746269226074,
-0.827240526676178,
0.07370925694704056,
-0.7496179342269897,
-0.6606046557426453,
-0.28479626774787903,
0.2891424596309662,
0.08803105354309082,
0.029020415619015694,
0.5339251160621643,
0.08328612148761749,
0.06870810687541962,
-0.10630388557910919,
-0.38382717967033386,
0.1809641718864441,
-0.10726289451122284,
0.05644599348306656,
0.6208564043045044,
-0.5196779370307922,
-0.44978925585746765,
-0.45674532651901245,
0.6634454131126404,
0.9708254933357239,
0.13602332770824432,
1.0696011781692505,
0.05162680521607399,
-0.09607669711112976,
0.11032000929117203,
-0.7372125387191772,
-0.02257448434829712,
-0.44239339232444763,
0.10918042063713074,
-0.299272358417511,
-0.930417001247406,
1.065159559249878,
0.04425307735800743,
0.25872233510017395,
0.02841147780418396,
0.8052724599838257,
-0.3229200541973114,
0.5898352265357971,
0.47258642315864563,
0.24360986053943634,
0.35175442695617676,
0.07607662677764893,
-0.0051525551825761795,
-0.5375352501869202,
-0.5743799209594727,
-0.5259971618652344,
-0.7155985832214355,
-1.0517187118530273,
-0.20072582364082336,
0.5223828554153442,
-0.7469161748886108,
-0.35564568638801575,
-0.001524357940070331,
-0.3353189527988434,
0.3217287063598633,
0.4121508002281189,
-0.11103016883134842,
0.2374257743358612,
-0.39033523201942444,
0.1960715353488922,
-0.2733405530452728,
-0.31383803486824036,
-0.589470386505127,
0.6415662169456482,
0.32496264576911926,
0.7224830389022827,
0.7468256950378418,
0.3886641561985016,
0.3539923131465912,
0.8531772494316101,
-0.5118753910064697,
0.4633435606956482,
0.08698570728302002,
-0.6298482418060303,
-0.2665870487689972,
-0.08322100341320038,
-0.9129511713981628,
0.38236355781555176,
-0.2993987500667572,
-0.8581958413124084,
0.5993780493736267,
-0.007272057700902224,
-0.21011735498905182,
0.06056082621216774,
-0.5700793266296387,
0.7284877300262451,
0.2053673416376114,
-0.44093745946884155,
-0.0498630665242672,
-1.0584660768508911,
0.4723181128501892,
-0.051528047770261765,
0.2576148808002472,
-0.17822706699371338,
0.12931543588638306,
0.2168683409690857,
-0.421879380941391,
0.916926920413971,
-0.006872628349810839,
-0.14459103345870972,
0.3081537187099457,
0.4159051775932312,
0.45712628960609436,
0.21292851865291595,
-0.3040456175804138,
0.30551791191101074,
0.091581791639328,
-0.1813526600599289,
-0.5415223240852356,
0.6455636024475098,
-1.2241100072860718,
-1.005335807800293,
-0.449378103017807,
-0.7265111207962036,
-0.3398435115814209,
-0.2672247588634491,
0.348705917596817,
-0.03457675501704216,
-0.4288455545902252,
0.26897454261779785,
0.5438051819801331,
0.09125367552042007,
0.4555344879627228,
0.6607756614685059,
-0.009285036474466324,
-0.8091440200805664,
0.5216055512428284,
0.4158811569213867,
0.6072582602500916,
-0.2350592017173767,
-0.19497255980968475,
0.2057260423898697,
-0.44683435559272766,
-0.197120800614357,
0.028662383556365967,
-0.7141221165657043,
0.019628332927823067,
-0.4571033716201782,
-0.15619640052318573,
-0.6390737295150757,
-0.08502262085676193,
-0.3147420883178711,
-0.4548114538192749,
0.12440188974142075,
0.08773504197597504,
-0.15199798345565796,
0.8187029957771301,
0.0710635855793953,
0.42890268564224243,
-0.7275201678276062,
-0.2543913424015045,
0.17454290390014648,
-0.013386258855462074,
-0.17158862948417664,
-0.4150111675262451,
-0.32876625657081604,
-0.07087145000696182,
-0.5734429359436035,
-1.1502881050109863,
-0.11827565729618073,
0.06788375973701477,
0.6904475688934326,
0.5634645223617554,
0.24644723534584045,
0.62067711353302,
-0.24111852049827576,
0.9913671016693115,
-0.06045541912317276,
-0.7807588577270508,
0.24912959337234497,
-0.3444545865058899,
0.23355340957641602,
0.7865993976593018,
0.20048704743385315,
-0.866454541683197,
-1.1620306968688965,
-0.6700701117515564,
-0.5537557601928711,
0.8094056248664856,
0.21996615827083588,
0.345122367143631,
0.009899408556520939,
0.38615289330482483,
0.3582518994808197,
0.4522882401943207,
-0.8278165459632874,
-0.7153473496437073,
-0.2987441420555115,
0.08392906934022903,
0.14462724328041077,
-0.2659548819065094,
-0.7528417706489563,
-0.04624127596616745,
0.4627992510795593,
-0.19717732071876526,
-0.14260359108448029,
0.18998949229717255,
0.14864422380924225,
-0.2549419403076172,
0.17719119787216187,
0.8014464974403381,
1.012435793876648,
0.12353849411010742,
0.18782825767993927,
0.13085362315177917,
-0.5630689859390259,
0.5324923396110535,
-0.07742145657539368,
-0.07960876822471619,
-0.27176618576049805,
0.27158573269844055,
0.5197756886482239,
-0.22576342523097992,
-0.10895796120166779,
0.399872362613678,
-0.5483139753341675,
-0.07696586847305298,
-0.5360847115516663,
0.11536450684070587,
-0.05754472315311432,
0.4623540937900543,
0.2583019733428955,
0.5184065103530884,
-0.2772611677646637,
-1.2225241661071777,
0.11824377626180649,
0.6723296642303467,
-0.1321718692779541,
-0.39074358344078064,
0.6821805834770203,
0.2155948430299759,
-0.3486236035823822,
0.453487753868103,
-0.12471400201320648,
-0.19960810244083405,
0.7084121108055115,
0.16673871874809265,
0.9599778056144714,
-0.6768090128898621,
0.497334748506546,
-0.22798876464366913,
0.639920711517334,
0.11844637244939804,
-0.07303986698389053,
0.21595044434070587,
-1.1039166450500488,
-0.01822330802679062,
-0.06116895750164986,
-1.014290452003479,
-0.06974522024393082,
-0.3405750095844269,
0.13411283493041992,
-0.7635934352874756,
-0.3464924693107605,
-0.3972882032394409,
-0.10237991809844971,
-0.4386034309864044,
-0.12093374878168106,
0.15468497574329376,
0.3954930603504181,
-0.5827990174293518,
0.8160762190818787,
0.8998275399208069,
-0.6507593393325806,
-0.6711236238479614,
0.5866693258285522,
0.16415807604789734,
-0.49523383378982544,
0.3167111873626709,
0.14650006592273712,
-0.2998815178871155,
-0.4552712142467499,
-0.7626059055328369,
-0.7924138307571411,
1.1496665477752686,
0.837414026260376,
-0.1185653880238533,
0.34160858392715454,
0.24046429991722107,
0.7100661396980286,
-0.6630857586860657,
0.23691591620445251,
0.3036061227321625,
0.5242824554443359,
0.4915481507778168,
-1.1431587934494019,
0.07093055546283722,
-0.2592087984085083,
-0.2640891373157501,
-0.2630251944065094,
-1.5212557315826416,
0.9225344061851501,
-0.03797551617026329,
-0.2678293287754059,
0.10734616965055466,
0.6741943359375,
0.5314607620239258,
0.5845243334770203,
0.47012364864349365,
0.12456990778446198,
0.9550620317459106,
-0.055855657905340195,
0.7840346097946167,
-0.46325141191482544,
0.004503211006522179,
1.2292122840881348,
-0.7151652574539185,
0.27663716673851013,
0.4970850944519043,
-0.14215008914470673,
0.9622994065284729,
0.478839635848999,
-0.010154680348932743,
0.20903673768043518,
-0.07261112332344055,
-0.31617629528045654,
-0.05010110139846802,
-0.10738450288772583,
-0.41262537240982056,
0.4827723205089569,
0.21833963692188263,
0.06701192259788513,
0.24643976986408234,
-0.11535526067018509,
0.25423556566238403,
0.23005077242851257,
-0.03421736881136894,
0.8762834668159485,
-0.05649995058774948,
-1.0500314235687256,
-0.00010104409011546522,
-0.29788723587989807,
0.32796889543533325,
-0.5750909447669983,
-0.0125894695520401,
-0.4208068549633026,
0.0565304234623909,
-0.2814367413520813,
-0.6359211206436157,
0.5442110300064087,
-0.5850846171379089,
-0.3988777697086334,
-0.38285231590270996,
0.32803580164909363,
-0.48222970962524414,
-0.07257091253995895,
0.22029779851436615,
0.7604142427444458,
0.2349170297384262,
0.19076687097549438,
-0.4475073516368866,
0.14652210474014282,
-0.21933552622795105,
-0.10264788568019867,
0.5147477984428406,
0.6543625593185425,
-0.030292997136712074,
0.6295391321182251,
0.27810442447662354,
-0.14769428968429565,
-0.15572071075439453,
0.0013002344639971852,
0.8313239216804504,
-0.09473439306020737,
-0.37040039896965027,
-1.0232138633728027,
0.6187567710876465,
-0.1355145424604416,
-0.033546630293130875,
0.9114829897880554,
0.2539404034614563,
0.7918401956558228,
-0.04707055166363716,
0.7552523612976074,
0.04581525921821594,
0.08051655441522598,
-0.20540554821491241,
0.8733150959014893,
-0.2795710265636444,
0.41268855333328247,
-0.3479413390159607,
-0.6317349076271057,
0.10976965725421906,
0.3038279414176941,
0.03840910643339157,
0.2306198626756668,
0.7961963415145874,
0.5516783595085144,
0.5663239359855652,
0.14453253149986267,
0.26240554451942444,
0.29515665769577026,
0.5669192671775818,
0.5648741722106934,
1.1140568256378174,
0.15324179828166962,
0.5092077255249023,
-0.11406922340393066,
-0.1449328511953354,
0.11604806780815125,
-0.6655020117759705,
-0.7627464532852173,
-0.7517586946487427,
-0.5531429648399353,
-0.7164385914802551,
-0.20404744148254395,
1.1611225605010986,
0.5873657464981079,
-0.743136465549469,
-0.46220195293426514,
0.30592432618141174,
0.33140474557876587,
-0.11261387169361115,
-0.2799624502658844,
-0.15876692533493042,
-0.17686690390110016,
-1.1760823726654053,
0.17401258647441864,
0.4630124568939209,
0.33149904012680054,
-0.6396359801292419,
-0.18436460196971893,
-0.06955258548259735,
0.49164700508117676,
0.22814229130744934,
0.381780743598938,
-0.6261926889419556,
-0.5174176096916199,
-0.35992637276649475,
-0.11037793755531311,
0.36711493134498596,
0.796700119972229,
-0.5144450664520264,
0.36878514289855957,
0.13600511848926544,
0.27833688259124756,
0.00314150657504797,
0.3434965908527374,
0.7635446190834045,
-0.8210989236831665,
0.43197542428970337,
0.21441549062728882,
0.3891947865486145,
0.3769456148147583,
-0.6510001420974731,
0.46884480118751526,
0.49073323607444763,
-1.028280258178711,
-0.5590423345565796,
0.5309237241744995,
-0.6714617013931274,
-0.11853734403848648,
0.8692706227302551,
-0.43795159459114075,
0.07788416743278503,
-0.39564889669418335,
-0.20388352870941162,
-0.10376077890396118,
-0.5487821102142334,
1.0090383291244507,
1.2464072704315186,
-0.8546342253684998,
-0.18330880999565125,
-0.2495744228363037,
0.6313403248786926,
0.20747804641723633,
-0.7826437950134277,
-0.15154290199279785,
0.8438982367515564,
0.19677942991256714,
0.5250119566917419,
0.9422982931137085,
0.17231887578964233,
0.13292010128498077,
-0.17141026258468628,
-0.34277579188346863,
0.04169658571481705,
-0.3492186367511749,
-0.14009800553321838,
0.6327172517776489,
0.18231435120105743,
0.017658906057476997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03845v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03845v1
|
Self-Improving Customer Review Response Generation Based on LLMs
| 2024-05-06T20:50:17 | 2024-05-06T20:50:17 |
Guy Azov, Tatiana Pelc, Adi Fledel Alon, Gila Kamhi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Previous studies have demonstrated that proactive interaction with user
reviews has a positive impact on the perception of app users and encourages
them to submit revised ratings. Nevertheless, developers encounter challenges
in managing a high volume of reviews, particularly in the case of popular apps
with a substantial influx of daily reviews. Consequently, there is a demand for
automated solutions aimed at streamlining the process of responding to user
reviews. To address this, we have developed a new system for generating
automatic responses by leveraging user-contributed documents with the help of
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) and advanced Large Language Models (LLMs).
Our solution, named SCRABLE, represents an adaptive customer review response
automation that enhances itself with self-optimizing prompts and a judging
mechanism based on LLMs. Additionally, we introduce an automatic scoring
mechanism that mimics the role of a human evaluator to assess the quality of
responses generated in customer review domains. Extensive experiments and
analyses conducted on real-world datasets reveal that our method is effective
in producing high-quality responses, yielding improvement of more than 8.5%
compared to the baseline. Further validation through manual examination of the
generated responses underscores the efficacy our proposed system.
|
[
-0.5321568846702576,
-0.3364814221858978,
0.4093850553035736,
0.41851043701171875,
-0.10732648521661758,
0.25973376631736755,
0.06305474042892456,
-0.4545179009437561,
0.6603267788887024,
0.8431764245033264,
-0.6391459703445435,
-0.22262795269489288,
-0.11327511072158813,
0.3989424705505371,
-0.2729572653770447,
1.2431910037994385,
-0.13391625881195068,
-0.07020952552556992,
-0.38077279925346375,
-0.16220444440841675,
-0.5141692161560059,
-0.2658643424510956,
-0.5055128335952759,
-0.23496444523334503,
0.5870621800422668,
0.8309085965156555,
0.4176919460296631,
-0.01530629862099886,
0.6676990389823914,
0.3446769416332245,
0.2911081314086914,
0.4507911205291748,
-0.32459861040115356,
0.6963931918144226,
-0.1430358588695526,
0.03340199962258339,
-0.6643911004066467,
-0.0519925095140934,
0.21997639536857605,
0.11461449414491653,
-0.38689151406288147,
0.5670811533927917,
0.3995095491409302,
1.0214999914169312,
-0.5127987265586853,
-0.1777271032333374,
-0.4747646152973175,
-0.0670730397105217,
0.28889021277427673,
-0.5188536047935486,
-0.1729532778263092,
-0.5602448582649231,
-0.0812072679400444,
-0.4212793707847595,
0.21956202387809753,
-0.07938343286514282,
0.6561423540115356,
0.18387238681316376,
-0.13098444044589996,
-0.6347488760948181,
-0.9536231756210327,
0.4067653715610504,
-0.5245012044906616,
0.10752925276756287,
0.19785228371620178,
0.559353768825531,
-0.24107956886291504,
-0.5504006743431091,
-0.45653265714645386,
-0.5138261318206787,
-0.02549605816602707,
0.5591543316841125,
-0.28770342469215393,
-0.3165190815925598,
0.196266770362854,
0.3130212724208832,
-0.5177592039108276,
0.006019947584718466,
-0.3156623840332031,
-0.3311862349510193,
1.0170679092407227,
0.5604130625724792,
-0.09077662229537964,
-0.394398957490921,
-0.44652649760246277,
-0.011735906824469566,
-0.4241594970226288,
0.29541927576065063,
0.37923696637153625,
0.027721518650650978,
0.4002223610877991,
0.648769736289978,
-0.5789998769760132,
0.4770818054676056,
0.3300390839576721,
0.12332914024591446,
0.288722962141037,
-0.31428325176239014,
-0.17388294637203217,
-0.12262751907110214,
0.8508238792419434,
0.7873364090919495,
0.03316044062376022,
0.08522148430347443,
-0.705479085445404,
0.1920861452817917,
0.49853047728538513,
-0.7130746245384216,
-0.07571762800216675,
0.4080093502998352,
-0.4259300231933594,
-0.4300200939178467,
0.0941288098692894,
-0.5622212290763855,
-0.5952441096305847,
-0.3140573799610138,
0.19332242012023926,
0.015069149434566498,
-0.07585707306861877,
0.001617061672732234,
0.20660847425460815,
0.012537403963506222,
0.5318045616149902,
-0.5849388837814331,
0.4090326428413391,
0.31839925050735474,
0.35656484961509705,
-0.37153542041778564,
-0.19412030279636383,
-0.8384049534797668,
0.16190394759178162,
-0.2719685733318329,
1.3920972347259521,
-0.24935194849967957,
-0.5633502006530762,
-0.11410374939441681,
-0.27646031975746155,
0.26042407751083374,
-0.8605546355247498,
0.6218580007553101,
-0.6039931178092957,
0.21132005751132965,
-0.08063716441392899,
-0.40080687403678894,
0.24940918385982513,
0.5861734747886658,
-0.402110755443573,
1.2134675979614258,
0.2765788435935974,
-0.5707356929779053,
0.10261355340480804,
-0.5370264649391174,
-0.294082373380661,
0.3671543598175049,
-0.053749050945043564,
-0.5831270217895508,
0.5469468832015991,
0.486504465341568,
0.3219252824783325,
-0.32298168540000916,
-0.06780914962291718,
-0.1342049390077591,
-0.11960656940937042,
0.5078848004341125,
-0.1343766301870346,
0.1848280429840088,
0.6803417801856995,
-0.010680239647626877,
0.3997264504432678,
-0.6635764837265015,
0.2771512567996979,
0.17074646055698395,
-0.5717988610267639,
0.08746806532144547,
-0.20914602279663086,
0.03764614462852478,
0.2825901210308075,
0.2521166205406189,
-0.6411277651786804,
0.30630064010620117,
-0.31770554184913635,
0.1296817809343338,
0.8323635458946228,
0.49990180134773254,
0.45995035767555237,
-0.2961006164550781,
0.8551537394523621,
-0.1727883368730545,
0.5207024216651917,
-0.3614925444126129,
-0.15164509415626526,
-0.8146310448646545,
0.10750712454319,
0.227637380361557,
0.38509073853492737,
-0.6458683013916016,
0.517581045627594,
-0.1821257621049881,
-0.6799170970916748,
-0.43170830607414246,
0.5385504364967346,
0.32794469594955444,
0.6363756060600281,
0.1502334475517273,
-0.5982836484909058,
-0.4530595541000366,
-0.678442120552063,
-0.48469632863998413,
-0.41722190380096436,
-0.2915877103805542,
0.6957957744598389,
0.04438810050487518,
-0.46864309906959534,
1.1377180814743042,
-0.723636269569397,
-0.5042012929916382,
-0.25950193405151367,
0.06342145800590515,
0.08063957840204239,
-0.045506615191698074,
0.17978686094284058,
-0.4734620451927185,
-0.7938818335533142,
-0.07890281081199646,
-0.47399866580963135,
-0.6412073969841003,
-0.12716221809387207,
-0.026808710768818855,
0.5234530568122864,
0.39200496673583984,
-0.39345186948776245,
0.37264928221702576,
0.505649983882904,
-0.18162137269973755,
0.9410917162895203,
-0.3359682261943817,
0.3078015446662903,
-1.0171865224838257,
-0.028519263491034508,
-0.00638407189399004,
-0.29139769077301025,
-0.3445194363594055,
-0.20608556270599365,
0.08035814017057419,
-0.31214872002601624,
-0.3662237524986267,
0.6019613146781921,
-0.37385842204093933,
-0.3924272656440735,
-0.5717493295669556,
0.15957938134670258,
0.179385244846344,
0.31534385681152344,
-0.30685245990753174,
0.701597273349762,
0.07214614003896713,
-0.7139944434165955,
0.4587411880493164,
0.2645561993122101,
-0.34602198004722595,
0.795045018196106,
-0.7674268484115601,
0.07860270887613297,
-0.08368949592113495,
0.44165170192718506,
-1.2663415670394897,
-0.39419692754745483,
0.4311084449291229,
-0.5501102209091187,
-0.19942031800746918,
0.08468416333198547,
-0.4154456853866577,
-0.8147920966148376,
-0.3560253083705902,
-0.25931015610694885,
0.4030696451663971,
-0.4938460886478424,
0.9754104018211365,
0.3040514588356018,
-0.5437493920326233,
-0.12210925668478012,
-0.22916381061077118,
0.46549248695373535,
0.01054778229445219,
-0.6466246843338013,
0.019481616094708443,
-0.35845643281936646,
-0.11360635608434677,
-0.2829306423664093,
-0.20469768345355988,
0.1942519247531891,
-0.09473719447851181,
0.252151221036911,
0.0956847071647644,
0.06929002702236176,
0.178693488240242,
-0.1194496676325798,
-0.4575692117214203,
0.13030390441417694,
-0.06144515424966812,
0.5323827862739563,
-0.13355232775211334,
-0.20848418772220612,
-0.5947259664535522,
0.20617461204528809,
0.6974121928215027,
-0.49550002813339233,
-0.24908898770809174,
0.3832797706127167,
0.01882469467818737,
-0.20369890332221985,
-0.8330731987953186,
-0.43240487575531006,
-0.5416428446769714,
0.09974057972431183,
-0.5430049896240234,
-0.7059633135795593,
0.521213173866272,
-0.14696602523326874,
0.050834011286497116,
0.33955129981040955,
0.7752841114997864,
-0.4780386984348297,
1.2931838035583496,
0.2514432370662689,
0.022015856578946114,
0.6025530099868774,
0.07892734557390213,
0.09875000268220901,
-0.78836590051651,
-0.22634422779083252,
-0.6732931137084961,
-0.1565033346414566,
-0.3371521234512329,
-0.054777465760707855,
0.4601939618587494,
-0.02792535349726677,
0.0353422649204731,
0.22861751914024353,
-0.6969285607337952,
0.35076871514320374,
0.2830589711666107,
0.024693448096513748,
0.35197126865386963,
0.35315021872520447,
-0.1407594233751297,
0.0244816392660141,
-0.4787029027938843,
-0.591598391532898,
0.7784340977668762,
0.4638393819332123,
1.1215476989746094,
0.013945827260613441,
0.9506394863128662,
0.565045952796936,
0.7410873770713806,
-0.6834102272987366,
0.6660158038139343,
0.11498716473579407,
-0.07907862961292267,
-0.16922269761562347,
-0.4798264503479004,
-0.80051589012146,
0.06784907728433609,
-0.45621681213378906,
-0.2685995399951935,
-0.05956581234931946,
0.3022153377532959,
-0.5534590482711792,
-0.3018706440925598,
-0.7097205519676208,
0.37324783205986023,
-0.6081058979034424,
-0.5168071389198303,
-0.11424650251865387,
-0.2566699683666229,
0.11416468769311905,
-0.1700524538755417,
0.08142178505659103,
-0.13738372921943665,
0.1957380175590515,
0.5752742290496826,
-0.6737018823623657,
0.635934591293335,
-0.38465848565101624,
-0.3545489013195038,
0.48873093724250793,
0.48575061559677124,
0.7057568430900574,
0.1208174005150795,
-0.05305084213614464,
-0.23293918371200562,
-0.2675904631614685,
-0.11796821653842926,
-0.8726823329925537,
0.8384365439414978,
-0.46656960248947144,
-0.5582613348960876,
-0.4662816822528839,
-0.3750822842121124,
-0.2922614514827728,
0.2600340247154236,
-0.01951425150036812,
0.2519364655017853,
-0.07652989029884338,
-0.11861714720726013,
0.2682163417339325,
-0.16377823054790497,
0.4049457609653473,
0.9547474384307861,
-0.5346308946609497,
-1.028849482536316,
0.6910523772239685,
-0.07911153882741928,
0.011774610728025436,
-0.33377915620803833,
0.4064358174800873,
-0.5947853922843933,
-0.29709163308143616,
-0.6350643634796143,
0.16711410880088806,
-0.44405239820480347,
-0.5961369872093201,
-0.7417753338813782,
-0.08577108383178711,
-0.5091025233268738,
0.11441301554441452,
-0.32284489274024963,
-0.3151966333389282,
-0.09198907017707825,
0.03758348897099495,
0.1997596025466919,
1.1183056831359863,
0.2032703161239624,
0.2601889669895172,
-1.0447487831115723,
0.5669590830802917,
0.45729541778564453,
0.5973954796791077,
0.05369333550333977,
-0.6355761885643005,
-0.35630372166633606,
-0.17841672897338867,
-0.5529588460922241,
-0.6712351441383362,
0.45789486169815063,
0.05334911122918129,
0.5958310961723328,
0.17013335227966309,
0.24615927040576935,
0.7260503172874451,
-0.5427941083908081,
0.721900999546051,
0.2782942056655884,
-0.6256175637245178,
0.6998282074928284,
-0.30006057024002075,
0.4049225449562073,
0.645892322063446,
0.08372903615236282,
-0.5184246897697449,
-0.5265757441520691,
-0.4301653802394867,
-0.9149554967880249,
0.3569173514842987,
0.12944769859313965,
0.39300546050071716,
0.07718603312969208,
0.5939732193946838,
0.057142142206430435,
0.009079072624444962,
-0.5046743154525757,
0.11626863479614258,
-0.21917688846588135,
-0.0637437254190445,
-0.1749904453754425,
-0.4919457733631134,
0.02888609655201435,
0.022663196548819542,
0.6636791229248047,
-0.2368643432855606,
0.07164560258388519,
0.4576115906238556,
-0.1590758115053177,
-0.48987603187561035,
0.253979355096817,
0.48309510946273804,
0.5562751889228821,
-0.09439612925052643,
-0.25107696652412415,
-0.00017764302901923656,
-0.3978513479232788,
0.16786739230155945,
-0.12198459357023239,
-0.23881672322750092,
-0.22715815901756287,
-0.18508566915988922,
0.325575053691864,
-0.1382668912410736,
-0.5145071744918823,
0.4346536099910736,
-0.6109315156936646,
-0.21549415588378906,
-0.4366448223590851,
0.15128178894519806,
-0.09417922049760818,
0.18567660450935364,
0.6864331960678101,
0.2416244000196457,
0.3033333420753479,
-0.19969028234481812,
0.35855114459991455,
0.37869498133659363,
-0.48692524433135986,
-0.01723019778728485,
0.4184064269065857,
0.6315840482711792,
-0.6872671246528625,
0.37289291620254517,
-0.09169894456863403,
-0.536985456943512,
0.2394036054611206,
0.5770040154457092,
1.1820526123046875,
-0.49344852566719055,
0.31325551867485046,
0.38809627294540405,
0.07275956869125366,
0.1765112280845642,
0.2887668311595917,
-0.28705814480781555,
-0.4015527367591858,
-0.26937487721443176,
-0.9033335447311401,
-0.7360055446624756,
-0.12726174294948578,
-0.7207170128822327,
0.2139226794242859,
-0.5088968873023987,
-0.3081098794937134,
-0.08789806067943573,
0.129861518740654,
-0.4135452210903168,
0.36939433217048645,
-0.05930369347333908,
0.8857500553131104,
-0.694389283657074,
0.39915165305137634,
0.6094497442245483,
-0.45158371329307556,
-0.7366704344749451,
0.2420758754014969,
-0.2974829077720642,
-0.36871451139450073,
0.5979871153831482,
0.30326685309410095,
-0.7024430632591248,
-0.05805138871073723,
-0.2855609953403473,
-0.5870017409324646,
0.8116401433944702,
0.05097762495279312,
-0.6842187643051147,
0.730370283126831,
0.1796061098575592,
0.9682539105415344,
-0.5596180558204651,
0.375623494386673,
0.30665141344070435,
0.11297588050365448,
0.07882781326770782,
-0.6680794358253479,
-0.12353169918060303,
-0.5273334383964539,
0.14125701785087585,
-0.08253558725118637,
-0.4790859818458557,
0.2599831819534302,
0.08414652943611145,
-0.1205926388502121,
0.2767932415008545,
0.7838038802146912,
0.4131017029285431,
0.5171101689338684,
0.6385555863380432,
0.37647953629493713,
0.4933204650878906,
0.27351096272468567,
1.0581328868865967,
-0.5507368445396423,
0.2015278935432434,
1.2449939250946045,
-0.741305947303772,
1.0762536525726318,
0.487880676984787,
0.04166397079825401,
0.688837468624115,
0.5718291401863098,
-0.013655352406203747,
0.19157789647579193,
0.3937395215034485,
-0.25356611609458923,
-0.26122575998306274,
-0.20474079251289368,
-0.08104685693979263,
0.5636000037193298,
0.138286292552948,
-0.2575197219848633,
-0.15474125742912292,
0.02091551199555397,
-0.38087204098701477,
0.4058224558830261,
-0.4592772126197815,
1.2347577810287476,
-0.1820867955684662,
-1.0950863361358643,
0.6570132374763489,
0.012145103886723518,
0.6024569272994995,
-0.5624406337738037,
0.11599081009626389,
-0.6822111010551453,
0.26793110370635986,
-0.5338392853736877,
-0.9382701516151428,
0.2156652808189392,
0.36757218837738037,
-0.3132111430168152,
-0.4670472741127014,
0.9765480756759644,
-0.09653905034065247,
-0.6171908974647522,
0.28387096524238586,
0.5357683897018433,
0.16438783705234528,
-0.04889298602938652,
-0.8495286107063293,
0.1029198095202446,
-0.011707747355103493,
-0.5186770558357239,
0.06366252154111862,
-0.03253322094678879,
-0.26536303758621216,
0.7829921245574951,
0.8566235899925232,
-0.010714089497923851,
-0.15677258372306824,
0.3828260004520416,
1.033063530921936,
-0.640309751033783,
-0.7561993598937988,
-0.4377003312110901,
0.46762630343437195,
-0.27356836199760437,
-0.2539820373058319,
1.0127489566802979,
0.7448868155479431,
0.4663675129413605,
-0.21241018176078796,
0.7781498432159424,
0.403618186712265,
1.0031648874282837,
-0.17971467971801758,
0.7600493431091309,
-0.5208665132522583,
0.6532547473907471,
-0.33846941590309143,
-1.3164453506469727,
-0.45840349793434143,
0.36540305614471436,
-0.1333775520324707,
0.052702415734529495,
0.30788999795913696,
0.966109037399292,
0.08621248602867126,
-0.25612011551856995,
0.044468626379966736,
0.23297156393527985,
0.4697157144546509,
0.15863190591335297,
1.1192724704742432,
-0.4253067076206207,
0.812738835811615,
0.07959365844726562,
-0.2750612199306488,
-0.454123854637146,
-0.8731566071510315,
-0.6214970350265503,
-0.20656776428222656,
-0.2644069492816925,
-0.8086092472076416,
0.00609951838850975,
0.8133425116539001,
0.2982633411884308,
-0.7677128314971924,
-0.430012583732605,
-0.047560226172208786,
-0.34393197298049927,
0.044542692601680756,
-0.2325805276632309,
0.11011207103729248,
-0.6011316180229187,
-0.3788256049156189,
0.3477976620197296,
0.4360097646713257,
0.02070668339729309,
-0.48057225346565247,
-0.5918598175048828,
0.5211772322654724,
0.34460100531578064,
0.5911832451820374,
0.3023964464664459,
-0.5520457029342651,
-0.15896837413311005,
0.35770076513290405,
-0.4344620704650879,
0.06089205667376518,
0.779649019241333,
-0.8643316030502319,
0.6197896003723145,
0.562242329120636,
0.33443543314933777,
0.5825787782669067,
0.2894754409790039,
0.42055243253707886,
-0.5645903944969177,
-0.5615609884262085,
0.3977586627006531,
0.09672349691390991,
0.41615036129951477,
-0.35479971766471863,
0.3089907765388489,
-0.12602192163467407,
-0.7624098062515259,
-0.7852269411087036,
0.49573203921318054,
-0.8818349838256836,
0.010168849490582943,
1.0577796697616577,
0.07161068171262741,
-0.202944815158844,
-0.0019936594180762768,
-0.6262744665145874,
-0.22799630463123322,
-0.501639723777771,
1.1497682332992554,
0.24266067147254944,
-0.5833485126495361,
-0.03229374811053276,
-0.05137064307928085,
0.44918566942214966,
0.4479197859764099,
-1.0006331205368042,
0.2819587290287018,
0.6547393798828125,
0.4925720989704132,
0.2133675515651703,
0.9374099373817444,
-0.13067765533924103,
0.5561604499816895,
-0.4849231243133545,
0.20456409454345703,
-0.132127583026886,
-0.4255322217941284,
-0.6300503015518188,
0.16712114214897156,
0.20699217915534973,
0.09919174015522003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03832v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03832v3
|
Guylingo: The Republic of Guyana Creole Corpora
| 2024-05-06T20:30:14 | 2024-07-02T21:23:32 |
Christopher Clarke, Roland Daynauth, Charlene Wilkinson, Hubert Devonish, Jason Mars
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While major languages often enjoy substantial attention and resources, the
linguistic diversity across the globe encompasses a multitude of smaller,
indigenous, and regional languages that lack the same level of computational
support. One such region is the Caribbean. While commonly labeled as "English
speaking", the ex-British Caribbean region consists of a myriad of Creole
languages thriving alongside English. In this paper, we present Guylingo: a
comprehensive corpus designed for advancing NLP research in the domain of
Creolese (Guyanese English-lexicon Creole), the most widely spoken language in
the culturally rich nation of Guyana. We first outline our framework for
gathering and digitizing this diverse corpus, inclusive of colloquial
expressions, idioms, and regional variations in a low-resource language. We
then demonstrate the challenges of training and evaluating NLP models for
machine translation in Creole. Lastly, we discuss the unique opportunities
presented by recent NLP advancements for accelerating the formal adoption of
Creole languages as official languages in the Caribbean.
|
[
-0.4151700735092163,
-0.6733698844909668,
0.31130871176719666,
0.5227903127670288,
-0.23111535608768463,
0.7330800890922546,
-0.745076596736908,
-0.4998387396335602,
0.6556010842323303,
0.7900766134262085,
0.05140204355120659,
-0.5038164258003235,
-0.7852250337600708,
0.7597786784172058,
-0.3329794108867645,
0.9136466383934021,
0.05477206036448479,
0.012468935921788216,
0.20240387320518494,
0.06960014253854752,
-0.37448251247406006,
-0.6307434439659119,
-0.9048143625259399,
0.2146703600883484,
0.6598248481750488,
0.4581787884235382,
0.6416046023368835,
0.4100487232208252,
0.56409752368927,
0.3778473734855652,
-0.0697782039642334,
0.5626065135002136,
-0.40248048305511475,
-0.01517584640532732,
-0.21072697639465332,
-0.6424999833106995,
-0.3798574209213257,
-0.2708108723163605,
0.36768853664398193,
0.7461039423942566,
-0.39922896027565,
-0.07531355321407318,
-0.2715929448604584,
0.5955880284309387,
-0.4066285490989685,
0.5705617666244507,
-0.7021272778511047,
0.009853011928498745,
-0.23959308862686157,
-0.2992798984050751,
-0.15921801328659058,
-0.6537148356437683,
0.014537198469042778,
-0.5958341956138611,
0.13149693608283997,
0.11280830204486847,
0.5775183439254761,
-0.16730302572250366,
-0.44197070598602295,
-0.3652592599391937,
-0.5214249491691589,
0.6248859167098999,
-0.4127378761768341,
0.44894492626190186,
0.7739904522895813,
0.42131054401397705,
0.008731693960726261,
-0.6972587704658508,
-0.7088667154312134,
0.0020530722104012966,
-0.159723162651062,
0.1265081912279129,
-0.09961701184511185,
0.052514467388391495,
-0.4125537574291229,
0.24331991374492645,
-0.6142693161964417,
-0.07508690655231476,
-0.7687831521034241,
0.025196729227900505,
0.712091326713562,
-0.08632224798202515,
0.5466959476470947,
-0.26051580905914307,
0.2533632218837738,
0.212957501411438,
-0.44152843952178955,
-0.14447742700576782,
0.6087164282798767,
0.808391273021698,
-0.1565183848142624,
0.4835422933101654,
0.2447807937860489,
0.8779895305633545,
-0.08193065971136093,
-0.16669420897960663,
0.014987404458224773,
-0.27690258622169495,
-0.2228361815214157,
0.06659700721502304,
0.5249334573745728,
0.18973931670188904,
0.43813422322273254,
-0.17079217731952667,
-0.03320327401161194,
-0.3823114335536957,
0.20614248514175415,
-0.39025336503982544,
-0.3967669904232025,
0.26417407393455505,
-0.2368960976600647,
-0.019951261579990387,
-0.05862759053707123,
-0.7423597574234009,
-0.006003816612064838,
-0.49920526146888733,
-0.5822311639785767,
-0.5162895321846008,
-0.3670555055141449,
0.11582061648368835,
0.0422871895134449,
0.07736009359359741,
0.35590651631355286,
-1.5212091207504272,
0.2825009226799011,
0.8660740256309509,
0.9951647520065308,
-0.15950807929039001,
-0.3154841363430023,
-0.37209099531173706,
0.01745631732046604,
-0.74444180727005,
0.7523306608200073,
-0.9513763785362244,
-0.745050311088562,
0.12169221043586731,
0.3315277099609375,
-0.23812268674373627,
-0.5156453251838684,
0.7277334928512573,
-0.5964136123657227,
0.2676195204257965,
-0.08628550171852112,
-0.3498448431491852,
-0.11928507685661316,
0.21063067018985748,
-0.3204241693019867,
0.48501479625701904,
0.9094715118408203,
-0.5258041024208069,
0.17730507254600525,
-0.1985948085784912,
-0.2934635281562805,
0.336486279964447,
-0.32440879940986633,
0.024275681003928185,
0.20683835446834564,
0.05913529172539711,
0.33445361256599426,
-0.31674936413764954,
0.47514286637306213,
0.09842347353696823,
-0.256328821182251,
0.06610472500324249,
0.03656304255127907,
0.9486933350563049,
0.5293521285057068,
0.14420761168003082,
-0.17370934784412384,
-0.5542790293693542,
-0.05977886915206909,
-0.04873502254486084,
-0.5725825428962708,
-0.45603910088539124,
-0.18232707679271698,
0.19240255653858185,
0.07755487412214279,
0.1712256669998169,
-0.3727116882801056,
0.43616053462028503,
-0.38021719455718994,
0.6198323369026184,
0.41226112842559814,
-0.10331431031227112,
0.5410814881324768,
0.1448432058095932,
0.9574494361877441,
-0.17067104578018188,
0.00564363831654191,
-0.20405064523220062,
-0.765583336353302,
-0.46549248695373535,
-0.4696356952190399,
0.7321820259094238,
0.8524003028869629,
-0.7417991757392883,
0.4271000325679779,
-0.22123326361179352,
-0.2015105038881302,
-0.5474874973297119,
0.06963864713907242,
0.12503784894943237,
0.5667089819908142,
0.4710905849933624,
-0.39563077688217163,
-0.8528842329978943,
-1.2614628076553345,
0.07214351743459702,
-0.35369983315467834,
-0.3717731237411499,
0.1867566853761673,
0.26607081294059753,
-0.2726896107196808,
0.4678340554237366,
-0.4299222528934479,
-0.11154969781637192,
-0.42382684350013733,
-0.18467548489570618,
0.1577671617269516,
0.3807693421840668,
0.670143187046051,
-0.6717563271522522,
-0.7231786847114563,
0.6462318897247314,
-0.7481377720832825,
0.006379070691764355,
0.07845605909824371,
-0.030859310179948807,
0.2566637396812439,
0.48822423815727234,
-0.2152438759803772,
-0.14405158162117004,
0.7509695291519165,
-0.0553673580288887,
0.5582165122032166,
-0.2733941972255707,
0.6643322110176086,
-0.8153138160705566,
0.15092970430850983,
-0.1665695607662201,
-0.34796378016471863,
-0.7677369117736816,
0.299980491399765,
-0.13123606145381927,
-0.4149731695652008,
-0.29475560784339905,
0.47652867436408997,
-0.2897176444530487,
0.30204689502716064,
-0.19325172901153564,
0.38752713799476624,
-0.04910484328866005,
0.23247548937797546,
0.2995911240577698,
0.8497927188873291,
0.3423730731010437,
-0.37200602889060974,
0.029741594567894936,
0.5040746927261353,
-0.043913185596466064,
0.7780627608299255,
-0.5264528393745422,
0.0436396561563015,
-0.09898240864276886,
0.008620292879641056,
-0.3900378346443176,
-0.4641910791397095,
0.21251222491264343,
-0.43990907073020935,
0.7053670883178711,
-0.6307719349861145,
-0.08915578573942184,
-0.3557277321815491,
0.1318700611591339,
0.057495731860399246,
0.24981163442134857,
-0.11145931482315063,
0.05783794820308685,
0.8351630568504333,
-0.7774341106414795,
-0.7342260479927063,
-0.9035455584526062,
0.8049404621124268,
-0.22861772775650024,
-0.4592967629432678,
0.024498334154486656,
0.08973369747400284,
-0.4735305905342102,
-0.6493313312530518,
0.34927281737327576,
-0.5015733242034912,
-0.0647878497838974,
-0.3457965552806854,
0.12463952600955963,
-0.17932170629501343,
0.041270844638347626,
0.21133874356746674,
0.07930963486433029,
-0.016347724944353104,
-0.681102454662323,
0.5173936486244202,
-0.28674501180648804,
0.18930545449256897,
0.05375010147690773,
0.7021655440330505,
0.10934357345104218,
-0.12295391410589218,
0.5843856930732727,
0.37965190410614014,
-0.11650445312261581,
-0.10404232889413834,
-0.16543035209178925,
0.10999387502670288,
-0.44740551710128784,
0.33177149295806885,
-0.6091798543930054,
-0.8662063479423523,
0.4182632267475128,
-0.09779449552297592,
0.00829332135617733,
0.08862544596195221,
0.363559365272522,
-0.2075667828321457,
0.5053038597106934,
0.8291330933570862,
-0.05090159550309181,
0.2854095995426178,
-0.1860271394252777,
0.3137094974517822,
-0.5076714754104614,
-0.164856418967247,
-0.8196595907211304,
-0.03916504234075546,
-0.9989026784896851,
-0.7922258973121643,
-0.14955869317054749,
0.17714624106884003,
0.09251575917005539,
0.9288817048072815,
-0.5383652448654175,
0.4862576425075531,
0.22119249403476715,
-0.22584670782089233,
0.5889259576797485,
0.24225302040576935,
0.12177494913339615,
-0.4334442913532257,
-0.8773862719535828,
-0.9377100467681885,
1.1008212566375732,
-0.022414319217205048,
0.17137113213539124,
0.2360064834356308,
0.6738659143447876,
0.5355207920074463,
-0.05446050316095352,
-0.3316347301006317,
0.4979395270347595,
-0.4538915157318115,
-0.30232271552085876,
0.06837332993745804,
-0.3419298529624939,
-1.2423267364501953,
0.0598556287586689,
0.10541427135467529,
-0.605147659778595,
0.5666211247444153,
0.1734876185655594,
0.11551321297883987,
0.27468496561050415,
-0.6066847443580627,
0.6343491673469543,
-0.034670908004045486,
-0.0843137577176094,
-0.08757076412439346,
-0.6765573024749756,
0.6552541255950928,
-0.10509350895881653,
0.404358446598053,
0.28927692770957947,
-0.2659418284893036,
0.19579221308231354,
-0.34947797656059265,
0.2852041721343994,
0.12786926329135895,
-0.3854425847530365,
0.5874796509742737,
0.3875846564769745,
0.28178223967552185,
0.5287004709243774,
-0.11508941650390625,
0.5127356648445129,
0.00390947051346302,
-0.8427908420562744,
-0.3425523638725281,
0.7264190912246704,
-0.6346678137779236,
-0.31660982966423035,
-0.25641047954559326,
-0.16435521841049194,
-0.21761180460453033,
-0.104642353951931,
0.01720341295003891,
-0.09682593494653702,
-0.38681042194366455,
-0.23560908436775208,
0.6306940913200378,
-0.23941512405872345,
0.2628830373287201,
0.327260822057724,
-0.7528478503227234,
-0.49059179425239563,
1.1500533819198608,
-0.03543764352798462,
0.14808543026447296,
0.44599053263664246,
-0.1837024688720703,
-0.013947096653282642,
-0.786027729511261,
-0.7049522995948792,
0.2671559453010559,
-0.5648232102394104,
0.1823873668909073,
-0.9103358387947083,
0.19469159841537476,
-0.2520177364349365,
-0.6190410256385803,
-0.32245922088623047,
-0.857333242893219,
-0.1373782753944397,
-0.3233497440814972,
-0.045938171446323395,
0.3680987060070038,
-0.20539997518062592,
0.31948336958885193,
-0.6205776333808899,
0.04471275210380554,
0.441454142332077,
-0.09289014339447021,
-0.5548744797706604,
-0.5714651942253113,
-0.20623335242271423,
-0.0412592813372612,
0.16321943700313568,
-0.7837470769882202,
0.7393302321434021,
0.3014081120491028,
0.34065914154052734,
0.22182241082191467,
-0.5046555995941162,
0.41244909167289734,
-0.4244833290576935,
0.8193188309669495,
0.260526180267334,
-0.7748740315437317,
0.6057129502296448,
-0.8526316285133362,
0.09574703127145767,
0.8825182914733887,
0.6326634287834167,
-1.016764760017395,
-0.5467345714569092,
-0.591576099395752,
-0.7979145646095276,
0.2754598557949066,
0.25113192200660706,
0.238666370511055,
-0.6714795827865601,
0.30196303129196167,
0.30759358406066895,
0.8261113166809082,
-0.3365921378135681,
-0.11444158852100372,
-0.4482552111148834,
0.085051991045475,
-0.1871904730796814,
0.06361443549394608,
-0.3835378885269165,
-0.21149533987045288,
0.4800295829772949,
-0.5164735913276672,
0.5300263166427612,
0.28657546639442444,
-0.3453098237514496,
0.10311173647642136,
0.4446135461330414,
0.8250226378440857,
1.0031042098999023,
-0.21187534928321838,
0.07920431345701218,
0.11021202057600021,
-0.7046827673912048,
0.035646822303533554,
0.04599245637655258,
-0.3765091300010681,
0.2561533749103546,
0.5118191242218018,
0.3684249818325043,
0.10915275663137436,
-0.6707437038421631,
0.09564922749996185,
-0.2800578474998474,
0.03104294091463089,
-0.3864037096500397,
0.11822166293859482,
0.424995481967926,
-0.05142132565379143,
0.48393625020980835,
0.3262476921081543,
-0.08239876478910446,
-0.7944386005401611,
0.14834511280059814,
0.07367000728845596,
-0.5491623878479004,
-0.5641683340072632,
0.6100289821624756,
0.5984497666358948,
-0.47717559337615967,
0.5545641183853149,
-0.5972892642021179,
-0.41458243131637573,
0.7450451254844666,
0.541598916053772,
0.6308947205543518,
-0.09536075592041016,
0.4407855272293091,
0.6912413835525513,
0.5790996551513672,
0.1424493044614792,
0.6212502717971802,
0.10675376653671265,
-0.37541332840919495,
-0.31750431656837463,
-0.6838563084602356,
-0.47427845001220703,
-0.2302785962820053,
-0.17492742836475372,
0.31362417340278625,
-0.6074512600898743,
-0.18045765161514282,
-0.19618022441864014,
0.052308566868305206,
-0.6635321378707886,
0.03582993522286415,
0.2396988868713379,
0.7539775371551514,
-0.48338234424591064,
0.8521193265914917,
0.49177590012550354,
-0.44083428382873535,
-0.3035895824432373,
-0.3661595284938812,
-0.03359885513782501,
-0.7305237054824829,
0.7301830649375916,
-0.2838815450668335,
-0.07193426042795181,
0.17193923890590668,
-0.35058000683784485,
-0.5372628569602966,
0.853855550289154,
0.44124242663383484,
-1.0503989458084106,
0.3091239333152771,
0.09138842672109604,
0.8459450006484985,
-0.6984790563583374,
0.48339009284973145,
0.7101687788963318,
0.8411878943443298,
-0.8233639001846313,
-0.9338472485542297,
-0.41997623443603516,
0.058340251445770264,
0.09154808521270752,
0.10462211817502975,
-0.8688140511512756,
0.7447695136070251,
-0.09890196472406387,
-0.1567477434873581,
-0.18502505123615265,
0.878711998462677,
0.12178514897823334,
0.025376571342349052,
0.15032853186130524,
0.08037371188402176,
1.0932703018188477,
-0.250661164522171,
1.0456148386001587,
-0.4986838102340698,
0.04053570330142975,
1.0417741537094116,
-0.3195216953754425,
0.5428203344345093,
0.4035322964191437,
-0.8040061593055725,
0.7562659978866577,
0.8534234762191772,
0.22324688732624054,
0.14949099719524384,
0.38493359088897705,
-0.5798725485801697,
0.1388874500989914,
-0.22856546938419342,
-0.3200967311859131,
0.6082574725151062,
0.4595293700695038,
-0.2558806240558624,
0.2326497733592987,
-0.09207180887460709,
0.22244660556316376,
0.6132288575172424,
-0.3485754728317261,
0.344417542219162,
0.15378935635089874,
-0.7528318762779236,
0.5844761729240417,
-0.010056506842374802,
0.6239190697669983,
-0.9320240616798401,
0.11764638125896454,
-0.6727904677391052,
-0.3582216799259186,
-0.3076784014701843,
-0.4638599753379822,
0.6718346476554871,
-0.03367825970053673,
-0.12090718001127243,
-0.06986837834119797,
0.5048919320106506,
-0.5818995833396912,
-0.5017528533935547,
0.49074339866638184,
0.7311110496520996,
0.43048587441444397,
0.19231903553009033,
-0.7988216876983643,
-0.3175109028816223,
0.14763157069683075,
-0.12614578008651733,
0.4504307508468628,
0.20579886436462402,
-0.18612399697303772,
0.6501425504684448,
0.5598946213722229,
0.38432052731513977,
0.09667275100946426,
0.17805466055870056,
0.3645404875278473,
-0.5963606238365173,
-0.5088596343994141,
-0.5409278869628906,
0.004708937834948301,
-0.16065296530723572,
-0.5700110197067261,
0.7957682609558105,
0.6992087960243225,
0.9243513345718384,
-0.2953129708766937,
1.0109227895736694,
-0.3825371265411377,
0.08072897046804428,
-0.2233714759349823,
0.5735316276550293,
-0.2104075402021408,
0.1377340406179428,
-0.22566501796245575,
-1.0165261030197144,
-0.35766923427581787,
0.43799862265586853,
-0.05556274950504303,
-0.23814506828784943,
0.8157473206520081,
0.5640623569488525,
-0.17995180189609528,
0.17274056375026703,
0.5127814412117004,
0.08218259364366531,
0.07439408451318741,
0.10050607472658157,
0.4638764262199402,
-0.28119760751724243,
0.6842560172080994,
-0.2444007694721222,
0.04141557961702347,
0.00015519154840148985,
-0.7710040807723999,
-0.5142802596092224,
-0.5846871733665466,
-0.2816765010356903,
-0.23373965919017792,
0.321770042181015,
0.880573034286499,
0.7234566807746887,
-1.0555537939071655,
-0.5376551151275635,
-0.22604496777057648,
0.19606146216392517,
-0.22979483008384705,
-0.26405519247055054,
0.08202731609344482,
-0.3954371511936188,
-1.2674908638000488,
0.8912872076034546,
0.6771758794784546,
-0.07688391953706741,
-0.4025407135486603,
-0.04255995526909828,
-0.6724069714546204,
0.03772485628724098,
0.8933594822883606,
0.7447677850723267,
-0.25435879826545715,
-0.30606693029403687,
-0.01350460946559906,
-0.14639869332313538,
0.2705364525318146,
1.1823837757110596,
-0.6488484740257263,
0.5277270078659058,
0.5012966394424438,
0.5298529863357544,
0.4918234348297119,
-0.030087845399975777,
0.90301114320755,
-0.9509997963905334,
0.31977006793022156,
0.3872758150100708,
0.4538322389125824,
0.6280415058135986,
-0.2578951120376587,
0.9727097749710083,
0.2646448612213135,
-0.7846981883049011,
-0.4916379749774933,
0.31702589988708496,
-0.827541172504425,
-0.4843842387199402,
0.5992107391357422,
-0.3702223300933838,
-0.29407691955566406,
-0.8496630787849426,
-0.2663874626159668,
0.042530424892902374,
-0.5963137745857239,
0.8402133584022522,
0.6977706551551819,
0.09051882475614548,
-0.21253903210163116,
-1.1459616422653198,
0.4368283748626709,
0.13408462703227997,
-0.8064498901367188,
0.09981773793697357,
0.2648181617259979,
0.1526879072189331,
0.29525598883628845,
0.9151535034179688,
0.1835637092590332,
0.06577031314373016,
0.1011912152171135,
0.1515350043773651,
0.2384463995695114,
-0.3206407427787781,
-0.3101491928100586,
0.14301984012126923,
-0.1674746572971344,
0.44696590304374695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03794v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03794v1
|
Detecting Anti-Semitic Hate Speech using Transformer-based Large Language Models
| 2024-05-06T19:00:31 | 2024-05-06T19:00:31 |
Dengyi Liu, Minghao Wang, Andrew G. Catlin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Academic researchers and social media entities grappling with the
identification of hate speech face significant challenges, primarily due to the
vast scale of data and the dynamic nature of hate speech. Given the ethical and
practical limitations of large predictive models like ChatGPT in directly
addressing such sensitive issues, our research has explored alternative
advanced transformer-based and generative AI technologies since 2019.
Specifically, we developed a new data labeling technique and established a
proof of concept targeting anti-Semitic hate speech, utilizing a variety of
transformer models such as BERT (arXiv:1810.04805), DistillBERT
(arXiv:1910.01108), RoBERTa (arXiv:1907.11692), and LLaMA-2 (arXiv:2307.09288),
complemented by the LoRA fine-tuning approach (arXiv:2106.09685). This paper
delineates and evaluates the comparative efficacy of these cutting-edge methods
in tackling the intricacies of hate speech detection, highlighting the need for
responsible and carefully managed AI applications within sensitive contexts.
|
[
-0.5116357207298279,
-1.1381887197494507,
0.03563591465353966,
-0.19088706374168396,
-0.1413390189409256,
0.2642478048801422,
-0.3096173107624054,
-0.6643922328948975,
0.12416231632232666,
0.38435113430023193,
-0.3484743535518646,
-0.3149075210094452,
-0.8342885375022888,
-0.18874512612819672,
-0.9317596554756165,
1.2004517316818237,
0.212129145860672,
0.07368871569633484,
0.2601613998413086,
-0.17877471446990967,
0.020746318623423576,
-0.5002802014350891,
-0.7993080019950867,
-0.2618597149848938,
0.8585957884788513,
0.06172456219792366,
0.9612266421318054,
0.5015485882759094,
0.5890367031097412,
0.2380070835351944,
-0.34115514159202576,
-0.20463716983795166,
-0.5479705929756165,
0.29194363951683044,
-0.11176419258117676,
-0.30457210540771484,
-0.2504093050956726,
-0.026194710284471512,
0.42084383964538574,
0.06728041917085648,
0.1406855285167694,
0.2923210859298706,
-0.17673510313034058,
0.2670639753341675,
-0.5296903848648071,
-0.15120291709899902,
-0.8326863646507263,
0.13329824805259705,
-0.7258766293525696,
0.3129153549671173,
-0.4341982901096344,
-0.3848763108253479,
-0.03626328706741333,
-0.22087006270885468,
0.3891262710094452,
-0.10768533498048782,
0.5017373561859131,
0.4748190641403198,
-0.26067331433296204,
-0.4910302758216858,
-1.0766010284423828,
0.6838304996490479,
-0.7927196621894836,
0.5393990278244019,
0.19671013951301575,
0.316510945558548,
0.06496371328830719,
-0.5799468159675598,
-0.8104445934295654,
-0.2677519917488098,
0.23921528458595276,
0.10887463390827179,
-0.8241044878959656,
-0.23084314167499542,
0.26528534293174744,
0.23165181279182434,
-0.5281065106391907,
0.662074863910675,
-0.3901402950286865,
-0.3351132869720459,
0.6661436557769775,
0.04751196876168251,
0.3510322868824005,
0.07532630115747452,
-0.22536778450012207,
-0.005745407193899155,
-0.5514202117919922,
-0.1896483451128006,
0.7760284543037415,
0.3724667429924011,
0.06745648384094238,
0.5079269409179688,
0.09562013298273087,
0.2755940854549408,
-0.06315504759550095,
0.07630564272403717,
0.21755798161029816,
0.19722925126552582,
0.028230519965291023,
0.16788984835147858,
0.7601906657218933,
0.2322739064693451,
0.525509238243103,
-0.29800552129745483,
-0.028742628172039986,
0.7657825350761414,
0.5391672253608704,
-0.7631848454475403,
-0.2997807562351227,
0.009041602723300457,
-0.2156747281551361,
-0.492391437292099,
-0.464205801486969,
-1.1091455221176147,
-0.9387177228927612,
-0.027841435745358467,
0.13847261667251587,
-0.3580724895000458,
-0.37968093156814575,
-0.3066256046295166,
-0.009927164763212204,
0.4227380156517029,
0.22237536311149597,
-0.6758102774620056,
0.06340859830379486,
0.7383386492729187,
0.7031328082084656,
-0.4709017872810364,
0.1507447063922882,
-0.5806187987327576,
-0.11442714184522629,
-0.11059941351413727,
0.7003673315048218,
-0.8233453035354614,
-0.2745896875858307,
0.15102459490299225,
-0.40945541858673096,
0.31213676929473877,
-0.5975492000579834,
1.0464425086975098,
-0.8172184824943542,
0.09318181872367859,
0.1747015118598938,
-0.4717765152454376,
-0.004398863762617111,
0.24898625910282135,
-0.6402897834777832,
0.9290416240692139,
0.11609238386154175,
-0.7788259983062744,
0.036695342510938644,
-0.7155762910842896,
-0.46216151118278503,
0.1830633282661438,
-0.1092468872666359,
-0.9069143533706665,
0.07679350674152374,
0.029761463403701782,
0.07222232967615128,
-0.29952433705329895,
0.2899755537509918,
-0.2640852928161621,
-0.10325538367033005,
0.29789140820503235,
-0.7767025232315063,
0.7744713425636292,
0.4928070902824402,
-0.7697553634643555,
0.5534456968307495,
-0.5734258890151978,
-0.3434472978115082,
0.5317373871803284,
0.0744650810956955,
-0.23001641035079956,
0.13872870802879333,
0.4770508110523224,
0.11474814265966415,
-0.03013644926249981,
-0.8882088661193848,
-0.2651958763599396,
-0.3153328597545624,
0.31273382902145386,
0.8741036653518677,
-0.5926573872566223,
-0.010470151901245117,
-0.18268728256225586,
0.7447389364242554,
0.028330476954579353,
0.24369145929813385,
0.39298689365386963,
-0.6570459008216858,
-0.6305075287818909,
-0.013357271440327168,
0.06888090819120407,
0.6500439643859863,
-0.4821404218673706,
0.3957058787345886,
-0.06914714723825455,
-0.7746457457542419,
-0.5475960969924927,
-0.29141905903816223,
0.2950070798397064,
0.5492884516716003,
0.6785711646080017,
0.053675659000873566,
-0.765885055065155,
-0.9901688694953918,
-0.46075814962387085,
-0.26692289113998413,
0.16908583045005798,
0.0691075250506401,
0.41703668236732483,
-0.33460524678230286,
0.9415240287780762,
-0.2696615755558014,
-0.10034728795289993,
-0.3102211356163025,
0.14280124008655548,
-0.11983559280633926,
0.24470512568950653,
0.6121812462806702,
-1.2550934553146362,
-0.7788527011871338,
-0.21541327238082886,
-0.26193884015083313,
-0.17681284248828888,
0.3349807560443878,
0.15391595661640167,
0.06209126114845276,
0.36603814363479614,
-0.218926802277565,
0.6730653047561646,
0.6131706833839417,
-0.3700847029685974,
0.5682142376899719,
0.5343044996261597,
0.2607599198818207,
-0.7703757286071777,
-0.1939936727285385,
0.09645470976829529,
-0.250748872756958,
-1.123462200164795,
-0.03930909186601639,
-0.24662287533283234,
-0.10471450537443161,
-0.7032816410064697,
0.3595025837421417,
0.24253107607364655,
0.3634951412677765,
-0.48268911242485046,
0.06527607142925262,
-0.5668260455131531,
0.14817370474338531,
-0.12706735730171204,
0.6841071844100952,
0.20368964970111847,
-0.1956932693719864,
0.5870868563652039,
0.35671889781951904,
-0.43863043189048767,
0.5529825687408447,
-0.5510390996932983,
0.20021623373031616,
-0.17296366393566132,
0.32067573070526123,
-0.9656683206558228,
-0.03821172937750816,
0.6190482974052429,
-0.5762593150138855,
-0.11435724794864655,
-0.2145424336194992,
-0.5353919863700867,
-0.4949839115142822,
-0.24122808873653412,
0.6818140149116516,
0.6167589426040649,
-0.43208664655685425,
0.632168173789978,
0.6550313234329224,
-0.17821459472179413,
-0.49745574593544006,
-0.6822342276573181,
0.06076434254646301,
-0.639514148235321,
-0.4075942039489746,
0.44269704818725586,
-0.060745950788259506,
-0.5544634461402893,
-0.06785811483860016,
0.019208291545510292,
-0.08049025386571884,
0.21875479817390442,
0.3199823498725891,
0.11419074237346649,
-0.2329643964767456,
-0.005293744150549173,
-0.18428027629852295,
-0.00820472463965416,
0.20047806203365326,
0.0669335424900055,
0.7378586530685425,
0.035710759460926056,
-0.36873987317085266,
-0.3533145785331726,
0.2927176058292389,
0.6937022805213928,
-0.28857117891311646,
0.6918054223060608,
1.19379723072052,
-0.41844019293785095,
0.042168572545051575,
-0.6744734644889832,
-0.08642363548278809,
-0.413364052772522,
0.4661378264427185,
0.12291358411312103,
-0.9864515662193298,
0.5212836265563965,
0.16092532873153687,
-0.0033176050055772066,
0.5925713777542114,
0.8377877473831177,
0.14599260687828064,
1.0029178857803345,
0.387529581785202,
-0.41523295640945435,
0.7354184985160828,
0.1815955936908722,
0.695982038974762,
-0.5047417879104614,
0.06766119599342346,
-0.8069307804107666,
-0.22223147749900818,
-0.6644484400749207,
-0.3239310085773468,
0.5132205486297607,
-0.34613922238349915,
-0.3234734833240509,
0.2444867044687271,
-0.61236971616745,
0.4278164207935333,
0.40862157940864563,
-0.21937084197998047,
0.1302759051322937,
0.09882303327322006,
0.4997251033782959,
-0.080879807472229,
-0.28597748279571533,
-0.42119258642196655,
0.957338809967041,
0.4141424596309662,
0.43957722187042236,
0.306047260761261,
0.276678204536438,
0.7455605864524841,
0.46822696924209595,
-0.7970172166824341,
0.4488568603992462,
-0.3027845025062561,
-1.0129187107086182,
-0.3254745602607727,
-0.2654244899749756,
-0.9442511796951294,
0.25116536021232605,
-0.1142607256770134,
-0.8959406614303589,
-0.22515228390693665,
0.10587118566036224,
-0.28831541538238525,
0.7984373569488525,
-0.32728302478790283,
0.730782151222229,
-0.041414592415094376,
-0.3223249316215515,
-0.4152680039405823,
-0.39475947618484497,
0.018494009971618652,
-0.21556900441646576,
0.3978908061981201,
-0.3870324492454529,
0.3740116059780121,
1.0314542055130005,
0.027947338297963142,
0.9862542152404785,
-0.29865407943725586,
-0.5380159616470337,
0.25621941685676575,
-0.1297258585691452,
0.6332815289497375,
-0.38607484102249146,
-0.25720155239105225,
0.3468037247657776,
-0.32052624225616455,
-0.2465745359659195,
-0.2711501121520996,
0.49985143542289734,
-0.5667508840560913,
-0.4681446850299835,
-0.1790262758731842,
-0.6147902607917786,
-0.1837201714515686,
0.25905370712280273,
0.2754712700843811,
0.3138994872570038,
-0.5089280009269714,
0.312412291765213,
0.8036290407180786,
-0.4356687366962433,
0.20355969667434692,
0.37090250849723816,
-0.274730920791626,
-0.27515023946762085,
0.9492128491401672,
0.16699820756912231,
0.0846405103802681,
0.06849223375320435,
0.3387037515640259,
-0.23679251968860626,
-0.7560491561889648,
-0.5252578258514404,
-0.01482389122247696,
-0.4389079809188843,
-0.2405834048986435,
-0.6877405643463135,
-0.29576942324638367,
-0.6140867471694946,
-0.23926222324371338,
-0.5415726900100708,
-0.11239955574274063,
0.07665999978780746,
0.11448969691991806,
0.4617864787578583,
0.6599922180175781,
0.03456005081534386,
0.5631293058395386,
-0.45114877820014954,
0.5353123545646667,
0.12116283923387527,
0.26119881868362427,
-0.1284719705581665,
-0.7757810354232788,
-0.26152101159095764,
0.36393439769744873,
-0.20841526985168457,
-0.8704296350479126,
0.30135905742645264,
-0.34187254309654236,
0.35424014925956726,
0.07562936842441559,
0.4157630205154419,
0.4593009352684021,
-0.6116264462471008,
0.7338640093803406,
0.03815114125609398,
-0.751996636390686,
0.6643446087837219,
-0.3972199857234955,
-0.045950379222631454,
0.23079441487789154,
0.6118757128715515,
-0.6907353401184082,
-0.6081511378288269,
-0.6944258213043213,
-0.8922536373138428,
0.5769677758216858,
0.3067416846752167,
0.26174065470695496,
0.00813567265868187,
-0.10199414193630219,
0.15508528053760529,
0.043056923896074295,
-0.8159068822860718,
-0.6386380195617676,
-0.15375785529613495,
-0.4252513349056244,
0.08388207107782364,
-0.26276472210884094,
-0.2276148945093155,
-0.11327546834945679,
0.8934675455093384,
0.13285641372203827,
0.1680132895708084,
-0.20771051943302155,
-0.1555698662996292,
-0.05876706913113594,
0.45627009868621826,
0.4076620936393738,
0.4206434488296509,
0.08134408295154572,
-0.08739326894283295,
0.012519321404397488,
-0.4952845573425293,
0.07647479325532913,
0.28635165095329285,
-0.4710126221179962,
0.058576639741659164,
0.2958195209503174,
0.7639029622077942,
-0.2914022207260132,
-0.7120131254196167,
0.5634486079216003,
0.1610792726278305,
-0.06987957656383514,
-0.6695875525474548,
0.04756256192922592,
-0.17951932549476624,
0.48220083117485046,
0.13151006400585175,
-0.1870783269405365,
0.12473075091838837,
-0.2496386021375656,
0.16231438517570496,
0.5915101766586304,
-0.5648537874221802,
-0.34869927167892456,
0.7674799561500549,
0.04331337660551071,
-0.5209856033325195,
0.5808033347129822,
0.007997781969606876,
-0.7332773804664612,
0.5763941407203674,
0.7209756970405579,
0.7286149263381958,
-0.5042234659194946,
0.29442521929740906,
0.11041111499071121,
0.2614580988883972,
0.41889896988868713,
-0.20773158967494965,
0.0016125703696161509,
-1.084868311882019,
-0.23007504642009735,
-0.5847387313842773,
-0.40462711453437805,
0.4834482967853546,
-0.6236716508865356,
-0.028182849287986755,
-0.3521186113357544,
-0.0938999205827713,
0.5379588007926941,
-0.14972591400146484,
-0.4792422950267792,
-0.05978289991617203,
0.8433426022529602,
0.6332714557647705,
-0.9028024077415466,
0.7993760108947754,
0.34941765666007996,
-0.1681673526763916,
-0.13293711841106415,
0.0476287379860878,
0.4425503611564636,
-0.9363775253295898,
0.45119762420654297,
0.152662992477417,
-0.5387949347496033,
0.18524520099163055,
-0.6131899356842041,
-0.5749024748802185,
0.40418246388435364,
0.22665290534496307,
-0.5611856579780579,
0.2052493393421173,
0.480221688747406,
0.7053314447402954,
-0.10012184828519821,
0.06535199284553528,
0.7849974036216736,
0.5571330189704895,
0.008479957468807697,
-0.7824013233184814,
-0.12311409413814545,
-0.20051592588424683,
-0.2559454143047333,
0.4967646896839142,
-0.5352342128753662,
0.4415035843849182,
0.18034139275550842,
-0.20338693261146545,
-0.12438157945871353,
0.6665986776351929,
-0.24823564291000366,
0.272164523601532,
0.7595177888870239,
0.6254590749740601,
0.5736631155014038,
-0.003116955980658531,
0.5991253852844238,
0.054156772792339325,
0.14937724173069,
1.0230402946472168,
-0.2272653579711914,
0.5263749361038208,
0.06733724474906921,
-0.28572654724121094,
0.42951327562332153,
0.19885393977165222,
-0.3320372700691223,
0.2772557735443115,
0.5199365615844727,
-0.5781776309013367,
-0.04442311450839043,
-0.6953769326210022,
-0.2931693494319916,
0.6560276746749878,
0.666032075881958,
-0.30494424700737,
-0.35317304730415344,
0.35154515504837036,
0.2918795645236969,
0.2399187684059143,
-0.37266775965690613,
0.7091934084892273,
-0.39087286591529846,
-0.2467334121465683,
0.3472869098186493,
0.07729905843734741,
0.9797723889350891,
-0.41428807377815247,
0.25186970829963684,
0.13277342915534973,
0.15818509459495544,
-0.12506723403930664,
-0.7016060948371887,
0.5783183574676514,
0.5794377326965332,
-0.1287367045879364,
-0.22876471281051636,
0.650474488735199,
-0.3157234489917755,
-0.30891039967536926,
0.46583276987075806,
0.2631103992462158,
0.06200556457042694,
-0.1924426108598709,
-0.8112056255340576,
0.47841283679008484,
0.17183049023151398,
-0.11561427265405655,
0.17721328139305115,
0.039760906249284744,
-0.21581286191940308,
0.5024322867393494,
0.5716851949691772,
-0.08917848765850067,
0.0543137826025486,
0.42996296286582947,
0.8235830664634705,
-0.6105096340179443,
-0.22081123292446136,
-1.0745714902877808,
0.20132777094841003,
-0.039468277245759964,
-0.3270513415336609,
0.6759220957756042,
0.6874212622642517,
1.0828685760498047,
0.3499530553817749,
0.9187762141227722,
-0.24614368379116058,
0.772188663482666,
-0.1349504142999649,
0.4106232225894928,
-0.2061396688222885,
-0.09597756713628769,
-0.37925878167152405,
-0.7964637279510498,
-0.6503702998161316,
0.5024759769439697,
-0.683811366558075,
-0.18611294031143188,
0.13839295506477356,
0.8412719368934631,
-0.11296374350786209,
0.29191336035728455,
0.24489250779151917,
0.4683605432510376,
0.8483293056488037,
0.17211805284023285,
0.9632944464683533,
-0.32400667667388916,
0.67734694480896,
-0.2016039490699768,
-0.15204431116580963,
-0.2643829882144928,
-0.4849298596382141,
-0.6311744451522827,
-0.5597061514854431,
-0.46989017724990845,
-0.4152415096759796,
0.13132505118846893,
0.9070056676864624,
0.3842853009700775,
-0.8856964707374573,
0.09906935691833496,
0.18997658789157867,
-0.008145510219037533,
-0.0402032695710659,
-0.20939753949642181,
0.32232874631881714,
-0.02230074256658554,
-0.9628231525421143,
0.38760557770729065,
0.07295343279838562,
-0.007755594328045845,
-0.08011870831251144,
0.1951426863670349,
-0.17123857140541077,
0.1031448170542717,
0.6551028490066528,
0.2485012263059616,
-0.9067785739898682,
-0.341121643781662,
-0.5385453104972839,
0.0503268726170063,
0.12347809225320816,
0.7613357305526733,
-0.6461467146873474,
0.11033523082733154,
0.17255625128746033,
1.0356926918029785,
0.38256075978279114,
-0.040937453508377075,
0.12216738611459732,
-0.29484671354293823,
0.09486742317676544,
0.6337447166442871,
0.19478528201580048,
0.23908202350139618,
-0.18851563334465027,
0.5918968915939331,
0.09816695749759674,
-0.551257848739624,
-0.9140325784683228,
0.6930455565452576,
-0.6854179501533508,
-0.21403007209300995,
1.1214003562927246,
0.15787561237812042,
-0.021960925310850143,
-0.33084067702293396,
-0.13421691954135895,
0.5470103025436401,
-0.32074040174484253,
0.8608685731887817,
0.49501416087150574,
-0.024324985221028328,
0.1573553830385208,
-0.44049933552742004,
0.377657413482666,
0.47174930572509766,
-0.656065046787262,
0.27712124586105347,
0.58626788854599,
-0.16129739582538605,
0.32351362705230713,
0.31252747774124146,
-0.1263865828514099,
0.048078183084726334,
-0.12636521458625793,
-0.018484096974134445,
0.150140181183815,
-0.23618218302726746,
-0.23843735456466675,
0.15321466326713562,
-0.266218900680542,
-0.06053026393055916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03789v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03789v1
|
On Adversarial Examples for Text Classification by Perturbing Latent Representations
| 2024-05-06T18:45:18 | 2024-05-06T18:45:18 |
Korn Sooksatra, Bikram Khanal, Pablo Rivas
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, 68T01, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Recently, with the advancement of deep learning, several applications in text
classification have advanced significantly. However, this improvement comes
with a cost because deep learning is vulnerable to adversarial examples. This
weakness indicates that deep learning is not very robust. Fortunately, the
input of a text classifier is discrete. Hence, it can prevent the classifier
from state-of-the-art attacks. Nonetheless, previous works have generated
black-box attacks that successfully manipulate the discrete values of the input
to find adversarial examples. Therefore, instead of changing the discrete
values, we transform the input into its embedding vector containing real values
to perform the state-of-the-art white-box attacks. Then, we convert the
perturbed embedding vector back into a text and name it an adversarial example.
In summary, we create a framework that measures the robustness of a text
classifier by using the gradients of the classifier.
|
[
-0.24996867775917053,
-1.1403809785842896,
0.4008553922176361,
-0.3227420747280121,
-0.32397857308387756,
0.052963901311159134,
0.11385630816221237,
0.03478524461388588,
-0.23673005402088165,
0.4248415529727936,
-0.2577243745326996,
-0.4366626739501953,
-0.7206737399101257,
-0.21837808191776276,
-0.7005956172943115,
1.556726098060608,
-0.025355316698551178,
-0.1790405660867691,
-0.007664566393941641,
-0.08062282204627991,
-0.11080991476774216,
-0.9863386750221252,
-0.5679750442504883,
-0.05699947848916054,
0.4706512689590454,
-0.040711209177970886,
0.8369601964950562,
0.23222266137599945,
0.4045218229293823,
0.3640127182006836,
-0.10315151512622833,
-0.2964473366737366,
-0.5680099725723267,
0.2685094177722931,
0.06168823689222336,
-0.5727118849754333,
-0.14944398403167725,
0.3571617305278778,
0.5776376724243164,
0.4072643220424652,
0.061853550374507904,
-0.326647013425827,
-0.013215495273470879,
0.12726350128650665,
-0.7614701986312866,
-0.08814258873462677,
-0.8305017948150635,
0.3725009858608246,
-0.19515518844127655,
-0.16329838335514069,
-0.4950561225414276,
-0.4303743541240692,
0.015711260959506035,
-0.2783915400505066,
0.22842228412628174,
-0.42150044441223145,
0.8294025659561157,
0.47620469331741333,
-0.3732060492038727,
-0.35904204845428467,
-0.8077680468559265,
0.7126458287239075,
-0.5540390610694885,
-0.00427106162533164,
0.2521054148674011,
0.5090206265449524,
-0.38767123222351074,
-0.8005150556564331,
-0.6542008519172668,
-0.010900821536779404,
-0.02888811193406582,
0.20405486226081848,
-0.472575843334198,
-0.016715064644813538,
0.2461727112531662,
0.45297592878341675,
-0.4901426136493683,
-0.04991450160741806,
-0.0745745450258255,
-0.08040964603424072,
0.5429142117500305,
0.10884886980056763,
0.36152568459510803,
0.2766796946525574,
-0.5715912580490112,
-0.6411504149436951,
-0.408579021692276,
0.20505163073539734,
0.598728597164154,
0.008719916455447674,
0.07668521255254745,
0.3586452007293701,
0.523969829082489,
0.5473598837852478,
0.1118556410074234,
-0.04944487288594246,
0.1085115373134613,
-0.17311802506446838,
-0.2550414800643921,
0.0860515683889389,
0.9460511803627014,
0.19152404367923737,
0.07302456349134445,
-0.14931289851665497,
-0.31824252009391785,
0.5269041657447815,
0.6625868678092957,
-1.049637794494629,
-0.3204492926597595,
-0.035765305161476135,
-0.39095690846443176,
-1.0503005981445312,
0.14888478815555573,
-1.0267881155014038,
-0.5564090609550476,
0.47037583589553833,
0.4461400806903839,
-0.13688640296459198,
0.12446217238903046,
0.0688202828168869,
-0.1541355550289154,
0.014016926288604736,
0.3606371581554413,
-0.9108420014381409,
0.4338226616382599,
0.5011736154556274,
0.6380672454833984,
0.04212035611271858,
-0.15722797811031342,
-0.5448487401008606,
-0.22095948457717896,
-0.367057204246521,
0.6420540809631348,
-0.45479869842529297,
-0.4676573574542999,
0.12728853523731232,
-0.19331005215644836,
0.20394347608089447,
-0.25915610790252686,
0.558239758014679,
-0.6298229694366455,
0.36384859681129456,
0.3420233428478241,
-0.30536675453186035,
-0.23258034884929657,
0.49829980731010437,
-0.6192441582679749,
0.7341305017471313,
0.12589578330516815,
-0.937237560749054,
0.0011995926033705473,
-0.3178838789463043,
-0.4305669069290161,
-0.0742795541882515,
-0.369790643453598,
-1.0737354755401611,
0.18566487729549408,
0.09122834354639053,
0.7451892495155334,
-0.09030706435441971,
0.02145833894610405,
-0.5394753813743591,
-0.4275713264942169,
0.7139701843261719,
-0.9979264140129089,
0.9700171947479248,
0.05921575427055359,
-0.3946179151535034,
-0.151010662317276,
-0.7104511857032776,
-0.317281574010849,
0.28217899799346924,
-0.22034026682376862,
-0.527407169342041,
0.0922275111079216,
0.04064996540546417,
0.21524998545646667,
0.0718972235918045,
-0.4526951014995575,
0.2641507387161255,
-0.5611491799354553,
0.45980381965637207,
0.8000615239143372,
0.07399535179138184,
0.44698023796081543,
-0.3092251420021057,
0.6877797842025757,
0.0023196088150143623,
-0.151190847158432,
-0.09055522829294205,
-0.3486673831939697,
-0.437559574842453,
-0.19659201800823212,
0.5124325156211853,
0.5978294014930725,
-0.9124801158905029,
0.4476833939552307,
-0.010780707001686096,
-0.5667417049407959,
-0.17820431292057037,
-0.12259366363286972,
0.2899901866912842,
0.43471306562423706,
0.20405952632427216,
0.05149812623858452,
-0.07614143192768097,
-0.5165308117866516,
-0.21074168384075165,
-0.22498276829719543,
-0.07981017976999283,
0.11242183297872543,
0.6447011828422546,
-0.4912665784358978,
0.41634464263916016,
-0.61087965965271,
-0.030348001047968864,
0.2519528865814209,
0.29574474692344666,
-0.08072161674499512,
0.4947223365306854,
0.8108676075935364,
-1.200380802154541,
-0.2909758687019348,
-0.09347300231456757,
-0.6090056896209717,
0.1751251369714737,
-0.3755419850349426,
0.06098879501223564,
-0.1698443442583084,
0.8417460322380066,
-0.09619209915399551,
0.7849240899085999,
0.560031533241272,
-0.6077066659927368,
0.3908163011074066,
-0.14526842534542084,
-0.0707864984869957,
-1.0260816812515259,
-0.22654125094413757,
-0.04940488189458847,
-0.25156086683273315,
-0.6322543621063232,
0.1487983763217926,
-0.017216645181179047,
-0.4468997120857239,
-0.33307066559791565,
0.3404701352119446,
0.21681085228919983,
0.28968462347984314,
-0.17226625978946686,
-0.11442253738641739,
-0.03345464915037155,
0.27759721875190735,
-0.3509727418422699,
0.5448528528213501,
0.3547883927822113,
-0.6483619213104248,
0.41343164443969727,
0.21236465871334076,
0.1136750876903534,
0.6387042999267578,
-0.6903123259544373,
0.05551154166460037,
-0.10504606366157532,
0.34115076065063477,
-1.0191233158111572,
0.15835866332054138,
0.4249522089958191,
-0.6809536814689636,
0.6596275568008423,
-0.07840008288621902,
-0.2510747015476227,
-0.015789132565259933,
-0.7502490282058716,
0.33690300583839417,
0.5006162524223328,
-0.766225278377533,
0.4837132394313812,
0.21307894587516785,
-0.0803331509232521,
-0.7634130716323853,
-0.9729375839233398,
0.15812651813030243,
-0.2999463677406311,
-0.18580108880996704,
0.6336168050765991,
-0.23043382167816162,
0.010148135013878345,
0.18955904245376587,
-0.0410681776702404,
-0.099403977394104,
0.7329607605934143,
0.2153756022453308,
0.08378290385007858,
-0.11542195826768875,
-0.0734030082821846,
0.04996621236205101,
-0.300134539604187,
0.32931599020957947,
-0.25132548809051514,
0.29596927762031555,
-0.060419656336307526,
-0.25573042035102844,
-0.4015952944755554,
0.3911821246147156,
0.7580976486206055,
-0.0970226302742958,
0.6216995716094971,
0.737267792224884,
-0.7175756692886353,
-0.492717981338501,
0.11329936236143112,
-0.030831577256321907,
-0.49424657225608826,
0.5660709738731384,
-0.45313844084739685,
-0.6675824522972107,
0.32877781987190247,
-0.042976487427949905,
0.04701046273112297,
0.4880008399486542,
0.3767562508583069,
-0.13437730073928833,
0.9867976903915405,
0.45170313119888306,
0.10209959745407104,
0.5802989602088928,
-0.44052258133888245,
0.1477869153022766,
-0.4997866749763489,
-0.0474788174033165,
-0.7019248604774475,
-0.1015438586473465,
-0.787813127040863,
-0.2107839584350586,
0.04974894970655441,
0.11677073687314987,
-0.3720632493495941,
0.2796335220336914,
-0.559191882610321,
0.2252323180437088,
0.27223238348960876,
0.2898194193840027,
-0.30978697538375854,
0.2544437348842621,
-0.2786119878292084,
-0.29276537895202637,
-0.6541764140129089,
-0.7439319491386414,
1.061172366142273,
0.5411731004714966,
0.9875848293304443,
0.30578914284706116,
0.6566818356513977,
0.4303000271320343,
0.43906813859939575,
-0.7305486798286438,
0.30175668001174927,
-0.831712007522583,
-0.29101118445396423,
-0.21314574778079987,
-0.5729010105133057,
-0.9982168078422546,
0.22933807969093323,
-0.5241675972938538,
-0.5840820074081421,
0.2730332016944885,
0.125672847032547,
-0.2415606677532196,
0.6015803217887878,
-0.4620797038078308,
1.0287483930587769,
-0.2889133095741272,
-0.1543104648590088,
0.1672406941652298,
-0.12514029443264008,
0.07616601139307022,
-0.3249298930168152,
0.14870521426200867,
0.48658284544944763,
-0.11814089864492416,
0.6863395571708679,
-0.37331581115722656,
0.9276918768882751,
-0.16030743718147278,
-0.13383741676807404,
0.010343387722969055,
0.12249667197465897,
0.5556151866912842,
0.141950786113739,
0.056629858911037445,
-0.08663129061460495,
-0.38215333223342896,
-0.5350832343101501,
-1.0064897537231445,
0.6191607713699341,
-0.7622684240341187,
-0.4433497190475464,
-0.7774867415428162,
-0.07824301719665527,
-0.07433133572340012,
0.0220698993653059,
0.4805110991001129,
0.6043210029602051,
-0.368486225605011,
0.4600699543952942,
0.9271529316902161,
-0.42227640748023987,
0.5389195680618286,
-0.029034443199634552,
0.1892770230770111,
-0.6176961064338684,
1.161057710647583,
0.027143195271492004,
0.07640120387077332,
0.647495687007904,
0.3399146795272827,
-0.3231973946094513,
-0.8782077431678772,
-0.46391674876213074,
-0.4142984449863434,
-0.6907948851585388,
-0.30448517203330994,
-0.5075191259384155,
-0.24586935341358185,
-0.27350202202796936,
-0.6138066649436951,
-0.14489665627479553,
-0.16599921882152557,
-0.7496753931045532,
-0.023270970210433006,
-0.020845845341682434,
0.850526750087738,
0.41543444991111755,
0.39042410254478455,
-0.5024113059043884,
0.30196937918663025,
0.7150917053222656,
0.2858002185821533,
0.06569415330886841,
-0.3938860595226288,
-0.0703490823507309,
-0.05076853558421135,
-0.5600625276565552,
-1.0369914770126343,
0.40305477380752563,
-0.12376835942268372,
0.5781228542327881,
0.5148822069168091,
0.3085707426071167,
0.2474469691514969,
-0.456461638212204,
0.7288635969161987,
0.36389029026031494,
-0.8388830423355103,
0.48659589886665344,
-0.16931043565273285,
-0.04012943059206009,
0.5122042298316956,
0.4918793737888336,
-0.11199212819337845,
-0.34701573848724365,
-0.8953354358673096,
-0.5496364831924438,
0.4227767586708069,
0.3301437497138977,
0.13548317551612854,
0.32138511538505554,
0.47029417753219604,
0.008119289763271809,
0.0709543377161026,
-0.9420238137245178,
-0.4661095142364502,
-0.7018557786941528,
-0.5266982316970825,
-0.3087015450000763,
-0.36454978585243225,
-0.037993695586919785,
0.20812608301639557,
0.5277889966964722,
0.018055712804198265,
0.28677523136138916,
0.1730632334947586,
-0.06150536239147186,
0.3859653174877167,
0.2498111128807068,
0.5674945712089539,
-0.22896547615528107,
-0.07273504137992859,
0.527127742767334,
0.2081444263458252,
-0.8124951124191284,
0.5968568921089172,
0.5269218683242798,
-0.5570958852767944,
-0.10561351478099823,
0.40906861424446106,
0.47400325536727905,
0.20386183261871338,
-0.22319917380809784,
0.8489256501197815,
-0.6538100242614746,
-0.19715845584869385,
-0.32299816608428955,
0.03772159665822983,
-0.39985960721969604,
0.05335277318954468,
0.43731704354286194,
0.4447574317455292,
0.2418496012687683,
-0.46753042936325073,
0.25594770908355713,
0.5061866641044617,
-0.8746945261955261,
-0.19892796874046326,
0.7154520153999329,
0.1993764340877533,
-0.4377235174179077,
-0.0064179482869803905,
-0.5215741395950317,
-0.9714770913124084,
0.5224146842956543,
0.5270897150039673,
0.8631807565689087,
-0.27761930227279663,
0.1435617357492447,
-0.022272856906056404,
0.35599374771118164,
0.06492244452238083,
-0.16191716492176056,
0.026136789470911026,
-0.5816706418991089,
-0.06690968573093414,
-0.3485123813152313,
-0.2869991660118103,
0.4519869387149811,
-0.5299631953239441,
0.1583799421787262,
-0.8443313241004944,
-0.1708516627550125,
0.3779184818267822,
0.14591865241527557,
-0.30487060546875,
0.42134466767311096,
0.07415808737277985,
0.39802855253219604,
-0.9329933524131775,
0.5305548310279846,
1.0294761657714844,
-0.2583605647087097,
-0.002027228707447648,
0.2776693105697632,
-0.08903498947620392,
-0.1577436923980713,
0.3021850883960724,
0.11266995221376419,
-0.16277091205120087,
-0.4663134515285492,
-0.6017149686813354,
-0.22252382338047028,
0.7029083967208862,
0.40646544098854065,
-0.2891448438167572,
0.17154572904109955,
-0.25162723660469055,
0.49879735708236694,
-0.17518705129623413,
0.03937726467847824,
-0.01505734771490097,
0.1309112310409546,
-0.34066611528396606,
-0.14063884317874908,
0.17372316122055054,
-0.39088869094848633,
0.09968948364257812,
0.10192468017339706,
-0.47687050700187683,
1.1359872817993164,
0.17134766280651093,
-0.2816297709941864,
-0.20270892977714539,
0.5459482669830322,
-0.10283758491277695,
0.441234827041626,
0.5484493970870972,
0.566594123840332,
0.7350115180015564,
-0.2496887445449829,
1.224426031112671,
0.16780124604701996,
0.2678113281726837,
0.8517191410064697,
0.129286989569664,
0.7760671377182007,
0.037878841161727905,
-0.21897217631340027,
0.5741670727729797,
0.4489521384239197,
-0.4056597948074341,
0.5531184673309326,
0.4036920964717865,
-0.4058104455471039,
0.006650588475167751,
0.31835874915122986,
-0.30680426955223083,
0.42755094170570374,
0.6714912056922913,
-0.32027876377105713,
-0.2283938080072403,
0.32375726103782654,
0.23159471154212952,
0.6462658643722534,
-0.2666340172290802,
0.6161643862724304,
-0.05116191506385803,
-0.09308704733848572,
0.6158856749534607,
0.2564755380153656,
1.0611801147460938,
-0.44880247116088867,
-0.1976807415485382,
0.23150482773780823,
0.5269636511802673,
-0.20816713571548462,
-0.5713903903961182,
0.238580122590065,
0.01692490093410015,
-0.21754825115203857,
-0.2054624855518341,
0.7999691367149353,
-0.12854903936386108,
-0.562050461769104,
0.16742704808712006,
-0.15918557345867157,
-0.00884944573044777,
-0.003577339928597212,
-0.7079468369483948,
-0.18723119795322418,
0.0449351891875267,
-0.09333769977092743,
0.41372787952423096,
0.6397362947463989,
0.24267776310443878,
0.43601223826408386,
0.6124099493026733,
0.029674604535102844,
-0.24676427245140076,
-0.22688277065753937,
0.8225772380828857,
-0.7760605812072754,
-0.6049262285232544,
-1.1085020303726196,
0.2392747849225998,
-0.1478797197341919,
-0.4785734713077545,
0.7570945620536804,
0.3674543499946594,
0.7948346734046936,
0.11442869156599045,
0.9850565195083618,
0.3870414197444916,
0.07340756058692932,
-0.4068527817726135,
0.8739462494850159,
-0.43019556999206543,
0.3695860803127289,
-0.39635956287384033,
-0.369255006313324,
-0.5795570611953735,
0.878532350063324,
-0.09270776063203812,
-0.0809675008058548,
0.7062754034996033,
0.40154242515563965,
-0.01921200379729271,
-0.05127628147602081,
0.48187756538391113,
0.24859191477298737,
0.5124696493148804,
0.5405153632164001,
0.7184894680976868,
-0.903720498085022,
0.993007481098175,
-0.3159638047218323,
-0.36634841561317444,
-0.24185357987880707,
-0.971490740776062,
-1.308598279953003,
-0.5723127722740173,
-0.5851356387138367,
-0.8637033700942993,
0.2579030394554138,
0.3226674199104309,
0.5488826036453247,
-0.9795640707015991,
0.3840143382549286,
-0.2346426546573639,
0.4012432396411896,
-0.02936618961393833,
-0.2300170212984085,
0.5087713599205017,
-0.17436324059963226,
-0.6138644218444824,
0.0804857462644577,
0.027519356459379196,
0.8076494336128235,
-0.533739447593689,
0.3512443006038666,
0.07188926637172699,
-0.06607996672391891,
0.521613359451294,
0.15253926813602448,
-0.1977146714925766,
-0.07003901898860931,
-0.26847100257873535,
-0.3329697847366333,
-0.24121546745300293,
0.7483670711517334,
-0.7721560001373291,
0.2809455990791321,
0.3095554709434509,
1.1579089164733887,
0.5089943408966064,
-0.15033620595932007,
0.4820270538330078,
-0.8308285474777222,
0.2221619188785553,
0.6082395315170288,
0.26477718353271484,
0.346285879611969,
-0.5184807777404785,
0.057526301592588425,
0.24744868278503418,
-0.31123781204223633,
-0.9192492961883545,
0.24615496397018433,
-0.6676256656646729,
-0.6010046601295471,
0.8890020847320557,
-0.5299259424209595,
-0.3621301054954529,
-0.24471555650234222,
-0.211295485496521,
0.03679582476615906,
-0.39416244626045227,
0.7424979209899902,
0.7066367864608765,
0.45218878984451294,
0.10395906120538712,
-0.4301527142524719,
0.5807769298553467,
0.048734378069639206,
-0.6507888436317444,
-0.10944464802742004,
-0.02970430813729763,
-0.06759152561426163,
0.415271520614624,
0.23273783922195435,
-0.3142557442188263,
0.39617636799812317,
0.6276971697807312,
-0.22094817459583282,
0.06672336906194687,
-0.10818007588386536,
-0.8807666301727295,
0.49547919631004333,
-0.10320145636796951,
-0.32680654525756836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06687v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06687v1
|
Hire Me or Not? Examining Language Model's Behavior with Occupation Attributes
| 2024-05-06T18:09:32 | 2024-05-06T18:09:32 |
Damin Zhang, Yi Zhang, Geetanjali Bihani, Julia Rayz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the impressive performance in various downstream tasks, large language
models (LLMs) have been widely integrated into production pipelines, like
recruitment and recommendation systems. A known issue of models trained on
natural language data is the presence of human biases, which can impact the
fairness of the system. This paper investigates LLMs' behavior with respect to
gender stereotypes, in the context of occupation decision making. Our framework
is designed to investigate and quantify the presence of gender stereotypes in
LLMs' behavior via multi-round question answering. Inspired by prior works, we
construct a dataset by leveraging a standard occupation classification
knowledge base released by authoritative agencies. We tested three LLMs
(RoBERTa-large, GPT-3.5-turbo, and Llama2-70b-chat) and found that all models
exhibit gender stereotypes analogous to human biases, but with different
preferences. The distinct preferences of GPT-3.5-turbo and Llama2-70b-chat may
imply the current alignment methods are insufficient for debiasing and could
introduce new biases contradicting the traditional gender stereotypes.
|
[
-0.274537593126297,
-0.5616512894630432,
0.7533380389213562,
0.10714047402143478,
0.237772136926651,
0.07272400707006454,
-0.047993071377277374,
-0.37202292680740356,
0.12332247197628021,
0.7743859887123108,
-0.7618375420570374,
-0.3931809365749359,
-0.59409499168396,
0.4147563874721527,
-0.4457723796367645,
0.7694922089576721,
0.2837819755077362,
0.2217404842376709,
-0.3061773478984833,
0.0552704744040966,
-0.705805778503418,
-0.7538194060325623,
-0.5165531039237976,
-0.21029812097549438,
0.3377174139022827,
0.42277294397354126,
0.8488447070121765,
0.4165201187133789,
0.1103520467877388,
0.35559597611427307,
-0.016439354047179222,
-0.014029785990715027,
-0.24893081188201904,
0.2582576274871826,
-0.0018263304373249412,
-0.814439058303833,
-0.35341814160346985,
0.519576907157898,
0.12232999503612518,
0.8547772169113159,
-0.3008993864059448,
0.44452792406082153,
-0.2836083769798279,
0.511009693145752,
-0.5345113277435303,
0.14126212894916534,
-0.8441429734230042,
-0.09680032730102539,
-0.2898080348968506,
0.16640090942382812,
-0.3087095618247986,
-0.4833769202232361,
0.14919470250606537,
-0.1828164905309677,
0.4711948037147522,
0.39356324076652527,
0.5997607111930847,
-0.03395621106028557,
-0.5610863566398621,
-0.3421289324760437,
-0.6383795142173767,
0.9409079551696777,
-0.840537428855896,
0.43104109168052673,
0.6970486640930176,
0.4978410601615906,
-0.11210759729146957,
-0.0074249194003641605,
-0.5678423047065735,
-0.3243199586868286,
-0.14433370530605316,
-0.19550707936286926,
-0.003521878970786929,
0.09134155511856079,
0.3353695869445801,
0.278230220079422,
-0.5930279493331909,
0.48800885677337646,
-0.6379299163818359,
-0.13548867404460907,
0.36590543389320374,
0.11776736378669739,
0.33898016810417175,
-0.09039009362459183,
-0.14058905839920044,
-0.058129046112298965,
-0.4094599187374115,
0.08901975303888321,
1.0355727672576904,
0.2597578167915344,
0.009468221105635166,
0.7201822400093079,
-0.35461509227752686,
0.6787559390068054,
0.16192856431007385,
-0.14403414726257324,
0.23320722579956055,
0.22059640288352966,
-0.24601101875305176,
0.07781990617513657,
0.681280255317688,
0.4658645689487457,
0.5310851335525513,
-0.19735309481620789,
-0.24612081050872803,
-0.07035123556852341,
0.4806438982486725,
-0.3295149803161621,
0.293232798576355,
0.27068570256233215,
-0.4285668432712555,
-0.3852790594100952,
-0.11500904709100723,
-0.6964952349662781,
-0.5665163993835449,
-0.17689846456050873,
0.08012484759092331,
0.028881648555397987,
-0.35895341634750366,
-0.024877632036805153,
-0.31821078062057495,
0.28322696685791016,
0.14409418404102325,
-1.2812379598617554,
-0.03546707332134247,
0.6685364246368408,
0.5408397912979126,
0.09566494822502136,
-0.1520230919122696,
-0.4587266147136688,
0.023349327966570854,
-0.44099828600883484,
0.3762739598751068,
-0.7287142872810364,
-0.3486601412296295,
0.23061582446098328,
0.026088038459420204,
-0.2823803722858429,
-0.8477134108543396,
0.5699033737182617,
-0.6146348714828491,
0.3632318675518036,
-0.2903316020965576,
-0.33483582735061646,
-0.10499371588230133,
0.41404351592063904,
-0.4221987724304199,
0.9968895316123962,
0.23140311241149902,
-0.544579267501831,
0.5692629218101501,
-0.4887145459651947,
0.044460322707891464,
-0.3227153420448303,
-0.5493177771568298,
-0.2461913675069809,
-0.011655976064503193,
0.1512478142976761,
0.47945159673690796,
-0.26239392161369324,
0.5552531480789185,
-0.7438158392906189,
-0.23102255165576935,
0.585444450378418,
-0.22630685567855835,
0.8604013323783875,
0.24082687497138977,
-0.10174398869276047,
-0.10601958632469177,
-0.29963943362236023,
-0.35448867082595825,
0.03369160741567612,
-0.27650871872901917,
-0.4191243350505829,
-0.033661987632513046,
-0.41292765736579895,
0.46400755643844604,
0.07715974748134613,
-0.719355583190918,
0.16733834147453308,
-0.3070679008960724,
0.1858203262090683,
1.0281516313552856,
-0.4586203396320343,
0.6651213765144348,
-0.36296379566192627,
0.8108511567115784,
-0.21317847073078156,
-0.013352932408452034,
0.5857283473014832,
-0.4604012966156006,
-0.598717451095581,
-0.1422700732946396,
-0.01876271516084671,
0.5466302633285522,
-0.6661818027496338,
0.3097606599330902,
-0.13863064348697662,
-0.25709283351898193,
-0.5487914681434631,
0.29442593455314636,
0.36915963888168335,
0.3190583288669586,
0.0639619380235672,
0.0827072486281395,
-0.6288113594055176,
-1.3396048545837402,
-0.6117228269577026,
-0.3077770471572876,
-0.08898879587650299,
0.22260615229606628,
0.4037488102912903,
-0.12467478215694427,
1.1932049989700317,
-0.48080965876579285,
-0.29053303599357605,
-0.29811331629753113,
0.15864254534244537,
0.5546219348907471,
0.17222021520137787,
0.9176319241523743,
-0.5509552359580994,
-0.11116017401218414,
-0.3948190212249756,
-0.7830975651741028,
-0.330443412065506,
0.1630963236093521,
-0.14897234737873077,
0.20607580244541168,
0.5701661109924316,
-0.651005744934082,
0.15634582936763763,
0.7740575671195984,
-0.4797402024269104,
0.7806225419044495,
-0.008652845397591591,
0.10350030660629272,
-0.6101723313331604,
-0.3160998821258545,
0.17140357196331024,
-0.18840786814689636,
-0.6240801215171814,
-0.2622171640396118,
-0.31676626205444336,
-0.12066029012203217,
-0.3767049312591553,
0.5791048407554626,
-0.48815494775772095,
-0.37203091382980347,
-0.0336206816136837,
-0.07659461349248886,
-0.03376387804746628,
0.41257616877555847,
0.1197589635848999,
0.8680270314216614,
0.2781969904899597,
-0.8672342896461487,
0.025276819244027138,
0.5288407802581787,
-0.3706832528114319,
0.6107799410820007,
-0.31278595328330994,
0.32600894570350647,
-0.4753740429878235,
0.1916787326335907,
-0.9933790564537048,
-0.16786673665046692,
0.0927906334400177,
-0.3426094949245453,
-0.021423468366265297,
-0.24567869305610657,
-0.6255127191543579,
-0.6116366982460022,
-0.26041701436042786,
0.27587342262268066,
0.5236916542053223,
-0.3725335896015167,
0.30666032433509827,
0.5188837051391602,
-0.315094530582428,
-0.7126218676567078,
-0.8062721490859985,
-0.15428157150745392,
-0.48694220185279846,
-0.6267551779747009,
-0.013259542174637318,
0.1646733283996582,
-0.742148220539093,
-0.5545188188552856,
-0.17093513906002045,
-0.3555600941181183,
-0.0739879235625267,
0.144317626953125,
0.2824981212615967,
-0.08219675719738007,
-0.1682775467634201,
-0.10199443995952606,
0.09290368109941483,
0.17999327182769775,
0.11203642934560776,
0.4416874051094055,
0.08392980694770813,
-0.42986398935317993,
-0.05077124387025833,
0.01914648897945881,
0.7574813365936279,
0.052442654967308044,
0.785812258720398,
0.770969808101654,
-0.04247165098786354,
0.07169730961322784,
-0.9952160716056824,
-0.2658937871456146,
-0.5011338591575623,
0.4544134736061096,
0.01822688803076744,
-1.1659785509109497,
0.40827104449272156,
0.3180190622806549,
0.19533604383468628,
0.1953372359275818,
0.49692997336387634,
-0.3112544119358063,
1.0667709112167358,
0.5220972299575806,
-0.20894061028957367,
0.31079816818237305,
0.03335368260741234,
0.27849119901657104,
-0.7425537705421448,
-0.20092567801475525,
-0.6723822951316833,
-0.37224194407463074,
-0.6123813390731812,
-0.4401138424873352,
0.3836139440536499,
-0.25678321719169617,
-0.25881198048591614,
0.04444492235779762,
-0.2462681084871292,
0.08266090601682663,
0.541740894317627,
-0.13014550507068634,
0.1720590889453888,
-0.2620910108089447,
0.14502465724945068,
-0.13254845142364502,
-0.4514443278312683,
-0.7656431794166565,
0.8713560104370117,
0.324993759393692,
0.6580193638801575,
0.4466738998889923,
0.31421321630477905,
0.49409982562065125,
0.09892141819000244,
-0.2531375288963318,
0.6320247054100037,
-0.31298720836639404,
-1.217519998550415,
-0.38240447640419006,
-0.3726000189781189,
-0.9131693243980408,
0.4412637948989868,
-0.3381393551826477,
-0.8489831686019897,
0.3411073684692383,
0.12069980800151825,
-0.10189907252788544,
0.5462438464164734,
-0.7691643834114075,
0.7284196019172668,
-0.48032960295677185,
0.083191879093647,
-0.1255197823047638,
-0.39771825075149536,
0.698634147644043,
-0.034248221665620804,
0.822435200214386,
-0.7913153767585754,
0.11609818041324615,
0.6495344042778015,
-0.5033648610115051,
1.0257056951522827,
-0.28532034158706665,
-0.18612617254257202,
0.20067183673381805,
0.1785312443971634,
0.47241687774658203,
-0.16858413815498352,
-0.716362714767456,
0.24288451671600342,
-0.038592077791690826,
-0.2679332494735718,
-0.34179726243019104,
0.46321362257003784,
-0.6898629665374756,
-0.676781415939331,
-0.4483253061771393,
-0.5348000526428223,
-0.4100464880466461,
0.06606384366750717,
0.09457261860370636,
0.17601071298122406,
-0.21050305664539337,
0.005939210299402475,
0.27488791942596436,
-0.6373070478439331,
0.13123959302902222,
0.4342546761035919,
-0.5389907360076904,
0.2527286112308502,
0.6128528118133545,
0.075670026242733,
0.3791143596172333,
0.13515931367874146,
-0.016572775319218636,
-0.5528764724731445,
-0.16970215737819672,
-0.47921687364578247,
0.2245507389307022,
-0.390419602394104,
-0.0009371378691866994,
-0.6969640851020813,
-0.022518349811434746,
-0.6679007411003113,
0.033596962690353394,
-0.23698432743549347,
-0.1320529282093048,
-0.07804002612829208,
-0.16400480270385742,
0.3776153028011322,
0.6565869450569153,
0.3286990225315094,
0.34434959292411804,
-0.4265105724334717,
0.5152965784072876,
0.6306290626525879,
0.37577417492866516,
-0.21591922640800476,
-0.5243417620658875,
0.04982810467481613,
0.14250585436820984,
-0.2732886075973511,
-0.9035014510154724,
0.4449146091938019,
0.01691097766160965,
0.8383995294570923,
0.17373420298099518,
0.08752920478582382,
0.2400515228509903,
-0.17517612874507904,
0.7557262182235718,
-0.03350504860281944,
-0.5249475240707397,
0.1615443229675293,
-0.7392904162406921,
-0.06941261887550354,
0.5470956563949585,
0.18491695821285248,
-0.4425661563873291,
-0.8706645369529724,
-0.6516203284263611,
-0.66507488489151,
1.099700689315796,
0.4401826858520508,
0.45065611600875854,
-0.18590477108955383,
0.3366793096065521,
0.18706735968589783,
0.7228910326957703,
-0.7112149000167847,
-0.45517826080322266,
0.10110687464475632,
0.09094548225402832,
0.2299821376800537,
-0.505835771560669,
0.3574337959289551,
-0.07147307693958282,
0.6188958883285522,
0.17066317796707153,
0.25378477573394775,
-0.22525285184383392,
-0.22342829406261444,
0.33200803399086,
0.7492157220840454,
0.30944564938545227,
0.6303027868270874,
-0.6203305721282959,
0.11246809363365173,
0.339345246553421,
-0.06780078262090683,
0.3001682162284851,
-0.2854662835597992,
-0.0904160887002945,
0.21499763429164886,
-0.02659723162651062,
0.698330819606781,
0.02669849433004856,
-0.7517291903495789,
0.5341666340827942,
0.02141677960753441,
-0.4090113341808319,
-0.41719573736190796,
0.16480763256549835,
0.048257242888212204,
0.24049635231494904,
0.2383071333169937,
-0.11807488650083542,
0.1826942414045334,
-0.6480041146278381,
-0.3146202862262726,
0.7220462560653687,
-0.45168283581733704,
-0.028684355318546295,
0.739018976688385,
0.2713421881198883,
-0.07791208475828171,
0.9174746870994568,
-0.34624817967414856,
-0.4024806022644043,
0.7251793146133423,
0.37568199634552,
0.6768208742141724,
-0.06226328760385513,
0.328113317489624,
0.28047415614128113,
0.41458383202552795,
-0.1286233514547348,
0.038746677339076996,
0.6262131929397583,
-1.0003736019134521,
-0.3319856524467468,
-0.5771951079368591,
-0.44153454899787903,
0.1605064421892166,
-0.49992215633392334,
0.44999054074287415,
-0.4453608989715576,
-0.3930952847003937,
-0.1528596132993698,
-0.626143753528595,
-0.7976303696632385,
0.27837106585502625,
0.3135554790496826,
0.5674283504486084,
-1.0092135667800903,
0.462592750787735,
0.7539262175559998,
-0.3932834565639496,
-0.5219690799713135,
-0.10039032250642776,
0.22174784541130066,
-1.0476793050765991,
0.704998791217804,
0.1734384149312973,
0.0028844645712524652,
-0.2378329038619995,
-0.40070703625679016,
-0.631969153881073,
0.8774816393852234,
0.8509126901626587,
-0.24851438403129578,
-0.2088950276374817,
0.20085735619068146,
0.26536479592323303,
-0.4442329704761505,
0.6040579080581665,
0.7729023098945618,
0.5163399577140808,
-0.23270997405052185,
-1.228137493133545,
-0.24627052247524261,
0.06488954275846481,
0.02114889770746231,
-0.07674117386341095,
-0.7172293663024902,
0.9561851620674133,
-0.17349036037921906,
0.24261370301246643,
-0.11023729294538498,
0.44863361120224,
0.46320703625679016,
0.016699882224202156,
0.9082616567611694,
0.1563418209552765,
0.8695041537284851,
0.026482686400413513,
1.0683119297027588,
0.1267997920513153,
0.25895729660987854,
0.8160359859466553,
-0.38693639636039734,
0.35099372267723083,
0.37886881828308105,
-0.47334912419319153,
0.7377718687057495,
0.5646708011627197,
-0.02991955541074276,
0.07984022051095963,
0.18480828404426575,
0.05702837556600571,
-0.5334663987159729,
-0.3827230930328369,
-0.2972949147224426,
0.6885809302330017,
0.1085972934961319,
-0.3224680721759796,
-0.3207438290119171,
-0.19199645519256592,
0.15745490789413452,
0.1345035880804062,
-0.23081013560295105,
0.5342782139778137,
0.16390731930732727,
-0.45997554063796997,
0.3700505197048187,
0.21445100009441376,
0.9217846393585205,
-0.5006092190742493,
-0.05945919081568718,
-0.1260608732700348,
-0.1435198038816452,
-0.3767741024494171,
-0.7754455804824829,
0.2900426685810089,
0.07536996901035309,
-0.536715567111969,
-0.3154256045818329,
0.3636816740036011,
-0.39360105991363525,
-0.5548543930053711,
0.1405317187309265,
0.67207270860672,
0.28018850088119507,
-0.2781106233596802,
-0.6902567744255066,
-0.2981751263141632,
0.15127769112586975,
0.060407817363739014,
0.5874123573303223,
0.25520607829093933,
-0.28887850046157837,
0.8639392256736755,
0.6947083473205566,
0.009063026867806911,
0.1780620962381363,
0.21717065572738647,
0.2879072427749634,
-0.5886461734771729,
-0.5095320343971252,
-0.9161960482597351,
0.3264463245868683,
-0.043872084468603134,
-0.18677067756652832,
0.7252030968666077,
0.5910292267799377,
0.5164340734481812,
-0.31319981813430786,
0.9147905111312866,
-0.010543763637542725,
0.8863332271575928,
-0.5540176033973694,
0.4341721832752228,
-0.4497690498828888,
0.482235848903656,
-0.47937461733818054,
-1.002745509147644,
0.21558140218257904,
0.5384697318077087,
-0.6905985474586487,
0.45609745383262634,
0.36651521921157837,
0.9475435614585876,
-0.1107768639922142,
-0.09648997336626053,
0.3385762572288513,
0.1597699224948883,
0.2150905728340149,
0.16505733132362366,
0.9817260503768921,
0.06495930999517441,
0.6481762528419495,
0.06256037205457687,
0.05908786505460739,
-0.36108827590942383,
-0.821208119392395,
-0.900730311870575,
-0.21938802301883698,
-0.27606400847435,
-0.3630935549736023,
-0.16342324018478394,
1.0256356000900269,
0.6706512570381165,
-0.6761102676391602,
-0.5850825309753418,
0.4068032205104828,
0.407124787569046,
0.12895449995994568,
-0.26696863770484924,
-0.08178823441267014,
-0.3622928261756897,
-0.7667399048805237,
0.30793851613998413,
-0.054019395262002945,
-0.18983706831932068,
-0.22403714060783386,
-0.023305578157305717,
-0.42452895641326904,
-0.11887257546186447,
0.28190070390701294,
0.13833780586719513,
-0.8130008578300476,
-0.2715896666049957,
-0.007221719715744257,
-0.25473183393478394,
0.02152295596897602,
0.6607479453086853,
-0.4552657902240753,
0.338209331035614,
0.2166507989168167,
0.357543408870697,
0.19958770275115967,
0.0810820460319519,
0.9697538614273071,
-1.0305670499801636,
0.2840213179588318,
-0.0012187783140689135,
0.3787291646003723,
0.44330891966819763,
-0.46795105934143066,
0.5531578063964844,
0.04355689883232117,
-0.5598531365394592,
-0.6607126593589783,
0.15052755177021027,
-0.5670875310897827,
-0.18389733135700226,
1.5177395343780518,
0.4077109396457672,
0.179544135928154,
-0.47472602128982544,
-0.1843169629573822,
0.06467731297016144,
-0.6409128308296204,
0.6896142959594727,
0.7101947665214539,
-0.2202957719564438,
0.034572891891002655,
-1.2321524620056152,
0.3982623219490051,
0.4440178871154785,
-0.3665759265422821,
0.04529194533824921,
0.6091961860656738,
0.39066722989082336,
-0.05217605084180832,
1.0191354751586914,
0.05144191533327103,
0.01992473192512989,
-0.46816131472587585,
0.29534390568733215,
0.040960632264614105,
0.20624057948589325,
-0.044708654284477234,
-0.12388815730810165,
0.6153086423873901,
-0.24128933250904083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03764v1
|
GOVERN: Gradient Orientation Vote Ensemble for Multi-Teacher Reinforced Distillation
| 2024-05-06T18:02:00 | 2024-05-06T18:02:00 |
Wenjie Zhou, Zhenxin Ding, Xiaodong Zhang, Haibo Shi, Junfeng Wang, Dawei Yin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Pre-trained language models have become an integral component of
question-answering systems, achieving remarkable performance. For practical
deployment, it is critical to carry out knowledge distillation to preserve high
performance under computational constraints. In this paper, we address a key
question: given the importance of unsupervised distillation for student
performance, how does one effectively ensemble knowledge from multiple teachers
at this stage without the guidance of ground-truth labels? We propose a novel
algorithm, GOVERN, to tackle this issue. GOVERN has demonstrated significant
improvements in both offline and online experiments. The proposed algorithm has
been successfully deployed in a real-world commercial question-answering
system.
|
[
-0.523249089717865,
-0.501104474067688,
0.6420649290084839,
0.47781530022621155,
-0.1799653321504593,
0.2792210876941681,
-0.30425703525543213,
0.15804268419742584,
0.053164128214120865,
0.5361491441726685,
-0.4147646725177765,
-0.47704100608825684,
-0.6385221481323242,
-0.12224174290895462,
-0.38731953501701355,
1.270111083984375,
0.16766180098056793,
0.4605026841163635,
-0.649079442024231,
-0.08258289098739624,
-0.18869741261005402,
-0.3474881947040558,
-0.38603267073631287,
-0.6753532290458679,
0.2509987950325012,
0.5357024073600769,
0.39427393674850464,
0.4522014260292053,
0.24667119979858398,
0.3904494047164917,
-0.11582127958536148,
0.23245353996753693,
-0.5331745147705078,
0.12498684972524643,
-0.2350289672613144,
-0.8544288873672485,
-0.11558890342712402,
0.22156399488449097,
0.5176785588264465,
0.4933452904224396,
-0.8921507596969604,
0.01893104612827301,
0.3118301331996918,
0.6409484148025513,
-0.833099901676178,
-0.24065569043159485,
-0.6634283661842346,
-0.057890478521585464,
0.10683178156614304,
-0.31181976199150085,
-0.33876481652259827,
-0.6822812557220459,
0.15700708329677582,
-0.6872411966323853,
0.10654851049184799,
-0.0533527173101902,
0.3056563436985016,
0.5016653537750244,
-0.44998544454574585,
-0.35615119338035583,
-0.8469118475914001,
0.6919658184051514,
-0.6068435907363892,
0.046027157455682755,
0.2987682819366455,
0.4663306176662445,
-0.22557459771633148,
-1.0283145904541016,
-0.831054151058197,
0.35321736335754395,
-0.14105792343616486,
0.20747844874858856,
0.2453562468290329,
0.4152921736240387,
-0.14133301377296448,
0.3706054091453552,
-0.18260551989078522,
-0.07542434334754944,
-0.498421847820282,
-0.10588611662387848,
0.3357621431350708,
-0.027089865878224373,
-0.2125953733921051,
0.14750830829143524,
-0.5207725763320923,
-0.2916216254234314,
-0.35367101430892944,
0.28268271684646606,
0.4235791862010956,
0.08745227009057999,
0.3152634799480438,
0.3425321578979492,
-0.2310730516910553,
0.7289168834686279,
0.567932665348053,
-0.06543401628732681,
-0.02959708869457245,
-0.21336232125759125,
-0.2256872057914734,
0.2749469578266144,
0.7151074409484863,
0.25764140486717224,
0.00220796512439847,
-0.02038837969303131,
-0.061299387365579605,
0.010957609862089157,
0.10655868053436279,
-0.9210835695266724,
-0.39201220870018005,
0.157175675034523,
-0.0267124492675066,
-0.5748014450073242,
0.2767026424407959,
-1.266837477684021,
-0.6345754861831665,
-0.4908749461174011,
0.6652763485908508,
0.03331831842660904,
-0.4483236074447632,
0.0976455807685852,
-0.4319882094860077,
0.16177424788475037,
0.22666527330875397,
-0.9160681366920471,
0.2688570022583008,
0.8576890230178833,
0.5913249254226685,
0.06715431064367294,
-0.478971004486084,
-0.5364323854446411,
-0.0520634725689888,
-0.011299227364361286,
0.4242386817932129,
-0.7899154424667358,
-0.36696550250053406,
-0.16655561327934265,
-0.2751142978668213,
-0.04644028842449188,
-0.41933053731918335,
0.36578369140625,
-0.6278029084205627,
0.6961526274681091,
-0.13116341829299927,
-0.7793728709220886,
-0.09212398529052734,
0.3248083293437958,
-0.22383643686771393,
0.9889649748802185,
-0.20738446712493896,
-0.7087517380714417,
0.423056423664093,
-0.5520089864730835,
-0.27045103907585144,
-0.16237090528011322,
-0.13230584561824799,
-0.3235292434692383,
0.026162490248680115,
0.5801091194152832,
0.3371967375278473,
-0.19231043756008148,
0.6039643883705139,
-0.16629847884178162,
-0.3925184905529022,
0.003746028058230877,
-0.42193472385406494,
1.017350196838379,
0.13771459460258484,
-0.32458558678627014,
0.14849993586540222,
-0.7724223136901855,
0.22284500300884247,
-0.4960237741470337,
-0.33980923891067505,
-0.4719206690788269,
0.15074275434017181,
-0.28999364376068115,
0.15532927215099335,
0.2266150414943695,
-0.5113154649734497,
0.5227062702178955,
0.017413653433322906,
0.5451609492301941,
0.839354932308197,
0.06521323323249817,
0.8816609978675842,
-0.14033325016498566,
0.591086208820343,
0.20643383264541626,
0.3167654573917389,
0.09794634580612183,
-0.44628238677978516,
-0.6750414967536926,
-0.3607887029647827,
0.43704330921173096,
0.5608475804328918,
-0.9705950021743774,
0.21413233876228333,
-0.0724281519651413,
-0.7671018838882446,
-0.6274996399879456,
0.2809848487377167,
0.25257086753845215,
0.851938009262085,
0.46246016025543213,
0.17676764726638794,
-0.32685187458992004,
-0.5993379950523376,
-0.14182914793491364,
-0.25447577238082886,
-0.061793580651283264,
0.20560629665851593,
0.1747870147228241,
-0.03287242352962494,
1.079537034034729,
-0.9496111869812012,
-0.2482786327600479,
0.12629370391368866,
0.5680957436561584,
0.26301175355911255,
0.4579380750656128,
0.6010287404060364,
-0.8986092209815979,
-0.3674832284450531,
-0.2687540352344513,
-0.46180394291877747,
-0.07438971102237701,
0.15954966843128204,
-0.45497044920921326,
-0.22548922896385193,
0.45932674407958984,
-0.27935120463371277,
-0.0025596315972507,
0.6432376503944397,
-0.2865849435329437,
0.18328972160816193,
-0.46101510524749756,
0.3446796238422394,
-0.9585954546928406,
-0.25285494327545166,
-0.16207994520664215,
-0.2067878246307373,
-0.5790342092514038,
0.05853791534900665,
0.08806849271059036,
-0.05123646929860115,
-0.4243638813495636,
-0.03423474356532097,
-0.2990439236164093,
0.4920711815357208,
-0.13422416150569916,
0.007524342741817236,
0.23781916499137878,
0.5461329817771912,
0.19267039000988007,
0.6269527077674866,
0.970659613609314,
-0.9399901032447815,
0.5698879361152649,
-0.018326105549931526,
-0.5286717414855957,
1.0013171434402466,
-0.36849120259284973,
0.2639296352863312,
-0.5887431502342224,
0.3263002038002014,
-1.1197415590286255,
-0.10105903446674347,
-0.20935262739658356,
-0.3462735712528229,
0.22816434502601624,
-0.37310782074928284,
-0.036977123469114304,
-0.2542545199394226,
-0.25036171078681946,
0.2070452719926834,
0.4982782006263733,
-0.8227109909057617,
0.7243277430534363,
0.4130959212779999,
0.37469741702079773,
-0.8697312474250793,
-0.5203005075454712,
-0.2943577468395233,
-0.6030194759368896,
-0.49909475445747375,
0.1349789798259735,
0.0641101747751236,
-0.14918063580989838,
0.02319132536649704,
-0.006328484509140253,
-0.44285401701927185,
0.30949631333351135,
0.0670405849814415,
-0.12431042641401291,
-0.15381208062171936,
0.2053147405385971,
0.31800681352615356,
0.2585638463497162,
0.1131778359413147,
-0.5683161616325378,
0.3852189779281616,
0.08882056176662445,
-0.10082879662513733,
-0.15732774138450623,
0.1781700998544693,
0.955917239189148,
-0.34602415561676025,
0.9542016386985779,
0.4145621955394745,
-0.037741683423519135,
-0.6601992249488831,
-0.40134045481681824,
-0.42554542422294617,
-0.5869031548500061,
0.19210107624530792,
-0.16909494996070862,
-0.6144609451293945,
0.5826677083969116,
-0.37560969591140747,
0.09643569588661194,
0.050628308206796646,
0.3470775783061981,
-0.2140028178691864,
0.7306948900222778,
0.41702523827552795,
-0.07510256767272949,
0.46873900294303894,
-0.14937256276607513,
0.17772531509399414,
-0.39120426774024963,
-0.4616822302341461,
-0.6173295974731445,
-0.47399693727493286,
-0.7085238695144653,
-0.3799166977405548,
0.7482571005821228,
0.4899958670139313,
-0.03166252747178078,
0.02413257583975792,
-0.8091452717781067,
0.6278188824653625,
0.9327923655509949,
0.1606704145669937,
0.24444061517715454,
-0.08246114104986191,
-0.1459815800189972,
0.19775812327861786,
-0.6480624675750732,
-0.2050795704126358,
1.2395195960998535,
0.006103646010160446,
0.7404330968856812,
0.309845894575119,
1.0274397134780884,
0.0356953926384449,
0.3634003698825836,
-0.3667023181915283,
0.45155757665634155,
-0.03588985279202461,
-0.8625256419181824,
-0.5513356328010559,
-0.45835840702056885,
-0.599653422832489,
0.6754776239395142,
-0.27607461810112,
-0.27326592803001404,
0.19190913438796997,
0.4050520956516266,
-0.46151942014694214,
0.3780859112739563,
-0.9264761209487915,
0.6901459097862244,
-0.1993281990289688,
-0.560185432434082,
-0.15826617181301117,
-0.5501270294189453,
0.34419938921928406,
-0.024073421955108643,
0.2383679896593094,
0.26208361983299255,
0.26652467250823975,
0.6843287944793701,
-0.6323077082633972,
0.5070885419845581,
-0.7852445840835571,
-0.06887131929397583,
0.7313121557235718,
-0.1837499737739563,
0.474145770072937,
0.291647732257843,
-0.08449119329452515,
-0.036624349653720856,
0.40574589371681213,
-0.24824051558971405,
-1.060239553451538,
0.8490623235702515,
-0.8598589301109314,
-0.910305917263031,
-0.3128259479999542,
-0.017733490094542503,
-0.4558922350406647,
0.059402890503406525,
0.47314056754112244,
0.2851225733757019,
-0.06951457262039185,
0.39993056654930115,
0.6665189862251282,
0.4699106812477112,
0.5813716650009155,
0.47903305292129517,
-0.4745750427246094,
-0.5148624181747437,
0.9554692506790161,
0.1820838302373886,
0.17684610188007355,
0.5289958715438843,
0.588916540145874,
-0.7511703372001648,
-0.4467092752456665,
-0.682874858379364,
-0.32669270038604736,
-0.5562391877174377,
-0.032687075436115265,
-0.3361181616783142,
0.08947751671075821,
-0.5475435256958008,
-0.04283996671438217,
-0.3367432951927185,
-0.503513753414154,
-0.4922648072242737,
-0.10940675437450409,
0.35010042786598206,
0.8713661432266235,
-0.19053997099399567,
0.5657250285148621,
-0.47466060519218445,
0.051556240767240524,
0.9406219720840454,
0.46169164776802063,
-0.19399181008338928,
-0.2980669140815735,
0.06093352660536766,
0.3702864348888397,
-0.4809470474720001,
-1.1086664199829102,
-0.10345686972141266,
0.4460616111755371,
0.5037304162979126,
0.7251145243644714,
0.44870123267173767,
0.7167321443557739,
-0.3495583236217499,
0.6148086786270142,
0.12161195278167725,
-0.9612239599227905,
0.43943843245506287,
-0.23326539993286133,
-0.00546175567433238,
0.9715831279754639,
0.44984182715415955,
-0.3318255543708801,
-0.4624677002429962,
-0.2975671589374542,
-0.6978912949562073,
0.6579337120056152,
-0.011327574960887432,
0.14178669452667236,
0.2813742160797119,
0.33080509305000305,
-0.07448293268680573,
0.6152682900428772,
-0.5241246819496155,
-0.4736655652523041,
-0.5425511598587036,
-0.44805583357810974,
-0.2846056818962097,
-0.08188865333795547,
-0.18114633858203888,
-0.5159725546836853,
0.6404744386672974,
-0.031861890107393265,
-0.20854178071022034,
0.1802084743976593,
0.07942987978458405,
0.2115577757358551,
0.40061238408088684,
0.5978260636329651,
0.6007388234138489,
-0.1975550353527069,
0.3913859724998474,
-0.0319928377866745,
-0.6865456104278564,
0.4912952184677124,
-0.04254233092069626,
-0.29573532938957214,
-0.3870597779750824,
-0.08384197950363159,
0.7416431307792664,
-0.0574190728366375,
-0.05410425364971161,
0.4971901476383209,
-0.10716652125120163,
-0.42793649435043335,
-0.13566866517066956,
0.3227318525314331,
0.04385443776845932,
0.21061068773269653,
0.5582525730133057,
0.21416062116622925,
0.13290438055992126,
-0.46817073225975037,
0.1933766007423401,
0.2814733386039734,
-0.2928149104118347,
-0.14028367400169373,
0.5440203547477722,
0.5394029021263123,
-0.09059371799230576,
0.5313642621040344,
-0.167327880859375,
-0.79413241147995,
0.54204922914505,
0.24021418392658234,
0.47582295536994934,
-0.5415831804275513,
0.43015316128730774,
0.39031246304512024,
0.19624575972557068,
-0.4403998851776123,
0.1223035678267479,
-0.346939355134964,
-0.763424813747406,
-0.15782591700553894,
-0.5715495944023132,
-0.3986794650554657,
-0.01016996894031763,
-0.8018496036529541,
0.2022949457168579,
-0.5769967436790466,
-0.13256758451461792,
0.07241062819957733,
-0.11321154236793518,
-0.334062397480011,
0.19503098726272583,
-0.04074130579829216,
0.3756575286388397,
-1.0948784351348877,
0.8313955664634705,
0.884833574295044,
-0.032137222588062286,
-0.8072742819786072,
-0.05644812434911728,
-0.11867465823888779,
-0.4269934594631195,
0.42398080229759216,
-0.02423858270049095,
-0.24979619681835175,
0.38432401418685913,
-0.7116479277610779,
-0.6268811821937561,
0.9839718341827393,
0.23709391057491302,
-0.6433883905410767,
0.21883414685726166,
0.07262949645519257,
0.6615923643112183,
-0.06727375090122223,
0.4651312232017517,
0.45472055673599243,
0.6074463725090027,
0.35723409056663513,
-0.8369469046592712,
-0.46588489413261414,
0.10031446069478989,
-0.5026902556419373,
0.22254127264022827,
-0.6437388062477112,
0.8646319508552551,
-0.04195714369416237,
-0.13711003959178925,
-0.657983660697937,
0.7821313738822937,
0.10492240637540817,
0.5446577668190002,
0.7382458448410034,
0.6823776960372925,
1.2514690160751343,
-0.1901421695947647,
0.5109652876853943,
-0.302427738904953,
0.5512579083442688,
1.2268190383911133,
-0.24353750050067902,
0.5870079398155212,
0.7948267459869385,
-0.34827008843421936,
0.567554235458374,
0.31783735752105713,
0.2779078483581543,
1.0686402320861816,
0.4677445888519287,
-0.4627159535884857,
-0.5121152400970459,
0.08633372187614441,
-0.15911254286766052,
0.7237728834152222,
0.06313426047563553,
-0.024169042706489563,
-0.048690155148506165,
0.0917995423078537,
-0.04898811876773834,
0.4583093822002411,
-0.6129570603370667,
0.7017970681190491,
-0.35325711965560913,
-1.4389915466308594,
0.41701897978782654,
0.055711779743433,
0.9125239849090576,
-0.3233099579811096,
-0.1192837804555893,
-0.25713133811950684,
0.40877488255500793,
-0.2653866708278656,
-0.8944768309593201,
-0.006486790254712105,
-0.21531230211257935,
-0.2898806929588318,
-0.31567004323005676,
0.23095464706420898,
-0.892289936542511,
-0.5260359644889832,
0.07554344087839127,
0.31998589634895325,
-0.1693665236234665,
-0.04978706315159798,
-0.14355655014514923,
-0.6923956274986267,
0.08779983967542648,
-0.19190184772014618,
0.12238648533821106,
0.5802919864654541,
-0.018143076449632645,
0.5434408783912659,
0.490384578704834,
-0.08245892822742462,
0.6362715363502502,
-0.2049783319234848,
1.0383862257003784,
-0.014832409098744392,
-0.7208216190338135,
-0.8182239532470703,
0.4365672767162323,
-0.1400981843471527,
-0.397569864988327,
0.7413607239723206,
0.4515015184879303,
0.7789457440376282,
0.03263448178768158,
0.5869005918502808,
-0.03981776535511017,
0.348829984664917,
-0.33954906463623047,
0.920301616191864,
-0.5135366916656494,
0.01725843735039234,
-0.13193778693675995,
-0.797816812992096,
-0.07019482553005219,
0.6056413650512695,
-0.32227060198783875,
-0.13611985743045807,
0.37623485922813416,
0.8443235754966736,
-0.05415233597159386,
0.22887873649597168,
0.21539311110973358,
-0.10402564704418182,
0.35687825083732605,
0.5754184722900391,
0.8185449242591858,
-0.20078948140144348,
0.4642328917980194,
-0.5170546174049377,
-0.23388633131980896,
0.1301235556602478,
-0.9476302266120911,
-1.0152294635772705,
-0.6845548748970032,
-0.3889465928077698,
-0.2598893940448761,
-0.20994232594966888,
0.692699134349823,
0.7974380254745483,
-0.8481622934341431,
0.01686936616897583,
-0.39150291681289673,
0.3677099645137787,
-0.18376967310905457,
-0.1947195678949356,
0.31277817487716675,
-0.15811920166015625,
-0.9041562676429749,
0.3586832284927368,
-0.32967332005500793,
-0.12135152518749237,
-0.5875013470649719,
-0.19830769300460815,
-0.344489723443985,
0.10950171202421188,
0.1539079248905182,
0.05548316240310669,
-0.21937035024166107,
0.06420020759105682,
-0.061526309698820114,
0.0725817009806633,
-0.08107178658246994,
0.9607700705528259,
-0.7720520496368408,
0.5448237061500549,
0.7666911482810974,
0.4768719971179962,
0.6544549465179443,
0.40294724702835083,
0.3924967050552368,
-1.0133962631225586,
0.2664180099964142,
0.2590450048446655,
0.028688088059425354,
0.09259802848100662,
-0.35770556330680847,
0.15422804653644562,
0.17346340417861938,
-0.6380023956298828,
-0.7681907415390015,
-0.009941230528056622,
-0.4524933993816376,
-0.14744873344898224,
1.0827991962432861,
-0.383577823638916,
-0.15330731868743896,
0.00620562257245183,
-0.08764979988336563,
0.1378856599330902,
-0.39417794346809387,
0.6784018874168396,
0.826474130153656,
0.19449496269226074,
-0.19810853898525238,
-0.0426492877304554,
0.6200723648071289,
0.4189339280128479,
-0.4549987316131592,
-0.13224829733371735,
0.5236064791679382,
0.4173745810985565,
0.21379657089710236,
0.5013710260391235,
0.1626596748828888,
-0.10981512814760208,
-0.19057612121105194,
-0.002045057713985443,
-0.3659771680831909,
-0.5788666605949402,
-0.3926101326942444,
0.6082010865211487,
-0.12295537441968918,
-0.5743640661239624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03689v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03689v1
|
Pose Priors from Language Models
| 2024-05-06T17:59:36 | 2024-05-06T17:59:36 |
Sanjay Subramanian, Evonne Ng, Lea Müller, Dan Klein, Shiry Ginosar, Trevor Darrell
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
We present a zero-shot pose optimization method that enforces accurate
physical contact constraints when estimating the 3D pose of humans. Our central
insight is that since language is often used to describe physical interaction,
large pretrained text-based models can act as priors on pose estimation.
We can thus leverage this insight to improve pose estimation by converting
natural language descriptors, generated by a large multimodal model (LMM), into
tractable losses to constrain the 3D pose optimization. Despite its simplicity,
our method produces surprisingly compelling pose reconstructions of people in
close contact, correctly capturing the semantics of the social and physical
interactions. We demonstrate that our method rivals more complex
state-of-the-art approaches that require expensive human annotation of contact
points and training specialized models. Moreover, unlike previous approaches,
our method provides a unified framework for resolving self-contact and
person-to-person contact.
|
[
-0.20806534588336945,
-0.4146784842014313,
0.8770047426223755,
-0.24347130954265594,
0.06352528184652328,
-0.3656595051288605,
0.04370667785406113,
-0.719691276550293,
0.25625520944595337,
0.5445926785469055,
-0.5671098828315735,
-0.5229821801185608,
-0.24471591413021088,
-0.024734843522310257,
-0.024403180927038193,
0.4787341058254242,
0.047156814485788345,
-0.3024888038635254,
-0.3623610734939575,
-0.12256190180778503,
-0.24049076437950134,
-0.8694573640823364,
-0.21911375224590302,
-0.21181881427764893,
0.5307641625404358,
0.23552273213863373,
0.7580761313438416,
0.5013983845710754,
0.32530421018600464,
0.23689156770706177,
0.17695824801921844,
0.20371563732624054,
-0.3197230398654938,
-0.01314542256295681,
-0.15702645480632782,
-0.3631349503993988,
-0.23447705805301666,
0.23952223360538483,
0.6582861542701721,
1.0296772718429565,
-0.05248027667403221,
0.007488622330129147,
-0.4344143867492676,
0.6635521650314331,
-1.130874514579773,
-0.2174980193376541,
-0.28958791494369507,
0.11242488771677017,
-0.5984380841255188,
-0.08981098234653473,
-0.48707115650177,
-0.01916544698178768,
0.13896843791007996,
-0.6752029657363892,
0.4527890384197235,
-0.1599111258983612,
0.8610954880714417,
0.3475669324398041,
-0.41857147216796875,
0.32016313076019287,
-1.0299839973449707,
0.6854180693626404,
-0.661585807800293,
0.6966317296028137,
0.7292436361312866,
0.43942365050315857,
-0.2721080780029297,
-0.2904450595378876,
-0.768370509147644,
-0.1744469851255417,
-0.18913984298706055,
0.004440854303538799,
0.08429548144340515,
0.31082379817962646,
0.5083303451538086,
0.20586293935775757,
-0.569897472858429,
-0.08616241812705994,
-0.2571251392364502,
-0.20665685832500458,
0.7711678743362427,
0.12260828167200089,
0.4409588873386383,
-0.017696788534522057,
-0.26781100034713745,
-0.1960648000240326,
-0.8782123923301697,
0.1113392561674118,
0.4963327944278717,
0.2891252338886261,
-0.3208484649658203,
0.7265827059745789,
-0.2662956714630127,
1.1147384643554688,
0.04126131907105446,
-0.20694774389266968,
0.008126989006996155,
-0.3451223075389862,
-0.06663887947797775,
-0.0454021617770195,
0.8123219013214111,
0.5334742069244385,
0.4673745036125183,
-0.10898829996585846,
0.2755720615386963,
-0.0990862101316452,
0.10797978192567825,
-0.5662617087364197,
-0.3867546319961548,
0.07168541103601456,
0.04444614425301552,
0.040256768465042114,
0.17655986547470093,
-0.5924978852272034,
-0.6585307717323303,
-0.3861308991909027,
0.25855526328086853,
-0.08039525896310806,
-0.5696153044700623,
0.46589311957359314,
0.13842655718326569,
0.4438389241695404,
0.42175984382629395,
-1.0798611640930176,
0.31840944290161133,
0.3541719913482666,
0.6789535880088806,
0.4772493839263916,
-0.23521511256694794,
-0.3271368741989136,
0.6353384256362915,
-0.6179345846176147,
0.9140836000442505,
-0.2827589809894562,
-0.21327179670333862,
-0.032382722944021225,
-0.10820318013429642,
-0.08919867128133774,
-0.26208925247192383,
0.2230921983718872,
-0.2552003264427185,
0.46967369318008423,
-0.08496343344449997,
-0.4546099007129669,
-0.13287734985351562,
0.3935132920742035,
-0.7569514513015747,
0.9193621277809143,
-0.015368344262242317,
-0.7446326613426208,
0.17679521441459656,
-0.46762487292289734,
-0.34282544255256653,
-0.14215485751628876,
-0.2273925393819809,
-0.21350353956222534,
0.2742641270160675,
0.43931663036346436,
0.5967851877212524,
-0.06270422041416168,
-0.14731091260910034,
-0.616507887840271,
-0.07523955404758453,
-0.019886182621121407,
0.2239411622285843,
0.5576459169387817,
-0.00047664783778600395,
0.004093194846063852,
0.08639489859342575,
-0.6237781643867493,
-0.19225497543811798,
0.35387521982192993,
0.1706639975309372,
-0.5923250913619995,
0.20456460118293762,
-0.40746206045150757,
0.3664972484111786,
0.27450451254844666,
-0.6848064661026001,
0.23307417333126068,
-0.660455584526062,
-0.01452120766043663,
0.3201814889907837,
-0.15987439453601837,
0.7612624764442444,
-0.05089874938130379,
0.49905896186828613,
-0.26537325978279114,
0.09622179716825485,
-0.519401490688324,
-0.17801977694034576,
-0.27694785594940186,
-0.3304091691970825,
-0.06260138005018234,
0.378622829914093,
-0.6008939146995544,
0.27823972702026367,
-0.3730401396751404,
-0.5512112975120544,
-0.3271639049053192,
-0.005451378412544727,
0.5707417130470276,
0.5117759704589844,
0.13142970204353333,
-0.12261421233415604,
-0.43704652786254883,
-0.881058931350708,
-0.33085596561431885,
-0.30896493792533875,
-0.3535468578338623,
0.007615962531417608,
0.05891510471701622,
0.1773279458284378,
1.2158831357955933,
-0.6709786653518677,
-0.28390249609947205,
0.09546557813882828,
-0.029191315174102783,
0.03518303856253624,
0.5072755217552185,
0.9864593744277954,
-0.7854712009429932,
-0.3570120930671692,
0.09640428423881531,
-0.8335475325584412,
0.08108055591583252,
-0.0972457304596901,
-0.2588329315185547,
0.29849907755851746,
0.5906316637992859,
-0.6234709024429321,
0.5184126496315002,
0.556683361530304,
-0.2257506102323532,
0.4019847512245178,
-0.09533677995204926,
0.2132648527622223,
-1.0266705751419067,
0.39726781845092773,
0.4601874351501465,
-0.5604769587516785,
-0.7594540119171143,
0.08975191414356232,
-0.03511170670390129,
-0.5222017168998718,
-0.6735838055610657,
1.0243147611618042,
-0.8003755807876587,
-0.044497568160295486,
-0.0812903344631195,
0.2354358583688736,
0.14184832572937012,
0.4198538661003113,
0.4765769839286804,
0.36139315366744995,
0.38158896565437317,
-0.5791918635368347,
0.11466573923826218,
0.3121183514595032,
-0.07601463794708252,
1.0875530242919922,
-0.762258768081665,
0.5488098859786987,
-0.30299580097198486,
0.2567695081233978,
-1.0799320936203003,
-0.679043173789978,
0.47627854347229004,
-0.5243610739707947,
0.41102489829063416,
-0.2970747649669647,
-0.523992657661438,
-0.5330765843391418,
-0.42821204662323,
0.716980516910553,
-0.12760889530181885,
-0.3822720944881439,
0.652682363986969,
0.5230597257614136,
0.11428506672382355,
-0.505129337310791,
-0.4283454418182373,
0.13482670485973358,
0.0240650437772274,
-0.5439264178276062,
0.41687601804733276,
-0.09170196950435638,
-0.12514451146125793,
-0.20817066729068756,
-0.1228180006146431,
-0.3526388704776764,
-0.17104284465312958,
0.13735611736774445,
0.20197804272174835,
-0.04142986610531807,
-0.13100704550743103,
-0.4262527525424957,
-0.30556392669677734,
-0.19741074740886688,
0.1839912086725235,
0.4772346019744873,
0.2588319182395935,
-0.5739361047744751,
-1.0835766792297363,
0.3615086078643799,
0.6132311820983887,
-0.13372796773910522,
0.41277000308036804,
0.12275930494070053,
-0.7987263202667236,
0.4420115649700165,
-0.7367045283317566,
-0.018481004983186722,
-0.47011131048202515,
0.3592465817928314,
-0.5408291220664978,
-0.5756961703300476,
0.24567733705043793,
0.12509068846702576,
0.01120149064809084,
0.15931600332260132,
0.15846820175647736,
-0.21773216128349304,
1.0657902956008911,
0.8920050859451294,
0.013291900977492332,
0.5698949098587036,
0.11113669723272324,
0.08237398415803909,
-0.7723395228385925,
-0.26388517022132874,
-0.7000645399093628,
-0.2478206753730774,
-0.07081668823957443,
-0.5685309767723083,
0.07718867063522339,
0.27593153715133667,
-0.48445507884025574,
0.7393989562988281,
-0.45248866081237793,
0.6216243505477905,
0.4098857045173645,
0.26716458797454834,
0.012231049127876759,
-0.1410464495420456,
0.008615654893219471,
-0.49701443314552307,
-0.24366030097007751,
-0.3438471555709839,
0.762415885925293,
0.1770855039358139,
0.6589350700378418,
0.16785018146038055,
0.7509915232658386,
-0.31789249181747437,
0.36566251516342163,
-0.8674567341804504,
0.42553845047950745,
0.09141327440738678,
-0.958774209022522,
-0.2190796285867691,
-0.37779927253723145,
-0.9546714425086975,
0.1677258461713791,
-0.1283891648054123,
-1.0941511392593384,
0.21618406474590302,
0.4744451940059662,
-0.6061808466911316,
0.23386207222938538,
-0.7974516749382019,
1.0899937152862549,
-0.2537274956703186,
-0.22312778234481812,
0.04778052493929863,
-0.9441107511520386,
0.464323490858078,
-0.02711530402302742,
0.24070794880390167,
-0.49724406003952026,
-0.06583014875650406,
0.5362879633903503,
-0.44401249289512634,
1.0968801975250244,
-0.41040661931037903,
-0.2905685305595398,
0.08076520264148712,
0.3093242049217224,
0.2137756198644638,
-0.4810774326324463,
-0.21953663229942322,
0.17608550190925598,
0.32988935708999634,
-0.5426285266876221,
-0.7304340600967407,
0.36712443828582764,
-0.6551975607872009,
-0.4140452742576599,
-0.38226181268692017,
-0.5725263953208923,
-0.49635350704193115,
0.27185529470443726,
0.1552775353193283,
0.3653424382209778,
-0.4158807098865509,
0.0187490563839674,
0.20700041949748993,
-0.3482288420200348,
0.48274195194244385,
0.44127753376960754,
-0.292000949382782,
-0.6216376423835754,
0.6095236539840698,
-0.04426957294344902,
0.42510759830474854,
0.7020804286003113,
0.24064669013023376,
-0.6261869072914124,
-0.19371040165424347,
-0.23649123311042786,
0.6314024925231934,
-0.48255982995033264,
-0.1790846586227417,
-0.3817873001098633,
0.1523081213235855,
-0.6753214597702026,
-0.5239928960800171,
-0.5537732839584351,
-0.3423107862472534,
-0.07973357290029526,
0.1104290708899498,
0.1554819792509079,
0.5921056270599365,
-0.23594002425670624,
0.5578190684318542,
-0.8885470032691956,
0.6412599086761475,
0.3553957939147949,
0.3252945840358734,
-0.3533066511154175,
-0.23172211647033691,
-0.0600888654589653,
0.4033665657043457,
-0.2932763397693634,
-0.7452317476272583,
0.12744317948818207,
0.3652746379375458,
0.7659411430358887,
0.4759455621242523,
0.3865688145160675,
1.122875452041626,
-0.6276044249534607,
0.727198600769043,
0.690713107585907,
-0.749750018119812,
0.7958773374557495,
-0.5408816337585449,
0.47172820568084717,
0.5677297115325928,
0.5299029350280762,
-0.6469740271568298,
0.13612040877342224,
-0.5456209778785706,
-0.6915838718414307,
0.745945930480957,
0.06705544143915176,
0.4732167422771454,
-0.12722551822662354,
0.7071710824966431,
-0.4766979217529297,
0.06369151920080185,
-0.8225017786026001,
-0.10877446830272675,
-0.05912004038691521,
-0.32737618684768677,
-0.1217152327299118,
-0.33059996366500854,
-0.2177860587835312,
-0.4260953366756439,
0.34598639607429504,
-0.18625026941299438,
0.15995946526527405,
0.26659467816352844,
-0.16870617866516113,
-0.29935187101364136,
-0.49446120858192444,
0.9642629623413086,
0.5959963202476501,
-0.15107733011245728,
0.22092367708683014,
-0.07023730129003525,
-0.21102525293827057,
0.18807435035705566,
0.03819364309310913,
0.0147035401314497,
0.11501409858465195,
0.3100884258747101,
0.4228510558605194,
0.58162522315979,
-0.4380478262901306,
0.8796851634979248,
0.08232548087835312,
-0.02810271829366684,
-0.2630262076854706,
-0.2643527090549469,
0.08097685128450394,
0.06282945722341537,
0.21098065376281738,
0.1451784074306488,
-0.21239648759365082,
-0.28664475679397583,
0.25245344638824463,
0.427183598279953,
-0.49685147404670715,
-0.7981880307197571,
0.802720308303833,
0.3210412263870239,
-0.4792211651802063,
0.14399133622646332,
0.06300390511751175,
-0.2753666937351227,
0.27780881524086,
0.4603700637817383,
0.7761796116828918,
-0.820850133895874,
0.23887783288955688,
0.7908567786216736,
0.07703523337841034,
-0.3235188126564026,
-0.11454169452190399,
-0.14357978105545044,
-1.0168776512145996,
-0.6375771164894104,
-0.46743208169937134,
-0.4851230978965759,
-0.034557729959487915,
-0.456607848405838,
0.6250445246696472,
-0.38032740354537964,
0.0320054292678833,
0.12393956631422043,
-0.0006013662205077708,
-0.6639123558998108,
0.13357950747013092,
0.5062037110328674,
0.24740348756313324,
-0.5804168581962585,
0.7003727555274963,
0.7806532382965088,
-0.5355463027954102,
-0.6031742095947266,
0.07657414674758911,
0.37203654646873474,
-0.7216868996620178,
0.4880211055278778,
0.47378915548324585,
-0.5174277424812317,
0.14594897627830505,
-0.6043246388435364,
-0.7778055667877197,
0.7168752551078796,
1.1447752714157104,
-0.4537791311740875,
-0.29240700602531433,
0.233737513422966,
0.3166339695453644,
0.10981990396976471,
-0.08402939140796661,
0.16998016834259033,
0.2177637219429016,
0.5217053294181824,
-1.0231387615203857,
-0.1271161437034607,
-0.05350590869784355,
0.14606058597564697,
0.47849732637405396,
-0.2754705846309662,
0.43004342913627625,
-0.3152371048927307,
-0.48495879769325256,
0.2594045102596283,
0.5058293342590332,
0.19382244348526,
0.031010838225483894,
0.5147508382797241,
0.8160381317138672,
0.5683745741844177,
0.29522842168807983,
1.317121982574463,
0.0014409037539735436,
0.4357241094112396,
1.3473937511444092,
-0.5456479787826538,
0.9099613428115845,
0.22918857634067535,
-0.3792630434036255,
0.23674757778644562,
0.6822677254676819,
0.4239563047885895,
0.6103489995002747,
0.09329371154308319,
-0.541588544845581,
-0.48889219760894775,
-0.13141308724880219,
-0.20081104338169098,
0.5645357966423035,
0.258841335773468,
0.09955930709838867,
-0.5631360411643982,
-0.1593279093503952,
0.3596625030040741,
0.49378591775894165,
-0.10717970877885818,
0.712899923324585,
-0.048789042979478836,
-0.3528016209602356,
0.5528314709663391,
-0.40626853704452515,
0.5110754370689392,
-0.5476821064949036,
0.084229975938797,
0.07386962324380875,
0.19645677506923676,
-0.106632299721241,
-0.6777626276016235,
0.6242758631706238,
-0.3629552721977234,
-0.0791390910744667,
-0.2128704935312271,
0.765529215335846,
-0.47972458600997925,
-0.6577702164649963,
0.17558151483535767,
0.2576151490211487,
0.3351609408855438,
-0.5434837937355042,
-0.4397484362125397,
-0.23152990639209747,
-0.3936893939971924,
-0.06902813911437988,
0.2297084480524063,
0.5730274319648743,
0.057407692074775696,
0.3414897918701172,
0.747685968875885,
-0.15023961663246155,
-0.15109968185424805,
-0.03663765266537666,
0.4955722987651825,
-0.638728141784668,
-0.13616405427455902,
-0.805881679058075,
0.6089692711830139,
-0.19907253980636597,
-0.33655327558517456,
0.2527082860469818,
0.3240530788898468,
0.9493818283081055,
-0.05074801295995712,
0.2412886619567871,
-0.004748275503516197,
0.5615328550338745,
-0.36587750911712646,
0.5543936491012573,
-0.6140046715736389,
-0.372414767742157,
-0.6133119463920593,
-0.9344174861907959,
-1.1246685981750488,
0.9570504426956177,
-0.5073277950286865,
-0.11293108016252518,
0.3841281533241272,
0.8157201409339905,
-0.05020284280180931,
-0.6955746412277222,
0.8058971762657166,
-0.3413558602333069,
0.36642447113990784,
0.37405136227607727,
0.7349297404289246,
-0.40199464559555054,
0.2656228840351105,
-0.5917708873748779,
-0.136941060423851,
-0.015460191294550896,
-1.243550181388855,
-0.7797383069992065,
-0.6851851344108582,
-0.5386055111885071,
-0.005542779807001352,
-0.2911771833896637,
0.9184665083885193,
1.1346144676208496,
-0.53404700756073,
-0.21050907671451569,
0.2614860236644745,
-0.25843364000320435,
-0.027370955795049667,
-0.1754528284072876,
0.16041964292526245,
-0.12499929219484329,
-0.9685576558113098,
0.2886437475681305,
0.4066518247127533,
0.3829604387283325,
-0.2332252711057663,
-0.18522827327251434,
-0.5159767866134644,
-0.09783859550952911,
0.829372763633728,
0.877817690372467,
-0.7616721987724304,
-0.684198796749115,
0.055589739233255386,
-0.09639731794595718,
0.178511381149292,
0.8432508707046509,
-0.658901035785675,
0.7396813035011292,
0.22761040925979614,
0.5642228722572327,
0.6055464148521423,
0.22369560599327087,
0.8407672047615051,
-1.2362604141235352,
0.8828127980232239,
0.2865307331085205,
0.3990921080112457,
0.7276914119720459,
-0.2918637692928314,
0.5524680018424988,
0.29630738496780396,
-0.23345495760440826,
-0.7890939712524414,
0.5311497449874878,
-1.1433067321777344,
-0.10527830570936203,
0.9011123776435852,
-0.22284981608390808,
-0.33365440368652344,
-0.17894268035888672,
-0.34185901284217834,
0.14332616329193115,
0.17064885795116425,
0.7142687439918518,
0.5026368498802185,
-0.27717125415802,
-0.6351144909858704,
-0.4628114700317383,
0.39392581582069397,
0.18698671460151672,
-0.7727479338645935,
0.04848627746105194,
0.8386620879173279,
0.12190519273281097,
0.39772820472717285,
0.9980811476707458,
-0.2340448945760727,
0.08759459108114243,
-0.3661680519580841,
0.7014682292938232,
0.054264988750219345,
-0.34281137585639954,
0.12415734678506851,
-0.1368272602558136,
0.1017623096704483,
-0.5694923400878906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03688v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03688v1
|
Large Language Models Reveal Information Operation Goals, Tactics, and Narrative Frames
| 2024-05-06T17:59:07 | 2024-05-06T17:59:07 |
Keith Burghardt, Kai Chen, Kristina Lerman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Adversarial information operations can destabilize societies by undermining
fair elections, manipulating public opinions on policies, and promoting scams.
Despite their widespread occurrence and potential impacts, our understanding of
influence campaigns is limited by manual analysis of messages and subjective
interpretation of their observable behavior. In this paper, we explore whether
these limitations can be mitigated with large language models (LLMs), using
GPT-3.5 as a case-study for coordinated campaign annotation. We first use
GPT-3.5 to scrutinize 126 identified information operations spanning over a
decade. We utilize a number of metrics to quantify the close (if imperfect)
agreement between LLM and ground truth descriptions. We next extract
coordinated campaigns from two large multilingual datasets from X (formerly
Twitter) that respectively discuss the 2022 French election and 2023 Balikaran
Philippine-U.S. military exercise in 2023. For each coordinated campaign, we
use GPT-3.5 to analyze posts related to a specific concern and extract goals,
tactics, and narrative frames, both before and after critical events (such as
the date of an election). While the GPT-3.5 sometimes disagrees with subjective
interpretation, its ability to summarize and interpret demonstrates LLMs'
potential to extract higher-order indicators from text to provide a more
complete picture of the information campaigns compared to previous methods.
|
[
-0.5074688792228699,
-0.9446344971656799,
0.8343717455863953,
0.3000049591064453,
-0.4323945939540863,
-0.1198965534567833,
-0.640123188495636,
-0.38405677676200867,
0.14611564576625824,
0.8302406668663025,
-0.4618019759654999,
-0.5124789476394653,
-0.9806184768676758,
-0.08632132411003113,
-0.3625476360321045,
1.4429761171340942,
-0.23956310749053955,
-0.040441177785396576,
0.3881078064441681,
-0.07315342128276825,
-0.26057329773902893,
-0.8557466864585876,
-0.6888904571533203,
-0.4318525195121765,
0.647003710269928,
0.022624434903264046,
0.8833171129226685,
0.6786472201347351,
0.6898459196090698,
0.23218218982219696,
0.06024935469031334,
0.11180371791124344,
-0.7869476079940796,
-0.1194080263376236,
-0.24119295179843903,
-0.5211013555526733,
-0.14035287499427795,
0.29014548659324646,
0.7346123456954956,
0.398200660943985,
-0.16919808089733124,
-0.1841341257095337,
0.0868394672870636,
0.5017597079277039,
-0.4926222860813141,
0.5382765531539917,
-0.6141067743301392,
-0.3149355351924896,
-0.29871460795402527,
-0.25334155559539795,
-0.2781565189361572,
-0.2850762605667114,
0.2936529815196991,
-0.6141030192375183,
0.11164988577365875,
-0.16391579806804657,
0.808499276638031,
0.1287136822938919,
-0.4178265929222107,
-0.6675141453742981,
-0.8031565546989441,
0.6621587872505188,
-0.6343812942504883,
-0.08028314262628555,
0.41137492656707764,
0.06259147822856903,
-0.3752860426902771,
-0.5699987411499023,
-0.5570607781410217,
-0.030301537364721298,
-0.12150518596172333,
0.14870406687259674,
-0.36408719420433044,
0.2895203232765198,
0.22071249783039093,
-0.00593141745775938,
-0.20963042974472046,
0.03544967994093895,
-0.35662713646888733,
0.0025618260260671377,
0.5738547444343567,
-0.02016332559287548,
0.3052341341972351,
-0.34017258882522583,
-0.5752639174461365,
-0.10426060110330582,
-0.9204226732254028,
-0.2341839224100113,
0.48421531915664673,
0.29626643657684326,
-0.4037768542766571,
0.5744888186454773,
-0.20134209096431732,
0.48908042907714844,
-0.10876933485269547,
0.22399085760116577,
-0.17982956767082214,
-0.4838087856769562,
-0.36652061343193054,
-0.0354069359600544,
1.0986777544021606,
0.359096497297287,
0.31506621837615967,
-0.12993226945400238,
-0.14685174822807312,
0.1490737348794937,
0.17184370756149292,
-0.8119060397148132,
-0.21264362335205078,
-0.1575319468975067,
-0.3507169187068939,
-0.30887943506240845,
0.33002158999443054,
-0.6584241390228271,
-0.6859855651855469,
-0.4652693569660187,
0.42165935039520264,
-0.17495624721050262,
-0.22502057254314423,
0.06111530959606171,
-0.025177588686347008,
-0.010604794137179852,
0.4452832043170929,
-0.5604404211044312,
0.032127801328897476,
0.9161166548728943,
0.8438349366188049,
-0.11162173002958298,
-0.1159713864326477,
-0.4709552526473999,
0.07262813299894333,
-0.4848385155200958,
0.31382685899734497,
-0.6392822265625,
-0.23895958065986633,
0.0351710319519043,
0.1087518259882927,
-0.1684664785861969,
-0.12119632959365845,
0.535357654094696,
-0.8417271971702576,
0.32005101442337036,
-0.35771164298057556,
-0.5399010181427002,
-0.3443185091018677,
0.3637726604938507,
-0.8569156527519226,
0.5966199040412903,
-0.22205662727355957,
-0.6702882647514343,
0.16364890336990356,
-0.5885913968086243,
-0.25435543060302734,
-0.36079004406929016,
-0.3161851763725281,
-0.16612057387828827,
0.13900542259216309,
0.3324491083621979,
0.6945620179176331,
-0.4853087365627289,
0.6117388606071472,
-0.2488354593515396,
-0.36336809396743774,
0.13548415899276733,
-0.44847747683525085,
0.6821522116661072,
-0.1617143750190735,
-0.7625297904014587,
0.08786836266517639,
-0.4785153865814209,
-0.5678780674934387,
0.08120689541101456,
-0.43628767132759094,
-0.3033049702644348,
0.16752208769321442,
-0.2434563934803009,
0.057852111756801605,
0.3233851194381714,
-0.3029608726501465,
0.5276989340782166,
-0.23789116740226746,
0.29422080516815186,
0.8609300255775452,
0.27381864190101624,
0.394094318151474,
-0.05643053352832794,
0.46152758598327637,
-0.18299564719200134,
0.1022273600101471,
-0.2015126496553421,
-0.6185094714164734,
-0.6554170250892639,
-0.05708852410316467,
-0.04395357146859169,
0.6521275639533997,
-0.991546630859375,
0.017583219334483147,
-0.5156612992286682,
-0.41580328345298767,
0.03249166160821915,
0.04589471593499184,
0.313586950302124,
0.1676807701587677,
0.06434237211942673,
0.05311980098485947,
-0.5361629128456116,
-0.7448573708534241,
-0.2799292504787445,
-0.44408756494522095,
0.19678537547588348,
0.029607834294438362,
0.46760475635528564,
0.017575252801179886,
0.6852471828460693,
-0.2684144079685211,
-0.20651978254318237,
-0.173982173204422,
0.4935589134693146,
0.3161359131336212,
0.0023092569317668676,
0.3938769996166229,
-1.110770583152771,
-0.1380728930234909,
0.1662697196006775,
-0.6369879245758057,
-0.06324470788240433,
-0.30698758363723755,
0.06887713819742203,
0.17474019527435303,
0.4408496618270874,
-0.6629428267478943,
0.2495918720960617,
0.8225353956222534,
-0.20101028680801392,
0.42916339635849,
-0.07018080353736877,
0.6286727786064148,
-0.8512862920761108,
-0.15806865692138672,
-0.009533355943858624,
-0.011684552766382694,
-0.7142879366874695,
-0.07402593642473221,
0.044136688113212585,
0.13167911767959595,
-0.19688749313354492,
0.4595194160938263,
-0.35670748353004456,
0.13306854665279388,
-0.2701406478881836,
0.5155107975006104,
-0.03201323002576828,
0.24127072095870972,
0.011129186488687992,
0.5966882705688477,
0.3733200430870056,
-0.37502142786979675,
0.45598453283309937,
0.031558796763420105,
-0.515973687171936,
0.5123357772827148,
-0.512894868850708,
0.2527194321155548,
-0.26274392008781433,
0.42527875304222107,
-0.9751192927360535,
-0.4719073474407196,
0.33170050382614136,
-0.38163650035858154,
0.283234179019928,
-0.30307430028915405,
-0.5494723916053772,
-0.021897854283452034,
-0.19890186190605164,
-0.10587631911039352,
0.07325919717550278,
-0.5748419165611267,
0.4312470853328705,
0.4117552936077118,
-0.09231255203485489,
-0.6628351807594299,
-0.6747311353683472,
0.40998777747154236,
-0.4486880898475647,
-0.47150692343711853,
-0.07736695557832718,
0.4096722900867462,
-0.4305957853794098,
-0.018273137509822845,
0.2949296832084656,
-0.02765306644141674,
-0.1364755630493164,
0.31532031297683716,
0.3500433564186096,
-0.1423078030347824,
0.2613116502761841,
-0.4886764883995056,
0.11327556520700455,
0.11393047124147415,
-0.23983168601989746,
0.30286452174186707,
0.07091477513313293,
-0.47351181507110596,
-0.0910799577832222,
0.27050691843032837,
0.5826099514961243,
-0.14480820298194885,
0.8700948357582092,
0.8227109909057617,
-0.2661585211753845,
0.2276792973279953,
-0.7790274620056152,
-0.10818953067064285,
-0.3670899569988251,
0.5462246537208557,
-0.07611233741044998,
-0.9244727492332458,
0.45915472507476807,
0.05487024784088135,
0.1190090924501419,
0.4082696735858917,
0.5812047123908997,
0.23548613488674164,
1.073798418045044,
0.37032410502433777,
-0.45081648230552673,
0.6850194931030273,
-0.14177650213241577,
0.11663378775119781,
-0.6601853370666504,
-0.1057688444852829,
-0.35235390067100525,
-0.04209301993250847,
-0.669605553150177,
-0.5642475485801697,
0.45507270097732544,
0.24033355712890625,
-0.18737287819385529,
0.07704418897628784,
-0.2904067039489746,
0.21616631746292114,
0.40381962060928345,
0.09346656501293182,
0.064817875623703,
0.12336819618940353,
0.5107064247131348,
-0.07915997505187988,
-0.5534290671348572,
-0.6057520508766174,
1.1965464353561401,
0.1679162085056305,
0.7226796746253967,
0.13416928052902222,
0.5371180176734924,
0.2394006848335266,
0.7045049071311951,
-0.498287171125412,
0.38379520177841187,
-0.2305525541305542,
-0.5941474437713623,
-0.18103091418743134,
-0.5512974858283997,
-0.8984548449516296,
0.19643662869930267,
-0.13613754510879517,
-0.8765981197357178,
0.03415922820568085,
-0.003511437214910984,
-0.13025414943695068,
0.4465612471103668,
-0.7871932983398438,
0.6924634575843811,
-0.26790714263916016,
-0.34671953320503235,
-0.23483330011367798,
-0.5515664219856262,
0.3956197500228882,
-0.1821368932723999,
0.5634264349937439,
-0.18027637898921967,
-0.301910936832428,
0.8027895092964172,
0.12402698397636414,
1.0434685945510864,
-0.23638145625591278,
-0.2133292853832245,
0.2000821977853775,
-0.09551741182804108,
1.193082571029663,
-0.13495540618896484,
-0.2506188750267029,
0.12028289586305618,
-0.21511594951152802,
-0.10344450920820236,
-0.7254431247711182,
0.8776000142097473,
-0.7428125143051147,
-0.8012319803237915,
-0.08420492708683014,
-0.43063950538635254,
0.08146476000547409,
0.2148911952972412,
0.2612127959728241,
0.5745400786399841,
-0.4852446913719177,
0.34852135181427,
0.43065422773361206,
0.08537060022354126,
0.38404983282089233,
0.3669922351837158,
0.0026172329671680927,
-0.4790101945400238,
0.8118227124214172,
0.155707448720932,
0.457218199968338,
0.36934569478034973,
0.3237609267234802,
-0.2958182096481323,
-0.6625006794929504,
-0.41323626041412354,
0.19550681114196777,
-0.888846218585968,
-0.034620173275470734,
-0.48779046535491943,
0.37868428230285645,
-0.05158178135752678,
-0.08689918369054794,
-0.23746313154697418,
-0.21124184131622314,
-0.3230445981025696,
0.030336134135723114,
0.22513307631015778,
1.3487796783447266,
-0.10206829756498337,
0.7089936137199402,
-0.370771586894989,
0.23562853038311005,
-0.11005745083093643,
0.11405463516712189,
-0.4715121388435364,
-0.2243502289056778,
-0.3430249094963074,
0.1780371069908142,
-0.19259241223335266,
-1.3233983516693115,
0.11804571002721786,
0.018147146329283714,
0.3113500773906708,
0.3779385983943939,
-0.0005774005549028516,
0.44024235010147095,
-0.18656356632709503,
1.0189496278762817,
0.05504800006747246,
-0.7978193163871765,
0.4553069472312927,
-0.7548671960830688,
0.16610337793827057,
0.2558625638484955,
0.28163647651672363,
-0.2789052128791809,
-0.5427674055099487,
-0.7577176690101624,
-0.735744059085846,
0.844730019569397,
0.27600598335266113,
0.10838693380355835,
-0.07856044173240662,
0.35331302881240845,
-0.3915870785713196,
0.3833562731742859,
-0.7296513915061951,
-0.15841734409332275,
0.17312189936637878,
-0.10851453989744186,
-0.2818651795387268,
-0.2920973598957062,
-0.37084683775901794,
0.3529159128665924,
0.8206554651260376,
-0.1634630560874939,
-0.15866903960704803,
0.27896133065223694,
0.2187391221523285,
-0.001556079601868987,
0.295427143573761,
0.5266063213348389,
0.7293360829353333,
0.09152526408433914,
0.2207450419664383,
-0.017582397907972336,
-0.41144639253616333,
-0.05187167972326279,
0.3926366865634918,
-0.13580922782421112,
-0.01934984140098095,
0.7731466889381409,
0.8903316259384155,
0.288747638463974,
-0.29275304079055786,
0.6855655908584595,
0.06092420965433121,
-0.004222097806632519,
-0.08123096823692322,
-0.2165052592754364,
0.1418568640947342,
0.4701415002346039,
0.4914776086807251,
-0.026871047914028168,
0.003405349561944604,
-0.6030678153038025,
0.16988889873027802,
0.7308102250099182,
-0.5429039001464844,
-0.321077436208725,
0.44881129264831543,
0.13417112827301025,
0.0008075935184024274,
0.12948621809482574,
-0.2613675594329834,
-0.804654598236084,
0.7203221321105957,
0.13663677871227264,
0.6777475476264954,
-0.2721383571624756,
0.25478121638298035,
0.19972246885299683,
0.8510336875915527,
-0.35380589962005615,
-0.1239292249083519,
0.1656796783208847,
-0.6344766020774841,
-0.6765928268432617,
-0.18276406824588776,
-0.22770169377326965,
0.43185925483703613,
-0.5083385705947876,
0.3032066226005554,
-0.3501490354537964,
-0.17466649413108826,
0.07926684617996216,
0.1261121779680252,
-0.7252877354621887,
0.19837602972984314,
0.11637110263109207,
0.2443322390317917,
-0.7186425924301147,
0.5462717413902283,
0.5530009865760803,
-0.06092806160449982,
-0.7358629703521729,
0.012563051655888557,
0.3261834979057312,
-0.8215234279632568,
0.605395495891571,
0.1193091943860054,
-0.09241625666618347,
-0.1986118108034134,
-0.5878252387046814,
-0.7995589971542358,
0.7607370615005493,
0.4695877432823181,
-0.6719913482666016,
-0.027979930862784386,
0.052234575152397156,
0.3378308415412903,
-0.46100154519081116,
0.13710102438926697,
0.8136646151542664,
0.7254465818405151,
-0.1215175911784172,
-0.8724914789199829,
0.16812251508235931,
0.17885278165340424,
-0.25713956356048584,
0.4519800841808319,
-0.6200593113899231,
0.8431979417800903,
-0.16720838844776154,
-0.41203436255455017,
-0.1636100560426712,
0.30951884388923645,
-0.1898365318775177,
0.04673127084970474,
0.4928381145000458,
0.1260889768600464,
0.5615929961204529,
-0.3957611918449402,
1.3235459327697754,
-0.25920385122299194,
0.48704081773757935,
1.0611013174057007,
0.10744266957044601,
0.43864843249320984,
0.5436373353004456,
-0.08631712198257446,
0.19790923595428467,
0.4319547712802887,
0.1858697086572647,
0.2380666434764862,
0.072923943400383,
-0.22759872674942017,
-0.11206864565610886,
-0.13373978435993195,
-0.15362124145030975,
0.4706910252571106,
0.6474722623825073,
-0.5475113391876221,
-0.3580947518348694,
-0.01795714534819126,
0.42790621519088745,
-0.010752696543931961,
-0.17735034227371216,
0.6862700581550598,
-0.07773950695991516,
-0.8639268279075623,
0.4281778633594513,
-0.160893514752388,
0.47793668508529663,
-0.7710257172584534,
-0.23369134962558746,
0.18182025849819183,
0.24093987047672272,
-0.09213011711835861,
-0.893513560295105,
0.13889287412166595,
-0.1375330090522766,
0.031080344691872597,
-0.03847410902380943,
0.5237049460411072,
-0.6296034455299377,
-0.43269991874694824,
0.4504762589931488,
0.2611905336380005,
-0.16813237965106964,
-0.44554412364959717,
-0.5741801857948303,
0.6764969229698181,
0.2100607305765152,
-0.7379920482635498,
-0.1136896163225174,
0.5856793522834778,
-0.07897722721099854,
0.3612777590751648,
0.5827350616455078,
0.5557008981704712,
-0.13194988667964935,
0.07621430605649948,
0.8106420636177063,
-0.29204249382019043,
-0.3573997914791107,
-1.1891388893127441,
0.09404990077018738,
-0.32773831486701965,
-0.03824023902416229,
0.8256800174713135,
0.3337651193141937,
0.6483114361763,
0.24393802881240845,
1.1900973320007324,
-0.0564330518245697,
0.31722643971443176,
-0.6214898824691772,
0.4427860379219055,
-0.33395710587501526,
0.4053099453449249,
-0.2701140344142914,
-0.6597456336021423,
-0.22412094473838806,
0.285818487405777,
-0.7316843867301941,
-0.0540948249399662,
0.34421825408935547,
0.7036350965499878,
0.0697186142206192,
0.22026100754737854,
0.024393761530518532,
0.3080879747867584,
0.658011257648468,
0.5421124696731567,
0.8294930458068848,
-0.23148837685585022,
0.828015148639679,
-0.1766330897808075,
-0.4495682120323181,
-0.13931462168693542,
-0.9033718109130859,
-1.08492910861969,
-0.6010318398475647,
-0.06467819213867188,
-0.2861877381801605,
0.25887560844421387,
0.5872653126716614,
0.626463770866394,
-0.39341434836387634,
-0.09386483579874039,
-0.04075435549020767,
0.23358112573623657,
0.33354705572128296,
-0.24993278086185455,
0.6190413236618042,
-0.14017845690250397,
-0.8197503685951233,
0.15302224457263947,
0.2981680631637573,
-0.020428406074643135,
-0.4756543040275574,
0.08419836312532425,
-0.14319247007369995,
0.12376193702220917,
0.48576128482818604,
0.0787796601653099,
-0.8462036848068237,
-0.5947209000587463,
-0.24435213208198547,
-0.008327808231115341,
-0.22469379007816315,
1.0649546384811401,
-0.36241990327835083,
0.6477701663970947,
0.2823980152606964,
0.5339028835296631,
0.547895610332489,
0.23044103384017944,
0.7360869646072388,
-0.76211017370224,
0.3013879656791687,
0.04437233880162239,
0.19587743282318115,
0.6479620337486267,
-0.43905314803123474,
0.6316356658935547,
0.1247471496462822,
-0.4944263994693756,
-0.4678061306476593,
0.14770066738128662,
-0.513613760471344,
-0.04076342284679413,
1.6698777675628662,
-0.17583522200584412,
-0.08168449252843857,
-0.12352405488491058,
-0.3612108528614044,
0.30045294761657715,
-0.33599627017974854,
0.6077244877815247,
1.2112361192703247,
-0.10019141435623169,
-0.03003591112792492,
-0.9309406876564026,
0.5896021127700806,
0.0856936126947403,
-0.75869220495224,
0.30264413356781006,
0.6079891324043274,
-0.07087382674217224,
0.3451146185398102,
0.7399145364761353,
0.0412345789372921,
-0.03028329648077488,
-0.24440211057662964,
-0.40743908286094666,
0.13785509765148163,
-0.1749172806739807,
-0.07782081514596939,
0.20002096891403198,
-0.27200502157211304,
-0.11937951296567917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03685v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03685v1
|
Language-Image Models with 3D Understanding
| 2024-05-06T17:57:27 | 2024-05-06T17:57:27 |
Jang Hyun Cho, Boris Ivanovic, Yulong Cao, Edward Schmerling, Yue Wang, Xinshuo Weng, Boyi Li, Yurong You, Philipp Krähenbühl, Yan Wang, Marco Pavone
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Multi-modal large language models (MLLMs) have shown incredible capabilities
in a variety of 2D vision and language tasks. We extend MLLMs' perceptual
capabilities to ground and reason about images in 3-dimensional space. To that
end, we first develop a large-scale pre-training dataset for 2D and 3D called
LV3D by combining multiple existing 2D and 3D recognition datasets under a
common task formulation: as multi-turn question-answering. Next, we introduce a
new MLLM named Cube-LLM and pre-train it on LV3D. We show that pure data
scaling makes a strong 3D perception capability without 3D specific
architectural design or training objective. Cube-LLM exhibits intriguing
properties similar to LLMs: (1) Cube-LLM can apply chain-of-thought prompting
to improve 3D understanding from 2D context information. (2) Cube-LLM can
follow complex and diverse instructions and adapt to versatile input and output
formats. (3) Cube-LLM can be visually prompted such as 2D box or a set of
candidate 3D boxes from specialists. Our experiments on outdoor benchmarks
demonstrate that Cube-LLM significantly outperforms existing baselines by 21.3
points of AP-BEV on the Talk2Car dataset for 3D grounded reasoning and 17.7
points on the DriveLM dataset for complex reasoning about driving scenarios,
respectively. Cube-LLM also shows competitive results in general MLLM
benchmarks such as refCOCO for 2D grounding with (87.0) average score, as well
as visual question answering benchmarks such as VQAv2, GQA, SQA, POPE, etc. for
complex reasoning. Our project is available at
https://janghyuncho.github.io/Cube-LLM.
|
[
-0.569139838218689,
-0.8575505018234253,
0.9172106385231018,
0.38376855850219727,
-0.16619513928890228,
-0.1829092651605606,
-0.10204046964645386,
-0.49574339389801025,
-0.5227720141410828,
0.4995202124118805,
-0.2675184905529022,
-0.5222314596176147,
-0.3729027807712555,
-0.04651937261223793,
-0.23162072896957397,
0.37016981840133667,
-0.1612323522567749,
0.30027201771736145,
-0.6761561036109924,
-0.19805149734020233,
-0.3380970358848572,
-0.5781039595603943,
-0.5418396592140198,
-0.17810176312923431,
0.5030504465103149,
0.38064271211624146,
0.909822940826416,
0.6392439603805542,
0.3901241421699524,
0.3145523965358734,
-0.03989671543240547,
0.20275478065013885,
-0.5130938291549683,
-0.25069373846054077,
-0.028668897226452827,
-0.38444390892982483,
-0.3686498999595642,
0.0446239672601223,
0.6122029423713684,
0.8908936381340027,
0.10457770526409149,
-0.19034233689308167,
-0.1559215486049652,
0.8873819708824158,
-0.5425878167152405,
0.14149706065654755,
-0.49702316522598267,
0.09144828468561172,
0.12266059219837189,
-0.07664263993501663,
-0.19528456032276154,
-0.1332552582025528,
-0.03786575794219971,
-0.7258352041244507,
0.1517530381679535,
0.2890661358833313,
0.6758330464363098,
0.2620124816894531,
-0.5938970446586609,
-0.10707030445337296,
-0.6409204602241516,
0.6691998839378357,
-0.4400329887866974,
0.7133395075798035,
0.38744795322418213,
0.5975190997123718,
0.011815751902759075,
-0.44921550154685974,
-0.7414567470550537,
-0.1698940247297287,
-0.07934371381998062,
0.23160172998905182,
0.07845580577850342,
-0.050806671380996704,
0.36833781003952026,
0.6499900221824646,
-0.5803749561309814,
0.1738361418247223,
-0.403211772441864,
-0.007546715904027224,
0.5075522065162659,
0.22196535766124725,
0.08885783702135086,
0.017780084162950516,
-0.590610146522522,
-0.1888301968574524,
-0.8678696155548096,
0.32710495591163635,
-0.02825050614774227,
-0.07667354494333267,
-0.30726903676986694,
0.6661997437477112,
-0.10375093668699265,
1.085634708404541,
-0.19321145117282867,
-0.10525206476449966,
0.34042975306510925,
-0.2249235212802887,
-0.532512366771698,
-0.31546029448509216,
0.6868534684181213,
0.5078231692314148,
0.1038484051823616,
0.028818635269999504,
-0.32228994369506836,
-0.2621985077857971,
0.17981655895709991,
-0.7106797695159912,
-0.160941943526268,
0.3225049674510956,
-0.5991290211677551,
-0.09971688687801361,
0.00016233364294748753,
-0.4250220060348511,
-0.8251467943191528,
-0.6944934725761414,
0.4408014118671417,
-0.4991178810596466,
-0.46923828125,
0.5946126580238342,
0.06960693001747131,
0.5077437162399292,
0.7017545700073242,
-0.7083650231361389,
0.18953080475330353,
0.6738458871841431,
0.691738486289978,
-0.07163575291633606,
-0.44848760962486267,
-0.319537878036499,
0.13234809041023254,
-0.5147901773452759,
0.9413252472877502,
-0.327190637588501,
-0.17394691705703735,
-0.05176706239581108,
-0.15851500630378723,
0.1449548751115799,
-0.6679494380950928,
0.10130278021097183,
-0.3764815926551819,
0.31834834814071655,
-0.008829949423670769,
-0.30209365487098694,
-0.4148064851760864,
0.6511258482933044,
-0.707290530204773,
0.7649778723716736,
0.1286967694759369,
-0.5083639025688171,
0.27023082971572876,
-0.42246878147125244,
-0.45956045389175415,
-0.0064352890476584435,
-0.57928067445755,
-0.26089078187942505,
0.20664247870445251,
0.5329469442367554,
0.6584776639938354,
-0.44756659865379333,
0.07736950367689133,
-0.4265120327472687,
-0.29900914430618286,
0.09254493564367294,
-0.3031509816646576,
0.8487241268157959,
0.08237793296575546,
-0.07627080380916595,
0.1831132173538208,
-0.8940582871437073,
-0.05756673961877823,
0.22798272967338562,
-0.44588103890419006,
-0.02744845673441887,
0.03748707100749016,
-0.03218403086066246,
0.31367504596710205,
0.18234498798847198,
-0.2421663999557495,
-0.006145728752017021,
-0.2267065942287445,
0.0788404643535614,
0.5197872519493103,
-0.3747258186340332,
0.431383341550827,
-0.27358266711235046,
0.3299247622489929,
0.30806007981300354,
0.19740250706672668,
-0.18412761390209198,
-0.42892491817474365,
-0.7782222628593445,
-0.4607103765010834,
-0.3992345929145813,
0.6405456066131592,
-0.8096634149551392,
0.25048622488975525,
-0.2477898746728897,
-0.4135761857032776,
-0.3087178170681,
0.14239348471164703,
0.23685240745544434,
0.5161963701248169,
0.5151050686836243,
0.3146612346172333,
-0.5542277097702026,
-1.1588993072509766,
-0.10932348668575287,
-0.11911916732788086,
-0.5083990097045898,
0.4778237044811249,
0.2612921893596649,
-0.12301100045442581,
0.7798392176628113,
-0.4964461028575897,
-0.40644219517707825,
-0.2902463972568512,
-0.13278652727603912,
0.48397454619407654,
0.3309555947780609,
0.5167560577392578,
-1.1122053861618042,
-0.29706236720085144,
0.12545441091060638,
-0.9972425103187561,
0.22864370048046112,
-0.24177837371826172,
-0.005428309086710215,
-0.1073933094739914,
0.847252368927002,
-0.6450551748275757,
0.33739522099494934,
0.46967580914497375,
-0.5069292783737183,
0.3403870463371277,
-0.24310962855815887,
0.10542012006044388,
-0.8512843251228333,
-0.24914829432964325,
-0.1409512460231781,
-0.2755330502986908,
-0.7510215640068054,
-0.023285923525691032,
0.0880952849984169,
0.03834923356771469,
-0.7212061285972595,
0.5395398736000061,
-0.6606608033180237,
-0.37443485856056213,
-0.15433649718761444,
0.37558087706565857,
0.24547512829303741,
0.5628013014793396,
0.4198523163795471,
0.44452664256095886,
0.9903380274772644,
-0.7163069844245911,
0.5118738412857056,
0.2459542602300644,
-0.8892827033996582,
0.6827861666679382,
-0.5231544971466064,
0.25348037481307983,
-0.34768396615982056,
0.13922622799873352,
-0.8555213212966919,
0.020175620913505554,
-0.005073332227766514,
-0.27513495087623596,
0.05331076309084892,
0.02554035745561123,
-0.5831573009490967,
-0.2713530659675598,
-0.04348926246166229,
0.5007013082504272,
0.2546522617340088,
-0.7510660290718079,
0.9629073143005371,
0.2951830327510834,
0.2804272770881653,
-0.23151466250419617,
-0.5282281637191772,
0.10359862446784973,
-0.19826461374759674,
-0.5693414807319641,
0.04915372654795647,
-0.11869579553604126,
-0.5205292105674744,
-0.06959694623947144,
-0.028666073456406593,
-0.0461776927113533,
0.11596903949975967,
0.40396615862846375,
0.29893362522125244,
-0.3552282452583313,
-0.028875326737761497,
-0.44678598642349243,
-0.025193607434630394,
0.23827007412910461,
-0.18744707107543945,
0.3851844072341919,
-0.6999809741973877,
-0.311553418636322,
-0.15810242295265198,
0.21540269255638123,
0.7716870307922363,
0.06473744660615921,
0.69027179479599,
0.7074213027954102,
-0.4681272804737091,
0.2992926239967346,
-0.5874871015548706,
0.100116066634655,
-0.4346162974834442,
0.5040402412414551,
-0.90385502576828,
-0.9001052975654602,
0.10936146974563599,
0.0156964473426342,
0.07898172736167908,
0.2622484266757965,
0.7569566369056702,
-0.5171270370483398,
1.3035320043563843,
0.4716464579105377,
0.1672990918159485,
0.09523947536945343,
-0.26460030674934387,
0.3448435962200165,
-1.0748988389968872,
-0.6034578084945679,
-0.16508299112319946,
-0.34503790736198425,
-0.18764829635620117,
-0.7094444632530212,
0.2950059771537781,
0.4741590917110443,
-0.41688862442970276,
-0.018179956823587418,
-0.1610528975725174,
0.5823706984519958,
0.24556541442871094,
0.020311806350946426,
0.20287105441093445,
-0.014897654764354229,
-0.14225398004055023,
0.2708648443222046,
-0.6627262830734253,
-0.3635888993740082,
0.7487779855728149,
0.4755805432796478,
0.6153403520584106,
0.14987528324127197,
-0.03914564475417137,
-0.08236681669950485,
0.2909157872200012,
-0.8045414090156555,
0.6785571575164795,
-0.03183244541287422,
-0.4771668314933777,
-0.3680345416069031,
-0.4195905029773712,
-0.7665868401527405,
0.7573745846748352,
-0.4513387084007263,
-0.3441142439842224,
0.129031240940094,
0.17500074207782745,
-0.2918858528137207,
0.5877219438552856,
-0.5327797532081604,
0.7324058413505554,
-0.5678253769874573,
-0.21514271199703217,
-0.2026863545179367,
-0.5040593147277832,
0.5579449534416199,
0.016758181154727936,
0.5819675326347351,
-0.3021436333656311,
-0.02143745683133602,
0.26358360052108765,
-0.13073886930942535,
0.5484248399734497,
-0.2862268090248108,
-0.2867552936077118,
0.007502052932977676,
0.20785318315029144,
0.15152928233146667,
0.39701807498931885,
0.17231622338294983,
0.563305675983429,
-0.11988832801580429,
-0.44947463274002075,
-0.8453552722930908,
0.5578908324241638,
-0.9211664199829102,
-0.8941715955734253,
-0.08953966200351715,
-0.8945421576499939,
-0.5292885303497314,
0.2983223795890808,
0.172704815864563,
0.4054534137248993,
-0.006550193298608065,
0.4759911596775055,
0.6028299927711487,
-0.3728291988372803,
0.05113154649734497,
0.44897860288619995,
-0.6917281150817871,
-0.4335372745990753,
0.6801368594169617,
-0.6086573004722595,
0.24192948639392853,
0.7251978516578674,
0.2915535569190979,
-0.46081775426864624,
-0.6924681067466736,
-0.3962151110172272,
0.10020408779382706,
-0.8445726633071899,
-0.1822780966758728,
-0.6653668284416199,
-0.311879962682724,
-0.2202676683664322,
-0.3456712067127228,
-0.30226755142211914,
-0.4528324007987976,
-0.21870842576026917,
-0.3412007689476013,
0.0882745087146759,
0.8233444094657898,
-0.1457897126674652,
0.04954929277300835,
-0.5302108526229858,
0.9249738454818726,
0.5615733861923218,
0.33800631761550903,
-0.17999593913555145,
-0.5006574392318726,
-0.2766897976398468,
0.25416550040245056,
0.14834052324295044,
-0.327986478805542,
0.07965116947889328,
-0.07125155627727509,
0.508925199508667,
0.5926191806793213,
-0.4307743310928345,
0.8282803893089294,
-0.6031249165534973,
0.6552687883377075,
0.47784385085105896,
-0.7378531098365784,
0.39581233263015747,
-0.23051679134368896,
0.6061927080154419,
0.2637951076030731,
0.2893419861793518,
-0.41124871373176575,
-0.3471009135246277,
-0.18825164437294006,
-0.5592899322509766,
0.6190667748451233,
0.23313294351100922,
-0.023875398561358452,
0.16641458868980408,
0.22763276100158691,
0.06136666610836983,
0.02756427600979805,
-0.7907440662384033,
-0.21063773334026337,
-0.7108207941055298,
0.010622082278132439,
-0.26413992047309875,
-0.3752761781215668,
-0.1468830108642578,
-0.5052286982536316,
0.217097207903862,
-0.10238489508628845,
0.18770895898342133,
0.14767137169837952,
-0.21138712763786316,
0.2647539973258972,
-0.05699886754155159,
0.7882452607154846,
0.7428337335586548,
-0.23710289597511292,
0.7239665985107422,
0.2558485269546509,
-0.3487796187400818,
0.14547885954380035,
-0.16613160073757172,
0.19111068546772003,
-0.4042416512966156,
0.6418161988258362,
1.006571650505066,
0.012091726996004581,
-0.6031558513641357,
0.48097217082977295,
-0.2659723162651062,
-0.712624192237854,
-0.3976941704750061,
-0.12107232213020325,
0.24598011374473572,
0.3419489860534668,
0.33285823464393616,
0.14146913588047028,
-0.045097772032022476,
-0.3645671010017395,
-0.07489453256130219,
0.3426329493522644,
-0.47578150033950806,
-0.25730758905410767,
0.5813647508621216,
-0.049306705594062805,
-0.10069918632507324,
0.7408509850502014,
0.06507623195648193,
-0.4264289140701294,
0.6067559123039246,
0.5900312066078186,
0.5117443203926086,
-0.03542601317167282,
-0.07410649955272675,
0.4891466498374939,
0.38628625869750977,
0.06605751067399979,
0.31345829367637634,
-0.08096128702163696,
-1.2517471313476562,
-0.2043965607881546,
-0.3784455955028534,
-0.19686943292617798,
0.6601620316505432,
-0.4723263382911682,
0.25714659690856934,
-0.7391846179962158,
0.28957754373550415,
-0.2624785602092743,
-0.30211135745048523,
-0.935638964176178,
0.5269238948822021,
0.5437963008880615,
0.8796708583831787,
-0.6118701100349426,
0.7344555854797363,
0.8316683769226074,
-0.0337069146335125,
-0.39660710096359253,
-0.3503184914588928,
0.03585250303149223,
-1.0485683679580688,
0.8219287395477295,
0.416852205991745,
-0.351773202419281,
-0.08092056214809418,
-0.586418867111206,
-0.9228744506835938,
1.0954234600067139,
0.13888801634311676,
-0.6013930439949036,
0.1842857152223587,
0.299482136964798,
0.30507421493530273,
-0.6759622693061829,
0.10571405291557312,
0.60688716173172,
0.5325696468353271,
0.26869258284568787,
-0.5282108187675476,
-0.019288010895252228,
-0.28651371598243713,
0.12053452432155609,
-0.08503898233175278,
-0.3786153197288513,
0.7802042365074158,
-0.39203715324401855,
-0.22974705696105957,
-0.14713868498802185,
0.7357233762741089,
0.5782403349876404,
0.11575763672590256,
1.0515598058700562,
0.6243789792060852,
0.5424231886863708,
0.035853106528520584,
1.0353779792785645,
0.016716863960027695,
-0.05500570312142372,
1.163030982017517,
-0.31393012404441833,
0.672023355960846,
0.5162575244903564,
-0.0808274894952774,
0.4374394416809082,
0.6011368036270142,
-0.0303513053804636,
0.5327548384666443,
0.22786042094230652,
-0.03855131193995476,
-0.6004990339279175,
0.20467296242713928,
-0.1819532960653305,
0.5096412301063538,
0.592592716217041,
0.1569056361913681,
-0.1445019543170929,
0.2741575241088867,
-0.21373222768306732,
0.061632998287677765,
-0.4287848174571991,
0.6291331052780151,
0.1973908394575119,
-0.3002157211303711,
0.7690003514289856,
-0.32577601075172424,
0.15280784666538239,
-0.2719229459762573,
-0.11535888910293579,
-0.3049651086330414,
0.19902358949184418,
-0.26981309056282043,
-1.0011783838272095,
0.24427875876426697,
-0.23295073211193085,
-0.15807820856571198,
-0.5673294067382812,
0.2871748208999634,
-0.38423657417297363,
-0.5802754759788513,
0.2249082773923874,
0.4424602687358856,
0.2890070974826813,
-0.2406851351261139,
-0.7131925225257874,
0.15963511168956757,
0.01278792042285204,
-0.248625710606575,
0.09833113849163055,
0.6336554288864136,
0.037932295352220535,
0.6976277232170105,
0.6986947655677795,
0.05611381679773331,
-0.09824901819229126,
0.33192533254623413,
0.7888737916946411,
-0.6791144609451294,
-0.14515230059623718,
-0.8080043792724609,
0.39920929074287415,
-0.118133544921875,
-0.0048383427783846855,
0.6694767475128174,
0.9410435557365417,
0.8184870481491089,
-0.09222520142793655,
0.6622676253318787,
0.1062578409910202,
0.34701651334762573,
-1.004494071006775,
0.38023805618286133,
-0.8914182782173157,
0.2592998445034027,
0.21777275204658508,
-1.0089348554611206,
-0.7458065152168274,
0.8979448676109314,
-0.3285105526447296,
-0.019502850249409676,
0.8871243000030518,
0.6548618674278259,
-0.10892708599567413,
-0.20661024749279022,
0.7631635069847107,
0.5191125273704529,
0.5318776965141296,
0.7466715574264526,
1.3303214311599731,
-0.20824751257896423,
0.5660040974617004,
-0.1730785220861435,
-0.2519185543060303,
-0.05112360045313835,
-0.7827141880989075,
-1.2517573833465576,
-0.6513799428939819,
-0.12599067389965057,
-0.18813131749629974,
-0.5494868755340576,
0.40268802642822266,
0.7672072649002075,
-0.6494065523147583,
-0.24566908180713654,
-0.24048824608325958,
0.2063983976840973,
-0.2048937976360321,
-0.16634617745876312,
0.376664400100708,
-0.1641705334186554,
-0.4691081643104553,
0.6452018022537231,
0.6414839625358582,
0.2789042592048645,
-0.327053040266037,
-0.1582518070936203,
-0.11079711467027664,
-0.1012410819530487,
0.9324220418930054,
0.022485075518488884,
-0.8742062449455261,
-0.2808927893638611,
-0.006369119975715876,
-0.1565890610218048,
0.33685237169265747,
0.9153041243553162,
-0.8627815246582031,
0.40907710790634155,
0.39592936635017395,
0.35287046432495117,
0.6985951662063599,
-0.07536841928958893,
0.6375473737716675,
-0.3515418469905853,
0.4446831941604614,
0.20963433384895325,
0.5751956701278687,
0.6310873031616211,
-0.28920939564704895,
0.47356143593788147,
-0.0631524845957756,
-0.27591490745544434,
-0.4452373683452606,
0.4600321352481842,
-0.809101402759552,
-0.5457226037979126,
1.249422311782837,
0.04859257861971855,
-0.2181820273399353,
-0.29476600885391235,
-0.33218851685523987,
-0.24184726178646088,
0.31213322281837463,
0.6869202256202698,
0.6175064444541931,
-0.22434452176094055,
-0.7038508653640747,
-0.495199978351593,
0.5649209022521973,
0.2345934957265854,
-1.0293892621994019,
0.06042829528450966,
0.7172850966453552,
-0.02276853658258915,
0.13348400592803955,
0.6337668895721436,
-0.1843491643667221,
0.2811623215675354,
-0.11944198608398438,
0.019473783671855927,
-0.3881387710571289,
-0.5112016797065735,
-0.324181467294693,
0.18662574887275696,
-0.028934579342603683,
-0.04539811611175537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03677v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03677v1
|
Towards A Human-in-the-Loop LLM Approach to Collaborative Discourse Analysis
| 2024-05-06T17:53:33 | 2024-05-06T17:53:33 |
Clayton Cohn, Caitlin Snyder, Justin Montenegro, Gautam Biswas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
LLMs have demonstrated proficiency in contextualizing their outputs using
human input, often matching or beating human-level performance on a variety of
tasks. However, LLMs have not yet been used to characterize synergistic
learning in students' collaborative discourse. In this exploratory work, we
take a first step towards adopting a human-in-the-loop prompt engineering
approach with GPT-4-Turbo to summarize and categorize students' synergistic
learning during collaborative discourse. Our preliminary findings suggest
GPT-4-Turbo may be able to characterize students' synergistic learning in a
manner comparable to humans and that our approach warrants further
investigation.
|
[
-0.5890675783157349,
-0.8131715059280396,
0.7016138434410095,
0.05669960007071495,
-0.19719251990318298,
1.0060651302337646,
-0.21945588290691376,
-0.19990049302577972,
0.46249938011169434,
0.08142758905887604,
-0.5555768013000488,
-0.348001629114151,
-0.12873686850070953,
0.5119408369064331,
-0.06291145086288452,
1.0385911464691162,
-0.13251058757305145,
0.15564660727977753,
-0.4266889691352844,
-0.09703849256038666,
-0.8736675381660461,
-0.780500590801239,
-0.4796833395957947,
-0.6493173241615295,
0.6355918049812317,
0.7555397152900696,
0.4275527000427246,
-0.09182503074407578,
0.2603464126586914,
0.39991840720176697,
-0.04999159649014473,
-0.19167794287204742,
-0.4037367105484009,
0.35818612575531006,
-0.49076375365257263,
-0.1827058047056198,
-0.3993215262889862,
0.5093562006950378,
0.7191333770751953,
0.9243154525756836,
-0.1379992812871933,
0.060756463557481766,
0.5207083821296692,
0.20904067158699036,
-0.2212151288986206,
0.13818606734275818,
-0.401329904794693,
-0.00739632872864604,
-0.23792262375354767,
-0.29199180006980896,
-0.28406375646591187,
-0.2983343303203583,
0.3027651906013489,
-0.856376588344574,
0.07472200691699982,
0.2223636507987976,
0.47351983189582825,
0.11145152151584625,
-0.3497973084449768,
-0.3771771788597107,
-0.49029308557510376,
0.7019791007041931,
-0.346822053194046,
0.0955568253993988,
0.0527324378490448,
0.3145788908004761,
-0.3638695180416107,
-0.9002940654754639,
-0.6354151368141174,
0.08070933818817139,
0.002763062249869108,
0.6815297603607178,
0.06559867411851883,
0.31604716181755066,
0.1359090805053711,
0.27472439408302307,
-0.6536054015159607,
0.39735403656959534,
-0.32661616802215576,
-0.44438859820365906,
0.5611461400985718,
0.4725073575973511,
0.3256370723247528,
-0.1949792355298996,
-0.6787398457527161,
0.15219642221927643,
-0.34266841411590576,
0.16278760135173798,
0.37854063510894775,
0.2816028296947479,
-0.16489103436470032,
0.3597503900527954,
0.21121497452259064,
0.36473795771598816,
0.06733176857233047,
-0.3181697726249695,
0.0065603917464613914,
-0.6871248483657837,
-0.2012157291173935,
0.03774431347846985,
0.9596129059791565,
0.09417451173067093,
-0.022840648889541626,
-0.25080937147140503,
0.05116967856884003,
0.13213886320590973,
0.23724357783794403,
-0.5138890743255615,
-0.24114033579826355,
-0.19682185351848602,
-0.2965739965438843,
-0.34827253222465515,
-0.03621102496981621,
-0.7965146899223328,
-0.13577014207839966,
-0.48773443698883057,
0.2771149277687073,
0.005357078742235899,
-0.1349906027317047,
-0.11944229155778885,
-0.23924006521701813,
0.3063967525959015,
0.15378142893314362,
-0.6423112750053406,
0.6651014685630798,
0.9231470823287964,
0.9027360081672668,
-0.4535350799560547,
-0.6243818998336792,
-0.2931292653083801,
0.15959204733371735,
0.010150530375540257,
0.8965181112289429,
-0.5342296957969666,
-0.8510544896125793,
-0.31275027990341187,
-0.13616015017032623,
-0.07303107529878616,
-0.4337851405143738,
0.564287543296814,
-0.46370118856430054,
0.6514127254486084,
-0.5075788497924805,
-0.7593253254890442,
-0.3069392442703247,
0.2510327696800232,
-0.40356966853141785,
0.8606715202331543,
0.2925337553024292,
-0.9422488212585449,
0.1855923980474472,
-0.5856255292892456,
-0.30945104360580444,
0.5062674880027771,
-0.7386499643325806,
-0.25744542479515076,
-0.15060724318027496,
-0.10551346838474274,
0.2449747622013092,
-0.3169439733028412,
0.6498735547065735,
-0.20584070682525635,
-0.662083625793457,
0.2517155706882477,
-0.13161829113960266,
1.0035420656204224,
0.09608540683984756,
-0.35057172179222107,
0.2731943428516388,
-0.25553959608078003,
-0.16590413451194763,
-0.09668299555778503,
-0.18773508071899414,
-0.064738430082798,
-0.367744505405426,
-0.3553686738014221,
0.28186243772506714,
0.05685212090611458,
-0.35699477791786194,
0.37898486852645874,
-0.4501781463623047,
0.3622216284275055,
0.8115253448486328,
0.03377658128738403,
0.665787935256958,
-0.440805047750473,
1.0105911493301392,
-0.34865033626556396,
-0.3269381523132324,
-0.3065789043903351,
-0.9133591055870056,
-0.4911678731441498,
-0.1387995183467865,
0.11924552917480469,
0.6292266249656677,
-1.0409765243530273,
0.1614391952753067,
0.09860393404960632,
-0.07885828614234924,
-0.20007523894309998,
0.15670810639858246,
0.4267512261867523,
0.7450929284095764,
0.27711614966392517,
-0.7257561087608337,
-0.718482494354248,
-0.5743163824081421,
-0.31812500953674316,
-0.5432340502738953,
-0.012570657767355442,
0.3007190525531769,
0.5959823131561279,
-0.09589649736881256,
1.2851403951644897,
-0.32172393798828125,
-0.15677501261234283,
-0.5196165442466736,
0.8517481684684753,
0.1426638811826706,
0.3256720304489136,
0.36292731761932373,
-0.26290345191955566,
-0.5368210077285767,
-0.21165603399276733,
-0.833670973777771,
-0.35769593715667725,
-0.11835668981075287,
-0.22661453485488892,
-0.14242134988307953,
0.37898167967796326,
-0.4124532639980316,
0.33810701966285706,
0.22920241951942444,
-0.288330614566803,
0.7774585485458374,
-0.13314595818519592,
-0.14228136837482452,
-1.0726045370101929,
-0.13083940744400024,
-0.1073753610253334,
-0.1690436154603958,
-0.3774084746837616,
-0.13421939313411713,
-0.31872427463531494,
-0.21241632103919983,
-0.2950246036052704,
0.40563032031059265,
-0.5660765767097473,
-0.44683822989463806,
-0.4374162256717682,
0.24219822883605957,
-0.07763662189245224,
0.5100111961364746,
-0.2018800526857376,
1.0970503091812134,
0.2617688477039337,
-0.045800577849149704,
0.3577982485294342,
0.1499459147453308,
0.10619813948869705,
0.8848757743835449,
-0.5422083139419556,
0.5205164551734924,
0.3127712607383728,
0.7760891914367676,
-1.1210027933120728,
-0.47132983803749084,
0.3629673719406128,
-0.48352670669555664,
0.1474785953760147,
0.1478116363286972,
-0.6838011741638184,
-0.6030731797218323,
-0.5348414778709412,
0.6278637051582336,
0.3926559090614319,
-0.43998852372169495,
0.5805325508117676,
0.6140265464782715,
-0.46513858437538147,
0.010378438979387283,
-0.20418262481689453,
0.29471591114997864,
-0.4589262306690216,
-0.7715616226196289,
0.6043434739112854,
-0.1908891648054123,
-0.457846462726593,
-0.4019789695739746,
0.15019026398658752,
-0.22966453433036804,
0.2943646013736725,
0.2853613793849945,
0.45005491375923157,
0.053120583295822144,
0.012598570436239243,
-0.07424245774745941,
-0.32605308294296265,
0.3990441560745239,
-0.04262658208608627,
0.22793614864349365,
-0.330992728471756,
-0.1333465576171875,
-0.7296215295791626,
0.42044347524642944,
0.29705020785331726,
0.1818072646856308,
0.15943166613578796,
0.4557764232158661,
-0.06372498720884323,
-0.0302767101675272,
-0.3774423897266388,
-0.33148741722106934,
-0.556749165058136,
-0.1274872124195099,
-0.11740873008966446,
-1.3217620849609375,
0.5217514634132385,
-0.48053526878356934,
-0.11594298481941223,
-0.011461262591183186,
0.5828806757926941,
-0.634039580821991,
0.7721038460731506,
0.7223220467567444,
-0.3445943593978882,
0.22018451988697052,
-0.1789325773715973,
0.0924721211194992,
-0.7703813314437866,
-0.2179313600063324,
-0.45227983593940735,
-0.5444207787513733,
-0.4911373555660248,
-0.43064019083976746,
0.546320378780365,
0.09063205868005753,
-0.3802647888660431,
0.042752835899591446,
-0.502195417881012,
0.5738126635551453,
0.48172736167907715,
-0.09091246128082275,
0.2692568302154541,
-0.3302212953567505,
-0.6695612072944641,
-0.2657914161682129,
-0.592681348323822,
-0.5689722895622253,
0.5944935083389282,
0.2083348035812378,
0.5319279432296753,
-0.06618144363164902,
0.9724475741386414,
-0.10958567261695862,
0.6303465366363525,
-0.7862235307693481,
0.8463351130485535,
0.3301389813423157,
-0.31374096870422363,
-0.0917661115527153,
-0.19698452949523926,
-1.1227924823760986,
0.3045100271701813,
0.1503787487745285,
-0.848789393901825,
-0.32061830163002014,
0.0005439975066110492,
-0.5160752534866333,
0.16367605328559875,
-0.6869131326675415,
0.7003465890884399,
-0.3934274911880493,
-0.5257580876350403,
-0.05795448645949364,
-0.8381824493408203,
0.5015810132026672,
-0.11385907977819443,
0.5066291093826294,
0.11380360275506973,
-0.15522535145282745,
0.7591632008552551,
-0.46201950311660767,
1.1181552410125732,
-0.10484141856431961,
-0.18600645661354065,
0.5800564289093018,
0.01309451088309288,
0.3464910089969635,
0.04577970132231712,
0.0983542874455452,
0.008549382910132408,
-0.6689471006393433,
-0.16342177987098694,
-0.5385725498199463,
0.7443596720695496,
-0.7502140402793884,
-0.8743664026260376,
-0.5581825971603394,
-0.7022380232810974,
-0.33608004450798035,
-0.058693524450063705,
0.12418265640735626,
0.07767761498689651,
-0.1770910918712616,
-0.35698238015174866,
0.16120664775371552,
-0.1258096694946289,
0.8033732771873474,
0.46212440729141235,
-0.2134970724582672,
-0.5181360840797424,
1.0109167098999023,
0.07695776224136353,
-0.017091184854507446,
-0.18013696372509003,
0.45973798632621765,
-0.3680151104927063,
-0.42031267285346985,
-0.12009554356336594,
0.3489178419113159,
-0.7166975736618042,
-0.06877674907445908,
-0.4016585648059845,
-0.00303445290774107,
-0.1615286022424698,
-0.7432460188865662,
0.0626286119222641,
-0.2677447497844696,
-0.769439160823822,
-0.11068225651979446,
-0.0941135585308075,
0.9724925756454468,
0.1649690866470337,
0.43351197242736816,
-0.573308527469635,
-0.005631512496620417,
0.5392588376998901,
0.21962368488311768,
0.02329403907060623,
-0.4543805718421936,
-0.030800413340330124,
-0.29567673802375793,
-1.0810292959213257,
-0.925571620464325,
0.3575679361820221,
0.017075419425964355,
0.7436187863349915,
0.04901018738746643,
-0.14739291369915009,
0.7508390545845032,
-0.3095704913139343,
1.2502720355987549,
0.450527548789978,
-0.9928895235061646,
0.6508820056915283,
-0.5355777144432068,
0.390166312456131,
0.5540503263473511,
0.4124707877635956,
-0.23679932951927185,
-0.5587204098701477,
-0.701702356338501,
-0.7985734939575195,
0.518610954284668,
0.18227480351924896,
-0.12361781299114227,
-0.014928609132766724,
0.31596529483795166,
0.35197708010673523,
0.006904460024088621,
-0.5830575227737427,
-0.10179716348648071,
-0.0786706879734993,
-0.019633745774626732,
0.14543257653713226,
-0.030939243733882904,
-0.05996442213654518,
-0.5969204902648926,
0.3908609449863434,
-0.41817954182624817,
0.07777002453804016,
-0.06233837828040123,
-0.16850295662879944,
0.07037767022848129,
0.40899547934532166,
0.5112035870552063,
0.6243112087249756,
-0.0060150292702019215,
0.2428247034549713,
0.4029172956943512,
-0.4754761755466461,
0.4572491943836212,
-0.08329091221094131,
0.16860076785087585,
-0.046792395412921906,
0.35480400919914246,
0.33016055822372437,
0.7826229929924011,
-0.23998554050922394,
0.6155803203582764,
-0.24106520414352417,
-0.3831425905227661,
-0.16905073821544647,
-0.019975053146481514,
0.2170213907957077,
0.39735937118530273,
0.3235439956188202,
-0.09379652887582779,
0.32435208559036255,
-0.4739031493663788,
0.36073195934295654,
0.31163233518600464,
-0.1903972178697586,
-0.9222745895385742,
0.7076115608215332,
0.7419214844703674,
-0.4922548234462738,
0.4340134263038635,
-0.4789259433746338,
-0.7542459964752197,
0.5449197888374329,
0.5676133632659912,
1.2648357152938843,
-0.0748731717467308,
0.27496495842933655,
0.4070057272911072,
-0.1571604311466217,
-0.022407690063118935,
0.4016686677932739,
-0.3515028953552246,
-0.5885642170906067,
-0.5954059362411499,
-0.2095567286014557,
-0.7796239852905273,
-0.3147643804550171,
-0.6830107569694519,
0.2758837342262268,
-0.3756524920463562,
-0.3143497109413147,
0.07800940424203873,
0.09011458605527878,
-0.6086927652359009,
-0.283107191324234,
0.21465755999088287,
0.3865450620651245,
-0.6795734763145447,
0.9462715983390808,
0.9697881937026978,
-0.30765295028686523,
-0.9938044548034668,
-0.0004621177795343101,
0.543672502040863,
-0.46182695031166077,
0.9956896305084229,
0.3091610074043274,
-0.1790696084499359,
0.20317776501178741,
-0.6495211720466614,
-0.5285711288452148,
1.427963137626648,
0.39019080996513367,
-0.4956437647342682,
-0.07766355574131012,
0.06030923128128052,
0.5337955951690674,
-0.434771329164505,
0.512082040309906,
0.5687646269798279,
0.3072715401649475,
0.13666844367980957,
-1.231595516204834,
-0.03654811531305313,
-0.035828035324811935,
-0.059707459062337875,
-0.03963993862271309,
-0.7874699831008911,
0.895945131778717,
-0.386011004447937,
-0.6174086332321167,
-0.025034818798303604,
0.6236766576766968,
0.3498865067958832,
0.7205485105514526,
0.39603281021118164,
0.6157607436180115,
0.9964672327041626,
-0.03913971781730652,
0.8863316178321838,
-0.0425260066986084,
0.5845746397972107,
1.4775139093399048,
-0.6278110146522522,
0.4714509844779968,
0.620324432849884,
-0.33524268865585327,
0.6377818584442139,
0.5933396816253662,
0.406404972076416,
0.25571465492248535,
0.45753705501556396,
-0.5214163064956665,
-0.1645495444536209,
-0.21622873842716217,
-0.23818528652191162,
0.4944475591182709,
0.34921377897262573,
0.01145433634519577,
-0.34317508339881897,
0.05513019487261772,
-0.05041741579771042,
0.034987084567546844,
-0.29640135169029236,
1.0506727695465088,
0.34625619649887085,
-0.8364284634590149,
0.44305893778800964,
-0.45342302322387695,
0.921445369720459,
0.08906198292970657,
-0.1699872463941574,
-0.1645612120628357,
-0.27217304706573486,
-0.08745241910219193,
-0.9963472485542297,
0.17291542887687683,
-0.05023537948727608,
0.05218367278575897,
-0.5081431269645691,
0.7899853587150574,
-0.22750136256217957,
-0.23546721041202545,
0.4656122922897339,
0.5806441903114319,
0.1553489863872528,
0.3919616937637329,
-0.5691472291946411,
0.047798387706279755,
-0.20174403488636017,
0.051209479570388794,
0.3521503210067749,
0.28549841046333313,
-0.15059229731559753,
0.47157761454582214,
0.4771222472190857,
-0.34304723143577576,
-0.22081853449344635,
0.2810063660144806,
1.1749110221862793,
-0.9598779082298279,
-0.4999005198478699,
-0.9674646854400635,
0.6456710696220398,
0.055386874824762344,
-0.30907705426216125,
0.862480103969574,
0.5502685308456421,
0.8466272950172424,
0.48793935775756836,
0.9672724604606628,
0.3891162574291229,
0.5105229616165161,
-0.1802404671907425,
0.21992962062358856,
-0.08215462416410446,
0.5336818099021912,
-0.551071047782898,
-0.6848272085189819,
-0.06658262014389038,
0.5112688541412354,
-0.05393457040190697,
-0.11474160104990005,
0.920237123966217,
0.40438681840896606,
0.22206902503967285,
0.7489662170410156,
0.18117575347423553,
0.06003166735172272,
0.46591296792030334,
0.5158045291900635,
1.4398419857025146,
0.0649089366197586,
0.24060551822185516,
-0.24694658815860748,
-0.544548749923706,
-0.06651176512241364,
-0.8500601053237915,
-1.01444673538208,
-0.3669499456882477,
-0.15488861501216888,
-0.13285475969314575,
-0.16731397807598114,
0.90618896484375,
0.2775377929210663,
-0.3685643970966339,
-0.6194349527359009,
-0.20331484079360962,
0.1305960863828659,
0.14257623255252838,
-0.23441466689109802,
-0.13178673386573792,
-0.5741857290267944,
-0.397212952375412,
0.6164185404777527,
0.47139468789100647,
0.04310830309987068,
-0.43220221996307373,
-0.2881586253643036,
-0.10761471837759018,
-0.2048099786043167,
0.5808922648429871,
0.21853749454021454,
-0.8695843815803528,
-0.29874786734580994,
0.09932832419872284,
-0.012438193894922733,
0.2177322804927826,
1.3311651945114136,
-1.1787285804748535,
0.693202018737793,
0.4654318690299988,
0.6281741857528687,
0.3528149425983429,
0.20341356098651886,
0.7639088034629822,
-0.8710950613021851,
0.019107306376099586,
0.4415051341056824,
0.3622499406337738,
0.22483110427856445,
-0.28079426288604736,
0.5241052508354187,
0.6441944241523743,
-1.0823523998260498,
-0.5793796181678772,
-0.17764467000961304,
-1.2285652160644531,
-0.11862984299659729,
0.8375644087791443,
-0.32441672682762146,
0.15455669164657593,
-0.6007410883903503,
-0.45777642726898193,
0.3675621449947357,
-0.4159182906150818,
0.6278863549232483,
0.9146656394004822,
-0.5508816242218018,
0.06950415670871735,
-0.4292134940624237,
0.12574084103107452,
0.3498496413230896,
-1.0977414846420288,
-0.3843815326690674,
0.4266202449798584,
0.20458213984966278,
0.1257626861333847,
0.9363973736763,
0.3205266296863556,
0.19054797291755676,
-0.2486688196659088,
-0.190731480717659,
0.19450148940086365,
-0.23198142647743225,
-0.36641255021095276,
0.17555421590805054,
-0.05290229991078377,
0.10315031558275223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.15793v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.15793v2
|
SWE-agent: Agent-Computer Interfaces Enable Automated Software Engineering
| 2024-05-06T17:41:33 | 2024-05-30T19:09:01 |
John Yang, Carlos E. Jimenez, Alexander Wettig, Kilian Lieret, Shunyu Yao, Karthik Narasimhan, Ofir Press
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Language model (LM) agents are increasingly being used to automate
complicated tasks in digital environments. Just as humans benefit from powerful
software applications, such as integrated development environments, for complex
tasks like software engineering, we posit that LM agents represent a new
category of end users with their own needs and abilities, and would benefit
from specially-built interfaces to the software they use. We investigate how
interface design affects the performance of language model agents. As a result
of this exploration, we introduce SWE-agent: a system that facilitates LM
agents to autonomously use computers to solve software engineering tasks.
SWE-agent's custom agent-computer interface (ACI) significantly enhances an
agent's ability to create and edit code files, navigate entire repositories,
and execute tests and other programs. We evaluate SWE-agent on SWE-bench and
HumanEvalFix, achieving state-of-the-art performance on both with a pass@1 rate
of 12.5% and 87.7%, respectively, far exceeding the previous state-of-the-art
achieved with non-interactive LMs. Finally, we provide insight on how the
design of the ACI can impact agents' behavior and performance.
|
[
-0.678989827632904,
-0.667746901512146,
0.48112475872039795,
0.13178414106369019,
0.34997496008872986,
0.3978615999221802,
0.1409396529197693,
-0.9995937347412109,
0.13774223625659943,
0.38676416873931885,
-0.42384573817253113,
-0.2656853497028351,
-0.12000522762537003,
0.09031189233064651,
-0.31672874093055725,
0.353105753660202,
-0.16703173518180847,
-0.1591871976852417,
-0.27934160828590393,
-0.05319734662771225,
-0.34179776906967163,
-0.4380759596824646,
-0.7045069932937622,
-0.6193747520446777,
0.4229692816734314,
0.1699046790599823,
1.1405141353607178,
0.5292239785194397,
0.4075287878513336,
0.49281230568885803,
0.3842047154903412,
-0.1529904305934906,
-0.04309036210179329,
0.27671104669570923,
-0.0947486162185669,
-0.39136800169944763,
-0.7798717617988586,
0.1545432060956955,
0.19763411581516266,
0.4871286153793335,
-0.06145649030804634,
0.031954776495695114,
-0.0911978930234909,
0.6331373453140259,
-0.3914830684661865,
0.17684970796108246,
-0.13187648355960846,
-0.07660422474145889,
0.1382266879081726,
-0.3108949661254883,
-0.7284883260726929,
-0.22418025135993958,
0.014761729165911674,
-0.8005997538566589,
-0.15163524448871613,
0.11404172331094742,
0.8574560880661011,
0.37145790457725525,
-0.41365960240364075,
-0.20606939494609833,
-0.7919626832008362,
0.6586670279502869,
-0.7535138726234436,
0.5610787272453308,
-0.11449670791625977,
0.3353904187679291,
-0.5305250883102417,
-0.4351087510585785,
-0.37605002522468567,
-0.6126158237457275,
-0.16430194675922394,
-0.095838263630867,
-0.23563501238822937,
0.5610825419425964,
0.356701523065567,
0.02455820143222809,
-0.7317670583724976,
0.38607892394065857,
0.007890185341238976,
-0.10896138101816177,
0.8621334433555603,
0.2646692097187042,
0.786631166934967,
0.3512384295463562,
-0.11034940183162689,
-0.19053404033184052,
-0.4694075286388397,
0.3641613721847534,
0.40462419390678406,
0.17182546854019165,
0.028063355013728142,
0.420467346906662,
-0.10013920813798904,
0.6458624601364136,
-0.27628228068351746,
0.04389091581106186,
0.19128718972206116,
0.14506615698337555,
-0.21568883955478668,
-0.4418705105781555,
0.5905323028564453,
0.12846828997135162,
0.3543671667575836,
-0.26941245794296265,
-0.6660192608833313,
0.1771249771118164,
0.39651525020599365,
-0.5869444608688354,
-0.07732435315847397,
0.4549722671508789,
-0.5511272549629211,
-0.4635477364063263,
-0.06938456743955612,
-0.11438041925430298,
-0.5684468746185303,
-0.7785940170288086,
0.8040795922279358,
-0.09118595719337463,
-0.41878002882003784,
-0.25240305066108704,
-0.56655353307724,
0.5288525819778442,
0.4592438042163849,
-0.2831459939479828,
0.6559383869171143,
0.5638583302497864,
0.5313584804534912,
-0.35505953431129456,
-0.49224111437797546,
-0.5680370926856995,
-0.06058717146515846,
-0.45529261231422424,
0.8258183598518372,
-0.7666304707527161,
-0.5174064040184021,
-0.25691089034080505,
-0.07051432132720947,
0.05128409340977669,
-0.6248722076416016,
-0.20466899871826172,
-0.5573777556419373,
-0.24022197723388672,
-0.1269102692604065,
-0.5975938439369202,
0.08703864365816116,
-0.19111551344394684,
-0.6530297994613647,
0.8032693862915039,
0.07098780572414398,
-0.23118779063224792,
0.12298466265201569,
-1.0699000358581543,
-0.5216144919395447,
0.2503187358379364,
-0.29019999504089355,
0.21575021743774414,
0.14923909306526184,
-0.4572322368621826,
0.10804526507854462,
-0.09994430840015411,
-0.1167757585644722,
-0.3727642893791199,
-0.5843287706375122,
0.339192271232605,
-0.014174229465425014,
0.6056976318359375,
0.35351088643074036,
-0.5107988119125366,
0.1502528041601181,
-0.7572885155677795,
0.2142626941204071,
0.029192401096224785,
-0.22606170177459717,
-0.38972482085227966,
0.11791664361953735,
0.17588463425636292,
0.4030461311340332,
0.3834191560745239,
-0.6127389073371887,
0.20979416370391846,
-0.3097624182701111,
-0.03416276350617409,
0.8361901640892029,
-0.20601163804531097,
0.6323786973953247,
-0.519733190536499,
0.6295168995857239,
-0.1898949146270752,
0.4216158390045166,
0.18006259202957153,
-0.3874925374984741,
-0.6123335361480713,
-0.11452095210552216,
0.05306242033839226,
0.6728187203407288,
-0.7051824927330017,
0.03236323222517967,
0.3134908676147461,
-0.5443292856216431,
-0.5085666179656982,
0.19634543359279633,
0.14829915761947632,
0.021440235897898674,
0.17346353828907013,
-0.38769540190696716,
-0.31177768111228943,
-1.039623498916626,
-0.36180827021598816,
-0.3471193015575409,
-0.13691316545009613,
0.7001707553863525,
0.2927965521812439,
-0.4794679582118988,
1.193469762802124,
-0.38083338737487793,
0.14337685704231262,
-0.39642584323883057,
0.3273200988769531,
-0.02333163470029831,
0.27744099497795105,
0.6360445618629456,
-0.48640963435173035,
-0.44419771432876587,
0.2332458794116974,
-0.8377501368522644,
-0.7283489108085632,
-0.18773801624774933,
-0.205814927816391,
0.5914140343666077,
0.41885292530059814,
-0.6101046800613403,
0.5151689648628235,
0.34147366881370544,
-0.39378124475479126,
0.5289347767829895,
-0.45599594712257385,
0.1777660846710205,
-0.4659688472747803,
0.1151813492178917,
0.12045224010944366,
-0.07703162729740143,
-0.84583580493927,
0.45546072721481323,
0.05481846258044243,
-0.23560413718223572,
-0.5217732191085815,
0.9390946626663208,
-0.506290853023529,
-0.29619526863098145,
-0.8492087125778198,
0.2709979712963104,
-0.12504643201828003,
0.5310762524604797,
0.1769683063030243,
0.969566285610199,
0.40161463618278503,
-0.6618583798408508,
0.11450378596782684,
-0.1850910186767578,
0.24387121200561523,
0.44262441992759705,
-0.7789474129676819,
0.34837213158607483,
-0.1005006805062294,
-0.03462465479969978,
-0.6602970957756042,
0.046559255570173264,
-0.2688674330711365,
-0.4303662180900574,
0.2816002666950226,
0.30270692706108093,
-0.2684953808784485,
-0.22654017806053162,
-0.46899208426475525,
0.18174462020397186,
0.5310792326927185,
-0.36376452445983887,
1.0063910484313965,
0.5289698839187622,
-0.06727051734924316,
-0.4566252827644348,
-0.41742268204689026,
0.2561824917793274,
0.3684600293636322,
-0.6708647608757019,
-0.024264317005872726,
-0.2495690882205963,
-0.7342090606689453,
0.05830346420407295,
-0.03482690081000328,
-0.23640309274196625,
0.3806263506412506,
0.4774596393108368,
0.3236464262008667,
-0.19737966358661652,
0.0181057620793581,
0.08565498888492584,
-0.09551499038934708,
0.19362770020961761,
0.22739852964878082,
0.3212679922580719,
-0.20459923148155212,
-0.3898152709007263,
-0.6161428689956665,
0.5401159524917603,
0.7853707671165466,
-0.15858294069766998,
0.6173461675643921,
0.22010454535484314,
-0.37463489174842834,
-0.3498978614807129,
-0.6268138885498047,
-0.17971180379390717,
-0.5942783951759338,
0.2837468981742859,
-0.712609052658081,
-0.5079741477966309,
0.5111610889434814,
-0.08685900270938873,
0.5121915936470032,
0.14865361154079437,
0.13329188525676727,
-0.23540648818016052,
1.2495728731155396,
0.9677676558494568,
-0.37706631422042847,
0.7243926525115967,
-0.12382320314645767,
0.23923470079898834,
-0.39758211374282837,
0.08246909826993942,
-0.7173663377761841,
-0.43512606620788574,
-0.669155478477478,
0.030136391520500183,
0.2181272655725479,
-0.35681992769241333,
-0.47836410999298096,
0.549328088760376,
-0.42933088541030884,
0.3612768054008484,
0.40836983919143677,
-0.08507027477025986,
0.37020018696784973,
-0.4716135859489441,
0.10583509504795074,
0.28995057940483093,
-0.5796375274658203,
-0.7352960705757141,
0.6651294231414795,
0.6958247423171997,
1.2510145902633667,
0.19611144065856934,
0.8037380576133728,
0.7245869040489197,
0.4419516921043396,
-0.5434555411338806,
0.8403894305229187,
0.17535462975502014,
-0.22449731826782227,
-0.5537983775138855,
-0.18092206120491028,
-0.9170069694519043,
0.2955584228038788,
0.013948023319244385,
-0.5621496438980103,
0.43547385931015015,
0.03426726907491684,
0.14544545114040375,
-0.12094494700431824,
-1.102352499961853,
0.8099892735481262,
-0.3102058470249176,
-0.2917363941669464,
-0.6238285303115845,
-0.33827072381973267,
-0.06487588584423065,
0.10903005301952362,
0.35231491923332214,
-0.01045747846364975,
-0.3547109067440033,
0.44181039929389954,
-0.6404141187667847,
0.8423038721084595,
-0.44705697894096375,
-0.058329373598098755,
0.18873876333236694,
0.3184928894042969,
0.8343921899795532,
-0.3129596710205078,
-0.24591773748397827,
-0.13658329844474792,
0.09431227296590805,
-0.4226248562335968,
-0.7943722605705261,
0.7008013129234314,
-0.9561071991920471,
-0.7499367594718933,
-0.3071829080581665,
-0.5405135154724121,
-0.0874498188495636,
0.05459447577595711,
-0.29100945591926575,
0.4688612222671509,
-0.4127349555492401,
-0.2752387225627899,
0.518161952495575,
-0.38036665320396423,
0.6277392506599426,
0.956950843334198,
-0.2508211135864258,
0.1853964477777481,
0.8900856375694275,
0.115000419318676,
0.45551320910453796,
0.23339858651161194,
-0.1371375024318695,
-0.12621678411960602,
-0.23396587371826172,
-0.3914167881011963,
0.21603277325630188,
-0.7523089647293091,
0.07135281711816788,
-0.559898316860199,
-0.5222015380859375,
-0.10132618993520737,
-0.5168768763542175,
-0.2787039279937744,
-0.27736958861351013,
-0.047010596841573715,
0.19722138345241547,
0.14598220586776733,
1.1265532970428467,
0.28475725650787354,
0.039778195321559906,
-0.5313939452171326,
0.23481939733028412,
0.18534357845783234,
0.3186054229736328,
0.0607391782104969,
-0.2755747437477112,
-0.18062244355678558,
-0.20805443823337555,
-0.29746097326278687,
-0.8641317486763,
0.11894925683736801,
0.1019754633307457,
0.9786162376403809,
0.08546093851327896,
0.23349307477474213,
0.2103218138217926,
-0.2502446174621582,
0.5299825668334961,
-0.3277079164981842,
-0.926521360874176,
0.4302271008491516,
-0.19940321147441864,
0.41877514123916626,
0.2974666655063629,
0.10174381732940674,
-0.5201011896133423,
-1.075973391532898,
-0.4849127531051636,
-0.661372184753418,
0.5083947777748108,
0.16818909347057343,
-0.14474475383758545,
0.24052250385284424,
0.28790831565856934,
-0.016450753435492516,
0.255262553691864,
-0.7474755644798279,
-0.34123000502586365,
0.12128543853759766,
-0.17375896871089935,
0.2240215241909027,
0.0883253887295723,
0.1814459264278412,
-0.09980859607458115,
0.7818904519081116,
-0.11918718367815018,
0.2162274569272995,
0.2054634541273117,
-0.5179836750030518,
-0.18108069896697998,
0.32613644003868103,
0.6534458994865417,
0.6517480611801147,
0.037774987518787384,
0.004470322746783495,
0.1866033524274826,
-0.38515061140060425,
0.21278712153434753,
0.003888897830620408,
-0.14043967425823212,
0.05233159288764,
0.28246697783470154,
0.5636071562767029,
-0.1540834754705429,
-0.7672771215438843,
0.4093477725982666,
-0.15435051918029785,
-0.17882533371448517,
-0.2866942584514618,
0.5340036749839783,
-0.15555556118488312,
0.38190004229545593,
0.42237982153892517,
0.1212264820933342,
0.41878366470336914,
-0.5856202244758606,
0.12077661603689194,
0.6056733131408691,
-0.11647415906190872,
-0.25122758746147156,
0.541111171245575,
0.5583001971244812,
-0.8219226002693176,
0.23011133074760437,
-0.0208870992064476,
-0.1651977151632309,
1.0347249507904053,
0.4060027003288269,
1.1407723426818848,
-0.3502195179462433,
0.17598874866962433,
-0.09720184653997421,
0.5295963287353516,
0.27963608503341675,
0.35905516147613525,
-0.15831056237220764,
-0.4642117917537689,
-0.40161144733428955,
-0.4558546543121338,
-0.7053765058517456,
-0.0643894299864769,
-0.07121828198432922,
0.2690778374671936,
-0.3408800959587097,
-0.11698552221059799,
-0.12064243853092194,
0.07766006886959076,
-0.7021283507347107,
0.13310115039348602,
0.127274289727211,
1.2713911533355713,
-0.864826500415802,
0.673488438129425,
1.0024906396865845,
-0.21744808554649353,
-0.8919589519500732,
-0.3297276198863983,
-0.08368266373872757,
-0.40988433361053467,
0.4445631802082062,
-0.03839149326086044,
-0.5427732467651367,
-0.09942512214183807,
-0.20024457573890686,
-0.7396222352981567,
0.9985800981521606,
0.2242320328950882,
-0.42628148198127747,
0.08186832070350647,
0.4556925594806671,
0.8355419635772705,
-0.44989636540412903,
0.8618835806846619,
0.5303432941436768,
0.5804930925369263,
-0.35314682126045227,
-1.2020378112792969,
0.059642210602760315,
-0.6866181492805481,
0.25380733609199524,
0.28270938992500305,
-0.6400354504585266,
0.3666422367095947,
-0.11543605476617813,
0.03493141382932663,
-0.045046281069517136,
0.3652355372905731,
0.1743437945842743,
0.4034484624862671,
0.6330399513244629,
0.08019262552261353,
0.576255738735199,
0.13313739001750946,
0.9353638887405396,
-0.6013715863227844,
-0.08609414100646973,
0.6797182559967041,
-0.4866265058517456,
0.8266229629516602,
0.36191633343696594,
-0.14312954246997833,
0.5471920371055603,
0.5311216115951538,
0.4040137827396393,
0.05146457627415657,
0.14037498831748962,
-0.4478082060813904,
-0.1816626489162445,
-0.06299235671758652,
-0.17019283771514893,
0.1783958226442337,
0.025717876851558685,
0.00985669530928135,
0.021897323429584503,
0.34984174370765686,
-0.38445189595222473,
0.04437640681862831,
-0.16043607890605927,
0.8019958734512329,
0.1545921266078949,
-0.40918970108032227,
0.1616276353597641,
-0.11983010917901993,
0.43171149492263794,
-0.5169479846954346,
-0.11267106980085373,
-0.3533872663974762,
0.14569547772407532,
-0.3792450428009033,
-0.6029576659202576,
0.2542567849159241,
-0.22333583235740662,
-0.1387850046157837,
-0.24859128892421722,
0.9414103627204895,
-0.07816663384437561,
-0.034160345792770386,
0.4866591691970825,
0.6756237745285034,
0.3033654987812042,
0.06491360068321228,
-0.6071345210075378,
0.1970479041337967,
-0.4441516399383545,
-0.6298162341117859,
0.5115407705307007,
0.2709709703922272,
-0.33794766664505005,
1.1711052656173706,
0.36854398250579834,
-0.09007292985916138,
-0.14914561808109283,
0.2555333077907562,
0.910454273223877,
-0.7615291476249695,
-0.2816027104854584,
-0.6334179639816284,
0.42438995838165283,
-0.051491878926754,
0.11178457736968994,
0.3769747316837311,
0.7142302989959717,
0.5265963077545166,
-0.13571438193321228,
0.8564801216125488,
-0.18656882643699646,
0.155558243393898,
-0.03160718455910683,
0.8810853362083435,
-0.7549604177474976,
0.40180882811546326,
-0.4768321216106415,
-0.6426485180854797,
0.11623222380876541,
0.2962881624698639,
-0.10383255779743195,
0.25540077686309814,
0.7375087141990662,
1.0766782760620117,
0.22490045428276062,
-0.14294850826263428,
0.5118611454963684,
0.14047843217849731,
0.5243641138076782,
0.3890661895275116,
0.8166885375976562,
-0.2874191105365753,
0.4188830256462097,
-0.1313137412071228,
-0.43499600887298584,
-0.03266443684697151,
-0.5807183384895325,
-0.8151039481163025,
-0.4517535865306854,
-0.4330289363861084,
0.024889757856726646,
0.02064550668001175,
1.0363006591796875,
0.5176651477813721,
-0.6575794816017151,
-0.705933153629303,
-0.09017951786518097,
0.32120785117149353,
-0.21669183671474457,
-0.24082200229167938,
-0.2556883692741394,
-0.7420035004615784,
-0.5702817440032959,
0.5701280832290649,
0.49813804030418396,
0.11866579949855804,
-0.3135933578014374,
-0.46867477893829346,
0.1791415810585022,
0.4328446686267853,
0.6037933230400085,
0.4637133479118347,
-0.5220449566841125,
-0.26375508308410645,
0.37529104948043823,
-0.5997462272644043,
0.00852481834590435,
0.8391555547714233,
-0.8622095584869385,
0.1418178677558899,
0.48273834586143494,
0.6201749444007874,
0.11077350378036499,
-0.025991102680563927,
0.8682101964950562,
-0.2603698670864105,
0.09342064708471298,
0.00966675579547882,
0.14142905175685883,
-0.24039550125598907,
-0.6383527517318726,
0.38039204478263855,
0.08947039395570755,
-0.9066355228424072,
-0.7844488024711609,
0.08782809227705002,
-0.9148878455162048,
-0.4976188838481903,
0.8478939533233643,
0.28015127778053284,
-0.41459885239601135,
-0.5174084305763245,
-0.5171799659729004,
-0.10273811966180801,
-0.5089629292488098,
0.6085548400878906,
0.6335291266441345,
-0.7140355110168457,
-0.3776076138019562,
-0.6489569544792175,
0.4581870436668396,
0.3601139783859253,
-0.988537073135376,
-0.09534316509962082,
0.45436590909957886,
0.26178446412086487,
-0.07996659725904465,
0.7695894837379456,
0.26710546016693115,
0.6553938388824463,
0.05250702425837517,
0.6995325088500977,
-0.22384175658226013,
-0.28873011469841003,
-0.17142853140830994,
0.06430573016405106,
0.8394759297370911,
-0.05056193470954895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03595v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03595v1
|
GREEN: Generative Radiology Report Evaluation and Error Notation
| 2024-05-06T16:04:03 | 2024-05-06T16:04:03 |
Sophie Ostmeier, Justin Xu, Zhihong Chen, Maya Varma, Louis Blankemeier, Christian Bluethgen, Arne Edward Michalson, Michael Moseley, Curtis Langlotz, Akshay S Chaudhari, Jean-Benoit Delbrouck
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Evaluating radiology reports is a challenging problem as factual correctness
is extremely important due to the need for accurate medical communication about
medical images. Existing automatic evaluation metrics either suffer from
failing to consider factual correctness (e.g., BLEU and ROUGE) or are limited
in their interpretability (e.g., F1CheXpert and F1RadGraph). In this paper, we
introduce GREEN (Generative Radiology Report Evaluation and Error Notation), a
radiology report generation metric that leverages the natural language
understanding of language models to identify and explain clinically significant
errors in candidate reports, both quantitatively and qualitatively. Compared to
current metrics, GREEN offers: 1) a score aligned with expert preferences, 2)
human interpretable explanations of clinically significant errors, enabling
feedback loops with end-users, and 3) a lightweight open-source method that
reaches the performance of commercial counterparts. We validate our GREEN
metric by comparing it to GPT-4, as well as to error counts of 6 experts and
preferences of 2 experts. Our method demonstrates not only higher correlation
with expert error counts, but simultaneously higher alignment with expert
preferences when compared to previous approaches."
|
[
0.13235796988010406,
-0.6036060452461243,
0.9657460451126099,
0.406889408826828,
-0.30277106165885925,
0.2435891032218933,
-0.1359151303768158,
-0.4923836588859558,
-0.07474537938833237,
-0.08620103448629379,
-0.13532589375972748,
-0.7672091722488403,
-0.8896845579147339,
0.0756271481513977,
0.04654938355088234,
1.0116925239562988,
-0.18753241002559662,
0.4070158898830414,
-0.13768194615840912,
-0.4944131374359131,
-0.7922723293304443,
0.2352127730846405,
-0.5536374449729919,
-0.07308857142925262,
0.4348103404045105,
0.5670661926269531,
1.2058722972869873,
0.5530623197555542,
0.8610846996307373,
0.32105252146720886,
0.3854066729545593,
0.2911982238292694,
-0.3625621795654297,
-0.3098844587802887,
-0.12158463150262833,
-0.11271809041500092,
-0.5928165316581726,
0.08132733404636383,
0.5185964703559875,
0.4270695745944977,
-0.2600895166397095,
-0.02439272776246071,
-0.38706648349761963,
0.8411979675292969,
-0.5605660676956177,
0.5474231839179993,
-0.37978285551071167,
0.3004743754863739,
-0.1524301916360855,
-0.6733599305152893,
-0.3441435396671295,
-0.7299395799636841,
-0.051599785685539246,
-0.8331408500671387,
0.3131358027458191,
-0.017469335347414017,
1.0939936637878418,
0.2063109427690506,
-0.1880238801240921,
-0.407607764005661,
-0.8128626942634583,
0.7320085167884827,
-0.6180764436721802,
0.22631601989269257,
0.21180592477321625,
0.7715637683868408,
0.24797655642032623,
-0.70038241147995,
-0.5195180177688599,
-0.3012230694293976,
-0.3454201817512512,
0.734216570854187,
-0.3932202160358429,
0.19337882101535797,
0.028416240587830544,
0.614518940448761,
-0.6065879464149475,
0.0006027408526279032,
-0.5667268633842468,
-0.3526129126548767,
0.7025202512741089,
0.3058941662311554,
0.7062717080116272,
-0.21648457646369934,
-0.2371581792831421,
-0.07136934995651245,
-0.21718816459178925,
-0.7518695592880249,
0.1348121017217636,
0.08181717246770859,
-0.3221527636051178,
0.5759427547454834,
-0.1447698026895523,
0.5528132319450378,
0.16628186404705048,
-0.25880005955696106,
0.46266087889671326,
-0.5276212692260742,
-0.22987613081932068,
0.0877515897154808,
0.9287452101707458,
0.8071279525756836,
-0.13029171526432037,
-0.2139071375131607,
-0.0712222084403038,
0.4945891201496124,
0.26457634568214417,
-0.5181654095649719,
-0.529857337474823,
0.373185932636261,
-0.5393930077552795,
-0.20954804122447968,
0.16320964694023132,
-0.8028814792633057,
-0.2891623079776764,
-0.22569069266319275,
0.5303784608840942,
-0.6857791543006897,
-0.4067153334617615,
0.31756797432899475,
-0.228860542178154,
0.1080392599105835,
0.7742378115653992,
-0.5783870220184326,
0.19125665724277496,
0.35945481061935425,
0.8748092651367188,
0.1036490648984909,
0.032295625656843185,
-0.6184077262878418,
-0.030302884057164192,
-0.4405587613582611,
0.867502748966217,
-0.42036426067352295,
-0.594854474067688,
-0.2808816134929657,
-0.23876287043094635,
-0.33829930424690247,
-0.4104960560798645,
0.5868675112724304,
-0.4686569273471832,
0.3254973292350769,
-0.07400664687156677,
-0.33475083112716675,
-0.21120662987232208,
0.12868356704711914,
-0.45701834559440613,
0.7347765564918518,
0.4891873598098755,
-0.8707380890846252,
0.6272505521774292,
-0.8487209677696228,
-0.1447342485189438,
0.5405781269073486,
-0.4503638744354248,
-0.46403592824935913,
0.01141346339136362,
-0.0055922954343259335,
0.307748943567276,
-0.32551565766334534,
0.16455376148223877,
0.16451242566108704,
-0.31082049012184143,
0.10476300865411758,
-0.13341914117336273,
0.5711408853530884,
0.3635430932044983,
-0.34705036878585815,
0.38304638862609863,
-0.795285701751709,
0.432722270488739,
0.3220687508583069,
-0.24772319197654724,
-0.04700670763850212,
-0.19562861323356628,
-0.1963409036397934,
-0.07579553872346878,
0.027011193335056305,
-0.7328558564186096,
-0.42736542224884033,
0.02534225396811962,
0.07401561737060547,
0.4058941900730133,
-0.01330720167607069,
0.07665219902992249,
-0.4442267417907715,
0.8375290036201477,
0.01272897981107235,
0.11942555755376816,
0.056917548179626465,
-0.592697024345398,
-0.4380028247833252,
-0.43303748965263367,
0.4196241796016693,
0.7135124206542969,
-0.3337128758430481,
0.31232115626335144,
-0.46555569767951965,
-0.84281986951828,
-0.6067359447479248,
-0.23843391239643097,
0.46886149048805237,
0.770381510257721,
0.37807223200798035,
-0.282599538564682,
-0.3881664276123047,
-0.814755916595459,
-0.07677212357521057,
-0.4400867521762848,
0.07329444587230682,
0.3130989372730255,
0.19082152843475342,
-0.5672726035118103,
0.7002879977226257,
-0.848783552646637,
-0.3901606500148773,
0.007169457618147135,
0.5831032395362854,
0.04002425819635391,
0.22575801610946655,
0.2702617049217224,
-0.6871859431266785,
-0.5058990716934204,
0.47955891489982605,
-0.8403720259666443,
-0.021497445181012154,
-0.259488970041275,
0.0144560057669878,
0.2334166318178177,
0.33089983463287354,
-0.417018860578537,
0.32242462038993835,
0.6632794141769409,
-0.422521710395813,
0.7050955891609192,
-0.6378949880599976,
0.5577820539474487,
-0.37671151757240295,
0.07682501524686813,
0.3113445043563843,
-0.22811031341552734,
-0.1760179102420807,
0.036332868039608,
0.2148061990737915,
-0.050030265003442764,
-0.07530979067087173,
0.24147507548332214,
-0.5060807466506958,
-0.25179964303970337,
0.21133604645729065,
0.1360631287097931,
0.04183033108711243,
-0.09233696758747101,
0.029789868742227554,
0.5613605976104736,
0.3164527416229248,
-0.23404017090797424,
0.29641517996788025,
0.3148796558380127,
-0.2900739014148712,
0.5234190225601196,
-0.5248902440071106,
0.29853886365890503,
-0.1846126765012741,
-0.05290863662958145,
-1.0224095582962036,
-0.375242680311203,
0.2509361207485199,
-0.6649388670921326,
0.4295170307159424,
-0.18541698157787323,
-0.2997259497642517,
-0.23631703853607178,
-0.22946669161319733,
0.330242782831192,
0.5085381865501404,
-0.3077656626701355,
0.35427334904670715,
0.29896777868270874,
-0.11676856875419617,
-0.4192168414592743,
-0.6683695316314697,
0.18323419988155365,
0.004715900868177414,
-0.7343549132347107,
0.29411739110946655,
-0.12634913623332977,
-0.37233874201774597,
0.2902413308620453,
-0.04209592193365097,
-0.16615886986255646,
0.04303770512342453,
0.056776851415634155,
0.3660028576850891,
-0.527672529220581,
-0.047976695001125336,
-0.4078080356121063,
-0.3434121906757355,
0.15269750356674194,
0.04918312281370163,
-0.04544682800769806,
-0.585787832736969,
-0.4854770004749298,
-0.3654879331588745,
0.13115274906158447,
0.6679750680923462,
-0.027032410725951195,
0.3320676386356354,
0.5183459520339966,
-0.4208329916000366,
0.08698836714029312,
-0.46552908420562744,
0.34266895055770874,
-0.4040631055831909,
0.4908857047557831,
0.054277244955301285,
-0.44162288308143616,
0.19276197254657745,
0.24862869083881378,
0.07291454076766968,
0.9042695760726929,
0.5298169851303101,
-0.19920505583286285,
1.041286587715149,
0.28706496953964233,
0.6317112445831299,
-0.21066269278526306,
0.12025503814220428,
0.363971471786499,
-0.6157795786857605,
-0.42131203413009644,
-0.49808621406555176,
0.22290414571762085,
-0.5669699311256409,
-0.6527544856071472,
0.5382645130157471,
-0.1369275599718094,
0.07298702001571655,
-0.32618632912635803,
-0.7815682888031006,
0.4790937006473541,
-0.04969733953475952,
0.08686470240354538,
0.4611758291721344,
-0.030622320249676704,
0.021444886922836304,
-0.29515770077705383,
-0.7685840129852295,
-0.705980658531189,
0.8494114279747009,
0.6046487092971802,
0.5597785711288452,
0.14156633615493774,
0.6155240535736084,
0.272487998008728,
0.766346275806427,
-0.9300267696380615,
0.332821786403656,
-0.4422474503517151,
-0.272573322057724,
-0.3471166789531708,
-0.4061082601547241,
-0.6795489192008972,
0.19256724417209625,
-0.22814534604549408,
-0.15781226754188538,
-0.10257251560688019,
0.4608992338180542,
-0.6005056500434875,
0.06701131910085678,
-0.8055648803710938,
1.0044832229614258,
-0.3840222954750061,
0.02317165583372116,
-0.35574936866760254,
-0.47034960985183716,
0.3206498324871063,
0.09867335110902786,
0.4304113984107971,
-0.1647334098815918,
-0.0781601145863533,
0.6393404603004456,
-0.47307661175727844,
0.6491008400917053,
-0.3121923804283142,
0.10983181744813919,
0.1092015877366066,
0.16230463981628418,
0.30865636467933655,
0.04288671910762787,
0.08759275078773499,
0.27136653661727905,
-0.03512787073850632,
-0.23076766729354858,
-0.46368780732154846,
0.3578595817089081,
-0.7206533551216125,
-0.4145200550556183,
-0.7852020263671875,
-0.3686518967151642,
-0.39157596230506897,
0.14213986694812775,
0.4138924777507782,
0.3916192650794983,
-0.4196855425834656,
-0.33511853218078613,
0.43171364068984985,
-0.385979562997818,
-0.22639816999435425,
0.562175452709198,
-0.0014528040774166584,
-0.3134286105632782,
1.0644073486328125,
0.11863373219966888,
0.19307570159435272,
0.21829375624656677,
0.5513710379600525,
-0.23841966688632965,
-1.1621809005737305,
-0.6092739701271057,
0.2877931594848633,
-1.0758249759674072,
-0.2118011862039566,
-0.8920655846595764,
-0.26486343145370483,
0.10396387428045273,
-0.27911654114723206,
-0.13882982730865479,
-0.23196183145046234,
-0.18001259863376617,
-0.22966110706329346,
0.408814936876297,
0.6977449655532837,
-0.2631983458995819,
0.04527948796749115,
-0.9071846008300781,
0.2564319372177124,
0.2302147001028061,
0.438829630613327,
-0.24159686267375946,
-0.23635263741016388,
-0.2690091133117676,
-0.19210411608219147,
-0.2804059088230133,
-0.8444603085517883,
0.3393014669418335,
-0.05507910996675491,
0.5045105814933777,
0.15228845179080963,
-0.24745985865592957,
0.8213516473770142,
-0.385381281375885,
0.6416734457015991,
0.7150059938430786,
-0.7950980067253113,
0.6933826804161072,
-0.6991220116615295,
0.31300339102745056,
0.6739825010299683,
0.18147046864032745,
-0.5428268909454346,
-0.6450808644294739,
-0.9703531861305237,
-0.7306190729141235,
0.4642135798931122,
-0.03863225877285004,
-0.19113238155841827,
-0.4528810977935791,
0.05945157632231712,
0.19733335077762604,
-0.25000107288360596,
-0.4838331341743469,
0.031334105879068375,
-0.4531354010105133,
-0.36710742115974426,
0.10982643067836761,
-0.32607802748680115,
-0.49087855219841003,
-0.10563158243894577,
0.6890245079994202,
-0.6188921928405762,
0.6212330460548401,
0.4149743914604187,
-0.17255733907222748,
-0.5121557712554932,
0.39535975456237793,
0.6801056861877441,
1.3315941095352173,
-0.3922518193721771,
0.04184465855360031,
0.09276064485311508,
-0.5546363592147827,
-0.15066969394683838,
-0.045828595757484436,
0.18849369883537292,
0.33398619294166565,
0.4427052438259125,
0.5142739415168762,
0.22639741003513336,
-0.39310529828071594,
0.5873229503631592,
-0.38541480898857117,
-0.4112774729728699,
-0.46135684847831726,
-0.08328301459550858,
0.16199012100696564,
-0.2665366530418396,
0.2449178546667099,
0.5514475107192993,
0.23114578425884247,
-0.2928869426250458,
0.13463376462459564,
0.35039404034614563,
-0.5367515683174133,
-0.2720409035682678,
0.6715895533561707,
0.3857213258743286,
0.18688641488552094,
0.6987912058830261,
-0.4514884948730469,
-0.1505817472934723,
0.8408204913139343,
0.4667609632015228,
1.0132790803909302,
0.13076753914356232,
0.7282761335372925,
0.8051320910453796,
0.16773724555969238,
0.00466806348413229,
0.4228522479534149,
0.42916038632392883,
-0.8579261302947998,
-0.6160203814506531,
-0.2947273254394531,
-0.6154739260673523,
0.0007422599010169506,
-0.7799296379089355,
0.21702714264392853,
-0.9146051406860352,
-0.08057307451963425,
0.35219430923461914,
-0.2488526701927185,
-0.5525602698326111,
0.6309924125671387,
0.044081080704927444,
0.7318956851959229,
-0.6726403832435608,
0.32081782817840576,
0.7944666743278503,
-0.37522098422050476,
-0.9685218930244446,
0.10761479288339615,
0.2379436045885086,
-0.9649949073791504,
0.9379596710205078,
0.03726569190621376,
-0.27642127871513367,
-0.3226843774318695,
-0.010459905490279198,
-0.5053173303604126,
1.0930689573287964,
0.23095019161701202,
-0.6213160157203674,
0.35196056962013245,
-0.23255252838134766,
0.6306465268135071,
-0.1948455423116684,
0.5307018160820007,
0.4711918830871582,
0.7209622859954834,
0.05675969645380974,
-0.9112467169761658,
0.40089476108551025,
0.0587414875626564,
-0.1243807002902031,
0.16960760951042175,
-0.5765944123268127,
0.3072735071182251,
-0.7134581208229065,
-0.800854504108429,
-0.12853609025478363,
0.5424597859382629,
0.13424257934093475,
0.33450818061828613,
0.5184795260429382,
0.46070942282676697,
1.0573832988739014,
-0.2812170088291168,
1.4236618280410767,
0.07392798364162445,
0.3907666802406311,
0.6933579444885254,
-0.1549060195684433,
0.24561280012130737,
0.12285111844539642,
-0.48692601919174194,
0.480938196182251,
0.4610011875629425,
-0.27079248428344727,
0.4465997815132141,
-0.013254626654088497,
-0.15956272184848785,
-0.10954039543867111,
0.19780884683132172,
-0.2276771366596222,
0.2792527377605438,
0.358676940202713,
-0.1759854406118393,
-0.3372020125389099,
-0.4976813793182373,
0.13569459319114685,
0.28635352849960327,
-0.24057775735855103,
0.7506884932518005,
-0.08937253057956696,
-0.6089912056922913,
0.5814127326011658,
0.1543319672346115,
0.5188054442405701,
-0.6884677410125732,
-0.197572261095047,
0.007496464066207409,
0.18792949616909027,
-0.7733055949211121,
-0.7469824552536011,
0.7580421566963196,
0.006674075964838266,
-0.149181067943573,
-0.03423989564180374,
0.26805579662323,
-0.16333559155464172,
-0.5355915427207947,
0.07018600404262543,
0.2743649184703827,
0.030871881172060966,
0.5135897994041443,
-0.7474836707115173,
0.06899522244930267,
0.20228753983974457,
0.35700029134750366,
0.055000320076942444,
0.32140302658081055,
-0.07923632860183716,
0.25509095191955566,
0.4665009081363678,
0.47710877656936646,
-0.3344469964504242,
0.12593698501586914,
0.37382772564888,
-0.564953088760376,
-0.6556029915809631,
-0.581301748752594,
0.6952067613601685,
-0.14750511944293976,
-0.4701617658138275,
0.6406307816505432,
0.40229833126068115,
0.48806867003440857,
-0.14353768527507782,
0.9692093729972839,
-0.10280197113752365,
0.4751792252063751,
-0.7776620388031006,
0.5687087774276733,
-0.1537923663854599,
0.27824869751930237,
-0.23925653100013733,
-0.5411962270736694,
-0.47274184226989746,
0.68101966381073,
-0.31083834171295166,
0.1732422113418579,
1.0583961009979248,
0.743965208530426,
-0.02941051498055458,
0.19363661110401154,
0.2929237484931946,
0.41340166330337524,
0.2120334953069687,
0.20264430344104767,
0.8858041763305664,
-0.23004041612148285,
0.4206498861312866,
-0.030345259234309196,
-0.5230897068977356,
-0.24029499292373657,
-1.0246155261993408,
-0.1749638319015503,
-0.22649039328098297,
-1.2474592924118042,
-0.5708935260772705,
0.20147694647312164,
0.3900347054004669,
0.6434849500656128,
-0.820472002029419,
0.20425136387348175,
-0.0959358811378479,
-0.1083189994096756,
-0.30635368824005127,
-0.27286168932914734,
0.6341241598129272,
-0.4589902460575104,
-0.3841814398765564,
0.2858613431453705,
0.5112647414207458,
-0.08876783400774002,
-0.023729829117655754,
-0.36834681034088135,
0.2937782108783722,
-0.15720269083976746,
0.22639667987823486,
0.44020876288414,
-0.5274074077606201,
-0.4993689954280853,
-0.517476499080658,
-0.24873429536819458,
0.4675365090370178,
0.6474707722663879,
-0.5181655287742615,
0.7999595999717712,
0.36318060755729675,
0.4527604877948761,
0.33743107318878174,
-0.18449747562408447,
0.6808547973632812,
-0.4041668176651001,
-0.23652587831020355,
0.48348546028137207,
0.32079488039016724,
0.7578560709953308,
-0.7143793106079102,
0.6984179615974426,
0.27568718791007996,
-0.41534191370010376,
-0.5749574303627014,
-0.11179821193218231,
-1.0022222995758057,
-0.11008642613887787,
1.1315537691116333,
-0.2577865719795227,
0.06049230322241783,
-0.26878365874290466,
-0.1265750378370285,
0.06551212817430496,
-0.15208874642848969,
0.7641546726226807,
0.4977715015411377,
-0.3458479642868042,
-0.03936724364757538,
-0.8119344711303711,
0.6233404278755188,
0.4494403302669525,
-0.8969197273254395,
-0.16521123051643372,
0.8241021633148193,
0.710056483745575,
0.46566876769065857,
1.092222809791565,
-0.7596740126609802,
1.0634154081344604,
0.0541527234017849,
-0.06619405001401901,
-0.17824795842170715,
0.07981467992067337,
-0.37563231587409973,
-0.03873986378312111,
0.3845233619213104,
-0.34482914209365845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03594v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03594v1
|
Enabling High-Sparsity Foundational Llama Models with Efficient Pretraining and Deployment
| 2024-05-06T16:03:32 | 2024-05-06T16:03:32 |
Abhinav Agarwalla, Abhay Gupta, Alexandre Marques, Shubhra Pandit, Michael Goin, Eldar Kurtic, Kevin Leong, Tuan Nguyen, Mahmoud Salem, Dan Alistarh, Sean Lie, Mark Kurtz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized Natural Language Processing
(NLP), but their size creates computational bottlenecks. We introduce a novel
approach to create accurate, sparse foundational versions of performant LLMs
that achieve full accuracy recovery for fine-tuning tasks at up to 70%
sparsity. We achieve this for the LLaMA-2 7B model by combining the SparseGPT
one-shot pruning method and sparse pretraining of those models on a subset of
the SlimPajama dataset mixed with a Python subset of The Stack dataset. We
exhibit training acceleration due to sparsity on Cerebras CS-3 chips that
closely matches theoretical scaling. In addition, we establish inference
acceleration of up to 3x on CPUs by utilizing Neural Magic's DeepSparse engine
and 1.7x on GPUs through Neural Magic's nm-vllm engine. The above gains are
realized via sparsity alone, thus enabling further gains through additional use
of quantization. Specifically, we show a total speedup on CPUs for
sparse-quantized LLaMA models of up to 8.6x. We demonstrate these results
across diverse, challenging tasks, including chat, instruction following, code
generation, arithmetic reasoning, and summarization to prove their generality.
