id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00942v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00942v2
|
LLaVA Finds Free Lunch: Teaching Human Behavior Improves Content Understanding Abilities Of LLMs
| 2024-05-02T02:04:01 | 2024-05-16T21:52:02 |
Somesh Singh, Harini S I, Yaman K Singla, Veeky Baths, Rajiv Ratn Shah, Changyou Chen, Balaji Krishnamurthy
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Communication is defined as "Who says what to whom with what effect." A
message from a communicator generates downstream receiver effects, also known
as behavior. Receiver behavior, being a downstream effect of the message,
carries rich signals about it. Even after carrying signals about the message,
the behavior data is often ignored while training large language models. We
show that training LLMs on receiver behavior can actually help improve their
content-understanding abilities. Specifically, we show that training LLMs to
predict the receiver behavior of likes and comments improves the LLM's
performance on a wide variety of downstream content understanding tasks. We
show this performance increase over 40 video and image understanding tasks over
23 benchmark datasets across both 0-shot and fine-tuning settings,
outperforming many supervised baselines. Moreover, since receiver behavior,
such as likes and comments, is collected by default on the internet and does
not need any human annotations to be useful, the performance improvement we get
after training on this data is essentially free-lunch. We release the receiver
behavior cleaned comments and likes of 750k images and videos collected from
multiple platforms along with our instruction-tuning data.
|
[
-0.3945930600166321,
-0.5488935112953186,
0.452996164560318,
0.27813148498535156,
-0.6731802821159363,
-0.03523247689008713,
-0.42758768796920776,
-0.6370165348052979,
0.33630359172821045,
0.34892353415489197,
-0.5643502473831177,
-0.3110571801662445,
-0.915788471698761,
-0.14315152168273926,
-0.5586037039756775,
1.2125186920166016,
0.3101359009742737,
0.23846746981143951,
-0.37722596526145935,
0.028977036476135254,
-0.49493908882141113,
-0.1688750982284546,
-1.0114262104034424,
-0.6407095789909363,
0.8892015218734741,
0.5574310421943665,
0.2574947476387024,
0.6510709524154663,
0.42066895961761475,
0.32134580612182617,
-0.15069156885147095,
0.15965089201927185,
-0.9525815844535828,
0.1572372019290924,
-0.10811115056276321,
-0.7231464982032776,
-0.2724076509475708,
0.0012414143420755863,
0.5894372463226318,
0.44277673959732056,
-0.24356162548065186,
0.17291109263896942,
0.23338985443115234,
1.030463695526123,
-0.5556833148002625,
0.3103550374507904,
-0.6894263625144958,
0.01833416149020195,
0.004445065278559923,
-0.5096169710159302,
-0.473724365234375,
-0.1321346014738083,
-0.02998735010623932,
-0.7681453227996826,
0.07681917399168015,
-0.16621820628643036,
0.8365330100059509,
0.42992907762527466,
-0.6068061590194702,
-0.36558958888053894,
-0.6695346832275391,
0.7854611873626709,
-0.2187078446149826,
0.5967358946800232,
0.500827431678772,
0.12090430408716202,
-0.42275652289390564,
-0.2929266393184662,
-0.5609735250473022,
0.26344799995422363,
0.0023356517776846886,
0.16031226515769958,
-0.1777464747428894,
0.2170216292142868,
0.1349707692861557,
0.3724561333656311,
-0.28500986099243164,
0.01759328320622444,
-0.290227472782135,
-0.09999781101942062,
0.6026856899261475,
0.09947755932807922,
0.1930815428495407,
-0.08001269400119781,
-0.1596049666404724,
-0.12856972217559814,
-0.739037275314331,
0.47072911262512207,
0.2291989028453827,
0.011453402228653431,
-0.15807926654815674,
0.37193167209625244,
-0.36494892835617065,
0.46512770652770996,
0.14946812391281128,
-0.23200157284736633,
0.24798016250133514,
-0.03606643155217171,
-0.31903544068336487,
-0.1460496038198471,
0.4775891602039337,
0.5479351878166199,
0.6242442727088928,
-0.322443425655365,
-0.1307116448879242,
-0.03111868165433407,
0.3227871060371399,
-0.7740557193756104,
-0.16513307392597198,
-0.07214571535587311,
-0.6285877823829651,
-0.28329330682754517,
0.12557338178157806,
-0.5016321539878845,
-0.6231967210769653,
-0.4090667963027954,
0.24574370682239532,
-0.3005417585372925,
-0.3073408901691437,
0.2156921923160553,
-0.23875373601913452,
0.7434530854225159,
0.6011055707931519,
-1.2525821924209595,
0.4277075231075287,
0.7655466794967651,
0.6673229932785034,
-0.131647989153862,
-0.13406135141849518,
-1.1231913566589355,
0.37780678272247314,
-0.3037017583847046,
1.1913986206054688,
-0.4622402787208557,
-0.3552835285663605,
-0.1572292447090149,
0.16764776408672333,
-0.15742571651935577,
-0.5756750106811523,
0.23686791956424713,
-0.8304288983345032,
-0.30226343870162964,
-0.4816133975982666,
-0.522173285484314,
-0.12071697413921356,
0.421997994184494,
-0.4888460040092468,
0.6671668887138367,
-0.1983528882265091,
-0.6848918795585632,
0.40051138401031494,
-0.5149725675582886,
-0.548328161239624,
0.004968506284058094,
-0.12316950410604477,
-0.1166849136352539,
0.22078277170658112,
0.1962592750787735,
0.3953983783721924,
0.3147214651107788,
0.012268617749214172,
-0.011975552886724472,
-0.6991182565689087,
0.5219473242759705,
-0.07037398964166641,
0.4145352244377136,
0.06314589083194733,
-0.2196887731552124,
0.08436393737792969,
-0.42249470949172974,
-0.18314288556575775,
0.09972932934761047,
-0.8555011749267578,
-0.29709649085998535,
0.2591761648654938,
-0.5054380893707275,
-0.004663220606744289,
-0.23656120896339417,
-0.6876130700111389,
0.23156271874904633,
-0.18852883577346802,
0.06163689121603966,
0.9275697469711304,
0.1427357792854309,
0.6293833255767822,
-0.4406936764717102,
0.38803911209106445,
0.06405233591794968,
0.24857601523399353,
-0.33200758695602417,
-0.5562554597854614,
-0.9646207690238953,
-0.20843522250652313,
-0.35116809606552124,
0.42341649532318115,
-0.6933318376541138,
-0.35446697473526,
-0.35852763056755066,
-0.16724929213523865,
-0.6233493089675903,
0.7165197730064392,
0.5171039700508118,
0.4253097176551819,
0.16391916573047638,
-0.5362286567687988,
-0.6507946848869324,
-0.5643694400787354,
-0.49847710132598877,
-0.07887765020132065,
-0.12129179388284683,
0.4065563976764679,
0.20058530569076538,
-0.10607446730136871,
0.5498197078704834,
-0.41230303049087524,
-0.16968274116516113,
-0.4061219394207001,
0.011233299039304256,
0.003401584690436721,
0.06985333561897278,
0.3040063977241516,
-0.47956350445747375,
-0.48445749282836914,
-0.41967615485191345,
-0.7091597318649292,
0.21380150318145752,
0.0902721956372261,
-0.2806647717952728,
0.20840899646282196,
0.3556841015815735,
-0.7076848745346069,
0.4021972119808197,
0.47449254989624023,
-0.330914705991745,
0.3040703237056732,
-0.027467433363199234,
0.1857936680316925,
-0.6836055517196655,
-0.47876667976379395,
0.2124844342470169,
-0.421451210975647,
-0.4954889714717865,
-0.25982269644737244,
-0.14592908322811127,
0.04579048603773117,
-0.8001106977462769,
0.39517420530319214,
-0.36521729826927185,
-0.5138570070266724,
-0.38963496685028076,
0.18463517725467682,
-0.0960649698972702,
0.4917934834957123,
0.28322818875312805,
0.963263750076294,
0.42546460032463074,
-0.9230392575263977,
0.2789541482925415,
0.35511577129364014,
-0.602118194103241,
0.6930885910987854,
-0.492490291595459,
0.3545698821544647,
-0.4419640302658081,
0.29921647906303406,
-1.0155832767486572,
-0.1466599404811859,
0.4026505947113037,
-0.6949296593666077,
0.3340907096862793,
-0.28162190318107605,
-0.47664839029312134,
-0.03707238286733627,
-0.5529989004135132,
-0.18577542901039124,
0.488651305437088,
-0.6645669937133789,
0.2753506898880005,
0.30947452783584595,
0.12628872692584991,
-0.659591019153595,
-0.8908127546310425,
0.07441922277212143,
-0.053654976189136505,
-0.5533430576324463,
0.058436810970306396,
-0.2966931164264679,
-0.17787638306617737,
-0.07941506803035736,
-0.0348893478512764,
0.04691000282764435,
0.3281615674495697,
0.36205893754959106,
0.09715394675731659,
0.023924119770526886,
0.4053068161010742,
-0.14879712462425232,
-0.08685316145420074,
0.34385865926742554,
-0.19157947599887848,
0.4399595558643341,
-0.16593873500823975,
-0.09962432086467743,
-0.5967164039611816,
0.009137513116002083,
0.0549573190510273,
0.09002475440502167,
0.8201976418495178,
0.6493526101112366,
0.2562885582447052,
-0.1407417356967926,
-0.2834077477455139,
-0.606163740158081,
-0.5596005320549011,
0.19014999270439148,
-0.13063494861125946,
-0.8754668831825256,
0.09056268632411957,
0.12333771586418152,
0.013675486668944359,
-0.2116481512784958,
0.15695509314537048,
-0.8063751459121704,
0.9688658714294434,
0.8524594306945801,
0.09557322412729263,
0.9934903383255005,
-0.392484575510025,
0.09362564235925674,
-1.0685943365097046,
-0.53084796667099,
-0.061991047114133835,
-0.5513776540756226,
-0.6659319996833801,
-0.3767002820968628,
0.07271655648946762,
-0.20264214277267456,
-0.23230427503585815,
-0.06915339827537537,
-0.24446077644824982,
0.6831719279289246,
0.5639513731002808,
0.4232909679412842,
0.6415145397186279,
0.39432305097579956,
0.12901782989501953,
-0.26247531175613403,
-0.36498042941093445,
-0.4633116126060486,
1.0775254964828491,
0.277040958404541,
1.1191942691802979,
0.18076103925704956,
0.8487929701805115,
0.511206865310669,
0.6422672867774963,
-1.1575137376785278,
0.7977312803268433,
-0.18772703409194946,
-0.2612549662590027,
0.028371762484312057,
-0.3738175332546234,
-1.041200041770935,
0.13239434361457825,
-0.1981467455625534,
-0.9108743667602539,
-0.09583758562803268,
0.4495423436164856,
0.13763760030269623,
0.4334828555583954,
-0.6750950813293457,
0.34162989258766174,
-0.26720482110977173,
-0.5089200139045715,
-0.5841494202613831,
-0.47299277782440186,
0.38498425483703613,
0.37563422322273254,
0.3048554062843323,
-0.15299558639526367,
-0.15659835934638977,
0.8993926644325256,
-0.018984632566571236,
1.070237636566162,
-0.36064279079437256,
-0.18304724991321564,
0.33964696526527405,
0.16990448534488678,
0.3909358084201813,
0.09176923334598541,
0.005480806343257427,
-0.08029142022132874,
-0.33165672421455383,
-0.42009636759757996,
-0.7443460822105408,
0.626064121723175,
-0.9836148023605347,
-0.7568005919456482,
-0.18945905566215515,
-0.5488656163215637,
-0.2218632847070694,
-0.02030440792441368,
-0.002951645292341709,
0.15322236716747284,
0.10447324812412262,
0.44192013144493103,
1.0738747119903564,
-0.1406129002571106,
0.4288662075996399,
0.8640329837799072,
-0.01324065774679184,
-0.30544358491897583,
0.9738081693649292,
-0.23471200466156006,
0.23024573922157288,
0.4747198820114136,
-0.027753399685025215,
-0.21758370101451874,
-0.27736788988113403,
-0.23907417058944702,
0.4862411618232727,
-1.0466123819351196,
-0.11444966495037079,
-0.6797146201133728,
0.06703575700521469,
-0.20704951882362366,
-0.10139200091362,
-0.167596235871315,
-0.24042311310768127,
-0.3774990737438202,
-0.2788720428943634,
0.41896164417266846,
1.023780345916748,
-0.11472386121749878,
0.7497807145118713,
-0.753119945526123,
0.185309499502182,
0.529729962348938,
0.6853770017623901,
0.30765020847320557,
-0.6886866688728333,
-0.4079303741455078,
0.1597544550895691,
-0.6688627600669861,
-0.7200684547424316,
0.14264212548732758,
0.3848951458930969,
0.6222889423370361,
0.4944287836551666,
-0.3098311424255371,
0.5647163391113281,
-0.024861129000782967,
0.5780990123748779,
-0.0002995869144797325,
-0.8798463344573975,
0.7310339212417603,
-0.3127759099006653,
0.19187456369400024,
0.2475551813840866,
0.4067399501800537,
-0.7943334579467773,
-0.3013717234134674,
-0.30046460032463074,
-0.41454166173934937,
0.7292198538780212,
0.014512734487652779,
0.5349979996681213,
-0.2781272828578949,
0.5246469974517822,
-0.021194718778133392,
0.39775320887565613,
-0.867214024066925,
-0.18611539900302887,
-0.37409061193466187,
0.040983375161886215,
-0.05554238706827164,
-0.49939197301864624,
0.0355178564786911,
-0.40127047896385193,
0.750484049320221,
-0.08983448147773743,
0.6213641166687012,
0.06821230798959732,
-0.4358136057853699,
-0.3535054326057434,
0.31459668278694153,
0.449201762676239,
0.3424667716026306,
-0.33961108326911926,
0.21872073411941528,
0.05758276581764221,
-0.6589954495429993,
0.28187689185142517,
-0.4819923937320709,
0.00003784871660172939,
-0.3087007403373718,
0.3878646194934845,
0.6833884716033936,
0.4788827896118164,
-0.7053276300430298,
0.5681582689285278,
-0.48172998428344727,
-0.3055400252342224,
-0.11151380091905594,
0.5426505208015442,
0.395464688539505,
0.313347190618515,
0.2663046717643738,
-0.22113557159900665,
0.05939198285341263,
-0.4978041350841522,
0.21360337734222412,
0.45516109466552734,
-0.3755127787590027,
-0.46289756894111633,
0.344243586063385,
0.38978251814842224,
-0.16461433470249176,
0.9220755100250244,
-0.12331315129995346,
-0.26852062344551086,
0.7107719779014587,
0.6383616924285889,
0.6771595478057861,
0.009828840382397175,
0.5571821928024292,
0.14167359471321106,
0.21848347783088684,
0.1170072853565216,
0.472085177898407,
-0.5244186520576477,
-0.899200439453125,
-0.6790212988853455,
-0.5094764232635498,
-0.5027845501899719,
0.06328283250331879,
-0.6767816543579102,
0.22861401736736298,
-0.3583065867424011,
0.0009634238667786121,
-0.06391638517379761,
0.1867416352033615,
-0.9204338788986206,
0.11815960705280304,
0.3244350552558899,
0.9324526190757751,
-0.8503001928329468,
0.9474756717681885,
1.0080959796905518,
-0.3515523672103882,
-0.7811272144317627,
0.013565141707658768,
-0.08184721320867538,
-1.1213549375534058,
0.9753919243812561,
0.36575233936309814,
-0.3705065846443176,
0.059079401195049286,
-0.717547595500946,
-0.9330364465713501,
1.1340484619140625,
0.402607798576355,
-0.6057741641998291,
0.2314642369747162,
0.04899262636899948,
0.5290655493736267,
-0.3510986268520355,
0.3100379407405853,
0.36085036396980286,
0.20899906754493713,
0.3836791217327118,
-0.452806293964386,
-0.1175907775759697,
-0.21459712088108063,
-0.10928086191415787,
0.15577788650989532,
-0.6988301277160645,
0.4392644464969635,
-0.6195589303970337,
-0.19104830920696259,
-0.22080281376838684,
0.5582718849182129,
0.1362869143486023,
0.5808360576629639,
0.6251174211502075,
0.46046191453933716,
0.6536064743995667,
0.13364052772521973,
1.1013950109481812,
0.032073408365249634,
0.1912311613559723,
1.0641591548919678,
0.05703163146972656,
0.8551250100135803,
0.7572501301765442,
0.07596047222614288,
0.9624791741371155,
0.7421044707298279,
0.2136639803647995,
0.6896893978118896,
0.07920053601264954,
-0.3287223279476166,
-0.3213096857070923,
-0.4044994115829468,
0.05042044818401337,
0.47163820266723633,
0.5577463507652283,
-0.2889229655265808,
-0.19824348390102386,
0.12277975678443909,
0.04663289338350296,
0.04955426976084709,
-0.3762144148349762,
1.1590297222137451,
0.21138004958629608,
-0.596337080001831,
0.6196926832199097,
-0.39602339267730713,
0.8130950927734375,
-0.3424006998538971,
0.05632994696497917,
-0.5623533725738525,
0.14995308220386505,
-0.4957559108734131,
-1.0760895013809204,
0.41197699308395386,
0.10578693449497223,
-0.10901257395744324,
-0.23898395895957947,
0.8740952610969543,
-0.26781386137008667,
0.18012389540672302,
0.5107987523078918,
0.3672802448272705,
0.3955877423286438,
-0.020900534465909004,
-0.385005384683609,
0.260955810546875,
-0.1518518328666687,
-0.4708090126514435,
0.5352166295051575,
0.09293635189533234,
0.044130247086286545,
0.9297035336494446,
0.7088721394538879,
0.09427381306886673,
-0.09994624555110931,
0.06412898749113083,
1.1039175987243652,
-0.7010956406593323,
-0.28863781690597534,
-0.7118386626243591,
0.39417174458503723,
-0.1057959645986557,
0.24670928716659546,
0.6574603915214539,
0.2799510359764099,
1.1422119140625,
-0.16598102450370789,
0.6740671992301941,
0.2010582536458969,
0.23565825819969177,
-0.32202067971229553,
0.30303844809532166,
-0.5227961540222168,
0.3594861924648285,
-0.011266245506703854,
-0.7490085363388062,
-0.031970396637916565,
0.457571804523468,
-0.6890687942504883,
-0.1627219319343567,
0.4537070393562317,
0.7221711277961731,
-0.11345779895782471,
-0.03160754218697548,
0.2651231288909912,
0.022186733782291412,
0.5197274088859558,
0.4130347967147827,
0.946811318397522,
-0.12293653190135956,
0.9573574662208557,
-0.43590247631073,
-0.10602936893701553,
-0.3814214766025543,
-0.7952657341957092,
-1.1314871311187744,
-0.11922480911016464,
-0.046736814081668854,
-0.3087915778160095,
0.3699854612350464,
0.7706577777862549,
0.8654905557632446,
-0.3953084349632263,
-0.3604312241077423,
-0.1565674990415573,
0.4931418299674988,
-0.17012278735637665,
-0.25622138381004333,
-0.015135597437620163,
-0.4868232309818268,
-0.490972101688385,
0.19664299488067627,
0.3090965747833252,
0.05189945176243782,
0.04687266796827316,
-0.4188281297683716,
-0.1608869582414627,
0.1918262541294098,
0.8475563526153564,
0.3466450870037079,
-0.4443322420120239,
-0.32530754804611206,
0.23344112932682037,
-0.04525071382522583,
0.21131861209869385,
0.915642261505127,
-0.8252288103103638,
0.5004595518112183,
0.2947656810283661,
0.6202089190483093,
0.7696241736412048,
0.06752278655767441,
0.2856762409210205,
-0.8803682923316956,
0.3109113872051239,
-0.25882041454315186,
0.17836879193782806,
0.6775000095367432,
-0.5718480348587036,
0.32547953724861145,
0.3421367108821869,
-0.5927611589431763,
-0.46426162123680115,
0.3688107430934906,
-0.7652910947799683,
-0.027617543935775757,
1.1352572441101074,
-0.07983525097370148,
-0.5284342765808105,
0.14377941191196442,
-0.1649322807788849,
0.3963560163974762,
-0.7176740765571594,
1.0580211877822876,
0.4660508334636688,
-0.3680887818336487,
-0.6587409973144531,
-0.7405918836593628,
0.4813256561756134,
0.5055586695671082,
-0.946499764919281,
-0.30280601978302,
0.16303247213363647,
0.7460553646087646,
-0.5094401240348816,
0.8924288153648376,
0.18266814947128296,
0.40623563528060913,
-0.4909802973270416,
0.06493230909109116,
-0.07505414634943008,
-0.264725923538208,
-0.2121528685092926,
-0.5537107586860657,
0.37649741768836975,
-0.5560412406921387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00903v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00903v1
|
A Named Entity Recognition and Topic Modeling-based Solution for Locating and Better Assessment of Natural Disasters in Social Media
| 2024-05-01T23:19:49 | 2024-05-01T23:19:49 |
Ayaz Mehmood, Muhammad Tayyab Zamir, Muhammad Asif Ayub, Nasir Ahmad, Kashif Ahmad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Over the last decade, similar to other application domains, social media
content has been proven very effective in disaster informatics. However, due to
the unstructured nature of the data, several challenges are associated with
disaster analysis in social media content. To fully explore the potential of
social media content in disaster informatics, access to relevant content and
the correct geo-location information is very critical. In this paper, we
propose a three-step solution to tackling these challenges. Firstly, the
proposed solution aims to classify social media posts into relevant and
irrelevant posts followed by the automatic extraction of location information
from the posts' text through Named Entity Recognition (NER) analysis. Finally,
to quickly analyze the topics covered in large volumes of social media posts,
we perform topic modeling resulting in a list of top keywords, that highlight
the issues discussed in the tweet. For the Relevant Classification of Twitter
Posts (RCTP), we proposed a merit-based fusion framework combining the
capabilities of four different models namely BERT, RoBERTa, Distil BERT, and
ALBERT obtaining the highest F1-score of 0.933 on a benchmark dataset. For the
Location Extraction from Twitter Text (LETT), we evaluated four models namely
BERT, RoBERTa, Distil BERTA, and Electra in an NER framework obtaining the
highest F1-score of 0.960. For topic modeling, we used the BERTopic library to
discover the hidden topic patterns in the relevant tweets. The experimental
results of all the components of the proposed end-to-end solution are very
encouraging and hint at the potential of social media content and NLP in
disaster management.
|
[
-0.4941098988056183,
-0.8725450038909912,
0.6949889063835144,
0.5445365309715271,
-0.453125923871994,
0.4083267152309418,
-0.1749628335237503,
-0.3110327422618866,
0.6018323302268982,
0.43222981691360474,
-0.33997565507888794,
-0.45088720321655273,
-0.8010063171386719,
0.15718017518520355,
-0.8190281987190247,
0.7581496238708496,
-0.16230075061321259,
-0.2516400218009949,
0.2372906357049942,
0.055448807775974274,
-0.42112430930137634,
-0.03910505026578903,
-0.8905565738677979,
0.22069303691387177,
0.41971343755722046,
0.3279803693294525,
0.3443865180015564,
0.19662220776081085,
1.0255625247955322,
0.33278587460517883,
-0.16752608120441437,
0.016070041805505753,
-0.48606741428375244,
-0.030273042619228363,
-0.6320030093193054,
0.26128312945365906,
-0.010747762396931648,
-0.26604241132736206,
0.6450725793838501,
0.28810930252075195,
-0.16739685833454132,
0.08529579639434814,
0.15700624883174896,
0.3376140296459198,
-0.41453641653060913,
-0.19871875643730164,
-0.6807705760002136,
-0.2747660279273987,
-0.003820043057203293,
-0.6639525890350342,
0.02516085095703602,
-0.7039323449134827,
0.558130145072937,
-0.18828120827674866,
0.6051468253135681,
-0.007954442873597145,
1.035859227180481,
0.31498390436172485,
-0.4143739938735962,
-0.1700349599123001,
-0.8982931971549988,
0.7667405605316162,
-0.4070560336112976,
0.40600264072418213,
0.19793565571308136,
0.4259035885334015,
-0.2671896517276764,
-0.2381632924079895,
-0.5023178458213806,
0.3876543641090393,
0.18748579919338226,
-0.2116113305091858,
-0.02809438668191433,
-0.25946781039237976,
0.059573862701654434,
0.1964217722415924,
-0.5682369470596313,
-0.03384613245725632,
-0.2348918467760086,
-0.2845299243927002,
0.7878233194351196,
0.0305375624448061,
0.5150007605552673,
-0.9562340378761292,
-0.3580012321472168,
0.09903634339570999,
-0.5386115908622742,
-0.26054251194000244,
0.09613079577684402,
0.6325904130935669,
-0.48248353600502014,
0.4895298480987549,
-0.321538507938385,
0.5172842144966125,
-0.18571682274341583,
-0.36965662240982056,
-0.02797720953822136,
-0.18947771191596985,
-0.005071462597697973,
0.2785962224006653,
0.7638475298881531,
0.4683208763599396,
-0.09758058935403824,
-0.1948639303445816,
-0.2276468127965927,
-0.24334469437599182,
0.4050057828426361,
-0.6214200854301453,
-0.10115653276443481,
0.26539885997772217,
-0.560631513595581,
-0.4221436381340027,
0.1642739325761795,
-0.8609709143638611,
-0.8473895788192749,
-0.23974673449993134,
0.4368024468421936,
-0.46297967433929443,
-0.5183185338973999,
-0.0930432602763176,
-0.1000571921467781,
0.038071636110544205,
0.6188828349113464,
-0.5912455916404724,
0.007303007412701845,
0.6909902691841125,
1.231528401374817,
-0.05154355242848396,
0.17496556043624878,
-0.19713518023490906,
0.11066067218780518,
-0.010384955443441868,
1.2900574207305908,
-0.24511733651161194,
-0.0933922678232193,
0.024453720077872276,
0.08543206006288528,
0.0872640311717987,
-0.1648010015487671,
0.785736620426178,
-0.5940050482749939,
-0.07065803557634354,
-0.6034393310546875,
-0.3217441141605377,
-0.4654597043991089,
0.3916775584220886,
-0.8590561151504517,
0.8725680112838745,
0.17001532018184662,
-1.2740612030029297,
0.34032121300697327,
-0.6283368468284607,
-0.3622177839279175,
0.22387424111366272,
0.03994878754019737,
-0.3705921471118927,
0.13884788751602173,
0.4080164134502411,
0.5809996724128723,
-0.704836905002594,
0.5894764065742493,
-0.5421456098556519,
-0.3681234121322632,
-0.12263869494199753,
-0.25963354110717773,
0.5456603169441223,
0.028236951678991318,
-0.3553071916103363,
0.04566764459013939,
-0.5700796246528625,
-0.06600525230169296,
0.28802594542503357,
-0.2622286379337311,
-0.5041313767433167,
0.23360678553581238,
0.3577570617198944,
0.21617639064788818,
0.0010789950611069798,
-0.4017004370689392,
-0.12795978784561157,
-0.15992029011249542,
0.3211594521999359,
0.5814451575279236,
0.6405439376831055,
0.5526329278945923,
-0.18623246252536774,
0.13732625544071198,
-0.15419617295265198,
-0.014204849489033222,
0.296853244304657,
-0.39359211921691895,
-0.5538034439086914,
0.006942992564290762,
0.5516173243522644,
0.6745707392692566,
-0.8986396789550781,
0.3267359435558319,
-0.5394700169563293,
-0.6439914107322693,
-0.3475571572780609,
-0.33671772480010986,
-0.3121102452278137,
0.6352012753486633,
0.49266818165779114,
0.14352953433990479,
-0.832324206829071,
-0.6048286557197571,
0.052208397537469864,
-0.2703480124473572,
-0.039272014051675797,
0.027868609875440598,
0.47986847162246704,
-0.14524506032466888,
1.0316320657730103,
-0.32444560527801514,
-0.10479550063610077,
-0.5214009284973145,
0.3481441140174866,
0.15179528295993805,
0.07508528977632523,
0.6110414266586304,
-1.3685157299041748,
-0.36048227548599243,
-0.06539952754974365,
-0.7853170037269592,
-0.17180463671684265,
-0.017994245514273643,
-0.14988106489181519,
0.1271074116230011,
-0.1891663372516632,
-0.3889610171318054,
0.5486254692077637,
0.12629638612270355,
-0.04191342368721962,
0.17562836408615112,
0.3626316785812378,
0.588786244392395,
-1.3892549276351929,
0.07251173257827759,
0.26803410053253174,
-0.0432962030172348,
-0.6249834895133972,
-0.22472286224365234,
0.042183540761470795,
-0.3589489459991455,
-0.46108704805374146,
0.6060030460357666,
-0.16618604958057404,
-0.24425742030143738,
-0.4245440661907196,
0.15554502606391907,
-0.39986467361450195,
-0.16152852773666382,
0.3937092125415802,
0.23814065754413605,
0.6531651020050049,
-0.5715241432189941,
0.35957106947898865,
0.05977378413081169,
-0.2787725627422333,
0.4710484445095062,
-0.5051469802856445,
-0.1765335649251938,
-0.3746628761291504,
0.14195579290390015,
-0.7478446960449219,
-0.5028257369995117,
0.39248326420783997,
-0.5024476051330566,
0.041073817759752274,
-0.25240227580070496,
-0.5874687433242798,
-0.5712665319442749,
-0.22590488195419312,
-0.07224534451961517,
0.1647932529449463,
-0.3033375144004822,
0.7656629681587219,
0.5850721001625061,
-0.4795583188533783,
-0.3850289583206177,
-0.09774421900510788,
0.18819689750671387,
-0.61380934715271,
-0.5371209979057312,
0.6061536073684692,
0.09802110493183136,
-0.176459401845932,
0.32058313488960266,
-0.2762660086154938,
-0.3070128560066223,
0.3522411286830902,
0.36373046040534973,
0.05526546388864517,
-0.02072964608669281,
0.08738085627555847,
-0.0729488804936409,
-0.20276090502738953,
-0.25599125027656555,
0.09740179032087326,
0.6698775291442871,
-0.004004874266684055,
0.03671664744615555,
-0.36933356523513794,
0.5028679370880127,
0.267333984375,
-0.2040480077266693,
0.8695716261863708,
0.5044460296630859,
-1.0858358144760132,
0.07246799767017365,
-0.6848466396331787,
-0.09389913082122803,
-0.40972083806991577,
-0.008176064118742943,
0.17021481692790985,
-0.7629173994064331,
0.6598621606826782,
-0.22653312981128693,
0.03841269761323929,
0.5402284264564514,
0.2338636964559555,
-0.23075981438159943,
0.43450403213500977,
0.8822892308235168,
-0.32798898220062256,
0.42416223883628845,
-0.252047061920166,
0.6649298667907715,
-0.30300891399383545,
-0.162398561835289,
-0.49787309765815735,
-0.17879825830459595,
-0.43064120411872864,
-0.26098090410232544,
0.15031100809574127,
0.10625538229942322,
0.012091175653040409,
0.6875360012054443,
-0.4981727600097656,
0.25080540776252747,
0.20714658498764038,
0.12279251962900162,
0.008058048784732819,
0.33387336134910583,
0.3810303509235382,
-0.1673084944486618,
-0.45606011152267456,
-0.7216037511825562,
0.527849555015564,
0.3563588559627533,
0.4759860932826996,
0.18837875127792358,
1.2468371391296387,
0.38601231575012207,
0.6565513610839844,
-0.37515661120414734,
0.5842453241348267,
0.16690513491630554,
-0.5360420942306519,
-0.4535425901412964,
-0.5966382622718811,
-0.3926745057106018,
-0.08845214545726776,
-0.35006335377693176,
-0.738289475440979,
0.1743815541267395,
-0.25715112686157227,
-0.7059134840965271,
0.49622347950935364,
-0.4201229512691498,
0.4656356871128082,
-0.13575683534145355,
-0.0371452160179615,
-0.07326488941907883,
-0.4960673451423645,
0.1736595630645752,
-0.25877436995506287,
0.4017704725265503,
-0.25961771607398987,
0.20671477913856506,
0.626652717590332,
-0.19785986840724945,
0.40788015723228455,
-0.20245224237442017,
-0.10747098922729492,
0.576067328453064,
-0.058854203671216965,
0.30465540289878845,
0.4242089092731476,
-0.22884102165699005,
0.1252935230731964,
-0.5179445743560791,
-0.12352880090475082,
-0.5199754238128662,
0.9220929741859436,
-0.5028949975967407,
-0.31417641043663025,
-0.4491245150566101,
-0.21975281834602356,
0.16662009060382843,
0.32436683773994446,
0.34152624011039734,
0.4473077058792114,
-0.1839645355939865,
0.06574568152427673,
0.6289896368980408,
-0.3605493903160095,
0.8189627528190613,
0.6598418354988098,
0.22827228903770447,
-0.4923042356967926,
1.2289104461669922,
0.3578616976737976,
-0.465034157037735,
0.7591708898544312,
-0.14596770703792572,
-0.2927505373954773,
-0.7040697932243347,
-0.026118509471416473,
0.2681942582130432,
-0.4833684265613556,
-0.6459203362464905,
-1.051190733909607,
-0.48732680082321167,
-0.40880286693573,
-0.42309141159057617,
-0.3494478762149811,
-0.10992351919412613,
-0.38644129037857056,
-0.29509615898132324,
0.3508961796760559,
0.434804230928421,
-0.32114675641059875,
0.24677111208438873,
-0.7725048661231995,
0.5388658046722412,
-0.1910548061132431,
0.4978286623954773,
-0.03864387050271034,
-0.21232032775878906,
-0.015265055932104588,
0.06762123852968216,
-0.3563719391822815,
-1.1474426984786987,
0.4647100269794464,
-0.1048862636089325,
0.2770339548587799,
0.4795631468296051,
0.3272637128829956,
0.639130175113678,
-0.4282173216342926,
0.41219228506088257,
-0.0003146515809930861,
-0.581995964050293,
0.9313498735427856,
-0.5737736821174622,
-0.2549002170562744,
0.6147948503494263,
0.739879846572876,
-0.5352181196212769,
-0.30164018273353577,
-0.6547924280166626,
-0.8504114151000977,
0.4777223467826843,
0.4542725384235382,
-0.0718291699886322,
-0.289374440908432,
0.18310131132602692,
-0.21455633640289307,
-0.06807473301887512,
-0.8075253963470459,
0.009788881056010723,
-0.09572567045688629,
0.049298711121082306,
0.32609906792640686,
-0.38479575514793396,
0.1705179363489151,
0.0599837526679039,
0.6910078525543213,
0.27227750420570374,
0.3306441307067871,
0.1526489108800888,
-0.016785942018032074,
-0.21207523345947266,
0.12087713927030563,
0.2425377368927002,
0.495799720287323,
-0.6316356062889099,
0.013283221051096916,
0.10852660983800888,
-0.18480761349201202,
0.08693072199821472,
0.6234219670295715,
-0.2861168086528778,
0.25996822118759155,
0.493161678314209,
0.2650040090084076,
0.5096925497055054,
-0.38294172286987305,
0.3345118761062622,
-0.23673738539218903,
0.14026306569576263,
-0.45701736211776733,
-0.13260608911514282,
0.18371376395225525,
0.4265481233596802,
0.7094773054122925,
-0.07507923990488052,
0.40870755910873413,
-0.23073925077915192,
0.38853636384010315,
0.04030390456318855,
-0.31992578506469727,
-0.11766476184129715,
0.38502833247184753,
0.275152325630188,
-0.5005412101745605,
0.7140786051750183,
-0.3997659981250763,
-0.617640495300293,
0.6206992864608765,
0.24706827104091644,
0.8611835241317749,
-0.6661456823348999,
0.7397438287734985,
0.6346152424812317,
0.4275631308555603,
-0.26176947355270386,
0.7466020584106445,
0.15644124150276184,
-0.6412471532821655,
-0.16089564561843872,
-0.8629133701324463,
-0.05526161193847656,
0.21079546213150024,
-0.361286997795105,
0.6965165138244629,
-0.4682713747024536,
-0.2952982485294342,
0.2304946482181549,
0.03784310445189476,
-0.5558802485466003,
0.32925790548324585,
0.10776226967573166,
0.7773967385292053,
-0.9356247186660767,
0.14597490429878235,
0.720198929309845,
-0.2645733952522278,
-0.7613338828086853,
0.3251712918281555,
-0.09263980388641357,
-0.08720441162586212,
0.31188255548477173,
0.4161154329776764,
0.4312785565853119,
0.07891083508729935,
-0.48435699939727783,
-1.2623809576034546,
1.0911085605621338,
0.26468321681022644,
-0.2542763352394104,
-0.17045632004737854,
0.20186199247837067,
0.4254681169986725,
-0.16120626032352448,
0.12669815123081207,
0.09769833832979202,
0.31122028827667236,
0.13882455229759216,
-0.7742819786071777,
0.12192989140748978,
-0.12196360528469086,
0.11326007544994354,
0.5768604874610901,
-0.4470546841621399,
0.2742744982242584,
-0.3328969478607178,
-0.5763893723487854,
-0.26132646203041077,
0.70857834815979,
0.26608794927597046,
0.5738728046417236,
0.42650702595710754,
0.5851691365242004,
0.5287417769432068,
-0.2133113443851471,
0.9857221245765686,
0.06541819870471954,
0.8606087565422058,
0.8098584413528442,
-0.13464361429214478,
0.8026896119117737,
0.2190304696559906,
0.12337242066860199,
0.25703808665275574,
1.1096903085708618,
0.0805092602968216,
1.0363175868988037,
-0.038845714181661606,
-0.3007729947566986,
-0.1755322962999344,
-0.5096508264541626,
-0.33072057366371155,
0.21315830945968628,
0.5090837478637695,
-0.4389082193374634,
-0.7978682518005371,
-0.023455826565623283,
-0.12022648751735687,
-0.25875088572502136,
-0.27202844619750977,
0.5395230650901794,
0.09587936103343964,
-0.15044939517974854,
0.1829371154308319,
0.3197501599788666,
0.30755823850631714,
-0.29207026958465576,
-0.30220744013786316,
-0.05018147453665733,
-0.4909965395927429,
-0.24110376834869385,
-0.7410758137702942,
0.7856146693229675,
0.037412699311971664,
-0.25261542201042175,
-0.05683039501309395,
1.0819604396820068,
-0.10302403569221497,
-0.700874388217926,
0.33473941683769226,
0.23504993319511414,
0.006090791895985603,
-0.342445969581604,
-0.4976763427257538,
0.19848743081092834,
-0.2031201422214508,
-0.02855869196355343,
-0.02943502739071846,
0.5208162665367126,
-0.23110923171043396,
0.6882196068763733,
0.4764784872531891,
-0.17660433053970337,
-0.3977116346359253,
0.09211788326501846,
0.8885441422462463,
-0.8174446821212769,
-0.6702008843421936,
-0.879968523979187,
0.49595290422439575,
-0.4052473306655884,
-0.038118038326501846,
0.4470650851726532,
0.36402952671051025,
0.2654244303703308,
0.20972268283367157,
0.8262481689453125,
-0.7156538963317871,
0.8545674681663513,
-0.05743774399161339,
0.7370465397834778,
-0.5524113178253174,
0.29049041867256165,
-0.9031789898872375,
-1.1682665348052979,
-0.3832307457923889,
0.5550143718719482,
-0.4495930075645447,
-0.2281339466571808,
0.42527851462364197,
0.5175143480300903,
-0.19786494970321655,
0.19941601157188416,
-0.21519148349761963,
-0.0914793461561203,
0.27951863408088684,
0.3418568968772888,
0.8282877802848816,
-0.4067141115665436,
0.27692002058029175,
-0.371072381734848,
-0.18104000389575958,
-0.44768813252449036,
-0.9678149819374084,
-0.8345848917961121,
-0.7960502505302429,
-0.4465928077697754,
-0.12839005887508392,
0.005452602636069059,
0.7328077554702759,
0.4359877407550812,
-0.8172273635864258,
0.442697137594223,
-0.06817127764225006,
0.668565034866333,
0.15002509951591492,
-0.3290126323699951,
0.5715736150741577,
0.3413727283477783,
-0.20835816860198975,
0.13324306905269623,
0.5831734538078308,
0.2174551635980606,
0.028300805017352104,
0.2997475862503052,
-0.2715083956718445,
-0.08982408046722412,
0.43168526887893677,
0.19371676445007324,
-0.7024447917938232,
-0.5349825024604797,
-0.008344233967363834,
0.0029414587188512087,
-0.31881827116012573,
0.544257402420044,
-0.5257691144943237,
0.02520303800702095,
0.5327867865562439,
0.813826322555542,
-0.04876140132546425,
0.28177881240844727,
0.2539011836051941,
-0.5291105508804321,
-0.21284940838813782,
0.22393913567066193,
0.3264361619949341,
0.7564133405685425,
-0.6401682496070862,
0.7236931920051575,
0.26692327857017517,
-0.24273747205734253,
-0.9796825647354126,
-0.12521855533123016,
-0.8498019576072693,
0.06886167079210281,
1.1217714548110962,
0.18662969768047333,
-0.01682463102042675,
-0.22844620048999786,
-0.08961180597543716,
0.4372537434101105,
-0.5158191323280334,
1.3174326419830322,
0.6545579433441162,
0.1337154656648636,
-0.5896504521369934,
-0.6339603662490845,
0.2594321370124817,
-0.2166900634765625,
-0.7631126642227173,
-0.31680285930633545,
0.21393674612045288,
0.5022662878036499,
0.43688535690307617,
0.7329447269439697,
0.022652676329016685,
0.19939970970153809,
-0.5516679286956787,
-0.09511458873748779,
0.5897094011306763,
-0.6725475788116455,
-0.020052727311849594,
0.29632309079170227,
-0.487529456615448,
0.07566498965024948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00899v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00899v2
|
Characterising the Creative Process in Humans and Large Language Models
| 2024-05-01T23:06:46 | 2024-06-05T19:15:43 |
Surabhi S. Nath, Peter Dayan, Claire Stevenson
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, q-bio.NC
|
Large language models appear quite creative, often performing on par with the
average human on creative tasks. However, research on LLM creativity has
focused solely on \textit{products}, with little attention on the creative
\textit{process}. Process analyses of human creativity often require hand-coded
categories or exploit response times, which do not apply to LLMs. We provide an
automated method to characterise how humans and LLMs explore semantic spaces on
the Alternate Uses Task, and contrast with behaviour in a Verbal Fluency Task.
We use sentence embeddings to identify response categories and compute semantic
similarities, which we use to generate jump profiles. Our results corroborate
earlier work in humans reporting both persistent (deep search in few semantic
spaces) and flexible (broad search across multiple semantic spaces) pathways to
creativity, where both pathways lead to similar creativity scores. LLMs were
found to be biased towards either persistent or flexible paths, that varied
across tasks. Though LLMs as a population match human profiles, their
relationship with creativity is different, where the more flexible models score
higher on creativity. Our dataset and scripts are available on
\href{https://github.com/surabhisnath/Creative_Process}{GitHub}.
|
[
-0.3683815002441406,
-1.0185096263885498,
0.7240012884140015,
0.2836951017379761,
0.05503680929541588,
0.45260557532310486,
-0.37880739569664,
-0.4662455916404724,
0.4372240900993347,
0.4646265208721161,
-0.9342348575592041,
-0.5132281184196472,
-0.3761902451515198,
0.15242448449134827,
-0.25599122047424316,
0.4366142749786377,
-0.08712548017501831,
-0.2138025015592575,
-0.3057304322719574,
-0.05514451488852501,
-0.4083409309387207,
-0.2662923038005829,
-0.5181074142456055,
-0.43629971146583557,
0.980096697807312,
0.442192018032074,
0.7770631313323975,
0.3792046904563904,
0.24612830579280853,
0.3764442205429077,
-0.3735235631465912,
0.08783502131700516,
-0.6142086982727051,
0.2276749312877655,
-0.46419185400009155,
-0.3094070851802826,
-0.1937633752822876,
0.27865028381347656,
0.34303465485572815,
0.717160701751709,
-0.08391767740249634,
0.06925105303525925,
-0.005695770028978586,
0.6015342473983765,
-0.21149154007434845,
-0.10664180666208267,
-0.6015098094940186,
0.07302755117416382,
-0.5379751324653625,
-0.3155081868171692,
-0.18039582669734955,
-0.24731308221817017,
-0.008276359178125858,
-0.5523035526275635,
0.43234971165657043,
0.004865200724452734,
0.46920785307884216,
0.14178705215454102,
-0.3387661874294281,
-0.6344780921936035,
-0.7979931831359863,
0.5975057482719421,
-0.5580624341964722,
0.1180083155632019,
0.06629807502031326,
0.22068366408348083,
-0.47563475370407104,
-0.6696827411651611,
-0.7518373727798462,
-0.464801162481308,
0.24179519712924957,
-0.09888699650764465,
0.013531148433685303,
-0.11213195323944092,
0.44050103425979614,
0.39553654193878174,
-0.7505056262016296,
0.3397190272808075,
-0.18177922070026398,
-0.15772458910942078,
0.8586885333061218,
0.4921513795852661,
0.5915163159370422,
0.10181588679552078,
-0.30342939496040344,
-0.25152134895324707,
-0.4865591824054718,
0.32990026473999023,
0.6485763192176819,
-0.024789344519376755,
0.21777373552322388,
1.054518699645996,
-0.37517663836479187,
0.521324634552002,
-0.20952975749969482,
-0.1281968653202057,
0.4059913456439972,
-0.30539771914482117,
0.05223461985588074,
-0.5657446980476379,
0.7540863156318665,
0.26497918367385864,
0.4786674380302429,
-0.4212194085121155,
-0.42758792638778687,
0.14393644034862518,
0.3726445734500885,
-0.4292638599872589,
-0.06076700612902641,
-0.07112067937850952,
-0.24579013884067535,
0.014447801746428013,
0.024300098419189453,
-0.31001418828964233,
-0.5127753019332886,
-0.2906564176082611,
0.3584958016872406,
-0.35938405990600586,
-0.2312144637107849,
0.40066829323768616,
-0.4872753620147705,
0.08058382570743561,
0.07098068296909332,
-0.7111177444458008,
0.2866465747356415,
0.7540891766548157,
0.7872779369354248,
-0.5035904049873352,
-0.5796579718589783,
-0.12545239925384521,
-0.22920024394989014,
-0.32072609663009644,
0.9452545046806335,
-0.5576816201210022,
-0.2513573467731476,
-0.21846480667591095,
-0.02051202394068241,
-0.038364920765161514,
-0.718254804611206,
0.5545369982719421,
-0.6433456540107727,
0.08775103837251663,
-0.2456202507019043,
-0.6716927289962769,
-0.16965463757514954,
-0.0007948671700432897,
-0.903144359588623,
0.8775792717933655,
0.13238774240016937,
-0.6557879447937012,
0.6203774809837341,
-0.8393204808235168,
-0.32822728157043457,
0.3051290810108185,
-0.23876269161701202,
-0.06584285199642181,
0.3414231240749359,
-0.09724685549736023,
0.5259333252906799,
-0.20072734355926514,
0.26083096861839294,
-0.5052120685577393,
-0.49171561002731323,
0.8645618557929993,
-0.19037383794784546,
0.7630903124809265,
0.255917489528656,
-0.14178051054477692,
0.30313393473625183,
-0.9348659515380859,
-0.0014622360467910767,
0.22843711078166962,
-0.5149896144866943,
-0.1412242203950882,
-0.006299066357314587,
0.16785073280334473,
0.6202242374420166,
0.3078501224517822,
-0.5405910015106201,
0.3768535256385803,
-0.5466494560241699,
0.4941549301147461,
0.5195152759552002,
0.2788524031639099,
0.3551514148712158,
-0.5810319185256958,
0.7043612003326416,
-0.13570384681224823,
-0.17684395611286163,
0.10021951049566269,
-0.8243616819381714,
-0.527539074420929,
-0.3058389723300934,
-0.20034146308898926,
0.4852992296218872,
-0.38788577914237976,
0.6265525817871094,
-0.24874219298362732,
-0.6195105314254761,
-0.4392888844013214,
0.6089811325073242,
-0.03473338857293129,
0.212905153632164,
-0.021669190376996994,
-0.6563321352005005,
-0.38554292917251587,
-0.8555941581726074,
-0.6044254302978516,
0.01988629624247551,
-0.44353732466697693,
0.25921598076820374,
0.5475510358810425,
-0.4004081189632416,
1.1047892570495605,
-0.3280133605003357,
-0.06235070154070854,
-0.35125261545181274,
0.4931740462779999,
0.42786896228790283,
0.12770794332027435,
0.2819902300834656,
-0.715087354183197,
-0.3013155460357666,
-0.34111329913139343,
-0.44515088200569153,
-0.5243117213249207,
-0.36951327323913574,
-0.2860450744628906,
0.15647944808006287,
0.4165632128715515,
-0.8646784424781799,
0.4510623514652252,
0.10635531693696976,
-0.6954730153083801,
0.4435998499393463,
0.08545418083667755,
-0.09717369079589844,
-0.6168543696403503,
0.23700444400310516,
-0.06454841792583466,
0.10823420435190201,
-0.2801915109157562,
-0.06275801360607147,
-0.2669181525707245,
0.14888572692871094,
-0.5590310096740723,
0.5503313541412354,
-0.48113614320755005,
-0.25491073727607727,
-0.18655025959014893,
0.07970515638589859,
-0.01008394081145525,
0.4685489535331726,
0.18639984726905823,
0.5050158500671387,
0.3384973406791687,
-0.2877715528011322,
0.4309789538383484,
-0.07234508544206619,
-0.620032787322998,
0.23089230060577393,
-0.682612419128418,
0.449436753988266,
-0.04373174533247948,
0.0738440454006195,
-1.5332773923873901,
-0.3810386657714844,
-0.01736542023718357,
-0.377693235874176,
-0.08877252042293549,
0.35746854543685913,
-1.0048495531082153,
-0.5123810172080994,
-0.25946420431137085,
0.12553566694259644,
0.6486226320266724,
-0.017893265932798386,
0.4946877956390381,
0.22709855437278748,
-0.24398981034755707,
-0.006166223436594009,
-0.8050634264945984,
0.2037486881017685,
-0.6803117990493774,
-1.2105828523635864,
0.47563496232032776,
-0.5133373141288757,
-0.4719919264316559,
-0.1497770994901657,
0.044729236513376236,
0.018984101712703705,
0.3979232609272003,
0.2816857695579529,
0.09355603903532028,
-0.12058008462190628,
-0.14972294867038727,
-0.4517505168914795,
0.18876561522483826,
0.1872812956571579,
0.07404235005378723,
0.5759304165840149,
0.02544223889708519,
-0.2944106459617615,
-0.33558177947998047,
0.25091052055358887,
0.6461346745491028,
0.28280898928642273,
0.7243141531944275,
0.7811930179595947,
-0.0735543742775917,
-0.22223496437072754,
-0.5788929462432861,
0.09904781728982925,
-0.508467972278595,
0.18792705237865448,
-0.25229373574256897,
-0.9314350485801697,
0.763954758644104,
0.1581496298313141,
0.03947907313704491,
0.5119472742080688,
0.915594220161438,
-0.17503973841667175,
0.8282669186592102,
0.7447860836982727,
0.3244123160839081,
0.38878732919692993,
-0.24000902473926544,
0.11469302326440811,
-0.6556248068809509,
-0.30656373500823975,
-0.08046819269657135,
-0.6783209443092346,
-0.3603664040565491,
-0.5347750782966614,
0.09624191373586655,
0.19578099250793457,
-0.07670334726572037,
0.2254200577735901,
-0.37572911381721497,
0.6647124290466309,
0.3660082519054413,
-0.2409517616033554,
0.20551955699920654,
-0.19946196675300598,
-0.3457165062427521,
-0.17358815670013428,
-0.5183886289596558,
-0.6388431191444397,
0.9329700469970703,
0.35756954550743103,
0.940873920917511,
0.1000702902674675,
0.7735335826873779,
0.3169011175632477,
0.2778851091861725,
-0.9496522545814514,
0.8577327132225037,
0.1591709554195404,
-0.509922981262207,
-0.4565841257572174,
-0.2611323893070221,
-1.099501371383667,
-0.009873159229755402,
-0.02299874648451805,
-0.8900468349456787,
-0.15469539165496826,
-0.14401133358478546,
-0.3563719093799591,
0.1482464075088501,
-0.655827522277832,
0.7383981347084045,
-0.2846374809741974,
-0.49998804926872253,
-0.14379224181175232,
-0.5691900849342346,
0.33652734756469727,
-0.19749486446380615,
0.11051490157842636,
-0.3000445067882538,
-0.10802698135375977,
0.8363686203956604,
-0.08217522501945496,
0.9500249028205872,
0.05701228603720665,
-0.24341611564159393,
0.4208633601665497,
0.23933273553848267,
0.18435722589492798,
-0.09858296066522598,
-0.01082177646458149,
-0.13567912578582764,
-0.44121721386909485,
-0.12719807028770447,
-0.6507843732833862,
0.7388874888420105,
-0.47952505946159363,
-0.6461817026138306,
-0.17155912518501282,
-0.8032641410827637,
-0.26120278239250183,
0.0954209566116333,
0.28679966926574707,
-0.0708157867193222,
-0.3749052584171295,
0.13473732769489288,
0.2911709249019623,
-0.24778543412685394,
0.4396972060203552,
0.4765703082084656,
-0.14237599074840546,
-0.1720815896987915,
0.4334753751754761,
0.262910395860672,
0.18064822256565094,
0.2162012904882431,
0.2691277265548706,
-0.6357986927032471,
-0.35501378774642944,
-0.0768670067191124,
0.21616755425930023,
-0.7702392339706421,
0.3945501446723938,
-0.4803988039493561,
-0.12094138562679291,
-0.4283351004123688,
-0.2020096331834793,
-0.09170454740524292,
-0.6131845116615295,
-0.5148252844810486,
0.02172604762017727,
0.28885677456855774,
0.9187690019607544,
0.006887408439069986,
-0.12289819866418839,
-0.47716981172561646,
0.41917863488197327,
0.45627346634864807,
0.23747676610946655,
0.21949025988578796,
-0.549194872379303,
-0.004675780888646841,
-0.04633089154958725,
-0.5656507015228271,
-0.7494184374809265,
0.5320801734924316,
0.3486599326133728,
0.8086657524108887,
0.35878005623817444,
-0.421051561832428,
0.5867587924003601,
-0.3985850512981415,
1.0897527933120728,
-0.013787883333861828,
-0.6210985779762268,
0.43040964007377625,
-0.26270565390586853,
0.44985735416412354,
0.3392559587955475,
0.4230900704860687,
-0.6707825064659119,
-0.3729279041290283,
-0.6324362754821777,
-1.080000638961792,
0.3803085386753082,
0.2717294991016388,
0.07683955878019333,
-0.14922794699668884,
0.204057976603508,
0.2277391403913498,
-0.028416123241186142,
-0.6864581108093262,
0.14117814600467682,
0.15068645775318146,
-0.0008054366917349398,
-0.2965371608734131,
-0.02670873887836933,
-0.17756426334381104,
-0.21334193646907806,
0.24794912338256836,
0.0454801470041275,
0.03289244323968887,
-0.015109616331756115,
-0.04427780583500862,
-0.2859571874141693,
0.2375417947769165,
0.45261505246162415,
0.6697095036506653,
0.045858751982450485,
0.16952531039714813,
0.05339818075299263,
-0.26796239614486694,
0.24623315036296844,
-0.2586645185947418,
0.28243088722229004,
-0.13967491686344147,
0.5741267204284668,
0.5792315602302551,
0.14852946996688843,
-1.068735122680664,
0.31922999024391174,
-0.0969831719994545,
-0.197195366024971,
-0.504708468914032,
0.6727564930915833,
0.5132657289505005,
0.46838676929473877,
0.21097266674041748,
0.1809331327676773,
0.29370981454849243,
-0.7396762371063232,
0.12567324936389923,
0.34229516983032227,
0.09459850192070007,
-0.529033362865448,
0.5737009048461914,
-0.08897346258163452,
-0.8557504415512085,
0.6187558174133301,
-0.3743550181388855,
-0.06377503275871277,
0.6778769493103027,
0.46776556968688965,
1.2224147319793701,
0.3639366328716278,
0.07694419473409653,
-0.07050858438014984,
-0.14687083661556244,
-0.16736750304698944,
0.5455458760261536,
-0.10792367905378342,
-0.7971022725105286,
-0.5079296827316284,
-0.748132050037384,
-0.09323553740978241,
0.3309827744960785,
-0.3967399001121521,
0.31616300344467163,
-0.20295307040214539,
-0.22339126467704773,
0.23911994695663452,
-0.1144736185669899,
-0.9617168307304382,
-0.05168259143829346,
0.5530803799629211,
1.1548140048980713,
-0.9476578831672668,
0.7076495289802551,
0.866193950176239,
-0.3083536624908447,
-0.5263432860374451,
0.022508367896080017,
0.24748173356056213,
-0.580294132232666,
0.793592095375061,
0.36575448513031006,
-0.3799271285533905,
-0.15912975370883942,
-0.6198969483375549,
-0.8767508864402771,
1.0808441638946533,
0.07634726911783218,
-0.39214494824409485,
-0.20333445072174072,
0.23423713445663452,
0.9798653721809387,
-0.5371596217155457,
-0.15059347450733185,
0.6715254187583923,
0.19587033987045288,
0.39868077635765076,
-0.6760557889938354,
-0.13023780286312103,
-0.5997170209884644,
0.3197815716266632,
-0.183174267411232,
-0.31051331758499146,
0.6415579319000244,
-0.2913787364959717,
-0.5442394018173218,
0.43336221575737,
0.3701295256614685,
0.5537740588188171,
0.32395124435424805,
0.5624216198921204,
0.7319211959838867,
0.6917257905006409,
0.27968260645866394,
0.762012779712677,
-0.08736131340265274,
0.17426659166812897,
0.7593963742256165,
-0.45525383949279785,
0.9018784761428833,
0.5649908781051636,
-0.05743499472737312,
0.585181713104248,
0.6480554342269897,
-0.06889510154724121,
0.45305752754211426,
0.7000463008880615,
-0.09164220094680786,
-0.20787610113620758,
0.12603023648262024,
0.2729083001613617,
0.42405036091804504,
0.5432892441749573,
-0.2831878960132599,
0.11020731180906296,
-0.043087564408779144,
-0.24475596845149994,
0.13522061705589294,
-0.07805362343788147,
0.6885288953781128,
0.03248625621199608,
-0.9345232844352722,
0.6544240117073059,
-0.1850103884935379,
0.9221853613853455,
-0.4220586121082306,
0.09246829152107239,
-0.012977995909750462,
-0.11520496755838394,
-0.08332117646932602,
-1.5188918113708496,
0.50154048204422,
-0.06568330526351929,
-0.0016534862807020545,
-0.48422354459762573,
0.6980326771736145,
-0.27374714612960815,
-0.302166610956192,
0.29880356788635254,
0.6062381863594055,
0.31149283051490784,
0.11328991502523422,
-0.6192667484283447,
-0.060128696262836456,
-0.2197457104921341,
-0.6539034247398376,
0.0735936090350151,
0.7020451426506042,
-0.09922923147678375,
0.6698138117790222,
0.6768122911453247,
0.13873617351055145,
0.11811890453100204,
0.42482003569602966,
0.613028347492218,
-1.0522518157958984,
-0.5661373138427734,
-0.9223718047142029,
0.6038621664047241,
-0.12972797453403473,
-0.7727164030075073,
0.7313830256462097,
0.4964786469936371,
0.9170517921447754,
-0.3033057749271393,
0.41978323459625244,
-0.10536299645900726,
0.43990984559059143,
-0.6282582879066467,
0.565044105052948,
-0.5754286646842957,
0.37787142395973206,
-0.30766990780830383,
-0.9266371726989746,
-0.2996279001235962,
0.5669012069702148,
-0.23994290828704834,
0.02587229385972023,
0.5165756940841675,
1.0625234842300415,
-0.1340823918581009,
-0.19030052423477173,
0.2660381495952606,
0.17692460119724274,
0.16272911429405212,
0.6337341666221619,
1.5046861171722412,
0.5229709148406982,
0.048288680613040924,
-0.1210608035326004,
-0.2279260754585266,
-0.1944567859172821,
-0.8822678327560425,
-0.9349692463874817,
-0.7443709969520569,
-0.24889878928661346,
-0.12464896589517593,
-0.5447109341621399,
0.8427612781524658,
0.5292991995811462,
-0.19223937392234802,
-0.3053959310054779,
-0.313134104013443,
-0.18042021989822388,
-0.22676622867584229,
-0.29619452357292175,
-0.18204748630523682,
-0.18699197471141815,
-0.39812201261520386,
0.5381404757499695,
0.3649117946624756,
0.08856436610221863,
-0.6557829976081848,
-0.00758860120549798,
0.035272203385829926,
0.380313903093338,
0.5090570449829102,
0.20935077965259552,
-1.0613418817520142,
0.014211407862603664,
0.36781394481658936,
-0.20398086309432983,
0.07394327223300934,
0.9949878454208374,
-0.6714926362037659,
0.3070284128189087,
0.8539185523986816,
0.35010185837745667,
0.3139256536960602,
-0.1719595193862915,
0.23341898620128632,
-0.6849989891052246,
0.01660887897014618,
0.5291405916213989,
0.33074629306793213,
0.47351258993148804,
-0.4541996717453003,
0.4858161211013794,
0.4525265097618103,
-0.6981227993965149,
-0.44463488459587097,
0.3562968075275421,
-1.1421302556991577,
-0.26368874311447144,
1.2754316329956055,
-0.027070341631770134,
-0.28480958938598633,
-0.0763326957821846,
-0.36314138770103455,
0.07732255011796951,
-0.18053773045539856,
0.9905201196670532,
1.016535758972168,
-0.7027497887611389,
0.31513386964797974,
-0.5022919178009033,
0.3055301606655121,
0.1086728647351265,
-0.4286830723285675,
-0.07573559135198593,
0.38645094633102417,
0.5951502919197083,
0.3169204592704773,
0.7643421292304993,
-0.036369722336530685,
0.19032369554042816,
-0.23333804309368134,
-0.01658371090888977,
0.204414963722229,
-0.2886865735054016,
-0.3078189194202423,
0.22997581958770752,
0.29286515712738037,
0.22732579708099365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00888v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00888v1
|
DynaMo: Accelerating Language Model Inference with Dynamic Multi-Token Sampling
| 2024-05-01T22:17:57 | 2024-05-01T22:17:57 |
Shikhar Tuli, Chi-Heng Lin, Yen-Chang Hsu, Niraj K. Jha, Yilin Shen, Hongxia Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Traditional language models operate autoregressively, i.e., they predict one
token at a time. Rapid explosion in model sizes has resulted in high inference
times. In this work, we propose DynaMo, a suite of multi-token prediction
language models that reduce net inference times. Our models
$\textit{dynamically}$ predict multiple tokens based on their confidence in the
predicted joint probability distribution. We propose a lightweight technique to
train these models, leveraging the weights of traditional autoregressive
counterparts. Moreover, we propose novel ways to enhance the estimated joint
probability to improve text generation quality, namely co-occurrence weighted
masking and adaptive thresholding. We also propose systematic qualitative and
quantitative methods to rigorously test the quality of generated text for
non-autoregressive generation. One of the models in our suite, DynaMo-7.3B-T3,
achieves same-quality generated text as the baseline (Pythia-6.9B) while
achieving 2.57$\times$ speed-up with only 5.87% and 2.67% parameter and
training time overheads, respectively.
|
[
-0.21839214861392975,
-0.786348819732666,
0.2474890947341919,
0.29624098539352417,
-0.37332138419151306,
0.4638245105743408,
-0.1250392347574234,
-0.5883100628852844,
0.4256148934364319,
0.28616607189178467,
-0.593804121017456,
-0.4890764355659485,
-0.4878859221935272,
-0.16268423199653625,
-0.7193692326545715,
0.6983107328414917,
0.09972251951694489,
0.05430026352405548,
0.1036340519785881,
-0.03215564042329788,
-0.18410570919513702,
-0.2502690851688385,
-0.45117512345314026,
-0.09800128638744354,
0.4163660705089569,
0.4730461537837982,
0.7250630259513855,
0.6495679616928101,
0.29820600152015686,
0.27267688512802124,
-0.048059675842523575,
0.11445585638284683,
-0.19490168988704681,
0.682784378528595,
0.18783538043498993,
-0.3443719446659088,
-0.49565157294273376,
0.023565443232655525,
0.5837735533714294,
0.7502968907356262,
-0.20830599963665009,
0.5029868483543396,
-0.24533937871456146,
0.4008595645427704,
-0.8217326998710632,
0.031393639743328094,
-0.8469167351722717,
-0.0977754294872284,
-0.27426865696907043,
0.1887640357017517,
-0.45687171816825867,
-0.13561347126960754,
-0.09959667921066284,
-0.4301031827926636,
0.6309939026832581,
0.32073935866355896,
0.7228848934173584,
0.14322106540203094,
-0.3496754765510559,
0.06313401460647583,
-0.6748138070106506,
0.8440247178077698,
-0.6824617981910706,
0.4676614999771118,
0.3748272657394409,
0.5364832282066345,
-0.12532398104667664,
-1.1451514959335327,
-0.9549681544303894,
-0.15018117427825928,
0.2607910931110382,
0.1726333349943161,
0.20726576447486877,
-0.0067213671281933784,
-0.05648364871740341,
0.30132102966308594,
-0.2566022276878357,
0.2897231876850128,
0.10356909781694412,
-0.2612535059452057,
0.5782289505004883,
0.2660277485847473,
0.05445035919547081,
-0.4227426052093506,
-0.09103955328464508,
-0.4003998637199402,
-0.5898798108100891,
-0.04591380059719086,
0.8086950778961182,
0.46579045057296753,
-0.10217656940221786,
0.48914361000061035,
-0.3792986273765564,
0.7153937816619873,
0.2023874670267105,
-0.10838551074266434,
0.23609568178653717,
-0.6975259184837341,
-0.15574759244918823,
-0.3562976121902466,
0.9692199230194092,
0.14065934717655182,
-0.3201599717140198,
-0.26284489035606384,
-0.2772659361362457,
-0.21532171964645386,
0.13444636762142181,
-0.8799019455909729,
-0.5208802819252014,
0.48784270882606506,
-0.7386439442634583,
-0.4496802091598511,
0.00701267272233963,
-1.0377874374389648,
-0.3357994556427002,
-0.14745137095451355,
0.186345636844635,
-0.4772650897502899,
-0.3716866970062256,
0.11711063981056213,
-0.27814704179763794,
-0.30840522050857544,
0.41097286343574524,
-1.0217442512512207,
0.19811463356018066,
0.3352976441383362,
0.7468361258506775,
-0.12728747725486755,
-0.4237949252128601,
-0.7926849126815796,
0.15157945454120636,
-0.2476714551448822,
0.7501556277275085,
-0.37715205550193787,
-0.16732220351696014,
-0.0007772223325446248,
-0.2501111626625061,
0.014873942360281944,
-0.23260833323001862,
0.5537831783294678,
-0.5001466274261475,
0.3069697320461273,
0.08883883059024811,
-0.40616747736930847,
0.04273718222975731,
-0.22636789083480835,
-0.8370267748832703,
1.3249977827072144,
0.15926168859004974,
-0.7619920969009399,
0.9132905006408691,
-0.38591548800468445,
-0.6348438858985901,
-0.07630147784948349,
0.261678010225296,
-0.5609826445579529,
0.23600317537784576,
0.45525118708610535,
0.45963406562805176,
-0.5818012952804565,
0.4951973557472229,
-0.5279605388641357,
-0.11939810961484909,
0.023632917553186417,
-0.6794613003730774,
0.7133968472480774,
0.19819502532482147,
-0.42935171723365784,
0.4281768202781677,
-1.0367921590805054,
0.13332974910736084,
-0.15329262614250183,
-0.1412118673324585,
0.029072387143969536,
0.08815572410821915,
0.38861262798309326,
0.3193838894367218,
0.13136199116706848,
-0.48837903141975403,
0.07357729971408844,
-0.3789190948009491,
0.06704755872488022,
0.5861724019050598,
-0.23683740198612213,
0.5419284105300903,
-0.07905114442110062,
0.6107077598571777,
-0.10948791354894638,
0.2426021248102188,
-0.23166106641292572,
-0.3079722821712494,
-1.0019466876983643,
-0.6712563037872314,
0.715548574924469,
0.09299127012491226,
-1.026663064956665,
0.7313424944877625,
-0.381323903799057,
-0.8003759980201721,
-0.7355162501335144,
-0.15925627946853638,
0.13030511140823364,
0.2660022974014282,
0.4561625123023987,
-0.1223817989230156,
-0.5194898843765259,
-0.7071558833122253,
-0.39431101083755493,
-0.41307997703552246,
-0.18022426962852478,
0.1809738725423813,
0.47193071246147156,
0.30775004625320435,
0.9413043856620789,
-0.3216618597507477,
0.0629715695977211,
-0.44443655014038086,
0.6655808687210083,
0.1593819111585617,
0.3800332248210907,
0.7017799019813538,
-0.5315226316452026,
-0.707734227180481,
-0.49143269658088684,
-0.31469130516052246,
-0.2643790543079376,
-0.13112516701221466,
0.02106599695980549,
0.3581182360649109,
0.333857923746109,
-0.7687617540359497,
0.2565600574016571,
0.8667688965797424,
-0.3942992687225342,
0.6729361414909363,
-0.2184751182794571,
0.11600050330162048,
-1.3563501834869385,
0.19428808987140656,
-0.3672894239425659,
-0.2567083537578583,
-0.5470919609069824,
0.05607268959283829,
0.1594034880399704,
-0.03733713552355766,
-0.31626424193382263,
0.891683042049408,
-0.7402806878089905,
-0.11058884114027023,
-0.42682766914367676,
0.04939291253685951,
0.0585305355489254,
0.05090387165546417,
-0.16033615171909332,
0.9922457337379456,
0.755772590637207,
-0.6793450117111206,
0.2617158591747284,
-0.08625023812055588,
-0.7016428112983704,
0.10042808204889297,
-0.3868863582611084,
0.004954595118761063,
-0.15860050916671753,
0.4186229705810547,
-1.1568334102630615,
-0.26895609498023987,
-0.09041529148817062,
-0.48253530263900757,
0.29572445154190063,
0.00285099889151752,
-1.1630040407180786,
-0.5772310495376587,
-0.17446593940258026,
0.24749258160591125,
0.5029311180114746,
-0.6465779542922974,
0.8422074913978577,
0.5258826017379761,
-0.08614002168178558,
-0.7624557018280029,
-0.35285553336143494,
0.21270088851451874,
-0.03671111539006233,
-0.43575891852378845,
0.4248899519443512,
0.36809036135673523,
-0.0661124438047409,
-0.03991444781422615,
-0.09765402972698212,
-0.046590205281972885,
0.3996252715587616,
0.07554241269826889,
0.07388004660606384,
0.0793793797492981,
0.47537320852279663,
0.34998348355293274,
-0.07371705770492554,
-0.23829524219036102,
-0.5347928404808044,
1.0164903402328491,
0.3762977719306946,
-0.40618792176246643,
-0.6598713994026184,
0.1048007532954216,
0.7175034880638123,
-0.3322422206401825,
1.1537796258926392,
0.7944243550300598,
-0.12737052142620087,
-0.2501588761806488,
-0.3983548581600189,
-0.4663504362106323,
-0.4149717390537262,
0.4127242863178253,
-0.4941977262496948,
-0.38807108998298645,
0.8594874143600464,
0.13507576286792755,
-0.00724518857896328,
0.6076738834381104,
0.6700822710990906,
0.10660549998283386,
1.0079842805862427,
0.3107944130897522,
-0.14687280356884003,
0.7446586489677429,
-0.22339829802513123,
0.21350616216659546,
-0.5413896441459656,
-0.0675351470708847,
-0.759819746017456,
-0.28509676456451416,
-0.4168243408203125,
-0.622382640838623,
0.08252032101154327,
0.179278165102005,
-0.011675461195409298,
0.3879379630088806,
-0.049734145402908325,
0.2026732712984085,
0.7805953621864319,
-0.18346478044986725,
0.25513240694999695,
-0.04857360199093819,
-0.3081567883491516,
0.1263292133808136,
-0.8997386693954468,
-0.2514879107475281,
1.2742431163787842,
0.13875235617160797,
0.745749831199646,
0.26597392559051514,
0.4226651191711426,
0.05910753086209297,
0.5348867177963257,
-0.40779995918273926,
0.46231988072395325,
-0.09945317357778549,
-0.8784148097038269,
-0.34426581859588623,
-0.5192990303039551,
-0.9431626200675964,
0.3016292452812195,
-0.5602964162826538,
-0.6971478462219238,
-0.11737333238124847,
0.3243248164653778,
-0.17039264738559723,
0.3811251223087311,
-0.5365099906921387,
0.49602046608924866,
-0.02556280419230461,
-0.5074079632759094,
-0.389227956533432,
-0.5740255117416382,
0.41913747787475586,
-0.2610018253326416,
0.11290004104375839,
-0.2971048951148987,
0.03992169350385666,
0.46687427163124084,
-0.5279415845870972,
0.9793907403945923,
-0.3982463777065277,
0.04597239941358566,
0.3652699887752533,
0.0506647489964962,
0.7579294443130493,
0.02250812202692032,
-0.46877792477607727,
0.048335056751966476,
-0.3600124418735504,
-0.434253990650177,
-0.5999078750610352,
0.4165095090866089,
-0.585850715637207,
-0.3574034869670868,
-0.17070217430591583,
-0.6425737142562866,
-0.13056063652038574,
0.32024866342544556,
0.2974351644515991,
0.45071595907211304,
-0.09803801029920578,
0.2123212218284607,
-0.07004129886627197,
-0.2681371569633484,
0.7367215156555176,
0.41467100381851196,
-0.33409246802330017,
-0.7088662385940552,
0.6502828001976013,
0.04073799028992653,
0.5176747441291809,
0.24451719224452972,
0.05176490545272827,
-0.7918919920921326,
-0.8912515640258789,
-0.7392854690551758,
0.0028314406517893076,
-0.4846717119216919,
-0.4091433882713318,
-1.0567572116851807,
0.21571505069732666,
-0.6785764098167419,
0.20798185467720032,
-0.49466973543167114,
-0.9000738859176636,
-0.29639625549316406,
0.03933115676045418,
0.39643895626068115,
0.2466772198677063,
0.18462540209293365,
0.8265852928161621,
-0.8828524947166443,
0.2908881604671478,
-0.07615793496370316,
0.3635740578174591,
0.27253079414367676,
-0.5933626890182495,
-0.3474717438220978,
-0.1104564219713211,
-0.2714412212371826,
-0.6925210952758789,
0.601992130279541,
0.2462616264820099,
0.4871763288974762,
0.12985189259052277,
0.3046802878379822,
0.761167049407959,
-0.6040599942207336,
0.9079607129096985,
0.34160470962524414,
-1.1241083145141602,
0.18034861981868744,
-0.3543126881122589,
0.28416791558265686,
0.6225191950798035,
-0.07080735266208649,
-0.47018417716026306,
-0.9352536797523499,
-0.9538773894309998,
-1.020495891571045,
0.5700778365135193,
0.303514689207077,
0.24003419280052185,
-0.17414513230323792,
0.25065767765045166,
0.3807896375656128,
0.5166154503822327,
-0.4161294102668762,
-0.37067684531211853,
-0.327984094619751,
-0.5027304887771606,
-0.07279464602470398,
-0.010900378227233887,
0.2550733983516693,
-0.12217938899993896,
0.6022899746894836,
-0.30944064259529114,
0.15323740243911743,
-0.25134724378585815,
-0.06981238722801208,
-0.16898463666439056,
-0.10668795555830002,
0.37620484828948975,
0.46234869956970215,
-0.07058127224445343,
0.08306629210710526,
0.0636526420712471,
-0.4981429874897003,
0.16165843605995178,
0.33964720368385315,
-0.32285645604133606,
0.2667750418186188,
0.44208988547325134,
0.9668684005737305,
-0.15169915556907654,
-0.5692591071128845,
0.35347339510917664,
-0.1970975697040558,
0.03555108606815338,
-0.15148431062698364,
0.09564913064241409,
0.04772654175758362,
-0.00638057803735137,
0.4666025936603546,
0.1584196388721466,
0.025974363088607788,
-0.4599018394947052,
0.29122045636177063,
0.5448439717292786,
-0.07422953099012375,
-0.518836498260498,
0.9100190997123718,
0.4301179051399231,
-0.23993971943855286,
0.4118899703025818,
-0.3485942482948303,
-0.3267640173435211,
0.5859337449073792,
0.6100172996520996,
0.826040506362915,
-0.16133692860603333,
0.27193009853363037,
0.489321768283844,
-0.021702952682971954,
-0.20217430591583252,
0.397779643535614,
0.1276184320449829,
-0.7850359678268433,
-0.6218442320823669,
-0.7114894390106201,
-0.39895281195640564,
0.1470070481300354,
-0.3720954358577728,
0.37368544936180115,
-0.27387040853500366,
-0.4627262353897095,
-0.015096185728907585,
0.1180969849228859,
-0.4124982953071594,
0.16602344810962677,
-0.45704028010368347,
0.9511858224868774,
-0.8702288866043091,
1.0102683305740356,
0.3029407858848572,
-0.31286507844924927,
-0.6493776440620422,
0.39549246430397034,
-0.17521093785762787,
-0.5107638835906982,
0.7759968638420105,
0.07294217497110367,
-0.19277140498161316,
0.2880869209766388,
-0.2601573169231415,
-1.1292537450790405,
0.9113161563873291,
0.3302075266838074,
-0.19362394511699677,
0.1913871318101883,
-0.2636564075946808,
0.5657410025596619,
-0.1926283985376358,
0.2885480225086212,
0.18514686822891235,
0.36191174387931824,
-0.006279539316892624,
-0.870894730091095,
-0.08799581229686737,
-0.01894606091082096,
-0.21692058444023132,
0.599789559841156,
-0.6567474007606506,
1.1166467666625977,
-0.24865037202835083,
-0.4156506657600403,
0.5132178068161011,
0.9980214834213257,
0.342772901058197,
0.0156986303627491,
0.5833604335784912,
0.39057642221450806,
1.161238670349121,
0.07692384719848633,
1.2033253908157349,
-0.7842401266098022,
0.40604186058044434,
1.2223877906799316,
-0.4530409872531891,
0.7301133871078491,
0.5237042307853699,
-0.007955528795719147,
0.5227615833282471,
0.6166394352912903,
0.062291219830513,
0.5351812243461609,
0.1288376748561859,
-0.4977825880050659,
-0.2251248061656952,
-0.14926207065582275,
-0.08373363316059113,
0.5734401345252991,
0.126775324344635,
-0.41379979252815247,
-0.04737929254770279,
-0.17755848169326782,
-0.12887966632843018,
-0.06652549654245377,
0.17481692135334015,
0.45598745346069336,
-0.3849862515926361,
-0.8122408390045166,
0.3458377718925476,
0.2765568792819977,
0.5241605043411255,
-0.20891770720481873,
0.2715842127799988,
-0.12669561803340912,
0.10675960034132004,
0.30276957154273987,
-0.49506956338882446,
0.020675184205174446,
-0.1257036328315735,
-0.16041751205921173,
-0.3218172490596771,
0.6414951682090759,
-0.4867856502532959,
-0.7060976624488831,
0.19938436150550842,
0.7523860335350037,
-0.07143683731555939,
0.10633745044469833,
-0.4214862287044525,
-0.2542218565940857,
-0.33766600489616394,
-0.29764482378959656,
0.20684029161930084,
0.6567218899726868,
0.08564211428165436,
0.8631361722946167,
0.9799789786338806,
0.4717386066913605,
0.1834849715232849,
0.27678704261779785,
0.659464955329895,
-0.573486864566803,
-0.41403627395629883,
-0.7152917981147766,
0.4326251149177551,
-0.3870607614517212,
-0.3999755084514618,
0.7160961031913757,
0.5958878397941589,
0.4123360514640808,
-0.16795887053012848,
0.6449989080429077,
-0.1305389106273651,
0.6769561767578125,
-0.7387992739677429,
0.9304585456848145,
-0.5561815500259399,
0.07260093092918396,
-0.07744468003511429,
-0.7910523414611816,
-0.4439098834991455,
0.41725581884384155,
0.033883169293403625,
0.09935887157917023,
0.7615315318107605,
0.4897247552871704,
-0.06312310695648193,
-0.12401842325925827,
0.0765417218208313,
0.013642248697578907,
0.5861222147941589,
-0.08549146354198456,
0.5996399521827698,
-0.515581488609314,
0.41139447689056396,
-0.19713856279850006,
0.10174766927957535,
-0.3169907331466675,
-1.0384740829467773,
-0.8053169846534729,
-0.5254888534545898,
0.019903525710105896,
-0.4383143484592438,
-0.17592233419418335,
0.9035886526107788,
0.8676953911781311,
-0.6358126401901245,
-0.10516420751810074,
-0.3684719204902649,
0.05800604447722435,
-0.28889355063438416,
-0.18191544711589813,
0.5856235027313232,
-0.7047701478004456,
-1.0971916913986206,
0.3256232738494873,
-0.017322439700365067,
0.3100087642669678,
-0.30894556641578674,
0.19451455771923065,
-0.05353812873363495,
-0.0949740931391716,
0.3848879635334015,
-0.23598934710025787,
-0.618804931640625,
-0.44875335693359375,
0.17015720903873444,
-0.05844733119010925,
-0.11811119318008423,
0.8141677379608154,
-0.8732297420501709,
0.3587964177131653,
0.7192122340202332,
0.5438231229782104,
0.5476164221763611,
0.07392478734254837,
0.858845055103302,
-0.9139512777328491,
0.537808895111084,
0.3254406452178955,
0.36874619126319885,
0.2298297882080078,
0.0609329529106617,
0.18596212565898895,
0.3516198396682739,
-0.3217143416404724,
-0.9855095744132996,
0.44065776467323303,
-0.4572680592536926,
-0.39550870656967163,
0.9646905064582825,
0.014719360508024693,
-0.13045631349086761,
-0.356012761592865,
0.09983690828084946,
0.5605779886245728,
-0.4957912862300873,
1.1173797845840454,
0.7481703758239746,
0.11595340818166733,
-0.18205517530441284,
-0.38245999813079834,
0.5414183735847473,
0.6026833057403564,
-0.8817302584648132,
0.5358197093009949,
0.4542900621891022,
-0.07760433852672577,
0.1678924411535263,
0.5591569542884827,
0.14851219952106476,
0.19113542139530182,
0.4126514196395874,
0.3861919939517975,
0.05372331663966179,
-0.6292864084243774,
-0.06379298120737076,
0.3278104066848755,
0.1790444552898407,
-0.18112562596797943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00864v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00864v1
|
Math Multiple Choice Question Generation via Human-Large Language Model Collaboration
| 2024-05-01T20:53:13 | 2024-05-01T20:53:13 |
Jaewook Lee, Digory Smith, Simon Woodhead, Andrew Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multiple choice questions (MCQs) are a popular method for evaluating
students' knowledge due to their efficiency in administration and grading.
Crafting high-quality math MCQs is a labor-intensive process that requires
educators to formulate precise stems and plausible distractors. Recent advances
in large language models (LLMs) have sparked interest in automating MCQ
creation, but challenges persist in ensuring mathematical accuracy and
addressing student errors. This paper introduces a prototype tool designed to
facilitate collaboration between LLMs and educators for streamlining the math
MCQ generation process. We conduct a pilot study involving math educators to
investigate how the tool can help them simplify the process of crafting
high-quality math MCQs. We found that while LLMs can generate well-formulated
question stems, their ability to generate distractors that capture common
student errors and misconceptions is limited. Nevertheless, a human-AI
collaboration has the potential to enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of
MCQ generation.
|
[
-0.7121165990829468,
-0.951810359954834,
0.6877295970916748,
-0.022978106513619423,
-0.02392449975013733,
0.3730963468551636,
-0.012865484692156315,
-0.15761412680149078,
0.1726822406053543,
0.5760787129402161,
-0.7447373270988464,
-0.21891991794109344,
-0.20511367917060852,
0.09841757267713547,
-0.13349425792694092,
0.7168930768966675,
-0.18652960658073425,
0.1742105633020401,
-0.6894674301147461,
0.005029771011322737,
-0.49726590514183044,
-0.6581573486328125,
-0.7610843777656555,
-0.2935318052768707,
0.5346289873123169,
0.728552520275116,
0.9198722839355469,
0.2670495808124542,
0.6051427721977234,
0.3346972167491913,
0.31340402364730835,
0.43903443217277527,
-0.1774410903453827,
0.2694479823112488,
-0.026240942999720573,
-0.3863498270511627,
-0.4391324520111084,
0.08767522126436234,
0.4666052460670471,
0.9283307194709778,
-0.2847678065299988,
0.528465211391449,
0.015432430431246758,
0.4349365532398224,
-0.6086786389350891,
-0.2533920705318451,
-0.6065518260002136,
0.03068738989531994,
-0.1203918382525444,
0.01645944081246853,
-0.23081529140472412,
-0.48421934247016907,
-0.03589288145303726,
-0.31094762682914734,
0.17864184081554413,
-0.09164293855428696,
0.580515444278717,
0.3696635663509369,
-0.3217787742614746,
-0.4774782359600067,
-0.6140606999397278,
0.7136043310165405,
-0.46518757939338684,
0.220378115773201,
0.28817838430404663,
0.6218768954277039,
-0.254523366689682,
-0.5071545243263245,
-0.6705933809280396,
-0.16461803019046783,
0.18419907987117767,
0.27004650235176086,
0.301492303609848,
-0.3157527446746826,
0.3703252971172333,
0.1293116956949234,
-0.3610186278820038,
-0.08968206495046616,
-0.3153381645679474,
-0.23040184378623962,
0.8891321420669556,
0.6434375047683716,
0.4881799519062042,
-0.2662684917449951,
-0.1163504496216774,
-0.04657987505197525,
-0.6282150745391846,
0.03468883037567139,
0.44911205768585205,
0.11801290512084961,
0.3123352527618408,
0.8989917039871216,
0.13251125812530518,
0.6823614835739136,
-0.16220572590827942,
-0.2526088356971741,
0.05478742718696594,
-0.3734782338142395,
-0.006536093540489674,
-0.20780202746391296,
0.9840565323829651,
0.2147318422794342,
0.19691620767116547,
0.27497097849845886,
-0.10739585012197495,
0.11428187042474747,
0.0644059032201767,
-0.6345503330230713,
-0.2347230315208435,
0.17776262760162354,
0.1195077896118164,
-0.3449263572692871,
0.06886431574821472,
-0.5490976572036743,
-0.029299631714820862,
-0.6079888939857483,
0.41418081521987915,
-0.22356247901916504,
-0.15422075986862183,
0.014865648001432419,
-0.07739222794771194,
-0.10393193364143372,
0.47494837641716003,
-0.6341085433959961,
0.19020360708236694,
0.39234185218811035,
0.4749480187892914,
-0.3375365436077118,
-0.5934325456619263,
-0.7229354381561279,
0.24244385957717896,
-0.2207219898700714,
0.6146688461303711,
-0.40378764271736145,
-0.6823664903640747,
-0.27509060502052307,
-0.553016185760498,
-0.064569391310215,
-0.5744951963424683,
0.3271404504776001,
-0.35774487257003784,
0.46690693497657776,
-0.1243211179971695,
-0.5473013520240784,
0.2304116189479828,
0.4444645941257477,
-0.5613019466400146,
1.2293745279312134,
0.23275087773799896,
-0.4827307164669037,
0.13496513664722443,
-0.7352995872497559,
-0.1828395426273346,
0.3508819043636322,
-0.5926548838615417,
-0.5466763973236084,
-0.16863283514976501,
0.47816750407218933,
0.41579121351242065,
-0.49505066871643066,
0.5011104345321655,
-0.17070156335830688,
-0.17384399473667145,
0.6475703120231628,
-0.558693528175354,
0.889897882938385,
0.12437491863965988,
-0.035021670162677765,
0.04730941727757454,
-0.5035945177078247,
0.18369044363498688,
0.24061816930770874,
-0.44477400183677673,
-0.025495104491710663,
-0.2383117377758026,
-0.09448356181383133,
0.5390726923942566,
0.1750393807888031,
-0.32965683937072754,
-0.011370361782610416,
0.1317014992237091,
0.27161020040512085,
0.6592133045196533,
0.24473407864570618,
0.07054290920495987,
-0.6989811062812805,
0.8796101212501526,
-0.11594847589731216,
0.1666189730167389,
-0.023123448714613914,
-0.6408961415290833,
-0.7855613827705383,
-0.27617961168289185,
0.15806855261325836,
0.48264482617378235,
-0.8288828134536743,
0.40027397871017456,
0.05711938440799713,
-0.5542911291122437,
-0.5447893142700195,
0.3785373270511627,
0.20908930897712708,
0.6010966300964355,
0.07467914372682571,
-0.030774995684623718,
-0.4281536936759949,
-0.5843140482902527,
-0.09838490933179855,
0.14339929819107056,
-0.22912274301052094,
0.6778623461723328,
0.532852828502655,
-0.054301340132951736,
1.3024736642837524,
-0.8077353835105896,
-0.009454509243369102,
-0.18824608623981476,
0.3631097972393036,
-0.02165323868393898,
0.491252064704895,
0.41910290718078613,
-0.6923370361328125,
-0.5686318278312683,
-0.5478174686431885,
-0.5895168781280518,
-0.07397691160440445,
-0.046511318534612656,
-0.6531395316123962,
-0.11603070050477982,
0.47114962339401245,
-0.5832012891769409,
0.0877620056271553,
0.3599899709224701,
-0.10503380000591278,
0.9832689762115479,
0.07632406800985336,
0.03216056525707245,
-1.4413429498672485,
0.12020772695541382,
-0.4353578984737396,
-0.08416866511106491,
-0.2531616687774658,
0.07469278573989868,
-0.09663303941488266,
-0.4969250559806824,
-0.6687731742858887,
0.5444023013114929,
-0.2855294346809387,
-0.06443841755390167,
0.24242155253887177,
0.442606657743454,
0.011112142354249954,
0.20968377590179443,
-0.10837133228778839,
0.8291471004486084,
0.32503020763397217,
-0.6392253041267395,
0.37154197692871094,
0.36219945549964905,
-0.17341837286949158,
0.818016529083252,
-0.5843702554702759,
0.18623210489749908,
0.05513674020767212,
0.1284113973379135,
-0.9371520280838013,
-0.5629110336303711,
0.08592075109481812,
-0.6844347715377808,
-0.21603316068649292,
-0.010804443620145321,
-0.6458914875984192,
-0.7255902290344238,
-0.16810902953147888,
0.4920329451560974,
0.4393031597137451,
-0.44550371170043945,
0.4697507917881012,
0.39363792538642883,
-0.3897327780723572,
-0.5534764528274536,
-0.5658663511276245,
0.07848071306943893,
0.16273517906665802,
-0.769934356212616,
-0.08713505417108536,
-0.6403569579124451,
-0.2701405882835388,
-0.1545962691307068,
0.15819555521011353,
-0.12411200255155563,
0.19239886105060577,
0.09119019657373428,
0.6982085108757019,
-0.16503706574440002,
0.2296680361032486,
0.2884501814842224,
0.027875849977135658,
0.443522572517395,
-0.0298279020935297,
0.5982129573822021,
0.12254952639341354,
-0.7644546627998352,
-0.12777866423130035,
0.5095182657241821,
0.7560168504714966,
-0.4270324110984802,
0.4027037024497986,
0.4047926068305969,
-0.3877548575401306,
-0.2912960350513458,
-0.6729503273963928,
-0.18105827271938324,
-0.5137858986854553,
0.07953068614006042,
-0.34758734703063965,
-0.9471753835678101,
0.32716983556747437,
-0.1842653751373291,
0.2583100199699402,
0.3106188476085663,
0.8269022703170776,
-0.03556394204497337,
1.3844375610351562,
0.062011703848838806,
0.2266048789024353,
0.30183491110801697,
-0.13250569999217987,
-0.22368142008781433,
-0.748126208782196,
-0.1373472660779953,
-0.4642646610736847,
-0.11734645813703537,
0.13338229060173035,
-0.635532021522522,
0.5459793210029602,
0.06233081594109535,
-0.2851046025753021,
-0.043688368052244186,
-0.49037209153175354,
0.7026461362838745,
0.8357906937599182,
-0.011560698039829731,
0.2785414457321167,
0.05272447317838669,
-0.6549158096313477,
-0.16116277873516083,
-0.5558848977088928,
-0.5607911348342896,
1.217651605606079,
-0.1498442441225052,
0.4826067090034485,
0.25996237993240356,
1.076788306236267,
-0.10249374806880951,
0.6153692007064819,
-0.6754122972488403,
0.7128092050552368,
0.3205263614654541,
-0.8703383803367615,
-0.5917865037918091,
-0.6796834468841553,
-0.8044129014015198,
0.21492044627666473,
-0.438001811504364,
-0.42460185289382935,
-0.5008662343025208,
0.08053337782621384,
-0.489437997341156,
0.10813002288341522,
-0.6214193105697632,
0.6901618242263794,
-0.3357352018356323,
-0.5199493765830994,
0.10368788987398148,
-0.46410098671913147,
0.5620162487030029,
-0.3180038034915924,
0.2121591567993164,
-0.10576047748327255,
0.1875709742307663,
0.7178979516029358,
-0.6089516282081604,
0.6072994470596313,
0.1412847489118576,
-0.24042057991027832,
0.7331266403198242,
0.4650112986564636,
0.16210098564624786,
0.46955716609954834,
-0.18699704110622406,
-0.30250394344329834,
-0.3672579228878021,
-0.27817222476005554,
-0.5539393424987793,
0.6496017575263977,
-0.8513426184654236,
-0.5825634598731995,
-0.08830258250236511,
-0.9432122111320496,
-0.317853182554245,
0.2820952534675598,
0.01249423436820507,
0.41459956765174866,
-0.09575489163398743,
-0.2147102952003479,
0.40070152282714844,
0.01303804013878107,
0.5177536606788635,
0.3444969654083252,
-0.2843007743358612,
-0.6944447755813599,
0.8974848389625549,
0.1088765412569046,
0.4318426251411438,
0.0807320848107338,
0.35316261649131775,
-0.24949471652507782,
-0.1321464329957962,
-0.6130752563476562,
0.3133562207221985,
-0.6522048115730286,
-0.27451300621032715,
-0.4472145438194275,
-0.43647995591163635,
-0.39838021993637085,
-0.5004535913467407,
-0.21085703372955322,
-0.38926777243614197,
-0.44075214862823486,
0.103501096367836,
-0.029970193281769753,
0.5912242531776428,
0.09155456721782684,
0.06602858006954193,
-1.1056382656097412,
0.24662162363529205,
0.910545825958252,
0.02665707841515541,
-0.04485377296805382,
-0.07839373499155045,
0.03352906182408333,
0.2782139182090759,
-0.5931750535964966,
-0.509922444820404,
0.244967982172966,
-0.2074626386165619,
0.39056551456451416,
0.20503206551074982,
0.06728734076023102,
0.751396656036377,
-0.5218417048454285,
0.8334203958511353,
0.5214306712150574,
-1.1585172414779663,
0.44195544719696045,
-0.346606969833374,
0.3897722065448761,
0.5322068333625793,
0.2924419045448303,
-0.38384726643562317,
-0.6032649278640747,
-0.6392980813980103,
-0.38262778520584106,
0.602879524230957,
0.3558829426765442,
0.07572537660598755,
-0.1557772308588028,
0.1955121010541916,
0.18157188594341278,
0.33521929383277893,
-0.445645809173584,
-0.16411137580871582,
-0.016167445108294487,
-0.41107386350631714,
-0.09361767023801804,
-0.05825386941432953,
-0.3092730641365051,
-0.24326205253601074,
0.3207746148109436,
-0.16666778922080994,
-0.014550425112247467,
0.041008103638887405,
-0.0748007670044899,
-0.5130864381790161,
0.39222705364227295,
0.6593477725982666,
0.8693196177482605,
-0.0025311713106930256,
0.08768971264362335,
0.24824576079845428,
-0.5433579087257385,
0.12427493184804916,
-0.057704858481884,
-0.25314921140670776,
-0.05066872015595436,
0.05118156969547272,
0.2697707414627075,
-0.0983365997672081,
-0.908537745475769,
0.41874054074287415,
-0.12217317521572113,
-0.6979612708091736,
-0.5035462975502014,
0.30058228969573975,
0.3593220114707947,
-0.046380817890167236,
0.30697906017303467,
0.28471100330352783,
-0.09542801976203918,
-0.34957996010780334,
0.39432382583618164,
0.5231915712356567,
-0.025524266064167023,
-0.024570664390921593,
0.7057300806045532,
0.4557379484176636,
-0.7572528123855591,
0.8181719779968262,
-0.2120680958032608,
-0.5781577825546265,
0.7023817300796509,
0.48557284474372864,
0.43374964594841003,
-0.23871265351772308,
0.4941560626029968,
0.3994504511356354,
-0.006048732902854681,
-0.0615767277777195,
0.559632420539856,
0.05767638608813286,
-0.7251135110855103,
-0.5079914927482605,
-0.28873568773269653,
-0.8529552817344666,
0.00020018416398670524,
-0.5922406315803528,
0.39647984504699707,
-0.34482425451278687,
-0.25245627760887146,
-0.09471273422241211,
-0.06586816161870956,
-0.7095263004302979,
0.17446213960647583,
0.17309966683387756,
0.45608431100845337,
-0.5321245789527893,
0.37715473771095276,
0.9251576662063599,
-0.5081536173820496,
-1.0717687606811523,
-0.19426831603050232,
-0.08758866041898727,
-0.7239720821380615,
0.6604107618331909,
0.08638647943735123,
-0.15414567291736603,
0.23644860088825226,
-0.6820801496505737,
-0.8697640299797058,
1.2397737503051758,
0.3265422284603119,
-0.45752260088920593,
0.0023893958423286676,
0.6074693202972412,
0.3761509358882904,
-0.3457368016242981,
0.4624851644039154,
0.08798673748970032,
0.26672616600990295,
0.5665867924690247,
-0.7501983642578125,
0.08890646696090698,
-0.13547876477241516,
-0.2528585195541382,
0.46228015422821045,
-0.488337904214859,
1.1309783458709717,
-0.39547818899154663,
0.04029842093586922,
-0.06024819612503052,
0.38377299904823303,
0.6585186123847961,
0.3004729151725769,
0.465788871049881,
0.5186877846717834,
0.8629010319709778,
0.1518838107585907,
0.4947798252105713,
-0.18526695668697357,
0.3488394320011139,
1.1958096027374268,
-0.4193005859851837,
0.924930214881897,
0.6212356090545654,
-0.1966865360736847,
0.3527751863002777,
0.28269657492637634,
-0.1194552555680275,
-0.34913790225982666,
0.6328075528144836,
-0.2631383538246155,
-0.7907027006149292,
0.07335413992404938,
-0.2489241510629654,
0.32498058676719666,
0.4973157048225403,
-0.08441828191280365,
-0.17806358635425568,
0.0013391280081123114,
-0.03383762761950493,
0.029690375551581383,
-0.2028397023677826,
0.42657470703125,
-0.11607541888952255,
-1.102691888809204,
0.2957215905189514,
-0.20320895314216614,
0.3759681284427643,
-0.30911242961883545,
-0.08420544117689133,
-0.16474087536334991,
0.03211413696408272,
0.040026742964982986,
-0.9250688552856445,
0.007089813239872456,
-0.058981556445360184,
0.0033261089120060205,
-0.004572125617414713,
0.3315093517303467,
-0.5498982071876526,
-0.866017758846283,
-0.2912651300430298,
1.0626035928726196,
0.11440859735012054,
0.07202845066785812,
-0.8952215909957886,
-0.17487359046936035,
-0.22905288636684418,
0.07354418188333511,
0.14814674854278564,
0.23897965252399445,
0.007377156522125006,
0.8443694710731506,
1.0130962133407593,
-0.1608535647392273,
0.1495683193206787,
0.25007662177085876,
0.7043986916542053,
-0.4431479573249817,
-0.2878386378288269,
-0.719331681728363,
0.6295442581176758,
-0.22425180673599243,
-0.5085222721099854,
0.7670392394065857,
0.6282862424850464,
0.7714439034461975,
-0.12667769193649292,
0.9042360782623291,
0.22656987607479095,
0.6400434970855713,
-0.2039666771888733,
0.6311410665512085,
-0.5196768045425415,
0.24739763140678406,
-0.48936423659324646,
-0.9024264216423035,
-0.43603548407554626,
0.19939306378364563,
0.07728523015975952,
0.025913598015904427,
0.7610682845115662,
0.5558381080627441,
0.036003608256578445,
-0.1880725622177124,
0.3690476417541504,
-0.39540034532546997,
0.5094872117042542,
0.6694256663322449,
1.098595142364502,
-0.3159638047218323,
1.01736581325531,
-0.24453328549861908,
-0.09328742325305939,
-0.11842463910579681,
-0.5375516414642334,
-1.3837411403656006,
-0.36233457922935486,
-0.3647005558013916,
-0.14495490491390228,
-0.404225617647171,
1.1629256010055542,
0.39238008856773376,
-0.4452207386493683,
-0.49389955401420593,
-0.25520363450050354,
0.28929847478866577,
0.030037393793463707,
-0.30868250131607056,
0.3110404908657074,
-0.25095489621162415,
-0.7750362753868103,
-0.03795427083969116,
-0.04061314836144447,
0.43909958004951477,
-0.5021645426750183,
-0.09334185719490051,
-0.15358702838420868,
0.31076952815055847,
0.42935556173324585,
-0.15573975443840027,
-0.4636077880859375,
-0.10133993625640869,
0.3185095191001892,
-0.2654101848602295,
-0.12895379960536957,
0.9167048335075378,
-0.5812627077102661,
0.36614176630973816,
0.40672510862350464,
0.7510879039764404,
0.13934071362018585,
0.02363494597375393,
0.5376338362693787,
-0.785276472568512,
-0.44361448287963867,
0.41353538632392883,
0.20707398653030396,
0.21450403332710266,
-0.18415315449237823,
0.3877753019332886,
0.23671257495880127,
-0.613174557685852,
-0.8341993093490601,
0.3292462229728699,
-0.6624974608421326,
-0.13393262028694153,
1.0166590213775635,
0.1882413774728775,
-0.14308874309062958,
-0.07719425112009048,
-0.691028356552124,
0.1319679170846939,
-0.3446227014064789,
0.7253697514533997,
0.9224250912666321,
-0.2524759769439697,
-0.08133306354284286,
-0.38923904299736023,
0.20046252012252808,
0.5012091994285583,
-1.0986344814300537,
-0.22031573951244354,
0.520882248878479,
0.18604055047035217,
0.4154077470302582,
0.3656734824180603,
0.16390156745910645,
0.5402774810791016,
0.07518233358860016,
0.13858747482299805,
-0.275347501039505,
-0.08686456084251404,
0.31252479553222656,
0.32146281003952026,
0.02771485038101673,
-0.07650783658027649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00828v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00828v1
|
WIBA: What Is Being Argued? A Comprehensive Approach to Argument Mining
| 2024-05-01T19:31:13 | 2024-05-01T19:31:13 |
Arman Irani, Ju Yeon Park, Kevin Esterling, Michalis Faloutsos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose WIBA, a novel framework and suite of methods that enable the
comprehensive understanding of "What Is Being Argued" across contexts. Our
approach develops a comprehensive framework that detects: (a) the existence,
(b) the topic, and (c) the stance of an argument, correctly accounting for the
logical dependence among the three tasks. Our algorithm leverages the
fine-tuning and prompt-engineering of Large Language Models. We evaluate our
approach and show that it performs well in all the three capabilities. First,
we develop and release an Argument Detection model that can classify a piece of
text as an argument with an F1 score between 79% and 86% on three different
benchmark datasets. Second, we release a language model that can identify the
topic being argued in a sentence, be it implicit or explicit, with an average
similarity score of 71%, outperforming current naive methods by nearly 40%.
Finally, we develop a method for Argument Stance Classification, and evaluate
the capability of our approach, showing it achieves a classification F1 score
between 71% and 78% across three diverse benchmark datasets. Our evaluation
demonstrates that WIBA allows the comprehensive understanding of What Is Being
Argued in large corpora across diverse contexts, which is of core interest to
many applications in linguistics, communication, and social and computer
science. To facilitate accessibility to the advancements outlined in this work,
we release WIBA as a free open access platform (wiba.dev).
|
[
-0.5937227606773376,
-1.1734719276428223,
0.5132229328155518,
0.20998772978782654,
-0.3408832252025604,
-0.21170496940612793,
-0.10917651653289795,
-0.3372032046318054,
0.29951876401901245,
0.3541114032268524,
-0.4732612669467926,
-0.43459340929985046,
-0.6618250608444214,
0.11267710477113724,
-0.47578373551368713,
1.0236668586730957,
0.1837880164384842,
-0.04330577701330185,
-0.5938462018966675,
-0.3558425307273865,
-0.5423459410667419,
-0.3327105641365051,
-0.5214409232139587,
-0.19001033902168274,
0.7619039416313171,
0.544167160987854,
0.42923781275749207,
0.22435107827186584,
-0.10825639218091965,
0.4269673824310303,
-0.24493184685707092,
0.13705550134181976,
0.05691877380013466,
0.380681574344635,
-0.5415508151054382,
-0.47356951236724854,
-0.19777853786945343,
-0.21555082499980927,
0.35768765211105347,
0.6438853740692139,
0.057451602071523666,
0.18286430835723877,
-0.3414415121078491,
0.5437901020050049,
-0.9087743759155273,
-0.19136101007461548,
-0.9204550385475159,
0.034524254500865936,
-0.5552569627761841,
-0.16160517930984497,
-0.5277506709098816,
0.018867606297135353,
0.2626052796840668,
-0.20159806311130524,
0.0682288184762001,
-0.020055139437317848,
1.2497406005859375,
-0.1377481371164322,
-0.7790566086769104,
-0.5087451338768005,
-0.1236550360918045,
0.7050742506980896,
-0.9931419491767883,
-0.13824859261512756,
0.15828797221183777,
0.03238968551158905,
-0.29105958342552185,
-0.8714114427566528,
-0.7740458250045776,
-0.05917014181613922,
0.030007263645529747,
0.17685076594352722,
-0.697721540927887,
0.06967147439718246,
0.3539499342441559,
0.1935470849275589,
-0.30270445346832275,
0.19460777938365936,
-0.26680174469947815,
-0.32449671626091003,
0.5435892939567566,
-0.04953464865684509,
0.25475454330444336,
-0.6368160843849182,
-0.2960306406021118,
0.2039099633693695,
-0.33998697996139526,
0.22953474521636963,
0.6262977719306946,
0.03649335354566574,
0.02627752348780632,
0.5953172445297241,
-0.29343733191490173,
0.7310251593589783,
0.04862616956233978,
0.27235251665115356,
-0.05675406754016876,
0.16484756767749786,
-0.34215837717056274,
0.09248487651348114,
1.0797137022018433,
0.21782155334949493,
-0.16893042623996735,
0.18628408014774323,
0.08929408341646194,
0.12423279881477356,
0.33394643664360046,
-0.7102237939834595,
-0.06617121398448944,
0.46377843618392944,
-0.6758953332901001,
-0.4452669024467468,
-0.02750496007502079,
-0.9364826083183289,
-0.6136625409126282,
-0.033065009862184525,
0.39568260312080383,
-0.08935654163360596,
-0.5715125203132629,
0.05233457684516907,
-0.3969555199146271,
0.25556090474128723,
0.13682031631469727,
-0.9153743982315063,
0.18640731275081635,
1.0546331405639648,
0.8974095582962036,
0.009312373585999012,
0.042044736444950104,
-0.6091717481613159,
0.03535955771803856,
-0.7501213550567627,
1.4608100652694702,
-0.7112874984741211,
-0.374625027179718,
0.1370743215084076,
-0.0770169198513031,
0.1734400987625122,
-0.5792264938354492,
1.244666337966919,
-0.4015897512435913,
0.32671502232551575,
-0.3560170829296112,
-1.0056873559951782,
-0.20264694094657898,
0.5601786971092224,
-0.9523587822914124,
0.9885396361351013,
-0.34153440594673157,
-0.9390360713005066,
0.5474308133125305,
-0.9655413031578064,
-0.5876028537750244,
0.2087521255016327,
-0.2134850025177002,
-0.3883585035800934,
0.44493040442466736,
0.027283625677227974,
0.40759846568107605,
-0.512969970703125,
0.3430241346359253,
-0.4676983058452606,
0.022108502686023712,
0.2768436372280121,
-0.30384162068367004,
1.0192322731018066,
0.4535236656665802,
-0.5855412483215332,
0.3146483302116394,
-0.6187708377838135,
0.04732514172792435,
-0.008973659947514534,
0.17066510021686554,
-0.49138084053993225,
0.6326175332069397,
-0.1792888343334198,
0.16375254094600677,
0.3100421130657196,
-0.7398732900619507,
0.07163786143064499,
-0.5298091173171997,
0.4969073235988617,
0.8525756597518921,
0.1529756337404251,
-0.05418520048260689,
0.20193004608154297,
0.3536725342273712,
0.13482044637203217,
0.03502771630883217,
-0.14481060206890106,
-0.7483534216880798,
-0.8705549240112305,
-0.17294061183929443,
0.393856018781662,
0.3447975516319275,
0.11449573189020157,
0.6122085452079773,
0.02104959264397621,
-0.34993186593055725,
-0.47885650396347046,
-0.1327190101146698,
-0.13586121797561646,
0.6058600544929504,
0.3021155893802643,
0.04750857874751091,
-0.619564950466156,
-1.1272355318069458,
-0.2530284821987152,
-0.47586655616760254,
0.0637241080403328,
-0.066318079829216,
0.3384943902492523,
-0.22648312151432037,
1.2889786958694458,
-0.3973131775856018,
0.026719342917203903,
-0.3353691101074219,
0.6577529907226562,
0.2731741964817047,
0.11732634902000427,
0.44544678926467896,
-0.9349272847175598,
-0.45533159375190735,
0.4290083646774292,
-0.6787227988243103,
-0.3800124228000641,
-0.06609650701284409,
-0.3576745390892029,
0.35604509711265564,
0.48171135783195496,
-0.5987050533294678,
0.4445623755455017,
0.26710641384124756,
-0.6103640198707581,
0.47168299555778503,
0.1385236531496048,
0.07233167439699173,
-1.4603904485702515,
0.16525816917419434,
0.05232318118214607,
-0.07859978079795837,
-0.47551706433296204,
-0.08348079025745392,
-0.038672998547554016,
-0.09669793397188187,
-0.1251337230205536,
0.4499993622303009,
0.016148140653967857,
0.5301472544670105,
-0.7478306889533997,
0.1013980358839035,
0.1821475327014923,
-0.0032579288817942142,
0.08446602523326874,
0.16752533614635468,
0.533105731010437,
-0.3703731894493103,
0.45087844133377075,
0.12101950496435165,
-0.508326530456543,
0.8729891180992126,
-0.6599370837211609,
0.06678444892168045,
0.0424540676176548,
0.12429729104042053,
-0.7304155826568604,
0.01021670550107956,
-0.017191767692565918,
-0.5429373383522034,
-0.08174644410610199,
-0.4376082122325897,
-0.23623985052108765,
-0.14433683454990387,
-0.23854440450668335,
-0.08799199014902115,
0.07403084635734558,
-0.515105128288269,
0.8625198602676392,
0.6640381813049316,
-0.35587915778160095,
-0.9306024312973022,
-0.2877797484397888,
0.3410183787345886,
-0.3892036974430084,
-0.5668257474899292,
0.4104997515678406,
0.12579110264778137,
-0.46798762679100037,
0.2607026696205139,
-0.13965699076652527,
-0.12543030083179474,
0.24772076308727264,
0.1336275190114975,
0.19985559582710266,
-0.1647273153066635,
0.19242961704730988,
0.29863807559013367,
-0.048709213733673096,
0.4812600910663605,
-0.18207865953445435,
0.3349459171295166,
0.023556087166070938,
-0.2620004117488861,
-0.1173744797706604,
0.9465217590332031,
0.37221795320510864,
-0.20166656374931335,
0.5155274868011475,
0.4576590359210968,
-0.6619688868522644,
-0.4899708926677704,
-0.5074681639671326,
0.4477953016757965,
-0.498935341835022,
0.49730178713798523,
-0.46429136395454407,
-0.5232927203178406,
0.31739476323127747,
-0.40697601437568665,
0.6942044496536255,
0.5626094341278076,
0.7609530687332153,
-0.3134860694408417,
1.1147668361663818,
0.5037162899971008,
-0.256150484085083,
0.29492101073265076,
0.049446988850831985,
0.64641273021698,
-0.4145640730857849,
-0.3623517155647278,
-0.9036241173744202,
-0.3123228847980499,
-0.5244265794754028,
-0.23709873855113983,
-0.1854429990053177,
0.28455325961112976,
-0.01681617833673954,
0.08526071906089783,
-0.2428593635559082,
0.3997662663459778,
0.17975659668445587,
-0.3640291094779968,
0.005688640289008617,
-0.11901456117630005,
-0.31481263041496277,
0.007726169191300869,
-0.33062973618507385,
-0.8694223165512085,
0.715478241443634,
0.24865731596946716,
0.21894952654838562,
0.21813854575157166,
0.5433754324913025,
0.7355898022651672,
0.4943735897541046,
-1.0794395208358765,
0.723037600517273,
-0.06953243911266327,
-0.961398720741272,
0.0183428768068552,
-0.3661552667617798,
-1.0918422937393188,
0.5216709971427917,
-0.37221062183380127,
-0.8653221726417542,
-0.005956090055406094,
0.056561004370450974,
0.11959896981716156,
0.7019299864768982,
-0.7613199949264526,
1.2927024364471436,
-0.16115906834602356,
-0.4373552203178406,
-0.5461671352386475,
-0.2858867943286896,
0.12768687307834625,
0.29818400740623474,
0.2918213903903961,
-0.2722746431827545,
0.12416140735149384,
1.0290919542312622,
-0.6402201652526855,
0.607280433177948,
-0.4463922083377838,
-0.37754660844802856,
0.6621691584587097,
-0.2799261212348938,
0.1339140385389328,
0.17219585180282593,
-0.24238257110118866,
-0.14859509468078613,
0.20004452764987946,
-0.5634893178939819,
-0.7145256996154785,
0.7443761229515076,
-0.36360761523246765,
-0.845130980014801,
-0.517167329788208,
-0.21890680491924286,
-0.4192202091217041,
0.23843562602996826,
0.1109611764550209,
0.3224784731864929,
-0.48379963636398315,
0.3237582743167877,
0.5080482959747314,
-0.13497649133205414,
0.38231441378593445,
0.19677788019180298,
0.049717701971530914,
-0.4311522841453552,
1.0339299440383911,
-0.09501051157712936,
-0.22054196894168854,
0.3785013258457184,
0.6099612712860107,
-0.40021851658821106,
-0.4879012107849121,
-0.38071104884147644,
-0.09395328164100647,
-0.9828716516494751,
-0.34111157059669495,
-0.7608912587165833,
0.2586866617202759,
-0.3939564824104309,
-0.08838698267936707,
-0.21076758205890656,
-0.3730543255805969,
0.20538876950740814,
-0.3733203411102295,
0.2509278655052185,
0.7090111374855042,
0.10644709318876266,
-0.09071038663387299,
-0.4390864372253418,
0.1881096363067627,
0.11265978962182999,
0.2077063024044037,
0.02459499053657055,
-0.06728064268827438,
-0.14540502429008484,
-0.2032986879348755,
-0.6875720024108887,
-1.0860333442687988,
-0.06799611449241638,
0.008208805695176125,
0.7161551117897034,
0.7367790341377258,
0.3533172905445099,
0.7281482815742493,
-0.4142672121524811,
0.9735493659973145,
0.25498339533805847,
-1.2076152563095093,
0.6992241740226746,
0.19251172244548798,
-0.1809655725955963,
0.52448570728302,
0.4395974278450012,
-0.5049669742584229,
-0.18379174172878265,
-0.651053249835968,
-0.9887247681617737,
0.30692046880722046,
-0.2792051434516907,
0.25050610303878784,
-0.4199817180633545,
0.09931831806898117,
0.08765560388565063,
0.04179069399833679,
-0.9289569854736328,
0.033622127026319504,
-0.22959215939044952,
-0.5030663013458252,
0.5423333048820496,
-0.1620904505252838,
-0.3057444393634796,
-0.2006397843360901,
0.5786007642745972,
-0.36692315340042114,
0.14489439129829407,
0.05806726589798927,
-0.10095886141061783,
0.22352313995361328,
0.5844820141792297,
0.1930280178785324,
0.49875959753990173,
0.2581595778465271,
-0.07477616518735886,
0.25746631622314453,
-0.23736028373241425,
-0.016932014375925064,
0.14643961191177368,
-0.3508337736129761,
0.3343958258628845,
0.5537118315696716,
0.9033799171447754,
0.11752521246671677,
-0.7185233235359192,
0.519886314868927,
0.032308172434568405,
-0.6080228686332703,
-0.27637553215026855,
-0.1284569352865219,
0.4108344614505768,
0.27085399627685547,
0.3536337614059448,
-0.02390105277299881,
0.32064929604530334,
-0.6763085126876831,
-0.0055499752052128315,
0.7196253538131714,
-0.3781258463859558,
-0.1787106692790985,
0.34244468808174133,
0.2520572543144226,
-0.16383829712867737,
0.3376403748989105,
0.13018271327018738,
-0.6044455170631409,
0.5679285526275635,
0.4331764280796051,
0.8700735569000244,
0.2483689934015274,
0.4637204110622406,
0.378225177526474,
-0.0917116180062294,
0.34326407313346863,
0.1450124979019165,
-0.410518079996109,
-0.6318134069442749,
-0.34230363368988037,
-0.48636394739151,
-0.6405454277992249,
0.17548474669456482,
-0.8600171208381653,
0.4798203110694885,
-0.5095875263214111,
-0.4045974314212799,
0.27624237537384033,
0.4336637854576111,
-0.15281365811824799,
0.08331894129514694,
0.26508063077926636,
1.085097312927246,
-0.7962466478347778,
0.6708693504333496,
0.8330629467964172,
-0.16158048808574677,
-0.326497882604599,
0.30193114280700684,
-0.06121579557657242,
0.26735392212867737,
0.18263296782970428,
0.38968053460121155,
-0.3871327042579651,
-0.46125975251197815,
-0.7300190925598145,
-0.13200293481349945,
0.6993266940116882,
0.5068655014038086,
-0.22489529848098755,
0.24647647142410278,
-0.21109141409397125,
0.34694141149520874,
-0.18776729702949524,
0.23672355711460114,
0.3120045065879822,
0.551910400390625,
-0.14997166395187378,
-0.2056015431880951,
-0.019513985142111778,
-0.5709629654884338,
-0.41530102491378784,
0.17020931839942932,
-0.5783182382583618,
0.44230955839157104,
-0.2175540179014206,
-0.3734198212623596,
0.1097152903676033,
1.1392048597335815,
0.23677027225494385,
0.41334018111228943,
0.7692389488220215,
0.5191643834114075,
1.1343175172805786,
-0.16647355258464813,
0.691700279712677,
0.14366868138313293,
0.09838049113750458,
0.8103999495506287,
-0.6342176795005798,
1.1249911785125732,
0.5286820530891418,
0.026863615959882736,
1.0574074983596802,
0.679301917552948,
0.09838742017745972,
0.22615160048007965,
0.3271746337413788,
-0.6387776732444763,
-0.4128076136112213,
-0.11264996975660324,
0.028369605541229248,
0.31657740473747253,
0.5632761716842651,
0.12421093881130219,
-0.09476316720247269,
-0.15444104373455048,
0.236186221241951,
0.47726064920425415,
-0.12694525718688965,
0.8358089923858643,
-0.13393136858940125,
-0.9303737878799438,
0.15526242554187775,
0.2586762011051178,
0.7652151584625244,
-0.8998328447341919,
0.04569707810878754,
-0.09055754542350769,
0.015060258097946644,
-0.4649259150028229,
-0.7340349555015564,
0.1469952017068863,
0.5054062604904175,
-0.18522535264492035,
0.23852379620075226,
0.5365951061248779,
-0.02458266168832779,
-0.3915979862213135,
0.5328242778778076,
0.11255908012390137,
-0.16090290248394012,
0.4101705551147461,
-0.7837966680526733,
0.10455627739429474,
-0.058819737285375595,
-0.3830285668373108,
0.24467308819293976,
0.8915483355522156,
-0.3495774269104004,
0.3466129004955292,
0.6419157981872559,
0.07542294263839722,
0.017177967354655266,
0.21132244169712067,
0.8599163293838501,
-0.6631426215171814,
-0.4168587923049927,
-0.9231038689613342,
0.6013604402542114,
-0.8426771759986877,
-0.5642263293266296,
0.48752230405807495,
0.6519169211387634,
0.5199394822120667,
0.3161301016807556,
0.842599093914032,
-0.5363054871559143,
0.314375102519989,
-0.33329442143440247,
0.5625438690185547,
-0.5208366513252258,
-0.13556161522865295,
-0.5373198986053467,
-0.6122570037841797,
-0.12021273374557495,
1.0016251802444458,
-0.14223502576351166,
-0.43445661664009094,
0.7601398825645447,
0.4592196047306061,
-0.09953565895557404,
0.4573390781879425,
0.14227858185768127,
-0.02955218218266964,
0.7880417704582214,
0.3181055784225464,
0.9223132133483887,
-0.39777442812919617,
0.5358579754829407,
0.02252431958913803,
-0.36549821496009827,
0.1059628278017044,
-1.2005610466003418,
-0.8251586556434631,
-0.7020565867424011,
-0.4859561324119568,
-0.32055360078811646,
-0.30156391859054565,
0.9876907467842102,
0.6462788581848145,
-1.006115436553955,
-0.30202198028564453,
0.045493707060813904,
0.24836555123329163,
-0.3183860778808594,
-0.21676331758499146,
0.20852670073509216,
-0.691663384437561,
-0.8293697834014893,
0.6007854342460632,
0.15767396986484528,
-0.690113365650177,
-0.16782726347446442,
0.013127749785780907,
-0.6930555701255798,
0.5754798650741577,
0.7887284159660339,
0.483682245016098,
-0.6922414302825928,
-0.1768658459186554,
-0.40035921335220337,
0.19432155787944794,
-0.0510605163872242,
1.032055377960205,
-0.5617021322250366,
0.5184322595596313,
0.46442580223083496,
0.9208774566650391,
0.4776478111743927,
-0.1399892270565033,
0.5918415188789368,
-0.48319780826568604,
0.22150973975658417,
0.14964325726032257,
0.777554452419281,
0.22189608216285706,
-0.015117398463189602,
0.2112991362810135,
0.03299696370959282,
-0.32241982221603394,
-1.0039124488830566,
0.23640576004981995,
-1.0040498971939087,
-0.48835334181785583,
0.7245344519615173,
-0.4135092496871948,
-0.30428546667099,
-0.29592838883399963,
-0.38939374685287476,
0.0218982957303524,
-0.13476170599460602,
0.6636414527893066,
1.084950566291809,
0.006327645853161812,
0.08195596933364868,
-0.4352780878543854,
0.26818084716796875,
0.7529321312904358,
-0.8519050478935242,
0.2809057831764221,
0.5905742049217224,
0.3271636664867401,
0.3548860251903534,
0.5210237503051758,
-0.4188203513622284,
0.15771551430225372,
-0.15712952613830566,
-0.20195770263671875,
0.3538278043270111,
-0.03209914639592171,
-0.09226792305707932,
0.7066088318824768,
0.1724260002374649,
-0.12053344398736954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00823v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00823v1
|
WorkBench: a Benchmark Dataset for Agents in a Realistic Workplace Setting
| 2024-05-01T19:07:03 | 2024-05-01T19:07:03 |
Olly Styles, Sam Miller, Patricio Cerda-Mardini, Tanaya Guha, Victor Sanchez, Bertie Vidgen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MA
|
We introduce WorkBench: a benchmark dataset for evaluating agents' ability to
execute tasks in a workplace setting. WorkBench contains a sandbox environment
with five databases, 26 tools, and 690 tasks. These tasks represent common
business activities, such as sending emails and scheduling meetings. The tasks
in WorkBench are challenging as they require planning, tool selection, and
often multiple actions. If a task has been successfully executed, one (or more)
of the database values may change. The correct outcome for each task is unique
and unambiguous, which allows for robust, automated evaluation. We call this
key contribution outcome-centric evaluation. We evaluate five existing ReAct
agents on WorkBench, finding they successfully complete as few as 3% of tasks
(Llama2-70B), and just 43% for the best-performing (GPT-4). We further find
that agents' errors can result in the wrong action being taken, such as an
email being sent to the wrong person. WorkBench reveals weaknesses in agents'
ability to undertake common business activities, raising questions about their
use in high-stakes workplace settings. WorkBench is publicly available as a
free resource at https://github.com/olly-styles/WorkBench.
|
[
-0.31438547372817993,
-0.38485413789749146,
0.41231968998908997,
0.1793486624956131,
-0.05956372991204262,
0.13319462537765503,
-0.0030370282474905252,
-0.6378030180931091,
0.027942338958382607,
0.2173234075307846,
-0.7353169322013855,
-0.34424176812171936,
-0.28920820355415344,
0.19998206198215485,
-0.3163338899612427,
0.7873755097389221,
-0.10345165431499481,
-0.2270047813653946,
-0.44671642780303955,
-0.32049617171287537,
-0.7145593762397766,
-0.23326998949050903,
-0.45986074209213257,
-0.6657660007476807,
0.49422794580459595,
0.5116022825241089,
0.8589457869529724,
0.5140403509140015,
0.6903333067893982,
0.31281355023384094,
0.20041701197624207,
-0.1660545915365219,
-0.8317281603813171,
0.3617554306983948,
-0.6399129033088684,
-0.4194145202636719,
-0.6015657186508179,
0.14168009161949158,
0.03692227229475975,
0.7382267117500305,
-0.48554500937461853,
0.30082085728645325,
-0.33307915925979614,
0.7410772442817688,
-0.7608487010002136,
0.389878511428833,
-0.17744936048984528,
0.2020864486694336,
-0.26265349984169006,
0.4309873580932617,
-0.2783108651638031,
-0.3820854425430298,
-0.37417981028556824,
-0.2931715250015259,
0.09352158010005951,
0.24004283547401428,
0.5168856978416443,
0.25383979082107544,
-0.45587292313575745,
0.30087557435035706,
-0.6950977444648743,
0.2746712863445282,
-0.3465869426727295,
0.12327272444963455,
0.19586782157421112,
0.837647020816803,
-0.37636855244636536,
-0.8930714726448059,
-0.44338658452033997,
-0.07697145640850067,
0.018612060695886612,
0.2664646506309509,
-0.23728561401367188,
0.17917871475219727,
0.48379358649253845,
0.4178817868232727,
-0.7357437610626221,
0.024071624502539635,
-0.13680341839790344,
-0.054783910512924194,
0.6231563687324524,
0.6546189188957214,
-0.05074658617377281,
0.08640915900468826,
-0.29881924390792847,
-0.6668813824653625,
-0.3904305696487427,
0.28107133507728577,
0.22098411619663239,
0.20823019742965698,
0.08693815767765045,
0.5397815108299255,
-0.5624556541442871,
0.6365768909454346,
0.041374605149030685,
0.31814083456993103,
0.428466260433197,
-0.2641470730304718,
-0.14186131954193115,
-0.1791963130235672,
0.5387397408485413,
0.3652389347553253,
-0.005463066045194864,
-0.5518062710762024,
-0.36945873498916626,
0.4567321240901947,
0.7762827277183533,
-0.7149255871772766,
0.006190521642565727,
0.35588252544403076,
-0.32945144176483154,
-0.48120927810668945,
0.10416217148303986,
-0.5436603426933289,
-0.8540287613868713,
-0.4085613787174225,
0.4012877345085144,
-0.11220589280128479,
-0.19838853180408478,
-0.32970353960990906,
-0.4604581892490387,
0.15515553951263428,
0.3123207986354828,
-0.2404780238866806,
0.6713493466377258,
0.681296169757843,
0.4383409917354584,
-0.391005277633667,
-0.650863528251648,
-0.7031278610229492,
-0.08629617094993591,
-0.5787221193313599,
0.7732507586479187,
-0.5398597717285156,
-0.4274989366531372,
-0.09673065692186356,
0.21147237718105316,
0.03490608185529709,
-0.7337532043457031,
0.2760677635669708,
-0.3678523302078247,
-0.5455330610275269,
-0.606713593006134,
-0.29968127608299255,
0.023479772731661797,
0.3674938380718231,
-0.9489402174949646,
1.1090186834335327,
0.6941762566566467,
-0.30929192900657654,
0.5002127289772034,
-0.8998585939407349,
-0.5180690884590149,
-0.044931888580322266,
-0.10811208188533783,
-0.09023850411176682,
0.3111530840396881,
-0.4541994333267212,
0.42669034004211426,
-0.4171728193759918,
-0.092093326151371,
-0.48230111598968506,
-0.41951608657836914,
0.40296801924705505,
0.06678562611341476,
0.44062498211860657,
0.06941421329975128,
-0.6931332349777222,
0.22467084228992462,
-0.6763015985488892,
0.14006246626377106,
0.028126703575253487,
0.030775928869843483,
0.2371300458908081,
-0.07734764367341995,
0.1973622739315033,
0.5286889672279358,
0.09760669618844986,
-0.7069557309150696,
-0.1897289901971817,
-0.08946853876113892,
-0.1743934452533722,
0.931445300579071,
-0.08100704103708267,
0.15281511843204498,
-0.6286558508872986,
0.6082983016967773,
-0.14115320146083832,
0.45073285698890686,
0.43607261776924133,
-0.098990298807621,
-0.14168556034564972,
-0.18910099565982819,
0.10045908391475677,
0.44933104515075684,
-0.6250491142272949,
0.3178779184818268,
-0.38406285643577576,
-1.0277003049850464,
0.055846333503723145,
0.12211255729198456,
0.5865291357040405,
0.6219854950904846,
-0.10473030805587769,
-0.8814353942871094,
-0.16852878034114838,
-0.8804922103881836,
-0.43125128746032715,
0.06934592872858047,
0.1392146646976471,
0.16616955399513245,
0.6985807418823242,
-0.1405734270811081,
1.081191062927246,
-0.3439994752407074,
-0.28871414065361023,
-0.12024693936109543,
0.29607048630714417,
0.34880876541137695,
0.22692903876304626,
0.4025065302848816,
-0.717572033405304,
-0.6370337009429932,
-0.05105886235833168,
-0.8218790888786316,
0.024647457525134087,
0.1923523247241974,
-0.47968238592147827,
0.1498284935951233,
0.3637811839580536,
-0.7755292654037476,
0.7644932270050049,
0.2571313679218292,
-0.46255698800086975,
0.5908918976783752,
-0.04363023862242699,
0.05973893776535988,
-0.7607773542404175,
0.5984482765197754,
-0.3326736092567444,
-0.6174485683441162,
-0.5084883570671082,
-0.07141058892011642,
0.09075652062892914,
-0.49482154846191406,
-0.48046597838401794,
0.43880870938301086,
-0.2372172772884369,
-0.5416076183319092,
-0.3259016275405884,
0.13507166504859924,
-0.02850508503615856,
0.5989789366722107,
-0.2037089318037033,
0.6658939719200134,
0.22352880239486694,
-0.3150253891944885,
0.8487737774848938,
0.4331679344177246,
-0.27312082052230835,
1.231353759765625,
-0.5229753255844116,
0.3902069926261902,
-0.05681299790740013,
0.526421070098877,
-0.7520819902420044,
-0.460454523563385,
0.10588007420301437,
-0.1209225058555603,
0.04399767145514488,
0.24771171808242798,
-0.7378122210502625,
-0.5446972846984863,
-0.3622482419013977,
0.01128453016281128,
0.5730305910110474,
-0.4974878132343292,
0.614086925983429,
0.3010888695716858,
-0.04331602156162262,
-0.6439599394798279,
-0.535671591758728,
0.07034869492053986,
0.184462308883667,
-0.37726739048957825,
0.3200375437736511,
0.05591769143939018,
-0.22024419903755188,
0.3338884711265564,
-0.6879551410675049,
-0.27175387740135193,
0.05410829558968544,
0.7563310265541077,
-0.04746020585298538,
0.30754396319389343,
-0.136521577835083,
-0.5357033014297485,
-0.33932822942733765,
0.08131987601518631,
0.16473053395748138,
0.2153719663619995,
-0.3186720013618469,
-0.6039738655090332,
-0.1296357810497284,
0.35294076800346375,
0.6905040740966797,
-0.15945854783058167,
0.6233320236206055,
0.658804178237915,
-0.46381503343582153,
-0.17386992275714874,
-0.5147616863250732,
-0.2690213918685913,
-0.4484895169734955,
0.20784004032611847,
-0.35527244210243225,
-0.05792627111077309,
0.7296358346939087,
-0.4031394124031067,
0.3151134252548218,
0.2804257869720459,
0.5676778554916382,
-0.05348361283540726,
0.7689018249511719,
0.5059487819671631,
-0.14760532975196838,
0.5936449766159058,
-0.052654579281806946,
0.18545418977737427,
-0.4799908995628357,
-0.13236625492572784,
-0.39957037568092346,
-0.563433825969696,
-0.20412477850914001,
-0.3533778190612793,
0.35939884185791016,
-0.43688127398490906,
-0.1547861099243164,
0.6356737017631531,
-0.38270440697669983,
0.4891194999217987,
0.5137648582458496,
0.273849219083786,
-0.09158169478178024,
-0.26396605372428894,
0.05712532997131348,
0.277891606092453,
-0.39132392406463623,
-0.3366509974002838,
1.0444698333740234,
-0.11021015048027039,
0.8052529096603394,
0.20334336161613464,
0.6052751541137695,
0.7789292931556702,
0.46854114532470703,
-0.31700265407562256,
0.5486875772476196,
0.13339264690876007,
-0.9638217091560364,
-0.4559372663497925,
-0.2515541911125183,
-1.2952946424484253,
0.41888824105262756,
0.1627601534128189,
-0.8827962875366211,
0.3661627471446991,
0.03537075221538544,
-0.06583329290151596,
-0.15911635756492615,
-0.70779949426651,
1.4147847890853882,
-0.11737237870693207,
-0.8262753486633301,
-0.5267788171768188,
-0.809836208820343,
-0.14137548208236694,
-0.05524975433945656,
0.34399983286857605,
-0.5093124508857727,
-0.00866826344281435,
0.5829694867134094,
-0.7662326693534851,
0.9847195744514465,
-0.5739859938621521,
0.37497881054878235,
0.21466949582099915,
0.2344939112663269,
0.945648729801178,
-0.2604491412639618,
-0.4818311631679535,
-0.30790701508522034,
0.2140626609325409,
-0.4931217432022095,
-0.6892775297164917,
0.46081840991973877,
-0.4568462371826172,
-0.04835734888911247,
-0.7001758217811584,
-0.38037970662117004,
-0.6031718254089355,
0.409696489572525,
-0.003711296245455742,
0.4989088773727417,
-0.6948713660240173,
0.24656252562999725,
0.023959847167134285,
0.3933682441711426,
0.43526503443717957,
0.7732945680618286,
0.17372597754001617,
-0.16306008398532867,
0.8312894105911255,
0.03474622592329979,
0.07784830033779144,
-0.0993499681353569,
-0.09347208589315414,
-0.37750059366226196,
-0.1416243463754654,
-0.1391589492559433,
-0.12366101145744324,
-1.1315832138061523,
-0.42197179794311523,
0.07595963031053543,
0.31588760018348694,
0.09705547243356705,
-0.29593244194984436,
-0.6517257690429688,
-0.17712321877479553,
0.20225559175014496,
-0.17724527418613434,
0.06063365191221237,
0.7638105154037476,
-0.2108301967382431,
0.09020935744047165,
-0.3908964693546295,
0.41675370931625366,
0.42358824610710144,
0.752316415309906,
-0.30597442388534546,
0.24674221873283386,
-0.43566858768463135,
-0.196767657995224,
-0.5424216389656067,
-0.9532920718193054,
0.11895672231912613,
0.07741899788379669,
0.8405139446258545,
0.027807898819446564,
0.47256961464881897,
0.26158618927001953,
-0.221810981631279,
0.5476418733596802,
-0.019628997892141342,
-0.8847575187683105,
0.22205552458763123,
-0.37941867113113403,
0.2140267938375473,
1.075602650642395,
0.1161738857626915,
-0.4350343346595764,
-0.1476449966430664,
-1.043729305267334,
-0.7550826072692871,
1.0875904560089111,
0.5412238836288452,
-0.20228569209575653,
0.29477444291114807,
0.06119197979569435,
0.08929699659347534,
0.693163275718689,
-0.36000192165374756,
-0.07659649103879929,
-0.1296023428440094,
-0.32567283511161804,
-0.31956207752227783,
0.25345075130462646,
-0.6452556252479553,
0.06691905111074448,
0.36969995498657227,
-0.212473526597023,
0.3557361662387848,
-0.058459777384996414,
-0.31276991963386536,
-0.25284239649772644,
0.18897145986557007,
0.11565025895833969,
1.0276705026626587,
-0.2778678834438324,
-0.01754213310778141,
0.33761677145957947,
-0.2792859971523285,
0.2179083228111267,
0.33277034759521484,
0.6896234750747681,
-0.01676279492676258,
0.11748486757278442,
0.5810920596122742,
0.1736961305141449,
-1.001179814338684,
0.7042106986045837,
-0.07796094566583633,
-0.11771336197853088,
-0.34923675656318665,
0.22431889176368713,
-0.10058265179395676,
0.3687991499900818,
0.15112735331058502,
0.18942506611347198,
0.2980266511440277,
-0.7708069086074829,
0.05427146703004837,
0.08596543967723846,
-0.5683656334877014,
-0.15515024960041046,
0.41940709948539734,
0.24992865324020386,
-0.34040597081184387,
0.4442785680294037,
-0.5373571515083313,
-0.2513992488384247,
1.0408942699432373,
0.24995511770248413,
0.8128752708435059,
-0.12722626328468323,
0.14537765085697174,
-0.12892961502075195,
0.21819284558296204,
-0.24670293927192688,
0.6333767771720886,
0.07172725349664688,
-0.26112258434295654,
-0.03763381391763687,
-0.19445544481277466,
-1.1105108261108398,
-0.334798663854599,
-0.6765073537826538,
-0.15922069549560547,
-0.4744058847427368,
-0.44287770986557007,
0.07729539275169373,
0.053427841514348984,
-1.0709198713302612,
0.3031921982765198,
-0.21512627601623535,
0.8477419018745422,
-0.785393476486206,
0.27073007822036743,
0.8950859308242798,
-0.14258506894111633,
-0.5680798292160034,
-0.3790510594844818,
0.23626643419265747,
-0.44757068157196045,
0.3334009647369385,
0.20992068946361542,
-0.13103850185871124,
-0.33908772468566895,
-0.20089904963970184,
-0.6642780303955078,
1.185394525527954,
0.38686031103134155,
-0.3118572235107422,
0.4561893045902252,
0.2888917028903961,
0.7516846060752869,
-0.19659297168254852,
0.37087851762771606,
0.6947278380393982,
0.7188805341720581,
-0.2588805854320526,
-1.052287220954895,
0.46347782015800476,
-0.49717724323272705,
-0.028289061039686203,
0.0797811895608902,
-0.7611508965492249,
0.8501010537147522,
0.18217653036117554,
0.06600864976644516,
-0.329126238822937,
0.05596115067601204,
0.03610605001449585,
0.45694366097450256,
0.7088015675544739,
0.4034978747367859,
0.907791256904602,
-0.18588794767856598,
1.2630243301391602,
-0.20075970888137817,
0.12412870675325394,
0.9368274211883545,
-0.7011013031005859,
0.8579502701759338,
0.23425346612930298,
-0.24756380915641785,
0.659401535987854,
0.5674479603767395,
-0.01832766830921173,
0.3889581263065338,
0.27085956931114197,
0.0024907453916966915,
-0.21667000651359558,
-0.166182279586792,
-0.2230168879032135,
0.4704848527908325,
0.0575520321726799,
0.2149268388748169,
-0.27513620257377625,
0.06575804948806763,
-0.18803726136684418,
-0.17640361189842224,
0.07082773000001907,
0.7574254274368286,
-0.047063373029232025,
-0.7618804574012756,
0.464141845703125,
-0.2241983413696289,
-0.18421512842178345,
-0.5237852931022644,
0.05062728747725487,
-0.10475139319896698,
0.4721934497356415,
-0.3746265769004822,
-0.6092504858970642,
0.25993114709854126,
-0.09040120989084244,
-0.006569265387952328,
-0.20802845060825348,
0.7175055742263794,
0.2780196964740753,
0.024466639384627342,
0.22690272331237793,
0.4683242738246918,
0.07385391741991043,
-0.5403925180435181,
-0.6192376613616943,
0.13946516811847687,
-0.5751055479049683,
-0.4666769802570343,
0.3336866796016693,
0.25645625591278076,
-0.13533438742160797,
0.5692899227142334,
0.4329887330532074,
-0.22852560877799988,
-0.29023218154907227,
0.03984808549284935,
0.9278984069824219,
-0.6550798416137695,
-0.6443652510643005,
-0.3685305118560791,
0.5866641402244568,
-0.6843287944793701,
-0.17677271366119385,
0.4819566309452057,
0.6549398303031921,
0.5044652223587036,
-0.24954353272914886,
0.8215317130088806,
-0.45862168073654175,
0.4734170138835907,
0.09532742947340012,
0.3799239993095398,
-0.5399702191352844,
-0.3972936272621155,
-0.37739497423171997,
-0.9686616659164429,
0.225383460521698,
0.4301574230194092,
-0.25329503417015076,
0.14261461794376373,
1.0137971639633179,
0.6937761902809143,
-0.04238349199295044,
0.08712087571620941,
0.255428671836853,
0.018189821392297745,
0.31897538900375366,
0.5463443398475647,
0.6984434723854065,
-0.29950714111328125,
0.8324464559555054,
-0.4824671149253845,
-0.2848914861679077,
-0.6105560064315796,
-0.7916058897972107,
-0.89178067445755,
-0.3227166533470154,
-0.2860814034938812,
-0.27514150738716125,
0.2137029469013214,
0.7733341455459595,
0.9097733497619629,
-0.5893737077713013,
-0.46198493242263794,
-0.25801366567611694,
0.06106681004166603,
-0.8931984901428223,
-0.1618843823671341,
-0.008562666364014149,
-0.4653330147266388,
-0.322407066822052,
0.494917094707489,
0.043310388922691345,
-0.20960858464241028,
0.15499550104141235,
-0.08947469294071198,
0.3993209898471832,
0.07072800397872925,
0.3364870250225067,
0.626471221446991,
-0.18514178693294525,
-0.1286650449037552,
-0.2147090882062912,
-0.41269227862358093,
-0.04363952577114105,
0.5911016464233398,
-0.6320312023162842,
0.5069625973701477,
0.5585891008377075,
0.6974354386329651,
0.8272014856338501,
0.12075794488191605,
0.7008427381515503,
-0.8374708294868469,
0.13301686942577362,
0.26753655076026917,
0.1938476264476776,
0.12922987341880798,
-0.1679164469242096,
1.0380144119262695,
0.1865006536245346,
-0.5186445116996765,
-0.876771867275238,
-0.05340680852532387,
-0.9819852113723755,
-0.21955108642578125,
0.6020141839981079,
0.0033180397003889084,
-0.3605770468711853,
-0.22196923196315765,
-0.22366869449615479,
0.17224760353565216,
-0.4250866770744324,
0.7492544651031494,
0.6667792201042175,
-0.41058149933815,
0.1118314117193222,
-0.6833117008209229,
0.457215815782547,
0.5335304141044617,
-1.1900230646133423,
0.26499420404434204,
0.6339541673660278,
0.2228286862373352,
0.04135577008128166,
0.7139862179756165,
0.18418334424495697,
0.8555532097816467,
0.5127197504043579,
0.19709870219230652,
-0.2954734265804291,
-0.22410649061203003,
0.1419059932231903,
0.273129403591156,
0.2187972515821457,
-0.3287845849990845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00821v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00821v1
|
Uncovering Agendas: A Novel French & English Dataset for Agenda Detection on Social Media
| 2024-05-01T19:02:35 | 2024-05-01T19:02:35 |
Gregorios Katsios, Ning Sa, Ankita Bhaumik, Tomek Strzalkowski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The behavior and decision making of groups or communities can be dramatically
influenced by individuals pushing particular agendas, e.g., to promote or
disparage a person or an activity, to call for action, etc.. In the examination
of online influence campaigns, particularly those related to important
political and social events, scholars often concentrate on identifying the
sources responsible for setting and controlling the agenda (e.g., public
media). In this article we present a methodology for detecting specific
instances of agenda control through social media where annotated data is
limited or non-existent. By using a modest corpus of Twitter messages centered
on the 2022 French Presidential Elections, we carry out a comprehensive
evaluation of various approaches and techniques that can be applied to this
problem. Our findings demonstrate that by treating the task as a textual
entailment problem, it is possible to overcome the requirement for a large
annotated training dataset.
|
[
-0.5810834765434265,
-0.9714540839195251,
0.673689603805542,
0.45480892062187195,
-0.2353868931531906,
-0.061710283160209656,
-0.16808120906352997,
-0.1486968845129013,
0.7741765379905701,
0.7404130101203918,
-0.7156002521514893,
-0.6958009004592896,
-1.0262689590454102,
-0.11623368412256241,
-0.5706591010093689,
0.7697122693061829,
-0.14317086338996887,
-0.18919898569583893,
-0.013227041810750961,
-0.12835665047168732,
-0.2810294032096863,
-0.1483367383480072,
-0.6595876812934875,
-0.27076831459999084,
0.6387085318565369,
0.2800479233264923,
0.281535804271698,
0.8669157028198242,
0.4228248596191406,
0.14136479794979095,
-0.0006676981574855745,
0.6855893731117249,
-0.9876552224159241,
-0.20615532994270325,
-0.18122832477092743,
-0.1254211813211441,
-0.06379902362823486,
0.09051855653524399,
0.5149102210998535,
0.1791187822818756,
0.31762298941612244,
0.23187963664531708,
0.2580239474773407,
0.731765627861023,
-0.6998077630996704,
0.28419575095176697,
-0.7358813285827637,
-0.4193676710128784,
-0.3972319960594177,
-0.7349468469619751,
-0.16315539181232452,
-0.3520585596561432,
-0.19860389828681946,
-0.5244827270507812,
0.04521302878856659,
-0.19941411912441254,
0.6623917818069458,
0.14729852974414825,
-0.55226069688797,
-0.629498302936554,
-0.8330709338188171,
0.7067359089851379,
-0.06350213289260864,
0.2782266438007355,
0.844517707824707,
0.030079221352934837,
-0.21717430651187897,
-0.4500328004360199,
-0.27206796407699585,
0.4913138151168823,
0.08451961725950241,
0.1186860129237175,
-0.09443973749876022,
-0.20574834942817688,
0.08255225419998169,
-0.36791977286338806,
-0.10432812571525574,
-0.021925190463662148,
-0.3021567761898041,
-0.015087190084159374,
0.6893002986907959,
-0.22284270823001862,
0.28339341282844543,
-0.28180891275405884,
-0.22169293463230133,
0.2517406940460205,
-0.7518335580825806,
-0.13739442825317383,
0.5814363956451416,
0.28501471877098083,
-0.2758341133594513,
0.6498715281486511,
-0.38110655546188354,
0.41904905438423157,
0.09038379043340683,
0.39685729146003723,
-0.02732839621603489,
-0.3048439621925354,
0.13296571373939514,
0.19229477643966675,
0.6418932676315308,
0.5488684773445129,
0.46333038806915283,
0.19827187061309814,
-0.15629668533802032,
0.18525969982147217,
0.014201712794601917,
-0.5962010622024536,
-0.22438593208789825,
0.5406249165534973,
-0.4825613796710968,
-0.14650604128837585,
0.24269364774227142,
-0.7799667716026306,
-0.7026199698448181,
-0.4004584848880768,
0.4127335846424103,
-0.07212948054075241,
-0.05414937809109688,
-0.17857138812541962,
-0.34097933769226074,
0.24393078684806824,
0.5438641905784607,
-0.5457367897033691,
-0.1061713770031929,
0.9353504180908203,
0.9402874112129211,
-0.01452210359275341,
0.25527632236480713,
-0.4981726408004761,
0.07792752236127853,
-0.5013746619224548,
0.8858698606491089,
-0.9119634032249451,
-0.37936925888061523,
0.47053542733192444,
0.19064021110534668,
0.2012348473072052,
-0.2183695137500763,
0.6212473511695862,
-0.4925387501716614,
-0.13228963315486908,
-0.4184419512748718,
-0.6242260336875916,
-0.07192978262901306,
0.06737906485795975,
-0.7863555550575256,
0.9043068289756775,
-0.26800212264060974,
-0.48785778880119324,
0.48257845640182495,
-0.7221108078956604,
-0.4712681770324707,
0.015124144963920116,
-0.6037641167640686,
-0.2759326696395874,
0.004623927641659975,
0.863366425037384,
0.6948077082633972,
-0.07935015857219696,
0.29436224699020386,
-0.2025117576122284,
-0.15970733761787415,
0.05271071195602417,
-0.2285616546869278,
0.972723126411438,
-0.4064100384712219,
-0.4656055271625519,
0.27443164587020874,
-0.49359914660453796,
-0.48094403743743896,
0.17767493426799774,
0.008693257346749306,
-0.47698286175727844,
0.5957834124565125,
0.17866595089435577,
0.0822836384177208,
0.3566645383834839,
-0.456435889005661,
0.11453141272068024,
0.09688197076320648,
0.5252134203910828,
0.8183782696723938,
0.866977870464325,
0.634282648563385,
-0.5706403255462646,
-0.06654845178127289,
-0.33034181594848633,
0.10270535200834274,
-0.19523048400878906,
-0.8348898887634277,
-0.5865058302879333,
-0.05068527162075043,
0.004335536155849695,
0.5487406849861145,
-0.8110491633415222,
0.4594438076019287,
-0.2335890829563141,
-0.41964444518089294,
-0.3914455771446228,
0.28688353300094604,
-0.18771736323833466,
-0.08614283800125122,
0.26494741439819336,
0.3095371723175049,
-0.5454826951026917,
-0.9175406098365784,
-0.565406858921051,
0.18452870845794678,
-0.19054605066776276,
0.30433228611946106,
0.8542740345001221,
0.046899739652872086,
0.6463205218315125,
-0.1657179743051529,
-0.5826680660247803,
-0.22890245914459229,
0.4547615349292755,
0.11145390570163727,
0.35497918725013733,
0.38053998351097107,
-1.1417902708053589,
-0.40620267391204834,
-0.025805950164794922,
-0.5543590188026428,
-0.19606436789035797,
-0.4283311069011688,
-0.21517714858055115,
-0.17098882794380188,
0.6335803270339966,
-0.0912819653749466,
0.6630208492279053,
0.27735090255737305,
-0.10811447352170944,
-0.1740979254245758,
0.08958286792039871,
0.4513401985168457,
-0.8419983983039856,
-0.3633368909358978,
0.5123910307884216,
-0.28996914625167847,
-0.704498827457428,
-0.36951151490211487,
0.22209478914737701,
0.21383318305015564,
-0.5135512351989746,
0.4614045321941376,
-0.2647538483142853,
0.48430049419403076,
-0.3092285990715027,
0.33376437425613403,
-0.13847340643405914,
0.23031914234161377,
0.15972140431404114,
0.27200791239738464,
0.33197033405303955,
-0.5243115425109863,
-0.04917487874627113,
0.42832013964653015,
-0.5876423716545105,
0.5035074353218079,
-0.4509136974811554,
0.4671628177165985,
-0.7181641459465027,
0.1657951921224594,
-1.1840513944625854,
-0.4285365045070648,
0.2505931556224823,
-0.5046422481536865,
-0.08993183821439743,
-0.28603053092956543,
-0.49044424295425415,
-0.022798480466008186,
-0.2849334180355072,
-0.2958787679672241,
0.26310038566589355,
-0.49107420444488525,
0.5357046127319336,
0.9139804840087891,
0.2060643881559372,
-0.3998912572860718,
-0.4883709251880646,
0.0388101190328598,
-0.2636186182498932,
-0.1164710745215416,
0.18627716600894928,
0.547391951084137,
-0.3829343914985657,
0.18532371520996094,
-0.03845355287194252,
0.036211736500263214,
-0.21690057218074799,
0.35163864493370056,
-0.20204350352287292,
0.2559968829154968,
0.21811483800411224,
0.22459672391414642,
0.11850925534963608,
-0.05606696754693985,
-0.3665989637374878,
0.5317078828811646,
0.41420575976371765,
-0.19407854974269867,
-0.626107394695282,
0.5438774228096008,
0.4359699785709381,
-0.4840157628059387,
0.6703113317489624,
0.5573844909667969,
-0.8528823852539062,
-0.42055681347846985,
-0.6412431001663208,
-0.43341508507728577,
-0.43408825993537903,
0.281631201505661,
0.2421208769083023,
-0.7309662103652954,
0.7132970094680786,
-0.29475629329681396,
0.1973755657672882,
0.5329124927520752,
0.6313284039497375,
0.058190666139125824,
1.1061103343963623,
0.4209423363208771,
-0.26521381735801697,
0.5472033023834229,
-0.38868144154548645,
-0.05636950209736824,
-0.49779582023620605,
-0.1979471743106842,
-0.6800646781921387,
-0.5104855895042419,
-0.8171519041061401,
-0.6188428401947021,
0.15411190688610077,
-0.257098525762558,
-0.10607507079839706,
0.2094605416059494,
-0.8233659863471985,
0.5551113486289978,
0.42589327692985535,
0.38013097643852234,
-0.018067091703414917,
-0.016635090112686157,
0.7771878242492676,
0.06010931357741356,
-0.48830363154411316,
-0.7394249439239502,
0.9983310103416443,
-0.06745906919240952,
0.45896193385124207,
-0.07714320719242096,
0.717263400554657,
0.5956991314888,
0.5504814386367798,
-0.6050987243652344,
0.47805723547935486,
-0.06534796953201294,
-0.8645642399787903,
-0.4001935124397278,
-0.2797188460826874,
-0.9775258898735046,
0.042055174708366394,
-0.5539721846580505,
-1.1970672607421875,
0.5858791470527649,
-0.09347399324178696,
0.06048104539513588,
0.43434402346611023,
-0.2367134988307953,
0.7182570695877075,
-0.4166179299354553,
-0.5717203617095947,
-0.11062191426753998,
-0.3017576038837433,
-0.10624569654464722,
-0.22428305447101593,
0.40441957116127014,
-0.5664394497871399,
-0.40329843759536743,
1.144766092300415,
0.2762325406074524,
0.8262775540351868,
-0.2143012434244156,
0.2483842968940735,
0.3126896917819977,
-0.2608191668987274,
1.0066486597061157,
0.20009414851665497,
0.16715815663337708,
0.18393395841121674,
-0.23514395952224731,
-0.29829922318458557,
-0.3544567823410034,
0.7142271995544434,
-0.4678662419319153,
-0.45829805731773376,
0.026728468015789986,
-0.43177610635757446,
0.07409466803073883,
0.29313868284225464,
0.4593193531036377,
0.440585732460022,
-0.4612801969051361,
0.46383804082870483,
0.5035966634750366,
0.08728180080652237,
0.4056980311870575,
0.21916481852531433,
-0.07256943732500076,
-0.08447770029306412,
0.9938217997550964,
0.7027832269668579,
-0.29974430799484253,
0.629537045955658,
0.19965027272701263,
-0.31752490997314453,
-0.4366607964038849,
-0.13106591999530792,
0.08780456334352493,
-0.6153736114501953,
0.1411038637161255,
-0.6269338130950928,
0.2603166699409485,
-0.199130579829216,
-0.3482285141944885,
-0.29230692982673645,
-0.2644006609916687,
-0.6419975757598877,
-0.05589527264237404,
0.4417048692703247,
1.0536922216415405,
0.057070497423410416,
0.5274270176887512,
-0.18562613427639008,
0.2029176503419876,
-0.0564412847161293,
0.07968475669622421,
-0.30402982234954834,
0.04862487316131592,
-0.08167535066604614,
0.016573350876569748,
-0.3296375572681427,
-1.5202562808990479,
0.35177555680274963,
0.20774152874946594,
0.31251072883605957,
0.8186230063438416,
0.2949639558792114,
0.19910931587219238,
-0.4471704065799713,
0.4574988782405853,
-0.3626267611980438,
-0.6581390500068665,
0.8279491066932678,
-0.9103723168373108,
0.17840367555618286,
0.5460523962974548,
0.9706708788871765,
-0.2818824350833893,
-0.4665098488330841,
-0.7201627492904663,
-1.0098251104354858,
0.4531404376029968,
0.40632420778274536,
0.19782130420207977,
-0.19669871032238007,
0.3942602872848511,
-0.2872817814350128,
0.4108489453792572,
-0.2700280249118805,
-0.3821481466293335,
0.09236853569746017,
-0.06156206503510475,
-0.08307606726884842,
-0.19991745054721832,
-0.3207589387893677,
-0.0952928215265274,
0.7061068415641785,
0.1328907161951065,
0.18036620318889618,
0.3629528284072876,
0.25888460874557495,
-0.15809988975524902,
-0.057923510670661926,
0.47147706151008606,
0.819981575012207,
-0.3514333665370941,
-0.04276410490274429,
-0.16904175281524658,
-0.1325373351573944,
-0.05516497418284416,
0.023220526054501534,
-0.44574710726737976,
0.2609544098377228,
0.28464266657829285,
0.5927724242210388,
-0.0009597846656106412,
-0.26789426803588867,
0.3714536130428314,
0.19433508813381195,
-0.43367433547973633,
-0.5156408548355103,
-0.36454683542251587,
0.33613741397857666,
0.12052552402019501,
0.7190813422203064,
-0.36558961868286133,
0.14272646605968475,
-0.5132284164428711,
0.4795190095901489,
0.5854302048683167,
-0.9987725019454956,
-0.21341179311275482,
0.8131685853004456,
0.28124842047691345,
-0.5924527645111084,
0.1704709380865097,
-0.3421613872051239,
-0.5220946073532104,
0.9568204879760742,
0.13125349581241608,
0.6809566617012024,
-0.29199695587158203,
0.23895685374736786,
0.11929196864366531,
0.9170584678649902,
-0.03146674484014511,
0.343773752450943,
0.16102460026741028,
-0.8940064311027527,
-0.5074648261070251,
0.04967603459954262,
-0.3064129650592804,
0.7102404832839966,
-0.6139926314353943,
0.4219014048576355,
-0.4205746650695801,
-0.3303411304950714,
0.6248507499694824,
-0.1535625457763672,
-0.6927199959754944,
-0.10875655710697174,
-0.21961823105812073,
0.7583523392677307,
-1.0190283060073853,
0.43966615200042725,
0.6833294630050659,
0.1585633009672165,
-0.3278887867927551,
0.130076065659523,
0.45461305975914,
-0.6297387480735779,
0.3554516136646271,
0.2687723934650421,
0.22059088945388794,
0.02508765459060669,
-0.7265456914901733,
-0.5153589248657227,
0.4504883885383606,
0.015635546296834946,
-0.4051743745803833,
0.28528428077697754,
0.041706401854753494,
0.11521512269973755,
-0.4655569791793823,
-0.2197207510471344,
0.5571068525314331,
0.8154993653297424,
-0.35696640610694885,
-0.30410680174827576,
-0.01316411979496479,
-0.1122712716460228,
-0.5182092785835266,
0.7625856995582581,
-0.5884604454040527,
0.6950204372406006,
0.24907241761684418,
-0.4541097581386566,
-0.4923596680164337,
0.4729917645454407,
-0.44805023074150085,
0.5210190415382385,
0.35588160157203674,
0.00020694269915111363,
0.663447380065918,
-0.4051350951194763,
0.9136634469032288,
-0.4916791021823883,
0.2980957329273224,
0.8076969385147095,
-0.2149088978767395,
0.6990609169006348,
0.45663008093833923,
0.2539667785167694,
-0.04443426430225372,
0.6517729759216309,
0.12234967201948166,
0.4728357195854187,
0.0031095175072550774,
-0.24527277052402496,
-0.5509644150733948,
-0.5120235085487366,
0.07310266047716141,
0.5282173752784729,
1.0386496782302856,
-0.33118823170661926,
-0.3618677258491516,
0.1322307139635086,
0.016679197549819946,
0.36546680331230164,
-0.5869019627571106,
0.7179725170135498,
-0.12926971912384033,
-0.4137618839740753,
0.02502772957086563,
-0.21892255544662476,
0.22565604746341705,
-0.473560631275177,
-0.3252578377723694,
0.30015209317207336,
0.006341114640235901,
-0.18648461997509003,
-0.6575725674629211,
0.18307557702064514,
-0.2652208209037781,
0.20882917940616608,
-0.20288504660129547,
0.9063515067100525,
-0.3522745668888092,
-0.45114946365356445,
0.3442291021347046,
0.7598778605461121,
-0.11010254174470901,
-0.24006995558738708,
-0.4346148669719696,
0.0665561631321907,
0.0843905508518219,
-0.28849735856056213,
-0.05701626092195511,
0.3055115342140198,
-0.3738248944282532,
0.40150198340415955,
0.5534765720367432,
0.11497461795806885,
-0.5102992653846741,
-0.24938082695007324,
0.6990960240364075,
-0.06693234294652939,
-0.4092182517051697,
-0.82098388671875,
0.14208781719207764,
-0.5346783995628357,
-0.26868578791618347,
1.0059162378311157,
0.5395286083221436,
0.8102294206619263,
0.13858141005039215,
1.0986052751541138,
0.04404594376683235,
0.5113378167152405,
-0.2525025010108948,
0.745634138584137,
-0.6039575934410095,
0.06163007393479347,
-0.015346097759902477,
-0.6784670352935791,
-0.3420060873031616,
0.6609128713607788,
-0.716620147228241,
-0.28210824728012085,
0.2169966697692871,
0.7655308842658997,
-0.013496994972229004,
0.20990410447120667,
-0.035316742956638336,
-0.00045498888357542455,
0.30335891246795654,
0.12290448695421219,
0.7199991345405579,
0.06835492700338364,
0.2858242988586426,
-0.3401728868484497,
-0.420795738697052,
-0.34656375646591187,
-0.8409186601638794,
-1.2878332138061523,
-0.9671795964241028,
-0.2525728642940521,
-0.4340168237686157,
0.3974911570549011,
1.1477420330047607,
0.5492018461227417,
-0.8663840889930725,
-0.06992838531732559,
-0.14298652112483978,
0.6108308434486389,
-0.26198041439056396,
-0.13636349141597748,
0.8835570812225342,
0.10052510350942612,
-0.9965020418167114,
0.18013902008533478,
0.4001428484916687,
-0.2053816318511963,
-0.14297224581241608,
0.5872876644134521,
-0.6820394396781921,
0.6283373832702637,
0.3340246379375458,
0.24532254040241241,
-0.43514400720596313,
-0.5228203535079956,
0.01333039253950119,
0.24258677661418915,
-0.037634558975696564,
0.999833345413208,
-0.2712927758693695,
0.4835039973258972,
0.6078952550888062,
0.5525714159011841,
0.5843027830123901,
0.05506683513522148,
0.15898431837558746,
-0.9298580884933472,
0.2869609296321869,
0.2856689989566803,
0.2907620072364807,
0.19772058725357056,
-0.3933905065059662,
0.4634641110897064,
0.0430588573217392,
-0.6240487098693848,
-0.500005304813385,
0.15802094340324402,
-0.8515979051589966,
-0.2332821935415268,
1.2436708211898804,
0.47296106815338135,
-0.3716699182987213,
-0.5141721963882446,
-0.25950559973716736,
0.1963759809732437,
-0.7718093991279602,
0.7182809114456177,
0.6497117280960083,
-0.11172115057706833,
-0.03101823478937149,
-1.0441404581069946,
0.5753148198127747,
-0.08271107077598572,
-0.5731322169303894,
0.007263583596795797,
0.19697298109531403,
-0.35412946343421936,
0.38122105598449707,
0.7435660362243652,
0.2224307805299759,
-0.02599124051630497,
-0.27422165870666504,
-0.36054110527038574,
0.14661236107349396,
-0.37592631578445435,
0.1433282345533371,
0.23387207090854645,
-0.676243782043457,
-0.2607366740703583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00801v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00801v2
|
"Ask Me Anything": How Comcast Uses LLMs to Assist Agents in Real Time
| 2024-05-01T18:31:36 | 2024-05-06T16:15:32 |
Scott Rome, Tianwen Chen, Raphael Tang, Luwei Zhou, Ferhan Ture
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Customer service is how companies interface with their customers. It can
contribute heavily towards the overall customer satisfaction. However,
high-quality service can become expensive, creating an incentive to make it as
cost efficient as possible and prompting most companies to utilize AI-powered
assistants, or "chat bots". On the other hand, human-to-human interaction is
still desired by customers, especially when it comes to complex scenarios such
as disputes and sensitive topics like bill payment.
This raises the bar for customer service agents. They need to accurately
understand the customer's question or concern, identify a solution that is
acceptable yet feasible (and within the company's policy), all while handling
multiple conversations at once.
In this work, we introduce "Ask Me Anything" (AMA) as an add-on feature to an
agent-facing customer service interface. AMA allows agents to ask questions to
a large language model (LLM) on demand, as they are handling customer
conversations -- the LLM provides accurate responses in real-time, reducing the
amount of context switching the agent needs. In our internal experiments, we
find that agents using AMA versus a traditional search experience spend
approximately 10% fewer seconds per conversation containing a search,
translating to millions of dollars of savings annually. Agents that used the
AMA feature provided positive feedback nearly 80% of the time, demonstrating
its usefulness as an AI-assisted feature for customer care.
|
[
-0.578838586807251,
-1.0429571866989136,
0.47533339262008667,
0.24308739602565765,
-0.04041295871138573,
0.17639762163162231,
0.26669326424598694,
-0.7620102763175964,
0.5387402772903442,
0.6612995862960815,
-0.7821318507194519,
0.15085309743881226,
-0.1750192791223526,
0.01737946644425392,
-0.3346121907234192,
0.576047420501709,
0.00558239221572876,
0.09538043290376663,
0.00652661407366395,
0.11678905785083771,
-0.5274432301521301,
-0.568073570728302,
-1.2612051963806152,
0.04374696686863899,
0.6794304251670837,
0.7626200318336487,
1.226156234741211,
0.7111745476722717,
0.3929798901081085,
0.3681345582008362,
0.11344312131404877,
0.5823239088058472,
-0.13618239760398865,
0.6351030468940735,
0.10765711218118668,
-0.5393737554550171,
-0.7063621282577515,
0.32673996686935425,
0.3238891065120697,
0.7592100501060486,
-0.2800499200820923,
0.20140030980110168,
-0.2131636142730713,
0.5697016716003418,
-0.5079076290130615,
-0.1408633440732956,
-0.621694803237915,
0.2537001371383667,
0.41198065876960754,
-0.5125208497047424,
0.09176407754421234,
-0.4164721965789795,
0.45737919211387634,
-0.8250289559364319,
0.08757064491510391,
0.22868295013904572,
0.9778186082839966,
0.45436331629753113,
-0.4717034101486206,
-0.548670768737793,
-0.8569360971450806,
0.3697493374347687,
-0.04935608431696892,
0.41407036781311035,
0.540396511554718,
0.5188307762145996,
0.011425444856286049,
-0.5857953429222107,
-0.6719725728034973,
-0.3556276261806488,
-0.07437930256128311,
0.13265103101730347,
-0.5431053042411804,
-0.007814045995473862,
0.15820452570915222,
0.004866710864007473,
-0.6169660687446594,
-0.13386376202106476,
0.06759247928857803,
0.00041434491868130863,
0.43261614441871643,
0.5574897527694702,
0.2005346566438675,
0.15185870230197906,
-0.007607501465827227,
0.016789283603429794,
-0.5233062505722046,
0.4026220440864563,
0.17123575508594513,
-0.12229082733392715,
0.05149742215871811,
0.5790925621986389,
-0.1954541653394699,
0.564696729183197,
0.05755436420440674,
0.3973950445652008,
-0.6195375323295593,
-0.09560147672891617,
-0.3495873510837555,
0.07440648227930069,
0.1890868842601776,
0.31680217385292053,
0.3228793740272522,
-0.052967458963394165,
0.29719415307044983,
-0.11094368994235992,
0.47701695561408997,
-0.5682875514030457,
0.08902068436145782,
0.6043785214424133,
-0.4316587448120117,
-0.17887404561042786,
0.05038748309016228,
-0.36987829208374023,
-0.5056139826774597,
-0.40705835819244385,
0.07301314175128937,
-0.011726748198270798,
-0.09959231317043304,
-0.10106484591960907,
-0.1921863555908203,
0.5702057480812073,
0.6321935653686523,
-0.4139321744441986,
0.21932603418827057,
0.7518388032913208,
0.5690996050834656,
0.1595349907875061,
-0.3629947304725647,
-1.0615977048873901,
0.08244724571704865,
-0.361283540725708,
1.1170766353607178,
-0.635903000831604,
-0.3857707977294922,
0.19360888004302979,
0.20514963567256927,
-0.23879316449165344,
-0.6567879319190979,
-0.049239225685596466,
-0.7593567967414856,
0.04621060565114021,
-0.14246244728565216,
-0.30383825302124023,
0.13771966099739075,
0.8164767026901245,
-0.3469438850879669,
0.5683553814888,
0.12286968529224396,
-0.0839332565665245,
0.12249160557985306,
-0.8475950360298157,
-0.267623633146286,
0.16105523705482483,
-0.017534971237182617,
-0.275572806596756,
0.06275086104869843,
0.014755725860595703,
0.49031001329421997,
-0.3604801893234253,
-0.26595863699913025,
-0.2843559980392456,
-0.3051377534866333,
1.109010934829712,
-0.696813702583313,
0.4620603322982788,
0.6296213269233704,
-0.3448326885700226,
-0.3135652244091034,
-0.6136993765830994,
0.00897088274359703,
0.08498377352952957,
-0.3705384433269501,
0.038531187921762466,
0.072193443775177,
-0.23329679667949677,
0.013133635744452477,
0.4956067204475403,
-0.524871826171875,
0.20879913866519928,
-0.32691624760627747,
0.14486780762672424,
0.681665301322937,
0.2229911983013153,
0.44288164377212524,
-0.6694203019142151,
0.9281072020530701,
-0.03086923621594906,
0.6048563718795776,
-0.24447086453437805,
-0.46215489506721497,
-1.1226038932800293,
-0.07368023693561554,
-0.13663563132286072,
0.6447213888168335,
-0.8621975183486938,
0.11911900341510773,
-0.33197346329689026,
-0.38037922978401184,
-0.823521614074707,
0.12045500427484512,
0.25223714113235474,
0.2171514481306076,
-0.026571955531835556,
-0.0015273891622200608,
-0.2743852734565735,
-0.64499431848526,
-0.17898441851139069,
0.006539454218000174,
-0.003616905538365245,
0.7674418687820435,
-0.2555833160877228,
0.04166080430150032,
1.1990561485290527,
-0.8040644526481628,
-0.1911415010690689,
-0.2026422619819641,
-0.02954714372754097,
-0.021996600553393364,
0.13101162016391754,
0.17257709801197052,
-0.8887302875518799,
-0.9606364369392395,
0.13293837010860443,
-0.7643711566925049,
-0.20639559626579285,
-0.19638456404209137,
-0.033151205629110336,
0.3003048896789551,
0.37743112444877625,
-0.6670843362808228,
0.5394142270088196,
0.45921480655670166,
-0.7524387836456299,
0.2765950560569763,
-0.7193499207496643,
0.40895771980285645,
-0.7694687247276306,
-0.03139985352754593,
-0.34890642762184143,
-0.4842122197151184,
-0.8443857431411743,
-0.1776931881904602,
-0.2387782335281372,
-0.655629575252533,
-0.842893123626709,
0.6812193393707275,
-0.473372220993042,
-0.2961021661758423,
-0.3987267315387726,
0.13327528536319733,
0.2851088345050812,
0.4323441684246063,
-0.2000800520181656,
1.106421709060669,
0.26188820600509644,
-1.1407476663589478,
0.4536476135253906,
0.44059622287750244,
0.02293175831437111,
1.1877981424331665,
-0.5577273964881897,
0.2879827916622162,
-0.09011993557214737,
0.0587257519364357,
-1.0887999534606934,
-0.04729093238711357,
0.4295806884765625,
-0.6877507567405701,
-0.2859949469566345,
0.038198214024305344,
-0.4371265470981598,
-0.08534441143274307,
-0.1621522307395935,
0.11244373023509979,
0.2508590519428253,
-0.5693190693855286,
0.9521404504776001,
0.5760248303413391,
-0.34809744358062744,
-0.26327696442604065,
-0.6338909268379211,
0.4066601097583771,
-0.004265026189386845,
-0.7867827415466309,
-0.18184323608875275,
-0.27638399600982666,
-0.3387419283390045,
-0.015491955913603306,
0.0597219318151474,
-0.5439155101776123,
0.5200482606887817,
0.24350664019584656,
0.1812310367822647,
0.05863669887185097,
0.07734744250774384,
0.08838038891553879,
-0.370628297328949,
-0.12601980566978455,
-0.20665107667446136,
0.9344460368156433,
0.07604788988828659,
-0.5323700308799744,
-0.6247347593307495,
0.8424172401428223,
0.6431754231452942,
-0.236696258187294,
0.40477854013442993,
0.14567576348781586,
0.023789256811141968,
-0.012913036160171032,
-0.9003092050552368,
-0.0496443547308445,
-0.5188395380973816,
-0.06848639249801636,
-0.37948858737945557,
-0.8826373219490051,
0.5984573364257812,
-0.020476410165429115,
0.2122800052165985,
-0.2604617178440094,
0.3906170427799225,
-0.7046136856079102,
1.543808102607727,
0.48587411642074585,
0.07528125494718552,
0.7688091993331909,
-0.19534999132156372,
0.2657727003097534,
-0.5060796737670898,
-0.34468957781791687,
-0.779324471950531,
-0.36141493916511536,
-0.3602970242500305,
-0.2464069128036499,
0.7623295187950134,
-0.5721442103385925,
-0.18337012827396393,
0.3119470775127411,
-0.3188382387161255,
0.13301335275173187,
0.6110265851020813,
0.05434779077768326,
0.42723143100738525,
-0.04541793465614319,
0.30897411704063416,
0.21250149607658386,
-0.7230561375617981,
-0.37116992473602295,
0.518667459487915,
0.41313183307647705,
0.8750272393226624,
0.2791081368923187,
0.12806130945682526,
0.7474674582481384,
0.30028268694877625,
-0.7914848923683167,
0.5377206206321716,
-0.013875279575586319,
-0.7027324438095093,
-0.23237760365009308,
-0.37202829122543335,
-1.5988285541534424,
0.1266384869813919,
-0.07952407002449036,
-0.2922646105289459,
0.5298921465873718,
0.4907209575176239,
-0.5298104882240295,
0.11574913561344147,
-0.7192352414131165,
0.4116349518299103,
-0.46268990635871887,
-0.1137775108218193,
-0.23199592530727386,
-0.4199262857437134,
-0.4019460678100586,
0.21973758935928345,
0.2170172780752182,
-0.25637468695640564,
-0.4083051383495331,
0.36811563372612,
-0.5917776226997375,
0.6647311449050903,
-0.0891677513718605,
-0.1824074387550354,
0.39312219619750977,
0.32380419969558716,
0.7598620057106018,
-0.1647413820028305,
0.015982914716005325,
-0.1538677215576172,
0.12155449390411377,
-0.5639132261276245,
-0.829013466835022,
0.5835869908332825,
-0.6610510945320129,
-0.3455764949321747,
-0.4969218373298645,
-0.6610646843910217,
-0.33027857542037964,
-0.06681104749441147,
-0.21185408532619476,
0.21845167875289917,
-0.21405555307865143,
0.020294705405831337,
0.5744211077690125,
-0.1360836774110794,
0.5473531484603882,
1.1169772148132324,
-0.0648803561925888,
-0.3637017607688904,
1.0149301290512085,
0.2937253713607788,
0.2129170149564743,
0.41199925541877747,
-0.03428490459918976,
-0.23811665177345276,
0.16275838017463684,
-0.3647524118423462,
0.21472105383872986,
-0.6529377698898315,
-0.11266254633665085,
-0.8733383417129517,
0.035840969532728195,
-0.4136112332344055,
-0.36364641785621643,
-0.3361000716686249,
-0.3312685489654541,
-0.2881312072277069,
0.08137216418981552,
0.17431651055812836,
0.34947463870048523,
0.22614796459674835,
0.8875763416290283,
-0.9730886816978455,
0.2652132511138916,
0.711966872215271,
0.17989091575145721,
-0.1445046365261078,
-0.17425505816936493,
-0.3721016049385071,
0.09153509885072708,
-0.3500518202781677,
-0.5642049312591553,
0.5056718587875366,
0.20665206015110016,
0.5616254210472107,
0.5457339286804199,
0.11360122263431549,
0.6301363706588745,
-0.21940572559833527,
0.8302950263023376,
-0.1369517594575882,
-0.8030003309249878,
0.01135130412876606,
-0.14893043041229248,
0.22640597820281982,
0.4797534942626953,
0.2732083797454834,
-0.8405442237854004,
-0.452538400888443,
-0.7652865052223206,
-0.5364512205123901,
0.571500837802887,
0.16831332445144653,
0.5517206192016602,
-0.11302804201841354,
0.3468857407569885,
-0.2844259738922119,
0.6732375025749207,
-0.07851596176624298,
-0.699680745601654,
0.13369156420230865,
0.16821381449699402,
0.12871259450912476,
-0.3071451783180237,
-0.014007301069796085,
-0.04007912427186966,
0.3528670370578766,
-0.12092678248882294,
0.6447660326957703,
0.3264422118663788,
-0.08395758271217346,
-0.2719222903251648,
0.38548028469085693,
0.545555830001831,
0.7449724078178406,
-0.3303091526031494,
0.14792320132255554,
0.17353327572345734,
-0.21410918235778809,
0.17683543264865875,
0.11974439769983292,
0.0036962705198675394,
0.0688425675034523,
-0.22124996781349182,
0.5870441794395447,
-0.06905557960271835,
-1.001253366470337,
0.4691692888736725,
-0.3572826087474823,
-0.22511085867881775,
-0.5983083844184875,
0.13832345604896545,
-0.13661527633666992,
0.3401229977607727,
0.48161110281944275,
-0.22796876728534698,
0.049298256635665894,
-0.7504347562789917,
0.033695414662361145,
0.6749687790870667,
-0.8217859268188477,
0.12396026402711868,
0.268520325422287,
0.33759284019470215,
-0.8059927225112915,
0.3358429968357086,
-0.016277970746159554,
-0.5497450828552246,
0.7974098920822144,
0.2573099732398987,
0.9461804032325745,
-0.22301150858402252,
0.4301411509513855,
-0.618087112903595,
0.06898725777864456,
0.4598061442375183,
0.5216062664985657,
-0.10161607712507248,
-0.6353546380996704,
-0.23660920560359955,
-0.12385931611061096,
-1.1758376359939575,
-0.010195693001151085,
-0.37325847148895264,
0.1685999184846878,
-0.7316665053367615,
0.07067261636257172,
-0.050173982977867126,
-0.013101146556437016,
-0.8112528324127197,
0.5051877498626709,
0.03145059198141098,
0.9911347031593323,
-0.39086875319480896,
0.4441317319869995,
0.8474622368812561,
-0.23516827821731567,
-0.8648778796195984,
-0.1597430557012558,
-0.3468397557735443,
-1.2711372375488281,
0.3601408302783966,
-0.14254546165466309,
-0.31804248690605164,
0.2446075677871704,
-0.7087956666946411,
-0.5127871632575989,
1.0959521532058716,
0.4081279933452606,
-0.26212677359580994,
-0.06283346563577652,
0.44209039211273193,
0.45584362745285034,
-0.6080787181854248,
0.5473855137825012,
0.7009502053260803,
0.4457617700099945,
0.1638961285352707,
-0.6776257157325745,
-0.10747677832841873,
-0.2056174874305725,
-0.21951474249362946,
0.07806534320116043,
-0.9328847527503967,
0.8278985023498535,
0.4189695119857788,
-0.07338305562734604,
0.009516069665551186,
0.19818377494812012,
0.04757138714194298,
0.6282702088356018,
0.7559910416603088,
0.10977915674448013,
0.71397864818573,
0.15112513303756714,
1.3426647186279297,
-0.4575655162334442,
0.04139653220772743,
0.6770412921905518,
-0.2298462986946106,
0.5585148334503174,
0.591770350933075,
-0.053912453353405,
-0.02015387825667858,
0.5642807483673096,
0.1824195384979248,
0.08193966001272202,
-0.08094534277915955,
-0.4743092954158783,
-0.5515139102935791,
-0.7197180390357971,
-0.2248481661081314,
0.3753877878189087,
0.11805856227874756,
0.0463603213429451,
-0.39420825242996216,
0.31832972168922424,
0.39165258407592773,
-0.1559741497039795,
-0.14612160623073578,
1.1606923341751099,
0.07989378273487091,
-1.1050970554351807,
0.6422619819641113,
-0.18465955555438995,
0.33578404784202576,
-0.8123658299446106,
-0.10857253521680832,
-0.6189064979553223,
0.21954087913036346,
-0.04251904785633087,
-0.44007372856140137,
0.40745192766189575,
0.11429397016763687,
-0.030605394393205643,
-0.271467924118042,
0.42781007289886475,
-0.3119095265865326,
-0.2712583839893341,
0.16971412301063538,
0.7363821864128113,
0.501535177230835,
-0.46565327048301697,
-1.0451233386993408,
0.13793574273586273,
-0.22454798221588135,
-0.13071787357330322,
0.39990729093551636,
0.20227877795696259,
0.22319313883781433,
1.2382854223251343,
0.946883499622345,
0.5041441917419434,
0.21062429249286652,
-0.2058359533548355,
1.0315396785736084,
-0.5122188329696655,
-0.6469749808311462,
-0.42828720808029175,
0.5714383721351624,
-0.14597338438034058,
-0.24967756867408752,
0.6737626791000366,
0.44135043025016785,
0.37674134969711304,
0.082466259598732,
0.8268497586250305,
-0.012762329541146755,
0.8120012283325195,
-0.3257940709590912,
0.521065354347229,
-0.9795430898666382,
0.497126042842865,
0.162546768784523,
-0.8720909357070923,
-0.02627740427851677,
0.44394534826278687,
-0.20880302786827087,
-0.3598811626434326,
0.6071068644523621,
0.7877817749977112,
0.005369370803236961,
-0.18101342022418976,
0.6650863885879517,
0.023032957687973976,
0.9371631145477295,
0.01634671725332737,
1.2214844226837158,
-0.006041544023901224,
0.9959080219268799,
-0.008847679942846298,
-0.16700074076652527,
-0.41933998465538025,
-0.6195600628852844,
-0.5344356894493103,
-0.07457256317138672,
-0.15783952176570892,
-0.36821433901786804,
0.18556645512580872,
1.3033076524734497,
0.5371562838554382,
-0.6773568391799927,
-0.5202239751815796,
0.09731671959161758,
0.2621230185031891,
-0.311989963054657,
-0.19521988928318024,
0.1088981032371521,
-0.6762545704841614,
-0.8412335515022278,
0.45345190167427063,
0.3309558928012848,
0.013475289568305016,
-0.18732622265815735,
-0.053982239216566086,
-0.30184659361839294,
0.4317000210285187,
0.3819109797477722,
0.5170311331748962,
-0.16065126657485962,
-0.3352617025375366,
0.33852165937423706,
-0.23100408911705017,
0.2004089653491974,
0.9103467464447021,
-0.3078330159187317,
0.48891180753707886,
0.35234326124191284,
1.0627326965332031,
0.4359048902988434,
0.2906442880630493,
0.5955712199211121,
-0.46739256381988525,
0.10220886021852493,
0.12960578501224518,
0.016420183703303337,
0.04461752623319626,
-0.6859789490699768,
0.22258898615837097,
-0.011065667495131493,
-0.7256288528442383,
-0.5657100677490234,
0.1862999051809311,
-0.8862730860710144,
-0.34221169352531433,
0.7608739733695984,
-0.3233197331428528,
-0.10936329513788223,
-0.7965364456176758,
-0.5731490850448608,
0.16688354313373566,
-0.615001380443573,
0.7738247513771057,
0.30195727944374084,
-0.45118898153305054,
-0.45061731338500977,
-0.5319916605949402,
0.26413458585739136,
0.8715507984161377,
-0.9777311682701111,
-0.02303377538919449,
0.27390047907829285,
0.16950984299182892,
0.17653967440128326,
0.8288840651512146,
0.4587029218673706,
0.40883660316467285,
-0.3918059170246124,
-0.35149630904197693,
-0.4327576160430908,
-0.48770031332969666,
-0.320056289434433,
0.3615444600582123,
0.12150713801383972,
-0.5171164870262146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00675v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00675v4
|
Self-Play Preference Optimization for Language Model Alignment
| 2024-05-01T17:59:20 | 2024-06-14T05:57:01 |
Yue Wu, Zhiqing Sun, Huizhuo Yuan, Kaixuan Ji, Yiming Yang, Quanquan Gu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Traditional reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) approaches
relying on parametric models like the Bradley-Terry model fall short in
capturing the intransitivity and irrationality in human preferences. Recent
advancements suggest that directly working with preference probabilities can
yield a more accurate reflection of human preferences, enabling more flexible
and accurate language model alignment. In this paper, we propose a
self-play-based method for language model alignment, which treats the problem
as a constant-sum two-player game aimed at identifying the Nash equilibrium
policy. Our approach, dubbed Self-Play Preference Optimization (SPPO),
approximates the Nash equilibrium through iterative policy updates and enjoys a
theoretical convergence guarantee. Our method can effectively increase the
log-likelihood of the chosen response and decrease that of the rejected
response, which cannot be trivially achieved by symmetric pairwise loss such as
Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) and Identity Preference Optimization
(IPO). In our experiments, using only 60k prompts (without responses) from the
UltraFeedback dataset and without any prompt augmentation, by leveraging a
pre-trained preference model PairRM with only 0.4B parameters, SPPO can obtain
a model from fine-tuning Mistral-7B-Instruct-v0.2 that achieves the
state-of-the-art length-controlled win-rate of 28.53% against GPT-4-Turbo on
AlpacaEval 2.0. It also outperforms the (iterative) DPO and IPO on MT-Bench and
the Open LLM Leaderboard. Starting from a stronger base model
Llama-3-8B-Instruct, we are able to achieve a length-controlled win rate of
38.77%. Notably, the strong performance of SPPO is achieved without additional
external supervision (e.g., responses, preferences, etc.) from GPT-4 or other
stronger language models. Codes are available at
https://github.com/uclaml/SPPO.
|
[
-0.16641865670681,
-0.2810370922088623,
0.2915773093700409,
0.2821342349052429,
-0.19041715562343597,
0.08839993178844452,
-0.35943567752838135,
-0.2533525228500366,
0.1105089783668518,
0.6824831962585449,
-0.7441859245300293,
-0.19883869588375092,
-0.2855992913246155,
-0.10269132256507874,
0.19237317144870758,
1.097794532775879,
-0.15067747235298157,
-0.09686212986707687,
-0.030784862115979195,
-0.12590962648391724,
-0.45339083671569824,
-0.30044281482696533,
-0.4714002311229706,
-0.5512503981590271,
0.35441574454307556,
0.5692916512489319,
0.786728024482727,
0.8703995943069458,
0.32511043548583984,
0.31762996315956116,
0.17308399081230164,
0.0852125808596611,
-0.5697611570358276,
0.03568483889102936,
-0.056286342442035675,
-0.2289203703403473,
-0.462693989276886,
0.09466427564620972,
0.7058369517326355,
0.004661224316805601,
-0.6082064509391785,
-0.08427666872739792,
0.10173799097537994,
0.6515491604804993,
-0.37416595220565796,
0.09251648187637329,
-0.5227246284484863,
0.2492508739233017,
-0.15878276526927948,
-0.3700735569000244,
-0.48651501536369324,
-0.3276095688343048,
0.1702372282743454,
-0.7440935969352722,
-0.06207354739308357,
0.09112995862960815,
0.9474042057991028,
0.2774299681186676,
-0.2595951557159424,
-0.06403575837612152,
-0.6558510661125183,
0.8217494487762451,
-1.0850985050201416,
0.2941633462905884,
0.28723666071891785,
0.24396678805351257,
-0.4109504222869873,
-0.03723382204771042,
-0.4871179759502411,
-0.5164381861686707,
0.04332966357469559,
0.32591623067855835,
0.042867984622716904,
0.27813684940338135,
-0.04556100815534592,
0.10831607133150101,
-0.8085941076278687,
0.49260371923446655,
-0.04713037982583046,
-0.22574730217456818,
0.8014950156211853,
0.07146578282117844,
0.17445255815982819,
-0.025537464767694473,
-0.65190190076828,
-0.22950613498687744,
-0.6358924508094788,
0.4058232009410858,
0.6520676016807556,
0.3110354244709015,
-0.05483906716108322,
0.4972071349620819,
-0.18671587109565735,
0.6243276000022888,
0.44271016120910645,
-0.3718668222427368,
0.08604704588651657,
0.02893362194299698,
0.0026461503002792597,
0.14071151614189148,
0.9363646507263184,
0.47835230827331543,
0.0896126851439476,
-0.20858658850193024,
-0.2874850034713745,
-0.04175453633069992,
0.18655575811862946,
-0.4733329117298126,
-0.01767505519092083,
0.18997718393802643,
-0.3243040442466736,
-0.3871384263038635,
-0.1949332356452942,
-0.6909724473953247,
-0.11068359017372131,
-0.3056316375732422,
0.5378292798995972,
-0.2880287766456604,
-0.2329069972038269,
0.06429575383663177,
0.3305664658546448,
0.4149162173271179,
0.1369292289018631,
-1.1968355178833008,
0.44412416219711304,
0.7443103194236755,
0.6176442503929138,
-0.5043942332267761,
-0.6245647668838501,
-0.458910197019577,
0.2043285369873047,
-0.3449800908565521,
0.6747123003005981,
-0.27430570125579834,
-0.42267799377441406,
-0.25362810492515564,
-0.25964200496673584,
-0.11386643350124359,
-0.2627786099910736,
0.4265241324901581,
-0.5351555943489075,
0.4115749001502991,
-0.0653981864452362,
-0.7752912044525146,
0.2073797583580017,
0.11741094291210175,
-0.41968557238578796,
1.0658105611801147,
-0.18259575963020325,
-0.5977722406387329,
0.162043958902359,
-0.5083121061325073,
-0.20107053220272064,
-0.0961928442120552,
-0.2826456129550934,
-0.6300982236862183,
-0.025129424408078194,
0.12261775881052017,
0.09116014093160629,
-0.2143784910440445,
0.4104671776294708,
-0.4998861849308014,
-0.384880393743515,
0.20810645818710327,
-0.16811487078666687,
0.4584883153438568,
0.17924757301807404,
-0.6338261961936951,
0.4039733111858368,
-0.427897572517395,
0.01593835838139057,
0.295526385307312,
-0.21264177560806274,
-0.05178895965218544,
0.21538762748241425,
-0.3585169017314911,
0.37465935945510864,
0.32353782653808594,
-0.4462586045265198,
0.4534509479999542,
-0.6739997267723083,
0.16455277800559998,
1.120833396911621,
-0.3139859437942505,
0.5995155572891235,
-0.19590336084365845,
0.7750227451324463,
-0.3468896448612213,
0.5085837841033936,
0.29599568247795105,
-0.30143293738365173,
-0.46327435970306396,
-0.20184816420078278,
0.4015449583530426,
0.4066292941570282,
-0.30022844672203064,
0.5742578506469727,
-0.15357930958271027,
-0.2735409140586853,
-0.6337329149246216,
0.12606008350849152,
0.5900759696960449,
0.816669762134552,
0.32265910506248474,
-0.3106868863105774,
-0.3666401207447052,
-1.0138047933578491,
-0.04558968171477318,
-0.3126218616962433,
0.4423503875732422,
0.5862911343574524,
-0.07156213372945786,
0.048252370208501816,
1.1211106777191162,
-0.6217944025993347,
-0.27946341037750244,
-0.22635985910892487,
0.15184542536735535,
0.20449742674827576,
0.4494968056678772,
0.5460885167121887,
-0.4164803922176361,
-0.6102245450019836,
0.058374591171741486,
-0.3811960518360138,
-0.21943314373493195,
0.006840449757874012,
-0.14168260991573334,
0.41351979970932007,
0.01150564569979906,
-0.3768392503261566,
0.12956489622592926,
0.8382214903831482,
-0.07863367348909378,
0.5110707879066467,
-0.3885264992713928,
0.15260049700737,
-0.8317578434944153,
0.08509477227926254,
-0.12546290457248688,
-0.20966781675815582,
-0.4346683621406555,
0.09305067360401154,
0.07883292436599731,
0.11546002328395844,
-0.2634153664112091,
0.611530065536499,
-0.33980509638786316,
-0.16506518423557281,
-0.5288782119750977,
0.061217956244945526,
-0.15117581188678741,
0.667937159538269,
0.2906505763530731,
1.0055066347122192,
0.32897016406059265,
-0.37548115849494934,
0.26086658239364624,
0.06776726990938187,
0.044873882085084915,
0.057416386902332306,
-0.5525650978088379,
0.23887185752391815,
-0.03396386280655861,
0.3213566541671753,
-1.0509377717971802,
0.007789393421262503,
0.2601953446865082,
-0.40986865758895874,
0.4762766659259796,
-0.14680136740207672,
0.004127237480133772,
-0.4195486009120941,
-0.3505855202674866,
0.3428574800491333,
0.4292697310447693,
-0.5858428478240967,
0.4074529707431793,
0.571110725402832,
-0.08627305924892426,
-1.0445311069488525,
-0.18216712772846222,
-0.13193464279174805,
-0.24702034890651703,
-0.3180505335330963,
0.4487690329551697,
-0.37650245428085327,
0.17206069827079773,
-0.3570556044578552,
-0.28174304962158203,
0.07709741592407227,
0.12019915133714676,
0.01793542131781578,
0.4213215112686157,
-0.12190216779708862,
0.027556471526622772,
0.029052631929516792,
-0.3218959867954254,
-0.14988775551319122,
-0.2959829568862915,
0.523592472076416,
-0.13044476509094238,
-0.12747155129909515,
-0.46553370356559753,
0.1256967931985855,
0.17770372331142426,
-0.3126416504383087,
0.321656197309494,
0.133741557598114,
0.05057753622531891,
-0.17656327784061432,
-0.5928271412849426,
-0.30620840191841125,
-0.5044097900390625,
0.1394897699356079,
-0.4264838695526123,
-0.9670047163963318,
0.40660473704338074,
0.10972984880208969,
0.025799712166190147,
0.483978271484375,
0.48495715856552124,
-0.1754678636789322,
1.1797631978988647,
0.4830981492996216,
-0.44118475914001465,
0.4085962176322937,
-0.07239615172147751,
-0.0397794209420681,
-0.612389862537384,
0.00209108111448586,
-0.33216655254364014,
-0.13091647624969482,
-0.6748687028884888,
-0.06979706138372421,
0.12588883936405182,
-0.04938117787241936,
-0.13833214342594147,
0.5933645963668823,
-0.5181075930595398,
0.5007607936859131,
0.5298853516578674,
0.14295370876789093,
0.09893366694450378,
-0.24427944421768188,
-0.3599477708339691,
-0.30877649784088135,
-0.742422342300415,
-0.31802448630332947,
1.0861997604370117,
0.5403410792350769,
0.8638219237327576,
0.3078857958316803,
1.075989007949829,
0.35031700134277344,
0.300166517496109,
-0.6643763184547424,
0.3683716058731079,
0.03021874651312828,
-0.46064361929893494,
-0.6134901642799377,
-0.49740713834762573,
-0.758270800113678,
0.20767289400100708,
-0.27693772315979004,
-0.631137490272522,
0.07755860686302185,
0.5238500833511353,
-0.6003105640411377,
-0.044300928711891174,
-0.4022151231765747,
0.9884486794471741,
-0.5575689673423767,
-0.5040374398231506,
-0.16844052076339722,
-0.7696130275726318,
0.41422322392463684,
0.09493885189294815,
0.10117415338754654,
-0.2548668682575226,
0.054743628948926926,
0.5935239195823669,
-0.373017817735672,
0.6561777591705322,
-0.037320151925086975,
-0.2647750675678253,
0.1447918564081192,
0.1819917857646942,
0.6460791826248169,
-0.07079571485519409,
-0.05131612718105316,
-0.055340856313705444,
-0.043064337223768234,
-0.27987396717071533,
-0.5533362627029419,
0.9045393466949463,
-1.1272095441818237,
-0.7454757690429688,
-0.6871500611305237,
-0.4106580317020416,
-0.2618454694747925,
0.1416783630847931,
0.15275681018829346,
0.23563197255134583,
-0.29065099358558655,
-0.20505134761333466,
0.535802960395813,
0.007371929008513689,
0.5145224332809448,
0.7323668003082275,
-0.307327538728714,
-0.5454424619674683,
0.9128134846687317,
-0.10552319139242172,
0.2743547856807709,
0.46185222268104553,
0.6526966691017151,
-0.7325482964515686,
-0.4610227048397064,
-0.5702998638153076,
0.3653407692909241,
-0.2759561240673065,
-0.29131779074668884,
-0.4350684881210327,
-0.06154068931937218,
-0.5283713340759277,
0.039640095084905624,
-0.6132162809371948,
-0.34933096170425415,
-0.252485454082489,
0.041948217898607254,
0.037535183131694794,
0.5825021862983704,
-0.17727434635162354,
0.45821043848991394,
-0.5402854681015015,
-0.00004501475268625654,
0.4676212966442108,
0.496832013130188,
-0.1636270135641098,
-0.7452378273010254,
-0.07599486410617828,
-0.053423039615154266,
-0.3490886092185974,
-1.0703343152999878,
0.374946653842926,
0.14042140543460846,
0.5967708230018616,
0.4966917335987091,
0.013952069915831089,
0.686413586139679,
-0.6191202998161316,
0.4368748962879181,
0.18818296492099762,
-0.9077808260917664,
0.5820533037185669,
-0.583580732345581,
-0.015068598091602325,
0.673905074596405,
0.23731809854507446,
-0.2964453101158142,
-0.0053197541274130344,
-0.6384302973747253,
-0.5086621046066284,
1.0618571043014526,
0.027570044621825218,
-0.04121065139770508,
0.0952756404876709,
0.47949790954589844,
-0.004782647825777531,
0.10061344504356384,
-0.8858711123466492,
-0.22925253212451935,
-0.18950878083705902,
-0.20401212573051453,
-0.17154178023338318,
-0.2676165699958801,
-0.22607438266277313,
0.02481590397655964,
0.9825667142868042,
-0.4310111403465271,
0.0036086528562009335,
0.026313960552215576,
0.05388662964105606,
-0.36104676127433777,
0.11667371541261673,
0.8070778250694275,
0.4547377824783325,
-0.48798537254333496,
-0.16417820751667023,
0.035230088979005814,
-0.012567310594022274,
0.3352844715118408,
0.2959279716014862,
-0.1367730349302292,
-0.4029395580291748,
-0.022083640098571777,
0.7149441838264465,
0.372942179441452,
-0.5904205441474915,
0.6386803388595581,
-0.026314007118344307,
0.017949381843209267,
-0.05397580564022064,
0.06276994943618774,
-0.071413554251194,
0.10214658826589584,
0.03632485866546631,
-0.3364580273628235,
0.2964112460613251,
-0.3881496787071228,
0.25619637966156006,
0.6249223351478577,
-0.4478548467159271,
-0.2572323977947235,
0.5156214833259583,
0.18861332535743713,
-0.22612889111042023,
0.16573894023895264,
-0.180776908993721,
-0.5622664093971252,
0.5638499855995178,
0.9657909274101257,
0.7051315903663635,
-0.6225457191467285,
0.4488659203052521,
0.3475198745727539,
0.13140279054641724,
-0.33269020915031433,
0.03032500483095646,
-0.15501391887664795,
-0.8710886836051941,
-0.4063200354576111,
-0.40789204835891724,
-0.5433140993118286,
-0.06589177995920181,
-0.5015392899513245,
0.1478511244058609,
-0.5739031434059143,
-0.19386684894561768,
-0.1749415248632431,
0.20851737260818481,
-0.16237573325634003,
0.11919420957565308,
0.24845586717128754,
0.5105171203613281,
-0.7505344152450562,
0.9958369731903076,
0.39890995621681213,
-0.28748393058776855,
-0.8655529022216797,
-0.011004280298948288,
0.21892382204532623,
-0.936832845211029,
0.43825680017471313,
-0.06732320040464401,
-0.2915996313095093,
0.17082816362380981,
-0.3507618308067322,
-1.206022024154663,
1.037455677986145,
0.322978138923645,
-0.699703574180603,
0.05662798136472702,
-0.009119645692408085,
0.47200942039489746,
-0.5050181746482849,
0.5168132185935974,
0.47946029901504517,
0.184089794754982,
0.1540653109550476,
-1.022672176361084,
-0.0775173082947731,
0.2548685669898987,
0.19264473021030426,
0.3053049147129059,
-1.0407190322875977,
0.4289138913154602,
-0.14102710783481598,
0.02331630326807499,
0.04914863035082817,
0.9299997687339783,
0.539795994758606,
-0.039713453501462936,
0.6138506531715393,
0.6646918058395386,
0.4059106409549713,
0.12340807169675827,
0.7289208173751831,
-0.4835008680820465,
0.6704146265983582,
1.3799498081207275,
-0.5296247005462646,
0.8563273549079895,
0.4103820025920868,
-0.22527608275413513,
0.3551333248615265,
0.649856448173523,
0.27519696950912476,
0.6423905491828918,
0.18793095648288727,
-0.0779729038476944,
-0.35405433177948,
-0.035479482263326645,
-0.31881821155548096,
0.6881136298179626,
-0.08971074968576431,
-0.06123833730816841,
-0.1079539880156517,
-0.409322589635849,
0.039843399077653885,
0.30805104970932007,
0.0674605444073677,
0.8706967234611511,
-0.22139962017536163,
-1.1284765005111694,
0.36398956179618835,
0.061172254383563995,
0.6734194159507751,
-0.8401124477386475,
0.01723896525800228,
-0.3494040071964264,
0.18196259438991547,
0.09418532252311707,
-0.7069525718688965,
-0.02052539959549904,
-0.24652396142482758,
-0.011505319736897945,
-0.12254846841096878,
0.5226315259933472,
-0.5526900291442871,
-0.10413523763418198,
0.4816841185092926,
0.06161411479115486,
-0.19830772280693054,
0.2618413269519806,
-1.098278284072876,
0.10413394868373871,
0.15705345571041107,
-0.18752242624759674,
0.5094305872917175,
-0.1652587205171585,
0.06310100853443146,
0.5243909358978271,
0.5469374060630798,
0.01650611311197281,
-0.1629636138677597,
-0.03983466699719429,
0.6939631104469299,
-0.4341491460800171,
-0.6216267943382263,
-0.7708155512809753,
0.08607859164476395,
0.010055126622319221,
-0.46472930908203125,
0.5395693182945251,
0.6700528264045715,
0.6357392072677612,
0.0575752928853035,
0.41296806931495667,
0.24271708726882935,
0.35990116000175476,
-0.41345900297164917,
0.4523375332355499,
-0.5482910871505737,
0.15362215042114258,
-0.33053767681121826,
-0.8113861083984375,
-0.05386049300432205,
0.5566706657409668,
-0.320695161819458,
-0.069114089012146,
0.21694542467594147,
0.8306037187576294,
-0.012596094980835915,
-0.11632776260375977,
0.28748786449432373,
0.10198725759983063,
0.14699901640415192,
0.5144166350364685,
0.6685015559196472,
-0.23833267390727997,
0.37422487139701843,
-0.3754243552684784,
-0.6425423622131348,
-0.24763721227645874,
-1.0462974309921265,
-0.5943782329559326,
-0.33861783146858215,
-0.22415174543857574,
-0.4950789213180542,
0.28318899869918823,
1.3499547243118286,
0.6768540143966675,
-0.7498810291290283,
-0.7186914086341858,
0.043484289199113846,
0.007864978164434433,
-0.31486010551452637,
-0.235467329621315,
0.3068696856498718,
-0.4604717195034027,
-0.5037263035774231,
0.5603207349777222,
0.33227667212486267,
0.05276788771152496,
-0.2417769581079483,
-0.4570706784725189,
-0.3891341984272003,
0.20098936557769775,
0.2425047755241394,
0.7645583748817444,
-0.9449582695960999,
-0.23923683166503906,
0.19910010695457458,
-0.18805913627147675,
0.1962972730398178,
0.6436027884483337,
-0.5419288277626038,
0.6888320446014404,
0.2624832093715668,
0.6130425930023193,
0.554349958896637,
0.22699758410453796,
0.7568145990371704,
-0.589741051197052,
0.05543070286512375,
0.20630653202533722,
0.2417089343070984,
0.12268265336751938,
-0.4765535295009613,
0.3250736594200134,
0.1581752747297287,
-0.7995395660400391,
-0.5347400307655334,
0.2644425928592682,
-0.8909105658531189,
-0.08849300444126129,
1.0569736957550049,
-0.09531492739915848,
-0.21626709401607513,
0.3825644850730896,
-0.33634206652641296,
0.17491662502288818,
-0.6822016835212708,
0.9477988481521606,
0.5028389692306519,
-0.40498098731040955,
-0.27396276593208313,
-0.08725687116384506,
0.8078429698944092,
0.8105433583259583,
-0.5459773540496826,
0.0693625807762146,
0.4248552918434143,
0.3221741318702698,
-0.1394786536693573,
1.0127954483032227,
0.031344786286354065,
0.21964415907859802,
-0.5149935483932495,
0.3605614900588989,
0.14685675501823425,
-0.35296300053596497,
-0.5585519671440125,
-0.15690886974334717,
0.2879064381122589,
-0.0867227241396904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00664v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00664v1
|
Is Bigger Edit Batch Size Always Better? -- An Empirical Study on Model Editing with Llama-3
| 2024-05-01T17:50:37 | 2024-05-01T17:50:37 |
Junsang Yoon, Akshat Gupta, Gopala Anumanchipalli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This study presents a targeted model editing analysis focused on the latest
large language model, Llama-3. We explore the efficacy of popular model editing
techniques - ROME, MEMIT, and EMMET, which are designed for precise layer
interventions. We identify the most effective layers for targeted edits through
an evaluation that encompasses up to 4096 edits across three distinct
strategies: sequential editing, batch editing, and a hybrid approach we call as
sequential-batch editing. Our findings indicate that increasing edit
batch-sizes may degrade model performance more significantly than using smaller
edit batches sequentially for equal number of edits. With this, we argue that
sequential model editing is an important component for scaling model editing
methods and future research should focus on methods that combine both batched
and sequential editing. This observation suggests a potential limitation in
current model editing methods which push towards bigger edit batch sizes, and
we hope it paves way for future investigations into optimizing batch sizes and
model editing performance.
|
[
-0.20257090032100677,
-0.9592330455780029,
0.7982547283172607,
0.48031702637672424,
-0.06737609207630157,
0.14818447828292847,
-0.20053553581237793,
-0.6671589612960815,
0.17005178332328796,
0.6216799020767212,
-0.27986326813697815,
-0.20557086169719696,
-0.6209005117416382,
0.29869768023490906,
-0.44041478633880615,
0.6309394240379333,
-0.24879899621009827,
0.1226111650466919,
0.06852206587791443,
0.026390764862298965,
-0.6806372404098511,
-0.5138538479804993,
-1.114693284034729,
-0.2270308881998062,
0.8983733654022217,
0.6423969268798828,
0.8611912727355957,
1.2280259132385254,
0.69217848777771,
0.3365897238254547,
-0.5948519110679626,
0.08905041217803955,
-0.4005292057991028,
-0.08067725598812103,
-0.004032475408166647,
-0.6637264490127563,
-1.2728408575057983,
0.12339449673891068,
0.87279212474823,
0.47071725130081177,
-0.15331584215164185,
0.44496214389801025,
-0.25640439987182617,
0.5740302205085754,
-0.6429011821746826,
-0.5732458829879761,
-0.6237304210662842,
0.06172158569097519,
-0.35616931319236755,
0.18937937915325165,
-0.4637601971626282,
0.07228188216686249,
-0.2978112995624542,
-0.5498844981193542,
0.014511807821691036,
0.18193988502025604,
0.44121986627578735,
0.4864780604839325,
-0.2511729300022125,
0.1300843507051468,
-0.6993043422698975,
0.748846709728241,
-1.1080836057662964,
0.15226426720619202,
0.2723258137702942,
0.1513497233390808,
-0.1142655611038208,
-0.8520991802215576,
-0.5585784912109375,
0.06863898038864136,
0.24800091981887817,
-0.34094491600990295,
-0.3643331825733185,
0.27656468749046326,
0.6426408886909485,
0.28726303577423096,
-0.30390822887420654,
0.9061152935028076,
-0.5110951662063599,
-0.14967583119869232,
0.6951756477355957,
0.29827597737312317,
0.4694272577762604,
-0.005800461862236261,
0.06592703610658646,
-0.10571624338626862,
-0.9248145222663879,
-0.29368600249290466,
0.46866363286972046,
0.009174386039376259,
0.21169614791870117,
0.8830143809318542,
-0.16519393026828766,
0.9492415189743042,
0.2349621206521988,
-0.38212817907333374,
-0.11765763908624649,
-0.1143295019865036,
-0.6361241936683655,
0.11124224215745926,
0.5892233848571777,
0.7032173871994019,
-0.013944314792752266,
0.11328549683094025,
-0.2897273004055023,
-0.3408846855163574,
0.32271984219551086,
-0.9796931743621826,
0.06360887736082077,
0.36844804883003235,
-0.5975531339645386,
-0.5235850214958191,
-0.33125239610671997,
-0.36144620180130005,
-0.5623952746391296,
-0.22756429016590118,
0.2916041314601898,
-0.10216531157493591,
0.06685151904821396,
0.3639470040798187,
-0.16369879245758057,
-0.042881228029727936,
0.6615931987762451,
-0.865703284740448,
0.3345057964324951,
0.7768364548683167,
1.0043412446975708,
0.14773212373256683,
-0.535461962223053,
-0.5332933068275452,
0.2641562521457672,
-0.6711305379867554,
0.727737307548523,
-0.6615896224975586,
-0.47096994519233704,
-0.6034327745437622,
-0.20430153608322144,
0.05884995311498642,
-0.6181390285491943,
0.3593223989009857,
-0.6377521753311157,
-0.020953543484210968,
-0.36497557163238525,
-0.5771167278289795,
-0.155735582113266,
-0.08446981757879257,
-0.9829410910606384,
0.9455329179763794,
-0.0647931694984436,
-0.49776142835617065,
0.3694302439689636,
-0.8046128153800964,
-0.38537803292274475,
-0.43643346428871155,
0.40555474162101746,
-0.5288516283035278,
0.3039452135562897,
0.5349661707878113,
0.5793637633323669,
-0.38977283239364624,
0.2716146409511566,
-0.36606597900390625,
-0.4245467185974121,
0.20057593286037445,
-0.11468899250030518,
0.47052857279777527,
0.2510063052177429,
-0.15487657487392426,
0.37170928716659546,
-0.8925811648368835,
-0.1912463903427124,
0.14666648209095,
-0.3201340138912201,
-0.11988886445760727,
-0.11958200484514236,
-0.07553357630968094,
0.22966954112052917,
0.35597947239875793,
-0.6873044967651367,
0.5485907793045044,
0.12569555640220642,
0.60794997215271,
1.0846720933914185,
0.2884078919887543,
0.6125778555870056,
-0.41197264194488525,
0.637718141078949,
-0.31406092643737793,
0.4087589383125305,
-0.0779389888048172,
-0.47226184606552124,
-0.8334490656852722,
-0.39611509442329407,
0.5531044602394104,
0.40902695059776306,
-0.19957326352596283,
0.027006715536117554,
-0.1319742351770401,
-0.7584453821182251,
-0.4298588037490845,
0.47446754574775696,
0.30139195919036865,
0.2630041241645813,
0.2967453896999359,
-0.37409794330596924,
-0.6129856109619141,
-1.2602064609527588,
-0.5448254346847534,
0.07049660384654999,
0.07569823414087296,
0.06531279534101486,
0.5625869035720825,
-0.20248837769031525,
0.6334322094917297,
-0.4676247239112854,
-0.08862090855836868,
-0.45582571625709534,
-0.10825487971305847,
-0.011771967634558678,
0.5886196494102478,
0.6462380886077881,
-0.34062421321868896,
-0.45885851979255676,
0.05529242008924484,
-0.45344752073287964,
-0.1969933956861496,
-0.2980666160583496,
-0.2514704167842865,
0.014116330072283745,
0.5733873844146729,
-0.3925895690917969,
0.1858290135860443,
0.6878411173820496,
-0.04778694733977318,
0.276363343000412,
-0.3042900860309601,
0.11308963596820831,
-0.7299801707267761,
-0.29650455713272095,
-0.016666719689965248,
-0.20019814372062683,
-0.8658091425895691,
0.09455092996358871,
0.509084939956665,
0.11978840827941895,
-0.46111637353897095,
0.46460849046707153,
-0.5276505351066589,
-0.22798123955726624,
-0.27373912930488586,
-0.10514659434556961,
0.11709526181221008,
0.2956313192844391,
-0.29929351806640625,
0.834811806678772,
-0.04240041971206665,
-0.23298379778862,
0.11736264079809189,
0.05628170073032379,
-0.7422366738319397,
0.15256664156913757,
-0.91396164894104,
0.7656223773956299,
0.14238741993904114,
0.5219666361808777,
-0.738948404788971,
-0.32208865880966187,
-0.08248896896839142,
0.031713586300611496,
0.23941603302955627,
0.16237592697143555,
-0.6967473030090332,
-0.3661632835865021,
-0.5645177960395813,
0.38265809416770935,
0.09492190182209015,
-0.6178129315376282,
0.44920042157173157,
0.28301480412483215,
-0.19807086884975433,
-0.5958656668663025,
-0.9334836602210999,
0.3282233774662018,
-0.4229578375816345,
-0.8619984984397888,
0.40675756335258484,
-0.10627293586730957,
-0.4611257314682007,
-0.20109258592128754,
-0.0035157634411007166,
-0.08861783146858215,
0.18488557636737823,
-0.01082825567573309,
0.3760218918323517,
-0.20048242807388306,
-0.33910390734672546,
0.3510438799858093,
0.20029737055301666,
-0.2464461475610733,
0.17756664752960205,
0.3485410511493683,
0.10510777682065964,
-0.10133805871009827,
-0.8104488849639893,
0.2053893357515335,
0.7275000810623169,
-0.32633301615715027,
0.7678940296173096,
0.20040468871593475,
-0.297000527381897,
-0.11182989180088043,
-0.9196313619613647,
0.086750328540802,
-0.48614072799682617,
0.5280347466468811,
-0.5275092720985413,
-0.9914293885231018,
0.5780014991760254,
-0.02810198813676834,
0.11421197652816772,
0.5083457827568054,
0.40250909328460693,
0.0013515605824068189,
1.1266508102416992,
0.6860085725784302,
-0.15689152479171753,
0.5736527442932129,
-0.32157546281814575,
0.04518509656190872,
-1.363844633102417,
0.10987499356269836,
-0.3586505055427551,
-0.7057378888130188,
-0.2640250027179718,
-0.7419331073760986,
0.1789010465145111,
0.12429077923297882,
-0.3986572027206421,
0.3380732238292694,
-0.21100272238254547,
0.7254543900489807,
0.26452308893203735,
0.20393964648246765,
0.4249460995197296,
-0.26048544049263,
0.25403454899787903,
0.07434462755918503,
-0.7324160933494568,
-0.6194519996643066,
1.319489598274231,
0.5737546682357788,
0.4226999282836914,
0.29720526933670044,
0.44911807775497437,
0.2867446839809418,
0.30108898878097534,
-0.6477184891700745,
0.5510451793670654,
0.05255488306283951,
-0.7847792506217957,
-0.5016763806343079,
0.05130765587091446,
-0.48201891779899597,
0.42393216490745544,
-0.08595478534698486,
-0.5704746842384338,
0.2321423888206482,
0.2433604747056961,
-0.5381559729576111,
0.8100537061691284,
-0.7691973447799683,
0.7510195374488831,
-0.1647777408361435,
-0.26301267743110657,
-0.3997126817703247,
-0.46572092175483704,
0.40967172384262085,
-0.43022164702415466,
0.36762866377830505,
-0.04129185527563095,
-0.4319567382335663,
0.8340131640434265,
-0.6810504794120789,
0.7574456930160522,
0.061774805188179016,
-0.3070245683193207,
0.10966145992279053,
0.25855085253715515,
0.8957091569900513,
-0.14617513120174408,
-0.3322489857673645,
0.16353654861450195,
-0.2832541763782501,
-0.36432206630706787,
-0.9950498938560486,
0.5929816961288452,
-0.8224936723709106,
-0.8630968332290649,
0.04465069621801376,
-0.6071265935897827,
-0.07926131784915924,
0.02257692627608776,
-0.013902165926992893,
0.5524893403053284,
-0.0611494816839695,
0.2491503357887268,
0.2225598394870758,
-0.22580206394195557,
0.5684117674827576,
0.3041597902774811,
-0.4064290523529053,
-0.32522067427635193,
0.6929376125335693,
0.4741419851779938,
0.6025479435920715,
0.2952951192855835,
0.2903442680835724,
0.40051352977752686,
-0.9101391434669495,
-0.5977599024772644,
0.3078465461730957,
-0.599197506904602,
0.02287263423204422,
-0.6449741721153259,
0.11492814123630524,
-0.2664623260498047,
-0.5740724205970764,
-0.6249691247940063,
-0.8563326597213745,
-0.14584635198116302,
-0.15531407296657562,
0.4081772267818451,
1.1578624248504639,
-0.28899407386779785,
0.8176006078720093,
-0.375179648399353,
0.2562919557094574,
0.2604582905769348,
0.3191748559474945,
0.18549759685993195,
-0.6736190319061279,
-0.2522241771221161,
-0.22115293145179749,
-0.2116214781999588,
-0.7441993355751038,
0.3004961907863617,
0.05305326730012894,
0.2732410728931427,
0.22995883226394653,
-0.5385384559631348,
0.9648621678352356,
-0.7285195589065552,
0.858115553855896,
-0.12351422756910324,
-1.0651204586029053,
0.540282666683197,
-0.48369309306144714,
0.4278901219367981,
0.29264193773269653,
0.04454188048839569,
-0.6146059632301331,
-0.23633848130702972,
-0.696624755859375,
-0.5710188746452332,
0.7757910490036011,
-0.07733999192714691,
-0.04739398881793022,
0.25605636835098267,
0.5995549559593201,
-0.012437152676284313,
0.15116141736507416,
-0.44592204689979553,
-0.21971896290779114,
0.3890504539012909,
0.26483848690986633,
-0.10797953605651855,
-0.7381515502929688,
0.14670158922672272,
-0.4455975592136383,
0.7761068344116211,
0.34382185339927673,
-0.032314810901880264,
-0.04045618698000908,
-0.10813049972057343,
-0.40497103333473206,
0.2527882754802704,
0.7576344013214111,
1.009826421737671,
-0.428264319896698,
-0.30878978967666626,
0.6702989935874939,
-0.6314036250114441,
0.08769029378890991,
-0.5703745484352112,
-0.15368109941482544,
-0.3820106089115143,
0.5410428047180176,
1.130049228668213,
0.2879573106765747,
-0.43861934542655945,
0.0971648097038269,
0.014931393787264824,
-0.2909216582775116,
0.09723453968763351,
0.17110900580883026,
-0.19136948883533478,
0.3369747996330261,
-0.025777913630008698,
0.3411179482936859,
0.23786893486976624,
-0.336087703704834,
-0.3861677050590515,
0.01827816106379032,
0.14135289192199707,
-0.014456523582339287,
0.7706735730171204,
-0.08026450127363205,
-0.4416444003582001,
0.6208341717720032,
0.47002971172332764,
-0.3309744894504547,
0.7514288425445557,
0.5215592384338379,
0.5822689533233643,
-0.46921801567077637,
0.04426681250333786,
0.4695734977722168,
0.5981916189193726,
-0.43282920122146606,
-0.24192659556865692,
0.1706468015909195,
-0.7115275859832764,
-0.8249308466911316,
-0.2759750783443451,
-0.7394543886184692,
0.35245102643966675,
-0.6922880411148071,
0.4079098105430603,
-0.8919034600257874,
-0.2039065659046173,
0.16705501079559326,
-0.17210140824317932,
-0.40652143955230713,
0.3603249192237854,
-0.16092894971370697,
0.9202710390090942,
-0.5880478620529175,
0.8759009838104248,
0.6549715399742126,
-0.15567713975906372,
-1.080786108970642,
-0.40389320254325867,
0.38866081833839417,
-0.7154647707939148,
0.40478411316871643,
0.03556368499994278,
0.06756443530321121,
0.08419597148895264,
-0.7047213912010193,
-1.169427514076233,
1.1407499313354492,
0.3527291715145111,
-0.7453354001045227,
-0.1495162546634674,
-0.04748445749282837,
0.3627290725708008,
-0.4072421193122864,
0.06073017790913582,
0.9795112013816833,
0.5449938178062439,
0.06954803317785263,
-0.9948451519012451,
-0.013738436624407768,
-0.2494584172964096,
0.38530370593070984,
0.1319017857313156,
-0.9057993292808533,
0.9973282814025879,
-0.3737928569316864,
0.24361340701580048,
0.3536056578159332,
0.576476514339447,
0.11531173437833786,
-0.23547859489917755,
0.5809689164161682,
0.7595720291137695,
0.8705244064331055,
0.38302475214004517,
1.476372480392456,
-0.04665196314454079,
-0.0466737374663353,
1.4323877096176147,
-0.17725691199302673,
1.0417484045028687,
0.41706642508506775,
-0.18331389129161835,
0.4371628165245056,
0.9001474380493164,
-0.0811932384967804,
0.1902296394109726,
0.17592385411262512,
-0.023345474153757095,
-0.029536087065935135,
0.24598993360996246,
-0.24764756858348846,
0.42954906821250916,
0.22245930135250092,
-0.4424129128456116,
0.4337097108364105,
0.143473282456398,
0.7255002856254578,
-0.1909804791212082,
-0.33816835284233093,
0.50169837474823,
-0.12252302467823029,
-0.43569111824035645,
0.40443748235702515,
0.4774397313594818,
0.4311673641204834,
-0.1770351678133011,
0.17512135207653046,
-0.3086434304714203,
0.046990763396024704,
-0.14314274489879608,
-0.569481611251831,
0.01811259426176548,
0.398893266916275,
-0.16516396403312683,
-0.2857537269592285,
0.44664376974105835,
-0.011499613523483276,
-0.6328968405723572,
0.14743588864803314,
0.21740306913852692,
0.05521181970834732,
-0.2996496558189392,
-0.5407271981239319,
0.5874526500701904,
0.05068155378103256,
-0.6237133145332336,
0.3172467350959778,
0.2430635541677475,
-0.19864758849143982,
0.48744261264801025,
0.7178654074668884,
0.3555651009082794,
0.21086348593235016,
0.23492898046970367,
0.7216044664382935,
-0.6921356320381165,
-0.11531985551118851,
-0.9805489778518677,
0.6310670375823975,
-0.23600450158119202,
-0.31948724389076233,
0.8702179789543152,
0.5596096515655518,
0.8019890785217285,
0.05247875675559044,
0.6852142214775085,
0.14904683828353882,
0.23393069207668304,
-0.6052422523498535,
0.3820682466030121,
-0.6811091303825378,
0.36986297369003296,
-0.5718693137168884,
-1.301725149154663,
-0.5242378115653992,
0.4730224311351776,
-0.5291419625282288,
-0.16298773884773254,
0.7202114462852478,
0.8877550959587097,
0.14711914956569672,
0.2275557965040207,
0.3652556538581848,
0.6777353882789612,
0.3804589807987213,
0.3023693561553955,
0.900516152381897,
-0.4578334093093872,
-0.18685446679592133,
-0.7160747051239014,
-0.161306694149971,
-0.031152604147791862,
-0.9061038494110107,
-0.9300780296325684,
-0.27919888496398926,
-0.17461609840393066,
0.12420182675123215,
-0.062344785779714584,
0.8764886856079102,
0.39943623542785645,
-0.38891106843948364,
-0.32286277413368225,
0.225315123796463,
-0.05098140612244606,
-0.1416744589805603,
-0.06853386759757996,
0.2435157299041748,
0.08545854687690735,
-0.9035868644714355,
0.5987576246261597,
0.3611169159412384,
-0.010598120279610157,
-0.008866171352565289,
0.17754417657852173,
-0.3180209696292877,
0.21156185865402222,
0.7675310969352722,
0.10272888839244843,
-0.7780226469039917,
-0.37469011545181274,
-0.1483502835035324,
0.04670727625489235,
-0.06045283377170563,
0.8978431224822998,
-0.1963668316602707,
0.5136996507644653,
0.141609787940979,
0.6554367542266846,
0.6683829426765442,
-0.004822412971407175,
0.7384100556373596,
-0.33450955152511597,
0.30852970480918884,
-0.2345251590013504,
0.4410068988800049,
0.47125640511512756,
-0.5422949194908142,
0.7200391888618469,
-0.20868702232837677,
-0.6862314343452454,
-0.9691840410232544,
-0.4186473488807678,
-0.9116271138191223,
-0.34479889273643494,
1.3390575647354126,
0.2840152084827423,
-0.2768116891384125,
0.4599805176258087,
-0.6050034761428833,
0.1677132397890091,
-0.08878187090158463,
0.3598965108394623,
0.9574465155601501,
-0.4003567397594452,
-0.130255788564682,
-1.0178025960922241,
0.17152462899684906,
0.49876463413238525,
-0.6774083971977234,
-0.05394859239459038,
0.7409076690673828,
0.04989861696958542,
-0.22289934754371643,
0.5124462842941284,
-0.03929481282830238,
0.3216647505760193,
-0.0704658254981041,
-0.04114533215761185,
-0.2803042232990265,
-0.5673284530639648,
-0.4520496428012848,
-0.0034153240267187357,
0.34960153698921204,
0.3483116626739502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00659v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00659v1
|
NLU-STR at SemEval-2024 Task 1: Generative-based Augmentation and Encoder-based Scoring for Semantic Textual Relatedness
| 2024-05-01T17:44:05 | 2024-05-01T17:44:05 |
Sanad Malaysha, Mustafa Jarrar, Mohammed Khalilia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Semantic textual relatedness is a broader concept of semantic similarity. It
measures the extent to which two chunks of text convey similar meaning or
topics, or share related concepts or contexts. This notion of relatedness can
be applied in various applications, such as document clustering and
summarizing. SemRel-2024, a shared task in SemEval-2024, aims at reducing the
gap in the semantic relatedness task by providing datasets for fourteen
languages and dialects including Arabic. This paper reports on our
participation in Track A (Algerian and Moroccan dialects) and Track B (Modern
Standard Arabic). A BERT-based model is augmented and fine-tuned for regression
scoring in supervised track (A), while BERT-based cosine similarity is employed
for unsupervised track (B). Our system ranked 1st in SemRel-2024 for MSA with a
Spearman correlation score of 0.49. We ranked 5th for Moroccan and 12th for
Algerian with scores of 0.83 and 0.53, respectively.