This work paves the way for rapidly creating smaller and faster LLMs without
sacrificing accuracy.
|
[
-0.3322836756706238,
-0.8554958701133728,
0.256374329328537,
0.6370545625686646,
-0.2715449333190918,
0.09057142585515976,
-0.589695930480957,
-0.196346253156662,
0.28753232955932617,
0.6716356873512268,
-0.5065943598747253,
-0.4769917130470276,
-0.8170033693313599,
-0.033609308302402496,
-0.47919762134552,
1.0828325748443604,
0.24624183773994446,
-0.49452337622642517,
0.11660461127758026,
-0.0662379339337349,
-0.575018048286438,
-0.4569498598575592,
-0.37092939019203186,
-0.1479019820690155,
0.3938876986503601,
0.3265800476074219,
1.0278704166412354,
0.816676139831543,
0.32059288024902344,
0.3028219938278198,
-0.31260183453559875,
0.24442702531814575,
-0.7958827614784241,
-0.02326856181025505,
0.23381052911281586,
-0.3329424262046814,
-0.594119131565094,
-0.2193118780851364,
0.7481511831283569,
0.9427513480186462,
-0.5042695999145508,
0.15676501393318176,
0.25911378860473633,
0.5398643016815186,
-0.8334271311759949,
-0.15539151430130005,
-0.8821815252304077,
-0.07401134073734283,
-0.1870928853750229,
-0.016696499660611153,
-0.1568574607372284,
-0.2857300043106079,
-0.01476724911481142,
-0.930052638053894,
0.22617726027965546,
-0.15224120020866394,
0.7756450772285461,
0.5706311464309692,
-0.12879623472690582,
-0.05584032088518143,
-0.46459776163101196,
0.756004810333252,
-0.7579604387283325,
0.29945996403694153,
0.3919685184955597,
0.08210491389036179,
-0.3732885420322418,
-0.8374722003936768,
-0.3852139413356781,
-0.2699558436870575,
0.11326639354228973,
-0.32984811067581177,
-0.226930171251297,
0.10966650396585464,
0.3713931441307068,
0.40824952721595764,
-0.6547300815582275,
0.07016944885253906,
-0.11662325263023376,
0.023696856573224068,
0.184973806142807,
0.0777568519115448,
-0.14589224755764008,
0.2178933322429657,
-0.12310344725847244,
0.10032676160335541,
-0.9745190143585205,
-0.29230543971061707,
0.002759604947641492,
0.2135743349790573,
-0.04786300286650658,
0.5438984632492065,
-0.2592739760875702,
0.7248291373252869,
0.16043917834758759,
-0.2067834883928299,
0.12086901068687439,
-0.31394386291503906,
-0.4185052514076233,
-0.03290585055947304,
0.6522899866104126,
-0.18554465472698212,
0.3709351718425751,
-0.2242247760295868,
-0.20723406970500946,
0.2396612912416458,
0.21425700187683105,
-0.98188716173172,
-0.13300544023513794,
-0.12202621251344681,
-0.1331636607646942,
-0.21689704060554504,
-0.43295130133628845,
-0.4540838599205017,
-0.46141037344932556,
-0.23126354813575745,
0.4154447019100189,
-0.21124149858951569,
-0.35052138566970825,
0.5822728276252747,
0.36827024817466736,
0.03877989202737808,
0.266182005405426,
-1.0282940864562988,
0.6634413599967957,
0.9300979971885681,
0.8881129026412964,
-0.00011211786477360874,
-0.23097962141036987,
-0.5863322019577026,
0.0926300659775734,
-0.5811914205551147,
0.6327139735221863,
-0.27380242943763733,
-0.128654345870018,
-0.22853542864322662,
-0.2790478467941284,
0.07341291755437851,
-0.6272377371788025,
0.3403420150279999,
-0.48302221298217773,
-0.34206435084342957,
-0.03758259117603302,
-0.16529753804206848,
0.18690982460975647,
0.41038399934768677,
-0.5088817477226257,
1.3333942890167236,
0.06139431148767471,
-0.4692521095275879,
0.13881996273994446,
-0.36023569107055664,
-0.49503999948501587,
-0.00777302123606205,
0.040863633155822754,
-0.3329545855522156,
0.4506652057170868,
0.1794893741607666,
0.6902881264686584,
-0.3918304741382599,
0.49866464734077454,
-0.20246651768684387,
-0.8208328485488892,
0.1663937270641327,
-0.5182939767837524,
0.46991026401519775,
0.067855603992939,
-0.46569305658340454,
-0.14423386752605438,
-1.014408826828003,
-0.0753416046500206,
0.07170090824365616,
-0.34318575263023376,
-0.2895576059818268,
-0.10555272549390793,
-0.1882161796092987,
-0.024600643664598465,
0.33510878682136536,
-0.13197514414787292,
0.14292964339256287,
-0.8048058748245239,
0.3690255582332611,
0.762831449508667,
-0.38905367255210876,
0.3365412652492523,
-0.060355111956596375,
0.3832691013813019,
-0.38482603430747986,
-0.06030223146080971,
-0.04086524248123169,
-0.32633858919143677,
-0.9333081245422363,
-0.5744209885597229,
0.37623485922813416,
0.4006396234035492,
-0.43451353907585144,
0.6576464772224426,
-0.5960506796836853,
-0.3386092483997345,
-0.4884956479072571,
0.4726998805999756,
0.5394441485404968,
0.41457298398017883,
0.31169065833091736,
-0.23244532942771912,
-0.4845361113548279,
-0.6750220060348511,
-0.018045131117105484,
0.1852961927652359,
-0.13533267378807068,
0.011097325943410397,
0.3454854488372803,
-0.2749096751213074,
0.723821759223938,
-0.49333131313323975,
-0.1776495724916458,
-0.13308416306972504,
0.14488285779953003,
0.5126788020133972,
0.6916922330856323,
0.3079453408718109,
-0.5513838529586792,
-0.26546797156333923,
-0.02533063292503357,
-0.5273271203041077,
-0.34305208921432495,
0.13730482757091522,
-0.3862111270427704,
-0.06689813733100891,
0.23280681669712067,
-0.8623166084289551,
0.38743993639945984,
0.6006326675415039,
-0.11814748495817184,
0.2524832785129547,
-0.11008327454328537,
-0.18388059735298157,
-1.0827287435531616,
0.09741050750017166,
0.06721789389848709,
-0.31140264868736267,
-0.6368688941001892,
0.019204717129468918,
-0.1134478747844696,
-0.09659744799137115,
-0.17379826307296753,
0.3528757393360138,
-0.42971548438072205,
-0.30273330211639404,
-0.42377763986587524,
0.054348718374967575,
0.05026356875896454,
0.5585028529167175,
0.10017137229442596,
0.9826536774635315,
0.27157530188560486,
-0.6461430788040161,
-0.04821167141199112,
0.11454881727695465,
-0.3217286765575409,
0.18888740241527557,
-0.9262962341308594,
0.0519641675055027,
0.06549148261547089,
0.18506060540676117,
-0.8123742938041687,
-0.09179126471281052,
-0.05179930850863457,
-0.3399713337421417,
0.29276135563850403,
-0.16766007244586945,
-0.6569480895996094,
-0.04982472583651543,
-0.29494044184684753,
0.3205181658267975,
0.7301756739616394,
-0.49792084097862244,
0.5671354532241821,
0.36272451281547546,
-0.14678092300891876,
-1.0714976787567139,
-0.6910226941108704,
0.1889333873987198,
-0.05740587040781975,
-0.5646914839744568,
0.31613361835479736,
0.024157829582691193,
-0.13226895034313202,
-0.21066996455192566,
-0.15087607502937317,
-0.2137439250946045,
0.6162108182907104,
0.22110068798065186,
0.12971378862857819,
-0.4408096969127655,
-0.002868067706003785,
0.08308300375938416,
-0.2903994917869568,
-0.16173283755779266,
-0.21746285259723663,
0.6084322333335876,
-0.4034397304058075,
-0.04968990013003349,
-0.24065513908863068,
0.0845119059085846,
0.25983643531799316,
-0.19318591058254242,
0.7945884466171265,
0.6039668321609497,
-0.6706452965736389,
-0.23385588824748993,
-0.9181391596794128,
0.024245308712124825,
-0.49076467752456665,
0.46585777401924133,
-0.3686615824699402,
-1.1328896284103394,
0.05211936682462692,
-0.25680258870124817,
0.0728749930858612,
0.2578740119934082,
0.6955329179763794,
0.12834805250167847,
0.9156041145324707,
0.9240729212760925,
-0.15414667129516602,
0.4093605577945709,
-0.40988072752952576,
0.03805932775139809,
-0.6043492555618286,
0.12562502920627594,
-0.6028610467910767,
-0.05132032185792923,
-0.10597440600395203,
-0.6193745732307434,
0.3159095346927643,
0.426038533449173,
-0.4570631980895996,
0.2967923581600189,
-0.5154872536659241,
0.7250548005104065,
0.3132672607898712,
0.024997970089316368,
0.35507118701934814,
0.3087884187698364,
0.20163625478744507,
-0.00010352562821935862,
-0.7620660662651062,
-0.553688108921051,
1.0016751289367676,
0.2261001616716385,
0.7470672726631165,
-0.0071775102987885475,
0.37676629424095154,
0.09746265411376953,
0.6150805354118347,
-0.5457833409309387,
0.5690227150917053,
-0.27965596318244934,
-0.30911627411842346,
-0.20828907191753387,
-0.42908975481987,
-0.8378860354423523,
0.48191213607788086,
-0.4358200132846832,
-0.5498476028442383,
-0.01844710484147072,
0.3545805513858795,
-0.5439144968986511,
0.02528986893594265,
-0.5596566796302795,
0.8529565334320068,
-0.07600443065166473,
-0.5191130042076111,
-0.47806471586227417,
-0.5738896131515503,
0.5959870219230652,
-0.13407865166664124,
0.09582693129777908,
-0.3761804699897766,
-0.28276875615119934,
0.5431515574455261,
-0.5817702412605286,
1.007149338722229,
-0.059610575437545776,
-0.15778115391731262,
0.16216830909252167,
0.20047029852867126,
0.5410428047180176,
0.07890071719884872,
-0.0920519158244133,
0.3188226521015167,
-0.26436418294906616,
-0.45369523763656616,
-0.596633791923523,
0.8664652705192566,
-0.8260745406150818,
-0.5925272107124329,
-0.22838382422924042,
-0.5514823198318481,
-0.452492892742157,
0.012186892330646515,
-0.15774989128112793,
0.2014293074607849,
-0.11420144885778427,
0.3538627028465271,
0.9886968731880188,
-0.08928562700748444,
0.14591991901397705,
0.4750485420227051,
0.24697266519069672,
-0.5287173390388489,
0.8879969716072083,
0.13585522770881653,
0.14983998239040375,
0.35451191663742065,
0.08886989951133728,
-0.08930718898773193,
-0.7773489356040955,
-0.48665717244148254,
0.2819923460483551,
-0.40116649866104126,
-0.4595315456390381,
-0.602564811706543,
-0.15558315813541412,
-0.3574046790599823,
-0.35424619913101196,
-0.5979235768318176,
-0.5705246329307556,
-0.4712568521499634,
0.00962801743298769,
0.3095913529396057,
0.6502361297607422,
-0.11765281111001968,
0.8709849119186401,
-0.6422262191772461,
0.43909820914268494,
0.23199807107448578,
0.307054728269577,
0.08452048897743225,
-0.6986036896705627,
-0.44027724862098694,
-0.02597668766975403,
-0.28906646370887756,
-0.4301186501979828,
0.5077651739120483,
0.36623793840408325,
0.1563982516527176,
0.178328275680542,
-0.39051225781440735,
1.216536521911621,
-0.4644402265548706,
0.5509361028671265,
0.1684470921754837,
-1.036260962486267,
0.44374826550483704,
-0.17170226573944092,
0.11636358499526978,
0.5716280937194824,
0.42526647448539734,
-0.24129422008991241,
-0.002877849852666259,
-0.3684411644935608,
-0.7353155016899109,
0.3846946060657501,
0.17046202719211578,
0.20895393192768097,
-0.0651363730430603,
0.6549359560012817,
0.11799507588148117,
0.38044968247413635,
-0.7413951754570007,
0.0888659656047821,
-0.225851371884346,
-0.4713186025619507,
-0.16189853847026825,
-0.4363299608230591,
-0.14165695011615753,
-0.14131827652454376,
0.7351979613304138,
-0.40782415866851807,
-0.08580724895000458,
-0.039530571550130844,
-0.37381672859191895,
0.007611962500959635,
0.17376181483268738,
0.4143330156803131,
0.5550239086151123,
-0.08097710460424423,
0.18923649191856384,
0.368610143661499,
-0.5515364408493042,
0.23349948227405548,
0.2624119818210602,
0.025998830795288086,
-0.21647511422634125,
0.29907381534576416,
0.6869627237319946,
0.5870752334594727,
-0.8009917140007019,
0.7460840940475464,
-0.10157161206007004,
0.03088589757680893,
-0.18997488915920258,
0.0017511523328721523,
0.05422930046916008,
0.23614822328090668,
0.3423386216163635,
0.03880408778786659,
0.005236685276031494,
-0.09063251316547394,
-0.10316169261932373,
0.5592917203903198,
0.18506573140621185,
-0.3267365097999573,
0.6558204293251038,
0.03340587764978409,
0.09836933761835098,
0.5331708192825317,
0.09449932724237442,
-0.14574845135211945,
0.49670714139938354,
0.7645701169967651,
0.6113104224205017,
0.02294076234102249,
-0.06895998120307922,
0.26460978388786316,
0.32661172747612,
-0.5189809203147888,
-0.0017961966805160046,
-0.33970198035240173,
-0.699494481086731,
-0.9519894123077393,
-0.9391071796417236,
-0.2127467393875122,
0.05042940378189087,
-0.38607078790664673,
0.030421648174524307,
-0.787129819393158,
-0.17021703720092773,
-0.33593764901161194,
0.1564525067806244,
-0.41202637553215027,
0.1622145175933838,
0.20430102944374084,
0.862755298614502,
-0.642644464969635,
0.7875381708145142,
0.19024966657161713,
0.013521404005587101,
-0.7383580207824707,
-0.3244467079639435,
-0.4000735282897949,
-0.9423362612724304,
0.541191041469574,
0.24621933698654175,
-0.19155186414718628,
0.16981211304664612,
-0.7312424182891846,
-1.0765125751495361,
1.0422894954681396,
0.8276365995407104,
-0.7420969009399414,
-0.09414707124233246,
0.11352922767400742,
0.5667400360107422,
-0.09621553868055344,
0.14758388698101044,
0.7553535103797913,
0.12598232924938202,
0.013604599982500076,
-0.8983306884765625,
0.12079547345638275,
-0.18442925810813904,
0.286047101020813,
0.17510205507278442,
-0.5603740811347961,
0.829279363155365,
-0.0820750966668129,
-0.1233585774898529,
0.4781605303287506,
0.8759562373161316,
0.6891069412231445,
-0.028089284896850586,
0.46858733892440796,
0.8717968463897705,
0.8634790182113647,
-0.09476583451032639,
0.9913651943206787,
-0.46355384588241577,
0.03745149075984955,
0.8355749845504761,
-0.2745596468448639,
0.880742609500885,
0.43082237243652344,
-0.0610526017844677,
0.36365339159965515,
0.40469685196876526,
0.2742660343647003,
0.4029313325881958,
0.4984748959541321,
-0.42842939496040344,
-0.4011521637439728,
-0.30954861640930176,
-0.36292025446891785,
0.045008618384599686,
0.6731091737747192,
0.04457142949104309,
0.03442620113492012,
-0.05095341429114342,
0.19053994119167328,
0.09218645095825195,
-0.5457258820533752,
0.5841805934906006,
0.17966927587985992,
-0.521586537361145,
1.1093883514404297,
0.14602848887443542,
1.0960965156555176,
-0.8887934684753418,
-0.09436684101819992,
-0.327899694442749,
0.27262720465660095,
-0.19856290519237518,
-0.3417862355709076,
0.2490537315607071,
0.22690922021865845,
0.005970703437924385,
-0.19366596639156342,
0.922136664390564,
-0.19926856458187103,
-0.4773399233818054,
0.019152173772454262,
0.42304015159606934,
0.08072806894779205,
-0.2441241443157196,
-0.5006597638130188,
0.3575391471385956,
-0.373618483543396,
-0.47118088603019714,
0.5383764505386353,
0.44678428769111633,
-0.13998614251613617,
0.7185092568397522,
0.7899162173271179,
0.25257375836372375,
0.4730900526046753,
-0.04516198858618736,
1.1145360469818115,
-0.4626603126525879,
-0.2672557234764099,
-0.7862024903297424,
0.2517242729663849,
0.18560168147087097,
-0.40908029675483704,
0.5525755286216736,
0.4817955791950226,
0.6584618091583252,
0.1572159081697464,
0.4263513386249542,
0.113013856112957,
0.26424047350883484,
-0.5422253012657166,
0.41077178716659546,
-0.3813076615333557,
0.38419175148010254,
-0.1711805909872055,
-0.8177968263626099,
-0.49927881360054016,
0.9185293316841125,
-0.017331711947917938,
-0.06120506301522255,
0.2878381907939911,
1.0710334777832031,
-0.07802116125822067,
-0.2336452156305313,
0.3535422384738922,
0.3822701871395111,
0.034899935126304626,
0.709051787853241,
0.8350918889045715,
-0.4900866746902466,
0.6699177622795105,
-0.3664548695087433,
-0.22900725901126862,
0.06651748716831207,
-0.8607281446456909,
-0.7809559106826782,
-0.11084665358066559,
-0.14727993309497833,
-0.41012004017829895,
0.3555205464363098,
1.0069535970687866,
0.9408749341964722,
-0.5282583832740784,
-0.36342984437942505,
-0.33288779854774475,
0.030336245894432068,
-0.06777866929769516,
-0.17958809435367584,
0.26002106070518494,
-0.36838793754577637,
-0.4918755292892456,
0.6089557409286499,
0.2920067608356476,
0.11238137632608414,
-0.29861652851104736,
-0.17785881459712982,
0.008519246242940426,
-0.013920484110713005,
0.664548397064209,
0.3774357736110687,
-0.5671025514602661,
0.133697509765625,
-0.19737876951694489,
-0.09847329556941986,
0.0551801472902298,
0.7926547527313232,
-1.1110918521881104,
-0.27353736758232117,
0.1286700814962387,
1.0873955488204956,
0.6639212369918823,
0.022050360217690468,
0.4512217938899994,
-0.9844164848327637,
0.4826125204563141,
0.2472265511751175,
0.3182776868343353,
0.34772273898124695,
-0.3136516213417053,
0.6496164798736572,
0.3289652466773987,
-0.4719063341617584,
-1.1216864585876465,
-0.09540780633687973,
-0.939100980758667,
-0.11122698336839676,
1.029052734375,
-0.14755702018737793,
-0.34366363286972046,
0.1583407074213028,
-0.1196884959936142,
0.08207251876592636,
-0.21095097064971924,
0.625817060470581,
0.34114938974380493,
0.23186317086219788,
-0.07408154010772705,
-0.42435988783836365,
0.3085429072380066,
0.6799947023391724,
-0.7190889120101929,
0.2162729650735855,
0.528396487236023,
0.2972865402698517,
-0.09875210374593735,
1.0390734672546387,
0.03693275526165962,
0.2496332973241806,
-0.009093391709029675,
0.10297031700611115,
-0.14520768821239471,
-0.4385596513748169,
-0.45570603013038635,
0.32183414697647095,
0.17348934710025787,
0.30976739525794983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03553v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03553v2
|
AlphaMath Almost Zero: process Supervision without process
| 2024-05-06T15:20:30 | 2024-05-23T05:07:24 |
Guoxin Chen, Minpeng Liao, Chengxi Li, Kai Fan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have substantially
enhanced their mathematical reasoning abilities. However, these models still
struggle with complex problems that require multiple reasoning steps,
frequently leading to logical or numerical errors. While numerical mistakes can
be largely addressed by integrating a code interpreter, identifying logical
errors within intermediate steps is more challenging. Moreover, manually
annotating these steps for training is not only expensive but also
labor-intensive, requiring the expertise of professional annotators. In our
study, we introduce an innovative approach that bypasses the need for process
annotations (from human or GPTs) by utilizing the Monte Carlo Tree Search
(MCTS) framework. This technique automatically generates both the process
supervision and the step-level evaluation signals. Our method iteratively
trains the policy and value models, leveraging the capabilities of a
well-pretrained LLM to progressively enhance its mathematical reasoning skills.
Furthermore, we propose an efficient inference strategy-step-level beam search,
where the value model is crafted to assist the policy model (i.e., LLM) in
navigating more effective reasoning paths, rather than solely relying on prior
probabilities. The experimental results on both in-domain and out-of-domain
datasets demonstrate that even without GPT-4 or human-annotated process
supervision, our AlphaMath framework achieves comparable or superior results to
previous state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.3697086572647095,
-0.7896938920021057,
0.9887734055519104,
-0.08685968071222305,
0.008256488479673862,
0.08956935256719589,
0.015354372560977936,
-0.12174223363399506,
-0.028216155245900154,
0.5128209590911865,
-0.8838711380958557,
-0.6197544932365417,
-0.5162386298179626,
-0.28357934951782227,
-0.05385929346084595,
0.8654538989067078,
-0.2503002882003784,
0.06671827286481857,
-0.011310308240354061,
0.2873166799545288,
-0.08258482068777084,
-0.33510658144950867,
-0.7435967922210693,
-0.609521210193634,
0.24104183912277222,
0.45085424184799194,
0.8901141881942749,
0.6582890748977661,
0.5244662761688232,
0.17296887934207916,
0.03884967789053917,
0.1868526190519333,
-0.062437765300273895,
0.04590994864702225,
-0.2792709171772003,
-0.2756098508834839,
-0.6526352167129517,
0.1460236757993698,
0.2921047806739807,
0.6948528289794922,
-0.2695271074771881,
0.08738527446985245,
-0.4469548463821411,
0.6216989159584045,
-0.6820474863052368,
0.6780539155006409,
-0.6031060814857483,
0.25633904337882996,
-0.011156965047121048,
-0.43371838331222534,
-0.47511065006256104,
-0.4113147556781769,
-0.17060405015945435,
-0.7282012701034546,
0.11394031345844269,
0.08073394000530243,
0.7248533368110657,
0.3026401698589325,
-0.24829219281673431,
-0.4042772352695465,
-0.6021760106086731,
0.8433130383491516,
-0.7254841327667236,
0.05759420618414879,
0.677799642086029,
0.492005854845047,
-0.280829519033432,
-0.36102786660194397,
-0.298595130443573,
-0.22194543480873108,
0.03004782646894455,
0.13151900470256805,
-0.05237232893705368,
0.60346919298172,
0.596928060054779,
0.04413621500134468,
-0.1730746477842331,
-0.2117399126291275,
-0.20874235033988953,
-0.2429899126291275,
0.5877413153648376,
0.019165292382240295,
0.10746046155691147,
-0.12732286751270294,
0.10161950439214706,
-0.26879748702049255,
-0.7001025676727295,
-0.12255042791366577,
0.24102267622947693,
0.3313292860984802,
0.33487728238105774,
0.7189441323280334,
-0.25315651297569275,
0.3039717376232147,
-0.34300851821899414,
-0.16076867282390594,
0.2539151906967163,
-0.1834779530763626,
-0.2793125808238983,
0.21173489093780518,
0.6906232237815857,
-0.13839979469776154,
0.6720510125160217,
-0.05575636029243469,
-0.4479998052120209,
0.27650022506713867,
0.29085516929626465,
-0.7474335432052612,
-0.3582271933555603,
0.10221860557794571,
0.09643050283193588,
-0.1820787489414215,
-0.1919114589691162,
-0.42496657371520996,
-0.1912297010421753,
-0.37019678950309753,
0.4341767728328705,
-0.5398605465888977,
-0.09592249989509583,
-0.0701657384634018,
0.18028053641319275,
0.07059650123119354,
0.6018700003623962,
-0.7665751576423645,
0.32779091596603394,
0.6360495686531067,
0.8992644548416138,
0.08091944456100464,
0.1283368021249771,
-0.6167856454849243,
-0.018398849293589592,
-0.7500587701797485,
0.5700584053993225,
-0.6850100159645081,
-0.35107651352882385,
-0.20597051084041595,
-0.30072373151779175,
-0.0644230917096138,
-0.2800980508327484,
0.6890234351158142,
-0.5355948209762573,
-0.0951719731092453,
0.029783768579363823,
-0.46260982751846313,
-0.3041932284832001,
0.3788040280342102,
-0.33058252930641174,
0.8863335251808167,
0.1745702624320984,
-0.49305179715156555,
0.2959546148777008,
-1.2586100101470947,
-0.2018863409757614,
-0.08813401311635971,
-0.4162891209125519,
-0.6696605682373047,
0.10767874866724014,
0.6156754493713379,
0.3583778142929077,
-0.06970111280679703,
0.4108659625053406,
-0.6575725078582764,
-0.47925320267677307,
-0.015364469960331917,
-0.43064481019973755,
0.76596599817276,
0.1336604207754135,
-0.5322127342224121,
0.16217200458049774,
-0.7283353209495544,
0.2042912393808365,
0.05511075630784035,
0.16065850853919983,
-0.17862311005592346,
0.11610323935747147,
-0.37105944752693176,
0.5643570423126221,
-0.14194157719612122,
-0.5512554049491882,
0.4206453859806061,
-0.3415766954421997,
0.28743332624435425,
0.8646789789199829,
0.3247048854827881,
0.4889325201511383,
-0.16386455297470093,
0.8753311634063721,
0.04248564690351486,
0.16975656151771545,
-0.6149739623069763,
-0.6624689698219299,
-0.6206874251365662,
-0.34087103605270386,
-0.054191138595342636,
0.6519042253494263,
-0.855983555316925,
0.0042146239429712296,
-0.01521340012550354,
-0.29485848546028137,
-0.6567527651786804,
0.16251632571220398,
0.5184826254844666,
0.4554484784603119,
0.4431028366088867,
-0.25978395342826843,
-0.5065075755119324,
-0.730625569820404,
-0.018637478351593018,
-0.20237666368484497,
0.03298185393214226,
0.16134296357631683,
0.605629026889801,
-0.20852649211883545,
1.0091242790222168,
-0.4832075238227844,
-0.40818294882774353,
0.09002621471881866,
0.34380200505256653,
0.5273074507713318,
0.5177726149559021,
-0.07666755467653275,
-0.30937933921813965,
-0.2200271338224411,
-0.0266225915402174,
-1.0276492834091187,
-0.159164696931839,
-0.13153305649757385,
-0.27763113379478455,
0.1639440506696701,
0.6580252647399902,
-0.5783651471138,
0.6331035494804382,
0.22943900525569916,
-0.11456223577260971,
0.34628668427467346,
-0.34798547625541687,
-0.011453509330749512,
-0.5225009918212891,
0.08912409096956253,
0.2412676215171814,
-0.24466687440872192,
-0.46941077709198,
0.048025257885456085,
0.126175656914711,
-0.1868731826543808,
-0.45001929998397827,
0.5466375946998596,
-0.5769281983375549,
-0.24333246052265167,
-0.11261839419603348,
-0.019949985668063164,
-0.1905299872159958,
0.8045482039451599,
0.18644849956035614,
0.8892611861228943,
0.6775565147399902,
-0.3706597089767456,
0.05419658496975899,
0.09279259294271469,
-0.05082474276423454,
0.6119763255119324,
-0.2841804027557373,
-0.014228195883333683,
-0.1710614114999771,
0.19420558214187622,
-0.8404276967048645,
0.051809534430503845,
0.46549707651138306,
-0.4419753849506378,
0.26217466592788696,
-0.4536217749118805,
-0.6300692558288574,
-0.2150074988603592,
-0.3919711709022522,
0.17899323999881744,
0.6338117122650146,
-0.18145203590393066,
0.6129884719848633,
0.18702849745750427,
-0.0934334546327591,
-0.4154473543167114,
-0.5975645184516907,
0.03600846603512764,
-0.008155281655490398,
-0.3235628604888916,
-0.2501433193683624,
0.0717892199754715,
-0.2950242757797241,
-0.09191848337650299,
-0.4880104064941406,
-0.1896374374628067,
0.26611900329589844,
0.43719834089279175,
0.3231962025165558,
-0.2621379494667053,
-0.20548929274082184,
0.18709489703178406,
-0.4819281995296478,
0.34881260991096497,
-0.3265411853790283,
0.13190285861492157,
-0.1595897674560547,
-0.915789008140564,
-0.5013501048088074,
-0.0721769854426384,
0.49471116065979004,
-0.23391400277614594,
0.4447561204433441,
0.33821728825569153,
-0.3685445189476013,
-0.31965482234954834,
-0.30163395404815674,
-0.32739007472991943,
-0.4605717360973358,
0.05119013786315918,
-0.41269630193710327,
-0.6326647996902466,
0.2483765184879303,
-0.2167334109544754,
0.37412938475608826,
0.2860816717147827,
0.3061886131763458,
-0.10191455483436584,
1.5093662738800049,
0.44138628244400024,
0.30228331685066223,
0.39507541060447693,
-0.374673992395401,
0.4449441730976105,
-0.8419349789619446,
-0.21497902274131775,
-0.16796256601810455,
0.0902637168765068,
-0.4009048342704773,
-0.6706852316856384,
0.560517430305481,
0.02866223081946373,
-0.34071290493011475,
0.14499247074127197,
-0.4933633804321289,
0.5560042858123779,
0.47133132815361023,
-0.053843043744564056,
0.5692079663276672,
0.015505585819482803,
-0.3327729403972626,
-0.16521023213863373,
-0.7510855197906494,
-0.5610957145690918,
1.3040571212768555,
0.3864372968673706,
0.7249089479446411,
-0.13979670405387878,
0.8189795613288879,
0.20039419829845428,
0.7874650955200195,
-0.7648495435714722,
0.5577854514122009,
0.42382046580314636,
-0.7375653982162476,
-0.352215439081192,
-0.7544130682945251,
-0.6834151744842529,
0.507307231426239,
-0.00365659361705184,
-0.8338212966918945,
-0.14454108476638794,
0.28252899646759033,
-0.48121488094329834,
0.35191842913627625,
-0.6508830189704895,
0.8124880790710449,
-0.16401152312755585,
-0.4845864772796631,
-0.0343223437666893,
-0.4000539183616638,
0.7003476619720459,
-0.4517955482006073,
0.7623893618583679,
-0.46038031578063965,
0.052428312599658966,
0.48758170008659363,
-0.5433803200721741,
0.5180829763412476,
-0.41249945759773254,
0.006257143337279558,
0.3067654073238373,
0.45101016759872437,
0.52275151014328,
0.19040422141551971,
-0.12871496379375458,
0.031942423433065414,
-0.14885132014751434,
-0.4627874791622162,
-0.5070784687995911,
0.4959639608860016,
-0.549883246421814,
-0.5029621720314026,
-0.9463754892349243,
-0.6994124054908752,
-0.47545126080513,
0.20306898653507233,
-0.3008260726928711,
0.09158144891262054,
0.09374960511922836,
-0.2061515599489212,
0.7125798463821411,
-0.00651850551366806,
0.6508144736289978,
0.4108946621417999,
-0.5063117146492004,
-0.17075848579406738,
0.7170233726501465,
0.07055862247943878,
0.21763630211353302,
0.08146680146455765,
0.0037881319876760244,
-0.28941088914871216,
-0.47206512093544006,
-0.46021768450737,
0.2516419589519501,
-0.6752224564552307,
-0.16727867722511292,
-0.6159478425979614,
-0.3270190954208374,
-0.016304321587085724,
-0.35129019618034363,
-0.5500884056091309,
-0.36793196201324463,
-0.02127043530344963,
-0.15711766481399536,
0.2827558219432831,
0.5336061716079712,
-0.13454914093017578,
0.4510285556316376,
-0.4966965615749359,
0.4264717102050781,
0.16658055782318115,
0.3664441406726837,
0.022278402000665665,
-0.4509119689464569,
-0.25451067090034485,
0.21367010474205017,
-0.4925770163536072,
-0.6524460315704346,
0.5367856025695801,
0.13785851001739502,
0.5041452646255493,
0.4087218940258026,
-0.01539422944188118,
0.8069401979446411,
-0.5554009079933167,
0.2898576259613037,
0.12095795571804047,
-1.1274739503860474,
0.6723970770835876,
-0.38078978657722473,
0.43578580021858215,
0.6946068406105042,
0.40778848528862,
-0.1738722324371338,
-0.6093041300773621,
-0.8865852952003479,
-0.9693511724472046,
1.1689300537109375,
0.638177216053009,
-0.2101830691099167,
-0.0534810796380043,
0.13171973824501038,
-0.4429473876953125,
0.3581661283969879,
-0.39044368267059326,
-0.04770239070057869,
0.011914179660379887,
0.026904208585619926,
-0.010573658160865307,
0.1786314845085144,
-0.14551766216754913,
-0.310899019241333,
1.0918405055999756,
-0.3132858872413635,
0.13069306313991547,
0.08482661098241806,
-0.20160074532032013,
-0.4003932774066925,
0.10692695528268814,
0.379250705242157,
0.9530858993530273,
-0.4497641623020172,
0.2313523143529892,
0.25038132071495056,
-0.1487027108669281,
0.2873592972755432,
0.045946959406137466,
-0.1171763464808464,
0.1788296401500702,
0.3558843433856964,
0.6229072213172913,
0.507000207901001,
-0.7742653489112854,
0.46684956550598145,
0.021633150056004524,
-0.36831134557724,
-0.4814797341823578,
0.07218697667121887,
0.09388541430234909,
0.20919454097747803,
0.4315282106399536,
0.07270728796720505,
0.023649921640753746,
-0.5432857275009155,
0.6224793195724487,
0.5120171308517456,
-0.5103954672813416,
-0.12324906885623932,
0.7313318848609924,
-0.2745184302330017,
-0.22065980732440948,
0.693798840045929,
-0.41181129217147827,
-0.2906959354877472,
0.5694777965545654,
0.09054375439882278,
0.6755881309509277,
-0.2625570595264435,
0.3409348726272583,
0.27447810769081116,
0.4751225709915161,
-0.38183024525642395,
0.15732866525650024,
-0.11834865808486938,
-0.5176344513893127,
-0.8031103014945984,
-0.563177227973938,
-0.9030079245567322,
-0.18501514196395874,
-0.5431792736053467,
0.3277532756328583,
-0.8798941969871521,
-0.08366074413061142,
0.05395803600549698,
0.14349530637264252,
-0.38211846351623535,
0.25939029455184937,
0.2268047332763672,
0.6825432777404785,
-1.0087448358535767,
0.9874182343482971,
0.5172513723373413,
-0.5756667852401733,
-0.6986920237541199,
-0.344041109085083,
0.2709290683269501,
-1.0671403408050537,
0.40808719396591187,
0.1457466185092926,
-0.102408766746521,
-0.02544737607240677,
-0.3328891098499298,
-0.785120964050293,
0.9451186656951904,
0.5397486686706543,
-0.6221567988395691,
-0.19607189297676086,
-0.10620491206645966,
0.5489726066589355,
-0.16399599611759186,
0.8633524775505066,
0.6725882887840271,
0.4926453232765198,
0.7438594698905945,
-0.7969879508018494,
-0.13377909362316132,
-0.10637430846691132,
-0.029131295159459114,
0.4209805428981781,
-0.03929604962468147,
0.7439331412315369,
-0.26536428928375244,
-0.060530904680490494,
-0.4287751615047455,
0.4553378224372864,
0.7174997925758362,
0.43978750705718994,
0.28289365768432617,
0.6048070788383484,
0.5909939408302307,
-0.057115159928798676,
0.9177876710891724,
-0.3865928649902344,
0.5578305721282959,
1.1226232051849365,
-0.3133755624294281,
0.49448341131210327,
0.537634551525116,
-0.10920635610818863,
0.21370051801204681,
0.6249721050262451,
0.1525428742170334,
0.27803632616996765,
0.4233096241950989,
-0.10917899012565613,
-0.48416778445243835,
0.10174322128295898,
-0.05426989868283272,
-0.04807291924953461,
0.4413767457008362,
-0.26821914315223694,
-0.6772638559341431,
-0.23184126615524292,
0.5641000270843506,
0.03575368970632553,
-0.4519280195236206,
0.5662076473236084,
0.45523685216903687,
-0.5994813442230225,
0.42890554666519165,
-0.002997739240527153,
0.44787168502807617,
-0.7573351860046387,
-0.26774629950523376,
-0.2637908160686493,
0.2928108870983124,
-0.329342782497406,
-0.7504202127456665,
0.5290526151657104,
0.07254315912723541,
0.3856627345085144,
-0.7070803046226501,
0.17505517601966858,
-0.2380073219537735,
-0.7209165692329407,
0.2656691074371338,
0.5886369943618774,
0.20092520117759705,
-0.2973051369190216,
-0.8420659303665161,
-0.12521177530288696,
-0.1775607466697693,
-0.5531234741210938,
0.21297793090343475,
0.6408010721206665,
-0.5189402103424072,
0.7920001745223999,
0.885108232498169,
0.20186252892017365,
-0.08318384736776352,
-0.10733982920646667,
0.7262483239173889,
-0.702705979347229,
-0.2709803581237793,
-1.119484782218933,
0.23963643610477448,
-0.014795791357755661,
-0.08871185779571533,
0.7195190191268921,
0.49914681911468506,
0.6692534685134888,
0.3257004916667938,
0.7222945690155029,
0.28998664021492004,
0.2751624584197998,
-0.39588749408721924,
0.48003679513931274,
-0.29379403591156006,
0.5084521174430847,
-0.5110861659049988,
-1.2269878387451172,
-0.6408071517944336,
0.9985630512237549,
-0.5468961000442505,
0.08880383521318436,
0.9056301712989807,
0.8180767893791199,
-0.38218727707862854,
-0.07472215592861176,
0.41437333822250366,
0.04926099255681038,
0.6082258224487305,
0.7547920346260071,
0.5205157399177551,
-0.17549338936805725,
0.4167865514755249,
-0.1672762632369995,
-0.24837486445903778,
-0.023336904123425484,
-0.9667707681655884,
-0.90000319480896,
-0.03267749771475792,
-0.41167083382606506,
-0.2998184561729431,
0.19109028577804565,
1.0608811378479004,
0.7710879445075989,
-0.8795062899589539,
-0.4031214416027069,
-0.47063687443733215,
0.16218183934688568,
-0.1033623218536377,
-0.14752598106861115,
0.274393767118454,
-0.558872401714325,
-0.4119134247303009,
0.4949236810207367,
0.3514166474342346,
-0.2169162482023239,
-0.35515859723091125,
-0.09358161687850952,
-0.29516324400901794,
0.3728926479816437,
0.28954482078552246,
0.3409130275249481,
-0.5529645085334778,
-0.10673727095127106,
-0.1724485456943512,
-0.008495052345097065,
0.3269954323768616,
0.6328372359275818,
-0.6632885336875916,
0.626144528388977,
0.08072494715452194,
0.549473226070404,
1.0395864248275757,
-0.13355079293251038,
0.5035650134086609,
-0.49968230724334717,
0.0476670004427433,
0.4424055814743042,
0.3016105592250824,
0.19828380644321442,
-0.08047035336494446,
0.7640811800956726,
0.26513344049453735,
-0.3148321807384491,
-0.8902707099914551,
0.2174241542816162,
-0.7206498980522156,
-0.05800734460353851,
1.0066170692443848,
-0.37471064925193787,
-0.3327125310897827,
-0.03360620141029358,
-0.2512414753437042,
0.25387388467788696,
-0.6831865310668945,
0.6893903613090515,
0.7143564820289612,
-0.4299381375312805,
-0.3872045576572418,
-1.0301494598388672,
0.49686700105667114,
0.4145495295524597,
-0.8989706039428711,
-0.12805630266666412,
0.4086228907108307,
0.02507307007908821,
0.09634429216384888,
0.8709741830825806,
-0.1921192854642868,
0.21820610761642456,
-0.11465161293745041,
0.31388041377067566,
-0.34702417254447937,
-0.38655319809913635,
-0.495487242937088,
0.31258532404899597,
0.16782191395759583,
-0.04205596074461937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03548v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03548v4
|
MAmmoTH2: Scaling Instructions from the Web
| 2024-05-06T15:11:38 | 2024-05-23T16:34:35 |
Xiang Yue, Tuney Zheng, Ge Zhang, Wenhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction tuning improves the reasoning abilities of large language models
(LLMs), with data quality and scalability being the crucial factors. Most
instruction tuning data come from human crowd-sourcing or GPT-4 distillation.
We propose a paradigm to efficiently harvest 10 million naturally existing
instruction data from the pre-training web corpus to enhance LLM reasoning. Our
approach involves (1) recalling relevant documents, (2) extracting
instruction-response pairs, and (3) refining the extracted pairs using
open-source LLMs. Fine-tuning base LLMs on this dataset, we build MAmmoTH2
models, which significantly boost performance on reasoning benchmarks. Notably,
MAmmoTH2-7B's (Mistral) performance increases from 11% to 36.7% on MATH and
from 36% to 68.4% on GSM8K without training on any in-domain data. Further
training MAmmoTH2 on public instruction tuning datasets yields MAmmoTH2-Plus,
achieving state-of-the-art performance on several reasoning and chatbot
benchmarks. Our work demonstrates how to harvest large-scale, high-quality
instruction data without costly human annotation or GPT-4 distillation,
providing a new paradigm for building better instruction tuning data.
|
[
-0.41170424222946167,
-0.7565457820892334,
0.2889108657836914,
-0.06746400147676468,
-0.3700768053531647,
-0.28794682025909424,
-0.41437608003616333,
-0.28596416115760803,
-0.22401626408100128,
0.7885410785675049,
-0.5773738026618958,
-0.3475877642631531,
-0.7295093536376953,
-0.07029309868812561,
-0.12404202669858932,
0.9032977819442749,
0.3306269347667694,
0.10977105796337128,
-0.4412497580051422,
0.15631446242332458,
-0.28788867592811584,
-0.2978453040122986,
-0.5589144229888916,
-0.152019202709198,
0.4090060591697693,
0.754996120929718,
0.6360567212104797,
1.4458256959915161,
0.4873944818973541,
0.31271490454673767,
0.15754778683185577,
0.671566903591156,
-0.8545113801956177,
-0.09651222079992294,
-0.15842735767364502,
-0.6781537532806396,
-0.6619377732276917,
0.26605331897735596,
0.5042367577552795,
0.40737074613571167,
-0.3102022111415863,
0.5232880711555481,
0.12262742966413498,
0.8757066130638123,
-0.550521969795227,
0.3629050850868225,
-0.8896903395652771,
-0.36216190457344055,
-0.3425181806087494,
-0.2919727861881256,
-0.5704945921897888,
-0.5098068118095398,
0.07044628262519836,
-0.928658664226532,
0.32291945815086365,
0.09381292015314102,
0.6489331722259521,
0.5199998021125793,
-0.1882585883140564,
-0.6263288259506226,
-0.40331748127937317,
0.9669522047042847,
-0.6293267011642456,
0.23331113159656525,
0.852904736995697,
0.28440484404563904,
-0.13605687022209167,
-0.7842227220535278,
-0.31728166341781616,
0.08303286135196686,
0.10416388511657715,
0.06950630247592926,
-0.18279683589935303,
-0.20797017216682434,
0.4832105040550232,
0.49981963634490967,
-0.4427032172679901,
0.271768182516098,
-0.6114051938056946,
-0.17077915370464325,
0.543941080570221,
0.1445518136024475,
-0.027634114027023315,
0.14699843525886536,
-0.15557081997394562,
-0.35448548197746277,
-0.922261655330658,
-0.12947866320610046,
0.6101274490356445,
0.22930888831615448,
0.05630054324865341,
0.3558901846408844,
-0.1541232317686081,
1.0022603273391724,
0.19158296287059784,
-0.23360422253608704,
-0.07630805671215057,
-0.00444352813065052,
-0.13380175828933716,
0.004870764445513487,
0.3615912199020386,
0.4370063841342926,
0.009967528283596039,
-0.1366576850414276,
-0.2117670625448227,
-0.17235879600048065,
0.499516099691391,
-1.0577895641326904,
-0.47712767124176025,
0.08226604014635086,
-0.38406407833099365,
0.20543615520000458,
0.04426689073443413,
-0.9004361033439636,
-0.40601301193237305,
-0.7466627955436707,
0.3158682584762573,
-0.33873236179351807,
-0.15466415882110596,
0.14605218172073364,
-0.262164443731308,
0.4449996054172516,
0.46288374066352844,
-1.4159468412399292,
0.2161664068698883,
1.2270119190216064,
0.6830583214759827,
-0.18508552014827728,
0.031317923218011856,
-0.6890796422958374,
0.09543456882238388,
-0.3394889533519745,
0.8371215462684631,
-0.5313234329223633,
-0.3888818323612213,
0.14443261921405792,
-0.1435268670320511,
0.0848524421453476,
-1.0203362703323364,
0.6224900484085083,
-0.6940177083015442,
0.18143421411514282,
-0.33554524183273315,
-0.7704913020133972,
-0.10627707093954086,
0.2557346522808075,
-0.7755504250526428,
0.8599163293838501,
0.08850434422492981,
-0.5211387276649475,
0.09229791164398193,
-0.4887183904647827,
-0.5064859390258789,
0.034304361790418625,
0.2073841542005539,
-0.1803281456232071,
0.15508674085140228,
0.38677820563316345,
0.28744789958000183,
-0.7442380785942078,
-0.2805521488189697,
-0.31944477558135986,
-0.38590070605278015,
-0.1402597576379776,
-0.44359561800956726,
0.7266631722450256,
0.34794116020202637,
-0.2762759327888489,
-0.24507059156894684,
-0.8246886730194092,
0.3499884307384491,
-0.022323310375213623,
-0.7022575736045837,
-0.2161054015159607,
0.0923607349395752,
-0.5378576517105103,
-0.17918957769870758,
0.5176355242729187,
-0.23620425164699554,
0.429338663816452,
-0.21656928956508636,
0.648145854473114,
0.7973554730415344,
-0.43033087253570557,
0.4924265742301941,
-0.25679779052734375,
0.29507961869239807,
-0.33918070793151855,
0.12486318498849869,
-0.2165450006723404,
-0.4666179418563843,
-1.0658442974090576,
-0.27732786536216736,
0.1198914647102356,
0.6554612517356873,
-0.7470544576644897,
0.3867517411708832,
-0.36682406067848206,
-0.5749364495277405,
-0.8625548481941223,
0.3380487859249115,
0.5328975915908813,
0.6259310841560364,
0.5178317427635193,
0.10984298586845398,
-0.43762490153312683,
-0.9028286337852478,
-0.2368737906217575,
-0.11605540663003922,
-0.45864951610565186,
0.473229318857193,
0.08996352553367615,
-0.12134817987680435,
0.6503991484642029,
-0.6399632096290588,
-0.026408152654767036,
0.10540001839399338,
0.29079335927963257,
0.24618704617023468,
0.39099934697151184,
-0.0705370306968689,
-0.6259981989860535,
-0.24032217264175415,
-0.008007470518350601,
-0.7244584560394287,
-0.14105862379074097,
0.18438959121704102,
-0.37304019927978516,
0.13033317029476166,
0.3662804067134857,
-0.6285847425460815,
-0.0968947783112526,
0.5339792966842651,
0.12991134822368622,
0.3649475574493408,
-0.3844256103038788,
0.09607602655887604,
-1.0964891910552979,
-0.3013278543949127,
-0.13656926155090332,
0.011597687378525734,
-0.25985631346702576,
0.1836135983467102,
0.22571280598640442,
0.17357103526592255,
-0.30419790744781494,
0.23917986452579498,
-0.7187604308128357,
-0.0035731063690036535,
-0.37122949957847595,
0.0905316174030304,
-0.005548792891204357,
0.30921027064323425,
-0.11757821589708328,
1.0709033012390137,
0.4843396544456482,
-0.6241298317909241,
0.5262373089790344,
0.13521113991737366,
-0.47869810461997986,
0.4374825060367584,
-0.5890214443206787,
0.6764259934425354,
0.28118428587913513,
0.21646668016910553,
-0.6283252239227295,
-0.4728657901287079,
-0.07666326314210892,
-0.3357034921646118,
0.35635140538215637,
-0.43933436274528503,
-0.5764325857162476,
-0.402647465467453,
-0.24154981970787048,
-0.12482638657093048,
0.8155530095100403,
-0.8844392895698547,
0.4763393700122833,
0.6351151466369629,
0.007713248487561941,
-0.4524780213832855,
-0.4214402735233307,
-0.053470782935619354,
-0.30371540784835815,
-0.6285470128059387,
-0.051056310534477234,
0.03946268558502197,
-0.2709069550037384,
-0.19420406222343445,
-0.21618099510669708,
-0.22248701751232147,
0.04364407807588577,
0.21775995194911957,
0.2488662153482437,
-0.33736732602119446,
0.07338441908359528,
0.1921931803226471,
-0.14519532024860382,
0.27578407526016235,
-0.8757203221321106,
0.30733227729797363,
-0.1169867068529129,
-0.11634941399097443,
-0.5776433348655701,
0.04225347563624382,
0.4041878581047058,
-0.10955159366130829,
0.4459623694419861,
0.7246466279029846,
-0.26191645860671997,
-0.2274860292673111,
-0.6772385835647583,
-0.38520801067352295,
-0.5360848903656006,
0.26662856340408325,
-0.20396435260772705,
-1.0751672983169556,
-0.10191670805215836,
-0.5448503494262695,
0.39925846457481384,
0.49648571014404297,
0.809432864189148,
-0.18516334891319275,
1.0468534231185913,
0.30794304609298706,
0.06045311689376831,
0.3434053063392639,
-0.4233728051185608,
-0.2295018881559372,
-0.9218973517417908,
-0.14140835404396057,
-0.5376564264297485,
-0.2885426878929138,
-0.5266385078430176,
-0.8412489891052246,
0.3412551283836365,
0.26670390367507935,
-0.23881515860557556,
0.3544740080833435,
-0.722582995891571,
0.7284255027770996,
0.8894396424293518,
0.080080546438694,
0.025614632293581963,
0.28148841857910156,
0.2735579013824463,
0.0702870711684227,
-0.5057355165481567,
-0.7966314554214478,
1.2346357107162476,
0.007286302745342255,
0.7575759887695312,
0.25863516330718994,
0.3901853561401367,
0.32073479890823364,
0.3090587258338928,
-0.5979581475257874,
0.49374809861183167,
-0.3249480426311493,
-0.6888026595115662,
-0.3498004376888275,
-0.651609480381012,
-1.0527371168136597,
0.16914717853069305,
-0.07913433760404587,
-0.7071589231491089,
-0.5093556046485901,
0.5695658922195435,
-0.23924079537391663,
0.19335511326789856,
-1.1442538499832153,
0.6106069087982178,
-0.16397109627723694,
-0.6070902943611145,
-0.5438975095748901,
-0.6329893469810486,
0.4470635950565338,
0.05060156062245369,
0.17814557254314423,
-0.1236177384853363,
-0.05169985070824623,
0.7467302680015564,
-0.6332895159721375,
0.751555860042572,
-0.2038627564907074,
-0.25586995482444763,
0.6494967341423035,
0.12075064331293106,
0.6448579430580139,
0.17855827510356903,
-0.18130718171596527,
0.3793753385543823,
-0.17150036990642548,
-0.5710605382919312,
-0.730688214302063,
0.9481254816055298,
-1.1466398239135742,
-1.1110223531723022,
0.08181082457304001,
-0.6028385162353516,
-0.27343428134918213,
0.046424467116594315,
0.2618979811668396,
0.4702557921409607,
0.14140544831752777,
0.42817723751068115,
0.888922393321991,
0.04113689810037613,
0.19072136282920837,
0.5159621238708496,
0.3037220537662506,
-0.5144025683403015,
1.169549584388733,
0.11070076376199722,
0.3181486129760742,
0.6457254886627197,
0.315168172121048,
-0.4864751994609833,
-0.4344349801540375,
-1.0555778741836548,
0.00013427503290586174,
-0.5309898853302002,
-0.23884719610214233,
-0.5155162811279297,
0.09220536053180695,
-0.35067281126976013,
0.009402248077094555,
-0.37679314613342285,
-0.571900486946106,
-0.5965484380722046,
-0.007655848283320665,
0.5525225400924683,
0.6909911036491394,
-0.19693051278591156,
0.46866586804389954,
-0.9730237126350403,
0.13025864958763123,
0.7358416318893433,
0.05840360000729561,
0.06656718254089355,
-0.8645109534263611,
-0.4398004412651062,
0.30018800497055054,
-0.36064472794532776,
-0.402253657579422,
0.14739704132080078,
0.2137523889541626,
0.24735228717327118,
0.6414902210235596,
-0.21302853524684906,
1.0381368398666382,
-0.7073529362678528,
0.7620142102241516,
0.07518136501312256,
-0.7877792716026306,
0.5595956444740295,
-0.3987097144126892,
0.3511066734790802,
0.35564419627189636,
0.4348508417606354,
-0.16331912577152252,
0.07767180353403091,
-0.3304418921470642,
-0.6685380339622498,
0.9933164119720459,
0.003354655811563134,
0.2786921560764313,
0.013923007063567638,
0.6244342923164368,
0.39408019185066223,
-0.0592784620821476,
0.08071403205394745,
-0.05165858566761017,
-0.23978880047798157,
-0.05545608326792717,
-0.05633331462740898,
-0.19894681870937347,
-0.2864542007446289,
-0.37801262736320496,
0.6851089596748352,
-0.21817895770072937,
0.1458657681941986,
-0.3489812910556793,
-0.22477716207504272,
-0.09983526915311813,
-0.1111689880490303,
0.5643303990364075,
0.7685459852218628,
-0.0529460608959198,
0.3652784526348114,
0.21250185370445251,
-0.7260751128196716,
-0.16137894988059998,
0.04205833747982979,
-0.0044616032391786575,
-0.5424457788467407,
0.5619469881057739,
0.7948301434516907,
0.03359753638505936,
-0.6535135507583618,
0.07947050034999847,
-0.09396703541278839,
-0.07644729316234589,
-0.14436258375644684,
0.5258914828300476,
0.4149271249771118,
0.21252216398715973,
0.3199264705181122,
-0.2079300433397293,
0.116193987429142,
-0.25119858980178833,
0.20984292030334473,
0.189887136220932,
-0.23720598220825195,
-0.48225539922714233,
0.6481131315231323,
0.31669583916664124,
-0.4724245071411133,
1.0716233253479004,
-0.2805525064468384,
-0.017482150346040726,
0.6316142082214355,
0.8102303147315979,
0.4038539528846741,
0.010096857324242592,
0.03589021414518356,
0.6919587254524231,
0.20917244255542755,
-0.23394283652305603,
0.020807892084121704,
-0.13964882493019104,
-0.5168300867080688,
-0.4288770854473114,
-0.6152601838111877,
-0.572089672088623,
0.03901294991374016,
-0.8640482425689697,
0.0874188020825386,
-0.5619815587997437,
0.007539901416748762,
-0.08986562490463257,
0.11470977216959,
-0.5650870203971863,
-0.013860677368938923,
0.2971319258213043,
0.8038151860237122,
-0.34570738673210144,
0.9584335684776306,
0.5537452697753906,
-0.03739990293979645,
-0.9406713843345642,
-0.3300964832305908,
0.40773263573646545,
-1.2281837463378906,
0.3374217450618744,
0.281389445066452,
-0.08814030885696411,
0.2326851189136505,
-0.7027314901351929,
-0.8385763764381409,
1.2224879264831543,
0.6063926815986633,
-0.8087380528450012,
0.16411465406417847,
0.05448189750313759,
0.4105868339538574,
-0.14607538282871246,
0.3554399311542511,
0.8650442361831665,
0.41339704394340515,
0.41625702381134033,
-0.570504903793335,
-0.14547665417194366,
-0.20908285677433014,
-0.18621045351028442,
0.329863041639328,
-0.7323815822601318,
0.941472053527832,
-0.25408288836479187,
-0.12390663474798203,
0.007024802267551422,
0.6710764765739441,
0.20744816958904266,
0.033787962049245834,
0.4736417531967163,
0.9774353504180908,
1.1751160621643066,
-0.1375068575143814,
1.1153314113616943,
-0.3148917853832245,
0.17319533228874207,
1.0776029825210571,
-0.13342300057411194,
0.8677143454551697,
0.12548957765102386,
-0.21838316321372986,
0.42215654253959656,
0.839797854423523,
0.08080808818340302,
0.3999529182910919,
0.3353787064552307,
-0.1887509971857071,
-0.5609934329986572,
-0.01277882419526577,
-0.29938805103302,
0.5618953704833984,
0.605570912361145,
-0.04514795169234276,
-0.20675508677959442,
-0.4756135046482086,
0.3480663597583771,
-0.03802720829844475,
-0.4007025361061096,
0.9072551727294922,
-0.0005510002374649048,
-0.9577705264091492,
0.9616379141807556,
0.0379626639187336,
0.4422314465045929,
-0.4543362855911255,
-0.29116663336753845,
-0.23052023351192474,
0.3346593677997589,
-0.07795214653015137,
-0.4073638319969177,
0.07882728427648544,
0.25199902057647705,
-0.29432788491249084,
-0.298970103263855,
0.49364346265792847,
-0.25227048993110657,
-0.46535342931747437,
-0.08294317871332169,
0.4937937259674072,
0.5197249054908752,
-0.03104725107550621,
-0.5324671864509583,
0.06975390017032623,
0.0623575896024704,
-0.2550908327102661,
0.5599383115768433,
0.7085891366004944,
-0.08231176435947418,
0.46387067437171936,
1.0108506679534912,
-0.09888246655464172,
0.23240523040294647,
-0.16921091079711914,
1.0009653568267822,
-0.3281458020210266,
-0.13423392176628113,
-0.9438114762306213,
0.08191491663455963,
-0.21559803187847137,
-0.5189681053161621,
0.682494580745697,
0.7481258511543274,
0.8991010189056396,
-0.006501337513327599,
0.4922175705432892,
0.002455436624586582,
0.4619411826133728,
-0.6062865853309631,
0.4914931058883667,
-0.3242180049419403,
0.09655138105154037,
0.6112322807312012,
-0.8733916878700256,
-0.029352931305766106,
0.40068519115448,
-0.30953025817871094,
-0.27947404980659485,
0.4442911148071289,
0.9601668119430542,
-0.019118038937449455,
0.24731123447418213,
0.11971331387758255,
0.2296445220708847,
0.20556576550006866,
0.544276773929596,
0.7525314092636108,
-0.02738836407661438,
0.679684042930603,
0.05467769876122475,
-0.5717983245849609,
-0.3026801645755768,
-0.7342507839202881,
-0.8958185911178589,
-0.4040474593639374,
-0.04013196751475334,
-0.1909678429365158,
0.10521303862333298,
0.8892203569412231,
0.9395684003829956,
-0.5670024156570435,
-0.23432360589504242,
0.15501144528388977,
0.14240123331546783,
-0.38511908054351807,
-0.13781018555164337,
0.4992164373397827,
-0.5098788738250732,
-0.8705390095710754,
0.5141306519508362,
0.24717381596565247,
-0.42793577909469604,
-0.18035046756267548,
-0.2074008584022522,
0.17724493145942688,
0.18880605697631836,
0.732131838798523,
0.20870335400104523,
-0.6661078929901123,
-0.20728185772895813,
0.05629201605916023,
-0.18591339886188507,
0.07338759303092957,
0.8352100849151611,
-0.5278237462043762,
0.5408053994178772,
0.27423155307769775,
0.9063053727149963,
0.5814829468727112,
0.2196291834115982,
0.355930358171463,
-0.38103222846984863,
0.11636944115161896,
0.03454609587788582,
0.03587228059768677,
0.35672879219055176,
-0.3117895722389221,
0.4920338988304138,
0.16202613711357117,
-0.6864215135574341,
-0.4837203025817871,
0.14376051723957062,
-0.8096892833709717,
-0.13220027089118958,
1.4077255725860596,
-0.42097264528274536,
-0.37442219257354736,
0.1848386526107788,
-0.07447470724582672,
0.33620625734329224,
-0.40300658345222473,
1.1119295358657837,
0.65263432264328,
-0.13798153400421143,
0.07289945334196091,
-0.7084041237831116,
0.38249239325523376,
0.18261289596557617,
-0.9842356443405151,
0.2618870735168457,
0.7143672704696655,
0.09567663073539734,
-0.023371607065200806,
0.20436641573905945,
-0.09190510213375092,
0.18000763654708862,
0.28536972403526306,
0.0019241664558649063,
-0.30199986696243286,
-0.17151403427124023,
0.09967954456806183,
0.20754894614219666,
-0.014748801477253437,
-0.27939853072166443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06686v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06686v1
|
Word2World: Generating Stories and Worlds through Large Language Models
| 2024-05-06T14:21:52 | 2024-05-06T14:21:52 |
Muhammad U. Nasir, Steven James, Julian Togelius
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have proven their worth across a diverse
spectrum of disciplines. LLMs have shown great potential in Procedural Content
Generation (PCG) as well, but directly generating a level through a pre-trained
LLM is still challenging. This work introduces Word2World, a system that
enables LLMs to procedurally design playable games through stories, without any
task-specific fine-tuning. Word2World leverages the abilities of LLMs to create
diverse content and extract information. Combining these abilities, LLMs can
create a story for the game, design narrative, and place tiles in appropriate
places to create coherent worlds and playable games. We test Word2World with
different LLMs and perform a thorough ablation study to validate each step. We
open-source the code at https://github.com/umair-nasir14/Word2World.
|
[
-0.195709228515625,
-0.8005897998809814,
0.6725879311561584,
0.336203008890152,
-0.3468017280101776,
0.3313547372817993,
-0.36574310064315796,
-0.6561760902404785,
0.0123292813077569,
0.6654476523399353,
-0.7774903178215027,
-0.6717671155929565,
-0.43368953466415405,
-0.0583697147667408,
-0.20344965159893036,
0.7444542050361633,
-0.036850154399871826,
-0.2558257281780243,
-0.4451534152030945,
0.15397444367408752,
-0.4393921196460724,
-0.1458878219127655,
-0.4826726019382477,
-0.5146985054016113,
0.5483834147453308,
0.5025338530540466,
0.678078293800354,
0.7611778378486633,
0.45764288306236267,
0.2980146110057831,
0.0027001032140105963,
0.6690195202827454,
-0.811857283115387,
0.5576537251472473,
-0.13228417932987213,
-0.3802546262741089,
-0.14194969832897186,
-0.0966484397649765,
0.2776815891265869,
0.47078949213027954,
-0.18900740146636963,
0.24284672737121582,
0.14146080613136292,
0.3944377899169922,
-0.16358697414398193,
0.11695235222578049,
-0.5903331637382507,
0.3186549246311188,
-0.04847010225057602,
-0.2706255316734314,
-0.14369231462478638,
-0.35068702697753906,
-0.03803081437945366,
-0.8860069513320923,
0.09059250354766846,
0.40602073073387146,
0.42701098322868347,
0.008571668528020382,
-0.15526191890239716,
-0.841905951499939,
-0.9322794675827026,
0.607917308807373,
-0.6674600839614868,
0.16357728838920593,
0.12034448981285095,
-0.00983879528939724,
-0.49230220913887024,
-0.697766900062561,
-0.8338122963905334,
-0.1547098010778427,
0.3522321283817291,
0.19331137835979462,
-0.07128006964921951,
0.08726969361305237,
0.4399993419647217,
0.5073655843734741,
-0.7407726645469666,
0.36921408772468567,
-0.4064699411392212,
-0.23135389387607574,
0.6626710891723633,
0.38905537128448486,
0.5107558369636536,
0.03765437379479408,
-0.2667854130268097,
0.12570281326770782,
-1.155056118965149,
0.06887911260128021,
0.7233805656433105,
0.25295525789260864,
-0.12462399154901505,
1.0672094821929932,
0.24899686872959137,
0.513615608215332,
-0.2905385494232178,
-0.7618898749351501,
-0.023456066846847534,
0.027013005688786507,
0.11843140423297882,
0.043902572244405746,
0.7412891983985901,
0.6034759879112244,
0.0922958254814148,
-0.33448630571365356,
-0.3154611885547638,
0.2977139949798584,
0.2827579975128174,
-0.9711525440216064,
0.0962458997964859,
0.48568761348724365,
-0.39156776666641235,
-0.4090260863304138,
-0.15583355724811554,
-0.5446491241455078,
-0.8048663139343262,
-0.2559129297733307,
0.18927885591983795,
-0.41615960001945496,
-0.3798232078552246,
0.173092320561409,
-0.6462081670761108,
0.18908661603927612,
0.1735193431377411,
-0.8906741738319397,
0.18311625719070435,
0.9999901652336121,
1.048570156097412,
-0.4170736074447632,
-0.2048289179801941,
-0.44494831562042236,
0.483957439661026,
-0.6617000102996826,
0.7574474811553955,
-0.4187600016593933,
-0.7884129285812378,
0.3703094720840454,
-0.19982272386550903,
0.8563903570175171,
-0.6786195635795593,
0.13308745622634888,
-0.4655286371707916,
0.18705055117607117,
-0.286797434091568,
-0.712731659412384,
0.1787434220314026,
0.5195127725601196,
-0.2835313379764557,
0.7868560552597046,
0.16056647896766663,
-0.5195797085762024,
0.14439041912555695,
-0.48158711194992065,
-0.6349877119064331,
0.46154364943504333,
-0.022125273942947388,
0.10568846762180328,
0.6151911020278931,
-0.2873798906803131,
-0.03420208394527435,
-0.25850561261177063,
0.10784628987312317,
-0.09710264205932617,
-0.4468246400356293,
-0.10534721612930298,
-0.07939489185810089,
0.3744146525859833,
0.3880261778831482,
-0.08744646608829498,
-0.020724918693304062,
-0.6901343464851379,
0.1810094714164734,
0.1583869904279709,
-0.5960325598716736,
-0.07508595287799835,
0.4374820291996002,
0.12895719707012177,
0.5131369829177856,
0.26193180680274963,
-0.8149673938751221,
0.557436466217041,
-0.5032252669334412,
0.4629765450954437,
0.39320605993270874,
-0.029444415122270584,
0.29494717717170715,
-0.4751637876033783,
0.7290216684341431,
-0.11833899468183517,
-0.42265596985816956,
-0.2553587853908539,
-0.5875176787376404,
-0.5780959725379944,
0.08892438560724258,
0.08839699625968933,
0.5956159830093384,
-1.0901422500610352,
0.4498523771762848,
-0.0630183219909668,
-0.677221417427063,
-0.09998249262571335,
0.25824907422065735,
0.2564311623573303,
0.20800592005252838,
0.09227314591407776,
-0.3465360403060913,
-0.7259271740913391,
-0.5010493397712708,
-0.010114902630448341,
-0.3865758180618286,
-0.4675273001194,
0.37618473172187805,
0.181889608502388,
-0.22695806622505188,
0.8981686234474182,
-0.6664721369743347,
-0.2785656750202179,
-0.5323002338409424,
0.16863642632961273,
-0.10448067635297775,
0.29121920466423035,
0.1403483748435974,
-0.2606092095375061,
-0.29104021191596985,
-0.013574700802564621,
-0.8576087355613708,
-0.3118790090084076,
-0.02344868704676628,
-0.11960382759571075,
0.06736735254526138,
0.5232824087142944,
-0.6656979918479919,
0.18849901854991913,
0.7834614515304565,
-0.25480324029922485,
0.5760684609413147,
-0.6036539673805237,
-0.18584628403186798,
-1.0657628774642944,
-0.0970056802034378,
-0.18248845636844635,
-0.19671711325645447,
-0.4280518591403961,
0.3608304560184479,
-0.28853532671928406,
-0.3877643346786499,
-0.44045934081077576,
0.8489500284194946,
-0.617344856262207,
-0.2666347026824951,
-0.6717066168785095,
0.22871799767017365,
0.08673150837421417,
0.2712242007255554,
0.28038331866264343,
0.617096483707428,
0.41823360323905945,
-0.5453878045082092,
0.6282730102539062,
0.4048139154911041,
-0.647261917591095,
0.3085293769836426,
-0.6630399227142334,
0.13695302605628967,
-0.08276169002056122,
0.3256584107875824,
-0.8804357647895813,
-0.23634210228919983,
-0.05098576098680496,
-0.32296431064605713,
-0.07702257484197617,
0.066196508705616,
-0.9392176866531372,
-0.7560533285140991,
-0.12017281353473663,
0.0070465668104588985,
0.9218096733093262,
-0.5337997674942017,
0.18117226660251617,
0.7095487713813782,
-0.3645469844341278,
0.05669277161359787,
-0.9288679361343384,
0.3297732174396515,
-0.1658221036195755,
-0.5922386646270752,
0.5493597984313965,
-0.49655652046203613,
-0.4060518443584442,
-0.2247323840856552,
-0.010312994942069054,
0.05781570076942444,
-0.11773543804883957,
0.4620613157749176,
-0.08925323188304901,
-0.14368483424186707,
0.17267096042633057,
0.2147473692893982,
0.11595697700977325,
0.1504598706960678,
-0.5007136464118958,
0.853917121887207,
0.29443293809890747,
-0.25051718950271606,
0.13158021867275238,
0.48018622398376465,
0.38817864656448364,
-0.27259841561317444,
0.4736911952495575,
0.5172315835952759,
-0.46114805340766907,
-0.6283623576164246,
-0.40383872389793396,
0.17351101338863373,
-0.5637592077255249,
0.463187575340271,
-0.2662156820297241,
-1.1484986543655396,
0.6070268154144287,
-0.27763158082962036,
0.4337565004825592,
0.19958947598934174,
0.8288790583610535,
-0.04239742457866669,
1.0723687410354614,
0.7423270344734192,
0.41561052203178406,
0.07220308482646942,
-0.061641231179237366,
0.27132728695869446,
-0.6617524027824402,
-0.41055434942245483,
-0.1038484200835228,
-0.5358538031578064,
-0.5428145527839661,
-0.6821992993354797,
0.21791388094425201,
0.288385272026062,
-0.1051236242055893,
0.004253406077623367,
-0.35621580481529236,
0.8804506063461304,
0.3858420252799988,
-0.0528598353266716,
0.33880454301834106,
0.3400404155254364,
-0.2980954945087433,
-0.16801096498966217,
-0.5160249471664429,
-0.6545087099075317,
0.8423949480056763,
0.2699892818927765,
0.6950538158416748,
0.3252679407596588,
0.6850069761276245,
0.25499626994132996,
0.08877038210630417,
-0.8700786232948303,
0.5591778755187988,
-0.1977752447128296,
-0.4986700415611267,
-0.3669861853122711,
-0.14601856470108032,
-0.9127197265625,
0.03716691583395004,
-0.4112173318862915,
-0.5169322490692139,
-0.38037797808647156,
-0.12469879537820816,
-0.564850926399231,
0.4134652614593506,
-0.13584136962890625,
0.39272892475128174,
-0.1734500676393509,
-0.4976804256439209,
-0.24164044857025146,
-0.3106507956981659,
0.4375602900981903,
0.027119366452097893,
0.2815907299518585,
-0.09372355788946152,
-0.2819836139678955,
0.2721540927886963,
-0.559895932674408,
0.597350001335144,
-0.16117548942565918,
-0.6590595841407776,
0.7554320693016052,
0.7090551257133484,
0.4042615592479706,
0.2895079255104065,
-0.015247809700667858,
0.11462815850973129,
-0.2694917917251587,
-0.051176298409700394,
-0.19975349307060242,
0.9704834818840027,
-0.7304069995880127,
-0.6101082563400269,
-0.3882296681404114,
-0.9970870018005371,
-0.2956179082393646,
0.2617526054382324,
0.23911379277706146,
0.4665203094482422,
-0.47556599974632263,
0.08459438383579254,
0.667311429977417,
-0.636501133441925,
0.509105384349823,
0.5536091327667236,
-0.5659087300300598,
-0.13545094430446625,
1.0880162715911865,
-0.028162743896245956,
0.119940847158432,
0.11076657474040985,
0.16850917041301727,
-0.36052021384239197,
-0.8476935625076294,
-0.43691331148147583,
-0.04760802164673805,
-0.3271039128303528,
-0.1410176157951355,
-0.5211339592933655,
-0.4537781774997711,
-0.17611466348171234,
-0.15889087319374084,
-0.16529926657676697,
-0.21918778121471405,
-0.1748693436384201,
-0.25701114535331726,
0.12820115685462952,
1.2036141157150269,
-0.3640243411064148,
0.39621502161026,
-0.815061628818512,
0.3809070289134979,
0.26392069458961487,
0.478061318397522,
-0.1908894032239914,
-0.3671308159828186,
0.018883800134062767,
0.10983971506357193,
-0.5233303308486938,
-0.49134379625320435,
0.5823047757148743,
0.12063707411289215,
0.21782679855823517,
0.39892828464508057,
-0.3065241277217865,
0.7065303325653076,
-1.0786398649215698,
1.1609621047973633,
0.3511669635772705,
-0.7515681385993958,
0.43587878346443176,
-0.6541204452514648,
0.44766488671302795,
0.23494026064872742,
0.204484224319458,
-0.9776872396469116,
-0.6403996348381042,
-0.4396238923072815,
-0.792567253112793,
0.6825289130210876,
0.05419072508811951,
0.39759352803230286,
-0.2710717022418976,
0.48018109798431396,
0.4766722619533539,
0.33278799057006836,
-0.5637889504432678,
-0.14471767842769623,
0.019232146441936493,
-0.19671078026294708,
-0.13816587626934052,
-0.5097475051879883,
-0.10278431326150894,
0.16407284140586853,
0.4523604214191437,
-0.09114494174718857,
0.08782367408275604,
-0.10061833262443542,
-0.2571321129798889,
-0.3484107553958893,
-0.11182359606027603,
0.7403552532196045,
0.8533111214637756,
0.15342320501804352,
0.1653045117855072,
-0.02990947850048542,
-0.4421043395996094,
0.13233545422554016,
-0.1940893977880478,
-0.10570914298295975,
-0.12328176945447922,
0.5113887190818787,
0.6782650947570801,
-0.15361464023590088,
-1.00135338306427,
0.41273730993270874,
-0.1383899599313736,
-0.6519128680229187,
-0.3392358422279358,
0.3233635425567627,
0.5434101819992065,
0.33010703325271606,
0.21137821674346924,
-0.2341381162405014,
-0.21375802159309387,
-0.6305108666419983,
0.019060159102082253,
0.41834282875061035,
-0.33417561650276184,
-0.3043278753757477,
0.6003885269165039,
0.3852888345718384,
-0.571901798248291,
0.6962454915046692,
-0.5827386975288391,
-0.19898338615894318,
0.6853472590446472,
1.091019868850708,
0.3817388713359833,
0.13154101371765137,
0.3991096615791321,
0.39396053552627563,
0.23706169426441193,
-0.16027654707431793,
0.49090081453323364,
0.31392183899879456,
-0.7671599388122559,
-0.43612581491470337,
-0.8199930787086487,
-0.431399941444397,
0.39433300495147705,
-0.14569562673568726,
0.21991397440433502,
-0.7712633609771729,
0.2358897477388382,
-0.45255613327026367,
0.20013058185577393,
-0.4828026294708252,
0.00681854085996747,
0.8456039428710938,
0.8939329385757446,
-0.6603055000305176,
0.4207773506641388,
0.6040924787521362,
-0.14728032052516937,
-0.6201896071434021,
-0.0716671347618103,
0.23007594048976898,
-0.8357167840003967,
0.2980358600616455,
0.18104426562786102,
0.3304027318954468,
0.15328218042850494,
-0.6072613596916199,
-0.7189827561378479,
1.2082619667053223,
0.1590181142091751,
-0.9061182141304016,
-0.23955734074115753,
0.6795588731765747,
0.8071540594100952,
-0.5814898014068604,
0.07103530317544937,
0.24003195762634277,
0.31209325790405273,
0.41817599534988403,
-0.5089066028594971,
-0.16650114953517914,
-0.09621505439281464,
0.29103508591651917,
-0.09461072087287903,
-0.5545297861099243,
0.6381042003631592,
-0.42895713448524475,
-0.257976770401001,
0.3806294798851013,
0.7626127004623413,
0.7275914549827576,
-0.0780554935336113,
0.4306879937648773,
0.7770581841468811,
0.8779724836349487,
-0.19517016410827637,
0.9331075549125671,
-0.5992170572280884,
0.00020359607879072428,
0.8846096992492676,
-0.596696138381958,
0.6143525242805481,
0.15845726430416107,
-0.014979596249759197,
0.5972754955291748,
0.7793838381767273,
-0.07445289939641953,
0.4983421266078949,
0.9050365090370178,
-0.3351607024669647,
-0.25284910202026367,
-0.2756778299808502,
-0.4195830821990967,
0.4628535807132721,
0.4628216028213501,
0.05947977304458618,
-0.31302282214164734,
0.017262760549783707,
-0.14998918771743774,
0.07902662456035614,
-0.4113297760486603,
0.7671178579330444,
0.12996840476989746,
-0.7160690426826477,
-0.019544199109077454,
0.1946287304162979,
0.8413935303688049,
-0.8235361576080322,
-0.16905763745307922,
-0.4482804536819458,
0.015950903296470642,
-0.16961610317230225,
-0.7871706485748291,
0.2463655024766922,
0.31390970945358276,
-0.18732774257659912,
-0.4518492519855499,
0.6586296558380127,
-0.8565880060195923,
-0.7576669454574585,
0.06499380618333817,
0.7695666551589966,
0.26942649483680725,
0.0044020116329193115,
-0.3867526054382324,
0.24965456128120422,
-0.11915093660354614,
-0.2365359663963318,
0.33470889925956726,
0.7856007814407349,
0.02660038322210312,
0.3433918058872223,
0.7996860146522522,
0.4472312927246094,
-0.18352080881595612,
0.06630612164735794,
0.5506277084350586,
-0.6064756512641907,
-0.6914377808570862,
-0.7638849020004272,
0.3856240212917328,
0.10707143694162369,
-0.3090464472770691,
0.6414737105369568,
0.9869332313537598,
0.5991454720497131,
0.02311246283352375,
0.9867398738861084,
-0.3279237151145935,
0.3382338583469391,
-0.3572233021259308,
0.7449234127998352,
-0.49251610040664673,
0.19474062323570251,
0.12896153330802917,
-1.2296642065048218,
-0.2467842698097229,
0.3537091612815857,
0.31459230184555054,
-0.2757500410079956,
0.650550901889801,
0.7731638550758362,
0.08769810199737549,
-0.0029606930911540985,
0.4085937440395355,
0.22339622676372528,
0.5948333144187927,
0.6129424571990967,
1.0122814178466797,
-0.0020863963291049004,
0.5589357018470764,
0.04154512286186218,
-0.18873164057731628,
0.2940274178981781,
-1.0563632249832153,
-1.0754631757736206,
-0.26730242371559143,
-0.08999109268188477,
-0.5290098190307617,
0.047942113131284714,
0.7306456565856934,
0.44105643033981323,
-0.5036396384239197,
-0.4381704032421112,
-0.38898444175720215,
-0.11069823056459427,
0.17578230798244476,
-0.1656559407711029,
-0.09515046328306198,
-0.2712876796722412,
-0.7546017169952393,
0.6114587783813477,
0.34318819642066956,
-0.04280395805835724,
-0.701854944229126,
-0.17598959803581238,
0.32958272099494934,
0.13018959760665894,
0.8292880058288574,
0.19011268019676208,
-0.5892273783683777,
-0.35876214504241943,
-0.17342162132263184,
-0.2794893980026245,
0.022793468087911606,
0.9679359197616577,
-0.6001984477043152,
0.22960343956947327,
0.5679488182067871,
0.43288204073905945,
0.41289669275283813,
-0.1679334044456482,
0.7389879822731018,
-0.8407073020935059,
0.34304454922676086,
0.18563586473464966,
0.1982078105211258,
0.3570503294467926,
-0.18953591585159302,
0.43044495582580566,
0.21652540564537048,
-0.4106193780899048,
-0.6894297003746033,
0.3867197334766388,
-0.6528780460357666,
-0.4229125678539276,
1.6861134767532349,
-0.010477093979716301,
-0.20912177860736847,
0.1440115123987198,
-0.2892172932624817,
0.13590773940086365,
-0.04598863795399666,
0.6251607537269592,
1.0733301639556885,
0.009983868338167667,
0.1744372695684433,
-0.4921644628047943,
0.5355047583580017,
-0.2345706820487976,
-0.8674939274787903,
0.14059463143348694,
0.8042157888412476,
0.3638010323047638,
0.1601676493883133,
0.5712617039680481,
-0.09480222314596176,
0.0029012132436037064,
0.20669086277484894,
0.44589921832084656,
-0.5450479984283447,
-0.3244408965110779,
-0.052890703082084656,
0.26185664534568787,
0.037120964378118515,
0.33104759454727173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03452v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03452v2
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) as Agents for Augmented Democracy
| 2024-05-06T13:23:57 | 2024-05-07T08:57:18 |
Jairo Gudiño-Rosero, Umberto Grandi, César A. Hidalgo
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We explore the capabilities of an augmented democracy system built on
off-the-shelf LLMs fine-tuned on data summarizing individual preferences across
67 policy proposals collected during the 2022 Brazilian presidential elections.
We use a train-test cross-validation setup to estimate the accuracy with which
the LLMs predict both: a subject's individual political choices and the
aggregate preferences of the full sample of participants. At the individual
level, the accuracy of the out of sample predictions lie in the range 69%-76%
and are significantly better at predicting the preferences of liberal and
college educated participants. At the population level, we aggregate
preferences using an adaptation of the Borda score and compare the ranking of
policy proposals obtained from a probabilistic sample of participants and from
data augmented using LLMs. We find that the augmented data predicts the
preferences of the full population of participants better than probabilistic
samples alone when these represent less than 30% to 40% of the total
population. These results indicate that LLMs are potentially useful for the
construction of systems of augmented democracy.
|
[
-0.7519842386245728,
-0.9720034003257751,
0.6605938673019409,
0.15978138148784637,
0.043639760464429855,
0.4106474816799164,
-0.5613946914672852,
-0.230535626411438,
0.4598860442638397,
0.8521000146865845,
0.09458395838737488,
-0.22537937760353088,
-0.6835052371025085,
0.16886869072914124,
-0.3803264796733856,
0.8276512622833252,
0.1376594454050064,
0.0899701789021492,
-0.13034358620643616,
0.2631743252277374,
0.0940200462937355,
-0.4002510607242584,
-0.44087353348731995,
-0.6455800533294678,
0.3975859582424164,
0.38496237993240356,
1.0688393115997314,
0.4725933372974396,
0.12942522764205933,
0.26849186420440674,
-0.07325360178947449,
0.4516170918941498,
-0.4536226689815521,
-0.2656470239162445,
-0.3562380075454712,
-0.337371289730072,
-0.6666739583015442,
0.19054263830184937,
0.7799668312072754,
0.6216261386871338,
-0.06797522306442261,
-0.05171515792608261,
0.18970687687397003,
0.4617747664451599,
-0.6578788161277771,
0.2486460953950882,
-0.656512439250946,
-0.2599217891693115,
0.12262886017560959,
-0.28326261043548584,
-0.24954219162464142,
-0.3044665455818176,
0.13685211539268494,
-0.19000402092933655,
-0.12495176494121552,
0.07691902667284012,
0.5063676834106445,
-0.1003972738981247,
-0.5479719042778015,
-0.36587655544281006,
-0.8079267740249634,
0.4993526339530945,
-0.5877082347869873,
0.4710415005683899,
0.6488168835639954,
0.08373360335826874,
-0.6062535047531128,
-0.4448910057544708,
-0.8886144757270813,
-0.35689210891723633,
0.1965310424566269,
-0.0011241446482017636,
-0.07381672412157059,
0.49376076459884644,
0.03783714398741722,
0.35205671191215515,
-0.43531563878059387,
0.26084697246551514,
-0.4134957492351532,
-0.16187603771686554,
0.7453197836875916,
0.016408933326601982,
-0.07866262644529343,
-0.2763415575027466,
-0.3040887713432312,
0.22049756348133087,
-0.8034254312515259,
-0.06050402671098709,
0.6603476405143738,
0.5459651350975037,
-0.16139186918735504,
0.845901370048523,
-0.28684303164482117,
1.1550458669662476,
0.12176275998353958,
-0.27452555298805237,
-0.036456212401390076,
-0.18539705872535706,
-0.44343313574790955,
-0.307515025138855,
1.0201040506362915,
0.017199426889419556,
0.3730353116989136,
-0.018474819138646126,
-0.5143888592720032,
0.050066642463207245,
-0.063786081969738,
-0.6370346546173096,
-0.22742219269275665,
0.42446932196617126,
-0.26532217860221863,
-0.08577366918325424,
0.04241694137454033,
-0.6429948806762695,
-0.6677796244621277,
-0.6017348170280457,
0.5781010985374451,
-0.07193447649478912,
-0.1178760752081871,
0.08959108591079712,
0.28472042083740234,
-0.002759549068287015,
0.6088392734527588,
-0.8948863744735718,
0.3468938171863556,
0.8912479877471924,
0.8024599552154541,
-0.3096330761909485,
-0.20048321783542633,
-0.6774835586547852,
0.00998593494296074,
-0.6079994440078735,
1.019361138343811,
-0.9008811712265015,
-0.5330513119697571,
0.3552086353302002,
-0.04242179915308952,
0.1911618709564209,
-0.6952146291732788,
0.20506954193115234,
-0.6557607054710388,
0.2566843330860138,
-0.21472039818763733,
-0.5084913969039917,
0.0920073464512825,
0.4946696162223816,
-0.7981891632080078,
0.8491597771644592,
0.03371921926736832,
-0.03335850313305855,
0.5698400139808655,
-0.5469841957092285,
-0.21853791177272797,
-0.10813796520233154,
-0.2776307165622711,
-0.1570894420146942,
-0.0860632061958313,
0.32982203364372253,
0.6139951944351196,
-0.20752166211605072,
0.47739535570144653,
-0.5533223152160645,
-0.47070324420928955,
0.2674869894981384,
-0.3015643358230591,
0.6850178837776184,
0.10362266004085541,
-0.08241185545921326,
0.3471546769142151,
-0.713358998298645,
-0.34597542881965637,
-0.359992653131485,
-0.6712487936019897,
0.06859523057937622,
0.16041235625743866,
0.004981767851859331,
0.14922896027565002,
0.5052842497825623,
-0.610344409942627,
0.7180953025817871,
-0.36997365951538086,
0.2122858762741089,
1.1682953834533691,
-0.11523017287254333,
0.7997527122497559,
-0.295485258102417,
0.5736420154571533,
-0.24303539097309113,
0.08105114847421646,
0.13069364428520203,
-0.4758126437664032,
-0.5300832390785217,
-0.5601804852485657,
0.4047897458076477,
0.6052891612052917,
-0.6862556338310242,
0.5565618276596069,
-0.23534944653511047,
-0.3307247757911682,
-0.24008595943450928,
0.13823151588439941,
-0.23586705327033997,
-0.010561295785009861,
-0.22917582094669342,
0.05561170354485512,
-0.656011700630188,
-0.5937932729721069,
0.07185683399438858,
-0.5244936943054199,
0.19652609527111053,
0.24207645654678345,
0.9058778285980225,
-0.2818017303943634,
0.995997965335846,
0.009520194493234158,
-0.17728593945503235,
-0.1373959183692932,
-0.22452695667743683,
0.2666367292404175,
0.03271884098649025,
0.23366624116897583,
-0.7818294167518616,
-0.06533825397491455,
0.20871828496456146,
-0.4121856391429901,
-0.033770348876714706,
0.18779446184635162,
0.19995413720607758,
0.3924863338470459,
0.04039676859974861,
-0.3890286684036255,
0.3644879162311554,
0.926371693611145,
-0.18276992440223694,
0.42699548602104187,
-0.4281295835971832,
0.3548794984817505,
-1.2006396055221558,
-0.24669291079044342,
-0.022086139768362045,
-0.4834992289543152,
-0.15126469731330872,
-0.22259746491909027,
-0.25890618562698364,
-0.11613979935646057,
-0.36823874711990356,
0.817678689956665,
-0.3774777948856354,
-0.41756758093833923,
-0.5989104509353638,
0.2882227599620819,
-0.12755070626735687,
-0.007182153407484293,
0.10845965147018433,
1.0106312036514282,
0.4014824330806732,
-0.5470019578933716,
0.8302603960037231,
0.17444781959056854,
-0.6716586947441101,
0.46148577332496643,
-0.7063881754875183,
0.1939643770456314,
-0.1487646847963333,
0.5374149084091187,
-1.0891056060791016,
-0.38921746611595154,
-0.05965953692793846,
-0.4076019823551178,
-0.07775011658668518,
-0.06985913217067719,
-0.7700748443603516,
-0.1611207276582718,
-0.08043588697910309,
-0.22560077905654907,
0.3495567739009857,
-0.6553968787193298,
0.7933231592178345,
0.8513721823692322,
-0.15618713200092316,
-0.7010685205459595,
-0.46771949529647827,
0.24201956391334534,
-0.02975156344473362,
-0.39591655135154724,
-0.00902293249964714,
0.20603494346141815,
-0.4571516811847687,
0.0681767538189888,
0.5642956495285034,
0.18978074193000793,
-0.27919167280197144,
0.49492332339286804,
0.15838438272476196,
0.10487126559019089,
0.29788607358932495,
0.01447229739278555,
0.12583595514297485,
-0.3144984245300293,
-0.20367850363254547,
0.7195717692375183,
-0.25443029403686523,
-0.3616103231906891,
-0.04296359419822693,
0.25302281975746155,
0.6248663067817688,
-0.4253477156162262,
0.8941430449485779,
0.3264554738998413,
-0.5545753240585327,
-0.07246915996074677,
-0.7338939309120178,
-0.1293378472328186,
-0.42664384841918945,
0.35972753167152405,
-0.4065210223197937,
-1.0751075744628906,
0.862127423286438,
-0.2008167952299118,
0.22265879809856415,
0.05489305779337883,
1.1257354021072388,
0.08887656033039093,
1.128811001777649,
0.5590885877609253,
-0.2983970046043396,
0.5439532399177551,
-0.25630319118499756,
0.06596806645393372,
-0.723281741142273,
-0.30359897017478943,
-0.4880629777908325,
-0.33443209528923035,
-0.9490306973457336,
-0.4573999345302582,
0.6632233262062073,
-0.07253149151802063,
-0.665795624256134,
-0.05174972116947174,
-0.3964010775089264,
0.3755393624305725,
0.7472333312034607,
0.16567212343215942,
0.36537355184555054,
0.3305746018886566,
0.4224465787410736,
0.23037733137607574,
-0.5226666927337646,
-0.8681544661521912,
1.3781802654266357,
0.07472136616706848,
0.9252325892448425,
0.10586816072463989,
0.8266348838806152,
0.7726831436157227,
0.3604634702205658,
-0.5576620101928711,
0.5736644268035889,
-0.04178554564714432,
-0.7418718934059143,
-0.4134778082370758,
-0.24475380778312683,
-1.1030409336090088,
0.34211698174476624,
-0.6181870102882385,
-0.7294974327087402,
0.45045775175094604,
0.22008103132247925,
-0.47816428542137146,
0.5748096704483032,
-0.3412204086780548,
0.5281145572662354,
-0.3277609348297119,
-0.4376480281352997,
-0.2906022369861603,
-0.3570268452167511,
0.12681053578853607,
0.05686836317181587,
0.23112572729587555,
-0.09639014303684235,
-0.42094823718070984,
0.8167230486869812,
-0.14292265474796295,
0.6877465844154358,
-0.07306502759456635,
-0.12221449613571167,
0.3715971112251282,
-0.13672590255737305,
0.7783054709434509,
0.05244102329015732,
-0.48858579993247986,
-0.01090241689234972,
-0.06440062075853348,
-0.6057741045951843,
-0.7033958435058594,
0.9854040145874023,
-1.2110639810562134,
-0.7884315848350525,
-0.6910441517829895,
-0.6127274036407471,
-0.11258329451084137,
0.025612562894821167,
0.008570611476898193,
0.29015302658081055,
-0.4546053409576416,
0.2044384777545929,
0.43154385685920715,
-0.11657737195491791,
0.2411249727010727,
0.47990167140960693,
-0.7796720266342163,
-0.6914344429969788,
0.7487421631813049,
0.4406485855579376,
0.29133275151252747,
0.3601909577846527,
0.20119541883468628,
-0.4649686813354492,
-0.5600602030754089,
-0.5823164582252502,
0.14859262108802795,
-0.3600176274776459,
-0.040175847709178925,
-0.42518681287765503,
0.2205190509557724,
-0.5558977723121643,
-0.1755821257829666,
-0.20992939174175262,
-0.27685508131980896,
-0.4063205420970917,
-0.27685871720314026,
0.31947028636932373,
0.877582311630249,
-0.39358195662498474,
0.42018377780914307,
-0.22880499064922333,
0.35840296745300293,
0.3846023976802826,
0.2737170457839966,
-0.5485662817955017,
-0.7011750340461731,
-0.055642928928136826,
0.2749074697494507,
-0.26970618963241577,
-1.033577799797058,
0.4077063500881195,
0.16062423586845398,
0.32801923155784607,
0.4217919111251831,
0.06776078045368195,
0.48248589038848877,
-0.3500244915485382,
0.9729601740837097,
-0.28646546602249146,
-0.642633318901062,
0.40828588604927063,
-0.45303839445114136,
-0.10734919458627701,
0.27821674942970276,
0.018346218392252922,
-0.007479444611817598,
-0.30250388383865356,
-0.5364494323730469,
-0.4239245057106018,
0.4255152642726898,
-0.3208114802837372,
0.5236174464225769,
-0.038529958575963974,
0.2780115008354187,
0.06537836790084839,
0.4046225845813751,
-0.5417073965072632,
-0.02286381460726261,
0.21523967385292053,
0.13255804777145386,
-0.23582050204277039,
-0.2737245261669159,
-0.2677443325519562,
-0.15225672721862793,
0.8140740990638733,
-0.17341651022434235,
0.15709955990314484,
0.09127022325992584,
0.36768314242362976,
-0.35750889778137207,
0.5090567469596863,
0.759369969367981,
1.0572175979614258,
-0.2428090125322342,
0.14577555656433105,
0.1069001629948616,
-0.005234383977949619,
0.36465537548065186,
0.19136661291122437,
-0.1950201690196991,
-0.163531094789505,
0.19371312856674194,
0.8917960524559021,
-0.40372994542121887,
-0.7161185145378113,
0.3477901816368103,
0.44660741090774536,
-0.038081031292676926,
-0.6670718789100647,
-0.22180087864398956,
0.028388984501361847,
0.45832908153533936,
0.5396803021430969,
-0.025477414950728416,
0.045978840440511703,
-1.109238624572754,
0.08577932417392731,
0.8612286448478699,
-0.3931555449962616,
-0.28212395310401917,
0.3445374667644501,
0.39804694056510925,
-0.6119622588157654,
0.20183035731315613,
-0.2596742510795593,
-0.5967089533805847,
0.384726881980896,
0.4775170087814331,
0.337271511554718,
-0.40773066878318787,
0.3476817011833191,
0.006929005496203899,
0.7287584543228149,
-0.2203754186630249,
0.3637329638004303,
0.18355241417884827,
-0.838356077671051,
-0.5976672172546387,
-0.5965480208396912,
-0.7097405791282654,
0.24223439395427704,
-0.4117022454738617,
0.3646424412727356,
-0.5294240117073059,
-0.406055212020874,
-0.3866264820098877,
0.44928377866744995,
-0.4743558466434479,
0.29595136642456055,
0.1933809071779251,
0.6500258445739746,
-1.172747015953064,
0.5961347818374634,
0.8010168671607971,
-0.15434738993644714,
-0.47583243250846863,
-0.4593193531036377,
-0.18113137781620026,
-0.9568631649017334,
0.266489177942276,
-0.5314950942993164,
0.11764585226774216,
-0.3567504286766052,
-0.6309962868690491,
-0.6670203804969788,
0.6551544666290283,
0.8436877727508545,
-0.6048634052276611,
-0.2476988583803177,
0.2320134937763214,
0.4871997833251953,
-0.508866012096405,
0.34965118765830994,
0.6605201959609985,
0.5927039384841919,
-0.22110681235790253,
-1.1742042303085327,
-0.2958001494407654,
0.08826197683811188,
-0.29011109471321106,
0.4148221015930176,
-0.7907888293266296,
0.9052506685256958,
-0.423873633146286,
0.2432314157485962,
-0.013536999933421612,
1.01425039768219,
0.3769099712371826,
0.4079248905181885,
0.41397494077682495,
0.3559786081314087,
0.6550754308700562,
-0.1208699569106102,
1.226101279258728,
-0.32419076561927795,
0.21540567278862,
0.8438128232955933,
-0.2720533311367035,
0.9090635180473328,
0.582406222820282,
-0.44471707940101624,
0.4361101984977722,
0.7225399017333984,
0.21449990570545197,
0.1982536017894745,
0.10075574368238449,
-0.5544794797897339,
-0.5525501370429993,
-0.3080432116985321,
-0.3060995936393738,
0.4872022271156311,
0.5711836218833923,
-0.4769613444805145,
0.10194912552833557,
0.4463423788547516,
0.002678999211639166,
0.45048022270202637,
-0.5387258529663086,
0.7632847428321838,
0.04304179176688194,
-0.7829111814498901,
0.4186073839664459,
-0.2609010636806488,
0.5173425674438477,
-0.26963767409324646,
-0.13840648531913757,
0.019941959530115128,
0.19387280941009521,
-0.36657825112342834,
-1.0912259817123413,
-0.16207841038703918,
-0.18106041848659515,
-0.22852487862110138,
-0.04379775747656822,
0.41031086444854736,
-0.6525132656097412,
-0.7991931438446045,
0.03575526922941208,
0.6468927264213562,
0.1249123141169548,
-0.0798940435051918,
-0.5047009587287903,
0.3546583354473114,
-0.1081148087978363,
-0.46744608879089355,
0.2800978720188141,
0.24439050257205963,
-0.20552507042884827,
0.7819423079490662,
0.5258793234825134,
0.6601314544677734,
-0.021340262144804,
-0.2708176076412201,
0.765951931476593,
-0.08518104255199432,
-0.44818469882011414,
-0.7273891568183899,
0.19345687329769135,
-0.10786328464746475,
-0.20389752089977264,
0.5194323658943176,
0.7439875602722168,
0.7855111360549927,
0.17765925824642181,
1.2506033182144165,
-0.016371382400393486,
0.6337524652481079,
-0.24545124173164368,
0.4897597134113312,
-0.4748031497001648,
0.2240760773420334,
-0.06841519474983215,
-1.1165698766708374,
-0.019046448171138763,
0.705351710319519,
-0.7710844278335571,
0.23891600966453552,
-0.059350885450839996,
1.0443816184997559,
-0.014367062598466873,
-0.3198070228099823,
0.5261040329933167,
-0.010586515069007874,
0.48185786604881287,
0.4183048605918884,
0.7543975710868835,
-0.17341940104961395,
0.38153162598609924,
-0.08908011019229889,
-0.307851642370224,
-0.2256903350353241,
-0.4864725172519684,
-0.9350437521934509,
-0.7489831447601318,
-0.10631217062473297,
-0.7440406084060669,
0.32103338837623596,
1.3105099201202393,
0.790357768535614,
-0.7254356145858765,
-0.5162198543548584,
0.40119537711143494,
0.25814273953437805,
0.3672323226928711,
-0.21229638159275055,
0.5010436177253723,
0.3685465157032013,
-1.1461514234542847,
0.2023387998342514,
0.2703896164894104,
-0.07476213574409485,
-0.6601209044456482,
-0.3247690200805664,
-0.1753164827823639,
0.3030446469783783,
0.7600921988487244,
0.3948433995246887,
-1.1190861463546753,
-0.6299178600311279,
-0.005315037909895182,
-0.07636003196239471,
-0.1753949224948883,
0.6991567611694336,
-1.0594016313552856,
0.88460773229599,
0.6082237958908081,
0.2739478349685669,
0.4030839204788208,
0.22292983531951904,
0.6273676753044128,
-0.28339850902557373,
0.43342047929763794,
0.30980628728866577,
0.35716769099235535,
0.4362083673477173,
0.10610681772232056,
0.31306201219558716,
-0.13400296866893768,
-0.9486922025680542,
-1.0267398357391357,
0.2984866201877594,
-1.0719414949417114,
0.14960016310214996,
1.5394381284713745,
0.18577052652835846,
-0.1752215027809143,
-0.11688438802957535,
-0.47056251764297485,
0.24427121877670288,
-0.7551841139793396,
0.7320341467857361,
0.4619382321834564,
-0.14348356425762177,
-0.37863990664482117,
-0.3609895706176758,
0.1971588134765625,
-0.07039060443639755,
-0.7119196057319641,
-0.30906471610069275,
0.704228937625885,
0.11902868002653122,
0.10232292115688324,
0.7875393033027649,
0.05022609606385231,
0.33887723088264465,
-0.28354763984680176,
-0.04062946140766144,
-0.06504576653242111,
-0.19353605806827545,
-0.19926151633262634,
0.3800494968891144,
0.09831643849611282,
-0.021871134638786316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06685v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06685v1
|
Multigenre AI-powered Story Composition
| 2024-05-06T12:54:41 | 2024-05-06T12:54:41 |
Edirlei Soares de Lima, Margot M. E. Neggers, Antonio L. Furtado
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper shows how to construct genre patterns, whose purpose is to guide
interactive story composition in a way that enforces thematic consistency. To
start the discussion we argue, based on previous seminal works, for the
existence of five fundamental genres, namely comedy, romance - in the sense of
epic plots, flourishing since the twelfth century -, tragedy, satire, and
mystery. To construct the patterns, a simple two-phase process is employed:
first retrieving examples that match our genre characterizations, and then
applying a form of most specific generalization to the groups of examples in
order to find their commonalities. In both phases, AI agents are instrumental,
with our PatternTeller prototype being called to operate the story composition
process, offering the opportunity to generate stories from a given premise of
the user, to be developed under the guidance of the chosen pattern and trying
to accommodate the user's suggestions along the composition stages.
|
[
-0.2498917430639267,
-0.46945834159851074,
0.7984054684638977,
0.8367965221405029,
-0.14040935039520264,
0.47341495752334595,
-0.01720297709107399,
-0.18553034961223602,
0.6040380001068115,
0.6805475354194641,
-0.6133726239204407,
-0.5377785563468933,
-0.2376500517129898,
0.2825530171394348,
-0.45513156056404114,
1.0827834606170654,
-0.21338163316249847,
-0.4211847484111786,
-0.1812155395746231,
-0.3186980187892914,
-0.7666031718254089,
-0.2656713128089905,
-0.3296099603176117,
-0.3319980502128601,
0.5681661367416382,
0.4041424095630646,
0.33581188321113586,
1.0067821741104126,
0.5764567852020264,
0.3689139485359192,
0.3431401550769806,
0.5464727282524109,
-0.16136035323143005,
0.790309727191925,
0.2826053202152252,
-0.7690093517303467,
-0.192713662981987,
0.36291074752807617,
0.5311303734779358,
0.23451825976371765,
-0.14716821908950806,
-0.12839913368225098,
0.0026160788256675005,
0.5017715096473694,
-0.24374033510684967,
0.22763320803642273,
-0.23356036841869354,
0.18701870739459991,
-0.13805903494358063,
-0.5672844648361206,
-0.4989793300628662,
-0.20104306936264038,
-0.28231745958328247,
-0.6449658870697021,
0.250859797000885,
0.3012259900569916,
0.595848560333252,
0.11694058775901794,
-0.5084793567657471,
-0.4963517487049103,
-1.334096908569336,
0.6625020503997803,
-0.24837975203990936,
-0.3354325294494629,
0.29486632347106934,
0.48070743680000305,
0.13329458236694336,
-0.8225085139274597,
-0.5388594269752502,
-0.5058927536010742,
-0.1834864765405655,
0.2606121897697449,
0.05150679126381874,
-0.2004903256893158,
0.04801222309470177,
0.29943153262138367,
-0.5936094522476196,
-0.21303054690361023,
-0.08834254741668701,
-0.17143936455249786,
0.8225069642066956,
0.721983015537262,
0.6001744270324707,
-0.17782612144947052,
-0.30071496963500977,
0.09677205979824066,
-0.4450396001338959,
0.10116389393806458,
0.5717402696609497,
-0.05957235023379326,
-0.27449387311935425,
0.5075439810752869,
0.2329622209072113,
0.40375515818595886,
0.1761617660522461,
-0.7165369391441345,
0.030329344794154167,
-0.7186330556869507,
0.29662394523620605,
0.2856019139289856,
0.9061907529830933,
0.6645570993423462,
0.2697150707244873,
-0.2768497169017792,
0.0018855086527764797,
0.04716383293271065,
0.44316384196281433,
-0.42421141266822815,
-0.22352014482021332,
0.2683860957622528,
-0.5862182974815369,
-0.5406404137611389,
0.18559536337852478,
-0.38768938183784485,
-0.6054118275642395,
-0.5696572661399841,
0.343230664730072,
-0.6383208632469177,
-0.14172393083572388,
-0.1412660926580429,
-0.7664308547973633,
0.11295177787542343,
0.1255955547094345,
-0.8725045919418335,
0.05933103710412979,
0.6477333307266235,
0.9368410706520081,
0.23232153058052063,
-0.5038837790489197,
-0.32736003398895264,
0.696449339389801,
-0.36578255891799927,
1.0046368837356567,
-0.499499648809433,
-0.2918005883693695,
-0.2641870379447937,
-0.23287662863731384,
-0.026754893362522125,
-0.2877482771873474,
0.37438878417015076,
-0.1147211343050003,
0.27893462777137756,
0.02339586429297924,
-0.5554441213607788,
-0.2507804036140442,
0.07164351642131805,
-0.590434193611145,
0.6385661363601685,
-0.04885197803378105,
-0.3787620961666107,
0.4109249413013458,
-0.4111567437648773,
-0.8235101699829102,
0.18400870263576508,
-0.3572188913822174,
-0.12191054224967957,
-0.000011058182280976325,
-0.0047592464834451675,
0.15169955790042877,
-0.21888060867786407,
0.25615957379341125,
0.05997296795248985,
-0.4211876094341278,
0.11661650240421295,
-0.25428929924964905,
0.6139575242996216,
0.3715847432613373,
-0.6177567839622498,
0.43018263578414917,
-1.0525785684585571,
-0.20976707339286804,
-0.000219619701965712,
0.08385251462459564,
-0.47845953702926636,
0.3381906747817993,
0.18628236651420593,
0.1383657157421112,
-0.07406783849000931,
-0.34658434987068176,
0.3765172064304352,
-0.06917466223239899,
0.8204072713851929,
0.607947826385498,
0.0935329794883728,
0.27265992760658264,
-1.1478736400604248,
0.9186421036720276,
0.10381685197353363,
0.10320988297462463,
-0.9484606981277466,
-0.4602925479412079,
-0.8041060566902161,
-0.449120432138443,
-0.0114604402333498,
0.7982962727546692,
-0.5926803946495056,
0.880786120891571,
0.14426563680171967,
-0.8605073690414429,
-0.5078668594360352,
0.019295141100883484,
0.03884132206439972,
0.13107101619243622,
0.1755198836326599,
-0.46940070390701294,
-0.5935693979263306,
-0.6842710375785828,
-0.0653337687253952,
-0.05110553279519081,
0.0905405655503273,
0.2136782854795456,
-0.033438097685575485,
0.22324134409427643,
1.2052628993988037,
-0.33674338459968567,
-0.4233025908470154,
-0.7260338068008423,
0.44370946288108826,
0.14176693558692932,
0.5705435872077942,
0.9109495282173157,
-0.7380756735801697,
-0.8474898934364319,
-0.24020272493362427,
-0.9106852412223816,
-0.06619272381067276,
-0.40135663747787476,
0.038052868098020554,
-0.08579859137535095,
0.5767279863357544,
-0.4102441370487213,
0.14342868328094482,
0.20903466641902924,
-0.3693815767765045,
0.416395902633667,
-0.1748843938112259,
0.41396665573120117,
-1.399741530418396,
-0.06082441285252571,
0.07585784047842026,
-0.07561970502138138,
-0.7248550653457642,
0.10195275396108627,
-0.4901248812675476,
-0.07683352380990982,
-0.048483557999134064,
0.37429580092430115,
-0.38199129700660706,
0.2672141194343567,
-0.22202429175376892,
-0.1572265475988388,
0.23538188636302948,
0.29726338386535645,
-0.24063891172409058,
0.29180097579956055,
0.59578937292099,
-0.5129454731941223,
0.547535240650177,
0.13028405606746674,
-0.36771631240844727,
0.820335328578949,
-0.6999845504760742,
0.23655089735984802,
-0.5416399240493774,
0.5092982053756714,
-1.0351042747497559,
-0.29501375555992126,
0.38188791275024414,
-0.0686093419790268,
-0.03797774761915207,
-0.1882760375738144,
-0.6852196455001831,
-0.04490644112229347,
-0.2956814765930176,
0.2127981334924698,
0.6363018155097961,
0.2246980220079422,
1.0413966178894043,
-0.08600002527236938,
-0.3612612783908844,
-0.19995300471782684,
-0.49735599756240845,
0.20397262275218964,
-0.6453508138656616,
-0.8417755365371704,
0.3386463224887848,
-0.44157522916793823,
-0.3760595917701721,
-0.1031608060002327,
0.41149669885635376,
0.15900002419948578,
0.05637415498495102,
0.4214024841785431,
-0.1475362330675125,
-0.4152282774448395,
-0.2172199934720993,
0.14567212760448456,
0.008183104917407036,
-0.2987889349460602,
-0.05559748411178589,
0.8284624218940735,
0.4084774851799011,
-0.3177517354488373,
-0.7453576922416687,
0.8294064402580261,
1.006917953491211,
-0.5550975203514099,
0.5047298669815063,
0.7393706440925598,
0.23418597877025604,
-0.28519144654273987,
-0.27679863572120667,
-0.0653224065899849,
-0.4908679723739624,
-0.22756123542785645,
-0.3147273063659668,
-0.7229464054107666,
0.7943715453147888,
0.12517859041690826,
0.25128138065338135,
0.6908022165298462,
0.3561995327472687,
-0.19311439990997314,
1.0810694694519043,
0.8429876565933228,
0.05445697903633118,
0.4726133644580841,
-0.17130063474178314,
0.19467565417289734,
-0.4259394407272339,
-0.34793171286582947,
-0.5809957385063171,
-0.7602176070213318,
-0.6718834042549133,
-0.013859374448657036,
0.7311592698097229,
0.07852102816104889,
-0.2767646312713623,
0.11815204471349716,
-0.4107116758823395,
0.6815693974494934,
0.8979136943817139,
-0.22440248727798462,
0.5704792737960815,
0.0818374902009964,
0.022264018654823303,
-0.0202759001404047,
-0.4979625642299652,
-0.547044575214386,
1.0163050889968872,
0.13376834988594055,
0.6655972003936768,
0.3526829183101654,
0.9439359307289124,
0.4450853168964386,
0.15466557443141937,
-0.7050860524177551,
0.3644280433654785,
-0.439728319644928,
-0.49141234159469604,
-0.21854501962661743,
0.1455940455198288,
-0.8937759399414062,
-0.11854112148284912,
-0.05173250287771225,
-0.5962048172950745,
0.16595885157585144,
0.04316944628953934,
-0.5916740298271179,
-0.0020508880261331797,
-0.39827561378479004,
0.5843148231506348,
-0.15932375192642212,
0.08680915832519531,
-0.3142234981060028,
-0.8976977467536926,
0.3964192867279053,
0.12237759679555893,
0.1923721730709076,
-0.20460499823093414,
0.35477662086486816,
0.3694605529308319,
-0.24671167135238647,
0.8275092840194702,
0.2668796181678772,
0.10817015916109085,
0.7819304466247559,
0.20911921560764313,
0.15579527616500854,
0.001804207917302847,
0.14189022779464722,
-0.28958648443222046,
-0.16058313846588135,
-0.2994973659515381,
-0.5533162951469421,
0.15761157870292664,
-0.7998334169387817,
-0.5919533371925354,
-0.34973299503326416,
-0.7700619697570801,
0.10536949336528778,
0.15456420183181763,
0.35778769850730896,
0.9637253284454346,
-0.13292686641216278,
0.304688036441803,
0.24363389611244202,
0.2399468719959259,
0.9819844365119934,
0.3519132435321808,
-0.18816272914409637,
-0.48776987195014954,
0.9148589372634888,
-0.11409205198287964,
0.11597906798124313,
0.4502699375152588,
0.11481907218694687,
0.22414126992225647,
-0.4448845088481903,
-0.6529660820960999,
-0.06870065629482269,
-0.3644791543483734,
0.058295223861932755,
-0.8196271657943726,
-0.40986618399620056,
-0.279785692691803,
-0.4172036945819855,
0.14199714362621307,
-0.08243861794471741,
-0.2177240252494812,
0.1810987889766693,
0.4969756603240967,
1.0286228656768799,
-0.14513179659843445,
0.4119481146335602,
-1.002187967300415,
0.34133780002593994,
0.28773361444473267,
-0.04187837243080139,
0.07818470150232315,
-0.11980830132961273,
-0.04046199098229408,
-0.28217071294784546,
-0.5418648719787598,
-0.6555907726287842,
0.254605233669281,
0.4182795584201813,
0.49895015358924866,
0.38162559270858765,
-0.22993533313274384,
0.3720986843109131,
-0.7407816052436829,
0.973207414150238,
0.18522951006889343,
-0.8081679940223694,
0.6796415448188782,
-0.6182659864425659,
0.037206511944532394,
0.4919641315937042,
0.4980261027812958,
-0.8448987603187561,
-0.7898640036582947,
-0.6703803539276123,
-0.8386794924736023,
0.6889243721961975,
0.2600870430469513,
0.4124651849269867,
0.23443523049354553,
0.3387955129146576,
0.5007261633872986,
0.43936192989349365,
-0.44210195541381836,
-0.6433554887771606,
-0.4518849551677704,
-0.480389803647995,
-0.468337744474411,
-0.0025665508583188057,
-0.5283742547035217,
-0.07841546088457108,
0.13557304441928864,
-0.09530731290578842,
0.12087330222129822,
0.009021848440170288,
0.2531943619251251,
-0.16717039048671722,
0.27607545256614685,
0.9858459830284119,
0.7961441278457642,
-0.07082939893007278,
0.06510592252016068,
-1.1696391105651855,
-0.49883219599723816,
0.6293189525604248,
0.1987210363149643,
-0.49667349457740784,
-0.030619582161307335,
0.8383936285972595,
0.8752042651176453,
-0.2759867012500763,
-0.4426741302013397,
0.16805553436279297,
0.0003096928121522069,
-0.2059486359357834,
-0.39183545112609863,
0.5981104969978333,
-0.06858976185321808,
0.4064345955848694,
0.5593032836914062,
0.17860133945941925,
0.020377308130264282,
-1.3334838151931763,
0.37789061665534973,
-0.01480497419834137,
-0.2867715656757355,
-0.24956494569778442,
0.5792523622512817,
0.216327965259552,
-0.4680596888065338,
0.6419113874435425,
-0.33453303575515747,
-0.2519785165786743,
1.1773375272750854,
0.7028296589851379,
1.0606133937835693,
-0.20789934694766998,
0.6986861824989319,
0.014296862296760082,
0.4035739600658417,
0.06888604164123535,
0.3581473231315613,
0.19553856551647186,
-0.7577414512634277,
-0.3552283048629761,
-0.683182954788208,
-0.13461381196975708,
-0.032717615365982056,
-0.24623341858386993,
0.3287044167518616,
-0.6524789929389954,
0.38098183274269104,
0.45412150025367737,
-0.40901345014572144,
-0.16861453652381897,
-0.12382714450359344,
0.010807609185576439,
0.5129707455635071,
-0.901892364025116,
0.39253687858581543,
0.8474030494689941,
-0.7495798468589783,
-1.152326226234436,
0.281571626663208,
0.24011266231536865,
-0.5716881155967712,
0.429726243019104,
0.11154604703187943,
0.265811026096344,
0.33160555362701416,
-0.48339489102363586,
-0.7720853686332703,
1.1829520463943481,
-0.00044157158117741346,
-0.394141286611557,
0.03532819449901581,
-0.1497945934534073,
0.7713562250137329,
-0.9925709962844849,
0.08804032951593399,
0.34194260835647583,
0.6598126888275146,
0.4634025990962982,
-0.8960553407669067,
-0.20312568545341492,
-0.2685229182243347,
-0.28560757637023926,
0.24828441441059113,
-1.0053608417510986,
0.8423950672149658,
-0.019955720752477646,
0.01126803271472454,
0.532487690448761,
0.5080582499504089,
0.3098694086074829,
0.6537615060806274,
0.31369128823280334,
0.3112487494945526,
0.24049390852451324,
-0.07862582802772522,
1.0202081203460693,
-0.4481033682823181,
-0.04098458215594292,
0.9400947690010071,
-0.3709021210670471,
0.06198791414499283,
-0.08061831444501877,
-0.20423534512519836,
1.0883055925369263,
0.5267943739891052,
-0.2979334890842438,
0.6980804204940796,
0.1837342381477356,
-0.316433310508728,
-0.2793622612953186,
-0.36471888422966003,
-0.2631080746650696,
0.8977078795433044,
0.004088499117642641,
-0.3681153357028961,
-0.059321992099285126,
0.1347079873085022,
-0.04653579741716385,
0.3012903034687042,
-0.286160945892334,
0.9907101392745972,
0.0001713079254841432,
-0.7311292886734009,
-0.025898147374391556,
0.22269946336746216,
0.3889445960521698,
-0.8815642595291138,
-0.21801765263080597,
-0.411060094833374,
-0.1899576187133789,
0.0015768567100167274,
-0.6763646602630615,
-0.027631523087620735,
-0.4103155732154846,
-0.556746780872345,
-0.21919408440589905,
0.410535603761673,
-0.691784679889679,
-0.4863271117210388,
-0.42319878935813904,
0.492825448513031,
-0.03499159589409828,
0.26654288172721863,
-0.4014798104763031,
-0.14314813911914825,
-0.1635490506887436,
0.27868133783340454,
0.09532102197408676,
0.5635172128677368,
-0.3060227930545807,
0.31388604640960693,
0.313039630651474,
-0.1652323454618454,
-0.17876999080181122,
0.3568861484527588,
0.28821879625320435,
-0.7437000870704651,
-0.9224236011505127,
-0.9558718800544739,
0.7547760009765625,
0.11085890978574753,
-0.4747689962387085,
0.6788846254348755,
0.3822443187236786,
0.1620512157678604,
-0.08238192647695541,
0.847938597202301,
-0.4098312556743622,
-0.010048231109976768,
-0.5418338775634766,
0.6987807750701904,
-0.4745037257671356,
0.042730558663606644,
-0.27293163537979126,
-1.1362628936767578,
-0.20501327514648438,
0.10069013386964798,
0.5541655421257019,
0.28144046664237976,
0.8980507254600525,
0.3626208007335663,
0.08914721012115479,
0.14440128207206726,
0.01941886730492115,
0.01230550929903984,
0.4053072929382324,
0.11914469301700592,
0.9509950876235962,
-0.08573973178863525,
0.1067470833659172,
-0.3055596351623535,
-0.2956058084964752,
-0.20566952228546143,
-0.9270531535148621,
-0.7891944646835327,
-0.7795699834823608,
-0.28597599267959595,
-0.13366112112998962,
-0.1397690623998642,
0.8074666261672974,
0.5895583033561707,
-0.638738214969635,
-0.443735271692276,
-0.08968813717365265,
0.22971367835998535,
-0.5936890244483948,
-0.27605777978897095,
0.1053542047739029,
-0.2960241734981537,
-0.5757355690002441,
0.5264784097671509,
0.6952179670333862,
-0.026050839573144913,
-0.55607670545578,
0.2549270987510681,
-0.05105999484658241,
0.27795708179473877,
0.6136258244514465,
0.05906807631254196,
-0.6937577128410339,
-0.3343009650707245,
-0.07602828741073608,
-0.08480513095855713,
0.16204944252967834,
1.5593622922897339,
-0.3034785985946655,
0.28708088397979736,
0.40415412187576294,
0.1703505963087082,
0.05128531903028488,
0.08563059568405151,
0.9134312868118286,
-0.96746826171875,
0.17339180409908295,
0.2279936969280243,
0.14662788808345795,
-0.0191643089056015,
-0.519690752029419,
0.3862125277519226,
0.6655598878860474,
-0.4496748447418213,
-0.362871378660202,
0.3868257999420166,
-1.2359400987625122,
-0.20366314053535461,
0.859893262386322,
0.08041109889745712,
0.13896869122982025,
-0.23247405886650085,
-0.33989325165748596,
-0.0014712916454300284,
-0.2641995847225189,
0.7665020823478699,
1.040310025215149,
-0.6750609874725342,
-0.13590674102306366,
-0.1283917874097824,
0.5625295639038086,
0.06829836219549179,
-0.7618718147277832,
-0.3523729145526886,
0.7497009038925171,
0.29921630024909973,
0.5327326059341431,
0.573245644569397,
0.0955975279211998,
0.28195303678512573,
0.1304597556591034,
-0.012300275266170502,
-0.07637308537960052,
-0.7872082591056824,
0.03239872679114342,
0.6565154194831848,
-0.06326434016227722,
0.16145765781402588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03425v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03425v1
|
Gaussian Stochastic Weight Averaging for Bayesian Low-Rank Adaptation of Large Language Models
| 2024-05-06T12:44:37 | 2024-05-06T12:44:37 |
Emre Onal, Klemens Flöge, Emma Caldwell, Arsen Sheverdin, Vincent Fortuin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Fine-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) often suffer from overconfidence and
poor calibration, particularly when fine-tuned on small datasets. To address
these challenges, we propose a simple combination of Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA)
with Gaussian Stochastic Weight Averaging (SWAG), facilitating approximate
Bayesian inference in LLMs. Through extensive testing across several Natural
Language Processing (NLP) benchmarks, we demonstrate that our straightforward
and computationally efficient approach improves model generalization and
calibration. We further show that our method exhibits greater robustness
against distribution shift, as reflected in its performance on
out-of-distribution tasks.
|
[
-0.006385765504091978,
-0.7317705154418945,
0.5469649434089661,
0.19537927210330963,
-0.21816584467887878,
0.00656130351126194,
-0.41398730874061584,
-0.3181310296058655,
0.06003808230161667,
0.44370222091674805,
-0.32665425539016724,
-0.6873787045478821,
-0.8090192675590515,
-0.4306061863899231,
-0.11080881953239441,
0.9218364357948303,
0.21039408445358276,
0.04885314777493477,
0.0067108143121004105,
-0.2756500840187073,
-0.32927799224853516,
-0.25202640891075134,
-0.714070200920105,
-0.255592942237854,
0.5879460573196411,
0.29940149188041687,
0.7720723152160645,
0.09545718133449554,
0.685721755027771,
0.1582222580909729,
0.09056815505027771,
0.3006468117237091,
-0.6347402930259705,
0.06191981956362724,
-0.4546671509742737,
-0.5704567432403564,
-0.6921676397323608,
-0.3037716746330261,
0.8192303776741028,
1.0219640731811523,
-0.5490241646766663,
0.24569594860076904,
0.09368631988763809,
0.7326093912124634,
-0.9884735941886902,
0.0635254830121994,
-0.8121136426925659,
-0.26577630639076233,
-0.005264429375529289,
-0.11433141678571701,
-0.517839789390564,
-0.32160744071006775,
0.009001392871141434,
-0.606930673122406,
0.08444209396839142,
0.08447079360485077,
0.49929606914520264,
0.3807317018508911,
-0.3187732398509979,
-0.15134744346141815,
-0.8221495151519775,
1.0127924680709839,
-1.1345614194869995,
0.07571703940629959,
0.411776602268219,
0.35226359963417053,
-0.6095743179321289,
-0.236331045627594,
-0.40618300437927246,
-0.12343908101320267,
0.3554109036922455,
0.128715381026268,
-0.3767431378364563,
0.09440933912992477,
0.20176538825035095,
0.2022678256034851,
-0.40164610743522644,
0.4440762996673584,
-0.11582254618406296,
0.33226296305656433,
0.7899122834205627,
-0.06676287949085236,
0.10315749049186707,
0.3366850018501282,
-0.21885468065738678,
-0.3580248951911926,
-0.6830230951309204,
-0.09664364904165268,
0.4308488965034485,
0.6832600235939026,
-0.18793617188930511,
0.45989173650741577,
-0.14225465059280396,
0.7045661807060242,
0.028766602277755737,
-0.1904391348361969,
0.15763802826404572,
-0.15035271644592285,
-0.41526690125465393,
-0.0705147460103035,
0.5025079846382141,
0.34232988953590393,
0.2206229418516159,
0.01812216080725193,
0.05181191861629486,
-0.02262621931731701,
0.08167068660259247,
-0.7602530717849731,
-0.37946727871894836,
0.09171650558710098,
-0.3512028753757477,
-0.22889409959316254,
-0.12172899395227432,
-0.8585083484649658,
-0.6607080698013306,
-0.03188484534621239,
0.8756319284439087,
-0.12130000442266464,
-0.04305010288953781,
0.27035239338874817,
-0.019791310653090477,
0.386358380317688,
0.5712496042251587,
-1.0736169815063477,
0.5480387210845947,
0.44359421730041504,
0.9102689027786255,
-0.24895142018795013,
-0.13559135794639587,
-0.9462055563926697,
0.31325212121009827,
-0.6281872987747192,
0.7989388704299927,
-0.5416668653488159,
-0.259137898683548,
-0.136696457862854,
0.036353789269924164,
-0.34778425097465515,
-0.540988028049469,
0.5232300162315369,
-0.2614043354988098,
0.03560440614819527,
-0.08065424859523773,
-0.39313971996307373,
0.0017013009637594223,
-0.16338761150836945,
-0.3224491477012634,
1.2741721868515015,
0.354322612285614,
-0.5734899640083313,
0.45952340960502625,
-0.43402257561683655,
-0.3564620018005371,
-0.298403799533844,
0.1414865106344223,
-0.3597750663757324,
0.6886916756629944,
0.540472149848938,
0.46798256039619446,
-0.4240877628326416,
-0.09085053950548172,
-0.8513510823249817,
-0.5694721937179565,
0.188839852809906,
-0.34870848059654236,
0.5698405504226685,
-0.05208314582705498,
-0.05274886637926102,
0.07818379998207092,
-0.8934647440910339,
0.004052347969263792,
0.07827810943126678,
-0.27189260721206665,
-0.6539332270622253,
0.45348918437957764,
-0.0951443463563919,
-0.04066916182637215,
0.205619215965271,
-0.24575954675674438,
0.5196430087089539,
-0.6606508493423462,
0.3329431414604187,
0.6750442981719971,
0.04746007174253464,
0.7599537372589111,
-0.3163850009441376,
0.3983316123485565,
0.060818787664175034,
-0.22180183231830597,
0.47801363468170166,
-0.5451072454452515,
-0.7149816751480103,
-0.5459330081939697,
0.38506126403808594,
0.5643097162246704,
-0.5264888405799866,
0.5794968008995056,
-0.6631938815116882,
-0.6525768637657166,
-0.6284412145614624,
0.4955095946788788,
-0.12425074726343155,
0.33865633606910706,
0.5125938057899475,
-0.244868203997612,
-0.03421266749501228,
-0.6768475770950317,
-0.164493590593338,
-0.2729542851448059,
-0.5542672872543335,
-0.020931394770741463,
0.38786637783050537,
-0.3491722345352173,
0.7726073265075684,
-0.45913946628570557,
-0.3449179530143738,
-0.3460429012775421,
0.3352653980255127,
0.5408608317375183,
0.39693403244018555,
0.7257109880447388,
-0.15503408014774323,
-0.39445796608924866,
0.08930617570877075,
-0.22429770231246948,
-0.35681962966918945,
-0.0034042110200971365,
-0.2566436231136322,
0.2702898681163788,
0.3810144066810608,
-0.3809160888195038,
0.48606622219085693,
0.8592237830162048,
-0.2134714126586914,
0.3394320607185364,
-0.6837983727455139,
-0.11566764116287231,
-1.1711879968643188,
0.012865514494478703,
0.13801689445972443,
-0.30707481503486633,
-0.7475414872169495,
-0.047104429453611374,
-0.04639364033937454,
0.05852164700627327,
-0.038249071687459946,
0.5612835884094238,
-0.33517634868621826,
-0.38417309522628784,
-0.46765923500061035,
0.29335495829582214,
-0.10711115598678589,
0.43435242772102356,
0.04245980456471443,
0.5885889530181885,
0.4996749460697174,
-0.5282328128814697,
0.04085614159703255,
0.054183121770620346,
-0.6321486830711365,
0.7698514461517334,
-0.5735450387001038,
-0.11562369018793106,
-0.17622429132461548,
0.3351493775844574,
-1.18488609790802,
-0.031504031270742416,
0.15383055806159973,
-0.20369967818260193,
0.2471255660057068,
-0.43358999490737915,
-0.4039401710033417,
0.09179616719484329,
-0.4259657859802246,
0.190756693482399,
0.5361858606338501,
-0.6428332328796387,
0.6767555475234985,
0.33241382241249084,
-0.5392097234725952,
-0.42713406682014465,
-0.9107668995857239,
-0.0032463944517076015,
-0.30206847190856934,
-0.31647640466690063,
0.34225571155548096,
-0.10111603885889053,
-0.3595080077648163,
-0.5099703073501587,
-0.10437450557947159,
0.04572306200861931,
0.22359207272529602,
0.2006673812866211,
0.17360399663448334,
-0.3170222342014313,
0.028016963973641396,
0.17330682277679443,
0.12932069599628448,
-0.09109434485435486,
0.1015450581908226,
0.3000646233558655,
0.06749275326728821,
-0.5473843216896057,
-0.1305469423532486,
0.2966940104961395,
0.4795275032520294,
0.2705913484096527,
0.7687380313873291,
0.6356860399246216,
-0.4260781705379486,
-0.6994553208351135,
-0.3052339255809784,
-0.04558688774704933,
-0.4377196729183197,
0.5598455667495728,
-0.18657472729682922,
-0.4350641667842865,
0.5965267419815063,
0.08029238134622574,
0.015309127047657967,
0.32547691464424133,
0.7159216403961182,
-0.24810776114463806,
1.2616435289382935,
0.8087918162345886,
-0.5082758069038391,
0.5507859587669373,
0.1752965748310089,
0.3747926950454712,
-0.680411159992218,
0.4024580717086792,
-0.6166081428527832,
-0.5212199091911316,
-0.6594151258468628,
-0.7828202843666077,
0.19943119585514069,
0.38646629452705383,
-0.0868912935256958,
0.07439051568508148,
-0.08682581782341003,
0.15296585857868195,
0.5856634974479675,
0.10897844284772873,
0.35851019620895386,
0.26601994037628174,
0.30295395851135254,
-0.0664711520075798,
-0.6420261263847351,
-0.20735737681388855,
0.9654147624969482,
0.4176594913005829,
1.3040995597839355,
0.44961994886398315,
0.5007643103599548,
0.3893531858921051,
0.40029457211494446,
-0.8793203234672546,
0.38189762830734253,
-0.4620789885520935,
-0.14531658589839935,
-0.39996838569641113,
-0.5164013504981995,
-0.680446982383728,
0.4954659342765808,
-0.25771284103393555,
-0.9929402470588684,
0.48608893156051636,
0.10122690349817276,
-0.4207504093647003,
0.13364048302173615,
-0.6827108263969421,
0.5834868550300598,
0.04366903007030487,
-0.2672692537307739,
-0.3804192543029785,
-0.37357017397880554,
0.26391878724098206,
-0.1815895289182663,
0.3602142930030823,
-0.5149672627449036,
-0.2511054575443268,
0.8042784929275513,
-0.41840171813964844,
0.8860135674476624,
-0.37977761030197144,
-0.4879950284957886,
-0.05022677406668663,
-0.09844613820314407,
0.7187211513519287,
0.09011006355285645,
-0.16502518951892853,
0.133561372756958,
0.3019867539405823,
-0.6108746528625488,
-0.6723646521568298,
0.6789312362670898,
-0.7882750034332275,
-0.461640328168869,
-0.4464452564716339,
-0.8029508590698242,
-0.6925495266914368,
-0.1458136886358261,
-0.0938100516796112,
0.020466003566980362,
-0.11721830815076828,
0.1149224191904068,
0.5821877121925354,
-0.15116922557353973,
0.4378802180290222,
0.37567710876464844,
-0.22661904990673065,
-0.4502028524875641,
0.7935823798179626,
0.12170795351266861,
0.5220815539360046,
0.4615122079849243,
0.21137674152851105,
-0.09697955846786499,
-0.9742387533187866,
-0.45245635509490967,
0.23164419829845428,
-0.6835484504699707,
-0.10531925410032272,
-0.27350351214408875,
-0.027711784467101097,
-0.5616233348846436,
-0.4141349494457245,
-0.17959538102149963,
-0.5023736357688904,
-0.33975571393966675,
0.11591479182243347,
0.3576841354370117,
0.3513619601726532,
0.19595219194889069,
0.6577585339546204,
-0.39832156896591187,
0.35640960931777954,
0.47883763909339905,
0.0087516400963068,
-0.22901740670204163,
-1.1636203527450562,
-0.17054878175258636,
0.18729953467845917,
0.1191912367939949,
-0.560218095779419,
0.4690234065055847,
0.8095903992652893,
0.5593996644020081,
0.43305426836013794,
0.05841095745563507,
0.9262517690658569,
-0.24997363984584808,
0.477985680103302,
0.022106505930423737,
-0.742867648601532,
0.37559133768081665,
-0.46815720200538635,
0.5201570391654968,
0.751289963722229,
0.08087074011564255,
-0.2616328001022339,
-0.2859993577003479,
-0.154728502035141,
-0.7510362863540649,
0.41084566712379456,
-0.11695810407400131,
0.15523730218410492,
0.22637850046157837,
0.051999080926179886,
-0.032691724598407745,
0.10535531491041183,
-0.6457555890083313,
0.08884581178426743,
0.14527060091495514,
-0.5404689311981201,
-0.536412239074707,
-0.23514693975448608,
-0.2070273607969284,
-0.17158423364162445,
0.7217726707458496,
-0.7784964442253113,
0.3020778298377991,
-0.1825096756219864,
-0.48141613602638245,
-0.11453491449356079,
0.4178914427757263,
0.7054183483123779,
0.8370436429977417,
-0.5676476359367371,
0.13075532019138336,
0.6451419591903687,
-0.4684121012687683,
-0.026198260486125946,
0.23620738089084625,
0.02923770435154438,
-0.08135263621807098,
0.4529501497745514,
0.7057444453239441,
0.7406514286994934,
-0.6702779531478882,
0.6454573273658752,
0.0990232452750206,
-0.24176450073719025,
0.06617765128612518,
0.18553204834461212,
0.34128525853157043,
0.2988045811653137,
0.6194089651107788,
-0.0638684630393982,
-0.20797564089298248,
-0.5352969169616699,
-0.15791861712932587,
0.6254464983940125,
-0.14660464227199554,
-0.2428945153951645,
0.4186958968639374,
-0.09202416986227036,
0.16121847927570343,
0.07877914607524872,
0.08290892094373703,
-0.029451828449964523,
0.2603423595428467,
0.6722877621650696,
0.6019564867019653,
-0.17741014063358307,
0.22897717356681824,
0.15522772073745728,
0.3484104871749878,
-0.4282290041446686,
0.38433781266212463,
0.03615444153547287,
-0.7672760486602783,
-0.5354170203208923,
-0.9611955285072327,
-0.6520618796348572,
-0.19507142901420593,
-0.72870934009552,
0.2767528295516968,
-0.7110530734062195,
-0.03480148687958717,
-0.10536060482263565,
0.16114398837089539,
-0.4410829246044159,
0.014626463875174522,
0.18787343800067902,
0.9403364062309265,
-1.0618904829025269,
1.188651442527771,
0.4554791748523712,
-0.07902350276708603,
-0.17083270847797394,
-0.07821805030107498,
-0.34442806243896484,
-0.8646391034126282,
0.3351873755455017,
-0.20306070148944855,
-0.26582857966423035,
0.14562812447547913,
-0.3822738826274872,
-1.0302379131317139,
1.0327948331832886,
0.6380859017372131,
-0.6048412919044495,
-0.1568974256515503,
0.08859992772340775,
0.6087148189544678,
-0.4774250090122223,
0.10432100296020508,
0.7132464647293091,
0.2903273403644562,
0.05641711875796318,
-0.7251848578453064,
-0.02407793328166008,
0.12523263692855835,
0.27985745668411255,
0.1184336319565773,
-0.374757319688797,
0.57676100730896,
-0.1675262600183487,
-0.10316791385412216,
0.18761877715587616,
0.7828055024147034,
0.4260815382003784,
0.08400970697402954,
0.5086435079574585,
0.5892935991287231,
0.9460077881813049,
0.09669461846351624,
0.6000444889068604,
0.031493451446294785,
0.32837557792663574,
1.3886494636535645,
-0.5123958587646484,
1.4336689710617065,
0.7220272421836853,
-0.556106448173523,
0.5537437796592712,
0.49494248628616333,
0.0006619886844418943,
0.7272769808769226,
0.1994991898536682,
-0.2593119740486145,
-0.31708014011383057,
0.1838066428899765,
-0.3789687752723694,
0.2546185553073883,
0.5688024759292603,
-0.2810582220554352,
-0.3207203447818756,
-0.026063820347189903,
-0.18910205364227295,
-0.10373584926128387,
-0.6634504795074463,
0.6669588685035706,
0.26448777318000793,
-0.224488765001297,
0.6056858897209167,
0.020407844334840775,
0.886313796043396,
-0.6484283208847046,
0.23249037563800812,
-0.11058928817510605,
0.35091567039489746,
-0.13043080270290375,
-0.28407320380210876,
-0.03306977078318596,
-0.2367207258939743,
-0.1812754124403,
0.014899244531989098,
0.8853039741516113,
-0.49912601709365845,
-1.0130583047866821,
0.32819947600364685,
0.36516717076301575,
-0.0433080829679966,
-0.04635497182607651,
-0.553365170955658,
-0.08293842524290085,
-0.4744717478752136,
-0.35382136702537537,
0.6987364292144775,
0.048774804919958115,
-0.15706251561641693,
0.7076719999313354,
0.7589096426963806,
0.4857438802719116,
0.24850545823574066,
0.23878243565559387,
0.5462350249290466,
-0.5801060795783997,
-0.5113494396209717,
-0.6874308586120605,
0.2065253108739853,
0.05886281281709671,
-0.12294595688581467,
0.6560778617858887,
-0.01036478579044342,
0.5058674216270447,
-0.006847661919891834,
0.8040740489959717,
0.03652213513851166,
0.45161333680152893,
-0.6538691520690918,
0.7009434700012207,
-0.5583850145339966,
0.1439962536096573,
-0.41233912110328674,
-1.156793475151062,
-0.4825994074344635,
0.7572908401489258,
-0.5646774768829346,
0.06316334754228592,
0.44599151611328125,
0.9317460060119629,
-0.22150516510009766,
-0.3764171004295349,
0.5360608100891113,
0.07842474430799484,
0.2281014323234558,
0.7372703552246094,
0.44674786925315857,
-0.452296644449234,
0.28551167249679565,
-0.04280072823166847,
-0.22287704050540924,
-0.588486909866333,
-1.1752312183380127,
-0.9416742920875549,
-0.12534968554973602,
-0.4298611879348755,
-0.11748243123292923,
0.07826122641563416,
1.0023491382598877,
0.7841419577598572,
-1.096327781677246,
-0.16141776740550995,
0.14788612723350525,
0.07499193400144577,
-0.5690079927444458,
-0.1419260948896408,
0.3334444761276245,
-0.2749473452568054,
-0.8107134699821472,
0.7415927052497864,
0.27975210547447205,
-0.04530484601855278,
-0.3469597101211548,
-0.04913009703159332,
-0.22039449214935303,
0.3276834189891815,
0.6295505166053772,
0.23397178947925568,
-0.46491310000419617,
-0.4918396770954132,
-0.5902255773544312,
-0.2680191397666931,
0.09513213485479355,
0.3759733736515045,
-0.44539204239845276,
0.2769084572792053,
0.6623441576957703,
0.7478588223457336,
0.4216383993625641,
0.21503746509552002,
0.6689366698265076,
-0.6697466373443604,
0.13213731348514557,
-0.08725707978010178,
0.4218887686729431,
0.2599596083164215,
0.011647957377135754,
0.5180625915527344,
0.06250863522291183,
-0.5508121848106384,
-1.1518385410308838,
-0.031318578869104385,
-1.2984519004821777,
-0.2109573930501938,
1.1268284320831299,
0.01582839898765087,
-0.33013680577278137,
0.017082922160625458,
-0.03222797065973282,
-0.0920836329460144,
-0.3162403404712677,
0.7402046322822571,
0.7558025121688843,
0.08282957971096039,
-0.18613843619823456,
-0.835285484790802,
0.3273499310016632,
0.52369624376297,
-0.9075992703437805,
0.2178122103214264,
0.3674730658531189,
0.4353051483631134,
-0.1268632560968399,
0.41235312819480896,
0.30782434344291687,
0.17127999663352966,
-0.17782703042030334,
-0.02316497638821602,
0.44438689947128296,
-0.0301981158554554,
-0.7379526495933533,
0.17623163759708405,
0.4542172849178314,
-0.06535901129245758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03387v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03387v1
|
The high dimensional psychological profile and cultural bias of ChatGPT
| 2024-05-06T11:45:59 | 2024-05-06T11:45:59 |
Hang Yuan, Zhongyue Che, Shao Li, Yue Zhang, Xiaomeng Hu, Siyang Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Given the rapid advancement of large-scale language models, artificial
intelligence (AI) models, like ChatGPT, are playing an increasingly prominent
role in human society. However, to ensure that artificial intelligence models
benefit human society, we must first fully understand the similarities and
differences between the human-like characteristics exhibited by artificial
intelligence models and real humans, as well as the cultural stereotypes and
biases that artificial intelligence models may exhibit in the process of
interacting with humans. This study first measured ChatGPT in 84 dimensions of
psychological characteristics, revealing differences between ChatGPT and human
norms in most dimensions as well as in high-dimensional psychological
representations. Additionally, through the measurement of ChatGPT in 13
dimensions of cultural values, it was revealed that ChatGPT's cultural value
patterns are dissimilar to those of various countries/regions worldwide.
Finally, an analysis of ChatGPT's performance in eight decision-making tasks
involving interactions with humans from different countries/regions revealed
that ChatGPT exhibits clear cultural stereotypes in most decision-making tasks
and shows significant cultural bias in third-party punishment and ultimatum
games. The findings indicate that, compared to humans, ChatGPT exhibits a
distinct psychological profile and cultural value orientation, and it also
shows cultural biases and stereotypes in interpersonal decision-making. Future
research endeavors should emphasize enhanced technical oversight and augmented
transparency in the database and algorithmic training procedures to foster more
efficient cross-cultural communication and mitigate social disparities.
|
[
-0.720407247543335,
-0.6545428037643433,
0.11831984668970108,
0.5281534194946289,
0.20966370403766632,
0.31346991658210754,
-0.3025956153869629,
-0.6469994187355042,
0.15567666292190552,
0.25137707591056824,
-0.6178817749023438,
-0.1492919623851776,
-0.6582643985748291,
-0.22558650374412537,
0.10724597424268723,
1.1387386322021484,
0.2445894479751587,
0.2122558057308197,
-0.04768801108002663,
-0.07065248489379883,
-0.4709385335445404,
-1.1851131916046143,
-0.6929954290390015,
-0.5431059002876282,
0.08942258358001709,
0.24510377645492554,
0.942244291305542,
0.4203711450099945,
0.648563802242279,
0.1875132918357849,
-0.04945870116353035,
-0.26898959279060364,
-0.6054078936576843,
-0.2974235713481903,
-0.09658519923686981,
-0.5001688599586487,
-0.4702353775501251,
0.6319824457168579,
0.23606078326702118,
0.44972851872444153,
0.04096487537026405,
0.4244200885295868,
0.10802733898162842,
0.7992867231369019,
-0.13328544795513153,
0.6058960556983948,
-0.2229335457086563,
0.31649717688560486,
-0.23836582899093628,
0.09099312871694565,
-0.15019230544567108,
-0.4777314364910126,
0.43517830967903137,
-0.3828478455543518,
0.26946336030960083,
0.03415173664689064,
0.7612428665161133,
0.25571754574775696,
-0.7716091871261597,
-0.21510104835033417,
-1.1266982555389404,
0.63984215259552,
-0.13417084515094757,
0.18683341145515442,
0.6087663769721985,
0.4075959324836731,
0.06705915927886963,
-0.17349274456501007,
-0.3568795323371887,
-0.4647892415523529,
-0.08784977346658707,
0.17871707677841187,
0.03998854011297226,
-0.0006771967164240777,
0.5548934936523438,
0.08754397183656693,
-0.41844168305397034,
0.13482649624347687,
-0.6192584037780762,
-0.36628004908561707,
0.9323721528053284,
0.2600705623626709,
0.32654476165771484,
-0.06869146972894669,
-0.20789200067520142,
-0.3134656846523285,
-0.5872855186462402,
0.30080515146255493,
0.5153229832649231,
0.03757236525416374,
-0.20674735307693481,
0.32661154866218567,
-0.3437177836894989,
-0.045289114117622375,
-0.08461769670248032,
-0.11653570085763931,
0.26925453543663025,
-0.13224929571151733,
0.25739923119544983,
0.14500370621681213,
0.7989165782928467,
0.5109992027282715,
0.8705485463142395,
0.135525181889534,
0.31804701685905457,
0.41498085856437683,
0.11792922019958496,
-0.8942090272903442,
-0.22658982872962952,
-0.06049938127398491,
-0.8706232905387878,
-0.17350658774375916,
-0.06382587552070618,
-0.8519842624664307,
-0.5303503274917603,
-0.18021680414676666,
0.13892138004302979,
-0.4801672399044037,
-0.2181473970413208,
-0.12306863069534302,
-0.08163726329803467,
0.4444738030433655,
0.17624926567077637,
-0.8155460357666016,
0.32825931906700134,
0.5900830030441284,
0.7531672716140747,
-0.23129838705062866,
-0.3532724976539612,
0.16154874861240387,
-0.2371222823858261,
-0.22304852306842804,
0.6144340634346008,
-0.777291476726532,
-0.42713236808776855,
-0.3265882134437561,
-0.518659234046936,
0.09414023160934448,
-0.2910109758377075,
0.672200083732605,
-0.21797825396060944,
0.4436059594154358,
-0.5689886212348938,
-0.18440140783786774,
-0.3514825701713562,
0.36064624786376953,
-0.3406199514865875,
0.7246943116188049,
-0.05258486419916153,
-0.5606709122657776,
0.7127283811569214,
-0.8954284191131592,
-0.30080273747444153,
0.25163358449935913,
-0.3218728005886078,
-0.18276657164096832,
-0.2298114001750946,
0.29452377557754517,
0.2004070281982422,
-0.25742846727371216,
0.0452796034514904,
-0.2327757477760315,
-0.5943819880485535,
0.2511787414550781,
-0.7519835233688354,
1.0365211963653564,
0.22595886886119843,
-0.3797835111618042,
-0.10027987509965897,
-0.6090164184570312,
-0.16932031512260437,
0.11225803196430206,
-0.3938411772251129,
-0.10718058794736862,
0.2964736819267273,
-0.012373332865536213,
0.7742481827735901,
0.2579980492591858,
-0.5400422811508179,
0.13753925263881683,
-0.025680024176836014,
0.687757670879364,
0.7680413126945496,
-0.006440720055252314,
0.24278956651687622,
-0.40392860770225525,
0.6552360653877258,
-0.03975911810994148,
0.5460688471794128,
0.32679253816604614,
-0.581416130065918,
-0.4194418787956238,
-0.2449205070734024,
0.04674233868718147,
0.9351846575737,
-0.0899851992726326,
0.36799290776252747,
-0.13050584495067596,
-0.5791426301002502,
-0.515553891658783,
-0.28627824783325195,
0.21616984903812408,
0.20629224181175232,
-0.07173076272010803,
-0.5017964243888855,
-0.2564619183540344,
-1.0869613885879517,
-0.3517957925796509,
-0.4285378158092499,
-0.1497909128665924,
0.5966526865959167,
0.6124882102012634,
-0.006994716823101044,
0.7835184335708618,
-0.3121128976345062,
-0.5378226041793823,
0.04743050038814545,
0.13685178756713867,
0.18817737698554993,
0.40803295373916626,
0.5968637466430664,
-0.8003066182136536,
-0.5362095236778259,
-0.08291879296302795,
-0.8111715316772461,
0.11418808996677399,
-0.08501117676496506,
-0.29545313119888306,
-0.013150571845471859,
0.1839999407529831,
-0.6526560187339783,
0.5708078742027283,
0.1621081531047821,
-0.5572790503501892,
0.7512864470481873,
-0.16802620887756348,
0.46369674801826477,
-0.6174440383911133,
-0.059695836156606674,
0.11554007232189178,
0.3111429214477539,
-0.5524001717567444,
-0.17481666803359985,
-0.1035153940320015,
-0.22015200555324554,
-0.11035077273845673,
0.35179904103279114,
-0.0827210322022438,
-0.08392737805843353,
0.17247240245342255,
-0.04147995635867119,
-0.24856999516487122,
0.6469759941101074,
0.16511206328868866,
0.7912258505821228,
0.38854241371154785,
-0.26997536420822144,
0.5421836376190186,
0.4190879166126251,
-0.4778226912021637,
0.8995997309684753,
-0.6429096460342407,
0.09755145013332367,
-0.29202669858932495,
0.48601895570755005,
-0.6296101808547974,
-0.10074623674154282,
0.047421399503946304,
-0.5805419087409973,
-0.36868205666542053,
0.002700500888749957,
-0.5096652507781982,
-0.3606468141078949,
-0.04328737035393715,
0.4109724164009094,
0.9503535628318787,
0.011555508710443974,
0.41502732038497925,
0.434409499168396,
-0.19875815510749817,
-0.43826839327812195,
-0.4960125684738159,
0.18238571286201477,
-0.5046249032020569,
-0.6852625012397766,
0.14336124062538147,
-0.15000557899475098,
-0.48160073161125183,
-0.4181540012359619,
0.1327695995569229,
0.16665227711200714,
0.010747689753770828,
0.27693265676498413,
0.18456314504146576,
-0.10478202998638153,
-0.140871062874794,
-0.5227042436599731,
-0.1843847930431366,
0.37963491678237915,
-0.19121205806732178,
0.7485538125038147,
-0.393153578042984,
-0.4101920425891876,
-0.4747989773750305,
0.36038658022880554,
0.6836010217666626,
-0.5294962525367737,
0.8156061172485352,
0.8072670698165894,
-0.05637264996767044,
0.3288651406764984,
-0.4680635631084442,
-0.3348454236984253,
-0.3768995404243469,
0.6547739505767822,
-0.2373342365026474,
-0.6100201606750488,
0.8405200839042664,
0.17839770019054413,
-0.13408540189266205,
0.1422189176082611,
0.7314132452011108,
-0.029063934460282326,
1.5988019704818726,
0.594281792640686,
-0.3771404027938843,
0.4216817617416382,
0.05055942013859749,
0.5647351741790771,
-0.41326597332954407,
-0.40482836961746216,
-0.537389874458313,
-0.5773048400878906,
-1.1784617900848389,
-0.0027817704249173403,
0.7468302249908447,
-0.3066703677177429,
-0.9870753884315491,
-0.45320725440979004,
-0.5598422288894653,
0.4888785481452942,
0.8947052955627441,
0.12548834085464478,
0.051884591579437256,
-0.0465858019888401,
0.04722823202610016,
-0.20307785272598267,
-0.36594128608703613,
-0.5043910145759583,
0.7484565377235413,
0.5415998697280884,
0.7849128842353821,
0.0034615674521774054,
0.3470609486103058,
0.5224890112876892,
-0.05746094882488251,
-0.6323282122612,
0.42828139662742615,
0.005306207109242678,
-0.756151020526886,
-0.2520952522754669,
-0.2734745442867279,
-0.5792273879051208,
0.23449748754501343,
-0.17591044306755066,
-1.0635470151901245,
0.0626329779624939,
0.05114268884062767,
-0.25313884019851685,
0.11608724296092987,
-0.8564583659172058,
0.7260311841964722,
-0.2575610280036926,
-0.1027788370847702,
-0.23601582646369934,
-0.7953541278839111,
0.3715777099132538,
0.13584205508232117,
0.2533119022846222,
-0.4483568072319031,
0.3123135566711426,
0.754164457321167,
-0.07923289388418198,
0.8804537057876587,
-0.23766812682151794,
0.11972036212682724,
-0.07959701865911484,
0.40183284878730774,
0.3985103964805603,
0.12409397959709167,
-0.1799444556236267,
0.374415785074234,
0.28525620698928833,
-0.6513131260871887,
-0.37855008244514465,
0.46659377217292786,
-1.4132763147354126,
-0.7327151298522949,
-0.4920496344566345,
-0.8003013730049133,
-0.3242037892341614,
0.012098955921828747,
0.24655526876449585,
0.24290895462036133,
-0.4852132201194763,
0.05186951160430908,
0.47982242703437805,
-0.5640991926193237,
0.1684645563364029,
0.15598896145820618,
-0.13429732620716095,
0.13706979155540466,
0.8934059143066406,
0.1267256885766983,
0.284334272146225,
0.07307033985853195,
0.24668344855308533,
-0.025228746235370636,
-0.023960087448358536,
-0.15571123361587524,
0.1227368488907814,
-0.5404881834983826,
0.42897018790245056,
-0.3877127766609192,
-0.3936781883239746,
-0.37206050753593445,
-0.03432491421699524,
-0.2976328432559967,
-0.16310343146324158,
0.31408482789993286,
0.004024356137961149,
0.30669718980789185,
0.7724446654319763,
-0.035508450120687485,
0.3174286186695099,
-0.4471766948699951,
0.02017921209335327,
0.144450381398201,
0.39235860109329224,
0.03742112219333649,
-0.233387291431427,
-0.12588268518447876,
0.34832608699798584,
-0.33473828434944153,
-0.5399131178855896,
0.3100898861885071,
0.0330696702003479,
0.4692976474761963,
0.5506052374839783,
0.05792567878961563,
0.3764022886753082,
-0.29572609066963196,
1.0549142360687256,
-0.4520236849784851,
-0.6746871471405029,
0.3796849846839905,
-0.5177379846572876,
0.28804972767829895,
0.16221541166305542,
0.48648080229759216,
-1.0614097118377686,
-0.24783462285995483,
-0.6242032051086426,
-0.40290743112564087,
0.9418395161628723,
0.2601045072078705,
0.37721988558769226,
0.02092941477894783,
0.13096043467521667,
0.0439680777490139,
0.07638926059007645,
-0.8860104084014893,
-0.3508646786212921,
-0.27536967396736145,
-0.015007893554866314,
0.002342764986678958,
-0.11048766225576401,
-0.16418951749801636,
-0.2327014058828354,
0.5393331050872803,
0.08403261005878448,
0.5177247524261475,
-0.10783839970827103,
0.16817082464694977,
0.05251754820346832,
0.09881996363401413,
0.451969176530838,
0.6594799757003784,
-0.2597103714942932,
-0.2126086801290512,
0.20767097175121307,
-0.6791739463806152,
0.19053852558135986,
-0.06648630648851395,
-0.09414028376340866,
-0.6659142971038818,
0.4316164553165436,
0.7509725689888,
-0.6684641242027283,
-0.5745419859886169,
0.3778361976146698,
-0.28999850153923035,
-0.1925324946641922,
-0.4550759792327881,
0.10069480538368225,
-0.20343489944934845,
0.3839426636695862,
0.24471689760684967,
0.2653162181377411,
-0.02694864012300968,
-0.7994193434715271,
-0.0752868503332138,
0.5177474617958069,
-0.5295068025588989,
-0.21243436634540558,
0.6108784079551697,
0.1901463270187378,
-0.5293108224868774,
1.1812940835952759,
-0.18858702480793,
-0.7577849626541138,
0.6604135632514954,
0.2534860670566559,
0.47600090503692627,
-0.09632652997970581,
0.510992169380188,
0.09485641121864319,
0.45689836144447327,
0.11754915118217468,
0.11714612692594528,
0.02320348657667637,
-0.9727979302406311,
-0.20338375866413116,
-0.47126564383506775,
-0.1681591123342514,
-0.0538736954331398,
-0.5446367859840393,
0.13618770241737366,
-0.3722386360168457,
-0.05478404462337494,
-0.24638569355010986,
0.24087119102478027,
-0.9032503962516785,
0.21694432199001312,
0.32584041357040405,
0.6221011877059937,
-0.8802396655082703,
0.635110080242157,
0.443854421377182,
-0.5424228310585022,
-0.5644715428352356,
0.15407860279083252,
0.30375808477401733,
-1.068907618522644,
1.0281552076339722,
0.16433866322040558,
0.08852659910917282,
-0.3186831772327423,
-0.361173152923584,
-0.974258542060852,
0.7723134756088257,
0.14038412272930145,
-0.020716536790132523,
-0.28661754727363586,
0.593308687210083,
0.8294703364372253,
-0.2641136050224304,
0.6356381773948669,
0.897487461566925,
0.4745343029499054,
-0.12172073870897293,
-1.1420942544937134,
-0.19821354746818542,
-0.2464180886745453,
0.1690467894077301,
0.19818998873233795,
-1.1843764781951904,
0.8297799825668335,
-0.0827297791838646,
0.0043827686458826065,
-0.33036455512046814,
0.363587349653244,
0.264840692281723,
-0.12264729291200638,
0.2590423822402954,
0.07234421372413635,
0.5915396213531494,
-0.10721055418252945,
0.8733021020889282,
-0.34848925471305847,
0.1593914031982422,
0.6073693633079529,
-0.3977740406990051,
0.2772361934185028,
0.09334811568260193,
-0.3568245768547058,
0.4320855736732483,
0.8292816281318665,
-0.2098979502916336,
0.3016486167907715,
0.1889500916004181,
-0.044274717569351196,
-0.0750465989112854,
-0.30675753951072693,
-0.19484834372997284,
1.0965445041656494,
0.4843403398990631,
-0.19974230229854584,
0.06530682742595673,
0.1767721027135849,
0.1958489716053009,
-0.06927371770143509,
-0.3201908767223358,
0.6819285154342651,
-0.24277742207050323,
-0.7130088210105896,
0.2911139726638794,
-0.1652657687664032,
0.7844100594520569,
-0.4064081013202667,
-0.024799508973956108,
-0.32006600499153137,
0.27993112802505493,
-0.042198341339826584,
-0.8398573994636536,
0.0744176059961319,
-0.09768933802843094,
-0.16221430897712708,
-0.23077470064163208,
0.41951918601989746,
-0.019396761432290077,
-0.38713231682777405,
0.20068955421447754,
0.5700441002845764,
0.32587793469429016,
-0.21168400347232819,
-0.7537806630134583,
-0.2206161618232727,
0.07998845726251602,
-0.22233493626117706,
0.4727056324481964,
0.5005137324333191,
-0.5639036297798157,
0.9334504008293152,
0.3194264769554138,
0.23429886996746063,
-0.1353963315486908,
0.024776075035333633,
0.13686519861221313,
-0.7055411338806152,
-0.7607612013816833,
-1.0828367471694946,
0.0962107852101326,
-0.22614353895187378,
-0.4248277544975281,
0.4787343144416809,
0.30788978934288025,
0.8935002684593201,
0.10810445994138718,
0.9441395998001099,
-0.2971058189868927,
0.1941421627998352,
-0.21026048064231873,
0.841612696647644,
0.1372898519039154,
0.08272269368171692,
-0.15551650524139404,
-0.9192003607749939,
0.0934874415397644,
0.6510262489318848,
-0.6110479831695557,
0.5604915618896484,
0.3509993255138397,
0.6564352512359619,
0.18634538352489471,
0.19528602063655853,
0.24026113748550415,
0.3642054498195648,
0.5601072311401367,
0.5157379508018494,
0.9389697909355164,
0.016737373545765877,
0.4622463285923004,
-0.44947707653045654,
-0.5521706938743591,
-0.04423781856894493,
-0.6215699911117554,
-1.0080269575119019,
-0.6814427375793457,
-0.035528331995010376,
-0.14776219427585602,
-0.28183767199516296,
1.1352465152740479,
0.9122008085250854,
-0.5596476197242737,
-0.4942925274372101,
0.5395673513412476,
-0.04184076189994812,
-0.5340704321861267,
-0.3365927040576935,
0.3802737295627594,
0.019128741696476936,
-0.6390633583068848,
-0.3772282600402832,
0.2456437349319458,
-0.1314416229724884,
-0.5237345099449158,
0.06194031983613968,
0.03686080873012543,
0.15294940769672394,
0.7845743894577026,
-0.027531059458851814,
-0.7379674911499023,
-0.622266948223114,
-0.15094512701034546,
-0.009378299117088318,
0.20045079290866852,
0.6160381436347961,
-0.6465909481048584,
0.04712618514895439,
0.46291491389274597,
0.16363267600536346,
0.37332889437675476,
-0.043662410229444504,
0.806429386138916,
-0.5422487258911133,
0.23898841440677643,
0.1598203182220459,
0.18815062940120697,
0.06512714177370071,
-0.7305939793586731,
0.5019449591636658,
0.11637058109045029,
-0.9634707570075989,
-0.444394052028656,
0.3096461296081543,
-0.5295092463493347,
-0.10167000442743301,
0.795879065990448,
0.09094255417585373,
0.11966703087091446,
-0.042210470885038376,
-0.6515152454376221,
0.17816948890686035,
-0.525949239730835,
1.2336071729660034,
0.9991930723190308,
-0.6696752905845642,
-0.1863836646080017,
-0.9524192214012146,
0.7507089972496033,
0.30715179443359375,
-0.6404884457588196,
0.10785500705242157,
0.4369909167289734,
0.09636880457401276,
0.1456500142812729,
0.3135836124420166,
-0.15925104916095734,
0.1163962110877037,
0.03676348552107811,
0.22626814246177673,
0.2086390256881714,
0.014139501377940178,
0.04214605689048767,
0.10705892741680145,
0.09130121767520905,
0.04997818544507027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03371v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03371v2
|
Explainable Fake News Detection With Large Language Model via Defense Among Competing Wisdom
| 2024-05-06T11:24:13 | 2024-06-20T04:33:33 |
Bo Wang, Jing Ma, Hongzhan Lin, Zhiwei Yang, Ruichao Yang, Yuan Tian, Yi Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Most fake news detection methods learn latent feature representations based
on neural networks, which makes them black boxes to classify a piece of news
without giving any justification. Existing explainable systems generate
veracity justifications from investigative journalism, which suffer from
debunking delayed and low efficiency. Recent studies simply assume that the
justification is equivalent to the majority opinions expressed in the wisdom of
crowds. However, the opinions typically contain some inaccurate or biased
information since the wisdom of crowds is uncensored. To detect fake news from
a sea of diverse, crowded and even competing narratives, in this paper, we
propose a novel defense-based explainable fake news detection framework.
Specifically, we first propose an evidence extraction module to split the
wisdom of crowds into two competing parties and respectively detect salient
evidences. To gain concise insights from evidences, we then design a
prompt-based module that utilizes a large language model to generate
justifications by inferring reasons towards two possible veracities. Finally,
we propose a defense-based inference module to determine veracity via modeling
the defense among these justifications. Extensive experiments conducted on two
real-world benchmarks demonstrate that our proposed method outperforms
state-of-the-art baselines in terms of fake news detection and provides
high-quality justifications.
|
[
-0.26254016160964966,
-0.9108505249023438,
0.7581601738929749,
0.04218965023756027,
-0.3916299343109131,
0.07530245184898376,
-0.01928023062646389,
-0.5111066699028015,
0.15548424422740936,
0.2660461962223053,
-0.4679466485977173,
-0.25253036618232727,
-0.3953988254070282,
-0.11970101296901703,
-0.45671236515045166,
0.8360031247138977,
0.22536809742450714,
-0.0007591264438815415,
-0.1580173671245575,
-0.17428159713745117,
-0.28032559156417847,
-0.4026291072368622,
-0.26133906841278076,
-0.11808498203754425,
0.312918096780777,
0.5379377007484436,
0.5247664451599121,
0.5404698848724365,
-0.13509882986545563,
0.28873375058174133,
-0.06344649940729141,
0.34576383233070374,
-0.29134371876716614,
-0.14668339490890503,
-0.5773118734359741,
-0.19408327341079712,
-0.06801861524581909,
0.06926804035902023,
0.3420308530330658,
0.25126129388809204,
-0.06804302334785461,
0.02085503749549389,
-0.411582350730896,
0.3097113072872162,
-0.465694397687912,
-0.2567088305950165,
-0.8513992428779602,
-0.0936138704419136,
-0.25223469734191895,
-0.15800818800926208,
-0.4958738088607788,
-0.276091992855072,
0.17744112014770508,
-0.4734897315502167,
0.3774090111255646,
0.00027593219419941306,
0.9814965724945068,
-0.13138537108898163,
-0.454385906457901,
-0.18546755611896515,
-0.4977225363254547,
0.6361582279205322,
-0.6816150546073914,
0.17280420660972595,
0.10481926798820496,
0.418513685464859,
0.0473259799182415,
-0.3546861410140991,
-0.9923913478851318,
-0.19894225895404816,
0.11345858126878738,
0.3030102550983429,
-0.6106752753257751,
-0.19358539581298828,
0.025646328926086426,
0.2383767068386078,
-0.7108039855957031,
0.29079848527908325,
-0.13359789550304413,
-0.3644241988658905,
0.6196256279945374,
-0.24725143611431122,
0.3499596118927002,
-0.2810373306274414,
-0.644766628742218,
0.004122430924326181,
-0.5506595969200134,
-0.11240596324205399,
0.6654680371284485,
0.03151022270321846,
-0.011526331305503845,
0.31317898631095886,
-0.5293776988983154,
0.5057363510131836,
0.1922755241394043,
-0.23378150165081024,
0.14170417189598083,
0.031574901193380356,
-0.1245308592915535,
0.3980264961719513,
0.7193842530250549,
0.3175604045391083,
0.09605380892753601,
-0.09846752136945724,
-0.2477913498878479,
0.2234228104352951,
0.3202178180217743,
-0.699823260307312,
-0.0483524426817894,
0.18425075709819794,
-0.7511727213859558,
-0.6678666472434998,
0.3090403378009796,
-0.882889449596405,
-0.5527700185775757,
0.0577932670712471,
0.499691367149353,
-0.42522671818733215,
-0.6744496822357178,
0.17727719247341156,
-0.36464768648147583,
0.017104055732488632,
0.38637855648994446,
-0.44913211464881897,
-0.06295628100633621,
0.7221627235412598,
0.8835887312889099,
-0.10930566489696503,
0.062281787395477295,
-0.6067952513694763,
-0.06811853498220444,
-0.419648140668869,
1.015526533126831,
-0.34619614481925964,
0.13349038362503052,
-0.10960584133863449,
0.047037992626428604,
0.39153969287872314,
-0.5452460050582886,
0.5507981777191162,
-0.8328515291213989,
0.33296263217926025,
-0.0733557790517807,
-0.5479410290718079,
-0.4549144506454468,
0.3977526128292084,
-0.6819800734519958,
0.5038014054298401,
-0.054579149931669235,
-0.7328248620033264,
0.38945725560188293,
-0.6105149388313293,
-0.5087171196937561,
0.30338573455810547,
0.10442877560853958,
-0.5491955876350403,
0.2750840187072754,
0.33247461915016174,
0.2965248227119446,
0.07925441861152649,
0.6036235690116882,
-0.4924335181713104,
-0.08161088079214096,
0.45760273933410645,
-0.8576576709747314,
0.8580119013786316,
0.4400356113910675,
-0.4984394907951355,
0.2177894413471222,
-0.6562566161155701,
-0.19593773782253265,
0.2656523585319519,
-0.163316011428833,
-0.5704310536384583,
0.034194692969322205,
-0.34694814682006836,
0.09624294191598892,
0.01867460086941719,
-0.6165420413017273,
-0.013722468167543411,
-0.3271213173866272,
0.30291101336479187,
0.7262775897979736,
0.09282657504081726,
0.3498435914516449,
-0.24085460603237152,
0.37198272347450256,
0.29350966215133667,
0.12454535067081451,
-0.4198938310146332,
-0.4018016755580902,
-0.49599483609199524,
-0.20323063433170319,
0.1682608276605606,
0.44982337951660156,
-0.994752049446106,
0.34986892342567444,
-0.20519420504570007,
-0.25922316312789917,
-0.48864659667015076,
-0.15313173830509186,
0.4198545217514038,
0.5713658928871155,
0.3589775264263153,
0.007236844394356012,
-0.4879613518714905,
-0.9111923575401306,
-0.6673509478569031,
-0.33661216497421265,
-0.00453674141317606,
-0.18222418427467346,
0.44927114248275757,
0.2751046419143677,
1.023325800895691,
-0.215663880109787,
0.1320885717868805,
-0.31651514768600464,
0.04296257346868515,
0.19791072607040405,
0.23542247712612152,
0.47595176100730896,
-1.3020615577697754,
-0.0873148962855339,
0.018435131758451462,
-0.7600809931755066,
-0.3975314199924469,
-0.2821897268295288,
-0.07871554791927338,
0.29644930362701416,
0.3857060372829437,
-0.7113824486732483,
0.5288372039794922,
0.33475032448768616,
-0.5738464593887329,
0.7958135008811951,
0.20099589228630066,
0.03451620042324066,
-1.0420116186141968,
-0.1711222380399704,
0.2413281500339508,
-0.5340546369552612,
-0.6571088433265686,
0.11791665852069855,
0.01470476295799017,
0.10452908277511597,
-0.4096216559410095,
0.5932343006134033,
-0.2554236948490143,
0.14683344960212708,
-0.639275074005127,
0.08727847784757614,
0.27271831035614014,
0.0789024755358696,
0.1817346215248108,
0.16685064136981964,
0.28950607776641846,
-0.5418589115142822,
0.8287747502326965,
-0.18375281989574432,
-0.6083733439445496,
0.7592670321464539,
-0.7023730874061584,
-0.29279619455337524,
-0.13655896484851837,
0.5874500870704651,
-0.7988150715827942,
-0.38469910621643066,
0.39651545882225037,
-0.7578688263893127,
-0.029640601947903633,
-0.5645030736923218,
-0.611787736415863,
-0.5407108068466187,
-0.037462856620550156,
0.1833259016275406,
0.3255481719970703,
-0.9794230461120605,
0.3663042485713959,
0.15968726575374603,
0.043510619550943375,
-0.6091929078102112,
-0.6487030982971191,
0.2835681140422821,
-0.5473242998123169,
-0.7542437314987183,
0.4042387902736664,
0.008435978554189205,
-0.6904550194740295,
0.2436722368001938,
-0.3980659246444702,
-0.10380042344331741,
0.13096089661121368,
0.15323153138160706,
0.2189178168773651,
-0.40161386132240295,
0.47353506088256836,
-0.08022135496139526,
0.07412168383598328,
0.14409443736076355,
-0.7684987187385559,
0.31653985381126404,
-0.0636008083820343,
-0.5172263979911804,
-0.7029035091400146,
0.4539514482021332,
0.7544652223587036,
-0.13787828385829926,
0.871370792388916,
0.5935609936714172,
-0.461040735244751,
-0.5520437955856323,
-0.8778419494628906,
-0.2813757359981537,
-0.4459581673145294,
0.5016204714775085,
-0.11325322836637497,
-0.5817673206329346,
0.3681716322898865,
-0.011068207211792469,
-0.12071746587753296,
0.5120707750320435,
0.4359295666217804,
0.3669348955154419,
0.8240638375282288,
0.24792291224002838,
-0.050327740609645844,
0.4349355697631836,
0.04370889440178871,
0.19648002088069916,
0.18449722230434418,
-0.3172791302204132,
-0.15559014678001404,
-0.06656086444854736,
-0.10658933967351913,
-0.21998387575149536,
0.03551069274544716,
0.014329850673675537,
-0.03674483671784401,
0.03667702153325081,
-0.5140929222106934,
0.7448152899742126,
0.5430651903152466,
0.26012277603149414,
0.42429253458976746,
0.21678617596626282,
0.08531367033720016,
0.21014201641082764,
-0.694301187992096,
-0.4235900640487671,
0.5678103566169739,
0.4949653744697571,
0.5218608975410461,
0.3800031840801239,
0.27669569849967957,
0.5682615637779236,
0.32113325595855713,
-0.8043257594108582,
0.4194822907447815,
-0.09048482775688171,
-0.7992558479309082,
-0.20217235386371613,
-0.6642105579376221,
-0.5606136918067932,
0.4079175293445587,
-0.16957159340381622,
-0.4002608358860016,
0.03418462350964546,
0.02160736545920372,
-0.3589467406272888,
0.6118404865264893,
-0.826378345489502,
0.7974116802215576,
-0.37302327156066895,
-0.4283757507801056,
-0.45919421315193176,
-0.43992429971694946,
0.6411659717559814,
-0.01677986979484558,
0.2700040340423584,
-0.06691214442253113,
0.1099376454949379,
0.5859421491622925,
-0.5377163887023926,
0.8833950161933899,
-0.43095725774765015,
-0.12439708411693573,
0.37822043895721436,
-0.03798184171319008,
0.29474371671676636,
0.38134557008743286,
-0.04605494812130928,
0.04053281247615814,
-0.47392338514328003,
-0.48534590005874634,
-0.4751264750957489,
0.7732551097869873,
-0.36033326387405396,
-0.733599841594696,
-0.29054877161979675,
-0.5244880318641663,
0.13633495569229126,
0.17938017845153809,
0.3948937952518463,
0.32618722319602966,
-0.37297913432121277,
0.07151549309492111,
0.9325463771820068,
-0.44615569710731506,
0.5499780178070068,
0.8347418904304504,
0.06147928535938263,
-0.2279219627380371,
1.0186352729797363,
0.14354276657104492,
0.03752182796597481,
0.3373572826385498,
0.4840112626552582,
-0.4319469630718231,
-0.6190781593322754,
-0.6130616068840027,
-0.1311560869216919,
-0.45900851488113403,
-0.24418486654758453,
-0.6498330235481262,
-0.13575521111488342,
-0.39400821924209595,
-0.052171748131513596,
-0.3255845904350281,
-0.3776513636112213,
-0.013891712762415409,
-0.11461848765611649,
0.4532947838306427,
0.642760694026947,
-0.15092313289642334,
0.1734616756439209,
-0.543204128742218,
0.6357439160346985,
0.5424572229385376,
0.1886608600616455,
0.09907624125480652,
-0.7803349494934082,
-0.21832573413848877,
0.2523966431617737,
-0.37282508611679077,
-1.1921168565750122,
0.39559051394462585,
-0.2183864712715149,
0.7084783911705017,
1.0034527778625488,
0.49253857135772705,
0.367585152387619,
-0.040694039314985275,
0.6830336451530457,
0.18173745274543762,
-0.9769567847251892,
0.599012553691864,
-0.45617398619651794,
0.08943042159080505,
0.11103612184524536,
0.3970267176628113,
-0.21453967690467834,
-0.11583039909601212,
-0.8275275826454163,
-0.6232622265815735,
0.6134584546089172,
-0.017790090292692184,
0.13943196833133698,
0.01893431693315506,
0.11048191040754318,
0.33201754093170166,
0.11957699805498123,
-1.193980097770691,
0.09481038898229599,
-0.5121350288391113,
-0.06643862277269363,
0.38980695605278015,
-0.24718905985355377,
-0.23937000334262848,
0.024754799902439117,
0.8471081852912903,
-0.0375552773475647,
0.02451905980706215,
0.18125402927398682,
-0.3286904990673065,
0.15237267315387726,
0.3588787913322449,
0.7329380512237549,
0.548281192779541,
0.1864256113767624,
0.3500814735889435,
0.003493614261969924,
-0.23849597573280334,
0.0920325219631195,
0.2955814003944397,
-0.2597690224647522,
0.33672836422920227,
0.4894123673439026,
0.6372800469398499,
-0.2373274713754654,
-0.6308563351631165,
0.9744396805763245,
0.09375524520874023,
-0.27883002161979675,
-0.530504047870636,
-0.0816386416554451,
0.08301909267902374,
0.4523508548736572,
0.8023232221603394,
0.24431434273719788,
-0.0203557126224041,
-0.5512351989746094,
0.15069255232810974,
0.5498827695846558,
-0.340933620929718,
-0.4227958619594574,
0.5020928978919983,
0.24841627478599548,
-0.07962969690561295,
0.2802581787109375,
-0.5154762268066406,
-0.7539429068565369,
0.7898300290107727,
0.5644638538360596,
0.5854352712631226,
-0.3792150914669037,
0.5183268189430237,
0.018539689481258392,
0.441649466753006,
-0.36577484011650085,
-0.10609804838895798,
0.06929931044578552,
-0.8585349917411804,
-0.39859452843666077,
-0.4166852831840515,
-0.02818712778389454,
0.7253209948539734,
-0.31139132380485535,
0.1736166924238205,
-0.24389120936393738,
0.19120052456855774,
0.17345334589481354,
-0.20475274324417114,
-0.14943945407867432,
0.08726119250059128,
0.39920109510421753,
0.9776095151901245,
-0.9202608466148376,
0.5009946823120117,
0.539251983165741,
-0.1731143444776535,
-0.38379618525505066,
0.3954245448112488,
0.4177521765232086,
-0.6124966144561768,
0.3030991554260254,
0.42157644033432007,
-0.018751021474599838,
-0.40170028805732727,
-0.863915741443634,
-0.2831359803676605,
0.6874901652336121,
0.581475555896759,
-0.43567225337028503,
0.13751636445522308,
-0.16592459380626678,
0.3336632549762726,
-0.47653642296791077,
0.05535239353775978,
0.046610865741968155,
0.6099517345428467,
0.06786837428808212,
-0.4144536852836609,
0.2101501077413559,
-0.29494786262512207,
-0.3271416127681732,
-0.16267599165439606,
-0.7794695496559143,
0.5878732800483704,
-0.38030752539634705,
-0.1672770231962204,
0.05232054367661476,
0.8953389525413513,
0.3224605917930603,
1.0522536039352417,
0.6965033411979675,
0.6728835105895996,
0.6746686697006226,
-0.057987987995147705,
0.8868393301963806,
0.0491352342069149,
-0.009119371883571148,
0.8933883905410767,
0.0192723348736763,
0.453043133020401,
0.15692736208438873,
0.20598331093788147,
0.8286666870117188,
0.6052433252334595,
-0.3143044710159302,
0.4657706916332245,
0.36905038356781006,
-0.6353407502174377,
-0.5079299211502075,
-0.3033164441585541,
-0.32997769117355347,
0.7086521983146667,
0.3365337550640106,
-0.5182262659072876,
-0.116785928606987,
0.20012523233890533,
0.2429487109184265,
0.28630608320236206,
-0.462436705827713,
0.5065199136734009,
-0.09051589667797089,
-0.865192174911499,
0.36045897006988525,
0.12356161326169968,
0.760843813419342,
-0.5191649794578552,
-0.006684449035674334,
-0.09721330553293228,
0.21387287974357605,
-0.37384724617004395,
-0.6205374598503113,
0.12742650508880615,
0.11214815825223923,
-0.4432568848133087,
-0.16229896247386932,
0.9818800091743469,
-0.46089601516723633,
-0.14050014317035675,
0.13029570877552032,
0.5877090692520142,
0.04552102088928223,
-0.5506296753883362,
-0.41126909852027893,
-0.21080650389194489,
-0.10303568840026855,
-0.36518871784210205,
0.20889005064964294,
0.8134471774101257,
-0.24128103256225586,
0.5882543921470642,
0.9030400514602661,
0.0018330537714064121,
-0.21831534802913666,
0.11321249604225159,
0.8791876435279846,
-0.35491612553596497,
-0.81615149974823,
-1.0605080127716064,
0.26376646757125854,
-0.5877044200897217,
-0.07928072661161423,
0.7731812596321106,
0.5550350546836853,
0.4589008688926697,
-0.08452438563108444,
1.0394682884216309,
0.09164122492074966,
0.5085387825965881,
-0.5780232548713684,
1.0347603559494019,
-0.5419135689735413,
0.2929055690765381,
-0.12511207163333893,
-0.6594977974891663,
-0.03863013535737991,
0.3851867914199829,
-0.11544886231422424,
0.024862518534064293,
0.5013613104820251,
0.7195620536804199,
-0.2810940742492676,
0.1569325476884842,
0.27901551127433777,
0.4491139054298401,
0.15924324095249176,
0.41261258721351624,
1.0769752264022827,
0.07160294055938721,
0.9664186835289001,
0.09826724976301193,
-0.3004545569419861,
-0.4059043228626251,
-1.005639910697937,
-0.931159257888794,
-0.41169342398643494,
-0.32832980155944824,
-0.7044191360473633,
0.23342366516590118,
0.38507479429244995,
1.0741580724716187,
-0.7093921303749084,
0.47646376490592957,
-0.19124342501163483,
0.4662995934486389,
-0.2713161110877991,
-0.4144231677055359,
0.20452064275741577,
0.17095904052257538,
-0.4105536937713623,
0.7283458113670349,
0.008432606235146523,
0.12734943628311157,
-0.2566637694835663,
-0.05971289798617363,
-0.14168263971805573,
0.3177429735660553,
0.42876145243644714,
0.5504404902458191,
-0.8861820697784424,
-0.3504430055618286,
-0.25310298800468445,
0.14597858488559723,
-0.38375338912010193,
0.6815143823623657,
-1.099965214729309,
0.3885175585746765,
0.45920059084892273,
0.513292670249939,
0.26172545552253723,
0.21007977426052094,
0.49883368611335754,
-0.8627356290817261,
0.1798761785030365,
0.04625655338168144,
0.2064361870288849,
0.42781761288642883,
-0.4365693926811218,
0.3083512485027313,
0.6667594909667969,
-0.333274781703949,
-0.8101071715354919,
0.38258928060531616,
-1.0182535648345947,
-0.712165892124176,
1.211076259613037,
-0.2164379507303238,
-0.18490415811538696,
-0.49017876386642456,
0.12466391175985336,
0.21045531332492828,
-0.6454757452011108,
1.0014928579330444,
0.7009697556495667,
0.34573739767074585,
-0.14360271394252777,
-0.4394799768924713,
0.3423370122909546,
0.23239544034004211,
-0.7342088222503662,
0.08262048661708832,
0.5979070067405701,
0.371262788772583,
0.2756817936897278,
0.3084458112716675,
-0.11014728993177414,
0.589654803276062,
0.09746900945901871,
-0.13987648487091064,
-0.3657851815223694,
-0.24764284491539001,
-0.3365132510662079,
0.3370324969291687,
-0.5986154675483704,
-0.10647077858448029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03359v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03359v1
|
MedDoc-Bot: A Chat Tool for Comparative Analysis of Large Language Models in the Context of the Pediatric Hypertension Guideline
| 2024-05-06T11:11:23 | 2024-05-06T11:11:23 |
Mohamed Yaseen Jabarulla, Steffen Oeltze-Jafra, Philipp Beerbaum, Theodor Uden
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
This research focuses on evaluating the non-commercial open-source large
language models (LLMs) Meditron, MedAlpaca, Mistral, and Llama-2 for their
efficacy in interpreting medical guidelines saved in PDF format. As a specific
test scenario, we applied these models to the guidelines for hypertension in
children and adolescents provided by the European Society of Cardiology (ESC).
Leveraging Streamlit, a Python library, we developed a user-friendly medical
document chatbot tool (MedDoc-Bot). This tool enables authorized users to
upload PDF files and pose questions, generating interpretive responses from
four locally stored LLMs. A pediatric expert provides a benchmark for
evaluation by formulating questions and responses extracted from the ESC
guidelines. The expert rates the model-generated responses based on their
fidelity and relevance. Additionally, we evaluated the METEOR and chrF metric
scores to assess the similarity of model responses to reference answers. Our
study found that Llama-2 and Mistral performed well in metrics evaluation.
However, Llama-2 was slower when dealing with text and tabular data. In our
human evaluation, we observed that responses created by Mistral, Meditron, and
Llama-2 exhibited reasonable fidelity and relevance. This study provides
valuable insights into the strengths and limitations of LLMs for future
developments in medical document interpretation. Open-Source Code:
https://github.com/yaseen28/MedDoc-Bot
|
[
-0.11168927699327469,
-0.7880681157112122,
0.8683401346206665,
0.11618975549936295,
-0.3519728183746338,
-0.17970634996891022,
-0.22065123915672302,
-0.38361915946006775,
-0.16506615281105042,
0.5630935430526733,
-0.42240938544273376,
-0.6593891978263855,
-0.8170186281204224,
0.36827483773231506,
-0.2769903540611267,
1.2233104705810547,
-0.07802645117044449,
0.2469410002231598,
-0.38587772846221924,
0.30373847484588623,
-0.005041067488491535,
-0.24060651659965515,
-0.710173487663269,
-0.38375797867774963,
0.5823792815208435,
0.3165307939052582,
0.7896458506584167,
0.6273361444473267,
1.1962374448776245,
0.2821440100669861,
-0.39143091440200806,
0.0705028623342514,
-0.3881499469280243,
0.27812907099723816,
-0.21636326611042023,
-0.24407069385051727,
-0.7087864875793457,
-0.15047544240951538,
0.4050946533679962,
0.42671775817871094,
-0.20096158981323242,
0.15403541922569275,
0.10535045713186264,
0.5023415684700012,
-0.2743191123008728,
0.5008946657180786,
-0.4775015413761139,
-0.18735167384147644,
-0.05965755507349968,
-0.6067359447479248,
-0.30809441208839417,
-0.2721567451953888,
0.4134780466556549,
-0.593658983707428,
0.13296552002429962,
-0.03687560558319092,
0.8851827383041382,
0.3250291645526886,
-0.47339147329330444,
-0.6236841678619385,
-0.590078592300415,
0.6242780685424805,
-1.0132908821105957,
0.24363283812999725,
0.4660694897174835,
0.3134041428565979,
-0.3795490860939026,
-0.8454043865203857,
-0.6539857983589172,
-0.35597658157348633,
0.002174314111471176,
0.29273566603660583,
-0.33125269412994385,
0.2951136529445648,
0.09956920892000198,
0.3749810457229614,
-0.7351284623146057,
0.2649930715560913,
-0.6616612076759338,
-0.10935316979885101,
0.30680981278419495,
0.2670886516571045,
0.1290213018655777,
-0.3583589196205139,
-0.24981555342674255,
-0.11641361564397812,
-0.6111695170402527,
-0.2384674847126007,
0.2318098247051239,
0.12913137674331665,
-0.3980340361595154,
0.5878653526306152,
0.01896076276898384,
0.6454014182090759,
-0.28347668051719666,
-0.5519469976425171,
0.28042086958885193,
-0.16664095222949982,
-0.2011004388332367,
-0.30199337005615234,
1.0569961071014404,
0.7588651180267334,
0.47897177934646606,
0.17667940258979797,
-0.0812595784664154,
-0.10059088468551636,
0.40966999530792236,
-0.8177860975265503,
-0.11391914635896683,
0.37845438718795776,
-0.8306998014450073,
-0.585834264755249,
-0.17703747749328613,
-0.7896369695663452,
-0.6291230320930481,
-0.36522674560546875,
0.0032963159028440714,
-0.1490812748670578,
-0.02080044336616993,
-0.07288355380296707,
-0.08239254355430603,
-0.0011273352429270744,
0.5272608995437622,
-0.638429582118988,
0.4502646327018738,
0.8976096510887146,
0.9894770383834839,
-0.27121850848197937,
-0.21981996297836304,
-0.1191909909248352,
-0.0822141021490097,
-0.24370047450065613,
1.059088945388794,
-0.38910797238349915,
-0.7391846776008606,
0.03796318173408508,
0.1139620840549469,
0.017398454248905182,
-0.6350294947624207,
0.9146906733512878,
-0.008233141154050827,
0.24087561666965485,
0.2972383499145508,
-0.520823061466217,
0.08939201384782791,
0.26643407344818115,
-0.5523875951766968,
0.7932066321372986,
0.1996733844280243,
-0.877242922782898,
0.19103319942951202,
-0.603656530380249,
-0.3220033347606659,
0.09897179901599884,
-0.3577836751937866,
-0.34107112884521484,
-0.14129510521888733,
0.36824458837509155,
0.5119300484657288,
-0.9150726199150085,
0.3328675925731659,
-0.32576897740364075,
-0.1996103674173355,
0.25652992725372314,
-0.6497042775154114,
0.4717350900173187,
0.28556108474731445,
0.11468619853258133,
0.4620400071144104,
-0.4722340404987335,
-0.06786127388477325,
0.18291938304901123,
-0.5122148394584656,
-0.013891683891415596,
0.16158118844032288,
0.3778338134288788,
0.2887583374977112,
0.17578671872615814,
-0.4385344088077545,
0.15693916380405426,
-0.187978595495224,
0.5991863012313843,
0.8259048461914062,
0.3016379475593567,
-0.12775525450706482,
-0.509393036365509,
0.6010711789131165,
-0.3827773928642273,
0.6881049275398254,
-0.038491927087306976,
-0.7773773074150085,
-0.3545520603656769,
-0.4243175685405731,
-0.05500536039471626,
0.27447229623794556,
-0.5525411367416382,
0.5176294445991516,
-0.5289617776870728,
-0.7472449541091919,
-0.5361325144767761,
0.05793032795190811,
0.21089479327201843,
0.9064066410064697,
0.17215661704540253,
-0.08921443670988083,
-0.3985975980758667,
-0.9921554327011108,
0.10031063109636307,
-0.5498151779174805,
-0.1837523728609085,
0.7254056930541992,
0.6410288214683533,
-0.35300347208976746,
0.4792693555355072,
-0.4292125999927521,
-0.2733334004878998,
-0.19553805887699127,
-0.04927873611450195,
0.44295355677604675,
0.2988876402378082,
0.4299714267253876,
-0.6066502928733826,
-0.5762569904327393,
0.03882133215665817,
-0.5628975629806519,
-0.3684951066970825,
0.058300331234931946,
-0.0032582138665020466,
-0.12330401688814163,
0.4615442454814911,
-0.36841800808906555,
0.32453468441963196,
0.9536833763122559,
-0.29928094148635864,
0.5211485624313354,
-0.40573644638061523,
0.21298524737358093,
-1.0392006635665894,
0.25418272614479065,
0.13367952406406403,
-0.3275301456451416,
-0.4515379071235657,
-0.09520246833562851,
0.04972749575972557,
-0.18310528993606567,
-0.6031433939933777,
0.7634546756744385,
0.06731297075748444,
0.26271581649780273,
-0.2611042261123657,
0.32523784041404724,
-0.20648902654647827,
0.30560117959976196,
0.13634160161018372,
0.8019380569458008,
0.49468258023262024,
-0.16011403501033783,
0.40547701716423035,
0.11594370007514954,
-0.194749116897583,
0.672417938709259,
-1.1122108697891235,
0.01127916481345892,
0.08193141967058182,
0.5421963334083557,
-0.8267596364021301,
-0.15827983617782593,
0.2792808711528778,
-0.47965508699417114,
0.07825903594493866,
-0.3964245021343231,
-0.83417809009552,
-0.5774303078651428,
-0.34140315651893616,
0.029362352564930916,
0.5523381233215332,
-0.31085333228111267,
0.1839841902256012,
0.5392386317253113,
-0.5141584277153015,
-0.3017319142818451,
-0.2510184347629547,
-0.06382017582654953,
0.04605408385396004,
-0.4395124614238739,
0.0859932079911232,
-0.11133906990289688,
-0.20970574021339417,
0.04233409836888313,
-0.34399229288101196,
-0.2643478512763977,
-0.1548573076725006,
0.6168476343154907,
0.6554739475250244,
-0.2333657145500183,
0.16398443281650543,
0.15780885517597198,
-0.09795352816581726,
0.03466736897826195,
-0.050462763756513596,
0.6185734868049622,
-0.3476596772670746,
-0.22202186286449432,
-0.5697464942932129,
0.0682266354560852,
0.9582081437110901,
0.08049310743808746,
0.6808978319168091,
0.2743125259876251,
-0.2566550374031067,
0.06577646732330322,
-0.360322505235672,
-0.07493622601032257,
-0.41092169284820557,
0.2763115167617798,
0.037968069314956665,
-0.5144983530044556,
0.18002471327781677,
-0.2500509023666382,
0.16407045722007751,
0.6707962155342102,
0.988337516784668,
-0.2984214425086975,
0.8359204530715942,
0.48452144861221313,
0.018845930695533752,
0.351431667804718,
-0.22337299585342407,
-0.2662948966026306,
-0.9445000290870667,
-0.22670412063598633,
-0.6332891583442688,
-0.05723103880882263,
-0.4649201035499573,
-0.5684409141540527,
0.4799414575099945,
-0.250503271818161,
-0.11920834332704544,
0.25198104977607727,
-0.5610275864601135,
0.34154075384140015,
0.08867893368005753,
-0.005507483612746,
0.39225414395332336,
-0.08581127226352692,
-0.16269183158874512,
-0.046046674251556396,
-0.6052711009979248,
-0.919115424156189,
1.5352305173873901,
0.5861960649490356,
0.9520548582077026,
-0.05686323717236519,
0.3746199905872345,
0.37632259726524353,
0.698040246963501,
-1.0034432411193848,
0.356223464012146,
-0.22637496888637543,
-0.7370176315307617,
-0.12324502319097519,
-0.47859472036361694,
-1.0385785102844238,
0.3792489171028137,
-0.4707517623901367,
-0.8775978684425354,
-0.1983286738395691,
-0.18114838004112244,
-0.19392137229442596,
0.21569959819316864,
-0.6423630118370056,
0.7930356860160828,
-0.20885850489139557,
-0.09065793454647064,
-0.3400433361530304,
-0.4910716116428375,
0.061202600598335266,
-0.34410667419433594,
0.18201977014541626,
-0.3083859980106354,
-0.34495165944099426,
0.8102037906646729,
-0.6626933217048645,
0.6943217515945435,
0.2932761013507843,
-0.2159288227558136,
0.10441301017999649,
-0.054034795612096786,
0.24142986536026,
0.14364276826381683,
-0.17520053684711456,
0.32662490010261536,
0.407048761844635,
-0.3357636332511902,
-0.638211190700531,
0.8970639109611511,
-0.9110538959503174,
-0.40301698446273804,
-0.5290453433990479,
-0.47306227684020996,
-0.050210095942020416,
0.39624983072280884,
0.02955654449760914,
0.510509729385376,
-0.23548147082328796,
0.41993293166160583,
0.1829938441514969,
-0.2357025444507599,
-0.011408801190555096,
0.7723734974861145,
-0.1553773730993271,
-0.39770835638046265,
0.37933650612831116,
-0.22708749771118164,
0.2799318730831146,
0.29538294672966003,
0.6095128655433655,
-0.26379063725471497,
-0.5247636437416077,
-0.3122640550136566,
0.6980547308921814,
-0.7859640717506409,
0.04556206241250038,
-0.4648090898990631,
-0.4082720875740051,
-0.4056609570980072,
-0.18005730211734772,
-0.11854773014783859,
-0.17811934649944305,
-0.02939269132912159,
0.1949159801006317,
0.3679540753364563,
0.7651739716529846,
0.2461639791727066,
0.46717479825019836,
-0.7675133943557739,
0.1743626594543457,
-0.16153547167778015,
0.2269790768623352,
-0.07657071202993393,
-0.5101915001869202,
0.1048438772559166,
-0.3655678927898407,
-0.4153541922569275,
-0.9230750799179077,
0.23424293100833893,
-0.07318202406167984,
0.5802677273750305,
0.6513050198554993,
-0.03392956033349037,
0.39372381567955017,
-0.5084050297737122,
0.6093419790267944,
0.18325212597846985,
-0.5993146896362305,
0.6475503444671631,
-0.5149842500686646,
0.16551801562309265,
0.48792514204978943,
0.5044161081314087,
-0.8171106576919556,
-0.45702821016311646,
-0.6719788908958435,
-0.6903948187828064,
0.5253867506980896,
0.44105708599090576,
-0.1468968391418457,
0.12745130062103271,
0.07049758732318878,
0.1808784008026123,
0.18011374771595,
-0.2936772108078003,
-0.10334870219230652,
0.2794278860092163,
-0.47609588503837585,
-0.19799643754959106,
-0.11311736702919006,
-0.3331633508205414,
-0.03392629325389862,
0.43638697266578674,
-0.04983365908265114,
0.07597707957029343,
0.35948508977890015,
0.1470789760351181,
-0.14735564589500427,
0.35760146379470825,
0.6777956485748291,
0.8834853768348694,
-0.3863085210323334,
0.11638543754816055,
-0.06729712337255478,
-0.9208211898803711,
-0.27645084261894226,
0.21148782968521118,
-0.06018555164337158,
0.10561031103134155,
0.798116147518158,
0.42328783869743347,
0.1558188796043396,
-0.9675997495651245,
0.651653528213501,
-0.33656424283981323,
-0.20293225347995758,
-0.14867497980594635,
-0.07350504398345947,
-0.002829308155924082,
0.042607564479112625,
-0.036552514880895615,
0.01496632769703865,
-0.15119270980358124,
-0.523851215839386,
0.08671063184738159,
-0.09793906658887863,
-0.4151071012020111,
-0.11137495934963226,
0.4682537913322449,
0.4192667007446289,
-0.3994341492652893,
0.5587900280952454,
0.3328495919704437,
-0.32536739110946655,
0.6381542682647705,
0.420255184173584,
0.47977855801582336,
0.08204639703035355,
0.13908368349075317,
0.30736279487609863,
0.32635751366615295,
0.15262895822525024,
0.3283766210079193,
-0.08111085742712021,
-0.22358117997646332,
-0.21655459702014923,
-0.2582554519176483,
-0.6313640475273132,
0.34553226828575134,
-0.44001999497413635,
0.2546885907649994,
-0.637278139591217,
-0.46562910079956055,
0.31410375237464905,
0.1336086094379425,
-0.7131490707397461,
-0.08255583792924881,
-0.04322617128491402,
0.8811668753623962,
-0.6733091473579407,
0.8380221128463745,
0.7200238704681396,
-0.4882999658584595,
-0.6359814405441284,
0.181480273604393,
0.4617576599121094,
-0.7820785045623779,
0.5153026580810547,
-0.23851805925369263,
-0.05065884441137314,
-0.41110852360725403,
-0.4857117235660553,
-0.5565317869186401,
0.979286789894104,
0.02159852534532547,
-0.5072163343429565,
-0.17015354335308075,
-0.0070542944595217705,
0.961633026599884,
-0.2052108496427536,
0.6530030369758606,
0.35068902373313904,
0.2832721769809723,
0.013656417839229107,
-1.3542141914367676,
-0.10417504608631134,
-0.4085685908794403,
-0.36748939752578735,
-0.008479781448841095,
-0.46013790369033813,
0.7417929172515869,
-0.09369190037250519,
0.012132009491324425,
0.24048876762390137,
0.05426780879497528,
0.20733988285064697,
0.11160709708929062,
0.3373766541481018,
0.16628707945346832,
0.6758193969726562,
-0.007461716420948505,
1.3186110258102417,
-0.44487595558166504,
0.5924094915390015,
1.079509973526001,
-0.1165192499756813,
1.0990853309631348,
0.6336783766746521,
-0.41601788997650146,
0.32726120948791504,
0.6010130643844604,
-0.09088079631328583,
0.24117890000343323,
0.20783978700637817,
-0.008921349421143532,
0.024935949593782425,
-0.2871718406677246,
-0.3111185133457184,
0.09820510447025299,
0.5376374125480652,
-0.5711627006530762,
-0.4551312327384949,
-0.3325205445289612,
0.2781950533390045,
-0.09660438448190689,
-0.2585681676864624,
0.6835576891899109,
0.33284661173820496,
-0.5319205522537231,
0.6288981437683105,
-0.08477690815925598,
0.472127765417099,
-0.6958901286125183,
-0.1131083071231842,
-0.018950041383504868,
0.40651175379753113,
-0.33865851163864136,
-1.1655546426773071,
-0.0033257317263633013,
0.5430586338043213,
0.011260280385613441,
-0.018452711403369904,
0.5747615098953247,
-0.05423806980252266,
-0.4214862883090973,
0.19985413551330566,
0.5001304149627686,
0.5433422923088074,
0.15638139843940735,
-0.9995344281196594,
0.004928983747959137,
-0.34304842352867126,
-0.08602847903966904,
0.039288438856601715,
0.22947773337364197,
-0.04942607134580612,
1.0274041891098022,
0.9170373678207397,
0.6749737858772278,
-0.3066909611225128,
0.3657403290271759,
0.7545331120491028,
-0.17067933082580566,
-0.3143872618675232,
-0.7059438228607178,
0.0961529016494751,
-0.09203027188777924,
-0.6243327856063843,
0.654576301574707,
0.5731867551803589,
0.616199254989624,
-0.12275905907154083,
0.6060594916343689,
0.03451309725642204,
0.6363669037818909,
-0.24834340810775757,
0.9416958689689636,
-0.595420241355896,
0.09783903509378433,
-0.3771001696586609,
-0.7073966264724731,
-0.32629936933517456,
0.5039057731628418,
-0.4337347745895386,
-0.2981393337249756,
0.9767769575119019,
0.7757167220115662,
0.033517856150865555,
-0.21531516313552856,
0.14736410975456238,
0.08874989300966263,
0.6661779880523682,
0.5008835196495056,
0.8836172223091125,
-0.1879863739013672,
0.756657063961029,
-0.14431333541870117,
-0.2950747609138489,
-0.44738054275512695,
-0.5667834281921387,
-1.0157430171966553,
-0.49157506227493286,
-0.16902028024196625,
-0.3140639364719391,
0.0936087816953659,
1.140626311302185,
0.7922437191009521,
-0.5537792444229126,
-0.17225050926208496,
0.198537215590477,
0.1293262541294098,
-0.09819775074720383,
-0.17006660997867584,
0.6231250762939453,
0.047786593437194824,
-0.7728278040885925,
0.12122773379087448,
0.3229217231273651,
0.21199755370616913,
-0.15463298559188843,
-0.10105063766241074,
0.1376500278711319,
0.08139999210834503,
0.36018264293670654,
0.2079208493232727,
-0.8561327457427979,
0.036821313202381134,
-0.030797161161899567,
-0.572835385799408,
0.15206560492515564,
0.9712000489234924,
-0.36509937047958374,
0.7079331874847412,
0.6952022314071655,
0.28975099325180054,
0.26632487773895264,
-0.07757566124200821,
0.42997869849205017,
-0.020612770691514015,
0.15391388535499573,
0.31989341974258423,
0.4286775290966034,
0.0873350128531456,
-0.05471520125865936,
0.6458126902580261,
0.06407811492681503,
-0.5790408849716187,
-0.6995368599891663,
-0.13586977124214172,
-1.0498054027557373,
-0.32889023423194885,
1.286202073097229,
-0.1862996220588684,
-0.3050388991832733,
-0.06812088936567307,
-0.6152638792991638,
0.20994168519973755,
-0.6476187705993652,
0.6412380933761597,
0.5676051378250122,
-0.09400448948144913,
0.1880894899368286,
-1.0184801816940308,
0.32646217942237854,
-0.028853926807641983,
-0.9567948579788208,
-0.07502369582653046,
0.14479419589042664,
0.3088362216949463,
-0.029481345787644386,
0.6422262787818909,
-0.4579048156738281,
0.2903769314289093,
0.11994326859712601,
-0.13074305653572083,
-0.028847752138972282,
-0.14982695877552032,
-0.4109632074832916,
-0.2771708369255066,
0.1539458930492401,
0.06518910825252533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06684v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06684v1
|
QuakeBERT: Accurate Classification of Social Media Texts for Rapid Earthquake Impact Assessment
| 2024-05-06T10:52:21 | 2024-05-06T10:52:21 |
Jin Han, Zhe Zheng, Xin-Zheng Lu, Ke-Yin Chen, Jia-Rui Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
Social media aids disaster response but suffers from noise, hindering
accurate impact assessment and decision making for resilient cities, which few
studies considered. To address the problem, this study proposes the first
domain-specific LLM model and an integrated method for rapid earthquake impact
assessment. First, a few categories are introduced to classify and filter
microblogs considering their relationship to the physical and social impacts of
earthquakes, and a dataset comprising 7282 earthquake-related microblogs from
twenty earthquakes in different locations is developed as well. Then, with a
systematic analysis of various influential factors, QuakeBERT, a
domain-specific large language model (LLM), is developed and fine-tuned for
accurate classification and filtering of microblogs. Meanwhile, an integrated
method integrating public opinion trend analysis, sentiment analysis, and
keyword-based physical impact quantification is introduced to assess both the
physical and social impacts of earthquakes based on social media texts.
Experiments show that data diversity and data volume dominate the performance
of QuakeBERT and increase the macro average F1 score by 27%, while the best
classification model QuakeBERT outperforms the CNN- or RNN-based models by
improving the macro average F1 score from 60.87% to 84.33%. Finally, the
proposed approach is applied to assess two earthquakes with the same magnitude
and focal depth. Results show that the proposed approach can effectively
enhance the impact assessment process by accurate detection of noisy
microblogs, which enables effective post-disaster emergency responses to create
more resilient cities.
|
[
-0.42488744854927063,
-1.111122488975525,
0.44979530572891235,
0.9854527115821838,
-0.4526970684528351,
0.27265578508377075,
-0.25270435214042664,
-0.6426716446876526,
0.5431686043739319,
0.1397593915462494,
-0.018861258402466774,
-0.6695618629455566,
-0.9553523063659668,
0.15278084576129913,
-0.7055763006210327,
0.7133842706680298,
-0.03224698454141617,
0.09663119167089462,
0.012616547755897045,
-0.1676430106163025,
-0.11516760289669037,
0.037891436368227005,
-0.5958337783813477,
-0.13175544142723083,
0.4993148744106293,
0.05905723571777344,
0.7905305027961731,
0.007828834466636181,
0.8150097727775574,
0.2410973310470581,
-0.5263058543205261,
0.06403186917304993,
-0.6309853792190552,
-0.6305266618728638,
0.017856530845165253,
0.019618501886725426,
-0.32739123702049255,
-0.11814172565937042,
0.54765784740448,
0.349709689617157,
-0.07334587723016739,
0.5150173306465149,
0.2805732488632202,
0.17353494465351105,
-0.4341092109680176,
0.051865700632333755,
-0.2627750337123871,
-0.05489595606923103,
0.31661754846572876,
-0.6477887034416199,
-0.2450544685125351,
-1.0220060348510742,
0.3213483989238739,
0.11514028161764145,
0.015451890416443348,
-0.16862206161022186,
0.5030291080474854,
0.36470910906791687,
-0.4870215654373169,
-0.1362355500459671,
-0.8780298233032227,
0.6657194495201111,
-0.342298299074173,
0.4130714535713196,
-0.0002655636053532362,
0.279594361782074,
-0.07564706355333328,
-0.6126617193222046,
-0.33629077672958374,
0.17453964054584503,
0.19365613162517548,
-0.009302959777414799,
-0.03971206024289131,
-0.12936651706695557,
0.013196601532399654,
0.1428082287311554,
-0.34984534978866577,
-0.2521495521068573,
-0.5940281748771667,
0.05647893249988556,
0.8260856866836548,
0.3814370334148407,
0.16215288639068604,
-0.498161643743515,
-0.7510184049606323,
0.003272611415013671,
-0.5695981979370117,
0.29757922887802124,
0.09537158161401749,
0.44309210777282715,
-0.381751149892807,
0.17086750268936157,
-0.2599237561225891,
0.2999119460582733,
-0.04419595003128052,
-0.5730713605880737,
0.18767312169075012,
-0.22401101887226105,
-0.2389315962791443,
0.26793769001960754,
1.0672513246536255,
0.46357452869415283,
0.20228873193264008,
-0.10424350202083588,
0.05654729902744293,
-0.22341854870319366,
0.3783701956272125,
-1.0970957279205322,
-0.11502232402563095,
0.37539422512054443,
-0.5833685398101807,
-1.0133665800094604,
0.10369057208299637,
-0.7944528460502625,
-0.9340152740478516,
-0.15512605011463165,
0.5027859807014465,
-0.050049006938934326,
-0.376508504152298,
0.2856209874153137,
0.12857434153556824,
-0.004304016008973122,
0.730053722858429,
-0.20366831123828888,
0.008239295333623886,
0.4642258286476135,
1.0550663471221924,
0.34201687574386597,
-0.14437654614448547,
-0.15340857207775116,
-0.30467689037323,
-0.09790589660406113,
1.2205568552017212,
-0.3193909823894501,
-0.4181476831436157,
0.3689134418964386,
-0.022582437843084335,
0.3525077998638153,
-0.2590729296207428,
0.7540004253387451,
-0.5716599225997925,
-0.3216518461704254,
-0.03899659961462021,
-0.1347389966249466,
-0.6596775650978088,
0.15756669640541077,
-0.5290858745574951,
1.1979511976242065,
0.18179436028003693,
-1.177594542503357,
0.43084052205085754,
-0.06686221808195114,
-0.692578136920929,
0.0920623391866684,
0.09900504350662231,
-0.27758246660232544,
0.19603948295116425,
0.31862324476242065,
0.6539235711097717,
-0.6552949547767639,
0.47960561513900757,
-0.6207405924797058,
-0.4596903622150421,
-0.08666236698627472,
-0.35306456685066223,
1.0573716163635254,
-0.12504234910011292,
-0.26449501514434814,
0.017692500725388527,
-0.9604842662811279,
0.13016286492347717,
0.09330446273088455,
-0.759053111076355,
-0.2754518687725067,
0.3805282711982727,
0.20310236513614655,
0.10084003210067749,
0.1418178379535675,
-0.3161381483078003,
0.15975794196128845,
0.06258325278759003,
0.08924828469753265,
0.5538585782051086,
0.26312610507011414,
0.2576533854007721,
-0.027360213920474052,
0.2153167724609375,
-0.24468281865119934,
0.5469093322753906,
0.3128741383552551,
-0.4026126265525818,
-0.18301385641098022,
-0.36435458064079285,
0.439625084400177,
0.7286056280136108,
-0.40946054458618164,
0.44233325123786926,
-0.7029890418052673,
-0.8772274255752563,
-0.8112668991088867,
-0.03701656311750412,
-0.11326894909143448,
0.22225748002529144,
0.3966618478298187,
-0.07359161227941513,
-0.7184286713600159,
-0.26854124665260315,
-0.3394858241081238,
-0.3074427843093872,
0.12731532752513885,
0.2727656364440918,
0.23627543449401855,
-0.4979037642478943,
0.7940851449966431,
-0.3094482123851776,
0.06792987138032913,
-0.26294946670532227,
0.3827248215675354,
0.14160776138305664,
-0.40973103046417236,
0.6711587905883789,
-0.9194998741149902,
-0.6360313296318054,
-0.21362484991550446,
-0.8537102937698364,
-0.36923691630363464,
-0.04910092055797577,
0.26545336842536926,
-0.5720146298408508,
0.02248612605035305,
-0.29212719202041626,
0.46905845403671265,
0.5264439582824707,
-0.16601844131946564,
0.40888136625289917,
0.36691728234291077,
0.4221905469894409,
-0.8936393857002258,
-0.3377644717693329,
0.19303354620933533,
-0.5119518637657166,
-0.7162852883338928,
-0.34121939539909363,
0.11611282825469971,
-0.10886091738939285,
-0.7997325658798218,
0.46557071805000305,
-0.12308759987354279,
0.1303243786096573,
-0.48670244216918945,
0.23382720351219177,
-0.2016039937734604,
-0.22242112457752228,
-0.1476704627275467,
0.21051180362701416,
0.5471250414848328,
-0.5000624656677246,
0.26562172174453735,
0.233213409781456,
-0.6689858436584473,
0.19549207389354706,
-0.7913231253623962,
-0.05408801510930061,
-0.19467273354530334,
0.5003066062927246,
-0.8769241571426392,
-0.14615069329738617,
0.19652126729488373,
-0.46692273020744324,
-0.020097849890589714,
-0.07968973368406296,
-0.6194157600402832,
-0.556769609451294,
-0.7181254625320435,
0.13785520195960999,
0.28894758224487305,
-0.7950325608253479,
0.9052298665046692,
0.6080794930458069,
-0.23237471282482147,
-0.36314666271209717,
-0.4646243155002594,
0.10074776411056519,
-0.35020360350608826,
-1.0370839834213257,
-0.13008201122283936,
-0.07096018642187119,
-0.327884703874588,
-0.07451064139604568,
0.044208161532878876,
-0.25212332606315613,
0.2236551195383072,
0.3968473970890045,
-0.027842601761221886,
0.1636144071817398,
-0.005549881141632795,
-0.12174644321203232,
0.15522727370262146,
0.11092108488082886,
0.4309075176715851,
0.5994472503662109,
-0.1847921460866928,
0.35874298214912415,
-0.45835649967193604,
-0.09172095358371735,
0.6294508576393127,
0.10961136966943741,
0.8961396217346191,
0.7807134389877319,
-0.2580970227718353,
-0.13425201177597046,
-0.5147997140884399,
-0.06062867119908333,
-0.41805922985076904,
0.05526715889573097,
-0.09434109181165695,
-0.8918136954307556,
0.4643874764442444,
-0.7286369800567627,
0.015019943006336689,
0.3306775987148285,
0.6628567576408386,
-0.16546127200126648,
0.6954404711723328,
0.6857175827026367,
-0.5102221369743347,
0.42961591482162476,
-0.13309182226657867,
0.4910222291946411,
-0.5397220253944397,
0.00047262798761948943,
-0.5127586722373962,
-0.2618100941181183,
-0.24327899515628815,
-0.34583911299705505,
0.3422239422798157,
0.17630694806575775,
0.17394378781318665,
0.5178095698356628,
-0.5573620200157166,
0.17593587934970856,
-0.048391323536634445,
0.4163098931312561,
0.2177036702632904,
0.18031230568885803,
0.5711930990219116,
0.17980794608592987,
-0.4460267126560211,
-0.5704391002655029,
0.938880980014801,
0.4988391697406769,
1.103623867034912,
-0.0011649016523733735,
0.866943359375,
0.6663060188293457,
0.8336690068244934,
-0.6690915822982788,
0.46664050221443176,
0.21815532445907593,
-0.5447849631309509,
-0.10731767863035202,
-0.5180023908615112,
-0.5045023560523987,
0.3209759294986725,
-0.502366840839386,
-0.7025887370109558,
0.2718861997127533,
-0.11313807219266891,
-0.5880444049835205,
0.16741691529750824,
-0.4401107430458069,
0.2352052927017212,
-0.414787232875824,
-0.09897468984127045,
-0.4186411201953888,
-0.5653712153434753,
0.3477610647678375,
-0.22552071511745453,
0.6258955001831055,
-0.3315187394618988,
0.2825632393360138,
0.4475869834423065,
-0.049144208431243896,
1.111451268196106,
-0.08028152585029602,
-0.05746586620807648,
1.0190942287445068,
0.06552104651927948,
0.785049319267273,
0.14811047911643982,
-0.02033296599984169,
0.5872962474822998,
-0.36937814950942993,
-0.023203734308481216,
-0.47302764654159546,
0.5945388078689575,
-0.8219733834266663,
-0.2573738098144531,
-0.052928514778614044,
-0.29914432764053345,
0.261017382144928,
-0.01846974343061447,
0.06381485611200333,
0.3530571758747101,
-0.48574358224868774,
0.1583830565214157,
0.4184431731700897,
-0.014179195277392864,
0.3641640543937683,
0.7552290558815002,
-0.34550416469573975,
-0.8248699903488159,
0.8274769186973572,
0.18497644364833832,
-0.40059688687324524,
0.25922077894210815,
0.39034706354141235,
-0.09567271173000336,
-0.40293848514556885,
-0.0072325156070292,
0.07966330647468567,
-0.6773074865341187,
-0.27403706312179565,
-0.8380420804023743,
-0.02617994323372841,
-0.3637697994709015,
-0.36798492074012756,
-0.23809920251369476,
-0.2213437557220459,
-0.04479586333036423,
-0.17899402976036072,
0.14142495393753052,
0.596635639667511,
-0.15319891273975372,
0.3541693389415741,
-1.0274581909179688,
0.223549947142601,
-0.03951575607061386,
0.16133150458335876,
-0.12331835180521011,
-0.4394415318965912,
-0.47185710072517395,
-0.2547527551651001,
-0.31142449378967285,
-0.8591553568840027,
0.19729718565940857,
-0.07583741843700409,
-0.10321981459856033,
0.7049750089645386,
0.16732825338840485,
0.5817135572433472,
-0.6152641177177429,
0.49041640758514404,
0.3501334488391876,
-0.49401798844337463,
0.5070179104804993,
-0.29473811388015747,
-0.03770560026168823,
0.5529778003692627,
0.6813568472862244,
-0.2566516399383545,
-0.19770000874996185,
-0.6706885695457458,
-0.8636984825134277,
0.16683804988861084,
0.08855939656496048,
0.017417170107364655,
-0.3466220796108246,
0.08506764471530914,
-0.18535202741622925,
0.17720302939414978,
-0.6962782740592957,
0.0996626764535904,
0.0860348790884018,
-0.05364486202597618,
0.19530616700649261,
-0.6704219579696655,
-0.3127911686897278,
-0.49464961886405945,
0.3508409559726715,
0.16886086761951447,
0.2987152338027954,
0.30393460392951965,
-0.2410239726305008,
-0.30015984177589417,
-0.04169683903455734,
0.4682239294052124,
0.40890076756477356,
-0.36495867371559143,
0.2856138050556183,
0.5505887866020203,
-0.5845762491226196,
0.11032136529684067,
-0.005584775470197201,
-0.2774682343006134,
0.24960309267044067,
0.6003903746604919,
0.20068544149398804,
0.44290396571159363,
-0.46339306235313416,
0.5503284335136414,
-0.13810613751411438,
-0.058746106922626495,
-0.2702137231826782,
-0.26157858967781067,
0.23172889649868011,
0.8140680193901062,
0.18472713232040405,
0.06264273822307587,
0.3743724524974823,
-0.29741302132606506,
0.0014031417667865753,
-0.0834469199180603,
-0.47277212142944336,
-0.5901692509651184,
0.5595155358314514,
0.5481467247009277,
-0.2942022383213043,
0.10321662575006485,
-0.05229058116674423,
-0.5968037247657776,
0.5553659796714783,
0.16960509121418,
1.1889296770095825,
-0.5642791986465454,
0.25949162244796753,
0.5882426500320435,
0.5655335187911987,
-0.3953944444656372,
0.6032068133354187,
0.15957799553871155,
-0.7623115181922913,
-0.12330766022205353,
-0.8756842613220215,
-0.10840146243572235,
-0.13149482011795044,
-0.23215539753437042,
0.6294073462486267,
-0.8118276596069336,
-0.6271188855171204,
-0.11278901249170303,
-0.019273677840828896,
-0.6283183693885803,
0.420609712600708,
0.003982523921877146,
1.0505467653274536,
-0.9809107780456543,
0.25745829939842224,
0.9514732360839844,
-0.3822794556617737,
-0.6901680827140808,
0.3391949236392975,
0.023963935673236847,
-0.5341261625289917,
0.40883493423461914,
0.20744588971138,
-0.29181233048439026,
-0.10113190114498138,
-0.8350290060043335,
-0.7709580659866333,
1.0181137323379517,
0.054838620126247406,
-0.32267600297927856,
0.42412853240966797,
0.35475286841392517,
0.7533552050590515,
-0.2826195955276489,
0.24339613318443298,
0.3102124333381653,
0.5357975959777832,
-0.236183300614357,
-0.7265360951423645,
0.064423568546772,
0.0971442386507988,
-0.04802248254418373,
0.3785742521286011,
-1.311087965965271,
0.31164035201072693,
-0.3258877694606781,
-0.2964898347854614,
-0.44482991099357605,
0.6797466278076172,
-0.27510952949523926,
0.5307492613792419,
0.5417215824127197,
0.7097634077072144,
0.6049962043762207,
-0.03183593600988388,
1.2686026096343994,
-0.6042734980583191,
0.9699567556381226,
0.8326807022094727,
0.017023663967847824,
0.8842114210128784,
0.05957283824682236,
-0.3448113799095154,
0.2732219099998474,
0.8027048707008362,
0.032658785581588745,
0.72258061170578,
0.08080950379371643,
-0.5447198748588562,
-0.05136276036500931,
-0.2297394722700119,
-0.13498759269714355,
0.30406099557876587,
0.1437842696905136,
-0.44989004731178284,
-0.31560322642326355,
-0.08317050337791443,
0.3082245886325836,
-0.5265511870384216,
-0.30837178230285645,
0.45728379487991333,
0.16471044719219208,
0.15885716676712036,
0.42708519101142883,
-0.09974253922700882,
0.3260749578475952,
-0.03942833095788956,
0.2892622649669647,
-0.03703560680150986,
0.10430783033370972,
-0.5916699767112732,
-0.8115824460983276,
0.3737802803516388,
0.06143097206950188,
-0.24957484006881714,
0.15747758746147156,
1.1510746479034424,
-0.21410278975963593,
-0.5865169763565063,
0.7520790100097656,
0.28234001994132996,
0.1788044273853302,
-0.13293810188770294,
-0.3637385368347168,
0.31117120385169983,
-0.09932117909193039,
-0.539535641670227,
0.015376536175608635,
0.6266813278198242,
0.1382143497467041,
0.6337509751319885,
0.14365799725055695,
-0.08661976456642151,
0.14122429490089417,
0.26954150199890137,
0.979865312576294,
-0.5830591320991516,
-0.18506014347076416,
-0.6970255970954895,
0.5964273810386658,
-0.08181237429380417,
-0.18272893130779266,
0.6255469918251038,
0.2988450229167938,
0.18264254927635193,
0.05290785804390907,
0.9080996513366699,
-0.3515039384365082,
0.3987824022769928,
0.2243908792734146,
0.5930038094520569,
-0.5611013174057007,
0.2669765055179596,
-0.40473493933677673,
-1.1166000366210938,
-0.44128599762916565,
0.45298054814338684,
-0.3981379270553589,
-0.1940823644399643,
0.5027470588684082,
0.41754215955734253,
0.004596279468387365,
0.06650054454803467,
0.17444320023059845,
0.5072634220123291,
0.233865886926651,
-0.03699210286140442,
0.7777523994445801,
-0.6042671203613281,
0.8170138001441956,
-0.12965404987335205,
-0.5903950333595276,
-0.594209611415863,
-0.5900388360023499,
-1.132224678993225,
0.03968014195561409,
-0.3221242129802704,
-0.571140468120575,
-0.06995562463998795,
0.8453815579414368,
0.22013826668262482,
-0.5262977480888367,
0.055213768035173416,
0.5217968821525574,
0.1993531882762909,
0.03506360575556755,
-0.3288649618625641,
0.479606032371521,
0.08136072754859924,
-0.4056693911552429,
0.39483216404914856,
0.6701103448867798,
-0.1636095494031906,
-0.08456916362047195,
0.09849341213703156,
0.014640776440501213,
0.350751668214798,
1.0390738248825073,
-0.016795985400676727,
-0.377234548330307,
-0.7728853821754456,
-0.2709197402000427,
-0.2830449044704437,
0.01659148745238781,
0.5347148776054382,
-0.42744091153144836,
0.32691025733947754,
0.7428600788116455,
0.6892935037612915,
0.09290552139282227,
0.2042582631111145,
-0.13390475511550903,
-0.5493173003196716,
0.22129885852336884,
0.02586091123521328,
0.2862560451030731,
0.34594056010246277,
-0.47448864579200745,
0.9713180065155029,
0.4169192314147949,
-0.6782705187797546,
-0.6385062336921692,
-0.2173796445131302,
-0.8683818578720093,
-0.010214504785835743,
1.3775466680526733,
0.06576204299926758,
-0.12694188952445984,
-0.07084164768457413,
-0.15241652727127075,
0.27079513669013977,
-0.34772026538848877,
1.6412863731384277,
0.7986158132553101,
0.04517422989010811,
-0.256321519613266,
-0.5012069344520569,
0.0586782731115818,
-0.18186955153942108,
-0.5643181800842285,
-0.3015606105327606,
0.1277923732995987,
0.2179877609014511,
0.3347613513469696,
0.6930869221687317,
0.020989282056689262,
0.19361867010593414,
0.054332200437784195,
0.253021240234375,
0.4723726212978363,
-0.666891872882843,
-0.1418171226978302,
0.4151889681816101,
-0.25091078877449036,
0.29774048924446106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00020v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00020v1
|
Visual Language Model based Cross-modal Semantic Communication Systems
| 2024-05-06T08:59:16 | 2024-05-06T08:59:16 |
Feibo Jiang, Chuanguo Tang, Li Dong, Kezhi Wang, Kun Yang, Cunhua Pan
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT
|
Semantic Communication (SC) has emerged as a novel communication paradigm in
recent years, successfully transcending the Shannon physical capacity limits
through innovative semantic transmission concepts. Nevertheless, extant Image
Semantic Communication (ISC) systems face several challenges in dynamic
environments, including low semantic density, catastrophic forgetting, and
uncertain Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR). To address these challenges, we propose
a novel Vision-Language Model-based Cross-modal Semantic Communication
(VLM-CSC) system. The VLM-CSC comprises three novel components: (1) Cross-modal
Knowledge Base (CKB) is used to extract high-density textual semantics from the
semantically sparse image at the transmitter and reconstruct the original image
based on textual semantics at the receiver. The transmission of high-density
semantics contributes to alleviating bandwidth pressure. (2) Memory-assisted
Encoder and Decoder (MED) employ a hybrid long/short-term memory mechanism,
enabling the semantic encoder and decoder to overcome catastrophic forgetting
in dynamic environments when there is a drift in the distribution of semantic
features. (3) Noise Attention Module (NAM) employs attention mechanisms to
adaptively adjust the semantic coding and the channel coding based on SNR,
ensuring the robustness of the CSC system. The experimental simulations
validate the effectiveness, adaptability, and robustness of the CSC system.
|
[
-0.4757353961467743,
-0.8700757026672363,
0.4611624479293823,
0.29709911346435547,
-0.4706653952598572,
-0.11554566770792007,
-0.37499937415122986,
-0.7786732912063599,
0.21772699058055878,
0.3330869972705841,
-0.6772153377532959,
-0.48682695627212524,
-0.49451717734336853,
0.08854791522026062,
-0.3556842803955078,
0.46378445625305176,
0.028661826625466347,
0.16324910521507263,
-0.3248409926891327,
-0.3199412226676941,
-0.6453899145126343,
-0.36607223749160767,
-0.3029073476791382,
0.1384870857000351,
0.3669090270996094,
0.024296751245856285,
0.6769472360610962,
0.2015126645565033,
0.47289854288101196,
0.33752796053886414,
-0.08662605285644531,
0.07468275725841522,
-0.6638307571411133,
-0.046049799770116806,
-0.4275447726249695,
-0.22672760486602783,
-0.32869386672973633,
-0.45241233706474304,
0.741888165473938,
0.41467198729515076,
-0.16734428703784943,
-0.15623287856578827,
-0.08355315774679184,
0.49698197841644287,
-0.9716206789016724,
0.3758328855037689,
-1.0495986938476562,
-0.042095087468624115,
0.14490823447704315,
-0.3909763693809509,
-0.44811663031578064,
0.5034019351005554,
0.12429089099168777,
-0.5995901823043823,
-0.36697709560394287,
0.10283313691616058,
0.8874430060386658,
0.3258277475833893,
-0.31548309326171875,
-0.25706514716148376,
-0.8297688364982605,
0.7800135016441345,
-0.4787827432155609,
0.6809920072555542,
0.32864564657211304,
0.4006158113479614,
0.050334781408309937,
-0.41042712330818176,
-0.6612876653671265,
-0.1763545721769333,
0.29832595586776733,
0.5132750868797302,
-0.12273000180721283,
-0.16630315780639648,
0.014566220343112946,
0.13653826713562012,
-0.3779868185520172,
-0.12872035801410675,
-0.35987234115600586,
-0.24788816273212433,
0.1630980521440506,
0.47510483860969543,
0.23814010620117188,
-0.19233399629592896,
-0.8566284775733948,
0.323623389005661,
-0.3421459496021271,
-0.12490515410900116,
-0.1934189647436142,
0.18601585924625397,
-0.3750595152378082,
0.4048875570297241,
-0.6043826341629028,
0.8733862638473511,
-0.22953906655311584,
-0.15283554792404175,
0.051695626229047775,
-0.6467138528823853,
-0.3251079320907593,
-0.024689149111509323,
0.6758049130439758,
0.5054946541786194,
-0.07155206799507141,
-0.20685356855392456,
-0.25670531392097473,
0.4858180284500122,
0.3474598526954651,
-0.3536842465400696,
0.09402062743902206,
-0.17891661822795868,
-0.8212561011314392,
-0.32943883538246155,
-0.17817561328411102,
-0.39778852462768555,
0.13014067709445953,
-0.3439023792743683,
0.6875746250152588,
-0.5604196190834045,
-0.21176551282405853,
0.3237271010875702,
0.05578024312853813,
0.5368707180023193,
0.6406598687171936,
-0.6904212832450867,
0.2964228689670563,
0.07884077727794647,
0.6965129971504211,
-0.2719286382198334,
-0.2565198838710785,
-0.21762345731258392,
0.45986616611480713,
0.12655767798423767,
0.7125678062438965,
-0.5045686960220337,
-0.29876235127449036,
-0.24741998314857483,
0.16566631197929382,
-0.13963089883327484,
-0.29045385122299194,
0.177041694521904,
-0.689512312412262,
-0.047709885984659195,
-0.23659376800060272,
-0.17925678193569183,
0.004125278443098068,
0.26900893449783325,
-0.4549855887889862,
0.6264948844909668,
0.11221875250339508,
-0.8199442625045776,
0.26163655519485474,
-0.23284755647182465,
-0.2072376310825348,
0.23791825771331787,
-0.16078099608421326,
-0.21051090955734253,
-0.11660385131835938,
0.017506463453173637,
0.2611757814884186,
-0.5318598747253418,
-0.09465451538562775,
-0.5322667956352234,
-0.36232897639274597,
0.2644159495830536,
-0.622929573059082,
0.4563046097755432,
0.38670259714126587,
-0.23193861544132233,
0.11302205175161362,
-1.119124412536621,
0.17219658195972443,
0.23467528820037842,
-0.5417596101760864,
-0.5340943932533264,
0.028452958911657333,
0.2327677309513092,
0.5967937111854553,
0.3235032558441162,
-0.6728566884994507,
-0.1691308319568634,
0.07473808526992798,
0.47533735632896423,
0.5068654417991638,
-0.21313625574111938,
0.2633574604988098,
0.01057882234454155,
-0.01925894431769848,
0.18576237559318542,
0.36878418922424316,
-0.03794937953352928,
-0.35764604806900024,
-0.9364867806434631,
-0.30120930075645447,
0.007137517910450697,
0.9436203241348267,
-1.3155547380447388,
0.44784802198410034,
-0.4100428521633148,
-0.10763292759656906,
-0.1656162142753601,
-0.007923190481960773,
0.35451188683509827,
0.6292405128479004,
0.3839765191078186,
-0.5515438914299011,
-0.2772008180618286,
-0.7871497273445129,
0.08363135904073715,
-0.18355602025985718,
0.2631576955318451,
0.6919404864311218,
0.3783310055732727,
-0.3230176568031311,
0.6129578948020935,
-0.031221861019730568,
-0.32990604639053345,
-0.29704785346984863,
-0.33224716782569885,
-0.47154685854911804,
0.37178274989128113,
0.3615877330303192,
-0.7738605737686157,
-0.21615293622016907,
0.08844392001628876,
-0.8769159317016602,
-0.09384869039058685,
-0.2563859522342682,
-0.3691149055957794,
0.49233943223953247,
0.5365283489227295,
-0.43264490365982056,
1.0401452779769897,
0.7374102473258972,
-0.4182361364364624,
0.3091264069080353,
-0.2765211760997772,
0.20561791956424713,
-0.800889253616333,
-0.08563777059316635,
-0.28246113657951355,
-0.38885825872421265,
-0.25969070196151733,
-0.24005255103111267,
0.11854811757802963,
-0.0227032583206892,
-0.6875655651092529,
0.10940676182508469,
-0.42676469683647156,
-0.10728663206100464,
-0.46718162298202515,
0.13121114671230316,
-0.16220197081565857,
0.7185322046279907,
0.5179056525230408,
0.3316067159175873,
0.8077653050422668,
-0.5945970416069031,
0.5552434921264648,
0.2574160099029541,
-0.17495279014110565,
1.0527849197387695,
-0.398435115814209,
-0.33191725611686707,
-0.10465333610773087,
0.3227460980415344,
-0.6606587767601013,
0.26424992084503174,
0.2699422538280487,
-0.3400074541568756,
-0.10106910020112991,
0.00016728343325667083,
-0.22759278118610382,
-0.2115897536277771,
0.29572057723999023,
0.4736593961715698,
0.30708780884742737,
-0.2821199595928192,
0.8863304257392883,
0.14917267858982086,
0.10986919701099396,
-0.24542032182216644,
-0.928175151348114,
0.6121097803115845,
0.21396766602993011,
-0.9762073755264282,
0.19149278104305267,
0.027694854885339737,
0.2927924692630768,
0.355403870344162,
-0.03086608275771141,
0.015554104931652546,
-0.2677841782569885,
0.3046926259994507,
0.5399507880210876,
-0.21369153261184692,
0.09606613218784332,
-0.18170149624347687,
-0.25774577260017395,
-0.02728273719549179,
-0.5396405458450317,
0.4371725022792816,
-0.3902663588523865,
-0.664435863494873,
-0.573798418045044,
0.8691372275352478,
0.614176332950592,
-0.3852086365222931,
0.8321405053138733,
0.5625122785568237,
-0.1763891875743866,
-0.2364051640033722,
-0.4882843792438507,
-0.24753513932228088,
-0.4283807873725891,
0.6553175449371338,
-0.5193546414375305,
-0.9309589862823486,
0.574060320854187,
-0.09915487468242645,
-0.5042240023612976,
0.06077616661787033,
0.7580288648605347,
0.07424839586019516,
0.6809521317481995,
0.8530842065811157,
0.3115224838256836,
0.4748249351978302,
-0.09670867770910263,
0.282539427280426,
-0.5621870756149292,
-0.32330062985420227,
0.17447514832019806,
-0.16258731484413147,
-0.19023345410823822,
-0.6647127866744995,
0.24749666452407837,
-0.008153037168085575,
-0.11595018208026886,
0.4681639075279236,
-0.2943029999732971,
-0.0161909069865942,
0.5000491142272949,
0.24796807765960693,
0.4669570326805115,
0.2058728039264679,
-0.21471138298511505,
-0.022271206602454185,
-0.908460795879364,
-0.24862731993198395,
0.5039147734642029,
0.315962553024292,
1.1932358741760254,
0.08760381489992142,
0.13678130507469177,
-0.004547166638076305,
-0.30768829584121704,
-0.6695132851600647,
0.89730304479599,
-0.022989705204963684,
-0.3295891284942627,
-0.26961979269981384,
-0.46072396636009216,
-0.39094793796539307,
0.42171627283096313,
-0.5884336233139038,
-0.7000302076339722,
0.43071383237838745,
-0.02445170097053051,
-0.07022233307361603,
0.5574285387992859,
-0.3976878821849823,
0.6650130748748779,
-0.2031971663236618,
-0.43419376015663147,
-0.36770352721214294,
-1.0144089460372925,
0.22906248271465302,
0.10858507454395294,
0.08446849882602692,
-0.01826554536819458,
-0.24147778749465942,
0.24679839611053467,
-0.5527654886245728,
0.9799858927726746,
0.17315462231636047,
-0.04533941298723221,
0.5546872019767761,
0.1021130234003067,
0.6601483821868896,
0.01186902541667223,
0.35131943225860596,
0.2842055857181549,
0.16199907660484314,
-0.47294145822525024,
-0.5642445087432861,
0.6574777960777283,
-0.5565791726112366,
-0.21205170452594757,
-0.20493192970752716,
-0.7763550281524658,
-0.2080918848514557,
0.18264102935791016,
0.0982465147972107,
0.37228119373321533,
-0.047906748950481415,
0.30224835872650146,
0.6409581303596497,
-0.3338756561279297,
0.4285103976726532,
0.7807067036628723,
-0.053146298974752426,
-0.48148971796035767,
1.2506662607192993,
-0.028938818722963333,
0.910213828086853,
0.34726133942604065,
-0.3477938175201416,
0.20288734138011932,
-0.36433061957359314,
-0.5409764647483826,
0.11434360593557358,
-0.8875927925109863,
-0.12593887746334076,
-0.871177613735199,
-0.43252092599868774,
-0.2743809223175049,
-0.3130248785018921,
-0.6195189952850342,
0.036415793001651764,
-0.1642472892999649,
0.31992658972740173,
0.33972012996673584,
0.35786664485931396,
-0.10988609492778778,
0.14966091513633728,
-0.8153669238090515,
0.4763602018356323,
0.35555970668792725,
0.483257532119751,
0.020587390288710594,
-0.24401333928108215,
-0.3520846664905548,
0.02166309393942356,
0.19746093451976776,
-0.6962935924530029,
0.45306703448295593,
-0.028711872175335884,
0.4074849486351013,
0.023661738261580467,
0.14739057421684265,
0.6239314079284668,
-0.22791418433189392,
0.5292706489562988,
0.43073543906211853,
-0.9077678918838501,
0.37104716897010803,
-0.3918186128139496,
0.4871531128883362,
0.20625290274620056,
-0.20686092972755432,
-0.6282742619514465,
-0.46331310272216797,
-0.23512040078639984,
-0.8386443257331848,
0.6284891963005066,
0.21069708466529846,
-0.13291852176189423,
0.09830594062805176,
-0.020671594887971878,
-0.23462039232254028,
-0.06006705388426781,
-0.7400668859481812,
0.027485482394695282,
-0.49846869707107544,
-0.2935667634010315,
0.4840437173843384,
-0.21643519401550293,
-0.07445236295461655,
-0.17962633073329926,
0.3679855763912201,
-0.24139699339866638,
0.4102705121040344,
0.3378923833370209,
-0.31922057271003723,
-0.06155623868107796,
0.22459939122200012,
0.7609874606132507,
0.6167917847633362,
0.1213265210390091,
0.19032715260982513,
0.6629383563995361,
-0.5521670579910278,
-0.1401401311159134,
-0.15454399585723877,
-0.129891499876976,
-0.24502906203269958,
0.20991374552249908,
1.2164063453674316,
0.4796883463859558,
-0.6917984485626221,
0.7668057680130005,
-0.2788357138633728,
-0.0657367929816246,
-0.3010251522064209,
-0.1893412321805954,
0.3868183493614197,
0.19756735861301422,
0.13075195252895355,
0.48967015743255615,
-0.0424167700111866,
-0.35046514868736267,
0.13922344148159027,
0.5209591388702393,
-0.8544877171516418,
-0.13973993062973022,
0.5555885434150696,
0.32319992780685425,
0.24230380356311798,
0.3382166028022766,
0.15315623581409454,
-0.37985655665397644,
0.31553423404693604,
0.5767707228660583,
0.3705921471118927,
0.18195746839046478,
0.14313025772571564,
-0.08997218310832977,
0.29852211475372314,
0.16909894347190857,
0.5771130323410034,
-0.42945635318756104,
-0.6046192646026611,
-0.4125203490257263,
-0.6047488451004028,
0.06336008757352829,
-0.27261561155319214,
-0.4883541762828827,
0.36360228061676025,
-0.30223020911216736,
0.05696895718574524,
-0.458509624004364,
-0.5039636492729187,
-0.5895224213600159,
0.3781450688838959,
0.5659319758415222,
1.0365246534347534,
-0.6366918087005615,
1.0531328916549683,
0.427056223154068,
-0.3667001724243164,
-0.7440691590309143,
-0.5633921027183533,
0.025034263730049133,
-0.906211793422699,
0.8051394820213318,
-0.2841610610485077,
-0.6732472777366638,
-0.12555725872516632,
-0.5231528282165527,
-0.9562621712684631,
1.2334095239639282,
0.0263324324041605,
-0.513190746307373,
0.1915857493877411,
0.19093874096870422,
0.3974049687385559,
-0.5910875797271729,
-0.010004395619034767,
-0.0745418518781662,
0.35238927602767944,
0.5284643173217773,
-1.1961705684661865,
0.07032163441181183,
-0.3296932578086853,
0.4840579926967621,
-0.11932478100061417,
-0.8203073740005493,
0.6942802667617798,
-0.23722322285175323,
-0.32384541630744934,
0.33209776878356934,
0.9700840711593628,
0.03853672370314598,
0.05620846897363663,
0.5825432538986206,
0.6150714159011841,
0.03355501964688301,
0.10186394304037094,
0.8119443655014038,
-0.2783330976963043,
0.2361036241054535,
0.825171947479248,
-0.27021875977516174,
0.9020510911941528,
0.8809226751327515,
0.16750210523605347,
0.3090898394584656,
0.18433763086795807,
0.1545916050672531,
0.7483853697776794,
0.07305753976106644,
-0.49950602650642395,
-0.8748087286949158,
-0.10230092704296112,
-0.38143378496170044,
0.4800792336463928,
0.5040355324745178,
-0.33178725838661194,
-0.44092369079589844,
0.4276778995990753,
-0.47444024682044983,
0.05353238806128502,
-0.2612111568450928,
0.7406163811683655,
0.1306910216808319,
-0.06924590468406677,
0.7354215979576111,
-0.11217555403709412,
0.8906211853027344,
-0.6842791438102722,
-0.038233429193496704,
0.33389678597450256,
0.26399627327919006,
-0.021173907443881035,
-0.5596117377281189,
0.28414034843444824,
-0.45578381419181824,
-0.3635377585887909,
-0.0329083576798439,
1.2039021253585815,
-0.7918415069580078,
-0.48626208305358887,
0.5332549214363098,
0.3918917179107666,
-0.05133068189024925,
0.1937117874622345,
-0.5661659240722656,
0.8074255585670471,
-0.29018107056617737,
-0.059324175119400024,
0.30442652106285095,
0.6426920294761658,
-0.29527580738067627,
0.9164280295372009,
0.5518157482147217,
0.15497781336307526,
0.44420090317726135,
0.07905978709459305,
1.0818053483963013,
-0.758943498134613,
-0.7555572986602783,
-0.2637317180633545,
0.4740602672100067,
-0.0552566722035408,
-0.16184203326702118,
0.562423586845398,
0.16265767812728882,
0.723247766494751,
-0.22431449592113495,
0.7430034875869751,
-0.19446201622486115,
0.14403705298900604,
-0.5056579113006592,
0.7244793176651001,
-0.5251414775848389,
0.23705023527145386,
-0.20845739543437958,
-0.5752620697021484,
-0.21390962600708008,
0.41424360871315,
-0.22873523831367493,
0.01816057600080967,
0.7569429874420166,
0.9487892389297485,
-0.20535683631896973,
0.10717868059873581,
0.7305557131767273,
0.07376229763031006,
0.049512557685375214,
0.9497931599617004,
0.9126712083816528,
-0.4972085654735565,
0.9226466417312622,
-0.2652295231819153,
-0.13149218261241913,
-0.36712637543678284,
-0.7524572014808655,
-0.6755488514900208,
-0.8095462322235107,
-0.27532801032066345,
-0.501275360584259,
0.29372695088386536,
0.408850759267807,
0.7207921147346497,
-0.4955452084541321,
0.058923497796058655,
-0.04246819391846657,
-0.13354717195034027,
-0.08521173149347305,
-0.22673572599887848,
-0.025512535125017166,
-0.20409107208251953,
-0.34885379672050476,
0.15015394985675812,
0.9167535901069641,
0.1516740769147873,
-0.4504789710044861,
-0.25561022758483887,
-0.16417816281318665,
0.20678703486919403,
0.7692581415176392,
0.29300302267074585,
-1.0330750942230225,
-0.5672655701637268,
0.032544463872909546,
-0.6045495271682739,
-0.17698979377746582,
0.8911322355270386,
-0.9203031659126282,
0.43403032422065735,
0.6557855606079102,
0.49638915061950684,
0.3844631314277649,
-0.3028858006000519,
0.4609811305999756,
-0.06231334060430527,
0.5765802264213562,
-0.013938422314822674,
0.3049899637699127,
0.21557970345020294,
-0.19757074117660522,
-0.07298574596643448,
0.6427127718925476,
-0.18962934613227844,
-0.475310355424881,
0.2644394338130951,
-1.6151270866394043,
-0.4839187264442444,
1.180928349494934,
-0.057956866919994354,
-0.6991953253746033,
-0.3139946460723877,
-0.41436341404914856,
-0.13526032865047455,
-0.28360918164253235,
0.36597734689712524,
0.46781307458877563,
0.2087389975786209,
-0.5179876685142517,
-0.45677947998046875,
0.10006952285766602,
0.4312881827354431,
-0.46656057238578796,
-0.010477185249328613,
0.58942049741745,
0.34919801354408264,
-0.036840494722127914,
0.5780414938926697,
-0.3489261269569397,
0.4846252202987671,
0.2092701643705368,
0.17565207183361053,
-0.16021613776683807,
-0.235907644033432,
0.10531237721443176,
0.03424529358744621,
-0.6104631423950195,
-0.19036081433296204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03279v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03279v2
|
Lifelong Knowledge Editing for LLMs with Retrieval-Augmented Continuous Prompt Learning
| 2024-05-06T08:52:11 | 2024-05-08T03:45:51 |
Qizhou Chen, Taolin Zhang, Xiaofeng He, Dongyang Li, Chengyu Wang, Longtao Huang, Hui Xue
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Model editing aims to correct outdated or erroneous knowledge in large
language models (LLMs) without the need for costly retraining. Lifelong model
editing is the most challenging task that caters to the continuous editing
requirements of LLMs. Prior works primarily focus on single or batch editing;
nevertheless, these methods fall short in lifelong editing scenarios due to
catastrophic knowledge forgetting and the degradation of model performance.
Although retrieval-based methods alleviate these issues, they are impeded by
slow and cumbersome processes of integrating the retrieved knowledge into the
model. In this work, we introduce RECIPE, a RetriEval-augmented ContInuous
Prompt lEarning method, to boost editing efficacy and inference efficiency in
lifelong learning. RECIPE first converts knowledge statements into short and
informative continuous prompts, prefixed to the LLM's input query embedding, to
efficiently refine the response grounded on the knowledge. It further
integrates the Knowledge Sentinel (KS) that acts as an intermediary to
calculate a dynamic threshold, determining whether the retrieval repository
contains relevant knowledge. Our retriever and prompt encoder are jointly
trained to achieve editing properties, i.e., reliability, generality, and
locality. In our experiments, RECIPE is assessed extensively across multiple
LLMs and editing datasets, where it achieves superior editing performance.
RECIPE also demonstrates its capability to maintain the overall performance of
LLMs alongside showcasing fast editing and inference speed.
|
[
0.1564076542854309,
-1.0291756391525269,
0.7693538069725037,
0.1531541496515274,
-0.012837989255785942,
0.29944655299186707,
-0.28804048895835876,
-0.22249841690063477,
0.225009486079216,
0.6318162679672241,
-0.6493502855300903,
-0.6479681134223938,
-0.501332700252533,
0.14574821293354034,
-0.08073072135448456,
0.4278210401535034,
-0.1062287837266922,
0.14360058307647705,
-0.565096914768219,
-0.11462843418121338,
-0.9972370266914368,
-0.5237658619880676,
-0.9960046410560608,
0.040633730590343475,
0.7267813682556152,
0.48298585414886475,
0.5078293681144714,
0.6561746597290039,
0.008261973038315773,
0.22557982802391052,
-0.4884079098701477,
0.7034258246421814,
-0.4936409592628479,
0.7458925247192383,
-0.33891525864601135,
-0.3976544141769409,
-0.4333254098892212,
-0.27549678087234497,
0.6481166481971741,
0.5167611837387085,
0.1188100203871727,
0.041338227689266205,
0.21465453505516052,
0.6751282215118408,
-0.787835419178009,
-0.05896441265940666,
-0.7316718697547913,
-0.03959318622946739,
-0.09292599558830261,
-0.1411782205104828,
-0.6804668307304382,
-0.558153510093689,
-0.21189866960048676,
-0.6268072724342346,
-0.08735916018486023,
-0.046502526849508286,
0.33961033821105957,
0.23060384392738342,
-0.2808374762535095,
-0.543831467628479,
-0.531115710735321,
0.5923776030540466,
-0.7302606105804443,
0.525517463684082,
0.2300529032945633,
0.19492000341415405,
-0.5594654083251953,
-0.837522566318512,
-0.6345868706703186,
-0.22256062924861908,
0.15802696347236633,
0.10546928644180298,
0.016761958599090576,
0.03250233829021454,
0.1258326917886734,
0.01892327331006527,
-0.33661937713623047,
0.21606236696243286,
0.0549507774412632,
-0.17185106873512268,
0.3368775546550751,
0.4390011727809906,
0.39652690291404724,
-0.17718225717544556,
-0.1703602522611618,
0.2331729382276535,
-0.8340736031532288,
-0.06702283769845963,
-0.040863633155822754,
0.14830394089221954,
0.45892536640167236,
0.7020387649536133,
-0.21699528396129608,
0.9549354314804077,
0.029254160821437836,
-0.3568651080131531,
-0.05572742596268654,
-0.294210821390152,
-0.03472282364964485,
-0.06716740131378174,
0.6365970969200134,
0.42211610078811646,
0.05371953919529915,
-0.10653279721736908,
-0.31734779477119446,
-0.19702406227588654,
0.05295013263821602,
-0.5396131873130798,
-0.02892589196562767,
0.003368914593011141,
-0.024848423898220062,
-0.0725182443857193,
-0.24949167668819427,
-0.5925853252410889,
-0.47636744379997253,
-0.3405516445636749,
0.5861731171607971,
-0.578834056854248,
0.29151150584220886,
0.11287348717451096,
-0.1982460469007492,
-0.1503870189189911,
0.605320155620575,
-0.7947540283203125,
0.016718225553631783,
0.5454686284065247,
0.9923307299613953,
-0.04481663554906845,
-0.38709667325019836,
-0.999215304851532,
0.33584487438201904,
-0.34724509716033936,
0.7262380719184875,
-0.6911773085594177,
-0.5737777948379517,
-0.04273078218102455,
0.0584619976580143,
-0.21301031112670898,
-0.6344282627105713,
0.39486637711524963,
-0.9775970578193665,
-0.07895641028881073,
-0.5050606727600098,
-1.0593801736831665,
0.053540464490652084,
0.20399698615074158,
-0.5571096539497375,
1.094649314880371,
0.10965874046087265,
-0.39117783308029175,
0.49156612157821655,
-0.5892730951309204,
-0.3851352035999298,
0.16360898315906525,
0.11129098385572433,
-0.25905895233154297,
-0.057507146149873734,
0.3900001645088196,
0.437491238117218,
0.030627790838479996,
0.5750345587730408,
-0.190519317984581,
-0.20994964241981506,
0.20131227374076843,
-0.37392568588256836,
0.3448634147644043,
0.029570821672677994,
0.015374365262687206,
0.27962565422058105,
-0.6505246758460999,
-0.218736931681633,
0.12092965096235275,
-0.5578922033309937,
-0.3795170485973358,
-0.019086025655269623,
-0.22265736758708954,
0.096683569252491,
0.397983580827713,
-0.48389506340026855,
0.5672390460968018,
-0.1121252179145813,
0.34755560755729675,
0.9612852931022644,
0.5897066593170166,
0.3349880874156952,
-0.42019161581993103,
0.5511435866355896,
-0.089509516954422,
0.2970395088195801,
-0.3248204290866852,
-0.4846934378147125,
-0.751792311668396,
-0.29219284653663635,
0.4406546652317047,
0.7113875150680542,
-0.9168335795402527,
0.49743199348449707,
-0.19439736008644104,
-0.4767342209815979,
-0.545685350894928,
0.48643118143081665,
0.1961420625448227,
0.9458116888999939,
0.4941938817501068,
-0.07203759253025055,
-0.5830114483833313,
-0.49413758516311646,
-0.49730899930000305,
0.2751306891441345,
-0.04692508652806282,
0.03301005810499191,
0.5463164448738098,
-0.40917226672172546,
1.1292228698730469,
-0.4604071080684662,
-0.02278350107371807,
-0.327063649892807,
-0.06884868443012238,
0.17477791011333466,
0.508055567741394,
0.10939884185791016,
-0.4925161600112915,
-0.7075490355491638,
-0.20080682635307312,
-1.0000706911087036,
-0.16316227614879608,
-0.35813871026039124,
-0.2284192442893982,
0.23705507814884186,
0.5072808861732483,
-0.7423961162567139,
0.4127604067325592,
0.03987130522727966,
-0.32449257373809814,
0.9600479006767273,
-0.1956871747970581,
0.3378041684627533,
-1.0429883003234863,
-0.07243835926055908,
-0.2780681848526001,
-0.3179292380809784,
-0.487627774477005,
0.0599847286939621,
0.41041019558906555,
0.009490841068327427,
-0.6447531580924988,
1.036077618598938,
-0.4250950217247009,
0.1481572538614273,
-0.036941077560186386,
0.14975474774837494,
0.1712685078382492,
0.29865536093711853,
0.02517356164753437,
1.014154076576233,
0.2850189805030823,
-0.7176799774169922,
0.48768261075019836,
0.3427135646343231,
-0.4200170338153839,
0.5144612193107605,
-0.5626152753829956,
0.2662057876586914,
0.06365373730659485,
0.25161856412887573,
-0.5142316818237305,
-0.16925854980945587,
0.37653565406799316,
-0.34197261929512024,
0.1006835401058197,
-0.21159929037094116,
-0.9534530639648438,
-0.013473693281412125,
-0.15457592904567719,
-0.07171755284070969,
0.4504970908164978,
-0.7697222232818604,
0.7590172290802002,
-0.15817199647426605,
-0.3645089268684387,
-0.40362748503685,
-0.44670429825782776,
0.3386978805065155,
-0.06066279113292694,
-0.6191460490226746,
0.3725120425224304,
-0.3597019612789154,
-0.16447141766548157,
0.13488762080669403,
0.036938928067684174,
0.21528758108615875,
0.012189111672341824,
0.0498000793159008,
0.3205351233482361,
0.08479247242212296,
0.25538527965545654,
0.5664070844650269,
-0.07808280736207962,
-0.11037858575582504,
-0.31774234771728516,
0.2783917188644409,
0.28502628207206726,
-0.30813464522361755,
-0.4479236304759979,
0.24353235960006714,
0.6057093143463135,
-0.2641473412513733,
1.180015206336975,
0.1229434683918953,
-0.3003212511539459,
-0.17482306063175201,
-0.8408680558204651,
-0.10132904350757599,
-0.4619171619415283,
0.13337759673595428,
-0.38646191358566284,
-0.9746742844581604,
0.6306836009025574,
-0.328403115272522,
0.07388109713792801,
0.41180312633514404,
0.25827130675315857,
-0.1100187823176384,
0.5776491761207581,
0.2775326371192932,
0.051627423614263535,
0.42995142936706543,
-0.025314655154943466,
-0.3782109022140503,
-1.1388204097747803,
-0.39599424600601196,
-0.23978154361248016,
0.02490014024078846,
0.020630216225981712,
-0.5479869842529297,
0.6129525303840637,
0.25123023986816406,
-0.42872777581214905,
0.0267304889857769,
-0.2389531433582306,
0.7365805506706238,
0.5262662172317505,
0.62054842710495,
0.5220600366592407,
-0.2875717878341675,
-0.44900110363960266,
-0.28203269839286804,
-0.8362553119659424,
-0.4136214852333069,
1.077634334564209,
0.08099371939897537,
0.5844247341156006,
0.007572989445179701,
0.7809164524078369,
0.5897918939590454,
0.1289318948984146,
-0.6295260190963745,
0.6088602542877197,
0.08973852545022964,
-0.1823035627603531,
-0.305038720369339,
-0.4440821409225464,
-0.48861443996429443,
-0.0370190404355526,
-0.2678303122520447,
-0.433963418006897,
0.07115337997674942,
0.3937448561191559,
-0.34261658787727356,
0.48345616459846497,
-0.737562894821167,
0.8362860083580017,
-0.4215129315853119,
-0.8000511527061462,
0.02071991376578808,
-0.630314290523529,
0.16164842247962952,
-0.21711741387844086,
0.3119907081127167,
0.34869584441185,
-0.012845695950090885,
0.7041769623756409,
-0.604839563369751,
0.9760883450508118,
-0.3498551845550537,
0.2443266361951828,
0.16150711476802826,
0.4566616714000702,
0.8645448088645935,
0.3132815659046173,
-0.2229616791009903,
-0.27258560061454773,
-0.2149069756269455,
-0.32532617449760437,
-0.9471468925476074,
0.6114814281463623,
-0.38899391889572144,
-0.7015199661254883,
-0.3401415944099426,
-0.3835994601249695,
-0.290301114320755,
0.2867836654186249,
0.06032424792647362,
0.4117676615715027,
-0.17282472550868988,
-0.038063857704401016,
1.0154991149902344,
-0.4193495810031891,
0.15685318410396576,
0.4550379812717438,
-0.3152375817298889,
-0.5587530732154846,
0.7844400405883789,
0.2519436478614807,
0.5353995561599731,
0.43982985615730286,
0.1602921485900879,
-0.18055561184883118,
-0.43644893169403076,
-0.47810226678848267,
0.15736602246761322,
-1.124918818473816,
-0.20303434133529663,
-0.8370912671089172,
-0.25650539994239807,
-0.3595549166202545,
-0.6266571879386902,
-0.2854821979999542,
-0.30270829796791077,
-0.6389999389648438,
0.04584367200732231,
0.6284803748130798,
0.6098518967628479,
-0.27315858006477356,
0.22091466188430786,
-0.9472025632858276,
0.28290095925331116,
0.45506662130355835,
0.1047305315732956,
0.07816888391971588,
-0.7678714990615845,
-0.25480350852012634,
-0.048280879855155945,
-0.14771778881549835,
-0.9226081371307373,
0.5460290908813477,
0.3107337951660156,
0.489980012178421,
-0.03550411015748978,
-0.058813948184251785,
0.8128899931907654,
-0.5756234526634216,
0.8608608841896057,
-0.08768342435359955,
-1.0319106578826904,
0.8250650763511658,
-0.1819877177476883,
0.7065642476081848,
0.6622692942619324,
0.4649173617362976,
-0.8875533938407898,
-0.349240779876709,
-0.1695200800895691,
-0.8574758768081665,
0.13839702308177948,
-0.3490198254585266,
0.054403673857450485,
-0.3081492483615875,
0.6751670241355896,
0.37011322379112244,
0.1505124717950821,
-0.3195173740386963,
0.054827556014060974,
0.05740721896290779,
-0.049222465604543686,
0.13560228049755096,
-0.6237643361091614,
0.18678529560565948,
-0.49008047580718994,
0.9575571417808533,
0.0880948156118393,
-0.012547235935926437,
0.16992619633674622,
-0.46034127473831177,
-0.009397747926414013,
0.3434888422489166,
0.42526984214782715,
0.7995046973228455,
-0.34712445735931396,
-0.06241137906908989,
0.43870604038238525,
-0.26453036069869995,
0.14119622111320496,
-0.26726922392845154,
-0.24616093933582306,
-0.03681080788373947,
0.6098740696907043,
0.7798571586608887,
0.6243419647216797,
-0.7039344906806946,
0.06463751196861267,
-0.17986325919628143,
0.05773245543241501,
-0.2960265874862671,
0.2419230192899704,
0.3735438585281372,
0.2077660858631134,
0.3146744668483734,
0.2402510792016983,
-0.08671700954437256,
-0.2669026553630829,
0.209872767329216,
0.10339765250682831,
0.053666409105062485,
0.06654767692089081,
0.6311719417572021,
0.05415397137403488,
-0.3623427450656891,
1.0199341773986816,
-0.2117992341518402,
-0.5805732011795044,
0.23518328368663788,
0.5363442301750183,
0.7523755431175232,
-0.21712274849414825,
0.09902694821357727,
0.369444876909256,
0.1266297698020935,
-0.03928365558385849,
0.05631330609321594,
-0.09964972734451294,
-0.5920078158378601,
-0.40873605012893677,
-0.6867908835411072,
-0.6594147682189941,
-0.14176884293556213,
-0.5952820181846619,
0.2725265622138977,
-0.385267972946167,
0.12595120072364807,
-0.2562606930732727,
-0.33703094720840454,
-0.622287929058075,
0.14264191687107086,
-0.3522194027900696,
1.1824413537979126,
-0.6651453375816345,
0.7962517738342285,
0.4293670654296875,
-0.43172046542167664,
-0.5089026093482971,
-0.20484551787376404,
0.20441971719264984,
-0.6390451788902283,
0.6783003807067871,
0.043244484812021255,
-0.004702860955148935,
0.19476135075092316,
-0.5983349680900574,
-0.6224536895751953,
1.1678613424301147,
0.4401433765888214,
-0.8405895233154297,
-0.20247438549995422,
-0.09009823203086853,
0.2881620526313782,
-0.2458876520395279,
0.06776917725801468,
0.5649100542068481,
0.44528600573539734,
0.45342305302619934,
-0.5608610510826111,
-0.051963698118925095,
-0.1527218222618103,
0.042432889342308044,
-0.07363655418157578,
-0.30954334139823914,
0.5458236932754517,
-0.13907381892204285,
-0.04043741896748543,
0.13417653739452362,
0.6565858721733093,
0.5182315111160278,
0.20931050181388855,
0.17004045844078064,
0.6306038498878479,
0.7353768348693848,
0.18565790355205536,
0.8088890314102173,
-0.23306526243686676,
0.12849587202072144,
1.4414278268814087,
-0.43258213996887207,
0.9615305662155151,
0.3822401762008667,
0.09076254069805145,
0.5078355669975281,
0.7748157382011414,
0.16046682000160217,
0.519888162612915,
-0.054852649569511414,
-0.7276384234428406,
-0.3159564137458801,
-0.12145321816205978,
-0.23651018738746643,
-0.014991560019552708,
0.5231127738952637,
-0.369862824678421,
0.06890029460191727,
0.3643798232078552,
0.4756234288215637,
0.2143520563840866,
-0.24711072444915771,
0.8846562504768372,
-0.03798147663474083,
-0.6083446145057678,
0.5351694226264954,
-0.02042304165661335,
0.5631270408630371,
-0.7405242919921875,
-0.2497255951166153,
-0.49478229880332947,
-0.20709294080734253,
-0.0221016276627779,
-0.8358083367347717,
0.2521890103816986,
0.11630650609731674,
-0.3276898264884949,
-0.22438226640224457,
0.6840842366218567,
-0.37893298268318176,
-0.4713042676448822,
0.2449396550655365,
0.3852021396160126,
-0.24201370775699615,
-0.09980113059282303,
-0.6625219583511353,
0.4252425730228424,
-0.21406230330467224,
-0.32632312178611755,
0.3162320852279663,
0.4025818705558777,
0.25075626373291016,
0.7586180567741394,
0.7439419627189636,
0.30696386098861694,
0.08975923806428909,
-0.16755637526512146,
1.0711541175842285,
-0.7271537780761719,
-0.4599493443965912,
-0.9320572018623352,
0.8300243616104126,
0.09400823712348938,
-0.09422951936721802,
0.679751455783844,
0.45412883162498474,
0.7163708209991455,
-0.3617123067378998,
0.8784911036491394,
0.03230929747223854,
0.36576637625694275,
-1.136987566947937,
0.7559502124786377,
-0.40807870030403137,
0.4502924680709839,
-0.05256730318069458,
-0.9199234247207642,
-0.5132122039794922,
0.10896765440702438,
-0.46661585569381714,
-0.10321318358182907,
0.5918282270431519,
0.9445216655731201,
0.15720519423484802,
-0.16818326711654663,
0.4082804322242737,
0.21180088818073273,
0.3461782932281494,
0.4792226254940033,
0.7568025588989258,
-0.053382016718387604,
-0.13012252748012543,
-0.25502288341522217,
-0.24070388078689575,
-0.07573091238737106,
-0.8650038838386536,
-0.8354642987251282,
-0.5164176225662231,
-0.043461285531520844,
-0.2694348692893982,
0.7716109156608582,
1.1806817054748535,
0.39360761642456055,
-0.4750273525714874,
0.029789311811327934,
-0.0794522762298584,
0.33501625061035156,
-0.25427114963531494,
-0.24480020999908447,
0.446262001991272,
-0.44722339510917664,
-0.43388962745666504,
0.8913792967796326,
0.3386625647544861,
-0.2553456425666809,
-0.012354040518403053,
-0.13780935108661652,
-0.5311754941940308,
0.1062755435705185,
0.751187264919281,
0.387446790933609,
-0.5736650228500366,
-0.23714035749435425,
0.0945664569735527,
0.16632680594921112,
-0.06580764055252075,
0.488944411277771,
-0.8655171990394592,
1.1320945024490356,
0.11128313839435577,
0.9601038694381714,
0.3526040017604828,
-0.20768873393535614,
0.3691804111003876,
-0.767997145652771,
-0.2182713896036148,
0.18761561810970306,
0.21854767203330994,
0.48794835805892944,
-0.6725109815597534,
0.20875900983810425,
0.5190548300743103,
-0.873170793056488,
-0.6028764247894287,
0.05902416259050369,
-0.7489320635795593,
-0.12302965670824051,
1.0412579774856567,
-0.3051561713218689,
-0.321648508310318,
0.10939299315214157,
-0.2962799072265625,
0.3811413049697876,
-0.42781198024749756,
0.5834411382675171,
0.5715636610984802,
-0.05647426098585129,
-0.3360641598701477,
-0.6373199224472046,
0.2772751450538635,
0.22436174750328064,
-0.8212431073188782,
0.030333783477544785,
0.7916449904441833,
0.4362053871154785,
-0.42695847153663635,
0.4319528341293335,
-0.05612114071846008,
0.5309259295463562,
-0.10094094276428223,
0.14070938527584076,
-0.36856237053871155,
-0.5466099381446838,
-0.32461681962013245,
0.07431492209434509,
0.4009688198566437,
0.1469908505678177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03207v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03207v1
|
A Philosophical Introduction to Language Models - Part II: The Way Forward
| 2024-05-06T07:12:45 | 2024-05-06T07:12:45 |
Raphaël Millière, Cameron Buckner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, the second of two companion pieces, we explore novel
philosophical questions raised by recent progress in large language models
(LLMs) that go beyond the classical debates covered in the first part. We focus
particularly on issues related to interpretability, examining evidence from
causal intervention methods about the nature of LLMs' internal representations
and computations. We also discuss the implications of multimodal and modular
extensions of LLMs, recent debates about whether such systems may meet minimal
criteria for consciousness, and concerns about secrecy and reproducibility in
LLM research. Finally, we discuss whether LLM-like systems may be relevant to
modeling aspects of human cognition, if their architectural characteristics and
learning scenario are adequately constrained.
|
[
-0.1099737286567688,
-0.7272250652313232,
0.9858427047729492,
-0.05825083330273628,
-0.1436702460050583,
-0.14950819313526154,
-0.3199102282524109,
-0.6908103227615356,
-0.049115169793367386,
0.8377125263214111,
-0.46229010820388794,
0.14685045182704926,
-0.7342109680175781,
-0.14327958226203918,
-0.6451855897903442,
0.5275125503540039,
0.009412460960447788,
0.2020406723022461,
-0.10240408778190613,
-0.04533642902970314,
-0.4491090476512909,
-0.5038847327232361,
-0.9587298035621643,
-0.4832249879837036,
0.45763468742370605,
0.27024662494659424,
0.6960816979408264,
0.4622572362422943,
0.3618738353252411,
0.3531889021396637,
-0.11054745316505432,
-0.30762431025505066,
-0.11162754148244858,
0.37062200903892517,
-0.36729809641838074,
-0.8263112306594849,
-0.22165970504283905,
0.04378156363964081,
0.9656003713607788,
1.0411497354507446,
-0.11560977250337601,
0.09219194203615189,
0.2680007517337799,
0.5735127925872803,
-0.19856159389019012,
0.38282909989356995,
-0.37572523951530457,
-0.01690155267715454,
-0.12602321803569794,
0.05048387870192528,
-0.6222290992736816,
-0.2331230342388153,
0.1206439733505249,
-0.2081589549779892,
-0.12753361463546753,
0.11159517616033554,
0.23916354775428772,
0.14624671638011932,
-0.7653339505195618,
-0.6707897782325745,
-0.98545241355896,
0.7854564189910889,
-0.7842028141021729,
0.4109918475151062,
0.377869576215744,
0.1912636011838913,
-0.38637521862983704,
-0.8331598043441772,
-0.6879109740257263,
-0.3406314253807068,
-0.23901791870594025,
-0.013139307498931885,
-0.22083424031734467,
0.16541041433811188,
0.08009734749794006,
0.22180797159671783,
-0.43366602063179016,
0.31727319955825806,
-0.43784192204475403,
-0.24949300289154053,
0.4369972348213196,
0.25056225061416626,
0.39027106761932373,
-0.13003122806549072,
-0.32461029291152954,
0.23033660650253296,
-0.6723759770393372,
-0.16480594873428345,
0.4053092300891876,
-0.03892746567726135,
-0.020523929968476295,
0.587150514125824,
0.08823969215154648,
0.8172259330749512,
-0.4023982286453247,
-0.06879720091819763,
-0.44673848152160645,
-0.3088037073612213,
-0.08071369677782059,
-0.11124444007873535,
0.4357967674732208,
0.19188004732131958,
0.23910416662693024,
-0.06127166002988815,
-0.014775069430470467,
0.07459528744220734,
0.19471091032028198,
-0.5379459857940674,
-0.49111300706863403,
0.330440491437912,
-0.41167959570884705,
0.02572047896683216,
-0.11183503270149231,
-0.39444440603256226,
-0.3980175852775574,
-0.6015738248825073,
0.17620114982128143,
-0.39029034972190857,
-0.4864244759082794,
0.42678967118263245,
0.26663175225257874,
0.5054109692573547,
0.6621513366699219,
-1.0043306350708008,
0.51872318983078,
1.232522964477539,
0.5522213578224182,
0.14672139286994934,
-0.1284736543893814,
0.03769062086939812,
0.2657085061073303,
-0.42223918437957764,
0.5749666094779968,
-0.6213007569313049,
-0.4304962158203125,
0.17509283125400543,
0.3052299916744232,
0.07872626185417175,
-0.18039816617965698,
0.6627534627914429,
-0.6579416990280151,
0.5798047780990601,
-0.49850454926490784,
-0.6956902146339417,
-0.5403846502304077,
0.06788898259401321,
-0.45608630776405334,
0.670333981513977,
-0.21926937997341156,
-0.5714700818061829,
-0.18602199852466583,
-0.6089414954185486,
-0.5238158702850342,
0.049620624631643295,
-0.2593934237957001,
0.4925721287727356,
0.4696005582809448,
-0.4962410628795624,
0.3949655294418335,
-0.5614618062973022,
0.25894272327423096,
-0.3697051405906677,
0.06654661148786545,
0.5504143834114075,
-0.46713361144065857,
0.8720047473907471,
0.27307912707328796,
-0.10085241496562958,
-0.23092243075370789,
-0.7167139649391174,
0.1055804193019867,
0.19294723868370056,
-0.10649880021810532,
-0.5337035059928894,
0.5637012124061584,
-0.23915903270244598,
0.23821856081485748,
0.46550285816192627,
-0.5601564049720764,
0.09160622954368591,
-0.4365766942501068,
0.830484926700592,
0.9894432425498962,
-0.20934760570526123,
0.5857217907905579,
-0.062104709446430206,
0.351568341255188,
-0.22003798186779022,
0.22069942951202393,
-0.39884936809539795,
-0.6676532030105591,
-0.854426920413971,
-0.09168887883424759,
0.020134437829256058,
0.4739065170288086,
-0.41269025206565857,
0.26736220717430115,
-0.09493044763803482,
-0.03721477836370468,
0.06068931519985199,
0.1352064311504364,
0.5118609666824341,
0.3999577760696411,
-0.07526575028896332,
-0.46335476636886597,
-0.44901055097579956,
-1.0167806148529053,
0.013973044231534004,
-0.6814586520195007,
-0.03415217995643616,
0.327246755361557,
0.5310786962509155,
0.02673049457371235,
0.8002327084541321,
-0.6935629844665527,
0.40653306245803833,
-0.21203114092350006,
-0.29749250411987305,
0.061950843781232834,
0.5491183996200562,
0.24440379440784454,
-0.4294799268245697,
0.027519579976797104,
-0.13375656306743622,
-0.9090064764022827,
0.10818155109882355,
0.12273120135068893,
-0.03731437399983406,
-0.17880210280418396,
0.5906836986541748,
-0.6466498374938965,
0.016726689413189888,
0.4678698480129242,
-0.21519067883491516,
0.2781229019165039,
-0.2782757878303528,
-0.32879868149757385,
-1.3637757301330566,
-0.2503063380718231,
-0.22730515897274017,
-0.07637287676334381,
-0.9354745149612427,
0.3536158502101898,
-0.24971920251846313,
-0.05640466511249542,
-0.31531447172164917,
0.7342604994773865,
-0.38404223322868347,
-0.34999167919158936,
-0.6600582599639893,
0.21887065470218658,
-0.012587977573275566,
0.24851757287979126,
0.09675844758749008,
0.38850507140159607,
0.6507219076156616,
-0.6035799980163574,
0.33604907989501953,
0.013147328980267048,
-0.46360448002815247,
0.5179755091667175,
-0.7046030163764954,
0.2819490432739258,
-0.3121863603591919,
0.5878528952598572,
-1.2459452152252197,
-0.4312823712825775,
0.5467970371246338,
-0.22716428339481354,
0.2426113337278366,
-0.03637781739234924,
-0.585959255695343,
-0.2245936542749405,
-0.05841439962387085,
0.5381535887718201,
0.5903078317642212,
-0.2870447039604187,
0.42471209168434143,
0.32942456007003784,
-0.316643089056015,
-0.20995181798934937,
-0.7208976745605469,
0.1329413801431656,
-0.09793529659509659,
-0.5946410298347473,
-0.2776012122631073,
-0.02437933161854744,
-0.8457960486412048,
-0.07626141607761383,
0.3178200423717499,
-0.037661075592041016,
0.2448989748954773,
0.3063521385192871,
0.305961936712265,
-0.3901055157184601,
0.37228214740753174,
-0.0028803737368434668,
-0.11727853864431381,
0.407073438167572,
-0.6673972010612488,
0.42482221126556396,
-0.11046739667654037,
-0.5138775110244751,
-0.376517653465271,
0.40822112560272217,
0.27801576256752014,
0.03436073660850525,
0.5919286012649536,
0.22185975313186646,
-0.514941930770874,
-0.0009854454547166824,
-0.4614647924900055,
-0.3630680441856384,
-0.4520561993122101,
0.4170517325401306,
-0.23148244619369507,
-0.9768216013908386,
0.39360764622688293,
-0.20669135451316833,
-0.0018624614458531141,
0.3374784588813782,
0.7587564587593079,
-0.3034195303916931,
0.5996987819671631,
0.8034706711769104,
0.19799348711967468,
0.44225215911865234,
-0.05815408378839493,
0.2500620484352112,
-1.12991464138031,
-0.22379350662231445,
-0.5164723992347717,
-0.11604384332895279,
-0.5597406029701233,
-0.5857322812080383,
0.03271779417991638,
0.2865901291370392,
-0.1801992654800415,
0.34458088874816895,
-0.1611989438533783,
0.385524719953537,
0.11174457520246506,
-0.0040315561927855015,
0.4179523289203644,
-0.20481128990650177,
-0.0059107085689902306,
0.0028536859899759293,
-0.5302466750144958,
-0.9016914367675781,
1.0604774951934814,
0.6905760169029236,
0.8326157927513123,
0.5274667143821716,
0.13881902396678925,
-0.0646495372056961,
0.3631983697414398,
-0.6425020098686218,
0.715588390827179,
0.022098422050476074,
-1.098854899406433,
-0.3298912048339844,
0.11346098780632019,
-0.7155197858810425,
0.5128657221794128,
0.1550825983285904,
-1.2105193138122559,
0.20375674962997437,
0.04890802875161171,
-0.26767897605895996,
0.4973412752151489,
-0.6241713166236877,
0.33322736620903015,
-0.3885413706302643,
-0.23798631131649017,
-0.5551449060440063,
-0.9819657206535339,
0.9465105533599854,
-0.14337895810604095,
0.5196247100830078,
-0.11215317994356155,
-0.42634615302085876,
0.7012729644775391,
-0.20847781002521515,
1.059492826461792,
0.05458826944231987,
-0.7213440537452698,
0.357838898897171,
0.07523027807474136,
0.31320199370384216,
0.1823989301919937,
-0.006027635652571917,
0.0029337930027395487,
0.14082327485084534,
-0.34779104590415955,
-0.7446995973587036,
0.7413963079452515,
-0.58075350522995,
-0.9005400538444519,
-0.26799532771110535,
-0.6865471601486206,
-0.3439817726612091,
0.2230386734008789,
-0.226888045668602,
0.6599926948547363,
-0.05410713702440262,
0.12822139263153076,
1.0219886302947998,
-0.3498017489910126,
0.48415860533714294,
0.6358630061149597,
-0.4741641879081726,
-0.17274710536003113,
0.5287626385688782,
-0.13035710155963898,
0.5425979495048523,
0.5039723515510559,
0.24489279091358185,
-0.42743390798568726,
-0.4575713574886322,
-0.2005896121263504,
0.36795639991760254,
-0.9480916261672974,
0.5578048229217529,
-0.537531316280365,
-0.008880577981472015,
-0.2700037658214569,
0.22304613888263702,
-0.3759906589984894,
-0.6064122319221497,
-0.3707662522792816,
-0.00776413269340992,
0.09089192748069763,
1.1524858474731445,
-0.07178027927875519,
0.39747995138168335,
-0.5336053967475891,
-0.07116074115037918,
0.47028225660324097,
0.23922911286354065,
0.22973236441612244,
-0.7192632555961609,
-0.22284048795700073,
-0.09623819589614868,
-0.12863865494728088,
-0.8126689791679382,
-0.3375590741634369,
-0.16252584755420685,
0.35252758860588074,
0.538568913936615,
-0.15367259085178375,
0.3732210695743561,
-0.7056133151054382,
0.8468566536903381,
0.2488655298948288,
-0.6900008320808411,
0.32450035214424133,
-0.2698434889316559,
-0.16948020458221436,
0.22721730172634125,
0.3427802622318268,
-0.47928038239479065,
-0.23064358532428741,
-0.43084898591041565,
-0.32583025097846985,
0.49024736881256104,
-0.09403222799301147,
0.5099804401397705,
0.2541581094264984,
0.8926926255226135,
0.05438149720430374,
0.08923667669296265,
-0.5533730387687683,
-0.2179117202758789,
0.1916118562221527,
-0.07367461174726486,
-0.4771367311477661,
-0.5339877605438232,
-0.1359093338251114,
-0.13076338171958923,
0.360098272562027,
0.039947547018527985,
0.3100830912590027,
0.059057679027318954,
0.06827288866043091,
0.04147471860051155,
0.41514337062835693,
0.9300252199172974,
0.774832010269165,
0.26486068964004517,
0.3570684790611267,
0.02210645191371441,
-0.18319068849086761,
0.30826708674430847,
-0.15290755033493042,
-0.04322332888841629,
-0.26500043272972107,
0.730480432510376,
0.7721260786056519,
0.39811307191848755,
-0.35954970121383667,
0.13452686369419098,
0.0998179242014885,
-0.06013539806008339,
-0.5671257972717285,
-0.0579407662153244,
0.26693761348724365,
0.5615642666816711,
0.10095051676034927,
-0.1727025806903839,
0.12864461541175842,
-1.1069461107254028,
-0.07496260106563568,
0.5559484958648682,
-0.39619600772857666,
-0.745281994342804,
0.5931764841079712,
-0.1047833040356636,
-0.4561728239059448,
0.24071340262889862,
0.20992766320705414,
-0.5802072286605835,
0.21981509029865265,
0.48412081599235535,
0.8740039467811584,
-0.21583715081214905,
-0.03599581494927406,
-0.008853261359035969,
0.5262773036956787,
-0.13890373706817627,
0.15810741484165192,
-0.19817441701889038,
-0.8481717109680176,
-0.6053342223167419,
-0.4282223582267761,
-0.6054540872573853,
-0.12207566201686859,
-0.6268773078918457,
0.04304247722029686,
-0.4000825583934784,
-0.09638690203428268,
0.0374443419277668,
-0.031400397419929504,
-0.11397526413202286,
-0.07142160087823868,
0.31917804479599,
0.8135841488838196,
-0.7815504670143127,
1.1260629892349243,
0.7025794982910156,
-0.22828595340251923,
-0.7215786576271057,
-0.03762788325548172,
-0.045269981026649475,
-0.7558806538581848,
0.6307989358901978,
-0.3759564757347107,
-0.27317965030670166,
-0.0595109760761261,
-0.64642333984375,
-0.8227644562721252,
0.8523325324058533,
0.612702488899231,
-0.40946274995803833,
-0.4452040493488312,
0.10595241189002991,
0.5318471789360046,
-0.06064193695783615,
0.24513724446296692,
0.4419373869895935,
0.3791734278202057,
0.10067452490329742,
-0.6006317138671875,
0.04873830825090408,
0.04500759392976761,
0.16071400046348572,
0.18988323211669922,
-0.884035587310791,
1.0710973739624023,
-0.05974821001291275,
-0.06950714439153671,
0.4985099732875824,
0.7046694159507751,
-0.10646117478609085,
0.061959829181432724,
0.13552112877368927,
0.48509320616722107,
0.6065351366996765,
0.05402367562055588,
1.2680937051773071,
-0.5532171130180359,
0.3050437271595001,
1.1076130867004395,
-0.5099050998687744,
0.8010379672050476,
0.5408499836921692,
-0.4911326766014099,
0.5347859859466553,
0.54464191198349,
0.5098625421524048,
0.31543484330177307,
0.291538268327713,
-0.46437323093414307,
-0.1864229142665863,
-0.081633061170578,
-0.4706023633480072,
0.29557889699935913,
0.5416828989982605,
-0.24359171092510223,
-0.09090868383646011,
0.010268708691000938,
-0.02218557894229889,
-0.04722598195075989,
-0.043571587651968,
0.6467497944831848,
0.5320591926574707,
-0.6609185338020325,
-0.10839328914880753,
0.2990746796131134,
0.21556511521339417,
-0.6170732975006104,
0.16867321729660034,
-0.2609902620315552,
0.2657339870929718,
0.07685492932796478,
-0.7853214740753174,
0.2716944217681885,
-0.2562366724014282,
-0.08032143115997314,
-0.20078851282596588,
0.8007537722587585,
-0.24250301718711853,
-0.56007981300354,
0.1433163583278656,
0.5775302052497864,
0.34817206859588623,
0.4994615316390991,
-0.5131858587265015,
0.1313086450099945,
-0.20196974277496338,
-0.25905922055244446,
0.3198273479938507,
0.3075438439846039,
-0.1384992003440857,
0.8828257322311401,
0.5853098034858704,
-0.024194005876779556,
0.22636497020721436,
-0.3376239538192749,
0.6513186693191528,
-0.7322213053703308,
-0.29671019315719604,
-0.994162917137146,
0.01530067902058363,
0.35422375798225403,
-0.05616426840424538,
0.8036737442016602,
0.37505486607551575,
0.6894900798797607,
0.1625683456659317,
0.5440333485603333,
0.010348782874643803,
0.3490146994590759,
-0.7242382168769836,
0.2909544110298157,
-0.4284077286720276,
0.4105991721153259,
-0.2771792411804199,
-0.6905121803283691,
-0.14663773775100708,
0.556395947933197,
-0.43753525614738464,
-0.08559994399547577,
0.749793291091919,
0.5681522488594055,
0.08262401819229126,
0.35588398575782776,
0.33368682861328125,
0.2767603099346161,
0.29884839057922363,
0.5661410689353943,
1.1756501197814941,
-0.3025597035884857,
-0.03407617658376694,
-0.06090784817934036,
-0.007480786181986332,
0.02323194406926632,
-0.6349895000457764,
-0.5900382995605469,
-0.5673889517784119,
-0.21049053966999054,
-0.2695007920265198,
-0.16561459004878998,
0.6780937910079956,
0.4901091754436493,
-0.6355587244033813,
-0.47573402523994446,
-0.06090512126684189,
0.14864395558834076,
0.24681036174297333,
-0.09158483892679214,
0.28067871928215027,
-0.006971913855522871,
-0.7929058074951172,
0.28591278195381165,
0.4631894528865814,
-0.011048519052565098,
-0.9026146531105042,
-0.19929832220077515,
-0.0971749797463417,
0.5217632055282593,
0.9283291697502136,
0.4468173682689667,
-1.1031274795532227,
-0.6232958436012268,
-0.21751132607460022,
-0.04449532553553581,
-0.23506003618240356,
0.9576104283332825,
-0.390177845954895,
0.3586006462574005,
0.32953256368637085,
0.5901669859886169,
0.16855847835540771,
-0.2872816026210785,
0.49229905009269714,
-0.0625978335738182,
0.45802202820777893,
0.14280880987644196,
0.5838622450828552,
0.19827894866466522,
0.09175357967615128,
0.39860716462135315,
0.2316504716873169,
-0.2947404682636261,
-0.985440731048584,
0.742168128490448,
-0.8347072005271912,
-0.3029334247112274,
1.0219347476959229,
-0.08614878356456757,
-0.11237164586782455,
-0.11437510699033737,
-0.0011349976994097233,
0.12856678664684296,
0.2343720942735672,
0.19926203787326813,
1.0534073114395142,
-0.19717034697532654,
-0.33284756541252136,
-0.8856956362724304,
0.08367884159088135,
0.4868657886981964,
-0.5843909978866577,
-0.04360364004969597,
0.5413561463356018,
0.4720604717731476,
0.17315766215324402,
0.7575972080230713,
-0.2687646150588989,
-0.08238080143928528,
-0.07530489563941956,
-0.25355982780456543,
0.2677249610424042,
-0.2851492166519165,
-0.6490302681922913,
0.11513641476631165,
0.4850781559944153,
-0.09366150200366974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03206v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03206v1
|
Vietnamese AI Generated Text Detection
| 2024-05-06T07:12:22 | 2024-05-06T07:12:22 |
Quang-Dan Tran, Van-Quan Nguyen, Quang-Huy Pham, K. B. Thang Nguyen, Trong-Hop Do
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have become integrated into our
daily lives, serving as invaluable assistants in completing tasks. Widely
embraced by users, the abuse of LLMs is inevitable, particularly in using them
to generate text content for various purposes, leading to difficulties in
distinguishing between text generated by LLMs and that written by humans. In
this study, we present a dataset named ViDetect, comprising 6.800 samples of
Vietnamese essay, with 3.400 samples authored by humans and the remainder
generated by LLMs, serving the purpose of detecting text generated by AI. We
conducted evaluations using state-of-the-art methods, including ViT5, BartPho,
PhoBERT, mDeberta V3, and mBERT. These results contribute not only to the
growing body of research on detecting text generated by AI but also demonstrate
the adaptability and effectiveness of different methods in the Vietnamese
language context. This research lays the foundation for future advancements in
AI-generated text detection and provides valuable insights for researchers in
the field of natural language processing.
|
[
-0.11485248804092407,
-1.0875859260559082,
0.9128216505050659,
0.06190493702888489,
-0.3674555718898773,
0.05238320678472519,
-0.08610326796770096,
-0.5963939428329468,
-0.09654470533132553,
0.7841756939888,
-0.2807142436504364,
-0.7716616988182068,
-0.6207535266876221,
0.7248468399047852,
-0.4307042956352234,
0.689584493637085,
-0.16542252898216248,
-0.3305792808532715,
-0.31841325759887695,
0.06520570069551468,
-0.35679662227630615,
-0.511025607585907,
-0.6138964295387268,
-0.13051947951316833,
0.3521387577056885,
0.32679736614227295,
0.05666758120059967,
0.5608279705047607,
0.7200523614883423,
0.40289047360420227,
0.03690275177359581,
0.550414502620697,
-0.3436611294746399,
0.3314882218837738,
0.04851393774151802,
-0.3418903052806854,
-0.36203423142433167,
-0.0764184519648552,
0.49678072333335876,
-0.410663902759552,
0.21042872965335846,
0.06177898868918419,
-0.027518069371581078,
0.4537872076034546,
-0.6048040390014648,
0.10693236440420151,
-0.8529386520385742,
-0.20287171006202698,
-0.39126619696617126,
-0.23793794214725494,
-0.5348070859909058,
-0.3433923125267029,
0.20474795997142792,
-0.3365737795829773,
0.04291410744190216,
-0.42271876335144043,
0.6324338316917419,
0.31400066614151,
-0.46256694197654724,
-0.39827191829681396,
-0.6168790459632874,
0.6215044260025024,
-0.6154822707176208,
-0.06048960983753204,
0.35389941930770874,
0.16720736026763916,
-0.08377141505479813,
-0.6605203151702881,
-0.9207913875579834,
-0.24565434455871582,
0.015599101781845093,
0.3103656470775604,
-0.32715606689453125,
-0.013743633404374123,
0.1830592304468155,
0.25766852498054504,
-0.7959933876991272,
0.2630396783351898,
-0.23037825524806976,
-0.390334814786911,
0.8293132781982422,
0.18685604631900787,
0.6400628685951233,
-0.5258104205131531,
-0.5306212902069092,
-0.0857279971241951,
-0.47448107600212097,
-0.15522059798240662,
0.2468881458044052,
-0.045019980520009995,
-0.0353417731821537,
0.6408175826072693,
-0.11577867716550827,
0.5515481233596802,
-0.536098301410675,
-0.42590853571891785,
0.19318552315235138,
-0.3344272971153259,
-0.3080442249774933,
-0.0741494819521904,
1.0863151550292969,
0.475452184677124,
0.829820454120636,
0.31119006872177124,
-0.5034574866294861,
0.3286585211753845,
0.2031177580356598,
-0.6664873957633972,
0.043648574501276016,
0.08650200068950653,
-0.5876679420471191,
-0.5560106635093689,
0.3705509901046753,
-0.4783654510974884,
-0.6078619360923767,
-0.24835318326950073,
0.2879638969898224,
-0.49598848819732666,
-0.37555399537086487,
0.036344848573207855,
-0.20035073161125183,
0.442714661359787,
0.29316556453704834,
-0.3912825882434845,
-0.06673698127269745,
0.7562853693962097,
0.8541592359542847,
-0.7305595874786377,
-0.30564653873443604,
-0.5577199459075928,
0.0467192679643631,
-0.08249159902334213,
1.1748600006103516,
-0.3683680295944214,
-0.5421950221061707,
0.25551360845565796,
-0.03528587520122528,
-0.05394723266363144,
-0.8085872530937195,
0.8026946783065796,
-0.2169542908668518,
0.20246657729148865,
0.07193414121866226,
-0.6763464212417603,
-0.07409773766994476,
0.2695275545120239,
-0.7725948691368103,
1.0716261863708496,
0.15884985029697418,
-0.88627028465271,
0.3956771790981293,
-0.41748255491256714,
-0.4543900489807129,
0.28617629408836365,
-0.30772510170936584,
-0.9306488037109375,
0.12713852524757385,
0.26530832052230835,
0.7041049599647522,
-0.2633522152900696,
0.14032888412475586,
-0.028131386265158653,
-0.41642245650291443,
0.45226895809173584,
-0.8072069883346558,
0.6860437393188477,
0.1502828150987625,
-0.34363701939582825,
0.15580610930919647,
-0.9701323509216309,
-0.30489492416381836,
0.2003675252199173,
-0.5972163081169128,
-0.6140124201774597,
-0.1793518364429474,
0.3339526057243347,
0.1581854373216629,
0.3008916676044464,
-0.6213758587837219,
0.001184473978355527,
-0.10334155708551407,
0.331189900636673,
0.9138270616531372,
0.2066347301006317,
0.014827212318778038,
-0.25286978483200073,
0.7865496873855591,
0.12839248776435852,
-0.2265736162662506,
-0.5532433390617371,
-0.5870746970176697,
-0.6468713283538818,
-0.624191164970398,
-0.09617692977190018,
0.8360413312911987,
-0.9916610717773438,
0.5292787551879883,
-0.1707390546798706,
-0.44412240386009216,
-0.6679525375366211,
0.11229801177978516,
0.42126286029815674,
0.3496271073818207,
0.2494857758283615,
-0.04175325483083725,
-0.6460918188095093,
-0.9314902424812317,
-0.3422054648399353,
-0.4548729658126831,
-0.2069406360387802,
0.24510157108306885,
0.7038280367851257,
-0.6987401843070984,
0.9510387778282166,
-0.5757196545600891,
-0.25668057799339294,
-0.35116317868232727,
0.2781544029712677,
-0.1612183004617691,
0.09339108318090439,
0.6801534295082092,
-0.688279390335083,
-0.7737157344818115,
0.10154208540916443,
-1.038822889328003,
-0.4661431610584259,
-0.22856292128562927,
0.04028216376900673,
0.4691324532032013,
0.6814168691635132,
-0.5456018447875977,
0.6314487457275391,
0.19318510591983795,
-0.23276792466640472,
0.5515216588973999,
-0.1656630039215088,
0.04501616582274437,
-1.286340355873108,
-0.018378451466560364,
0.23310045897960663,
-0.5214990973472595,
-0.39387649297714233,
-0.14878778159618378,
-0.04681586101651192,
0.214370459318161,
-0.2503640055656433,
0.6974066495895386,
-0.2384459227323532,
0.37545424699783325,
-0.6478805541992188,
0.09245617687702179,
0.00005053003042121418,
0.03877653554081917,
0.18382978439331055,
0.9615767002105713,
0.14747528731822968,
-0.4270581305027008,
0.30635976791381836,
0.04732201620936394,
-0.29778847098350525,
0.7386898994445801,
-0.65662682056427,
0.19863490760326385,
-0.15671944618225098,
0.1058444231748581,
-0.9941067695617676,
-0.1514590084552765,
0.21820951998233795,
-0.5062686800956726,
-0.12593799829483032,
0.0869203582406044,
-0.35512295365333557,
-0.19240215420722961,
-0.5115563869476318,
0.144685298204422,
0.41147953271865845,
-0.40077799558639526,
0.3674931526184082,
0.4299910068511963,
-0.28597477078437805,
-0.259833961725235,
-0.3729526102542877,
0.314256876707077,
-0.57386714220047,
-0.49399077892303467,
0.027611469849944115,
0.025674596428871155,
-0.6338173747062683,
-0.31650814414024353,
0.34326955676078796,
-0.140257328748703,
0.25014781951904297,
0.1858990341424942,
0.2392134666442871,
-0.44448122382164,
0.0755108967423439,
-0.02670941688120365,
-0.27052736282348633,
0.1609373390674591,
-0.4019373953342438,
0.3670768439769745,
0.07033821940422058,
-0.09668980538845062,
-0.8072652816772461,
0.3409947156906128,
0.74522864818573,
-0.35003748536109924,
0.5402628183364868,
0.9969971179962158,
-0.2690848112106323,
-0.19260863959789276,
-0.46938788890838623,
-0.03895091637969017,
-0.4588377773761749,
0.3706425428390503,
-0.2229118049144745,
-0.7928615808486938,
0.1017443910241127,
0.19331508874893188,
-0.03752933815121651,
0.5742504000663757,
0.806207001209259,
-0.060206491500139236,
0.7756703495979309,
0.6026070713996887,
-0.43587470054626465,
0.5487024188041687,
0.0016605500131845474,
-0.0430033802986145,
-0.4601556658744812,
0.18279747664928436,
-0.5314017534255981,
0.07029769569635391,
-1.1579643487930298,
-0.39605066180229187,
0.13012278079986572,
-0.6183466911315918,
-0.020574301481246948,
0.29278114438056946,
-0.6676695346832275,
0.38806089758872986,
0.7616629004478455,
0.010779115371406078,
0.5998851656913757,
0.15973132848739624,
0.07798870652914047,
-0.02485964074730873,
-0.06076871231198311,
-1.0310685634613037,
1.1968603134155273,
0.14424563944339752,
0.44605353474617004,
-0.1992846429347992,
0.8598027229309082,
0.7601034045219421,
0.23441393673419952,
-0.5778999924659729,
0.6086458563804626,
-0.24517497420310974,
-0.17641936242580414,
-0.21997903287410736,
-0.2912553548812866,
-1.0585838556289673,
0.16659146547317505,
-0.16195867955684662,
-0.6398016810417175,
-0.16833330690860748,
-0.22321437299251556,
-0.00005061678166384809,
0.12377723306417465,
-0.6756519675254822,
0.5429468154907227,
-0.1949373036623001,
-0.13247640430927277,
0.05360531061887741,
-0.34002968668937683,
0.32901328802108765,
-0.13024871051311493,
-0.08492918312549591,
-0.16538503766059875,
0.02578064240515232,
0.6650844812393188,
-0.15926021337509155,
0.6572504639625549,
0.080409474670887,
-0.5080373287200928,
0.8112337589263916,
-0.10725270956754684,
0.3958275318145752,
0.38533347845077515,
-0.051483411341905594,
0.09494444727897644,
-0.3955865204334259,
-0.18977850675582886,
-0.12308928370475769,
0.4745154082775116,
-0.7470455169677734,
-0.4769034683704376,
-0.5315690636634827,
-0.382114052772522,
0.48694583773612976,
0.4552978575229645,
0.5809829235076904,
0.0603332482278347,
-0.466545045375824,
0.002217473229393363,
0.6136857271194458,
-0.5020964741706848,
0.3817751109600067,
0.4671160876750946,
-0.12516100704669952,
-0.5242736339569092,
1.1906335353851318,
-0.2812821865081787,
-0.04524858668446541,
0.666629433631897,
0.13252447545528412,
-0.026361556723713875,
-0.5502907633781433,
-0.228162944316864,
0.24322247505187988,
-0.3929302990436554,
-0.18208283185958862,
-0.7479121088981628,
-0.5257250070571899,
-0.40038713812828064,
-0.08868510276079178,
-0.08372499793767929,
-0.19249242544174194,
-0.5169999599456787,
-0.2886798679828644,
0.4160294830799103,
0.9589696526527405,
0.1639620065689087,
0.5575711727142334,
-0.6645014882087708,
0.5361827611923218,
0.19033536314964294,
-0.2130499929189682,
-0.42316916584968567,
-0.23084405064582825,
-0.11751316487789154,
-0.11190972477197647,
-0.43849822878837585,
-0.5836049914360046,
0.4873931407928467,
0.03681853413581848,
0.2946961522102356,
0.751474916934967,
0.04857076704502106,
0.0009285198757424951,
-0.2820507287979126,
0.6714054942131042,
-0.3550526797771454,
-0.652985692024231,
0.6618438959121704,
-0.5523589849472046,
0.4087541699409485,
0.4425366520881653,
0.06535343825817108,
-0.43471696972846985,
-0.6126827001571655,
-0.47593921422958374,
-0.666086733341217,
0.34597745537757874,
0.6064212322235107,
0.08606322854757309,
-0.00866225641220808,
0.4508749544620514,
0.24736298620700836,
0.16567085683345795,
-0.8576818704605103,
0.08951122313737869,
0.07118416577577591,
-0.45499250292778015,
-0.09464285522699356,
-0.39516234397888184,
0.43057477474212646,
0.08127916604280472,
0.3305777311325073,
-0.1353074461221695,
0.38721558451652527,
0.21890127658843994,
-0.33990004658699036,
0.28150880336761475,
0.0341925285756588,
0.8236549496650696,
0.3883402347564697,
-0.021532762795686722,
0.1784456968307495,
-0.10426952689886093,
-0.8550357818603516,
0.1873384565114975,
-0.007518571801483631,
-0.4621315598487854,
0.23573249578475952,
0.9763465523719788,
0.6510359644889832,
-0.5983837842941284,
-0.8819960355758667,
0.4539029598236084,
-0.4305119514465332,
-0.01321400236338377,
-0.5385518074035645,
0.38306111097335815,
-0.19875214993953705,
0.16391704976558685,
0.1838451772928238,
-0.23057040572166443,
0.13119658827781677,
-0.26766735315322876,
0.26385852694511414,
0.42273974418640137,
-0.4219842255115509,
-0.45140931010246277,
0.5461556911468506,
0.3369540572166443,
-0.6099683046340942,
0.7912085056304932,
-0.004408326465636492,
-0.7379971742630005,
0.7671056389808655,
0.31772083044052124,
1.3284519910812378,
-0.281678706407547,
0.36885499954223633,
0.21666325628757477,
0.5426344871520996,
0.21485060453414917,
0.47737598419189453,
-0.04163097217679024,
-0.880035400390625,
-0.0911283940076828,
-0.5602090358734131,
-0.1572040170431137,
0.4649813771247864,
-0.39023271203041077,
0.3873443901538849,
-0.07079101353883743,
-0.16896983981132507,
-0.12467998266220093,
-0.13146992027759552,
-0.5635189414024353,
0.14639297127723694,
0.3547321856021881,
0.6438608169555664,
-0.911879301071167,
0.5907875895500183,
0.7854459285736084,
-0.31530439853668213,
-0.12260796874761581,
0.4056158661842346,
0.27514028549194336,
-0.7457621693611145,
0.2102144956588745,
0.5413615703582764,
-0.15770132839679718,
-0.0692385733127594,
-0.6335961222648621,
-0.2646310031414032,
1.0814744234085083,
0.23258157074451447,
-0.14302793145179749,
0.1591036468744278,
0.5066384077072144,
0.7975595593452454,
-0.28367000818252563,
0.27156028151512146,
0.9418116807937622,
0.5824753046035767,
-0.4543519616127014,
-0.5980502367019653,
-0.13725610077381134,
-0.3496457636356354,
0.025420403108000755,
-0.19473117589950562,
-0.5864989757537842,
0.8302145004272461,
0.04940454289317131,
-0.10382360965013504,
0.24783307313919067,
0.71030592918396,
0.552047610282898,
0.5652055740356445,
0.39854881167411804,
0.3113536536693573,
0.7545937299728394,
0.16720519959926605,
0.8860575556755066,
0.044749557971954346,
-0.03311724215745926,
0.7596071362495422,
-0.34953582286834717,
0.6201755404472351,
0.24670830368995667,
-0.02657741867005825,
0.4745692312717438,
0.5739206075668335,
-0.060617730021476746,
0.08117461204528809,
0.2035224735736847,
-0.4626302719116211,
-0.07740394026041031,
-0.26144328713417053,
-0.15656563639640808,
0.8951327800750732,
0.31827595829963684,
-0.45817941427230835,
0.16669517755508423,
0.12908662855625153,
0.1763395369052887,
0.3936973512172699,
0.012512768618762493,
1.138410210609436,
0.22036737203598022,
-0.808928906917572,
0.2700180411338806,
0.05987435206770897,
0.7521106600761414,
-0.2772967517375946,
-0.16761693358421326,
-0.26002636551856995,
0.4615742564201355,
0.01358037069439888,
-0.7575851678848267,
-0.05164036899805069,
0.3838203549385071,
-0.13436727225780487,
-0.1735098510980606,
1.053686499595642,
-0.27790629863739014,
-0.729481041431427,
0.3091399073600769,
0.656878650188446,
0.07195068150758743,
-0.30687248706817627,
-0.21744973957538605,
0.0764731615781784,
0.03368654474616051,
-0.2411651313304901,
0.02716882713139057,
0.8378704786300659,
-0.28503474593162537,
0.4997911751270294,
0.39177206158638,
-0.0075559308752417564,
-0.15028929710388184,
-0.25109925866127014,
0.6507197618484497,
-0.6306442022323608,
-0.49523690342903137,
-1.2676780223846436,
0.3552192449569702,
-0.2827092409133911,
-0.46018290519714355,
0.8062210083007812,
0.6878449320793152,
0.8354079723358154,
-0.18450628221035004,
1.4459059238433838,
0.3134402930736542,
0.4831700921058655,
-0.6602006554603577,
0.9393635392189026,
-0.3847852051258087,
0.27015453577041626,
-0.7409014701843262,
-0.8562559485435486,
-0.17503266036510468,
0.6309558153152466,
0.025397999212145805,
-0.049311425536870956,
0.509960412979126,
0.5187183618545532,
0.12014663219451904,
-0.14904198050498962,
0.2911528944969177,
0.17617452144622803,
0.6978216171264648,
0.32836854457855225,
1.0391179323196411,
-0.2936634123325348,
0.43068912625312805,
0.10085556656122208,
-0.09621131420135498,
-0.3598768413066864,
-0.650240421295166,
-1.1328381299972534,
-0.6834114789962769,
-0.22924233973026276,
-0.11241364479064941,
0.0310240276157856,
0.632165789604187,
0.09943511337041855,
-0.7441442012786865,
-0.32887130975723267,
-0.07167074829339981,
0.40867796540260315,
0.05555129423737526,
-0.2145165354013443,
0.46650567650794983,
0.013560027815401554,
-0.9193413853645325,
0.3071599304676056,
0.4077705144882202,
0.20073260366916656,
-0.3757629096508026,
0.04031640291213989,
-0.3021828234195709,
0.18367455899715424,
0.8990421891212463,
-0.047201529145240784,
-0.4690301716327667,
-0.3221296966075897,
0.12915804982185364,
-0.3958381116390228,
0.1266402006149292,
0.9316678643226624,
-0.8514044284820557,
0.4015629291534424,
0.8716650009155273,
0.6189426183700562,
0.14397868514060974,
0.16036435961723328,
0.7304492592811584,
-0.500307023525238,
0.1108173355460167,
0.14713835716247559,
0.2582072913646698,
0.4020199179649353,
-0.4194260835647583,
0.5944784283638,
0.3615330755710602,
-0.6804302334785461,
-0.7999078035354614,
0.11131144315004349,
-0.6549590826034546,
-0.17705240845680237,
1.1972815990447998,
-0.13076801598072052,
-0.21424736082553864,
-0.26386457681655884,
-0.5827124714851379,
0.25790056586265564,
-0.4348253905773163,
0.9149386882781982,
0.65412437915802,
0.0022569738794118166,
-0.022516971454024315,
-0.4502009451389313,
0.5713773369789124,
-0.018383814021945,
-1.1978260278701782,
-0.09238416701555252,
0.45394277572631836,
-0.05767153203487396,
-0.14593330025672913,
0.7394864559173584,
0.2994140684604645,
0.27837735414505005,
-0.2906167507171631,
-0.05239754915237427,
0.2282741367816925,
-0.3124489486217499,
-0.17672613263130188,
-0.15108448266983032,
0.027719588950276375,
-0.1407705843448639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03205v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03205v2
|
Anchored Answers: Unravelling Positional Bias in GPT-2's Multiple-Choice Questions
| 2024-05-06T07:10:09 | 2024-05-23T07:47:02 |
Ruizhe Li, Yanjun Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs), such as the GPT-4 and LLaMA families, have
demonstrated considerable success across diverse tasks, including
multiple-choice questions (MCQs). However, these models exhibit a positional
bias, particularly an even worse anchored bias in the GPT-2 family, where they
consistently favour the first choice 'A' in MCQs during inference. This
anchored bias challenges the integrity of GPT-2's decision-making process, as
it skews performance based on the position rather than the content of the
choices in MCQs. In this study, we utilise the mechanistic interpretability
approach to identify the internal modules within GPT-2 models responsible for
this bias. We focus on the Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) layers and attention
heads, using the "logit lens" method to trace and modify the specific value
vectors that contribute to the bias. By updating these vectors within MLP and
recalibrating attention patterns to neutralise the preference for the first
choice 'A', we effectively mitigate the anchored bias. Our interventions not
only mitigate the bias but also improve the overall MCQ prediction accuracy for
the GPT-2 family across various datasets. This work represents the first
comprehensive mechanistic analysis of anchored bias in MCQs within the GPT-2
models, introducing targeted, minimal-intervention strategies that
significantly enhance GPT2 model robustness and accuracy in MCQs. Our code is
available at https://github.com/ruizheliUOA/Anchored_Bias_GPT2.
|
[
-0.20877203345298767,
-0.8297032117843628,
0.748842179775238,
-0.0246500913053751,
-0.1918100267648697,
0.1293269693851471,
-0.004495213273912668,
-0.27703121304512024,
-0.17332977056503296,
0.3323870599269867,
-0.6334612965583801,
-0.13370242714881897,
-0.8108207583427429,
-0.19045674800872803,
0.21171900629997253,
0.9728238582611084,
-0.22543488442897797,
-0.03626730665564537,
-0.23570042848587036,
-0.3204834461212158,
-0.3199474513530731,
-0.5217022895812988,
-0.551746666431427,
-0.466153621673584,
0.5146815776824951,
0.49817943572998047,
0.9646201729774475,
0.415140837430954,
0.09858252853155136,
0.07687468826770782,
-0.3431272506713867,
0.058171596378088,
-0.45068368315696716,
-0.09852040559053421,
-0.3910380005836487,
-0.5137668251991272,
-0.4843709170818329,
0.05133726820349693,
0.5507850646972656,
0.3806386888027191,
0.009383458644151688,
0.3794918358325958,
0.3856104910373688,
0.49822136759757996,
-0.6039069890975952,
0.0901854932308197,
-0.6040159463882446,
-0.07594418525695801,
-0.056385383009910583,
-0.12352119386196136,
-0.4201935827732086,
-0.01772269234061241,
0.29578426480293274,
-0.3364257514476776,
0.1784326583147049,
-0.35913553833961487,
0.5375214219093323,
0.5445727705955505,
-0.7499756813049316,
-0.1855819672346115,
-0.3313506543636322,
0.8378938436508179,
-0.5996106266975403,
0.2003488540649414,
0.3142251670360565,
-0.1172838807106018,
-0.10372325032949448,
-0.21893757581710815,
-0.3075657784938812,
0.027598420158028603,
-0.22901415824890137,
0.39443689584732056,
0.1086295023560524,
0.06294969469308853,
0.2844640612602234,
-0.16478200256824493,
-0.8364127278327942,
0.11466507613658905,
-0.28555023670196533,
-0.08405327051877975,
0.31663036346435547,
-0.15648892521858215,
0.1723928153514862,
-0.00004964434265275486,
-0.3994485139846802,
-0.04305383935570717,
-0.86557537317276,
0.18903909623622894,
0.40449532866477966,
-0.029246585443615913,
0.10835562646389008,
0.81605464220047,
-0.19099733233451843,
0.3414365351200104,
0.4689817726612091,
-0.09041447192430496,
0.06858384609222412,
-0.13516919314861298,
-0.10153243690729141,
0.23181955516338348,
0.23519368469715118,
0.4187980890274048,
0.10261716693639755,
0.2588847279548645,
-0.022042596712708473,
0.03312555328011513,
0.19008255004882812,
-0.5283435583114624,
-0.07277527451515198,
0.573984682559967,
-0.3327940106391907,
-0.38875776529312134,
-0.16683557629585266,
-0.4916608929634094,
-0.25237780809402466,
-0.07041671872138977,
0.5672696828842163,
0.09980466216802597,
-0.5164273977279663,
-0.15289196372032166,
-0.025159642100334167,
0.4888058602809906,
0.1680307388305664,
-1.0374335050582886,
-0.03476555645465851,
0.8028144240379333,
0.726613461971283,
-0.10531220585107803,
-0.31846046447753906,
-0.12968046963214874,
0.5943415760993958,
-0.10947554558515549,
0.7753809690475464,
-0.6494273543357849,
-0.1010078638792038,
-0.0022939357440918684,
0.07464498281478882,
-0.23603886365890503,
-0.30844634771347046,
0.6044933199882507,
-0.6417341232299805,
0.33554014563560486,
-0.6852937340736389,
-0.21672454476356506,
-0.14021046459674835,
0.43596404790878296,
-0.5158904790878296,
1.084451675415039,
0.23003096878528595,
-0.9957433938980103,
0.38619083166122437,
-0.581584632396698,
-0.16918420791625977,
-0.48648956418037415,
-0.3581550121307373,
-0.4686574339866638,
0.12452942132949829,
0.5629636645317078,
0.2371954619884491,
-0.1414259821176529,
0.19846327602863312,
-0.3271084129810333,
-0.31779804825782776,
0.08760091662406921,
-0.4316454529762268,
0.7950302362442017,
-0.15283259749412537,
-0.58327716588974,
0.006589998956769705,
-0.33380720019340515,
0.02987072803080082,
0.06525532901287079,
-0.34122157096862793,
-0.15898369252681732,
0.095528244972229,
-0.29688096046447754,
0.5652576088905334,
0.15935921669006348,
-0.2721536159515381,
0.4420851767063141,
-0.09543634951114655,
0.6301003694534302,
1.000566840171814,
0.02059541456401348,
0.5357421040534973,
0.06298340857028961,
0.6010995507240295,
0.28440722823143005,
0.27668696641921997,
-0.018859947100281715,
-0.772742509841919,
-0.3383714556694031,
0.1339753270149231,
-0.03481031581759453,
0.6368064880371094,
-0.7056406140327454,
-0.1370575726032257,
-0.1910872608423233,
-0.09816117584705353,
-0.4402807950973511,
0.0359283909201622,
0.5436385273933411,
0.7073162794113159,
0.4565083682537079,
-0.17609991133213043,
-0.2168736755847931,
-1.1129369735717773,
-0.31514424085617065,
-0.27932026982307434,
-0.1434655487537384,
0.265451043844223,
0.4416143000125885,
-0.25577086210250854,
0.8819983005523682,
-0.4555380940437317,
0.05707798898220062,
0.0213303305208683,
0.007711948826909065,
0.31531304121017456,
0.5241517424583435,
0.23890571296215057,
-0.6646469235420227,
-0.3877529799938202,
-0.2196621149778366,
-0.6972808241844177,
0.013812744058668613,
0.04829796776175499,
-0.21947219967842102,
0.06520726531744003,
0.08972322195768356,
-1.0076587200164795,
0.28369683027267456,
0.5213191509246826,
-0.44684886932373047,
0.7117164731025696,
0.10110942274332047,
-0.15998640656471252,
-0.7026888728141785,
-0.15779829025268555,
-0.12700726091861725,
0.08560337126255035,
-0.5274425745010376,
0.015661897137761116,
0.1680683195590973,
0.2978910803794861,
-0.157579705119133,
0.556216299533844,
-0.47790980339050293,
-0.33419570326805115,
-0.14499832689762115,
0.0650232806801796,
0.11932005733251572,
0.6516057848930359,
0.1016579121351242,
0.9758062958717346,
0.2916945219039917,
-0.20479826629161835,
-0.15463104844093323,
0.6125866770744324,
-0.09353744983673096,
0.3972020447254181,
-0.822638750076294,
0.6094460487365723,
-0.1741192638874054,
0.46792882680892944,
-1.301352858543396,
-0.3380777835845947,
0.4151168465614319,
-0.562624454498291,
0.4833900034427643,
-0.5944705009460449,
-0.2099732905626297,
-0.20400744676589966,
-0.4475916922092438,
0.8406301140785217,
0.2049955278635025,
-0.4807088375091553,
0.4069441556930542,
0.41009002923965454,
-0.38277146220207214,
-1.2568633556365967,
-0.6682212352752686,
-0.12727954983711243,
-0.25411257147789,
-0.6558500528335571,
0.14729389548301697,
0.10858097672462463,
-0.20170989632606506,
-0.12398295849561691,
-0.649907112121582,
0.00720145832747221,
-0.14107324182987213,
-0.077044777572155,
0.18279488384723663,
-0.4025897979736328,
0.06620354950428009,
0.4711853861808777,
-0.37690192461013794,
0.1480533629655838,
-0.7516493201255798,
0.2466438114643097,
-0.08342087268829346,
-0.4057243764400482,
0.01573922485113144,
0.22933346033096313,
0.6154325604438782,
-0.2543388605117798,
0.5428869724273682,
0.5187338590621948,
-0.22540763020515442,
0.08287335932254791,
-0.6337293982505798,
-0.2648196816444397,
-0.42121222615242004,
0.5117297172546387,
-0.4407874047756195,
-1.0623934268951416,
0.4796774685382843,
0.22650423645973206,
-0.1657305806875229,
0.41976380348205566,
0.7884121537208557,
-0.07685332000255585,
1.325649380683899,
0.22340776026248932,
-0.20014514029026031,
0.20642121136188507,
-0.03934482857584953,
0.1126246303319931,
-1.3484727144241333,
-0.08348299562931061,
0.032504189759492874,
-0.3715979754924774,
-0.43032780289649963,
-0.5861299633979797,
0.6159566044807434,
0.06069612875580788,
-0.3868428170681,
0.06588089466094971,
-0.6909676790237427,
0.468140572309494,
0.6433372497558594,
0.4114643633365631,
0.0752713680267334,
-0.08143578469753265,
-0.2931244373321533,
0.18174514174461365,
-0.7204108238220215,
-0.6894030570983887,
1.35477614402771,
0.608035147190094,
0.3835761249065399,
0.18659608066082,
0.141622856259346,
0.07772230356931686,
0.3513703942298889,
-0.5389031767845154,
0.1984933614730835,
0.1373966783285141,
-0.9212256073951721,
-0.421606183052063,
0.036385804414749146,
-0.5984684824943542,
0.5087781548500061,
0.17772923409938812,
-0.8808054327964783,
0.2935401499271393,
0.4360765814781189,
-0.4521036744117737,
0.1843414455652237,
-0.5989823341369629,
0.8766539096832275,
-0.42431381344795227,
-1.0493937730789185,
-0.1924571841955185,
-0.9170415997505188,
0.4285871982574463,
0.1615118533372879,
0.04968737065792084,
-0.12202827632427216,
-0.1276717483997345,
0.5149390697479248,
-0.025740424171090126,
0.6940600872039795,
-0.4287784993648529,
-0.3764437437057495,
0.38065725564956665,
-0.0512952022254467,
0.7376841306686401,
0.3868403136730194,
-0.18727675080299377,
0.1566898375749588,
0.0734124630689621,
-0.6327691078186035,
-0.6082071661949158,
0.5845220685005188,
-0.7823653221130371,
-0.7508134245872498,
-0.3607498109340668,
-0.4575121998786926,
-0.47735655307769775,
0.03701502084732056,
0.2691645920276642,
0.4438958168029785,
0.2980372905731201,
-0.12912128865718842,
0.8725234866142273,
-0.16681477427482605,
0.21332380175590515,
0.271341472864151,
0.06750642508268356,
-0.3233506679534912,
0.4207308888435364,
0.2572805881500244,
0.33076468110084534,
0.41446465253829956,
0.2087344527244568,
-0.4961763620376587,
-0.7122491002082825,
-0.5596795082092285,
0.16017159819602966,
-0.7175621390342712,
0.11577831953763962,
-0.3253214359283447,
0.14964036643505096,
-0.14701838791370392,
-0.015007629059255123,
-0.3108776807785034,
-0.5268595218658447,
-0.13496777415275574,
-0.6410986185073853,
-0.14962799847126007,
0.714330792427063,
0.10549228638410568,
0.3932296931743622,
-0.4721733331680298,
0.23464320600032806,
0.4004407525062561,
0.43070587515830994,
-0.03708019107580185,
-0.49392762780189514,
-0.1021648421883583,
0.07129565626382828,
-0.27679482102394104,
-0.9631391763687134,
-0.07859846204519272,
-0.2344486564397812,
0.531387448310852,
0.5322788953781128,
-0.3174475431442261,
0.6040449738502502,
-0.46568429470062256,
0.6969018578529358,
-0.15687742829322815,
-0.7301833629608154,
0.5440592765808105,
-0.6871293783187866,
0.2812662422657013,
0.5927191972732544,
0.24739812314510345,
-0.03726935014128685,
-0.06622831523418427,
-0.6062046885490417,
-0.8693460822105408,
0.670361340045929,
0.2728952467441559,
-0.05603630095720291,
0.0683915987610817,
0.7371077537536621,
0.020351696759462357,
0.342382550239563,
-0.7315321564674377,
-0.1578739881515503,
-0.10764306038618088,
-0.08934000134468079,
-0.017560746520757675,
-0.9365519881248474,
-0.17502142488956451,
-0.2505514919757843,
0.6508349776268005,
-0.3442428708076477,
0.41452059149742126,
0.45256102085113525,
-0.33916139602661133,
-0.12670151889324188,
0.2407839447259903,
0.7573973536491394,
0.9254549145698547,
-0.36888962984085083,
0.3089015781879425,
0.23575536906719208,
-0.4956875741481781,
0.22142647206783295,
-0.17193706333637238,
-0.4472382664680481,
-0.3062155246734619,
0.24664565920829773,
0.6001562476158142,
0.3579774498939514,
-0.30408281087875366,
0.32733336091041565,
0.32723966240882874,
0.001274975948035717,
-0.3579727113246918,
-0.21443413197994232,
-0.04592014476656914,
0.47514668107032776,
0.3820435106754303,
-0.03128961846232414,
0.05222981050610542,
-0.5998632907867432,
0.43119069933891296,
0.5991476774215698,
-0.6019232869148254,
-0.49686330556869507,
0.9288328289985657,
-0.08059711009263992,
0.11815574765205383,
0.5785657167434692,
0.05624736100435257,
-0.8215357661247253,
0.44134044647216797,
0.4837038218975067,
0.8148418664932251,
-0.46495500206947327,
0.2172854095697403,
0.48512524366378784,
0.5392454266548157,
-0.1351735144853592,
0.21475283801555634,
0.1191478744149208,
-0.9747568368911743,
-0.4423421025276184,
-0.30394458770751953,
-0.35944822430610657,
0.09976931661367416,
-0.7788164615631104,
-0.06150936707854271,
-0.41707801818847656,
-0.24007999897003174,
-0.3698963522911072,
-0.11824093014001846,
-0.33040669560432434,
0.2092054784297943,
0.240800678730011,
0.5895635485649109,
-0.8360254764556885,
0.7082733511924744,
0.8788291811943054,
-0.3379688858985901,
-0.5592443346977234,
0.25436192750930786,
0.332036554813385,
-1.0372931957244873,
0.15933053195476532,
0.2778381407260895,
-0.1404295563697815,
0.061928413808345795,
-0.7485476136207581,
-1.0986422300338745,
1.3139244318008423,
0.3382731080055237,
-0.2638893723487854,
-0.18643897771835327,
0.21281328797340393,
0.15433785319328308,
-0.1629296839237213,
0.7418464422225952,
0.9147695899009705,
0.5342674255371094,
-0.041549768298864365,
-0.853339672088623,
0.24885113537311554,
-0.10105429589748383,
-0.29926902055740356,
0.07060270756483078,
-0.8997063636779785,
0.8616893291473389,
-0.36244142055511475,
0.28591474890708923,
-0.2024339884519577,
0.20083396136760712,
0.5567950010299683,
0.38010820746421814,
0.26608970761299133,
0.4801742434501648,
0.794259786605835,
-0.06619119644165039,
0.9918062686920166,
-0.13782495260238647,
0.4971684217453003,
1.2446746826171875,
-0.16677166521549225,
0.8469685912132263,
0.7535086870193481,
-0.38984817266464233,
0.42824286222457886,
0.773392915725708,
-0.007140554022043943,
0.5666857957839966,
0.05015883222222328,
-0.23291407525539398,
-0.12459632754325867,
0.17351828515529633,
-0.16240033507347107,
0.38217082619667053,
0.47599393129348755,
-0.22167284786701202,
0.024141231551766396,
-0.3661685287952423,
0.14662134647369385,
-0.46691396832466125,
-0.36839020252227783,
0.5871279239654541,
0.040871381759643555,
-0.854081392288208,
0.2529630959033966,
-0.10382065176963806,
0.33539244532585144,
-0.49087417125701904,
0.033338189125061035,
-0.16345037519931793,
0.27104976773262024,
-0.375331312417984,
-0.8815523386001587,
0.036606330424547195,
-0.22621580958366394,
-0.42849910259246826,
-0.0969262346625328,
0.8094714283943176,
-0.395038366317749,
-0.34369537234306335,
0.293152779340744,
0.548038899898529,
-0.1496104598045349,
-0.5096246600151062,
-0.7610393762588501,
-0.07474010437726974,
0.15602970123291016,
-0.6096267104148865,
0.43160614371299744,
0.023226754739880562,
-0.37460240721702576,
0.5933305621147156,
0.5351857542991638,
-0.4012606739997864,
0.13565830886363983,
-0.10074920952320099,
0.7618075609207153,
-0.4106094539165497,
-0.29879260063171387,
-0.9180084466934204,
0.9150339365005493,
0.1302386224269867,
-0.21296969056129456,
0.6279745101928711,
0.4651341736316681,
0.5865506529808044,
-0.13479959964752197,
0.9692236185073853,
0.19880016148090363,
0.3235899806022644,
-0.6012805700302124,
0.4882882833480835,
-0.21600233018398285,
0.3739060163497925,
-0.35115471482276917,
-1.0011043548583984,
-0.12925031781196594,
0.6571871042251587,
-0.5074912309646606,
0.07632077485322952,
0.666248619556427,
0.6748111844062805,
-0.15045315027236938,
-0.20400668680667877,
-0.0037670109886676073,
0.4377346932888031,
0.15550918877124786,
0.780167281627655,
0.9785531163215637,
-0.39896053075790405,
0.4452740252017975,
-0.14287440478801727,
-0.39037027955055237,
-0.12209375202655792,
-0.8040888905525208,
-0.6634301543235779,
-0.2170717418193817,
-0.2541978359222412,
-0.33269691467285156,
0.16709750890731812,
0.7194554805755615,
0.39845412969589233,
-1.0258320569992065,
0.00303074368275702,
0.07314920425415039,
0.33847326040267944,
-0.259888619184494,
-0.1724603921175003,
0.7140260934829712,
0.00704866461455822,
-0.5027104616165161,
0.30936673283576965,
0.2994047701358795,
-0.22066211700439453,
0.0567484050989151,
0.0112984087318182,
-0.3217858076095581,
-0.11410755664110184,
0.8031104803085327,
0.1328296661376953,
-0.9108357429504395,
-0.5722209215164185,
-0.010641413740813732,
0.409760981798172,
0.31158143281936646,
0.6882207989692688,
-0.567986786365509,
0.2935605049133301,
0.14295999705791473,
0.5141791701316833,
0.44590291380882263,
0.5256403088569641,
0.6090700626373291,
-0.7696848511695862,
0.060351740568876266,
0.09383070468902588,
0.3383390009403229,
0.1516343057155609,
-0.4734404683113098,
0.7200440168380737,
0.0877051129937172,
-0.6643344163894653,
-0.7693842649459839,
0.33177563548088074,
-0.9585036039352417,
-0.02632928639650345,
1.423007607460022,
-0.007785344962030649,
0.23934955894947052,
-0.201025128364563,
-0.30170556902885437,
0.2910824716091156,
-0.15362507104873657,
0.6512195467948914,
0.9153968095779419,
-0.3402869403362274,
-0.4557185769081116,
-0.8882487416267395,
0.5019919872283936,
0.6626161336898804,
-0.21189558506011963,
0.04755828529596329,
0.44330736994743347,
0.4595501720905304,
0.009082128293812275,
0.5369852781295776,
-0.24152205884456635,
0.11748305708169937,
-0.12831299006938934,
-0.47631239891052246,
0.038087110966444016,
-0.2589814066886902,
-0.5629616379737854,
0.2999044358730316,
0.10140922665596008,
-0.07139814645051956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03170v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03170v1
|
Oracle-Checker Scheme for Evaluating a Generative Large Language Model
| 2024-05-06T05:36:29 | 2024-05-06T05:36:29 |
Yueling Jenny Zeng, Li-C. Wang, Thomas Ibbetson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This work presents a novel approach called oracle-checker scheme for
evaluating the answer given by a generative large language model (LLM). Two
types of checkers are presented. The first type of checker follows the idea of
property testing. The second type of checker follows the idea of program
checking. Their applications are demonstrated in two separate contexts, entity
extraction and paraphrase decision, respectively.
|
[
-0.24207739531993866,
-1.032106876373291,
0.6081626415252686,
0.3893445134162903,
-0.3733535408973694,
-0.05396858602762222,
-0.06084351986646652,
-0.2799193263053894,
0.13452140986919403,
1.0072021484375,
-0.4339072108268738,
-0.3820468485355377,
-0.6145102977752686,
0.2515404522418976,
-0.6306061148643494,
0.7017837166786194,
-0.3469502627849579,
-0.10531149059534073,
-0.23611611127853394,
0.04161616787314415,
-0.15197785198688507,
-0.31480568647384644,
-0.9908531308174133,
-0.6201179027557373,
0.08309989422559738,
-0.050122685730457306,
0.646300733089447,
0.31567850708961487,
0.8379538655281067,
0.4276672303676605,
-0.398846298456192,
-0.08988405019044876,
-0.18003232777118683,
0.08047444373369217,
-0.04720785841345787,
-0.8400678634643555,
-0.4316328763961792,
-0.3225051462650299,
0.4787788689136505,
0.35287973284721375,
-0.3286171853542328,
0.2441101223230362,
-0.331510066986084,
0.4622974693775177,
-0.7066118717193604,
0.3700496554374695,
-0.617300808429718,
0.007845782674849033,
-0.17293472588062286,
-0.20755045115947723,
-0.5580029487609863,
-0.7207581400871277,
-0.04199490323662758,
-0.2487853765487671,
0.08573693037033081,
0.036148250102996826,
0.8438932299613953,
0.2491772174835205,
-0.47616562247276306,
-0.3371456563472748,
-0.8164296746253967,
0.7407018542289734,
-0.7143219113349915,
0.19378097355365753,
0.3539840281009674,
0.6850072145462036,
0.11147680878639221,
-0.4929097890853882,
-1.1181859970092773,
-0.5780016183853149,
-0.09277600795030594,
0.022761067375540733,
-0.05950072407722473,
0.4082058072090149,
0.3200241029262543,
1.063185453414917,
-0.6549779176712036,
0.261785089969635,
-0.2229616940021515,
-0.22858156263828278,
0.5404019355773926,
0.20439302921295166,
0.5635326504707336,
-0.28864094614982605,
-0.5029910206794739,
-0.06988588720560074,
-0.8950793743133545,
-0.3041810095310211,
0.24198734760284424,
-0.08779043704271317,
0.032594241201877594,
1.1686081886291504,
-0.22313645482063293,
1.0765961408615112,
-0.02826552651822567,
-0.3648465871810913,
-0.05925041437149048,
-0.6074649095535278,
-0.6424830555915833,
-0.05407201498746872,
0.41024789214134216,
0.21824869513511658,
0.16174359619617462,
-0.18235276639461517,
-0.7264018654823303,
0.3482617437839508,
-0.24229805171489716,
-0.5952866673469543,
-0.053740259259939194,
0.3258795738220215,
-0.5689236521720886,
-0.33219408988952637,
-0.06996177136898041,
-0.8188314437866211,
-0.39361390471458435,
-0.30095839500427246,
0.3528807461261749,
-0.3659958243370056,
-0.19445592164993286,
0.1072050929069519,
-0.020931817591190338,
1.026932716369629,
0.1970771998167038,
-0.7918294072151184,
0.33870911598205566,
1.0903968811035156,
0.510057270526886,
-0.1559447944164276,
-0.1806238889694214,
-0.5056571364402771,
0.2116280347108841,
-0.3598024547100067,
0.8838855028152466,
-0.6966567039489746,
-0.11067590117454529,
0.35570186376571655,
-0.24997544288635254,
-0.05516716465353966,
-0.8528446555137634,
0.5737854838371277,
-0.8643317818641663,
0.18680059909820557,
-0.01948169805109501,
-0.7868121266365051,
-0.15625767409801483,
0.3509514331817627,
-0.7632809281349182,
1.2590324878692627,
0.40906551480293274,
-0.47005560994148254,
0.7148357033729553,
-0.6890599131584167,
-0.22139281034469604,
0.4571307897567749,
-0.19461409747600555,
-0.5392598509788513,
-0.006746274884790182,
0.013714286498725414,
0.13976258039474487,
-0.6881313920021057,
0.3525716960430145,
-0.2892080545425415,
-0.37879908084869385,
0.21054363250732422,
-0.18453587591648102,
1.0577739477157593,
0.39019137620925903,
-0.4168262481689453,
0.3060789406299591,
-1.102918267250061,
0.0900423601269722,
0.07187466323375702,
-0.6775451898574829,
-0.4788210988044739,
-0.003413423663005233,
0.08969306945800781,
0.15539371967315674,
0.4967389702796936,
-0.4852204918861389,
0.388440877199173,
-0.5287732481956482,
0.16930705308914185,
0.5654162764549255,
0.08046961575746536,
0.25779834389686584,
-0.21891912817955017,
0.7331975698471069,
-0.04102006182074547,
0.07065332680940628,
-0.05905144661664963,
-0.2132653445005417,
-1.4668807983398438,
-0.3334991931915283,
0.19188138842582703,
0.7752406597137451,
-1.0151244401931763,
0.8574808239936829,
0.09413691610097885,
-0.44716647267341614,
-0.36280569434165955,
0.285507470369339,
0.8788841366767883,
-0.263427197933197,
0.23882712423801422,
0.12828075885772705,
-0.6128212213516235,
-0.901166558265686,
-0.12468049675226212,
-0.4803159534931183,
-0.06215175241231918,
0.10271338373422623,
0.7308118939399719,
-0.2132059931755066,
0.5347731709480286,
-0.5647086501121521,
0.18819256126880646,
-0.7068725228309631,
0.16500034928321838,
0.2548447549343109,
0.16221670806407928,
0.45270800590515137,
-0.5964226722717285,
-0.47395315766334534,
0.19407112896442413,
-0.7412909865379333,
-0.13504816591739655,
-0.2967265546321869,
0.050527606159448624,
0.17156817018985748,
0.5669634938240051,
-0.8919113278388977,
0.3416430950164795,
0.42463481426239014,
-0.4185370206832886,
0.5816152691841125,
-0.3087056577205658,
-0.039127569645643234,
-0.9689483642578125,
-0.179190531373024,
-0.17405590415000916,
-0.20065169036388397,
-0.4780762791633606,
0.7025942802429199,
-0.026597704738378525,
0.051656514406204224,
-0.242917999625206,
0.4587225317955017,
-0.5761021375656128,
-0.31318315863609314,
-0.34601762890815735,
-0.08556188642978668,
-0.35384687781333923,
0.05711105093359947,
-0.032839737832546234,
0.9048771262168884,
0.730665385723114,
-0.814276397228241,
0.7223708629608154,
0.25070828199386597,
-0.5559008717536926,
0.7504280805587769,
-0.8213835954666138,
0.36332064867019653,
-0.29829105734825134,
0.03629511222243309,
-0.8502718210220337,
-0.18768435716629028,
0.08302991092205048,
0.077134869992733,
0.21364791691303253,
0.15841971337795258,
-0.5465273261070251,
-0.7673732042312622,
-0.3195164203643799,
0.037621621042490005,
0.22481830418109894,
-0.7203893065452576,
0.8558974266052246,
0.1670394092798233,
-0.19147154688835144,
-0.5246888995170593,
-0.5164605379104614,
0.2447482943534851,
-0.46851086616516113,
-0.7424407005310059,
0.13286621868610382,
-0.10811925679445267,
-0.7328081130981445,
-0.29115045070648193,
-0.024996202439069748,
-0.4204007089138031,
-0.09469501674175262,
0.003911449108272791,
0.41544604301452637,
-0.49786919355392456,
-0.3064248561859131,
0.052071794867515564,
-0.10188926756381989,
0.22506657242774963,
-0.21700409054756165,
0.6785814762115479,
-0.15447017550468445,
-0.5554128885269165,
-0.3127194941043854,
0.21057209372520447,
0.6320671439170837,
-0.3583349585533142,
0.7369557023048401,
0.24700921773910522,
-0.3767818808555603,
-0.2574942111968994,
-0.8813090324401855,
-0.13108760118484497,
-0.4840482473373413,
0.4239356517791748,
-0.6188966035842896,
-0.8207957744598389,
0.6575232744216919,
-0.04561479762196541,
-0.2958865165710449,
0.44812023639678955,
0.8926111459732056,
0.2977539896965027,
0.31824517250061035,
0.8685487508773804,
0.03651145100593567,
0.2132655531167984,
-0.1407076120376587,
0.4304574429988861,
-0.5096966624259949,
-0.37227100133895874,
-0.7015811204910278,
0.18782249093055725,
-0.4017089605331421,
-0.41724666953086853,
0.06854088604450226,
0.27199169993400574,
-0.26706159114837646,
0.5438380837440491,
-0.12409484386444092,
0.7528614401817322,
0.3655930757522583,
0.0003025264013558626,
0.6017637252807617,
-0.2374359667301178,
-0.1460338681936264,
0.1588275134563446,
-0.07209425419569016,
-0.6019046306610107,
0.8520190715789795,
0.2546115517616272,
0.773734450340271,
0.44535520672798157,
0.7993746399879456,
0.21064859628677368,
0.47098031640052795,
-0.8907177448272705,
0.8914313912391663,
-0.16150930523872375,
-0.7570857405662537,
-0.4906916320323944,
-0.20496432483196259,
-0.8073614239692688,
0.2311142534017563,
0.016737988218665123,
-0.7500145435333252,
0.3577635586261749,
0.006932269781827927,
-0.1434832513332367,
0.2591359317302704,
-0.3670938313007355,
0.6445780396461487,
-0.2552851736545563,
0.20287558436393738,
-0.03904798626899719,
-0.27560731768608093,
0.7746355533599854,
-0.3209472596645355,
-0.32507309317588806,
0.22966066002845764,
-0.010791230946779251,
0.4859555661678314,
-0.5299162864685059,
0.5845732688903809,
-0.027230074629187584,
-0.4169090688228607,
0.5969829559326172,
0.3461255729198456,
0.9554097056388855,
-0.06285185366868973,
-0.24481792747974396,
-0.33204585313796997,
-0.12812069058418274,
-0.1471244841814041,
-0.5282657742500305,
0.28406304121017456,
-0.6500608325004578,
-0.6524533629417419,
-0.31122156977653503,
-0.3345707058906555,
0.11879726499319077,
0.3379916846752167,
0.24725939333438873,
-0.05762278288602829,
-0.1976451724767685,
0.2241095006465912,
0.6465743184089661,
-0.3184491991996765,
0.29173868894577026,
0.8378832936286926,
-0.49119246006011963,
-0.054192911833524704,
0.7286309003829956,
-0.4917100667953491,
0.5024055242538452,
0.9082688093185425,
0.09057951718568802,
-0.38107529282569885,
-0.8236602544784546,
-0.12384677678346634,
0.3873897194862366,
-0.9275839924812317,
-0.017838023602962494,
-0.1910889893770218,
-0.410633385181427,
-0.10882912576198578,
0.10681696236133575,
-0.43601280450820923,
-0.16552065312862396,
0.18791690468788147,
-0.20769162476062775,
0.20437872409820557,
0.7726426124572754,
0.3916821777820587,
0.23800203204154968,
-0.3817276060581207,
0.24478182196617126,
0.7538970708847046,
0.22950179874897003,
-0.356997549533844,
-0.39806225895881653,
0.36596426367759705,
-0.5128442645072937,
-0.14439329504966736,
-1.0194255113601685,
0.3086835741996765,
0.20245404541492462,
0.7236198782920837,
0.4949914515018463,
-0.40879368782043457,
0.3559384346008301,
-0.233355313539505,
0.8046219348907471,
0.1844983845949173,
-0.8457143306732178,
0.7300459146499634,
-0.2770313322544098,
-0.15220578014850616,
0.5651496052742004,
0.15388420224189758,
-0.2318267673254013,
-0.27550849318504333,
-0.2700839936733246,
-0.6843724250793457,
0.36434948444366455,
0.26368948817253113,
0.08615294098854065,
-0.052527472376823425,
0.49120163917541504,
0.07206156104803085,
-0.002279676264151931,
-1.041965126991272,
-0.6128798723220825,
0.05940134823322296,
0.28824326395988464,
0.08820084482431412,
-0.6720425486564636,
-0.19697913527488708,
0.14723913371562958,
0.32199782133102417,
-0.08606947958469391,
0.1502152681350708,
-0.18754298985004425,
-0.186639666557312,
-0.15818126499652863,
0.752067506313324,
0.4126766324043274,
0.7599363327026367,
-0.4075801372528076,
0.22660747170448303,
0.2656417489051819,
-0.291513592004776,
0.3696662485599518,
0.038855619728565216,
-0.5831241011619568,
-0.1684514433145523,
0.26276540756225586,
0.9354568719863892,
-0.08827492594718933,
-0.4650813937187195,
0.5166168808937073,
0.18964476883411407,
-0.260735422372818,
-0.4122682809829712,
0.07337339222431183,
0.017269616946578026,
0.18677017092704773,
-0.05417383834719658,
-0.2163158357143402,
0.39283472299575806,
-0.5353911519050598,
0.10146252810955048,
0.3276595175266266,
-0.12988246977329254,
-0.1731080412864685,
0.4561834931373596,
0.0038598240353167057,
-0.4588279724121094,
0.6661785840988159,
-0.5281047224998474,
-0.39994940161705017,
0.8013041615486145,
0.998549222946167,
1.0156482458114624,
-0.5112475156784058,
0.39496684074401855,
0.21363525092601776,
0.4608207941055298,
-0.10047034919261932,
0.6663698554039001,
0.036863695830106735,
-0.6908730268478394,
-0.868854820728302,
-0.7876253128051758,
-0.5039868354797363,
0.5701408386230469,
-0.7062471508979797,
0.36846286058425903,
-0.17549674212932587,
0.18106675148010254,
0.24565008282661438,
-0.42654046416282654,
-0.6467500925064087,
0.15550054609775543,
0.22942808270454407,
0.8782678842544556,
-0.7678617238998413,
1.0359289646148682,
0.8786010146141052,
-0.5044487714767456,
-0.6172090172767639,
0.17098940908908844,
-0.1414734274148941,
-0.9617491960525513,
1.1560230255126953,
-0.2289981096982956,
-0.08078090101480484,
-0.4517139494419098,
-0.25068965554237366,
-1.0461622476577759,
0.9585661888122559,
0.5126624703407288,
-0.6933558583259583,
0.05157725140452385,
0.18951034545898438,
0.6605163216590881,
-0.026851406320929527,
0.28981056809425354,
0.8513094782829285,
0.6800095438957214,
0.17111846804618835,
-1.0412098169326782,
0.08995956927537918,
-0.1926887333393097,
0.3377418518066406,
0.3543989658355713,
-0.4806503653526306,
0.9568588137626648,
-0.15307484567165375,
-0.15205107629299164,
0.39874404668807983,
0.7354397773742676,
0.5986033082008362,
0.043365806341171265,
0.5644505023956299,
0.8158218860626221,
0.666460394859314,
-0.0708685964345932,
1.4863803386688232,
-0.33284515142440796,
0.6236733198165894,
0.8628600835800171,
-0.3946244418621063,
0.8845371603965759,
0.3385384678840637,
-0.8316148519515991,
0.43533143401145935,
0.2913672924041748,
-0.18505452573299408,
0.3127007782459259,
0.5765668153762817,
-0.5488116145133972,
-0.3408995568752289,
0.2336757481098175,
-0.3979673981666565,
0.7683193683624268,
0.4167585074901581,
-0.25981035828590393,
-0.18828968703746796,
-0.43976160883903503,
-0.0982217788696289,
-0.028074143454432487,
-0.25036340951919556,
0.7417939901351929,
-0.00773546751588583,
-1.011905550956726,
0.5270237326622009,
0.21680375933647156,
0.5619677305221558,
-0.42743542790412903,
-0.07806217670440674,
-0.2064628154039383,
0.3908542990684509,
-0.11567471921443939,
-0.790791392326355,
0.504572868347168,
-0.10743901133537292,
-0.12883080542087555,
0.14179670810699463,
0.9017461538314819,
-0.44251203536987305,
-0.5768715143203735,
0.47465234994888306,
0.4406498074531555,
0.1573973447084427,
-0.01302837673574686,
-0.8060416579246521,
-0.038807522505521774,
-0.1058746874332428,
-0.28767818212509155,
0.007304072380065918,
0.3599524199962616,
-0.06374666094779968,
0.8352586627006531,
0.45688188076019287,
0.2030639499425888,
0.12958502769470215,
0.42511388659477234,
0.8079767227172852,
-0.6172907948493958,
-0.36755698919296265,
-0.9940686225891113,
0.03148771449923515,
-0.07720261812210083,
-0.31030741333961487,
0.90914386510849,
0.622285783290863,
0.5392613410949707,
-0.2699509561061859,
0.6975568532943726,
-0.08898277580738068,
0.24734880030155182,
-0.6616648435592651,
0.20355860888957977,
-0.1928081065416336,
0.5081015825271606,
-0.3330472409725189,
-1.330005407333374,
-0.452605664730072,
0.6636229753494263,
-0.44692283868789673,
0.25392770767211914,
0.9661067128181458,
0.8332566022872925,
0.22893068194389343,
0.0037630153819918633,
0.3216214179992676,
0.3020668029785156,
0.27844032645225525,
0.6654692888259888,
1.1109440326690674,
-0.27747583389282227,
0.5169676542282104,
-0.18998795747756958,
-0.3156034052371979,
0.015159472823143005,
-0.9284861087799072,
-1.1552152633666992,
-0.2786542475223541,
-0.3746158182621002,
-0.6009442806243896,
0.06354973465204239,
0.4398961365222931,
0.35390642285346985,
-1.088463544845581,
-0.17579054832458496,
-0.35011327266693115,
0.222128763794899,
-0.12783576548099518,
-0.19662931561470032,
0.6065486669540405,
-0.21752984821796417,
-0.5208138823509216,
0.2356635332107544,
0.5504626035690308,
-0.19151335954666138,
-0.5283095240592957,
-0.20347285270690918,
0.050656940788030624,
0.16177944839000702,
0.671190083026886,
0.1591213047504425,
-1.0966039896011353,
0.008838828653097153,
-0.05084438621997833,
-0.16661924123764038,
0.012141994200646877,
0.937657356262207,
-0.26483359932899475,
0.49383682012557983,
0.6622776389122009,
0.6381132006645203,
0.671596348285675,
-0.3042352497577667,
0.35640043020248413,
-0.3014798164367676,
0.05613448843359947,
0.07083126157522202,
0.6635639667510986,
0.10786402970552444,
-0.4406481087207794,
0.33952611684799194,
0.030638914555311203,
-0.523540198802948,
-0.5620222091674805,
0.5008759498596191,
-1.23476243019104,
-0.06781967729330063,
1.2769180536270142,
-0.18956895172595978,
-0.15759828686714172,
-0.2396068125963211,
-0.18926867842674255,
0.0021645736414939165,
-0.04934016615152359,
0.9137665629386902,
0.6570390462875366,
-0.028587358072400093,
-0.29021093249320984,
-0.21151815354824066,
0.4079444706439972,
0.2801772952079773,
-1.217974305152893,
-0.12620462477207184,
0.13966432213783264,
0.3269149363040924,
0.4047139286994934,
0.6582598090171814,
-0.45623230934143066,
0.3398679494857788,
0.08091205358505249,
0.1894606351852417,
0.2789703905582428,
-0.0343063548207283,
-0.31842130422592163,
0.18199782073497772,
0.3131241798400879,
0.09720208495855331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03162v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03162v1
|
Advancing Multimodal Medical Capabilities of Gemini
| 2024-05-06T04:44:22 | 2024-05-06T04:44:22 |
Lin Yang, Shawn Xu, Andrew Sellergren, Timo Kohlberger, Yuchen Zhou, Ira Ktena, Atilla Kiraly, Faruk Ahmed, Farhad Hormozdiari, Tiam Jaroensri, Eric Wang, Ellery Wulczyn, Fayaz Jamil, Theo Guidroz, Chuck Lau, Siyuan Qiao, Yun Liu, Akshay Goel, Kendall Park, Arnav Agharwal, Nick George, Yang Wang, Ryutaro Tanno, David G. T. Barrett, Wei-Hung Weng, S. Sara Mahdavi, Khaled Saab, Tao Tu, Sreenivasa Raju Kalidindi, Mozziyar Etemadi, Jorge Cuadros, Gregory Sorensen, Yossi Matias, Katherine Chou, Greg Corrado, Joelle Barral, Shravya Shetty, David Fleet, S. M. Ali Eslami, Daniel Tse, Shruthi Prabhakara, Cory McLean, Dave Steiner, Rory Pilgrim, Christopher Kelly, Shekoofeh Azizi, Daniel Golden
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Many clinical tasks require an understanding of specialized data, such as
medical images and genomics, which is not typically found in general-purpose
large multimodal models. Building upon Gemini's multimodal models, we develop
several models within the new Med-Gemini family that inherit core capabilities
of Gemini and are optimized for medical use via fine-tuning with 2D and 3D
radiology, histopathology, ophthalmology, dermatology and genomic data.
Med-Gemini-2D sets a new standard for AI-based chest X-ray (CXR) report
generation based on expert evaluation, exceeding previous best results across
two separate datasets by an absolute margin of 1% and 12%, where 57% and 96% of
AI reports on normal cases, and 43% and 65% on abnormal cases, are evaluated as
"equivalent or better" than the original radiologists' reports. We demonstrate
the first ever large multimodal model-based report generation for 3D computed
tomography (CT) volumes using Med-Gemini-3D, with 53% of AI reports considered
clinically acceptable, although additional research is needed to meet expert
radiologist reporting quality. Beyond report generation, Med-Gemini-2D
surpasses the previous best performance in CXR visual question answering (VQA)
and performs well in CXR classification and radiology VQA, exceeding SoTA or
baselines on 17 of 20 tasks. In histopathology, ophthalmology, and dermatology
image classification, Med-Gemini-2D surpasses baselines across 18 out of 20
tasks and approaches task-specific model performance. Beyond imaging,
Med-Gemini-Polygenic outperforms the standard linear polygenic risk score-based
approach for disease risk prediction and generalizes to genetically correlated
diseases for which it has never been trained. Although further development and
evaluation are necessary in the safety-critical medical domain, our results
highlight the potential of Med-Gemini across a wide range of medical tasks.
|
[
-0.36863669753074646,
-0.3336285352706909,
0.6648461818695068,
-0.027850612998008728,
-0.15162093937397003,
-0.010945928283035755,
0.1838911473751068,
-0.7469968795776367,
0.25075310468673706,
0.6519474387168884,
-0.4164600670337677,
-0.5323233604431152,
-0.9612380266189575,
-0.03919567912817001,
-0.41133350133895874,
1.0672675371170044,
0.3455602824687958,
0.2719945013523102,
-0.3451853394508362,
-0.15582114458084106,
-0.3651808202266693,
-0.5926005244255066,
-0.6142833828926086,
0.10706108808517456,
0.7984738349914551,
0.21596261858940125,
1.229766607284546,
0.7877613306045532,
1.0613417625427246,
0.2679542005062103,
0.22483213245868683,
0.19865943491458893,
-0.037077609449625015,
0.044003743678331375,
0.062299344688653946,
-0.46662840247154236,
-0.6599292755126953,
0.0003565194201655686,
0.30752936005592346,
0.5773629546165466,
-0.13052861392498016,
-0.22101609408855438,
-0.6625912189483643,
0.7326788306236267,
-0.5450758337974548,
0.22542916238307953,
-0.08643636107444763,
0.06241699308156967,
-0.22723616659641266,
-0.2077586054801941,
-0.15118278563022614,
-0.2568126916885376,
0.3860268294811249,
-0.6778796315193176,
0.13308614492416382,
-0.10535801202058792,
0.4341939091682434,
0.1811484545469284,
-0.806659996509552,
-0.4128798246383667,
-0.5239320993423462,
0.42174002528190613,
-0.28905189037323,
0.2510428726673126,
-0.022196847945451736,
0.7214435338973999,
0.15486374497413635,
-1.15215265750885,
-0.14071471989154816,
-0.6107219457626343,
-0.10524695366621017,
0.4984770119190216,
-0.2646295726299286,
0.029325831681489944,
-0.020477058365941048,
0.2788294553756714,
-0.5489081144332886,
0.0011484276037663221,
-0.7959612011909485,
-0.16818901896476746,
0.7316117882728577,
0.4907635748386383,
0.3150300681591034,
-0.31486767530441284,
-0.45927301049232483,
-0.3234744966030121,
-0.32707035541534424,
-0.0758211612701416,
-0.4346461594104767,
-0.05179088935256004,
-0.2990202009677887,
0.7076452374458313,
-0.0257651936262846,
0.5038700103759766,
-0.019147345796227455,
-0.1192239373922348,
0.5057221055030823,
-0.34132859110832214,
-0.052508920431137085,
-0.04577275365591049,
0.6228432059288025,
0.46604037284851074,
-0.15595749020576477,
0.15217925608158112,
0.09567996114492416,
0.3383950889110565,
0.48532527685165405,
-0.628675639629364,
-0.2010798156261444,
0.4062249958515167,
-0.9128512144088745,
-0.4428476393222809,
0.21613255143165588,
-0.37075671553611755,
-0.5458194613456726,
-0.3094894587993622,
0.4963666498661041,
-0.5489075779914856,
-0.4410698413848877,
0.37313246726989746,
-0.3170439898967743,
-0.22934533655643463,
0.3081839084625244,
-0.5340558290481567,
0.12953363358974457,
0.5182620286941528,
0.6658814549446106,
-0.16372887790203094,
0.02137683890759945,
-0.4375610649585724,
0.13282126188278198,
-0.48911014199256897,
0.6668999791145325,
-0.41301870346069336,
-0.5717021822929382,
-0.2916257083415985,
-0.2406013309955597,
-0.10839679092168808,
-0.6035841107368469,
0.2509322166442871,
-0.08260123431682587,
0.1875503957271576,
0.034237977117300034,
-0.07896633446216583,
-0.10222698748111725,
0.34387242794036865,
-0.5603804588317871,
0.5538923144340515,
0.3937018811702728,
-0.5166577696800232,
0.2880730926990509,
-0.7006268501281738,
-0.24842114746570587,
-0.03211502730846405,
-0.5288784503936768,
-0.367653489112854,
0.4160594940185547,
0.21679583191871643,
0.5044230818748474,
-0.43703481554985046,
0.20968542993068695,
-0.09051336348056793,
0.047394461929798126,
0.3465346097946167,
-0.26103439927101135,
0.3717869818210602,
0.2519683837890625,
-0.006299226079136133,
0.28888216614723206,
-0.9099546670913696,
0.1972808986902237,
0.005491664167493582,
-0.2994827926158905,
-0.14278839528560638,
-0.2226402312517166,
0.09989732503890991,
0.5736292004585266,
0.10981559008359909,
-0.7802485823631287,
0.06429290771484375,
-0.35557618737220764,
0.24290508031845093,
0.4122178852558136,
-0.1825023889541626,
-0.00689161941409111,
-0.6627424359321594,
0.47923001646995544,
0.3990381360054016,
0.8605301976203918,
-0.3676767349243164,
-0.6796308159828186,
-0.44854116439819336,
-0.7344632148742676,
0.08156616985797882,
0.4181264340877533,
-0.7139248251914978,
-0.044950712472200394,
-0.32435014843940735,
-0.7201340198516846,
-0.44558995962142944,
-0.3865802586078644,
0.5320965647697449,
0.43240639567375183,
0.3111124336719513,
-0.5827440619468689,
-0.3675740957260132,
-1.1732800006866455,
0.24373134970664978,
0.06678500771522522,
0.08434759080410004,
0.4655998647212982,
0.2384699583053589,
-0.48972997069358826,
0.4414195716381073,
-0.5924022793769836,
-0.40154993534088135,
-0.24932129681110382,
0.31618398427963257,
0.45069509744644165,
0.411372572183609,
0.7029349207878113,
-0.9393122792243958,
-0.49513140320777893,
0.2461782693862915,
-0.7571448087692261,
0.22509321570396423,
-0.027601292356848717,
-0.07785779982805252,
0.31212231516838074,
0.5283651351928711,
-0.49738284945487976,
0.426100492477417,
0.8605418801307678,
-0.3756875693798065,
0.20905569195747375,
-0.6662195324897766,
0.2502681612968445,
-1.0407031774520874,
0.15839707851409912,
0.11838464438915253,
-0.3902375102043152,
-0.5840758681297302,
0.04345036670565605,
0.2342389076948166,
-0.1323690414428711,
-0.3858150839805603,
0.2845174968242645,
-0.39050379395484924,
0.023516234010457993,
-0.20272907614707947,
-0.28132495284080505,
-0.07247064262628555,
0.006437493022531271,
0.12548843026161194,
0.15200361609458923,
0.7306409478187561,
-0.4981371760368347,
0.35690009593963623,
0.34250155091285706,
-0.2503390312194824,
0.5190269947052002,
-0.6218451857566833,
0.035174548625946045,
-0.4540478587150574,
0.25938504934310913,
-0.7434723973274231,
-0.12432581931352615,
0.02242334559559822,
-0.7015761733055115,
0.4747600555419922,
0.0178387351334095,
-0.22132474184036255,
-0.7183798551559448,
-0.279664546251297,
0.27754154801368713,
0.42834436893463135,
-0.22637198865413666,
0.8616204857826233,
0.317066490650177,
-0.24971994757652283,
-0.6432486176490784,
-0.7108387351036072,
0.2688368260860443,
0.25946903228759766,
-0.8719508647918701,
0.5875277519226074,
-0.24896858632564545,
-0.1552438735961914,
-0.06858638674020767,
-0.07094310224056244,
-0.14791014790534973,
-0.2668731212615967,
0.47939714789390564,
0.7294744849205017,
-0.2650383710861206,
-0.15602414309978485,
-0.050083961337804794,
-0.5074512362480164,
0.1343144327402115,
-0.07465187460184097,
0.20167191326618195,
0.06285633891820908,
-0.46039879322052,
-0.45286282896995544,
0.5101637840270996,
1.0532034635543823,
-0.24408386647701263,
0.5741873383522034,
0.5855618715286255,
-0.2838270366191864,
0.4553726017475128,
-0.6381311416625977,
-0.04713239148259163,
-0.3611595034599304,
0.5867437124252319,
-0.2855229079723358,
-0.6342093348503113,
0.16094206273555756,
0.2869698107242584,
0.12923483550548553,
0.5484954714775085,
0.5942202806472778,
-0.1959826499223709,
1.446297526359558,
0.6274383664131165,
0.3173893392086029,
0.1396675407886505,
-0.23992758989334106,
-0.1172063797712326,
-0.6035752296447754,
-0.5911338925361633,
-0.4579865336418152,
-0.177141472697258,
-0.6605345606803894,
-0.5301286578178406,
1.2704949378967285,
-0.7284883856773376,
-0.1754513680934906,
-0.19357752799987793,
-0.733078122138977,
0.09570856392383575,
0.6829897165298462,
0.44381260871887207,
0.3394419252872467,
-0.1672695428133011,
-0.04330109804868698,
-0.007023089099675417,
-0.7104905247688293,
0.021755874156951904,
1.5797786712646484,
0.20299141108989716,
0.6100814342498779,
0.14508037269115448,
0.40757882595062256,
0.3439382016658783,
0.5461613535881042,
-0.4933862090110779,
0.0778452530503273,
-0.9028506875038147,
-1.0415973663330078,
0.16345109045505524,
-0.36983102560043335,
-0.929487943649292,
0.2638518512248993,
-0.680367648601532,
-0.1872802972793579,
-0.0240777675062418,
0.16965261101722717,
-0.7068315148353577,
-0.00884870532900095,
-0.37906283140182495,
0.5706412196159363,
-0.5534794926643372,
-0.12028301507234573,
-0.46426501870155334,
-0.9998974204063416,
0.3922572433948517,
-0.12017554044723511,
0.3537781834602356,
0.049286507070064545,
-0.25167611241340637,
0.31144699454307556,
-0.318880170583725,
0.7044178247451782,
-0.13777905702590942,
0.25070348381996155,
-0.07451687753200531,
-0.0588185116648674,
0.023424070328474045,
0.1737387776374817,
0.1522347778081894,
0.2115572690963745,
0.45961272716522217,
-0.14478719234466553,
-0.3589279055595398,
0.7112053632736206,
-1.0214171409606934,
-0.3653858006000519,
-0.6585286259651184,
-0.8643076419830322,
-0.10408900678157806,
0.017758570611476898,
0.24604184925556183,
0.752464771270752,
0.022948481142520905,
0.3712937831878662,
0.417815238237381,
-0.548607587814331,
0.04365149512887001,
0.45751866698265076,
-0.19277693331241608,
-0.7982237339019775,
0.7201791405677795,
0.05083564296364784,
0.20812824368476868,
0.6429082751274109,
0.28611984848976135,
-0.25704190135002136,
-0.579958438873291,
-0.3041491210460663,
0.21851618587970734,
-0.5105748176574707,
-0.29372674226760864,
-0.8165119290351868,
-0.45102009177207947,
-0.3934208154678345,
-0.29042211174964905,
-0.5660129189491272,
-0.46919891238212585,
-0.01112988032400608,
0.2864121198654175,
0.10215311497449875,
0.751130998134613,
-0.2428407073020935,
0.2025858461856842,
-1.259158730506897,
0.5582391023635864,
-0.010388750582933426,
0.08291669934988022,
-0.5440409183502197,
-0.11168370395898819,
-0.1619655042886734,
-0.13662806153297424,
-0.389475554227829,
-0.42698803544044495,
0.34510496258735657,
-0.1377270519733429,
0.4419349133968353,
0.37257707118988037,
-0.2908567190170288,
0.5202105641365051,
0.098985955119133,
0.5780981779098511,
0.7531269788742065,
-0.6668806672096252,
0.5352764129638672,
-0.40758049488067627,
0.29772093892097473,
0.15637537837028503,
0.20712299644947052,
-0.5348271727561951,
-0.19151093065738678,
-0.7132288813591003,
-0.7406727075576782,
0.6974025368690491,
0.3412000238895416,
0.11341561377048492,
-0.198382169008255,
0.5667278170585632,
0.34077367186546326,
0.1583109349012375,
-0.39734113216400146,
-0.2396138608455658,
-0.3055708706378937,
-0.3305480480194092,
-0.28118202090263367,
-0.1108088418841362,
-0.2409936785697937,
-0.23512202501296997,
0.3251115083694458,
-0.31751981377601624,
0.4043598175048828,
0.42366519570350647,
0.1132342591881752,
0.11337648332118988,
-0.04108177125453949,
0.5762574076652527,
0.7028641104698181,
-0.1481914520263672,
-0.01917668990790844,
-0.24743719398975372,
-0.6551882028579712,
-0.21125532686710358,
0.33927541971206665,
0.4070938527584076,
-0.20768874883651733,
0.31617265939712524,
0.3353286683559418,
0.10441180318593979,
-0.6755980253219604,
0.7471542358398438,
-0.3160790801048279,
-0.3474290072917938,
-0.47357746958732605,
0.28254279494285583,
0.05546996369957924,
0.3686513602733612,
0.17491959035396576,
0.7074653506278992,
0.165124773979187,
-0.4665078818798065,
0.23439310491085052,
0.35591819882392883,
-0.5208227038383484,
-0.07679690420627594,
0.7852233052253723,
0.3615952730178833,
0.5710804462432861,
1.064778208732605,
0.5479013919830322,
0.08742182701826096,
1.0428571701049805,
0.4071447551250458,
0.18819236755371094,
-0.19334037601947784,
0.2783915400505066,
0.5178956389427185,
0.2719741761684418,
-0.05714898183941841,
0.6220085024833679,
0.3503355383872986,
-0.6248273253440857,
-0.1691657453775406,
-0.03915295749902725,
-0.4007231891155243,
-0.12666666507720947,
-0.8134281039237976,
0.2943630516529083,
-0.7785800099372864,
-0.405421644449234,
0.30210185050964355,
-0.20090846717357635,
-0.4578184485435486,
0.7070273160934448,
0.5599581599235535,
1.0946613550186157,
-0.2381039708852768,
0.7404975891113281,
0.6631702780723572,
-0.306852251291275,
-0.2743765413761139,
-0.6044203042984009,
0.42241227626800537,
-1.0785109996795654,
0.4332997500896454,
0.3217514157295227,
0.07926268130540848,
-0.15246793627738953,
-0.2811070382595062,
-0.9669472575187683,
1.424224615097046,
0.31157398223876953,
-0.6242232322692871,
-0.001198076643049717,
0.22472700476646423,
0.48383113741874695,
-0.621013879776001,
0.5078758001327515,
0.347432941198349,
0.48687487840652466,
0.2978650629520416,
-0.8661977648735046,
-0.06529360264539719,
-0.33142662048339844,
0.09827034920454025,
0.2274997979402542,
-0.7268508076667786,
0.9395323395729065,
-0.695734441280365,
0.10230933129787445,
0.5080426335334778,
0.29560887813568115,
0.33766716718673706,
0.5290395617485046,
0.4371162950992584,
0.430984228849411,
0.4907579720020294,
-0.3331925868988037,
1.5392119884490967,
-0.4011594355106354,
-0.24664480984210968,
0.5835230350494385,
0.04405619204044342,
0.5366312861442566,
0.17837920784950256,
0.20444925129413605,
0.3514636158943176,
0.31656816601753235,
-0.09254492819309235,
0.3037211000919342,
0.03177252411842346,
-0.12447083741426468,
-0.2860890328884125,
-0.042187947779893875,
-0.5845963358879089,
0.6919436454772949,
0.6069148182868958,
-0.6183419227600098,
0.25456398725509644,
0.3401324152946472,
-0.06689540296792984,
-0.3358098864555359,
-0.5435347557067871,
0.5656754374504089,
-0.04932013899087906,
-0.5673941969871521,
0.25128549337387085,
0.06714757531881332,
0.6833093166351318,
-1.0052759647369385,
0.13942398130893707,
-0.06418672204017639,
0.60236656665802,
-0.264302521944046,
-0.8330279588699341,
0.581930935382843,
-0.30738815665245056,
-0.21082881093025208,
0.0684569701552391,
0.3726016879081726,
0.14190055429935455,
-0.7354092001914978,
0.29510247707366943,
0.5469107031822205,
-0.11526082456111908,
-0.22896870970726013,
-0.547339141368866,
0.06554266810417175,
-0.015305228531360626,
0.012631700374186039,
0.2442704737186432,
0.10863551497459412,
-0.010828552767634392,
0.7829633355140686,
0.6369583606719971,
-0.01493033580482006,
-0.04709003120660782,
0.015817614272236824,
0.9793813228607178,
-0.77826327085495,
-0.19576407968997955,
-0.3214857578277588,
0.830333948135376,
0.04475199803709984,
-0.6010697484016418,
0.1522430181503296,
0.6021571755409241,
0.5281423330307007,
-0.00937223993241787,
0.9745336771011353,
-0.2275816947221756,
0.28038710355758667,
-0.4830719232559204,
0.5490607619285583,
-0.8859857320785522,
-0.05876434966921806,
0.0417364127933979,
-0.3887390196323395,
-0.8114936947822571,
0.2214297205209732,
0.050457846373319626,
0.24867837131023407,
0.9327965974807739,
0.8165290355682373,
-0.1086682677268982,
-0.007401805371046066,
0.5113851428031921,
0.41663652658462524,
0.3648301362991333,
0.619896650314331,
0.8628835678100586,
-0.31240683794021606,
0.8755843043327332,
-0.4062137305736542,
-0.7779759764671326,
-0.12753979861736298,
-0.38308605551719666,
-0.7762184143066406,
-0.5226447582244873,
-0.4297303259372711,
-0.42775192856788635,
0.10851714015007019,
0.7813082933425903,
1.113413691520691,
-0.4095321595668793,
0.1327541619539261,
0.3151032328605652,
-0.5127168893814087,
-0.41933563351631165,
-0.10602433234453201,
0.38659486174583435,
0.01978212036192417,
-0.5713576674461365,
0.25583383440971375,
0.7432522773742676,
0.004522058647125959,
-0.057280369102954865,
0.0034058373421430588,
0.2778284549713135,
-0.09332383424043655,
0.6565690040588379,
0.06454472243785858,
-0.6275219321250916,
0.011347629129886627,
0.13613542914390564,
-0.35315385460853577,
0.2739238739013672,
0.9090983271598816,
-0.7002569437026978,
0.631976306438446,
0.32635825872421265,
0.24026937782764435,
0.4846266508102417,
-0.3599652349948883,
0.5653895139694214,
-0.16165141761302948,
-0.11670750379562378,
0.25349003076553345,
0.37626782059669495,
0.16941764950752258,
-0.6562641263008118,
0.29664382338523865,
0.10580377280712128,
-0.354436457157135,
-0.1981356292963028,
0.14785993099212646,
-1.3546555042266846,
-0.43746817111968994,
0.7121374607086182,
0.11461670696735382,
-0.0001529520668555051,
-0.05041682347655296,
-0.37017133831977844,
0.07241756469011307,
-0.18058480322360992,
0.9819076657295227,
0.06321288645267487,
-0.5823469161987305,
-0.3694995939731598,
-0.4207307696342468,
0.1425376981496811,
0.21846173703670502,
-0.9979422688484192,
-0.4211141765117645,
0.6000931262969971,
0.41705793142318726,
0.26159894466400146,
0.667723536491394,
-0.877167820930481,
0.8782835006713867,
-0.02586226537823677,
-0.00446661002933979,
-0.43275201320648193,
-0.5552212595939636,
0.10592631250619888,
0.3836255967617035,
-0.2363603562116623,
-0.3261776268482208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06683v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06683v1
|
ERAGent: Enhancing Retrieval-Augmented Language Models with Improved Accuracy, Efficiency, and Personalization
| 2024-05-06T04:42:18 | 2024-05-06T04:42:18 |
Yunxiao Shi, Xing Zi, Zijing Shi, Haimin Zhang, Qiang Wu, Min Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) for language models significantly
improves language understanding systems. The basic retrieval-then-read pipeline
of response generation has evolved into a more extended process due to the
integration of various components, sometimes even forming loop structures.
Despite its advancements in improving response accuracy, challenges like poor
retrieval quality for complex questions that require the search of multifaceted
semantic information, inefficiencies in knowledge re-retrieval during long-term
serving, and lack of personalized responses persist. Motivated by transcending
these limitations, we introduce ERAGent, a cutting-edge framework that embodies
an advancement in the RAG area. Our contribution is the introduction of the
synergistically operated module: Enhanced Question Rewriter and Knowledge
Filter, for better retrieval quality. Retrieval Trigger is incorporated to
curtail extraneous external knowledge retrieval without sacrificing response
quality. ERAGent also personalizes responses by incorporating a learned user
profile. The efficiency and personalization characteristics of ERAGent are
supported by the Experiential Learner module which makes the AI assistant being
capable of expanding its knowledge and modeling user profile incrementally.
Rigorous evaluations across six datasets and three question-answering tasks
prove ERAGent's superior accuracy, efficiency, and personalization, emphasizing
its potential to advance the RAG field and its applicability in practical
systems.
|
[
-0.3474331796169281,
-0.9932622909545898,
0.3726155161857605,
-0.18285636603832245,
0.21779823303222656,
0.1805621087551117,
-0.1590213030576706,
-0.42793548107147217,
0.1929100602865219,
0.5577665567398071,
-0.381742000579834,
-0.19308562576770782,
-0.38545483350753784,
0.04314352571964264,
-0.4737730920314789,
0.9142416715621948,
0.3051091134548187,
-0.0003970192919950932,
-0.2154855579137802,
-0.30118417739868164,
-0.43397000432014465,
-0.375390887260437,
-0.8686225414276123,
-0.4281720221042633,
0.5299047231674194,
0.2333448976278305,
0.5466816425323486,
0.5592091083526611,
0.36562395095825195,
0.4247415363788605,
-0.033483944833278656,
0.35502874851226807,
-0.23264124989509583,
0.7866443395614624,
-0.31775152683258057,
-0.5703144669532776,
-0.6319337487220764,
-0.2875317335128784,
0.47511568665504456,
0.8628239631652832,
-0.35773566365242004,
0.24035270512104034,
0.14131614565849304,
0.6469788551330566,
-0.8081995248794556,
-0.2011178731918335,
-0.4624387323856354,
-0.13524432480335236,
-0.011486565694212914,
-0.43666449189186096,
-0.4367857873439789,
-0.06522758305072784,
0.14915227890014648,
-0.8794752359390259,
0.43839773535728455,
0.3134661316871643,
0.5412715077400208,
0.3769410252571106,
-0.41279685497283936,
-0.2509637773036957,
-0.8321391940116882,
0.7783176302909851,
-0.5807695388793945,
0.7861374616622925,
0.3420039117336273,
0.5375357270240784,
-0.3059363067150116,
-1.0012027025222778,
-0.5207131505012512,
-0.18721528351306915,
-0.07554755359888077,
0.32762598991394043,
-0.045065756887197495,
0.003429217031225562,
0.14621025323867798,
0.2721264660358429,
-0.7652570009231567,
-0.15510378777980804,
0.07853781431913376,
-0.0621400848031044,
0.3318825960159302,
0.41442960500717163,
0.3041350245475769,
-0.12497267872095108,
-0.3321843147277832,
-0.18996015191078186,
-0.4613240361213684,
0.053933512419462204,
0.43747520446777344,
0.21735569834709167,
0.25262650847435,
0.3744898736476898,
-0.5431113839149475,
1.0057257413864136,
-0.0414862185716629,
0.03620384633541107,
0.1893661618232727,
-0.27026882767677307,
-0.09500475227832794,
-0.46065568923950195,
0.36360910534858704,
-0.06598851829767227,
-0.15113511681556702,
-0.1272151619195938,
-0.35845857858657837,
-0.39892759919166565,
0.3984262943267822,
-0.569282054901123,
-0.21148619055747986,
0.24799926578998566,
-0.5136305689811707,
-0.18871626257896423,
0.2436569780111313,
-0.820457398891449,
-0.4323267340660095,
-0.5094698071479797,
0.41666123270988464,
-0.38357406854629517,
-0.39044854044914246,
0.030706102028489113,
-0.291777640581131,
0.36522164940834045,
0.5486695170402527,
-0.5754013061523438,
0.3890690803527832,
0.8652856349945068,
0.33638742566108704,
-0.06948933750391006,
-0.21689535677433014,
-0.6422758102416992,
0.20308580994606018,
-0.22814634442329407,
1.0174052715301514,
-0.7088408470153809,
-0.3512091338634491,
0.02884097769856453,
-0.20562537014484406,
0.09020430594682693,
-0.6710577607154846,
0.2876039147377014,
-0.895469069480896,
0.47913792729377747,
0.08433902263641357,
-0.6928037405014038,
-0.10814237594604492,
0.16225719451904297,
-0.5312875509262085,
0.9897809624671936,
0.10874806344509125,
-0.5634515881538391,
0.30641505122184753,
-0.5817558765411377,
-0.3451366722583771,
0.2683248817920685,
-0.05019836872816086,
-0.16407650709152222,
0.24198469519615173,
0.11821727454662323,
0.17040814459323883,
-0.5564488768577576,
0.21547570824623108,
-0.10356069356203079,
-0.20403827726840973,
0.24826335906982422,
-0.40802258253097534,
0.6815606355667114,
0.46539461612701416,
0.01929561048746109,
0.11667987704277039,
-0.7779219150543213,
0.1707984358072281,
0.2375587522983551,
-0.3878718614578247,
-0.5533324480056763,
-0.13441093266010284,
0.06559810042381287,
-0.11102831363677979,
0.42304864525794983,
-0.5724186897277832,
-0.22194308042526245,
-0.5178419351577759,
-0.04183296486735344,
0.7452734708786011,
0.034588128328323364,
0.4672616422176361,
-0.4757309854030609,
0.618270754814148,
-0.2901395857334137,
0.13101284205913544,
-0.38641801476478577,
-0.24001078307628632,
-1.0370628833770752,
0.11468002200126648,
0.15407760441303253,
0.5399573445320129,
-0.9572575688362122,
0.2960645854473114,
-0.16716045141220093,
-0.251334547996521,
-0.5769331455230713,
0.10787025839090347,
0.5511659383773804,
0.6983479857444763,
0.4111628532409668,
-0.20648083090782166,
-0.5344868898391724,
-0.6794968843460083,
-0.6388683915138245,
-0.28409773111343384,
-0.040003176778554916,
0.6600335836410522,
0.06597248464822769,
-0.030338989570736885,
1.0821813344955444,
-0.635979950428009,
-0.11402485519647598,
-0.38187459111213684,
0.13850955665111542,
0.17738603055477142,
0.3385743796825409,
-0.00983573216944933,
-1.1413326263427734,
-0.4054420590400696,
0.09939786791801453,
-0.6719256043434143,
-0.4158306419849396,
0.09920157492160797,
-0.11354175955057144,
0.36992424726486206,
0.5914419889450073,
-0.08537666499614716,
0.3139576315879822,
0.3433346748352051,
-0.47753235697746277,
0.4726351201534271,
-0.45472443103790283,
0.4015018939971924,
-1.3349117040634155,
0.4772530496120453,
-0.3052225112915039,
-0.4702078402042389,
-0.8713605999946594,
0.3835223317146301,
0.064667247235775,
-0.06106813624501228,
-0.2626110017299652,
0.8169901371002197,
-0.2911026179790497,
-0.10260701924562454,
-0.4968739449977875,
0.2077159881591797,
0.15549911558628082,
0.2663174569606781,
-0.218479722738266,
0.8391429781913757,
-0.07609963417053223,
-0.6296486854553223,
0.4260800778865814,
0.2933235764503479,
0.03682197257876396,
0.764979898929596,
-0.6791365146636963,
0.3958706855773926,
-0.2654113173484802,
0.16336889564990997,
-0.8490354418754578,
-0.3582178056240082,
0.018595891073346138,
-0.837365448474884,
0.5017469525337219,
-0.029229380190372467,
-0.41024696826934814,
0.1220586895942688,
-0.24703386425971985,
0.25709179043769836,
0.6211052536964417,
-0.6511449813842773,
0.9990245699882507,
0.4285333454608917,
-0.17937268316745758,
-0.795448899269104,
-0.36935949325561523,
0.08070123195648193,
-0.042643953114748,
-0.45829376578330994,
0.2697359323501587,
-0.07318475842475891,
-0.23521846532821655,
0.16876468062400818,
-0.004428742919117212,
-0.055068932473659515,
0.2223856896162033,
-0.0847073346376419,
0.32589197158813477,
-0.0973052978515625,
0.3982793986797333,
0.04968541860580444,
-0.4139748513698578,
-0.1830853819847107,
-0.29273584485054016,
0.664569616317749,
0.1484808325767517,
-0.3066963255405426,
-0.071391761302948,
0.4064193367958069,
-0.022703880444169044,
-0.42737868428230286,
0.7025364637374878,
0.6410700082778931,
-0.2614090144634247,
-0.3843459486961365,
-0.7032197713851929,
-0.25192806124687195,
-0.5174952745437622,
0.4071715474128723,
-0.6705808043479919,
-1.222542405128479,
0.5268009305000305,
-0.12272550910711288,
0.25801217555999756,
0.3901461958885193,
0.34610795974731445,
-0.10109231621026993,
1.073561191558838,
0.7331792116165161,
0.1691371500492096,
0.6549386978149414,
-0.03417545557022095,
0.16278798878192902,
-1.2229663133621216,
-0.24664218723773956,
-0.7039099335670471,
0.12623253464698792,
-0.6217163801193237,
-0.23427769541740417,
0.5648722052574158,
0.022440403699874878,
-0.35813161730766296,
0.2736571133136749,
-0.37917912006378174,
0.11603901535272598,
0.4406910836696625,
0.03372076153755188,
0.4580264091491699,
-0.19446483254432678,
0.00032857301994226873,
0.1319185197353363,
-0.7687497735023499,
-0.32669395208358765,
1.0438315868377686,
0.2011854648590088,
1.0901463031768799,
0.4700554609298706,
0.8009459972381592,
0.33248549699783325,
0.2670813500881195,
-0.4583736062049866,
0.579923689365387,
-0.19698435068130493,
-0.6363429427146912,
-0.22720760107040405,
-0.622774600982666,
-0.9929576516151428,
0.3674237132072449,
-0.12300312519073486,
-0.47931501269340515,
0.0236174575984478,
0.4231438934803009,
-0.45429447293281555,
0.0034512910060584545,
-0.5882772207260132,
0.5335381031036377,
-0.0576840415596962,
-0.5063320398330688,
-0.33034747838974,
-0.667608916759491,
-0.027027320116758347,
-0.06322924047708511,
0.11672841012477875,
0.07557466626167297,
-0.5125606060028076,
0.5694008469581604,
-0.31374287605285645,
0.6205877065658569,
-0.22042766213417053,
0.12921202182769775,
0.07296627014875412,
0.16072632372379303,
0.4525838792324066,
-0.07634244859218597,
-0.03259238973259926,
-0.38060417771339417,
-0.16648991405963898,
-0.13789351284503937,
-0.8990676403045654,
0.7849764227867126,
-0.6243654489517212,
-0.853851854801178,
-0.1965591311454773,
-0.5122100114822388,
-0.2091142237186432,
0.2521286904811859,
0.03875485062599182,
0.641827404499054,
-0.32084742188453674,
-0.030349237844347954,
0.7821241021156311,
-0.6570448279380798,
0.07116414606571198,
0.6719254851341248,
-0.4317290186882019,
-0.4795072376728058,
1.048061490058899,
-0.1666094809770584,
0.33901017904281616,
0.5143659710884094,
0.23786526918411255,
-0.3919287621974945,
-0.1948096752166748,
-0.36833035945892334,
0.08668563514947891,
-0.8403865098953247,
-0.40549004077911377,
-1.0402848720550537,
-0.13390040397644043,
-0.8405043482780457,
0.002442516153678298,
-0.25291207432746887,
-0.48154816031455994,
-0.12356685847043991,
0.3450623154640198,
0.31347569823265076,
0.8091152906417847,
-0.08613331615924835,
0.1514611840248108,
-0.5994482040405273,
0.38332808017730713,
0.2870773673057556,
0.2785056531429291,
-0.03167812153697014,
-0.7906857132911682,
-0.19167640805244446,
-0.2739856243133545,
-0.07908879220485687,
-0.6594310998916626,
0.3006821274757385,
0.4285435676574707,
0.695249617099762,
0.01062149927020073,
-0.0008909089956432581,
0.6632470488548279,
-0.5063892006874084,
0.4965214133262634,
-0.28874045610427856,
-0.790359377861023,
0.60762619972229,
-0.24279215931892395,
0.33659932017326355,
0.5028439164161682,
-0.060104526579380035,
-0.7646325826644897,
-0.4520403742790222,
-0.6883388757705688,
-1.1387290954589844,
0.6333605051040649,
-0.18692021071910858,
0.22986991703510284,
0.0863569974899292,
0.4699804484844208,
0.21383406221866608,
0.1503627747297287,
-0.05862336605787277,
-0.3329342007637024,
0.06931398063898087,
-0.27360790967941284,
0.07053157687187195,
-0.1821075975894928,
0.2842085659503937,
0.012394574470818043,
0.8548662066459656,
-0.22666002810001373,
0.33221152424812317,
0.286726713180542,
-0.32441455125808716,
-0.06502406299114227,
0.3469623923301697,
0.1553478240966797,
0.4992457330226898,
-0.09628111869096756,
0.09212420135736465,
0.34564849734306335,
-0.30541449785232544,
0.07778023183345795,
0.3540867567062378,
-0.02171275019645691,
-0.17842143774032593,
0.3594280183315277,
0.34764355421066284,
0.0708385482430458,
-0.6540346741676331,
0.2895912528038025,
-0.25101712346076965,
0.41430366039276123,
-0.6885376572608948,
0.35977569222450256,
-0.1183844804763794,
0.21985997259616852,
0.3470004200935364,
-0.03061247244477272,
0.6433501243591309,
-0.23088659346103668,
0.4513181746006012,
0.3552623689174652,
-0.14659351110458374,
-0.09109301120042801,
0.7426398396492004,
0.19500337541103363,
-0.3846037983894348,
0.48478734493255615,
-0.11458635330200195,
-0.46960896253585815,
0.3786439001560211,
0.6299711465835571,
0.9100149869918823,
-0.49590054154396057,
0.03953192010521889,
0.35060155391693115,
-0.05935757979750633,
0.1844026893377304,
0.3066067397594452,
-0.29269248247146606,
-0.8533922433853149,
-0.4381959140300751,
-0.7592890858650208,
-0.38411760330200195,
-0.1603444665670395,
-0.838016927242279,
-0.00018761609680950642,
-0.43539419770240784,
-0.12473328411579132,
-0.07626839727163315,
-0.05536751449108124,
-0.7081947326660156,
0.01139939483255148,
-0.20466771721839905,
0.8760305643081665,
-0.5212558507919312,
0.6705597639083862,
1.0860934257507324,
-0.38238492608070374,
-0.5642988085746765,
-0.013018179684877396,
0.05672479420900345,
-0.7495492100715637,
0.72747403383255,
0.024338755756616592,
-0.3314477503299713,
0.3604092597961426,
-0.20868033170700073,
-0.8012689352035522,
1.098621129989624,
-0.0030656971503049135,
-0.12852618098258972,
0.217136949300766,
-0.028543967753648758,
0.5380388498306274,
-0.37397301197052,
0.44968172907829285,
0.6166760921478271,
0.15952745079994202,
-0.06122907996177673,
-0.7466447353363037,
-0.0899529829621315,
-0.420071005821228,
0.3405594825744629,
0.452688068151474,
-0.47749319672584534,
0.7430513501167297,
-0.039209846407175064,
-0.24212460219860077,
0.318409264087677,
0.7901542782783508,
0.22192184627056122,
0.1973484456539154,
0.5300027132034302,
0.6752784252166748,
0.3910417854785919,
-0.025087783113121986,
1.2164318561553955,
-0.31629374623298645,
0.19434234499931335,
1.2864441871643066,
-0.24124570190906525,
0.8526847958564758,
0.3316100835800171,
-0.08494718372821808,
0.4204954206943512,
0.15943336486816406,
0.46762028336524963,
0.3697022497653961,
-0.13475260138511658,
-0.5483441352844238,
-0.23447304964065552,
-0.5470113158226013,
0.023766813799738884,
0.4452308416366577,
0.4137873351573944,
-0.2918015718460083,
-0.2539908289909363,
0.1086931973695755,
-0.15054726600646973,
0.33852720260620117,
0.09902523458003998,
1.1221131086349487,
0.025731896981596947,
-0.6752343773841858,
0.13467860221862793,
0.03655799850821495,
0.618326723575592,
-0.49364393949508667,
-0.4414641261100769,
-0.2698253095149994,
0.3831433355808258,
-0.021888768300414085,
-0.686112642288208,
0.25968214869499207,
0.01156879123300314,
-0.04075989872217178,
-0.27355608344078064,
1.1748778820037842,
-0.49844592809677124,
-0.04100640490651131,
0.3836004436016083,
0.9761678576469421,
0.004761515185236931,
0.2496873438358307,
-0.9283832907676697,
0.029395585879683495,
-0.11229878664016724,
-0.5620400905609131,
0.13340692222118378,
0.24840284883975983,
0.24712856113910675,
0.6960442662239075,
0.7353771328926086,
0.08548452705144882,
-0.015212344005703926,
0.34033438563346863,
0.8106245398521423,
-0.5233408212661743,
-0.3495076596736908,
-0.43626660108566284,
0.4970948398113251,
-0.23437237739562988,
-0.24572739005088806,
0.695371687412262,
0.5032909512519836,
0.9775866866111755,
0.271660715341568,
0.8027658462524414,
-0.3359003961086273,
1.0507512092590332,
-0.342624306678772,
0.7490466833114624,
-0.7435601949691772,
0.35574087500572205,
-0.027193492278456688,
-0.9040268659591675,
-0.29139548540115356,
0.48998868465423584,
-0.21953549981117249,
0.5600214600563049,
0.348721444606781,
0.9156723022460938,
0.03602876514196396,
-0.1598075032234192,
0.5339635610580444,
-0.02451799437403679,
0.614991307258606,
0.298252671957016,
0.8572968244552612,
-0.3525255024433136,
0.203054279088974,
-0.246773824095726,
-0.39537084102630615,
-0.1424274891614914,
-0.39744046330451965,
-0.6425594687461853,
-0.7810768485069275,
0.12201213836669922,
-0.2885987460613251,
0.3951926529407501,
1.113569974899292,
0.5030056238174438,
-0.6710211634635925,
-0.2793164849281311,
-0.10355500876903534,
-0.1889365166425705,
0.09384362399578094,
-0.26852667331695557,
0.2583153247833252,
-0.8391035795211792,
-0.7189744114875793,
0.41095253825187683,
0.24662798643112183,
-0.149459108710289,
-0.3224165737628937,
-0.037858035415410995,
-0.20888932049274445,
-0.06511890888214111,
0.4757387340068817,
0.2999774217605591,
-0.5770981907844543,
-0.22206638753414154,
0.2832655608654022,
-0.10176225751638412,
-0.25842607021331787,
0.8299882411956787,
-0.9341310858726501,
0.7700285315513611,
0.7109137177467346,
0.9812102317810059,
0.11698318272829056,
0.10750233381986618,
0.7112432718276978,
-0.6702088117599487,
0.04719157516956329,
0.3435635566711426,
0.2785162627696991,
0.4925364553928375,
-0.35485899448394775,
0.5526316165924072,
0.033169928938150406,
-0.6948922872543335,
-0.5227501392364502,
0.4150732457637787,
-0.3579086661338806,
-0.38605716824531555,
0.9504332542419434,
-0.25282853841781616,
-0.30093300342559814,
-0.37326595187187195,
0.02506907843053341,
0.41677772998809814,
-0.4270070493221283,
0.4334219992160797,
0.29317885637283325,
-0.43832072615623474,
-0.16229131817817688,
-0.8638602495193481,
0.4670986533164978,
0.8189378976821899,
-0.9723512530326843,
0.0837334468960762,
0.6131858825683594,
0.3183384835720062,
0.09218060225248337,
0.4920435845851898,
-0.14046645164489746,
0.4123854637145996,
-0.07475904375314713,
0.12418432533740997,
-0.1943061649799347,
-0.43189069628715515,
-0.516151487827301,
-0.03609289973974228,
0.34511885046958923,
0.040626537054777145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03153v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03153v1
|
Exploring the Potential of the Large Language Models (LLMs) in Identifying Misleading News Headlines
| 2024-05-06T04:06:45 | 2024-05-06T04:06:45 |
Md Main Uddin Rony, Md Mahfuzul Haque, Mohammad Ali, Ahmed Shatil Alam, Naeemul Hassan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
In the digital age, the prevalence of misleading news headlines poses a
significant challenge to information integrity, necessitating robust detection
mechanisms. This study explores the efficacy of Large Language Models (LLMs) in
identifying misleading versus non-misleading news headlines. Utilizing a
dataset of 60 articles, sourced from both reputable and questionable outlets
across health, science & tech, and business domains, we employ three LLMs-
ChatGPT-3.5, ChatGPT-4, and Gemini-for classification. Our analysis reveals
significant variance in model performance, with ChatGPT-4 demonstrating
superior accuracy, especially in cases with unanimous annotator agreement on
misleading headlines. The study emphasizes the importance of human-centered
evaluation in developing LLMs that can navigate the complexities of
misinformation detection, aligning technical proficiency with nuanced human
judgment. Our findings contribute to the discourse on AI ethics, emphasizing
the need for models that are not only technically advanced but also ethically
aligned and sensitive to the subtleties of human interpretation.
|
[
-0.014191343449056149,
-0.7784772515296936,
0.9063229560852051,
0.4804631173610687,
-0.18863213062286377,
0.15575888752937317,
-0.23088961839675903,
-0.8167048096656799,
-0.15441027283668518,
0.37512144446372986,
-0.32713690400123596,
-0.36233317852020264,
-0.8730086088180542,
0.11624341458082199,
-0.7000267505645752,
0.9914958477020264,
0.24485138058662415,
0.2566477358341217,
-0.0826648399233818,
0.28369778394699097,
-0.4353240728378296,
-0.381173700094223,
-0.9116339683532715,
-0.3459431827068329,
0.5531250238418579,
0.13995656371116638,
0.9060638546943665,
0.6588640213012695,
0.5645366907119751,
0.19861149787902832,
-0.20153935253620148,
0.21892395615577698,
-0.41731908917427063,
-0.3555890917778015,
-0.2815006673336029,
-0.5097843408584595,
-0.22549782693386078,
0.4511718153953552,
0.44212543964385986,
0.46665018796920776,
-0.22660879790782928,
0.2342248558998108,
-0.06500869989395142,
0.5063409805297852,
-0.4477419853210449,
0.08121813088655472,
-0.6711840033531189,
-0.08603131771087646,
-0.11887379735708237,
-0.27458977699279785,
-0.5580286383628845,
-0.42946571111679077,
0.07585935294628143,
-0.39722341299057007,
-0.08167074620723724,
0.3476976454257965,
1.0584017038345337,
0.4134501814842224,
-0.5746286511421204,
-0.5492506623268127,
-0.7954256534576416,
0.8216295838356018,
-0.8966518044471741,
0.45517876744270325,
0.3332829773426056,
0.28816336393356323,
-0.27506422996520996,
-0.43781420588493347,
-0.5983951687812805,
-0.38596734404563904,
0.09198767691850662,
0.050407350063323975,
-0.49832668900489807,
-0.09417624771595001,
0.17605862021446228,
0.2092818021774292,
-0.45950809121131897,
0.6944501996040344,
-0.3625850975513458,
-0.41934314370155334,
0.654233455657959,
-0.023609859868884087,
0.3394036889076233,
-0.3609195649623871,
-0.36547476053237915,
0.2370903342962265,
-0.7524154782295227,
-0.22000239789485931,
0.6245078444480896,
0.34299561381340027,
-0.35827118158340454,
0.6270434260368347,
0.03725668787956238,
0.6813797950744629,
0.10567622631788254,
-0.5986179113388062,
0.20451326668262482,
-0.2593251168727875,
-0.24563370645046234,
0.2646922171115875,
0.8641871809959412,
0.6091803908348083,
0.3783125877380371,
-0.09326477348804474,
-0.309419184923172,
0.2178301066160202,
0.4663293659687042,
-0.48637357354164124,
0.15970751643180847,
0.19650863111019135,
-0.5455798506736755,
-0.5325300097465515,
0.02253430150449276,
-0.6894304752349854,
-0.9812124967575073,
-0.4186471104621887,
0.4132540822029114,
-0.2762795686721802,
-0.018118834123015404,
0.3637911081314087,
-0.09158296138048172,
0.2561803162097931,
0.4389144480228424,
-0.3355567455291748,
-0.07665633410215378,
0.7134910225868225,
0.4529860317707062,
-0.011619198136031628,
0.03633883222937584,
-0.35715219378471375,
-0.005198065657168627,
-0.5028295516967773,
0.6934998631477356,
-0.6728826761245728,
-0.27904394268989563,
-0.07278918474912643,
-0.11092174798250198,
-0.005468482151627541,
-0.5096665620803833,
1.142663836479187,
-0.6033913493156433,
0.32963860034942627,
-0.1755780577659607,
-0.38703763484954834,
-0.2929447591304779,
0.46112099289894104,
-0.6935517191886902,
0.6431443095207214,
0.007755324710160494,
-0.9812623858451843,
0.2933505177497864,
-0.5318860411643982,
-0.4242156445980072,
-0.13398978114128113,
-0.17924554646015167,
-0.5610458850860596,
0.16836877167224884,
0.4313376843929291,
0.3341478407382965,
-0.49935126304626465,
0.5466498136520386,
-0.02187892608344555,
-0.43971917033195496,
0.4712551236152649,
-0.9653582572937012,
0.6675313711166382,
0.3350241482257843,
-0.3543259799480438,
-0.0589551143348217,
-0.5333284139633179,
-0.40196695923805237,
0.19132883846759796,
-0.6329818964004517,
-0.3426077663898468,
-0.04265917092561722,
0.10532107949256897,
0.22676274180412292,
0.2617951035499573,
-0.4984298646450043,
-0.024073366075754166,
-0.11788543313741684,
0.2852776050567627,
0.6593804359436035,
-0.06327115744352341,
0.033290982246398926,
-0.5457640290260315,
0.39322564005851746,
0.3229517638683319,
0.2453494369983673,
-0.07204530388116837,
-0.4899180233478546,
-0.48127123713493347,
-0.24379198253154755,
0.47595295310020447,
0.5939282178878784,
-0.5957993865013123,
0.47801080346107483,
-0.46675345301628113,
-0.43644553422927856,
-0.7007878422737122,
-0.08862116187810898,
0.330674409866333,
0.5527278184890747,
0.15836675465106964,
0.21057267487049103,
-0.4902612566947937,
-1.159959077835083,
-1.0128213167190552,
-0.1319381147623062,
-0.03799367696046829,
0.2526126801967621,
0.39447346329689026,
-0.39939016103744507,
0.9482336640357971,
-0.0023436034098267555,
-0.013184592127799988,
-0.222859188914299,
0.27160507440567017,
0.2864733338356018,
0.12676289677619934,
0.41290220618247986,
-1.1799789667129517,
-0.18993635475635529,
-0.16203537583351135,
-0.6987332701683044,
-0.2047247439622879,
-0.3381537199020386,
0.42022705078125,
0.25471773743629456,
0.23185694217681885,
-0.7833315134048462,
0.26139089465141296,
0.5964279174804688,
-0.43763113021850586,
0.6695075035095215,
0.022547896951436996,
0.2887852191925049,
-0.9623457789421082,
-0.009220343083143234,
0.46214810013771057,
-0.41903257369995117,
-0.49321070313453674,
-0.2402721345424652,
0.2007315754890442,
0.08442550152540207,
-0.44663965702056885,
0.5153787136077881,
-0.44547539949417114,
-0.10534264892339706,
-0.30053845047950745,
0.2466694414615631,
0.02081323228776455,
-0.2604174315929413,
-0.19570712745189667,
0.6167353987693787,
0.3649965822696686,
-0.3889087438583374,
0.25512319803237915,
-0.06713047623634338,
-0.5303095579147339,
0.5702345967292786,
-0.5117955207824707,
-0.19030192494392395,
-0.48043254017829895,
0.4844370186328888,
-0.7558239698410034,
-0.4421285390853882,
0.3351568877696991,
-0.6856258511543274,
0.3315991163253784,
0.0834677442908287,
-0.9067179560661316,
-0.6472046375274658,
-0.22381655871868134,
0.1452929675579071,
0.5052218437194824,
-0.5012326240539551,
0.3510175943374634,
0.3842991292476654,
0.020245078951120377,
-0.7667496800422668,
-0.8554996848106384,
0.403595894575119,
-0.4650113582611084,
-0.4776938259601593,
-0.007863370701670647,
0.24744802713394165,
-0.5652799606323242,
-0.004360841121524572,
-0.27267640829086304,
0.008497104048728943,
0.21879687905311584,
0.04112911596894264,
0.44809481501579285,
-0.092568039894104,
0.22241057455539703,
-0.2689070999622345,
0.021823182702064514,
0.1093393862247467,
-0.0921514481306076,
0.322935551404953,
-0.09574782848358154,
-0.38198715448379517,
-0.7787476181983948,
0.07847721874713898,
0.9136673212051392,
-0.23306351900100708,
0.8731367588043213,
0.7175125479698181,
-0.49003905057907104,
0.17225779592990875,
-0.9399917125701904,
-0.10750356316566467,
-0.3993664085865021,
0.4727860689163208,
0.27641481161117554,
-0.7697464823722839,
0.14724701642990112,
-0.011345676146447659,
-0.07578222453594208,
0.5656057000160217,
0.41147688031196594,
0.10474108159542084,
1.046667218208313,
0.5997961759567261,
-0.4403873682022095,
0.20198632776737213,
0.20474812388420105,
0.5898493528366089,
-0.5918557643890381,
-0.2685256898403168,
-0.47837141156196594,
-0.11628943681716919,
-0.5690181851387024,
-0.37878119945526123,
0.40414053201675415,
0.02661709673702717,
-0.20154604315757751,
-0.1014949306845665,
-0.48596417903900146,
0.4904544949531555,
0.33039751648902893,
0.1539534479379654,
0.6377009153366089,
0.05209100991487503,
0.3670988380908966,
-0.023443175479769707,
-0.39026373624801636,
-0.8968876004219055,
1.0084035396575928,
0.7550908923149109,
0.9955521821975708,
-0.007876555435359478,
0.35512223839759827,
0.5857119560241699,
0.5524749159812927,
-0.8045536279678345,
0.27349787950515747,
-0.0665912926197052,
-0.8048235774040222,
-0.07770024985074997,
-0.5612101554870605,
-0.8947701454162598,
0.12958493828773499,
-0.2523537278175354,
-0.8120371699333191,
-0.11462973058223724,
-0.12963007390499115,
-0.5024462342262268,
0.346892774105072,
-0.6618546843528748,
0.5045945048332214,
-0.5243765115737915,
-0.09531966596841812,
-0.29746657609939575,
-0.5536141991615295,
0.6795015931129456,
-0.4048433005809784,
0.7167931199073792,
-0.26477041840553284,
-0.18993210792541504,
0.616511881351471,
0.39884239435195923,
1.015849232673645,
0.1349792629480362,
-0.3350478708744049,
0.1446586549282074,
-0.2955755293369293,
0.6521459817886353,
0.07313238829374313,
-0.18111319839954376,
0.38514000177383423,
-0.3656978905200958,
-0.2245972603559494,
-0.13166597485542297,
0.6260416507720947,
-0.7390559911727905,
-0.6967816352844238,
-0.5612366199493408,
-0.7434586882591248,
-0.19339407980442047,
0.34403446316719055,
0.16870370507240295,
0.08128774911165237,
-0.021010207012295723,
0.2518649995326996,
0.5935264825820923,
-0.539812445640564,
0.2054789960384369,
0.7865944504737854,
-0.19224011898040771,
0.07204785943031311,
0.7045817971229553,
0.06813707202672958,
0.0028051931876689196,
0.2227497696876526,
0.2508432865142822,
-0.24919097125530243,
-0.6516198515892029,
-0.25941118597984314,
0.4478858709335327,
-0.5704033970832825,
-0.205117866396904,
-0.5557759404182434,
-0.4701646864414215,
-0.24221639335155487,
0.07706263661384583,
-0.4236602187156677,
-0.0016285688616335392,
-0.35735586285591125,
-0.11319427937269211,
0.08828571438789368,
0.861912190914154,
0.09583338350057602,
0.41298261284828186,
-0.8031543493270874,
0.3715876340866089,
-0.0939846783876419,
0.1777409166097641,
-0.31259357929229736,
-0.48934608697891235,
-0.17795763909816742,
0.4224091172218323,
-0.47674795985221863,
-0.8188381791114807,
0.26285359263420105,
-0.36149996519088745,
0.820732057094574,
0.49019286036491394,
-0.04016152769327164,
0.29114454984664917,
-0.33324286341667175,
0.8892781734466553,
0.2735382616519928,
-0.7713607549667358,
0.27643582224845886,
-0.6912175416946411,
0.03514331206679344,
0.1948109269142151,
0.7278696894645691,
-0.436694473028183,
-0.43563178181648254,
-0.5989328622817993,
-0.6630223989486694,
0.4816938042640686,
0.15691906213760376,
0.21878866851329803,
-0.13817645609378815,
0.3332660496234894,
0.12800031900405884,
0.4639647603034973,
-1.0459932088851929,
-0.14851614832878113,
0.22887568175792694,
-0.2876940667629242,
0.04520348832011223,
-0.4195463955402374,
-0.06840018182992935,
0.11473696678876877,
0.5657473206520081,
0.1119459867477417,
0.28517693281173706,
0.1494218111038208,
-0.048272039741277695,
-0.13378357887268066,
0.5154709815979004,
0.7281904220581055,
0.8432996869087219,
0.17916905879974365,
0.016406966373324394,
-0.15562547743320465,
-0.43550625443458557,
-0.015586921013891697,
0.2278841882944107,
-0.11053230613470078,
0.045871101319789886,
0.5467234253883362,
0.537723183631897,
0.24720971286296844,
-0.7758583426475525,
0.7818936109542847,
0.05656331032514572,
0.11868472397327423,
-0.30857333540916443,
-0.22938357293605804,
0.23745813965797424,
0.42973265051841736,
0.6015734672546387,
0.20652048289775848,
0.24204258620738983,
-0.672519326210022,
-0.02706698514521122,
0.5694902539253235,
-0.10016681998968124,
-0.10300669819116592,
0.6693055629730225,
0.11299261450767517,
-0.16128161549568176,
0.6612313389778137,
0.014827368780970573,
-0.54152911901474,
0.6137763857841492,
0.45648524165153503,
0.5448907017707825,
-0.38158711791038513,
0.2472776621580124,
0.1086522564291954,
0.775627076625824,
-0.561021089553833,
0.024617457762360573,
0.5277810096740723,
-0.861645519733429,
-0.38253000378608704,
-0.6672403812408447,
-0.14917904138565063,
0.4516275227069855,
-0.32463201880455017,
0.30217230319976807,
-0.18264786899089813,
-0.36004704236984253,
0.16974176466464996,
-0.16630053520202637,
-0.48685765266418457,
0.1782844513654709,
0.6541807651519775,
1.003647804260254,
-0.822052538394928,
0.593860387802124,
0.5128013491630554,
-0.15563364326953888,
-0.6810901761054993,
0.5034582614898682,
0.37006261944770813,
-0.7522216439247131,
0.4855131506919861,
0.4245423674583435,
0.08558708429336548,
-0.15022984147071838,
-0.7918182015419006,
-0.7911651730537415,
0.930474042892456,
0.6608465909957886,
-0.7742924690246582,
-0.36727309226989746,
0.31884652376174927,
0.3963070511817932,
-0.2959282398223877,
0.14239554107189178,
0.6492347717285156,
0.87363600730896,
0.07980899512767792,
-1.399489164352417,
-0.0941946730017662,
0.18925096094608307,
-0.1417066901922226,
0.0579206682741642,
-0.6903192400932312,
0.8589508533477783,
-0.37365150451660156,
-0.15264882147312164,
-0.09238032251596451,
0.331712543964386,
0.21980702877044678,
0.4224775433540344,
0.3716408908367157,
0.42785388231277466,
0.9416515231132507,
-0.12274287641048431,
1.329079508781433,
-0.1721707433462143,
0.3592066466808319,
0.7627834677696228,
-0.022448573261499405,
0.49894097447395325,
0.3836952745914459,
-0.05667007714509964,
0.38770610094070435,
0.8112544417381287,
-0.09664690494537354,
0.30560746788978577,
0.22708675265312195,
-0.07556936144828796,
-0.3118225932121277,
-0.3398763835430145,
-0.14480958878993988,
0.5421850085258484,
0.7473879456520081,
-0.6495566368103027,
-0.4158098101615906,
0.019522467628121376,
0.5006842613220215,
-0.0058310627937316895,
-0.6143090128898621,
0.2312915176153183,
0.22253264486789703,
-0.5976704955101013,
0.432345986366272,
0.2783573269844055,
0.8418704867362976,
-0.36386075615882874,
0.15732651948928833,
0.14323857426643372,
0.117180734872818,
-0.3616310954093933,
-0.7941262125968933,
0.22089411318302155,
-0.007299104705452919,
-0.11893250048160553,
0.1347714066505432,
0.7803441286087036,
-0.35317498445510864,
-0.6495745182037354,
0.14640958607196808,
0.4449872672557831,
0.042788002640008926,
-0.25046345591545105,
-0.7284726500511169,
0.40087229013442993,
0.10292159765958786,
-0.31004494428634644,
0.058767154812812805,
0.22342590987682343,
-0.23736852407455444,
0.8963928818702698,
0.5989118814468384,
0.03685103729367256,
-0.002434918424114585,
-0.08592936396598816,
0.6390542984008789,
-0.63594651222229,
-0.4646928608417511,
-1.019501805305481,
0.3891858160495758,
-0.28958433866500854,
-0.030612075701355934,
0.9424964785575867,
0.5204340815544128,
0.40491029620170593,
0.02168378420174122,
0.9695131778717041,
0.19182905554771423,
0.5895369052886963,
-0.6339879631996155,
0.7439966797828674,
-0.4368710517883301,
0.5824670791625977,
-0.10531546175479889,
-0.7496688365936279,
-0.35316792130470276,
0.4153338670730591,
-0.6582979559898376,
0.4074763357639313,
0.5019775629043579,
0.5240874290466309,
-0.09970200061798096,
0.2587989568710327,
0.30539166927337646,
0.5713213682174683,
0.25990816950798035,
0.41486629843711853,
1.0731157064437866,
-0.16772136092185974,
0.4093779921531677,
0.2224365770816803,
-0.23953372240066528,
-0.5689902901649475,
-1.0152547359466553,
-0.9398072361946106,
-0.0786956250667572,
-0.27443569898605347,
-0.2330693155527115,
0.28119197487831116,
0.8867045640945435,
0.5420143604278564,
-0.29429811239242554,
0.21396327018737793,
0.15467165410518646,
0.15241119265556335,
0.07681064307689667,
-0.30486470460891724,
0.24808070063591003,
-0.1647036075592041,
-0.7608786225318909,
0.37515315413475037,
0.2672087550163269,
0.022738678380846977,
-0.3393954336643219,
0.11079005897045135,
-0.0898437649011612,
0.4009840786457062,
0.5198519229888916,
0.026868000626564026,
-1.013985276222229,
-0.39051949977874756,
-0.2786175310611725,
-0.46138060092926025,
-0.15399296581745148,
0.6474759578704834,
-0.77105712890625,
0.032047610729932785,
-0.06338399648666382,
0.7720341682434082,
0.01249088067561388,
0.31341877579689026,
0.4388016164302826,
-0.5293876528739929,
0.02805979549884796,
0.35375189781188965,
0.26497429609298706,
0.7169287204742432,
-0.7889606952667236,
0.3514406383037567,
0.07716549187898636,
-0.6151642799377441,
-0.8789270520210266,
0.012523515149950981,
-0.89912348985672,
-0.2867305278778076,
1.466949701309204,
0.1950242519378662,
-0.22446903586387634,
-0.2616724669933319,
-0.20722632110118866,
0.11545970290899277,
-0.43961194157600403,
1.0174810886383057,
0.7454596161842346,
0.013797963038086891,
-0.12259801477193832,
-1.0204368829727173,
0.3758333921432495,
-0.011157214641571045,
-0.7881991267204285,
0.021954962983727455,
0.5556384325027466,
0.4095193147659302,
0.27279701828956604,
0.2826289236545563,
-0.3957539498806,
0.3020455539226532,
-0.2345070093870163,
-0.1719496250152588,
-0.019162414595484734,
-0.24066253006458282,
-0.23769105970859528,
-0.23677441477775574,
0.040797021239995956,
-0.0013734981184825301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03146v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03146v2
|
Quantifying the Capabilities of LLMs across Scale and Precision
| 2024-05-06T03:42:34 | 2024-05-08T02:10:36 |
Sher Badshah, Hassan Sajjad
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Scale is often attributed as one of the factors that cause an increase in the
performance of LLMs, resulting in models with billion and trillion parameters.
One of the limitations of such large models is the high computational
requirements that limit their usage, deployment, and debugging in
resource-constrained scenarios. Two commonly used alternatives to bypass these
limitations are to use the smaller versions of LLMs (e.g. Llama 7B instead of
Llama 70B) and lower the memory requirements by using quantization. While these
approaches effectively address the limitation of resources, their impact on
model performance needs thorough examination. In this study, we perform a
comprehensive evaluation to investigate the effect of model scale and
quantization on the performance. We experiment with two major families of
open-source instruct models ranging from 7 billion to 70 billion parameters.
Our extensive zero-shot experiments across various tasks including natural
language understanding, reasoning, misinformation detection, and hallucination
reveal that larger models generally outperform their smaller counterparts,
suggesting that scale remains an important factor in enhancing performance. We
found that larger models show exceptional resilience to precision reduction and
can maintain high accuracy even at 4-bit quantization for numerous tasks and
they serve as a better solution than using smaller models at high precision
under similar memory requirements.
|
[
-0.5168793797492981,
-0.5956942439079285,
0.6889381408691406,
0.23725645244121552,
-0.27251434326171875,
-0.17070631682872772,
-0.28108546137809753,
-0.537202000617981,
-0.133736714720726,
0.416352242231369,
-0.03927856683731079,
-0.26268526911735535,
-0.6558622121810913,
0.2641220688819885,
-0.3335135281085968,
0.6514993906021118,
-0.09015343338251114,
0.1349077969789505,
-0.529576301574707,
-0.30830058455467224,
-0.4781140983104706,
-0.6523433923721313,
-0.4471951127052307,
-0.23957639932632446,
0.5207036733627319,
0.3786804676055908,
0.8460610508918762,
0.9835546016693115,
1.1082537174224854,
0.31486374139785767,
-0.34796836972236633,
0.03049144335091114,
-0.3716079890727997,
0.07500550150871277,
-0.11955300718545914,
-0.8166446685791016,
-0.7502397298812866,
-0.0181944090873003,
1.0856479406356812,
0.6262349486351013,
-0.08200234174728394,
0.7014915347099304,
-0.03611733764410019,
0.588667094707489,
-0.816643238067627,
0.11016274243593216,
-0.43777748942375183,
-0.08617160469293594,
-0.11876384168863297,
0.22026604413986206,
-0.2006000131368637,
-0.3926006257534027,
-0.1626066416501999,
-0.6579017639160156,
0.11915042251348495,
0.12813670933246613,
0.6337980031967163,
0.5681736469268799,
-0.4501035809516907,
-0.13846898078918457,
-1.0274479389190674,
0.9782205820083618,
-1.008186936378479,
0.20345664024353027,
0.20447802543640137,
0.34789881110191345,
0.20361579954624176,
-0.6890789866447449,
-0.09517043083906174,
-0.22251422703266144,
0.07615118473768234,
-0.331643670797348,
-0.41871553659439087,
0.1373727172613144,
0.7124346494674683,
0.673347532749176,
-0.4107527732849121,
0.4073008894920349,
-0.5952428579330444,
-0.14881755411624908,
0.4884088337421417,
0.5127944350242615,
-0.06960257887840271,
-0.09502283483743668,
-0.05178464949131012,
-0.2027471959590912,
-0.6814417839050293,
-0.05568254366517067,
0.045700155198574066,
0.3222939968109131,
0.1003255546092987,
0.6235678791999817,
-0.29312393069267273,
0.7005838751792908,
0.029525987803936005,
-0.3641399145126343,
-0.3340238928794861,
-0.3042072653770447,
-0.5392946004867554,
-0.21262803673744202,
0.5995147824287415,
0.17389318346977234,
0.037756383419036865,
-0.051430750638246536,
-0.12853683531284332,
-0.04259789362549782,
0.4708198010921478,
-1.2206207513809204,
0.1144278272986412,
0.13365598022937775,
-0.6415798664093018,
-0.22691717743873596,
-0.39681920409202576,
-0.4036187529563904,
-0.4853491187095642,
-0.2835331857204437,
0.7612237930297852,
-0.3096611201763153,
-0.20490822196006775,
0.04007349908351898,
-0.010924622416496277,
0.06685322523117065,
0.3542964458465576,
-0.7843369245529175,
0.29904165863990784,
0.766321063041687,
1.1437010765075684,
0.056613728404045105,
0.21055737137794495,
-0.277510404586792,
0.05610223114490509,
-0.5177367925643921,
0.4296301305294037,
-0.3416074812412262,
-0.6447438597679138,
-0.6584545373916626,
-0.43152379989624023,
0.30759352445602417,
-0.98490971326828,
0.24120663106441498,
-0.5554540157318115,
-0.5333170294761658,
-0.4591236710548401,
-0.6067851185798645,
-0.2972801625728607,
0.2611047327518463,
-1.0179733037948608,
0.7381760478019714,
0.2650218605995178,
-0.43061545491218567,
0.4059965908527374,
-0.4724370241165161,
-0.004463277757167816,
-0.0014815343311056495,
-0.03383571654558182,
-0.4602503776550293,
0.7904672026634216,
0.1073606014251709,
0.49959585070610046,
-0.7100136280059814,
0.09495841711759567,
-0.4445391595363617,
-0.5417572855949402,
0.21670104563236237,
-0.5811390280723572,
0.3472324311733246,
0.1970507800579071,
-0.06158636137843132,
0.07428321242332458,
-0.9021440744400024,
0.1657446175813675,
0.02575494721531868,
-0.3720415532588959,
-0.3071487843990326,
-0.2013365477323532,
-0.4749011993408203,
-0.1328011155128479,
0.4519101679325104,
-0.2379603236913681,
0.15144729614257812,
-0.2981864809989929,
0.6874630451202393,
0.6076582074165344,
-0.06296666711568832,
0.6029647588729858,
-0.39549267292022705,
0.7296925187110901,
-0.14742890000343323,
0.3291945457458496,
-0.1239498034119606,
-0.2578749656677246,
-0.6327825784683228,
-0.5680202841758728,
0.5655116438865662,
0.27409347891807556,
-0.26586297154426575,
-0.047052402049303055,
-0.4250815212726593,
-0.5535457730293274,
-0.34239742159843445,
0.16818396747112274,
0.34209582209587097,
0.19431966543197632,
0.21500451862812042,
-0.33490127325057983,
-0.29996299743652344,
-1.092910885810852,
-0.0928168073296547,
-0.27707865834236145,
-0.6063957810401917,
0.21588683128356934,
0.5519564747810364,
0.12078503519296646,
0.9009273648262024,
-0.28914719820022583,
-0.02177664451301098,
0.07691508531570435,
0.04249727725982666,
0.12164627015590668,
0.2293829470872879,
0.35715728998184204,
-0.6426364183425903,
-0.1264830231666565,
-0.02246292307972908,
-0.7260218858718872,
-0.07742824405431747,
0.04371780529618263,
0.24245403707027435,
0.1678064912557602,
0.3641586899757385,
-0.5085169076919556,
0.4945061206817627,
0.6230348348617554,
0.06366555392742157,
0.5559625029563904,
-0.4181540608406067,
0.11855725944042206,
-0.8161166310310364,
0.02479064278304577,
0.1507631093263626,
-0.10204537212848663,
-0.46998438239097595,
0.26469019055366516,
0.44654202461242676,
0.11147964745759964,
-0.3181578516960144,
0.24803300201892853,
-0.43475162982940674,
-0.4826318919658661,
-0.09805894643068314,
-0.0623844638466835,
0.22068580985069275,
0.025753971189260483,
-0.10840745270252228,
1.0410078763961792,
0.1136263757944107,
-0.6429504156112671,
0.284425288438797,
-0.2529389262199402,
-0.40729889273643494,
0.7623063325881958,
-0.9712169170379639,
-0.12623992562294006,
0.20508097112178802,
-0.09284515678882599,
-0.9244529604911804,
-0.09613024443387985,
-0.32607507705688477,
-0.28263452649116516,
0.22984248399734497,
0.00036647915840148926,
-0.8501026630401611,
-0.2528165876865387,
-0.3813885450363159,
0.5694845914840698,
0.5387407541275024,
-0.31262752413749695,
0.6427752375602722,
-0.09181604534387589,
0.21151413023471832,
-0.06668169796466827,
-0.6970818638801575,
0.004152846522629261,
-0.6391306519508362,
-0.7146843075752258,
0.22181960940361023,
-0.08444317430257797,
-0.6864565014839172,
-0.1906765252351761,
-0.3732123076915741,
0.007119846995919943,
0.22756633162498474,
0.46105214953422546,
0.25143101811408997,
-0.39372068643569946,
0.3928596079349518,
-0.012338663451373577,
-0.013136904686689377,
0.1784726083278656,
-0.037544071674346924,
0.30949780344963074,
-0.5193415284156799,
-0.3888147473335266,
-0.3540708124637604,
-0.04334411025047302,
0.7771223187446594,
-0.2630665600299835,
0.9000993371009827,
0.4422113299369812,
-0.3318197727203369,
-0.09314890205860138,
-0.5849673748016357,
-0.2603248357772827,
-0.5152324438095093,
0.2800567150115967,
-0.39700594544410706,
-0.9556487202644348,
0.7017159461975098,
-0.37900829315185547,
-0.17700760066509247,
0.3905225098133087,
0.49677926301956177,
0.11102128028869629,
0.8179517984390259,
0.5064948201179504,
-0.038841478526592255,
0.10706700384616852,
-0.31826168298721313,
0.13197992742061615,
-1.071427822113037,
-0.011840521357953548,
-0.4611629545688629,
-0.5058068633079529,
-0.6176259517669678,
-0.8145524263381958,
0.6479731798171997,
0.4365537464618683,
-0.5827049016952515,
0.24851374328136444,
-0.6057630777359009,
0.35625365376472473,
0.5290789604187012,
0.12300474941730499,
0.6395524740219116,
-0.014893618412315845,
0.343711256980896,
-0.173599973320961,
-0.659398078918457,
-0.8402745127677917,
1.4291874170303345,
0.5487633943557739,
0.778192937374115,
0.2569950520992279,
0.5105921030044556,
0.1652573049068451,
0.3376066982746124,
-0.8210826516151428,
0.6061888933181763,
-0.23060739040374756,
-0.5741034746170044,
-0.6857032775878906,
-0.6714870929718018,
-0.6554065346717834,
0.48156389594078064,
0.0015183178475126624,
-0.48935291171073914,
-0.024189574643969536,
0.026333866640925407,
-0.736032247543335,
0.557895302772522,
-0.6409485340118408,
0.5292034149169922,
-0.14422044157981873,
-0.15908057987689972,
-0.4066320061683655,
-0.364383339881897,
0.35292255878448486,
-0.3524734079837799,
0.3189244270324707,
-0.13981926441192627,
-0.5628832578659058,
0.5671640038490295,
-0.40869128704071045,
0.8987096548080444,
0.264158695936203,
-0.38747161626815796,
0.2981136739253998,
0.363314151763916,
0.37128081917762756,
0.1591804325580597,
-0.3241802453994751,
0.6181342005729675,
0.21195261180400848,
-0.328708678483963,
-0.6007146835327148,
0.7352988719940186,
-0.8228760361671448,
-0.7348769903182983,
0.014573492109775543,
-0.8824304938316345,
-0.18381139636039734,
-0.011587000451982021,
0.13785043358802795,
0.31856775283813477,
-0.01983708329498768,
0.4798213541507721,
0.8447991013526917,
-0.1485917717218399,
0.475945383310318,
0.5191895961761475,
-0.1334565132856369,
-0.3976544439792633,
0.7070106267929077,
0.642350435256958,
0.7243504524230957,
0.37697041034698486,
0.2101549357175827,
0.0633503645658493,
-0.8521894216537476,
-0.38449326157569885,
0.28047099709510803,
-0.4616403877735138,
-0.4527018368244171,
-0.1592034250497818,
-0.09512189775705338,
-0.23632848262786865,
-0.10440926998853683,
-0.4254077970981598,
-0.6855067610740662,
-0.634415328502655,
-0.048235934227705,
0.5233725309371948,
0.7081868052482605,
-0.23278743028640747,
0.5678742527961731,
-0.7018658518791199,
0.28233861923217773,
0.3518246114253998,
0.416622519493103,
0.1613895446062088,
-0.7480960488319397,
-0.4525061845779419,
0.07320858538150787,
-0.4199342727661133,
-0.5750526785850525,
0.2744346261024475,
-0.07006537914276123,
0.2009875774383545,
0.37971067428588867,
-0.04941354691982269,
0.7535997033119202,
-0.271974116563797,
0.6802466511726379,
-0.06559735536575317,
-1.1032127141952515,
0.5406904220581055,
-0.33251720666885376,
0.5310328006744385,
0.17436771094799042,
0.3494684100151062,
-0.15945450961589813,
-0.18344782292842865,
-0.4859531819820404,
-0.6455276608467102,
0.5194146037101746,
0.1794956922531128,
-0.141282856464386,
0.34386351704597473,
0.8216254115104675,
-0.10859350860118866,
0.2673768103122711,
-0.402677446603775,
-0.003301173448562622,
0.24719639122486115,
0.10723193734884262,
-0.10236141830682755,
-0.3898453116416931,
0.015381942503154278,
-0.17853431403636932,
0.2945384979248047,
0.05968519672751427,
-0.030201977118849754,
-0.10717902332544327,
0.10440138727426529,
-0.16337765753269196,
0.04842954874038696,
0.5619416832923889,
0.7504329085350037,
-0.26086288690567017,
0.011946205049753189,
0.614177942276001,
-0.32306554913520813,
0.10987728834152222,
-0.3749120235443115,
0.01725296676158905,
-0.3271738588809967,
0.5574817657470703,
0.628708004951477,
0.13974539935588837,
-0.5870028734207153,
0.04493549093604088,
0.09132955968379974,
-0.14613276720046997,
0.006033509038388729,
0.22415557503700256,
0.22367405891418457,
0.6020482778549194,
0.12776845693588257,
-0.18683642148971558,
0.12683479487895966,
-0.21119330823421478,
-0.19544902443885803,
0.5681571364402771,
0.10839902609586716,
-0.12808413803577423,
0.6488919854164124,
-0.1385897994041443,
-0.26968929171562195,
0.6984402537345886,
0.018124651163816452,
0.02273348905146122,
1.1806600093841553,
0.2764531373977661,
0.4820438325405121,
-0.24806568026542664,
0.06229622662067413,
0.4169996678829193,
0.5687772631645203,
-0.40853047370910645,
-0.1252446472644806,
-0.12142873555421829,
-0.40634211897850037,
-0.6167041659355164,
-0.6436846852302551,
-0.6462918519973755,
0.08327720314264297,
-0.95960932970047,
-0.0012635275488719344,
-0.846024215221405,
-0.5955862998962402,
-0.1332990676164627,
0.17463243007659912,
-0.4712570607662201,
0.19314484298229218,
0.18428300321102142,
0.7792925238609314,
-0.5024043917655945,
0.5442215204238892,
0.524241030216217,
-0.3638249933719635,
-0.9213743209838867,
-0.37907150387763977,
0.011545722372829914,
-0.7529690265655518,
0.770142674446106,
0.009985038079321384,
0.0217951200902462,
-0.0606299452483654,
-0.38685163855552673,
-1.195459008216858,
1.4956774711608887,
0.5409175157546997,
-0.7400210499763489,
-0.10165244340896606,
0.46987664699554443,
0.7476155161857605,
-0.13361553847789764,
0.29495325684547424,
0.6530580520629883,
0.3483488857746124,
0.14119532704353333,
-1.3840283155441284,
0.22612565755844116,
0.4237477481365204,
0.6636374592781067,
0.45281878113746643,
-0.9321736097335815,
1.2247300148010254,
-0.3034099042415619,
-0.05190914869308472,
0.17049847543239594,
0.4968505799770355,
0.4529462456703186,
0.1705479919910431,
0.18405461311340332,
0.71195387840271,
0.7072214484214783,
0.02292460761964321,
0.9089780449867249,
-0.2642456591129303,
0.33463844656944275,
0.8373612761497498,
-0.2949000298976898,
0.9526365995407104,
0.5166824460029602,
-0.5400108695030212,
0.1434839367866516,
0.5668914914131165,
-0.046143002808094025,
0.025474075227975845,
0.5630024671554565,
-0.376953125,
-0.322346955537796,
-0.02937437780201435,
-0.21242235600948334,
0.26178762316703796,
0.4867520332336426,
-0.35562339425086975,
-0.141940638422966,
0.12046567350625992,
0.010694841854274273,
-0.03132705017924309,
-0.7264285087585449,
0.5052870512008667,
0.13161969184875488,
-0.061847202479839325,
0.7007611989974976,
0.07355568557977676,
0.6074296832084656,
-0.39934730529785156,
0.08731250464916229,
-0.26716509461402893,
0.25215789675712585,
-0.12200836092233658,
-0.44109147787094116,
0.4693896770477295,
-0.004478096961975098,
-0.28827062249183655,
-0.12494657933712006,
0.5982011556625366,
0.2096184641122818,
-0.7265793681144714,
0.10506200045347214,
0.3540302813053131,
0.12613818049430847,
-0.5630406737327576,
-0.1664164662361145,
0.4917188286781311,
-0.32944267988204956,
-0.3472778797149658,
0.6055939793586731,
0.7396103739738464,
-0.33691737055778503,
0.9514222145080566,
0.33641496300697327,
0.25359946489334106,
0.07342458516359329,
-0.20759542286396027,
0.7139285206794739,
-0.5976695418357849,
0.11424870043992996,
-1.069277048110962,
0.1643938273191452,
0.14663274586200714,
0.01136329211294651,
0.9782917499542236,
0.5037285685539246,
0.7401187419891357,
0.08689458668231964,
0.4576840102672577,
0.14552846550941467,
0.2354220747947693,
-0.18474991619586945,
0.403100848197937,
-0.6445934772491455,
0.570293128490448,
0.11414062976837158,
-0.909786581993103,
-0.38428741693496704,
0.5057273507118225,
-0.4819944202899933,
0.1365550309419632,
0.3732511103153229,
0.7207757234573364,
0.2564723491668701,
-0.10261592268943787,
0.7836797833442688,
0.053672198206186295,
0.272722065448761,
0.6896921992301941,
0.6516329050064087,
-0.335573673248291,
0.6829271912574768,
-0.3199895918369293,
-0.2793847620487213,
-0.22844603657722473,
-0.9060083031654358,
-0.8966824412345886,
-0.31020358204841614,
-0.3612958490848541,
-0.1152212992310524,
-0.2549508213996887,
0.3500896990299225,
0.8088000416755676,
-0.40839412808418274,
-0.34597253799438477,
0.09545478969812393,
0.024070238694548607,
-0.0039146956987679005,
-0.15248450636863708,
0.10616067051887512,
-0.22727783024311066,
-0.5482642650604248,
0.014577630907297134,
0.4190651774406433,
0.23560981452465057,
-0.7120340466499329,
0.19127342104911804,
0.3657853603363037,
0.4058615565299988,
0.7671120762825012,
0.06133069843053818,
-0.7142691016197205,
-0.21796853840351105,
0.13428747653961182,
-0.10176263749599457,
-0.05732208117842674,
0.7571359872817993,
-0.7392784357070923,
0.19580267369747162,
0.33671268820762634,
0.3869055509567261,
0.5103549957275391,
0.04978920519351959,
0.3397190570831299,
-0.42301997542381287,
0.026989253237843513,
0.16337470710277557,
-0.00969127006828785,
0.1181803047657013,
-0.45371899008750916,
0.669883668422699,
-0.06850304454565048,
-0.7649126052856445,
-0.9421618580818176,
0.09847360104322433,
-0.7133296728134155,
-0.4032859802246094,
1.0575042963027954,
0.011430329643189907,
-0.01443745568394661,
0.4722345173358917,
-0.08155247569084167,
0.10298715531826019,
-0.12374184280633926,
0.7535841464996338,
0.898560106754303,
-0.2618517577648163,
-0.1617276519536972,
-0.7870737314224243,
0.1145300343632698,
0.3191100060939789,
-0.6371765732765198,
0.06202048435807228,
0.5711784958839417,
0.23389284312725067,
0.2448672205209732,
0.34629106521606445,
-0.11352654546499252,
0.026186691597104073,
0.18507951498031616,
0.028341144323349,
-0.12570154666900635,
-0.13427789509296417,
-0.6838759779930115,
0.38829487562179565,
0.39740803837776184,
-0.0905262902379036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03138v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03138v1
|
CRAFT: Extracting and Tuning Cultural Instructions from the Wild
| 2024-05-06T03:21:55 | 2024-05-06T03:21:55 |
Bin Wang, Geyu Lin, Zhengyuan Liu, Chengwei Wei, Nancy F. Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have rapidly evolved as the foundation of
various natural language processing (NLP) applications. Despite their wide use
cases, their understanding of culturally-related concepts and reasoning remains
limited. Meantime, there is a significant need to enhance these models'
cultural reasoning capabilities, especially concerning underrepresented
regions. This paper introduces a novel pipeline for extracting high-quality,
culturally-related instruction tuning datasets from vast unstructured corpora.
We utilize a self-instruction generation pipeline to identify cultural concepts
and trigger instruction. By integrating with a general-purpose instruction
tuning dataset, our model demonstrates enhanced capabilities in recognizing and
understanding regional cultural nuances, thereby enhancing its reasoning
capabilities. We conduct experiments across three regions: Singapore, the
Philippines, and the United States, achieving performance improvement of up to
6%. Our research opens new avenues for extracting cultural instruction tuning
sets directly from unstructured data, setting a precedent for future
innovations in the field.
|
[
-0.09525102376937866,
-0.5177271366119385,
0.2660796046257019,
0.21988412737846375,
-0.3109695613384247,
0.3399212658405304,
-0.6731675267219543,
-0.13825279474258423,
0.10873828083276749,
0.9932050704956055,
-0.9235200881958008,
-0.9580519199371338,
-0.3277897238731384,
-0.07735292613506317,
-0.18367792665958405,
0.8326855301856995,
0.11660035699605942,
-0.04007269814610481,
0.11619037389755249,
-0.00840341579169035,
-0.6241689920425415,
-0.3403465449810028,
-0.2212660312652588,
-0.08311405777931213,
-0.04327229782938957,
0.9192364811897278,
0.4502628743648529,
1.2095072269439697,
0.3982710540294647,
0.3519514203071594,
0.07310257852077484,
0.7027526497840881,
-0.47725576162338257,
0.19192713499069214,
-0.38621264696121216,
-0.5146002769470215,
-0.2531608045101166,
0.10878206044435501,
0.4571813642978668,
0.6078135371208191,
-0.2566586136817932,
0.5140159130096436,
-0.10365952551364899,
0.6015839576721191,
-0.5406581163406372,
0.15274330973625183,
-0.9630596041679382,
0.2007986307144165,
-0.34548133611679077,
-0.6360005140304565,
-0.4532910883426666,
-0.36059296131134033,
0.07629801332950592,
-0.5614491701126099,
0.5310299396514893,
-0.042312465608119965,
0.44416728615760803,
0.46477827429771423,
-0.4164791405200958,
-0.4483298659324646,
-0.6389219760894775,
0.986171305179596,
-0.538286566734314,
0.139308363199234,
0.5208140015602112,
0.10754984617233276,
-0.3977257311344147,
-0.7229540944099426,
-0.0644640401005745,
0.3105432689189911,
0.03207032009959221,
0.10361828655004501,
0.11188602447509766,
-0.1535719335079193,
0.2598099708557129,
0.6545916199684143,
-0.4823560416698456,
0.522975742816925,
-0.6822787523269653,
-0.3066592216491699,
0.828147292137146,
0.2853968143463135,
0.3744010925292969,
-0.25333890318870544,
-0.15871131420135498,
-0.023293521255254745,
-0.7692610621452332,
0.10776661336421967,
0.26555269956588745,
0.36632537841796875,
-0.3196265697479248,
0.43551433086395264,
-0.29185751080513,
0.8169042468070984,
-0.004884498193860054,
-0.2712545692920685,
-0.04533456265926361,
-0.11405745148658752,
-0.23381224274635315,
0.04869300499558449,
0.46079474687576294,
0.3418797254562378,
0.34608474373817444,
-0.28535178303718567,
-0.01565028913319111,
-0.1012314036488533,
0.14256788790225983,
-0.6924057006835938,
-0.4670567512512207,
-0.011682895012199879,
-0.4823627471923828,
-0.09914737194776535,
-0.008265256881713867,
-0.8724486231803894,
-0.4209889769554138,
-0.571174144744873,
-0.23672990500926971,
-0.2596711814403534,
-0.09306850284337997,
-0.054820142686367035,
-0.17716506123542786,
0.5638414025306702,
-0.006954560987651348,
-1.4154033660888672,
-0.17777612805366516,
0.840168833732605,
0.7388039827346802,
-0.29857152700424194,
-0.1577182114124298,
-0.42354369163513184,
0.20309528708457947,
-0.5944386124610901,
0.7354011535644531,
-0.8851660490036011,
-0.5308699607849121,
0.08042946457862854,
0.33617308735847473,
0.08508027344942093,
-0.6274204850196838,
0.6579256057739258,
-0.5001461505889893,
0.18155233561992645,
-0.3153350353240967,
-0.4003395438194275,
0.0021036311518400908,
-0.12772198021411896,
-0.4122556746006012,
1.036077857017517,
0.03804773837327957,
-0.2608358561992645,
0.38310831785202026,
-0.7008628249168396,
-0.6100879907608032,
0.2251598984003067,
-0.1425475925207138,
0.033355653285980225,
0.2685844898223877,
0.6705693602561951,
0.4838801920413971,
-0.4038870930671692,
0.08209029585123062,
-0.1994311511516571,
-0.6971786022186279,
0.004788460209965706,
-0.5944585204124451,
0.8857339024543762,
0.47001945972442627,
-0.3673107326030731,
0.005026685073971748,
-0.8934492468833923,
0.3371813893318176,
-0.015343285165727139,
-0.4332660734653473,
-0.42152106761932373,
-0.15657837688922882,
-0.4843011498451233,
0.06652284413576126,
0.203959122300148,
-0.408582478761673,
0.43956854939460754,
-0.37555810809135437,
0.7391467094421387,
0.871641993522644,
-0.06902588158845901,
0.8242432475090027,
0.1385599821805954,
0.7071356177330017,
-0.16931864619255066,
0.05773894861340523,
-0.49022436141967773,
-0.1716037392616272,
-0.7882506251335144,
-0.4848872721195221,
0.21889661252498627,
0.5894643068313599,
-0.8175790905952454,
0.4157714545726776,
-0.16914887726306915,
-0.5594310760498047,
-0.9490665197372437,
0.5427249073982239,
0.16374501585960388,
0.4624844789505005,
0.27855202555656433,
-0.22114600241184235,
-0.6499150395393372,
-0.506451427936554,
-0.11396975070238113,
0.3421463966369629,
-0.2734696567058563,
0.12288374453783035,
0.06901947408914566,
-0.008982564322650433,
0.7940201759338379,
-0.6075741648674011,
-0.23052816092967987,
-0.07704512029886246,
0.2394859343767166,
0.41588419675827026,
0.48158037662506104,
0.14554916322231293,
-0.3654564619064331,
-0.3182463049888611,
0.09569308161735535,
-0.9683127999305725,
-0.2934366762638092,
-0.14587949216365814,
-0.571054220199585,
0.433287650346756,
0.8267609477043152,
-0.21138028800487518,
0.21924754977226257,
0.5943520665168762,
-0.22867451608181,
0.3559303283691406,
-0.44683074951171875,
0.09200672805309296,
-0.8722520470619202,
-0.2750881612300873,
-0.137970432639122,
0.33300507068634033,
-0.21251732110977173,
0.1792057752609253,
0.13441155850887299,
-0.24272944033145905,
-0.1632949858903885,
0.36758121848106384,
-0.8388798832893372,
-0.07740360498428345,
-0.40309634804725647,
-0.058572184294462204,
0.014455562457442284,
0.4607400596141815,
0.5287928581237793,
0.7543294429779053,
0.6384613513946533,
-0.3942303955554962,
0.3950375020503998,
0.04585250839591026,
-0.6597143411636353,
0.42372703552246094,
-0.3829328119754791,
0.4198397994041443,
-0.13814790546894073,
0.18807964026927948,
-0.3459564745426178,
-0.35508444905281067,
-0.06121502444148064,
0.01340300589799881,
0.34866100549697876,
-0.686700165271759,
-0.38483601808547974,
-0.38623324036598206,
0.10321301966905594,
-0.06733495742082596,
0.583302915096283,
-0.7260239124298096,
0.5566714406013489,
0.3129453957080841,
0.05890292674303055,
-0.7457402348518372,
-0.6174275279045105,
-0.13443638384342194,
-0.6070523262023926,
-0.5436381697654724,
0.09749602526426315,
0.014848796650767326,
-0.050092827528715134,
-0.3282730281352997,
-0.2044483721256256,
-0.07645020633935928,
0.224534809589386,
0.26975324749946594,
0.2386178821325302,
-0.5453905463218689,
0.18897271156311035,
0.32529759407043457,
0.03625251352787018,
0.24231259524822235,
-0.6408875584602356,
0.2970461845397949,
-0.05945819243788719,
-0.2642088532447815,
-0.10776832699775696,
0.4046001434326172,
0.4913199543952942,
-0.7475606203079224,
0.6744979023933411,
0.9034594297409058,
-0.00660450616851449,
-0.7226530909538269,
-0.457080215215683,
-0.3238213360309601,
-0.6024445295333862,
0.32204121351242065,
-0.2630848288536072,
-0.8587567210197449,
0.385481059551239,
-0.4601304829120636,
0.20470774173736572,
0.09438582509756088,
0.4414670765399933,
-0.19631215929985046,
0.7979954481124878,
0.7086898684501648,
0.107033371925354,
0.37686410546302795,
-0.46886536478996277,
0.1324937790632248,
-0.6373381614685059,
-0.20295687019824982,
-0.37496232986450195,
-0.3302966356277466,
-1.0562934875488281,
-0.7702869176864624,
0.4569346606731415,
0.0014563872246071696,
-0.38198748230934143,
-0.01814272440969944,
-0.6219852566719055,
1.1093765497207642,
0.771993100643158,
-0.053805142641067505,
0.2436791956424713,
0.26771992444992065,
-0.10704269260168076,
-0.08715607970952988,
-0.8432652354240417,
-0.6999493837356567,
1.1196765899658203,
0.2757883667945862,
0.8996373414993286,
0.0947597399353981,
0.5592280626296997,
0.27546876668930054,
0.312699556350708,
-0.6641969680786133,
0.2953648865222931,
-0.7959921360015869,
-0.5710883736610413,
-0.3586512804031372,
-0.3277662396430969,
-0.8010988831520081,
0.10759033262729645,
-0.1888033151626587,
-0.6894963979721069,
0.0014537111856043339,
0.19172236323356628,
-0.34172868728637695,
0.21403701603412628,
-1.020459771156311,
0.9508535265922546,
-0.49693426489830017,
-0.26714345812797546,
-0.017038021236658096,
-0.6570501327514648,
0.5269324779510498,
-0.07591979205608368,
0.3224957585334778,
-0.2143414318561554,
0.3468203544616699,
0.34119126200675964,
-0.07811123132705688,
1.1275930404663086,
-0.0873693972826004,
-0.31855249404907227,
0.34684115648269653,
0.27201569080352783,
0.19808538258075714,
0.03368864580988884,
-0.3135232627391815,
0.3309463858604431,
-0.022650010883808136,
-0.38159963488578796,
-0.7609152793884277,
0.8888534903526306,
-0.8970014452934265,
-0.7804446220397949,
0.06117744743824005,
-0.7958893775939941,
-0.1774732619524002,
-0.04785386100411415,
0.21357476711273193,
0.5961620211601257,
0.08336227387189865,
0.2454431802034378,
0.8085044026374817,
-0.4126564562320709,
0.3658886253833771,
0.8881535530090332,
0.2438245266675949,
-0.09313783049583435,
1.015260100364685,
0.07530901581048965,
0.20079858601093292,
0.28979459404945374,
0.2712777256965637,
-0.23702006042003632,
-0.38194936513900757,
-0.8766101598739624,
0.13226456940174103,
-1.0219842195510864,
-0.16042841970920563,
-0.1808691769838333,
-0.12666593492031097,
-0.4181261956691742,
-0.2884647846221924,
-0.2889871895313263,
-0.18267005681991577,
-0.42920899391174316,
-0.11082702875137329,
0.25935131311416626,
0.6375709176063538,
-0.22267505526542664,
0.3831750452518463,
-0.8747910261154175,
-0.02982068806886673,
0.3021770417690277,
0.3051337003707886,
-0.06720311939716339,
-0.9092031717300415,
-0.36866727471351624,
0.13614025712013245,
-0.16109244525432587,
-0.6178380846977234,
0.5685350894927979,
0.2998991012573242,
0.5501708984375,
0.4841625690460205,
0.26634296774864197,
1.024975299835205,
-0.4914238154888153,
0.6766334176063538,
-0.3882937431335449,
-0.799031674861908,
0.8131205439567566,
-0.26896464824676514,
0.6943140029907227,
0.22900910675525665,
0.5210410952568054,
-0.5252060890197754,
-0.36207109689712524,
-0.2130165696144104,
-0.8852139711380005,
0.8295018076896667,
-0.475852906703949,
0.46323657035827637,
-0.1736886352300644,
0.32838091254234314,
0.23721878230571747,
-0.181211918592453,
-0.5118614435195923,
-0.059993110597133636,
-0.3897744417190552,
-0.2291094958782196,
0.09615641832351685,
-0.02606385573744774,
-0.24475547671318054,
-0.2917117476463318,
0.5405974984169006,
-0.4669977128505707,
-0.15194924175739288,
-0.10700009763240814,
-0.20089511573314667,
-0.39879655838012695,
0.2781856656074524,
0.3941281735897064,
0.7971809506416321,
-0.021979888901114464,
0.04766771197319031,
0.32156243920326233,
-0.31866171956062317,
-0.17719952762126923,
-0.12479900568723679,
-0.1268610954284668,
-0.44949671626091003,
0.5688822865486145,
0.7037721276283264,
0.1299450695514679,
-0.6197202205657959,
0.005823016632348299,
-0.15149100124835968,
0.2636692225933075,
-0.5204148292541504,
0.35321563482284546,
0.014309299178421497,
0.3007371723651886,
0.31764569878578186,
-0.2080160677433014,
-0.10783179104328156,
-0.6592909693717957,
0.032835230231285095,
0.3716343939304352,
-0.28219741582870483,
-0.1081070527434349,
0.3926674425601959,
0.46483591198921204,
-0.1720767766237259,
1.2279013395309448,
-0.08377301692962646,
-0.35538920760154724,
0.6364321708679199,
0.6320846676826477,
0.44892436265945435,
0.0019228323362767696,
0.48003554344177246,
0.4137459993362427,
0.4094995856285095,
0.14395180344581604,
0.13063311576843262,
-0.338744193315506,
-0.6909967660903931,
-0.893734335899353,
-0.8832044005393982,
-0.1728590726852417,
0.10330858081579208,
-0.6926549077033997,
0.29834145307540894,
-0.26320481300354004,
0.3408396244049072,
-0.26836520433425903,
-0.04056166112422943,
-0.7599032521247864,
0.23181891441345215,
0.45432987809181213,
0.8602421879768372,
-1.06598961353302,
0.8763728141784668,
0.5591809153556824,
-0.004762123804539442,
-0.9437796473503113,
0.00975501537322998,
0.18890485167503357,
-1.1032311916351318,
0.7082046866416931,
0.04060094803571701,
-0.16428913176059723,
-0.10573162883520126,
-0.7465474009513855,
-0.9297213554382324,
1.0274568796157837,
0.3585186004638672,
-0.4957478940486908,
0.12958192825317383,
0.21108503639698029,
0.7894494533538818,
-0.5517536997795105,
0.24000799655914307,
1.0195304155349731,
0.12305168062448502,
0.44082626700401306,
-0.620809018611908,
-0.13301821053028107,
-0.16465073823928833,
-0.21637387573719025,
0.06970151513814926,
-0.5638154149055481,
0.3268381655216217,
-0.38149896264076233,
-0.1440241038799286,
-0.031734567135572433,
0.9317079782485962,
0.34194979071617126,
0.14135834574699402,
0.12664903700351715,
0.24968461692333221,
0.9900670051574707,
-0.1693795919418335,
0.8256291747093201,
-0.31560951471328735,
-0.21618320047855377,
1.217949390411377,
-0.05316874384880066,
0.5536019206047058,
0.09588704258203506,
0.274527370929718,
0.7905331254005432,
0.8954215049743652,
-0.14105015993118286,
0.5718045234680176,
0.3556089699268341,
-0.07787138223648071,
-0.5502458810806274,
-0.30952829122543335,
-0.20313392579555511,
1.270281434059143,
0.7219662070274353,
-0.5140600204467773,
0.013669057749211788,
-0.3156048655509949,
0.0935705378651619,
0.3239516019821167,
-0.49726802110671997,
0.6886239051818848,
-0.04736272618174553,
-1.110088586807251,
0.6881293058395386,
0.09221075475215912,
0.6431121230125427,
-0.6260203719139099,
-0.26538577675819397,
-0.5604376196861267,
0.010205001570284367,
-0.18473288416862488,
-0.6262826919555664,
0.27769699692726135,
0.19825586676597595,
-0.2666473090648651,
-0.4396440088748932,
0.42988720536231995,
-0.6273193359375,
-0.5359959006309509,
-0.0389089435338974,
0.36208805441856384,
0.27374574542045593,
0.3883318305015564,
-0.5575052499771118,
0.09592180699110031,
0.17759756743907928,
0.0772581398487091,
0.2007950097322464,
1.026052713394165,
-0.336323618888855,
0.5695549845695496,
0.7023891806602478,
0.17299173772335052,
0.15726248919963837,
0.17467495799064636,
0.5318090915679932,
-0.6044560074806213,
-0.37229034304618835,
-0.627238929271698,
0.4406375288963318,
-0.17324870824813843,
-0.4143887162208557,
0.6317589282989502,
0.19691434502601624,
1.1203724145889282,
-0.18065357208251953,
0.596217155456543,
0.08894357830286026,
0.43325889110565186,
-0.7882904410362244,
0.5055328011512756,
-0.2663733959197998,
0.5187757015228271,
0.1928156018257141,
-0.664542019367218,
0.0019485988887026906,
0.5312445163726807,
-0.5379332900047302,
-0.09871764481067657,
0.5060788989067078,
0.9417968392372131,
-0.19877149164676666,
0.4011249542236328,
0.17824016511440277,
0.19956281781196594,
0.06629210710525513,
0.16609573364257812,
0.815694272518158,
0.25365981459617615,
0.4744020998477936,
-0.5467353463172913,
-0.29039448499679565,
0.41429048776626587,
-1.1187148094177246,
-0.9414814710617065,
-0.41388827562332153,
-0.23326919972896576,
0.04155467450618744,
-0.07840334624052048,
1.0678560733795166,
0.9162802696228027,
-0.8143414258956909,
-0.42858779430389404,
0.4546257257461548,
0.17112977802753448,
-0.3229379951953888,
-0.2532157599925995,
0.5240374207496643,
-0.44307443499565125,
-0.7281425595283508,
0.8591082692146301,
0.23619896173477173,
-0.20324942469596863,
-0.43998560309410095,
0.10347678512334824,
0.2262709140777588,
0.03220334276556969,
0.6757504343986511,
0.36433306336402893,
-0.7247691750526428,
-0.1743984967470169,
0.27996712923049927,
0.2747608721256256,
-0.2568659484386444,
1.0080244541168213,
-0.5221154093742371,
0.5837888717651367,
0.10514654219150543,
0.46096330881118774,
0.3755321502685547,
0.07269980758428574,
0.7255156636238098,
-1.2189539670944214,
0.1298711895942688,
0.02363232895731926,
0.2042349874973297,
0.5636520981788635,
-0.4622381925582886,
0.6913314461708069,
0.054736219346523285,
-0.6624693274497986,
-0.5343897342681885,
0.19522692263126373,
-0.5251528024673462,
-0.404308557510376,
1.19618558883667,
-0.36254259943962097,
-0.2997862994670868,
-0.08901217579841614,
0.014805737882852554,
0.2839309275150299,
-0.11422178149223328,
1.1752030849456787,
0.5626487135887146,
0.036611929535865784,
-0.15651512145996094,
-0.5900127291679382,
0.4190700054168701,
0.3879610002040863,
-0.7485713362693787,
0.24439385533332825,
0.6490662693977356,
0.3356040120124817,
-0.17719849944114685,
0.21366290748119354,
-0.13054944574832916,
0.2856829762458801,
-0.43118736147880554,
-0.0010746560292318463,
0.011348709464073181,
-0.34605708718299866,
-0.20754830539226532,
0.11118704080581665,
-0.030373141169548035,
-0.028308577835559845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03133v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03133v1
|
Lory: Fully Differentiable Mixture-of-Experts for Autoregressive Language Model Pre-training
| 2024-05-06T03:06:33 | 2024-05-06T03:06:33 |
Zexuan Zhong, Mengzhou Xia, Danqi Chen, Mike Lewis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Mixture-of-experts (MoE) models facilitate efficient scaling; however,
training the router network introduces the challenge of optimizing a
non-differentiable, discrete objective. Recently, a fully-differentiable MoE
architecture, SMEAR, was proposed (Muqeeth et al., 2023), which softly merges
experts in the parameter space; nevertheless, its effectiveness was only
demonstrated in downstream fine-tuning on classification tasks. In this paper,
we present Lory, the first approach that scales such architectures to
autoregressive language model pre-training. Lory introduces two key techniques:
(1) a causal segment routing strategy that achieves high efficiency for expert
merging operations while preserving the autoregressive nature of language
models; (2) a similarity-based data batching method that encourages expert
specialization by grouping similar documents in training instances. We
pre-train a series of Lory models on 150B tokens from scratch, with up to 32
experts and 30B (1.5B active) parameters. Experimental results show significant
performance gains over parameter-matched dense models on both perplexity
(+13.9%) and a variety of downstream tasks (+1.5%-11.1%). Despite segment-level
routing, Lory models achieve competitive performance compared to
state-of-the-art MoE models with token-level routing. We further demonstrate
that the trained experts in Lory capture domain-level specialization without
supervision. Our work highlights the potential of fully-differentiable MoE
architectures for language model pre-training and advocates future research in
this area.
|
[
-0.486240953207016,
-0.7235126495361328,
0.3058249354362488,
0.18105237185955048,
-0.17834283411502838,
-0.004574547987431288,
-0.30328166484832764,
-0.33284106850624084,
0.45305943489074707,
0.5960233211517334,
-0.49180325865745544,
-0.318523645401001,
-0.8980867862701416,
-0.2534222900867462,
-0.6437035202980042,
0.8008061051368713,
0.15652284026145935,
-0.1282324641942978,
0.21607962250709534,
-0.23976892232894897,
-0.1076228991150856,
-0.40161579847335815,
-0.7757499814033508,
-0.06878203898668289,
0.7167603969573975,
0.1294981986284256,
0.5079835057258606,
0.9194322228431702,
0.6080326437950134,
0.44466185569763184,
0.11643685400485992,
0.22958090901374817,
-0.41440021991729736,
0.13382463157176971,
-0.25088170170783997,
-0.30058562755584717,
-0.6756757497787476,
0.06906559318304062,
0.5779234766960144,
0.8389829993247986,
-0.5659873485565186,
-0.1290367841720581,
-0.10167738795280457,
0.647103488445282,
-0.7178053855895996,
-0.13991563022136688,
-0.8700854778289795,
-0.1326027512550354,
-0.2670166492462158,
-0.10382532328367233,
-0.35575661063194275,
-0.11217301338911057,
0.20897512137889862,
-0.3277771770954132,
0.291481077671051,
0.12289578467607498,
0.7057624459266663,
0.6135052442550659,
-0.4852001667022705,
-0.12933814525604248,
-0.6496500968933105,
0.9396109580993652,
-0.9728696346282959,
0.35347357392311096,
0.17692922055721283,
0.3179193437099457,
0.04956517741084099,
-0.6439705491065979,
-0.2542336583137512,
0.06470704078674316,
0.13927830755710602,
-0.016144387423992157,
-0.10184353590011597,
0.0820143073797226,
-0.2006332278251648,
0.5636123418807983,
-0.39041441679000854,
0.41388681530952454,
-0.41007205843925476,
-0.0885934978723526,
0.7776892781257629,
0.18076741695404053,
0.03683283552527428,
0.3878118395805359,
-0.2888735234737396,
0.1278664916753769,
-0.423120379447937,
-0.2462550550699234,
0.5153747797012329,
0.4143967926502228,
-0.04011467844247818,
0.3085139989852905,
-0.41664713621139526,
0.9293333888053894,
0.5081635117530823,
-0.15388986468315125,
0.18332162499427795,
-0.007690361235290766,
-0.23181116580963135,
0.056055206805467606,
0.9330465793609619,
-0.225152388215065,
0.05298550799489021,
-0.2596086263656616,
-0.22163386642932892,
-0.1172933280467987,
0.34579935669898987,
-0.7125362157821655,
-0.607966423034668,
-0.07983894646167755,
-0.21258266270160675,
-0.4497004449367523,
-0.34199628233909607,
-0.4989869296550751,
-0.05127917602658272,
-0.44936564564704895,
0.6134865880012512,
-0.24672994017601013,
-0.478956401348114,
0.2685755491256714,
0.3761439323425293,
0.10252691060304642,
0.5250537991523743,
-1.0201733112335205,
0.20885202288627625,
0.5395402908325195,
0.522431492805481,
-0.3089732229709625,
-0.4685429036617279,
-0.580014169216156,
0.003538512159138918,
-0.23229475319385529,
0.8015402555465698,
-0.6692302823066711,
-0.3682774305343628,
-0.21846063435077667,
-0.3458859622478485,
-0.41628265380859375,
-0.4884221851825714,
0.11501547694206238,
-0.7952843904495239,
0.3459463119506836,
0.03437180444598198,
-0.4146649241447449,
0.0015117693692445755,
0.2525174915790558,
-0.4567384123802185,
0.9212972521781921,
0.13335029780864716,
-0.8631440997123718,
0.30154162645339966,
-0.4634955823421478,
-0.583611786365509,
-0.07645785808563232,
-0.2649095356464386,
-0.09322217851877213,
0.12125138193368912,
0.18910866975784302,
0.3955133855342865,
-0.36562061309814453,
0.2596856355667114,
-0.29126641154289246,
-0.004981461446732283,
-0.13392457365989685,
-0.5710042119026184,
0.7125599980354309,
0.20470525324344635,
-0.51579350233078,
0.11512661725282669,
-0.8323091864585876,
0.050712618976831436,
-0.22500453889369965,
-0.4861244857311249,
-0.44497016072273254,
-0.002297663129866123,
-0.19685231149196625,
0.20955659449100494,
0.5338781476020813,
-0.35393527150154114,
0.1954588145017624,
-0.3021319508552551,
0.38469624519348145,
0.8252712488174438,
-0.15467222034931183,
0.49409738183021545,
-0.05627122148871422,
0.2807489037513733,
0.25369763374328613,
0.30361661314964294,
-0.050378795713186264,
-0.4829992651939392,
-1.1341339349746704,
-0.5706339478492737,
0.31505513191223145,
0.37387239933013916,
-0.5808354616165161,
0.7661067843437195,
-0.2503374218940735,
-0.61577308177948,
-0.7018773555755615,
0.20428432524204254,
0.49202975630760193,
0.6521477699279785,
0.4420021176338196,
-0.565497875213623,
-0.1813216656446457,
-0.9452117085456848,
-0.15273576974868774,
-0.20761851966381073,
0.23827381432056427,
0.11845633387565613,
0.11209313571453094,
-0.4591256380081177,
0.9946302771568298,
-0.6509383320808411,
-0.1956922560930252,
0.025439739227294922,
0.49910151958465576,
0.08986855298280716,
0.59755939245224,
0.2207193523645401,
-0.8163702487945557,
-0.6609799265861511,
0.11010266095399857,
-0.5024390816688538,
-0.11242291331291199,
0.3878558278083801,
-0.2931262254714966,
0.03507225960493088,
0.5943551659584045,
-0.4382956326007843,
0.1853465884923935,
0.6515603065490723,
-0.07397251576185226,
0.2811395525932312,
-0.39225903153419495,
0.09418340772390366,
-1.113919734954834,
-0.14052097499370575,
-0.09712956100702286,
-0.21297742426395416,
-0.6715524196624756,
0.19967244565486908,
-0.18617145717144012,
0.08731494843959808,
-0.3983207046985626,
0.697163462638855,
-0.30530449748039246,
0.1489657759666443,
-0.30761510133743286,
0.02248859964311123,
-0.1343851536512375,
0.6053656935691833,
0.13099725544452667,
0.464985191822052,
0.8340252041816711,
-0.7464415431022644,
0.13533367216587067,
-0.19115345180034637,
-0.22434167563915253,
0.6720246076583862,
-0.5475019812583923,
0.11726997792720795,
-0.05610772594809532,
-0.14126650989055634,
-0.8730270862579346,
-0.25646400451660156,
-0.11126808822154999,
-0.2975693643093109,
0.3457704484462738,
-0.23948296904563904,
-0.2445598542690277,
-0.15433359146118164,
0.17573538422584534,
0.5548837780952454,
0.7654319405555725,
-0.30566075444221497,
1.053479552268982,
0.3804408013820648,
-0.10173045098781586,
-0.594139814376831,
-0.8214914798736572,
-0.30318504571914673,
-0.2554974853992462,
-0.5701917409896851,
0.13136278092861176,
-0.16710089147090912,
-0.14471039175987244,
0.08831754326820374,
-0.08183860033750534,
-0.5628337264060974,
0.07509561628103256,
0.06470031291246414,
0.04107356816530228,
-0.4995938539505005,
-0.24400608241558075,
0.25332126021385193,
-0.1611848920583725,
-0.17115305364131927,
-0.5701015591621399,
0.49192193150520325,
-0.038337286561727524,
-0.7843352556228638,
-0.28888455033302307,
0.2690906822681427,
0.5116173624992371,
-0.45560944080352783,
0.8030670881271362,
0.7930013537406921,
-0.03506728261709213,
-0.0780378207564354,
-1.096184492111206,
0.05013309791684151,
-0.5407625436782837,
0.35671743750572205,
-0.21880008280277252,
-1.031658411026001,
0.3937813341617584,
-0.03301066905260086,
0.2678051292896271,
0.5354571342468262,
0.5271792411804199,
0.14836929738521576,
0.8367066383361816,
0.8643704652786255,
-0.42387548089027405,
0.4740056097507477,
-0.11198637634515762,
0.3964141607284546,
-0.5563427805900574,
0.01158098317682743,
-0.4259606599807739,
-0.14373479783535004,
-0.44416749477386475,
-0.7453309893608093,
0.3078114986419678,
0.3025650680065155,
-0.4095127582550049,
0.1653795689344406,
-0.2945806682109833,
0.4737507998943329,
0.5106503963470459,
-0.167291060090065,
0.3580487370491028,
0.14314404129981995,
-0.060926951467990875,
0.27887022495269775,
-0.7881804704666138,
-0.1568518728017807,
0.9270132780075073,
0.2073179930448532,
0.9849611520767212,
0.08518734574317932,
0.939477801322937,
0.2810969948768616,
0.3673388361930847,
-0.6388291120529175,
0.645804762840271,
-0.5527585744857788,
-0.5735015273094177,
-0.5041549205780029,
-0.6205041408538818,
-0.7363349795341492,
0.35245218873023987,
0.12802758812904358,
-0.6409184336662292,
0.38708487153053284,
0.47351640462875366,
-0.3260801434516907,
0.5242394804954529,
-0.6680115461349487,
0.4370817244052887,
-0.3521740138530731,
-0.2511695921421051,
-0.27441102266311646,
-0.6317161321640015,
0.20640559494495392,
-0.3318956792354584,
0.1861392706632614,
-0.018501177430152893,
-0.05308697745203972,
0.7327529191970825,
-0.4042116105556488,
0.7801138162612915,
-0.31979992985725403,
-0.15146875381469727,
0.2961794435977936,
0.13926032185554504,
0.44662603735923767,
-0.3112785220146179,
-0.12509828805923462,
0.14865930378437042,
-0.417435884475708,
-0.5780853629112244,
-0.5591855645179749,
0.8238099217414856,
-1.1131212711334229,
-0.5835191011428833,
0.13550710678100586,
-0.42052990198135376,
-0.39415162801742554,
0.4314087927341461,
0.2897891700267792,
0.6814613938331604,
0.0075944275595247746,
0.16497205197811127,
1.0698230266571045,
0.3004835247993469,
0.4163137376308441,
0.7883300185203552,
-0.07223197817802429,
-0.3513852655887604,
0.9236029982566833,
0.01832697167992592,
0.3433121144771576,
0.6677463054656982,
0.09540505707263947,
-0.08062025159597397,
-0.652694821357727,
-0.27308809757232666,
0.15548276901245117,
-0.5483866333961487,
0.001643510302528739,
-0.9499323964118958,
-0.40755248069763184,
-0.3430713713169098,
-0.34664756059646606,
-0.9424974918365479,
-0.25005924701690674,
-0.3113144636154175,
0.2067229002714157,
0.14902788400650024,
0.8159500360488892,
-0.1413816511631012,
0.5956587791442871,
-0.6316059231758118,
-0.045009955763816833,
0.7983425855636597,
0.24917542934417725,
0.286093145608902,
-0.7467870116233826,
-0.49595850706100464,
-0.10695832222700119,
0.10034778714179993,
-0.21395625174045563,
0.38450777530670166,
0.14876627922058105,
0.6886820197105408,
0.7550528645515442,
-0.02690543420612812,
0.8179501295089722,
-0.5629396438598633,
0.5913767218589783,
0.3092483878135681,
-0.819619357585907,
0.2798985242843628,
-0.5410768985748291,
0.08642556518316269,
0.8252416253089905,
0.5419168472290039,
-0.046722862869501114,
-0.3338014781475067,
-0.5241042971611023,
-1.0267634391784668,
0.5286078453063965,
-0.011113793589174747,
0.04420860856771469,
0.01818559318780899,
0.15377546846866608,
0.16324150562286377,
0.37748393416404724,
-0.48850134015083313,
-0.20354707539081573,
-0.09510264545679092,
-0.4070858359336853,
-0.1608661413192749,
-0.058004230260849,
-0.1893305778503418,
-0.055990442633628845,
0.5904247164726257,
0.04457554221153259,
0.2149478644132614,
0.01727803610265255,
-0.2427290827035904,
0.08718268573284149,
0.11749862134456635,
0.3534630835056305,
0.6200534105300903,
-0.24374361336231232,
0.08501686900854111,
-0.02892145700752735,
-0.42262303829193115,
0.19531439244747162,
0.11474569886922836,
0.11701119691133499,
-0.23749296367168427,
0.4746226668357849,
0.9471692442893982,
0.22619187831878662,
-0.39705178141593933,
0.5457172393798828,
0.02777097001671791,
-0.4048409163951874,
-0.08494982868432999,
0.37599048018455505,
-0.04501693323254585,
0.27349019050598145,
0.4451206624507904,
0.2232750505208969,
-0.06634359061717987,
-0.1756967455148697,
0.02122746780514717,
0.17954879999160767,
-0.49992135167121887,
-0.3734562397003174,
0.5317569375038147,
0.516942024230957,
-0.22634637355804443,
0.49647974967956543,
-0.22846539318561554,
-0.22581514716148376,
0.36463019251823425,
0.16951678693294525,
0.7779700756072998,
-0.45020216703414917,
-0.05158218741416931,
-0.07540539652109146,
0.22495371103286743,
-0.1966487616300583,
-0.18008722364902496,
-0.11688125133514404,
-0.6932026743888855,
-0.43283313512802124,
-0.6452504992485046,
-0.20067918300628662,
-0.05720599368214607,
-0.8153175711631775,
0.07823310047388077,
-0.48331218957901,
-0.0774962306022644,
-0.21585939824581146,
-0.16758203506469727,
-0.7150116562843323,
0.4802217483520508,
-0.12287037819623947,
0.8717595934867859,
-0.8875331878662109,
0.9840680956840515,
0.8366284370422363,
-0.09904991835355759,
-0.8888686299324036,
0.05844418331980705,
-0.2474781572818756,
-0.9098954796791077,
0.8520451188087463,
-0.15647514164447784,
-0.38809308409690857,
0.2685679793357849,
-0.2083626389503479,
-0.9642510414123535,
0.9440062642097473,
0.09724345058202744,
-0.738220751285553,
-0.3238772749900818,
-0.06952613592147827,
0.501078724861145,
-0.546223521232605,
0.28452184796333313,
0.23663407564163208,
0.10362371057271957,
0.17229920625686646,
-0.8567920923233032,
-0.33637699484825134,
-0.18146251142024994,
-0.06279805302619934,
0.3874817192554474,
-0.8690171837806702,
1.251774787902832,
0.12708619236946106,
0.1629500687122345,
-0.02628953568637371,
0.7253791689872742,
-0.03139476105570793,
0.029116785153746605,
0.828091025352478,
0.7514600157737732,
0.8010637760162354,
0.287339985370636,
0.6873893141746521,
-0.4933796226978302,
0.3267759382724762,
1.3026025295257568,
-0.3312293291091919,
0.9512906074523926,
0.32659777998924255,
-0.11360976099967957,
0.6651753187179565,
0.4245576858520508,
0.4441337287425995,
0.8443590402603149,
0.03160634636878967,
-0.3932470381259918,
-0.5008407831192017,
0.1439555287361145,
-0.44484084844589233,
0.2653898298740387,
0.2304704636335373,
-0.20699667930603027,
-0.2921818792819977,
-0.02530287578701973,
0.025142481550574303,
-0.10830233991146088,
-0.5073988437652588,
0.7115027904510498,
-0.10752596706151962,
-0.5383875370025635,
0.3238318860530853,
0.1326322704553604,
1.0178840160369873,
-0.9077211022377014,
0.4278692305088043,
-0.45753568410873413,
0.14333021640777588,
-0.12190781533718109,
-0.3112710416316986,
0.043547824025154114,
-0.0767822191119194,
-0.38595932722091675,
0.005218835081905127,
0.5692673325538635,
-0.5415399670600891,
-0.5212606191635132,
0.2830807864665985,
0.5979991555213928,
0.18268552422523499,
-0.03750857710838318,
-0.5920590162277222,
-0.11267610639333725,
0.08598164469003677,
-0.21762153506278992,
0.567101240158081,
0.7199779152870178,
-0.0345413014292717,
0.7262094616889954,
0.34686794877052307,
0.26865679025650024,
0.433219313621521,
0.06657393276691437,
1.0395344495773315,
-0.4197058081626892,
-0.5974376797676086,
-0.6578968167304993,
0.6077770590782166,
0.04000905528664589,
-0.22041471302509308,
0.5236624479293823,
0.3525879681110382,
0.8717862367630005,
0.02979746274650097,
0.6138477325439453,
-0.09677567332983017,
0.4464717507362366,
-0.4931594431400299,
0.5438449382781982,
-0.6996868252754211,
0.16595952212810516,
-0.01613050326704979,
-0.7801355719566345,
0.007717094384133816,
0.4496062994003296,
-0.6471176147460938,
0.2773723304271698,
0.5365323424339294,
0.8251671195030212,
-0.39004936814308167,
-0.3157643675804138,
0.3662433326244354,
0.20439891517162323,
0.24330884218215942,
0.34308096766471863,
0.6479493975639343,
-0.14732696115970612,
0.39522504806518555,
-0.10934699326753616,
-0.24320261180400848,
-0.36789563298225403,
-0.7614204287528992,
-1.1430774927139282,
-0.5557818412780762,
-0.528679370880127,
0.13204868137836456,
0.10828323662281036,
0.8718625903129578,
1.1759827136993408,
-0.5584399700164795,
-0.19928883016109467,
-0.18405646085739136,
-0.15175479650497437,
0.25514981150627136,
-0.2062651813030243,
0.2829984724521637,
-0.5559511780738831,
-0.5528529286384583,
0.40662822127342224,
0.42110323905944824,
-0.07192303985357285,
-0.5827270150184631,
-0.007414075545966625,
-0.195497065782547,
0.2729605436325073,
0.4695812463760376,
0.18881767988204956,
-0.5900753140449524,
0.11404091864824295,
-0.38870885968208313,
-0.14667974412441254,
-0.11420091241598129,
0.912140429019928,
-0.5434722900390625,
0.34906241297721863,
0.328091025352478,
0.8512173891067505,
0.3707519769668579,
0.061082176864147186,
0.4781513810157776,
-0.6248577237129211,
0.29918673634529114,
0.19288703799247742,
0.12774278223514557,
0.27507254481315613,
-0.25562822818756104,
0.3251657783985138,
0.16938288509845734,
-0.634660005569458,
-0.665981113910675,
0.22649125754833221,
-0.8446475863456726,
-0.1077595204114914,
0.8800674676895142,
-0.39406684041023254,
-0.14185455441474915,
-0.07105278968811035,
0.04218042641878128,
-0.007329242769628763,
-0.40759503841400146,
0.6214351654052734,
0.5639530420303345,
-0.0972389280796051,
-0.043592024594545364,
-0.19610224664211273,
0.11871273815631866,
0.4663495123386383,
-0.7391501665115356,
-0.11475472152233124,
0.23503416776657104,
0.3623238801956177,
0.1601041555404663,
0.9615369439125061,
-0.04697149246931076,
-0.2630850672721863,
0.06409192085266113,
-0.0009696577326394618,
-0.19697321951389313,
-0.4996146857738495,
-0.17566446959972382,
0.1125478446483612,
0.32812389731407166,
-0.032826974987983704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03111v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03111v1
|
An Active Inference Agent for Simulating Human Translation Processes in a Hierarchical Architecture: Integrating the Task Segment Framework and the HOF taxonomy
| 2024-05-06T02:07:13 | 2024-05-06T02:07:13 |
Michael Carl
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we propose modelling human translation production as a
hierarchy of three embedded translation processes. The proposed architecture
replicates the temporal dynamics of keystroke production across sensorimotor,
cognitive, and phenomenal layers. Utilizing data from the CRITT TPR-DB, the
Task Segment Framework, and the HOF taxonomy, we demonstrate the temporal
breakdown of the typing flow on distinct timelines within these three layers.
|
[
0.17263583838939667,
-0.9415034055709839,
0.7432695627212524,
0.20276618003845215,
0.0007830150425434113,
0.3308420181274414,
0.03846193477511406,
-0.36989736557006836,
0.013340845704078674,
0.6013015508651733,
-0.6926092505455017,
-0.6002844572067261,
-0.20557640492916107,
-0.04776948690414429,
-0.5327529907226562,
0.38384199142456055,
-0.13183508813381195,
-0.17330491542816162,
0.10456938296556473,
0.01864021085202694,
0.14694979786872864,
-0.7404038310050964,
-0.5714625716209412,
-0.5216578245162964,
0.260786235332489,
0.24287478625774384,
1.0076535940170288,
1.0110805034637451,
0.4601486623287201,
0.24886754155158997,
-0.12385372072458267,
-0.15330870449543,
0.2021704912185669,
0.4568786323070526,
-0.19248943030834198,
-0.46159473061561584,
-1.0379412174224854,
-0.06164708361029625,
0.7256373167037964,
0.79067462682724,
-0.10168711841106415,
-0.013048766180872917,
0.016823187470436096,
0.07964523136615753,
-0.43079063296318054,
0.08661891520023346,
-0.11151790618896484,
0.2096846103668213,
-0.18999429047107697,
-0.14193323254585266,
-0.33451002836227417,
0.04108300432562828,
0.23228967189788818,
-0.5936928391456604,
0.21991737186908722,
0.005399697460234165,
0.6724916100502014,
0.2739149332046509,
-0.8069556355476379,
-0.025916321203112602,
-0.787651002407074,
0.46425339579582214,
-0.7782463431358337,
0.3082776665687561,
0.4387926161289215,
0.20347264409065247,
-0.03426184505224228,
-0.8764422535896301,
-0.43367043137550354,
-0.12554378807544708,
0.015459643676877022,
0.09141968190670013,
-0.1162220761179924,
0.3708319664001465,
-0.026018856093287468,
0.15041767060756683,
-0.5403591394424438,
-0.13057194650173187,
-0.059751082211732864,
-0.11095619201660156,
0.3006539046764374,
0.34035801887512207,
0.48665347695350647,
-0.41263964772224426,
-0.06982214003801346,
-0.278292715549469,
-0.35550254583358765,
-0.22336657345294952,
0.2964894771575928,
0.0023652869276702404,
-0.21412251889705658,
0.5695830583572388,
-0.02094322070479393,
0.5903852581977844,
0.016502032056450844,
-0.3799199163913727,
0.43710264563560486,
-0.2993629276752472,
-0.3706953227519989,
-0.07494128495454788,
0.8111828565597534,
0.1361212283372879,
-0.17800211906433105,
-0.4859960377216339,
-0.339061439037323,
0.15219691395759583,
0.5788098573684692,
-0.4486753046512604,
0.20196066796779633,
0.4346955716609955,
-0.31288161873817444,
-0.4943506121635437,
-0.05669821426272392,
-0.4259759783744812,
0.1510288417339325,
0.1150512546300888,
0.30113789439201355,
-0.4335290491580963,
-0.28069138526916504,
-0.08928777277469635,
-0.2012604922056198,
0.27226999402046204,
0.09808815270662308,
-0.5977228879928589,
0.5316017866134644,
0.6526104211807251,
0.950524628162384,
-0.5198727250099182,
-0.6180066466331482,
-0.31789129972457886,
0.5726571679115295,
-0.4756346046924591,
0.7179025411605835,
-0.6285086274147034,
-0.5115786790847778,
0.24311529099941254,
0.08763875812292099,
-0.4110732972621918,
-0.5931892395019531,
0.5163714289665222,
-0.7430909276008606,
-0.2353603094816208,
0.11588042229413986,
-0.31099504232406616,
0.01497503463178873,
0.2955656945705414,
-0.6660179495811462,
1.158022165298462,
0.2834532558917999,
-0.3293127417564392,
0.3345622420310974,
-0.81134033203125,
-0.8336197733879089,
0.08064403384923935,
0.04453113302588463,
-0.29850858449935913,
-0.23373368382453918,
-0.09999227523803711,
0.48281529545783997,
-0.08890320360660553,
0.3073999583721161,
-0.39983901381492615,
-0.031071413308382034,
0.35486456751823425,
0.038674820214509964,
0.508464515209198,
0.4153274595737457,
-0.7337557077407837,
0.2115291804075241,
-0.6754862070083618,
-0.34376224875450134,
-0.24356713891029358,
-0.49020394682884216,
-0.11973553895950317,
0.2796745300292969,
0.16951289772987366,
0.3225676715373993,
-0.014396347105503082,
-0.5587934851646423,
0.32162219285964966,
0.05666078254580498,
0.7372101545333862,
0.09091796725988388,
0.80409175157547,
0.8680696487426758,
-0.07706841081380844,
0.8261011838912964,
0.4417220652103424,
0.1310775727033615,
0.20567093789577484,
-0.5303061604499817,
-0.4989311695098877,
-0.07880264520645142,
-0.008170150220394135,
0.5730977654457092,
-0.828711211681366,
0.23651106655597687,
-0.3095472753047943,
-0.20392878353595734,
-0.392556756734848,
-0.2009628713130951,
0.5007346868515015,
0.3743969798088074,
0.07308072596788406,
-0.08431247621774673,
-0.10978735238313675,
-1.0189268589019775,
-0.2505602240562439,
-0.5064403414726257,
-0.2450229674577713,
-0.06194838508963585,
0.4403626024723053,
-0.337404727935791,
0.46994736790657043,
-0.3487114906311035,
-0.24656172096729279,
-0.24055442214012146,
0.7543671727180481,
-0.13472022116184235,
0.6747528314590454,
0.5054073333740234,
-0.6631757020950317,
-0.1574246734380722,
0.23819276690483093,
-0.519210934638977,
-0.3128933012485504,
-0.3670840263366699,
-0.616661012172699,
0.06966281682252884,
0.6253295540809631,
-0.7339802384376526,
0.3911164402961731,
0.3990788459777832,
-0.5223203301429749,
0.2964771091938019,
-0.10078644752502441,
0.41535934805870056,
-1.2213791608810425,
0.2654991149902344,
-0.16353079676628113,
-0.29365113377571106,
-0.6340182423591614,
0.36191004514694214,
0.21044953167438507,
-0.28481367230415344,
-0.516400933265686,
0.5072283148765564,
-0.7678073048591614,
-0.6328177452087402,
-0.16680797934532166,
-0.03751277178525925,
0.000636213575489819,
0.8368437886238098,
0.3246428370475769,
0.6951650381088257,
0.49504444003105164,
-0.641038715839386,
-0.12561102211475372,
0.2489589899778366,
-0.4424160122871399,
0.24288204312324524,
-0.8384804725646973,
-0.13236424326896667,
0.3233291506767273,
0.01390757691115141,
-0.7737688422203064,
-0.7698844075202942,
0.3973916172981262,
-0.5015388131141663,
0.17994941771030426,
-0.21189835667610168,
-0.8934639096260071,
-0.264647513628006,
0.2689227759838104,
0.2429269254207611,
0.7730811834335327,
0.1243087500333786,
0.8686701059341431,
0.4254128336906433,
0.09886809438467026,
-0.04510024935007095,
-0.8868451714515686,
0.06401675194501877,
-0.03863533213734627,
-0.5346379280090332,
0.75677889585495,
0.4113077223300934,
-0.3821313679218292,
0.16930554807186127,
-0.2513295114040375,
-0.2932853698730469,
0.3345335125923157,
0.45747020840644836,
0.046304862946271896,
-0.22558847069740295,
-0.27573660016059875,
0.34266525506973267,
0.4668968617916107,
0.13481587171554565,
-0.0862731784582138,
0.043222181499004364,
0.11893226206302643,
-0.5747320055961609,
-0.47867801785469055,
0.39735108613967896,
1.2936183214187622,
-0.24844659864902496,
0.5838642120361328,
0.541751503944397,
-0.5469175577163696,
-0.10268653929233551,
-0.06676170974969864,
-0.08017151802778244,
-0.3539183735847473,
0.3639828860759735,
-0.5297475457191467,
-0.49765536189079285,
0.7114233374595642,
0.19893261790275574,
0.3769093453884125,
0.4707273840904236,
0.7898035049438477,
-0.06762015074491501,
1.3159064054489136,
0.09723341464996338,
0.39226552844047546,
0.5771708488464355,
-0.3991403579711914,
0.08403626829385757,
-1.0071629285812378,
-0.14208874106407166,
-0.4311416447162628,
-0.4926970601081848,
-0.06623072922229767,
-1.0056439638137817,
0.6375827789306641,
0.3013501465320587,
-0.1579194962978363,
0.45293208956718445,
0.03989201411604881,
-0.17398551106452942,
0.6038616895675659,
0.18564684689044952,
0.2124374657869339,
-0.1248139888048172,
-0.6513782143592834,
0.3503571152687073,
-0.7189000248908997,
-0.7342829704284668,
0.5561355948448181,
0.4929158687591553,
0.7188085317611694,
0.12631794810295105,
0.4738951325416565,
0.7546165585517883,
0.3135949671268463,
-0.7079334855079651,
0.470102459192276,
0.16433203220367432,
-1.0806547403335571,
-0.273495614528656,
-0.02491532452404499,
-0.5998190641403198,
0.20643435418605804,
0.07020796835422516,
-0.5117682218551636,
0.4086710810661316,
0.37365394830703735,
-0.5219292640686035,
0.2709224224090576,
-0.610512375831604,
1.1224461793899536,
-0.02369416132569313,
-0.546571671962738,
-0.2909453213214874,
-0.9140605926513672,
0.1630246490240097,
0.15142719447612762,
0.12195587903261185,
-0.07439380139112473,
-0.26363638043403625,
0.8626728653907776,
-0.40379878878593445,
1.2514971494674683,
-0.2357807457447052,
0.08526022732257843,
0.69478839635849,
0.5012707114219666,
0.3802332580089569,
-0.2857051491737366,
-0.11019077152013779,
-0.10809303820133209,
0.002282193163409829,
-0.4280449450016022,
-0.4323682487010956,
0.26734301447868347,
-0.9716762900352478,
-0.4017083942890167,
-0.17025701701641083,
-0.4451504349708557,
-0.3590911328792572,
0.0353899784386158,
0.25185033679008484,
0.41456475853919983,
-0.3947674632072449,
-0.014920458197593689,
0.24240121245384216,
0.3194851875305176,
0.36187314987182617,
0.3568609058856964,
0.10085724294185638,
-0.32661670446395874,
0.34153977036476135,
-0.20272155106067657,
0.4017929136753082,
0.8219274878501892,
-0.1246284693479538,
-0.2068510800600052,
-0.4519217610359192,
-0.505347490310669,
0.2592686116695404,
-0.5734432935714722,
-0.06077282503247261,
-1.1258991956710815,
-0.021822357550263405,
-0.804521918296814,
-0.39807477593421936,
-0.18910953402519226,
-0.4685673713684082,
-0.4393062889575958,
-0.28510943055152893,
0.0004097058263141662,
0.8707285523414612,
-0.010818027891218662,
0.7524662017822266,
-1.0732426643371582,
0.44083529710769653,
0.29568129777908325,
-0.15555766224861145,
0.21538007259368896,
-0.5748750567436218,
-0.44176992774009705,
0.15461842715740204,
-0.4224676191806793,
-1.1658188104629517,
0.48239806294441223,
0.37434250116348267,
0.7234954237937927,
0.528995156288147,
-0.16202375292778015,
0.5718167424201965,
-0.4170761704444885,
1.1006412506103516,
-0.11007620394229889,
-1.0468785762786865,
0.27274563908576965,
-0.6550704836845398,
0.6328144669532776,
0.17078249156475067,
0.31344228982925415,
-0.6626400351524353,
-0.7159180641174316,
-0.5395684242248535,
-0.7405366897583008,
0.6880987286567688,
0.34439024329185486,
-0.5927308797836304,
-0.4196174740791321,
0.29139062762260437,
-0.11009873449802399,
0.23648521304130554,
-0.34476661682128906,
0.20051611959934235,
0.06756827235221863,
-0.010369709692895412,
0.25053882598876953,
-0.07012883573770523,
0.08109386265277863,
-0.06479208916425705,
0.7260830998420715,
-0.2106757014989853,
0.4106537699699402,
0.4727546274662018,
-0.4987882077693939,
-0.25095316767692566,
0.27961811423301697,
0.5060092210769653,
0.44775500893592834,
-0.3216087222099304,
0.2501322329044342,
-0.4588393270969391,
-0.4286385476589203,
0.24208642542362213,
-0.5034053921699524,
-0.14756716787815094,
-0.029728157445788383,
0.9193788766860962,
0.9758275151252747,
0.79657381772995,
-0.3453943431377411,
0.3464643657207489,
0.3701743185520172,
-0.5234655737876892,
-0.11665134876966476,
0.12096398323774338,
0.40304356813430786,
0.4506252408027649,
0.4575524926185608,
0.13490943610668182,
0.2189735621213913,
-0.8331479430198669,
0.37444084882736206,
-0.23881669342517853,
-0.4664013981819153,
-0.9368947148323059,
1.166203498840332,
0.4702104926109314,
-0.3629142940044403,
0.4575052857398987,
-0.15815018117427826,
-0.7651107907295227,
0.7870718836784363,
0.45360612869262695,
1.3401353359222412,
-0.26543280482292175,
0.3117862045764923,
0.3324870765209198,
0.15815617144107819,
-0.22168613970279694,
0.35501042008399963,
-0.41047829389572144,
-0.599538266658783,
-0.576005756855011,
-0.8669512867927551,
-0.3146797716617584,
-0.37561506032943726,
-1.0951536893844604,
-0.33992859721183777,
0.045181211084127426,
-0.5919460654258728,
0.0586264431476593,
-0.3794563114643097,
-0.647386908531189,
-0.04248722270131111,
0.29379361867904663,
1.0643960237503052,
-1.0998107194900513,
1.1971709728240967,
1.2693054676055908,
-0.3731118142604828,
-0.3628292977809906,
0.4011099636554718,
0.044638700783252716,
-0.7302390933036804,
0.9500872492790222,
-0.4981094002723694,
-0.23273611068725586,
0.03838116675615311,
-0.2357758730649948,
-0.6215823888778687,
1.1099152565002441,
0.028542278334498405,
-0.27089881896972656,
-0.7387780547142029,
-0.036192718893289566,
0.9013407826423645,
-0.6506399512290955,
-0.4228760600090027,
0.9162578582763672,
0.4865632653236389,
-0.009790493175387383,
-0.7666157484054565,
-0.15000011026859283,
-0.23793186247348785,
0.18560202419757843,
0.06652717292308807,
-0.3520629405975342,
0.6472532153129578,
-0.17723247408866882,
-0.4364965856075287,
0.20010557770729065,
0.7767094969749451,
-0.014484882354736328,
-0.19566571712493896,
0.5419536828994751,
0.5438030362129211,
0.019935939460992813,
0.16255344450473785,
1.1509486436843872,
-0.6438737511634827,
0.12672317028045654,
1.0400222539901733,
-0.5186684131622314,
1.0126259326934814,
0.5379568338394165,
-0.17959319055080414,
0.37600579857826233,
0.8709291815757751,
0.39856210350990295,
0.7776246666908264,
-0.24677489697933197,
-0.2469848245382309,
-0.5843077301979065,
0.01174324844032526,
0.2355535477399826,
0.3401084244251251,
0.5975008606910706,
-0.46963152289390564,
-0.21163518726825714,
0.13664419949054718,
-0.05197122320532799,
-0.29997843503952026,
-0.17565953731536865,
0.6976751089096069,
0.06281513720750809,
-1.1212199926376343,
0.3511929512023926,
0.2455611526966095,
0.08593281358480453,
-0.5664303302764893,
-0.0855679139494896,
-0.17521679401397705,
0.021131547167897224,
0.13877485692501068,
-0.9864709973335266,
0.3451165556907654,
-0.11577939987182617,
0.02537585236132145,
-0.6862767934799194,
0.5368067622184753,
-0.6808190941810608,
-0.2594296336174011,
0.5230674147605896,
0.6435715556144714,
0.1554090529680252,
-0.009080358780920506,
-0.5731630921363831,
0.07877694815397263,
-0.08830996602773666,
-0.6697279214859009,
0.03623081371188164,
0.5209051370620728,
-0.216121107339859,
0.4073250889778137,
0.25695663690567017,
0.03986499831080437,
0.6310039162635803,
0.22819462418556213,
0.3867419362068176,
-0.7727414965629578,
-0.7042554020881653,
-0.44367796182632446,
0.3132719397544861,
0.07428735494613647,
-0.4324004352092743,
0.4005758464336395,
0.32551780343055725,
0.36577749252319336,
-0.21578308939933777,
0.6708880662918091,
-0.26023417711257935,
0.3526569902896881,
-0.1595780998468399,
0.7246564030647278,
-0.642450749874115,
-0.16377973556518555,
-0.1953335553407669,
-0.7471232414245605,
-0.2101447433233261,
0.3043592870235443,
0.02470587007701397,
-0.33537861704826355,
1.0694090127944946,
0.5686632990837097,
-0.244672030210495,
-0.3138958513736725,
0.5268487334251404,
0.41061732172966003,
0.13216373324394226,
0.254867285490036,
0.3804796040058136,
-0.32359224557876587,
0.4108048379421234,
-0.43677955865859985,
-0.19438302516937256,
-0.48522964119911194,
-0.5563565492630005,
-0.8307593464851379,
-0.9561039805412292,
-0.4689592719078064,
-0.2256935089826584,
-0.05114822834730148,
0.7121071219444275,
0.8778272271156311,
-0.6066454648971558,
-0.5109623670578003,
0.026020878925919533,
-0.08029794692993164,
-0.7324206233024597,
-0.26427456736564636,
0.2895881235599518,
-0.1619601994752884,
-0.8665350675582886,
0.469259649515152,
0.4385705292224884,
0.18889307975769043,
-0.38409167528152466,
0.08408442884683609,
-0.33837202191352844,
-0.15665361285209656,
0.7507561445236206,
0.2501595616340637,
-0.8129034638404846,
-0.18299360573291779,
0.4265371859073639,
-0.4355292320251465,
-0.11327912658452988,
1.2852078676223755,
-0.33837321400642395,
0.05676237866282463,
0.6757133603096008,
0.7326403856277466,
0.6047549843788147,
0.009649211540818214,
0.9019894003868103,
-0.8205503225326538,
-0.02753281407058239,
0.3763941824436188,
0.3437790274620056,
0.11094192415475845,
-0.3438173830509186,
0.5080954432487488,
0.36718446016311646,
-0.4156613051891327,
-0.6198810935020447,
0.2506648004055023,
-1.1290147304534912,
-0.3287769854068756,
1.185951590538025,
-0.11006695032119751,
-0.9700151681900024,
-0.25469499826431274,
0.34931808710098267,
0.5653409957885742,
-0.4521805942058563,
0.424932062625885,
0.7911084890365601,
-0.38372135162353516,
0.057718630880117416,
-0.4583587646484375,
0.28621768951416016,
0.12391775101423264,
-0.6710323691368103,
0.1340140700340271,
0.6297727227210999,
0.05664911866188049,
0.22423650324344635,
0.6063645482063293,
-0.3369465172290802,
0.3855198323726654,
0.41006168723106384,
0.5094645619392395,
0.2508701682090759,
-0.4226636290550232,
0.07392533123493195,
0.26466235518455505,
0.058520104736089706,
-0.3193016052246094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03098v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03098v1
|
FairMonitor: A Dual-framework for Detecting Stereotypes and Biases in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-06T01:23:07 | 2024-05-06T01:23:07 |
Yanhong Bai, Jiabao Zhao, Jinxin Shi, Zhentao Xie, Xingjiao Wu, Liang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Detecting stereotypes and biases in Large Language Models (LLMs) is crucial
for enhancing fairness and reducing adverse impacts on individuals or groups
when these models are applied. Traditional methods, which rely on embedding
spaces or are based on probability metrics, fall short in revealing the nuanced
and implicit biases present in various contexts. To address this challenge, we
propose the FairMonitor framework and adopt a static-dynamic detection method
for a comprehensive evaluation of stereotypes and biases in LLMs. The static
component consists of a direct inquiry test, an implicit association test, and
an unknown situation test, including 10,262 open-ended questions with 9
sensitive factors and 26 educational scenarios. And it is effective for
evaluating both explicit and implicit biases. Moreover, we utilize the
multi-agent system to construst the dynamic scenarios for detecting subtle
biases in more complex and realistic setting. This component detects the biases
based on the interaction behaviors of LLMs across 600 varied educational
scenarios. The experimental results show that the cooperation of static and
dynamic methods can detect more stereotypes and biased in LLMs.