|
[
-0.6117397546768188,
-0.6362774968147278,
0.45514509081840515,
0.3958677649497986,
-0.33893945813179016,
-0.2371363788843155,
-0.2389066070318222,
-0.7580247521400452,
0.39875441789627075,
0.6237492561340332,
-0.6234847903251648,
-0.8492057919502258,
-0.3544745445251465,
0.28662049770355225,
-0.36772429943084717,
1.0387845039367676,
-0.028306974098086357,
-0.02539787068963051,
-0.5558306574821472,
-0.6362793445587158,
-0.4714491367340088,
-0.8373141884803772,
-0.33469343185424805,
-0.2854946255683899,
0.6685149669647217,
0.21677903831005096,
0.6089962124824524,
0.306367963552475,
0.8267510533332825,
0.2924422323703766,
0.04292416200041771,
0.12838509678840637,
-0.1585243195295334,
0.4963356852531433,
-0.40202075242996216,
-0.23755326867103577,
-0.586236298084259,
-0.3113352954387665,
0.2164877951145172,
0.5622838139533997,
0.18327690660953522,
0.16041335463523865,
0.1428799331188202,
0.6879674196243286,
-0.3106158971786499,
-0.10079164057970047,
-0.42997342348098755,
-0.21588273346424103,
-0.2663905620574951,
-0.31848591566085815,
-0.18928100168704987,
-0.3377440571784973,
0.11899244785308838,
-0.35110944509506226,
0.5615957975387573,
-0.042464256286621094,
1.143923282623291,
0.35023045539855957,
-0.40543800592422485,
-0.5781368613243103,
-0.476193904876709,
0.8755204081535339,
-0.686520516872406,
0.25482121109962463,
0.6686874628067017,
-0.007774637546390295,
0.0884920135140419,
-0.4771791398525238,
-0.3884780704975128,
-0.1136084571480751,
-0.10350137203931808,
0.31168022751808167,
0.12583893537521362,
-0.14024868607521057,
0.08089341968297958,
0.15521277487277985,
-0.6979870200157166,
-0.09657036513090134,
-0.17748261988162994,
-0.3506125211715698,
0.7375167012214661,
-0.014093714766204357,
0.22305014729499817,
-0.036560870707035065,
-0.49669450521469116,
-0.015804165974259377,
-0.7409253120422363,
-0.23014700412750244,
0.47691452503204346,
0.24173089861869812,
-0.19510890543460846,
0.586819589138031,
-0.19677181541919708,
0.6684679985046387,
-0.28811579942703247,
0.3489348590373993,
0.6313939690589905,
-0.6489003896713257,
0.11742289364337921,
0.1442813277244568,
0.7807748913764954,
0.3311573266983032,
0.08720417320728302,
-0.05435020849108696,
-0.18818578124046326,
0.20694226026535034,
0.1358514130115509,
-0.4980687201023102,
-0.13298605382442474,
-0.11432059109210968,
-0.4618898630142212,
0.02219509705901146,
0.04187116399407387,
-0.5478304028511047,
0.05081622302532196,
-0.44541484117507935,
0.7617617249488831,
-0.635878324508667,
0.02914552390575409,
-0.30374875664711,
0.0457027405500412,
0.4024239182472229,
0.5294421911239624,
-0.5364896059036255,
0.20100420713424683,
0.7084149718284607,
0.7641818523406982,
-0.35225072503089905,
-0.3567308187484741,
-0.06807848066091537,
0.08742675930261612,
-0.031203584745526314,
0.8032802939414978,
-0.6797266602516174,
-0.3674886226654053,
-0.013695620000362396,
-0.007149663288146257,
-0.19040589034557343,
-0.6406874060630798,
0.9718766212463379,
-0.6549022197723389,
0.19112542271614075,
-0.32892635464668274,
-0.6373512744903564,
-0.5407317280769348,
0.2723683714866638,
-0.7770247459411621,
1.483269453048706,
0.12243935465812683,
-0.6427491307258606,
0.2597549855709076,
-0.3668735921382904,
-0.4954430162906647,
-0.03792312741279602,
-0.1538652926683426,
-0.4802190363407135,
0.03481244668364525,
0.2649736702442169,
0.3308441936969757,
-0.2244054079055786,
0.2006116509437561,
-0.10144403576850891,
-0.560028076171875,
0.14965017139911652,
-0.43793344497680664,
0.33179327845573425,
0.2246660441160202,
-0.22793717682361603,
0.23135995864868164,
-0.7537224292755127,
-0.011855589225888252,
-0.32828110456466675,
-0.19575241208076477,
-0.633831262588501,
-0.18623127043247223,
0.3260498642921448,
0.4440511167049408,
0.5648729205131531,
-0.42595773935317993,
-0.1590895801782608,
-0.5959190130233765,
-0.08252649009227753,
0.3840941786766052,
0.2086087316274643,
0.259619802236557,
-0.5826499462127686,
0.3098897635936737,
0.05230551213026047,
-0.2893375754356384,
-0.2974034249782562,
-0.5934334397315979,
-1.02970552444458,
-0.17848551273345947,
0.5691837072372437,
0.5543630123138428,
-0.5890995860099792,
0.6738936305046082,
-0.4502161145210266,
-0.564363956451416,
-0.4403195083141327,
-0.07131566107273102,
0.3960602879524231,
0.20546765625476837,
0.5839267373085022,
-0.39513540267944336,
-0.5799538493156433,
-0.954420268535614,
-0.1684984266757965,
-0.04379914328455925,
-0.06657208502292633,
0.09830116480588913,
0.6439660787582397,
-0.2429829239845276,
0.5735568404197693,
-0.08256545662879944,
-0.5630197525024414,
0.027177443727850914,
0.15748994052410126,
0.4696536362171173,
0.5677666068077087,
0.6109147071838379,
-0.6276668310165405,
-0.5846326947212219,
0.26250550150871277,
-0.7973110675811768,
-0.2279215306043625,
0.300868958234787,
-0.03862744942307472,
0.440085232257843,
0.720441997051239,
-0.11006075888872147,
0.4820072650909424,
0.5039045810699463,
-0.47802913188934326,
0.16443604230880737,
-0.28428369760513306,
0.4822734296321869,
-1.2796337604522705,
-0.14634478092193604,
-0.17721785604953766,
-0.09648384898900986,
-0.5434972643852234,
0.023756643757224083,
-0.21097515523433685,
0.085059255361557,
-0.2326686829328537,
0.3655373752117157,
-0.0953221321105957,
0.02300114557147026,
-0.17538456618785858,
0.011435690335929394,
-0.04790113866329193,
0.42641374468803406,
0.07628942281007767,
0.9144415855407715,
0.266676127910614,
-0.52447110414505,
0.12246468663215637,
0.2734255790710449,
-0.28837308287620544,
0.4706394374370575,
-0.7793292999267578,
0.2682984471321106,
-0.06491848081350327,
-0.12813428044319153,
-0.7575357556343079,
0.06730543076992035,
-0.20833554863929749,
-0.6603257656097412,
0.19490082561969757,
0.18488717079162598,
-0.3702213764190674,
0.12122206389904022,
-0.3183918297290802,
0.6826476454734802,
0.29013359546661377,
-0.24303875863552094,
0.676585853099823,
0.12962612509727478,
-0.5016440749168396,
-0.5480632781982422,
-0.5919612050056458,
0.0812140479683876,
-0.3093714714050293,
-0.7747931480407715,
0.5610256195068359,
0.13720814883708954,
-0.12961241602897644,
0.2978959083557129,
0.014663416892290115,
0.13198013603687286,
-0.11605506390333176,
0.4767770767211914,
0.24979561567306519,
-0.2983241379261017,
0.23608893156051636,
0.041388776153326035,
0.029039667919278145,
0.04099314287304878,
0.022808918729424477,
0.6449543833732605,
-0.19995051622390747,
-0.462507039308548,
0.02864586003124714,
0.6421759128570557,
0.23028352856636047,
-0.22308401763439178,
0.8958791494369507,
0.8629632592201233,
-0.3154769837856293,
0.05044974759221077,
-0.6507142782211304,
-0.08538355678319931,
-0.4197883903980255,
0.44902801513671875,
-0.7070814371109009,
-1.2276654243469238,
0.654032826423645,
0.06284970045089722,
-0.24456527829170227,
0.7518296837806702,
0.7252205610275269,
-0.2864888310432434,
0.6930517554283142,
0.4592173993587494,
-0.08275028318166733,
0.20459391176700592,
-0.07685600221157074,
0.12838198244571686,
-0.7025899291038513,
-0.41951924562454224,
-0.856970489025116,
-0.061946768313646317,
-0.9506291151046753,
-0.6942625641822815,
0.252642959356308,
0.07320219278335571,
-0.2447652667760849,
0.6447665691375732,
-0.10630583763122559,
0.212760329246521,
0.5908918976783752,
-0.029921114444732666,
0.11694534868001938,
0.18914754688739777,
-0.3834649324417114,
-0.2642955482006073,
-0.5336243510246277,
-0.5584626793861389,
0.9436242580413818,
0.15956835448741913,
0.5184339284896851,
0.4500453770160675,
1.0561262369155884,
0.6832593083381653,
0.08607134968042374,
-0.5250849723815918,
0.5936129093170166,
-0.07188858836889267,
-0.2740795612335205,
-0.3366367220878601,
-0.22236447036266327,
-0.8780208826065063,
0.17669187486171722,
-0.23158249258995056,
-0.6150158643722534,
0.1462431699037552,
-0.23914144933223724,
0.2678404450416565,
-0.34047600626945496,
-0.3297361731529236,
0.5335166454315186,
0.08983386307954788,
-0.569963812828064,
-0.3246000409126282,
-0.8090276718139648,
-0.14525611698627472,
-0.2379489243030548,
0.3505078852176666,
-0.38598179817199707,
-0.11678017675876617,
0.8961207866668701,
-0.5455576777458191,
0.4647577106952667,
0.13546422123908997,
-0.19204650819301605,
0.271139532327652,
-0.07431607693433762,
0.2470196932554245,
-0.17947694659233093,
-0.513012707233429,
0.4290769696235657,
0.18063190579414368,
-0.43984270095825195,
-0.46543198823928833,
1.0324755907058716,
-0.8199755549430847,
-0.3800237774848938,
-0.7681032419204712,
-0.5084998607635498,
-0.229076087474823,
0.005330118350684643,
0.2070041447877884,
0.5236804485321045,
-0.4235132038593292,
0.16693666577339172,
0.42409539222717285,
-0.23125793039798737,
0.4756493866443634,
0.42039385437965393,
-0.08455794304609299,
-0.4580187201499939,
1.101333498954773,
-0.24227377772331238,
0.011601625010371208,
0.5902057886123657,
-0.22543443739414215,
-0.5991118550300598,
-0.40594103932380676,
-0.37589848041534424,
0.27188417315483093,
-0.7648964524269104,
-0.31843990087509155,
-0.5711646676063538,
-0.49543076753616333,
-0.306738942861557,
-0.2565034031867981,
0.09524190425872803,
-0.5099864602088928,
-0.2554723918437958,
-0.002905357861891389,
0.4415052831172943,
0.7488235235214233,
0.07261490076780319,
0.01628502644598484,
-0.9671050310134888,
-0.07579845935106277,
0.04592151567339897,
-0.06470032781362534,
-0.2662934958934784,
-0.8896191716194153,
-0.30170801281929016,
-0.24899059534072876,
-0.1277463138103485,
-0.6557285189628601,
0.4476793110370636,
0.5773029327392578,
0.41287797689437866,
0.12235397845506668,
0.10658203810453415,
0.6320098042488098,
-0.6146989464759827,
0.8236875534057617,
0.03352509066462517,
-0.905840277671814,
0.7448298931121826,
-0.38684627413749695,
0.3369884490966797,
0.8784164786338806,
0.4640849232673645,
-0.23833045363426208,
-0.5718184113502502,
-0.4213155210018158,
-1.0044984817504883,
0.4610270857810974,
0.5939939022064209,
0.2692056894302368,
-0.10102447867393494,
-0.015458235517144203,
0.1620751917362213,
-0.03330077975988388,
-0.4529483914375305,
-0.39644384384155273,
-0.07996314018964767,
-0.6584305763244629,
-0.13318072259426117,
-0.3782125413417816,
0.18174320459365845,
-0.1729300171136856,
0.844018816947937,
0.025382239371538162,
0.34250739216804504,
0.3002454936504364,
-0.16609668731689453,
0.20799942314624786,
0.609230637550354,
0.6101458668708801,
0.574678361415863,
-0.30526506900787354,
0.20582740008831024,
0.5157323479652405,
-0.5948658585548401,
0.18869860470294952,
0.31458780169487,
-0.2895892262458801,
0.2962343692779541,
0.7108115553855896,
0.7147151827812195,
0.08566078543663025,
-0.5908030271530151,
0.4967820942401886,
0.0786067470908165,
-0.2765754163265228,
-0.4504229426383972,
-0.16904626786708832,
0.12383107841014862,
0.05012935400009155,
0.3290015757083893,
0.18725024163722992,
0.3469783663749695,
-0.47694623470306396,
0.3659031093120575,
0.19690127670764923,
-1.0659997463226318,
-0.35404542088508606,
0.3316574990749359,
0.2324531078338623,
-0.13166262209415436,
0.14833775162696838,
-0.2195839136838913,
-0.6590942144393921,
0.6441337466239929,
0.663182258605957,
0.43140068650245667,
-0.40510255098342896,
-0.03324776515364647,
0.6834174990653992,
0.21247713267803192,
0.2538144886493683,
0.6483134627342224,
-0.07030411064624786,
-0.8090758323669434,
-0.5397692918777466,
-1.002058744430542,
-0.17527027428150177,
-0.10278478264808655,
-0.969851553440094,
0.385330468416214,
0.26392221450805664,
-0.19546277821063995,
-0.056323498487472534,
-0.11928338557481766,
-0.7646414637565613,
0.4106389582157135,
-0.13738448917865753,
0.71463543176651,
-0.8603658080101013,
0.906991183757782,
1.0637853145599365,
-0.32228341698646545,
-0.6368693709373474,
-0.09437432885169983,
-0.07428288459777832,
-0.4818740487098694,
0.6308227181434631,
0.28356680274009705,
-0.14633339643478394,
-0.06654702872037888,
0.10533928126096725,
-0.8233168125152588,
1.1207984685897827,
-0.0490136444568634,
-0.5893203616142273,
0.1469181478023529,
0.2756458818912506,
0.6439419984817505,
-0.19234699010849,
0.4639423191547394,
0.5554831624031067,
0.15941648185253143,
0.11741423606872559,
-0.8973836898803711,
-0.04945093020796776,
-0.44166627526283264,
0.028021275997161865,
0.5720998644828796,
-0.4075063169002533,
0.5349737405776978,
0.08595847338438034,
-0.08745855838060379,
0.3897287845611572,
0.8572096824645996,
0.11639194190502167,
0.5854583382606506,
0.24724729359149933,
0.9247928857803345,
0.354078471660614,
-0.2402142435312271,
0.6263825297355652,
-0.40539979934692383,
0.32996678352355957,
1.3025636672973633,
-0.47206658124923706,
0.9801518321037292,
0.4451649487018585,
-0.34584978222846985,
0.6928436756134033,
0.36078187823295593,
0.1281011402606964,
0.5710036754608154,
0.018721528351306915,
-0.6667834520339966,
-0.029908906668424606,
-0.683785080909729,
-0.6387010812759399,
0.628994345664978,
0.5853185057640076,
-0.5117873549461365,
-0.1319759488105774,
-0.03128728270530701,
-0.11574897915124893,
0.5120400786399841,
-0.2653810381889343,
1.1046842336654663,
0.18243634700775146,
-0.5793716907501221,
0.27948886156082153,
0.021800395101308823,
0.6071605086326599,
-0.6096437573432922,
-0.3496682941913605,
-0.019680798053741455,
0.058802280575037,
-0.09312032908201218,
-0.7141078114509583,
0.5435947179794312,
-0.05583736672997475,
-0.2871379256248474,
0.16691358387470245,
0.8967114686965942,
-0.6695238947868347,
-0.6370065212249756,
0.5344142913818359,
0.744965136051178,
0.14294132590293884,
0.17596426606178284,
-0.4374096989631653,
0.18858420848846436,
0.008015411905944347,
0.26029232144355774,
0.29715079069137573,
0.4988020360469818,
-0.3002903163433075,
0.19878292083740234,
0.5169875025749207,
-0.009742308408021927,
-0.05964288115501404,
0.5363727807998657,
0.7456831336021423,
-0.8553711175918579,
-0.24283649027347565,
-0.7545998692512512,
-0.14244192838668823,
-0.019812671467661858,
-0.269885778427124,
1.053031325340271,
0.7679992914199829,
0.9941810369491577,
-0.19788336753845215,
0.6686596870422363,
-0.06339539587497711,
0.6995829343795776,
-0.626345157623291,
0.5500239729881287,
-0.3559350371360779,
0.31203535199165344,
-0.33796173334121704,
-1.2508424520492554,
-0.17363668978214264,
0.624451220035553,
-0.251356840133667,
-0.02885143831372261,
0.7929290533065796,
1.0553641319274902,
0.06071298196911812,
0.154732808470726,
0.514010488986969,
-0.3072427213191986,
-0.18325002491474152,
0.5850207209587097,
1.0650070905685425,
-0.6752588152885437,
0.2237372249364853,
-0.15257924795150757,
0.09541915357112885,
-0.094075046479702,
-0.684337854385376,
-0.9479823708534241,
-0.8868193626403809,
-0.2629191279411316,
-0.45121094584465027,
0.2155447155237198,
0.9815356731414795,
0.272468239068985,
-1.2743910551071167,
-0.22313594818115234,
0.024547509849071503,
-0.08924120664596558,
-0.05613762512803078,
-0.24101616442203522,
0.69851154088974,
-0.12834957242012024,
-0.522489070892334,
0.26641544699668884,
0.4280928671360016,
-0.04099823907017708,
0.2033333033323288,
-0.18753281235694885,
-0.5335119366645813,
0.05865997448563576,
0.6469117999076843,
-0.11573692411184311,
-0.7820892333984375,
-0.4532302916049957,
-0.07937919348478317,
-0.14805273711681366,
-0.10107043385505676,
0.5990269184112549,
-0.7511992454528809,
0.33816686272621155,
0.5849881172180176,
0.6191958785057068,
0.5379223823547363,
0.2071065902709961,
0.38714399933815,
-0.7612682580947876,
0.3274529278278351,
0.3928929269313812,
0.3232690095901489,
0.5404303073883057,
-0.026297887787222862,
0.8186461925506592,
-0.020400352776050568,
-0.7544533610343933,
-0.28661859035491943,
0.26088905334472656,
-1.0670737028121948,
0.19539301097393036,
0.9699404835700989,
-0.3587060570716858,
-0.07045602798461914,
-0.6078215837478638,
-0.240912526845932,
0.1515924632549286,
-0.27843940258026123,
0.3834589421749115,
0.6798505187034607,
-0.016772456467151642,
0.04039532691240311,
-0.38088637590408325,
0.4253515303134918,
0.7291059494018555,
-0.775543212890625,
-0.6558072566986084,
0.38817495107650757,
0.1124918982386589,
0.27554360032081604,
0.45982012152671814,
-0.11752069741487503,
0.28276821970939636,
-0.09655454009771347,
-0.012493668124079704,
0.19396360218524933,
-0.10925285518169403,
-0.3434288501739502,
0.016820237040519714,
0.06899072974920273,
-0.024791574105620384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00657v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00657v1
|
RST-LoRA: A Discourse-Aware Low-Rank Adaptation for Long Document Abstractive Summarization
| 2024-05-01T17:37:50 | 2024-05-01T17:37:50 |
Dongqi Pu, Vera Demberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
For long document summarization, discourse structure is important to discern
the key content of the text and the differences in importance level between
sentences. Unfortunately, the integration of rhetorical structure theory (RST)
into parameter-efficient fine-tuning strategies for long document summarization
remains unexplored. Therefore, this paper introduces RST-LoRA and proposes four
RST-aware variants to explicitly incorporate RST into the LoRA model. Our
empirical evaluation demonstrates that incorporating the type and uncertainty
of rhetorical relations can complementarily enhance the performance of LoRA in
summarization tasks. Furthermore, the best-performing variant we introduced
outperforms the vanilla LoRA and full-parameter fine-tuning models, as
confirmed by multiple automatic and human evaluations, and even surpasses
previous state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.14654068648815155,
-0.715745747089386,
0.579810619354248,
0.41351446509361267,
-0.5812027454376221,
0.23058447241783142,
-0.09445315599441528,
-0.47500917315483093,
0.49390244483947754,
0.3322330713272095,
-0.10144168138504028,
-0.38214871287345886,
-0.9104917645454407,
0.1562645584344864,
-0.39517584443092346,
1.2981699705123901,
0.11360156536102295,
-0.31206846237182617,
0.18339502811431885,
-0.3276364803314209,
-0.16221384704113007,
-0.38457730412483215,
-0.5886963605880737,
-0.255228191614151,
0.9531687498092651,
0.2770073115825653,
0.6416829824447632,
0.49704575538635254,
0.5518743991851807,
0.24112184345722198,
-0.4815181791782379,
0.08653870224952698,
-0.6175658702850342,
0.3346225917339325,
-0.6044002175331116,
-0.48444974422454834,
-1.0773093700408936,
-0.43880805373191833,
0.869020402431488,
0.6911030411720276,
-0.061314038932323456,
0.19847863912582397,
0.3657410144805908,
1.0097339153289795,
-0.7320702075958252,
0.10959595441818237,
-0.5062829852104187,
-0.07469552755355835,
-0.1459318846464157,
-0.5717810988426208,
-0.48263856768608093,
-0.4353432059288025,
0.13223223388195038,
-0.7108361124992371,
-0.2449515163898468,
0.10263809561729431,
0.6054249405860901,
0.3850639760494232,
-0.5184530019760132,
-0.13988542556762695,
-0.6959525346755981,
0.5713626742362976,
-0.7597516775131226,
-0.08762995898723602,
0.27353668212890625,
0.1886390745639801,
-0.08265981078147888,
-0.5475689768791199,
0.05275857076048851,
0.11768963932991028,
-0.03504046052694321,
0.4416327476501465,
-0.189694344997406,
0.2974138855934143,
0.11944831907749176,
0.39578643441200256,
-0.34511008858680725,
0.1594209372997284,
-0.48853686451911926,
0.27004474401474,
0.2501770555973053,
0.007228124886751175,
-0.15891724824905396,
-0.552687406539917,
-0.19165943562984467,
0.32999029755592346,
-0.7905163764953613,
-0.14602914452552795,
0.20332948863506317,
0.7630202770233154,
-0.34415969252586365,
0.5828011631965637,
-0.32277920842170715,
0.6010209321975708,
0.1296592354774475,
-0.21325112879276276,
-0.24852021038532257,
-0.22569668292999268,
-0.19791527092456818,
0.09949413686990738,
0.522743821144104,
0.09790375083684921,
0.030815299600362778,
0.25787705183029175,
-0.11557997763156891,
-0.06246351823210716,
-0.14634239673614502,
-1.0008223056793213,
-0.012973018921911716,
0.08202023059129715,
-0.5525924563407898,
-0.42433762550354004,
-0.2187078446149826,
-0.7276313900947571,
-0.47384899854660034,
-0.1524566411972046,
0.3669601082801819,
-0.5118047595024109,
-0.009157735854387283,
0.19519244134426117,
-0.12526936829090118,
0.3308817148208618,
0.6909011602401733,
-0.9201020002365112,
0.6434755325317383,
0.8154755234718323,
1.0342522859573364,
-0.4193101227283478,
-0.25218284130096436,
-0.7211725115776062,
0.502449095249176,
-0.18799063563346863,
1.3361217975616455,
-0.39360669255256653,
-0.4472917318344116,
-0.2793061435222626,
-0.33059629797935486,
-0.1680765002965927,
0.0029501300305128098,
0.7675849199295044,
-0.4169916808605194,
0.4969181418418884,
-0.35092565417289734,
-0.29248499870300293,
-0.0775272324681282,
0.17813745141029358,
-0.48960915207862854,
0.9552674293518066,
0.4810742437839508,
-0.9567312002182007,
-0.08028595894575119,
-1.0170525312423706,
-0.8257720470428467,
-0.1971132755279541,
-0.00950714386999607,
-0.5036255121231079,
0.3170820474624634,
0.21267388761043549,
0.25803402066230774,
-0.18958517909049988,
-0.18365362286567688,
-0.07646704465150833,
-0.5583022236824036,
0.1178746148943901,
-0.1600213646888733,
0.5584570169448853,
0.13846264779567719,
0.09201326221227646,
0.33826252818107605,
-0.7381314039230347,
-0.04749825969338417,
-0.08571115881204605,
-0.37008294463157654,
-0.504500150680542,
0.12315282970666885,
-0.03845290094614029,
-0.04719756171107292,
0.2280624806880951,
0.030992060899734497,
0.12193702161312103,
-0.802697479724884,
0.7555127143859863,
0.8214137554168701,
0.4148900508880615,
0.4623579978942871,
-0.4678722321987152,
0.6692718267440796,
-0.15095312893390656,
-0.14974455535411835,
-0.3072625994682312,
-0.36687421798706055,
-0.7277191281318665,
-0.3123646676540375,
0.6751783490180969,
0.5427966117858887,
-0.4675367772579193,
0.40787458419799805,
-0.5470737814903259,
-0.3443412780761719,
-0.1723320633172989,
-0.1515701860189438,
0.5475665926933289,
0.3626175820827484,
0.19663123786449432,
-0.1628464013338089,
-0.5583730936050415,
-0.6526928544044495,
-0.4189286530017853,
-0.1463756561279297,
0.15987995266914368,
-0.19572722911834717,
0.646606981754303,
0.4330381751060486,
0.9860745668411255,
-0.7157475352287292,
-0.2845136821269989,
-0.5355687141418457,
0.4339359700679779,
0.24179136753082275,
0.24603718519210815,
0.7156344056129456,
-0.4055427610874176,
-0.6776083111763,
0.005942291114479303,
-0.4456198215484619,
0.22973214089870453,
0.12550023198127747,
0.013815926387906075,
0.23057986795902252,
0.41000545024871826,
-0.5933569669723511,
0.5570952296257019,
0.3769330084323883,
-0.21661695837974548,
0.14364375174045563,
-0.4775993824005127,
0.15105052292346954,
-1.6485992670059204,
0.05456509068608284,
-0.08736995607614517,
-0.44768616557121277,
-0.3038109242916107,
0.12393122166395187,
0.06887836009263992,
-0.4021218717098236,
-0.2900139093399048,
0.3378167450428009,
-0.5323613882064819,
-0.5277253985404968,
-0.32290908694267273,
0.5318173766136169,
0.18804022669792175,
0.6040006875991821,
-0.12413006275892258,
0.7108131647109985,
0.18114013969898224,
-0.6010690927505493,
-0.3552001118659973,
0.307656466960907,
-0.34784695506095886,
0.9594886302947998,
-0.8651326894760132,
0.01911327615380287,
-0.3090139329433441,
0.5386815071105957,
-1.047377109527588,
-0.35761550068855286,
0.21411888301372528,
-0.33792853355407715,
0.10040738433599472,
-0.5753998756408691,
-0.25325945019721985,
0.23254089057445526,
-0.600230872631073,
0.46377483010292053,
0.4434851109981537,
-0.04318482428789139,
0.7921008467674255,
0.1569986492395401,
-0.650755763053894,
-0.7598187923431396,
-0.6646973490715027,
0.15449734032154083,
-0.41592955589294434,
-0.2983546257019043,
0.5011270046234131,
-0.027643149718642235,
-0.28161555528640747,
-0.2390211969614029,
-0.09461850672960281,
0.14930608868598938,
0.17764179408550262,
0.3057260513305664,
0.022406021133065224,
-0.6284414529800415,
-0.14141474664211273,
0.5169787406921387,
-0.26030775904655457,
-0.2793063819408417,
0.15544922649860382,
0.20219355821609497,
-0.02172025665640831,
-0.32597920298576355,
-0.36700639128685,
0.47176823019981384,
0.6467623114585876,
-0.30338016152381897,
0.502025306224823,
0.10193581134080887,
-0.2853115499019623,
-0.25595808029174805,
0.022016946226358414,
-0.008070233277976513,
-0.43275246024131775,
0.6084030270576477,
-0.42477190494537354,
-0.6796178221702576,
0.6709437370300293,
-0.09267368912696838,
0.08196938037872314,
0.5088539719581604,
0.15184016525745392,
-0.2308621108531952,
0.6485019326210022,
0.7426614761352539,
-0.18552495539188385,
0.5251226425170898,
0.012591741979122162,
0.28891682624816895,
-0.912675142288208,
0.4597957730293274,
-0.7985345721244812,
-0.34926873445510864,
-0.4378650188446045,
-0.28085875511169434,
0.5892361998558044,
-0.10709160566329956,
-0.15082164108753204,
0.15288083255290985,
-0.5054731369018555,
0.643318772315979,
0.02599211595952511,
-0.07048098742961884,
0.7423609495162964,
0.027042783796787262,
0.6609700322151184,
-0.08561332523822784,
-0.4802456796169281,
-0.2743380069732666,
0.737037181854248,
0.40541398525238037,
0.7936648726463318,
0.4605807065963745,
0.7119454145431519,
0.44170892238616943,
0.09209776669740677,
-1.027590274810791,
0.6033993363380432,
-0.37268126010894775,
-0.180404394865036,
-0.5836113095283508,
-0.04587067291140556,
-1.0906428098678589,
0.47253477573394775,
-0.05905286967754364,
-0.5908292531967163,
0.16140983998775482,
0.13516002893447876,
-0.8652061820030212,
-0.05423089861869812,
-0.6039236783981323,
0.3829919993877411,
0.02037815749645233,
-0.1487913578748703,
-0.3365650177001953,
-0.634972095489502,
0.28033626079559326,
0.047228310257196426,
0.26970693469047546,
-0.20820015668869019,
-0.3018612265586853,
0.8499834537506104,
-0.04074402153491974,
0.9672253727912903,
-0.009962772019207478,
-0.3038826286792755,
-0.0719793438911438,
0.09522444009780884,
0.9111087322235107,
0.05875425785779953,
-0.2579742670059204,
-0.45962271094322205,
0.10841473937034607,
-0.3833620548248291,
-0.8383926153182983,
0.7166309952735901,
-0.6887878179550171,
-0.5498368144035339,
-0.7184945940971375,
-0.5016905069351196,
-0.27962392568588257,
0.41344785690307617,
0.25919899344444275,
0.3587965667247772,
-0.5808701515197754,
0.23787014186382294,
0.8932380080223083,
0.18326036632061005,
0.3602977693080902,
0.37964555621147156,
-0.297529011964798,
-0.44117823243141174,
0.7652552127838135,
0.2806803584098816,
0.23669648170471191,
0.7442710995674133,
0.31243896484375,
0.09852425009012222,
-0.9481616020202637,
-0.2616736888885498,
0.23940950632095337,
-0.8398828506469727,
-0.2940295934677124,
-0.5568928718566895,
-0.42480090260505676,
-0.3354891836643219,
-0.43487608432769775,
-0.44370439648628235,
-1.1105406284332275,
-0.3750610649585724,
-0.1343863308429718,
0.6029772758483887,
0.8972291946411133,
0.3007742762565613,
0.5408650040626526,
-0.13580374419689178,
0.6804665327072144,
0.18166090548038483,
0.3739028871059418,
-0.28194597363471985,
-0.9963982105255127,
-0.15649065375328064,
-0.2429511547088623,
-0.21470330655574799,
-0.7431448101997375,
0.12416611611843109,
0.3683605492115021,
0.07302083820104599,
0.23853850364685059,
0.22570082545280457,
0.6556295156478882,
-0.22525112330913544,
0.6479964852333069,
0.06664685159921646,
-0.8610968589782715,
0.5715638995170593,
-1.0168852806091309,
0.49136605858802795,
0.7056563496589661,
-0.08773946762084961,
-0.33458656072616577,
-0.17563338577747345,
-0.18776600062847137,
-0.822887659072876,
0.511528491973877,
0.11319214105606079,
0.0005373279564082623,
0.3741679787635803,
0.301153302192688,
0.10764157772064209,
-0.06327170878648758,
-0.7954268455505371,
0.035078972578048706,
-0.2808067798614502,
-0.18716076016426086,
0.03518911823630333,
-0.5091723799705505,
-0.34631651639938354,
-0.18903477489948273,
0.7145136594772339,
-0.2708185315132141,
0.11204525083303452,
0.06330493837594986,
-0.20242804288864136,
0.02570146881043911,
0.8664391040802002,
1.1809509992599487,
1.0019577741622925,
-0.49792543053627014,
0.09013309329748154,
0.29303497076034546,
-0.25583916902542114,
-0.06369328498840332,
0.11766991019248962,
-0.20790396630764008,
-0.06790699064731598,
0.19061940908432007,
0.6366773843765259,
0.9053053855895996,
-0.11228757351636887,
0.46923866868019104,
-0.01453649252653122,
-0.3033054769039154,
-0.3449835181236267,
-0.09187006205320358,
0.24629676342010498,
-0.018030010163784027,
0.35055074095726013,
0.20990239083766937,
0.13691949844360352,
-0.5465968251228333,
-0.26693296432495117,
0.19558316469192505,
-0.25281187891960144,
-0.3823242485523224,
0.3750040829181671,
0.4235425591468811,
-0.4593476355075836,
-0.24344375729560852,
-0.14203661680221558,
-0.14581598341464996,
0.1949191391468048,
0.6759113669395447,
0.7554922103881836,
-0.19513607025146484,
0.33287402987480164,
0.15626145899295807,
0.1488768309354782,
-0.1980193853378296,
0.37345683574676514,
0.024188606068491936,
-0.06191256269812584,
-0.5879428386688232,
-0.37264275550842285,
-0.6928182244300842,
-0.10730316489934921,
-0.6958571672439575,
0.34510013461112976,
-0.6133829951286316,
-0.045383140444755554,
0.13723942637443542,
-0.17598700523376465,
0.12921655178070068,
-0.28238698840141296,
-0.39627155661582947,
0.7502118349075317,
-0.46414998173713684,
0.7260356545448303,
0.4146031439304352,
-0.19969385862350464,
-0.24052996933460236,
-0.0322980135679245,
-0.254387766122818,
-0.5119012594223022,
0.311110258102417,
-0.46670281887054443,
-0.7737447619438171,
-0.048091448843479156,
-0.22699059545993805,
-1.2316501140594482,
1.1405919790267944,
0.6223536729812622,
-0.15055842697620392,
-0.4780842065811157,
0.09251279383897781,
0.6817723512649536,
-0.2925663888454437,
0.05586951971054077,
0.3381842076778412,
0.43437179923057556,
0.07714919000864029,
-0.7546967267990112,
0.02914838120341301,
0.025563707575201988,
0.036047257483005524,
0.31131359934806824,
-0.824767529964447,
0.8551206588745117,
-0.18530382215976715,
-0.12230940908193588,
0.45270514488220215,
1.0041764974594116,
0.27132460474967957,
0.2302660495042801,
0.1232120469212532,
0.17685317993164062,
0.7273789048194885,
0.1528407335281372,
0.5830143690109253,
-0.3773992955684662,
-0.017789741978049278,
1.7011311054229736,
-0.35548684000968933,
1.1508190631866455,
0.5035029649734497,
-0.16234862804412842,
0.754399299621582,
0.25922703742980957,
0.38915255665779114,
0.4577696919441223,
0.08226685971021652,
-0.055526744574308395,
0.16253909468650818,
0.08895259350538254,
-0.6877429485321045,
0.5943273305892944,
0.6286903023719788,
-0.48543182015419006,
-0.39445915818214417,
-0.20311172306537628,
0.12300701439380646,
0.33108317852020264,
-0.39142516255378723,
0.8045458793640137,
0.28622451424598694,
-0.784672737121582,
0.6992363333702087,
0.23047055304050446,
0.6819251179695129,
-0.7606040239334106,
0.13360774517059326,
-0.1936791092157364,
0.01725510135293007,
-0.3232269585132599,
-0.5853307843208313,
0.22786757349967957,
-0.10165444016456604,
-0.3103654384613037,
-0.15683497488498688,
0.793114423751831,
-0.0543796643614769,
-0.4522036015987396,
-0.07082424312829971,
0.6161968111991882,
-0.027964530512690544,
-0.026972072198987007,
-0.4448619782924652,
0.045922499150037766,
-0.25273850560188293,
-0.398364394903183,
0.7546794414520264,
0.45799511671066284,
-0.10371106117963791,
0.4636080265045166,
0.20720627903938293,
0.0465690903365612,
-0.49828049540519714,
-0.014361136592924595,
0.8503542542457581,
-0.8301526308059692,
-0.9993215203285217,
-0.7407798767089844,
0.3170345425605774,
-0.17446888983249664,
-0.4194512367248535,
0.5721657872200012,
0.6836938858032227,
-0.09715639799833298,
0.10621124505996704,
0.8646939992904663,
0.1693776249885559,
0.8438817262649536,
-0.6070614457130432,
0.9571793079376221,
-0.14487753808498383,
0.22158801555633545,
-0.43154314160346985,
-0.9042159914970398,
-0.07901608943939209,
0.45706257224082947,
-0.3743622899055481,
-0.15130552649497986,
0.9727649092674255,
0.4329085946083069,
-0.3245837986469269,
0.11401175707578659,
0.24168524146080017,
0.295624703168869,
0.0063664792105555534,
0.5224953889846802,
0.6008445024490356,
-0.5815240740776062,
0.5435989499092102,
0.11890518665313721,
-0.06548184901475906,
-0.24449698626995087,
-1.2300080060958862,
-0.9781069159507751,
-0.6865321397781372,
-0.39179563522338867,
-0.3155157268047333,
0.45531004667282104,
0.7568070292472839,
0.5987769365310669,
-0.5582672953605652,
-0.21496689319610596,
0.2588055729866028,
0.36548498272895813,
-0.16400089859962463,
-0.1051645278930664,
0.679713785648346,
0.10548482835292816,
-0.4563032388687134,
0.5457644462585449,
0.609393835067749,
0.2526514232158661,
-0.06369420886039734,
0.03956782445311546,
-0.0500919483602047,
0.5052444338798523,
0.9960381388664246,
0.674464225769043,
-0.5075259804725647,
-0.41739627718925476,
-0.41653063893318176,
-0.09738797694444656,
0.40645137429237366,
0.8344212174415588,
-0.4818631410598755,
-0.2606925070285797,
0.407254159450531,
0.35415855050086975,
0.5346621870994568,
0.3126179277896881,
0.4596938192844391,
-0.8054625988006592,
0.13297544419765472,
0.2463304102420807,
0.35097938776016235,
0.22972647845745087,
-0.26473990082740784,
0.5511411428451538,
-0.23165380954742432,
-0.408527135848999,
-1.0755592584609985,
0.3307960331439972,
-1.5784926414489746,
-0.2834286391735077,
1.0931901931762695,
0.04784790426492691,
-0.3715188801288605,
-0.24903616309165955,
-0.41962653398513794,
0.060374289751052856,
-0.6126301288604736,
0.9168627858161926,
0.5085148215293884,
-0.1928771734237671,
-0.23570474982261658,
-0.2800765335559845,
0.7028104066848755,
0.4272269308567047,
-1.2455239295959473,
0.3600565791130066,
0.16914813220500946,
0.2226666361093521,
0.14493781328201294,
0.9436426162719727,
-0.06676080822944641,
0.30233529210090637,
-0.35886329412460327,
-0.5861595869064331,
-0.017581898719072342,
0.018764369189739227,
-0.3654237389564514,
0.5657978653907776,
0.44395291805267334,
0.2583315968513489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00632v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00632v1
|
When Quantization Affects Confidence of Large Language Models?
| 2024-05-01T16:58:28 | 2024-05-01T16:58:28 |
Irina Proskurina, Luc Brun, Guillaume Metzler, Julien Velcin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent studies introduced effective compression techniques for Large Language
Models (LLMs) via post-training quantization or low-bit weight representation.
Although quantized weights offer storage efficiency and allow for faster
inference, existing works have indicated that quantization might compromise
performance and exacerbate biases in LLMs. This study investigates the
confidence and calibration of quantized models, considering factors such as
language model type and scale as contributors to quantization loss. Firstly, we
reveal that quantization with GPTQ to 4-bit results in a decrease in confidence
regarding true labels, with varying impacts observed among different language
models. Secondly, we observe fluctuations in the impact on confidence across
different scales. Finally, we propose an explanation for quantization loss
based on confidence levels, indicating that quantization disproportionately
affects samples where the full model exhibited low confidence levels in the
first place.
|
[
-0.21407268941402435,
-0.44186922907829285,
0.675561785697937,
0.18691784143447876,
-0.08085966110229492,
-0.12527987360954285,
-0.13735227286815643,
-0.38482776284217834,
-0.19719302654266357,
0.18998880684375763,
0.10813040286302567,
-0.3639720380306244,
-0.8635120987892151,
0.06484831869602203,
-0.2966674864292145,
0.9675696492195129,
0.018864626064896584,
0.3981970250606537,
-0.3535650372505188,
-0.010346213355660439,
-0.22379396855831146,
-1.1692430973052979,
-0.5958054661750793,
-0.4042741656303406,
0.45048788189888,
-0.08984930068254471,
1.080100178718567,
0.47803038358688354,
0.3911341428756714,
0.24570533633232117,
-0.31188035011291504,
-0.5167915225028992,
-0.4835205078125,
0.11372603476047516,
0.21554386615753174,
-1.1765391826629639,
-0.41617682576179504,
0.15603193640708923,
0.908057451248169,
0.7856371998786926,
-0.38405030965805054,
0.18921855092048645,
0.11199498921632767,
0.4810984134674072,
-0.9606724977493286,
0.0892680212855339,
-0.3093944787979126,
-0.09030807763338089,
-0.03687445446848869,
-0.2174711525440216,
-0.4242601990699768,
-0.34952446818351746,
0.005577419884502888,
-0.44484826922416687,
0.008663293905556202,
-0.07653596997261047,
0.7541568279266357,
0.522912859916687,
-0.6937485337257385,
-0.027249978855252266,
-0.9615093469619751,
0.9358033537864685,
-0.8957124352455139,
0.25245174765586853,
0.6244130730628967,
-0.05307004973292351,
0.24842619895935059,
-0.40923628211021423,
-0.33537063002586365,
-0.006579608656466007,
0.060078687965869904,
-0.26546183228492737,
-0.03177500516176224,
0.4021475613117218,
0.4734576344490051,
0.6972019672393799,
-0.3026506304740906,
0.05996938422322273,
-0.058762770146131516,
-0.2777678966522217,
0.4140717685222626,
-0.09838834404945374,
0.0054311128333210945,
0.03757235407829285,
-0.009365486912429333,
-0.49988338351249695,
-0.9282732605934143,
0.042648158967494965,
0.6026946306228638,
0.06222378462553024,
0.16484832763671875,
0.5155724883079529,
-0.04181167855858803,
0.7354572415351868,
-0.017577989026904106,
-0.26831719279289246,
0.04183879494667053,
-0.2885076105594635,
-0.44577574729919434,
0.06185618042945862,
0.7865927219390869,
0.276708722114563,
0.4912796914577484,
0.09410832077264786,
-0.32421210408210754,
0.051370251923799515,
-0.07862722873687744,
-1.106499195098877,
-0.3218364715576172,
0.028659159317612648,
-0.2924122214317322,
-0.30451324582099915,
0.07165003567934036,
0.1229064017534256,
-0.4092477262020111,
-0.06342683732509613,
0.8156346678733826,
-0.32371267676353455,
-0.14303497970104218,
0.3244560658931732,
-0.06759746372699738,
0.13909779489040375,
0.3361284136772156,
-0.9115399718284607,
0.3100492060184479,
0.5690793991088867,
0.7087215185165405,
0.44415587186813354,
0.27894333004951477,
-0.38136357069015503,
0.04731769487261772,
-0.6426092386245728,
0.1861429214477539,
-0.40404725074768066,
-0.5230947732925415,
-0.025504624471068382,
-0.0800282210111618,
0.11315689235925674,
-0.4460148215293884,
0.23839448392391205,
-0.5680286884307861,
0.04931524023413658,
-0.11735609173774719,
-0.6048386693000793,
-0.14071227610111237,
0.06471609324216843,
-0.8806727528572083,
0.7543615102767944,
0.0979049801826477,
-0.7890695333480835,
0.30937960743904114,
0.29706254601478577,
-0.23064585030078888,
-0.009001925587654114,
-0.13550782203674316,
-0.4129772484302521,
0.6534315943717957,
-0.08978389203548431,
0.4095506966114044,
-0.3468087613582611,
0.215133398771286,
-0.42236587405204773,
-0.8033438324928284,
0.7819547653198242,
-0.5642091631889343,
0.6205053329467773,
-0.043672967702150345,
-0.10924549400806427,
-0.3920958936214447,
-0.5762947797775269,
0.3631826341152191,
-0.12151337414979935,
-0.47353553771972656,
-0.6484075784683228,
-0.018876835703849792,
-0.13411574065685272,
0.10191790759563446,
0.16272294521331787,
-0.375933438539505,
0.2529311180114746,
-0.25117871165275574,
0.6099855303764343,
0.5891113877296448,
0.13637109100818634,
0.4273947775363922,
-0.17613762617111206,
0.7236483693122864,
-0.1134081482887268,
-0.026699252426624298,
-0.0035587134771049023,
-0.45068255066871643,
-0.6523453593254089,
0.027853595092892647,
0.9406203031539917,
0.38831594586372375,
-0.7308598756790161,
0.1473090946674347,
-0.6387672424316406,
-0.13941708207130432,
-0.6733748316764832,
-0.21029597520828247,
0.5241081714630127,
-0.09040803462266922,
-0.10981553047895432,
-0.2049243301153183,
-0.21796944737434387,
-1.0381965637207031,
-0.3560716509819031,
-0.19192536175251007,
-0.5206397175788879,
-0.14084459841251373,
0.4894774258136749,
0.05905852094292641,
0.8855502605438232,
-0.4153750538825989,
-0.057555247098207474,
0.13149233162403107,
0.507619321346283,
-0.04776795953512192,
0.5299614667892456,
0.3420969247817993,
-0.713834822177887,
-0.37344813346862793,
-0.2994881570339203,
-0.13646665215492249,
0.0426950603723526,
0.05573055520653725,
0.26794707775115967,
0.34095486998558044,
0.3914465606212616,
-0.6332245469093323,
0.6314296722412109,
1.038804531097412,
-0.049348827451467514,
0.4964160621166229,
-0.20577587187290192,
0.35280993580818176,
-0.9257084131240845,
-0.24500353634357452,
0.24127978086471558,
-0.38491782546043396,
-0.540335476398468,
-0.01704581454396248,
0.2707614600658417,
0.09748581796884537,
-0.2511157989501953,
0.18266575038433075,
-0.2967783808708191,
-0.1750980168581009,
-0.1063549593091011,
-0.04248734936118126,
0.4376271367073059,
0.2178787887096405,
0.14109696447849274,
1.0295103788375854,
0.36198970675468445,
-0.48860836029052734,
-0.09205508232116699,
-0.09783253818750381,
-0.4912634491920471,
0.3935873210430145,
-0.8502111434936523,
0.08396086096763611,
0.007990832440555096,
0.3873824179172516,
-0.9466732740402222,
-0.1542397439479828,
-0.22510460019111633,
-0.5579954981803894,
0.6317789554595947,
-0.3858790993690491,
-0.872433066368103,
-0.15125924348831177,
-0.5835829973220825,
0.5530087351799011,
0.5059581995010376,
-0.09648679941892624,
0.06895478814840317,
0.1910298466682434,
0.05947205051779747,
-0.2626577913761139,
-1.306046962738037,
0.01968495547771454,
-0.19414721429347992,
-0.47520455718040466,
0.3429206907749176,
-0.23816372454166412,
-0.42183226346969604,
-0.2277064472436905,
-0.38607290387153625,
-0.26505959033966064,
0.09976118803024292,
0.24900637567043304,
-0.004746661055833101,
-0.05686734616756439,
0.5454150438308716,
-0.11463302373886108,
0.11779740452766418,
0.2342594712972641,
-0.3411966860294342,
0.4490879476070404,
-0.35092565417289734,
-0.033974383026361465,
-0.4907838702201843,
0.05400548502802849,
0.3109495937824249,
-0.09414266794919968,
1.244232416152954,
0.44488778710365295,
-0.2811594307422638,
0.0862974300980568,
-0.5153594017028809,
-0.32973331212997437,
-0.45441558957099915,
0.2937277555465698,
-0.4767731726169586,
-1.198748230934143,
0.35536471009254456,
0.060503095388412476,
-0.6337549686431885,
0.3108368515968323,
0.5880804061889648,
-0.17025327682495117,
1.2733594179153442,
0.8145813345909119,
0.008402674458920956,
0.3759639859199524,
-0.1314394474029541,
0.3185689449310303,
-0.8977487087249756,
0.15875709056854248,
-0.7159423828125,
-0.25518929958343506,
-1.0172498226165771,
-0.650696337223053,
0.3132971227169037,
0.3260214626789093,
-0.3732379078865051,
-0.02334892563521862,
-0.423289030790329,
0.4907152056694031,
0.5496712923049927,
0.07275466620922089,
0.3700959384441376,
-0.08979728072881699,
0.4762573540210724,
-0.16045759618282318,
-0.7356308698654175,
-0.5360803008079529,
1.2163194417953491,
0.5009638071060181,
1.1429522037506104,
0.28087159991264343,
0.5949539542198181,
0.167878195643425,
0.2805670201778412,
-0.9704870581626892,
0.17159920930862427,
-0.005396671127527952,
-0.6479947566986084,
-0.4730462431907654,
-0.810340940952301,
-0.7687521576881409,
0.11290513724088669,
-0.1247510015964508,
-0.6587235927581787,
0.3537692427635193,
0.2567828893661499,
-0.7317542433738708,
0.02905626781284809,
-0.7515580654144287,
0.6996611952781677,
0.0929713249206543,
-0.04658891260623932,
-0.028686964884400368,
-0.6325992345809937,
0.6220686435699463,
-0.30209434032440186,
0.41137000918388367,
0.010668938048183918,
-0.25598180294036865,
0.8025173544883728,
-0.6427769064903259,
0.9303339123725891,
0.1388506442308426,
-0.5527275800704956,
0.2519576847553253,
0.2652767598628998,
0.5329111814498901,
0.17745842039585114,
-0.0694313570857048,
0.39960452914237976,
0.3969307541847229,
-0.47877708077430725,
-0.6987090706825256,
0.5319317579269409,
-0.7108297944068909,
-0.5954124331474304,
-0.39447593688964844,
-0.6103483438491821,
-0.32795825600624084,
-0.3130328953266144,
0.5424947738647461,
0.39133745431900024,
0.32747653126716614,
0.47761398553848267,
1.0806479454040527,
-0.37181490659713745,
0.28622251749038696,
0.2511778175830841,
0.012735684402287006,
-0.39262792468070984,
0.5892975926399231,
0.389478862285614,
0.8336515426635742,
0.49391064047813416,
0.16738256812095642,
-0.11663834005594254,
-0.3565441370010376,
0.10022836178541183,
0.27610281109809875,
-0.717064619064331,
-0.4071098864078522,
-0.06916606426239014,
-0.15635932981967926,
-0.7373059391975403,
0.19531938433647156,
-0.40002116560935974,
-0.7798199653625488,
-0.2707628905773163,
-0.0749625414609909,
0.3315383195877075,
0.6555638909339905,
0.1634623259305954,
0.8827046751976013,
-0.7629229426383972,
-0.15293462574481964,
0.42315778136253357,
0.4509316384792328,
-0.2178419828414917,
-0.778513491153717,
-0.6398143768310547,
0.19385233521461487,
0.029632627964019775,
-0.876839280128479,
0.17210768163204193,
0.27182164788246155,
-0.051853325217962265,
0.44411948323249817,
-0.13516391813755035,
0.5489448308944702,
-0.33090102672576904,
0.8396525979042053,
0.12210217118263245,
-1.182811975479126,
0.18503762781620026,
-0.18911436200141907,
0.6252993941307068,
0.4233011305332184,
0.5386766791343689,
-0.6258147358894348,
-0.21968424320220947,
-0.5612640976905823,
-0.6572273373603821,
0.49704551696777344,
0.03357384726405144,
0.21233496069908142,
0.0052151912823319435,
0.4737186133861542,
-0.30725082755088806,
0.6193217635154724,
-1.0601115226745605,
-0.2430942803621292,
-0.05936199054121971,
-0.046528082340955734,
-0.25162068009376526,
-0.7480067610740662,
-0.002059301594272256,
-0.07924900949001312,
0.5254843235015869,
0.021681951358914375,
0.13548941910266876,
0.012303153052926064,
-0.11286643892526627,
-0.178426593542099,
0.3421906530857086,
0.49526214599609375,
0.2645348608493805,
-0.2150053083896637,
0.2114211767911911,
-0.14528103172779083,
-0.3816249966621399,
0.3067442774772644,
-0.17284752428531647,
-0.21887901425361633,
-0.0963413417339325,
0.5658589601516724,
0.9468100666999817,
0.5395901799201965,
-0.3766036331653595,
0.6697427034378052,
-0.07735981792211533,
-0.340310662984848,
-0.1481810361146927,
-0.13506561517715454,
-0.03888217732310295,
-0.006230797152966261,
0.2793288230895996,
-0.17063702642917633,
0.17717178165912628,
-0.5998989343643188,
-0.17878082394599915,
0.6139515042304993,
-0.10991562902927399,
-0.25614866614341736,
0.6699026823043823,
-0.16227376461029053,
-0.0765252485871315,
0.5413557291030884,
-0.1096307635307312,
-0.46253323554992676,
0.49239882826805115,
0.244766965508461,
0.5729823112487793,
-0.6169041991233826,
0.14644712209701538,
0.2943774163722992,
0.49409225583076477,
-0.4874493479728699,
-0.1149335503578186,
-0.010316015221178532,
-0.6252114176750183,
-1.0436164140701294,
-0.7326505780220032,
-0.4060315787792206,
0.1217319443821907,
-0.8070903420448303,
-0.11307421326637268,
-0.315828800201416,
-0.7405537366867065,
-0.473911851644516,
0.08285927027463913,
-0.4566783010959625,
0.42079734802246094,
0.5139192938804626,
0.6486660838127136,
-0.8170270919799805,
0.8987725973129272,
0.439321905374527,
-0.3991837501525879,
-1.203497290611267,
0.04777996987104416,
-0.17668846249580383,
-0.4824686050415039,
0.8239462375640869,
0.05804010480642319,
-0.058307334780693054,
0.40284019708633423,
-0.6325082778930664,
-1.2558434009552002,
0.9386634230613708,
0.45726293325424194,
-0.557404100894928,
-0.13257868587970734,
0.4607987105846405,
0.7151090502738953,
0.13196119666099548,
0.24765242636203766,
0.6949925422668457,
0.4440905749797821,
0.1370941698551178,
-1.0760165452957153,
-0.03580582141876221,
0.23680905997753143,
0.48308509588241577,
0.4877861738204956,
-0.48718905448913574,
1.125691533088684,
0.0758294090628624,
-0.31703004240989685,
0.15769344568252563,
0.29990991950035095,
0.04833127558231354,
-0.21673782169818878,
0.19153662025928497,
0.7420114278793335,
0.5990469455718994,
-0.2563900649547577,
1.4504072666168213,
-0.37403160333633423,
0.5464752316474915,
0.843696117401123,
0.020563574507832527,
0.828697919845581,
0.537476122379303,
-0.5537234544754028,
0.3298819959163666,
0.7635209560394287,
0.22460436820983887,
0.300899475812912,
0.7071540355682373,
-0.31036150455474854,
-0.265434592962265,
-0.06596890836954117,
-0.24839180707931519,
0.21780239045619965,
0.4544357359409332,
-0.16408605873584747,
0.1781490296125412,
0.16504891216754913,
0.18105541169643402,
-0.19051870703697205,
-0.6036962270736694,
0.3386293649673462,
0.32338595390319824,
-0.3742406666278839,
0.9482799768447876,
0.08059284836053848,
0.6460599899291992,
-0.5183531641960144,
0.23486283421516418,
-0.20357157289981842,
-0.06959393620491028,
-0.17314623296260834,
-0.5955340266227722,
-0.011859157122671604,
-0.3629380166530609,
-0.102204330265522,
-0.39344602823257446,
0.2492063194513321,
-0.5796169638633728,
-0.4098438024520874,
-0.09006825089454651,
0.3839787542819977,
0.21672025322914124,
-0.69362473487854,
-0.20656847953796387,
0.3745492398738861,
-0.11282671988010406,
-0.7251095175743103,
0.5753239989280701,
0.7047399878501892,
-0.1309543251991272,
0.7202088832855225,
0.34357157349586487,
0.23202191293239594,
-0.03685618191957474,
0.10498117655515671,
0.53046715259552,
-0.42284703254699707,
-0.15442053973674774,
-0.9000019431114197,
0.15979743003845215,
0.22960783541202545,
0.12542840838432312,
0.8681000471115112,
0.3623300790786743,
0.7973530888557434,
-0.06276891380548477,
0.538117527961731,
0.23305697739124298,
0.10770545899868011,
-0.5687040686607361,
0.6913363337516785,
-0.5131432414054871,
0.34162572026252747,
-0.13917453587055206,
-1.0252764225006104,
-0.5454562306404114,
0.609648585319519,
-0.50187087059021,
0.37517261505126953,
0.7867798209190369,
0.4362371861934662,
0.6574174165725708,
-0.533275842666626,
0.7471323609352112,
0.3712506592273712,
0.12187258899211884,
0.5683143138885498,
0.46759364008903503,
-0.5106329321861267,
0.6400198936462402,
-0.3493538200855255,
-0.16662529110908508,
-0.16906136274337769,
-0.8924475908279419,
-0.6831185221672058,
-0.5997074842453003,
-0.5134329199790955,
-0.3007393777370453,
-0.09809307754039764,
0.2923487424850464,
0.9043264985084534,
-0.4727250635623932,
-0.10684064775705338,
-0.029136650264263153,
-0.05198987200856209,
0.22118498384952545,
-0.26649507880210876,
0.2996506690979004,
-0.1467169225215912,
-0.8681814074516296,
-0.14387986063957214,
0.13687308132648468,
0.5540536642074585,
-0.41912105679512024,
0.11080948263406754,
0.23519444465637207,
0.22545482218265533,
0.5667209625244141,
-0.012979252263903618,
-0.5405830144882202,
-0.3212493658065796,
-0.2325831651687622,
-0.3753378391265869,
-0.011440171860158443,
0.7953650951385498,
-0.9522339105606079,
0.14858253300189972,
0.14970572292804718,
0.3696710765361786,
0.48906639218330383,
0.24486763775348663,
0.6657260656356812,
-1.0931918621063232,
0.2600666284561157,
0.20762565732002258,
0.19060717523097992,
0.4579659104347229,
-0.4514243006706238,
0.45093807578086853,
0.18939732015132904,
-0.8132521510124207,
-0.8857395052909851,
0.1737748086452484,
-0.506429135799408,
-0.3391241729259491,
1.1828360557556152,
-0.05843218043446541,
-0.2289504110813141,
0.42946547269821167,
0.07131368666887283,
0.17581719160079956,
-0.23958438634872437,
0.5726116299629211,
1.2930866479873657,
0.11774782836437225,
-0.4318675994873047,
-0.7936842441558838,
0.7231742143630981,
0.45782148838043213,
-0.3871365189552307,
0.12413469702005386,
0.5180978775024414,
0.16985058784484863,
0.10511213541030884,
0.49417877197265625,
0.11072199046611786,
0.0387040413916111,
0.042150311172008514,
0.3650266230106354,
0.46310073137283325,
0.13472454249858856,
-0.8174288868904114,
0.022050095722079277,
0.5369647741317749,
0.09672016650438309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00622v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00622v1
|
Causal Evaluation of Language Models
| 2024-05-01T16:43:21 | 2024-05-01T16:43:21 |
Sirui Chen, Bo Peng, Meiqi Chen, Ruiqi Wang, Mengying Xu, Xingyu Zeng, Rui Zhao, Shengjie Zhao, Yu Qiao, Chaochao Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Causal reasoning is viewed as crucial for achieving human-level machine
intelligence. Recent advances in language models have expanded the horizons of
artificial intelligence across various domains, sparking inquiries into their
potential for causal reasoning. In this work, we introduce Causal evaluation of
Language Models (CaLM), which, to the best of our knowledge, is the first
comprehensive benchmark for evaluating the causal reasoning capabilities of
language models. First, we propose the CaLM framework, which establishes a
foundational taxonomy consisting of four modules: causal target (i.e., what to
evaluate), adaptation (i.e., how to obtain the results), metric (i.e., how to
measure the results), and error (i.e., how to analyze the bad results). This
taxonomy defines a broad evaluation design space while systematically selecting
criteria and priorities. Second, we compose the CaLM dataset, comprising
126,334 data samples, to provide curated sets of causal targets, adaptations,
metrics, and errors, offering extensive coverage for diverse research pursuits.
Third, we conduct an extensive evaluation of 28 leading language models on a
core set of 92 causal targets, 9 adaptations, 7 metrics, and 12 error types.
Fourth, we perform detailed analyses of the evaluation results across various
dimensions (e.g., adaptation, scale). Fifth, we present 50 high-level empirical
findings across 9 dimensions (e.g., model), providing valuable guidance for
future language model development. Finally, we develop a multifaceted platform,
including a website, leaderboards, datasets, and toolkits, to support scalable
and adaptable assessments. We envision CaLM as an ever-evolving benchmark for
the community, systematically updated with new causal targets, adaptations,
models, metrics, and error types to reflect ongoing research advancements.
Project website is at https://opencausalab.github.io/CaLM.
|
[
-0.16049964725971222,
-0.8522710800170898,
0.49018433690071106,
0.6302430033683777,
0.12183269113302231,
-0.226125106215477,
-0.5531291961669922,
-0.3226860761642456,
-0.3716266453266144,
0.05809780955314636,
-0.3801412880420685,
-0.4634643495082855,
-0.44493764638900757,
-0.010513448156416416,
-0.48715946078300476,
0.7451679110527039,
0.005679984577000141,
0.0023508877493441105,
0.00747206574305892,
-0.10528948158025742,
-0.6229373812675476,
-0.2860943675041199,
-0.9610029458999634,
-0.4452268183231354,
0.6959493160247803,
0.31891515851020813,
0.753503143787384,
0.6014736890792847,
0.6353752017021179,
0.3419978618621826,
0.1572778820991516,
-0.38009870052337646,
-0.6533298492431641,
0.0239697452634573,
-0.5358896851539612,
-0.19457535445690155,
-0.36700525879859924,
0.12804938852787018,
0.7045918107032776,
0.8369901180267334,
-0.13908693194389343,
0.21658796072006226,
-0.16929377615451813,
0.4304276704788208,
-0.9326313138008118,
0.33943644165992737,
-0.519982635974884,
-0.23293055593967438,
-0.10819221287965775,
-0.07224784791469574,
-0.6669963002204895,
-0.4456227719783783,
0.07847147434949875,
-0.44269105792045593,
-0.17179009318351746,
0.17456528544425964,
0.7211977243423462,
0.4029383957386017,
-0.6310144066810608,
-0.06438969820737839,
-0.9134999513626099,
0.952800989151001,
-0.8468700647354126,
0.4693247377872467,
0.3597131669521332,
0.2608795762062073,
-0.42959898710250854,
-0.7510228753089905,
-0.46031633019447327,
-0.39846256375312805,
0.21993885934352875,
0.33357998728752136,
-0.5359886288642883,
-0.16325734555721283,
0.25786155462265015,
0.10482563823461533,
-0.609727144241333,
0.3607105314731598,
-0.10686726123094559,
-0.18055205047130585,
0.7854277491569519,
0.44123604893684387,
0.4469545781612396,
0.17766880989074707,
-0.3438344895839691,
-0.0017907157307490706,
-0.3744666576385498,
0.08696896582841873,
0.1324288547039032,
0.5002954602241516,
-0.23256175220012665,
0.2050071507692337,
-0.40460288524627686,
0.6483938694000244,
-0.04062272235751152,
-0.20702891051769257,
-0.13438881933689117,
-0.2823590934276581,
-0.2738051414489746,
-0.11612636595964432,
0.9205633401870728,
0.35376450419425964,
0.06431231647729874,
-0.29347777366638184,
-0.15624813735485077,
0.23115338385105133,
0.2735694646835327,
-0.6184982657432556,
-0.12243500351905823,
0.2504466474056244,
-0.2664574384689331,
-0.18700413405895233,
-0.23371285200119019,
-0.7265303730964661,
-0.41712677478790283,
-0.5503194332122803,
0.4131259024143219,
-0.21935006976127625,
-0.38101571798324585,
0.3898635804653168,
0.10510069131851196,
0.185831680893898,
0.33552801609039307,
-0.5853193998336792,
0.6017563939094543,
0.74783855676651,
0.4177962839603424,
-0.07687020301818848,
-0.5749025940895081,
-0.17079003155231476,
-0.06084079667925835,
-0.5295864343643188,
1.029211401939392,
-0.5256867408752441,
-0.21624772250652313,
0.1883223056793213,
-0.16835075616836548,
-0.3289538323879242,
-0.1844232976436615,
1.1794800758361816,
-0.4183695912361145,
0.17146025598049164,
-0.3410608172416687,
-0.5473548173904419,
-0.32226288318634033,
-0.04389512538909912,
-0.6026612520217896,
1.0236139297485352,
0.00965120643377304,
-0.7356398701667786,
0.4688512682914734,
-0.3135388195514679,
-0.563802182674408,
-0.08717834204435349,
0.13795898854732513,
-0.2271864414215088,
0.15373583137989044,
-0.10798158496618271,
0.2108813226222992,
-1.1895320415496826,
0.9990522861480713,
-0.6543462872505188,
-0.3121962249279022,
0.3910304605960846,
-0.4609110355377197,
1.0509034395217896,
0.27106961607933044,
-0.5832338929176331,
0.3406011760234833,
-0.8333560228347778,
-0.003939630929380655,
-0.01979711465537548,
-0.3143112063407898,
-0.2987495958805084,
0.3337761163711548,
0.005479907616972923,
0.5076111555099487,
0.048983726650476456,
-0.19285249710083008,
-0.10589184612035751,
0.004536688327789307,
0.18779271841049194,
0.7162702083587646,
0.13911990821361542,
0.22115352749824524,
-0.1907408982515335,
0.384359747171402,
-0.029794739559292793,
0.5076518058776855,
0.05110706016421318,
-0.44554904103279114,
-0.9463623762130737,
-0.32410335540771484,
-0.06400629878044128,
0.6612568497657776,
-0.3182840347290039,
0.5033249855041504,
-0.217174232006073,
-0.7897595167160034,
-0.4079791307449341,
0.017753779888153076,
0.584899365901947,
0.7630009651184082,
0.1916412115097046,
-0.2917977571487427,
-0.30201494693756104,
-0.8459744453430176,
-0.5962552428245544,
-0.5998131632804871,
0.17045490443706512,
0.1236068457365036,
0.4389459490776062,
-0.26653215289115906,
0.8012462258338928,
-0.31518322229385376,
0.24125398695468903,
0.07173769176006317,
0.5529565811157227,
0.16490328311920166,
0.49170368909835815,
0.4467158019542694,
-0.404479056596756,
-0.05029628053307533,
-0.14115314185619354,
-0.8483998775482178,
-0.47592297196388245,
-0.17731691896915436,
-0.3888254463672638,
-0.11485915631055832,
0.6365833878517151,
-0.4737696051597595,
0.28607746958732605,
0.2303599715232849,
-0.5861421823501587,
0.8141019344329834,
0.11626888811588287,
0.34506458044052124,
-0.6919618844985962,
0.5394047498703003,
0.10645810514688492,
0.3073205053806305,
-0.8408752083778381,
0.1254071742296219,
-0.10895507782697678,
-0.26554200053215027,
-0.3102076053619385,
0.8984841704368591,
-0.046810083091259,
0.2846594750881195,
-0.049478188157081604,
0.18435853719711304,
-0.16647914052009583,
0.5816054940223694,
-0.25005725026130676,
0.3262884020805359,
0.6995371580123901,
-0.522479772567749,
0.17395125329494476,
-0.21924813091754913,
-0.4322555959224701,
0.533304750919342,
-0.7033780813217163,
0.15847371518611908,
0.05994049832224846,
-0.04579133540391922,
-0.8223311901092529,
-0.23904912173748016,
0.14423500001430511,
-0.2278241217136383,
0.22307483851909637,
0.2595707178115845,
-0.5685784816741943,
-0.4255636930465698,
-0.057000331580638885,
0.34682533144950867,
0.3167143166065216,
-0.30667930841445923,
0.3807145953178406,
0.5128445625305176,
-0.17381185293197632,
-0.4804621934890747,
-0.45149993896484375,
0.014546954073011875,
-0.34022513031959534,
-0.4703807532787323,
-0.08099820464849472,
-0.20382142066955566,
-0.7564978003501892,
0.11342532932758331,
-0.01759476400911808,
-0.3407747149467468,
0.5187308192253113,
0.23176977038383484,
0.11220388114452362,
-0.36535462737083435,
0.2839268445968628,
-0.05102020874619484,
-0.25363391637802124,
0.3404037058353424,
-0.24477894604206085,
0.09253662079572678,
-0.4268845021724701,
-0.37082698941230774,
-0.47767648100852966,
0.23415511846542358,
0.6633197069168091,
-0.2941076457500458,
0.7607604265213013,
0.6269451379776001,
-0.6110008358955383,
-0.0976138710975647,
-0.5344557166099548,
-0.13517053425312042,
-0.3445809483528137,
0.22063048183918,
-0.26113712787628174,
-0.8975658416748047,
0.6089260578155518,
-0.35116714239120483,
-0.08093944191932678,
0.6031181216239929,
0.8316465020179749,
0.32636362314224243,
1.130223274230957,
0.6184626221656799,
-0.42499518394470215,
0.25707319378852844,
0.47347527742385864,
0.5486863851547241,
-0.47764700651168823,
-0.1871752142906189,
-1.0690112113952637,
0.0639418214559555,
-0.5150983333587646,
-0.46054086089134216,
0.06835232675075531,
0.5563955903053284,
-0.6528708338737488,
0.17875492572784424,
0.036146968603134155,
0.15366917848587036,
0.3103516101837158,
-0.10614175349473953,
0.18918462097644806,
-0.3852344751358032,
-0.2398056834936142,
0.050395481288433075,
-0.7368173003196716,
-0.5880876779556274,
0.8108598589897156,
0.3620411157608032,
0.813863217830658,
0.30493244528770447,
0.17610250413417816,
0.17162753641605377,
0.7152372002601624,
-0.6877635717391968,
0.6035251021385193,
0.12297625839710236,
-0.8968212604522705,
-0.30635157227516174,
-0.5131972432136536,
-0.8876567482948303,
0.1299976259469986,
-0.09969235211610794,
-0.9515774250030518,
0.3814845681190491,
0.012405360117554665,
-0.06533677130937576,
-0.08671996742486954,
-0.8077089786529541,
1.11397385597229,
-0.20365849137306213,
-0.6831274628639221,
-0.43214401602745056,
-0.5833536386489868,
0.841424286365509,
-0.35958001017570496,
0.402919739484787,
-0.4468424916267395,
0.20980925858020782,
0.7029467821121216,
-0.2010572850704193,
0.933196485042572,
0.023134004324674606,
-0.017306115478277206,
0.39776110649108887,
0.15539774298667908,
0.008769482374191284,
-0.11654520779848099,
-0.5312510132789612,
0.24479438364505768,
-0.22819927334785461,
-0.4430124759674072,
-0.7125571966171265,
0.8903966546058655,
-0.8031728267669678,
-0.604368269443512,
-0.34009477496147156,
-0.6618618965148926,
-0.30154427886009216,
0.37746161222457886,
-0.35533004999160767,
0.5978302359580994,
-0.49066317081451416,
-0.08958753943443298,
0.2697119414806366,
-0.45287978649139404,
0.30697065591812134,
1.0637339353561401,
-0.3562566041946411,
-0.23389817774295807,
0.8856591582298279,
-0.2803770899772644,
0.21978580951690674,
0.3789038062095642,
0.5186131596565247,
-0.2618216574192047,
-0.2615028917789459,
0.03362464904785156,
0.07476308196783066,
-1.0163859128952026,
-0.1363484263420105,
-0.37597647309303284,
0.10864712297916412,
-0.5504979491233826,
-0.18349510431289673,
-0.2292054444551468,
-0.29109999537467957,
-0.044865209609270096,
0.056109704077243805,
0.2166389524936676,
0.565007746219635,
-0.21817301213741302,
0.05001068115234375,
-0.3619632124900818,
0.07269702851772308,
0.2720930874347687,
0.3838861584663391,
0.1972167193889618,
-0.47321000695228577,
-0.3419913351535797,
-0.37882083654403687,
-0.05441823974251747,
-0.8678253889083862,
0.1735375076532364,
0.15012630820274353,
0.8693185448646545,
0.6665096879005432,
0.2038765549659729,
0.8454645872116089,
-0.5298358798027039,
0.5504819750785828,
0.06409282237291336,
-1.1061253547668457,
0.6663678884506226,
-0.4688745439052582,
0.5475289225578308,
0.7686766982078552,
0.4494436979293823,
-0.39581161737442017,
-0.6355111598968506,
-0.5615203380584717,
-0.7392920255661011,
0.4907597005367279,
-0.004571698606014252,
-0.2586521506309509,
-0.2984329164028168,
0.4086274206638336,
-0.16610004007816315,
-0.056415144354104996,
-0.5244550704956055,
-0.1428036242723465,
0.1374405026435852,
-0.11214442551136017,
-0.3206276297569275,
-0.12773214280605316,
-0.1536860167980194,
-0.3590756952762604,
0.7596700191497803,
-0.06836597621440887,
0.16217443346977234,
-0.05889458954334259,
-0.1517314314842224,
-0.3729005753993988,
0.4043720066547394,
0.6134154200553894,
0.7479251027107239,
-0.17085163295269012,
0.3570508360862732,
0.08822202682495117,
-0.19719219207763672,
0.1126803308725357,
0.30361539125442505,
-0.19338344037532806,
-0.2447386085987091,
0.7847772836685181,
0.8417568206787109,
0.8425412774085999,
-0.7710016965866089,
0.20983651280403137,
-0.22577491402626038,
0.4138082265853882,
0.11200527101755142,
-0.07279844582080841,
-0.08630447834730148,
0.13006503880023956,
0.0013165924465283751,
0.12492598593235016,
0.25471991300582886,
-0.5892210602760315,
0.2706385850906372,
-0.0010540568036958575,
-0.6357386708259583,
-0.5551773905754089,
0.6874464750289917,
0.1276618242263794,
-0.17282994091510773,
0.6136699318885803,
-0.18583209812641144,
-0.41786065697669983,
0.47160202264785767,
0.6684881448745728,
1.1889196634292603,
-0.7145230174064636,
0.21472950279712677,
0.7282059788703918,
0.7532438039779663,
-0.05459311977028847,
0.5105078220367432,
0.1667925864458084,
-0.697900652885437,
-0.3836042582988739,
-0.7486231923103333,
-0.38057610392570496,
-0.08648590743541718,
-0.8413376212120056,
0.3448934555053711,
-0.41524723172187805,
-0.2299693077802658,
-0.04577053710818291,
-0.028486570343375206,
-0.7489790916442871,
0.3175774812698364,
0.00967781525105238,
1.0515954494476318,
-1.1351133584976196,
0.8370518684387207,
0.564856231212616,
-0.49715882539749146,
-0.9795570969581604,
-0.04966504126787186,
0.40369805693626404,
-0.594912052154541,
0.7424120306968689,
-0.024405203759670258,
-0.3256627917289734,
-0.1460801661014557,
-0.5196170210838318,
-0.8510139584541321,
0.8100374937057495,
0.5526157021522522,
-0.3854643702507019,
0.594878077507019,
0.021663451567292213,
0.7778493165969849,
-0.24417941272258759,
0.330584317445755,
0.7209819555282593,
0.6696441769599915,
-0.15576918423175812,
-0.7836697101593018,
0.32971858978271484,
-0.5359077453613281,
-0.14954881370067596,
-0.059853240847587585,
-0.5106386542320251,
0.8234040141105652,
-0.2338016778230667,
-0.298392653465271,
-0.0733863115310669,
0.6039769649505615,
0.29025712609291077,
0.2959683835506439,
0.31105828285217285,
0.6736072301864624,
0.8403989672660828,
-0.20575019717216492,
1.4455820322036743,
-0.4988066256046295,
0.3346996307373047,
1.3364553451538086,
-0.6473529934883118,
0.9863957166671753,
0.245095357298851,
-0.08483818173408508,
0.46210283041000366,
0.5593850612640381,
0.35104846954345703,
0.3571479618549347,
0.33686357736587524,
-0.3506178557872772,
-0.25790712237358093,
-0.6111364960670471,
-0.042310021817684174,
0.35445651412010193,
0.4778427481651306,
0.029821882024407387,
-0.2842954695224762,
-0.2717299163341522,
0.3354450464248657,
0.07013574987649918,
-0.24293439090251923,
0.49009111523628235,
0.12195499986410141,
-0.8915709853172302,
0.3709401488304138,
0.2236907184123993,
-0.1462637335062027,
-0.5902159810066223,
0.2573462426662445,
-0.3943171799182892,
0.3726238012313843,
0.020812133327126503,
-0.5014464855194092,
0.19669209420681,
0.09135220944881439,
-0.025483902543783188,
-0.10283879190683365,
0.9097777605056763,
-0.24812939763069153,
-0.5879850387573242,
0.5828925371170044,
0.438775897026062,
0.16315874457359314,
0.28765004873275757,
-0.8755614757537842,
0.5358028411865234,
-0.42220538854599,
-0.20243079960346222,
0.12173492461442947,
0.5768120884895325,
-0.40469202399253845,
0.8185346126556396,
0.5503115653991699,
-0.11790803074836731,
0.10945753753185272,
0.6339062452316284,
0.8242758512496948,
-0.7550563812255859,
-0.2596144676208496,
-0.7537004947662354,
0.639228343963623,
0.2039259523153305,
-0.6576318740844727,
0.8318270444869995,
0.3806392252445221,
0.4808911681175232,
0.11802864819765091,
0.5281027555465698,
-0.010852417908608913,
0.21279343962669373,
-0.3573458194732666,
0.5782784819602966,
-0.39425739645957947,
0.0629347413778305,
-0.5669552087783813,
-0.6593069434165955,
-0.6362063884735107,
0.41220328211784363,
-0.6154462695121765,
-0.00947166420519352,
0.876609206199646,
0.7245371341705322,
0.30035245418548584,
0.07049988955259323,
0.31972700357437134,
0.5503292679786682,
0.30790644884109497,
0.4439474940299988,
0.9996204972267151,
-0.30542445182800293,
0.021178165450692177,
-0.2272944450378418,
-0.542194128036499,
-0.1925487220287323,
-1.098862886428833,
-0.8853216171264648,
-0.6324002742767334,
-0.6850130558013916,
-0.10342679917812347,
0.09924018383026123,
0.5730576515197754,
0.5901374816894531,
-0.9304038286209106,
-0.5714477300643921,
-0.029207836836576462,
0.32112258672714233,
-0.4015575349330902,
-0.2583284378051758,
0.3023511469364166,
-0.5807809233665466,
-0.36539196968078613,
0.52149897813797,
0.6677695512771606,
-0.488383948802948,
-0.2805819511413574,
-0.14265751838684082,
-0.4588607847690582,
0.35504502058029175,
0.6703014373779297,
0.5146003365516663,
-0.8544822335243225,
-0.3982822299003601,
-0.1854422390460968,
-0.3088977038860321,
-0.49519112706184387,
0.9719759225845337,
-0.4110991060733795,
0.6469594240188599,
0.3772295415401459,
0.6200180649757385,
0.03711975738406181,
-0.3870481550693512,
0.7030582427978516,
-0.13931238651275635,
0.37877196073532104,
0.128325954079628,
0.48848757147789,
0.19494891166687012,
-0.031642813235521317,
0.48007863759994507,
0.11337430030107498,
-0.6659376621246338,
-0.9199127554893494,
0.1970384567975998,
-0.9577789902687073,
-0.21155251562595367,
0.8803514242172241,
-0.35873162746429443,
-0.12934918701648712,
-0.24470411241054535,
0.10062824189662933,
0.35883569717407227,
-0.15080367028713226,
0.9345206618309021,
0.7107408046722412,
-0.12208671122789383,
-0.08360474556684494,
-0.6259533166885376,
0.35297727584838867,
0.42816007137298584,
-1.118950366973877,
0.10890863835811615,
0.620847761631012,
-0.038895830512046814,
0.046968795359134674,
0.533317506313324,
-0.24893231689929962,
0.2994423806667328,
0.2608913779258728,
0.2072797417640686,
0.6099523901939392,
-0.38025715947151184,
-0.6368409991264343,
-0.008376315236091614,
0.30911895632743835,
0.5568149089813232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00611v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00611v1
|
Addressing Topic Granularity and Hallucination in Large Language Models for Topic Modelling
| 2024-05-01T16:32:07 | 2024-05-01T16:32:07 |
Yida Mu, Peizhen Bai, Kalina Bontcheva, Xingyi Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) with their strong zero-shot topic extraction
capabilities offer an alternative to probabilistic topic modelling and
closed-set topic classification approaches. As zero-shot topic extractors, LLMs
are expected to understand human instructions to generate relevant and
non-hallucinated topics based on the given documents. However, LLM-based topic
modelling approaches often face difficulties in generating topics with
adherence to granularity as specified in human instructions, often resulting in
many near-duplicate topics. Furthermore, methods for addressing hallucinated
topics generated by LLMs have not yet been investigated. In this paper, we
focus on addressing the issues of topic granularity and hallucinations for
better LLM-based topic modelling. To this end, we introduce a novel approach
that leverages Direct Preference Optimisation (DPO) to fine-tune open-source
LLMs, such as Mistral-7B. Our approach does not rely on traditional human
annotation to rank preferred answers but employs a reconstruction pipeline to
modify raw topics generated by LLMs, thus enabling a fast and efficient
training and inference framework. Comparative experiments show that our
fine-tuning approach not only significantly improves the LLM's capability to
produce more coherent, relevant, and precise topics, but also reduces the
number of hallucinated topics.
|
[
-0.7027754187583923,
-1.0570863485336304,
0.6511019468307495,
-0.026290642097592354,
-0.44433334469795227,
-0.35935071110725403,
-0.4278244376182556,
-0.15998513996601105,
0.3333076238632202,
0.9326556324958801,
-0.45050048828125,
-0.6082184314727783,
-0.6199011206626892,
-0.009832106530666351,
-0.2729129493236542,
0.766208827495575,
0.16705399751663208,
-0.07037955522537231,
-0.20456604659557343,
0.24683284759521484,
-0.5010197162628174,
-0.6584837436676025,
-0.49386563897132874,
-0.37368595600128174,
0.49807655811309814,
0.36441290378570557,
0.6978861689567566,
0.644404947757721,
0.4600389897823334,
0.18459902703762054,
-0.5394207239151001,
0.3470769226551056,
-0.7939710021018982,
0.24579307436943054,
-0.3229725956916809,
-0.17016546428203583,
-0.6254046559333801,
-0.2616177499294281,
0.35388997197151184,
0.8785959482192993,
-0.01363531406968832,
-0.07960455119609833,
0.0617048554122448,
0.5164910554885864,
-0.5191168785095215,
0.03105579875409603,
-1.109863042831421,
-0.07247307151556015,
-0.07905450463294983,
-0.5036913752555847,
-0.3049321174621582,
-0.10166491568088531,
-0.030574046075344086,
-0.33964797854423523,
0.517565131187439,
-0.20069268345832825,
0.7944462299346924,
0.4477963447570801,
-0.22148358821868896,
-0.44181230664253235,
-0.6967078447341919,
0.6838695406913757,
-0.6616721153259277,
0.25565749406814575,
0.4895477294921875,
0.0030114336404949427,
-0.4012793302536011,
-0.48441314697265625,
-0.411913126707077,
-0.15340453386306763,
0.08898644149303436,
-0.30109483003616333,
0.028089113533496857,
0.17259956896305084,
0.23416154086589813,
0.5117478370666504,
-0.47917354106903076,
0.246623694896698,
-0.205380380153656,
-0.27222979068756104,
0.543045163154602,
0.2781688868999481,
-0.12572413682937622,
-0.43613746762275696,
0.0215954277664423,
0.23971393704414368,
-0.565521776676178,
-0.36521095037460327,
0.34198248386383057,
0.5199103355407715,
0.252433180809021,
0.4796387255191803,
-0.4294739365577698,
0.8370206356048584,
0.5429364442825317,
-0.30536526441574097,
0.15225476026535034,
0.09318060427904129,
-0.06894319504499435,
0.1640636920928955,
0.5139821767807007,
-0.00455920584499836,
0.040337514132261276,
-0.49490341544151306,
-0.13776928186416626,
-0.022320806980133057,
0.4643509089946747,
-0.9494650363922119,
-0.12244836241006851,
0.6990152597427368,
-0.3699060082435608,
-0.4590368866920471,
0.0703703910112381,
-0.7704792618751526,
-0.4846455752849579,
-0.6316140294075012,
0.4121347963809967,
-0.3135944604873657,
-0.32517391443252563,
0.5319737792015076,
0.2212376445531845,
0.1650269329547882,
0.6708999276161194,
-1.0045056343078613,
0.1917554885149002,
1.101751446723938,
0.8211221694946289,
-0.4784863293170929,
-0.2982783317565918,
-0.581989049911499,
0.221857950091362,
-0.4578563868999481,
0.8755622506141663,
-0.5948939919471741,
-0.41743654012680054,
-0.12250004708766937,
-0.09631510823965073,
0.3870176076889038,
-0.7930851578712463,
0.4948493540287018,
-0.38099023699760437,
0.17384245991706848,
-0.3641473650932312,
-0.4004877805709839,
0.02544591948390007,
0.2993655800819397,
-0.43586790561676025,
0.8567181825637817,
-0.13325732946395874,
-0.8075444102287292,
0.3588220775127411,
-0.5212357044219971,
-0.26340246200561523,
-0.06631304323673248,
-0.3633846044540405,
-0.12477673590183258,
0.4260960519313812,
0.14729705452919006,
0.646233320236206,
-0.285715252161026,
1.0150322914123535,
-0.2938333749771118,
-0.39591607451438904,
0.06455762684345245,
-0.4873898923397064,
0.27320247888565063,
0.16441857814788818,
-0.41602379083633423,
0.40800201892852783,
-0.6913586854934692,
-0.329515278339386,
-0.17912594974040985,
0.02734426222741604,
-0.3706267178058624,
-0.09627892822027206,
-0.04830874130129814,
0.2639278173446655,
0.40301790833473206,
-0.13193635642528534,
0.4241196811199188,
-0.42665815353393555,
0.2742484509944916,
1.0402735471725464,
0.12436095625162125,
0.47292572259902954,
-0.35757631063461304,
0.2619446814060211,
0.23533344268798828,
-0.062229711562395096,
-0.03734395280480385,
-0.2818317115306854,
-0.7009640336036682,
-0.4884823262691498,
0.21710658073425293,
0.20312091708183289,
-0.49030888080596924,
0.8302351236343384,
-0.26760774850845337,
-0.36740392446517944,
-0.3687095046043396,
0.006122504826635122,
-0.05845298245549202,
0.3424288034439087,
0.1676667332649231,
-0.21965301036834717,
-0.2404186725616455,
-0.8677786588668823,
0.07243797183036804,
-0.014926516450941563,
0.14296549558639526,
0.5784775614738464,
0.3569454252719879,
-0.3985387980937958,
0.9721306562423706,
-0.7750858664512634,
-0.32017409801483154,
-0.15314100682735443,
0.21014858782291412,
0.23807038366794586,
0.18491749465465546,
0.1849394589662552,
-0.962332010269165,
-0.2733869254589081,
0.0832618772983551,
-0.6911507248878479,
-0.33514219522476196,
-0.20355698466300964,
-0.3174973726272583,
0.11723782122135162,
0.4006531238555908,
-0.7824748754501343,
0.30162933468818665,
0.029014192521572113,
-0.15960465371608734,
0.5457112789154053,
-0.17831185460090637,
0.07592979818582535,
-1.311315894126892,
-0.03636954352259636,
-0.21967972815036774,
-0.11056220531463623,
-0.6043382883071899,
0.054263897240161896,
-0.16861362755298615,
-0.35947057604789734,
-0.5434207916259766,
0.9153712391853333,
-0.3961094617843628,
0.02420032024383545,
-0.7192890644073486,
0.1373177170753479,
-0.1500961184501648,
0.301744282245636,
0.3361804485321045,
0.6899939775466919,
0.8719180226325989,
-0.6752801537513733,
0.02702239900827408,
0.22164596617221832,
0.03154471516609192,
0.1349046230316162,
-0.434332013130188,
0.25901728868484497,
-0.33201655745506287,
0.08651059865951538,
-0.6221902370452881,
-0.4395408630371094,
0.21537327766418457,
-0.10959986597299576,
0.38393017649650574,
-0.18391545116901398,
-0.3263755440711975,
0.020263662561774254,
-0.38082632422447205,
0.13682328164577484,
0.34773290157318115,
-0.4876450002193451,
0.4200493395328522,
0.4173241853713989,
-0.21130894124507904,
-0.5977876782417297,
-0.13069695234298706,
0.19379226863384247,
-0.45671504735946655,
-0.541066586971283,
0.5803999304771423,
-0.09078958630561829,
-0.465095579624176,
-0.16115951538085938,
-0.28928256034851074,
-0.07074026018381119,
0.07808008044958115,
0.4949893355369568,
-0.1591881960630417,
-0.039244744926691055,
0.1326991766691208,
0.18632321059703827,
-0.22261762619018555,
-0.2348940074443817,
-0.20376712083816528,
1.067126989364624,
0.1358107328414917,
-0.30408185720443726,
-0.23854875564575195,
0.4196407198905945,
0.6061328053474426,
-0.011938350275158882,
0.5732845664024353,
0.5530166625976562,
-0.45863834023475647,
-0.43269991874694824,
-0.6661227345466614,
-0.39946889877319336,
-0.4577963650226593,
0.4160620868206024,
-0.5768601298332214,
-1.1010924577713013,
0.5324882864952087,
-0.21279221773147583,
-0.11811903119087219,
0.4457377791404724,
0.9889419078826904,
0.4566226005554199,
0.4368443489074707,
0.6472031474113464,
-0.22579063475131989,
0.43612730503082275,
-0.22094862163066864,
0.1277853399515152,
-0.597419261932373,
-0.101564921438694,
-0.5288035869598389,
0.02926664613187313,
-0.3401630222797394,
-0.6055610775947571,
0.15070296823978424,
0.24961087107658386,
-0.0003451949160080403,
-0.019148405641317368,
-0.5790122151374817,
0.45616286993026733,
0.2448984980583191,
0.18284259736537933,
0.3293669819831848,
0.36468321084976196,
0.2260124385356903,
0.0808069258928299,
-0.4250408113002777,
-0.8814321756362915,
0.8394119739532471,
0.2699149250984192,
1.0042083263397217,
-0.15198983252048492,
0.9853960871696472,
0.36946141719818115,
-0.13790467381477356,
-0.8246640563011169,
0.6641389727592468,
-0.24057912826538086,
-0.5008060336112976,
-0.46151718497276306,
-0.4985383450984955,
-0.8393032550811768,
0.5270583033561707,
0.01103466097265482,
-0.860466718673706,
0.3754395842552185,
-0.07188168168067932,
-0.2339598536491394,
0.3987366259098053,
-0.2173941731452942,
0.6430761814117432,
-0.04264632239937782,
-0.49184396862983704,
-0.14428962767124176,
-0.1404910832643509,
0.33141013979911804,
-0.3131321668624878,
-0.027735210955142975,
-0.2360982596874237,
-0.026352111250162125,
0.44428694248199463,
-0.09766814857721329,
0.94583660364151,
0.02133026532828808,
-0.5640769004821777,
0.1871912181377411,
0.1471024453639984,
0.2829931080341339,
0.44157639145851135,
-0.3979233205318451,
0.39876097440719604,
-0.27982297539711,
-0.33583298325538635,
-0.41960054636001587,
0.9422149658203125,
-0.8821094036102295,
-1.07346773147583,
-0.4127792716026306,
-0.7181960344314575,
-0.14685913920402527,
-0.009684276767075062,
0.29968905448913574,
0.5945422649383545,
-0.2865522503852844,
0.04827825352549553,
0.9421159029006958,
-0.33074823021888733,
0.34777992963790894,
0.38291481137275696,
-0.40174877643585205,
-0.4197145104408264,
0.9751201272010803,
0.12164583802223206,
0.16532844305038452,
0.35360187292099,
0.14969226717948914,
0.01642737351357937,
-0.9110848903656006,
-0.2793511152267456,
0.2746324837207794,
-0.6379196047782898,
-0.03229638189077377,
-1.0652860403060913,
-0.34383487701416016,
-0.6452470421791077,
-0.22108128666877747,
-0.3680378198623657,
-0.2541046142578125,
-0.7536733150482178,
0.01340603455901146,
0.2811088562011719,
0.5028524398803711,
-0.19268614053726196,
0.17850375175476074,
-0.5364978313446045,
0.8186120390892029,
0.20932205021381378,
0.22801630198955536,
0.03485973924398422,
-0.8353244066238403,
0.02053792029619217,
-0.0326487198472023,
-0.46162259578704834,
-0.6099567413330078,
0.4773365259170532,
-0.06794243305921555,
0.5532934665679932,
0.6197580695152283,
0.21629144251346588,
0.7761018872261047,
-0.39956149458885193,
0.8081575632095337,
-0.17253175377845764,
-0.8560277223587036,
0.7214272618293762,
-0.4642440378665924,
0.12258020788431168,
0.6494662761688232,
0.5423611402511597,
-0.331313818693161,
-0.21196216344833374,
-0.5200613141059875,
-0.8832118511199951,
0.6158626079559326,
0.17341412603855133,
0.29551613330841064,
-0.22663824260234833,
0.6435281038284302,
0.7646802067756653,
0.31960421800613403,
-0.5592596530914307,
-0.14169226586818695,
0.09082087129354477,
0.13266006112098694,
-0.15657174587249756,
-0.5152270793914795,
-0.07760430872440338,
-0.1858338564634323,
0.6701022386550903,
-0.21810993552207947,
0.11628781259059906,
0.0970921516418457,
-0.10553161799907684,
-0.2340506762266159,
0.2878423035144806,
0.6871359348297119,
0.8759384155273438,
-0.4471961259841919,
0.11558273434638977,
-0.03590895235538483,
-0.43547704815864563,
0.17203277349472046,
0.003331907093524933,
-0.3586682379245758,
0.17452365159988403,
0.23998403549194336,
0.910048246383667,
-0.2309148609638214,
-0.4301479458808899,
0.250997930765152,
0.03910157084465027,
-0.28007566928863525,
-0.03610878810286522,
0.18113714456558228,
-0.08102110773324966,
0.09759562462568283,
0.33579838275909424,
-0.21484383940696716,
0.16372068226337433,
-0.6035842895507812,
0.2683591842651367,
0.49587786197662354,
-0.5169857144355774,
-0.24880282580852509,
0.3827061355113983,
0.11661656945943832,
-0.43510034680366516,
0.13234511017799377,
-0.18962129950523376,
-0.30372893810272217,
0.45381253957748413,
0.47244104743003845,
0.980997622013092,
0.10768278688192368,
0.38274919986724854,
0.07098188996315002,
0.04658621922135353,
-0.3342655301094055,
0.3320159316062927,
-0.05660545825958252,
-0.5875949859619141,
-0.3562588095664978,
-0.888991117477417,
-0.5315368175506592,
0.5249446034431458,
-0.6805031895637512,
0.5132322907447815,
-0.18739503622055054,
-0.04668576642870903,
0.03962402790784836,
0.0031968536786735058,
-0.12092369049787521,
0.10748309642076492,
0.1254579722881317,
0.5914056301116943,
-0.7961142659187317,
0.8966888785362244,
0.6164088249206543,
-0.14485833048820496,
-0.25788602232933044,
0.48865631222724915,
-0.35919252038002014,
-0.3096825182437897,
0.4833645224571228,
0.12285705655813217,
0.03247635066509247,
-0.09871001541614532,
-0.5431853532791138,
-0.6268735527992249,
0.8952721357345581,
0.49110862612724304,
-0.5703734755516052,
-0.13347455859184265,
0.33345910906791687,
0.4091314375400543,
-0.2656431496143341,
0.02815301902592182,
0.3052282929420471,
0.2805497944355011,
0.34266725182533264,
-0.8815630674362183,
-0.0472552590072155,
0.11894803494215012,
-0.08107934892177582,
0.4094519317150116,
-0.662805438041687,
0.8962422609329224,
-0.010907999239861965,
0.18509243428707123,
-0.1251285821199417,
0.5564467906951904,
0.3112989664077759,
0.33465683460235596,
0.25804370641708374,
0.5798358917236328,
0.9234587550163269,
0.07226604968309402,
0.7790725231170654,
-0.36138635873794556,
0.3356996476650238,
1.1110807657241821,
-0.5288045406341553,
0.6267515420913696,
0.5929149389266968,
0.1220620721578598,
-0.16072964668273926,
0.9046968817710876,
0.29274308681488037,
0.700243353843689,
0.3649373948574066,
-0.11044690757989883,
-0.4091072082519531,
-0.132070392370224,
-0.6836351752281189,
0.39620503783226013,
0.2810157239437103,
-0.23107177019119263,
-0.2919398546218872,
0.1064242273569107,
-0.15798765420913696,
-0.11854575574398041,
-0.46491676568984985,
1.073960304260254,
0.1507989913225174,
-0.47549498081207275,
0.7761529684066772,
0.007337307091802359,
0.855390727519989,
-0.4318631887435913,
0.07071355730295181,
-0.48789167404174805,
0.0423770397901535,
-0.1108923852443695,
-0.431034654378891,
0.3195229768753052,
0.004114517010748386,
-0.5156266689300537,
-0.1164642944931984,
0.9481438398361206,
-0.3548513650894165,
-0.5085632801055908,
0.14493198692798615,
0.6274546384811401,
0.322862446308136,
-0.525177001953125,
-0.43365126848220825,
0.17166770994663239,
0.09943704307079315,
-0.2193547785282135,
0.7026752233505249,
0.9824646711349487,
-0.16056427359580994,
0.5941757559776306,
0.4814194142818451,
0.3391895890235901,
-0.19700153172016144,
0.10622424632310867,
1.0363610982894897,
-0.8388073444366455,
-0.37476474046707153,
-0.9557710289955139,
0.2184823900461197,
0.044030919671058655,
-0.36848583817481995,
0.505437433719635,
0.6221873760223389,
0.6526041030883789,
-0.16089029610157013,
0.6510425209999084,
0.167094424366951,
0.2022968828678131,
-0.5684649348258972,
0.6072914600372314,
-0.6050331592559814,
0.4604097604751587,
-0.4054211676120758,
-1.121095061302185,
-0.22271686792373657,
0.4996328353881836,
-0.48587948083877563,
-0.09753010421991348,
0.45302560925483704,
1.073810338973999,
-0.22567687928676605,
-0.1224374771118164,
0.6469351649284363,
0.24073129892349243,
0.24270099401474,
0.268880695104599,
0.9201927185058594,
0.026657553389668465,
0.23463217914104462,
-0.46141454577445984,
-0.06437987834215164,
-0.3440111577510834,
-0.7750852108001709,
-1.1839795112609863,
-0.6011881232261658,
-0.44610854983329773,
-0.21346460282802582,
0.11825408041477203,
0.8720426559448242,
0.6622474193572998,
-0.7816371321678162,
-0.2576085031032562,
-0.044719256460666656,
0.17910736799240112,
0.17083221673965454,
-0.23974569141864777,
0.5258911848068237,
-0.40951383113861084,
-0.5651838779449463,
0.1186680942773819,
0.4839501976966858,
-0.039027485996484756,
-0.5074982047080994,
0.06555604189634323,
0.14560335874557495,
0.10414407402276993,
0.7103590369224548,
-0.2808455228805542,
-1.1309852600097656,
-0.18376369774341583,
0.017812766134738922,
-0.1707790344953537,
0.210797518491745,
0.867525577545166,
-0.6414601802825928,
0.1532481461763382,
0.37082523107528687,
0.516694188117981,
0.5946838855743408,
0.17590998113155365,
0.2770467698574066,
-0.3303785026073456,
0.36547166109085083,
0.2431923747062683,
0.12698471546173096,
0.2170553356409073,
-0.595228910446167,
0.3899638056755066,
0.059233445674180984,
-0.49190929532051086,
-1.04557466506958,
0.2241019904613495,
-1.1604351997375488,
-0.6973286867141724,
1.5936236381530762,
0.2624519169330597,
-0.13303887844085693,
-0.1560109704732895,
-0.6645718216896057,
-0.0061816805973649025,
-0.448577880859375,
1.2229737043380737,
0.6109542846679688,
-0.03318905085325241,
0.07632018625736237,
-0.395805686712265,
0.4175785779953003,
0.1277124285697937,
-0.8588217496871948,
0.5099846720695496,
0.6094011068344116,
0.08401762694120407,
0.10398854315280914,
0.670501708984375,
0.05768054723739624,
-0.024718523025512695,
-0.032708924263715744,
0.09754758328199387,
-0.10274063050746918,
-0.6088446378707886,
-0.4781244099140167,
0.5857004523277283,
0.20389927923679352,
0.14733202755451202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00602v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00602v1
|
Investigating Automatic Scoring and Feedback using Large Language Models
| 2024-05-01T16:13:54 | 2024-05-01T16:13:54 |
Gloria Ashiya Katuka, Alexander Gain, Yen-Yun Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Automatic grading and feedback have been long studied using traditional
machine learning and deep learning techniques using language models. With the
recent accessibility to high performing large language models (LLMs) like
LLaMA-2, there is an opportunity to investigate the use of these LLMs for
automatic grading and feedback generation. Despite the increase in performance,
LLMs require significant computational resources for fine-tuning and additional
specific adjustments to enhance their performance for such tasks. To address
these issues, Parameter Efficient Fine-tuning (PEFT) methods, such as LoRA and
QLoRA, have been adopted to decrease memory and computational requirements in
model fine-tuning. This paper explores the efficacy of PEFT-based quantized
models, employing classification or regression head, to fine-tune LLMs for
automatically assigning continuous numerical grades to short answers and
essays, as well as generating corresponding feedback. We conducted experiments
on both proprietary and open-source datasets for our tasks. The results show
that prediction of grade scores via finetuned LLMs are highly accurate,
achieving less than 3% error in grade percentage on average. For providing
graded feedback fine-tuned 4-bit quantized LLaMA-2 13B models outperform
competitive base models and achieve high similarity with subject matter expert
feedback in terms of high BLEU and ROUGE scores and qualitatively in terms of
feedback. The findings from this study provide important insights into the
impacts of the emerging capabilities of using quantization approaches to
fine-tune LLMs for various downstream tasks, such as automatic short answer
scoring and feedback generation at comparatively lower costs and latency.
|
[
-0.30261892080307007,
-1.1701654195785522,
0.6126372218132019,
0.17618829011917114,
-0.1251264214515686,
0.18021062016487122,
-0.4091874659061432,
-0.40821295976638794,
-0.21065931022167206,
0.5515270829200745,
-0.16534769535064697,
-0.5948118567466736,
-0.40247899293899536,
0.03606762737035751,
-0.2788239121437073,
1.2513893842697144,
-0.12758561968803406,
0.08820489048957825,
-0.019300663843750954,
0.005464879795908928,
-0.4940497577190399,
-0.7545919418334961,
-0.9320216178894043,
-0.37204509973526,
0.6725368499755859,
0.42574194073677063,
0.578416645526886,
0.5940994024276733,
0.6127787232398987,
0.2990049123764038,
-0.0494222454726696,
0.19332647323608398,
-0.3676835596561432,
-0.08172395825386047,
-0.17503373324871063,
-0.609478235244751,
-0.9480581879615784,
0.15778101980686188,
0.8451617360115051,
0.6260985136032104,
-0.23246487975120544,
0.510567307472229,
0.3406410813331604,
0.7297798991203308,
-0.6373673677444458,
0.24602733552455902,
-0.480607271194458,
-0.10752814263105392,
-0.03405703604221344,
-0.18338075280189514,
-0.5049875378608704,
-0.6007707118988037,
-0.011015674099326134,
-0.4709951877593994,
-0.125288724899292,
-0.13074296712875366,
0.736901581287384,
0.5160143971443176,
-0.38384202122688293,
-0.31083545088768005,
-0.7370676398277283,
0.918175458908081,
-0.7493758201599121,
-0.10430050641298294,
0.6304289698600769,
0.2693423926830292,
0.15287645161151886,
-0.4346400797367096,
-0.17423713207244873,
-0.3081020712852478,
0.011067730374634266,
-0.12666773796081543,
-0.09270630776882172,
0.25695735216140747,
0.19259850680828094,
0.5104430913925171,
-0.20651541650295258,
0.45273008942604065,
-0.2461521476507187,
-0.14500856399536133,
0.7686481475830078,
0.38419607281684875,
-0.2410752773284912,
-0.08408225327730179,
0.10165397077798843,
-0.12220770865678787,
-0.6999841332435608,
0.3359036445617676,
0.4251442849636078,
0.3403002917766571,
0.017030948773026466,
0.5062927007675171,
-0.3825891613960266,
0.8001455664634705,
0.3828662037849426,
-0.23149776458740234,
-0.011829459108412266,
-0.19197332859039307,
-0.3192382752895355,
-0.21760348975658417,
0.7485191226005554,
0.4233066439628601,
0.39039015769958496,
0.021545829251408577,
-0.5355213284492493,
0.11630585789680481,
0.05067218467593193,
-0.8720318078994751,
-0.41400015354156494,
-0.07199027389287949,
-0.49686041474342346,
-0.5884624719619751,
-0.2839069068431854,
-0.6804240942001343,
-0.2672065496444702,
-0.6018116474151611,
0.7629984617233276,
-0.18752768635749817,
0.15136581659317017,
0.007869595661759377,
0.46040135622024536,
0.020560383796691895,
0.8264468908309937,
-0.7074787616729736,
0.34717848896980286,
0.5331551432609558,
0.7892922759056091,
-0.23968346416950226,
-0.1586507260799408,
-0.8561878800392151,
-0.054377537220716476,
-0.3843630254268646,
0.9531941413879395,
-0.5945477485656738,
-0.10779833793640137,
-0.11205261200666428,
-0.09539669752120972,
0.008814239874482155,
-0.7005519270896912,
0.43136003613471985,
-0.5556539297103882,
0.03467126935720444,
0.06765688210725784,
-0.4871767461299896,
-0.17039665579795837,
0.48676246404647827,
-0.5471787452697754,
0.9524953365325928,
0.22452864050865173,
-0.3474312722682953,
0.05256108567118645,
-0.47283583879470825,
-0.11555033177137375,
-0.02854979783296585,
0.23268704116344452,
-0.5202434659004211,
0.20026226341724396,
0.13769716024398804,
0.5418816804885864,
-0.4416811466217041,
0.3614915907382965,
-0.32394713163375854,
-0.6446595191955566,
0.2981800436973572,
-0.536453127861023,
0.14252713322639465,
0.13427704572677612,
-0.4485335052013397,
0.16061057150363922,
-0.8625221252441406,
0.3481700122356415,
-0.13111908733844757,
-0.8062446117401123,
-0.31648528575897217,
-0.1420324593782425,
-0.07793321460485458,
0.02668328583240509,
0.27193406224250793,
-0.35538965463638306,
0.2769258916378021,
-0.3254227936267853,
0.5565645098686218,
0.9136636853218079,
-0.006136356387287378,
0.40692758560180664,
-0.3712877333164215,
0.6553816795349121,
-0.23187345266342163,
0.13478010892868042,
-0.11161394417285919,
-0.1750962734222412,
-0.7871000170707703,
-0.17761965095996857,
0.8099173903465271,
0.4573539197444916,
-0.33487823605537415,
0.20141847431659698,
-0.11577446758747101,
-0.4414556622505188,
-0.5571613311767578,
0.31098684668540955,
0.4861100912094116,
0.2533208131790161,
0.21442192792892456,
-0.16728653013706207,
-0.24833253026008606,
-0.7495346069335938,
-0.12186889350414276,
-0.26192978024482727,
-0.015662772580981255,
0.24447572231292725,
0.262817919254303,
-0.08759907633066177,
0.7681172490119934,
-0.4517039656639099,
-0.3919750154018402,
0.2041093111038208,
0.24179568886756897,
0.09021533280611038,
0.39254435896873474,
0.4141045808792114,
-0.35328409075737,
-0.5787540078163147,
-0.10012543946504593,
-0.30558136105537415,
-0.33831456303596497,
0.1605096459388733,
-0.055157605558633804,
0.4101337492465973,
0.4408380687236786,
-0.222458615899086,
0.19411136209964752,
0.6775386333465576,
-0.34549957513809204,
0.5120450258255005,
-0.11433425545692444,
0.2094939798116684,
-0.5484262108802795,
0.021093927323818207,
0.12640276551246643,
-0.422163724899292,
-0.22537687420845032,
0.010765544138848782,
0.1121600940823555,
0.16147185862064362,
-0.22902964055538177,
0.4165886342525482,
-0.1084175556898117,
0.191722109913826,
-0.5319253206253052,
-0.15000049769878387,
0.029576720669865608,
0.7401819825172424,
-0.011824848130345345,
0.6923844814300537,
0.15984946489334106,
-0.5520245432853699,
0.08432845771312714,
-0.18754324316978455,
-0.24653488397598267,
0.5922073721885681,
-0.7658410668373108,
0.2516452968120575,
0.1402665674686432,
0.22912898659706116,
-0.9074722528457642,
-0.17674843966960907,
0.01033955067396164,
-0.2746017873287201,
0.20649655163288116,
-0.3113902807235718,
-0.7830519676208496,
-0.14761300384998322,
-0.36227622628211975,
0.4687648415565491,
0.6044094562530518,
-0.34969019889831543,
0.3693191409111023,
0.45002996921539307,
-0.3160148561000824,
-0.13577520847320557,
-0.44941115379333496,
-0.20417015254497528,
-0.346738338470459,
-0.24117924273014069,
0.22655735909938812,
-0.22629030048847198,
-0.3770865797996521,
-0.22380247712135315,
0.18103459477424622,
-0.07622355967760086,
0.26416075229644775,
0.3547605276107788,
0.16687826812267303,
-0.25232595205307007,
0.27381467819213867,
0.3557114899158478,
0.060912150889635086,
0.19118240475654602,
-0.18905694782733917,
0.46581223607063293,
-0.5262792110443115,
-0.10416213423013687,
-0.38648876547813416,
0.1616293340921402,
0.6891798973083496,
-0.29336223006248474,
0.5311181545257568,
0.494870126247406,
-0.30393996834754944,
-0.31717586517333984,
-0.6657781600952148,
-0.2352137714624405,
-0.4746762812137604,
0.32577279210090637,
-0.20265305042266846,
-1.19809091091156,
0.3584347069263458,
-0.21434375643730164,
-0.01613260619342327,
0.4621674418449402,
0.9274156093597412,
-0.1718948632478714,
1.4015579223632812,
0.6596910953521729,
0.002578252926468849,
0.40130019187927246,
-0.3208148777484894,
0.003581300377845764,
-0.6861407160758972,
-0.12887641787528992,
-0.47384679317474365,
-0.3824610412120819,
-0.6469826102256775,
-0.3469168245792389,
0.334811270236969,
0.48237350583076477,
-0.41395023465156555,
-0.06866703927516937,
-0.5296759009361267,
0.6148091554641724,
0.530113697052002,
0.11418899893760681,
0.4799049496650696,
-0.011785429902374744,
0.021021410822868347,
0.1491168588399887,
-0.4383223354816437,
-0.8175418972969055,
1.16197669506073,
0.6538529992103577,
0.8336055874824524,
-0.10667988657951355,
0.4807487428188324,
0.44870367646217346,
0.46666789054870605,
-0.9002989530563354,
0.4128407835960388,
-0.31654292345046997,
-0.13738374412059784,
-0.3900254964828491,
-0.3746521770954132,
-0.5871527194976807,
0.0963698998093605,
-0.007288320921361446,
-0.4909062087535858,
-0.07026655972003937,
0.34039247035980225,
-0.7563965916633606,
0.10482949763536453,
-0.7279151082038879,
0.5481396317481995,
-0.1805804818868637,
-0.6414681673049927,
-0.38447046279907227,
-0.37791311740875244,
0.2316257357597351,
-0.50467848777771,
0.20477287471294403,
-0.30012527108192444,
0.10106172412633896,
0.9642257690429688,
-0.5184447169303894,
1.0299947261810303,
-0.21410460770130157,
-0.6933249235153198,
0.4248335659503937,
0.2193412035703659,
0.49372896552085876,
0.34162893891334534,
-0.26694533228874207,
0.11634470522403717,
0.35764583945274353,
-0.175425723195076,
-0.5961681604385376,
0.9231570959091187,
-0.9872488379478455,
-0.549261212348938,
-0.20229068398475647,
-0.6024765968322754,
-0.36335289478302,
-0.06044447049498558,
0.016382789239287376,
0.20938657224178314,
0.3830336928367615,
0.022188182920217514,
0.5859524607658386,
-0.11715930700302124,
0.39603203535079956,
0.8625025749206543,
-0.25631818175315857,
-0.6768162250518799,
0.9777840971946716,
0.2607888877391815,
-0.02268720045685768,
0.3321852385997772,
0.24535317718982697,
-0.11799227446317673,
-0.5347338318824768,
-0.4711860418319702,
0.3120609521865845,
-0.5909844040870667,
-0.6154025197029114,
-0.3850195109844208,
-0.10423209518194199,
-0.15839828550815582,
0.011615889146924019,
-0.3601836860179901,
-0.6142921447753906,
-0.4098716676235199,
-0.03831591457128525,
0.38972559571266174,
0.9009432196617126,
0.0011305965017527342,
0.5157907009124756,
-0.8634277582168579,
-0.015178230591118336,
0.3644733428955078,
0.6617484092712402,
0.24576330184936523,
-0.7462377548217773,
-0.5491641759872437,
0.03463849425315857,
-0.538033664226532,
-0.5257474780082703,
0.24430951476097107,
0.25558310747146606,
0.08191408216953278,
0.05626154690980911,
-0.05259685218334198,
0.7120763063430786,
-0.3865795135498047,
0.7088617086410522,
-0.17265883088111877,
-1.191908836364746,
0.6487263441085815,
-0.40318119525909424,
0.26501700282096863,
0.6151375770568848,
0.11500941216945648,
-0.12266033887863159,
-0.3783576488494873,
-0.03109097294509411,
-0.7151404023170471,
0.7970046401023865,
-0.10822179913520813,
0.060151226818561554,
0.0555083267390728,
0.6446843147277832,
0.2277328073978424,
0.25147226452827454,
-0.6814512610435486,
0.12399576604366302,
0.10006185621023178,
-0.2455815076828003,
-0.10887975245714188,
-0.3264036178588867,
0.09473410993814468,
-0.4452332556247711,
0.6186234354972839,
-0.3610376715660095,
0.030350932851433754,
-0.055507585406303406,
-0.06710251420736313,
-0.4316365122795105,
0.2663551867008209,
0.5136561393737793,
0.4846962094306946,
-0.17094533145427704,
-0.005345341749489307,
0.3122881054878235,
-0.32070815563201904,
0.3943042457103729,
-0.10357193648815155,
-0.11664152890443802,
-0.1858077198266983,
0.1551990509033203,
0.7112153172492981,
0.02920728735625744,
-0.8439424633979797,
0.2977547347545624,
-0.030811993405222893,
-0.24269333481788635,
-0.3353396952152252,
0.10169177502393723,
-0.230538010597229,
0.3333043158054352,
0.32088860869407654,
-0.13785295188426971,
0.16026383638381958,
-0.35642263293266296,
-0.0005055812071077526,
0.3561883866786957,
-0.305840402841568,
-0.474113792181015,
0.5408356785774231,
0.16642282903194427,
-0.2782299816608429,
0.5492010712623596,
0.04144653305411339,
-0.371513307094574,
0.5621155500411987,
0.37466123700141907,
0.5209847688674927,
-0.1999344378709793,
0.24053652584552765,
0.36677396297454834,
-0.055329982191324234,
-0.18654848635196686,
0.0906810536980629,
-0.2691093385219574,
-0.15790970623493195,
-0.8127948641777039,
-1.1512137651443481,
-0.5024939775466919,
0.23462891578674316,
-0.7974908947944641,
0.2709343731403351,
-0.6135031580924988,
-0.5608376860618591,
-0.24428580701351166,
0.30498644709587097,
-0.46143144369125366,
0.3586413264274597,
0.4049447476863861,
0.5310617685317993,
-0.7157899141311646,
0.9764574766159058,
0.8493359088897705,
-0.22637274861335754,
-1.1589654684066772,
-0.08153968304395676,
-0.3572535812854767,
-0.42925652861595154,
0.840766191482544,
0.07855164259672165,
-0.166213259100914,
0.1532347947359085,
-0.3696903884410858,
-0.9395416975021362,
0.7898228764533997,
0.5187539458274841,
-0.8488404154777527,
-0.35180509090423584,
0.3351566195487976,
0.9246423244476318,
0.01262497715651989,
0.4758966565132141,
0.8329405784606934,
0.4252510666847229,
-0.29642385244369507,
-1.2189213037490845,
-0.115616574883461,
-0.387417733669281,
0.0820729061961174,
0.40539413690567017,
-0.9879401922225952,
0.9370787739753723,
0.014118238352239132,
0.2557537853717804,
0.2342032641172409,
0.5071762800216675,
0.4605376422405243,
0.3395867645740509,
0.4228367507457733,
0.6520287990570068,
0.6933258771896362,
-0.06251406669616699,
0.8673813343048096,
-0.3714506924152374,
0.5286389589309692,
0.890789270401001,
-0.23255369067192078,
1.0087295770645142,
0.3933941721916199,
-0.3184874951839447,
0.628593385219574,
0.7519398331642151,
-0.19565290212631226,
0.5329124331474304,
0.598800003528595,
0.0604885034263134,
-0.28134363889694214,
-0.17178703844547272,
-0.013807356357574463,
0.49348899722099304,
0.30887144804000854,
-0.38261833786964417,
-0.014570868574082851,
0.2645251452922821,
-0.18077345192432404,
0.18085063993930817,
-0.8090982437133789,
0.7943665385246277,
0.12075003981590271,
-0.9075836539268494,
0.8535994291305542,
0.37223443388938904,
0.8930898308753967,
-0.24021010100841522,
-0.17537915706634521,
-0.40559273958206177,
0.38522571325302124,
-0.30222856998443604,
-0.5824877619743347,
0.2298545241355896,
0.4478517770767212,
-0.3663022518157959,
-0.18555453419685364,
0.30085787177085876,
-0.33947399258613586,
-0.6047355532646179,
0.16201834380626678,
0.2807798385620117,
-0.11840520054101944,
-0.18163809180259705,
-0.4993748068809509,
0.14304031431674957,
-0.22212032973766327,
-0.3253136873245239,
0.5488237738609314,
0.3391757905483246,
-0.40234753489494324,
0.538067102432251,
0.41552865505218506,
0.0974927768111229,
-0.013981766067445278,
0.08529873937368393,
0.62078458070755,
-0.45449647307395935,
-0.4452754557132721,
-0.9666234254837036,
0.08327165246009827,
0.4684098958969116,
-0.23036697506904602,
0.718595564365387,
0.5013812780380249,
0.9470444321632385,
0.000770716171246022,
0.5949035882949829,
0.3501441776752472,
0.6327784061431885,
-0.6376355886459351,
0.7463743090629578,
-0.5526952743530273,
0.3820061981678009,
-0.3532593548297882,
-0.8737614154815674,
-0.28571608662605286,
0.45706385374069214,
-0.4951256215572357,
0.13959042727947235,
0.5406913161277771,
0.5224277973175049,
0.28568464517593384,
-0.28604400157928467,
0.21773084998130798,
0.06797639280557632,
0.25626102089881897,
0.759794294834137,
1.0498809814453125,
-0.41018348932266235,
0.5586761832237244,
-0.5598986744880676,
-0.07336482405662537,
-0.3282194137573242,
-0.5046520233154297,
-0.9839076995849609,
-0.39649203419685364,
-0.6784400343894958,
-0.3025939166545868,
0.12380438297986984,
0.7915747165679932,
0.6874544620513916,
-0.9644332528114319,
-0.25730687379837036,
-0.06292537599802017,
-0.19420288503170013,
0.07617529481649399,
-0.32264411449432373,
0.6338983178138733,
-0.2512115240097046,
-0.9811069965362549,
0.07175631076097488,
0.22081193327903748,
0.1048429012298584,
-0.2692122459411621,
-0.09467379003763199,
0.3285115361213684,
0.14682532846927643,
0.7669667601585388,
-0.09099239856004715,
-0.8278110027313232,
-0.15831594169139862,
0.08817164599895477,
-0.2311648279428482,
0.053955916315317154,
0.6503183245658875,
-1.1566463708877563,
-0.21524079144001007,
0.36861056089401245,
0.4634315073490143,
0.2480987161397934,
0.2569884657859802,
0.5154376029968262,
-0.437590628862381,
-0.25896933674812317,
0.355218768119812,
0.06437309831380844,
0.30829963088035583,
-0.45149463415145874,
0.4450232684612274,
-0.11516135185956955,
-0.8647338151931763,
-1.1096487045288086,
-0.15778416395187378,
-0.7306419014930725,
-0.22370903193950653,
1.0814239978790283,
-0.17822186648845673,
-0.19245746731758118,
0.3146287798881531,
-0.3980987071990967,
0.22811023890972137,
-0.4152044951915741,
1.013526201248169,
0.5773798227310181,
-0.18974652886390686,
-0.2287631779909134,
-0.28114476799964905,
0.4629073441028595,
0.7597177028656006,
-0.835824728012085,
0.08445518463850021,
0.48577991127967834,
0.3109648525714874,
-0.00816508661955595,
0.4222118854522705,
-0.10055036097764969,
0.4102332592010498,
-0.5142106413841248,
-0.19979457557201385,
-0.06177222356200218,
-0.3170825242996216,
-0.7796093225479126,
0.47225770354270935,
0.4479382336139679,
0.1453230232000351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00588v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00588v1
|
Are Models Biased on Text without Gender-related Language?
| 2024-05-01T15:51:15 | 2024-05-01T15:51:15 |
Catarina G Belém, Preethi Seshadri, Yasaman Razeghi, Sameer Singh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Gender bias research has been pivotal in revealing undesirable behaviors in
large language models, exposing serious gender stereotypes associated with
occupations, and emotions. A key observation in prior work is that models
reinforce stereotypes as a consequence of the gendered correlations that are
present in the training data. In this paper, we focus on bias where the effect
from training data is unclear, and instead address the question: Do language
models still exhibit gender bias in non-stereotypical settings? To do so, we
introduce UnStereoEval (USE), a novel framework tailored for investigating
gender bias in stereotype-free scenarios. USE defines a sentence-level score
based on pretraining data statistics to determine if the sentence contain
minimal word-gender associations. To systematically benchmark the fairness of
popular language models in stereotype-free scenarios, we utilize USE to
automatically generate benchmarks without any gender-related language. By
leveraging USE's sentence-level score, we also repurpose prior gender bias
benchmarks (Winobias and Winogender) for non-stereotypical evaluation.
Surprisingly, we find low fairness across all 28 tested models. Concretely,
models demonstrate fair behavior in only 9%-41% of stereotype-free sentences,
suggesting that bias does not solely stem from the presence of gender-related
words. These results raise important questions about where underlying model
biases come from and highlight the need for more systematic and comprehensive
bias evaluation. We release the full dataset and code at
https://ucinlp.github.io/unstereo-eval.
|
[
-0.05722947418689728,
-0.32399898767471313,
0.3443071246147156,
0.22649964690208435,
0.011338266544044018,
-0.1961572766304016,
-0.3221094608306885,
-0.4154234230518341,
-0.21323111653327942,
0.5760075449943542,
-0.5936257839202881,
-0.49060511589050293,
-0.4001481235027313,
0.1393943876028061,
-0.5215586423873901,
1.1167856454849243,
0.16559411585330963,
0.6564526557922363,
-0.41382142901420593,
-0.2758515477180481,
-0.4419887959957123,
-0.6392298936843872,
0.15766370296478271,
-0.5458744168281555,
-0.16028408706188202,
0.28201374411582947,
0.5165472030639648,
0.4842473268508911,
0.17870767414569855,
0.2016921490430832,
-0.19507019221782684,
-0.2906239330768585,
-0.4749924838542938,
0.1434367597103119,
-0.12751434743404388,
-0.4908771514892578,
-0.2917135953903198,
0.4863348603248596,
0.31311434507369995,
1.0266908407211304,
-0.12819494307041168,
0.19191522896289825,
0.1998894065618515,
0.8217226266860962,
-0.7830081582069397,
0.14066962897777557,
-0.7446981072425842,
0.048267900943756104,
-0.13687372207641602,
0.03076518513262272,
-0.3271365165710449,
-0.3251214325428009,
0.32987746596336365,
-0.3385629653930664,
0.5828830599784851,
0.11134286224842072,
0.5794435739517212,
0.12594449520111084,
-0.6381170153617859,
-0.3861845135688782,
-0.38495761156082153,
0.9499935507774353,
-0.5222943425178528,
0.4770705997943878,
0.5128289461135864,
-0.11363906413316727,
-0.19448263943195343,
-0.1606963723897934,
-0.2677868604660034,
-0.4669475257396698,
-0.07371728122234344,
0.04720883071422577,
-0.3879856467247009,
0.11099515110254288,
0.4215297996997833,
0.26898980140686035,
-0.2785474359989166,
-0.050798267126083374,
-0.44095879793167114,
0.07860191911458969,
0.5061798691749573,
-0.16289515793323517,
0.3834250569343567,
-0.44946855306625366,
-0.379092812538147,
-0.13582009077072144,
-0.6299217939376831,
0.019150950014591217,
0.7536628246307373,
0.4728139042854309,
-0.2742575705051422,
0.7911966443061829,
0.07998422533273697,
0.31066158413887024,
-0.03770064562559128,
0.4940616488456726,
0.44711217284202576,
-0.05713702738285065,
-0.3600546717643738,
0.2411859929561615,
0.8814867734909058,
0.4268478751182556,
0.7691102623939514,
-0.25092214345932007,
-0.18620353937149048,
0.2181430608034134,
0.42853230237960815,
-0.5867213606834412,
-0.11905445903539658,
-0.07429161667823792,
-0.47821393609046936,
-0.5836607813835144,
-0.03664637356996536,
-1.114827275276184,
-0.5440585613250732,
0.0980583131313324,
0.055123575031757355,
-0.14446347951889038,
-0.24180158972740173,
-0.0965752974152565,
-0.4139494001865387,
-0.16032300889492035,
-0.0909937173128128,
-0.9778808355331421,
0.21757377684116364,
0.38013774156570435,
0.5475513935089111,
0.042937956750392914,
-0.20277884602546692,
-0.2954435348510742,
-0.12904058396816254,
-0.653817355632782,
0.5552151203155518,
-0.8128346800804138,
-0.5447733998298645,
0.2097892165184021,
-0.06813547015190125,
-0.09948388487100601,
-0.5287217497825623,
0.6896058917045593,
-0.02803611196577549,
0.6436569094657898,
-0.3447491228580475,
-0.527898907661438,
-0.011409652419388294,
-0.05306442454457283,
-0.6559557914733887,
1.1184229850769043,
-0.022809471935033798,
-1.2107045650482178,
0.5518851280212402,
-0.7562626600265503,
-0.14014531672000885,
-0.4318110942840576,
-0.3116950988769531,
-0.11240915954113007,
0.42050033807754517,
0.17386281490325928,
-0.07806670665740967,
-0.4154028594493866,
0.6239436268806458,
-0.47592923045158386,
-0.28977736830711365,
0.29432523250579834,
-0.560702919960022,
0.822937548160553,
-0.15894344449043274,
-0.5637887120246887,
0.0286441408097744,
-0.5248304605484009,
0.053970806300640106,
-0.12002711743116379,
0.013344122096896172,
-0.85564786195755,
-0.132096067070961,
0.3052356243133545,
0.26711297035217285,
0.06938411295413971,
-0.7471433281898499,
-0.025308679789304733,
-0.3910946846008301,
0.24270625412464142,
0.8788176774978638,
-0.5802091360092163,
0.9239004850387573,
-0.20970913767814636,
0.41811802983283997,
-0.24079222977161407,
-0.009756422601640224,
0.3212244510650635,
-0.2669958472251892,
-0.6260008215904236,
-0.34345221519470215,
0.34797725081443787,
0.3574444651603699,
-0.6132122278213501,
0.047349777072668076,
-0.0008954718941822648,
-0.22482213377952576,
-0.6845798492431641,
0.11411802470684052,
0.7645551562309265,
0.5019032955169678,
0.28291797637939453,
-0.13165903091430664,
-0.6091445088386536,
-1.2784727811813354,
-0.9105990529060364,
-0.332947701215744,
-0.17655958235263824,
0.22363057732582092,
0.682497501373291,
0.007807252462953329,
0.9174008965492249,
-0.1700240522623062,
-0.3838998079299927,
-0.2973936200141907,
0.42821404337882996,
0.0905902087688446,
0.3141365647315979,
0.7010610103607178,
-0.49489128589630127,
0.10332681238651276,
-0.42570415139198303,
-1.0135430097579956,
-0.597095787525177,
0.27572405338287354,
-0.17027881741523743,
0.39564043283462524,
0.28008967638015747,
-0.5025217533111572,
0.4119853675365448,
0.7748807072639465,
-0.58458411693573,
0.3420241177082062,
-0.16451595723628998,
0.0732385516166687,
-0.5635772347450256,
0.19647081196308136,
0.1468268781900406,
-0.18174529075622559,
-0.6695117354393005,
-0.1961488425731659,
-0.012428722344338894,
0.18973417580127716,
-0.40838825702667236,
0.8090035319328308,
-0.553610622882843,
-0.2330390363931656,
-0.4004673659801483,
-0.1969059407711029,
-0.07048175483942032,
0.32806396484375,
0.3145148456096649,
0.7090590000152588,
0.40736204385757446,
-0.4017968475818634,
-0.4595053493976593,
0.20591160655021667,
-0.16516388952732086,
0.4700060188770294,
-0.6480336785316467,
0.1712634414434433,
-0.45070984959602356,
0.05631685256958008,
-0.5169826149940491,
0.04369252920150757,
0.1320188194513321,
-0.3824876844882965,
-0.05692422017455101,
-0.269729882478714,
-0.2199995517730713,
-0.1824682056903839,
-0.6016120910644531,
0.34548690915107727,
0.46194493770599365,
-0.3815985321998596,
0.18392419815063477,
0.4452817142009735,
0.253645122051239,
-0.8145225048065186,
-0.7177035212516785,
-0.40037643909454346,
-0.13451798260211945,
-0.2538910210132599,
0.07623595744371414,
-0.13254404067993164,
-0.5684638023376465,
-0.18351340293884277,
-0.39713484048843384,
-0.3388630151748657,
-0.11278581619262695,
0.4766787886619568,
0.40419983863830566,
0.14664244651794434,
0.203649640083313,
0.09310513734817505,
0.3258800506591797,
0.06791271269321442,
-0.17697963118553162,
0.3632408082485199,
-0.16232863068580627,
-0.00044280377915129066,
-0.32242026925086975,
0.31044137477874756,
0.5872095227241516,
0.19403010606765747,
0.61705482006073,
0.21133218705654144,
-0.4501325488090515,
-0.25084832310676575,
-0.34474682807922363,
-0.32672780752182007,
-0.3887234926223755,
0.4810992181301117,
-0.02589622512459755,
-1.0724467039108276,
0.19665087759494781,
0.536740779876709,
0.15925323963165283,
0.35118183493614197,
0.340025395154953,
-0.16410255432128906,
0.958293616771698,
0.7954471707344055,
-0.027895931154489517,
0.35059186816215515,
0.1847103089094162,
-0.08153043687343597,
-0.7739356756210327,
-0.25157594680786133,
-0.7012467384338379,
-0.12448735535144806,
-0.9774574637413025,
-0.2565109431743622,
-0.05705234780907631,
-0.0007629139581695199,
-0.37982699275016785,
0.06050502136349678,
-0.3306330442428589,
0.3334783911705017,
0.49461373686790466,
-0.33818069100379944,
0.3722863495349884,
0.0351218543946743,
-0.1331874579191208,
-0.48478007316589355,
-0.6174085736274719,
-0.5775924921035767,
1.3535959720611572,
0.1962938904762268,
0.6977105140686035,
-0.2544932961463928,
0.34684860706329346,
0.6665370464324951,
0.4923373758792877,
-0.3394623100757599,
0.3636501729488373,
-0.4052732586860657,
-1.0602283477783203,
-0.003811868140473962,
-0.6903509497642517,
-0.8265506029129028,
0.46526890993118286,
-0.3378753662109375,
-0.7656010985374451,
0.3684733510017395,
0.2737334966659546,
0.3003216087818146,
0.22576795518398285,
-0.4771822690963745,
0.8781282901763916,
-0.3440418839454651,
-0.30397218465805054,
0.21126359701156616,
-0.34277305006980896,
0.6562052369117737,
0.003400741843506694,
0.5409360527992249,
-0.3363252282142639,
0.2433122992515564,
0.9880119562149048,
-0.3673829734325409,
0.7149602174758911,
-0.22224915027618408,
-0.08459363132715225,
-0.13211394846439362,
0.21723511815071106,
0.014226398430764675,
0.08756814152002335,
-0.15202189981937408,
0.5978012681007385,
0.03262206166982651,
-0.22080649435520172,
-0.3283410370349884,
0.6238769292831421,
-0.77985018491745,
-0.24831242859363556,
-0.7139015793800354,
-0.5625001192092896,
-0.3159262239933014,
0.3429054021835327,
0.35933393239974976,
0.2565205991268158,
-0.5617181062698364,
-0.060592491179704666,
0.44464319944381714,
-0.2743707001209259,
0.2934006452560425,
0.505230188369751,
-0.29101064801216125,
-0.13193389773368835,
0.37793123722076416,
-0.21365170180797577,
0.1070282831788063,
0.2885186970233917,
0.15070194005966187,
-0.390696257352829,
-0.12799644470214844,
-0.466257244348526,
0.26328468322753906,
-0.2897259294986725,
0.002512218663468957,
-0.6470893025398254,
0.009964719414710999,
-0.46297091245651245,
0.07162345200777054,
-0.7985314726829529,
-0.42731183767318726,
-0.10754566639661789,
-0.07886228710412979,
0.18503212928771973,
0.7760123610496521,
0.0427963025867939,
0.1893155723810196,
-0.39188626408576965,
0.3371882736682892,
0.1934087574481964,
0.17147089540958405,
-0.16741019487380981,
-0.4580444097518921,
0.3668486475944519,
0.26880398392677307,
0.08363619446754456,
-0.9110426306724548,
0.5503876209259033,
0.07323407381772995,
0.4636894166469574,
0.19602128863334656,
0.08504638820886612,
0.2078855186700821,
-0.48360928893089294,
0.5594006180763245,
0.22994393110275269,
-1.2048548460006714,
0.41177481412887573,
-0.5190889239311218,
0.046006131917238235,
0.7622133493423462,
0.23412218689918518,
-0.5866321325302124,
-0.5892162919044495,
-0.5896435976028442,
-0.7300560474395752,
0.8206305503845215,
0.5581116080284119,
0.3194034695625305,
-0.20864519476890564,
0.25156956911087036,
0.12379669398069382,
0.8389784693717957,
-0.9604542255401611,
-0.30714693665504456,
-0.3718995451927185,
-0.25392946600914,
0.126591756939888,
-0.35606124997138977,
-0.01190180703997612,
-0.058890242129564285,
0.4811556339263916,
-0.07668990641832352,
0.27059999108314514,
0.0696994960308075,
-0.37017348408699036,
0.09179257601499557,
0.644199550151825,
0.3346189856529236,
0.5082168579101562,
-0.502335250377655,
0.022257909178733826,
-0.07085265219211578,
-0.48477309942245483,
-0.0017027840949594975,
-0.04360289126634598,
-0.5016074180603027,
0.23645171523094177,
0.396930456161499,
0.630013108253479,
0.33724555373191833,
-0.8403435945510864,
0.8628058433532715,
-0.2610425353050232,
-0.254551500082016,
-0.24490895867347717,
-0.09964374452829361,
-0.20076049864292145,
0.2286979854106903,
0.2294182926416397,
0.13968342542648315,
0.15570534765720367,
-0.6923785209655762,
-0.008369465358555317,
0.702347457408905,
-1.0628724098205566,
-0.3395369350910187,
0.9315281510353088,
0.20142339169979095,
0.16608291864395142,
0.795028805732727,
0.08049217611551285,
-0.41212892532348633,
0.564041256904602,
0.3718322813510895,
0.9206345677375793,
-0.18323415517807007,
0.5223371386528015,
0.21370242536067963,
0.68829345703125,
-0.2572875916957855,
0.22243739664554596,
0.26184922456741333,
-0.8067074418067932,
0.12546080350875854,
-0.643044650554657,
-0.01149352453649044,
0.09031280130147934,
-0.7345985174179077,
0.18586328625679016,
-0.3999682366847992,
-0.1350231170654297,
-0.22594882547855377,
-0.3792966902256012,
-0.6093743443489075,
0.15261024236679077,
0.12723027169704437,
0.7660014629364014,
-1.0897969007492065,
0.5272468328475952,
0.673026978969574,
-0.30969488620758057,
-0.3614896535873413,
-0.05102840065956116,
0.23749594390392303,
-0.6464589238166809,
0.6810451745986938,
0.2512182891368866,
-0.14348261058330536,
-0.5751854777336121,
-0.4302152693271637,
-0.36111980676651,
0.6312927007675171,
0.7235159277915955,
-0.38627520203590393,
-0.24941754341125488,
0.18930089473724365,
0.6153106689453125,
-0.5963817834854126,
0.6355301141738892,
0.3689625859260559,
0.3749397397041321,
-0.13164669275283813,
-0.947508692741394,
-0.0473816879093647,
-0.3524034023284912,
0.1971384882926941,
-0.048078473657369614,
-0.2784610688686371,
1.0028533935546875,
-0.09267737716436386,
0.03674609586596489,
0.019055915996432304,
0.556257426738739,
0.15749311447143555,
0.24510563910007477,
0.41229960322380066,
0.3395019471645355,
0.9812873601913452,
0.07579516619443893,
1.0179574489593506,
-0.03468864783644676,
0.30596300959587097,
1.1552410125732422,
-0.39466360211372375,
0.5695449709892273,
0.46996942162513733,
0.20016959309577942,
0.5020666718482971,
0.27849018573760986,
0.16895397007465363,
0.45600688457489014,
0.28847047686576843,
-0.10882394015789032,
-0.23134712874889374,
-0.49392038583755493,
-0.3754172623157501,
0.780387818813324,
-0.17273905873298645,
-0.6970794200897217,
-0.25639885663986206,
-0.057326748967170715,
0.49018892645835876,
0.1489412933588028,
-0.2929316759109497,
0.32712748646736145,
0.06621642410755157,
-0.4405864477157593,
0.27121099829673767,
0.08660125732421875,
0.9878606200218201,
-0.59449702501297,
0.04552563279867172,
-0.46623262763023376,
0.16743265092372894,
-0.1633056104183197,
-0.3822133243083954,
0.06710250675678253,
0.48637887835502625,
-0.5032063126564026,
-0.2683483064174652,
0.5703777074813843,
-0.6574075222015381,
-0.6914732456207275,
0.41253748536109924,
0.8494018912315369,
0.1260199099779129,
-0.10149455815553665,
-0.42774903774261475,
-0.35693153738975525,
0.14652104675769806,
-0.027326462790369987,
0.43804314732551575,
0.1737995594739914,
-0.413120836019516,
0.5480793118476868,
0.612104058265686,
0.1503550410270691,
0.03577784448862076,
0.44487860798835754,
0.5344038009643555,
-0.5774016976356506,
-0.2510477304458618,
-0.835414469242096,
0.2155051827430725,
-0.14875932037830353,
-0.3986143469810486,
0.8198685646057129,
0.6357348561286926,
0.839029848575592,
0.027860261499881744,
0.8611889481544495,
0.13014553487300873,
0.31308797001838684,
-0.43342557549476624,
1.1335687637329102,
-0.6290595531463623,
0.18876321613788605,
-0.6940048336982727,
-0.9904283285140991,
-0.1645083725452423,
0.6285701990127563,
-0.329228013753891,
0.3973511755466461,
0.771812915802002,
0.607326328754425,
0.029243916273117065,
0.345491886138916,
0.16280531883239746,
0.1789664477109909,
-0.10108376294374466,
0.3785170912742615,
0.9010393619537354,
-0.29021909832954407,
0.4047009348869324,
-0.00456224475055933,
-0.2924036681652069,
0.2682841122150421,
-0.9181433320045471,
-1.3220503330230713,
-0.2837145924568176,
-0.20624807476997375,
-0.20145992934703827,
0.47014790773391724,
0.781436026096344,
0.4096347391605377,
-0.5517390966415405,
-0.5547851324081421,
-0.10789772868156433,
0.3008785843849182,
0.09496258944272995,
-0.18495680391788483,
0.1883503496646881,
-0.19595284759998322,
-0.8118383288383484,
0.16562804579734802,
-0.03687228262424469,
-0.17261508107185364,
0.0036243379581719637,
0.012747233733534813,
-0.07096092402935028,
0.03897150605916977,
0.24087537825107574,
0.037427935749292374,
-0.29132431745529175,
-0.16895654797554016,
0.16892151534557343,
0.016149330884218216,
-0.016308773308992386,
1.060263991355896,
-0.7196414470672607,
0.45480799674987793,
0.40298062562942505,
-0.007945210672914982,
0.2012375444173813,
-0.09418904036283493,
0.8162363767623901,
-0.8174539804458618,
0.24426360428333282,
0.08047901093959808,
0.3287791609764099,
0.5437766313552856,
-0.09556843340396881,
0.35396531224250793,
0.33554917573928833,
-0.12993350625038147,
-0.9116891026496887,
0.04953084886074066,
-0.4289768636226654,
-0.38968583941459656,
1.178071141242981,
0.20072413980960846,
-0.33974263072013855,
-0.014221505261957645,
0.14381985366344452,
0.2707206904888153,
-0.6650455594062805,
0.9033872485160828,
0.7499827146530151,
-0.04217492416501045,
-0.08770062774419785,
-1.0081660747528076,
0.7562180757522583,
0.5343301892280579,
-0.651138424873352,
0.3575654923915863,
0.7291392087936401,
0.4375232756137848,
-0.250440388917923,
0.7540811896324158,
-0.2614009976387024,
0.05092241242527962,
-0.18727797269821167,
0.36079996824264526,
0.0570661835372448,
-0.31069597601890564,
-0.30163633823394775,
-0.04688863828778267,
-0.11776068061590195,
-0.055988118052482605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00578v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00578v1
|
The Real, the Better: Aligning Large Language Models with Online Human Behaviors
| 2024-05-01T15:30:41 | 2024-05-01T15:30:41 |
Guanying Jiang, Lingyong Yan, Haibo Shi, Dawei Yin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language model alignment is widely used and studied to avoid LLM
producing unhelpful and harmful responses. However, the lengthy training
process and predefined preference bias hinder adaptation to online diverse
human preferences. To this end, this paper proposes an alignment framework,
called Reinforcement Learning with Human Behavior (RLHB), to align LLMs by
directly leveraging real online human behaviors. By taking the generative
adversarial framework, the generator is trained to respond following expected
human behavior; while the discriminator tries to verify whether the triplets of
query, response, and human behavior come from real online environments.
Behavior modeling in natural-language form and the multi-model joint training
mechanism enable an active and sustainable online alignment. Experimental
results confirm the effectiveness of our proposed methods by both human and
automatic evaluations.
|
[
-0.3233690559864044,
-0.9299089312553406,
0.41436073184013367,
0.1159319207072258,
0.09934001415967941,
0.4662337005138397,
-0.32051974534988403,
-0.5606611371040344,
0.3081979751586914,
0.3329137861728668,
-0.7788540720939636,
0.030321326106786728,
-0.09244241565465927,
-0.09891485422849655,
0.004027324263006449,
0.9620813131332397,
0.0854666605591774,
0.17387911677360535,
-0.3067935109138489,
-0.1166565865278244,
-0.43594151735305786,
-0.5191970467567444,
-0.7412854433059692,
-0.5709661245346069,
0.5490645170211792,
0.016064077615737915,
0.9288778305053711,
0.7509455680847168,
0.39684978127479553,
0.3922468423843384,
0.20065313577651978,
0.4099017083644867,
-0.6074013113975525,
0.09909604489803314,
-0.2513048052787781,
-0.2794235646724701,
-0.5973740220069885,
-0.004231829196214676,
0.4753427803516388,
0.2415175437927246,
-0.745029628276825,
-0.055456142872571945,
-0.09093563258647919,
0.6115282773971558,
-0.412871778011322,
-0.15257741510868073,
-0.3320019245147705,
0.20820748805999756,
0.17497889697551727,
0.0003157860483042896,
-0.3339127004146576,
-0.7538840770721436,
0.006050627678632736,
-0.9635047316551208,
-0.01655862107872963,
0.37481963634490967,
1.075395107269287,
0.33929142355918884,
-0.504712700843811,
-0.037354812026023865,
-0.6835601925849915,
0.6502331495285034,
-0.760661244392395,
0.5472404956817627,
0.2143993228673935,
0.4568799138069153,
-0.46519437432289124,
-0.24075429141521454,
-0.8971830010414124,
-0.23414893448352814,
-0.09514756500720978,
0.11183888465166092,
0.1250932216644287,
0.16067323088645935,
0.1133149191737175,
-0.01359640620648861,
-0.80046147108078,
0.43813255429267883,
-0.06252545863389969,
-0.2716314196586609,
0.7774163484573364,
0.2454858124256134,
0.4177285134792328,
0.16470257937908173,
-0.4923631250858307,
-0.3563317358493805,
-0.6775658130645752,
0.13084326684474945,
0.8137370347976685,
0.41951268911361694,
-0.22837884724140167,
0.4808051884174347,
0.10902861505746841,
0.8663445115089417,
0.5505817532539368,
-0.331582635641098,
0.10911683738231659,
-0.12239311635494232,
-0.1310148984193802,
0.3353966772556305,
0.8027394413948059,
0.3835253417491913,
0.35589420795440674,
-0.22926898300647736,
-0.14867784082889557,
0.08964721858501434,
0.8189918994903564,
-0.5076959133148193,
0.003214813768863678,
0.07937470823526382,
-0.3405246138572693,
-0.3737310767173767,
0.16627810895442963,
-0.7903513312339783,
-0.6461484432220459,
-0.6664976477622986,
0.3863765001296997,
-0.22718390822410583,
-0.5121288895606995,
0.018203159794211388,
0.2751443088054657,
0.40425798296928406,
0.2316073477268219,
-1.131986379623413,
0.3972582519054413,
0.9676002264022827,
0.6162917017936707,
-0.4089200794696808,
-0.3455421030521393,
-0.7875595688819885,
0.24922363460063934,
-0.38352909684181213,
0.5194238424301147,
-0.28794947266578674,
0.0019668908789753914,
0.15143105387687683,
-0.07190161198377609,
-0.11573774367570877,
-0.5609603524208069,
0.3854556083679199,
-0.8312707543373108,
0.461153119802475,
-0.055517297238111496,
-0.7347624897956848,
-0.0757705345749855,
0.5596296191215515,
-0.7449480891227722,
0.9935634136199951,
-0.05935914069414139,
-0.5526527166366577,
0.2198115736246109,
-0.7052198052406311,
-0.3416040241718292,
-0.16580812633037567,
-0.15676304697990417,
-0.8379623293876648,
-0.16194985806941986,
0.2211552858352661,
0.3000994026660919,
0.18301840126514435,
0.6203776597976685,
-0.5507612824440002,
-0.4034530818462372,
0.6662988662719727,
-0.19584184885025024,
0.7072526812553406,
0.2493886947631836,
-0.24496044218540192,
0.587714433670044,
-0.5126282572746277,
0.046094123274087906,
0.2240079790353775,
-0.7665402293205261,
-0.08013490587472916,
0.22294987738132477,
-0.11835338920354843,
0.46923351287841797,
0.2316095530986786,
-0.5132986307144165,
0.4532451629638672,
-0.5652377605438232,
0.2289036065340042,
1.0228352546691895,
-0.23872241377830505,
0.5638967156410217,
-0.47216805815696716,
0.7465059161186218,
-0.3221573233604431,
0.07057709991931915,
0.5437714457511902,
-0.0774284079670906,
-0.672727108001709,
-0.2791190445423126,
0.06823846697807312,
0.5550029277801514,
-0.3908888101577759,
0.7573346495628357,
-0.5321151614189148,
-0.13767199218273163,
-0.7303792238235474,
0.07052677124738693,
0.6757307648658752,
0.31272202730178833,
0.22698858380317688,
-0.0009850499918684363,
-0.7426794767379761,
-0.727180004119873,
-0.4228965938091278,
-0.22594793140888214,
-0.002468667458742857,
0.09116271883249283,
0.11103621870279312,
-0.1824445128440857,
1.1389000415802002,
-0.46542856097221375,
-0.1393834948539734,
-0.35319340229034424,
0.2229132056236267,
-0.20075944066047668,
0.28051120042800903,
0.2435963749885559,
-0.7964920401573181,
-0.36847805976867676,
-0.03073536790907383,
-0.6992888450622559,
0.07794589549303055,
-0.1752219945192337,
-0.320789635181427,
0.29697057604789734,
0.4258502721786499,
-0.5069072246551514,
-0.04783998429775238,
0.7556665539741516,
-0.22845622897148132,
0.2570156455039978,
-0.3459066152572632,
0.08343328535556793,
-1.145379662513733,
-0.09098697453737259,
0.20884151756763458,
-0.6687526702880859,
-0.5833266377449036,
0.06688956171274185,
0.12948518991470337,
-0.051392391324043274,
-0.519698441028595,
0.6809235215187073,
-0.3259700834751129,
-0.41741690039634705,
-0.25860825181007385,
0.206344336271286,
-0.033562615513801575,
0.6330417394638062,
0.2588805854320526,
0.8120236396789551,
-0.016955675557255745,
-0.7701808214187622,
0.7293356657028198,
0.3822348415851593,
-0.4386126399040222,
0.7502611875534058,
-0.2657727301120758,
0.11714467406272888,
-0.2696373462677002,
0.48150354623794556,
-0.7452571988105774,
-0.4090152680873871,
0.31094396114349365,
-0.3533813953399658,
0.3481106758117676,
0.11302715539932251,
-0.2822296619415283,
-0.23650358617305756,
-0.36020636558532715,
0.09745066612958908,
0.3700942099094391,
-0.7177078127861023,
0.7106326222419739,
0.3940616250038147,
0.05312712490558624,
-0.46935734152793884,
-0.4874171018600464,
-0.031243333593010902,
-0.4681158661842346,
-0.5519124865531921,
0.5255404114723206,
-0.19599249958992004,
-0.3154543936252594,
-0.16987182199954987,
0.17572356760501862,
0.051285725086927414,
0.2464292049407959,
0.04803360253572464,
0.5573707818984985,
-0.12623389065265656,
0.06782467663288116,
-0.5568013191223145,
0.04910283908247948,
-0.11451002210378647,
-0.05815253034234047,
0.5180889964103699,
0.019473593682050705,
-0.4943481683731079,
-0.6103819012641907,
0.05438779294490814,
0.27565234899520874,
-0.07789979875087738,
0.7532963156700134,
0.6966763138771057,
-0.2065628170967102,
-0.036932166665792465,
-0.39847543835639954,
-0.24734382331371307,
-0.4950231909751892,
0.49592509865760803,
0.02546338550746441,
-0.8716464638710022,
0.12440524250268936,
0.17871199548244476,
0.030026037245988846,
-0.12717875838279724,
0.5274232029914856,
-0.32555726170539856,
1.449723720550537,
0.6884598135948181,
-0.09342896193265915,
0.6327340006828308,
0.3485807180404663,
0.5321401357650757,
-0.8177443742752075,
-0.27061545848846436,
-0.1974143534898758,
-0.46158358454704285,
-0.6568107008934021,
-0.12053357064723969,
0.17799769341945648,
0.09730412811040878,
-0.6989961266517639,
0.3763220012187958,
-0.37496137619018555,
0.3185717463493347,
0.3471544086933136,
0.31581753492355347,
0.04019227996468544,
-0.008868670091032982,
-0.07870665937662125,
-0.2882538139820099,
-0.445768803358078,
-0.4701330363750458,
0.7384645938873291,
0.37436431646347046,
0.8557026386260986,
0.6265994310379028,
0.46136561036109924,
0.2941298186779022,
0.4765944480895996,
-0.8036249279975891,
0.44913965463638306,
0.2196345031261444,
-0.6638810038566589,
-0.3875112235546112,
-0.4138823449611664,
-0.9311952590942383,
0.41517606377601624,
-0.5114591717720032,
-0.7266369462013245,
-0.3251608610153198,
0.4732494652271271,
-0.5669997334480286,
0.24299919605255127,
-0.36521658301353455,
0.9115567207336426,
-0.974371612071991,
-0.45078223943710327,
-0.25611570477485657,
-0.6732853651046753,
0.5288662314414978,
0.03743968904018402,
0.4382951259613037,
-0.180395245552063,
0.04295215383172035,
0.711420476436615,
-0.2530570328235626,
0.9660401940345764,
-0.1431839019060135,
-0.2424391508102417,
-0.17919933795928955,
0.1376560926437378,
0.9731412529945374,
-0.4364296793937683,
0.08882085978984833,
-0.36140599846839905,
-0.3603707253932953,
-0.22768308222293854,
-0.5703149437904358,
0.7522914409637451,
-0.9708285331726074,
-0.5124365091323853,
-0.5572086572647095,
-0.3038819134235382,
-0.5516223311424255,
-0.08706670254468918,
-0.1513710469007492,
0.01100842747837305,
-0.5424867272377014,
-0.14455896615982056,
0.8053956627845764,
-0.2782258689403534,
0.34204983711242676,
0.6756917238235474,
-0.5327887535095215,
-0.47702810168266296,
1.2044492959976196,
-0.4282439649105072,
0.31461474299430847,
0.6140747666358948,
0.3831564486026764,
-0.6444681882858276,
-0.09959546476602554,
-0.5259906053543091,
0.2915985584259033,
-0.5174788236618042,
-0.062326859682798386,
-0.48919954895973206,
0.05042403191328049,
-0.613200843334198,
-0.39073243737220764,
-0.18628185987472534,
0.0003312488261144608,
-0.3224753439426422,
-0.31081080436706543,
0.23602959513664246,
0.6640416383743286,
0.06971564888954163,
0.4295955300331116,
-0.7731189131736755,
0.4770768880844116,
0.6629567742347717,
0.27579107880592346,
0.0360475592315197,
-0.48452767729759216,
-0.1317749172449112,
0.18971340358257294,
-0.46658754348754883,
-0.6034712791442871,
0.44351696968078613,
0.27839744091033936,
0.7616000175476074,
0.593923032283783,
0.01858527399599552,
0.9563398957252502,
-0.3304865062236786,
0.5766359567642212,
0.37782084941864014,
-0.6834708452224731,
0.22505298256874084,
-0.34365007281303406,
-0.022167682647705078,
0.3892931342124939,
0.5054038166999817,
-0.7708499431610107,
-0.014627194963395596,
-0.4173412621021271,
-0.5876371264457703,
0.8035638332366943,
-0.09677048772573471,
-0.009425901807844639,
0.07156301289796829,
0.10032910108566284,
-0.14368128776550293,
0.19993971288204193,
-1.024243950843811,
0.038383107632398605,
-0.26180049777030945,
-0.5178347826004028,
0.139957457780838,
0.1774006187915802,
-0.22477179765701294,
-0.08573252707719803,
0.9219284653663635,
-0.32857877016067505,
0.11204025894403458,
-0.4588944911956787,
-0.31499069929122925,
-0.35589057207107544,
0.1950346976518631,
0.6838995218276978,
0.6090537309646606,
-0.1943017691373825,
-0.08775755763053894,
0.028612559661269188,
-0.043388474732637405,
0.41928187012672424,
-0.15967431664466858,
0.0072761825285851955,
-0.6755011081695557,
0.26537391543388367,
0.8604279160499573,
0.5542547106742859,
-0.9001436829566956,
0.6615430116653442,
-0.23271150887012482,
-0.008602051064372063,
-0.33869749307632446,
0.22329342365264893,
0.3948611617088318,
0.17664383351802826,
-0.10056215524673462,
-0.2658228278160095,
-0.41458407044410706,
-0.5764963030815125,
0.13022805750370026,
0.6418771743774414,
-0.4714455306529999,
-0.22405368089675903,
0.688667893409729,
0.39636847376823425,
-0.5249005556106567,
0.6986687183380127,
-0.23410242795944214,
-0.6564462184906006,
0.4985654652118683,
0.779495894908905,
0.6210882067680359,
-0.22010952234268188,
0.2994474172592163,
0.47608304023742676,
-0.14212572574615479,
-0.4121525287628174,
0.003728794865310192,
0.11909276992082596,
-1.0252577066421509,
-0.45775407552719116,
-0.8775360584259033,
-0.31231406331062317,
0.07560136914253235,
-0.6186853647232056,
0.29862383008003235,
-0.47219982743263245,
0.02640005573630333,
-0.1424989253282547,
-0.1429763287305832,
-0.30453911423683167,
0.158132866024971,
0.310576856136322,
0.21031321585178375,
-0.8406527042388916,
0.8858304619789124,
0.7502844333648682,
-0.4324127435684204,
-0.8257191181182861,
0.11871249973773956,
0.3688144385814667,
-1.0575536489486694,
0.6773757338523865,
0.1816411167383194,
-0.2935240864753723,
0.1800410896539688,
-0.4590405523777008,
-0.9291645288467407,
0.9938916563987732,
0.39228326082229614,
-0.6707620024681091,
-0.0684489980340004,
-0.10318548232316971,
0.4952906668186188,
-0.35781461000442505,
0.034514229744672775,
0.3532945215702057,
0.5994323492050171,
-0.029471782967448235,
-0.7427648901939392,
0.10541042685508728,
0.19515405595302582,
0.0754784494638443,
0.5110880732536316,
-0.6035104990005493,
0.5131729245185852,
-0.06793727725744247,
-0.42149728536605835,
0.01196857076138258,
0.7090007662773132,
0.3859260678291321,
-0.21374383568763733,
0.593723714351654,
0.7902613878250122,
0.801435112953186,
0.1127273365855217,
0.8045329451560974,
-0.003993913996964693,
0.28486624360084534,
1.192496418952942,
-0.5894346237182617,
0.8711355328559875,
0.3920349180698395,
-0.4693654477596283,
0.5400140881538391,
0.7976101040840149,
0.1324639618396759,
0.5317859053611755,
0.43013995885849,
-0.3928261697292328,
-0.6241858005523682,
-0.1057845950126648,
-0.08527404069900513,
0.31861358880996704,
0.1680225282907486,
0.17737002670764923,
-0.06663867086172104,
-0.04748188331723213,
0.08147091418504715,
0.5378813743591309,
-0.16561102867126465,
1.2182087898254395,
-0.238458514213562,
-1.1537336111068726,
0.4398711621761322,
0.18728160858154297,
1.0908393859863281,
-0.6110648512840271,
0.025126878172159195,
-0.06963489949703217,
0.3128276765346527,
-0.30421534180641174,
-0.6320019960403442,
0.13550159335136414,
-0.09751126915216446,
-0.08321242779493332,
-0.3393322229385376,
0.4187089204788208,
-0.5664810538291931,
-0.2934218943119049,
0.3620448708534241,
0.147699236869812,
-0.08664809167385101,
0.19709412753582,
-0.8688295483589172,
-0.14216548204421997,
-0.034643612802028656,
-0.12855671346187592,
0.8848151564598083,
-0.09766755998134613,
-0.22983577847480774,
0.7373268604278564,
0.8478818535804749,
0.12972353398799896,
0.09821965545415878,
0.0454411543905735,
0.4414798617362976,
-0.7100335359573364,
-0.6191384196281433,
-0.778285562992096,
0.3206109404563904,
-0.2299337536096573,
-0.057333894073963165,
0.47741225361824036,
0.4070816934108734,
0.9021804928779602,
0.13710138201713562,
0.7866805791854858,
0.0030617702286690474,
0.4854097068309784,
-0.638915479183197,
0.43214428424835205,
-0.3977679908275604,
0.02729080803692341,
0.22696836292743683,
-0.9287263751029968,
-0.07803872972726822,
0.853726327419281,
-0.012823743745684624,
-0.029306819662451744,
0.3625320494174957,
1.0147385597229004,
-0.22871048748493195,
-0.34004321694374084,
0.32786625623703003,
-0.154860720038414,
0.5291132926940918,
0.25466740131378174,
0.8697569370269775,
0.04557942971587181,
0.5029971599578857,
-0.051909156143665314,
-0.01765650138258934,
-0.5147965550422668,
-1.196079134941101,
-0.6582985520362854,
-0.1721869707107544,
-0.22502250969409943,
-0.40975379943847656,
0.13599523901939392,
1.556982398033142,
0.667320728302002,
-0.7279943227767944,
-0.29501622915267944,
-0.1398087739944458,
0.04157564416527748,
-0.40741807222366333,
-0.2758996784687042,
0.1450904756784439,
-0.28045853972435,
-0.5151405334472656,
0.5519457459449768,
0.0611436665058136,
0.14816409349441528,
-0.5647351741790771,
-0.7787260413169861,
-0.5789880752563477,
0.006282253190875053,
0.2682226002216339,
0.5610678195953369,
-0.9767811298370361,
-0.45774009823799133,
-0.1588805913925171,
-0.44059067964553833,
0.1834864765405655,
0.785051703453064,
-0.6647975444793701,
0.44039830565452576,
0.42165350914001465,
0.7887980937957764,
0.23916685581207275,
0.5413392186164856,
0.8962869644165039,
-0.7993696331977844,
-0.1098983883857727,
0.18343962728977203,
0.23892301321029663,
0.6333997845649719,
-0.36105865240097046,
0.14621064066886902,
-0.040545184165239334,
-0.6507071852684021,
-0.48100733757019043,
0.41443371772766113,
-0.7438934445381165,
-0.3080213963985443,
1.1155263185501099,
-0.12951719760894775,
-0.22204402089118958,
-0.17810849845409393,
-0.08734072744846344,
0.5162885785102844,
-0.5012040138244629,
0.9999505281448364,
0.6148143410682678,
-0.4203534424304962,
-0.009806605987250805,
-0.43913570046424866,
0.6012089252471924,
0.3160419464111328,
-1.0760186910629272,
0.16701216995716095,
0.6319979429244995,
0.21060062944889069,
-0.07227067649364471,
0.43248414993286133,
0.27171197533607483,
0.04688103869557381,
-0.6219176650047302,
0.35096460580825806,
-0.0255934726446867,
-0.043983254581689835,
-0.5130629539489746,
-0.12455379962921143,
0.293689101934433,
-0.026118211448192596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00566v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00566v1
|
NumLLM: Numeric-Sensitive Large Language Model for Chinese Finance
| 2024-05-01T15:17:27 | 2024-05-01T15:17:27 |
Huan-Yi Su, Ke Wu, Yu-Hao Huang, Wu-Jun Li
|
cs.CE
|
cs.CE, cs.CL, q-fin.GN
|
Recently, many works have proposed various financial large language models
(FinLLMs) by pre-training from scratch or fine-tuning open-sourced LLMs on
financial corpora. However, existing FinLLMs exhibit unsatisfactory performance
in understanding financial text when numeric variables are involved in
questions. In this paper, we propose a novel LLM, called numeric-sensitive
large language model (NumLLM), for Chinese finance. We first construct a
financial corpus from financial textbooks which is essential for improving
numeric capability of LLMs during fine-tuning. After that, we train two
individual low-rank adaptation (LoRA) modules by fine-tuning on our constructed
financial corpus. One module is for adapting general-purpose LLMs to financial
domain, and the other module is for enhancing the ability of NumLLM to
understand financial text with numeric variables. Lastly, we merge the two LoRA
modules into the foundation model to obtain NumLLM for inference. Experiments
on financial question-answering benchmark show that NumLLM can boost the
performance of the foundation model and can achieve the best overall
performance compared to all baselines, on both numeric and non-numeric
questions.
|
[
-0.0708095133304596,
-1.0292245149612427,
0.04916459694504738,
0.3952723443508148,
-0.47582167387008667,
0.17610906064510345,
-0.3599872887134552,
-0.3806317448616028,
-0.25680744647979736,
0.8676670789718628,
-0.05035340413451195,
-0.7350325584411621,
-0.3303992748260498,
-0.04751600697636604,
-0.2993355989456177,
1.1945686340332031,
0.2928983271121979,
0.12152229249477386,
-0.007806063629686832,
-0.07073993980884552,
-0.3475923538208008,
-0.5956388115882874,
-0.7481101751327515,
-0.23726628720760345,
0.3104434907436371,
0.2306383103132248,
0.7130531668663025,
0.3468713164329529,
0.670520007610321,
0.2971138656139374,
-0.20020532608032227,
-0.049375880509614944,
-0.5321117043495178,
-0.15763764083385468,
0.11519934237003326,
-0.4865076541900635,
-0.8964413404464722,
-0.2433762103319168,
0.7823589444160461,
0.7164020538330078,
-0.05549190565943718,
0.3334902822971344,
0.1373409628868103,
0.6759520173072815,
-0.6265156269073486,
0.3946787714958191,
-0.6310350298881531,
-0.09046275168657303,
0.09937458485364914,
-0.21961988508701324,
-0.700497031211853,
-0.46056777238845825,
0.14028893411159515,
-0.6837957501411438,
-0.01816144399344921,
-0.05720735341310501,
0.39970120787620544,
0.3783535063266754,
-0.6344115734100342,
0.016583656892180443,
-0.42042770981788635,
0.7248768210411072,
-1.0571178197860718,
-0.016575252637267113,
0.43846482038497925,
0.272360235452652,
0.08451516181230545,
-0.5332298874855042,
0.012836713343858719,
-0.3828337788581848,
-0.08817000687122345,
-0.12455764412879944,
0.01717640645802021,
-0.15283946692943573,
0.29949894547462463,
0.2209959775209427,
-0.5649906396865845,
0.3174166977405548,
-0.25060299038887024,
-0.0304938405752182,
0.7902820706367493,
0.20535096526145935,
0.010966408997774124,
0.05332593619823456,
-0.7583511471748352,
-0.14721699059009552,
-0.828732967376709,
-0.009994364343583584,
-0.03310902789235115,
0.6322185397148132,
-0.41694319248199463,
0.2703707814216614,
-0.04545779526233673,
0.8543561697006226,
-0.05616649612784386,
-0.29666998982429504,
0.15814609825611115,
-0.04164343327283859,
-0.599689781665802,
0.3687538206577301,
0.2924685776233673,
0.19678834080696106,
0.4258960783481598,
0.12507547438144684,
-0.4459924101829529,
-0.32387760281562805,
-0.07684007287025452,
-0.8216286301612854,
-0.2139437049627304,
0.23688307404518127,
-0.4373569190502167,
-0.5562183856964111,
0.0870886817574501,
-0.6007689237594604,
-0.5437468886375427,
-0.2532212734222412,
0.5114269852638245,
-0.30210497975349426,
-0.2836024761199951,
0.23601295053958893,
0.019716138020157814,
0.6686742305755615,
0.4010351896286011,
-0.9706634879112244,
0.2535693049430847,
1.0493746995925903,
0.7246173620223999,
0.023925183340907097,
-0.06950432062149048,
-0.9360781908035278,
0.32289546728134155,
-0.2774219512939453,
0.7503677606582642,
-0.36048460006713867,
-0.40143904089927673,
-0.1415780782699585,
-0.30514320731163025,
-0.06105271726846695,
-0.5166199207305908,
0.0603262223303318,
-0.7006487846374512,
-0.01719622127711773,
-0.004505365155637264,
-0.4818451702594757,
-0.10885263234376907,
0.31876465678215027,
-0.7684486508369446,
0.7845335006713867,
0.24827399849891663,
-0.7634981870651245,
0.2896483242511749,
-0.9880300760269165,
-0.40328723192214966,
0.4315333068370819,
-0.038621578365564346,
-0.48498088121414185,
-0.1722153276205063,
-0.04651324078440666,
0.38023191690444946,
-0.5300542712211609,
0.591457724571228,
-0.47141408920288086,
-0.6288045644760132,
0.8204882144927979,
-0.6046227812767029,
0.7470113635063171,
0.058216921985149384,
-0.2864547371864319,
0.27315661311149597,
-0.9406613707542419,
0.006623547989875078,
0.03929625451564789,
-0.24872171878814697,
-0.6758310794830322,
-0.3493903577327728,
0.2834600508213043,
-0.14297878742218018,
0.6247480511665344,
-0.06310423463582993,
0.13433876633644104,
-0.6074293255805969,
0.4646974503993988,
0.9841281771659851,
-0.11248163878917694,
0.4871572256088257,
-0.31335383653640747,
0.3517923355102539,
-0.09539148211479187,
0.11512285470962524,
-0.01982763037085533,
-0.22637557983398438,
-0.505370557308197,
-0.1529712975025177,
0.48880472779273987,
0.387534499168396,
-0.5318971276283264,
0.2220032662153244,
-0.013475676998496056,
-0.3565012812614441,
-0.2213025689125061,
0.2808355689048767,
0.2721666395664215,
0.3495550751686096,
0.145613431930542,
0.05989488959312439,
-0.2871360182762146,
-0.6950371861457825,
-0.18973958492279053,
-0.3187641203403473,
-0.09120695292949677,
0.20890451967716217,
0.44686970114707947,
0.3331701457500458,
0.7322452068328857,
-0.7819004654884338,
-0.13068541884422302,
-0.24256853759288788,
0.22724880278110504,
0.6536426544189453,
0.3703038692474365,
0.8626841902732849,
-1.2119828462600708,
-0.6019932627677917,
0.21973831951618195,
-0.44198471307754517,
-0.19020476937294006,
-0.21076299250125885,
-0.03223944082856178,
0.3210979998111725,
0.5747115612030029,
-0.3421812057495117,
0.4318237900733948,
0.5305299162864685,
-0.7742346525192261,
0.21658217906951904,
-0.45566216111183167,
-0.3946669399738312,
-0.9380816221237183,
0.3568357527256012,
-0.03147562965750694,
-0.07216477394104004,
-0.7435791492462158,
0.09271089732646942,
0.35410434007644653,
0.15558433532714844,
-0.5003715753555298,
0.8721816539764404,
-0.3748392164707184,
-0.3072523772716522,
-0.48573121428489685,
0.31354039907455444,
0.08554266393184662,
0.4824391305446625,
-0.08907226473093033,
0.7119750380516052,
0.31897208094596863,
-0.6094807386398315,
0.2291402667760849,
0.20137497782707214,
-0.4774702191352844,
0.43220359086990356,
-0.6937069296836853,
-0.10823442041873932,
0.059681814163923264,
0.04786904901266098,
-1.0426421165466309,
0.10168491303920746,
0.12853746116161346,
-0.13035541772842407,
0.26009756326675415,
-0.008134989999234676,
-0.10904160887002945,
-0.057749178260564804,
-0.1815883070230484,
0.556283712387085,
0.3933382034301758,
-0.3267251253128052,
0.5960590839385986,
0.11848097294569016,
-0.47483205795288086,
-0.6161572337150574,
-0.48952654004096985,
0.005058689974248409,
-0.41918709874153137,
-0.5778152346611023,
0.09884737432003021,
-0.2895961105823517,
-0.5991175174713135,
-0.15841826796531677,
0.06989244371652603,
-0.14960156381130219,
0.7745085954666138,
0.14941389858722687,
0.8844783902168274,
-0.7744137644767761,
0.32788777351379395,
-0.35612285137176514,
-0.3798145055770874,
0.0076362756080925465,
-0.21171076595783234,
0.4517951011657715,
-0.2711760997772217,
-0.13740767538547516,
0.24008217453956604,
-0.04028240963816643,
0.49961230158805847,
-0.37950557470321655,
0.8544901609420776,
0.44630488753318787,
-0.2089289426803589,
-0.37799930572509766,
-0.31146907806396484,
0.016091953963041306,
-0.484392911195755,
0.42048975825309753,
-0.29087260365486145,
-1.0481669902801514,
0.3450877070426941,
0.030310623347759247,
0.07544199377298355,
0.7301580905914307,
0.9023162722587585,
0.3684854805469513,
0.5067328214645386,
0.7474303841590881,
-0.36304745078086853,
0.22772179543972015,
-0.1604476273059845,
0.13101857900619507,
-0.3782828450202942,
-0.04329248517751694,
-0.620066225528717,
-0.29363319277763367,
-0.2797720730304718,
-0.3619534373283386,
0.19675618410110474,
-0.017247026786208153,
-0.6325380206108093,
0.18054290115833282,
-0.018854517489671707,
0.578546941280365,
0.2422199845314026,
-0.25557741522789,
0.6289738416671753,
-0.1919085681438446,
0.0024935146793723106,
0.18450406193733215,
-0.5036303997039795,
-0.4025111496448517,
1.053802490234375,
0.39439859986305237,
0.9082333445549011,
0.20465348660945892,
0.07505403459072113,
0.31405404210090637,
0.6801254749298096,
-0.4488382041454315,
0.2797980010509491,
-0.6071641445159912,
-0.4451883137226105,
-0.6430851817131042,
-0.6762869954109192,
-0.5141005516052246,
0.23836271464824677,
-0.13780303299427032,
-0.4531891644001007,
0.02789887599647045,
-0.19058988988399506,
-0.8744783997535706,
0.18348877131938934,
-0.2970043122768402,
0.845914363861084,
-0.6781042218208313,
-0.2597077190876007,
0.15713949501514435,
-0.5403416752815247,
0.609252393245697,
-0.7358905076980591,
0.3661085367202759,
-0.39582836627960205,
-0.1907426118850708,
0.5013515949249268,
-0.23034149408340454,
1.1040369272232056,
-0.08286131173372269,
-0.6791900396347046,
-0.021914130076766014,
-0.12358297407627106,
0.44762179255485535,
0.26809293031692505,
-0.4144890606403351,
0.227009579539299,
-0.024493753910064697,
-0.3595772683620453,
-0.5465416312217712,
0.652769923210144,
-0.7950382828712463,
-0.5241295695304871,
-0.3388040065765381,
-0.8821475505828857,
-0.15242359042167664,
0.2092069387435913,
-0.09914034605026245,
0.20862746238708496,
-0.42459776997566223,
0.5683945417404175,
0.3965217173099518,
-0.39657464623451233,
0.4255176782608032,
0.9417872428894043,
-0.48332738876342773,
-0.42130953073501587,
0.6709286570549011,
-0.07622947543859482,
0.42727917432785034,
0.7377620935440063,
0.31565943360328674,
-0.3243510127067566,
-0.3392358422279358,
-0.17246925830841064,
0.2213304340839386,
-0.5926993489265442,
-0.2757507860660553,
-0.39850741624832153,
-0.5051000118255615,
-0.5773172378540039,
-0.233228862285614,
-0.09836087375879288,
-0.31506696343421936,
-0.5399294495582581,
-0.11387671530246735,
0.7994046211242676,
0.6322423815727234,
-0.15553270280361176,
0.13741275668144226,
-0.8726064562797546,
0.6459702253341675,
0.3242861032485962,
0.5018450617790222,
0.1701517552137375,
-1.029831051826477,
-0.4637569189071655,
0.08906280994415283,
0.20618899166584015,
-0.27283409237861633,
0.5984150171279907,
0.20164650678634644,
0.35245388746261597,
0.7790889739990234,
0.40598034858703613,
0.5675382018089294,
0.1525690108537674,
0.27436110377311707,
-0.03195078670978546,
-0.8035239577293396,
0.09420182555913925,
-0.20428794622421265,
0.43467098474502563,
0.4885239899158478,
0.0868833139538765,
-0.6464296579360962,
-0.2510252296924591,
-0.18031831085681915,
-0.9424593448638916,
0.6164668202400208,
0.024428725242614746,
0.20154830813407898,
0.19110392034053802,
0.46985894441604614,
0.267330139875412,
0.3066229820251465,
-0.7844401001930237,
-0.16728182137012482,
0.006306379567831755,
-0.0186027679592371,
-0.34683865308761597,
-0.3931632339954376,
0.04360944777727127,
-0.13397666811943054,
0.6475178599357605,
-0.425530344247818,
-0.3446674644947052,
-0.21670500934123993,
0.019376318901777267,
-0.11824024468660355,
0.16429373621940613,
0.631477415561676,
0.6649692058563232,
-0.44521456956863403,
0.061156149953603745,
0.43555331230163574,
-0.4215194284915924,
0.02619750052690506,
-0.03612364083528519,
-0.2093181163072586,
-0.1394011676311493,
0.3416222333908081,
0.781125009059906,
0.8815750479698181,
-0.7738674283027649,
0.5437177419662476,
-0.13837501406669617,
-0.42451924085617065,
-0.5571213960647583,
0.15851333737373352,
0.23304449021816254,
0.3458150327205658,
0.547716498374939,
-0.2569136321544647,
-0.18010295927524567,
-0.33991873264312744,
0.2783442735671997,
0.35652956366539,
-0.31902432441711426,
0.021839125081896782,
0.8071333169937134,
0.24962088465690613,
-0.11227580904960632,
0.5506990551948547,
0.29726019501686096,
-0.39375415444374084,
1.0182113647460938,
0.7444939017295837,
0.9744016528129578,
-0.15615741908550262,
0.3803621828556061,
0.10374753177165985,
0.14545969665050507,
-0.1216980442404747,
0.37626445293426514,
0.1006498709321022,
-0.6425598859786987,
-0.5922293066978455,
-0.8493049740791321,
-0.5748657584190369,
0.12969940900802612,
-0.7069360613822937,
0.5699602365493774,
-0.8321881294250488,
-0.012119785882532597,
0.08363787084817886,
-0.06404536962509155,
-0.2645456790924072,
0.1347341537475586,
0.38713619112968445,
1.2172505855560303,
-0.6436078548431396,
0.8223616480827332,
0.4492241442203522,
-0.14636386930942535,
-0.5390647053718567,
-0.3938746750354767,
-0.2624379098415375,
-0.928371250629425,
0.7587348818778992,
0.03571901097893715,
0.20584861934185028,
0.05625433474779129,
-0.5271226167678833,
-0.9347467422485352,
1.252475619316101,
0.46547865867614746,
-0.6077147722244263,
-0.03668597340583801,
0.5758686065673828,
0.4275510311126709,
-0.5059791207313538,
-0.052688781172037125,
0.49962398409843445,
0.7615983486175537,
0.29717352986335754,
-0.5625513792037964,
-0.15032730996608734,
-0.3978126049041748,
-0.14656025171279907,
0.39464423060417175,
-0.9796341061592102,
1.2543997764587402,
-0.26155003905296326,
0.16578297317028046,
0.4172487258911133,
0.5665333271026611,
0.4312712252140045,
0.6927017569541931,
0.4379459619522095,
0.14643190801143646,
0.8410800099372864,
0.023733099922537804,
0.818432092666626,
-0.6222248077392578,
0.46764668822288513,
1.1707090139389038,
-0.5913828015327454,
1.05251145362854,
0.13502603769302368,
-0.124715656042099,
0.22928458452224731,
0.3838528096675873,
-0.4110075831413269,
0.19442488253116608,
0.40132689476013184,
-0.32185128331184387,
-0.523760974407196,
0.026440920308232307,
-0.625945508480072,
0.6170607805252075,
0.129378542304039,
-0.32107824087142944,
0.012987491674721241,
-0.1468091458082199,
-0.24143736064434052,
-0.0319635309278965,
-0.43750500679016113,
0.793815553188324,
0.5683271288871765,
-0.23832160234451294,
0.3939228057861328,
0.257633775472641,
0.4300557076931,
-0.7703879475593567,
0.00036098682903684676,
-0.48273324966430664,
0.1834845393896103,
0.03345249965786934,
-0.40567076206207275,
0.05688265338540077,
0.1745109111070633,
-0.009775135666131973,
-0.0009187294635921717,
0.994706392288208,
-0.42620718479156494,
-0.8530628681182861,
0.30258458852767944,
0.35149720311164856,
0.05711370334029198,
-0.29991239309310913,
-0.40773165225982666,
-0.35714107751846313,
-0.0745352953672409,
-0.24326865375041962,
0.491270512342453,
0.780931830406189,
-0.17074616253376007,
0.6423856616020203,
1.1388044357299805,
-0.1117882952094078,
-0.4377283751964569,
0.2828812301158905,
0.7242603898048401,
-1.347862720489502,
-0.7488883137702942,
-1.0638153553009033,
0.196760356426239,
0.0805220678448677,
-0.32560670375823975,
0.5647758841514587,
0.5165886282920837,
0.39696362614631653,
-0.14394663274288177,
0.7094669342041016,
0.6778848171234131,
0.11325483024120331,
-0.6913655996322632,
1.052459716796875,
-0.4016895294189453,
0.5873488187789917,
-0.37418076395988464,
-0.9778040647506714,
-0.6607413291931152,
0.42044100165367126,
-0.4342572093009949,
-0.07102962583303452,
0.27682504057884216,
0.4225744903087616,
0.16817592084407806,
0.30034348368644714,
0.8320671916007996,
0.604142963886261,
-0.12749511003494263,
0.7388352155685425,
0.7131819128990173,
-0.2426135390996933,
0.4888729751110077,
0.02985706366598606,
0.02946864441037178,
-0.722122848033905,
-1.0343152284622192,
-0.8883537650108337,
-0.015229812823235989,
-0.28831052780151367,
0.001095356303267181,
-0.3243368864059448,
0.7860250473022461,
-0.013002259656786919,
-0.814723789691925,
-0.5548694729804993,
0.46239081025123596,
0.21998131275177002,
0.12133757770061493,
-0.21117088198661804,
0.4713278114795685,
-0.029038406908512115,
-0.3722197711467743,
0.11106587201356888,
0.7724246382713318,
0.35107508301734924,
-0.4790450632572174,
-0.20895373821258545,
0.14124688506126404,
0.0570288822054863,
0.6815259456634521,
0.11977419257164001,
-0.254925012588501,
-0.07177763432264328,
0.2627047896385193,
-0.28507333993911743,
0.04631035029888153,
0.8266946077346802,
-0.5153277516365051,
-0.09118649363517761,
0.15362147986888885,
0.7382454872131348,
0.25442445278167725,
0.22139385342597961,
0.5812505483627319,
-0.24990665912628174,
0.229997918009758,
0.0423193983733654,
0.2793899178504944,
0.09737316519021988,
-0.4754980504512787,
0.49305254220962524,
-0.09694556146860123,
-0.38872405886650085,
-0.6380160450935364,
-0.3372778296470642,
-0.9891932606697083,
-0.618426501750946,
1.251919150352478,
-0.00856082420796156,
-0.6364841461181641,
-0.25859835743904114,
-0.2902492582798004,
-0.015485191717743874,
-0.25958386063575745,
0.7602917551994324,
0.48040056228637695,
0.622291088104248,
-0.05118553712964058,
-0.48310235142707825,
0.1847928911447525,
0.296800822019577,
-0.659892737865448,
0.3821655809879303,
0.19240179657936096,
0.16075372695922852,
-0.1687307357788086,
0.649681568145752,
0.014163704589009285,
0.5529723167419434,
-0.021610453724861145,
-0.12129534780979156,
-0.09183333814144135,
-0.043461158871650696,
-0.4196375012397766,
0.48019394278526306,
0.3665772080421448,
0.29012247920036316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00557v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00557v2
|
Mixture of insighTful Experts (MoTE): The Synergy of Thought Chains and Expert Mixtures in Self-Alignment
| 2024-05-01T15:06:05 | 2024-07-03T15:04:25 |
Zhili Liu, Yunhao Gou, Kai Chen, Lanqing Hong, Jiahui Gao, Fei Mi, Yu Zhang, Zhenguo Li, Xin Jiang, Qun Liu, James T. Kwok
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have expanded
dramatically, aligning these models with human values presents a significant
challenge. Traditional alignment strategies rely heavily on human intervention,
such as Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning from Human
Feedback (RLHF), or on the self-alignment capacities of LLMs, which usually
require a strong LLM's emergent ability to improve its original bad answer. To
address these challenges, we propose a novel self-alignment method that
utilizes a Chain of Thought (CoT) approach, termed AlignCoT. This method
encompasses stages of Question Analysis, Answer Guidance, and Safe Answer
production. It is designed to enable LLMs to generate high-quality, safe
responses throughout various stages of their development. Furthermore, we
introduce the Mixture of insighTful Experts (MoTE) architecture, which applies
mixture of experts to enhance each component of the AlignCoT process, markedly
increasing alignment efficiency. The MoTE approach not only outperforms
existing methods in aligning LLMs with human values but also highlights the
benefits of using self-generated data, revealing the dual benefits of improved
alignment and training efficiency.
|
[
-0.4119221866130829,
-0.5910055637359619,
0.43546563386917114,
-0.13611386716365814,
-0.13468550145626068,
0.6853612661361694,
-0.2450270652770996,
-0.3728872537612915,
0.40526315569877625,
0.5433000326156616,
-0.6932860016822815,
-0.30343952775001526,
-0.3214361369609833,
-0.02406603842973709,
-0.25503385066986084,
0.894719660282135,
-0.06641718745231628,
-0.04967234656214714,
-0.1824897825717926,
-0.250892698764801,
-0.43342921137809753,
-0.2923785150051117,
-0.32564979791641235,
-0.08928292989730835,
0.301338791847229,
0.5827672481536865,
0.7469860315322876,
0.8859821557998657,
0.5114646553993225,
0.3375590443611145,
0.2512810528278351,
0.6103333830833435,
-0.45377877354621887,
0.25596320629119873,
-0.7508430480957031,
-0.1508890837430954,
-0.5738124251365662,
0.04523105546832085,
0.05065680295228958,
0.47227638959884644,
-0.5051090717315674,
0.04525907337665558,
0.20313289761543274,
0.4586736261844635,
-0.5850238800048828,
-0.515145480632782,
-0.8849994540214539,
-0.1346997767686844,
-0.05256672948598862,
-0.21777865290641785,
-0.19465389847755432,
-0.19854912161827087,
0.0813976377248764,
-0.482555627822876,
0.17516446113586426,
0.2787439525127411,
0.5476576685905457,
0.48307281732559204,
-0.3773721754550934,
-0.20718039572238922,
-0.41990211606025696,
0.8046634793281555,
-0.9620386362075806,
0.15362122654914856,
-0.04056744650006294,
0.22472500801086426,
-0.4566277861595154,
-0.1556233912706375,
-0.7719503045082092,
0.4305001199245453,
0.06982091814279556,
0.27812737226486206,
0.33012115955352783,
-0.10147687792778015,
-0.35646453499794006,
0.20843353867530823,
-0.5801429748535156,
0.37207016348838806,
-0.06914155185222626,
-0.26884838938713074,
0.8467666506767273,
0.2582547068595886,
0.3635556995868683,
-0.03599508851766586,
-0.7124179601669312,
-0.10535147041082382,
-0.4117618799209595,
-0.28361353278160095,
0.3167966902256012,
0.23027385771274567,
0.17244412004947662,
0.5436182618141174,
-0.04871158301830292,
0.6990810632705688,
0.4854896068572998,
-0.44051307439804077,
0.06464486569166183,
-0.36775076389312744,
-0.05913107842206955,
0.3145122528076172,
1.120376706123352,
0.3501901924610138,
0.15724319219589233,
-0.19262807071208954,
-0.3294772207736969,
-0.13758881390094757,
0.3203177750110626,
-0.4266389310359955,
-0.18674910068511963,
0.3482566773891449,
-0.04740483686327934,
-0.5388860106468201,
0.0448375903069973,
-0.8055714964866638,
-0.5302980542182922,
-0.46272316575050354,
0.30871057510375977,
-0.4100363850593567,
-0.43164247274398804,
0.09029947966337204,
0.16301438212394714,
0.34455373883247375,
0.41792964935302734,
-1.1374577283859253,
0.3858938217163086,
0.7869552373886108,
0.4265362322330475,
-0.5201629400253296,
-0.270579993724823,
-0.31626641750335693,
0.4130770266056061,
-0.4250052571296692,
0.902556836605072,
-0.3270604610443115,
-0.2183101773262024,
-0.32953912019729614,
-0.3917014002799988,
-0.08367393910884857,
-0.47082287073135376,
0.2094782441854477,
-0.43788766860961914,
0.47149819135665894,
-0.23520299792289734,
-0.6335141658782959,
0.21279315650463104,
0.39245763421058655,
-0.19269967079162598,
1.1458287239074707,
0.17722827196121216,
-0.8618929982185364,
0.21523602306842804,
-0.2865629494190216,
-0.2447565495967865,
0.14188843965530396,
-0.683928370475769,
-0.04209630936384201,
0.03487123176455498,
0.4863583445549011,
0.2595905661582947,
-0.23491503298282623,
0.48079928755760193,
-0.2145088016986847,
0.20245018601417542,
0.40636518597602844,
-0.29864174127578735,
0.6120299696922302,
0.3312210440635681,
-0.4367468059062958,
0.18459376692771912,
-0.5582149028778076,
0.39407140016555786,
-0.13463714718818665,
-0.07262090593576431,
-0.3010728359222412,
-0.11006315797567368,
-0.458646684885025,
0.5821481347084045,
0.4581025242805481,
-0.5287656188011169,
0.2531956732273102,
-0.35649311542510986,
0.30840611457824707,
1.0654946565628052,
-0.02546793594956398,
0.41456228494644165,
-0.18180552124977112,
0.6366069316864014,
0.3114835321903229,
-0.09883701056241989,
0.1142236590385437,
-0.20959782600402832,
-0.7386361360549927,
-0.004646796267479658,
0.36492854356765747,
0.43190112709999084,
-0.6400724649429321,
0.8659152984619141,
-0.31834009289741516,
-0.4077088236808777,
-1.1001570224761963,
0.6086995005607605,
0.43848755955696106,
0.9045783281326294,
0.42235255241394043,
-0.3729797899723053,
-0.48483341932296753,
-0.9335432648658752,
-0.22106343507766724,
-0.13629956543445587,
0.27684861421585083,
0.032468363642692566,
0.25402265787124634,
-0.0718744769692421,
1.2518935203552246,
-0.5234395861625671,
0.048740193247795105,
-0.022821757942438126,
0.20074330270290375,
0.018947284668684006,
0.6801299452781677,
0.13580548763275146,
-0.39615875482559204,
-0.5842381715774536,
0.3622896075248718,
-0.599803626537323,
-0.09762520343065262,
0.04008663073182106,
-0.474420964717865,
0.1337403506040573,
0.3795188367366791,
-0.3286217749118805,
-0.1096043512225151,
0.500093400478363,
-0.17531731724739075,
0.38552868366241455,
-0.09509812295436859,
0.2047904133796692,
-1.473530650138855,
-0.1638636440038681,
-0.09719941020011902,
-0.41784536838531494,
-0.3888726532459259,
0.022818133234977722,
0.1454838216304779,
0.11850766837596893,
-0.3243403136730194,
0.46962109208106995,
-0.5508708953857422,
0.2039058804512024,
-0.2884770333766937,
0.493675172328949,
-0.04040225222706795,
0.4811336100101471,
-0.06818417459726334,
1.1573423147201538,
0.30007749795913696,
-0.32656770944595337,
0.24501702189445496,
0.4195120334625244,
-0.26556292176246643,
0.6630384922027588,
-0.32947996258735657,
0.5363222360610962,
-0.08449383080005646,
-0.048994868993759155,
-0.9390422701835632,
-0.2954629063606262,
0.025893155485391617,
-0.3111032247543335,
0.25220006704330444,
0.14407879114151,
-0.22716931998729706,
-0.3046806752681732,
-0.14800870418548584,
0.4642848074436188,
0.5168925523757935,
-0.47704169154167175,
0.6604188680648804,
0.6305875182151794,
-0.23319567739963531,
-0.8444948196411133,
-0.5130470991134644,
0.07077163457870483,
-0.20436523854732513,
-0.7382088303565979,
0.4047149419784546,
-0.04595101624727249,
-0.15729892253875732,
-0.06205325573682785,
-0.42576852440834045,
0.17480085790157318,
0.05415363982319832,
-0.26880472898483276,
0.22460414469242096,
-0.3311663568019867,
0.17536966502666473,
0.06362175196409225,
-0.08095960319042206,
-0.042365897446870804,
-0.5596960186958313,
0.532342255115509,
-0.11721307784318924,
-0.3422560691833496,
-0.28500470519065857,
0.4148370921611786,
0.5028040409088135,
-0.5034400820732117,
0.6386382579803467,
0.2807866930961609,
-0.12547899782657623,
-0.27872562408447266,
-0.8946661353111267,
-0.12263739109039307,
-0.4960542619228363,
0.17768028378486633,
-0.16855672001838684,
-0.8354344367980957,
0.3987867534160614,
0.02794341929256916,
0.0485198087990284,
0.46769365668296814,
0.5039899945259094,
-0.407106876373291,
1.1535769701004028,
0.5234476327896118,
-0.1400471329689026,
0.1731170117855072,
-0.0010207552695646882,
0.4689739942550659,
-0.989514172077179,
-0.3155982196331024,
-0.3323403298854828,
-0.4549427628517151,
-0.3902280628681183,
-0.3927915096282959,
0.27490687370300293,
0.08950228244066238,
-0.28554022312164307,
0.4398075044155121,
-0.7087242603302002,
0.5705613493919373,
0.3405177593231201,
0.24002300202846527,
0.19958212971687317,
-0.2650536000728607,
-0.33323222398757935,
0.02036864496767521,
-0.8524265885353088,
-0.6163308620452881,
0.8495886325836182,
0.1651315838098526,
1.130383849143982,
0.20201681554317474,
0.9031605124473572,
0.06444550305604935,
0.2100672572851181,
-0.5987749695777893,
0.6270132660865784,
0.0616084523499012,
-0.4615859389305115,
-0.38358908891677856,
-0.3289276957511902,
-0.6290904879570007,
0.254930704832077,
-0.2978104054927826,
-0.7595227360725403,
0.15214815735816956,
0.27321603894233704,
-0.5663575530052185,
0.19861751794815063,
-0.6450761556625366,
0.75103759765625,
-0.8024768233299255,
-0.44527968764305115,
-0.10359515249729156,
-0.9241681098937988,
0.3159676492214203,
-0.1957699954509735,
0.17109526693820953,
-0.15854458510875702,
-0.13498647511005402,
0.8038217425346375,
-0.5076523423194885,
0.7693786025047302,
0.2074582576751709,
-0.4449682831764221,
0.4891620874404907,
0.11380141228437424,
0.4858470559120178,
-0.3118225634098053,
0.007301546633243561,
-0.32253405451774597,
-0.11623329669237137,
-0.3624327778816223,
-0.8700249791145325,
0.7535696625709534,
-0.964141309261322,
-1.0267984867095947,
-0.21587002277374268,
-0.7065167427062988,
-0.5883390307426453,
0.2664423882961273,
0.07796119153499603,
0.2347893863916397,
-0.040326010435819626,
-0.04384337365627289,
0.8733662366867065,
0.1974203884601593,
0.29072996973991394,
0.45400774478912354,
-0.13835924863815308,
-0.9130881428718567,
0.8180226683616638,
-0.02874784544110298,
0.5238024592399597,
0.43347030878067017,
0.3140573799610138,
-0.35760390758514404,
-0.35560283064842224,
-0.31095802783966064,
0.12186894565820694,
-0.7015752792358398,
-0.49068447947502136,
-0.7787472009658813,
-0.29377299547195435,
-0.7424415946006775,
-0.22824721038341522,
-0.45696452260017395,
-0.43093621730804443,
-0.1200934574007988,
-0.23731660842895508,
0.1293366700410843,
0.4930174648761749,
0.1550077348947525,
0.38935548067092896,
-0.7491910457611084,
-0.012725802138447762,
0.49020737409591675,
0.1612984985113144,
0.053540002554655075,
-0.3185764253139496,
-0.2518501579761505,
0.2687774896621704,
-0.5966576933860779,
-0.7916442155838013,
0.2508479058742523,
-0.10376663506031036,
0.6285208463668823,
0.42552685737609863,
0.12728369235992432,
1.0146805047988892,
-0.23002417385578156,
0.6092227697372437,
0.5118955969810486,
-0.9732810258865356,
0.5638903379440308,
-0.3450239896774292,
0.136241152882576,
0.9112582802772522,
0.1255996972322464,
-0.37961894273757935,
-0.5448240041732788,
-0.7059067487716675,
-0.7060399651527405,
0.36172839999198914,
-0.00026547812740318477,
-0.14585427939891815,
-0.166002094745636,
0.09649349749088287,
0.2762090265750885,
0.30958956480026245,
-0.42514514923095703,
0.290865033864975,
-0.034985579550266266,
-0.9583637118339539,
0.13726016879081726,
0.07883540540933609,
-0.4076395332813263,
-0.2310919463634491,
0.7690269947052002,
-0.4315846264362335,
-0.07575749605894089,
0.22237113118171692,
-0.19116327166557312,
-0.39597445726394653,
0.37175217270851135,
0.5432923436164856,
0.7238616943359375,
0.052197933197021484,
0.36074143648147583,
0.21969616413116455,
-0.02480332925915718,
0.32329314947128296,
-0.3477562963962555,
0.17596063017845154,
-0.6043927669525146,
0.300911009311676,
0.4267229735851288,
0.174610897898674,
-0.5888159871101379,
0.5500245094299316,
0.1702963262796402,
-0.1143011748790741,
0.035248469561338425,
0.4943259060382843,
0.14938117563724518,
0.07821701467037201,
0.1772167980670929,
0.23012997210025787,
-0.2031586617231369,
-0.5188426971435547,
0.20992088317871094,
0.5721216797828674,
-0.38825908303260803,
-0.14874379336833954,
0.6015799641609192,
0.5189510583877563,
-0.3785327672958374,
0.6206345558166504,
0.10129174590110779,
-0.6908849477767944,
0.5291064381599426,
0.656461775302887,
0.911401093006134,
-0.3893907964229584,
0.08288665860891342,
0.06681656837463379,
0.12894296646118164,
-0.06455003470182419,
0.19389687478542328,
-0.06419406831264496,
-1.091884970664978,
-0.5294375419616699,
-0.3837657868862152,
-0.31663551926612854,
-0.28979992866516113,
-0.5779010653495789,
0.18184815347194672,
-0.33924782276153564,
-0.016251951456069946,
-0.14118757843971252,
-0.053813185542821884,
-0.4816182255744934,
0.2936905026435852,
-0.015513247810304165,
0.8912832140922546,
-0.7651838064193726,
0.8356484770774841,
0.6181061863899231,
-0.30883273482322693,
-1.1659268140792847,
0.11521361023187637,
-0.03933766856789589,
-0.9659738540649414,
0.2220391184091568,
0.046358466148376465,
-0.4282398223876953,
0.21789592504501343,
-0.7225853204727173,
-0.910088837146759,
1.0960426330566406,
0.26309990882873535,
-0.7021687626838684,
0.07553572952747345,
-0.03815944120287895,
0.5838947296142578,
-0.6809027194976807,
0.21734696626663208,
0.5888831615447998,
0.1845477670431137,
0.2271289825439453,
-0.6769596934318542,
0.053595803678035736,
-0.1571858674287796,
-0.1028449684381485,
0.5452643036842346,
-0.7709343433380127,
0.3888278305530548,
-0.2394770383834839,
-0.16104665398597717,
-0.12343660742044449,
0.9517249464988708,
0.19104214012622833,
-0.1635032743215561,
0.5752296447753906,
0.813522219657898,
1.0068402290344238,
0.16658754646778107,
0.5007323622703552,
-0.5978060960769653,
0.2100069224834442,
1.4282872676849365,
-0.4019470512866974,
0.7494497299194336,
0.7423732876777649,
-0.026034124195575714,
0.6672939658164978,
0.5097226500511169,
0.23402447998523712,
0.611688494682312,
0.003918663132935762,
-0.17117293179035187,
-0.5585343241691589,
-0.018064327538013458,
-0.1830284148454666,
0.3390892446041107,
0.16274510324001312,
-0.06982673704624176,
-0.10277190804481506,
-0.3308429718017578,
-0.13489662110805511,
0.40210285782814026,
-0.11106657981872559,
1.0446027517318726,
-0.07048805803060532,
-1.1497606039047241,
0.3135230243206024,
-0.2708042562007904,
0.48657238483428955,
-0.3817974328994751,
0.10891655832529068,
-0.12116049230098724,
0.14252540469169617,
-0.33211860060691833,
-1.083727478981018,
-0.00840130914002657,
-0.13672156631946564,
-0.014367107301950455,
-0.2964203357696533,
0.4430978298187256,
-0.807310938835144,
-0.44010674953460693,
0.04560217261314392,
0.5725648999214172,
-0.13230833411216736,
0.44144803285598755,
-0.6007888317108154,
-0.3875124752521515,
0.060299668461084366,
0.14837238192558289,
0.3358134627342224,
0.6949135065078735,
0.022367240861058235,
0.675711989402771,
0.36703914403915405,
-0.06203960254788399,
0.03783392533659935,
-0.1714763343334198,
0.9158896803855896,
-0.7145135998725891,
-0.4311399757862091,
-0.8699182868003845,
0.711777925491333,
-0.3505080044269562,
-0.563366711139679,
0.5959922671318054,
0.5650520324707031,
0.6965501308441162,
0.2044578492641449,
0.8093287944793701,
-0.026376822963356972,
0.39548259973526,
-0.5694709420204163,
0.3423402011394501,
-0.3613739311695099,
0.24272172152996063,
-0.2748681902885437,
-0.7096948623657227,
0.10867905616760254,
0.4034028649330139,
-0.21832051873207092,
-0.041464149951934814,
0.8325484395027161,
0.9053543210029602,
-0.15508413314819336,
0.11615537852048874,
0.17730578780174255,
0.14406633377075195,
0.4449050724506378,
0.4398384690284729,
0.8377017974853516,
-0.15893511474132538,
0.33807724714279175,
-0.31564733386039734,
-0.28350043296813965,
0.055123068392276764,
-0.9345046281814575,
-0.7277097702026367,
-0.4018234312534332,
-0.38446134328842163,
-0.2516283690929413,
-0.07146259397268295,
1.4746661186218262,
0.6054521203041077,
-1.0049777030944824,
-0.29038703441619873,
-0.23170213401317596,
0.08618532866239548,
-0.27518603205680847,
-0.18655937910079956,
0.35605230927467346,
-0.6101808547973633,
-0.41595223546028137,
0.3304380774497986,
0.4682990610599518,
0.09009791165590286,
-0.41269582509994507,
-0.05827714502811432,
-0.23605751991271973,
0.13009656965732574,
0.10839522629976273,
-0.018955009058117867,
-0.7777826189994812,
-0.4112532436847687,
0.1686778962612152,
-0.40803802013397217,
0.34935811161994934,
0.7719384431838989,
-0.6960921883583069,
0.6229568123817444,
0.44964689016342163,
0.8795162439346313,
-0.03789040818810463,
0.6079617738723755,
0.9453440308570862,
-0.5147199034690857,
-0.27393099665641785,
0.4732663035392761,
0.4242379367351532,
0.35378074645996094,
-0.5576556921005249,
0.452971488237381,
-0.05488651245832443,
-0.6743419170379639,
-0.43214571475982666,
0.2483634352684021,
-1.0943329334259033,
-0.11844442039728165,
0.9484068155288696,
0.13286910951137543,
-0.3857993483543396,
0.007248692214488983,
-0.44478121399879456,
0.10275370627641678,
-0.3172228932380676,
0.9519859552383423,
0.7704922556877136,
-0.27733907103538513,
-0.1710495799779892,
0.11234026402235031,
0.17983174324035645,
0.5740628838539124,
-0.924239456653595,
0.09814456105232239,
0.1958574503660202,
0.36053889989852905,
0.13807477056980133,
0.5003711581230164,
-0.12932786345481873,
-0.16612955927848816,
-0.35085707902908325,
0.2140931338071823,
0.2601102888584137,
-0.24811439216136932,
0.043665554374456406,
-0.0025381629820913076,
0.19400960206985474,
-0.025081491097807884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00543v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00543v1
|
New Benchmark Dataset and Fine-Grained Cross-Modal Fusion Framework for Vietnamese Multimodal Aspect-Category Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-05-01T14:29:03 | 2024-05-01T14:29:03 |
Quy Hoang Nguyen, Minh-Van Truong Nguyen, Kiet Van Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The emergence of multimodal data on social media platforms presents new
opportunities to better understand user sentiments toward a given aspect.
However, existing multimodal datasets for Aspect-Category Sentiment Analysis
(ACSA) often focus on textual annotations, neglecting fine-grained information
in images. Consequently, these datasets fail to fully exploit the richness
inherent in multimodal. To address this, we introduce a new Vietnamese
multimodal dataset, named ViMACSA, which consists of 4,876 text-image pairs
with 14,618 fine-grained annotations for both text and image in the hotel
domain. Additionally, we propose a Fine-Grained Cross-Modal Fusion Framework
(FCMF) that effectively learns both intra- and inter-modality interactions and
then fuses these information to produce a unified multimodal representation.
Experimental results show that our framework outperforms SOTA models on the
ViMACSA dataset, achieving the highest F1 score of 79.73%. We also explore
characteristics and challenges in Vietnamese multimodal sentiment analysis,
including misspellings, abbreviations, and the complexities of the Vietnamese
language. This work contributes both a benchmark dataset and a new framework
that leverages fine-grained multimodal information to improve multimodal
aspect-category sentiment analysis. Our dataset is available for research
purposes:
https://github.com/hoangquy18/Multimodal-Aspect-Category-Sentiment-Analysis.
|
[
-0.6325418949127197,
-0.7660084962844849,
0.43820181488990784,
0.3041470944881439,
-0.4801006317138672,
-0.023401513695716858,
-0.21617190539836884,
-0.2345481812953949,
0.32666072249412537,
0.3975246548652649,
-0.4534815549850464,
-0.7190874218940735,
-0.4085147976875305,
-0.0301115233451128,
0.025409691035747528,
0.764221727848053,
-0.19911131262779236,
0.1401071548461914,
-0.4819667935371399,
-0.770797610282898,
-0.2931113839149475,
-0.6337300539016724,
-0.03124774806201458,
-0.0625564232468605,
0.538858950138092,
0.5076608061790466,
0.6224679946899414,
0.15765738487243652,
0.6651530861854553,
0.1318201869726181,
0.37601518630981445,
0.5988829135894775,
-0.1455903947353363,
-0.009532085619866848,
-0.10162807255983353,
-0.029806284233927727,
-0.4656001031398773,
-0.13797728717327118,
0.4924052655696869,
0.33246299624443054,
0.16595306992530823,
0.17465320229530334,
-0.009329481981694698,
0.6242860555648804,
-0.7488426566123962,
0.3910771906375885,
-0.37301507592201233,
-0.13879811763763428,
-0.12434940785169601,
-0.22592677175998688,
-0.013526273891329765,
-0.09684423357248306,
0.1328122764825821,
-0.3519015312194824,
-0.11658985167741776,
-0.2418804168701172,
0.9050735235214233,
0.12909935414791107,
-0.9049906134605408,
0.05892393738031387,
-0.4284062087535858,
0.8185949921607971,
-0.29288721084594727,
0.5275640487670898,
0.35665300488471985,
0.44006219506263733,
0.3300049304962158,
-0.36614927649497986,
-0.6877142786979675,
-0.11835366487503052,
-0.08130068331956863,
0.13159160315990448,
-0.1920957863330841,
-0.030276484787464142,
-0.1360645294189453,
0.4328778386116028,
-0.6218481659889221,
-0.19993853569030762,
-0.134941965341568,
-0.20360173285007477,
0.5349826216697693,
0.19715633988380432,
0.060322731733322144,
-0.7995575070381165,
-0.73719722032547,
-0.2824373245239258,
-0.4785492420196533,
0.2098616063594818,
-0.04677615314722061,
0.32363229990005493,
-0.3370856046676636,
0.6667904257774353,
-0.438098281621933,
0.5130566954612732,
-0.46636486053466797,
-0.10959751904010773,
0.733916163444519,
-0.6778102517127991,
-0.36374396085739136,
-0.045165445655584335,
1.0082300901412964,
0.9464312195777893,
-0.03388569876551628,
0.35698768496513367,
-0.371177077293396,
0.5144749283790588,
0.05503669008612633,
-0.535192608833313,
-0.1891375333070755,
0.35823309421539307,
-0.636576235294342,
-0.2208593189716339,
0.4591231346130371,
-1.0325441360473633,
-0.34071168303489685,
-0.3031376600265503,
0.5598177313804626,
-0.28620946407318115,
-0.41780632734298706,
-0.05556492879986763,
-0.10870935022830963,
0.3633260428905487,
0.3825100064277649,
-0.21201825141906738,
-0.0852164775133133,
0.5620836615562439,
0.8637426495552063,
-0.1500190794467926,
-0.31442105770111084,
-0.5660273432731628,
-0.15871135890483856,
0.03499193489551544,
0.8457699418067932,
-0.8412909507751465,
-0.6330919861793518,
0.23783518373966217,
0.1696176379919052,
0.06389547884464264,
-0.5973806381225586,
0.48582735657691956,
0.001049773651175201,
-0.03161998093128204,
-0.28929582238197327,
-0.005436296574771404,
-0.4262361526489258,
0.5437508225440979,
-0.8198848366737366,
1.0964974164962769,
0.31578192114830017,
-0.39740967750549316,
0.2896122932434082,
-0.3949367105960846,
-0.42906713485717773,
-0.3544495701789856,
-0.2003057450056076,
-0.44126060605049133,
0.3048069179058075,
0.546105146408081,
0.7186827659606934,
-0.3836854100227356,
0.2811364233493805,
-0.572845458984375,
0.14286723732948303,
0.4950563609600067,
-0.5228376984596252,
0.2634202539920807,
0.37213876843452454,
-0.12061672657728195,
0.17665733397006989,
-0.8625739216804504,
-0.15168143808841705,
-0.08796859532594681,
-0.2169044017791748,
-0.6108065843582153,
-0.2761835753917694,
0.660423994064331,
0.6397109627723694,
0.34131449460983276,
-0.4385868012905121,
0.11395801603794098,
0.29292863607406616,
0.2240106761455536,
0.5775806903839111,
0.13082213699817657,
0.33780089020729065,
-0.3821642994880676,
0.48384201526641846,
0.6042214632034302,
0.3685154914855957,
-0.6302278637886047,
-0.34698349237442017,
-0.7250494360923767,
-0.44616299867630005,
-0.006582723930478096,
0.20635981857776642,
-1.1774451732635498,
0.19448667764663696,
-0.2378935068845749,
-0.561742901802063,
-0.8535304665565491,
0.12921328842639923,
0.38930779695510864,
0.2717862129211426,
0.4383772611618042,
-0.5467342734336853,
-0.7013462781906128,
-0.9509113430976868,
-0.15973728895187378,
-0.1624840348958969,
0.15132665634155273,
0.33106112480163574,
0.29334694147109985,
-0.7403646111488342,
0.8257639408111572,
-0.3904649019241333,
-0.7257000207901001,
-0.03160783275961876,
0.35773399472236633,
-0.2967734932899475,
0.4242742359638214,
0.6593548059463501,
-1.0244381427764893,
-0.139864981174469,
0.11638154089450836,
-0.7257074117660522,
-0.06276291608810425,
0.0179215706884861,
0.010239391587674618,
0.33091968297958374,
0.271681547164917,
-0.3874790072441101,
0.16081394255161285,
0.7985758185386658,
-0.3373596668243408,
0.34214672446250916,
0.15539899468421936,
0.4316774904727936,
-1.3206381797790527,
-0.07723001390695572,
0.5527541041374207,
-0.27913549542427063,
-0.4204378128051758,
0.019930236041545868,
0.05291908234357834,
0.0180949866771698,
-0.6241841912269592,
0.6265274882316589,
-0.13293112814426422,
0.24298609793186188,
-0.4486192464828491,
0.011086882092058659,
0.19853204488754272,
0.612195611000061,
0.13225755095481873,
0.35029149055480957,
0.4738333523273468,
-0.1941799521446228,
0.3315732777118683,
-0.11862411350011826,
-0.2600322961807251,
0.7352413535118103,
-0.3031626343727112,
-0.2092728167772293,
-0.11586014181375504,
0.3089005947113037,
-1.1035438776016235,
-0.2953924536705017,
0.09742093831300735,
-0.2270190417766571,
-0.058625947684049606,
0.053046517074108124,
-0.4232121706008911,
-0.001266857492737472,
-0.6818611025810242,
0.6198477745056152,
0.08387011289596558,
-0.2883667051792145,
0.902730405330658,
0.6323039531707764,
-0.08724700659513474,
-0.31715449690818787,
-0.4206640422344208,
-0.04495004191994667,
-0.09205766767263412,
-0.20808608829975128,
0.1490774154663086,
0.20080319046974182,
-0.15184253454208374,
0.055646106600761414,
-0.002500333823263645,
-0.14782901108264923,
-0.27862709760665894,
0.5206773281097412,
0.36689886450767517,
-0.3188096284866333,
0.17518416047096252,
0.1712493747472763,
-0.13964669406414032,
-0.043397050350904465,
-0.029485899955034256,
0.6056053042411804,
-0.4873652458190918,
-0.19779345393180847,
-0.45386797189712524,
0.40092939138412476,
0.8209506273269653,
-0.3834706246852875,
0.43829381465911865,
1.0780885219573975,
-0.39714834094047546,
0.33707064390182495,
-0.6647659540176392,
0.03649747371673584,
-0.3357660174369812,
0.4668480455875397,
-0.4871113896369934,
-0.9869405031204224,
0.24130849540233612,
0.045917361974716187,
-0.10449489951133728,
0.5968539118766785,
0.743104875087738,
-0.021268775686621666,
0.9689027667045593,
0.6419909000396729,
-0.3705045282840729,
0.5706748962402344,
-0.25065678358078003,
-0.08532796055078506,
-0.7224788665771484,
-0.3841826915740967,
-0.32945674657821655,
-0.30975890159606934,
-0.8973016142845154,
-0.9177985191345215,
0.33199891448020935,
-0.26332521438598633,
0.035182077437639236,
0.056758150458335876,
-0.1255023330450058,
0.04765065759420395,
0.47646835446357727,
0.08891406655311584,
0.45323994755744934,
0.08874054253101349,
0.08160427212715149,
0.02430683933198452,
-0.27815401554107666,
-0.45608043670654297,
0.8751735091209412,
0.25124770402908325,
0.8963460922241211,
-0.12124303728342056,
0.3959209620952606,
0.33532336354255676,
0.038897156715393066,
-0.7194429039955139,
0.39207321405410767,
-0.24947746098041534,
-0.2577437162399292,
0.18809297680854797,
-0.5072095990180969,
-0.5022324323654175,
0.4372197389602661,
-0.36563706398010254,
-0.3249675929546356,
0.6745052933692932,
-0.07389917224645615,
-0.1668419986963272,
0.02685460075736046,
-0.6529633402824402,
0.8414660692214966,
-0.19394688308238983,
-0.11885455250740051,
-0.19960449635982513,
-0.6578570008277893,
0.3800927996635437,
-0.22760866582393646,
0.30033352971076965,
-0.5014299750328064,
-0.10999889671802521,
0.5554121732711792,
-0.2685456871986389,
0.753208339214325,
-0.18674130737781525,
-0.20089663565158844,
0.27497053146362305,
-0.10074784606695175,
-0.037458643317222595,
0.5251680016517639,
0.1153649389743805,
0.6336435675621033,
0.05246409401297569,
-0.32985231280326843,
-0.43109872937202454,
1.0289804935455322,
-0.8944944143295288,
-0.07629647850990295,
-0.3687101900577545,
-0.3950241506099701,
-0.2714351415634155,
-0.007382360752671957,
0.14882077276706696,
0.5780670046806335,
-0.29612794518470764,
0.25999975204467773,
0.2668839395046234,
-0.08218931406736374,
0.34646084904670715,
0.3738343119621277,
-0.3735661208629608,
-0.8464296460151672,
1.329140543937683,
0.06331155449151993,
0.031626224517822266,
0.662508487701416,
-0.012154887430369854,
-0.2223615050315857,
0.1887362003326416,
-0.2959934175014496,
0.014912241138517857,
-0.5704556107521057,
-0.39247193932533264,
-0.8633114099502563,
-0.0639696717262268,
-0.38101184368133545,
-0.14139264822006226,
-0.49785882234573364,
-0.5050966143608093,
-0.058668047189712524,
0.052235495299100876,
0.35668641328811646,
0.45999667048454285,
0.05177866667509079,
0.33188560605049133,
-1.0357285737991333,
0.586815595626831,
0.3145199418067932,
0.15494613349437714,
-0.16234132647514343,
0.03612538427114487,
-0.21601013839244843,
0.1838626265525818,
-0.36283746361732483,
-0.5202352404594421,
0.30323347449302673,
0.16491959989070892,
0.2081034630537033,
0.5841121673583984,
0.06582648307085037,
0.6365294456481934,
-0.008002628572285175,
0.8384255170822144,
0.2723672389984131,
-0.8342821598052979,
0.5359195470809937,
-0.31721261143684387,
0.5637337565422058,
0.6433491706848145,
0.28177410364151,
-0.6774373054504395,
-0.31355518102645874,
-0.39747223258018494,
-0.8731461763381958,
0.47719472646713257,
0.05885593965649605,
0.06096436828374863,
0.13010351359844208,
-0.16319876909255981,
0.38081514835357666,
0.5445592999458313,
-0.7109866738319397,
-0.1592027097940445,
-0.5647042989730835,
-0.5014100670814514,
-0.41872888803482056,
-0.22968311607837677,
-0.06152629107236862,
-0.38214337825775146,
0.47911837697029114,
-0.33164921402931213,
0.2402377724647522,
0.059777356684207916,
-0.20520687103271484,
-0.09483534097671509,
0.19720084965229034,
0.5826388001441956,
0.429984450340271,
-0.2877919375896454,
0.39925387501716614,
-0.18557074666023254,
-0.4108002781867981,
0.13857746124267578,
0.2877338230609894,
0.26927393674850464,
0.1564054638147354,
0.3359021246433258,
0.6980290412902832,
0.07341734319925308,
-0.8230551481246948,
0.5126806497573853,
-0.2194223701953888,
0.10758843272924423,
0.053936004638671875,
-0.1801413893699646,
-0.36207354068756104,
0.32553550601005554,
0.32727959752082825,
0.2331455945968628,
0.09580494463443756,
-0.730640172958374,
0.19719591736793518,
0.372287392616272,
-0.8986079692840576,
-0.5241430401802063,
0.25267675518989563,
0.2602196931838989,
0.19789323210716248,
0.17084385454654694,
0.1294427365064621,
-0.47421523928642273,
0.2210569679737091,
-0.02205909602344036,
1.038770318031311,
-0.23829272389411926,
0.445420503616333,
0.04419634863734245,
0.29661235213279724,
0.12568636238574982,
0.5728297829627991,
-0.09204775094985962,
-0.40499117970466614,
-0.07891947776079178,
-0.8920779228210449,
-0.3195682764053345,
-0.10514689981937408,
-0.6319713592529297,
0.25460803508758545,
-0.26869067549705505,
-0.18836262822151184,
-0.173348069190979,
-0.07351868599653244,
-0.7369477152824402,
0.4075030982494354,
0.11913752555847168,
0.46995842456817627,
-0.858777642250061,
0.8843376636505127,
1.1365638971328735,
-0.4932369887828827,
-0.4172916114330292,
0.05132859945297241,
0.23816220462322235,
-0.6465533971786499,
0.13531610369682312,
0.4888950288295746,
-0.08903948962688446,
-0.5533738136291504,
-0.3066675364971161,
-0.48021772503852844,
0.8304938077926636,
0.032535284757614136,
-0.3776649832725525,
0.2696017920970917,
0.4124576151371002,
0.36241453886032104,
-0.7118523120880127,
0.03524651378393173,
0.582153856754303,
0.3587934374809265,
-0.12228713929653168,
-0.8036876916885376,
-0.00032878131605684757,
-0.4446532130241394,
0.14230002462863922,
0.2786230444908142,
-0.8679667115211487,
0.8587256073951721,
0.22508132457733154,
0.30816105008125305,
-0.1537436842918396,
0.7581846117973328,
0.10513100773096085,
0.6752368807792664,
0.5745419263839722,
0.5059278607368469,
0.3368718922138214,
-0.23114632070064545,
0.7307367324829102,
-0.01432985719293356,
0.4822942018508911,
0.9748217463493347,
-0.35244670510292053,
1.0758424997329712,
0.6330600380897522,
0.22603030502796173,
0.5312016606330872,
0.5533437728881836,
0.15627175569534302,
0.7512429356575012,
-0.46469980478286743,
-0.13974334299564362,
-0.3709970712661743,
-0.5920174717903137,
-0.4657101631164551,
0.8600689172744751,
0.33104488253593445,
-0.30301371216773987,
-0.3423498272895813,
0.7342087030410767,
-0.09305444359779358,
-0.1716471165418625,
-0.3045498728752136,
0.837310791015625,
0.31793197989463806,
-0.4161684215068817,
0.29302436113357544,
0.05154111608862877,
0.662623941898346,
-0.5422593951225281,
0.008098820224404335,
-0.203574538230896,
0.24390378594398499,
-0.18669091165065765,
-0.8276363015174866,
-0.06401030719280243,
-0.10906115919351578,
-0.23813199996948242,
0.07194078713655472,
0.6848512887954712,
-0.5934848785400391,
-0.6417664885520935,
0.17512117326259613,
0.5249717235565186,
-0.39043503999710083,
-0.31202590465545654,
-0.5382757782936096,
0.4524620771408081,
-0.2166936695575714,
-0.05513878911733627,
0.2824424207210541,
0.6300254464149475,
-0.1847345381975174,
0.29048576951026917,
0.4041344225406647,
-0.32177409529685974,
-0.20521903038024902,
0.16454656422138214,
1.0868192911148071,
-0.7445665001869202,
-0.46707385778427124,
-0.8628440499305725,
0.4493507742881775,
0.0017813753802329302,
-0.6646156907081604,
0.8470168113708496,
0.6209498643875122,
0.9868281483650208,
-0.03375968337059021,
0.8510897159576416,
0.023627184331417084,
0.02427530661225319,
-0.6392502188682556,
0.42774710059165955,
-1.0821760892868042,
-0.006083660293370485,
-0.7160243988037109,
-1.0665929317474365,
-0.2233799695968628,
0.38109374046325684,
0.036678727716207504,
0.1252533495426178,
0.5271015763282776,
0.8525118231773376,
-0.11939769238233566,
0.05925412476062775,
0.32024598121643066,
0.10585013031959534,
0.44476011395454407,
0.4303518533706665,
1.043421745300293,
-0.5496206283569336,
0.37074190378189087,
-0.5263553857803345,
-0.19045564532279968,
-0.6872038841247559,
-0.5640639066696167,
-0.7539044618606567,
-1.0357259511947632,
-0.3333171010017395,
-0.38687413930892944,
-0.1519027203321457,
1.2588386535644531,
0.47578078508377075,
-0.7921480536460876,
-0.26330068707466125,
0.5891158580780029,
0.030690979212522507,
-0.4293197691440582,
-0.27829667925834656,
0.4355373978614807,
-0.13210202753543854,
-0.6863007545471191,
0.0006268093711696565,
0.7341942191123962,
0.003293838119134307,
-0.5276252627372742,
-0.01729825884103775,
-0.3275793194770813,
0.06223517283797264,
0.9874925017356873,
-0.08728159964084625,
-0.6548227667808533,
-0.16921280324459076,
-0.026007819920778275,
-0.31141549348831177,
0.17798534035682678,
1.0260140895843506,
-0.7822750806808472,
0.8034723997116089,
0.4435027241706848,
0.4973853528499603,
0.13171175122261047,
-0.13919205963611603,
0.42764559388160706,
-0.759087860584259,
0.28790658712387085,
0.01462554931640625,
0.6254751086235046,
0.36714592576026917,
0.009412690065801144,
0.22015716135501862,
0.27646318078041077,
-0.2438739538192749,
-0.7372032999992371,
0.012894450686872005,
-1.4958720207214355,
-0.26681074500083923,
1.1982090473175049,
0.24046699702739716,
-0.46057119965553284,
-0.20003476738929749,
-0.5492817163467407,
0.08175414800643921,
-0.6208721399307251,
0.7377252578735352,
0.5208666324615479,
0.27662530541419983,
-0.09569103270769119,
-0.22990413010120392,
0.3970854878425598,
0.3782632052898407,
-0.811449408531189,
0.11094692349433899,
0.8266615867614746,
-0.19996976852416992,
0.13037124276161194,
0.6296762228012085,
-0.004007543902844191,
0.48313480615615845,
-0.2988327145576477,
-0.11055538803339005,
-0.0021385159343481064,
-0.6777829527854919,
-0.4247492551803589,
0.47348904609680176,
-0.23950006067752838,
-0.3597366213798523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00536v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00536v1
|
A Legal Framework for Natural Language Processing Model Training in Portugal
| 2024-05-01T14:18:50 | 2024-05-01T14:18:50 |
Rúben Almeida, Evelin Amorim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.ET, 68T50, K.5.0
|
Recent advances in deep learning have promoted the advent of many
computational systems capable of performing intelligent actions that, until
then, were restricted to the human intellect. In the particular case of human
languages, these advances allowed the introduction of applications like ChatGPT
that are capable of generating coherent text without being explicitly
programmed to do so. Instead, these models use large volumes of textual data to
learn meaningful representations of human languages. Associated with these
advances, concerns about copyright and data privacy infringements caused by
these applications have emerged. Despite these concerns, the pace at which new
natural language processing applications continued to be developed largely
outperformed the introduction of new regulations. Today, communication barriers
between legal experts and computer scientists motivate many unintentional legal
infringements during the development of such applications. In this paper, a
multidisciplinary team intends to bridge this communication gap and promote
more compliant Portuguese NLP research by presenting a series of everyday NLP
use cases, while highlighting the Portuguese legislation that may arise during
its development.