|
[
-0.5098633766174316,
-0.953091025352478,
0.6430848836898804,
0.0903591737151146,
0.19946376979351044,
0.1342073529958725,
-0.4381653964519501,
-0.22906649112701416,
-0.030170058831572533,
0.27102673053741455,
-0.5065460205078125,
-0.7437929511070251,
-0.5569520592689514,
-0.014762725681066513,
-0.15484754741191864,
0.9186002016067505,
-0.06595553457736969,
0.2768539786338806,
-0.3085007667541504,
-0.19386038184165955,
-0.5875789523124695,
-0.3826823830604553,
-0.7047181725502014,
-0.2110842913389206,
0.18353089690208435,
0.3495073914527893,
0.570486307144165,
0.1965361386537552,
0.35582873225212097,
0.37856370210647583,
-0.25084179639816284,
0.18544182181358337,
-0.4324735403060913,
0.47507989406585693,
-0.35253214836120605,
-0.5576716065406799,
-0.3763814866542816,
0.31596672534942627,
0.6111201643943787,
0.49481773376464844,
0.0067202262580394745,
0.5321007370948792,
0.07210800796747208,
0.2785959541797638,
-0.7915025949478149,
0.4477989077568054,
-0.5418838858604431,
0.305607408285141,
-0.34354010224342346,
0.005413302686065435,
-0.16280250251293182,
-0.33992695808410645,
-0.28175657987594604,
-0.3579358756542206,
0.2246558666229248,
-0.009198631159961224,
0.4280582666397095,
0.160706028342247,
-0.8750539422035217,
-0.17651519179344177,
-0.371867835521698,
1.0745782852172852,
-0.573436439037323,
0.34279265999794006,
-0.0038667526096105576,
0.6455761790275574,
-0.31649309396743774,
-0.24990932643413544,
-0.6650352478027344,
-0.27735045552253723,
0.010972240008413792,
-0.0064001539722085,
0.08234865218400955,
0.05863168090581894,
0.4044409394264221,
0.11911655962467194,
-0.37813177704811096,
0.19133888185024261,
0.05896409600973129,
-0.31478920578956604,
0.4936266541481018,
0.1624642014503479,
0.4793373942375183,
-0.26581740379333496,
-0.20083200931549072,
-0.08839137852191925,
-0.2873843312263489,
0.12348998337984085,
0.7067277431488037,
0.31405553221702576,
-0.2616618573665619,
0.2356872409582138,
-0.043407198041677475,
0.3576371669769287,
0.12711487710475922,
-0.4091702699661255,
0.5348568558692932,
-0.2246892899274826,
0.12886200845241547,
0.23507876694202423,
0.47059035301208496,
0.6150354743003845,
0.6055562496185303,
0.11100370436906815,
-0.5977418422698975,
0.5113727450370789,
-0.2337421029806137,
-0.6253754496574402,
0.17973393201828003,
0.0719614326953888,
-0.5254286527633667,
-0.6125875115394592,
-0.13307958841323853,
-1.3131000995635986,
-0.762747585773468,
-0.33012330532073975,
0.07933555543422699,
0.06543701142072678,
-0.5517273545265198,
0.18194974958896637,
-0.13831426203250885,
-0.03902454301714897,
0.37579214572906494,
-0.429522305727005,
0.33556097745895386,
0.6919507384300232,
0.6696409583091736,
-0.10859435796737671,
-0.00016351557860616595,
-0.9062206745147705,
-0.012490539811551571,
0.028572039678692818,
0.6472448706626892,
-0.6867009401321411,
-0.023718176409602165,
0.35675933957099915,
-0.11017238348722458,
0.17450717091560364,
-0.586631178855896,
0.6689542531967163,
-0.39199697971343994,
0.27755191922187805,
-0.23751333355903625,
-0.36632809042930603,
-0.025405073538422585,
0.5349577069282532,
-0.6594934463500977,
1.075955867767334,
-0.012050136923789978,
-0.9729400873184204,
0.49502065777778625,
-0.5162409543991089,
-0.15850022435188293,
-0.3422311544418335,
-0.6288256049156189,
-0.21978704631328583,
0.07927053421735764,
0.323893278837204,
0.38623350858688354,
-0.3205723166465759,
0.919338047504425,
-0.6499369144439697,
-0.5885286927223206,
0.2769539952278137,
-0.8586564064025879,
0.8869670629501343,
0.07917273789644241,
-0.6457923650741577,
0.011458075605332851,
-0.7142913341522217,
-0.39359164237976074,
0.2478208988904953,
-0.2735195457935333,
-0.5154313445091248,
0.11888410896062851,
0.06295167654752731,
0.5097467303276062,
0.26812535524368286,
-0.6076821684837341,
-0.09306406229734421,
-0.09530597180128098,
-0.3232651650905609,
1.1898682117462158,
-0.26656967401504517,
0.38765865564346313,
-0.2144409567117691,
0.6945641040802002,
0.25228917598724365,
0.18702273070812225,
0.22201693058013916,
-0.16668309271335602,
-0.7289460897445679,
-0.5286213755607605,
-0.16995282471179962,
0.5999093055725098,
-0.47300824522972107,
0.3924855887889862,
-0.1452043354511261,
0.15471304953098297,
-0.43142905831336975,
0.32397350668907166,
0.46981775760650635,
0.3635682463645935,
0.0814388245344162,
-0.14575232565402985,
-0.44213929772377014,
-0.810832142829895,
-0.6783205270767212,
0.01680457405745983,
0.07082144170999527,
0.2383529245853424,
0.4430788457393646,
-0.1407085806131363,
0.8553824424743652,
-0.3660558760166168,
-0.3231498599052429,
-0.02983773499727249,
-0.13172747194766998,
0.369427889585495,
0.20708376169204712,
1.002363920211792,
-0.7249478697776794,
-0.3552076816558838,
-0.45024538040161133,
-0.907223105430603,
-0.6053653359413147,
0.33568689227104187,
-0.03504175692796707,
0.05123181641101837,
0.6337378621101379,
-0.35696664452552795,
0.25093764066696167,
0.6032074689865112,
-0.6609441637992859,
0.56093430519104,
0.27923911809921265,
0.2368280589580536,
-0.6799964308738708,
-0.17675474286079407,
0.349575012922287,
-0.44744452834129333,
-0.4391060471534729,
0.03936794772744179,
-0.2521585524082184,
0.13295716047286987,
-0.3799888491630554,
0.9777423143386841,
-0.4038064479827881,
0.10910102725028992,
-0.14201268553733826,
0.5152629017829895,
-0.019907034933567047,
0.2529527246952057,
-0.3487702012062073,
0.7533356547355652,
0.4733181297779083,
-0.27689462900161743,
0.404645711183548,
-0.1317606121301651,
-0.5591272115707397,
0.8288435935974121,
-0.3501465618610382,
-0.024906054139137268,
-0.5385578274726868,
0.4340406060218811,
-0.8599356412887573,
-0.04623245447874069,
0.39585641026496887,
-0.20147554576396942,
0.14972935616970062,
-0.21731984615325928,
-0.601990282535553,
-0.29827433824539185,
-0.736439049243927,
0.5343137979507446,
0.2888205647468567,
-0.7167090177536011,
0.5468814373016357,
0.6955382823944092,
-0.15994247794151306,
-0.8585099577903748,
-0.3531218469142914,
-0.18868200480937958,
-0.3444923758506775,
-0.617195188999176,
-0.2288515567779541,
-0.014942587353289127,
-0.9305652976036072,
-0.09523124992847443,
-0.321744829416275,
0.04622776806354523,
0.3114524483680725,
0.1243017241358757,
0.28011301159858704,
-0.1995760053396225,
0.15679968893527985,
0.23372091352939606,
0.10580587387084961,
0.14207245409488678,
-0.15134696662425995,
0.6601356863975525,
-0.34803491830825806,
-0.3497958779335022,
-0.27908313274383545,
0.13667374849319458,
0.6946685314178467,
-0.18575379252433777,
0.7242467403411865,
0.7815114259719849,
-0.2803693413734436,
-0.4898264408111572,
-0.7640318870544434,
-0.31013810634613037,
-0.5508279204368591,
0.6162405014038086,
-0.27515605092048645,
-0.9417510628700256,
0.5659672617912292,
0.01329761277884245,
-0.0026454245671629906,
0.028566041961312294,
0.49007558822631836,
0.3056953251361847,
1.346736192703247,
0.6236099004745483,
-0.2000061720609665,
0.4977662265300751,
0.1607218235731125,
0.36857345700263977,
-0.42482638359069824,
-0.26512157917022705,
-0.492963045835495,
-0.3169535994529724,
-0.6604354977607727,
-0.5457373857498169,
0.4422799348831177,
-0.14026129245758057,
-0.5035274624824524,
-0.4997286796569824,
-0.3069724440574646,
0.4262353479862213,
0.33443763852119446,
-0.08499561250209808,
0.4455978274345398,
0.03748418390750885,
-0.36970415711402893,
-0.13206125795841217,
-0.2023765593767166,
-0.8533008098602295,
0.9493368268013,
0.5502323508262634,
0.6088517904281616,
0.419341117143631,
0.5408633351325989,
0.3605433702468872,
0.6533967852592468,
-0.7200239896774292,
0.7334198355674744,
-0.2933662235736847,
-0.8820177316665649,
-0.0005923015996813774,
-0.6383756399154663,
-0.3456406891345978,
0.46796491742134094,
-0.30213430523872375,
-0.8089231848716736,
0.2975727319717407,
0.30664750933647156,
0.1183258667588234,
0.39251577854156494,
-0.35789185762405396,
0.8004799485206604,
-0.2557169198989868,
-0.409104585647583,
-0.11356160044670105,
-0.3152306377887726,
0.7799056768417358,
-0.25885942578315735,
0.7729041576385498,
-0.6289171576499939,
0.03979695588350296,
0.6893042922019958,
-0.02165340818464756,
0.9253213405609131,
-0.5701727867126465,
-0.31726083159446716,
0.09142535924911499,
0.21679075062274933,
0.44828173518180847,
0.2783215343952179,
-0.43769335746765137,
0.06019255891442299,
-0.11425689607858658,
-0.19034524261951447,
-0.5159183144569397,
0.7471107244491577,
-0.6755843162536621,
-0.6160517930984497,
-0.6508253216743469,
-0.6963424682617188,
-0.37048089504241943,
0.20498919486999512,
-0.32492467761039734,
0.29802125692367554,
-0.29149138927459717,
-0.18535299599170685,
0.6170176863670349,
-0.6243609189987183,
-0.1095459833741188,
0.735711395740509,
-0.4747536778450012,
0.13064926862716675,
0.5250154137611389,
-0.22759966552257538,
0.030973680317401886,
-0.028557514771819115,
0.3110954463481903,
-0.13242414593696594,
-0.16992463171482086,
-0.024867361411452293,
0.31905555725097656,
-0.7060351967811584,
-0.15551245212554932,
-0.6262446045875549,
0.13012921810150146,
-0.659679114818573,
-0.013141407631337643,
-0.3638002872467041,
-0.04967086389660835,
0.11099708825349808,
-0.18198353052139282,
0.19710177183151245,
0.375732421875,
-0.24904398620128632,
0.164761021733284,
-0.32550859451293945,
0.31374308466911316,
0.2869374454021454,
0.2878623902797699,
0.05704690143465996,
-0.4994547367095947,
0.2320403754711151,
0.01075733546167612,
-0.07987098395824432,
-0.7015359997749329,
0.23035143315792084,
0.09791675955057144,
0.6842027902603149,
0.7040219306945801,
0.1210426613688469,
0.028530079871416092,
-0.48511359095573425,
0.46507593989372253,
0.16449084877967834,
-0.9501172304153442,
0.23698878288269043,
-0.3443484902381897,
-0.11388017237186432,
0.6849261522293091,
0.09292377531528473,
-0.5666826367378235,
-0.8306023478507996,
-0.11665071547031403,
-0.6052678823471069,
0.8022357225418091,
-0.20318634808063507,
0.24873901903629303,
-0.1788456290960312,
0.12525178492069244,
-0.060937266796827316,
0.39131563901901245,
-0.7476568222045898,
-0.4658143222332001,
-0.0426286906003952,
-0.6336632966995239,
-0.1539926528930664,
-0.29328653216362,
-0.313918799161911,
-0.10908851772546768,
0.47600188851356506,
-0.035466268658638,
0.003939000889658928,
-0.37215477228164673,
-0.08184782415628433,
0.13638709485530853,
0.5424667596817017,
0.14780572056770325,
0.24205204844474792,
-0.5463040471076965,
0.4749172329902649,
0.11508342623710632,
-0.4561004340648651,
0.3004836440086365,
0.21811223030090332,
-0.20500019192695618,
0.128625750541687,
0.1700257807970047,
0.51421058177948,
0.13315871357917786,
-0.9100196361541748,
1.0407296419143677,
-0.16584818065166473,
0.23790666460990906,
-0.3244926333427429,
0.15062743425369263,
-0.257980078458786,
0.44301584362983704,
-0.11098108440637589,
-0.09089290350675583,
0.3188013732433319,
-0.8805837035179138,
0.18535181879997253,
0.5232546329498291,
-0.44088637828826904,
-0.2821630537509918,
0.504652202129364,
0.40212756395339966,
0.08549731224775314,
0.40190067887306213,
-0.35672903060913086,
-0.8035756945610046,
0.9010169506072998,
0.5775931477546692,
0.6166589856147766,
-0.24762026965618134,
0.43329447507858276,
0.07274123281240463,
0.36314061284065247,
-0.25175461173057556,
0.25229284167289734,
0.15860699117183685,
-1.2078371047973633,
-0.07070472836494446,
-0.736543595790863,
0.004229055251926184,
0.14953745901584625,
-0.6174240112304688,
0.41811469197273254,
-0.3544479310512543,
-0.288002610206604,
-0.09244893491268158,
0.08441899716854095,
-0.9338849186897278,
0.019392646849155426,
0.3645358383655548,
0.8654642105102539,
-1.1951797008514404,
0.3812323212623596,
0.8451644778251648,
-0.1714845895767212,
-0.5838885307312012,
0.1763709932565689,
0.7697057723999023,
-0.8314673900604248,
0.9805967807769775,
0.4436238706111908,
-0.5037328004837036,
-0.401141494512558,
-0.41064053773880005,
-0.459189236164093,
0.6765785217285156,
0.6167715191841125,
-0.6675899028778076,
0.11463911086320877,
-0.12714771926403046,
0.4973330497741699,
-0.1978210061788559,
0.41307905316352844,
0.6850041151046753,
0.7833734750747681,
-0.436208039522171,
-0.830563485622406,
0.16834791004657745,
-0.2859891951084137,
-0.2799760699272156,
0.1143699586391449,
-0.6844923496246338,
0.9110733866691589,
0.1476813554763794,
-0.1706198751926422,
-0.29916319251060486,
0.40600407123565674,
0.5303153395652771,
0.6577691435813904,
0.8795015215873718,
0.17065133154392242,
0.9680889248847961,
0.04301713779568672,
0.7595640420913696,
-0.3341732621192932,
0.43919917941093445,
0.9221067428588867,
-0.6011939644813538,
0.17215131223201752,
0.34405770897865295,
0.03079533763229847,
0.45311057567596436,
0.17483767867088318,
0.08544725179672241,
0.4040067493915558,
0.5757371187210083,
-0.7447014451026917,
-0.32951420545578003,
-0.53850257396698,
-0.28590959310531616,
0.4634115993976593,
0.43172577023506165,
-0.08583395928144455,
-0.3485715389251709,
0.17155545949935913,
0.6055984497070312,
0.4611753523349762,
-0.32911217212677,
0.13754120469093323,
0.1920996457338333,
-0.3961780071258545,
-0.029473239555954933,
0.33341842889785767,
1.2757993936538696,
-0.3070793151855469,
0.07928545773029327,
-0.46334946155548096,
0.48675116896629333,
-0.026782508939504623,
-0.641943633556366,
-0.17019051313400269,
0.2598598301410675,
-0.2007821500301361,
-0.11355513334274292,
0.82976233959198,
-0.5215809345245361,
-0.4475158751010895,
0.6648170948028564,
0.6439756751060486,
-0.021136879920959473,
0.20074310898780823,
-0.5857272744178772,
0.15488213300704956,
-0.18144585192203522,
-0.23818565905094147,
0.35044461488723755,
0.5428147315979004,
-0.2713170647621155,
0.5903311371803284,
0.2993747293949127,
0.12024836987257004,
0.06080688163638115,
0.4434466063976288,
0.7191336750984192,
-0.2533431649208069,
-0.35189300775527954,
-0.6019097566604614,
0.09427691251039505,
-0.31922757625579834,
-0.0357978455722332,
0.8426076173782349,
0.34790974855422974,
0.7732491493225098,
0.0605720579624176,
0.8071991801261902,
0.22409114241600037,
0.4774584174156189,
-0.398806631565094,
0.5384569764137268,
-0.7740049362182617,
0.5088982582092285,
-0.4482250213623047,
-0.9521320462226868,
-0.23728424310684204,
0.7730226516723633,
-0.4493197798728943,
0.33767572045326233,
0.4990219175815582,
0.8729875683784485,
-0.37688300013542175,
-0.1661122739315033,
0.06045721471309662,
0.31909215450286865,
0.5203315019607544,
0.3436067998409271,
0.9382180571556091,
0.04647987708449364,
0.3507949709892273,
0.14174243807792664,
-0.5400782823562622,
-0.18876570463180542,
-0.7697473764419556,
-1.2355577945709229,
0.08452479541301727,
-0.24390143156051636,
-0.44310101866722107,
0.4089074730873108,
1.1332335472106934,
0.311073362827301,
-0.8262158632278442,
-0.2598739564418793,
0.4051644206047058,
0.3955972492694855,
0.05673838034272194,
-0.3689102232456207,
0.22497844696044922,
-0.34176450967788696,
-0.9553723335266113,
0.2514044940471649,
0.1233697459101677,
-0.30175283551216125,
-0.3390008211135864,
0.11686960607767105,
-0.012369941920042038,
0.265415757894516,
0.540963351726532,
-0.07250775396823883,
-0.26885831356048584,
-0.6092778444290161,
-0.33201658725738525,
-0.2085120677947998,
-0.3299599885940552,
0.6893995404243469,
-0.6153335571289062,
0.35443806648254395,
0.46406465768814087,
0.3223748505115509,
-0.02181287109851837,
-0.2703319787979126,
0.49987056851387024,
-0.8686085939407349,
0.576654314994812,
0.16375963389873505,
0.3685717284679413,
0.2714487910270691,
-0.24605101346969604,
0.2108563482761383,
0.34189486503601074,
-0.33264800906181335,
-1.1415936946868896,
0.30392006039619446,
-0.7243006229400635,
-0.2327444851398468,
1.2356293201446533,
-0.009644664824008942,
0.09253156930208206,
-0.36561286449432373,
0.07060698419809341,
0.3415949046611786,
-0.6046891212463379,
0.7739923596382141,
0.5578928589820862,
0.3059028387069702,
0.2524924576282501,
-1.0115628242492676,
0.3576809763908386,
0.35181236267089844,
-0.6484472155570984,
-0.17182698845863342,
0.7192972302436829,
0.5894301533699036,
-0.0021292183082550764,
0.6838087439537048,
-0.24464479088783264,
-0.056268200278282166,
-0.26742807030677795,
0.059683267027139664,
0.028241092339158058,
-0.28922024369239807,
-0.3106873631477356,
0.02422749251127243,
-0.144484281539917,
0.03001660667359829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03097v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03097v1
|
To Each (Textual Sequence) Its Own: Improving Memorized-Data Unlearning in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-06T01:21:50 | 2024-05-06T01:21:50 |
George-Octavian Barbulescu, Peter Triantafillou
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
LLMs have been found to memorize training textual sequences and regurgitate
verbatim said sequences during text generation time. This fact is known to be
the cause of privacy and related (e.g., copyright) problems. Unlearning in LLMs
then takes the form of devising new algorithms that will properly deal with
these side-effects of memorized data, while not hurting the model's utility. We
offer a fresh perspective towards this goal, namely, that each textual sequence
to be forgotten should be treated differently when being unlearned based on its
degree of memorization within the LLM. We contribute a new metric for measuring
unlearning quality, an adversarial attack showing that SOTA algorithms lacking
this perspective fail for privacy, and two new unlearning methods based on
Gradient Ascent and Task Arithmetic, respectively. A comprehensive performance
evaluation across an extensive suite of NLP tasks then mapped the solution
space, identifying the best solutions under different scales in model
capacities and forget set sizes and quantified the gains of the new approaches.
|
[
0.06066471338272095,
-0.5369297862052917,
0.3918572664260864,
-0.013449525460600853,
-0.2378852665424347,
0.24682146310806274,
-0.2338889241218567,
-0.11876999586820602,
-0.047646213322877884,
0.7669764757156372,
-0.4526815414428711,
-0.6549282670021057,
-0.6888402104377747,
-0.05987584590911865,
-0.7187570333480835,
1.1830532550811768,
0.22290746867656708,
0.20059342682361603,
-0.31894704699516296,
-0.20603537559509277,
-0.2770034074783325,
-0.799298107624054,
-0.5218018293380737,
-0.382838636636734,
0.5199063420295715,
0.47804513573646545,
0.5525807738304138,
0.855379581451416,
0.44363895058631897,
0.3554992377758026,
-0.35612475872039795,
0.24855276942253113,
-0.7653795480728149,
0.11703610420227051,
-0.22414612770080566,
-0.5447983741760254,
-0.4063030779361725,
-0.2575052082538605,
0.935641884803772,
0.7087205648422241,
-0.2806488275527954,
0.3060142695903778,
0.31919312477111816,
0.9748733043670654,
-0.6269180774688721,
-0.10617973655462265,
-0.5412281155586243,
0.12714733183383942,
-0.1642439067363739,
-0.40133923292160034,
-0.5271309614181519,
-0.28057846426963806,
0.01667504943907261,
-0.5011457800865173,
0.31067442893981934,
-0.10815074294805527,
0.4445066452026367,
0.3432695269584656,
-0.1912923902273178,
-0.3692450523376465,
-0.708214282989502,
0.8963077664375305,
-0.7792946100234985,
0.30330678820610046,
0.25046005845069885,
-0.09066987037658691,
-0.3403456509113312,
-0.8377881050109863,
-0.13490800559520721,
0.18283791840076447,
0.16244681179523468,
0.12937085330486298,
-0.13345664739608765,
-0.10042790323495865,
0.1840028464794159,
0.4939814805984497,
-0.454546719789505,
0.3624371588230133,
-0.3812413811683655,
-0.16017788648605347,
0.869368851184845,
0.2359318733215332,
0.13395075500011444,
0.005180328153073788,
-0.34054237604141235,
0.06449596583843231,
-1.0347495079040527,
0.04013894125819206,
0.5370969176292419,
0.19113029539585114,
0.24079202115535736,
0.38944610953330994,
-0.038487184792757034,
0.2462437003850937,
-0.2210189402103424,
-0.11881983280181885,
0.2308519184589386,
-0.011323638260364532,
-0.28295886516571045,
-0.06484085321426392,
0.929105818271637,
0.06350371986627579,
0.31663092970848083,
-0.5236393809318542,
-0.2292773574590683,
-0.3869380056858063,
0.32175543904304504,
-0.4680434465408325,
-0.278433620929718,
0.1310892254114151,
-0.5741590261459351,
-0.07700827717781067,
-0.017227159813046455,
-0.883736789226532,
-0.635159969329834,
-0.4829619526863098,
0.4911382496356964,
-0.5212633013725281,
0.01421782374382019,
0.22697985172271729,
-0.025510624051094055,
-0.24901552498340607,
0.2528328001499176,
-0.9445647597312927,
0.3517298698425293,
0.6846930980682373,
0.5910181999206543,
-0.20065221190452576,
-0.5465632081031799,
-0.35492318868637085,
0.041377484798431396,
-0.35214102268218994,
0.444097101688385,
-0.36043062806129456,
-0.5712263584136963,
0.04517095163464546,
-0.08391548693180084,
-0.030197663232684135,
-0.6483711004257202,
0.30619755387306213,
-0.5365815162658691,
0.42537787556648254,
-0.4137864112854004,
-1.0034698247909546,
-0.32986244559288025,
-0.10760864615440369,
-0.6123912334442139,
0.8663425445556641,
-0.2504316568374634,
-0.6995851993560791,
0.07632686197757721,
-0.543788492679596,
-0.30069097876548767,
-0.01054936833679676,
-0.01210488099604845,
-0.5812234282493591,
0.406978040933609,
0.03820289671421051,
0.6270624399185181,
-0.28462475538253784,
0.33600088953971863,
-0.0662091076374054,
-0.35283392667770386,
0.4245569407939911,
-0.49551260471343994,
0.8167012929916382,
0.20227012038230896,
-0.1489676833152771,
0.10888051241636276,
-0.9098784327507019,
0.09135955572128296,
0.23958046734333038,
-0.5648218393325806,
-0.304325133562088,
0.084499791264534,
-0.32207316160202026,
-0.06053290516138077,
0.4289505183696747,
-0.38803571462631226,
-0.017588602378964424,
-0.5302315950393677,
0.5075377821922302,
0.9884719252586365,
0.07077313959598541,
0.7586620450019836,
-0.49623236060142517,
0.19013723731040955,
0.004686387255787849,
0.18201279640197754,
-0.47312161326408386,
-0.3171062171459198,
-0.7392808794975281,
-0.15270332992076874,
0.3010784685611725,
0.5135512948036194,
-0.2653946876525879,
0.3104826509952545,
-0.21774820983409882,
-0.426168292760849,
-0.46549534797668457,
0.5787842869758606,
0.7197793126106262,
0.15954631567001343,
0.23275986313819885,
-0.5849728584289551,
-0.4813230633735657,
-0.4850336015224457,
-0.5394169092178345,
0.004737490322440863,
-0.028737779706716537,
-0.027319585904479027,
0.5076423287391663,
-0.16105547547340393,
0.7196333408355713,
-0.2646148204803467,
-0.4155140221118927,
-0.029493091627955437,
0.13425768911838531,
-0.07660702615976334,
0.3346673846244812,
0.05891460180282593,
-0.6222128868103027,
-0.0735199823975563,
-0.21770380437374115,
-1.0491997003555298,
0.26811784505844116,
-0.07507719844579697,
0.12966540455818176,
0.3832184672355652,
0.6124920845031738,
-0.33248457312583923,
0.3690430521965027,
0.3307913839817047,
-0.0990479588508606,
0.2677709460258484,
-0.4695073664188385,
-0.13276003301143646,
-1.0508041381835938,
-0.11144993454217911,
-0.427828848361969,
-0.09784812480211258,
-0.7518182396888733,
0.11900565773248672,
0.12302601337432861,
0.11006931960582733,
-0.6606482863426208,
0.42121121287345886,
-0.619952917098999,
-0.2745700478553772,
-0.24009263515472412,
0.09536870568990707,
-0.07205551117658615,
0.6684409379959106,
-0.3547692596912384,
0.7369683384895325,
0.3389672040939331,
-0.7899609804153442,
0.267918199300766,
0.3075708746910095,
-0.27884453535079956,
0.07044698297977448,
-0.23496221005916595,
0.3394550383090973,
-0.4813041687011719,
-0.1181805431842804,
-0.8927028775215149,
0.06404029577970505,
-0.1905602514743805,
-0.6165306568145752,
0.554429829120636,
0.14679446816444397,
-0.589816689491272,
-0.038032110780477524,
-0.38020220398902893,
0.3703884184360504,
0.5695956945419312,
-0.6813342571258545,
0.3943093717098236,
0.49177202582359314,
-0.038436878472566605,
-1.0410860776901245,
-0.4906175434589386,
0.21143202483654022,
-0.3940255641937256,
-0.3432537913322449,
0.2878700792789459,
-0.04137543588876724,
-0.17075957357883453,
-0.0926230251789093,
-0.12416792660951614,
-0.12375430762767792,
0.23831228911876678,
0.4667910635471344,
0.02078397572040558,
0.00880277156829834,
0.28930994868278503,
-0.33219942450523376,
-0.20911049842834473,
0.22735294699668884,
-0.5381984114646912,
0.6570256948471069,
-0.07145556807518005,
-0.2964858412742615,
-0.29348546266555786,
0.34159067273139954,
0.32108208537101746,
-0.22978243231773376,
0.7431617379188538,
0.2708439826965332,
-0.4309307336807251,
-0.30030328035354614,
-0.46908512711524963,
0.009020873345434666,
-0.46969980001449585,
0.4546516239643097,
-0.006402087397873402,
-0.9598608016967773,
0.6594393849372864,
-0.12637974321842194,
0.44651171565055847,
0.28499293327331543,
0.6436878442764282,
-0.36116111278533936,
0.5918431282043457,
0.915310263633728,
-0.29919594526290894,
0.43090111017227173,
-0.3917323350906372,
0.33987879753112793,
-0.6742726564407349,
-0.5011863112449646,
-0.3955513536930084,
-0.3182600438594818,
-0.6324265003204346,
-0.18415305018424988,
0.10797645896673203,
0.27487489581108093,
-0.3591643273830414,
0.22356979548931122,
-0.2728366255760193,
0.6785461902618408,
0.7205655574798584,
0.1643579751253128,
0.700062096118927,
0.16364413499832153,
0.05425669252872467,
-0.09449654072523117,
-0.6110885739326477,
-0.7009188532829285,
1.4924381971359253,
0.43159815669059753,
0.7307724356651306,
0.17562507092952728,
1.0897693634033203,
0.14622879028320312,
0.2954648435115814,
-0.5553928017616272,
0.6135355234146118,
-0.6074254512786865,
-0.5514768958091736,
-0.4562755525112152,
-0.5188330411911011,
-1.0739696025848389,
0.006446364801377058,
0.013784153386950493,
-0.9086862802505493,
-0.14925183355808258,
0.17813298106193542,
-0.38940808176994324,
0.6249686479568481,
-0.440375417470932,
0.6649073362350464,
-0.19878384470939636,
-0.3844219744205475,
-0.11090884357690811,
-0.6257302761077881,
0.4279545545578003,
-0.37147805094718933,
0.18152447044849396,
-0.0683857724070549,
-0.041706379503011703,
1.024269700050354,
-0.197726771235466,
0.9733825922012329,
0.03251349925994873,
-0.25424647331237793,
0.16190016269683838,
0.024691270664334297,
0.2594928741455078,
-0.07006441801786423,
0.05139946565032005,
0.3482913672924042,
-0.12107819318771362,
-0.31153109669685364,
-0.5309728980064392,
0.6400583982467651,
-0.6897997856140137,
-0.493399441242218,
-0.20415517687797546,
-0.5703296661376953,
-0.09141639620065689,
0.22214944660663605,
0.6982293128967285,
0.3135756254196167,
-0.49069616198539734,
0.1485460102558136,
1.097862958908081,
-0.49880367517471313,
0.7445365786552429,
0.6758890748023987,
0.0005610127118416131,
-0.26443201303482056,
0.900556743144989,
0.2724466919898987,
0.21509400010108948,
0.6627062559127808,
-0.04111291468143463,
-0.45327475666999817,
-0.6711830496788025,
-0.24062314629554749,
0.22979335486888885,
-0.9402402639389038,
-0.3029654026031494,
-0.6049097776412964,
-0.3869354724884033,
-0.3484211266040802,
0.07350890338420868,
-0.5063348412513733,
-0.4620545208454132,
-0.5473604798316956,
-0.07860211282968521,
0.37165316939353943,
0.8805873990058899,
-0.13122421503067017,
0.5024605393409729,
-0.9479048252105713,
0.21825569868087769,
0.04763443395495415,
0.252538800239563,
0.057513799518346786,
-0.8204737901687622,
-0.1982206255197525,
-0.055781204253435135,
-0.5181560516357422,
-0.5905184745788574,
0.6237465143203735,
0.19426071643829346,
0.4156029224395752,
0.23291565477848053,
-0.0781911090016365,
0.45185309648513794,
-0.6630764603614807,
0.5378483533859253,
0.20334738492965698,
-0.8725572824478149,
0.3286629915237427,
-0.23188826441764832,
0.028635693714022636,
0.321308970451355,
0.24205775558948517,
-0.5720340609550476,
-0.4364926218986511,
-0.9140040278434753,
-0.9745340943336487,
0.5053268671035767,
-0.10275759547948837,
0.3710727095603943,
0.1435060054063797,
0.623797595500946,
0.14210616052150726,
0.4875109791755676,
-0.6016680598258972,
-0.48655086755752563,
-0.027296284213662148,
-0.4504769444465637,
-0.46158015727996826,
-0.511101484298706,
-0.06430285423994064,
-0.018091002479195595,
0.5102772116661072,
0.19882328808307648,
0.27880650758743286,
-0.20207922160625458,
-0.27768781781196594,
-0.009506022557616234,
0.4640295207500458,
0.2280930131673813,
0.7305794954299927,
0.030150508508086205,
0.05916766822338104,
0.36490970849990845,
-0.46533769369125366,
0.2883772850036621,
-0.24931108951568604,
-0.3091261684894562,
-0.030019046738743782,
0.37385323643684387,
0.44633957743644714,
0.39676979184150696,
-0.634645938873291,
0.5917076468467712,
0.08851110190153122,
-0.29653385281562805,
-0.47366708517074585,
0.24810999631881714,
0.10267230123281479,
0.12404847145080566,
0.1420159488916397,
0.06720898300409317,
0.13997744023799896,
-0.604272186756134,
0.40905195474624634,
0.2942461669445038,
-0.2080184519290924,
-0.17769454419612885,
0.627407968044281,
-0.11955931037664413,
-0.4470817744731903,
0.6068423986434937,
-0.01390837598592043,
-0.40935447812080383,
0.5069170594215393,
0.5276879668235779,
0.8282533288002014,
-0.5057071447372437,
0.12271515280008316,
0.14288415014743805,
0.3053758442401886,
-0.5440446734428406,
0.22638994455337524,
0.12593580782413483,
-0.6758562326431274,
-0.4064003527164459,
-0.44282066822052,
-0.3054770231246948,
0.2946348190307617,
-0.7794435620307922,
-0.08187110722064972,
-0.7897775769233704,
0.060286346822977066,
-0.0746583566069603,
0.04950644448399544,
-0.6260712742805481,
0.2901647686958313,
-0.1710759401321411,
0.6473896503448486,
-0.7030341029167175,
0.706531822681427,
0.4371798634529114,
-0.35560142993927,
-0.5778735280036926,
-0.11260182410478592,
0.2862657308578491,
-0.9399593472480774,
0.494901567697525,
0.10468371957540512,
-0.05931815877556801,
0.09851779788732529,
-0.3371061086654663,
-0.89865642786026,
0.8199687600135803,
0.4116450548171997,
-0.698367178440094,
-0.04150109365582466,
0.2478335052728653,
0.5714657306671143,
-0.06282766163349152,
-0.1279776692390442,
0.7477734088897705,
-0.05892573669552803,
-0.20460276305675507,
-0.5539311766624451,
-0.25064918398857117,
-0.09649771451950073,
-0.13627880811691284,
0.4375842809677124,
-0.5166867971420288,
0.8264065980911255,
-0.3438880741596222,
-0.40860405564308167,
0.3309966027736664,
0.5364915728569031,
-0.1061796322464943,
0.5420035719871521,
0.08146876841783524,
0.6724222898483276,
1.1045578718185425,
-0.025140145793557167,
0.784961462020874,
0.10973062366247177,
0.20371583104133606,
1.3207368850708008,
-0.05859772115945816,
0.883828341960907,
0.17491820454597473,
-0.031784895807504654,
0.02308630757033825,
0.537453830242157,
0.1001557856798172,
0.5074200630187988,
0.438310444355011,
-0.24192777276039124,
0.14072848856449127,
0.11671819537878036,
-0.10529337078332901,
0.4315913915634155,
0.300373911857605,
-0.43535786867141724,
-0.18303541839122772,
0.08096059411764145,
0.16781477630138397,
0.5328031778335571,
-0.3068108558654785,
1.085891842842102,
0.28048160672187805,
-0.4683957099914551,
0.5967612266540527,
0.15615390241146088,
0.6407785415649414,
-0.3561375141143799,
0.3458227217197418,
-0.4592706561088562,
0.5074820518493652,
-0.3019770085811615,
-0.5740915536880493,
0.27677401900291443,
0.12328615039587021,
-0.3982418477535248,
-0.38770925998687744,
0.224781796336174,
-0.4060809910297394,
-0.30510613322257996,
0.4201526343822479,
0.5189507603645325,
0.3483634293079376,
-0.08962738513946533,
-0.598078727722168,
-0.2255946844816208,
0.1226566880941391,
-0.17124827206134796,
0.5969949960708618,
0.6330152750015259,
-0.05529773235321045,
0.8550756573677063,
0.5370669364929199,
-0.005455116741359234,
0.25979435443878174,
0.3192412257194519,
0.7058829665184021,
-0.9146746397018433,
-0.31488871574401855,
-1.0621908903121948,
0.3557504117488861,
0.04001045227050781,
-0.4112781584262848,
0.8862407803535461,
0.549720287322998,
1.0560214519500732,
0.2659924328327179,
0.5822156071662903,
0.6419804692268372,
0.6932360529899597,
-0.8495155572891235,
0.5830370783805847,
-0.5880947709083557,
0.6769477725028992,
-0.16593028604984283,
-0.8176594972610474,
-0.39431485533714294,
0.4028063714504242,
0.010287296958267689,
0.015429971739649773,
0.7608745098114014,
0.7972090244293213,
0.21776710450649261,
0.20578743517398834,
0.4280892014503479,
0.0725305899977684,
0.23159895837306976,
0.795607328414917,
1.1356542110443115,
-0.6299220323562622,
0.40869995951652527,
-0.11990109831094742,
-0.1153138130903244,
0.0303038340061903,
-0.6824871897697449,
-0.8133307099342346,
-0.7253010869026184,
-0.21787995100021362,
-0.17799845337867737,
0.25791341066360474,
0.6704275012016296,
0.30621495842933655,
-0.6431166529655457,
-0.28145456314086914,
-0.07349372655153275,
0.16778723895549774,
-0.12354055792093277,
-0.09567456692457199,
0.3836195766925812,
-0.5360841751098633,
-0.5429385900497437,
0.38075757026672363,
0.3989098072052002,
0.1560191810131073,
-0.20528778433799744,
-0.1326267570257187,
0.15832534432411194,
-0.02219841629266739,
0.4146352708339691,
0.4525451064109802,
-0.5690914392471313,
0.15825118124485016,
-0.0063159773126244545,
-0.08770382404327393,
0.13496409356594086,
1.0537899732589722,
-0.4776015877723694,
0.23326343297958374,
0.3247988224029541,
0.7930238842964172,
0.3394593894481659,
-0.04714357480406761,
0.4663492441177368,
-1.1141667366027832,
0.0816512405872345,
0.22156469523906708,
0.4229961633682251,
0.4363456666469574,
-0.4352019131183624,
0.3648574650287628,
-0.044805265963077545,
-0.6906636953353882,
-0.9255809783935547,
0.2166171669960022,
-0.3361281454563141,
-0.5965638160705566,
0.9142813682556152,
-0.3271418511867523,
-0.24599531292915344,
-0.1430359184741974,
0.1336982399225235,
0.31485843658447266,
-0.20804190635681152,
1.042264699935913,
0.6059560179710388,
0.3238499164581299,
-0.12535005807876587,
-0.596462607383728,
0.677606999874115,
0.6097730398178101,
-0.7066704034805298,
0.44500088691711426,
0.48166489601135254,
0.28395453095436096,
0.08519736677408218,
0.8224782943725586,
-0.45708420872688293,
0.16073569655418396,
-0.3119640052318573,
-0.04432526230812073,
-0.10180498659610748,
-0.7133364081382751,
-0.7054262757301331,
0.09343288838863373,
0.05709046125411987,
-0.34205231070518494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03085v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03085v1
|
Compressing Long Context for Enhancing RAG with AMR-based Concept Distillation
| 2024-05-06T00:18:43 | 2024-05-06T00:18:43 |
Kaize Shi, Xueyao Sun, Qing Li, Guandong Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have made significant strides in information
acquisition. However, their overreliance on potentially flawed parametric
knowledge leads to hallucinations and inaccuracies, particularly when handling
long-tail, domain-specific queries. Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG)
addresses this limitation by incorporating external, non-parametric knowledge.
Nevertheless, the retrieved long-context documents often contain noisy,
irrelevant information alongside vital knowledge, negatively diluting LLMs'
attention. Inspired by the supportive role of essential concepts in
individuals' reading comprehension, we propose a novel concept-based RAG
framework with the Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR)-based concept
distillation algorithm. The proposed algorithm compresses the cluttered raw
retrieved documents into a compact set of crucial concepts distilled from the
informative nodes of AMR by referring to reliable linguistic features. The
concepts explicitly constrain LLMs to focus solely on vital information in the
inference process. We conduct extensive experiments on open-domain
question-answering datasets to empirically evaluate the proposed method's
effectiveness. The results indicate that the concept-based RAG framework
outperforms other baseline methods, particularly as the number of supporting
documents increases, while also exhibiting robustness across various backbone
LLMs. This emphasizes the distilled concepts are informative for augmenting the
RAG process by filtering out interference information. To the best of our
knowledge, this is the first work introducing AMR to enhance the RAG,
presenting a potential solution to augment inference performance with
semantic-based context compression.
|
[
-0.605633020401001,
-0.7876770496368408,
0.5746267437934875,
-0.10546701401472092,
-0.7325586080551147,
0.3215448260307312,
-0.31993088126182556,
-0.5731579661369324,
0.5048412680625916,
0.5158179998397827,
-0.33657243847846985,
-0.26904797554016113,
-0.7475730180740356,
0.26132479310035706,
-0.30659279227256775,
0.9138144850730896,
-0.017301935702562332,
-0.35620903968811035,
-0.39218851923942566,
-0.14245668053627014,
-0.48732486367225647,
-0.43304911255836487,
-0.5529904961585999,
-0.5883186459541321,
0.285912424325943,
0.1960960030555725,
0.31901776790618896,
0.5293046236038208,
0.37182530760765076,
0.32076865434646606,
-0.4377158284187317,
0.5468417406082153,
-0.5006149411201477,
0.5353155732154846,
-0.2715194821357727,
-0.3449315130710602,
-0.407694011926651,
-0.15416990220546722,
0.4398568868637085,
0.6336220502853394,
-0.25726503133773804,
0.1683058738708496,
0.34055837988853455,
0.8899391889572144,
-0.7994402050971985,
0.21929748356342316,
-0.8417741060256958,
-0.2095787078142166,
-0.1341359168291092,
-0.5381121039390564,
-0.3512963652610779,
0.05469326302409172,
-0.023479264229536057,
-0.7000063061714172,
0.2938218116760254,
0.1182681992650032,
0.8556801676750183,
0.7402019500732422,
-0.3475739657878876,
-0.5428867340087891,
-0.71480792760849,
0.7393713593482971,
-0.5001112222671509,
0.2181100696325302,
0.5245623588562012,
0.170254185795784,
-0.17342530190944672,
-0.5443357825279236,
-0.8639819622039795,
0.09361707419157028,
-0.24736149609088898,
0.14748992025852203,
-0.07874730974435806,
0.03199879825115204,
0.2808946371078491,
0.39937686920166016,
-0.1737566739320755,
-0.2828225791454315,
-0.5090830326080322,
0.0032145618461072445,
0.438737154006958,
-0.1676737368106842,
-0.11566751450300217,
-0.46470558643341064,
-0.44154611229896545,
-0.1365598738193512,
-0.4158253073692322,
-0.1613621711730957,
0.05343199521303177,
0.12741097807884216,
0.14186836779117584,
0.7094074487686157,
-0.25564318895339966,
0.8274268507957458,
0.2044132649898529,
-0.2714827060699463,
0.42920538783073425,
-0.22200702130794525,
-0.07467841356992722,
0.1906234622001648,
0.366580605506897,
0.27807024121284485,
0.1045595332980156,
-0.22165943682193756,
-0.26439347863197327,
0.09940749406814575,
0.4155290126800537,
-0.6522299647331238,
0.04592803865671158,
0.3005191683769226,
-0.19899524748325348,
-0.18564850091934204,
0.07674150913953781,
-0.8234109282493591,
-0.47848519682884216,
-0.5847906470298767,
0.18809457123279572,
-0.43037423491477966,
-0.20153434574604034,
0.16738663613796234,
-0.4003565311431885,
0.0443204790353775,
0.3403370976448059,
-0.5766540169715881,
0.1942443549633026,
0.7253992557525635,
0.8365570306777954,
-0.2982061803340912,
0.1843339055776596,
-0.497658371925354,
0.5170314908027649,
-0.14530864357948303,
0.8763624429702759,
-0.5410354733467102,
-0.44034600257873535,
-0.35621243715286255,
-0.2604888081550598,
0.26879847049713135,
-0.6638801097869873,
0.7611654996871948,
-0.7717132568359375,
-0.1531168669462204,
-0.02178439125418663,
-0.6172847747802734,
-0.08117081969976425,
0.39028802514076233,
-0.7745388746261597,
0.9399905204772949,
0.03277130052447319,
-0.985811173915863,
0.18954817950725555,
-0.5649473071098328,
-0.3738509714603424,
0.053010519593954086,
-0.41555312275886536,
-0.2699560523033142,
0.3566724956035614,
0.2367512583732605,
0.34455323219299316,
-0.509089469909668,
0.18197689950466156,
-0.14765901863574982,
-0.2759847044944763,
0.3591051995754242,
-0.32640326023101807,
0.3499831259250641,
0.3115677237510681,
-0.04307091236114502,
-0.2889106571674347,
-0.805264413356781,
-0.012944480404257774,
-0.029879707843065262,
-0.2951655089855194,
-0.9691123366355896,
-0.1058758869767189,
-0.3424836993217468,
0.12311367690563202,
0.27172595262527466,
-0.5992414355278015,
-0.08434224128723145,
-0.4427453875541687,
0.24997612833976746,
0.5483313798904419,
0.36199289560317993,
0.43269824981689453,
-0.4189646542072296,
0.41406065225601196,
0.27336281538009644,
-0.49816468358039856,
-0.2446233481168747,
-0.17203785479068756,
-0.7904056310653687,
-0.40261128544807434,
0.303789347410202,
0.3309953510761261,
-1.090236783027649,
0.572920560836792,
-0.5115953683853149,
-0.13489629328250885,
-0.41491827368736267,
0.14881761372089386,
0.3989848792552948,
0.8793277740478516,
0.5815615653991699,
-0.036113716661930084,
-0.4852558672428131,
-0.606901228427887,
0.002226975979283452,
-0.11676419526338577,
-0.16824127733707428,
0.32450518012046814,
0.33310654759407043,
-0.07249899953603745,
1.0879408121109009,
-0.8400570750236511,
-0.5247056484222412,
-0.1330704241991043,
0.2959071397781372,
0.31193095445632935,
0.28771108388900757,
0.05605728551745415,
-1.19036865234375,
-0.37581974267959595,
-0.08243133127689362,
-0.5836659073829651,
-0.17488513886928558,
0.02268400974571705,
-0.18707220256328583,
0.21335440874099731,
0.6344724893569946,
-0.5402758717536926,
0.4633326232433319,
0.2885797321796417,
-0.33430376648902893,
0.43687930703163147,
-0.37306588888168335,
0.09407352656126022,
-1.4359694719314575,
0.21909545361995697,
-0.005875054281204939,
-0.1342708319425583,
-0.38091641664505005,
0.09357257187366486,
0.13563388586044312,
0.10903714597225189,
-0.1660117357969284,
0.8031491041183472,
-0.6212958097457886,
0.3261324167251587,
-0.6201136708259583,
0.21975278854370117,
0.3961733281612396,
0.3743286430835724,
0.21940074861049652,
0.6749436855316162,
-0.011254713870584965,
-0.7675552368164062,
0.09574712812900543,
0.3777085840702057,
-0.3195987343788147,
0.5790911912918091,
-0.5366083979606628,
0.13618813455104828,
-0.5118457674980164,
0.3945285379886627,
-0.7050706744194031,
-0.2871399521827698,
0.05334203690290451,
-0.43166807293891907,
0.5540577173233032,
-0.09492383152246475,
-0.349326491355896,
-0.14460068941116333,
-0.10593374073505402,
0.2989504635334015,
0.551543653011322,
-0.5121250748634338,
0.689383327960968,
0.5172435641288757,
-0.11285869032144547,
-0.9042004346847534,
-0.6610367298126221,
0.06986600160598755,
-0.5253405570983887,
-0.3870757818222046,
0.6517722010612488,
0.08005908131599426,
-0.3858294188976288,
0.17441001534461975,
-0.5481510162353516,
-0.20252884924411774,
-0.10246865451335907,
0.07737183570861816,
0.2617681920528412,
0.060956548899412155,
0.30270397663116455,
0.26854991912841797,
-0.1811566799879074,
-0.01098043005913496,
-0.18069051206111908,
0.35195234417915344,
0.2934845983982086,
-0.11244764924049377,
0.19806747138500214,
0.36403688788414,
0.386430948972702,
-0.3107205927371979,
0.6757887601852417,
0.34624338150024414,
-0.30288323760032654,
-0.5577800869941711,
-0.5961841940879822,
-0.20598940551280975,
-0.4902714192867279,
0.24978569149971008,
-0.625220775604248,
-0.9988195300102234,
0.4151381552219391,
-0.3317842483520508,
-0.042238131165504456,
0.17423729598522186,
0.23290476202964783,
-0.15441365540027618,
0.39970269799232483,
0.4148448705673218,
0.16715949773788452,
0.34243476390838623,
-0.34657734632492065,
0.12828895449638367,
-1.169662356376648,
-0.05311232805252075,
-0.47321072220802307,
-0.2838495969772339,
-0.2808856964111328,
-1.0811370611190796,
0.5519940257072449,
0.36911842226982117,
0.1998557597398758,
-0.1243852823972702,
-0.5197615027427673,
0.6182023286819458,
0.31128421425819397,
0.2895228862762451,
0.6467545032501221,
0.1931610405445099,
-0.16424085199832916,
0.08480445295572281,
-0.3449627161026001,
-0.44805067777633667,
0.9589045643806458,
0.17764230072498322,
0.9051687121391296,
0.22590845823287964,
0.9125440716743469,
0.21870942413806915,
0.11853693425655365,
-0.8704625964164734,
0.41605740785598755,
-0.24127396941184998,
-0.5588478446006775,
-0.3583916127681732,
-0.49215275049209595,
-0.7901554107666016,
0.34357741475105286,
-0.19346275925636292,
-0.4986816346645355,
0.33932918310165405,
0.1306914985179901,
-0.23646357655525208,
0.05731841176748276,
-0.4529455304145813,
0.2611607015132904,
0.21392500400543213,
-0.3835952877998352,
-0.26117655634880066,
-0.6353163123130798,
0.4966380000114441,
-0.5609774589538574,
0.28408506512641907,
-0.08611844480037689,
-0.38046762347221375,
0.417647123336792,
-0.4037376344203949,
0.6803857684135437,
-0.2037496715784073,
-0.09490769356489182,
0.4865512251853943,
-0.18843205273151398,
0.5899571776390076,
0.036264702677726746,
-0.2625611126422882,
0.00616705184802413,
-0.08275877684354782,
-0.2134314775466919,
-1.030022144317627,
0.43719497323036194,
-0.3827848434448242,
-0.707114040851593,
-0.44233909249305725,
-0.5049901008605957,
-0.3295127749443054,
0.14793823659420013,
0.22089433670043945,
0.30975237488746643,
-0.09852141886949539,
0.3639204204082489,
0.970612108707428,
0.030069956555962563,
0.210024893283844,
0.4608863890171051,
-0.00666196970269084,
-0.33476412296295166,
0.8241313099861145,
0.038628656417131424,
0.2811766266822815,
0.6299189925193787,
0.16606228053569794,
-0.5249202847480774,
-0.6574198007583618,
-0.341797798871994,
0.1878892183303833,
-0.7722744941711426,
-0.42896515130996704,
-0.7515599131584167,
-0.29053348302841187,
-0.17144504189491272,
0.023376429453492165,
-0.08700941503047943,
-0.48219653964042664,
-0.25842419266700745,
0.058260124176740646,
0.3972289264202118,
0.4042588174343109,
-0.048937246203422546,
0.15082551538944244,
-0.8502256870269775,
0.687746524810791,
0.010084743611514568,
0.1600618064403534,
-0.0004351878596935421,
-0.5397641062736511,
-0.3728571832180023,
0.14487886428833008,
-0.2024516612291336,
-0.6450425386428833,
0.38926219940185547,
0.35587605834007263,
0.4297467768192291,
0.27551236748695374,
0.6680500507354736,
0.8851562142372131,
-0.6108644008636475,
0.354364812374115,
0.07957316190004349,
-0.6894293427467346,
0.3802236318588257,
-0.09214296191930771,
0.3697390556335449,
0.6895873546600342,
0.3042384088039398,
-0.3288831412792206,
-0.6081371307373047,
-0.4908411502838135,
-1.0011765956878662,
0.501461923122406,
0.09504087269306183,
0.2237941324710846,
-0.22438690066337585,
0.5897043943405151,
0.05324733629822731,
0.2640921473503113,
-0.37912648916244507,
-0.25196439027786255,
-0.036460328847169876,
-0.2747139036655426,
-0.2134496420621872,
-0.3348511755466461,
-0.089469775557518,
-0.052404288202524185,
0.6961765885353088,
-0.24359457194805145,
0.12129829823970795,
0.4373648762702942,
-0.14662881195545197,
0.12856730818748474,
0.41076213121414185,
0.3477184474468231,
0.5128030180931091,
-0.2451740801334381,
0.365815669298172,
-0.032072536647319794,
-0.667651355266571,
0.41149529814720154,
0.2354927808046341,
-0.15416352450847626,
0.06638094037771225,
0.15180470049381256,
0.6498404145240784,
0.046255409717559814,
-0.6875531077384949,
0.21831564605236053,
-0.1863633394241333,
-0.07447133213281631,
-0.39482221007347107,
0.22560133039951324,
0.07714959233999252,
0.20860175788402557,
0.6524026989936829,
0.05310674384236336,
0.2988245487213135,
-0.22043129801750183,
0.3869945704936981,
0.4626181125640869,
-0.07805000990629196,
0.054375551640987396,
0.420339435338974,
0.18308992683887482,
0.18824243545532227,
0.2158041149377823,
-0.32586273550987244,
-0.23718847334384918,
0.36380210518836975,
0.5271841883659363,
0.7803407311439514,
0.019632412120699883,
0.03089061751961708,
0.4440325200557709,
-0.018005246296525,
-0.07398075610399246,
0.12870267033576965,
-0.4891134202480316,
-0.8489858508110046,
-0.7303696870803833,
-1.1884344816207886,
-0.28746914863586426,
0.1703825145959854,
-0.7926203012466431,
0.29164937138557434,
-0.07833845913410187,
-0.16618654131889343,
0.00034104054793715477,
0.11310166120529175,
-0.20288339257240295,
0.22169651091098785,
0.00774383544921875,
0.8616093993186951,
-0.4584251642227173,
0.9859939217567444,
0.7196004986763,
-0.26392874121665955,
-0.6073843240737915,
0.43326112627983093,
-0.14204397797584534,
-0.42062410712242126,
0.6331478357315063,
-0.0329974964261055,
-0.275115430355072,
0.15629254281520844,
-0.007750341668725014,
-0.9390125274658203,
1.0463358163833618,
0.25761765241622925,
-0.48654863238334656,
-0.2711692750453949,
0.07626312971115112,
0.5402652621269226,
-0.3387727737426758,
-0.07984931021928787,
0.4638340473175049,
0.3501954972743988,
0.8503734469413757,
-0.6359184980392456,
0.1814020425081253,
-0.326006680727005,
0.04482844099402428,
0.3218163549900055,
-0.3157500922679901,
0.43670976161956787,
-0.08966365456581116,
-0.35668644309043884,
-0.06369057297706604,
0.8095845580101013,
0.511591911315918,
0.3142157196998596,
0.6020240187644958,
0.6347997188568115,
0.9043096303939819,
0.20547759532928467,
0.817969799041748,
-0.4331468343734741,
0.11014285683631897,
1.5666429996490479,
-0.0539117269217968,
0.9490169882774353,
0.8230116367340088,
0.1229243129491806,
0.36673930287361145,
0.3363342881202698,
0.4501611292362213,
0.6208029389381409,
0.18481874465942383,
-0.5341396927833557,
0.01542665995657444,
-0.15827983617782593,
-0.2839930057525635,
0.4843924045562744,
0.6520925760269165,
-0.35141870379447937,
-0.297392338514328,
0.06948570162057877,
-0.08831452578306198,
0.24217091500759125,
-0.10904964804649353,
1.0715751647949219,
0.2980072796344757,
-0.824305534362793,
0.962817370891571,
-0.08133921772241592,
0.7690456509590149,
-0.5148823857307434,
-0.17182578146457672,
-0.03950824588537216,
0.1169828251004219,
-0.05993020534515381,
-0.6784675717353821,
0.642593264579773,
0.07934205234050751,
-0.44364944100379944,
-0.271095871925354,
0.8519272208213806,
-0.5446614623069763,
-0.4355795979499817,
0.15894034504890442,
0.6886294484138489,
0.13899965584278107,
-0.10579308122396469,
-0.4570273458957672,
0.1309032291173935,
0.042142100632190704,
-0.2330734133720398,
0.20816683769226074,
0.8022897839546204,
0.05941805616021156,
0.3989252746105194,
0.46697089076042175,
0.31784895062446594,
-0.12491707503795624,
-0.1667359620332718,
1.096325397491455,
-0.5319401621818542,
-0.5382572412490845,
-0.701292097568512,
0.5341071486473083,
-0.33605650067329407,
-0.022485675290226936,
0.5657920241355896,
0.44437408447265625,
0.7300859689712524,
0.10270535945892334,
0.834671139717102,
-0.18499025702476501,
0.8196129202842712,
-0.6596527695655823,
0.7905449271202087,
-0.6468362212181091,
0.4491761028766632,
-0.21879149973392487,
-1.0387836694717407,
-0.07957664132118225,
0.5384540557861328,
-0.18620334565639496,
-0.10403330624103546,
0.6430015563964844,
0.6398455500602722,
-0.22864830493927002,
-0.08006421476602554,
0.34243905544281006,
0.20039036870002747,
0.19314135611057281,
0.16330187022686005,
0.6540058255195618,
-0.11623535305261612,
0.3812658488750458,
-0.27698734402656555,
-0.38757699728012085,
-0.023045266047120094,
-0.916226327419281,
-0.8094996213912964,
-0.7789227366447449,
-0.26035168766975403,
-0.477278470993042,
-0.01683596521615982,
0.8011579513549805,
0.42925721406936646,
-0.4795278012752533,
-0.004920097067952156,
-0.2097606360912323,
0.1138806939125061,
0.07606600224971771,
-0.22126200795173645,
0.3239700496196747,
-0.7223389148712158,
-0.8466988801956177,
0.35297346115112305,
0.08153156191110611,
0.07711148262023926,
-0.15251493453979492,
-0.048479750752449036,
-0.11655068397521973,
0.23835237324237823,
0.6353257894515991,
0.06986450403928757,
-0.5557396411895752,
-0.008464623242616653,
-0.1767328530550003,
0.10030697286128998,
0.08202272653579712,
0.68190997838974,
-0.9621990323066711,
0.6114450693130493,
0.42845219373703003,
0.7212892770767212,
0.6210010647773743,
0.3880593180656433,
0.49817055463790894,
-1.0020496845245361,
0.34599387645721436,
0.3610016107559204,
0.23711563646793365,
0.2731133997440338,
-0.4327898919582367,
0.5844752192497253,
0.021993771195411682,
-0.3214177191257477,
-0.9153932332992554,
0.18418513238430023,
-0.8092631101608276,
-0.5568772554397583,
1.17604398727417,
-0.16222377121448517,
-0.4530505836009979,
-0.2630583643913269,
-0.10787468403577805,
0.2783297002315521,
-0.47362491488456726,
0.870589017868042,
0.7550180554389954,
-0.11708901077508926,
-0.00563596049323678,
-0.5102714896202087,
0.6141147017478943,
0.1763768494129181,
-0.7138347625732422,
0.2726978659629822,
0.7147064805030823,
0.05268089473247528,
0.4667246341705322,
0.5059207081794739,
-0.13635532557964325,
-0.07128115743398666,
-0.09150727093219757,
-0.12282990664243698,
-0.26154059171676636,
-0.18677343428134918,
-0.29698309302330017,
0.17673259973526,
-0.004510980099439621,
0.014773191884160042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03084v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03084v1
|
Analyzing Emotional Trends from X platform using SenticNet: A Comparative Analysis with Cryptocurrency Price
| 2024-05-06T00:18:35 | 2024-05-06T00:18:35 |
Moein Shahiki Tash, Zahra Ahani, Olga Kolesnikova, Grigori Sidorov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This study delves into the relationship between emotional trends from X
platform data and the market dynamics of well-known cryptocurrencies Cardano,
Binance, Fantom, Matic, and Ripple over the period from October 2022 to March
2023. Leveraging SenticNet, we identified emotions like Fear and Anxiety, Rage
and Anger, Grief and Sadness, Delight and Pleasantness, Enthusiasm and
Eagerness, and Delight and Joy. Following data extraction, we segmented each
month into bi-weekly intervals, replicating this process for price data
obtained from Finance-Yahoo. Consequently, a comparative analysis was
conducted, establishing connections between emotional trends observed across
bi-weekly intervals and cryptocurrency prices, uncovering significant
correlations between emotional sentiments and coin valuations.
|
[
-0.625575840473175,
-0.4741138815879822,
0.2171785980463028,
-0.036464396864175797,
-0.39298132061958313,
0.4628368318080902,
-0.09396348893642426,
-0.7929624915122986,
0.9147619605064392,
0.5160374641418457,
-0.8529529571533203,
-0.6072515845298767,
-0.43773114681243896,
-0.0034636338241398335,
-0.5012245774269104,
1.125866413116455,
0.04826638102531433,
-0.20626695454120636,
0.3548496663570404,
-0.09555529803037643,
-0.26571783423423767,
-0.6386456489562988,
-0.7036899328231812,
-0.21553002297878265,
0.49326634407043457,
0.41701391339302063,
0.6800365447998047,
0.31100499629974365,
0.8869739770889282,
0.3940376341342926,
0.08521547168493271,
-0.2168457955121994,
-0.35327449440956116,
0.3476860821247101,
0.08188053965568542,
-0.6703566908836365,
-0.4923171103000641,
0.23260143399238586,
-0.055066198110580444,
0.27266600728034973,
-0.054632190614938736,
0.03337986394762993,
-0.2526513934135437,
1.06255042552948,
-0.4069024920463562,
0.4342641234397888,
-0.5896094441413879,
0.3906744718551636,
-0.397469699382782,
-0.4298812448978424,
0.1309899538755417,
-0.23313000798225403,
0.16035224497318268,
-0.6943885087966919,
0.05145828053355217,
0.37674516439437866,
0.5982360243797302,
-0.03958159685134888,
-0.07522103190422058,
-0.8062803745269775,
-0.13911058008670807,
0.7689282894134521,
-0.290051132440567,
0.45897573232650757,
0.24801084399223328,
0.19678042829036713,
0.13493612408638,
-0.6524847149848938,
-0.3822159469127655,
-0.2557598054409027,
0.2350134402513504,
0.1365518420934677,
-0.8216125965118408,
-0.17980535328388214,
0.09132364392280579,
0.3855724632740021,
-0.5580607056617737,
-0.35243576765060425,
-0.1934770792722702,
-0.11466900259256363,
0.7238917350769043,
0.5000497102737427,
0.5943591594696045,
-0.3752725124359131,
-0.4244503378868103,
-0.3630208373069763,
-0.5870100855827332,
0.2116498053073883,
0.9281991720199585,
0.29447677731513977,
-0.4286145269870758,
0.5012446641921997,
-0.028405897319316864,
0.1537274718284607,
0.20139352977275848,
0.19981838762760162,
0.6080455780029297,
-0.12152186781167984,
-0.0905325636267662,
0.5971258878707886,
1.1652500629425049,
0.6863284707069397,
0.20563052594661713,
0.012498720549046993,
-0.30095741152763367,
0.23258456587791443,
0.2791195511817932,
-0.7886403799057007,
-0.0981287881731987,
0.5384167432785034,
-1.1132638454437256,
-0.6976399421691895,
0.15248152613639832,
-1.3766636848449707,
-0.47162267565727234,
-0.3180902600288391,
0.04315372183918953,
-0.07213956862688065,
-0.6938927173614502,
0.144475519657135,
-0.3673327565193176,
-0.12787732481956482,
0.01703394204378128,
-0.8531609177589417,
0.6034878492355347,
1.205886721611023,
1.1208025217056274,
-0.1999809741973877,
0.08729817718267441,
-0.05796156823635101,
-0.7659273147583008,
-0.7433521151542664,
0.5644639134407043,
-0.3901934027671814,
-0.41827040910720825,
-0.0365363284945488,
0.02716352976858616,
0.2033103108406067,
-0.5141028165817261,
0.2826911509037018,
-0.5262454748153687,
-0.10459169745445251,
-0.5030987858772278,
-0.09219855815172195,
0.10601203888654709,
0.6403912305831909,
-0.7623991966247559,
0.8446539640426636,
0.16026577353477478,
-1.2335889339447021,
0.18312422931194305,
-0.9289963841438293,
-0.13800901174545288,
-0.013138385489583015,
-0.2547677159309387,
-0.05328298360109329,
-0.06373269855976105,
-0.3412008285522461,
0.2199794501066208,
-0.3302103877067566,
-0.1147330030798912,
-0.5206516981124878,
-0.2768014669418335,
1.0609647035598755,
-0.1547791212797165,
0.4936302900314331,
0.39180290699005127,
-0.8869184851646423,
0.3298517167568207,
-0.7962196469306946,
-0.3093162477016449,
-0.3088937997817993,
0.6049545407295227,
-0.4506964087486267,
0.13516324758529663,
0.27161622047424316,
0.4621880054473877,
0.2544451355934143,
-0.7753339409828186,
0.17558735609054565,
-0.7125152945518494,
0.7346878051757812,
0.8892877697944641,
0.14821270108222961,
0.1414894312620163,
-0.026431633159518242,
0.8605090975761414,
0.11345528811216354,
0.5700029134750366,
0.12442758679389954,
-0.6505231857299805,
-0.42669036984443665,
-0.03502485156059265,
-0.44222673773765564,
0.5190176367759705,
-0.0628199577331543,
0.20859119296073914,
0.16715161502361298,
-0.5945988297462463,
-0.39056500792503357,
-0.2497059553861618,
-0.012342069298028946,
0.5086095929145813,
0.06721912324428558,
-0.10040038824081421,
-0.6508064270019531,
-0.6325359344482422,
-0.02435922622680664,
-0.28136730194091797,
0.36971014738082886,
0.36741265654563904,
0.34886616468429565,
-0.5138545036315918,
0.691878616809845,
-0.4705221652984619,
0.259878545999527,
0.25393080711364746,
0.6840354800224304,
0.420271098613739,
0.21339771151542664,
0.4239295721054077,
-0.8419869542121887,
-0.42130178213119507,
0.7146771550178528,
-0.42836514115333557,
0.14625950157642365,
-0.11837347596883774,
-0.3757553994655609,
0.24935811758041382,
0.46523067355155945,
-0.6813988089561462,
0.6000639200210571,
0.45356667041778564,
-0.7014578580856323,
0.5351624488830566,
0.06932638585567474,
0.7708740234375,
-0.9186698794364929,
0.19540297985076904,
-0.06898555904626846,
-0.02269514836370945,
-0.22155719995498657,
-0.3047989308834076,
-0.07298479229211807,
-0.46689170598983765,
-0.33976781368255615,
0.1699376404285431,
-0.2654707431793213,
-0.16426776349544525,
-0.6150811910629272,
0.29797491431236267,
-0.39296597242355347,
0.07596448063850403,
0.0777963250875473,
0.66135174036026,
0.9018012881278992,
-0.19894564151763916,
0.8088470101356506,
0.1252126693725586,
-0.2641202211380005,
0.3435356914997101,
-0.658218502998352,
0.10509287565946579,
0.3301652669906616,
-0.3161154091358185,
-1.0601550340652466,
0.3002825975418091,
0.8382238149642944,
-0.685864269733429,
-0.07503734529018402,
0.37078094482421875,
-0.06355825066566467,
-0.6196804046630859,
-0.6077092289924622,
0.08927816152572632,
0.27316975593566895,
-0.13004134595394135,
0.5866469144821167,
0.13015992939472198,
-0.272113561630249,
-1.0448706150054932,
-0.7828160524368286,
0.4006319046020508,
-0.4559955298900604,
-0.455166757106781,
0.2976035177707672,
-0.5704798102378845,
-0.790946364402771,
-0.02950560301542282,
0.02967749536037445,
0.33975061774253845,
0.09115465730428696,
0.9051018357276917,
0.4672277271747589,
-0.05425373464822769,
-0.021884771063923836,
-0.2148454487323761,
-0.5895388126373291,
0.7513508200645447,
-0.3164772093296051,
0.6200494170188904,
-0.30322420597076416,
0.04237508401274681,
-0.5062089562416077,
0.37924110889434814,
0.7195225954055786,
-0.07177375257015228,
0.5837615132331848,
0.3930175006389618,
-0.36222097277641296,
-0.00478946790099144,
-0.26246464252471924,
-0.11641273647546768,
-0.5325249433517456,
0.16823254525661469,
-0.29598337411880493,
-0.7095200419425964,
1.1243996620178223,
0.27146992087364197,
-0.2455168515443802,
0.5270583033561707,
0.7767800092697144,
-0.023172905668616295,
1.154729962348938,
0.547908365726471,
-0.2791835367679596,
0.5082690715789795,
-0.19267913699150085,
0.21709775924682617,
-0.42646920680999756,
-0.48375990986824036,
-0.4640440344810486,
-0.6139878630638123,
-1.1729662418365479,
-0.0011355136521160603,
-0.13224077224731445,
-0.4674314260482788,
-0.32397642731666565,
0.22378739714622498,
-0.6132267713546753,
-0.0819898322224617,
0.31370261311531067,
0.21677528321743011,
-0.04106999188661575,
-0.1508399099111557,
0.1798652857542038,
-0.12662966549396515,
-0.021301157772541046,
-0.16349612176418304,
1.1784017086029053,
0.1662714034318924,
0.5227921605110168,
-0.251118928194046,
0.440479576587677,
0.6735159754753113,
0.5665615797042847,
-0.9950950741767883,
0.24136610329151154,
0.11114685237407684,
-0.6411513686180115,
0.009436579421162605,
-0.47339189052581787,
-1.1828279495239258,
-0.32647234201431274,
-0.2356409728527069,
-0.795842170715332,
0.7886252999305725,
-0.26169517636299133,
-0.22513224184513092,
0.2541281282901764,
-0.027094123885035515,
0.9030525088310242,
-0.2603459358215332,
-0.29085686802864075,
-0.4100097715854645,
-0.6917504072189331,
0.2039703130722046,
-0.27089524269104004,
0.32909730076789856,
-0.29969456791877747,
-0.4484200179576874,
0.9242293834686279,
-0.6654295325279236,
0.5258309245109558,
0.17387020587921143,
0.02437053993344307,
0.5574031472206116,
-0.2163483053445816,
0.31231722235679626,
0.11612123996019363,
-0.12311873584985733,
0.10032086074352264,
-0.011005694046616554,
-0.24223975837230682,
-0.5062249302864075,
1.0842868089675903,
-1.1207796335220337,
0.14623111486434937,
-0.3213450014591217,
-0.39597275853157043,
0.07643315196037292,
0.02159135229885578,
0.5054227113723755,
0.44692835211753845,
-0.3480168282985687,
-0.06833967566490173,
0.6004877686500549,
0.03680509328842163,
0.7144429087638855,
0.18185508251190186,
-0.19448034465312958,
-0.9891927242279053,
0.8951393365859985,
-0.043699655681848526,
-0.1332939863204956,
0.45118215680122375,
0.5582945942878723,
-0.16633471846580505,
-0.15452462434768677,
0.02862078882753849,
0.1390702724456787,
-0.5270072221755981,
-0.3293575942516327,
-0.8357478380203247,
0.4604422152042389,
-0.48236286640167236,
-0.2645268142223358,
-0.8333958983421326,
-0.02497781068086624,
-0.43562814593315125,
-0.29548826813697815,
0.6552758812904358,
0.7037211656570435,
-0.2277175933122635,
0.3617677390575409,
-0.7652881145477295,
0.0439455471932888,
-0.016898777335882187,
0.3612385094165802,
-0.04764483496546745,
0.044337525963783264,
-0.17457126080989838,
-0.05580794811248779,
-0.0589798241853714,
-1.337022304534912,
0.7695232033729553,
-0.4216098189353943,
0.22736604511737823,
1.1646589040756226,
-0.026202667504549026,
0.4651550054550171,
0.3090675175189972,
0.6697509288787842,
0.7155841588973999,
-1.2881371974945068,
0.6810995936393738,
-0.4094997048377991,
-0.280997633934021,
0.30611157417297363,
0.6322215795516968,
-1.0717260837554932,
0.0020545085426419973,
-0.8854140639305115,
-0.7601099610328674,
0.6430836915969849,
0.15540730953216553,
0.11905121058225632,
-0.27150091528892517,
0.6073441505432129,
0.3665611445903778,
0.5387380123138428,
-0.5527863502502441,
-0.6930646896362305,
-0.4715697467327118,
-0.4882977306842804,
0.097220778465271,
-0.17801114916801453,
0.10329501330852509,
-0.004412544425576925,
0.40811964869499207,
-0.12294161319732666,
0.35853707790374756,
0.04373503103852272,
0.32595348358154297,
-0.5221924185752869,
-0.05568036064505577,
0.26802271604537964,
0.5629144310951233,
-0.47987499833106995,
0.09862549602985382,
-0.13789717853069305,
-0.5342655777931213,
0.04757452383637428,
0.08264993876218796,
0.13558293879032135,
-0.09674277901649475,
0.32426029443740845,
0.8381941914558411,
0.43706515431404114,
-1.0205150842666626,
0.6115084886550903,
-0.17745833098888397,
-0.5675159692764282,
-0.2960353195667267,
-0.05198408663272858,
0.0026709733065217733,
0.5477942228317261,
0.2936410903930664,
0.3384571373462677,
0.6355512142181396,
-0.874428391456604,
0.3298022150993347,
0.1690022498369217,
-1.1681113243103027,
-0.7392807006835938,
0.5345795750617981,
0.09415198117494583,
-0.23307783901691437,
0.9355534315109253,
0.09848811477422714,
-0.665118932723999,
0.9634762406349182,
0.24507002532482147,
1.0533804893493652,
-0.15178588032722473,
0.215546116232872,
0.27690190076828003,
0.2695116400718689,
0.009446972981095314,
0.6803125739097595,
-0.08604937791824341,
-0.6311699748039246,
-0.1371542513370514,
0.10180440545082092,
-0.3275231719017029,
-0.24811697006225586,
-0.7705771327018738,
0.32394611835479736,
-0.521687924861908,
-0.6972902417182922,
-0.03728368878364563,
0.6015061736106873,
-0.6128578782081604,
0.48147132992744446,
0.5084778666496277,
0.7900898456573486,
-0.8515329957008362,
0.23381300270557404,
0.6810321807861328,
-0.2221093624830246,
-0.5507736802101135,
-0.5910686254501343,
-0.055994048714637756,
-0.6237996220588684,
0.70754474401474,
0.27461686730384827,
-0.2900557219982147,
-0.4177868962287903,
-0.6702707409858704,
-0.694979190826416,
0.9466849565505981,
-0.16522087156772614,
-0.8790802359580994,
0.5301566123962402,
0.2101268768310547,
0.6052740216255188,
-0.6366442441940308,
0.8123241066932678,
0.3689184784889221,
0.5911149382591248,
0.0002843963447958231,
-0.141938716173172,
-0.13332070410251617,
-0.7762519717216492,
-0.6164294481277466,
0.7308229804039001,
-0.9433804154396057,
0.8801484107971191,
0.15937486290931702,
-0.17575891315937042,
-0.25991877913475037,
0.6520466208457947,
0.07797626405954361,
0.9296534061431885,
0.7844886183738708,
0.43199971318244934,
0.8920139670372009,
-0.043385494500398636,
0.672463059425354,
-0.8724455237388611,
0.42484232783317566,
0.45475271344184875,
-0.06102271005511284,
0.9166461229324341,
0.3049205541610718,
-0.25129908323287964,
0.8623180985450745,
0.9399343729019165,
0.2345609962940216,
0.26157185435295105,
0.21164676547050476,
-0.06301932036876678,
-0.2678414583206177,
0.18827949464321136,
-0.5416221022605896,
0.3986007869243622,
0.4230792224407196,
-0.40682944655418396,
0.36059072613716125,
0.259222149848938,
0.0805681124329567,
-0.4240959584712982,
-0.5201348662376404,
0.3629387617111206,
0.06736645847558975,
-0.33233803510665894,
-0.2426314353942871,
-0.25402769446372986,
0.7192807793617249,
-0.5619561076164246,
0.29150915145874023,
-0.4343430697917938,
0.12915468215942383,
-0.16789156198501587,
-0.5322514772415161,
0.40997204184532166,
0.016321957111358643,
-0.09061774611473083,
-0.12458453327417374,
0.904934287071228,
-0.053423382341861725,
-0.3742380142211914,
0.6308358311653137,
0.16849321126937866,
0.20557944476604462,
-0.5155794620513916,
-1.1947410106658936,
0.3760043680667877,
0.0017208987846970558,
-0.5877822637557983,
0.15074220299720764,
0.6514641642570496,
0.21876448392868042,
0.8526221513748169,
0.6863549947738647,
-0.0690535306930542,
-0.21871452033519745,
-0.1107441633939743,
0.842606246471405,
-1.1439552307128906,
-0.7865287065505981,
-0.9238287806510925,
0.3511182963848114,
-0.22391782701015472,
-0.5808594226837158,
0.44401490688323975,
0.5032027363777161,
0.0885833203792572,
0.27521857619285583,
0.41503021121025085,
0.11923663318157196,
0.04154599457979202,
-0.0028884110506623983,
0.7348487973213196,
-0.636670708656311,
0.03821354731917381,
-0.4171217679977417,
-0.8027265667915344,
0.013097269460558891,
0.48497238755226135,
-0.2683345079421997,
-0.2163366973400116,
0.6052138805389404,
0.8608142137527466,
0.2944275736808777,
0.6355413794517517,
0.06868536025285721,
0.009598310105502605,
0.08373267948627472,
0.15321630239486694,
1.1170014142990112,
-0.3912065029144287,
0.3739641606807709,
-0.5900275707244873,
-0.49808987975120544,
-0.4807857871055603,
-0.8641734719276428,
-0.7121065855026245,
-0.3061308264732361,
-0.7769893407821655,
-0.4535009264945984,
0.20740807056427002,
1.055631399154663,
0.7018555998802185,
-0.8236257433891296,
-0.45775851607322693,
-0.3551028370857239,
-0.034026145935058594,
-0.3795091509819031,
-0.3307807147502899,
0.4173745810985565,
-0.0718061774969101,
-0.5398681163787842,
-0.02211972139775753,
0.6071798205375671,
-0.18765661120414734,
-0.28296875953674316,
0.07670161128044128,
0.3841398358345032,
0.36599141359329224,
0.4429876208305359,
0.09153665602207184,
-0.12606149911880493,
0.03616977855563164,
0.4133729934692383,
-0.3226091265678406,
0.2399616837501526,
1.1282225847244263,
-0.4271671175956726,
0.36163750290870667,
0.8449136018753052,
0.08112555742263794,
0.5188607573509216,
0.06523895263671875,
0.3848993182182312,
0.0495513416826725,
-0.012482584454119205,
0.010373180732131004,
0.3047632575035095,
0.14337484538555145,
-0.6210793852806091,
0.17892388999462128,
0.4505951702594757,
-0.7798646092414856,
-0.2981877326965332,
-0.2864832580089569,
-1.2651335000991821,
-0.3920413851737976,
0.5154068470001221,
0.02533336542546749,
-0.5538911819458008,
0.2344774305820465,
-0.17783313989639282,
0.2720855474472046,
-0.4835743308067322,
0.9005888104438782,
0.6283397078514099,
-0.329141229391098,
-0.263871431350708,
-0.5587353706359863,
0.2284851223230362,
0.2578851282596588,
-0.8483796715736389,
0.11613284796476364,
0.21229498088359833,
-0.023793283849954605,
0.1485569328069687,
0.3407106101512909,
-0.05425124987959862,
0.07406143099069595,
0.5653138160705566,
0.2614874839782715,
0.233205646276474,
-0.05551769584417343,
0.13192078471183777,
0.28625449538230896,
-0.342947393655777,
-0.4555000066757202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06682v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06682v1
|
Self-Reflection in LLM Agents: Effects on Problem-Solving Performance
| 2024-05-05T18:56:46 | 2024-05-05T18:56:46 |
Matthew Renze, Erhan Guven
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this study, we investigated the effects of self-reflection in large
language models (LLMs) on problem-solving performance. We instructed nine
popular LLMs to answer a series of multiple-choice questions to provide a
performance baseline. For each incorrectly answered question, we instructed
eight types of self-reflecting LLM agents to reflect on their mistakes and
provide themselves with guidance to improve problem-solving. Then, using this
guidance, each self-reflecting agent attempted to re-answer the same questions.
Our results indicate that LLM agents are able to significantly improve their
problem-solving performance through self-reflection ($p < 0.001$). In addition,
we compared the various types of self-reflection to determine their individual
contribution to performance. All code and data are available on GitHub at
https://github.com/matthewrenze/self-reflection
|
[
-0.21259261667728424,
-0.7264692187309265,
0.8489704728126526,
0.551688551902771,
0.14462220668792725,
0.2671639025211334,
0.03998110070824623,
-0.5710897445678711,
0.45644649863243103,
0.8119043111801147,
-0.4163665473461151,
-0.1092132180929184,
-0.46483114361763,
0.44307827949523926,
-0.38139382004737854,
0.8534914255142212,
0.07194306701421738,
0.41244223713874817,
-0.42453792691230774,
0.004942525643855333,
-0.6389336585998535,
-0.37435999512672424,
-0.60238116979599,
-0.38647526502609253,
0.6192272305488586,
0.5740675926208496,
0.46443620324134827,
0.5414861440658569,
0.74334716796875,
0.4628675878047943,
0.11079975217580795,
0.08499789983034134,
-0.6033533215522766,
0.5105116963386536,
-0.45517346262931824,
-0.5423528552055359,
-0.4155177175998688,
0.21978160738945007,
0.7032501697540283,
0.25798195600509644,
-0.4340372383594513,
0.337019681930542,
0.3118179738521576,
0.6879695057868958,
-0.5609239935874939,
0.19096502661705017,
-0.3088000416755676,
-0.13973650336265564,
0.00019809938385151327,
-0.4685591757297516,
-0.3791975975036621,
-0.16167588531970978,
-0.040526751428842545,
-0.5050901174545288,
0.2797211706638336,
0.019948335364460945,
0.25120216608047485,
0.6110150218009949,
-0.4117075204849243,
-0.4793090522289276,
-0.7988916635513306,
0.5817643404006958,
-0.7001189589500427,
-0.028019379824399948,
0.07474874705076218,
0.11701007932424545,
-0.4452907145023346,
-0.558408796787262,
-0.2869971990585327,
-0.2826070785522461,
-0.1347595453262329,
0.4406853914260864,
0.14935274422168732,
0.16041038930416107,
0.3470993936061859,
0.2772733271121979,
-0.38738012313842773,
0.10364075750112534,
-0.26363036036491394,
-0.14301277697086334,
0.8855021595954895,
0.48778969049453735,
0.07343211024999619,
0.07847556471824646,
-0.19157257676124573,
0.01593768037855625,
-0.6484696865081787,
0.019707731902599335,
0.1172366812825203,
0.39518722891807556,
0.3422520160675049,
0.47505518794059753,
-0.29247626662254333,
0.4666876196861267,
0.050826724618673325,
-0.3492409884929657,
0.14088594913482666,
-0.37123990058898926,
0.14977408945560455,
-0.015791159123182297,
0.5350492596626282,
0.3011031150817871,
0.2695920765399933,
-0.06936231255531311,
-0.4309062957763672,
-0.3618564307689667,
0.41417643427848816,
-0.8002225160598755,
0.08258975297212601,
0.09238290041685104,
-0.5194975137710571,
-0.28858640789985657,
-0.1446729302406311,
-0.7069578170776367,
-0.6196961402893066,
-0.20325729250907898,
0.8905482888221741,
0.19183655083179474,
-0.3080700635910034,
0.22455482184886932,
-0.05341162160038948,
0.3743203580379486,
0.6525225639343262,
-0.5141386389732361,
0.5754668116569519,
0.4606727659702301,
0.7559593319892883,
-0.1835450381040573,
-0.6942194104194641,
-0.4845746159553528,
0.06467510014772415,
-0.3062284290790558,
0.9104490280151367,
-0.34417301416397095,
-0.5843296647071838,
-0.01268311683088541,
-0.11406933516263962,
-0.08774194121360779,
-0.961689293384552,
0.16987952589988708,
-0.4187963902950287,
-0.0241744015365839,
-0.6199668645858765,
-0.5335155129432678,
0.05113118141889572,
0.19875407218933105,
-0.6421271562576294,
1.1487621068954468,
-0.059011757373809814,
-0.4948830008506775,
-0.08185328543186188,
-0.6878403425216675,
-0.29285871982574463,
0.0737261101603508,
-0.18924254179000854,
-0.3494417667388916,
0.25782129168510437,
-0.10414774715900421,
0.5044145584106445,
-0.2378133088350296,
-0.07515595108270645,
-0.3349682688713074,
-0.39911434054374695,
0.48328179121017456,
-0.1550620198249817,
0.49982208013534546,
0.03637457266449928,
-0.5039937496185303,
-0.07006102055311203,
-0.7002928853034973,
0.0840473547577858,
0.4086293876171112,
-0.4583629369735718,
-0.055785778909921646,
-0.01625644415616989,
-0.4593139886856079,
0.5599327683448792,
0.45352494716644287,
-0.6491576433181763,
0.48307740688323975,
0.012377774342894554,
-0.06688474863767624,
0.9644293785095215,
0.16681061685085297,
-0.0039366125129163265,
-0.48017072677612305,
0.7350970506668091,
-0.005997475236654282,
0.055508628487586975,
-0.05484068766236305,
-0.6041793823242188,
-0.7163383364677429,
0.0909435898065567,
-0.03113359771668911,
0.45820868015289307,
-0.7406867146492004,
-0.47113969922065735,
0.2722167670726776,
-0.4445786476135254,
-0.657823383808136,
0.4886583089828491,
0.7056469321250916,
0.49229034781455994,
0.29379957914352417,
-0.24804572761058807,
-0.4033118188381195,
-0.9081940650939941,
-0.5390332341194153,
-0.1131383553147316,
0.4240289330482483,
0.36377424001693726,
0.8892183899879456,
0.015597854740917683,
0.9898908138275146,
-0.8518714308738708,
-0.4624057412147522,
-0.16068491339683533,
0.16816411912441254,
-0.06901838630437851,
0.41875314712524414,
0.3395024538040161,
-0.4821784794330597,
-0.5689958930015564,
-0.5474355220794678,
-0.6688770651817322,
-0.38325732946395874,
0.0427946038544178,
0.01094780396670103,
0.38113120198249817,
0.5919104218482971,
-0.4731362760066986,
0.3388529121875763,
0.6989464163780212,
-0.4458836615085602,
0.993122935295105,
-0.4383949041366577,
0.0032004057429730892,
-0.7974677085876465,
-0.19385330379009247,
0.02906680293381214,
-0.31588512659072876,
-0.6524904370307922,
-0.15346096456050873,
-0.16893050074577332,
0.28346362709999084,
-0.5323208570480347,
0.46440988779067993,
-0.5945211052894592,
-0.3788904845714569,
-0.4904143214225769,
0.23094354569911957,
-0.040689028799533844,
0.378011554479599,
-0.046357136219739914,
1.2718064785003662,
0.388348251581192,
-0.615605890750885,
0.36480510234832764,
0.059008412063121796,
-0.14356474578380585,
0.3121680021286011,
-0.6326367259025574,
0.37811681628227234,
-0.2231326848268509,
0.0792258009314537,
-1.2064125537872314,
0.05991644784808159,
0.22812828421592712,
-0.25528159737586975,
0.2685430943965912,
0.12825614213943481,
-0.4722064733505249,
-0.31894823908805847,
-0.28715941309928894,
0.3869238495826721,
0.10315670073032379,
-0.4131261110305786,
0.732896089553833,
0.16337350010871887,
-0.0374998115003109,
-0.6271506547927856,
-0.5861502289772034,
-0.0024465012829750776,
-0.07135874032974243,
-0.4522635340690613,
0.19328942894935608,
-0.5818561911582947,
-0.3990815579891205,
0.047163691371679306,
-0.008154426701366901,
0.17910869419574738,
0.23438309133052826,
0.1256272792816162,
0.018544398248195648,
-0.10402452945709229,
0.25064390897750854,
-0.48931875824928284,
-0.18201065063476562,
0.35962197184562683,
0.07587485760450363,
0.637273907661438,
-0.7048909068107605,
-0.4083954691886902,
-0.24313336610794067,
0.4461749792098999,
0.4116778075695038,
-0.3604387044906616,
0.9977140426635742,
0.019903969019651413,
0.02469237521290779,
-0.25309643149375916,
-0.9059127569198608,
-0.22555598616600037,
-0.5681769251823425,
0.2677905857563019,
-0.454241007566452,
-0.8353400230407715,
0.8363749384880066,
0.04554292559623718,
-0.12064526975154877,
0.4725545346736908,
0.7529172897338867,
-0.5197252035140991,
1.1990126371383667,
0.5897571444511414,
0.03234231844544411,
0.3931841552257538,
-0.3938350975513458,
-0.11470676958560944,
-0.7538564801216125,
-0.3137645721435547,
-0.4525473713874817,
-0.21481144428253174,
-0.8436887860298157,
-0.27946990728378296,
0.2094603180885315,
-0.26536664366722107,
-0.054910797625780106,
0.08762306720018387,
-0.65723717212677,
0.5764477252960205,
0.650057852268219,
-0.043957021087408066,
0.5899937152862549,
-0.5893982648849487,
0.20089636743068695,
0.0554693266749382,
-0.6361773610115051,
-0.5380501747131348,
1.1240395307540894,
0.3746860921382904,
0.9599434733390808,
0.17127709090709686,
1.1837856769561768,
0.18035849928855896,
0.5326962471008301,
-0.6613499522209167,
0.866036057472229,
0.29791027307510376,
-0.8429331183433533,
-0.6006526350975037,
-0.4606483280658722,
-1.0512551069259644,
0.4364176392555237,
0.20155812799930573,
-0.43455979228019714,
0.10156825929880142,
0.16179032623767853,
-0.2568618059158325,
0.04511677101254463,
-0.5835185050964355,
0.766221821308136,
-0.5697678327560425,
-0.37022119760513306,
-0.41664478182792664,
-0.37499698996543884,
0.06018149107694626,
-0.10052437335252762,
0.08652391284704208,
-0.10831368714570999,
-0.1698341965675354,
0.9706966876983643,
-0.15428093075752258,
0.9921890497207642,
-0.3497259318828583,
-0.5332972407341003,
0.4864952266216278,
0.20771172642707825,
0.5590903759002686,
-0.10474808514118195,
0.036673061549663544,
-0.04454120248556137,
0.11009035259485245,
-0.30464836955070496,
-0.8544158935546875,
0.5830911993980408,
-0.8514727354049683,
-1.2193787097930908,
-0.6323464512825012,
-0.6111581921577454,
-0.015572262927889824,
0.24947108328342438,
-0.03492411971092224,
0.4827801585197449,
-0.06617700308561325,
-0.10529345273971558,
0.7049532532691956,
0.12464655935764313,
0.7243636846542358,
1.2083507776260376,
-0.6230572462081909,
-0.35317471623420715,
0.955065906047821,
0.7669585943222046,
0.43619921803474426,
0.011044856160879135,
0.16994808614253998,
-0.13806892931461334,
-0.6335617899894714,
-0.034188125282526016,
0.6699753403663635,
-0.794242262840271,
-0.19380784034729004,
-0.28184181451797485,
-0.15635578334331512,
-0.3540070056915283,
0.18744246661663055,
-0.6907249093055725,
-0.45963436365127563,
-0.3368179202079773,
0.1366080641746521,
-0.07284034788608551,
1.2236324548721313,
-0.1494106501340866,
0.24228094518184662,
-0.5731185674667358,
0.04522319883108139,
0.5011911988258362,
0.6678532958030701,
-0.022910580039024353,
-0.3309974670410156,
-0.6048846244812012,
-0.05198691785335541,
-0.5936934351921082,
-0.9940894246101379,
0.16016799211502075,
0.07318861782550812,
0.7013372182846069,
0.25116991996765137,
0.05370478332042694,
0.6119003295898438,
-0.42326852679252625,
0.616130530834198,
-0.09171555191278458,
-0.759629487991333,
0.5189424157142639,
-0.32862842082977295,
0.2903194725513458,
0.56580650806427,
0.15858356654644012,
-0.6427870988845825,
-0.6797350645065308,
-0.41725364327430725,
-0.40912094712257385,
0.7666447758674622,
0.20382384955883026,
0.012166980654001236,
-0.005992547143250704,
0.6966912150382996,
-0.09192056953907013,
0.2302279770374298,
-0.9028856754302979,
-0.747505784034729,
-0.1565106064081192,
0.2448233962059021,
-0.43016794323921204,
-0.6486496329307556,
-0.285963773727417,
-0.3179733455181122,
0.678923487663269,
-0.18830013275146484,
0.5709559917449951,
0.5741159319877625,
-0.2363891750574112,
-0.31479719281196594,
0.2591570317745209,
0.9369627237319946,
0.6317076683044434,
-0.23001781105995178,
0.13526001572608948,
0.33590197563171387,
-0.37978848814964294,
0.39586400985717773,
-0.10628262162208557,
0.04252586513757706,
-0.23367595672607422,
0.4223761260509491,
0.12807407975196838,
-0.14698004722595215,
-0.5197911858558655,
0.3895699679851532,
-0.09373147040605545,
-0.3572639226913452,
-0.5131362080574036,
0.26839420199394226,
0.1781303435564041,
0.4372031092643738,
0.536267876625061,
-0.348123699426651,
0.35782894492149353,
-0.7035899758338928,
0.02091999165713787,
0.46705567836761475,
-0.04387415200471878,
-0.13573352992534637,
0.19082951545715332,
0.1716575175523758,
-0.7822664380073547,
0.5151330232620239,
-0.16411149501800537,
-0.7944996953010559,
0.7615943551063538,
0.9834502935409546,
0.8287109732627869,
-0.6372800469398499,
0.4041241705417633,
0.04446865990757942,
0.06406956166028976,
-0.12185351550579071,
0.5081565976142883,
0.10327319800853729,
-0.8272565603256226,
-0.5342477560043335,
-0.2017877697944641,
-0.7482863664627075,
-0.10204967111349106,
-0.6791518926620483,
-0.21109262108802795,
-0.37794315814971924,
-0.20828545093536377,
-0.2751610279083252,
0.3815986216068268,
-0.5045238137245178,
0.1511760950088501,
0.06050320714712143,
0.8755626082420349,
-0.6001123189926147,
0.4742104709148407,
0.8507886528968811,
-0.5537627339363098,
-0.8738176226615906,
0.06477447599172592,
-0.10983188450336456,
-0.8198392391204834,
0.7910140752792358,
0.193448007106781,
-0.7364150285720825,
0.1557764708995819,
-0.6735934019088745,
-1.3658850193023682,
1.2450331449508667,
0.39923176169395447,
-0.4308094084262848,
0.14667905867099762,
0.6186954975128174,
0.8987112045288086,
-0.4515208899974823,
0.4558233916759491,
0.48123764991760254,
0.4355054199695587,
-0.053807128220796585,
-1.1311179399490356,
0.09696229547262192,
-0.28724849224090576,
-0.07383091747760773,
0.08954734355211258,
-1.2788347005844116,
0.6953537464141846,
-0.2077983170747757,
-0.0021475704852491617,
-0.16289056837558746,
0.5234231948852539,
0.14578817784786224,
0.420727014541626,
0.377352237701416,
0.3587689995765686,
0.6586118936538696,
0.08299613744020462,
0.9086829423904419,
-0.4717792570590973,
0.5199614763259888,
1.1880626678466797,
-0.3218884766101837,
0.750328779220581,
0.4996921122074127,
-0.024490676820278168,
0.6914232969284058,
0.21614687144756317,
0.006618386600166559,
0.4877156615257263,
0.2317512035369873,
-0.1506175994873047,
-0.3237851858139038,
-0.11339522153139114,
-0.4283254146575928,
0.7055119872093201,
0.10588875412940979,
-0.1368679255247116,
-0.13011738657951355,
0.012462327256798744,
-0.11312755197286606,
0.03269598260521889,
-0.4530829191207886,
0.7648444175720215,
0.12930354475975037,
-0.8799806833267212,
0.3570411801338196,
-0.168052077293396,
0.395667165517807,
-0.2522513270378113,
-0.13103580474853516,
-0.28668662905693054,
0.3599695861339569,
-0.361691415309906,
-1.1531200408935547,
0.2607209384441376,
-0.4722845256328583,
-0.09615948051214218,
-0.6564898490905762,
0.8655596971511841,
-0.3331041634082794,
-0.14458149671554565,
0.6498462557792664,
0.8452967405319214,
0.20336201786994934,
-0.08640719205141068,
-0.6504929065704346,
-0.2633209526538849,
-0.21842308342456818,
-0.6471512913703918,
0.4334162175655365,
0.13093355298042297,
0.2120242863893509,
1.324063777923584,
0.3196566700935364,
-0.13021168112754822,
0.17393632233142853,
0.007994957268238068,
0.868688702583313,
-0.7999932169914246,
-0.1067899689078331,
-0.8525825142860413,
0.47280219197273254,
0.0683048889040947,
-0.17800015211105347,
1.1489760875701904,
0.7610887289047241,
0.7346677780151367,
-0.09772349148988724,
0.4046904444694519,
0.28094035387039185,
0.6875333189964294,
-0.4084664583206177,
0.4585166871547699,
-0.6637674570083618,
0.38950568437576294,
-0.41282933950424194,
-0.943945050239563,
-0.03737933933734894,
0.44372761249542236,
-0.603847861289978,
0.2475438416004181,
0.7608497142791748,
1.070942997932434,
0.6463621258735657,
-0.19810180366039276,
0.3862590491771698,
0.49579235911369324,
0.5018824934959412,
0.20196792483329773,
1.4024280309677124,
-0.058591537177562714,
0.6385228037834167,
-0.36773526668548584,
0.10709431022405624,
-0.3055998384952545,
-0.6146018505096436,
-0.78566974401474,
-0.5648071765899658,
-0.4630138576030731,
-0.5381418466567993,
0.13344766199588776,
0.9842172861099243,
0.2940431237220764,
-0.4976907968521118,
-0.5382447838783264,
0.09768398106098175,
0.18593204021453857,
-0.21664869785308838,
-0.21275894343852997,
0.14318041503429413,
-0.5308469533920288,
-0.35503479838371277,
0.3229442536830902,
0.11681506782770157,
0.1322970688343048,
-0.5619806051254272,
-0.3638693392276764,
-0.17991653084754944,
0.2583966851234436,
0.49449682235717773,
0.14117279648780823,
-0.5677690505981445,
-0.47538334131240845,
0.07198876887559891,
-0.39898326992988586,
0.49635744094848633,
0.9665095210075378,
-0.8733765482902527,
0.37514224648475647,
0.13549701869487762,
0.34715914726257324,
0.7103938460350037,
0.05071674659848213,
0.34427717328071594,
-0.44208642840385437,
-0.5052574276924133,
0.3015079200267792,
0.2890598773956299,
-0.04987899959087372,
-0.5407697558403015,
0.6047490835189819,
0.17834846675395966,
-1.0090235471725464,
-0.705954909324646,
0.16807188093662262,
-0.5762208700180054,
-0.21896980702877045,
1.1188470125198364,
-0.029797974973917007,
-0.10580728203058243,
-0.12236446887254715,
-0.4875886142253876,
0.013918702490627766,
-0.44004499912261963,
0.9827691912651062,
0.8416188359260559,
-0.6001610159873962,
-0.4908047020435333,
-0.5409187078475952,
0.49866119027137756,
0.6834310293197632,
-0.8022607564926147,
0.01901782862842083,
0.38254016637802124,
0.6353415250778198,
0.28890687227249146,
1.0663830041885376,
0.22556179761886597,
0.3500472903251648,
-0.1380651295185089,
0.0028060576878488064,
-0.16648638248443604,
-0.5602564215660095,
-0.5476396679878235,
0.14704769849777222,
0.3774392604827881,
-0.029324211180210114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06681v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06681v1
|
Leveraging Lecture Content for Improved Feedback: Explorations with GPT-4 and Retrieval Augmented Generation
| 2024-05-05T18:32:06 | 2024-05-05T18:32:06 |
Sven Jacobs, Steffen Jaschke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
This paper presents the use of Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) to
improve the feedback generated by Large Language Models for programming tasks.
For this purpose, corresponding lecture recordings were transcribed and made
available to the Large Language Model GPT-4 as external knowledge source
together with timestamps as metainformation by using RAG. The purpose of this
is to prevent hallucinations and to enforce the use of the technical terms and
phrases from the lecture. In an exercise platform developed to solve
programming problems for an introductory programming lecture, students can
request feedback on their solutions generated by GPT-4. For this task GPT-4
receives the students' code solution, the compiler output, the result of unit
tests and the relevant passages from the lecture notes available through the
use of RAG as additional context. The feedback generated by GPT-4 should guide
students to solve problems independently and link to the lecture content, using
the time stamps of the transcript as meta-information. In this way, the
corresponding lecture videos can be viewed immediately at the corresponding
positions. For the evaluation, students worked with the tool in a workshop and
decided for each feedback whether it should be extended by RAG or not. First
results based on a questionnaire and the collected usage data show that the use
of RAG can improve feedback generation and is preferred by students in some
situations. Due to the slower speed of feedback generation, the benefits are
situation dependent.
|
[
-0.45163068175315857,
-0.5963671207427979,
0.49872025847435,
0.20417696237564087,
-0.11381355673074722,
0.3503541648387909,
-0.2663136422634125,
-0.23102736473083496,
0.2066456824541092,
0.44060367345809937,
-0.08256396651268005,
-0.1564178764820099,
-0.32347238063812256,
0.07798825204372406,
-0.29368123412132263,
1.5766677856445312,
-0.04324186220765114,
0.09697158634662628,
-0.20127184689044952,
0.08960343897342682,
-0.5508283972740173,
-0.5314364433288574,
-0.7314419150352478,
-0.26096242666244507,
0.3852865993976593,
0.36120331287384033,
0.3367699086666107,
0.17831280827522278,
0.5073217153549194,
0.37875106930732727,
0.003809774061664939,
0.13863134384155273,
-0.4783953130245209,
-0.02069934457540512,
-0.4435616433620453,
-0.4145892560482025,
-0.37936508655548096,
-0.1034623458981514,
0.7982652187347412,
0.42865630984306335,
-0.17486293613910675,
0.28639665246009827,
0.33597368001937866,
0.6136393547058105,
-0.5259236097335815,
0.14951109886169434,
-0.10046539455652237,
0.05228997394442558,
-0.24490588903427124,
-0.7315183281898499,
-0.5489163994789124,
-0.491889625787735,
0.026987995952367783,
-0.6149519681930542,
0.3538161814212799,
-0.2463347315788269,
0.643778383731842,
0.31140410900115967,
-0.10734493285417557,
-0.5478445887565613,
-1.0989190340042114,
0.8560243844985962,
-0.5974143147468567,
0.42445507645606995,
0.4515492022037506,
0.46476709842681885,
-0.11797390133142471,
-0.7355147004127502,
-0.41257837414741516,
-0.4455859661102295,
-0.03283803537487984,
0.14409641921520233,
0.4198131561279297,
0.04597775265574455,
0.5895335078239441,
0.6114806532859802,
-0.3204583525657654,
-0.4175117015838623,
-0.5989624261856079,
-0.29070401191711426,
0.5127389430999756,
-0.0916726365685463,
0.144576758146286,
-0.5228763222694397,
-0.04752836376428604,
-0.2767615020275116,
-0.7002981901168823,
-0.04810553416609764,
0.5817601084709167,
0.11304178833961487,
0.28756701946258545,
0.6190515756607056,
0.04572277516126633,
0.7801429033279419,
0.11709226667881012,
-0.4558946490287781,
0.5497661232948303,
-0.3606261610984802,
0.06127779558300972,
-0.32350119948387146,
0.35173219442367554,
0.17397592961788177,
-0.22995713353157043,
-0.1852997988462448,
-0.2292916178703308,
-0.1701325923204422,
0.5497622489929199,
-0.8548702001571655,
-0.5744590759277344,
-0.09474864602088928,
-0.39775121212005615,
-0.13760338723659515,
-0.061872050166130066,
-1.1891239881515503,
-0.3148415684700012,
-0.680336594581604,
0.5068908333778381,
-0.283880352973938,
-0.4094161093235016,
-0.34796953201293945,
-0.2787892520427704,
0.13078148663043976,
0.4583119750022888,
-0.8558226823806763,
0.39573511481285095,
0.49262961745262146,
0.773411750793457,
-0.36192914843559265,
-0.029199108481407166,
-0.8394667506217957,
0.32905805110931396,
-0.1576295644044876,
0.7232909798622131,
-0.7217358946800232,
-0.71314936876297,
-0.1118050217628479,
0.05707123503088951,
0.24429161846637726,
-0.6151397824287415,
0.46653231978416443,
-0.5571032166481018,
0.5857065916061401,
-0.17188479006290436,
-0.6074538230895996,
-0.23956283926963806,
0.4042322635650635,
-0.5126677751541138,
1.2038830518722534,
0.4771699905395508,
-0.7566266059875488,
0.09285831451416016,
-0.9214486479759216,
-0.05520712956786156,
0.413135826587677,
-0.44710037112236023,
-0.23897422850131989,
-0.1377551108598709,
0.1422375589609146,
0.10698484629392624,
0.208787739276886,
0.043043963611125946,
0.15468233823776245,
-0.34444600343704224,
-0.03105270490050316,
-0.08347521722316742,
0.18449965119361877,
0.2753415107727051,
-0.7031036019325256,
0.09110323339700699,
-0.7739253044128418,
0.34979549050331116,
-0.21734069287776947,
-0.7768996357917786,
-0.3988962769508362,
-0.09565363079309464,
-0.2116115391254425,
-0.1098334863781929,
0.13882525265216827,
-0.4041377902030945,
0.44726046919822693,
-0.20412065088748932,
-0.05083869397640228,
0.7942372560501099,
0.35717281699180603,
0.5039244890213013,
-0.15559490025043488,
0.9504508376121521,
-0.329873263835907,
-0.006558737251907587,
-0.23047541081905365,
-0.2969745695590973,
-0.6375643610954285,
0.06402689963579178,
0.3664984405040741,
0.44576311111450195,
-1.2111811637878418,
-0.43249908089637756,
0.09945668280124664,
-0.31888309121131897,
-0.3924616575241089,
0.3681240975856781,
0.5207367539405823,
0.44589483737945557,
0.4979475736618042,
-0.41937050223350525,
-0.7583995461463928,
-0.32593637704849243,
-0.08618777245283127,
-0.15744827687740326,
-0.10864175111055374,
0.6711908578872681,
0.15344661474227905,
-0.4185458719730377,
0.6576052904129028,
-0.685276210308075,
0.0024948418140411377,
-0.28801220655441284,
0.3473062515258789,
0.27410683035850525,
0.5240131616592407,
0.4570586681365967,
-0.6983742713928223,
-0.5662139058113098,
-0.055408213287591934,
-0.3927055597305298,
-0.1630769968032837,
-0.07212571799755096,
-0.2290336787700653,
0.36250969767570496,
0.36830934882164,
-0.1215454638004303,
0.35121914744377136,
0.5116358995437622,
-0.08012865483760834,
0.9042074084281921,
-0.10334383696317673,
0.41558122634887695,
-0.9233209490776062,
0.08037976175546646,
-0.35963618755340576,
-0.24850304424762726,
-0.2681700885295868,
0.19069741666316986,
-0.19556382298469543,
-0.169183611869812,
-0.009672540239989758,
0.46781882643699646,
-0.4971581697463989,
-0.22011426091194153,
-0.6508316993713379,
0.2353966385126114,
-0.09924236685037613,
0.425908625125885,
-0.05951816961169243,
0.9521913528442383,
0.18377749621868134,
-0.7247119545936584,
0.5036625862121582,
0.13755206763744354,
-0.08160806447267532,
0.30598336458206177,
-0.5249471068382263,
0.6331825852394104,
0.12863920629024506,
0.30088579654693604,
-0.6756103038787842,
-0.2912260591983795,
0.16641263663768768,
-0.703236997127533,
0.7833669185638428,
-0.40075889229774475,
-0.13615970313549042,
-0.5461240410804749,
-0.45309802889823914,
0.29482945799827576,
0.46312442421913147,
-0.595430850982666,
0.49422118067741394,
0.3516150414943695,
-0.3758467137813568,
-0.8154553174972534,
-0.21145197749137878,
-0.09494064748287201,
-0.017537921667099,
-0.3799513876438141,
0.2141670137643814,
-0.3478127717971802,
-0.0933292955160141,
0.08364201337099075,
-0.13215406239032745,
0.1952141672372818,
-0.36782896518707275,
0.20593348145484924,
0.34285834431648254,
0.06559399515390396,
0.4071669280529022,
-0.2644951343536377,
-0.12774351239204407,
0.02513197436928749,
-0.368076890707016,
0.5993930101394653,
-0.1524582952260971,
-0.37494075298309326,
0.0069323377683758736,
0.37815678119659424,
0.05972941592335701,
-0.13014939427375793,
0.3790416419506073,
0.7968063354492188,
-0.027990521863102913,
-0.15992018580436707,
-0.7719375491142273,
-0.3650937080383301,
-0.5162642598152161,
0.3546990156173706,
-0.20443132519721985,
-0.98542720079422,
0.22226287424564362,
-0.33369091153144836,
0.18560747802257538,
0.11048804223537445,
0.6793388724327087,
0.060791440308094025,
0.9067228436470032,
0.8362968564033508,
0.028744369745254517,
0.7918045520782471,
-0.6936680674552917,
0.24990327656269073,
-1.2254071235656738,
-0.42393162846565247,
-0.6319348812103271,
-0.15484505891799927,
-0.5475257635116577,
-0.6574063301086426,
0.37586715817451477,
0.08763612806797028,
-0.13019518554210663,
0.10678441822528839,
-0.8531075716018677,
0.582378089427948,
0.7790623307228088,
0.10517105460166931,
0.12756413221359253,
-0.002108711516484618,
-0.054281316697597504,
-0.29299166798591614,
-0.49325302243232727,
-0.41760480403900146,
1.2840940952301025,
0.14049166440963745,
0.8660155534744263,
0.24803997576236725,
0.9356217384338379,
0.24835503101348877,
0.5405969619750977,
-0.6563460826873779,
0.5205286145210266,
0.13290011882781982,
-0.5353946089744568,
-0.2579827606678009,
-0.7188321948051453,
-0.8169691562652588,
0.0881657600402832,
0.17554683983325958,
-0.6513875722885132,
-0.21067087352275848,
0.34183424711227417,
-0.28704845905303955,
0.22028771042823792,
-0.8571094870567322,
0.6536800265312195,
-0.1675950139760971,
-0.7198277115821838,
-0.3345770835876465,
-0.4171268343925476,
0.2601115107536316,
0.09682662039995193,
0.2955824136734009,
0.6001999974250793,
0.3065018355846405,
0.8738852739334106,
-0.596382737159729,
0.5613495111465454,
-0.5842127799987793,
-0.10133732110261917,
0.7053611874580383,
0.1170741468667984,
0.4930989742279053,
0.1174669861793518,
0.10853570699691772,
-0.5985857248306274,
-0.050646666437387466,
-0.18934494256973267,
-0.8937220573425293,
0.7638043761253357,
-0.8843976855278015,
-0.8344438672065735,
-0.3435707092285156,
-0.5733128786087036,
-0.21709029376506805,
0.024184228852391243,
0.012050936929881573,
0.7611692547798157,
0.4581872522830963,
0.1517249494791031,
0.5282869935035706,
-0.38018038868904114,
0.33525949716567993,
0.5479549765586853,
-0.6123844981193542,
-0.4607192873954773,
1.255507230758667,
0.02987404726445675,
0.2499837428331375,
0.22442272305488586,
0.19391684234142303,
-0.32491111755371094,
-0.5005797147750854,
-0.4179118871688843,
0.25088030099868774,
-0.8170584440231323,
-0.34964698553085327,
-0.5564848184585571,
-0.16192598640918732,
-0.6730995774269104,
0.04379979893565178,
-0.13394883275032043,
-0.6500009298324585,
0.10053936392068863,
-0.1553575098514557,
0.308174192905426,
1.0697534084320068,
-0.45884135365486145,
0.23529523611068726,
-0.9597083926200867,
0.3418653905391693,
0.46981552243232727,
0.4248853921890259,
0.003063394222408533,
-0.5965814590454102,
-0.4948691427707672,
-0.1841343194246292,
-0.9165704250335693,
-0.9933034181594849,
0.26716557145118713,
0.0867968201637268,
0.642998218536377,
0.21668954193592072,
-0.22096341848373413,
0.5819805860519409,
-0.5059232711791992,
0.99934983253479,
-0.1016136035323143,
-0.9183858633041382,
0.7866451144218445,
-0.26122719049453735,
0.20969806611537933,
0.2911604940891266,
0.36516234278678894,
-0.47085240483283997,
-0.5045755505561829,
-0.6367506980895996,
-0.8454881906509399,
0.7203419208526611,
0.054447438567876816,
0.04561339318752289,
-0.00970470905303955,
0.499986857175827,
0.07567055523395538,
0.2906671464443207,
-0.8675864338874817,
0.08944755047559738,
-0.42803850769996643,
0.1995939463376999,
0.011699973605573177,
-0.3931816816329956,
-0.19834759831428528,
-0.31301119923591614,
0.9234771132469177,
-0.15764658153057098,
0.33150428533554077,
0.1472313106060028,
0.16995951533317566,
-0.19215422868728638,
0.3156023919582367,
0.5997110605239868,
0.8271217346191406,
-0.18735173344612122,
0.07004941254854202,
0.12062026560306549,
-0.8737358450889587,
0.07400238513946533,
-0.01318732276558876,
-0.0987519770860672,
0.3055238723754883,
0.1265726387500763,
0.5388344526290894,
0.09506861865520477,
-0.40968623757362366,
0.35446372628211975,
0.07259266823530197,
0.14123952388763428,
-0.4093976616859436,
0.17017780244350433,
-0.28782761096954346,
0.25602221488952637,
0.3417135179042816,
-0.06923443078994751,
0.5252190232276917,
-0.572283923625946,
0.22737036645412445,
0.21555767953395844,
0.05944744870066643,
-0.22419656813144684,
0.5281028747558594,
0.3481672704219818,
-0.4396861493587494,
0.5108968019485474,
-0.5186535120010376,
-0.8970431685447693,
0.3273995816707611,
0.6639962792396545,
0.5596131086349487,
-0.6218001842498779,
0.41866186261177063,
0.8662177324295044,
-0.03225156292319298,
0.0288726557046175,
0.2572341561317444,
-0.4673320949077606,
-0.2176751047372818,
-1.091402292251587,
-0.6568030118942261,
-0.8600294589996338,
0.08975446224212646,
-0.7081230878829956,
0.3074631094932556,
-0.2933427393436432,
-0.12421898543834686,
-0.4208838939666748,
0.27507343888282776,
-0.4239288866519928,
0.023075250908732414,
-0.048294395208358765,
0.5264236330986023,
-0.4134844243526459,
0.7069926857948303,
0.9281740188598633,
-0.42200666666030884,
-1.3247191905975342,
-0.21483014523983002,
-0.0402195043861866,
-0.3392404019832611,
0.8525105714797974,
0.04410150647163391,
0.020547904074192047,
-0.16341650485992432,
-0.5524885654449463,
-0.847832977771759,
0.8065253496170044,
0.06471129506826401,
-0.3714834451675415,
-0.081486277282238,
-0.14515192806720734,
0.7054505944252014,
0.04828284680843353,
0.4481464922428131,
0.37575826048851013,
0.42887482047080994,
0.39394503831863403,
-0.9598779678344727,
-0.2225525975227356,
-0.4036053717136383,
-0.13158056139945984,
0.5562035441398621,
-0.38913723826408386,
0.8489314913749695,
-0.2758224606513977,
-0.021376175805926323,
-0.04093288630247116,
0.6441518068313599,
0.41001543402671814,
0.46738946437835693,
0.41610726714134216,
0.6386107802391052,
0.7768207788467407,
-0.027028797194361687,
1.3121739625930786,
-0.09815112501382828,
0.43232786655426025,
1.468335509300232,
0.12018575519323349,
0.7095777988433838,
0.6077456474304199,
-0.4310421347618103,
0.820941686630249,
0.3121607303619385,
0.05862905830144882,
0.6278656721115112,
0.4995676577091217,
-0.4032517075538635,
0.18915356695652008,
0.05159137770533562,
-0.7998952865600586,
0.05991167202591896,
0.48530063033103943,
-0.07923819869756699,
-0.039237286895513535,
0.296257883310318,
-0.039362628012895584,
-0.06635459512472153,
-0.29800623655319214,
0.8673262000083923,
-0.05909566581249237,
-0.9975547790527344,
0.541157603263855,
-0.2456933706998825,
0.4512121379375458,
-0.5570240616798401,
-0.5316855907440186,
-0.2649707794189453,
0.4520990550518036,
-0.4557930827140808,
-0.6064620614051819,
0.4514830410480499,
0.19362758100032806,
-0.10276101529598236,
-0.22712279856204987,
0.5688073039054871,
-0.41202011704444885,
-0.22051534056663513,
0.09990061819553375,
0.1865704208612442,
0.5004990696907043,
0.2172040045261383,
-0.24651634693145752,
0.12077366560697556,
0.2581544518470764,
-0.2558136582374573,
0.23472119867801666,
0.5478417873382568,
0.13308221101760864,
0.472478449344635,
0.5522382855415344,
0.22040215134620667,
0.2672570049762726,
0.2009284645318985,
1.1197774410247803,
-0.4714743196964264,
-0.33287563920021057,
-0.43270695209503174,
0.30696460604667664,
-0.29090192914009094,
-0.05478254333138466,
1.107795238494873,
0.5624874830245972,
1.038641333580017,
-0.11747820675373077,
0.739847719669342,
-0.3335592448711395,
1.164477825164795,
-0.4088280498981476,
0.20207442343235016,
-0.342041015625,
0.5004318356513977,
-0.6600459814071655,
-1.1635088920593262,
0.16852208971977234,
0.6283279657363892,
-0.3744014501571655,
0.29117587208747864,
0.7675673961639404,
0.5425354838371277,
0.13105906546115875,
-0.03243475779891014,
-0.058086857199668884,
0.10896623879671097,
0.7522529363632202,
0.4034023582935333,
0.9306774735450745,
-0.19838538765907288,
0.7024421095848083,
-0.3641451299190521,
-0.481805682182312,
-0.2832512855529785,
-0.6748599410057068,
-0.8978104591369629,
-0.5095180869102478,
-0.359223872423172,
-0.6108067035675049,
-0.06493954360485077,
0.6653011441230774,
0.6123309135437012,
-0.8453236818313599,
-0.15908274054527283,
0.05599673464894295,
0.030021119862794876,
0.08589232712984085,
-0.37560704350471497,
0.4673251211643219,
-0.759204089641571,
-0.7700995802879333,
0.36890244483947754,
0.017865505069494247,
0.03554150462150574,
-0.42106154561042786,
-0.26735222339630127,
0.08198103308677673,
-0.2717750072479248,
0.6458659768104553,
0.40459075570106506,
-0.2823880910873413,
-0.4696353077888489,
0.12253819406032562,
0.26923221349716187,
-0.16732971370220184,
1.0497286319732666,
-0.9873486161231995,
0.63010573387146,
0.5396490097045898,
0.8186136484146118,
0.8292206525802612,
0.08255059272050858,
0.6159248352050781,
-0.947952926158905,
0.24753232300281525,
0.444182813167572,
0.2056693136692047,
0.5532064437866211,
-0.43274056911468506,
0.9343758225440979,
0.1936672478914261,
-1.1249287128448486,
-0.8962849378585815,
-0.007019723765552044,
-0.7451481223106384,
0.07096460461616516,
1.1996585130691528,
-0.25613781809806824,
0.14925265312194824,
0.07598298043012619,
-0.7856144309043884,
0.24153004586696625,
-0.2685387134552002,
1.0845911502838135,
0.8137984275817871,
-0.369035542011261,
-0.2507181465625763,
-0.9734707474708557,
0.7489395141601562,
0.4845583438873291,
-0.9828333854675293,
-0.3366614282131195,
0.5212587714195251,
0.12398068606853485,
0.6062461137771606,
0.6848199367523193,
-0.3549862802028656,
0.3879927098751068,
-0.140138179063797,
0.03796551376581192,
0.027498342096805573,
-0.4108758568763733,
-0.04402920976281166,
0.0696360245347023,
0.12560363113880157,
-0.23682183027267456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03007v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03007v1
|
On the performativity of SDG classifications in large bibliometric databases
| 2024-05-05T17:28:54 | 2024-05-05T17:28:54 |
Matteo Ottaviani, Stephan Stahlschmidt
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large bibliometric databases, such as Web of Science, Scopus, and OpenAlex,
facilitate bibliometric analyses, but are performative, affecting the
visibility of scientific outputs and the impact measurement of participating
entities. Recently, these databases have taken up the UN's Sustainable
Development Goals (SDGs) in their respective classifications, which have been
criticised for their diverging nature. This work proposes using the feature of
large language models (LLMs) to learn about the "data bias" injected by diverse
SDG classifications into bibliometric data by exploring five SDGs. We build a
LLM that is fine-tuned in parallel by the diverse SDG classifications inscribed
into the databases' SDG classifications. Our results show high sensitivity in
model architecture, classified publications, fine-tuning process, and natural
language generation. The wide arbitrariness at different levels raises concerns
about using LLM in research practice.
|
[
-0.5823782682418823,
-0.3788122832775116,
0.5237269401550293,
0.0544966422021389,
-0.2826841175556183,
0.13485634326934814,
-0.4601988196372986,
-0.5857900381088257,
0.023691896349191666,
0.6361836791038513,
-0.5155565738677979,
-0.8911306858062744,
-0.898208737373352,
0.36688363552093506,
-0.2211218923330307,
1.2121118307113647,
-0.07600957900285721,
0.25108635425567627,
-0.20394566655158997,
-0.20512795448303223,
-0.10373564064502716,
-0.24150528013706207,
0.0682995393872261,
-0.34074467420578003,
0.49772921204566956,
0.1569337695837021,
0.7009583711624146,
0.6026554703712463,
0.7098779082298279,
0.07971052825450897,
-0.25464674830436707,
0.3287397027015686,
-0.7266961336135864,
-0.12371061742305756,
-0.6929616332054138,
-0.440611332654953,
-0.1082615777850151,
0.06754975765943527,
0.8051401376724243,
0.9125444293022156,
0.06204934045672417,
0.5940629839897156,
0.34760525822639465,
0.5497660636901855,
-0.40978872776031494,
0.5227588415145874,
-0.3627021312713623,
-0.12011422961950302,
-0.25212183594703674,
0.19819532334804535,
-0.32034218311309814,
-0.379951536655426,
-0.06909330189228058,
-0.25499531626701355,
0.457444965839386,
0.12371858954429626,
0.7507507801055908,
0.4612013101577759,
-0.4298081696033478,
-0.39509978890419006,
-0.663798451423645,
0.8547247052192688,
-0.5237816572189331,
0.41152119636535645,
0.2568715512752533,
-0.015515419654548168,
-0.24311165511608124,
-0.359404981136322,
-0.4731540083885193,
0.1533239781856537,
0.23041501641273499,
-0.09633646160364151,
0.19912822544574738,
0.06591885536909103,
0.5475008487701416,
0.3550601899623871,
-0.45986616611480713,
0.4014078378677368,
-0.47705012559890747,
-0.027095748111605644,
0.8057962656021118,
0.09588246792554855,
-0.1981227546930313,
-0.23776407539844513,
-0.33562424778938293,
0.07804781198501587,
-0.9256144165992737,
-0.26650163531303406,
0.4894651770591736,
0.7082707285881042,
-0.10557160526514053,
0.6726182699203491,
-0.23590272665023804,
0.627038300037384,
-0.20454908907413483,
-0.032106686383485794,
0.29956185817718506,
-0.7873148322105408,
0.04629461094737053,
0.02816757559776306,
0.5391204357147217,
0.6015838980674744,
0.035761334002017975,
-0.2661694288253784,
-0.0002502950082998723,
0.3266776502132416,
0.1945648342370987,
-0.9480702877044678,
-0.20483514666557312,
0.11824061721563339,
-0.5926272869110107,
0.025091852992773056,
0.05132446438074112,
-0.7173539400100708,
-0.6021134257316589,
-0.5426339507102966,
0.016213275492191315,
0.0011364882811903954,
-0.1207328736782074,
0.28105583786964417,
0.1389753669500351,
0.010018418543040752,
0.17976538836956024,
-0.6251397132873535,
0.03055351786315441,
0.5691395998001099,
0.899178683757782,
-0.2071034163236618,
-0.006298473104834557,
-0.24516847729682922,
0.33974790573120117,
-0.08349373191595078,
0.7444668412208557,
-0.6386010050773621,
-0.5534769296646118,
-0.03545735403895378,
-0.04714830964803696,
0.18046338856220245,
-0.529321014881134,
0.9795607328414917,
-0.39440613985061646,
-0.23447325825691223,
-0.9066172242164612,
-0.6781226396560669,
-0.09156638383865356,
-0.020879806950688362,
-0.7697608470916748,
0.8386203050613403,
-0.05870850011706352,
-0.7420561909675598,
1.148301124572754,
-0.5613983273506165,
-0.3479715585708618,
0.21277517080307007,
-0.29139503836631775,
-0.34832116961479187,
0.17466747760772705,
0.09528505057096481,
0.6898884773254395,
-0.58808434009552,
0.5176666975021362,
-0.4135240912437439,
-0.2740333080291748,
-0.08178726583719254,
-0.021437928080558777,
0.601101815700531,
0.2020626813173294,
0.04340410977602005,
-0.15703454613685608,
-1.0840028524398804,
0.06280484050512314,
-0.274120956659317,
-0.7517320513725281,
-0.4633208215236664,
0.4078058898448944,
0.17981061339378357,
0.19864219427108765,
0.22753606736660004,
-0.6289605498313904,
0.5152322053909302,
0.0029349022079259157,
0.3548646569252014,
0.8094717264175415,
-0.17837515473365784,
0.17079012095928192,
-0.28229621052742004,
0.32762208580970764,
-0.053747471421957016,
-0.08089740574359894,
0.25700756907463074,
-0.40453875064849854,
-0.1708013117313385,
-0.5323383808135986,
0.6202324032783508,
0.20223075151443481,
-0.4270870089530945,
0.7898550033569336,
-0.4859893321990967,
-0.4371848404407501,
-0.571703314781189,
0.3909188508987427,
0.1181321069598198,
0.1768837571144104,
0.23945185542106628,
-0.2694109380245209,
-0.5228161811828613,
-0.7001306414604187,
-0.3800341486930847,
-0.08864065259695053,
-0.036941830068826675,
0.47377046942710876,
0.7942237257957458,
-0.5113537907600403,
0.7294905185699463,
-0.2672359049320221,
-0.27323290705680847,
0.12256240844726562,
0.21054311096668243,
0.36666104197502136,
0.055949196219444275,
0.46303147077560425,
-0.9859896302223206,
-0.2728428840637207,
-0.09334293007850647,
-0.7750962376594543,
-0.458286851644516,
0.240923672914505,
0.06869672983884811,
0.04227379336953163,
0.36044204235076904,
-0.6161179542541504,
0.08329479396343231,
0.5424667000770569,
-0.4171063303947449,
0.4715324938297272,
0.042310189455747604,
-0.05883394181728363,
-0.7507055401802063,
-0.06926914304494858,
0.3799392282962799,
-0.036141082644462585,
-0.2560464143753052,
0.04532482102513313,
0.23524340987205505,
0.1542062759399414,
-0.05492375046014786,
0.3402123749256134,
-0.51279217004776,
-0.16937746107578278,
0.012630203738808632,
-0.023806288838386536,
-0.15913008153438568,
-0.25064051151275635,
-0.026108872145414352,
0.5232788920402527,
0.5262227654457092,
-0.8540254831314087,
0.2230340838432312,
0.3372440040111542,
-0.7248932123184204,
0.5676141381263733,
-0.5403494238853455,
-0.14930571615695953,
-0.34419143199920654,
0.3056153357028961,
-0.7918993234634399,
-0.22481441497802734,
-0.1988605409860611,
0.013800167478621006,
0.18632446229457855,
-0.2710212469100952,
-0.8932406306266785,
-0.4867989718914032,
-0.19740258157253265,
0.18615564703941345,
0.2010459005832672,
-0.743192195892334,
0.20922081172466278,
0.37894707918167114,
-0.1344459354877472,
-0.4496380686759949,
-0.5909120440483093,
-0.0388222336769104,
-0.3802590072154999,
-0.5982965230941772,
0.14287777245044708,
-0.13222627341747284,
-0.27127474546432495,
-0.09877586364746094,
-0.22309979796409607,
0.6268652677536011,
-0.160746768116951,
0.36670684814453125,
0.037731755524873734,
0.08043325692415237,
0.2608778476715088,
-0.09349840134382248,
0.33621707558631897,
0.13987292349338531,
-0.25623565912246704,
0.45806989073753357,
0.08657651394605637,
-0.27461573481559753,
0.11655088514089584,
0.14088357985019684,
0.47925397753715515,
-0.39661723375320435,
0.9309239387512207,
0.5663736462593079,
-0.16670727729797363,
-0.47097915410995483,
-0.4657767415046692,
-0.06904897093772888,
-0.432169646024704,
0.34391218423843384,
-0.2106124609708786,
-1.0117549896240234,
0.6735872626304626,
-0.38536179065704346,
0.11409734189510345,
0.13655655086040497,
0.6326832175254822,
0.13886310160160065,
1.0696667432785034,
0.5061188340187073,
0.024760501459240913,
0.25037625432014465,
-0.1332431137561798,
0.24602438509464264,
-0.8921502232551575,
-0.2839643955230713,
-0.802447497844696,
-0.3056800663471222,
-0.9005947113037109,
-0.5437438488006592,
0.26475289463996887,
0.47605594992637634,
-0.2291211634874344,
0.04665500298142433,
-0.6283338069915771,
0.3589591085910797,
0.1677534431219101,
-0.15143916010856628,
0.2918165624141693,
0.1561088263988495,
-0.059650011360645294,
-0.2628133296966553,
-0.46190646290779114,
-0.8661425709724426,
1.2751784324645996,
0.32636958360671997,
1.1537961959838867,
0.20463289320468903,
0.7415940165519714,
0.4448917508125305,
0.22026027739048004,
-0.5558689832687378,
0.3707273602485657,
-0.41093531250953674,
-0.5713832378387451,
-0.16756413877010345,
-0.6014076471328735,
-0.7740750908851624,
0.21636448800563812,
-0.148929163813591,
-0.6877805590629578,
0.5796235203742981,
-0.12741057574748993,
-0.1342051923274994,
0.16737332940101624,
-0.600570023059845,
0.458494633436203,
-0.18863314390182495,
-0.5142016410827637,
-0.1650783270597458,
-0.2649998962879181,
0.14047619700431824,
-0.020124688744544983,
0.5132399797439575,
-0.42526566982269287,
-0.037624821066856384,
0.7236347794532776,
0.033832620829343796,
0.8375025987625122,
-0.27352404594421387,
-0.3438279330730438,
0.16654463112354279,
-0.05868400260806084,
0.6302263140678406,
0.22675591707229614,
-0.3517853915691376,
0.43669837713241577,
-0.05001993849873543,
-0.44306862354278564,
-0.08419196307659149,
0.8028004765510559,
-0.5666790008544922,
-0.4768618643283844,
-0.43186458945274353,
-0.5108650326728821,
-0.2701179087162018,
0.3780142366886139,
-0.04421217739582062,
-0.1976441890001297,
-0.3247433602809906,
0.2644970715045929,
1.0059205293655396,
-0.2388085573911667,
0.09347124397754669,
0.6824820041656494,
-0.18678002059459686,
0.08665723353624344,
0.8867021799087524,
0.6146410703659058,
0.37094083428382874,
-0.003484713612124324,
0.08786723762750626,
-0.47138792276382446,
-0.9110228419303894,
-0.28313136100769043,
0.42617180943489075,
-0.5587427020072937,
-0.2921372354030609,
-0.41120824217796326,
0.09075465798377991,
-0.4593198895454407,
0.018343640491366386,
0.015396827831864357,
-0.11881040036678314,
-0.43050405383110046,
-0.3165975511074066,
0.4643941819667816,
0.8791319727897644,
-0.08887406438589096,
-0.0534958690404892,
-0.5601077079772949,
0.3749353885650635,
-0.10006790608167648,
0.6422050595283508,
-0.3750441372394562,
-0.18106324970722198,
-0.3577475845813751,
0.20278076827526093,
-0.21559394896030426,
-0.5737272500991821,
0.18818362057209015,
0.25841379165649414,
0.5960087776184082,
0.38690608739852905,
0.17130769789218903,
0.3370043635368347,
-0.5082138776779175,
0.6799964308738708,
0.03600731119513512,
-0.6266933679580688,
0.39112210273742676,
-0.7514399886131287,
0.10575917363166809,
0.43697866797447205,
0.5744295716285706,
-0.12502425909042358,
-0.034829892218112946,
-0.26367413997650146,
-0.9833435416221619,
0.6644598841667175,
-0.1661207526922226,
-0.061633046716451645,
0.02430007979273796,
0.36782121658325195,
0.3418283462524414,
0.5771479606628418,
-0.6875629425048828,
0.058130037039518356,
-0.10199229419231415,
-0.17117173969745636,
-0.15002836287021637,
-0.23288500308990479,
-0.354947954416275,
0.01060743723064661,
0.5781420469284058,
-0.3627265393733978,
-0.05642952397465706,
-0.06090899929404259,
0.022243572399020195,
-0.05846669524908066,
0.4901772737503052,
0.2561403810977936,
0.833995521068573,
-0.21852673590183258,
0.07726076245307922,
-0.07654844224452972,
-0.43143558502197266,
-0.14361904561519623,
0.17293709516525269,
-0.46940284967422485,
-0.23596465587615967,
0.12230871617794037,
0.6514094471931458,
-0.0903983935713768,
-0.785793125629425,
-0.06591787189245224,
0.09384471923112869,
-0.18804669380187988,
0.12366607785224915,
0.10581820458173752,
0.20777691900730133,
0.41416192054748535,
0.1806873232126236,
-0.1627844125032425,
0.17035309970378876,
-0.6685647368431091,
-0.0836513414978981,
0.538969874382019,
0.08816968649625778,
-0.06369122117757797,
0.7072381377220154,
0.23867137730121613,
0.0951346829533577,
0.3330889940261841,
-0.3162499964237213,
-0.2589331269264221,
0.4192127287387848,
0.44413942098617554,
0.23947644233703613,
-0.0916808694601059,
0.2557596266269684,
0.3849790692329407,
0.44098734855651855,
-0.46220019459724426,
0.6938028931617737,
0.12834303081035614,
-0.7517799735069275,
-0.4189538061618805,
-1.0922216176986694,
-0.19996769726276398,
-0.1364142745733261,
-0.8588398098945618,
0.31966516375541687,
-0.43649017810821533,
-0.3961785137653351,
0.4570348262786865,
0.17013466358184814,
-0.9392829537391663,
0.058802761137485504,
0.05251391977071762,
0.5079772472381592,
-0.7574748992919922,
0.6603288054466248,
0.6904018521308899,
-0.33050304651260376,
-0.3769141435623169,
-0.07045543938875198,
-0.1480824202299118,
-0.6530156135559082,
0.7956150770187378,
0.013310295529663563,
0.07724621146917343,
-0.3079858720302582,
-0.7214043736457825,
-0.870712161064148,
0.9297312498092651,
0.5686211585998535,
-0.8326603770256042,
-0.1167827919125557,
0.37205010652542114,
0.6894810199737549,
-0.19853068888187408,
-0.26717454195022583,
0.6707803010940552,
0.793496310710907,
-0.2533719837665558,
-1.0685346126556396,
-0.03324786201119423,
0.10934805124998093,
0.011434084735810757,
0.30534836649894714,
-1.0620676279067993,
0.7803076505661011,
-0.16494472324848175,
-0.05341406166553497,
-0.3455386459827423,
0.3974493443965912,
0.21186259388923645,
0.1149294376373291,
0.13319267332553864,
0.6075944304466248,
1.000465989112854,
-0.37943387031555176,
1.059403657913208,
-0.15982744097709656,
0.5705351233482361,
0.6891307234764099,
-0.7623998522758484,
0.4359987676143646,
0.3598323166370392,
-0.5445922613143921,
0.175254225730896,
0.6183661818504333,
-0.6116805076599121,
0.6081148982048035,
0.6006276607513428,
-0.20493140816688538,
-0.22745393216609955,
-0.4749969244003296,
-0.30425533652305603,
0.30761775374412537,
0.7418519258499146,
-0.45930221676826477,
-0.12122786045074463,
0.05647813528776169,
-0.05016680061817169,
0.2897631824016571,
-0.7926168441772461,
0.32858362793922424,
0.08942972868680954,
-0.29746124148368835,
0.5942836403846741,
0.16495227813720703,
0.8342936038970947,
-0.31302595138549805,
-0.024663012474775314,
0.17652177810668945,
0.19749215245246887,
-0.5309726595878601,
-0.9226893782615662,
0.10379071533679962,
0.01706794649362564,
-0.5335955023765564,
-0.1857619285583496,
0.47607603669166565,
-0.3065240979194641,
-0.7146278619766235,
0.3363165855407715,
0.18398453295230865,
0.04922961816191673,
0.2259412705898285,
-0.4017738699913025,
0.30627837777137756,
0.06763918697834015,
-0.15075325965881348,
0.39165225625038147,
0.5161232948303223,
-0.2997719645500183,
0.6511257290840149,
0.4127199053764343,
0.38578319549560547,
0.22286908328533173,
0.21898919343948364,
0.6485791206359863,
-0.45990949869155884,
-0.4326099157333374,
-0.6242095232009888,
0.02347693219780922,
-0.015659529715776443,
-0.1680753380060196,
1.0908604860305786,
0.7016943693161011,
0.9927136301994324,
0.1641930490732193,
1.0701472759246826,
-0.14372199773788452,
0.8308178782463074,
-0.43506336212158203,
0.5327927470207214,
-0.292095810174942,
0.4571116268634796,
-0.4256110191345215,
-1.0167193412780762,
-0.21405234932899475,
0.5575103163719177,
-0.3401884138584137,
0.33964619040489197,
0.11674649268388748,
0.530714750289917,
0.05919152870774269,
0.1392299383878708,
0.07345739006996155,
0.27350494265556335,
0.3478097915649414,
0.13381722569465637,
0.42369702458381653,
0.03388332575559616,
0.12562361359596252,
0.20872901380062103,
-0.05038842931389809,
-0.12697777152061462,
-0.8459592461585999,
-1.0976258516311646,
-0.32016465067863464,
-0.4402126371860504,
-0.4050862491130829,
0.20333856344223022,
0.7473835349082947,
0.5258030891418457,
-0.8563753962516785,
-0.016431264579296112,
0.08493779599666595,
0.08576033264398575,
-0.01998412236571312,
-0.2046481966972351,
0.587602436542511,
0.24800196290016174,
-0.7459649443626404,
0.1322353184223175,
-0.04528136923909187,
-0.12386465817689896,
-0.5710557103157043,
-0.06551408767700195,
-0.19964998960494995,
0.028860019519925117,
0.4751405417919159,
0.18307718634605408,
-0.43651384115219116,
-0.4299508333206177,
-0.2854306995868683,
0.12316227704286575,
-0.2218073308467865,
0.7269445657730103,
-0.6142420768737793,
0.3269434869289398,
0.37248873710632324,
0.5807138681411743,
0.5826953053474426,
0.0264971274882555,
0.26892781257629395,
-0.6284160017967224,
-0.07176288962364197,
0.22003918886184692,
0.34841224551200867,
0.4546591639518738,
-0.3454380929470062,
0.6193868517875671,
0.04863816872239113,
-0.7804010510444641,
-1.1402581930160522,
0.25751766562461853,
-0.7305039167404175,
-0.18557581305503845,
1.4983986616134644,
0.012874064967036247,
0.23442095518112183,
-0.21851854026317596,
-0.02505427412688732,
0.12828445434570312,
-0.41466888785362244,
0.9453666806221008,
1.1315103769302368,
-0.25943928956985474,
-0.04497184231877327,
-0.6645376086235046,
0.5472452044487,
0.12621954083442688,
-0.609520673751831,
0.32185232639312744,
0.7215257883071899,
0.2265121191740036,
0.1995113641023636,
0.1327752023935318,
-0.26193273067474365,
-0.11668119579553604,
-0.256916344165802,
0.28495320677757263,
0.15481683611869812,
-0.18742921948432922,
-0.24553492665290833,
0.042154405266046524,
0.33079293370246887,
0.35668814182281494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03004v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03004v1
|
Exploring prompts to elicit memorization in masked language model-based named entity recognition
| 2024-05-05T17:19:35 | 2024-05-05T17:19:35 |
Yuxi Xia, Anastasiia Sedova, Pedro Henrique Luz de Araujo, Vasiliki Kougia, Lisa Nußbaumer, Benjamin Roth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Training data memorization in language models impacts model capability
(generalization) and safety (privacy risk). This paper focuses on analyzing
prompts' impact on detecting the memorization of 6 masked language model-based
named entity recognition models. Specifically, we employ a diverse set of 400
automatically generated prompts, and a pairwise dataset where each pair
consists of one person's name from the training set and another name out of the
set. A prompt completed with a person's name serves as input for getting the
model's confidence in predicting this name. Finally, the prompt performance of
detecting model memorization is quantified by the percentage of name pairs for
which the model has higher confidence for the name from the training set. We
show that the performance of different prompts varies by as much as 16
percentage points on the same model, and prompt engineering further increases
the gap. Moreover, our experiments demonstrate that prompt performance is
model-dependent but does generalize across different name sets. A comprehensive
analysis indicates how prompt performance is influenced by prompt properties,
contained tokens, and the model's self-attention weights on the prompt.
|
[
-0.308860182762146,
-0.4880499243736267,
0.724994421005249,
0.06603000313043594,
-0.07276991009712219,
-0.03599962219595909,
0.0224765595048666,
-0.4184567928314209,
-0.033471737056970596,
0.4868974983692169,
-0.45833805203437805,
-0.45617201924324036,
-0.43936216831207275,
0.20418719947338104,
-0.09553635865449905,
0.8580505847930908,
0.15742549300193787,
-0.024047400802373886,
-0.1666181981563568,
0.018324071541428566,
-1.0419901609420776,
-0.695615828037262,
-0.7224811911582947,
0.19957305490970612,
0.6271997094154358,
0.16023306548595428,
0.18224413692951202,
0.8383302092552185,
0.2542961537837982,
0.2820202708244324,
-0.2297026813030243,
-0.20591585338115692,
-0.07092645019292831,
0.5480288863182068,
0.0014825710095465183,
-0.6243576407432556,
-0.26555630564689636,
0.1234806627035141,
0.8919619917869568,
0.664131760597229,
0.12140543013811111,
0.11290839314460754,
0.016305476427078247,
0.3064323365688324,
-0.7245178818702698,
0.20502780377864838,
-0.7643689513206482,
-0.12428149580955505,
-0.0708577036857605,
-0.17196635901927948,
-0.6284170150756836,
-0.0595393143594265,
0.2892001271247864,
-0.4829029142856598,
0.5476999878883362,
0.3754783272743225,
0.7403437495231628,
0.150798037648201,
-0.22460058331489563,
-0.38112202286720276,
-0.563261091709137,
0.6527106761932373,
-0.3263927102088928,
0.5175110697746277,
0.5095245242118835,
0.39545580744743347,
-0.07406128942966461,
-0.6030359864234924,
-0.2913241386413574,
-0.2929712235927582,
-0.11208098381757736,
-0.3196854591369629,
-0.2039809226989746,
0.2939562201499939,
1.0024781227111816,
0.1916513890028,
-0.29912298917770386,
0.16316543519496918,
-0.49645909667015076,
-0.4151035249233246,
0.3090578317642212,
0.1508314311504364,
0.5986178517341614,
-0.17757385969161987,
-0.4689290523529053,
0.03547300770878792,
-0.6553935408592224,
0.5846781730651855,
0.49186620116233826,
0.5578045845031738,
0.10263504087924957,
0.20310913026332855,
-0.2524026334285736,
0.6156606674194336,
0.14402613043785095,
-0.16907745599746704,
0.17322644591331482,
0.016445647925138474,
-0.3996049165725708,
0.30636224150657654,
0.5493677258491516,
0.2915647625923157,
0.36188599467277527,
-0.23068244755268097,
-0.5091187357902527,
-0.14859607815742493,
0.031819093972444534,
-0.9335755109786987,
-0.443102091550827,
0.04544458165764809,
-0.4413338899612427,
-0.12431412935256958,
0.0585256852209568,
-0.4735686480998993,
-0.6764691472053528,
-0.32112857699394226,
0.49404677748680115,
-0.5291563272476196,
-0.05132819339632988,
0.011190575547516346,
-0.3045906722545624,
-0.018643315881490707,
0.4816378355026245,
-0.9611486792564392,
0.22201070189476013,
0.5991232991218567,
0.7836899161338806,
-0.04949532821774483,
-0.08888989686965942,
-0.8478747010231018,
-0.07862073183059692,
-0.14683803915977478,
0.6878862977027893,
-0.6300904154777527,
-0.43353885412216187,
-0.20342230796813965,
0.14057080447673798,
-0.45227816700935364,
-0.5084190368652344,
0.22957836091518402,
-0.5636369585990906,
0.3664551377296448,
-0.5669294595718384,
-0.7625855803489685,
-0.26077502965927124,
0.048551443964242935,
-0.9336103200912476,
0.7262628078460693,
-0.27801641821861267,
-0.7129074335098267,
0.3881379961967468,
-0.25818148255348206,
-0.1934255212545395,
0.32509419322013855,
-0.30788883566856384,
-0.29606252908706665,
0.18800495564937592,
0.3126462697982788,
0.6513306498527527,
-0.06652148067951202,
0.2848677635192871,
-0.04601806029677391,
-0.32106447219848633,
0.5182018280029297,
-0.4197760820388794,
0.8165231347084045,
0.048680972307920456,
-0.355691134929657,
-0.20629101991653442,
-0.9522244930267334,
-0.10588611662387848,
-0.05438350513577461,
-0.04986421763896942,
-0.6237501502037048,
-0.38995465636253357,
-0.39792102575302124,
0.1886066496372223,
-0.11095165461301804,
-0.2968837022781372,
0.06453823298215866,
-0.14479775726795197,
0.20093804597854614,
0.825727641582489,
0.49027374386787415,
0.33137035369873047,
-0.3343086838722229,
0.7797244191169739,
0.17922016978263855,
0.028063012287020683,
-1.074568271636963,
-0.8109097480773926,
-0.601703405380249,
-0.5129684805870056,
0.6764099597930908,
0.5074265003204346,
-0.45204269886016846,
0.020884988829493523,
-0.050368066877126694,
-0.22243012487888336,
-0.4790474772453308,
-0.25478965044021606,
0.5849083662033081,
0.7727490663528442,
0.1921498328447342,
-0.2551060616970062,
-0.3650861978530884,
-0.9548179507255554,
-0.4809403419494629,
-0.38078707456588745,
-0.12453523278236389,
0.5202454328536987,
0.4833875894546509,
0.15304750204086304,
1.0605313777923584,
-0.36264580488204956,
-0.14910396933555603,
0.09349754452705383,
0.06171979382634163,
0.08231539279222488,
0.5681586861610413,
0.5464268922805786,
-0.6826785802841187,
-0.3426966369152069,
-0.5254629254341125,
-0.4657120108604431,
-0.1219862774014473,
-0.3280237913131714,
0.25588318705558777,
0.10507332533597946,
0.486167311668396,
-0.6381928324699402,
0.3060692250728607,
-0.016918208450078964,
-0.32863518595695496,
0.6218977570533752,
-0.07576324790716171,
0.15028499066829681,
-0.9468672871589661,
0.22803935408592224,
-0.07463233172893524,
-0.06429238617420197,
-0.9668994545936584,
-0.04714013263583183,
0.2723102569580078,
-0.13756175339221954,
-0.5583234429359436,
0.726771354675293,
-0.9624555110931396,
-0.06976611912250519,
0.10725903511047363,
-0.0523834191262722,
-0.01704179123044014,
0.4944201111793518,
0.01792425476014614,
1.1237748861312866,
0.6915766000747681,
-0.9252432584762573,
0.02838769741356373,
-0.013807731680572033,
-0.4905250668525696,
0.5716018080711365,
-0.5840005874633789,
0.4567333161830902,
-0.10504193603992462,
-0.11439915746450424,
-0.9996137022972107,
-0.23742792010307312,
0.41009536385536194,
-0.6218006014823914,
0.4815010130405426,
-0.29321354627609253,
-0.3251158893108368,
-0.06857797503471375,
-0.258730411529541,
0.4388807713985443,
0.3799990713596344,
-0.47332963347435,
0.5800493955612183,
0.365617960691452,
-0.1495906561613083,
-0.6990391612052917,
-0.48846524953842163,
0.09202724695205688,
-0.4191560745239258,
-0.34907081723213196,
0.22196954488754272,
-0.19871389865875244,
-0.3050978183746338,
-0.22847406566143036,
-0.29606831073760986,
-0.04779215157032013,
0.5195891857147217,
0.6292547583580017,
0.35675764083862305,
-0.0009538550511933863,
0.49735260009765625,
-0.06230136752128601,
-0.03293146193027496,
0.37969502806663513,
-0.41076356172561646,
0.47111400961875916,
-0.13618376851081848,
-0.04963064566254616,
-0.47869035601615906,
0.2511698007583618,
0.26971861720085144,
-0.409940242767334,
0.930412232875824,
-0.031196270138025284,
-0.7176216244697571,
-0.35435763001441956,
-0.6842960119247437,
-0.31363821029663086,
-0.5060558319091797,
-0.02691064029932022,
-0.7690916657447815,
-0.8154213428497314,
0.9336736798286438,
0.17391572892665863,
-0.2745923101902008,
0.19151590764522552,
0.29021012783050537,
0.023528853431344032,
0.904288649559021,
0.5469282269477844,
0.07688166201114655,
0.6694766879081726,
0.047827403992414474,
0.09386307001113892,
-0.7696249485015869,
-0.5348246693611145,
-0.5061025619506836,
-0.17732450366020203,
-0.5013040900230408,
-0.24004815518856049,
0.05990923196077347,
0.059445612132549286,
0.1345839947462082,
0.3200637102127075,
-0.5080627202987671,
0.704870879650116,
0.6455022692680359,
0.07478732615709305,
0.29029926657676697,
-0.030110623687505722,
-0.5037318468093872,
-0.04142091050744057,
-0.45782753825187683,
-0.5050835013389587,
0.9216315150260925,
0.5358551144599915,
0.4055770933628082,
-0.22940590977668762,
0.82830810546875,
0.46194764971733093,
-0.21768252551555634,
-0.5724957585334778,
0.7407912015914917,
0.47951316833496094,
-0.5998902320861816,
-0.2124497890472412,
-0.3880614936351776,
-0.972215473651886,
-0.0402924083173275,
0.15172980725765228,
-0.8830897212028503,
0.45802170038223267,
0.22614388167858124,
-0.734351396560669,
0.08620930463075638,
-0.8045242428779602,
0.7966678738594055,
-0.1442994475364685,
0.1082330197095871,
0.31871697306632996,
-0.6212501525878906,
0.3907485604286194,
0.00683093536645174,
-0.05781661719083786,
-0.1637754589319229,
-0.08829084783792496,
0.882953405380249,
-0.04902750626206398,
0.8476799130439758,
-0.3132699728012085,
0.0397697389125824,
0.1921493113040924,
0.0732642188668251,
0.6681126952171326,
0.06829521805047989,
0.18050968647003174,
0.03652713820338249,
-0.37261462211608887,
-0.05249989405274391,
-0.7131630778312683,
0.5385370850563049,
-0.4347958266735077,
-0.9035744071006775,
-0.2884257733821869,
-0.505321204662323,
-0.11768797785043716,
0.290414422750473,
0.4686028063297272,
0.4142681658267975,
0.004893227480351925,
-0.1019347757101059,
1.3085076808929443,
-0.3217082917690277,
0.31031185388565063,
0.5312167406082153,
-0.31479790806770325,
-0.25016090273857117,
0.8438125252723694,
0.4346180856227875,
0.3318667709827423,
0.29036885499954224,
-0.1966225951910019,
-0.2448296844959259,
-0.5141139626502991,
-0.46499204635620117,
0.26910465955734253,
-1.0069698095321655,
-0.22325842082500458,
-1.1158440113067627,
-0.16835367679595947,
-0.44642993807792664,
0.18715378642082214,
0.1314459890127182,
-0.6718966960906982,
-0.6251738667488098,
-0.3815023899078369,
0.3024888336658478,
0.4087572395801544,
0.29866108298301697,
0.22248786687850952,
-0.5852389931678772,
0.029519570991396904,
0.5435000658035278,
0.3983501195907593,
0.004809912759810686,
-0.5197777152061462,
0.07150402665138245,
-0.2668148875236511,
0.25965723395347595,
-1.331612467765808,
0.18418847024440765,
0.06411562860012054,
0.7376129627227783,
0.47247427701950073,
0.17040398716926575,
0.359983891248703,
-0.378834992647171,
0.6475151181221008,
0.03474990651011467,
-0.9372714757919312,
0.6458461880683899,
-0.3817368149757385,
0.059174031019210815,
0.4978412091732025,
0.19001765549182892,
-0.7463522553443909,
-0.40423375368118286,
-0.7191464900970459,
-0.5989076495170593,
0.9354525804519653,
0.11029496043920517,
0.09203407913446426,
-0.10785020142793655,
0.42395877838134766,
0.06910749524831772,
0.3447995185852051,
-0.5483738780021667,
-0.3973443806171417,
0.13425500690937042,
0.14143714308738708,
0.3302503228187561,
-0.48017603158950806,
0.2039342224597931,
0.1354527473449707,
0.4721149206161499,
0.11312796920537949,
0.3781234622001648,
-0.04512744024395943,
-0.3104627728462219,
0.15623235702514648,
0.3922029733657837,
0.6862881779670715,
0.04006178304553032,
-0.15188594162464142,
0.12265937775373459,
0.2247251570224762,
-0.42528265714645386,
0.1696820706129074,
0.16290707886219025,
-0.5649868249893188,
0.26736611127853394,
0.24056380987167358,
1.2720870971679688,
0.2687740921974182,
-0.5273846983909607,
0.34025776386260986,
-0.24493248760700226,
0.18836311995983124,
-0.18683277070522308,
0.5496071577072144,
-0.19525906443595886,
0.1365157961845398,
0.42031624913215637,
0.04902788624167442,
0.43964049220085144,
-0.38968271017074585,
0.18788295984268188,
0.4087313115596771,
-0.3378152549266815,
-0.3969650864601135,
0.6849821209907532,
0.0007222297135740519,
-0.6543332934379578,
0.6650407910346985,
-0.30654773116111755,
-0.7493134140968323,
0.9246541857719421,
0.5027158856391907,
1.0580958127975464,
-0.7364134192466736,
0.1185740977525711,
0.5221547484397888,
0.4110215902328491,
-0.1336883157491684,
0.11641224473714828,
-0.260718435049057,
-0.3971802294254303,
0.2171539068222046,
-0.21265573799610138,
-0.33021280169487,
0.16176916658878326,
-0.7714588642120361,
0.5031864047050476,
-0.7226056456565857,
-0.4000927209854126,
0.07808654755353928,
-0.16924349963665009,
-0.8788583874702454,
0.20742067694664001,
0.31901222467422485,
0.9114612340927124,
-0.7786087989807129,
0.5119435787200928,
0.6671373248100281,
-0.38754111528396606,
-1.1069724559783936,
0.028057502582669258,
0.013471199199557304,
-0.7108725309371948,
0.6990208625793457,
0.9956395626068115,
0.11602340638637543,
0.14977416396141052,
-0.2607845366001129,
-0.9634175300598145,
1.2029811143875122,
0.4079437553882599,
-0.7074763178825378,
-0.3279808461666107,
0.04373545199632645,
0.4953588843345642,
-0.5539708137512207,
0.39697322249412537,
0.5075028538703918,
0.25169509649276733,
-0.13054567575454712,
-0.956618070602417,
0.1753467619419098,
-0.31945618987083435,
0.18464910984039307,
0.10808423906564713,
-0.3670208156108856,
1.1088067293167114,
-0.4443119764328003,
-0.9173990488052368,
-0.09491976350545883,
0.5423009395599365,
0.4934799075126648,
0.5326775312423706,
0.5247778296470642,
0.23025549948215485,
1.2585705518722534,
0.040250249207019806,
0.9768800735473633,
-0.2394152283668518,
0.2255944460630417,
1.0253657102584839,
-0.20051072537899017,
0.41842493414878845,
0.3451400399208069,
0.08162656426429749,
0.47307637333869934,
0.5625154376029968,
-0.2362019419670105,
0.5062474608421326,
0.14593695104122162,
-0.3192267119884491,
-0.23737013339996338,
-0.42130953073501587,
-0.4242887496948242,
-0.02520734630525112,
0.4418204724788666,
-0.7047765851020813,
-0.000079253593867179,
0.3762424886226654,
0.04928349331021309,
-0.2607627809047699,
-0.3875288963317871,
0.5952608585357666,
0.14904193580150604,
-0.8763889670372009,
0.33435606956481934,
-0.04056907072663307,
0.3271666467189789,
-0.2959245443344116,
0.07964432239532471,
-0.1984458565711975,
-0.04625924676656723,
0.08757186681032181,
-0.49994957447052,
-0.2218378633260727,
0.07324208319187164,
-0.5249446034431458,
-0.21310555934906006,
0.92549729347229,
-0.4355626404285431,
-0.25737714767456055,
0.1255928874015808,
0.3861916661262512,
0.228178471326828,
-0.39063066244125366,
-0.49276167154312134,
-0.22349461913108826,
-0.07885771244764328,
-0.31278106570243835,
0.4442947506904602,
0.44050905108451843,
-0.27794402837753296,
0.8635089993476868,
0.6902874708175659,
-0.20430146157741547,
0.42938166856765747,
-0.034147605299949646,
0.717391848564148,
-0.5357660055160522,
-0.7809969782829285,
-0.9743979573249817,
0.4845168888568878,
-0.06908935308456421,
-0.1468970775604248,
0.8296253085136414,
0.4795886278152466,
0.7493131756782532,
-0.243723526597023,
0.6022796630859375,
0.36735326051712036,
0.48418527841567993,
-0.7024597525596619,
0.7347443699836731,
-0.061515748500823975,
0.6191660761833191,
-0.11904159188270569,
-0.7547434568405151,
-0.26523348689079285,
0.24167756736278534,
-0.3474216163158417,
0.30876845121383667,
0.5120723247528076,
0.8867369890213013,
0.2520264983177185,
-0.05947404354810715,
0.47639429569244385,
-0.21944905817508698,
0.299102783203125,
0.5312272906303406,
0.957236111164093,
-0.4136626124382019,
0.3557029962539673,
-0.15363234281539917,
0.01716906763613224,
-0.21562016010284424,
-0.857590913772583,
-1.3781417608261108,
-0.7449914813041687,
-0.40698760747909546,
-0.23753617703914642,
0.2679390013217926,
0.9333309531211853,
0.4764566421508789,
-0.8715706467628479,
0.3323817551136017,
0.11575635522603989,
0.22942985594272614,
-0.07781822979450226,
-0.214565247297287,
0.4395259916782379,
-0.4494175910949707,
-0.6892896294593811,
0.29556483030319214,
0.21312792599201202,
0.4616625905036926,
0.007050209678709507,
0.11429572850465775,
0.24696576595306396,
0.13293099403381348,
0.04561722278594971,
0.40009674429893494,
-0.7846139669418335,
-0.15696099400520325,
0.45223987102508545,
-0.33359217643737793,
-0.030725473538041115,
1.0351805686950684,
-1.1003923416137695,
0.6513071656227112,
0.38826504349708557,
0.513274610042572,
-0.01213059388101101,
-0.07150430977344513,
0.46887901425361633,
-1.180566430091858,
-0.09674164652824402,
0.12491406500339508,
0.4484513998031616,
0.4469607472419739,
-0.6394240260124207,
0.1353403925895691,
0.5463203191757202,
-0.4355975389480591,
-1.1388670206069946,
0.0939968004822731,
-0.6944513320922852,
-0.03105316497385502,
1.176713228225708,
-0.4701385200023651,
-0.06620325148105621,
-0.22286613285541534,
-0.13327448070049286,
0.19309240579605103,
-0.6664565205574036,
0.7963601350784302,
0.8612145185470581,
0.2302830070257187,
-0.4722035229206085,
-0.5365896224975586,
0.6072422862052917,
0.3334164023399353,
-0.47776666283607483,
0.18988539278507233,
0.5495452880859375,
0.3684764504432678,
0.16909199953079224,
0.6444805264472961,
0.30821847915649414,
0.5967153906822205,
-0.10455678403377533,
-0.023042570799589157,
-0.5625839829444885,
-0.6893492937088013,
-0.9025138020515442,
0.2157907485961914,
-0.1155146062374115,
-0.41189032793045044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03003v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03003v1
|
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning with Discrete Fourier Transform
| 2024-05-05T17:15:24 | 2024-05-05T17:15:24 |
Ziqi Gao, Qichao Wang, Aochuan Chen, Zijing Liu, Bingzhe Wu, Liang Chen, Jia Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Low-rank adaptation~(LoRA) has recently gained much interest in fine-tuning
foundation models. It effectively reduces the number of trainable parameters by
incorporating low-rank matrices $A$ and $B$ to represent the weight change,
i.e., $\Delta W=BA$. Despite LoRA's progress, it faces storage challenges when
handling extensive customization adaptations or larger base models. In this
work, we aim to further compress trainable parameters by enjoying the powerful
expressiveness of the Fourier transform. Specifically, we introduce FourierFT,
which treats $\Delta W$ as a matrix in the spatial domain and learns only a
small fraction of its spectral coefficients. With the trained spectral
coefficients, we implement the inverse discrete Fourier transform to recover
$\Delta W$. Empirically, our FourierFT method shows comparable or better
performance with fewer parameters than LoRA on various tasks, including natural
language understanding, natural language generation, instruction tuning, and
image classification. For example, when performing instruction tuning on the
LLaMA2-7B model, FourierFT surpasses LoRA with only 0.064M trainable
parameters, compared to LoRA's 33.5M. Our code is released at
\url{https://github.com/Chaos96/fourierft}.
|
[
-0.8707143068313599,
-0.7519930601119995,
0.2968551814556122,
0.2528306245803833,
-0.5127469301223755,
-0.18160264194011688,
-0.4450623393058777,
-0.5470657348632812,
0.08622675389051437,
0.45504194498062134,
-0.5681913495063782,
-0.2552536129951477,
-0.5472844839096069,
-0.16966812312602997,
-0.46685346961021423,
0.8586900234222412,
0.0047765769995749,
-0.1406656950712204,
0.25598177313804626,
-0.07335981726646423,
-0.32261717319488525,
-0.1040971428155899,
-0.7202872037887573,
-0.5472415685653687,
0.6758272051811218,
0.5526284575462341,
0.5528522729873657,
0.5941221714019775,
0.6637539863586426,
0.27844691276550293,
-0.030687833204865456,
-0.0625796839594841,
-0.8914055228233337,
-0.045491136610507965,
0.0036669981200248003,
-0.2626384198665619,
-0.4935651421546936,
-0.21266977488994598,
0.6989824175834656,
0.8868677020072937,
-0.4393990635871887,
0.4393039643764496,
0.1134304478764534,
1.1306780576705933,
-0.7378336787223816,
0.15441428124904633,
-0.7809857726097107,
0.11292987316846848,
-0.18185515701770782,
-0.2187182754278183,
-0.12141858786344528,
-0.5930101871490479,
-0.1317877322435379,
-0.8015890717506409,
0.1450873762369156,
-0.1747887134552002,
0.8837279677391052,
0.7932451963424683,
-0.3164277672767639,
0.5099860429763794,
-0.9241418838500977,
0.7204857468605042,
-0.49826788902282715,
0.8071107268333435,
0.632962167263031,
0.7974522709846497,
-0.12461300194263458,
-0.6786899566650391,
-0.3849930763244629,
0.29499495029449463,
0.1427445262670517,
-0.02455180138349533,
-0.3694293200969696,
0.08696204423904419,
0.38659021258354187,
0.45343562960624695,
-0.3238290250301361,
0.18198946118354797,
-0.4318375289440155,
0.03721604123711586,
0.5057828426361084,
-0.05019776523113251,
-0.5038977861404419,
0.13287833333015442,
-0.14862464368343353,
-0.5083978772163391,
-0.8135926723480225,
0.21521535515785217,
0.3194176256656647,
0.38048887252807617,
-0.21940627694129944,
0.23181366920471191,
-0.4889916777610779,
0.741358757019043,
0.6075212359428406,
-0.09095099568367004,
0.05265621468424797,
0.2098640650510788,
-0.5792438387870789,
-0.07419125735759735,
0.23032264411449432,
-0.016035178676247597,
0.2502145767211914,
-0.10185959935188293,
-0.1668110340833664,
-0.13792647421360016,
0.2771155834197998,
-1.03236722946167,
-0.4178466200828552,
-0.12394833564758301,
-0.47794222831726074,
-0.041166696697473526,
-0.14949378371238708,
-0.7742010354995728,
-0.3300422430038452,
-0.48466956615448,
0.62969571352005,
-0.28403621912002563,
0.16433294117450714,
0.24678318202495575,
-0.08273394405841827,
0.4871840178966522,
0.8456879258155823,
-1.1437230110168457,
0.5635175108909607,
0.5016401410102844,
0.39055636525154114,
0.02324683591723442,
-0.03977525606751442,
-0.7290721535682678,
-0.013473794795572758,
-0.29677385091781616,
0.7561877369880676,
-0.3782470226287842,
-0.30920231342315674,
-0.34311166405677795,
-0.26727554202079773,
0.04910416156053543,
-0.5185142159461975,
0.5523895025253296,
-0.7681698799133301,
-0.08553680032491684,
-0.44332119822502136,
0.07476798444986343,
-0.3500593900680542,
0.06495223194360733,
-0.7192662954330444,
1.2463414669036865,
0.48257431387901306,
-0.2670519948005676,
0.23440246284008026,
-0.6373298764228821,
-0.3423595130443573,
-0.21275165677070618,
-0.03647474944591522,
-0.4714698791503906,
0.40062758326530457,
0.30106499791145325,
0.43465331196784973,
-0.5149314999580383,
-0.009985598735511303,
-0.4700290560722351,
-0.8143148422241211,
0.012933317571878433,
-0.425670325756073,
0.3073479235172272,
0.05213356018066406,
-0.2668393552303314,
-0.28818705677986145,
-1.0560989379882812,
0.11918507516384125,
-0.056808724999427795,
-0.6670795679092407,
-0.14685973525047302,
-0.1463184356689453,
0.05804571881890297,
-0.0011639369186013937,
0.13798871636390686,
-0.3868057131767273,
0.25628623366355896,
-0.5678423047065735,
0.16943037509918213,
0.7947717308998108,
0.0727163553237915,
0.4497276842594147,
-0.31008413434028625,
0.26542097330093384,
-0.24421849846839905,
0.12908995151519775,
0.36646953225135803,
-0.2517721354961395,
-0.8823239803314209,
-0.4724343717098236,
0.5278610587120056,
0.09298485517501831,
-0.6092783212661743,
0.5093842148780823,
-0.4992925822734833,
-0.7039844989776611,
-0.32060644030570984,
0.2851552367210388,
0.06138025224208832,
0.6464695334434509,
0.5067815184593201,
-0.09770631045103073,
-0.45335158705711365,
-1.0101381540298462,
0.02981376275420189,
0.02780195139348507,
0.053465913981199265,
0.1458701491355896,
0.41774630546569824,
-0.11082550883293152,
1.109298825263977,
-0.7178290486335754,
-0.3467004895210266,
0.17981617152690887,
0.15015746653079987,
0.4523950517177582,
0.6468205451965332,
0.8238914012908936,
-0.7437412142753601,
-0.6055802702903748,
0.04187769815325737,
-0.3689028322696686,
-0.05078911781311035,
0.19462531805038452,
-0.3582788407802582,
-0.06595280021429062,
0.2118135541677475,
-0.4447356164455414,
0.3222983777523041,
0.534262478351593,
-0.15383167564868927,
0.05540212616324425,
-0.11072108149528503,
0.14032554626464844,
-0.7177554965019226,
0.27973946928977966,
-0.10515431314706802,
-0.41509246826171875,
-0.5194960832595825,
-0.0002773535961750895,
0.03515271469950676,
-0.1615590751171112,
-0.345762699842453,
0.4456090033054352,
-0.15931706130504608,
-0.03042934462428093,
-0.10918757319450378,
-0.19955562055110931,
-0.15779396891593933,
1.028864860534668,
-0.00006045584086677991,
0.4656224250793457,
0.43779951333999634,
-0.6284304857254028,
0.005602460354566574,
0.33391937613487244,
-0.3319655656814575,
0.6982694864273071,
-0.5367964506149292,
0.2169240117073059,
-0.011075484566390514,
0.16598373651504517,
-0.6921483874320984,
-0.11830773949623108,
0.2524505853652954,
-0.0212397538125515,
0.2965506315231323,
-0.4797179102897644,
-0.4644169807434082,
-0.08211614191532135,
-0.5526953935623169,
0.2139544039964676,
0.7434659600257874,
-0.9044092297554016,
0.5713845491409302,
0.08359359949827194,
-0.1047002524137497,
-0.5507988333702087,
-0.7410691380500793,
-0.33406737446784973,
-0.3349570631980896,
-0.38258519768714905,
0.46523743867874146,
-0.3244956433773041,
0.018336491659283638,
-0.2289280742406845,
-0.3347238302230835,
-0.15716980397701263,
0.4558885991573334,
0.33972442150115967,
-0.10010658204555511,
-0.4429975152015686,
-0.007924797013401985,
0.6849077343940735,
-0.18038725852966309,
-0.18695920705795288,
-0.03994598984718323,
0.39906182885169983,
-0.27081552147865295,
-0.3621152639389038,
-0.09242606908082962,
0.33282819390296936,
0.43633538484573364,
-0.04598012566566467,
0.5873177647590637,
0.7599174380302429,
-0.6368781328201294,
-0.5008910894393921,
-0.31346026062965393,
-0.272614985704422,
-0.6146214008331299,
0.3096150755882263,
-0.2610098719596863,
-0.7986617088317871,
0.5129364728927612,
-0.2883297801017761,
0.02802415005862713,
0.43935883045196533,
0.3890646696090698,
-0.31195199489593506,
0.6967917084693909,
0.7559030055999756,
0.06728503108024597,
0.6496891379356384,
-0.46490660309791565,
0.02198471687734127,
-0.6712875366210938,
0.1461353302001953,
-0.6497002840042114,
-0.8837554454803467,
-0.37727558612823486,
-0.21027539670467377,
0.6403948068618774,
0.5150980353355408,
-0.7792492508888245,
0.40234968066215515,
-0.37812039256095886,
0.5536350607872009,
0.38568413257598877,
0.2256387323141098,
0.2980341613292694,
0.3897470533847809,
0.40526673197746277,
-0.15090425312519073,
-0.4966643154621124,
0.04564863070845604,
0.7740601897239685,
0.40289855003356934,
1.0676430463790894,
0.4099180996417999,
0.8334527015686035,
0.302778959274292,
0.21609237790107727,
-0.7460622191429138,
0.48562633991241455,
-0.41965892910957336,
-0.1323065459728241,
-0.4738384485244751,
-0.4505584239959717,
-0.8842066526412964,
0.3854081928730011,
-0.40551576018333435,
-0.8709261417388916,
0.7982927560806274,
0.36901912093162537,
-0.5443281531333923,
0.07075914740562439,
-0.5004213452339172,
0.47746238112449646,
0.029261130839586258,
-0.08276286721229553,
-0.3934308886528015,
-0.4400408864021301,
0.34034040570259094,
-0.5925990343093872,
-0.056741371750831604,
-0.2111179530620575,
0.09792699664831161,
0.7512809634208679,
-0.3510342538356781,
0.8989420533180237,
-0.45199504494667053,
-0.45373964309692383,
-0.2638382613658905,
0.12665310502052307,
0.6179853677749634,
0.1396506130695343,
-0.2229291945695877,
0.23422996699810028,
0.16465649008750916,
-0.22101719677448273,
-0.8763180375099182,
0.7513204216957092,
-0.9181004762649536,
-0.3660239577293396,
-0.03801858797669411,
-0.5257434844970703,
-0.7345920205116272,
0.16645967960357666,
0.20594355463981628,
0.3936815857887268,
-0.22232656180858612,
0.3749619424343109,
0.7344310283660889,
0.12825791537761688,
0.5882031917572021,
0.6320365071296692,
-0.11218775808811188,
-0.363252192735672,
1.0468759536743164,
0.06883644312620163,
-0.003969389945268631,
0.5873700380325317,
0.3398949205875397,
-0.12104085087776184,
-0.6965255737304688,
-0.4380887746810913,
0.08381599932909012,
-0.8861453533172607,
-0.6747165322303772,
-0.16380606591701508,
-0.11182823777198792,
-0.021659990772604942,
-0.4200279414653778,
-0.514430582523346,
-0.8350290656089783,
-0.35024571418762207,
0.23678629100322723,
0.7090615034103394,
0.4130496680736542,
-0.19823159277439117,
0.7159295082092285,
-0.7056108713150024,
0.6092458367347717,
0.5016584396362305,
0.680880069732666,
0.022540409117937088,
-0.6856281757354736,
-0.5270443558692932,
0.07138568162918091,
-0.15995244681835175,
-0.5366547107696533,
0.14216040074825287,
0.7867712378501892,
0.5019453763961792,
0.430827796459198,
0.22876426577568054,
0.9322738647460938,
-0.34738925099372864,
0.40286126732826233,
0.03454602137207985,
-1.0166460275650024,
0.37827032804489136,
-0.44245395064353943,
0.31234678626060486,
0.9098737835884094,
0.0858205184340477,
-0.14317987859249115,
-0.05149481073021889,
-0.32590824365615845,
-0.6059600710868835,
0.8906517028808594,
0.07081780582666397,
0.15771441161632538,
0.6122524738311768,
0.4380626380443573,
0.26481860876083374,
0.19203120470046997,
-0.6583104729652405,
-0.30613017082214355,
-0.2996875047683716,
-0.23121760785579681,
0.07208678126335144,
0.047242194414138794,
-0.3584822714328766,
-0.6233524680137634,
0.6559417247772217,
-0.5502027869224548,
0.5376570224761963,
-0.1967722326517105,
-0.23544761538505554,
-0.5120246410369873,
0.18428374826908112,
0.616220235824585,
0.36452716588974,
-0.38326382637023926,
0.1938527673482895,
0.397469162940979,
-0.5496254563331604,
0.09671640396118164,
0.5133447051048279,
-0.013958483003079891,
-0.34478306770324707,
0.23798474669456482,
0.7094154953956604,
0.6874591708183289,
-0.4264143109321594,
0.1608513593673706,
-0.060887280851602554,
-0.30433398485183716,
-0.11192476004362106,
0.42589929699897766,
-0.05755479261279106,
0.4901079535484314,
0.5312450528144836,
0.4251440167427063,
0.10852731764316559,
-0.10033544152975082,
-0.017360487952828407,
0.2906014323234558,
-0.2673358619213104,
-0.25572165846824646,
0.4913443624973297,
0.10073748975992203,
0.10406026989221573,
0.3243473470211029,
0.009655285626649857,
-0.06850352883338928,
0.37093082070350647,
0.45127224922180176,
0.6921072006225586,
-0.0034526807721704245,
0.08014501631259918,
0.1942661553621292,
0.25554394721984863,
-0.10861203074455261,
0.45349228382110596,
-0.38213303685188293,
-0.5903352499008179,
-0.22684280574321747,
-0.9647617340087891,
-0.2539135217666626,
0.0017999450210481882,
-0.8052638173103333,
0.29308396577835083,
-0.754080593585968,
0.0021538985893130302,
0.08421821892261505,
0.10128887742757797,
-0.5638098120689392,
0.1028779149055481,
0.09621516615152359,
1.1240895986557007,
-0.7022437453269958,
1.1541588306427002,
0.4403430223464966,
-0.07272553443908691,
-0.627417802810669,
-0.0813620463013649,
-0.3071891665458679,
-0.6802515387535095,
0.6446998119354248,
-0.3654400706291199,
-0.3943679928779602,
0.3326692283153534,
-0.5569114685058594,
-1.1425776481628418,
1.2599308490753174,
1.1417889595031738,
-0.5297514796257019,
0.17795629799365997,
0.19640620052814484,
0.6162834167480469,
0.10689546167850494,
-0.258043110370636,
0.6068681478500366,
0.7447509765625,
0.12024034559726715,
-0.8273959159851074,
0.0008767109247855842,
-0.15568946301937103,
0.015471676364541054,
0.4633606970310211,
-0.5308348536491394,
0.8534241914749146,
0.16060346364974976,
-0.1728796511888504,
0.13785743713378906,
0.6814113855361938,
-0.009836304001510143,
-0.12631455063819885,
0.6442292928695679,
0.5078334212303162,
0.8766149878501892,
-0.22015242278575897,
0.8277656435966492,
-0.036443062126636505,
0.5255582332611084,
0.969014048576355,
-0.10293663293123245,
1.0896910429000854,
0.4909778833389282,
-0.14260593056678772,
0.45007988810539246,
0.697969913482666,
-0.1291588693857193,
0.7947162985801697,
0.02613578923046589,
0.060859378427267075,
-0.3658844530582428,
0.2880476117134094,
-0.5178335905075073,
0.6428530812263489,
0.28702905774116516,
0.015474580228328705,
-0.5043584108352661,
0.14926929771900177,
-0.2978677749633789,
-0.014523882418870926,
-0.6016521453857422,
0.5878722071647644,
0.19253534078598022,
-0.35950788855552673,
1.1695623397827148,
0.22157421708106995,
0.4650976359844208,
-0.858660876750946,
-0.24359598755836487,
-0.2635355591773987,
0.2668676972389221,
-0.22526110708713531,
-0.2999630272388458,
0.31360742449760437,
-0.20959308743476868,
-0.2989466190338135,
-0.3000073730945587,
0.5927426815032959,
-0.3703165650367737,
-0.39392217993736267,
0.21332618594169617,
0.29993781447410583,
-0.30856627225875854,
-0.22055400907993317,
-0.5234440565109253,
0.15123715996742249,
-0.30497801303863525,
-0.25028708577156067,
0.5009664297103882,
-0.003613009350374341,
-0.07546883821487427,
0.47084078192710876,
0.574830949306488,
-0.08081461489200592,
-0.18993589282035828,
-0.12133315205574036,
0.9571388363838196,
-0.5951264500617981,
-0.5668954849243164,
-0.47169217467308044,
0.12433739006519318,
0.2753995358943939,
-0.32538503408432007,
0.35935887694358826,
0.3804466128349304,
0.48900943994522095,
-0.20628690719604492,
0.31519412994384766,
0.03322970122098923,
0.26894643902778625,
-0.8493656516075134,
0.9149653911590576,
-0.6576216816902161,
0.28927403688430786,
-0.4024617373943329,
-0.975055992603302,
-0.31124991178512573,
0.6696147322654724,
-0.07609253376722336,
0.20632527768611908,
0.5655162334442139,
0.6307970285415649,
-0.4423040747642517,
0.16085225343704224,
0.4016963839530945,
0.15129661560058594,
-0.008962875232100487,
0.6655688881874084,
0.5767837762832642,
-0.6040596961975098,
0.4411027729511261,
-0.441996693611145,
-0.0018852615030482411,
-0.20748935639858246,
-0.8971331715583801,
-0.7224720120429993,
-0.6560986042022705,
-0.31310179829597473,
0.002550652017816901,
-0.12545599043369293,
0.8375285863876343,
1.1323591470718384,
-0.8372142314910889,
-0.0854930654168129,
0.1972026824951172,
0.050729263573884964,
-0.5888124704360962,
-0.15176555514335632,
0.46392136812210083,
0.19581004977226257,
-0.6242271065711975,
0.6080185174942017,
0.11370375752449036,
0.11410775780677795,
-0.1814386397600174,
-0.20982441306114197,
0.011559965088963509,
0.1781730055809021,
0.6354247331619263,
0.43046313524246216,
-0.37649956345558167,
-0.5839267373085022,
-0.1942877471446991,
0.02691677212715149,
0.21033625304698944,
0.6466064453125,
-1.0209134817123413,
-0.09492043405771255,
0.3548552989959717,
0.7009883522987366,
0.9502623677253723,
-0.10715977847576141,
0.43272864818573,
-1.0342613458633423,
-0.06216597184538841,
0.05959601327776909,
0.34891656041145325,
0.18749657273292542,
-0.42045173048973083,
0.604783296585083,
0.10265514254570007,
-0.16812552511692047,
-0.745940089225769,
0.029798762872815132,
-1.548300862312317,
-0.1505480706691742,
0.7201669812202454,
0.28158700466156006,
-0.1428980827331543,
0.05146066099405289,
-0.2458665519952774,
-0.04174260422587395,
-0.4519486129283905,
0.7773542404174805,
0.21239866316318512,
-0.27009421586990356,
-0.32825496792793274,
-0.2837415337562561,
0.6623632907867432,
0.2031126171350479,
-0.9206230044364929,
0.03131160885095596,
0.2745819091796875,
0.11997301876544952,
0.03676649183034897,
0.5472679734230042,
0.15442441403865814,
0.5904853343963623,
-0.2922479212284088,
-0.12297330796718597,
-0.2951352000236511,
-0.2140982300043106,
-0.7983546853065491,
0.2933855950832367,
0.23368313908576965,
-0.012647208757698536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03000v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03000v1
|
MedAdapter: Efficient Test-Time Adaptation of Large Language Models towards Medical Reasoning
| 2024-05-05T17:06:31 | 2024-05-05T17:06:31 |
Wenqi Shi, Ran Xu, Yuchen Zhuang, Yue Yu, Hang Wu, Carl Yang, May D. Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite their improved capabilities in generation and reasoning, adapting
large language models (LLMs) to the biomedical domain remains challenging due
to their immense size and corporate privacy. In this work, we propose
MedAdapter, a unified post-hoc adapter for test-time adaptation of LLMs towards
biomedical applications. Instead of fine-tuning the entire LLM, MedAdapter
effectively adapts the original model by fine-tuning only a small BERT-sized
adapter to rank candidate solutions generated by LLMs. Experiments demonstrate
that MedAdapter effectively adapts both white-box and black-box LLMs in
biomedical reasoning, achieving average performance improvements of 25.48% and
11.31%, respectively, without requiring extensive computational resources or
sharing data with third parties. MedAdapter also yields superior performance
when combined with train-time adaptation, highlighting a flexible and
complementary solution to existing adaptation methods. Faced with the
challenges of balancing model performance, computational resources, and data
privacy, MedAdapter provides an efficient, privacy-preserving, cost-effective,
and transparent solution for adapting LLMs to the biomedical domain.
|
[
-0.09875024855136871,
-0.4553718864917755,
0.720661997795105,
0.14228391647338867,
-0.5392862558364868,
-0.010191221721470356,
-0.1398213505744934,
-0.44058388471603394,
-0.09635908901691437,
0.3211873471736908,
-0.44112664461135864,
-0.2809327244758606,
-0.4731626510620117,
-0.03293875977396965,
0.27923280000686646,
1.0463268756866455,
-0.2669219374656677,
0.16078442335128784,
-0.12908026576042175,
-0.47999414801597595,
-0.39074644446372986,
-0.3435797393321991,
-0.5882019996643066,
-0.6037722229957581,
0.3436143398284912,
0.04872944951057434,
0.6089531183242798,
0.4611780643463135,
0.654235303401947,
0.24634593725204468,
0.22534798085689545,
0.04154905676841736,
-0.38431933522224426,
0.137959823012352,
-0.8698194622993469,
-0.2958962321281433,
-0.7486679553985596,
-0.25741204619407654,
0.536162257194519,
0.6912871599197388,
-0.1540745049715042,
0.3591258227825165,
-0.16199064254760742,
0.5358126163482666,
-0.5446733832359314,
0.08093200623989105,
-0.7212352156639099,
-0.21601393818855286,
0.06431098282337189,
-0.5870419144630432,
-0.47206544876098633,
-0.4413502812385559,
-0.04721343144774437,
-0.8152226805686951,
-0.04836920276284218,
0.13454948365688324,
0.5020612478256226,
0.544535219669342,
-0.30288201570510864,
0.2884720265865326,
-0.7316630482673645,
0.6969097852706909,
-0.6711838841438293,
0.4486054480075836,
0.06909601390361786,
0.6531184315681458,
-0.5884946584701538,
-0.7131479382514954,
-0.37038758397102356,
0.06133820861577988,
0.2621297836303711,
0.24395638704299927,
-0.26205578446388245,
0.1648133248090744,
0.05252571776509285,
0.14826002717018127,
-0.8125988245010376,
0.26526492834091187,
-0.1792607605457306,
-0.2542397081851959,
0.611735999584198,
0.026919720694422722,
0.2469482719898224,
0.11889476329088211,
-0.03929589316248894,
-0.10067886114120483,
-0.6076854467391968,
-0.17632783949375153,
-0.35909754037857056,
0.017704924568533897,
-0.09445706754922867,
0.5022450089454651,
0.0008259752066805959,
0.7510630488395691,
-0.004499676637351513,
-0.1864735633134842,
0.22476458549499512,
-0.14435476064682007,
-0.3822897672653198,
0.13844555616378784,
0.563676655292511,
0.4994492828845978,
0.16803516447544098,
0.04314832016825676,
0.13591033220291138,
0.30383408069610596,
0.2040725201368332,
-1.1899627447128296,
-0.48313456773757935,
0.42979657649993896,
-0.6797323822975159,
-0.204164519906044,
-0.5710600018501282,
-0.7513738870620728,
-0.8033972978591919,
-0.050466299057006836,
0.4729737639427185,
-0.44748690724372864,
-0.16057027876377106,
0.620734453201294,
-0.12840016186237335,
0.3926764130592346,
0.5144184827804565,
-0.4903300106525421,
0.41427502036094666,
0.6615850925445557,
0.8411242365837097,
-0.2191893607378006,
-0.13153603672981262,
-0.7682830095291138,
0.34287816286087036,
-0.3077777028083801,
0.9353494048118591,
-0.36668428778648376,
-0.4514180123806,
-0.46693503856658936,
0.4066733717918396,
-0.29784297943115234,
-0.3614239990711212,
0.4466570317745209,
-0.5498743653297424,
0.2539818584918976,
0.15285992622375488,
-0.5656483173370361,
0.10753855854272842,
0.16066846251487732,
-0.2559412717819214,
0.6492761373519897,
0.23467345535755157,
-0.7608407139778137,
0.48562002182006836,
-1.159932017326355,
-0.5978793501853943,
0.3705179989337921,
-0.16892392933368683,
-0.5030582547187805,
0.14940544962882996,
0.29706358909606934,
0.4660383462905884,
-0.32809650897979736,
0.19554047286510468,
-0.5497182607650757,
-0.4655851125717163,
0.39652296900749207,
-0.011154010891914368,
0.8230698108673096,
0.17075057327747345,
-0.2522416412830353,
0.3880001902580261,
-0.9356001615524292,
0.055346883833408356,
0.28508004546165466,
-0.40990644693374634,
-0.5221124887466431,
0.24047072231769562,
0.14472654461860657,
0.30287569761276245,
-0.12959323823451996,
-0.7738184332847595,
0.2491540014743805,
-0.5552523136138916,
0.5752344727516174,
0.9283744692802429,
-0.07025177031755447,
0.41361403465270996,
-0.5153577327728271,
0.5315786004066467,
-0.23192614316940308,
0.1952277421951294,
0.22518593072891235,
-0.40981778502464294,
-0.30447325110435486,
-0.6254836916923523,
0.3599899113178253,
0.573287844657898,
-0.6792898178100586,
0.4571245014667511,
-0.6753036379814148,
-0.4880824089050293,
-0.9403877854347229,
-0.22078320384025574,
0.07919693738222122,
0.50486159324646,
0.4673263728618622,
-0.0982210710644722,
-0.515216588973999,
-0.6655459403991699,
-0.4276692569255829,
-0.258772075176239,
-0.5323579907417297,
0.472432941198349,
0.5700920224189758,
-0.6667689681053162,
0.42230162024497986,
-0.3952513337135315,
-0.08759766817092896,
-0.16527506709098816,
-0.31275784969329834,
0.45883944630622864,
0.40935832262039185,
0.642302393913269,
-0.43939048051834106,
-0.06854575872421265,
0.35909149050712585,
-0.6513506770133972,
-0.21080131828784943,
-0.10806287825107574,
-0.2835894227027893,
0.20858894288539886,
0.4961108863353729,
-0.28252458572387695,
0.27361688017845154,
1.1232528686523438,
-0.6094260215759277,
0.5778353214263916,
-0.6314650774002075,
0.10951302945613861,
-1.329399824142456,
0.23893913626670837,
-0.3564293384552002,
-0.522259533405304,
-0.37783217430114746,
-0.05756840482354164,
0.10795339196920395,
-0.14484231173992157,
-0.377711683511734,
1.0082186460494995,
-0.16678057610988617,
0.10517063736915588,
-0.44599294662475586,
-0.06959931552410126,
0.08090848475694656,
-0.019479338079690933,
-0.10652928054332733,
0.7133160829544067,
0.6429667472839355,
-0.668014407157898,
0.2037988007068634,
0.43990203738212585,
-0.2707257866859436,
0.7342657446861267,
-0.8795447945594788,
0.06912042945623398,
-0.14138466119766235,
0.5278552174568176,
-0.7972842454910278,
-0.46425187587738037,
0.09070610255002975,
-0.18252819776535034,
0.027461349964141846,
-0.3475448191165924,
-0.24341656267642975,
-0.4372097849845886,
-0.4295167624950409,
0.6211317181587219,
0.7047202587127686,
-0.7710636854171753,
0.8691972494125366,
0.43019071221351624,
-0.3273695111274719,
-0.15705226361751556,
-0.7005801796913147,
-0.1955471634864807,
0.036089181900024414,
-0.4057193994522095,
0.38123035430908203,
-0.46320486068725586,
-0.06124294176697731,
-0.21026460826396942,
-0.2997905910015106,
-0.009613816626369953,
0.1938350647687912,
0.4644046127796173,
0.4985522925853729,
-0.3179156184196472,
0.27015891671180725,
0.4373754560947418,
-0.26916176080703735,
-0.047037046402692795,
-0.42092186212539673,
0.2780296206474304,
0.15313024818897247,
-0.33522385358810425,
-0.3889123499393463,
0.1732003092765808,
1.007948637008667,
-0.06896687299013138,
0.8586185574531555,
0.27244430780410767,
-0.3564733862876892,
-0.3085428476333618,
-0.3388180136680603,
-0.22179169952869415,
-0.49073526263237,
0.6460224390029907,
-0.41675132513046265,
-0.8687463998794556,
0.27826860547065735,
-0.49861347675323486,
0.12414777278900146,
0.18281766772270203,
0.7816999554634094,
-0.07056296616792679,
0.9098166227340698,
0.4705055058002472,
-0.14806529879570007,
0.4276489317417145,
0.41291382908821106,
0.11157124489545822,
-0.8553260564804077,
0.06795602291822433,
-0.2457522749900818,
-0.3849676251411438,
-0.6079581379890442,
-0.5873098969459534,
0.4680754244327545,
-0.49137791991233826,
-0.4142915606498718,
-0.07680362462997437,
-0.566626787185669,
0.40712878108024597,
0.1045355498790741,
0.3024679720401764,
0.2838018536567688,
-0.10522545874118805,
-0.03713717684149742,
0.10139986872673035,
-0.6560200452804565,
-0.23468832671642303,
1.2002307176589966,
0.27852797508239746,
0.8630119562149048,
-0.009328960441052914,
0.3007841408252716,
-0.08553288877010345,
0.6249935626983643,
-0.7945087552070618,
0.36658719182014465,
-0.21515993773937225,
-0.6738463640213013,
-0.07628319412469864,
-0.5011810660362244,
-1.1130359172821045,
0.31716156005859375,
-0.22479920089244843,
-0.5970292687416077,
0.24052326381206512,
0.21939492225646973,
-0.3569258153438568,
0.4023876190185547,
-0.517577588558197,
1.0483899116516113,
-0.09755469113588333,
-0.28917378187179565,
-0.06991754472255707,
-0.649848222732544,
0.10490451008081436,
-0.49299103021621704,
0.6004348397254944,
-0.3303832709789276,
0.029385223984718323,
0.8468915820121765,
-0.300045371055603,
0.5477811694145203,
-0.25235381722450256,
0.2124062478542328,
-0.22730082273483276,
0.3268008828163147,
0.3974270224571228,
0.07864398509263992,
-0.2505740523338318,
0.022035865113139153,
0.41456374526023865,
-0.7509555220603943,
-0.3280673027038574,
0.7007868885993958,
-0.6639713644981384,
-0.33269205689430237,
-0.42137783765792847,
-1.1377792358398438,
-0.36802172660827637,
0.5231503844261169,
0.0846969410777092,
0.35524308681488037,
-0.3841526508331299,
0.1724705547094345,
0.5218707919120789,
-0.532203197479248,
0.21304523944854736,
0.7439067959785461,
-0.44600629806518555,
-0.26955586671829224,
0.6223971843719482,
-0.34468182921409607,
0.29320693016052246,
0.3041602373123169,
0.37325718998908997,
-0.2621454894542694,
-0.8132013082504272,
-0.35985898971557617,
0.6347985863685608,
-0.38342034816741943,
-0.21875110268592834,
-0.5564315915107727,
-0.0378403440117836,
-0.2506513297557831,
-0.4284229278564453,
-0.49317821860313416,
-0.5126916170120239,
-0.016646191477775574,
0.00817234069108963,
0.7170036435127258,
0.2443428486585617,
0.08484594523906708,
0.39054086804389954,
-0.7290040850639343,
0.5935797095298767,
0.209231898188591,
0.7147232890129089,
-0.722620964050293,
-0.8706303834915161,
0.06010168790817261,
-0.2494753897190094,
0.08064208179712296,
-0.5150238871574402,
-0.04513324424624443,
0.3500095009803772,
0.38854554295539856,
0.10179906338453293,
0.03485989570617676,
0.6098704934120178,
-0.818915843963623,
0.32538655400276184,
0.002048603491857648,
-0.6885022521018982,
0.6255555748939514,
-0.3770846724510193,
0.40226632356643677,
0.6840230822563171,
0.11654950678348541,
-0.2613259553909302,
-0.15243113040924072,
-0.2273760288953781,
-0.41184002161026,
0.3761586844921112,
-0.13793015480041504,
-0.09750382602214813,
0.4046616554260254,
0.4917370676994324,
0.21455298364162445,
-0.19140611588954926,
-0.39289167523384094,
-0.11510540544986725,
-0.1175178661942482,
-0.4942733943462372,
-0.28126615285873413,
-0.0017429464496672153,
-0.30857837200164795,
-0.6009811758995056,
0.49910062551498413,
-0.42904558777809143,
0.18134310841560364,
0.22416603565216064,
-0.23680537939071655,
-0.18066878616809845,
0.6191303730010986,
0.3577628433704376,
0.7710447907447815,
-0.4421011507511139,
0.14924916625022888,
0.35018107295036316,
-0.6349431276321411,
0.31044813990592957,
0.5946516990661621,
0.1587240993976593,
0.011555864475667477,
0.34019190073013306,
0.4637715518474579,
0.29558220505714417,
-0.8439439535140991,
0.6574878692626953,
-0.21712762117385864,
-0.34505894780158997,
0.24196237325668335,
0.12045992165803909,
0.06355255097150803,
0.32186558842658997,
-0.12520964443683624,
0.29365068674087524,
0.09022046625614166,
-0.4062559902667999,
0.248747780919075,
0.16939975321292877,
-0.20714214444160461,
-0.4272913336753845,
1.0981876850128174,
0.038260314613580704,
-0.15031452476978302,
0.09167228639125824,
0.1998601108789444,
-0.14872483909130096,
0.10097715258598328,
0.8885324597358704,
0.5416457653045654,
-0.9006664156913757,
0.026376325637102127,
0.043709926307201385,
0.15508005023002625,
0.007907821796834469,
0.6534286141395569,
0.3828867971897125,
-0.6758341789245605,
-0.7887150049209595,
-0.690014123916626,
-0.44752877950668335,
0.03051094524562359,
-0.4976826608181,
0.06202450767159462,
-0.5839522480964661,
-0.10024961084127426,
0.24310851097106934,
-0.3832775056362152,
-0.6767393946647644,
0.11393105238676071,
0.03323464095592499,
1.0867644548416138,
-0.7700827717781067,
0.9826632738113403,
1.0559749603271484,
0.21368151903152466,
-0.428535133600235,
-0.396694540977478,
-0.031830865889787674,
-0.8777669072151184,
-0.04448035731911659,
-0.24294373393058777,
-0.0858188197016716,
-0.012302384711802006,
-0.24898622930049896,
-0.44248148798942566,
1.072613000869751,
0.5931872725486755,
-0.7003796100616455,
0.1589074283838272,
-0.12574169039726257,
0.5972765684127808,
-0.15903697907924652,
-0.009779001586139202,
0.8393259644508362,
0.3050869107246399,
-0.037390876561403275,
-1.0312656164169312,
0.48429521918296814,
-0.3011828660964966,
-0.08526472002267838,
0.15927258133888245,
-0.24855771660804749,
0.403328537940979,
-0.2562827467918396,
0.2845310866832733,
-0.027623580768704414,
0.1319480687379837,
0.8103137016296387,
0.3185693919658661,
0.45941534638404846,
0.1746823638677597,
0.9977294206619263,
0.17205148935317993,
1.371308445930481,
-0.11514962464570999,
0.14851804077625275,
1.0586943626403809,
-0.6489380598068237,
0.6724411249160767,
0.5562126636505127,
-0.25354525446891785,
0.5759684443473816,
0.3063046634197235,
0.17293916642665863,
0.5397036075592041,
0.28835615515708923,
-0.22204862534999847,
-0.21317455172538757,
-0.03409164771437645,
-0.6795152425765991,
0.27913904190063477,
0.345734179019928,
-0.3346633017063141,
-0.13163353502750397,
0.11966986954212189,
0.08789655566215515,
-0.21926310658454895,
-0.4037551283836365,
0.7271677851676941,
0.21397261321544647,
-0.2083853781223297,
0.5976212620735168,
-0.25667619705200195,
0.38434043526649475,
-0.4862748384475708,
0.07236885279417038,
0.15456025302410126,
0.7882068157196045,
-0.12931987643241882,
-0.4567854702472687,
0.17154589295387268,
-0.2065383791923523,
-0.20592579245567322,
-0.021198011934757233,
0.9718217253684998,
-0.07209017127752304,
-0.6506343483924866,
0.5300783514976501,
0.45691147446632385,
0.20113448798656464,
-0.1491290032863617,
-0.7431813478469849,
0.2746623456478119,
-0.2940293848514557,
-0.22886206209659576,
0.4116458296775818,
0.4592646658420563,
0.044002633541822433,
0.6227585673332214,
0.7701601386070251,
0.33946171402931213,
-0.049054913222789764,
0.2725595235824585,
1.1068618297576904,
-0.6283642053604126,
-0.48526662588119507,
-0.7998865842819214,
0.3891761004924774,
0.034293074160814285,
-0.12225745618343353,
0.3804570734500885,
0.5030615925788879,
0.4867376685142517,
-0.15476112067699432,
0.9995111227035522,
0.3210736811161041,
0.6436415314674377,
-0.29312220215797424,
0.9450055360794067,
-0.5623987317085266,
0.046889882534742355,
-0.2665885090827942,
-0.5103306770324707,
-0.832165002822876,
0.6532496809959412,
-0.4926927387714386,
-0.20998458564281464,
0.8806100487709045,
0.6570560336112976,
-0.37122049927711487,
-0.19032390415668488,
0.29438677430152893,
0.5582711100578308,
0.5707755088806152,
0.8172034025192261,
0.5679095983505249,
-0.5067957639694214,
0.42202046513557434,
0.18107900023460388,
-0.7540494799613953,
-0.4455609917640686,
-0.9555933475494385,
-1.0713919401168823,
-0.04361119866371155,
-0.45493942499160767,
-0.44556036591529846,
0.2162240594625473,
1.0231897830963135,
0.8774545788764954,
-1.0867825746536255,
0.07301793247461319,
0.037636321038007736,
-0.0247814804315567,
-0.2205977588891983,
-0.15905414521694183,
0.5637287497520447,
0.052774619311094284,
-0.25893884897232056,
0.6208632588386536,
0.4961804747581482,
-0.0945451408624649,
0.48994338512420654,
-0.11551649123430252,
0.06421566754579544,
0.32674911618232727,
0.7481850981712341,
0.305789053440094,
-0.4390329122543335,
-0.3803705871105194,
-0.1634000986814499,
-0.0010241535492241383,
0.11990499496459961,
0.8252304196357727,
-0.706467866897583,
0.7075643539428711,
0.18077298998832703,
1.00070321559906,
0.45518550276756287,
-0.12125885486602783,
0.4848870038986206,
-0.2705869972705841,
0.4118216335773468,
0.23787547647953033,
0.5498409271240234,
0.15115498006343842,
-0.16188570857048035,
0.3322143852710724,
0.13796783983707428,
-0.9052917957305908,
-1.0376882553100586,
0.11006858199834824,
-1.1975685358047485,
-0.4810860753059387,
1.0613423585891724,
0.06964655220508575,
-0.5378655195236206,
-0.3549426198005676,
-0.3936566114425659,
0.42926502227783203,
-0.12172657996416092,
0.7805827856063843,
0.198614701628685,
-0.1420411914587021,
0.05287671834230423,
-0.680393397808075,
0.3967873454093933,
0.3745926022529602,
-1.1895802021026611,
0.011453523300588131,
0.2956937551498413,
0.7605125308036804,
-0.36091092228889465,
0.9697549343109131,
-0.40055957436561584,
0.526238203048706,
-0.2935471832752228,
0.14192382991313934,
-0.057034704834222794,
-0.06129053235054016,
-0.5093246102333069,
-0.1638922393321991,
0.13776502013206482,
-0.4764319956302643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06680v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06680v1
|
Exploring the Compositional Deficiency of Large Language Models in Mathematical Reasoning
| 2024-05-05T16:35:30 | 2024-05-05T16:35:30 |
Jun Zhao, Jingqi Tong, Yurong Mou, Ming Zhang, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Human cognition exhibits systematic compositionality, the algebraic ability
to generate infinite novel combinations from finite learned components, which
is the key to understanding and reasoning about complex logic. In this work, we
investigate the compositionality of large language models (LLMs) in
mathematical reasoning. Specifically, we construct a new dataset
\textsc{MathTrap}\footnotemark[3] by introducing carefully designed logical
traps into the problem descriptions of MATH and GSM8k. Since problems with
logical flaws are quite rare in the real world, these represent ``unseen''
cases to LLMs. Solving these requires the models to systematically compose (1)
the mathematical knowledge involved in the original problems with (2) knowledge
related to the introduced traps. Our experiments show that while LLMs possess
both components of requisite knowledge, they do not \textbf{spontaneously}
combine them to handle these novel cases. We explore several methods to
mitigate this deficiency, such as natural language prompts, few-shot
demonstrations, and fine-tuning. We find that LLMs' performance can be
\textbf{passively} improved through the above external intervention. Overall,
systematic compositionality remains an open challenge for large language
models.
|
[
-0.24289068579673767,
-0.6614670753479004,
0.903071403503418,
0.25139302015304565,
-0.19742295145988464,
0.30499061942100525,
-0.38611122965812683,
-0.3277587592601776,
-0.030326293781399727,
0.5639640092849731,
-0.6563465595245361,
-0.48982182145118713,
-0.47293680906295776,
0.09571034461259842,
-0.16931232810020447,
0.7947940826416016,
-0.34246671199798584,
0.09156404435634613,
-0.4926222562789917,
-0.04623565077781677,
-0.6631106734275818,
-0.45134371519088745,
-0.2582383453845978,
-0.4213727116584778,
0.38547492027282715,
0.16146032512187958,
0.48179811239242554,
0.44022902846336365,
0.43147751688957214,
0.30556556582450867,
0.03514419496059418,
0.3027878999710083,
-0.5275700688362122,
0.2053627222776413,
-0.16084755957126617,
-0.9111012816429138,
-0.1762305051088333,
-0.24314017593860626,
0.7491711974143982,
1.0304505825042725,
-0.15795639157295227,
-0.18084661662578583,
-0.01563430018723011,
0.5980879068374634,
-0.7547898292541504,
0.4334012567996979,
-0.728875458240509,
0.13070042431354523,
-0.2830648720264435,
0.2460288256406784,
-0.5269047617912292,
-0.018823888152837753,
0.010721469298005104,
-0.6948007345199585,
0.04239588603377342,
-0.31397199630737305,
0.4015340507030487,
0.3119589686393738,
-0.40350234508514404,
-0.43202826380729675,
-0.9421523213386536,
0.9751551151275635,
-0.7053415179252625,
0.10291629284620285,
0.3207017183303833,
0.3317199945449829,
-0.33650436997413635,
-0.2789183259010315,
-0.4548962712287903,
-0.24520307779312134,
-0.05268692970275879,
0.12292984873056412,
-0.12692326307296753,
-0.09267482161521912,
0.4851941764354706,
0.15487322211265564,
-0.6563839912414551,
-0.11740272492170334,
-0.28436318039894104,
-0.3316301107406616,
0.7173318266868591,
0.4975713789463043,
0.4763227105140686,
-0.0009306430583819747,
-0.013325377367436886,
0.10157672315835953,
-0.9485849738121033,
-0.12663473188877106,
0.38951244950294495,
0.12203093618154526,
-0.1549721211194992,
0.7756443023681641,
0.09203116595745087,
0.7890370488166809,
-0.40702930092811584,
-0.23880897462368011,
-0.22290511429309845,
-0.2643919289112091,
-0.11095104366540909,
-0.10148622840642929,
0.4614093601703644,
-0.2560984492301941,
0.6588512063026428,
-0.050471168011426926,
-0.47667333483695984,
0.5557044744491577,
-0.07438237965106964,
-0.528873860836029,
-0.43857327103614807,
-0.0652148500084877,
-0.025388747453689575,
0.020615465939044952,
0.09116392582654953,
-0.16293571889400482,
-0.38172781467437744,
-0.5242958664894104,
0.47506141662597656,
-0.29564225673675537,
-0.15260650217533112,
0.5502224564552307,
-0.038981322199106216,
-0.04736678674817085,
0.2120509147644043,
-0.9622106552124023,
0.3203502893447876,
0.9309015870094299,
0.5356329083442688,
0.06987598538398743,
-0.1774776726961136,
-0.3608814775943756,
0.2496596723794937,
-0.5326712727546692,
0.783697247505188,
-0.7006807923316956,
-0.34932011365890503,
0.02795771136879921,
-0.3036012351512909,
-0.2711222171783447,
-0.8133713006973267,
0.5665450692176819,
-0.3786177933216095,
0.21844351291656494,
-0.32542675733566284,
-0.550268292427063,
-0.24423688650131226,
0.13258697092533112,
-0.6846550703048706,
0.6062753200531006,
0.17257152497768402,
-0.47668543457984924,
-0.03774353116750717,
-0.3781937062740326,
-0.5947750806808472,
0.01367434486746788,
-0.4033748209476471,
-0.19725921750068665,
0.564660370349884,
0.15454337000846863,
0.22259356081485748,
-0.3454282879829407,
0.29148367047309875,
-0.435416042804718,
-0.5220631957054138,
0.6907140016555786,
-0.29921817779541016,
0.6999773383140564,
0.025546861812472343,
-0.1759059876203537,
-0.01903187669813633,
-0.6827690601348877,
-0.22594822943210602,
0.33910298347473145,
-0.1570429652929306,
-0.5195980072021484,
0.027489127591252327,
-0.3701963424682617,
0.1791033148765564,
0.11022492498159409,
-0.18524925410747528,
0.3387712836265564,
-0.5311580896377563,
0.544788122177124,
0.8770832419395447,
-0.20115503668785095,
0.550172746181488,
-0.44038042426109314,
0.6082659363746643,
0.12217934429645538,
-0.08299768716096878,
-0.4189020097255707,
-0.4721130430698395,
-0.8906137943267822,
-0.4490126371383667,
0.1662440448999405,
0.49785080552101135,
-0.5989210605621338,
0.3806151747703552,
-0.23790979385375977,
-0.12991459667682648,
-0.13830482959747314,
0.3366285562515259,
0.34779995679855347,
0.4046933948993683,
-0.06092144548892975,
0.01622876711189747,
-0.4475072920322418,
-0.9712437391281128,
-0.3236478567123413,
0.28412768244743347,
-0.21069155633449554,
0.18916171789169312,
0.5715991854667664,
-0.23722656071186066,
0.645786464214325,
-0.7908738851547241,
-0.3044377565383911,
-0.2088831216096878,
0.0001762985048117116,
0.28542041778564453,
0.25691699981689453,
0.3607345223426819,
-0.38692137598991394,
-0.37136733531951904,
-0.2693013846874237,
-0.9921668171882629,
-0.11765708029270172,
-0.07669151574373245,
-0.23709353804588318,
0.19451653957366943,
0.2227296531200409,
-0.8560498952865601,
0.30643945932388306,
0.4447859525680542,
-0.29093217849731445,
0.6183484196662903,
0.039965175092220306,
-0.4446588158607483,
-0.8744411468505859,
-0.17158743739128113,
0.02133651077747345,
0.11288852244615555,
-0.37009477615356445,
0.13122498989105225,
-0.12249377369880676,
-0.2486782670021057,
-0.02896755374968052,
0.5638518929481506,
-0.7414901256561279,
-0.016779744997620583,
-0.29652297496795654,
0.20006202161312103,
0.0660509541630745,
0.43724003434181213,
-0.09585772454738617,
0.4981527030467987,
0.6553465723991394,
-0.5992754697799683,
0.3531094193458557,
0.06480914354324341,
-0.32793882489204407,
0.5039079785346985,
-0.6903369426727295,
-0.054362282156944275,
-0.24523335695266724,
0.5138058066368103,
-0.9374862313270569,
-0.4514043629169464,
0.20300033688545227,
-0.30820026993751526,
0.16426301002502441,
-0.18895375728607178,
-0.552434504032135,
-0.3579654395580292,
-0.20890510082244873,
0.6730169057846069,
0.5184921026229858,
-0.16214987635612488,
0.790448009967804,
0.14857512712478638,
-0.20968292653560638,
-0.4133750796318054,
-0.7485852241516113,
0.023830408230423927,
-0.12279514223337173,
-0.9911097884178162,
0.028859077021479607,
-0.20112262666225433,
-0.5291887521743774,
0.11068330705165863,
-0.25359824299812317,
0.10967819392681122,
0.18433654308319092,
0.08743313699960709,
0.43630972504615784,
-0.37164875864982605,
0.2956240475177765,
0.018027126789093018,
-0.2666560709476471,
0.45825034379959106,
-0.45210960507392883,
0.5112050175666809,
0.01574009470641613,
-0.7781938910484314,
-0.19958089292049408,
0.5540400147438049,
0.5401330590248108,
-0.3102407455444336,
0.6315726041793823,
0.3041699230670929,
-0.6595735549926758,
-0.619663655757904,
-0.25928038358688354,
-0.48332104086875916,
-0.4200122058391571,
0.1868150532245636,
-0.45568162202835083,
-0.9638515710830688,
0.8735398650169373,
0.18679770827293396,
-0.12211986631155014,
0.4456149637699127,
0.4639899432659149,
0.07625002413988113,
1.2227447032928467,
0.25191012024879456,
0.07504443824291229,
0.1787114143371582,
-0.37723273038864136,
0.3724075257778168,
-0.7984839081764221,
-0.24171210825443268,
-0.3772033154964447,
-0.27977049350738525,
-0.3066907525062561,
-0.4829285740852356,
0.5354170203208923,
0.006012983154505491,
-0.3813337981700897,
-0.05451417714357376,
-0.19474157691001892,
0.7882340550422668,
0.365813285112381,
0.10198433697223663,
0.38754019141197205,
0.05675673857331276,
-0.3686489164829254,
-0.3013668358325958,
-0.7390443086624146,
-0.3393937051296234,
1.1067464351654053,
0.0688701719045639,
1.0136622190475464,
0.32277601957321167,
0.583566427230835,
-0.1759570837020874,
0.24475763738155365,
-0.9061453342437744,
0.5547986030578613,
-0.07534632831811905,
-0.6148338317871094,
-0.038113225251436234,
-0.6951944231987,
-0.7971253395080566,
0.2214801162481308,
-0.2131262868642807,
-0.6634843945503235,
-0.15946975350379944,
0.21743588149547577,
-0.29893574118614197,
0.15126977860927582,
-0.6719966530799866,
0.7236173152923584,
-0.22937963902950287,
-0.43759244680404663,
-0.12447062134742737,
-0.4763154685497284,
0.9988657832145691,
-0.13188976049423218,
0.24415969848632812,
-0.11091014742851257,
0.13212443888187408,
0.3646160364151001,
-0.4252065122127533,
0.9487136006355286,
0.09520730376243591,
-0.517767071723938,
0.4148007929325104,
0.572443425655365,
0.7931476831436157,
0.11555234342813492,
0.23980562388896942,
-0.2923094928264618,
-0.3528311252593994,
-0.5746855139732361,
-0.8123401403427124,
0.8425403237342834,
-0.506138026714325,
-0.6406074166297913,
-0.43960636854171753,
-0.6153707504272461,
-0.4110734462738037,
-0.027891796082258224,
0.12136919796466827,
0.6805763840675354,
0.19830067455768585,
0.11597314476966858,
1.0402590036392212,
-0.06413213908672333,
0.27334117889404297,
0.2417914867401123,
-0.10981451719999313,
-0.33778178691864014,
0.8372207880020142,
0.062415122985839844,
0.3351767063140869,
0.3506401777267456,
0.38372763991355896,
-0.4511977434158325,
-0.39079469442367554,
-0.30935052037239075,
0.6818023324012756,
-0.8567193746566772,
-0.23955439031124115,
-0.36435067653656006,
-0.29433128237724304,
-0.21740536391735077,
-0.13062933087348938,
-0.15993326902389526,
-0.35209015011787415,
-0.3637697994709015,
-0.007097311783581972,
0.1111365258693695,
0.6955063939094543,
0.0344034880399704,
0.11118736118078232,
-0.9600784182548523,
0.32154595851898193,
0.3974701762199402,
0.31604138016700745,
0.276904821395874,
-0.5820249319076538,
-0.20863692462444305,
0.1563587635755539,
-0.1887032389640808,
-0.7762436270713806,
0.05012825131416321,
0.05500699207186699,
0.6585507988929749,
0.5073039531707764,
-0.020686166360974312,
0.6062397956848145,
-0.3553657829761505,
0.5615298748016357,
0.07479219883680344,
-1.0488895177841187,
0.3047366440296173,
-0.6498283743858337,
0.45147714018821716,
0.12315864861011505,
0.2502894699573517,
-0.4634987711906433,
-0.26757580041885376,
-0.4264727830886841,
-0.5559112429618835,
0.43199148774147034,
0.13238078355789185,
0.37461280822753906,
0.09200076013803482,
0.14854750037193298,
-0.06393730640411377,
0.10934212058782578,
-0.7967637777328491,
0.04764540120959282,
0.1539074182510376,
-0.45839235186576843,
-0.09948616474866867,
-0.2319078892469406,
-0.48717623949050903,
-0.29714393615722656,
0.5120273232460022,
-0.16835589706897736,
0.14687882363796234,
-0.1214381754398346,
-0.20800352096557617,
-0.11934389173984528,
0.06961666792631149,
1.1351808309555054,
1.0027337074279785,
0.3148278594017029,
0.45670202374458313,
-0.1326204240322113,
-0.2258021980524063,
0.11360727250576019,
-0.005909740459173918,
-0.170621857047081,
-0.27531638741493225,
0.7064533233642578,
0.6451126933097839,
0.3815144896507263,
-0.9412325620651245,
0.4035135507583618,
0.19627174735069275,
-0.2597249150276184,
-0.43045032024383545,
0.11749284714460373,
0.4595627784729004,
0.21130309998989105,
0.3789401054382324,
0.022057827562093735,
0.020939119160175323,
-0.6592971682548523,
-0.11902990937232971,
0.6387216448783875,
-0.021607238799333572,
-0.5063686370849609,
0.4818762242794037,
-0.05741598829627037,
-0.03253890573978424,
0.6597505211830139,
-0.26050370931625366,
-0.7613459229469299,
0.5159265995025635,
0.7922595143318176,
0.7420077919960022,
-0.08308768272399902,
0.1250915229320526,
0.23667854070663452,
0.4223666191101074,
-0.0801248699426651,
0.24828393757343292,
0.08932013064622879,
-0.801044762134552,
-0.8034910559654236,
-0.4061433970928192,
-0.15431024134159088,
0.15312422811985016,
-0.11952763050794601,
0.20001128315925598,
-0.39955323934555054,
0.3128437101840973,
-0.14606505632400513,
-0.23629425466060638,
-0.37351277470588684,
-0.15860453248023987,
0.1851557493209839,
0.5253748893737793,
-1.16596257686615,
0.29977887868881226,
0.587708055973053,
-0.21844694018363953,
-0.9621717929840088,
-0.17601396143436432,
-0.036426376551389694,
-0.7766548991203308,
0.47782212495803833,
-0.022417843341827393,
-0.12985947728157043,
-0.23216570913791656,
-0.6751123070716858,
-0.5994781851768494,
0.5117934942245483,
0.6621735692024231,
-0.4249173104763031,
0.1653868854045868,
0.25211215019226074,
0.5411707162857056,
-0.29050689935684204,
-0.08095960319042206,
0.3423762321472168,
0.6513448357582092,
0.40893077850341797,
-0.5749704837799072,
0.14841467142105103,
-0.12616801261901855,
-0.0578000433743,
0.47156965732574463,
-0.47959837317466736,
1.0840011835098267,
-0.2998741567134857,
-0.20856215059757233,
0.01894262433052063,
0.388302743434906,
0.6290302276611328,
0.48302850127220154,
0.11484356969594955,
0.8323913812637329,
0.6190864443778992,
-0.11556827276945114,
0.8943057060241699,
0.11407855153083801,
0.2336588352918625,
1.04720938205719,
-0.5029915571212769,
0.49498772621154785,
0.29366883635520935,
-0.15632949769496918,
0.41348400712013245,
0.30649831891059875,
0.13354729115962982,
0.20653674006462097,
0.6865110993385315,
-0.6972501873970032,
-0.7213014364242554,
0.15404222905635834,
-0.29701611399650574,
0.5524892807006836,
0.527899980545044,
-0.17822672426700592,
-0.26571571826934814,
0.019509537145495415,
0.19113090634346008,
0.5077954530715942,
-0.12261073291301727,
0.6120575666427612,
0.37385016679763794,
-0.7750934362411499,
0.7245334982872009,
0.022715996950864792,
0.4074189364910126,
-0.6179218888282776,
-0.1918930560350418,
-0.47482913732528687,
0.29748886823654175,
-0.22761669754981995,
-0.6695853471755981,
0.35726621747016907,
-0.16074328124523163,
-0.09914351999759674,
0.1904163807630539,
0.668868362903595,
-0.4012499451637268,
-0.7520954012870789,
-0.0967128574848175,
0.5678889751434326,
-0.015182592906057835,
-0.3631267845630646,
-0.336112380027771,
0.22956164181232452,
-0.13833178579807281,
0.24381005764007568,
0.19234490394592285,
0.7161868810653687,
-0.38003644347190857,
0.76385897397995,
0.7078762054443359,
0.0724523514509201,
0.12728935480117798,
0.0492936372756958,
1.0373374223709106,
-0.6877346038818359,
-0.3192310631275177,
-1.039929986000061,
0.38655388355255127,
0.16663330793380737,
-0.0495273731648922,
0.7517447471618652,
0.5815489292144775,
0.7066641449928284,
-0.5068678259849548,
0.7601580619812012,
0.412440687417984,
0.1755351722240448,
-0.7243818640708923,
0.3723492920398712,
-0.36149862408638,
0.47666120529174805,
-0.15061701834201813,
-1.1024669408798218,
-0.5496294498443604,
0.6253737807273865,
-0.18555161356925964,
0.08023832738399506,
0.726908266544342,
0.7199404835700989,
-0.3136778473854065,
-0.08222969621419907,
0.43114519119262695,
0.18220247328281403,
0.14506186544895172,
1.125056266784668,
1.2593519687652588,
-0.15893058478832245,
0.4072800278663635,
-0.017080366611480713,
-0.1295170783996582,
-0.28129714727401733,
-0.7881952524185181,
-0.9411182403564453,
-0.45020297169685364,
-0.178633451461792,
-0.2343115657567978,
-0.1815176159143448,
0.6758352518081665,
0.5108173489570618,
-0.6194324493408203,
-0.19878005981445312,
-0.321101576089859,
0.4311286509037018,
0.07809022068977356,
-0.20232485234737396,
0.008174391463398933,
-0.19500704109668732,
-0.5924568772315979,
0.30099576711654663,
0.30118510127067566,
0.20143653452396393,
-0.49728140234947205,
0.020364675670862198,
0.19574415683746338,
0.31954050064086914,
0.6943585872650146,
0.19565941393375397,
-0.6841928362846375,
-0.13700717687606812,
0.3059767186641693,
0.009693698957562447,
-0.0841989815235138,
1.1806894540786743,
-0.5132561922073364,
0.26356109976768494,
0.6174108982086182,
0.6334944367408752,
0.42075297236442566,
-0.22799301147460938,
0.560833215713501,
-0.6306619644165039,
0.14781811833381653,
0.46593987941741943,
0.5070781707763672,
0.42952069640159607,
-0.06645125895738602,
0.21744230389595032,
0.666836142539978,
-0.22834473848342896,
-0.7712144255638123,
0.675412654876709,
-1.0257223844528198,
-0.38649338483810425,
1.0024625062942505,
0.019778747111558914,
-0.18399032950401306,
0.18740873038768768,
-0.15320956707000732,
-0.028123578056693077,
-0.0828932374715805,
0.7517101764678955,
1.0330957174301147,
-0.007989330217242241,
-0.05860404297709465,
-0.4721505641937256,
0.22974282503128052,
0.4210972189903259,
-0.8246392607688904,
0.0024942609015852213,
0.7814605236053467,
0.2697494924068451,
0.035313576459884644,
0.2477458119392395,
-0.13172632455825806,
0.19312724471092224,
-0.012509321793913841,
-0.1904170960187912,
0.05616135150194168,
-0.4747830033302307,
-0.31786713004112244,
-0.0004511892911978066,
0.07032851874828339,
0.14256048202514648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02985v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02985v1
|
Can Large Language Models Make the Grade? An Empirical Study Evaluating LLMs Ability to Mark Short Answer Questions in K-12 Education
| 2024-05-05T16:11:06 | 2024-05-05T16:11:06 |
Owen Henkel, Adam Boxer, Libby Hills, Bill Roberts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper presents reports on a series of experiments with a novel dataset
evaluating how well Large Language Models (LLMs) can mark (i.e. grade) open
text responses to short answer questions, Specifically, we explore how well
different combinations of GPT version and prompt engineering strategies
performed at marking real student answers to short answer across different
domain areas (Science and History) and grade-levels (spanning ages 5-16) using
a new, never-used-before dataset from Carousel, a quizzing platform. We found
that GPT-4, with basic few-shot prompting performed well (Kappa, 0.70) and,
importantly, very close to human-level performance (0.75). This research builds
on prior findings that GPT-4 could reliably score short answer reading
comprehension questions at a performance-level very close to that of expert
human raters. The proximity to human-level performance, across a variety of
subjects and grade levels suggests that LLMs could be a valuable tool for
supporting low-stakes formative assessment tasks in K-12 education and has
important implications for real-world education delivery.
|
[
-0.3396969139575958,
-0.9283364415168762,
0.8570408225059509,
0.04595988243818283,
-0.05883941799402237,
0.08378764241933823,
-0.21440546214580536,
-0.6588190197944641,
-0.06619218736886978,
0.02371208928525448,
-0.3476371765136719,
-0.45328786969184875,
-0.4854210913181305,
0.09986083209514618,
-0.3435955047607422,
0.8436318039894104,
-0.027258561924099922,
0.17447388172149658,
-0.519152820110321,
0.08052263408899307,
-0.531263530254364,
-0.7169501185417175,
-0.6520445346832275,
-0.36679747700691223,
0.7649189233779907,
0.6062801480293274,
0.6128644347190857,
0.6453876495361328,
0.6375647783279419,
0.20138436555862427,
-0.19391456246376038,
-0.23852747678756714,
-0.2773376703262329,
-0.07030432671308517,
-0.031535979360342026,
-0.4694977104663849,
-0.6588096618652344,
0.29689323902130127,
0.8064053654670715,
0.9778174161911011,
0.23848062753677368,
0.22820264101028442,
0.3702827990055084,
0.5869945287704468,
-0.31878066062927246,
0.091973215341568,
-0.27551695704460144,
-0.15750284492969513,
-0.10713674873113632,
0.06809023767709732,
-0.5690774917602539,
-0.5477639436721802,
0.19310545921325684,
-0.6198930144309998,
-0.0788251981139183,
0.08110468089580536,
0.8070710301399231,
0.055310968309640884,
-0.4981805980205536,
-0.577895998954773,
-0.5495442152023315,
0.9065877795219421,
-0.6608421802520752,
0.1487462967634201,
0.46198469400405884,
0.4082808196544647,
0.0894952341914177,
-0.8154203295707703,
-0.28113141655921936,
-0.44237977266311646,
-0.07071477174758911,
0.0844561904668808,
0.17856650054454803,
0.015284987166523933,
0.40648138523101807,
0.48622697591781616,
-0.535465657711029,
0.3668682277202606,
-0.6011559963226318,
-0.2595905661582947,
0.40333065390586853,
0.38891249895095825,
0.17210417985916138,
-0.14638960361480713,
-0.19815735518932343,
-0.11408433318138123,
-0.8902058601379395,
0.6112476587295532,
0.4568967819213867,
0.5071508288383484,
0.0982048287987709,
0.8212897777557373,
-0.28093042969703674,
0.6589378714561462,
-0.08049673587083817,
-0.025668751448392868,
-0.01011721696704626,
-0.22628848254680634,
-0.0005391662125475705,
-0.12419598549604416,
0.6036359667778015,
0.5839331150054932,
0.5015062689781189,
0.047342460602521896,
-0.40658822655677795,
0.16421420872211456,
-0.17424453794956207,
-1.0275657176971436,
-0.33153724670410156,
-0.08543661236763,
-0.254679799079895,
-0.2727171778678894,
-0.2286396324634552,
-0.8009065389633179,
-0.3887914717197418,
-0.37831732630729675,
0.7512808442115784,
-0.188588947057724,
0.14908304810523987,
0.2520862817764282,
0.10352551937103271,
0.31156161427497864,
0.6160328984260559,
-0.8189408779144287,
0.37343788146972656,
0.5552771091461182,
0.8580672144889832,
-0.23365163803100586,
-0.48875972628593445,
-0.5051503777503967,
-0.30485203862190247,
-0.35575124621391296,
0.8471235036849976,
-0.6224937438964844,
-0.45087137818336487,
0.08188222348690033,
-0.042995475232601166,
-0.06586013734340668,
-0.55260169506073,
0.4546595513820648,
-0.8519386649131775,
0.40736669301986694,
-0.33979105949401855,
-0.8665920495986938,
0.1681874841451645,
0.6376776099205017,
-0.5860376358032227,
0.9886974096298218,
-0.041694238781929016,
-0.5365116000175476,
0.3020947277545929,
-0.4780077040195465,
-0.2320365309715271,
-0.027532929554581642,
0.024066995829343796,
-0.1232280358672142,
-0.19487705826759338,
0.24198225140571594,
0.33552640676498413,
-0.281078964471817,
0.08427388966083527,
-0.2375793159008026,
-0.5944880247116089,
0.37203148007392883,
-0.47958120703697205,
0.36871087551116943,
-0.1911255121231079,
-0.07612776011228561,
0.01685255393385887,
-0.7683947682380676,
0.33962371945381165,
0.1291683316230774,
-0.6629058718681335,
-0.4756731390953064,
-0.19076159596443176,
-0.11084474623203278,
0.4092826843261719,
0.43637794256210327,
-0.6487113833427429,
0.39037391543388367,
-0.18531562387943268,
0.36936697363853455,
0.8834164142608643,
0.05857052281498909,
0.5143873691558838,
-0.5594098567962646,
0.7335056066513062,
-0.32973724603652954,
-0.03536137565970421,
-0.2928778827190399,
-0.743619978427887,
-0.5832131505012512,
-0.2778099477291107,
0.4326178729534149,
0.39161160588264465,
-0.4257306158542633,
-0.02425825223326683,
-0.3345049321651459,
-0.6259087920188904,
-0.5278140306472778,
-0.05827417969703674,
0.29621267318725586,
0.7603792548179626,
0.34528848528862,
0.00196435977704823,
-0.09024400264024734,
-0.7225537896156311,
-0.4609413146972656,
-0.33429139852523804,
-0.3316580355167389,
0.25956663489341736,
0.7062717080116272,
0.25683876872062683,
1.152649164199829,
-0.6496631503105164,
-0.05420367792248726,
0.005823106970638037,
0.135907843708992,
0.25790417194366455,
0.31431782245635986,
0.3576757311820984,
-0.45678237080574036,
-0.513934850692749,
-0.22298644483089447,
-0.6056971549987793,
-0.29510611295700073,
0.3200834095478058,
0.03773603215813637,
-0.11579150706529617,
0.49913448095321655,
-0.5366044640541077,
0.2327289581298828,
0.31061750650405884,
-0.5232341885566711,
0.7309336066246033,
-0.15178880095481873,
0.2777639925479889,
-0.5393768548965454,
0.028664307668805122,
-0.02898699976503849,
-0.1804768294095993,
-0.6026794910430908,
-0.10600306838750839,
0.34864580631256104,
-0.12153150886297226,
-0.5627216100692749,
0.9031444787979126,
-0.14631718397140503,
-0.06200723350048065,
-0.381778746843338,
0.11300666630268097,
0.010429998859763145,
0.3654762804508209,
-0.13087773323059082,
0.9194824695587158,
0.21240371465682983,
-0.4936545193195343,
0.07354167848825455,
-0.0011081076227128506,
-0.5774900913238525,
0.553197979927063,
-0.8945063352584839,
0.1658630222082138,
-0.08340123295783997,
0.21665231883525848,
-1.1569912433624268,
-0.3699088990688324,
-0.07776494324207306,
-0.4638170003890991,
0.011503891088068485,
-0.2975863516330719,
-0.6319623589515686,
-0.4869595766067505,
-0.34587565064430237,
0.4639960527420044,
0.7068072557449341,
-0.48578038811683655,
0.19798903167247772,
-0.05848284438252449,
-0.5153136253356934,
-0.2600692808628082,
-0.5411879420280457,
-0.21599382162094116,
-0.29539892077445984,
-0.6331357359886169,
-0.03929714486002922,
-0.4205141067504883,
-0.24585798382759094,
-0.04078008607029915,
-0.11645388603210449,
-0.2586495578289032,
0.15381397306919098,
0.021233510226011276,
0.44499945640563965,
-0.4478524625301361,
0.20836292207241058,
-0.11908206343650818,
0.08989398181438446,
0.2893418073654175,
0.09269452095031738,
0.3584895730018616,
-0.31490448117256165,
-0.48206526041030884,
-0.19285368919372559,
0.0957445502281189,
0.8023682832717896,
-0.06514930725097656,
0.4659218490123749,
0.03245583921670914,
-0.42186862230300903,
-0.08304647356271744,
-0.32214802503585815,
-0.47663241624832153,
-0.4857199788093567,
0.26683372259140015,
-0.3660672605037689,
-1.2959944009780884,
0.5168928503990173,
0.14826537668704987,
0.11624954640865326,
0.316787987947464,
0.45717403292655945,
-0.2594550848007202,
1.0763089656829834,
0.3583860397338867,
-0.03616199269890785,
0.2276402711868286,
-0.0026973357889801264,
0.2689547836780548,
-0.5149677395820618,
-0.04794899746775627,
-0.6635004281997681,
-0.45738568902015686,
-0.5176578164100647,
-0.2805670201778412,
0.3235785961151123,
0.27021175622940063,
-0.3545256555080414,
-0.31902414560317993,
-0.28292280435562134,
0.7243579030036926,
0.5754238963127136,
-0.17361541092395782,
0.48918938636779785,
-0.18967531621456146,
-0.10309740900993347,
-0.1798526793718338,
-0.1998240202665329,
-0.9665436744689941,
1.0275182723999023,
0.46747729182243347,
0.7061913013458252,
-0.023736508563160896,
0.3984428346157074,
0.30513516068458557,
0.6156511306762695,
-0.943570077419281,
0.7148548364639282,
0.20781749486923218,
-0.8497281074523926,
-0.7360450029373169,
-0.28947654366493225,
-0.7631723880767822,
0.3654170036315918,
0.1717059165239334,
-0.5512315034866333,
-0.18407946825027466,
0.004281495697796345,
-0.22227028012275696,
0.14583702385425568,
-0.8318102955818176,
0.794941782951355,
-0.019947849214076996,
-0.3801804482936859,
0.273941308259964,
-0.535641610622406,
0.3788246214389801,
-0.3013165593147278,
0.36063915491104126,
-0.26473724842071533,
-0.03297094628214836,
0.9674801230430603,
-0.2540729343891144,
0.8284256458282471,
-0.3835389018058777,
-0.2877606451511383,
0.6528815031051636,
0.07546556740999222,
0.4971843659877777,
0.013306493870913982,
-0.17989268898963928,
-0.307588666677475,
0.10163770616054535,
-0.5473642945289612,
-0.6647016406059265,
0.7999301552772522,
-0.7896541357040405,
-0.6406562328338623,
-0.5348008275032043,
-0.6666563749313354,
-0.4283091723918915,
0.23914840817451477,
-0.00545719126239419,
0.36123284697532654,
-0.04166877269744873,
0.11794711649417877,
0.6683491468429565,
-0.03293313458561897,
0.5482518672943115,
0.7358972430229187,
-0.32357898354530334,
-0.3821927011013031,
0.8507710099220276,
0.38839781284332275,
0.4529016613960266,
0.26205530762672424,
0.4655831754207611,
-0.4375010132789612,
-0.4548397362232208,
-0.4712342619895935,
0.33455997705459595,
-0.997771143913269,
-0.02486194297671318,
-0.47829991579055786,
-0.12366396933794022,
-0.2601395547389984,
-0.26802483201026917,
-0.15532848238945007,
-0.5751939415931702,
-0.2008851021528244,
-0.31767538189888,
0.15595321357250214,
0.9834408760070801,
0.0940447598695755,
0.3775187134742737,
-0.6386464238166809,
-0.06370208412408829,
0.7097052931785583,
0.3760341703891754,
0.05361180379986763,
-0.7324336171150208,
-0.21165479719638824,
0.10108722746372223,
-0.4214439392089844,
-0.5136098861694336,
-0.05412106215953827,
-0.029629556462168694,
0.20639722049236298,
-0.08938322961330414,
-0.03821008652448654,
0.44023430347442627,
-0.7137431502342224,
1.219246745109558,
0.04132702201604843,
-0.7389048337936401,
0.3236101567745209,
-0.547922670841217,
0.5341426134109497,
0.43764108419418335,
0.37578538060188293,
-0.6642294526100159,
-0.4653136432170868,
-0.1364860087633133,
-0.735740065574646,
0.6698406934738159,
0.0147573072463274,
0.1341104954481125,
-0.1073475107550621,
0.2554510533809662,
0.18411637842655182,
0.11690040677785873,
-0.8544008731842041,
-0.15406683087348938,
-0.011290149763226509,
-0.3406562805175781,
-0.25102758407592773,
-0.34911343455314636,
0.20997542142868042,
-0.12047699838876724,
0.6051582098007202,
-0.16427788138389587,
0.037423890084028244,
0.1042160838842392,
-0.14461712539196014,
0.032545194029808044,
0.6827083826065063,
0.8524719476699829,
0.7479938268661499,
-0.3231459856033325,
0.10724575817584991,
0.1130179688334465,
-0.6945386528968811,
0.5123815536499023,
0.0471203587949276,
-0.14212414622306824,
-0.2679000496864319,
0.42778170108795166,
0.20587663352489471,
0.02981709875166416,
-0.6760252714157104,
0.622281551361084,
-0.16443100571632385,
-0.32260453701019287,
0.010536672547459602,
-0.201775461435318,
0.12854303419589996,
0.11032560467720032,
0.5365195870399475,
-0.43931078910827637,
-0.08193832635879517,
-0.26002752780914307,
0.07580914348363876,
0.050443489104509354,
-0.34590500593185425,
-0.5833644866943359,
0.5759652853012085,
0.12891018390655518,
-0.18061141669750214,
0.54472416639328,
0.03755670040845871,
-0.24687635898590088,
0.7398713827133179,
0.4495052993297577,
0.40497177839279175,
-0.23404675722122192,
0.15150727331638336,
0.40021276473999023,
0.4121241569519043,
-0.18838071823120117,
0.35296353697776794,
0.10712766647338867,
-0.35408470034599304,
-0.6609811782836914,
-0.58859783411026,
-0.617777407169342,
0.25033703446388245,
-0.5505370497703552,
0.2741420269012451,
-0.4434700012207031,
-0.13260497152805328,
-0.13284528255462646,
0.033868078142404556,
-0.6196088790893555,
0.5938444137573242,
0.0067503806203603745,
0.8559082746505737,
-1.0494779348373413,
0.6618687510490417,
1.003477692604065,
-0.41854336857795715,
-0.7283481359481812,
-0.1770186573266983,
-0.06287846714258194,
-0.5947383642196655,
0.7757156491279602,
0.3316585123538971,
0.13048318028450012,
0.1432504653930664,
-0.5101550221443176,
-0.9270477890968323,
0.9357286691665649,
0.04649268835783005,
-0.4210408926010132,
-0.3786921203136444,
0.501775324344635,
0.6400598287582397,
-0.1461268961429596,
0.42626065015792847,
0.5168786644935608,
0.5106663107872009,
-0.04653511568903923,
-0.9649655818939209,
-0.10497543215751648,
-0.10756797343492508,
-0.2947930693626404,
0.22009773552417755,
-0.5436280369758606,
0.7979893684387207,
-0.09135239571332932,
0.1561243087053299,
0.34639817476272583,
0.7362372279167175,
0.5510269403457642,
0.7473337054252625,
0.36972254514694214,
0.5697182416915894,
0.7603569030761719,
-0.22990719974040985,
0.9339619874954224,
-0.03954057767987251,
0.35125982761383057,
1.0208717584609985,
-0.3927212953567505,
0.8950917720794678,
0.6675470471382141,
-0.19322426617145538,
0.26655223965644836,
0.770291268825531,
0.1979156732559204,
0.6731873750686646,
0.5328730344772339,
-0.1795671582221985,
-0.24349014461040497,
-0.1935047209262848,
-0.3672935962677002,
0.1232171282172203,
0.20361924171447754,
-0.09966745227575302,
-0.09324876219034195,
0.23851154744625092,
0.08596190065145493,
0.14403091371059418,
-0.5758873224258423,
0.442388117313385,
0.19994738698005676,
-0.6457369923591614,
0.3773590326309204,
-0.0537572056055069,
0.6277355551719666,
-0.4527679681777954,
0.0967322364449501,
-0.4453727602958679,
0.15947753190994263,
0.06917604058980942,
-1.142722249031067,
-0.1009635329246521,
0.2833724915981293,
-0.4192522466182709,
-0.2934826612472534,
0.6198751330375671,
-0.29966533184051514,
-0.38071495294570923,
-0.00850991252809763,
0.5662479400634766,
0.15325070917606354,
0.10626501590013504,
-0.1365392655134201,
-0.03915052488446236,
-0.3720462918281555,
-0.45682859420776367,
0.4753064513206482,
0.5823634266853333,
-0.11693040281534195,
0.6054759621620178,
0.47368481755256653,
-0.1000540554523468,
0.3614236116409302,
0.00003802143328357488,
0.663555383682251,
-0.6561574339866638,
-0.47433555126190186,
-0.7150367498397827,
0.5979872345924377,
0.0263016726821661,
-0.3251563608646393,
0.8254266381263733,
0.6173684597015381,
0.9499077200889587,
-0.14390675723552704,
0.7857592701911926,
0.25979918241500854,
0.7954660058021545,
-0.4686155617237091,
0.4426872134208679,
-0.36842331290245056,
0.15105994045734406,
-0.2834668755531311,
-0.9547904133796692,
-0.250789612531662,
0.13682107627391815,
-0.8031296730041504,
0.22240681946277618,
0.9422594904899597,
0.5300406813621521,
0.17858237028121948,
0.037351492792367935,
0.5601345300674438,
-0.0071480730548501015,
0.7017910480499268,
0.5030338168144226,
1.3774915933609009,
-0.36899513006210327,
0.6681368350982666,
-0.1810843050479889,
-0.060609910637140274,
-0.13880658149719238,
-0.6100478768348694,
-1.1359314918518066,
-0.3131893575191498,
-0.2645277678966522,
-0.26797810196876526,
0.04889240115880966,
0.6221346259117126,
0.18276385962963104,
-0.41172632575035095,
-0.2318539321422577,
0.2862732410430908,
-0.058550965040922165,
0.1155049204826355,
-0.250219464302063,
0.563461184501648,
-0.30379658937454224,
-0.7860985994338989,
0.4375631809234619,
-0.01929325982928276,
0.3514096736907959,
0.004160859156399965,
0.02263980358839035,
0.039230287075042725,
0.09452544897794724,
0.5965855121612549,
0.14486722648143768,
-0.616777777671814,
-0.6125625371932983,
0.3868533968925476,
-0.4114335775375366,
0.04277430474758148,
0.7334290146827698,
-0.7185710668563843,
0.10505524277687073,
0.4914291799068451,
0.671863317489624,
0.21527619659900665,
0.020132288336753845,
0.19343732297420502,
-0.6248222589492798,
-0.14357101917266846,
0.4689331352710724,
0.2135610282421112,
0.5140405893325806,
-0.04631754383444786,
0.35646694898605347,
0.22375038266181946,
-1.012133002281189,
-0.8399617075920105,
-0.06923744082450867,
-0.6551364064216614,
-0.11836075782775879,
1.1504383087158203,
-0.09739688038825989,
-0.14349901676177979,
0.035520344972610474,
-0.21257370710372925,
-0.26243749260902405,
-0.3887559771537781,
0.7072194814682007,
1.303400993347168,
0.13997983932495117,
-0.019896358251571655,
-0.7688048481941223,
0.31205108761787415,
0.4465164840221405,
-0.8567215800285339,
-0.03793977573513985,
0.6018646359443665,
0.4348306655883789,
0.004449332132935524,
0.6918493509292603,
-0.11189620941877365,
0.38589054346084595,
-0.34993162751197815,
-0.14998571574687958,
0.045536018908023834,
-0.3498636484146118,
-0.4619833528995514,
0.37773776054382324,
0.5151634812355042,
-0.18158911168575287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02984v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02984v1
|
E-TSL: A Continuous Educational Turkish Sign Language Dataset with Baseline Methods
| 2024-05-05T16:07:23 | 2024-05-05T16:07:23 |
Şükrü Öztürk, Hacer Yalim Keles
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
This study introduces the continuous Educational Turkish Sign Language
(E-TSL) dataset, collected from online Turkish language lessons for 5th, 6th,
and 8th grades. The dataset comprises 1,410 videos totaling nearly 24 hours and
includes performances from 11 signers. Turkish, an agglutinative language,
poses unique challenges for sign language translation, particularly with a
vocabulary where 64% are singleton words and 85% are rare words, appearing less
than five times. We developed two baseline models to address these challenges:
the Pose to Text Transformer (P2T-T) and the Graph Neural Network based
Transformer (GNN-T) models. The GNN-T model achieved 19.13% BLEU-1 score and
3.28% BLEU-4 score, presenting a significant challenge compared to existing
benchmarks. The P2T-T model, while demonstrating slightly lower performance in
BLEU scores, achieved a higher ROUGE-L score of 22.09%. Additionally, we
benchmarked our model using the well-known PHOENIX-Weather 2014T dataset to
validate our approach.
|
[
-0.025799164548516273,
-0.6613397002220154,
0.11756942421197891,
-0.08475910127162933,
-0.49515458941459656,
0.08960133045911789,
0.10846779495477676,
-0.4776669144630432,
-0.15526443719863892,
0.31303057074546814,
-0.4795295298099518,
-0.6672557592391968,
-0.9568239450454712,
0.08717785775661469,
-0.4619165062904358,
0.8444111347198486,
-0.002306942827999592,
-0.08165714889764786,
0.4723171889781952,
-0.20425601303577423,
-0.20231211185455322,
-0.12364377081394196,
-0.9079200625419617,
-0.16415223479270935,
0.1467921882867813,
0.5474282503128052,
0.45234256982803345,
0.44399502873420715,
0.46767863631248474,
0.13675406575202942,
-0.16440558433532715,
-0.0864875540137291,
-0.297864705324173,
0.018693502992391586,
0.22498437762260437,
0.19366054236888885,
-0.3775539994239807,
-0.152866929769516,
0.8196040987968445,
0.6589797139167786,
-0.05954000726342201,
0.6150685548782349,
0.12486256659030914,
0.5851771235466003,
-0.3800632655620575,
0.07853047549724579,
-0.3251657783985138,
0.1962694674730301,
-0.26231250166893005,
0.30010682344436646,
-0.5369753837585449,
-0.46341007947921753,
0.2130550891160965,
-0.5241416692733765,
0.22461090981960297,
0.057490769773721695,
0.9959472417831421,
0.20836234092712402,
-0.9439162611961365,
-0.291708379983902,
-0.6548466682434082,
0.705004870891571,
-0.7709305286407471,
0.7742051482200623,
0.2309068739414215,
0.5011061429977417,
-0.042396239936351776,
-0.9532949924468994,
-0.5677817463874817,
-0.6165369749069214,
-0.12477871030569077,
0.24547016620635986,
-0.014960971660912037,
0.27152693271636963,
0.2870592772960663,
0.36704179644584656,
-0.8612218499183655,
-0.10840069502592087,
-0.6774291396141052,
-0.11371198296546936,
0.5134205222129822,
0.3206652104854584,
0.38686907291412354,
0.173064187169075,
-0.23286569118499756,
-0.16575987637043,
-0.5842902660369873,
0.323370099067688,
0.10772374272346497,
0.6677819490432739,
-0.27461862564086914,
0.8719210624694824,
-0.19042691588401794,
1.2201473712921143,
0.023549875244498253,
-0.11233130097389221,
0.0825691670179367,
-0.3604069948196411,
-0.31714513897895813,
0.04062788933515549,
0.5589326024055481,
0.18327981233596802,
0.1791652888059616,
0.006899424362927675,
-0.2091725468635559,
0.0943978950381279,
-0.20272186398506165,
-0.7235207557678223,
-0.14385351538658142,
0.24533700942993164,
-0.23111537098884583,
-0.10294719785451889,
0.044892214238643646,
-0.38798394799232483,
-0.43391332030296326,
-0.28693175315856934,
0.5063157081604004,
-0.321031391620636,
-0.23951002955436707,
0.08489257097244263,
0.07211526483297348,
0.43901368975639343,
0.41689953207969666,
-0.6602287888526917,
0.616473913192749,
0.3943788707256317,
1.1824575662612915,
-0.17434369027614594,
-0.09160531312227249,
-0.3571312427520752,
0.10916966944932938,
-0.1905641108751297,
0.3680272102355957,
-0.39576682448387146,
-0.1699291169643402,
0.1047850176692009,
-0.00705189723521471,
-0.4129505157470703,
-0.08340995013713837,
0.6225489974021912,
-0.12817616760730743,
0.43706879019737244,
0.007722083944827318,
-0.7300845384597778,
-0.12565593421459198,
0.30585864186286926,
-0.853947639465332,
1.257847785949707,
0.22666427493095398,
-0.3921162188053131,
0.4514561593532562,
-0.5670846700668335,
-0.45231589674949646,
0.23589523136615753,
0.030259542167186737,
-0.7295384407043457,
-0.0976407378911972,
0.06724545359611511,
0.32357558608055115,
0.005124356597661972,
-0.10331941395998001,
0.14627724885940552,
-0.47569552063941956,
-0.037566158920526505,
-0.07722238451242447,
0.7856931090354919,
0.22641506791114807,
-0.6204176545143127,
-0.032758940011262894,
-0.6167436242103577,
-0.014641286805272102,
-0.04845181852579117,
-0.34276267886161804,
0.0012155469739809632,
-0.19214604794979095,
0.44551002979278564,
0.7003290057182312,
0.09723187237977982,
-0.7727338075637817,
-0.005396327003836632,
-0.14218130707740784,
0.014208612032234669,
0.4445008933544159,
-0.006844350136816502,
-0.11915873736143112,
-0.3013764023780823,
0.3801910877227783,
0.2098556011915207,
0.2169845849275589,
0.07719982415437698,
-0.8633739948272705,
-0.9799531698226929,
0.06234017387032509,
-0.12575210630893707,
0.44236987829208374,
-0.4037846624851227,
0.4547436237335205,
-0.4123286306858063,
-0.4632086753845215,
-0.4233832061290741,
-0.10890299826860428,
0.5280669331550598,
0.6689720749855042,
0.4070280194282532,
0.012928372249007225,
-0.42062023282051086,
-0.5837557911872864,
-0.24503573775291443,
-0.27276942133903503,
-0.05158958584070206,
-0.04800159111618996,
0.5251125693321228,
0.4632013142108917,
0.5191441774368286,
0.006828459911048412,
-0.6472311019897461,
-0.42759451270103455,
-0.1943080723285675,
0.5041537284851074,
0.3624923527240753,
0.32037264108657837,
-0.6628082394599915,
-1.048780083656311,
0.33368149399757385,
-0.5640677809715271,
0.0661865696310997,
-0.032866865396499634,
0.2781769633293152,
0.40027767419815063,
0.3959164023399353,
-0.33357805013656616,
0.5356395840644836,
0.8330166935920715,
-1.1509931087493896,
0.468818724155426,
-0.01607155241072178,
0.2939298450946808,
-1.246922254562378,
0.32632121443748474,
0.3511357009410858,
-0.37682533264160156,
-1.1828522682189941,
-0.06179795041680336,
-0.06291670352220535,
-0.27522513270378113,
-0.7677039504051208,
0.7588822841644287,
-0.5625036954879761,
-0.006331617943942547,
-0.09656522423028946,
0.16644085943698883,
-0.24264414608478546,
0.21930377185344696,
0.1356627196073532,
0.6985637545585632,
0.42386192083358765,
-0.6079371571540833,
0.30115461349487305,
0.28902506828308105,
-0.3290194571018219,
0.4463656544685364,
-0.7042070627212524,
0.18702344596385956,
0.20787599682807922,
0.0418553501367569,
-0.9670111536979675,
0.03810965269804001,
0.5607275366783142,
-0.4567994177341461,
0.4126671552658081,
-0.21561098098754883,
-0.07938335090875626,
-0.3991800844669342,
0.12501099705696106,
0.15129628777503967,
0.5141754746437073,
-0.31627705693244934,
0.6837668418884277,
0.15027640759944916,
0.01624286361038685,
-0.6594095230102539,
-0.5331239700317383,
0.2603399157524109,
-0.33610162138938904,
-0.5341216921806335,
-0.036028459668159485,
0.15507064759731293,
-0.1548723578453064,
0.019534030929207802,
-0.18213891983032227,
0.0005186873022466898,
0.01467384584248066,
-0.06203551962971687,
0.13591383397579193,
-0.33008038997650146,
-0.02923477813601494,
-0.3174014985561371,
-0.020805057138204575,
-0.23630934953689575,
-0.6857585310935974,
0.4061327576637268,
-0.47363191843032837,
-0.33618679642677307,
-0.7229703068733215,
-0.10058838874101639,
0.6122632622718811,
0.16049335896968842,
1.0900229215621948,
0.4626791477203369,
-0.5945131182670593,
0.0628632977604866,
-0.3281131684780121,
0.1030958816409111,
-0.4166801869869232,
0.5907853841781616,
-0.534145176410675,
-0.8497719168663025,
0.6048527956008911,
0.16467750072479248,
0.41275569796562195,
0.2884412407875061,
0.5631868839263916,
-0.1824473887681961,
0.7939800024032593,
0.43184179067611694,
-0.04733109101653099,
0.5566242337226868,
-0.15575678646564484,
-0.00128211360424757,
-0.6538789868354797,
-0.4269185960292816,
-0.3671312928199768,
-0.3039315938949585,
-0.33288145065307617,
-0.04923347383737564,
0.3365212678909302,
-0.01052222028374672,
-0.5157909393310547,
0.4943518340587616,
-0.49158844351768494,
0.26350638270378113,
0.15730899572372437,
0.30210041999816895,
0.28303590416908264,
0.14837223291397095,
0.06123516708612442,
0.049204446375370026,
-0.35694465041160583,
-0.6074115633964539,
1.3017494678497314,
0.24632522463798523,
0.14826273918151855,
0.6190406680107117,
0.4038553535938263,
0.5513195395469666,
0.299917072057724,
-0.7025423645973206,
0.5262776613235474,
-0.3095763623714447,
-0.6583452820777893,
-0.8894109129905701,
-0.20486335456371307,
-1.1402499675750732,
0.3931834101676941,
-0.07484123855829239,
-0.9598422050476074,
-0.30608734488487244,
0.2601095139980316,
-0.07682772725820541,
0.33854299783706665,
-0.6325837969779968,
0.949022114276886,
-0.16673220694065094,
-0.3636075556278229,
0.01668943092226982,
-0.6155432462692261,
0.32841503620147705,
-0.1095910370349884,
0.05437025800347328,
-0.1913110613822937,
-0.022295119240880013,
0.7548415064811707,
-0.5993268489837646,
0.7001678347587585,
-0.3078593909740448,
0.0958259180188179,
0.2542353570461273,
-0.05754471570253372,
0.5915826559066772,
-0.36199143528938293,
-0.16781727969646454,
-0.14420443773269653,
0.02522244304418564,
-0.8562778234481812,
-0.41416803002357483,
0.3298778831958771,
-0.9883113503456116,
-0.4138970673084259,
-0.6635122895240784,
-0.2428271323442459,
-0.1498192995786667,
0.30359333753585815,
0.3024709224700928,
0.48983222246170044,
-0.48752909898757935,
0.017790857702493668,
0.433939129114151,
0.24431370198726654,
0.5015864372253418,
0.5635488629341125,
-0.07668647915124893,
-0.4489191174507141,
0.8036540150642395,
0.18402737379074097,
0.4431837499141693,
0.1559736132621765,
0.3626041114330292,
-0.5852580666542053,
-0.6808509826660156,
-0.6124395728111267,
0.2246236801147461,
-0.7529655694961548,
0.23382681608200073,
-0.23600836098194122,
-0.26769036054611206,
-0.5373505353927612,
-0.03483080491423607,
-0.26718899607658386,
-0.606939435005188,
0.1511680632829666,
-0.32661065459251404,
0.23529918491840363,
0.8942677974700928,
0.15470020473003387,
0.4910354018211365,
-0.6368293762207031,
0.1358964741230011,
0.06914759427309036,
0.2229982614517212,
-0.12377175688743591,
-1.0200139284133911,
-0.5044614672660828,
0.01533910259604454,
-0.14071018993854523,
-0.8402593731880188,
0.20937451720237732,
0.6807644963264465,
0.5490789413452148,
0.2972688376903534,
0.03759349510073662,
0.4050871431827545,
-0.14397627115249634,
1.105635166168213,
0.35002079606056213,
-0.8830868005752563,
0.4815143048763275,
-0.5068485140800476,
0.5002995133399963,
0.401174932718277,
0.18069307506084442,
-1.1732803583145142,
-0.3834768533706665,
-0.5541961789131165,
-0.840668261051178,
0.8118098378181458,
0.7785377502441406,
-0.07547877728939056,
0.33837372064590454,
0.12093889713287354,
0.019779808819293976,
0.028242139145731926,
-0.8767722249031067,
-0.5644273161888123,
-0.5272805690765381,
-0.4223331809043884,
-0.24335815012454987,
0.04885266721248627,
0.006862356793135405,
-0.31870630383491516,
0.7981921434402466,
0.026087511330842972,
0.024299999698996544,
-0.15111009776592255,
-0.43836331367492676,
-0.09527075290679932,
0.17204716801643372,
1.0956220626831055,
0.6151309609413147,
-0.21827685832977295,
0.015110326930880547,
0.43103352189064026,
-1.1900368928909302,
0.4760064482688904,
-0.01360355131328106,
-0.2635941803455353,
0.14708620309829712,
0.4928630292415619,
1.080405354499817,
-0.29757803678512573,
-0.14639902114868164,
0.39018818736076355,
-0.0964815765619278,
-0.11781936883926392,
-0.6422498822212219,
-0.4251047372817993,
-0.1466815024614334,
-0.07039068639278412,
0.5398131012916565,
-0.3636564314365387,
-0.17531125247478485,
-0.10870786756277084,
0.4407137632369995,
-0.053320638835430145,
-0.4925532639026642,
-0.6046285629272461,
0.5501917600631714,
0.14020009338855743,
-0.33718788623809814,
0.8486074209213257,
0.1324884444475174,
-0.39619705080986023,
0.7240656018257141,
0.6785996556282043,
0.9109334349632263,
-0.5877490639686584,
0.4573093354701996,
0.8019717335700989,
0.5237513780593872,
0.056564636528491974,
0.3868291676044464,
0.026656659319996834,
-0.6185570359230042,
-0.1780981868505478,
-0.4943173825740814,
-0.495007187128067,
0.4647666811943054,
-0.5845886468887329,
0.5445594191551208,
-0.4012356102466583,
-0.17854149639606476,
-0.4843659996986389,
0.2962256371974945,
-0.8159728646278381,
0.6560163497924805,
0.4264240264892578,
0.7940238118171692,
-1.4153411388397217,
0.7839075922966003,
0.9999669194221497,
-0.47776898741722107,
-0.8368560075759888,
-0.09804754704236984,
0.1385471224784851,
-0.5452952980995178,
0.5618153810501099,
0.15789471566677094,
-0.07321625202894211,
0.4802541732788086,
-0.1610019952058792,
-1.0461459159851074,
1.1147757768630981,
0.14900104701519012,
-0.45493388175964355,
-0.04861976206302643,
0.8180379867553711,
0.714501678943634,
-0.22241748869419098,
0.4588954448699951,
0.7310655117034912,
0.5567054748535156,
0.3165583908557892,
-0.980036735534668,
0.07046009600162506,
-0.2853723168373108,
-0.2360316812992096,
0.13630525767803192,
-0.7104036211967468,
0.4089956283569336,
0.0866771936416626,
-0.4457140266895294,
-0.04527859389781952,
0.7854452133178711,
0.5961974263191223,
0.49074801802635193,
0.38644492626190186,
0.6096335053443909,
0.701239824295044,
-0.15518340468406677,
0.6642409563064575,
-0.5074892640113831,
0.4741472005844116,
0.8297951221466064,
0.00788058340549469,
0.7305111885070801,
0.5325906872749329,
-0.2227313369512558,
0.1984805017709732,
0.7999638319015503,
0.20162290334701538,
0.3658585548400879,
0.1330041140317917,
-0.49424293637275696,
-0.375137597322464,
-0.08204998075962067,
-0.26746493577957153,
0.17898057401180267,
0.5598600506782532,
-0.11488017439842224,
-0.424562931060791,
0.05405157431960106,
-0.13769549131393433,
-0.05237238109111786,
-0.4576716125011444,
0.4954788088798523,
0.3753339350223541,
-0.24162645637989044,
0.5398405194282532,
-0.3479328751564026,
0.23103924095630646,
-0.5754366517066956,
0.06125612184405327,
-0.39096468687057495,
0.2472199946641922,
-0.18103116750717163,
-0.8953763842582703,
0.32971325516700745,
-0.22605648636817932,
0.36938077211380005,
-0.20112344622612,
0.573728084564209,
-0.5518929362297058,
-0.8160120844841003,
-0.03958415612578392,
0.4589110314846039,
0.44365593791007996,
0.4619734287261963,
-0.7279244661331177,
-0.07071292400360107,
-0.20973558723926544,
-0.6023063063621521,
0.1255589723587036,
0.26577892899513245,
-0.32010504603385925,
0.7328653931617737,
0.3883754312992096,
0.15999193489551544,
0.4627830386161804,
0.08477084338665009,
0.5713024139404297,
-0.505778431892395,
-0.6162136793136597,
-0.5777556300163269,
0.8270273208618164,
-0.09127391874790192,
-0.6187472343444824,
0.7458265423774719,
0.7208084464073181,
0.6938822269439697,
-0.2648019790649414,
0.9159765839576721,
-0.22216901183128357,
0.41782084107398987,
-0.5286078453063965,
0.839240550994873,
-0.4494611322879791,
-0.21004618704319,
-0.2659245431423187,
-1.0553181171417236,
-0.4271368086338043,
0.39767026901245117,
-0.10539703816175461,
-0.014809650368988514,
0.7896692156791687,
0.4638720154762268,
-0.0802556574344635,
-0.18289883434772491,
0.7996748089790344,
-0.09031912684440613,
0.4318477213382721,
0.7893858551979065,
0.6047611236572266,
-0.9295140504837036,
0.6136505007743835,
0.02490425296127796,
0.009214028716087341,
-0.10221628844738007,
-0.6710805892944336,
-1.0780260562896729,
-0.9299226999282837,
-0.4469040334224701,
-0.571153998374939,
0.359119176864624,
0.9036186933517456,
0.3313261568546295,
-1.2072176933288574,
-0.6316326856613159,
-0.16584919393062592,
-0.2244282066822052,
-0.4314844608306885,
-0.121571846306324,
0.7969307899475098,
-0.01804165169596672,
-0.6297744512557983,
0.34980031847953796,
-0.19676586985588074,
0.3341541886329651,
0.12609390914440155,
-0.40903130173683167,
-0.21881712973117828,
-0.17106091976165771,
0.47746527194976807,
0.60149085521698,
-0.738552987575531,
-0.6967626214027405,
0.1503339558839798,
-0.3163434863090515,
0.018756166100502014,
0.5161079168319702,
-0.5179693698883057,
0.4392080307006836,
0.5554622411727905,
0.29397839307785034,
0.7317031621932983,
0.17291873693466187,
0.44418397545814514,
-0.7304252982139587,
0.18077456951141357,
0.14549438655376434,
0.298879474401474,
0.3780391812324524,
-0.21864549815654755,
0.43662843108177185,
0.3896697759628296,
-0.26518821716308594,
-0.6635439991950989,
0.31014639139175415,
-0.8995237350463867,
0.21061524748802185,
1.1666452884674072,
-0.24365556240081787,
-0.06650970131158829,
-0.7077405452728271,
0.0703844353556633,
0.6701967716217041,
-0.23708240687847137,
0.8294293284416199,
0.6284564733505249,
-0.16348962485790253,
-0.675861120223999,
-0.329506516456604,
0.551679790019989,
0.19020168483257294,
-0.42338162660598755,
-0.18077781796455383,
0.3968483507633209,
0.37994223833084106,
-0.1717081516981125,
0.6635094285011292,
0.09219551831483841,
0.3457072079181671,
0.10356811434030533,
0.14409495890140533,
-0.48055773973464966,
-0.25268587470054626,
-0.4253302216529846,
0.05097753927111626,
0.1313728541135788,
-0.3460646867752075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02937v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02937v2
|
Unraveling the Dominance of Large Language Models Over Transformer Models for Bangla Natural Language Inference: A Comprehensive Study
| 2024-05-05T13:57:05 | 2024-05-07T17:34:13 |
Fatema Tuj Johora Faria, Mukaffi Bin Moin, Asif Iftekher Fahim, Pronay Debnath, Faisal Muhammad Shah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural Language Inference (NLI) is a cornerstone of Natural Language
Processing (NLP), providing insights into the entailment relationships between
text pairings. It is a critical component of Natural Language Understanding
(NLU), demonstrating the ability to extract information from spoken or written
interactions. NLI is mainly concerned with determining the entailment
relationship between two statements, known as the premise and hypothesis. When
the premise logically implies the hypothesis, the pair is labeled "entailment".
If the hypothesis contradicts the premise, the pair receives the
"contradiction" label. When there is insufficient evidence to establish a
connection, the pair is described as "neutral". Despite the success of Large
Language Models (LLMs) in various tasks, their effectiveness in NLI remains
constrained by issues like low-resource domain accuracy, model overconfidence,
and difficulty in capturing human judgment disagreements. This study addresses
the underexplored area of evaluating LLMs in low-resourced languages such as
Bengali. Through a comprehensive evaluation, we assess the performance of
prominent LLMs and state-of-the-art (SOTA) models in Bengali NLP tasks,
focusing on natural language inference. Utilizing the XNLI dataset, we conduct
zero-shot and few-shot evaluations, comparing LLMs like GPT-3.5 Turbo and
Gemini 1.5 Pro with models such as BanglaBERT, Bangla BERT Base, DistilBERT,
mBERT, and sahajBERT. Our findings reveal that while LLMs can achieve
comparable or superior performance to fine-tuned SOTA models in few-shot
scenarios, further research is necessary to enhance our understanding of LLMs
in languages with modest resources like Bengali. This study underscores the
importance of continued efforts in exploring LLM capabilities across diverse
linguistic contexts.
|
[
-0.20398856699466705,
-0.8404536247253418,
0.3553473651409149,
0.3616620898246765,
-0.08644307404756546,
0.07330627739429474,
-0.252731055021286,
-0.6379396915435791,
0.04012876749038696,
0.5978376865386963,
-0.3980483114719391,
-0.15736420452594757,
-0.6801326274871826,
0.3724015951156616,
-0.361915647983551,
0.8942176103591919,
0.17032670974731445,
-0.004051256459206343,
-0.07273457199335098,
-0.06659935414791107,
-0.46952471137046814,
-0.2676032483577728,
-0.5351554751396179,
-0.6554690003395081,
0.42868879437446594,
-0.0009842183208093047,
0.7181886434555054,
0.4124153256416321,
0.41946467757225037,
0.263129860162735,
-0.4829528331756592,
0.03146452456712723,
-0.38618242740631104,
0.08516082167625427,
-0.27801430225372314,
-0.9027404189109802,
-0.15929311513900757,
-0.157905712723732,
0.7342104911804199,
1.0185935497283936,
0.13211564719676971,
0.16820915043354034,
0.037175942212343216,
0.7080654501914978,
-0.9340304732322693,
0.02506410889327526,
-0.6774040460586548,
-0.11889203637838364,
-0.18909241259098053,
-0.05316438898444176,
-0.6153544187545776,
-0.37829455733299255,
0.23713107407093048,
-0.15077482163906097,
0.051268789917230606,
0.19173358380794525,
0.9812760353088379,
0.372461199760437,
-0.5449088215827942,
-0.28341707587242126,
-0.861078143119812,
1.0796433687210083,
-1.0551968812942505,
0.34214767813682556,
0.3054044544696808,
0.25288787484169006,
-0.20420849323272705,
-0.20557883381843567,
-0.6703196167945862,
-0.15291596949100494,
-0.19095537066459656,
0.1733272820711136,
-0.3488422930240631,
0.1073019728064537,
0.33624404668807983,
0.3507674038410187,
-0.583012044429779,
0.39713728427886963,
-0.23302385210990906,
0.14527495205402374,
0.5923953652381897,
0.09393568336963654,
0.1501733958721161,
-0.6575741171836853,
-0.19721731543540955,
0.3145798146724701,
-0.8407013416290283,
-0.0053571900352835655,
0.342157781124115,
0.4635346531867981,
-0.16064241528511047,
0.683070719242096,
-0.042264919728040695,
0.9160448312759399,
0.05171527341008186,
-0.30201083421707153,
0.03697315230965614,
-0.5092490315437317,
-0.5421056747436523,
0.1317140907049179,
0.7578798532485962,
0.11287195235490799,
0.34516918659210205,
-0.27863049507141113,
0.025944847613573074,
0.08594377338886261,
0.08184795081615448,
-0.7260968685150146,
0.2811836898326874,
0.170089989900589,
-0.49973195791244507,
-0.08703131228685379,
-0.1297067254781723,
-0.8560265898704529,
-0.5895847082138062,
-0.30594244599342346,
0.3985101282596588,
-0.34083154797554016,
-0.48739323019981384,
0.022816583514213562,
-0.009930822998285294,
0.6761717796325684,
0.01953761652112007,
-0.9616364240646362,
0.2319999486207962,
0.8166787028312683,
0.8357491493225098,
-0.18855993449687958,
-0.13049833476543427,
-0.05113110691308975,
0.11829102039337158,
-0.4670843780040741,
0.7551852464675903,
-0.7049023509025574,
-0.3868107497692108,
0.14742924273014069,
-0.20046508312225342,
-0.3072842061519623,
-0.7654715180397034,
0.7815245985984802,
-0.5624338388442993,
0.032132476568222046,
-0.06589414179325104,
-0.7174704074859619,
-0.21874438226222992,
0.25366634130477905,
-0.7019545435905457,
0.856950044631958,
-0.06558148562908173,
-0.9566400647163391,
0.4174960255622864,
-0.5541548132896423,
-0.4122408330440521,
-0.01288848090916872,
-0.15332862734794617,
-0.35981419682502747,
0.3094373047351837,
0.05720020830631256,
0.44798919558525085,
-0.6560672521591187,
0.5227951407432556,
-0.3030683100223541,
-0.48076146841049194,
0.24079369008541107,
-0.5198295712471008,
0.86788010597229,
0.047652050852775574,
-0.24880245327949524,
0.1984022855758667,
-0.8730736374855042,
-0.15491944551467896,
0.12924155592918396,
-0.14521174132823944,
-0.4896901249885559,
-0.07118920981884003,
0.021294130012392998,
-0.005887111648917198,
-0.10445360094308853,
-0.6104093194007874,
0.2343631237745285,
-0.8817140460014343,
0.46691930294036865,
0.48747533559799194,
-0.029038824141025543,
0.6006484627723694,
-0.07869035005569458,
0.5133711099624634,
-0.347185879945755,
-0.04342728108167648,
-0.13705025613307953,
-0.5516909956932068,
-0.7428919672966003,
-0.2923220694065094,
0.5043873190879822,
0.48337796330451965,
-0.48022714257240295,
0.3718695342540741,
-0.37708741426467896,
-0.39589422941207886,
-0.8035753965377808,
0.17622779309749603,
0.2933291494846344,
0.26670652627944946,
0.1402057558298111,
0.27491796016693115,
-0.8686837553977966,
-1.1357852220535278,
-0.40354034304618835,
-0.11310713738203049,
-0.12595683336257935,
0.03888856619596481,
0.6192180514335632,
-0.3859747350215912,
1.3660399913787842,
-0.21977603435516357,
-0.10368608683347702,
-0.9019278287887573,
0.3369523882865906,
0.7073476314544678,
0.23766730725765228,
0.5336613655090332,
-1.0321836471557617,
-0.48711639642715454,
-0.0772002786397934,
-0.7041399478912354,
-0.24571122229099274,
-0.31074100732803345,
-0.042032640427351,
0.5524835586547852,
0.22313982248306274,
-0.6241123676300049,
0.5557916164398193,
0.6450799703598022,
-0.25543463230133057,
0.670198380947113,
0.1296921819448471,
-0.060219790786504745,
-0.932950496673584,
0.1874382197856903,
0.16266672313213348,
-0.06881575286388397,
-0.8624433875083923,
0.118018239736557,
-0.16263854503631592,
0.17655906081199646,
-0.18235963582992554,
0.6905499696731567,
-0.36153528094291687,
-0.0858677327632904,
-0.39069893956184387,
0.04250481352210045,
-0.11443601548671722,
0.2557434141635895,
0.12320603430271149,
0.6436710953712463,
0.5029032230377197,
-0.38564133644104004,
-0.09295491129159927,
0.19012492895126343,
-0.38866326212882996,
0.2858342230319977,
-0.8313893675804138,
-0.21548263728618622,
-0.04035351052880287,
0.12440431863069534,
-1.0555319786071777,
-0.23044319450855255,
-0.07219845056533813,
-0.26688310503959656,
0.4928155243396759,
-0.25227847695350647,
-0.4788993000984192,
-0.26667550206184387,
-0.15374647080898285,
0.22205784916877747,
0.538494348526001,
-0.4470951557159424,
0.8161090016365051,
0.2230214774608612,
-0.015731412917375565,
-0.6724032759666443,
-0.8673146367073059,
0.232550710439682,
-0.22639796137809753,
-0.5168406963348389,
0.09944086521863937,
0.0869869515299797,
-0.5333340167999268,
-0.13004443049430847,
-0.2711161971092224,
-0.26495349407196045,
0.048228614032268524,
0.4333961308002472,
0.4458025395870209,
-0.1806117296218872,
-0.11532522737979889,
-0.07634227722883224,
-0.21203628182411194,
0.06060211732983589,
-0.03350061550736427,
0.5275161862373352,
-0.14930492639541626,
-0.42398297786712646,
-0.381860613822937,
0.33101990818977356,
0.3982458710670471,
-0.0444105863571167,
1.0899494886398315,
0.5764743685722351,
-0.32488855719566345,
-0.05843965336680412,
-0.8339554667472839,
0.013484078459441662,
-0.38088977336883545,
0.22026066482067108,
-0.391943097114563,
-0.9212416410446167,
0.43729445338249207,
-0.10758476704359055,
-0.15377816557884216,
0.37929433584213257,
0.6390501260757446,
0.1392512321472168,
0.8626934885978699,
0.8343172073364258,
-0.26328033208847046,
0.19653134047985077,
-0.417235791683197,
0.7016749978065491,
-0.832247257232666,
-0.06566838175058365,
-0.5068601369857788,
-0.1088639572262764,
-0.9519641995429993,
-0.19198130071163177,
0.12483569979667664,
0.19535928964614868,
-0.08404853194952011,
0.2658196985721588,
-0.13526929914951324,
0.509002149105072,
0.4934048354625702,
-0.1839185655117035,
0.39265578985214233,
-0.32411128282546997,
0.17324043810367584,
-0.10183172672986984,
-0.7618032097816467,
-0.6780490875244141,
1.0506986379623413,
0.2769671678543091,
0.7129940986633301,
0.18010593950748444,
0.6706107258796692,
0.10947183519601822,
0.2389695793390274,
-0.8667639493942261,
0.45999667048454285,
-0.028873218223452568,
-0.8274732828140259,
-0.13635358214378357,
-0.4001370668411255,
-0.9420696496963501,
0.32973960041999817,
-0.30466482043266296,
-0.7987277507781982,
0.16702735424041748,
-0.05117274820804596,
-0.3724344074726105,
0.3863937556743622,
-0.8152613639831543,
0.8045799732208252,
0.11336932331323624,
-0.6357262134552002,
-0.1400473415851593,
-0.6946924924850464,
0.7071957588195801,
-0.1270446926355362,
0.23633305728435516,
-0.08900890499353409,
0.13328342139720917,
0.6426282525062561,
-0.00025032629491761327,
1.0400872230529785,
-0.008719663135707378,
-0.26528042554855347,
0.4085502326488495,
-0.0130102364346385,
0.21536971628665924,
-0.08961287885904312,
-0.43130967020988464,
0.3747338652610779,
0.07605775445699692,
-0.5783237814903259,
-0.7422195672988892,
0.5518934726715088,
-0.6275249123573303,
-0.5042982697486877,
-0.31121087074279785,
-0.5160704851150513,
-0.09413517266511917,
0.10606666654348373,
0.22021973133087158,
0.42531535029411316,
-0.05986406281590462,
0.24483522772789001,
0.44531795382499695,
-0.27912336587905884,
0.5130891799926758,
0.42761215567588806,
-0.19940662384033203,
0.018135152757167816,
0.7373102307319641,
0.17658481001853943,
0.41125980019569397,
0.5490549802780151,
0.38166168332099915,
-0.40592044591903687,
-0.8319938778877258,
-0.19935685396194458,
0.35788100957870483,
-0.5203643441200256,
-0.09625411033630371,
-0.6093499660491943,
-0.363655149936676,
-0.38575440645217896,
-0.18928396701812744,
-0.360591322183609,
-0.20650118589401245,
0.19274310767650604,
0.03970405459403992,
-0.012427509762346745,
0.8986753225326538,
0.07738349586725235,
0.260172575712204,
-0.6534439325332642,
0.3570145070552826,
0.15744204819202423,
0.2093680202960968,
0.0561770536005497,
-0.7607089877128601,
-0.10778158903121948,
-0.08725858479738235,
-0.09075760841369629,
-0.8085793256759644,
0.39809727668762207,
0.17699645459651947,
0.5299308896064758,
0.5458065867424011,
0.12918305397033691,
0.7285869121551514,
-0.4506530463695526,
0.7888083457946777,
0.10242919623851776,
-0.9376255869865417,
0.5139222741127014,
-0.2901827394962311,
0.31248021125793457,
0.4311513304710388,
0.5771253108978271,
-0.37170132994651794,
-0.45797282457351685,
-0.4370381236076355,
-0.9251083135604858,
0.4334971606731415,
0.3237338364124298,
-0.036014750599861145,
-0.02118367701768875,
0.31636619567871094,
0.2428799420595169,
0.247052863240242,
-0.8867721557617188,
-0.21438927948474884,
0.1659342646598816,
-0.1296704113483429,
0.0317005030810833,
-0.5600427985191345,
0.20583580434322357,
-0.2820580303668976,
0.582611620426178,
-0.17500460147857666,
0.20624534785747528,
0.11451886594295502,
-0.148220956325531,
0.06741306930780411,
0.6369211077690125,
0.37938392162323,
0.7721278071403503,
-0.3688795268535614,
0.10979428142309189,
0.3476913273334503,
-0.1967536360025406,
0.03850198909640312,
-0.12658452987670898,
-0.33536097407341003,
-0.08945880085229874,
0.9440546035766602,
0.9938283562660217,
0.31303226947784424,
-0.8025475144386292,
0.4418466091156006,
0.19474293291568756,
0.12658898532390594,
-0.24647848308086395,
-0.041107796132564545,
0.018645459786057472,
0.23549331724643707,
0.4226451516151428,
0.19710512459278107,
0.18514569103717804,
-0.6797865033149719,
-0.07519857585430145,
0.5031659007072449,
-0.24306350946426392,
-0.4524070918560028,
0.38501307368278503,
-0.038240429013967514,
-0.28565138578414917,
0.35868993401527405,
-0.38918745517730713,
-0.5407494306564331,
0.4770021140575409,
0.8082460761070251,
0.7981164455413818,
-0.0958554819226265,
0.05750228092074394,
0.5117863416671753,
0.37756016850471497,
-0.033006247133016586,
0.054140884429216385,
0.04654362052679062,
-0.8703271150588989,
-1.0247418880462646,
-0.8729881644248962,
-0.49240121245384216,
0.19964668154716492,
-0.7818372845649719,
0.13479658961296082,
-0.20605960488319397,
-0.019848715513944626,
-0.029387861490249634,
0.0931519865989685,
-0.5024920701980591,
-0.030591195449233055,
0.2325722724199295,
0.9129745364189148,
-1.0209606885910034,
0.7473369240760803,
0.4844997525215149,
-0.3104357123374939,
-0.608020544052124,
0.1670224368572235,
0.03507368639111519,
-0.6512581706047058,
0.8678756356239319,
0.3066155016422272,
-0.26755255460739136,
-0.1250809133052826,
-0.47694462537765503,
-0.6896739602088928,
0.6364935040473938,
0.4332844913005829,
-0.5448033213615417,
-0.09316136687994003,
0.24875704944133759,
0.6766541004180908,
-0.16464240849018097,
0.6727334856987,
1.0552904605865479,
0.5927603840827942,
0.14603526890277863,
-0.8780174851417542,
-0.006097016390413046,
-0.19785812497138977,
0.06509912759065628,
0.18880514800548553,
-0.4833243489265442,
0.4736303389072418,
-0.3406411409378052,
-0.24985170364379883,
0.22813476622104645,
0.6744445562362671,
0.2655947208404541,
0.2545945942401886,
0.41812747716903687,
0.40511831641197205,
0.41643983125686646,
-0.06702932715415955,
1.210140347480774,
-0.06785745918750763,
0.18130053579807281,
1.1255640983581543,
-0.49908027052879333,
1.1464412212371826,
0.6181622743606567,
-0.4033692479133606,
0.46362626552581787,
0.3386651575565338,
0.003559175645932555,
0.20861755311489105,
0.11675059050321579,
-0.07548234611749649,
-0.3907480835914612,
-0.5005229711532593,
-0.0323106087744236,
0.8411714434623718,
0.20984648168087006,
-0.026796190068125725,
-0.243464857339859,
-0.07033604383468628,
-0.03910021856427193,
0.3070763349533081,
-0.09768112003803253,
0.7451777458190918,
0.013914809562265873,
-0.5197049975395203,
0.766703188419342,
-0.25289103388786316,
0.9960882067680359,
-0.7462209463119507,
0.047616831958293915,
-0.0769270807504654,
0.16245298087596893,
-0.32732319831848145,
-0.7337057590484619,
0.7106573581695557,
0.24716266989707947,
-0.29342886805534363,
-0.0273646991699934,
0.6872227787971497,
-0.24697111546993256,
-0.585210382938385,
0.6516615748405457,
0.40988460183143616,
0.08525626361370087,
0.015756847336888313,
-0.4804512858390808,
0.2356870025396347,
0.005238454323261976,
-0.21838882565498352,
0.374449759721756,
0.23038026690483093,
0.10757560282945633,
0.809230625629425,
0.38897424936294556,
0.3645067811012268,
0.09011177718639374,
0.32076144218444824,
0.5471275448799133,
-0.5950173139572144,
-0.11119066178798676,
-1.1352518796920776,
0.3361518979072571,
-0.18242573738098145,
-0.06573566049337387,
0.9430411458015442,
0.5335743427276611,
0.6424733996391296,
-0.02973604016005993,
0.7917788624763489,
-0.04776610806584358,
0.6047496795654297,
-0.5431257486343384,
0.5951167345046997,
-0.426988422870636,
0.10261153429746628,
-0.21296341717243195,
-0.9249628782272339,
-0.4189808666706085,
0.5821199417114258,
-0.5996229648590088,
-0.07761866599321365,
0.5478966236114502,
0.7413279414176941,
0.07353862375020981,
0.15391390025615692,
0.3922867178916931,
0.47233617305755615,
0.27308377623558044,
0.47267162799835205,
0.942276120185852,
-0.42202866077423096,
0.4347190856933594,
-0.059942033141851425,
-0.21134710311889648,
-0.06613364070653915,
-0.9481921195983887,
-1.2020208835601807,
-0.3323158323764801,
-0.22733533382415771,
0.10009150952100754,
-0.0629277378320694,
0.9939792156219482,
0.6932251453399658,
-1.1048099994659424,
-0.32741889357566833,
-0.21609900891780853,
0.301395982503891,
-0.11366970837116241,
-0.2690063714981079,
0.3658318817615509,
-0.37981462478637695,
-0.9719232320785522,
0.5212959051132202,
0.3613641858100891,
-0.21318453550338745,
-0.3152863085269928,
0.10508423298597336,
-0.5643301606178284,
0.3140464127063751,
0.6383777260780334,
0.17175671458244324,
-1.0256836414337158,
-0.017321452498435974,
-0.15167729556560516,
0.11970292031764984,
0.045327723026275635,
0.664982795715332,
-0.7090340256690979,
0.31414082646369934,
0.539202868938446,
0.8866165280342102,
0.2811942398548126,
-0.054801300168037415,
0.4955907464027405,
-0.6656622290611267,
0.2613358795642853,
0.032437749207019806,
0.3632785677909851,
0.40969008207321167,
-0.013446493074297905,
0.6104860901832581,
0.14074890315532684,
-0.5082526803016663,
-1.0201584100723267,
0.3414163291454315,
-0.8018794059753418,
-0.2572568953037262,
1.20259690284729,
-0.008352894335985184,
-0.3973010778427124,
-0.20944282412528992,
-0.18928012251853943,
0.2850334942340851,
-0.14350004494190216,
0.6821849346160889,
0.5142455697059631,
-0.11045820266008377,
-0.09425845742225647,
-0.8580305576324463,
0.24362966418266296,
0.536516010761261,
-0.5984788537025452,
0.09958583116531372,
-0.02111075259745121,
-0.02413993328809738,
0.4135284423828125,
0.22514241933822632,
0.22641515731811523,
-0.2492256909608841,
-0.009218825958669186,
0.030742473900318146,
0.17034249007701874,
-0.20248262584209442,
-0.5146661400794983,
0.24941985309123993,
0.04386679083108902,
0.08243949711322784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02935v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02935v1
|
Enabling Patient-side Disease Prediction via the Integration of Patient Narratives
| 2024-05-05T13:54:02 | 2024-05-05T13:54:02 |
Zhixiang Su, Yinan Zhang, Jiazheng Jing, Jie Xiao, Zhiqi Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Disease prediction holds considerable significance in modern healthcare,
because of its crucial role in facilitating early intervention and implementing
effective prevention measures. However, most recent disease prediction
approaches heavily rely on laboratory test outcomes (e.g., blood tests and
medical imaging from X-rays). Gaining access to such data for precise disease
prediction is often a complex task from the standpoint of a patient and is
always only available post-patient consultation. To make disease prediction
available from patient-side, we propose Personalized Medical Disease Prediction
(PoMP), which predicts diseases using patient health narratives including
textual descriptions and demographic information. By applying PoMP, patients
can gain a clearer comprehension of their conditions, empowering them to
directly seek appropriate medical specialists and thereby reducing the time
spent navigating healthcare communication to locate suitable doctors. We
conducted extensive experiments using real-world data from Haodf to showcase
the effectiveness of PoMP.
|
[
-0.32513296604156494,
-0.42869409918785095,
0.8422062397003174,
-0.11217577010393143,
-0.4598863422870636,
0.14110353589057922,
0.26942896842956543,
-0.6354591846466064,
0.8402212262153625,
0.8183994293212891,
-0.6647923588752747,
-0.6805093288421631,
-0.4046771824359894,
-0.1640009880065918,
0.04934856668114662,
1.022326946258545,
0.0461549386382103,
0.4085440933704376,
-0.669090986251831,
0.19307614862918854,
-0.4552801549434662,
-0.5563212633132935,
-0.4891844391822815,
-0.4911242127418518,
0.5978012681007385,
0.5487387180328369,
0.8816074132919312,
0.6898679137229919,
0.5352013111114502,
0.09763635694980621,
0.27030372619628906,
0.027904167771339417,
-0.01888314262032509,
0.4481677711009979,
-0.15059927105903625,
-0.37428510189056396,
-0.5477420687675476,
0.129961296916008,
0.010043478570878506,
0.8984979391098022,
-0.2720777988433838,
-0.009679059498012066,
-0.33968862891197205,
0.5045620203018188,
-0.13694018125534058,
0.039659563452005386,
0.031985849142074585,
0.772850751876831,
-0.4693096876144409,
-0.649282693862915,
-0.02383226901292801,
-0.192742720246315,
0.605890154838562,
-0.587731659412384,
0.21059678494930267,
0.2594525218009949,
0.45322906970977783,
0.2830890715122223,
-0.4851946234703064,
-0.07856824994087219,
-0.6884722709655762,
0.28483131527900696,
-0.5965123176574707,
0.0928061380982399,
0.9092565774917603,
0.9943010807037354,
-0.3599925935268402,
-0.779015064239502,
-0.19512520730495453,
0.036886975169181824,
-0.46606606245040894,
0.6016101241111755,
0.1338227540254593,
0.1236846074461937,
-0.23601235449314117,
0.4294320344924927,
-0.5441763997077942,
-0.011863491497933865,
-0.30397897958755493,
-0.1917397528886795,
0.8511949181556702,
0.7101498246192932,
0.41499412059783936,
-0.0783018097281456,
-0.536041259765625,
0.452756404876709,
-0.5851291418075562,
0.06887836754322052,
-0.028290880843997,
0.009282408282160759,
-0.417912095785141,
0.4379825294017792,
-0.2393072545528412,
0.6067139506340027,
0.41944363713264465,
-0.3168465197086334,
0.3899650275707245,
-0.20571358501911163,
-0.0025525358505547047,
0.4025184214115143,
0.6386006474494934,
0.37411293387413025,
-0.30501583218574524,
-0.21760527789592743,
0.15392784774303436,
-0.2299002856016159,
0.20792235434055328,
-0.9252979755401611,
-0.5768835544586182,
0.5646732449531555,
-0.7253760099411011,
-0.42315950989723206,
-0.03777635097503662,
-1.1322678327560425,
-1.1970415115356445,
-0.051022034138441086,
0.13573116064071655,
-0.33646801114082336,
-0.10549893975257874,
0.2718442380428314,
-0.20688346028327942,
-0.36585673689842224,
0.5089481472969055,
-0.6038702130317688,
0.2611594498157501,
0.4583781063556671,
0.5625288486480713,
-0.0814879834651947,
-0.14788012206554413,
-0.9413054585456848,
0.5535479187965393,
-0.12076365947723389,
1.000601053237915,
-0.8431406021118164,
-0.6201480627059937,
-0.028550468385219574,
-0.24077658355236053,
0.05450491979718208,
-0.5154566764831543,
0.3217945992946625,
-0.0861763209104538,
0.43519654870033264,
-0.186875581741333,
-0.4595777094364166,
0.11052482575178146,
-0.029432697221636772,
-0.5816172957420349,
0.22183017432689667,
0.5150801539421082,
-1.2283903360366821,
0.3603048324584961,
-0.3677828311920166,
-0.8333329558372498,
0.38195857405662537,
-0.7258734703063965,
-0.7947658896446228,
0.39081451296806335,
0.2977251708507538,
0.6290190815925598,
-0.4397360384464264,
0.26265889406204224,
-0.40100520849227905,
-0.23948176205158234,
0.07790449261665344,
0.3340097665786743,
0.16972365975379944,
0.07154673337936401,
-0.10516077280044556,
0.32613807916641235,
-0.4774032235145569,
-0.46118664741516113,
0.18770325183868408,
0.1918032169342041,
-0.36198925971984863,
0.2818315029144287,
-0.6319687366485596,
0.08316788822412491,
0.00591660151258111,
-0.3534737825393677,
0.3443041741847992,
-0.47916632890701294,
0.21406640112400055,
0.5243867039680481,
0.30515727400779724,
0.4313424229621887,
-0.6612061858177185,
1.1034431457519531,
0.19170816242694855,
0.49071139097213745,
-0.306851327419281,
-1.1501762866973877,
0.15724262595176697,
-0.31600531935691833,
0.11379387229681015,
0.510425329208374,
-0.702902615070343,
0.11732227355241776,
-0.12731783092021942,
-0.5095940828323364,
-0.4327513873577118,
-0.25532233715057373,
0.21234488487243652,
0.9993826150894165,
0.2875925600528717,
-0.4255240857601166,
-0.6622549295425415,
-0.5423035025596619,
-0.14291448891162872,
-0.33543476462364197,
-0.35015869140625,
0.5123427510261536,
0.05577516928315163,
-0.4212389886379242,
0.8858268857002258,
-0.801580548286438,
-0.6240894198417664,
-0.6026200652122498,
-0.02800936810672283,
0.27958187460899353,
0.2524639368057251,
0.40066081285476685,
-0.8563851118087769,
-0.6647824645042419,
0.24666273593902588,
-0.7390691041946411,
-0.1985979527235031,
0.11060117185115814,
-0.08853064477443695,
-0.2656961977481842,
0.14897984266281128,
-0.23078466951847076,
0.9608885645866394,
0.7967663407325745,
-0.7888204455375671,
0.4820895195007324,
-0.6372832655906677,
0.01922648400068283,
-1.0354496240615845,
-0.1538582295179367,
-0.002972489921376109,
-0.43101003766059875,
-0.6402972936630249,
-0.5021207332611084,
-0.18326601386070251,
-0.4881173074245453,
-0.12431969493627548,
0.7700241804122925,
-0.1502094268798828,
0.0466294139623642,
0.042719703167676926,
-0.3567742109298706,
0.0842166468501091,
-0.09594690054655075,
0.15705132484436035,
0.285908043384552,
0.5324013233184814,
-0.2546677589416504,
0.17077235877513885,
0.4085119664669037,
-0.4970211088657379,
0.680753231048584,
-0.48083657026290894,
0.006165069993585348,
-0.14569225907325745,
0.7291820049285889,
-0.6112703084945679,
-0.6598168611526489,
0.5211802124977112,
-0.6989771723747253,
0.2577613294124603,
0.1099892258644104,
-0.2403908371925354,
-0.5200226306915283,
-0.2656780481338501,
0.3687261641025543,
0.6030569672584534,
-0.3002648651599884,
0.9459423422813416,
0.7354417443275452,
-0.3391580283641815,
-0.09227196127176285,
-0.8930054306983948,
-0.05384611338376999,
-0.29910925030708313,
-0.650421679019928,
0.5742769837379456,
-0.02608787640929222,
-0.09478214383125305,
-0.07596884667873383,
-0.0049085128121078014,
-0.1266244500875473,
-0.07160115987062454,
0.814265787601471,
0.3657931685447693,
0.005134320817887783,
0.40830111503601074,
0.14441415667533875,
-0.45712941884994507,
-0.22129376232624054,
-0.19641153514385223,
0.41719183325767517,
0.3576144278049469,
-0.4838293194770813,
-0.8032673001289368,
0.741636335849762,
0.531710147857666,
-0.37816089391708374,
0.8122066855430603,
0.39230936765670776,
-0.6048426628112793,
0.14863039553165436,
-0.44267916679382324,
-0.23250341415405273,
-0.3763910233974457,
0.08082442730665207,
-0.30862370133399963,
-0.34144508838653564,
0.6658085584640503,
0.02360459603369236,
-0.33336174488067627,
0.20376357436180115,
0.44344109296798706,
-0.4465720057487488,
1.4641544818878174,
0.5559365749359131,
0.07806621491909027,
0.2218461036682129,
0.05608599632978439,
0.12772881984710693,
-0.4115322530269623,
-0.6605800986289978,
-0.15750399231910706,
-0.37417587637901306,
-0.4716407358646393,
-0.4288766384124756,
0.6099425554275513,
-0.1168900728225708,
-0.1984996795654297,
0.07895413041114807,
-0.6514269113540649,
-0.049378640949726105,
0.3640299439430237,
0.5499289631843567,
0.42222946882247925,
-0.1680677831172943,
-0.1704012006521225,
-0.21572047472000122,
-0.5333814024925232,
-0.13356661796569824,
1.0688741207122803,
0.4146884083747864,
0.58792644739151,
-0.2483866959810257,
0.9788351058959961,
0.5624071359634399,
0.4805848002433777,
-0.4083060920238495,
0.108299121260643,
-0.40815824270248413,
-0.5563660264015198,
0.0006417577969841659,
-0.3637942671775818,
-1.1871905326843262,
-0.259445458650589,
-0.1663658618927002,
-0.7014666199684143,
0.3803088366985321,
0.40278008580207825,
-1.0006861686706543,
0.14294952154159546,
-0.7096019983291626,
0.8320717215538025,
-0.3204571604728699,
-0.08574903756380081,
-0.06811276078224182,
-0.9707295298576355,
-0.14349117875099182,
-0.06809547543525696,
0.45816898345947266,
-0.2467230260372162,
-0.2759271562099457,
0.6114975810050964,
-0.5846377015113831,
0.8071979284286499,
-0.34771451354026794,
0.27999213337898254,
-0.09039823710918427,
-0.03438887372612953,
0.47812578082084656,
0.4479147493839264,
-0.2022809535264969,
0.0054077100940048695,
0.152964249253273,
-0.6377543210983276,
-0.3551630973815918,
0.6742473840713501,
-0.61127108335495,
-0.6277456879615784,
-0.5324761271476746,
-0.29244446754455566,
-0.59276282787323,
-0.060651302337646484,
0.37366950511932373,
0.4737708866596222,
0.051085345447063446,
-0.38052576780319214,
0.2671726942062378,
-0.5145284533500671,
-0.23616106808185577,
0.47576117515563965,
-0.48685064911842346,
-0.5189563632011414,
0.7288965582847595,
0.0510580949485302,
0.05202513188123703,
0.6228199005126953,
0.954194962978363,
0.023631442338228226,
-0.6606475114822388,
-0.20028266310691833,
0.18753387033939362,
-0.457504540681839,
-0.3493340313434601,
-0.6470587253570557,
0.12393797934055328,
-0.5257542729377747,
-0.3187902569770813,
-0.012729069218039513,
0.10676630586385727,
-0.2177858054637909,
0.004969323985278606,
0.13569258153438568,
0.7402222156524658,
0.13641683757305145,
0.4789348542690277,
-0.6685711145401001,
0.43163472414016724,
0.09340286254882812,
0.1868765652179718,
-0.4539217948913574,
-0.3851725161075592,
-0.2755747437477112,
-0.05115683376789093,
-0.08012256771326065,
-1.158469557762146,
0.6651021838188171,
0.1063440814614296,
0.5962603092193604,
0.7419872283935547,
0.39749056100845337,
0.49362602829933167,
-0.42886826395988464,
0.3069781959056854,
0.553630530834198,
-0.55107182264328,
0.8732393980026245,
-0.22515206038951874,
0.2324952334165573,
0.5552846193313599,
0.4888058006763458,
-0.5188320875167847,
0.05601595714688301,
-0.5895503163337708,
-0.37895703315734863,
0.3811107575893402,
-0.1973387449979782,
-0.2829299569129944,
0.08089633285999298,
0.23152659833431244,
0.7123433351516724,
0.20634856820106506,
0.1367260217666626,
-0.11943689733743668,
-0.33586105704307556,
-0.30945080518722534,
-0.46878862380981445,
-0.10334080457687378,
-0.15464186668395996,
-0.4430185556411743,
0.16652631759643555,
-0.14839808642864227,
0.4630889594554901,
0.5748642086982727,
0.38207122683525085,
-0.3949447274208069,
-0.12037092447280884,
0.27389538288116455,
0.7049494981765747,
-0.4015578329563141,
0.24841217696666718,
-0.008027393370866776,
-0.47203630208969116,
-0.3294174075126648,
0.28130391240119934,
0.307256281375885,
0.2014787197113037,
0.39313599467277527,
0.5816755890846252,
0.1393701136112213,
-0.75819993019104,
0.6991134285926819,
-0.11842343956232071,
0.12033310532569885,
-0.5634145736694336,
-0.218580424785614,
0.1968020796775818,
0.40959152579307556,
0.2622010111808777,
0.04920267313718796,
0.2898724377155304,
-0.5039442181587219,
0.2081492692232132,
-0.04516150802373886,
-0.8462985157966614,
-0.684245765209198,
0.8135625123977661,
0.3620404601097107,
-0.3747822046279907,
0.45607611536979675,
-0.030023243278265,
-0.3413048982620239,
0.6684641242027283,
0.4228685796260834,
0.38270413875579834,
-0.6458699107170105,
0.45080751180648804,
0.027999239042401314,
-0.28984421491622925,
0.05250279977917671,
0.16142432391643524,
0.3866048753261566,
-0.10371779650449753,
-0.4952843487262726,
-0.42568886280059814,
-0.5827140808105469,
-0.02083485946059227,
-0.3981902301311493,
0.7185972332954407,
-0.46403828263282776,
-0.3044251501560211,
0.21998398005962372,
0.1874595582485199,
-0.5425475835800171,
0.4261007308959961,
0.6416476368904114,
1.0072120428085327,
-0.6828444600105286,
1.0255006551742554,
0.8647968173027039,
-0.34651193022727966,
-0.3166722357273102,
0.18752841651439667,
0.058470942080020905,
-0.9139916300773621,
0.1626388430595398,
0.5325195789337158,
0.5083312392234802,
-0.3207560181617737,
-0.08904265612363815,
-0.40213292837142944,
1.2018307447433472,
0.6017372608184814,
-0.5818361043930054,
-0.28063949942588806,
0.10570964217185974,
0.6023974418640137,
-0.7401900887489319,
0.07757604122161865,
0.35122546553611755,
0.4737015962600708,
0.44145771861076355,
-0.9004327058792114,
0.12603799998760223,
-0.14383333921432495,
-0.3710312247276306,
0.27989503741264343,
-0.2003999948501587,
0.8567145466804504,
-0.8330232501029968,
-0.1650264859199524,
0.16821852326393127,
0.5062532424926758,
0.06438794732093811,
1.223443627357483,
0.363224595785141,
0.4083753526210785,
0.9029022455215454,
0.09286641329526901,
1.531538486480713,
-0.23689548671245575,
-0.0574486218392849,
1.228262186050415,
-0.3477090001106262,
0.6237831711769104,
0.22698542475700378,
-0.3359713554382324,
0.4937666058540344,
0.9121824502944946,
0.2744971811771393,
0.9644892811775208,
0.18380653858184814,
-0.43161410093307495,
-0.35318320989608765,
-0.2383980005979538,
-0.8586995005607605,
0.35300353169441223,
0.39938488602638245,
-0.6548200845718384,
0.1486234813928604,
0.3334026634693146,
-0.04280996695160866,
0.05729443579912186,
-0.37068015336990356,
0.5758869647979736,
-0.10318799316883087,
-0.5425964593887329,
0.08765467256307602,
-0.3636528551578522,
0.5119696855545044,
-0.4911381006240845,
-0.09911701828241348,
-0.37130817770957947,
0.3469110429286957,
-0.5141274333000183,
-0.669549822807312,
0.35584118962287903,
-0.6530259847640991,
-0.17880144715309143,
-0.14380744099617004,
0.9882797598838806,
-0.43552446365356445,
-0.3658585548400879,
0.30901384353637695,
0.7357226014137268,
0.17305892705917358,
-0.35496944189071655,
-0.28803181648254395,
-0.1644182652235031,
-0.13747872412204742,
-0.021987339481711388,
0.6307780146598816,
0.23126301169395447,
-0.016615640372037888,
0.7047543525695801,
0.32944628596305847,
0.27130112051963806,
-0.5388281941413879,
-0.30753761529922485,
0.857994556427002,
-0.6266503930091858,
-0.6920422911643982,
-0.5625771880149841,
0.2769743502140045,
-0.07282377034425735,
-0.25427815318107605,
0.3274596929550171,
0.39536163210868835,
0.34716930985450745,
0.007549885660409927,
0.9849054217338562,
0.29884073138237,
0.8315553665161133,
-0.02570604346692562,
0.9458091855049133,
-0.5716909766197205,
0.1729172170162201,
0.1402660459280014,
0.062466371804475784,
-0.3164309561252594,
0.14503853023052216,
-0.6564439535140991,
-0.14190493524074554,
0.6859986782073975,
0.17095546424388885,
0.13097073137760162,
0.11344242841005325,
0.49746689200401306,
0.11510197073221207,
0.3652787208557129,
0.594092845916748,
0.678192675113678,
0.19711382687091827,
0.28573668003082275,
-0.7151928544044495,
-0.6252917647361755,
-0.6432592868804932,
-0.7289708256721497,
-1.040650725364685,
-0.4573573172092438,
-0.3699108362197876,
-0.3307417035102844,
0.37939637899398804,
0.6169093251228333,
0.7949271202087402,
-0.718877375125885,
0.20255011320114136,
0.08297482132911682,
-0.10012146085500717,
-0.13440442085266113,
-0.049927279353141785,
0.4832717478275299,
0.2916460931301117,
-0.3069045841693878,
0.32323795557022095,
0.42020276188850403,
0.031481411308050156,
-0.13009503483772278,
-0.37588194012641907,
0.3183307945728302,
-0.12615610659122467,
0.13342881202697754,
0.31919053196907043,
-0.3886817693710327,
0.18376782536506653,
-0.03799023479223251,
-0.2199489325284958,
0.21653753519058228,
0.9741629958152771,
-1.3417600393295288,
0.6798954010009766,
0.46065807342529297,
0.5166483521461487,
0.2951854467391968,
-0.00788752268999815,
0.863163411617279,
-0.03693591430783272,
-0.15418027341365814,
0.6501278877258301,
0.2945178151130676,
0.3746015429496765,
-0.6907942295074463,
0.2886797785758972,
0.339489221572876,
-0.34473562240600586,
-0.6247749924659729,
0.061086684465408325,
-0.8247351050376892,
-0.23642827570438385,
0.970207154750824,
-0.498749703168869,
-0.3596815764904022,
-0.5354183316230774,
-0.4193779230117798,
0.2374943643808365,
-0.48581981658935547,
0.8548678159713745,
0.005822537932544947,
-0.7376965880393982,
0.14165401458740234,
-0.6994065046310425,
0.5451938509941101,
0.3610587418079376,
-1.159411907196045,
-0.4365638494491577,
0.06023670360445976,
0.14591321349143982,
-0.08168859034776688,
0.772956371307373,
-0.10596376657485962,
0.38883525133132935,
-0.27585288882255554,
-0.23328155279159546,
-0.4120141863822937,
-0.19750475883483887,
0.1611308455467224,
0.13395000994205475,
-0.4007991552352905,
-0.3512035608291626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02933v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02933v1
|
Relay Decoding: Concatenating Large Language Models for Machine Translation
| 2024-05-05T13:42:25 | 2024-05-05T13:42:25 |
Chengpeng Fu, Xiaocheng Feng, Yichong Huang, Wenshuai Huo, Baohang Li, Hui Wang, Bin Qin, Ting Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Leveraging large language models for machine translation has demonstrated
promising results. However, it does require the large language models to
possess the capability of handling both the source and target languages in
machine translation. When it is challenging to find large models that support
the desired languages, resorting to continuous learning methods becomes a
costly endeavor. To mitigate these expenses, we propose an innovative approach
called RD (Relay Decoding), which entails concatenating two distinct large
models that individually support the source and target languages. By
incorporating a simple mapping layer to facilitate the connection between these
two models and utilizing a limited amount of parallel data for training, we
successfully achieve superior results in the machine translation task.
Experimental results conducted on the Multi30k and WikiMatrix datasets validate
the effectiveness of our proposed method.
|
[
-0.23096707463264465,
-0.4876086711883545,
0.20936036109924316,
0.5419036149978638,
-0.36771854758262634,
0.18757960200309753,
-0.31832531094551086,
-0.4752618670463562,
-0.09593850374221802,
0.7786182165145874,
-0.5217965245246887,
-0.44750547409057617,
-0.750242292881012,
0.3561045825481415,
-0.6182432174682617,
0.8197273015975952,
-0.1717345118522644,
0.21905457973480225,
-0.05825246870517731,
-0.10431932657957077,
-0.7989915609359741,
-0.5614737868309021,
-0.5675147175788879,
-0.3761473298072815,
0.59352707862854,
0.7279955744743347,
0.5379638075828552,
0.3902711272239685,
0.6335764527320862,
0.31815168261528015,
0.23623476922512054,
0.6868381500244141,
-0.3996170163154602,
0.5520957112312317,
-0.08115600049495697,
-0.17853155732154846,
-0.2924029529094696,
-0.2518230974674225,
0.8338709473609924,
0.8543720841407776,
0.09505592286586761,
0.12283290177583694,
0.128740593791008,
0.9187600612640381,
-0.6564010977745056,
0.33134618401527405,
-0.5230668783187866,
-0.14326928555965424,
-0.21345576643943787,
-0.23744092881679535,
-1.022438883781433,
-0.2638586759567261,
-0.11097481846809387,
-0.5363884568214417,
0.11648616939783096,
0.15909218788146973,
0.47113510966300964,
-0.09329432249069214,
-0.6775164008140564,
-0.29786473512649536,
-1.0926392078399658,
0.8158751726150513,
-0.4659964144229889,
0.3651837110519409,
0.44274407625198364,
0.46505656838417053,
-0.02941334806382656,
-0.6947800517082214,
-0.48660141229629517,
-0.18880333006381989,
-0.29762741923332214,
-0.037136904895305634,
-0.32011106610298157,
-0.04085632041096687,
0.09851229935884476,
0.055332645773887634,
-0.6577589511871338,
0.10970644652843475,
-0.36313045024871826,
0.03695065528154373,
0.4896564185619354,
0.14541316032409668,
0.27739575505256653,
0.028876079246401787,
-0.44547033309936523,
-0.2668861150741577,
-0.7801591753959656,
-0.34691378474235535,
0.0946858748793602,
0.7685868740081787,
-0.2193305492401123,
0.5862100124359131,
-0.20600083470344543,
0.8425016403198242,
-0.1351105123758316,
0.15973129868507385,
0.05660860240459442,
-0.574177086353302,
-0.17164185643196106,
0.09536106139421463,
0.7539158463478088,
0.1559717357158661,
0.20854459702968597,
-0.4252144992351532,
-0.14927861094474792,
-0.01132396049797535,
0.15705066919326782,
-0.6672923564910889,
-0.10830775648355484,
0.08295220881700516,
-0.3465997576713562,
-0.05090571939945221,
-0.012467575259506702,
-0.6103297472000122,
-0.11204247176647186,
-0.29733824729919434,
0.39744073152542114,
-0.3989854156970978,
-0.2308996170759201,
0.3805961608886719,
-0.1264566034078598,
0.09932760894298553,
0.220468208193779,
-1.0068320035934448,
0.457681268453598,
0.6765804886817932,
0.8937237858772278,
0.19740161299705505,
-0.5517371296882629,
-0.8169200420379639,
0.3612942695617676,
-0.30469241738319397,
0.6411572098731995,
-0.40539148449897766,
-0.11720049381256104,
0.17062772810459137,
0.03897480666637421,
-0.15922974050045013,
-0.4750538170337677,
0.3624580502510071,
-0.8670512437820435,
-0.14318563044071198,
-0.22262564301490784,
-0.35333800315856934,
-0.35761067271232605,
0.05063927546143532,
-0.8813404440879822,
0.707592248916626,
0.4101732075214386,
-0.7439681887626648,
0.03904068470001221,
-0.3629520833492279,
-0.6304512619972229,
0.15344151854515076,
0.2998523414134979,
-0.5650007128715515,
0.16774117946624756,
0.27784812450408936,
0.47213563323020935,
-0.6004108786582947,
0.18108594417572021,
-0.15976150333881378,
-0.16307997703552246,
0.21297800540924072,
-0.23834054172039032,
0.723545253276825,
0.31420162320137024,
-0.11546353995800018,
0.014577175490558147,
-0.4049476683139801,
-0.2093747854232788,
-0.060087431222200394,
-0.28015387058258057,
-0.5639961361885071,
-0.01435308437794447,
0.3721569776535034,
0.29652753472328186,
0.07381013035774231,
-0.4351074695587158,
0.3932933807373047,
-0.12106060236692429,
0.32522687315940857,
0.2643619179725647,
-0.23970070481300354,
0.800825834274292,
-0.19722570478916168,
0.611426591873169,
0.15933072566986084,
-0.1452774852514267,
-0.29520705342292786,
-0.43556344509124756,
-0.7351712584495544,
-0.28725746273994446,
0.47563543915748596,
0.42459866404533386,
-0.9931614995002747,
0.24503476917743683,
-0.3593319058418274,
-0.33224448561668396,
-0.8264921307563782,
0.22145703434944153,
0.5118299126625061,
0.4381260275840759,
0.6286004781723022,
-0.1902664601802826,
-0.9940233826637268,
-0.6952965259552002,
-0.19073118269443512,
0.30622562766075134,
0.010359780862927437,
-0.1924530267715454,
0.5048272609710693,
-0.25364673137664795,
0.7011302709579468,
-0.21863675117492676,
-0.3946986198425293,
-0.8072938919067383,
-0.02735218219459057,
0.23066933453083038,
0.629596471786499,
0.4646610617637634,
-0.785827100276947,
-0.7916549444198608,
0.5698719620704651,
-0.7601578831672668,
0.09291889518499374,
-0.04539922997355461,
-0.1720414012670517,
0.01753954589366913,
0.3405968248844147,
-0.7265498042106628,
0.0528004914522171,
1.0017871856689453,
-0.23574568331241608,
0.538300096988678,
-0.4959111213684082,
0.20029965043067932,
-1.1178644895553589,
0.21738743782043457,
-0.12231778353452682,
-0.4781142771244049,
-0.908201277256012,
0.182671457529068,
0.3393286168575287,
-0.15968924760818481,
-0.41899096965789795,
0.5472310781478882,
-0.7190719842910767,
-0.012389805167913437,
-0.4747721254825592,
-0.03574996441602707,
0.13512560725212097,
0.041552599519491196,
-0.06592198461294174,
0.5514477491378784,
0.32455047965049744,
-0.46835124492645264,
0.6792290806770325,
0.3166837990283966,
-0.4971710741519928,
0.1080205887556076,
-0.4827183187007904,
0.14333954453468323,
-0.19675549864768982,
0.672211229801178,
-0.6633625030517578,
-0.29324501752853394,
0.16102106869220734,
-0.18502472341060638,
0.24899408221244812,
-0.21928660571575165,
-0.5981484055519104,
-0.5255456566810608,
0.0863305851817131,
0.7597872614860535,
0.5551515221595764,
-0.5416027903556824,
0.4106025695800781,
0.3142746686935425,
0.04108431190252304,
-0.499161958694458,
-0.7939386367797852,
0.20727956295013428,
-0.21925638616085052,
-0.6063672304153442,
0.25297895073890686,
0.3152245879173279,
-0.051559753715991974,
-0.06353861093521118,
0.2051551789045334,
-0.1374610811471939,
-0.12808655202388763,
0.05937470495700836,
0.17496620118618011,
-0.14383003115653992,
0.009086382575333118,
0.1395852416753769,
-0.6325860023498535,
-0.34480562806129456,
-0.8220239281654358,
0.6894382238388062,
0.33589479327201843,
-0.25940853357315063,
-0.5396171808242798,
1.120976209640503,
0.7710559368133545,
-0.5735931396484375,
1.1849703788757324,
0.35123389959335327,
-0.38214191794395447,
-0.5920554995536804,
-0.2648438513278961,
-0.19249239563941956,
-0.46420666575431824,
0.4124860167503357,
-0.53886479139328,
-0.8730230331420898,
0.4526492655277252,
-0.18107067048549652,
-0.20476365089416504,
0.22949405014514923,
0.690125048160553,
-0.20753799378871918,
1.009947657585144,
0.896869421005249,
-0.31065061688423157,
0.4261932373046875,
-0.38613829016685486,
0.4916565716266632,
-0.5711034536361694,
-0.30367687344551086,
-0.862542450428009,
-0.32829412817955017,
-0.3671455681324005,
-0.6596145629882812,
0.23470257222652435,
0.13321444392204285,
-0.2953706681728363,
0.7307913303375244,
-0.35161375999450684,
0.35331764817237854,
0.7055183053016663,
0.197602778673172,
0.5901612043380737,
0.21517963707447052,
-0.01864599622786045,
0.016543639823794365,
-0.9928199648857117,
-0.2454332560300827,
0.9634756445884705,
0.24583777785301208,
0.786952793598175,
-0.021857112646102905,
0.3875080645084381,
0.19423173367977142,
0.3441139757633209,
-0.5914493799209595,
0.3451920449733734,
-0.5512285232543945,
-0.39281994104385376,
-0.14675866067409515,
-0.6211362481117249,
-0.9051923751831055,
0.41069403290748596,
-0.1531732678413391,
-0.17727991938591003,
0.20754005014896393,
0.2595917284488678,
0.07154485583305359,
0.2529866397380829,
-0.7518779039382935,
0.8602823615074158,
0.028697077184915543,
0.03282572701573372,
-0.3779892027378082,
-0.6558405160903931,
0.5025513768196106,
-0.14102055132389069,
0.3705935478210449,
0.24464257061481476,
0.308719277381897,
0.3700677156448364,
-0.3534058630466461,
0.7049025297164917,
0.020430218428373337,
0.06873603165149689,
0.06659119576215744,
0.05919728800654411,
0.8162180781364441,
-0.19867545366287231,
-0.19074739515781403,
-0.03869621828198433,
-0.37732794880867004,
-0.6079253554344177,
-0.5684760212898254,
0.6145653128623962,
-0.6355139017105103,
-0.11856383085250854,
-0.24108177423477173,
-0.897985577583313,
-0.05820886418223381,
0.17728406190872192,
0.1980406641960144,
0.3964257538318634,
0.04303455352783203,
0.23690849542617798,
0.4985090494155884,
0.0063305324874818325,
0.2656186819076538,
0.5716732740402222,
-0.1425171047449112,
-0.5441182255744934,
0.8699580430984497,
-0.08599298447370529,
0.46299320459365845,
0.7453383803367615,
-0.07286348938941956,
-0.18190939724445343,
-0.5766011476516724,
-0.3301359713077545,
0.47987478971481323,
-0.4252528250217438,
-0.6044713258743286,
-0.7369404435157776,
-0.29185864329338074,
-0.29182660579681396,
-0.18815496563911438,
-0.5309284329414368,
-0.2667694389820099,
-0.07287497073411942,
0.02145370841026306,
0.3057214617729187,
0.7042306065559387,
-0.12218444794416428,
0.4721897840499878,
-1.2058721780776978,
0.347525417804718,
0.1911672204732895,
-0.09858319163322449,
0.18179799616336823,
-0.3405075967311859,
-0.9457720518112183,
0.24978503584861755,
-0.19892488420009613,
-0.9524168968200684,
0.7038793563842773,
0.19747160375118256,
0.2861565053462982,
0.28750646114349365,
0.3615662753582001,
0.6306781768798828,
-0.8472149968147278,
0.302099347114563,
0.40392082929611206,
-1.047250509262085,
0.48050662875175476,
-0.23295782506465912,
0.24764984846115112,
0.27078884840011597,
0.35643765330314636,
-0.834241509437561,
-0.6285094022750854,
0.0008477105293422937,
-0.8662199378013611,
0.6486459374427795,
0.10219749808311462,
0.1246514841914177,
-0.044836144894361496,
0.05915554240345955,
0.29734230041503906,
0.017356276512145996,
-0.5537029504776001,
-0.020710011944174767,
0.1525527536869049,
-0.30695533752441406,
-0.41916725039482117,
-0.3504827618598938,
-0.29948553442955017,
-0.28829070925712585,
0.2506032884120941,
0.002911422634497285,
0.28288206458091736,
-0.1776401251554489,
-0.2852800786495209,
-0.18780186772346497,
0.07858698815107346,
0.5225781202316284,
0.43287205696105957,
-0.01620216853916645,
0.4098762571811676,
-0.04056079313158989,
-0.39188846945762634,
0.38441649079322815,
-0.030389366671442986,
-0.12489904463291168,
0.24608606100082397,
0.6454930901527405,
0.9121714234352112,
0.33840054273605347,
-0.3659053444862366,
0.30067378282546997,
0.21218831837177277,
-0.13656064867973328,
0.15814566612243652,
-0.28419673442840576,
0.2843155562877655,
0.37079617381095886,
0.4037763774394989,
0.15567640960216522,
-0.17927542328834534,
-0.34548914432525635,
0.37293094396591187,
0.40969404578208923,
-0.09043362736701965,
-0.5261644721031189,
0.6059204339981079,
0.35476210713386536,
-0.2680380046367645,
0.8850151300430298,
0.22049590945243835,
-0.5857515931129456,
0.62873375415802,
1.0323628187179565,
0.960343599319458,
-0.3809574842453003,
0.34630653262138367,
0.3820207715034485,
0.46658462285995483,
-0.4560566842556,
-0.04277431592345238,
-0.15080805122852325,
-0.5954452753067017,
-0.8026381731033325,
-0.47927170991897583,
-0.4584468901157379,
-0.22351360321044922,
-0.685670018196106,
0.20087885856628418,
0.24339470267295837,
0.09013189375400543,
-0.3762325644493103,
-0.0009701985400170088,
-0.6731622815132141,
0.08712441474199295,
-0.07865646481513977,
1.139095664024353,
-1.1067250967025757,
1.3401037454605103,
0.4104557931423187,
-0.2535099387168884,
-0.7035187482833862,
-0.2998470962047577,
-0.4011508524417877,
-0.44780439138412476,
0.8995236158370972,
0.12072023004293442,
-0.029851755127310753,
0.15893107652664185,
-0.21505692601203918,
-0.6373864412307739,
0.9187543392181396,
0.6906595230102539,
-0.7045714259147644,
-0.19686102867126465,
0.2918536067008972,
0.25360164046287537,
-0.6226104497909546,
-0.027390005066990852,
0.4899651110172272,
0.4528397023677826,
0.04250036180019379,
-0.838501513004303,
0.06235397607088089,
-0.009184028021991253,
0.09043073654174805,
0.21244138479232788,
-0.43975144624710083,
0.8829815983772278,
-0.1292143166065216,
-0.3578381836414337,
0.13081789016723633,
0.685208261013031,
0.2144668847322464,
0.2394181191921234,
0.07465997338294983,
0.4192504584789276,
0.5014830231666565,
-0.019800789654254913,
1.1145477294921875,
-0.20039047300815582,
0.743342399597168,
0.9457883834838867,
-0.12483275681734085,
0.9500498175621033,
0.5043097734451294,
-0.0907415822148323,
0.21895469725131989,
0.4308696687221527,
0.38079050183296204,
0.9825106859207153,
0.0348488949239254,
-0.5761393904685974,
-0.3278846740722656,
0.14656521379947662,
-0.5983085632324219,
0.18757618963718414,
0.34835681319236755,
-0.34658199548721313,
-0.5543979406356812,
0.533749520778656,
0.012401631101965904,
0.16763682663440704,
-0.07628590613603592,
0.4802496135234833,
0.3475695550441742,
-0.5540253520011902,
0.6236616373062134,
0.12668156623840332,
0.3496398627758026,
-0.8047385215759277,
-0.10496844351291656,
-0.5060796737670898,
0.4085736572742462,
-0.059904325753450394,
-0.4049990475177765,
0.4703535735607147,
0.12043451517820358,
-0.46990323066711426,
-0.7181488275527954,
0.391704261302948,
-0.8449074029922485,
-0.5218102931976318,
0.5418602228164673,
0.3542097806930542,
-0.19131967425346375,
0.03121025115251541,
-0.21047793328762054,
0.42691290378570557,
-0.12338754534721375,
-0.02099539525806904,
0.40920740365982056,
0.5088265538215637,
0.02568982169032097,
0.8825220465660095,
0.6342414021492004,
0.29875850677490234,
0.15707217156887054,
-0.03873899206519127,
1.1006652116775513,
-0.6222046613693237,
-0.459846168756485,
-0.8004969954490662,
0.8352388143539429,
0.18849322199821472,
0.05074964463710785,
0.896577775478363,
0.45769909024238586,
0.7738381028175354,
-0.5011628270149231,
0.8789564371109009,
0.16276422142982483,
0.30763599276542664,
-0.5364617705345154,
0.8075149655342102,
-0.3242414891719818,
0.1579502522945404,
-0.10270144045352936,
-1.0030877590179443,
-0.6597979664802551,
0.3885825574398041,
-0.08566846698522568,
-0.287742018699646,
0.8088268041610718,
0.6459941267967224,
-0.1304863542318344,
-0.25779837369918823,
0.28024911880493164,
0.07066626846790314,
0.3607228100299835,
0.905182421207428,
0.7441055178642273,
-0.5795642137527466,
0.3689606487751007,
-0.08622220158576965,
-0.4081951975822449,
-0.39220789074897766,
-0.6906887292861938,
-0.7505818605422974,
-0.7571519017219543,
-0.023075474426150322,
-0.5381810665130615,
0.281773179769516,
0.6319378614425659,
0.7730295062065125,
-0.9527559876441956,
-0.5090320706367493,
-0.12469203025102615,
0.43350180983543396,
-0.6309818029403687,
-0.04988770931959152,
0.30155250430107117,
-0.586454451084137,
-1.078878402709961,
0.5631608366966248,
0.2884697914123535,
-0.22931888699531555,
-0.3136051595211029,
-0.2597220838069916,
-0.12308475375175476,
-0.08729100972414017,
0.7650117874145508,
0.34436163306236267,
-0.33703866600990295,
-0.03849148005247116,
-0.04588141292333603,
-0.43716752529144287,
-0.24982905387878418,
1.0855536460876465,
-0.7905228734016418,
0.6129642724990845,
0.6218061447143555,
0.8530502915382385,
0.6392751336097717,
0.00796421617269516,
0.899355411529541,
-0.5695191025733948,
0.5414950251579285,
0.16996505856513977,
-0.026340574026107788,
0.32950741052627563,
-0.036557070910930634,
0.10764122009277344,
0.11654741317033768,
-0.4728471636772156,
-0.9436629414558411,
0.38364899158477783,
-1.077715516090393,
-0.12402263283729553,
0.8717643618583679,
-0.32068875432014465,
-0.05358733609318733,
-0.14414872229099274,
-0.03242272883653641,
0.25586050748825073,
-0.08315296471118927,
0.5947112441062927,
0.5042836666107178,
0.32749757170677185,
-0.2914251983165741,
-0.5601858496665955,
0.37412533164024353,
0.12469121068716049,
-0.5085576772689819,
0.10837344825267792,
0.1714591383934021,
-0.058711256831884384,
-0.1786089390516281,
0.41522908210754395,
0.07507006078958511,
0.2623309791088104,
0.19400838017463684,
-0.030145877972245216,
-0.07321010529994965,
-0.6015013456344604,
-0.33408597111701965,
0.4091416597366333,
-0.11152643710374832,
-0.6350061297416687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02925v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02925v1
|
A Two-Stage Prediction-Aware Contrastive Learning Framework for Multi-Intent NLU
| 2024-05-05T13:09:55 | 2024-05-05T13:09:55 |
Guanhua Chen, Yutong Yao, Derek F. Wong, Lidia S. Chao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multi-intent natural language understanding (NLU) presents a formidable
challenge due to the model confusion arising from multiple intents within a
single utterance. While previous works train the model contrastively to
increase the margin between different multi-intent labels, they are less suited
to the nuances of multi-intent NLU. They ignore the rich information between
the shared intents, which is beneficial to constructing a better embedding
space, especially in low-data scenarios. We introduce a two-stage
Prediction-Aware Contrastive Learning (PACL) framework for multi-intent NLU to
harness this valuable knowledge. Our approach capitalizes on shared intent
information by integrating word-level pre-training and prediction-aware
contrastive fine-tuning. We construct a pre-training dataset using a word-level
data augmentation strategy. Subsequently, our framework dynamically assigns
roles to instances during contrastive fine-tuning while introducing a
prediction-aware contrastive loss to maximize the impact of contrastive
learning. We present experimental results and empirical analysis conducted on
three widely used datasets, demonstrating that our method surpasses the
performance of three prominent baselines on both low-data and full-data
scenarios.
|
[
-0.31497418880462646,
-0.5563389658927917,
0.5386204719543457,
0.2358822077512741,
-0.39813509583473206,
-0.15117903053760529,
-0.09905122965574265,
-0.5228436589241028,
0.020895566791296005,
0.43061360716819763,
-0.8220762610435486,
-0.35454341769218445,
-0.8444628715515137,
-0.06672797352075577,
0.10375931113958359,
0.8469347953796387,
0.008693605661392212,
0.09732535481452942,
-0.09114522486925125,
-0.3558677136898041,
-0.8346132040023804,
-0.010841273702681065,
-1.0566760301589966,
-0.41463610529899597,
0.5736518502235413,
0.6448756456375122,
0.4887475371360779,
0.35995954275131226,
0.09639949351549149,
0.17363493144512177,
0.08507133275270462,
0.4068741798400879,
-0.6700055003166199,
0.024322332814335823,
0.123182013630867,
-0.35388845205307007,
-0.13467645645141602,
0.17953848838806152,
0.2139534056186676,
0.7629642486572266,
-0.03738076239824295,
-0.30761510133743286,
0.30358582735061646,
0.5676289796829224,
-0.6928161382675171,
0.48943614959716797,
-0.8782883286476135,
0.11898519843816757,
0.27539169788360596,
-0.1574186533689499,
-0.68935227394104,
0.009735183790326118,
0.44368594884872437,
-1.133980393409729,
0.04303814843297005,
0.15200288593769073,
0.5674446821212769,
0.5887160897254944,
-0.4389793574810028,
-0.4856756031513214,
-0.39865684509277344,
0.948769211769104,
-0.6104090213775635,
0.5067282319068909,
0.6009801030158997,
0.2058621644973755,
0.0970047116279602,
-0.614842414855957,
-0.5330616235733032,
0.09123251587152481,
-0.4197637736797333,
0.2891363501548767,
0.20303897559642792,
0.18924665451049805,
-0.26579415798187256,
0.21079568564891815,
-0.4660900831222534,
0.1390768587589264,
-0.22300969064235687,
-0.04397992044687271,
0.23400430381298065,
-0.10223165154457092,
-0.14313830435276031,
0.148637056350708,
-0.6537694334983826,
-0.04262162372469902,
-0.47402143478393555,
-0.053047191351652145,
0.02704937569797039,
0.6194210052490234,
-0.24495702981948853,
0.2738809585571289,
-0.09378011524677277,
0.43129265308380127,
0.1723318099975586,
0.04446425288915634,
0.23429058492183685,
-0.46551477909088135,
-0.3803669512271881,
0.4293981194496155,
0.6869737505912781,
0.20690907537937164,
-0.03279193118214607,
-0.14921393990516663,
-0.01858128421008587,
0.18133680522441864,
0.32347986102104187,
-0.8115248084068298,
-0.14173510670661926,
0.32332009077072144,
-0.10818734765052795,
-0.27473536133766174,
-0.10451751202344894,
-0.457088828086853,
-0.7380412817001343,
-0.47154080867767334,
0.6640887260437012,
-0.5604144334793091,
0.0811077356338501,
0.5423076152801514,
0.3111073672771454,
0.14563962817192078,
0.714981734752655,
-0.727647066116333,
0.3065870702266693,
0.8118356466293335,
0.5018031001091003,
-0.0674225389957428,
-0.48421183228492737,
-0.7745099663734436,
0.2442733198404312,
-0.3644927740097046,
0.47951558232307434,
-0.620137631893158,
-0.185531884431839,
0.08012693375349045,
-0.20294062793254852,
-0.28160393238067627,
-0.14223498106002808,
0.8100759983062744,
-0.4626181423664093,
0.5044227838516235,
0.048168525099754333,
-0.6616482734680176,
-0.3550981879234314,
0.33549028635025024,
-0.835081160068512,
0.7725416421890259,
-0.1640809178352356,
-0.8144122958183289,
0.5856456756591797,
-0.695513904094696,
-0.6942256689071655,
-0.17212098836898804,
-0.16920319199562073,
-0.6031987071037292,
0.14553678035736084,
0.20588400959968567,
0.5336094498634338,
0.17509114742279053,
0.3767595589160919,
-0.19936682283878326,
-0.44581493735313416,
0.021781258285045624,
-0.505846381187439,
0.30064836144447327,
-0.022923870012164116,
-0.2578730583190918,
0.2785876989364624,
-0.8018128275871277,
-0.4297133982181549,
-0.11691717058420181,
-0.32234835624694824,
-0.3597392141819,
0.004867848940193653,
-0.2827546298503876,
0.46631917357444763,
0.0840928927063942,
-0.41035035252571106,
-0.015383000485599041,
-0.46307092905044556,
-0.12670134007930756,
0.7353746294975281,
-0.21847359836101532,
0.5546347498893738,
-0.15993568301200867,
0.246379554271698,
0.1747840940952301,
0.34671688079833984,
-0.18820536136627197,
-0.6177095174789429,
-0.7336127161979675,
0.07940229028463364,
0.06228430196642876,
0.3850717544555664,
-0.8894272446632385,
0.2625333070755005,
-0.13866710662841797,
-0.13941951096057892,
-0.8771631717681885,
0.22711317241191864,
0.6211886405944824,
0.6650110483169556,
0.7025484442710876,
-0.08947848528623581,
-0.5701867938041687,
-0.48473429679870605,
-0.11485277861356735,
0.0646052211523056,
0.1906883418560028,
0.7380412817001343,
0.07842212915420532,
-0.45571455359458923,
0.5041383504867554,
-0.5147294402122498,
-0.8621522188186646,
-0.3918605446815491,
0.43838638067245483,
0.25406917929649353,
0.31092870235443115,
-0.039916373789310455,
-1.086790919303894,
-0.5090969204902649,
-0.07580367475748062,
-0.42570874094963074,
0.2536703944206238,
-0.2637701630592346,
-0.17272166907787323,
0.0031335644889622927,
0.5562441349029541,
-0.21151429414749146,
0.23811841011047363,
0.8407760858535767,
-0.49465054273605347,
0.3697313964366913,
-0.4011833965778351,
0.050061702728271484,
-1.321723222732544,
-0.2741893529891968,
-0.044258881360292435,
0.1587512046098709,
-0.9663563370704651,
-0.5961990356445312,
0.018186036497354507,
0.07881161570549011,
-0.5906128287315369,
0.6502914428710938,
-0.22878021001815796,
-0.07481201738119125,
-0.22613026201725006,
0.16760244965553284,
0.34342464804649353,
0.40654897689819336,
0.20919856429100037,
0.6849938631057739,
0.47425347566604614,
-0.8783926367759705,
-0.3461288809776306,
0.4727761447429657,
-0.3823414742946625,
0.1383635252714157,
-0.42340362071990967,
-0.06101305037736893,
-0.20873108506202698,
0.40433672070503235,
-1.2508461475372314,
-0.1692700833082199,
0.18381892144680023,
-0.4267752468585968,
0.30231529474258423,
0.006920000072568655,
-0.10848821699619293,
0.022267358377575874,
-0.3215447962284088,
0.5528185963630676,
-0.05832262709736824,
-0.7420703172683716,
0.7399511933326721,
0.21803990006446838,
-0.0786927193403244,
-1.122832179069519,
-0.7680487632751465,
-0.36401811242103577,
-0.0788518488407135,
-0.366432785987854,
0.45468226075172424,
-0.17587800323963165,
0.165546253323555,
-0.12914778292179108,
0.02216460555791855,
-0.07133021950721741,
0.28214502334594727,
0.3710361123085022,
0.3509410619735718,
-0.035815734416246414,
0.4271825850009918,
0.16975711286067963,
-0.21663813292980194,
-0.14521919190883636,
-0.20804013311862946,
0.7240413427352905,
-0.03211168199777603,
-0.24919529259204865,
-0.41505834460258484,
0.09505388885736465,
0.3168923258781433,
-0.22885079681873322,
0.9183146953582764,
0.9718173146247864,
-0.27136337757110596,
-0.06736109405755997,
-0.36022210121154785,
-0.20485788583755493,
-0.4189649224281311,
0.09034272283315659,
-0.4244539439678192,
-0.8803269267082214,
0.21104177832603455,
-0.14822807908058167,
0.40590399503707886,
0.25826019048690796,
0.19356639683246613,
-0.00005738363688578829,
0.7517021298408508,
0.7439993023872375,
0.14501255750656128,
0.5605776309967041,
-0.41499263048171997,
0.3052045702934265,
-1.0533875226974487,
-0.48641201853752136,
-0.12037240713834763,
-0.3214075267314911,
-0.30409353971481323,
-0.7174813747406006,
0.01587643474340439,
0.19883234798908234,
0.010780619457364082,
0.11297328025102615,
-0.21606242656707764,
0.40961000323295593,
0.26933392882347107,
0.13453418016433716,
0.28821101784706116,
-0.2153860181570053,
-0.0445314422249794,
0.07576493918895721,
-0.42941346764564514,
-0.13172338902950287,
1.05703604221344,
0.10691998898983002,
0.6440680027008057,
0.13075801730155945,
0.8125249743461609,
0.05225767940282822,
0.2714773118495941,
-0.9765298962593079,
0.173350989818573,
-0.5292879343032837,
-0.3709738552570343,
-0.44465431571006775,
-0.33189311623573303,
-1.1663368940353394,
0.6354692578315735,
-0.5006968975067139,
-0.42937201261520386,
0.3277643024921417,
0.3079495131969452,
-0.4448840618133545,
0.010413430631160736,
-0.794838547706604,
0.9544807076454163,
-0.1954382210969925,
-0.5182732343673706,
-0.3237868845462799,
-0.8429291248321533,
0.37167325615882874,
-0.09741931408643723,
0.5137673616409302,
-0.34660065174102783,
-0.214736208319664,
0.6811582446098328,
0.2179734706878662,
0.8471444845199585,
-0.1496507227420807,
-0.095181904733181,
-0.05047861486673355,
-0.08431301265954971,
0.3156357705593109,
0.26307612657546997,
-0.44527894258499146,
-0.29266756772994995,
-0.6711522936820984,
-0.2740508019924164,
-0.31433066725730896,
0.6652106642723083,
-0.6840432286262512,
-0.10637710243463516,
-0.25411611795425415,
-0.6081307530403137,
-0.5740952491760254,
0.2894086539745331,
0.26184144616127014,
0.5584743618965149,
-0.440784215927124,
0.2028035819530487,
0.8181002140045166,
-0.18123655021190643,
0.3526983857154846,
0.3522433042526245,
0.0915389433503151,
-0.25533029437065125,
0.8457526564598083,
-0.5204850435256958,
0.31408512592315674,
0.6339705586433411,
0.44743844866752625,
-0.6795744895935059,
-0.60462886095047,
-0.1583254486322403,
0.09381408989429474,
-0.6559545993804932,
0.0054779970087111,
-0.7198154330253601,
0.22360888123512268,
-0.45173394680023193,
-0.4076962172985077,
-0.4186164140701294,
-0.03035449981689453,
-0.5367201566696167,
-0.0863986536860466,
-0.03255190700292587,
0.6774716973304749,
0.05544939637184143,
0.4812352955341339,
-0.4394488036632538,
0.5390751957893372,
0.3330691158771515,
0.4787081182003021,
-0.23162630200386047,
-0.4528590738773346,
-0.1476099193096161,
-0.07179318368434906,
-0.04125301539897919,
-0.36469054222106934,
0.4008182883262634,
0.5774455070495605,
0.5116696953773499,
0.6650855541229248,
0.14048388600349426,
0.6018883585929871,
-0.4316779673099518,
0.5037975907325745,
0.5467685461044312,
-0.6822421550750732,
0.7830594778060913,
0.12789569795131683,
0.3423520028591156,
1.2559144496917725,
0.5159498453140259,
-0.458698034286499,
-0.10133470594882965,
-0.5912767052650452,
-0.8803647756576538,
0.9625487923622131,
0.06732241064310074,
-0.07001662999391556,
0.19262701272964478,
0.15807025134563446,
0.6118298172950745,
0.27184346318244934,
-0.7267496585845947,
-0.4919895529747009,
-0.19638173282146454,
-0.25774726271629333,
-0.4978516399860382,
-0.058843642473220825,
0.07506658881902695,
-0.195077583193779,
0.7347115874290466,
-0.37701141834259033,
-0.08901134133338928,
0.023055873811244965,
-0.2567313313484192,
0.20855101943016052,
0.5175865292549133,
0.5559771656990051,
0.5750104188919067,
-0.2969955801963806,
0.17092086374759674,
0.13640816509723663,
-0.5095499753952026,
-0.07112094759941101,
0.4060804545879364,
0.08463124185800552,
-0.0074510048143565655,
0.10431084781885147,
1.3860902786254883,
0.6663815379142761,
-0.45143863558769226,
0.5089920163154602,
-0.5501980781555176,
-0.19175021350383759,
0.013702280819416046,
-0.24191929399967194,
0.021829800680279732,
-0.08596067130565643,
0.0722581073641777,
0.19940689206123352,
0.470731258392334,
-0.6306619048118591,
0.4243144392967224,
0.20401403307914734,
-0.7753454446792603,
-0.02614988014101982,
0.34917110204696655,
0.3080698549747467,
0.16191016137599945,
0.24867190420627594,
-0.4403010606765747,
-0.3876904845237732,
0.4221475124359131,
0.5086777210235596,
0.5665066242218018,
-0.4574697017669678,
0.37739473581314087,
0.3593255877494812,
-0.04202020913362503,
0.04377586767077446,
0.12851694226264954,
0.046918079257011414,
-0.9759615659713745,
-0.43189775943756104,
-0.7876831889152527,
-0.4612693786621094,
0.29264476895332336,
-0.5762535929679871,
0.2561235725879669,
-0.29594558477401733,
0.2498563975095749,
0.12056424468755722,
0.2708439826965332,
-0.7227982878684998,
0.4047151803970337,
0.2585977613925934,
0.5213372111320496,
-0.8675618767738342,
1.0396836996078491,
0.526881992816925,
-0.023693615570664406,
-0.9061086177825928,
0.10033220797777176,
0.010126704350113869,
-0.9020528793334961,
0.23563681542873383,
0.8004334568977356,
-0.36672720313072205,
-0.03417283296585083,
0.06093703210353851,
-0.4961903989315033,
1.2575048208236694,
0.12298139929771423,
-0.4273994565010071,
0.062093574553728104,
-0.06425219774246216,
0.262184739112854,
-0.7667431235313416,
0.14240923523902893,
0.5931717157363892,
0.4512927234172821,
0.4927491843700409,
-0.39511838555336,
-0.13205131888389587,
0.23598416149616241,
-0.28818342089653015,
0.12858101725578308,
-0.23705622553825378,
0.839023768901825,
-0.5476963520050049,
-0.3032321333885193,
-0.343296080827713,
0.6426710486412048,
0.40574002265930176,
0.6781315207481384,
0.7171096801757812,
0.5922189354896545,
0.8510401248931885,
-0.14323030412197113,
0.9854391813278198,
-0.29081737995147705,
0.25300347805023193,
1.5499428510665894,
-0.11512553691864014,
0.9589484333992004,
0.41938525438308716,
0.2806892395019531,
0.3870503306388855,
0.4583081007003784,
0.32622960209846497,
0.8279477953910828,
-0.17420297861099243,
-0.3619080185890198,
-0.19983866810798645,
-0.4072895348072052,
-0.09511344879865646,
0.5004862546920776,
0.7676156759262085,
-0.16088218986988068,
-0.028408503159880638,
0.0017695531714707613,
-0.24293169379234314,
0.03587759658694267,
-0.3667154908180237,
1.11030912399292,
0.0773477628827095,
-0.6731784343719482,
0.268030047416687,
-0.4422937035560608,
1.0290684700012207,
-0.5569276809692383,
-0.039888929575681686,
-0.07535526901483536,
0.4120364785194397,
-0.19523705542087555,
-0.9867932200431824,
0.05382027477025986,
-0.5859158635139465,
0.11945728212594986,
-0.12768705189228058,
0.7754936218261719,
-0.7705110311508179,
-0.23534372448921204,
0.6766969561576843,
0.37020859122276306,
-0.07856374233961105,
0.005315002519637346,
-0.9837212562561035,
0.09262996912002563,
0.0006071129464544356,
0.05840685963630676,
0.2220020741224289,
0.4112820327281952,
0.524224579334259,
0.5855177044868469,
0.44669973850250244,
-0.059307605028152466,
0.029575876891613007,
0.595649003982544,
0.6701748967170715,
-0.0561244823038578,
-0.607020378112793,
-0.46545663475990295,
0.43397098779678345,
-0.18185117840766907,
-0.3854176998138428,
0.30100277066230774,
0.6177937984466553,
0.9023407697677612,
0.05902324244379997,
0.6837753653526306,
0.2483827769756317,
0.22863779962062836,
-0.5636097192764282,
0.31809988617897034,
-0.7230610251426697,
0.21170161664485931,
0.0065785362385213375,
-0.6748446822166443,
-0.2952025234699249,
0.4700242877006531,
-0.1934908926486969,
-0.19406819343566895,
0.6676397919654846,
0.5219869017601013,
-0.21515043079853058,
0.1336050182580948,
0.5255828499794006,
0.08319196850061417,
0.2556042969226837,
0.7758321166038513,
0.49575138092041016,
-0.6255907416343689,
0.6574235558509827,
-0.5589501857757568,
-0.17661453783512115,
-0.40628862380981445,
-0.6590782403945923,
-0.5833203792572021,
-0.6467515230178833,
-0.20480407774448395,
-0.05054114758968353,
0.07495532184839249,
0.527323842048645,
0.6892724633216858,
-0.8161443471908569,
0.05427173897624016,
-0.34146639704704285,
0.14998599886894226,
-0.12936042249202728,
-0.17008650302886963,
0.4008469581604004,
-0.6273065805435181,
-0.6344655156135559,
0.5650026202201843,
0.27655699849128723,
0.026267657056450844,
0.1464485228061676,
-0.5451582670211792,
-0.5529157519340515,
0.19046984612941742,
0.8375248908996582,
0.03304397687315941,
-0.7908725738525391,
-0.14155811071395874,
-0.32388338446617126,
-0.2591221034526825,
0.18847906589508057,
0.7174569964408875,
-0.7982292771339417,
0.521056056022644,
0.24678826332092285,
0.7907673120498657,
0.5145384669303894,
0.0723673552274704,
0.3766765296459198,
-1.1027042865753174,
0.09763249009847641,
0.3403298854827881,
0.5183218717575073,
0.3721618950366974,
-0.5047735571861267,
0.5085683465003967,
-0.31333646178245544,
-0.31488871574401855,
-0.19525666534900665,
0.30145978927612305,
-1.4202059507369995,
-0.5057333111763,
1.137132167816162,
-0.14225813746452332,
0.30259981751441956,
-0.435342013835907,
-0.25422120094299316,
0.5906916260719299,
-0.6174929141998291,
0.6521881222724915,
0.36006224155426025,
-0.325064092874527,
-0.14828377962112427,
-0.3218812644481659,
0.7601825594902039,
0.5589379668235779,
-1.0138672590255737,
0.2769755721092224,
0.4021308124065399,
-0.24744060635566711,
0.4036298990249634,
0.5298377275466919,
0.1425231248140335,
0.22752515971660614,
-0.12063023447990417,
-0.23741087317466736,
-0.049357667565345764,
-0.636235237121582,
-0.4515380859375,
0.06872325390577316,
0.02631288208067417,
-0.42612606287002563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02917v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02917v1
|
Overconfidence is Key: Verbalized Uncertainty Evaluation in Large Language and Vision-Language Models
| 2024-05-05T12:51:38 | 2024-05-05T12:51:38 |
Tobias Groot, Matias Valdenegro-Toro
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Language and Vision-Language Models (LLMs/VLMs) have revolutionized the field
of AI by their ability to generate human-like text and understand images, but
ensuring their reliability is crucial. This paper aims to evaluate the ability
of LLMs (GPT4, GPT-3.5, LLaMA2, and PaLM 2) and VLMs (GPT4V and Gemini Pro
Vision) to estimate their verbalized uncertainty via prompting. We propose the
new Japanese Uncertain Scenes (JUS) dataset, aimed at testing VLM capabilities
via difficult queries and object counting, and the Net Calibration Error (NCE)
to measure direction of miscalibration. Results show that both LLMs and VLMs
have a high calibration error and are overconfident most of the time,
indicating a poor capability for uncertainty estimation. Additionally we
develop prompts for regression tasks, and we show that VLMs have poor
calibration when producing mean/standard deviation and 95% confidence
intervals.
|
[
-0.32997530698776245,
-0.9262421131134033,
1.126268744468689,
-0.012327823787927628,
-0.17733444273471832,
0.11651141941547394,
-0.2888332009315491,
-0.32746225595474243,
-0.40676310658454895,
0.2248172163963318,
-0.5936939716339111,
-0.3742903769016266,
-0.8270993828773499,
0.16650278866291046,
-0.12210194021463394,
0.5453396439552307,
-0.25885215401649475,
0.21059605479240417,
-0.29233089089393616,
0.10555046796798706,
-0.5086351037025452,
-0.23079508543014526,
-0.6715666055679321,
-0.015419230796396732,
0.2785816788673401,
0.2241446077823639,
1.155038595199585,
0.01614866964519024,
0.24423466622829437,
0.41256552934646606,
0.17024634778499603,
0.27333834767341614,
-0.16789333522319794,
0.1848786622285843,
-0.17886234819889069,
-0.8404157757759094,
-0.030126629397273064,
-0.16541486978530884,
0.5765094757080078,
0.5127297639846802,
-0.04611600562930107,
0.10244745016098022,
-0.1344635933637619,
0.6142263412475586,
-0.9641523957252502,
0.540117084980011,
-0.659186601638794,
-0.04863665625452995,
-0.1123119667172432,
-0.02506914548575878,
-0.13523262739181519,
-0.35799503326416016,
0.19308564066886902,
-0.9818705916404724,
-0.145771786570549,
0.16534113883972168,
0.9928849935531616,
0.6501409411430359,
-0.02146223932504654,
-0.2845006585121155,
-0.7093479633331299,
0.9073461294174194,
-0.7044072151184082,
0.3176119029521942,
0.8368680477142334,
0.4676864743232727,
-0.24849969148635864,
-0.4628358781337738,
-0.6503970623016357,
-0.3569590747356415,
0.27477383613586426,
0.43372848629951477,
-0.2754007577896118,
0.058849167078733444,
0.20492474734783173,
-0.17599695920944214,
-0.4286189377307892,
0.1971518099308014,
-0.16709023714065552,
-0.1452903151512146,
0.48364007472991943,
0.22863809764385223,
0.00011986212484771386,
-0.30502238869667053,
-0.27410992980003357,
-0.2838720679283142,
-0.3868121802806854,
0.08522326499223709,
0.3510117828845978,
0.06834203004837036,
0.002964344574138522,
0.6218528747558594,
-0.20477819442749023,
0.8052164912223816,
-0.08552180975675583,
-0.3046022057533264,
0.20234842598438263,
-0.4221000373363495,
-0.33195096254348755,
-0.23012667894363403,
0.9859513640403748,
0.6289241909980774,
0.7135088443756104,
0.2075033187866211,
-0.11113573610782623,
0.11327313631772995,
0.2893640100955963,
-0.27609461545944214,
0.20341479778289795,
0.41997870802879333,
0.10720322281122208,
-0.20409724116325378,
-0.032766759395599365,
-0.568888783454895,
-0.5397623181343079,
-0.20315895974636078,
0.6254692077636719,
-0.5224501490592957,
-0.006903538014739752,
0.23953500390052795,
-0.274310827255249,
0.34774380922317505,
0.644732654094696,
-0.44565778970718384,
0.05984567478299141,
0.440401166677475,
0.5307029485702515,
0.12176655977964401,
-0.45325469970703125,
-0.05893333628773689,
-0.17357364296913147,
-0.7302556037902832,
0.5437852144241333,
-0.3561558425426483,
-0.649125874042511,
-0.01665364019572735,
-0.20368091762065887,
-0.25180676579475403,
-0.16493862867355347,
0.622778058052063,
-0.22324571013450623,
0.2831365466117859,
-0.42329466342926025,
-0.46342703700065613,
-0.10025643557310104,
0.5658043622970581,
-0.30495506525039673,
1.1016324758529663,
0.31956177949905396,
-0.7741978168487549,
0.3820565342903137,
-0.1859908252954483,
-0.017436128109693527,
0.1324498951435089,
-0.740702748298645,
-0.3886730968952179,
0.07507441937923431,
0.6415488719940186,
0.5202860832214355,
-0.45717301964759827,
0.6082358360290527,
-0.4130367338657379,
-0.4344230592250824,
0.740953266620636,
-1.0851753950119019,
0.6197018623352051,
0.03268866240978241,
-0.22051066160202026,
-0.035357605665922165,
-0.4740486443042755,
0.20729783177375793,
0.10415036231279373,
0.03612503409385681,
-0.38769716024398804,
0.17557287216186523,
-0.40276169776916504,
0.17201250791549683,
0.400814026594162,
-0.3851673901081085,
-0.034588322043418884,
-0.359829843044281,
0.3124929964542389,
0.7153493165969849,
-0.04084791988134384,
0.08333895355463028,
-0.174162819981575,
0.619938850402832,
-0.0075051793828606606,
0.6000936031341553,
-0.16599617898464203,
-0.6315732598304749,
-0.8520143628120422,
0.1921958327293396,
-0.10649198293685913,
0.7282974123954773,
-1.1808375120162964,
0.18684439361095428,
-0.31000903248786926,
-0.6073453426361084,
-0.5525470972061157,
-0.04015558212995529,
0.5875991582870483,
0.5790696144104004,
0.19614958763122559,
-0.10406135767698288,
-0.3319680392742157,
-0.6944314241409302,
0.00023388146655634046,
-0.6085702776908875,
-0.20706875622272491,
0.4435763955116272,
0.3834300637245178,
-0.05277305096387863,
0.832521915435791,
-0.3141603469848633,
-0.03936963155865669,
-0.06498625129461288,
0.06165694817900658,
0.01512692216783762,
0.15377478301525116,
0.358010470867157,
-0.711453378200531,
-0.24820388853549957,
-0.28935500979423523,
-0.7350285053253174,
0.16517816483974457,
-0.18581721186637878,
0.16659000515937805,
0.4791637659072876,
0.6161333322525024,
-0.6756944060325623,
0.5631582140922546,
0.5274766683578491,
-0.007585532497614622,
0.731078028678894,
-0.229790598154068,
0.24708406627178192,
-0.8172934651374817,
-0.020534638315439224,
0.2725955843925476,
-0.21756111085414886,
-0.26392701268196106,
0.03525779768824577,
0.015355202369391918,
0.1630714386701584,
-0.4385817050933838,
0.3937166631221771,
-0.5308380722999573,
-0.3064911663532257,
-0.06464479118585587,
0.3844189941883087,
0.08865402638912201,
0.3635573089122772,
0.266882985830307,
0.7705798745155334,
0.7656463980674744,
-0.2583816647529602,
0.3645387589931488,
0.058825522661209106,
-0.7046368718147278,
0.7822781801223755,
-0.737670361995697,
-0.14680683612823486,
-0.32590150833129883,
0.1852589100599289,
-1.1718382835388184,
-0.5145279765129089,
0.4313462972640991,
-0.5322107076644897,
0.4267459511756897,
0.1017591804265976,
-0.21120566129684448,
-0.7086633443832397,
-0.400408536195755,
0.2505994439125061,
0.47862163186073303,
-0.024389158934354782,
0.3760867416858673,
0.09516094624996185,
-0.19240735471248627,
-0.8964338302612305,
-0.793746829032898,
0.23577500879764557,
0.09977490454912186,
-0.40493065118789673,
-0.06664308905601501,
0.09201191365718842,
-0.2857489287853241,
-0.05935433879494667,
-0.10496943444013596,
-0.0015166497323662043,
0.13340239226818085,
0.6026086211204529,
0.5137249231338501,
-0.08745279163122177,
0.06056797131896019,
-0.11865484714508057,
-0.19460445642471313,
0.1805724948644638,
-0.05342922359704971,
0.29932159185409546,
-0.3195916414260864,
-0.8608139157295227,
-0.4106304943561554,
-0.05757629871368408,
0.48951610922813416,
0.09011294692754745,
0.498464435338974,
0.6397613883018494,
-0.34765538573265076,
0.2302442342042923,
-0.6369627118110657,
0.09394960850477219,
-0.46438637375831604,
0.5411672592163086,
-0.40830177068710327,
-0.6827092170715332,
0.3751572072505951,
0.09568618983030319,
-0.14234985411167145,
0.45841914415359497,
0.3604593873023987,
-0.23684212565422058,
1.030694603919983,
0.38425421714782715,
-0.17243558168411255,
0.24661828577518463,
-0.04668807238340378,
-0.10310538858175278,
-0.6650228500366211,
-0.20532424747943878,
-0.532741129398346,
0.050857268273830414,
-0.4734165072441101,
-0.7146846055984497,
0.5915996432304382,
-0.05247003957629204,
-0.41732120513916016,
-0.005052271299064159,
-0.0538090318441391,
0.5605546236038208,
0.69512939453125,
0.19274485111236572,
0.05079595744609833,
-0.28325170278549194,
-0.008611711673438549,
-0.17034129798412323,
-0.6909081339836121,
-0.5378913879394531,
0.9578481316566467,
0.5113922357559204,
0.9974293112754822,
-0.27152836322784424,
0.28117915987968445,
-0.18678335845470428,
-0.03722758963704109,
-0.960693359375,
0.3257206976413727,
0.027560018002986908,
-0.5945137739181519,
-0.7477574944496155,
-0.258588969707489,
-0.630240261554718,
-0.10535337775945663,
-0.16769565641880035,
-0.9494508504867554,
0.35446977615356445,
0.13085637986660004,
-0.704103946685791,
0.004829753655940294,
-0.4706619381904602,
0.6084829568862915,
-0.29120200872421265,
-0.10102248936891556,
0.23477141559123993,
-1.0574771165847778,
0.3939642608165741,
-0.21707119047641754,
0.35758113861083984,
-0.14098475873470306,
-0.32367974519729614,
0.2954774796962738,
-0.34183862805366516,
1.150025486946106,
-0.10528653115034103,
-0.0038611351046711206,
0.5293241143226624,
0.09010780602693558,
0.6565028429031372,
0.11250006407499313,
-0.2811426520347595,
0.19328106939792633,
-0.100603848695755,
-0.18230310082435608,
-0.6901900172233582,
0.40928658843040466,
-0.9904201030731201,
-0.6088237166404724,
-0.5230569243431091,
-0.2621084749698639,
-0.48650890588760376,
-0.015086245723068714,
0.751699686050415,
0.32028740644454956,
-0.1674651950597763,
-0.15938252210617065,
0.41896989941596985,
-0.357618510723114,
0.4222871959209442,
0.4084851145744324,
-0.12741366028785706,
-0.4191746413707733,
0.7298201322555542,
0.2768033444881439,
0.6412101984024048,
0.13952551782131195,
0.14940333366394043,
-0.44367286562919617,
-0.6019334197044373,
-0.6708887219429016,
-0.06208644434809685,
-0.6808751821517944,
-0.2996017038822174,
-0.1655879020690918,
-0.47846540808677673,
-0.22079342603683472,
-0.31214794516563416,
-0.5941449403762817,
-0.22967396676540375,
-0.39069634675979614,
-0.19124875962734222,
0.28131935000419617,
0.6428505778312683,
0.12734179198741913,
0.4409314692020416,
-0.6483033895492554,
0.07460722327232361,
0.1723494678735733,
0.22144700586795807,
-0.3856149911880493,
-0.5731844305992126,
-0.05576498433947563,
0.23109881579875946,
-0.016652684658765793,
-0.8633425235748291,
0.3799769878387451,
0.15987661480903625,
0.5124593377113342,
0.3144204914569855,
0.15704788267612457,
0.8867427110671997,
-0.24237143993377686,
1.034273386001587,
0.13429822027683258,
-1.0386316776275635,
0.516936719417572,
-0.21523568034172058,
0.48884716629981995,
0.7813553810119629,
0.5725946426391602,
-0.4108627140522003,
-0.631810188293457,
-0.7385683655738831,
-0.7761604189872742,
0.537227988243103,
0.31887978315353394,
0.005118283908814192,
0.06681420654058456,
0.36927729845046997,
-0.23824498057365417,
0.3235267698764801,
-0.41456207633018494,
-0.22208142280578613,
-0.31396326422691345,
-0.269485741853714,
-0.31229445338249207,
-0.39593958854675293,
0.012462825514376163,
0.047325003892183304,
0.5233239531517029,
-0.23405957221984863,
0.003186279209330678,
0.5076863169670105,
0.17709355056285858,
-0.2889882028102875,
0.1455816924571991,
0.4846058785915375,
0.539777398109436,
-0.19284498691558838,
0.05578523129224777,
0.3260076344013214,
-0.425193727016449,
0.029137449339032173,
-0.05809762701392174,
-0.27785998582839966,
0.09497086703777313,
0.48422107100486755,
1.1252374649047852,
0.20228222012519836,
-0.665145754814148,
0.7855942249298096,
-0.18330377340316772,
-0.16423551738262177,
-0.6159999370574951,
0.10473982989788055,
-0.11669406294822693,
0.1358909010887146,
0.14643913507461548,
0.32946813106536865,
0.0787927582859993,
-0.34857267141342163,
-0.07088243216276169,
0.4513855576515198,
-0.48299744725227356,
-0.08355646580457687,
0.4558507800102234,
-0.024333851411938667,
0.08845162391662598,
0.5031408071517944,
-0.2813025116920471,
-0.5996690392494202,
0.6648544073104858,
0.2887676954269409,
0.704233705997467,
-0.3285198211669922,
0.38359391689300537,
0.3772914409637451,
0.6621665358543396,
-0.36054524779319763,
0.5135836005210876,
0.21890780329704285,
-1.0096909999847412,
-0.55987149477005,
-0.4091421365737915,
-0.6909345388412476,
0.05592179670929909,
-0.6689603924751282,
0.16785097122192383,
-0.5311022996902466,
-0.47056084871292114,
-0.16669514775276184,
-0.19832780957221985,
-0.7541856169700623,
0.3653673231601715,
0.13765273988246918,
0.6218664050102234,
-0.8295129537582397,
0.622951865196228,
0.39694714546203613,
-0.24075420200824738,
-0.9866071939468384,
-0.10971834510564804,
0.16251328587532043,
-1.196693778038025,
0.3987761437892914,
0.0576394721865654,
-0.0995732769370079,
-0.16741590201854706,
-0.7201064229011536,
-0.9456596970558167,
0.9474287629127502,
0.4563010334968567,
-0.9487383365631104,
-0.018636558204889297,
0.24705004692077637,
0.4645672142505646,
0.10955271869897842,
0.5477135181427002,
0.6644684672355652,
0.7871055603027344,
0.22536183893680573,
-0.9701139330863953,
-0.07470032572746277,
0.04984087869524956,
0.275667667388916,
0.13142317533493042,
-0.4531223773956299,
0.7216047644615173,
-0.44877657294273376,
-0.29190170764923096,
0.17439992725849152,
0.51576167345047,
0.32104745507240295,
0.3072434365749359,
0.531260073184967,
0.27760931849479675,
0.7573602795600891,
-0.22243981063365936,
1.2034624814987183,
-0.035515524446964264,
0.0498814694583416,
1.368890643119812,
-0.23250116407871246,
1.0522172451019287,
0.598754346370697,
-0.3984476923942566,
0.23458993434906006,
0.5822467803955078,
0.08585222065448761,
0.12238235026597977,
0.20153184235095978,
-0.09898252040147781,
-0.45229315757751465,
0.00915384478867054,
-0.0843469426035881,
0.4408039152622223,
0.9362472891807556,
-0.2802756428718567,
-0.1210782527923584,
0.06075849011540413,
0.035514481365680695,
-0.05824870988726616,
-0.16918277740478516,
0.553822934627533,
0.29599761962890625,
-0.8572425246238708,
0.5178772807121277,
-0.11803676187992096,
0.5110827088356018,
-0.5829048752784729,
0.4143684506416321,
-0.025212828069925308,
-0.08307475596666336,
0.03596927970647812,
-1.225162386894226,
0.24024873971939087,
0.06465870887041092,
0.36144718527793884,
0.32751011848449707,
0.6764944195747375,
-0.2668215334415436,
-0.8619219064712524,
0.009546474553644657,
0.5966832041740417,
0.3378479480743408,
-0.3544287085533142,
-0.8972433805465698,
0.20033439993858337,
0.08999006450176239,
-0.5213545560836792,
-0.10365917533636093,
0.4041566550731659,
-0.2507036030292511,
1.0328913927078247,
0.36694228649139404,
0.058637022972106934,
0.046451177448034286,
0.311977356672287,
0.6006852984428406,
-0.4078999161720276,
0.10864260047674179,
-0.9778570532798767,
0.46666425466537476,
0.11504387110471725,
-0.6323443651199341,
0.7395092844963074,
-0.06099492684006691,
0.7339916229248047,
0.037965498864650726,
0.8997237682342529,
0.1248805895447731,
0.020177066326141357,
-0.7076290249824524,
0.2744036316871643,
-0.3891676962375641,
0.12222921848297119,
-0.3905385136604309,
-0.5803621411323547,
-0.32890862226486206,
0.7008814215660095,
-0.37365853786468506,
0.1829250603914261,
0.443325012922287,
0.8629059195518494,
0.23176203668117523,
-0.08100347220897675,
0.5704007744789124,
0.29800766706466675,
0.13224563002586365,
0.6589253544807434,
0.9298423528671265,
-0.5923551917076111,
0.45030227303504944,
-0.37882208824157715,
-0.10813656449317932,
-0.12846751511096954,
-1.0380817651748657,
-0.5648637413978577,
-0.512764573097229,
-0.4696480631828308,
-0.13514506816864014,
0.26990610361099243,
0.6185214519500732,
0.4270595908164978,
-0.522849440574646,
0.02985900640487671,
-0.3340727984905243,
-0.039442986249923706,
0.05318151041865349,
-0.14148862659931183,
0.31166428327560425,
-0.32362857460975647,
-0.8217742443084717,
0.34134721755981445,
0.27506840229034424,
0.6224139928817749,
-0.558712899684906,
-0.12428366392850876,
0.2773657739162445,
0.18887245655059814,
0.2876044809818268,
0.16038042306900024,
-0.978511393070221,
-0.38114774227142334,
-0.04976503923535347,
-0.34570997953414917,
-0.1879335343837738,
-0.01756887510418892,
-0.7198866605758667,
0.6659917831420898,
0.37929365038871765,
0.34199202060699463,
0.27082693576812744,
0.1736348271369934,
0.8571439981460571,
-0.766463041305542,
0.09551505744457245,
0.23656046390533447,
0.5160381197929382,
0.5063614845275879,
-0.3429892957210541,
0.4249671697616577,
-0.03885573148727417,
-0.5529155731201172,
-0.5351786017417908,
0.18362824618816376,
-0.9596917629241943,
-0.3507137596607208,
1.2503527402877808,
-0.3706476092338562,
-0.44351696968078613,
-0.20791515707969666,
-0.5171769261360168,
0.1824910193681717,
-0.3841325044631958,
0.434604287147522,
0.938502848148346,
0.20501814782619476,
-0.08079005777835846,
-0.742107093334198,
0.5626399517059326,
0.46573153138160706,
-0.7006571292877197,
-0.0485658124089241,
0.6282316446304321,
0.09826309978961945,
0.29009202122688293,
0.5130341053009033,
-0.07228487730026245,
0.2943436801433563,
0.3183682858943939,
-0.1310604214668274,
0.01015191525220871,
-0.292320191860199,
-0.3462282419204712,
-0.22451652586460114,
0.38552919030189514,
-0.2576461732387543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02887v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02887v1
|
Sentiment Analysis Across Languages: Evaluation Before and After Machine Translation to English
| 2024-05-05T10:52:09 | 2024-05-05T10:52:09 |
Aekansh Kathunia, Mohammad Kaif, Nalin Arora, N Narotam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
People communicate in more than 7,000 languages around the world, with around
780 languages spoken in India alone. Despite this linguistic diversity,
research on Sentiment Analysis has predominantly focused on English text data,
resulting in a disproportionate availability of sentiment resources for
English. This paper examines the performance of transformer models in Sentiment
Analysis tasks across multilingual datasets and text that has undergone machine
translation. By comparing the effectiveness of these models in different
linguistic contexts, we gain insights into their performance variations and
potential implications for sentiment analysis across diverse languages. We also
discuss the shortcomings and potential for future work towards the end.
|
[
-0.3887571096420288,
-0.118906669318676,
0.34375032782554626,
0.6343486905097961,
-0.21077309548854828,
0.3404639661312103,
-0.36538320779800415,
-0.6067730784416199,
0.026416828855872154,
0.13911497592926025,
-0.40458035469055176,
-0.38958030939102173,
-1.011769413948059,
0.6392943859100342,
-0.33610594272613525,
1.0771362781524658,
0.05753251537680626,
0.6324934959411621,
-0.17058101296424866,
-0.6028254628181458,
-0.3553306758403778,
-0.656665563583374,
-0.3263838589191437,
-0.4196445345878601,
0.3976515829563141,
0.1361200213432312,
0.8470869064331055,
-0.27515101432800293,
0.8158243298530579,
0.3671342134475708,
-0.2583823800086975,
0.002891300478950143,
-0.2643042802810669,
0.15069502592086792,
-0.2550528347492218,
-0.767934262752533,
-0.0801113098859787,
-0.027493182569742203,
0.7390750050544739,
0.6666366457939148,
0.20344969630241394,
0.06792400777339935,
0.15513134002685547,
0.711043655872345,
-0.5053237676620483,
0.16444893181324005,
-0.32818910479545593,
0.12270128726959229,
-0.10779164731502533,
0.3975940942764282,
-0.4937652051448822,
-0.4348320960998535,
0.3111463785171509,
0.07979245483875275,
-0.04667917266488075,
-0.15154407918453217,
0.7355368137359619,
0.12147021293640137,
-0.5359961986541748,
-0.43158239126205444,
-0.8230917453765869,
1.2478049993515015,
-0.6565329432487488,
0.5600053668022156,
-0.03667966648936272,
0.30370354652404785,
0.41112545132637024,
-0.5439401268959045,
-0.5243216156959534,
0.03985891863703728,
-0.4391062557697296,
0.3309595286846161,
-0.46620798110961914,
-0.39923369884490967,
0.08147066086530685,
0.617196261882782,
-0.3666306138038635,
-0.12925562262535095,
-0.3634122312068939,
0.10512810945510864,
0.590094804763794,
0.22539374232292175,
0.24742886424064636,
-0.6895466446876526,
-0.21128587424755096,
-0.2004222571849823,
-0.2370964139699936,
0.2883773446083069,
0.39911478757858276,
0.37215837836265564,
-0.22673194110393524,
0.37033599615097046,
0.1597885638475418,
0.5434291362762451,
-0.25434303283691406,
-0.25497549772262573,
0.4711924195289612,
-0.2283516675233841,
-0.22647660970687866,
-0.37261736392974854,
1.223102331161499,
0.4471869468688965,
0.22600899636745453,
-0.205547034740448,
-0.3350459635257721,
0.4309636354446411,
0.272344708442688,
-0.5779709219932556,
0.2419515997171402,
0.15456464886665344,
-0.7367373704910278,
-0.21568484604358673,
0.13678473234176636,
-1.0559022426605225,
-0.5902822613716125,
-0.0959586575627327,
0.06407294422388077,
-0.3064182996749878,
-0.6852855682373047,
0.16094109416007996,
-0.2297595888376236,
0.6425196528434753,
-0.16757260262966156,
-0.48825228214263916,
0.33046501874923706,
0.6397729516029358,
0.8023615479469299,
-0.39835840463638306,
-0.4035714268684387,
0.12305451929569244,
-0.6706807017326355,
-0.321378231048584,
0.8684628009796143,
-0.8845670819282532,
-0.879475474357605,
0.11523973941802979,
0.18763475120067596,
-0.39582133293151855,
-0.47415462136268616,
0.7673437595367432,
-0.5112451910972595,
0.47490665316581726,
-0.3441658020019531,
-0.2250450998544693,
-0.42246219515800476,
0.35089316964149475,
-0.8307158350944519,
0.9939860105514526,
0.13703642785549164,
-0.9123948216438293,
0.31400835514068604,
-0.7723333835601807,
-0.8021616339683533,
-0.26274052262306213,
-0.0240484569221735,
-0.4473305344581604,
0.5260722637176514,
0.4148888885974884,
0.465496689081192,
-0.5055146813392639,
0.18118108808994293,
0.10543083399534225,
-0.1308128833770752,
0.5214344263076782,
-0.4454456567764282,
0.6950477957725525,
0.46670839190483093,
-0.32720211148262024,
0.02510402910411358,
-0.5893057584762573,
-0.16392192244529724,
-0.06154720112681389,
-0.04698696359992027,
-0.3272637724876404,
0.12379666417837143,
0.5165517926216125,
0.5111770629882812,
0.007420024834573269,
-0.7976239919662476,
0.08759670704603195,
-0.6844946146011353,
0.5515874028205872,
0.20304256677627563,
-0.22526629269123077,
0.5149072408676147,
-0.0008987180190160871,
1.0952725410461426,
0.3248557448387146,
0.17241641879081726,
-0.24337069690227509,
-0.6059798002243042,
-0.7130232453346252,
0.07112175226211548,
0.2566858232021332,
0.6663183569908142,
-0.513595700263977,
-0.04196929559111595,
-0.6719684600830078,
-0.5760557055473328,
-1.088741421699524,
-0.17123772203922272,
0.312289297580719,
0.09513881057500839,
0.33641719818115234,
-0.12419947981834412,
-0.6741631031036377,
-1.1486250162124634,
-0.6858746409416199,
-0.014206942170858383,
0.1383267641067505,
-0.1589938849210739,
0.3830724060535431,
-0.5303798317909241,
0.8660185933113098,
-0.2576547861099243,
-0.06857644021511078,
-0.7616737484931946,
0.16097690165042877,
0.30606040358543396,
-0.082600899040699,
0.518494725227356,
-0.9919188618659973,
-0.7341927886009216,
0.30727145075798035,
-0.7476766705513,
0.16869840025901794,
-0.0674750953912735,
0.02387569658458233,
0.5713390707969666,
0.20831997692584991,
-0.536851167678833,
0.23071715235710144,
1.0724151134490967,
-0.04127445071935654,
0.05002783238887787,
0.30680200457572937,
0.5856963396072388,
-1.4416948556900024,
0.09625217318534851,
0.14903034269809723,
-0.17844021320343018,
-0.6397559642791748,
-0.06719356030225754,
0.06339089572429657,
-0.3023531138896942,
-0.5941048860549927,
0.47112056612968445,
-0.4216173589229584,
0.20788909494876862,
-0.2099222093820572,
-0.04386749118566513,
-0.06609833240509033,
0.14632707834243774,
0.019475309178233147,
0.7614476680755615,
0.5373755097389221,
-0.1321161836385727,
0.14347007870674133,
0.19675618410110474,
-0.3028637766838074,
0.6957274079322815,
-0.6211069226264954,
-0.1318320631980896,
-0.31032854318618774,
0.022397872060537338,
-1.2707422971725464,
-0.01080225594341755,
0.04139767587184906,
-0.643619954586029,
0.2421472817659378,
-0.03942697122693062,
-0.21669989824295044,
-0.43648800253868103,
-0.3239845633506775,
0.07026957720518112,
0.6561214923858643,
-0.34093475341796875,
0.9761391878128052,
0.48615899682044983,
-0.049461591988801956,
-0.6952152848243713,
-0.8898236751556396,
0.19857992231845856,
-0.45775699615478516,
-0.718791663646698,
-0.15867586433887482,
0.11044943332672119,
-0.6151936650276184,
-0.1675739735364914,
0.09370584040880203,
-0.03704848513007164,
-0.09710332751274109,
0.3808402121067047,
0.12169669568538666,
-0.01620353013277054,
0.06568288803100586,
-0.13119377195835114,
-0.23338238894939423,
0.0775400698184967,
-0.044243987649679184,
0.4929167330265045,
-0.3677538335323334,
-0.2477663904428482,
-0.25573551654815674,
0.5701200366020203,
0.9370572566986084,
-0.2647946774959564,
0.9467133283615112,
0.7055771350860596,
-0.12286864221096039,
-0.00009850578499026597,
-0.5505731105804443,
0.08276709914207458,
-0.401449590921402,
0.3843804895877838,
-0.5354466438293457,
-0.7211889624595642,
0.7264177799224854,
-0.03566964343190193,
0.06632176786661148,
0.9128129482269287,
0.6665971279144287,
-0.0006263024406507611,
1.2353997230529785,
0.77717125415802,
-0.7018688917160034,
0.2910858392715454,
-0.04598063975572586,
0.7174161076545715,
-0.4789475202560425,
-0.11300214380025864,
-0.6415235996246338,
-0.2557462453842163,
-1.083297610282898,
-0.08933235704898834,
0.5259993076324463,
-0.14311672747135162,
0.41109007596969604,
0.20410695672035217,
-0.5736271739006042,
0.42939111590385437,
0.1092730388045311,
-0.33061683177948,
0.26792895793914795,
0.0605754517018795,
0.15309962630271912,
-0.4497048556804657,
-0.4755570590496063,
-0.7271503806114197,
0.8188723921775818,
0.36764827370643616,
0.5583764314651489,
-0.002954602474346757,
0.4326162338256836,
0.1803208887577057,
0.4958043098449707,
-0.9918315410614014,
0.2661391496658325,
-0.46562114357948303,
-0.40498775243759155,
-0.048894185572862625,
-0.20232461392879486,
-0.883041501045227,
0.5756710171699524,
0.1540999710559845,
-0.19670873880386353,
-0.022191351279616356,
-0.3563966751098633,
0.08641654998064041,
0.2576316297054291,
-0.7534788846969604,
0.8388129472732544,
-0.023876091465353966,
0.14692775905132294,
-0.2583619952201843,
-0.6821710467338562,
0.30521807074546814,
-0.10639315098524094,
0.7811968922615051,
0.15195810794830322,
0.2615486979484558,
0.753207266330719,
-0.053565457463264465,
0.7572216987609863,
-0.1541745960712433,
-0.22080819308757782,
0.2169916033744812,
-0.20702260732650757,
0.2821362018585205,
-0.13139405846595764,
-0.4294854402542114,
0.47958147525787354,
0.05543574318289757,
-0.2195635437965393,
-0.4061051607131958,
0.5457680821418762,
-0.8968688249588013,
-0.3079722821712494,
-0.3554088771343231,
-0.2915990948677063,
-0.2971106767654419,
-0.06392831355333328,
0.4839964509010315,
0.16024835407733917,
-0.12158971279859543,
0.201282799243927,
0.24128644168376923,
-0.26942625641822815,
0.6938943266868591,
0.3939433693885803,
-0.22765541076660156,
-0.3502904772758484,
0.836807370185852,
0.13453340530395508,
0.07226122915744781,
0.4443553686141968,
0.2536972761154175,
-0.4028773903846741,
0.0467367023229599,
-0.502758264541626,
0.2603481411933899,
-1.0123165845870972,
-0.10371696949005127,
-0.8512471318244934,
0.102116659283638,
-0.40266793966293335,
-0.2046714425086975,
-0.5977070927619934,
-0.24460114538669586,
0.3160744607448578,
-0.04944021627306938,
0.3710672855377197,
1.0616075992584229,
0.2583056688308716,
0.3578932285308838,
-1.075623631477356,
0.09223949164152145,
0.0028025757055729628,
0.3774206042289734,
-0.12153199315071106,
-0.46817144751548767,
-0.2888549268245697,
-0.051091745495796204,
-0.24577262997627258,
-0.9892733097076416,
0.6400113701820374,
-0.019061561673879623,
0.5352295637130737,
0.0001783089537639171,
-0.33153921365737915,
0.5583000183105469,
-0.41651451587677,
1.1548150777816772,
0.16799066960811615,
-1.165774941444397,
0.32074418663978577,
-0.12204750627279282,
0.47354093194007874,
0.3432287871837616,
0.8252397775650024,
-1.0300559997558594,
-0.5694155097007751,
-0.316383957862854,
-0.7864236831665039,
0.5098598003387451,
-0.04837580770254135,
0.5819056630134583,
-0.09167886525392532,
-0.14610795676708221,
0.3303057849407196,
0.0939493477344513,
-0.8444702625274658,
-0.33796560764312744,
-0.22119837999343872,
-0.2874908447265625,
-0.4169667959213257,
-0.1393522173166275,
0.07828687131404877,
-0.2926509380340576,
0.48617035150527954,
0.05596919730305672,
0.2670206129550934,
0.022625435143709183,
-0.3551616966724396,
0.0033165381755679846,
0.6274130940437317,
0.27662646770477295,
0.6086155772209167,
0.34302201867103577,
-0.06932926177978516,
0.394854336977005,
-0.44636932015419006,
0.023433413356542587,
-0.013291236944496632,
-0.038174569606781006,
0.3289467692375183,
0.3940870761871338,
0.8331990838050842,
0.28831174969673157,
-0.5138737559318542,
0.4096876084804535,
-0.2552756667137146,
0.12188027799129486,
-0.17406868934631348,
-0.3947684168815613,
0.17280638217926025,
0.13120238482952118,
0.2720596194267273,
0.26255422830581665,
0.22191153466701508,
-0.3506569564342499,
-0.10072585195302963,
0.30459120869636536,
-0.5946851372718811,
-0.6081711649894714,
0.43666884303092957,
0.11805975437164307,
-0.1961480975151062,
0.5688781142234802,
0.03726191818714142,
-0.9094700217247009,
0.2599847614765167,
0.2307506650686264,
1.082176923751831,
-0.3518311083316803,
0.16925601661205292,
0.21842719614505768,
0.3467823266983032,
-0.2311793714761734,
0.40579116344451904,
0.32467782497406006,
-0.6337172389030457,
-0.5653001070022583,
-0.8953632712364197,
-0.5280091166496277,
-0.32100412249565125,
-0.7753726243972778,
0.35446327924728394,
0.31405794620513916,
-0.40006953477859497,
0.10884270071983337,
-0.21915222704410553,
-0.9232404232025146,
0.31211477518081665,
0.17409667372703552,
0.5401040315628052,
-1.265238881111145,
0.5989141464233398,
1.1947146654129028,
-0.5274326205253601,
-0.6829301118850708,
-0.12933489680290222,
-0.13978277146816254,
-0.521895706653595,
0.6510050296783447,
0.25580406188964844,
-0.407381534576416,
-0.1620548963546753,
-0.29359447956085205,
-0.6473739147186279,
0.44309812784194946,
-0.06398925185203552,
-0.34397709369659424,
0.3269396126270294,
0.6166298389434814,
0.9549804329872131,
-0.20955021679401398,
0.571628212928772,
0.7770230174064636,
0.5184532999992371,
-0.21542610228061676,
-1.0326926708221436,
-0.4446727931499481,
-0.5113723278045654,
0.10235900431871414,
0.34775060415267944,
-0.7417680025100708,
0.7919056415557861,
0.34500211477279663,
-0.20618541538715363,
-0.38319194316864014,
0.4627043306827545,
-0.18917836248874664,
-0.023813264444470406,
0.4054654836654663,
0.2709754705429077,
0.4516791105270386,
-0.2004813551902771,
1.3591364622116089,
-0.613821268081665,
0.4639648199081421,
0.5005362033843994,
-0.24436694383621216,
0.9113385081291199,
0.47640466690063477,
-0.6875624060630798,
0.640595555305481,
0.32023701071739197,
0.12936672568321228,
0.17635351419448853,
-0.14940841495990753,
-0.1981699913740158,
-0.10690537095069885,
-0.15338283777236938,
-0.250357985496521,
0.6710112690925598,
0.2020386904478073,
-0.41860297322273254,
-0.08975669741630554,
0.38679239153862,
0.11264113336801529,
0.2436428666114807,
-0.16136321425437927,
0.6520883440971375,
0.15435610711574554,
-0.8189721703529358,
0.40516236424446106,
0.13845892250537872,
1.1127488613128662,
-0.43689659237861633,
0.2627474367618561,
-0.5003799796104431,
0.3017008304595947,
-0.3695749044418335,
-1.0478917360305786,
0.8075436353683472,
0.2101566642522812,
-0.4343816041946411,
-0.35505664348602295,
0.6071856021881104,
-0.24581286311149597,
-0.7709206938743591,
0.5856530070304871,
0.64390629529953,
0.2876771092414856,
-0.01627514511346817,
-0.5138164162635803,
0.34849750995635986,
0.12346165627241135,
-0.6232855916023254,
0.1966642588376999,
0.39138540625572205,
-0.23730593919754028,
0.673442006111145,
0.22064071893692017,
-0.07237136363983154,
0.22083629667758942,
0.25451940298080444,
0.6725753545761108,
-0.6461150646209717,
-0.291946142911911,
-1.0423123836517334,
0.905684232711792,
-0.009181071072816849,
-0.4476730525493622,
1.1303335428237915,
0.48737457394599915,
0.8827359080314636,
-0.3966740369796753,
1.1037756204605103,
-0.05942394211888313,
0.7353447079658508,
0.05540135130286217,
0.5650951862335205,
-0.46602165699005127,
-0.035355862230062485,
-0.4862833619117737,
-0.9835808873176575,
-0.4206864535808563,
0.6050224304199219,
-0.5277805924415588,
-0.03318134695291519,
0.6399986743927002,
0.6244843006134033,
0.0037558989133685827,
0.34599173069000244,
0.3305112421512604,
-0.023934774100780487,
0.32627540826797485,
0.07236827909946442,
1.018385887145996,
-0.7741844058036804,
0.5283117294311523,
-0.18671873211860657,
0.16587160527706146,
0.2746484577655792,
-0.6795831322669983,
-0.7084705233573914,
-0.4866984784603119,
-0.017670873552560806,
-0.3049418330192566,
-0.404012531042099,
0.7017179131507874,
0.4668644666671753,
-1.094072937965393,
-0.47106510400772095,
0.2602345943450928,
0.05615679547190666,
0.038221850991249084,
-0.26491332054138184,
0.20622561872005463,
-0.5587303638458252,
-1.0659005641937256,
0.28080540895462036,
0.15596045553684235,
-0.32280293107032776,
-0.5318905711174011,
0.055295005440711975,
0.1167406216263771,
0.12300568073987961,
0.8720201849937439,
-0.10109727829694748,
-0.633169412612915,
0.008308076299726963,
0.27856314182281494,
-0.22833746671676636,
0.2515244781970978,
1.0156350135803223,
-0.5770609378814697,
0.5742228031158447,
0.6215046644210815,
0.5586733818054199,
0.2027798295021057,
-0.00939442589879036,
0.4897453486919403,
-0.6443262696266174,
0.26159730553627014,
0.17817777395248413,
0.3105073869228363,
0.7349183559417725,
-0.12250377237796783,
0.43091100454330444,
0.09004299342632294,
-0.6000344753265381,
-0.6866816282272339,
-0.019973380491137505,
-0.4904095232486725,
-0.23103564977645874,
1.1297211647033691,
-0.044666409492492676,
0.04375651851296425,
-0.011264409869909286,
-0.10625584423542023,
0.10151135176420212,
-0.24823610484600067,
0.5443446636199951,
0.9557316899299622,
-0.05368529260158539,
-0.19326911866664886,
-0.5191892981529236,
0.34807640314102173,
0.5566790103912354,
-0.6764351725578308,
-0.07064598053693771,
0.28385233879089355,
0.17254376411437988,
0.36751052737236023,
0.41596677899360657,
-0.28843969106674194,
-0.24716973304748535,
-0.15010307729244232,
0.1788455843925476,
0.7414847612380981,
-0.16055485606193542,
-0.7164753079414368,
0.2805126905441284,
0.13754718005657196,
0.014868582598865032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02861v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02861v1
|
Revisiting a Pain in the Neck: Semantic Phrase Processing Benchmark for Language Models
| 2024-05-05T09:20:38 | 2024-05-05T09:20:38 |
Yang Liu, Melissa Xiaohui Qin, Hongming Li, Chao Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7
|
We introduce LexBench, a comprehensive evaluation suite enabled to test
language models (LMs) on ten semantic phrase processing tasks. Unlike prior
studies, it is the first work to propose a framework from the comparative
perspective to model the general semantic phrase (i.e., lexical collocation)
and three fine-grained semantic phrases, including idiomatic expression, noun
compound, and verbal construction. Thanks to \ourbenchmark, we assess the
performance of 15 LMs across model architectures and parameter scales in
classification, extraction, and interpretation tasks. Through the experiments,
we first validate the scaling law and find that, as expected, large models
excel better than the smaller ones in most tasks. Second, we investigate
further through the scaling semantic relation categorization and find that
few-shot LMs still lag behind vanilla fine-tuned models in the task. Third,
through human evaluation, we find that the performance of strong models is
comparable to the human level regarding semantic phrase processing. Our
benchmarking findings can serve future research aiming to improve the generic
capability of LMs on semantic phrase comprehension. Our source code and data
are available at https://github.com/jacklanda/LexBench
|
[
-0.2662559449672699,
-0.7398948073387146,
0.6951364874839783,
0.32622551918029785,
-0.3019838035106659,
0.06717313826084137,
-0.2814837098121643,
-0.6183888912200928,
-0.1143178716301918,
0.5594640970230103,
-0.4881417155265808,
-0.6892307996749878,
-0.34151825308799744,
0.1235443726181984,
-0.4392326772212982,
0.5130536556243896,
0.21895650029182434,
0.3085377812385559,
-0.36175185441970825,
-0.31225866079330444,
-0.33263203501701355,
-0.2945299744606018,
-0.6647557616233826,
-0.4464135766029358,
0.3770591616630554,
0.11557041853666306,
0.9460272192955017,
0.6145917773246765,
0.6600528955459595,
0.305045485496521,
-0.45190656185150146,
-0.18102014064788818,
-0.3790906071662903,
0.18653850257396698,
-0.46632060408592224,
-0.2796131372451782,
-0.38672226667404175,
0.02219988778233528,
0.6636085510253906,
1.192474365234375,
-0.08484651893377304,
0.1835562139749527,
-0.0795229822397232,
0.5441619157791138,
-0.542276918888092,
-0.00847186055034399,
-0.9024602174758911,
-0.13231918215751648,
-0.29060477018356323,
0.18630993366241455,
-0.37144196033477783,
-0.16161653399467468,
-0.08814810961484909,
-0.256098210811615,
0.3126884698867798,
0.25370675325393677,
1.092500925064087,
0.2575625479221344,
-0.14747853577136993,
-0.05387573689222336,
-0.11488228291273117,
0.5494011044502258,
-0.7611560225486755,
0.32069525122642517,
0.08686592429876328,
0.20118707418441772,
-0.17872123420238495,
-0.9528942704200745,
-0.48288223147392273,
-0.49572721123695374,
0.04791199043393135,
-0.12491968274116516,
-0.5029996633529663,
0.17902636528015137,
0.4949834644794464,
0.5156201124191284,
-0.6932821869850159,
0.3635103404521942,
-0.11724840849637985,
-0.041438546031713486,
0.46688708662986755,
0.35487431287765503,
0.26487964391708374,
-0.34321656823158264,
-0.5645673871040344,
-0.24590234458446503,
-0.6263771057128906,
-0.024979908019304276,
0.09755506366491318,
0.6108151078224182,
0.07436078041791916,
0.6062560677528381,
-0.45049262046813965,
1.0288395881652832,
-0.2696743309497833,
0.21862326562404633,
0.3423459529876709,
-0.30643126368522644,
-0.2208860069513321,
-0.0564713180065155,
0.7700563669204712,
0.48254725337028503,
0.13050982356071472,
-0.4374077022075653,
-0.14472341537475586,
0.2633267641067505,
0.43663087487220764,
-0.8482085466384888,
0.1156173050403595,
0.03635014593601227,
-0.4900455176830292,
-0.07699070870876312,
-0.07663960754871368,
-0.8029826879501343,
-0.4618426561355591,
-0.3093256950378418,
0.2716910243034363,
-0.4081394672393799,
-0.3228420913219452,
0.519061267375946,
-0.1984904706478119,
0.4157346189022064,
-0.03627566993236542,
-0.4810621440410614,
0.749660313129425,
1.0645893812179565,
0.8966711163520813,
-0.20424628257751465,
-0.1916639655828476,
-0.5182061195373535,
-0.2681572735309601,
-0.398273766040802,
0.8952357172966003,
-0.5333824157714844,
-0.47939613461494446,
0.02492561563849449,
0.0397387370467186,
-0.23325395584106445,
-0.9132415056228638,
0.6665985584259033,
-0.47131407260894775,
-0.3837842643260956,
-0.2481885403394699,
-0.8955315947532654,
0.08987332880496979,
0.24671775102615356,
-0.7107793688774109,
0.9220218658447266,
0.2040993720293045,
-0.6129909157752991,
0.09198702126741409,
-0.5418090224266052,
-0.40871599316596985,
0.07777781039476395,
-0.13547003269195557,
-0.26874539256095886,
0.5032100081443787,
-0.1487342119216919,
0.27616116404533386,
-0.7646183967590332,
0.10336008667945862,
-0.6968020796775818,
-0.3376794159412384,
0.3162047564983368,
0.15329235792160034,
0.7796416282653809,
0.31483370065689087,
-0.148732528090477,
0.15436753630638123,
-0.9696775674819946,
0.3983016014099121,
0.12221864610910416,
-0.010395013727247715,
-0.35311034321784973,
-0.1628553867340088,
0.06707870215177536,
0.3238169848918915,
0.05328800529241562,
-0.6962971091270447,
-0.07259970903396606,
-0.3542797863483429,
0.26179543137550354,
0.4071384370326996,
-0.16486574709415436,
0.29666978120803833,
0.03945473954081535,
0.5506468415260315,
-0.1947195678949356,
-0.18519087135791779,
0.03011564165353775,
-0.19229942560195923,
-0.6269990801811218,
0.014801086857914925,
0.43958088755607605,
0.34997278451919556,
-0.3976166546344757,
0.32194241881370544,
-0.4594467580318451,
-0.5897854566574097,
-0.4648403823375702,
0.07976610958576202,
0.6155785322189331,
0.4791755676269531,
0.39242732524871826,
-0.4125130772590637,
-0.22832728922367096,
-0.9532756805419922,
-0.6187735199928284,
-0.34194159507751465,
-0.22847941517829895,
-0.07570088654756546,
0.36815711855888367,
0.04568059369921684,
1.0835107564926147,
-0.5405973792076111,
-0.2626805007457733,
-0.5502191781997681,
0.611402153968811,
0.06028501316905022,
0.3335686922073364,
0.48143669962882996,
-0.6242116689682007,
-0.15821774303913116,
-0.0601826049387455,
-0.5923119783401489,
-0.3984886705875397,
0.09885773807764053,
-0.004611689131706953,
0.06027529388666153,
0.9887152314186096,
-0.5544611215591431,
0.2901298701763153,
0.4741000831127167,
-0.4369332194328308,
0.5513631701469421,
0.001728854957036674,
-0.3766746520996094,
-0.8558013439178467,
0.18701104819774628,
-0.18762165307998657,
-0.1138133853673935,
-0.42848896980285645,
0.49894624948501587,
0.26913172006607056,
-0.19224593043327332,
-0.43046149611473083,
0.5853258967399597,
-0.2800997197628021,
-0.49537450075149536,
-0.39935240149497986,
0.3256917893886566,
0.07937052100896835,
0.2134413719177246,
-0.011109840124845505,
0.7408632636070251,
0.40420737862586975,
-0.35748162865638733,
0.30529603362083435,
-0.04768936708569527,
-0.48638883233070374,
0.6552841067314148,
-0.9901372790336609,
0.12691962718963623,
0.07659430801868439,
0.0017351910937577486,
-0.8919631242752075,
-0.037348099052906036,
-0.13232609629631042,
-0.2897210717201233,
0.1727052479982376,
-0.058857567608356476,
-0.6998880505561829,
-0.2958272695541382,
-0.16226114332675934,
0.14168810844421387,
0.3205752670764923,
-0.3614901602268219,
0.5200994610786438,
0.33802297711372375,
-0.013523992151021957,
-0.03846634179353714,
-0.574684739112854,
0.3078813850879669,
-0.22467976808547974,
-0.617123544216156,
0.5912817120552063,
0.06107371672987938,
-0.6952901482582092,
0.1468699872493744,
-0.2653777599334717,
-0.1635429859161377,
0.36265555024147034,
0.028426360338926315,
0.026029545813798904,
-0.3126835525035858,
0.6207531690597534,
-0.2861623167991638,
-0.23871548473834991,
0.15609993040561676,
-0.04998696222901344,
0.6819748282432556,
-0.6415712833404541,
-0.15436013042926788,
-0.1896650791168213,
0.2381541132926941,
0.2050132304430008,
-0.40646234154701233,
0.5102651715278625,
0.6571567058563232,
-0.20830346643924713,
0.03120904415845871,
-0.5110027194023132,
-0.02402641624212265,
-0.38237810134887695,
0.4987364411354065,
-0.7074511647224426,
-0.9194035530090332,
0.5089414119720459,
-0.36850422620773315,
-0.22444701194763184,
0.5642379522323608,
0.20842047035694122,
0.22435270249843597,
0.8603123426437378,
0.5926204323768616,
-0.11649616062641144,
0.15548458695411682,
-0.07569172233343124,
0.14939330518245697,
-0.7545139193534851,
0.3812342584133148,
-0.8709561824798584,
-0.15729592740535736,
-0.7418665885925293,
-0.5415759086608887,
0.24295522272586823,
0.39974522590637207,
-0.05412883684039116,
0.4241706132888794,
0.006911732722073793,
0.54157555103302,
0.26648277044296265,
-0.09462542086839676,
0.2442985624074936,
-0.26535341143608093,
-0.3659868538379669,
-0.08535654097795486,
-0.5620063543319702,
-0.4604996144771576,
0.7601532936096191,
0.19571031630039215,
0.6897640824317932,
-0.009103991091251373,
0.7496441602706909,
0.06099231541156769,
-0.008841216564178467,
-0.8824971318244934,
0.8689154386520386,
-0.4724484384059906,
-0.4529188871383667,
-0.20421496033668518,
-0.3429417610168457,
-0.9502065777778625,
0.5854030251502991,
0.050221942365169525,
-0.820236325263977,
0.07023418694734573,
-0.1720389872789383,
-0.5069862008094788,
0.24207249283790588,
-0.46188145875930786,
1.40700364112854,
-0.06758247315883636,
-0.6644253134727478,
-0.518714964389801,
-0.7418736815452576,
0.17576943337917328,
0.10008050501346588,
0.27854377031326294,
-0.5164333581924438,
-0.09319734573364258,
0.46826207637786865,
-0.5193964838981628,
0.6420855522155762,
-0.09656467288732529,
0.03299187868833542,
0.14437370002269745,
0.15647122263908386,
0.18802465498447418,
-0.10996132344007492,
-0.311270147562027,
0.11519931256771088,
0.10051973164081573,
-0.3738597333431244,
-0.4909150004386902,
0.581665575504303,
-0.3357800245285034,
-0.3891700506210327,
-0.4095909595489502,
-0.4277117848396301,
-0.4533040225505829,
0.13448885083198547,
-0.0097683509811759,
0.5643682479858398,
-0.5030052661895752,
0.27502337098121643,
0.4110603332519531,
-0.20209738612174988,
0.3994157016277313,
0.5778964757919312,
-0.3297538757324219,
-0.027706805616617203,
0.7031587958335876,
-0.22245272994041443,
0.4647236168384552,
0.3640550971031189,
0.10633401572704315,
-0.17096447944641113,
-0.6201948523521423,
-0.20306767523288727,
0.33366528153419495,
-0.7634251117706299,
-0.2128240168094635,
-0.4871140420436859,
-0.136801615357399,
-0.3663160800933838,
0.21945424377918243,
-0.6436225771903992,
-0.33750903606414795,
-0.005719707813113928,
0.021975023671984673,
0.18848219513893127,
0.5002617835998535,
-0.03653837740421295,
0.46509861946105957,
-0.6948462128639221,
0.3302745223045349,
0.13118687272071838,
0.37921395897865295,
-0.31410953402519226,
-0.25954851508140564,
-0.1942695826292038,
-0.2610854208469391,
-0.22803087532520294,
-0.5106995105743408,
0.2675172686576843,
0.22714927792549133,
0.39550837874412537,
0.23270605504512787,
0.13453301787376404,
0.908555269241333,
-0.569391131401062,
0.7592508792877197,
0.09924787282943726,
-1.067118525505066,
0.31297481060028076,
-0.003928761463612318,
0.6791250109672546,
0.7673080563545227,
0.08988001942634583,
-0.7128995060920715,
-0.48675987124443054,
-0.6127232313156128,
-0.9551318287849426,
0.5432175993919373,
-0.027639277279376984,
0.09412699192762375,
-0.3272726833820343,
0.2678711414337158,
-0.04854515939950943,
0.04064720496535301,
-0.5044216513633728,
0.07827101647853851,
0.2977317273616791,
-0.1092037558555603,
-0.24979305267333984,
-0.380662739276886,
0.09063991159200668,
-0.07846866548061371,
0.3248213827610016,
-0.312402606010437,
0.1436019390821457,
0.09934530407190323,
-0.47532185912132263,
-0.04383260756731033,
0.4142463803291321,
0.37337812781333923,
0.8120746612548828,
-0.29916563630104065,
0.22693754732608795,
0.07233083993196487,
0.03743050992488861,
-0.3268938660621643,
0.3392355144023895,
0.07628820836544037,
0.3938657343387604,
0.4648888111114502,
0.7953351736068726,
0.7555275559425354,
-0.8736416101455688,
0.4129568934440613,
-0.23881952464580536,
-0.05546402186155319,
-0.2289627492427826,
-0.11056865006685257,
0.2528674900531769,
0.2165684998035431,
-0.08070264011621475,
-0.2718222141265869,
0.30118855834007263,
-0.4119873344898224,
0.20234976708889008,
0.4201827645301819,
-0.40224456787109375,
-0.21703346073627472,
0.5546768307685852,
-0.1668124496936798,
-0.036872074007987976,
0.5570276975631714,
-0.39090919494628906,
-0.4766617715358734,
0.4218460023403168,
0.3674216568470001,
0.9034653306007385,
-0.005796119105070829,
0.15730591118335724,
0.4655704200267792,
0.06812164187431335,
-0.23548074066638947,
0.2081276923418045,
-0.14697977900505066,
-0.7247960567474365,
-0.18996627628803253,
-0.8896410465240479,
-0.46982496976852417,
-0.16063129901885986,
-1.0219162702560425,
0.1563108265399933,
-0.2502095699310303,
-0.2597016394138336,
0.28557702898979187,
0.000055867367336759344,
-0.5735288262367249,
0.02552703768014908,
0.12498386949300766,
1.089692234992981,
-0.5023531317710876,
0.8601670861244202,
0.6083176732063293,
-0.45502352714538574,
-0.5585065484046936,
0.03454401716589928,
0.1390308439731598,
-0.7359609603881836,
0.7717109322547913,
0.2944028675556183,
-0.2627353370189667,
-0.045813463628292084,
-0.36119717359542847,
-0.760270893573761,
0.7160541415214539,
0.1898779273033142,
-0.559220552444458,
-0.02902344800531864,
0.34722596406936646,
0.8094714879989624,
-0.40273937582969666,
-0.08382991701364517,
0.9713167548179626,
0.23121021687984467,
0.11300724744796753,
-1.026044487953186,
-0.014686753042042255,
-0.2661411464214325,
0.4424533247947693,
0.04353693500161171,
-0.37388843297958374,
1.0233588218688965,
-0.023325426504015923,
-0.18886961042881012,
0.61726313829422,
0.6196757555007935,
0.06690388172864914,
0.14319726824760437,
0.7227692604064941,
0.8832330107688904,
0.613617479801178,
-0.22588320076465607,
1.3495017290115356,
-0.4035947024822235,
0.28602227568626404,
1.5917482376098633,
-0.6569482088088989,
1.207701563835144,
0.5629522204399109,
-0.3869333863258362,
0.4263104796409607,
0.5477328300476074,
0.11994406580924988,
0.3381897807121277,
0.5740953683853149,
-0.12790651619434357,
-0.3979859948158264,
-0.37196823954582214,
-0.3359874486923218,
0.7232790589332581,
0.28060615062713623,
-0.25692620873451233,
-0.5787379145622253,
-0.06527956575155258,
0.19611117243766785,
0.3206615447998047,
-0.326331228017807,
0.9213389158248901,
0.16620370745658875,
-0.5600075721740723,
0.633614182472229,
0.1509409099817276,
0.20802055299282074,
-0.7359314560890198,
0.31858202815055847,
-0.24408060312271118,
0.5901076793670654,
0.2861440181732178,
-0.49557843804359436,
0.48117250204086304,
-0.023918097838759422,
0.1212010532617569,
-0.15553462505340576,
0.764922022819519,
-0.31347891688346863,
-0.39256981015205383,
0.6724604964256287,
0.5132801532745361,
0.2448669970035553,
-0.38449349999427795,
-0.7810114622116089,
0.5159934163093567,
-0.4193897247314453,
-0.11254993826150894,
0.4304981529712677,
0.4630871117115021,
0.014676854945719242,
0.4050239622592926,
0.20484541356563568,
0.14014273881912231,
0.09712864458560944,
0.5440546870231628,
0.8246484994888306,
-0.8973269462585449,
-0.3730066120624542,
-0.7597039937973022,
0.2751602232456207,
-0.3632335662841797,
-0.3664116859436035,
0.684910774230957,
0.5566306114196777,
1.0762300491333008,
-0.00854047853499651,
0.28791677951812744,
-0.0673692375421524,
0.7962878942489624,
-0.554637610912323,
0.35255348682403564,
-0.7025027871131897,
0.17749032378196716,
-0.2657264769077301,
-0.6830489635467529,
-0.6024205088615417,
0.53715580701828,
-0.3764086663722992,
-0.16608791053295135,
0.972229540348053,
0.8770076632499695,
0.16402941942214966,
0.1578417867422104,
0.40854740142822266,
0.2880658805370331,
0.10463161766529083,
0.18747952580451965,
0.8721387982368469,
-0.357950896024704,
0.3261502981185913,
-0.45414406061172485,
0.05022478848695755,
-0.14558064937591553,
-0.8035150766372681,
-0.629977822303772,
-0.36413341760635376,
-0.33376094698905945,
-0.3285841643810272,
0.09480589628219604,
0.9704570770263672,
0.45628607273101807,
-0.6209152340888977,
-0.7664443254470825,
-0.2163822203874588,
0.08511829376220703,
-0.42323899269104004,
-0.2479224056005478,
0.2491302788257599,
-1.118278980255127,
-0.6349509954452515,
0.38016441464424133,
0.17914824187755585,
-0.27806809544563293,
0.04598386585712433,
0.05981094017624855,
-0.1355953812599182,
-0.24191169440746307,
0.684158444404602,
0.1311068832874298,
-0.8812476992607117,
-0.24491603672504425,
-0.18063519895076752,
-0.21077339351177216,
-0.020470192655920982,
1.0477285385131836,
-0.6624700427055359,
0.5467076897621155,
0.23293519020080566,
0.7745357751846313,
0.2992609739303589,
-0.15280528366565704,
0.46565747261047363,
-0.5150202512741089,
0.23061828315258026,
0.09948182851076126,
0.5537023544311523,
0.2878621518611908,
0.2699623107910156,
0.8421253561973572,
0.16126073896884918,
-0.23279954493045807,
-0.9407066702842712,
0.20953458547592163,
-1.1161292791366577,
-0.5286607146263123,
0.9611398577690125,
-0.28765419125556946,
-0.38097450137138367,
0.11863701790571213,
-0.11963066458702087,
0.05927570164203644,
0.05021197348833084,
0.4925827085971832,
0.5922648906707764,
-0.07773972302675247,
-0.0689178854227066,
-0.4885229766368866,
0.387836217880249,
0.5783307552337646,
-0.6987748742103577,
0.3622467517852783,
0.5482388138771057,
0.21448995172977448,
0.1329205334186554,
0.28307488560676575,
-0.34751972556114197,
0.33007892966270447,
0.1639370322227478,
0.23262189328670502,
0.15021181106567383,
0.03441695123910904,
-0.6592875719070435,
0.2746063768863678,
0.3349108397960663,
-0.08889303356409073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02858v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02858v1
|
Language Evolution for Evading Social Media Regulation via LLM-based Multi-agent Simulation
| 2024-05-05T09:02:54 | 2024-05-05T09:02:54 |
Jinyu Cai, Jialong Li, Mingyue Zhang, Munan Li, Chen-Shu Wang, Kenji Tei
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.CL
|
Social media platforms such as Twitter, Reddit, and Sina Weibo play a crucial
role in global communication but often encounter strict regulations in
geopolitically sensitive regions. This situation has prompted users to
ingeniously modify their way of communicating, frequently resorting to coded
language in these regulated social media environments. This shift in
communication is not merely a strategy to counteract regulation, but a vivid
manifestation of language evolution, demonstrating how language naturally
evolves under societal and technological pressures. Studying the evolution of
language in regulated social media contexts is of significant importance for
ensuring freedom of speech, optimizing content moderation, and advancing
linguistic research. This paper proposes a multi-agent simulation framework
using Large Language Models (LLMs) to explore the evolution of user language in
regulated social media environments. The framework employs LLM-driven agents:
supervisory agent who enforce dialogue supervision and participant agents who
evolve their language strategies while engaging in conversation, simulating the
evolution of communication styles under strict regulations aimed at evading
social media regulation. The study evaluates the framework's effectiveness
through a range of scenarios from abstract scenarios to real-world situations.
Key findings indicate that LLMs are capable of simulating nuanced language
dynamics and interactions in constrained settings, showing improvement in both
evading supervision and information accuracy as evolution progresses.
Furthermore, it was found that LLM agents adopt different strategies for
different scenarios.
|
[
-0.36628663539886475,
-1.343162178993225,
0.4725889563560486,
0.4394756555557251,
-0.4613637924194336,
0.4627740979194641,
-0.6308927536010742,
-0.29805949330329895,
0.4031424820423126,
0.6752532720565796,
-0.6078410148620605,
-0.30348023772239685,
-0.47878775000572205,
0.22546015679836273,
-0.4587276577949524,
0.857682466506958,
-0.12091397494077682,
-0.13071341812610626,
0.07663404196500778,
0.10274101048707962,
-0.09071217477321625,
-0.5518789887428284,
-0.6267573237419128,
-0.36919450759887695,
0.5911508798599243,
0.1519412398338318,
0.44139179587364197,
0.35494959354400635,
0.5008827447891235,
0.30668285489082336,
-0.31256282329559326,
0.3522529602050781,
-0.8227437138557434,
0.1732957512140274,
-0.08265473693609238,
-0.06065322831273079,
-0.26153677701950073,
-0.2731805741786957,
0.6562893390655518,
0.09221995621919632,
-0.4066471755504608,
0.010796263813972473,
0.18720965087413788,
0.22411341965198517,
-0.49508413672447205,
0.27045902609825134,
-0.7042372822761536,
-0.42928197979927063,
0.15309499204158783,
-0.6858136653900146,
-0.2991539239883423,
-0.31295180320739746,
-0.09236142784357071,
-0.39937981963157654,
-0.18684272468090057,
-0.17047110199928284,
0.8393037915229797,
-0.04189985245466232,
-0.4872713088989258,
-0.26627659797668457,
-1.1083314418792725,
0.5011731386184692,
-0.5749393701553345,
0.2955017685890198,
0.07824835181236267,
0.44638925790786743,
-0.44634202122688293,
-0.8755159378051758,
-0.6138029098510742,
-0.18499068915843964,
0.30959275364875793,
0.1136820986866951,
-0.23250658810138702,
0.08847497403621674,
0.0930689349770546,
-0.3288179934024811,
0.023078881204128265,
0.24525342881679535,
-0.39229056239128113,
0.13440978527069092,
0.7174846529960632,
-0.04115310311317444,
0.35060834884643555,
-0.10849164426326752,
-0.347851425409317,
-0.16230018436908722,
-0.625095546245575,
-0.0726824477314949,
0.49041512608528137,
0.5228326916694641,
-0.259162575006485,
0.14620323479175568,
-0.11819905787706375,
0.2112210988998413,
-0.0906338170170784,
-0.17995162308216095,
0.20109467208385468,
-0.2060481458902359,
-0.0844932571053505,
0.03705914318561554,
0.8869200348854065,
0.5053291320800781,
0.452939510345459,
0.15382294356822968,
-0.23399050533771515,
0.080824114382267,
0.4128659665584564,
-0.7113398909568787,
0.15284568071365356,
0.15605662763118744,
-0.34059199690818787,
-0.5966999530792236,
-0.01584543101489544,
-0.969265341758728,
-0.7177838683128357,
-0.21136215329170227,
0.22060707211494446,
-0.20515145361423492,
-0.5533828735351562,
0.163905531167984,
-0.06643476337194443,
0.45092666149139404,
0.3456587791442871,
-0.7855791449546814,
0.291660875082016,
0.7785087823867798,
0.8638234734535217,
-0.01315285637974739,
-0.4061402380466461,
-0.3173922002315521,
0.23420502245426178,
-0.4109961688518524,
0.5724958777427673,
-0.5365576148033142,
-0.4015811085700989,
0.5332357287406921,
0.09549430757761002,
0.02942005731165409,
-0.2513381838798523,
0.49057093262672424,
-0.9238491058349609,
-0.302249550819397,
-0.09127334505319595,
-0.2540989816188812,
0.004991603083908558,
0.168960303068161,
-0.6342015266418457,
0.6469136476516724,
-0.03514685109257698,
-0.5217634439468384,
0.2671445608139038,
-0.9229752421379089,
-0.5044355392456055,
0.2990629971027374,
-0.26356935501098633,
-0.3731118142604828,
0.004443638492375612,
0.07656440138816833,
0.43431270122528076,
-0.2739071249961853,
0.43226197361946106,
-0.6415206789970398,
-0.4800034463405609,
0.5270899534225464,
-0.5264207720756531,
0.605925977230072,
0.1563124656677246,
-0.36239415407180786,
0.34619030356407166,
-0.42092353105545044,
-0.11199483275413513,
0.2966601848602295,
-0.36936283111572266,
-0.17084890604019165,
0.26776668429374695,
0.24456240236759186,
0.36385059356689453,
-0.059675056487321854,
-0.3860521912574768,
0.05951880291104317,
-0.16627563536167145,
0.7548685669898987,
0.9050047993659973,
0.6765310764312744,
0.26058080792427063,
-0.5117105841636658,
0.6162399649620056,
-0.2349662333726883,
0.36649981141090393,
0.14085006713867188,
-0.30549219250679016,
-0.41616398096084595,
-0.15689706802368164,
-0.01374395564198494,
0.4780760109424591,
-0.8939452171325684,
0.08793816715478897,
-0.5066367387771606,
-0.43048742413520813,
-0.6884374022483826,
0.2539331912994385,
-0.00018803596321959049,
-0.255252867937088,
0.15255582332611084,
0.2206559181213379,
-0.4303230345249176,
-0.7084397673606873,
-0.2718552052974701,
-0.40671980381011963,
0.16116617619991302,
0.26194489002227783,
0.34413331747055054,
-0.638318657875061,
0.8064360618591309,
-0.11405358463525772,
0.128135085105896,
-0.7276453971862793,
0.06085136532783508,
-0.24952000379562378,
0.06439733505249023,
0.5042679905891418,
-0.9373906254768372,
-0.4901462197303772,
0.14187324047088623,
-0.49402573704719543,
-0.5168489813804626,
-0.5842934846878052,
-0.11031894385814667,
0.2714564800262451,
0.7483767867088318,
-0.4249982237815857,
0.28481075167655945,
0.7582530379295349,
-0.007393965031951666,
0.6681729555130005,
-0.0718550980091095,
0.25936445593833923,
-1.1788524389266968,
-0.07912604510784149,
0.07034044712781906,
-0.36612263321876526,
-0.9412345290184021,
0.2386936992406845,
0.04522324725985527,
0.16394120454788208,
-0.6721038818359375,
0.6695887446403503,
-0.5438957810401917,
0.21638859808444977,
-0.5462908148765564,
0.29771047830581665,
-0.3271268308162689,
0.4686105251312256,
-0.20043295621871948,
0.6101062297821045,
0.6097002625465393,
-0.7435594797134399,
0.4476601183414459,
-0.0947527214884758,
-0.41787174344062805,
0.1523173600435257,
-0.46619558334350586,
0.13866733014583588,
-0.1631097048521042,
0.24207916855812073,
-0.6228758096694946,
-0.329008013010025,
0.23949460685253143,
-0.16391851007938385,
0.14656636118888855,
-0.0366329587996006,
-0.7769370675086975,
-0.2433752417564392,
-0.45650532841682434,
0.04022888094186783,
0.4757038354873657,
-0.4408648610115051,
0.7327548861503601,
0.5072740316390991,
-0.16082793474197388,
-0.4186185598373413,
-0.5284789800643921,
0.2829135060310364,
-0.5486771464347839,
-0.594340443611145,
0.14150460064411163,
-0.2293156385421753,
-0.6356877088546753,
-0.23712114989757538,
0.1873350292444229,
0.17472253739833832,
0.35942700505256653,
0.13356660306453705,
0.01163778267800808,
0.026592079550027847,
-0.06825774163007736,
0.3658767342567444,
0.5122179388999939,
0.29311010241508484,
0.17702560126781464,
0.9309093952178955,
-0.1629100739955902,
-0.12855829298496246,
-0.6235154271125793,
0.1297561675310135,
0.6536704897880554,
0.06293228268623352,
0.8165764808654785,
0.3987332284450531,
-0.15699324011802673,
-0.5049825310707092,
-0.54202800989151,
-0.43318283557891846,
-0.5854565501213074,
0.3669722080230713,
-0.17794883251190186,
-0.9116199612617493,
0.7160665988922119,
-0.40980371832847595,
0.2403632402420044,
0.014494632370769978,
0.7394366264343262,
0.13246071338653564,
0.7952011227607727,
0.7404838800430298,
0.21181951463222504,
0.8856886029243469,
0.14865364134311676,
0.03877260908484459,
-0.514325737953186,
0.042036090046167374,
-0.19202598929405212,
-0.12579192221164703,
-0.8116245865821838,
-0.4188077449798584,
0.1652640849351883,
-0.011219724081456661,
0.15976321697235107,
0.3695716857910156,
0.21067996323108673,
0.503797173500061,
0.23020870983600616,
0.07774879038333893,
0.13502469658851624,
0.24853353202342987,
0.06686823815107346,
0.28068941831588745,
-0.5092034339904785,
-0.6921794414520264,
0.8456773161888123,
0.5080787539482117,
0.933476984500885,
0.2727710008621216,
0.7972836494445801,
0.5974485278129578,
0.6636509299278259,
-0.5237532258033752,
0.6774930357933044,
0.10143779963254929,
-0.4086841940879822,
-0.1764819622039795,
-0.5526440143585205,
-0.7803381681442261,
0.35721367597579956,
-0.41310369968414307,
-0.7978705167770386,
0.12544786930084229,
-0.008030052296817303,
-0.0721011832356453,
0.22841821610927582,
-0.619563639163971,
0.6378659605979919,
-0.2880954146385193,
-0.4863334000110626,
-0.2721313536167145,
-0.63248610496521,
0.23706144094467163,
-0.4895896911621094,
0.501847505569458,
-0.05310741439461708,
-0.039415739476680756,
0.4655638635158539,
-0.05049329623579979,
1.110459327697754,
0.06954700499773026,
-0.2605169117450714,
0.5821782350540161,
0.03876958787441254,
0.5224506855010986,
0.06707338988780975,
0.022016534581780434,
0.053450699895620346,
-0.022632550448179245,
-0.1939191073179245,
-0.4921702444553375,
0.6176000237464905,
-0.8945359587669373,
-0.5168851613998413,
-0.025625234469771385,
-0.26769816875457764,
-0.16767455637454987,
0.22733080387115479,
0.15258504450321198,
0.094878189265728,
-0.526103675365448,
0.2332601398229599,
0.2256351262331009,
-0.18932276964187622,
0.440544992685318,
0.6437873244285583,
-0.39939039945602417,
-0.3318367302417755,
0.7132144570350647,
0.008252554573118687,
0.48276254534721375,
0.04187627136707306,
0.4332486093044281,
-0.2725136876106262,
-0.31047293543815613,
-0.24553558230400085,
0.4295390248298645,
-0.7470405101776123,
-0.07094233483076096,
-0.628582239151001,
-0.3391640782356262,
-0.5946969389915466,
-0.20919343829154968,
0.0302264466881752,
0.03357238695025444,
-0.10539592802524567,
-0.13035021722316742,
0.187748521566391,
0.7440758347511292,
-0.13458043336868286,
0.6653608083724976,
-0.47751855850219727,
-0.009936350397765636,
0.1326466053724289,
0.27754896879196167,
-0.2391846925020218,
-0.5310289263725281,
-0.10724718868732452,
0.19630928337574005,
-0.257725328207016,
-1.2173222303390503,
0.2699136734008789,
0.07536498457193375,
0.5099285244941711,
0.5253989696502686,
0.1364981234073639,
0.5400993824005127,
-0.5099683403968811,
0.37409335374832153,
-0.06887750327587128,
-0.8067429661750793,
0.2768091857433319,
-0.6022861003875732,
-0.057458363473415375,
0.34851279854774475,
-0.006163108162581921,
-0.929682731628418,
-0.8446056842803955,
-0.4519668519496918,
-0.8409826755523682,
0.6703386902809143,
0.17561164498329163,
0.7490349411964417,
-0.02146906964480877,
0.44119444489479065,
-0.1994534581899643,
0.2752474844455719,
-1.0105094909667969,
0.03703093156218529,
0.10865648835897446,
0.03196655213832855,
0.02105766534805298,
-0.35739126801490784,
-0.35698971152305603,
0.11625775694847107,
0.698514997959137,
-0.057143330574035645,
0.16779457032680511,
-0.16398967802524567,
-0.020565340295433998,
-0.22656098008155823,
0.534965455532074,
0.8274957537651062,
0.6133903861045837,
-0.05760408937931061,
-0.053819820284843445,
0.0699286088347435,
-0.422607421875,
-0.017075829207897186,
0.0029240516014397144,
-0.32172244787216187,
-0.14616763591766357,
0.13618196547031403,
0.9565380811691284,
0.13751763105392456,
-0.81302410364151,
0.5079946517944336,
-0.16296590864658356,
-0.41404351592063904,
-0.2780005633831024,
0.10346245765686035,
0.22841961681842804,
0.5773957371711731,
0.27942076325416565,
-0.3905295133590698,
-0.1108599454164505,
-0.5776811242103577,
0.2079574018716812,
0.36821213364601135,
-0.1954858899116516,
-0.27503299713134766,
0.39412471652030945,
0.2524521052837372,
-0.5594484806060791,
-0.0024006208404898643,
-0.3989724814891815,
-0.4542061984539032,
0.631925642490387,
0.7837207317352295,
1.0732409954071045,
-0.18838763236999512,
0.42337533831596375,
-0.04603103548288345,
0.5164626240730286,
-0.20109935104846954,
0.25863322615623474,
0.1670629382133484,
-0.8950406908988953,
-0.2553366720676422,
-0.697008490562439,
-0.5383193492889404,
0.36500269174575806,
-0.3110835552215576,
0.6600078344345093,
-0.5716301202774048,
-0.33166199922561646,
-0.06663355231285095,
-0.22893422842025757,
-0.26760634779930115,
-0.3805968165397644,
0.30226826667785645,
0.6277084350585938,
-0.9180372953414917,
0.8338899612426758,
0.8866898417472839,
-0.03942784667015076,
-0.5211696624755859,
0.4835294485092163,
0.12878185510635376,
-0.6986542344093323,
0.25981375575065613,
0.2839895784854889,
-0.5802816152572632,
0.08194748312234879,
-0.9209641814231873,
-0.5298343896865845,
0.9278560280799866,
0.33472591638565063,
-0.4025409519672394,
0.13051117956638336,
0.12829044461250305,
1.0654957294464111,
-0.3989860415458679,
-0.09795187413692474,
0.31356897950172424,
0.1791873276233673,
-0.01289746630936861,
-0.6234083771705627,
0.02604067698121071,
-0.23946556448936462,
0.16376125812530518,
0.14935994148254395,
-0.801076352596283,
0.6422597169876099,
-0.057393476366996765,
-0.6796729564666748,
-0.17150163650512695,
0.5375593304634094,
0.1634409874677658,
0.24344120919704437,
0.5263832807540894,
-0.27384230494499207,
0.24187037348747253,
0.24415019154548645,
0.7770220041275024,
-0.6750982999801636,
0.4629666209220886,
0.811621367931366,
-0.6252231597900391,
0.9601598381996155,
0.39304840564727783,
0.29618358612060547,
0.7521926164627075,
0.4386845529079437,
0.03647742420434952,
0.2246972620487213,
0.3287338316440582,
-0.35550588369369507,
-0.117153599858284,
-0.29978516697883606,
-0.07601940631866455,
0.6213614344596863,
0.4094218313694,
-0.2799977660179138,
-0.1388026922941208,
-0.0516069270670414,
0.3099440038204193,
0.2674422264099121,
-0.20223718881607056,
0.8955824971199036,
-0.04077502712607384,
-0.5305536389350891,
0.44481876492500305,
0.3927484154701233,
0.6272892355918884,
-0.7140031456947327,
0.11202733218669891,
-0.16605962812900543,
0.14067833125591278,
0.08891157060861588,
-0.5441789031028748,
0.0639011412858963,
0.17171630263328552,
0.4750230014324188,
-0.4987362027168274,
0.8175211548805237,
-0.5674344897270203,
-0.2911413013935089,
0.8558496236801147,
0.5841203331947327,
-0.021456345915794373,
0.12447373569011688,
-0.7657841444015503,
0.36836129426956177,
-0.3104911148548126,
-0.4330781102180481,
0.24562163650989532,
0.4082883298397064,
-0.1716906577348709,
0.7321308255195618,
0.6989467144012451,
0.19991645216941833,
0.10937415808439255,
0.3343920409679413,
1.0556418895721436,
-0.45067209005355835,
-0.7515426874160767,
-1.0613857507705688,
-0.014106030575931072,
-0.3530547320842743,
-0.0018220209749415517,
0.5660629272460938,
0.11556373536586761,
0.6243511438369751,
0.1309499740600586,
0.8319016695022583,
0.06757385283708572,
0.2578848898410797,
-0.4895573854446411,
0.9511798024177551,
-0.7038528919219971,
0.32919666171073914,
-0.5300968289375305,
-0.8477920293807983,
-0.18263430893421173,
0.3116985559463501,
-0.215467631816864,
0.12871003150939941,
0.45268514752388,
0.8377013802528381,
0.04430222511291504,
-0.056126486510038376,
0.2221670001745224,
0.3029067814350128,
0.573532223701477,
0.17643922567367554,
0.9375892281532288,
0.13440415263175964,
0.7210896015167236,
-0.2141876220703125,
-0.2587423622608185,
-0.3803631365299225,
-0.635300874710083,
-1.021790862083435,
-0.419707715511322,
-0.15370593965053558,
-0.5524235963821411,
0.12453032284975052,
1.3422132730484009,
0.3978574275970459,
-0.45607635378837585,
-0.6468042731285095,
0.07534965872764587,
0.024711603298783302,
-0.20269523561000824,
-0.29659023880958557,
-0.10891853272914886,
-0.16597753763198853,
-0.6605052947998047,
0.31698569655418396,
0.3364434838294983,
0.2276596575975418,
-0.43154317140579224,
-0.17144185304641724,
-0.323300302028656,
0.5074846148490906,
0.7026777863502502,
0.44488465785980225,
-0.7001562714576721,
-0.2998572885990143,
0.08358387649059296,
-0.39244869351387024,
-0.13089649379253387,
0.6995649337768555,
-0.200945645570755,
0.47913914918899536,
0.4499697983264923,
0.7668973803520203,
0.12387185543775558,
0.27363651990890503,
0.51030033826828,
-0.7592672109603882,
-0.08547663688659668,
0.12990020215511322,
0.10662903636693954,
0.29215386509895325,
-0.06557643413543701,
0.226577028632164,
0.24283665418624878,
-0.5840206146240234,
-1.0322749614715576,
0.34637129306793213,
-0.8355735540390015,
-0.48391371965408325,
1.8665854930877686,
0.2740169167518616,
-0.2739623486995697,
-0.033957403153181076,
-0.14111045002937317,
0.29963183403015137,
-0.7702369689941406,
1.2048509120941162,
0.8322481513023376,
0.1096159890294075,
-0.42593705654144287,
-0.7258467674255371,
0.5807039141654968,
0.021736644208431244,
-1.0356756448745728,
0.4070412814617157,
0.3447243273258209,
0.2175155133008957,
0.10775657743215561,
0.81119304895401,
0.2339756339788437,
0.12565933167934418,
-0.2794337868690491,
-0.12080829590559006,
0.24288935959339142,
-0.3948882520198822,
-0.5122231841087341,
-0.0103379487991333,
0.043843187391757965,
0.15849031507968903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02817v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02817v1
|
HuixiangDou-CR: Coreference Resolution in Group Chats
| 2024-05-05T05:43:20 | 2024-05-05T05:43:20 |
Huanjun Kong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
How to eliminate pronominal reference in group chats? In this work, we have
preprocessed 58k authentic chat data and manually annotated 2.3k questions. The
reliability of this annotation was confirmed by the scaling law. After this, we
conducted fine-tuning on Qwen models, ranging from 0.5B to 32B parameters. The
optimal version improved 29.07 in F1 score. This confirms the viability of
fine-tuning Large Language Model (LLM) for downstream Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks. Our contributions are: 1) Created Supervised
Fine-Tuning (SFT) training data in alpaca format, along with a set of Low-Rank
Adaptation (LoRA) weights, and 2) Developed a method for acquiring high-quality
data leveraging scaling law principle. The script, raw data with alpaca format
and experiments track are open-sourced on Github
https://github.com/InternLM/HuixiangDou/tree/main/web/tools, HuggingFace
https://huggingface.co/tpoisonooo and WandB
https://wandb.ai/tpoisonooo/huixiangdou-cr/table?nw=nwusertpoisonooo . The
privacy of the data involved has been authorized by users.
|
[
-0.4709280729293823,
-0.5692723393440247,
0.05519282445311546,
0.2583428919315338,
-0.5295292139053345,
-0.06008442863821983,
-0.5745975375175476,
-0.6727712154388428,
0.0733698159456253,
0.7210389971733093,
-0.40923282504081726,
-0.577948808670044,
-0.5589324831962585,
0.11841259151697159,
-0.1750817894935608,
1.0732407569885254,
0.19060884416103363,
-0.1232253909111023,
0.028577759861946106,
-0.44032031297683716,
-0.050311505794525146,
-0.8498724102973938,
-0.8410388231277466,
-0.21402493119239807,
0.4353877007961273,
0.7671986222267151,
0.9992091059684753,
0.6805484294891357,
0.5180078148841858,
0.3398367464542389,
-0.2888946235179901,
0.4091622233390808,
-0.6425449252128601,
-0.07232022285461426,
-0.11749035120010376,
-0.370747834444046,
-0.8284035325050354,
0.04957260563969612,
0.5275277495384216,
0.593913733959198,
-0.0961717814207077,
0.2256162464618683,
0.4591424763202667,
0.5600770711898804,
-0.38469836115837097,
0.2983328104019165,
-0.8618391752243042,
-0.11490438133478165,
-0.38809871673583984,
-0.0683152824640274,
-0.37718600034713745,
-0.3955146372318268,
-0.10521501302719116,
-0.7721906900405884,
0.5040082931518555,
0.3218318223953247,
1.1670186519622803,
0.1727363020181656,
-0.36648425459861755,
-0.35699355602264404,
-0.4507462680339813,
0.8231131434440613,
-0.9747543334960938,
0.0365411676466465,
0.9208821058273315,
-0.026989340782165527,
-0.3751177191734314,
-0.5297161340713501,
-0.5224373936653137,
-0.3290237486362457,
-0.13794675469398499,
-0.12623366713523865,
-0.18035344779491425,
0.3538714349269867,
0.38992390036582947,
0.3749944269657135,
-0.39007043838500977,
0.36716732382774353,
-0.5267065167427063,
-0.3718729317188263,
0.5954926609992981,
0.06041601300239563,
0.08633413910865784,
-0.19910305738449097,
0.11096975952386856,
0.26056891679763794,
-0.48272624611854553,
0.044961925595998764,
0.29187437891960144,
0.6015304327011108,
0.07749854773283005,
0.4621313512325287,
-0.360628604888916,
0.41330620646476746,
0.8095414638519287,
-0.2552053928375244,
0.3767555058002472,
-0.5052310228347778,
-0.07147859036922455,
-0.13487105071544647,
0.9294172525405884,
0.6601112484931946,
0.3692252039909363,
-0.3059692680835724,
0.42755040526390076,
-0.2640218436717987,
-0.04334922134876251,
-0.8873050212860107,
-0.2691746950149536,
0.2971860468387604,
-0.46475955843925476,
-0.17357811331748962,
-0.0700368732213974,
-0.3894021213054657,
-0.43342477083206177,
-0.4420025646686554,
0.07379908114671707,
-0.471879780292511,
-0.19493936002254486,
-0.17870387434959412,
0.24896715581417084,
0.028645453974604607,
0.2771543562412262,
-0.9952788352966309,
0.3331010043621063,
0.5444512963294983,
0.6954400539398193,
0.009401773102581501,
-0.1400042623281479,
-0.638856053352356,
0.10643220692873001,
-0.147706538438797,
0.6525894999504089,
-0.3044721186161041,
-0.553230881690979,
-0.2994266152381897,
0.1403171271085739,
0.11411068588495255,
-0.9566154479980469,
0.978341281414032,
-0.13416391611099243,
0.1300036907196045,
-0.38240355253219604,
-0.5202635526657104,
0.05195581912994385,
0.24486768245697021,
-0.4664234220981598,
0.9095913171768188,
-0.1615336388349533,
-0.7357398271560669,
0.08396784961223602,
-0.28321537375450134,
-0.12805114686489105,
0.20253872871398926,
-0.010205904021859169,
-0.14762672781944275,
-0.24381312727928162,
0.33308663964271545,
0.5866527557373047,
-0.36346131563186646,
0.39938512444496155,
-0.1133740022778511,
-0.1743626445531845,
-0.062746562063694,
0.08166488260030746,
0.7312609553337097,
0.1423761248588562,
0.07862856239080429,
0.485857754945755,
-0.8282589912414551,
0.17703038454055786,
-0.28809797763824463,
0.038174889981746674,
-0.47395139932632446,
-0.08837136626243591,
-0.329263836145401,
0.1752445250749588,
0.3743440508842468,
-0.43808606266975403,
0.1653209775686264,
-0.10045778006315231,
0.5637677311897278,
0.5674525499343872,
0.07118631899356842,
0.5525655150413513,
-0.010406001470983028,
0.1815204620361328,
0.1320134997367859,
0.5997015833854675,
0.2936468720436096,
-0.3571917414665222,
-0.6699163913726807,
-0.1619659662246704,
0.18642236292362213,
0.3932007849216461,
-0.7376771569252014,
0.7123166918754578,
-0.03003564476966858,
-0.8871829509735107,
-0.3584202229976654,
0.3077417314052582,
0.15518207848072052,
0.7221477627754211,
0.6036236882209778,
-0.14700908958911896,
-0.5434604287147522,
-0.9406580924987793,
0.07548379898071289,
-0.4164313077926636,
-0.4165681004524231,
0.2807933986186981,
0.10563109815120697,
-0.08980433642864227,
0.9854490160942078,
-0.18839876353740692,
-0.551007091999054,
-0.04784810543060303,
0.2652643918991089,
0.382608562707901,
0.48751595616340637,
0.5517686009407043,
-0.7133264541625977,
-0.39301928877830505,
-0.030393721535801888,
-0.45823925733566284,
-0.39685937762260437,
0.20033195614814758,
-0.36734941601753235,
-0.0815872997045517,
0.6924532651901245,
-0.5071423053741455,
0.27541956305503845,
0.7785499691963196,
-0.31754621863365173,
0.854308545589447,
-0.04096895456314087,
0.20479623973369598,
-1.1955420970916748,
-0.07952519506216049,
0.15439780056476593,
-0.24376216530799866,
-0.5351607203483582,
-0.03307529538869858,
0.04997509345412254,
0.1968672126531601,
-0.3531346619129181,
0.27471908926963806,
-0.38175687193870544,
0.456425279378891,
-0.4145987629890442,
0.49525752663612366,
-0.04715237393975258,
0.749398410320282,
-0.14896529912948608,
0.7358834743499756,
0.28310883045196533,
-0.9705065488815308,
0.7182636857032776,
0.3092253506183624,
-0.07381495833396912,
0.5016336441040039,
-0.7861976027488708,
0.31784844398498535,
0.18009811639785767,
0.33156126737594604,
-0.6750491261482239,
0.07336463034152985,
0.4904040992259979,
-0.4555712044239044,
0.019352499395608902,
-0.2657340168952942,
-0.34706762433052063,
-0.23709486424922943,
-0.22746585309505463,
0.477511465549469,
0.1212722659111023,
-0.39713600277900696,
0.6163652539253235,
0.4249210059642792,
-0.20738089084625244,
-0.6119142770767212,
-0.2626879811286926,
0.12914243340492249,
-0.25666096806526184,
-0.4553954601287842,
0.6228088736534119,
-0.08532515168190002,
-0.2952443063259125,
-0.10965596139431,
-0.059761129319667816,
-0.0827634334564209,
-0.22824305295944214,
0.4555429220199585,
0.29763707518577576,
0.0271677915006876,
0.21183982491493225,
-0.16742143034934998,
-0.08627517521381378,
-0.13682664930820465,
0.05080416426062584,
0.638657808303833,
-0.37611404061317444,
0.061461497098207474,
-0.40272054076194763,
0.15279918909072876,
0.17752063274383545,
-0.13121455907821655,
0.8947580456733704,
0.8141545653343201,
-0.3470885157585144,
0.3219337463378906,
-0.581066906452179,
-0.11061941832304001,
-0.5068964958190918,
0.4752883017063141,
-0.3068453371524811,
-1.1870079040527344,
0.9518918395042419,
-0.07841750979423523,
0.2730160057544708,
0.5457444787025452,
0.552550733089447,
-0.07486752420663834,
0.5024299025535583,
0.5224419236183167,
-0.309360533952713,
0.5618625283241272,
0.07769981026649475,
0.21020406484603882,
-1.035009503364563,
0.06525655090808868,
-0.92473304271698,
-0.18392683565616608,
-0.6836280822753906,
-0.4940951466560364,
0.28294235467910767,
0.5436371564865112,
-0.27490663528442383,
0.6863929629325867,
-0.29793787002563477,
0.5003170967102051,
0.5406033992767334,
0.3567312955856323,
0.42581912875175476,
-0.4468227028846741,
0.1929319202899933,
-0.20930762588977814,
-0.4601348638534546,
-0.5389550924301147,
0.7501397132873535,
0.2986891269683838,
0.5250616669654846,
-0.007810956332832575,
0.41707339882850647,
0.2014370560646057,
0.3578090965747833,
-0.8637118935585022,
0.848540186882019,
-0.24633516371250153,
-0.25180718302726746,
-0.5392796397209167,
-0.6713723540306091,
-0.9140630960464478,
0.2741171419620514,
-0.10202202200889587,
-0.9755971431732178,
0.19413861632347107,
0.1914944052696228,
-0.39650821685791016,
0.2651756703853607,
-0.4883356988430023,
0.7151364088058472,
0.20953409373760223,
-0.351148784160614,
-0.341117262840271,
-0.6261435747146606,
0.25707608461380005,
0.1614077389240265,
0.2380230724811554,
-0.6019036769866943,
0.2980995178222656,
0.9195558428764343,
-0.5974087119102478,
1.0435110330581665,
-0.11899292469024658,
-0.32890960574150085,
0.5105658173561096,
0.04539322480559349,
0.46518608927726746,
0.032080069184303284,
-0.1642715483903885,
0.5257612466812134,
0.20665132999420166,
-0.32418838143348694,
-0.4667283892631531,
0.4639386832714081,
-0.786780595779419,
-0.6326048970222473,
0.0644482672214508,
-0.5779573917388916,
-0.3417719304561615,
-0.0638900175690651,
0.4494929015636444,
0.4374426305294037,
-0.1005842387676239,
0.49663856625556946,
0.3291182816028595,
0.019679447636008263,
0.247065007686615,
0.2722242474555969,
-0.2801113426685333,
-0.3084450662136078,
0.4914969205856323,
0.27328869700431824,
0.28047430515289307,
0.02640455588698387,
0.2160218209028244,
0.08340562134981155,
-0.42547672986984253,
-0.1355060636997223,
0.4331553876399994,
-0.614656388759613,
-0.35571086406707764,
-0.3530377745628357,
-0.25775864720344543,
-0.6890120506286621,
0.2624618411064148,
-0.4393378496170044,
-0.49758458137512207,
-0.4140079915523529,
-0.11694221198558807,
0.3613128364086151,
-0.03531692549586296,
-0.09070558100938797,
0.5231190323829651,
-1.0120497941970825,
0.41461023688316345,
0.182264506816864,
-0.026150360703468323,
-0.1765836924314499,
-0.981411337852478,
-0.5326845645904541,
0.183632493019104,
-0.25549250841140747,
-0.573223888874054,
0.23391860723495483,
0.27727046608924866,
0.43423721194267273,
0.5761873722076416,
0.5182449221611023,
0.8883605599403381,
-0.2104174792766571,
0.8637407422065735,
0.01086621917784214,
-0.9982324242591858,
0.4916038513183594,
-0.2703918218612671,
0.2545974552631378,
0.7119526267051697,
0.2673949897289276,
-0.8355562090873718,
-0.5263497233390808,
-0.587731659412384,
-0.9654051065444946,
0.2775264382362366,
0.15730364620685577,
0.16262999176979065,
-0.09127188473939896,
0.8306021094322205,
0.01306104939430952,
0.07941494882106781,
-0.43143579363822937,
-0.10224410146474838,
0.06350488215684891,
-0.12924335896968842,
0.09616664797067642,
-0.5443640351295471,
-0.17115885019302368,
-0.5360612273216248,
0.7915291786193848,
-0.4370947480201721,
0.09894002974033356,
0.10902557522058487,
0.01771506667137146,
-0.1827935129404068,
0.1858290284872055,
0.525757372379303,
0.6706681251525879,
-0.07173377275466919,
-0.04557783529162407,
0.25690957903862,
-0.7957428693771362,
-0.2708642780780792,
-0.2059062272310257,
0.09382980316877365,
-0.024721048772335052,
0.3885008692741394,
0.6744064092636108,
-0.006105486769229174,
-0.37434065341949463,
0.12568522989749908,
-0.05921446159482002,
-0.33169713616371155,
-0.24223624169826508,
0.20154434442520142,
-0.028941750526428223,
0.2593214809894562,
0.5968689322471619,
0.04983843117952347,
-0.011119833216071129,
-0.4078366458415985,
0.03832809254527092,
0.1297449767589569,
-0.17570719122886658,
-0.3442821800708771,
0.4501022696495056,
0.4712217152118683,
-0.09525813162326813,
0.7672416567802429,
-0.14624689519405365,
-0.5001685619354248,
0.5123395919799805,
0.27388593554496765,
0.6481956839561462,
-0.502581775188446,
0.14897683262825012,
0.7781916260719299,
0.251820832490921,
-0.028609469532966614,
-0.11949798464775085,
-0.20207485556602478,
-1.2850326299667358,
-0.43039843440055847,
-0.2533338665962219,
-0.9275233149528503,
0.05314793810248375,
-1.0077615976333618,
0.24272531270980835,
-0.4209247827529907,
-0.6093489527702332,
-0.1943785548210144,
0.23780246078968048,
-0.376077264547348,
0.03919451683759689,
-0.06762141734361649,
0.5867494940757751,
-0.5124958753585815,
1.0085285902023315,
0.18529804050922394,
-0.10411140322685242,
-0.8379366993904114,
0.023673873394727707,
-0.1322433203458786,
-0.6245752573013306,
0.3645229935646057,
-0.05309474840760231,
-0.21101102232933044,
-0.06613609194755554,
-0.8813793063163757,
-0.6835598349571228,
1.0000020265579224,
0.288852334022522,
-0.7114933133125305,
-0.19529256224632263,
-0.0721895843744278,
0.5937841534614563,
-0.1336909979581833,
-0.02149997465312481,
0.6427505612373352,
0.35449451208114624,
0.24776685237884521,
-1.5852090120315552,
-0.057761386036872864,
-0.24393194913864136,
-0.2819956839084625,
-0.1434270590543747,
-1.002896785736084,
0.7442371249198914,
-0.1716475933790207,
-0.1232433095574379,
0.0037987881805747747,
1.130320429801941,
0.190893292427063,
0.021089758723974228,
0.6412758231163025,
0.19182142615318298,
1.0676894187927246,
-0.11179337650537491,
0.44472256302833557,
-0.31673601269721985,
0.35688915848731995,
1.474353313446045,
-0.4278721511363983,
0.7319319844245911,
0.5582115650177002,
-0.1535075306892395,
0.26635563373565674,
0.6537988185882568,
0.08922898769378662,
0.18991632759571075,
0.09799791127443314,
-0.10459538549184799,
-0.2410719245672226,
-0.5249205231666565,
-0.3035000264644623,
0.322424054145813,
0.5224248766899109,
-0.18731911480426788,
0.009867001324892044,
0.12553541362285614,
0.3919728398323059,
0.1705576330423355,
-0.5295931696891785,
0.671640157699585,
0.022764042019844055,
-0.3478832542896271,
0.48979780077934265,
0.07950355857610703,
0.9004681706428528,
-0.6022091507911682,
0.2261420339345932,
-0.38257020711898804,
0.25424548983573914,
-0.3239761292934418,
-0.4454362690448761,
0.32251501083374023,
-0.037731483578681946,
-0.04552791267633438,
0.14285041391849518,
0.5885501503944397,
-0.5235916376113892,
-0.23491142690181732,
0.19911827147006989,
0.3147425949573517,
0.27969875931739807,
-0.3762390613555908,
-0.5260394811630249,
0.019138451665639877,
0.04593437910079956,
-0.39069226384162903,
0.22793611884117126,
0.5274308919906616,
-0.35844656825065613,
0.7304432392120361,
0.41821882128715515,
-0.012661999091506004,
-0.16084177792072296,
0.4029814600944519,
0.8449549674987793,
-0.5994539260864258,
-0.3096081018447876,
-0.7380598783493042,
-0.12775354087352753,
-0.15339505672454834,
-0.4347015619277954,
0.7495800256729126,
0.40009424090385437,
0.7071844935417175,
0.286996990442276,
0.3406808078289032,
-0.1921311467885971,
0.5385051369667053,
-0.4342305362224579,
0.35316169261932373,
0.1113266721367836,
-0.11960679292678833,
-0.23725265264511108,
-0.7083186507225037,
-0.43190670013427734,
0.613359272480011,
-0.3407289981842041,
-0.09554066509008408,
0.5066295862197876,
0.8136155009269714,
0.3632967472076416,
0.1600596308708191,
0.3131163418292999,
0.397921085357666,
0.44498661160469055,
0.4817761182785034,
0.37026864290237427,
-0.5242258310317993,
0.5906912088394165,
-0.30018556118011475,
-0.26041778922080994,
-0.1855207085609436,
-0.9569966793060303,
-0.8874959945678711,
-0.6320714950561523,
-0.6475196480751038,
-0.5295557379722595,
-0.29918769001960754,
1.2947793006896973,
0.7495038509368896,
-0.8699225783348083,
-0.24839109182357788,
0.41250231862068176,
-0.11647850275039673,
-0.5266901254653931,
-0.2132689356803894,
0.35931795835494995,
-0.19540773332118988,
-0.8890564441680908,
0.11733285337686539,
-0.0958264023065567,
-0.057271428406238556,
-0.052277784794569016,
-0.056241121143102646,
-0.04072682932019234,
-0.2815847098827362,
0.6075409054756165,
0.2775055170059204,
-0.6087021231651306,
-0.5075326561927795,
-0.10648008435964584,
-0.30777910351753235,
0.18352513015270233,
0.8946649432182312,
-0.3332802653312683,
-0.03607764467597008,
0.19928255677223206,
-0.005999721586704254,
0.31778889894485474,
0.4667503237724304,
0.3803290128707886,
-0.9198024868965149,
0.4814826250076294,
0.22589799761772156,
0.274690181016922,
0.13874438405036926,
-0.5850194096565247,
0.66611248254776,
0.16140374541282654,
-0.7278476357460022,
-0.5025942921638489,
-0.029830923303961754,
-1.2787755727767944,
0.07920559495687485,
1.186700463294983,
-0.21093733608722687,
-0.25743910670280457,
-0.24594105780124664,
-0.7707177996635437,
0.42822766304016113,
-0.3101104497909546,
0.7995988726615906,
1.012550950050354,
-0.2288016676902771,
-0.4105764925479889,
-0.3801176846027374,
0.5212771892547607,
0.15606281161308289,
-0.660483181476593,
0.5094922184944153,
0.41491416096687317,
0.07984704524278641,
0.24404796957969666,
0.8528051376342773,
-0.14568106830120087,
-0.06708413362503052,
-0.23835453391075134,
0.46367147564888,
-0.23341788351535797,
-0.05770260840654373,
0.20137755572795868,
0.18341654539108276,
0.09391074627637863,
-0.32388386130332947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02816v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02816v1
|
Stochastic RAG: End-to-End Retrieval-Augmented Generation through Expected Utility Maximization
| 2024-05-05T05:42:33 | 2024-05-05T05:42:33 |
Hamed Zamani, Michael Bendersky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces Stochastic RAG--a novel approach for end-to-end
optimization of retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) models that relaxes the
simplifying assumptions of marginalization and document independence, made in
most prior work. Stochastic RAG casts the retrieval process in RAG as a
stochastic sampling without replacement process. Through this formulation, we
employ straight-through Gumbel-top-k that provides a differentiable
approximation for sampling without replacement and enables effective end-to-end
optimization for RAG. We conduct extensive experiments on seven diverse
datasets on a wide range of tasks, from open-domain question answering to fact
verification to slot-filling for relation extraction and to dialogue systems.
By applying this optimization method to a recent and effective RAG model, we
advance state-of-the-art results on six out of seven datasets.
|
[
-0.44220826029777527,
-0.8255663514137268,
0.5666244029998779,
-0.024862101301550865,
-0.32248005270957947,
0.1261897087097168,
-0.24668686091899872,
-0.16538645327091217,
0.3945108950138092,
0.6182448267936707,
-0.665274977684021,
-0.07484662532806396,
-0.45276063680648804,
-0.2796694338321686,
-0.16028708219528198,
1.2627038955688477,
-0.1728355884552002,
-0.1814153492450714,
-0.49491816759109497,
0.007024512160569429,
-0.07139716297388077,
-0.22242945432662964,
-0.9314737915992737,
-0.2596403658390045,
0.5289438962936401,
0.32971325516700745,
0.5296135544776917,
0.4634930491447449,
0.4047175943851471,
0.16488146781921387,
-0.11046594381332397,
0.2856113314628601,
-0.921059250831604,
0.39496833086013794,
-0.2862633168697357,
-0.38664504885673523,
-0.18334494531154633,
0.07618740200996399,
0.38252705335617065,
0.6636181473731995,
-0.6256146430969238,
0.6553329825401306,
-0.24166804552078247,
0.7617465853691101,
-0.9835120439529419,
-0.42348799109458923,
-0.4135470390319824,
-0.01562684215605259,
-0.029286902397871017,
-0.7284050583839417,
-0.4714021384716034,
-0.6232234239578247,
-0.0951743870973587,
-0.5955997705459595,
0.45476967096328735,
0.10490596294403076,
1.0076240301132202,
0.4837898015975952,
-0.33914631605148315,
-0.4075052738189697,
-1.0150139331817627,
1.0457361936569214,
-0.31601467728614807,
0.2303043007850647,
0.6366057991981506,
0.5995640754699707,
-0.5135586857795715,
-0.8647285103797913,
-0.3380572497844696,
-0.3191379904747009,
0.225747212767601,
0.5749914646148682,
-0.01327187567949295,
0.043880317360162735,
0.18466214835643768,
0.38324669003486633,
-0.3127928078174591,
-0.21528038382530212,
-0.3515889346599579,
0.3784726560115814,
0.7069873809814453,
-0.1752309650182724,
-0.10934372246265411,
-0.2948591411113739,
-0.6140156388282776,
-0.2244839370250702,
-0.3787759840488434,
0.3204825818538666,
0.8053007125854492,
0.040678832679986954,
0.09189397841691971,
0.6175088882446289,
0.017397617921233177,
0.46439123153686523,
0.018548035994172096,
-0.13707603514194489,
-0.10877816379070282,
-0.2798076272010803,
-0.3745940923690796,
-0.34485942125320435,
0.42506101727485657,
0.24535039067268372,
-0.0388767272233963,
-0.14419974386692047,
-0.3501107692718506,
-0.379962295293808,
0.49420228600502014,
-0.46237483620643616,
0.1965591311454773,
0.3470158576965332,
-0.5830355286598206,
-0.5684540867805481,
-0.2826913297176361,
-0.8140290379524231,
-0.11712899059057236,
-0.4259960651397705,
0.33359333872795105,
-0.26071202754974365,
-0.556812584400177,
-0.08950165659189224,
-0.2881409525871277,
0.1656372994184494,
0.2219955325126648,
-0.4192076027393341,
0.3489226996898651,
0.5901986956596375,
0.46229708194732666,
-0.0989161878824234,
0.2503787875175476,
-0.48732563853263855,
0.12102694809436798,
-0.7290604114532471,
1.0628198385238647,
-0.6067754030227661,
-0.5811171531677246,
-0.14000724256038666,
-0.2339865118265152,
0.11775283515453339,
-0.5165751576423645,
0.9205737709999084,
-0.6855764389038086,
0.2304065227508545,
-0.0671604722738266,
-0.3937753736972809,
-0.014268612489104271,
-0.0456790067255497,
-0.7102888226509094,
1.283523440361023,
0.36398836970329285,
-0.7002477645874023,
0.43597665429115295,
-0.42125388979911804,
-0.1141844242811203,
-0.18607041239738464,
-0.04046149179339409,
-0.5914731025695801,
0.59152752161026,
-0.3936006426811218,
-0.01681539975106716,
-0.7775828242301941,
0.4630619287490845,
-0.30522510409355164,
0.02565605752170086,
0.17731699347496033,
-0.4561587870121002,
0.7985395193099976,
0.567799985408783,
0.07196108996868134,
0.1496748924255371,
-0.8717905879020691,
0.13923081755638123,
0.13726654648780823,
-0.24674074351787567,
-0.6889992952346802,
0.1537202000617981,
0.11863154917955399,
0.10670043528079987,
0.3407016694545746,
-0.5961422324180603,
0.12427186220884323,
-0.31336456537246704,
-0.43504005670547485,
0.7460548281669617,
0.2957098186016083,
0.5650047659873962,
-0.8773032426834106,
0.6339341998100281,
-0.0689874067902565,
0.3275171220302582,
-0.05689806491136551,
-0.21520541608333588,
-0.49705812335014343,
-0.404849648475647,
0.4424586892127991,
0.3098638951778412,
-0.7887614965438843,
0.024738755077123642,
-0.04990396648645401,
-0.47270911931991577,
-0.4026249349117279,
-0.3095892071723938,
0.4494864344596863,
0.4196341931819916,
0.2136135697364807,
-0.35199272632598877,
-0.6511914730072021,
-0.8632257580757141,
-0.20392899215221405,
0.061204101890325546,
-0.20519952476024628,
0.6472541689872742,
0.0026930905878543854,
-0.09519787132740021,
1.021057367324829,
-0.4955573081970215,
-0.027701616287231445,
-0.2894897758960724,
0.50893634557724,
0.5029827952384949,
0.28556492924690247,
0.27069851756095886,
-1.2024035453796387,
-0.5463781356811523,
-0.038863979279994965,
-0.5178537368774414,
-0.21637223660945892,
-0.3038709759712219,
-0.3924504816532135,
0.37800806760787964,
0.29905566573143005,
-0.5980150103569031,
0.605475902557373,
0.2108994722366333,
0.179939404129982,
0.7854901552200317,
-0.5838892459869385,
0.19731086492538452,
-1.2108359336853027,
0.21211066842079163,
-0.08284255862236023,
-0.15587815642356873,
-0.7896921038627625,
0.32477205991744995,
-0.12866759300231934,
0.02403920330107212,
-0.19336745142936707,
0.5380017757415771,
-0.7069869637489319,
-0.31535905599594116,
-0.5458641648292542,
-0.071644626557827,
-0.23493435978889465,
0.5285938382148743,
-0.21657991409301758,
0.7155141234397888,
0.17711403965950012,
-0.547890841960907,
0.0307601410895586,
-0.16198666393756866,
0.05308336019515991,
0.5408273935317993,
-0.4326575994491577,
0.03351328521966934,
-0.8229876160621643,
0.08206073939800262,
-1.027266025543213,
-0.2840861678123474,
-0.19443893432617188,
-0.519927442073822,
0.6684666872024536,
-0.24859102070331573,
-0.2500040829181671,
-0.16496872901916504,
-0.5080602765083313,
0.3668854534626007,
0.6620075106620789,
-0.39442867040634155,
0.8098079562187195,
0.8012647032737732,
-0.3144308030605316,
-0.9287301898002625,
0.1840282827615738,
-0.18190138041973114,
-0.07762780040502548,
-0.3558495342731476,
0.26842331886291504,
0.12950599193572998,
-0.1754559427499771,
0.01151947770267725,
-0.3326897621154785,
-0.10017852485179901,
0.005900288932025433,
-0.20721258223056793,
0.3355879783630371,
0.21619850397109985,
-0.00006804020813433453,
0.2193719744682312,
-0.28843769431114197,
-0.284955233335495,
-0.18128448724746704,
0.5498254895210266,
0.4625031352043152,
-0.26122549176216125,
0.33460983633995056,
0.8010212779045105,
0.08543441444635391,
-0.06038491800427437,
0.3053198456764221,
0.4202457666397095,
-0.4192218482494354,
-0.4169101119041443,
-0.5897159576416016,
0.16245655715465546,
-0.45914512872695923,
0.26750582456588745,
-0.5014374852180481,
-0.6744450330734253,
0.4596155285835266,
-0.36721035838127136,
0.4479089677333832,
0.224098339676857,
0.4065000116825104,
-0.30878904461860657,
0.7892101407051086,
0.7356550693511963,
0.5825029015541077,
0.3381185829639435,
-0.22824670374393463,
0.3135348856449127,
-0.9481253027915955,
0.05913379788398743,
-0.5644612312316895,
-0.21424973011016846,
-0.9705235362052917,
-0.8781648278236389,
0.5249200463294983,
0.543971836566925,
-0.08205313980579376,
0.18040570616722107,
-0.6739085912704468,
0.17242850363254547,
0.8061190247535706,
-0.032297283411026,
0.2425260841846466,
0.07387547194957733,
-0.306319922208786,
-0.1328592598438263,
-0.5281198024749756,
-0.3526824712753296,
1.2097957134246826,
0.00979473628103733,
0.9988494515419006,
0.2717578113079071,
0.9680835604667664,
0.07862712442874908,
0.5201308727264404,
-0.6393865346908569,
0.4519759714603424,
-0.30131882429122925,
-0.5250446200370789,
-0.4169411063194275,
-0.6044162511825562,
-1.2082529067993164,
0.22349683940410614,
-0.02703860029578209,
-0.7634262442588806,
0.3400935232639313,
-0.09714807569980621,
0.08331622183322906,
0.3231483995914459,
-0.45614922046661377,
0.33369284868240356,
0.06458811461925507,
-0.5622618198394775,
-0.17108139395713806,
-0.5196440815925598,
0.44975534081459045,
-0.16617842018604279,
0.3508850634098053,
-0.01960691250860691,
-0.17631864547729492,
0.6573954224586487,
-0.1792302131652832,
0.2675473392009735,
-0.4564359188079834,
0.19975365698337555,
0.5086166858673096,
-0.16593971848487854,
0.773520827293396,
-0.27492234110832214,
0.1031159982085228,
-0.3671909272670746,
0.12750476598739624,
-0.2938987910747528,
-0.6028996109962463,
0.23201318085193634,
-0.5361142158508301,
-0.6590731143951416,
-0.37587252259254456,
-0.5490952134132385,
-0.2122340351343155,
0.09662884473800659,
0.4084397256374359,
0.37539735436439514,
-0.2837063670158386,
0.022745154798030853,
0.7867668867111206,
-0.5169024467468262,
0.4373701810836792,
0.23819579184055328,
-0.32961368560791016,
-0.2841411232948303,
0.8934168219566345,
0.2556130886077881,
0.24639445543289185,
0.5236627459526062,
0.25086528062820435,
-0.4791468679904938,
-0.40151533484458923,
-0.42563217878341675,
0.3643577992916107,
-0.38401713967323303,
-0.11442029476165771,
-0.892353892326355,
-0.27726754546165466,
-0.31411516666412354,
-0.2296464741230011,
-0.4653519093990326,
-0.6237292289733887,
-0.11462408304214478,
-0.03559038043022156,
0.18050338327884674,
0.4501558542251587,
-0.4559983015060425,
0.08974408358335495,
-0.5631516575813293,
0.5771965384483337,
0.08777384459972382,
0.3885074853897095,
-0.02970414236187935,
-0.3951508104801178,
-0.24021022021770477,
-0.08510996401309967,
-0.5055990815162659,
-0.8705378770828247,
0.631965696811676,
0.12310478836297989,
1.0027097463607788,
0.10481106489896774,
0.3874182403087616,
0.6396604180335999,
-0.6701146364212036,
0.3789782226085663,
0.36865144968032837,
-0.2256280481815338,
0.36403194069862366,
-0.5564503073692322,
-0.07257196307182312,
0.5017063021659851,
0.5938658714294434,
-0.3483675420284271,
-0.4291761815547943,
-0.971039891242981,
-1.3436591625213623,
0.48205259442329407,
0.09530839323997498,
-0.12496829777956009,
0.08109882473945618,
0.21234562993049622,
0.1447795182466507,
0.5230064988136292,
-0.08276404440402985,
-0.30829480290412903,
0.06589240580797195,
-0.28917616605758667,
0.13438162207603455,
-0.5828619003295898,
-0.3362642824649811,
0.41617685556411743,
0.7340030670166016,
-0.013805114664137363,
0.6880045533180237,
0.2343071699142456,
0.11330000311136246,
-0.3310472369194031,
0.548202395439148,
0.6012104153633118,
0.6183675527572632,
-0.4116683304309845,
-0.1393362432718277,
-0.015009301714599133,
-0.519841194152832,
0.3580421805381775,
0.3206993639469147,
-0.33766138553619385,
0.32271888852119446,
-0.3340991735458374,
0.49003517627716064,
0.29248756170272827,
-0.4153514504432678,
0.3203886151313782,
-0.12989890575408936,
-0.09777574986219406,
-0.8088586926460266,
-0.04612059146165848,
-0.10460784286260605,
0.1563294380903244,
0.9705939888954163,
0.09329578280448914,
0.38480183482170105,
-0.29791557788848877,
0.6547682285308838,
0.6084232330322266,
-0.07575614750385284,
0.058452486991882324,
0.7863582968711853,
-0.4286549985408783,
-0.5140478610992432,
-0.30684810876846313,
-0.39961007237434387,
0.06773017346858978,
0.6184259057044983,
0.36634546518325806,
1.132926344871521,
-0.29248833656311035,
0.34523195028305054,
0.5116625428199768,
0.14981895685195923,
-0.04620346799492836,
0.4269631803035736,
-0.31455105543136597,
-0.37348097562789917,
-0.5879601240158081,
-1.1177937984466553,
-0.7758310437202454,
-0.18014611303806305,
-1.0686873197555542,
0.09108515828847885,
-0.2469920516014099,
-0.4615527093410492,
-0.1369118094444275,
0.13307560980319977,
-0.516547441482544,
0.2155229151248932,
-0.5680733323097229,
0.9271808862686157,
-0.27934250235557556,
0.5933882594108582,
0.5383930206298828,
-0.34422567486763,
-0.721590518951416,
-0.15277650952339172,
-0.1477327048778534,
-0.533129096031189,
0.4719424247741699,
-0.2762388288974762,
-0.16419583559036255,
0.13124017417430878,
-0.42684948444366455,
-1.1780186891555786,
0.9110780358314514,
0.11254653334617615,
-0.07829230278730392,
-0.22668024897575378,
-0.2270737886428833,
0.44489753246307373,
-0.263569712638855,
0.6237955689430237,
0.3511302173137665,
0.2722407579421997,
0.5237323641777039,
-0.710634171962738,
-0.2007848620414734,
-0.3509620130062103,
0.5197169184684753,
0.42909979820251465,
-0.5217113494873047,
0.7964617609977722,
-0.21519038081169128,
-0.5788212418556213,
0.14850661158561707,
0.6656649112701416,
0.6542560458183289,
0.4720589518547058,
0.4536360800266266,
0.7388376593589783,
0.7165650129318237,
0.013760906644165516,
1.2492066621780396,
-0.05495375394821167,
0.43613365292549133,
1.271716594696045,
-0.25316306948661804,
0.796089231967926,
0.5672187209129333,
-0.2771765887737274,
0.2449224889278412,
0.7040831446647644,
0.3820233643054962,
0.8231721520423889,
0.15798847377300262,
-0.5732160806655884,
0.06961813569068909,
-0.21372422575950623,
-0.10611889511346817,
0.11248864978551865,
0.23328374326229095,
-0.13174858689308167,
-0.4793226718902588,
0.07849784195423126,
-0.09363099932670593,
0.09396818280220032,
-0.15838751196861267,
0.9319448471069336,
-0.0032923270482569933,
-1.0465457439422607,
0.5739380717277527,
0.10140860825777054,
0.6387760043144226,
-0.5742524266242981,
0.02613764815032482,
-0.3042992949485779,
-0.09094692021608353,
0.007485631853342056,
-0.5212440490722656,
0.4079156816005707,
0.018170181661844254,
-0.3919675350189209,
-0.3402044475078583,
1.039507269859314,
-0.289633572101593,
-0.482744961977005,
0.22997479140758514,
0.5694848895072937,
0.36839935183525085,
0.6717508435249329,
-0.3664543032646179,
-0.428162157535553,
0.02897932007908821,
-0.6014323830604553,
0.6129283308982849,
0.3886643946170807,
-0.10876724869012833,
0.6123009324073792,
1.090026617050171,
0.3681318461894989,
0.07399792969226837,
0.0005959429545328021,
0.7472174763679504,
-0.5813598036766052,
-0.6848323345184326,
-0.11872883886098862,
0.6217925548553467,
-0.38475272059440613,
-0.12333843111991882,
0.3977741301059723,
0.5426511764526367,
0.7990999817848206,
0.1327832192182541,
0.9062985777854919,
-0.1194547563791275,
1.1778748035430908,
-0.2114344835281372,
0.6002525091171265,
-0.7534862756729126,
0.009723405353724957,
-0.1526382565498352,
-0.7391525506973267,
0.2121889889240265,
0.5768144130706787,
-0.20231018960475922,
0.2790357172489166,
0.5286674499511719,
0.8192788362503052,
-0.019109226763248444,
0.10033891350030899,
0.6453782916069031,
-0.10859718918800354,
0.2644125521183014,
0.3261593282222748,
0.6796337366104126,
-0.3267669677734375,
0.44164323806762695,
-0.11364246904850006,
-0.7979258298873901,
-0.1528857797384262,
-0.726556122303009,
-0.34799742698669434,
-0.7614700794219971,
0.1880883127450943,
-0.34359443187713623,
0.039885763078927994,
0.7907054424285889,
0.43185779452323914,
-0.39240142703056335,
-0.34386980533599854,
-0.09116343408823013,
0.199949711561203,
-0.25730469822883606,
-0.2804108262062073,
0.25973114371299744,
-0.7949350476264954,
-0.7854316234588623,
0.11467456817626953,
0.24132998287677765,
-0.2242286205291748,
-0.15858368575572968,
0.18363024294376373,
-0.4604385197162628,
0.3731186091899872,
0.5310318470001221,
0.46045011281967163,
-0.18811392784118652,
0.0018295457120984793,
0.20368975400924683,
-0.1873006522655487,
-0.0009335865033790469,
0.7860282063484192,
-0.49783119559288025,
0.4757474660873413,
0.4643697738647461,
0.7913183569908142,
1.0665526390075684,
0.33957648277282715,
0.5933708548545837,
-0.8058775067329407,
0.11178417503833771,
0.3651920258998871,
0.12263856083154678,
0.11484498530626297,
-0.4917587637901306,
0.815002977848053,
0.11800834536552429,
-0.8465007543563843,
-1.0286680459976196,
0.47851598262786865,
-0.9609342813491821,
-0.2492247074842453,
1.0648338794708252,
0.00025410077068954706,
-0.5003130435943604,
-0.37355777621269226,
-0.011210676282644272,
0.614385187625885,
-0.37461692094802856,
0.6253344416618347,
0.3107810914516449,
-0.34368765354156494,
-0.4360494017601013,
-0.9563408493995667,
0.646826446056366,
0.3221476674079895,
-0.6972771286964417,
0.03286389261484146,
0.5499680042266846,
0.019570477306842804,
0.23816722631454468,
1.0157719850540161,
-0.07282935082912445,
0.38965708017349243,
0.09759440273046494,
0.00922529585659504,
0.004483992233872414,
-0.15366926789283752,
0.13464447855949402,
0.34515380859375,
-0.16892099380493164,
-0.05616056174039841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02814v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02814v2
|
NegativePrompt: Leveraging Psychology for Large Language Models Enhancement via Negative Emotional Stimuli
| 2024-05-05T05:06:07 | 2024-05-12T16:11:48 |
Xu Wang, Cheng Li, Yi Chang, Jindong Wang, Yuan Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become integral to a wide spectrum of
applications, ranging from traditional computing tasks to advanced artificial
intelligence (AI) applications. This widespread adoption has spurred extensive
research into LLMs across various disciplines, including the social sciences.
Notably, studies have revealed that LLMs possess emotional intelligence, which
can be further developed through positive emotional stimuli. This discovery
raises an intriguing question: can negative emotions similarly influence LLMs,
potentially enhancing their performance? In response to this question, we
introduce NegativePrompt, a novel approach underpinned by psychological
principles, involving ten specifically designed negative emotional stimuli. We
embark on rigorous experimental evaluations of five LLMs including
Flan-T5-Large, Vicuna, Llama 2, ChatGPT, and GPT-4, across a set of 45 tasks.
The results are revealing: NegativePrompt markedly enhances the performance of
LLMs, evidenced by relative improvements of 12.89% in Instruction Induction
tasks and 46.25% in BIG-Bench tasks. Moreover, we conduct attention
visualization experiments to decipher the underlying mechanisms of
NegativePrompt's influence. Our research contributes significantly to the
understanding of LLMs and emotion interaction, demonstrating the practical
efficacy of NegativePrompt as an emotion-driven method and offering novel
insights for the enhancement of LLMs in real-world applications. The code is
available at https://github.com/wangxu0820/NegativePrompt.
|
[
-0.6985104084014893,
-1.0976332426071167,
0.6448375582695007,
0.3420329689979553,
-0.1922043263912201,
-0.18484582006931305,
-0.4440235495567322,
-0.6808233261108398,
0.452756404876709,
0.28798943758010864,
-0.7829606533050537,
-0.7099650502204895,
-0.6472216844558716,
0.054392680525779724,
-0.6426047086715698,
0.8441900610923767,
0.3665112257003784,
0.07950180768966675,
-0.1877608299255371,
-0.1105535626411438,
-0.5278023481369019,
-0.8382576107978821,
-0.5281421542167664,
-0.6447610855102539,
0.6488274931907654,
0.6459786295890808,
0.5617860555648804,
-0.13039469718933105,
0.34493470191955566,
0.22115033864974976,
0.3194090723991394,
-0.22730733454227448,
-0.6386273503303528,
0.26778262853622437,
-0.07754442095756531,
-0.4663662314414978,
-0.5000109076499939,
0.16978314518928528,
0.18844972550868988,
0.33588024973869324,
-0.06974533945322037,
0.19208043813705444,
0.0405702069401741,
0.6078271269798279,
-0.7450683116912842,
0.04909912869334221,
-0.3338402509689331,
0.09482746571302414,
-0.2889467775821686,
-0.34942755103111267,
-0.4441843032836914,
-0.2447139471769333,
-0.06678137928247452,
-0.3132684826850891,
0.055207882076501846,
-0.24295668303966522,
0.5717403888702393,
0.22512023150920868,
-0.4328262209892273,
-0.2199082374572754,
-0.4887240529060364,
0.7093857526779175,
-0.8311500549316406,
0.5317857265472412,
0.17752386629581451,
-0.151194766163826,
-0.020107265561819077,
-0.043244387954473495,
-0.7928058505058289,
-0.6932985782623291,
0.139242023229599,
0.2939039468765259,
-0.04740952327847481,
0.20629891753196716,
0.4206441640853882,
0.1988449990749359,
-0.5020778775215149,
0.45476844906806946,
-0.07210348546504974,
-0.010238486342132092,
0.6760241389274597,
0.269816517829895,
0.5842106342315674,
0.17902831733226776,
0.08039926737546921,
-0.005276545416563749,
-0.8357697129249573,
-0.06805603206157684,
0.4098852276802063,
0.2891980707645416,
-0.25172141194343567,
0.8038279414176941,
-0.036645520478487015,
0.6341521143913269,
-0.048809122294187546,
0.18390443921089172,
0.1856490522623062,
0.25533527135849,
-0.20966801047325134,
0.1271246373653412,
0.5601379871368408,
0.3111999034881592,
0.4732216000556946,
-0.09059607237577438,
-0.12047217041254044,
0.8760812878608704,
0.16328281164169312,
-0.969007134437561,
-0.0779779702425003,
0.3502613604068756,
-0.15442514419555664,
-0.3226361870765686,
-0.38891518115997314,
-0.8519612550735474,
-0.9896358847618103,
-0.7289953827857971,
0.546147346496582,
-0.5062471032142639,
-0.48484471440315247,
0.04521854966878891,
-0.0034742492716759443,
0.21186226606369019,
0.3382393419742584,
-0.7529428601264954,
0.4112238883972168,
1.013933539390564,
0.598038911819458,
0.13920453190803528,
-0.3699423372745514,
-0.7259498238563538,
-0.27591878175735474,
-0.49330827593803406,
0.6918988227844238,
-0.8820856213569641,
-0.22972051799297333,
0.004680479411035776,
-0.2650941014289856,
0.06298263370990753,
-0.7342118620872498,
0.5522053837776184,
-0.3458010256290436,
0.24449069797992706,
-0.2848680913448334,
-0.5019973516464233,
-0.11414196342229843,
0.532479465007782,
-0.5183840394020081,
0.820449709892273,
-0.12705394625663757,
-0.41720589995384216,
-0.01843852922320366,
-0.8378334045410156,
-0.7846888899803162,
-0.0829438716173172,
-0.24527646601200104,
-0.1773679554462433,
0.5531775951385498,
-0.12779204547405243,
0.5202202200889587,
-0.4606608748435974,
0.02825894020497799,
-0.8302409648895264,
-0.5664428472518921,
0.39575546979904175,
-0.21291880309581757,
0.519535481929779,
-0.15571874380111694,
-0.4514504075050354,
0.1250765025615692,
-0.6051905751228333,
-0.10664617270231247,
0.170192152261734,
0.1882544308900833,
-0.49017831683158875,
-0.08093965798616409,
-0.21309451758861542,
0.51544588804245,
0.22672604024410248,
-0.4960692524909973,
0.24957504868507385,
-0.4150012135505676,
0.3406014144420624,
0.7715921401977539,
0.08955978602170944,
0.32934466004371643,
-0.010294587351381779,
0.8041136860847473,
-0.0644608736038208,
0.11604605615139008,
0.16912253201007843,
-0.20753371715545654,
-0.7664244771003723,
-0.16760283708572388,
-0.33197179436683655,
0.48574143648147583,
-0.46335574984550476,
0.007246601860970259,
0.2221972942352295,
-0.6670269966125488,
-0.47050413489341736,
0.24719847738742828,
0.2658832371234894,
0.6299448609352112,
0.4018375277519226,
-0.22660310566425323,
-0.5309237241744995,
-0.6834354996681213,
-0.3244397044181824,
-0.052936851978302,
0.049290068447589874,
0.3348170220851898,
0.3097041845321655,
-0.31189268827438354,
0.3707584738731384,
-0.7323528528213501,
-0.28718629479408264,
-0.21780434250831604,
0.41819635033607483,
0.4922271966934204,
0.18386277556419373,
0.49845069646835327,
-0.5184395909309387,
-0.4480119049549103,
-0.40199580788612366,
-0.5206074714660645,
-0.46336427330970764,
-0.1611904799938202,
-0.2271054983139038,
0.3919513523578644,
0.3156989812850952,
-0.9945474863052368,
0.1216147392988205,
0.676410436630249,
-0.6472432613372803,
0.9375967979431152,
0.040361739695072174,
0.09339217841625214,
-0.6040757298469543,
-0.0010927553521469235,
0.5052585005760193,
0.14841996133327484,
-0.7895093560218811,
0.07554149627685547,
0.0119081512093544,
-0.38858741521835327,
-0.400529146194458,
0.5784412026405334,
-0.29479965567588806,
0.12246523797512054,
-0.4191029667854309,
0.3013613224029541,
-0.027808163315057755,
0.48820170760154724,
0.09605468809604645,
0.5506848096847534,
0.6472246646881104,
-0.6374573707580566,
0.2892951965332031,
-0.06136626377701759,
-0.14164553582668304,
0.845784604549408,
-0.4680672287940979,
0.07107086479663849,
-0.2774033844470978,
-0.003453661222010851,
-0.8445515036582947,
-0.13099408149719238,
0.14664700627326965,
-0.38273128867149353,
0.41432830691337585,
0.3988253176212311,
-0.5514592528343201,
-0.3560624122619629,
-0.5990714430809021,
0.03196147456765175,
0.7516281008720398,
-0.42835932970046997,
0.42747679352760315,
0.07423966377973557,
-0.349500447511673,
-0.2514757215976715,
-0.6952364444732666,
0.35851380228996277,
-0.42600151896476746,
-0.303891122341156,
0.20934046804904938,
-0.1843196153640747,
-0.465819776058197,
-0.09696238487958908,
0.008388800546526909,
0.16753517091274261,
0.2877282500267029,
0.38928401470184326,
0.22794286906719208,
-0.15721815824508667,
0.3745124936103821,
-0.1282682567834854,
-0.09556136280298233,
0.3384225368499756,
-0.011108102276921272,
0.8650438189506531,
-0.18573971092700958,
-0.5292640328407288,
-0.7089112401008606,
0.162667378783226,
0.7954422831535339,
-0.27934178709983826,
0.7382225394248962,
0.8197379112243652,
-0.2932621240615845,
-0.2768065333366394,
-0.49253198504447937,
-0.5863603353500366,
-0.4773660898208618,
0.472676545381546,
-0.18261225521564484,
-0.4732186794281006,
0.33921924233436584,
-0.04899214580655098,
-0.38557448983192444,
0.07622702419757843,
0.6909593939781189,
-0.1983557641506195,
1.2227272987365723,
0.6650458574295044,
-0.17796334624290466,
0.7585389614105225,
-0.16134829819202423,
0.3826378285884857,
-0.8662176132202148,
-0.10979629307985306,
-0.24792513251304626,
-0.6532434225082397,
-0.5208190083503723,
-0.11948829889297485,
0.2194981873035431,
-0.07782714813947678,
-0.5287951231002808,
0.0208517424762249,
-0.3140241801738739,
0.3065996468067169,
0.4341279864311218,
0.07273899018764496,
-0.03652124106884003,
-0.4130861163139343,
0.26776567101478577,
-0.2644180655479431,
-0.19086024165153503,
-0.2836266756057739,
0.657369077205658,
0.2619751989841461,
0.7938076257705688,
0.1977742612361908,
0.8856197595596313,
0.4263745844364166,
0.7623050212860107,
-0.9954859018325806,
0.8629920482635498,
-0.31189295649528503,
-0.502964437007904,
-0.14961908757686615,
-0.2684233486652374,
-0.5445352792739868,
0.020258218050003052,
-0.34283533692359924,
-1.078621745109558,
0.09126549959182739,
0.3995264172554016,
-0.1916320025920868,
-0.19692163169384003,
-1.0970628261566162,
0.9547520279884338,
-0.6740283370018005,
-0.6801704168319702,
-0.46098288893699646,
-0.2741979956626892,
0.48291918635368347,
-0.15462441742420197,
0.11697138845920563,
-0.1853688657283783,
-0.05888909101486206,
0.5049690008163452,
-0.11764370650053024,
1.034947395324707,
-0.5494282245635986,
-0.5811083912849426,
0.07446783781051636,
0.41165784001350403,
0.8037640452384949,
-0.005551037844270468,
-0.29934513568878174,
0.0036683380603790283,
-0.315456748008728,
-0.2667922377586365,
-0.9595006704330444,
0.802472710609436,
-0.6928499937057495,
-0.7690140008926392,
-0.14074327051639557,
-0.5945112109184265,
-0.5034186244010925,
0.18981127440929413,
-0.06249352917075157,
0.3906589150428772,
0.010946964845061302,
0.031126458197832108,
0.4654413163661957,
-0.6500614881515503,
0.10637281835079193,
0.8153419494628906,
-0.34449130296707153,
-0.046296991407871246,
1.3534867763519287,
0.23478086292743683,
0.2950725257396698,
0.4982633590698242,
0.2022828459739685,
-0.29801610112190247,
-0.44088324904441833,
0.16024158895015717,
0.3519916832447052,
-0.5271094441413879,
-0.08567821979522705,
-0.3480973541736603,
0.004837687127292156,
-0.4261033535003662,
-0.12797385454177856,
-0.40539541840553284,
-0.3061044216156006,
-0.5663661360740662,
-0.15515367686748505,
0.28592321276664734,
0.6360982060432434,
-0.034317340701818466,
-0.0027127715293318033,
-0.5993505716323853,
0.474040150642395,
0.044602394104003906,
0.3582842946052551,
0.30159851908683777,
-0.37495291233062744,
-0.16540353000164032,
-0.06743436306715012,
-0.430429071187973,
-1.006156086921692,
0.6840071678161621,
0.1677083969116211,
0.24558475613594055,
0.6193006038665771,
0.36459580063819885,
0.7365952134132385,
-0.3301471471786499,
0.7777231931686401,
0.2970699369907379,
-1.079872488975525,
0.364566445350647,
-0.2925598621368408,
0.30890294909477234,
0.26422491669654846,
0.4360460638999939,
-0.7419208288192749,
-0.757777750492096,
-0.5497603416442871,
-0.9245595932006836,
0.5244611501693726,
-0.1333402544260025,
0.2610563337802887,
-0.06666111201047897,
0.3076217770576477,
0.0642256885766983,
0.11907579004764557,
-0.6964529752731323,
-0.13860894739627838,
-0.190767303109169,
-0.5069116353988647,
-0.43924638628959656,
-0.35406211018562317,
-0.03084130771458149,
-0.1574256867170334,
0.7287396788597107,
0.13940826058387756,
0.3718664348125458,
-0.012789118103682995,
-0.1920020878314972,
0.003323901677504182,
0.5269671082496643,
0.8871018886566162,
0.26460695266723633,
-0.3219020366668701,
0.3284687399864197,
0.292620450258255,
-0.2532332241535187,
0.20675833523273468,
0.1305418163537979,
0.16285714507102966,
-0.42834845185279846,
0.6124323606491089,
0.6034436821937561,
-0.07197466492652893,
-0.8261174559593201,
0.37430819869041443,
-0.05005708336830139,
-0.06723737716674805,
-0.29772070050239563,
0.22592318058013916,
0.29274681210517883,
0.618007242679596,
0.3365766704082489,
-0.20283661782741547,
0.13821208477020264,
-0.6434352397918701,
-0.10028097778558731,
0.5396025776863098,
-0.42665472626686096,
-0.6858105659484863,
0.39703866839408875,
0.29629942774772644,
-0.5059149861335754,
0.698881983757019,
-0.4161611795425415,
-0.6502780318260193,
0.7191813588142395,
0.9086713194847107,
0.8253254890441895,
-0.024844203144311905,
0.28440093994140625,
0.057780105620622635,
0.15472838282585144,
0.24925900995731354,
0.4698323607444763,
-0.018946737051010132,
-0.5781809687614441,
-0.6011244058609009,
-0.32865670323371887,
-0.5460344552993774,
0.5606538653373718,
-0.5972530841827393,
0.4720885157585144,
-0.294045627117157,
-0.18909485638141632,
-0.2137066125869751,
0.28865543007850647,
-0.6244455575942993,
0.3058508634567261,
0.750447154045105,
0.8246405720710754,
-1.0793222188949585,
0.7409045100212097,
0.7754137516021729,
-0.18779611587524414,
-0.6349837779998779,
0.2216409593820572,
0.15177187323570251,
-0.7294629216194153,
0.7929341197013855,
0.414805144071579,
-0.12030725181102753,
0.047144245356321335,
-0.43037644028663635,
-0.6443254947662354,
0.8181298971176147,
0.713722288608551,
-0.7377145290374756,
0.2813100218772888,
0.1662483662366867,
0.9321698546409607,
-0.007335546426475048,
0.3081884980201721,
0.40227481722831726,
0.5801731944084167,
-0.277077317237854,
-0.339284211397171,
0.3099353611469269,
-0.5330171585083008,
-0.4232041537761688,
0.4254016876220703,
-0.6446800231933594,
0.7608045339584351,
-0.41367360949516296,
-0.2139977514743805,
-0.0679347887635231,
0.30968716740608215,
0.38391581177711487,
0.4396214485168457,
0.27556851506233215,
0.702746570110321,
0.705508828163147,
0.22697028517723083,
1.0488353967666626,
-0.6359944343566895,
0.22741153836250305,
1.0802273750305176,
-0.7663665413856506,
0.7838414907455444,
0.679392397403717,
-0.02632405422627926,
0.5546006560325623,
0.5508443117141724,
0.11386711150407791,
0.41957876086235046,
0.31756195425987244,
-0.33280155062675476,
-0.22090713679790497,
-0.4782024025917053,
-0.4394880533218384,
0.2968299090862274,
0.5650573968887329,
-0.1612366884946823,
-0.055424369871616364,
0.16069509088993073,
-0.007212487980723381,
0.09122257679700851,
-0.26874464750289917,
0.4771179258823395,
0.33084389567375183,
-0.501488208770752,
0.5880795121192932,
-0.19577208161354065,
0.6986360549926758,
-0.4157814681529999,
-0.07992234081029892,
-0.2961060702800751,
0.41219910979270935,
-0.3577542304992676,
-0.6987431049346924,
0.1296796202659607,
0.1371309906244278,
0.014996141195297241,
-0.2962157130241394,
0.8385117053985596,
-0.2965725362300873,
-0.34466949105262756,
0.6068798303604126,
0.36816659569740295,
-0.13413217663764954,
-0.3554081916809082,
-0.42273345589637756,
0.24443398416042328,
-0.38388463854789734,
-0.47829070687294006,
0.5064400434494019,
0.48409441113471985,
0.15393123030662537,
0.6013332009315491,
0.4274135231971741,
0.2095947563648224,
-0.39930635690689087,
0.4755643606185913,
0.7868956327438354,
-0.8914793729782104,
-0.15713457763195038,
-1.4236750602722168,
0.3194841742515564,
0.09077086299657822,
0.022309910506010056,
0.765689492225647,
0.2569918632507324,
0.5126292705535889,
-0.12490077316761017,
0.6744244694709778,
0.008464252576231956,
0.22299379110336304,
-0.2930885851383209,
0.5691049695014954,
-0.7126901149749756,
0.19554339349269867,
-0.5814166069030762,
-0.8280291557312012,
-0.3825676143169403,
0.21193522214889526,
-0.9561320543289185,
-0.1917504519224167,
0.46190258860588074,
0.8898608088493347,
0.21524566411972046,
0.012193909846246243,
0.3261038661003113,
0.5547049641609192,
0.4921892285346985,
0.8470602631568909,
1.2188994884490967,
0.21480290591716766,
0.2534754276275635,
-0.2832811772823334,
-0.209017813205719,
-0.2888674736022949,
-0.9486712217330933,
-0.7642349004745483,
-0.22576157748699188,
-0.28165316581726074,
-0.23235242068767548,
0.09818558394908905,
1.091212511062622,
0.4328468441963196,
-0.5829989314079285,
-0.15199683606624603,
-0.397987425327301,
0.10072933882474899,
-0.13650648295879364,
-0.3127219080924988,
0.15315452218055725,
-0.3769105076789856,
-0.5453318953514099,
0.17308774590492249,
0.24689194560050964,
0.029167205095291138,
-0.27452465891838074,
-0.2695743441581726,
-0.13046616315841675,
0.22924456000328064,
0.9443185925483704,
0.30392903089523315,
-0.30782580375671387,
-0.19408836960792542,
0.0010680920677259564,
-0.0051801856607198715,
-0.19818203151226044,
0.5383480787277222,
-0.7334428429603577,
0.05898454040288925,
0.49214401841163635,
0.4381555914878845,
0.37046393752098083,
0.110434889793396,
0.5891425013542175,
-0.5933387875556946,
0.2206999510526657,
0.508815586566925,
0.1399908810853958,
0.30306631326675415,
-0.5893404483795166,
0.3729605972766876,
0.1162044107913971,
-0.34115204215049744,
-1.0442087650299072,
0.39524999260902405,
-0.672816812992096,
-0.32743901014328003,
1.1791585683822632,
0.24114155769348145,
-0.08779114484786987,
0.4989596903324127,
-0.2193300426006317,
0.21188709139823914,
-0.4697381854057312,
1.206634521484375,
0.673183262348175,
-0.6157869696617126,
-0.28840920329093933,
-0.7315583825111389,
0.048645664006471634,
0.7553644180297852,
-0.8775100708007812,
0.12853077054023743,
0.4578860402107239,
-0.026332376524806023,
0.112322598695755,
0.5666141510009766,
0.111879363656044,
0.18222829699516296,
-0.20169681310653687,
0.2987554669380188,
-0.11816956102848053,
-0.25426021218299866,
-0.36136385798454285,
0.2672310769557953,
0.2319040596485138,
0.06837140023708344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02793v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02793v1
|
ImageInWords: Unlocking Hyper-Detailed Image Descriptions
| 2024-05-05T02:15:11 | 2024-05-05T02:15:11 |
Roopal Garg, Andrea Burns, Burcu Karagol Ayan, Yonatan Bitton, Ceslee Montgomery, Yasumasa Onoe, Andrew Bunner, Ranjay Krishna, Jason Baldridge, Radu Soricut
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Despite the longstanding adage "an image is worth a thousand words," creating
accurate and hyper-detailed image descriptions for training Vision-Language
models remains challenging. Current datasets typically have web-scraped
descriptions that are short, low-granularity, and often contain details
unrelated to the visual content. As a result, models trained on such data
generate descriptions replete with missing information, visual inconsistencies,
and hallucinations. To address these issues, we introduce ImageInWords (IIW), a
carefully designed human-in-the-loop annotation framework for curating
hyper-detailed image descriptions and a new dataset resulting from this
process. We validate the framework through evaluations focused on the quality
of the dataset and its utility for fine-tuning with considerations for
readability, comprehensiveness, specificity, hallucinations, and
human-likeness. Our dataset significantly improves across these dimensions
compared to recently released datasets (+66%) and GPT-4V outputs (+48%).