|
[
-0.36314600706100464,
-0.6724953055381775,
0.2694312632083893,
0.15543872117996216,
-0.25816214084625244,
0.12332206964492798,
-0.3650617301464081,
-0.8374598026275635,
-0.13010169565677643,
0.9317998290061951,
-0.3634341061115265,
-0.43889451026916504,
-0.7680229544639587,
0.05420307815074921,
-0.4719412922859192,
1.0692261457443237,
0.15224230289459229,
0.19272355735301971,
0.013681387528777122,
-0.18343569338321686,
-0.5569729208946228,
-0.7957879900932312,
-0.7822781205177307,
-0.13065297901630402,
0.2382694035768509,
0.18594761192798615,
0.47323256731033325,
0.4622742235660553,
0.35546907782554626,
0.3066023588180542,
-0.22718487679958344,
-0.11397028714418411,
-0.2245032638311386,
0.25194692611694336,
-0.2767573595046997,
-0.5866745114326477,
-0.04004265367984772,
-0.1021614670753479,
0.4227431118488312,
0.6372703909873962,
-0.35691893100738525,
-0.3018362522125244,
0.23419612646102905,
0.7215041518211365,
-0.5387256741523743,
0.218525692820549,
-0.5488518476486206,
0.3027501702308655,
-0.23853746056556702,
-0.0607609897851944,
-0.264269083738327,
-0.44340765476226807,
0.3208366632461548,
-0.3865620493888855,
0.38942277431488037,
-0.35060471296310425,
0.9431000351905823,
0.38382261991500854,
-0.3997112214565277,
-0.7349640130996704,
-0.5338283777236938,
0.5759106874465942,
-0.7819538116455078,
0.4138556718826294,
0.33777913451194763,
0.5039058327674866,
-0.371050089597702,
-0.5513836741447449,
-0.35078081488609314,
-0.4428141713142395,
0.12419771403074265,
-0.14804735779762268,
-0.4307411015033722,
0.1598699688911438,
0.33776772022247314,
0.07853444665670395,
-0.465567022562027,
0.3076879382133484,
-0.6583403944969177,
-0.20212624967098236,
0.5399540662765503,
-0.18148289620876312,
0.3087369203567505,
0.021120186895132065,
-0.14580602943897247,
0.1385330706834793,
-0.7688314914703369,
-0.0008018180378712714,
0.6490141153335571,
0.4294484555721283,
-0.08755514770746231,
0.4569922387599945,
-0.11866738647222519,
0.856594443321228,
-0.4929899573326111,
0.19269335269927979,
0.16097323596477509,
0.04603100195527077,
-0.25119948387145996,
0.1591121405363083,
0.7408603429794312,
-0.0266242828220129,
0.5500845909118652,
-0.11941312998533249,
-0.16723477840423584,
0.10850512981414795,
0.4023981988430023,
-0.5980674624443054,
-0.015935273841023445,
0.13590724766254425,
-0.25660279393196106,
-0.25726762413978577,
0.022600548341870308,
-0.646401047706604,
-0.5906757116317749,
-0.5785449147224426,
-0.08630123734474182,
-0.3936953842639923,
-0.31323951482772827,
0.4433375298976898,
-0.024016505107283592,
0.2822815179824829,
0.0885034054517746,
-1.0026642084121704,
0.46633976697921753,
0.885770320892334,
0.4995834529399872,
0.12531788647174835,
-0.07468010485172272,
-0.2700069546699524,
0.06286997348070145,
-0.06368578225374222,
0.6872854232788086,
-0.43420881032943726,
-0.3018340766429901,
0.13966000080108643,
-0.04074811562895775,
-0.07969081401824951,
-0.4111553430557251,
0.9954137206077576,
-0.5287734270095825,
0.47434982657432556,
-0.029576679691672325,
-0.49186965823173523,
-0.25924742221832275,
0.4235394299030304,
-0.4951038658618927,
0.6911405920982361,
-0.23110364377498627,
-0.8232883810997009,
0.5075317621231079,
-0.8016232848167419,
-0.5042229294776917,
0.18630781769752502,
-0.4489165246486664,
-0.27318623661994934,
-0.08786679804325104,
0.06820834428071976,
0.5189040303230286,
-0.2575162649154663,
0.6648297309875488,
-0.05032576993107796,
-0.0571107417345047,
0.04376275837421417,
-0.6279470920562744,
1.20480477809906,
0.46314767003059387,
-0.25747352838516235,
0.047808799892663956,
-0.8435899615287781,
-0.275754451751709,
-0.05286453664302826,
-0.6448338031768799,
-0.4093310534954071,
-0.017371900379657745,
0.059872016310691833,
0.44307413697242737,
0.06160081550478935,
-0.6090454459190369,
0.06276300549507141,
-0.6584957838058472,
0.9196870923042297,
0.4252476394176483,
-0.1273196041584015,
0.32244473695755005,
-0.07002901285886765,
0.6381111145019531,
-0.15269936621189117,
0.07587578892707825,
-0.11224100738763809,
-0.7955729961395264,
-0.6708332300186157,
-0.0998896136879921,
0.4461103677749634,
0.5361868143081665,
-0.7242852449417114,
0.23607562482357025,
-0.3959488272666931,
-0.35115107893943787,
-0.7806485891342163,
0.0997183620929718,
0.27915525436401367,
0.4871896505355835,
0.15852415561676025,
-0.3827221691608429,
-0.6417847871780396,
-0.8997382521629333,
-0.39310598373413086,
0.04506480693817139,
-0.14416511356830597,
0.3027920722961426,
0.5738977789878845,
-0.22871257364749908,
1.0482863187789917,
-0.022173874080181122,
-0.4774537682533264,
-0.275680810213089,
0.20432692766189575,
0.3409936726093292,
0.5900643467903137,
0.5692920684814453,
-0.9153530597686768,
-0.3843879997730255,
0.04318758845329285,
-0.7332993745803833,
-0.15550562739372253,
0.05681821331381798,
0.13877888023853302,
0.4093693792819977,
0.5910170078277588,
-0.543529748916626,
0.33449509739875793,
0.38440367579460144,
-0.4196465313434601,
0.3491852879524231,
-0.43396925926208496,
-0.08977712690830231,
-0.8482639789581299,
0.06455855816602707,
-0.05574794486165047,
-0.35420161485671997,
-0.6900337934494019,
0.17946159839630127,
-0.21328914165496826,
-0.33996346592903137,
-0.7471938729286194,
0.32770055532455444,
-0.23691201210021973,
0.0907658264040947,
-0.29460573196411133,
-0.17683641612529755,
-0.16430965065956116,
0.3188113868236542,
0.24143239855766296,
0.4549412131309509,
0.6777091026306152,
-0.7027714848518372,
0.21389994025230408,
0.145597442984581,
-0.1986437290906906,
0.7342450618743896,
-0.5348325967788696,
0.001148031442426145,
-0.19479407370090485,
-0.031075874343514442,
-0.40961065888404846,
-0.30811765789985657,
0.38028085231781006,
-0.45920777320861816,
0.3082028031349182,
-0.5857417583465576,
-0.36207637190818787,
-0.31031712889671326,
-0.031059248372912407,
0.11093419045209885,
0.21092183887958527,
-0.3247019052505493,
0.5419912934303284,
0.754128098487854,
-0.09081975370645523,
-0.7306126952171326,
-1.0610082149505615,
0.5724746584892273,
-0.35071462392807007,
-0.8307884335517883,
0.2419893443584442,
0.2054179161787033,
-0.17768961191177368,
0.028061842545866966,
0.29640287160873413,
-0.5920827984809875,
0.3745322823524475,
0.24373207986354828,
-0.30955642461776733,
-0.11287204176187515,
0.008309593424201012,
0.044853053987026215,
-0.1971183568239212,
0.3290107846260071,
-0.1810571402311325,
0.6309893727302551,
-0.07109081745147705,
-0.2886253297328949,
-0.44517531991004944,
0.4580070674419403,
0.17929571866989136,
-0.09911315143108368,
0.40734198689460754,
0.3288179039955139,
-0.42111316323280334,
-0.18114487826824188,
-0.563525915145874,
0.049669165164232254,
-0.47948747873306274,
0.16794222593307495,
-0.13405875861644745,
-1.0805459022521973,
0.272506982088089,
0.18618816137313843,
0.34551873803138733,
0.3408416211605072,
0.6335336565971375,
0.10104231536388397,
0.6064701080322266,
0.9602442383766174,
-0.06062223017215729,
0.5719262957572937,
0.007409895770251751,
0.2768983244895935,
-0.2815936207771301,
-0.2003720998764038,
-0.7794907689094543,
0.049408748745918274,
-0.916939377784729,
-0.2742505967617035,
0.018722761422395706,
-0.14622104167938232,
-0.0848156288266182,
0.7682796120643616,
-0.6750730276107788,
0.7373489141464233,
0.7545793056488037,
-0.1311470866203308,
0.4928916394710541,
0.002990970853716135,
-0.3191318213939667,
-0.0744076669216156,
-0.8493388891220093,
-0.775037944316864,
0.9402118921279907,
0.42475298047065735,
0.48759207129478455,
-0.017562469467520714,
0.887015700340271,
0.3590655028820038,
0.11601372063159943,
-0.7421655058860779,
0.48090553283691406,
-0.15640853345394135,
-0.7568632960319519,
-0.05295667424798012,
-0.49025967717170715,
-1.4435946941375732,
0.16284513473510742,
-0.21236591041088104,
-0.6729493737220764,
0.33333277702331543,
0.00832060631364584,
-0.27593356370925903,
0.11522228270769119,
-0.726226270198822,
0.9531407952308655,
-0.19607965648174286,
-0.5241041779518127,
-0.22177332639694214,
-0.7743393778800964,
0.19858434796333313,
0.18339742720127106,
0.46231260895729065,
-0.22978097200393677,
0.3036845028400421,
0.7868529558181763,
-0.2598622739315033,
1.021602749824524,
-0.2366635948419571,
-0.3157511055469513,
0.4859697222709656,
0.10397765040397644,
0.11790917813777924,
-0.0035483918618410826,
0.015494603663682938,
0.07149846851825714,
0.030229000374674797,
-0.21467098593711853,
0.042093466967344284,
0.46444830298423767,
-0.3933957517147064,
-0.37960749864578247,
-0.5136215090751648,
-0.3384852707386017,
-0.04872239753603935,
0.4210019111633301,
0.23063033819198608,
-0.18476659059524536,
-0.4682613015174866,
0.07590034604072571,
0.6044026613235474,
-0.2850170135498047,
0.3559289574623108,
0.7714258432388306,
0.1413554698228836,
-0.06553171575069427,
0.9607167840003967,
0.05691517889499664,
-0.0806804671883583,
0.19126544892787933,
0.10321327298879623,
-0.20178106427192688,
-0.6533136963844299,
-0.22417117655277252,
-0.033602915704250336,
-0.7653445601463318,
0.0642256885766983,
-0.6448838114738464,
-0.13128264248371124,
-0.5534804463386536,
-0.019210858270525932,
-0.2644970118999481,
-0.47233134508132935,
-0.10102174431085587,
0.0664927139878273,
0.12730441987514496,
0.672336220741272,
-0.08285173773765564,
0.2726152539253235,
-0.8947514295578003,
0.1374937891960144,
0.3451336622238159,
0.39437738060951233,
-0.34773898124694824,
-0.29016023874282837,
-0.11135507375001907,
0.16437369585037231,
-0.5014992952346802,
-0.5665358901023865,
0.6261163949966431,
0.06446623802185059,
0.5616652965545654,
0.08499845862388611,
-0.40024492144584656,
0.2625756561756134,
-0.5539987683296204,
0.4422460198402405,
-0.04248131439089775,
-0.8118271231651306,
0.6273404359817505,
-0.5928081274032593,
-0.07716213166713715,
0.5394890904426575,
0.2601120173931122,
-0.752111554145813,
-0.43806952238082886,
-0.6754018068313599,
-1.0074087381362915,
0.5967044234275818,
0.47562456130981445,
0.2973032295703888,
0.17523537576198578,
0.28126275539398193,
0.05660572275519371,
0.4269992709159851,
-1.001657247543335,
0.4667663872241974,
0.021629175171256065,
-0.056062277406454086,
0.38381487131118774,
0.05580363795161247,
-0.22421111166477203,
-0.13950738310813904,
0.6500086784362793,
-0.03420701622962952,
0.20413778722286224,
-0.045775532722473145,
-0.24736864864826202,
0.2909356653690338,
0.49836471676826477,
0.4966326355934143,
0.5682203769683838,
0.1412404477596283,
-0.026422953233122826,
-0.006098857149481773,
-0.4988422691822052,
-0.02359815686941147,
0.3367516100406647,
-0.21748194098472595,
0.011762198992073536,
0.24537667632102966,
0.6213421821594238,
0.22800412774085999,
-0.9345131516456604,
0.510323703289032,
-0.1857462078332901,
-0.305174320936203,
-0.34413397312164307,
0.30229389667510986,
0.0995873436331749,
0.26469650864601135,
-0.028470449149608612,
0.16907791793346405,
0.40514087677001953,
-0.4452388882637024,
0.25252920389175415,
0.23217175900936127,
-0.5383787751197815,
0.0029816257301717997,
0.7715283632278442,
0.22515958547592163,
-0.32564470171928406,
0.34371641278266907,
-0.198330357670784,
-0.5467216372489929,
0.6287951469421387,
0.07685830444097519,
0.8038917183876038,
-0.01190006174147129,
0.12150278687477112,
0.004453184083104134,
0.3014428913593292,
-0.4927745759487152,
0.38451361656188965,
-0.18632902204990387,
-0.7833460569381714,
-0.4189499020576477,
-0.37941378355026245,
-0.6329613924026489,
-0.202469602227211,
-0.42537376284599304,
0.45918339490890503,
-0.35684892535209656,
-0.06844504177570343,
-0.03814627602696419,
-0.15313389897346497,
-0.6962986588478088,
0.06464037299156189,
0.3954862952232361,
0.636835515499115,
-0.7093952894210815,
1.0600061416625977,
0.4360167980194092,
-0.2875955402851105,
-0.13440024852752686,
-0.4319221079349518,
0.03424995765089989,
-0.6712087988853455,
0.4909847676753998,
0.28317171335220337,
0.0001234082883456722,
-0.13521675765514374,
-0.6972702145576477,
-0.24522726237773895,
0.561174213886261,
0.7351019978523254,
-0.6295573115348816,
-0.08020216226577759,
0.608969509601593,
0.9240812063217163,
-0.10907432436943054,
-0.10476923733949661,
0.8480069637298584,
0.27010783553123474,
0.05708148702979088,
-0.6442703008651733,
-0.2792702913284302,
-0.2504558861255646,
-0.27362480759620667,
0.15401749312877655,
-0.2043488621711731,
0.6465073823928833,
0.10760655999183655,
-0.27841395139694214,
-0.23797719180583954,
0.4306499660015106,
0.23643432557582855,
0.04935329779982567,
0.14976583421230316,
0.6644085049629211,
0.8527874946594238,
-0.19787003099918365,
1.03672456741333,
-0.28832995891571045,
0.2478635460138321,
1.2686594724655151,
-0.22278504073619843,
0.537998378276825,
0.43923965096473694,
0.02450421079993248,
0.14421075582504272,
0.4316713809967041,
-0.3272208869457245,
0.15425677597522736,
0.40118473768234253,
-0.3091902732849121,
0.04238336905837059,
-0.4251815676689148,
-0.2030072957277298,
0.45563697814941406,
0.6706843972206116,
-0.3896165192127228,
-0.4598747789859772,
0.10057347267866135,
0.2816735506057739,
0.34692180156707764,
-0.12446905672550201,
0.7108701467514038,
0.18729513883590698,
-0.5276739597320557,
0.280075341463089,
0.28119102120399475,
0.8845677375793457,
-0.46020445227622986,
0.08211621642112732,
0.09351282566785812,
0.10752880573272705,
-0.18990778923034668,
-0.945580005645752,
0.6720278859138489,
0.44013363122940063,
0.21539975702762604,
-0.5548999309539795,
0.7339602708816528,
-0.24354799091815948,
-0.3381364345550537,
0.42684951424598694,
0.3621530830860138,
0.3072393834590912,
-0.12908361852169037,
-1.0768002271652222,
-0.08138445764780045,
-0.15695782005786896,
-0.1985437572002411,
0.2179466336965561,
0.6171658039093018,
-0.18427221477031708,
0.7862937450408936,
0.623089611530304,
0.1651550531387329,
0.3145875036716461,
0.25736427307128906,
0.9597828388214111,
-0.6344170570373535,
-0.7047666907310486,
-0.9068353176116943,
0.2923598289489746,
-0.1440228819847107,
-0.5097261667251587,
0.5306501388549805,
0.5329413414001465,
0.8117875456809998,
0.29237696528434753,
0.8011726140975952,
-0.226316899061203,
0.45525044202804565,
-0.6440543532371521,
0.8257777690887451,
-0.025566602125763893,
0.42351678013801575,
0.004993516951799393,
-0.7673829197883606,
-0.589248776435852,
0.6494808197021484,
-0.35957804322242737,
-0.12494554370641708,
0.2066585272550583,
0.4931401014328003,
-0.17254717648029327,
0.26829883456230164,
0.2698955237865448,
0.2885896563529968,
0.7057056427001953,
0.7155712842941284,
0.6316395401954651,
-0.29268768429756165,
0.5231168270111084,
-0.30716177821159363,
0.21641755104064941,
0.13477669656276703,
-1.0313119888305664,
-0.857177734375,
-0.23204414546489716,
-0.2050766944885254,
-0.3390805721282959,
0.15183013677597046,
0.9788126945495605,
0.6093358993530273,
-1.0456973314285278,
-0.46539223194122314,
-0.6766587495803833,
0.07820091396570206,
0.11406610906124115,
-0.22356919944286346,
0.13716432452201843,
-0.35206812620162964,
-0.7652801275253296,
0.351383239030838,
0.15878534317016602,
0.1685466170310974,
-0.2010323703289032,
0.055912986397743225,
-0.2706778645515442,
-0.2577902376651764,
0.4720260202884674,
0.6484432220458984,
-0.26737460494041443,
0.032132141292095184,
-0.5123625993728638,
-0.15821687877178192,
0.3953142464160919,
0.9182726740837097,
-0.8611735105514526,
0.5881871581077576,
0.5838545560836792,
0.8390753865242004,
0.4166558086872101,
-0.47578859329223633,
0.77774578332901,
-0.8143813610076904,
0.5342150926589966,
0.7649598717689514,
0.4904623031616211,
0.4409174919128418,
-0.15085536241531372,
0.7104655504226685,
0.14689037203788757,
-0.47353482246398926,
-0.7007018327713013,
0.16348031163215637,
-0.7416807413101196,
-0.33013424277305603,
0.8181747794151306,
-0.12859003245830536,
-0.1639755815267563,
-0.6006868481636047,
-0.4681549370288849,
0.22141623497009277,
-0.5427667498588562,
0.9382956027984619,
0.7951554656028748,
0.08849108219146729,
0.004790345206856728,
-1.3187956809997559,
0.6694039106369019,
0.16077648103237152,
-0.9409406185150146,
0.08526307344436646,
0.227714404463768,
0.19298206269741058,
0.03912816941738129,
0.44824498891830444,
-0.28120920062065125,
0.13011404871940613,
-0.3723490536212921,
0.21478872001171112,
0.12321189790964127,
-0.22093087434768677,
-0.5155830383300781,
0.14823731780052185,
-0.0948498398065567,
0.1763535737991333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00523v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00523v1
|
CookingSense: A Culinary Knowledgebase with Multidisciplinary Assertions
| 2024-05-01T13:58:09 | 2024-05-01T13:58:09 |
Donghee Choi, Mogan Gim, Donghyeon Park, Mujeen Sung, Hyunjae Kim, Jaewoo Kang, Jihun Choi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper introduces CookingSense, a descriptive collection of knowledge
assertions in the culinary domain extracted from various sources, including web
data, scientific papers, and recipes, from which knowledge covering a broad
range of aspects is acquired. CookingSense is constructed through a series of
dictionary-based filtering and language model-based semantic filtering
techniques, which results in a rich knowledgebase of multidisciplinary
food-related assertions. Additionally, we present FoodBench, a novel benchmark
to evaluate culinary decision support systems. From evaluations with FoodBench,
we empirically prove that CookingSense improves the performance of retrieval
augmented language models. We also validate the quality and variety of
assertions in CookingSense through qualitative analysis.
|
[
-0.45242318511009216,
-0.5586058497428894,
0.539047122001648,
0.34168267250061035,
0.6454178094863892,
0.020245758816599846,
-0.09366672486066818,
-0.2709665894508362,
0.5450907349586487,
0.4393320083618164,
-0.5521747469902039,
-0.7131238579750061,
-0.6703279614448547,
0.12179048359394073,
-0.2849667966365814,
0.6025980114936829,
-0.26074543595314026,
0.22758063673973083,
-0.6884862780570984,
-0.009086249396204948,
-0.6273448467254639,
0.04092719405889511,
-0.16924747824668884,
-0.25548624992370605,
0.8002074360847473,
0.6935502290725708,
0.32033345103263855,
0.2707105278968811,
0.7679604291915894,
0.21756917238235474,
0.3049596846103668,
0.5510588884353638,
0.14685851335525513,
0.6504278182983398,
-0.6052926182746887,
-0.3603346347808838,
-0.14558520913124084,
0.057155631482601166,
-0.2091076523065567,
0.5951409935951233,
-0.1567719578742981,
0.28082865476608276,
-0.12769007682800293,
0.8925126791000366,
-1.1621291637420654,
0.13162319362163544,
-0.2548429071903229,
-0.013137755915522575,
-0.05915989726781845,
0.3411077558994293,
-0.2946007251739502,
-0.737541675567627,
-0.05441726744174957,
-0.621753990650177,
0.025779208168387413,
-0.3188793957233429,
0.6000666618347168,
0.1527009904384613,
-0.6189218163490295,
-0.3382984697818756,
-0.8811551332473755,
0.7102102041244507,
-0.39509186148643494,
0.7159778475761414,
0.7487818002700806,
0.9751194715499878,
-0.0634714886546135,
-1.095584750175476,
-0.645642101764679,
-0.12858855724334717,
0.056618332862854004,
0.2566508650779724,
0.27245673537254333,
-0.28367701172828674,
-0.03151239827275276,
0.35497188568115234,
-0.5032056570053101,
-0.19841699302196503,
0.06496351212263107,
0.08845565468072891,
0.7245173454284668,
0.18359804153442383,
0.3477407693862915,
-0.4027648866176605,
-0.43722474575042725,
-0.10585897415876389,
-0.3062455654144287,
-0.009461157023906708,
-0.27995240688323975,
-0.24497711658477783,
0.1936332732439041,
0.685073971748352,
-0.5048074126243591,
0.7615846395492554,
-0.3581947088241577,
-0.34188413619995117,
-0.002291653538122773,
-0.5221297144889832,
-0.019301041960716248,
-0.128016859292984,
0.6056416034698486,
0.7976505160331726,
-0.22680352628231049,
-0.23021534085273743,
0.05215028300881386,
0.5677338242530823,
0.054488327354192734,
-0.4313924312591553,
-0.6492655277252197,
0.22202101349830627,
-0.2404746562242508,
-0.17433792352676392,
0.5574118494987488,
-0.9774794578552246,
-0.8590739369392395,
0.0393805205821991,
-0.01833629608154297,
-0.2577236294746399,
-0.5885452628135681,
0.08314403891563416,
-0.9824257493019104,
0.2071906179189682,
0.009905634447932243,
-0.8893703818321228,
0.4910067021846771,
0.9216886758804321,
0.846569836139679,
-0.16856646537780762,
-0.15193910896778107,
-0.07995692640542984,
0.3739042282104492,
-0.29109442234039307,
1.016884207725525,
-0.7341287732124329,
-0.6789731383323669,
-0.3266127109527588,
0.09142747521400452,
-0.122334785759449,
-0.7732575535774231,
0.9015164375305176,
-0.2865252196788788,
-0.26006820797920227,
-1.2022446393966675,
-0.9532700777053833,
-0.33847230672836304,
0.45148831605911255,
-0.6878030896186829,
0.9573825001716614,
0.209193155169487,
-0.5812471508979797,
0.8692788481712341,
-0.8128660321235657,
-0.5079606175422668,
0.16437922418117523,
-0.409027099609375,
-0.06108245998620987,
0.061291106045246124,
0.23214322328567505,
0.4905296266078949,
-0.7910639047622681,
0.2871924340724945,
-0.5505108833312988,
0.19689851999282837,
0.2392171323299408,
-0.1812010407447815,
0.5375535488128662,
0.5527613162994385,
-0.051335081458091736,
0.004293056204915047,
-0.636773407459259,
0.06441842764616013,
0.239836186170578,
-0.25535494089126587,
-0.8443885445594788,
0.379167765378952,
-0.2580936849117279,
0.005474884528666735,
0.19802945852279663,
-0.9442103505134583,
0.2853587567806244,
-0.06985564529895782,
0.23895366489887238,
0.3351743519306183,
0.38536131381988525,
0.09794649481773376,
-0.7179317474365234,
0.3693813681602478,
-0.01750660501420498,
0.17775402963161469,
-0.039846111088991165,
-0.5615684390068054,
-0.45299869775772095,
-0.35073357820510864,
0.21979616582393646,
0.8630353212356567,
-1.1083370447158813,
0.4271763861179352,
-0.1301080733537674,
-0.6954264640808105,
-0.3597007393836975,
-0.050291817635297775,
0.0022017676383256912,
0.6655805706977844,
0.39341914653778076,
-0.011366531252861023,
-0.5877060890197754,
-0.8210413455963135,
-0.6748391389846802,
0.3517681360244751,
-0.09973783046007156,
0.09742129594087601,
0.22492621839046478,
-0.10663274675607681,
0.8307551741600037,
-0.9499332308769226,
0.03656699135899544,
-0.16022607684135437,
-0.06536739319562912,
0.1307571679353714,
0.4163913130760193,
0.7724284529685974,
-0.777808666229248,
-1.0572705268859863,
0.4402906000614166,
-1.1178475618362427,
0.09755466878414154,
0.3525274693965912,
-0.17319510877132416,
-0.42545267939567566,
0.3135337233543396,
-0.7580582499504089,
0.37469780445098877,
0.2680550515651703,
-0.8375574350357056,
0.7427151799201965,
0.460186630487442,
0.5870751738548279,
-1.2610163688659668,
-0.36579152941703796,
0.37183499336242676,
0.03192539140582085,
-0.31269124150276184,
0.10513541102409363,
0.18236058950424194,
0.1653786301612854,
-0.13929344713687897,
0.7046284675598145,
-0.24468891322612762,
0.13494278490543365,
-0.09864991158246994,
-0.30730634927749634,
0.6721631288528442,
0.11695671081542969,
-0.07457675039768219,
0.5236227512359619,
0.7142882347106934,
-0.3091239035129547,
0.9799185395240784,
0.2338046282529831,
-0.8162820935249329,
0.9272538423538208,
-0.27080196142196655,
-0.26347941160202026,
0.1629999279975891,
0.026854394003748894,
-1.33441162109375,
-0.2135334312915802,
0.3510020971298218,
-0.1318342387676239,
-0.031153513118624687,
-0.21853068470954895,
-0.41660282015800476,
-0.7501291632652283,
0.02770303562283516,
-0.15424731373786926,
-0.14429867267608643,
-0.6512552499771118,
0.9060039520263672,
0.262662798166275,
-0.3499583899974823,
-0.2698301076889038,
-0.5633241534233093,
0.17614227533340454,
-0.2409486174583435,
-0.549461841583252,
-0.028223209083080292,
0.0954328402876854,
-0.5170214772224426,
0.10024462640285492,
-0.1838211566209793,
-0.22889336943626404,
0.3052988052368164,
0.24186477065086365,
0.18932847678661346,
-0.36885330080986023,
0.033375587314367294,
0.09808332473039627,
0.28701111674308777,
0.4401102364063263,
-0.4416980445384979,
0.14846181869506836,
-0.04247008636593819,
-0.503330647945404,
-0.37000468373298645,
0.6159874796867371,
0.8468301892280579,
-0.2913050055503845,
0.706740140914917,
0.5098772644996643,
-0.16343477368354797,
0.04422014206647873,
-0.8078045845031738,
-0.1302572637796402,
-0.4770854711532593,
0.1287461221218109,
-0.5042883157730103,
-0.26153531670570374,
0.6516163945198059,
-0.3521271347999573,
0.35015809535980225,
0.570850670337677,
-0.1086781769990921,
-0.18333177268505096,
0.7585889101028442,
0.012643393129110336,
0.19595026969909668,
0.12807351350784302,
-0.04604402557015419,
-0.1714368462562561,
-0.6696867346763611,
-0.5342608094215393,
-0.7812134027481079,
-0.23211167752742767,
-0.3275102376937866,
-0.5925202369689941,
0.43980672955513,
-0.4756357967853546,
-0.2862803637981415,
0.18882213532924652,
-0.6060498356819153,
1.0058269500732422,
0.3420414924621582,
0.29852935671806335,
0.3803834319114685,
-0.18714848160743713,
-0.5686061978340149,
-0.17506718635559082,
-0.579312264919281,
-0.39114755392074585,
0.9230648875236511,
0.11377626657485962,
0.7823732495307922,
0.5544778108596802,
0.49993735551834106,
0.6115938425064087,
0.2486429065465927,
-0.9478517174720764,
0.3913007080554962,
-0.4221343994140625,
-0.7376328706741333,
-0.22134260833263397,
-0.7196385264396667,
-0.4021915793418884,
0.41558289527893066,
-0.13907963037490845,
-0.342820942401886,
0.3466436266899109,
-0.1782809942960739,
-0.1904338151216507,
0.40739554166793823,
-1.280550479888916,
1.04795503616333,
-0.665364146232605,
-0.6641919612884521,
0.17522650957107544,
-0.2005324363708496,
0.5277838110923767,
0.30009493231773376,
0.16519926488399506,
-0.18904277682304382,
0.40969061851501465,
0.7831767201423645,
-0.45097726583480835,
0.7845236659049988,
-0.7700642347335815,
-0.14062434434890747,
0.19272027909755707,
0.6444375514984131,
0.3099730312824249,
0.19318805634975433,
-0.35498714447021484,
-0.03873017802834511,
0.6533216834068298,
-0.2863054573535919,
-0.9839392900466919,
1.0075441598892212,
-0.4493923783302307,
-0.5781028270721436,
-0.4441867470741272,
-0.1523657888174057,
-0.6601695418357849,
0.5262293219566345,
-0.04404624179005623,
-0.0094040771946311,
-0.3528098165988922,
0.004877248778939247,
0.6633031964302063,
-0.022509928792715073,
0.13092157244682312,
0.27928483486175537,
-0.44251111149787903,
-0.3274095356464386,
1.1614269018173218,
0.1097172200679779,
0.04342380538582802,
0.4667649567127228,
0.5944834351539612,
-0.20360854268074036,
-0.0264272578060627,
-0.12944519519805908,
-0.2091333121061325,
-0.8073647618293762,
-0.3757854104042053,
-0.5364961624145508,
-0.019741075113415718,
-0.5389201641082764,
-0.16648751497268677,
-0.6755655407905579,
-0.751332700252533,
0.11545813828706741,
-0.3616842031478882,
0.5445515513420105,
0.8170982599258423,
-0.004861917812377214,
-0.08462671935558319,
-0.787764847278595,
0.542452335357666,
0.3105195462703705,
0.5397822856903076,
0.19586274027824402,
0.06919363886117935,
-0.4648240804672241,
-0.007509407587349415,
-0.4953426122665405,
-0.9032142162322998,
0.15099753439426422,
0.3476695418357849,
0.7328545451164246,
0.5946841835975647,
0.2259511798620224,
0.3294927179813385,
-0.17725025117397308,
0.8830451369285583,
0.502155601978302,
-0.4792543649673462,
0.6583776473999023,
-0.2440783977508545,
0.43875280022621155,
0.823902428150177,
0.7843126058578491,
-0.6272608041763306,
-0.12036269903182983,
-0.18073606491088867,
-0.6185780763626099,
-0.15214738249778748,
-0.5214442610740662,
-0.23047393560409546,
-0.4315739870071411,
0.3005683124065399,
0.5330536365509033,
-0.02746179886162281,
-0.3724327087402344,
-0.14297568798065186,
-0.6967674493789673,
-0.12852399051189423,
0.24936823546886444,
-0.11663047224283218,
-0.42231082916259766,
-0.7827624082565308,
0.4939284920692444,
0.18755842745304108,
-0.06868229061365128,
0.08352209627628326,
0.3273142874240875,
0.09960750490427017,
0.17601746320724487,
0.45991960167884827,
0.774078905582428,
-0.07817770540714264,
0.31474804878234863,
-0.13290616869926453,
-0.3640413284301758,
0.3228754699230194,
-0.18375201523303986,
0.33847561478614807,
0.016629807651042938,
0.4464292526245117,
0.555443525314331,
-0.018635589629411697,
-0.23337988555431366,
0.5266788601875305,
-0.38040247559547424,
-0.33409491181373596,
-0.11868880689144135,
0.23239348828792572,
0.3359150290489197,
0.1330399215221405,
0.25680747628211975,
0.2859911322593689,
0.5107362270355225,
-0.2629372775554657,
0.5356599688529968,
0.19579912722110748,
-0.1355399191379547,
-0.044553328305482864,
0.3506317734718323,
0.4060065746307373,
0.41971924901008606,
0.590339183807373,
0.028256140649318695,
-0.17081962525844574,
0.5249658226966858,
0.030429910868406296,
0.6634674072265625,
-0.5717034339904785,
0.6072955131530762,
0.35513755679130554,
-0.044748272746801376,
0.020516108721494675,
0.5241644978523254,
-0.4080086648464203,
-0.7755934000015259,
-0.20290060341358185,
-0.6182493567466736,
-0.3375975489616394,
-0.44042882323265076,
-0.8948032855987549,
-0.031559888273477554,
-0.5178002119064331,
-0.40243130922317505,
0.45534995198249817,
-0.2429441511631012,
-0.6653690338134766,
0.016123734414577484,
-0.33649325370788574,
1.3279054164886475,
-1.001858115196228,
0.5259363651275635,
0.8376899361610413,
-0.19961045682430267,
-0.6038564443588257,
-0.10255356878042221,
0.236316978931427,
-0.6554526686668396,
0.7627385854721069,
-0.3492893576622009,
-0.20823925733566284,
-0.4067201018333435,
-0.4031042158603668,
-0.646194577217102,
0.5837600231170654,
0.030862364917993546,
-0.5271152853965759,
-0.023983579128980637,
-0.10667005181312561,
0.10029447078704834,
-0.16270971298217773,
-0.05728200078010559,
0.6514824628829956,
0.9854423999786377,
0.5054460763931274,
-0.7956030368804932,
-0.0243829358369112,
-0.23052965104579926,
-0.2218618094921112,
0.21866466104984283,
-0.4732462763786316,
0.6751495003700256,
-0.049769360572099686,
-0.03859800100326538,
-0.03393286466598511,
0.523577094078064,
-0.10275672376155853,
0.4073898196220398,
0.04118647426366806,
0.6948306560516357,
0.799055814743042,
-0.4185231029987335,
1.0833300352096558,
0.1717473715543747,
0.16472749412059784,
1.3234035968780518,
-0.820556640625,
0.4769790768623352,
0.4414640963077545,
-0.18278199434280396,
0.8120357990264893,
0.903823971748352,
-0.2012363225221634,
1.1058539152145386,
0.03138841316103935,
-0.39467015862464905,
-0.15093013644218445,
-0.30521783232688904,
-0.365127295255661,
0.7412242889404297,
0.6505016088485718,
-0.3795360326766968,
-0.40068894624710083,
0.24769841134548187,
-0.19322404265403748,
0.212898388504982,
0.0455087274312973,
1.1963720321655273,
0.013424653559923172,
-0.7199390530586243,
0.49833086133003235,
0.08282072097063065,
0.0628451481461525,
-0.5295498371124268,
-0.39910247921943665,
-0.15711049735546112,
-0.05567677319049835,
-0.35836806893348694,
-1.05781090259552,
0.3202647268772125,
-0.400336354970932,
-0.47568708658218384,
-0.0887245237827301,
0.6588934659957886,
-0.12086205184459686,
-0.6287739276885986,
0.22178497910499573,
0.6817615032196045,
-0.34766119718551636,
-0.04648175463080406,
-0.46281546354293823,
0.1537480652332306,
-0.18241608142852783,
-0.028543028980493546,
0.03288563713431358,
0.5880143642425537,
0.2178780734539032,
0.3982482850551605,
0.3093772530555725,
0.20369437336921692,
0.16321495175361633,
0.09239323437213898,
0.834547758102417,
-0.5234052538871765,
-0.6670225858688354,
-0.7407523393630981,
0.38972795009613037,
-0.19701097905635834,
0.1029861569404602,
1.1022729873657227,
0.5215022563934326,
0.9084261059761047,
-0.31008750200271606,
1.205410361289978,
-0.3446520268917084,
0.8407909870147705,
-0.5350403189659119,
0.6109921336174011,
-0.5267594456672668,
0.3702685236930847,
-0.29100531339645386,
-0.6793402433395386,
-0.19132494926452637,
0.6435496807098389,
-0.6057599186897278,
0.1450587511062622,
0.512428879737854,
0.6379638910293579,
-0.2157621681690216,
0.4023040235042572,
0.3256441652774811,
-0.14021964371204376,
0.27439242601394653,
0.18414990603923798,
1.0898566246032715,
-0.18869727849960327,
-0.42474979162216187,
-0.35208868980407715,
-0.3782441020011902,
-0.10624904930591583,
-0.6212751269340515,
-0.5060598254203796,
-0.7142061591148376,
-0.3026789426803589,
-0.1357114166021347,
0.011230283416807652,
0.6982907652854919,
0.9142818450927734,
-0.9222947359085083,
-0.30934393405914307,
0.12385592609643936,
0.4944239556789398,
-0.9694876074790955,
-0.3195277154445648,
0.11181061714887619,
-0.03765036538243294,
0.004933538381010294,
0.7767718434333801,
0.20409400761127472,
-0.40650904178619385,
-0.21259969472885132,
0.06688631325960159,
-0.6607136130332947,
-0.009004239924252033,
0.8162302374839783,
0.5314797163009644,
-0.4689759314060211,
0.05129888281226158,
-0.13215364515781403,
0.20319172739982605,
-0.0699344351887703,
0.9515734314918518,
-0.2725507616996765,
0.6544992923736572,
0.2710660696029663,
0.9180065393447876,
0.34811636805534363,
-0.16844142973423004,
0.4189314842224121,
-0.8492797613143921,
-0.31969746947288513,
0.053869400173425674,
0.4521591067314148,
0.36750301718711853,
-0.6083249449729919,
0.4178960919380188,
0.2821277678012848,
-0.5160852074623108,
-0.40761598944664,
0.322725385427475,
-0.5895938873291016,
-0.7068965435028076,
0.7713912129402161,
-0.2507302761077881,
-0.16894476115703583,
-0.2326362431049347,
0.19931279122829437,
0.06111445650458336,
-0.21620284020900726,
0.878589928150177,
0.9019336700439453,
-0.4324813783168793,
-0.1399897187948227,
-0.6723629832267761,
0.3804919421672821,
0.16334164142608643,
-0.9686464071273804,
0.22813092172145844,
0.7148023247718811,
0.6570289134979248,
0.35785725712776184,
0.01732461340725422,
0.08832951635122299,
0.2533434331417084,
-0.016581231728196144,
0.0640668198466301,
-0.040882594883441925,
-0.800530195236206,
0.7533620595932007,
0.3025337755680084,
0.27044427394866943,
-0.25601646304130554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00522v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00522v1
|
DAM: A Universal Dual Attention Mechanism for Multimodal Timeseries Cryptocurrency Trend Forecasting
| 2024-05-01T13:58:01 | 2024-05-01T13:58:01 |
Yihang Fu, Mingyu Zhou, Luyao Zhang
|
econ.GN
|
econ.GN, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.CR, q-fin.CP, q-fin.EC
|
In the distributed systems landscape, Blockchain has catalyzed the rise of
cryptocurrencies, merging enhanced security and decentralization with
significant investment opportunities. Despite their potential, current research
on cryptocurrency trend forecasting often falls short by simplistically merging
sentiment data without fully considering the nuanced interplay between
financial market dynamics and external sentiment influences. This paper
presents a novel Dual Attention Mechanism (DAM) for forecasting cryptocurrency
trends using multimodal time-series data. Our approach, which integrates
critical cryptocurrency metrics with sentiment data from news and social media
analyzed through CryptoBERT, addresses the inherent volatility and prediction
challenges in cryptocurrency markets. By combining elements of distributed
systems, natural language processing, and financial forecasting, our method
outperforms conventional models like LSTM and Transformer by up to 20\% in
prediction accuracy. This advancement deepens the understanding of distributed
systems and has practical implications in financial markets, benefiting
stakeholders in cryptocurrency and blockchain technologies. Moreover, our
enhanced forecasting approach can significantly support decentralized science
(DeSci) by facilitating strategic planning and the efficient adoption of
blockchain technologies, improving operational efficiency and financial risk
management in the rapidly evolving digital asset domain, thus ensuring optimal
resource allocation.
|
[
-0.43569374084472656,
-0.6245698928833008,
0.05383677035570145,
0.5333725214004517,
-0.8698070645332336,
0.48814985156059265,
-0.07576486468315125,
-0.3987569808959961,
0.5097512006759644,
0.38574013113975525,
-0.8277633786201477,
-0.5008835196495056,
-0.44075801968574524,
-0.2866538465023041,
-0.40995508432388306,
1.2313050031661987,
0.10511427372694016,
0.13532087206840515,
-0.05568883195519447,
0.13702146708965302,
-0.15781113505363464,
-0.2820318937301636,
-0.5873311161994934,
-0.18562918901443481,
0.6010489463806152,
0.2791292071342468,
0.5593819618225098,
0.5114681720733643,
0.9801449179649353,
0.2390562742948532,
0.4660605490207672,
0.32345521450042725,
-0.15427833795547485,
0.4453960955142975,
0.15314944088459015,
0.16711822152137756,
-0.42655259370803833,
-0.11111990362405777,
0.39819756150245667,
0.2839679419994354,
-0.2842279374599457,
0.2353271096944809,
0.007652890868484974,
0.5013645887374878,
-0.7176570296287537,
0.3895939886569977,
-0.38347917795181274,
0.22603173553943634,
-0.29201287031173706,
-0.601459264755249,
-0.12824854254722595,
0.026378577575087547,
0.24271830916404724,
-0.4507177174091339,
0.21451352536678314,
0.24606573581695557,
0.3426222503185272,
0.2930496335029602,
-0.4917950928211212,
-0.015985682606697083,
-0.5756787657737732,
0.7918308973312378,
-0.3339076042175293,
0.26964354515075684,
-0.071268230676651,
0.31755685806274414,
0.21877190470695496,
-0.7478653788566589,
-0.36417391896247864,
0.032855819910764694,
0.11902648955583572,
0.25489768385887146,
-0.21292494237422943,
-0.19511374831199646,
0.07467357069253922,
0.3500692546367645,
-0.1864796280860901,
-0.29547250270843506,
-0.5144505500793457,
-0.3512904644012451,
0.4343384802341461,
0.3963017463684082,
0.039391182363033295,
-0.20220355689525604,
-0.9383206367492676,
-0.1939830183982849,
-0.11375822871923447,
0.047746576368808746,
0.3931082487106323,
0.6258832812309265,
-0.5552324652671814,
0.29997390508651733,
-0.08131585270166397,
0.2581747770309448,
0.20877976715564728,
-0.22343076765537262,
0.19672958552837372,
-0.5895752906799316,
-0.012947375886142254,
0.5522134900093079,
0.855401337146759,
0.7353418469429016,
-0.03534199297428131,
-0.15823541581630707,
-0.11966376006603241,
0.16899095475673676,
0.4014643728733063,
-0.8071575164794922,
0.08475291728973389,
0.34491991996765137,
-0.14708121120929718,
-0.616420328617096,
0.2485194206237793,
-1.4728224277496338,
-0.5955143570899963,
-0.4556649923324585,
0.11531557142734528,
0.038077693432569504,
-0.5732957720756531,
-0.04379335045814514,
-0.5738056898117065,
-0.15002276003360748,
0.0724978893995285,
-0.9128490090370178,
0.5284045338630676,
0.775811493396759,
1.0723670721054077,
-0.14291365444660187,
0.007928956300020218,
-0.6391971707344055,
0.27618128061294556,
-0.16550405323505402,
0.6244006156921387,
-0.2013261318206787,
-0.36914336681365967,
0.012632591649889946,
-0.24473518133163452,
0.19703161716461182,
0.023012105375528336,
0.15132035315036774,
-0.7150120735168457,
-0.039010170847177505,
0.07866937667131424,
0.21931518614292145,
-0.05423835292458534,
0.3667844235897064,
-0.7006736993789673,
0.668933629989624,
-0.12757228314876556,
-1.5248335599899292,
0.27791717648506165,
-0.8777072429656982,
-0.5216002464294434,
-0.14493049681186676,
0.2799051105976105,
-0.5341139435768127,
-0.4355240762233734,
0.4531322419643402,
0.3614802658557892,
-0.45354655385017395,
0.5091663002967834,
-0.9055291414260864,
-0.07473769038915634,
0.5677545070648193,
-0.6512717604637146,
0.4724639654159546,
0.001598741509951651,
-0.7109913229942322,
0.4891703724861145,
-0.8559558391571045,
-0.04857683926820755,
-0.0070437099784612656,
0.45202702283859253,
-0.4015575051307678,
-0.0450093038380146,
0.5393334031105042,
0.36186471581459045,
0.6056271195411682,
-0.32854849100112915,
0.22530122101306915,
-0.3786545693874359,
0.9315467476844788,
1.1191539764404297,
0.32240405678749084,
0.33680427074432373,
-0.020537031814455986,
0.3218672275543213,
0.31009528040885925,
0.5868629217147827,
0.04488718882203102,
-0.018895165994763374,
-0.39708584547042847,
-0.44877761602401733,
0.04263677820563316,
0.5623745322227478,
-0.11159316450357437,
0.008372628130018711,
-0.310524582862854,
-0.3583439290523529,
-0.48435792326927185,
-0.003962322138249874,
-0.16182032227516174,
0.15414296090602875,
0.3074025511741638,
-0.24849064648151398,
-0.8881222605705261,
-0.7934011220932007,
0.08820446580648422,
0.10671592503786087,
0.22472967207431793,
0.08159159123897552,
0.27368834614753723,
-0.4271163046360016,
0.6283798217773438,
-0.25677812099456787,
-0.16039235889911652,
0.04192964732646942,
0.3672237694263458,
0.20136022567749023,
-0.03355412930250168,
0.10402634739875793,
-1.1098047494888306,
-0.26422256231307983,
0.21557419002056122,
-0.4398193359375,
0.3835478723049164,
-0.023550918325781822,
-0.08375337719917297,
0.04976532608270645,
0.14689487218856812,
-0.4672890603542328,
0.262651652097702,
0.6287616491317749,
-0.32777222990989685,
0.43096041679382324,
-0.26139333844184875,
0.2802107036113739,
-1.2788727283477783,
-0.03427086025476456,
0.04126328229904175,
-0.14152979850769043,
-0.27987799048423767,
-0.13303843140602112,
0.22004924714565277,
-0.2316352128982544,
-0.10015971958637238,
0.4723395109176636,
-0.3213854432106018,
0.0009109569946303964,
-0.3485077917575836,
0.462859183549881,
-0.18955551087856293,
0.35809528827667236,
-0.22114719450473785,
0.5540614128112793,
1.1065953969955444,
-0.6339418888092041,
1.0083848237991333,
-0.32942479848861694,
-0.2112540900707245,
0.43637263774871826,
-0.6595535278320312,
0.15946877002716064,
0.025712713599205017,
-0.20140834152698517,
-1.1231999397277832,
-0.10086597502231598,
0.5747065544128418,
-0.3047442138195038,
0.42498278617858887,
0.4053933620452881,
-0.3928016722202301,
-0.7925751805305481,
-0.7193577885627747,
0.24587313830852509,
-0.023409070447087288,
-0.3304557502269745,
0.5570359230041504,
0.33293211460113525,
-0.166468545794487,
-1.188118577003479,
-0.49651750922203064,
0.06818471848964691,
-0.4336695969104767,
-0.5672968626022339,
0.28177475929260254,
-0.34794723987579346,
-0.5595844388008118,
-0.03923756256699562,
-0.32394298911094666,
0.2957404851913452,
0.055524177849292755,
0.6965096592903137,
0.9052795171737671,
0.10173933207988739,
-0.0214689951390028,
-0.025198787450790405,
-0.4082793593406677,
0.0862221047282219,
-0.74412602186203,
0.5417216420173645,
0.0493745394051075,
-0.0689719170331955,
-0.7730262875556946,
0.3195464313030243,
1.0798676013946533,
-0.2914291322231293,
0.7656945586204529,
0.5360177159309387,
-0.0524357371032238,
-0.049889590591192245,
-0.4663774371147156,
-0.3353133201599121,
-0.45550039410591125,
0.09709064662456512,
-0.1745777279138565,
-0.7865478992462158,
0.5726981163024902,
0.2327064871788025,
0.07322624325752258,
0.42972415685653687,
0.808597981929779,
0.31721487641334534,
1.3717361688613892,
0.7520890831947327,
-0.3757941424846649,
0.5969052910804749,
-0.29163068532943726,
0.41706615686416626,
-0.7768074870109558,
-0.2632458508014679,
-0.13527216017246246,
-0.5101820230484009,
-0.7970353960990906,
-0.29085808992385864,
0.2680797874927521,
-0.18335923552513123,
-0.2806369662284851,
0.19032113254070282,
-0.5326327085494995,
-0.34021681547164917,
0.5889177322387695,
0.14355532824993134,
0.43147507309913635,
0.32563114166259766,
-0.1680302619934082,
-0.09944158047437668,
-0.22078758478164673,
0.04674532637000084,
1.4473077058792114,
0.13137856125831604,
0.8113524913787842,
-0.4614752531051636,
0.416900634765625,
0.7702695727348328,
0.5387913584709167,
-0.6221060752868652,
0.0002942100982181728,
0.043056849390268326,
-0.5087915658950806,
-0.31501248478889465,
-0.3150709271430969,
-0.46453532576560974,
0.24568921327590942,
0.13668742775917053,
-0.2532615661621094,
0.35835137963294983,
-0.17374397814273834,
-0.42613789439201355,
0.2769289016723633,
-0.14324593544006348,
0.9508324265480042,
-0.08528502285480499,
-0.5126354694366455,
-0.7626849412918091,
-0.4901786148548126,
0.18796055018901825,
-0.04346361383795738,
0.6590359210968018,
-0.23824943602085114,
-0.5516178607940674,
0.454507052898407,
-0.1782855987548828,
0.770133912563324,
-0.02077210322022438,
0.01247407030314207,
0.12818801403045654,
-0.5099499821662903,
0.6976547241210938,
0.5511243939399719,
0.20916648209095,
0.19644971191883087,
-0.32750725746154785,
-0.381738543510437,
-0.27598732709884644,
1.099938154220581,
-0.8937142491340637,
-0.4392632842063904,
-0.51446932554245,
-0.6530007123947144,
-0.053159747272729874,
0.08688055723905563,
0.15084055066108704,
0.5571121573448181,
-0.22087228298187256,
-0.07719045132398605,
0.17422211170196533,
0.8287940621376038,
0.6730979084968567,
0.5827139019966125,
0.14783984422683716,
-1.1108253002166748,
0.6919437646865845,
-0.1451038420200348,
0.031264778226614,
0.7163242101669312,
0.15312616527080536,
-0.4484013020992279,
-0.22736097872257233,
-0.2794940769672394,
0.2520900070667267,
-0.5237069129943848,
-0.22838827967643738,
-0.8267152309417725,
0.18911895155906677,
-0.9061782360076904,
0.13598233461380005,
-0.30976781249046326,
-0.26178160309791565,
-0.07599857449531555,
-0.2374466061592102,
0.3963279128074646,
0.15505538880825043,
-0.3438681662082672,
-0.09478020668029785,
-0.6096493005752563,
0.69716477394104,
0.6302167177200317,
0.21038798987865448,
0.08883118629455566,
-0.24986517429351807,
-0.2220517098903656,
0.29927563667297363,
-0.4504231810569763,
-0.8110014200210571,
0.49708881974220276,
-0.19720473885536194,
0.1652609258890152,
1.037044644355774,
0.20233304798603058,
0.7963892817497253,
-0.22028160095214844,
0.25916433334350586,
0.6736941933631897,
-0.8333308100700378,
0.6113858222961426,
-0.22783787548542023,
-0.08023711293935776,
0.05543173477053642,
0.2971441149711609,
-0.9080758690834045,
-0.6604418754577637,
-0.5078713297843933,
-0.8207514882087708,
0.8267641067504883,
-0.17504994571208954,
0.12832441926002502,
-0.07371149957180023,
-0.1835336983203888,
0.23418639600276947,
0.707444965839386,
-0.681818962097168,
-0.5693790912628174,
-0.7543390989303589,
-0.1498217135667801,
-0.041145458817481995,
-0.21828711032867432,
-0.24380964040756226,
-0.11571477353572845,
0.6864637732505798,
-0.11271687597036362,
0.0006929124938324094,
0.10819815844297409,
0.40336719155311584,
-0.5850619077682495,
0.380614310503006,
0.37071964144706726,
0.6918193101882935,
-0.2778453230857849,
0.08863463252782822,
-0.19039785861968994,
-0.39324966073036194,
-0.008470173925161362,
0.5275874137878418,
-0.3217798173427582,
-0.141304150223732,
0.11439821124076843,
0.9068577885627747,
0.6002479791641235,
-0.6638690829277039,
0.43922221660614014,
-0.15473094582557678,
-0.11097215116024017,
-0.4810503125190735,
-0.30976060032844543,
0.016509659588336945,
0.5740714073181152,
0.6341584920883179,
0.6311120390892029,
0.35929226875305176,
-0.6280373334884644,
0.11054468154907227,
0.5196400880813599,
-0.7273369431495667,
-0.5434070229530334,
0.9597226977348328,
-0.012968916445970535,
0.0521952286362648,
0.4796624183654785,
0.15018221735954285,
-0.2823043763637543,
0.7123769521713257,
0.4060926139354706,
1.0272129774093628,
-0.3569297194480896,
0.21402549743652344,
0.5034408569335938,
0.1484566032886505,
-0.19651100039482117,
0.17350813746452332,
-0.35436680912971497,
-0.5107556581497192,
-0.4668727517127991,
-0.5845514535903931,
0.009258453734219074,
-0.15743528306484222,
-0.6304604411125183,
0.5599690079689026,
-0.6215590238571167,
-0.5715351700782776,
0.350776731967926,
0.24641765654087067,
-0.48243552446365356,
0.09257438778877258,
0.42180734872817993,
0.4788026511669159,
-0.44241976737976074,
0.5195064544677734,
0.6780455112457275,
-0.13296689093112946,
-0.12659995257854462,
-0.1109897717833519,
0.0034280268009752035,
-0.7392777800559998,
0.5638501644134521,
0.3699782192707062,
-0.1409653127193451,
-0.048718441277742386,
-0.48441484570503235,
-0.782656192779541,
0.9846415519714355,
0.07668053358793259,
-0.7539569139480591,
-0.1294039785861969,
-0.08919277042150497,
0.3050042986869812,
-0.5008369088172913,
0.11518214643001556,
0.07384464144706726,
0.8865290284156799,
0.050897207111120224,
-0.5406531691551208,
-0.1026245728135109,
-0.4612244665622711,
-0.20008769631385803,
0.7984305024147034,
-0.8173662424087524,
0.5879080891609192,
-0.7512526512145996,
-0.47693219780921936,
-0.17779496312141418,
0.7432434558868408,
-0.01346089318394661,
0.8252385258674622,
0.6122013330459595,
0.4387029707431793,
0.5208877325057983,
-0.08897918462753296,
0.8814586997032166,
-0.6998153924942017,
0.6166220903396606,
0.5041869282722473,
-0.02203083410859108,
0.6175435185432434,
0.7975161075592041,
-0.3830054700374603,
0.7701495289802551,
0.6142755746841431,
0.018620673567056656,
1.0544896125793457,
-0.13400721549987793,
-0.23422271013259888,
-0.6305044293403625,
-0.3084459602832794,
-0.5810165405273438,
0.13941732048988342,
0.20560021698474884,
-0.0412553995847702,
0.03206799924373627,
0.34715673327445984,
-0.3729482591152191,
-0.16017654538154602,
-0.5488710403442383,
0.4855996072292328,
0.1651705503463745,
-0.42195212841033936,
0.041435979306697845,
0.06036078557372093,
0.8739553093910217,
-0.7292103171348572,
0.3477799892425537,
0.001459288876503706,
0.42687487602233887,
0.09696409851312637,
-0.2782175540924072,
-0.0037883904296904802,
-0.3137892186641693,
-0.5337061882019043,
-0.3461277484893799,
0.4115752875804901,
-0.32436296343803406,
-0.6195014715194702,
0.5713310241699219,
-0.11272900551557541,
-0.5594660043716431,
-0.3542132079601288,
-0.6795816421508789,
-0.28235653042793274,
-0.19931800663471222,
-0.07641211152076721,
0.27781423926353455,
0.5694892406463623,
0.06628426909446716,
0.8058302402496338,
0.7263287901878357,
-0.07942020893096924,
-0.14367343485355377,
0.263194739818573,
0.8225974440574646,
-0.7890004515647888,
-1.0009592771530151,
-0.8375601768493652,
0.42175793647766113,
-0.26700082421302795,
-0.0019772788509726524,
0.6464279294013977,
0.4320056736469269,
0.4765572249889374,
0.05472064018249512,
0.7212429642677307,
0.21050840616226196,
0.36645615100860596,
0.06475827842950821,
0.21089370548725128,
-0.5866230130195618,
-0.056126922369003296,
-0.016214560717344284,
-0.5688477754592896,
0.06974537670612335,
-0.1029706746339798,
-0.3943953812122345,
-0.24780656397342682,
0.6665291786193848,
0.47334837913513184,
-0.0762757882475853,
0.14855271577835083,
-0.012735745869576931,
-0.023935837671160698,
-0.13254186511039734,
0.32759159803390503,
0.5536872744560242,
-0.35125279426574707,
0.8086274862289429,
-0.8316477537155151,
-0.014366325922310352,
-0.5512207746505737,
-0.6241849064826965,
-0.8748130202293396,
-0.38736453652381897,
-0.34758785367012024,
-0.06385750323534012,
0.0474374033510685,
0.7500439286231995,
0.5686613321304321,
-1.1268020868301392,
-0.15398147702217102,
0.07775013148784637,
0.2167581170797348,
-0.7737969160079956,
-0.3759198486804962,
0.45886483788490295,
-0.3073776960372925,
-0.7573373913764954,
-0.01996489055454731,
0.8607994914054871,
-0.0850958526134491,
-0.5913427472114563,
0.07530954480171204,
0.27329081296920776,
-0.1759679764509201,
0.2451578676700592,
-0.3112248480319977,
-0.5719144344329834,
0.10687407851219177,
0.33615416288375854,
-0.3233129680156708,
0.0574631430208683,
1.2351077795028687,
-0.432836651802063,
0.5386924147605896,
0.49174565076828003,
0.0288398340344429,
0.5466428399085999,
0.029870042577385902,
0.3351919949054718,
-0.41018083691596985,
0.44341614842414856,
-0.012823953293263912,
0.1880078762769699,
0.38808733224868774,
-0.5192832350730896,
-0.0910787582397461,
0.6382716298103333,
-0.2708744406700134,
-0.6535293459892273,
-0.27657532691955566,
-1.0753648281097412,
-0.11734757572412491,
0.4543997049331665,
0.31178387999534607,
-0.3335692882537842,
-0.07097040861845016,
-0.023107564076781273,
0.49877429008483887,
-0.7825157046318054,
1.1200151443481445,
0.648998498916626,
0.38527315855026245,
-0.29098328948020935,
-0.7521505951881409,
0.11572379618883133,
-0.08617424219846725,
-0.3687424659729004,
0.2892361283302307,
0.22839319705963135,
0.08328720182180405,
0.463237464427948,
0.3841079771518707,
-0.1340147703886032,
0.5839807987213135,
0.06942606717348099,
0.008046046830713749,
-0.33807581663131714,
-0.4333762228488922,
0.14708015322685242,
0.503983736038208,
-0.4334781765937805,
-0.32420068979263306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00516v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00516v1
|
Navigating WebAI: Training Agents to Complete Web Tasks with Large Language Models and Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-05-01T13:51:45 | 2024-05-01T13:51:45 |
Lucas-Andreï Thil, Mirela Popa, Gerasimos Spanakis
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, 68T07, I.2.7; I.2.8; I.2.1
|
Recent advancements in language models have demonstrated remarkable
improvements in various natural language processing (NLP) tasks such as web
navigation. Supervised learning (SL) approaches have achieved impressive
performance while utilizing significantly less training data compared to
previous methods. However, these SL-based models fall short when compared to
reinforcement learning (RL) approaches, which have shown superior results. In
this paper, we propose a novel approach that combines SL and RL techniques over
the MiniWoB benchmark to leverage the strengths of both methods. We also
address a critical limitation in previous models' understanding of HTML
content, revealing a tendency to memorize target elements rather than
comprehend the underlying structure. To rectify this, we propose methods to
enhance true understanding and present a new baseline of results. Our
experiments demonstrate that our approach outperforms previous SL methods on
certain tasks using less data and narrows the performance gap with RL models,
achieving 43.58\% average accuracy in SL and 36.69\% when combined with a
multimodal RL approach. This study sets a new direction for future web
navigation and offers insights into the limitations and potential of language
modeling for computer tasks.
|
[
-0.44280099868774414,
-0.8007635474205017,
0.37808844447135925,
0.021104246377944946,
-0.05802635848522186,
0.2779277265071869,
-0.2482060194015503,
-0.41436681151390076,
-0.07627546787261963,
0.18091638386249542,
-0.8941764235496521,
-0.572558581829071,
-0.42036280035972595,
-0.07086344063282013,
-0.2202487587928772,
0.9149091243743896,
0.17710256576538086,
0.011291158385574818,
-0.47452232241630554,
-0.11697554588317871,
-0.2745102345943451,
-0.31965988874435425,
-0.9407018423080444,
-0.5864315032958984,
0.8112426400184631,
0.2911383807659149,
0.7637125253677368,
0.6835598349571228,
0.36557501554489136,
0.3173075020313263,
0.10623721778392792,
0.4595431685447693,
-0.3865683972835541,
-0.02882423996925354,
-0.39137715101242065,
-0.5358220338821411,
-0.4117274284362793,
0.01278778724372387,
0.3226606249809265,
0.8034458160400391,
-0.2536904215812683,
-0.020589975640177727,
-0.11253629624843597,
0.7992715239524841,
-0.7895680069923401,
0.3116605281829834,
-0.3611829876899719,
0.1139594316482544,
0.07873956859111786,
-0.26418137550354004,
-0.7194837927818298,
0.0009464712929911911,
0.2983708679676056,
-1.0999034643173218,
0.24697116017341614,
0.22498393058776855,
0.8080140352249146,
0.4148768186569214,
-0.7834104895591736,
-0.4033917188644409,
-0.5630403757095337,
0.9852391481399536,
-0.6129445433616638,
0.7304720878601074,
0.5887129306793213,
0.4494722783565521,
-0.0886612981557846,
-0.7401131987571716,
-0.3861527144908905,
-0.36780402064323425,
-0.05151021108031273,
0.035832252353429794,
-0.3291700482368469,
0.023035047575831413,
0.19996868073940277,
-0.2773140072822571,
-0.8552975654602051,
0.29687145352363586,
-0.11302024871110916,
-0.20218826830387115,
0.7480248808860779,
0.17490364611148834,
0.37800663709640503,
0.011380800977349281,
-0.4293181300163269,
-0.6699159741401672,
-0.3693997263908386,
0.28889375925064087,
0.11324770003557205,
0.6174371242523193,
-0.15289436280727386,
0.13826997578144073,
-0.4064365327358246,
0.6967981457710266,
0.052613936364650726,
-0.6307876110076904,
0.36363062262535095,
-0.21797147393226624,
-0.06233362480998039,
-0.2559848427772522,
0.6000158786773682,
0.38631129264831543,
0.2596433758735657,
-0.28955838084220886,
-0.301858127117157,
0.052550412714481354,
0.5518079996109009,
-0.3826391398906708,
-0.4034900665283203,
0.008480207063257694,
-0.5696181058883667,
-0.020096812397241592,
-0.005304153077304363,
-0.6863065958023071,
-0.3841472566127777,
-0.3076322376728058,
0.2848643958568573,
-0.44908663630485535,
-0.2930228114128113,
-0.22249610722064972,
-0.23041819036006927,
0.33690956234931946,
0.5630713701248169,
-0.9051839709281921,
0.5129543542861938,
0.6356296539306641,
0.6662377119064331,
-0.5059147477149963,
-0.4504876434803009,
-0.6725946664810181,
0.2542356848716736,
-0.324282169342041,
0.6578814387321472,
-0.4666473865509033,
-0.2650526463985443,
0.21645350754261017,
-0.29541558027267456,
-0.14757698774337769,
-0.3806401789188385,
0.17255893349647522,
-0.7411452531814575,
-0.13452893495559692,
0.15684807300567627,
-0.38989511132240295,
-0.5545681715011597,
0.46497413516044617,
-0.8662635087966919,
0.6836218237876892,
-0.1865759640932083,
-0.40529122948646545,
0.24206474423408508,
-0.5491796135902405,
-0.7170725464820862,
-0.11765434592962265,
0.040324483066797256,
-0.3231668174266815,
-0.10709570348262787,
0.5149610638618469,
0.37318170070648193,
-0.07168205827474594,
-0.07959161698818207,
-0.10147407650947571,
-0.17983748018741608,
0.2841375470161438,
-0.4257558286190033,
0.543556809425354,
0.13622665405273438,
-0.20744042098522186,
0.1773926019668579,
-0.8354019522666931,
0.23726999759674072,
0.20567794144153595,
-0.534085214138031,
-0.5887988209724426,
0.06734349578619003,
0.2151443511247635,
0.22983063757419586,
0.30052509903907776,
-0.1568385809659958,
0.28833964467048645,
-0.23455810546875,
0.02811235748231411,
0.7292714715003967,
-0.07373634725809097,
0.6766127347946167,
-0.29259437322616577,
0.6978989243507385,
-0.0713077187538147,
0.36723387241363525,
0.02795541100203991,
-0.43678829073905945,
-1.0295469760894775,
0.2571444511413574,
0.326753705739975,
0.5244850516319275,
-1.3026295900344849,
-0.2602027952671051,
-0.40818753838539124,
-0.5726298093795776,
-0.49154800176620483,
0.26911094784736633,
0.8485727906227112,
0.17174585163593292,
0.7474874258041382,
-0.30050283670425415,
-0.5190499424934387,
-0.6486602425575256,
-0.23745207488536835,
-0.337361603975296,
0.11020679771900177,
0.28116998076438904,
0.48988834023475647,
-0.5292676687240601,
0.842248797416687,
-0.44888320565223694,
-0.37641552090644836,
-0.6822119951248169,
0.43805158138275146,
-0.1469198316335678,
0.5354369878768921,
0.09208868443965912,
-1.2578643560409546,
-0.6326267719268799,
0.17319457232952118,
-0.7053486704826355,
0.20058411359786987,
-0.2565138041973114,
0.2608351707458496,
0.1470988541841507,
0.5368562936782837,
-0.4399822950363159,
0.502907395362854,
0.4459286034107208,
-0.06714700162410736,
0.3262788653373718,
-0.32367250323295593,
-0.05417706444859505,
-0.4889616072177887,
-0.289011687040329,
0.5157229900360107,
-0.5631903409957886,
-0.8861547708511353,
0.541898787021637,
0.19625170528888702,
0.08197199553251266,
-0.5988871455192566,
0.6414515376091003,
-0.6968941688537598,
-0.10623306781053543,
-0.5378293395042419,
0.3224325180053711,
-0.11720390617847443,
0.990215003490448,
-0.0807783231139183,
0.784615695476532,
0.282594233751297,
-0.9424875378608704,
0.50482577085495,
0.27854683995246887,
0.14023888111114502,
0.38382354378700256,
-0.31537050008773804,
0.08985906839370728,
-0.14068999886512756,
0.2852950990200043,
-0.6894815564155579,
-0.09493641555309296,
-0.06626889854669571,
-0.6823932528495789,
0.3118714392185211,
-0.18277429044246674,
-0.3731401562690735,
-0.20024217665195465,
-0.17557522654533386,
0.25668561458587646,
0.5318055152893066,
-0.4610357880592346,
0.8939183950424194,
0.3362201154232025,
0.049140945076942444,
-0.49839019775390625,
-0.6246943473815918,
-0.007674656808376312,
-0.10018607974052429,
-0.4078436493873596,
0.39548954367637634,
0.055778779089450836,
-0.32926085591316223,
-0.22979985177516937,
-0.07411893457174301,
-0.31804895401000977,
0.28285878896713257,
0.29958170652389526,
0.09201107919216156,
-0.12467842549085617,
0.13579468429088593,
-0.16763384640216827,
-0.36775752902030945,
-0.1729607731103897,
-0.25715214014053345,
0.6040992736816406,
-0.1122923195362091,
-0.43686187267303467,
-0.8284968137741089,
0.19031691551208496,
0.16742834448814392,
-0.2921721041202545,
0.6245966553688049,
0.6275719404220581,
-0.174155130982399,
-0.2827441990375519,
-0.48718029260635376,
-0.13199689984321594,
-0.48317912220954895,
0.2546471357345581,
-0.42521655559539795,
-0.5853248834609985,
0.13300888240337372,
-0.30393731594085693,
0.08480291068553925,
0.24912132322788239,
0.17788079380989075,
-0.5161161422729492,
1.2927420139312744,
1.143837332725525,
-0.14963684976100922,
0.595626175403595,
-0.34733396768569946,
-0.04368690028786659,
-0.5941251516342163,
-0.4115039110183716,
-0.35863158106803894,
-0.2862772047519684,
-0.7420172095298767,
-0.47476664185523987,
0.379564106464386,
-0.06467689573764801,
0.033310458064079285,
0.367412805557251,
0.07304175198078156,
0.18392714858055115,
0.8613113760948181,
0.23978681862354279,
0.446016401052475,
-0.08758466690778732,
-0.38143059611320496,
0.22396747767925262,
-0.9379497766494751,
-0.2596028447151184,
1.1432667970657349,
0.2418266385793686,
1.059658408164978,
0.2651215195655823,
0.6074201464653015,
0.6407281160354614,
-0.07862254232168198,
-0.4975615441799164,
0.6962003707885742,
0.0672631487250328,
-0.2640470862388611,
-0.5392645001411438,
-0.32261785864830017,
-1.1056580543518066,
0.5084402561187744,
-0.23538464307785034,
-0.6074474453926086,
-0.05163775756955147,
0.1581377387046814,
-0.2834811210632324,
0.04511786624789238,
-0.6660003066062927,
0.7855545282363892,
-0.3547839820384979,
-0.5162019729614258,
-0.4964260756969452,
-0.8383015394210815,
0.032190293073654175,
0.396119087934494,
0.49884656071662903,
0.2203035205602646,
-0.23679977655410767,
0.5707494616508484,
-0.2849195599555969,
0.8677041530609131,
-0.19863997399806976,
0.08838357776403427,
-0.05977177992463112,
-0.012445670552551746,
0.7141055464744568,
-0.3072497546672821,
0.2639178931713104,
-0.2954317033290863,
-0.26481062173843384,
-0.5707378387451172,
-0.7510525584220886,
0.5001605153083801,
-0.7640047669410706,
-0.5113406777381897,
-0.6269155740737915,
-0.5186826586723328,
-0.48474380373954773,
-0.029101217165589333,
-0.2010846585035324,
0.3813572824001312,
-0.10793845355510712,
0.03713366761803627,
0.8535622954368591,
-0.2372654676437378,
0.645739734172821,
0.751069962978363,
-0.3452741801738739,
-0.14994972944259644,
1.0738112926483154,
-0.23857703804969788,
0.2273688018321991,
0.7072334885597229,
-0.031878452748060226,
-0.48468002676963806,
-0.7516610622406006,
-0.5193739533424377,
0.1359313428401947,
-0.7831313610076904,
0.006339358165860176,
-0.5960995554924011,
-0.08740280568599701,
-0.5122937560081482,
-0.017013104632496834,
-0.2803310453891754,
-0.10466758906841278,
-0.24635395407676697,
-0.010624902322888374,
0.02581084705889225,
0.728684663772583,
-0.1197001039981842,
0.4433740973472595,
-0.7695158123970032,
0.4188282787799835,
0.5390942096710205,
-0.15509402751922607,
0.48711901903152466,
-0.10693615674972534,
-0.526213526725769,
0.06558898836374283,
-0.30956050753593445,
-0.8212921023368835,
0.49382367730140686,
0.04555100202560425,
0.8778961300849915,
0.46466952562332153,
0.010913591831922531,
0.9281061887741089,
-0.4540739059448242,
0.6789903044700623,
0.3105893135070801,
-0.7248746752738953,
0.728079080581665,
-0.2737112045288086,
0.4606553614139557,
0.5677013397216797,
0.5884633660316467,
-0.49996116757392883,
-0.1674373745918274,
-0.5527142286300659,
-0.729637861251831,
0.5382524132728577,
0.12202586233615875,
-0.2557837665081024,
0.23408672213554382,
0.01235714741051197,
-0.11209098249673843,
0.12031497806310654,
-0.9366779327392578,
-0.27364903688430786,
0.0048599159345030785,
-0.12144573032855988,
-0.24028342962265015,
0.06434772163629532,
0.15701770782470703,
-0.1700134575366974,
1.0017940998077393,
-0.4517231285572052,
0.026004735380411148,
-0.013420318253338337,
-0.8737525343894958,
0.13900059461593628,
0.10635139048099518,
0.41651952266693115,
0.8514612913131714,
0.04999757558107376,
0.08054274320602417,
0.2624285817146301,
-0.2039567083120346,
0.21367642283439636,
0.0025630455929785967,
-0.26571089029312134,
-0.2123112976551056,
0.6811290383338928,
0.8649091124534607,
0.3338673412799835,
-1.0071725845336914,
0.5988691449165344,
-0.13829033076763153,
0.14524966478347778,
-0.3196299076080322,
0.2687261998653412,
0.059660326689481735,
0.4866323471069336,
0.5564067363739014,
-0.13348132371902466,
0.2194712907075882,
-0.7517394423484802,
0.24049867689609528,
0.4406648874282837,
-0.5769649744033813,
0.015907911583781242,
0.5141584277153015,
0.2926907539367676,
-0.42054274678230286,
0.6018940806388855,
-0.3413364291191101,
-0.4286271929740906,
0.5951541066169739,
0.46823185682296753,
0.5860549211502075,
-0.05887603014707565,
0.3753068745136261,
0.22760546207427979,
0.27542203664779663,
-0.06297536194324493,
-0.058147452771663666,
-0.27664121985435486,
-0.5014859437942505,
-0.39028069376945496,
-0.49976298213005066,
-0.502247154712677,
-0.21271802484989166,
-0.9317047595977783,
-0.26945120096206665,
-0.48228320479393005,
-0.13498179614543915,
-0.15734733641147614,
0.2328493446111679,
-0.7456909418106079,
0.5836654901504517,
0.17787674069404602,
0.8308748602867126,
-0.7556480169296265,
1.0985853672027588,
0.7709941864013672,
-0.7735625505447388,
-0.6486029028892517,
0.22440823912620544,
0.1731366366147995,
-0.5726220011711121,
0.6691210269927979,
0.1856001913547516,
-0.28837111592292786,
0.04965341463685036,
-0.3537319600582123,
-0.6654496788978577,
1.163435459136963,
-0.34324464201927185,
-0.5292207598686218,
-0.3779348134994507,
-0.010909355245530605,
0.5569728016853333,
-0.22185058891773224,
0.2713215947151184,
0.5249942541122437,
0.39917293190956116,
-0.06629592180252075,
-0.95303875207901,
-0.061482641845941544,
-0.3173246681690216,
0.24612082540988922,
-0.060923803597688675,
-0.7283453345298767,
0.8846361041069031,
-0.23458142578601837,
-0.2494172304868698,
0.15441274642944336,
0.9390623569488525,
0.11165577918291092,
0.57234126329422,
0.7164797782897949,
0.5150144696235657,
0.742213785648346,
0.06835361570119858,
0.9924771785736084,
0.18023212254047394,
0.2686312794685364,
1.1391035318374634,
-0.1381414234638214,
0.9777432084083557,
0.5116527080535889,
-0.24039869010448456,
0.8068674802780151,
0.4940868020057678,
0.18780745565891266,
0.789230465888977,
0.0790313333272934,
-0.1260017603635788,
-0.5931527018547058,
-0.20504151284694672,
-0.02404690533876419,
0.5554693937301636,
0.3335138261318207,
0.024897215887904167,
-0.32884761691093445,
0.5901049971580505,
-0.12732714414596558,
0.5729608535766602,
-0.48725539445877075,
1.1645662784576416,
0.0011836150661110878,
-0.7829848527908325,
0.35466164350509644,
0.30602678656578064,
0.811393141746521,
-0.8780679702758789,
-0.17954353988170624,
-0.2774810492992401,
0.1729002743959427,
0.024430260062217712,
-0.3118361234664917,
-0.1515524685382843,
0.07924136519432068,
-0.12885436415672302,
-0.5328938364982605,
0.6650367975234985,
-0.14782577753067017,
-0.2712351977825165,
0.5256816744804382,
0.7138399481773376,
0.03994427248835564,
0.09634958952665329,
-0.7557244300842285,
0.03239474445581436,
0.16618385910987854,
0.036552466452121735,
0.6077575087547302,
0.06943134218454361,
-0.09646657854318619,
1.411405324935913,
0.8063277006149292,
-0.19556260108947754,
0.33983367681503296,
0.020127061754465103,
0.754810631275177,
-0.7625348567962646,
-0.8056185841560364,
-0.7190359234809875,
0.27775290608406067,
-0.19628773629665375,
-0.10447167605161667,
0.7924399375915527,
0.588681697845459,
1.0591545104980469,
0.01258718129247427,
0.8525174260139465,
0.21658793091773987,
0.5049405097961426,
-0.8318294286727905,
0.5991222858428955,
-0.8496019244194031,
-0.10538192838430405,
-0.2050807923078537,
-0.4896058738231659,
-0.011655116453766823,
0.7369112968444824,
-0.05064868554472923,
0.055070728063583374,
0.8043490648269653,
0.670922040939331,
-0.0726664587855339,
-0.08827441930770874,
0.4459914565086365,
-0.0008007246069610119,
0.40481916069984436,
0.8902024626731873,
0.7901819348335266,
-0.36683061718940735,
0.7466578483581543,
-0.4347459077835083,
-0.12602972984313965,
-0.38559848070144653,
-0.6497501134872437,
-1.0032687187194824,
-0.6768860816955566,
-0.19112537801265717,
-0.15451452136039734,
0.4610717296600342,
1.024932861328125,
0.9944238066673279,
-0.6383736729621887,
-0.37540292739868164,
-0.02061055228114128,
0.32870757579803467,
-0.7015885710716248,
-0.14608457684516907,
0.12184928357601166,
-0.4648157060146332,
-0.8746775388717651,
0.7492324113845825,
0.11039862036705017,
0.17074424028396606,
-0.5900403261184692,
-0.40485525131225586,
-0.708585798740387,
-0.11103237420320511,
0.41223838925361633,
0.46475693583488464,
-0.9311176538467407,
0.012588564306497574,
-0.2484099417924881,
-0.29807746410369873,
-0.0012882242444902658,
0.7281831502914429,
-1.178420066833496,
0.2918277680873871,
0.3065478801727295,
0.8388351202011108,
0.9347353577613831,
0.11504064500331879,
0.4703633189201355,
-0.7319140434265137,
0.2443869411945343,
0.22988857328891754,
0.12791918218135834,
0.3543856739997864,
-0.03856418654322624,
0.5427409410476685,
0.09995266050100327,
-0.11363854259252548,
-0.5323601365089417,
0.30053117871284485,
-1.051498293876648,
-0.5674464702606201,
1.1167713403701782,
-0.19130849838256836,
-0.2693327069282532,
-0.20131941139698029,
0.11941464245319366,
0.3958822786808014,
-0.4383276700973511,
0.5284693241119385,
0.4023154675960541,
-0.2196321189403534,
-0.363608181476593,
-0.8288813233375549,
0.4138612449169159,
0.21244534850120544,
-0.8708810210227966,
-0.3814639449119568,
0.49373188614845276,
0.04377971962094307,
0.2793775200843811,
0.6235798597335815,
0.6582983136177063,
0.47802647948265076,
0.1396273970603943,
0.024350782856345177,
-0.11732429265975952,
-0.7953144907951355,
-0.1297580450773239,
0.2564920485019684,
0.007407367695122957,
-0.3132234215736389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00494v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00494v1
|
GOLD: Geometry Problem Solver with Natural Language Description
| 2024-05-01T13:00:51 | 2024-05-01T13:00:51 |
Jiaxin Zhang, Yashar Moshfeghi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Addressing the challenge of automated geometry math problem-solving in
artificial intelligence (AI) involves understanding multi-modal information and
mathematics. Current methods struggle with accurately interpreting geometry
diagrams, which hinders effective problem-solving. To tackle this issue, we
present the Geometry problem sOlver with natural Language Description (GOLD)
model. GOLD enhances the extraction of geometric relations by separately
processing symbols and geometric primitives within the diagram. Subsequently,
it converts the extracted relations into natural language descriptions,
efficiently utilizing large language models to solve geometry math problems.
Experiments show that the GOLD model outperforms the Geoformer model, the
previous best method on the UniGeo dataset, by achieving accuracy improvements
of 12.7% and 42.1% in calculation and proving subsets. Additionally, it
surpasses the former best model on the PGPS9K and Geometry3K datasets, PGPSNet,
by obtaining accuracy enhancements of 1.8% and 3.2%, respectively.
|
[
-0.11894889175891876,
-1.022883653640747,
0.40259286761283875,
0.2250720113515854,
-0.05085233971476555,
-0.10984256118535995,
-0.11963125318288803,
-0.4806181788444519,
-0.03135859966278076,
0.5917220711708069,
-0.695260226726532,
-0.49423640966415405,
-0.6728194952011108,
0.35504016280174255,
-0.36155247688293457,
1.0446038246154785,
-0.2506506145000458,
0.009797433391213417,
-0.3150305449962616,
0.09437648206949234,
-0.3071514070034027,
-0.556594729423523,
-0.6391163468360901,
-0.44575315713882446,
0.20896515250205994,
0.06812192499637604,
1.1382571458816528,
0.8102871775627136,
0.9972244501113892,
0.5119543671607971,
-0.20268356800079346,
0.3009483218193054,
-0.2276272177696228,
-0.500371515750885,
0.15335635840892792,
-0.41997474431991577,
-0.6413763165473938,
-0.1514969766139984,
0.4538048505783081,
0.9564248323440552,
-0.04467862844467163,
0.16084299981594086,
-0.04091855138540268,
0.9855930209159851,
-0.4007195830345154,
0.8043078184127808,
-0.26302576065063477,
0.052968427538871765,
-0.096305713057518,
-0.184284970164299,
0.10575190931558609,
-0.6064374446868896,
0.3536563813686371,
-1.2988009452819824,
0.19691972434520721,
0.10857654362916946,
0.9495825171470642,
0.4807610809803009,
-0.17229925096035004,
-0.4650110900402069,
-1.0643402338027954,
0.7380422949790955,
-0.5565446019172668,
0.13039936125278473,
0.5153411030769348,
0.684710681438446,
-0.20185664296150208,
-0.5857433676719666,
-0.38065508008003235,
-0.1398562490940094,
-0.43937405943870544,
-0.07995156198740005,
-0.29094383120536804,
0.26049551367759705,
0.17073367536067963,
0.9039018750190735,
-0.741999089717865,
-0.4282304644584656,
-0.9251604676246643,
-0.26227158308029175,
0.7497479319572449,
0.15382696688175201,
0.559352457523346,
-0.40700221061706543,
0.0895199403166771,
0.05037068575620651,
-0.3046073615550995,
0.05997508019208908,
0.38541561365127563,
0.43882063031196594,
-0.09286921471357346,
0.7758833169937134,
-0.3997132182121277,
0.9412196278572083,
-0.3042813837528229,
-0.13536129891872406,
0.23129890859127045,
-0.11618233472108841,
-0.39212819933891296,
-0.007706330623477697,
0.7073619961738586,
0.048047058284282684,
0.5385730862617493,
-0.2845880389213562,
0.03210928291082382,
0.24761581420898438,
-0.005917761940509081,
-0.5330005288124084,
-0.7128779292106628,
0.07867966592311859,
-0.48554161190986633,
-0.0222073495388031,
0.21505536139011383,
-0.5996127128601074,
-0.22044993937015533,
-0.7140465974807739,
0.2764427065849304,
-0.42828261852264404,
-0.18383164703845978,
0.580093264579773,
0.03614823520183563,
-0.16915561258792877,
0.1792181432247162,
-0.536867082118988,
0.46254241466522217,
0.9225541353225708,
0.9396560788154602,
0.2609730362892151,
-0.22676101326942444,
-0.6916409134864807,
0.20402775704860687,
-0.21077921986579895,
0.8845643401145935,
-0.4925503730773926,
-0.2878308594226837,
-0.2847074568271637,
0.0666620060801506,
-0.025985226035118103,
-0.5826804041862488,
0.787818968296051,
-0.1078111082315445,
0.5124510526657104,
-0.28173157572746277,
-0.5448791980743408,
-0.5344604253768921,
0.3964654803276062,
-1.140598177909851,
1.0412101745605469,
0.22086381912231445,
-0.5734862089157104,
-0.06798233091831207,
-1.1419787406921387,
0.019888056442141533,
0.40905702114105225,
-0.018019646406173706,
-0.41460543870925903,
0.2156963050365448,
0.5434907674789429,
-0.08465109020471573,
0.04273397848010063,
0.2264716476202011,
-0.19858315587043762,
-0.2768436372280121,
0.0634538009762764,
-0.22367244958877563,
0.6822393536567688,
0.04350312426686287,
0.00006652769661741331,
0.2071733921766281,
-0.6202293038368225,
-0.029118945822119713,
0.43990641832351685,
-0.153901144862175,
-0.21813471615314484,
0.022365838289260864,
0.011118329130113125,
0.1930588036775589,
0.3679589629173279,
-0.5588695406913757,
0.10796110332012177,
-0.8198789954185486,
0.31802040338516235,
0.5235421657562256,
-0.21420659124851227,
0.5526682138442993,
-0.2574433386325836,
0.4794885218143463,
-0.458984375,
0.30616286396980286,
0.15306778252124786,
-0.592265248298645,
-0.6191987991333008,
-0.24846485257148743,
0.15175873041152954,
0.8152726888656616,
-0.5488532185554504,
0.40191739797592163,
-0.42745915055274963,
-0.3290303945541382,
-0.4043149948120117,
0.304941326379776,
0.4195643663406372,
0.6134874820709229,
0.41851603984832764,
0.0517321340739727,
-0.5042674541473389,
-0.7855302095413208,
-0.5848442912101746,
-0.18002471327781677,
-0.09092646092176437,
0.3325040340423584,
0.3698703646659851,
-0.06680991500616074,
1.160434365272522,
-0.6899442672729492,
-0.6256239414215088,
-0.43896570801734924,
0.5266302824020386,
0.21566855907440186,
0.11332590878009796,
0.40706247091293335,
-0.8466764688491821,
-0.3673275411128998,
0.18399883806705475,
-0.9988661408424377,
-0.18683724105358124,
0.09783429652452469,
-0.37412628531455994,
0.196686789393425,
0.1185310110449791,
-0.5806781649589539,
0.8108555674552917,
0.5534523129463196,
-0.48186540603637695,
0.474944531917572,
-0.35142356157302856,
-0.05421699211001396,
-0.7815601825714111,
0.25394150614738464,
0.25053566694259644,
0.055927589535713196,
-0.3603561222553253,
-0.03657105192542076,
-0.1722092479467392,
-0.43402913212776184,
-0.27368074655532837,
0.5646038055419922,
-0.388862669467926,
-0.27557533979415894,
-0.2521018087863922,
0.0200531966984272,
0.2112206369638443,
0.38412877917289734,
0.042045146226882935,
0.6691203117370605,
0.5335817933082581,
-0.5178917050361633,
0.88779616355896,
0.5602755546569824,
-0.07127899676561356,
0.41517361998558044,
-0.9078813791275024,
-0.0942569375038147,
-0.34057483077049255,
0.21610580384731293,
-0.7212105989456177,
-0.2830825746059418,
0.2827267050743103,
-0.4140951633453369,
-0.2027338445186615,
-0.43230104446411133,
-0.702876091003418,
-0.6365894079208374,
-0.054652582854032516,
0.46660616993904114,
0.05472623556852341,
-0.35678136348724365,
0.8127405643463135,
0.13802094757556915,
-0.4786941409111023,
-0.30140653252601624,
-0.4910510778427124,
0.19912445545196533,
-0.26282766461372375,
-0.8178336024284363,
0.3137657642364502,
-0.21163786947727203,
-0.40516984462738037,
0.3113984763622284,
0.05555097758769989,
-0.17790593206882477,
-0.06518197059631348,
0.05612001568078995,
0.5321183204650879,
-0.08511392027139664,
0.07665430009365082,
-0.32506445050239563,
-0.741187572479248,
0.32931846380233765,
-0.25153934955596924,
0.5534977912902832,
-0.5507776737213135,
-0.3510739803314209,
-0.7978681325912476,
0.47862446308135986,
0.3617960810661316,
-0.6858379244804382,
0.6513537168502808,
0.37232068181037903,
-0.738443911075592,
0.42337632179260254,
-0.06543952226638794,
0.03669357672333717,
-0.49895942211151123,
0.558496356010437,
-0.29240983724594116,
-0.4003882110118866,
0.47130316495895386,
-0.02824432961642742,
0.29802456498146057,
0.5968814492225647,
0.07051848620176315,
0.1786150187253952,
1.4319260120391846,
0.7907209992408752,
-0.31481391191482544,
0.32231733202934265,
-0.41643965244293213,
0.6293489933013916,
-0.5610281825065613,
-0.4718782901763916,
-0.5382295846939087,
-0.3767843246459961,
-0.1749112606048584,
-0.010038081556558609,
0.6215481162071228,
0.3265306353569031,
-0.23986276984214783,
0.1538183093070984,
-0.8095447421073914,
0.6686643958091736,
0.2941272556781769,
-0.13766157627105713,
0.5636054873466492,
0.4544776380062103,
0.3691404461860657,
-0.32757335901260376,
-0.4925270676612854,
-0.6494979858398438,
0.9212679862976074,
0.157262921333313,
0.8035373091697693,
0.22380174696445465,
0.3430362641811371,
-0.039225369691848755,
0.08440767973661423,
-0.7928068041801453,
0.2727965712547302,
-0.4006750285625458,
-0.4650960862636566,
-0.17200559377670288,
-0.8207694292068481,
-0.8886224627494812,
-0.0274816807359457,
-0.16981342434883118,
-0.6444019079208374,
-0.5231013298034668,
0.22972580790519714,
-0.6575411558151245,
0.5666201710700989,
-0.5885123014450073,
1.0135725736618042,
-0.6471224427223206,
0.08970655500888824,
0.11243993043899536,
-0.2781222462654114,
0.2028452605009079,
0.44980916380882263,
0.43583694100379944,
-0.06876301020383835,
0.26633960008621216,
0.7059792280197144,
-0.35043594241142273,
0.40209609270095825,
-0.04765479266643524,
-0.0697711631655693,
0.28035953640937805,
0.3537033200263977,
0.32171183824539185,
0.10256168991327286,
-0.0007590846507810056,
0.10396650433540344,
-0.037577781826257706,
-0.3762442469596863,
-0.8567517995834351,
0.41559240221977234,
-0.8907499313354492,
-0.04133492708206177,
-0.2917061150074005,
-0.9773483276367188,
0.20212973654270172,
0.10600679367780685,
0.2430785745382309,
0.8449952602386475,
-0.05411922559142113,
-0.20701904594898224,
0.4336753785610199,
-0.3180157244205475,
0.3629237115383148,
0.03447629138827324,
-0.4471169114112854,
-0.49561673402786255,
0.8911489248275757,
0.058003656566143036,
-0.10033466666936874,
0.07370645552873611,
0.2828216850757599,
-0.5247734189033508,
-0.17049279808998108,
-0.633101224899292,
0.6190676093101501,
-0.5677393078804016,
-0.34103265404701233,
-0.5510545372962952,
-0.4767206609249115,
-0.17714402079582214,
-0.16325394809246063,
-0.4929812550544739,
-0.6049546003341675,
-0.14829121530056,
0.04475327953696251,
0.6378616690635681,
0.9314626455307007,
0.11355767399072647,
0.5492271184921265,
-0.8727918267250061,
0.4512085020542145,
0.20875011384487152,
0.4813876152038574,
-0.5105652809143066,
-0.22767968475818634,
-0.09234864264726639,
0.23665112257003784,
-0.22768568992614746,
-0.5467044115066528,
0.7446122169494629,
0.35859397053718567,
0.44564148783683777,
0.30250972509384155,
-0.14638285338878632,
1.0306215286254883,
-0.27755117416381836,
0.4716680347919464,
-0.0757177397608757,
-0.7685490250587463,
0.6986334919929504,
-0.2133232057094574,
0.3461253046989441,
0.33849844336509705,
0.08615434169769287,
-0.40262338519096375,
-0.17404676973819733,
-0.603803277015686,
-0.766475260257721,
0.6179202795028687,
0.41529008746147156,
-0.17056182026863098,
0.3845871090888977,
0.5449010729789734,
-0.03210487216711044,
-0.007046287879347801,
-0.7451639175415039,
-0.23411671817302704,
-0.18490633368492126,
-0.5224957466125488,
-0.004242362454533577,
-0.03202832117676735,
-0.37311917543411255,
-0.32255658507347107,
0.6166141033172607,
-0.21284158527851105,
0.45951247215270996,
0.016696497797966003,
-0.3347042500972748,
-0.44349199533462524,
0.17672604322433472,
0.38105863332748413,
1.0464190244674683,
-0.239729106426239,
0.05475766211748123,
-0.035520970821380615,
-0.3838576674461365,
-0.5601533651351929,
0.7876002192497253,
-0.005414985120296478,
0.12026268243789673,
0.3943966031074524,
0.5176249742507935,
-0.13194145262241364,
-0.5171816945075989,
0.15538348257541656,
-0.3653308153152466,
-0.17721445858478546,
-0.5302465558052063,
-0.06353884190320969,
-0.14097405970096588,
-0.09809393435716629,
0.5320472121238708,
0.24468424916267395,
0.4310777485370636,
-0.19075559079647064,
0.02887148968875408,
0.4313758909702301,
-0.20960982143878937,
-0.3694145679473877,
0.4450349509716034,
0.023193234577775,
-0.503557026386261,
0.972065269947052,
-0.25552523136138916,
-0.9793050289154053,
0.7247711420059204,
0.5167688131332397,
0.3840826749801636,
0.07260648161172867,
0.26270970702171326,
0.5090422034263611,
0.2463323175907135,
-0.006700222846120596,
0.35616031289100647,
0.33111244440078735,
-0.32251644134521484,
-0.7060765624046326,
-0.5780500769615173,
-0.1631190925836563,
0.12573136389255524,
-0.7448629140853882,
0.06105461344122887,
-0.4555916488170624,
0.12126260995864868,
-0.29167240858078003,
0.5381016135215759,
-0.4717530310153961,
0.03352479636669159,
0.3999519944190979,
0.6813980340957642,
-0.9389773011207581,
0.24316300451755524,
0.9742116928100586,
-0.16885261237621307,
-0.9066880941390991,
-0.44729557633399963,
0.31542864441871643,
-0.4149780869483948,
0.3840208947658539,
0.3844984471797943,
-0.21046948432922363,
-0.04485663026571274,
-0.5264914631843567,
-1.0114399194717407,
1.0210267305374146,
0.6499781608581543,
-0.12268151342868805,
-0.0827222466468811,
0.44823309779167175,
0.36536356806755066,
-0.11730658262968063,
0.19607745110988617,
0.5174611806869507,
0.5065129995346069,
0.21556583046913147,
-1.1990914344787598,
-0.44588154554367065,
-0.5685616731643677,
-0.08717036992311478,
0.49745893478393555,
-0.09633807837963104,
0.9528306722640991,
0.0831393375992775,
-0.1986139714717865,
0.3171795606613159,
0.8506029844284058,
0.5014640092849731,
0.3011835515499115,
0.384270042181015,
0.7193081378936768,
0.9162350296974182,
-0.30840155482292175,
1.118900179862976,
-0.21453192830085754,
0.603047788143158,
0.7462354898452759,
0.17587776482105255,
0.40795809030532837,
0.1063871756196022,
-0.21571247279644012,
0.755945086479187,
0.5633116960525513,
0.31103119254112244,
0.20026816427707672,
-0.06782867014408112,
-0.13314685225486755,
-0.3513158857822418,
-0.004325222223997116,
-0.5439619421958923,
0.5825498104095459,
0.3308814465999603,
0.0009268899448215961,
-0.7077118158340454,
-0.30026933550834656,
0.05821523815393448,
0.32519400119781494,
-0.5779035687446594,
0.6032512784004211,
-0.16886290907859802,
-0.27228090167045593,
0.3015878200531006,
0.1693231463432312,
0.40990132093429565,
-0.6293291449546814,
-0.35591739416122437,
-0.17095433175563812,
0.5139464139938354,
-0.389934778213501,
-0.6097718477249146,
0.7875937819480896,
0.02218918688595295,
-0.15900491178035736,
-0.032952021807432175,
0.4907348155975342,
-0.41728833317756653,
-1.3409793376922607,
0.018589435145258904,
0.38509637117385864,
0.09734645485877991,
-0.40156248211860657,
-1.0561045408248901,
-0.045830242335796356,
-0.41156983375549316,
0.2479228675365448,
-0.208406001329422,
0.6643715500831604,
-0.16314058005809784,
0.8801752328872681,
0.761603593826294,
0.12398212403059006,
0.25794583559036255,
-0.21874560415744781,
0.8975338935852051,
-0.4562918543815613,
-0.9142008423805237,
-0.7770712971687317,
0.5467529892921448,
-0.3017950654029846,
-0.20700675249099731,
0.6620211005210876,
0.8443660736083984,
0.677699863910675,
0.10719276964664459,
0.6083611249923706,
-0.01805182732641697,
0.5167216658592224,
-0.43594101071357727,
0.5948420763015747,
-0.29496848583221436,
0.2631261348724365,
-0.30865994095802307,
-1.0637812614440918,
-0.6901757717132568,
1.0496937036514282,
-0.6282562613487244,
-0.00274859182536602,
0.6657959222793579,
0.6765313744544983,
-0.41811296343803406,
0.25522926449775696,
-0.190425306558609,
-0.20977753400802612,
0.4074529707431793,
0.7576329112052917,
0.8267284631729126,
-0.5128606557846069,
0.9040501117706299,
-0.4605835974216461,
-0.25982120633125305,
0.14413650333881378,
-0.7039591073989868,
-0.8147613406181335,
-0.2188355028629303,
-0.22515203058719635,
-0.17885299026966095,
-0.18221637606620789,
0.808292806148529,
0.7009907364845276,
-0.735547661781311,
-0.3683412969112396,
-0.2395894080400467,
0.012243764474987984,
-0.2319907248020172,
-0.28556278347969055,
0.6224238872528076,
-0.2734289765357971,
-0.758592963218689,
0.12645532190799713,
0.31582990288734436,
-0.09929852187633514,
-0.17876122891902924,
-0.3993991017341614,
0.08887596428394318,
-0.21446971595287323,
0.3883565366268158,
0.376158207654953,
-0.7089227437973022,
-0.0897609069943428,
0.02547423169016838,
0.09631025791168213,
0.11378566920757294,
0.872350811958313,
-0.8961039185523987,
0.41016608476638794,
0.18659862875938416,
0.6057443618774414,
0.12741784751415253,
0.3748290538787842,
0.5823284983634949,
-0.4774533212184906,
0.19776450097560883,
0.04062260314822197,
0.3703358769416809,
0.6288841366767883,
-0.6344782710075378,
0.45434120297431946,
0.34533512592315674,
-0.3533885180950165,
-0.39688193798065186,
0.35850557684898376,
-0.8038500547409058,
-0.1116078644990921,
0.881131112575531,
-0.030903581529855728,
-0.5636668801307678,
-0.1851803958415985,
-0.41449177265167236,
0.33805587887763977,
-0.16131030023097992,
0.9709930419921875,
0.4253620207309723,
-0.37293902039527893,
-0.15608584880828857,
-0.6385250687599182,
0.4225948750972748,
0.37926357984542847,
-0.982054591178894,
-0.026854120194911957,
0.6685823202133179,
0.07567078620195389,
0.21649475395679474,
0.2654082775115967,
-0.4065171778202057,
0.1978243589401245,
-0.497123122215271,
-0.09116612374782562,
-0.6327936053276062,
-0.5282729268074036,
-0.3521440327167511,
0.04918695613741875,
-0.24367977678775787,
-0.10593506693840027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00492v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00492v1
|
Is Temperature the Creativity Parameter of Large Language Models?
| 2024-05-01T12:59:37 | 2024-05-01T12:59:37 |
Max Peeperkorn, Tom Kouwenhoven, Dan Brown, Anna Jordanous
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) are applied to all sorts of creative tasks, and
their outputs vary from beautiful, to peculiar, to pastiche, into plain
plagiarism. The temperature parameter of an LLM regulates the amount of
randomness, leading to more diverse outputs; therefore, it is often claimed to
be the creativity parameter. Here, we investigate this claim using a narrative
generation task with a predetermined fixed context, model and prompt.
Specifically, we present an empirical analysis of the LLM output for different
temperature values using four necessary conditions for creativity in narrative
generation: novelty, typicality, cohesion, and coherence. We find that
temperature is weakly correlated with novelty, and unsurprisingly, moderately
correlated with incoherence, but there is no relationship with either cohesion
or typicality. However, the influence of temperature on creativity is far more
nuanced and weak than suggested by the "creativity parameter" claim; overall
results suggest that the LLM generates slightly more novel outputs as
temperatures get higher. Finally, we discuss ideas to allow more controlled LLM
creativity, rather than relying on chance via changing the temperature
parameter.
|
[
-0.4310761094093323,
-0.9486585259437561,
0.9640402793884277,
0.2644243538379669,
-0.5337649583816528,
0.014267472550272942,
-0.529072642326355,
-0.10104334354400635,
0.4264514148235321,
0.42212343215942383,
-0.5225942730903625,
-0.49320659041404724,
-0.49121424555778503,
-0.00930118653923273,
-0.4133356213569641,
0.8618905544281006,
-0.08054282516241074,
-0.5728534460067749,
-0.46992745995521545,
0.19778060913085938,
-0.055038828402757645,
-0.6154537796974182,
-0.33448880910873413,
-0.3606497645378113,
1.1226295232772827,
0.47696593403816223,
0.7080993056297302,
0.7519978880882263,
0.1571294665336609,
0.3600541949272156,
0.07632951438426971,
-0.16913995146751404,
-0.5159735679626465,
0.7955335378646851,
-0.0842224583029747,
-0.4531221091747284,
-0.0952582061290741,
0.26603108644485474,
0.4417223036289215,
0.4919659197330475,
-0.1051725447177887,
0.1696377992630005,
-0.0492389053106308,
0.564842939376831,
-0.3869538903236389,
-0.11978161334991455,
-0.7906671166419983,
-0.2199573665857315,
-0.3488720953464508,
-0.29967331886291504,
-0.2636517584323883,
-0.5190752744674683,
0.16265226900577545,
-0.18376435339450836,
0.474459707736969,
0.10944776982069016,
0.6728628277778625,
0.16964998841285706,
-0.3542592525482178,
-0.6314804553985596,
-0.8726602792739868,
0.9537255764007568,
-0.8745331764221191,
0.057321108877658844,
-0.008457865566015244,
-0.16374421119689941,
0.08819280564785004,
-0.5559872984886169,
-0.8454724550247192,
-0.2564309537410736,
0.5337908864021301,
0.1643659919500351,
-0.019327757880091667,
-0.6004672646522522,
0.34288620948791504,
0.4384171962738037,
-0.4924355149269104,
0.3723323345184326,
-0.07204685360193253,
0.04854664206504822,
0.7155904769897461,
0.5968330502510071,
0.5269999504089355,
0.09533078968524933,
-0.11120931804180145,
-0.17357593774795532,
-0.5343158841133118,
0.39644762873649597,
0.6666116118431091,
0.14937910437583923,
-0.14894606173038483,
0.4842589795589447,
-0.15681609511375427,
0.4035942852497101,
-0.07303193211555481,
-0.26457643508911133,
0.05665457621216774,
-0.09643705189228058,
0.02186494879424572,
-0.03595396876335144,
0.7865518927574158,
0.5901744961738586,
0.2031148225069046,
-0.34968748688697815,
-0.21166491508483887,
-0.22697043418884277,
0.15417875349521637,
-0.7932800650596619,
-0.48738235235214233,
0.07032031565904617,
0.055678702890872955,
-0.37032759189605713,
0.204823836684227,
-0.5512682199478149,
-0.23081880807876587,
-0.290340781211853,
-0.08813676983118057,
-0.051108814775943756,
-0.44785311818122864,
-0.1915329396724701,
-0.4794140160083771,
0.047621361911296844,
0.16141819953918457,
-1.000891089439392,
-0.10699692368507385,
0.5136080980300903,
0.6792832016944885,
-0.5591408014297485,
-0.5539274215698242,
0.07318425923585892,
0.3736921548843384,
-0.7328860759735107,
0.7641533017158508,
-0.6551787853240967,
-0.14387190341949463,
-0.2767893373966217,
-0.2227790504693985,
-0.017670340836048126,
-0.1592765748500824,
0.2181028425693512,
-0.6771968603134155,
0.3841192126274109,
-0.6077849864959717,
-0.34644564986228943,
-0.008707122877240181,
-0.12857282161712646,
-0.8235433101654053,
0.6840898990631104,
-0.011109380051493645,
-0.5746875405311584,
0.7824261784553528,
-0.1356775462627411,
-0.301717072725296,
0.17256607115268707,
-0.07294364273548126,
-0.38508832454681396,
0.38488155603408813,
-0.20440807938575745,
0.4316006004810333,
-0.7012903690338135,
0.4956444501876831,
-0.4369101822376251,
-0.1589275300502777,
0.8254240155220032,
-0.5561819076538086,
0.3770662844181061,
0.3212186098098755,
-0.36535242199897766,
0.08752508461475372,
-0.6342117786407471,
0.37408626079559326,
0.3648487627506256,
-0.654229462146759,
-0.2366550713777542,
-0.3320329487323761,
-0.2780836224555969,
0.06826033443212509,
0.48489344120025635,
-0.5196359157562256,
0.1689589023590088,
-0.4514085650444031,
0.3998400866985321,
0.5876953601837158,
0.36664241552352905,
0.6545600891113281,
-0.6941053867340088,
0.7077456116676331,
-0.0826859250664711,
-0.5454830527305603,
0.06545274704694748,
-0.744945228099823,
-0.5587618947029114,
-0.4112558364868164,
-0.1498645693063736,
0.4717139005661011,
-0.5648743510246277,
0.08207383006811142,
0.22787043452262878,
-1.022343397140503,
-0.21201135218143463,
0.6110045909881592,
0.13924072682857513,
0.4018491506576538,
-0.2133655846118927,
0.13446936011314392,
-0.3797600269317627,
-0.7022988200187683,
-0.45927342772483826,
0.19136199355125427,
-0.21186764538288116,
0.30230140686035156,
0.154472216963768,
0.2783849835395813,
0.9120289087295532,
-0.3917621672153473,
0.3500008285045624,
-0.6278882026672363,
0.4629055857658386,
0.8852468132972717,
0.4416201114654541,
0.8414257168769836,
-0.5801458358764648,
-0.5623059272766113,
-0.30996233224868774,
-0.8168007731437683,
-0.42801398038864136,
-0.006174223031848669,
0.08168577402830124,
0.5911155939102173,
0.49013182520866394,
-0.8596281409263611,
0.26240795850753784,
0.5806909799575806,
-0.290851354598999,
0.5522711277008057,
-0.242741197347641,
0.25829169154167175,
-0.9587363600730896,
-0.08020199835300446,
-0.01948573812842369,
0.3684498965740204,
-0.7778245806694031,
0.1406371146440506,
-0.30606696009635925,
-0.10468287020921707,
-0.5937913656234741,
0.6064936518669128,
-0.36347657442092896,
0.5062368512153625,
-0.48700156807899475,
-0.20051617920398712,
0.1276453137397766,
0.36782222986221313,
0.10803143680095673,
0.2501789927482605,
0.835674524307251,
-0.5774518847465515,
0.9526727795600891,
-0.3891564905643463,
-0.3830965459346771,
-0.0662093535065651,
-0.7444190382957458,
0.5440393686294556,
-0.11526867002248764,
-0.01660507172346115,
-1.088044285774231,
-0.530452311038971,
-0.26816239953041077,
-0.09728969633579254,
0.07348424196243286,
0.4019247591495514,
-0.8507819771766663,
-0.4115962088108063,
-0.05605015903711319,
0.18496432900428772,
0.5732404589653015,
-0.14738096296787262,
0.37829387187957764,
-0.17382699251174927,
-0.5744187235832214,
0.18622566759586334,
-0.7169817090034485,
-0.018132206052541733,
-0.7557293772697449,
-0.6880529522895813,
0.19796842336654663,
-0.6386039853096008,
-0.6706684231758118,
-0.2447558343410492,
0.06877197325229645,
0.05922314524650574,
0.09614948183298111,
0.472769170999527,
-0.00190344441216439,
-0.4898095726966858,
-0.2105477899312973,
0.04385923966765404,
0.20918859541416168,
0.33734753727912903,
0.13562758266925812,
0.8310412764549255,
-0.11040136963129044,
-0.09375345706939697,
-0.27942022681236267,
0.579908549785614,
0.5478593707084656,
0.2906125485897064,
0.7782137393951416,
0.59205162525177,
-0.013798989355564117,
-0.30431079864501953,
-0.6649194955825806,
-0.10511891543865204,
-0.5572398900985718,
0.007358914706856012,
-0.46689337491989136,
-0.8350253701210022,
0.8537511825561523,
0.5016829967498779,
-0.0907403826713562,
0.5717185735702515,
1.023044466972351,
-0.10392618924379349,
0.8115820288658142,
0.4350987374782562,
0.3842245936393738,
0.25754329562187195,
0.19988226890563965,
0.2898454964160919,
-0.3852475881576538,
-0.30360549688339233,
-0.4391142725944519,
-0.5128940343856812,
-0.7701399326324463,
-0.11047761142253876,
0.19138453900814056,
0.09042922407388687,
-0.3551286458969116,
-0.17160916328430176,
-0.21991506218910217,
0.7824016213417053,
1.0497140884399414,
-0.05038730055093765,
-0.05015759542584419,
-0.21741805970668793,
-0.16921788454055786,
-0.18545027077198029,
-0.6755726933479309,
-0.5306169390678406,
0.8739367127418518,
0.2261248081922531,
0.7412866353988647,
0.39210274815559387,
0.9909599423408508,
-0.16892394423484802,
0.1449081301689148,
-0.32436174154281616,
0.5661850571632385,
-0.06572338193655014,
-0.593141496181488,
-0.7122460603713989,
-0.3719230592250824,
-0.683018684387207,
-0.26508283615112305,
-0.16521605849266052,
-0.858102023601532,
-0.14025549590587616,
0.0015147192170843482,
-0.4216982126235962,
0.4887082874774933,
-0.7707037329673767,
0.5702283978462219,
-0.19216342270374298,
-0.6263219118118286,
0.14668932557106018,
-0.24271273612976074,
0.35999006032943726,
-0.4369070529937744,
0.083964042365551,
-0.3496648669242859,
0.12697872519493103,
0.7512974143028259,
-0.08018578588962555,
0.8391309380531311,
-0.028449932113289833,
-0.29544734954833984,
0.48120325803756714,
0.5354880094528198,
0.34708836674690247,
0.17111462354660034,
-0.5274121165275574,
-0.08318869024515152,
-0.001964407740160823,
-0.396274209022522,
-0.5182788968086243,
1.096570611000061,
-0.748656690120697,
-1.2464734315872192,
-0.2298421710729599,
-1.2403758764266968,
-0.1498909741640091,
0.19365361332893372,
0.8339182734489441,
0.2830074429512024,
-0.03787079453468323,
0.5216625928878784,
0.4075716733932495,
-0.56412672996521,
0.8238934278488159,
0.43075326085090637,
-0.01198780257254839,
0.05644566938281059,
0.9226443767547607,
0.21333733201026917,
0.48450878262519836,
-0.061285149306058884,
0.622462272644043,
0.06948595494031906,
-0.6341315507888794,
-0.11286001652479172,
0.034432269632816315,
-0.7626762390136719,
0.005230723414570093,
-0.43170806765556335,
-0.4067792296409607,
-0.6407195925712585,
-0.6269311308860779,
-0.06500445306301117,
-0.23455603420734406,
-0.8496068120002747,
-0.08079304546117783,
0.524075984954834,
0.7821845412254333,
-0.04844943806529045,
0.11979609727859497,
-0.4937197268009186,
0.16830486059188843,
0.48616740107536316,
0.0188406053930521,
0.18305696547031403,
-0.6958035826683044,
-0.07529722154140472,
-0.09568009525537491,
-0.2520873248577118,
-0.6489689350128174,
0.7017735242843628,
0.24609911441802979,
0.6197101473808289,
0.5529220700263977,
0.13624975085258484,
0.08858375251293182,
-0.21454504132270813,
1.2227741479873657,
0.3032573461532593,
-0.735768735408783,
0.3574422001838684,
-0.6371523141860962,
1.1090856790542603,
0.1372331976890564,
0.2936912178993225,
-0.0916847437620163,
-1.2091459035873413,
-0.7892614603042603,
-0.9390235543251038,
0.33675628900527954,
-0.22134198248386383,
0.7862251996994019,
-0.0968087688088417,
0.23182153701782227,
0.5473958849906921,
0.23102669417858124,
-0.7752569317817688,
0.0018186240922659636,
-0.1567973792552948,
0.0845889300107956,
-0.21483807265758514,
-0.4518495500087738,
-0.13679955899715424,
-0.22488270699977875,
0.27363401651382446,
0.13949042558670044,
-0.036649588495492935,
-0.13050878047943115,
0.4060525894165039,
-0.5336300134658813,
0.3796003758907318,
0.8212889432907104,
0.9458267688751221,
-0.1953144371509552,
0.4433710277080536,
0.24145357310771942,
-0.11308304965496063,
-0.21322259306907654,
-0.5362657308578491,
-0.14212997257709503,
-0.13808204233646393,
0.521695077419281,
0.7843841314315796,
-0.1504892259836197,
-0.38495123386383057,
0.1414337307214737,
0.032374657690525055,
-0.3784070909023285,
-0.34537410736083984,
0.7986395359039307,
0.37037137150764465,
0.5273821353912354,
0.43058130145072937,
0.09431536495685577,
-0.32189100980758667,
-0.8620120882987976,
-0.02427808567881584,
0.3761269748210907,
0.07063201069831848,
-0.5806554555892944,
0.8322230577468872,
-0.2114754617214203,
-0.3717036247253418,
0.5966891050338745,
-0.3100999593734741,
-0.33463358879089355,
0.8296797275543213,
0.8179770708084106,
0.6140618324279785,
-0.11572368443012238,
0.22154782712459564,
0.17497415840625763,
0.16518253087997437,
0.11126545816659927,
0.6567193865776062,
0.15457192063331604,
-0.9205432534217834,
-0.050552673637866974,
-0.8142428994178772,
-0.3728470504283905,
0.21354739367961884,
-0.48884546756744385,
0.04075227677822113,
-0.5159433484077454,
-0.0033622276969254017,
-0.008512935601174831,
-0.34821030497550964,
-0.9896041750907898,
0.3683132231235504,
0.41122329235076904,
0.4382554888725281,
-0.7891598343849182,
1.0020415782928467,
0.25035762786865234,
-0.2791909873485565,
-0.9260307550430298,
-0.036361660808324814,
0.1929377019405365,
-0.6169735789299011,
0.7025316953659058,
-0.1329445242881775,
-0.05442959442734718,
-0.02585356868803501,
-0.768884003162384,
-0.9897220134735107,
0.9630917310714722,
0.5635597109794617,
-0.5281035304069519,
-0.204955592751503,
0.3606070578098297,
0.940126895904541,
-0.8101367354393005,
-0.39647382497787476,
0.5995022654533386,
0.4644644558429718,
0.5479273200035095,
-0.655219554901123,
0.2146981805562973,
-0.3201655149459839,
-0.052978869527578354,
-0.2000451683998108,
-0.472353458404541,
1.0176059007644653,
-0.7750382423400879,
-0.03577382117509842,
0.3285748362541199,
0.6347382664680481,
0.4394979178905487,
0.7050178647041321,
0.10356253385543823,
0.539923906326294,
0.6123303771018982,
-0.17866185307502747,
1.1753901243209839,
-0.2954254448413849,
-0.16296377778053284,
0.9014193415641785,
-0.32399553060531616,
0.6910371780395508,
0.5851261019706726,
0.30477023124694824,
0.5087563395500183,
0.5919525027275085,
-0.1311003565788269,
0.5880224704742432,
0.37627938389778137,
-0.23268114030361176,
-0.23495668172836304,
-0.11430827528238297,
-0.13442912697792053,
0.3242798149585724,
0.2697717547416687,
-0.5829833745956421,
0.14386935532093048,
0.15631665289402008,
0.197612926363945,
0.09245691448450089,
-0.21706564724445343,
0.8215770125389099,
0.22527381777763367,
-0.915019690990448,
0.5109102129936218,
-0.26506611704826355,
0.3452305793762207,
-0.30207034945487976,
0.4540497064590454,
-0.16536559164524078,
-0.18807601928710938,
-0.14895734190940857,
-1.2870879173278809,
0.3504715859889984,
0.07661761343479156,
-0.45712003111839294,
-0.6605685353279114,
0.4443448483943939,
-0.3911150097846985,
-0.503110945224762,
-0.2122562825679779,
0.5247336030006409,
0.17535486817359924,
-0.08572464436292648,
-0.24149902164936066,
0.22653871774673462,
-0.09177690744400024,
-0.7426546812057495,
0.2168971747159958,
1.0996774435043335,
0.44160935282707214,
0.2583504915237427,
0.6690734028816223,
0.34558960795402527,
-0.04122692346572876,
0.1719919592142105,
0.7580335736274719,
-0.8710470199584961,
-0.45797857642173767,
-1.064910888671875,
0.30255693197250366,
0.25714969635009766,
-0.6895341873168945,
0.8589178323745728,
0.2952456772327423,
0.25843149423599243,
-0.25274717807769775,
0.6160669922828674,
-0.01552270632237196,
0.39470338821411133,
-0.7895950675010681,
0.6414663791656494,
-0.5074462294578552,
0.3482942581176758,
-0.4204971194267273,
-1.3729993104934692,
-0.12547887861728668,
-0.09474027156829834,
-0.6520611047744751,
0.10931099951267242,
0.866894006729126,
0.7222655415534973,
0.2904886305332184,
0.021312860772013664,
0.5311195850372314,
0.21086172759532928,
0.21178916096687317,
0.3774934709072113,
0.9642528891563416,
0.5263079404830933,
0.11015013605356216,
-0.3111031651496887,
-0.16940848529338837,
0.18993929028511047,
-1.1113849878311157,
-1.034576177597046,
-0.9178990125656128,
-0.3937481641769409,
-0.3520786762237549,
-0.3028590977191925,
0.7490636110305786,
0.24326547980308533,
-0.5565325021743774,
-0.1798146367073059,
0.0354120098054409,
-0.10361446440219879,
0.07273820787668228,
-0.26746866106987,
0.08822732418775558,
0.049237534403800964,
-0.6407334804534912,
0.23011375963687897,
0.39411699771881104,
0.1988925337791443,
-0.35806697607040405,
0.2000303417444229,
0.28463974595069885,
0.6671742796897888,
0.4308040142059326,
0.07367708534002304,
-0.8487250804901123,
-0.07978709787130356,
0.07571177184581757,
-0.2631697952747345,
-0.057621464133262634,
0.7234127521514893,
-0.22544367611408234,
0.18534570932388306,
0.7362294793128967,
-0.021396471187472343,
0.3867909908294678,
-0.19026757776737213,
0.6599364280700684,
-0.9258633852005005,
0.1363457590341568,
0.32462427020072937,
0.2438475340604782,
0.2926562428474426,
-0.46515026688575745,
-0.26229578256607056,
0.20587632060050964,
-0.6436989307403564,
-0.6800178289413452,
0.4209668040275574,
-0.9638924598693848,
-0.43026602268218994,
1.5172300338745117,
0.12052158266305923,
-0.38279053568840027,
0.35316383838653564,
0.00800975039601326,
0.12253980338573456,
-0.5247947573661804,
1.1187386512756348,
1.0749716758728027,
-0.21700142323970795,
-0.45191967487335205,
-0.5307350158691406,
0.2512013614177704,
0.04214948043227196,
-0.47991055250167847,
0.09523793309926987,
0.2526763677597046,
0.36437085270881653,
0.16638578474521637,
0.3892819285392761,
0.4045868217945099,
0.19358640909194946,
-0.06258966773748398,
-0.10802613198757172,
-0.03403053805232048,
-0.15317140519618988,
0.2744519114494324,
0.6585279703140259,
0.3462349772453308,
0.6842848658561707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00489v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00489v1
|
Explainable Automatic Grading with Neural Additive Models
| 2024-05-01T12:56:14 | 2024-05-01T12:56:14 |
Aubrey Condor, Zachary Pardos
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.AP
|
The use of automatic short answer grading (ASAG) models may help alleviate
the time burden of grading while encouraging educators to frequently
incorporate open-ended items in their curriculum. However, current
state-of-the-art ASAG models are large neural networks (NN) often described as
"black box", providing no explanation for which characteristics of an input are
important for the produced output. This inexplicable nature can be frustrating
to teachers and students when trying to interpret, or learn from an
automatically-generated grade. To create a powerful yet intelligible ASAG
model, we experiment with a type of model called a Neural Additive Model that
combines the performance of a NN with the explainability of an additive model.