Furthermore, models fine-tuned with IIW data excel by +31% against prior work
along the same human evaluation dimensions. Given our fine-tuned models, we
also evaluate text-to-image generation and vision-language reasoning. Our
model's descriptions can generate images closest to the original, as judged by
both automated and human metrics. We also find our model produces more
compositionally rich descriptions, outperforming the best baseline by up to 6%
on ARO, SVO-Probes, and Winoground datasets.
|
[
-0.4935093820095062,
-0.30497443675994873,
0.32857781648635864,
0.20637746155261993,
-0.6407473683357239,
-0.11929251253604889,
-0.2853548526763916,
-0.9729689955711365,
-0.09128955006599426,
0.8350902199745178,
-0.15760889649391174,
-0.4568476974964142,
-0.6061766147613525,
0.28486186265945435,
-0.6364337801933289,
0.9387264251708984,
-0.1437748670578003,
0.06436597555875778,
-0.4438168406486511,
-0.2658628821372986,
-0.35135990381240845,
-0.06676597893238068,
-0.3913300633430481,
-0.2737448215484619,
0.4715396463871002,
0.32282528281211853,
0.9649274349212646,
1.1966743469238281,
0.9741227030754089,
0.12534664571285248,
0.10442004352807999,
0.36749038100242615,
-0.3860734701156616,
-0.13607226312160492,
-0.15095891058444977,
-0.1722453385591507,
-0.12453694641590118,
0.03646700084209442,
0.40943947434425354,
0.44506871700286865,
0.22289492189884186,
0.1528249979019165,
0.16187164187431335,
0.6130279898643494,
-0.6542507410049438,
0.3510439991950989,
-0.8430710434913635,
0.3030523955821991,
-0.28408169746398926,
-0.32692787051200867,
-0.10697867721319199,
-0.0012273893225938082,
0.4143347144126892,
-0.9412069320678711,
0.41402092576026917,
0.1375712752342224,
1.3988666534423828,
0.20651930570602417,
0.22936603426933289,
-0.30926457047462463,
-0.5314154624938965,
0.5030807256698608,
-0.6587779521942139,
-0.007813679054379463,
0.6874142289161682,
0.34947413206100464,
0.06666892766952515,
-0.8998293280601501,
-0.7043620944023132,
-0.29208022356033325,
-0.10171572118997574,
0.12430260330438614,
-0.23429781198501587,
0.2528876066207886,
0.3743247389793396,
0.5079570412635803,
-0.4401889741420746,
0.1939256489276886,
-0.45815303921699524,
-0.1776726245880127,
0.7224791049957275,
0.32321974635124207,
0.18045076727867126,
-0.08220013976097107,
-0.5103382468223572,
-0.20140093564987183,
-0.5093799233436584,
-0.05855174362659454,
0.38219162821769714,
0.0401199609041214,
0.04788442328572273,
0.7266646027565002,
-0.4499134123325348,
0.7430293560028076,
-0.18911775946617126,
-0.06010912358760834,
0.04850267246365547,
-0.1749248057603836,
0.0056512425653636456,
-0.1359080672264099,
0.7070459723472595,
0.9631803035736084,
0.4721554219722748,
-0.5161108374595642,
-0.5556180477142334,
0.035713281482458115,
0.31531259417533875,
-1.0462034940719604,
-0.3495521545410156,
0.09089992195367813,
-0.6596214175224304,
-0.48160427808761597,
0.19676467776298523,
-0.774099588394165,
-0.6853077411651611,
-0.4208453297615051,
0.5895054340362549,
-0.253368079662323,
0.17106583714485168,
0.19055019319057465,
-0.36315444111824036,
0.11591944843530655,
0.24558769166469574,
-0.47213780879974365,
0.09560226649045944,
0.3339605927467346,
0.7647926211357117,
-0.20094995200634003,
-0.4733719527721405,
-0.34099528193473816,
0.2351558953523636,
-0.6951190829277039,
0.853187620639801,
-0.7592219114303589,
-0.09549205750226974,
0.1434345543384552,
-0.08473649621009827,
0.5798243880271912,
-0.861806333065033,
0.30990979075431824,
-0.2186475545167923,
0.05235160514712334,
-0.07355325669050217,
-0.5749253034591675,
-0.163458451628685,
0.23767460882663727,
-0.6487259268760681,
0.8312433958053589,
-0.051309797912836075,
-0.8834480047225952,
0.4680975675582886,
-0.7644070386886597,
-0.3439774215221405,
0.6549527645111084,
-0.2993955910205841,
-0.3458959758281708,
0.4283687174320221,
0.31687378883361816,
0.6662185192108154,
-0.4223189353942871,
0.1318352073431015,
-0.14005494117736816,
-0.7658395171165466,
0.44635581970214844,
-0.11570277810096741,
0.1491115689277649,
0.12276384979486465,
-0.5483014583587646,
0.0885947197675705,
-0.7418821454048157,
0.07300618290901184,
0.2674427926540375,
-0.1483849138021469,
-0.1853988915681839,
-0.10272573679685593,
0.30913645029067993,
0.09345628321170807,
0.2547779381275177,
-0.6408032178878784,
-0.04183056578040123,
-0.28467226028442383,
0.31044164299964905,
0.6933652758598328,
-0.1938495934009552,
0.18202756345272064,
-0.08976860344409943,
0.523513913154602,
0.1396421194076538,
0.2715323865413666,
-0.6621803045272827,
-0.39728403091430664,
-0.5932510495185852,
-0.14448806643486023,
0.09345405548810959,
0.5529667139053345,
-0.9084511995315552,
0.45769643783569336,
-0.43635594844818115,
-0.6336631178855896,
-0.7110944390296936,
0.2958157956600189,
0.7939127683639526,
0.6915250420570374,
0.4168761372566223,
-0.6387599110603333,
-0.1574825644493103,
-1.3235745429992676,
-0.281920462846756,
0.056919749826192856,
0.06045237183570862,
0.37466609477996826,
0.529025137424469,
-0.5321030020713806,
0.7865753173828125,
-0.5218800902366638,
-0.5554453730583191,
0.01886618137359619,
0.3145866096019745,
-0.16384179890155792,
0.22672033309936523,
0.2323005199432373,
-0.6458002328872681,
-0.25688114762306213,
0.1173240914940834,
-0.9160536527633667,
0.13594497740268707,
-0.39019373059272766,
-0.14258356392383575,
0.0482822060585022,
0.36262959241867065,
-0.5699616074562073,
0.9096174836158752,
0.24733932316303253,
-0.12982770800590515,
0.6964094042778015,
-0.378768652677536,
0.0026424401439726353,
-0.9457192420959473,
0.17930291593074799,
0.4068377614021301,
-0.003968010190874338,
-0.006864218506962061,
0.3951680660247803,
0.05834382027387619,
-0.19266653060913086,
-0.21024958789348602,
0.6604440808296204,
-0.4538270831108093,
0.04081128165125847,
-0.4975862205028534,
0.0622054822742939,
0.10265089571475983,
0.4096217453479767,
0.12584103643894196,
0.6225795745849609,
0.9729880094528198,
-0.3522645831108093,
0.7114443182945251,
0.28716957569122314,
-0.6846654415130615,
0.6173868179321289,
-0.8271355032920837,
0.17986339330673218,
-0.2340555638074875,
0.35319045186042786,
-0.843884289264679,
-0.7396817207336426,
-0.10066914558410645,
-0.17583954334259033,
0.1357700079679489,
-0.0517573282122612,
-0.9708935618400574,
-0.5517199039459229,
-0.17321686446666718,
0.2768620550632477,
0.3898424208164215,
-0.6785221099853516,
0.1966717392206192,
0.2731720209121704,
0.06353922933340073,
-0.5083118677139282,
-0.7500454187393188,
0.8149200081825256,
-0.1882539689540863,
-0.37198662757873535,
0.4233456552028656,
0.22674308717250824,
-0.037902068346738815,
0.10252498835325241,
0.24640440940856934,
-0.18111266195774078,
-0.17122586071491241,
0.3938378095626831,
0.18409544229507446,
0.17622782289981842,
0.41622164845466614,
-0.1711808145046234,
-0.0763758197426796,
-0.01827663742005825,
-0.42131367325782776,
0.26128214597702026,
-0.21059761941432953,
0.016813842579722404,
-0.6354933381080627,
0.35463735461235046,
0.5081225037574768,
-0.40671101212501526,
0.15623918175697327,
1.0416332483291626,
-0.6685589551925659,
0.055361054837703705,
-0.4644510746002197,
-0.19250552356243134,
-0.4013945758342743,
0.736728310585022,
-0.3332063853740692,
-0.5114198923110962,
0.4323566257953644,
-0.011057455092668533,
0.10429541021585464,
0.3064298927783966,
0.1396714448928833,
-0.5846580862998962,
1.1133112907409668,
0.5686990022659302,
0.26169639825820923,
0.33301061391830444,
-0.3735046684741974,
0.18758700788021088,
-0.825908362865448,
-0.2886318266391754,
0.034761346876621246,
-0.6371701955795288,
-0.4443596601486206,
-0.3092542886734009,
0.3609466254711151,
0.016087455675005913,
0.2408980429172516,
0.2801770567893982,
-0.8006049394607544,
0.8156829476356506,
0.5803924202919006,
0.3051404058933258,
-0.10656531900167465,
0.48297441005706787,
0.20477470755577087,
-0.27408310770988464,
-0.24167723953723907,
-0.675882875919342,
1.1337825059890747,
0.2671661078929901,
0.9276083111763,
-0.4606228768825531,
0.4932621419429779,
0.30588388442993164,
0.12490005046129227,
-0.7079452872276306,
0.6717342138290405,
-0.505643367767334,
-0.4237755239009857,
-0.06364823132753372,
-0.11651796847581863,
-0.8873364329338074,
-0.19444511830806732,
-0.41879406571388245,
-0.5012416839599609,
-0.02603057585656643,
0.4441576600074768,
-0.27442482113838196,
0.42509812116622925,
-0.29870885610580444,
0.7258792519569397,
-0.41502854228019714,
-0.454559326171875,
-0.2176378071308136,
-0.9378175139427185,
0.13661998510360718,
-0.005209136288613081,
0.0065872822888195515,
-0.012144220992922783,
-0.18016362190246582,
0.555748462677002,
-0.2622544467449188,
0.7590823769569397,
-0.14280156791210175,
0.06551919132471085,
0.1720665842294693,
-0.026219632476568222,
0.408920556306839,
-0.29811805486679077,
0.38701289892196655,
0.3277856409549713,
-0.10670720040798187,
-0.4815653860569,
-0.41390785574913025,
0.5190989971160889,
-0.4793757498264313,
-0.19566884636878967,
0.07503969222307205,
-0.6814426183700562,
-0.07719795405864716,
0.023824136704206467,
0.7652868032455444,
0.8492708206176758,
0.16665644943714142,
0.16529835760593414,
0.7086876630783081,
-0.4568653106689453,
0.36625537276268005,
-0.36316943168640137,
-0.26878294348716736,
-0.610758364200592,
1.0500764846801758,
-0.009821069426834583,
0.02518000826239586,
0.28115808963775635,
0.22855956852436066,
-0.18041178584098816,
-0.6347396969795227,
-0.857307493686676,
0.1656012386083603,
-0.9491996765136719,
-0.5197106003761292,
-0.6579264402389526,
0.0762653723359108,
-0.1296536922454834,
-0.2674063444137573,
-0.14793218672275543,
-0.33250609040260315,
-0.13838201761245728,
-0.006494443863630295,
0.4229038655757904,
0.8877599239349365,
0.17434664070606232,
0.5138705968856812,
-0.6662147641181946,
0.5333985686302185,
0.19023853540420532,
0.5393969416618347,
-0.13065747916698456,
-0.5892643332481384,
-0.6275380849838257,
0.03465316817164421,
-0.2507832944393158,
-0.615013062953949,
0.36665546894073486,
0.4613455533981323,
0.21785689890384674,
0.5605270862579346,
-0.32719528675079346,
1.1620285511016846,
-0.17841190099716187,
0.8701748251914978,
0.2958466708660126,
-0.6241798400878906,
0.6325333118438721,
-0.1792801469564438,
0.3635580241680145,
0.5029895901679993,
0.04460388794541359,
-0.276249498128891,
-0.5375913977622986,
-0.5853649973869324,
-1.1331814527511597,
0.3304309844970703,
0.10633709281682968,
0.6305971741676331,
0.08417654782533646,
0.758262574672699,
0.28303852677345276,
0.25491586327552795,
-0.6170977354049683,
-0.005760269705206156,
-0.33354413509368896,
-0.43443888425827026,
0.1627536416053772,
-0.2594771683216095,
-0.27476897835731506,
-0.3474317491054535,
0.5257459282875061,
-0.34932419657707214,
0.1448548138141632,
0.22448031604290009,
-0.3439353406429291,
-0.09522456675767899,
-0.1679280549287796,
0.39831289649009705,
0.6748061180114746,
0.09957006573677063,
0.33931076526641846,
-0.11234848946332932,
-0.6320383548736572,
-0.3968140482902527,
0.1423947811126709,
-0.12949152290821075,
0.18061187863349915,
0.7010632753372192,
0.9915204048156738,
-0.05966387316584587,
-1.0845407247543335,
0.6385570168495178,
-0.07741961628198624,
-0.07827131450176239,
-0.1965990960597992,
-0.1317708045244217,
-0.14210520684719086,
0.01503890473395586,
0.4220327138900757,
0.32169967889785767,
0.34844234585762024,
-0.3170868754386902,
0.07064846903085709,
0.31255975365638733,
-0.7069957852363586,
-0.25507262349128723,
0.5046192407608032,
0.1377667635679245,
0.017573554068803787,
0.7841171622276306,
-0.32873591780662537,
-0.36363568902015686,
0.504690408706665,
0.37416061758995056,
0.9895604252815247,
0.5645688772201538,
0.09278266131877899,
0.3435772657394409,
0.37686392664909363,
-0.14298491179943085,
0.27731743454933167,
-0.044046808034181595,
-0.42029428482055664,
-0.19402717053890228,
-0.6694079637527466,
-0.16428358852863312,
0.09653324633836746,
-0.7678127884864807,
0.10393872112035751,
-0.5033899545669556,
-0.32454046607017517,
0.030285963788628578,
-0.2582032382488251,
-0.949463963508606,
0.5259366035461426,
0.362045019865036,
0.8905691504478455,
-0.6878657937049866,
0.5039916634559631,
0.9741507172584534,
-0.5943175554275513,
-0.6791054606437683,
0.0887436494231224,
-0.49862179160118103,
-0.7264302372932434,
0.6703379154205322,
0.5371485948562622,
0.05907256156206131,
-0.13361911475658417,
-1.1872328519821167,
-0.4191237688064575,
1.079694151878357,
0.4120868742465973,
-0.6051763296127319,
-0.03855416551232338,
0.16309194266796112,
0.607950747013092,
-0.5795411467552185,
-0.14567548036575317,
0.2786475718021393,
0.5028661489486694,
0.09824942797422409,
-0.7634232640266418,
-0.15446221828460693,
-0.34805670380592346,
0.3477281332015991,
-0.216105654835701,
-0.1365598738193512,
0.546741247177124,
-0.7233036160469055,
-0.12852288782596588,
0.4192575514316559,
0.4985579550266266,
-0.02513851411640644,
0.28204917907714844,
0.40807363390922546,
0.8028988242149353,
0.5984290242195129,
-0.2209431231021881,
1.3522273302078247,
-0.34930750727653503,
-0.02048497460782528,
1.2114700078964233,
0.0787137895822525,
0.6840980052947998,
0.38746166229248047,
0.21595719456672668,
0.2651340067386627,
0.7039218544960022,
-0.3227265477180481,
0.4553379714488983,
0.27046945691108704,
-0.07571829110383987,
-0.5003355145454407,
-0.4566711187362671,
-0.062135256826877594,
0.6345776319503784,
0.2508935332298279,
-0.714841365814209,
-0.10489850491285324,
0.25131699442863464,
-0.22136938571929932,
0.14794760942459106,
-0.3283346891403198,
0.8982113599777222,
-0.12354940176010132,
-0.42725425958633423,
0.39326420426368713,
-0.14378798007965088,
0.7018378376960754,
-0.2756127119064331,
-0.26930516958236694,
-0.1747674196958542,
0.23284617066383362,
-0.42100101709365845,
-1.1497623920440674,
0.19596759974956512,
0.16508135199546814,
0.025299694389104843,
-0.004500664304941893,
0.6389222145080566,
-0.6472586393356323,
-0.691387414932251,
0.044229403138160706,
0.0018388987518846989,
0.4620654582977295,
-0.4211804270744324,
-0.7167263031005859,
-0.0576559379696846,
-0.15970206260681152,
0.1720014363527298,
-0.12942565977573395,
0.5860455632209778,
-0.33331719040870667,
0.5996132493019104,
0.42279118299484253,
0.38927561044692993,
0.05681599676609039,
0.08295983821153641,
0.5487248301506042,
-0.6272005438804626,
-0.2319154590368271,
-0.725295901298523,
0.437086284160614,
-0.35227206349372864,
-0.5773289799690247,
0.34163129329681396,
0.6994825005531311,
1.0443115234375,
-0.27062827348709106,
0.9878308176994324,
0.08693867921829224,
-0.1406421810388565,
-0.27999645471572876,
0.7407296895980835,
-0.6751438975334167,
-0.20907807350158691,
-0.2535962164402008,
-0.8955916166305542,
-0.41238486766815186,
0.6541715860366821,
0.23932527005672455,
-0.25209346413612366,
0.37601056694984436,
0.8210140466690063,
-0.047341782599687576,
-0.22170096635818481,
0.39553067088127136,
0.06898625195026398,
0.21078267693519592,
0.17851153016090393,
0.9484685063362122,
-0.5707473158836365,
0.6090193390846252,
-0.5851600766181946,
-0.23722624778747559,
-0.14082683622837067,
-0.7961743474006653,
-0.716715931892395,
-0.7883055210113525,
-0.5958196520805359,
-0.3718497157096863,
-0.1742282658815384,
0.690244734287262,
0.8378603458404541,
-0.4667288661003113,
-0.18860860168933868,
-0.00431264890357852,
-0.4778657555580139,
-0.2318737655878067,
-0.18804676830768585,
0.3216749131679535,
-0.3152240514755249,
-0.5397305488586426,
-0.33343908190727234,
0.7463438510894775,
0.2372608780860901,
-0.4285025894641876,
-0.1295752227306366,
0.4747258126735687,
0.025138413533568382,
0.612812340259552,
-0.05740441381931305,
-0.9956239461898804,
-0.14974288642406464,
-0.13733795285224915,
-0.2579234540462494,
0.02187332697212696,
0.7280426621437073,
-0.6007483601570129,
1.00844144821167,
0.19603762030601501,
0.6289227604866028,
0.24302910268306732,
-0.07651019841432571,
0.3412664234638214,
-0.6792011857032776,
0.13162179291248322,
0.27415409684181213,
0.43053632974624634,
0.8250637054443359,
-0.3321576416492462,
0.5440493226051331,
0.1560288518667221,
-0.23484058678150177,
-0.8067265748977661,
0.24442929029464722,
-1.104278564453125,
-0.08084456622600555,
1.0781031847000122,
-0.34027302265167236,
-0.13212968409061432,
0.24224978685379028,
-0.3424844741821289,
0.12691351771354675,
0.0049862610176205635,
1.0460087060928345,
0.5660967230796814,
0.06626375019550323,
0.03488883748650551,
-0.31832170486450195,
0.37938761711120605,
0.094874307513237,
-0.8376511335372925,
0.19768136739730835,
0.649167001247406,
0.04186141863465309,
0.22674596309661865,
0.17029127478599548,
-0.47054383158683777,
0.35060879588127136,
-0.18102851510047913,
0.5238639116287231,
-0.21151728928089142,
-0.3944893479347229,
-0.17208194732666016,
-0.11596394330263138,
0.03823808953166008,
-0.35028284788131714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06677v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06677v1
|
ATG: Benchmarking Automated Theorem Generation for Generative Language Models
| 2024-05-05T02:06:37 | 2024-05-05T02:06:37 |
Xiaohan Lin, Qingxing Cao, Yinya Huang, Zhicheng Yang, Zhengying Liu, Zhenguo Li, Xiaodan Liang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Humans can develop new theorems to explore broader and more complex
mathematical results. While current generative language models (LMs) have
achieved significant improvement in automatically proving theorems, their
ability to generate new or reusable theorems is still under-explored. Without
the new theorems, current LMs struggle to prove harder theorems that are
distant from the given hypotheses with the exponentially growing search space.
Therefore, this paper proposes an Automated Theorem Generation (ATG) benchmark
that evaluates whether an agent can automatically generate valuable (and
possibly brand new) theorems that are applicable for downstream theorem proving
as reusable knowledge. Specifically, we construct the ATG benchmark by
splitting the Metamath library into three sets: axioms, library, and problem
based on their proving depth. We conduct extensive experiments to investigate
whether current LMs can generate theorems in the library and benefit the
problem theorems proving. The results demonstrate that high-quality ATG data
facilitates models' performances on downstream ATP. However, there is still
room for current LMs to develop better ATG and generate more advanced and
human-like theorems. We hope the new ATG challenge can shed some light on
advanced complex theorem proving.
|
[
-0.5365232825279236,
-0.4891405403614044,
0.6019226908683777,
-0.3174389600753784,
-0.31667038798332214,
0.16327552497386932,
-0.2074897289276123,
-0.32403436303138733,
-0.06384719908237457,
0.6045851111412048,
-0.3452015519142151,
-0.7546488046646118,
-0.5543902516365051,
0.40963709354400635,
-0.5437644124031067,
0.35376250743865967,
-0.139353409409523,
-0.2506857216358185,
-0.3077319860458374,
-0.16546976566314697,
-0.3044968545436859,
-0.236342653632164,
-0.6444721817970276,
-0.5289769172668457,
0.07956187427043915,
0.40023040771484375,
0.8930719494819641,
1.0563123226165771,
0.42520689964294434,
0.415945827960968,
0.3246227502822876,
0.3344612121582031,
0.12854225933551788,
0.39495226740837097,
0.05254595726728439,
-0.47515565156936646,
-0.5181644558906555,
-0.004073037765920162,
0.8389214873313904,
0.6085912585258484,
-0.23765449225902557,
0.27000322937965393,
-0.11575128883123398,
0.6211605668067932,
-0.6924265027046204,
0.29222798347473145,
-0.7751644849777222,
0.014492410235106945,
-0.42581939697265625,
-0.14152546226978302,
-0.17839372158050537,
-0.7659766674041748,
0.04113653674721718,
-0.5643393397331238,
0.5231688618659973,
-0.002731811720877886,
0.9858626127243042,
0.6233990788459778,
-0.34900805354118347,
-0.3371390998363495,
-0.31763893365859985,
0.691515326499939,
-0.7876468896865845,
0.31911253929138184,
0.37650394439697266,
0.6880854964256287,
-0.2292363941669464,
-0.8593047261238098,
-0.48339027166366577,
-0.2667795419692993,
-0.06729162484407425,
-0.1638934463262558,
-0.43300381302833557,
-0.1958174705505371,
0.2882325351238251,
0.33675554394721985,
-0.5304901599884033,
-0.3452795445919037,
-0.023524384945631027,
-0.09824058413505554,
0.7855331897735596,
0.1779617965221405,
0.12463966012001038,
-0.5162107348442078,
0.08336252719163895,
-0.45267072319984436,
-1.009297251701355,
-0.1801966428756714,
0.5033663511276245,
0.10289210826158524,
0.425775945186615,
0.5257847309112549,
-0.2282409816980362,
0.6590484976768494,
-0.35469818115234375,
0.09154541045427322,
0.4025862216949463,
-0.36753609776496887,
0.08453798294067383,
-0.08081048727035522,
0.8468196988105774,
0.2515203654766083,
0.499162495136261,
-0.10424204915761948,
-0.4626907706260681,
-0.053186677396297455,
0.33102840185165405,
-0.8561930060386658,
-0.26429906487464905,
0.15738973021507263,
-0.4425589442253113,
-0.432056725025177,
-0.09529193490743637,
-0.6626188158988953,
-0.2917916476726532,
-0.3167063295841217,
0.3281736969947815,
-0.5945701599121094,
-0.18562354147434235,
0.1783660352230072,
-0.0252044890075922,
0.05575506016612053,
0.016833370551466942,
-0.5919836759567261,
0.5168194770812988,
0.6445953845977783,
0.6854378581047058,
-0.12822163105010986,
-0.48253172636032104,
-0.766287624835968,
0.21666358411312103,
-0.3784158527851105,
1.2957935333251953,
-0.3424714505672455,
-0.31488218903541565,
0.1292281448841095,
-0.20911145210266113,
0.004599221050739288,
-1.1185275316238403,
0.5779989361763,
-0.39214563369750977,
0.0032945540733635426,
-0.3613901436328888,
-0.689225435256958,
-0.05170914903283119,
0.3451809883117676,
-0.46475377678871155,
0.8713797926902771,
-0.10121376812458038,
-0.3894103765487671,
0.6047678589820862,
-0.8936312794685364,
-0.3669188320636749,
0.18413463234901428,
-0.4995497167110443,
-0.7085360884666443,
0.08174785226583481,
0.2545219361782074,
0.3000566363334656,
-0.8857912421226501,
0.3173697888851166,
-0.24755121767520905,
0.024694571271538734,
0.34993305802345276,
-0.17621490359306335,
0.56123948097229,
0.2676195502281189,
-0.4320446252822876,
0.1396605223417282,
-1.0240609645843506,
0.5431740283966064,
0.19324718415737152,
-0.32704198360443115,
-0.17959295213222504,
0.4517180323600769,
-0.3978727161884308,
-0.07966028153896332,
-0.09699249267578125,
-0.3948833644390106,
0.29630231857299805,
-0.14394313097000122,
0.41739621758461,
0.6590065360069275,
-0.11863448470830917,
0.04293936491012573,
-0.46568602323532104,
0.6458940505981445,
-0.3078918755054474,
-0.20209619402885437,
-0.11954420059919357,
-0.45824113488197327,
-0.7922964096069336,
-0.4090149402618408,
0.3890009820461273,
0.2641454339027405,
-0.7038914561271667,
0.7120639681816101,
-0.41058409214019775,
-0.45388758182525635,
-0.5376738905906677,
0.176657035946846,
0.3055763244628906,
0.21556037664413452,
0.33672478795051575,
-0.40064066648483276,
-0.2938023805618286,
-0.9142702221870422,
-0.4621415138244629,
-0.3358287513256073,
-0.45683225989341736,
0.5393904447555542,
0.5643218755722046,
-0.48662421107292175,
1.2535254955291748,
-0.7579339742660522,
-0.08568691462278366,
0.04066459462046623,
0.6458333134651184,
-0.09985168278217316,
0.3427218496799469,
0.4267866611480713,
-0.3488588333129883,
-0.4548022747039795,
-0.18168796598911285,
-0.9631810784339905,
-0.6369377374649048,
0.2773309350013733,
-0.20145238935947418,
0.10762882232666016,
0.5690895318984985,
-0.6155980825424194,
0.2751072943210602,
0.13922682404518127,
-0.34539830684661865,
0.7230761051177979,
-0.4244561791419983,
0.10638884454965591,
-0.9398520588874817,
-0.025148309767246246,
-0.3403317630290985,
-0.46351203322410583,
-0.23878023028373718,
0.12284161150455475,
0.07438018172979355,
-0.3634161353111267,
-0.09989303350448608,
0.6194970011711121,
-0.5177684426307678,
-0.3079665005207062,
-0.5486841797828674,
-0.15344394743442535,
-0.1344531625509262,
0.1068810448050499,
0.0046721817925572395,
0.6014581322669983,
0.7350668907165527,
-0.7252821922302246,
0.7449119091033936,
0.13246865570545197,
-0.33089542388916016,
0.35381460189819336,
-0.7597866058349609,
-0.019509634003043175,
0.15806688368320465,
0.39374011754989624,
-0.7970170378684998,
-0.2839434742927551,
0.03999898210167885,
-0.46053841710090637,
-0.02295728214085102,
-0.18931464850902557,
-1.095823049545288,
-0.3087138235569,
-0.19095495343208313,
0.6768289804458618,
0.7345833778381348,
-0.6768206357955933,
0.8249016404151917,
0.09461675584316254,
0.026389801874756813,
-0.2310640811920166,
-0.38280895352363586,
0.21064655482769012,
-0.5318912267684937,
-0.9342460036277771,
0.36036673188209534,
0.25507059693336487,
-0.5066261887550354,
0.08259397000074387,
0.1980857253074646,
0.10291747748851776,
-0.012457076460123062,
-0.00029973077471368015,
-0.2260381281375885,
-0.21802303194999695,
0.17337077856063843,
-0.17168547213077545,
-0.5888327360153198,
0.3837253451347351,
-0.7148618698120117,
0.5999797582626343,
-0.2565009891986847,
-0.7634444236755371,
0.01475830003619194,
0.21910403668880463,
0.5663244128227234,
-0.43456512689590454,
0.34166499972343445,
0.5695676207542419,
-0.6536535024642944,
-0.40298518538475037,
-0.48994719982147217,
-0.21933376789093018,
-0.5145845413208008,
0.18793505430221558,
-0.35841473937034607,
-0.1460748165845871,
0.7355714440345764,
-0.17825070023536682,
0.14833298325538635,
0.4809649884700775,
0.5307040810585022,
0.3542655408382416,
0.7181829214096069,
0.3008490800857544,
0.31024783849716187,
0.2741823196411133,
-0.3779093325138092,
-0.025975355878472328,
-0.39345410466194153,
0.1304425448179245,
-0.6060107946395874,
0.010108496993780136,
-0.6356187462806702,
-0.6747429370880127,
0.4720446765422821,
0.0424051471054554,
-0.2354537397623062,
0.5931122899055481,
-0.42936936020851135,
0.6707070469856262,
0.6761050820350647,
-0.12330351769924164,
0.5086037516593933,
-0.07316187769174576,
-0.19625261425971985,
0.11242733150720596,
-0.5474012494087219,
-0.772189199924469,
1.4669926166534424,
0.052367933094501495,
0.6992329359054565,
0.28638631105422974,
0.9043624997138977,
0.5776380896568298,
0.5447667837142944,
-0.5157713294029236,
0.6900322437286377,
-0.09400904923677444,
-0.5639068484306335,
-0.2744370400905609,
-0.5953130125999451,
-0.9899274706840515,
0.2802939713001251,
0.07917166501283646,
-0.5780171751976013,
-0.014637170359492302,
0.412070095539093,
-0.2724476158618927,
0.21783696115016937,
-0.547882616519928,
0.9806158542633057,
-0.16037693619728088,
-0.5363754630088806,
-0.3141968250274658,
-0.4237121045589447,
0.265499085187912,
-0.20534028112888336,
-0.08260850608348846,
-0.20679976046085358,
-0.021897388622164726,
0.6836609244346619,
-0.9436568021774292,
0.4503037929534912,
-0.23898746073246002,
-0.35943424701690674,
0.7230132222175598,
0.17141886055469513,
0.6067853569984436,
0.04730896279215813,
-0.09177754819393158,
-0.18273667991161346,
-0.4315913915634155,
-0.40095433592796326,
-0.4191857874393463,
0.41425850987434387,
-0.6423038244247437,
-0.5691083669662476,
-0.42624324560165405,
-0.44645172357559204,
-0.12594333291053772,
0.3134332001209259,
0.46981847286224365,
0.46958351135253906,
-0.0029903301037847996,
0.10908109694719315,
0.5598068237304688,
-0.3366694152355194,
0.262408971786499,
0.6829614043235779,
-0.16769662499427795,
-0.3900940716266632,
1.0987964868545532,
-0.016418348997831345,
0.33962976932525635,
0.08161085844039917,
0.35229116678237915,
-0.5756493210792542,
-0.49751973152160645,
-0.5701987743377686,
0.06148802489042282,
-0.9229053854942322,
-0.36330148577690125,
-0.5351166129112244,
-0.10753729939460754,
-0.36303308606147766,
-0.11593496799468994,
-0.7439801692962646,
-0.3309561610221863,
0.16659227013587952,
0.28034085035324097,
0.34812697768211365,
0.5496179461479187,
-0.23179791867733002,
0.006813240237534046,
-0.7728099226951599,
0.3583400845527649,
0.6981408596038818,
0.2359979897737503,
-0.09082235395908356,
-0.27774930000305176,
-0.09243510663509369,
-0.1786690205335617,
-0.8744215369224548,
-0.6360877156257629,
0.35441920161247253,
0.24354836344718933,
0.5692659616470337,
0.41268807649612427,
0.059582676738500595,
0.4597526788711548,
-0.7626829743385315,
0.5175647735595703,
-0.14930593967437744,
-1.1607235670089722,
0.5164467096328735,
-0.6148999929428101,
0.2639586627483368,
0.4567509591579437,
0.07445000857114792,
-0.23802584409713745,
-0.5089356303215027,
-0.8846292495727539,
-0.863632321357727,
0.3442833423614502,
0.5771052837371826,
-0.27727505564689636,
-0.039974991232156754,
0.3526328206062317,
0.08551871031522751,
0.3601977825164795,
-0.6742450594902039,
-0.15714921057224274,
-0.31877270340919495,
-0.0801137238740921,
0.004792309831827879,
0.14490026235580444,
-0.1587996631860733,
-0.1765221804380417,
0.5142999291419983,
-0.3853895366191864,
0.42370662093162537,
-0.22077018022537231,
-0.04467769339680672,
-0.33078932762145996,
0.19988593459129333,
0.41708847880363464,
0.6889991760253906,
-0.3509761691093445,
0.4214031398296356,
0.12167925387620926,
-0.06801801174879074,
0.32971298694610596,
0.5717609524726868,
-0.031010985374450684,
0.1155259907245636,
0.5698463916778564,
0.4163810908794403,
-0.2845679223537445,
-0.9880964159965515,
0.4094945192337036,
-0.15778572857379913,
-0.43821266293525696,
-0.48913809657096863,
0.2895148992538452,
0.03903315216302872,
0.19257085025310516,
0.5753477215766907,
0.05466924607753754,
0.029551085084676743,
-0.47385165095329285,
0.46318620443344116,
0.5236815214157104,
0.25222599506378174,
-0.2749177813529968,
0.8424336314201355,
0.18454356491565704,
-0.44358834624290466,
0.44241759181022644,
-0.467365562915802,
-0.6821253299713135,
0.660389244556427,
0.42694252729415894,
1.2148611545562744,
0.08442527800798416,
-0.01738683320581913,
0.46737146377563477,
0.07179490476846695,
-0.1291135847568512,
-0.09309986233711243,
-0.3353211581707001,
-0.8050949573516846,
-0.1484338641166687,
-0.4515058994293213,
-0.5639083385467529,
-0.04767242819070816,
-0.4560973644256592,
0.4256364703178406,
-0.0933181419968605,
-0.09462644904851913,
0.07616928964853287,
0.05732402205467224,
-0.5126575827598572,
0.10450787097215652,
0.039068758487701416,
0.5111731290817261,
-0.7696312069892883,
0.8451265096664429,
0.6865889430046082,
-0.15330784022808075,
-0.5436147451400757,
0.32694897055625916,
0.06148636341094971,
-0.7806209921836853,
0.6114808320999146,
0.15409092605113983,
-0.2844848036766052,
-0.07691683620214462,
-0.3893823027610779,
-0.8483892679214478,
1.2858549356460571,
0.3945135772228241,
-0.0344412662088871,
0.20400868356227875,
0.3249210715293884,
0.5939957499504089,
-0.5159474611282349,
0.20747700333595276,
0.5725482702255249,
0.5383399724960327,
0.18338355422019958,
-0.572492778301239,
0.1653033345937729,
-0.3775479197502136,
-0.08556161820888519,
0.233212411403656,
-0.48253944516181946,
1.1122021675109863,
-0.11981163918972015,
-0.25185054540634155,
0.0890316516160965,
0.6755797863006592,
0.6180132031440735,
0.18751703202724457,
0.8073424696922302,
0.6969957947731018,
0.7983721494674683,
-0.16145817935466766,
1.1486331224441528,
-0.4090367555618286,
0.3473547697067261,
0.8923776745796204,
-0.45278677344322205,
0.5433092713356018,
0.09070426970720291,
-0.10980173200368881,
0.4100148677825928,
0.5101802349090576,
-0.15428149700164795,
0.44260647892951965,
0.7772392630577087,
-0.37181729078292847,
-0.40396443009376526,
0.05270884558558464,
-0.5475913286209106,
0.2571270763874054,
0.0002714440051931888,
-0.3402879536151886,
-0.350769579410553,
-0.22237370908260345,
-0.07900804281234741,
0.1192447692155838,
0.17907023429870605,
0.6191774606704712,
-0.16111737489700317,
-1.0256751775741577,
1.104576587677002,
0.15039828419685364,
0.41267162561416626,
-0.6306703686714172,
0.04402383789420128,
-0.3308533728122711,
0.6148131489753723,
-0.05058344453573227,
-0.4877833127975464,
0.3796420991420746,
0.3891104459762573,
0.0667884349822998,
-0.3059309720993042,
0.6794000267982483,
-0.28407415747642517,
-0.4150272607803345,
0.2597280740737915,
0.7198759317398071,
0.24666158854961395,
-0.01131727546453476,
-0.4857824146747589,
-0.25720518827438354,
-0.039330121129751205,
-0.31205105781555176,
-0.03128867596387863,
0.803284764289856,
-0.05575733631849289,
1.1284621953964233,
0.5569966435432434,
0.1372992992401123,
0.24210575222969055,
0.03753079101443291,
0.8639435172080994,
-0.6975550055503845,
-0.3174559772014618,
-0.8747051358222961,
0.27640923857688904,
-0.024686330929398537,
-0.21924391388893127,
0.7566735744476318,
0.5465258359909058,
0.6655977964401245,
-0.015870286151766777,
0.8864458203315735,
-0.19520646333694458,
0.41224080324172974,
-0.45563262701034546,
0.5654276013374329,
-0.8692033886909485,
0.44601261615753174,
-0.3722846806049347,
-1.1072345972061157,
-0.31342455744743347,
0.6559068560600281,
-0.1811084747314453,
0.043210215866565704,
0.8592049479484558,
0.7351418137550354,
-0.2067873179912567,
-0.09851127862930298,
0.057557228952646255,
-0.18876564502716064,
0.9359636902809143,
0.524142861366272,
0.9026472568511963,
-0.49005356431007385,
0.7597112059593201,
0.08377644419670105,
-0.15680190920829773,
-0.0033456457313150167,
-1.047194004058838,
-0.8362612128257751,
-0.34215039014816284,
-0.5125415325164795,
-0.41846829652786255,
-0.08597584068775177,
1.1048192977905273,
0.6761434674263,
-0.6054114699363708,
-0.42847681045532227,
-0.6883969306945801,
0.0477474220097065,
-0.23714441061019897,
-0.19650498032569885,
0.5240347385406494,
-0.46519654989242554,
-0.6652839779853821,
0.24695652723312378,
-0.14302891492843628,
0.179668590426445,
-0.2921300232410431,
-0.292254239320755,
0.028154637664556503,
0.12595583498477936,
0.17832788825035095,
0.3705105483531952,
-0.4787735939025879,
-0.298325777053833,
-0.259719580411911,
-0.07368800044059753,
0.05310871824622154,
1.1085214614868164,
-0.7738836407661438,
0.3263428807258606,
0.4155269265174866,
0.729783296585083,
0.45216748118400574,
0.10676325112581253,
0.9721090197563171,
-0.7301889061927795,
-0.10274933278560638,
0.21527528762817383,
0.5074913501739502,
0.366776704788208,
0.2386898696422577,
0.5867321491241455,
0.42908236384391785,
-0.7407538890838623,
-0.9573794603347778,
0.4414467215538025,
-0.4009179174900055,
-0.12610401213169098,
1.1482288837432861,
-0.18841488659381866,
0.021718837320804596,
0.08883077651262283,
0.29463332891464233,
0.31039896607398987,
-0.35497206449508667,
0.9705014824867249,
0.7744833827018738,
-0.14008605480194092,
0.10952754318714142,
-0.4764915108680725,
0.7323891520500183,
0.6361278891563416,
-1.2021805047988892,
0.596246600151062,
0.37819817662239075,
0.3550073802471161,
0.25030216574668884,
0.6063175201416016,
-0.13453172147274017,
0.2916031777858734,
0.12174847722053528,
0.23928064107894897,
-0.16705171763896942,
-0.29197511076927185,
0.07970808446407318,
0.056169960647821426,
0.08609187602996826,
-0.2667717933654785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02774v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02774v1
|
Get more for less: Principled Data Selection for Warming Up Fine-Tuning in LLMs
| 2024-05-05T00:08:00 | 2024-05-05T00:08:00 |
Feiyang Kang, Hoang Anh Just, Yifan Sun, Himanshu Jahagirdar, Yuanzhi Zhang, Rongxing Du, Anit Kumar Sahu, Ruoxi Jia
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This work focuses on leveraging and selecting from vast, unlabeled, open data
to pre-fine-tune a pre-trained language model. The goal is to minimize the need
for costly domain-specific data for subsequent fine-tuning while achieving
desired performance levels. While many data selection algorithms have been
designed for small-scale applications, rendering them unsuitable for our
context, some emerging methods do cater to language data scales. However, they
often prioritize data that aligns with the target distribution. While this
strategy may be effective when training a model from scratch, it can yield
limited results when the model has already been pre-trained on a different
distribution. Differing from prior work, our key idea is to select data that
nudges the pre-training distribution closer to the target distribution. We show
the optimality of this approach for fine-tuning tasks under certain conditions.
We demonstrate the efficacy of our methodology across a diverse array of tasks
(NLU, NLG, zero-shot) with models up to 2.7B, showing that it consistently
surpasses other selection methods. Moreover, our proposed method is
significantly faster than existing techniques, scaling to millions of samples
within a single GPU hour. Our code is open-sourced (Code repository:
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/DV4LLM-D761/ ). While fine-tuning offers
significant potential for enhancing performance across diverse tasks, its
associated costs often limit its widespread adoption; with this work, we hope
to lay the groundwork for cost-effective fine-tuning, making its benefits more
accessible.
|
[
-0.706129789352417,
-0.673924446105957,
0.42737558484077454,
-0.0059337317943573,
-0.46886828541755676,
-0.10369542986154556,
-0.6652982234954834,
-0.28945237398147583,
0.008983046747744083,
0.6962670683860779,
-0.8229629397392273,
-0.4972107708454132,
-0.5007787346839905,
-0.1139693409204483,
-0.09602810442447662,
0.9403325915336609,
0.23160499334335327,
-0.1914091408252716,
-0.10529099404811859,
-0.1262429654598236,
-0.3503360450267792,
-0.13945172727108002,
-0.8652350902557373,
-0.48325058817863464,
0.4386563301086426,
0.8098745942115784,
0.604864239692688,
1.0028409957885742,
0.8091868758201599,
0.16348308324813843,
-0.14885103702545166,
0.3771083950996399,
-0.8940876722335815,
0.1299138367176056,
0.1474362462759018,
-0.5272045731544495,
-0.4522026777267456,
0.10663428902626038,
0.5074883699417114,
0.7579309940338135,
-0.19381631910800934,
0.56773841381073,
0.04069986566901207,
1.0104018449783325,
-0.8606167435646057,
0.09221949428319931,
-0.9833099246025085,
0.1667972207069397,
-0.3763052225112915,
-0.16266728937625885,
-0.233481302857399,
-0.2331276684999466,
-0.07925692945718765,
-0.7016745805740356,
0.2591831684112549,
0.13524310290813446,
0.7483069896697998,
0.663860023021698,
0.04529333859682083,
0.056398287415504456,
-0.679341197013855,
1.0632336139678955,
-0.501406729221344,
0.6030916571617126,
0.5286666750907898,
0.2428460568189621,
0.3179543912410736,
-0.5406057834625244,
-0.26253560185432434,
-0.36621883511543274,
0.18771854043006897,
0.06017105653882027,
-0.09944657236337662,
0.028737779706716537,
0.47267502546310425,
0.4540158808231354,
-0.5800108313560486,
0.4205290973186493,
-0.2004343420267105,
0.07723504304885864,
0.5647522211074829,
0.21041277050971985,
-0.07645392417907715,
0.28659120202064514,
-0.05176783353090286,
-0.2668460011482239,
-1.0740976333618164,
-0.08790048211812973,
0.33658701181411743,
0.6630054116249084,
-0.15217207372188568,
0.5735254287719727,
-0.6112030148506165,
0.8877883553504944,
0.19259211421012878,
-0.06671261787414551,
0.05229184404015541,
-0.4519561231136322,
-0.4781254529953003,
-0.19687382876873016,
0.5128272175788879,
0.3358267843723297,
0.2860852777957916,
0.013668201863765717,
-0.3436140716075897,
-0.02364000491797924,
0.08705316483974457,
-1.0018385648727417,
-0.4768771529197693,
-0.060458675026893616,
-0.4096963107585907,
-0.25395363569259644,
-0.36252495646476746,
-0.6616276502609253,
-0.3513779044151306,
-0.7987310886383057,
-0.02721174620091915,
-0.11604876071214676,
-0.16528677940368652,
0.25725826621055603,
0.03932701423764229,
0.009059058502316475,
0.25250595808029175,
-1.047097086906433,
0.3724372982978821,
0.5276332497596741,
0.8209179639816284,
-0.2822097837924957,
-0.09382764250040054,
-0.6022717356681824,
-0.03100413642823696,
-0.5735946893692017,
0.7152005434036255,
-0.6777184009552002,
-0.24756211042404175,
-0.19345688819885254,
-0.25494053959846497,
-0.034418560564517975,
-0.8018831610679626,
0.6121295094490051,
-0.5090515613555908,
-0.10588137805461884,
-0.377407968044281,
-0.37567850947380066,
0.3442333936691284,
0.04194138944149017,
-0.684799075126648,
1.2062970399856567,
0.10942387580871582,
-0.6698629856109619,
0.7265146374702454,
-0.5442146062850952,
-0.45407673716545105,
0.00220224866643548,
-0.0914892852306366,
-0.4982750117778778,
0.25958263874053955,
0.36146923899650574,
0.6534245014190674,
-0.5355758666992188,
-0.06549689918756485,
-0.37538576126098633,
-0.26135963201522827,
-0.21546471118927002,
-0.27151644229888916,
0.47872623801231384,
0.6558815240859985,
-0.20438413321971893,
0.1867331713438034,
-0.8079866170883179,
0.13511209189891815,
0.03331577405333519,
-0.3223714530467987,
-0.20856143534183502,
-0.03019055165350437,
0.0582783967256546,
0.04283457249403,
0.2343069165945053,
-0.3050815761089325,
0.17785879969596863,
-0.4445732533931732,
0.2492513656616211,
0.7284443974494934,
-0.25191211700439453,
0.79774409532547,
-0.41780999302864075,
0.5822668075561523,
-0.2755372226238251,
0.30615004897117615,
0.3027867078781128,
-0.008167177438735962,
-0.6707408428192139,
-0.43725380301475525,
0.3202621638774872,
0.36121025681495667,
-0.6123534440994263,
0.42629945278167725,
-0.2636720538139343,
-0.47616541385650635,
-0.7182117104530334,
0.6680740118026733,
0.2975662648677826,
0.37539777159690857,
0.4809890687465668,
-0.0782131627202034,
-0.554223895072937,
-0.8161463141441345,
0.009718509390950203,
0.29837462306022644,
-0.16761654615402222,
0.5449572801589966,
0.07105939090251923,
-0.1917765885591507,
0.8026096820831299,
-1.064518928527832,
-0.49276480078697205,
-0.36153534054756165,
-0.2106073647737503,
0.27479100227355957,
0.422150194644928,
0.532292902469635,
-0.5532332062721252,
-0.610965371131897,
0.19101017713546753,
-0.32386314868927,
-0.0689217820763588,
0.006081928964704275,
-0.25857871770858765,
-0.15357184410095215,
0.6511927843093872,
-0.542177140712738,
-0.04605884477496147,
0.6117043495178223,
0.03267502412199974,
0.16169317066669464,
-0.3946952223777771,
-0.08945900946855545,
-0.90036541223526,
-0.024935496971011162,
0.08019597083330154,
-0.2664470374584198,
-0.45380890369415283,
0.04058303311467171,
0.03435596451163292,
-0.15809939801692963,
-0.37965869903564453,
0.6597570180892944,
-0.62157142162323,
0.08178520947694778,
-0.3183528780937195,
0.08973947167396545,
-0.2511306405067444,
0.35540613532066345,
0.11377108842134476,
0.72577303647995,
0.7976767420768738,
-0.8687478303909302,
0.19830858707427979,
0.12959636747837067,
-0.48148807883262634,
0.31737515330314636,
-0.5894066095352173,
0.15835826098918915,
-0.0261461790651083,
-0.1733745038509369,
-0.7245786190032959,
-0.16314904391765594,
-0.03811967745423317,
-0.15540722012519836,
0.4571746289730072,
-0.2871440351009369,
-0.4755558669567108,
-0.07492104917764664,
-0.4172385036945343,
0.32517361640930176,
0.6639121770858765,
-0.6584780216217041,
0.05297981575131416,
0.6432228684425354,
-0.19459377229213715,
-0.4031029939651489,
-0.5016401410102844,
-0.3016228675842285,
-0.31011465191841125,
-0.29037436842918396,
0.2578657865524292,
-0.2084878385066986,
-0.2162264585494995,
-0.2702152729034424,
-0.3095591068267822,
-0.08274774253368378,
0.32731354236602783,
-0.008260780945420265,
0.11852309852838516,
-0.13551202416419983,
-0.0023844316601753235,
0.2633993923664093,
-0.29175665974617004,
-0.367197722196579,
-0.3563677668571472,
0.568824291229248,
0.19142132997512817,
-0.2842806279659271,
-0.1995989978313446,
0.001597113790921867,
0.3091225028038025,
-0.2723352909088135,
0.5341206789016724,
0.7121666073799133,
-0.2662661671638489,
-0.43682539463043213,
-0.42595505714416504,
-0.41542765498161316,
-0.5278086066246033,
0.3372361660003662,
-0.39271271228790283,
-0.9463133811950684,
0.18223895132541656,
-0.20211517810821533,
0.217544287443161,
0.1036253497004509,
0.7161645293235779,
-0.044309258460998535,
0.937473475933075,
0.9197550415992737,
-0.342556893825531,
0.91081303358078,
-0.2543931305408478,
0.00554986298084259,
-0.7327711582183838,
0.16696138679981232,
-0.6213799118995667,
-0.30270639061927795,
-0.5679367184638977,
-0.5316746234893799,
0.26562637090682983,
0.06941347569227219,
-0.1240539476275444,
0.16992759704589844,
-0.740025520324707,
0.8352340459823608,
0.5477645993232727,
0.1664365530014038,
0.16538512706756592,
0.046589624136686325,
0.09642176330089569,
-0.07860998064279556,
-0.7193658351898193,
-0.26436010003089905,
1.3505501747131348,
0.12715953588485718,
0.9859215617179871,
-0.11536063998937607,
0.6755052804946899,
0.12573717534542084,
0.1309167891740799,
-0.6100851893424988,
0.5176364183425903,
-0.3676147162914276,
-0.47592854499816895,
-0.5593332648277283,
-0.5337691307067871,
-1.1899034976959229,
0.20607028901576996,
-0.16821640729904175,
-0.4734419584274292,
0.0035794631112366915,
0.4209250807762146,
-0.5781689286231995,
0.1656842827796936,
-0.677558422088623,
0.6907094717025757,
-0.02572443336248398,
-0.2105930894613266,
-0.40584278106689453,
-0.5680041909217834,
0.22198881208896637,
-0.13862229883670807,
0.12869516015052795,
-0.5516875386238098,
-0.00842730887234211,
0.6307960152626038,
-0.16566993296146393,
0.7361695170402527,
-0.19507138431072235,
-0.07024746388196945,
-0.06080644950270653,
-0.05680375546216965,
0.6446691751480103,
0.18607260286808014,
-0.05118704214692116,
-0.01799524761736393,
-0.08022558689117432,
-0.5336616039276123,
-0.3378312289714813,
0.8984185457229614,
-0.7614479064941406,
-0.4124112129211426,
0.14696958661079407,
-0.5617928504943848,
-0.4057253301143646,
0.23438532650470734,
0.3547069728374481,
0.23569072782993317,
0.04889107123017311,
0.41634413599967957,
0.967624306678772,
0.051340386271476746,
0.24186863005161285,
0.35498711466789246,
-0.039286062121391296,
-0.30868440866470337,
1.0413196086883545,
0.08980584889650345,
0.47545379400253296,
0.5924860835075378,
0.16951143741607666,
-0.3084365129470825,
-1.065968632698059,
-0.22410109639167786,
0.08733963966369629,
-0.4528672993183136,
-0.30920788645744324,
-0.52012038230896,
0.10901002585887909,
-0.49581944942474365,
-0.20330236852169037,
-0.6395248770713806,
-0.41111132502555847,
-0.4953655004501343,
-0.19986335933208466,
0.4264705777168274,
0.30483871698379517,
-0.22247186303138733,
0.5392165780067444,
-0.48864179849624634,
0.5441902875900269,
0.2163320630788803,
0.3818584084510803,
-0.2895139753818512,
-0.6543103456497192,
-0.4599229395389557,
0.01914748176932335,
-0.16583871841430664,
-0.13920250535011292,
0.43368929624557495,
0.3081011176109314,
0.5311952829360962,
0.3792172372341156,
0.19084830582141876,
0.7898682951927185,
-0.4915793240070343,
0.3517584204673767,
0.11538393795490265,
-0.6336684226989746,
0.7537007331848145,
-0.25496432185173035,
0.22929343581199646,
0.9385466575622559,
0.3350335657596588,
-0.2729722559452057,
-0.24969282746315002,
-0.5347761511802673,
-0.9230082631111145,
0.7381993532180786,
0.1515573263168335,
0.17308877408504486,
0.2649247646331787,
0.32546865940093994,
0.17078261077404022,
0.2864026129245758,
-0.3644528090953827,
-0.4387429654598236,
0.16778673231601715,
-0.1963725984096527,
-0.38140028715133667,
-0.06861472874879837,
-0.3072373569011688,
-0.48435601592063904,
0.554446816444397,
-0.4996860921382904,
0.07815400511026382,
-0.2428685426712036,
-0.22855187952518463,
-0.25452420115470886,
0.017381373792886734,
0.5239536762237549,
0.5686436891555786,
-0.33377596735954285,
-0.0513094924390316,
0.3408746123313904,
-0.4840598404407501,
-0.1096099242568016,
0.2548927068710327,
-0.25007086992263794,
-0.15527880191802979,
0.05706338211894035,
1.1751328706741333,
0.2635347843170166,
-0.6465321183204651,
0.05190609022974968,
-0.017360229045152664,
-0.22380222380161285,
0.055102769285440445,
0.26190343499183655,
-0.011837662197649479,
0.3365379273891449,
0.0906444862484932,
0.20562198758125305,
-0.013740447349846363,
-0.2866087853908539,
0.18488965928554535,
0.753728449344635,
-0.19315938651561737,
-0.2726384401321411,
0.6001729369163513,
0.038680221885442734,
0.003955282270908356,
0.49993425607681274,
-0.08519268035888672,
0.16779138147830963,
0.45027053356170654,
0.12255819141864777,
0.6970745921134949,
0.0722799226641655,
0.1439831703901291,
0.22157137095928192,
0.3583815395832062,
-0.2685706317424774,
0.33362358808517456,
-0.180502787232399,
-0.9374263286590576,
-0.4350009858608246,
-0.8112493753433228,
-0.4305133819580078,
0.21245242655277252,
-0.7065962553024292,
0.404604971408844,
-0.6199201345443726,
-0.2520517110824585,
-0.026085741817951202,
0.4150819182395935,
-0.8784815073013306,
0.2798629403114319,
0.17091581225395203,
0.7902830243110657,
-0.8001035451889038,
1.0362286567687988,
0.5335186719894409,
-0.11468664556741714,
-0.6668888330459595,
-0.11557658761739731,
-0.02008846215903759,
-1.002590298652649,
0.4439002275466919,
-0.2920019328594208,
0.041191015392541885,
0.3903619349002838,
-0.5706097483634949,
-1.029715895652771,
1.1103323698043823,
0.7663936018943787,
-0.804782509803772,
-0.011277325451374054,
-0.022236745804548264,
0.38859501481056213,
-0.2213474065065384,
0.1169428676366806,
0.808822512626648,
0.3390286862850189,
0.3397309482097626,
-0.8840824365615845,
-0.014959231950342655,
0.20340019464492798,
-0.03432054817676544,
0.3834505081176758,
-0.6080280542373657,
0.8030838966369629,
-0.33769261837005615,
-0.10284934937953949,
-0.12299299985170364,
0.33668121695518494,
0.39880862832069397,
0.10986051708459854,
0.394706130027771,
0.6607610583305359,
1.0107792615890503,
0.03716219589114189,
1.0516221523284912,
-0.3798522651195526,
0.5716312527656555,
1.1623116731643677,
-0.3461947441101074,
0.7939639091491699,
0.45351624488830566,
-0.366256445646286,
-0.31816309690475464,
0.9456063508987427,
0.10437597334384918,
0.9133152961730957,
0.22430093586444855,
-0.2033141851425171,
-0.36230239272117615,
-0.15195801854133606,
-0.3354998230934143,
0.022172702476382256,
0.21830302476882935,
-0.04297913238406181,
-0.37353986501693726,
0.032910071313381195,
-0.09543348848819733,
-0.16314534842967987,
-0.4267213046550751,
0.8849819302558899,
0.11224392056465149,
-0.3373526632785797,
0.8294309973716736,
-0.18624506890773773,
0.7725903391838074,
-0.600662887096405,
0.3426470458507538,
-0.42852234840393066,
0.31912893056869507,
-0.1435948759317398,
-0.5168740749359131,
0.2859315276145935,
-0.04216603562235832,
-0.21289654076099396,
-0.586212694644928,
0.7463039755821228,
-0.43566086888313293,
-0.4269157946109772,
0.05210718885064125,
0.6577965617179871,
0.05521012842655182,
-0.31266844272613525,
-0.7145206928253174,
0.24905073642730713,
0.22285014390945435,
-0.3516961336135864,
0.7521856427192688,
0.45362216234207153,
0.12817594408988953,
0.7713532447814941,
1.013311743736267,
0.5070990324020386,
0.05414820462465286,
0.10630634427070618,
1.0002741813659668,
-0.5778540968894958,
-0.2204868048429489,
-0.8831942081451416,
0.1990911215543747,
-0.03794163092970848,
-0.4518571197986603,
0.5975545048713684,
0.6385634541511536,
1.0234625339508057,
-0.14203885197639465,
0.6948552131652832,
0.21142178773880005,
0.5178902745246887,
-0.7718250155448914,
0.4816094636917114,
-0.5872463583946228,
0.29518458247184753,
-0.14250557124614716,
-0.8920367956161499,
-0.39133116602897644,
0.6102645993232727,
-0.268384724855423,
-0.19585750997066498,
0.4940832555294037,
0.9405686259269714,
-0.11111639440059662,
-0.2594594955444336,
0.6691077947616577,
-0.13471052050590515,
0.20050376653671265,
0.3966045379638672,
0.6477543115615845,
-0.0046219415962696075,
0.3882629871368408,
-0.3615233302116394,
-0.09081554412841797,
-0.2149612158536911,
-0.7392070293426514,
-0.9387085437774658,
-0.3851238489151001,
-0.4272018373012543,
-0.012665195390582085,
-0.0527128130197525,
1.1879523992538452,
1.126101016998291,
-0.7387377023696899,
-0.2424679398536682,
-0.17394782602787018,
0.22633209824562073,
-0.26204389333724976,
-0.13166998326778412,
0.03968329355120659,
-0.6943442225456238,
-0.804824709892273,
0.42947444319725037,
0.21432577073574066,
-0.07436668872833252,
0.06711445748806,
-0.08377580344676971,
0.12335005402565002,
-0.03578557074069977,
0.6327393651008606,
0.24522793292999268,
-0.3306283950805664,
0.1108083501458168,
0.024319661781191826,
-0.0636323094367981,
0.1556236296892166,
0.9148254990577698,
-0.6103115677833557,
0.04071371257305145,
0.3616602122783661,
0.9097744822502136,
0.8363499045372009,
-0.14873884618282318,
0.362657368183136,
-1.0471919775009155,
0.31736814975738525,
0.33984336256980896,
0.17677785456180573,
0.11553959548473358,
-0.4006790518760681,
0.6394267082214355,
0.0763169676065445,
-0.5792392492294312,
-0.9955514073371887,
0.2189549058675766,
-0.94010329246521,
-0.3175618648529053,
1.375686526298523,
0.16630205512046814,
0.08252748847007751,
0.11367366462945938,
-0.3026883900165558,
0.008479920215904713,
-0.47964078187942505,
0.5830777287483215,
0.4171740412712097,
-0.3175872564315796,
-0.3435841202735901,
-0.7405917048454285,
0.9534130692481995,
0.4649200737476349,
-0.9102944135665894,
0.4712594747543335,
0.4812663793563843,
0.2595925033092499,
-0.24500565230846405,
0.7350971698760986,
0.27499115467071533,
-0.09799590706825256,
-0.21799258887767792,
-0.12411333620548248,
0.06448975950479507,
-0.2861257791519165,
-0.3470804691314697,
0.038112226873636246,
0.4603126347064972,
-0.25593188405036926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02765v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02765v2
|
Detecting Edited Knowledge in Language Models
| 2024-05-04T22:02:24 | 2024-07-01T19:20:58 |
Paul Youssef, Zhixue Zhao, Jörg Schlötterer, Christin Seifert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge editing methods (KEs) can update language models' obsolete or
inaccurate knowledge learned from pre-training. However, KEs can be used for
malicious applications, e.g., inserting misinformation and toxic content.
Knowing whether a generated output is based on edited knowledge or first-hand
knowledge from pre-training can increase users' trust in generative models and
provide more transparency. Driven by this, we propose a novel task: detecting
edited knowledge in language models. Given an edited model and a fact retrieved
by a prompt from an edited model, the objective is to classify the knowledge as
either unedited (based on the pre-training), or edited (based on subsequent
editing). We instantiate the task with four KEs, two LLMs, and two datasets.
Additionally, we propose using the hidden state representations and the
probability distributions as features for the detection. Our results reveal
that, using these features as inputs to a simple AdaBoost classifiers
establishes a strong baseline. This classifier requires only a limited amount
of data and maintains its performance even in cross-domain settings. Last, we
find it more challenging to distinguish edited knowledge from unedited but
related knowledge, highlighting the need for further research. Our work lays
the groundwork for addressing malicious model editing, which is a critical
challenge associated with the strong generative capabilities of LLMs.
|
[
-0.009781940840184689,
-0.7354440689086914,
0.7802419662475586,
-0.25446510314941406,
0.024775812402367592,
0.057783521711826324,
-0.16581518948078156,
-0.42591238021850586,
-0.04984969273209572,
0.8003242015838623,
-0.27110689878463745,
-0.6811871528625488,
-0.7829568386077881,
-0.002178692724555731,
-0.5635524392127991,
0.9407007694244385,
-0.07199925184249878,
-0.14546702802181244,
-0.46983495354652405,
-0.1389847993850708,
-0.3065437972545624,
-0.5947640538215637,
-0.520706057548523,
-0.236976757645607,
0.12329551577568054,
0.17282311618328094,
0.7315253019332886,
0.6363248229026794,
0.15536996722221375,
0.2918858826160431,
-0.4985516369342804,
0.4389640986919403,
-0.24739490449428558,
0.10786991566419601,
-0.25825804471969604,
-0.6443659067153931,
-0.7458605766296387,
-0.11673378944396973,
0.4433164894580841,
0.2336873561143875,
-0.08917882293462753,
0.0382474809885025,
0.15423054993152618,
0.4616169333457947,
-0.8967125415802002,
0.11917277425527573,
-0.9710872173309326,
-0.010800852440297604,
-0.349945068359375,
-0.1974099576473236,
-0.592849850654602,
-0.09003567695617676,
-0.32266727089881897,
-0.6443237066268921,
0.31815728545188904,
-0.19057618081569672,
0.6836614608764648,
0.38386839628219604,
-0.31749802827835083,
-0.3811790645122528,
-0.5106870532035828,
0.3665151596069336,
-0.8809813261032104,
0.5520099401473999,
0.43590113520622253,
-0.02734113298356533,
-0.3939845561981201,
-0.6046856045722961,
-0.9102413654327393,
-0.14608734846115112,
-0.24841390550136566,
-0.11961830407381058,
-0.6821075677871704,
0.2129795253276825,
0.42126336693763733,
0.2166004329919815,
-0.20327545702457428,
0.3265633285045624,
-0.28650543093681335,
-0.6739177703857422,
0.5009095668792725,
-0.04076431691646576,
0.47939804196357727,
-0.33129698038101196,
-0.027839260175824165,
0.042945995926856995,
-0.8296089172363281,
-0.02045672945678234,
0.6064740419387817,
0.10871805250644684,
0.13527663052082062,
0.7153574824333191,
-0.25034835934638977,
0.7826390266418457,
0.14057348668575287,
-0.12321656197309494,
0.1550734043121338,
-0.22208115458488464,
-0.29414665699005127,
-0.006520068272948265,
0.6549397706985474,
0.2370903044939041,
0.17367219924926758,
0.0913485661149025,
-0.5391690731048584,
-0.035336922854185104,
0.20933493971824646,
-0.4369809031486511,
-0.4185863137245178,
0.03944433480501175,
-0.10669222474098206,
-0.641894519329071,
-0.2788771390914917,
-0.33955174684524536,
-0.9000968933105469,
-0.08427940309047699,
0.569860577583313,
-0.4608658254146576,
-0.16654084622859955,
0.09720594435930252,
-0.04382993280887604,
-0.29773348569869995,
0.599510133266449,
-0.6977581977844238,
0.008381460793316364,
0.6427134275436401,
0.5560080409049988,
0.1204792782664299,
-0.15511931478977203,
-0.5159476399421692,
0.23259755969047546,
-0.31418377161026,
0.8049007654190063,
-0.6149535179138184,
-0.1432674080133438,
0.007808681111782789,
-0.06947346031665802,
0.19818294048309326,
-0.5424060225486755,
0.4940238296985626,
-1.0286757946014404,
0.17278935015201569,
-0.161288321018219,
-0.8852701187133789,
-0.09038490802049637,
0.23242142796516418,
-0.6174980998039246,
0.9873847961425781,
-0.07023032009601593,
-0.9193693995475769,
0.5665662288665771,
-0.5926133394241333,
-0.3829168975353241,
-0.17334647476673126,
0.039184778928756714,
-0.6204683780670166,
0.04206768050789833,
0.5261822938919067,
0.5013414025306702,
0.4233839213848114,
0.28898531198501587,
-0.3470021188259125,
0.04813629761338234,
0.33382758498191833,
-0.4067421555519104,
0.7876313924789429,
0.04556256905198097,
0.12439236789941788,
0.1659315675497055,
-0.7748533487319946,
-0.17708280682563782,
0.07545685768127441,
-0.617303729057312,
-0.5682705640792847,
-0.1359681785106659,
-0.41156554222106934,
0.08891843259334564,
0.4090685546398163,
-0.7199971079826355,
0.3256538510322571,
-0.23525340855121613,
0.056480828672647476,
0.9840808510780334,
0.2730347514152527,
0.2973519265651703,
-0.21123124659061432,
0.5735546350479126,
0.3588792085647583,
0.2687147259712219,
-0.1939852386713028,
-0.49442222714424133,
-0.9711204767227173,
-0.08942042291164398,
0.3889502286911011,
0.6046304702758789,
-0.8630303740501404,
0.5006998777389526,
-0.1791909784078598,
-0.35769686102867126,
-0.7714317440986633,
0.44042307138442993,
0.3978467583656311,
0.5650372505187988,
0.43505343794822693,
-0.06306122243404388,
-0.47966712713241577,
-0.7262088060379028,
-0.7510010004043579,
-0.28771018981933594,
-0.028604889288544655,
0.22837519645690918,
0.44297564029693604,
-0.2700936794281006,
0.9237922430038452,
-0.5819334983825684,
-0.3354169726371765,
-0.03939076513051987,
0.13680149614810944,
-0.07517950981855392,
0.4586455821990967,
0.43559059500694275,
-0.32904142141342163,
-0.2638823986053467,
0.05537055432796478,
-0.756837010383606,
-0.3895336389541626,
-0.07082242518663406,
0.08012813329696655,
0.11696521192789078,
0.654030978679657,
-0.497480183839798,
0.5435734987258911,
0.35602882504463196,
-0.27414825558662415,
0.5602303147315979,
-0.39725133776664734,
0.23879513144493103,
-0.9270129799842834,
-0.1386197805404663,
-0.27366724610328674,
-0.4882543087005615,
-0.7800391912460327,
-0.03380997106432915,
0.37044376134872437,
0.15025974810123444,
-0.449829638004303,
0.5596320033073425,
-0.4553893506526947,
0.17426839470863342,
-0.20321181416511536,
0.09566621482372284,
0.002153057837858796,
0.49586933851242065,
0.05511206015944481,
0.6643356680870056,
0.4882122278213501,
-0.48039302229881287,
0.30503007769584656,
0.5057864189147949,
-0.7635008692741394,
0.341698557138443,
-0.2584547996520996,
0.6282796263694763,
-0.24608030915260315,
-0.03994092717766762,
-0.6745121479034424,
-0.20497533679008484,
0.24377033114433289,
-0.5858168005943298,
0.39537522196769714,
-0.44884905219078064,
-0.6838135123252869,
-0.030473781749606133,
-0.028758088126778603,
0.14792977273464203,
0.35242828726768494,
-0.4834088981151581,
0.5675352215766907,
0.5035663843154907,
-0.20024575293064117,
-0.8369265794754028,
-0.5398566126823425,
0.037333399057388306,
0.08838918060064316,
-0.6397170424461365,
0.1313951164484024,
0.16222050786018372,
-0.2735522985458374,
0.32468611001968384,
-0.28882455825805664,
-0.22589634358882904,
0.31557539105415344,
0.10373108834028244,
0.26080870628356934,
-0.08750699460506439,
0.17019498348236084,
0.4913124740123749,
0.07685878872871399,
-0.018735915422439575,
-0.11423029750585556,
0.14932802319526672,
0.14275947213172913,
-0.5736517310142517,
-0.3972282409667969,
-0.15933513641357422,
0.5692200660705566,
-0.34988510608673096,
0.7804132699966431,
0.2904512882232666,
-0.5265610814094543,
-0.35870641469955444,
-0.6861575245857239,
-0.028147757053375244,
-0.47549450397491455,
0.5868661403656006,
-0.2403920739889145,
-0.9517790675163269,
0.5356541872024536,
-0.01521054282784462,
0.0833626538515091,
0.4187978208065033,
0.3669229745864868,
-0.07830709218978882,
1.0370405912399292,
0.7160677313804626,
0.003884220030158758,
0.4582608938217163,
-0.008176195435225964,
0.09438401460647583,
-0.7620973587036133,
-0.18716742098331451,
-0.2456926554441452,
-0.16039393842220306,
-0.35844483971595764,
-0.466382771730423,
0.5090567469596863,
0.3330804109573364,
0.19276073575019836,
0.27709490060806274,
-0.16339623928070068,
0.7601343989372253,
0.41455045342445374,
0.5411696434020996,
0.5962910652160645,
-0.3260340094566345,
-0.24830588698387146,
0.17902956902980804,
-0.7377938032150269,
-0.5028064250946045,
1.3647197484970093,
0.2618566155433655,
0.5418556332588196,
0.1294158548116684,
0.6475861668586731,
0.7766473293304443,
0.4924842119216919,
-0.6271610856056213,
0.5694851875305176,
-0.05455518886446953,
-0.6732485294342041,
-0.21897299587726593,
-0.2459636777639389,
-0.5013921856880188,
0.0518188513815403,
-0.37641414999961853,
-0.5120114088058472,
0.33951830863952637,
0.6867407560348511,
-0.4747806489467621,
0.687366783618927,
-0.5980357527732849,
0.9035153985023499,
-0.020088890567421913,
-0.21108029782772064,
-0.31919988989830017,
-0.26858848333358765,
0.508351743221283,
-0.4195457100868225,
0.38158538937568665,
0.03152759000658989,
0.12640172243118286,
0.8433797955513,
-0.5718002319335938,
0.8645941615104675,
-0.331915944814682,
-0.13967032730579376,
0.08591704815626144,
0.48381611704826355,
0.8401865363121033,
-0.06132989376783371,
0.012281653471291065,
0.07465367764234543,
-0.12544141709804535,
-0.15308023989200592,
-0.7132752537727356,
0.35970211029052734,
-0.48185235261917114,
-0.9079042673110962,
-0.358449250459671,
-0.46664491295814514,
-0.40102508664131165,
0.2812204957008362,
0.22773893177509308,
0.15206898748874664,
-0.21352581679821014,
-0.12429158389568329,
0.7967997193336487,
-0.36905917525291443,
-0.026345206424593925,
0.7531604170799255,
-0.2896415591239929,
-0.06247526407241821,
0.581122875213623,
-0.050286389887332916,
0.40191417932510376,
0.3158073425292969,
0.16248752176761627,
-0.05970216915011406,
-0.9029778838157654,
-0.3664586544036865,
0.03655743598937988,
-1.0228841304779053,
-0.387922078371048,
-0.7657539248466492,
-0.30903443694114685,
-0.47411051392555237,
-0.03399073705077171,
-0.3539118468761444,
-0.49204307794570923,
-0.3845328986644745,
-0.29397472739219666,
0.4794236421585083,
0.9674893021583557,
-0.42348504066467285,
0.3533960282802582,
-0.8795017600059509,
0.24450425803661346,
0.4555079936981201,
0.28690439462661743,
-0.10059438645839691,
-0.8767028450965881,
-0.23759928345680237,
0.19223317503929138,
-0.15733389556407928,
-1.0953965187072754,
0.32490813732147217,
0.22822460532188416,
0.5084659457206726,
0.6902068853378296,
0.03721131384372711,
0.4806573688983917,
-0.44404250383377075,
0.5595009922981262,
-0.1719861924648285,
-1.167205572128296,
0.7734915614128113,
-0.11245876550674438,
0.046813808381557465,
0.36183103919029236,
0.27335432171821594,
-0.6886173486709595,
-0.7189562320709229,
-0.6159875988960266,
-0.172726571559906,
0.8709437251091003,
0.10623496770858765,
0.168439581990242,
0.06302513927221298,
0.23919664323329926,
0.08765967190265656,
0.31202632188796997,
-0.720848560333252,
-0.1800355762243271,
0.0015192936407402158,
-0.0062120831571519375,
0.2206193208694458,
-0.6153758764266968,
0.004253847990185022,
-0.274656742811203,
0.9118120074272156,
0.20844559371471405,
-0.05184324458241463,
-0.05793512240052223,
-0.5943969488143921,
-0.177321657538414,
0.5188117027282715,
0.4203619956970215,
0.5233181118965149,
-0.10655833780765533,
0.1963042914867401,
0.31892895698547363,
-0.43999192118644714,
0.020607633516192436,
-0.12989060580730438,
-0.46061384677886963,
-0.026342490687966347,
0.6398634314537048,
0.9025408625602722,
0.22256624698638916,
-0.5566132664680481,
0.7616384029388428,
0.28134769201278687,
0.07288309186697006,
-0.02827276661992073,
0.2824101746082306,
-0.14908549189567566,
0.13565360009670258,
-0.12368252128362656,
0.615308403968811,
0.0287356898188591,
-0.38123276829719543,
0.4302154779434204,
0.23416069149971008,
-0.2221718430519104,
-0.5015909671783447,
0.5376770496368408,
0.08744005113840103,
-0.21907402575016022,
0.580474853515625,
-0.40692126750946045,
-0.9841175079345703,
0.1464345008134842,
0.22490066289901733,
0.7122763991355896,
-0.582006573677063,
0.06405384838581085,
0.21774017810821533,
0.5724368095397949,
0.1370564103126526,
0.15624411404132843,
-0.16875630617141724,
-1.3337630033493042,
-0.23425382375717163,
-0.6087262034416199,
-0.15598881244659424,
0.507029116153717,
-0.6019334197044373,
0.4494677186012268,
-0.4226510524749756,
-0.04075469821691513,
0.19202649593353271,
-0.6308358311653137,
-0.7567172646522522,
0.032939761877059937,
0.10037344694137573,
0.7442110180854797,
-1.2192720174789429,
0.966469943523407,
0.6137017607688904,
-0.16429981589317322,
-0.3851087689399719,
-0.06279905140399933,
0.27239537239074707,
-1.199163556098938,
0.6122044324874878,
-0.27502167224884033,
0.05683821812272072,
-0.03446927294135094,
-0.5024152994155884,
-0.6568776369094849,
0.6027514338493347,
0.41498494148254395,
-0.4802112877368927,
0.0130213163793087,
0.15811148285865784,
0.4112398326396942,
0.17168918251991272,
-0.17110516130924225,
0.6111303567886353,
0.4452196955680847,
-0.0449955016374588,
-0.9793497920036316,
-0.07740925997495651,
-0.2967571020126343,
-0.40354713797569275,
0.2579320967197418,
-0.05210272967815399,
0.5813348293304443,
-0.38133227825164795,
-0.35066840052604675,
-0.18617753684520721,
0.6472058892250061,
-0.01964648626744747,
0.10409917682409286,
0.6683311462402344,
0.7986637353897095,
1.0168312788009644,
0.05052024871110916,
0.7311093807220459,
-0.17420625686645508,
0.10342056304216385,
1.221169352531433,
-0.15353955328464508,
0.6871994733810425,
0.28549203276634216,
-0.25155144929885864,
0.4697648286819458,
0.4071868062019348,
0.012583979405462742,
0.546961784362793,
0.002304997993633151,
-0.4754545986652374,
-0.5653568506240845,
-0.0054822806268930435,
-0.11369314789772034,
0.640204668045044,
0.44160202145576477,
-0.39194342494010925,
-0.09448682516813278,
0.2542501389980316,
0.4460226595401764,
0.12971265614032745,
-0.4025900065898895,
1.0961947441101074,
-0.18436302244663239,
-0.496753990650177,
0.37029513716697693,
0.18617652356624603,
0.5774283409118652,
-0.44769322872161865,
-0.0702325850725174,
-0.14768683910369873,
0.12469294667243958,
-0.27893897891044617,
-1.0488938093185425,
0.3007802367210388,
0.39619171619415283,
-0.1509498804807663,
-0.19468851387500763,
0.9689619541168213,
-0.559278666973114,
-0.4026047885417938,
-0.01931007020175457,
0.44377267360687256,
-0.029479283839464188,
-0.3448120057582855,
-0.41570860147476196,
-0.04313613846898079,
0.18741938471794128,
-0.1718963086605072,
0.15109077095985413,
0.4958445727825165,
-0.08379454910755157,
0.6656877398490906,
0.7758169174194336,
0.3776218593120575,
0.22907015681266785,
-0.17311906814575195,
0.8333194851875305,
-0.2203420102596283,
-0.5820591449737549,
-0.7627471685409546,
0.5029840469360352,
-0.1854848712682724,
-0.11081161350011826,
0.7325341105461121,
0.48706817626953125,
1.01101553440094,
-0.1326657235622406,
1.0010299682617188,
0.12181021273136139,
0.40120819211006165,
-0.8181389570236206,
1.0186676979064941,
-0.5138118267059326,
0.5166972279548645,
-0.19612155854701996,
-0.4209303557872772,
-0.1540549248456955,
0.295460969209671,
-0.4348352253437042,
-0.17223314940929413,
0.47694429755210876,
1.0760314464569092,
-0.16838696599006653,
-0.06341253966093063,
0.408124715089798,
0.6236658096313477,
0.1407594382762909,
0.2857198417186737,
0.9875760674476624,
-0.22995764017105103,
0.2704240679740906,
-0.48128482699394226,
-0.21899867057800293,
-0.05656523257493973,
-0.9821431040763855,
-0.9610328674316406,
-0.654390275478363,
-0.44179725646972656,
-0.3224206864833832,
0.28372424840927124,
0.6138517260551453,
0.3760931193828583,
-0.9993562698364258,
0.2652367055416107,
0.08128030598163605,
0.3216724693775177,
-0.15745188295841217,
-0.15194390714168549,
0.45266711711883545,
-0.060685526579618454,
-0.4345615804195404,
0.6767429113388062,
0.06041436642408371,
0.1190912052989006,
0.006238358560949564,
0.21214482188224792,
-0.041077904403209686,
0.14129112660884857,
0.4089787006378174,
0.2427034080028534,
-0.7144606709480286,
-0.5454443097114563,
-0.24707983434200287,
0.13341161608695984,
-0.14085990190505981,
0.7620744109153748,
-0.6719616055488586,
0.8550735712051392,
0.5401263236999512,
0.6869570016860962,
0.3005111813545227,
-0.23896411061286926,
0.47183194756507874,
-1.1940034627914429,
-0.018744824454188347,
0.21085801720619202,
0.5888996124267578,
0.403260737657547,
-0.532643735408783,
0.06601458787918091,
0.39449456334114075,
-0.39941033720970154,
-1.0438861846923828,
0.15077361464500427,
-0.631107747554779,
-0.19908495247364044,
1.0260730981826782,
-0.2994171679019928,
-0.025630192831158638,
-0.1634698510169983,
-0.03318661078810692,
0.438102126121521,
-0.19405005872249603,
0.8858546018600464,
0.781161367893219,
0.02842673286795616,
-0.012395648285746574,
-0.40177085995674133,
0.927596926689148,
0.217580184340477,
-0.8195367455482483,
0.36299970746040344,
0.7318025231361389,
0.4955768883228302,
-0.08764523267745972,
0.40130746364593506,
-0.07978353649377823,
0.4575834572315216,
-0.16291901469230652,
0.2928439676761627,
-0.5517159700393677,
-0.35027366876602173,
-0.3647889792919159,
-0.021627601236104965,
0.12124994397163391,
0.025805296376347542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02764v1
|
Assessing Adversarial Robustness of Large Language Models: An Empirical Study
| 2024-05-04T22:00:28 | 2024-05-04T22:00:28 |
Zeyu Yang, Zhao Meng, Xiaochen Zheng, Roger Wattenhofer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized natural language processing,
but their robustness against adversarial attacks remains a critical concern. We
presents a novel white-box style attack approach that exposes vulnerabilities
in leading open-source LLMs, including Llama, OPT, and T5. We assess the impact
of model size, structure, and fine-tuning strategies on their resistance to
adversarial perturbations. Our comprehensive evaluation across five diverse
text classification tasks establishes a new benchmark for LLM robustness. The
findings of this study have far-reaching implications for the reliable
deployment of LLMs in real-world applications and contribute to the advancement
of trustworthy AI systems.
|
[
-0.2737255394458771,
-1.160621166229248,
0.4440126419067383,
-0.012371262535452843,
-0.04498407617211342,
0.13300341367721558,
-0.28811806440353394,
-0.4354010224342346,
-0.3672432601451874,
0.5668848156929016,
-0.20981504023075104,
-0.5851023197174072,
-0.9287219643592834,
0.19403323531150818,
-0.789706826210022,
0.9694404006004333,
0.20457762479782104,
-0.13133738934993744,
-0.18199078738689423,
-0.23633402585983276,
-0.3085991144180298,
-0.5643429160118103,
-0.6096116304397583,
-0.09032328426837921,
0.39466217160224915,
-0.024515094235539436,
1.0357898473739624,
0.5791547298431396,
0.6894580125808716,
0.37019169330596924,
-0.33884119987487793,
-0.10846064239740372,
-0.6625291109085083,
0.23167702555656433,
-0.06194448843598366,
-0.7872061729431152,
-0.5127174258232117,
-0.2592584490776062,
0.651739239692688,
0.4801681637763977,
0.08682715892791748,
0.17398616671562195,
0.03813830390572548,
0.4551728665828705,
-0.736811101436615,
-0.10870995372533798,
-1.1236522197723389,
-0.032138071954250336,
-0.39353105425834656,
0.0007151419995352626,
-0.6550353765487671,
-0.21074271202087402,
-0.04829445108771324,
-0.32208001613616943,
0.017520999535918236,
-0.043242767453193665,
0.593109667301178,
0.5712528824806213,
-0.3954513669013977,
-0.1808461844921112,
-0.6577587723731995,
0.7497392296791077,
-0.8092657923698425,
0.14310301840305328,
0.2027377486228943,
0.3900676667690277,
-0.49103644490242004,
-0.6926804780960083,
-0.3107515275478363,
-0.5329475402832031,
0.12986542284488678,
-0.17577412724494934,
-0.5503906607627869,
-0.01773715391755104,
0.29116740822792053,
0.4491192400455475,
-0.6147350072860718,
0.444100558757782,
-0.15123337507247925,
-0.11318667978048325,
0.663128137588501,
0.13169972598552704,
0.5272956490516663,
0.33918842673301697,
-0.40994367003440857,
-0.1280433088541031,
-0.8174045085906982,
-0.19780226051807404,
0.641632616519928,
0.2573325037956238,
-0.1372721642255783,
0.6208137273788452,
0.06755643337965012,
0.5290738344192505,
-0.20935209095478058,
-0.17930756509304047,
-0.2724064588546753,
-0.2004988193511963,
-0.3850874900817871,
-0.04373824596405029,
1.042670488357544,
0.16657951474189758,
0.22720147669315338,
-0.3093598186969757,
-0.20388548076152802,
0.10104221850633621,
0.6552668809890747,
-0.6334795355796814,
-0.1150050014257431,
0.2339961975812912,
-0.26307985186576843,
-0.7252102494239807,
-0.09291823953390121,
-0.7917614579200745,
-0.6904732584953308,
0.301990270614624,
0.3459053337574005,
-0.33010318875312805,
0.003907517530024052,
-0.061496395617723465,
0.1996459662914276,
0.03265029564499855,
0.16909930109977722,
-0.8376989960670471,
0.3860105276107788,
0.8388891220092773,
0.7584224939346313,
-0.23750363290309906,
-0.21231067180633545,
-0.4861419200897217,
0.07136066257953644,
-0.4399763345718384,
0.5480330586433411,
-0.3741757273674011,
-0.34643465280532837,
0.18982677161693573,
-0.2325204312801361,
0.22332033514976501,
-0.4196956753730774,
0.6997470259666443,
-0.7261705994606018,
-0.04704383388161659,
0.10463970899581909,
-0.3184531629085541,
-0.04754052311182022,
0.654071569442749,
-0.7363073229789734,
0.7540028095245361,
-0.09051541984081268,
-0.9172353744506836,
0.04416050389409065,
-0.5312932729721069,
-0.5350203514099121,
-0.14744289219379425,
0.025648174807429314,
-0.5893862247467041,
0.21968382596969604,
0.26546382904052734,
0.481528103351593,
-0.33246368169784546,
-0.0015747277066111565,
-0.8484134674072266,
-0.21728789806365967,
0.6223254799842834,
-0.9008469581604004,
0.8675869703292847,
0.19024421274662018,
-0.12623067200183868,
0.29113298654556274,
-0.9446722865104675,
-0.18794742226600647,
0.43437087535858154,
-0.22343748807907104,
-0.3250960409641266,
0.09537006914615631,
-0.12915317714214325,
-0.11997480690479279,
0.2746671140193939,
-0.38016557693481445,
0.2552282512187958,
-0.5007020831108093,
0.6069868206977844,
0.7894264459609985,
-0.13814742863178253,
0.1921962946653366,
-0.04196082800626755,
0.6197630763053894,
-0.27220115065574646,
0.20089419186115265,
-0.04346945136785507,
-0.10792914777994156,
-0.6343411803245544,
-0.28665584325790405,
0.3683185577392578,
0.4423859417438507,
-0.5361679792404175,
0.3737683594226837,
-0.18983995914459229,
-0.7041640281677246,
-0.1988990157842636,
0.21330317854881287,
0.34740307927131653,
0.1644371598958969,
0.22701974213123322,
0.06099103018641472,
-0.29052531719207764,
-0.8335151672363281,
-0.30991679430007935,
-0.25253066420555115,
-0.028586173430085182,
0.013736283406615257,
0.6361159682273865,
-0.4654281735420227,
0.36108076572418213,
-0.48158714175224304,
0.033891767263412476,
-0.18496426939964294,
-0.07688193023204803,
-0.10653148591518402,
0.14455363154411316,
0.6444326639175415,
-0.6044517159461975,
-0.24402986466884613,
-0.03889870643615723,
-0.6275551915168762,
-0.032778892666101456,
0.11668320000171661,
0.02240736410021782,
0.24574406445026398,
0.6994017362594604,
-0.43974411487579346,
0.3199496269226074,
0.7043991684913635,
-0.27291351556777954,
0.464261531829834,
-0.13659140467643738,
-0.18799974024295807,
-0.9584076404571533,
0.014850562438368797,
0.02365093305706978,
-0.19715845584869385,
-0.7570715546607971,
0.2121054083108902,
-0.056271955370903015,
-0.07564875483512878,
-0.4666130542755127,
0.4018155336380005,
-0.16850227117538452,
-0.12605996429920197,
-0.18210113048553467,
-0.061011552810668945,
-0.21182075142860413,
0.06616754829883575,
-0.4678865671157837,
0.6950998306274414,
0.4632551968097687,
-0.4924856126308441,
0.3546241819858551,
0.027656637132167816,
-0.25728803873062134,
0.4387606382369995,
-0.7213253378868103,
0.28194886445999146,
0.07469682395458221,
0.1816137284040451,
-0.9916583895683289,
-0.22188113629817963,
0.0772596225142479,
-0.514895498752594,
0.5181983709335327,
0.09298045933246613,
-0.5355875492095947,
-0.048543620854616165,
-0.5437003970146179,
0.2383444607257843,
0.27714523673057556,
-0.46637001633644104,
0.4671593904495239,
0.3412426710128784,
-0.1505066156387329,
-0.608303964138031,
-0.5977479219436646,
0.44212597608566284,
-0.39137884974479675,
-0.5948624610900879,
0.10971729457378387,
-0.11520839482545853,
-0.5628816485404968,
-0.2344348430633545,
-0.030744517222046852,
-0.14517056941986084,
0.8233647346496582,
0.13748444616794586,
0.10018720477819443,
-0.2558281421661377,
-0.2963930666446686,
-0.41976282000541687,
0.050890032202005386,
0.22206571698188782,
-0.031133027747273445,
0.46084585785865784,
-0.2436525821685791,
-0.41205230355262756,
-0.26672661304473877,
-0.020989295095205307,
0.9896171689033508,
-0.30113187432289124,
0.8176902532577515,
0.613477349281311,
-0.47849977016448975,
-0.4257097840309143,
-0.33680272102355957,
0.12598149478435516,
-0.4897421598434448,
0.7514133453369141,
-0.17800089716911316,
-0.8731927275657654,
0.3732486665248871,
0.23205061256885529,
0.1744692325592041,
0.5095862746238708,
0.6918240189552307,
0.16360235214233398,
1.0207713842391968,
0.699312150478363,
-0.3807331919670105,
0.3476771116256714,
-0.0004809838719666004,
0.18856628239154816,
-0.6061899662017822,
-0.06649398803710938,
-0.7137929201126099,
-0.06749546527862549,
-0.5690781474113464,
-0.037564121186733246,
0.26625970005989075,
-0.020886773243546486,
-0.32799971103668213,
0.16638913750648499,
-0.15212935209274292,
0.2950360178947449,
0.341743528842926,
-0.15678954124450684,
0.35964035987854004,
-0.027357326820492744,
0.11529534310102463,
0.30149045586586,
-0.46658676862716675,
-0.9091466665267944,
1.3266912698745728,
0.7609118819236755,
0.9368701577186584,
0.4073164165019989,
0.3183623254299164,
0.3529694080352783,
0.42240485548973083,
-0.669552206993103,
0.6070988774299622,
-0.35589686036109924,
-0.522797703742981,
-0.42135685682296753,
-0.3118240237236023,
-0.891431450843811,
0.21040935814380646,
-0.3528449535369873,
-0.8404871225357056,
-0.37339022755622864,
-0.022970810532569885,
-0.3923204243183136,
0.5403680205345154,
-0.5987789630889893,
0.7147349715232849,
-0.5763412117958069,
-0.2401435524225235,
0.024706685915589333,
-0.4037678837776184,
0.5937497615814209,
-0.3141382932662964,
0.14812587201595306,
0.024795198813080788,
-0.3359559178352356,
0.4023648500442505,
-0.22305268049240112,
0.8609197735786438,
0.3298838138580322,
-0.39040347933769226,
-0.07414022088050842,
0.22966909408569336,
0.5556303858757019,
0.18294262886047363,
-0.1674499362707138,
0.35626736283302307,
-0.1752903312444687,
-0.4170476198196411,
-0.562195897102356,
0.8115519881248474,
-0.8036305904388428,
-0.6838210821151733,
-0.4662799537181854,
-0.607760488986969,
-0.3511626720428467,
0.31377169489860535,
0.19914475083351135,
0.25096309185028076,
-0.5305377244949341,
0.5181400179862976,
0.7878340482711792,
-0.3633604049682617,
0.48590606451034546,
0.40524396300315857,
0.08868300914764404,
-0.5674890875816345,
0.7010015845298767,
0.0496651753783226,
0.5894880294799805,
0.5252270102500916,
0.04707886651158333,
-0.12181403487920761,
-1.1461302042007446,
-0.44370537996292114,
-0.18551704287528992,
-0.592352032661438,
-0.23506702482700348,
-0.3989192247390747,
-0.21113382279872894,
-0.40206730365753174,
-0.15976357460021973,
-0.5118955969810486,
-0.0054009719751775265,
-0.31314191222190857,
0.02169398032128811,
0.12461690604686737,
1.0521029233932495,
0.7117845416069031,
0.2306331843137741,
-0.6077497005462646,
0.20489270985126495,
0.3827979266643524,
0.3387315571308136,
-0.15326954424381256,
-0.4638146758079529,
-0.05677951127290726,
-0.0926460474729538,
-0.4614553153514862,
-0.7116009593009949,
0.24017080664634705,
-0.03527310863137245,
0.4957456588745117,
0.47205114364624023,
0.187849760055542,
0.23701053857803345,
-0.5122021436691284,
0.8847945332527161,
0.07751014083623886,
-0.7254785299301147,
0.38625821471214294,
-0.41965076327323914,
0.2972601354122162,
0.3423823416233063,
0.13726744055747986,
-0.04564383253455162,
-0.593379557132721,
-0.704929530620575,
-0.6844820380210876,
0.5031588077545166,
0.3347319960594177,
0.021819787099957466,
0.19525974988937378,
0.2015816569328308,
0.013398815877735615,
0.13363933563232422,
-0.8110350370407104,
-0.35684671998023987,
-0.17237812280654907,
-0.3363085687160492,
-0.29919570684432983,
-0.3780903220176697,
-0.23925556242465973,
0.2896401584148407,
0.5870056748390198,
-0.10279501229524612,
-0.03907758742570877,
-0.05043177306652069,
-0.14033207297325134,
0.03561152145266533,
0.5188763737678528,
0.7505221962928772,
0.46021556854248047,
-0.07798326760530472,
0.4175293445587158,
0.5626795291900635,
-0.49029549956321716,
0.15559256076812744,
0.13683441281318665,
-0.38684701919555664,
-0.38369354605674744,
0.8288216590881348,
0.6646233201026917,
0.17384204268455505,
-0.635358452796936,
0.38404712080955505,
-0.3577614426612854,
-0.060945335775613785,
-0.21275509893894196,
0.14683037996292114,
-0.10869190841913223,
0.27367135882377625,
0.15019038319587708,
0.05765892565250397,
-0.0705416351556778,
-0.6156847476959229,
-0.16989928483963013,
0.8595479726791382,
-0.3523654341697693,
-0.29264935851097107,
0.6296623945236206,
-0.017838239669799805,
-0.37137335538864136,
0.0437886044383049,
0.16132022440433502,
-0.6939982175827026,
0.5905614495277405,
0.6399070620536804,
0.9575579762458801,
-0.07000958919525146,
-0.18787159025669098,
-0.08958403766155243,
0.8362992405891418,
-0.14596696197986603,
-0.2873977720737457,
0.22569824755191803,
-0.507753312587738,
-0.10850920528173447,
-0.5554023385047913,
-0.5296894311904907,
0.5868459343910217,
-0.4640488028526306,
0.2039458155632019,
-0.7538624405860901,
-0.16466854512691498,
0.009403909556567669,
0.014232655987143517,
-0.19455087184906006,
0.13906356692314148,
0.4858090877532959,
0.9455264210700989,
-0.5926414728164673,
0.6757717728614807,
0.859805703163147,
-0.07424910366535187,
-0.3861803710460663,
0.3224674463272095,
0.16782128810882568,
-0.586931049823761,
0.39588770270347595,
-0.0005924489814788103,
-0.165616974234581,
-0.39537882804870605,
-0.5884378552436829,
-0.8896183967590332,
0.9481998682022095,
0.7912212014198303,
-0.4240090250968933,
0.26739150285720825,
0.13262790441513062,
0.6307156085968018,
-0.029767265543341637,
0.19509060680866241,
0.5971628427505493,
0.27287381887435913,
-0.1596994698047638,
-0.8172120451927185,
0.058051254600286484,
-0.17775455117225647,
0.08325110375881195,
0.2728980481624603,
-0.8398739099502563,
0.5709291696548462,
-0.0425666905939579,
-0.15794509649276733,
0.1393483579158783,
0.7296998500823975,
0.11876163631677628,
0.07172967493534088,
0.5385734438896179,
0.6210604906082153,
0.7166800498962402,
-0.07956302165985107,
1.1633893251419067,
-0.257267564535141,
0.08973051607608795,
0.8855358958244324,
-0.202739417552948,
0.9394533038139343,
0.26453298330307007,
-0.3632534146308899,
0.04137467220425606,
0.33076485991477966,
-0.10907812416553497,
0.32047176361083984,
0.36574193835258484,
-0.09890579432249069,
-0.06122084707021713,
0.08971881866455078,
-0.289463609457016,
0.39338061213493347,
0.2952958643436432,
-0.2593134641647339,
-0.10018215328454971,
-0.07760602235794067,
0.29267680644989014,
0.16037534177303314,
-0.45472365617752075,
0.7035093903541565,
0.1586865335702896,
-0.4778953492641449,
0.6098858714103699,
0.057601798325777054,
0.7507549524307251,
-0.6354483366012573,
0.21404196321964264,
-0.0027579499874264,
0.5327633023262024,
-0.16046759486198425,
-0.6778278350830078,
0.1724138855934143,
0.32234615087509155,
0.05786580964922905,
0.13004536926746368,
0.7901170253753662,
-0.1256301999092102,
-0.5626888871192932,
0.31236016750335693,
0.0014145798049867153,
-0.2970591187477112,
0.10751572251319885,
-0.5193654894828796,
0.5186611413955688,
-0.09469018876552582,
-0.37341704964637756,
0.5698620676994324,
0.27277347445487976,
0.005551088601350784,
1.0114861726760864,
0.6219193935394287,
0.2509504556655884,
0.0763881579041481,
-0.10435588657855988,
0.7306484580039978,
-0.4820441007614136,
-0.1595735102891922,
-1.2921725511550903,
0.20760616660118103,
-0.05326114222407341,
-0.32453468441963196,
1.0466947555541992,
0.3162299692630768,
0.8193634748458862,
0.2515734136104584,
0.8477284908294678,
0.3192571699619293,
0.14988481998443604,
-0.5622103810310364,
0.8473418354988098,
-0.3884034752845764,
0.716214120388031,
-0.3029155731201172,
-0.6771458387374878,
-0.5629812479019165,
0.1664343774318695,
-0.2617664337158203,
-0.11544440686702728,
0.5004031658172607,
0.6711378693580627,
0.15686869621276855,
-0.08484296500682831,
0.41704216599464417,
0.5708789825439453,
0.6276550889015198,
0.46077582240104675,
0.915652871131897,
-0.4034300148487091,
0.8286116123199463,
-0.1628507673740387,
-0.11612623184919357,
-0.20425143837928772,
-1.0035502910614014,
-1.2832027673721313,
-0.12030474096536636,
-0.30200493335723877,
-0.4484722316265106,
0.2735174000263214,
0.625501811504364,
0.35526156425476074,
-0.8296562433242798,
0.015910351648926735,
0.03695942461490631,
0.2725399434566498,
0.09935102611780167,
-0.14639975130558014,
0.37425026297569275,
-0.23751531541347504,
-0.5842959880828857,
0.4658295810222626,
0.3120134174823761,
0.12199525535106659,
-0.6676586866378784,
0.10116846114397049,
0.0955970510840416,
0.14701563119888306,
0.6529285907745361,
0.13633768260478973,
-0.7835096716880798,
-0.25264835357666016,
-0.12077163904905319,
-0.3034078776836395,
-0.22279100120067596,
0.3727470934391022,
-0.26256081461906433,
0.29731953144073486,
0.30196064710617065,
0.9866828918457031,
-0.07972366362810135,
-0.07425156235694885,
0.7071229219436646,
-0.4149778485298157,
0.031224502250552177,
0.20006334781646729,
0.43378791213035583,
0.3402951657772064,
-0.3498908281326294,
0.3681042790412903,
-0.10863330215215683,
-0.499982625246048,
-1.1959739923477173,
0.11371742188930511,
-0.7899330258369446,
-0.3176431357860565,
1.3036587238311768,
-0.1797308623790741,
-0.33571910858154297,
-0.05581044778227806,
-0.1326601505279541,
0.06809532642364502,
-0.22986355423927307,
0.7721943259239197,
0.8531599640846252,
0.44013917446136475,
0.10665979981422424,
-0.7797284722328186,
0.2894497811794281,
0.1919247955083847,
-0.8891533017158508,
0.1390586644411087,
0.20619885623455048,
0.21074435114860535,
0.13802941143512726,
0.1380915492773056,
-0.20481880009174347,
0.026857133954763412,
-0.028572820127010345,
-0.2963428199291229,
-0.27627524733543396,
-0.24561874568462372,
-0.6816263198852539,
0.5301790833473206,
0.3861573338508606,
-0.017138876020908356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06676v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06676v1
|
EDA Corpus: A Large Language Model Dataset for Enhanced Interaction with OpenROAD
| 2024-05-04T21:29:37 | 2024-05-04T21:29:37 |
Bing-Yue Wu, Utsav Sharma, Sai Rahul Dhanvi Kankipati, Ajay Yadav, Bintu Kappil George, Sai Ritish Guntupalli, Austin Rovinski, Vidya A. Chhabria
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.AR
|
Large language models (LLMs) serve as powerful tools for design, providing
capabilities for both task automation and design assistance. Recent
advancements have shown tremendous potential for facilitating LLM integration
into the chip design process; however, many of these works rely on data that
are not publicly available and/or not permissively licensed for use in LLM
training and distribution. In this paper, we present a solution aimed at
bridging this gap by introducing an open-source dataset tailored for OpenROAD,
a widely adopted open-source EDA toolchain. The dataset features over 1000 data
points and is structured in two formats: (i) a pairwise set comprised of
question prompts with prose answers, and (ii) a pairwise set comprised of code
prompts and their corresponding OpenROAD scripts. By providing this dataset, we
aim to facilitate LLM-focused research within the EDA domain. The dataset is
available at https://github.com/OpenROAD-Assistant/EDA-Corpus.
|
[
-0.3789173662662506,
-0.7298051118850708,
0.7365518808364868,
0.23869596421718597,
-0.11218298226594925,
0.19198445975780487,
-0.4594830572605133,
-0.4213169515132904,
0.4832785427570343,
0.6253070831298828,
-0.29669445753097534,
-1.0182853937149048,
-0.14485357701778412,
-0.16366571187973022,
-0.24763278663158417,
0.7183607816696167,
-0.4550686776638031,
-0.08253633230924606,
-0.4916844069957733,
-0.1421625018119812,
-0.40335384011268616,
-0.25160080194473267,
-0.1135801449418068,
0.1716884970664978,
0.6025185585021973,
0.5623700618743896,
0.5048476457595825,
0.6641700267791748,
0.4048784375190735,
0.1019120067358017,
0.13939902186393738,
0.13947704434394836,
-0.31892016530036926,
0.09633231163024902,
-0.21342965960502625,
-0.08337581902742386,
-0.7540521621704102,
0.08698941022157669,
0.5733101963996887,
0.6803843975067139,
-0.12665311992168427,
0.4462047815322876,
-0.04067235812544823,
0.1705894023180008,
-0.4801171123981476,
0.3073911666870117,
-0.5337122678756714,
-0.40055137872695923,
-0.5662131905555725,
-0.06756090372800827,
-0.4152165651321411,
-0.6392219662666321,
-0.3460821509361267,
-0.8104857802391052,
-0.19034963846206665,
-0.1012849509716034,
0.5402117371559143,
0.18979083001613617,
0.05152514576911926,
-0.5005787014961243,
-0.9083936810493469,
0.5852735042572021,
-0.5576679706573486,
0.40224748849868774,
0.5525726079940796,
0.1733771413564682,
-0.1859256476163864,
-0.5763124227523804,
-0.5595125555992126,
0.021584786474704742,
0.2180221527814865,
-0.014953941106796265,
-0.32085683941841125,
-0.008155403658747673,
0.009725802578032017,
0.26815661787986755,
-0.5854530930519104,
0.5146509408950806,
-0.491188108921051,
0.06248373165726662,
0.3721509575843811,
0.09813662618398666,
0.323419988155365,
-0.0016237851232290268,
-0.38189995288848877,
-0.1320600062608719,
-1.1420038938522339,
0.0418764092028141,
0.6603696346282959,
0.5779178142547607,
-0.19767139852046967,
0.7414135932922363,
-0.06414685398340225,
0.7732377052307129,
-0.3842391073703766,
0.2559729218482971,
0.49483445286750793,
-0.1483302265405655,
-0.13402263820171356,
0.014617993496358395,
0.9242679476737976,
0.14044931530952454,
0.18150466680526733,
-0.11528100073337555,
-0.33921018242836,
-0.2079116553068161,
0.10932517796754837,
-0.7453559041023254,
-0.1827121078968048,
0.6542883515357971,
-0.12811414897441864,
-0.14906980097293854,
0.27303043007850647,
-1.0612949132919312,
-0.2868494987487793,
-0.4042917490005493,
-0.07607986032962799,
-0.1725832223892212,
-0.3124848008155823,
0.11658399552106857,
0.05203701928257942,
0.2781578004360199,
0.012507306411862373,
-0.7239785194396973,
0.12308432161808014,
0.9183831214904785,
0.9767402410507202,
-0.08488257229328156,
-0.060901377350091934,
-0.5709301829338074,
0.3671571910381317,
-0.5717282295227051,
0.8210278749465942,
-0.9304594993591309,
-0.39517661929130554,
0.3221662938594818,
-0.07024096697568893,
0.12841233611106873,
-0.6179139614105225,
0.5862751007080078,
-0.9140506982803345,
-0.13454213738441467,
-0.02747049555182457,
-0.20616714656352997,
0.02450425922870636,
-0.05354950949549675,
-0.9007916450500488,
1.085938811302185,
0.12167765945196152,
-0.587525486946106,
0.09263616055250168,
-0.8454582095146179,
-0.3915495276451111,
0.3190979063510895,
-0.6660431027412415,
0.029745692387223244,
-0.00456719845533371,
0.15931320190429688,
0.24847619235515594,
-0.3427073061466217,
0.45017772912979126,
-0.5370651483535767,
-0.21526004374027252,
0.14988555014133453,
-0.1022009551525116,
0.959114134311676,
0.2972353994846344,
0.15020820498466492,
0.3998701274394989,
-0.9094862341880798,
-0.0977940633893013,
0.14641746878623962,
-0.403801292181015,
-0.7557691335678101,
-0.17547263205051422,
0.08074729144573212,
0.13154658675193787,
0.42608341574668884,
-0.9670474529266357,
0.28184080123901367,
-0.24467380344867706,
0.3539978861808777,
0.9878823757171631,
-0.3062209486961365,
0.2195601761341095,
0.03410475328564644,
0.7790035605430603,
-0.0984327495098114,
-0.10351381450891495,
-0.04794805496931076,
-0.560710072517395,
-0.30311211943626404,
-0.5048602819442749,
0.3235246241092682,
0.5547899007797241,
-0.7980116605758667,
0.41461896896362305,
-0.363986074924469,
-0.35166633129119873,
-0.944709062576294,
0.1886310875415802,
0.24634017050266266,
0.4005226194858551,
0.258949339389801,
0.10351095348596573,
-0.5585235357284546,
-0.8991318941116333,
0.3238084018230438,
-0.16408784687519073,
-0.5204054713249207,
0.45099905133247375,
0.33605897426605225,
-0.10727589577436447,
1.2407960891723633,
-0.8797986507415771,
-0.37177377939224243,
-0.10249188542366028,
0.0707084983587265,
0.2524734139442444,
0.3208542466163635,
0.6767065525054932,
-0.2681354582309723,
-0.31653228402137756,
0.060210734605789185,
-0.6898790597915649,
-0.5091983079910278,
0.26533013582229614,
-0.3594374358654022,
0.026670105755329132,
0.596774160861969,
-0.4064621925354004,
0.11942153424024582,
0.9177072048187256,
-0.1521424502134323,
0.19829894602298737,
-0.20889027416706085,
-0.0007160122622735798,
-1.395716905593872,
0.3548600375652313,
-0.11609991639852524,
-0.018821753561496735,
-0.36917614936828613,
0.1334550678730011,
0.13966220617294312,
-0.16035746037960052,
-0.518439769744873,
0.5506958961486816,
-0.19916819036006927,
-0.260852575302124,
-0.13835828006267548,
0.46551069617271423,
-0.09438910335302353,
0.2546982169151306,
0.006511949934065342,
1.2335437536239624,
0.5554472804069519,
-0.3841894865036011,
0.3707308769226074,
0.7325645089149475,
-0.48806390166282654,
0.3995736241340637,
-0.9740617275238037,
0.4546111226081848,
-0.07112479954957962,
-0.0708777979016304,
-0.7487716674804688,
-0.32290706038475037,
0.2921731472015381,
-0.2339550256729126,
-0.10252851992845535,
-0.020189277827739716,
-0.7911617159843445,
-0.19923289120197296,
-0.48314282298088074,
0.5105923414230347,
0.4569103419780731,
-0.9582228660583496,
0.3857380151748657,
0.8408342599868774,
-0.48553013801574707,
-0.15833470225334167,
-0.440515398979187,
-0.0734831839799881,
0.04176988825201988,
-0.7664374709129333,
0.5732622742652893,
-0.37701696157455444,
-0.4860457479953766,
0.031537480652332306,
0.6264529824256897,
-0.1623326987028122,
-0.1802731305360794,
0.4700479507446289,
0.5163098573684692,
-0.28971344232559204,
0.4552268385887146,
0.13926276564598083,
0.004798358306288719,
0.09309964627027512,
-0.1383165419101715,
0.7052417993545532,
0.10589514672756195,
-0.38282155990600586,
-0.003852000692859292,
0.39817461371421814,
0.4482573866844177,
-0.5596826076507568,
0.5935222506523132,
0.09233089536428452,
-0.47028252482414246,
-0.5447576642036438,
0.09312766790390015,
0.2396966964006424,
-0.5328194499015808,
0.09492754936218262,
-0.4366099238395691,
-0.8620474934577942,
0.5577220320701599,
-0.05086947977542877,
0.4098541736602783,
0.31372734904289246,
0.634550929069519,
-0.047144535928964615,
0.6551840305328369,
0.7955976724624634,
-0.09837201237678528,
0.4044854938983917,
0.05442677065730095,
0.06469853967428207,
-0.9357390403747559,
-0.29955601692199707,
-0.6878586411476135,
-0.27578845620155334,
-0.28544414043426514,
-0.5878992080688477,
0.1915510594844818,
-0.16542372107505798,
-0.07337778806686401,
0.2905748188495636,
-0.2903144657611847,
0.5462690591812134,
0.5537649989128113,
-0.004918304737657309,
0.45395106077194214,
0.0801137313246727,
-0.17964662611484528,
0.27970677614212036,
-0.5829766392707825,
-0.7829523086547852,
1.139260172843933,
0.47736626863479614,
0.9666879773139954,
0.22447176277637482,
0.399307519197464,
0.019914712756872177,
0.21809692680835724,
-0.6537265777587891,
0.663802981376648,
-0.19894404709339142,
-0.4806930124759674,
-0.2535456120967865,
-0.2963657081127167,
-0.9941575527191162,
-0.4588741064071655,
0.15790435671806335,
-0.3684362471103668,
0.1413952112197876,
-0.14439980685710907,
-0.5949224233627319,
0.39565473794937134,
-0.24045394361019135,
0.6887193918228149,
-0.1395508199930191,
-0.25253790616989136,
-0.06656013429164886,
-0.2523062229156494,
0.33948254585266113,
-0.3180437386035919,
0.41262897849082947,
-0.12885650992393494,
-0.13813650608062744,
1.044467806816101,
-0.27012836933135986,
0.9463701844215393,
0.022366341203451157,
-0.569879949092865,
0.5113862156867981,
-0.08614828437566757,
0.48897698521614075,
0.03306425362825394,
-0.20194365084171295,
0.15661796927452087,
-0.29437530040740967,
-0.20001138746738434,
-0.13123822212219238,
1.129285216331482,
-0.8447834849357605,
-0.2271781712770462,
-0.12252289056777954,
-0.7236547470092773,
-0.24923895299434662,
0.06035574525594711,
-0.1594236195087433,
0.5911132097244263,
-0.4148111939430237,
0.17851951718330383,
0.8136357069015503,
-0.62748122215271,
0.5012362599372864,
0.5660359263420105,
-0.5635168552398682,
-0.47349411249160767,
0.8817560076713562,
0.008295878767967224,
0.2716488242149353,
0.09855619072914124,
-0.0048883468843996525,
-0.19235539436340332,
-0.5563062429428101,
-0.770159125328064,
0.2927616238594055,
-0.8813877105712891,
-0.10990333557128906,
-0.4993504285812378,
-0.03742140904068947,
-0.5697309970855713,
-0.12151487171649933,
-0.1611701101064682,
-0.3301953077316284,
-0.48508793115615845,
-0.4588283896446228,
0.8801454305648804,
1.0834213495254517,
0.03656724467873573,
0.11664964258670807,
-0.7308918833732605,
0.28837835788726807,
-0.03760199993848801,
0.9982407689094543,
-0.17166154086589813,
-0.356534868478775,
-0.2189209908246994,
-0.09800273180007935,
0.0457192026078701,
-0.7520964741706848,
0.1905156373977661,
-0.0395357646048069,
0.5556023120880127,
0.2463497370481491,
0.24610817432403564,
0.231744185090065,
-0.49604281783103943,
0.6199517250061035,
-0.17627555131912231,
-0.5573353171348572,
0.5943700075149536,
-0.5760383009910583,
0.16817209124565125,
0.5810839533805847,
0.6032443642616272,
-0.3457513749599457,
-0.24984467029571533,
-0.3265165090560913,
-0.8991314768791199,
0.5853285193443298,
-0.08081046491861343,
0.17343348264694214,
-0.14409124851226807,
0.1194620355963707,
0.40972700715065,
0.19312527775764465,
-0.18251408636569977,
-0.06892741471529007,
0.028267595916986465,
-0.654567539691925,
0.08842679858207703,
-0.01664053462445736,
-0.3839449882507324,
-0.049940358847379684,
0.6169595122337341,
-0.1417926847934723,
0.11017190665006638,
-0.20247285068035126,
-0.05544094741344452,
-0.13862475752830505,
0.21738532185554504,
0.6273092031478882,
0.7807717323303223,
-0.29223090410232544,
0.24242572486400604,
-0.23464906215667725,
-0.5941203236579895,
-0.10837285965681076,
0.23624639213085175,
-0.4488033056259155,
-0.0068818144500255585,
0.11041838675737381,
0.5277471542358398,
-0.08382674306631088,
-1.106162667274475,
0.4080961048603058,
0.16957825422286987,
-0.05708019807934761,
-0.4267648458480835,
-0.3651912808418274,
0.11864729225635529,
0.20435450971126556,
0.14935877919197083,
-0.6080620884895325,
-0.15144211053848267,
-0.39349862933158875,
0.4246428906917572,
0.41233447194099426,
-0.5283104181289673,
-0.4908682107925415,
0.67269366979599,
0.460338294506073,
-0.37262678146362305,
0.7415229678153992,
-0.12811310589313507,
-0.11140504479408264,
0.6314087510108948,
0.40235212445259094,
0.9642435312271118,
-0.11590403318405151,
0.32375583052635193,
0.29241943359375,
0.2947523891925812,
0.44599390029907227,
0.7005445957183838,
0.4888812303543091,
-0.5403952598571777,
-0.4573599398136139,
-0.7303166389465332,
-0.5250869989395142,
0.3308737576007843,
-0.38487622141838074,
0.5704454779624939,
-0.716518223285675,
0.17043204605579376,
-0.19325417280197144,
-0.634800136089325,
-0.5467832684516907,
-0.1989390254020691,
-0.03358232602477074,
1.007698655128479,
-0.7157935500144958,
0.9638487696647644,
0.8113345503807068,
-0.7859103083610535,
-0.5767990946769714,
-0.16457602381706238,
-0.19934910535812378,
-0.8959414958953857,
0.5919492244720459,
-0.08895130455493927,
-0.11120741814374924,
0.058006107807159424,
-0.5088755488395691,
-0.7425172328948975,
1.159483790397644,
0.31357672810554504,
-0.5984454154968262,
0.16913366317749023,
0.3854908347129822,
0.30611008405685425,
-0.5968844294548035,
0.070758156478405,
0.43144676089286804,
0.3687399625778198,
0.14410868287086487,
-0.8243795037269592,
0.1497199833393097,
-0.14624039828777313,
-0.3505954146385193,
0.4120306968688965,
-0.538908064365387,
0.8491718769073486,
-0.1387443095445633,
-0.16855454444885254,
-0.02234666235744953,
0.6505544781684875,
0.32504191994667053,
0.19369344413280487,
0.27687275409698486,
0.47460824251174927,
0.7487547397613525,
0.15802475810050964,
0.6850003004074097,
-0.5950417518615723,
0.0301587525755167,
1.2872653007507324,
-0.5188270807266235,
1.3655190467834473,
0.4550829827785492,
-0.14513851702213287,
0.5035020112991333,
0.5181280970573425,
0.1444081962108612,
0.41146761178970337,
0.22471776604652405,
-0.30163171887397766,
0.07149600982666016,
-0.4357219338417053,
-0.3610699772834778,
0.22873246669769287,
0.3028824031352997,
-0.49991223216056824,
-0.2419377863407135,
0.13573524355888367,
-0.05593780428171158,
0.1977214813232422,
-0.30804380774497986,
0.676203191280365,
-0.020557690411806107,
-0.20354513823986053,
0.1003090962767601,
0.034629084169864655,
0.5406083464622498,
-0.4864169657230377,
-0.2412632256746292,
-0.15662971138954163,
0.040150031447410583,
-0.14744988083839417,
-1.2507438659667969,
0.4327484667301178,
0.25216758251190186,
-0.10896527767181396,
-0.427807092666626,
0.583617627620697,
-0.5630305409431458,
-0.4842327833175659,
0.42915356159210205,
0.5515499114990234,
0.29755282402038574,
0.0880451425909996,
0.018363283947110176,
0.4687057435512543,
-0.3521905243396759,
-0.0729164332151413,
0.35159096121788025,
0.3529110252857208,
-0.10947857797145844,
0.38588982820510864,
0.6343669295310974,
0.11213967949151993,
-0.022552257403731346,
0.13451868295669556,
1.190622091293335,
-0.6661040186882019,
-0.3642391562461853,
-0.5007022023200989,
0.27662065625190735,
-0.003551972797140479,
-0.37666910886764526,
0.5153623819351196,
0.8225044012069702,
0.9365739822387695,
-0.18479058146476746,
1.0221376419067383,
-0.14991188049316406,
0.7165066599845886,
-0.6501553654670715,
0.6545582413673401,
-0.17033645510673523,
0.45618176460266113,
-0.04574417322874069,
-0.7866029143333435,
-0.17704682052135468,
0.2019014060497284,
-0.2751184105873108,
-0.15792688727378845,
0.3654010593891144,
0.9123303890228271,
-0.2110939770936966,
0.06576170027256012,
0.12635797262191772,
0.02890334092080593,
0.5202078819274902,
0.5946705341339111,
0.6259523630142212,
0.017779091373085976,
0.5991632342338562,
-0.11054300516843796,
-0.5897417664527893,
-0.10645318031311035,
-0.9053511619567871,
-0.8549542427062988,
-0.6266490817070007,
-0.16756077110767365,
-0.13001318275928497,
-0.1622277945280075,
1.1619070768356323,
0.29968181252479553,
-0.7918639779090881,
-0.3651541471481323,
0.055864911526441574,
-0.07588709145784378,
0.13547851145267487,
-0.14028023183345795,
0.36379894614219666,
0.08870361745357513,
-0.7889623641967773,
0.7859784364700317,
0.1627853810787201,
0.011251896619796753,
-0.6728890538215637,
0.016887623816728592,
-0.12693481147289276,
0.29926830530166626,
0.6511126756668091,
0.23311279714107513,
-0.41406598687171936,
-0.30501288175582886,
0.30733856558799744,
-0.1939389407634735,
0.2087441086769104,
0.9885692000389099,
-0.8198060393333435,
0.34154370427131653,
0.7245408892631531,
0.8388291597366333,
-0.11255025118589401,
0.017540832981467247,
0.7697807550430298,
-0.8392442464828491,
0.04701974615454674,
0.10628429800271988,
0.20092563331127167,
0.1845788061618805,
-0.09206479042768478,
0.45471513271331787,
-0.06950148195028305,
-0.3970381021499634,
-0.7092529535293579,
0.29899269342422485,
-1.0015476942062378,
-0.32933762669563293,
1.3170194625854492,
-0.10295255482196808,
-0.16573208570480347,
-0.24649129807949066,
-0.24633994698524475,
0.05718472599983215,
-0.6278935074806213,
0.38878607749938965,
0.6160796880722046,
0.03269802778959274,
0.017673775553703308,
-0.9041462540626526,
0.3302132189273834,
-0.19866760075092316,
-1.2510486841201782,
0.5747875571250916,
0.6962132453918457,
0.10267015546560287,
0.17454683780670166,
0.5374960899353027,
-0.22322747111320496,
-0.08752434700727463,
-0.1327408105134964,
0.33903738856315613,
-0.4181792140007019,
-0.69823157787323,
-0.5538060069084167,
0.33432912826538086,
0.3058174252510071,
-0.5016040802001953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02750v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02750v1
|
Enhancing Contextual Understanding in Large Language Models through Contrastive Decoding
| 2024-05-04T20:38:41 | 2024-05-04T20:38:41 |
Zheng Zhao, Emilio Monti, Jens Lehmann, Haytham Assem
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) tend to inadequately integrate input context
during text generation, relying excessively on encoded prior knowledge in model
parameters, potentially resulting in generated text with factual
inconsistencies or contextually unfaithful content. LLMs utilize two primary
knowledge sources: 1) prior (parametric) knowledge from pretraining, and 2)
contextual (non-parametric) knowledge from input prompts. The study addresses
the open question of how LLMs effectively balance these knowledge sources
during the generation process, specifically in the context of open-domain
question answering. To address this issue, we introduce a novel approach
integrating contrastive decoding with adversarial irrelevant passages as
negative samples to enhance robust context grounding during generation.
Notably, our method operates at inference time without requiring further
training. We conduct comprehensive experiments to demonstrate its applicability
and effectiveness, providing empirical evidence showcasing its superiority over
existing methodologies. Our code is publicly available at:
https://github.com/amazon-science/ContextualUnderstanding-ContrastiveDecoding.
|
[
-0.4907820224761963,
-0.7895981669425964,
0.6435648798942566,
0.03732994571328163,
-0.5332627296447754,
-0.34475281834602356,
-0.3113384246826172,
-0.22730016708374023,
-0.2735878527164459,
0.5257540941238403,
-0.35074684023857117,
-0.4488925337791443,
-0.453530877828598,
-0.08029255270957947,
-0.17596614360809326,
1.0144785642623901,
-0.04320560395717621,
0.15672539174556732,
-0.5633934736251831,
-0.3833908438682556,
-0.4409774839878082,
-0.4919469654560089,
-0.6822841763496399,
-0.4840892553329468,
0.35692739486694336,
0.1953335553407669,
0.6089349389076233,
0.40065306425094604,
0.012128755450248718,
0.17953161895275116,
-0.29933175444602966,
0.20328405499458313,
-0.7083628177642822,
0.18330109119415283,
-0.515175998210907,
-0.3298892676830292,
-0.0867851972579956,
-0.1108146458864212,
0.5073848962783813,
0.9060959219932556,
0.03442716971039772,
-0.11138976365327835,
0.3568793535232544,
0.3674519658088684,
-1.0341383218765259,
-0.019048122689127922,
-0.82090824842453,
-0.13919305801391602,
0.04332726448774338,
-0.6179755330085754,
-0.5263514518737793,
-0.00578270573168993,
0.11150453984737396,
-0.6752750873565674,
0.29167935252189636,
-0.2870793640613556,
0.6053491830825806,
0.29269903898239136,
-0.6094855070114136,
-0.4544668197631836,
-0.5244234204292297,
0.7857654690742493,
-0.873708188533783,
0.2259742170572281,
0.3093627393245697,
0.02701682038605213,
-0.05502532050013542,
-0.4863636791706085,
-0.6923152208328247,
-0.020553914830088615,
-0.3188173770904541,
0.23483002185821533,
-0.061662979423999786,
0.007900025695562363,
0.08068357408046722,
0.36621570587158203,
-0.4536161720752716,
0.09670078754425049,
-0.0382319912314415,
-0.08146410435438156,
0.13990981876850128,
0.12197663635015488,
0.3059941232204437,
-0.01229090802371502,
-0.2601402997970581,
-0.07363289594650269,
-0.8064881563186646,
0.041313961148262024,
0.15834231674671173,
0.3901386260986328,
-0.24732449650764465,
0.40125566720962524,
-0.1815553605556488,
0.8956810235977173,
0.2160717397928238,
0.1724185049533844,
0.12162382155656815,
-0.4328030049800873,
-0.28883305191993713,
-0.07183066010475159,
0.5352582931518555,
0.4043843746185303,
0.013139113783836365,
-0.30906733870506287,
-0.12533250451087952,
0.04501489922404289,
0.22928613424301147,
-0.9952583312988281,
-0.1516164243221283,
0.2828516960144043,
-0.23944921791553497,
-0.384460985660553,
-0.051293712109327316,
-0.7438523173332214,
-0.6254776120185852,
-0.35576897859573364,
0.45791852474212646,
-0.4502040147781372,
-0.044572748243808746,
0.055947333574295044,
-0.16818730533123016,
0.523246169090271,
0.4452129602432251,
-0.7002076506614685,
0.11145367473363876,
0.44822922348976135,
0.5716281533241272,
0.037496745586395264,
-0.1865016371011734,
-0.8571154475212097,
0.2372909039258957,
-0.4133952558040619,
0.5662363171577454,
-0.3806208670139313,
-0.24606861174106598,
0.08734913170337677,
-0.1460580825805664,
-0.028280047699809074,
-0.5985433459281921,
0.6204785704612732,
-1.0683159828186035,
0.3265908360481262,
-0.20662730932235718,
-0.43878787755966187,
-0.1278415024280548,
0.384477436542511,
-0.448701411485672,
0.603696346282959,
-0.035928454250097275,
-0.9918379187583923,
0.17048484086990356,
-0.3288787603378296,
-0.662544310092926,
0.021180085837841034,
-0.3804631233215332,
-0.21325227618217468,
0.20862634479999542,
0.6502269506454468,
0.48644787073135376,
-0.33079493045806885,
0.442401260137558,
-0.32612186670303345,
-0.3772970736026764,
0.26331856846809387,
-0.4745050370693207,
0.8173651695251465,
0.313893586397171,
-0.45187219977378845,
0.07571786642074585,
-0.672511875629425,
-0.17248651385307312,
0.38803768157958984,
-0.31245073676109314,
-0.6539486646652222,
-0.04267331585288048,
-0.12632305920124054,
0.29757434129714966,
0.1115095242857933,
-0.26666316390037537,
-0.2368735820055008,
-0.5009351372718811,
0.4170995354652405,
0.6019228100776672,
0.11576917767524719,
0.5787165760993958,
-0.1376238465309143,
0.36255842447280884,
0.3532472252845764,
-0.46304479241371155,
-0.49809837341308594,
-0.06343095004558563,
-0.7141073942184448,
0.018231144174933434,
0.1829245537519455,
0.43079453706741333,
-1.0793930292129517,
0.4558213949203491,
-0.13457176089286804,
-0.050113316625356674,
-0.2455037385225296,
0.24995772540569305,
0.4701368510723114,
1.0558767318725586,
0.6275013089179993,
0.16337384283542633,
-0.5689274668693542,
-0.736764669418335,
-0.07902637869119644,
0.1674026995897293,
-0.3582304120063782,
0.5494561791419983,
0.4038797914981842,
-0.2635889947414398,
0.8641823530197144,
-0.6092920303344727,
0.050480205565690994,
-0.2076839655637741,
0.15658918023109436,
0.08549432456493378,
0.5102217197418213,
0.4875923693180084,
-0.8595893383026123,
-0.24702732264995575,
-0.07027650624513626,
-0.9719425439834595,
-0.17885397374629974,
-0.11437028646469116,
-0.3388427793979645,
0.04346538335084915,
0.8328771591186523,
-0.5207270383834839,
0.06391631811857224,
0.6869713664054871,
-0.48032018542289734,
0.27598705887794495,
-0.18889954686164856,
0.1827569603919983,
-1.29055917263031,
0.3946954309940338,
-0.09856697171926498,
-0.13538259267807007,
-0.7600054144859314,
0.34791824221611023,
0.18641307950019836,
-0.19571445882320404,
-0.33046966791152954,
0.7077301740646362,
-0.44152310490608215,
0.1521514356136322,
-0.40091097354888916,
0.4646570086479187,
0.38266271352767944,
0.38984736800193787,
0.11414773017168045,
0.9913998246192932,
0.29285478591918945,
-0.7167704701423645,
-0.025121226906776428,
0.2507363557815552,
-0.3740444779396057,
0.6447412967681885,
-0.5728253722190857,
0.07259551435709,
-0.4018537700176239,
0.4842270612716675,
-1.1759183406829834,
-0.17963023483753204,
0.2510075569152832,
-0.4568057358264923,
0.36065995693206787,
-0.09612613171339035,
-0.18222610652446747,
0.10739348828792572,
-0.20468775928020477,
0.7610138654708862,
0.5366663932800293,
-0.8539407253265381,
0.4376329481601715,
0.19997422397136688,
-0.2507929801940918,
-0.585950493812561,
-0.7313001155853271,
0.11240436881780624,
-0.34418442845344543,
-0.5018225312232971,
0.44180142879486084,
-0.08627285808324814,
-0.3277468681335449,
-0.026786908507347107,
-0.18019261956214905,
-0.07752758264541626,
0.2878667712211609,
-0.19026599824428558,
0.09494643658399582,
-0.5288416147232056,
0.050826795399188995,
0.09056275337934494,
0.02506842650473118,
0.2097560316324234,
-0.45670390129089355,
0.595252513885498,
0.20672067999839783,
-0.19608239829540253,
-0.22061112523078918,
0.36685869097709656,
0.5785040855407715,
-0.26515433192253113,
1.0615252256393433,
0.44969642162323,
-0.2988134026527405,
-0.3954419195652008,
-0.3941464126110077,
-0.11649458855390549,
-0.4451463222503662,
0.23831072449684143,
-0.3732773959636688,
-0.846312403678894,
0.6184594035148621,
0.10193373262882233,
-0.1779947131872177,
0.3064172863960266,
0.47911036014556885,
-0.019849322736263275,
0.8958046436309814,
0.22092565894126892,
0.08992895483970642,
0.4858492612838745,
-0.047808535397052765,
0.07072222232818604,
-0.9838577508926392,
-0.028623666614294052,
-0.37072062492370605,
0.01834823191165924,
-0.11129902303218842,
-0.5780560374259949,
0.20289169251918793,
0.5312697291374207,
-0.20856960117816925,
-0.14887820184230804,
0.004246867727488279,
0.5663465857505798,
0.48261889815330505,
0.4075452983379364,
0.16073137521743774,
-0.09593622386455536,
-0.16848912835121155,
0.05851224437355995,
-0.7055581212043762,
-0.42215436697006226,
1.0747274160385132,
0.12175443768501282,
0.6506595015525818,
0.08173242211341858,
0.45145562291145325,
-0.00952010229229927,
0.31589987874031067,
-0.5758169293403625,
0.3665951192378998,
-0.1794893592596054,
-0.4280136823654175,
-0.24665017426013947,
-0.5591851472854614,
-0.8833490014076233,
0.5745455622673035,
-0.13747327029705048,
-0.3496812880039215,
0.127388134598732,
0.3606158494949341,
-0.38201552629470825,
0.24337556958198547,
-0.6072531938552856,
0.9671363234519958,
-0.011194488033652306,
-0.6648736596107483,
0.045245461165905,
-0.6437031626701355,
0.4992908835411072,
0.045902058482170105,
0.2554001808166504,
0.48258140683174133,
-0.005838295444846153,
0.5052186250686646,
-0.22788065671920776,
0.8108128905296326,
-0.3271121680736542,
-0.5214208364486694,
0.2734670639038086,
0.03838975355029106,
0.5809904932975769,
0.23843885958194733,
-0.14429576694965363,
-0.016772303730249405,
-0.4394478499889374,
-0.5905985236167908,
-0.699826717376709,
0.8259464502334595,
-0.7200462222099304,
-0.5826935172080994,
-0.07051247358322144,
-0.6417460441589355,
-0.4330180585384369,
0.22916410863399506,
0.43251508474349976,
0.5949978232383728,
-0.2614899277687073,
0.5028358697891235,
1.052472710609436,
-0.532142698764801,
0.12987907230854034,
0.5569624900817871,
0.24492284655570984,
-0.5292156338691711,
0.8104373812675476,
-0.3337744176387787,
0.36932051181793213,
0.6670878529548645,
0.21550652384757996,
-0.37384361028671265,
-0.9077170491218567,
-0.395212322473526,
0.1227489709854126,
-1.019932508468628,
-0.1626584678888321,
-0.6958129405975342,
-0.05251273512840271,
-0.5701190233230591,
-0.3713119626045227,
-0.05179160460829735,
0.12769082188606262,
-0.5201367735862732,
-0.07345190644264221,
-0.24413271248340607,
0.382340669631958,
0.2327548712491989,
0.3269248306751251,
-0.7005977630615234,
0.5598551630973816,
0.36170822381973267,
0.10884411633014679,
0.1441032737493515,
-0.6690593361854553,
-0.28647568821907043,
0.20654699206352234,
-0.17559438943862915,
-0.7996082901954651,
0.16699470579624176,
-0.07537365704774857,
0.6452487707138062,
0.43877196311950684,
0.3844043016433716,
0.6401517391204834,
-0.3897811770439148,
0.8451442718505859,
-0.019649293273687363,
-1.0492303371429443,
0.4681304693222046,
-0.5848072171211243,
0.6944567561149597,
0.6699636578559875,
0.24711312353610992,
-0.2914353907108307,
-0.3915896415710449,
-0.32009157538414,
-1.0079506635665894,
0.8666013479232788,
0.26121267676353455,
0.24543799459934235,
-0.07328825443983078,
0.37606409192085266,
0.08271327614784241,
0.2382548302412033,
-0.8770595788955688,
-0.17913134396076202,
-0.2711573541164398,
-0.2582937777042389,
-0.6082478165626526,
-0.4025971591472626,
-0.454102098941803,
0.08791511505842209,
0.579266369342804,
-0.2064945548772812,
-0.03448950871825218,
0.1957966387271881,
-0.4350166916847229,
0.023371530696749687,
0.465576171875,
0.8742529153823853,
0.7109273672103882,
-0.13161493837833405,
0.539199948310852,
0.28041431307792664,
-0.11374133825302124,
-0.020074987784028053,
0.13459710776805878,
-0.2677501142024994,
-0.25853678584098816,
0.5474377274513245,
0.7731136679649353,
0.24893119931221008,
-0.6077280640602112,
0.6143782734870911,
-0.06703159958124161,
-0.31386131048202515,
0.003810314228758216,
-0.0774456188082695,
0.18432354927062988,
0.23294205963611603,
0.27034690976142883,
-0.04212474822998047,
0.012116524390876293,
-0.3790806531906128,
0.1270565390586853,
0.5217189192771912,
-0.18176792562007904,
-0.2036876380443573,
0.6445041298866272,
0.40815749764442444,
0.14944571256637573,
0.4731028378009796,
-0.10973087698221207,
-0.396310955286026,
0.6079897880554199,
0.7969881892204285,
0.792231559753418,
-0.0652313083410263,
-0.045170340687036514,
0.21991871297359467,
0.04601432755589485,
0.2041693776845932,
-0.05700697377324104,
-0.3977828919887543,
-0.9265801906585693,
-0.40368831157684326,
-0.5678742527961731,
-0.3950171172618866,
0.735611617565155,
-0.6957756876945496,
0.13035836815834045,
-0.2534082531929016,
0.43971142172813416,
-0.18027658760547638,
-0.3270322382450104,
-0.5615653991699219,
0.5110125541687012,
0.31205853819847107,
0.6545124053955078,
-0.891055703163147,
0.6639747023582458,
0.7962465286254883,
-0.26151007413864136,
-0.3591803312301636,
0.594020664691925,
-0.2606719136238098,
-0.7185236215591431,
0.6191925406455994,
0.26461032032966614,
-0.345075786113739,
0.034337177872657776,
-0.44001680612564087,
-0.5898590683937073,
0.952417254447937,
0.49042272567749023,
-0.12040062248706818,
-0.020893478766083717,
-0.09743783622980118,
0.5413392186164856,
-0.3849867880344391,
0.15871059894561768,
0.409548282623291,
0.16829709708690643,
0.2948715388774872,
-0.2224227786064148,
0.45622602105140686,
-0.37171900272369385,
0.03706921637058258,
0.11572097986936569,
-0.25576430559158325,
0.9245093464851379,
-0.0772198885679245,
-0.36745259165763855,
0.06646350771188736,
0.5599619150161743,
0.3063260614871979,
0.3388073146343231,
0.47996172308921814,
0.5990667939186096,
0.48612478375434875,
0.21789677441120148,
0.9792085886001587,
-0.5625458359718323,
0.14303825795650482,
1.3623168468475342,
-0.2126619815826416,
0.6757586002349854,
0.6316966414451599,
0.17192700505256653,
0.29405155777931213,
0.47494935989379883,
0.40069249272346497,
0.7436273097991943,
0.15582267940044403,
-0.46856287121772766,
-0.3329356908798218,
-0.08512808382511139,
-0.5775002241134644,
0.2140333503484726,
0.34938085079193115,
-0.48972511291503906,
-0.48674896359443665,
-0.020829515531659126,
-0.038111936300992966,
0.374234676361084,
-0.2192002832889557,
0.8874487280845642,
-0.06967192143201828,
-0.8938485980033875,
0.8594655394554138,
0.05393299460411072,
0.6552480459213257,
-0.6183716058731079,
-0.024356162175536156,
-0.3257184624671936,
0.2815593481063843,
-0.1117076426744461,
-0.7443057894706726,
0.24520421028137207,
-0.0069139376282691956,
-0.31995466351509094,
-0.291146844625473,
0.46483278274536133,
-0.48047053813934326,
0.07620216906070709,
0.3845190107822418,
0.4292811453342438,
-0.2974352240562439,
-0.22246772050857544,
-0.3043716549873352,
-0.0613606721162796,
-0.07224602997303009,
-0.291096568107605,
0.4173271954059601,
0.5967211723327637,
0.25364556908607483,
0.1588958203792572,
0.6110035181045532,
-0.2180871069431305,
-0.29658329486846924,
0.11009006947278976,
1.133967638015747,
-0.600105881690979,
-0.7569781541824341,
-0.9743239879608154,
0.5541948676109314,
0.015993967652320862,
-0.30682244896888733,
0.7501984238624573,
0.36433616280555725,
0.935947835445404,
-0.11117572337388992,
0.875812828540802,
0.14142118394374847,
0.18860146403312683,
-0.9187399744987488,
0.5499308109283447,
-0.7057207822799683,
0.4222564399242401,
-0.2542934715747833,
-0.7305142283439636,
-0.360653281211853,
0.45507073402404785,
-0.5229876041412354,
0.034864574670791626,
0.6205516457557678,
0.6415910720825195,
-0.16916809976100922,
-0.08931208401918411,
0.4194929003715515,
0.2568521797657013,
0.388694703578949,
0.6499232649803162,
0.9648255705833435,
-0.33909884095191956,
0.6597666144371033,
-0.0716966912150383,
-0.2060447335243225,
-0.2247631847858429,
-0.8770666122436523,
-1.0689027309417725,
-0.2535969018936157,
-0.06102025881409645,
-0.49721887707710266,
0.11427032947540283,
0.5433274507522583,
0.564710259437561,
-0.9505882263183594,
-0.0566534623503685,
-0.5685912370681763,
0.0173103678971529,
0.1486186385154724,
-0.2653823494911194,
0.2348448634147644,
-0.6211416125297546,
-0.6344202756881714,
0.6377657651901245,
-0.08125634491443634,
0.12119510024785995,
-0.0898081436753273,
-0.15061064064502716,
-0.16237986087799072,
0.15266118943691254,
0.7277767062187195,
0.11875694990158081,
-0.5949057936668396,
-0.11476515978574753,
-0.24332740902900696,
-0.2637060284614563,
0.04984312504529953,
0.8953586220741272,
-0.7458462119102478,
0.34334108233451843,
0.6102727651596069,
0.9507231712341309,
0.2994919717311859,
0.40047547221183777,
0.8024734258651733,
-0.8535870909690857,
0.28390762209892273,
0.15843936800956726,
0.3989379405975342,
0.43123859167099,
-0.42448025941848755,
0.17694199085235596,
0.1711166650056839,
-0.318483829498291,
-0.7309589982032776,
0.37866532802581787,
-0.737281322479248,
-0.8163423538208008,
1.165716528892517,
-0.26312020421028137,
0.078574039041996,
0.0030857918318361044,
-0.24078181385993958,
0.23023128509521484,
-0.2453320324420929,
0.5094497799873352,
0.7116801142692566,
0.08166542649269104,
-0.08322112262248993,
-0.3138231933116913,
0.35384416580200195,
0.6179667711257935,
-0.8735979795455933,
0.20709453523159027,
0.6844161152839661,
0.22187985479831696,
0.08726228028535843,
0.5431734323501587,
0.0037241033278405666,
0.14519184827804565,
0.17467103898525238,
-0.2995138466358185,
-0.17613565921783447,
-0.211872860789299,
-0.8814191818237305,
0.4763529300689697,
-0.07848715782165527,
-0.07651007920503616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02743v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02743v1
|
Beyond Performance: Quantifying and Mitigating Label Bias in LLMs
| 2024-05-04T19:53:03 | 2024-05-04T19:53:03 |
Yuval Reif, Roy Schwartz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable adaptability to diverse
tasks, by leveraging context prompts containing instructions, or minimal
input-output examples. However, recent work revealed they also exhibit label
bias -- an undesirable preference toward predicting certain answers over
others. Still, detecting and measuring this bias reliably and at scale has
remained relatively unexplored. In this study, we evaluate different approaches
to quantifying label bias in a model's predictions, conducting a comprehensive
investigation across 279 classification tasks and ten LLMs. Our investigation
reveals substantial label bias in models both before and after debiasing
attempts, as well as highlights the importance of outcomes-based evaluation
metrics, which were not previously used in this regard. We further propose a
novel label bias calibration method tailored for few-shot prompting, which
outperforms recent calibration approaches for both improving performance and
mitigating label bias. Our results emphasize that label bias in the predictions
of LLMs remains a barrier to their reliability.
|
[
-0.5447809100151062,
-0.6062581539154053,
0.6185623407363892,
0.057341355830430984,
0.15871760249137878,
-0.011700076051056385,
-0.19013498723506927,
-0.38883867859840393,
-0.1414640098810196,
0.5080409646034241,
-0.6437393426895142,
-0.3776955306529999,
-0.8503249883651733,
-0.0983903631567955,
0.017041949555277824,
1.1159380674362183,
0.06708451360464096,
0.24936236441135406,
-0.5778589248657227,
-0.17575322091579437,
-0.6185907125473022,
-0.5851754546165466,
-0.4392384886741638,
-0.820453405380249,
0.6334495544433594,
0.32383492588996887,
0.4631657600402832,
0.4360438883304596,
0.3391849398612976,
0.10570261627435684,
-0.30794739723205566,
0.11200017482042313,
-0.6441457867622375,
0.08357695490121841,
-0.10735906660556793,
-0.6769909262657166,
-0.6326985359191895,
0.07506713271141052,
0.9684827923774719,
0.8588927388191223,
0.1329144686460495,
0.43966829776763916,
0.45793771743774414,
0.7443680763244629,
-0.9745264053344727,
0.050531055778265,
-0.5472639203071594,
0.03551120311021805,
-0.3583582639694214,
-0.02577936090528965,
-0.7058009505271912,
-0.24915440380573273,
-0.1316189020872116,
-0.48791369795799255,
-0.21866486966609955,
-0.009555419906973839,
0.28581780195236206,
0.45922431349754333,
-0.3473132848739624,
-0.2594589293003082,
-0.7633967995643616,
1.0879334211349487,
-0.7619698643684387,
0.4760492742061615,
0.5646364092826843,
0.25935378670692444,
-0.12632492184638977,
-0.40259426832199097,
-0.07446283847093582,
-0.2808544337749481,
0.08617249876260757,
0.042319949716329575,
-0.2736053764820099,
0.10123574733734131,
0.6109556555747986,
-0.06831778585910797,
-0.2877481281757355,
0.6200122833251953,
0.005769228562712669,
-0.34729132056236267,
0.3161378502845764,
0.2592889666557312,
0.015955215319991112,
0.2774944305419922,
-0.33675000071525574,
-0.05269746854901314,
-0.9677644371986389,
0.18217279016971588,
0.3588685393333435,
0.1675647497177124,
0.04994559660553932,
0.4923436939716339,
-0.15436673164367676,
0.8193106651306152,
-0.09864996373653412,
-0.3316274583339691,
0.1486629694700241,
-0.17317497730255127,
-0.1194697916507721,
0.18331176042556763,
0.5285038352012634,
0.4555998742580414,
0.27550822496414185,
0.041886862367391586,
-0.32022279500961304,
0.20153623819351196,
0.0723942294716835,
-0.8249955773353577,
-0.1487596035003662,
0.009990593418478966,
-0.3220459222793579,
-0.19094163179397583,
-0.30287784337997437,
-0.6561277508735657,
-0.8164341449737549,
-0.11149744689464569,
0.33384570479393005,
-0.08241568505764008,
-0.015240096487104893,
-0.2890937924385071,
0.002356707351282239,
-0.04411141946911812,
0.20391146838665009,
-0.8041903376579285,
0.11669269949197769,
0.8660311698913574,
0.6591824889183044,
-0.37166956067085266,
-0.17962868511676788,
-0.7279506921768188,
0.18172234296798706,
-0.4747786223888397,
0.8577119708061218,
-0.7022679448127747,
-0.44687092304229736,
-0.21195560693740845,
-0.2924329340457916,
0.13851533830165863,
-0.7184052467346191,
0.616226851940155,
-0.5014140605926514,
-0.22400052845478058,
-0.5872403383255005,
-0.8157113790512085,
-0.09533445537090302,
0.5213950276374817,
-0.6488973498344421,
0.9418013095855713,
-0.0893181562423706,
-0.8940145969390869,
0.695163905620575,
-0.5226860642433167,
-0.13897615671157837,
-0.10434966534376144,
-0.10739735513925552,
-0.3398805558681488,
0.2713332176208496,
0.2638871669769287,
0.3556998372077942,
-0.4465363919734955,
0.29960089921951294,
-0.5132061243057251,
-0.5393105149269104,
0.5694336295127869,
-0.6954939365386963,
0.4289018213748932,
0.024107273668050766,
-0.2544780969619751,
0.008283068425953388,
-0.7463045716285706,
0.1934625506401062,
-0.31169530749320984,
-0.39363932609558105,
-0.39895597100257874,
-0.087044857442379,
-0.3694749176502228,
0.15455754101276398,
0.04610661044716835,
-0.5010929107666016,
0.1074736937880516,
-0.33818355202674866,
0.11255080252885818,
0.9356169104576111,
-0.1857154220342636,
0.498844176530838,
-0.412209153175354,
0.8668181896209717,
-0.10786469280719757,
0.028564276173710823,
-0.2321329265832901,
-0.3824588656425476,
-0.6152492165565491,
-0.3326587975025177,
0.3715389668941498,
0.4083693027496338,
-0.5470036864280701,
0.0014109007315710187,
-0.33124759793281555,
-0.5753552913665771,
-0.4016328752040863,
0.23507991433143616,
0.6079174876213074,
0.5762001872062683,
0.22877328097820282,
-0.31486597657203674,
-0.3669155538082123,
-0.9087620973587036,
-0.6035857200622559,
-0.1584024578332901,
-0.2538565695285797,
0.4240707457065582,
0.4563975930213928,
-0.4328007698059082,
0.8675360083580017,
-0.5772522687911987,
-0.2029462307691574,
-0.15624912083148956,
0.1391511708498001,
0.21036675572395325,
0.27717989683151245,
0.3413546085357666,
-0.21069933474063873,
-0.20075097680091858,
-0.2729969322681427,
-0.46764734387397766,
-0.5667293071746826,
0.03257399797439575,
0.11472945660352707,
0.34922704100608826,
0.4770009517669678,
-0.15321332216262817,
0.2862336039543152,
0.7102341651916504,
-0.01675596833229065,
0.6556347012519836,
0.060526538640260696,
-0.03465479612350464,
-0.35731056332588196,
-0.0030820020474493504,
0.25057077407836914,
-0.1695033609867096,
-0.5391628742218018,
-0.317889928817749,
0.031100286170840263,
0.4206027388572693,
-0.48885664343833923,
0.8055078983306885,
-0.3452625572681427,
-0.3338172733783722,
-0.46900463104248047,
0.030103405937552452,
0.19455158710479736,
0.06387969851493835,
0.007561058271676302,
0.8479479551315308,
0.4867934286594391,
-0.6993132829666138,
0.163705974817276,
-0.12099852412939072,
-0.6000044941902161,
0.608979344367981,
-0.5353745818138123,
0.07164894789457321,
-0.17457620799541473,
0.6098028421401978,
-1.2267342805862427,
0.1475439965724945,
0.2763277292251587,
-0.35440587997436523,
0.412314236164093,
-0.17550233006477356,
-0.4289795458316803,
-0.37462863326072693,
-0.4321382939815521,
0.6578569412231445,
0.4994485676288605,
-0.45323413610458374,
0.31643640995025635,
0.3241938650608063,
0.039892300963401794,
-0.5367004871368408,
-0.84214848279953,
-0.1845693737268448,
-0.3873179852962494,
-0.21661682426929474,
0.1764465868473053,
-0.16662751138210297,
-0.29079383611679077,
-0.5211892127990723,
-0.32063186168670654,
0.058619655668735504,
0.12663882970809937,
0.3428482115268707,
0.11755891889333725,
-0.08351295441389084,
0.30665379762649536,
-0.08483780175447464,
-0.24338848888874054,
0.23319172859191895,
-0.2376565784215927,
0.41528141498565674,
0.18406088650226593,
-0.3701140284538269,
-0.28257623314857483,
-0.1615203469991684,
0.4232722222805023,
-0.03055712580680847,
0.6723459362983704,
0.6341010928153992,
-0.20456130802631378,
-0.3126496374607086,
-0.7584054470062256,
-0.3947449028491974,
-0.4600431025028229,
0.37822195887565613,
-0.29781949520111084,
-0.7650851607322693,
0.42764437198638916,
-0.3302815556526184,
-0.09914742410182953,
0.10690338164567947,
0.6413575410842896,
-0.13528111577033997,
0.9815081357955933,
0.5852725505828857,
-0.039155926555395126,
0.3674027621746063,
-0.05120766535401344,
0.11698006093502045,
-1.2410153150558472,
-0.1817016303539276,
-0.48237037658691406,
-0.4075319170951843,
-0.6222417950630188,
-0.5669876337051392,
0.4926983714103699,
0.062088944017887115,
-0.2610098421573639,
-0.1283249408006668,
-0.4101984202861786,
0.49730628728866577,
0.4960075318813324,
-0.01695656031370163,
0.19728587567806244,
-0.14605869352817535,
-0.10927320271730423,
-0.2864729166030884,
-0.8808368444442749,
-0.7980769872665405,
1.221118450164795,
0.6181175708770752,
1.0263583660125732,
-0.20187591016292572,
0.5648084282875061,
0.2802372872829437,
0.7024762034416199,
-0.8634979724884033,
0.39415863156318665,
-0.03202605992555618,
-0.8405957221984863,
-0.3669626712799072,
-0.36462587118148804,
-0.7437945604324341,
0.44045382738113403,
0.004800381138920784,
-1.0935131311416626,
-0.015306221321225166,
0.3301735520362854,
-0.3816696107387543,
0.23025371134281158,
-0.4523179233074188,
0.78681480884552,
-0.3234834671020508,
-0.4817899763584137,
0.13005568087100983,
-0.37532588839530945,
0.5203484892845154,
-0.31030306220054626,
0.5444925427436829,
-0.22254011034965515,
-0.24178174138069153,
1.0044641494750977,
-0.07766462862491608,
1.1211234331130981,
-0.013424106873571873,
-0.48206233978271484,
0.29308608174324036,
0.11365858465433121,
0.46646109223365784,
-0.10781941562891006,
-0.33320915699005127,
0.11629721522331238,
0.11448530107736588,
-0.2552608847618103,
-0.5124632716178894,
0.8235443830490112,
-0.4687701463699341,
-0.4439827799797058,
-0.28944507241249084,
-0.6353591680526733,
-0.5958383083343506,
-0.009619683027267456,
0.35056808590888977,
0.32482972741127014,
-0.2581360340118408,
-0.03846843168139458,
0.7874306440353394,
-0.5243090391159058,
0.3556792140007019,
0.4955257773399353,
-0.1961417943239212,
-0.2836170196533203,
0.8351587653160095,
0.3949439227581024,
0.4650373160839081,
0.347026526927948,
0.3816209137439728,
-0.44727668166160583,
-0.36346909403800964,
-0.26662951707839966,
0.10906574875116348,
-0.903611958026886,
-0.2774229645729065,
-0.4477934241294861,
0.2785834074020386,
-0.3694533407688141,
0.011916725896298885,
-0.4242098927497864,
-0.32574084401130676,
-0.41870614886283875,
-0.17542508244514465,
0.08186779916286469,
0.8466504216194153,
-0.034896042197942734,
0.5539140105247498,
-0.724400520324707,
0.12037508934736252,
0.18588991463184357,
0.46002888679504395,
0.21314997971057892,
-0.7874699234962463,
-0.09259237349033356,
0.21556934714317322,
-0.5242083668708801,
-0.8773720860481262,
0.1552850902080536,
0.07719142735004425,
0.6648738384246826,
0.26652851700782776,
0.09965216368436813,
0.35210174322128296,
-0.428647518157959,
0.8564953207969666,
0.16201099753379822,
-1.0280370712280273,
0.5196264386177063,
-0.10099455714225769,
0.5920664668083191,
0.35472220182418823,
0.41770875453948975,
-0.33241409063339233,
-0.2998219430446625,
-0.28012821078300476,
-0.7393476366996765,
0.7424444556236267,
-0.13822852075099945,
0.010503928177058697,
0.13553859293460846,
0.1639566868543625,
0.18493498861789703,
0.2712998390197754,
-0.7942438125610352,
-0.34502410888671875,
0.21711154282093048,
0.2060818076133728,
-0.3383769690990448,
-0.5791481733322144,
-0.07040046155452728,
-0.2531258761882782,
0.7464774250984192,
-0.18192045390605927,
-0.09330069273710251,
-0.17631690204143524,
-0.232302725315094,
0.06165238097310066,
0.4894956946372986,
0.7588053345680237,
0.9148986339569092,
-0.0732918232679367,
0.1274726688861847,
0.46146121621131897,
-0.17029611766338348,
0.24624457955360413,
-0.1298712193965912,
-0.33149316906929016,
-0.04580298066139221,
0.5490461587905884,
0.9197114109992981,
0.21325290203094482,
-0.6584458351135254,
0.312173455953598,
0.3797575533390045,
0.1407354772090912,
0.0557994544506073,
0.04348865523934364,
0.08473469316959381,
0.2230156660079956,
0.16860908269882202,
-0.35356083512306213,
0.2559821605682373,
-0.47864389419555664,
0.1676097810268402,
0.5684310793876648,
-0.724200427532196,
-0.15387077629566193,
0.6882880330085754,
0.08143172413110733,
-0.040477652102708817,
0.21517795324325562,
0.06346914172172546,
-0.5709061026573181,
0.714934766292572,
0.47929057478904724,
0.6208555698394775,
-0.2855534255504608,
0.3283206522464752,
0.23626600205898285,
0.4570713937282562,
-0.1711171716451645,
-0.1815444827079773,
-0.06783825904130936,
-0.713271975517273,
-0.47120848298072815,
-0.568838357925415,
-0.45737770199775696,
0.1536405235528946,
-0.7104954719543457,
0.09687714278697968,
-0.3185946047306061,
-0.6828779578208923,
0.15553098917007446,
-0.1428394466638565,
-0.6007678508758545,
0.29439666867256165,
0.5688853859901428,
0.814979076385498,
-0.9664037227630615,
0.7439618110656738,
0.7826281785964966,
-0.03842897340655327,
-0.4981978237628937,
-0.04792541638016701,
0.20823608338832855,
-0.7548694610595703,
0.8704859018325806,
0.2703176438808441,
-0.24551314115524292,
-0.1481727808713913,
-0.3544134795665741,
-0.7566011548042297,
0.8961679935455322,
0.4496268033981323,
-0.7584428191184998,
0.20477290451526642,
0.26990020275115967,
0.44501063227653503,
-0.27573463320732117,
0.6407040953636169,
1.0013114213943481,
0.6411842703819275,
0.05827685445547104,
-1.0169271230697632,
0.05887279286980629,
0.4826565980911255,
0.18427541851997375,
0.12313735485076904,
-0.46309083700180054,
0.4723830223083496,
-0.2227007895708084,
0.13453105092048645,
-0.16250544786453247,
0.29271024465560913,
0.5583804845809937,
0.5148571729660034,
0.308436781167984,
0.4149519205093384,
0.8653976321220398,
-0.2055204212665558,
1.0734869241714478,
0.07940231263637543,
0.2501021921634674,
1.236080527305603,
-0.4999326467514038,
0.5138895511627197,
0.6866928339004517,
-0.35556653141975403,
0.17018474638462067,
0.6138510704040527,
0.0501239188015461,
0.49811550974845886,
0.6945030689239502,
-0.21403270959854126,
-0.4167338013648987,
-0.5093060731887817,
-0.4242420494556427,
0.3664729595184326,
0.4976983070373535,
-0.4006708264350891,
-0.14232072234153748,
0.28371167182922363,
0.023463541641831398,
-0.04167189076542854,
-0.48450979590415955,
0.8641872406005859,
0.2608006000518799,
-0.768905758857727,
0.7916250824928284,
-0.20426392555236816,
0.9335252046585083,
-0.3481872081756592,
0.11483588069677353,
-0.186554953455925,
0.2780795395374298,
-0.1793699711561203,
-0.9370566606521606,
0.07883886247873306,
-0.1524651199579239,
-0.2949102520942688,
-0.33521386981010437,
0.6633673310279846,
-0.2768455445766449,
-0.5820114612579346,
0.28395846486091614,
0.4826541244983673,
0.09015006572008133,
-0.09633379429578781,
-0.5060255527496338,
0.6652716398239136,
-0.02442466840147972,
-0.3627113699913025,
0.38621383905410767,
0.2791878879070282,
-0.07535912841558456,
0.9591211080551147,
0.18652617931365967,
0.1255190372467041,
0.19026853144168854,
0.03419343754649162,
0.7176807522773743,
-0.40409761667251587,
-0.19430853426456451,
-1.120086431503296,
0.3158838450908661,
0.23419731855392456,
-0.16228114068508148,
0.7655826807022095,
0.5121706128120422,
0.8350955247879028,
-0.0017259193118661642,
0.7013350129127502,
0.582759439945221,
0.43090614676475525,
-0.4583318829536438,
0.5825439095497131,
-0.4937359392642975,
0.646689236164093,
-0.5504166483879089,
-0.9953804612159729,
-0.24249976873397827,
0.39834943413734436,
-0.5809261798858643,
0.24480752646923065,
0.4316340684890747,
0.7399308085441589,
0.20310662686824799,
-0.2317906618118286,
0.4842269718647003,
0.04309418424963951,
0.3372582495212555,
0.6565809845924377,
1.007193922996521,
-0.2205187827348709,
0.4887545108795166,
-0.10744411498308182,
-0.3237208425998688,
-0.1949017494916916,
-1.1509785652160645,
-0.9191601872444153,
-0.11545029282569885,
-0.5379220843315125,
-0.31374311447143555,
0.09333246946334839,
0.46368539333343506,
0.7097240090370178,
-0.852119505405426,
-0.1817886382341385,
0.2220216542482376,
0.4545654356479645,
-0.015447232872247696,
-0.17377068102359772,
0.08655841648578644,
-0.1984609216451645,
-0.6535251140594482,
0.20518407225608826,
0.11112061887979507,
0.12026814371347427,
-0.22586871683597565,
-0.04729966074228287,
0.1752784550189972,
0.1415191888809204,
0.7215677499771118,
0.14482834935188293,
-0.9618342518806458,
-0.03986545652151108,
-0.2228904813528061,
-0.03692781552672386,
-0.02669447474181652,
0.6698395609855652,
-0.9765009880065918,
0.4454001188278198,
0.472488135099411,
0.6504701375961304,
0.39369311928749084,
0.03996330499649048,
0.6127744913101196,
-0.7861843109130859,
-0.029309112578630447,
0.30103275179862976,
0.04497469961643219,
0.4442128539085388,
-0.19850708544254303,
0.4158107042312622,
-0.1897830367088318,
-0.6542786359786987,
-1.1660661697387695,
0.3912006914615631,
-0.4815213680267334,
-0.3092157542705536,
1.3594393730163574,
-0.1440991908311844,
-0.011798050254583359,
0.23333297669887543,
-0.1611584573984146,
0.12434590607881546,
-0.2962062656879425,
0.46647223830223083,
0.9880263805389404,
-0.1880807727575302,
-0.14222072064876556,
-0.7916197180747986,
0.43032440543174744,
0.5377069711685181,
-0.6317559480667114,
0.2913099527359009,
0.6895639300346375,
0.3042955696582794,
0.020793525502085686,
0.6199349761009216,
0.15302389860153198,
0.030437778681516647,
-0.26587626338005066,
-0.14111915230751038,
0.0666017085313797,
-0.31800568103790283,
-0.5215482711791992,
-0.13184362649917603,
0.419154554605484,
-0.12781888246536255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02738v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02738v1
|
Relations Prediction for Knowledge Graph Completion using Large Language Models
| 2024-05-04T19:04:51 | 2024-05-04T19:04:51 |
Sakher Khalil Alqaaidi, Krzysztof Kochut
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.4
|
Knowledge Graphs have been widely used to represent facts in a structured
format. Due to their large scale applications, knowledge graphs suffer from
being incomplete. The relation prediction task obtains knowledge graph
completion by assigning one or more possible relations to each pair of nodes.
In this work, we make use of the knowledge graph node names to fine-tune a
large language model for the relation prediction task. By utilizing the node
names only we enable our model to operate sufficiently in the inductive
settings. Our experiments show that we accomplish new scores on a widely used
knowledge graph benchmark.
|
[
-0.4057759940624237,
-0.4737996459007263,
0.7861220836639404,
-0.09823427349328995,
-0.17716388404369354,
-0.031533870846033096,
-0.3271922171115875,
-0.8080540299415588,
0.24889691174030304,
0.6058391332626343,
-0.5890534520149231,
-0.39401206374168396,
-0.599263608455658,
0.05602538585662842,
-0.23575003445148468,
0.9431665539741516,
-0.02779540792107582,
-0.058032989501953125,
-0.6230940818786621,
-0.09214019775390625,
-0.4983474314212799,
-0.23852664232254028,
-0.6146882176399231,
-0.807183027267456,
0.6618725061416626,
0.464335560798645,
0.9986349940299988,
0.8666331171989441,
0.4088663160800934,
0.28792208433151245,
-0.15537510812282562,
0.4061240553855896,
-0.473104327917099,
0.34494566917419434,
-0.20687636733055115,
-0.018961653113365173,
-0.4397675693035126,
-0.10282639414072037,
0.8628283739089966,
1.426944613456726,
0.30032697319984436,
0.11062663048505783,
0.017363272607326508,
0.6133273839950562,
-0.38800370693206787,
0.838738739490509,
-0.6266568303108215,
0.08883191645145416,
-0.07606463879346848,
-0.04076496511697769,
-0.4258050322532654,
-0.3760068714618683,
0.2860833406448364,
-0.6358584761619568,
0.03686516731977463,
0.2644680440425873,
0.6840327978134155,
-0.0452461875975132,
-0.6075506806373596,
0.028184205293655396,
-0.9445738792419434,
0.4171323776245117,
-0.5642798542976379,
0.5549322962760925,
0.7109996676445007,
0.3371502161026001,
-0.4516116678714752,
-0.7330672740936279,
-0.36634358763694763,
-0.4720829725265503,
-0.45322370529174805,
-0.07406507432460785,
0.17764726281166077,
0.25171369314193726,
0.6025405526161194,
0.29496270418167114,
-0.17379117012023926,
-0.12804606556892395,
-0.35917818546295166,
-0.028877925127744675,
0.5211495161056519,
0.2763691246509552,
-0.009336121380329132,
-0.10279977321624756,
-0.1893860101699829,
0.2066350281238556,
-0.6556471586227417,
-0.08828871697187424,
0.18053479492664337,
0.5966209769248962,
0.2896136939525604,
0.6970676183700562,
-0.6801202893257141,
1.1353814601898193,
-0.0988364964723587,
-0.28895455598831177,
0.33858156204223633,
-0.2864348590373993,
-0.2609502375125885,
-0.0288198534399271,
0.8532031774520874,
0.38589662313461304,
0.8468886017799377,
-0.6710488200187683,
0.022342663258314133,
-0.27367478609085083,
-0.05514657869935036,
-0.7035605907440186,
-0.46287089586257935,
0.03843280300498009,
-0.05130407214164734,
-0.0051924725994467735,
-0.16179552674293518,
-0.3745015561580658,
-0.5967991948127747,
-0.5011863112449646,
0.1489269882440567,
-0.5940836668014526,
-0.3974665403366089,
-0.18270917236804962,
-0.1310700923204422,
-0.21983833611011505,
0.4588816463947296,
-0.6021475791931152,
0.4347114562988281,
0.5055257678031921,
0.6066387295722961,
0.1782470941543579,
-0.6124635934829712,
-0.5288989543914795,
0.4815220236778259,
-0.3514755070209503,
0.6746925711631775,
-0.7317832708358765,
-0.15920738875865936,
-0.025947295129299164,
0.009910497814416885,
-0.07637634873390198,
-0.4565654993057251,
0.3441690504550934,
-0.6783889532089233,
-0.14964009821414948,
-0.39306139945983887,
-1.0466023683547974,
-0.030934728682041168,
0.28663116693496704,
-1.0517706871032715,
0.7996042370796204,
0.3951403498649597,
-1.174221396446228,
0.17978060245513916,
-0.3268064856529236,
-0.7860904335975647,
0.17201410233974457,
0.14027273654937744,
-0.304429292678833,
-0.27747592329978943,
-0.12289929389953613,
0.6913996934890747,
-0.2839074730873108,
0.2714197039604187,
-0.46999871730804443,
-0.08741386234760284,
0.16984686255455017,
0.43686211109161377,
0.43350833654403687,
0.08183063566684723,
0.1971488744020462,
0.005338122136890888,
-0.7938110828399658,
0.02545350417494774,
0.02241360768675804,
-0.07431565225124359,
-0.47116297483444214,
0.19141553342342377,
-0.3470323979854584,
0.13649946451187134,
0.1420217603445053,
-0.5879871845245361,
0.2354211062192917,
-0.3732298016548157,
0.3318662941455841,
0.46806737780570984,
0.22183623909950256,
0.6363953948020935,
-0.10134920477867126,
0.49036353826522827,
-0.1609509289264679,
-0.06347917765378952,
0.08392812311649323,
-0.5921923518180847,
-0.49212878942489624,
0.3059675395488739,
0.69920414686203,
0.22140125930309296,
-0.7460272312164307,
0.3234758675098419,
-0.5510570406913757,
-0.6833757758140564,
0.09459561109542847,
0.13959640264511108,
0.35302871465682983,
0.7547883987426758,
0.2763815224170685,
0.07026885449886322,
-0.6826207637786865,
-0.6032820343971252,
-0.19997534155845642,
-0.2837807238101959,
0.1537654548883438,
0.44968095421791077,
0.3128233253955841,
-0.07654963433742523,
0.96146559715271,
-0.8755379915237427,
-0.4899049401283264,
-0.18755517899990082,
-0.1338224560022354,
0.22184979915618896,
0.19146087765693665,
0.27658024430274963,
-0.5818731784820557,
-0.6238142251968384,
0.2679808735847473,
-0.615996778011322,
0.45949864387512207,
0.2774020731449127,
-0.18845319747924805,
-0.2314850091934204,
0.6255484223365784,
-0.672549307346344,
0.1715545505285263,
0.4929051995277405,
-0.37348490953445435,
0.5930265188217163,
0.13380707800388336,
-0.2552916705608368,
-1.0974936485290527,
0.08676524460315704,
-0.04163701832294464,
-0.7184876203536987,
-0.4287642240524292,
-0.13158266246318817,
0.05812637880444527,
-0.016611924394965172,
-0.0839361771941185,
0.7156074047088623,
-0.5769858956336975,
-0.07503316551446915,
0.09420093148946762,
0.28412675857543945,
-0.07596775144338608,
0.3141627311706543,
0.12027410417795181,
0.2806244194507599,
0.43618422746658325,
-0.657690167427063,
0.8012251257896423,
0.3827505111694336,
-0.49247464537620544,
0.13216987252235413,
-0.5155602097511292,
-0.06187428534030914,
-0.10530257970094681,
0.08811899274587631,
-0.9898685216903687,
-0.49016067385673523,
-0.068584144115448,
-0.6214781999588013,
0.4093085825443268,
-0.3340934216976166,
-0.5977839231491089,
-0.44020184874534607,
0.09726200252771378,
0.42190253734588623,
0.12180837243795395,
-0.34334930777549744,
0.6779217720031738,
0.48476311564445496,
-0.08538554608821869,
-0.6440110802650452,
-0.4086153507232666,
-0.06364326924085617,
0.0883852168917656,
-0.5464328527450562,
0.3483559489250183,
0.07333367317914963,
-0.15821850299835205,
0.5127130150794983,
0.14539697766304016,
-0.14238888025283813,
-0.05152887850999832,
0.4793601334095001,
0.11804623156785965,
0.03940077871084213,
0.6870235204696655,
-0.24013473093509674,
-0.0374717116355896,
0.09331605583429337,
-0.02932797744870186,
0.5249043703079224,
0.2208332121372223,
0.04191039130091667,
0.0024138744920492172,
0.03927905857563019,
0.6805061101913452,
-0.3189077079296112,
0.9957650303840637,
0.17384248971939087,
-0.6604399085044861,
-0.03971725329756737,
-0.4260875880718231,
-0.03671696037054062,
-0.34098219871520996,
0.503109872341156,
-0.5360221266746521,
-0.9213069677352905,
0.6944606900215149,
-0.2518460750579834,
-0.272396057844162,
0.4888682961463928,
-0.02635047398507595,
0.1156720295548439,
0.898448646068573,
0.6631901860237122,
-0.3834965229034424,
0.47832614183425903,
-0.31382960081100464,
0.2762925326824188,
-0.989983320236206,
-0.309007465839386,
-0.4530515670776367,
-0.047573503106832504,
-0.5180882215499878,
0.09496259689331055,
0.3198484182357788,
0.3460409939289093,
-0.3083304464817047,
0.6433000564575195,
-0.1818741112947464,
0.5436311960220337,
0.5005887746810913,
0.08185402303934097,
0.6076846122741699,
0.10469125211238861,
-0.28171294927597046,
0.10772751271724701,
-0.5044386982917786,
-0.02538231760263443,
0.9774467349052429,
0.13422369956970215,
0.5580583214759827,
-0.2146250605583191,
0.6105844378471375,
-0.03435544669628143,
0.42982980608940125,
-0.9056853652000427,
0.31542086601257324,
-0.0357690192759037,
-0.479619562625885,
-0.658096194267273,
-0.7573378086090088,
-1.1084142923355103,
-0.2673552632331848,
-0.2923199534416199,
-0.8208640813827515,
-0.23020419478416443,
0.009614821523427963,
-0.17387939989566803,
0.13830016553401947,
-0.38918349146842957,
0.9208554029464722,
0.22813589870929718,
-0.011480888351798058,
-0.09228350967168808,
-0.4996553063392639,
0.44762519001960754,
0.12856492400169373,
0.2104843109846115,
-0.3225001096725464,
0.47822654247283936,
0.8885507583618164,
-0.6926332116127014,
0.5964834690093994,
-0.10457110404968262,
0.17058750987052917,
0.24156343936920166,
0.09802687168121338,
0.8782749772071838,
0.04950134828686714,
-0.4119803011417389,
-0.3196442127227783,
-0.07571626454591751,
-0.09188740700483322,
-0.5420729517936707,
0.7171199321746826,
-0.8233815431594849,
-0.2509426474571228,
-0.07703246176242828,
-0.6954076290130615,
-0.5569187998771667,
0.5078037977218628,
0.2701631784439087,
0.6190635561943054,
-0.2234645038843155,
-0.02984890528023243,
0.4672360122203827,
0.2540864944458008,
0.17310522496700287,
0.2386746108531952,
-0.5317608118057251,
-0.5181639790534973,
0.6190992593765259,
0.4885783791542053,
0.25705358386039734,
0.26596325635910034,
0.07982072234153748,
-0.45171910524368286,
-0.3528946042060852,
-0.2227761447429657,
0.4805995523929596,
-0.7434443831443787,
-0.7560552954673767,
-0.7814341187477112,
-0.5418875813484192,
-0.5917916893959045,
0.3094165623188019,
-0.3469545543193817,
-0.4935254454612732,
0.007094886153936386,
-0.2663276493549347,
0.5488932728767395,
1.0553971529006958,
0.3890675902366638,
0.17753274738788605,
-0.7399566769599915,
0.28205329179763794,
0.4537642300128937,
0.7898749709129333,
0.20659470558166504,
-0.1888635754585266,
-0.4693610668182373,
-0.11959892511367798,
0.04113313555717468,
-0.8533796668052673,
0.031241826713085175,
0.33601805567741394,
0.39182502031326294,
0.20012642443180084,
0.39065688848495483,
0.671353816986084,
-0.5729482173919678,
0.13814783096313477,
0.2009810358285904,
-0.6444380879402161,
0.5495185256004333,
-0.3932487368583679,
0.10417114943265915,
0.4356003999710083,
0.43568146228790283,
-0.6021573543548584,
-0.39948463439941406,
-0.7093487977981567,
-0.7435399293899536,
0.5548206567764282,
0.03583041578531265,
-0.031569045037031174,
-0.0714767649769783,
0.4863987863063812,
-0.03312937915325165,
0.204594224691391,
-0.687210202217102,
-0.3679991364479065,
0.09687007963657379,
-0.07856927812099457,
-0.12780725955963135,
-0.39842942357063293,
-0.09887168556451797,
-0.48325589299201965,
0.7572717666625977,
-0.06507563591003418,
0.09090887010097504,
-0.03685618191957474,
0.1646994948387146,
-0.6115803718566895,
-0.011825231835246086,
-0.0773671418428421,
1.0989346504211426,
-0.19247347116470337,
0.0704549103975296,
-0.025423632934689522,
-0.09153523296117783,
-0.023708004504442215,
0.42181628942489624,
-0.15592247247695923,
0.16364391148090363,
0.4978189170360565,
0.6886463761329651,
0.06193624064326286,
-0.38743868470191956,
0.5457155704498291,
0.041551969945430756,
-0.12281404435634613,
-0.6507429480552673,
-0.10280501842498779,
0.6360882520675659,
0.20241908729076385,
0.06677281856536865,
0.05494280159473419,
0.05667293071746826,
-0.6335183382034302,
0.022107601165771484,
0.47247371077537537,
-0.5096078515052795,
-0.1300876885652542,
0.4394221305847168,
-0.019656378775835037,
-0.11281199753284454,
0.7843087315559387,
-0.5500110387802124,
-0.7567484378814697,
0.68345046043396,
0.6214585304260254,
0.41739416122436523,
-0.2012137770652771,
0.20032696425914764,
0.7604343295097351,
0.07236731052398682,
-0.271666944026947,
0.11827357858419418,
0.1963612586259842,
-1.039452314376831,
-0.8710471391677856,
-0.9054006934165955,
-0.5191620588302612,
0.11381076276302338,
-0.4267280101776123,
0.3228265047073364,
-0.5073730945587158,
-0.2027849406003952,
0.27194610238075256,
0.2982284128665924,
-0.8655595779418945,
0.3611816167831421,
-0.018650559708476067,
0.8575823903083801,
-0.8989700078964233,
1.2504929304122925,
0.8270838856697083,
-0.3976087272167206,
-1.4031972885131836,
-0.28933656215667725,
-0.5035104751586914,
-0.33464089035987854,
0.7099748253822327,
0.11999277770519257,
-0.014013968408107758,
0.047994181513786316,
-0.2868550419807434,
-1.2988578081130981,
1.0021957159042358,
0.49684324860572815,
-0.4608398377895355,
-0.007765723392367363,
0.17828616499900818,
0.36118143796920776,
-0.4910425543785095,
0.04449024796485901,
0.4322155714035034,
0.6824961304664612,
0.37547567486763,
-1.046862006187439,
0.34624752402305603,
-0.2396952211856842,
0.012064548209309578,
0.4803858995437622,
-0.3261743187904358,
0.9428095817565918,
-0.23749388754367828,
-0.1423867642879486,
0.15891975164413452,
0.774497389793396,
-0.03578097000718117,
0.19743046164512634,
0.5597468018531799,
0.5640904307365417,
1.0162183046340942,
-0.038793668150901794,
0.9949166774749756,
-0.33977073431015015,
0.5277374386787415,
1.446550726890564,
-0.32337650656700134,
0.8103492259979248,
-0.07543286681175232,
-0.5185957551002502,
0.6038230061531067,
0.5235583782196045,
0.043911390006542206,
0.3174057602882385,
-0.010478619486093521,
-0.0843140259385109,
-0.3842979669570923,
-0.5133473873138428,
-0.5585270524024963,
0.334337055683136,
0.3697018623352051,
-0.43540579080581665,
0.018442805856466293,
-0.3010847568511963,
0.17503207921981812,
0.07383294403553009,
-0.494138240814209,
0.7259670495986938,
-0.1044842004776001,
-0.8832705616950989,
0.37126705050468445,
-0.1919993907213211,
0.05079321935772896,
-0.4754386842250824,
-0.051436323672533035,
-0.03937188908457756,
0.2115352898836136,
-0.45298805832862854,
-0.9282419681549072,
0.26176390051841736,
-0.610541820526123,
-0.509162962436676,
0.2809862792491913,
1.0070520639419556,
-0.8324531316757202,
-0.6074635982513428,
0.746304452419281,
0.578300416469574,
-0.21836979687213898,
-0.39662569761276245,
0.045598387718200684,
-0.4470166265964508,
-0.15457704663276672,
-0.1040365919470787,
0.2115737348794937,
0.6752600073814392,
-0.031470976769924164,
0.669289231300354,
0.21568289399147034,
0.16445736587047577,
-0.10052244365215302,
0.05508407950401306,
1.1396856307983398,
-0.6428878307342529,
-0.13952654600143433,
-0.7034942507743835,
0.16929838061332703,
-0.23779737949371338,
-0.05423426628112793,
0.6535601615905762,
0.5484263300895691,
0.8021343350410461,
0.006182567216455936,
0.881680428981781,
-0.16683311760425568,
0.7470579147338867,
-0.32432541251182556,
0.48087647557258606,
-0.30125951766967773,
-0.07359060645103455,
-0.46378910541534424,
-1.2768620252609253,
-0.30848410725593567,
0.1963943988084793,
-0.3002168834209442,
-0.020884845405817032,
0.9312837719917297,
0.40708181262016296,
-0.007169872522354126,
-0.10897918045520782,
0.3529345393180847,
0.3679075241088867,
-0.11378193646669388,
0.5963991284370422,
0.7444511651992798,
-0.28662019968032837,
0.6818730235099792,
-0.6504239439964294,
-0.058668240904808044,
-0.09888261556625366,
-0.8578023910522461,
-1.0617884397506714,
-0.6777586340904236,
-0.33499354124069214,
-0.582144558429718,
-0.05340135842561722,
0.7786502838134766,
0.6572940349578857,
-0.6641665101051331,
-0.15230652689933777,
-0.02077317051589489,
0.5408763885498047,
-0.1625066101551056,
-0.19862151145935059,
0.4395890533924103,
-0.42323118448257446,
-0.45977190136909485,
0.16441743075847626,
-0.033024273812770844,
-0.16127611696720123,
0.05660077929496765,
-0.12002603709697723,
-0.3555777072906494,
-0.5683460831642151,
0.6031638979911804,
0.19396443665027618,
-0.3401549160480499,
-0.4774065911769867,
-0.25370487570762634,
0.03291882947087288,
-0.039421264082193375,
0.7490870356559753,
-0.9184706807136536,
0.45906883478164673,
0.6328825354576111,
0.28351765871047974,
0.56880784034729,
-0.04126882553100586,
0.7592023015022278,
-0.9529674053192139,
-0.10958141088485718,
0.07569706439971924,
0.7979797720909119,
0.5046225786209106,
-0.48217305541038513,
0.8637073040008545,
0.13534174859523773,
-0.45655620098114014,
-0.3891245424747467,
0.43488743901252747,
-0.8668831586837769,
-0.1922423392534256,
1.2477786540985107,
-0.4184724688529968,
-0.15709547698497772,
-0.19565318524837494,
0.10924486070871353,
0.6140438318252563,
-0.3790300488471985,
0.39342200756073,
0.6637599468231201,
-0.16839450597763062,
-0.01348179206252098,
-0.46917054057121277,
0.6573907136917114,
0.04606848210096359,
-0.4550876319408417,
0.3101508915424347,
0.4740263819694519,
0.40323010087013245,
0.33502042293548584,
0.6963402628898621,
0.06911461800336838,
0.027829959988594055,
-0.22943805158138275,
-0.05884462222456932,
-0.275495707988739,
-0.4347843825817108,
0.4206564426422119,
0.21472138166427612,
0.6359128952026367,
0.3143741488456726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02732v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02732v1
|
Recall Them All: Retrieval-Augmented Language Models for Long Object List Extraction from Long Documents
| 2024-05-04T18:32:08 | 2024-05-04T18:32:08 |
Sneha Singhania, Simon Razniewski, Gerhard Weikum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Methods for relation extraction from text mostly focus on high precision, at
the cost of limited recall. High recall is crucial, though, to populate long
lists of object entities that stand in a specific relation with a given
subject. Cues for relevant objects can be spread across many passages in long
texts. This poses the challenge of extracting long lists from long texts. We
present the L3X method which tackles the problem in two stages: (1)
recall-oriented generation using a large language model (LLM) with judicious
techniques for retrieval augmentation, and (2) precision-oriented
scrutinization to validate or prune candidates. Our L3X method outperforms
LLM-only generations by a substantial margin.
|
[
-0.21525532007217407,
-0.8008967041969299,
0.9384447932243347,
0.015851883217692375,
-0.09591804444789886,
-0.10372576862573624,
-0.18032416701316833,
-0.7615431547164917,
-0.011263387277722359,
0.9152525067329407,
-0.2829284965991974,
-0.32228341698646545,
-0.3840295374393463,
0.19180765748023987,
-0.8190136551856995,
0.9161880016326904,
-0.1530987024307251,
-0.6039426326751709,
-0.03202804923057556,
-0.05280408263206482,
-0.3116101622581482,
-0.7577317357063293,
-0.3285440504550934,
-0.26889702677726746,
0.6216922998428345,
0.5670580267906189,
0.5767755508422852,
0.8804833292961121,
0.40901830792427063,
0.17753253877162933,
-0.19684310257434845,
0.22915886342525482,
-0.5305235981941223,
0.2465367466211319,
-0.4060647189617157,
-0.4979932904243469,
-0.4248145818710327,
-0.31803375482559204,
0.7959684729576111,
0.6621497273445129,
-0.08619822561740875,
-0.04598304629325867,
-0.037580206990242004,
0.7581368684768677,
-0.9407657980918884,
0.032588325440883636,
-0.6191455125808716,
-0.0969586968421936,
-0.35953986644744873,
-0.04424053430557251,
-0.6251129508018494,
-0.3176155686378479,
0.08594287931919098,
-0.5443711280822754,
0.24621401727199554,
0.17666691541671753,
0.6529563665390015,
-0.25409218668937683,
-0.3443542420864105,
-0.28743118047714233,
-1.0124306678771973,
0.9339403510093689,
-0.46000799536705017,
0.31499502062797546,
0.5645895004272461,
0.13596995174884796,
-0.11366334557533264,
-0.8600974082946777,
-0.40451791882514954,
-0.26187795400619507,
0.09697774797677994,
0.18143713474273682,
0.10721801966428757,
-0.13608959317207336,
0.5277808904647827,
0.4192701280117035,
-0.21269801259040833,
0.11278832703828812,
-0.5478634238243103,
0.0496680848300457,
0.7120887637138367,
-0.17076900601387024,
0.03302108496427536,
-0.3636450171470642,
-0.5143218040466309,
-0.1899852454662323,
-0.9625457525253296,
-0.3173506557941437,
0.18177376687526703,
0.38586679100990295,
0.5323836803436279,
0.6965701580047607,
-0.24907086789608002,
0.6639142036437988,
-0.04372180625796318,
-0.3417893648147583,
0.011450045742094517,
-0.24089224636554718,
0.007137094158679247,
0.1251411736011505,
0.7411661148071289,
0.1958862692117691,
0.38181284070014954,
-0.06509652733802795,
-0.3208273947238922,
-0.5107239484786987,
0.16043521463871002,
-0.5909750461578369,
0.11675087362527847,
0.17604279518127441,
-0.507540225982666,
0.02481859363615513,
-0.09432840347290039,
-0.7805054187774658,
-0.33674538135528564,
-0.19775336980819702,
0.42058321833610535,
-0.4580080211162567,
-0.2437371164560318,
0.10418777912855148,
0.03458256646990776,
0.11020756512880325,
0.27059897780418396,
-0.9803730249404907,
0.38661885261535645,
0.7471526861190796,
0.5547464489936829,
-0.42153310775756836,
-0.46906450390815735,
-0.7252277731895447,
0.6161655783653259,
-0.1818542331457138,
0.8208056688308716,
-0.5475993752479553,
-0.6579383611679077,
0.27972811460494995,
-0.053784336894750595,
0.31044986844062805,
-0.7072102427482605,
0.7008428573608398,
-0.46312326192855835,
0.08047354221343994,
-0.16782990097999573,
-0.8616984486579895,
-0.17851246893405914,
0.29196104407310486,
-1.0112440586090088,
1.3641413450241089,
0.23351667821407318,
-0.5226181745529175,
0.03208630159497261,
-0.21339300274848938,
-0.42245179414749146,
-0.05889996886253357,
-0.19734011590480804,
-0.5293070673942566,
0.055660828948020935,
0.3777923882007599,
0.9103984236717224,
-0.4914359748363495,
0.2492416501045227,
-0.3243900239467621,
-0.307708203792572,
-0.048418715596199036,
-0.23072071373462677,
0.4188025891780853,
0.1927841752767563,
-0.07340400665998459,
0.0749812126159668,
-0.8176031112670898,
-0.21798300743103027,
0.26195859909057617,
-0.32288694381713867,
-0.4608787000179291,
0.18551082909107208,
0.00233581755310297,
0.13284729421138763,
0.2485375851392746,
-0.34897246956825256,
0.3214733302593231,
-0.3812043070793152,
0.2014297991991043,
0.4840155243873596,
0.12817160785198212,
0.5773010849952698,
-0.26124098896980286,
0.27099576592445374,
0.03655974566936493,
-0.007265843916684389,
-0.5903905034065247,
-0.15929041802883148,
-0.5577898025512695,
-0.25558850169181824,
0.030118944123387337,
0.4902051091194153,
-0.6267890930175781,
0.5573115944862366,
-0.4643647074699402,
-0.413756787776947,
0.09771335124969482,
0.41506391763687134,
0.26064175367355347,
0.21572336554527283,
0.40045812726020813,
0.03195495158433914,
-0.4217017590999603,
-0.8705955743789673,
-0.2182692587375641,
-0.2112896740436554,
-0.09588836878538132,
0.23430445790290833,
0.5716722011566162,
0.012597485445439816,
0.8924583792686462,
-0.6390917301177979,
-0.24596746265888214,
-0.4292777478694916,
-0.006936646532267332,
0.1595882624387741,
0.39314621686935425,
0.42221835255622864,
-0.8037306666374207,
-0.27292877435684204,
0.042778048664331436,
-0.6888520121574402,
0.4484163820743561,
-0.2599281668663025,
-0.17669902741909027,
0.24703477323055267,
0.7746933698654175,
-0.7888262271881104,
0.4419097900390625,
-0.1769178807735443,
0.09233145415782928,
0.345337837934494,
-0.14439237117767334,
-0.1563560962677002,
-1.3302550315856934,
0.25165578722953796,
-0.05427742004394531,
-0.5403116345405579,
-0.4467112720012665,
0.2308371514081955,
0.512202799320221,
-0.20075377821922302,
-0.5507859587669373,
0.6790918707847595,
-0.803188145160675,
-0.2189350724220276,
-0.285260945558548,
0.6081179976463318,
0.14089611172676086,
0.22405633330345154,
0.2814469337463379,
0.4879770874977112,
0.2082623988389969,
-0.697451114654541,
0.591114342212677,
0.2023911476135254,
-0.3775167167186737,
0.5636825561523438,
-0.1763087660074234,
0.20066769421100616,
-0.2056315392255783,
0.24390755593776703,
-0.5687849521636963,
-0.07517701387405396,
0.06382156163454056,
-0.04593081399798393,
0.4567321538925171,
0.06577963382005692,
-0.5708726048469543,
-0.5160640478134155,
-0.3063531219959259,
0.3767545819282532,
0.3411220610141754,
-0.6760010719299316,
0.6893966197967529,
0.18654765188694,
-0.3677141070365906,
-0.8623771667480469,
-0.20470118522644043,
0.030616385862231255,
-0.2631591260433197,
-0.10773474723100662,
0.3482677638530731,
0.016325518488883972,
-0.3097500801086426,
-0.16819442808628082,
-0.13734278082847595,
0.020324809476733208,
0.09108246117830276,
0.05900963023304939,
0.3423219323158264,
0.0220202524214983,
0.2025313824415207,
-0.3577021658420563,
-0.07082539051771164,
-0.12356755137443542,
-0.11300984025001526,
0.40539315342903137,
0.1860722303390503,
-0.34742048382759094,
-0.0801285058259964,
0.745576798915863,
0.545648455619812,
-0.30637097358703613,
0.35019367933273315,
0.2913815379142761,
-0.7534313797950745,
0.06072632595896721,
-1.0941661596298218,
-0.09775277972221375,
-0.3398871421813965,
0.7042034268379211,
-0.5096633434295654,
-0.7246280312538147,
0.5405845046043396,
0.025997892022132874,
0.1249924823641777,
0.45639315247535706,
0.23449797928333282,
0.20927640795707703,
0.9140430688858032,
0.5744155645370483,
-0.5826523303985596,
0.3960060775279999,
-0.11602740734815598,
0.04557742923498154,
-0.9415770173072815,
-0.1405724138021469,
-0.664970874786377,
0.1535700410604477,
-0.2223781794309616,
-0.3110432028770447,
0.007634364999830723,
0.43311208486557007,
-0.15557216107845306,
0.3626495599746704,
-0.30253472924232483,
0.7470251321792603,
0.5946986079216003,
0.2022244930267334,
0.40310147404670715,
0.13942182064056396,
0.4210212528705597,
0.1947518289089203,
-0.2552849352359772,
-0.3603808879852295,
1.2187856435775757,
0.3173753619194031,
0.5676217079162598,
0.044758040457963943,
1.052431583404541,
-0.1393984854221344,
0.43576446175575256,
-1.038956642150879,
0.7432615160942078,
-0.23589198291301727,
-0.7299805283546448,
-0.2809142768383026,
-0.2634006142616272,
-1.0454990863800049,
-0.08937826752662659,
-0.19632479548454285,
-0.9541543126106262,
0.09496792405843735,
-0.15163679420948029,
-0.4888943135738373,
0.3737102448940277,
-0.19081874191761017,
0.36866477131843567,
-0.2637360692024231,
-0.6862130761146545,
-0.22717581689357758,
-0.6095770597457886,
0.5339478850364685,
-0.42801162600517273,
0.14175555109977722,
-0.13102957606315613,
-0.03237351030111313,
0.6958258748054504,
-0.14947766065597534,
0.49172064661979675,
0.0577942319214344,
-0.3372393250465393,
0.38091033697128296,
0.20088313519954681,
0.9989456534385681,
-0.09834630787372589,
-0.3503437936306,
-0.199485182762146,
-0.01809220016002655,
-0.32455670833587646,
-0.6074584722518921,
0.8595496416091919,
-0.484607458114624,
-0.5996871590614319,
-0.4206416606903076,
-0.4941207766532898,
-0.09495273232460022,
0.4617666006088257,
0.019950632005929947,
0.19219312071800232,
-0.18792003393173218,
0.33290934562683105,
0.5922045707702637,
-0.06850220263004303,
0.5890246033668518,
0.37102314829826355,
-0.5887914896011353,
-0.47250884771347046,
0.851112425327301,
0.16567224264144897,
0.28967049717903137,
0.5193573832511902,
-0.07766567915678024,
-0.35215333104133606,
-0.4048646092414856,
-0.26252543926239014,
0.3338274657726288,
-0.7655121088027954,
-0.2747131586074829,
-0.48930323123931885,
-0.19319728016853333,
-0.18765079975128174,
0.014520920813083649,
-0.4485832750797272,
-0.4179493486881256,
-0.49338236451148987,
-0.07955478131771088,
0.4185144007205963,
0.809722900390625,
0.07262521982192993,
0.3030106723308563,
-1.160398244857788,
0.5995346903800964,
0.26261433959007263,
0.1617620289325714,
-0.08350646495819092,
-0.11114021390676498,
-0.2827865183353424,
-0.15009154379367828,
-0.30284255743026733,
-0.9638208746910095,
0.4148724675178528,
0.11316712200641632,
0.5070757269859314,
0.4760230481624603,
-0.11897549778223038,
0.7525739073753357,
-0.5790207386016846,
0.8236187696456909,
0.2470017969608307,
-0.7521100044250488,
0.6463148593902588,
-0.3628663122653961,
-0.013459710404276848,
0.3404208719730377,
0.4114758372306824,
-0.41881263256073,
0.04094040393829346,
-0.7627429366111755,
-1.0415654182434082,
0.674071729183197,
0.07726427167654037,
-0.06285476684570312,
-0.45023030042648315,
0.9093593955039978,
0.08785106986761093,
-0.06768650561571121,
-0.670650064945221,
-0.05574939027428627,
0.15532150864601135,
-0.2711506485939026,
-0.201729416847229,
-0.6407945156097412,
-0.15067926049232483,
0.14262942969799042,
0.6147328019142151,
-0.1128922626376152,
-0.006483281496912241,
0.32925310730934143,
-0.2262878566980362,
0.04375556856393814,
0.2764469087123871,
0.5848188996315002,
0.9618737101554871,
-0.40349167585372925,
0.03189752250909805,
0.14850853383541107,
-0.4656960964202881,
0.11433915048837662,
0.1428384780883789,
-0.054567158222198486,
-0.08952705562114716,
0.3070208430290222,
0.4908759593963623,
0.27953946590423584,
-0.6601249575614929,
0.509437620639801,
0.17438988387584686,
-0.19228076934814453,
-0.5505276322364807,
-0.1903519481420517,
0.02051706425845623,
0.169380784034729,
0.5275965332984924,
-0.3358024060726166,
0.17334093153476715,
-0.6679288744926453,
0.21421769261360168,
0.3085392415523529,
-0.14407049119472504,
0.007058670744299889,
0.4503996670246124,
0.12801620364189148,
-0.20323814451694489,
0.7828059792518616,
0.2156507670879364,
-0.23959095776081085,
0.3853890895843506,
0.8042060732841492,
0.7683956623077393,
-0.16672827303409576,
-0.14595192670822144,
0.5712104439735413,
0.021823763847351074,
-0.9857529401779175,
0.07921061664819717,
-0.24466347694396973,
-0.5010946393013,
-0.6301472783088684,
-0.3276631236076355,
-0.37206101417541504,
0.2133413553237915,
-0.996581494808197,
0.2560042142868042,
-0.3153866231441498,
0.003397593041881919,
-0.23322542011737823,
-0.005556567572057247,
-0.3477829694747925,
0.23697829246520996,
0.27536913752555847,
0.8887056112289429,
-0.5044623017311096,
0.9504096508026123,
0.14968067407608032,
-0.5000167489051819,
-0.7003474831581116,
-0.1288325935602188,
-0.32113155722618103,
-0.791394054889679,
0.8484096527099609,
0.2340809404850006,
-0.03143063560128212,
0.21329480409622192,
-0.47530436515808105,
-0.9751793742179871,
0.8968510031700134,
0.0855197086930275,
-1.0013580322265625,
-0.28896060585975647,
0.03844396397471428,
0.07953651994466782,
-0.16242863237857819,
0.2617090046405792,
0.8391850590705872,
0.2819160223007202,
-0.01527339406311512,
-0.8604567646980286,
0.09432011097669601,
-0.012889250181615353,
0.0022751535288989544,
0.5086084008216858,
-0.4341775178909302,
0.6950302720069885,
-0.08715945482254028,
-0.18381880223751068,
0.4718088209629059,
0.8477649092674255,
0.5191935300827026,
0.11654696613550186,
0.5274168252944946,
0.4355849027633667,
0.9201563596725464,
0.13417789340019226,
1.055203914642334,
-0.17655570805072784,
0.20788317918777466,
1.2579740285873413,
-0.6737446784973145,
1.279007077217102,
0.5595150589942932,
-0.09842495620250702,
0.09116243571043015,
0.4536295235157013,
0.22812244296073914,
0.11204804480075836,
0.13294313848018646,
-0.37890541553497314,
-0.28454723954200745,
0.09351211786270142,
-0.326740026473999,
0.28138816356658936,
0.5569035410881042,
-0.4730730950832367,
-0.01608625426888466,
0.13291093707084656,
0.20671239495277405,
0.23811456561088562,
-0.3620449900627136,
0.9124369621276855,
0.0708320289850235,
-0.9387718439102173,
0.613923966884613,
-0.19994497299194336,
0.33769962191581726,
-0.43500733375549316,
-0.27199700474739075,
-0.17778834700584412,
0.37018635869026184,
0.008410428650677204,
-0.8448917269706726,
-0.0016032226849347353,
-0.1774291694164276,
-0.42004871368408203,
-0.09414023905992508,
0.7742370367050171,
-0.4151068329811096,
-0.6122127771377563,
0.3054598569869995,
0.4629024863243103,
0.2921518385410309,
-0.3539249002933502,
-0.36230963468551636,
-0.02198355458676815,
0.16844139993190765,
-0.32957640290260315,
0.17870363593101501,
0.3458538055419922,
-0.4214487671852112,
0.6869240999221802,
0.5474972128868103,
0.2760748565196991,
-0.1502835750579834,
0.15571707487106323,
0.6532661318778992,
-1.0552799701690674,
-0.021765170618891716,
-1.0003525018692017,
0.2942377030849457,
-0.338297039270401,
0.044938813894987106,
0.5851694941520691,
0.8124101161956787,
0.6271770596504211,
-0.04676366597414017,
0.7559757232666016,
0.253502756357193,
0.9552367925643921,
-0.6068206429481506,
0.3259055018424988,
-0.5580012202262878,
0.2511994242668152,
-0.2227797955274582,
-1.4030011892318726,
-0.5299291610717773,
0.5402853488922119,
-0.12659363448619843,
-0.04439667612314224,
0.7510415315628052,
0.6519173979759216,
-0.07214856147766113,
-0.137435182929039,
0.21902519464492798,
0.20489847660064697,
0.47568464279174805,
0.6120127439498901,
0.9530688524246216,
-0.5707976222038269,
0.7753969430923462,
-0.41342929005622864,
-0.02568444237112999,
-0.392546147108078,
-0.9230690002441406,
-0.6844732165336609,
-0.45832374691963196,
-0.10574714839458466,
-0.4268166124820709,
0.12451177090406418,
0.8684172034263611,
0.4926125109195709,
-0.5326822996139526,
-0.30641019344329834,
0.13600312173366547,
0.0796724408864975,
-0.07854294031858444,
-0.13798639178276062,
0.664804220199585,
-0.1132718026638031,
-0.9919780492782593,
0.5335062742233276,
0.33357739448547363,
0.19349005818367004,
-0.16445527970790863,
0.11992928385734558,
-0.35465797781944275,
-0.2801819145679474,
0.7158998847007751,
0.5608435869216919,
-0.7041111588478088,
-0.49502184987068176,
0.04586169123649597,
-0.008916781283915043,
0.011046233586966991,
0.6805188655853271,
-0.8799080848693848,
0.34568676352500916,
0.46652713418006897,
0.3548746407032013,
0.778739333152771,
0.1800837516784668,
0.727047860622406,
-0.7420664429664612,
0.2752363085746765,
0.1841873973608017,
0.4190434217453003,
0.30462580919265747,
-0.27649399638175964,
0.5075303316116333,
0.03106083534657955,
-0.7140083312988281,
-0.973762571811676,
0.29426708817481995,
-1.0312743186950684,
-0.3378443717956543,
1.2689399719238281,
0.020070789381861687,
-0.3525985777378082,
-0.003945510368794203,
-0.6065940856933594,
0.2390514612197876,
-0.12388794124126434,
0.6634474396705627,
0.6127969026565552,
0.02216140367090702,
-0.22429348528385162,
-0.5374723076820374,
0.4789564311504364,
0.41160011291503906,
-0.7927076816558838,
0.3504374325275421,
0.5782639384269714,
0.14492112398147583,
0.44414594769477844,
0.4659876227378845,
-0.21896761655807495,
0.18976742029190063,
-0.33908161520957947,
0.28528350591659546,
0.1832168996334076,
-0.33194035291671753,
0.042565565556287766,
0.2264135777950287,
0.2368694543838501,
0.11615587770938873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02714v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02714v1
|
Beyond Relevance: Evaluate and Improve Retrievers on Perspective Awareness
| 2024-05-04T17:10:00 | 2024-05-04T17:10:00 |
Xinran Zhao, Tong Chen, Sihao Chen, Hongming Zhang, Tongshuang Wu
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
The task of Information Retrieval (IR) requires a system to identify relevant
documents based on users' information needs. In real-world scenarios,
retrievers are expected to not only rely on the semantic relevance between the
documents and the queries but also recognize the nuanced intents or
perspectives behind a user query. For example, when asked to verify a claim, a
retrieval system is expected to identify evidence from both supporting vs.
contradicting perspectives, for the downstream system to make a fair judgment
call. In this work, we study whether retrievers can recognize and respond to
different perspectives of the queries -- beyond finding relevant documents for
a claim, can retrievers distinguish supporting vs. opposing documents? We
reform and extend six existing tasks to create a benchmark for retrieval, where
we have diverse perspectives described in free-form text, besides root, neutral
queries. We show that current retrievers covered in our experiments have
limited awareness of subtly different perspectives in queries and can also be
biased toward certain perspectives. Motivated by the observation, we further
explore the potential to leverage geometric features of retriever
representation space to improve the perspective awareness of retrievers in a
zero-shot manner. We demonstrate the efficiency and effectiveness of our
projection-based methods on the same set of tasks. Further analysis also shows
how perspective awareness improves performance on various downstream tasks,
with 4.2% higher accuracy on AmbigQA and 29.9% more correlation with designated
viewpoints on essay writing, compared to non-perspective-aware baselines.
|
[
-0.2771260440349579,
-0.11247527599334717,
1.0084306001663208,
0.01750362105667591,
-0.07350217550992966,
-0.0732872411608696,
0.04098370298743248,
-0.731358528137207,
0.3178153336048126,
0.42168453335762024,
-0.14978131651878357,
-0.32186007499694824,
-0.6515353918075562,
0.01679963245987892,
-0.3716118037700653,
0.907753586769104,
0.07160860300064087,
-0.12283175438642502,
-0.40665486454963684,
-0.3244788944721222,
-0.5961952805519104,
-0.5072421431541443,
-0.24850153923034668,
-0.22585242986679077,
0.6535114645957947,
0.24591980874538422,
0.18872766196727753,
0.2655666470527649,
0.7646304965019226,
0.23134636878967285,
-0.02449052408337593,
-0.2129438817501068,
-0.5739534497261047,
0.46763673424720764,
-0.4993151128292084,
-0.7414010763168335,
-0.06821642071008682,
0.19158175587654114,
0.5542976260185242,
0.6052285432815552,
-0.10683012753725052,
0.33908310532569885,
0.30381935834884644,
1.0057883262634277,
-1.292184829711914,
-0.022777501493692398,
-0.690523624420166,
0.23994627594947815,
-0.3330337107181549,
-0.3618987202644348,
-0.5215340256690979,
-0.44183462858200073,
0.5010310411453247,
-0.8429849743843079,
0.40803399682044983,
0.022454144433140755,
0.7916309237480164,
0.1547936052083969,
-0.4994069039821625,
-0.05810919031500816,
-0.6307260394096375,
0.7742800712585449,
-0.22874116897583008,
0.6896971464157104,
0.17909084260463715,
0.4448793828487396,
0.16519425809383392,
-0.45204979181289673,
-0.22270219027996063,
-0.05408627167344093,
-0.17188028991222382,
0.45544132590293884,
-0.18321675062179565,
-0.13407999277114868,
0.5395984053611755,
0.5267594456672668,
-0.360578715801239,
-0.48777320981025696,
-0.13135065138339996,
-0.17333665490150452,
0.17813070118427277,
-0.20408101379871368,
-0.21059849858283997,
-0.3569009006023407,
-0.405022531747818,
-0.19734448194503784,
-0.46509841084480286,
0.17343246936798096,
0.22718626260757446,
0.16571366786956787,
0.40140700340270996,
0.6805000305175781,
-0.5782442092895508,
0.6698622703552246,
0.3682035207748413,
0.06689335405826569,
0.3949025869369507,
-0.060633350163698196,
-0.323068767786026,
-0.11021512746810913,
-0.015510340221226215,
0.617656946182251,
-0.24145115911960602,
-0.1608954519033432,
-0.13869702816009521,
-0.2887920141220093,
0.8127644658088684,
-0.5929692387580872,
0.035796891897916794,
-0.051453299820423126,
-0.800567626953125,
0.07594511657953262,
0.11029480397701263,
-0.6401422619819641,
-0.9865365624427795,
-0.3935721516609192,
0.6584665179252625,
-0.6555421352386475,
-0.4465688169002533,
-0.06784093379974365,
-0.5082398653030396,
0.5666444897651672,
0.774307131767273,
-0.2642534077167511,
0.07845043390989304,
0.5912755727767944,
0.6047036647796631,
0.24278849363327026,
0.20778070390224457,
-0.7163792848587036,
0.20112505555152893,
-0.22409860789775848,
0.9842869639396667,
-0.5548591613769531,
-0.27259916067123413,
-0.04694586247205734,
-0.28059104084968567,
-0.16334161162376404,
-0.6148397922515869,
0.694233238697052,
-0.7541396617889404,
0.3332763910293579,
-0.9846500158309937,
-0.4589100778102875,
-0.43785297870635986,
0.9007809162139893,
-0.5684733986854553,
0.9397484660148621,
0.16759759187698364,
-0.9258286952972412,
0.708416223526001,
-0.5230673551559448,
-0.23964618146419525,
0.2755873501300812,
-0.4453693926334381,
0.12167046964168549,
0.5644940137863159,
-0.04207965359091759,
0.012993508018553257,
-0.19658629596233368,
-0.11300098150968552,
-0.00015700195217505097,
-0.06611087918281555,
0.030011672526597977,
0.043798498809337616,
0.43736031651496887,
0.03822604939341545,
-0.297334760427475,
-0.18971948325634003,
-0.6444664001464844,
0.12274075299501419,
-0.24951785802841187,
-0.35701891779899597,
-0.9282281398773193,
0.191936194896698,
-0.21037554740905762,
0.242828369140625,
0.2254907488822937,
-0.7110168933868408,
-0.12494057416915894,
-0.45024627447128296,
-0.32564255595207214,
0.44509220123291016,
0.060777101665735245,
0.3884902596473694,
-0.26401442289352417,
0.4572436809539795,
0.15594366192817688,
0.014494532719254494,
-0.10457606613636017,
-0.17893460392951965,
-0.7208392024040222,
-0.07777100056409836,
0.06214737147092819,
0.6276610493659973,
-0.7547940015792847,
0.1815771758556366,
-0.3105336129665375,
-0.3319060206413269,
-0.4075765311717987,
-0.02217661216855049,
0.6739609837532043,
1.256874442100525,
0.5280389189720154,
-0.6790501475334167,
-0.5496205687522888,
-1.0042139291763306,
-0.8197782039642334,
-0.41274428367614746,
-0.3212002217769623,
0.6500924825668335,
0.2783414423465729,
0.5235102772712708,
0.8838247656822205,
-0.5309308767318726,
-0.6110413074493408,
-0.12504525482654572,
0.0726412981748581,
0.057807207107543945,
0.19597887992858887,
0.6219280958175659,
-1.1340668201446533,
-0.39511412382125854,
0.13608253002166748,
-1.0769072771072388,
0.014386356808245182,
-0.021727707237005234,
-0.3319303095340729,
-0.11116679757833481,
0.31470000743865967,
-0.41808226704597473,
0.6372899413108826,
-0.39695626497268677,
-0.32098066806793213,
0.14740562438964844,
-0.026032084599137306,
0.4092422425746918,
-0.7603108882904053,
0.4087306559085846,
0.343165785074234,
-0.10804440081119537,
-0.4302803575992584,
0.1981727033853531,
0.2762731611728668,
0.17991285026073456,
-0.42221546173095703,
0.32526329159736633,
-0.7604178786277771,
-0.19889812171459198,
-0.17938737571239471,
0.3774879276752472,
0.30327168107032776,
0.11933854222297668,
0.16198208928108215,
0.5507954955101013,
0.3629041612148285,
-0.38971009850502014,
-0.18348823487758636,
0.23063182830810547,
-0.4052109718322754,
1.1397873163223267,
-0.2699785828590393,
0.07843278348445892,
-0.5559975504875183,
0.19325999915599823,
-0.9269242882728577,
-0.07434535771608353,
0.20889638364315033,
-0.4908520579338074,
0.3707183599472046,
-0.14373742043972015,
-0.2581981122493744,
-0.28353172540664673,
-0.6402596831321716,
0.2555176019668579,
0.1381482630968094,
-0.3024803698062897,
0.9151061177253723,
0.2560003399848938,
0.08903411775827408,
-0.9447848200798035,
-0.5400298833847046,
0.28023767471313477,
-0.33892378211021423,
-0.1841871440410614,
0.34712713956832886,
0.25655168294906616,
-0.4008607566356659,
-0.1289205551147461,
-0.5270254611968994,
0.1338982880115509,
0.0014718117890879512,
0.19837956130504608,
0.06807068735361099,
-0.18075115978717804,
-0.0343746617436409,
-0.11686400324106216,
0.06765584647655487,
0.14677242934703827,
-0.38054633140563965,
0.019000601023435593,
-0.04148165136575699,
-0.48185795545578003,
-0.13477426767349243,
0.5447183847427368,
0.18601882457733154,
-0.4555076062679291,
0.6735426187515259,
0.1766037791967392,
-0.45562493801116943,
0.3955047130584717,
-1.0918127298355103,
0.02793838456273079,
-0.37522608041763306,
0.1664443016052246,
-0.5350815653800964,
-0.7450528740882874,
0.5813808441162109,
0.12646479904651642,
0.04079679399728775,
0.40950414538383484,
0.05855274572968483,
-0.05736663565039635,
0.8372644782066345,
1.1270231008529663,
0.07109137624502182,
0.7393734455108643,
0.0015571581898257136,
0.40498819947242737,
-1.332641363143921,
-0.7055806517601013,
-0.7675125598907471,
-0.37174391746520996,
-0.3706235885620117,
-0.37077581882476807,
0.44418779015541077,
0.16128721833229065,
0.06596893072128296,
0.37256717681884766,
-0.758493185043335,
0.4746120572090149,
0.5133529901504517,
0.3195159137248993,
0.43011993169784546,
-0.056555457413196564,
-0.24109983444213867,
-0.35760918259620667,
-0.13518142700195312,
-0.5265675783157349,
1.0093913078308105,
-0.08178582042455673,
0.41319540143013,
0.17938920855522156,
0.7891218066215515,
0.15122726559638977,
0.6330435872077942,
-0.8831667900085449,
0.48390522599220276,
0.043201152235269547,
-0.792809247970581,
0.1507830023765564,
-0.1862291693687439,
-0.5483652949333191,
0.6963039636611938,
0.041472177952528,
-1.1553970575332642,
0.6798208355903625,
0.03002852387726307,
-0.5132526755332947,
0.000721562362741679,
-0.7418745756149292,
0.6020509600639343,
-0.06118224561214447,
-0.5250635743141174,
-0.26553353667259216,
-0.9493343234062195,
0.03169071674346924,
0.1504351943731308,
-0.12484799325466156,
-0.001544754602946341,
-0.14392732083797455,
0.48496532440185547,
-0.03458460792899132,
0.48768606781959534,
-0.5351406335830688,
-0.07130534946918488,
0.2457892894744873,
0.17775581777095795,
-0.03476276621222496,
0.0004465690581128001,
-0.6011034846305847,
-0.24478524923324585,
-0.11490307748317719,
-0.18081653118133545,
-0.6599543690681458,
0.47596439719200134,
-0.3555775582790375,
-1.0890192985534668,
-0.523171603679657,
-0.433391273021698,
-0.2714836299419403,
0.543755054473877,
0.08416160196065903,
0.2836073637008667,
-0.3649972379207611,
0.41949647665023804,
0.9589603543281555,
-0.07215970754623413,
0.196274071931839,
0.7388502359390259,
-0.019734473899006844,
0.011532006785273552,
0.5280444622039795,
0.26364800333976746,
-0.15531133115291595,
1.1074614524841309,
-0.2128731906414032,
-0.4340617060661316,
-0.4404478371143341,
-0.18536220490932465,
-0.10283847153186798,
-0.7821971774101257,
-0.5859274864196777,
-0.8622026443481445,
-0.06900044530630112,
-0.38100355863571167,
-0.02449914999306202,
-0.05250518023967743,
-0.43225276470184326,
-0.20648959279060364,
-0.13091698288917542,
0.04901517927646637,
0.335823655128479,
-0.0923357829451561,
-0.030824944376945496,
-0.5379113554954529,
0.3157688081264496,
0.2306872457265854,
0.3905552923679352,
0.06359697878360748,
-0.44459566473960876,
-0.21536590158939362,
-0.17048907279968262,
-0.6617211699485779,
-0.8363566398620605,
0.13667918741703033,
-0.013693665154278278,
0.8049609065055847,
0.4338950514793396,
0.18150389194488525,
0.6303594708442688,
-0.4236796796321869,
0.524340808391571,
-0.029672587290406227,
-0.803655207157135,
1.0013244152069092,
-0.20647430419921875,
0.03135701268911362,
0.9569095373153687,
0.45378026366233826,
-0.343224436044693,
-0.431179404258728,
-0.3599936068058014,
-0.7769031524658203,
0.8188952803611755,
0.2952772080898285,
-0.08754926174879074,
-0.003034172346815467,
0.7165661454200745,
0.045585453510284424,
0.45027363300323486,
-0.5030338764190674,
0.07669000327587128,
-0.5627272725105286,
0.12445195764303207,
0.36030760407447815,
-0.21240347623825073,
-0.20820516347885132,
-0.08796849846839905,
0.41535359621047974,
-0.2607707679271698,
0.24723932147026062,
0.6873103976249695,
-0.24668444693088531,
0.06530069559812546,
0.45426321029663086,
0.17732740938663483,
0.7587381601333618,
-0.462104856967926,
0.18939051032066345,
-0.16539624333381653,
-0.5020679235458374,
-0.06810016185045242,
0.4933891296386719,
-0.2871552109718323,
-0.09296572208404541,
0.06645485758781433,
0.32716843485832214,
-0.005131726153194904,
-0.42501118779182434,
0.6121594905853271,
-0.30888596177101135,
0.04172242432832718,
-0.22174376249313354,
0.10167393088340759,
-0.24800966680049896,
0.5010588765144348,
0.8016112446784973,
0.2966596484184265,
0.7815920114517212,
-0.3961666524410248,
-0.07253890484571457,
0.6901208162307739,
-0.5767406225204468,
-0.17241039872169495,
0.7365951538085938,
0.12588319182395935,
-0.017369532957673073,
0.5304156541824341,
0.13236349821090698,
-0.35392510890960693,
0.5179922580718994,
0.24548855423927307,
0.9593192338943481,
-0.0653955340385437,
-0.01278788410127163,
0.18608416616916656,
0.24624210596084595,
-0.008106216788291931,
0.25685447454452515,
-0.5465825796127319,
-0.7085685729980469,
-0.12074879556894302,
-0.5373764038085938,
-0.3045385777950287,
0.04158201068639755,
-1.1603419780731201,
0.03095257095992565,
-0.2931051254272461,
-0.318447083234787,
0.19218692183494568,
0.2676996886730194,
-0.6197077035903931,
0.30766889452934265,
0.06176750734448433,
1.13289213180542,
-0.4304516613483429,
0.46760743856430054,
1.1260508298873901,
-0.617336094379425,
-0.46457144618034363,
0.4325353801250458,
0.20789727568626404,
-0.561677873134613,
0.6111813187599182,
0.5550855398178101,
-0.573275625705719,
-0.3134203553199768,
-0.3420239984989166,
-0.8990049362182617,
1.0171513557434082,
0.46535763144493103,
-0.2631493806838989,
-0.04915182292461395,
-0.19180341064929962,
0.7818692326545715,
-0.24029356241226196,
0.48229122161865234,
0.3018185794353485,
0.28214308619499207,
0.24900583922863007,
-0.7458099722862244,
0.022455262020230293,
-0.38934966921806335,
0.3265727162361145,
0.20949174463748932,
-0.6639783382415771,
0.44680219888687134,
-0.10725221037864685,
-0.2840992212295532,
0.03389502316713333,
0.7122799158096313,
0.24721087515354156,
0.41035082936286926,
0.5276691913604736,
0.5010197162628174,
0.7431368827819824,
0.06933892518281937,
1.075085163116455,
-0.07191470265388489,
0.11509555578231812,
0.9977712035179138,
-0.7529004812240601,
0.8568979501724243,
0.7525272965431213,
0.2144879251718521,
0.7114743590354919,
0.27769702672958374,
0.34249821305274963,
0.7644962072372437,
-0.10087581723928452,
-0.3944697678089142,
-0.3777904212474823,
-0.49601560831069946,
-0.5695937275886536,
0.3311370611190796,
0.46290069818496704,
-0.3845979571342468,
-0.47779297828674316,
-0.030933497473597527,
-0.19422248005867004,
0.376041978597641,
-0.24477629363536835,
0.874199390411377,
0.04238086938858032,
-0.7338702082633972,
0.13167567551136017,
-0.15828175842761993,
0.4993270933628082,
-0.27210021018981934,
-0.0014466759748756886,
-0.23172347247600555,
0.5279833078384399,
-0.3440946340560913,
-0.9825132489204407,
0.37009134888648987,
0.02339843474328518,
-0.6178783774375916,
-0.47321856021881104,
0.9823672771453857,
0.0927470251917839,
-0.36668094992637634,
0.36237865686416626,
0.7243410348892212,
0.027256891131401062,
-0.4612346589565277,
-0.47591733932495117,
-0.2027517706155777,
0.05361621826887131,
-0.4220367670059204,
0.4824414849281311,
0.7557277679443359,
-0.2765864431858063,
0.3753829300403595,
0.18618044257164001,
-0.19996494054794312,
-0.2302694171667099,
0.20310470461845398,
1.0112409591674805,
-0.6841365098953247,
-0.33113911747932434,
-0.5086894035339355,
0.4060468077659607,
-0.4135550856590271,
-0.16651742160320282,
0.9160506129264832,
0.8981538414955139,
0.9316017031669617,
0.023548657074570656,
0.7117467522621155,
-0.5130109786987305,
0.9810624718666077,
-0.09843479096889496,
0.541934072971344,
-0.8246380686759949,
0.12291240692138672,
-0.3720884323120117,
-0.8856306076049805,
-0.42181527614593506,
0.8711274862289429,
-0.5768946409225464,
0.08960447460412979,
0.4662628769874573,
0.48653918504714966,
-0.12866893410682678,
-0.0161894541233778,
0.07520944625139236,
0.0013658993411809206,
0.2956080734729767,
0.5909240245819092,
0.9577176570892334,
-0.5184632539749146,
0.5956637263298035,
-0.14678795635700226,
-0.33997437357902527,
-0.0795096904039383,
-0.9081859588623047,
-0.6579044461250305,
-0.40527963638305664,
-0.2766004502773285,
-0.18866944313049316,
0.11485264450311661,
0.3405172824859619,
0.5649164915084839,
-0.5173313617706299,
-0.047992195934057236,
0.08457571268081665,
0.1756817102432251,
-0.1712176352739334,
-0.28108757734298706,
-0.05580701306462288,
-0.3599596619606018,
-0.27963507175445557,
0.15790076553821564,
0.5722628235816956,
-0.33699461817741394,
0.16255824267864227,
0.44193771481513977,
-0.35994577407836914,
-0.09012763202190399,
0.8016743659973145,
0.4103831946849823,
-0.5711371302604675,
-0.5864386558532715,
0.32982173562049866,
-0.03133219853043556,
0.5294978022575378,
1.0226730108261108,
-1.2623143196105957,
0.46079644560813904,
0.46096712350845337,
0.5728757381439209,
0.6069308519363403,
0.24088218808174133,
0.37002506852149963,
-0.8832444548606873,
-0.02834569290280342,
0.4975535273551941,
0.12952002882957458,
0.5960890650749207,
-0.6623667478561401,
0.48638972640037537,
0.04522983357310295,
-0.2895204424858093,
-0.6447846293449402,
0.08285898715257645,
-0.7662541270256042,
0.07433975487947464,
0.6198369264602661,
-0.25254136323928833,
-0.04185711219906807,
-0.04308526962995529,
-0.16294769942760468,
0.22187590599060059,
-0.46532389521598816,
0.9467040300369263,
0.6775619983673096,
-0.5988070964813232,
-0.11831283569335938,
-0.5645778179168701,
0.2249472439289093,
0.5852862596511841,
-0.8266850113868713,
0.0472915880382061,
0.8189941048622131,
0.3102433681488037,
0.6132171750068665,
0.8862296342849731,
-0.4491766691207886,
0.12091197073459625,
-0.3315447270870209,
-0.14182691276073456,
0.6265381574630737,
-0.36480867862701416,
-0.08529430627822876,
0.27347108721733093,
0.06928189098834991,
-0.1485006958246231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02712v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02712v1
|
CoE-SQL: In-Context Learning for Multi-Turn Text-to-SQL with Chain-of-Editions
| 2024-05-04T16:56:14 | 2024-05-04T16:56:14 |
Hanchong Zhang, Ruisheng Cao, Hongshen Xu, Lu Chen, Kai Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have been demonstrated to possess
impressive capabilities in a variety of domains and tasks. We investigate the
issue of prompt design in the multi-turn text-to-SQL task and attempt to
enhance the LLMs' reasoning capacity when generating SQL queries. In the
conversational context, the current SQL query can be modified from the
preceding SQL query with only a few operations due to the context dependency.
We introduce our method called CoE-SQL which can prompt LLMs to generate the
SQL query based on the previously generated SQL query with an edition chain. We
also conduct extensive ablation studies to determine the optimal configuration
of our approach. Our approach outperforms different in-context learning
baselines stably and achieves state-of-the-art performances on two benchmarks
SParC and CoSQL using LLMs, which is also competitive to the SOTA fine-tuned
models.
|
[
-0.45214971899986267,
-0.9856077432632446,
0.6800239682197571,
0.2680237889289856,
-0.38011518120765686,
0.08422128856182098,
-0.42137962579727173,
-0.2152007669210434,
-0.1686393767595291,
0.774898111820221,
-0.9435116648674011,
-0.6106702089309692,
-0.06069144234061241,
0.45736223459243774,
-0.25564250349998474,
0.9254973530769348,
0.28674301505088806,
0.22882047295570374,
-0.5095431804656982,
-0.3451313376426697,
-0.6551504135131836,
-0.8473798632621765,
-0.6781294941902161,
-0.15560199320316315,
0.4731013774871826,
0.5431007742881775,
0.255720317363739,
0.16153351962566376,
0.08685492724180222,
0.2468450963497162,
-0.20107927918434143,
0.655521810054779,
-0.43475425243377686,
0.6161168813705444,
-0.32928550243377686,
-0.33321332931518555,
-0.32680854201316833,
-0.3649040758609772,
0.6966888904571533,
0.6970630884170532,
-0.2295343577861786,
-0.32063037157058716,
0.22780603170394897,
0.8334882259368896,
-0.4886666536331177,
-0.35722872614860535,
-0.9806723594665527,
-0.29912689328193665,
0.07899162173271179,
-0.4179195463657379,
-1.0313833951950073,
-0.16495557129383087,
0.1341198980808258,
-0.47948190569877625,
0.06615868210792542,
0.642038106918335,
0.36405402421951294,
0.08010422438383102,
-0.6770910024642944,
-0.6520097255706787,
-0.4531060755252838,
0.7748276591300964,
-0.38684359192848206,
0.5845540165901184,
-0.21580354869365692,
0.19646558165550232,
-0.4615718126296997,
-0.5795993208885193,
-0.38073766231536865,
-0.31833529472351074,
-0.09979061782360077,
-0.07742750644683838,
0.31416094303131104,
-0.11929634213447571,
0.2848060131072998,
0.1848333179950714,
-0.4788684546947479,
0.1612371951341629,
-0.007410061080008745,
0.15215829014778137,
0.6016871929168701,
0.33979082107543945,
0.10260084271430969,
0.040046170353889465,
-0.7446292042732239,
0.1973223090171814,
-1.222804069519043,
-0.13394133746623993,
0.040139149874448776,
0.7800692915916443,
0.04343719780445099,
0.6029275059700012,
-0.017247162759304047,
0.9957694411277771,
0.1694546341896057,
0.16376382112503052,
-0.08103179931640625,
-0.37432458996772766,
-0.22497253119945526,
0.10795249789953232,
0.7160820960998535,
0.14524796605110168,
-0.03401653841137886,
-0.1696484535932541,
-0.17573311924934387,
-0.2130884826183319,
0.14378228783607483,
-0.7389687299728394,
0.3064415156841278,
0.2571532428264618,
-0.04156716912984848,
0.09478305280208588,
-0.17752613127231598,
-0.7505507469177246,
-0.5492662787437439,
-0.5943446159362793,
0.16502854228019714,
-0.5543390512466431,
-0.06363976746797562,
-0.17143352329730988,
0.11686212569475174,
0.315312922000885,
0.46414947509765625,
-0.758282482624054,
0.39248576760292053,
0.4969814121723175,
0.7464914917945862,
-0.7308634519577026,
-0.17484423518180847,
-0.8227560520172119,
0.32326287031173706,
-0.2787206768989563,
0.8088566064834595,
-0.5057573914527893,
-0.6474654674530029,
0.13716663420200348,
0.03169567510485649,
-0.03181165084242821,
-0.5467718243598938,
0.16737259924411774,
-0.6539715528488159,
0.21577668190002441,
-0.49039822816848755,
-0.6869871020317078,
0.29764559864997864,
0.3575437664985657,
-0.38471052050590515,
1.0690361261367798,
0.06158361956477165,
-0.595859944820404,
0.27766674757003784,
-0.6178419589996338,
-0.729941189289093,
0.03986850008368492,
-0.36052200198173523,
-0.2695158123970032,
0.008391563780605793,
0.30214592814445496,
0.2852875590324402,
-0.30088698863983154,
0.18021026253700256,
-0.06698783487081528,
-0.2087102085351944,
0.33185720443725586,
-0.07857310026884079,
0.8143256306648254,
0.21609918773174286,
-0.09094953536987305,
0.21433164179325104,
-0.6049944162368774,
-0.23366253077983856,
-0.017108310014009476,
-0.362739235162735,
-0.3543059229850769,
0.023464903235435486,
-0.1640026569366455,
0.2827428877353668,
0.08978600054979324,
-0.32175377011299133,
0.45143961906433105,
-0.44730761647224426,
0.31073758006095886,
0.6009111404418945,
0.21938498318195343,
0.6982990503311157,
0.02371382713317871,
0.21475014090538025,
0.23401688039302826,
0.09018716961145401,
-0.3673386871814728,
-0.20872119069099426,
-0.7021849155426025,
-0.22713707387447357,
0.042542465031147,
0.4783519506454468,
-0.9953567981719971,
0.2895107567310333,
0.233051136136055,
-0.27161017060279846,
0.07713231444358826,
0.043467309325933456,
0.28350263833999634,
0.4859941303730011,
0.5542459487915039,
0.0069024586118757725,
-0.45410576462745667,
-0.41936150193214417,
-0.630744993686676,
0.12253909558057785,
0.19585302472114563,
0.7313143610954285,
0.3741261065006256,
-0.06611602753400803,
1.034956932067871,
-0.5403727889060974,
-0.3578999936580658,
-0.39952003955841064,
-0.05199270695447922,
0.15066252648830414,
0.3748508393764496,
0.3493362367153168,
-0.5720583200454712,
-0.510628879070282,
0.021662745624780655,
-0.6977921724319458,
0.036509063094854355,
-0.22671112418174744,
-0.3563457131385803,
0.8268167972564697,
0.7408866882324219,
-0.2984251081943512,
0.028582951053977013,
0.25390535593032837,
-0.418613076210022,
0.6909928321838379,
-0.27340421080589294,
0.1420086920261383,
-1.1007144451141357,
-0.2535669803619385,
0.08370538800954819,
-0.08555109053850174,
-0.5500208139419556,
-0.1124030351638794,
0.0331672839820385,
-0.20699389278888702,
-0.6123233437538147,
0.6245802640914917,
-0.6336957216262817,
-0.12973619997501373,
-0.029599767178297043,
0.35679540038108826,
0.14200159907341003,
0.550112247467041,
0.28248530626296997,
1.0180109739303589,
0.41289329528808594,
-1.0329360961914062,
0.1471864879131317,
0.41292890906333923,
-0.25758203864097595,
0.9428461790084839,
-0.5480895042419434,
0.29195961356163025,
-0.11865667998790741,
0.4068463444709778,
-1.0785837173461914,
-0.10521476715803146,
-0.11387273669242859,
-0.29104694724082947,
0.22370050847530365,
-0.1763191819190979,
-0.3576156198978424,
-0.02887929603457451,
0.04715632647275925,
0.10811089724302292,
0.2792242765426636,
-0.8923124074935913,
0.6984637975692749,
0.10181869566440582,
-0.16480083763599396,
-0.5522359013557434,
-0.6313830614089966,
0.015888841822743416,
-0.24688975512981415,
-0.5408874750137329,
0.5762081146240234,
-0.10399504750967026,
-0.29739826917648315,
-0.44970861077308655,
-0.030505187809467316,
-0.015777308493852615,
-0.14659881591796875,
-0.1679263412952423,
0.4983541667461395,
0.01621905528008938,
0.2879631519317627,
0.38051220774650574,
0.08227600902318954,
0.017333419993519783,
-0.29124772548675537,
0.5928025245666504,
-0.012789286673069,
-0.23692113161087036,
-0.15816740691661835,
0.7551733255386353,
0.45835167169570923,
-0.1519508957862854,
0.8819572329521179,
0.10837729275226593,
-0.16167108714580536,
-0.5384612679481506,
-0.4740649461746216,
-0.41686132550239563,
-0.48814985156059265,
0.18093393743038177,
-0.5896488428115845,
-0.9461914896965027,
0.3339424431324005,
-0.548884391784668,
0.18661393225193024,
0.2636735141277313,
0.7701454758644104,
-0.14721879363059998,
1.0013076066970825,
0.3841245770454407,
0.35716527700424194,
0.730277419090271,
-0.12028486281633377,
0.09289911389350891,
-0.9198920726776123,
-0.46600738167762756,
-0.7773926854133606,
0.42494961619377136,
-0.29763710498809814,
-0.15480022132396698,
0.6537915468215942,
-0.02964087761938572,
-0.5002409815788269,
0.28258344531059265,
-0.6156383752822876,
0.49430614709854126,
0.3181877136230469,
0.3263966143131256,
0.46823763847351074,
0.19235487282276154,
-0.3809095323085785,
0.10196422785520554,
-0.7182319760322571,
-0.33823487162590027,
0.7338801622390747,
-0.28037822246551514,
0.8053560853004456,
0.16677771508693695,
0.7333413362503052,
0.24579471349716187,
0.10359891504049301,
-0.5637564659118652,
0.5135830640792847,
-0.1004723310470581,
-0.41383638978004456,
-0.2858056426048279,
-0.4125851094722748,
-0.7743969559669495,
0.26758065819740295,
-0.2501474916934967,
-0.5752598643302917,
0.07004754990339279,
0.10243739187717438,
-0.21611303091049194,
-0.09973528981208801,
-0.7632536888122559,
0.8031970262527466,
-0.33944767713546753,
-0.7445231080055237,
-0.15178096294403076,
-0.6672216653823853,
0.20903320610523224,
0.2593790292739868,
0.2698798179626465,
0.13423915207386017,
-0.2091166228055954,
0.3049885630607605,
-0.4234795570373535,
0.6677337288856506,
-0.26178357005119324,
-0.1666787713766098,
0.45087817311286926,
0.03253499045968056,
0.8188778162002563,
0.2433287799358368,
-0.49767857789993286,
-0.3591943085193634,
-0.21119697391986847,
-0.07036446034908295,
-0.6741421818733215,
0.6954687833786011,
-0.4602603316307068,
-0.6619061827659607,
-0.33043232560157776,
-0.4042993485927582,
-0.3628953993320465,
0.07657502591609955,
0.3873327672481537,
0.7384638786315918,
-0.397247314453125,
0.0332355722784996,
0.8666200637817383,
-0.352925568819046,
0.35492926836013794,
0.36827439069747925,
-0.1150793731212616,
-0.33845457434654236,
0.6645609140396118,
0.03780021145939827,
0.4648887813091278,
0.33536598086357117,
0.02014540322124958,
-0.8605731129646301,
-0.3839834928512573,
-0.727258563041687,
0.23102588951587677,
-0.763312816619873,
-0.2523801326751709,
-0.6632749438285828,
-0.07028193026781082,
-0.2795224189758301,
-0.3986421525478363,
-0.13854864239692688,
-0.11331784725189209,
-0.5174541473388672,
0.3115537762641907,
0.6578832864761353,
0.5837796330451965,
0.5458610653877258,
0.42185890674591064,
-0.5839059352874756,
0.006830695550888777,
0.17690902948379517,
0.24241378903388977,
-0.10877801477909088,
-0.5082430839538574,
-0.1313331127166748,
-0.263968288898468,
-0.4112616181373596,
-0.989486575126648,
0.23079992830753326,
0.2925466299057007,
0.5195059776306152,
0.0395185686647892,
0.4222303032875061,
0.46256205439567566,
-0.6470036506652832,
0.9056435823440552,
0.35889190435409546,
-0.9819214940071106,
0.7408324480056763,
-0.3160482943058014,
0.22169415652751923,
0.6318644285202026,
0.4150142967700958,
-0.43291765451431274,
-0.3029473125934601,
-0.6035387516021729,
-0.8179670572280884,
0.686028778553009,
-0.06802160292863846,
0.041011057794094086,
-0.2074255496263504,
0.42546164989471436,
0.316392183303833,
0.16987140476703644,
-0.45244407653808594,
-0.29271966218948364,
0.13046307861804962,
-0.04184131696820259,
0.2497202605009079,
-0.2484627664089203,
0.031416017562150955,
-0.2767619490623474,
0.7224327921867371,
-0.48589473962783813,
0.21671049296855927,
0.2644578218460083,
-0.2836836278438568,
0.3983677327632904,
0.5391098260879517,
0.5216905474662781,
0.8265244960784912,
0.05305459722876549,
0.06710927933454514,
0.5508087873458862,
0.04777882620692253,
0.10996093600988388,
-0.3780754506587982,
0.06499844044446945,
-0.07403945922851562,
-0.06180237978696823,
0.8204604387283325,
0.08708152174949646,
-0.5987846255302429,
0.41677039861679077,
-0.07655725628137589,
-0.10453717410564423,
-0.12836752831935883,
0.05580683425068855,
0.1658569723367691,
0.18355707824230194,
0.4518241286277771,
-0.024109072983264923,
0.19046179950237274,
-0.5826584100723267,
0.2613278925418854,
0.5025100708007812,
-0.3216184973716736,
0.09427846223115921,
0.3632638454437256,
0.3928673267364502,
-0.4406164884567261,
0.7713362574577332,
-0.20696568489074707,
-0.4313347041606903,
0.2926332950592041,
0.9658580422401428,
0.4868623614311218,
-0.3028244376182556,
-0.08468936383724213,
0.49323928356170654,
-0.038976170122623444,
-0.043734900653362274,
0.48305758833885193,
-0.12271837890148163,
-0.5550183653831482,
-0.44224196672439575,
-0.31530117988586426,
-0.6920777559280396,
-0.3608684837818146,
-0.5268288254737854,
0.6995498538017273,
-0.3144237995147705,
-0.03255358338356018,
-0.20327769219875336,
-0.06481657177209854,
-0.2910020351409912,
0.16911108791828156,
-0.20920391380786896,
1.0024884939193726,
-0.6257059574127197,
0.775970458984375,
0.5389149188995361,
-0.283012330532074,
-0.4634263813495636,
-0.22334378957748413,
-0.15614503622055054,
-0.46575188636779785,
0.21920758485794067,
0.08969470858573914,
-0.14522723853588104,
0.19110777974128723,
-0.6404890418052673,
-0.36834219098091125,
0.9287077784538269,
0.48027941584587097,
-0.6659018993377686,
0.08363083004951477,
0.02856694906949997,
0.259098619222641,
-0.8432020545005798,
0.16625717282295227,
0.7726817727088928,
0.1913105994462967,
0.46574801206588745,
-0.34860020875930786,
0.12907901406288147,
0.18566925823688507,
0.007905705831944942,
0.10971731692552567,
-0.5096754431724548,
0.7918563485145569,
-0.3636113405227661,
-0.1424238532781601,
-0.02665608935058117,
0.8470601439476013,
0.8217037320137024,
0.23558247089385986,
0.6351948976516724,
0.058278053998947144,
0.8297483325004578,
-0.14367876946926117,
0.9317557215690613,
-0.08579370379447937,
0.20950037240982056,
1.207810401916504,
-0.5343008041381836,
0.8147007822990417,
0.7968965768814087,
-0.0670192539691925,
0.7833453416824341,
0.6863560080528259,
0.3879890739917755,
0.5593897104263306,
0.2741056978702545,
-0.5266736149787903,
-0.36042264103889465,
-0.30110859870910645,
-0.29325640201568604,
0.010256274603307247,
0.6983135938644409,
-0.1639174371957779,
-0.13355468213558197,
0.13273875415325165,
0.006886613089591265,
0.26276084780693054,
-0.2413923740386963,
1.1327606439590454,
0.2175523042678833,
-0.8854435086250305,
0.5799462199211121,
-0.18195512890815735,
0.5795442461967468,
-0.46313557028770447,
-0.041577473282814026,
-0.3402729034423828,
0.135684072971344,
-0.24847716093063354,
-0.6585935950279236,
0.4258995056152344,
-0.0793706625699997,
-0.11653216183185577,
-0.036655597388744354,
0.5694675445556641,
-0.6816120743751526,
-0.30340906977653503,
0.26441407203674316,
0.5129815340042114,
0.02427433431148529,
-0.11906537413597107,
-0.6580314040184021,
0.2570354640483856,
-0.15445303916931152,
-0.20399296283721924,
0.3136400282382965,
0.6134085655212402,
-0.14568845927715302,
0.48514753580093384,
0.3965570628643036,
-0.2669169306755066,
-0.02555161342024803,
0.3473495841026306,
0.9118531346321106,
-0.4863181710243225,
-0.5417323112487793,
-1.0263242721557617,
0.4157886505126953,
-0.26485008001327515,
-0.1578991562128067,
0.5793964266777039,
0.6311327815055847,
0.49314430356025696,
-0.028699008747935295,
0.6735954880714417,
-0.10525846481323242,
0.321830689907074,
-0.7287643551826477,
0.25036948919296265,
-0.7217602729797363,
0.42382997274398804,
-0.2626200020313263,
-0.884506106376648,
-0.2989826798439026,
0.27269935607910156,
-0.1583515852689743,
0.06552208214998245,
1.0179340839385986,
0.9029316306114197,
0.30675452947616577,
0.2244613915681839,
0.12909848988056183,
-0.04425875470042229,
0.248411163687706,
0.5363718271255493,
0.9943691492080688,
-0.2722686231136322,
0.4551476538181305,
0.2875650227069855,
-0.32651305198669434,
-0.28396645188331604,
-0.9835472702980042,
-1.0793861150741577,
-0.8032556176185608,
-0.16258056461811066,
-0.6050360202789307,
0.17568433284759521,
1.2329384088516235,
0.6026435494422913,
-0.70661860704422,
-0.4240540564060211,
-0.1973744034767151,
0.5061447024345398,
-0.4010641276836395,
-0.1652645766735077,
0.44492998719215393,
-0.9244396090507507,
-0.7184014320373535,
0.5957146883010864,
0.24008527398109436,
-0.13427899777889252,
-0.19809888303279877,
-0.23804347217082977,
-0.47094985842704773,
0.16812534630298615,
0.9319396615028381,
-0.12340930849313736,
-0.5528009533882141,
-0.1686699390411377,
0.21952013671398163,
-0.16621816158294678,
0.2703166902065277,
1.077505350112915,
-0.7734114527702332,
0.10501866042613983,
0.4493231177330017,
0.6618731021881104,
0.7125938534736633,
0.014254582114517689,
0.6861913204193115,
-1.143507719039917,
0.05736356973648071,
0.1133134663105011,
0.28833210468292236,
0.38048654794692993,
-0.6613515019416809,
0.47310972213745117,
0.1471872627735138,
-0.5411204099655151,
-0.6899389028549194,
0.34804877638816833,
-1.0547828674316406,
-0.46845319867134094,
1.3476922512054443,
0.11179773509502411,
-0.36420738697052,
-0.3384723961353302,
-0.45828840136528015,
0.24200862646102905,
-0.5455183386802673,
0.2623375356197357,
0.3573814332485199,
-0.3849593698978424,
-0.1667693555355072,
0.0829458087682724,
0.5470846891403198,
0.23370510339736938,
-0.9440671801567078,
0.4461468756198883,
0.5731433033943176,
0.18395735323429108,
-0.233255073428154,
0.5931931138038635,
-0.22550727427005768,
0.04965702444314957,
-0.2397593855857849,
-0.13063636422157288,
0.022353364154696465,
-0.6817834973335266,
-0.1719343215227127,
0.2004643976688385,
0.1584412306547165,
0.1852409541606903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02710v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02710v1
|
Enhancing News Summarization with ELearnFit through Efficient In-Context Learning and Efficient Fine-Tuning
| 2024-05-04T16:48:05 | 2024-05-04T16:48:05 |
Che Guan, Andrew Chin, Puya Vahabi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the deluge of information delivered by the daily news cycle, there is a
growing need to effectively and efficiently summarize news feeds for quick
consumption. We leverage large language models (LLMs), with their advanced
learning and generative abilities as compared to conventional language models,
to generate concise and coherent summaries for news articles from the XSum
dataset. Our paper focuses on two key aspects of LLMs: Efficient in-context
Learning (ELearn) and Parameter Efficient Fine-tuning (EFit). Under ELearn, we
find that increasing the number of shots in prompts and utilizing simple
templates generally improve the quality of summaries. We also find that
utilizing relevant examples in few-shot learning for ELearn does not improve
model performance. In addition, we studied EFit using different methods and
demonstrate that fine-tuning the first layer of LLMs produces better outcomes
as compared to fine-tuning other layers or utilizing LoRA. We also find that
leveraging more relevant training samples using selective layers does not
result in better performance. By combining ELearn and EFit, we create a new
model (ELearnFit) that leverages the benefits of both few-shot learning and
fine-tuning and produces superior performance to either model alone. We also
use ELearnFit to highlight the trade-offs between prompting and fine-tuning,
especially for situations where only a limited number of annotated samples are
available. Ultimately, our research provides practical techniques to optimize
news summarization during the prompting and fine-tuning stages and enhances the
synthesis of news articles.
|
[
-0.3468254506587982,
-0.7020580172538757,
0.3667871057987213,
0.010902008973062038,
-0.4321208596229553,
0.04529363289475441,
-0.4295479655265808,
-0.5023995637893677,
0.26820164918899536,
0.16535820066928864,
-0.550491213798523,
-0.531732439994812,
-0.44819343090057373,
0.08590378612279892,
-0.7204491496086121,
1.4611780643463135,
0.2183031588792801,
-0.15959341824054718,
-0.10142125934362411,
-0.09451974183320999,
-0.11767061799764633,
-0.14585915207862854,
-0.9977660775184631,
-0.19780725240707397,
0.7204701900482178,
0.5797151327133179,
0.5149554014205933,
0.6570414900779724,
0.41996365785598755,
0.17420949041843414,
-0.14027276635169983,
0.41477856040000916,
-0.7685574293136597,
0.05369064211845398,
-0.024556241929531097,
-0.3988218307495117,
-0.4631734788417816,
-0.2462083250284195,
0.5265414714813232,
0.7237407565116882,
0.04963716119527817,
0.1825801283121109,
0.31991520524024963,
0.7863753437995911,
-0.5953800678253174,
0.02501155622303486,
-0.6430817246437073,
-0.21883636713027954,
0.002596178324893117,
-0.2108064591884613,
-0.10310059785842896,
-0.08489707857370377,
0.258727490901947,
-0.733069121837616,
0.197954922914505,
-0.023745106533169746,
0.9069724678993225,
0.33632194995880127,
-0.43218228220939636,
-0.27521491050720215,
-0.525788426399231,
0.7099596858024597,
-0.7891043424606323,
0.3907693922519684,
0.29640451073646545,
0.05154154449701309,
0.028256423771381378,
-0.6699926257133484,
-0.27129995822906494,
-0.12177663296461105,
-0.21015417575836182,
0.28236889839172363,
0.04708573967218399,
0.031581632792949677,
-0.029619233682751656,
0.431214302778244,
-0.5948801040649414,
0.25259047746658325,
-0.2792260944843292,
0.11440927535295486,
0.6344796419143677,
0.18912722170352936,
-0.017229018732905388,
-0.30366045236587524,
-0.10981346666812897,
-0.02372354455292225,
-0.770449161529541,
-0.10461241751909256,
0.2933383285999298,
0.40026792883872986,
-0.0861435979604721,
0.43685317039489746,
-0.43099474906921387,
0.6644584536552429,
-0.059433579444885254,
-0.42367035150527954,
0.1330915242433548,
-0.4562901258468628,
-0.18301571905612946,
0.09934300184249878,
0.2925293445587158,
0.6757889986038208,
0.15551090240478516,
0.17079178988933563,
-0.3708876073360443,
-0.18547861278057098,
-0.020548367872834206,
-0.813205361366272,
-0.152894988656044,
0.3668569028377533,
-0.3218437731266022,
-0.44059962034225464,
0.18917256593704224,
-0.7062075138092041,
-0.1427089124917984,
-0.4502166509628296,
0.394904226064682,
-0.23219749331474304,
0.12504445016384125,
0.2428508996963501,
-0.2357010692358017,
0.10331830382347107,
0.6810903549194336,
-0.8238335847854614,
0.24265748262405396,
0.7527958750724792,
0.921175479888916,
-0.23805367946624756,
-0.2767240107059479,
-0.7403582334518433,
0.2523481547832489,
-0.1566568911075592,
0.8632355332374573,
-0.14739558100700378,
-0.026535091921687126,
0.16575917601585388,
-0.14352215826511383,
0.01633351668715477,
-0.40645432472229004,
0.3221278488636017,
-0.5515924096107483,
0.38950493931770325,
-0.18648427724838257,
-0.8399091958999634,
-0.1919528841972351,
0.2946515381336212,
-0.7132571935653687,
0.8619111180305481,
0.1203700378537178,
-0.6628119349479675,
0.39416274428367615,
-0.6748815178871155,
-0.8434891700744629,
-0.24389643967151642,
0.10258453339338303,
-0.42801082134246826,
0.2007395327091217,
0.58967125415802,
0.7053613662719727,
0.1918295919895172,
0.014644413255155087,
0.11602780222892761,
-0.29236719012260437,
-0.20328876376152039,
-0.27854713797569275,
0.41279086470603943,
0.19299116730690002,
-0.267111212015152,
-0.0932365357875824,
-0.7777698040008545,
-0.2955247461795807,
-0.03091401420533657,
-0.5531488060951233,
-0.4723297655582428,
0.03600304573774338,
0.19139617681503296,
-0.049643684178590775,
0.09799687564373016,
-0.17955900728702545,
0.011148657649755478,
-0.6014875173568726,
0.40913689136505127,
0.4231323301792145,
0.29691874980926514,
0.5623652338981628,
-0.7008667588233948,
0.26918989419937134,
-0.14236637949943542,
-0.1645699143409729,
-0.9716745615005493,
-0.0538126602768898,
-0.8209743499755859,
-0.17846615612506866,
0.4252419173717499,
0.519877552986145,
-0.6285300254821777,
0.17497557401657104,
-0.2795044183731079,
-0.3056926131248474,
-0.2805120646953583,
0.32626914978027344,
0.1916564702987671,
0.5905429124832153,
0.26334917545318604,
0.1603294014930725,
-0.6247397065162659,
-0.6406040191650391,
-0.37890535593032837,
0.14237722754478455,
-0.11552215367555618,
0.0525389164686203,
0.6020733118057251,
0.162563756108284,
0.7229260802268982,
-0.5147179365158081,
-0.4361834228038788,
-0.4767196774482727,
0.14815795421600342,
0.24993352591991425,
0.20813396573066711,
0.609495997428894,
-0.8543977737426758,
-0.44886699318885803,
0.06851676851511002,
-0.4448203146457672,
-0.17575493454933167,
-0.4425487518310547,
0.16708408296108246,
0.31239765882492065,
0.6639522314071655,
-0.2537316381931305,
0.24974258244037628,
0.47917047142982483,
-0.11953171342611313,
0.3328680098056793,
-0.05577632039785385,
0.21606241166591644,
-1.138507604598999,
-0.12298606336116791,
0.13670194149017334,
-0.8049352765083313,
-0.4255215525627136,
0.19225706160068512,
0.09778960794210434,
-0.02314940094947815,
-0.8255808353424072,
0.7287182807922363,
-0.3302631378173828,
0.1384829431772232,
-0.4349781274795532,
0.4344514012336731,
0.33336126804351807,
0.43796125054359436,
0.0007488000555895269,
0.6900458931922913,
0.05523126944899559,
-0.7542940378189087,
0.041342053562402725,
0.13887274265289307,
-0.5784087777137756,
0.28524643182754517,
-0.7691822052001953,
-0.41921520233154297,
-0.37674272060394287,
0.3131009042263031,
-0.7348493337631226,
-0.6069612503051758,
-0.34130457043647766,
-0.19327351450920105,
0.13118672370910645,
0.26107436418533325,
-0.4925917387008667,
-0.032506123185157776,
-0.7906852960586548,
0.19232022762298584,
0.39272594451904297,
-0.6002116203308105,
0.34570255875587463,
0.21015988290309906,
-0.4140109717845917,
-0.2682134211063385,
-0.6366413831710815,
-0.07576283812522888,
-0.227923184633255,
-0.5128389596939087,
0.723884105682373,
0.017068278044462204,
-0.2702763080596924,
0.1407933533191681,
-0.08257689327001572,
0.14397558569908142,
0.20195291936397552,
-0.21089376509189606,
0.05926482751965523,
-0.20667584240436554,
0.2880055606365204,
0.42948901653289795,
-0.050497204065322876,
-0.3622512221336365,
-0.25037893652915955,
0.28857967257499695,
0.09729427844285965,
-0.22955073416233063,
-0.455000102519989,
0.626012921333313,
0.6455636024475098,
-0.28249937295913696,
0.700944721698761,
0.462730348110199,
-0.4511759579181671,
-0.2760307788848877,
-0.49837440252304077,
-0.4562819004058838,
-0.3267754018306732,
0.6534903049468994,
-0.04590922221541405,
-1.026920199394226,
0.6016270518302917,
0.03859668970108032,
0.5681781768798828,
0.4998297393321991,
0.6201717257499695,
-0.30726057291030884,
1.1415787935256958,
0.7157008051872253,
-0.21020682156085968,
0.9841912388801575,
-0.3368852734565735,
-0.11416590958833694,
-0.5268849730491638,
0.009883481077849865,
-0.2564593553543091,
-0.40949922800064087,
-0.3404462933540344,
0.18966321647167206,
0.706244707107544,
-0.16614478826522827,
-0.15580181777477264,
0.11220012605190277,
0.034267179667949677,
0.9015099406242371,
0.6130198240280151,
0.21333007514476776,
0.6648184061050415,
0.13520798087120056,
0.26433777809143066,
0.11156455427408218,
-0.9198521971702576,
-0.37247222661972046,
0.8691409826278687,
0.38441675901412964,
0.901760458946228,
0.036544278264045715,
0.7088703513145447,
0.23409384489059448,
0.02716267667710781,
-0.6958718299865723,
0.12056584656238556,
-0.46602338552474976,
-0.37396249175071716,
-0.17480935156345367,
-0.25139859318733215,
-0.7739489078521729,
0.28449520468711853,
-0.30609896779060364,
-0.43820351362228394,
0.0715225338935852,
0.14011383056640625,
-0.857322096824646,
0.17161762714385986,
-0.7193586230278015,
0.4842322766780853,
-0.07930668443441391,
-0.3259710967540741,
-0.4025360643863678,
-0.5160160064697266,
0.3713585436344147,
-0.08898746222257614,
0.2326056808233261,
0.08762265741825104,
-0.18920037150382996,
0.630774974822998,
-0.4350230097770691,
0.8917850255966187,
0.2975761890411377,
-0.19801099598407745,
0.12843331694602966,
-0.2536360025405884,
0.5502846240997314,
0.39170151948928833,
-0.0813794881105423,
-0.163043811917305,
-0.15210799872875214,
-0.46189290285110474,
-0.6228190660476685,
0.7035764455795288,
-0.7452694177627563,
-0.5473601222038269,
-0.09039571136236191,
-0.6412166357040405,
-0.0205779280513525,
0.16033822298049927,
0.5161535739898682,
0.7124407887458801,
-0.23363913595676422,
0.5078117847442627,
0.7040174007415771,
0.051341116428375244,
0.5796741247177124,
0.3384038209915161,
-0.24236541986465454,
-0.3984130322933197,
0.677868664264679,
0.357205867767334,
0.2228843867778778,
0.6805204153060913,
0.06657132506370544,
-0.07685254514217377,
-0.41472572088241577,
-0.3173387348651886,
0.21606849133968353,
-0.5657182335853577,
-0.5505979657173157,
-0.7483147382736206,
-0.3014904260635376,
-0.3031280040740967,
-0.535613477230072,
-0.3281698524951935,
-0.6369051337242126,
-0.3674274682998657,
-0.2175624519586563,
0.28571945428848267,
0.520951509475708,
0.0436503104865551,
0.6249871850013733,
-0.8673192858695984,
0.29954788088798523,
0.32940641045570374,
-0.03508846461772919,
0.034367214888334274,
-0.5745487213134766,
-0.7817279100418091,
0.07586672902107239,
-0.3007202446460724,
-0.7347512245178223,
0.27343031764030457,
0.5333526134490967,
0.33525550365448,
0.5501847267150879,
0.03903759643435478,
0.6127305626869202,
-0.40396639704704285,
0.8023632168769836,
-0.11543892323970795,
-0.8042763471603394,
0.8413317203521729,
-0.7272634506225586,
0.47876325249671936,
0.7648367881774902,
0.28159084916114807,
-0.39733368158340454,
-0.600319504737854,
-0.4837093651294708,
-1.1543099880218506,
0.3876723647117615,
0.14186738431453705,
0.3911248743534088,
-0.11835113912820816,
0.4712936580181122,
0.26967915892601013,
0.32218167185783386,
-0.49721798300743103,
-0.08072725683450699,
-0.044728219509124756,
-0.27808627486228943,
-0.0240001417696476,
-0.20141631364822388,
-0.05802825093269348,
-0.47324633598327637,
0.8783960342407227,
-0.16493922472000122,
-0.20252272486686707,
0.19941860437393188,
-0.5802363753318787,
-0.034771472215652466,
0.01009252667427063,
0.876813530921936,
0.6056743860244751,
-0.07821685075759888,
0.06370173394680023,
0.3246031403541565,
-0.32403144240379333,
-0.08608542382717133,
0.0837216004729271,
-0.38246285915374756,
0.20527300238609314,
0.657306432723999,
0.8101340532302856,
0.6456512808799744,
-0.6786469221115112,
0.7076618075370789,
-0.025912707671523094,
-0.25900575518608093,
-0.18784378468990326,
0.3683526813983917,
-0.09121262282133102,
0.33955246210098267,
0.5538877248764038,
-0.14879050850868225,
0.11628757417201996,
-0.38471296429634094,
0.30762040615081787,
0.1846868097782135,
0.13518626987934113,
-0.20961032807826996,
0.7266380786895752,
0.4282207787036896,
0.07822417467832565,
0.4130271077156067,
-0.2264207899570465,
-0.31812170147895813,
0.674465000629425,
0.5248507261276245,
0.7092699408531189,
0.01026721391826868,
0.24928687512874603,
0.37600740790367126,
0.25022655725479126,
-0.2293010652065277,
-0.054122086614370346,
0.10088934004306793,
-0.5615532398223877,
-0.7742712497711182,
-0.4093649089336395,
-0.4643997550010681,
0.23802314698696136,
-0.6029528975486755,
0.6204841136932373,
-0.17794589698314667,
0.06509547680616379,
-0.04690242558717728,
0.3176491856575012,
-0.5886993408203125,
0.0969257801771164,
0.05085621401667595,
1.2581675052642822,
-1.0287343263626099,
0.37211406230926514,
0.8248606324195862,
-0.30119842290878296,
-0.606087863445282,
0.1039704978466034,
0.07582425326108932,
-0.4596656560897827,
0.02135673351585865,
0.09356540441513062,
0.265028178691864,
0.2800484895706177,
-0.4347444474697113,
-0.7426883578300476,
1.2898273468017578,
0.5053749680519104,
-0.6858519911766052,
-0.18969841301441193,
-0.3384130299091339,
0.234517902135849,
-0.5089951753616333,
0.22277367115020752,
0.5245429277420044,
0.5185311436653137,
-0.06892180442810059,
-0.7082717418670654,
-0.38067713379859924,
-0.0270910132676363,
-0.11840692907571793,
0.1987055242061615,
-0.6934992074966431,
0.7535138726234436,
-0.41361263394355774,
-0.17260542511940002,
-0.06893265247344971,
0.93418949842453,
0.003088172757998109,
0.35973024368286133,
0.3556162416934967,
0.5576092600822449,
0.8326960802078247,
0.12425006926059723,
1.1483384370803833,
-0.3310735821723938,
0.411271333694458,
1.3250958919525146,
0.06499767303466797,
0.8052071332931519,
0.3790804445743561,
0.16773155331611633,
0.5244320034980774,
0.6745942831039429,
0.13593100011348724,
0.6822063326835632,
-0.25022387504577637,
-0.3266461193561554,
-0.030919577926397324,
-0.20533178746700287,
-0.22343724966049194,
0.5428327918052673,
0.35202229022979736,
-0.44454556703567505,
-0.7757402658462524,
0.5032898783683777,
0.31091398000717163,
0.06740260124206543,
-0.6158044338226318,
0.9483969211578369,
0.12001897394657135,
-0.6096804738044739,
0.19777804613113403,
0.10319812595844269,
0.6805976033210754,
-0.5020085573196411,
0.06404659897089005,
-0.41311755776405334,
-0.040509290993213654,
-0.4231209456920624,
-0.49451175332069397,
0.3240889310836792,
0.11961127817630768,
-0.39985737204551697,
-0.09194392710924149,
0.7758018970489502,
-0.6915580034255981,
-0.4993519186973572,
-0.049243178218603134,
0.8708874583244324,
-0.1085055023431778,
-0.1708577424287796,
-0.3867332339286804,
-0.02121771313250065,
-0.10683393478393555,
-0.7677187919616699,
0.29660505056381226,
0.3975062966346741,
-0.11260222643613815,
0.3719782531261444,
0.7116629481315613,
0.16457711160182953,
-0.23941664397716522,
0.2743929326534271,
0.9132367968559265,
-0.4629250168800354,
-0.7147150635719299,
-1.0164532661437988,
0.5656110048294067,
-0.02550707757472992,
-0.280195415019989,
0.5756949782371521,
0.5942485928535461,
1.0156301259994507,
0.02505449578166008,
0.6383540630340576,
0.19237682223320007,
0.3986378610134125,
-0.7694618701934814,
0.7565985918045044,
-0.7584758996963501,
0.2872367203235626,
-0.16153399646282196,
-0.9444023966789246,
-0.6799799799919128,
0.5956424474716187,
-0.12241386622190475,
0.09969763457775116,
0.7069815397262573,
0.7398384213447571,
-0.16895529627799988,
0.05166354402899742,
0.44670921564102173,
0.086844302713871,
0.175835520029068,
0.4274652302265167,
0.5311682820320129,
-0.45725733041763306,
0.3808547556400299,
-0.304739385843277,
-0.22742830216884613,
-0.5595324039459229,
-1.1304408311843872,
-0.8480173349380493,
-0.5945976972579956,
-0.43063193559646606,
0.024117901921272278,
0.2300901561975479,
1.1524184942245483,
0.8555269241333008,
-0.7378385066986084,
0.08056232333183289,
-0.01721755973994732,
0.3897783160209656,
-0.29469865560531616,
-0.25165313482284546,
0.4491911232471466,
-0.5887380838394165,
-1.0129203796386719,
0.16819719970226288,
0.27171996235847473,
0.00963778980076313,
-0.153788760304451,
0.09507916867733002,
-0.068939208984375,
0.046638913452625275,
0.9996547102928162,
0.07350093126296997,
-0.22406455874443054,
-0.24096167087554932,
0.0453583300113678,
-0.049438126385211945,
-0.021212946623563766,
0.8070797920227051,
-0.9066722393035889,
-0.047821104526519775,
0.5773326754570007,
0.8936917185783386,
0.4054875671863556,
0.07865716516971588,
0.3833272159099579,
-1.064860463142395,
0.030035611242055893,
0.01841619238257408,
0.37435367703437805,
0.28424882888793945,
-0.53996741771698,
0.4500628709793091,
-0.13417929410934448,
-0.5688408613204956,
-0.6888495087623596,
0.0417662188410759,
-0.6004914045333862,
-0.2677517831325531,
1.1618077754974365,
0.08412156254053116,
-0.328798770904541,
0.04941622167825699,
-0.17210577428340912,
0.16008271276950836,
-0.5067881345748901,
0.6434009671211243,
0.5144945979118347,
-0.2023557424545288,
-0.37894541025161743,
-0.7957331538200378,
0.3658636808395386,
0.3530750870704651,
-0.8234025835990906,
-0.1512506604194641,
0.3719223141670227,
0.19446298480033875,
-0.11731543391942978,
0.538921058177948,
0.10846862941980362,
0.4115122854709625,
-0.41820529103279114,
-0.44025635719299316,
-0.21418353915214539,
-0.5522180795669556,
-0.4161902368068695,
0.14587025344371796,
-0.12488091737031937,
-0.03120455890893936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06674v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06674v1
|
Open-SQL Framework: Enhancing Text-to-SQL on Open-source Large Language Models
| 2024-05-04T15:40:17 | 2024-05-04T15:40:17 |
Xiaojun Chen, Tianle Wang, Tianhao Qiu, Jianbin Qin, Min Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the success of large language models (LLMs) in Text-to-SQL tasks,
open-source LLMs encounter challenges in contextual understanding and response
coherence. To tackle these issues, we present \ours, a systematic methodology
tailored for Text-to-SQL with open-source LLMs. Our contributions include a
comprehensive evaluation of open-source LLMs in Text-to-SQL tasks, the
\openprompt strategy for effective question representation, and novel
strategies for supervised fine-tuning. We explore the benefits of
Chain-of-Thought in step-by-step inference and propose the \openexample method
for enhanced few-shot learning. Additionally, we introduce token-efficient
techniques, such as \textbf{Variable-length Open DB Schema}, \textbf{Target
Column Truncation}, and \textbf{Example Column Truncation}, addressing
challenges in large-scale databases. Our findings emphasize the need for
further investigation into the impact of supervised fine-tuning on contextual
learning capabilities. Remarkably, our method significantly improved Llama2-7B
from 2.54\% to 41.04\% and Code Llama-7B from 14.54\% to 48.24\% on the
BIRD-Dev dataset. Notably, the performance of Code Llama-7B surpassed GPT-4
(46.35\%) on the BIRD-Dev dataset.
|
[
-0.46269333362579346,
-1.0530143976211548,
0.39189112186431885,
0.14915668964385986,
-0.26550018787384033,
-0.3290855288505554,
-0.6263123750686646,
-0.43129411339759827,
0.03258012607693672,
0.7682380080223083,
-0.5286978483200073,
-0.8184353113174438,
-0.2034551352262497,
0.13584007322788239,
-0.4086519181728363,
0.8442691564559937,
0.1134464293718338,
0.09899473935365677,
-0.21113699674606323,
-0.18348067998886108,
-0.4501124620437622,
-0.5560814738273621,
-0.4268779456615448,
0.12044398486614227,
0.48317602276802063,
0.6570605635643005,
0.4991759657859802,
0.6634168028831482,
0.7278963327407837,
0.11609526723623276,
-0.2328256070613861,
0.15529750287532806,
-0.8098672032356262,
0.2898484468460083,
-0.5143775343894958,
-0.6108130216598511,
-0.5519462823867798,
-0.4639817178249359,
0.5077752470970154,
0.8584961891174316,
-0.2854159474372864,
0.24935248494148254,
0.12322389334440231,
0.8521793484687805,
-0.8288511633872986,
0.27380409836769104,
-0.7534012794494629,
0.16859272122383118,
-0.45259127020835876,
-0.13430719077587128,
-0.5143548250198364,
-0.08422152698040009,
-0.055945999920368195,
-0.6123724579811096,
0.08762956410646439,
0.215994730591774,
0.37736615538597107,
0.2951926589012146,
-0.3089545667171478,
-0.21051213145256042,
-0.700168251991272,
0.6032800078392029,
-0.6205536723136902,
0.30006036162376404,
0.278632253408432,
0.38699108362197876,
-0.40926989912986755,
-0.7020747661590576,
-0.4030200242996216,
-0.15253567695617676,
-0.0313505157828331,
-0.02339255064725876,
0.11912956833839417,
0.06761359423398972,
0.34046033024787903,
0.5360847115516663,
-0.5517548322677612,
0.20485371351242065,
-0.17161467671394348,
0.07637718319892883,
0.5085878372192383,
0.08667133748531342,
-0.14353226125240326,
0.13756443560123444,
-0.17064982652664185,
0.048695117235183716,
-0.953524649143219,
-0.2750518321990967,
0.12573428452014923,
0.7799827456474304,
0.18186673521995544,
0.8717392683029175,
-0.48233917355537415,
0.9173111915588379,
-0.14792761206626892,
0.36127182841300964,
0.028649087995290756,
-0.5831544399261475,
-0.4470020830631256,
-0.020957211032509804,
0.5972191691398621,
0.20598162710666656,
0.21982760727405548,
-0.26785680651664734,
-0.08347253501415253,
-0.19983799755573273,
0.0525730662047863,
-0.8377511501312256,
-0.03455135598778725,
0.4358050227165222,
-0.37327471375465393,
-0.15869946777820587,
-0.002741210162639618,
-0.8170678615570068,
-0.4625619947910309,
-0.2112303078174591,
0.33946019411087036,
-0.2565207779407501,
-0.36866307258605957,
0.038575150072574615,
0.07720379531383514,
0.19245921075344086,
0.4540781080722809,
-0.8401935696601868,
0.3666858375072479,
0.7876623272895813,
0.8370696306228638,
-0.3555242419242859,
-0.0018564265919849277,
-0.7810961008071899,
0.28607016801834106,
-0.5242154598236084,
0.6672632694244385,
-0.462873637676239,
-0.3265853226184845,
0.1024746224284172,
-0.14808396995067596,
0.2226688265800476,
-0.5993480682373047,
0.4429018497467041,
-0.42526572942733765,
0.32611411809921265,
-0.35954251885414124,
-0.6159378290176392,
0.07399675995111465,
0.22341911494731903,
-0.668692946434021,
1.1186327934265137,
-0.002876138314604759,
-0.6860940456390381,
0.46391889452934265,
-0.8978849053382874,
-0.4351930320262909,
-0.0799059197306633,
-0.2510068416595459,
-0.2839870750904083,
0.3199115991592407,
0.41451650857925415,
0.5474534630775452,
-0.39572638273239136,
0.10328835994005203,
-0.4942677617073059,
-0.5521754026412964,
-0.06295616179704666,
-0.026996461674571037,
0.8174592852592468,
0.1980219930410385,
-0.1853557974100113,
0.38564667105674744,
-0.8156992197036743,
0.16953913867473602,
0.0675923302769661,
-0.36339154839515686,
-0.375739187002182,
0.0472288616001606,
0.103216253221035,
0.010962276719510555,
-0.09256436675786972,
-0.34199774265289307,
0.27091163396835327,
-0.7119487524032593,
0.4005238711833954,
0.5579371452331543,
0.002620931016281247,
0.5633112192153931,
0.1731686145067215,
0.3577756881713867,
0.23956651985645294,
0.006633363198488951,
-0.4335861802101135,
-0.21348880231380463,
-0.6326419115066528,
-0.3850836455821991,
0.19472916424274445,
0.4577975571155548,
-0.6049156188964844,
0.4789871573448181,
-0.09508643299341202,
-0.2266656905412674,
-0.3236362636089325,
0.1458190232515335,
0.237484410405159,
0.46131306886672974,
0.6429266333580017,
-0.5163326263427734,
-0.5489934682846069,
-0.639541745185852,
-0.38316401839256287,
-0.07851563394069672,
-0.17111285030841827,
0.32633283734321594,
0.6383615136146545,
0.07435266673564911,
1.137312889099121,
-0.6918556094169617,
-0.6833319067955017,
0.034025877714157104,
-0.1875944435596466,
0.17982466518878937,
0.5372430086135864,
0.4750875234603882,
-0.5031877160072327,
-0.3576127886772156,
0.049546096473932266,
-0.6869069933891296,
0.037268705666065216,
0.16655604541301727,
-0.2210932821035385,
0.5258826017379761,
0.6721497774124146,
-0.6692799925804138,
0.30019789934158325,
0.1828574240207672,
-0.410869836807251,
0.42128556966781616,
0.01814345270395279,
-0.04649876803159714,
-1.2411818504333496,
0.17519114911556244,
-0.04327869415283203,
-0.13027621805667877,
-0.30559563636779785,
0.3547123968601227,
0.035438500344753265,
-0.09473788738250732,
-0.5707360506057739,
0.404133141040802,
-0.5477847456932068,
-0.34054604172706604,
0.056745558977127075,
0.19520290195941925,
-0.2976457476615906,
0.3703330457210541,
0.03774416074156761,
0.8751928806304932,
0.4626813530921936,
-0.4306810200214386,
0.2810214161872864,
0.4040879011154175,
-0.49074462056159973,
0.8212242722511292,
-0.5442085862159729,
0.1867363154888153,
-0.10431501269340515,
0.32143551111221313,
-0.8124129176139832,
-0.4648686647415161,
0.17501333355903625,
-0.18025146424770355,
0.2509978711605072,
-0.1878165751695633,
-0.6100671291351318,
-0.18051572144031525,
-0.21392802894115448,
0.10933981090784073,
0.2455238699913025,
-0.6696298122406006,
0.2787731885910034,
0.13232755661010742,
-0.08080747723579407,
-0.7016293406486511,
-0.8263422250747681,
0.2917081117630005,
-0.08909980207681656,
-0.5131048560142517,
0.3166186511516571,
0.09073860198259354,
-0.299662709236145,
0.036473482847213745,
-0.16692349314689636,
-0.3833679258823395,
0.021167589351534843,
-0.007585157174617052,
0.07578027993440628,
-0.571596086025238,
0.4230441749095917,
0.15833386778831482,
0.24792668223381042,
-0.027339711785316467,
-0.5577529072761536,
0.3191578984260559,
-0.25163236260414124,
-0.42553797364234924,
-0.018803657963871956,
0.32573920488357544,
0.0702551081776619,
-0.508621335029602,
0.9816913604736328,
0.5425665378570557,
-0.44704678654670715,
-0.42817866802215576,
-0.2477574646472931,
-0.37617942690849304,
-0.37942054867744446,
0.5216768980026245,
-0.44203272461891174,
-1.2271193265914917,
0.32367992401123047,
-0.18307621777057648,
0.07158823311328888,
0.3980725109577179,
0.5485045313835144,
-0.12307611107826233,
0.7737569212913513,
0.7506241798400879,
0.1064324826002121,
0.569816529750824,
-0.09494683891534805,
0.004714618902653456,
-0.5409035682678223,
-0.23483382165431976,
-0.7489864230155945,
0.06841466575860977,
-0.3241119682788849,
-0.5443794131278992,
0.20374107360839844,
0.4348285496234894,
-0.32951998710632324,
0.2566433548927307,
-0.28163856267929077,
0.7604621648788452,
0.16752907633781433,
0.15781298279762268,
0.620485246181488,
0.21340258419513702,
-0.0847257599234581,
0.06541579216718674,
-0.6283012628555298,
-0.298346608877182,
1.2029213905334473,
0.3148619830608368,
0.8171889185905457,
0.31998777389526367,
0.670103132724762,
0.09570425003767014,
0.2460724115371704,
-0.772891640663147,
0.6243991851806641,
-0.1206996738910675,
-0.8240323662757874,
-0.4785207509994507,
-0.4240661859512329,
-0.6114789843559265,
0.3707375228404999,
-0.34877637028694153,
-0.7238051891326904,
-0.05983736366033554,
0.2910519242286682,
-0.11288955807685852,
0.0302584208548069,
-0.6892160177230835,
0.9542647004127502,
-0.016860349103808403,
-0.7875316739082336,
-0.18211564421653748,
-0.6018975973129272,
0.5095924735069275,
-0.16622383892536163,
0.03631853312253952,
0.07254618406295776,
-0.32986146211624146,
0.4781595468521118,
-0.5636226534843445,
0.882774829864502,
-0.23550021648406982,
-0.30250084400177,
0.33543553948402405,
-0.11708426475524902,
0.4167790412902832,
0.11679743230342865,
-0.2644745707511902,
0.2311428189277649,
0.0610971674323082,
-0.4454788565635681,
-0.6215319037437439,
0.7046481966972351,
-0.21641767024993896,
-0.5011221766471863,
-0.26682451367378235,
-0.5516412258148193,
-0.40297046303749084,
0.43367800116539,
-0.013695529662072659,
0.34522831439971924,
-0.4414825439453125,
0.6349270939826965,
0.7099378705024719,
-0.17473497986793518,
0.36373358964920044,
0.45782285928726196,
-0.4387846887111664,
-0.3952944278717041,
0.4183906316757202,
0.031774867326021194,
0.1930406540632248,
0.5894672274589539,
0.04289484769105911,
-0.40675920248031616,
-0.6520077586174011,
-0.550134539604187,
0.03921009600162506,
-0.7833326458930969,
-0.2397093027830124,
-0.2685183584690094,
0.2712574601173401,
-0.34845224022865295,
0.1918833702802658,
-0.17945533990859985,
-0.6301464438438416,
-0.41513776779174805,
-0.08166635781526566,
0.392485111951828,
0.5699100494384766,
0.272331178188324,
0.39370352029800415,
-0.6520602107048035,
-0.020450199022889137,
-0.19292907416820526,
0.7461240887641907,
-0.10799749940633774,
-0.1899978220462799,
-0.3920523524284363,
-0.08104031533002853,
-0.1437670886516571,
-0.8044068217277527,
0.05487603694200516,
0.44833189249038696,
0.3506631553173065,
0.19703420996665955,
0.17336983978748322,
0.7371786832809448,
-0.45768868923187256,
0.8501356840133667,
0.06995933502912521,
-0.9151079058647156,
0.7278812527656555,
-0.4821224808692932,
0.23462365567684174,
0.6203919649124146,
0.29168185591697693,
-0.1258372962474823,
-0.17907337844371796,
-0.11732299625873566,
-0.8408861756324768,
0.727329671382904,
0.24625787138938904,
-0.1080111712217331,
-0.019432026892900467,
0.5444589257240295,
0.05845704302191734,
0.41546422243118286,
-0.6108144521713257,
-0.013073286972939968,
-0.015949930995702744,
-0.3686613142490387,
-0.33801352977752686,
-0.052534427493810654,
-0.1921537071466446,
-0.17207922041416168,
0.44880709052085876,
-0.6068934202194214,
0.1295260339975357,
0.15576988458633423,
-0.2908852696418762,
-0.13075901567935944,
0.46345046162605286,
0.6157343983650208,
0.7328372597694397,
-0.31349697709083557,
-0.049676310271024704,
0.2854371964931488,
-0.30288252234458923,
-0.24760495126247406,
-0.019247623160481453,
-0.0129169300198555,
-0.2402871996164322,
0.3866950273513794,
0.6154959201812744,
0.05468948557972908,
-0.7878901362419128,
0.43217265605926514,
0.07689197361469269,
-0.12541334331035614,
-0.04293818399310112,
0.14627765119075775,
0.17918923497200012,
0.24676404893398285,
0.28063228726387024,
-0.09364563226699829,
0.11959115415811539,
-0.6657505035400391,
0.10067075490951538,
0.6140575408935547,
-0.5264843702316284,
-0.06099037453532219,
0.7487800717353821,
0.2828981280326843,
-0.09652338176965714,
0.4532392621040344,
0.18757115304470062,
-0.13517044484615326,
0.46474331617355347,
0.689250111579895,
0.7632735967636108,
-0.02099599502980709,
-0.21562042832374573,
0.3631509840488434,
0.32313263416290283,
-0.2779616415500641,
0.5994823575019836,
-0.24782289564609528,
-0.28108227252960205,
-0.5860787630081177,
-0.5244551301002502,
-0.4967138171195984,
-0.034050047397613525,
-0.7109825015068054,
0.3925322890281677,
-0.3533059060573578,
-0.026119768619537354,
-0.21674028038978577,
-0.057780858129262924,
-0.40285956859588623,
0.10231523960828781,
-0.26675719022750854,
1.4530540704727173,
-0.6242139339447021,
0.9095371961593628,
0.690689206123352,
-0.6100534796714783,
-0.485688716173172,
0.10167090594768524,
-0.15464846789836884,
-0.30672913789749146,
0.48191267251968384,
0.1440640687942505,
0.06827505677938461,
0.12354031205177307,
-0.6985437273979187,
-0.6527668237686157,
0.9976065158843994,
0.5939901471138,
-0.7364887595176697,
-0.051410529762506485,
0.21860551834106445,
0.7096020579338074,
-0.46953946352005005,
0.1837373524904251,
0.6686910390853882,
0.22913967072963715,
0.02555755153298378,
-0.9265281558036804,
0.0758291557431221,
0.15668024122714996,
0.09543684870004654,
0.41444161534309387,
-0.3804807960987091,
0.6266078352928162,
-0.48971986770629883,
-0.027590269222855568,
0.033984921872615814,
0.8356505036354065,
0.06791567802429199,
0.32075074315071106,
0.339472234249115,
0.5147740840911865,
0.7384788990020752,
-0.09472209960222244,
0.8146154880523682,
-0.018221236765384674,
0.4656270742416382,
1.3487045764923096,
-0.4696904420852661,
1.392976999282837,
0.6467922329902649,
-0.2608370780944824,
0.37162548303604126,
0.6003734469413757,
0.2560758888721466,
0.42459604144096375,
0.25386083126068115,
-0.10017570108175278,
-0.06020127236843109,
-0.02361464872956276,
-0.40428122878074646,
0.40148109197616577,
0.4846798777580261,
-0.29124507308006287,
-0.2451908439397812,
0.017892511561512947,
-0.18248696625232697,
0.23831485211849213,
-0.3682115375995636,
0.8581440448760986,
0.11816567927598953,
-0.574469268321991,
0.5820371508598328,
-0.09913206845521927,
0.524623453617096,
-0.43637460470199585,
-0.07483898848295212,
-0.21030791103839874,
0.34120452404022217,
-0.4600450098514557,
-0.8718553185462952,
0.5600908398628235,
0.026955973356962204,
-0.12841972708702087,
0.023014502599835396,
0.7431790828704834,
-0.633043646812439,
-0.16965577006340027,
0.1744292676448822,
0.46862685680389404,
0.04484012722969055,
-0.3896161615848541,
-0.45216846466064453,
0.1765650361776352,
-0.23588523268699646,
-0.3040810525417328,
0.3333415687084198,
0.3275480270385742,
-0.14223064482212067,
0.44083791971206665,
0.581019401550293,
0.05985770747065544,
-0.15295159816741943,
0.03939972445368767,
0.7364299893379211,
-0.6190862655639648,
-0.5044096112251282,
-0.8468920588493347,
0.35507887601852417,
-0.22240860760211945,
-0.09876158088445663,
0.6484281420707703,
0.8680119514465332,
1.0950748920440674,
-0.31098487973213196,
0.5576463341712952,
-0.13711707293987274,
0.5471789836883545,
-0.7594934701919556,
0.687420129776001,
-0.6442654728889465,
0.4788455367088318,
-0.25026851892471313,
-1.1942752599716187,
-0.5221763849258423,
0.4257051348686218,
-0.1750999391078949,
-0.012968184426426888,
0.7634857296943665,
0.9617331027984619,
0.0038951379247009754,
0.10250438004732132,
0.17888669669628143,
0.3386933505535126,
0.24186648428440094,
0.47637006640434265,
0.5182586908340454,
-0.27362462878227234,
0.7505685091018677,
0.02970041148364544,
-0.28183960914611816,
-0.3269542157649994,
-1.0770533084869385,
-1.0458252429962158,
-0.5326177477836609,
-0.26555538177490234,
-0.4425477683544159,
0.2679319977760315,
1.0437129735946655,
0.7032576203346252,
-0.9413883686065674,
-0.36842235922813416,
-0.39053982496261597,
-0.034680258482694626,
-0.3307291865348816,
-0.1901511549949646,
0.2639228105545044,
-0.42568784952163696,
-0.4782032072544098,
0.4522617757320404,
0.31218570470809937,
-0.09490795433521271,
-0.3723442852497101,
0.0443815179169178,
-0.10232958197593689,
0.01644604466855526,
1.00083589553833,
0.19842854142189026,
-0.7326782941818237,
-0.13501125574111938,
0.041406385600566864,
-0.11289484053850174,
0.040350541472435,
0.7119412422180176,
-0.7438304424285889,
0.37192264199256897,
0.5620505809783936,
0.7025378346443176,
0.5465366244316101,
0.06490068882703781,
0.5917636752128601,
-0.9654033780097961,
0.17523710429668427,
0.246801495552063,
0.14046964049339294,
0.21849675476551056,
-0.3024185001850128,
0.8198869824409485,
0.1654769778251648,
-0.32271048426628113,
-1.1021944284439087,
0.2321176379919052,
-0.9000239372253418,
-0.4437565505504608,
1.0198688507080078,
-0.031788524240255356,
-0.23654280602931976,
0.050948433578014374,
-0.38283634185791016,
0.08629667013883591,
-0.28543031215667725,
0.38066428899765015,
0.5986261367797852,
-0.08084946870803833,
-0.10228246450424194,
-0.429505318403244,
0.5299596786499023,
0.3839351236820221,
-1.2048273086547852,
0.27395081520080566,
0.7288021445274353,
0.15905256569385529,
-0.10144881904125214,
0.6153566241264343,
-0.13276463747024536,
0.1261521428823471,
-0.09790124744176865,
-0.12279368191957474,
-0.24510161578655243,
-0.3305579125881195,
-0.5395385026931763,
0.4403896927833557,
0.18747377395629883,
-0.06806691735982895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02677v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02677v1
|
Evaluating the Ability of Computationally Extracted Narrative Maps to Encode Media Framing
| 2024-05-04T14:40:28 | 2024-05-04T14:40:28 |
Sebastián Concha Macías, Brian Keith Norambuena
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Narratives serve as fundamental frameworks in our understanding of the world
and play a crucial role in collaborative sensemaking, providing a versatile
foundation for sensemaking. Framing is a subtle yet potent mechanism that
influences public perception through specific word choices, shaping
interpretations of reported news events. Despite the recognized importance of
narratives and framing, a significant gap exists in the literature with regard
to the explicit consideration of framing within the context of computational
extraction and representation. This article explores the capabilities of a
specific narrative extraction and representation approach -- narrative maps --
to capture framing information from news data. The research addresses two key
questions: (1) Does the narrative extraction method capture the framing
distribution of the data set? (2) Does it produce a representation with
consistent framing? Our results indicate that while the algorithm captures
framing distributions, achieving consistent framing across various starting and
ending events poses challenges. Our results highlight the potential of
narrative maps to provide users with insights into the intricate framing
dynamics within news narratives. However, we note that directly leveraging
framing information in the computational narrative extraction process remains
an open challenge.
|
[
-0.6685375571250916,
-0.753180742263794,
0.9698686003684998,
0.04492923244833946,
-0.2796618640422821,
0.3385590612888336,
-0.23142223060131073,
-0.5307767987251282,
0.3053325414657593,
0.3345398008823395,
-0.4109915792942047,
-0.4645472466945648,
-1.0009671449661255,
0.0009921177988871932,
-0.5969249606132507,
0.7439765930175781,
-0.39471277594566345,
-0.2707809805870056,
0.0823625847697258,
-0.0591912604868412,
-0.5528513193130493,
-0.49860695004463196,
-0.07490446418523788,
-0.07035709917545319,
0.23926809430122375,
0.20164039731025696,
0.8361595273017883,
1.0649226903915405,
0.5032678246498108,
0.1660831868648529,
-0.004694138187915087,
0.13098075985908508,
-0.5527052283287048,
0.1866486519575119,
0.07003944367170334,
-0.27786076068878174,
0.004877045750617981,
0.6230418086051941,
0.6985632181167603,
0.6321898102760315,
0.03294927254319191,
0.5573315024375916,
0.025960581377148628,
0.6461134552955627,
-0.6710712313652039,
0.21967454254627228,
-0.4125097095966339,
0.29468947649002075,
-0.32563135027885437,
-0.5007891058921814,
-0.3751414120197296,
-0.3224092721939087,
0.16156607866287231,
-0.7858934998512268,
0.15381816029548645,
0.3939253091812134,
0.9435121417045593,
0.08515234291553497,
-0.6321658492088318,
-0.5528841614723206,
-0.8350670337677002,
0.24940603971481323,
-0.1698172688484192,
0.06597628444433212,
0.5796369314193726,
0.6859822273254395,
-0.06017423793673515,
-0.5161153078079224,
-0.36493247747421265,
0.28431227803230286,
-0.15846394002437592,
0.221195250749588,
-0.4058687686920166,
-0.3417964577674866,
0.41541075706481934,
0.23202064633369446,
-0.36955463886260986,
-0.2803415358066559,
-0.5552525520324707,
-0.11261560022830963,
0.5455870032310486,
0.36101460456848145,
0.45784926414489746,
-0.5250941514968872,
-0.5038856863975525,
0.00469642598181963,
-0.46943819522857666,
0.09120586514472961,
0.3608372211456299,
0.2913566529750824,
-0.37858161330223083,
0.5655779838562012,
-0.15637029707431793,
0.7176235914230347,
-0.07523386180400848,
-0.05634952709078789,
0.15944017469882965,
-0.0514233224093914,
-0.0712292343378067,
0.4133329689502716,
0.7220634818077087,
0.7380093932151794,
0.20579662919044495,
-0.06788848340511322,
-0.03720236197113991,
-0.06944926083087921,
0.42949768900871277,
-0.45515868067741394,
0.15707483887672424,
-0.09248008579015732,
-0.56395423412323,
-0.2958393394947052,
0.45300135016441345,
-0.8918598294258118,
-0.4958411157131195,
-0.26178810000419617,
0.12981420755386353,
-0.061174046248197556,
-0.37964433431625366,
0.16159798204898834,
-0.652600884437561,
0.320183128118515,
0.2185761034488678,
-0.7768954634666443,
0.09392232447862625,
0.7216343283653259,
0.9714996814727783,
-0.306901216506958,
0.11677680909633636,
-0.4251309335231781,
0.3408372104167938,
-0.45837363600730896,
0.7246565222740173,
-0.6969342827796936,
-0.19362175464630127,
0.1648329496383667,
-0.3009409010410309,
0.1828698068857193,
-0.4742870032787323,
0.2842893898487091,
-0.7335847020149231,
0.1637374758720398,
-0.3939381539821625,
-0.6033326387405396,
-0.26606228947639465,
0.45195165276527405,
-0.9871589541435242,
0.5891932845115662,
-0.007592330686748028,
-0.558367908000946,
0.1623830497264862,
-0.4450402855873108,
-0.24752476811408997,
-0.08320054411888123,
-0.2991498112678528,
-0.08383911848068237,
0.46114444732666016,
0.7548237442970276,
0.15617485344409943,
-0.3652088940143585,
0.36012572050094604,
-0.17768602073192596,
-0.3977408707141876,
0.33347445726394653,
-0.43630748987197876,
0.675734281539917,
0.20550502836704254,
-0.17715558409690857,
-0.23819765448570251,
-0.4374268352985382,
-0.35674384236335754,
0.3150447607040405,
-0.21082326769828796,
-0.007200456690043211,
0.056114982813596725,
0.17021040618419647,
-0.028690777719020844,
-0.17362193763256073,
-0.4405161738395691,
0.11198674142360687,
-0.0975581556558609,
0.3922998905181885,
0.5853990912437439,
0.2930450439453125,
0.7009195685386658,
-0.40566298365592957,
0.7646945714950562,
-0.06300956755876541,
-0.3834417462348938,
-0.7689271569252014,
-0.5379565954208374,
0.006463299505412579,
-0.30769726634025574,
0.44398343563079834,
0.380825012922287,
-0.7089871764183044,
-0.09915380924940109,
-0.2938228249549866,
-0.2296866774559021,
-0.40789994597435,
-0.4127016067504883,
-0.042572833597660065,
0.5556926727294922,
0.08702380210161209,
-0.3097441792488098,
-0.6422356963157654,
-0.5977863073348999,
-0.44249969720840454,
0.04788223281502724,
-0.03746533393859863,
0.03757639601826668,
0.2377547025680542,
0.38622528314590454,
1.551066279411316,
-0.7855273485183716,
-0.20462371408939362,
-0.20320039987564087,
0.42190611362457275,
0.25546887516975403,
0.11454998701810837,
0.622565746307373,
-1.1761616468429565,
-0.1778239607810974,
-0.23324647545814514,
-1.2260905504226685,
-0.18015699088573456,
-0.5023690462112427,
0.11229384690523148,
-0.1784173995256424,
0.47903233766555786,
-0.5627016425132751,
0.8413978219032288,
0.39638349413871765,
-0.2573685944080353,
0.6838014721870422,
0.2053077518939972,
0.5941210985183716,
-0.6864066123962402,
-0.20030690729618073,
-0.09937779605388641,
-0.43465617299079895,
-0.320901095867157,
0.09381680935621262,
-0.10372084379196167,
-0.4194260239601135,
-0.4027922749519348,
0.3121562600135803,
-0.7725831270217896,
-0.38928401470184326,
-0.3827815353870392,
0.4631088972091675,
0.16917802393436432,
0.43129128217697144,
0.021313367411494255,
0.3881828784942627,
0.4646422863006592,
0.1434512585401535,
0.3119499385356903,
0.1652270257472992,
-0.7342900633811951,
0.2780361473560333,
-0.2346789538860321,
0.1027468889951706,
-0.3549579977989197,
0.44907137751579285,
-0.8673695921897888,
-0.3356807231903076,
0.44977864623069763,
-0.5497920513153076,
0.03699036315083504,
-0.11962593346834183,
-0.6383775472640991,
-0.1292647421360016,
-0.15441551804542542,
0.2986195981502533,
0.34570008516311646,
-0.48675987124443054,
0.5290758013725281,
0.8133679032325745,
0.052006807178258896,
0.08325490355491638,
-0.7262291312217712,
0.24103520810604095,
-0.3857687711715698,
-0.4125239849090576,
0.17430207133293152,
0.31982576847076416,
-0.23764054477214813,
0.3384474813938141,
-0.35183078050613403,
-0.16718748211860657,
-0.06255871057510376,
0.5087922811508179,
0.14016440510749817,
-0.2783281207084656,
0.0486137755215168,
0.05948089435696602,
-0.5096123218536377,
0.12565797567367554,
-0.056989751756191254,
0.2125517874956131,
0.04604845121502876,
-0.5100072026252747,
-0.2819347083568573,
0.9253199100494385,
0.5724122524261475,
-0.4555695354938507,
0.5029569864273071,
0.6436746120452881,
-0.6407841444015503,
-0.003313017077744007,
-0.2976413667201996,
-0.02884655073285103,
-0.3810034692287445,
0.03701697662472725,
-0.2842518985271454,
-1.032041311264038,
0.529147207736969,
-0.4585978090763092,
-0.18240532279014587,
0.28561079502105713,
0.30408212542533875,
-0.3271888494491577,
1.0311075448989868,
0.26995426416397095,
-0.029741672798991203,
0.21169660985469818,
-0.12189295142889023,
0.30720651149749756,
-0.8026115894317627,
-0.05633673816919327,
-0.3562721610069275,
-0.7079471945762634,
-0.08508041501045227,
-0.24330030381679535,
0.4777394235134125,
0.25946909189224243,
0.05383329465985298,
0.1913524866104126,
-0.5183877944946289,
0.7060961127281189,
0.43098875880241394,
-0.13453294336795807,
0.5341038703918457,
0.15089575946331024,
0.33795008063316345,
-0.23838995397090912,
-0.568687915802002,
-0.6042462587356567,
0.908276379108429,
0.004189452156424522,
0.383417010307312,
0.059708643704652786,
0.6198757290840149,
0.4826061725616455,
0.26452258229255676,
-0.3600683808326721,
0.4224426746368408,
0.3626871407032013,
-0.7196742296218872,
0.05823918431997299,
-0.2676958441734314,
-0.9480298757553101,
0.28087228536605835,
-0.5905455350875854,
-0.9271433353424072,
0.3815970718860626,
-0.35438936948776245,
-0.42725181579589844,
0.3023110628128052,
-0.736859142780304,
0.7194086909294128,
-0.063179612159729,
0.23914498090744019,
-0.14743806421756744,
-0.7435187101364136,
0.13833172619342804,
-0.1976119428873062,
0.6844726204872131,
-0.4851126968860626,
0.13872650265693665,
0.5029743909835815,
0.09246865659952164,
0.6992221474647522,
0.026524992659687996,
0.5071813464164734,
0.5829528570175171,
0.2359628975391388,
-0.01929154060781002,
0.06496014446020126,
0.04084509238600731,
0.3965412676334381,
-0.057217758148908615,
-0.20379140973091125,
-0.844885528087616,
0.10317613929510117,
-0.5130887031555176,
-0.7325230836868286,
-0.5050778985023499,
-0.717761754989624,
0.03108254261314869,
0.01837814971804619,
0.22888478636741638,
0.7266820669174194,
-0.21635465323925018,
0.1355373114347458,
0.007363998796790838,
0.06645731627941132,
0.7325447797775269,
0.17912213504314423,
-0.4316297769546509,
-0.3164811432361603,
0.8165901303291321,
0.3594023585319519,
-0.10016673803329468,
0.19150324165821075,
0.20858648419380188,
0.08192022144794464,
-0.7685801982879639,
-0.652416467666626,
-0.27357375621795654,
-0.5591628551483154,
-0.3416057527065277,
-0.2123911827802658,
-0.18188408017158508,
-0.019615229219198227,
-0.5408253073692322,
-0.14580091834068298,
-0.3754745125770569,
-0.3209401071071625,
-0.41783082485198975,
0.02205563336610794,
0.6148560643196106,
-0.29346808791160583,
0.31854793429374695,
-0.973660945892334,
0.5280255079269409,
-0.03325643762946129,
-0.18481530249118805,
-0.16166159510612488,
-0.030598141252994537,
-0.3826153576374054,
0.05273208022117615,
-0.4178137481212616,
-1.5382816791534424,
0.4091494083404541,
-0.1246025338768959,
0.5307253003120422,
0.21199482679367065,
0.30318278074264526,
0.7751964926719666,
-0.6546856164932251,
0.8541779518127441,
0.14975756406784058,
-0.7616032361984253,
0.8039613962173462,
-0.5292688012123108,
0.5409191846847534,
0.463333398103714,
0.5581240653991699,
-0.30661454796791077,
-0.4033670425415039,
-0.4631630778312683,
-0.6295261979103088,
0.7631329894065857,
0.30208832025527954,
0.10054641962051392,
-0.28772643208503723,
0.32422277331352234,
0.025675790384411812,
0.20906595885753632,
-0.2690413296222687,
0.0972282737493515,
-0.060974277555942535,
-0.10749842971563339,
0.11632205545902252,
-0.0932050421833992,
-0.29510530829429626,
-0.1575205773115158,
-0.0022328351624310017,
-0.03509495034813881,
0.1286398321390152,
0.33783119916915894,
-0.3337353467941284,
-0.12783583998680115,
-0.1076871007680893,
0.16676297783851624,
0.6847990155220032,
-0.05647078529000282,
0.20232054591178894,
-0.25237780809402466,
-0.3884417712688446,
-0.10846938192844391,
0.2125839740037918,
-0.1742376834154129,
-0.014610473066568375,
0.7051559686660767,
0.7270705699920654,
0.36683374643325806,
-0.7750307321548462,
0.6477146148681641,
-0.043036073446273804,
0.010376179590821266,
-0.018399978056550026,
-0.1754187047481537,
0.06733766198158264,
0.6773406267166138,
0.7579039335250854,
0.13026300072669983,
0.3142506778240204,
-0.6535192131996155,
0.3361668884754181,
0.15067164599895477,
-0.16333311796188354,
-0.17654849588871002,
0.5751320123672485,
-0.013292718678712845,
-0.5104751586914062,
0.8161913752555847,
-0.12458275258541107,
-0.3780067265033722,
0.6427682638168335,
0.6548709273338318,
0.7449911236763,
0.19738151133060455,
0.3196766972541809,
0.2941010296344757,
0.42072317004203796,
0.047171059995889664,
-0.3151405453681946,
-0.29903241991996765,
-0.8179839849472046,
-0.256192684173584,
-0.4709688425064087,
-0.32343655824661255,
-0.6906306743621826,
-1.1038594245910645,
0.041771698743104935,
-0.2082034796476364,
-0.4200366735458374,
0.035946980118751526,
-0.30767709016799927,
-0.3831371068954468,
-0.08165650069713593,
0.7335464954376221,
0.8760800957679749,
-0.725200891494751,
0.3911828100681305,
0.33203551173210144,
-0.15614953637123108,
-0.6694883108139038,
0.07784975320100784,
0.6806238293647766,
-0.5953280329704285,
0.11887746304273605,
0.3983803987503052,
0.04465334862470627,
-0.2142978012561798,
-0.46447449922561646,
-0.7212910652160645,
1.0696837902069092,
0.7663039565086365,
-0.3508535325527191,
-0.05223022401332855,
0.2888353168964386,
0.359518826007843,
-0.9722451567649841,
-0.011859962716698647,
0.6660720705986023,
0.4268636703491211,
0.23271110653877258,
-0.5134887099266052,
0.05596623197197914,
-0.15409491956233978,
-0.11903256922960281,
0.15314677357673645,
-0.0882367193698883,
0.2868104577064514,
-0.2176194190979004,
-0.6754913330078125,
-0.376818984746933,
0.5029079914093018,
0.15799537301063538,
0.6847642064094543,
0.25714972615242004,
0.43988534808158875,
0.603798508644104,
-0.3523954749107361,
1.1812649965286255,
-0.14133962988853455,
0.30477410554885864,
1.2434531450271606,
-0.028548602014780045,
0.7818371057510376,
0.3389595150947571,
0.21155981719493866,
0.4995502233505249,
0.5190673470497131,
0.06769301742315292,
0.6722488403320312,
-0.1401863992214203,
0.042580075562000275,
-0.25060197710990906,
0.0006284333649091423,
-0.1653866320848465,
0.8951400518417358,
0.3159831762313843,
-0.3949284851551056,
-0.6767178773880005,
0.33511438965797424,
-0.009857458993792534,
0.39024001359939575,
-0.13295789062976837,
0.5919638276100159,
0.15790773928165436,
-0.5199634432792664,
0.06418067961931229,
-0.07020784169435501,
-0.07311473041772842,
-0.4669579863548279,
-0.16244398057460785,
0.08690812438726425,
-0.502048134803772,
0.012601654045283794,
-0.9109693765640259,
0.9620718359947205,
0.05100039765238762,
-0.3508569598197937,
-0.8957300782203674,
0.7610443234443665,
-0.3335738778114319,
-0.20736375451087952,
0.10753510147333145,
0.6118802428245544,
-0.016764603555202484,
-0.33851510286331177,
-0.26050084829330444,
0.8437349200248718,
-0.18063944578170776,
-0.49568915367126465,
0.309945285320282,
0.3061477541923523,
0.029254434630274773,
0.01011991873383522,
0.6313871145248413,
-0.11893778294324875,
0.0018886540783569217,
-0.2930830717086792,
0.5494945049285889,
-0.7890845537185669,
-0.6300803422927856,
-0.9680019617080688,
0.6539760828018188,
-0.18785908818244934,
-0.39913108944892883,
0.6618317365646362,
0.6184781193733215,
0.5059311389923096,
0.144525945186615,
0.5004609823226929,
0.14497704803943634,
-0.06697506457567215,
-0.37922948598861694,
0.7792741656303406,
-0.22482456266880035,
0.14568950235843658,
0.08964434266090393,
-0.8955904841423035,
-0.40032756328582764,
0.40700140595436096,
-0.32884618639945984,
-0.526525616645813,
0.5231455564498901,
0.43424075841903687,
0.11423014104366302,
0.836318850517273,
0.07862859219312668,
0.11562637984752655,
0.22326764464378357,
0.528560996055603,
0.7954315543174744,
-0.20288363099098206,
0.4505919814109802,
0.09499646723270416,
-0.4204953610897064,
0.09341012686491013,
-0.9212917685508728,
-0.5460405945777893,
-0.9838146567344666,
-0.18945883214473724,
0.01913069374859333,
0.09692756086587906,
0.4507956802845001,
0.8991093039512634,
-0.15322396159172058,
-0.1201879233121872,
0.31766387820243835,
0.35538455843925476,
-0.3832753002643585,
-0.18207257986068726,
0.445465087890625,
-0.07564037293195724,
-0.44411009550094604,
0.5043288469314575,
0.699839174747467,
-0.29882141947746277,
-0.011978951282799244,
0.11252309381961823,
-0.00035281016607768834,
0.1551576852798462,
0.4140118658542633,
0.1807003617286682,
-0.34825602173805237,
-0.46786239743232727,
-0.30589357018470764,
-0.08773989230394363,
0.3397420048713684,
1.1138418912887573,
-1.1194239854812622,
0.7618442177772522,
0.4409525692462921,
0.800604522228241,
1.0865923166275024,
0.08674152940511703,
0.6674029231071472,
-0.7467734217643738,
0.11302860081195831,
-0.013250860385596752,
0.15184719860553741,
0.33391040563583374,
-0.20783545076847076,
0.5924638509750366,
0.36129480600357056,
-0.08328952640295029,
-0.9328411817550659,
0.17475484311580658,
-1.2462949752807617,
-0.3505040407180786,
0.9380677342414856,
0.0582406148314476,
-0.4648745656013489,
-0.15441110730171204,
-0.1978122889995575,
0.04667793586850166,
-0.1056315004825592,
0.5865287184715271,
0.9856441020965576,
-0.053362369537353516,
-0.2537172734737396,
-0.8530774712562561,
-0.07336343079805374,
-0.37261831760406494,
-0.6706352233886719,
-0.18998835980892181,
0.6434897184371948,
-0.15767112374305725,
0.33689823746681213,
0.9074142575263977,
-0.25911545753479004,
0.2746580243110657,
0.2609676420688629,
-0.5675480365753174,
-0.35039085149765015,
-0.37165749073028564,
-0.16462825238704681,
0.9801926016807556,
-0.843073308467865,
-0.39957162737846375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02673v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02673v1
|
On the Information Redundancy in Non-Autoregressive Translation
| 2024-05-04T14:20:28 | 2024-05-04T14:20:28 |
Zhihao Wang, Longyue Wang, Jinsong Su, Junfeng Yao, Zhaopeng Tu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Token repetition is a typical form of multi-modal problem in fully
non-autoregressive translation (NAT). In this work, we revisit the multi-modal
problem in recently proposed NAT models. Our study reveals that these advanced
models have introduced other types of information redundancy errors, which
cannot be measured by the conventional metric - the continuous repetition
ratio. By manually annotating the NAT outputs, we identify two types of
information redundancy errors that correspond well to lexical and reordering
multi-modality problems. Since human annotation is time-consuming and
labor-intensive, we propose automatic metrics to evaluate the two types of
redundant errors. Our metrics allow future studies to evaluate new methods and
gain a more comprehensive understanding of their effectiveness.
|
[
-0.22313249111175537,
-0.6743251085281372,
0.14000079035758972,
0.503643274307251,
-0.3709690272808075,
0.10296422243118286,
-0.05628509074449539,
-0.5086925625801086,
0.3058272898197174,
0.1963595747947693,
-0.41737839579582214,
-0.044275812804698944,
-0.6551843881607056,
0.5128896832466125,
-0.6988596320152283,
0.9873268604278564,
-0.42022696137428284,
0.19576475024223328,
-0.04590895026922226,
-0.5674303770065308,
-0.8233466148376465,
-0.7288124561309814,
-0.5665155649185181,
0.024161741137504578,
0.5507708787918091,
0.23499462008476257,
0.7014341354370117,
0.6005960702896118,
0.7507547736167908,
0.27735525369644165,
0.1284535527229309,
0.5589983463287354,
-0.21160352230072021,
0.0526101253926754,
0.05631466582417488,
-0.3195399343967438,
-0.3996601700782776,
-0.001053431537002325,
1.0285989046096802,
0.8385713696479797,
0.10946176946163177,
0.23175233602523804,
-0.30699393153190613,
0.6793830394744873,
-0.40092089772224426,
0.17174366116523743,
-0.3731718063354492,
0.1561240553855896,
-0.1304403692483902,
-0.40748870372772217,
-0.2297050505876541,
-0.42288365960121155,
-0.09175924956798553,
-0.5714126825332642,
0.22152984142303467,
0.3129121661186218,
0.6935011148452759,
0.4552736282348633,
-0.6645792126655579,
-0.06590219587087631,
-0.9100905060768127,
0.8829807043075562,
-0.5541273355484009,
0.3867417573928833,
0.357550710439682,
0.046635501086711884,
-0.14114688336849213,
-0.325054407119751,
-0.7095933556556702,
-0.22355735301971436,
-0.3778765797615051,
0.008465392515063286,
-0.3029573857784271,
-0.07422792911529541,
0.09900806099176407,
0.3342207074165344,
-0.26693999767303467,
-0.2668873369693756,
-0.5940192937850952,
-0.3141489624977112,
0.4155517518520355,
0.2897273004055023,
0.3937840461730957,
-0.35843124985694885,
-0.6324893236160278,
-0.0012740589445456862,
-0.164653941988945,
-0.3620583713054657,
0.23399536311626434,
0.16717448830604553,
-0.28747665882110596,
0.5401617884635925,
-0.08598246425390244,
1.0321731567382812,
-0.031983520835638046,
-0.2028084695339203,
0.6912573575973511,
-1.2682842016220093,
0.05610903352499008,
-0.22122454643249512,
0.7434698343276978,
0.3199876844882965,
0.04147564619779587,
-0.295528769493103,
-0.417360782623291,
-0.3075573444366455,
0.26503831148147583,
0.03919077292084694,
-0.11422257125377655,
0.02712315507233143,
-0.32949575781822205,
-0.25958770513534546,
0.15493144094944,
-0.5975351929664612,
0.013186194002628326,
-0.41750791668891907,
0.4575405418872833,
-0.38787007331848145,
-0.4951232969760895,
-0.09476303309202194,
-0.3357137143611908,
-0.05239090323448181,
0.43294963240623474,
-0.4948978126049042,
-0.13112708926200867,
0.4804946184158325,
1.167115569114685,
-0.44457411766052246,
-0.6767876744270325,
-0.25607654452323914,
-0.09671946614980698,
-0.4833422303199768,
0.5485374331474304,
-0.2574227750301361,
-0.2703567445278168,
-0.28416907787323,
0.153802290558815,
-0.35483741760253906,
-0.3725704550743103,
0.2703634202480316,
-0.41875287890434265,
0.1459953784942627,
-0.5792675018310547,
-0.28179946541786194,
-0.5252600908279419,
0.4787365794181824,
-0.9825406074523926,
0.8313084840774536,
0.3600931763648987,
-0.8566418290138245,
0.3116549253463745,
-0.6505336761474609,
-0.33762022852897644,
-0.11928287893533707,
0.20350314676761627,
-0.27448001503944397,
0.5030723214149475,
-0.5160739421844482,
-0.17430379986763,
-0.40130341053009033,
0.429122656583786,
0.10546915233135223,
-0.21700800955295563,
0.5438418984413147,
-0.8007079362869263,
0.4674317240715027,
0.11195358633995056,
-0.5061690807342529,
0.10249155759811401,
-0.9550071358680725,
-0.2114201933145523,
-0.048758406192064285,
-0.6304544806480408,
-0.3225696384906769,
-0.27473214268684387,
0.19968725740909576,
0.37097159028053284,
0.40479880571365356,
-0.6085457801818848,
0.08342672884464264,
0.10679381340742111,
0.36354660987854004,
0.570056140422821,
0.0440400131046772,
0.18133333325386047,
-0.6361274123191833,
0.313883513212204,
0.4394112229347229,
0.21619582176208496,
-0.044103167951107025,
-0.5373298525810242,
-1.0013680458068848,
-0.16053900122642517,
0.37064215540885925,
0.5652440786361694,
-0.7619370818138123,
0.13956789672374725,
-0.4364947974681854,
-0.38469845056533813,
-0.3693430721759796,
-0.07698013633489609,
0.6499167680740356,
0.5335130095481873,
0.6146976947784424,
-0.6709169149398804,
-0.6120672225952148,
-0.924563467502594,
-0.08743096143007278,
-0.26072898507118225,
0.496051549911499,
0.13286535441875458,
0.5829828977584839,
-0.420586496591568,
0.8344115614891052,
0.2543392777442932,
-0.31205180287361145,
0.028965938836336136,
0.806140661239624,
-0.2301565259695053,
0.63003009557724,
0.3318234980106354,
-0.8024347424507141,
-0.19326777756214142,
-0.10056857764720917,
-0.6693384051322937,
-0.2622198760509491,
-0.5553675293922424,
0.034236613661050797,
0.57784503698349,
0.27886420488357544,
-0.4621630609035492,
0.4709063470363617,
0.4829541742801666,
-0.29133811593055725,
0.6829315423965454,
-0.18949787318706512,
0.4390225410461426,
-0.7841010689735413,
0.5097149610519409,
-0.3253665268421173,
-0.3209872841835022,
-0.7116657495498657,
-0.3430931866168976,
0.22960421442985535,
0.2552700340747833,
-0.49956053495407104,
0.6795745491981506,
-0.6009988784790039,
-0.2383027970790863,
-0.28607916831970215,
0.10800705850124359,
0.16585275530815125,
0.41007745265960693,
-0.08885682374238968,
0.8509851098060608,
-0.19973289966583252,
-0.5611560940742493,
0.6474584937095642,
0.15380068123340607,
-0.029835309833288193,
0.7162021398544312,
-0.31555110216140747,
-0.10881604999303818,
-0.4712035059928894,
0.26112255454063416,
-1.2276856899261475,
-0.21585926413536072,
0.34885916113853455,
-0.4426206946372986,
0.2032354772090912,
0.018462948501110077,
-0.7760213613510132,
-0.18769708275794983,
-0.13723953068256378,
1.0920872688293457,
-0.005841112695634365,
-0.2966006398200989,
0.2209419310092926,
0.15390382707118988,
0.038262754678726196,
-0.6517634987831116,
-0.8843911290168762,
0.1746130734682083,
-0.05509796366095543,
-0.2344440519809723,
0.013438587076961994,
0.03835069760680199,
-0.10835546255111694,
0.2279849350452423,
-0.027695149183273315,
-0.29295891523361206,
0.16522450745105743,
0.049922600388526917,
0.292834997177124,
-0.03465927764773369,
0.47057393193244934,
-0.3226551115512848,
-0.22297410666942596,
-0.16103574633598328,
-0.2876192033290863,
0.4845101833343506,
-0.29984501004219055,
-0.6874954104423523,
-0.8772761225700378,
0.7562566995620728,
0.888479471206665,
-0.08590530604124069,
0.7160688638687134,
0.5153658390045166,
-0.40030017495155334,
0.7008832693099976,
-0.9146912693977356,
0.19428479671478271,
-0.3008696734905243,
0.5523820519447327,
0.008539507165551186,
-0.42368167638778687,
0.49562254548072815,
0.2857376039028168,
0.34680068492889404,
0.5362451076507568,
0.16891178488731384,
0.13876193761825562,
0.5993989109992981,
0.40602925419807434,
-0.07965832948684692,
0.43359366059303284,
-0.006891793571412563,
0.14026311039924622,
-0.9020815491676331,
-0.5069281458854675,
-0.19144845008850098,
-0.747782289981842,
-0.16568854451179504,
-0.5624914169311523,
0.3279605209827423,
0.20631900429725647,
-0.34816452860832214,
0.4953722357749939,
-0.34948045015335083,
0.2760840654373169,
0.6021865606307983,
-0.5588207840919495,
0.7090953588485718,
0.14618828892707825,
0.03285184130072594,
-0.08797707408666611,
-0.6768812537193298,
-0.1575927585363388,
0.9121852517127991,
0.1288396418094635,
0.5242695212364197,
0.37655916810035706,
0.48996415734291077,
0.3401988446712494,
0.5073932409286499,
-0.6809773445129395,
0.2246633917093277,
0.08511710166931152,
-0.7771850228309631,
-0.30900993943214417,
-0.7612623572349548,
-0.9952793121337891,
0.24055685102939606,
-0.11255969852209091,
-0.4251365065574646,
0.4270135164260864,
0.31431564688682556,
-0.3480331599712372,
0.5623782873153687,
-0.5737981200218201,
0.7940558791160583,
-0.539063036441803,
-0.0035595400258898735,
0.09566096216440201,
-0.6193581223487854,
0.28914040327072144,
-0.531180202960968,
0.4348330497741699,
-0.023527542129158974,
-0.3719747066497803,
0.6678029894828796,
-0.39006054401397705,
0.9514768719673157,
-0.133609339594841,
0.347283273935318,
0.2129395306110382,
0.25480204820632935,
0.5162466168403625,
-0.22110381722450256,
0.10433229058980942,
0.46379518508911133,
0.06683669984340668,
-0.45397892594337463,
-0.3421233296394348,
0.3702731728553772,
-0.7812235951423645,
-0.16643297672271729,
-0.7252429723739624,
-0.5216952562332153,
0.08242247253656387,
0.2823559641838074,
0.30500802397727966,
0.34616684913635254,
0.003179998369887471,
0.15722666680812836,
0.14335018396377563,
-0.059323232620954514,
0.5828449726104736,
0.5386715531349182,
0.09517303854227066,
-0.7124012112617493,
0.979289710521698,
0.4379938244819641,
0.5542095303535461,
0.14218075573444366,
-0.09768243879079819,
-0.24344030022621155,
-0.435372918844223,
-0.5878000855445862,
0.5034211874008179,
-0.7153494954109192,
-0.3850642442703247,
-0.8087930679321289,
-0.17668087780475616,
0.05892517417669296,
-0.03448350355029106,
-0.5800936222076416,
-0.7390863299369812,
-0.5022158622741699,
0.036635760217905045,
0.30599746108055115,
0.6730534434318542,
-0.47083136439323425,
0.24294301867485046,
-1.045676827430725,
0.18717630207538605,
0.06248380243778229,
0.3105735182762146,
0.24258697032928467,
-0.5725695490837097,
-0.21191544830799103,
0.13566100597381592,
-0.15574109554290771,
-0.9711973071098328,
0.43975630402565,
0.04217805340886116,
0.4754500985145569,
0.011726757511496544,
-0.017723269760608673,
0.8442085385322571,
-0.22319135069847107,
0.8607954382896423,
0.5978884100914001,
-0.8645463585853577,
0.05941329896450043,
-0.11502120643854141,
0.32961761951446533,
0.7953699827194214,
0.3206717073917389,
-1.098531723022461,
-0.18406465649604797,
-0.5997113585472107,
-1.1641778945922852,
0.5913286209106445,
0.10199140757322311,
0.08252614736557007,
-0.6244961023330688,
0.4282175302505493,
0.10767535865306854,
0.6052801012992859,
-0.9619399905204773,
-0.32837897539138794,
-0.34976693987846375,
-0.013084898702800274,
0.07275180518627167,
-0.4009856879711151,
-0.17774184048175812,
-0.08123478293418884,
0.6208054423332214,
0.07585152983665466,
0.3367941379547119,
0.44495007395744324,
-0.38193726539611816,
-0.2664073407649994,
0.14602233469486237,
0.9552717804908752,
0.6632639169692993,
0.1584533005952835,
0.13026638329029083,
0.2866556942462921,
-0.17883281409740448,
0.44529932737350464,
-0.30315709114074707,
-0.2790054678916931,
0.4257805347442627,
0.3854672610759735,
0.905981719493866,
0.38341856002807617,
-0.4496549963951111,
0.7126302123069763,
0.02214519865810871,
-0.1009826734662056,
-0.8762993216514587,
-0.5360085368156433,
-0.11340584605932236,
0.0034876682329922915,
0.25732454657554626,
0.4639686346054077,
-0.19358420372009277,
-0.4950234591960907,
0.20646458864212036,
0.4215351641178131,
-0.41419517993927,
-0.46475544571876526,
0.5629803538322449,
0.3292156457901001,
-0.5059664249420166,
0.744638204574585,
-0.49059051275253296,
-0.3585702180862427,
0.41152194142341614,
0.5426464676856995,
0.9069681167602539,
-0.026701126247644424,
0.14884674549102783,
0.47036197781562805,
0.3204507827758789,
-0.5170113444328308,
0.24387429654598236,
-0.046277083456516266,
-0.4497229754924774,
-0.38716045022010803,
-0.5070697069168091,
-0.2830859422683716,
0.06465751677751541,
-0.58415287733078,
-0.007024132180958986,
-0.3940284252166748,
-0.4835740327835083,
-0.26488029956817627,
-0.47440585494041443,
-0.5948107242584229,
-0.16982683539390564,
-0.10528425127267838,
0.5087360143661499,
-0.8523357510566711,
0.42022815346717834,
0.519461452960968,
-0.6123840808868408,
-0.5016761422157288,
-0.062247782945632935,
0.18260005116462708,
-0.5657058954238892,
1.0346791744232178,
0.015783151611685753,
-0.20292668044567108,
-0.19152970612049103,
0.14963091909885406,
-1.3194239139556885,
0.9686357975006104,
-0.017135314643383026,
-0.37741735577583313,
-0.24069024622440338,
0.1827736347913742,
0.44690418243408203,
-0.18458686769008636,
0.16687242686748505,
0.4833703637123108,
0.8664372563362122,
-0.029028447344899178,
-1.301683783531189,
0.034576963633298874,
-0.2820562720298767,
0.05545082688331604,
0.4416195750236511,
-1.0706182718276978,
1.0733544826507568,
0.10277098417282104,
-0.45268186926841736,
0.150857612490654,
0.19659855961799622,
-0.34986481070518494,
0.12709185481071472,
0.5310450792312622,
0.5206955075263977,
0.725524365901947,
-0.10657107084989548,
0.8818700313568115,
-0.3600046932697296,
0.30887284874916077,
1.1125160455703735,
0.2657988369464874,
0.5471412539482117,
0.5696988701820374,
0.016052210703492165,
0.15089400112628937,
0.3758082985877991,
-0.21324113011360168,
0.11444173008203506,
0.14354649186134338,
-0.26776155829429626,
-0.07599245011806488,
0.00640533771365881,
-0.45332348346710205,
0.41003668308258057,
0.19817803800106049,
-0.3814956545829773,
-0.2970391511917114,
-0.11105279624462128,
-0.026799554005265236,
-0.3918007016181946,
0.050419583916664124,
0.7654847502708435,
-0.12369517236948013,
-0.8247343301773071,
1.0137711763381958,
0.32145750522613525,
0.6880964040756226,
-0.3732128441333771,
0.17218823730945587,
-0.46172627806663513,
-0.27701815962791443,
-0.26504626870155334,
-0.10494249314069748,
0.7800337076187134,
-0.09936890006065369,
-0.3061971962451935,
-0.10540972650051117,
0.03275958076119423,
-0.48468080163002014,
-0.5564883947372437,
0.16554000973701477,
0.5333876609802246,
0.3059748113155365,
0.15429070591926575,
-0.5019193291664124,
0.0064850677736103535,
0.11688987165689468,
-0.04963509365916252,
0.08070598542690277,
0.4629223048686981,
-0.3431794047355652,
0.5533751845359802,
0.6062671542167664,
0.22644247114658356,
0.563055694103241,
-0.227177694439888,
0.44096803665161133,
-1.1126022338867188,
-0.3019988536834717,
-0.7956728935241699,
0.3837546706199646,
-0.15463580191135406,
-0.4774758517742157,
0.6405095458030701,
0.45828497409820557,
0.7929465770721436,
-0.027086297050118446,
0.8581740856170654,
0.16486844420433044,
0.39037761092185974,
-0.1302885115146637,
0.36964961886405945,
-0.7064082622528076,
0.3113802969455719,
-0.11289653182029724,
-0.9570544958114624,
-0.3884502351284027,
0.5068826675415039,
0.00040888352668844163,
-0.17304079234600067,
0.9644928574562073,
0.4343380331993103,
-0.08289993554353714,
-0.15479116141796112,
0.18873284757137299,
-0.09761451929807663,
0.14178204536437988,
0.49634668231010437,
0.7215490341186523,
-0.4816046357154846,
0.6577651500701904,
0.008877580985426903,
-0.20789764821529388,
-0.552967369556427,
-0.6936083436012268,
-0.3520817160606384,
-0.8074378371238708,
-0.4794214367866516,
-0.3701343238353729,
-0.11904909461736679,
1.0408518314361572,
0.4984423816204071,
-0.6651790142059326,
-0.08760640025138855,
-0.1309821903705597,
0.15142419934272766,
-0.19500932097434998,
-0.18081901967525482,
0.1454663723707199,
-0.6217716336250305,
-0.6386035084724426,
0.2549450695514679,
0.4135024845600128,
0.6692039966583252,
-0.3126422166824341,
0.32818731665611267,
-0.3178217113018036,
0.16997437179088593,
0.3497774302959442,
0.6376400589942932,
-0.8261623978614807,
-0.5487130880355835,
-0.24510306119918823,
-0.11798813194036484,
0.2570999264717102,
0.8955019116401672,
-0.4519546627998352,
0.780642032623291,
0.5913784503936768,
0.7131174206733704,
0.10770488530397415,
0.3330821990966797,
0.4624963700771332,
-0.8504696488380432,
0.263386607170105,
0.083023801445961,
0.3436763882637024,
0.571177065372467,
-0.09373157471418381,
0.33105868101119995,
0.7883219718933105,
-0.25312134623527527,
-0.8800227642059326,
0.5250269770622253,
-0.7365681529045105,
-0.03659571334719658,
1.329644799232483,
-0.16165894269943237,
-0.012721627950668335,
-0.5915499925613403,
-0.014309579506516457,
0.19635966420173645,
-0.150428906083107,
0.9558811187744141,
1.1031103134155273,
-0.062404148280620575,
0.0769835114479065,
-0.6189321279525757,
0.38231363892555237,
0.5826559066772461,
-0.3636590838432312,
0.05910496786236763,
0.7588830590248108,
0.36985138058662415,
0.70677649974823,
0.9421489834785461,
-0.5144354701042175,
0.3413757085800171,
0.14109793305397034,
-0.15526024997234344,
-0.3682994842529297,
-0.4389553368091583,
-0.24441979825496674,
0.05057385936379433,
0.15534083545207977,
-0.3570650517940521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02659v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02659v2
|
R4: Reinforced Retriever-Reorder-Responder for Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models
| 2024-05-04T12:59:10 | 2024-06-25T09:24:01 |
Taolin Zhang, Dongyang Li, Qizhou Chen, Chengyu Wang, Longtao Huang, Hui Xue, Xiaofeng He, Jun Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented large language models (LLMs) leverage relevant content
retrieved by information retrieval systems to generate correct responses,
aiming to alleviate the hallucination problem. However, existing
retriever-responder methods typically append relevant documents to the prompt
of LLMs to perform text generation tasks without considering the interaction of
fine-grained structural semantics between the retrieved documents and the LLMs.
This issue is particularly important for accurate response generation as LLMs
tend to "lose in the middle" when dealing with input prompts augmented with
lengthy documents. In this work, we propose a new pipeline named "Reinforced
Retriever-Reorder-Responder" (R$^4$) to learn document orderings for
retrieval-augmented LLMs, thereby further enhancing their generation abilities
while the large numbers of parameters of LLMs remain frozen. The reordering
learning process is divided into two steps according to the quality of the
generated responses: document order adjustment and document representation
enhancement. Specifically, document order adjustment aims to organize retrieved
document orderings into beginning, middle, and end positions based on graph
attention learning, which maximizes the reinforced reward of response quality.
Document representation enhancement further refines the representations of
retrieved documents for responses of poor quality via document-level gradient
adversarial learning. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our proposed
pipeline achieves better factual question-answering performance on
knowledge-intensive tasks compared to strong baselines across various public
datasets. The source codes and trained models will be released upon paper
acceptance.
|
[
-0.3682483732700348,
-0.7083762884140015,
0.3651696443557739,
-0.11575097590684891,
-0.07981213182210922,
0.20269779860973358,
-0.06914760917425156,
-0.3689132630825043,
0.2834049165248871,
0.6353458166122437,
-0.49605271220207214,
-0.1954810619354248,
-0.5575358271598816,
0.34417039155960083,
-0.4272899925708771,
0.9837390184402466,
0.06677018105983734,
-0.07404571771621704,
-0.15186358988285065,
0.03294501453638077,
-0.46579083800315857,
-0.5000022053718567,
-0.7239030003547668,
-0.23517252504825592,
0.8820615410804749,
0.2971647083759308,
0.5633795261383057,
0.6252266764640808,
0.4416414499282837,
0.442644327878952,
-0.010649495758116245,
0.1872396469116211,
-0.7216895818710327,
0.3282725214958191,
-0.3180909752845764,
-0.40507516264915466,
-0.47072315216064453,
-0.17080925405025482,
0.6178274154663086,
0.4264402389526367,
-0.13999702036380768,
0.04104484245181084,
0.04605783149600029,
0.6843280792236328,
-0.6915051341056824,
0.0414980910718441,
-0.7285467982292175,
-0.09003828465938568,
0.06296712160110474,
-0.6059510707855225,
-0.6762465834617615,
-0.3189452588558197,
0.05384262651205063,
-0.5045210719108582,
0.7117356061935425,
0.24795584380626678,
0.7402082681655884,
0.20265424251556396,
-0.2388475388288498,
-0.33616554737091064,
-0.3889295756816864,
0.5109984278678894,
-0.5295425057411194,
0.5643666982650757,
0.20180654525756836,
0.25262022018432617,
-0.42588669061660767,
-1.0345385074615479,
-0.6289075016975403,
0.12445054203271866,
-0.1320107877254486,
0.21722523868083954,
0.1252143532037735,
0.06285368651151657,
0.22886231541633606,
0.4438285529613495,
-0.6171768307685852,
0.1585170328617096,
-0.40122050046920776,
-0.25935161113739014,
0.5096262097358704,
0.25343823432922363,
0.030737513676285744,
-0.23573270440101624,
-0.19843952357769012,
-0.2771506607532501,
-0.6110687255859375,
-0.22441381216049194,
0.2686353921890259,
0.39615169167518616,
0.3306120038032532,
0.6062541007995605,
-0.1890041083097458,
0.6420413255691528,
0.5405490398406982,
0.032431308180093765,
0.4149479269981384,
-0.29969319701194763,
-0.27349165081977844,
0.07003550976514816,
0.7073047757148743,
0.14818879961967468,
-0.1659063845872879,
-0.19237561523914337,
-0.5523650050163269,
-0.3049726188182831,
0.7178539633750916,
-0.8928918838500977,
-0.055663980543613434,
0.21308688819408417,
-0.2943219244480133,
-0.2452627718448639,
-0.2613389194011688,
-0.7734931111335754,
-0.3211371600627899,
-0.2821865677833557,
0.22360128164291382,
-0.3287496864795685,
0.09337140619754791,
0.15078072249889374,
0.13829931616783142,
0.2151688188314438,
0.3072434961795807,
-1.089642882347107,
0.28650468587875366,
0.5546459555625916,
0.5792521834373474,
-0.013333586975932121,
-0.22327573597431183,
-1.121159315109253,
0.12404543906450272,
-0.24281291663646698,
0.8835009336471558,
-0.4372531473636627,
-0.23000267148017883,
0.295815646648407,
0.2451462596654892,
0.04632238298654556,
-0.4793771505355835,
0.9123169779777527,
-1.0767532587051392,
0.5320075154304504,
-0.3149452805519104,
-0.39974305033683777,
-0.009822672232985497,
0.5440319776535034,
-0.6681081652641296,
0.9526322484016418,
0.17232033610343933,
-0.9887552857398987,
0.01563001424074173,
-0.1760333925485611,
-0.29779481887817383,
0.12594251334667206,
-0.15985965728759766,
-0.43796753883361816,
-0.03516874462366104,
0.3965488374233246,
0.5554051399230957,
-0.1665954291820526,
0.11434188485145569,
-0.23058946430683136,
-0.36107128858566284,
0.17214557528495789,
-0.39269936084747314,
0.2520725131034851,
0.13029374182224274,
-0.02631307579576969,
0.2506699562072754,
-0.674338161945343,
-0.017661601305007935,
0.20507636666297913,
-0.929806113243103,
0.05715848132967949,
-0.1398005187511444,
-0.0393986776471138,
0.20509041845798492,
0.2955436110496521,
-0.5058474540710449,
-0.0018667092081159353,
-0.6764489412307739,
0.20896689593791962,
0.7632582783699036,
0.0151138324290514,
0.5189982652664185,
-0.3231850266456604,
0.4425640404224396,
-0.23058469593524933,
-0.2511294186115265,
-0.2530660629272461,
0.055257394909858704,
-0.6612542867660522,
-0.15350349247455597,
0.1826210767030716,
0.5214486718177795,
-0.9523259997367859,
0.33720269799232483,
-0.5114021301269531,
-0.11986950039863586,
-0.29310092329978943,
0.14212791621685028,
0.714216411113739,
0.7686826586723328,
0.5152752995491028,
-0.14747515320777893,
-0.5487925410270691,
-0.654484748840332,
-0.04728052392601967,
-0.29436761140823364,
-0.19665265083312988,
0.22512763738632202,
0.22147783637046814,
-0.013715401291847229,
0.5129873752593994,
-0.6075931787490845,
-0.12742768228054047,
-0.23501935601234436,
0.27080249786376953,
0.04178617149591446,
0.10315395146608353,
0.25796273350715637,
-0.7685396075248718,
-0.044028982520103455,
-0.21627892553806305,
-0.5972007513046265,
-0.02041826955974102,
0.07667974382638931,
-0.16386345028877258,
0.4331740736961365,
0.5076595544815063,
-0.6267849802970886,
-0.018544070422649384,
0.18963627517223358,
0.018665598705410957,
0.5759774446487427,
-0.3081720173358917,
0.05558357387781143,
-1.2792261838912964,
0.0429086871445179,
-0.15570133924484253,
-0.14086763560771942,
-0.5609667301177979,
0.11926118284463882,
0.18469011783599854,
-0.1888241469860077,
-0.3614134192466736,
0.43225350975990295,
-0.6225593686103821,
-0.43131762742996216,
-0.4298498332500458,
0.4258909523487091,
0.19087035953998566,
0.5788116455078125,
0.17167599499225616,
0.6963945627212524,
-0.00020315164874773473,
-0.524770200252533,
0.3770413398742676,
0.5768206119537354,
-0.1268766075372696,
0.5050141215324402,
-0.6073659062385559,
0.2200419008731842,
-0.4056670367717743,
0.45384207367897034,
-1.0920912027359009,
-0.3842993378639221,
0.13584262132644653,
-0.6623592376708984,
0.6818283200263977,
-0.061506956815719604,
-0.3807929456233978,
-0.5887073874473572,
-0.3561321198940277,
0.16485874354839325,
0.12001898884773254,
-0.688816487789154,
0.7335014343261719,
0.055668894201517105,
-0.43102920055389404,
-0.9575895667076111,
-0.5496690273284912,
0.04534914344549179,
0.010747543536126614,
-0.6261284351348877,
0.44241195917129517,
-0.19880607724189758,
0.21787786483764648,
-0.131607785820961,
-0.14285041391849518,
-0.026283448562026024,
-0.025179488584399223,
-0.08131217956542969,
0.2844602167606354,
-0.18878118693828583,
0.2024209201335907,
0.007751602213829756,
-0.027785494923591614,
0.20761702954769135,
-0.04173790290951729,
0.46393799781799316,
0.09521981328725815,
-0.13134591281414032,
0.008215178735554218,
0.24226388335227966,
0.5568342804908752,
-0.4116801619529724,
0.6955441236495972,
0.5373871326446533,
-0.26944705843925476,
0.10014123469591141,
-0.6724075078964233,
-0.4340904951095581,
-0.5065346360206604,
0.545523464679718,
-0.5428951382637024,
-1.0031965970993042,
0.3730185925960541,
0.14619387686252594,
0.41412249207496643,
0.14512456953525543,
0.5688207745552063,
0.08290622383356094,
0.914249837398529,
0.19016899168491364,
-0.11082979291677475,
0.5142295360565186,
-0.10491374880075455,
0.3058601915836334,
-0.921338677406311,
-0.2955380380153656,
-0.6018904447555542,
-0.21554158627986908,
-0.32809382677078247,
-0.26478901505470276,
0.029685989022254944,
0.13128474354743958,
-0.32977452874183655,
0.18041542172431946,
-0.5631271004676819,
0.36918210983276367,
0.19572046399116516,
0.21109682321548462,
0.11430875957012177,
0.20147491991519928,
-0.14592549204826355,
0.15937435626983643,
-0.7184667587280273,
-0.41698983311653137,
0.8138055205345154,
0.31941723823547363,
0.7683579325675964,
0.17255309224128723,
0.7453389763832092,
0.10990830510854721,
0.3033791780471802,
-0.7278083562850952,
0.5609202980995178,
0.09400345385074615,
-0.27210304141044617,
-0.3065786063671112,
-0.3723840117454529,
-1.058168649673462,
0.36752936244010925,
-0.23754271864891052,
-0.32020026445388794,
0.15591250360012054,
0.029690438881516457,
-0.43256011605262756,
-0.01912444643676281,
-0.6712088584899902,
0.5385046005249023,
-0.14374472200870514,
-0.6170818209648132,
0.06831281632184982,
-0.7076573371887207,
0.4074617624282837,
0.0026372249703854322,
0.08952320367097855,
0.30661699175834656,
0.07332558929920197,
0.6227697730064392,
-0.38879305124282837,
0.6710572242736816,
-0.07535884529352188,
-0.29926225543022156,
0.11680125445127487,
0.1993468552827835,
0.8904401063919067,
0.05179165303707123,
-0.1772114336490631,
-0.5808990597724915,
-0.34136903285980225,
-0.4051009714603424,
-0.8415296077728271,
0.9272096753120422,
-0.6976643204689026,
-0.9532637596130371,
-0.32518085837364197,
-0.6775241494178772,
-0.2033878117799759,
0.28408166766166687,
0.17760518193244934,
0.7086856961250305,
0.04568253830075264,
0.15137054026126862,
0.824532151222229,
-0.06241663917899132,
0.37503743171691895,
0.6922847628593445,
-0.004688953515142202,
-0.7548176050186157,
0.8448855876922607,
0.11029953509569168,
0.12076473981142044,
0.6710628867149353,
-0.15471722185611725,
-0.6125152111053467,
-0.7579030394554138,
-0.2987607717514038,
0.39622294902801514,
-0.7411357760429382,
-0.41251039505004883,
-1.007433295249939,
-0.269792765378952,
-0.5590982437133789,
-0.3073425889015198,
-0.057276491075754166,
-0.2555919289588928,
-0.4857264757156372,
-0.3877330720424652,
0.09868814051151276,
0.5083225965499878,
0.18671093881130219,
-0.03728079795837402,
-0.9089548587799072,
0.4197705388069153,
0.2753566801548004,
0.17356514930725098,
0.07336656004190445,
-0.7757020592689514,
-0.2393113523721695,
-0.07467479258775711,
-0.4914289712905884,
-0.6161491274833679,
0.4274764657020569,
-0.12569940090179443,
0.5186939835548401,
0.17487108707427979,
0.36118456721305847,
0.5756022334098816,
-0.6308793425559998,
0.580427885055542,
0.06187186390161514,
-0.43303030729293823,
0.37658780813217163,
-0.3631111979484558,
0.19680112600326538,
0.3293083608150482,
0.2455468624830246,
-0.1760999709367752,
-0.3659597635269165,
-0.36329829692840576,
-0.9933212399482727,
0.7283893823623657,
0.07808804512023926,
0.19686658680438995,
-0.47413912415504456,
0.5966187715530396,
-0.10829833149909973,
0.08261819183826447,
-0.4679969251155853,
0.14739002287387848,
-0.4327574670314789,
-0.20908203721046448,
-0.07230229675769806,
-0.4838739335536957,
0.00007418767199851573,
0.2626262903213501,
0.742987871170044,
-0.39288386702537537,
0.33535152673721313,
0.2692229747772217,
-0.12426892668008804,
-0.08617059886455536,
0.4648353159427643,
0.5191516280174255,
0.43804800510406494,
-0.3769867420196533,
0.3462919294834137,
0.1775871068239212,
-0.36225101351737976,
0.16966068744659424,
0.2646104395389557,
0.12590596079826355,
-0.25168800354003906,
0.308147132396698,
0.6674056053161621,
0.256641149520874,
-0.4893920123577118,
0.399583637714386,
-0.19657622277736664,
-0.31581994891166687,
-0.17393748462200165,
-0.05596617981791496,
0.006430026143789291,
0.3196089267730713,
0.48284032940864563,
-0.1742379516363144,
0.15662483870983124,
-0.33216336369514465,
0.32109948992729187,
0.3913862407207489,
-0.18510091304779053,
-0.1779433935880661,
0.6679651737213135,
0.3031822741031647,
-0.3804541230201721,
0.7545890808105469,
0.00834376085549593,
-0.5225868225097656,
0.2604109048843384,
0.8350208401679993,
0.6006265878677368,
-0.18489326536655426,
0.10903389751911163,
0.5535804629325867,
0.0738319605588913,
-0.26565369963645935,
0.22942960262298584,
0.11727359890937805,
-0.7246672511100769,
-0.5294449925422668,
-0.5907504558563232,
-0.11597272753715515,
0.17897829413414001,
-0.7117869853973389,
0.09083041548728943,
-0.49733611941337585,
-0.06152273714542389,
-0.21841606497764587,
0.13647374510765076,
-0.3654041290283203,
0.26961541175842285,
-0.08281368017196655,
0.8367827534675598,
-0.4448646008968353,
0.5769686698913574,
0.5345481634140015,
-0.6286109089851379,
-0.7588644027709961,
0.11343603581190109,
-0.22231410443782806,
-0.630111813545227,
0.811240553855896,
0.13962599635124207,
-0.28072279691696167,
0.2543967366218567,
-0.38145822286605835,
-0.8742066621780396,
1.2080645561218262,
0.4455684423446655,
-0.3903304636478424,
-0.16891710460186005,
-0.2147720605134964,
0.6108903884887695,
-0.228328675031662,
0.5054492950439453,
0.16622701287269592,
0.06627452373504639,
0.47939300537109375,
-0.3847047984600067,
0.3840327858924866,
-0.33528754115104675,
0.198375403881073,
0.3247118890285492,
-0.6328138709068298,
0.4971388280391693,
-0.11591876298189163,
-0.2995149493217468,
0.28266358375549316,
0.9739612936973572,
0.5891035795211792,
0.11697378009557724,
0.225966215133667,
0.6001749038696289,
0.8224689364433289,
0.032989438623189926,
1.1237682104110718,
-0.27320781350135803,
0.09965427219867706,
1.1835089921951294,
-0.4527404308319092,
1.0402950048446655,
0.41811028122901917,
0.03370101749897003,
0.5033036470413208,
0.6212033033370972,
0.2422914057970047,
0.527000904083252,
0.2730571925640106,
-0.33873116970062256,
-0.07470279186964035,
-0.23887519538402557,
-0.3417920172214508,
-0.06653154641389847,
0.34705156087875366,
-0.4140569865703583,
-0.14971256256103516,
-0.13215629756450653,
-0.18645916879177094,
0.13084997236728668,
-0.14439085125923157,
0.7325465083122253,
-0.18016719818115234,
-0.8082696795463562,
0.983456552028656,
-0.011977513320744038,
0.5129460096359253,
-0.3133922517299652,
-0.05161897465586662,
-0.5535608530044556,
0.16527624428272247,
-0.24435801804065704,
-0.928431510925293,
0.1908462792634964,
-0.0225150715559721,
-0.6974482536315918,
-0.21458123624324799,
0.8096818327903748,
-0.46253517270088196,
-0.27293694019317627,
0.3412089943885803,
0.16152772307395935,
0.06074356660246849,
0.20797504484653473,
-0.6507266163825989,
-0.04159064218401909,
-0.16980883479118347,
-0.49607956409454346,
0.5137923955917358,
0.4826270341873169,
-0.017668209969997406,
0.6996365785598755,
0.753898024559021,
-0.32260453701019287,
0.15831907093524933,
0.18767574429512024,
1.081397533416748,
-0.3107028901576996,
-0.27186164259910583,
-0.3340511918067932,
0.3587411642074585,
0.028352005407214165,
0.27532094717025757,
0.5269560217857361,
0.6294611096382141,
0.7386630177497864,
-0.1050262451171875,
0.6004390716552734,
0.05993112176656723,
0.590964674949646,
-0.613084077835083,
0.34942421317100525,
-0.44578590989112854,
0.3471095860004425,
-0.0993063673377037,
-0.9146561622619629,
-0.2917008101940155,
0.3020346760749817,
-0.36363908648490906,
0.05311135575175285,
0.6855054497718811,
1.115625023841858,
-0.0855722725391388,
-0.20935271680355072,
0.2520832121372223,
0.20758585631847382,
0.39548394083976746,
0.49207115173339844,
0.6322262287139893,
-0.6365368366241455,
0.9180488586425781,
0.15947562456130981,
0.13380390405654907,
-0.21772605180740356,
-0.4768284857273102,
-0.8934462070465088,
-0.39611494541168213,
-0.05909287929534912,
-0.6724991202354431,
0.22833251953125,
0.7644821405410767,
0.22022645175457,
-0.5685930252075195,
0.06953185796737671,
-0.20311105251312256,
0.08503612875938416,
0.11491487920284271,
-0.2811480462551117,
0.44606083631515503,
-0.6817507147789001,
-0.6920229196548462,
0.4891349971294403,
0.08252338320016861,
0.05885215476155281,
-0.11429022252559662,
-0.43365731835365295,
-0.3501591682434082,
0.029817748814821243,
0.6281358003616333,
0.38262659311294556,
-0.7233436107635498,
-0.3047909140586853,
0.2555921673774719,
-0.22784927487373352,
0.09783196449279785,
0.6523069143295288,
-0.8640932440757751,
0.3934915363788605,
0.7919431328773499,
1.0080152750015259,
0.45778411626815796,
0.13566073775291443,
0.5885033011436462,
-0.9233194589614868,
-0.156717449426651,
0.012340533547103405,
0.42003682255744934,
0.47045183181762695,
-0.5254529714584351,
0.3921355605125427,
0.12062712758779526,
-0.670069694519043,
-0.705115795135498,
0.2302047461271286,
-0.718277633190155,
-0.12348413467407227,
0.9895663857460022,
-0.2706741988658905,
-0.2961682379245758,
-0.14500172436237335,
-0.40460920333862305,
0.3659055829048157,
-0.4891354739665985,
0.828194260597229,
0.4312710464000702,
0.12978234887123108,
-0.5884875655174255,
-0.2435012012720108,
0.20726756751537323,
0.4990590214729309,
-0.6476947069168091,
0.3308064937591553,
0.838935136795044,
0.2579501271247864,
0.33301910758018494,
0.6625418663024902,
-0.20083598792552948,
0.2503877282142639,
-0.2743453085422516,
-0.00580217968672514,
-0.1792680323123932,
-0.31161585450172424,
-0.2477228194475174,
0.43473169207572937,
0.09562922269105911,
-0.11740973591804504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02650v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02650v1
|
Identifying Narrative Patterns and Outliers in Holocaust Testimonies Using Topic Modeling
| 2024-05-04T12:29:00 | 2024-05-04T12:29:00 |
Maxim Ifergan, Renana Keydar, Omri Abend, Amit Pinchevski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The vast collection of Holocaust survivor testimonies presents invaluable
historical insights but poses challenges for manual analysis. This paper
leverages advanced Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques to explore the
USC Shoah Foundation Holocaust testimony corpus. By treating testimonies as
structured question-and-answer sections, we apply topic modeling to identify
key themes. We experiment with BERTopic, which leverages recent advances in
language modeling technology. We align testimony sections into fixed parts,
revealing the evolution of topics across the corpus of testimonies. This
highlights both a common narrative schema and divergences between subgroups
based on age and gender. We introduce a novel method to identify testimonies
within groups that exhibit atypical topic distributions resembling those of
other groups. This study offers unique insights into the complex narratives of
Holocaust survivors, demonstrating the power of NLP to illuminate historical
discourse and identify potential deviations in survivor experiences.
|
[
-0.2426605224609375,
-0.9440463781356812,
0.7020874619483948,
-0.20545968413352966,
-0.4517306685447693,
0.301032692193985,
0.13350121676921844,
-0.3516440987586975,
-0.06335180997848511,
0.7021282911300659,
-0.7074581980705261,
-0.6334790587425232,
-0.7037187814712524,
-0.17378075420856476,
-0.8748300671577454,
1.2133870124816895,
-0.06803401559591293,
-0.1148223876953125,
-0.1948382556438446,
-0.11012416332960129,
-0.3884880542755127,
-0.6021328568458557,
-0.30992746353149414,
-0.06311357021331787,
0.03144626319408417,
0.3182302415370941,
0.5593400597572327,
0.7957720160484314,
0.5117112398147583,
0.20724989473819733,
-0.1599794179201126,
-0.27293550968170166,
-0.369961678981781,
0.3483809232711792,
-0.1338147073984146,
-0.554338276386261,
0.0029592339415103197,
-0.001944454270415008,
0.39815062284469604,
0.7943030595779419,
-0.12343567609786987,
0.10722441971302032,
-0.3398458957672119,
0.2395406812429428,
-0.28379133343696594,
-0.19209928810596466,
-0.7739684581756592,
0.1675850749015808,
-0.6203769445419312,
-0.3092522919178009,
-0.4963997006416321,
-0.8051339983940125,
0.44659850001335144,
-0.13674473762512207,
1.0580734014511108,
0.002342007588595152,
0.5198301076889038,
-0.07737050950527191,
-0.4434009790420532,
-0.6117008328437805,
-0.4645049571990967,
0.9694356322288513,
-1.0008820295333862,
-0.016014866530895233,
0.6306976079940796,
-0.008127504028379917,
-0.2792142331600189,
-0.6017796993255615,
-0.2327718883752823,
-0.1900414377450943,
-0.2112697809934616,
-0.17625805735588074,
-0.37933075428009033,
-0.41806110739707947,
0.11602667719125748,
0.39091068506240845,
-0.9192079901695251,
0.08074038475751877,
-0.2263953685760498,
-0.41635027527809143,
0.5779185891151428,
0.3685070872306824,
0.6783455610275269,
-0.4788270592689514,
-0.3634757697582245,
-0.1563921570777893,
-0.4279818534851074,
0.09992945939302444,
0.4652799665927887,
0.2557184398174286,
-0.24518294632434845,
0.47130921483039856,
-0.04619738087058067,
0.4461369216442108,
-0.37727463245391846,
-0.09795737266540527,
0.14972728490829468,
-0.045815907418727875,
0.30972805619239807,
0.4052427411079407,
0.28263288736343384,
0.38952967524528503,
0.14219512045383453,
-0.1522422581911087,
0.3594573736190796,
0.21027806401252747,
0.6309491991996765,
-0.6412677764892578,
-0.1350645273923874,
-0.05213812366127968,
-0.9815568923950195,
-0.3163963258266449,
0.061366066336631775,
-1.2000514268875122,
-0.7189534306526184,
0.1720675677061081,
0.018389297649264336,
-0.33230161666870117,
-0.16658152639865875,
0.20753870904445648,
-0.7614691257476807,
0.15291717648506165,
0.2893584668636322,
-0.9457072019577026,
0.4944149851799011,
0.7714831829071045,
0.7416917085647583,
-0.42458105087280273,
0.13696074485778809,
-0.43945831060409546,
0.09393820911645889,
-0.14108602702617645,
0.8600119948387146,
-0.7428078055381775,
-0.5592361092567444,
0.3476563096046448,
-0.09771868586540222,
0.19629532098770142,
-0.4472503066062927,
0.826023280620575,
-0.6360601782798767,
0.47926250100135803,
-0.03383699432015419,
-1.0303981304168701,
-0.42833462357521057,
0.022924214601516724,
-0.36761048436164856,
0.7797097563743591,
0.08625379949808121,
-0.9588462114334106,
0.14058233797550201,
-0.267536997795105,
-0.2188648134469986,
0.029736021533608437,
-0.34890303015708923,
-0.5145325660705566,
0.580371618270874,
-0.09386852383613586,
0.21770645678043365,
-0.3162175118923187,
0.5757951736450195,
-0.3958463966846466,
-0.3205919861793518,
0.2493206262588501,
-0.4946592450141907,
0.730255126953125,
-0.0370924137532711,
-0.3419176936149597,
0.2942088544368744,
-0.9314799904823303,
-0.16932721436023712,
0.3110821843147278,
-0.07990714907646179,
-0.5308529138565063,
0.2738451063632965,
0.20703966915607452,
-0.006889251992106438,
-0.04775172844529152,
-0.47049757838249207,
0.044402673840522766,
-0.5334784388542175,
0.2787625193595886,
0.6427798867225647,
0.5103082656860352,
0.08773699402809143,
-0.30623751878738403,
0.3752986192703247,
-0.049185022711753845,
0.15740935504436493,
-0.26314136385917664,
-0.9347503185272217,
-0.46873000264167786,
0.3458482027053833,
-0.08515971153974533,
0.31168147921562195,
-0.12697206437587738,
0.3419729173183441,
0.21643836796283722,
-0.45568233728408813,
0.02288847602903843,
-0.026686275377869606,
0.14889439940452576,
0.8294579982757568,
0.5619516372680664,
-0.32096734642982483,
-0.5467891693115234,
-1.1870297193527222,
-0.17947617173194885,
-0.5792422294616699,
-0.3014521598815918,
-0.28338053822517395,
0.5913248658180237,
-0.0069823055528104305,
1.0985933542251587,
-0.7060640454292297,
0.16879874467849731,
-0.1710248738527298,
0.8868990540504456,
0.10284720361232758,
0.6765332221984863,
0.5175824761390686,
-1.0794999599456787,
-0.1901548057794571,
-0.1201222762465477,
-0.6904757022857666,
0.014827619306743145,
-0.09234685450792313,
-0.1278095692396164,
-0.12514489889144897,
0.45873963832855225,
-0.2566961944103241,
0.8024603128433228,
0.39143994450569153,
-0.7712936401367188,
0.6957590579986572,
0.01702365092933178,
0.09195408970117569,
-0.87702476978302,
-0.20426572859287262,
-0.21413370966911316,
0.02437259629368782,
-0.7978652715682983,
-0.04119747504591942,
0.007927441038191319,
-0.07498069852590561,
-0.45710626244544983,
0.31198805570602417,
0.13274304568767548,
-0.03035176917910576,
-0.42232465744018555,
0.003961985930800438,
-0.08338742703199387,
0.4896020293235779,
0.3855450749397278,
0.18804772198200226,
0.47169217467308044,
-0.15957410633563995,
0.3737027049064636,
0.6428378820419312,
-0.17324675619602203,
0.39269861578941345,
-0.4286629259586334,
0.19470873475074768,
-0.12758083641529083,
0.216286301612854,
-0.9781382083892822,
-0.3327310085296631,
0.2041337639093399,
-0.2188292145729065,
0.15074998140335083,
-0.002016911981627345,
-0.41371336579322815,
-0.127029150724411,
-0.6417587995529175,
0.4349544048309326,
0.43390733003616333,
0.1270105093717575,
0.6095157861709595,
0.25746801495552063,
-0.5902435779571533,
-0.1538877636194229,
-0.38977721333503723,
0.11609894037246704,
-0.6484494805335999,
-0.4756524860858917,
0.5726246237754822,
-0.25095123052597046,
-0.5866737961769104,
-0.007898587733507156,
-0.2830129861831665,
-0.3749983012676239,
0.16161459684371948,
0.3378588557243347,
0.23207440972328186,
-0.357302188873291,
0.30547377467155457,
0.05752973631024361,
-0.14313891530036926,
0.10949952155351639,
0.4514510929584503,
0.6844500303268433,
-0.10056613385677338,
-0.45293989777565,
-0.3706527352333069,
1.058861255645752,
0.24521858990192413,
0.06001153588294983,
0.7795144319534302,
0.3090623915195465,
-0.49341467022895813,
0.1021033376455307,
-0.7377685904502869,
-0.4124642610549927,
-0.355444997549057,
0.3089955449104309,
0.12006855010986328,
-0.7968575358390808,
0.6817061901092529,
0.026593653485178947,
0.26571375131607056,
0.5087609887123108,
0.6638064980506897,
-0.18974669277668,
0.7704541683197021,
0.6724379658699036,
-0.006415832322090864,
0.5210868120193481,
0.09366469830274582,
-0.06578810513019562,
-0.44098368287086487,
-0.10006186366081238,
-0.689522922039032,
-0.013287682086229324,
-0.39039769768714905,
-0.2826271951198578,
0.13003477454185486,
0.07890944927930832,
-0.17019392549991608,
0.14592646062374115,
0.12634246051311493,
0.0027437196113169193,
0.6708568930625916,
0.23631761968135834,
0.547553300857544,
-0.20027601718902588,
0.40917307138442993,
-0.299478679895401,
-0.3480473756790161,
-0.7929369807243347,
0.858053982257843,
0.30842670798301697,
0.3228854835033417,
0.019856322556734085,
0.5298354029655457,
0.864433228969574,
0.3151710033416748,
-0.28740835189819336,
0.44673413038253784,
-0.15698625147342682,
-0.8066043257713318,
-0.26920613646507263,
-0.14395616948604584,
-0.6877301931381226,
0.10177268087863922,
-0.1574094146490097,
-1.0101439952850342,
0.35279572010040283,
-0.3366575539112091,
-0.45078548789024353,
0.15538938343524933,
-0.28994640707969666,
0.9925547242164612,
0.028749030083417892,
0.264866441488266,
-0.2717995047569275,
-0.9288257360458374,
0.20145218074321747,
-0.25143831968307495,
0.31299740076065063,
-0.33743855357170105,
0.1214546263217926,
0.9138534069061279,
-0.4354775846004486,
0.9558362364768982,
0.24504782259464264,
-0.1756448894739151,
0.32947707176208496,
0.15447060763835907,
0.334038645029068,
0.1312742829322815,
-0.1954440325498581,
0.07422192394733429,
-0.2224731147289276,
-0.44162362813949585,
-0.5739893317222595,
0.3352231979370117,
-0.6034036874771118,
-0.7500277757644653,
-0.09748560935258865,
-0.6213825345039368,
-0.41295126080513,
-0.10762062668800354,
0.17174291610717773,
0.7164623737335205,
-0.38104745745658875,
0.4423997402191162,
0.6957852840423584,
-0.4709772765636444,
0.700150191783905,
0.5685518980026245,
-0.052472393959760666,
-0.08821377903223038,
0.5056118369102478,
-0.27859875559806824,
0.11089814454317093,
0.2879861295223236,
0.40841144323349,
-0.10636290907859802,
-0.8988237380981445,
-0.34692829847335815,
0.2482919842004776,
-0.818246066570282,
-0.011893452145159245,
-0.6896939277648926,
0.010479679331183434,
-0.3414056599140167,
-0.31719619035720825,
-0.251126766204834,
-0.15313521027565002,
-0.37400683760643005,
-0.3724903464317322,
0.28494635224342346,
0.16589012742042542,
0.27738070487976074,
0.4471084475517273,
-0.8444573283195496,
0.6996984481811523,
0.49803173542022705,
-0.23529821634292603,
-0.19353996217250824,
-0.7020989656448364,
0.11878344416618347,
-0.12304714322090149,
-0.27130281925201416,
-1.3414710760116577,
0.29075419902801514,
-0.054918136447668076,
0.6755560040473938,
0.5368280410766602,
0.3522452116012573,
0.5385385751724243,
-0.41516420245170593,
0.8764007687568665,
0.008225496858358383,
-0.9137210845947266,
1.1076775789260864,
-0.5119299292564392,
-0.04286603257060051,
0.52559494972229,
0.43929845094680786,
-0.5661104321479797,
-0.8844259977340698,
-0.8230392336845398,
-0.8889151215553284,
0.6751692891120911,
0.29939377307891846,
0.3206120729446411,
-0.0139605812728405,
0.2054615020751953,
0.6342269778251648,
0.23704811930656433,
-0.6598569750785828,
-0.10318702459335327,
-0.1801147609949112,
-0.2920229136943817,
0.1889408677816391,
-0.45431336760520935,
-0.3191090226173401,
-0.08603516221046448,
0.48244428634643555,
-0.1363285630941391,
-0.08608325570821762,
-0.2752973735332489,
-0.13979512453079224,
-0.242526575922966,
0.26745378971099854,
0.537131667137146,
0.8703927397727966,
-0.2870079278945923,
0.194878488779068,
0.13570214807987213,
-0.3369291126728058,
-0.09284751117229462,
0.12359076738357544,
-0.21846336126327515,
0.23277020454406738,
0.9339430928230286,
0.8305938243865967,
0.5084406137466431,
-1.0459909439086914,
0.6068375110626221,
-0.2555893659591675,
-0.14633437991142273,
-0.23590822517871857,
0.08247935026884079,
-0.045607760548591614,
0.5745701193809509,
0.7243163585662842,
0.0002749076229520142,
0.21176011860370636,
-1.0975265502929688,
0.2729836702346802,
0.163492351770401,
-0.28100207448005676,
-0.13825730979442596,
0.44350817799568176,
-0.20995491743087769,
-0.3650742173194885,
0.9211562871932983,
0.5075624585151672,
-0.4328133165836334,
0.6706692576408386,
0.5675484538078308,
0.6644654273986816,
0.003333871718496084,
0.7362540364265442,
-0.0736265704035759,
-0.10889706760644913,
-0.005658285226672888,
0.0014954596990719438,
-0.10376524925231934,
-0.6528546810150146,
-0.08365796506404877,
-0.7486336827278137,
-0.4987144470214844,
0.006427736021578312,
-1.029229760169983,
-0.08301515132188797,
0.07516948133707047,
-0.01906776800751686,
-0.060716040432453156,
-0.20452791452407837,
-0.3666718006134033,
0.13646024465560913,
0.4473262131214142,
0.6330559253692627,
-1.1298375129699707,
0.47866955399513245,
0.21984250843524933,
-0.227476105093956,
-0.25300461053848267,
0.12109117954969406,
0.003713637823238969,
-0.581483781337738,
0.39475172758102417,
-0.03173019737005234,
0.35838058590888977,
-0.08252231031656265,
-0.19783243536949158,
-0.5945197939872742,
0.6151216626167297,
0.431206613779068,
-0.35639047622680664,
-0.1911766082048416,
0.0797831267118454,
0.6185054183006287,
-0.2509121298789978,
-0.1288881152868271,
0.6244484782218933,
0.4507043659687042,
-0.0507710799574852,
-0.34512341022491455,
0.006568164564669132,
-0.17855742573738098,
0.010382858105003834,
-0.004640400875359774,
-0.21449358761310577,
0.6002344489097595,
0.0477982833981514,
-0.18282397091388702,
0.24391070008277893,
0.734527587890625,
0.4940486550331116,
0.4888141453266144,
0.4347209632396698,
0.2211693525314331,
0.6358612179756165,
-0.09895437955856323,
0.9939848780632019,
0.09099801629781723,
0.12840905785560608,
1.1125257015228271,
-0.044671326875686646,
0.7566623687744141,
0.46191495656967163,
-0.19835729897022247,
0.8582638502120972,
0.6079302430152893,
-0.1032637357711792,
0.6586015820503235,
0.35171595215797424,
-0.27926039695739746,
-0.2658466100692749,
-0.17303170263767242,
-0.5354290008544922,
0.5662647485733032,
0.082354836165905,
-0.4733067750930786,
-0.571292519569397,
0.43809038400650024,
-0.027835296466946602,
0.1751869022846222,
-0.2653954029083252,
0.7423578500747681,
0.027247963473200798,
-0.2398293912410736,
-0.25358447432518005,
0.04470633715391159,
0.3761333227157593,
-0.762133777141571,
-0.17617398500442505,
-0.17584228515625,
-0.040132343769073486,
0.07268347591161728,
-0.5992599129676819,
0.5988635420799255,
0.20603586733341217,
-0.3697253167629242,
-0.33497828245162964,
0.7709280252456665,
-0.15123338997364044,
-0.4995254576206207,
-0.09090980142354965,
0.715956449508667,
0.11862732470035553,
-0.20298540592193604,
-0.47676053643226624,
0.29620176553726196,
-0.029116127640008926,
-0.5201718211174011,
0.37371546030044556,
0.3387368619441986,
-0.4992024004459381,
0.44005247950553894,
0.5430964231491089,
-0.06363309919834137,
0.16695863008499146,
0.4949842393398285,
0.7663775682449341,
-0.8916809558868408,
-0.6180354952812195,
-1.1820988655090332,
0.4587823450565338,
-0.20058226585388184,
-0.6029613018035889,
0.8579071760177612,
0.5285598039627075,
0.5403151512145996,
-0.08079905062913895,
0.41329485177993774,
0.19172823429107666,
0.6139195561408997,
-0.4384201467037201,
0.5329867005348206,
-0.2742673456668854,
-0.11821575462818146,
-0.37864285707473755,
-0.7225589156150818,
-0.2672528624534607,
0.6248864531517029,
-0.26262637972831726,
-0.3812185823917389,
0.44841182231903076,
0.2886747419834137,
0.3855352997779846,
0.7734416723251343,
0.13598552346229553,
0.14059454202651978,
0.3721679151058197,
0.15626664459705353,
1.1247066259384155,
-0.25879913568496704,
0.4084106683731079,
-0.16114403307437897,
-0.0072293756529688835,
-0.43935054540634155,
-0.8861743211746216,
-0.7034573554992676,
-0.573907196521759,
-0.46625950932502747,
0.32409849762916565,
-0.017239218577742577,
0.49841079115867615,
0.5366714000701904,
-1.0819352865219116,
-0.025881441310048103,
-0.21926146745681763,
0.09388773888349533,
-0.34180811047554016,
-0.30799299478530884,
0.5552747249603271,
-0.09031704813241959,
-0.47690460085868835,
0.5716898441314697,
0.3252481520175934,
0.16500374674797058,
-0.20576339960098267,
0.1480792760848999,
-0.19975969195365906,
0.07391328364610672,
0.32625824213027954,
-0.03257075697183609,
-0.8136143088340759,
-0.39960193634033203,
-0.40095239877700806,
0.2510571777820587,
0.06100042909383774,
1.3006840944290161,
-0.5545403361320496,
0.35499313473701477,
0.3004342317581177,
0.5682908296585083,
0.749018132686615,
0.22455157339572906,
0.6433115601539612,
-0.8312087655067444,
0.056188371032476425,
0.5864595770835876,
0.5536095499992371,
0.04959483444690704,
-0.16574670374393463,
0.3924277126789093,
0.45643743872642517,
-0.24012663960456848,
-1.047567367553711,
0.2560313642024994,
-0.945524275302887,
-0.6327940821647644,
0.629796028137207,
-0.25055211782455444,
0.21651171147823334,
-0.6639459729194641,
-0.28596052527427673,
0.3879159986972809,
-0.22639785706996918,
1.0933561325073242,
1.0423405170440674,
-0.3340165615081787,
-0.17955924570560455,
-0.8411379456520081,
0.2582980692386627,
0.17920468747615814,
-0.8499852418899536,
0.17575912177562714,
0.653782844543457,
0.08943241089582443,
0.24884732067584991,
0.4236105680465698,
-0.1591780185699463,
0.23016700148582458,
0.15560045838356018,
-0.2472141832113266,
0.18216130137443542,
-0.10423678159713745,
-0.10023048520088196,
0.775070309638977,
-0.5165769457817078,
0.183759406208992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02637v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02637v1
|
TREC iKAT 2023: A Test Collection for Evaluating Conversational and Interactive Knowledge Assistants
| 2024-05-04T11:22:16 | 2024-05-04T11:22:16 |
Mohammad Aliannejadi, Zahra Abbasiantaeb, Shubham Chatterjee, Jeffery Dalton, Leif Azzopardi
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Conversational information seeking has evolved rapidly in the last few years
with the development of Large Language Models (LLMs), providing the basis for
interpreting and responding in a naturalistic manner to user requests. The
extended TREC Interactive Knowledge Assistance Track (iKAT) collection aims to
enable researchers to test and evaluate their Conversational Search Agents
(CSA). The collection contains a set of 36 personalized dialogues over 20
different topics each coupled with a Personal Text Knowledge Base (PTKB) that
defines the bespoke user personas. A total of 344 turns with approximately
26,000 passages are provided as assessments on relevance, as well as additional
assessments on generated responses over four key dimensions: relevance,
completeness, groundedness, and naturalness. The collection challenges CSA to
efficiently navigate diverse personal contexts, elicit pertinent persona
information, and employ context for relevant conversations. The integration of
a PTKB and the emphasis on decisional search tasks contribute to the uniqueness
of this test collection, making it an essential benchmark for advancing
research in conversational and interactive knowledge assistants.
|
[
-0.751939594745636,
-0.7150256037712097,
0.6154110431671143,
0.13924480974674225,
-0.14256593585014343,
0.5565698146820068,
0.07781119644641876,
-0.631181001663208,
0.14149856567382812,
0.6237995624542236,
-0.5267534852027893,
-0.5147395730018616,
-0.4946710765361786,
0.2452755868434906,
-0.48723846673965454,
0.6547324657440186,
-0.08473696559667587,
-0.3387424647808075,
-0.2548670470714569,
-0.3362431824207306,
-0.8476160764694214,
0.03218806907534599,
-0.5965040326118469,
-0.09550852328538895,
0.6565855741500854,
1.0247093439102173,
0.5437309741973877,
0.2084682136774063,
0.6363617181777954,
0.28612518310546875,
-0.05634358152747154,
-0.028132645413279533,
-0.36322081089019775,
0.38519924879074097,
0.0865795761346817,
-0.42360901832580566,
-0.32802408933639526,
0.10675980150699615,
0.4170774817466736,
0.5810849666595459,
0.00041075082845054567,
0.20756462216377258,
-0.18950825929641724,
0.5261793732643127,
-0.5405352115631104,
0.3268781304359436,
-0.4062322974205017,
-0.10694508999586105,
-0.2460044026374817,
-0.10959085077047348,
-0.4079616367816925,
-0.6164816617965698,
0.817418098449707,
-0.5993496775627136,
-0.21024297177791595,
0.17510491609573364,
0.7142427563667297,
-0.1304556131362915,
-0.9490152597427368,
-0.6564576029777527,
-0.7679773569107056,
0.7593476176261902,
-0.47020673751831055,
0.5466451644897461,
0.5884515643119812,
0.648830235004425,
-0.2329253852367401,
-0.9674375653266907,
-0.6031010746955872,
-0.5465142130851746,
0.10601846873760223,
0.277387410402298,
0.00826952513307333,
0.18518230319023132,
-0.04047287628054619,
0.44302019476890564,
-0.5270400047302246,
-0.34812065958976746,
-0.26569581031799316,
-0.022926418110728264,
0.4031241834163666,
0.20071350038051605,
0.26620805263519287,
-0.32100480794906616,
-0.2091125100851059,
-0.4236791729927063,
-0.42773017287254333,
0.1335906684398651,
0.5001969337463379,
-0.03057575412094593,
-0.03511523827910423,
1.0006046295166016,
-0.45296499133110046,
0.6530748605728149,
-0.07661978900432587,
-0.10653834789991379,
0.15112510323524475,
-0.5064370632171631,
0.07550796866416931,
0.009091448970139027,
0.6468610763549805,
0.10792180895805359,
0.20616641640663147,
-0.0638454332947731,
0.15586422383785248,
-0.38992539048194885,
0.35557252168655396,
-0.39958223700523376,
-0.2582888603210449,
0.2696773111820221,
-0.2644348740577698,
-0.31448113918304443,
0.16564542055130005,
-1.008294701576233,
-0.3963663876056671,
-0.46748244762420654,
0.2836672365665436,
-0.6149952411651611,
-0.23919278383255005,
-0.08186168223619461,
-0.0275917686522007,
0.5128049254417419,
0.14795228838920593,
-0.4140426516532898,
0.18805810809135437,
0.5188665390014648,
0.601081371307373,
-0.45746496319770813,
-0.1395149677991867,
-0.2385459542274475,
0.07236034423112869,
-0.19365447759628296,
0.9611737132072449,
-1.039488434791565,
-0.6270025372505188,
0.0980379581451416,
-0.05899132043123245,
-0.13085539638996124,
-0.3763539493083954,
0.48335662484169006,
-0.7632807493209839,
0.3448520302772522,
-0.5677348971366882,
-0.21017101407051086,
-0.32532206177711487,
0.6405086517333984,
-0.8519461750984192,
1.3805954456329346,
0.46319353580474854,
-0.5163595080375671,
0.4695916175842285,
-1.2182483673095703,
-0.43179017305374146,
0.2794523537158966,
-0.09140868484973907,
-0.24460989236831665,
-0.2362460047006607,
-0.005499120336025953,
0.3589423596858978,
-0.42962315678596497,
0.28743886947631836,
-0.26433923840522766,
-0.440475195646286,
0.38827911019325256,
-0.03318221494555473,
0.28187239170074463,
0.4867628216743469,
-0.607273280620575,
-0.11137315630912781,
-0.7704814076423645,
0.0693582147359848,
-0.035282742232084274,
-0.5755792260169983,
-0.3919731676578522,
-0.21751441061496735,
-0.19339488446712494,
0.05525219067931175,
0.35159921646118164,
-0.6700755953788757,
0.09790481626987457,
-0.2967613935470581,
0.03656158223748207,
0.7653900384902954,
0.22325851023197174,
0.010673969984054565,
-0.2674391269683838,
0.7701668739318848,
0.078316330909729,
0.27114391326904297,
-0.261980265378952,
-0.5979718565940857,
-0.969462513923645,
0.014707759954035282,
0.2871595621109009,
0.35339298844337463,
-0.9760413765907288,
0.3599712550640106,
-0.3711795210838318,
-0.4815230667591095,
-0.5088285803794861,
-0.06032773107290268,
0.3247295320034027,
0.5128326416015625,
0.13879622519016266,
-0.3075195252895355,
-0.6383697390556335,
-0.8594160079956055,
-0.2172553539276123,
-0.3946336507797241,
-0.10672076791524887,
0.8197517991065979,
0.5644532442092896,
-0.2719704806804657,
1.114883542060852,
-0.16198641061782837,
-0.21603815257549286,
-0.5659231543540955,
0.48268505930900574,
-0.2600780725479126,
0.1086672767996788,
0.424263060092926,
-0.9536960124969482,
-0.6580991744995117,
0.31341269612312317,
-0.5181553959846497,
-0.09730527549982071,
0.22225679457187653,
-0.1676459163427353,
0.09454476088285446,
0.14448457956314087,
-0.38018155097961426,
0.4944472908973694,
0.44612130522727966,
-0.5496978163719177,
0.3222208023071289,
0.25776657462120056,
0.7251908183097839,
-1.193877100944519,
0.43158775568008423,
-0.3590497672557831,
-0.1467365026473999,
-0.3695087730884552,
-0.05637694150209427,
-0.2850079834461212,
-0.15353962779045105,
-0.3586350679397583,
0.664489209651947,
-0.3459700644016266,
-0.08139965683221817,
-0.11565058678388596,
0.313050240278244,
-0.10984009504318237,
0.5752264261245728,
-0.17625464498996735,
0.9233013987541199,
0.06707218289375305,
-0.7058601975440979,
0.5010660886764526,
0.6271316409111023,
-0.36478036642074585,
0.9472731351852417,
-0.438411146402359,
0.6479464173316956,
0.19832679629325867,
0.049305450171232224,
-1.138851284980774,
-0.4224216043949127,
0.10285602509975433,
-0.5421043634414673,
0.09212182462215424,
0.2792755961418152,
-0.27884799242019653,
-0.4713480770587921,
-0.3236476480960846,
0.41747555136680603,
0.39283451437950134,
-0.5560062527656555,
1.1312084197998047,
0.5626707673072815,
-0.2969781756401062,
-0.6006131172180176,
-0.4795033037662506,
0.3150806725025177,
-0.09699717909097672,
-0.5270692706108093,
-0.21434806287288666,
-0.24124480783939362,
-0.20113950967788696,
-0.16073235869407654,
-0.16943342983722687,
0.03584494814276695,
0.09303426742553711,
0.16002225875854492,
0.03409716114401817,
-0.23175400495529175,
-0.06010599806904793,
-0.20173707604408264,
0.104159414768219,
0.062448933720588684,
-0.09469068795442581,
0.8536277413368225,
-0.46096888184547424,
-0.5561787486076355,
-0.1752433329820633,
0.31733062863349915,
0.6519747376441956,
-0.08392363786697388,
0.5178519487380981,
0.6166324615478516,
-0.05061196908354759,
0.5627253651618958,
-1.152535080909729,
0.014365009032189846,
-0.5223307013511658,
0.2968604862689972,
-0.5881385803222656,
-1.0612614154815674,
0.6829788684844971,
-0.18555687367916107,
0.07999614626169205,
0.34437549114227295,
0.331624299287796,
-0.21468882262706757,
1.152297019958496,
0.542768657207489,
0.007621795870363712,
0.40100547671318054,
-0.2767682373523712,
0.16938516497612,
-0.9349954724311829,
-0.8898201584815979,
-0.7382121682167053,
-0.31433919072151184,
-0.5009005665779114,
0.027747444808483124,
0.42564940452575684,
-0.7387786507606506,
-0.06684195250272751,
0.41603946685791016,
-0.3396809995174408,
0.35659345984458923,
0.831267237663269,
0.23998042941093445,
0.38897237181663513,
-0.38199031352996826,
-0.39557453989982605,
-0.12103378772735596,
-0.24826382100582123,
-0.47705990076065063,
1.2091675996780396,
0.1919156163930893,
0.48171383142471313,
0.14007318019866943,
0.1683059185743332,
0.6497596502304077,
0.3355330526828766,
-0.9651788473129272,
0.9185607433319092,
0.3038942515850067,
-0.5957568287849426,
-0.27728208899497986,
-0.3909197449684143,
-1.0164719820022583,
-0.34743034839630127,
0.30671900510787964,
-0.7362543940544128,
0.12102296948432922,
-0.026730258017778397,
0.06082339212298393,
0.24031126499176025,
-0.5978124141693115,
0.7657414674758911,
-0.258811354637146,
0.02774479053914547,
-0.07476306706666946,
-0.8526926040649414,
0.48267391324043274,
-0.16068245470523834,
-0.24342292547225952,
-0.12140288203954697,
-0.011868391185998917,
0.8940061330795288,
0.04435344412922859,
0.5252469182014465,
-0.21992385387420654,
0.3686032295227051,
0.46263760328292847,
0.3637314736843109,
0.6818062663078308,
-0.18965286016464233,
0.024287203326821327,
-0.2977890968322754,
0.3236927092075348,
-0.3703831732273102,
-0.33249664306640625,
0.5153679251670837,
-0.700434148311615,
-0.49382495880126953,
-0.5333439707756042,
-0.6170923113822937,
-0.5833908915519714,
0.3378477990627289,
-0.1074526309967041,
0.26122987270355225,
-0.45568087697029114,
0.7589669823646545,
0.8262924551963806,
-0.2646200954914093,
-0.07295943051576614,
0.7223028540611267,
-0.009723189286887646,
-0.3533560633659363,
0.7488735914230347,
-0.2957122027873993,
0.2060745358467102,
0.4987226128578186,
0.27070724964141846,
-0.4951542913913727,
-0.6245384812355042,
0.19643692672252655,
0.05640255659818649,
-0.709868311882019,
-0.19123375415802002,
-0.8970678448677063,
-0.044115178287029266,
-0.6336380243301392,
0.054556168615818024,
-0.16913090646266937,
-0.04819445312023163,
-0.11221948266029358,
-0.13488222658634186,
0.622732937335968,
1.0644370317459106,
0.22440916299819946,
0.6325836777687073,
-0.4827827215194702,
0.3609309792518616,
0.5163981318473816,
0.4095994234085083,
-0.3453438878059387,
-0.5200488567352295,
-0.06559654325246811,
0.0004971446469426155,
-0.426910936832428,
-0.7986316680908203,
0.20103293657302856,
0.0769595056772232,
0.5677115321159363,
0.268311470746994,
0.19667915999889374,
0.7387859225273132,
0.15109573304653168,
0.8854918479919434,
-0.03638681024312973,
-0.7069726586341858,
0.6120057702064514,
-0.425074964761734,
0.5786871910095215,
1.0854748487472534,
0.4678238034248352,
-0.8862522840499878,
-0.5365692973136902,
-0.6169355511665344,
-0.7160313129425049,
0.917946994304657,
0.23940473794937134,
-0.17146983742713928,
-0.15818952023983002,
0.2522308826446533,
0.10075255483388901,
0.26860764622688293,
-0.43412691354751587,
-0.01304952334612608,
-0.10440424084663391,
-0.5320841670036316,
0.45496147871017456,
-0.607254683971405,
-0.09236077219247818,
0.059800613671541214,
0.7610833644866943,
-0.2932939827442169,
0.41064056754112244,
0.15809857845306396,
0.09527996182441711,
-0.030900035053491592,
0.28979063034057617,
0.41722339391708374,
0.5760275721549988,
-0.45304548740386963,
0.04836736619472504,
0.4250383973121643,
-1.095512866973877,
0.028917346149683,
0.0529438853263855,
0.04195524379611015,
-0.21742625534534454,
-0.07465662062168121,
0.6608187556266785,
0.33477187156677246,
-1.0241827964782715,
0.3799901604652405,
-0.36573219299316406,
-0.09457909315824509,
-0.7362047433853149,
-0.11632516980171204,
-0.09631092846393585,
-0.015370958484709263,
0.34432050585746765,
-0.04936446249485016,
0.33882322907447815,
-0.5083791017532349,
0.3451332151889801,
0.3443855345249176,
-0.7198483943939209,
-0.30661457777023315,
0.43892866373062134,
0.34614843130111694,
-0.3480530381202698,
0.766437828540802,
0.018144531175494194,
-0.47717392444610596,
0.48994091153144836,
-0.0260616485029459,
0.9771453142166138,
-0.2790156900882721,
0.3489797115325928,
0.0698821097612381,
0.3151467442512512,
0.09815268218517303,
0.313959538936615,
-0.34722843766212463,
-0.37881094217300415,
-0.19823822379112244,
-0.4364379644393921,
-0.893841028213501,
0.4395441710948944,
-0.7069234848022461,
0.36562663316726685,
0.062445931136608124,
-0.012455505318939686,
-0.4279801547527313,
0.4290909171104431,
-0.961150586605072,
0.07198713719844818,
-0.25172263383865356,
1.1525629758834839,
-0.36643314361572266,
0.5527921915054321,
0.5841851830482483,
-0.24283257126808167,
-0.7461316585540771,
-0.1915559023618698,
-0.01579701341688633,
-1.0480536222457886,
0.3591042459011078,
0.049585241824388504,
-0.21530897915363312,
-0.0887724757194519,
-0.5652509331703186,
-0.903584361076355,
1.313876986503601,
0.18105864524841309,
-0.2740778625011444,
-0.1027534082531929,
0.8371701836585999,
0.4948366582393646,
-0.24773691594600677,
0.6465028524398804,
1.156403660774231,
0.889908492565155,
0.6391273140907288,
-0.9283989667892456,
-0.17162886261940002,
-0.26071515679359436,
-0.25620365142822266,
0.02337142825126648,
-0.6764554381370544,
0.22411122918128967,
0.11177881807088852,
-0.1605716496706009,
0.5246953368186951,
0.4604063928127289,
0.5527129769325256,
0.541756272315979,
0.6792090535163879,
0.32943040132522583,
0.48929548263549805,
-0.4320339560508728,
1.104095458984375,
-0.13378779590129852,
-0.13224159181118011,
1.1206793785095215,
-0.3684581518173218,
0.4979807436466217,
0.5392205715179443,
-0.013981944881379604,
0.41459783911705017,
0.763157069683075,
0.2568500339984894,
0.345257967710495,
-0.1511116772890091,
-0.30630525946617126,
-0.08534406870603561,
-0.48434093594551086,
-0.12485842406749725,
0.5624161958694458,
0.3964770436286926,
-0.09689895808696747,
0.08464048057794571,
0.3347872197628021,
0.010301921516656876,
-0.02313312143087387,
0.19989906251430511,
0.9863256812095642,
-0.11581259965896606,
-0.9893394708633423,
-0.12492834776639938,
-0.43864428997039795,
0.3392972946166992,
-0.8910173773765564,
-0.1417916864156723,
-0.32156339287757874,
0.0948801189661026,
0.25176841020584106,
-1.0193800926208496,
-0.002383706858381629,
-0.13678576052188873,
0.5629997849464417,
-0.08057177811861038,
0.7776064872741699,
-0.23449115455150604,
-0.3195396959781647,
0.20887725055217743,
0.43904948234558105,
0.3246830403804779,
-0.004633298143744469,
-0.5943037271499634,
0.02478988841176033,
0.07886936515569687,
-0.7435898184776306,
0.09024908393621445,
0.4923732876777649,
0.011582665145397186,
0.9413051605224609,
0.5739016532897949,
-0.06835579872131348,
0.15133416652679443,
0.09613483399152756,
0.8634539246559143,
-0.862450122833252,
-0.2632700800895691,
-0.14287534356117249,
0.42531904578208923,
-0.12644769251346588,
-0.5793539881706238,
0.5320254564285278,
0.7096066474914551,
0.7018576860427856,
0.021120917052030563,
0.7825841903686523,
-0.32353705167770386,
0.8123342394828796,
-0.27226805686950684,
0.3584528863430023,
-0.3835160732269287,
0.2816759943962097,
-0.13436627388000488,
-0.732689380645752,
0.029670052230358124,
0.22820401191711426,
-0.26526308059692383,
0.3281731903553009,
0.7152701616287231,
0.4129525125026703,
-0.05311380326747894,
0.34025001525878906,
0.31591108441352844,
0.0956154391169548,
0.60780268907547,
0.5655039548873901,
1.215021014213562,
-0.47329631447792053,
1.1329214572906494,
-0.37410300970077515,
0.024289269000291824,
-0.33289390802383423,
-0.74716717004776,
-1.0428818464279175,
-0.8210101127624512,
-0.07656312733888626,
-0.133070707321167,
0.09190782904624939,
0.7736331224441528,
0.5078833699226379,
-0.9640018939971924,
-0.1874970942735672,
-0.1360318958759308,
0.012655983678996563,
0.06516366451978683,
-0.3633015751838684,
0.10173831880092621,
-0.0720377266407013,
-0.810636043548584,
0.39784857630729675,
0.21287456154823303,
0.26278290152549744,
-0.4647297263145447,
-0.11736614257097244,
-0.3511563837528229,
0.0364692360162735,
0.5029433965682983,
0.49310070276260376,
-0.6029413342475891,
-0.6931262016296387,
0.8105368614196777,
0.102898009121418,
0.06940896064043045,
0.9612131118774414,
-0.9300395846366882,
0.8497567176818848,
0.46516990661621094,
0.586094081401825,
0.7523719668388367,
-0.057681843638420105,
0.8220696449279785,
-0.6842564344406128,
-0.06754063069820404,
0.7225807309150696,
0.09425584971904755,
0.19702009856700897,
-0.32192936539649963,
0.717705249786377,
-0.06752295047044754,
-0.65511155128479,
-1.031894564628601,
-0.023963607847690582,
-1.440761923789978,
0.30490848422050476,
1.0271649360656738,
-0.03349752724170685,
-0.09630117565393448,
-0.6441526412963867,
-0.44971778988838196,
0.2450011819601059,
-0.5822467803955078,
1.0293676853179932,
0.8126501441001892,
-0.16179534792900085,
-0.26956623792648315,
-0.5913589596748352,
0.31673601269721985,
0.409471720457077,
-1.1203879117965698,
-0.2633911967277527,
0.11752668768167496,
0.12856918573379517,
0.19697363674640656,
0.3936261534690857,
-0.36915120482444763,
0.4066528379917145,
-0.4613957405090332,
0.1448763906955719,
-0.06462819874286652,
-0.45953187346458435,
0.16400833427906036,
0.01169105526059866,
0.16172783076763153,
-0.08589733392000198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02602v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02602v1
|
Astro-NER -- Astronomy Named Entity Recognition: Is GPT a Good Domain Expert Annotator?
| 2024-05-04T08:04:39 | 2024-05-04T08:04:39 |
Julia Evans, Sameer Sadruddin, Jennifer D'Souza
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, math.IT
|
In this study, we address one of the challenges of developing NER models for
scholarly domains, namely the scarcity of suitable labeled data. We experiment
with an approach using predictions from a fine-tuned LLM model to aid
non-domain experts in annotating scientific entities within astronomy
literature, with the goal of uncovering whether such a collaborative process
can approximate domain expertise. Our results reveal moderate agreement between
a domain expert and the LLM-assisted non-experts, as well as fair agreement
between the domain expert and the LLM model's predictions. In an additional
experiment, we compare the performance of finetuned and default LLMs on this
task. We have also introduced a specialized scientific entity annotation scheme
for astronomy, validated by a domain expert. Our approach adopts a scholarly
research contribution-centric perspective, focusing exclusively on scientific
entities relevant to the research theme. The resultant dataset, containing
5,000 annotated astronomy article titles, is made publicly available.
|
[
-0.5156640410423279,
-0.3681001365184784,
0.703499436378479,
-0.22715424001216888,
-0.17261697351932526,
-0.01307722833007574,
-0.2426862120628357,
-0.9686254858970642,
0.6528087258338928,
0.7394696474075317,
-0.3618263900279999,
-0.44020602107048035,
-0.9550556540489197,
0.5126286745071411,
-0.5118206143379211,
1.3668402433395386,
0.16317087411880493,
-0.09510387480258942,
-0.6366540789604187,
0.2610999345779419,
-0.2243986278772354,
-0.1725117266178131,
-0.8852846026420593,
-0.2057410329580307,
0.7624303698539734,
0.2583919167518616,
0.6516615748405457,
0.7285832166671753,
1.0898463726043701,
0.25455591082572937,
-0.19787228107452393,
0.498655766248703,
-0.42599165439605713,
-0.13529029488563538,
-0.4778461456298828,
-0.1211545541882515,
-0.7551495432853699,
0.12003816664218903,
0.2798469662666321,
0.8204760551452637,
0.12792281806468964,
0.22468291223049164,
-0.04802512004971504,
0.298283189535141,
-0.29164618253707886,
0.20003215968608856,
-0.9876998662948608,
-0.13766613602638245,
-0.5458166599273682,
-0.28693464398384094,
-0.3010724186897278,
-0.2828432321548462,
0.30894461274147034,
-1.454628348350525,
0.4072186052799225,
0.49200737476348877,
0.9385861158370972,
0.6827629208564758,
-0.23558580875396729,
-0.41117385029792786,
-0.9290116429328918,
0.6796835660934448,
-0.4340251386165619,
0.08823782205581665,
0.43586018681526184,
0.1390606313943863,
-0.18190088868141174,
-0.6495100259780884,
-0.4918060302734375,
-0.21758699417114258,
-0.07935117185115814,
0.0879332646727562,
0.007142147980630398,
-0.1400112360715866,
0.12077481299638748,
-0.07858208566904068,
-0.3566882610321045,
0.17415565252304077,
-0.4242981970310211,
-0.19559209048748016,
0.5833136439323425,
0.10110554099082947,
-0.18289396166801453,
-0.27691009640693665,
-0.24453915655612946,
0.4106518626213074,
-0.6824765205383301,
-0.6158102750778198,
0.3870127499103546,
0.20432215929031372,
0.4632362425327301,
0.8552094101905823,
-0.15575264394283295,
0.48048868775367737,
0.5682948231697083,
-0.018259841948747635,
-0.10925912857055664,
-0.11892729997634888,
-0.10260405391454697,
-0.06193818897008896,
0.5241000652313232,
0.40599602460861206,
0.24767754971981049,
-0.6658782958984375,
0.0015437875408679247,
0.12299328297376633,
0.2606501877307892,
-0.42255866527557373,
-0.525025486946106,
-0.0055006565526127815,
-0.05138590186834335,
-0.11376387625932693,
0.00808026548475027,
-0.6434971690177917,
-0.5836588144302368,
-0.5452761054039001,
0.654757559299469,
-0.2341487556695938,
0.005148386582732201,
-0.1609800010919571,
0.11137348413467407,
-0.26211145520210266,
0.7775517702102661,
-0.9133278131484985,
0.40328502655029297,
0.9429856538772583,
0.5607632398605347,
-0.06376274675130844,
-0.2248869091272354,
-0.20239293575286865,
0.2448645979166031,
-0.13475169241428375,
1.0340869426727295,
-0.7452377676963806,
-0.47747746109962463,
-0.6130469441413879,
-0.10133277624845505,
-0.04077812656760216,
-0.40490972995758057,
0.539066731929779,
-0.9641562700271606,
0.0905783474445343,
-0.13912521302700043,
-0.9472872614860535,
-0.2732878029346466,
-0.08853457123041153,
-0.6670819520950317,
0.7803446650505066,
-0.07706547528505325,
-0.7315790057182312,
0.9070765376091003,
-0.6759714484214783,
0.22415965795516968,
0.6231767535209656,
-0.2407713383436203,
-0.41128435730934143,
0.035068247467279434,
0.17171818017959595,
0.30554744601249695,
0.01129262987524271,
0.348604291677475,
-0.3167198598384857,
-0.0439286008477211,
0.34280315041542053,
0.04506148025393486,
-0.0604429729282856,
0.15013088285923004,
-0.07925410568714142,
-0.1272536963224411,
-0.6684365272521973,
-0.10002344846725464,
-0.18950675427913666,
0.1021917462348938,
-0.6990106105804443,
0.002032593823969364,
0.3251323103904724,
-0.1885644942522049,
0.4789162278175354,
-0.5629178881645203,
0.5528801083564758,
-0.22379589080810547,
-0.021094266325235367,
0.5623213648796082,
0.18836356699466705,
0.7021250128746033,
-0.06718749552965164,
0.23769623041152954,
-0.22233904898166656,
-0.002923517720773816,
0.375110000371933,
-0.7127212285995483,
-0.6791963577270508,
-0.0894140675663948,
0.5393165349960327,
0.24238304793834686,
-0.5234754681587219,
0.1807609498500824,
-0.09083627164363861,
-0.7319100499153137,
-0.4745244085788727,
0.08947090059518814,
0.5701428651809692,
0.7693667411804199,
0.5414071083068848,
-0.34254398941993713,
-0.6699233055114746,
-0.8121441006660461,
-0.20647509396076202,
-0.2106626331806183,
0.16423876583576202,
0.7428919076919556,
0.9975522756576538,
-0.2819729745388031,
0.9178644418716431,
-0.4130835235118866,
-0.3494681715965271,
0.6034715175628662,
0.3284173309803009,
0.14006143808364868,
0.20419888198375702,
0.18431127071380615,
-0.7864885330200195,
-0.4166494607925415,
0.24734732508659363,
-0.7606290578842163,
-0.14518088102340698,
0.051707446575164795,
-0.013095374219119549,
0.23070845007896423,
0.3284139931201935,
-0.5119240880012512,
0.3124040961265564,
0.3161925673484802,
-0.46620744466781616,
0.5502422451972961,
-0.19420544803142548,
0.16618864238262177,
-0.8458866477012634,
0.36280471086502075,
0.25885772705078125,
-0.06487692147493362,
-0.46969208121299744,
-0.2176458239555359,
-0.09701437503099442,
0.14896677434444427,
-0.19654807448387146,
0.6625992655754089,
-0.5609543323516846,
-0.11842706799507141,
-0.6517016887664795,
0.09296969324350357,
-0.2783922255039215,
-0.16669917106628418,
0.6331693530082703,
0.6861144304275513,
0.46631667017936707,
-0.5702593326568604,
0.08544269949197769,
0.5938832759857178,
-0.1860092282295227,
0.6454387903213501,
-0.594211220741272,
0.36956673860549927,
-0.215128093957901,
0.034523025155067444,
-0.46191635727882385,
-0.5194811224937439,
0.1950591653585434,
-0.4243816137313843,
0.3768201768398285,
-0.607196033000946,
-0.19197611510753632,
-0.2236405462026596,
0.5936952829360962,
0.30140936374664307,
0.18616034090518951,
-0.3491955101490021,
0.4833105504512787,
0.47056257724761963,
-0.40360310673713684,
-0.7746312022209167,
-0.18537123501300812,
0.4628618359565735,
-0.44799336791038513,
-0.5569857358932495,
0.8302311897277832,
0.13447733223438263,
-0.3427645266056061,
0.472202330827713,
0.02078736014664173,
-0.02416849136352539,
0.050401460379362106,
0.5470941066741943,
0.44914212822914124,
-0.05643526464700699,
0.06465768069028854,
-0.4521051049232483,
-0.6007636189460754,
0.024806195870041847,
-0.568052351474762,
-0.1934271603822708,
-0.2493475377559662,
-0.11141223460435867,
-0.1488976925611496,
0.09994953870773315,
0.0375429168343544,
0.02726777456700802,
0.4132101237773895,
0.44329217076301575,
-0.5751560926437378,
0.02290043979883194,
-0.6124787330627441,
-0.3079780638217926,
-0.3998141288757324,
0.13306337594985962,
-0.18535132706165314,
-0.9389002919197083,
0.5488102436065674,
-0.013257833197712898,
-0.055927615612745285,
0.7765964865684509,
0.24521863460540771,
-0.24602222442626953,
0.3368717432022095,
0.7677411437034607,
0.05530630052089691,
-0.11146633327007294,
-0.3121293783187866,
-0.019572319462895393,
-0.8947509527206421,
-0.4211433231830597,
-0.6385104060173035,
-0.2622726559638977,
-0.4320386052131653,
-0.6203632950782776,
0.34374451637268066,
-0.102524034678936,
0.024053936824202538,
0.6165956854820251,
-0.8046315908432007,
0.7800872921943665,
0.4749603569507599,
-0.2111620008945465,
0.40138986706733704,
-0.17495809495449066,
0.48830416798591614,
-0.36913397908210754,
-0.21883165836334229,
-0.9217957258224487,
1.131356120109558,
0.0700245127081871,
0.9465476274490356,
-0.13585183024406433,
0.910591185092926,
0.039042387157678604,
0.660496711730957,
-0.5201834440231323,
0.4907892644405365,
-0.21063818037509918,
-0.7773801684379578,
-0.25219130516052246,
-0.37953981757164,
-0.7293914556503296,
-0.18190249800682068,
-0.43424248695373535,
-0.6333686113357544,
0.536666214466095,
-0.047851499170064926,
-0.39653417468070984,
0.21291975677013397,
-0.3134409785270691,
0.5186640024185181,
-0.07032458484172821,
-0.20275041460990906,
-0.003074843669310212,
-0.477871298789978,
0.04670196399092674,
-0.5030757784843445,
0.20128656923770905,
-0.15012317895889282,
-0.4212564527988434,
1.0396337509155273,
-0.05767648667097092,
0.7490915060043335,
-0.30756545066833496,
0.19071456789970398,
0.24265050888061523,
0.14421795308589935,
0.4981352984905243,
0.5054954886436462,
-0.08133720606565475,
0.21589425206184387,
-0.3306589424610138,
-0.13614466786384583,
-0.23610694706439972,
0.9025362730026245,
-0.9316593408584595,
-0.6642904281616211,
-0.6091289520263672,
-0.4860665798187256,
-0.08000288158655167,
0.23428288102149963,
0.25205302238464355,
0.11294665932655334,
-0.11466319113969803,
-0.006284697446972132,
0.6738489866256714,
0.3163522779941559,
0.1973882019519806,
0.5382523536682129,
-0.21152356266975403,
-0.6065748333930969,
0.7133665680885315,
0.29978176951408386,
-0.25300073623657227,
0.43985995650291443,
-0.2853246331214905,
-0.265182226896286,
-1.0192948579788208,
-0.26141834259033203,
0.1865786761045456,
-0.5512245297431946,
-0.2845100164413452,
-0.7985071539878845,
-0.03862902149558067,
-0.0625070258975029,
-0.3841884136199951,
-0.3014443516731262,
-0.7015960812568665,
-0.7917656898498535,
-0.10189518332481384,
0.7791288495063782,
0.8861067295074463,
0.0845700278878212,
0.09025286883115768,
-0.3625066876411438,
-0.06285342574119568,
0.023466162383556366,
0.17226038873195648,
-0.39500367641448975,
-0.599743127822876,
-0.5028725266456604,
-0.34882456064224243,
-0.1885436475276947,
-0.5688312649726868,
0.4895685613155365,
0.4679093062877655,
0.4248977601528168,
0.23648351430892944,
-0.15730692446231842,
0.7218040227890015,
-0.4820326864719391,
0.6366806626319885,
-0.06162410229444504,
-0.5600882172584534,
0.34718966484069824,
-0.5658822059631348,
-0.3624074161052704,
0.7185237407684326,
0.4673928916454315,
-0.21444030106067657,
-0.5389342308044434,
-0.8413793444633484,
-0.7950452566146851,
0.3755491375923157,
0.19086210429668427,
-0.10958290100097656,
-0.055883828550577164,
0.8702115416526794,
0.5756094455718994,
0.185114786028862,
-0.7031072378158569,
-0.22943080961704254,
-0.14781776070594788,
0.15402834117412567,
-0.18508689105510712,
0.12482249736785889,
0.006267099175602198,
0.24584048986434937,
0.7899720072746277,
-0.14656856656074524,
0.31254708766937256,
0.3963346481323242,
0.0304414089769125,
-0.38153621554374695,
0.12620438635349274,
0.39650261402130127,
0.7018718123435974,
-0.30734798312187195,
0.10734004527330399,
0.14124061167240143,
-0.5732742547988892,
-0.1949876844882965,
0.4173075258731842,
-0.4817401170730591,
-0.02475373074412346,
0.2807621359825134,
0.48975637555122375,
0.15309369564056396,
0.06353358179330826,
-0.027392370626330376,
0.23869216442108154,
-0.3460124731063843,
-0.4891508221626282,
0.03525032848119736,
0.26206618547439575,
0.22030167281627655,
0.6644394397735596,
0.5400239825248718,
0.34551969170570374,
0.1304672509431839,
0.2537173926830292,
0.5230305194854736,
-0.21800433099269867,
-0.4592816233634949,
1.1380085945129395,
0.18153654038906097,
-0.05026751756668091,
0.27657049894332886,
-0.35720697045326233,
-0.21795859932899475,
0.7948110699653625,
0.276579886674881,
0.6739992499351501,
0.17278793454170227,
0.14989325404167175,
0.19684867560863495,
0.17444375157356262,
0.11963723599910736,
0.07929345220327377,
0.34692180156707764,
-0.46132370829582214,
-0.7694091200828552,
-0.5718690156936646,
-1.028327226638794,
-0.16621986031532288,
-0.3286624848842621,
0.3629140257835388,
-0.3751383125782013,
-0.5835084915161133,
0.8686100840568542,
0.4923376142978668,
-0.8804991841316223,
0.3020149767398834,
0.21762840449810028,
0.6660638451576233,
-0.5743458271026611,
0.6005327701568604,
0.9605355262756348,
-0.49184292554855347,
-0.6502975821495056,
-0.4477245509624481,
0.11206020414829254,
-0.5000796318054199,
1.0539277791976929,
-0.07299845665693283,
-0.0012809619074687362,
0.1346156895160675,
-0.4321897327899933,
-1.1343119144439697,
1.2322959899902344,
-0.03567126393318176,
-0.8447301387786865,
0.06451550126075745,
-0.15281186997890472,
0.7519042491912842,
-0.5976108312606812,
0.5386683344841003,
-0.16830497980117798,
0.8585254549980164,
0.2706415355205536,
-1.0629138946533203,
-0.1890021413564682,
-0.2507082521915436,
-0.262746661901474,
0.48259639739990234,
-0.528746485710144,
0.6765381693840027,
-0.42930150032043457,
-0.027033325284719467,
0.26169726252555847,
0.9704732894897461,
0.06775715202093124,
0.9923215508460999,
0.18934094905853271,
0.6492788791656494,
1.064561128616333,
-0.15523409843444824,
0.7603376507759094,
-0.2381722331047058,
0.5686579942703247,
0.746783971786499,
-0.49569475650787354,
0.6210815906524658,
0.7780619859695435,
-0.16123025119304657,
0.26832664012908936,
0.8082084655761719,
-0.5238858461380005,
0.5697188377380371,
-0.1177457869052887,
-0.1987624168395996,
-0.17134293913841248,
-0.38794663548469543,
-0.3146240711212158,
0.1632978618144989,
0.48994502425193787,
-0.22310838103294373,
0.053783055394887924,
-0.20473334193229675,
0.053138330578804016,
0.04779757559299469,
-0.49594825506210327,
0.9197863340377808,
0.2941892147064209,
-0.5506851077079773,
0.03375474363565445,
0.02088913507759571,
0.8646979928016663,
-0.2045232504606247,
0.1679995208978653,
0.11831290274858475,
-0.026173019781708717,
-0.6420337557792664,
-0.7420427203178406,
0.5025468468666077,
0.20137391984462738,
-0.39555490016937256,
0.11049089580774307,
0.9235824942588806,
-0.372957706451416,
-0.5929231643676758,
0.09425444900989532,
0.4998779594898224,
0.47866249084472656,
0.15066727995872498,
-0.22379671037197113,
-0.5308895111083984,
-0.2936919033527374,
-0.1932823807001114,
0.27217504382133484,
0.4073009490966797,
-0.12043052911758423,
0.48617950081825256,
0.7268002033233643,
0.2546296715736389,
-0.09016664326190948,
-0.2066512405872345,
0.5546749234199524,
-0.689247727394104,
-0.041360076516866684,
-0.4798024594783783,
0.2021043747663498,
0.018605366349220276,
-0.635550856590271,
0.8747518062591553,
0.5197715163230896,
0.7583438158035278,
-0.3532056212425232,
0.5783249139785767,
-0.12910138070583344,
0.49426496028900146,
-0.23344266414642334,
0.5838931202888489,
-0.3283749520778656,
0.33855363726615906,
-0.3973250091075897,
-1.1258823871612549,
-0.5736865401268005,
0.3565117120742798,
-0.7312989234924316,
0.19755877554416656,
0.438816100358963,
0.7620351314544678,
-0.10035853832960129,
0.14584612846374512,
0.06885451078414917,
0.002148872008547187,
0.19997243583202362,
0.5599917769432068,
0.9161014556884766,
-0.20463430881500244,
0.36694109439849854,
-0.2616807520389557,
-0.004244518466293812,
-0.44261065125465393,
-1.1410828828811646,
-0.8256613612174988,
-0.3606151342391968,
-0.7871154546737671,
-0.11602362245321274,
0.11262353509664536,
0.8336085081100464,
0.7602534294128418,
-0.7160137891769409,
0.38407963514328003,
-0.10868013650178909,
-0.2521389126777649,
-0.13392288982868195,
-0.13739794492721558,
0.6293079853057861,
0.11202279478311539,
-0.6976626515388489,
0.38571444153785706,
0.16362830996513367,
-0.10910622775554657,
-0.08908439427614212,
-0.14117859303951263,
0.39456525444984436,
0.15105612576007843,
0.04103614389896393,
0.17730319499969482,
-0.7766570448875427,
-0.5695482492446899,
0.3378182053565979,
-0.01545017585158348,
-0.2904852628707886,
0.2696092426776886,
-0.6645994186401367,
0.35116174817085266,
-0.10630683600902557,
0.5151996612548828,
0.44574224948883057,
0.03376872465014458,
-0.1276487559080124,
-0.470140278339386,
-0.34609878063201904,
0.5455361008644104,
0.2595404088497162,
0.39360007643699646,
-0.8101525902748108,
0.7400657534599304,
0.2975468337535858,
-1.2355211973190308,
-0.5287635326385498,
-0.0812816172838211,
-1.2888518571853638,
0.3207533061504364,
1.0662873983383179,
0.00968733336776495,
-0.05178315192461014,
-0.28945133090019226,
-0.13514047861099243,
-0.24956053495407104,
-0.6385825872421265,
0.9861100316047668,
0.660186231136322,
-0.3584151268005371,
-0.13293634355068207,
-0.4953274130821228,
0.5109195709228516,
0.23200461268424988,
-0.7310419082641602,
-0.1658502221107483,
0.448862224817276,
0.33752474188804626,
0.6907090544700623,
0.45302897691726685,
-0.10692186653614044,
0.30715838074684143,
-0.021850477904081345,
0.1987106055021286,
-0.42556771636009216,
-0.5807363986968994,
0.1335587203502655,
0.02165880613029003,
0.34268566966056824,
0.4258166551589966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02596v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02596v1
|
Random Masking Finds Winning Tickets for Parameter Efficient Fine-tuning
| 2024-05-04T07:44:18 | 2024-05-04T07:44:18 |
Jing Xu, Jingzhao Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Fine-tuning large language models (LLM) can be costly. Parameter-efficient
fine-tuning (PEFT) addresses the problems by training a fraction of the
parameters, whose success reveals the expressiveness and flexibility of
pretrained models. This paper studies the limit of PEFT, by further simplifying
its design and reducing the number of trainable parameters beyond standard
setups. To this end, we use Random Masking to fine-tune the pretrained model.
Despite its simplicity, we show that Random Masking is surprisingly effective:
with a larger-than-expected learning rate, Random Masking can match the
performance of standard PEFT algorithms such as LoRA on various tasks, using
fewer trainable parameters. We provide both empirical and theoretical
explorations into the success of Random Masking. We show that masking induces a
flatter loss landscape and more distant solutions, which allows for and
necessitates large learning rates.
|
[
-0.6679210662841797,
-0.7937248945236206,
0.501973569393158,
0.061661627143621445,
-0.5269886255264282,
0.03600955754518509,
-0.4738564193248749,
-0.49962103366851807,
-0.008702303282916546,
0.672144889831543,
-0.5202511548995972,
-0.29532626271247864,
-0.6151894927024841,
-0.1946277767419815,
-0.40117672085762024,
0.9744521975517273,
0.10178455710411072,
-0.16949504613876343,
0.30476248264312744,
0.1562812477350235,
-0.018337031826376915,
-0.4857173562049866,
-1.1811554431915283,
-0.3986170291900635,
0.7758891582489014,
0.33380404114723206,
0.4046561121940613,
0.886260986328125,
0.4214145839214325,
0.15053415298461914,
0.03689148649573326,
0.3885211944580078,
-0.8117287158966064,
-0.11573205143213272,
0.08955912292003632,
-0.7746775150299072,
0.17941127717494965,
0.11152702569961548,
0.9085692167282104,
0.8279518485069275,
-0.3301818072795868,
0.02553386241197586,
0.027421973645687103,
0.7156053781509399,
-0.6181135773658752,
-0.2005694955587387,
-0.9448338150978088,
0.2553061544895172,
-0.5146616697311401,
-0.21816322207450867,
-0.32451915740966797,
-0.13927067816257477,
-0.09868637472391129,
-0.6175558567047119,
0.26297858357429504,
0.27909165620803833,
1.0104047060012817,
0.41147875785827637,
0.030960388481616974,
0.13802964985370636,
-0.9985547065734863,
0.77008455991745,
-0.5450131893157959,
0.3767390847206116,
0.43140709400177,
0.4823840856552124,
-0.2750549912452698,
-0.5520059466362,
-0.3523867428302765,
0.08340034633874893,
0.12203089147806168,
-0.40583035349845886,
-0.08774592727422714,
0.25138023495674133,
0.4308517873287201,
0.38126182556152344,
-0.34647706151008606,
0.3889457881450653,
-0.36466899514198303,
-0.3090246319770813,
0.4679259657859802,
0.04289098083972931,
0.06614988297224045,
0.4638914167881012,
-0.19452182948589325,
-0.26513540744781494,
-0.7912974953651428,
0.2715604603290558,
0.7595351934432983,
0.3696376383304596,
0.31779032945632935,
0.25722041726112366,
-0.6620134711265564,
1.0565074682235718,
0.20034834742546082,
-0.26196011900901794,
-0.27184680104255676,
0.1859440803527832,
-0.36624202132225037,
-0.257373183965683,
0.4887351393699646,
0.08927992731332779,
0.6666070818901062,
-0.425851970911026,
-0.40320271253585815,
-0.3276192247867584,
0.014490182511508465,
-0.7546533346176147,
-0.3928394317626953,
-0.10066685080528259,
-0.27485793828964233,
-0.5663820505142212,
-0.04116138070821762,
-0.392054945230484,
-0.35257503390312195,
-0.4060933589935303,
0.6157086491584778,
-0.2810836732387543,
0.05278005823493004,
0.532660186290741,
-0.08507650345563889,
0.4057844579219818,
0.5676723122596741,
-0.9120803475379944,
0.33090484142303467,
0.7646093964576721,
0.4947441816329956,
-0.05419012904167175,
-0.3716258108615875,
-0.9524176120758057,
-0.0942469909787178,
-0.45244333148002625,
0.9120407700538635,
-0.48864981532096863,
0.15408456325531006,
-0.34434109926223755,
-0.22519032657146454,
-0.23697857558727264,
-0.7360551357269287,
0.22230426967144012,
-0.6761735081672668,
-0.0921124741435051,
-0.07201658934354782,
-0.3295353353023529,
-0.18098106980323792,
-0.07743900269269943,
-0.64677894115448,
0.6984820365905762,
-0.015436309389770031,
-0.1106746569275856,
0.7514705061912537,
-0.2650870382785797,
-0.41381046175956726,
-0.01985372044146061,
-0.07969298958778381,
-0.6151505708694458,
0.5479324460029602,
0.0840321034193039,
0.5083727836608887,
-0.17787690460681915,
0.15964382886886597,
-0.3590894341468811,
-0.6230340003967285,
0.1390465795993805,
-0.4183163344860077,
0.5500843524932861,
0.6423377990722656,
-0.43128731846809387,
-0.23937037587165833,
-1.0294798612594604,
0.07356798648834229,
0.04756500944495201,
-0.4807935357093811,
-0.36752286553382874,
-0.03771553561091423,
0.005004143342375755,
0.13264410197734833,
-0.017889060080051422,
-0.4702799320220947,
0.014241674914956093,
-0.6585613489151001,
0.48649099469184875,
0.8645881414413452,
-0.0777081549167633,
0.597683310508728,
-0.5020642876625061,
0.38515642285346985,
-0.13998281955718994,
0.11751314997673035,
0.006765555590391159,
-0.38711705803871155,
-0.6492192149162292,
-0.5353736877441406,
0.6545660495758057,
0.2350231260061264,
-0.2253057360649109,
0.11744161695241928,
0.1819109320640564,
-0.5106465220451355,
-0.6026090383529663,
0.43936261534690857,
0.3707887530326843,
0.27695563435554504,
-0.051932137459516525,
-0.29384645819664,
-0.35033708810806274,
-1.1626529693603516,
-0.6059408783912659,
0.2570623457431793,
-0.19888003170490265,
0.23827074468135834,
0.08228792250156403,
0.1803714483976364,
0.7449935674667358,
-0.5354998111724854,
-0.415434330701828,
0.034555789083242416,
0.1155075877904892,
0.1717812716960907,
0.7944947481155396,
0.588601291179657,
-0.6476417779922485,
-0.6232965588569641,
0.03494758531451225,
0.02868170477449894,
-0.15989789366722107,
-0.30382099747657776,
0.01946168951690197,
0.13328073918819427,
0.563265860080719,
-0.40500444173812866,
0.18138964474201202,
0.344777911901474,
-0.0021924437023699284,
0.19450098276138306,
-0.21569663286209106,
0.024442635476589203,
-0.5210232734680176,
-0.03117658570408821,
-0.15740966796875,
-0.6630517244338989,
-0.4432050287723541,
0.3352940082550049,
-0.2155066281557083,
-0.3223540484905243,
-0.45484688878059387,
0.4886622428894043,
-0.3605213761329651,
0.37242963910102844,
-0.3258116841316223,
-0.2035820484161377,
-0.09312443435192108,
0.6221356391906738,
-0.06943774223327637,
0.4540070593357086,
0.590498685836792,
-0.47837451100349426,
-0.11233221739530563,
-0.48264774680137634,
-0.6082846522331238,
0.4280444085597992,
-0.48004820942878723,
0.3045119643211365,
-0.09950415790081024,
0.06092394143342972,
-1.0479977130889893,
-0.43512123823165894,
0.25516024231910706,
0.04773998260498047,
0.38193774223327637,
-0.16914883255958557,
-0.6074570417404175,
-0.16351863741874695,
-0.34081122279167175,
0.5170543789863586,
0.7797727584838867,
-0.7389749884605408,
0.44435134530067444,
0.3890343904495239,
0.2091086208820343,
-0.31608447432518005,
-0.5183477997779846,
0.016133582219481468,
-0.46962204575538635,
-0.4512036442756653,
0.4155355393886566,
-0.21765032410621643,
-0.034676771610975266,
-0.3614453375339508,
-0.2694486081600189,
-0.12997762858867645,
0.36408236622810364,
0.018574455752968788,
-0.5389093160629272,
-0.19035297632217407,
-0.054243046790361404,
0.08487503975629807,
-0.10923121869564056,
-0.21154779195785522,
-0.35724860429763794,
0.665758490562439,
-0.12022009491920471,
-0.43550166487693787,
-0.2177402824163437,
0.4338952302932739,
0.3287179172039032,
-0.11135414242744446,
0.8863333463668823,
0.6254987716674805,
-0.6783397793769836,
-0.7215721607208252,
-1.0089759826660156,
-0.2874120771884918,
-0.5011000633239746,
0.28235143423080444,
-0.6350387930870056,
-1.191769003868103,
0.8713117241859436,
-0.16665701568126678,
-0.04399282857775688,
0.25961506366729736,
0.30448558926582336,
-0.15728193521499634,
1.1174527406692505,
0.9109980463981628,
0.1880263388156891,
0.6181570887565613,
0.0835704356431961,
0.28347352147102356,
-0.3697637617588043,
-0.14025036990642548,
-0.5184186100959778,
-0.6179761290550232,
-0.6577277183532715,
-0.27862831950187683,
0.12295065820217133,
0.5297609567642212,
-0.3104461431503296,
0.11959730088710785,
-0.7017869353294373,
1.1843421459197998,
0.9380784630775452,
0.3994273543357849,
0.3761216998100281,
0.4094250798225403,
0.24809224903583527,
-0.026370611041784286,
-0.8167555928230286,
-0.22517652809619904,
0.9869986176490784,
0.4541722536087036,
0.9403408765792847,
-0.3828090727329254,
1.088911771774292,
-0.16193629801273346,
0.07238481193780899,
-0.4898656904697418,
0.4040790796279907,
-0.31945735216140747,
-0.5699865221977234,
-0.6256234049797058,
-0.31634384393692017,
-0.7399210929870605,
-0.0028566184919327497,
-0.17589454352855682,
-0.7947809100151062,
0.499845027923584,
0.3580770194530487,
-0.6740354299545288,
0.5963840484619141,
-0.7649999856948853,
0.5133564472198486,
0.1225212886929512,
-0.10535764694213867,
-0.11281681805849075,
-0.705611526966095,
0.3763049840927124,
-0.7501713037490845,
-0.00784697663038969,
-0.09193522483110428,
0.04411553218960762,
1.0574378967285156,
-0.29307442903518677,
0.9444717764854431,
-0.23456956446170807,
-0.12748591601848602,
0.14097276329994202,
-0.024611765518784523,
0.7639461755752563,
0.07390498369932175,
0.014173920266330242,
0.039646636694669724,
-0.014791635796427727,
-0.5085632801055908,
-0.5816122889518738,
0.7279576659202576,
-0.6906208395957947,
-0.7803686261177063,
-0.058081917464733124,
-0.4760299623012543,
-0.16863320767879486,
0.3286408483982086,
0.37961697578430176,
0.18516851961612701,
0.17168480157852173,
0.37575826048851013,
1.1298296451568604,
-0.18636161088943481,
0.20805348455905914,
0.6013121008872986,
-0.22241951525211334,
-0.19712789356708527,
1.1364071369171143,
0.4709084630012512,
0.29443761706352234,
0.4796905815601349,
0.25179335474967957,
0.19581665098667145,
-0.9264363646507263,
-0.1466217339038849,
0.3688232898712158,
-0.5406007766723633,
-0.1769493967294693,
-0.43605807423591614,
-0.38266563415527344,
-0.0867324247956276,
-0.2665558457374573,
-0.4680701792240143,
-0.6509873270988464,
-0.08895201981067657,
0.026762958616018295,
0.3299389183521271,
0.3293721377849579,
-0.28366371989250183,
0.5851215720176697,
-0.16917061805725098,
0.15100088715553284,
0.7514710426330566,
0.9582752585411072,
-0.1615942120552063,
-0.5335361957550049,
-0.3494024872779846,
-0.031131090596318245,
-0.0711112767457962,
-0.3380603492259979,
0.012875407002866268,
0.44877827167510986,
0.507073163986206,
0.46287548542022705,
0.18032145500183105,
0.7843403220176697,
-0.6575056314468384,
0.4554325044155121,
0.057747408747673035,
-0.6542454361915588,
0.37219855189323425,
-0.5152115225791931,
0.20634253323078156,
0.8052088618278503,
-0.0705917477607727,
-0.08748997002840042,
-0.628189206123352,
-0.5931564569473267,
-0.8438002467155457,
0.7261306643486023,
0.06228707358241081,
0.30603528022766113,
0.18222875893115997,
0.5871015787124634,
0.23189234733581543,
0.05810720473527908,
-0.8409495949745178,
-0.2246464043855667,
0.26268506050109863,
0.07881207019090652,
-0.24665877223014832,
-0.300230473279953,
-0.3339286744594574,
-0.3042311668395996,
0.540822446346283,
0.043530289083719254,
0.25441399216651917,
-0.08997001498937607,
-0.0007113420870155096,
-0.5343003869056702,
0.07616554200649261,
1.0209823846817017,
0.4747331738471985,
-0.3857469856739044,
0.36367419362068176,
0.2112971991300583,
-0.22258445620536804,
0.018601732328534126,
0.22938013076782227,
-0.0545494481921196,
-0.16941402852535248,
-0.022126544266939163,
0.7919386029243469,
0.19632993638515472,
-0.7098183035850525,
0.1884584128856659,
0.027375388890504837,
-0.3403952717781067,
0.05411665514111519,
0.492479145526886,
-0.017804795876145363,
0.23616977035999298,
0.5398755669593811,
0.3069553077220917,
0.08045382797718048,
-0.14274436235427856,
0.32562336325645447,
0.6610204577445984,
-0.10954868048429489,
-0.03064246103167534,
0.8201053738594055,
-0.12179961800575256,
-0.6281231045722961,
0.24534441530704498,
-0.09059373289346695,
-0.266021192073822,
0.6871891021728516,
0.5595554113388062,
0.7680180668830872,
-0.11892002075910568,
0.006035842001438141,
0.05434706062078476,
0.6360080242156982,
-0.2493453323841095,
-0.12353435158729553,
-0.1411326676607132,
-0.3879598379135132,
-0.5991783142089844,
-0.9629122018814087,
-0.3495980501174927,
0.516219437122345,
-0.3367270827293396,
0.3374772369861603,
-0.557227373123169,
0.22815123200416565,
0.049919452518224716,
-0.05825906619429588,
-0.8550138473510742,
0.2894459366798401,
0.19978606700897217,
0.9696362018585205,
-0.8759681582450867,
0.8294503688812256,
0.5091885924339294,
-0.045552682131528854,
-1.1617828607559204,
-0.1707209199666977,
-0.3669595420360565,
-1.1526433229446411,
0.6174747347831726,
0.04433882236480713,
0.009547725319862366,
0.30619359016418457,
-0.7410844564437866,
-0.8529045581817627,
0.6048500537872314,
0.7130404114723206,
-0.8638051152229309,
-0.12120389938354492,
0.4480224549770355,
0.46079221367836,
-0.3231091797351837,
-0.32382434606552124,
0.5571237206459045,
0.36183249950408936,
-0.16853532195091248,
-0.9321364164352417,
0.04746461659669876,
-0.08194998651742935,
0.026610637083649635,
0.4379534423351288,
-0.5882005095481873,
0.7608605623245239,
0.07854819297790527,
-0.0810113176703453,
-0.04096167907118797,
0.1856922209262848,
0.1563829779624939,
0.33855512738227844,
0.6844257712364197,
0.7344332933425903,
0.750258207321167,
-0.11217782646417618,
0.9535582661628723,
-0.15514609217643738,
0.3869389295578003,
0.9607862830162048,
0.07141728699207306,
0.6326618194580078,
0.6896811723709106,
-0.17633268237113953,
0.03714914992451668,
0.7132101058959961,
0.04748600721359253,
0.7798599004745483,
0.5725926756858826,
-0.18920205533504486,
-0.7143792510032654,
0.1276596486568451,
-0.3040802776813507,
0.30561938881874084,
0.005334038753062487,
-0.3416070342063904,
-0.39666667580604553,
0.4136372208595276,
-0.1370726376771927,
-0.05529388412833214,
-0.29170694947242737,
0.6281675100326538,
0.3149222135543823,
-0.5315415859222412,
0.7260404825210571,
-0.03826526552438736,
0.6095467209815979,
-0.6352224349975586,
0.12276837229728699,
-0.2569539546966553,
0.16743361949920654,
-0.060284361243247986,
-0.3580930531024933,
0.3114452362060547,
-0.3696548044681549,
-0.36218535900115967,
-0.3306366801261902,
0.74871826171875,
-0.5091192722320557,
-0.25471875071525574,
-0.09443750977516174,
0.3110940158367157,
0.13003039360046387,
-0.31177085638046265,
-0.42877915501594543,
0.005000465549528599,
0.009368530474603176,
-0.5274071097373962,
0.8877199292182922,
0.5814613699913025,
-0.019255170598626137,
0.6340746879577637,
0.760380744934082,
0.19207054376602173,
0.0624050572514534,
-0.09216119349002838,
0.8248860239982605,
-0.3855911195278168,
-0.5845239758491516,
-0.871922492980957,
0.34831690788269043,
0.03751515969634056,
-0.19953863322734833,
0.5394645929336548,
0.5040859580039978,
1.033095359802246,
-0.28076067566871643,
0.35448819398880005,
0.3489546477794647,
0.3832138478755951,
-0.5245633721351624,
0.8184989094734192,
-0.6059943437576294,
0.5426939129829407,
-0.20233817398548126,
-0.9598327279090881,
-0.7064194083213806,
0.7281493544578552,
-0.3296772241592407,
-0.021384404972195625,
0.3917934000492096,
0.8921853303909302,
-0.361285924911499,
-0.24367478489875793,
0.7329678535461426,
-0.07747551798820496,
0.18129794299602509,
0.6801580190658569,
0.5932487845420837,
-0.3148285746574402,
0.6548198461532593,
-0.6843788027763367,
-0.35124310851097107,
-0.20440155267715454,
-0.9607008695602417,
-1.0162452459335327,
-0.5740816593170166,
-0.4888400733470917,
-0.1542045623064041,
0.17040488123893738,
0.6136391162872314,
1.0749207735061646,
-0.8747214078903198,
0.09147654473781586,
-0.2961317002773285,
0.17693868279457092,
-0.3972366154193878,
-0.24056242406368256,
0.278683066368103,
-0.5410313606262207,
-0.7018280625343323,
0.11400655657052994,
0.20017297565937042,
-0.003983749076724052,
-0.02320840395987034,
0.11838449537754059,
0.08226224035024643,
0.36311811208724976,
0.43461936712265015,
0.5246303081512451,
-0.6459202170372009,
-0.5238008499145508,
0.00625451747328043,
-0.04015834257006645,
-0.20357391238212585,
0.6933515071868896,
-0.7490639090538025,
0.3866747319698334,
0.22803588211536407,
0.8363977670669556,
0.6137921810150146,
-0.329100102186203,
0.6469008326530457,
-0.7438343167304993,
0.04385870322585106,
0.08976505696773529,
0.10411667078733444,
-0.1208445355296135,
-0.338370680809021,
0.5519199967384338,
0.1809748411178589,
-0.6125314235687256,
-1.4011424779891968,
0.2080223560333252,
-1.0341112613677979,
-0.34299594163894653,
0.8808980584144592,
0.15232668817043304,
-0.1011824831366539,
-0.06484238803386688,
-0.31150680780410767,
-0.05060506984591484,
-0.1452939808368683,
1.0667644739151,
0.7589720487594604,
-0.15268667042255402,
-0.2703137993812561,
-0.3889960050582886,
0.8279166221618652,
0.6633213758468628,
-0.5073257088661194,
-0.10586469620466232,
-0.011957057751715183,
0.5963882803916931,
0.05632314831018448,
0.6706032752990723,
0.3243477940559387,
0.38548359274864197,
-0.2194567322731018,
-0.44500675797462463,
-0.2690929174423218,
-0.35275426506996155,
-0.5096422433853149,
0.4691297709941864,
0.34397372603416443,
-0.07124946266412735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02578v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02578v1
|
Mixat: A Data Set of Bilingual Emirati-English Speech
| 2024-05-04T06:06:34 | 2024-05-04T06:06:34 |
Maryam Al Ali, Hanan Aldarmaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces Mixat: a dataset of Emirati speech code-mixed with
English. Mixat was developed to address the shortcomings of current speech
recognition resources when applied to Emirati speech, and in particular, to
bilignual Emirati speakers who often mix and switch between their local dialect
and English. The data set consists of 15 hours of speech derived from two
public podcasts featuring native Emirati speakers, one of which is in the form
of conversations between the host and a guest. Therefore, the collection
contains examples of Emirati-English code-switching in both formal and natural
conversational contexts. In this paper, we describe the process of data
collection and annotation, and describe some of the features and statistics of
the resulting data set. In addition, we evaluate the performance of pre-trained
Arabic and multi-lingual ASR systems on our dataset, demonstrating the
shortcomings of existing models on this low-resource dialectal Arabic, and the
additional challenge of recognizing code-switching in ASR. The dataset will be
made publicly available for research use.
|
[
-0.6305215954780579,
-0.4271584749221802,
-0.18469466269016266,
0.4580706059932709,
-0.12989863753318787,
0.5044265985488892,
-0.3969973623752594,
-0.7571864128112793,
0.5986215472221375,
0.5166827440261841,
-0.24642817676067352,
-0.23657222092151642,
-0.5550482869148254,
0.18708018958568573,
-0.6072092056274414,
1.0218154191970825,
-0.1853645294904709,
0.3647235035896301,
0.26162639260292053,
-0.5254968404769897,
-0.784881591796875,
-0.4996548593044281,
-0.47986122965812683,
-0.29699668288230896,
0.21290762722492218,
0.9716099500656128,
0.9897222518920898,
0.37726348638534546,
0.05667760223150253,
0.1575462371110916,
0.009826569817960262,
0.154079869389534,
-0.2648797929286957,
-0.09008552134037018,
-0.054119132459163666,
-0.40226423740386963,
-0.17767371237277985,
-0.3614121079444885,
0.36595869064331055,
0.5829182863235474,
-0.33937394618988037,
0.1025603786110878,
-0.23636625707149506,
0.449355810880661,
-0.40345311164855957,
0.15170502662658691,
-0.48044201731681824,
-0.0844632014632225,
-0.6731763482093811,
-0.049612902104854584,
0.07325863093137741,
-0.16983671486377716,
-0.10332564264535904,
-0.007187328301370144,
0.010119966231286526,
-0.04078913852572441,
0.6626604795455933,
0.13327009975910187,
-0.6808017492294312,
-0.5701707005500793,
-0.9393698573112488,
0.6880972981452942,
-0.5122116208076477,
0.6857936978340149,
0.6531046628952026,
0.5032404065132141,
0.15535295009613037,
-0.3990144431591034,
-0.712816596031189,
-0.02475079707801342,
0.001971921883523464,
0.016241861507296562,
-0.1176246702671051,
-0.46421903371810913,
-0.06819409132003784,
0.38802915811538696,
-0.4690333306789398,
-0.02238519676029682,
-0.5894525647163391,
-0.17142684757709503,
0.8349447846412659,
-0.08421418815851212,
0.7089669108390808,
-0.0059021469205617905,
0.15038003027439117,
-0.16649430990219116,
-0.7588607668876648,
0.07415569573640823,
0.5078343152999878,
0.46277907490730286,
-0.4902777671813965,
0.7300408482551575,
-0.10986313968896866,
0.44286149740219116,
-0.03751273825764656,
-0.011737250722944736,
0.6179949045181274,
-0.5088382363319397,
0.11378893256187439,
0.5580572485923767,
0.62936931848526,
0.09156108647584915,
0.3267812728881836,
-0.06440450251102448,
-0.36960652470588684,
0.306137353181839,
-0.20870265364646912,
-0.7256353497505188,
-0.39329206943511963,
0.3547216057777405,
-0.06976776570081711,
0.27317121624946594,
-0.0181743074208498,
-0.7975425124168396,
0.045463964343070984,
-0.3819030225276947,
0.14693328738212585,
-0.42845654487609863,
-0.42814236879348755,
0.3753700852394104,
0.0773388147354126,
0.20620116591453552,
0.0010028677061200142,
-0.7661776542663574,
0.5090464949607849,
0.27917197346687317,
0.6752108931541443,
-0.08594222366809845,
-0.3424028158187866,
-0.3980550765991211,
0.2499440461397171,
-0.1352740228176117,
0.5493324398994446,
-0.6412308216094971,
-0.6980258822441101,
0.12543216347694397,
-0.22016507387161255,
0.01466302014887333,
-0.8023275136947632,
0.6338546872138977,
-0.49542075395584106,
0.2861102819442749,
-0.06258279830217361,
-0.18045920133590698,
-0.21821974217891693,
-0.24913936853408813,
-0.9570376873016357,
1.0665526390075684,
-0.24007777869701385,
-0.9631586074829102,
0.5532573461532593,
-0.7498465180397034,
-0.9104430675506592,
0.1535353660583496,
-0.47715091705322266,
-0.4175719618797302,
-0.21570147573947906,
0.6963605880737305,
0.11209883540868759,
-0.16624023020267487,
0.21840694546699524,
0.3643738031387329,
-0.3174969255924225,
0.4485260844230652,
-0.08672536164522171,
0.8038555979728699,
0.4307617247104645,
-0.5499367117881775,
-0.15357692539691925,
-0.8300186991691589,
-0.022852109745144844,
-0.03712673485279083,
-0.14323092997074127,
-0.20050035417079926,
0.40296635031700134,
0.755134105682373,
0.28359130024909973,
0.38984036445617676,
-0.5001053810119629,
-0.00312409526668489,
-0.1644999384880066,
0.1769971251487732,
0.16517655551433563,
-0.05774001032114029,
-0.04021482169628143,
-0.6403242945671082,
0.6844919323921204,
0.4562588930130005,
-0.39139512181282043,
0.18983252346515656,
-0.5344510674476624,
-0.8502850532531738,
-0.6017575860023499,
0.39571988582611084,
0.8575305938720703,
-0.9011229872703552,
0.4839257001876831,
-0.2757960855960846,
-0.4355379343032837,
-0.695490300655365,
0.22715908288955688,
0.25967738032341003,
-0.17350192368030548,
0.43946802616119385,
-0.24420277774333954,
-0.9210634827613831,
-1.0985625982284546,
-0.17722463607788086,
0.0020430772565305233,
0.004899852443486452,
0.3190094232559204,
0.6058690547943115,
-0.525266170501709,
1.1127554178237915,
0.1021425873041153,
-0.03112407773733139,
-0.6090084314346313,
0.29977428913116455,
0.23071137070655823,
0.4921109676361084,
0.4638882279396057,
-0.9438678026199341,
-0.5152930021286011,
0.26279714703559875,
-0.36990442872047424,
-0.3669973611831665,
-0.07888399809598923,
0.012048156000673771,
-0.10731963813304901,
0.27313610911369324,
-0.06808186322450638,
0.2902287542819977,
0.8286089301109314,
-0.46757107973098755,
0.3174732029438019,
0.15323801338672638,
0.5786241292953491,
-1.2342908382415771,
-0.2490333914756775,
-0.2427942454814911,
-0.3853064477443695,
-0.6020639538764954,
-0.1479620486497879,
-0.05998921021819115,
-0.14761923253536224,
-0.562477707862854,
0.4285835027694702,
-0.5209725499153137,
0.006813011132180691,
-0.08473514020442963,
-0.37742480635643005,
-0.4450986087322235,
0.2508792281150818,
0.14198561012744904,
1.5169868469238281,
0.6420655846595764,
-0.3501051962375641,
0.17523358762264252,
0.5813637971878052,
-0.4170346260070801,
0.5101744532585144,
-0.5497464537620544,
0.4254334270954132,
-0.08253937214612961,
-0.10910411924123764,
-0.8854550123214722,
-0.2762531042098999,
0.06071360781788826,
-0.21788641810417175,
0.20334665477275848,
-0.1543203592300415,
-0.6676570773124695,
0.13302220404148102,
-0.07105614989995956,
0.7845782041549683,
0.5326307415962219,
-0.6301699280738831,
0.5328336358070374,
0.9146260619163513,
-0.5659288167953491,
-0.14724090695381165,
-0.7134268879890442,
0.3344946801662445,
-0.32115647196769714,
-0.6470738053321838,
0.12749308347702026,
0.032175496220588684,
-0.33654624223709106,
-0.18774788081645966,
0.029009535908699036,
-0.4988785982131958,
-0.25264668464660645,
0.4865923225879669,
-0.10680455714464188,
-0.2511804401874542,
-0.38700079917907715,
0.16759507358074188,
0.2060638964176178,
-0.005037834867835045,
0.050062455236911774,
0.7082140445709229,
-0.15606288611888885,
-0.423021137714386,
-0.4038854241371155,
0.6634571552276611,
0.29135483503341675,
-0.3535308837890625,
0.5286299586296082,
0.23325978219509125,
-0.31860780715942383,
-0.2722777724266052,
-0.4073282480239868,
0.15182733535766602,
-0.41838008165359497,
0.3353285491466522,
-0.5524687170982361,
-0.7584666609764099,
0.8179059624671936,
0.32974526286125183,
0.0023449768777936697,
0.1799336075782776,
0.7739049792289734,
-0.010795123875141144,
0.7860110402107239,
0.2971416115760803,
-0.5216028690338135,
0.6017678380012512,
-0.03499597683548927,
0.23894797265529633,
-0.05063631013035774,
-0.08686545491218567,
-0.8258326053619385,
-0.35650694370269775,
-0.675975501537323,
-0.5108702778816223,
0.34638938307762146,
-0.06228075176477432,
-0.059037379920482635,
0.2779952883720398,
-0.030676916241645813,
0.7591485977172852,
0.517545223236084,
0.03548230975866318,
0.37626293301582336,
0.09309771656990051,
0.12304625660181046,
-0.2938820421695709,
-0.7262328267097473,
-0.37853798270225525,
1.1082261800765991,
0.07900220155715942,
0.7882097363471985,
0.44263413548469543,
0.8050336837768555,
0.6367053985595703,
0.007961196824908257,
-0.42037418484687805,
0.3751392960548401,
0.11037790775299072,
-0.4251466989517212,
0.036089785397052765,
-0.5330455899238586,
-1.0067521333694458,
-0.07541556656360626,
0.06545627862215042,
-0.4054890275001526,
0.11790506541728973,
-0.052261415868997574,
0.14151987433433533,
0.09766429662704468,
-0.735065221786499,
0.5083560943603516,
-0.3624485433101654,
-0.07996387779712677,
-0.16936245560646057,
-0.4942927658557892,
0.17048192024230957,
-0.26036953926086426,
0.5436816215515137,
-0.016160471364855766,
0.2855386734008789,
1.188616156578064,
-0.3707529604434967,
0.6603161096572876,
0.08235826343297958,
0.13692334294319153,
0.2853517532348633,
0.10321662575006485,
0.05143966153264046,
-0.04360906779766083,
0.2932022511959076,
0.6426066160202026,
0.2977297306060791,
-0.6413245797157288,
-0.11715185642242432,
0.3609926998615265,
-1.0919513702392578,
0.04054785147309303,
-0.5783743262290955,
-0.49364250898361206,
-0.5131116509437561,
-0.06730343401432037,
0.10562820732593536,
0.46497246623039246,
-0.20783087611198425,
-0.03402873873710632,
0.24460169672966003,
-0.12887513637542725,
0.28322359919548035,
0.4171268939971924,
-0.5630049109458923,
-0.5533465147018433,
0.8868852257728577,
0.20583517849445343,
-0.05952010676264763,
0.07239160686731339,
-0.04251889884471893,
-0.36194559931755066,
-0.5231313705444336,
-0.5599608421325684,
0.30667200684547424,
-0.618715763092041,
-0.0076757618226110935,
-0.25627416372299194,
-0.17487415671348572,
-0.15199977159500122,
-0.23744267225265503,
-0.34980207681655884,
-0.4732550084590912,
0.11248823255300522,
-0.07786590605974197,
0.4656214714050293,
0.8746041655540466,
0.07181566208600998,
0.30643489956855774,
-0.7017707228660583,
0.4581815302371979,
0.2149379700422287,
0.24838832020759583,
-0.6178517937660217,
-0.49820318818092346,
-0.4908914864063263,
0.2829347252845764,
0.15786468982696533,
-1.228800654411316,
0.4724830389022827,
0.283856600522995,
0.44230979681015015,
0.11300916224718094,
-0.24248258769512177,
0.6635197997093201,
-0.49536675214767456,
0.7007219195365906,
-0.10982579737901688,
-1.142244577407837,
0.5179483294487,
-0.4617331922054291,
0.21909275650978088,
0.8496726751327515,
0.30756819248199463,
-0.7442080974578857,
-0.5571256279945374,
-0.47560763359069824,
-0.8498495817184448,
0.5650219321250916,
0.383882075548172,
-0.057569749653339386,
0.024854304268956184,
-0.28719326853752136,
0.29541802406311035,
0.4031566083431244,
-0.5782707929611206,
-0.390614777803421,
-0.21311332285404205,
-0.4632117450237274,
-0.21383506059646606,
-0.28008130192756653,
-0.3667682409286499,
-0.4845064878463745,
0.6378989219665527,
0.07991635054349899,
0.07729256898164749,
-0.284131795167923,
-0.4888412654399872,
0.03125384449958801,
0.5686439871788025,
0.39187946915626526,
0.7982747554779053,
-0.29172977805137634,
0.07507335394620895,
-0.06714367866516113,
-0.5989899039268494,
0.17837992310523987,
0.3141525983810425,
-0.29310280084609985,
0.23565161228179932,
0.2607690393924713,
0.6893287301063538,
0.36660417914390564,
-1.209665298461914,
0.457275390625,
0.009405848570168018,
-0.07610232383012772,
-0.4712284207344055,
-0.15869025886058807,
0.04422448202967644,
0.040021494030952454,
0.24506832659244537,
0.048695072531700134,
0.2462347447872162,
-0.5576921701431274,
0.45662811398506165,
0.030138952657580376,
0.02695605345070362,
-0.318369597196579,
0.7100661993026733,
0.44115060567855835,
-0.5276584029197693,
0.36136624217033386,
-0.19565130770206451,
-0.5284761190414429,
0.43451184034347534,
0.4018409252166748,
0.8055070638656616,
-0.11996697634458542,
0.15166372060775757,
-0.10065341740846634,
0.12259198725223541,
0.07820608466863632,
0.9010316133499146,
-0.15499919652938843,
-0.9755827188491821,
-0.2447962462902069,
-0.457352876663208,
-0.6784552931785583,
-0.1934143453836441,
-0.8043993711471558,
0.28097212314605713,
-0.21710212528705597,
0.2022344321012497,
-0.12505535781383514,
-0.05933617427945137,
-0.8822594285011292,
-0.04713306576013565,
0.26100870966911316,
0.7209174633026123,
-1.25467050075531,
0.9056978821754456,
0.9194759130477905,
-0.4530251622200012,
-0.8426189422607422,
-0.17129860818386078,
-0.051684603095054626,
-0.8701512813568115,
0.7024950981140137,
0.002965061692520976,
-0.41171151399612427,
-0.1911485493183136,
-0.343975305557251,
-0.49278104305267334,
0.5177950859069824,
0.1191854402422905,
-0.41488146781921387,
0.48097506165504456,
0.6259688138961792,
0.364202618598938,
-0.288785457611084,
0.20858943462371826,
0.9308544397354126,
0.23567309975624084,
0.10096980631351471,
-1.328796625137329,
-0.48701992630958557,
-0.4402426481246948,
-0.405582070350647,
0.30244603753089905,
-0.4008671045303345,
0.8820667266845703,
0.34886249899864197,
-0.2169087678194046,
-0.3440590798854828,
0.5979043841362,
0.16186964511871338,
0.32293954491615295,
0.4549417495727539,
0.5326120257377625,
0.39050164818763733,
-0.0954170823097229,
0.6743035316467285,
-0.459182471036911,
0.0575237050652504,
1.1438913345336914,
-0.6253139972686768,
1.0959813594818115,
0.6113748550415039,
-0.35656827688217163,
0.34930431842803955,
0.2964995205402374,
0.3706192076206207,
0.4987477660179138,
-0.1259017139673233,
-0.35235217213630676,
0.1264544427394867,
-0.11976998299360275,
-0.48641321063041687,
0.7776387929916382,
0.2914804518222809,
0.22889810800552368,
-0.2279714196920395,
0.08847644180059433,
0.23498782515525818,
0.021988844498991966,
-0.1966961771249771,
0.8396829962730408,
-0.4528140723705292,
-0.2583844065666199,
0.5073686242103577,
0.06518278270959854,
0.8853387236595154,
-0.5221668481826782,
-0.07035994529724121,
-0.3193538188934326,
-0.17097119987010956,
-0.2704448997974396,
-0.6152943968772888,
0.358671098947525,
0.15524227917194366,
0.10210778564214706,
-0.321230411529541,
0.15290267765522003,
-0.9288744330406189,
-0.8328223824501038,
0.18304938077926636,
0.8483582139015198,
0.2887217402458191,
0.32062479853630066,
-0.4712894856929779,
0.2544795870780945,
0.2508634328842163,
0.19253471493721008,
0.07037419080734253,
0.4107886850833893,
-0.12746044993400574,
0.3690771460533142,
0.548596203327179,
0.6299051642417908,
0.5319824814796448,
0.20607338845729828,
0.6551668643951416,
-0.7399385571479797,
-0.9154335260391235,
-0.4773785173892975,
0.4534873068332672,
0.09077581018209457,
-0.3556794226169586,
0.709426760673523,
0.9794890880584717,
1.116091012954712,
0.0015744291013106704,
0.9659222960472107,
-0.04458945617079735,
0.8592001795768738,
-0.6813358068466187,
0.5780954957008362,
-0.31632480025291443,
0.2223130613565445,
0.09454129636287689,
-0.6557775139808655,
-0.05232446640729904,
0.6369133591651917,
-0.265575110912323,
0.0902179479598999,
0.3940110206604004,
0.867053747177124,
-0.421840101480484,
0.2432217299938202,
0.23995782434940338,
0.09434936195611954,
0.3690711557865143,
0.44092097878456116,
0.8460953235626221,
-0.3439919054508209,
0.08375004678964615,
-0.16049081087112427,
0.022660115733742714,
-0.26050227880477905,
-0.44087478518486023,
-0.7492536902427673,
-0.50569087266922,
-0.349355012178421,
-0.295756459236145,
0.11902184039354324,
1.1368457078933716,
0.6712994575500488,
-1.2162652015686035,
-1.0203455686569214,
0.23549549281597137,
-0.265720009803772,
-0.19621610641479492,
-0.18100783228874207,
0.0051229302771389484,
0.2018079161643982,
-0.675041675567627,
0.5634258985519409,
0.06900814920663834,
0.16258779168128967,
0.08674904704093933,
-0.10638231039047241,
-0.34224024415016174,
0.14406080543994904,
0.05487111583352089,
0.6488637924194336,
-0.3158653974533081,
-0.23750817775726318,
-0.5481569170951843,
-0.04128960147500038,
0.39043933153152466,
0.9743307828903198,
-0.5986663699150085,
0.42455726861953735,
0.0870867446064949,
0.9311981797218323,
0.7192832231521606,
-0.12699350714683533,
0.4862481951713562,
-0.970889687538147,
0.7449119091033936,
0.4955943524837494,
0.5885173678398132,
0.5109937787055969,
0.0928523913025856,
0.24939246475696564,
0.024831609800457954,
-0.4427436292171478,
-0.6107528209686279,
0.1954697072505951,
-1.1246546506881714,
0.19552618265151978,
1.084571123123169,
0.34556400775909424,
0.09946968406438828,
-0.4598696231842041,
-0.5403232574462891,
-0.0700916275382042,
-0.5842288732528687,
0.5984190702438354,
0.8707098960876465,
-0.2218330353498459,
-0.26353248953819275,
-0.6966649293899536,
0.42535457015037537,
0.6794339418411255,
-1.041808843612671,
-0.2709873616695404,
0.718388557434082,
0.3508613705635071,
-0.13057535886764526,
0.8002658486366272,
0.22951218485832214,
0.29662418365478516,
0.09973087906837463,
0.18901196122169495,
0.09629741311073303,
-0.38390254974365234,
-0.5439915657043457,
0.08131013065576553,
0.21962180733680725,
-0.4831621050834656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02573v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02573v1
|
A Combination of BERT and Transformer for Vietnamese Spelling Correction
| 2024-05-04T05:24:19 | 2024-05-04T05:24:19 |
Hieu Ngo Trung, Duong Tran Ham, Tin Huynh, Kiem Hoang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, many studies have shown the efficiency of using Bidirectional
Encoder Representations from Transformers (BERT) in various Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks. Specifically, English spelling correction task that
uses Encoder-Decoder architecture and takes advantage of BERT has achieved
state-of-the-art result. However, to our knowledge, there is no implementation
in Vietnamese yet. Therefore, in this study, a combination of Transformer
architecture (state-of-the-art for Encoder-Decoder model) and BERT was proposed
to deal with Vietnamese spelling correction. The experiment results have shown
that our model outperforms other approaches as well as the Google Docs Spell
Checking tool, achieves an 86.24 BLEU score on this task.
|
[
0.03227376192808151,
-0.6407723426818848,
0.3062378764152527,
0.22001734375953674,
-0.2224947214126587,
0.09425602853298187,
-0.23466110229492188,
-0.3661253750324249,
0.3637361228466034,
0.5084186792373657,
-0.2691691517829895,
-0.44271591305732727,
-0.8334556818008423,
0.45241543650627136,
-0.2193121463060379,
0.5772961974143982,
-0.1591973900794983,
0.07905133813619614,
0.1053263247013092,
-0.06189318001270294,
-0.6962728500366211,
-0.5550752878189087,
-0.5703083872795105,
-0.3395664393901825,
0.49763697385787964,
0.4313628375530243,
0.7388098835945129,
0.23196084797382355,
0.6995140910148621,
0.34411582350730896,
-0.2240767627954483,
0.4458785355091095,
-0.4472586214542389,
0.03633864223957062,
-0.02674924023449421,
-0.6050348281860352,
-0.5668699741363525,
-0.12892603874206543,
0.645271897315979,
0.25954166054725647,
-0.06688765436410904,
-0.11494750529527664,
-0.08829031139612198,
0.7383934855461121,
-0.5969271063804626,
-0.046335939317941666,
-0.7027232050895691,
-0.16182540357112885,
0.056123096495866776,
-0.05528341978788376,
-0.5388452410697937,
-0.38451051712036133,
0.396056592464447,
-0.2246837317943573,
0.3772013187408447,
-0.3203258216381073,
1.0311386585235596,
0.4335235357284546,
-0.5528976917266846,
-0.3050905764102936,
-0.9486262202262878,
0.5916492938995361,
-0.5599596500396729,
0.48901844024658203,
0.08729489892721176,
0.36151087284088135,
-0.02954605221748352,
-0.5502777099609375,
-0.8539003729820251,
0.09856365621089935,
-0.3754696846008301,
0.529727041721344,
-0.319108247756958,
0.48986950516700745,
0.06982641667127609,
0.32213690876960754,
-0.6831791996955872,
0.147714763879776,
-0.5208125710487366,
-0.2246185690164566,
0.5042794942855835,
-0.44688883423805237,
0.1713271141052246,
-0.5955013036727905,
-0.2585803270339966,
-0.21682967245578766,
-0.4014855623245239,
-0.19847318530082703,
0.2481054812669754,
0.20541712641716003,
0.1772529035806656,
0.7812023758888245,
0.04379356652498245,
0.6042951941490173,
0.08026932924985886,
-0.010067865252494812,
0.18644419312477112,
0.07207855582237244,
-0.4813397526741028,
0.32867762446403503,
0.4163234829902649,
0.500508725643158,
0.20214517414569855,
-0.1964399814605713,
-0.5567165017127991,
0.15819121897220612,
0.5106355547904968,
-0.34631550312042236,
-0.16024525463581085,
0.41659772396087646,
-0.5329344272613525,
0.09877824783325195,
0.4629081189632416,
-0.5283073782920837,
0.13954655826091766,
-0.3184299170970917,
1.1049525737762451,
-0.6715999245643616,
-0.06103302165865898,
0.30892425775527954,
-0.509296715259552,
0.373651385307312,
0.30758607387542725,
-0.5903551578521729,
-0.1336475908756256,
0.7559730410575867,
0.8988706469535828,
-0.0848473310470581,
-0.3721001446247101,
-0.36199283599853516,
0.23314402997493744,
-0.10173515230417252,
0.8719071745872498,
-0.3398362994194031,
-0.565540075302124,
0.6253200173377991,
0.15780068933963776,
-0.4163573384284973,
-0.700880229473114,
0.8230614066123962,
-0.5850324034690857,
0.2762381434440613,
-0.0004758179420605302,
-0.7750986814498901,
-0.47213324904441833,
0.10515382885932922,
-0.9791415929794312,
1.1779435873031616,
0.11452418565750122,
-0.5269628167152405,
0.26485154032707214,
-0.585116982460022,
-0.6121788024902344,
0.3241545855998993,
0.6107584834098816,
-0.4268432557582855,
0.2382430136203766,
0.39418208599090576,
0.2623884975910187,
0.1981385052204132,
0.012496777810156345,
0.5031612515449524,
-0.6507503390312195,
0.006625539157539606,
-0.5149691700935364,
0.926086962223053,
-0.16663943231105804,
-0.39188843965530396,
0.2017570585012436,
-0.78764808177948,
-0.15026217699050903,
-0.13629573583602905,
-0.5976700186729431,
-0.49139320850372314,
-0.34001991152763367,
0.31488755345344543,
0.2149370163679123,
0.530329167842865,
-0.6970382332801819,
0.23058685660362244,
-0.41438958048820496,
0.3695194721221924,
0.5357114672660828,
-0.28738346695899963,
0.5160118937492371,
-0.4175010919570923,
0.24252791702747345,
-0.0460578016936779,
0.2141043245792389,
-0.15719355642795563,
-0.6843821406364441,
-1.12285578250885,
-0.4885733127593994,
0.49784642457962036,
0.8858906030654907,
-1.0947033166885376,
0.81544029712677,
-0.3295304477214813,
-0.7102910876274109,
-1.346046805381775,
-0.10622502863407135,
0.32106661796569824,
0.43997201323509216,
0.5807360410690308,
-0.01828657276928425,
-0.8205507397651672,
-0.8230414390563965,
-0.18055151402950287,
-0.2355080246925354,
-0.5012986660003662,
-0.14503571391105652,
0.5058937072753906,
-0.7201949954032898,
0.9080575108528137,
-0.5134721398353577,
-0.5783559679985046,
-0.1750093549489975,
0.3148791193962097,
0.37149208784103394,
0.2431224286556244,
0.3374854326248169,
-0.9619219899177551,
-0.3634921908378601,
-0.13823407888412476,
-0.3786068260669708,
-0.150197371840477,
0.1159089058637619,
-0.13254180550575256,
0.8317095637321472,
0.12341485172510147,
-0.7227278351783752,
0.5036975145339966,
0.6409633755683899,
-0.08064321428537369,
0.752467930316925,
-0.898449718952179,
0.19903990626335144,
-0.8479330539703369,
-0.15544497966766357,
-0.14191579818725586,
-0.194557785987854,
-0.7633313536643982,
0.13036872446537018,
0.41856393218040466,
0.17766572535037994,
-0.41352468729019165,
0.29522058367729187,
-0.08926939964294434,
0.4124342203140259,
-0.3401752710342407,
-0.1329193115234375,
-0.11184263229370117,
0.25715601444244385,
0.19118189811706543,
0.6248123645782471,
0.22729729115962982,
-0.4598236083984375,
0.4537059962749481,
0.1904168426990509,
0.13686855137348175,
0.7422111630439758,
-0.7741189002990723,
0.19624018669128418,
-0.23506303131580353,
0.3219076991081238,
-1.0430675745010376,
0.10893435031175613,
-0.07306454330682755,
-0.3272266387939453,
0.2973400056362152,
0.06147672235965729,
-0.7409095764160156,
-0.9061500430107117,
-0.35426345467567444,
-0.06796255707740784,
0.7177736759185791,
-0.9583280086517334,
0.6930307149887085,
0.07326699048280716,
0.2096865475177765,
-0.3670198917388916,
-0.4390562176704407,
0.13249891996383667,
-0.06217937171459198,
-0.6293182373046875,
0.7054048776626587,
0.04647497460246086,
0.09941618889570236,
-0.03905095160007477,
0.161863312125206,
-0.2442353069782257,
-0.5317444205284119,
0.1449272483587265,
0.6320434212684631,
-0.22245155274868011,
0.28463155031204224,
-0.06408873200416565,
-0.29486069083213806,
-0.1345675140619278,
-0.45514726638793945,
0.2622923254966736,
-0.03341519087553024,
-0.06803175061941147,
-0.4227389097213745,
0.32798561453819275,
0.7834230661392212,
-0.31200110912323,
0.906704306602478,
0.7390787601470947,
-0.5809255838394165,
0.08096961677074432,
-1.1229280233383179,
-0.1524355262517929,
-0.4887237250804901,
0.19589228928089142,
-0.19978560507297516,
-0.8714341521263123,
0.24095822870731354,
-0.032293789088726044,
-0.09475456178188324,
0.497824102640152,
0.6041147112846375,
-0.3028748631477356,
0.8160871267318726,
0.6911324262619019,
-0.14963050186634064,
0.2887206971645355,
-0.25245314836502075,
0.5560783743858337,
-0.5792258381843567,
-0.06630700826644897,
-0.3784230649471283,
-0.5593729019165039,
-1.0232422351837158,
-0.6615732312202454,
0.42489388585090637,
-0.25529274344444275,
0.02922762557864189,
0.6141119003295898,
-0.7326112985610962,
0.10852708667516708,
1.3591810464859009,
0.2931610345840454,
0.4419955015182495,
-0.06246643885970116,
-0.12313202768564224,
-0.23105230927467346,
-0.5915693640708923,
-0.6481266617774963,
1.0382016897201538,
-0.039162520319223404,
0.41280385851860046,
-0.17438046634197235,
0.8687224984169006,
0.15683704614639282,
-0.13553550839424133,
-0.8320625424385071,
0.4011533856391907,
-0.6290389895439148,
-0.3950575590133667,
-0.4220668077468872,
0.016636159271001816,
-0.8806328773498535,
0.08617334812879562,
-0.23125429451465607,
-0.3481060862541199,
0.09264793246984482,
-0.041109826415777206,
-0.014364500530064106,
0.4091355502605438,
-0.960442066192627,
0.711418092250824,
-0.1482447236776352,
0.13536331057548523,
-0.37822434306144714,
-0.7220420837402344,
0.1111428365111351,
-0.08180519938468933,
-0.1273774951696396,
0.33911457657814026,
0.308096706867218,
0.5571073889732361,
-0.5802642703056335,
0.4894699156284332,
-0.1422690451145172,
-0.30611759424209595,
0.30706462264060974,
-0.3805229365825653,
0.2818235456943512,
-0.06739424914121628,
-0.23110800981521606,
0.48887354135513306,
-0.17328304052352905,
-0.2603778839111328,
-0.5501781702041626,
0.42035314440727234,
-0.8097769021987915,
-0.4562835991382599,
-0.3066297769546509,
-0.5612702965736389,
0.327693909406662,
0.17984028160572052,
0.48666876554489136,
0.012288006022572517,
-0.2084425389766693,
-0.14869244396686554,
0.5454443693161011,
-0.1123698279261589,
0.46825140714645386,
0.5408887267112732,
0.14333033561706543,
-0.5185138583183289,
0.8409856557846069,
0.331955224275589,
-0.042287543416023254,
0.9598733186721802,
0.01529943197965622,
-0.2507789731025696,
0.030612772330641747,
-0.2353653460741043,
0.627071738243103,
-0.47608688473701477,
-0.096865214407444,
-0.4624101519584656,
-0.7604334354400635,
-0.4394739270210266,
-0.5642871260643005,
-0.33406293392181396,
-0.3349458873271942,
-0.06977525353431702,
0.05385174602270126,
0.3181121349334717,
0.9198282957077026,
-0.17746089398860931,
0.5732953548431396,
-0.8676919341087341,
0.5777817368507385,
0.7975181937217712,
0.19112266600131989,
-0.23462745547294617,
-0.3325403332710266,
-0.22163692116737366,
0.24071241915225983,
-0.37505295872688293,
-0.8138347268104553,
0.5181857943534851,
0.13999523222446442,
0.28217223286628723,
0.30375105142593384,
-0.05442817136645317,
0.780422031879425,
-0.8259117007255554,
0.6048338413238525,
-0.2369898110628128,
-1.023366928100586,
0.8861787915229797,
0.08376879245042801,
0.48556381464004517,
0.06823274493217468,
0.16997167468070984,
-0.849883496761322,
-0.517372727394104,
-0.5674615502357483,
-0.6424126029014587,
0.5011086463928223,
0.35530784726142883,
-0.09030409157276154,
0.07620039582252502,
0.3196907937526703,
0.1531790941953659,
0.12915821373462677,
-0.17149674892425537,
-0.28902605175971985,
-0.13489051163196564,
-0.16153156757354736,
-0.199028879404068,
-0.6722475290298462,
0.2356472760438919,
-0.5097783803939819,
0.8379180431365967,
0.21394731104373932,
0.43246620893478394,
0.3067117929458618,
-0.445016473531723,
-0.05438010394573212,
0.2839788794517517,
0.5001885294914246,
0.38795748353004456,
-0.54035484790802,
0.07841678708791733,
0.12890447676181793,
-0.7881491780281067,
0.038250796496868134,
0.2803746163845062,
-0.3521587550640106,
0.7427815198898315,
0.44049814343452454,
0.5568053722381592,
0.4036247730255127,
-0.47469377517700195,
0.37604039907455444,
-0.1036820113658905,
-0.2754865884780884,
-0.028923409059643745,
-0.32330065965652466,
0.08353039622306824,
0.18039923906326294,
0.5939754247665405,
-0.019922681152820587,
-0.021009501069784164,
-0.1654193103313446,
0.06923937052488327,
0.31745100021362305,
-0.3837820589542389,
-0.3336118757724762,
0.573563277721405,
0.23089873790740967,
-0.7776607871055603,
0.931002140045166,
-0.28355148434638977,
-1.0449820756912231,
0.46954721212387085,
0.7312642335891724,
1.0609790086746216,
-0.7584347128868103,
0.4548673927783966,
0.3956016004085541,
0.6048371195793152,
-0.14512503147125244,
0.5564097166061401,
0.34279507398605347,
-0.5777013301849365,
-0.27377039194107056,
-0.6385208964347839,
-0.652442455291748,
-0.15057916939258575,
-0.6098718643188477,
0.6251481771469116,
0.4001280665397644,
0.07135190069675446,
-0.3778397738933563,
-0.14599092304706573,
-0.8613459467887878,
0.21996012330055237,
0.22185440361499786,
0.7935435175895691,
-0.7129219174385071,
0.8777426481246948,
1.1357561349868774,
-0.06070428714156151,
-0.5640522837638855,
0.07332132011651993,
-0.14677461981773376,
-0.8328495025634766,
0.7060645222663879,
0.44908323884010315,
-0.11233881115913391,
0.06484006345272064,
-0.023654747754335403,
-0.598041832447052,
0.891968309879303,
0.249176025390625,
-0.6230813264846802,
-0.24323421716690063,
0.4148900508880615,
0.7835273146629333,
0.09559422731399536,
0.223086416721344,
0.9229728579521179,
0.6344572305679321,
0.21683301031589508,
-1.319076657295227,
-0.43402189016342163,
-0.08791954815387726,
0.2631552517414093,
0.1260688155889511,
-0.40191444754600525,
0.6964021325111389,
-0.07261748611927032,
-0.08364664018154144,
-0.15920831263065338,
0.749420166015625,
0.01918678730726242,
0.09182770550251007,
0.42359352111816406,
0.7718387246131897,
0.8527936339378357,
-0.09397561103105545,
0.5654188990592957,
-0.393774151802063,
0.39840564131736755,
0.6349278688430786,
-0.11496396362781525,
1.1306891441345215,
0.398319274187088,
-0.3699148893356323,
0.49597346782684326,
0.2167850285768509,
0.14921265840530396,
0.4142998456954956,
-0.19685624539852142,
-0.14137591421604156,
0.09813662618398666,
-0.034048497676849365,
0.00900881364941597,
0.8397800326347351,
0.331788033246994,
-0.141765758395195,
-0.1614413857460022,
0.3450295329093933,
-0.029604731127619743,
0.147012859582901,
-0.3817251920700073,
0.6229782104492188,
-0.2513223886489868,
-0.6522243618965149,
0.5256891846656799,
0.053360942751169205,
1.2083301544189453,
-0.38508927822113037,
-0.2666183114051819,
-0.036712396889925,
0.4512678384780884,
0.008442804217338562,
-0.7286771535873413,
0.33583202958106995,
-0.05094463378190994,
-0.28468629717826843,
-0.3609444797039032,
0.7919807434082031,
-0.876718282699585,
-0.855660617351532,
0.4919288456439972,
0.4825580418109894,
-0.152327761054039,
-0.3168622553348541,
-0.24762460589408875,
-0.15091915428638458,
-0.4486003816127777,
0.4211635887622833,
-0.33975186944007874,
0.5114519596099854,
0.30746960639953613,
0.27875202894210815,
0.24374312162399292,
0.2211325764656067,
0.36782005429267883,
0.3093232810497284,
0.4831143319606781,
-0.47751960158348083,
-0.5581231117248535,
-0.785959005355835,
0.3341384530067444,
0.03876161947846413,
-0.16461405158042908,
0.8651286363601685,
0.6715307235717773,
1.0033565759658813,
-0.490751713514328,
0.8185699582099915,
0.13442955911159515,
0.5270102024078369,
-0.37109991908073425,
0.7717284560203552,
-0.35649341344833374,
-0.1767859160900116,
-0.3468336760997772,
-1.1018983125686646,
-0.4479810893535614,
0.6547137498855591,
-0.15285217761993408,
-0.39674675464630127,
0.9715193510055542,
0.7261896133422852,
0.34872379899024963,
0.07660368084907532,
0.37230929732322693,
0.2521481215953827,
0.26134660840034485,
0.6799030900001526,
0.4489888846874237,
-0.7822129726409912,
0.3891519010066986,
-0.5595551133155823,
-0.23564642667770386,
-0.7026312351226807,
-0.5245292782783508,
-0.8816792368888855,
-0.8752140402793884,
-0.13777102530002594,
-0.14784713089466095,
0.43529751896858215,
0.7976306080818176,
0.25743234157562256,
-0.8516538739204407,
-0.2688046395778656,
0.3340441882610321,
0.4507705867290497,
-0.7246538400650024,
-0.2303718477487564,
0.7063953280448914,
-0.23869876563549042,
-1.1699557304382324,
0.09791333973407745,
0.6177587509155273,
-0.08939527720212936,
-0.15668366849422455,
0.03603013604879379,
-0.49273213744163513,
-0.030168980360031128,
0.989543616771698,
-0.21844473481178284,
-0.9054839611053467,
-0.5022332072257996,
0.2739728093147278,
-0.32798320055007935,
0.3252146542072296,
0.651001513004303,
-1.0540027618408203,
0.919893205165863,
0.6223086714744568,
0.46485525369644165,
0.059081338346004486,
-0.09413212537765503,
0.6464369297027588,
-0.6865234971046448,
-0.00719632301479578,
0.13488984107971191,
0.5014293193817139,
0.45945122838020325,
-0.47198206186294556,
0.39603638648986816,
0.11456262320280075,
-0.8100532293319702,
-0.3039407432079315,
-0.25358736515045166,
-0.9350713491439819,
0.06846034526824951,
1.0120338201522827,
0.2065516859292984,
-0.36592602729797363,
-0.1475125104188919,
-0.769417941570282,
0.6357763409614563,
-0.2956119179725647,
1.2392911911010742,
0.7733554840087891,
0.17753282189369202,
0.15048862993717194,
-0.30285289883613586,
0.060555849224328995,
0.30430999398231506,
-0.38806289434432983,
-0.2954302430152893,
0.2129959911108017,
-0.1867762953042984,
0.3380129635334015,
0.16470350325107574,
0.3306853771209717,
0.5382084250450134,
-0.24508912861347198,
0.3168865442276001,
0.32618558406829834,
-0.23266936838626862,
-0.519629180431366,
-0.10993259400129318,
-0.3111482262611389,
-0.41904905438423157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02559v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02559v1
|
A Literature Review and Framework for Human Evaluation of Generative Large Language Models in Healthcare
| 2024-05-04T04:16:07 | 2024-05-04T04:16:07 |
Thomas Yu Chow Tam, Sonish Sivarajkumar, Sumit Kapoor, Alisa V Stolyar, Katelyn Polanska, Karleigh R McCarthy, Hunter Osterhoudt, Xizhi Wu, Shyam Visweswaran, Sunyang Fu, Piyush Mathur, Giovanni E. Cacciamani, Cong Sun, Yifan Peng, Yanshan Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As generative artificial intelligence (AI), particularly Large Language
Models (LLMs), continues to permeate healthcare, it remains crucial to
supplement traditional automated evaluations with human expert evaluation.