We use a Knowledge Integration (KI) framework from the learning sciences to
guide feature engineering to create inputs that reflect whether a student
includes certain ideas in their response. We hypothesize that indicating the
inclusion (or exclusion) of predefined ideas as features will be sufficient for
the NAM to have good predictive power and interpretability, as this may guide a
human scorer using a KI rubric. We compare the performance of the NAM with
another explainable model, logistic regression, using the same features, and to
a non-explainable neural model, DeBERTa, that does not require feature
engineering.
|
[
-0.5054218769073486,
-0.8408222198486328,
0.5384223461151123,
0.03215993568301201,
-0.19306686520576477,
-0.0019971178844571114,
0.0898674800992012,
-0.6970422863960266,
0.17355884611606598,
0.1988103985786438,
-0.2555330991744995,
-0.3126087784767151,
-0.6699234843254089,
-0.19269225001335144,
-0.5473273992538452,
1.1378930807113647,
-0.05812402814626694,
0.13510319590568542,
-0.4120972752571106,
-0.20589162409305573,
-0.5895905494689941,
-0.4742196500301361,
-0.7983558773994446,
-0.730242133140564,
0.46763819456100464,
0.3535914421081543,
0.8250677585601807,
0.9346078038215637,
0.6441937685012817,
0.3163613975048065,
-0.3395038843154907,
-0.14102672040462494,
0.2524566054344177,
-0.3101356625556946,
-0.23309551179409027,
-0.5255688428878784,
-0.9332088828086853,
0.2727513611316681,
0.3610524535179138,
0.9303743243217468,
0.2885798513889313,
0.39414840936660767,
0.12966704368591309,
0.5374660491943359,
-0.6053690314292908,
0.37353503704071045,
-0.12069252133369446,
0.12711696326732635,
0.3069717586040497,
0.1230810359120369,
-0.303203284740448,
-0.7379165291786194,
0.3820333182811737,
-0.4722643494606018,
0.256550669670105,
-0.4924393892288208,
0.8788453340530396,
0.30634352564811707,
-0.3810559809207916,
-0.6586106419563293,
-0.6211066246032715,
0.47933194041252136,
-0.5691467523574829,
-0.1036800742149353,
0.43621259927749634,
0.5499963164329529,
0.22591403126716614,
-0.5312619805335999,
-0.5384547710418701,
-0.3284894824028015,
-0.17980895936489105,
0.24423319101333618,
0.12882308661937714,
0.3973301351070404,
0.10080810636281967,
0.5226965546607971,
-0.3548619747161865,
0.321107417345047,
-0.3141670227050781,
-0.12858273088932037,
0.7207414507865906,
0.16511200368404388,
0.23503737151622772,
-0.32290759682655334,
-0.36102038621902466,
0.08208070695400238,
-0.32700014114379883,
0.5319597125053406,
0.5138371586799622,
0.13256266713142395,
0.2149956077337265,
0.6891409158706665,
-0.032026030123233795,
0.7925693392753601,
0.016683431342244148,
0.2151491492986679,
-0.06019268184900284,
-0.07976604253053665,
-0.07248027622699738,
0.3197597563266754,
0.46872660517692566,
0.33576998114585876,
0.10779353976249695,
-0.08416404575109482,
-0.2836407721042633,
0.4818761348724365,
0.23142924904823303,
-0.7590856552124023,
-0.5314310789108276,
-0.004248328041285276,
-0.43806225061416626,
-0.7047759294509888,
-0.47582578659057617,
-0.5541726350784302,
-0.2964497208595276,
-0.5665661692619324,
1.0161738395690918,
-0.2949907183647156,
-0.013194411993026733,
-0.06121034547686577,
-0.14044785499572754,
-0.09283925592899323,
0.6522473692893982,
-0.609719455242157,
0.10308835655450821,
0.3771767020225525,
0.7203851938247681,
-0.11449844390153885,
-0.23679304122924805,
-0.12752605974674225,
-0.2805880904197693,
-0.35181277990341187,
0.8744379281997681,
-0.4944101572036743,
-0.07101292163133621,
-0.4503098726272583,
-0.18340501189231873,
0.042931508272886276,
-0.39580854773521423,
0.16173923015594482,
-0.6541749835014343,
0.3411487340927124,
-0.053850188851356506,
-0.7334630489349365,
-0.7579786777496338,
0.3415357768535614,
-0.474945992231369,
0.6834650039672852,
0.28951576352119446,
-0.298041969537735,
0.36695560812950134,
-1.1724975109100342,
-0.2684950530529022,
0.19392700493335724,
0.1157979741692543,
-0.37779027223587036,
0.12058792263269424,
0.026759248226881027,
0.3243611454963684,
-0.17167864739894867,
0.5098108053207397,
-0.32436951994895935,
-0.4831310212612152,
0.3757966160774231,
-0.3865020275115967,
0.7148905992507935,
0.18531803786754608,
-0.2786600887775421,
0.2037409394979477,
-0.9753025770187378,
0.04330394044518471,
-0.07032149285078049,
-0.33625495433807373,
-0.32961469888687134,
-0.1388607919216156,
-0.33182403445243835,
0.28208068013191223,
0.3679335117340088,
-0.3575984835624695,
-0.006141653284430504,
-0.21957279741764069,
0.3543151319026947,
1.0064054727554321,
-0.05150889977812767,
0.5856204628944397,
-0.37738552689552307,
0.8090983629226685,
0.23746369779109955,
0.0932467058300972,
-0.1831117421388626,
-0.541037380695343,
-0.8677219748497009,
-0.07042690366506577,
0.7553871273994446,
0.42267942428588867,
-0.6014358401298523,
0.3561297059059143,
0.13917690515518188,
-0.29630881547927856,
-0.6554486155509949,
0.19213195145130157,
0.36866289377212524,
0.8675975799560547,
0.3534773588180542,
-0.4200122356414795,
-0.1743776500225067,
-0.9803171157836914,
-0.23801465332508087,
-0.22625143826007843,
-0.11895707994699478,
0.2610883414745331,
0.4239817261695862,
0.16318950057029724,
0.8475341200828552,
-0.6164397597312927,
-0.12458774447441101,
-0.07332711666822433,
0.45190128684043884,
0.1451667696237564,
0.46676763892173767,
0.4391499161720276,
-0.5858251452445984,
-0.17227071523666382,
-0.20470863580703735,
-0.9379435181617737,
-0.09372017532587051,
0.01598823070526123,
-0.21542495489120483,
-0.20036505162715912,
0.27847573161125183,
-0.21410755813121796,
0.9111378192901611,
0.06049749627709389,
-0.6185352802276611,
0.5522075295448303,
-0.17626117169857025,
0.09535468369722366,
-0.6402319669723511,
-0.09204046428203583,
0.2991607189178467,
-0.014369484037160873,
-0.5617876052856445,
0.10431011021137238,
0.31145042181015015,
-0.34811726212501526,
-0.30728879570961,
0.6671929955482483,
-0.03816435858607292,
-0.060842227190732956,
-0.6280291676521301,
-0.05905186012387276,
0.37841910123825073,
0.7306609749794006,
-0.0989179015159607,
0.56972336769104,
0.39802834391593933,
-0.8913284540176392,
0.2880196273326874,
0.131683811545372,
-0.4198073148727417,
0.5063982009887695,
-0.7724913358688354,
-0.2005942165851593,
-0.36384502053260803,
0.13030728697776794,
-0.8668943047523499,
-0.17099490761756897,
-0.05464931204915047,
-0.6197887659072876,
0.082254558801651,
-0.4387032389640808,
-0.1699555218219757,
-0.29830026626586914,
0.049472909420728683,
0.5893529057502747,
0.6521937847137451,
-0.7140363454818726,
0.5486278533935547,
0.11948634684085846,
-0.14322561025619507,
-0.512839138507843,
-0.5651825666427612,
-0.08437012881040573,
-0.44778692722320557,
-0.44707223773002625,
0.28597626090049744,
-0.06826934218406677,
-0.11903543025255203,
0.3012646734714508,
0.007759890519082546,
-0.3124235272407532,
0.5119987726211548,
0.20470763742923737,
0.4718824326992035,
-0.5467782020568848,
0.4214518666267395,
0.04528595134615898,
-0.1125953271985054,
0.4383818507194519,
-0.16620957851409912,
0.009089930914342403,
-0.15544520318508148,
-0.2920137345790863,
-0.41362354159355164,
0.11388861387968063,
0.8275387287139893,
-0.29902952909469604,
0.734466552734375,
0.4275563955307007,
-0.5355023145675659,
-0.27326375246047974,
-0.23965948820114136,
-0.26601001620292664,
-0.43943849205970764,
0.30666616559028625,
-0.1494070440530777,
-0.4763914942741394,
0.8117757439613342,
0.12599007785320282,
0.11294455081224442,
0.3193001449108124,
0.164103701710701,
-0.25734829902648926,
1.3344712257385254,
0.6298133134841919,
0.4621050953865051,
0.5241161584854126,
-0.39163148403167725,
0.4197370707988739,
-0.9403628706932068,
-0.3978135883808136,
-0.3393825590610504,
-0.7777877449989319,
-0.4100475013256073,
-0.030187686905264854,
0.21593260765075684,
0.4589186906814575,
-0.09244673699140549,
0.07953376322984695,
-0.6907051801681519,
0.6117166876792908,
0.5693334341049194,
0.34743380546569824,
0.130005344748497,
-0.3185648024082184,
-0.06623435020446777,
0.2923414707183838,
-0.6772779226303101,
-0.4599193334579468,
1.1416248083114624,
0.38397112488746643,
0.5505402684211731,
-0.03489140793681145,
0.49745601415634155,
0.43592631816864014,
0.6836175322532654,
-1.1665107011795044,
0.5320976376533508,
-0.3017319440841675,
-0.5971814393997192,
-0.2799661457538605,
-0.3848685324192047,
-0.630486011505127,
0.2600652873516083,
-0.23986463248729706,
-0.43912243843078613,
0.24474583566188812,
0.4519908130168915,
-0.5618576407432556,
0.30727726221084595,
-1.1897670030593872,
0.7936635613441467,
-0.37699732184410095,
-0.3106682300567627,
-0.02078905515372753,
-0.20448750257492065,
0.5411347150802612,
-0.09554906189441681,
0.2458856999874115,
-0.1994042694568634,
0.3528687655925751,
0.9298759698867798,
-0.6139844655990601,
0.566939651966095,
-0.3595661222934723,
0.12673720717430115,
0.6129654049873352,
0.18861250579357147,
0.19291935861110687,
-0.04812317714095116,
-0.26361873745918274,
-0.08370765298604965,
-0.3991072475910187,
-0.48514676094055176,
-1.0139364004135132,
0.7997868657112122,
-0.8235199451446533,
-0.5940549969673157,
-0.26132556796073914,
-0.8417247533798218,
0.05346005782485008,
-0.039168115705251694,
0.06762378662824631,
0.5445942282676697,
0.3290466070175171,
-0.1343255639076233,
0.7224730253219604,
-0.20825806260108948,
0.5454691052436829,
0.3119906485080719,
-0.12982524931430817,
-0.22969092428684235,
1.1580278873443604,
0.5824492573738098,
0.2114063948392868,
-0.11411209404468536,
0.5190132260322571,
-0.4503138065338135,
-0.6328181028366089,
-0.5702387690544128,
-0.16522985696792603,
-1.0469231605529785,
-0.22376401722431183,
-0.6757102608680725,
-0.4386305809020996,
-0.19821099936962128,
-0.43344128131866455,
0.06589918583631516,
-1.0229871273040771,
-0.4765118956565857,
-0.2819348871707916,
0.46009495854377747,
0.9764394760131836,
-0.008242614567279816,
0.5228047370910645,
-0.4361933171749115,
0.3836205005645752,
0.5949358940124512,
0.6294153928756714,
0.44783273339271545,
-0.8800074458122253,
-0.3310695290565491,
0.11882200092077255,
-0.4912567138671875,
-0.6394665241241455,
0.15877829492092133,
0.10953381657600403,
0.41068530082702637,
0.327687531709671,
-0.05341392010450363,
0.7016695737838745,
-0.14297902584075928,
0.770694375038147,
0.21382197737693787,
-0.9624554514884949,
0.6210670471191406,
-0.06489510834217072,
0.4567739963531494,
0.2760976552963257,
0.3292095363140106,
0.00756477564573288,
-0.4550260305404663,
-0.7234359979629517,
-0.9229260087013245,
0.8073455095291138,
0.006235604640096426,
-0.14907407760620117,
-0.01141266617923975,
0.515139639377594,
0.22234629094600677,
0.15802964568138123,
-0.9321956038475037,
-0.22388899326324463,
-0.5158435106277466,
-0.42742282152175903,
-0.13768815994262695,
-0.175223708152771,
0.05935295671224594,
-0.4066157341003418,
0.6485989689826965,
-0.07094325125217438,
-0.006909097544848919,
-0.03991609811782837,
-0.3251880407333374,
0.14571255445480347,
0.32844677567481995,
0.6046918034553528,
0.6565470695495605,
-0.35491499304771423,
0.21466904878616333,
0.13686959445476532,
-0.2630397379398346,
0.36791688203811646,
0.16047851741313934,
-0.32283395528793335,
-0.10650353878736496,
0.25981467962265015,
0.6877000331878662,
-0.10792383551597595,
-0.2940097749233246,
0.25988906621932983,
-0.19404193758964539,
-0.39457979798316956,
-0.2778061032295227,
0.40031731128692627,
-0.04656292498111725,
0.1462302803993225,
0.24939405918121338,
0.4684290885925293,
0.2155599296092987,
-0.4215453565120697,
0.07896404713392258,
0.21153075993061066,
-0.6338424682617188,
-0.29358237981796265,
0.689551591873169,
0.27673718333244324,
-0.5964365005493164,
0.4592023491859436,
-0.07638504356145859,
-0.5378111004829407,
1.2526071071624756,
0.38220635056495667,
0.8822417855262756,
-0.04681074619293213,
0.36562004685401917,
0.37780991196632385,
0.2072998285293579,
0.04973294958472252,
0.011481843888759613,
-0.26765677332878113,
-0.3713194727897644,
-0.4571065306663513,
-0.8267090916633606,
-0.3322833478450775,
0.3059229254722595,
-0.7548204064369202,
0.21950308978557587,
-0.8472511768341064,
-0.22243629395961761,
0.4892083406448364,
-0.2752125859260559,
-0.7422975897789001,
0.6669174432754517,
-0.02343820221722126,
0.6328786611557007,
-1.1728363037109375,
0.45915934443473816,
1.0552926063537598,
-0.4723431468009949,
-0.8827343583106995,
-0.32108572125434875,
-0.2808825969696045,
-0.7694911360740662,
0.7153422236442566,
0.2961257994174957,
0.1820918768644333,
-0.08932266384363174,
-0.15035013854503632,
-0.7238349914550781,
0.912331223487854,
0.07073798775672913,
0.1368967890739441,
-0.3602577745914459,
0.008382568135857582,
0.7782227993011475,
-0.349105566740036,
0.7360950708389282,
0.3418601453304291,
0.34526389837265015,
0.15353111922740936,
-0.49303707480430603,
-0.056838929653167725,
-0.3766437768936157,
-0.18006469309329987,
0.35765203833580017,
-0.379286527633667,
0.7133920788764954,
-0.1922609806060791,
0.1980200856924057,
-0.33043918013572693,
0.5209619998931885,
-0.05678825452923775,
0.6427996754646301,
0.39779171347618103,
0.7579725384712219,
0.5453558564186096,
-0.11322791129350662,
0.7682324051856995,
-0.08328688889741898,
-0.014927241951227188,
1.0357404947280884,
0.22165898978710175,
0.299533873796463,
0.15139435231685638,
0.05040261149406433,
0.7047637701034546,
0.624312698841095,
-0.016036882996559143,
0.26586759090423584,
0.3753816783428192,
-0.3632887601852417,
-0.3665977716445923,
-0.21992987394332886,
-0.22610066831111908,
0.7140185236930847,
0.47106826305389404,
-0.6509923934936523,
-0.36352941393852234,
0.327631413936615,
-0.6001784205436707,
0.16558556258678436,
-0.8386332988739014,
0.7791913151741028,
-0.03621567413210869,
-0.9815744757652283,
0.5468997359275818,
-0.011590645648539066,
0.5455408096313477,
-0.40395820140838623,
-0.3395323157310486,
-0.2819852828979492,
0.25360107421875,
-0.3655382990837097,
-0.9192186594009399,
0.3123463988304138,
0.1075931191444397,
-0.4277537167072296,
-0.2077389657497406,
0.3798792362213135,
-0.44212329387664795,
-0.6728733777999878,
-0.009094214998185635,
0.11640795320272446,
0.08076213300228119,
0.26765406131744385,
-0.5933624505996704,
-0.596705973148346,
-0.07809600979089737,
-0.03658478707075119,
0.4146973192691803,
0.47340506315231323,
-0.2870040535926819,
0.8933176398277283,
0.5689665079116821,
-0.009411532431840897,
0.02972397394478321,
-0.219354048371315,
0.5302752256393433,
-0.5801025629043579,
-0.5867558121681213,
-0.7103596925735474,
0.7139570116996765,
0.2000955194234848,
-0.24931801855564117,
0.4724937975406647,
0.32021480798721313,
0.5522601008415222,
0.10463584214448929,
0.6507429480552673,
0.25089165568351746,
0.3131515085697174,
-0.38608288764953613,
0.9174835681915283,
-0.5750699043273926,
0.40158942341804504,
-0.1326945275068283,
-0.7136839628219604,
-0.1543920785188675,
0.5412147641181946,
-0.28374844789505005,
0.12057187408208847,
0.6931344270706177,
0.2798801362514496,
-0.11079047620296478,
0.22417519986629486,
0.22932736575603485,
-0.1897769421339035,
0.3411020338535309,
0.5715437531471252,
0.9322754144668579,
-0.4548100531101227,
0.5886059999465942,
-0.5750478506088257,
-0.4145306944847107,
-0.22302496433258057,
-0.7556712031364441,
-1.117777943611145,
-0.283905029296875,
-0.6772326827049255,
-0.5667059421539307,
-0.13117921352386475,
0.6364763379096985,
0.4942465126514435,
-0.7411612272262573,
0.019576314836740494,
-0.11792617291212082,
0.4825827479362488,
-0.1328023225069046,
-0.30221322178840637,
0.50043123960495,
-0.14407894015312195,
-0.4291464686393738,
0.20996472239494324,
-0.048026543110609055,
0.5723713040351868,
-0.020748909562826157,
0.24781200289726257,
-0.08111261576414108,
0.28953197598457336,
0.5263684988021851,
0.15221741795539856,
-0.5650750994682312,
-0.3692645728588104,
-0.05289620906114578,
0.16867071390151978,
0.042486175894737244,
0.5353918671607971,
-0.8886610269546509,
0.6085942387580872,
0.40768495202064514,
0.5881701707839966,
0.22180306911468506,
0.14028839766979218,
0.5760504603385925,
-0.41724371910095215,
-0.020889652892947197,
0.4974361062049866,
0.16807220876216888,
0.11779551208019257,
-0.6070150136947632,
0.2637535631656647,
-0.0016346513293683529,
-0.6044893860816956,
-0.9590696096420288,
0.2050582319498062,
-0.5068134665489197,
-0.39029523730278015,
0.3988679349422455,
-0.3864671587944031,
-0.1785113662481308,
-0.14401775598526,
0.21738301217556,
0.33167263865470886,
-0.09865575283765793,
1.274020791053772,
0.9410570859909058,
-0.42711320519447327,
-0.1538858264684677,
-0.35260000824928284,
0.5005246996879578,
0.615173876285553,
-0.7353810667991638,
-0.16738365590572357,
0.4787934422492981,
0.25955232977867126,
0.3027920126914978,
0.05901039391756058,
-0.19553504884243011,
0.6971127986907959,
-0.16855472326278687,
0.15000058710575104,
-0.524128258228302,
-0.5645923018455505,
-0.6105280518531799,
0.36981430649757385,
0.21166394650936127,
-0.294697105884552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00467v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00467v1
|
Harnessing the Power of Multiple Minds: Lessons Learned from LLM Routing
| 2024-05-01T12:04:28 | 2024-05-01T12:04:28 |
KV Aditya Srivatsa, Kaushal Kumar Maurya, Ekaterina Kochmar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the rapid development of LLMs, it is natural to ask how to harness their
capabilities efficiently. In this paper, we explore whether it is feasible to
direct each input query to a single most suitable LLM. To this end, we propose
LLM routing for challenging reasoning tasks. Our extensive experiments suggest
that such routing shows promise but is not feasible in all scenarios, so more
robust approaches should be investigated to fill this gap.
|
[
-0.6633075475692749,
-0.5876363515853882,
1.2696982622146606,
0.10459128022193909,
-0.34275728464126587,
0.10933490097522736,
-0.003590781707316637,
-0.16493012011051178,
-0.004911686759442091,
0.8112998008728027,
-1.0700267553329468,
-0.1444731056690216,
-0.5873385071754456,
0.22204719483852386,
-0.25216829776763916,
0.4763306975364685,
0.017842911183834076,
0.21641018986701965,
-0.45875003933906555,
-0.3883882462978363,
-0.7452602386474609,
-0.8411768078804016,
-0.8333670496940613,
-0.7562660574913025,
0.8990959525108337,
0.5824263095855713,
0.36082184314727783,
0.1818215698003769,
0.6271730661392212,
0.3092970848083496,
-0.029268071055412292,
0.6898662447929382,
-0.1305033266544342,
0.5875643491744995,
-0.551791787147522,
-0.7407039999961853,
-0.17327773571014404,
-0.1754298359155655,
0.6871221661567688,
0.7532578110694885,
-0.15696929395198822,
-0.19626206159591675,
-0.21625478565692902,
0.9987295269966125,
-0.4536299407482147,
-0.49192720651626587,
-0.909690797328949,
0.09412699192762375,
-0.4553828835487366,
-0.4916948974132538,
-0.31628429889678955,
-0.3274042010307312,
0.006485557183623314,
-0.39046111702919006,
0.0315253771841526,
0.5519423484802246,
0.30017948150634766,
0.6485425233840942,
-0.7124776244163513,
-0.3992466926574707,
-0.7597421407699585,
0.653006911277771,
-0.21158142387866974,
0.19979605078697205,
0.19421938061714172,
0.675666868686676,
-0.07752929627895355,
-0.749125599861145,
-0.4461488425731659,
0.15460216999053955,
0.2355281561613083,
0.17371238768100739,
0.005930495448410511,
0.062270715832710266,
0.34929174184799194,
0.04627237096428871,
-0.26773974299430847,
0.1388900876045227,
-0.2872312366962433,
0.09339015930891037,
0.8021135330200195,
0.5078234672546387,
0.13795743882656097,
0.002040816703811288,
-0.43707185983657837,
0.15494003891944885,
-0.7896057367324829,
-0.07851698994636536,
0.5232831239700317,
0.25846439599990845,
0.4138801395893097,
0.6096511483192444,
-0.2066550999879837,
0.9965600967407227,
-0.02620328590273857,
-0.21296292543411255,
-0.40028971433639526,
-0.4463825821876526,
0.03892837464809418,
0.0009095963905565441,
0.4206503629684448,
0.21146266162395477,
0.21891409158706665,
-0.38996121287345886,
-0.015251215547323227,
-0.07187528908252716,
0.7757073640823364,
-0.3442959785461426,
-0.18797102570533752,
0.2237756997346878,
-0.25831401348114014,
0.048894140869379044,
-0.10501612722873688,
-0.9694125056266785,
-0.7713986039161682,
-0.23837287724018097,
0.5034586787223816,
-0.32479509711265564,
-0.3094942271709442,
0.3168119490146637,
-0.24592705070972443,
0.4506678879261017,
0.4638100266456604,
-1.0530647039413452,
0.6130832433700562,
0.7636303305625916,
0.7926233410835266,
-0.42939579486846924,
-0.2564765512943268,
-0.14175371825695038,
0.08101922273635864,
0.019718173891305923,
1.0617241859436035,
-0.5141878724098206,
-0.5111125707626343,
-0.2914222478866577,
-0.3291380703449249,
-0.2644067108631134,
-0.578252375125885,
0.6657806634902954,
-0.6862019896507263,
-0.10446105897426605,
-0.83245849609375,
-0.5904126763343811,
-0.25076213479042053,
0.39188340306282043,
-0.515049934387207,
0.39288991689682007,
-0.14574983716011047,
-0.6577805280685425,
-0.04610053822398186,
-0.5218120813369751,
-0.7190008759498596,
-0.16535420715808868,
-0.31647154688835144,
-0.015342425554990768,
-0.0007399088935926557,
0.39129695296287537,
0.3597232401371002,
-0.48849746584892273,
-0.05038249492645264,
-0.34308046102523804,
-0.17712578177452087,
0.2890952527523041,
-0.4176273047924042,
1.081647276878357,
0.1086641401052475,
-0.12808166444301605,
0.07173806428909302,
-0.6523783206939697,
0.10087614506483078,
0.2685792148113251,
-0.3703770935535431,
-0.18793180584907532,
0.21858085691928864,
-0.44176167249679565,
0.30824247002601624,
-0.19987593591213226,
-0.3854459822177887,
0.4864504933357239,
-0.2402588427066803,
0.62086421251297,
1.152320384979248,
-0.00969020463526249,
0.7299615144729614,
-0.7772027850151062,
0.7502306699752808,
-0.046893708407878876,
-0.15190835297107697,
0.13729359209537506,
-0.67071932554245,
-1.0149403810501099,
0.08338433504104614,
-0.16465120017528534,
0.7247658371925354,
-0.8606741428375244,
-0.17810304462909698,
0.13693057000637054,
-0.4455870985984802,
-0.5539685487747192,
0.2731105387210846,
0.12570558488368988,
0.6359412670135498,
0.44642364978790283,
0.01715170219540596,
-0.5307157635688782,
-0.6889582276344299,
-0.5688628554344177,
-0.07876036316156387,
0.05312493070960045,
0.6501787900924683,
0.290645033121109,
0.11039570719003677,
0.5577645301818848,
-0.578914225101471,
-0.3661554455757141,
-0.3522813618183136,
-0.25321653485298157,
0.15822143852710724,
0.4584142565727234,
0.1230747252702713,
-0.881749153137207,
-0.12502910196781158,
-0.3184046745300293,
-0.9414359331130981,
-0.0571594163775444,
-0.2944164276123047,
-0.526484489440918,
-0.2513808310031891,
0.49058592319488525,
-0.8750354051589966,
0.09214267134666443,
0.14766660332679749,
-0.10635041445493698,
0.5400810241699219,
0.20299619436264038,
0.062007881700992584,
-0.8390523195266724,
-0.5234436392784119,
-0.03258606418967247,
-0.030750976875424385,
-0.5188325047492981,
0.2735843360424042,
-0.19926069676876068,
0.07867083698511124,
-0.43074244260787964,
0.6086721420288086,
-0.5143944025039673,
-0.09844502806663513,
-0.03937850892543793,
0.21401742100715637,
0.09948701411485672,
0.5854827165603638,
-0.2796057164669037,
0.8092955350875854,
0.8805338740348816,
-0.7528228759765625,
0.9951974749565125,
0.12984314560890198,
-0.049810755997896194,
1.0431883335113525,
-0.40901899337768555,
0.56243497133255,
-0.17026293277740479,
0.18181556463241577,
-1.0320416688919067,
-0.1654852032661438,
0.167732834815979,
-0.2954745888710022,
0.12454897910356522,
0.17946405708789825,
-0.45375582575798035,
-0.3366183936595917,
-0.07706150412559509,
0.36837732791900635,
0.4204739034175873,
-0.7657116651535034,
0.9321820735931396,
0.308285653591156,
0.01885664090514183,
-0.26969197392463684,
-0.8408867716789246,
0.0634661540389061,
-0.6219479441642761,
-0.8748157024383545,
0.40242907404899597,
-0.19289931654930115,
-0.3788283169269562,
-0.32556992769241333,
-0.22559981048107147,
0.05624985322356224,
0.1296708583831787,
0.29156115651130676,
-0.06392285227775574,
0.003976271953433752,
0.22557221353054047,
0.04662838578224182,
-0.05216998979449272,
0.3920048773288727,
-0.6422190070152283,
0.29695942997932434,
-0.06157064437866211,
-0.9959214329719543,
-0.22161124646663666,
0.8240662813186646,
0.6471575498580933,
-0.23338396847248077,
0.32546472549438477,
0.24333666265010834,
-0.43418803811073303,
-0.4758475124835968,
-0.8707641959190369,
-0.23302505910396576,
-0.5177947282791138,
0.037082333117723465,
-0.6331301331520081,
-1.1346049308776855,
0.39439526200294495,
-0.7105224132537842,
0.014495552517473698,
-0.07847660034894943,
0.5542256832122803,
-0.32825541496276855,
1.1149828433990479,
0.5633875131607056,
0.11346876621246338,
0.05005566030740738,
-0.05340736359357834,
0.350965291261673,
-1.03086519241333,
-0.4562927484512329,
-0.5446288585662842,
-0.32655227184295654,
-0.4866194427013397,
-0.4572892189025879,
0.7584730982780457,
0.1279054880142212,
-0.01598098874092102,
-0.16602236032485962,
-0.4912038743495941,
0.3576403260231018,
0.9451387524604797,
0.4298240840435028,
0.5083590149879456,
0.10760566592216492,
-0.6378124356269836,
0.21633577346801758,
-1.2604905366897583,
-0.45739009976387024,
0.8262955546379089,
-0.22135472297668457,
0.8233431577682495,
0.3550642728805542,
0.5291287302970886,
-0.26776957511901855,
0.1417488008737564,
-0.9306463599205017,
0.8965787887573242,
-0.0005098431138321757,
-0.7368276119232178,
-0.3810681402683258,
-0.31891679763793945,
-0.9281545877456665,
0.459485799074173,
-0.08749106526374817,
-0.8278627991676331,
-0.10839574038982391,
-0.022494690492749214,
-0.4724178910255432,
0.9136133790016174,
-0.5356499552726746,
0.23462046682834625,
-0.5016177892684937,
-0.6275997757911682,
-0.26489049196243286,
-0.7676123976707458,
0.59868323802948,
0.029560735449194908,
0.17840372025966644,
-0.11387158930301666,
-0.06506611406803131,
0.6054490208625793,
-0.27768436074256897,
0.47409743070602417,
0.20821036398410797,
0.2363114356994629,
0.4420192241668701,
-0.10587696731090546,
0.07005175948143005,
0.009595894254744053,
-0.3647927939891815,
-0.16100682318210602,
-0.527383029460907,
-0.40662792325019836,
-0.6378441452980042,
0.7722154855728149,
-0.6049359440803528,
-1.1481578350067139,
-0.32167550921440125,
-0.6873824000358582,
-0.7498595714569092,
0.28039005398750305,
0.27203670144081116,
0.376631498336792,
0.18114854395389557,
-0.12330256402492523,
0.8071954250335693,
0.11410542577505112,
0.6153280138969421,
0.14878074824810028,
0.03777291998267174,
-0.27487966418266296,
0.7061518430709839,
0.32160890102386475,
0.22304116189479828,
0.2820400595664978,
0.07533251494169235,
-0.47293201088905334,
-0.7655887007713318,
-0.5892378687858582,
0.0917794480919838,
-0.8367327451705933,
-0.3154173195362091,
-0.6725504398345947,
-0.0697707086801529,
-0.15260477364063263,
-0.33070871233940125,
-0.2764599919319153,
-0.4050062894821167,
-0.29170653223991394,
-0.13004660606384277,
0.3329380452632904,
0.593205451965332,
-0.17418988049030304,
0.26847273111343384,
-0.515122652053833,
0.6049326062202454,
1.0409536361694336,
0.36582398414611816,
0.4558468461036682,
-0.12713570892810822,
0.17688414454460144,
-0.2670513689517975,
-0.7724325060844421,
-1.1609067916870117,
0.1591486632823944,
-0.16061483323574066,
0.8759531378746033,
0.20776747167110443,
0.21494591236114502,
0.6217272281646729,
-0.732008695602417,
0.6593616008758545,
0.3907555043697357,
-0.6666668653488159,
0.9052876830101013,
-0.19145654141902924,
0.3790733218193054,
0.5012757182121277,
0.6544085741043091,
-0.1142391636967659,
-0.25453007221221924,
-0.4983469545841217,
-0.7577208280563354,
0.5084325075149536,
0.046597227454185486,
-0.1551106870174408,
0.09892482310533524,
0.4078797698020935,
0.06858115643262863,
0.07036012411117554,
-0.3354407250881195,
-0.4133870005607605,
0.04336216673254967,
0.26334166526794434,
0.4021686911582947,
-0.013623501174151897,
-0.45363786816596985,
-0.42098599672317505,
0.3943798542022705,
-0.16266615688800812,
0.4883517622947693,
0.37684938311576843,
0.22603529691696167,
-0.08716223388910294,
0.22638267278671265,
0.42195063829421997,
1.022422432899475,
0.11085416376590729,
0.6567056775093079,
0.4582063555717468,
0.04821435362100601,
0.3700658679008484,
-0.12798121571540833,
-0.04601253941655159,
-0.23752374947071075,
0.2032002955675125,
0.6533705592155457,
-0.30485787987709045,
-0.45909473299980164,
0.15045176446437836,
-0.2586401104927063,
-0.5960912704467773,
-0.019510919228196144,
0.43238863348960876,
0.4231712818145752,
0.6446858644485474,
0.5849138498306274,
0.27245259284973145,
0.05539655312895775,
-0.24216416478157043,
0.06544413417577744,
0.6476739048957825,
-0.1864037960767746,
0.017178112640976906,
0.7266759872436523,
0.25225183367729187,
-0.9212360382080078,
0.7808515429496765,
-0.0645645409822464,
-0.6770831346511841,
0.6290927529335022,
0.5091649889945984,
0.7988711595535278,
0.06512057036161423,
-0.24465249478816986,
0.07428727298974991,
0.5442599058151245,
-0.24185338616371155,
0.25277918577194214,
-0.14754743874073029,
-0.8577097058296204,
-0.43846482038497925,
-0.35953018069267273,
-0.9191422462463379,
-0.2355158030986786,
-0.6372961401939392,
-0.04057199880480766,
-0.6069286465644836,
-0.2785704731941223,
-0.1832694113254547,
-0.08016162365674973,
-0.8283611536026001,
0.13073278963565826,
0.19274917244911194,
0.6910590529441833,
-0.4146336019039154,
0.8158769607543945,
1.12795889377594,
-0.16878405213356018,
-0.842134952545166,
-0.33610644936561584,
0.2702249586582184,
-0.9688106775283813,
0.2360801100730896,
0.05458208546042442,
-0.5183924436569214,
0.02190665900707245,
-0.750563383102417,
-0.5429554581642151,
1.2461082935333252,
0.23241659998893738,
-0.3281463384628296,
-0.12133105844259262,
-0.010894001461565495,
-0.017775116488337517,
-0.3131026029586792,
0.07012761384248734,
0.4696209728717804,
0.481678307056427,
0.2623412013053894,
-0.6895344853401184,
0.23428978025913239,
0.042597267776727676,
-0.03404168784618378,
-0.12399078160524368,
-1.1259841918945312,
0.7752810120582581,
-0.46893244981765747,
-0.1369173377752304,
-0.12006942182779312,
0.581758975982666,
0.7609875798225403,
0.5362164974212646,
0.6286827921867371,
0.6622629165649414,
1.262830138206482,
-0.02643262967467308,
0.9388034343719482,
0.19350434839725494,
-0.051445022225379944,
0.8941147327423096,
-0.38834989070892334,
0.3578824996948242,
0.7501760125160217,
-0.38613754510879517,
0.23504355549812317,
0.496000200510025,
0.4776380658149719,
0.5792629718780518,
0.5242919325828552,
-0.5494031310081482,
-0.6403067111968994,
-0.09047979861497879,
-0.1736479103565216,
0.2910558879375458,
0.48451000452041626,
0.2743722200393677,
-0.3387145698070526,
0.2682080566883087,
-0.0031028627417981625,
0.07766295224428177,
-0.5948046445846558,
0.4858507215976715,
0.4564310610294342,
-0.842564582824707,
0.21333371102809906,
-0.1577952653169632,
0.8595394492149353,
-0.4693352282047272,
-0.10053043812513351,
-0.3012356162071228,
-0.04391638562083244,
-0.1716574877500534,
-0.6477475762367249,
0.36502307653427124,
-0.18626907467842102,
-0.13490711152553558,
-0.7274004220962524,
1.31913161277771,
0.11954792588949203,
-0.5571250915527344,
0.1932409703731537,
1.08047354221344,
0.18526391685009003,
-0.05707462877035141,
-0.5947783589363098,
0.04187284782528877,
-0.09139183163642883,
-0.21028046309947968,
0.5507694482803345,
0.7822369337081909,
0.22951337695121765,
1.373295783996582,
0.5830725431442261,
0.26261311769485474,
0.43402940034866333,
0.09399926662445068,
1.0457265377044678,
-0.9258022308349609,
-0.1994895190000534,
-1.1379448175430298,
0.25370433926582336,
-0.07184793055057526,
-0.3204588294029236,
0.853417694568634,
-0.02192223258316517,
0.793359100818634,
0.29127779603004456,
0.8814791440963745,
0.1431855708360672,
0.3650323450565338,
-0.6869792938232422,
0.2630302906036377,
-0.6336526274681091,
0.4619544744491577,
0.08624080568552017,
-0.5492360591888428,
-0.24380120635032654,
0.740365207195282,
0.05457916110754013,
-0.022652657702565193,
0.9915011525154114,
0.7892547249794006,
0.1194741353392601,
0.33593204617500305,
0.2176479548215866,
-0.0976799726486206,
0.25620341300964355,
1.1191205978393555,
1.102629542350769,
0.06362317502498627,
0.5213257074356079,
-0.3489956259727478,
-0.13186395168304443,
-0.041906774044036865,
-0.9680107831954956,
-0.9829686880111694,
-0.20057038962841034,
-0.21084505319595337,
-0.20293550193309784,
0.13860851526260376,
0.4911469519138336,
0.9635055065155029,
-0.34093862771987915,
-0.3018776476383209,
-0.38535311818122864,
1.0621216297149658,
-0.3650483787059784,
-0.14796015620231628,
-0.00377560593187809,
-0.30029401183128357,
-0.4855334162712097,
0.49334341287612915,
0.31623056530952454,
-0.3213745355606079,
-0.6911917328834534,
0.21307329833507538,
-0.5837507247924805,
0.10684467107057571,
0.6743842363357544,
0.07344447076320648,
-0.891502320766449,
-0.28322967886924744,
0.2677479684352875,
-0.007394813001155853,
0.11325191706418991,
1.1283055543899536,
-0.9534701108932495,
0.3195801377296448,
0.44052180647850037,
1.1054980754852295,
0.6443004608154297,
-0.0540592260658741,
0.45652252435684204,
-0.388077974319458,
-0.35849183797836304,
0.5538164377212524,
0.2806990444660187,
0.3463954031467438,
-0.41569027304649353,
0.5913467407226562,
0.39386993646621704,
-0.8025372624397278,
-0.5118230581283569,
0.5273971557617188,
-1.19939386844635,
-0.3716927766799927,
1.2482666969299316,
0.031779419630765915,
0.015847934409976006,
-0.3927524983882904,
-0.2207723706960678,
0.10310681164264679,
0.05048295482993126,
0.37255239486694336,
1.068332314491272,
-1.0179009437561035,
-0.4227089285850525,
-0.9253899455070496,
0.051192499697208405,
0.7642409801483154,
-0.6716662645339966,
-0.29494205117225647,
0.2863572835922241,
0.1130957305431366,
0.0653872936964035,
1.0794624090194702,
0.16262194514274597,
-0.173471137881279,
0.07718758285045624,
-0.655113160610199,
-0.19028069078922272,
-0.5109152793884277,
-0.12986411154270172,
0.6173089742660522,
0.18882323801517487,
-0.07494053244590759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00465v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00465v3
|
BiomedRAG: A Retrieval Augmented Large Language Model for Biomedicine
| 2024-05-01T12:01:39 | 2024-05-03T01:12:08 |
Mingchen Li, Halil Kilicoglu, Hua Xu, Rui Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have swiftly emerged as vital resources for
different applications in the biomedical and healthcare domains; however, these
models encounter issues such as generating inaccurate information or
hallucinations. Retrieval-augmented generation provided a solution for these
models to update knowledge and enhance their performance. In contrast to
previous retrieval-augmented LMs, which utilize specialized cross-attention
mechanisms to help LLM encode retrieved text, BiomedRAG adopts a simpler
approach by directly inputting the retrieved chunk-based documents into the
LLM. This straightforward design is easily applicable to existing retrieval and
language models, effectively bypassing noise information in retrieved
documents, particularly in noise-intensive tasks. Moreover, we demonstrate the
potential for utilizing the LLM to supervise the retrieval model in the
biomedical domain, enabling it to retrieve the document that assists the LM in
improving its predictions. Our experiments reveal that with the tuned
scorer,\textsc{ BiomedRAG} attains superior performance across 5 biomedical NLP
tasks, encompassing information extraction (triple extraction, relation
extraction), text classification, link prediction, and question-answering,
leveraging over 9 datasets. For instance, in the triple extraction task,
\textsc{BiomedRAG} outperforms other triple extraction systems with micro-F1
scores of 81.42 and 88.83 on GIT and ChemProt corpora, respectively.
|
[
0.07629574835300446,
-0.6830001473426819,
0.675300121307373,
0.0547671914100647,
-0.34101420640945435,
0.3161906898021698,
-0.1999538242816925,
-0.7979363799095154,
0.6447402834892273,
0.39187154173851013,
-0.1742602437734604,
-0.4509274661540985,
-0.7507134079933167,
0.4315037131309509,
-0.3481970727443695,
1.0915634632110596,
0.17859607934951782,
0.3441646993160248,
-0.11435650289058685,
-0.10219493508338928,
-0.26677006483078003,
-0.5511155128479004,
-0.5776641964912415,
-0.621755838394165,
1.0039622783660889,
-0.12888886034488678,
0.4825998544692993,
0.6946669220924377,
0.8640621900558472,
0.25542551279067993,
-0.38078150153160095,
0.1894916146993637,
-0.3019362986087799,
0.4970104694366455,
-0.2718854248523712,
-0.3350069224834442,
-0.6570541858673096,
-0.2286127507686615,
0.7134011387825012,
0.6415151357650757,
-0.18813496828079224,
0.23782502114772797,
0.11594071239233017,
0.594090461730957,
-0.5730382204055786,
0.10695723444223404,
-0.5127673149108887,
0.06663902848958969,
-0.37066081166267395,
-0.5258235931396484,
-0.3413081169128418,
-0.23639079928398132,
-0.21928267180919647,
-0.31921690702438354,
0.017294542863965034,
0.10131991654634476,
0.45053455233573914,
0.5227864980697632,
-0.11907318234443665,
-0.14802788197994232,
-0.566125750541687,
0.456193208694458,
-0.40897589921951294,
0.5948145389556885,
0.4343098998069763,
0.19301658868789673,
-0.2137596607208252,
-1.0029863119125366,
-0.12661899626255035,
-0.025659218430519104,
0.05542423203587532,
0.16655196249485016,
-0.20549209415912628,
0.24811241030693054,
0.2512364685535431,
0.4507473409175873,
-0.5113180875778198,
0.19424006342887878,
-0.7721364498138428,
-0.1394733488559723,
0.5073747634887695,
0.16529488563537598,
0.3044874370098114,
-0.39447611570358276,
-0.11939447373151779,
0.14545825123786926,
-0.7719376683235168,
-0.3843970000743866,
-0.1751611828804016,
0.1924726963043213,
0.20383265614509583,
0.8525452017784119,
-0.2037530541419983,
0.7327339053153992,
0.12801046669483185,
-0.28350308537483215,
0.46584558486938477,
-0.2676081657409668,
-0.21831299364566803,
0.34298238158226013,
0.7942365407943726,
-0.026958541944622993,
-0.22801974415779114,
-0.2840917706489563,
-0.1291569322347641,
-0.05682514235377312,
0.6607009172439575,
-0.9439758062362671,
-0.20820067822933197,
0.5727669596672058,
-0.5499957799911499,
-0.38214677572250366,
-0.36032506823539734,
-0.8100336194038391,
-0.4643414318561554,
-0.04666772857308388,
0.4766893982887268,
-0.5463016629219055,
0.19883908331394196,
0.37327247858047485,
-0.1468215137720108,
-0.041800208389759064,
0.2302914261817932,
-0.7292511463165283,
0.06983918696641922,
0.8054203987121582,
1.0480453968048096,
-0.3225725591182709,
-0.018737995997071266,
-0.9180613160133362,
0.2957254648208618,
-0.18067948520183563,
0.9665268659591675,
-0.6826527118682861,
-0.3959437906742096,
-0.1042502224445343,
-0.06098894402384758,
-0.08926291763782501,
-0.7634792923927307,
0.6629290580749512,
-0.6392709612846375,
0.009904145263135433,
0.011518474668264389,
-0.6000916957855225,
-0.09198131412267685,
0.05153514817357063,
-0.6979866027832031,
0.9431731104850769,
0.06038818508386612,
-0.7952476143836975,
0.2285185009241104,
-0.6599236130714417,
-0.39552614092826843,
0.5197795033454895,
-0.275387167930603,
-0.3581215739250183,
0.08764471113681793,
0.06533967703580856,
0.5318372249603271,
-0.21815012395381927,
0.2855992615222931,
-0.2718011140823364,
-0.5105140209197998,
0.09198348969221115,
-0.11889299005270004,
0.6148255467414856,
0.12138906121253967,
-0.03614399954676628,
0.10761238634586334,
-0.7002343535423279,
-0.037692517042160034,
-0.1953829675912857,
-1.0000587701797485,
-0.24137836694717407,
-0.02955799549818039,
-0.019155286252498627,
0.06743812561035156,
0.23892995715141296,
-0.7149029970169067,
0.25651782751083374,
-0.6187315583229065,
0.35023778676986694,
0.3315056562423706,
0.021710624918341637,
0.2401696890592575,
-0.5567417740821838,
0.6647893786430359,
-0.33699944615364075,
-0.24441587924957275,
-0.014860262162983418,
-0.47775089740753174,
-0.12110792845487595,
-0.7986208200454712,
0.5703824758529663,
0.5348405838012695,
-0.7309806942939758,
0.38136348128318787,
-0.2679133713245392,
-0.40296506881713867,
-0.9580633044242859,
0.22257420420646667,
0.34473174810409546,
0.5619449019432068,
0.62956702709198,
-0.1313880831003189,
-0.5806964039802551,
-0.6281982660293579,
-0.3381173610687256,
-0.10061709582805634,
-0.23649317026138306,
0.27926698327064514,
0.45855677127838135,
-0.6291482448577881,
0.3500622510910034,
-0.4051414132118225,
-0.2634997069835663,
-0.43881750106811523,
0.007331914734095335,
0.3985571563243866,
0.24214044213294983,
0.23027454316616058,
-0.6402919888496399,
-0.26708757877349854,
0.20501871407032013,
-0.6867935061454773,
-0.48015469312667847,
0.38948965072631836,
-0.05960406735539436,
0.0760134756565094,
0.39780741930007935,
-0.8861976861953735,
0.3308028280735016,
0.4490911364555359,
-0.03931080922484398,
0.754867434501648,
-0.3293707072734833,
0.15352235734462738,
-1.1390763521194458,
0.4846501648426056,
-0.11965605616569519,
-0.4161606729030609,
-0.45854243636131287,
0.24517205357551575,
0.1557837277650833,
0.06900713592767715,
-0.2652919590473175,
0.8157463669776917,
-0.2628149092197418,
-0.0644787847995758,
-0.3543294668197632,
0.004217841196805239,
0.17626239359378815,
0.15541397035121918,
0.06749290972948074,
0.7527751922607422,
0.2171507328748703,
-0.4365531802177429,
0.3401123583316803,
0.5477676391601562,
-0.387464314699173,
0.40735653042793274,
-0.9219915270805359,
0.018561607226729393,
-0.35415658354759216,
0.5139464139938354,
-0.4592582583427429,
-0.6250810027122498,
0.18666788935661316,
-0.2886600196361542,
0.5389125347137451,
-0.021784532815217972,
-0.6239893436431885,
-0.45835649967193604,
-0.34945374727249146,
0.3204091787338257,
0.49082714319229126,
-0.5057428479194641,
0.39299288392066956,
0.46492379903793335,
-0.48877203464508057,
-0.6066708564758301,
-0.4709334373474121,
-0.030352072790265083,
-0.05622241646051407,
-0.13882479071617126,
0.5889663696289062,
-0.03517541289329529,
-0.21002815663814545,
-0.27783048152923584,
-0.08246756345033646,
0.0038972622714936733,
-0.10875730216503143,
0.22687065601348877,
0.3335893452167511,
-0.022800873965024948,
0.6295074820518494,
0.2773202061653137,
-0.02797102928161621,
-0.04763014614582062,
-0.1473747342824936,
0.5819988250732422,
0.3465072214603424,
-0.18352966010570526,
-0.13573697209358215,
0.32717835903167725,
0.5554401874542236,
-0.29519742727279663,
0.716469943523407,
0.6991256475448608,
-0.441031813621521,
0.08603537082672119,
-0.5494542121887207,
-0.2903882563114166,
-0.3957790732383728,
0.6631931066513062,
-0.10732796043157578,
-0.9594250917434692,
0.23210874199867249,
-0.14806631207466125,
-0.09341707080602646,
0.45685678720474243,
0.8128071427345276,
-0.29509422183036804,
0.883571445941925,
0.287066251039505,
-0.1547672152519226,
0.2659364640712738,
0.033515918999910355,
-0.07003738731145859,
-1.2214289903640747,
-0.5223679542541504,
-0.7892286777496338,
-0.44560864567756653,
-0.3748309314250946,
-0.6517335176467896,
0.855318009853363,
0.15681740641593933,
-0.12863336503505707,
0.10197684913873672,
-0.6081210970878601,
0.16772501170635223,
0.33381202816963196,
0.5930311679840088,
0.45540687441825867,
0.15500310063362122,
-0.2503992021083832,
0.09324786812067032,
-0.9333791732788086,
-0.3084954023361206,
1.0242829322814941,
0.2906345725059509,
0.7364144921302795,
0.09802351146936417,
0.8206222653388977,
0.21373894810676575,
0.4406895041465759,
-0.8352863192558289,
0.29894572496414185,
-0.21399755775928497,
-0.7339213490486145,
-0.022312752902507782,
-0.5857352614402771,
-1.1898751258850098,
0.21625998616218567,
-0.4520849287509918,
-0.8348336815834045,
0.08804178982973099,
0.06612157821655273,
-0.6601192355155945,
0.21546487510204315,
-0.09907403588294983,
0.4837394654750824,
-0.11641062796115875,
-0.6619961261749268,
-0.3429565131664276,
-0.7037523984909058,
0.2647717297077179,
-0.4746430814266205,
0.20387160778045654,
0.10019960254430771,
-0.1832856982946396,
0.6578683853149414,
-0.42047807574272156,
0.6239744424819946,
0.2509222626686096,
-0.07062427699565887,
-0.03813169151544571,
0.05739801004528999,
0.3779785931110382,
-0.07462354749441147,
-0.43122798204421997,
0.1344311386346817,
0.26324328780174255,
-0.22176219522953033,
-0.4043826162815094,
0.5685940384864807,
-0.35766711831092834,
-0.48102355003356934,
-0.31678569316864014,
-0.6366018056869507,
-0.13863085210323334,
0.2305697798728943,
0.3177461326122284,
0.618973970413208,
-0.019290542230010033,
0.4306212067604065,
0.7425807118415833,
-0.6606038808822632,
0.17486384510993958,
0.5246644616127014,
-0.48228418827056885,
-0.4257984757423401,
0.6486070156097412,
0.055058520287275314,
-0.024596821516752243,
0.5325062274932861,
0.10572709888219833,
-0.4182397723197937,
-0.39151865243911743,
-0.35249847173690796,
0.37616193294525146,
-0.2837878465652466,
-0.5365824103355408,
-1.133478045463562,
-0.37312957644462585,
-0.2760677635669708,
0.079305000603199,
-0.06703806668519974,
-0.30712181329727173,
-0.32127514481544495,
-0.14435157179832458,
0.6343417167663574,
0.7082104682922363,
-0.20517154037952423,
0.09017594158649445,
-1.1911098957061768,
0.4608445167541504,
-0.0683276429772377,
0.4562089741230011,
-0.2559698820114136,
-0.6910713315010071,
-0.31538495421409607,
-0.15571866929531097,
-0.22247882187366486,
-1.0387719869613647,
0.6140903234481812,
0.26585638523101807,
0.3495081961154938,
0.04072577878832817,
-0.32284560799598694,
0.3680785298347473,
-0.8501570224761963,
0.4036990702152252,
-0.026948457583785057,
-0.3636489510536194,
0.5423222780227661,
-0.48391810059547424,
0.43460798263549805,
0.5445939898490906,
0.4499848783016205,
-0.2649765908718109,
-0.3292214274406433,
-0.5038543343544006,
-0.6487820148468018,
0.2933013141155243,
-0.2227131724357605,
-0.03499988093972206,
-0.22186097502708435,
0.6219412088394165,
0.09094607830047607,
0.4069250524044037,
-0.32113662362098694,
0.1090969517827034,
0.4635671079158783,
-0.5461582541465759,
-0.016820399090647697,
-0.42000067234039307,
-0.07565620541572571,
-0.43133196234703064,
0.5676919221878052,
-0.03848716616630554,
0.4053402841091156,
0.3761700391769409,
-0.047067172825336456,
-0.1558482050895691,
0.3172595202922821,
0.5142229199409485,
0.3164861798286438,
-0.3239959478378296,
0.05426526814699173,
0.027588237076997757,
-0.7112301588058472,
-0.021982058882713318,
0.3724890947341919,
-0.02103138156235218,
0.1754685342311859,
0.42872869968414307,
0.36889782547950745,
0.4900893270969391,
-0.8097548484802246,
0.1418905109167099,
0.3689315915107727,
-0.03738090395927429,
0.11962935328483582,
0.07955949008464813,
0.06313158571720123,
0.5352557301521301,
0.3033582270145416,
0.05652877688407898,
0.512021541595459,
-0.4411814212799072,
0.40413734316825867,
0.45918911695480347,
-0.3715399503707886,
-0.22020001709461212,
0.9212146997451782,
-0.0026016635820269585,
-0.4368782341480255,
0.23018057644367218,
0.25567394495010376,
-0.46099838614463806,
0.15596550703048706,
0.6592541933059692,
0.5947680473327637,
-0.28154435753822327,
0.17785657942295074,
0.2761498689651489,
-0.032757718116045,
-0.3227017819881439,
0.39574676752090454,
0.0419883206486702,
-0.4579601287841797,
-0.7839577198028564,
-1.168046474456787,
-0.25953909754753113,
-0.018504103645682335,
-0.5189023613929749,
0.01189516019076109,
-0.21372385323047638,
-0.3362874388694763,
0.14585167169570923,
0.08381981402635574,
-0.3240976929664612,
0.09595487266778946,
-0.14501701295375824,
0.9008861780166626,
-0.19719569385051727,
0.8676548004150391,
0.6940707564353943,
-0.3045240044593811,
-0.5972332954406738,
-0.38152527809143066,
-0.08137263357639313,
-0.6625534892082214,
0.6932322978973389,
-0.11338379979133606,
0.02439875714480877,
-0.02355356328189373,
-0.4116731882095337,
-0.6595677733421326,
0.9504674077033997,
0.3037857413291931,
-0.7264793515205383,
-0.1529064178466797,
-0.1876247078180313,
0.8163593411445618,
-0.12365338951349258,
0.18920665979385376,
0.4615863263607025,
0.3417464792728424,
-0.025933802127838135,
-0.9967958331108093,
-0.06116502359509468,
-0.3460310399532318,
-0.39661821722984314,
0.233480766415596,
-0.5838356018066406,
0.6835866570472717,
-0.1827135980129242,
0.16003882884979248,
0.2432803511619568,
0.2569233477115631,
0.6381530165672302,
0.23224668204784393,
-0.22397713363170624,
0.45687881112098694,
1.0062206983566284,
0.1138971745967865,
1.514146089553833,
-0.43238136172294617,
0.06602103263139725,
0.984765350818634,
-0.43861907720565796,
1.1070377826690674,
0.3471701145172119,
-0.16380974650382996,
0.47887033224105835,
0.31394609808921814,
0.2540057897567749,
0.23905529081821442,
0.16105468571186066,
-0.5008881688117981,
-0.08946935087442398,
-0.2925293445587158,
-0.5155600309371948,
0.49776825308799744,
0.46976396441459656,
-0.7747377753257751,
0.06422878056764603,
0.0046372367069125175,
0.037202540785074234,
-0.07157213985919952,
-0.4678211808204651,
0.8487353324890137,
0.2741469144821167,
-0.36454498767852783,
0.5034288763999939,
0.03747545927762985,
0.5577874779701233,
-0.4262700378894806,
-0.1837504506111145,
-0.10357221961021423,
0.10761528462171555,
-0.25951963663101196,
-0.49856260418891907,
0.299481064081192,
0.14078497886657715,
-0.35128656029701233,
-0.0477561354637146,
1.0947619676589966,
-0.5899754166603088,
-0.7045851945877075,
0.26298218965530396,
0.5317208170890808,
0.34087347984313965,
-0.003719743574038148,
-0.5017856359481812,
0.4535430073738098,
-0.2853946089744568,
-0.0739840641617775,
0.38187581300735474,
0.15614096820354462,
0.29976099729537964,
0.6975886821746826,
0.4414710998535156,
0.5753925442695618,
-0.1799696832895279,
-0.14514492452144623,
0.7236185073852539,
-0.5289336442947388,
-0.034298866987228394,
-0.7993211150169373,
0.12437300384044647,
-0.05308682471513748,
0.005094306543469429,
0.43582019209861755,
0.561072826385498,
0.29575619101524353,
-0.07853482663631439,
0.6476016044616699,
0.18945471942424774,
1.0673892498016357,
-0.6505057215690613,
1.0085382461547852,
-0.6060201525688171,
0.29728904366493225,
-0.22051458060741425,
-0.8131887912750244,
-0.4987448751926422,
0.6088151335716248,
-0.22175714373588562,
0.20532427728176117,
0.739473819732666,
0.6584072113037109,
0.06638577580451965,
-0.16456027328968048,
0.3488619327545166,
0.4326973259449005,
-0.051199063658714294,
0.4815596342086792,
0.4986627697944641,
-0.39023739099502563,
0.11154650151729584,
0.2092922031879425,
-0.05762961506843567,
-0.3536193072795868,
-0.4862162172794342,
-0.6183441281318665,
-0.1562677025794983,
-0.1635439246892929,
-0.5370388031005859,
0.4189072549343109,
1.1350241899490356,
0.4905655086040497,
-0.49355822801589966,
0.08662012219429016,
0.44108036160469055,
0.009380141273140907,
0.026354225352406502,
-0.1634846329689026,
0.2866624593734741,
-0.3414236307144165,
-0.6461858153343201,
0.732134997844696,
0.6602963805198669,
-0.2477315068244934,
-0.07605577260255814,
0.08470109850168228,
-0.32923322916030884,
0.0336519293487072,
0.7629135251045227,
0.2809617817401886,
-0.42005905508995056,
-0.17280369997024536,
0.015065747313201427,
-0.3410479724407196,
0.15393182635307312,
0.5660409331321716,
-1.058912754058838,
0.2586865723133087,
0.39809197187423706,
0.9471747875213623,
0.48084765672683716,
0.0051865545101463795,
0.6052821278572083,
-0.5872717499732971,
0.024242468178272247,
0.2659224569797516,
0.3830527365207672,
0.27707985043525696,
-0.5276616811752319,
0.6856760382652283,
0.15045416355133057,
-0.7247007489204407,
-0.851995587348938,
-0.1174481064081192,
-0.8708812594413757,
-0.21445025503635406,
1.220494031906128,
0.2204972356557846,
-0.2525702714920044,
-0.1700303554534912,
-0.3032888174057007,
0.3248361349105835,
-0.21726547181606293,
0.9413419365882874,
0.26697084307670593,
-0.027642741799354553,
-0.06166472285985947,
-0.8135286569595337,
0.6638774275779724,
0.5079939961433411,
-0.8136034607887268,
-0.2824724018573761,
0.6465145349502563,
0.1598765105009079,
0.10207056999206543,
0.8252331018447876,
-0.43381398916244507,
0.33586201071739197,
-0.36948108673095703,
0.04402497783303261,
0.21232637763023376,
-0.4140024483203888,
-0.4156646728515625,
0.32268643379211426,
-0.0754949301481247,
0.15179438889026642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00461v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00461v1
|
Enhancing Surgical Robots with Embodied Intelligence for Autonomous Ultrasound Scanning
| 2024-05-01T11:39:38 | 2024-05-01T11:39:38 |
Huan Xu, Jinlin Wu, Guanglin Cao, Zhen Lei, Zhen Chen, Hongbin Liu
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Ultrasound robots are increasingly used in medical diagnostics and early
disease screening. However, current ultrasound robots lack the intelligence to
understand human intentions and instructions, hindering autonomous ultrasound
scanning. To solve this problem, we propose a novel Ultrasound Embodied
Intelligence system that equips ultrasound robots with the large language model
(LLM) and domain knowledge, thereby improving the efficiency of ultrasound
robots. Specifically, we first design an ultrasound operation knowledge
database to add expertise in ultrasound scanning to the LLM, enabling the LLM
to perform precise motion planning. Furthermore, we devise a dynamic ultrasound
scanning strategy based on a \textit{think-observe-execute} prompt engineering,
allowing LLMs to dynamically adjust motion planning strategies during the
scanning procedures. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our system
significantly improves ultrasound scan efficiency and quality from verbal
commands. This advancement in autonomous medical scanning technology
contributes to non-invasive diagnostics and streamlined medical workflows.
|
[
-0.31489574909210205,
-0.3983684182167053,
1.0335904359817505,
-0.2543255090713501,
-0.6124163269996643,
0.1301935613155365,
0.23062527179718018,
-0.8121703863143921,
0.8161963820457458,
0.6681369543075562,
-0.7078406810760498,
-0.4248885214328766,
-0.7290173768997192,
0.13760678470134735,
-0.36298906803131104,
0.4922465682029724,
0.17863236367702484,
0.12965770065784454,
-0.019870802760124207,
-0.3296163082122803,
-0.2519107460975647,
-0.13507753610610962,
-0.4092600643634796,
-0.2145133763551712,
0.48400917649269104,
0.0992593988776207,
1.1002895832061768,
0.916667103767395,
0.5498895645141602,
0.3574725091457367,
0.25934046506881714,
0.7644517421722412,
-0.0032744985073804855,
0.06714440137147903,
-0.19907647371292114,
-0.23161421716213226,
-0.818576455116272,
-0.28110334277153015,
0.3855747580528259,
0.9341493248939514,
-0.21298032999038696,
-0.2594519555568695,
-0.29107949137687683,
0.6310672760009766,
-0.39058318734169006,
0.09494993090629578,
-0.08640257269144058,
0.12737411260604858,
0.3825933635234833,
-0.45650556683540344,
-0.0014133922522887588,
-0.2892046868801117,
-0.05648503825068474,
-0.8933838605880737,
-0.1923326849937439,
-0.28744685649871826,
0.3929310142993927,
0.8871855139732361,
-0.4525015950202942,
-0.4134194850921631,
-0.9903410077095032,
0.2363569438457489,
-0.2830021381378174,
0.7896183729171753,
0.04449690133333206,
0.16404016315937042,
-0.08513622730970383,
-0.7331421971321106,
-0.25543105602264404,
-0.3333446979522705,
-0.01616913266479969,
0.2571553587913513,
-0.13222430646419525,
0.3551380932331085,
0.10603844374418259,
0.08743590861558914,
-0.4917263090610504,
0.09300035238265991,
-0.22493000328540802,
-0.026626965031027794,
0.7594258189201355,
0.2945951223373413,
0.4101915955543518,
0.28065574169158936,
-0.4090504050254822,
-0.20160698890686035,
-0.42583465576171875,
-0.15726922452449799,
0.007995051331818104,
0.010005500167608261,
0.08570263534784317,
0.5865868330001831,
-0.25751176476478577,
0.6522138118743896,
0.11868893355131149,
-0.20713728666305542,
0.2877747118473053,
-0.1126481369137764,
-0.14493779838085175,
0.24439014494419098,
0.6306484341621399,
0.16608643531799316,
-0.12071636319160461,
-0.03448047488927841,
-0.5177933573722839,
-0.09730160981416702,
0.7669867873191833,
-0.632417619228363,
0.003982956521213055,
0.15358178317546844,
-0.5685498714447021,
0.023356355726718903,
-0.12996134161949158,
-0.3335624933242798,
-0.8998138904571533,
-0.4566488265991211,
0.501579225063324,
-0.42209309339523315,
-0.2843250632286072,
0.735054075717926,
-0.039669573307037354,
0.18460948765277863,
0.5811050534248352,
-0.7830333709716797,
0.2558477520942688,
0.7128475308418274,
0.5463371872901917,
0.4731731712818146,
0.09797079861164093,
-0.42360344529151917,
0.34484052658081055,
-0.7742962837219238,
0.8052554726600647,
-0.535042941570282,
-0.8810700178146362,
-0.17286933958530426,
-0.05231236293911934,
0.029508983716368675,
-0.7893431782722473,
0.4331832528114319,
-0.26258328557014465,
-0.26916995644569397,
0.04214397072792053,
-0.4498057961463928,
-0.5321794152259827,
0.006401631515473127,
-0.7680379748344421,
0.47587651014328003,
0.2843930721282959,
0.04198956862092018,
0.3296927511692047,
-0.8572325110435486,
-0.7476447224617004,
0.4820239543914795,
-0.6053000688552856,
-0.2186414897441864,
0.11639111489057541,
0.48519280552864075,
0.6775809526443481,
-0.21622666716575623,
0.3188909888267517,
-0.16204001009464264,
-0.6956896781921387,
0.003930683713406324,
-0.048284709453582764,
0.5487480759620667,
-0.15407459437847137,
-0.38215014338493347,
0.22187595069408417,
-0.38872790336608887,
-0.40318769216537476,
0.13070233166217804,
-0.040240395814180374,
-0.059102803468704224,
0.09400200098752975,
-0.6634950041770935,
-0.1680736094713211,
0.4076486825942993,
-0.36271899938583374,
0.6131733655929565,
-0.7667105197906494,
-0.07750386744737625,
0.46888136863708496,
0.053435392677783966,
0.5984212160110474,
-0.6819766759872437,
0.6354646682739258,
-0.4045052230358124,
0.27989405393600464,
0.17094877362251282,
-0.6639474630355835,
-0.766816258430481,
-0.5015698671340942,
-0.4621254503726959,
0.6148979067802429,
-0.7840529680252075,
0.36741864681243896,
-0.1089877337217331,
-0.7286498546600342,
-0.6402300000190735,
-0.05725599080324173,
0.2505338490009308,
0.6036553978919983,
0.2935500741004944,
-0.15835219621658325,
-0.521450400352478,
-0.793601930141449,
-0.040534473955631256,
-0.3258878290653229,
-0.24168330430984497,
0.7906035780906677,
0.22018609941005707,
-0.40940847992897034,
0.301342248916626,
-0.4886123538017273,
-0.5114116072654724,
-0.25764375925064087,
0.1393027901649475,
0.7533218860626221,
0.5163587927818298,
0.5001941323280334,
-0.7322381734848022,
0.27360162138938904,
0.28008803725242615,
-1.0295677185058594,
0.052275627851486206,
-0.22657853364944458,
-0.25359898805618286,
0.34198957681655884,
0.6061586737632751,
-0.9839675426483154,
0.4933255612850189,
0.23254752159118652,
-0.1623329073190689,
0.3029116690158844,
-0.5736584663391113,
0.28639712929725647,
-0.8550176620483398,
0.07716347277164459,
-0.020634500309824944,
0.022305157035589218,
-0.34317606687545776,
0.22453980147838593,
0.008504576981067657,
-0.03972942754626274,
-0.15029072761535645,
0.5620681643486023,
-0.4862667918205261,
-0.2040475457906723,
-0.40785980224609375,
-0.008932078257203102,
0.04716207832098007,
0.27622777223587036,
0.35345521569252014,
0.6585469841957092,
0.411923885345459,
-0.8265759348869324,
0.562158465385437,
0.28549790382385254,
-0.16810673475265503,
0.3798280656337738,
-0.6000134348869324,
0.40094703435897827,
0.21255256235599518,
0.258555144071579,
-0.5137943625450134,
-0.21169111132621765,
0.2684965431690216,
-0.6369686126708984,
0.4626222848892212,
-0.07946158200502396,
-0.33770978450775146,
-0.5952340960502625,
-0.15601254999637604,
0.1212865337729454,
0.7302377820014954,
-0.5148254632949829,
1.3316646814346313,
0.5849962830543518,
-0.256098210811615,
-0.5771557688713074,
-0.26516449451446533,
0.15976229310035706,
0.014239956624805927,
-0.5541836023330688,
0.17669761180877686,
0.05756783112883568,
-0.24742738902568817,
-0.10685554891824722,
-0.24905039370059967,
-0.18327739834785461,
0.34234854578971863,
0.06418649852275848,
0.4786073565483093,
-0.19694291055202484,
0.26176390051841736,
0.5167311429977417,
-0.251560240983963,
0.40769410133361816,
-0.661934494972229,
0.562311589717865,
0.16840046644210815,
-0.5764296650886536,
-0.7845513820648193,
0.1831781417131424,
0.7297404408454895,
-0.17440269887447357,
0.26212531328201294,
0.5527151823043823,
-0.42831382155418396,
-0.17520862817764282,
-0.5094398856163025,
-0.7201859951019287,
-0.5296801328659058,
0.5001171827316284,
-0.2211562842130661,
-0.5926251411437988,
0.4039894640445709,
-0.12791898846626282,
0.03673028573393822,
0.0915934219956398,
0.5915511846542358,
-0.5197377800941467,
1.404184103012085,
0.6586443781852722,
0.06609595566987991,
0.15034635365009308,
-0.30770620703697205,
0.177598774433136,
-0.7701589465141296,
-0.5097024440765381,
-0.45891430974006653,
-0.3561543822288513,
-0.5037716627120972,
-0.6177084445953369,
0.8844122290611267,
-0.4196684956550598,
-0.34154993295669556,
0.02574714459478855,
-0.7677985429763794,
0.1550649106502533,
0.6751376986503601,
0.4507778584957123,
0.09157467633485794,
-0.4141004681587219,
-0.02082730084657669,
0.48339760303497314,
-0.6185569763183594,
-0.6216368079185486,
0.8034040927886963,
0.049065329134464264,
0.8634510040283203,
-0.13099166750907898,
0.6468915939331055,
0.1746940165758133,
-0.2542203366756439,
-0.9280911087989807,
0.8210644721984863,
-0.33006560802459717,
-0.2568618655204773,
-0.2929936647415161,
-0.06111564114689827,
-1.0719956159591675,
-0.020403854548931122,
-0.06488052755594254,
-0.4102562665939331,
0.17763656377792358,
0.30334708094596863,
-0.6445316076278687,
0.48507216572761536,
-0.13093754649162292,
0.10525979101657867,
-0.40494585037231445,
-0.286910742521286,
-0.5204145908355713,
-0.7088164687156677,
0.030153699219226837,
-0.01548447273671627,
0.0967675969004631,
-0.10487806051969528,
-0.5765403509140015,
0.6072186827659607,
-0.3209029734134674,
0.8571561574935913,
-0.4965636134147644,
-0.34713563323020935,
0.09061340242624283,
0.4029187560081482,
0.34004855155944824,
0.1258193850517273,
-0.07224740087985992,
0.1497814655303955,
-0.543742835521698,
0.0008963319123722613,
-0.7261203527450562,
0.2586761713027954,
-0.49614375829696655,
-0.7144573330879211,
-0.08441983908414841,
-0.8047521710395813,
-0.27663686871528625,
0.12011945247650146,
-0.23404482007026672,
0.442383348941803,
-0.0009655350586399436,
-0.012872160412371159,
0.7521675229072571,
-0.25116467475891113,
0.2228633612394333,
0.43152788281440735,
0.08330436795949936,
-0.07743555307388306,
0.7476820349693298,
0.06085014343261719,
-0.19588786363601685,
0.545387327671051,
0.3216482102870941,
-0.5429337024688721,
-0.5996386408805847,
-0.8852763175964355,
0.40775224566459656,
-0.4943797290325165,
-0.20279338955879211,
-0.8419913649559021,
-0.08888477832078934,
-0.41323646903038025,
-0.5892943739891052,
-0.47550198435783386,
-0.15097194910049438,
-0.46373802423477173,
0.003636059118434787,
0.4907199442386627,
1.00052809715271,
-0.12071971595287323,
-0.05782567709684372,
-1.0861867666244507,
0.6372571587562561,
0.4192231595516205,
0.193320631980896,
-0.1733950674533844,
-0.37780725955963135,
-0.1122601255774498,
0.03653036430478096,
0.1133539155125618,
-0.5534054040908813,
0.37911027669906616,
-0.06715895235538483,
0.6813759803771973,
0.6552259922027588,
0.03683948516845703,
0.6091821193695068,
-0.22320996224880219,
0.47388654947280884,
-0.0541672557592392,
-0.7531943321228027,
0.5140981078147888,
-0.5776958465576172,
0.36676985025405884,
0.2949478030204773,
0.3884965181350708,
-0.2097311168909073,
-0.5676438808441162,
-0.31970036029815674,
-0.740304708480835,
0.5391777157783508,
-0.32158780097961426,
0.1213872879743576,
0.24176651239395142,
0.5522623062133789,
0.16827642917633057,
0.3578011393547058,
-0.08201418071985245,
0.2262697070837021,
0.05946585536003113,
-0.26693159341812134,
0.22860468924045563,
0.1301621049642563,
-0.2178233563899994,
-0.4414721727371216,
0.7310453653335571,
-0.4853435754776001,
0.5991242527961731,
0.20517894625663757,
0.11125124990940094,
-0.00625812541693449,
-0.4182312786579132,
0.7082387804985046,
0.35294389724731445,
0.03861076757311821,
-0.20078237354755402,
0.16513937711715698,
-0.8285388350486755,
-0.011607637628912926,
0.09297407418489456,
0.18163685500621796,
-0.21891902387142181,
0.4423341751098633,
0.5045729279518127,
0.07863026112318039,
-0.8362595438957214,
0.31259724497795105,
-0.06652624160051346,
-0.3349561095237732,
-0.27377504110336304,
0.436260849237442,
0.32641103863716125,
0.5749425292015076,
0.36842212080955505,
0.1517893224954605,
0.5037403106689453,
-0.1557047814130783,
0.08328548818826675,
0.43457290530204773,
-0.42563101649284363,
-0.03734571859240532,
0.5597550272941589,
0.34078794717788696,
-0.30869996547698975,
0.7851126790046692,
-0.11950023472309113,
-0.38857826590538025,
0.9810072779655457,
0.17511172592639923,
0.7375706434249878,
-0.5298650860786438,
-0.05402619019150734,
0.17437231540679932,
0.6117992997169495,
0.2546199858188629,
0.7168528437614441,
-0.3606266975402832,
-0.78512042760849,
-0.4747573137283325,
-0.2456200271844864,
-0.6914496421813965,
-0.20789313316345215,
-0.5919411182403564,
0.2854365408420563,
-0.6343345046043396,
0.20676080882549286,
-0.21032381057739258,
-0.13833753764629364,
-0.4122340679168701,
0.4605337977409363,
0.39895209670066833,
0.6070268154144287,
-0.18174591660499573,
0.6908979415893555,
0.9872980117797852,
-0.10483067482709885,
-0.9574311375617981,
-0.19042962789535522,
-0.015432849526405334,
-1.465888261795044,
0.3313590884208679,
0.21564804017543793,
-0.9807316064834595,
-0.15777024626731873,
-0.4964759051799774,
-0.820353090763092,
0.9245710968971252,
0.4218813478946686,
-0.6351178884506226,
-0.07375603169202805,
-0.13471713662147522,
0.5093411803245544,
-0.3069028854370117,
0.15349149703979492,
0.4857141077518463,
0.5791159868240356,
0.11307810992002487,
-1.0850465297698975,
0.012502077035605907,
-0.36515623331069946,
-0.5320267081260681,
0.4984658360481262,
-0.29798439145088196,
0.5084854960441589,
-0.7459480166435242,
-0.014206238090991974,
0.30293095111846924,
0.47954046726226807,
0.28003913164138794,
0.45050734281539917,
0.6243088841438293,
0.5985842347145081,
0.9304270148277283,
0.027566490694880486,
1.1617003679275513,
-0.6207112669944763,
-0.32859277725219727,
0.6675912141799927,
-0.5162636637687683,
0.3061932325363159,
0.05962906405329704,
0.29508936405181885,
0.4202570915222168,
0.3864533007144928,
0.07325553894042969,
0.12445914000272751,
-0.18910296261310577,
-0.4826986789703369,
-0.5285952687263489,
-0.29456478357315063,
-0.23287461698055267,
1.0719019174575806,
0.7341872453689575,
-0.2135317623615265,
0.2568229138851166,
0.4933709502220154,
0.011048300191760063,
0.04485299438238144,
-0.6074907779693604,
1.1580508947372437,
-0.10719427466392517,
-0.48089465498924255,
0.5306429266929626,
-0.43214648962020874,
0.42649248242378235,
-0.5785740613937378,
-0.3727436363697052,
-0.0038542000111192465,
0.10890445113182068,
-0.10903605818748474,
-0.9255018830299377,
0.26463156938552856,
-0.4194192588329315,
0.20519056916236877,
-0.25145286321640015,
0.8017057180404663,
0.15121538937091827,
-0.3661269247531891,
0.5198286175727844,
0.6860935091972351,
0.22664490342140198,
-0.10897043347358704,
-0.47647809982299805,
-0.1375793218612671,
-0.09449869394302368,
-0.0408940352499485,
0.054210759699344635,
0.2711833715438843,
0.0680932030081749,
0.9548959732055664,
0.4934958219528198,
0.005195308942347765,
-0.5060144066810608,
0.0633285716176033,
1.121474027633667,
-0.6839800477027893,
-0.438524067401886,
-0.5086722373962402,
0.3057522475719452,
0.06787931174039841,
-0.08446730673313141,
0.14658395946025848,
0.3493591845035553,
0.5831247568130493,
0.059422463178634644,
0.4815158247947693,
0.22652022540569305,
0.6390489339828491,
-0.45319536328315735,
1.1097861528396606,
-0.9533068537712097,
0.011159362271428108,
-0.0993926003575325,
-0.4052029550075531,
-0.3686012923717499,
0.958742618560791,
-0.023088529706001282,
0.4311007857322693,
0.4506572484970093,
0.8424277305603027,
0.0588805116713047,
0.1542980670928955,
0.44438719749450684,
0.24668852984905243,
0.11491768807172775,
0.38415035605430603,
0.7658675312995911,
0.11106321215629578,
0.06777971237897873,
-0.36899062991142273,
-0.3015052080154419,
-0.39189019799232483,
-0.5577095746994019,
-0.4737807512283325,
-0.4770124852657318,
-0.1491028517484665,
-0.07558484375476837,
0.13737578690052032,
0.9465141892433167,
1.0459991693496704,
-0.0334576852619648,
-0.3124735951423645,
0.13171808421611786,
0.07153847068548203,
-0.3120522201061249,
-0.0770212933421135,
0.2766033411026001,
0.10710351914167404,
-0.8111164569854736,
1.1501387357711792,
0.7070872783660889,
-0.020203538239002228,
-0.09980882704257965,
-0.11968212574720383,
0.08486991375684738,
0.22788852453231812,
0.3993006646633148,
0.20381346344947815,
-0.36969614028930664,
-0.22318759560585022,
0.2708563804626465,
-0.1280815750360489,
0.1613188534975052,
0.6418682336807251,
-1.1227374076843262,
0.5832792520523071,
0.11166377365589142,
0.7136320471763611,
0.1377703845500946,
-0.20009148120880127,
0.43325889110565186,
-0.013550766743719578,
0.23984654247760773,
1.0999599695205688,
0.5121180415153503,
0.006130356807261705,
-0.8963075876235962,
0.5444630980491638,
0.1343471258878708,
-0.5466489195823669,
-0.3744588792324066,
0.11281277239322662,
-1.1738065481185913,
-0.3935478925704956,
0.6162769198417664,
0.09999292343854904,
-0.4571368396282196,
-0.2534235417842865,
-0.3167208433151245,
0.46486786007881165,
-0.3594507873058319,
0.7123990058898926,
-0.24116040766239166,
-0.774677574634552,
-0.016821933910250664,
-0.202614426612854,
0.15654420852661133,
0.4040864109992981,
-0.8760173320770264,
-0.4348594546318054,
0.4523738622665405,
-0.13330309092998505,
0.2423979789018631,
0.699927568435669,
-0.2511451542377472,
0.8590577244758606,
0.06590499728918076,
0.41726356744766235,
-0.33547163009643555,
-0.5267102718353271,
-0.22367294132709503,
0.10307316482067108,
-0.16316886246204376,
-0.30342555046081543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00449v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00449v1
|
RAG-based Explainable Prediction of Road Users Behaviors for Automated Driving using Knowledge Graphs and Large Language Models
| 2024-05-01T11:06:31 | 2024-05-01T11:06:31 |
Mohamed Manzour Hussien, Angie Nataly Melo, Augusto Luis Ballardini, Carlota Salinas Maldonado, Rubén Izquierdo, Miguel Ángel Sotelo
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.NE
|
Prediction of road users' behaviors in the context of autonomous driving has
gained considerable attention by the scientific community in the last years.
Most works focus on predicting behaviors based on kinematic information alone,
a simplification of the reality since road users are humans, and as such they
are highly influenced by their surrounding context. In addition, a large
plethora of research works rely on powerful Deep Learning techniques, which
exhibit high performance metrics in prediction tasks but may lack the ability
to fully understand and exploit the contextual semantic information contained
in the road scene, not to mention their inability to provide explainable
predictions that can be understood by humans. In this work, we propose an
explainable road users' behavior prediction system that integrates the
reasoning abilities of Knowledge Graphs (KG) and the expressiveness
capabilities of Large Language Models (LLM) by using Retrieval Augmented
Generation (RAG) techniques. For that purpose, Knowledge Graph Embeddings (KGE)
and Bayesian inference are combined to allow the deployment of a fully
inductive reasoning system that enables the issuing of predictions that rely on
legacy information contained in the graph as well as on current evidence
gathered in real time by onboard sensors. Two use cases have been implemented
following the proposed approach: 1) Prediction of pedestrians' crossing
actions; 2) Prediction of lane change maneuvers. In both cases, the performance
attained surpasses the current state of the art in terms of anticipation and
F1-score, showing a promising avenue for future research in this field.
|
[
-0.5207234621047974,
-0.843358039855957,
1.0719282627105713,
0.06570753455162048,
-0.14511284232139587,
-0.01171772088855505,
-0.024453055113554,
-0.6595779657363892,
0.2540760934352875,
0.5057120323181152,
-0.6860851645469666,
-0.2423323392868042,
-0.40675950050354004,
-0.22100326418876648,
-0.48551997542381287,
0.6351538300514221,
-0.12222348153591156,
-0.08970587700605392,
-0.39917898178100586,
-0.013345710933208466,
-0.5040906071662903,
-0.1739410161972046,
-0.3501216769218445,
-0.4505825340747833,
0.7062028646469116,
0.16549836099147797,
0.7412228584289551,
0.45962202548980713,
0.2006344050168991,
0.3479171693325043,
0.1032327339053154,
0.26936662197113037,
-0.023729536682367325,
0.14315448701381683,
-0.31547701358795166,
0.23479020595550537,
-0.38117897510528564,
-0.20800328254699707,
0.5534378886222839,
0.8487871885299683,
-0.08223102986812592,
-0.2993883192539215,
-0.04963941127061844,
0.5350496172904968,
-0.6888742446899414,
0.24530243873596191,
-0.441186785697937,
-0.2787438631057739,
-0.07817631214857101,
-0.27298808097839355,
-0.2634866535663605,
-0.26354271173477173,
0.14552326500415802,
-0.6812291741371155,
-0.14828304946422577,
0.0731215849518776,
0.43122929334640503,
0.3075312674045563,
-0.607204794883728,
-0.4199952781200409,
-0.8141958117485046,
0.5152372717857361,
-0.6157787442207336,
0.5252615809440613,
0.4634271562099457,
0.6522769927978516,
-0.40103504061698914,
-0.29880020022392273,
-0.8939399123191833,
-0.22516408562660217,
-0.339349627494812,
0.30648380517959595,
0.0382261723279953,
0.06124507635831833,
0.15304824709892273,
-0.251926988363266,
-0.718536913394928,
0.2113960087299347,
-0.08367829769849777,
0.04630096256732941,
0.8773134350776672,
0.4659446179866791,
-0.018275989219546318,
-0.06036582216620445,
-0.5689502954483032,
0.04145750403404236,
-0.47660917043685913,
0.4245237708091736,
0.10333342105150223,
0.16088169813156128,
-0.1370595246553421,
0.45099297165870667,
-0.5562880635261536,
0.8658463358879089,
0.03455216437578201,
-0.15858317911624908,
0.44940996170043945,
0.03814549371600151,
-0.2011840045452118,
-0.15576781332492828,
0.9186469316482544,
0.48157966136932373,
0.46128979325294495,
-0.5560882091522217,
-0.19798393547534943,
-0.01763879880309105,
0.09269607067108154,
-0.6038976907730103,
-0.11460195481777191,
0.08025071024894714,
-0.2067221850156784,
-0.32992419600486755,
0.2517401874065399,
-1.0350794792175293,
-0.7640191316604614,
-0.5841955542564392,
0.31273433566093445,
-0.490692138671875,
-0.48426297307014465,
0.08646799623966217,
0.0584382563829422,
0.38233762979507446,
0.7266188859939575,
-0.6972300410270691,
0.2281208038330078,
0.5006307363510132,
0.5313698053359985,
-0.3500056862831116,
-0.3823513388633728,
-0.3689221441745758,
0.47395193576812744,
-0.0542333647608757,
0.9732398986816406,
-0.47464945912361145,
-0.29566729068756104,
-0.10243569314479828,
0.02535872533917427,
-0.0966407060623169,
-0.23311682045459747,
0.44294679164886475,
-0.6201851963996887,
-0.14071214199066162,
0.0754057765007019,
-0.5288119316101074,
-0.5999289155006409,
0.08018168061971664,
-0.5654312968254089,
0.6357755064964294,
0.16456057131290436,
-0.6270018219947815,
0.2645704448223114,
-0.7150229215621948,
-0.9089732766151428,
0.12709376215934753,
0.014832152053713799,
-0.49668481945991516,
-0.039436835795640945,
0.3316570222377777,
0.5652133226394653,
-0.15356899797916412,
0.6216009259223938,
-0.4270738959312439,
-0.12922343611717224,
0.6130886673927307,
-0.3079415261745453,
0.7741583585739136,
0.12320327758789062,
-0.26896682381629944,
0.23703612387180328,
-0.5159692168235779,
-0.09120166301727295,
0.02403111383318901,
-0.10110500454902649,
-0.28317537903785706,
0.11638179421424866,
-0.11532097309827805,
0.3370242714881897,
0.1394510567188263,
-0.496233731508255,
-0.17555153369903564,
-0.36883753538131714,
-0.06164681911468506,
1.084885597229004,
0.014303205534815788,
0.48607125878334045,
-0.26261386275291443,
0.7055689096450806,
0.14255186915397644,
0.020352039486169815,
0.02200113609433174,
-0.7449116110801697,
-0.42563289403915405,
0.28701087832450867,
0.07827620208263397,
0.5844864845275879,
-0.6840817332267761,
0.22632063925266266,
-0.3769165277481079,
-0.49284303188323975,
-0.258620947599411,
0.05957205221056938,
0.2860216200351715,
0.7399677634239197,
0.23563730716705322,
0.005638131406158209,
-0.3192311227321625,
-0.33387038111686707,
-0.3327407240867615,
-0.3228718340396881,
-0.015610998496413231,
0.6426822543144226,
0.3987267315387726,
-0.4128704369068146,
1.1119883060455322,
-0.4887290298938751,
0.01882409304380417,
-0.42657867074012756,
0.21579399704933167,
-0.09686766564846039,
0.429329514503479,
0.2902367115020752,
-1.0723462104797363,
-0.3523305356502533,
0.125740185379982,
-0.5910691022872925,
-0.09219364076852798,
-0.15929122269153595,
-0.09690772742033005,
0.2694331705570221,
0.522901177406311,
-0.4967990517616272,
0.7334463596343994,
0.5773728489875793,
-0.8060464262962341,
0.5667549967765808,
-0.2582376003265381,
-0.061853472143411636,
-0.7193071246147156,
-0.06767354905605316,
0.14919045567512512,
-0.5343025326728821,
-0.6123325228691101,
-0.28968003392219543,
-0.15436868369579315,
0.10563631355762482,
0.01777256466448307,
0.7280242443084717,
-0.04702024906873703,
-0.5251581072807312,
-0.3433557152748108,
0.19630242884159088,
-0.29359397292137146,
0.4171472489833832,
0.1516663283109665,
0.47862327098846436,
0.5157880187034607,
-0.8324962854385376,
0.2115619033575058,
0.013503863476216793,
-0.540690541267395,
0.2699851989746094,
-0.39865225553512573,
-0.2573840320110321,
-0.36311572790145874,
0.23795224726200104,
-1.0137357711791992,
-0.5043781399726868,
0.07715241611003876,
-0.9075653553009033,
0.0799255520105362,
-0.14017677307128906,
-0.47414615750312805,
-0.22846728563308716,
0.41462036967277527,
0.21576228737831116,
0.7183718681335449,
-0.45843037962913513,
0.981275200843811,
0.8468040823936462,
-0.03395312279462814,
-0.11531875282526016,
-0.37564417719841003,
-0.04713795706629753,
-0.4821794927120209,
-0.7800872325897217,
0.23574139177799225,
-0.1150878295302391,
-0.3097850978374481,
0.029485609382390976,
0.20645318925380707,
-0.23915371298789978,
0.4597419500350952,
0.640206515789032,
0.4065459370613098,
0.13804946839809418,
0.251071035861969,
-0.058794084936380386,
-0.4606519639492035,
0.3226695954799652,
-0.08781622350215912,
0.4007267355918884,
0.05262429639697075,
-0.05974751338362694,
-0.4902360439300537,
0.07690095156431198,
0.6267525553703308,
-0.35303938388824463,
0.4603177309036255,
0.8562038540840149,
-0.1516176462173462,
-0.03787236288189888,
-0.1987147480249405,
-0.20766502618789673,
-0.49373772740364075,
0.1652863472700119,
-0.36110764741897583,
-0.7800418734550476,
0.3531194031238556,
-0.48051032423973083,
-0.27005141973495483,
0.36820465326309204,
0.538655161857605,
-0.7048582434654236,
1.404990315437317,
0.4687829315662384,
0.13508100807666779,
0.4074315130710602,
0.002278763335198164,
0.14368347823619843,
-0.6010740995407104,
-0.46004727482795715,
-0.1345600187778473,
-0.26622822880744934,
-1.03655207157135,
-0.4258464276790619,
0.6032872796058655,
-0.22337263822555542,
-0.3306533992290497,
0.0762891173362732,
-0.045970555394887924,
0.22461114823818207,
0.3816046416759491,
0.09852536022663116,
0.1688554584980011,
-0.13459770381450653,
-0.009773935191333294,
0.357250839471817,
-0.5328329801559448,
-0.11068544536828995,
0.8439626097679138,
0.20256495475769043,
0.8810584545135498,
0.15674066543579102,
0.38729244470596313,
0.25559574365615845,
0.3026868402957916,
-0.8082959651947021,
0.6978502869606018,
-0.14288555085659027,
-0.31039515137672424,
-0.41463786363601685,
-0.8277668952941895,
-1.1220612525939941,
-0.05238119512796402,
-0.4059962034225464,
-0.758777916431427,
-0.09730258584022522,
0.21378251910209656,
-0.29823678731918335,
0.22956065833568573,
-0.24296900629997253,
0.9499632120132446,
-0.5492345690727234,
-0.2625414729118347,
-0.3556996285915375,
-0.8249501585960388,
0.23993262648582458,
0.20238161087036133,
0.6757080554962158,
-0.31114256381988525,
0.20645229518413544,
0.6508508920669556,
-0.18591143190860748,
0.7874559760093689,
-0.6626224517822266,
0.1891952008008957,
0.15089015662670135,
0.1315370500087738,
0.6582820415496826,
-0.25522512197494507,
-0.011055677197873592,
-0.071662038564682,
-0.4536982476711273,
0.07874283194541931,
-0.9405207633972168,
0.5907585024833679,
-0.4651246666908264,
-0.35899293422698975,
-0.11979172378778458,
-0.7697391510009766,
-0.3976909816265106,
0.10598581284284592,
-0.00478519918397069,
0.5258384943008423,
0.20663200318813324,
-0.29102709889411926,
0.5357248783111572,
-0.18785177171230316,
0.22962884604930878,
0.5990809798240662,
-0.5449265241622925,
-0.20110361278057098,
1.0641610622406006,
-0.033992186188697815,
0.09450701624155045,
0.3689603805541992,
0.6198951601982117,
-0.5269120931625366,
-0.5346174836158752,
-0.5416887998580933,
0.2613650858402252,
-0.4274229109287262,
0.012411476112902164,
-0.6016026139259338,
0.082746222615242,
-0.5174770355224609,
-0.2864131033420563,
-0.06298612058162689,
-0.599747896194458,
0.03800635039806366,
-0.08303292840719223,
0.40046611428260803,
1.0840034484863281,
-0.1576271802186966,
0.5332548022270203,
-0.2822589874267578,
0.44456422328948975,
0.45070481300354004,
0.44946199655532837,
0.07562414556741714,
-0.3893321454524994,
-0.3756994903087616,
-0.07779916375875473,
-0.12564076483249664,
-0.7682434320449829,
0.400656521320343,
-0.3335551619529724,
0.6212472915649414,
0.4554003179073334,
0.23762664198875427,
0.5767602920532227,
-0.21022236347198486,
0.17887695133686066,
0.2185206562280655,
-0.5234432220458984,
0.5567643046379089,
-0.4324319362640381,
0.10274963825941086,
0.31025034189224243,
0.35373634099960327,
-0.3391563594341278,
-0.4409831166267395,
-0.44748544692993164,
-0.7966145277023315,
0.45863449573516846,
0.16374795138835907,
-0.2729392349720001,
0.2867985665798187,
0.17732080817222595,
0.16463495790958405,
-0.07815486937761307,
-0.6329352259635925,
-0.04587901756167412,
-0.10265517979860306,
-0.4047980308532715,
-0.2605520188808441,
-0.07678753137588501,
0.36966443061828613,
-0.5110515356063843,
0.5778682827949524,
-0.21993882954120636,
0.18038566410541534,
-0.020608488470315933,
-0.02114996500313282,
-0.1057484969496727,
0.056927889585494995,
0.48981136083602905,
0.7954197525978088,
-0.3465591073036194,
0.17241805791854858,
0.026116712018847466,
-0.18088507652282715,
0.056827958673238754,
0.1582254022359848,
-0.46148720383644104,
-0.05339999869465828,
0.10210268199443817,
0.6131606698036194,
0.05463194102048874,
-0.9024336934089661,
0.474905401468277,
0.09673760086297989,
0.05556609854102135,
-0.9478352069854736,
0.2094772756099701,
0.023985812440514565,
0.28077903389930725,
0.10844672471284866,
0.1185675784945488,
0.32341909408569336,
-0.30096057057380676,
0.0512324795126915,
0.45183509588241577,
-0.7644702196121216,
-0.3237106204032898,
0.6959220767021179,
0.15236935019493103,
-0.016384316608309746,
0.29698625206947327,
-0.47513657808303833,
-0.6551348567008972,
0.5857545137405396,
0.2619156539440155,
0.8567366600036621,
-0.32051101326942444,
0.17254377901554108,
0.5614725351333618,
-0.000021532041500904597,
0.14376898109912872,
0.05012194439768791,
-0.10078231990337372,
-0.950480043888092,
-0.5427677035331726,
-0.7148858308792114,
-0.31248918175697327,
-0.06776104867458344,
-0.46987229585647583,
0.007285646162927151,
-0.29035329818725586,
-0.0691724643111229,
0.14629271626472473,
-0.22020602226257324,
-0.4994640648365021,
0.39321431517601013,
0.16620756685733795,
0.792628288269043,
-0.8427985310554504,
0.8020904064178467,
0.7678159475326538,
-0.23730197548866272,
-0.5527768731117249,
0.22689490020275116,
0.011323717422783375,
-0.6549995541572571,
0.6874346733093262,
0.36522164940834045,
-0.35832110047340393,
-0.13093198835849762,
-0.2879689931869507,
-0.6654253602027893,
1.1528431177139282,
0.07699716091156006,
-0.20466852188110352,
-0.14516949653625488,
0.15316101908683777,
0.14031171798706055,
-0.4683360159397125,
-0.07185464352369308,
0.5993393063545227,
0.7550843358039856,
0.3459767699241638,
-0.6211963295936584,
0.13702857494354248,
0.08199512958526611,
-0.012826086953282356,
0.22294501960277557,
-0.16224974393844604,
0.7824281454086304,
-0.3397926688194275,
-0.08565211296081543,
0.19563326239585876,
0.6382878422737122,
0.37101611495018005,
0.7518704533576965,
0.9776777625083923,
0.6572616696357727,
0.6784437894821167,
0.07004304230213165,
1.2336969375610352,
-0.0904368981719017,
0.07606802880764008,
1.1357570886611938,
-0.09142381697893143,
0.6448464393615723,
0.3436688482761383,
-0.10434279590845108,
0.9761740565299988,
0.254056841135025,
0.31974703073501587,
0.7466672658920288,
-0.04301372542977333,
-0.2732487618923187,
-0.7174108028411865,
-0.019962824881076813,
0.22219400107860565,
0.9192519783973694,
0.5167083740234375,
-0.2533766031265259,
-0.1856876015663147,
0.02068309113383293,
-0.12917013466358185,
0.051766928285360336,
-0.5239664912223816,
1.1089985370635986,
-0.33874139189720154,
-0.8522053360939026,
0.041644688695669174,
-0.005281229503452778,
0.3256760239601135,
-0.3986961543560028,
-0.21851249039173126,
0.17942847311496735,
0.2449883073568344,
-0.1637500375509262,
-1.3453444242477417,
0.2659273147583008,
-0.15371325612068176,
-0.1484304517507553,
-0.42119231820106506,
0.8871184587478638,
-0.31924834847450256,
-0.5933597683906555,
0.42659828066825867,
0.4609583616256714,
0.25174757838249207,
0.01820969767868519,
-0.40904831886291504,
-0.2829768657684326,
0.08686628192663193,
-0.09821488708257675,
0.3245905637741089,
0.5915889739990234,
-0.12727616727352142,
0.997331976890564,
0.5936211943626404,
-0.0017386568943038583,
-0.1478203684091568,
-0.251290887594223,
1.0034505128860474,
-0.7599427700042725,
-0.5756664872169495,
-0.8067907094955444,
0.7779242396354675,
0.04312087967991829,
-0.04208485782146454,
0.6458965539932251,
0.37085604667663574,
0.44629642367362976,
0.23266196250915527,
1.0286287069320679,
-0.11061467230319977,
0.9083289504051208,
-0.6607824563980103,
0.5233141183853149,
-0.5660408139228821,
0.12107521295547485,
-0.23293811082839966,
-0.3280419409275055,
0.12059148401021957,
0.8274987936019897,
-0.46914878487586975,
0.2951091229915619,
0.026241669431328773,
0.5953786969184875,
-0.2927194833755493,
-0.08753444254398346,
0.27780723571777344,
0.3276982009410858,
0.2667730450630188,
0.5901842713356018,
0.7991394400596619,
0.23056748509407043,
0.40932321548461914,
-0.4731909930706024,
-0.34298253059387207,
-0.5508890151977539,
-0.7690210938453674,
-0.5932691097259521,
-0.7323644161224365,
0.019236672669649124,
-0.2518788278102875,
-0.11352937668561935,
0.34285768866539,
0.6333462595939636,
-0.6010990142822266,
-0.288320928812027,
-0.47147297859191895,
0.40914320945739746,
-0.04314061999320984,
-0.31601086258888245,
0.23827020823955536,
-0.30582624673843384,
-0.25568607449531555,
0.4198760986328125,
0.22150833904743195,
0.22418683767318726,
-0.4192237854003906,
-0.5960395932197571,
-0.02850158140063286,
-0.21040089428424835,
0.53925621509552,
0.2401992827653885,
-0.6106532216072083,
-0.14273197948932648,
-0.16923631727695465,
0.09515919536352158,
-0.2675403952598572,
0.7363452911376953,
-1.3425863981246948,
0.48456963896751404,
0.4023137390613556,
0.3619067370891571,
0.677475094795227,
0.2536962926387787,
0.7355468273162842,
-0.2340897023677826,
-0.05702032148838043,
0.31845757365226746,
0.33605653047561646,
0.28643348813056946,
-0.1928112655878067,
0.5959933400154114,
0.14532774686813354,
-0.6734858155250549,
-0.3629337549209595,
0.4684460461139679,
-1.0781545639038086,
-0.48455777764320374,
1.1207789182662964,
-0.18068283796310425,
-0.34119921922683716,
-0.4247680902481079,
0.14364711940288544,
0.20682744681835175,
-0.40939396619796753,
0.7947008609771729,
-0.014191627502441406,
-0.49006521701812744,
-0.3839094340801239,
-0.7287493348121643,
0.48829880356788635,
0.09646719694137573,
-0.9203215837478638,
0.41620779037475586,
0.6814406514167786,
0.05499260500073433,
-0.09664055705070496,
0.3993281126022339,
0.29228007793426514,
0.5468282699584961,
-0.4395756721496582,
-0.2924635410308838,
-0.25802159309387207,
-0.4445194602012634,
0.07195594161748886,
-0.0797877162694931,
-0.06969798356294632,
0.2635601758956909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00438v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00438v1
|
MetaRM: Shifted Distributions Alignment via Meta-Learning
| 2024-05-01T10:43:55 | 2024-05-01T10:43:55 |
Shihan Dou, Yan Liu, Enyu Zhou, Tianlong Li, Haoxiang Jia, Limao Xiong, Xin Zhao, Junjie Ye, Rui Zheng, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The success of Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) in language
model alignment is critically dependent on the capability of the reward model
(RM). However, as the training process progresses, the output distribution of
the policy model shifts, leading to the RM's reduced ability to distinguish
between responses. This issue is further compounded when the RM, trained on a
specific data distribution, struggles to generalize to examples outside of that
distribution. These two issues can be united as a challenge posed by the
shifted distribution of the environment. To surmount this challenge, we
introduce MetaRM, a method leveraging meta-learning to align the RM with the
shifted environment distribution. MetaRM is designed to train the RM by
minimizing data loss, particularly for data that can improve the
differentiation ability to examples of the shifted target distribution.