Understanding and evaluating the generated texts is vital for ensuring safety,
reliability, and effectiveness. However, the cumbersome, time-consuming, and
non-standardized nature of human evaluation presents significant obstacles to
the widespread adoption of LLMs in practice. This study reviews existing
literature on human evaluation methodologies for LLMs within healthcare. We
highlight a notable need for a standardized and consistent human evaluation
approach. Our extensive literature search, adhering to the Preferred Reporting
Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, spans
publications from January 2018 to February 2024. This review provides a
comprehensive overview of the human evaluation approaches used in diverse
healthcare applications.This analysis examines the human evaluation of LLMs
across various medical specialties, addressing factors such as evaluation
dimensions, sample types, and sizes, the selection and recruitment of
evaluators, frameworks and metrics, the evaluation process, and statistical
analysis of the results. Drawing from diverse evaluation strategies highlighted
in these studies, we propose a comprehensive and practical framework for human
evaluation of generative LLMs, named QUEST: Quality of Information,
Understanding and Reasoning, Expression Style and Persona, Safety and Harm, and
Trust and Confidence. This framework aims to improve the reliability,
generalizability, and applicability of human evaluation of generative LLMs in
different healthcare applications by defining clear evaluation dimensions and
offering detailed guidelines.
|
[
-0.07445752620697021,
-0.4041837155818939,
0.7272409796714783,
0.20568321645259857,
-0.12418989092111588,
0.13776400685310364,
-0.21873897314071655,
-0.4606485962867737,
0.05990416929125786,
0.423797607421875,
-0.5365176200866699,
-0.5859193801879883,
-0.3897230327129364,
0.4554210901260376,
-0.28219470381736755,
0.5323894619941711,
-0.052574168890714645,
0.5720164179801941,
-0.468024879693985,
-0.07593996822834015,
-0.2961272597312927,
-0.6364566087722778,
-0.6106666922569275,
-0.6227663159370422,
0.5569029450416565,
0.006479859352111816,
0.6890718340873718,
0.2161455750465393,
0.6363645792007446,
0.36823770403862,
-0.26071253418922424,
0.21636809408664703,
-0.37629079818725586,
0.05317499488592148,
-0.16322052478790283,
-0.24355880916118622,
-0.5154680609703064,
-0.05538767948746681,
0.6982550621032715,
0.8780655264854431,
-0.35611268877983093,
0.15364159643650055,
0.014089877717196941,
0.8134943842887878,
-0.5756595730781555,
0.06838025152683258,
-0.10518976300954819,
0.39152881503105164,
-0.1676877737045288,
-0.2351357340812683,
-0.22425800561904907,
-0.41551947593688965,
0.507064938545227,
-0.4981595277786255,
0.07264866679906845,
0.08637464791536331,
0.4777933955192566,
0.11348453164100647,
-0.5621348023414612,
-0.3533410429954529,
-0.7657264471054077,
0.7879425287246704,
-0.7737753987312317,
0.3265133500099182,
0.19429723918437958,
0.44583144783973694,
-0.26130691170692444,
-0.6370247006416321,
-0.46075475215911865,
-0.45525166392326355,
-0.10179898887872696,
0.045073773711919785,
0.040886931121349335,
0.5029069185256958,
0.1471676230430603,
0.6877419948577881,
-0.7299691438674927,
0.2942892909049988,
-0.215842142701149,
-0.2198028564453125,
0.8394708037376404,
0.5781001448631287,
0.7284883260726929,
-0.42053791880607605,
-0.1743955910205841,
0.24687127768993378,
-0.6077712774276733,
-0.23462478816509247,
0.025315269827842712,
-0.07828158140182495,
0.027997763827443123,
0.48186585307121277,
-0.35957279801368713,
0.6493280529975891,
-0.322735071182251,
-0.5977159738540649,
0.4291066527366638,
-0.32971274852752686,
-0.40044596791267395,
-0.32305341958999634,
1.0283699035644531,
0.49518561363220215,
-0.01332509983330965,
-0.7288193106651306,
-0.21581535041332245,
-0.03582887724041939,
0.5637922286987305,
-0.7146599888801575,
0.27485644817352295,
0.19844289124011993,
-0.8604124784469604,
-0.2752096354961395,
-0.11086537688970566,
-0.8287733793258667,
-0.6907876133918762,
-0.4222642779350281,
0.12299074977636337,
-0.23470662534236908,
-0.04920078068971634,
0.25056955218315125,
0.10634210705757141,
0.3291146457195282,
0.3313537836074829,
-0.7825940847396851,
0.32235902547836304,
0.7531287670135498,
0.5638753175735474,
-0.47316044569015503,
-0.28340670466423035,
-0.25278812646865845,
-0.06746307015419006,
-0.44790926575660706,
0.5841390490531921,
-0.3378241956233978,
-0.5561947822570801,
0.3757821321487427,
-0.004549043718725443,
-0.1154446229338646,
-0.7056096196174622,
0.9774104952812195,
-0.5470209717750549,
0.21864256262779236,
-0.2831396460533142,
-0.4142799377441406,
-0.13787975907325745,
0.29948797821998596,
-0.669505774974823,
0.33825674653053284,
0.36986643075942993,
-0.5441804528236389,
0.3921584188938141,
-0.8151989579200745,
-0.5763173699378967,
0.4980092942714691,
-0.2879580557346344,
-0.45853543281555176,
0.12187080830335617,
0.3394828736782074,
0.3633364737033844,
-1.0202693939208984,
0.4584828019142151,
0.01537703163921833,
-0.5932816863059998,
0.3292917311191559,
-0.4268145263195038,
0.9176633954048157,
0.19638806581497192,
-0.34327903389930725,
0.47630980610847473,
-0.5658290982246399,
0.23155325651168823,
-0.05803697556257248,
-0.5096713900566101,
-0.028133010491728783,
0.1332070678472519,
0.16719873249530792,
-0.09648770093917847,
-0.05300828814506531,
-0.27390339970588684,
0.06161987781524658,
-0.6492267847061157,
0.5372066497802734,
0.4351087510585785,
0.2719323933124542,
0.4061957597732544,
-0.4366915225982666,
0.942783772945404,
-0.513729989528656,
0.5584998726844788,
0.05283176526427269,
-0.33889615535736084,
-0.4771603047847748,
-0.32664933800697327,
0.2499537169933319,
0.44428956508636475,
-0.763127326965332,
0.6333888173103333,
-0.3722638785839081,
-0.590183436870575,
-0.7741914987564087,
0.17532308399677277,
0.6299009919166565,
0.3885170817375183,
0.1549377739429474,
-0.39356929063796997,
-0.507300615310669,
-0.9853761196136475,
-0.2999197840690613,
-0.291041761636734,
-0.35058459639549255,
0.36812084913253784,
0.34972426295280457,
-1.0188041925430298,
0.8061689138412476,
-0.08110255002975464,
-0.19279015064239502,
-0.34305819869041443,
0.30973073840141296,
-0.011659452691674232,
0.14376969635486603,
0.408507376909256,
-0.6866403222084045,
-0.04669008404016495,
-0.09110512584447861,
-0.8903886079788208,
-0.06630592793226242,
-0.052667222917079926,
-0.11501193791627884,
0.07470239698886871,
0.04946921393275261,
-0.5621657967567444,
0.3519648015499115,
0.42417341470718384,
-0.18190667033195496,
0.7207452654838562,
-0.0692574679851532,
0.5021855235099792,
-0.8569558262825012,
0.2348833680152893,
0.07397159188985825,
-0.08113556355237961,
-0.574032723903656,
0.2832852005958557,
-0.1268252730369568,
-0.06551571190357208,
-0.18048632144927979,
0.7345494627952576,
-0.4830080568790436,
-0.14946790039539337,
-0.07081635296344757,
-0.016207212582230568,
0.1271308809518814,
0.1325756460428238,
-0.24302084743976593,
0.6393658518791199,
0.257161021232605,
-0.2800108790397644,
0.6767613291740417,
0.3124052882194519,
-0.7658025622367859,
0.6998432874679565,
-0.8913164138793945,
0.1419900804758072,
-0.032274678349494934,
0.2920040190219879,
-0.5811170339584351,
-0.34170353412628174,
0.325225830078125,
-0.20383991301059723,
0.2828039526939392,
0.10677628219127655,
-0.7704167366027832,
-0.5353379845619202,
-0.1952810138463974,
0.32204964756965637,
0.5859245657920837,
-0.17375780642032623,
0.5562572479248047,
0.5714132189750671,
-0.19989310204982758,
-0.396363228559494,
-0.2527177631855011,
0.5020592212677002,
-0.13971221446990967,
-0.7027052044868469,
0.27217814326286316,
-0.14137932658195496,
-0.5536887645721436,
-0.21016663312911987,
0.031839415431022644,
-0.15641562640666962,
0.20162764191627502,
0.2042539268732071,
0.4310339093208313,
0.03609072044491768,
0.178312286734581,
-0.047248780727386475,
0.070879265666008,
0.2850492596626282,
0.014453500509262085,
0.3285812437534332,
-0.3315926492214203,
-0.6168174147605896,
-0.7322896718978882,
0.40453094244003296,
0.757086992263794,
-0.06430195271968842,
0.3636951744556427,
0.6846286654472351,
-0.3717998266220093,
0.21345221996307373,
-0.6589952111244202,
-0.17593853175640106,
-0.34556713700294495,
0.639531672000885,
-0.0642828643321991,
-0.7377772331237793,
0.3014468252658844,
-0.07987610995769501,
0.03450896218419075,
0.5766811370849609,
0.9684887528419495,
-0.14718729257583618,
1.0387014150619507,
0.4012017250061035,
-0.13543471693992615,
-0.02709616720676422,
-0.06615257263183594,
0.22501584887504578,
-1.1128610372543335,
-0.4865208864212036,
-0.5023002028465271,
-0.002525671385228634,
-0.40113845467567444,
-0.5465247631072998,
0.7058244347572327,
-0.0539848767220974,
-0.08885183930397034,
-0.32063740491867065,
-0.46889054775238037,
0.10361044108867645,
0.08009350299835205,
0.1396866738796234,
0.3909255862236023,
-0.04760072007775307,
-0.23489196598529816,
0.0003553614660631865,
-0.5569035410881042,
-0.7020419239997864,
0.9780956506729126,
0.6353160738945007,
0.82994145154953,
-0.0034377288538962603,
0.548032820224762,
0.5129201412200928,
0.6592245697975159,
-1.0292950868606567,
0.42393314838409424,
-0.014431261457502842,
-0.6657296419143677,
-0.6042650938034058,
-0.4978090822696686,
-1.055795669555664,
0.29926297068595886,
-0.26323169469833374,
-0.6212039589881897,
-0.24899576604366302,
-0.2546366751194,
-0.4957233965396881,
0.050464559346437454,
-0.5634228587150574,
0.7222796678543091,
-0.4737272560596466,
-0.05453623831272125,
-0.29333218932151794,
-0.6277170777320862,
0.38047903776168823,
0.014718910679221153,
0.12304454296827316,
0.029069527983665466,
0.01972411386668682,
0.8098624348640442,
-0.3630986511707306,
0.8074368238449097,
0.027779143303632736,
-0.14308379590511322,
0.07105610519647598,
-0.13071148097515106,
0.08303496241569519,
0.06474889069795609,
-0.21597988903522491,
0.2932385802268982,
0.15702718496322632,
-0.25445547699928284,
-0.7396382093429565,
0.5182631015777588,
-0.9309383630752563,
-0.5679359436035156,
-0.39766499400138855,
-0.46914348006248474,
-0.657180666923523,
0.12717995047569275,
0.15196678042411804,
0.43509215116500854,
-0.5561774373054504,
-0.01654096320271492,
0.5471841096878052,
-0.559093177318573,
-0.19812466204166412,
0.47974708676338196,
-0.11740462481975555,
-0.4648863673210144,
0.6431787610054016,
-0.24500851333141327,
-0.007375734392553568,
0.33342596888542175,
0.26032885909080505,
-0.31502535939216614,
-0.6752961874008179,
-0.736518144607544,
0.4222806394100189,
-0.5802357792854309,
0.01222093403339386,
-0.43301764130592346,
-0.42312631011009216,
-0.4455140233039856,
-0.034849509596824646,
0.0458046980202198,
0.16423088312149048,
-0.41573646664619446,
0.17438827455043793,
-0.10421326756477356,
0.9624232053756714,
0.5269734859466553,
0.14287781715393066,
-0.8533165454864502,
0.43687915802001953,
0.447815865278244,
0.5176310539245605,
0.19458796083927155,
-0.3780355751514435,
-0.13831587135791779,
-0.07589075714349747,
-0.1698123961687088,
-0.7959438562393188,
0.37923526763916016,
0.038295991718769073,
0.9900975823402405,
0.5174751281738281,
-0.1852428913116455,
0.5458955764770508,
-0.6586563587188721,
0.7690296173095703,
0.4867343604564667,
-0.7492467761039734,
0.18110838532447815,
-0.2375800609588623,
0.25763124227523804,
0.6208851933479309,
0.4492112100124359,
-0.8272947072982788,
0.1496908813714981,
-0.21463343501091003,
-0.8601504564285278,
0.43275511264801025,
-0.01696273684501648,
0.08849243819713593,
0.0800735279917717,
0.44521796703338623,
-0.059662871062755585,
0.2526891827583313,
-0.41749393939971924,
-0.04870405048131943,
0.34087949991226196,
-0.11492778360843658,
-0.005028191953897476,
-0.6182230710983276,
-0.5332299470901489,
-0.022351371124386787,
0.41691333055496216,
-0.07413966208696365,
0.3139082193374634,
0.20892049372196198,
-0.16367073357105255,
-0.2262999266386032,
0.6567551493644714,
0.3221201002597809,
1.0932751893997192,
-0.04580770805478096,
-0.3332888185977936,
0.009289830923080444,
-0.28616848587989807,
0.11230591684579849,
0.07912331074476242,
-0.18391968309879303,
-0.03338056802749634,
0.6035997271537781,
0.6326800584793091,
0.27109071612358093,
-1.049415111541748,
0.6121838688850403,
-0.2277984619140625,
-0.1307947039604187,
-0.47533366084098816,
-0.08243082463741302,
0.060531310737133026,
0.07618790119886398,
0.37195420265197754,
-0.20039786398410797,
0.5481467843055725,
-0.6210425496101379,
-0.07729990780353546,
0.47301557660102844,
-0.46320468187332153,
-0.2027209848165512,
0.27008894085884094,
0.4633078873157501,
-0.4060474932193756,
0.713076114654541,
-0.21711641550064087,
-0.4653428792953491,
0.3368605971336365,
0.1902465522289276,
1.1389617919921875,
-0.22945788502693176,
0.344590425491333,
0.1299915313720703,
0.3064939081668854,
-0.09801783412694931,
0.22288228571414948,
0.16508105397224426,
-0.3833944499492645,
-0.6539555191993713,
-0.9636757373809814,
-0.5055131316184998,
0.16732539236545563,
-0.5661805868148804,
0.036779917776584625,
-0.27464741468429565,
-0.23785074055194855,
-0.14239424467086792,
0.10563524067401886,
-0.7793935537338257,
0.12465737015008926,
0.22336700558662415,
0.7606966495513916,
-0.5079290270805359,
0.4218105673789978,
0.7117090821266174,
-0.29489773511886597,
-0.6460186243057251,
0.2204904407262802,
0.15675859153270721,
-0.7551968097686768,
0.5220261216163635,
-0.07097453624010086,
-0.11563905328512192,
-0.5135329365730286,
-0.22109001874923706,
-0.47211962938308716,
1.1905360221862793,
0.20625272393226624,
-0.6606509685516357,
-0.5221729278564453,
0.10221606492996216,
1.0199506282806396,
-0.3884764015674591,
0.47085195779800415,
0.7872375249862671,
0.47220373153686523,
0.0759013220667839,
-1.204472541809082,
0.03540940582752228,
-0.2893379032611847,
0.42611271142959595,
-0.2617352604866028,
-0.5172888040542603,
0.33617255091667175,
-0.24145130813121796,
-0.31927749514579773,
0.5701529383659363,
0.2367725372314453,
0.26296600699424744,
0.3302154839038849,
0.44688406586647034,
0.42936477065086365,
0.7958724498748779,
0.02618613839149475,
1.385366439819336,
-0.1022493839263916,
0.18396270275115967,
0.6507234573364258,
-0.4967474043369293,
0.40078791975975037,
0.17243485152721405,
-0.633277177810669,
0.6201735138893127,
0.5436909794807434,
0.07867500931024551,
0.1130182221531868,
0.6461055874824524,
-0.33416181802749634,
-0.15786133706569672,
-0.19198882579803467,
-0.21311555802822113,
0.47664210200309753,
0.4063718020915985,
-0.5571446418762207,
-0.06438944488763809,
-0.0004061248619109392,
-0.08526411652565002,
-0.013275588862597942,
-0.35412290692329407,
0.9158074259757996,
0.07325843721628189,
-0.7645163536071777,
0.7517417073249817,
0.21826544404029846,
0.3891611099243164,
-0.45234304666519165,
0.0029474461916834116,
0.04323601350188255,
-0.2207222878932953,
-0.3386270999908447,
-0.34968921542167664,
0.1110013797879219,
0.01617659442126751,
-0.22002162039279938,
-0.10347811877727509,
0.6141923666000366,
0.012356034480035305,
-0.5272059440612793,
0.18802590668201447,
0.5429601073265076,
0.15908801555633545,
0.07225321233272552,
-0.8154221773147583,
0.02852189727127552,
-0.1639278680086136,
-0.20793703198432922,
0.4232862889766693,
0.17479486763477325,
-0.10666491091251373,
0.7298531532287598,
0.5401358604431152,
0.3086163103580475,
-0.2952842116355896,
0.6513819694519043,
0.7213753461837769,
-0.5598137974739075,
-0.1372767984867096,
-0.7258345484733582,
0.2789073586463928,
0.02872624434530735,
-0.12278001010417938,
0.43629780411720276,
0.3909156620502472,
0.24798661470413208,
0.0029485139530152082,
1.0282959938049316,
0.13464342057704926,
0.6971390247344971,
-0.38492950797080994,
0.8937296867370605,
-0.43921467661857605,
0.2681937515735626,
-0.3516996204853058,
-0.6845263242721558,
-0.40049490332603455,
0.5338695645332336,
-0.401819109916687,
0.1694297045469284,
0.5136606693267822,
0.44519391655921936,
0.4710301458835602,
-0.048570312559604645,
0.5381975769996643,
0.20771199464797974,
0.3888968825340271,
0.3694356083869934,
1.0355498790740967,
-0.24204784631729126,
0.2855052649974823,
0.1397630274295807,
-0.5254999399185181,
-0.46970826387405396,
-0.6265344023704529,
-0.8380473256111145,
-0.5292598605155945,
-0.02073388732969761,
-0.21915015578269958,
0.23877210915088654,
0.9549972414970398,
0.8345262408256531,
-0.5420119762420654,
-0.23608309030532837,
0.28175845742225647,
0.14081984758377075,
-0.13014094531536102,
-0.2433067262172699,
0.3653799593448639,
-0.3841506242752075,
-0.7804003953933716,
0.2846077084541321,
0.6373723745346069,
-0.20683149993419647,
-0.9164831042289734,
-0.34698182344436646,
0.24211490154266357,
-0.09957654774188995,
0.7548860907554626,
0.15303179621696472,
-1.0662437677383423,
0.155556321144104,
0.06923900544643402,
-0.41778329014778137,
-0.16795514523983002,
1.0063892602920532,
-0.6826887726783752,
0.6624531149864197,
0.4454716742038727,
0.8270530104637146,
-0.07507152110338211,
-0.06082954257726669,
0.5465364456176758,
-0.07388479262590408,
-0.27643904089927673,
0.7295032739639282,
0.5006040930747986,
0.5062883496284485,
-0.3703775405883789,
0.4725203812122345,
0.12479645013809204,
-0.802032470703125,
-0.7666705250740051,
0.1499861478805542,
-0.8362349271774292,
-0.13368037343025208,
1.2796647548675537,
-0.285163938999176,
-0.14895470440387726,
-0.3769347369670868,
-0.23108384013175964,
0.009555193595588207,
-0.09749474376440048,
1.1210964918136597,
0.49878522753715515,
-0.3143494725227356,
0.16740044951438904,
-0.6014814376831055,
0.5803587436676025,
0.28777995705604553,
-0.9738500118255615,
-0.1395026445388794,
0.5755418539047241,
0.2382294088602066,
0.09472165256738663,
0.7873650193214417,
-0.5053434371948242,
0.39147281646728516,
-0.5886591076850891,
0.18314960598945618,
0.36245933175086975,
-0.10068249702453613,
-0.42158374190330505,
-0.04215864837169647,
0.3112267255783081,
0.3254553973674774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06673v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06673v2
|
Overview of the EHRSQL 2024 Shared Task on Reliable Text-to-SQL Modeling on Electronic Health Records
| 2024-05-04T04:12:18 | 2024-05-23T17:25:21 |
Gyubok Lee, Sunjun Kweon, Seongsu Bae, Edward Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Electronic Health Records (EHRs) are relational databases that store the
entire medical histories of patients within hospitals. They record numerous
aspects of patients' medical care, from hospital admission and diagnosis to
treatment and discharge. While EHRs are vital sources of clinical data,
exploring them beyond a predefined set of queries requires skills in query
languages like SQL. To make information retrieval more accessible, one strategy
is to build a question-answering system, possibly leveraging text-to-SQL models
that can automatically translate natural language questions into corresponding
SQL queries and use these queries to retrieve the answers. The EHRSQL 2024
shared task aims to advance and promote research in developing a
question-answering system for EHRs using text-to-SQL modeling, capable of
reliably providing requested answers to various healthcare professionals to
improve their clinical work processes and satisfy their needs. Among more than
100 participants who applied to the shared task, eight teams were formed and
completed the entire shared task requirement and demonstrated a wide range of
methods to effectively solve this task. In this paper, we describe the task of
reliable text-to-SQL modeling, the dataset, and the methods and results of the
participants. We hope this shared task will spur further research and insights
into developing reliable question-answering systems for EHRs.
|
[
-0.0303170308470726,
-1.036616325378418,
1.0127837657928467,
-0.2660808861255646,
-0.17728374898433685,
-0.17542141675949097,
0.35158219933509827,
-0.6784637570381165,
0.050387926399707794,
0.8980128765106201,
-0.5399513244628906,
-0.5657442808151245,
-0.3152330219745636,
0.3335437774658203,
-0.5416019558906555,
1.247451901435852,
-0.16868473589420319,
0.12128565460443497,
-0.6456182599067688,
-0.25067827105522156,
-0.5264835953712463,
-0.8633549809455872,
-0.34012851119041443,
-0.13709671795368195,
0.33208033442497253,
0.26232072710990906,
0.4445529282093048,
0.6205942034721375,
0.7120245099067688,
0.15140987932682037,
0.09793290495872498,
0.1747218370437622,
-0.46772533655166626,
0.39068812131881714,
-0.04856589809060097,
-0.5498852133750916,
-0.7683749198913574,
-0.7186339497566223,
0.4246384799480438,
0.4959511458873749,
-0.6519147157669067,
0.280276358127594,
-0.06206986680626869,
0.7338793277740479,
-0.11756151169538498,
0.02854727767407894,
-0.6369128227233887,
0.026436518877744675,
-0.3013208210468292,
-0.36210447549819946,
-0.45637616515159607,
-0.40444666147232056,
0.16681338846683502,
-0.48527368903160095,
0.1726461499929428,
0.2693037986755371,
0.9136972427368164,
0.27807390689849854,
-0.6634320616722107,
-0.19644013047218323,
-0.7962211966514587,
0.7848353981971741,
-0.47610947489738464,
0.5731664299964905,
0.4280950129032135,
0.35697251558303833,
0.09478170424699783,
-0.7898521423339844,
-0.24248072504997253,
0.2313091903924942,
-0.24338386952877045,
0.014680550433695316,
0.15801602602005005,
0.1205577477812767,
0.007217233534902334,
0.13387538492679596,
-0.6888926029205322,
-0.4581242501735687,
-0.18587298691272736,
0.07160501927137375,
0.6260408163070679,
0.5428169965744019,
0.44658181071281433,
-0.23787634074687958,
-0.428059846162796,
0.4410149157047272,
-0.5302067995071411,
-0.24455390870571136,
-0.48540058732032776,
0.26757094264030457,
-0.022411802783608437,
0.7490241527557373,
-0.27499082684516907,
0.6861348152160645,
0.15223607420921326,
0.193772554397583,
0.29087620973587036,
-0.8157373070716858,
-0.1932346671819687,
0.07142333686351776,
0.6285266280174255,
0.2670896053314209,
-0.14192374050617218,
-0.33271631598472595,
-0.4033515155315399,
-0.24648113548755646,
0.4714853763580322,
-0.5389527678489685,
-0.28810688853263855,
0.8003944158554077,
-0.6551654934883118,
-0.007182463072240353,
-0.301853746175766,
-0.8294503092765808,
-0.024596072733402252,
-0.37612196803092957,
0.6809635162353516,
-0.3688678741455078,
-0.11355888098478317,
0.05315510928630829,
0.05774614214897156,
-0.03747184947133064,
0.36994850635528564,
-0.6666366457939148,
0.8306674361228943,
0.6765404343605042,
0.5556105971336365,
-0.33883360028266907,
0.020560160279273987,
-0.5600918531417847,
0.25161364674568176,
-0.13103826344013214,
0.7511756420135498,
-0.09765468537807465,
-0.3971904516220093,
-0.00880111288279295,
0.07071579247713089,
-0.2707195281982422,
-0.6086762547492981,
0.6815600991249084,
-0.7268194556236267,
0.261558473110199,
-0.5120299458503723,
-0.867339551448822,
0.16660965979099274,
0.5594443082809448,
-0.8600871562957764,
0.7939749360084534,
-0.1452077478170395,
-0.8103386163711548,
0.11592201888561249,
-0.6372552514076233,
-0.11057810485363007,
0.4130055904388428,
-0.3187304735183716,
-0.905906081199646,
-0.1706395000219345,
0.11151178181171417,
0.44197604060173035,
-0.4283589720726013,
0.39879533648490906,
-0.016553500667214394,
-0.2703046202659607,
0.11764343827962875,
0.011981923133134842,
0.6868563890457153,
0.033146899193525314,
-0.02280065044760704,
0.009981383569538593,
-0.5505184531211853,
0.37913864850997925,
0.2818068265914917,
-0.3443295955657959,
-0.19508330523967743,
0.25518620014190674,
0.1790303736925125,
0.10324660688638687,
0.4620498716831207,
-0.48847007751464844,
-0.41503196954727173,
-0.21891644597053528,
0.1293742060661316,
0.17074385285377502,
0.5134468078613281,
0.11882741004228592,
-0.7902806401252747,
0.5051117539405823,
-0.00995019730180502,
0.46386271715164185,
-0.30171430110931396,
-0.5685003995895386,
-0.2277527153491974,
0.07516048103570938,
0.12040713429450989,
0.7430465817451477,
-0.6705343723297119,
0.25651082396507263,
-0.3314562439918518,
-0.32983890175819397,
-0.4792589247226715,
-0.25106799602508545,
0.354615718126297,
0.7364833950996399,
0.717613935470581,
-0.1418498158454895,
-0.4485365152359009,
-0.7523295283317566,
-0.36122047901153564,
-0.2286318838596344,
-0.02430914156138897,
0.39097562432289124,
0.3977406322956085,
-0.051746927201747894,
0.7352303266525269,
-0.33289244771003723,
-0.3850373327732086,
-0.1315401792526245,
-0.04856143519282341,
0.1801159530878067,
0.26694151759147644,
0.2493700534105301,
-0.9790554642677307,
-0.523671567440033,
0.04395654425024986,
-0.9063675403594971,
0.23922450840473175,
0.2314876914024353,
-0.16674576699733734,
0.17190442979335785,
0.2534824311733246,
-0.4544829726219177,
0.28824353218078613,
0.5170422196388245,
-0.4627155661582947,
0.559958279132843,
-0.32307833433151245,
0.561286985874176,
-1.1793279647827148,
0.3482625186443329,
-0.0732445940375328,
-0.32787081599235535,
-0.7520475387573242,
-0.03826674818992615,
0.11353006213903427,
-0.1381382793188095,
-0.2985340356826782,
0.16449837386608124,
-0.5425717830657959,
-0.0047709746286273,
0.287792444229126,
-0.18786628544330597,
0.28098127245903015,
0.09567826241254807,
0.017796367406845093,
0.5174435973167419,
0.3968704640865326,
-0.4568295180797577,
0.30205580592155457,
0.6799266934394836,
-0.04657059535384178,
0.9925031065940857,
-0.8861713409423828,
0.36035865545272827,
-0.12591208517551422,
0.026404909789562225,
-0.7085519433021545,
-0.39042720198631287,
0.09918025135993958,
-0.45294293761253357,
0.11563578993082047,
-0.10961037129163742,
-0.49513787031173706,
-0.27934280037879944,
0.06370087713003159,
0.3587367534637451,
0.344081848859787,
-0.2592822313308716,
0.7597715854644775,
0.7643168568611145,
-0.46451741456985474,
-0.35214218497276306,
-0.7490320205688477,
0.02326897904276848,
-0.12226532399654388,
-0.6227923035621643,
0.758083164691925,
-0.002764369361102581,
-0.3066272735595703,
0.485431432723999,
0.18896882236003876,
-0.7251167893409729,
-0.19804532825946808,
0.09499253332614899,
0.6455780863761902,
-0.18310827016830444,
0.5716539025306702,
0.025319907814264297,
0.1981285810470581,
0.3242679238319397,
-0.07957587391138077,
0.332011342048645,
0.00193863979075104,
-0.6333252191543579,
-0.6180466413497925,
0.8781186938285828,
0.47154372930526733,
-0.5918866991996765,
1.0099653005599976,
-0.1958058923482895,
-0.702505350112915,
0.0261693075299263,
-0.5171107053756714,
-0.3563622534275055,
-0.35138756036758423,
0.5546898245811462,
-0.12715637683868408,
-0.7647324800491333,
0.4948517382144928,
0.04370824247598648,
0.3410424590110779,
0.46751168370246887,
0.31519535183906555,
-0.2711676061153412,
1.0393531322479248,
0.5748459100723267,
0.36397722363471985,
-0.05303576588630676,
0.33494216203689575,
0.010457461699843407,
-0.5986810922622681,
-0.7941557168960571,
-0.8589919805526733,
0.30407437682151794,
-0.21171316504478455,
-0.4905044138431549,
0.6745588183403015,
-0.3618142604827881,
-0.27835389971733093,
0.13616198301315308,
-0.6141310930252075,
0.1813160926103592,
0.019438352435827255,
0.5798094272613525,
0.5931951999664307,
-0.019785473123192787,
-0.02736840583384037,
-0.05821740999817848,
-0.42374783754348755,
-0.5656258463859558,
1.1500616073608398,
0.18822328746318817,
0.40302711725234985,
0.06271856278181076,
1.0417048931121826,
0.2126217484474182,
-0.14913654327392578,
-0.3553408086299896,
0.4675033986568451,
-0.13016624748706818,
-0.9502220153808594,
-0.562488317489624,
-0.37666913866996765,
-0.9118930101394653,
-0.13694559037685394,
-0.33765465021133423,
-0.4183763563632965,
-0.12740804255008698,
0.43577244877815247,
-0.4090896546840668,
0.274746835231781,
-0.402654230594635,
1.0154798030853271,
-0.47641676664352417,
-0.38662004470825195,
-0.054201871156692505,
-0.831809401512146,
-0.04872874543070793,
-0.26839661598205566,
0.31303492188453674,
0.10343490540981293,
-0.0505814291536808,
0.7395608425140381,
-0.3652961850166321,
0.4111075699329376,
-0.02438143640756607,
0.1864219605922699,
0.4235856235027313,
-0.1395694464445114,
0.5597003102302551,
-0.14878951013088226,
-0.44099339842796326,
0.12927116453647614,
0.5748822093009949,
-0.5082054138183594,
-0.3165356516838074,
0.38905858993530273,
-0.4522184133529663,
-0.24847270548343658,
-0.38319963216781616,
-0.2713180184364319,
-0.35818585753440857,
0.3311763405799866,
0.049154918640851974,
0.6278405785560608,
-0.47085508704185486,
0.045381031930446625,
0.9498013257980347,
-0.19925883412361145,
-0.10213540494441986,
0.3859683573246002,
-0.19993828237056732,
-0.12066750228404999,
0.5974242687225342,
0.23393647372722626,
0.23856955766677856,
0.6397402882575989,
-0.141678124666214,
-0.54055255651474,
-0.5778157114982605,
-0.5614177584648132,
0.3612385392189026,
-0.5293930172920227,
-0.16048385202884674,
-0.8901950120925903,
-0.33281174302101135,
-0.1426188349723816,
0.1435765027999878,
-0.2606489360332489,
-0.20055527985095978,
-0.5110384225845337,
-0.11742202192544937,
0.4866311848163605,
0.8386332988739014,
0.5412887334823608,
-0.31092575192451477,
-1.3738367557525635,
0.3126806914806366,
0.21523131430149078,
0.4389735460281372,
-0.215101957321167,
-0.3002278208732605,
-0.2432967871427536,
-0.07424761354923248,
-0.152272567152977,
-1.2200061082839966,
0.3707547187805176,
0.1999046802520752,
0.7335754632949829,
-0.23075516521930695,
0.2913079559803009,
0.4227195084095001,
-0.8816070556640625,
0.8179981112480164,
0.17923827469348907,
-0.772740364074707,
0.7163084745407104,
-0.5641695261001587,
0.09265321493148804,
0.9196935296058655,
0.513477623462677,
-0.4959661662578583,
-0.05401070415973663,
-0.4916929006576538,
-0.8689393401145935,
0.3549022078514099,
0.05594111606478691,
-0.20914098620414734,
0.02827172726392746,
0.5181038975715637,
-0.031858090311288834,
0.2707351744174957,
-0.3882584571838379,
-0.29843154549598694,
-0.07556404173374176,
-0.5676700472831726,
0.2769947052001953,
-0.23741576075553894,
-0.12732650339603424,
0.021387455984950066,
0.5067835450172424,
0.08878310024738312,
0.5389952063560486,
0.25470274686813354,
0.1966560035943985,
-0.4792485237121582,
0.5599039196968079,
0.0014319978654384613,
0.671631932258606,
-0.3318483531475067,
0.008892329409718513,
0.3032945990562439,
-0.3520333766937256,
-0.03185297176241875,
0.337337851524353,
-0.2638702094554901,
0.17257347702980042,
-0.1528172791004181,
0.5794028639793396,
-0.006761237047612667,
-0.7749694585800171,
0.4906671345233917,
-0.25667867064476013,
-0.2635039985179901,
-0.4155891537666321,
-0.287219762802124,
0.3993654251098633,
-0.13449528813362122,
0.40012744069099426,
-0.013624354265630245,
0.45095425844192505,
-0.40310031175613403,
0.7436115741729736,
0.2534067630767822,
-0.7903412580490112,
-0.27202707529067993,
0.9294521808624268,
0.1737995743751526,
-0.37434861063957214,
0.6041005849838257,
0.29571670293807983,
-0.41508159041404724,
0.6834508776664734,
0.5210138559341431,
0.36728426814079285,
-0.5774661302566528,
0.12884195148944855,
0.4537993371486664,
-0.08372650295495987,
-0.32089486718177795,
0.7708766460418701,
0.3943822383880615,
-0.2785194516181946,
-0.45307737588882446,
-0.2988196611404419,
-0.7130151987075806,
-0.1750190705060959,
-1.0155858993530273,
0.2790084183216095,
-0.008027440868318081,
-0.2646140456199646,
-0.290499210357666,
-0.1382283717393875,
-0.6802048087120056,
0.5045589804649353,
-0.25603368878364563,
0.5318387746810913,
-0.7747218608856201,
0.6578187942504883,
0.78859543800354,
-0.18926143646240234,
-1.081453561782837,
-0.0773051530122757,
0.06941889226436615,
-0.43930843472480774,
0.2627120316028595,
-0.20801754295825958,
0.2179483026266098,
0.0969008058309555,
-0.39809203147888184,
-0.7142788767814636,
1.1207916736602783,
0.06071007251739502,
-0.6904121041297913,
-0.35088449716567993,
0.3823986053466797,
0.6595673561096191,
0.007991881109774113,
0.10735782980918884,
0.2828775942325592,
0.2017187476158142,
0.003549311077222228,
-1.2406574487686157,
0.3036148250102997,
-0.16459135711193085,
-0.4435819983482361,
0.5035368204116821,
-0.29920440912246704,
0.8964490294456482,
-0.2930813133716583,
-0.10774887353181839,
0.14536090195178986,
0.3966648280620575,
0.44065555930137634,
0.5678132176399231,
0.2802264392375946,
0.40878865122795105,
0.9665391445159912,
-0.031656086444854736,
1.2302281856536865,
-0.26383861899375916,
0.41290953755378723,
1.1210477352142334,
-0.5927870273590088,
1.1078957319259644,
0.5676261186599731,
-0.3246680200099945,
0.352030873298645,
0.1881733536720276,
0.22188502550125122,
0.48555970191955566,
-0.1680516004562378,
-0.5779334902763367,
-0.2121206372976303,
-0.5047428011894226,
-0.46342048048973083,
-0.02988387830555439,
0.3414570391178131,
-0.4019869863986969,
0.0061628748662769794,
-0.2823510766029358,
-0.23058673739433289,
0.23984572291374207,
-0.17395716905593872,
0.8540946245193481,
0.31196334958076477,
-0.6790146827697754,
0.08336810767650604,
-0.28830236196517944,
0.2691786289215088,
-0.43748465180397034,
-0.3325602114200592,
0.27657386660575867,
-0.03814306855201721,
-0.25267019867897034,
-0.8661717772483826,
0.6007276177406311,
0.10681663453578949,
-0.24237731099128723,
-0.1901603639125824,
0.9339738488197327,
-0.5930758118629456,
-0.25516384840011597,
0.12203601747751236,
0.6891796588897705,
0.10693679749965668,
0.010502162389457226,
-0.7941221594810486,
0.021619930863380432,
-0.08831129223108292,
0.13985809683799744,
0.2703898251056671,
0.6232292652130127,
0.14828771352767944,
0.42304059863090515,
0.2828153073787689,
0.2817392945289612,
0.10359563678503036,
-0.11735851317644119,
0.5600780844688416,
-0.5131090879440308,
-0.4341224431991577,
-0.5144200325012207,
0.7096313238143921,
-0.09088155627250671,
0.05528143420815468,
0.6231011748313904,
0.7045568227767944,
0.4501968324184418,
-0.04233226925134659,
0.8316527009010315,
0.08000402897596359,
1.4577218294143677,
-0.3623819053173065,
0.8972669839859009,
-0.658804714679718,
0.0640203058719635,
-0.20688964426517487,
-0.43792808055877686,
-0.247409850358963,
0.25573086738586426,
-0.042242176830768585,
-0.02005481719970703,
0.763845682144165,
0.49378615617752075,
0.4464675486087799,
0.11644481867551804,
0.3941722512245178,
-0.014829629100859165,
0.34213122725486755,
0.5414408445358276,
0.5263211727142334,
-0.7311261296272278,
0.692719042301178,
-0.23479722440242767,
0.07945260405540466,
-0.2157551497220993,
-0.7102170586585999,
-0.4056524634361267,
-0.6293432712554932,
-0.4558761715888977,
-0.44845038652420044,
0.5429550409317017,
0.9144231081008911,
0.5846379995346069,
-1.0755889415740967,
-0.06591770052909851,
-0.17701125144958496,
-0.19584481418132782,
-0.1841101199388504,
-0.16627095639705658,
0.5123285055160522,
0.08101680129766464,
-0.39306211471557617,
0.003913844935595989,
0.20485717058181763,
-0.04683220759034157,
0.317512184381485,
0.011175993829965591,
-0.11059517413377762,
0.03366808220744133,
0.25302767753601074,
0.35661524534225464,
-0.3027806580066681,
0.026954444125294685,
0.5062294006347656,
-0.37450358271598816,
0.23534901440143585,
0.37961700558662415,
-0.4954242706298828,
0.4756493866443634,
0.5264694094657898,
0.837250292301178,
0.49003854393959045,
0.39406463503837585,
0.43256938457489014,
-0.4011310338973999,
-0.6757674217224121,
0.6684737205505371,
0.17552708089351654,
0.47923052310943604,
-0.5896963477134705,
0.11538230627775192,
-0.02646428719162941,
-1.0532941818237305,
-0.6728618144989014,
-0.0032275377307087183,
-0.9666051268577576,
-0.03376853093504906,
0.8134556412696838,
-0.13744953274726868,
-0.12309245765209198,
-0.7957677245140076,
-0.10777736455202103,
0.425405353307724,
-0.33691489696502686,
0.7016972303390503,
0.2368842512369156,
-0.39974352717399597,
-0.28491514921188354,
-0.863309919834137,
0.4577615559101105,
0.5175911784172058,
-1.3959136009216309,
-0.13711343705654144,
0.5001940727233887,
0.42737898230552673,
-0.11504757404327393,
1.0628690719604492,
-0.5453497767448425,
0.4282710552215576,
-0.3258157968521118,
0.043275732547044754,
0.30659863352775574,
-0.30284830927848816,
-0.11166948825120926,
0.35165131092071533,
0.15879784524440765,
-0.245820090174675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02517v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02517v1
|
Mothman at SemEval-2024 Task 9: An Iterative System for Chain-of-Thought Prompt Optimization
| 2024-05-03T23:04:52 | 2024-05-03T23:04:52 |
Alvin Po-Chun Chen, Ray Groshan, Sean von Bayern
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Extensive research exists on the performance of large language models on
logic-based tasks, whereas relatively little has been done on their ability to
generate creative solutions on lateral thinking tasks. The BrainTeaser shared
task tests lateral thinking and uses adversarial datasets to prevent
memorization, resulting in poor performance for out-of-the-box models. We
propose a system for iterative, chain-of-thought prompt engineering which
optimizes prompts using human evaluation. Using this shared task, we
demonstrate our system's ability to significantly improve model performance by
optimizing prompts and evaluate the input dataset.
|
[
-0.5740998983383179,
-0.7557700276374817,
0.7616417407989502,
0.4814792275428772,
-0.15830668807029724,
0.1129240021109581,
-0.07450713217258453,
-0.21672795712947845,
0.41147980093955994,
0.4466952085494995,
-1.2282801866531372,
-0.1858474761247635,
-0.2664473354816437,
0.41048088669776917,
-0.0100145498290658,
0.7690394520759583,
-0.07110314071178436,
-0.06227255240082741,
-0.29789596796035767,
-0.04738723486661911,
-1.0377100706100464,
-0.4640662968158722,
-1.01275634765625,
-0.4867447018623352,
0.7307509779930115,
0.3908674418926239,
0.518836498260498,
0.3488091230392456,
0.4284064471721649,
0.28118711709976196,
0.009836048819124699,
0.13882359862327576,
-0.3977075517177582,
0.3441186249256134,
-0.6796747446060181,
-0.19185811281204224,
-0.3138728141784668,
-0.22236178815364838,
0.09934214502573013,
0.6902835965156555,
-0.053712695837020874,
0.1879926323890686,
-0.06031649559736252,
0.7535313367843628,
-0.7501176595687866,
-0.037200625985860825,
-0.441612184047699,
0.11483903229236603,
-0.09455052763223648,
-0.37189531326293945,
-0.3648095428943634,
-0.5387403964996338,
0.17246975004673004,
-0.5987864136695862,
-0.10166467726230621,
0.35214152932167053,
0.3379811644554138,
0.4182341992855072,
-0.21022090315818787,
-0.26399490237236023,
-0.24738819897174835,
0.7259827852249146,
-0.43241265416145325,
0.23761571943759918,
0.3264949917793274,
0.48765045404434204,
-0.16975975036621094,
-0.45201021432876587,
-0.4152430593967438,
-0.009247909300029278,
0.2690221071243286,
0.22723817825317383,
-0.32497137784957886,
-0.04148174077272415,
0.33461952209472656,
-0.15806913375854492,
-0.731753408908844,
0.041313447058200836,
-0.5455513000488281,
-0.28487443923950195,
0.6685115694999695,
0.6625188589096069,
0.34364035725593567,
-0.12490320950746536,
-0.3871529698371887,
-0.14826567471027374,
-0.339656800031662,
0.36600449681282043,
0.21957071125507355,
0.14251156151294708,
0.33926907181739807,
0.5815802812576294,
-0.3905215561389923,
0.5933100581169128,
0.16141994297504425,
0.5648248791694641,
0.22343327105045319,
-0.22260144352912903,
0.018105464056134224,
-0.0009313837508670986,
0.7068889141082764,
0.6203994750976562,
0.12519650161266327,
-0.22532157599925995,
-0.5155067443847656,
0.5893471837043762,
0.46475738286972046,
-0.6466236710548401,
-0.3884775638580322,
0.23180259764194489,
-0.2874999940395355,
-0.338032603263855,
-0.2657765746116638,
-0.8258723020553589,
-0.6591200232505798,
-0.2974037528038025,
0.8360555768013,
-0.5063391327857971,
0.05511521175503731,
0.37442266941070557,
-0.49981555342674255,
-0.2747999131679535,
0.09451886266469955,
-0.6008964776992798,
0.34538838267326355,
0.4907178282737732,
0.6170457601547241,
-0.4934910833835602,
-0.45917776226997375,
-0.6912094354629517,
-0.12116961926221848,
-0.29777991771698,
0.9378319978713989,
-0.4981918931007385,
-0.33391034603118896,
-0.3477269113063812,
-0.14729659259319305,
-0.1453881412744522,
-0.553948163986206,
0.6604764461517334,
-0.7345704436302185,
0.07903793454170227,
-0.793728232383728,
-0.47822830080986023,
-0.29453521966934204,
0.2667415738105774,
-0.7554411292076111,
0.7797924280166626,
-0.11016257107257843,
-0.7747538089752197,
0.19253994524478912,
-0.8864929676055908,
-0.47840651869773865,
0.09451272338628769,
-0.3550463020801544,
-0.0366978719830513,
0.05822327733039856,
0.5737134218215942,
0.3527600169181824,
-0.5647138953208923,
0.5171769857406616,
-0.23830868303775787,
-0.5604466199874878,
0.3315759301185608,
-0.24382537603378296,
1.1750699281692505,
0.15056246519088745,
-0.5832931995391846,
0.45516204833984375,
-0.6207563877105713,
0.09408272057771683,
0.19898121058940887,
-0.0477331168949604,
-0.2061944603919983,
-0.18651743233203888,
-0.2392875850200653,
0.267404705286026,
0.38000959157943726,
-0.4136675298213959,
0.35468798875808716,
-0.3051464259624481,
0.2699722945690155,
1.124776005744934,
0.45140543580055237,
0.31716015934944153,
-0.4092491865158081,
0.8227584362030029,
0.13858655095100403,
0.27132683992385864,
-0.13023173809051514,
-0.4992457926273346,
-0.9033995270729065,
0.03273690864443779,
-0.21901363134384155,
0.7948179841041565,
-1.1089357137680054,
0.43144017457962036,
0.11094067245721817,
-0.41023048758506775,
-0.2953649163246155,
-0.06611990928649902,
0.2524176836013794,
0.6106427311897278,
0.38531792163848877,
-0.13585712015628815,
-0.6678557395935059,
-1.1830546855926514,
-0.4742075502872467,
0.17845095694065094,
0.02776418998837471,
-0.09506212174892426,
0.5236790180206299,
-0.5383297801017761,
0.733262836933136,
-0.6497359275817871,
0.17594856023788452,
-0.12620459496974945,
0.2035488486289978,
0.6019865274429321,
0.3781154751777649,
0.10669104754924774,
-0.39863982796669006,
-0.12075218558311462,
-0.31933048367500305,
-0.7512105703353882,
-0.4058036804199219,
-0.07457750290632248,
-0.32447242736816406,
-0.07268601655960083,
0.31649401783943176,
-0.6414732336997986,
0.45225340127944946,
0.24232248961925507,
-0.5235177874565125,
0.5206706523895264,
-0.231807678937912,
0.25504162907600403,
-0.8300892114639282,
0.280742883682251,
-0.24971148371696472,
0.04983586445450783,
-0.39479824900627136,
-0.07875679433345795,
0.03953162208199501,
-0.45881572365760803,
-0.09293976426124573,
0.47755300998687744,
-0.47230011224746704,
0.018433885648846626,
-0.34003397822380066,
0.15113788843154907,
0.0006490766536444426,
0.8282620310783386,
-0.2583179473876953,
1.0373988151550293,
0.6631172299385071,
-0.8425945043563843,
0.4130866229534149,
0.29483988881111145,
-0.21557572484016418,
0.6918164491653442,
-0.7608461380004883,
0.6567241549491882,
-0.3600085377693176,
0.005715640727430582,
-0.9187954068183899,
0.010283472947776318,
0.3321930766105652,
-0.2695356607437134,
-0.1962854266166687,
0.7773411273956299,
-0.3910992443561554,
-0.8046180009841919,
-0.434837281703949,
0.45448753237724304,
0.3920595645904541,
-0.6524946093559265,
0.49331092834472656,
0.5760126709938049,
-0.27102240920066833,
-0.35500723123550415,
-0.3654952049255371,
0.17828921973705292,
-0.2291823774576187,
-0.7368057370185852,
0.1826658844947815,
-0.27626487612724304,
-0.2646757960319519,
-0.20340564846992493,
-0.2864387631416321,
0.022877806797623634,
0.036600105464458466,
0.27215781807899475,
0.34304913878440857,
0.24176472425460815,
0.03954561427235603,
0.16000904142856598,
-0.2529599964618683,
0.4005342423915863,
-0.4325999915599823,
0.6541935205459595,
-0.23676340281963348,
-0.21768847107887268,
-0.5809022188186646,
0.5055859684944153,
0.23975756764411926,
-0.20874781906604767,
0.27560514211654663,
0.24426165223121643,
-0.4407518804073334,
-0.4262244403362274,
-0.5335692167282104,
-0.43281763792037964,
-0.5610103011131287,
0.15656937658786774,
-0.5967792272567749,
-0.7961649894714355,
0.587615430355072,
-0.030788009986281395,
0.053241461515426636,
0.4482746422290802,
0.4220550060272217,
-0.20027555525302887,
1.1571723222732544,
0.45042020082473755,
-0.08183702081441879,
0.05820242688059807,
-0.23173944652080536,
0.13624653220176697,
-0.591988742351532,
-0.28445184230804443,
-0.42354822158813477,
-0.5814862847328186,
0.01392147596925497,
-0.4758155047893524,
0.5156701803207397,
-0.057296011596918106,
-0.38026008009910583,
0.6307790875434875,
-0.7853018045425415,
0.5040349364280701,
0.6579997539520264,
0.45433008670806885,
0.024605268612504005,
-0.21774418652057648,
-0.5999792218208313,
-0.08365075290203094,
-0.9047806859016418,
-0.4336818754673004,
0.7242335677146912,
-0.014766928739845753,
0.6512942314147949,
-0.26892510056495667,
0.5718114972114563,
0.35835886001586914,
-0.1024228185415268,
-0.5601857900619507,
0.9667958617210388,
0.16297033429145813,
-0.5819253325462341,
-0.25898459553718567,
-0.2698849141597748,
-0.9194566607475281,
0.06426240503787994,
0.22460682690143585,
-1.0041052103042603,
0.2701805830001831,
0.06836811453104019,
-0.5967105031013489,
-0.12370241433382034,
-0.418061226606369,
0.8228961825370789,
-0.12619389593601227,
-0.40847110748291016,
-0.41163045167922974,
-0.6450580954551697,
0.2085820585489273,
-0.17429982125759125,
-0.06863914430141449,
0.2055528461933136,
-0.0731755867600441,
1.0431219339370728,
-0.38510963320732117,
0.6206346750259399,
-0.29572156071662903,
0.049285463988780975,
0.49731436371803284,
0.12271063029766083,
0.6689175367355347,
-0.09712820500135422,
-0.3044973313808441,
-0.15652363002300262,
-0.21478290855884552,
-0.15264491736888885,
-0.8137115836143494,
0.507158637046814,
-0.6173611879348755,
-0.8367385268211365,
-0.19167444109916687,
-0.5743854641914368,
-0.37301570177078247,
0.17715251445770264,
0.43394166231155396,
0.492055207490921,
0.037448473274707794,
0.08443205058574677,
0.5161203145980835,
-0.3249942660331726,
0.5116474628448486,
0.0906703770160675,
-0.28721633553504944,
-0.8012464046478271,
0.7106747627258301,
0.003222163999453187,
-0.19594025611877441,
0.23737357556819916,
0.20374487340450287,
-0.37236207723617554,
-0.1476382166147232,
-0.23395328223705292,
-0.09137699753046036,
-0.971759557723999,
-0.17427630722522736,
-0.8656235337257385,
-0.04141056537628174,
-0.17803415656089783,
-0.37483444809913635,
-0.15999217331409454,
-0.5965011119842529,
-0.14346173405647278,
-0.1306990683078766,
0.1719726175069809,
0.6043065786361694,
-0.006728166714310646,
0.2579818069934845,
-0.5571988821029663,
0.2635495364665985,
0.32114100456237793,
-0.03193340077996254,
0.10237950086593628,
-0.2557869851589203,
-0.1915898621082306,
-0.09997361898422241,
-0.5311556458473206,
-1.031604528427124,
0.2179519087076187,
-0.3673047423362732,
0.6736811995506287,
0.2532225251197815,
0.11522670835256577,
0.8054504990577698,
-0.5027360320091248,
0.584373950958252,
0.3541114628314972,
-1.0603291988372803,
0.8859519362449646,
-0.4304201304912567,
0.6190556287765503,
0.8704066276550293,
0.3278962969779968,
-0.46153464913368225,
-0.3456856608390808,
-0.517536461353302,
-0.6395571231842041,
0.5823138356208801,
0.22658264636993408,
-0.4263368546962738,
-0.11018501222133636,
0.1711176186800003,
0.23433208465576172,
0.23398149013519287,
-0.24277059733867645,
0.05687340348958969,
0.04354052618145943,
-0.16543792188167572,
-0.02171855978667736,
0.05027962848544121,
-0.0441385954618454,
-0.3789641261100769,
0.6418079137802124,
-0.12408554553985596,
0.25663822889328003,
0.1977972388267517,
-0.05522730574011803,
-0.31588810682296753,
0.14373432099819183,
0.5645321011543274,
0.8018736243247986,
0.09051671624183655,
0.15216466784477234,
0.41510728001594543,
-0.2703121304512024,
0.3049762547016144,
-0.1463116854429245,
-0.320687860250473,
-0.1353473961353302,
0.02277093566954136,
0.9559527635574341,
0.20078003406524658,
-0.6858834028244019,
0.3792704641819,
0.06859573721885681,
-0.01847911812365055,
-0.20541004836559296,
0.3581717908382416,
0.18287859857082367,
0.6335797309875488,
0.3145502507686615,
0.6545582413673401,
0.5154203772544861,
-0.3035324215888977,
0.40013861656188965,
0.17434604465961456,
-0.27591994404792786,
-0.5109815001487732,
0.8106547594070435,
0.31259849667549133,
-0.7000552415847778,
0.5264960527420044,
-0.22166168689727783,
-0.8886699676513672,
0.7166483998298645,
0.4695965647697449,
1.2480981349945068,
-0.17475053668022156,
0.07367826998233795,
0.41383156180381775,
0.33851611614227295,
-0.12928737699985504,
0.8767476677894592,
-0.12192472070455551,
-0.5143070816993713,
-0.270700067281723,
-0.20665237307548523,
-0.38277333974838257,
-0.045766450464725494,
-0.5161222219467163,
0.5655556917190552,
-0.528045654296875,
-0.5765629410743713,
-0.17259708046913147,
0.07736840099096298,
-1.0229178667068481,
0.21317894756793976,
-0.24984559416770935,
1.020822286605835,
-0.5204746127128601,
0.5016498565673828,
0.6979973912239075,
-0.3447188138961792,
-0.7713137269020081,
-0.17283031344413757,
0.026649244129657745,
-0.6361879110336304,
0.9770838022232056,
0.5523726344108582,
-0.3741968274116516,
0.15022924542427063,
-0.2874916195869446,
-0.5394819378852844,
1.13384211063385,
0.2092961072921753,
-0.6676968336105347,
-0.14265364408493042,
-0.17093946039676666,
0.25449711084365845,
-0.2613826394081116,
0.26932716369628906,
0.37447431683540344,
0.5219581127166748,
0.017821647226810455,
-0.7724502682685852,
0.2851419746875763,
-0.448482483625412,
0.18094883859157562,
0.10077372938394547,
-0.5566585659980774,
0.8999729752540588,
-0.2632664740085602,
-0.3229234516620636,
-0.033760637044906616,
0.5935832262039185,
0.6582270860671997,
0.38070791959762573,
0.690990149974823,
0.5379080772399902,
1.0067977905273438,
0.3745180666446686,
0.7408838868141174,
-0.24042080342769623,
0.019024036824703217,
1.0975195169448853,
-0.495218425989151,
0.7019447088241577,
0.7297166585922241,
-0.02933339774608612,
0.25982725620269775,
0.5707970857620239,
0.1433829367160797,
0.6768690347671509,
0.4696602523326874,
-0.17889787256717682,
-0.197670117020607,
-0.09594709426164627,
-0.027891872450709343,
0.29892635345458984,
0.061904534697532654,
-0.007331229280680418,
-0.1478908807039261,
0.3393940031528473,
-0.3202390670776367,
0.05464507266879082,
-0.26615309715270996,
0.5959071516990662,
0.025395864620804787,
-1.1083048582077026,
0.4394330680370331,
-0.2073313593864441,
0.6488139033317566,
-0.23052111268043518,
0.31038302183151245,
-0.19174298644065857,
0.4172554612159729,
0.15918228030204773,
-0.5795858502388,
0.35231438279151917,
0.030818086117506027,
-0.09898881614208221,
-0.31376025080680847,
0.9227408766746521,
-0.093917116522789,
-0.439945787191391,
0.30711010098457336,
0.4128860831260681,
0.01762060448527336,
-0.22829663753509521,
-0.6038476824760437,
0.3119777739048004,
-0.048290740698575974,
-0.4005644917488098,
-0.27078863978385925,
0.5033069252967834,
-0.1319562941789627,
0.9575132727622986,
0.4534866213798523,
-0.1324705183506012,
-0.07153014838695526,
0.029086695984005928,
1.0723013877868652,
-0.9851933717727661,
-0.7675999402999878,
-1.0827460289001465,
0.5384926199913025,
-0.351121723651886,
-0.461505264043808,
0.7661669254302979,
0.7137293815612793,
0.4788699150085449,
-0.30662184953689575,
0.6249195337295532,
0.19948914647102356,
0.4143243730068207,
-0.32390642166137695,
0.6916797161102295,
-0.38546812534332275,
0.10815033316612244,
-0.45148202776908875,
-1.0020288228988647,
0.03795037791132927,
0.5976868271827698,
-0.24305814504623413,
-0.18968673050403595,
1.0436664819717407,
0.7785215973854065,
0.14189240336418152,
0.6114745140075684,
0.3345056176185608,
-0.2109365463256836,
0.1529647260904312,
0.9523530006408691,
1.2089695930480957,
-0.466037780046463,
0.24397499859333038,
-0.24624484777450562,
-0.3397963047027588,
-0.08470392227172852,
-0.6420267224311829,
-1.1989874839782715,
-0.7990036010742188,
-0.16363781690597534,
-0.06745841354131699,
0.2875741124153137,
1.1715787649154663,
0.3911004066467285,
-0.64267498254776,
-0.5166189670562744,
-0.3588184416294098,
-0.32898613810539246,
-0.24743662774562836,
-0.22786274552345276,
0.09622978419065475,
-0.48901546001434326,
-0.3205801248550415,
0.5874959826469421,
0.6423889994621277,
-0.404403418302536,
-0.2280523031949997,
0.020744027569890022,
-0.1654409021139145,
0.22201946377754211,
0.5227482914924622,
-0.20332811772823334,
-0.4969460070133209,
-0.23582273721694946,
0.4885149300098419,
-0.116373710334301,
-0.1813785582780838,
0.9709811806678772,
-0.9049689769744873,
0.38394859433174133,
0.7135528326034546,
1.1417326927185059,
0.3077549338340759,
-0.0729270949959755,
0.8814735412597656,
-0.23705706000328064,
0.008879599161446095,
0.6037635803222656,
0.2846372127532959,
0.1464795023202896,
-0.5185062289237976,
0.5395921468734741,
0.22309598326683044,
-0.6962476968765259,
-0.5174769759178162,
0.09134242683649063,
-0.871300220489502,
-0.2898024916648865,
0.7140998840332031,
0.1517331302165985,
-0.409995973110199,
0.04266669601202011,
-0.5041900873184204,
0.2964450418949127,
-0.4359261393547058,
0.8469942212104797,
0.8082551956176758,
-0.2922695279121399,
-0.26389753818511963,
-0.3475223481655121,
0.30343708395957947,
0.6897474527359009,
-0.960351288318634,
-0.12936557829380035,
0.4594588875770569,
-0.016536975279450417,
0.15787288546562195,
0.8604621887207031,
0.39411333203315735,
0.3234836161136627,
0.03123699128627777,
-0.048544757068157196,
-0.002525404328480363,
-0.48968610167503357,
-0.2179720550775528,
0.16108554601669312,
-0.37848877906799316,
-0.23525507748126984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02501v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02501v2
|
PICLe: Eliciting Diverse Behaviors from Large Language Models with Persona In-Context Learning
| 2024-05-03T22:17:22 | 2024-05-14T05:53:07 |
Hyeong Kyu Choi, Yixuan Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are trained on massive text corpora, which are
encoded with diverse personality traits. This triggers an interesting goal of
eliciting a desired personality trait from the LLM, and probing its behavioral
preferences. Accordingly, we formalize the persona elicitation task, aiming to
customize LLM behaviors to align with a target persona. We present Persona
In-Context Learning (PICLe), a novel persona elicitation framework grounded in
Bayesian inference. At the core, PICLe introduces a new ICL example selection
criterion based on likelihood ratio, which is designed to optimally guide the
model in eliciting a specific target persona. We demonstrate the effectiveness
of PICLe through extensive comparisons against baseline methods across three
contemporary LLMs. Code is available at
https://github.com/deeplearning-wisc/picle.
|
[
-0.30010491609573364,
-0.8912785053253174,
0.5863465070724487,
0.39294540882110596,
0.0774960070848465,
0.2279493361711502,
-0.2045072615146637,
-0.3597782850265503,
-0.20198564231395721,
0.3017992675304413,
-0.5900294780731201,
-0.6352295279502869,
-0.23450279235839844,
-0.1395343691110611,
-0.14209657907485962,
0.9769748449325562,
0.5045034885406494,
0.2492588460445404,
-0.19197407364845276,
0.13039518892765045,
-0.32941749691963196,
-0.5522010326385498,
-0.8890075087547302,
-0.4806714355945587,
0.8496243357658386,
0.6871435642242432,
0.23347072303295135,
-0.2190249115228653,
0.26883843541145325,
0.21560731530189514,
0.036344610154628754,
0.013036194257438183,
-0.6153589487075806,
0.22402694821357727,
-0.4245801568031311,
-0.4475313425064087,
-0.2820214331150055,
0.08832866698503494,
0.7798663973808289,
1.032668113708496,
0.14414826035499573,
0.0063090878538787365,
0.1669480949640274,
0.46023595333099365,
-0.768500804901123,
0.14337050914764404,
-0.4853498935699463,
0.10038167238235474,
0.0012704739347100258,
-0.003004583762958646,
-0.6884757876396179,
-0.2507915794849396,
0.2610996961593628,
-0.2031170129776001,
0.0107116075232625,
0.2044484168291092,
0.407735675573349,
-0.15726138651371002,
-0.7566872239112854,
-0.1417589783668518,
-0.7601019144058228,
0.8367204070091248,
-0.4455806612968445,
0.3305375277996063,
0.47727739810943604,
0.23613205552101135,
-0.23323693871498108,
-0.45841193199157715,
-0.4939570128917694,
-0.3535129129886627,
-0.10988326370716095,
0.21200929582118988,
0.030458621680736542,
0.08805299550294876,
0.31099840998649597,
0.503185510635376,
-0.5731310844421387,
0.42876869440078735,
-0.003006495302543044,
0.06959609687328339,
0.4137183725833893,
0.019468551501631737,
0.20595331490039825,
-0.12391944974660873,
-0.38269585371017456,
-0.13652636110782623,
-0.6990768909454346,
0.3764610290527344,
0.4513985514640808,
0.1468859612941742,
-0.2853396236896515,
0.6221330165863037,
-0.12084303796291351,
0.4810861647129059,
0.5420388579368591,
-0.3608567416667938,
0.2767554521560669,
0.2796919643878937,
-0.2842235565185547,
-0.03556964918971062,
0.6553731560707092,
0.19042973220348358,
0.006239701062440872,
-0.3131316900253296,
-0.12043783068656921,
-0.17146636545658112,
-0.010001123882830143,
-0.947472095489502,
-0.41655173897743225,
0.4909452497959137,
-0.3826334476470947,
-0.396045446395874,
0.03512733429670334,
-0.8686736226081848,
-0.539597749710083,
-0.24572467803955078,
0.21063049137592316,
-0.7987525463104248,
-0.118988037109375,
-0.08614648133516312,
-0.1148548498749733,
0.6556960940361023,
0.3891981244087219,
-1.1361333131790161,
0.15694384276866913,
0.6906801462173462,
0.6652795672416687,
-0.3104632794857025,
-0.5073348879814148,
-1.0110597610473633,
0.38381287455558777,
-0.2341068685054779,
1.0159002542495728,
-0.699565052986145,
-0.5185468792915344,
-0.022508354857563972,
-0.2386658489704132,
-0.17564044892787933,
-0.47239550948143005,
0.4292798638343811,
-0.36265432834625244,
0.39262235164642334,
-0.3491154909133911,
-0.8796644806861877,
-0.06107313185930252,
0.36259812116622925,
-0.4445261061191559,
0.6695482730865479,
0.4608534872531891,
-0.6015781760215759,
0.5569429993629456,
-0.6087174415588379,
-0.4624471664428711,
0.4424111247062683,
-0.4115806818008423,
-0.21141214668750763,
0.187767893075943,
0.07766269892454147,
0.7584526538848877,
-0.17479310929775238,
0.2048770785331726,
-0.5292608141899109,
-0.3236674964427948,
0.5011847019195557,
-0.10985907912254333,
0.9515378475189209,
0.2632808983325958,
-0.07022872567176819,
0.36860230565071106,
-0.360444039106369,
-0.10433230549097061,
-0.045893408358097076,
-0.6478027105331421,
-0.21060939133167267,
0.050491828471422195,
0.23669753968715668,
0.1453460156917572,
0.2911202013492584,
-0.4864252507686615,
0.3499579131603241,
-0.3618776798248291,
0.09021718800067902,
0.5952268838882446,
0.08042501658201218,
0.7205390930175781,
-0.4503636062145233,
0.472601056098938,
-0.026530316099524498,
0.08112458884716034,
-0.26209557056427,
-0.4178653657436371,
-0.17142656445503235,
-0.8196755051612854,
-0.041115716099739075,
0.6047300696372986,
-0.5063138008117676,
0.6286088228225708,
-0.05966801196336746,
-0.570075273513794,
-0.07132342457771301,
0.02932417206466198,
0.4009611904621124,
0.5245480537414551,
0.0012388437753543258,
-0.178512305021286,
-0.24523422122001648,
-0.84523606300354,
-0.27158844470977783,
-0.3693031072616577,
-0.21434743702411652,
0.5534057021141052,
0.31852948665618896,
-0.3359401822090149,
0.8760070204734802,
-0.19076652824878693,
0.004560158122330904,
-0.7541839480400085,
0.15583786368370056,
0.0994919016957283,
0.38895100355148315,
0.9251344799995422,
-1.0257925987243652,
-0.5595783591270447,
-0.11161871254444122,
-0.5551913380622864,
-0.157830148935318,
-0.16732758283615112,
-0.15089692175388336,
-0.03131522983312607,
0.4976925551891327,
-0.4910043478012085,
0.09745053946971893,
0.6473855376243591,
-0.5671149492263794,
0.7521158456802368,
-0.046740297228097916,
0.32212144136428833,
-1.1699103116989136,
0.18000270426273346,
0.30072474479675293,
-0.2485441267490387,
-0.5752272009849548,
0.22594517469406128,
0.1939842402935028,
-0.13542066514492035,
-0.5846416354179382,
0.9431079030036926,
-0.17085184156894684,
-0.21551573276519775,
-0.13585534691810608,
-0.12573261559009552,
-0.02645290456712246,
0.6130833625793457,
0.1863929182291031,
0.6256646513938904,
0.6161472201347351,
-0.66425621509552,
0.32863089442253113,
0.40807491540908813,
-0.6615976095199585,
1.0655848979949951,
-0.38004687428474426,
0.07808920741081238,
-0.23712773621082306,
0.2691609263420105,
-1.0919866561889648,
-0.5451148152351379,
0.21934984624385834,
-0.17662006616592407,
0.2637665867805481,
-0.42185401916503906,
-0.5705205798149109,
-0.11181796342134476,
-0.17497369647026062,
0.2833288311958313,
0.5209239721298218,
-0.7322475910186768,
0.5330374836921692,
0.45270949602127075,
-0.1923842579126358,
-0.2515949010848999,
-0.5654529929161072,
0.03839744254946709,
-0.5463526844978333,
-0.14044426381587982,
0.5205538272857666,
-0.6440945267677307,
-0.41920554637908936,
-0.5071823000907898,
0.27985668182373047,
-0.17588582634925842,
0.08796048909425735,
0.14534765481948853,
0.2270081639289856,
0.006246758624911308,
0.16420738399028778,
0.20667171478271484,
0.20688281953334808,
-0.0023476562928408384,
-0.20526669919490814,
0.7291200160980225,
-0.3849274814128876,
-0.3289702236652374,
-0.3380134701728821,
0.5674570202827454,
0.5266759395599365,
-0.06106117367744446,
0.6541721224784851,
0.6771659851074219,
-0.16685354709625244,
-0.23811253905296326,
-0.46902796626091003,
-0.3195803165435791,
-0.47229140996932983,
0.43362903594970703,
-0.5281566977500916,
-1.0380337238311768,
0.5661589503288269,
-0.3843553960323334,
0.035063814371824265,
-0.18741749227046967,
0.5670079588890076,
-0.3220057785511017,
0.8492091298103333,
0.7820023894309998,
-0.25788983702659607,
0.8184560537338257,
-0.08871457725763321,
0.2700153589248657,
-0.9803276062011719,
-0.3766559362411499,
-0.307029128074646,
-0.5521672964096069,
-0.496184378862381,
-0.19187967479228973,
0.17594534158706665,
0.09164507687091827,
-0.5000549554824829,
0.09080328047275543,
0.039622243493795395,
0.4885447323322296,
0.6608566045761108,
0.31737542152404785,
0.14917629957199097,
0.03332474082708359,
-0.19817693531513214,
-0.153401181101799,
-0.5837656259536743,
-0.45950448513031006,
0.7840380072593689,
0.14385706186294556,
0.9151406288146973,
0.45333918929100037,
0.624496579170227,
0.0524558387696743,
0.4928739070892334,
-1.135500431060791,
0.6956489086151123,
-0.19616806507110596,
-0.5782425403594971,
-0.15771332383155823,
-0.38083094358444214,
-1.0050538778305054,
0.21851058304309845,
-0.3913156986236572,
-1.2908238172531128,
0.2937243580818176,
0.3991621732711792,
-0.26504743099212646,
0.3153790235519409,
-0.5817015171051025,
1.16876220703125,
-0.48372554779052734,
-0.4611203670501709,
-0.21506263315677643,
-0.5120053291320801,
0.45737048983573914,
0.002234488958492875,
-0.15268224477767944,
-0.1868230253458023,
-0.10121209919452667,
0.16334187984466553,
0.28856244683265686,
1.0988779067993164,
-0.06127113848924637,
-0.08105628937482834,
-0.08956312388181686,
0.4250624477863312,
0.34379738569259644,
0.24711662530899048,
-0.24938371777534485,
-0.12699921429157257,
-0.05980871990323067,
-0.3992086350917816,
-0.5340142250061035,
0.8543082475662231,
-0.6035601496696472,
-0.32741373777389526,
-0.30852994322776794,
-0.652234673500061,
-0.5473081469535828,
0.11517830938100815,
0.46249863505363464,
0.28950950503349304,
-0.630145251750946,
0.33903518319129944,
0.89307701587677,
-0.6473323702812195,
0.40286245942115784,
0.6000672578811646,
-0.5265371203422546,
-0.06344501674175262,
0.6403906345367432,
-0.5153777599334717,
0.1793500930070877,
0.826873779296875,
0.2525068521499634,
-0.15271060168743134,
-0.2767205536365509,
-0.09845441579818726,
0.13991153240203857,
-0.6278855204582214,
0.19911445677280426,
-0.5640820860862732,
-0.0419982485473156,
-0.37675216794013977,
-0.3969336748123169,
-0.22806349396705627,
0.07067408412694931,
-0.18157421052455902,
0.22954076528549194,
-0.02464596927165985,
0.5153449773788452,
0.3918910622596741,
0.41641291975975037,
-0.5490111708641052,
0.14012174308300018,
0.43166065216064453,
0.1913817971944809,
-0.127615287899971,
-0.6088405847549438,
0.020420588552951813,
-0.17414285242557526,
-0.2821923494338989,
-0.9136753678321838,
0.5635323524475098,
0.38797852396965027,
0.7333910465240479,
0.596179723739624,
-0.14873982965946198,
0.3652157485485077,
-0.41438597440719604,
0.5746865272521973,
0.2240564525127411,
-0.7831796407699585,
0.8844411373138428,
-0.6042128205299377,
0.49980857968330383,
0.47685062885284424,
0.6556037068367004,
-0.6836661696434021,
-0.30777084827423096,
-0.5958789587020874,
-0.5516939759254456,
0.1865728795528412,
-0.21010993421077728,
0.21306627988815308,
-0.259484201669693,
0.49645495414733887,
0.340702086687088,
0.3524560034275055,
-0.9306923151016235,
0.0649028867483139,
0.167552649974823,
-0.36540162563323975,
-0.12933838367462158,
-0.24862992763519287,
0.07006054371595383,
-0.35582175850868225,
0.3655151426792145,
-0.5136830806732178,
0.32352954149246216,
-0.0570518933236599,
-0.24210208654403687,
0.0722578838467598,
0.2806950807571411,
0.026742953807115555,
0.6233602166175842,
-0.28454121947288513,
-0.04674243927001953,
0.002307221991941333,
-0.25839582085609436,
-0.11029813438653946,
-0.061022110283374786,
-0.2921605408191681,
-0.4537414312362671,
0.1774848997592926,
0.6375670433044434,
0.7907782196998596,
-0.9804912805557251,
0.7588866353034973,
-0.17216716706752777,
-0.06818438321352005,
-0.545128345489502,
0.3622492551803589,
0.03684950992465019,
0.536243200302124,
0.30247756838798523,
-0.21405600011348724,
0.23514603078365326,
-0.8164846897125244,
0.09524278342723846,
0.6379705667495728,
-0.23950672149658203,
-0.302226185798645,
0.4560004770755768,
0.1294945776462555,
-0.2541559338569641,
0.7877941131591797,
-0.29726263880729675,
-0.10558393597602844,
0.3585388660430908,
0.7547018527984619,
0.9324029684066772,
-0.3038046360015869,
0.4075147211551666,
0.38256579637527466,
-0.08992119133472443,
0.15281733870506287,
0.29273566603660583,
-0.1790979951620102,
-0.8829178810119629,
-0.6055242419242859,
-0.6805294752120972,
-0.7807881832122803,
0.42001545429229736,
-0.4951907694339752,
0.30087336897850037,
-0.6235597729682922,
0.09075913578271866,
-0.13742251694202423,
0.069544717669487,
-0.7187555432319641,
-0.008431301452219486,
0.29849350452423096,
0.728706419467926,
-0.8434154987335205,
1.0079058408737183,
1.022408366203308,
-0.2662527859210968,
-0.5139783620834351,
0.27464064955711365,
0.15080766379833221,
-0.3861504793167114,
0.6844452619552612,
0.15624339878559113,
0.05034156143665314,
0.1702863872051239,
-0.676883339881897,
-0.5114776492118835,
0.9904547333717346,
0.6788768768310547,
-0.5418470501899719,
0.030103955417871475,
-0.1752312034368515,
0.25726690888404846,
-0.7468945980072021,
0.10745231807231903,
0.3544391393661499,
0.15677675604820251,
0.1722922921180725,
-0.5739569664001465,
-0.3115313649177551,
-0.28190407156944275,
-0.032753072679042816,
-0.21812283992767334,
-0.693341076374054,
0.7352723479270935,
-0.32832473516464233,
0.22980348765850067,
0.24671073257923126,
0.7200993895530701,
0.7074134945869446,
0.2600446343421936,
0.5918291211128235,
0.2706242799758911,
1.0135976076126099,
0.1801568865776062,
1.1703834533691406,
-0.19290779531002045,
-0.008529768325388432,
1.3349989652633667,
-0.478147953748703,
1.0038180351257324,
0.38338983058929443,
0.05214567482471466,
0.806674063205719,
0.8971846699714661,
-0.038836464285850525,
0.5298997759819031,
-0.1421290934085846,
-0.7189514636993408,
-0.3249574899673462,
0.1088745966553688,
0.2504904866218567,
0.5447243452072144,
0.5721422433853149,
-0.18229003250598907,
0.028244495391845703,
0.3348678648471832,
-0.16833427548408508,
0.039007917046546936,
-0.2950741648674011,
0.594588577747345,
0.05812132731080055,
-0.7223732471466064,
-0.3066384196281433,
-0.1795470267534256,
0.6938327550888062,
-0.5424878597259521,
0.10892648994922638,
-0.46360543370246887,
0.18930548429489136,
-0.015313966199755669,
-0.7123925089836121,
-0.1542768031358719,
-0.15889717638492584,
-0.29428717494010925,
-0.24984265863895416,
0.7818755507469177,
-0.5195288062095642,
-0.45598167181015015,
0.29000672698020935,
0.563002347946167,
0.2902298867702484,
-0.24001069366931915,
-0.7687636613845825,
-0.27749985456466675,
-0.21311746537685394,
-0.3002301752567291,
0.6701862812042236,
0.3848910927772522,
0.059706978499889374,
0.8602030277252197,
0.4499199390411377,
-0.07211489975452423,
-0.2827620804309845,
0.38211697340011597,
0.5946481227874756,
-0.5161874294281006,
-0.6594727039337158,
-0.7336534857749939,
0.5800429582595825,
-0.17192181944847107,
-0.4126341640949249,
0.9739751219749451,
0.7666947841644287,
0.9243202209472656,
-0.3624882102012634,
0.7773973941802979,
-0.17325708270072937,
0.40835464000701904,
-0.44605717062950134,
0.43313711881637573,
-0.30625811219215393,
0.35843926668167114,
-0.4642990529537201,
-1.0877134799957275,
-0.16920988261699677,
0.9211581945419312,
-0.49569159746170044,
0.3439502716064453,
0.7260202169418335,
0.7731108069419861,
-0.34573838114738464,
-0.07940134406089783,
0.5461507439613342,
0.013340060599148273,
0.3388969302177429,
0.8152727484703064,
0.9473612904548645,
0.07195327430963516,
0.1922621876001358,
-0.2387235015630722,
-0.4923107922077179,
-0.28457823395729065,
-0.9881294369697571,
-1.1722607612609863,
-0.7277337908744812,
-0.5055099725723267,
-0.1994963437318802,
-0.1360274851322174,
1.1091585159301758,
0.9210177659988403,
-0.6745270490646362,
-0.47763004899024963,
-0.07661828398704529,
0.05885951593518257,
-0.17929913103580475,
-0.23913533985614777,
-0.013310804031789303,
-0.3966098427772522,
-1.0499181747436523,
0.5674331784248352,
0.36112597584724426,
0.08604636788368225,
-0.26464706659317017,
-0.18294081091880798,
-0.23203912377357483,
-0.13369274139404297,
0.9178817868232727,
0.3861837089061737,
-0.49791526794433594,
-0.2650763988494873,
-0.12117953598499298,
-0.1862022578716278,
-0.030918991193175316,
0.9628142714500427,
-0.8850106596946716,
-0.03372765704989433,
0.3556484282016754,
0.45498737692832947,
0.6039450764656067,
-0.19886335730552673,
0.5054081678390503,
-0.8546218276023865,
0.32958167791366577,
0.4131781756877899,
0.42474663257598877,
0.3767012655735016,
-0.46046897768974304,
0.28694483637809753,
0.0707034021615982,
-0.6923113465309143,
-0.40870389342308044,
0.6238319277763367,
-1.2310887575149536,
-0.7146478891372681,
1.2755062580108643,
-0.11705436557531357,
-0.22810468077659607,
0.00020607560873031616,
-0.2999630868434906,
-0.21508625149726868,
-0.31903839111328125,
0.7369025349617004,
0.4277719557285309,
-0.4263646602630615,
-0.4568432867527008,
-0.4598161280155182,
0.43354296684265137,
0.26631468534469604,
-0.9044151306152344,
-0.05930682644248009,
0.8519541025161743,
0.3411162495613098,
-0.2781194746494293,
0.594469428062439,
0.09297613799571991,
0.2451665997505188,
-0.32118263840675354,
0.005709882825613022,
0.43502384424209595,
-0.3569274842739105,
-0.21227455139160156,
0.1650737226009369,
0.3208053708076477,
0.3677339553833008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02472v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02472v1
|
Semantic Scaling: Bayesian Ideal Point Estimates with Large Language Models
| 2024-05-03T20:20:15 | 2024-05-03T20:20:15 |
Michael Burnham
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces "Semantic Scaling," a novel method for ideal point
estimation from text. I leverage large language models to classify documents
based on their expressed stances and extract survey-like data. I then use item
response theory to scale subjects from these data. Semantic Scaling
significantly improves on existing text-based scaling methods, and allows
researchers to explicitly define the ideological dimensions they measure. This
represents the first scaling approach that allows such flexibility outside of
survey instruments and opens new avenues of inquiry for populations difficult
to survey. Additionally, it works with documents of varying length, and
produces valid estimates of both mass and elite ideology. I demonstrate that
the method can differentiate between policy preferences and in-group/out-group
affect. Among the public, Semantic Scaling out-preforms Tweetscores according
to human judgement; in Congress, it recaptures the first dimension DW-NOMINATE
while allowing for greater flexibility in resolving construct validity
challenges.
|
[
-0.5426979660987854,
-0.9092620015144348,
0.7387548089027405,
0.09809008985757828,
-0.0020566110033541918,
-0.3381897509098053,
-0.4036620259284973,
-0.30025893449783325,
0.41305023431777954,
0.5916677713394165,
-0.5095391273498535,
-0.6673077940940857,
-1.0351324081420898,
-0.2229948192834854,
-0.3945266902446747,
0.8611452579498291,
0.3402833342552185,
0.01260059792548418,
-0.00356999016366899,
-0.28598111867904663,
0.1315944641828537,
-0.30536195635795593,
-0.4541885554790497,
-0.2283046990633011,
0.8091970682144165,
0.5678330659866333,
1.1411608457565308,
0.8718414902687073,
0.7994282841682434,
0.26928284764289856,
0.06464160978794098,
-0.2992208003997803,
-0.4705216884613037,
0.04041615128517151,
-0.40134385228157043,
-0.4456506073474884,
-0.7100375294685364,
0.2446819692850113,
1.0317387580871582,
1.0820661783218384,
0.03550030291080475,
0.3321917951107025,
-0.09207213670015335,
0.7740175724029541,
-0.7213546633720398,
0.23000295460224152,
-0.9397541284561157,
-0.26138511300086975,
0.046980876475572586,
0.021494196727871895,
-0.37169942259788513,
-0.4034903943538666,
0.25196602940559387,
-0.8120309114456177,
0.09071792662143707,
0.06081810221076012,
0.7637046575546265,
0.06211753934621811,
-0.8824442625045776,
-0.1969992071390152,
-0.6391792893409729,
1.0707406997680664,
-0.6994228363037109,
0.22299885749816895,
0.5788004994392395,
0.10883292555809021,
-0.08780487626791,
-0.665299654006958,
-0.5395875573158264,
-0.23486372828483582,
0.020511051639914513,
-0.12070322781801224,
-0.1801350861787796,
0.23786099255084991,
0.28823187947273254,
0.23556332290172577,
-0.24057359993457794,
0.13617798686027527,
-0.056486692279577255,
0.03662992641329765,
0.7556324601173401,
0.22082610428333282,
0.2521200180053711,
-0.3617621660232544,
-0.2450236678123474,
-0.3682694137096405,
-0.4944884181022644,
-0.04509054869413376,
0.27266958355903625,
0.5492958426475525,
0.24035269021987915,
0.8750132918357849,
-0.44510552287101746,
0.8772565722465515,
-0.06040570139884949,
-0.047160711139440536,
-0.035887304693460464,
-0.25472643971443176,
0.10986269265413284,
0.039757512509822845,
0.6439076662063599,
0.8140813708305359,
0.05845090001821518,
0.24909253418445587,
0.09620984643697739,
0.10801410675048828,
0.3161843419075012,
-0.9718413352966309,
-0.10122517496347427,
0.022198623046278954,
-0.7213443517684937,
-0.09876582026481628,
0.04828174412250519,
-0.8239187002182007,
-0.6139180064201355,
-0.4812852740287781,
0.5402939319610596,
-0.3505568504333496,
-0.6027570366859436,
0.143487811088562,
-0.3197658658027649,
0.4318280816078186,
0.469763845205307,
-1.0347084999084473,
0.4660149812698364,
1.0836056470870972,
0.8726063370704651,
0.0035861104261130095,
-0.05129040405154228,
-0.12453418970108032,
0.07793788611888885,
-0.548761785030365,
0.9895226359367371,
-0.7930529713630676,
-0.4195820987224579,
0.034120891243219376,
-0.28615689277648926,
0.1989230513572693,
-0.35508081316947937,
0.5066535472869873,
-0.1704331934452057,
0.0684599056839943,
-0.46204107999801636,
-0.8471832275390625,
0.07537364959716797,
0.5595836639404297,
-0.5808942317962646,
0.8496102094650269,
0.28037160634994507,
-0.8169957399368286,
0.8650010228157043,
-0.6761797070503235,
-0.02673058956861496,
-0.23274600505828857,
-0.014755075797438622,
-0.06527156382799149,
0.2969786822795868,
-0.03833320736885071,
0.4658231735229492,
-0.3277612328529358,
-0.12187070399522781,
-0.7268611788749695,
0.19090647995471954,
0.17648662626743317,
-0.2233445793390274,
0.5824285745620728,
0.18550559878349304,
0.060964178293943405,
0.33024656772613525,
-1.0579854249954224,
0.4803093671798706,
-0.03990738093852997,
-0.09043697267770767,
-0.9410518407821655,
0.46872013807296753,
0.08632047474384308,
0.012629332020878792,
0.5715225338935852,
-0.9622306227684021,
0.22999176383018494,
-0.5256063342094421,
0.22758154571056366,
0.5979549884796143,
0.015522792935371399,
0.7034021019935608,
-0.11374371498823166,
0.04534786567091942,
-0.5395787954330444,
0.05160580947995186,
0.38214489817619324,
-0.38338664174079895,
-0.46233195066452026,
-0.3546462953090668,
0.09668057411909103,
0.28626909852027893,
-0.21922597289085388,
0.7205356359481812,
-0.5922311544418335,
-0.784210741519928,
-0.2949391007423401,
-0.30190423130989075,
0.036314960569143295,
0.2961425483226776,
0.3118496835231781,
-0.17074556648731232,
-0.05125107243657112,
-0.9197725057601929,
-0.515501856803894,
-0.8594210743904114,
-0.6637307405471802,
-0.012775998562574387,
0.4055882692337036,
0.1246463879942894,
1.115210771560669,
-0.7576652765274048,
-0.16769155859947205,
-0.03860187530517578,
0.5982745885848999,
-0.09230528771877289,
0.3167748749256134,
0.1743653565645218,
-0.8617449998855591,
-0.2461722195148468,
0.04848930612206459,
-0.33444520831108093,
-0.17304137349128723,
0.24216166138648987,
-0.226774200797081,
-0.02560710348188877,
0.28413528203964233,
-0.309914767742157,
0.1874367743730545,
0.4601278007030487,
-0.7771607041358948,
0.25162234902381897,
-0.28580352663993835,
0.23635414242744446,
-1.3489971160888672,
-0.17170540988445282,
0.3578794002532959,
0.12970879673957825,
-0.6633599400520325,
-0.02993885800242424,
0.2320234775543213,
0.24646615982055664,
-0.14757129549980164,
0.5333282351493835,
-0.021743616089224815,
-0.1530245989561081,
-0.28021401166915894,
0.27636390924453735,
-0.04058226943016052,
0.01024404726922512,
0.25648775696754456,
0.0009269436704926193,
-0.006136481184512377,
-0.12258348613977432,
0.1966453343629837,
0.10067296773195267,
-0.2541259229183197,
1.1648863554000854,
-0.598292350769043,
-0.2588685154914856,
-0.10143119841814041,
0.2703644931316376,
-1.1715781688690186,
-0.21839365363121033,
-0.175500750541687,
-0.5670025944709778,
0.08139669895172119,
-0.09322306513786316,
-0.38012146949768066,
-0.047704484313726425,
-0.46888139843940735,
0.2430434674024582,
0.2235049307346344,
-0.022532666102051735,
0.3646390438079834,
0.7077648639678955,
-0.09340014308691025,
-0.1555970013141632,
-0.2978966534137726,
0.03621918335556984,
-0.4644864797592163,
-0.6153160333633423,
0.2502133846282959,
0.17552630603313446,
-0.7536208033561707,
0.25104188919067383,
-0.21143336594104767,
-0.3087964653968811,
-0.13495108485221863,
0.11986157298088074,
0.2343299239873886,
-0.3732457160949707,
0.2896432876586914,
0.03439227119088173,
-0.16871675848960876,
0.30133068561553955,
-0.4407568573951721,
0.2635875344276428,
-0.3604108989238739,
-0.15681862831115723,
-0.24422654509544373,
0.6632786989212036,
0.6010585427284241,
-0.15383020043373108,
0.6878424286842346,
0.4049873650074005,
-0.448445200920105,
0.05992709845304489,
-0.43257230520248413,
-0.1992662101984024,
-0.3598571717739105,
0.6635786294937134,
-0.28990766406059265,
-0.8694573044776917,
0.3298264443874359,
-0.2557624876499176,
0.36051055788993835,
0.9694527387619019,
0.6421092748641968,
0.13281895220279694,
1.279100775718689,
0.8777167201042175,
0.09730436652898788,
0.4729693531990051,
-0.1566915661096573,
0.3580121695995331,
-0.7347732186317444,
-0.019396204501390457,
-1.1140061616897583,
-0.34426116943359375,
-0.9036989212036133,
-0.40822821855545044,
0.5612693428993225,
-0.1261327713727951,
-0.47011566162109375,
0.21973207592964172,
-0.4828287363052368,
0.31060150265693665,
0.35093367099761963,
-0.029586046934127808,
0.35202261805534363,
-0.01977398246526718,
0.38153553009033203,
-0.23315969109535217,
-0.295077919960022,
-0.6217774748802185,
1.1032358407974243,
0.36729660630226135,
0.8649877309799194,
0.044735804200172424,
0.562283456325531,
0.2012300044298172,
0.47138312458992004,
-1.2812410593032837,
0.5788379907608032,
-0.2023949772119522,
-0.6224775910377502,
-1.0981965065002441,
-0.6101801991462708,
-0.8392303586006165,
0.5254271030426025,
-0.28786203265190125,
-0.9358503222465515,
0.1716969609260559,
-0.12087536603212357,
-0.1412106305360794,
0.36324480175971985,
-0.642145037651062,
0.7993096709251404,
0.14888130128383636,
-0.018053308129310608,
-0.5308955907821655,
-0.723987340927124,
-0.08482519537210464,
0.04809139296412468,
0.2154066264629364,
-0.7551687359809875,
-0.6251463294029236,
1.0267375707626343,
-0.5391477942466736,
0.6239525675773621,
-0.26731544733047485,
-0.288707435131073,
0.03388003259897232,
0.15804877877235413,
0.2776370942592621,
0.005424834787845612,
-0.24179944396018982,
0.19944848120212555,
0.5488393902778625,
-0.7646442651748657,
-0.9968497157096863,
0.7098153829574585,
-0.9896115064620972,
-0.519386887550354,
-0.27187851071357727,
-0.8776152729988098,
-0.5396115779876709,
0.3028901517391205,
0.17207589745521545,
0.3748815059661865,
-0.4617091715335846,
0.47539860010147095,
0.5433686971664429,
0.27798184752464294,
0.1276654601097107,
0.6317288279533386,
-0.03385620191693306,
-0.3011714518070221,
0.8279184103012085,
0.5600779056549072,
0.5794973373413086,
0.7584239840507507,
0.5354081988334656,
-0.4385111331939697,
-0.40043574571609497,
-0.2461620420217514,
0.08239883184432983,
-0.45343926548957825,
0.11406872421503067,
-0.6721080541610718,
-0.020356863737106323,
-0.3830040693283081,
-0.32540127635002136,
-0.6799576878547668,
-0.8621034622192383,
0.22844679653644562,
-0.11153817921876907,
0.28502291440963745,
0.8261809349060059,
-0.062068428844213486,
0.2528297007083893,
-0.39055362343788147,
0.11304613947868347,
0.17089103162288666,
0.2762669026851654,
-0.3023952841758728,
-0.41052868962287903,
-0.05654667690396309,
0.059354010969400406,
-0.1109699085354805,
-0.7865750789642334,
0.23053501546382904,
0.23197951912879944,
0.3513806462287903,
0.553356945514679,
0.4845602214336395,
0.32234159111976624,
-0.37218064069747925,
0.903981626033783,
0.30868521332740784,
-0.7411051988601685,
0.5895139575004578,
-0.569572925567627,
0.38463011384010315,
0.5822998285293579,
0.7062569856643677,
-0.6499104499816895,
-0.6169620156288147,
-0.5221520662307739,
-1.0216715335845947,
0.25559917092323303,
0.012903619557619095,
0.3829118013381958,
-0.18003620207309723,
0.24471281468868256,
-0.05124242603778839,
-0.09590338915586472,
-0.2614648640155792,
0.05877448245882988,
-0.18135684728622437,
-0.4599356949329376,
-0.29119551181793213,
-0.3791697919368744,
-0.1715800166130066,
-0.3372276723384857,
0.4210096299648285,
-0.33488601446151733,
0.0976673886179924,
0.16086602210998535,
0.1948329508304596,
0.01717783883213997,
0.46190130710601807,
0.38684168457984924,
0.9983837604522705,
-0.332881897687912,
0.41859886050224304,
0.044141676276922226,
-0.4162101447582245,
0.26096969842910767,
0.0015745103592053056,
0.06039347127079964,
-0.24893179535865784,
0.36293256282806396,
0.2952083945274353,
0.1626856029033661,
-0.363948792219162,
0.4336914122104645,
-0.11469260603189468,
-0.3276433050632477,
-0.20339350402355194,
-0.17252497375011444,
-0.06360715627670288,
0.06899942457675934,
0.218864306807518,
-0.2705811858177185,
0.18084415793418884,
-0.615836501121521,
0.2036716192960739,
0.5217183828353882,
-0.7856591939926147,
-0.15911263227462769,
0.32914960384368896,
0.055790871381759644,
-0.14156541228294373,
0.44981077313423157,
0.1443052887916565,
-0.030800897628068924,
0.5572205781936646,
0.5227845311164856,
0.760254979133606,
-0.18420669436454773,
0.44144338369369507,
0.5668510794639587,
0.36883416771888733,
-0.04168492183089256,
-0.12640805542469025,
-0.11012010276317596,
-0.8807369470596313,
-0.13577786087989807,
-0.8369024991989136,
-0.49830862879753113,
-0.3353769779205322,
-0.9004005789756775,
0.06462811678647995,
-0.5517934560775757,
-0.359946608543396,
0.27972838282585144,
0.4439506232738495,
-0.1332775354385376,
0.08997529745101929,
-0.0905177965760231,
0.8707848191261292,
-0.8897227048873901,
0.7021453380584717,
0.7422160506248474,
-0.046108439564704895,
-0.674912691116333,
0.23596052825450897,
0.3989638090133667,
-0.6744462847709656,
0.267041951417923,
-0.11639370024204254,
-0.15129147469997406,
0.019583407789468765,
-0.2346481829881668,
-1.0806666612625122,
0.6912164688110352,
0.20150691270828247,
0.005873317830264568,
-0.25697633624076843,
0.2986855208873749,
0.524732232093811,
-0.3894408941268921,
0.2512933909893036,
0.8038839101791382,
0.5867226719856262,
0.12362147122621536,
-0.747952401638031,
0.03436882048845291,
-0.0942981094121933,
0.1708156168460846,
0.6802883148193359,
-0.4330276548862457,
0.700998842716217,
0.051824603229761124,
0.18521763384342194,
0.017274988815188408,
0.8285952806472778,
-0.26571398973464966,
0.19125746190547943,
0.7791491746902466,
0.560585618019104,
0.7754265069961548,
-0.048841316252946854,
0.9147182703018188,
-0.32673630118370056,
0.43072062730789185,
0.9833966493606567,
-0.18564635515213013,
1.0931743383407593,
0.5429099202156067,
-0.20120307803153992,
0.4963902533054352,
0.6356186270713806,
0.31590673327445984,
0.1865004152059555,
0.3595173954963684,
-0.425879567861557,
-0.16682028770446777,
-0.4589959979057312,
-0.23759084939956665,
0.48832255601882935,
0.7382961511611938,
-0.17999273538589478,
-0.5445029735565186,
-0.0029427462723106146,
0.37764036655426025,
0.35618072748184204,
-0.5562442541122437,
1.035267949104309,
-0.05576137825846672,
-0.49058809876441956,
0.23333629965782166,
0.1434067189693451,
0.36486151814460754,
-0.844632089138031,
0.09334956854581833,
0.10839574784040451,
0.16281631588935852,
-0.03769262135028839,
-1.0223948955535889,
0.5956414341926575,
-0.0016320872819051147,
-0.35717421770095825,
-0.2878526449203491,
0.7048959136009216,
-0.3276660144329071,
-0.8023689985275269,
0.235649973154068,
0.2875309884548187,
0.11641697585582733,
-0.3299505412578583,
-0.34069544076919556,
-0.08589275181293488,
-0.42318597435951233,
-0.5853599905967712,
0.503362238407135,
0.6449025869369507,
-0.2794971168041229,
0.3483387529850006,
0.3261187970638275,
0.18886253237724304,
0.01245162170380354,
-0.1936539113521576,
0.5548118352890015,
-0.5299080610275269,
-0.2776767909526825,
-0.7516964673995972,
0.14754590392112732,
-0.434879332780838,
-0.4502967596054077,
0.7688806653022766,
0.43840235471725464,
0.902436375617981,
0.4035351872444153,
0.5033119320869446,
-0.48040398955345154,
0.4671386778354645,
-0.2551835775375366,
0.7004935145378113,
-0.5941072106361389,
-0.31101444363594055,
-0.3084520101547241,
-0.860770046710968,
-0.5428408980369568,
0.5989843010902405,
-0.7813246250152588,
-0.2205733358860016,
0.6025298237800598,
0.9116834402084351,
0.16362033784389496,
-0.08468072861433029,
0.559280276298523,
0.17871247231960297,
0.40470394492149353,
0.27436232566833496,
0.5865744948387146,
0.09429412335157394,
0.33302363753318787,
-0.17978231608867645,
-0.7448588609695435,
0.05536947026848793,
-0.6627992391586304,
-0.5514741539955139,
-0.9661361575126648,
-0.3222120702266693,
-0.35779398679733276,
-0.26556527614593506,
1.1019095182418823,
0.7674775123596191,
-0.27508896589279175,
-0.4039996266365051,
0.23229727149009705,
0.269619345664978,
-0.18137529492378235,
-0.2554590106010437,
0.4412561058998108,
-0.42468371987342834,
-0.7852675914764404,
-0.17302249372005463,
0.3376561105251312,
-0.4841127395629883,
-0.40054792165756226,
0.23557034134864807,
-0.08407526463270187,
0.5049101710319519,
0.943538248538971,
0.15832023322582245,
-0.7921280264854431,
-0.8596200942993164,
-0.3236989378929138,
-0.20962777733802795,
-0.07711312174797058,
0.9369498491287231,
-0.2503167390823364,
0.4892469346523285,
0.7640516757965088,
0.40662288665771484,
0.13384369015693665,
-0.012600531801581383,
0.4127076268196106,
-0.3219228684902191,
0.12461353838443756,
0.23156124353408813,
0.058013755828142166,
0.011888683773577213,
-0.16539201140403748,
0.3141765296459198,
0.05394282191991806,
-0.5092899203300476,
-0.46257707476615906,
0.4638117551803589,
-1.1010105609893799,
-0.2861514389514923,
1.156996726989746,
-0.12269838154315948,
-0.45865964889526367,
0.14864258468151093,
-0.22970588505268097,
-0.08166743069887161,
-0.2884857952594757,
0.7872171401977539,
0.7719895243644714,
-0.17503389716148376,
0.13432259857654572,
-0.5852959752082825,
0.19404016435146332,
0.2701711654663086,
-0.7545291185379028,
0.228378027677536,
0.6329783201217651,
0.1829310655593872,
0.24564127624034882,
0.727924108505249,
-0.3348805010318756,
-0.14795316755771637,
0.2454524040222168,
-0.11446932703256607,
0.5617011189460754,
-0.23863552510738373,
-0.07712918519973755,
0.4667242467403412,
0.313976526260376,
0.04645192250609398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02454v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02454v1
|
What is Sentiment Meant to Mean to Language Models?
| 2024-05-03T19:37:37 | 2024-05-03T19:37:37 |
Michael Burnham
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Sentiment analysis is one of the most widely used techniques in text
analysis. Recent advancements with Large Language Models have made it more
accurate and accessible than ever, allowing researchers to classify text with
only a plain English prompt. However, "sentiment" entails a wide variety of
concepts depending on the domain and tools used. It has been used to mean
emotion, opinions, market movements, or simply a general ``good-bad''
dimension. This raises a question: What exactly are language models doing when
prompted to label documents by sentiment? This paper first overviews how
sentiment is defined across different contexts, highlighting that it is a
confounded measurement construct in that it entails multiple variables, such as
emotional valence and opinion, without disentangling them. I then test three
language models across two data sets with prompts requesting sentiment,
valence, and stance classification. I find that sentiment labels most strongly
correlate with valence labels. I further find that classification improves when
researchers more precisely specify their dimension of interest rather than
using the less well-defined concept of sentiment. I conclude by encouraging
researchers to move beyond "sentiment" when feasible and use a more precise
measurement construct.
|
[
-0.5358185768127441,
-0.7833410501480103,
0.5096079707145691,
0.35869380831718445,
-0.36889246106147766,
0.002653492381796241,
-0.09837156534194946,
-0.42140015959739685,
0.2254413217306137,
0.1274467408657074,
-0.3188493847846985,
-0.5528254508972168,
-0.7798908948898315,
-0.01917228475213051,
-0.3946034610271454,
1.5624289512634277,
0.09726562350988388,
0.3972908556461334,
-0.4801393747329712,
-0.47328147292137146,
-0.12872231006622314,
-1.028801679611206,
-0.44618281722068787,
-0.41868844628334045,
0.9584282636642456,
0.12058704346418381,
0.9760189652442932,
0.08211055397987366,
0.7455533146858215,
0.2780039608478546,
-0.34328046441078186,
-0.38792455196380615,
-0.15811744332313538,
0.2959838807582855,
-0.10434132814407349,
-0.5764313340187073,
-0.6682440638542175,
0.6492708325386047,
0.2961837649345398,
1.1031088829040527,
0.21748541295528412,
0.018037574365735054,
0.10744907706975937,
0.80760258436203,
-0.4556873142719269,
0.11494848132133484,
-0.012492312118411064,
0.07717519998550415,
-0.1410696655511856,
0.06897655874490738,
-0.3694789707660675,
-0.5797211527824402,
0.42371830344200134,
-0.007975772954523563,
0.11661767214536667,
-0.1342260092496872,
0.8358932733535767,
-0.059024859219789505,
-0.6692709922790527,
-0.6435009241104126,
-0.5263301730155945,
1.0981473922729492,
-0.4609256386756897,
0.38078874349594116,
0.17584142088890076,
0.13601519167423248,
0.3376369774341583,
-0.24243828654289246,
-0.642514169216156,
-0.20317521691322327,
-0.05955568701028824,
0.29659101366996765,
-0.1684994399547577,
0.2307594269514084,
0.35033470392227173,
0.537341296672821,
-0.3068961501121521,
-0.18155786395072937,
-0.0812964215874672,
0.011212483048439026,
0.5850358009338379,
0.08033114671707153,
0.36178311705589294,
-0.34807446599006653,
-0.5108965039253235,
-0.17957188189029694,
-0.4840691387653351,
0.30619367957115173,
0.4039433002471924,
0.6127756834030151,
-0.27646979689598083,
0.38826942443847656,
0.15021897852420807,
0.5402680039405823,
-0.13274508714675903,
-0.0748954489827156,
0.390943706035614,
-0.03505723923444748,
-0.352722704410553,
-0.11041916161775589,
0.8094731569290161,
0.5797863602638245,
0.1914905458688736,
0.11762667447328568,
-0.5500908493995667,
0.4415229856967926,
0.125400111079216,
-0.6479543447494507,
-0.1470428705215454,
0.45012086629867554,
-0.5732473731040955,
-0.5548146367073059,
0.1281619518995285,
-0.8926635384559631,
-0.594112753868103,
-0.4798838198184967,
0.29668790102005005,
-0.08133342117071152,
-0.43727630376815796,
0.18636099994182587,
-0.4511813521385193,
0.2715838551521301,
0.24883095920085907,
-0.7920652031898499,
0.18594485521316528,
0.9205005764961243,
0.6669127345085144,
0.07675112783908844,
-0.13084587454795837,
-0.29238811135292053,
-0.6210454702377319,
-0.5161439180374146,
0.8154441118240356,
-0.6974512338638306,
-0.7621625065803528,
0.08680809289216995,
-0.02448849380016327,
0.09259779751300812,
-0.15581423044204712,
0.6182505488395691,
-0.4228142201900482,
0.5481306910514832,
-0.6443896293640137,
-0.7103432416915894,
-0.47509267926216125,
0.6405975222587585,
-0.5426345467567444,
0.8828208446502686,
0.12979529798030853,
-0.7312778234481812,
0.31652748584747314,
-0.40639224648475647,
-0.32202571630477905,
-0.16932237148284912,
0.14082421362400055,
-0.2618330717086792,
0.6047743558883667,
-0.5366582274436951,
0.611379861831665,
-0.4622499346733093,
0.14699363708496094,
-0.5236281752586365,
0.017504354938864708,
0.860133707523346,
-0.20810751616954803,
0.51643967628479,
0.22003944218158722,
0.12033829092979431,
-0.10369528830051422,
-0.5255746245384216,
-0.11238804459571838,
-0.2740347385406494,
-0.2956775724887848,
-0.9193547964096069,
0.17520871758460999,
0.09396039694547653,
0.19558633863925934,
0.3332583010196686,
-0.6609019041061401,
0.18972039222717285,
-0.7037087678909302,
0.14801527559757233,
0.5069981217384338,
0.0002927827590610832,
0.7448758482933044,
0.06509009748697281,
0.6805327534675598,
0.13913503289222717,
0.2775103747844696,
-0.03115605004131794,
-0.454525887966156,
-0.715045690536499,
-0.018032986670732498,
0.27643707394599915,
0.3541153371334076,
0.11329298466444016,
0.14393772184848785,
-0.01605934649705887,
-0.49809640645980835,
-0.46625155210494995,
-0.14633330702781677,
0.25822755694389343,
0.507348358631134,
0.18948683142662048,
-0.19138556718826294,
-0.3665520250797272,
-0.809066116809845,
-0.3582068383693695,
-0.4812944531440735,
0.4592800438404083,
-0.037739429622888565,
0.39859068393707275,
-0.2509852945804596,
0.6458277106285095,
-0.4920532703399658,
0.06957419961690903,
-0.20940397679805756,
0.6307319402694702,
0.26568010449409485,
0.03561002388596535,
0.5687586665153503,
-0.8446459174156189,
-0.4387778043746948,
0.0746811181306839,
-0.7746884226799011,
-0.03623079136013985,
0.0137693602591753,
-0.06859152764081955,
0.38425537943840027,
0.33716872334480286,
-0.5880661606788635,
0.04291455075144768,
0.680184543132782,
-0.3064632713794708,
0.4946221113204956,
0.22523623704910278,
0.07682141661643982,
-0.9403287172317505,
-0.21114544570446014,
0.3832642436027527,
0.02332751639187336,
-0.8105484843254089,
0.2313733547925949,
-0.09177398681640625,
-0.03475744649767876,
-0.5843881964683533,
0.6579165458679199,
-0.14142721891403198,
0.24690064787864685,
-0.4708300232887268,
0.031365253031253815,
0.48395010828971863,
-0.03284057602286339,
-0.12660956382751465,
0.3939993977546692,
0.8108959794044495,
-0.6018018126487732,
0.5499739050865173,
0.20503021776676178,
0.10431874543428421,
0.9624963402748108,
-0.2736639082431793,
0.1263003796339035,
-0.39625272154808044,
-0.10870132595300674,
-1.0423835515975952,
-0.07588668912649155,
0.2101469784975052,
-0.719892144203186,
0.19165544211864471,
-0.09693700075149536,
-0.2751513719558716,
-0.12333328276872635,
-0.3823261857032776,
0.1855556219816208,
0.21498912572860718,
-0.34006887674331665,
0.7289206981658936,
0.5946622490882874,
-0.1419164389371872,
-0.5056384801864624,
-0.7837210297584534,
-0.039029560983181,
-0.518650233745575,
-0.3767513930797577,
-0.0865916982293129,
-0.05149771645665169,
-0.8724333047866821,
-0.06877950578927994,
0.016584135591983795,
-0.20638857781887054,
0.18882611393928528,
0.3450314998626709,
0.3801132142543793,
-0.18689049780368805,
0.7671706080436707,
-0.06409856677055359,
-0.16288478672504425,
0.34812912344932556,
0.08872257173061371,
0.3041314482688904,
-0.2847091853618622,
0.044002849608659744,
-0.00042123644379898906,
0.7057415843009949,
0.8277217745780945,
-0.13569407165050507,
0.789173424243927,
0.4339809715747833,
-0.2949793040752411,
-0.23735128343105316,
-0.19349631667137146,
0.06051483005285263,
-0.3610951602458954,
0.09515693783760071,
-0.35701099038124084,
-0.733299970626831,
0.4424675703048706,
0.012497447431087494,
-0.2435792237520218,
0.4019813537597656,
0.5133206844329834,
-0.6244815587997437,
1.306577205657959,
0.7233911752700806,
-0.45228147506713867,
0.20679971575737,
-0.04242200404405594,
0.7350536584854126,
-0.6077239513397217,
-0.112254798412323,
-0.9279042482376099,
-0.17410747706890106,
-0.713637113571167,
-0.26300638914108276,
0.15146952867507935,
0.15819557011127472,
0.005040606018155813,
-0.09938526153564453,
-0.38704752922058105,
0.30468595027923584,
0.17944106459617615,
-0.29042986035346985,
-0.03151103854179382,
-0.25503578782081604,
0.09307613968849182,
-0.2890286147594452,
-0.10931622236967087,
-0.8633949756622314,
0.641386091709137,
0.4221727252006531,
0.7446873784065247,
-0.04573049023747444,
0.6497951745986938,
0.3759271204471588,
0.46273887157440186,
-1.4186681509017944,
0.6668071150779724,
-0.4139719605445862,
-0.5819823145866394,
0.04479355365037918,
-0.07171037793159485,
-0.6355329751968384,
0.2736605107784271,
-0.27272582054138184,
-0.3633245527744293,
0.2632652819156647,
0.21097484230995178,
-0.1139003187417984,
0.07413198053836823,
-0.6842231750488281,
0.858372151851654,
-0.36821725964546204,
-0.05270647630095482,
-0.22824984788894653,
-0.3167387545108795,
0.22466018795967102,
0.050150007009506226,
0.40581363439559937,
-0.35424157977104187,
0.1485501527786255,
0.5985813736915588,
-0.3162158727645874,
0.8893341422080994,
-0.3948448896408081,
-0.3205074667930603,
0.4142451882362366,
0.18205246329307556,
0.20083847641944885,
-0.39170393347740173,
-0.3056071102619171,
-0.008038969710469246,
0.2344384789466858,
-0.1050867959856987,
-0.7497275471687317,
0.5318644046783447,
-0.7571717500686646,
-0.28775885701179504,
-0.6287054419517517,
-0.3276735544204712,
-0.3234309256076813,
-0.25225359201431274,
0.14809663593769073,
0.5541948676109314,
-0.5188741087913513,
0.1574227660894394,
0.6068020462989807,
-0.38667920231819153,
0.06472057104110718,
0.3512188196182251,
-0.4044629633426666,
0.06103304773569107,
1.1963790655136108,
0.04143793508410454,
0.18606626987457275,
0.7099192142486572,
0.5550372004508972,
-0.5449461340904236,
-0.02218790352344513,
0.14293983578681946,
0.1711633801460266,
-1.0908247232437134,
-0.05867186561226845,
-0.6322973370552063,
0.12794248759746552,
-0.27824071049690247,
-0.1669708490371704,
-0.2123882919549942,
-0.4022315442562103,
-0.3171538710594177,
-0.4533805251121521,
0.3263607621192932,
0.623792827129364,
0.03419706970453262,
0.4113704562187195,
-0.9102964997291565,
0.008313428610563278,
0.2644340991973877,
0.22809690237045288,
-0.17063964903354645,
-0.2553448975086212,
-0.2787889540195465,
-0.11376168578863144,
-0.15782605111598969,
-1.2282830476760864,
0.592043936252594,
0.06584060937166214,
0.34288495779037476,
0.32350292801856995,
-0.09845758974552155,
0.16080012917518616,
-0.013917104341089725,
0.9083671569824219,
0.3588975965976715,
-1.149526834487915,
0.548500657081604,
-0.467170774936676,
0.10342825204133987,
0.3494512438774109,
0.5039035081863403,
-0.946561872959137,
-0.552510678768158,
-0.36525002121925354,
-0.7018288969993591,
0.1605851650238037,
-0.5586928129196167,
0.7170790433883667,
-0.41266411542892456,
0.19064833223819733,
0.3337121605873108,
0.33617642521858215,
-0.7586398124694824,
-0.10361870378255844,
-0.3611081838607788,
-0.5222340822219849,
-0.20473194122314453,
-0.49669626355171204,
-0.1814744472503662,
-0.08633224666118622,
0.41465914249420166,
-0.1027006283402443,
0.30248838663101196,
-0.18589335680007935,
-0.1966938078403473,
-0.09940199553966522,
0.5930449962615967,
0.03554781526327133,
0.29108917713165283,
-0.07684686779975891,
0.29929888248443604,
-0.17622146010398865,
-0.09989500790834427,
0.13607226312160492,
-0.29503393173217773,
-0.16714587807655334,
0.043969448655843735,
0.0981508195400238,
0.8624187707901001,
0.05190300941467285,
-0.1494971215724945,
0.5907763242721558,
0.0598476268351078,
-0.08420869708061218,
-0.043272871524095535,
-0.07380163669586182,
0.06263154000043869,
0.07891062647104263,
0.03640123829245567,
0.0716143324971199,
0.34526950120925903,
-0.8682680726051331,
-0.23040573298931122,
0.5573897361755371,
-0.7783999443054199,
-0.6825446486473083,
0.18707697093486786,
0.32108283042907715,
-0.006689635571092367,
0.3865719735622406,
-0.13874606788158417,
-0.7092321515083313,
0.48808199167251587,
0.13707518577575684,
0.9691027998924255,
-0.22231420874595642,
0.6156929135322571,
0.3733590841293335,
0.015208754688501358,
-0.18696512281894684,
0.4420967698097229,
0.27699658274650574,
-1.0682947635650635,
-0.17912624776363373,
-0.9467992186546326,
-0.6238892078399658,
-0.12170825898647308,
-0.8827601671218872,
0.18360288441181183,
-0.30501922965049744,
-0.555367112159729,
0.1427612453699112,
-0.11032724380493164,
-0.5387197136878967,
0.8352408409118652,
0.3969368636608124,
0.7948349118232727,
-1.2168465852737427,
0.48987314105033875,
1.121355652809143,
-0.5540778636932373,
-0.7722274661064148,
-0.09624318033456802,
0.4136745035648346,
-0.17963886260986328,
0.5790757536888123,
0.3090875446796417,
-0.35357341170310974,
-0.34256085753440857,
-0.8667902946472168,
-0.4119054079055786,
0.1117405816912651,
-0.17649531364440918,
-0.29475370049476624,
0.2356235831975937,
0.009778096340596676,
0.9677950143814087,
-0.402002215385437,
0.08254299312829971,
0.5090058445930481,
0.48972341418266296,
-0.2180154025554657,
-0.2934482991695404,
-0.3023315668106079,
-0.4126463234424591,
-0.22287282347679138,
0.1990831196308136,
-0.5084754228591919,
0.96449214220047,
0.11301315575838089,
-0.07707501947879791,
-0.12075309455394745,
0.5264132618904114,
-0.11796402186155319,
0.18584318459033966,
0.4918532967567444,
0.2763027548789978,
1.0176500082015991,
-0.4431939125061035,
1.2185206413269043,
-0.3662821352481842,
0.503058671951294,
0.44344496726989746,
-0.34121906757354736,
0.8473253846168518,
0.41998398303985596,
-0.20078858733177185,
0.6648705005645752,
0.6777129173278809,
0.031508345156908035,
0.48124024271965027,
0.11218154430389404,
-0.39259305596351624,
-0.38671430945396423,
-0.1873667985200882,
-0.10844985395669937,
0.3836223781108856,
0.529462456703186,
-0.250201016664505,
0.0006625723908655345,
0.21994683146476746,
0.12372004985809326,
0.17921362817287445,
-0.3420102596282959,
0.7694805860519409,
0.46262967586517334,
-0.6954227089881897,
-0.11419308185577393,
0.05437902361154556,
0.5189012885093689,
-0.47768110036849976,
0.2649689018726349,
-0.40567588806152344,
0.17526832222938538,
-0.3113149404525757,
-1.2020633220672607,
0.3901050388813019,
0.17285193502902985,
-0.5770657062530518,
-0.3941383361816406,
0.6639466285705566,
-0.21492663025856018,
-0.5592754483222961,
0.5066689848899841,
0.7749128341674805,
0.303699791431427,
0.025991231203079224,
-0.6543999314308167,
0.21657110750675201,
-0.2287675142288208,
-0.38047537207603455,
0.44286301732063293,
0.628380537033081,
0.039863500744104385,
0.4425237774848938,
0.3383716344833374,
0.23684310913085938,
-0.24083751440048218,
0.590864896774292,
0.610936164855957,
-0.9382772445678711,
-0.3589186370372772,
-0.8581095337867737,
0.7126898169517517,
0.2052077203989029,
-0.3420535624027252,
0.7462120652198792,
0.32561564445495605,
0.5038702487945557,
0.02739715576171875,
1.0120537281036377,
0.022061524912714958,
0.6630219221115112,
-0.2271948605775833,
0.43687400221824646,
-0.6439307332038879,
0.13887473940849304,
-0.5795077681541443,
-0.7588090300559998,
-0.46400776505470276,
0.7443979382514954,
-0.47421735525131226,
-0.12056707590818405,
0.612865149974823,
0.6122505068778992,
0.1893545389175415,
0.20459981262683868,
0.2358185350894928,
0.14884503185749054,
0.28811776638031006,
0.10506731271743774,
1.2789442539215088,
-0.10365679860115051,
0.10445249825716019,
-0.07810554653406143,
0.008471516892313957,
-0.018449371680617332,
-0.6218588352203369,
-0.7801794409751892,
-0.6117121577262878,
-0.5531423091888428,
-0.40470871329307556,
-0.08084513247013092,
0.7852085828781128,
0.44928863644599915,
-0.7110888361930847,
-0.35650986433029175,
0.21722514927387238,
0.12204521894454956,
0.045799370855093,
-0.23712632060050964,
0.089504174888134,
-0.673728346824646,
-0.8195842504501343,
0.05208806321024895,
0.39694780111312866,
0.10112887620925903,
-0.4628247618675232,
0.04296915605664253,
0.2166440635919571,
0.3240216076374054,
0.7281783223152161,
0.1005454733967781,
-0.4693529009819031,
-0.4268395006656647,
0.16255660355091095,
-0.4822086691856384,
0.18554195761680603,
0.6235873103141785,
-0.4058344066143036,
0.6550681591033936,
0.7126006484031677,
0.07192172110080719,
-0.05392266809940338,
0.12825018167495728,
0.6537919640541077,
-0.8472135663032532,
-0.018837448209524155,
0.19846457242965698,
0.38169264793395996,
0.6985427141189575,
-0.24308231472969055,
0.1513984501361847,
0.1941666305065155,
-0.386576384305954,
-0.8847513198852539,
0.40705838799476624,
-0.8901246190071106,
-0.32332348823547363,
0.9722281694412231,
0.08207365870475769,
-0.18334998190402985,
0.10617002844810486,
-0.09701181203126907,
0.08027372509241104,
-0.32146236300468445,
0.6472871899604797,
1.0341567993164062,
-0.025895018130540848,
-0.2929290235042572,
-0.3736349046230316,
0.382420152425766,
0.20947030186653137,
-0.6162565350532532,
0.02943209558725357,
0.544918417930603,
0.12139430642127991,
0.39393967390060425,
0.5543910264968872,
-0.23596298694610596,
-0.006231386214494705,
-0.1899808645248413,
0.20380543172359467,
0.685553789138794,
-0.2972809672355652,
-0.5637986660003662,
0.3889091908931732,
0.19640277326107025,
-0.006840804126113653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02566v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02566v1
|
Combining X-Vectors and Bayesian Batch Active Learning: Two-Stage Active Learning Pipeline for Speech Recognition
| 2024-05-03T19:24:41 | 2024-05-03T19:24:41 |
Ognjen Kundacina, Vladimir Vincan, Dragisa Miskovic
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Emphasizing a data-centric AI approach, this paper introduces a novel
two-stage active learning (AL) pipeline for automatic speech recognition (ASR),
combining unsupervised and supervised AL methods. The first stage utilizes
unsupervised AL by using x-vectors clustering for diverse sample selection from
unlabeled speech data, thus establishing a robust initial dataset for the
subsequent supervised AL. The second stage incorporates a supervised AL
strategy, with a batch AL method specifically developed for ASR, aimed at
selecting diverse and informative batches of samples. Here, sample diversity is
also achieved using x-vectors clustering, while the most informative samples
are identified using a Bayesian AL method tailored for ASR with an adaptation
of Monte Carlo dropout to approximate Bayesian inference. This approach enables
precise uncertainty estimation, thereby enhancing ASR model training with
significantly reduced data requirements. Our method has shown superior
performance compared to competing methods on homogeneous, heterogeneous, and
OOD test sets, demonstrating that strategic sample selection and innovative
Bayesian modeling can substantially optimize both labeling effort and data
utilization in deep learning-based ASR applications.
|
[
-0.017455697059631348,
-0.5357125401496887,
-0.010225900448858738,
-0.3046317994594574,
-0.20588761568069458,
0.37321269512176514,
-0.03747493028640747,
-0.20547081530094147,
-0.18255005776882172,
0.25030359625816345,
-0.36822137236595154,
-0.38769295811653137,
-0.5222125053405762,
-0.5219935178756714,
-0.7478835582733154,
0.5206377506256104,
-0.006376280914992094,
0.3979848027229309,
0.2900890111923218,
-0.21540798246860504,
-0.3107953369617462,
-0.3015006184577942,
-1.2169792652130127,
-0.18360736966133118,
0.40330055356025696,
0.4041924476623535,
0.41093459725379944,
0.873507559299469,
0.33018767833709717,
0.2900148034095764,
-0.04653562232851982,
0.006489571649581194,
0.18699777126312256,
0.513630211353302,
0.00888584740459919,
-0.5013408660888672,
-0.361361563205719,
0.05924070626497269,
0.9169443249702454,
0.8014111518859863,
-0.29019832611083984,
0.16478855907917023,
-0.10874468833208084,
0.34565022587776184,
-0.7079747915267944,
0.19115762412548065,
-0.8309652209281921,
0.27926796674728394,
-0.20419345796108246,
0.27730998396873474,
0.0040144287049770355,
0.05157331004738808,
0.10556858032941818,
-0.4836306869983673,
0.46330052614212036,
-0.043036773800849915,
0.35557398200035095,
0.5757542848587036,
-0.3767685890197754,
-0.42226287722587585,
-0.9734592437744141,
0.9193278551101685,
-0.4034528434276581,
0.6467140913009644,
0.2034343034029007,
0.5939888954162598,
0.21749714016914368,
-1.0173934698104858,
-0.6698006391525269,
0.06644626706838608,
0.5736607313156128,
0.15672893822193146,
-0.5126248598098755,
0.009613636881113052,
0.022616876289248466,
0.43560776114463806,
-0.5467749834060669,
0.3885171413421631,
-0.7169310450553894,
-0.21375802159309387,
0.7139230370521545,
-0.3949842154979706,
-0.004602051340043545,
0.2526320517063141,
-0.34614264965057373,
-0.4328741729259491,
-0.4192541241645813,
0.41890427470207214,
0.13024014234542847,
0.9020342230796814,
0.25201812386512756,
0.609096884727478,
0.07736781239509583,
0.5769182443618774,
0.07984723895788193,
-0.07605601102113724,
0.49507972598075867,
0.012695930898189545,
-0.24750395119190216,
0.616279125213623,
0.7947362065315247,
-0.2680260241031647,
-0.09063175320625305,
-0.06248588114976883,
-0.40808993577957153,
0.5735243558883667,
0.34298306703567505,
-0.3038574755191803,
-0.3310554027557373,
0.3961796462535858,
-0.22010980546474457,
-0.3108918070793152,
0.26884710788726807,
-0.3677690625190735,
-0.3530465066432953,
-0.3697720468044281,
0.733167290687561,
-0.0503002367913723,
-0.09781745821237564,
-0.07964501529932022,
-0.034534964710474014,
0.0036453327629715204,
0.26909583806991577,
-0.40682223439216614,
0.47567394375801086,
0.5195909738540649,
0.5759726166725159,
-0.4864862561225891,
0.02919442020356655,
-1.1749463081359863,
0.2601723074913025,
-0.4945210814476013,
0.603166401386261,
-0.5860881805419922,
-0.3395145833492279,
-0.17902307212352753,
-0.04950147867202759,
-0.03371843695640564,
-0.6495429277420044,
0.7682638764381409,
-0.35496968030929565,
0.06799108535051346,
0.16685661673545837,
-0.35017192363739014,
-0.5215851068496704,
-0.3464444577693939,
-0.6261467337608337,
0.9554346203804016,
-0.25371596217155457,
-0.2015419751405716,
0.7653492093086243,
-0.5169609785079956,
-0.6489753723144531,
0.058378916233778,
-0.5768517255783081,
-0.857036292552948,
-0.034502170979976654,
0.2248447686433792,
0.5898555517196655,
-0.0023385549429804087,
0.0034204733092337847,
-0.15568961203098297,
-0.09580514580011368,
0.2047002762556076,
-0.5439521074295044,
0.6134474277496338,
0.3958127498626709,
-0.6028875708580017,
0.443979412317276,
-1.2434853315353394,
0.07903746515512466,
-0.30231860280036926,
-0.46990570425987244,
-0.10907726734876633,
0.21036794781684875,
-0.012080743908882141,
0.3410479724407196,
-0.15719151496887207,
-0.713982105255127,
-0.04674818739295006,
-0.12606264650821686,
0.3740631639957428,
0.4692360460758209,
-0.1327126920223236,
0.6206551194190979,
-0.07113421708345413,
0.46995165944099426,
0.11462044715881348,
0.018162831664085388,
0.03361327201128006,
-0.584927499294281,
-0.7977839708328247,
-0.6673458814620972,
0.36281129717826843,
0.8445680737495422,
-0.4806375205516815,
0.624276876449585,
0.11801769584417343,
-0.4605240523815155,
-0.7939878106117249,
0.17977069318294525,
0.5487636923789978,
0.44439542293548584,
0.5088041424751282,
-0.3992777466773987,
-0.5505505800247192,
-0.4178985059261322,
0.00758453318849206,
-0.38759225606918335,
-0.30304476618766785,
0.2589975893497467,
-0.05739254131913185,
-0.2643282413482666,
0.7573668360710144,
-0.22834448516368866,
-0.5762305855751038,
-0.2307073175907135,
0.3632515072822571,
0.192099928855896,
0.5136053562164307,
0.0794488787651062,
-0.8217832446098328,
-0.4603528082370758,
0.16404631733894348,
-0.3713339865207672,
0.05330228805541992,
0.10375456511974335,
0.14034143090248108,
0.07113101333379745,
0.471639484167099,
-0.2209327518939972,
0.7064322233200073,
0.46513593196868896,
-0.12916377186775208,
-0.30764493346214294,
0.05537739396095276,
-0.031633276492357254,
-0.7723545432090759,
-0.05353839695453644,
0.0882098525762558,
-0.010474960319697857,
-0.7999654412269592,
-0.44451308250427246,
0.173858180642128,
-0.3466489315032959,
-0.4445599317550659,
0.41077324748039246,
-0.5436409115791321,
-0.27382639050483704,
-0.4417043924331665,
-0.22515548765659332,
-0.21559956669807434,
0.2920539081096649,
0.209476038813591,
0.4760805666446686,
1.046903133392334,
-0.6677025556564331,
0.49405190348625183,
0.28687047958374023,
-0.19580288231372833,
-0.12690602242946625,
-0.6310433149337769,
0.12367881834506989,
-0.11465150117874146,
0.18615084886550903,
-1.2312065362930298,
0.04554418846964836,
0.3213358223438263,
-0.7693958282470703,
0.672126829624176,
-0.3237839639186859,
-0.178587406873703,
-0.355937659740448,
0.11761496961116791,
0.30443158745765686,
0.7076724171638489,
-0.3950181007385254,
0.6217078566551208,
0.6272111535072327,
-0.37891045212745667,
-0.5306508541107178,
-0.8250774145126343,
-0.2753424048423767,
-0.06954001635313034,
-0.10705013573169708,
0.28445714712142944,
0.2426498681306839,
-0.21389587223529816,
-0.13545817136764526,
-0.5423259735107422,
-0.3430992662906647,
-0.1882825493812561,
0.5968565344810486,
0.10792501270771027,
0.015370490029454231,
-0.021874861791729927,
0.34636661410331726,
-0.1698414385318756,
-0.03559054806828499,
-0.3435887396335602,
0.12972398102283478,
0.3595789074897766,
-0.7154823541641235,
-0.6343158483505249,
0.4253019690513611,
0.3959181010723114,
-0.4748557507991791,
0.2925700843334198,
0.9680421948432922,
-0.568208634853363,
-0.3776720464229584,
-0.351958692073822,
-0.16773955523967743,
-0.4036162793636322,
0.24864111840724945,
-0.12247183918952942,
-0.7274904251098633,
0.2317078858613968,
0.3064391016960144,
0.4391436278820038,
0.3318944275379181,
0.5384771227836609,
-0.0041761090978980064,
1.1411244869232178,
0.2511892020702362,
-0.1256895512342453,
0.61225825548172,
-0.5049219131469727,
0.319866418838501,
-0.5029404163360596,
-0.33274325728416443,
-0.4288044571876526,
-0.38408955931663513,
-0.298161119222641,
-0.8835052847862244,
0.4194979965686798,
-0.12522196769714355,
-0.30228492617607117,
-0.11649953573942184,
-0.4496995508670807,
-0.2197570502758026,
0.9272611141204834,
0.01945994608104229,
0.08826277405023575,
0.2914885878562927,
0.11707096546888351,
0.29195114970207214,
-0.8272676467895508,
-0.34297630190849304,
1.2429771423339844,
0.3951408565044403,
0.863947868347168,
0.149992436170578,
0.2653879225254059,
0.4785415828227997,
-0.31301918625831604,
-1.1146408319473267,
0.4538470208644867,
-0.34995236992836,
-0.6879264712333679,
-0.5096772313117981,
-0.4082511365413666,
-1.1506839990615845,
0.08995667099952698,
-0.2341156303882599,
-0.31253957748413086,
0.5099591612815857,
0.2497679591178894,
-0.8479496836662292,
0.34208521246910095,
-0.5283375978469849,
0.31015944480895996,
-0.20440369844436646,
-0.26289764046669006,
-0.1112796887755394,
-0.9211079478263855,
-0.12007324397563934,
-0.2816210091114044,
0.15483365952968597,
-0.05490061640739441,
-0.17344065010547638,
1.1359871625900269,
-0.08270970731973648,
0.7312765717506409,
-0.5318781137466431,
0.1515156775712967,
0.6316648721694946,
-0.3731798231601715,
0.27865132689476013,
0.07682502269744873,
-0.1999790370464325,
0.03206203132867813,
-0.314657986164093,
-0.25774481892585754,
-0.5052544474601746,
0.4546753168106079,
-0.9216567277908325,
-0.022214045748114586,
-0.657747209072113,
-0.49785327911376953,
-0.38713207840919495,
0.04696720838546753,
0.0027145445346832275,
0.6717770099639893,
0.11859453469514847,
0.2679418921470642,
0.7943558096885681,
-0.04725592955946922,
0.5100235342979431,
0.5753474235534668,
0.12720230221748352,
-0.6478052735328674,
0.8663732409477234,
0.40138328075408936,
0.064811110496521,
0.46783003211021423,
-0.039468493312597275,
-0.3147719204425812,
-0.8183377981185913,
-0.29117703437805176,
-0.0803670883178711,
-0.3517845869064331,
-0.2238335758447647,
-0.7546841502189636,
-0.47382408380508423,
-0.6172547340393066,
0.0864483118057251,
-0.6232869625091553,
-0.7193213105201721,
-0.4543665051460266,
-0.0848294049501419,
0.18876862525939941,
0.4915221035480499,
-0.28482702374458313,
0.48819419741630554,
-0.6071538925170898,
0.6675686836242676,
0.7087510824203491,
-0.013944445177912712,
-0.10855183005332947,
-0.8294652700424194,
-0.19917719066143036,
0.18494880199432373,
-0.19044096767902374,
-0.6031737327575684,
0.44313618540763855,
0.7021994590759277,
0.9909993410110474,
0.83939129114151,
0.13931617140769958,
0.37975066900253296,
-0.5333559513092041,
0.4877609610557556,
0.1662018746137619,
-0.6523315906524658,
0.8603707551956177,
-0.12297239899635315,
0.06312588602304459,
0.4805612564086914,
0.5560067892074585,
0.06564386188983917,
-0.0588814876973629,
-0.48903605341911316,
-1.067191243171692,
0.7016729116439819,
0.20135168731212616,
-0.2892150580883026,
0.17934469878673553,
0.3111404478549957,
0.1362045854330063,
0.3695290982723236,
-0.20876839756965637,
-0.45469361543655396,
-0.14431455731391907,
-0.23445472121238708,
-0.2662702202796936,
0.04666685685515404,
-0.23550115525722504,
-0.5162681937217712,
0.966421365737915,
0.03801856189966202,
0.34021231532096863,
-0.15083253383636475,
0.024084091186523438,
-0.2920975983142853,
0.09039361774921417,
-0.004987213294953108,
0.38247039914131165,
-0.26981398463249207,
0.0034049206878989935,
-0.022957725450396538,
-0.7050942778587341,
0.3578551411628723,
0.5505616068840027,
-0.03414860740303993,
0.0856277123093605,
0.17448440194129944,
1.1844041347503662,
-0.007913037203252316,
-0.614282488822937,
0.5139327645301819,
-0.14810967445373535,
-0.2868403494358063,
-0.5181329250335693,
0.3689981698989868,
-0.4964461028575897,
0.621830940246582,
0.9495442509651184,
0.37121468782424927,
0.3895533084869385,
-0.6488838791847229,
0.4305419325828552,
0.39644891023635864,
-0.8801420331001282,
-0.20808061957359314,
0.8588996529579163,
0.13849638402462006,
-0.2696928381919861,
0.5512834191322327,
-0.20591965317726135,
-0.30804443359375,
0.2972617745399475,
0.15539096295833588,
0.8182048201560974,
-0.7838886380195618,
0.021319491788744926,
0.23231898248195648,
-0.06998349726200104,
-0.08402049541473389,
0.4951951801776886,
-0.21656054258346558,
-0.7385545372962952,
-0.33667105436325073,
-0.5460888743400574,
-0.4971684515476227,
-0.005682387854903936,
-1.136063814163208,
0.4056984484195709,
-0.4446970224380493,
-0.17206238210201263,
0.033454518765211105,
0.26348593831062317,
-0.30147144198417664,
0.6486111283302307,
0.3987201154232025,
0.5190675854682922,
-1.0107359886169434,
1.0591602325439453,
1.0162153244018555,
-0.0843646377325058,
-0.7416442632675171,
-0.06750722229480743,
0.08260977268218994,
-0.8853299021720886,
0.10795079171657562,
0.0028306369204074144,
0.05850643292069435,
0.23860526084899902,
-0.176347553730011,
-0.9700872302055359,
1.2052664756774902,
-0.10055593401193619,
-0.6789191365242004,
0.14450469613075256,
-0.2932904064655304,
0.20240412652492523,
-0.19720464944839478,
-0.24764251708984375,
0.3976224660873413,
-0.005310607608407736,
0.8357725739479065,
-0.675392210483551,
-0.37877026200294495,
-0.3946141004562378,
-0.20411014556884766,
0.2216227650642395,
-0.2678409516811371,
0.6853861808776855,
-0.23837146162986755,
-0.09559947997331619,
-0.1536506563425064,
1.1284377574920654,
0.6415271162986755,
0.6173442006111145,
0.8208267688751221,
0.48176878690719604,
0.9234302639961243,
0.04057983681559563,
0.3148724436759949,
-0.11634375900030136,
-0.17407052218914032,
0.9895011186599731,
-0.32488512992858887,
1.1783664226531982,
0.2721814215183258,
-0.3744765520095825,
0.13869717717170715,
0.5841107964515686,
-0.12109603732824326,
0.793408989906311,
0.17416967451572418,
-0.644481897354126,
-0.10599754750728607,
0.18141336739063263,
-0.2573333978652954,
0.6283497214317322,
0.559794545173645,
-0.39149805903434753,
0.22700898349285126,
0.40993621945381165,
0.009440070018172264,
-0.23099815845489502,
-0.7153686881065369,
0.7756186723709106,
0.023784859105944633,
-0.40454721450805664,
0.2107701599597931,
-0.13513822853565216,
0.565190315246582,
-0.6270078420639038,
0.07125881314277649,
0.2434285432100296,
0.3479463756084442,
-0.2211165726184845,
-0.6554325222969055,
0.22084634006023407,
0.15035498142242432,
-0.2601546049118042,
-0.21901296079158783,
0.5692930817604065,
-0.5928459167480469,
-0.9603084325790405,
0.056778401136398315,
0.5128980278968811,
0.20039917528629303,
-0.23861153423786163,
-0.6576231122016907,
0.24439279735088348,
0.004643797408789396,
-0.08989697694778442,
0.10309842973947525,
0.3597472310066223,
-0.24175335466861725,
0.628035843372345,
0.6913899779319763,
0.21908345818519592,
0.4169696271419525,
0.22578345239162445,
0.9116652607917786,
-0.22766149044036865,
-0.4190085530281067,
-0.2658340632915497,
0.7108292579650879,
0.21359069645404816,
0.07090961933135986,
0.6255583763122559,
0.6383189558982849,
0.5396571159362793,
0.41630464792251587,
1.1602154970169067,
-0.07472321391105652,
1.134644627571106,
-0.1629830002784729,
0.5882173776626587,
-0.4246237277984619,
0.2865186929702759,
-0.2259400635957718,
-0.6951560378074646,
-0.5153731107711792,
0.9926194548606873,
-0.09821975976228714,
0.31505823135375977,
0.27643314003944397,
0.670950174331665,
-0.25105440616607666,
-0.15720431506633759,
0.30424588918685913,
0.15273158252239227,
0.1450360268354416,
0.17096014320850372,
0.5842726230621338,
-0.6121174693107605,
0.5883592367172241,
-0.30561524629592896,
-0.5932853817939758,
0.16859465837478638,
-0.2971608340740204,
-0.7448475956916809,
-0.8138144016265869,
-0.7747578024864197,
-0.10861773788928986,
0.1506778746843338,
0.8857038617134094,
0.8437206745147705,
-1.0880076885223389,
-0.31176427006721497,
-0.2142232358455658,
-0.37483030557632446,
-0.43824252486228943,
-0.10719331353902817,
0.3107900023460388,
-0.1375296264886856,
-0.8734267950057983,
0.904086172580719,
0.05296571925282478,
0.1257377415895462,
-0.18711912631988525,
0.01871170476078987,
-0.25618401169776917,
0.016950521618127823,
0.4438137412071228,
0.37184348702430725,
-0.5911160707473755,
0.19797852635383606,
-0.2680022716522217,
0.30561357736587524,
0.00936818215996027,
0.5456730127334595,
-0.9725086688995361,
0.516451895236969,
0.46446236968040466,
0.5062035918235779,
0.5847497582435608,
0.07935662567615509,
0.6449779272079468,
-0.7031281590461731,
0.2226300984621048,
0.5353999733924866,
0.09904970973730087,
0.3930758237838745,
0.030526356771588326,
0.4029949903488159,
0.010444353334605694,
-0.5648861527442932,
-0.9951803684234619,
0.010093636810779572,
-1.2730644941329956,
-0.09011770039796829,
1.213585615158081,
-0.19126161932945251,
0.09896030277013779,
-0.2940046787261963,
-0.15537765622138977,
0.8462474942207336,
-0.6471613049507141,
0.4758923053741455,
-0.0921175479888916,
-0.46017104387283325,
-0.3697187602519989,
-0.5540348887443542,
0.3552635908126831,
0.0538586787879467,
-0.3085508942604065,
-0.2801254987716675,
0.42593324184417725,
0.02059902995824814,
-0.01961338520050049,
0.23434434831142426,
0.08261305838823318,
0.22195714712142944,
-0.0626397356390953,
0.1643570512533188,
-0.004846879281103611,
-0.6232316493988037,
-0.6354256868362427,
0.2426319122314453,
0.06718092411756516,
-0.8980900645256042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02429v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02429v1
|
CALRec: Contrastive Alignment of Generative LLMs For Sequential Recommendation
| 2024-05-03T18:51:19 | 2024-05-03T18:51:19 |
Yaoyiran Li, Xiang Zhai, Moustafa Alzantot, Keyi Yu, Ivan Vulić, Anna Korhonen, Mohamed Hammad
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Traditional recommender systems such as matrix factorization methods rely on
learning a shared dense embedding space to represent both items and user
preferences. Sequence models such as RNN, GRUs, and, recently, Transformers
have also excelled in the task of sequential recommendation. This task requires
understanding the sequential structure present in users' historical
interactions to predict the next item they may like. Building upon the success
of Large Language Models (LLMs) in a variety of tasks, researchers have
recently explored using LLMs that are pretrained on vast corpora of text for
sequential recommendation. To use LLMs in sequential recommendations, both the
history of user interactions and the model's prediction of the next item are
expressed in text form. We propose CALRec, a two-stage LLM finetuning framework
that finetunes a pretrained LLM in a two-tower fashion using a mixture of two
contrastive losses and a language modeling loss: the LLM is first finetuned on
a data mixture from multiple domains followed by another round of target domain
finetuning. Our model significantly outperforms many state-of-the-art baselines
(+37% in Recall@1 and +24% in NDCG@10) and systematic ablation studies reveal
that (i) both stages of finetuning are crucial, and, when combined, we achieve
improved performance, and (ii) contrastive alignment is effective among the
target domains explored in our experiments.
|
[
-0.34344232082366943,
-0.47184786200523376,
0.4520024061203003,
0.25076887011528015,
-0.17205403745174408,
0.08246108144521713,
-0.11613235622644424,
-0.10426793992519379,
0.052212417125701904,
0.6657811403274536,
-0.6456843614578247,
-0.5286518931388855,
-0.3227626085281372,
-0.03757660463452339,
-0.4727371633052826,
1.1804171800613403,
-0.22497715055942535,
0.27189719676971436,
-0.25181448459625244,
-0.15739722549915314,
-0.7543554306030273,
-0.20636484026908875,
-0.5806271433830261,
-0.8153292536735535,
0.7896889448165894,
0.7513843774795532,
0.6722496151924133,
0.4044232666492462,
0.5704872608184814,
0.2877129316329956,
0.12629345059394836,
0.29926180839538574,
-0.8698041439056396,
0.29654550552368164,
-0.14965584874153137,
-0.48724883794784546,
-0.24095091223716736,
-0.16542474925518036,
0.5638095736503601,
0.7407580018043518,
-0.31715965270996094,
-0.1339472085237503,
0.4025669991970062,
0.9214854836463928,
-0.4960489869117737,
-0.2841772735118866,
-0.5214654207229614,
-0.041160181164741516,
-0.1314818263053894,
-0.36705073714256287,
-0.5815811157226562,
-0.5845353603363037,
0.32430174946784973,
-0.560910165309906,
0.3064056634902954,
0.15734297037124634,
0.5773953795433044,
0.2430170327425003,
-0.3941754698753357,
-0.1441364288330078,
-0.8743392825126648,
0.7366943359375,
-0.35589754581451416,
0.4847119450569153,
0.43476924300193787,
0.22679634392261505,
-0.2289334535598755,
-0.7762988209724426,
-0.4104556441307068,
-0.14133678376674652,
-0.03252062201499939,
0.1215694472193718,
0.022546852007508278,
-0.08478379994630814,
0.007206474430859089,
0.5577036142349243,
-0.7668741345405579,
0.41053342819213867,
-0.1570381373167038,
-0.18933817744255066,
0.2597004771232605,
0.3007962107658386,
0.0579153411090374,
0.29597213864326477,
-0.6650905609130859,
-0.1588447093963623,
-0.9770087003707886,
-0.24642792344093323,
0.40766236186027527,
0.19510695338249207,
-0.27837491035461426,
0.6965761184692383,
0.03292496129870415,
0.5112990736961365,
0.40868183970451355,
0.15697519481182098,
0.03880086541175842,
-0.5710914134979248,
-0.09091959148645401,
0.17036405205726624,
0.8200446963310242,
0.6177250742912292,
0.521953821182251,
-0.0048081702552735806,
-0.08165561407804489,
0.10358427464962006,
0.3508487045764923,
-1.0133705139160156,
-0.39929208159446716,
-0.06090029329061508,
-0.32073473930358887,
-0.19658982753753662,
0.07085936516523361,
-0.4180116355419159,
-0.5973324179649353,
-0.5122982263565063,
0.20880573987960815,
-0.3963295817375183,
0.2648804187774658,
0.00591903505846858,
0.25985562801361084,
0.07171481847763062,
0.3639538586139679,
-1.0790693759918213,
0.6230681538581848,
0.6616445183753967,
0.9242159128189087,
-0.2528059184551239,
-0.3090702295303345,
-0.5624781847000122,
-0.12943542003631592,
-0.3475969135761261,
0.8731919527053833,
-0.5117418766021729,
-0.5044757127761841,
0.19469492137432098,
-0.06253473460674286,
0.15727145969867706,
-0.606529712677002,
0.5051755309104919,
-0.7854853272438049,
0.20185598731040955,
-0.10782422125339508,
-0.5679262280464172,
-0.2220836877822876,
0.054551802575588226,
-0.6081234812736511,
0.9330112934112549,
0.13716444373130798,
-0.6143956184387207,
0.2385246455669403,
0.1103629618883133,
-0.5265277624130249,
-0.00406733388081193,
-0.25250595808029175,
-0.2873755693435669,
0.07033807039260864,
0.03359948843717575,
0.4237954318523407,
-0.555125892162323,
0.27755481004714966,
-0.4081321358680725,
-0.5174081921577454,
0.30161428451538086,
-0.228570356965065,
0.17589691281318665,
0.26777398586273193,
-0.050913091748952866,
0.35828202962875366,
-0.5595510601997375,
-0.25716349482536316,
-0.1132674589753151,
-0.1981944590806961,
-0.33304068446159363,
0.15582534670829773,
0.15030968189239502,
0.17327192425727844,
0.2974379062652588,
-0.1409335434436798,
0.1523580253124237,
-0.5884845852851868,
0.2642454504966736,
0.7149739861488342,
-0.13685014843940735,
0.8300089836120605,
-0.6378499269485474,
0.4703318476676941,
-0.03330446779727936,
-0.4016163945198059,
-0.3726655840873718,
-0.11896929144859314,
-0.8367341160774231,
0.12800201773643494,
0.38588157296180725,
0.7070146799087524,
-0.5661631226539612,
0.5044625997543335,
-0.16836915910243988,
-0.2576199471950531,
-0.25111520290374756,
0.3957839608192444,
0.4578675925731659,
0.4615784287452698,
0.30294010043144226,
-0.6069479584693909,
-0.7242003083229065,
-0.894019603729248,
0.13044174015522003,
0.023702610284090042,
-0.011440168134868145,
0.3033981919288635,
0.028250856325030327,
-0.40959763526916504,
0.6177521347999573,
-0.6113845109939575,
-0.5867835879325867,
-0.14874593913555145,
0.2269407957792282,
0.1827417016029358,
0.4547591805458069,
0.22950208187103271,
-0.4705802798271179,
-0.46794816851615906,
0.17047546803951263,
-0.35058164596557617,
-0.236663818359375,
-0.14826519787311554,
-0.26163148880004883,
-0.06225213408470154,
0.3968295156955719,
-0.009592031128704548,
0.14439509809017181,
0.5812574625015259,
-0.1441236287355423,
0.33552494645118713,
-0.3414767384529114,
0.10913409292697906,
-1.176984429359436,
-0.11748502403497696,
0.2842485010623932,
-0.22873228788375854,
-0.5713755488395691,
-0.32310566306114197,
0.024121593683958054,
0.17840217053890228,
-0.08358082175254822,
0.6364057660102844,
-0.09069538116455078,
0.12649279832839966,
-0.4397942125797272,
0.25644925236701965,
-0.006562771275639534,
0.4199148416519165,
0.021287601441144943,
0.7463712692260742,
0.08751322329044342,
-0.49470314383506775,
-0.0626620501279831,
0.4549895226955414,
-0.4428243041038513,
0.6234942078590393,
-0.5743589401245117,
0.23448032140731812,
0.11630620807409286,
0.5020871758460999,
-1.2919402122497559,
0.08582044392824173,
0.11648966372013092,
-0.07212720811367035,
0.2335120141506195,
-0.036497194319963455,
-0.31968924403190613,
-0.1390870362520218,
-0.2717711925506592,
0.8942856788635254,
0.35448187589645386,
-0.4997827708721161,
0.3770284950733185,
0.16117946803569794,
-0.43079957365989685,
-0.6366912722587585,
-0.5949645638465881,
-0.16634684801101685,
-0.12026949971914291,
-0.5842382907867432,
0.7799112200737,
-0.3223317265510559,
-0.05469378083944321,
-0.31696441769599915,
-0.10182955116033554,
0.11889088898897171,
-0.1314295381307602,
0.5381045937538147,
0.5454201698303223,
-0.25926709175109863,
-0.007021897938102484,
-0.09449294954538345,
-0.2620674967765808,
-0.2648930549621582,
-0.4939879775047302,
0.8153868317604065,
0.010091928765177727,
-0.1055644154548645,
-0.5719294548034668,
0.1816643625497818,
0.3077855706214905,
-0.02291448414325714,
0.4358144700527191,
0.70844966173172,
-0.3587334454059601,
-0.06586863845586777,
-0.974459171295166,
-0.25738105177879333,
-0.453220933675766,
0.33285894989967346,
-0.2644882798194885,
-1.0329407453536987,
0.5945779085159302,
-0.08503371477127075,
0.0021443653386086226,
0.4404301643371582,
0.7436549663543701,
-0.08187759667634964,
0.905025064945221,
0.6476243734359741,
-0.16754749417304993,
0.7965601086616516,
-0.3595704138278961,
0.04518288001418114,
-0.8903398513793945,
-0.36461010575294495,
-0.458295077085495,
-0.5106077790260315,
-0.6545563340187073,
-0.3357739746570587,
-0.06036011129617691,
0.36348098516464233,
-0.5068368911743164,
0.32224324345588684,
-0.10830139368772507,
0.4715738892555237,
0.5131980180740356,
0.20146453380584717,
0.24864251911640167,
0.21233485639095306,
-0.5630146861076355,
-0.2202569842338562,
-0.5108335614204407,
-0.47911712527275085,
0.9628623127937317,
0.15685728192329407,
1.0127850770950317,
0.03966810554265976,
0.7441914081573486,
0.16709940135478973,
0.3261263370513916,
-0.9494007229804993,
0.4248865246772766,
-0.6703710556030273,
-0.11425784975290298,
-0.04530175030231476,
-0.3062235713005066,
-0.8873165845870972,
0.03918498009443283,
-0.32093024253845215,
-0.5191779136657715,
0.3904078006744385,
0.22431117296218872,
-0.5456819534301758,
-0.05404059588909149,
-0.41771700978279114,
0.7435816526412964,
-0.23881526291370392,
-0.7262066602706909,
-0.4951494038105011,
-0.5846170783042908,
0.3212105631828308,
-0.1974395364522934,
-0.03736763447523117,
-0.01946415565907955,
0.061189454048871994,
0.712348461151123,
-0.4668482840061188,
0.6937332153320312,
0.24432584643363953,
-0.14225149154663086,
0.086835578083992,
0.4800962209701538,
0.6506342887878418,
-0.1251266896724701,
-0.023981310427188873,
-0.08033370971679688,
-0.12403999269008636,
0.04197664186358452,
-0.5260710716247559,
1.1845102310180664,
-0.671173095703125,
-0.3192159831523895,
-0.26334986090660095,
-0.458255797624588,
-0.16335000097751617,
0.2900613248348236,
0.15552948415279388,
0.6349385976791382,
-0.41513773798942566,
0.301817923784256,
0.5008483529090881,
-0.03171056881546974,
0.008139055222272873,
0.4827159345149994,
-0.19841918349266052,
-0.8491840362548828,
0.9206781983375549,
-0.2524971663951874,
0.15645073354244232,
0.685584306716919,
0.2217373102903366,
-0.4709404706954956,
-0.71522057056427,
-0.12572291493415833,
0.2551664113998413,
-0.5965380072593689,
-0.227878600358963,
-0.4064248204231262,
-0.12307768315076828,
-0.2995971441268921,
-0.3969777524471283,
-0.11117113381624222,
-0.28582045435905457,
-0.5541062951087952,
0.02306196093559265,
0.10384051501750946,
0.8788812160491943,
0.07433094084262848,
0.4892312288284302,
-0.5867918133735657,
0.4575537145137787,
0.12647803127765656,
0.4236813187599182,
-0.07233571261167526,
-0.6966359615325928,
-0.3154740333557129,
-0.15029767155647278,
-0.5061281323432922,
-0.49225160479545593,
0.39527440071105957,
0.15751294791698456,
0.2839108109474182,
0.7282441258430481,
-0.09304411709308624,
0.8521361947059631,
-0.9004285335540771,
0.4268195629119873,
0.5688745975494385,
-0.3783595561981201,
0.3305904269218445,
-0.15891218185424805,
0.45132118463516235,
0.9508545398712158,
0.4800572991371155,
-0.6504917144775391,
-0.03865933418273926,
-0.24343906342983246,
-0.8467535376548767,
0.6379441618919373,
-0.12928558886051178,
-0.04849223420023918,
-0.11333751678466797,
0.3356282711029053,
0.37524527311325073,
-0.009133098646998405,
-0.3631391227245331,
-0.3773195743560791,
0.07991921901702881,
-0.3630388081073761,
-0.5095310211181641,
-0.6376291513442993,
-0.20046335458755493,
0.047071728855371475,
0.536963164806366,
0.006581990979611874,
-0.041074223816394806,
-0.03267231583595276,
-0.18509338796138763,
-0.25521567463874817,
0.1813913881778717,
0.7725253701210022,
0.4479009211063385,
-0.30013903975486755,
0.23924602568149567,
0.07211904227733612,
-0.41812241077423096,
0.21763759851455688,
0.36934423446655273,
-0.037928950041532516,
-0.43809956312179565,
0.14958731830120087,
0.7124114632606506,
0.7640189528465271,
-0.3367127478122711,
0.2667880952358246,
-0.03475577384233475,
-0.3038102090358734,
-0.32394635677337646,
-0.07581458985805511,
-0.03912543132901192,
0.2751007676124573,
0.1567852795124054,
0.23753508925437927,
0.12324521690607071,
-0.4017733931541443,
0.3369782269001007,
0.35833999514579773,
-0.5824029445648193,
-0.14479899406433105,
0.6003423929214478,
0.39879533648490906,
-0.35738566517829895,
0.7167083024978638,
0.26128655672073364,
-0.3044525980949402,
0.21224921941757202,
0.6628996729850769,
1.0183048248291016,
-0.13553476333618164,
0.006906764581799507,
0.4665776193141937,
-0.10738750547170639,
-0.5249595046043396,
-0.12178229540586472,
-0.193568617105484,
-0.8761374354362488,
-0.3719431459903717,
-0.6897501349449158,
-0.3242535889148712,
-0.11201950907707214,
-0.628502368927002,
0.380497545003891,
-0.41732779145240784,
-0.1346292644739151,
-0.007042412646114826,
0.1368490755558014,
-0.8704567551612854,
-0.0047069392167031765,
0.21240118145942688,
0.6472063064575195,
-0.7088111639022827,
0.7721312642097473,
0.38905537128448486,
-0.2680564522743225,
-0.5550293326377869,
-0.1867164522409439,
0.1945638209581375,
-0.8433094620704651,
0.7626906633377075,
0.210035502910614,
-0.43607771396636963,
0.09923361986875534,
-0.041628800332546234,
-0.582108736038208,
1.2463675737380981,
0.23994433879852295,
-1.0927298069000244,
-0.0077375867404043674,
-0.15807996690273285,
0.413194477558136,
-0.6646514534950256,
0.36091017723083496,
0.5239946246147156,
0.19600574672222137,
0.5730516910552979,
-0.7723925709724426,
0.12996451556682587,
-0.09870024025440216,
0.09815480560064316,
0.33361783623695374,
-0.3258296847343445,
0.4474908113479614,
-0.47766613960266113,
-0.387450248003006,
0.5769301652908325,
0.7116509675979614,
0.34479448199272156,
0.34910455346107483,
0.48001834750175476,
0.6783701777458191,
0.5970876216888428,
-0.10366889834403992,
0.9889214634895325,
-0.27612441778182983,
0.018956847488880157,
1.5316684246063232,
-0.5060458779335022,
1.0214664936065674,
0.35684505105018616,
-0.24613229930400848,
0.8172864317893982,
0.7794644832611084,
0.03454241901636124,
0.5985097885131836,
0.3032599091529846,
-0.1936878263950348,
-0.2378746122121811,
-0.22630931437015533,
-0.38951215147972107,
0.07257013022899628,
0.2673189640045166,
-0.44785037636756897,
-0.02608952671289444,
-0.14118574559688568,
-0.3216201961040497,
0.26656627655029297,
-0.06548810005187988,
0.9671519994735718,
0.3298650085926056,
-0.8676178455352783,
0.5912681818008423,
-0.1342088282108307,
0.7252600789070129,
-0.6614715456962585,
-0.1602281779050827,
-0.42104271054267883,
0.40581193566322327,
-0.27496394515037537,
-0.6520341634750366,
-0.20834103226661682,
-0.22911863029003143,
-0.42609167098999023,
-0.30836227536201477,
0.45502689480781555,
-0.7651970982551575,
-0.4446873366832733,
0.2449985146522522,
0.2603521943092346,
0.006031847093254328,
0.25695380568504333,
-0.5699496865272522,
0.024744141846895218,
-0.04216649755835533,
0.1300506293773651,
0.36441269516944885,
0.06302879005670547,
-0.0718240961432457,
0.6532719731330872,
0.5912603735923767,
0.04324376955628395,
-0.3102473318576813,
0.7331539392471313,
0.6429965496063232,
-0.6045456528663635,
-0.37860819697380066,
-0.8315138816833496,
0.29307618737220764,
0.32781219482421875,
-0.12031519412994385,
0.5688302516937256,
0.6585621237754822,
0.8741266131401062,
0.17656047642230988,
0.29083797335624695,
0.4164990782737732,
0.17971163988113403,
-0.6247197389602661,
0.19050928950309753,
-0.3745788633823395,
0.6369182467460632,
0.00782739743590355,
-1.2239470481872559,
-0.4593069851398468,
0.48935380578041077,
-0.3172435760498047,
0.22991026937961578,
0.925094485282898,
1.0479183197021484,
0.1258138120174408,
-0.0221546720713377,
0.14157560467720032,
0.11098381876945496,
0.003917730413377285,
0.6261721849441528,
0.9024711847305298,
-0.3282623589038849,
0.5505223870277405,
-0.28595253825187683,
-0.08900933712720871,
-0.4740902781486511,
-0.7040371298789978,
-0.7522448897361755,
-0.6022382974624634,
-0.3336324393749237,
-0.5419836044311523,
0.009428584016859531,
1.0113365650177002,
0.4927423894405365,
-1.0028971433639526,
-0.5756003260612488,
-0.2170342057943344,
0.08339174091815948,
-0.12691713869571686,
-0.16341377794742584,
0.3455541729927063,
-0.13826783001422882,
-0.5938809514045715,
0.4942891299724579,
0.1926773190498352,
0.2240181267261505,
-0.2698781490325928,
-0.2954470217227936,
-0.1876993477344513,
-0.2752155065536499,
0.46743813157081604,
0.1721511334180832,
-0.8924052119255066,
-0.1278591752052307,
-0.17417766153812408,
-0.3554226756095886,
0.011945310980081558,
1.25266432762146,
-0.8988916277885437,
0.5170325040817261,
0.6171772480010986,
0.4815436899662018,
0.6435750126838684,
0.1657663881778717,
0.9214664101600647,
-0.4803735017776489,
-0.07296488434076309,
0.05688811093568802,
0.439527302980423,
0.27888378500938416,
-0.14728738367557526,
0.4007972776889801,
-0.20404581725597382,
-0.7617623805999756,
-0.5827447175979614,
0.21263720095157623,
-1.2643065452575684,
0.05925093591213226,
1.1119167804718018,
0.10197581350803375,
0.34690162539482117,
0.07400590926408768,
-0.44748276472091675,
0.14112131297588348,
-0.39984238147735596,
0.5192008018493652,
0.5702105760574341,
0.07130999863147736,
0.0020593409426510334,
-0.28340208530426025,
0.2807531952857971,
0.6030247211456299,
-0.24685221910476685,
0.0014892462641000748,
0.6799026727676392,
0.18215428292751312,
-0.0224001482129097,
0.5338259935379028,
0.03668450564146042,
0.2053445726633072,
-0.3708120286464691,
-0.04794590175151825,
0.06339489668607712,
-0.43989530205726624,
-0.6224711537361145,
0.09401095658540726,
0.30546775460243225,
-0.01406774576753378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02421v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02421v1
|
What does the Knowledge Neuron Thesis Have to do with Knowledge?
| 2024-05-03T18:34:37 | 2024-05-03T18:34:37 |
Jingcheng Niu, Andrew Liu, Zining Zhu, Gerald Penn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We reassess the Knowledge Neuron (KN) Thesis: an interpretation of the
mechanism underlying the ability of large language models to recall facts from
a training corpus. This nascent thesis proposes that facts are recalled from
the training corpus through the MLP weights in a manner resembling key-value
memory, implying in effect that "knowledge" is stored in the network.
Furthermore, by modifying the MLP modules, one can control the language model's
generation of factual information. The plausibility of the KN thesis has been
demonstrated by the success of KN-inspired model editing methods (Dai et al.,
2022; Meng et al., 2022).
We find that this thesis is, at best, an oversimplification. Not only have we
found that we can edit the expression of certain linguistic phenomena using the
same model editing methods but, through a more comprehensive evaluation, we
have found that the KN thesis does not adequately explain the process of
factual expression. While it is possible to argue that the MLP weights store
complex patterns that are interpretable both syntactically and semantically,
these patterns do not constitute "knowledge." To gain a more comprehensive
understanding of the knowledge representation process, we must look beyond the
MLP weights and explore recent models' complex layer structures and attention
mechanisms.
|
[
-0.09448461979627609,
-0.4093192517757416,
0.5743553042411804,
-0.09530933946371078,
0.1887844353914261,
-0.24273681640625,
-0.25605252385139465,
-0.42523515224456787,
0.24189695715904236,
0.35777971148490906,
-0.0678132101893425,
-0.26862791180610657,
-0.6245868802070618,
-0.27295583486557007,
-0.38260671496391296,
0.900526762008667,
0.04327484592795372,
0.13523229956626892,
-0.6109939813613892,
-0.1250915676355362,
-0.23110699653625488,
-0.5206975936889648,
-0.3936522305011749,
-0.8244320750236511,
0.745459258556366,
0.2058202475309372,
0.5233796238899231,
0.5630983114242554,
0.17165350914001465,
0.2780592441558838,
-0.38873812556266785,
-0.21647970378398895,
-0.31739503145217896,
0.05761871486902237,
-0.14454078674316406,
-0.9959951043128967,
-0.3130069971084595,
-0.0016400405438616872,
0.6670091152191162,
1.2708821296691895,
-0.0063604917377233505,
0.03435581177473068,
0.05788474902510643,
1.063187837600708,
-0.6612209677696228,
0.3364342749118805,
-0.6073654890060425,
0.11497808247804642,
0.2101859152317047,
-0.1220497116446495,
-0.3966633379459381,
-0.20479197800159454,
0.5088982582092285,
-0.5407149195671082,
0.28664064407348633,
-0.03716173395514488,
0.818397581577301,
0.0962018147110939,
-0.42199817299842834,
-0.1996556520462036,
-0.5770244002342224,
0.5434663891792297,
-0.7515089511871338,
0.1575939655303955,
0.42078518867492676,
0.2993270754814148,
-0.21028445661067963,
-0.5797987580299377,
-0.709376335144043,
-0.4243180751800537,
-0.19189491868019104,
0.15676529705524445,
0.04088583588600159,
0.2609691023826599,
0.6733732223510742,
0.0713263750076294,
-0.2790767252445221,
-0.19009928405284882,
-0.6517192125320435,
-0.37031129002571106,
0.34079939126968384,
-0.05129701644182205,
0.3277800977230072,
-0.37921610474586487,
-0.41072022914886475,
0.10002140700817108,
-0.5758379697799683,
0.1099218875169754,
0.4776451587677002,
-0.024059439077973366,
0.0909264087677002,
0.6864618062973022,
-0.3942217230796814,
0.8821590542793274,
-0.34900417923927307,
-0.11076908558607101,
0.13682134449481964,
0.33366158604621887,
-0.2552719712257385,
0.5051860213279724,
0.5658137202262878,
0.5189833641052246,
0.510748565196991,
-0.4702018201351166,
-0.01828366331756115,
0.05071685090661049,
0.6807205677032471,
-0.4193130433559418,
-0.5219348073005676,
0.0173368901014328,
-0.5920543074607849,
-0.42008069157600403,
-0.1935487687587738,
-0.3573380410671234,
-0.36125969886779785,
-0.5565484762191772,
0.7201974391937256,
-0.6010519862174988,
-0.43458297848701477,
0.2568042576313019,
-0.6375184655189514,
-0.06074361875653267,
0.28852376341819763,
-1.0016027688980103,
0.3182080090045929,
0.5941185355186462,
0.6301506161689758,
-0.12175395339727402,
-0.5957996845245361,
0.5299577116966248,
0.31706082820892334,
-0.5916334390640259,
0.6376595497131348,
-0.40749043226242065,
0.03132668137550354,
-0.040704626590013504,
-0.0722089633345604,
-0.22170309722423553,
-0.5539759397506714,
0.11314482241868973,
-0.961000919342041,
-0.008915146812796593,
-0.8752101063728333,
-1.0188167095184326,
-0.5963121056556702,
0.20584715902805328,
-0.5465011596679688,
0.46838074922561646,
-0.020085738971829414,
-0.9445778727531433,
0.5837685465812683,
-0.6304340958595276,
-0.3311878740787506,
-0.3378273844718933,
-0.021031085401773453,
0.1363278031349182,
0.31599631905555725,
-0.42236411571502686,
0.4539758861064911,
-0.10745055228471756,
0.17143164575099945,
-0.503555178642273,
-0.0525464192032814,
0.5356912016868591,
-0.16385744512081146,
0.6320619583129883,
-0.11782154440879822,
-0.025596123188734055,
-0.1392509639263153,
-0.8942618370056152,
-0.19038644433021545,
0.06725294888019562,
-0.571452796459198,
-0.6245011687278748,
-0.050283629447221756,
-0.5295102000236511,
0.3063693046569824,
0.3423246145248413,
-0.7452728152275085,
0.4052586257457733,
-0.5103133320808411,
0.35188958048820496,
0.8129684925079346,
-0.008191865868866444,
0.8312737345695496,
-0.3737570643424988,
0.1314130276441574,
0.14836637675762177,
-0.0949254110455513,
0.19873939454555511,
-0.4954897165298462,
-0.9833567142486572,
0.4219609797000885,
0.44380152225494385,
0.1756572723388672,
-0.5633439421653748,
-0.01585531234741211,
-0.18483199179172516,
-0.5124019980430603,
-0.36956652998924255,
-0.18245291709899902,
0.1422223448753357,
0.8131220936775208,
0.3519532382488251,
-0.1691346913576126,
-0.42125245928764343,
-1.210370421409607,
-0.5246866345405579,
-0.06654620170593262,
0.18765120208263397,
0.07281221449375153,
0.6457480788230896,
0.39291059970855713,
1.0159696340560913,
-0.466982364654541,
-0.08991310745477676,
-0.12954175472259521,
0.3292919993400574,
0.2568352222442627,
0.5803181529045105,
0.6426061987876892,
-0.6154367327690125,
-0.20249328017234802,
-0.04058269038796425,
-1.045894742012024,
0.0017241444438695908,
-0.15276576578617096,
0.04791155457496643,
0.06901733577251434,
0.5040703415870667,
-0.9648587107658386,
0.39771604537963867,
0.18240328133106232,
-0.1468224823474884,
0.9077656269073486,
-0.4441978335380554,
-0.06326626241207123,
-0.8157389163970947,
0.157760888338089,
-0.3867986798286438,
0.2649451196193695,
-0.7121715545654297,
-0.3161066770553589,
0.17705702781677246,
0.14753267168998718,
-0.2047000378370285,
0.3418346643447876,
-0.3290049433708191,
-0.40092936158180237,
-0.7655923366546631,
-0.035698890686035156,
0.08475405722856522,
0.7348174452781677,
-0.04290094971656799,
0.26599034667015076,
0.7115722894668579,
-0.9947493672370911,
0.3375469744205475,
-0.0014841658994555473,
-0.7804406881332397,
0.3274156153202057,
-0.5075578689575195,
-0.047327205538749695,
-0.3489501476287842,
-0.15564444661140442,
-0.7761852741241455,
-0.2103174775838852,
0.23612253367900848,
-0.5949098467826843,
0.5657082200050354,
-0.3007574677467346,
-0.5409489274024963,
-0.07586551457643509,
0.1880338042974472,
0.20494253933429718,
0.4406270682811737,
-0.24297261238098145,
0.6796436309814453,
0.4321858286857605,
0.05746198445558548,
-0.7749739289283752,
-0.8150876760482788,
0.03308537229895592,
-0.028959015384316444,
-0.4568007290363312,
0.26764461398124695,
0.3558351397514343,
-0.3064675033092499,
0.2366684526205063,
-0.45122969150543213,
-0.11173762381076813,
0.03764801844954491,
0.24332861602306366,
-0.051623180508613586,
-0.15960891544818878,
0.5554210543632507,
0.20051982998847961,
-0.16531679034233093,
0.5147897005081177,
-0.46114540100097656,
0.500139594078064,
0.2613380253314972,
-0.3481782078742981,
-0.342233806848526,
-0.030533885583281517,
0.4737952649593353,
0.19048058986663818,
0.843263566493988,
0.36590296030044556,
-0.3893369138240814,
-0.14826597273349762,
-0.43199145793914795,
-0.24125951528549194,
-0.3846491277217865,
0.4311703145503998,
-0.3346586525440216,
-0.6802241206169128,
0.5320931673049927,
-0.234710693359375,
-0.09782174974679947,
0.6019877791404724,
0.18562185764312744,
-0.48858147859573364,
0.7451097369194031,
0.6116363406181335,
0.033685583621263504,
0.19706209003925323,
-0.380083292722702,
-0.019742142409086227,
-1.1425857543945312,
-0.29144206643104553,
-0.45838814973831177,
-0.6767733693122864,
-0.09778424352407455,
0.03676164895296097,
0.15537263453006744,
0.3805907666683197,
-0.2745440900325775,
0.334771990776062,
-0.14808759093284607,
0.39150217175483704,
0.6366470456123352,
0.09045054018497467,
0.09866026043891907,
-0.13030317425727844,
-0.3836904764175415,
-0.11867230385541916,
-1.1902949810028076,
-0.5384960770606995,
1.2822462320327759,
0.17314676940441132,
0.5356118679046631,
-0.09719438850879669,
0.19185641407966614,
0.19141598045825958,
0.18562690913677216,
-0.7561254501342773,
0.6690950393676758,
0.17093758285045624,
-0.8168686628341675,
-0.05597309023141861,
-0.39690014719963074,
-0.8342708945274353,
0.29942405223846436,
-0.2728472054004669,
-0.8133882284164429,
0.3155970871448517,
0.27660953998565674,
-0.27422627806663513,
0.6713067889213562,
-0.7912960052490234,
0.799263060092926,
0.026066303253173828,
-0.09948524087667465,
-0.656834602355957,
-0.5912261009216309,
0.5271918773651123,
0.16690559685230255,
-0.08362917602062225,
0.05255524814128876,
0.0362338051199913,
1.1851154565811157,
-0.31207630038261414,
1.0501322746276855,
-0.4184917211532593,
0.002229182980954647,
0.27953511476516724,
0.3266035318374634,
0.16266003251075745,
-0.34659093618392944,
-0.06131395697593689,
0.10408858954906464,
-0.020052025094628334,
-0.3747495710849762,
-0.9573588967323303,
0.6199983358383179,
-0.8263520002365112,
-0.554495632648468,
-0.30303698778152466,
-0.8739544749259949,
-0.0978100448846817,
0.23335811495780945,
0.1544797420501709,
0.5226460099220276,
0.10680636018514633,
0.1600264310836792,
0.7912428379058838,
-0.3461872637271881,
0.21870940923690796,
0.3819454610347748,
-0.34731850028038025,
-0.06544432789087296,
0.981196403503418,
0.6462360620498657,
0.5313379168510437,
0.5222625732421875,
0.2890092432498932,
-0.017234312370419502,
-0.5899285674095154,
-0.097170390188694,
0.08914800733327866,
-1.1910810470581055,
0.12349064648151398,
-1.0450034141540527,
-0.09006185829639435,
-0.39849579334259033,
0.054677944630384445,
-0.26125162839889526,
-0.8818904757499695,
-0.05340401455760002,
-0.13267679512500763,
0.36579012870788574,
0.9607456922531128,
-0.3218609094619751,
0.41544535756111145,
-0.5744068622589111,
0.4249623119831085,
0.45320847630500793,
0.20991234481334686,
0.5298435688018799,
-0.47337237000465393,
-0.4971793591976166,
0.0725240707397461,
-0.08972989767789841,
-0.9088214039802551,
0.08068755269050598,
-0.0508185438811779,
0.6446409225463867,
0.39034706354141235,
-0.04337663948535919,
0.270111620426178,
-0.3737865388393402,
0.7177160978317261,
0.21783527731895447,
-0.6885199546813965,
0.3016507029533386,
-0.07751991599798203,
0.3268480896949768,
0.2579540014266968,
0.5691438913345337,
-0.6053547859191895,
-0.13963282108306885,
-0.8652742505073547,
-0.5744331479072571,
0.8092896342277527,
-0.17214597761631012,
0.07995183765888214,
0.12411030381917953,
0.5865231156349182,
0.059961456805467606,
0.5379945635795593,
-0.5412695407867432,
-0.35188454389572144,
-0.3114125430583954,
0.09251594543457031,
0.26293259859085083,
-0.5653337240219116,
-0.14484688639640808,
-0.35182783007621765,
0.6971155405044556,
0.032253384590148926,
0.36629512906074524,
0.31657689809799194,
-0.2631787359714508,
0.03868957236409187,
0.09281812608242035,
0.5492632389068604,
0.8203020095825195,
-0.11401814222335815,
0.23240190744400024,
0.18595191836357117,
-0.44130435585975647,
-0.2045980989933014,
-0.344217985868454,
-0.451427161693573,
0.03256705030798912,
0.525360107421875,
0.8393856883049011,
0.37023237347602844,
-0.16009964048862457,
0.36124086380004883,
0.24680113792419434,
-0.47927528619766235,
-0.28643906116485596,
0.22380562126636505,
0.24016527831554413,
0.2718808054924011,
0.08350520581007004,
0.7906351089477539,
0.04233643412590027,
-0.5574941635131836,
0.15852399170398712,
0.2795012891292572,
-0.4996463656425476,
-0.35719534754753113,
0.5284284353256226,
-0.3925929665565491,
-0.025520527735352516,
0.38976210355758667,
0.02342372201383114,
-0.8280532956123352,
0.7701820135116577,
0.3937685191631317,
0.567939043045044,
-0.0034460851456969976,
0.21754352748394012,
0.590374231338501,
0.4214663505554199,
-0.15516924858093262,
0.2055601328611374,
-0.07130196690559387,
-1.15436589717865,
-0.7000644207000732,
-0.6406009197235107,
-0.12276006489992142,
0.010130894370377064,
-0.5720571279525757,
-0.16875016689300537,
-0.4981449544429779,
-0.08549260348081589,
0.18008506298065186,
-0.3988524079322815,
-0.4016745090484619,
0.2910771667957306,
-0.002461927244439721,
1.1361764669418335,
-0.6694348454475403,
1.0837807655334473,
0.5323120951652527,
-0.40509676933288574,
-0.7653563618659973,
-0.16541089117527008,
-0.22815485298633575,
-0.7730824947357178,
1.0257936716079712,
0.14597579836845398,
0.18176151812076569,
0.020112575963139534,
-0.7426751255989075,
-0.8831345438957214,
0.7717871069908142,
0.30338314175605774,
-0.2033875584602356,
-0.13247977197170258,
0.24612748622894287,
0.46738672256469727,
-0.2190081626176834,
-0.19020868837833405,
0.3816148042678833,
0.6003396511077881,
-0.10859030485153198,
-0.5370270609855652,
-0.08403615653514862,
-0.13551217317581177,
-0.25903624296188354,
0.1008095070719719,
-0.2610950469970703,
0.803948700428009,
-0.33648622035980225,
-0.023035217076539993,
-0.15398605167865753,
0.6663250923156738,
-0.27491238713264465,
-0.01623324677348137,
0.3572295606136322,
0.8906456828117371,
0.600723147392273,
-0.01793452724814415,
1.2162363529205322,
-0.22995178401470184,
0.16966351866722107,
1.0850118398666382,
-0.10660217702388763,
0.5150532722473145,
0.5737546682357788,
-0.06824614107608795,
0.4679671823978424,
0.20351091027259827,
0.0003791757917497307,
0.6437592506408691,
0.3561041057109833,
-0.07435259968042374,
-0.3990679681301117,
-0.06636139005422592,
-0.25481367111206055,
0.49647510051727295,
0.31859031319618225,
-0.4751065969467163,
-0.1692703515291214,
0.005410639103502035,
-0.007116740103811026,
-0.08239085227251053,
-0.4493696987628937,
0.8117247819900513,
0.3241404891014099,
-0.598395824432373,
0.4416869878768921,
-0.16949576139450073,
0.23839721083641052,
-0.7859131693840027,
-0.18120405077934265,
0.42171257734298706,
0.09522037208080292,
-0.16729722917079926,
-0.7852476835250854,
0.4696529507637024,
-0.45333144068717957,
-0.3900854289531708,
-0.20563483238220215,
1.0945957899093628,
-0.23864726722240448,
-0.03974991664290428,
0.2618935704231262,
0.41038060188293457,
0.2490249127149582,
-0.19380244612693787,
-0.6417063474655151,
-0.3171898126602173,
-0.07667720317840576,
-0.40049025416374207,
0.464637815952301,
0.588772177696228,
0.44853147864341736,
0.7054746150970459,
0.672842264175415,
0.3739188015460968,
0.13059043884277344,
0.1396513730287552,
0.7533212304115295,
-0.7583587169647217,
-0.19157198071479797,
-0.7556624412536621,
0.41984906792640686,
-0.1556767076253891,
-0.2112855166196823,
0.6659330725669861,
0.3847811222076416,
0.8810607194900513,
-0.2907964885234833,
0.9347410798072815,
-0.2641929090023041,
0.42092734575271606,
-0.7357092499732971,
1.0909725427627563,
-0.4817337989807129,
-0.029385920614004135,
-0.2993723452091217,
-0.6472986340522766,
-0.2055993527173996,
0.674191415309906,
-0.5911397933959961,
-0.1298551857471466,
0.8895190358161926,
0.5786691308021545,
0.09910792857408524,
0.2807655334472656,
0.5206521153450012,
0.6833449006080627,
-0.13661855459213257,
0.4184504747390747,
1.066514253616333,
-0.39066725969314575,
0.36850690841674805,
-0.5462268590927124,
0.016005435958504677,
0.012655938044190407,
-0.8254795074462891,
-0.9198030829429626,
-0.6386289000511169,
-0.16060470044612885,
-0.4182755649089813,
-0.11129415035247803,
0.6561753153800964,
0.5108188986778259,
-0.5865466594696045,
-0.20866641402244568,
-0.3027665317058563,
0.31295910477638245,
-0.4038611650466919,
-0.20036214590072632,
0.4782577455043793,
-0.5794792771339417,
-0.09976119548082352,
0.4644699692726135,
0.3028685748577118,
0.05544379726052284,
-0.26530614495277405,
0.08219273388385773,
-0.31846457719802856,
-0.3708863854408264,
0.6118065714836121,
0.17498022317886353,
-0.42741549015045166,
-0.3103778660297394,
0.006443527992814779,
0.04489270970225334,
0.06578242778778076,
0.8829941749572754,
-0.7694925665855408,
0.5431477427482605,
0.7280303239822388,
0.6615298986434937,
0.3440113961696625,
-0.6562953591346741,
0.8291130065917969,
-0.41151949763298035,
-0.059921249747276306,
0.14944742619991302,
0.6637728810310364,
0.2670513093471527,
-0.0032480903901159763,
0.06263117492198944,
0.5472525954246521,
-0.6057847142219543,
-0.4761556386947632,
0.48059484362602234,
-0.8790250420570374,
-0.6441231966018677,
0.9058001637458801,
-0.1841154396533966,
-0.6096245050430298,
-0.31299182772636414,
-0.16681063175201416,
0.4841736853122711,
-0.0743950754404068,
1.0317790508270264,
0.9688317179679871,
0.13648532330989838,
0.10838638246059418,
-1.0486980676651,
0.6652402281761169,
0.42388609051704407,
-0.19368350505828857,
0.14882531762123108,
0.26096218824386597,
0.2993764579296112,
0.43910905718803406,
0.2473239302635193,
0.007740466855466366,
0.2156021147966385,
0.12828053534030914,
0.4221172034740448,
-0.04393680393695831,
-0.4508666694164276,
-0.12051401287317276,
0.43612098693847656,
-0.04948108270764351,
0.1442970633506775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02411v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02411v1
|
The Call for Socially Aware Language Technologies
| 2024-05-03T18:12:39 | 2024-05-03T18:12:39 |
Diyi Yang, Dirk Hovy, David Jurgens, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language technologies have made enormous progress, especially with the
introduction of large language models (LLMs). On traditional tasks such as
machine translation and sentiment analysis, these models perform at near-human
level. These advances can, however, exacerbate a variety of issues that models
have traditionally struggled with, such as bias, evaluation, and risks. In this
position paper, we argue that many of these issues share a common core: a lack
of awareness of the factors, context, and implications of the social
environment in which NLP operates, which we call social awareness. While NLP is
getting better at solving the formal linguistic aspects, limited progress has
been made in adding the social awareness required for language applications to
work in all situations for all users. Integrating social awareness into NLP
models will make applications more natural, helpful, and safe, and will open up
new possibilities. Thus we argue that substantial challenges remain for NLP to
develop social awareness and that we are just at the beginning of a new era for
the field.
|
[
-0.1513756662607193,
-0.5923136472702026,
0.5866959095001221,
0.36375123262405396,
0.18318001925945282,
0.38964754343032837,
-0.2810223698616028,
-0.9398212432861328,
0.16796694695949554,
0.2267329841852188,
-0.06643500179052353,
-0.3689451813697815,
-0.8577914834022522,
0.07858486473560333,
-0.5604153275489807,
0.6534706950187683,
0.33032163977622986,
-0.28860029578208923,
-0.062131598591804504,
-0.06377405673265457,
-0.23447968065738678,
-0.7104430198669434,
-0.8458848595619202,
-0.4853266477584839,
0.5422115921974182,
0.28515374660491943,
0.7347903251647949,
0.1415860801935196,
0.34357979893684387,
0.31607872247695923,
-0.6100859642028809,
-0.0004297638370189816,
-0.10862507671117783,
0.0997769832611084,
-0.22520838677883148,
-0.2920137941837311,
-0.599844753742218,
-0.08131330460309982,
0.6678367257118225,
0.944396436214447,
0.20632115006446838,
0.2716927230358124,
0.14724813401699066,
0.9832233190536499,
-0.4282233417034149,
0.06815913319587708,
-0.7302247285842896,
0.14432676136493683,
-0.06642724573612213,
-0.04879259690642357,
-0.18613308668136597,
-0.3652518093585968,
0.45429256558418274,
-0.40824607014656067,
-0.10145842283964157,
-0.08817266672849655,
0.5170846581459045,
0.09017748385667801,
-0.39889970421791077,
-0.27662011981010437,
-0.831304132938385,
0.6431443095207214,
-0.5770778059959412,
0.5063955187797546,
0.36648935079574585,
0.20687036216259003,
-0.11189483106136322,
-0.2950834035873413,
-0.5469470024108887,
0.059032782912254333,
0.39924854040145874,
-0.1140795648097992,
-0.2821712791919708,
-0.1973276436328888,
0.2021917998790741,
-0.08353010565042496,
-0.24154147505760193,
0.060558419674634933,
-0.3564184606075287,
-0.17840442061424255,
0.5983017086982727,
-0.04857518896460533,
0.41078421473503113,
-0.38135793805122375,
-0.24223262071609497,
0.48255178332328796,
-0.5350608229637146,
0.06965085119009018,
0.005936022382229567,
0.295092910528183,
-0.36155030131340027,
0.37308743596076965,
-0.17584040760993958,
0.43071040511131287,
-0.21333378553390503,
-0.0305621400475502,
0.26807188987731934,
-0.27903610467910767,
-0.14029434323310852,
0.13143572211265564,
0.4550357162952423,
0.49643999338150024,
0.6377887725830078,
0.22259482741355896,
-0.16196756064891815,
0.3213125169277191,
0.09992741793394089,
-0.12414991110563278,
0.2403530329465866,
0.3962971270084381,
-0.13733701407909393,
-0.4046447277069092,
-0.30019092559814453,
-0.47137489914894104,
-0.9195166826248169,
-0.3143170177936554,
0.08575638383626938,
-0.18494199216365814,
-0.7069907188415527,
0.41480711102485657,
-0.1328391581773758,
0.5054240822792053,
0.49700024724006653,
-0.9323351383209229,
0.1907518208026886,
1.0629256963729858,
0.8714351654052734,
0.4438118040561676,
0.14661379158496857,
0.025205442681908607,
0.24926860630512238,
-0.226235494017601,
0.7801686525344849,
-0.5430691838264465,
-0.6385151147842407,
0.22557851672172546,
-0.04340558499097824,
0.09793608635663986,
-0.2130487561225891,
0.2089899778366089,
-0.19682592153549194,
-0.13034862279891968,
-0.5783721208572388,
-0.2451627403497696,
0.0542440190911293,
0.4253266751766205,
-0.07078298926353455,
1.1947799921035767,
-0.06768687814474106,
-0.8384129405021667,
0.21258224546909332,
-0.7120295763015747,
-0.6544287204742432,
0.4737958312034607,
-0.04125700518488884,
-0.10406964272260666,
0.31983745098114014,
-0.03337111696600914,
0.4810221195220947,
-0.12819191813468933,
0.446268230676651,
-0.43098703026771545,
-0.3141535520553589,
0.2654232978820801,
-0.21660712361335754,
1.0090402364730835,
0.10716085880994797,
-0.5275447964668274,
0.010568417608737946,
-0.5120606422424316,
-0.2726004123687744,
0.03289492055773735,
-0.19289131462574005,
-0.5814231038093567,
0.09384645521640778,
-0.07513371109962463,
0.23978576064109802,
0.5323543548583984,
-0.4518565833568573,
-0.455570250749588,
-0.4691790044307709,
0.563080370426178,
1.3070722818374634,
-0.30435606837272644,
0.7539439797401428,
-0.3737209737300873,
0.4217474162578583,
-0.209501251578331,
0.5489345788955688,
0.2960454225540161,
-0.8443282246589661,
-0.7553104162216187,
0.18094691634178162,
-0.24562488496303558,
0.5648459792137146,
-0.35464930534362793,
0.6335610747337341,
-0.1727464646100998,
-0.6320685148239136,
-0.43555518984794617,
0.1947791874408722,
0.12799352407455444,
0.29503923654556274,
-0.08431531488895416,
-0.1344606876373291,
-0.5713209509849548,
-0.6732112765312195,
-0.37692657113075256,
-0.5452070832252502,
0.2761854827404022,
0.48766636848449707,
0.1907937079668045,
-0.4237828552722931,
0.7940347194671631,
-0.1682845950126648,
-0.16887617111206055,
-0.5559414029121399,
-0.2562728524208069,
-0.03317756578326225,
0.3548378646373749,
0.20123633742332458,
-0.7556453943252563,
-0.6623947620391846,
0.3697913885116577,
-0.8495040535926819,
-0.26853153109550476,
0.2636420726776123,
0.10708881169557571,
0.44162818789482117,
0.6711869239807129,
-0.4796016216278076,
0.11296887695789337,
0.5141318440437317,
-0.09335722029209137,
0.2971542775630951,
-0.08370428532361984,
-0.1376086175441742,
-1.1459548473358154,
0.06967882812023163,
0.2837394177913666,
-0.19104011356830597,
-0.7482624650001526,
-0.3507084548473358,
-0.1471734195947647,
-0.37010371685028076,
-0.47430041432380676,
0.821015477180481,
-0.5974453091621399,
-0.18991529941558838,
-0.1944594532251358,
0.6125029921531677,
0.09776586294174194,
-0.21625706553459167,
0.060809116810560226,
0.315437376499176,
0.8019092679023743,
-0.6768428683280945,
0.24870669841766357,
-0.06724143773317337,
-0.3650229275226593,
0.48712852597236633,
-0.9561743140220642,
0.17834769189357758,
-0.28678035736083984,
0.053607963025569916,
-0.719545841217041,
-0.1655987948179245,
0.18861696124076843,
-0.7416289448738098,
0.18298719823360443,
0.12249579280614853,
-0.33324316143989563,
-0.47949662804603577,
-0.34377166628837585,
0.0974595695734024,
0.6655288934707642,
0.00659666582942009,
0.6044421792030334,
1.0150197744369507,
-0.4171127676963806,
-0.7185540795326233,
-0.565596342086792,
0.2830105423927307,
-0.060714177787303925,
-0.8871567249298096,
-0.1655896008014679,
0.28000608086586,
-0.6643235683441162,
-0.07014653086662292,
-0.14847981929779053,
0.0915260910987854,
0.6448191404342651,
0.25742650032043457,
0.19243790209293365,
0.07110466063022614,
0.38142886757850647,
-0.1502918004989624,
-0.37015053629875183,
0.2695356011390686,
-0.31945231556892395,
0.452565997838974,
-0.43150636553764343,
-0.14996181428432465,
-0.28763148188591003,
0.45100104808807373,
0.21458035707473755,
-0.18419335782527924,
0.49110108613967896,
0.5850866436958313,
-0.7074937224388123,
-0.028813377022743225,
-0.8439949154853821,
-0.0006739508244208992,
-0.5253993272781372,
0.5189526081085205,
0.14924786984920502,
-1.3501055240631104,
0.35016486048698425,
0.009260858409106731,
0.05143623799085617,
0.17222842574119568,
0.35840708017349243,
-0.3059252202510834,
1.0426195859909058,
1.0893642902374268,
-0.07219049334526062,
0.7651333212852478,
0.2543224096298218,
0.5661095976829529,
-0.8293421268463135,
-0.11435341835021973,
-0.866091787815094,
-0.02008233219385147,
-0.5669131278991699,
-0.2505176365375519,
0.38388049602508545,
-0.3425699472427368,
0.03519679233431816,
0.2712070941925049,
-0.5413178205490112,
0.28812113404273987,
0.33160969614982605,
-0.032983776181936264,
0.316864937543869,
-0.14673244953155518,
0.31751981377601624,
-0.0015212073922157288,
-0.7504956722259521,
-0.9067992568016052,
0.790608823299408,
0.48438942432403564,
0.46395766735076904,
-0.03003699518740177,
0.6849753856658936,
0.4011499881744385,
0.36035048961639404,
-0.5605729222297668,
0.8504235744476318,
-0.10172385722398758,
-0.7852524518966675,
-0.26824644207954407,
-0.18505991995334625,
-0.7603809833526611,
-0.10791374742984772,
-0.2874610722064972,
-0.7289408445358276,
0.21670058369636536,
0.2045372575521469,
-0.4408875107765198,
0.10926570743322372,
-0.8193778991699219,
0.762669026851654,
0.0033747388515621424,
-0.2892521023750305,
-0.18558330833911896,
-0.8193929195404053,
0.23580066859722137,
-0.020393554121255875,
0.8014260530471802,
-0.6266776919364929,
0.34954044222831726,
0.6806653141975403,
-0.08038810640573502,
1.3012281656265259,
-0.1587902307510376,
-0.3348313868045807,
0.5143042802810669,
-0.24404260516166687,
0.4059652090072632,
-0.09310851991176605,
-0.03131096437573433,
-0.0200666356831789,
-0.07770191133022308,
-0.3893451690673828,
-0.20479606091976166,
0.6267390847206116,
-0.5828798413276672,
-0.8887115120887756,
-0.5613343715667725,
-0.2537253797054291,
-0.02431247942149639,
0.06498575210571289,
-0.29366955161094666,
0.2754453718662262,
-0.17465373873710632,
0.048483531922101974,
0.8961554169654846,
-0.47396227717399597,
0.22168973088264465,
0.26407259702682495,
-0.3646216094493866,
0.2465381920337677,
0.8231939673423767,
0.2265041023492813,
0.44300341606140137,
0.05247955769300461,
0.3635745942592621,
-0.15050138533115387,
-0.3967899680137634,
0.0880674421787262,
0.37249964475631714,
-0.8818451762199402,
0.1361306756734848,
-1.029207468032837,
-0.05729822814464569,
-0.9413107633590698,
-0.6926939487457275,
-0.28272905945777893,
-0.373862087726593,
-0.18673516809940338,
-0.13245071470737457,
0.3628791868686676,
0.7860455513000488,
-0.3415153920650482,
0.21450312435626984,
-0.9820629358291626,
0.14949534833431244,
0.3640759289264679,
0.3620378375053406,
0.09891954064369202,
-0.3903578221797943,
-0.22992856800556183,
-0.1451667994260788,
0.04529079794883728,
-0.4767593443393707,
0.12074548006057739,
0.010372970253229141,
0.38203826546669006,
0.14350779354572296,
0.030789176002144814,
0.2106964886188507,
-0.3834438920021057,
0.6660845279693604,
-0.0010599008528515697,
-1.095768928527832,
0.6417766213417053,
-0.34734025597572327,
0.2784842848777771,
0.3897147476673126,
0.36283430457115173,
-1.148680329322815,
-0.5034029483795166,
-0.5440041422843933,
-0.9732184410095215,
0.2476327121257782,
-0.27239030599594116,
0.4884214699268341,
-0.5082196593284607,
0.09969304502010345,
-0.1998312771320343,
0.0036710400599986315,
-0.9084749817848206,
0.13870233297348022,
0.05921874940395355,
0.10025063902139664,
0.06167182698845863,
-0.538491427898407,
0.15962766110897064,
-0.11183362454175949,
0.7153072357177734,
0.15737053751945496,
0.05788891762495041,
0.2405013144016266,
0.01763983443379402,
-0.11816569417715073,
0.6065994501113892,
0.27888283133506775,
0.6098440885543823,
-0.1580161452293396,
0.2988947331905365,
0.006832786835730076,
-0.3506471812725067,
0.05491475388407707,
-0.26892921328544617,
-0.393417626619339,
-0.2323310226202011,
0.06269056349992752,
0.3311174213886261,
0.46215516328811646,
-0.4274192154407501,
0.5430678725242615,
0.1969481110572815,
0.004257237538695335,
-0.7320910692214966,
-0.06016559526324272,
0.45792561769485474,
0.24777334928512573,
0.21960531175136566,
0.1705264449119568,
0.04573516175150871,
-0.6722287535667419,
-0.06442873179912567,
0.754497766494751,
-0.9106391668319702,
-0.430780827999115,
0.507505476474762,
0.5993919968605042,
-0.5808694362640381,
0.04225466772913933,
-0.1711525321006775,
-0.6705448031425476,
0.47495052218437195,
0.4688061475753784,
1.0508050918579102,
-0.28109872341156006,
0.3442517817020416,
0.10694584995508194,
0.8294055461883545,
-0.12733763456344604,
0.4871862232685089,
0.2220436930656433,
-1.0387563705444336,
-0.3337046802043915,
-0.567251443862915,
-0.33869469165802,
-0.4765051007270813,
-0.2727102041244507,
0.3146776854991913,
-0.7557156085968018,
-0.5690056085586548,
-0.0021383503917604685,
-0.13584162294864655,
-0.3774397075176239,
-0.06534948199987411,
0.0637834370136261,
0.8460314869880676,
-1.0237845182418823,
0.6156842708587646,
0.720478355884552,
0.07115448266267776,
-0.32824939489364624,
-0.3583551347255707,
0.08670967817306519,
-0.7163304090499878,
0.5259745121002197,
0.46822282671928406,
-0.4917079210281372,
0.12450218200683594,
-0.6434050798416138,
-0.47630956768989563,
0.7607545256614685,
0.018316583707928658,
-0.3329882323741913,
-0.025752775371074677,
0.07219480723142624,
0.5443647503852844,
-0.2614918351173401,
-0.2761380076408386,
0.2505747377872467,
0.6649162769317627,
-0.3007574677467346,
-0.6208957433700562,
-0.030393417924642563,
-0.2932845950126648,
0.3512778878211975,
0.17566312849521637,
-0.5544428825378418,
0.4673273265361786,
-0.23283988237380981,
-0.5919638276100159,
-0.5633798241615295,
0.5364940166473389,
-0.03430478647351265,
0.4594420790672302,
0.46477237343788147,
0.12194687873125076,
0.6357346773147583,
0.06226718798279762,
1.111997365951538,
-0.11530132591724396,
-0.04816446080803871,
0.672650933265686,
-0.8587422966957092,
0.6004191040992737,
0.3655751645565033,
-0.2252417802810669,
-0.048032376915216446,
0.3156435191631317,
0.5579294562339783,
-0.14190445840358734,
0.17845703661441803,
-0.6630584001541138,
-0.45718902349472046,
-0.6260936260223389,
-0.47939541935920715,
0.21782954037189484,
0.6081499457359314,
-0.1499401479959488,
-0.029475942254066467,
-0.24905261397361755,
0.09410877525806427,
0.5920193791389465,
-0.30705687403678894,
0.684568464756012,
0.3589251935482025,
-0.1166258305311203,
0.14230148494243622,
-0.03767843544483185,
0.9613592624664307,
-0.4880327582359314,
0.18321441113948822,
-0.02900596894323826,
-0.10970322042703629,
-0.20646460354328156,
-0.6042795777320862,
0.6752782464027405,
-0.02420009672641754,
-0.05875794216990471,
-0.28083503246307373,
1.214150071144104,
-0.18623290956020355,
-0.5275233387947083,
0.645810604095459,
0.6501420140266418,
0.19231662154197693,
-0.17758239805698395,
-0.6072857975959778,
0.20558930933475494,
-0.0864790827035904,
-0.025283897295594215,
0.38902366161346436,
0.635515570640564,
-0.013767784461379051,
0.8684784173965454,
0.6806260347366333,
0.05048343166708946,
0.290362685918808,
0.236264169216156,
0.6122593283653259,
-0.6605439782142639,
-0.14919336140155792,
-0.9173572063446045,
0.4887705445289612,
-0.15642577409744263,
-0.19317218661308289,
0.6455205082893372,
0.030483268201351166,
0.48001664876937866,
0.35879647731781006,
1.03249192237854,
-0.10280126333236694,
0.5459665656089783,
-0.08035275340080261,
0.6935932040214539,
-0.44513610005378723,
0.34458526968955994,
-0.7152661085128784,
-0.7746542692184448,
-0.40003305673599243,
0.6876262426376343,
-0.39095550775527954,
0.05689201503992081,
0.37937605381011963,
0.6603018641471863,
0.46907731890678406,
0.25702062249183655,
0.4162655174732208,
0.13769018650054932,
0.3047018349170685,
0.366622656583786,
0.7496230006217957,
-0.1133778914809227,
0.1547788679599762,
-0.26304715871810913,
-0.4588177502155304,
-0.19289462268352509,
-1.0787078142166138,
-0.7891736030578613,
-0.5534695386886597,
-0.37046948075294495,
-0.44825881719589233,
0.22638195753097534,
1.0995564460754395,
0.13837458193302155,
-0.451873779296875,
-0.3469233810901642,
0.06528925150632858,
0.4999048709869385,
0.022063536569476128,
-0.23227158188819885,
-0.1542273312807083,
-0.4754182994365692,
-0.5416487455368042,
0.1666533201932907,
0.9091877341270447,
0.173001229763031,
-0.3224983215332031,
0.23423178493976593,
-0.6763318181037903,
0.0884314626455307,
1.038827896118164,
0.44173887372016907,
-0.44137534499168396,
-0.7774059772491455,
0.28251776099205017,
-0.23721179366111755,
-0.11147472262382507,
0.4553638994693756,
-0.34098201990127563,
0.2756829857826233,
0.38697388768196106,
0.8020324110984802,
-0.0010469505796208978,
-0.4143875241279602,
0.7069287896156311,
-0.5233469009399414,
0.029627544805407524,
0.2720176875591278,
0.37702757120132446,
0.7531532645225525,
-0.36263465881347656,
0.4906347692012787,
0.3346012830734253,
-0.5260246992111206,
-0.921589732170105,
0.5401227474212646,
-0.8511736989021301,
-0.003440488362684846,
1.08821439743042,
0.22262345254421234,
-0.35303905606269836,
-0.6348739266395569,
-0.017237331718206406,
0.344027578830719,
-0.41900935769081116,
0.8426122069358826,
0.7473313808441162,
0.40408167243003845,
-0.233943372964859,
-0.6185398101806641,
0.4148629605770111,
0.5916756987571716,
-0.7303550243377686,
0.47082990407943726,
0.28633177280426025,
0.05955444276332855,
0.35785847902297974,
1.1666494607925415,
-0.5126930475234985,
0.056011397391557693,
-0.155320942401886,
0.3476836383342743,
0.35986918210983276,
-0.3222018778324127,
-0.27404892444610596,
-0.0018534869886934757,
0.4177636504173279,
0.5299257040023804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02287v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02287v1
|
Vibe-Eval: A hard evaluation suite for measuring progress of multimodal language models
| 2024-05-03T17:59:55 | 2024-05-03T17:59:55 |
Piotr Padlewski, Max Bain, Matthew Henderson, Zhongkai Zhu, Nishant Relan, Hai Pham, Donovan Ong, Kaloyan Aleksiev, Aitor Ormazabal, Samuel Phua, Ethan Yeo, Eugenie Lamprecht, Qi Liu, Yuqi Wang, Eric Chen, Deyu Fu, Lei Li, Che Zheng, Cyprien de Masson d'Autume, Dani Yogatama, Mikel Artetxe, Yi Tay
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
We introduce Vibe-Eval: a new open benchmark and framework for evaluating
multimodal chat models. Vibe-Eval consists of 269 visual understanding prompts,
including 100 of hard difficulty, complete with gold-standard responses
authored by experts. Vibe-Eval is open-ended and challenging with dual
objectives: (i) vibe checking multimodal chat models for day-to-day tasks and
(ii) rigorously testing and probing the capabilities of present frontier
models. Notably, our hard set contains >50% questions that all frontier models
answer incorrectly. We explore the nuances of designing, evaluating, and
ranking models on ultra challenging prompts. We also discuss trade-offs between
human and automatic evaluation, and show that automatic model evaluation using
Reka Core roughly correlates to human judgment. We offer free API access for
the purpose of lightweight evaluation and plan to conduct formal human
evaluations for public models that perform well on the Vibe-Eval's automatic
scores. We release the evaluation code and data, see
https://github.com/reka-ai/reka-vibe-eval
|
[
-0.28203004598617554,
-1.03005850315094,
0.5679866671562195,
0.4867457151412964,
0.0319691076874733,
0.3174262046813965,
-0.4303489327430725,
-0.31550705432891846,
0.07916820049285889,
0.32852062582969666,
-0.9341340661048889,
-0.5183321833610535,
-0.08434689790010452,
-0.13253141939640045,
-0.5394322276115417,
0.780942976474762,
0.14797872304916382,
0.09329927712678909,
-0.3798777759075165,
-0.06802044808864594,
-0.6511557698249817,
-0.2620159983634949,
-0.289623498916626,
-0.1841827780008316,
0.3812960386276245,
0.29435575008392334,
0.8287485837936401,
0.00018029414059128612,
0.6550774574279785,
0.3258732259273529,
-0.22343860566616058,
-0.1571274697780609,
-0.6109528541564941,
0.38156354427337646,
-0.1527603715658188,
-0.5754764080047607,
-0.7003304362297058,
0.03751349076628685,
0.5470397472381592,
0.6363544464111328,
-0.23983560502529144,
0.3606085479259491,
-0.05943763256072998,
0.8575347065925598,
-0.7184857726097107,
0.06441079080104828,
-0.45302367210388184,
0.011986122466623783,
-0.14354874193668365,
0.06253918260335922,
-0.461158812046051,
-0.40975549817085266,
0.1626308560371399,
-0.30953529477119446,
-0.23730483651161194,
0.19010624289512634,
0.7752870321273804,
0.10713203251361847,
-0.6749504804611206,
-0.023955481126904488,
-0.6123136281967163,
0.8723954558372498,
-0.26144662499427795,
0.9887474775314331,
0.12400293350219727,
0.5629510879516602,
-0.2818939983844757,
-0.6422008275985718,
-0.5169442296028137,
-0.5454028844833374,
0.4506850242614746,
0.251260906457901,
-0.556106448173523,
-0.032959017902612686,
0.01741449162364006,
0.614070475101471,
-0.3947330713272095,
-0.28734850883483887,
-0.3713178038597107,
-0.3836597204208374,
0.46171754598617554,
0.45189207792282104,
0.3342186212539673,
-0.3358921408653259,
-0.30063357949256897,
-0.30327996611595154,
-0.3742671608924866,
0.32286784052848816,
0.43181824684143066,
0.3282739520072937,
-0.393314927816391,
0.5638856291770935,
-0.3336024284362793,
0.5715556144714355,
0.020157424733042717,
0.012695698998868465,
0.5936510562896729,
-0.6521562337875366,
-0.044305071234703064,
-0.6677746772766113,
1.1357768774032593,
0.48513734340667725,
-0.16277271509170532,
-0.04726564139127731,
-0.39101895689964294,
0.039872538298368454,
0.48061493039131165,
-0.5998666286468506,
-0.100162573158741,
0.30310770869255066,
-0.6003297567367554,
-0.5052089691162109,
-0.347385436296463,
-1.0476062297821045,
-0.3177456259727478,
-0.4346744120121002,
0.5126852989196777,
-0.534082293510437,
-0.4625449776649475,
0.07519084215164185,
-0.10261718183755875,
0.34760987758636475,
0.7059364914894104,
-0.3470449149608612,
0.04593354091048241,
0.8140890002250671,
1.0301491022109985,
-0.046130064874887466,
-0.28810280561447144,
-0.38414672017097473,
-0.9534918665885925,
-0.5221924781799316,
0.8040993809700012,
-0.6733694076538086,
-0.47723254561424255,
-0.14950352907180786,
-0.13958796858787537,
0.08812899887561798,
-0.10784606635570526,
0.8624228835105896,
-0.3034944534301758,
0.21692751348018646,
-0.2756977379322052,
-0.5043079853057861,
-0.12186978757381439,
0.33018431067466736,
-0.41857579350471497,
1.0559959411621094,
0.3489393889904022,
-0.5518320798873901,
0.2495902180671692,
-0.829547643661499,
-0.015211849473416805,
-0.04475842043757439,
0.03788670897483826,
-0.03030385449528694,
0.400860071182251,
0.06938979029655457,
0.15852704644203186,
-0.5169486403465271,
0.22257372736930847,
-0.5952075719833374,
-0.17356696724891663,
0.5953299403190613,
-0.5434732437133789,
0.6927761435508728,
0.5071587562561035,
-0.06252528727054596,
0.6079795956611633,
-0.71769779920578,
0.4409370720386505,
-0.1813099980354309,
-0.1660180538892746,
-0.1129864826798439,
-0.2862413227558136,
0.4330504536628723,
0.3630695641040802,
0.3198714852333069,
-0.4683174788951874,
0.2285093367099762,
-0.018837053328752518,
0.2480037361383438,
0.8351266980171204,
-0.3008216619491577,
0.11215725541114807,
-0.21324366331100464,
0.8556566834449768,
-0.07995755225419998,
0.3823128640651703,
-0.45458415150642395,
-0.47029316425323486,
-0.6866138577461243,
-0.2803247570991516,
0.38070791959762573,
0.40919700264930725,
-0.7535276412963867,
0.40405839681625366,
-0.2250390499830246,
-1.094638705253601,
-0.8695024251937866,
0.008955756202340126,
0.6569669842720032,
0.27836018800735474,
0.061899010092020035,
-0.41745737195014954,
-0.28736022114753723,
-1.0459810495376587,
-0.4040553569793701,
-0.314773291349411,
-0.08701197803020477,
0.45273473858833313,
0.5778026580810547,
-0.3673691749572754,
1.0435250997543335,
-0.3977769613265991,
0.1554374396800995,
-0.29035961627960205,
0.3639447093009949,
0.1028170958161354,
0.2531624436378479,
0.570121169090271,
-0.7158902287483215,
-0.2429153472185135,
-0.2159348726272583,
-0.6464983820915222,
-0.18761314451694489,
0.18593892455101013,
-0.318089097738266,
-0.26868635416030884,
0.23689591884613037,
-0.3949334919452667,
0.17402738332748413,
0.6913517713546753,
-0.796653151512146,
0.8725719451904297,
0.05721418932080269,
0.7151127457618713,
-0.7717542052268982,
0.006764745339751244,
0.16330274939537048,
-0.45089566707611084,
-0.7221192717552185,
0.2726019024848938,
0.30165332555770874,
-0.519101083278656,
-0.7680142521858215,
0.621157169342041,
-0.11779195815324783,
-0.040037550032138824,
-0.1353902965784073,
0.0929352194070816,
0.11907366663217545,
0.5924046039581299,
-0.1842351257801056,
0.8018016219139099,
0.8074577450752258,
-0.45729970932006836,
0.5215960144996643,
0.03217625990509987,
-0.5176044702529907,
0.9231454133987427,
-0.6234708428382874,
0.5146825909614563,
0.0074045248329639435,
0.2635026276111603,
-1.0543478727340698,
-0.23799572885036469,
0.08991661667823792,
-0.3647899925708771,
-0.031610600650310516,
-0.1772538423538208,
-0.1924455314874649,
-0.49111470580101013,
-0.5167018175125122,
0.26579728722572327,
0.6002659797668457,
-0.4508879482746124,
0.6143268942832947,
0.41888147592544556,
0.1485014259815216,
-0.237158864736557,
-0.3342697024345398,
0.11886945366859436,
-0.21952874958515167,
-0.7773969173431396,
-0.06649862229824066,
-0.19093158841133118,
-0.456061452627182,
-0.24852719902992249,
0.09222417324781418,
-0.2728201448917389,
0.3012048304080963,
0.3836880922317505,
0.23710602521896362,
-0.13200949132442474,
0.1557357907295227,
-0.2966160178184509,
0.11596899479627609,
0.11838927865028381,
-0.07612606883049011,
0.5977237224578857,
-0.9713004231452942,
-0.5296549797058105,
-0.6536316275596619,
0.013680852018296719,
0.9100358486175537,
-0.059801265597343445,
0.2625332772731781,
0.7791466116905212,
-0.21953873336315155,
0.4506349563598633,
-0.6786071062088013,
-0.0004640503029804677,
-0.4584956467151642,
0.47685182094573975,
-0.5808404684066772,
-0.677973747253418,
0.574869692325592,
0.006155399139970541,
0.17522284388542175,
0.40801799297332764,
0.8291807174682617,
0.1487601101398468,
0.9470933675765991,
0.7816864848136902,
0.09856534749269485,
0.5087956190109253,
0.22852005064487457,
-0.016387438401579857,
-0.9399913549423218,
-0.20054881274700165,
-0.45036643743515015,
-0.20004266500473022,
-0.49678337574005127,
-0.5480778217315674,
0.3678237795829773,
0.14215360581874847,
0.10938132554292679,
0.35167235136032104,
-0.2749834656715393,
0.3471536636352539,
0.39642736315727234,
0.2028796523809433,
0.2773701548576355,
-0.5207111835479736,
-0.09444693475961685,
-0.2306617945432663,
-0.20979927480220795,
-0.534400224685669,
1.3554391860961914,
0.6546589136123657,
1.040663719177246,
0.20618048310279846,
0.425592839717865,
0.3772505223751068,
0.40453460812568665,
-0.9158459901809692,
0.5414493680000305,
0.3077840507030487,
-0.6481156945228577,
-0.09141983836889267,
-0.5168396830558777,
-0.7308708429336548,
0.48227038979530334,
-0.25479334592819214,
-0.996602475643158,
-0.015194060280919075,
0.2806808352470398,
-0.38404908776283264,
0.1684456169605255,
-0.7955089807510376,
0.9929419755935669,
-0.3730069398880005,
-0.442275732755661,
-0.36448243260383606,
-0.34463733434677124,
0.6841728091239929,
0.00821883138269186,
0.39204859733581543,
-0.35683849453926086,
0.12045980244874954,
0.7993718385696411,
-0.2716847062110901,
0.6139728426933289,
-0.10445783287286758,
-0.22357606887817383,
0.4776136875152588,
0.26820969581604004,
0.06878478080034256,
-0.02255912497639656,
0.050486475229263306,
0.3793238699436188,
0.1602059155702591,
-0.17900942265987396,
-0.7846015691757202,
0.5178852677345276,
-0.6406484842300415,
-0.20696356892585754,
-0.20113471150398254,
-0.24043259024620056,
-0.3168098032474518,
0.033003129065036774,
0.0916958749294281,
0.7534860968589783,
-0.5670126676559448,
0.3814014792442322,
0.20206305384635925,
-0.3763686716556549,
-0.01867525465786457,
0.5657405853271484,
-0.9702111482620239,
-0.37610992789268494,
0.9265533685684204,
-0.44259265065193176,
0.284940630197525,
0.2455892413854599,
0.4291365146636963,
-0.38356098532676697,
-0.04130140319466591,
-0.4965064227581024,
-0.2989071309566498,
-0.7657538652420044,
0.013696743175387383,
-0.8000139594078064,
0.19815686345100403,
-0.2769899070262909,
0.12857136130332947,
-1.060677170753479,
-0.31666386127471924,
0.21809615194797516,
0.3235895335674286,
0.33772704005241394,
0.7560412287712097,
-0.07089459896087646,
0.007815211080014706,
-0.7150325775146484,
0.15800967812538147,
0.21374669671058655,
0.45252540707588196,
-0.0441267304122448,
-0.4109494984149933,
-0.06989876925945282,
0.2377554476261139,
-0.6576135754585266,
-0.9136319756507874,
0.23963940143585205,
-0.021155551075935364,
0.16092100739479065,
0.3509211540222168,
-0.04535920172929764,
0.7019463777542114,
-0.5218066573143005,
0.9410557150840759,
0.49375295639038086,
-1.2768278121948242,
0.5721231698989868,
-0.4880102276802063,
0.3419983685016632,
0.7058225870132446,
0.01965252123773098,
-0.8920366764068604,
-0.5384644865989685,
-0.6631983518600464,
-0.6711675524711609,
0.47111794352531433,
0.45002004504203796,
0.10635276138782501,
-0.046941179782152176,
0.16007685661315918,
0.11355678737163544,
0.46531739830970764,
-0.619484007358551,
-0.22069184482097626,
-0.36658331751823425,
-0.023316701874136925,
0.19337980449199677,
-0.2699316143989563,
0.1577148139476776,
-0.2237464040517807,
0.3378755748271942,
-0.17670679092407227,
0.44497033953666687,
0.013409513980150223,
-0.16447576880455017,
-0.11283300817012787,
0.7379950284957886,
0.506317675113678,
0.7870127558708191,
-0.3656081557273865,
-0.18203654885292053,
0.1545923501253128,
-0.3489267826080322,
0.08796555548906326,
-0.38124778866767883,
0.155613973736763,
-0.07632483541965485,
0.29424387216567993,
0.9817869663238525,
0.5796765089035034,
-0.9468017220497131,
0.6876081824302673,
-0.5830471515655518,
-0.01727396994829178,
-0.20290783047676086,
0.03479103744029999,
-0.1524905115365982,
0.26331478357315063,
0.31519612669944763,
0.06173301115632057,
0.3457266688346863,
-0.8298017978668213,
0.16655263304710388,
0.4572224020957947,
-0.7280210256576538,
-0.7532961964607239,
0.5312582850456238,
0.46943143010139465,
-0.4284246861934662,
0.5406217575073242,
-0.40412184596061707,
-0.6371644139289856,
0.41566362977027893,
0.17185306549072266,
1.0817259550094604,
-0.04372018203139305,
0.1636953502893448,
0.28919076919555664,
0.14680452644824982,
0.016824685037136078,
0.49989622831344604,
-0.023250078782439232,
-0.5363302826881409,
-0.37011459469795227,
-0.6158565282821655,
-0.9214214086532593,
0.08573795109987259,
-0.851220428943634,
0.5542698502540588,
-0.2424083948135376,
-0.4043019413948059,
0.059928134083747864,
-0.219569131731987,
-1.0658587217330933,
-0.11822041869163513,
0.016530511900782585,
0.9005834460258484,
-0.7573766112327576,
0.32322752475738525,
0.7834401726722717,
-0.17572003602981567,
-0.5620046854019165,
-0.03218026086688042,
0.46966004371643066,
-0.551740288734436,
0.749138355255127,
0.29435691237449646,
-0.24017678201198578,
-0.3957233428955078,
-0.5264396071434021,
-0.763664186000824,
0.6960326433181763,
0.39202913641929626,
-0.7092565298080444,
0.1731354296207428,
-0.5085777044296265,
0.7259200215339661,
-0.17343853414058685,
1.0664860010147095,
0.5386866927146912,
0.525172770023346,
-0.02840632200241089,
-1.329217791557312,
-0.2438933253288269,
-0.4835069477558136,
-0.17350086569786072,
0.1355924904346466,
-0.8488409519195557,
0.9922692179679871,
-0.170169860124588,
-0.24472665786743164,
0.07884911447763443,
0.7613120079040527,
0.050401076674461365,
0.2640674412250519,
0.9254679679870605,
0.38023117184638977,
0.8466091156005859,
-0.27051568031311035,
1.2428058385849,
-0.4157715439796448,
0.5490724444389343,
0.8398802876472473,
-0.21276624500751495,
0.824629545211792,
0.24729220569133759,
-0.47343236207962036,
0.5502169728279114,
0.5653821229934692,
0.3022756576538086,
0.3203088045120239,
0.14890281856060028,
0.08640974014997482,
-0.4790884256362915,
-0.20091302692890167,
-0.21412254869937897,
0.7820106744766235,
0.2266395092010498,
0.30143725872039795,
-0.30474159121513367,
0.11900708824396133,
-0.18013013899326324,
-0.1521274298429489,
-0.1736883521080017,
0.6034224629402161,
0.013507340103387833,
-0.6969918608665466,
0.3361910879611969,
0.015226416289806366,
0.779985249042511,
-0.45759978890419006,
0.22656123340129852,
-0.11332474648952484,
0.1860211044549942,
0.06946192681789398,
-0.8551601767539978,
0.1779250204563141,
0.14425671100616455,
0.03836476057767868,
-0.16159237921237946,
0.6933032274246216,
-0.3294869363307953,
-0.5811646580696106,
0.18498916923999786,
0.7842870354652405,
0.3598009943962097,
-0.16705317795276642,
-1.0225894451141357,
0.2199750542640686,
-0.08076991140842438,
-0.516848623752594,
0.20280827581882477,
0.4653654098510742,
0.04477645829319954,
1.1260799169540405,
0.7822579741477966,
-0.36973121762275696,
-0.19353055953979492,
0.21101050078868866,
0.80840665102005,
-0.8860037326812744,
-0.7430835962295532,
-0.9431876540184021,
0.48916834592819214,
0.1435963213443756,
-0.5925168395042419,
0.746152937412262,
0.38663631677627563,
0.21563583612442017,
0.07807166874408722,
0.5306529998779297,
-0.11136284470558167,
0.4239130914211273,
-0.508777916431427,
0.5174834132194519,
-0.7689814567565918,
-0.005666637793183327,
-0.6630797386169434,
-0.7860117554664612,
0.2072632908821106,
0.5583813190460205,
-0.06527894735336304,
0.1283150315284729,
0.6590676307678223,
0.6248148083686829,
-0.016822582110762596,
0.31367266178131104,
0.37790441513061523,
0.03374888002872467,
0.45651113986968994,
0.5741438865661621,
1.409237027168274,
-0.27629226446151733,
0.45260608196258545,
-0.4101267158985138,
-0.37739014625549316,
-0.2577718198299408,
-1.0086253881454468,
-1.007266640663147,
-0.6978668570518494,
-0.5335969924926758,
-0.5158335566520691,
-0.08451606333255768,
1.3121262788772583,
0.7693877816200256,
-0.49261581897735596,
-0.22256161272525787,
0.05604402720928192,
0.2690871059894562,
-0.2131616175174713,
-0.3291109502315521,
0.11648138612508774,
-0.49439942836761475,
-0.7276822924613953,
0.6885064244270325,
0.3954665958881378,
-0.10582408308982849,
-0.7025271058082581,
0.07675192505121231,
0.15796057879924774,
-0.071783147752285,
0.5452989339828491,
0.0797281488776207,
-0.7672160267829895,
-0.34557467699050903,
0.1386597454547882,
-0.0877610519528389,
0.0569881796836853,
0.8881720900535583,
-0.7546906471252441,
0.6112710237503052,
0.43091732263565063,
0.34415802359580994,
0.10758258402347565,
-0.07952363044023514,
0.7739427089691162,
-0.6614405512809753,
0.10146453231573105,
0.021812748163938522,
0.5062664151191711,
0.3557952046394348,
-0.08551567047834396,
0.4621352255344391,
-0.04685060307383537,
-0.44892093539237976,
-1.050101399421692,
0.20083202421665192,
-0.8223894238471985,
-0.010437983088195324,
1.0674318075180054,
-0.08379048109054565,
-0.4859301745891571,
0.029944689944386482,
-0.16909275949001312,
-0.19208885729312897,
-0.7016393542289734,
0.6692759394645691,
0.8784664273262024,
-0.032160110771656036,
-0.08347933739423752,
-0.6942446231842041,
0.3264745771884918,
0.42748191952705383,
-0.7654779553413391,
0.2192368507385254,
0.48556211590766907,
0.1993066817522049,
0.42210498452186584,
0.7394160628318787,
-0.12765733897686005,
0.4088510274887085,
-0.0744888186454773,
0.2676394581794739,
0.1335844248533249,
-0.3631136119365692,
-0.5326942801475525,
-0.04971402883529663,
-0.022388752549886703,
-0.004060416482388973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02267v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02267v1
|
Structural Pruning of Pre-trained Language Models via Neural Architecture Search
| 2024-05-03T17:34:57 | 2024-05-03T17:34:57 |
Aaron Klein, Jacek Golebiowski, Xingchen Ma, Valerio Perrone, Cedric Archambeau
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Pre-trained language models (PLM), for example BERT or RoBERTa, mark the
state-of-the-art for natural language understanding task when fine-tuned on
labeled data. However, their large size poses challenges in deploying them for
inference in real-world applications, due to significant GPU memory
requirements and high inference latency. This paper explores neural
architecture search (NAS) for structural pruning to find sub-parts of the
fine-tuned network that optimally trade-off efficiency, for example in terms of
model size or latency, and generalization performance. We also show how we can
utilize more recently developed two-stage weight-sharing NAS approaches in this
setting to accelerate the search process. Unlike traditional pruning methods
with fixed thresholds, we propose to adopt a multi-objective approach that
identifies the Pareto optimal set of sub-networks, allowing for a more flexible
and automated compression process.
|
[
-0.591910183429718,
-0.7039088010787964,
0.5168665647506714,
0.3371991813182831,
-0.46863362193107605,
-0.16085930168628693,
-0.3515673279762268,
-0.21457378566265106,
0.26430726051330566,
0.12342517077922821,
-0.5528361797332764,
-0.3750509023666382,
-0.47760069370269775,
-0.1364177167415619,
-0.14088153839111328,
0.5071956515312195,
0.04189993813633919,
-0.10285986959934235,
0.04629664495587349,
-0.0917472094297409,
-0.5614824295043945,
-0.5634559392929077,
-0.6857933402061462,
-0.3076017200946808,
0.5764533281326294,
0.15042246878147125,
0.7499588131904602,
0.8218536972999573,
0.3603312373161316,
0.3042415976524353,
-0.4556221663951874,
0.2460959255695343,
-0.2220078408718109,
0.054195575416088104,
-0.07678324729204178,
-0.42606812715530396,
-0.4485175907611847,
-0.0812649056315422,
0.7491394877433777,
0.8027259707450867,
-0.14257875084877014,
0.2534310221672058,
-0.09468844532966614,
0.670078694820404,
-0.5646630525588989,
0.35073310136795044,
-0.5628089904785156,
0.22123660147190094,
-0.2950468063354492,
-0.17261245846748352,
-0.33892038464546204,
-0.1675315648317337,
0.2544763684272766,
-0.613290011882782,
0.31258854269981384,
0.0530247800052166,
1.0461281538009644,
0.3783717155456543,
-0.08858995139598846,
-0.005464103538542986,
-0.39902785420417786,
0.7803972959518433,
-0.6842139363288879,
0.43510881066322327,
0.4227447211742401,
0.09041427075862885,
-0.134828582406044,
-0.6478320360183716,
-0.1430305391550064,
-0.2513841986656189,
-0.09303829073905945,
-0.192061185836792,
-0.13566730916500092,
0.48417767882347107,
-0.20399993658065796,
0.4548119604587555,
-0.7939459085464478,
0.12950485944747925,
-0.5461380481719971,
-0.2659659683704376,
0.3727869689464569,
-0.3334507942199707,
0.43106305599212646,
-0.08663906902074814,
-0.24881930649280548,
-0.20034655928611755,
-0.7067343592643738,
-0.15845422446727753,
0.5082683563232422,
0.40116068720817566,
0.32687675952911377,
0.3797582983970642,
-0.0007381578907370567,
0.9417368769645691,
-0.33779218792915344,
0.2744463384151459,
0.1436372548341751,
-0.6405032873153687,
-0.3115684390068054,
-0.01670599728822708,
0.5089581608772278,
-0.2075026035308838,
0.520027220249176,
-0.19036737084388733,
-0.23959295451641083,
0.09597305953502655,
0.49879220128059387,
-0.6397042870521545,
-0.4561232030391693,
-0.03577172011137009,
-0.7878816723823547,
0.005753078497946262,
-0.24662142992019653,
-0.3576139211654663,
0.3260095417499542,
-0.40035340189933777,
0.32465341687202454,
-0.442018985748291,
-0.2401302605867386,
0.32425740361213684,
-0.20372000336647034,
-0.03115379996597767,
-0.05837360396981239,
-0.6233574151992798,
0.34096965193748474,
0.6367917656898499,
1.0749645233154297,
0.13971884548664093,
-0.08990752696990967,
-0.5755147933959961,
-0.16081050038337708,
-0.48871931433677673,
0.4523565471172333,
-0.4903809726238251,
-0.03763740882277489,
-0.319295197725296,
-0.3023908734321594,
-0.2870636582374573,
-0.46475642919540405,
0.5621913075447083,
-0.7384905815124512,
-0.17874206602573395,
-0.016689375042915344,
-0.29718217253685,
-0.2805870473384857,
0.3538025915622711,
-0.7988661527633667,
0.8498694896697998,
0.000699851952958852,
-0.5224855542182922,
0.1897459626197815,
-0.5455077886581421,
-0.6975862979888916,
0.032287295907735825,
-0.10919128358364105,
-0.5413364768028259,
0.5385645031929016,
0.3881194591522217,
0.5070979595184326,
-0.29447221755981445,
0.7210140824317932,
-0.11906583607196808,
-0.5028678178787231,
-0.3695104122161865,
-0.21479526162147522,
0.5700074434280396,
0.2927129864692688,
-0.17627134919166565,
0.2698183059692383,
-0.5664832592010498,
-0.03615816682577133,
0.15462346374988556,
-0.5121775269508362,
-0.6257684230804443,
0.21048928797245026,
-0.22098322212696075,
0.09658132493495941,
0.29644668102264404,
-0.3197645843029022,
0.13271838426589966,
-0.7438336610794067,
0.5959718823432922,
0.7150423526763916,
-0.23897820711135864,
0.6556680202484131,
-0.29203879833221436,
0.5251958966255188,
-0.039682649075984955,
0.2750033438205719,
0.08957915753126144,
-0.281493216753006,
-0.7170372009277344,
-0.10479239374399185,
0.4803023934364319,
0.15564730763435364,
-0.5984596610069275,
0.46814095973968506,
-0.24378827214241028,
-0.36235371232032776,
-0.6441806554794312,
0.19538529217243195,
0.5785788297653198,
0.2696239650249481,
0.5794554352760315,
-0.45599520206451416,
-0.6868268251419067,
-1.2485237121582031,
-0.10812661051750183,
-0.09127664566040039,
-0.05854657664895058,
0.4726930260658264,
0.22003814578056335,
0.18766434490680695,
0.8430126905441284,
-0.46914103627204895,
-0.42668241262435913,
-0.454715758562088,
0.35015392303466797,
0.4065338373184204,
0.5219786763191223,
0.4924067556858063,
-1.1513601541519165,
-0.28504201769828796,
-0.14714428782463074,
-0.16282308101654053,
-0.013157923705875874,
-0.20450662076473236,
0.11644317954778671,
-0.3439689576625824,
0.42141619324684143,
-0.47181233763694763,
0.2122320979833603,
0.7049083709716797,
0.15909196436405182,
0.45896145701408386,
-0.3971669375896454,
-0.4003327488899231,
-0.8277530670166016,
0.06875988841056824,
0.15849550068378448,
0.01754615269601345,
-0.5104920864105225,
0.18386304378509521,
0.014002355746924877,
-0.09453433752059937,
-0.3152713179588318,
0.4470669627189636,
-1.0422083139419556,
-0.47861459851264954,
-0.04360983148217201,
0.0026477952487766743,
0.13401271402835846,
0.8770706057548523,
0.21896035969257355,
0.9706909656524658,
0.4817884564399719,
-0.822343647480011,
-0.14441664516925812,
0.11904378980398178,
-0.6237665414810181,
-0.2278079092502594,
-0.7390255331993103,
0.02430710382759571,
-0.36350905895233154,
0.25266313552856445,
-0.7048973441123962,
0.14199399948120117,
0.0844615027308464,
-0.2893997132778168,
0.2517955005168915,
-0.37239915132522583,
-0.3194291293621063,
-0.13968203961849213,
-0.23892883956432343,
0.6133289933204651,
0.09900243580341339,
-0.36111170053482056,
0.6203165650367737,
0.46859222650527954,
-0.23728671669960022,
-0.5725948810577393,
-0.6992145776748657,
0.07653103768825531,
-0.010358690284192562,
-0.7048420906066895,
0.7096503973007202,
0.005669505335390568,
-0.017017263919115067,
0.03114311397075653,
-0.4392942190170288,
-0.2848793864250183,
0.35942673683166504,
0.04920746758580208,
-0.019030513241887093,
-0.5145467519760132,
0.15843023359775543,
0.11954299360513687,
-0.04032373055815697,
-0.10804882645606995,
-0.37462887167930603,
0.9471507668495178,
-0.30429670214653015,
-0.21412540972232819,
-0.4032860994338989,
0.21474091708660126,
0.3008575141429901,
-0.639000415802002,
0.7789199352264404,
0.34510913491249084,
-0.2649485170841217,
-0.3965372145175934,
-0.38940250873565674,
-0.12288901209831238,
-0.44093087315559387,
0.5871022939682007,
-0.559044599533081,
-0.7873127460479736,
0.3102917969226837,
-0.1427135169506073,
0.053128089755773544,
0.27230948209762573,
0.32761308550834656,
0.27565738558769226,
0.991513192653656,
0.48265886306762695,
-0.08228450268507004,
0.708051860332489,
-0.4079305827617645,
0.31492990255355835,
-0.9311015605926514,
-0.04573676735162735,
-0.6402802467346191,
-0.6827854514122009,
-0.13527382910251617,
-0.583554208278656,
0.24582579731941223,
0.11216458678245544,
0.03130370005965233,
0.6284124851226807,
-0.6037634611129761,
0.5179814696311951,
0.7724570035934448,
0.10440190136432648,
0.16328810155391693,
-0.067843496799469,
-0.16347968578338623,
0.13925719261169434,
-0.9293913245201111,
-0.13703183829784393,
0.6695550680160522,
0.4104982316493988,
0.279969722032547,
-0.058423303067684174,
0.48226749897003174,
-0.04539009556174278,
0.17485931515693665,
-0.8385470509529114,
0.5418761372566223,
-0.4792589843273163,
-0.697864830493927,
-0.38838377594947815,
-0.7243024706840515,
-0.8791490793228149,
0.4094950258731842,
0.18009252846240997,
-0.4806324541568756,
0.4978013336658478,
0.2299976944923401,
-0.415569931268692,
0.27110931277275085,
-0.6598260402679443,
0.804527997970581,
-0.3636311888694763,
0.04899955540895462,
-0.302635133266449,
-0.718559205532074,
0.2889363467693329,
0.06434686481952667,
0.09080691635608673,
-0.07079948484897614,
0.10750306397676468,
0.7600107789039612,
-0.23540174961090088,
0.6699808239936829,
-0.22794431447982788,
0.3228816092014313,
-0.00420219823718071,
0.1087794229388237,
0.4225601851940155,
-0.06277943402528763,
-0.32905474305152893,
0.19822274148464203,
-0.3196095824241638,
-0.30086183547973633,
-0.3896091878414154,
0.4023350477218628,
-0.6401753425598145,
-0.40578290820121765,
-0.10057888180017471,
-0.5160031914710999,
-0.18109817802906036,
0.14264489710330963,
0.13189473748207092,
0.45223474502563477,
-0.15918435156345367,
0.6181726455688477,
0.5824602842330933,
-0.2757393717765808,
0.4086131751537323,
0.17308510839939117,
0.23168525099754333,
-0.1327761858701706,
0.8834166526794434,
0.29555365443229675,
0.0033633054699748755,
0.651245653629303,
0.28759142756462097,
-0.19386248290538788,
-1.2269096374511719,
-0.20123150944709778,
0.05012274906039238,
-0.15753571689128876,
-0.3692605793476105,
-0.5421184301376343,
-0.2377164661884308,
-0.23541352152824402,
-0.041569262742996216,
-0.5595000982284546,
-0.15588267147541046,
-0.4076826870441437,
-0.1656414121389389,
-0.14016854763031006,
0.34771454334259033,
-0.07098367065191269,
0.8421386480331421,
-0.746220052242279,
0.2957078218460083,
0.09708650410175323,
0.4354841709136963,
0.15517543256282806,
-0.22965200245380402,
-0.2400440126657486,
-0.011527113616466522,
0.05820169299840927,
-0.7774654030799866,
0.6719405055046082,
0.5645191669464111,
0.5446599721908569,
0.3417588770389557,
-0.030669165775179863,
0.7712268233299255,
-0.36294156312942505,
0.2719632685184479,
0.05927349254488945,
-0.7863656282424927,
0.38636672496795654,
-0.0717027485370636,
0.16771531105041504,
0.7643728852272034,
0.4935087561607361,
-0.31435510516166687,
0.09497623890638351,
-0.47914502024650574,
-1.1141695976257324,
0.8050968647003174,
0.3545054495334625,
-0.08893393725156784,
0.016394447535276413,
0.3947969079017639,
-0.28197553753852844,
0.2417525351047516,
-0.6004181504249573,
-0.04320337623357773,
0.04578394442796707,
-0.19287924468517303,
0.04221579059958458,
-0.24165959656238556,
-0.01507334690541029,
-0.13809610903263092,
0.6523054242134094,
-0.2466457635164261,
-0.0718279480934143,
0.24178285896778107,
-0.4369361698627472,
0.21171008050441742,
0.23110678791999817,
0.2748089134693146,
0.6952699422836304,
-0.19167853891849518,
0.21697194874286652,
-0.13500802218914032,
-0.2685549557209015,
-0.03857193887233734,
0.10894753783941269,
-0.21814702451229095,
0.06596951931715012,
0.22226086258888245,
1.1027060747146606,
0.5148153901100159,
-0.6363571286201477,
0.47224143147468567,
-0.34340518712997437,
-0.301015168428421,
-0.006483807228505611,
-0.0003162331704515964,
0.19311046600341797,
0.22646518051624298,
0.2833269238471985,
0.09330475330352783,
0.15553748607635498,
-0.4348888397216797,
0.29650068283081055,
0.5094262361526489,
-0.09609940648078918,
-0.3980172574520111,
0.3851277828216553,
0.028740227222442627,
-0.4842248260974884,
0.8485540151596069,
-0.0696210041642189,
-0.6880609393119812,
0.7688080072402954,
0.29750269651412964,
0.6597176194190979,
-0.06252692639827728,
0.3429417014122009,
0.13772521913051605,
0.44868016242980957,
-0.34223583340644836,
0.11520932614803314,
-0.4001410901546478,
-0.8795509934425354,
-0.8557817339897156,
-1.0691120624542236,
-0.07911843806505203,
0.21322278678417206,
-0.6127540469169617,
-0.13322284817695618,
-0.5741063356399536,
-0.1297300010919571,
-0.0818440318107605,
0.2011128067970276,
-0.5331955552101135,
0.17750704288482666,
-0.009550297632813454,
1.062845230102539,
-0.6619259119033813,
0.9187508225440979,
0.5724729299545288,
-0.37660834193229675,
-0.9665468335151672,
-0.286031037569046,
-0.25047606229782104,
-0.7611850500106812,
0.7121468782424927,
0.1833035796880722,
0.1275200992822647,
0.04170843958854675,
-0.20222046971321106,
-0.8405414819717407,
0.7137874960899353,
0.6183633804321289,
-0.7500661015510559,
-0.7466205358505249,
-0.2524615526199341,
0.4971957206726074,
-0.2162371575832367,
0.022916186600923538,
0.4766973853111267,
0.5548956990242004,
0.0061531951650977135,
-0.8321541547775269,
-0.18820907175540924,
-0.40466374158859253,
0.2005685716867447,
0.4209407567977905,
-0.5177765488624573,
1.0972132682800293,
0.27236127853393555,
-0.24858684837818146,
-0.08843155205249786,
0.6858838796615601,
0.23054322600364685,
0.06263867020606995,
0.8760266304016113,
0.6527066826820374,
0.48711249232292175,
0.11434782296419144,
0.7681449055671692,
-0.3459799289703369,
0.24094098806381226,
1.2001210451126099,
0.01876704953610897,
0.7729308605194092,
0.44149911403656006,
-0.007272887043654919,
0.20495983958244324,
0.8909177184104919,
0.13055402040481567,
0.4296186864376068,
0.4399290382862091,
0.03891654685139656,
-0.44059181213378906,
-0.07478081434965134,
-0.12938454747200012,
0.3512577414512634,
0.3154834508895874,
-0.35187095403671265,
-0.2955508232116699,
-0.26018136739730835,
-0.10210299491882324,
-0.102763831615448,
-0.12710162997245789,
0.7054464817047119,
0.15606044232845306,
-0.7453440427780151,
0.27186354994773865,
0.15391972661018372,
0.7171882390975952,
-0.7824179530143738,
0.06409825384616852,
-0.30727678537368774,
0.0611678883433342,
0.07653473317623138,
-0.31225770711898804,
0.6414137482643127,
-0.41237300634384155,
-0.13116222620010376,
-0.7111654877662659,
0.7844436168670654,
-0.31880462169647217,
-0.17841891944408417,
0.641269862651825,
0.5063127875328064,
0.13886547088623047,
-0.51651531457901,
-0.6475358009338379,
0.1467280387878418,
-0.03900584205985069,
-0.6198042631149292,
0.5174529552459717,
0.09691209346055984,
-0.03209696337580681,
0.47786054015159607,
0.7810983657836914,
0.4914391040802002,
0.21382573246955872,
0.014295943081378937,
0.9119253158569336,
-0.2638096809387207,
-0.5847638845443726,
-0.6552019119262695,
0.08155520260334015,
-0.05311984196305275,
-0.31596922874450684,
0.3180135488510132,
0.5783796906471252,
0.8958300352096558,
0.12364260852336884,
0.24372956156730652,
0.0662672370672226,
0.16670681536197662,
-0.52409428358078,
0.7085645794868469,
-0.7841804027557373,
0.2028513252735138,
0.1135200709104538,
-0.9784247279167175,
-0.2921735942363739,
0.8573049306869507,
-0.2931494414806366,
-0.19412609934806824,
0.42225217819213867,
0.8560213446617126,
-0.33662158250808716,
-0.09546046704053879,
0.16477054357528687,
0.23371821641921997,
0.18249480426311493,
0.5232279896736145,
0.19990502297878265,
-0.14542156457901,
0.7164796590805054,
-0.18498948216438293,
-0.0723375678062439,
-0.11166238784790039,
-0.7739264965057373,
-0.5572039484977722,
-0.6618059277534485,
-0.03258838132023811,
0.27689221501350403,
0.22995132207870483,
0.7421017289161682,
1.150071620941162,
-0.5482669472694397,
-0.056728705763816833,
-0.4988272786140442,
0.20535729825496674,
-0.20344685018062592,
-0.16108421981334686,
0.45621028542518616,
-0.3431040942668915,
-0.6143659353256226,
1.056114673614502,
0.34116390347480774,
-0.32674044370651245,
-0.2648178040981293,
-0.010871633887290955,
-0.7480260133743286,
-0.026488812640309334,
0.32181307673454285,
0.3473569452762604,
-0.32181739807128906,
-0.03477192670106888,
-0.07325857877731323,
0.27678927779197693,
0.10109616070985794,
1.008172869682312,
-0.7264003753662109,
0.1420438140630722,
0.7943381667137146,
1.050812840461731,
0.6060506701469421,
0.1365547478199005,
0.9070916771888733,
-1.2416185140609741,
0.2821398079395294,
0.5399755239486694,
0.5276318192481995,
0.10751811414957047,
-0.1557534635066986,
0.542081356048584,
0.1018478274345398,
-0.30766987800598145,
-0.8278679847717285,
0.24803201854228973,
-0.6558136940002441,
-0.6921947002410889,
0.7094125151634216,
-0.2176290601491928,
-0.4495827257633209,
-0.09153562039136887,
0.02853916957974434,
0.41193243861198425,
-0.251245379447937,
0.40278908610343933,
0.5675192475318909,
-0.01949787139892578,
-0.19539964199066162,
-0.3206004202365875,
0.39588144421577454,
0.7585427761077881,
-0.6181229948997498,
-0.12940801680088043,
0.31214427947998047,
-0.10251865535974503,
0.3768920600414276,
0.5985196232795715,
0.15956483781337738,
-0.09543970972299576,
-0.28838759660720825,
-0.10015017539262772,
-0.3861713409423828,
-0.9285862445831299,
-0.26645007729530334,
0.6116912364959717,
-0.1401781290769577,
-0.30134832859039307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06671v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06671v2
|
Parameter-Efficient Instruction Tuning of Large Language Models For Extreme Financial Numeral Labelling
| 2024-05-03T16:41:36 | 2024-05-15T14:43:23 |
Subhendu Khatuya, Rajdeep Mukherjee, Akash Ghosh, Manjunath Hegde, Koustuv Dasgupta, Niloy Ganguly, Saptarshi Ghosh, Pawan Goyal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CE, cs.LG
|
We study the problem of automatically annotating relevant numerals (GAAP
metrics) occurring in the financial documents with their corresponding XBRL
tags. Different from prior works, we investigate the feasibility of solving
this extreme classification problem using a generative paradigm through
instruction tuning of Large Language Models (LLMs). To this end, we leverage
metric metadata information to frame our target outputs while proposing a
parameter efficient solution for the task using LoRA. We perform experiments on
two recently released financial numeric labeling datasets. Our proposed model,
FLAN-FinXC, achieves new state-of-the-art performances on both the datasets,
outperforming several strong baselines. We explain the better scores of our
proposed model by demonstrating its capability for zero-shot as well as the
least frequently occurring tags. Also, even when we fail to predict the XBRL
tags correctly, our generated output has substantial overlap with the
ground-truth in majority of the cases.
|
[
-0.35757359862327576,
-0.7932707667350769,
0.18685419857501984,
0.054948266595602036,
-0.3397406339645386,
0.1823047548532486,
-0.22436660528182983,
-0.742744505405426,
0.02069232054054737,
0.8405521512031555,
-0.18391083180904388,
-1.00490403175354,
-0.4811399579048157,
-0.25890445709228516,
-0.4101980924606323,
1.4041084051132202,
0.1252003014087677,
-0.19671422243118286,
0.2957756221294403,
-0.0890362411737442,
0.062204282730817795,
-0.6476221084594727,
-0.7554333209991455,
-0.28201591968536377,
0.2808555066585541,
0.4710351824760437,
0.8162308931350708,
1.2986811399459839,
0.7909315824508667,
0.3179683983325958,
-0.21909818053245544,
0.23463252186775208,
-0.35008901357650757,
-0.18320080637931824,
0.11687105894088745,
-0.519713819026947,
-0.7237868905067444,
-0.17073197662830353,
0.8302817940711975,
0.7779004573822021,
-0.35111773014068604,
0.39500734210014343,
-0.2900320589542389,
0.6741973757743835,
-0.549816906452179,
0.6040862202644348,
-0.5295729637145996,
0.04114706441760063,
-0.25534331798553467,
-0.40517881512641907,
-0.7092861533164978,
-0.29531681537628174,
0.049400895833969116,
-0.7270810008049011,
0.2111971080303192,
0.3647216558456421,
0.9691956043243408,
0.21324482560157776,
-0.31195807456970215,
-0.3506868779659271,
-0.745082437992096,
0.5783721208572388,
-0.805823802947998,
0.3325693607330322,
0.3609382212162018,
0.15746742486953735,
0.1209559291601181,
-0.5620421171188354,
0.06308147311210632,
-0.10646338760852814,
0.37286892533302307,
0.0036571251694113016,
-0.33073121309280396,
0.18348275125026703,
0.4613586962223053,
0.34220147132873535,
-0.3635021448135376,
0.6906926035881042,
-0.1561013013124466,
-0.08205980807542801,
0.6449337005615234,
0.2125796526670456,
-0.20634882152080536,
0.2599547803401947,
-0.4128703474998474,
-0.4752572178840637,
-0.7118748426437378,
-0.16175797581672668,
0.4960605502128601,
0.3944397568702698,
-0.09515117108821869,
0.378465473651886,
-0.17612598836421967,
0.9753414392471313,
-0.08222467452287674,
-0.2675786316394806,
0.24520456790924072,
0.18322695791721344,
-0.3759557902812958,
0.41726744174957275,
0.2600727677345276,
0.3153919279575348,
0.1296338140964508,
-0.0227689016610384,
-0.686436116695404,
-0.11164508759975433,
-0.01754521206021309,
-0.4923815131187439,
-0.2394329160451889,
-0.10194900631904602,
-0.15401045978069305,
-0.39462363719940186,
0.07117366045713425,
-0.6356059908866882,
-0.16030865907669067,
-0.3869543969631195,
0.6232438683509827,
-0.3474132716655731,
0.2043687254190445,
0.3173466920852661,
-0.07383999973535538,
0.39310744404792786,
0.10935903340578079,
-1.2593587636947632,
0.15077997744083405,
1.011087417602539,
0.6570156812667847,
0.5786551833152771,
0.27949392795562744,
-0.9317857027053833,
0.32241928577423096,
-0.5438423156738281,
0.9156500101089478,
-0.9364339113235474,
-0.3636094033718109,
-0.01753118261694908,
-0.46814945340156555,
0.15062692761421204,
-0.5322752594947815,
0.3843327462673187,
-1.0982670783996582,
-0.4502102732658386,
-0.11274278908967972,
-0.8804637789726257,
-0.20356403291225433,
-0.15176165103912354,
-0.7409912347793579,
0.801583468914032,
0.2698427438735962,
-0.5712190270423889,
0.39961138367652893,
-0.8103451728820801,
-0.3516961932182312,
0.3372386395931244,
0.013848917558789253,
-0.49524691700935364,
0.059427447617053986,
0.07564759254455566,
0.568003237247467,
-0.4938086271286011,
0.09917750954627991,
-0.3212912380695343,
-0.3679209351539612,
0.49941346049308777,
-0.48494064807891846,
0.32463932037353516,
0.04892757907509804,
-0.5696755051612854,
0.02651934325695038,
-1.153205394744873,
0.3229386806488037,
-0.10620063543319702,
-0.21437138319015503,
-0.6998416781425476,
-0.23830799758434296,
-0.023706860840320587,
-0.1220409944653511,
0.11956159770488739,
-0.3039359450340271,
0.2434375286102295,
-0.4575830399990082,
0.43517300486564636,
1.1073682308197021,
-0.18728868663311005,
0.34208011627197266,
-0.2410047948360443,
0.5373560786247253,
-0.2980289161205292,
0.081333689391613,
-0.3670807182788849,
-0.4126797616481781,
-0.8488017916679382,
-0.37121888995170593,
0.9253392815589905,
0.5555515289306641,
-0.4225004017353058,
0.5525760054588318,
-0.17663712799549103,
-0.42995840311050415,
-0.42154234647750854,
0.21457745134830475,
0.6980140805244446,
0.6195477843284607,
0.24255989491939545,
0.0326736681163311,
-0.43926194310188293,
-1.0042363405227661,
0.06154154986143112,
-0.07089004665613174,
0.13800469040870667,
0.19616711139678955,
0.45807117223739624,
0.12839096784591675,
0.5513643026351929,
-0.9573714733123779,
-0.37677597999572754,
0.00882185623049736,
0.6701940298080444,
0.3481815755367279,
0.31888315081596375,
0.6033176183700562,
-0.8261204957962036,
-0.5604638457298279,
0.38065433502197266,
-0.39915838837623596,
-0.2619395852088928,
-0.37741920351982117,
-0.14718125760555267,
0.6291068196296692,
0.5707815289497375,
0.07797105610370636,
0.445712149143219,
0.45968732237815857,
-0.3012249767780304,
0.24442864954471588,
-0.5685814619064331,
-0.12899631261825562,
-0.5620245337486267,
-0.034201670438051224,
0.46305111050605774,
-0.25308212637901306,
-0.5214676856994629,
0.10985095798969269,
0.38751184940338135,
0.23893529176712036,
-0.09918566048145294,
0.5094253420829773,
-0.4466674327850342,
-0.029697095975279808,
-0.2814522087574005,
0.0867171660065651,
-0.19741889834403992,
0.47027087211608887,
0.18893583118915558,
0.6398876309394836,
0.487201064825058,
-0.497938334941864,
0.2695895731449127,
0.11280648410320282,
-0.7121219635009766,
0.38099461793899536,
-0.3533659279346466,
-0.03117559105157852,
-0.09444255381822586,
0.3104696571826935,
-0.8293024301528931,
-0.15065132081508636,
0.03863614797592163,
-0.08750210702419281,
0.5849330425262451,
-0.08307059854269028,
-0.6122106313705444,
-0.13566629588603973,
-0.15004171431064606,
0.0694723129272461,
0.7076867818832397,
-0.6503825187683105,
0.33655837178230286,
0.29770416021347046,
-0.21439914405345917,
-0.5626369714736938,
-0.5631967186927795,
0.08067135512828827,
-0.4099840223789215,
-0.4955069422721863,
0.4068414568901062,
-0.0334467887878418,
-0.3498649001121521,
-0.16159506142139435,
-0.14153091609477997,
0.09655476361513138,
0.15119816362857819,
0.1461840271949768,
0.7252818942070007,
-0.6588906049728394,
0.13495081663131714,
0.06144668906927109,
-0.5669661164283752,
-0.01681559532880783,
-0.5231217741966248,
0.39591002464294434,
-0.3310653269290924,
-0.10268540680408478,
-0.27492156624794006,
0.42518219351768494,
0.23272442817687988,
-0.32370609045028687,
0.972740113735199,
0.42951247096061707,
-0.12320853024721146,
-0.5151665210723877,
-0.645246148109436,
0.41468796133995056,
-0.5294944047927856,
0.3418082296848297,
-0.3822082281112671,
-0.8880401849746704,
0.7043536901473999,
0.05534743890166283,
0.391143798828125,
0.43622079491615295,
0.3897722661495209,
0.20385919511318207,
1.2060705423355103,
0.8308365345001221,
0.15689370036125183,
0.44225651025772095,
-0.6097816824913025,
0.09680475294589996,
-0.64151531457901,
-0.19672000408172607,
-0.5123435854911804,
-0.2572782635688782,
-0.32194602489471436,
-0.5606775283813477,
0.44712695479393005,
-0.08797916024923325,
-0.2501681447029114,
0.14867913722991943,
-0.23016412556171417,
0.7686919569969177,
0.5893759727478027,
-0.08891011029481888,
0.22575689852237701,
0.006061968393623829,
-0.03844192996621132,
0.04412517696619034,
-0.554499089717865,
-0.5254421830177307,
1.2384816408157349,
0.2902252972126007,
0.9406246542930603,
-0.01462324894964695,
0.7110168933868408,
0.3212202191352844,
0.6408402323722839,
-0.6897238492965698,
0.38943347334861755,
-0.5513628125190735,
-0.48839110136032104,
-0.2895817756652832,
-0.6055375933647156,
-0.43115490674972534,
0.030289459973573685,
-0.018398815765976906,
-0.7413754463195801,
0.02847849763929844,
0.24007058143615723,
-0.9578219652175903,
0.51628178358078,
-0.6926377415657043,
0.6424461603164673,
-0.36539432406425476,
-0.12526963651180267,
0.0893721953034401,
-0.6782445907592773,
0.4656679332256317,
-0.7086786031723022,
0.3616717457771301,
-0.14439760148525238,
-0.4630469083786011,
0.8567997217178345,
-0.5898568630218506,
0.8929043412208557,
-0.07833338528871536,
-0.8378878831863403,
0.19141630828380585,
-0.31736886501312256,
0.5646357536315918,
0.10367148369550705,
-0.3227231204509735,
0.09348642081022263,
-0.10792532563209534,
-0.28140348196029663,
-0.7035869359970093,
0.6950295567512512,
-0.7183510065078735,
-0.6083039045333862,
-0.250963419675827,
-0.6731712222099304,
-0.26137682795524597,
-0.11518315970897675,
0.11949373781681061,
0.7967338562011719,
0.025645554065704346,
0.3428342640399933,
1.0599974393844604,
0.05710919573903084,
0.4769078493118286,
0.8763340711593628,
-0.22712184488773346,
-0.5301377177238464,
1.036194086074829,
0.45386913418769836,
0.38537776470184326,
0.8435244560241699,
0.12066927552223206,
-0.44102057814598083,
-0.4925169348716736,
-0.5436788201332092,
0.20601177215576172,
-0.964263916015625,
-0.5880197286605835,
-0.3599676787853241,
-0.25528231263160706,
-0.42225342988967896,
-0.5439896583557129,
-0.2226041555404663,
-0.5490095615386963,
-0.5307666063308716,
-0.22240884602069855,
0.7071635127067566,
0.6194109320640564,
-0.5205169320106506,
0.5092850923538208,
-1.1278096437454224,
0.3523954749107361,
0.1401839405298233,
0.5414268970489502,
0.15269991755485535,
-0.9910858869552612,
-0.4769350588321686,
0.03868789225816727,
0.14631387591362,
-0.5374901294708252,
0.3098882734775543,
0.512824535369873,
0.3532904386520386,
1.012932538986206,
0.4121890664100647,
0.7955200672149658,
-0.2964269816875458,
0.16642704606056213,
0.11820638924837112,
-1.0504053831100464,
0.2439640313386917,
-0.3326730728149414,
0.19115805625915527,
0.2808789312839508,
0.5131576657295227,
-0.5017752051353455,
-0.31377437710762024,
-0.6413937211036682,
-1.2134648561477661,
0.8629328608512878,
-0.16381540894508362,
0.14874914288520813,
-0.04864824190735817,
0.5822181105613708,
0.4068085551261902,
-0.1697804182767868,
-0.3334832787513733,
-0.41763362288475037,
0.08935367316007614,
0.0017174152890220284,
-0.04452625662088394,
-0.39804381132125854,
-0.17822229862213135,
-0.10235442221164703,
1.0147343873977661,
-0.247852623462677,
-0.2367956042289734,
-0.221510112285614,
0.2023645043373108,
-0.2340487837791443,
0.10355550795793533,
0.6507558822631836,
0.6886711120605469,
-0.28444862365722656,
-0.008960050530731678,
0.0981922373175621,
-0.23102761805057526,
0.19310402870178223,
0.2573910653591156,
-0.12349307537078857,
-0.17702749371528625,
0.35459429025650024,
1.0631736516952515,
0.7108164429664612,
-0.8362163305282593,
0.13226750493049622,
0.045596893876791,
-0.4433603882789612,
-0.4452921450138092,
0.4118048846721649,
0.061358921229839325,
0.24459689855575562,
0.5775932669639587,
-0.06264183670282364,
-0.0935678705573082,
-0.3400202691555023,
0.2269243448972702,
0.4291946589946747,
-0.30134937167167664,
-0.1893928349018097,
0.8186414837837219,
0.2209240198135376,
-0.27154189348220825,
0.840255618095398,
-0.1611005961894989,
-0.2725082337856293,
0.8399766683578491,
0.8470373153686523,
0.7446842193603516,
-0.10385216772556305,
0.5411342978477478,
0.0014327348908409476,
0.1529899686574936,
-0.10230360925197601,
0.25446149706840515,
-0.21088889241218567,
-0.4286072552204132,
-0.5630990862846375,
-0.883620023727417,
-0.5271472334861755,
0.03918833285570145,
-1.0495719909667969,
0.2893715798854828,
-0.8344864249229431,
-0.24556313455104828,
0.7366313934326172,
-0.10507077723741531,
-0.36434221267700195,
0.18491986393928528,
0.617755651473999,
1.0748831033706665,
-0.9377655982971191,
0.7632006406784058,
0.7652490735054016,
-0.2321886420249939,
-0.7204097509384155,
-0.6265748739242554,
-0.016463767737150192,
-0.9667485952377319,
0.8043725490570068,
0.08919141441583633,
-0.10992240160703659,
0.3739396631717682,
-0.4537677764892578,
-1.0902252197265625,
0.7870030403137207,
0.30797919631004333,
-0.8676056861877441,
-0.1827467679977417,
0.2926972210407257,
0.48215237259864807,
-0.3946722149848938,
-0.05921848863363266,
0.7508705854415894,
0.685715913772583,
0.565386176109314,
-0.6341810822486877,
-0.3237479627132416,
-0.2506074905395508,
-0.013746276497840881,
0.7315741777420044,
-0.8428415656089783,
0.44087815284729004,
-0.3484514057636261,
0.01460434589534998,
0.21530742943286896,
0.9194241166114807,
0.08443054556846619,
0.17371173202991486,
0.4898293912410736,
0.7194892764091492,
0.8639373779296875,
-0.09654838591814041,
0.9543810486793518,
-0.4004252254962921,
0.2751358449459076,
0.9739062786102295,
-0.485003262758255,
0.885732889175415,
-0.022608116269111633,
-0.1608133465051651,
0.20849323272705078,
0.6541551351547241,
-0.33941593766212463,
0.09909243136644363,
0.33200395107269287,
-0.38552892208099365,
-0.6564702391624451,
-0.11264988034963608,
-0.404041051864624,
0.6291348338127136,
0.5006574988365173,
-0.4993882477283478,
-0.1917942315340042,
0.022275421768426895,
0.1857597678899765,
-0.06315643340349197,
-0.4494209885597229,
0.6896722316741943,
0.17066234350204468,
-0.31614401936531067,
0.6963125467300415,
0.36651182174682617,
0.5589219331741333,
-0.9993043541908264,
-0.10868623107671738,
-0.2519916594028473,
0.22164393961429596,
-0.06818773597478867,
-0.4547281265258789,
0.12094660103321075,
0.19445115327835083,
-0.2783657908439636,
-0.32169634103775024,
0.03842538595199585,
-0.2588268518447876,
-0.8707209825515747,
-0.03031066060066223,
-0.12138079851865768,
0.12051494419574738,
0.06530199944972992,
-0.4341265857219696,
0.002465168246999383,
0.09014980494976044,
-0.14596505463123322,
0.5540005564689636,
0.4720456600189209,
-0.23569846153259277,
0.6687484383583069,
0.8070208430290222,
0.00960805919021368,
0.08051782846450806,
0.12120121717453003,
0.8355737924575806,
-1.0160548686981201,
-0.6768974661827087,
-0.7646335363388062,
0.07993710786104202,
0.10517867654561996,
-0.40117424726486206,
0.5937445163726807,
0.7338679432868958,
0.7015253901481628,
-0.044937822967767715,
0.5321512222290039,
0.3277251422405243,
0.18402306735515594,
-0.8387138843536377,
0.6611084938049316,
-0.4199939966201782,
0.6041231751441956,
-0.29777491092681885,
-1.0800530910491943,
-0.733680248260498,
0.39784255623817444,
-0.26512739062309265,
-0.1649552583694458,
0.4528314471244812,
0.6635808348655701,
0.12822115421295166,
0.37091225385665894,
0.511223316192627,
0.13424243032932281,
0.10761960595846176,
0.49683573842048645,
0.6054152250289917,
-0.2057897448539734,
0.7170659303665161,
-0.42433789372444153,
-0.46371519565582275,
-0.3995261490345001,
-1.0138440132141113,
-0.5663753747940063,
-0.3708319664001465,
-0.8542349934577942,
0.04084688052535057,
-0.0006670412258245051,
0.8700522184371948,
0.4418472945690155,
-0.6515768766403198,
-0.1894216388463974,
0.4788582921028137,
-0.15601295232772827,
-0.25815925002098083,
-0.18114621937274933,
0.6378307938575745,
-0.36015865206718445,
-0.6259666085243225,
0.2243688404560089,
0.6518438458442688,
0.27676820755004883,
-0.2640504837036133,
0.21100027859210968,
0.11528655886650085,
0.25929391384124756,
0.47232580184936523,
0.320829838514328,
-0.40600284934043884,
-0.22657658159732819,
0.07069923728704453,
0.13972949981689453,
0.12952694296836853,
0.7693463563919067,
-0.45014122128486633,
0.14190596342086792,
0.1634182333946228,
0.5534511804580688,
0.3114255368709564,
0.2908802926540375,
0.3784172832965851,
-0.42820948362350464,
-0.12902861833572388,
0.12111885845661163,
0.026190243661403656,
0.13053050637245178,
-0.3350781202316284,
0.41680750250816345,
-0.14545999467372894,
-0.46369823813438416,
-0.8613625168800354,
-0.13927532732486725,
-0.8929064869880676,
-0.15945279598236084,
1.0489232540130615,
-0.3732094466686249,
-0.6330670118331909,
0.04814829304814339,
-0.0036460263654589653,
-0.04258488118648529,
-0.39795753359794617,
0.7490810751914978,
0.4484580159187317,
-0.09934059530496597,
0.1532093584537506,
-0.5454486012458801,
0.18691354990005493,
0.20554395020008087,
-0.5124537944793701,
0.4030827283859253,
0.5023680925369263,
0.05173413082957268,
0.1455695778131485,
0.34920138120651245,
-0.01049099676311016,
0.2859955430030823,
0.20411182940006256,
0.03993736580014229,
-0.17016664147377014,
-0.216304212808609,
-0.30324169993400574,
0.22857628762722015,
0.06194407865405083,
0.10581134259700775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02228v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02228v2
|
REASONS: A benchmark for REtrieval and Automated citationS Of scieNtific Sentences using Public and Proprietary LLMs
| 2024-05-03T16:38:51 | 2024-05-09T00:23:16 |
Deepa Tilwani, Yash Saxena, Ali Mohammadi, Edward Raff, Amit Sheth, Srinivasan Parthasarathy, Manas Gaur
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Automatic citation generation for sentences in a document or report is
paramount for intelligence analysts, cybersecurity, news agencies, and
education personnel. In this research, we investigate whether large language
models (LLMs) are capable of generating references based on two forms of
sentence queries: (a) Direct Queries, LLMs are asked to provide author names of
the given research article, and (b) Indirect Queries, LLMs are asked to provide
the title of a mentioned article when given a sentence from a different
article. To demonstrate where LLM stands in this task, we introduce a large
dataset called REASONS comprising abstracts of the 12 most popular domains of
scientific research on arXiv. From around 20K research articles, we make the
following deductions on public and proprietary LLMs: (a) State-of-the-art,
often called anthropomorphic GPT-4 and GPT-3.5, suffers from high pass
percentage (PP) to minimize the hallucination rate (HR). When tested with
Perplexity.ai (7B), they unexpectedly made more errors; (b) Augmenting relevant
metadata lowered the PP and gave the lowest HR; (c) Advance retrieval-augmented
generation (RAG) using Mistral demonstrates consistent and robust citation
support on indirect queries and matched performance to GPT-3.5 and GPT-4. The
HR across all domains and models decreased by an average of 41.93%, and the PP
was reduced to 0% in most cases. In terms of generation quality, the average F1
Score and BLEU were 68.09% and 57.51%, respectively; (d) Testing with
adversarial samples showed that LLMs, including the Advance RAG Mistral,
struggle to understand context, but the extent of this issue was small in
Mistral and GPT-4-Preview. Our study contributes valuable insights into the
reliability of RAG for automated citation generation tasks.
|
[
-0.45152223110198975,
-0.6046273708343506,
0.9443773627281189,
0.07958110421895981,
-0.07513319700956345,
-0.2412795126438141,
-0.05783802643418312,
-0.5087542533874512,
-0.06236617639660835,
0.40422043204307556,
-0.20660872757434845,
-0.4103794991970062,
-0.4082403779029846,
0.69100421667099,
-0.5856969356536865,
0.9675087332725525,
-0.10240310430526733,
0.053988002240657806,
-0.5230266451835632,
-0.05910748615860939,
-0.038684744387865067,
-0.6761285066604614,
-0.3826814889907837,
-0.23917897045612335,
0.7865414023399353,
0.2099393606185913,
0.5438075661659241,
0.6125496625900269,
0.7320961356163025,
0.29629161953926086,
0.06053133308887482,
0.4696521759033203,
-0.21888625621795654,
0.3703951835632324,
-0.3298377990722656,
-0.3475557863712311,
-0.3137170374393463,
0.0857604444026947,
0.531206488609314,
0.4681314527988434,
0.17574778199195862,
0.25260666012763977,
-0.05988256633281708,
0.7136585116386414,
-0.6432735919952393,
-0.060391709208488464,
-0.9459748864173889,
-0.24553126096725464,
-0.4234057664871216,
-0.46983110904693604,
-0.46800824999809265,
-0.3897995054721832,
0.04727267473936081,
-0.4586872160434723,
0.31915491819381714,
0.28914275765419006,
1.0001178979873657,
0.32743319869041443,
-0.48381519317626953,
-0.40236300230026245,
-0.504180908203125,
0.7633326649665833,
-0.5159428119659424,
0.20822277665138245,
0.3648932874202728,
0.0689050629734993,
-0.2850819528102875,
-0.8589325547218323,
-0.4476602077484131,
-0.519203782081604,
-0.1575329750776291,
-0.13582533597946167,
-0.41027966141700745,
-0.18713179230690002,
0.49506425857543945,
0.1042962372303009,
-0.644615113735199,
-0.2441103756427765,
-0.33039453625679016,
0.0472395084798336,
0.5920999050140381,
0.15384361147880554,
0.014110825024545193,
-0.33027034997940063,
-0.30555933713912964,
0.07621181011199951,
-1.1110820770263672,
-0.31108805537223816,
0.3581899106502533,
0.24474290013313293,
0.46371743083000183,
0.6985551714897156,
0.04922354221343994,
0.6946013569831848,
0.03415774926543236,
-0.008257163688540459,
0.058177199214696884,
-0.4163818955421448,
-0.05840487405657768,
0.011153622530400753,
0.8576105833053589,
0.1855265349149704,
0.2695363461971283,
-0.4136373996734619,
-0.05842629075050354,
-0.2944958209991455,
0.29926589131355286,
-0.940867006778717,
-0.04414809122681618,
0.08477862924337387,
-0.18448267877101898,
-0.13306134939193726,
0.22127757966518402,
-0.41359129548072815,
-0.2960336208343506,
-0.4754962623119354,
0.36863231658935547,
-0.3235715627670288,
0.1472223997116089,
-0.34679463505744934,
-0.06072796881198883,
0.06218300759792328,
0.30167868733406067,
-0.33722490072250366,
0.2668514549732208,
0.43832239508628845,
0.9262024164199829,
-0.5007702112197876,
-0.20528917014598846,
-0.5612234473228455,
0.17921032011508942,
-0.38882654905319214,
0.9853466749191284,
-0.5159308314323425,
-0.3715285360813141,
-0.1359107494354248,
-0.006617160048335791,
-0.18629470467567444,
-0.7967530488967896,
0.423088014125824,
-0.5757989883422852,
0.20439788699150085,
-0.522986650466919,
-0.4062965214252472,
0.044770993292331696,
0.003075868356972933,
-0.5489842891693115,
0.9540311694145203,
-0.12718483805656433,
-0.9490636587142944,
0.18431992828845978,
-0.4874790906906128,
-0.41336265206336975,
0.007090211845934391,
-0.3577668368816376,
-0.36277085542678833,
0.06884387135505676,
-0.007610400673002005,
0.32270175218582153,
-0.6828835606575012,
0.5838853716850281,
-0.2832024097442627,
-0.2800160050392151,
0.48605087399482727,
-0.17959584295749664,
0.43234431743621826,
0.40885260701179504,
-0.4473816752433777,
-0.062006156891584396,
-0.7368938326835632,
0.003400178859010339,
0.1556902676820755,
-0.29321154952049255,
-0.4514048397541046,
0.18406081199645996,
-0.04360733926296234,
0.07344520837068558,
0.08969509601593018,
-0.3692934513092041,
0.04486662149429321,
-0.020380182191729546,
0.2587776482105255,
0.6151145100593567,
0.2711248993873596,
0.08165231347084045,
-0.3637072741985321,
0.5240596532821655,
-0.08235344290733337,
-0.3434675633907318,
-0.22186525166034698,
-0.37408706545829773,
-0.6319871544837952,
-0.17213335633277893,
0.2545221447944641,
0.3263798654079437,
-0.6207741498947144,
0.1860795021057129,
-0.20844462513923645,
-0.31651416420936584,
-0.31379610300064087,
0.1419551968574524,
0.43462422490119934,
0.6179691553115845,
0.37750959396362305,
0.26303166151046753,
-0.6676825881004333,
-0.9767855405807495,
-0.37263068556785583,
-0.13871325552463531,
-0.06853453814983368,
0.5752506852149963,
0.7337294816970825,
-0.09714425355195999,
1.079180359840393,
-0.3520353138446808,
0.04319937154650688,
0.02913774363696575,
0.24849814176559448,
0.1803305745124817,
0.08335274457931519,
0.49243083596229553,
-0.9126988053321838,
-0.47456300258636475,
-0.21498623490333557,
-0.8227114081382751,
-0.4565533399581909,
0.021446513012051582,
-0.22067447006702423,
0.32118430733680725,
0.5939127206802368,
-0.7143464684486389,
0.15472707152366638,
0.2839822471141815,
-0.27795422077178955,
0.7571786642074585,
-0.031794775277376175,
0.10135691612958908,
-1.0836400985717773,
0.6534956693649292,
0.21743641793727875,
-0.2135172039270401,
-0.3594212532043457,
0.07591798901557922,
-0.09655439853668213,
-0.08924677222967148,
-0.20324066281318665,
0.5639947056770325,
-0.5787922739982605,
-0.03315295651555061,
-0.4622207581996918,
0.19567537307739258,
-0.019427871331572533,
0.03627709671854973,
0.020009074360132217,
0.9555214643478394,
0.22067223489284515,
-0.734657347202301,
0.19176030158996582,
-0.03592044115066528,
-0.14395052194595337,
0.4045339822769165,
-0.9070714712142944,
0.11032801121473312,
-0.11895113438367844,
0.37976691126823425,
-0.7272897362709045,
-0.2874612808227539,
0.00227153766900301,
-0.30661556124687195,
0.06513946503400803,
0.16711340844631195,
-0.5526533126831055,
-0.23381857573986053,
-0.2286120057106018,
0.23345914483070374,
0.2982247769832611,
-0.5134090185165405,
0.36600053310394287,
0.30394524335861206,
-0.32001322507858276,
-0.5462287664413452,
-0.41997379064559937,
0.33377185463905334,
-0.2091575711965561,
-0.6324880719184875,
0.3781595528125763,
-0.19579704105854034,
-0.7497368454933167,
0.16700655221939087,
-0.23582394421100616,
0.15459071099758148,
0.0502840094268322,
0.2974592447280884,
0.3150606155395508,
-0.30882737040519714,
0.24534395337104797,
-0.06415672600269318,
0.0866822600364685,
0.18404145538806915,
-0.06850745528936386,
0.3616636097431183,
-0.11619222164154053,
-0.25104525685310364,
-0.1321496069431305,
0.4469548463821411,
0.5571213364601135,
-0.015096543356776237,
0.49674156308174133,
0.3490549623966217,
-0.09240026026964188,
-0.155094712972641,
-0.7072317600250244,
-0.24869440495967865,
-0.4118422567844391,
0.11924930661916733,
-0.3736037313938141,
-0.7300336956977844,
0.3873254358768463,
0.06064721196889877,
-0.0706493929028511,
0.605722963809967,
0.5776371359825134,
0.21028678119182587,
0.7864760160446167,
0.11782316118478775,
-0.05438094958662987,
0.16844484210014343,
0.03214605897665024,
0.1828821301460266,
-0.7570158839225769,
-0.07875864952802658,
-0.8472715020179749,
0.049993935972452164,
-0.6238798499107361,
-0.3662618398666382,
0.5024385452270508,
0.10407132655382156,
-0.26859384775161743,
0.15535247325897217,
-0.5479881167411804,
0.39430853724479675,
0.6344915628433228,
-0.08650320768356323,
0.5218280553817749,
0.1837361752986908,
-0.22154691815376282,
0.13136719167232513,
-0.4172947406768799,
-0.8114291429519653,
1.0723117589950562,
0.11541889607906342,
0.7497248649597168,
0.04716799408197403,
0.7864950299263,
0.1991792619228363,
0.32237210869789124,
-0.5062299370765686,
0.7521645426750183,
0.01906771957874298,
-0.7589052319526672,
-0.02263406105339527,
-0.5607858300209045,
-1.0564388036727905,
0.3514847457408905,
0.058549534529447556,
-0.4606838822364807,
0.19683988392353058,
-0.025613050907850266,
-0.21205875277519226,
-0.11310192942619324,
-0.44403693079948425,
0.38394221663475037,
-0.13420628011226654,
-0.6098949909210205,
0.06061047315597534,
-0.46218591928482056,
0.4265357255935669,
-0.29950788617134094,
0.06817428022623062,
-0.12609238922595978,
-0.01963840238749981,
0.7525344491004944,
-0.3993600308895111,
0.5499674081802368,
-0.0567510686814785,
0.048177558928728104,
0.3917023539543152,
-0.03132108226418495,
0.6363644599914551,
0.13882140815258026,
-0.2696782350540161,
-0.06969484686851501,
-0.14168044924736023,
0.014317735098302364,
-0.388658732175827,
0.9350314736366272,
-0.5866204500198364,
-0.9508340954780579,
-0.716171145439148,
-0.6058416962623596,
-0.1513376384973526,
0.16235004365444183,
0.40618982911109924,
0.1808202713727951,
0.05971289798617363,
0.5344663858413696,
0.668960690498352,
-0.10548198968172073,
0.25205519795417786,
0.7231705188751221,
-0.03510813042521477,
-0.30272939801216125,
0.684747576713562,
0.17753145098686218,
0.043266188353300095,
0.2622434198856354,
0.09985785186290741,
-0.1496703326702118,
-0.574966549873352,
-0.204244926571846,
0.4698069989681244,
-0.5060936808586121,
-0.42057138681411743,
-0.8733952641487122,
-0.2431209832429886,
-0.5316130518913269,
0.10254264622926712,
0.05440457910299301,
-0.30986660718917847,
-0.29349127411842346,
-0.03816651180386543,
0.43137407302856445,
0.640184760093689,
-0.0006197671173140407,
-0.22956402599811554,
-0.5461297035217285,
0.3555017411708832,
0.20477743446826935,
-0.14296627044677734,
-0.030856885015964508,
-0.3966636061668396,
-0.08011224865913391,
-0.332228422164917,
-0.4111780524253845,
-0.8700350522994995,
0.37294065952301025,
0.1951109766960144,
0.6794541478157043,
0.08996962010860443,
0.22629807889461517,
0.6194589138031006,
-0.727409839630127,
0.7959046363830566,
-0.1354566514492035,
-0.5492725372314453,
0.5173731446266174,
-0.4175361096858978,
0.1496492624282837,
0.508249044418335,
0.7163365483283997,
-0.17228738963603973,
-0.6172196865081787,
-0.5539401173591614,
-1.1064469814300537,
0.6206623315811157,
0.27100199460983276,
-0.15792803466320038,
-0.35324063897132874,
0.39235344529151917,
0.09665974974632263,
0.15904027223587036,
-0.706822395324707,
-0.25801214575767517,
0.11888584494590759,
-0.00402096938341856,
-0.09715454280376434,
-0.3057354688644409,
-0.3653203248977661,
-0.004680009558796883,
0.8385462164878845,
-0.1377291977405548,
0.34409967064857483,
0.5141120553016663,
-0.09070844948291779,
-0.1176028624176979,
0.2863199710845947,
0.8091712594032288,
0.8311743140220642,
-0.14533129334449768,
0.22500331699848175,
-0.09772201627492905,
-0.3313426375389099,
-0.0009977789595723152,
0.37515708804130554,
-0.3829008936882019,
0.3735870122909546,
0.21488139033317566,
0.5027609467506409,
-0.042675260454416275,
-0.6570540070533752,
0.35513371229171753,
0.14038273692131042,
-0.28511741757392883,
-0.4320181906223297,
0.0052984170615673065,
0.07148032635450363,
0.2118307650089264,
0.9281600117683411,
-0.15699294209480286,
0.3517044484615326,
-0.3728213906288147,
0.22829072177410126,
0.5757424831390381,
0.1447245180606842,
-0.23288017511367798,
0.674221932888031,
-0.014646848663687706,
0.053722817450761795,
0.34976136684417725,
-0.14570030570030212,
-0.2334052175283432,
0.49517354369163513,
0.643735945224762,
0.7539535164833069,
-0.005874265916645527,
0.19088146090507507,
0.45398831367492676,
0.034169040620326996,
-0.2885819673538208,
0.13695479929447174,
-0.10233142971992493,
-0.3633619546890259,
-0.3619251251220703,
-0.8590323328971863,
-0.4845898449420929,
0.31624191999435425,
-0.5247160792350769,
0.10395869612693787,
-0.16888435184955597,
-0.41815489530563354,
0.15752610564231873,
0.04704810678958893,
-0.49450191855430603,
-0.05761084705591202,
0.05806052312254906,
0.773594856262207,
-0.6534806489944458,
0.7467915415763855,
0.7362463474273682,
-0.5309211015701294,
-0.7399071455001831,
-0.06031617894768715,
0.07021956145763397,
-0.496916264295578,
1.0477536916732788,
-0.10191909968852997,
-0.2194570004940033,
-0.13430918753147125,
-0.5967609882354736,
-1.0245277881622314,
1.0896849632263184,
0.42697685956954956,
-0.5841547846794128,
-0.3441651463508606,
0.006441968958824873,
0.526020884513855,
-0.4426366090774536,
0.2708137333393097,
0.2577970623970032,
0.6691976189613342,
0.2356719970703125,
-0.8345434665679932,
0.32612642645835876,
-0.36752569675445557,
0.13081522285938263,
0.07691764086484909,
-0.4731018841266632,
0.891231894493103,
-0.1628466099500656,
-0.128346785902977,
0.3573319613933563,
0.5109606385231018,
0.7838719487190247,
0.48632338643074036,
0.13930758833885193,
0.3736903965473175,
0.8151741027832031,
-0.05432252585887909,
1.1073565483093262,
-0.4481133222579956,
0.045336008071899414,
0.9815354943275452,
-0.4373442828655243,
0.8278704285621643,
0.7096574306488037,
-0.1394420713186264,
0.5711139440536499,
0.4305817782878876,
-0.23298461735248566,
0.39412200450897217,
0.2729586660861969,
-0.19472436606884003,
-0.1797368973493576,
-0.18860889971256256,
-0.610941469669342,
0.1474848836660385,
0.09246042370796204,
-0.7628511786460876,
-0.31559839844703674,
-0.0348178893327713,
0.2357577383518219,
-0.006958862766623497,
-0.07846251875162125,
0.5379735827445984,
0.23782625794410706,
-0.9277863502502441,
0.5937646627426147,
-0.13416530191898346,
0.43395787477493286,
-0.5547488927841187,
0.06395038217306137,
-0.2052181512117386,
0.1565244197845459,
-0.34882432222366333,
-0.3324931859970093,
0.0845363512635231,
0.3457918167114258,
-0.3038542568683624,
-0.06568466871976852,
0.7028299570083618,
-0.18650591373443604,
-0.479196697473526,
-0.030704595148563385,
0.5280545353889465,
0.48777058720588684,
-0.12353600561618805,
-0.46203720569610596,
0.02314111962914467,
-0.0369412899017334,
-0.6441623568534851,
0.47825267910957336,
0.5163504481315613,
-0.15440185368061066,
0.48206987977027893,
0.6835175156593323,
0.24528037011623383,
0.060850709676742554,
0.0408814363181591,
0.8033773303031921,
-0.6889258027076721,
0.04201880097389221,
-0.7951846718788147,
0.16536377370357513,
-0.26635757088661194,
-0.25844743847846985,
1.104445457458496,
0.6266431212425232,
0.49858811497688293,
0.04874153435230255,
0.8790206909179688,
-0.04824690520763397,
0.6684383153915405,
-0.5248847603797913,
0.5396316051483154,
-0.5825881958007812,
0.3137882351875305,
-0.23172980546951294,
-1.068857192993164,
-0.30280494689941406,
0.4631425440311432,
-0.4319051504135132,
0.14796002209186554,
0.8788788318634033,
0.7535216808319092,
0.1991075873374939,
-0.2585882842540741,
0.09092092514038086,
0.19674409925937653,
0.442818284034729,
0.16011442244052887,
0.7407703399658203,
-0.2634328603744507,
0.765631914138794,
0.0972721129655838,
0.08035247772932053,
-0.2977125942707062,
-0.8905225396156311,
-0.7720462083816528,
-0.5100528001785278,
-0.41715431213378906,
-0.5143279433250427,
0.35329002141952515,
0.8444094657897949,
0.4804253876209259,
-0.7154039144515991,
-0.10832419246435165,
-0.24291108548641205,
-0.042783740907907486,
0.17732210457324982,
-0.276566743850708,
0.427247554063797,
-0.6814539432525635,
-0.712702751159668,
0.43588170409202576,
0.055370550602674484,
-0.1962057203054428,
-0.1753041297197342,
-0.07515668869018555,
-0.1824977993965149,
0.14412033557891846,
0.49215295910835266,
0.34326454997062683,
-0.7995472550392151,
-0.1344219595193863,
0.20403102040290833,
-0.4771234393119812,
-0.16032011806964874,
0.9349650740623474,
-0.7917736768722534,
0.0766824409365654,
0.4681228697299957,
0.5174672603607178,
0.4575083255767822,
0.20713172852993011,
0.492413192987442,
-0.4468708336353302,
-0.2588767409324646,
0.395607590675354,
0.3559001684188843,
0.3267379105091095,
-0.32041049003601074,
0.5895020365715027,
0.34780362248420715,
-1.002271056175232,
-1.0822410583496094,
-0.017247416079044342,
-0.8098306655883789,
-0.3794916868209839,
1.5370408296585083,
-0.0664728507399559,
-0.30994418263435364,
-0.09402189403772354,
-0.063702292740345,
-0.04550725221633911,
-0.46938595175743103,
0.7957485318183899,
0.7768407464027405,
-0.3736594617366791,
0.025324096903204918,
-0.4343622922897339,
0.5123412609100342,
0.22892411053180695,
-0.5811280012130737,
0.1046980768442154,
0.7107601165771484,
0.2362791746854782,
0.4454847574234009,
0.4912557303905487,
-0.24321264028549194,
0.32089290022850037,
-0.13556186854839325,
-0.0763854831457138,
-0.3057931959629059,
-0.28260573744773865,
0.014125222340226173,
0.4028143286705017,
0.18825840950012207,
0.17863428592681885
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.