Extensive experiments demonstrate that MetaRM significantly improves the RM's
distinguishing ability in iterative RLHF optimization, and also provides the
capacity to identify subtle differences in out-of-distribution samples.
|
[
-0.2660904824733734,
-0.3051656186580658,
0.24933329224586487,
-0.09558431059122086,
-0.13532482087612152,
-0.030398709699511528,
-0.28843000531196594,
0.013160043396055698,
0.09485256671905518,
0.43240517377853394,
-1.0302038192749023,
-0.36310476064682007,
-0.6372354030609131,
-0.058590251952409744,
0.060787830501794815,
1.2001214027404785,
-0.06767961382865906,
-0.034806035459041595,
-0.3007873296737671,
-0.31145408749580383,
-0.3965757489204407,
-0.3656264543533325,
-0.33499106764793396,
-0.7512111663818359,
0.7306829690933228,
0.4628535509109497,
0.7508631944656372,
1.0246844291687012,
0.7707265615463257,
0.21703524887561798,
0.20588113367557526,
0.015429344028234482,
-0.5675909519195557,
0.20626115798950195,
-0.4516938030719757,
-0.1896158903837204,
-0.07209429889917374,
0.06995543092489243,
0.6875430941581726,
0.5092687010765076,
-0.627506673336029,
0.3335684537887573,
0.176338329911232,
0.8448425531387329,
-1.1526451110839844,
0.1359080970287323,
-0.31816115975379944,
0.15488967299461365,
-0.19416360557079315,
-0.2946711480617523,
-0.5135238170623779,
-0.3601800501346588,
0.07492675632238388,
-0.5478950142860413,
0.11027154326438904,
-0.07121102511882782,
0.7133535146713257,
0.6908116340637207,
-0.5116512775421143,
-0.15335360169410706,
-1.0507197380065918,
0.885292112827301,
-0.32636111974716187,
0.6005797982215881,
0.277031272649765,
0.6237168312072754,
0.05508992820978165,
-0.3592189848423004,
-0.3071646988391876,
0.07883427292108536,
-0.023555323481559753,
0.08133102208375931,
0.1533389836549759,
-0.1500878483057022,
0.054363004863262177,
0.007722567766904831,
-0.4595796465873718,
-0.046673718839883804,
-0.3192071318626404,
-0.27575385570526123,
0.6440081000328064,
0.4380577504634857,
0.17469522356987,
-0.04906005039811134,
-0.28602591156959534,
-1.0014411211013794,
-0.6425641775131226,
0.08330168575048447,
0.46262070536613464,
0.44549083709716797,
0.15000154078006744,
0.3767370879650116,
0.08520179986953735,
0.6574715375900269,
-0.021058857440948486,
-0.35239946842193604,
0.43582800030708313,
0.0665656328201294,
-0.25549355149269104,
0.10021353513002396,
0.7279221415519714,
0.2752123475074768,
-0.3281533122062683,
0.10974471271038055,
-0.3493518531322479,
-0.12968246638774872,
0.4266972839832306,
-0.5642616152763367,
-0.2897520661354065,
-0.18806937336921692,
-0.5916720032691956,
-0.3567356467247009,
0.37988218665122986,
-0.8799386620521545,
-0.4456040859222412,
-0.22088995575904846,
0.407843679189682,
-0.13296739757061005,
-0.594214677810669,
0.052669018507003784,
-0.3009624481201172,
0.2596881687641144,
-0.00924480240792036,
-1.2758647203445435,
0.25195786356925964,
0.7546390295028687,
0.48685476183891296,
-0.3052087128162384,
-0.3299800455570221,
-0.7121517658233643,
0.43692925572395325,
-0.17654122412204742,
0.6288450956344604,
-0.8013585805892944,
-0.30073854327201843,
0.033268481492996216,
0.031464215368032455,
-0.44735187292099,
-0.8251743912696838,
0.5628674626350403,
-0.48109349608421326,
0.3250129520893097,
-0.4607395529747009,
-0.2580810785293579,
-0.1666327565908432,
0.3961867690086365,
-0.728752076625824,
1.0905441045761108,
0.3933514952659607,
-0.9152974486351013,
0.4178762435913086,
-0.7778552770614624,
-0.26009538769721985,
-0.2047284096479416,
0.011672167107462883,
-0.6449644565582275,
-0.022236565127968788,
0.012472888454794884,
0.056165970861911774,
0.013315117917954922,
0.10428198426961899,
-0.4628225266933441,
-0.14692825078964233,
0.33890214562416077,
-0.3050563633441925,
0.47443801164627075,
0.35448551177978516,
-0.39367368817329407,
0.19768324494361877,
-0.5663918256759644,
0.085472971200943,
-0.021452827379107475,
-0.5710620284080505,
-0.48528701066970825,
0.2534276247024536,
-0.01177322119474411,
0.34643301367759705,
-0.134616881608963,
-0.20120906829833984,
0.40024152398109436,
-0.18731838464736938,
0.38950610160827637,
0.8206803798675537,
-0.17547564208507538,
0.8888300657272339,
-0.2694246172904968,
0.8617996573448181,
0.0388762541115284,
0.24486719071865082,
0.29618775844573975,
0.05688159912824631,
-0.30961719155311584,
-0.3270769715309143,
0.5348269939422607,
0.8120020031929016,
-0.5696976780891418,
0.3661847710609436,
-0.2779320180416107,
-0.22733278572559357,
-0.7269064784049988,
0.15577679872512817,
0.3510444164276123,
0.6305704712867737,
0.4328240752220154,
-0.10386635363101959,
-0.49681586027145386,
-0.8491896390914917,
-0.36656755208969116,
-0.04543190449476242,
0.09854938834905624,
0.22887977957725525,
0.2957794666290283,
-0.7890053391456604,
0.9529494047164917,
-0.7021964192390442,
-0.14808432757854462,
-0.2771502435207367,
0.38039225339889526,
-0.09282413125038147,
0.48009631037712097,
0.23734433948993683,
-0.7612282633781433,
-0.341493159532547,
-0.08973145484924316,
-0.4569019675254822,
-0.3544672727584839,
-0.03648531064391136,
-0.44959551095962524,
0.012493523769080639,
0.5409643054008484,
-0.3725978136062622,
0.26461005210876465,
0.6607229113578796,
-0.18435928225517273,
0.38217225670814514,
-0.1770310401916504,
-0.09640008956193924,
-0.8970322608947754,
0.15127375721931458,
-0.3705228865146637,
-0.380783349275589,
-0.31348392367362976,
-0.0012660172069445252,
0.24730733036994934,
-0.03428639471530914,
-0.2997860312461853,
0.6828770041465759,
-0.29139408469200134,
-0.24171903729438782,
-0.3320178985595703,
-0.25780099630355835,
-0.297209233045578,
0.40001264214515686,
0.36104774475097656,
0.5398646593093872,
0.27580416202545166,
-0.9357529282569885,
0.29840219020843506,
0.4060617983341217,
-0.12146187573671341,
0.6873083114624023,
-0.32872703671455383,
0.0472879596054554,
-0.13189361989498138,
0.3457445204257965,
-0.7994092702865601,
-0.24583618342876434,
0.6828420758247375,
-0.1437336951494217,
0.25782904028892517,
0.04843013361096382,
-0.12893903255462646,
-0.28651347756385803,
-0.25673696398735046,
0.6318908929824829,
0.543067216873169,
-0.6647653579711914,
0.6142745018005371,
0.20152729749679565,
0.0406438447535038,
-1.0176715850830078,
-0.5178349614143372,
-0.4629383385181427,
-0.5187591910362244,
-0.19766449928283691,
0.3727168142795563,
-0.044945601373910904,
-0.1967434585094452,
0.14748868346214294,
-0.14722990989685059,
0.23993700742721558,
0.19556425511837006,
0.24724797904491425,
-0.08279512077569962,
0.09937363862991333,
0.5457327961921692,
0.04447117820382118,
-0.3945713937282562,
0.1839328557252884,
-0.23464913666248322,
0.48810088634490967,
0.1935795247554779,
-0.4608684778213501,
-0.18282833695411682,
0.13080832362174988,
0.31003767251968384,
-0.22012346982955933,
0.8593559265136719,
0.7414873838424683,
-0.09998378157615662,
-0.2399713695049286,
-0.04873037710785866,
-0.39057883620262146,
-0.49727845191955566,
0.3227770924568176,
-0.10608985275030136,
-0.45969539880752563,
0.2497478723526001,
-0.20605696737766266,
0.1476605087518692,
0.5215539932250977,
0.4459644556045532,
-0.10955040156841278,
1.1759148836135864,
0.8559001684188843,
-0.08344458788633347,
0.9202455282211304,
-0.04600545018911362,
-0.0857522189617157,
-0.9839047789573669,
-0.3663097321987152,
-0.30314901471138,
-0.7581140995025635,
-0.40744519233703613,
-0.26752540469169617,
0.4061008095741272,
-0.13893115520477295,
-0.4758475124835968,
0.21883568167686462,
-0.507885217666626,
0.46711429953575134,
0.7213072776794434,
0.26361045241355896,
-0.013968869112432003,
-0.1776941567659378,
-0.1966378539800644,
-0.1871725469827652,
-0.7423575520515442,
-0.3169364333152771,
1.009537696838379,
0.25248441100120544,
0.9508704543113708,
0.20430269837379456,
0.9223131537437439,
0.45774027705192566,
0.5885475277900696,
-0.43279704451560974,
0.350914865732193,
0.25261375308036804,
-0.4149307906627655,
-0.5044306516647339,
-0.7881969809532166,
-1.0638318061828613,
0.23860014975070953,
-0.39624735713005066,
-0.15572479367256165,
0.12298747152090073,
0.316098153591156,
-0.24397867918014526,
0.2643435001373291,
-0.5026316046714783,
1.0661766529083252,
-0.29034319519996643,
-0.06842149049043655,
-0.22578437626361847,
-0.9075547456741333,
0.36195793747901917,
0.210149884223938,
0.3080044090747833,
-0.10281882435083389,
-0.0015426587779074907,
0.8033431172370911,
-0.4965980350971222,
0.6248835921287537,
-0.2737143635749817,
-0.13653559982776642,
0.09717880189418793,
0.26639634370803833,
0.614505410194397,
-0.07613125443458557,
0.06871497631072998,
-0.49722379446029663,
-0.05062579736113548,
-0.384113609790802,
-0.7342295050621033,
0.21542851626873016,
-0.9055629968643188,
-0.3929637670516968,
-0.4026426672935486,
-0.7448368668556213,
-0.07052876055240631,
0.01815611682832241,
0.37097758054733276,
0.11548402160406113,
-0.42753100395202637,
0.03652647137641907,
0.7571941614151001,
-0.2647596597671509,
0.43859440088272095,
0.45490697026252747,
-0.2376902997493744,
-0.6416202187538147,
0.8754459619522095,
-0.2333287000656128,
0.47233232855796814,
0.6676693558692932,
0.4620230197906494,
-0.6648977398872375,
0.06037217006087303,
-0.32756516337394714,
0.24498003721237183,
-0.9163246154785156,
-0.30745187401771545,
-0.46447473764419556,
-0.087819904088974,
-0.36720365285873413,
-0.07028144598007202,
-0.3037961423397064,
-0.2422260046005249,
-0.358319491147995,
-0.23957669734954834,
0.015823256224393845,
0.7188367247581482,
-0.457931786775589,
0.41306912899017334,
-0.8075700998306274,
-0.005418422631919384,
0.6626622080802917,
0.17598585784435272,
-0.25681769847869873,
-0.6390203237533569,
-0.19032615423202515,
0.3373757600784302,
-0.5161437392234802,
-1.0156660079956055,
0.46562817692756653,
0.23115435242652893,
0.5428212285041809,
0.6277152895927429,
0.16683745384216309,
0.631117582321167,
-0.3652079701423645,
0.33425384759902954,
0.21806420385837555,
-0.9217135906219482,
0.32534244656562805,
-0.28397056460380554,
0.25310078263282776,
0.6021417379379272,
0.25648823380470276,
-0.8316632509231567,
-0.1160673275589943,
-0.8146798610687256,
-0.4466520845890045,
0.6879833340644836,
-0.24926884472370148,
0.06822020560503006,
0.044699471443891525,
0.24952499568462372,
0.1624581515789032,
0.2808178663253784,
-0.9750215411186218,
-0.03641239181160927,
-0.2902436852455139,
-0.4543260931968689,
-0.2541508376598358,
-0.08592518419027328,
-0.4150749444961548,
-0.3055856227874756,
0.5764945149421692,
-0.20307207107543945,
0.3363328278064728,
-0.1351204663515091,
-0.37610888481140137,
-0.3349018394947052,
0.3329240679740906,
1.0832971334457397,
0.6596370339393616,
-0.2572142481803894,
0.5333721041679382,
0.08678897470235825,
-0.3440823554992676,
0.4249102771282196,
-0.17911583185195923,
0.05020405724644661,
-0.1800922006368637,
0.30140483379364014,
0.8799635171890259,
0.3266550898551941,
-0.6881872415542603,
0.5305987000465393,
0.15503111481666565,
-0.4632502794265747,
0.14220105111598969,
0.2721782624721527,
0.1469525396823883,
0.3986528217792511,
0.24183803796768188,
0.09116658568382263,
-0.06292187422513962,
-0.5654193758964539,
0.32648932933807373,
0.5848249793052673,
-0.42669248580932617,
-0.2775292694568634,
0.6476554274559021,
0.16757161915302277,
-0.4624224603176117,
1.0268439054489136,
-0.3105737268924713,
-0.7599073052406311,
0.5181077122688293,
0.752566397190094,
0.8932679891586304,
-0.5234237313270569,
0.6117043495178223,
0.4334750175476074,
0.2371360957622528,
-0.49779000878334045,
0.03796286880970001,
-0.1510826200246811,
-0.8323979377746582,
-0.0004335733538027853,
-0.21808196604251862,
-0.525060772895813,
-0.2465960532426834,
-1.0620436668395996,
0.25265419483184814,
-0.43423643708229065,
-0.09061114490032196,
-0.49430057406425476,
-0.38256916403770447,
-0.5756435990333557,
-0.020544622093439102,
0.3038312494754791,
0.5519983768463135,
-1.3089252710342407,
0.5802764892578125,
0.5914803743362427,
-0.05818602442741394,
-0.6745437979698181,
-0.005259428173303604,
-0.02478855475783348,
-0.9251296520233154,
0.8452650308609009,
-0.01604515127837658,
-0.08307970315217972,
-0.09452933818101883,
-0.6021963953971863,
-0.9693480134010315,
1.3025825023651123,
0.4974934160709381,
-0.44264066219329834,
0.26857122778892517,
0.14130856096744537,
0.36196717619895935,
-0.42796245217323303,
0.35967060923576355,
0.4591812491416931,
0.5781310796737671,
0.13952375948429108,
-0.6580632925033569,
-0.05362677574157715,
0.2098444700241089,
-0.16535411775112152,
0.7942155003547668,
-0.4850441515445709,
0.8324840664863586,
-0.2719227969646454,
-0.37640076875686646,
-0.6239134073257446,
0.5654777884483337,
0.4727459251880646,
0.30211809277534485,
0.6512471437454224,
0.8568275570869446,
0.9498887658119202,
-0.008013165555894375,
0.8639031052589417,
0.12403162568807602,
0.6671133041381836,
0.9783479571342468,
-0.3653647303581238,
1.0024465322494507,
0.4399310052394867,
-0.08877775818109512,
0.9634792804718018,
0.9805005788803101,
0.23565365374088287,
1.11391019821167,
0.22129210829734802,
-0.13601332902908325,
-0.3673531711101532,
0.2743106782436371,
-0.49749964475631714,
0.00873844139277935,
0.20901648700237274,
-0.4091995358467102,
-0.4543142318725586,
0.22990991175174713,
-0.24431514739990234,
-0.014164182357490063,
-0.3158482313156128,
0.8711829781532288,
-0.15485742688179016,
-0.7375278472900391,
0.5618510246276855,
0.07353738695383072,
0.4023028612136841,
-0.491275817155838,
-0.014332609251141548,
-0.23564974963665009,
0.44831329584121704,
-0.26765769720077515,
-0.4626317024230957,
0.5325614213943481,
-0.5458921790122986,
-0.38933655619621277,
-0.6018856763839722,
0.5142039060592651,
-0.7508227229118347,
-0.2418496459722519,
0.15433716773986816,
0.3504534363746643,
-0.07514236122369766,
0.12668688595294952,
-0.9018818140029907,
-0.014127826318144798,
-0.07687179744243622,
-0.11258360743522644,
0.4165060818195343,
0.41481292247772217,
-0.004343291278928518,
0.7480372786521912,
0.41834813356399536,
-0.21144235134124756,
0.09984105080366135,
-0.2704980969429016,
0.5300551652908325,
-0.7485732436180115,
-0.6853605508804321,
-1.1623432636260986,
0.2141684591770172,
0.11997882276773453,
-0.24089141190052032,
0.4003084897994995,
0.32252204418182373,
0.6578516960144043,
-0.39350762963294983,
0.6894350647926331,
0.011942032724618912,
0.581501841545105,
-0.5140194892883301,
0.1757824569940567,
-0.43664851784706116,
0.09603236615657806,
-0.22183364629745483,
-1.1695475578308105,
-0.1804366260766983,
0.7002670764923096,
-0.5236830711364746,
-0.01782076619565487,
0.9232665300369263,
0.6544868350028992,
-0.3044518828392029,
-0.4831882417201996,
0.032656896859407425,
-0.46193841099739075,
0.27206772565841675,
0.8063908815383911,
0.9911618232727051,
-0.1963377594947815,
0.6708970665931702,
0.08352083712816238,
0.06904621422290802,
-0.5183551907539368,
-1.0987600088119507,
-0.7189854383468628,
-0.5390312075614929,
-0.39236971735954285,
-0.4099312722682953,
-0.07137833535671234,
1.2252440452575684,
0.870513379573822,
-0.6610878109931946,
-0.26768264174461365,
-0.18837685883045197,
0.5884760022163391,
-0.8545913100242615,
-0.2330579161643982,
0.1870744526386261,
-0.37075918912887573,
-0.39495551586151123,
0.09243927896022797,
0.18713153898715973,
0.0825512632727623,
-0.22407600283622742,
-0.5597354173660278,
-0.0332086943089962,
-0.03941607475280762,
0.0924716517329216,
0.6548938751220703,
-0.3681216239929199,
-0.30219176411628723,
0.027576560154557228,
-0.3607008159160614,
0.07686389982700348,
1.087655782699585,
-0.6481851935386658,
0.1578783094882965,
0.675741970539093,
0.9685859680175781,
0.2988983988761902,
0.3886234760284424,
0.7231602668762207,
-0.8748524785041809,
0.05552301183342934,
0.133860245347023,
0.0006408917834050953,
0.30100321769714355,
-0.30991795659065247,
0.5516630411148071,
0.29915380477905273,
-0.7350493669509888,
-0.9547293782234192,
0.38378238677978516,
-0.6110460758209229,
-0.24295896291732788,
1.3489915132522583,
0.34135961532592773,
-0.32191407680511475,
0.21948866546154022,
-0.07018119841814041,
0.20211204886436462,
-0.1926751434803009,
0.9066980481147766,
0.864729642868042,
-0.02519860491156578,
-0.5641613602638245,
-0.29643553495407104,
0.924872636795044,
0.685651957988739,
-0.9324617981910706,
0.271698534488678,
0.27678775787353516,
0.5770484209060669,
0.021250039339065552,
0.5247336626052856,
0.17886213958263397,
0.1861000955104828,
-0.47062787413597107,
0.2568981945514679,
0.12393371760845184,
-0.42618468403816223,
-0.5549819469451904,
-0.05437016487121582,
-0.023483967408537865,
-0.5688361525535583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00402v1
|
Self-Refine Instruction-Tuning for Aligning Reasoning in Language Models
| 2024-05-01T09:10:27 | 2024-05-01T09:10:27 |
Leonardo Ranaldi, Andrè Freitas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The alignments of reasoning abilities between smaller and larger Language
Models are largely conducted via Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) using
demonstrations generated from robust Large Language Models (LLMs). Although
these approaches deliver more performant models, they do not show sufficiently
strong generalization ability as the training only relies on the provided
demonstrations.
In this paper, we propose the Self-refine Instruction-tuning method that
elicits Smaller Language Models to self-refine their abilities. Our approach is
based on a two-stage process, where reasoning abilities are first transferred
between LLMs and Small Language Models (SLMs) via Instruction-tuning on
demonstrations provided by LLMs, and then the instructed models Self-refine
their abilities through preference optimization strategies. In particular, the
second phase operates refinement heuristics based on the Direct Preference
Optimization algorithm, where the SLMs are elicited to deliver a series of
reasoning paths by automatically sampling the generated responses and providing
rewards using ground truths from the LLMs. Results obtained on commonsense and
math reasoning tasks show that this approach significantly outperforms
Instruction-tuning in both in-domain and out-domain scenarios, aligning the
reasoning abilities of Smaller and Larger Language Models.
|
[
-0.2578141987323761,
-0.6419100761413574,
0.614327609539032,
-0.17701691389083862,
-0.23167955875396729,
-0.2308070808649063,
-0.5410690307617188,
0.10036726295948029,
-0.1519402414560318,
0.6890160441398621,
-0.8821168541908264,
-0.22994987666606903,
-0.2890927791595459,
-0.04003635421395302,
0.12530696392059326,
0.8130945563316345,
0.05915791541337967,
0.05500687286257744,
-0.34591564536094666,
0.052172597497701645,
-0.6816625595092773,
-0.085020050406456,
-0.6215457320213318,
-0.5584303736686707,
0.2624237835407257,
0.7779682874679565,
0.5283085703849792,
0.9789292216300964,
0.24083799123764038,
0.3363756835460663,
0.3532008230686188,
0.4776694178581238,
-0.5012432336807251,
0.1097555160522461,
-0.7442916631698608,
-0.36110830307006836,
-0.3059631586074829,
-0.00019642891129478812,
0.48909899592399597,
0.3526332378387451,
-0.20579150319099426,
0.4471922516822815,
0.16649138927459717,
0.8261047005653381,
-0.513944149017334,
0.06181522458791733,
-0.8634847402572632,
-0.17806601524353027,
0.07252221554517746,
-0.34630122780799866,
-0.519210696220398,
-0.2764970362186432,
-0.06060156226158142,
-0.517208456993103,
0.35189586877822876,
0.15545454621315002,
0.7398825883865356,
0.6773120760917664,
-0.1484312117099762,
0.032487452030181885,
-0.42688706517219543,
1.044327735900879,
-0.9770495295524597,
0.26990652084350586,
0.20926247537136078,
0.3034455478191376,
-0.0890544131398201,
-0.35255926847457886,
-0.24492257833480835,
-0.20579853653907776,
-0.2680841088294983,
-0.13557350635528564,
0.04867523908615112,
-0.014666784554719925,
0.38249683380126953,
0.07022280246019363,
-0.598526120185852,
0.3933824896812439,
-0.2503044307231903,
-0.17077991366386414,
0.7755351662635803,
0.1294865906238556,
-0.11375328153371811,
-0.01134924590587616,
-0.2285050004720688,
-0.04599149152636528,
-0.7488125562667847,
-0.08433285355567932,
0.3902565836906433,
0.5502500534057617,
0.14762543141841888,
0.5470275282859802,
-0.48563385009765625,
0.9075427651405334,
0.7163450717926025,
-0.29741933941841125,
0.018155349418520927,
-0.359394907951355,
-0.23995190858840942,
-0.017987698316574097,
0.6935666799545288,
0.2573692202568054,
0.37684255838394165,
0.1139514222741127,
-0.286295086145401,
-0.08750984817743301,
0.3685554265975952,
-0.7746545076370239,
-0.34386488795280457,
-0.08871331810951233,
-0.37986379861831665,
-0.21364790201187134,
-0.3567747175693512,
-0.7337926030158997,
-0.05962629243731499,
-0.8911640644073486,
0.6743044257164001,
-0.2559891641139984,
-0.15764565765857697,
0.2465958148241043,
0.24888336658477783,
0.08863455802202225,
0.35259711742401123,
-1.3586219549179077,
0.18106599152088165,
0.7878440618515015,
0.31572601199150085,
-0.04139666631817818,
-0.22106888890266418,
-0.5871974229812622,
0.18310701847076416,
-0.31114307045936584,
0.8135815858840942,
-0.6155176758766174,
-0.026495758444070816,
-0.10622166097164154,
-0.06702350080013275,
-0.33453598618507385,
-0.60623699426651,
0.3550876975059509,
-0.3462297320365906,
0.23778222501277924,
-0.24531638622283936,
-0.6712054014205933,
0.10683596134185791,
0.1199890598654747,
-0.1716184914112091,
1.1088029146194458,
-0.01268303394317627,
-0.4073716998100281,
0.08317749202251434,
-0.4675203859806061,
-0.41527509689331055,
-0.18235553801059723,
-0.3651122450828552,
-0.4455418586730957,
0.12127985805273056,
0.4965587258338928,
0.4493907690048218,
-0.25474315881729126,
0.16939859092235565,
-0.3189781904220581,
-0.3540778160095215,
-0.15656587481498718,
-0.22509174048900604,
0.333053320646286,
0.2270776480436325,
-0.5890299677848816,
0.2970922589302063,
-0.47282013297080994,
0.5349550247192383,
0.11344912648200989,
0.09413948655128479,
-0.14646215736865997,
0.017690103501081467,
-0.8837617039680481,
0.2850963771343231,
0.5542338490486145,
-0.2656034231185913,
0.5108930468559265,
-0.6720806360244751,
0.45351144671440125,
0.9052870869636536,
-0.16758783161640167,
0.6893355250358582,
-0.2428382784128189,
0.4177156984806061,
-0.07904890924692154,
0.11924058198928833,
-0.17221078276634216,
-0.3390287756919861,
-1.0397872924804688,
0.03231194615364075,
0.3125092387199402,
0.42667365074157715,
-0.5297242403030396,
0.6165470480918884,
-0.20965321362018585,
-0.24566997587680817,
-0.8562545776367188,
0.38712170720100403,
0.5705000162124634,
0.7607038617134094,
0.5255651473999023,
0.1722852885723114,
-0.23395714163780212,
-1.2135181427001953,
-0.31506308913230896,
0.030715858563780785,
0.14111201465129852,
0.3100613057613373,
0.4248923063278198,
0.07517281919717789,
0.8876172304153442,
-0.5152567625045776,
-0.2262437492609024,
0.032101109623909,
0.19238245487213135,
-0.00555109977722168,
0.6417839527130127,
0.2159002274274826,
-0.2265985608100891,
-0.5116925835609436,
0.08865658193826675,
-0.4292154312133789,
-0.365724116563797,
-0.11060627549886703,
-0.30597811937332153,
0.2896171510219574,
0.5958282351493835,
-0.1574864238500595,
0.25140389800071716,
0.3068666458129883,
-0.1255127489566803,
0.6110713481903076,
-0.37315434217453003,
0.11775092035531998,
-0.6589956283569336,
-0.3775002062320709,
-0.03380493074655533,
-0.2293645292520523,
-0.21838970482349396,
0.11128532141447067,
0.14056023955345154,
0.029787098988890648,
0.04206915944814682,
0.6814228892326355,
-0.6311284303665161,
0.0590401254594326,
-0.5294605493545532,
0.3242398202419281,
0.17593468725681305,
0.6069790124893188,
0.23192726075649261,
0.8752338886260986,
0.5611556768417358,
-0.45746269822120667,
0.25415778160095215,
-0.14867596328258514,
-0.17326517403125763,
0.5189560055732727,
-0.4404427111148834,
0.3142174184322357,
0.12389213591814041,
-0.05252290889620781,
-0.8334519267082214,
0.02805902808904648,
0.07373533397912979,
-0.09043993800878525,
0.37430527806282043,
-0.45121264457702637,
-0.3324248194694519,
-0.4100445806980133,
0.011939996853470802,
0.25221186876296997,
0.600654661655426,
-0.7890689969062805,
0.618844211101532,
-0.03748583793640137,
-0.18702831864356995,
-0.5110874772071838,
-0.3671940863132477,
-0.4856232702732086,
-0.15140944719314575,
-0.7157082557678223,
0.21985460817813873,
-0.11572100967168808,
-0.012539103627204895,
-0.13819509744644165,
-0.3600943386554718,
0.2201451063156128,
-0.10548368841409683,
-0.02101624570786953,
0.1805596500635147,
-0.44077959656715393,
0.3104013204574585,
0.6041724681854248,
-0.3534744083881378,
-0.06292690336704254,
-0.5979737639427185,
0.34200477600097656,
-0.3045980632305145,
-0.6522476673126221,
-0.44632837176322937,
0.16388311982154846,
0.11849209666252136,
-0.3558441996574402,
0.49888911843299866,
0.45980480313301086,
-0.07929417490959167,
-0.4787401258945465,
-0.8311662673950195,
-0.6123059391975403,
-0.5273698568344116,
0.08215118944644928,
-0.5914404988288879,
-1.0777804851531982,
0.036150094121694565,
-0.3616558313369751,
0.09776996821165085,
0.5790860652923584,
0.7187084555625916,
-0.09584993869066238,
1.4428702592849731,
0.39919283986091614,
0.07732492685317993,
0.31249234080314636,
-0.19788189232349396,
0.2720060646533966,
-0.8273372650146484,
-0.0348537378013134,
-0.5857902765274048,
-0.25996464490890503,
-0.3759543299674988,
-0.4446747899055481,
0.061599601060152054,
0.16042205691337585,
-0.5399556756019592,
0.26883456110954285,
-0.81630939245224,
0.7913398146629333,
0.5782445669174194,
0.028611425310373306,
0.2145378291606903,
0.11103034019470215,
-0.40927377343177795,
-0.24671348929405212,
-0.7288481593132019,
-0.7171822190284729,
0.8591955900192261,
0.2208942323923111,
0.9608768820762634,
-0.010367956012487411,
0.849270761013031,
0.00002775183202174958,
0.21416912972927094,
-0.5647785067558289,
0.5285943746566772,
-0.3606626093387604,
-0.5057417154312134,
-0.5080356001853943,
-0.5067337155342102,
-0.5886048674583435,
0.3335137367248535,
-0.09416663646697998,
-0.7581767439842224,
0.10650087893009186,
0.5353056192398071,
-0.4881359338760376,
-0.030917944386601448,
-1.0384256839752197,
1.1135481595993042,
-0.4224526286125183,
-0.5333765149116516,
-0.6119737029075623,
-0.5184745788574219,
0.355785995721817,
0.18276375532150269,
0.14718198776245117,
-0.3286820948123932,
0.166634202003479,
0.3327248990535736,
-0.38536712527275085,
0.8774691820144653,
-0.13940034806728363,
-0.3157638907432556,
0.15914003551006317,
0.2621670961380005,
0.5435831546783447,
0.1344219595193863,
-0.1928987205028534,
-0.24685311317443848,
0.08595548570156097,
-0.279838502407074,
-1.0271843671798706,
0.9770557284355164,
-0.7379007339477539,
-1.1276795864105225,
-0.06626182794570923,
-0.328216552734375,
-0.4626865088939667,
0.22693710029125214,
0.09342627227306366,
0.33733105659484863,
0.1264311671257019,
-0.17381563782691956,
0.7492405772209167,
0.2400171160697937,
0.10505735129117966,
0.7040643692016602,
-0.23636561632156372,
-0.3257620930671692,
1.1403132677078247,
-0.1109834834933281,
0.6143821477890015,
0.3433847427368164,
0.465226948261261,
-0.4415072202682495,
-0.348530650138855,
-0.6792246103286743,
0.41253748536109924,
-0.6320739388465881,
-0.3752303123474121,
-0.18380510807037354,
-0.18404483795166016,
-0.5747250318527222,
-0.21894845366477966,
-0.5743432641029358,
-0.4807458817958832,
-0.3890377879142761,
0.12658128142356873,
0.19380059838294983,
0.36191093921661377,
-0.15846514701843262,
0.30043649673461914,
-0.38837283849716187,
0.4579382538795471,
0.7003337144851685,
0.37744686007499695,
-0.04644492268562317,
-1.0190547704696655,
-0.2667476534843445,
0.2625918686389923,
-0.331493079662323,
-0.4680795669555664,
0.14725928008556366,
0.2553018033504486,
0.4076010584831238,
0.45167839527130127,
-0.07233644276857376,
0.9281577467918396,
-0.602129340171814,
0.43922725319862366,
0.03030666522681713,
-0.8537720441818237,
0.871516764163971,
-0.2766786515712738,
0.32625818252563477,
0.7599775195121765,
-0.059589024633169174,
-0.041799791157245636,
-0.1698015332221985,
-0.5631589293479919,
-0.2749629318714142,
0.8525686264038086,
-0.03423340246081352,
0.05924258381128311,
0.034278202801942825,
0.5765723586082458,
0.09566915780305862,
0.07560011744499207,
-0.48278555274009705,
-0.11660300940275192,
-0.3673344552516937,
-0.3545466363430023,
0.11829890310764313,
-0.10436759144067764,
-0.3906215727329254,
-0.5655568242073059,
1.0686843395233154,
-0.7082287073135376,
0.021969109773635864,
-0.11162442713975906,
0.08788508176803589,
-0.40099936723709106,
0.3993052542209625,
0.6164118051528931,
0.5827107429504395,
0.04287237673997879,
0.059699393808841705,
0.16098690032958984,
0.18721379339694977,
0.2241087555885315,
0.115110844373703,
-0.2631288170814514,
-0.49642592668533325,
0.015513591468334198,
0.9428321123123169,
0.2968544661998749,
-0.45774638652801514,
0.4683270752429962,
0.014048311859369278,
-0.19236144423484802,
0.013229064643383026,
0.5378704071044922,
0.1585707813501358,
0.40932756662368774,
-0.04464714601635933,
0.007186722941696644,
-0.01848474144935608,
-0.22557039558887482,
0.004769479855895042,
0.6514322757720947,
-0.13102690875530243,
-0.04470057040452957,
0.4106108844280243,
0.167341947555542,
-0.2906487286090851,
0.6377631425857544,
-0.2613426446914673,
-0.3325788676738739,
0.4495847821235657,
0.9078825116157532,
0.7791118621826172,
-0.19023823738098145,
0.22712373733520508,
0.6123625636100769,
0.3059570789337158,
-0.3093809187412262,
0.025290077552199364,
-0.12565596401691437,
-0.9255926012992859,
-0.6358397603034973,
-0.5836896300315857,
-0.2878962457180023,
0.07087865471839905,
-0.6839418411254883,
0.2645077705383301,
-0.36137402057647705,
0.005909687839448452,
0.00985514372587204,
0.03830583766102791,
-0.46970245242118835,
0.2953694760799408,
0.06835519522428513,
0.7144643068313599,
-0.744692325592041,
0.9745036959648132,
0.488360732793808,
-0.1646021008491516,
-1.0730972290039062,
-0.08991197496652603,
-0.038096800446510315,
-0.9431885480880737,
0.6110634207725525,
0.07396313548088074,
-0.46499955654144287,
0.3153141736984253,
-0.5610798001289368,
-0.9554666876792908,
0.9152786135673523,
0.6300452947616577,
-0.995403528213501,
-0.03867645934224129,
-0.030023915693163872,
0.6532102227210999,
-0.6710956692695618,
0.19351907074451447,
0.7779520750045776,
0.4286337196826935,
0.1625566929578781,
-0.8570218682289124,
-0.02135355956852436,
-0.035844847559928894,
0.014692804776132107,
0.20824314653873444,
-0.8705186247825623,
0.4209582209587097,
-0.3745795786380768,
-0.048024047166109085,
0.15988394618034363,
0.8955234289169312,
0.42678070068359375,
-0.07402091473340988,
0.5932732224464417,
0.7724339365959167,
0.6690661311149597,
-0.14506028592586517,
0.5758378505706787,
-0.3723987340927124,
0.4205021262168884,
1.4795722961425781,
-0.2622128129005432,
0.7399351596832275,
0.335867315530777,
0.008434071205556393,
0.7288029193878174,
0.40289586782455444,
-0.05463893339037895,
0.5106915235519409,
0.19079884886741638,
-0.05482614412903786,
-0.792832612991333,
0.23235106468200684,
-0.3342683017253876,
0.33069854974746704,
0.3537084758281708,
-0.2231164574623108,
-0.1435476392507553,
-0.1621485948562622,
-0.19257819652557373,
0.3699783682823181,
-0.3731135129928589,
0.7773556113243103,
-0.021694954484701157,
-1.1646391153335571,
0.6801252365112305,
0.13033810257911682,
0.3780648410320282,
-0.4739242494106293,
-0.10343880951404572,
-0.13883516192436218,
0.2690034508705139,
-0.09821731597185135,
-0.6403709650039673,
0.1375879943370819,
-0.13257238268852234,
-0.2614968717098236,
-0.3911210298538208,
0.8232983350753784,
-0.6134352087974548,
-0.3997356593608856,
0.13488085567951202,
0.3885650038719177,
-0.030315138399600983,
0.10950510203838348,
-0.9845905900001526,
-0.23066583275794983,
0.11573126912117004,
-0.09033335745334625,
0.5092760920524597,
0.5348025560379028,
-0.10082364082336426,
0.7263201475143433,
0.4711763858795166,
-0.06776754558086395,
0.047086961567401886,
0.5005723834037781,
0.7506913542747498,
-0.48976948857307434,
-0.34170979261398315,
-0.8376216292381287,
0.30365124344825745,
-0.06895016878843307,
-0.24521662294864655,
0.6865683197975159,
0.5108543038368225,
0.8050775527954102,
-0.13739559054374695,
0.5401132702827454,
0.24094565212726593,
0.7185686230659485,
-0.7420942783355713,
0.274495005607605,
-0.5810275673866272,
0.2907000184059143,
0.05895334482192993,
-0.6438688039779663,
0.1390487551689148,
0.9136365056037903,
-0.6018782258033752,
0.28589552640914917,
0.5843591690063477,
1.0571132898330688,
-0.1466820240020752,
-0.04016612097620964,
0.28235578536987305,
0.1265621781349182,
-0.013185701332986355,
0.4038589894771576,
0.5870495438575745,
-0.13458524644374847,
0.24876806139945984,
-0.5016295313835144,
-0.3015647828578949,
-0.12414661794900894,
-0.8672302961349487,
-0.9977288842201233,
-0.25683972239494324,
-0.4580809772014618,
-0.1340632289648056,
0.060316599905490875,
0.8867416381835938,
0.8842872381210327,
-0.8498439788818359,
-0.1718224734067917,
-0.008623503148555756,
0.16823600232601166,
-0.42112821340560913,
-0.26834607124328613,
0.3540089726448059,
-0.7990538477897644,
-0.6139429211616516,
0.595492959022522,
0.3032906651496887,
-0.27389800548553467,
-0.5155794620513916,
-0.0762382224202156,
-0.035940021276474,
0.22836962342262268,
0.3579609990119934,
0.3071810305118561,
-0.975718080997467,
-0.562004566192627,
0.033783648163080215,
-0.12832732498645782,
0.06296180188655853,
0.7793668508529663,
-0.8510181903839111,
0.5672316551208496,
0.20805668830871582,
0.43474745750427246,
0.5667918920516968,
0.26391613483428955,
0.5067321062088013,
-0.8749829530715942,
-0.19339044392108917,
0.03143603354692459,
0.2760726809501648,
0.22989721596240997,
-0.38736599683761597,
0.37566569447517395,
-0.016766712069511414,
-0.8695712685585022,
-0.5922308564186096,
0.3826601207256317,
-0.7087708115577698,
-0.19962146878242493,
1.0659445524215698,
0.03058648109436035,
-0.01658051088452339,
0.21316170692443848,
-0.34001240134239197,
0.118472620844841,
-0.37393754720687866,
0.8637678623199463,
0.5384011268615723,
-0.3857783377170563,
-0.28137022256851196,
-0.17371229827404022,
0.5838778018951416,
0.7541351318359375,
-0.7434532046318054,
0.3482958674430847,
0.5041287541389465,
0.47927919030189514,
0.060361724346876144,
0.5121167302131653,
0.04358683153986931,
0.27055624127388,
-0.31963977217674255,
-0.05712854862213135,
-0.08936706185340881,
-0.4553180932998657,
-0.374284565448761,
-0.056749045848846436,
0.19261685013771057,
0.15567946434020996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01601v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01601v1
|
Efficient Sample-Specific Encoder Perturbations
| 2024-05-01T08:55:16 | 2024-05-01T08:55:16 |
Yassir Fathullah, Mark J. F. Gales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Encoder-decoder foundation models have displayed state-of-the-art performance
on a range of autoregressive sequence tasks. This paper proposes a simple and
lightweight modification to such systems to control the behaviour according to
a specific attribute of interest. This paper proposes a novel
inference-efficient approach to modifying the behaviour of an encoder-decoder
system according to a specific attribute of interest. Specifically, we show
that a small proxy network can be used to find a sample-by-sample perturbation
of the encoder output of a frozen foundation model to trigger the decoder to
generate improved decodings. This work explores a specific realization of this
framework focused on improving the COMET performance of Flan-T5 on Machine
Translation and the WER of Whisper foundation models on Speech Recognition.
Results display consistent improvements in performance evaluated through COMET
and WER respectively. Furthermore, experiments also show that the proxies are
robust to the exact nature of the data used to train them and can extend to
other domains.
|
[
-0.09798301756381989,
-0.5155874490737915,
-0.03162926807999611,
0.09465605765581131,
-0.13184450566768646,
-0.19040557742118835,
-0.0035574501380324364,
-0.2869437634944916,
0.3843999207019806,
0.45627209544181824,
-0.34295469522476196,
-0.20820575952529907,
-0.6109830141067505,
0.17343151569366455,
-0.7877956628799438,
0.4806440770626068,
0.2241988629102707,
0.08212894201278687,
0.22306683659553528,
0.028262341395020485,
-0.0021904786117374897,
-0.5198420286178589,
-0.47310009598731995,
-0.335649698972702,
0.1812358796596527,
0.23378901183605194,
0.77753746509552,
0.8127653002738953,
0.4852471351623535,
0.3327332139015198,
-0.21921473741531372,
-0.20654529333114624,
-0.5584978461265564,
0.14145107567310333,
-0.32390037178993225,
-0.5491375923156738,
-0.2796211540699005,
-0.5232120752334595,
0.5927326679229736,
0.8427146673202515,
-0.2680443525314331,
0.16177208721637726,
0.08885268121957779,
0.5167204737663269,
-0.9887084364891052,
-0.04620008543133736,
-0.6840411424636841,
0.029135720804333687,
-0.11054686456918716,
-0.27329221367836,
-0.4618785083293915,
-0.003830365603789687,
-0.049454085528850555,
-0.31662794947624207,
0.692471444606781,
-0.23820890486240387,
0.7302435040473938,
0.5846699476242065,
-0.010964514687657356,
-0.1377861350774765,
-0.7576454877853394,
0.5919502377510071,
-0.6688562035560608,
0.7447165846824646,
0.23815517127513885,
0.31331273913383484,
-0.470520943403244,
-0.8246614336967468,
-0.49115028977394104,
0.16314661502838135,
-0.08413640409708023,
0.08231374621391296,
-0.11063845455646515,
0.014214947819709778,
0.1180279329419136,
0.41721311211586,
-0.16854524612426758,
0.06931836903095245,
0.0637887716293335,
-0.4596805274486542,
0.290127158164978,
0.14939813315868378,
-0.04445517063140869,
0.013549720868468285,
0.1652350127696991,
-0.5356768369674683,
-0.6828683614730835,
0.20524480938911438,
0.4322255551815033,
0.3611769378185272,
0.10638134926557541,
0.4914051294326782,
-0.5922819972038269,
0.8055633306503296,
0.5298033356666565,
-0.004496817011386156,
0.25073525309562683,
0.03532317653298378,
-0.3381015658378601,
0.22298578917980194,
0.5211266279220581,
-0.09673035889863968,
-0.2006106823682785,
-0.3644256591796875,
-0.5766317844390869,
0.3367154896259308,
-0.00320894131436944,
-1.0450927019119263,
-0.40728071331977844,
0.20677299797534943,
-0.4235819876194,
-0.26076740026474,
0.1571425050497055,
-0.6840426325798035,
-0.21129442751407623,
0.09861528128385544,
0.6172059774398804,
-0.3501110076904297,
-0.12937931716442108,
0.5331501364707947,
-0.3077957332134247,
0.040757983922958374,
0.22622805833816528,
-0.8715426921844482,
0.6040502786636353,
0.24598397314548492,
0.6642549633979797,
0.14097310602664948,
-0.0024722658563405275,
-1.0218844413757324,
0.17158232629299164,
-0.30096572637557983,
0.5919424295425415,
-0.8020275831222534,
-0.3442906141281128,
-0.16652989387512207,
-0.07959787547588348,
-0.018562819808721542,
-0.5960167646408081,
0.1051526591181755,
-0.7148061394691467,
-0.34404540061950684,
-0.2506852149963379,
-0.5082128047943115,
0.14834721386432648,
-0.18060052394866943,
-0.9512208700180054,
0.5652315020561218,
0.004908446688205004,
-0.6937173008918762,
0.1151559054851532,
-0.6541199088096619,
-0.5756700038909912,
-0.27239564061164856,
0.03567498177289963,
-0.22943204641342163,
0.07854977995157242,
0.5406462550163269,
0.48605555295944214,
-0.22534535825252533,
-0.08026562631130219,
-0.09945981204509735,
-0.637444257736206,
0.36270326375961304,
-0.31235095858573914,
0.5420142412185669,
0.348874032497406,
-0.5392327308654785,
-0.1221332922577858,
-0.9615160226821899,
-0.038878846913576126,
-0.11042433232069016,
-0.47858795523643494,
-0.22812433540821075,
0.20649640262126923,
-0.13883450627326965,
-0.23134134709835052,
-0.02689547650516033,
-0.4266613721847534,
-0.08337756246328354,
-0.4982983469963074,
0.5204042792320251,
0.3577251732349396,
0.11345218122005463,
0.6184410452842712,
-0.17326700687408447,
0.4472217559814453,
0.05586206912994385,
0.012310517951846123,
-0.3623756468296051,
-0.14141200482845306,
-0.8427128195762634,
-0.5080300569534302,
0.7380584478378296,
0.42658519744873047,
-0.9195050001144409,
0.3138832151889801,
-0.2370331734418869,
-0.17404037714004517,
-0.8752216696739197,
0.11172740906476974,
0.45410123467445374,
0.5899094939231873,
0.5859736800193787,
-0.4619350731372833,
-0.2778182029724121,
-0.7052253484725952,
-0.5188190340995789,
0.056436993181705475,
-0.2588730752468109,
0.01660527102649212,
0.34960225224494934,
0.008776280097663403,
0.9523776769638062,
-0.26563382148742676,
0.009496776387095451,
-0.00010503087105462328,
-0.0543699786067009,
0.4577985107898712,
0.8930412530899048,
0.3633778989315033,
-1.0152961015701294,
-0.2548660635948181,
-0.3130827844142914,
-0.3735637664794922,
-0.34382298588752747,
-0.05346379429101944,
-0.16445089876651764,
-0.20980612933635712,
0.4518072307109833,
-0.41443559527397156,
0.7249181866645813,
0.35751083493232727,
-0.3741743564605713,
0.3750448524951935,
0.07525292783975601,
0.2896789610385895,
-0.6327196955680847,
-0.031213143840432167,
-0.1342451423406601,
-0.2870163917541504,
-0.8469136357307434,
0.2839656472206116,
0.18313170969486237,
0.2192283272743225,
-0.5413175821304321,
0.2848101556301117,
-0.5212940573692322,
-0.1874695122241974,
-0.10833451896905899,
-0.32046979665756226,
-0.054848045110702515,
0.22908799350261688,
0.30159249901771545,
0.6138930916786194,
0.5954211354255676,
-0.9770333170890808,
0.07290609925985336,
0.34032097458839417,
-0.19428712129592896,
0.30047059059143066,
-0.6937159895896912,
0.33549484610557556,
-0.2747332751750946,
0.40534213185310364,
-0.6103625893592834,
-0.295897901058197,
0.17315886914730072,
-0.4627997875213623,
0.32299500703811646,
-0.42355597019195557,
-0.4872623682022095,
-0.10398425161838531,
0.02273775264620781,
0.11295145004987717,
0.6506391167640686,
-0.8068190217018127,
0.9260354042053223,
0.053444430232048035,
0.45092013478279114,
-0.6468914747238159,
-0.9842069745063782,
0.03612761199474335,
-0.06870166212320328,
-0.4322696626186371,
0.6022431254386902,
-0.20057280361652374,
-0.10034341365098953,
0.06087183952331543,
-0.32318320870399475,
0.0011443899711593986,
0.05379245802760124,
0.1932818442583084,
-0.38500258326530457,
-0.21218308806419373,
-0.11268913000822067,
0.33960506319999695,
-0.011314607225358486,
-0.20973524451255798,
-0.4517116844654083,
0.5006247758865356,
-0.03897003456950188,
-0.3153865337371826,
-0.48010095953941345,
0.24059957265853882,
0.398337185382843,
-0.29983943700790405,
0.748690664768219,
0.36788302659988403,
-0.40834182500839233,
-0.5444589853286743,
-0.6415269374847412,
-0.7121464610099792,
-0.5994784832000732,
0.21822480857372284,
-1.0383776426315308,
-0.7241085171699524,
0.6845780611038208,
-0.1423177868127823,
-0.22579970955848694,
0.15389609336853027,
0.32021594047546387,
0.1931530386209488,
0.8449406623840332,
0.5887711644172668,
-0.11542902886867523,
0.46940943598747253,
-0.5210574865341187,
-0.11011911183595657,
-0.683539628982544,
-0.0029455344192683697,
-0.5938457250595093,
-0.35825473070144653,
-0.2451963722705841,
-0.37488898634910583,
0.20801369845867157,
0.29468217492103577,
-0.3325660824775696,
0.5162340402603149,
-0.3714348375797272,
0.34723591804504395,
0.3012644946575165,
0.344990611076355,
0.1273912489414215,
0.044157516211271286,
-0.40686845779418945,
0.25554582476615906,
-1.141440749168396,
-0.41652029752731323,
0.7670068144798279,
0.18102285265922546,
0.9817185401916504,
0.3683702349662781,
0.7202317714691162,
0.30332279205322266,
0.16776788234710693,
-0.37575700879096985,
0.49243634939193726,
-0.5178198218345642,
-0.3286982774734497,
-0.29381465911865234,
-0.44896838068962097,
-0.7448516488075256,
0.43325668573379517,
-0.1559850573539734,
-0.808088481426239,
0.8019861578941345,
0.5655193328857422,
-0.29083243012428284,
0.33159297704696655,
-0.5492562055587769,
0.471030056476593,
0.20721711218357086,
-0.5273166298866272,
-0.1316561996936798,
-0.4543202221393585,
-0.0881575271487236,
-0.07499038428068161,
0.014328401535749435,
0.16503730416297913,
-0.07946470379829407,
0.455377459526062,
-0.6331237554550171,
1.0371427536010742,
-0.4241417944431305,
0.20544129610061646,
0.32487618923187256,
0.3403952121734619,
0.5671141147613525,
0.02486308664083481,
-0.6891927123069763,
0.02262258343398571,
-0.029775507748126984,
-0.45896801352500916,
-0.8594333529472351,
0.47313761711120605,
-0.5559684038162231,
-0.5466367602348328,
0.07636983692646027,
-0.2035512775182724,
-0.2675894796848297,
0.08366722613573074,
0.4069061875343323,
0.7706001400947571,
-0.14336693286895752,
0.40286800265312195,
0.6916152238845825,
-0.04769447445869446,
0.5002188086509705,
0.8656746745109558,
0.1899319589138031,
-0.3437853753566742,
0.503223180770874,
-0.014932023361325264,
0.38535547256469727,
0.896371603012085,
0.28548285365104675,
-0.14680850505828857,
-0.6897532939910889,
-0.4611841142177582,
-0.14975295960903168,
-0.9515137076377869,
-0.32847049832344055,
-0.6462729573249817,
0.05044122040271759,
-0.5151675343513489,
-0.1704183965921402,
-0.5588188171386719,
-0.451320081949234,
-0.44434815645217896,
0.07089612632989883,
0.39580026268959045,
0.4437384605407715,
-0.1553703099489212,
0.6878568530082703,
-0.732823371887207,
0.308463454246521,
0.25482022762298584,
0.34056803584098816,
-0.02713443711400032,
-0.7858714461326599,
-0.14665357768535614,
0.1686587780714035,
0.27621981501579285,
-1.063508152961731,
0.38366860151290894,
0.5704233646392822,
0.5284334421157837,
0.3802644610404968,
0.44338440895080566,
0.7706382870674133,
-0.5217952132225037,
0.6615176200866699,
0.0408918596804142,
-1.3827128410339355,
0.5762917995452881,
-0.04362574964761734,
0.40441185235977173,
0.3206517994403839,
0.1188633069396019,
-0.004717935808002949,
-0.4287380874156952,
-0.4167320132255554,
-0.6799476742744446,
0.5049585700035095,
0.4314965605735779,
0.042584892362356186,
0.11082626134157181,
0.7139784693717957,
-0.029461009427905083,
0.2075166255235672,
0.04552524536848068,
-0.11836405843496323,
-0.6760633587837219,
-0.2864457070827484,
0.0641278326511383,
-0.03781446814537048,
0.10101797431707382,
-0.1092996746301651,
0.5877273678779602,
-0.34388068318367004,
0.23717746138572693,
0.5496242642402649,
-0.41677331924438477,
-0.13883152604103088,
0.16436222195625305,
0.15724971890449524,
0.377753347158432,
-0.2509150505065918,
0.26038017868995667,
0.24349811673164368,
-0.5823430418968201,
0.17612040042877197,
-0.018004899844527245,
-0.40961363911628723,
0.03205125033855438,
0.19640420377254486,
0.89205002784729,
0.27445974946022034,
-0.46277526021003723,
0.34357449412345886,
-0.01958937756717205,
-0.14983759820461273,
-0.106196328997612,
0.5224719047546387,
-0.11771876364946365,
0.40012243390083313,
0.5416361689567566,
0.24959991872310638,
0.4603523015975952,
-0.3727320432662964,
0.30776575207710266,
0.035627130419015884,
-0.21988195180892944,
-0.4927749037742615,
0.8304670453071594,
0.07113809883594513,
-0.38841548562049866,
0.4460216164588928,
-0.031032869592308998,
-0.5766435861587524,
0.6537703275680542,
0.8374276757240295,
0.6997330784797668,
-0.5303160548210144,
-0.08892800658941269,
0.26691555976867676,
0.2680375874042511,
-0.3291485607624054,
0.30750149488449097,
-0.1544310450553894,
-1.1781554222106934,
-0.394662469625473,
-0.7068179249763489,
-0.3112029433250427,
0.025095896795392036,
-0.8741351962089539,
0.10030020028352737,
-0.34110504388809204,
-0.34162431955337524,
0.02346704714000225,
-0.4538065791130066,
-1.0218536853790283,
0.5290043354034424,
-0.2444283366203308,
1.1511378288269043,
-0.6160897016525269,
1.0626335144042969,
0.6892909407615662,
-0.1989445835351944,
-0.7395133972167969,
0.053465042263269424,
-0.09528128802776337,
-0.3124254047870636,
0.6173521876335144,
-0.1817975640296936,
-0.6499367356300354,
0.20125751197338104,
-0.5084307193756104,
-1.0744770765304565,
0.9198600053787231,
0.5795456171035767,
-0.8952314257621765,
0.3228754997253418,
-0.10079296678304672,
0.47624626755714417,
-0.5061123967170715,
0.24204517900943756,
0.7712472677230835,
0.313547283411026,
0.11578987538814545,
-0.9701296091079712,
0.12513579428195953,
-0.4829237759113312,
0.21120432019233704,
0.0016341914888471365,
-0.634704053401947,
0.4780143201351166,
-0.11901647597551346,
-0.10895231366157532,
0.23271726071834564,
0.8603131175041199,
-0.0075547341257333755,
-0.12402355670928955,
0.7917088270187378,
0.32959437370300293,
0.6403115391731262,
-0.0004867181705776602,
1.013025164604187,
-0.484804630279541,
0.010462854988873005,
1.0816690921783447,
-0.1441946178674698,
1.0363341569900513,
0.5376951694488525,
-0.0844813883304596,
0.3394392132759094,
0.3184751868247986,
-0.0026005085092037916,
0.9419562220573425,
0.36156365275382996,
-0.2969893515110016,
-0.3119235336780548,
0.26700282096862793,
-0.07611507922410965,
0.5576418042182922,
0.6724231243133545,
-0.2424555867910385,
0.1862344592809677,
0.09912032634019852,
-0.15825794637203217,
0.08255137503147125,
-0.3173612654209137,
0.5203138589859009,
-0.04965989291667938,
-0.3344576954841614,
0.6784985661506653,
0.3242042064666748,
0.8440686464309692,
-0.6381024122238159,
-0.04930209368467331,
-0.17075543105602264,
0.33902063965797424,
-0.3109886348247528,
-0.07002275437116623,
0.15148590505123138,
0.06522218883037567,
-0.293637752532959,
-0.016629159450531006,
0.7385064363479614,
-0.4288838505744934,
-0.31623169779777527,
0.26879262924194336,
0.11530999839305878,
0.2709053158760071,
0.02575494349002838,
-0.3906151056289673,
0.34868094325065613,
-0.10100364685058594,
-0.37844663858413696,
0.19875288009643555,
0.15297071635723114,
0.21848057210445404,
0.556678831577301,
0.7167018055915833,
0.2266460806131363,
0.305882066488266,
0.25338059663772583,
0.866865873336792,
-0.5053603649139404,
-0.8102378845214844,
-0.5200187563896179,
0.49384334683418274,
0.016413137316703796,
-0.04707400128245354,
0.469666987657547,
0.30216026306152344,
0.7383319139480591,
-0.21465067565441132,
0.7683054208755493,
-0.16169416904449463,
0.4588712453842163,
-0.8020316958427429,
0.7325117588043213,
-0.29544469714164734,
0.6523983478546143,
-0.19551298022270203,
-0.6837341785430908,
-0.2989685535430908,
0.7487351894378662,
-0.04189131781458855,
-0.0857706293463707,
0.5405508875846863,
1.1359190940856934,
-0.07390986382961273,
0.14000307023525238,
0.364492803812027,
0.3604566752910614,
0.4015251100063324,
0.20457249879837036,
0.46173232793807983,
-0.56471848487854,
0.3172725737094879,
-0.5043386220932007,
-0.23092207312583923,
-0.10911646485328674,
-1.0113885402679443,
-0.7501795887947083,
-0.4798707962036133,
-0.5229387283325195,
-0.537398636341095,
0.6644810438156128,
0.8138903379440308,
0.9475102424621582,
-1.1644221544265747,
-0.14558614790439606,
0.025121383368968964,
-0.13914942741394043,
-0.519500732421875,
-0.17659682035446167,
0.4444945454597473,
-0.19696983695030212,
-0.6848023533821106,
0.9318181276321411,
-0.18334949016571045,
0.017825381830334663,
-0.03808867186307907,
-0.2835642099380493,
0.3577580153942108,
0.2646442651748657,
0.3276257812976837,
0.27611446380615234,
-0.6674428582191467,
-0.3322250545024872,
-0.030274443328380585,
0.31863662600517273,
-0.06680118292570114,
0.9528580904006958,
-1.0576969385147095,
0.5165225863456726,
0.48700717091560364,
0.6798052787780762,
0.8266273140907288,
-0.01387447863817215,
0.6692940592765808,
-0.6341238021850586,
0.2241600751876831,
0.2455844283103943,
0.45070186257362366,
0.49107229709625244,
-0.5741578340530396,
0.4363240897655487,
0.2132699191570282,
-0.10803525149822235,
-0.7583377361297607,
0.1377626210451126,
-0.45674166083335876,
-0.2701527178287506,
1.0040831565856934,
-0.24611406028270721,
-0.41165030002593994,
0.042943306267261505,
0.3466138243675232,
0.25982388854026794,
-0.633251965045929,
0.6059110760688782,
0.2503332495689392,
-0.011502176523208618,
-0.22860077023506165,
-0.22197410464286804,
0.4231528341770172,
0.36327433586120605,
-0.3068290054798126,
-0.37727856636047363,
0.48746010661125183,
0.6274498105049133,
-0.015871020033955574,
0.653281033039093,
-0.1396176517009735,
0.2565099895000458,
0.20666514337062836,
0.029089855030179024,
-0.09524009376764297,
-0.4045920968055725,
-0.4972201883792877,
0.4186001121997833,
-0.15712082386016846,
-0.3243386447429657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00390v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00390v2
|
CofiPara: A Coarse-to-fine Paradigm for Multimodal Sarcasm Target Identification with Large Multimodal Models
| 2024-05-01T08:44:44 | 2024-05-20T07:25:27 |
Hongzhan Lin, Zixin Chen, Ziyang Luo, Mingfei Cheng, Jing Ma, Guang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social media abounds with multimodal sarcasm, and identifying sarcasm targets
is particularly challenging due to the implicit incongruity not directly
evident in the text and image modalities. Current methods for Multimodal
Sarcasm Target Identification (MSTI) predominantly focus on superficial
indicators in an end-to-end manner, overlooking the nuanced understanding of
multimodal sarcasm conveyed through both the text and image. This paper
proposes a versatile MSTI framework with a coarse-to-fine paradigm, by
augmenting sarcasm explainability with reasoning and pre-training knowledge.
Inspired by the powerful capacity of Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) on
multimodal reasoning, we first engage LMMs to generate competing rationales for
coarser-grained pre-training of a small language model on multimodal sarcasm
detection. We then propose fine-tuning the model for finer-grained sarcasm
target identification. Our framework is thus empowered to adeptly unveil the
intricate targets within multimodal sarcasm and mitigate the negative impact
posed by potential noise inherently in LMMs. Experimental results demonstrate
that our model far outperforms state-of-the-art MSTI methods, and markedly
exhibits explainability in deciphering sarcasm as well.
|
[
-0.3793790936470032,
-0.9254732728004456,
0.49193936586380005,
0.3790188431739807,
-0.24983307719230652,
-0.14531873166561127,
-0.44652655720710754,
-0.31555095314979553,
0.16814355552196503,
-0.14183871448040009,
-0.9389021992683411,
-0.012606709264218807,
-0.5606945753097534,
-0.023258419707417488,
-0.12363308668136597,
1.228244423866272,
0.24229565262794495,
-0.07301639020442963,
0.04189635068178177,
0.07040824741125107,
-0.27257680892944336,
-0.24579690396785736,
-0.9732256531715393,
-0.015768053010106087,
1.0223044157028198,
0.46660372614860535,
0.6390320658683777,
0.07544361799955368,
0.704550564289093,
0.31741800904273987,
0.14066070318222046,
0.19989101588726044,
-0.5865563750267029,
-0.15729248523712158,
-0.26529785990715027,
-0.40580424666404724,
-0.2608206570148468,
-0.02779511734843254,
0.2359972596168518,
0.1936206817626953,
0.33394742012023926,
0.3363109230995178,
-0.15100082755088806,
0.05802541226148605,
-0.9048532843589783,
0.07366188615560532,
-0.4713079333305359,
0.165217325091362,
-0.4057355523109436,
-0.5760207176208496,
-0.6097287535667419,
0.012550385668873787,
-0.302421510219574,
-0.49572232365608215,
0.152101069688797,
-0.10549674928188324,
1.0299813747406006,
0.4966386556625366,
-0.5234529376029968,
-0.16908615827560425,
-0.5474936366081238,
0.7641221284866333,
-0.39051398634910583,
0.3720523715019226,
0.040129221975803375,
0.8204663991928101,
0.08138206601142883,
-0.585682213306427,
-0.3896116614341736,
-0.3352716267108917,
-0.2755948603153229,
0.047474972903728485,
-0.17593589425086975,
-0.03138667717576027,
0.371699720621109,
0.251177042722702,
-0.5714825987815857,
-0.3175894320011139,
-0.07487267255783081,
-0.41264450550079346,
0.2712222933769226,
-0.02572578564286232,
0.21471722424030304,
-0.24868644773960114,
-0.8447666764259338,
0.4235747754573822,
0.04675959050655365,
0.3490523099899292,
0.24530401825904846,
0.300091952085495,
-0.4279087483882904,
0.3491198718547821,
-0.30498799681663513,
0.2011028528213501,
0.37868109345436096,
-0.4175582528114319,
0.24201901257038116,
-0.4216037392616272,
-0.20105516910552979,
-0.32745853066444397,
0.7590785026550293,
0.13438962399959564,
0.4618820250034332,
-0.14368164539337158,
-0.248075932264328,
0.20192256569862366,
0.2622894048690796,
-0.6138937473297119,
-0.07533592730760574,
-0.13873326778411865,
-0.36338722705841064,
-0.4155442714691162,
-0.206399068236351,
-0.9347689747810364,
-0.2963009476661682,
-0.16140708327293396,
0.594113826751709,
-0.608544647693634,
-0.44089263677597046,
-0.23407411575317383,
-0.5495036244392395,
0.19383376836776733,
0.3790442943572998,
-0.6327328085899353,
-0.03277811035513878,
0.5670161843299866,
0.793368399143219,
0.3865797817707062,
-0.37992873787879944,
-0.5536351203918457,
0.2518315315246582,
0.04363783821463585,
0.7760599255561829,
-0.6739076972007751,
0.2548797130584717,
-0.3453531861305237,
-0.2086792141199112,
-0.26290392875671387,
0.049961671233177185,
0.804982602596283,
-0.30821657180786133,
-0.22499613463878632,
-0.19393596053123474,
0.18547509610652924,
-0.24167852103710175,
0.6623522043228149,
-0.5929372906684875,
0.9640060663223267,
0.31444862484931946,
-0.9851071238517761,
0.20939324796199799,
-0.6549472212791443,
-0.44175985455513,
-0.11222773045301437,
-0.10710468888282776,
-0.08184777200222015,
0.36665764451026917,
0.2941585183143616,
0.6393251419067383,
-0.5144961476325989,
0.7066895365715027,
-0.5924959778785706,
-0.4654447138309479,
0.3497020900249481,
-1.2437000274658203,
0.7919255495071411,
0.5921192765235901,
-0.4449848532676697,
-0.09750618040561676,
-0.547818124294281,
-0.04696432128548622,
0.14023344218730927,
0.020816771313548088,
-0.3645644187927246,
-0.489009290933609,
0.11560320109128952,
0.5495003461837769,
0.3665233254432678,
-0.1626095026731491,
-0.3410278856754303,
0.03317640349268913,
0.48088887333869934,
0.6956273913383484,
-0.27877548336982727,
0.4442538917064667,
-0.2725078761577606,
0.45634132623672485,
0.2875215709209442,
0.7340669631958008,
-0.466413289308548,
-0.18569320440292358,
-0.7066973447799683,
-1.1664713621139526,
0.09398090094327927,
0.316815584897995,
-1.0003831386566162,
-0.1273990124464035,
-0.4585360586643219,
-0.49715080857276917,
-0.4547044336795807,
-0.08490478247404099,
0.6624067425727844,
0.6009228229522705,
0.4465077519416809,
-0.15803085267543793,
-0.32944798469543457,
-1.1748987436294556,
-0.7455571293830872,
0.10301590710878372,
0.32963162660598755,
0.3664570450782776,
0.4921503961086273,
-0.23965057730674744,
0.7543358206748962,
-0.30737289786338806,
-0.23620131611824036,
-0.18305642902851105,
0.3331569731235504,
-0.0913931354880333,
0.3966321647167206,
0.5996754765510559,
-1.0491745471954346,
-0.4670120179653168,
-0.11094515025615692,
-0.6812238097190857,
-0.11625106632709503,
-0.3623565435409546,
-0.26863446831703186,
-0.2624163031578064,
0.4699800908565521,
-0.7108954191207886,
0.5031481385231018,
0.11440686881542206,
-0.37328243255615234,
0.6654510498046875,
0.3148011565208435,
0.590627133846283,
-1.0377172231674194,
0.13590404391288757,
0.36669525504112244,
-0.3560733497142792,
-0.6949897408485413,
0.499784916639328,
-0.05763143673539162,
-0.14779561758041382,
-0.585280179977417,
0.7105258107185364,
-0.11504792422056198,
0.18064087629318237,
0.24962453544139862,
-0.3071286976337433,
0.1955496370792389,
0.8416120409965515,
-0.34519511461257935,
0.6319233775138855,
0.33249446749687195,
-0.35033807158470154,
0.25450605154037476,
-0.3080866038799286,
0.08135820180177689,
1.2079097032546997,
-0.5015319585800171,
-0.13145117461681366,
-0.19190502166748047,
0.5367156863212585,
-1.1569383144378662,
-0.685580313205719,
0.5525057911872864,
-0.6210514903068542,
0.26135095953941345,
-0.3249185383319855,
-0.3242064118385315,
-0.41987791657447815,
-0.4328921139240265,
0.9342784881591797,
0.0428466796875,
-0.5732021331787109,
1.0049543380737305,
-0.12481825798749924,
-0.13555452227592468,
-0.8685382008552551,
-0.7267509698867798,
0.039533521980047226,
-0.40741655230522156,
-0.8542951345443726,
0.17007073760032654,
-0.2107275277376175,
-0.13196657598018646,
-0.3897608816623688,
0.14728206396102905,
-0.5249894857406616,
0.056996092200279236,
0.2111864686012268,
0.10038503259420395,
-0.2342953383922577,
0.18037159740924835,
0.19794881343841553,
-0.23695290088653564,
-0.10880587995052338,
0.23034150898456573,
0.560613751411438,
-0.271838903427124,
-0.3290804922580719,
-0.9437748789787292,
0.4929649829864502,
0.7504384517669678,
-0.23977117240428925,
0.338725209236145,
1.3897989988327026,
-0.40892493724823,
0.1471555083990097,
-0.6720871329307556,
-0.05764877796173096,
-0.4929543137550354,
0.32099565863609314,
-0.904394805431366,
-0.5963917374610901,
0.29573366045951843,
-0.3624640703201294,
-0.4535227417945862,
0.41760995984077454,
0.45774760842323303,
-0.016083160415291786,
1.117537260055542,
0.6855714321136475,
-0.008450839668512344,
0.46202293038368225,
0.002786973724141717,
0.19786867499351501,
-0.49725341796875,
-0.25563034415245056,
-0.5220232605934143,
-0.42894500494003296,
-0.12935906648635864,
-0.5775133967399597,
0.2637525498867035,
-0.06616378575563431,
-0.5059508681297302,
0.13426560163497925,
-0.06034046411514282,
0.5173274874687195,
0.4950128495693207,
0.4177013039588928,
0.179561048746109,
0.04549937695264816,
0.04755237698554993,
-0.024511221796274185,
-0.47623273730278015,
-0.18463046848773956,
0.5236697793006897,
0.5555171370506287,
0.8234952688217163,
0.15522998571395874,
0.48835399746894836,
0.3900240361690521,
0.3151282072067261,
-0.9020636081695557,
0.40274131298065186,
-0.22962521016597748,
-0.8458254337310791,
0.06180739775300026,
-0.6300285458564758,
-0.12159866839647293,
0.011832389049232006,
-0.15767741203308105,
-0.39434579014778137,
0.1671239137649536,
0.3597102165222168,
-0.47687214612960815,
0.04585302621126175,
-1.1333057880401611,
1.0169066190719604,
-0.2668549716472626,
-0.4222499430179596,
-0.2024269998073578,
-0.838405191898346,
0.5666866302490234,
0.0994027778506279,
0.6207876801490784,
-0.23855073750019073,
0.011280202306807041,
0.2286963015794754,
-0.10646618902683258,
1.229477047920227,
-0.3804304599761963,
-0.006612978409975767,
0.16967277228832245,
0.017035501077771187,
0.38800734281539917,
0.3461158275604248,
-0.134995236992836,
0.324140340089798,
-0.11405893415212631,
-0.60134357213974,
-0.5009380578994751,
0.7305907011032104,
-0.5489398837089539,
-0.2754330039024353,
-0.13257648050785065,
-0.81391441822052,
-0.10960032045841217,
0.27076074481010437,
0.4292278587818146,
0.6998386383056641,
-0.26933568716049194,
-0.08485114574432373,
0.431745320558548,
0.08488713949918747,
0.4607701897621155,
0.009198534302413464,
0.5393747687339783,
-0.40550360083580017,
1.1642825603485107,
-0.24813805520534515,
0.10054801404476166,
0.4551047086715698,
0.11677667498588562,
-0.13710863888263702,
0.07146025449037552,
-0.3513059914112091,
0.22875343263149261,
-0.9054833650588989,
-0.3016030192375183,
-0.6471990942955017,
-0.16166004538536072,
-0.5430594682693481,
-0.6121630668640137,
-0.4300812780857086,
-0.3060704469680786,
-0.37547117471694946,
0.43710455298423767,
0.14630958437919617,
0.1863761693239212,
-0.11161146312952042,
0.5319250822067261,
-0.36029312014579773,
0.5054783821105957,
0.3080684542655945,
0.19978946447372437,
-0.06574618816375732,
-0.7406312227249146,
-0.06617427617311478,
0.326736181974411,
-0.07275441288948059,
-0.6531522870063782,
0.22602641582489014,
0.5098634362220764,
0.2281937599182129,
0.7022033929824829,
-0.015086829662322998,
1.0096709728240967,
-0.4244726300239563,
0.4788115322589874,
0.5938431620597839,
-0.8551974296569824,
0.4395749866962433,
-0.47572794556617737,
0.2860298156738281,
0.8027487993240356,
0.589324951171875,
-0.2272467464208603,
-0.32246583700180054,
-0.4628407657146454,
-0.5521490573883057,
0.507377028465271,
-0.15900537371635437,
0.5249021053314209,
-0.14128588140010834,
0.36586034297943115,
0.2950563430786133,
0.24562302231788635,
-1.1051849126815796,
0.1485845297574997,
-0.27043449878692627,
-0.6962525248527527,
-0.0802818238735199,
-0.20086991786956787,
-0.39573559165000916,
-0.2580034136772156,
0.43597841262817383,
-0.5582582950592041,
0.4476505517959595,
-0.07305612415075302,
-0.5348095893859863,
-0.01507672481238842,
0.4742743968963623,
0.6496092677116394,
0.25987422466278076,
0.03145020827651024,
0.5355662703514099,
-0.10302101820707321,
-0.3035695254802704,
0.003488482441753149,
0.18130460381507874,
-0.04037142172455788,
-0.09549378603696823,
0.37103530764579773,
0.7006708383560181,
0.4433363974094391,
-0.5213912725448608,
0.9979919791221619,
-0.1377594769001007,
-0.059340838342905045,
-0.2477288395166397,
-0.062594935297966,
-0.3242838382720947,
0.6935112476348877,
0.28631046414375305,
0.7818266749382019,
0.3816045820713043,
-0.6591102480888367,
0.10202042013406754,
0.5759992599487305,
-0.7460771799087524,
-0.6011587381362915,
0.3496135473251343,
0.2172430008649826,
-0.09265367686748505,
0.1280599981546402,
-0.24004361033439636,
-0.5697212219238281,
0.6372023820877075,
0.4710578918457031,
0.820487380027771,
-0.1452692598104477,
0.6053012609481812,
0.18472512066364288,
0.5054489374160767,
0.06352312862873077,
0.25649386644363403,
-0.2860777676105499,
-0.35241538286209106,
-0.15395572781562805,
-0.506554126739502,
0.20908120274543762,
-0.1256982982158661,
-0.6443085074424744,
0.6875004768371582,
-0.5941377282142639,
-0.2909854054450989,
0.471677303314209,
-0.5305935740470886,
-0.8430725932121277,
0.5749640464782715,
0.2536957859992981,
0.9033753871917725,
-1.0003046989440918,
0.3530902862548828,
0.3992348909378052,
-0.6803433895111084,
-0.6996710896492004,
0.23814302682876587,
0.19432467222213745,
-0.80552738904953,
0.6459714770317078,
0.45985138416290283,
-0.31796279549598694,
0.12322844564914703,
-0.7585126161575317,
-0.5365272164344788,
0.9447243809700012,
0.8016210794448853,
-0.18918173015117645,
-0.1737467348575592,
0.061130400747060776,
0.5147629976272583,
-0.36467432975769043,
0.8483120203018188,
0.38537105917930603,
0.6078753471374512,
0.37196627259254456,
-0.8645901679992676,
0.19994431734085083,
-0.27905574440956116,
-0.28673896193504333,
0.13177606463432312,
-1.0183674097061157,
1.0825754404067993,
-0.41698288917541504,
-0.023433808237314224,
-0.06763476133346558,
0.3305664658546448,
-0.12803055346012115,
0.7350521087646484,
0.5516793131828308,
0.7051848769187927,
0.43379655480384827,
-0.1598701924085617,
0.9533100724220276,
0.1437041163444519,
0.3171969950199127,
1.115022897720337,
0.15625770390033722,
0.6743453741073608,
0.6923819780349731,
0.3015556335449219,
0.5741002559661865,
0.6388883590698242,
0.14817528426647186,
0.6074267029762268,
-0.27003902196884155,
-0.3028988838195801,
-0.47493648529052734,
-0.39893946051597595,
-0.29556894302368164,
0.612596869468689,
0.4254074692726135,
-0.4749094843864441,
-0.4653892517089844,
0.26267820596694946,
0.1547158658504486,
-0.2310158759355545,
-0.5275927186012268,
0.6006883978843689,
-0.047793660312891006,
-0.466519832611084,
0.7197369933128357,
0.03044753149151802,
0.9782320261001587,
-0.4956164062023163,
0.18699216842651367,
-0.12858547270298004,
0.22512181103229523,
-0.22631072998046875,
-0.28951436281204224,
0.27505138516426086,
-0.020339863374829292,
-0.29122933745384216,
0.14424622058868408,
0.953130841255188,
-0.4426989257335663,
-0.45683369040489197,
0.17194479703903198,
0.267196387052536,
-0.08686631172895432,
-0.21823877096176147,
-1.0703938007354736,
-0.007906393148005009,
-0.2740404009819031,
-0.07635781913995743,
0.03449154645204544,
0.9143260717391968,
-0.1916406750679016,
0.6149083971977234,
0.3925595283508301,
-0.49583181738853455,
-0.09753728657960892,
0.30773404240608215,
1.0743151903152466,
-0.4400884211063385,
-0.5781676769256592,
-0.8925175666809082,
0.6907600164413452,
-0.18911567330360413,
-0.48618432879447937,
0.4517700970172882,
0.13484281301498413,
0.5076325535774231,
-0.27157333493232727,
0.6139932870864868,
-0.2515370845794678,
0.15294577181339264,
-0.2857446074485779,
0.4436497092247009,
-1.0203436613082886,
-0.14740882813930511,
-0.46096616983413696,
-0.5859187841415405,
-0.2671366333961487,
0.4102027714252472,
-0.25240394473075867,
0.4383144676685333,
0.7916561961174011,
0.9283249974250793,
-0.584287166595459,
0.05573777109384537,
0.3556692898273468,
0.23077864944934845,
-0.05960556119680405,
0.708289384841919,
0.9872114062309265,
-0.3354613482952118,
0.8501767516136169,
-0.2080407291650772,
-0.6126208901405334,
-0.4570169746875763,
-0.7251869440078735,
-1.134451985359192,
-0.3161781132221222,
-0.12394311279058456,
-0.16988003253936768,
0.10158827155828476,
0.9661393761634827,
0.7226619720458984,
-0.4929666817188263,
0.34653282165527344,
0.18279197812080383,
-0.047427691519260406,
-0.2516939342021942,
-0.2935038208961487,
-0.0247891154140234,
-0.5347679853439331,
-0.6240086555480957,
0.0675162747502327,
0.5468940138816833,
-0.3436294496059418,
-0.1639275997877121,
-0.021200308576226234,
-0.45970359444618225,
0.5259072780609131,
0.690916895866394,
0.15697960555553436,
-0.7215806841850281,
-0.4357282519340515,
0.01710089109838009,
-0.2871158719062805,
-0.1569804549217224,
0.8100064396858215,
-0.3317193388938904,
0.28841909766197205,
0.3768356442451477,
0.5212321877479553,
0.02246127836406231,
-0.18088002502918243,
0.1562480330467224,
-1.122867226600647,
0.553264856338501,
0.10382509976625443,
0.29684945940971375,
0.29343563318252563,
-0.6519981026649475,
0.37025487422943115,
0.45817211270332336,
-0.09724991768598557,
-0.9190502166748047,
0.3831605315208435,
-1.1374177932739258,
-0.3061269521713257,
1.1429955959320068,
-0.23674657940864563,
-0.4002849757671356,
-0.2879044711589813,
-0.44859811663627625,
0.31901028752326965,
-0.3749806582927704,
0.831670880317688,
0.47414740920066833,
0.2512943148612976,
-0.316549152135849,
-0.33975353837013245,
0.5037037134170532,
0.4824683666229248,
-0.7759103178977966,
-0.23804450035095215,
0.5401967167854309,
0.16590802371501923,
0.35874056816101074,
0.8531925678253174,
-0.11445682495832443,
0.6949886679649353,
0.14498817920684814,
-0.09055482596158981,
0.0420459620654583,
-0.8790088891983032,
-0.06691285967826843,
0.39118126034736633,
-0.28037795424461365,
0.3030354380607605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.15787v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.15787v1
|
Extracting chemical food safety hazards from the scientific literature automatically using large language models
| 2024-05-01T08:02:10 | 2024-05-01T08:02:10 |
Neris Özen, Wenjuan Mu, Esther D. van Asselt, Leonieke M. van den Bulk
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
The number of scientific articles published in the domain of food safety has
consistently been increasing over the last few decades. It has therefore become
unfeasible for food safety experts to read all relevant literature related to
food safety and the occurrence of hazards in the food chain. However, it is
important that food safety experts are aware of the newest findings and can
access this information in an easy and concise way. In this study, an approach
is presented to automate the extraction of chemical hazards from the scientific
literature through large language models. The large language model was used
out-of-the-box and applied on scientific abstracts; no extra training of the
models or a large computing cluster was required. Three different styles of
prompting the model were tested to assess which was the most optimal for the
task at hand. The prompts were optimized with two validation foods (leafy
greens and shellfish) and the final performance of the best prompt was
evaluated using three test foods (dairy, maize and salmon). The specific
wording of the prompt was found to have a considerable effect on the results. A
prompt breaking the task down into smaller steps performed best overall. This
prompt reached an average accuracy of 93% and contained many chemical
contaminants already included in food monitoring programs, validating the
successful retrieval of relevant hazards for the food safety domain. The
results showcase how valuable large language models can be for the task of
automatic information extraction from the scientific literature.
|
[
0.05420655384659767,
-0.6940933465957642,
0.6994458436965942,
0.05047178268432617,
0.05260787531733513,
-0.3407006859779358,
-0.12183501571416855,
-0.7585515379905701,
-0.07040287554264069,
0.4451321065425873,
-0.17259961366653442,
-0.5314538478851318,
-0.6959903836250305,
0.5829668045043945,
-0.6903785467147827,
0.8688535094261169,
-0.31393009424209595,
-0.037734366953372955,
0.03455301374197006,
0.5581674575805664,
-0.34082573652267456,
-0.2805180549621582,
-0.5565212965011597,
0.21191325783729553,
0.6412585377693176,
0.36950552463531494,
0.3908650875091553,
0.45842573046684265,
0.41448572278022766,
0.36853620409965515,
-0.04956405982375145,
-0.027087386697530746,
0.20083095133304596,
0.3997577130794525,
-0.6150974631309509,
-0.1705804020166397,
-0.18362219631671906,
0.15084953606128693,
0.15143650770187378,
0.42718830704689026,
0.12561744451522827,
0.27880212664604187,
0.14743387699127197,
0.6105954647064209,
-0.5743440389633179,
0.529604434967041,
-0.4423275291919708,
0.14954949915409088,
0.3791322112083435,
-0.31388697028160095,
-0.5468424558639526,
-0.6327219009399414,
0.2380836457014084,
-0.7336548566818237,
-0.3516058325767517,
0.21039064228534698,
0.7994447350502014,
-0.04111040383577347,
-0.49498775601387024,
-0.5893661379814148,
-0.7019099593162537,
0.7257615923881531,
-0.6258590817451477,
0.1906823068857193,
0.4720967411994934,
0.4866380989551544,
-0.4313417375087738,
-0.6139575242996216,
-0.4509716331958771,
-0.6825741529464722,
0.09078942984342575,
-0.11306438595056534,
0.005402629263699055,
-0.19041183590888977,
0.4444657564163208,
-0.08585108816623688,
-0.45463791489601135,
0.06615914404392242,
-0.3571837246417999,
-0.1533740609884262,
0.6063122749328613,
0.18427354097366333,
0.6274431943893433,
-0.22841030359268188,
-0.40177544951438904,
-0.38670673966407776,
-0.4836488962173462,
-0.04492875188589096,
-0.10357002168893814,
0.3922891318798065,
0.20624446868896484,
0.7334057092666626,
-0.3408149778842926,
0.32530251145362854,
-0.25730347633361816,
-0.30988001823425293,
0.10497730225324631,
-0.47481003403663635,
0.19766922295093536,
0.18461091816425323,
0.8919803500175476,
0.5197230577468872,
0.3305893838405609,
0.0553162507712841,
-0.18867142498493195,
-0.1773097813129425,
-0.013616111129522324,
-0.7075559496879578,
-0.37757378816604614,
0.2549285292625427,
-0.25823092460632324,
-0.3589189648628235,
-0.07157737761735916,
-0.9973622560501099,
-0.634340763092041,
-0.2093910425901413,
0.5155435800552368,
-0.23140981793403625,
-0.07861047238111496,
0.029563747346401215,
-0.2344249039888382,
-0.12836025655269623,
0.2925818860530853,
-0.7649065852165222,
0.1001230850815773,
0.440534383058548,
0.819363534450531,
-0.22054126858711243,
0.22677992284297943,
-0.6533105373382568,
0.4002973437309265,
0.04308440536260605,
0.8076156377792358,
-0.5168361067771912,
-0.23525512218475342,
-0.11363216489553452,
0.3477698266506195,
0.04390208050608635,
-0.39801710844039917,
0.5693565011024475,
-0.5149354338645935,
-0.09681415557861328,
-0.3884124159812927,
-0.2810344994068146,
-0.30364149808883667,
0.11128982156515121,
-0.6711627840995789,
0.8777673840522766,
-0.03887839615345001,
-0.6436366438865662,
0.3024686276912689,
-0.5566665530204773,
-0.7080190181732178,
0.0496821254491806,
-0.09877826273441315,
-0.14004330337047577,
-0.3533599376678467,
0.4144406318664551,
0.43402549624443054,
-0.6912568807601929,
0.43630844354629517,
-0.2974587678909302,
0.18038538098335266,
0.3283770680427551,
-0.4065031111240387,
0.4723702073097229,
0.28242403268814087,
-0.2916567623615265,
0.17658863961696625,
-0.4360464811325073,
0.06901799142360687,
0.16828873753547668,
-0.5825219750404358,
-0.32204312086105347,
0.08292525261640549,
0.261246919631958,
0.478716641664505,
0.1787802278995514,
-0.5217827558517456,
-0.06790032982826233,
-0.2031734436750412,
0.3626827597618103,
0.6799109578132629,
0.38819822669029236,
0.2684370279312134,
-0.29508450627326965,
0.39429450035095215,
-0.08467765897512436,
0.20882904529571533,
-0.32045137882232666,
-0.36869317293167114,
-0.1872192621231079,
-0.3061028718948364,
0.4888409674167633,
0.9352970719337463,
-0.7396936416625977,
0.9615693688392639,
-0.042675647884607315,
-0.5310669541358948,
0.10987178236246109,
-0.09205640852451324,
0.05141335353255272,
0.7284068465232849,
0.3648611903190613,
0.03403467684984207,
-0.4149608612060547,
-0.4600009620189667,
-0.2703549265861511,
-0.1296735256910324,
-0.11688993871212006,
0.04280813783407211,
0.611893355846405,
-0.11472316831350327,
0.9335333108901978,
-0.9254416227340698,
0.2758820354938507,
-0.10788557678461075,
0.12460128217935562,
0.3218052089214325,
0.5284765362739563,
0.3532855212688446,
-0.6565994024276733,
-0.8652363419532776,
0.4701876640319824,
-0.8531246781349182,
-0.18506036698818207,
0.2121470868587494,
-0.20674175024032593,
0.21712270379066467,
0.6145212054252625,
-0.6110813021659851,
0.3126169741153717,
0.23659110069274902,
-0.030142225325107574,
0.8878778219223022,
-0.1145835667848587,
0.20947299897670746,
-0.9186504483222961,
0.5780823826789856,
0.514034628868103,
0.05792014300823212,
-0.5100096464157104,
-0.1677245795726776,
0.13202181458473206,
-0.2530228793621063,
-0.43897372484207153,
0.7519939541816711,
-0.523678183555603,
0.21793468296527863,
-0.17369422316551208,
0.029115628451108932,
0.1998046189546585,
0.034479763358831406,
0.19596925377845764,
0.4613857567310333,
0.5640419721603394,
-0.7967395186424255,
0.5149473547935486,
0.005536225158721209,
-0.384572833776474,
0.0001839150208979845,
-0.6007562875747681,
-0.5001339912414551,
-0.2074868083000183,
0.5350123047828674,
-1.0536351203918457,
-0.3928035795688629,
0.6564165353775024,
0.04710416495800018,
0.16778810322284698,
-0.006114369258284569,
-0.7253154516220093,
-0.6160337924957275,
-0.057991769164800644,
-0.15455028414726257,
0.3465774357318878,
-0.33992695808410645,
0.5294877290725708,
0.6777572631835938,
-0.9290772676467896,
-0.3334791362285614,
-0.14527994394302368,
-0.08838814496994019,
-0.23279593884944916,
-0.2652147114276886,
-0.45275530219078064,
-0.2947821617126465,
-0.14895716309547424,
-0.356968492269516,
-0.4355556070804596,
-0.08460105210542679,
0.22812989354133606,
0.34749123454093933,
0.3373705744743347,
0.2121303826570511,
0.2137482613325119,
0.13745717704296112,
-0.24337612092494965,
0.3457678258419037,
-0.05662684515118599,
0.40933385491371155,
0.11300310492515564,
0.07980144023895264,
-0.6160467267036438,
0.5210731029510498,
0.6127452850341797,
-0.2949279546737671,
0.45376017689704895,
0.26903387904167175,
-0.5029112100601196,
0.11457737535238266,
-0.10564729571342468,
-0.3686327636241913,
-0.4992021322250366,
0.4051375389099121,
0.029591882601380348,
-0.13143840432167053,
0.14249083399772644,
-0.2832067012786865,
0.15520310401916504,
0.5751582384109497,
-0.021364770829677582,
-0.14978258311748505,
1.066288948059082,
0.2836105227470398,
-0.1930280476808548,
0.451117604970932,
0.11965969204902649,
0.12992748618125916,
-0.24207524955272675,
-0.4988992512226105,
-1.034546136856079,
0.36286085844039917,
-0.07802087813615799,
-0.38402169942855835,
0.7357480525970459,
-0.6105894446372986,
-0.42704150080680847,
0.32617413997650146,
-0.4766438901424408,
0.7805178761482239,
0.11823531240224838,
0.17704057693481445,
0.42344674468040466,
0.3673136532306671,
-0.39330151677131653,
0.18762387335300446,
-0.47540396451950073,
-0.6996192336082458,
0.5843163132667542,
0.6755695939064026,
0.9971581101417542,
-0.10713189840316772,
0.29623112082481384,
0.1677032858133316,
0.4359890818595886,
-0.8533546924591064,
0.6154730319976807,
-0.12784817814826965,
-0.7748281359672546,
-0.48314207792282104,
-0.5097178220748901,
-0.6564085483551025,
0.11218618601560593,
-0.41435110569000244,
-0.7090243101119995,
0.02859046868979931,
-0.03213786333799362,
-0.48697149753570557,
-0.01054480392485857,
-0.8645074367523193,
0.6460466384887695,
-0.5536154508590698,
-0.12290505319833755,
0.3806113004684448,
-0.919165313243866,
0.3284507691860199,
-0.4382898211479187,
0.5530489683151245,
-0.2894405722618103,
0.019468456506729126,
0.7447607517242432,
-0.22789061069488525,
1.0394423007965088,
-0.11370088905096054,
-0.597756028175354,
0.20611533522605896,
0.2227848470211029,
0.9141412973403931,
-0.23077604174613953,
-0.28392812609672546,
-0.14926402270793915,
0.12369032204151154,
0.03360757976770401,
-0.2509818971157074,
0.6086685061454773,
-0.2761439383029938,
-0.3686668574810028,
-0.8043114542961121,
-0.5164198875427246,
-0.11755720525979996,
0.540252685546875,
0.09768830239772797,
-0.02268274314701557,
-0.00926347728818655,
-0.18642671406269073,
0.577115535736084,
-0.5746906399726868,
0.6321064829826355,
0.7356716394424438,
-0.23990309238433838,
-0.18503427505493164,
0.8191884756088257,
0.22742298245429993,
0.06696406751871109,
0.33043548464775085,
0.45777595043182373,
-0.5524472594261169,
-0.23606322705745697,
-0.17749258875846863,
0.0037295965012162924,
-0.916876494884491,
-0.41003113985061646,
-1.0297695398330688,
-0.2695310115814209,
-0.45448005199432373,
-0.005092964507639408,
0.059468504041433334,
-0.19541700184345245,
-0.4726133644580841,
-0.16922132670879364,
0.4394056797027588,
0.6206810474395752,
0.06868305057287216,
0.0424874946475029,
-1.3111293315887451,
0.2740587890148163,
0.12238766998052597,
0.09091594070196152,
0.3033529818058014,
-0.24955150485038757,
-0.07452800869941711,
-0.09268795698881149,
-0.17909514904022217,
-1.2217520475387573,
0.7105273604393005,
0.08995412290096283,
0.6104452013969421,
0.43914705514907837,
0.3850261867046356,
0.32294806838035583,
-0.5404473543167114,
0.6214879751205444,
0.5551932454109192,
-0.7617255449295044,
0.6211249828338623,
-0.5204958915710449,
0.24357931315898895,
0.5871906280517578,
1.1013071537017822,
-0.6561757922172546,
-0.37214359641075134,
-0.06752808392047882,
-1.2630681991577148,
0.3961232304573059,
-0.14702068269252777,
-0.41231927275657654,
-0.3717750608921051,
-0.009310834109783173,
0.42428579926490784,
-0.13719020783901215,
-0.7033731341362,
0.11148223280906677,
0.25853922963142395,
-0.317474365234375,
0.03256760537624359,
-0.20277635753154755,
-0.2575245797634125,
-0.41623517870903015,
0.8546324968338013,
0.01825197972357273,
-0.03465303033590317,
0.17768047749996185,
-0.23966193199157715,
-0.49970486760139465,
0.40929317474365234,
0.3186328411102295,
0.45108094811439514,
-0.043812502175569534,
0.33918607234954834,
0.087299644947052,
-0.6197713613510132,
0.23087774217128754,
0.07886862754821777,
-0.016674449667334557,
-0.20953452587127686,
0.17071831226348877,
0.12838959693908691,
0.10495710372924805,
-0.9836583733558655,
0.33625632524490356,
-0.07899941504001617,
0.1446312963962555,
-0.3771102726459503,
0.20200344920158386,
-0.09898834675550461,
0.11304044723510742,
0.6303618550300598,
0.025023579597473145,
0.4553467035293579,
-0.509878396987915,
0.4926896095275879,
0.0907401442527771,
0.18806326389312744,
0.006553220562636852,
0.39624616503715515,
0.4728747308254242,
0.21948203444480896,
0.4320049583911896,
-0.0554240420460701,
-0.3834230601787567,
0.7921090126037598,
0.7760933637619019,
0.5484395027160645,
-0.4403454065322876,
0.37118902802467346,
0.7411116361618042,
0.30473262071609497,
-0.18851996958255768,
0.3301263451576233,
0.4102184772491455,
-0.24221141636371613,
-0.39182519912719727,
-0.7557974457740784,
-0.005422690417617559,
0.21937724947929382,
-0.36462026834487915,
0.07151541113853455,
-0.5562746524810791,
-0.058281298726797104,
0.5487872958183289,
-0.2715884745121002,
-0.26507899165153503,
0.10438904166221619,
-0.011784300208091736,
1.0009706020355225,
-1.3838788270950317,
0.3934597373008728,
0.6351205706596375,
-0.3593055009841919,
-0.7906438708305359,
0.14399805665016174,
0.04168272390961647,
-0.35182294249534607,
0.6877193450927734,
0.23490537703037262,
0.10562294721603394,
-0.2861056625843048,
-0.6180465221405029,
-1.1531099081039429,
0.7668846249580383,
0.19321811199188232,
-0.8619794845581055,
-0.23995357751846313,
0.07835211604833603,
0.3973662555217743,
-0.22829891741275787,
0.41744640469551086,
0.4093470871448517,
0.8868356347084045,
0.25359198451042175,
-0.8714118003845215,
0.4987562894821167,
-0.3320654034614563,
-0.15591908991336823,
0.04101944714784622,
-0.11764879524707794,
0.4455876350402832,
-0.16279329359531403,
-0.333861380815506,
-0.04156213998794556,
0.5709239840507507,
0.1842634230852127,
0.46403080224990845,
0.5162232518196106,
-0.15297085046768188,
0.7868126630783081,
0.16314345598220825,
0.833785891532898,
-0.03171415627002716,
0.09641262143850327,
1.0178099870681763,
-0.521690845489502,
0.8176907896995544,
0.3268905282020569,
-0.03357435390353203,
0.18476428091526031,
1.0073771476745605,
-0.12606240808963776,
0.7232040762901306,
0.1266927868127823,
-0.4303130507469177,
-0.04453359544277191,
-0.23424071073532104,
-0.3345482349395752,
0.14193929731845856,
0.6803306341171265,
-0.8695167303085327,
-0.4190162718296051,
0.19811569154262543,
0.214774027466774,
-0.2574302554130554,
-0.3139893114566803,
0.6495595574378967,
0.11348550021648407,
-0.7547863125801086,
0.41876503825187683,
0.023202549666166306,
0.05064832791686058,
-0.3711187243461609,
-0.37843719124794006,
0.20027892291545868,
-0.1926889270544052,
-0.1991567611694336,
-0.7893143892288208,
-0.021433964371681213,
0.07072804123163223,
-0.09124358743429184,
0.19479326903820038,
0.743442714214325,
-0.607532262802124,
-0.4949718117713928,
0.17913898825645447,
0.11900442093610764,
0.34157055616378784,
-0.11568272858858109,
-0.6399372816085815,
0.05334842950105667,
-0.23125135898590088,
-0.024912754073739052,
0.08407049626111984,
0.15045030415058136,
-0.20465274155139923,
0.5198336243629456,
0.7258613109588623,
-0.0282683577388525,
-0.059046268463134766,
-0.3524329364299774,
1.0104613304138184,
-0.6098475456237793,
-0.6550484299659729,
-0.46001848578453064,
0.5551692843437195,
-0.17646245658397675,
0.22416235506534576,
0.5333350300788879,
0.3053444027900696,
0.2598962187767029,
-0.44006824493408203,
0.9056847095489502,
-0.21923084557056427,
0.2147642970085144,
-0.5070024132728577,
0.8357551693916321,
-0.2747490704059601,
0.3492850661277771,
-0.46750348806381226,
-0.7383542656898499,
-0.24112235009670258,
0.5627787113189697,
-0.5460733771324158,
0.11495994031429291,
1.0194711685180664,
0.7778918743133545,
0.10123161226511002,
0.03432983160018921,
-0.12403171509504318,
0.4615473747253418,
0.21875372529029846,
0.2972899377346039,
0.5380957722663879,
-0.0397106297314167,
0.20710328221321106,
0.03421957790851593,
-0.4450909197330475,
-0.42781350016593933,
-1.1282399892807007,
-0.557037889957428,
-0.5498842597007751,
-0.5351077914237976,
-0.3604651987552643,
0.27161741256713867,
1.1221102476119995,
0.4342382848262787,
-0.7458460927009583,
0.04555715620517731,
0.17361755669116974,
0.00427979463711381,
-0.1999194473028183,
-0.20432597398757935,
0.4437289237976074,
-0.21302996575832367,
-0.3527202904224396,
0.4811420142650604,
0.09185527265071869,
0.21216100454330444,
0.2389131635427475,
0.19185875356197357,
-0.44166043400764465,
0.11623746901750565,
0.7899206280708313,
0.7501557469367981,
-0.33415231108665466,
-0.33585041761398315,
-0.3721314072608948,
-0.2949865162372589,
-0.360097199678421,
0.18381021916866302,
-0.11502579599618912,
0.490425169467926,
0.5184097290039062,
0.4332599639892578,
0.23881986737251282,
-0.12322170287370682,
0.610012948513031,
-0.5982171297073364,
-0.3557944595813751,
0.06937258690595627,
0.15893113613128662,
0.043931085616350174,
-0.8020941019058228,
0.3749893009662628,
0.010443032719194889,
-0.5079440474510193,
-0.7335095405578613,
0.10421506315469742,
-1.0340988636016846,
-0.47300294041633606,
1.4922157526016235,
-0.2475874423980713,
-0.6822871565818787,
-0.2744380831718445,
-0.2929043471813202,
0.4754399359226227,
-0.4305823743343353,
0.904227077960968,
0.4888909161090851,
0.11482615023851395,
0.04085633531212807,
-0.7170496582984924,
0.5767775774002075,
-0.04788963124155998,
-1.2748743295669556,
0.1656028926372528,
0.5951097011566162,
0.7087569236755371,
0.24891354143619537,
0.09090166538953781,
-0.3408631384372711,
0.3164255917072296,
-0.184121772646904,
0.27961546182632446,
0.23251107335090637,
-0.8113166093826294,
-0.19961044192314148,
0.17163850367069244,
-0.04151298478245735,
0.07833177596330643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00361v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00361v1
|
AdaMoLE: Fine-Tuning Large Language Models with Adaptive Mixture of Low-Rank Adaptation Experts
| 2024-05-01T07:33:43 | 2024-05-01T07:33:43 |
Zefang Liu, Jiahua Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce AdaMoLE, a novel method for fine-tuning large language models
(LLMs) through an Adaptive Mixture of Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) Experts.
Moving beyond conventional methods that employ a static top-k strategy for
activating experts, AdaMoLE dynamically adjusts the activation threshold using
a dedicated threshold network, adaptively responding to the varying
complexities of different tasks. By replacing a single LoRA in a layer with
multiple LoRA experts and integrating a gating function with the threshold
mechanism, AdaMoLE effectively selects and activates the most appropriate
experts based on the input context. Our extensive evaluations across a variety
of commonsense reasoning and natural language processing tasks show that
AdaMoLE exceeds baseline performance. This enhancement highlights the
advantages of AdaMoLE's adaptive selection of LoRA experts, improving model
effectiveness without a corresponding increase in the expert count. The
experimental validation not only confirms AdaMoLE as a robust approach for
enhancing LLMs but also suggests valuable directions for future research in
adaptive expert selection mechanisms, potentially broadening the scope for
optimizing model performance across diverse language processing tasks.
|
[
-0.47454285621643066,
-0.7402933835983276,
0.32416287064552307,
-0.04944118112325668,
-0.14090092480182648,
0.43695515394210815,
-0.5775818824768066,
-0.6797499060630798,
0.05699767544865608,
0.4156787395477295,
-0.09160599857568741,
-0.37990471720695496,
-0.6919206380844116,
0.17715641856193542,
-0.19071975350379944,
0.7636417150497437,
0.3098162114620209,
-0.28465646505355835,
-0.22030362486839294,
-0.24976256489753723,
-0.2554808557033539,
0.11136776208877563,
-1.1525063514709473,
-0.2757505178451538,
0.3861388564109802,
0.6433228850364685,
0.4712463319301605,
0.45867329835891724,
0.09890235215425491,
0.43710118532180786,
-0.4140997529029846,
0.43852803111076355,
-0.5895599722862244,
0.3932036757469177,
-0.49296826124191284,
-0.3666866719722748,
-0.9344145655632019,
-0.2223278135061264,
0.4031077027320862,
0.8178840279579163,
-0.16247065365314484,
0.14444683492183685,
0.4010452628135681,
0.5087334513664246,
-0.7809752821922302,
-0.31681880354881287,
-1.1636356115341187,
-0.1477711945772171,
0.12873652577400208,
-0.4337550103664398,
-0.4440079927444458,
-0.13366974890232086,
-0.11167510598897934,
-0.6137229204177856,
-0.12328571826219559,
0.342054545879364,
0.21419279277324677,
0.5614755153656006,
-0.14616236090660095,
-0.10930339246988297,
-0.8518639206886292,
0.945757269859314,
-0.995688259601593,
0.2592785060405731,
0.2520373463630676,
0.0524606816470623,
-0.11151547729969025,
-0.22687122225761414,
-0.3105534017086029,
-0.3980228304862976,
0.49345138669013977,
-0.18510518968105316,
-0.1586044579744339,
-0.07074020057916641,
-0.0823957622051239,
0.21311219036579132,
-0.09273035079240799,
0.5958248376846313,
-0.3209940493106842,
0.06840537488460541,
0.6135711669921875,
-0.2882683575153351,
0.18318170309066772,
0.38573935627937317,
-0.18701571226119995,
0.19793345034122467,
-0.4914611577987671,
0.09749637544155121,
0.44462376832962036,
0.5241865515708923,
0.06527774035930634,
0.1878044456243515,
-0.2910597324371338,
0.8229451775550842,
0.43989911675453186,
-0.2692376375198364,
0.07766520977020264,
-0.05640975385904312,
-0.21755492687225342,
0.3507043123245239,
0.6512491703033447,
0.22571901977062225,
0.36280640959739685,
-0.28717124462127686,
-0.26189544796943665,
-0.467235803604126,
0.2919566333293915,
-0.709576427936554,
-0.30182135105133057,
0.26096299290657043,
-0.00836971029639244,
-0.7095386385917664,
-0.5203173160552979,
-0.9273157119750977,
-0.6145029664039612,
-0.14989779889583588,
0.2112390100955963,
-0.3732016980648041,
-0.23578985035419464,
0.006612659431993961,
0.28022468090057373,
-0.21417060494422913,
0.42090195417404175,
-1.2142010927200317,
0.5745832324028015,
0.5848060846328735,
0.4787982106208801,
-0.12971051037311554,
-0.49365234375,
-0.873206615447998,
0.143137589097023,
-0.5624582767486572,
0.9940329194068909,
-0.9508662223815918,
0.002240784466266632,
-0.17357151210308075,
-0.3389951288700104,
-0.2344295233488083,
-0.7020972967147827,
0.7120826840400696,
-0.5040884613990784,
-0.026703061535954475,
-0.09778521955013275,
-0.4623260796070099,
-0.156793013215065,
0.28379666805267334,
-0.3727986216545105,
1.20158052444458,
0.1124109998345375,
-0.3934711217880249,
0.5415729284286499,
-0.8570291996002197,
-0.44102296233177185,
0.2262158989906311,
0.011989704333245754,
-0.07858427613973618,
0.23207210004329681,
0.5401305556297302,
0.4322744607925415,
-0.23240163922309875,
-0.18521341681480408,
-0.3117373585700989,
-0.20135937631130219,
0.20326918363571167,
-0.083274245262146,
0.5167864561080933,
0.09707604348659515,
-0.10768087953329086,
0.5656580924987793,
-1.101080298423767,
-0.13326166570186615,
0.020731158554553986,
-0.5405917167663574,
-0.7067150473594666,
0.3798812925815582,
-0.18226204812526703,
-0.009308596141636372,
0.3136960566043854,
-0.4645825922489166,
0.19780071079730988,
-0.515272855758667,
0.7077381610870361,
0.9927353858947754,
0.14021778106689453,
0.721609890460968,
-0.1588098108768463,
0.41182082891464233,
0.02949259616434574,
-0.020262060686945915,
0.2562576234340668,
-0.31489717960357666,
-0.8773412704467773,
-0.13017074763774872,
0.4323853552341461,
0.5158776044845581,
-0.7692928910255432,
0.6427512168884277,
-0.32449766993522644,
-0.3305686116218567,
-0.6194048523902893,
0.7507072687149048,
0.07079791277647018,
0.5046784281730652,
0.3097471594810486,
-0.08059804141521454,
-0.2329367697238922,
-0.6612693071365356,
-0.15792445838451385,
-0.013063370250165462,
0.26552897691726685,
0.3661106824874878,
0.31609874963760376,
0.1339469999074936,
0.6302251815795898,
0.010719671845436096,
-0.19824589788913727,
-0.5285906791687012,
0.07786288857460022,
0.371367871761322,
0.49142929911613464,
0.7178733348846436,
-0.41027751564979553,
-0.4203777313232422,
0.3836825489997864,
-0.38438642024993896,
-0.09666574001312256,
-0.18726849555969238,
-0.1058131754398346,
0.10207876563072205,
0.7274021506309509,
-0.05611862987279892,
-0.32621216773986816,
0.7363627552986145,
-0.23045314848423004,
0.24648205935955048,
-0.39831629395484924,
0.1278407871723175,
-1.17183256149292,
-0.04629979655146599,
0.0910729169845581,
-0.5161213874816895,
-0.7126435041427612,
0.27803874015808105,
-0.15252184867858887,
-0.023939987644553185,
-0.6314607858657837,
0.6650575399398804,
-0.3666432797908783,
-0.02737419307231903,
-0.32942628860473633,
0.3386160135269165,
-0.22087933123111725,
0.4367499053478241,
-0.5697228908538818,
1.0108306407928467,
0.941868245601654,
-0.8287169933319092,
0.2631121575832367,
0.3227786123752594,
-0.34859803318977356,
0.7370707988739014,
-0.5021329522132874,
0.4465485215187073,
0.041589900851249695,
-0.2660049796104431,
-0.8605356216430664,
-0.2437370866537094,
0.22536341845989227,
-0.2491448074579239,
0.24024489521980286,
-0.5973399877548218,
-0.18837568163871765,
-0.14902785420417786,
-0.2975331246852875,
0.4666632115840912,
0.47052475810050964,
-0.2381603717803955,
0.6905587911605835,
0.32044506072998047,
-0.5375143885612488,
-0.452735960483551,
-0.44000208377838135,
0.3853873610496521,
-0.14971423149108887,
-0.3371010720729828,
0.11578024923801422,
-0.11349622160196304,
-0.33714908361434937,
-0.008832139894366264,
-0.044812850654125214,
0.0066150035709142685,
0.5936146974563599,
-0.01588272489607334,
-0.046762652695178986,
-0.2568493187427521,
-0.08442974835634232,
0.3873162567615509,
-0.13809461891651154,
-0.21337468922138214,
-0.3991047143936157,
0.6253010034561157,
-0.08202138543128967,
-0.15465441346168518,
-0.22962193191051483,
0.10522583872079849,
0.5862125754356384,
-0.3650067448616028,
0.8611565828323364,
0.6872954368591309,
-0.367881715297699,
-0.6049660444259644,
-0.33802032470703125,
-0.03946837782859802,
-0.5034396648406982,
0.5699607133865356,
-0.4049060046672821,
-0.9324716329574585,
0.6009591817855835,
-0.27552324533462524,
0.11829551309347153,
0.3748866617679596,
0.6001697182655334,
0.12360985577106476,
0.8408353924751282,
0.5975873470306396,
-0.30572447180747986,
0.43186599016189575,
0.012582584284245968,
0.303049236536026,
-1.1312228441238403,
0.19557039439678192,
-0.4841475784778595,
-0.6201983094215393,
-0.41808539628982544,
-0.29021063446998596,
0.3866730332374573,
0.35071277618408203,
-0.10915542393922806,
0.0535203218460083,
-0.6238343119621277,
0.7639212012290955,
0.6155961751937866,
0.21681401133537292,
0.3051542341709137,
0.004423005506396294,
0.12248046696186066,
0.3334052562713623,
-0.6929832100868225,
-0.41967299580574036,
1.0723352432250977,
0.287566214799881,
0.8003037571907043,
0.14526879787445068,
0.7032133936882019,
0.6701712608337402,
-0.0346054770052433,
-0.7110018134117126,
0.8009630441665649,
-0.3274948000907898,
-0.45348575711250305,
-0.5338025093078613,
-0.21633663773536682,
-0.7609309554100037,
0.08296962827444077,
-0.5513421893119812,
-1.0322455167770386,
0.4149211347103119,
0.3637535572052002,
-0.915509819984436,
0.5185309648513794,
-0.43001532554626465,
0.47093266248703003,
-0.18207499384880066,
-0.5084291100502014,
-0.48962727189064026,
-0.19899074733257294,
0.04463338479399681,
-0.17001165449619293,
0.21129707992076874,
-0.4047148823738098,
-0.1792154312133789,
0.7670782208442688,
0.007930010557174683,
0.8610445857048035,
-0.21010349690914154,
-0.22320590913295746,
0.06684031337499619,
0.33812272548675537,
0.734932541847229,
-0.10216830670833588,
-0.4947618544101715,
-0.05129345878958702,
-0.15427061915397644,
-0.617784857749939,
-0.3068482577800751,
0.9324965476989746,
-0.9252801537513733,
-0.5281578898429871,
-0.10424446314573288,
-0.7420312166213989,
-0.4283052384853363,
0.38392987847328186,
-0.1062241867184639,
0.48770129680633545,
-0.09447383135557175,
0.3019150495529175,
0.5737391710281372,
-0.20310670137405396,
0.4964728355407715,
0.18359704315662384,
-0.12227465212345123,
-0.5779979825019836,
0.9997352957725525,
-0.2258942425251007,
0.3874140679836273,
0.2717097997665405,
0.10402815788984299,
0.14547240734100342,
-1.3381749391555786,
-0.610334038734436,
-0.05498872697353363,
-0.7647855281829834,
-0.08266838639974594,
-0.48759815096855164,
-0.11140459775924683,
-0.48344358801841736,
-0.3636641800403595,
-0.5271620154380798,
-0.33538374304771423,
-0.39968374371528625,
-0.06759301573038101,
0.3635979890823364,
0.5969194769859314,
0.14703795313835144,
0.2637676000595093,
-0.4725382924079895,
0.18045787513256073,
0.5538226366043091,
0.31300967931747437,
0.01302605215460062,
-0.8095452189445496,
-0.27868619561195374,
-0.07796122878789902,
0.005301968660205603,
-0.4866817891597748,
0.18682754039764404,
0.6849262118339539,
0.7091079354286194,
0.4523601830005646,
0.11743473261594772,
0.4108451306819916,
-0.6071485280990601,
0.5042832493782043,
-0.1702203005552292,
-0.9679728150367737,
0.37244802713394165,
-0.6018583178520203,
0.04205593839287758,
0.8890482187271118,
-0.040203601121902466,
-0.3027845025062561,
-0.44336339831352234,
-0.22970260679721832,
-0.8911508917808533,
0.6637927889823914,
0.07343978434801102,
0.3497511148452759,
0.31566935777664185,
0.3592621684074402,
0.32124727964401245,
0.10284999758005142,
-0.5869148373603821,
0.09667278081178665,
0.19193266332149506,
-0.3489297330379486,
0.14257103204727173,
-0.43421486020088196,
-0.44302263855934143,
-0.28549742698669434,
0.8809477090835571,
-0.493186891078949,
0.2730630338191986,
0.02142074517905712,
-0.4054526388645172,
-0.5788590908050537,
0.5940242409706116,
0.8600091934204102,
1.1080362796783447,
-0.3912159204483032,
0.14974893629550934,
0.7423347234725952,
-0.11163022369146347,
-0.06408464908599854,
0.3010704517364502,
-0.21510739624500275,
-0.611190915107727,
0.5137181282043457,
1.069618821144104,
0.454946905374527,
-0.4859340786933899,
0.05901801586151123,
0.21656844019889832,
-0.46103447675704956,
-0.1468820422887802,
0.6647183895111084,
-0.07434841245412827,
0.5411147475242615,
0.6546220779418945,
0.5862677693367004,
-0.018941855058073997,
-0.45074063539505005,
0.03203201666474342,
0.17750774323940277,
-0.27611976861953735,
-0.2935577929019928,
0.8890625834465027,
0.6628947257995605,
-0.4132464826107025,
0.126104936003685,
-0.38495934009552,
-0.32290738821029663,
0.36102041602134705,
0.5070204138755798,
0.762953519821167,
-0.35522890090942383,
0.05670104920864105,
0.1282709240913391,
0.3403850495815277,
0.18427851796150208,
0.06378994882106781,
0.10109205543994904,
-1.0882846117019653,
-0.6911547780036926,
-0.7338159680366516,
-0.5293793082237244,
0.12451709806919098,
-0.48132017254829407,
-0.020519189536571503,
-0.8109158277511597,
0.09385207295417786,
0.15145736932754517,
-0.12790651619434357,
-0.4206073582172394,
0.03218532353639603,
0.5183087587356567,
1.0624477863311768,
-0.9843377470970154,
0.7797623872756958,
0.9275979399681091,
0.0408010259270668,
-0.3028469979763031,
0.013133350759744644,
-0.2442585676908493,
-0.9123597145080566,
0.17537935078144073,
-0.30405470728874207,
-0.13111025094985962,
0.5045718550682068,
-0.5234118103981018,
-0.7587026953697205,
0.8894211649894714,
0.3273738622665405,
-0.6924066543579102,
0.15931513905525208,
0.009006639011204243,
0.5774909853935242,
-0.48547613620758057,
0.21324321627616882,
0.5771984457969666,
0.40502944588661194,
0.11597342044115067,
-0.7729705572128296,
0.051256511360406876,
-0.2747569680213928,
-0.17701327800750732,
0.1596745401620865,
-0.4581931233406067,
0.614371657371521,
-0.18923233449459076,
0.40965536236763,
0.1278887242078781,
0.7015981078147888,
0.2631339728832245,
0.05155717581510544,
0.9825501441955566,
0.48940616846084595,
0.960067629814148,
0.18754522502422333,
0.9785206913948059,
-0.7151792049407959,
0.15783612430095673,
1.0499777793884277,
-0.44759392738342285,
0.9394930601119995,
0.3055761456489563,
-0.14861613512039185,
0.4277987480163574,
0.5561836361885071,
0.117714062333107,
0.43587860465049744,
-0.25826868414878845,
-0.3260803818702698,
-0.6706620454788208,
-0.012817036360502243,
-0.0802074670791626,
0.43459051847457886,
0.3013280928134918,
-0.24997863173484802,
-0.07210133969783783,
0.12466685473918915,
0.026791784912347794,
0.13393117487430573,
-0.5959864854812622,
0.7992474436759949,
-0.12125666439533234,
-0.5704253911972046,
0.7495819330215454,
-0.040173809975385666,
0.4325101375579834,
-0.19708453118801117,
0.2061052769422531,
-0.19699952006340027,
0.31777670979499817,
-0.060582563281059265,
-0.5220049619674683,
-0.2645365595817566,
-0.07506310194730759,
-0.003152035642415285,
-0.01593254692852497,
0.955634355545044,
-0.564541757106781,
-0.896858274936676,
0.20722445845603943,
0.5364993214607239,
-0.14826364815235138,
-0.08285238593816757,
-0.9366753101348877,
0.028079845011234283,
0.014117823913693428,
-0.15529285371303558,
0.2349056452512741,
0.37028539180755615,
0.07178487628698349,
0.6924747228622437,
0.6976864337921143,
0.3530949056148529,
0.006796254310756922,
0.2683512568473816,
0.9956536293029785,
-0.4764816164970398,
-0.3876369893550873,
-0.6798086762428284,
0.4229181110858917,
-0.21497710049152374,
-0.3111536204814911,
0.5539212226867676,
0.20762336254119873,
0.6390053629875183,
0.0798625648021698,
0.745083212852478,
-0.042056646198034286,
0.5670070052146912,
-0.6426199078559875,
0.6984043717384338,
-0.5575765371322632,
0.2858121395111084,
-0.15721233189105988,
-1.1826658248901367,
-0.3068808913230896,
0.43321824073791504,
-0.48912131786346436,
0.31465113162994385,
0.4921810030937195,
0.6339806914329529,
-0.33426353335380554,
-0.21122460067272186,
0.401826411485672,
0.7882719039916992,
0.37370702624320984,
0.5112795233726501,
0.6867930293083191,
-0.14828139543533325,
0.4041036367416382,
-0.24711905419826508,
-0.2527294158935547,
-0.3958311676979065,
-0.8986908793449402,
-1.1883832216262817,
-0.25565165281295776,
-0.4174128472805023,
0.03830994293093681,
0.38848018646240234,
1.3450089693069458,
0.9676448702812195,
-1.2556639909744263,
0.06781081110239029,
0.007832293398678303,
0.1382560133934021,
-0.3660244345664978,
-0.0965849906206131,
0.1755092293024063,
-0.5251753330230713,
-1.0744367837905884,
0.8658610582351685,
0.4705675542354584,
-0.3534664213657379,
-0.13033761084079742,
-0.13307926058769226,
-0.19485454261302948,
0.09736698120832443,
0.5671830177307129,
0.24534231424331665,
-0.5697563290596008,
-0.5028163194656372,
-0.3705745339393616,
0.1914006918668747,
0.19609999656677246,
0.4925358295440674,
-0.5854004621505737,
0.17026641964912415,
0.45449042320251465,
0.7603131532669067,
-0.02732669934630394,
0.10813528299331665,
0.299173504114151,
-0.7652654647827148,
0.38324329257011414,
0.21629977226257324,
0.3679203391075134,
0.30027952790260315,
-0.2999480068683624,
0.38634026050567627,
0.05581046640872955,
-0.7433215975761414,
-0.9099079966545105,
-0.07763317972421646,
-1.2023837566375732,
-0.3245057165622711,
1.2182328701019287,
0.2718065679073334,
-0.26681047677993774,
-0.09415382146835327,
-0.24823784828186035,
-0.0833994597196579,
-0.7000166773796082,
0.9050589203834534,
0.4414083957672119,
0.022350329905748367,
-0.5648084878921509,
-0.6880379915237427,
0.29795515537261963,
0.4435214102268219,
-0.8963468074798584,
-0.08167510479688644,
0.12416460365056992,
0.3468465805053711,
0.133210688829422,
0.2657453715801239,
0.48216262459754944,
0.04118482396006584,
-0.24820801615715027,
0.11864428967237473,
-0.44932398200035095,
-0.42966675758361816,
-0.11286207288503647,
0.15970125794410706,
0.6532973051071167,
-0.04019983857870102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00332v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00332v3
|
A Careful Examination of Large Language Model Performance on Grade School Arithmetic
| 2024-05-01T05:52:05 | 2024-05-03T17:53:26 |
Hugh Zhang, Jeff Da, Dean Lee, Vaughn Robinson, Catherine Wu, Will Song, Tiffany Zhao, Pranav Raja, Dylan Slack, Qin Lyu, Sean Hendryx, Russell Kaplan, Michele Lunati, Summer Yue
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive success on many
benchmarks for mathematical reasoning. However, there is growing concern that
some of this performance actually reflects dataset contamination, where data
closely resembling benchmark questions leaks into the training data, instead of
true reasoning ability. To investigate this claim rigorously, we commission
Grade School Math 1000 (GSM1k). GSM1k is designed to mirror the style and
complexity of the established GSM8k benchmark, the gold standard for measuring
elementary mathematical reasoning. We ensure that the two benchmarks are
comparable across important metrics such as human solve rates, number of steps
in solution, answer magnitude, and more. When evaluating leading open- and
closed-source LLMs on GSM1k, we observe accuracy drops of up to 13%, with
several families of models (e.g., Phi and Mistral) showing evidence of
systematic overfitting across almost all model sizes. At the same time, many
models, especially those on the frontier, (e.g., Gemini/GPT/Claude) show
minimal signs of overfitting. Further analysis suggests a positive relationship
(Spearman's r^2=0.32) between a model's probability of generating an example
from GSM8k and its performance gap between GSM8k and GSM1k, suggesting that
many models may have partially memorized GSM8k.
|
[
-0.4372020959854126,
-0.5267674326896667,
0.8102168440818787,
0.023640206083655357,
-0.10709366202354431,
-0.027983753010630608,
0.07668331265449524,
-0.3529561758041382,
-0.32236671447753906,
0.6405972242355347,
-0.5125178694725037,
-0.4560142457485199,
-0.8516204357147217,
-0.13237857818603516,
-0.3928711414337158,
0.6930165886878967,
-0.10735909640789032,
0.21954289078712463,
-0.5771629214286804,
-0.12687888741493225,
-0.08971837908029556,
-0.861709475517273,
-0.6611458659172058,
-0.7206801176071167,
0.31314972043037415,
0.26047152280807495,
0.7744532823562622,
0.9710512757301331,
0.5727260112762451,
0.2958044707775116,
-0.2558341920375824,
0.037641432136297226,
-0.5445185899734497,
-0.1027814969420433,
-0.37320825457572937,
-0.5945003032684326,
-0.5982747077941895,
0.26383256912231445,
0.6934459805488586,
0.9659257531166077,
-0.3744441866874695,
0.18353082239627838,
-0.10176530480384827,
1.0941022634506226,
-0.7055323123931885,
0.20003435015678406,
-0.628657877445221,
-0.18029649555683136,
-0.4507638216018677,
0.13298895955085754,
-0.6232730150222778,
-0.42636924982070923,
-0.14260457456111908,
-0.7325336337089539,
-0.016459794715046883,
-0.08462057262659073,
0.6505571603775024,
0.36664313077926636,
-0.4257314205169678,
-0.39690306782722473,
-0.6190910339355469,
0.9165631532669067,
-0.8483381867408752,
0.3871762156486511,
0.8301834464073181,
0.48802104592323303,
-0.2705747187137604,
-0.5688411593437195,
-0.34877902269363403,
-0.1372469663619995,
0.19863681495189667,
0.11013417690992355,
-0.10655784606933594,
-0.0059118689969182014,
0.7438840270042419,
0.4011882543563843,
-0.5801306962966919,
-0.1605461984872818,
-0.5991078615188599,
-0.15065817534923553,
0.6659101843833923,
0.40747302770614624,
0.19029885530471802,
-0.009851343929767609,
-0.2533349096775055,
-0.08970525115728378,
-1.1938390731811523,
0.1826552450656891,
0.5865952372550964,
0.08138181269168854,
0.24018245935440063,
0.5811982750892639,
-0.31877169013023376,
0.760502278804779,
-0.3875902593135834,
-0.2778366208076477,
-0.020920855924487114,
-0.17554113268852234,
-0.20832829177379608,
0.18189892172813416,
0.5135036706924438,
0.09980855137109756,
0.64310222864151,
-0.08292704820632935,
-0.3397817313671112,
0.3669155240058899,
0.2056964486837387,
-1.0190186500549316,
-0.3671925961971283,
-0.05950034037232399,
-0.048573195934295654,
-0.008851902559399605,
0.12366557866334915,
-0.11315875500440598,
-0.25497132539749146,
-0.521386981010437,
0.37515708804130554,
-0.3253602981567383,
-0.07504041492938995,
0.5424506664276123,
0.22878436744213104,
-0.2853921055793762,
0.33372077345848083,
-0.8435242176055908,
0.41539302468299866,
1.2817002534866333,
0.5716604590415955,
0.032020844519138336,
-0.2813775837421417,
-0.36953994631767273,
-0.07994575798511505,
-0.6447482705116272,
0.6974529027938843,
-0.6103584170341492,
-0.37951356172561646,
-0.02261524274945259,
-0.17646004259586334,
-0.2104460746049881,
-0.9144361019134521,
0.842825710773468,
-0.623190701007843,
0.031181728467345238,
-0.42233848571777344,
-0.9131957292556763,
-0.15793189406394958,
0.21985800564289093,
-0.6392806768417358,
0.989557683467865,
0.08976203948259354,
-0.5178725123405457,
0.2967320382595062,
-0.06644318252801895,
-0.2397889345884323,
-0.0951022207736969,
-0.07221265882253647,
-0.3894882798194885,
0.06274952739477158,
0.08939169347286224,
0.17324791848659515,
-0.2676859200000763,
0.26695871353149414,
-0.6926360130310059,
-0.5325734615325928,
0.4149913787841797,
-0.5046834349632263,
0.8186501264572144,
0.21859414875507355,
0.08802606165409088,
-0.37352725863456726,
-0.8340479731559753,
0.33450111746788025,
-0.003384792013093829,
-0.283856064081192,
-0.5574349761009216,
-0.15451017022132874,
-0.47043275833129883,
0.548186182975769,
-0.004619786515831947,
-0.49659278988838196,
0.3154580295085907,
-0.18486064672470093,
0.5667429566383362,
0.7132176756858826,
-0.08569531887769699,
0.3562324643135071,
-0.6311793923377991,
0.46489477157592773,
-0.08179708570241928,
0.09929138422012329,
-0.5197319984436035,
-0.5698452591896057,
-0.663176953792572,
-0.19537082314491272,
0.44513723254203796,
0.4317423105239868,
-0.5323036313056946,
0.13296745717525482,
-0.5185030698776245,
-0.48803791403770447,
-0.3722497820854187,
0.21204334497451782,
0.43244266510009766,
0.485774427652359,
0.13114939630031586,
-0.14874666929244995,
-0.10690120607614517,
-0.8520207405090332,
-0.47896671295166016,
-0.17801982164382935,
-0.1735968291759491,
0.2861151695251465,
0.4345288872718811,
0.09915003180503845,
0.8286088705062866,
-0.4596177637577057,
-0.03678111732006073,
0.13294629752635956,
0.05107656121253967,
0.25072434544563293,
0.4483622610569,
0.31667304039001465,
-0.3728269040584564,
-0.2774166166782379,
-0.19606159627437592,
-0.8724995255470276,
-0.18740585446357727,
0.14637045562267303,
-0.3167335093021393,
0.03593623265624046,
0.32640978693962097,
-0.6132762432098389,
0.4424532353878021,
0.5691064596176147,
-0.5231932997703552,
0.48345956206321716,
-0.12753230333328247,
0.14060159027576447,
-0.7155605554580688,
-0.07906574755907059,
0.2253294289112091,
-0.15049320459365845,
-0.5387647151947021,
0.03176764398813248,
0.34775781631469727,
-0.024708915501832962,
-0.30333277583122253,
0.43667837977409363,
-0.12074044346809387,
-0.13103578984737396,
-0.09169869124889374,
0.09676042199134827,
0.1922297477722168,
0.12570446729660034,
-0.395439088344574,
0.9627326726913452,
0.32281026244163513,
-0.32233676314353943,
0.20116952061653137,
0.04397593066096306,
-0.7471958994865417,
0.4481227695941925,
-0.6467790007591248,
0.24431659281253815,
0.12084192782640457,
0.32169991731643677,
-0.9771159887313843,
-0.1875743865966797,
-0.08090540766716003,
-0.49932661652565,
0.20090089738368988,
-0.5499024391174316,
-0.6986520290374756,
-0.23677043616771698,
-0.17635835707187653,
0.4632169306278229,
0.486734539270401,
-0.7020518779754639,
0.29565542936325073,
0.29583561420440674,
-0.4033343493938446,
-0.47512394189834595,
-0.5910846590995789,
0.04910609871149063,
-0.13562597334384918,
-1.1407908201217651,
-0.11690467596054077,
0.08290473371744156,
-0.5730201601982117,
-0.027873702347278595,
-0.4444867670536041,
-0.19071565568447113,
0.21183724701404572,
0.42994120717048645,
0.6013221740722656,
-0.40730127692222595,
0.07280109077692032,
0.05082784965634346,
-0.24774636328220367,
0.5086607336997986,
-0.0817512720823288,
0.3692781925201416,
-0.13537074625492096,
-0.6653257608413696,
-0.17886307835578918,
-0.009534814395010471,
0.7554956674575806,
-0.10836740583181381,
0.6744041442871094,
-0.16929829120635986,
-0.46989554166793823,
-0.25046494603157043,
-0.4771019518375397,
-0.10476654767990112,
-0.4903745949268341,
0.16574649512767792,
-0.6143779158592224,
-0.7126978039741516,
0.6863726377487183,
-0.13905330002307892,
-0.12132417410612106,
0.4198238253593445,
0.09175553917884827,
0.10042092949151993,
1.2593472003936768,
0.12463249266147614,
-0.05899912863969803,
0.20068126916885376,
-0.28699320554733276,
-0.0006515247514471412,
-0.7288006544113159,
-0.1449277102947235,
-0.5004332661628723,
0.011869039386510849,
-0.3719402849674225,
-0.40897107124328613,
0.11405859887599945,
0.4826168417930603,
-0.5506266951560974,
0.031896885484457016,
-0.15126588940620422,
0.8652844429016113,
0.37496575713157654,
0.025884289294481277,
0.5405522584915161,
0.1826097071170807,
-0.0441792756319046,
-0.27195867896080017,
-0.7088930010795593,
-0.7806721925735474,
1.2866131067276,
0.5362940430641174,
0.9397080540657043,
0.05958783999085426,
0.6158726811408997,
0.019249409437179565,
0.5703243613243103,
-0.5550838708877563,
0.4472716152667999,
-0.3836464583873749,
-0.8246933817863464,
-0.27338430285453796,
-0.8885976672172546,
-0.6598750948905945,
0.22399047017097473,
0.0908493623137474,
-0.533064067363739,
-0.032679855823516846,
0.0906524509191513,
-0.15158501267433167,
0.20631824433803558,
-0.6803480982780457,
0.8447678685188293,
0.060885995626449585,
-0.4659308195114136,
-0.128746896982193,
-0.2969678044319153,
0.8081246018409729,
-0.13419222831726074,
0.3643881380558014,
-0.3332485854625702,
0.17594890296459198,
0.6161300539970398,
-0.5541438460350037,
0.37449732422828674,
0.0032444745302200317,
-0.4033481776714325,
0.35370489954948425,
0.38928472995758057,
0.7088127136230469,
0.012166431173682213,
-0.20683498680591583,
0.42893582582473755,
-0.06796122342348099,
-0.6226422786712646,
-0.738854169845581,
0.8608652949333191,
-0.7089596390724182,
-0.4932752549648285,
-0.3576678931713104,
-0.3352181017398834,
-0.3908487558364868,
0.04856235533952713,
0.18631108105182648,
0.796604335308075,
0.19158923625946045,
0.23430663347244263,
0.8253435492515564,
0.08411229401826859,
0.10691207647323608,
0.43475621938705444,
-0.367289662361145,
-0.5235447883605957,
0.982416570186615,
0.4790719151496887,
0.6984596252441406,
-0.1217513382434845,
0.2847220301628113,
-0.3687225580215454,
-0.49416086077690125,
-0.7785767316818237,
0.303597629070282,
-0.9721195101737976,
-0.10674700140953064,
-0.3422452509403229,
-0.4066593050956726,
-0.2044590413570404,
0.03898639976978302,
-0.5725616812705994,
-0.7085611820220947,
0.12325066328048706,
-0.03016114979982376,
0.03293047845363617,
0.9344580173492432,
0.3410067856311798,
0.16416476666927338,
-0.8075371384620667,
0.09649502485990524,
0.31564420461654663,
0.5368967652320862,
-0.01461686659604311,
-1.0077027082443237,
-0.21874980628490448,
0.13457973301410675,
-0.205370232462883,
-0.40902623534202576,
0.04094593971967697,
-0.047317881137132645,
0.5412907600402832,
0.6282731890678406,
-0.12352674454450607,
0.6221571564674377,
-0.5428081154823303,
0.5954164266586304,
0.1170586347579956,
-0.9056004285812378,
0.1442141830921173,
-0.47062867879867554,
0.37514686584472656,
0.4172159433364868,
0.3688700497150421,
-0.45964959263801575,
-0.5250555276870728,
-0.7426021695137024,
-0.5534977912902832,
0.7436787486076355,
0.2488945573568344,
-0.0404091440141201,
0.2592434883117676,
0.4074467420578003,
0.03744679316878319,
0.004879857879132032,
-0.3736454248428345,
-0.4091738760471344,
-0.22581975162029266,
-0.16105185449123383,
-0.1942390650510788,
-0.31134283542633057,
-0.2419063299894333,
-0.23643016815185547,
0.6178367733955383,
0.13671329617500305,
-0.24574710428714752,
-0.24585117399692535,
-0.04982961341738701,
-0.24318864941596985,
0.273052453994751,
0.9573435187339783,
1.1569827795028687,
-0.019457172602415085,
0.46891161799430847,
0.026947710663080215,
-0.7810986638069153,
0.1424756795167923,
0.15411663055419922,
-0.12972508370876312,
-0.15852995216846466,
0.600625216960907,
0.5172505974769592,
0.16291365027427673,
-0.6304866075515747,
0.361792653799057,
-0.013586767017841339,
-0.4035506844520569,
-0.11895692348480225,
0.23164722323417664,
0.28990060091018677,
0.03603747859597206,
0.6031243801116943,
0.08193785697221756,
0.07183282822370529,
-0.6056613922119141,
0.27563539147377014,
0.19958491623401642,
-0.02874339185655117,
-0.2557694911956787,
0.5354393124580383,
-0.1345217525959015,
-0.17044733464717865,
0.6203145384788513,
-0.26692885160446167,
-0.7788742184638977,
0.864517331123352,
0.47455063462257385,
0.4119442105293274,
-0.25432029366493225,
-0.045308083295822144,
0.5288048386573792,
0.5097020268440247,
-0.5669966340065002,
0.01025370229035616,
0.16368456184864044,
-0.4919193387031555,
-0.728857696056366,
-0.31734782457351685,
-0.5016117691993713,
0.20452511310577393,
-0.6786304712295532,
0.0034782434813678265,
-0.5072541832923889,
-0.02236900106072426,
0.19700169563293457,
0.2398013472557068,
-0.2920592427253723,
0.26462510228157043,
0.29741814732551575,
0.99338698387146,
-0.9671586155891418,
0.8917955160140991,
0.5541942119598389,
-0.020612850785255432,
-1.0451613664627075,
-0.2579881250858307,
0.0009257107740268111,
-0.8391246795654297,
0.8246098756790161,
0.1686476767063141,
0.04675498977303505,
-0.21632781624794006,
-0.44627296924591064,
-0.9395504593849182,
0.874899685382843,
0.567689836025238,
-0.7538554072380066,
0.30347394943237305,
0.4873420298099518,
0.4451773762702942,
-0.15060444176197052,
0.27458855509757996,
0.6456528306007385,
0.3309125602245331,
0.45835262537002563,
-0.9268772006034851,
0.024376925081014633,
-0.13886024057865143,
-0.12593263387680054,
0.5279988050460815,
-0.5441211462020874,
1.106176495552063,
-0.07918363064527512,
-0.2789335250854492,
-0.09143129736185074,
0.20803576707839966,
0.5465854406356812,
0.7324349880218506,
0.2967272400856018,
1.0601269006729126,
0.6792193055152893,
-0.3146776854991913,
1.035821795463562,
-0.17718012630939484,
0.5222726464271545,
1.0941210985183716,
-0.33306851983070374,
0.852583646774292,
0.15803691744804382,
-0.650540292263031,
0.08376096189022064,
0.5962957143783569,
0.2578171491622925,
0.3858084976673126,
0.4100708067417145,
-0.4002665579319,
-0.6553141474723816,
0.3594495356082916,
-0.4871909022331238,
0.10685846209526062,
0.3902006149291992,
-0.21618033945560455,
-0.3980918228626251,
-0.277959942817688,
0.20419789850711823,
0.19051243364810944,
-0.530807375907898,
0.5194345712661743,
0.3516071140766144,
-0.7489555478096008,
0.7823873162269592,
-0.11625748872756958,
0.19160160422325134,
-0.3227299749851227,
-0.05840224772691727,
-0.5371166467666626,
0.35645991563796997,
-0.23688548803329468,
-0.9278983473777771,
0.27458125352859497,
-0.0827004685997963,
-0.21389999985694885,
-0.13256168365478516,
0.6340892314910889,
-0.47909125685691833,
-0.6211892366409302,
-0.06130460277199745,
0.4163571894168854,
0.27712300419807434,
-0.27769291400909424,
-0.5102096199989319,
0.25261497497558594,
-0.18950064480304718,
-0.24762989580631256,
0.5113087296485901,
0.6239219903945923,
-0.04146141931414604,
1.0121054649353027,
0.7505457401275635,
0.07572803646326065,
0.4144454896450043,
0.09436129778623581,
0.9149054288864136,
-0.4936271607875824,
-0.3074941337108612,
-1.059350848197937,
0.11124151200056076,
-0.05084051936864853,
-0.33229246735572815,
0.9173703789710999,
0.9617305397987366,
0.9707508087158203,
0.1873026192188263,
0.5098657608032227,
0.6554660797119141,
0.48535001277923584,
-0.7172472476959229,
0.6329197883605957,
-0.282936155796051,
0.43454110622406006,
-0.11518170684576035,
-0.8897895812988281,
-0.04581815004348755,
0.6102598309516907,
-0.6120398044586182,
0.015189675614237785,
0.6954710483551025,
0.6142251491546631,
-0.1736968457698822,
0.21159811317920685,
0.5878227353096008,
-0.08751306682825089,
0.23108206689357758,
0.7383736371994019,
1.1295467615127563,
-0.4710630476474762,
0.6275670528411865,
-0.37134888768196106,
-0.13423870503902435,
-0.12597912549972534,
-0.6455097198486328,
-0.8947901725769043,
-0.16413027048110962,
-0.34110215306282043,
-0.3913837969303131,
0.09606798738241196,
0.5795281529426575,
0.6341985464096069,
-0.5887312889099121,
-0.05204933136701584,
-0.06873665004968643,
0.14424030482769012,
0.11277448385953903,
-0.18537932634353638,
0.1481838971376419,
-0.21642747521400452,
-0.5662674903869629,
0.2378864884376526,
0.11094795167446136,
0.06240713968873024,
-0.26877427101135254,
-0.093455471098423,
0.353378027677536,
0.29926371574401855,
0.572028636932373,
0.14600741863250732,
-0.593539297580719,
-0.13709041476249695,
0.07703810930252075,
-0.48867133259773254,
0.0248878113925457,
0.9015514850616455,
-0.5375661849975586,
0.3263557255268097,
0.3887538015842438,
0.6723492741584778,
0.5610663890838623,
0.2866247296333313,
0.21031732857227325,
-0.34365761280059814,
-0.12470109760761261,
0.12518858909606934,
0.3193419277667999,
0.30239295959472656,
-0.11025617271661758,
0.5495297312736511,
0.3281189203262329,
-0.7599714398384094,
-1.0438729524612427,
0.09572352468967438,
-0.7533654570579529,
-0.15156838297843933,
1.2260328531265259,
-0.44254523515701294,
-0.17006616294384003,
0.010498051531612873,
0.0973016545176506,
-0.18476663529872894,
-0.40178805589675903,
0.8823366761207581,
1.3065102100372314,
0.05990500748157501,
-0.043412789702415466,
-1.0644800662994385,
0.39869698882102966,
0.4551520347595215,
-0.8549493551254272,
0.39495527744293213,
0.48262014985084534,
0.37007978558540344,
0.14505738019943237,
0.3046783208847046,
-0.186791330575943,
0.31703758239746094,
0.297425776720047,
-0.25090426206588745,
-0.35377776622772217,
-0.1943061649799347,
-0.35297828912734985,
0.12441742420196533,
0.08434418588876724,
0.07504981011152267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00321v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00321v1
|
DFKI-NLP at SemEval-2024 Task 2: Towards Robust LLMs Using Data Perturbations and MinMax Training
| 2024-05-01T05:03:08 | 2024-05-01T05:03:08 |
Bhuvanesh Verma, Lisa Raithel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The NLI4CT task at SemEval-2024 emphasizes the development of robust models
for Natural Language Inference on Clinical Trial Reports (CTRs) using large
language models (LLMs). This edition introduces interventions specifically
targeting the numerical, vocabulary, and semantic aspects of CTRs. Our proposed
system harnesses the capabilities of the state-of-the-art Mistral model,
complemented by an auxiliary model, to focus on the intricate input space of
the NLI4CT dataset. Through the incorporation of numerical and acronym-based
perturbations to the data, we train a robust system capable of handling both
semantic-altering and numerical contradiction interventions. Our analysis on
the dataset sheds light on the challenging sections of the CTRs for reasoning.
|
[
0.007746212184429169,
-0.8790469765663147,
0.5325490832328796,
0.26635855436325073,
-0.10667213052511215,
-0.22154085338115692,
0.08824200183153152,
-0.20143531262874603,
-0.04331241920590401,
0.8127251267433167,
-0.5407500267028809,
-0.5968937873840332,
-0.8214409351348877,
0.4853852093219757,
-0.26854339241981506,
1.0032331943511963,
-0.1001489907503128,
0.493251770734787,
-0.1540297269821167,
-0.11134906858205795,
-0.4992510676383972,
-0.8401548862457275,
-0.6878334879875183,
-0.32179778814315796,
0.6994267702102661,
0.44699540734291077,
0.5705012083053589,
0.3010379374027252,
0.7631697058677673,
0.2696012854576111,
-0.27028951048851013,
-0.055717214941978455,
-0.6408928632736206,
0.239793598651886,
0.13349193334579468,
-0.5431797504425049,
-0.463468462228775,
-0.23130683600902557,
0.5224743485450745,
0.6304143667221069,
-0.26078060269355774,
-0.3998951315879822,
0.08325446397066116,
0.41421374678611755,
-0.4875842332839966,
-0.043218083679676056,
-0.6933282613754272,
0.15128234028816223,
-0.044585078954696655,
-0.20768465101718903,
-0.3232059180736542,
-0.19298028945922852,
0.17250707745552063,
-0.6010968089103699,
0.12425810098648071,
-0.3467589318752289,
0.6615422964096069,
0.6889477968215942,
-0.8302638530731201,
-0.49573031067848206,
-0.506723165512085,
0.902740478515625,
-1.0971413850784302,
0.39428114891052246,
0.5421104431152344,
0.205990731716156,
-0.6182825565338135,
-1.0042020082473755,
-0.48465442657470703,
-0.2487172782421112,
-0.024250654503703117,
0.10096994042396545,
-0.15823578834533691,
0.38945990800857544,
0.507005512714386,
-0.01701628416776657,
-0.35038790106773376,
0.3142150640487671,
-0.17786772549152374,
-0.3770882487297058,
0.5146620273590088,
0.568805456161499,
0.033176932483911514,
-0.059296444058418274,
-0.458075612783432,
0.15150825679302216,
-0.7181865572929382,
-0.17428213357925415,
0.1622716188430786,
0.29636189341545105,
-0.1640423983335495,
0.7016810178756714,
-0.14339394867420197,
0.8249969482421875,
-0.05748526751995087,
-0.28763875365257263,
0.2495286762714386,
-0.7004611492156982,
-0.31477120518684387,
-0.02929096482694149,
0.7428026795387268,
0.32285159826278687,
-0.22559556365013123,
-0.0889865830540657,
-0.3875398337841034,
0.040926672518253326,
0.16303500533103943,
-0.7368625998497009,
0.015532826073467731,
0.2778991162776947,
-0.17235206067562103,
-0.7579962611198425,
-0.31460773944854736,
-0.9464632868766785,
-0.3801717162132263,
-0.3121567666530609,
0.6458067297935486,
-0.4539056420326233,
0.0233547855168581,
0.3562234938144684,
-0.1917584091424942,
0.17711661756038666,
0.40159186720848083,
-0.5915933847427368,
0.5223898887634277,
0.6858419179916382,
0.6360970139503479,
-0.11946432292461395,
-0.12565815448760986,
-0.6652129888534546,
0.10462180525064468,
-0.15981365740299225,
0.7390125393867493,
-0.5345564484596252,
-0.6014737486839294,
0.1929648220539093,
-0.05698557570576668,
-0.14041371643543243,
-0.46904900670051575,
1.0959502458572388,
-0.40622714161872864,
0.24562504887580872,
-0.4892268180847168,
-0.7861482501029968,
0.12360551208257675,
0.4280352294445038,
-0.6328092813491821,
0.892948567867279,
0.025949371978640556,
-1.1004637479782104,
0.20331500470638275,
-0.6757566928863525,
-0.4441086947917938,
-0.11070618778467178,
-0.3233172297477722,
-0.41674569249153137,
0.11131118983030319,
0.20036514103412628,
0.209529310464859,
-0.12743210792541504,
0.373760849237442,
-0.3990935981273651,
-0.21018335223197937,
0.40001609921455383,
-0.50579833984375,
0.6993235945701599,
0.35272204875946045,
-0.33162721991539,
0.046982213854789734,
-0.8398764133453369,
-0.21265040338039398,
0.005661515053361654,
-0.38219574093818665,
-0.32698166370391846,
-0.1911645233631134,
0.039134617894887924,
0.13603943586349487,
0.2773822546005249,
-0.5877262353897095,
0.19078634679317474,
-0.6318480968475342,
0.6574274301528931,
0.5397199988365173,
0.3039714992046356,
0.16952770948410034,
-0.23033474385738373,
0.6615603566169739,
0.15817275643348694,
0.32489433884620667,
0.026394320651888847,
-0.348478764295578,
-0.6681249141693115,
-0.35143226385116577,
0.4754813611507416,
0.4762084186077118,
-1.0808714628219604,
0.18779194355010986,
-0.22074128687381744,
-0.23601290583610535,
-0.11210781335830688,
-0.060758884996175766,
0.27016064524650574,
0.7621838450431824,
0.27394601702690125,
0.0720171257853508,
-0.6559638977050781,
-1.0119704008102417,
-0.06608336418867111,
0.022085240110754967,
0.07856282591819763,
0.06262437999248505,
0.6933562159538269,
-0.4358978271484375,
0.7079282402992249,
-0.2457025647163391,
-0.42964968085289,
-0.2219989150762558,
0.1963229477405548,
0.40743550658226013,
0.4180481731891632,
0.280730277299881,
-0.7840511798858643,
-0.14418461918830872,
-0.33540794253349304,
-0.6437078714370728,
-0.4452514946460724,
-0.21370621025562286,
-0.04050951078534126,
-0.08367739617824554,
0.7762584090232849,
-0.3941408097743988,
0.6540323495864868,
0.5137135982513428,
-0.4319956302642822,
0.38920196890830994,
-0.19595882296562195,
0.13016623258590698,
-0.9687817692756653,
-0.03668230026960373,
-0.06814634054899216,
-0.1738012433052063,
-1.057327151298523,
-0.27098533511161804,
-0.33422335982322693,
0.22264254093170166,
-0.33947011828422546,
0.46844735741615295,
-0.10764956474304199,
0.16755858063697815,
-0.31594714522361755,
-0.2274300903081894,
0.01468520238995552,
0.13424909114837646,
-0.09837234020233154,
0.6846594214439392,
0.19982731342315674,
-0.553960382938385,
0.04890816658735275,
0.5992445349693298,
0.023632172495126724,
0.19695425033569336,
-1.0222854614257812,
0.08757542073726654,
-0.04943079128861427,
0.3605085015296936,
-0.8712922930717468,
-0.346818208694458,
0.09039365500211716,
-0.5226984024047852,
0.2653106153011322,
-0.12024754285812378,
-0.47866857051849365,
-0.18872368335723877,
-0.24934935569763184,
0.36977529525756836,
0.10613969713449478,
-0.30897414684295654,
0.64640212059021,
0.4695589244365692,
-0.1637866199016571,
-0.7350273728370667,
-0.9521586894989014,
0.3278834819793701,
-0.2502807676792145,
-0.43736010789871216,
0.4158381521701813,
-0.08924128115177155,
-0.324281245470047,
-0.16524282097816467,
0.0679367259144783,
-0.3560025691986084,
0.14985962212085724,
0.26819470524787903,
0.201872780919075,
-0.1294146180152893,
0.04648538678884506,
0.30329111218452454,
-0.05940433591604233,
0.1784665286540985,
0.10365396738052368,
0.21236440539360046,
-0.03446508198976517,
-0.4324049651622772,
-0.5748417973518372,
0.3709256947040558,
0.5719543695449829,
0.20310193300247192,
0.47403907775878906,
0.3760215938091278,
-0.5225546360015869,
0.13582457602024078,
-0.5480630397796631,
-0.19936427474021912,
-0.4660499393939972,
0.43394389748573303,
-0.5409266948699951,
-1.3696824312210083,
0.21034552156925201,
-0.12931789457798004,
0.08683470636606216,
0.4316082298755646,
0.8965147137641907,
0.02094442769885063,
1.2095385789871216,
0.5096936821937561,
0.02904793992638588,
0.20639967918395996,
-0.1142045110464096,
0.1026080772280693,
-0.7477316856384277,
-0.13127344846725464,
-0.6461005210876465,
-0.12364457547664642,
-0.37781593203544617,
-0.5051549077033997,
0.6674107313156128,
0.054301176220178604,
-0.3420320451259613,
-0.15232469141483307,
-0.40308117866516113,
0.13776983320713043,
0.28185394406318665,
0.17433056235313416,
0.193380206823349,
0.15695825219154358,
-0.4544317424297333,
-0.34227246046066284,
-0.9430055022239685,
-0.47572216391563416,
1.1113446950912476,
0.5352960228919983,
0.7603127956390381,
0.1608717441558838,
0.6150106191635132,
0.30106091499328613,
0.14903205633163452,
-0.6855946779251099,
0.3300163745880127,
-0.13031113147735596,
-0.5522500276565552,
-0.18796473741531372,
-0.35581713914871216,
-1.0070768594741821,
0.12315191328525543,
-0.20383360981941223,
-0.4693455696105957,
0.3294951319694519,
0.04556797817349434,
-0.3950626254081726,
-0.03934585675597191,
-0.518663227558136,
0.7153457999229431,
-0.34393247961997986,
-0.28268229961395264,
-0.055747997015714645,
-0.7784520387649536,
0.28572627902030945,
-0.1430494636297226,
0.24372830986976624,
-0.05213048681616783,
-0.4552210867404938,
0.5143824815750122,
-0.6271917223930359,
1.064927577972412,
-0.3592734932899475,
-0.10182131826877594,
0.18902897834777832,
-0.11224047094583511,
0.6076940894126892,
0.25129756331443787,
-0.32158297300338745,
0.15549279749393463,
0.3878525495529175,
-0.45986658334732056,
-0.538519024848938,
0.564146101474762,
-0.7073805928230286,
-0.4984028935432434,
-0.5883874297142029,
-0.4002782106399536,
-0.4533235728740692,
0.12382214516401291,
0.4617783725261688,
0.683840274810791,
-0.29830700159072876,
0.13780459761619568,
0.6137275099754333,
-0.4077889025211334,
-0.008352010510861874,
0.4251542091369629,
0.11548659205436707,
-0.6981543898582458,
0.41005560755729675,
-0.14659757912158966,
0.1998152881860733,
0.4528854787349701,
0.259451687335968,
-0.5192549824714661,
-1.0444778203964233,
0.05829697847366333,
0.31851890683174133,
-0.8129873275756836,
-0.24519120156764984,
-0.7135657072067261,
-0.2629404366016388,
-0.5257665514945984,
-0.01929926499724388,
-0.1688132882118225,
-0.49079716205596924,
-0.38860630989074707,
-0.11282654851675034,
0.3133397102355957,
0.7998486161231995,
-0.14331242442131042,
0.30866801738739014,
-0.8728724122047424,
-0.05120263248682022,
0.11047551780939102,
0.11827678233385086,
-0.4141214191913605,
-0.8536871671676636,
-0.14177058637142181,
0.08169489353895187,
-0.023685483261942863,
-0.721957266330719,
0.41406750679016113,
0.34300073981285095,
0.6050118803977966,
0.25133880972862244,
0.12768234312534332,
0.7132617235183716,
-0.4973122477531433,
0.7701221704483032,
0.31404200196266174,
-0.7473575472831726,
0.7710244059562683,
-0.553359866142273,
0.3071829676628113,
0.8413792848587036,
0.41038304567337036,
-0.30014991760253906,
-0.36420831084251404,
-0.4015694260597229,
-0.6950086355209351,
0.40457266569137573,
0.36042696237564087,
0.10990353673696518,
-0.01710807904601097,
0.8064314723014832,
0.06795661151409149,
0.04173597693443298,
-0.5570492148399353,
0.13276569545269012,
-0.10189437866210938,
-0.6386665105819702,
0.08257422596216202,
-0.6965876817703247,
-0.4816356897354126,
-0.29094183444976807,
0.6206681728363037,
-0.35995927453041077,
0.3995988667011261,
0.6499874591827393,
0.08855028450489044,
0.1897212117910385,
0.20312269032001495,
0.8580304980278015,
0.5152064561843872,
-0.0004639255930669606,
0.1624278575181961,
0.5845831632614136,
-0.6418766379356384,
0.1265530288219452,
0.17101691663265228,
-0.1401885598897934,
-0.026607656851410866,
0.6605451107025146,
0.8204377293586731,
0.3011300265789032,
-0.8949658274650574,
0.7512801885604858,
-0.5504313111305237,
-0.5805935263633728,
-0.6630533933639526,
-0.07133088260889053,
-0.25200125575065613,
0.2678806185722351,
0.003896877635270357,
-0.08698682487010956,
0.39674898982048035,
0.13792598247528076,
0.3999333381652832,
0.25727421045303345,
-0.8022244572639465,
-0.523545503616333,
0.7569951415061951,
0.11667068302631378,
0.14640402793884277,
0.41414302587509155,
0.12494899332523346,
-0.5548988580703735,
0.4977070689201355,
0.4421841502189636,
0.5292091965675354,
-0.045761603862047195,
-0.0849834457039833,
0.5076160430908203,
0.2976570129394531,
0.07535894960165024,
0.4527963697910309,
0.374761700630188,
-0.875456690788269,
-0.5692806839942932,
-0.48110929131507874,
-0.3424077033996582,
0.39432135224342346,
-0.586997389793396,
0.5928471088409424,
-0.5298647284507751,
-0.3471337854862213,
0.05474788323044777,
-0.20807625353336334,
-0.5205990672111511,
0.21621863543987274,
0.09116911143064499,
1.056368112564087,
-0.6390370726585388,
1.0090773105621338,
0.700756847858429,
-0.15040133893489838,
-0.7709536552429199,
-0.1943710297346115,
0.40463292598724365,
-0.53006511926651,
0.8161205649375916,
-0.18151646852493286,
-0.08961828798055649,
-0.035820674151182175,
-0.701906681060791,
-0.8521893620491028,
0.9706173539161682,
0.2028411477804184,
-0.48885515332221985,
-0.08596204966306686,
0.41580432653427124,
0.6119241714477539,
-0.20442919433116913,
0.1690530627965927,
0.7282683849334717,
0.36757636070251465,
0.36725595593452454,
-0.7066511511802673,
-0.08374401926994324,
-0.1493002474308014,
-0.014362446032464504,
-0.06244019791483879,
-0.34172940254211426,
0.4575103223323822,
-0.11688538640737534,
0.13857904076576233,
0.3457478880882263,
0.6499485969543457,
0.24964141845703125,
0.3360847532749176,
0.7414532899856567,
0.7655068635940552,
0.6421346068382263,
-0.11037098616361618,
0.9872685670852661,
-0.20505984127521515,
0.25863203406333923,
1.1303260326385498,
-0.5384677648544312,
0.766287088394165,
0.6292986273765564,
-0.17073777318000793,
0.12608197331428528,
0.5261929631233215,
-0.01846955344080925,
0.6109042167663574,
0.11255767196416855,
-0.5243065357208252,
-0.10201183706521988,
-0.19149868190288544,
-0.20699122548103333,
0.5862754583358765,
0.7199772596359253,
-0.07778387516736984,
-0.04667670652270317,
0.10362835228443146,
0.10510651767253876,
-0.1251005381345749,
0.14989088475704193,
0.920744001865387,
0.21949656307697296,
-0.6072953343391418,
0.6755978465080261,
0.0412481389939785,
0.569828450679779,
-0.7847216725349426,
-0.13925153017044067,
-0.15900331735610962,
0.28391164541244507,
-0.14566312730312347,
-0.37460649013519287,
0.43949779868125916,
0.09691821783781052,
0.1180635318160057,
0.17461691796779633,
0.9314301609992981,
-0.2359541803598404,
-0.6276991367340088,
0.27699989080429077,
0.24393059313297272,
-0.13122861087322235,
0.3872472643852234,
-0.9028913378715515,
0.21189050376415253,
0.26007646322250366,
-0.2392984926700592,
0.31587204337120056,
0.6294236183166504,
0.16011905670166016,
0.5304703712463379,
0.4856733977794647,
0.17753110826015472,
0.10711117833852768,
0.3831673562526703,
0.9809111952781677,
-0.6271670460700989,
-0.24593015015125275,
-0.6201895475387573,
0.32696250081062317,
-0.01571713574230671,
-0.44669970870018005,
0.5888153910636902,
0.4571109414100647,
0.2534807622432709,
0.30935147404670715,
0.7947028875350952,
0.08860393613576889,
0.677030086517334,
-0.7761645913124084,
0.24334579706192017,
-0.588405191898346,
0.3508526384830475,
-0.09390048682689667,
-0.28018301725387573,
-0.5575370788574219,
0.3391258418560028,
-0.254441499710083,
-0.13247504830360413,
0.6056238412857056,
0.7980678081512451,
0.3402392268180847,
0.22519168257713318,
0.336399108171463,
0.7039549350738525,
0.5944018959999084,
0.4375961124897003,
1.015167236328125,
-0.45671841502189636,
0.4277809262275696,
-0.285788357257843,
-0.287855327129364,
-0.07746637612581253,
-0.8471773266792297,
-0.7330280542373657,
-0.4046608805656433,
-0.35328859090805054,
-0.49545174837112427,
0.08825575560331345,
0.8781474828720093,
0.3600466251373291,
-0.9618486166000366,
-0.04718717932701111,
-0.38634490966796875,
-0.10818272083997726,
0.1270599663257599,
-0.16753387451171875,
0.2608790993690491,
-0.6195840835571289,
-0.6511633992195129,
0.6045827269554138,
0.3424675166606903,
0.15232254564762115,
-0.05468073859810829,
-0.1608162522315979,
-0.20109595358371735,
-0.04650459811091423,
0.5720913410186768,
-0.14555811882019043,
-0.6949818134307861,
-0.1524098813533783,
0.053405266255140305,
-0.1756565272808075,
-0.05870473384857178,
0.954024612903595,
-0.6064971685409546,
0.45245784521102905,
0.47017449140548706,
0.9103665947914124,
0.46180459856987,
-0.18965205550193787,
0.6834540367126465,
-0.510002613067627,
0.29146185517311096,
0.6905733942985535,
0.37770283222198486,
0.13742494583129883,
-0.4154665172100067,
0.6613237261772156,
0.2797296345233917,
-0.7920722365379333,
-0.9000844955444336,
0.10742848366498947,
-0.8984644412994385,
-0.24784475564956665,
1.272391438484192,
-0.018065502867102623,
-0.0816543772816658,
-0.51303631067276,
-0.128858745098114,
0.1210002675652504,
-0.10076448321342468,
0.46383678913116455,
0.8266175389289856,
-0.22646331787109375,
-0.021355150267481804,
-0.9372231960296631,
0.6784055829048157,
0.6069650053977966,
-0.7014040350914001,
-0.32312384247779846,
0.5848180651664734,
0.23669418692588806,
-0.30194956064224243,
0.8296561241149902,
-0.46383944153785706,
0.05772023648023605,
0.014786716550588608,
-0.22819562256336212,
0.16009436547756195,
0.013920213095843792,
-0.7818505764007568,
-0.035583920776844025,
0.22444991767406464,
0.24062643945217133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00302v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00302v3
|
Generating Feedback-Ladders for Logical Errors in Programming using Large Language Models
| 2024-05-01T03:52:39 | 2024-05-08T20:38:58 |
Hasnain Heickal, Andrew Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In feedback generation for logical errors in programming assignments, large
language model (LLM)-based methods have shown great promise. These methods ask
the LLM to generate feedback given the problem statement and a student's
(buggy) submission. There are several issues with these types of methods.
First, the generated feedback messages are often too direct in revealing the
error in the submission and thus diminish valuable opportunities for the
student to learn. Second, they do not consider the student's learning context,
i.e., their previous submissions, current knowledge, etc. Third, they are not
layered since existing methods use a single, shared prompt for all student
submissions. In this paper, we explore using LLMs to generate a
"feedback-ladder", i.e., multiple levels of feedback for the same
problem-submission pair. We evaluate the quality of the generated
feedback-ladder via a user study with students, educators, and researchers. We
have observed diminishing effectiveness for higher-level feedback and
higher-scoring submissions overall in the study. In practice, our method
enables teachers to select an appropriate level of feedback to show to a
student based on their personal learning context, or in a progressive manner to
go more detailed if a higher-level feedback fails to correct the student's
error.
|
[
-0.06894568353891373,
-0.7522987723350525,
0.4870498776435852,
0.44894030690193176,
0.151697039604187,
0.1926121860742569,
-0.09773392975330353,
-0.04539581760764122,
0.08425138145685196,
0.23444154858589172,
-0.5150201916694641,
-0.6289082765579224,
-0.3811514675617218,
0.2612663507461548,
-0.5588667392730713,
1.1777064800262451,
-0.10210629552602768,
0.13897433876991272,
-0.5005789399147034,
0.1904861479997635,
-0.817439079284668,
-0.5241936445236206,
-0.6141912937164307,
-0.17464424669742584,
0.576957106590271,
0.7645348906517029,
0.3597414791584015,
0.4042279124259949,
0.7094959020614624,
0.23344779014587402,
0.16889916360378265,
0.09456782788038254,
-0.4962000846862793,
0.27489039301872253,
-0.26291611790657043,
-0.7006776928901672,
-0.4064406454563141,
-0.15222211182117462,
0.8171212077140808,
0.7025979161262512,
-0.20707865059375763,
0.47451603412628174,
0.3578798770904541,
0.6063375473022461,
-0.5799201130867004,
0.2492578625679016,
-0.37696361541748047,
0.24840572476387024,
-0.19783428311347961,
-0.40259966254234314,
-0.7023823857307434,
-0.5686934590339661,
-0.3898676335811615,
-0.2097163051366806,
-0.05419245362281799,
-0.027555542066693306,
0.3754706084728241,
0.2668294906616211,
-0.461897075176239,
-0.5322779417037964,
-0.9666702747344971,
0.7098405957221985,
-0.9063072204589844,
0.14460326731204987,
0.13351492583751678,
0.33420273661613464,
-0.39523398876190186,
-0.389798104763031,
-0.39660078287124634,
-0.4246581792831421,
0.11072392016649246,
0.29480379819869995,
0.1103510856628418,
-0.08824063092470169,
0.4627874791622162,
0.08743681013584137,
-0.42742565274238586,
0.2665134370326996,
-0.4591333270072937,
-0.2149437665939331,
0.6504488587379456,
0.40806183218955994,
0.28031203150749207,
-0.3858702778816223,
-0.299027681350708,
-0.10105571895837784,
-1.0307410955429077,
0.38013312220573425,
0.5857928395271301,
0.36874133348464966,
0.23567183315753937,
0.8314470052719116,
-0.02881430834531784,
0.8659588694572449,
-0.10206624120473862,
-0.49053823947906494,
0.21924494206905365,
-0.36418479681015015,
0.09868290275335312,
-0.19991275668144226,
0.6130420565605164,
0.45450639724731445,
-0.020770687609910965,
-0.012853081338107586,
-0.617953360080719,
0.3153342306613922,
0.13974444568157196,
-0.627355694770813,
-0.2804197669029236,
0.1887243241071701,
-0.29250699281692505,
-0.48434993624687195,
0.07517559081315994,
-0.863749623298645,
-0.5599808096885681,
-0.3239184319972992,
0.4177107512950897,
-0.0555046908557415,
-0.16946616768836975,
-0.19545073807239532,
0.13486509025096893,
-0.04399237409234047,
0.44253888726234436,
-0.4768270254135132,
0.29778891801834106,
0.42963534593582153,
0.4821988344192505,
0.02058529667556286,
-0.47042030096054077,
-1.0830554962158203,
0.02930481918156147,
-0.4240909516811371,
0.5963220000267029,
-0.6685997843742371,
-0.3576388359069824,
0.05796344578266144,
-0.5164054036140442,
0.12141388654708862,
-0.6184444427490234,
0.3082127869129181,
-0.342527836561203,
0.21721656620502472,
-0.33743423223495483,
-0.6186001896858215,
0.26155930757522583,
0.3002874255180359,
-0.31318414211273193,
0.9765569567680359,
0.046630486845970154,
-0.8118910789489746,
0.019201762974262238,
-0.6028100848197937,
-0.14482846856117249,
0.08067900687456131,
-0.4317507743835449,
-0.1210126131772995,
0.021626777946949005,
0.11418015509843826,
0.317312091588974,
-0.1580454707145691,
0.3005833327770233,
-0.06541746109724045,
-0.337208092212677,
0.3783154785633087,
-0.14363333582878113,
0.6326882839202881,
0.17097128927707672,
-0.37067192792892456,
0.32709449529647827,
-0.897699236869812,
0.07017862051725388,
0.02214745618402958,
-0.7267470359802246,
-0.085719995200634,
0.2638181746006012,
-0.23473574221134186,
0.40096062421798706,
0.23030349612236023,
-0.4981207251548767,
0.3284345269203186,
-0.13522009551525116,
0.35311204195022583,
1.0545274019241333,
-0.009421930648386478,
0.09946350008249283,
-0.4120328426361084,
0.8443544507026672,
0.3027860224246979,
-0.11743547022342682,
-0.24237574636936188,
-0.25626423954963684,
-0.7187103033065796,
0.1577986478805542,
0.2725175619125366,
0.6777774691581726,
-0.7047189474105835,
0.2018580585718155,
-0.07909249514341354,
-0.307630717754364,
-0.22281812131404877,
0.6340739727020264,
0.5354310274124146,
0.6460574269294739,
0.07482779771089554,
-0.2950908839702606,
-0.46545204520225525,
-0.5621753334999084,
-0.3343445658683777,
-0.45792216062545776,
-0.11679673939943314,
0.281772255897522,
0.43452849984169006,
-0.37560614943504333,
0.9535972476005554,
-0.6097127199172974,
-0.16648975014686584,
-0.21125946938991547,
0.046736203134059906,
0.21657268702983856,
0.573092520236969,
0.2742233872413635,
-0.33766791224479675,
-0.36554956436157227,
-0.364496111869812,
-0.6004832983016968,
-0.26158860325813293,
-0.29900607466697693,
-0.03967289254069328,
0.23428742587566376,
0.467216819524765,
-0.27403509616851807,
0.13825923204421997,
0.5888800621032715,
-0.22800150513648987,
0.7637879848480225,
-0.14297181367874146,
-0.0755360946059227,
-1.011742353439331,
-0.08522773534059525,
0.13568797707557678,
-0.15126144886016846,
-0.2642425298690796,
0.27607864141464233,
0.0018039604183286428,
-0.12277599424123764,
-0.06517583131790161,
0.2114185094833374,
-0.4069174528121948,
-0.051315370947122574,
0.03687683492898941,
0.4191916584968567,
-0.41206783056259155,
0.5273312330245972,
-0.3357839286327362,
0.35865509510040283,
0.5897699594497681,
-0.32042691111564636,
0.6662232875823975,
-0.06839899718761444,
-0.09671133011579514,
0.7042738199234009,
-0.5697475671768188,
0.2959461808204651,
-0.2153765708208084,
0.4109981656074524,
-1.3289400339126587,
-0.40139928460121155,
0.30001720786094666,
-0.6877173781394958,
0.200405091047287,
0.048373784869909286,
-0.7196024656295776,
-0.683607280254364,
-0.5475723743438721,
0.19897966086864471,
0.425335168838501,
-0.540685772895813,
0.20448824763298035,
0.14958389103412628,
-0.24202555418014526,
-0.6720574498176575,
-0.5996127724647522,
0.055659107863903046,
0.059151582419872284,
-0.7972105145454407,
-0.25363749265670776,
-0.27052170038223267,
-0.16876724362373352,
0.01999812014400959,
-0.37792396545410156,
0.13154393434524536,
0.16411179304122925,
0.4013650715351105,
0.3530017137527466,
-0.09882062673568726,
0.1472817212343216,
-0.0723705068230629,
0.03156464546918869,
0.49365758895874023,
-0.15790361166000366,
0.30513715744018555,
-0.4356352984905243,
-0.659864604473114,
-0.23790830373764038,
0.276360422372818,
0.4379742741584778,
-0.3588528335094452,
0.6174032092094421,
0.24172843992710114,
-0.33582353591918945,
-0.6659196019172668,
-0.48486658930778503,
-0.23746222257614136,
-0.41327208280563354,
0.41285741329193115,
-0.2101893573999405,
-0.803815484046936,
0.4934070110321045,
-0.12412721663713455,
0.33740106225013733,
-0.01609472557902336,
0.6078299283981323,
-0.25254887342453003,
1.1100894212722778,
0.5896015763282776,
0.04976276308298111,
0.20776183903217316,
-0.18544650077819824,
0.4811538755893707,
-0.6849846243858337,
-0.4664730429649353,
-0.8146600127220154,
-0.3106277585029602,
-0.39374762773513794,
-0.25401806831359863,
0.39393630623817444,
0.35971903800964355,
-0.35861456394195557,
0.12251323461532593,
-0.4558388888835907,
0.4919983446598053,
0.7443431615829468,
0.11428224295377731,
0.43077823519706726,
0.04263726994395256,
-0.24348320066928864,
-0.10937090218067169,
-0.7632644772529602,
-0.5262090563774109,
1.1128727197647095,
0.3285456597805023,
1.0677001476287842,
0.32508063316345215,
1.1608774662017822,
0.0888507291674614,
0.5133554339408875,
-0.7437788844108582,
0.6235065460205078,
0.2990776598453522,
-0.47781696915626526,
-0.371938556432724,
-0.928575873374939,
-0.6906982660293579,
0.19259557127952576,
-0.07262014597654343,
-0.7661714553833008,
-0.34537166357040405,
0.4455144703388214,
-0.3382095396518707,
0.32879552245140076,
-0.5969751477241516,
0.7537984251976013,
-0.04381416365504265,
-0.37226951122283936,
-0.09282957017421722,
-0.7503190040588379,
0.4806918501853943,
-0.17313864827156067,
0.48347365856170654,
0.41903766989707947,
0.29667484760284424,
0.7560774683952332,
-0.6351524591445923,
1.0444272756576538,
-0.3331013321876526,
-0.37054502964019775,
0.4689086377620697,
0.46324828267097473,
0.6903699040412903,
0.22725939750671387,
0.10586676001548767,
-0.4570193886756897,
-0.04483900964260101,
-0.27120834589004517,
-0.6101288199424744,
0.751830518245697,
-0.8472333550453186,
-0.8926210999488831,
-0.4687589406967163,
-0.6937177181243896,
-0.3407614827156067,
0.115077443420887,
0.10653220117092133,
0.7438543438911438,
0.49266862869262695,
0.06568266451358795,
0.27530553936958313,
-0.3882389962673187,
0.20664601027965546,
0.35095447301864624,
-0.6235201358795166,
-0.09371151775121689,
1.0151207447052002,
0.2212630957365036,
0.22729940712451935,
0.049751315265893936,
0.17620700597763062,
-0.07978718727827072,
-0.5396682620048523,
-0.3227807283401489,
0.22716747224330902,
-0.9641295075416565,
-0.32478830218315125,
-0.16502025723457336,
-0.28722235560417175,
-0.32022789120674133,
-0.12206815183162689,
-0.16886204481124878,
-0.37360531091690063,
-0.035846322774887085,
-0.19125576317310333,
-0.12865738570690155,
1.0172103643417358,
-0.233228400349617,
-0.0011406384874135256,
-0.9667249917984009,
0.07867446541786194,
0.2072581648826599,
0.21087291836738586,
0.33616286516189575,
-0.38353779911994934,
-0.08517520129680634,
0.1275983452796936,
-0.5434594750404358,
-1.0163321495056152,
0.18236182630062103,
-0.17007938027381897,
0.43587374687194824,
0.026345741003751755,
0.10131374001502991,
0.47367751598358154,
-0.37338992953300476,
0.8939194679260254,
0.4503512680530548,
-1.0027785301208496,
0.8370724320411682,
-0.2893351912498474,
0.282873272895813,
0.2983354926109314,
0.2832924723625183,
-0.6589150428771973,
-0.8616487383842468,
-0.19860999286174774,
-0.8528298735618591,
0.7308416962623596,
0.11377736181020737,
0.15965798497200012,
0.015523692592978477,
0.28257763385772705,
-0.06635197252035141,
0.09832634031772614,
-1.2054529190063477,
-0.18843087553977966,
-0.11039052158594131,
-0.17522074282169342,
0.18399029970169067,
-0.21463324129581451,
-0.23278042674064636,
-0.14481286704540253,
0.5046049952507019,
-0.22954486310482025,
-0.09210588783025742,
0.156618133187294,
-0.06408844143152237,
-0.5683229565620422,
0.5113615989685059,
0.4303143322467804,
1.1435140371322632,
-0.07670354098081589,
0.38834649324417114,
-0.003959351219236851,
-0.25779083371162415,
0.2370569258928299,
-0.41810253262519836,
-0.15897706151008606,
-0.12136903405189514,
0.4739539623260498,
0.23764105141162872,
-0.10324249416589737,
-0.7609154582023621,
0.5940102338790894,
0.09299144893884659,
0.022052599117159843,
-0.18091805279254913,
0.137693852186203,
0.24174118041992188,
0.1071099117398262,
0.28726276755332947,
0.2898590862751007,
-0.016813643276691437,
-0.6605437994003296,
0.015886683017015457,
0.2585031986236572,
-0.10498938709497452,
-0.27928462624549866,
0.47668033838272095,
0.5325129628181458,
-0.48491713404655457,
0.8223934173583984,
-0.17488360404968262,
-0.5205089449882507,
0.729644238948822,
0.8685516715049744,
0.43978676199913025,
-0.15783166885375977,
0.45470449328422546,
0.5819065570831299,
0.25157269835472107,
-0.02092943899333477,
0.21732380986213684,
-0.08991030603647232,
-0.5069523453712463,
-0.6626688838005066,
-0.536424994468689,
-0.5681425333023071,
-0.055103279650211334,
-0.704579770565033,
0.21622870862483978,
-0.5846096873283386,
-0.01553268451243639,
-0.33086097240448,
-0.03276308253407478,
-0.3477361798286438,
0.00542014604434371,
0.2221880704164505,
0.7242649793624878,
-0.8450589776039124,
0.6718189120292664,
0.9767012596130371,
-0.5549954771995544,
-1.3253451585769653,
-0.03217291459441185,
0.19166253507137299,
-0.41871383786201477,
1.0850400924682617,
0.06874602288007736,
-0.17554685473442078,
-0.20160561800003052,
-0.6098760366439819,
-0.6667735576629639,
0.7998405694961548,
0.2811480760574341,
-0.8283851742744446,
-0.19636808335781097,
0.2980315387248993,
0.6844750046730042,
-0.24779324233531952,
0.16975277662277222,
0.06495165824890137,
0.2815944254398346,
0.17147612571716309,
-0.7908667922019958,
0.2397642731666565,
-0.2450929433107376,
0.2107626050710678,
0.14642946422100067,
-0.6040833592414856,
0.9158923625946045,
-0.4270254075527191,
-0.11369004845619202,
-0.10238416492938995,
0.5325644016265869,
0.5962194800376892,
0.15135829150676727,
0.5721060037612915,
0.5208680033683777,
0.9810715317726135,
0.1190042570233345,
0.9583761692047119,
-0.21360573172569275,
0.5701971650123596,
1.2313001155853271,
-0.33756136894226074,
0.8452397584915161,
0.5142407417297363,
-0.1824972927570343,
0.5858603715896606,
0.5176912546157837,
-0.11595337837934494,
0.11733705550432205,
0.8287668824195862,
-0.014561568386852741,
-0.2845946252346039,
0.22907237708568573,
-0.4418592154979706,
-0.03403608873486519,
0.14414022862911224,
-0.028283745050430298,
-0.4134257137775421,
-0.18356095254421234,
0.03641180694103241,
0.1479736864566803,
-0.4330306053161621,
0.3011167347431183,
0.18107326328754425,
-0.9400588274002075,
0.589461624622345,
0.05227114260196686,
0.5762709975242615,
-0.2744832932949066,
-0.18586798012256622,
-0.4768238365650177,
0.31225505471229553,
-0.812846302986145,
-0.805256724357605,
0.2235192358493805,
0.44476792216300964,
-0.1447163224220276,
-0.17181426286697388,
0.42086800932884216,
-0.34150341153144836,
-0.5371862649917603,
0.26750341057777405,
0.5013520121574402,
0.12881843745708466,
0.4325348734855652,
-0.36432403326034546,
0.0763949528336525,
0.09561631083488464,
-0.20300880074501038,
0.24857833981513977,
0.3491581380367279,
-0.004391801077872515,
0.7939385175704956,
0.5916712284088135,
0.15151865780353546,
0.31567561626434326,
0.09155479818582535,
0.8668143153190613,
-0.5102243423461914,
-0.20384368300437927,
-0.8508774638175964,
0.4791998267173767,
0.19161781668663025,
-0.23765262961387634,
1.1253089904785156,
0.4806274473667145,
1.107198715209961,
-0.06858839839696884,
0.7191258072853088,
-0.06414251029491425,
0.4145226776599884,
-0.40520524978637695,
0.2962329089641571,
-0.47962042689323425,
0.786998450756073,
-0.5837478637695312,
-1.2109179496765137,
-0.4278731644153595,
0.5318149924278259,
-0.11171972006559372,
0.08620642125606537,
0.8562359809875488,
0.7943528294563293,
0.26578783988952637,
-0.1259378343820572,
0.0164002925157547,
0.536389172077179,
0.4872211515903473,
0.8986167311668396,
1.3151122331619263,
-0.04110553115606308,
0.6728591322898865,
-0.13963726162910461,
-0.41836661100387573,
-0.23761186003684998,
-0.6702224016189575,
-0.8859413266181946,
-0.2704011797904968,
-0.5725084543228149,
-0.7697346806526184,
-0.07814577221870422,
0.9891104102134705,
0.3658211827278137,
-0.7444290518760681,
-0.4950200617313385,
-0.20119458436965942,
0.3830121159553528,
-0.014291481114923954,
-0.2435862272977829,
0.17552736401557922,
-0.7287289500236511,
-0.4568389058113098,
0.1965804249048233,
-0.0015529267257079482,
-0.45118942856788635,
-0.45360058546066284,
-0.14449544250965118,
0.197470560669899,
-0.025600086897611618,
0.5353610515594482,
0.05472681298851967,
-0.5455983281135559,
-0.48350048065185547,
0.09173190593719482,
-0.29686200618743896,
0.13685870170593262,
0.6997233033180237,
-0.6127113699913025,
0.2597580552101135,
0.7680661082267761,
0.685696542263031,
0.2916204631328583,
-0.10455215722322464,
0.4339664578437805,
-0.7691073417663574,
-0.4409872889518738,
0.32674115896224976,
0.25188353657722473,
0.191807359457016,
-0.34472429752349854,
0.42973431944847107,
0.24662509560585022,
-0.7994523048400879,
-1.132051944732666,
0.21104611456394196,
-0.861641526222229,
-0.18987636268138885,
1.130841612815857,
-0.31498631834983826,
-0.05902815982699394,
0.3730967938899994,
-0.3522959053516388,
-0.04356943070888519,
-0.3042958974838257,
0.8473374247550964,
0.9399735331535339,
-0.2947135865688324,
0.13309001922607422,
-0.4498648941516876,
0.17765949666500092,
0.5025104284286499,
-0.9313869476318359,
-0.016659580171108246,
0.8656912446022034,
0.5305059552192688,
0.38082849979400635,
0.4748307466506958,
-0.21501773595809937,
0.39307495951652527,
0.0673961341381073,
-0.06057177856564522,
0.05181128531694412,
-0.6851641535758972,
-0.33996784687042236,
0.42753469944000244,
0.44610846042633057,
0.12695908546447754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00301v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00301v3
|
Enhanced Language Model Truthfulness with Learnable Intervention and Uncertainty Expression
| 2024-05-01T03:50:09 | 2024-06-07T01:41:15 |
Farima Fatahi Bayat, Xin Liu, H. V. Jagadish, Lu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) can generate long-form and coherent text, yet
they often hallucinate facts, which undermines their reliability. To mitigate
this issue, inference-time methods steer LLM representations toward the
"truthful directions" previously learned for truth elicitation. However,
applying these truthful directions with the same intensity fails to generalize
across different query contexts. We propose LITO, a Learnable Intervention
method for Truthfulness Optimization that automatically identifies the optimal
intervention intensity tailored to each specific context. LITO explores a
sequence of model generations based on increasing levels of intervention
intensities. It selects the most accurate response or refuses to answer when
the predictions are highly uncertain. Experiments on multiple LLMs and
question-answering datasets demonstrate that LITO improves truthfulness while
preserving task accuracy. The adaptive nature of LITO counters the limitations
of one-size-fits-all intervention methods, maximizing truthfulness by
reflecting the model's internal knowledge only when it is confident. Our code
is available at https://github.com/launchnlp/LITO.
|
[
0.27046042680740356,
-0.9463331699371338,
0.8265350461006165,
0.2731396555900574,
-0.18409962952136993,
0.18683665990829468,
-0.4954677224159241,
-0.27709150314331055,
-0.08610482513904572,
0.5942198038101196,
-0.36143219470977783,
-0.3656896650791168,
-0.43623846769332886,
-0.06360190361738205,
-0.10315854102373123,
0.8744629621505737,
0.12450753152370453,
-0.03531612455844879,
0.12029799818992615,
-0.11693330109119415,
-0.30659615993499756,
-0.059296298772096634,
-0.7408145070075989,
-0.3746453523635864,
0.40965092182159424,
0.44389691948890686,
0.789770781993866,
0.5684829950332642,
0.3641233742237091,
0.31349003314971924,
-0.10322465747594833,
0.37573692202568054,
-0.6140667796134949,
0.17980808019638062,
-0.015698757022619247,
-0.6857160329818726,
-0.38799962401390076,
-0.04335859790444374,
0.7302192449569702,
0.8140439391136169,
-0.2965869605541229,
-0.13463209569454193,
0.0743504986166954,
0.6005836129188538,
-0.7678149342536926,
0.07757854461669922,
-0.867843747138977,
-0.05880099907517433,
0.3868507742881775,
-0.22630073130130768,
-0.5709234476089478,
-0.6115204095840454,
0.13013309240341187,
-0.7042888402938843,
-0.11876832693815231,
0.019471200183033943,
0.5077096223831177,
0.5020930767059326,
-0.45086726546287537,
-0.4854881167411804,
-0.9244371056556702,
1.1151540279388428,
-0.936409592628479,
0.42550331354141235,
0.23546861112117767,
0.2695392966270447,
-0.22485803067684174,
-0.5837565064430237,
-0.4843573570251465,
-0.16164322197437286,
0.11803586035966873,
0.3785821199417114,
0.17444248497486115,
0.359562486410141,
0.20559115707874298,
0.06796646118164062,
-0.43691691756248474,
0.04012303054332733,
0.05468674749135971,
-0.31663036346435547,
0.5174927711486816,
-0.030629832297563553,
0.0009650031570345163,
-0.062052369117736816,
-0.36577108502388,
0.06756795942783356,
-0.5657802224159241,
0.14781764149665833,
0.3568767309188843,
0.13318650424480438,
-0.10336707532405853,
0.49423497915267944,
-0.2522941529750824,
0.6716828942298889,
-0.09051494300365448,
-0.658734917640686,
0.2794003188610077,
-0.17495016753673553,
-0.13478851318359375,
0.16534726321697235,
0.5532264709472656,
0.5712243318557739,
-0.027906084433197975,
-0.2099457085132599,
-0.5970319509506226,
-0.13170145452022552,
0.06110726296901703,
-0.9927205443382263,
0.23769734799861908,
0.5051644444465637,
-0.1619751900434494,
-0.4792824685573578,
-0.16455532610416412,
-0.7463836669921875,
-0.43991026282310486,
-0.04019754379987717,
0.6111199855804443,
-0.41793903708457947,
-0.3406884968280792,
0.39328593015670776,
0.1115938276052475,
0.24472816288471222,
0.40088245272636414,
-0.5854564905166626,
0.014220197685062885,
0.4830766022205353,
0.7541189193725586,
0.020434774458408356,
0.06737764924764633,
-0.7789758443832397,
0.24521683156490326,
-0.6722514033317566,
0.3636032044887543,
-0.8151967525482178,
-0.27667248249053955,
0.1279570758342743,
-0.3006346523761749,
-0.13895273208618164,
-0.3669203817844391,
0.7971702218055725,
-0.6970120072364807,
0.35161930322647095,
-0.10045557469129562,
-0.828348696231842,
-0.21838025748729706,
0.23434236645698547,
-0.5069063305854797,
0.7854653000831604,
0.20120291411876678,
-0.7010518908500671,
0.2458764612674713,
-0.7250550985336304,
-0.25600630044937134,
-0.04694052040576935,
-0.2359350025653839,
-0.4230654537677765,
0.4005637466907501,
0.1844692975282669,
0.399532675743103,
-0.10518142580986023,
0.6331498026847839,
-0.26641055941581726,
-0.29408255219459534,
0.434685081243515,
-0.6038291454315186,
0.55594801902771,
0.2759593427181244,
-0.22392180562019348,
0.2967321574687958,
-0.896132230758667,
0.060217779129743576,
0.3072335422039032,
-0.38500678539276123,
-0.2945135533809662,
0.11634474247694016,
-0.19825680553913116,
-0.1088206097483635,
0.4486229717731476,
-0.6559949517250061,
0.013079803436994553,
-0.6264679431915283,
0.2487601935863495,
0.8594754934310913,
0.17843292653560638,
0.28818580508232117,
-0.3854913115501404,
0.40648186206817627,
-0.24601271748542786,
0.4301649332046509,
0.06605707108974457,
-0.2643432319164276,
-0.7512129545211792,
-0.28323736786842346,
0.0870087519288063,
0.525479793548584,
-1.109319806098938,
0.40823233127593994,
-0.4457668364048004,
-0.054226186126470566,
-0.46681082248687744,
0.1912810355424881,
0.44941553473472595,
0.8573710322380066,
0.236649289727211,
0.2104910910129547,
-0.34949302673339844,
-0.790190577507019,
-0.3862749934196472,
-0.24426984786987305,
0.09279691427946091,
0.34161505103111267,
0.3082888424396515,
-0.18240980803966522,
0.8808892965316772,
-0.5407230854034424,
0.2105393260717392,
-0.44392165541648865,
0.3527370095252991,
0.29795292019844055,
0.29015305638313293,
0.47321557998657227,
-0.9892440438270569,
-0.45789021253585815,
-0.04979533329606056,
-0.7611892819404602,
-0.23875147104263306,
-0.4961394965648651,
0.149091899394989,
0.07753380388021469,
0.25639474391937256,
-0.09958098828792572,
0.187120258808136,
0.6910703182220459,
-0.03891703113913536,
0.23086076974868774,
-0.2598116993904114,
0.10751276463270187,
-1.132863998413086,
-0.09957026690244675,
-0.440083771944046,
-0.364402174949646,
-0.7836975455284119,
-0.05620817467570305,
0.17623618245124817,
0.18217581510543823,
-0.3496834337711334,
0.61134934425354,
-0.2588328719139099,
0.10344327986240387,
-0.4866355061531067,
0.06722458451986313,
0.06215742602944374,
0.49863383173942566,
0.2241663783788681,
0.9168928861618042,
0.4827386438846588,
-0.5222128033638,
0.2533207833766937,
-0.16513539850711823,
-0.32027390599250793,
0.31638067960739136,
-0.6987257599830627,
0.35248908400535583,
-0.1645866185426712,
-0.2712623178958893,
-0.6756122708320618,
-0.46962520480155945,
-0.03432091325521469,
-0.39867278933525085,
0.3027585446834564,
-0.0053110988810658455,
-0.3082278370857239,
0.028015080839395523,
-0.5940991044044495,
0.2578672170639038,
0.38424715399742126,
-0.5805140137672424,
0.8946545124053955,
0.17175078392028809,
-0.08952321112155914,
-0.7668372392654419,
-0.47911369800567627,
-0.021611278876662254,
-0.27625030279159546,
-0.47395554184913635,
0.05945739895105362,
-0.5516877770423889,
-0.32583916187286377,
-0.3290553689002991,
-0.1975296437740326,
-0.025363797321915627,
0.3134121894836426,
0.09875103086233139,
0.28664731979370117,
0.06222839280962944,
0.386409729719162,
0.3003990948200226,
0.031116073951125145,
0.026531226933002472,
-0.06356159597635269,
0.44230711460113525,
-0.25376537442207336,
-0.3121732473373413,
-0.24977008998394012,
0.13314233720302582,
0.33874404430389404,
-0.07049451768398285,
0.8400768637657166,
0.6067091226577759,
-0.33296969532966614,
-0.3250071108341217,
-0.7402963042259216,
-0.2960306704044342,
-0.5428468585014343,
0.4007300138473511,
-0.3428468108177185,
-0.9158619046211243,
0.38783082365989685,
-0.24751457571983337,
0.24666865170001984,
-0.020405156537890434,
0.24626509845256805,
0.18081897497177124,
1.115756869316101,
0.8291947245597839,
-0.028811419382691383,
0.6075230240821838,
-0.10299833863973618,
0.17118701338768005,
-0.8552742600440979,
-0.0861346498131752,
-0.2548006474971771,
0.11204942315816879,
-0.47419628500938416,
-0.4107617139816284,
0.5810667276382446,
0.12187843024730682,
-0.025290338322520256,
-0.17186732590198517,
-0.350458025932312,
0.318109393119812,
0.30411139130592346,
0.4198874533176422,
0.48763883113861084,
-0.08312340080738068,
0.11448090523481369,
-0.11209681630134583,
-0.7281885147094727,
-0.4199366867542267,
1.2121851444244385,
0.30816707015037537,
0.886224091053009,
0.16811643540859222,
0.7756395936012268,
0.05190597474575043,
0.4745975136756897,
-0.9947670698165894,
0.4744618237018585,
0.3569120764732361,
-0.5593551397323608,
-0.47055861353874207,
-0.7978101968765259,
-0.7191225290298462,
0.02609381265938282,
-0.303216814994812,
-0.5014488101005554,
0.17400075495243073,
0.1127941831946373,
-0.5204858183860779,
0.10738798975944519,
-0.6633854508399963,
0.46404725313186646,
-0.4196716845035553,
-0.5166550278663635,
-0.22641323506832123,
-0.6128078699111938,
0.274332195520401,
-0.42397600412368774,
0.5436445474624634,
-0.08314528316259384,
-0.5578219294548035,
0.600730836391449,
-0.15062856674194336,
0.8539857864379883,
-0.06765789538621902,
-0.11668382585048676,
0.28747352957725525,
0.1288755089044571,
0.8484373092651367,
0.17586514353752136,
-0.4073287546634674,
-0.32426512241363525,
-0.3805930018424988,
-0.4589177072048187,
-0.7777768969535828,
0.47823649644851685,
-0.6200687885284424,
-0.5582559108734131,
-0.13146983087062836,
-0.8684064745903015,
-0.4635765850543976,
0.2756732106208801,
0.25807949900627136,
0.41250890493392944,
-0.1739223301410675,
0.44114920496940613,
1.0338902473449707,
-0.26753392815589905,
0.6851539015769958,
0.7979587912559509,
-0.508196234703064,
-0.5423943996429443,
0.7609548568725586,
-0.03126330301165581,
0.6469162106513977,
0.4890792965888977,
0.6210137605667114,
-0.2411985993385315,
-0.8541733622550964,
-0.0403672531247139,
0.23577164113521576,
-0.6998884677886963,
-0.14155030250549316,
-0.4326736032962799,
-0.11751782894134521,
-0.3924862742424011,
-0.21260134875774384,
-0.5933475494384766,
-0.2817324995994568,
-0.009147887118160725,
-0.19362682104110718,
0.3534908890724182,
0.5323308110237122,
-0.06732118874788284,
0.4150382876396179,
-0.5668743252754211,
0.2837560474872589,
0.5437090992927551,
0.24576784670352936,
-0.39298123121261597,
-0.8054437041282654,
-0.1498454213142395,
0.20122680068016052,
0.1453915387392044,
-0.8130950927734375,
0.4172801673412323,
0.45509177446365356,
0.5347120761871338,
0.4880717098712921,
0.4024713635444641,
0.3097527325153351,
-0.18994562327861786,
0.4593025743961334,
0.24200807511806488,
-0.8874858617782593,
0.8471329212188721,
-0.24644114077091217,
0.26823216676712036,
0.5317966938018799,
0.32616713643074036,
-0.22576460242271423,
-0.26771873235702515,
-0.3700898289680481,
-0.6868101954460144,
0.40084683895111084,
0.2361903041601181,
0.26874205470085144,
0.18544724583625793,
0.5468553900718689,
0.18406787514686584,
0.3796660304069519,
-0.9274200201034546,
0.010518082417547703,
-0.15774932503700256,
-0.49962037801742554,
0.21855026483535767,
-0.44707438349723816,
-0.43834391236305237,
0.14150504767894745,
0.7688754796981812,
-0.6557878851890564,
-0.08961900323629379,
0.34678858518600464,
-0.29559949040412903,
-0.26257431507110596,
0.35573145747184753,
0.49785566329956055,
0.7430040836334229,
-0.3258185386657715,
0.18976978957653046,
0.23607869446277618,
-0.5658161640167236,
-0.16458696126937866,
0.005161658860743046,
-0.5039696097373962,
-0.1735651046037674,
0.7587361931800842,
0.8402213454246521,
0.15376320481300354,
-0.8201004862785339,
0.6793501973152161,
-0.08283261209726334,
0.0877457708120346,
-0.15112978219985962,
0.3896160125732422,
-0.08718328922986984,
0.4179518520832062,
0.2817497253417969,
-0.2979275584220886,
0.23074907064437866,
-0.5906292796134949,
-0.17532040178775787,
0.5127760171890259,
-0.45090070366859436,
-0.1800219565629959,
0.44240137934684753,
0.22272513806819916,
-0.2429150491952896,
0.3510669767856598,
-0.18865293264389038,
-0.5140833854675293,
0.3535209000110626,
0.45753416419029236,
0.7999714016914368,
-0.5174444913864136,
0.24507547914981842,
0.273939311504364,
0.4434219300746918,
-0.06612180173397064,
0.5597264170646667,
0.17064706981182098,
-1.0834301710128784,
-0.5029228329658508,
-0.5302392244338989,
-0.4108160734176636,
0.23633012175559998,
-0.580768346786499,
-0.08225707709789276,
-0.5996792316436768,
-0.12903420627117157,
-0.4247976541519165,
0.10751140862703323,
-0.3073989748954773,
0.2636035680770874,
-0.07044652104377747,
0.5895037055015564,
-0.8113484978675842,
0.8523615598678589,
0.3593687415122986,
-0.38344424962997437,
-0.8656914830207825,
0.049677714705467224,
-0.1614050716161728,
-0.975147008895874,
0.1649058759212494,
0.11654011905193329,
-0.41325220465660095,
0.02469034120440483,
-0.9650511145591736,
-0.7456678748130798,
1.115931749343872,
0.6371458172798157,
-0.602508544921875,
0.17408965528011322,
0.20269237458705902,
0.4110620319843292,
-0.474412739276886,
0.22195252776145935,
0.4163907468318939,
0.4380713701248169,
0.18187443912029266,
-0.7338719964027405,
0.07526987046003342,
0.16191941499710083,
0.06035804748535156,
-0.1648981273174286,
-0.7182668447494507,
0.3671056032180786,
-0.4033181071281433,
-0.02085101418197155,
0.05042358860373497,
0.7485862970352173,
0.10989949107170105,
0.20830507576465607,
0.7075324654579163,
0.24936527013778687,
0.9905267357826233,
-0.02748815342783928,
1.0025941133499146,
-0.5319058895111084,
0.28874391317367554,
1.314862608909607,
-0.2212079018354416,
0.5886019468307495,
0.4788531959056854,
0.0790630429983139,
0.3016655147075653,
0.40695735812187195,
0.4443845748901367,
0.5483478307723999,
-0.3319719135761261,
-0.5747841000556946,
-0.4336065649986267,
-0.4513699412345886,
-0.18732881546020508,
0.22133304178714752,
0.51808100938797,
-0.2703409492969513,
0.14803320169448853,
0.04171471670269966,
0.10207914561033249,
0.24317213892936707,
-0.18630556762218475,
0.7548519968986511,
-0.019678711891174316,
-0.5138392448425293,
0.5380700826644897,
-0.2969914376735687,
0.46469828486442566,
-0.7419288754463196,
-0.16182956099510193,
-0.33503589034080505,
0.019274435937404633,
-0.13542746007442474,
-0.7333977222442627,
0.015629053115844727,
-0.2000662237405777,
0.010960442014038563,
-0.13404013216495514,
0.7262510657310486,
-0.5408857464790344,
-0.5622483491897583,
0.4343603253364563,
0.4901732802391052,
-0.08951614797115326,
-0.1049998328089714,
-0.7245355844497681,
0.28643670678138733,
0.13190317153930664,
-0.6267060041427612,
-0.05168042331933975,
0.46609845757484436,
0.1962767094373703,
0.9386312961578369,
0.46748772263526917,
0.2318456918001175,
0.028643647208809853,
0.27156445384025574,
0.803178608417511,
-0.323138028383255,
-0.10129597038030624,
-0.5241885781288147,
0.35143813490867615,
-0.3190913498401642,
-0.11066455394029617,
0.5764367580413818,
0.5776119828224182,
0.5295935273170471,
0.21523945033550262,
0.6505491733551025,
0.3012198209762573,
0.5677492022514343,
-0.8257223963737488,
0.28634437918663025,
-0.6773547530174255,
0.48855048418045044,
-0.0013599294470623136,
-0.8919521570205688,
-0.24435323476791382,
0.5837792158126831,
-0.384111613035202,
0.057923197746276855,
0.6550458073616028,
0.9837601780891418,
0.15026064217090607,
-0.02181202918291092,
0.6224269866943359,
0.4804627299308777,
0.2881525754928589,
0.4942973852157593,
0.6942988038063049,
-0.14518937468528748,
0.5334151387214661,
-0.43020346760749817,
-0.5002598166465759,
-0.27457061409950256,
-1.051943302154541,
-0.8082441091537476,
-0.2411462366580963,
-0.20596756041049957,
-0.21360735595226288,
0.21856345236301422,
1.0166010856628418,
0.6750208735466003,
-0.6146886944770813,
-0.05870884656906128,
-0.1791268140077591,
0.3819374144077301,
-0.014144142158329487,
-0.2459793984889984,
0.3227129876613617,
-0.5220848917961121,
-0.8334734439849854,
0.5285033583641052,
0.373372346162796,
0.030183633789420128,
-0.03521982952952385,
-0.2515130341053009,
-0.009830585680902004,
0.4845068156719208,
0.5259981155395508,
0.0015122215263545513,
-0.49858301877975464,
-0.6579411029815674,
0.05285116285085678,
-0.0961347445845604,
0.13209138810634613,
0.6446661353111267,
-0.4776085913181305,
0.7851805090904236,
0.4146082103252411,
0.6888370513916016,
0.3166089653968811,
-0.2061726301908493,
0.5067507028579712,
-0.7303104400634766,
0.1470271497964859,
0.5945126414299011,
0.41287896037101746,
0.5027580857276917,
-0.5572255253791809,
0.7291146516799927,
0.2214999496936798,
-0.39358699321746826,
-0.8535485863685608,
0.43275174498558044,
-0.8719143271446228,
-0.4509941637516022,
1.1907494068145752,
-0.245627298951149,
-0.2063858062028885,
-0.09652219712734222,
-0.0918465107679367,
0.38751569390296936,
-0.4223923087120056,
0.7730405926704407,
0.5412706732749939,
-0.15547150373458862,
-0.2096436619758606,
-0.7308128476142883,
0.4597291648387909,
0.5660691857337952,
-0.8373057842254639,
0.05631881207227707,
0.46005532145500183,
0.29305610060691833,
0.11904416233301163,
0.42929115891456604,
0.1566145271062851,
0.03982280194759369,
-0.04840899631381035,
0.10476403683423996,
-0.001773275900632143,
-0.49943646788597107,
-0.37376442551612854,
-0.02876109816133976,
0.32996290922164917,
0.2284761518239975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00291v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00291v1
|
How Can I Improve? Using GPT to Highlight the Desired and Undesired Parts of Open-ended Responses
| 2024-05-01T02:59:10 | 2024-05-01T02:59:10 |
Jionghao Lin, Eason Chen, Zeifei Han, Ashish Gurung, Danielle R. Thomas, Wei Tan, Ngoc Dang Nguyen, Kenneth R. Koedinger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Automated explanatory feedback systems play a crucial role in facilitating
learning for a large cohort of learners by offering feedback that incorporates
explanations, significantly enhancing the learning process. However, delivering
such explanatory feedback in real-time poses challenges, particularly when high
classification accuracy for domain-specific, nuanced responses is essential.
Our study leverages the capabilities of large language models, specifically
Generative Pre-Trained Transformers (GPT), to explore a sequence labeling
approach focused on identifying components of desired and less desired praise
for providing explanatory feedback within a tutor training dataset. Our aim is
to equip tutors with actionable, explanatory feedback during online training
lessons. To investigate the potential of GPT models for providing the
explanatory feedback, we employed two commonly-used approaches: prompting and
fine-tuning. To quantify the quality of highlighted praise components
identified by GPT models, we introduced a Modified Intersection over Union
(M-IoU) score. Our findings demonstrate that: (1) the M-IoU score effectively
correlates with human judgment in evaluating sequence quality; (2) using
two-shot prompting on GPT-3.5 resulted in decent performance in recognizing
effort-based (M-IoU of 0.46) and outcome-based praise (M-IoU of 0.68); and (3)
our optimally fine-tuned GPT-3.5 model achieved M-IoU scores of 0.64 for
effort-based praise and 0.84 for outcome-based praise, aligning with the
satisfaction levels evaluated by human coders. Our results show promise for
using GPT models to provide feedback that focuses on specific elements in their
open-ended responses that are desirable or could use improvement.
|
[
-0.5696071982383728,
-0.7007081508636475,
0.33125820755958557,
0.06393890082836151,
-0.4236106276512146,
0.11255882680416107,
-0.43468597531318665,
-0.37689587473869324,
0.11606194823980331,
0.06886567175388336,
-0.4109223186969757,
-0.4668557643890381,
-0.5383455753326416,
0.2322850525379181,
-0.4455263912677765,
1.3979746103286743,
-0.07226037979125977,
0.19817695021629333,
0.10766350477933884,
0.1343076378107071,
-0.8263012766838074,
-0.4888964593410492,
-0.5886368155479431,
-0.047996971756219864,
0.6158812642097473,
0.6252983212471008,
0.563506007194519,
0.4312848150730133,
0.5081966519355774,
0.240822896361351,
0.01819809153676033,
0.16203537583351135,
-0.4296160638332367,
0.030248679220676422,
-0.14350198209285736,
-0.5443210005760193,
-0.5704283714294434,
0.18456000089645386,
0.2597818672657013,
0.6531504988670349,
0.008970377966761589,
0.2712152898311615,
0.6357995867729187,
0.4437113404273987,
-0.38719215989112854,
0.4661865532398224,
-0.2140253335237503,
0.2514095902442932,
0.011273072101175785,
-0.33023393154144287,
-0.6358044147491455,
-0.6357941627502441,
0.3323976993560791,
-0.6504390835762024,
0.5027658939361572,
-0.27653399109840393,
0.7599567770957947,
0.4682968258857727,
0.052548207342624664,
-0.3777836263179779,
-0.8550992608070374,
0.6896237730979919,
-0.7049142718315125,
0.031512219458818436,
0.4067971706390381,
0.5266202688217163,
0.2426900863647461,
-0.576646089553833,
-0.3293512165546417,
-0.2590000629425049,
-0.2678605914115906,
0.5379190444946289,
0.10890445113182068,
0.005322903860360384,
0.4188692271709442,
0.5490596890449524,
-0.4631037712097168,
0.21275408565998077,
-0.20179404318332672,
-0.12202727794647217,
0.49945318698883057,
-0.02387731708586216,
0.01690545678138733,
-0.010289294645190239,
-0.047081444412469864,
-0.30776798725128174,
-0.6283431649208069,
0.40866246819496155,
0.4499910771846771,
0.5228667855262756,
0.04265613108873367,
0.6775432825088501,
-0.1975286304950714,
0.7677302360534668,
0.14503733813762665,
0.06364361941814423,
0.05639897286891937,
-0.24941472709178925,
0.06767525523900986,
-0.26313546299934387,
0.5266115069389343,
0.4518895745277405,
0.24433554708957672,
-0.18832479417324066,
-0.30103936791419983,
0.07633688300848007,
0.2910235822200775,
-0.7298613786697388,
-0.3785604238510132,
0.13189949095249176,
-0.32281720638275146,
-0.07319331914186478,
0.4939672350883484,
-0.9558298587799072,
-0.12796783447265625,
-0.6528947949409485,
0.6472417712211609,
-0.4022073745727539,
-0.0957191064953804,
-0.09355641156435013,
-0.07561253011226654,
0.12128974497318268,
0.5960664749145508,
-0.9287410378456116,
-0.0506240539252758,
0.5116584897041321,
0.8335707187652588,
-0.036712732166051865,
-0.1551702469587326,
-0.6817089915275574,
-0.14515839517116547,
0.009957078844308853,
0.9063873887062073,
-0.5236236453056335,
-0.45402637124061584,
0.0886966809630394,
-0.040830519050359726,
-0.13368411362171173,
-0.5380133390426636,
0.3969714343547821,
-0.4167719781398773,
0.6031521558761597,
-0.15254947543144226,
-0.6691288352012634,
-0.18289504945278168,
0.08256629854440689,
-0.5908453464508057,
0.7129195928573608,
0.4141981899738312,
-0.5053351521492004,
0.4237922728061676,
-0.8070844411849976,
-0.31840404868125916,
0.16958516836166382,
-0.17778660356998444,
-0.4812798500061035,
0.21639913320541382,
0.3706039488315582,
0.35763147473335266,
0.08609933406114578,
0.17294800281524658,
0.005522030871361494,
-0.5081759095191956,
0.276176780462265,
-0.3068722188472748,
0.09052447974681854,
-0.020708004012703896,
-0.7492849230766296,
0.605739414691925,
-0.6097882986068726,
0.3610645830631256,
-0.14122092723846436,
-0.39383623003959656,
0.03512074425816536,
-0.23785831034183502,
-0.09018334001302719,
0.06984701007604599,
-0.11903258413076401,
-0.29985594749450684,
0.45214107632637024,
-0.2984687089920044,
0.4068623483181,
0.8692806959152222,
-0.11183121800422668,
0.1296570599079132,
-0.2510595917701721,
0.8369163870811462,
-0.18012063205242157,
0.1533203274011612,
-0.31969428062438965,
-0.5747427940368652,
-0.7467840909957886,
-0.2520149052143097,
0.5762980580329895,
0.20300813019275665,
-0.8499144911766052,
0.45294010639190674,
-0.320803165435791,
-0.2642483115196228,
-0.7130823135375977,
0.05416493862867355,
0.5500316619873047,
0.5557394027709961,
0.6380082368850708,
-0.65061354637146,
-0.4271392524242401,
-0.5500776171684265,
-0.36097294092178345,
-0.1289398968219757,
-0.35155296325683594,
0.21186724305152893,
0.3107970654964447,
0.11368738114833832,
1.0424227714538574,
-0.6220558881759644,
-0.2725832462310791,
-0.3339146673679352,
0.3881628215312958,
0.23002761602401733,
0.23561571538448334,
0.08276060968637466,
-0.7501538395881653,
-0.7180647850036621,
-0.1846712976694107,
-0.39210182428359985,
-0.14778262376785278,
0.03195839002728462,
0.01104329526424408,
-0.12385626882314682,
0.2548180818557739,
-0.28473562002182007,
0.486716628074646,
0.09675171971321106,
-0.3356269299983978,
0.8353923559188843,
-0.0025492936838418245,
0.19177214801311493,
-0.6669917106628418,
0.07057499885559082,
-0.18226806819438934,
-0.1947447508573532,
-0.43825119733810425,
0.09323529899120331,
0.019723104313015938,
-0.014061487279832363,
-0.3647438883781433,
0.17401522397994995,
-0.2579496204853058,
0.07934676110744476,
-0.3328949809074402,
-0.0891723707318306,
-0.06978387385606766,
0.7670578360557556,
-0.01412713062018156,
0.8938876986503601,
0.20705941319465637,
-0.5477454662322998,
0.2960064709186554,
0.38499715924263,
-0.35613512992858887,
0.4706612229347229,
-0.7409137487411499,
0.17633549869060516,
0.0019477856112644076,
0.176003560423851,
-1.0297259092330933,
-0.5956560373306274,
0.2136276215314865,
-0.536831796169281,
0.5055460333824158,
-0.1748434156179428,
-0.5245561003684998,
-0.5824776887893677,
-0.20272497832775116,
0.27317607402801514,
0.6141313314437866,
-0.7076075077056885,
0.20620571076869965,
-0.16267453134059906,
-0.3917444944381714,
-0.25565019249916077,
-0.32149025797843933,
-0.2109811007976532,
-0.17371204495429993,
-0.2430059313774109,
0.2489476203918457,
-0.09476920962333679,
0.20066608488559723,
-0.13060764968395233,
0.016008269041776657,
0.011817905120551586,
0.0053345682099461555,
0.3033348619937897,
0.2403842806816101,
-0.14406384527683258,
0.10477756708860397,
-0.16188080608844757,
-0.3755878806114197,
-0.036165639758110046,
-0.318046897649765,
0.4604833722114563,
-0.28695470094680786,
-0.5802249908447266,
-0.4726760983467102,
0.29023274779319763,
0.4297759532928467,
-0.35709384083747864,
0.31188905239105225,
0.8312045931816101,
0.01830247789621353,
-0.156667560338974,
-0.20918336510658264,
-0.43910881876945496,
-0.41561830043792725,
0.3865750730037689,
-0.07268134504556656,
-1.103448510169983,
0.2795606255531311,
0.16959162056446075,
0.14540338516235352,
0.21800439059734344,
0.44158026576042175,
-0.08455388247966766,
1.3420201539993286,
0.5931420922279358,
0.14688561856746674,
0.5937033891677856,
-0.4939301609992981,
0.276838093996048,
-0.8834331631660461,
-0.1279100626707077,
-0.2527223527431488,
-0.27206990122795105,
-0.2749602496623993,
-0.1477845162153244,
0.40789541602134705,
0.44179320335388184,
-0.036822207272052765,
0.3710826337337494,
-0.7618051171302795,
0.49852943420410156,
0.8125017285346985,
0.3753388524055481,
0.24322164058685303,
-0.026287095621228218,
-0.07130157202482224,
-0.06859366595745087,
-0.5000044107437134,
-0.46946612000465393,
0.928840696811676,
0.40240955352783203,
0.7285546660423279,
0.2983960211277008,
0.40197011828422546,
0.1310291439294815,
0.697723925113678,
-0.9243674874305725,
0.39331793785095215,
0.000959654338657856,
-0.20946204662322998,
-0.3855306804180145,
-0.38467666506767273,
-0.7939035892486572,
0.12176323682069778,
0.19317491352558136,
-0.5821455121040344,
-0.3114936947822571,
0.3811436593532562,
-0.7769882678985596,
0.1409609019756317,
-0.8778648972511292,
0.9096790552139282,
-0.21244670450687408,
-0.5006113648414612,
0.07001133263111115,
-0.6990256309509277,
0.09111766517162323,
-0.02520912140607834,
0.04523654282093048,
0.055877409875392914,
0.3346456289291382,
0.5764220952987671,
-0.7351230978965759,
1.064084768295288,
-0.35123518109321594,
-0.1765148639678955,
0.37086519598960876,
-0.3527759313583374,
0.33543160557746887,
-0.13818255066871643,
0.1287403106689453,
-0.3634677231311798,
-0.28549015522003174,
-0.40456631779670715,
-0.9042262434959412,
0.24146966636180878,
-0.6828054785728455,
-0.6679490208625793,
0.06458982825279236,
-0.423513799905777,
-0.3103090226650238,
-0.017706695944070816,
0.6051679849624634,
0.6093612313270569,
0.17518620193004608,
-0.2154022753238678,
0.5396764278411865,
-0.19631005823612213,
0.3862555921077728,
0.5516259074211121,
-0.2824338972568512,
-0.4219726622104645,
1.1581941843032837,
0.19468708336353302,
0.33824071288108826,
0.31046053767204285,
0.16967906057834625,
-0.5263326168060303,
-0.47072598338127136,
-0.7171302437782288,
0.0069105979055166245,
-0.7543957829475403,
-0.3267780840396881,
-0.3704596757888794,
0.023321576416492462,
-0.4487311840057373,
0.058609023690223694,
-0.049169912934303284,
-0.4763813614845276,
-0.356874942779541,
-0.18999479711055756,
0.2893534302711487,
1.0271930694580078,
0.015632618218660355,
0.5713083744049072,
-0.7632290720939636,
0.051064908504486084,
0.5218074917793274,
0.73655104637146,
0.26217153668403625,
-0.6634188890457153,
-0.47374847531318665,
0.07894252985715866,
-0.6470404267311096,
-0.8718722462654114,
0.4269118010997772,
0.29000124335289,
0.24350537359714508,
0.34393325448036194,
-0.10315226763486862,
0.7288026213645935,
-0.41766515374183655,
0.9048085808753967,
0.08724743127822876,
-0.8362882733345032,
0.7932712435722351,
-0.2611168920993805,
0.3360172510147095,
0.40684187412261963,
0.36067113280296326,
-0.30126187205314636,
-0.5128176808357239,
-0.3886038661003113,
-1.0408269166946411,
0.6567105054855347,
0.059221141040325165,
-0.2171466201543808,
-0.039240479469299316,
0.36288416385650635,
0.4386242926120758,
0.3732648491859436,
-0.5978115797042847,
-0.18620774149894714,
-0.4930594861507416,
-0.17229291796684265,
-0.08211439847946167,
-0.011381970718502998,
-0.07261965423822403,
-0.28104889392852783,
0.7148046493530273,
-0.44829419255256653,
0.5103641152381897,
0.2172926664352417,
-0.14328300952911377,
-0.0629667118191719,
0.5770128965377808,
0.6135056614875793,
0.5754643082618713,
-0.15431521832942963,
0.045193951576948166,
-0.2026563584804535,
-0.3557034730911255,
0.19514122605323792,
0.2742782533168793,
-0.1139964684844017,
0.2584538459777832,
0.37199848890304565,
0.7658806443214417,
0.12293767929077148,
-0.3585719168186188,
0.6540111303329468,
-0.2351350039243698,
0.10896261036396027,
-0.03499782830476761,
0.20783434808254242,
-0.3039083182811737,
-0.034605156630277634,
0.29606106877326965,
-0.06425503641366959,
0.10078015178442001,
-0.3262867331504822,
0.24370580911636353,
0.20062300562858582,
-0.6222559809684753,
-0.5031676888465881,
0.6762028336524963,
0.28964704275131226,
-0.20983006060123444,
0.5345733761787415,
-0.3568180203437805,
-0.7638172507286072,
0.5747798681259155,
0.430522620677948,
0.9319530129432678,
-0.18028278648853302,
0.37215715646743774,
0.48233741521835327,
-0.21488820016384125,
-0.0859578475356102,
0.20630790293216705,
-0.26448768377304077,
-0.18748216331005096,
-0.7887114882469177,
-0.5273047089576721,
-0.686295211315155,
0.04013264179229736,
-1.1831951141357422,
0.27330780029296875,
-0.329892098903656,
-0.2601795792579651,
0.058889999985694885,
-0.31426236033439636,
-0.7862465381622314,
0.08521921187639236,
-0.12263131141662598,
0.6899781227111816,
-0.6735111474990845,
0.5903332829475403,
0.8148411512374878,
-0.9943966865539551,
-1.2598652839660645,
0.004680371843278408,
-0.0752638503909111,
-0.6574839949607849,
0.5637310743331909,
0.584128201007843,
0.26939889788627625,
0.25334158539772034,
-0.5324058532714844,
-0.6130435466766357,
0.772757887840271,
0.16177478432655334,
-0.530121922492981,
-0.15010711550712585,
0.3340313136577606,
0.778846025466919,
-0.20137980580329895,
0.8099892735481262,
0.41713714599609375,
0.3492491543292999,
-0.009938250295817852,
-1.0587013959884644,
-0.022293394431471825,
-0.3705707788467407,
-0.077806256711483,
0.19545729458332062,
-0.5756481885910034,
0.5700788497924805,
-0.4355708956718445,
-0.32896101474761963,
0.42660394310951233,
0.6252418756484985,
-0.1066727489233017,
0.14455430209636688,
0.3576817512512207,
0.5740410089492798,
0.667878270149231,
-0.3880414068698883,
1.1221462488174438,
-0.04559559002518654,
0.47050437331199646,
1.280336618423462,
0.23409897089004517,
0.7614551782608032,
0.33636927604675293,
-0.387626975774765,
0.4451531767845154,
0.7586416602134705,
-0.19610175490379333,
0.6402938961982727,
0.4657031297683716,
-0.29200419783592224,
-0.01743038184940815,
-0.20164845883846283,
-0.5964317321777344,
-0.04447910934686661,
0.19751441478729248,
-0.3727201819419861,
-0.09716131538152695,
0.3629615604877472,
-0.43816837668418884,
-0.10991142690181732,
-0.33611544966697693,
0.9050365686416626,
-0.06796828657388687,
-1.0885974168777466,
0.6354026794433594,
-0.3558851182460785,
0.6790100336074829,
-0.41416147351264954,
-0.3545936346054077,
-0.15301552414894104,
0.28351497650146484,
-0.48377981781959534,
-0.7939404845237732,
0.10558456182479858,
0.15526491403579712,
-0.4573792815208435,
-0.23719419538974762,
-0.013819963671267033,
-0.7394764423370361,
-0.14427371323108673,
0.06614779680967331,
0.3515860140323639,
0.1639585793018341,
-0.1428181380033493,
-0.3953232169151306,
-0.2294340282678604,
0.27547702193260193,
-0.07617694139480591,
0.22030100226402283,
0.16610729694366455,
0.10213115066289902,
0.3530208468437195,
0.6204579472541809,
-0.08941872417926788,
0.028526155278086662,
0.5550519227981567,
0.8384208679199219,
-0.6507133841514587,
-0.44045543670654297,
-0.638932466506958,
0.7007473707199097,
0.16110406816005707,
-0.4309708774089813,
0.8144564032554626,
0.43619048595428467,
1.1167486906051636,
-0.36558085680007935,
0.9642224311828613,
0.00927038211375475,
0.913115918636322,
-0.4341634213924408,
0.23914922773838043,
-0.22103062272071838,
0.44088536500930786,
-0.37050843238830566,
-0.8635513186454773,
-0.3742308020591736,
0.552316427230835,
-0.38309016823768616,
0.07207547128200531,
0.6241042017936707,
0.554025411605835,
0.1015099361538887,
0.45183539390563965,
0.0984513908624649,
0.08991717547178268,
0.6110644340515137,
0.6001875400543213,
1.2882664203643799,
-0.2611466348171234,
0.5579246282577515,
-0.27534282207489014,
-0.3979324698448181,
-0.2640073001384735,
-0.6308329105377197,
-0.7375357747077942,
-0.25739750266075134,
-0.5283298492431641,
-0.4284648895263672,
0.12185799330472946,
0.8583672642707825,
0.5894460082054138,
-1.082258701324463,
0.0465395413339138,
-0.2003939151763916,
-0.07057590037584305,
-0.3367170989513397,
-0.3002396821975708,
0.5649690628051758,
-0.6110642552375793,
-0.6710530519485474,
0.18198895454406738,
0.03631178289651871,
0.2868550419807434,
-0.08086045831441879,
-0.061412956565618515,
0.4272790253162384,
-0.5875988006591797,
0.6558583974838257,
0.29463037848472595,
-0.8906583189964294,
-0.4386588931083679,
0.14455577731132507,
0.036985207349061966,
0.15773215889930725,
0.8519855737686157,
-0.6780185699462891,
0.5245488286018372,
0.22477248311042786,
0.5883203148841858,
0.17285555601119995,
0.258749783039093,
0.7673331499099731,
-0.8566401600837708,
-0.3329886496067047,
0.3048733174800873,
0.3076099455356598,
0.46619611978530884,
-0.2442142516374588,
0.6933203339576721,
0.10638361424207687,
-0.6239692568778992,
-0.48714011907577515,
0.0724836140871048,
-0.6640917658805847,
-0.09284830093383789,
1.0009297132492065,
-0.5831867456436157,
0.21845006942749023,
-0.09098450839519501,
-0.5231803059577942,
0.4089500904083252,
-0.4018668234348297,
0.969151496887207,
0.7509042024612427,
-0.5212379097938538,
0.0406758077442646,
-0.44055911898612976,
0.547990083694458,
0.8322040438652039,
-0.7912489175796509,
0.0008040734101086855,
0.44754061102867126,
-0.11270532757043839,
0.37427058815956116,
0.2999446392059326,
-0.15767717361450195,
0.5020058751106262,
-0.4120940864086151,
-0.1735488325357437,
-0.1051725372672081,
-0.3802024722099304,
-0.5681020617485046,
0.23621368408203125,
0.15929603576660156,
-0.27909886837005615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00289v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00289v2
|
Adversarial Attacks and Defense for Conversation Entailment Task
| 2024-05-01T02:49:18 | 2024-05-02T03:37:08 |
Zhenning Yang, Ryan Krawec, Liang-Yuan Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As the deployment of NLP systems in critical applications grows, ensuring the
robustness of large language models (LLMs) against adversarial attacks becomes
increasingly important. Large language models excel in various NLP tasks but
remain vulnerable to low-cost adversarial attacks. Focusing on the domain of
conversation entailment, where multi-turn dialogues serve as premises to verify
hypotheses, we fine-tune a transformer model to accurately discern the
truthfulness of these hypotheses. Adversaries manipulate hypotheses through
synonym swapping, aiming to deceive the model into making incorrect
predictions. To counteract these attacks, we implemented innovative fine-tuning
techniques and introduced an embedding perturbation loss method to
significantly bolster the model's robustness. Our findings not only emphasize
the importance of defending against adversarial attacks in NLP but also
highlight the real-world implications, suggesting that enhancing model
robustness is critical for reliable NLP applications.
|
[
-0.36160507798194885,
-1.3565367460250854,
0.27894753217697144,
0.030371930450201035,
0.025331921875476837,
0.08461747318506241,
-0.09009572863578796,
-0.29005685448646545,
-0.021452872082591057,
0.9806094765663147,
-0.5199247598648071,
-0.1765063852071762,
-0.926872730255127,
-0.1105113998055458,
-0.8056992888450623,
0.8156160116195679,
0.1441110074520111,
-0.07683494687080383,
-0.2146749347448349,
-0.13215908408164978,
-0.3322463929653168,
-0.6277555227279663,
-0.7559571266174316,
-0.46269556879997253,
0.34192532300949097,
0.04169350489974022,
1.182305097579956,
0.3912062644958496,
0.6668951511383057,
0.30405348539352417,
-0.29002076387405396,
0.19302505254745483,
-0.5912211537361145,
0.6371906399726868,
0.009668296203017235,
-0.9606086015701294,
-0.39194974303245544,
-0.06139786168932915,
0.3046519160270691,
0.5428130626678467,
-0.26365435123443604,
-0.17605872452259064,
0.11340314894914627,
0.5017129778862,
-0.5848023891448975,
-0.15247300267219543,
-1.2956585884094238,
0.08543429523706436,
-0.2541090250015259,
-0.21966297924518585,
-0.7011299729347229,
0.01868268847465515,
0.17791959643363953,
-0.37435364723205566,
0.2583273947238922,
0.10324833542108536,
1.0716432332992554,
0.5896692872047424,
-0.1434716135263443,
-0.2350524514913559,
-0.6617341041564941,
0.6581096053123474,
-0.9327389597892761,
0.2549956142902374,
0.27446699142456055,
0.28282809257507324,
-0.5322325229644775,
-0.5789333581924438,
-0.6542799472808838,
-0.2750343382358551,
-0.11222182214260101,
0.03723461925983429,
-0.7146952748298645,
0.24273328483104706,
0.3799312710762024,
0.32926154136657715,
-0.33069321513175964,
0.20699098706245422,
0.17326930165290833,
-0.18654227256774902,
0.4370076656341553,
0.28404614329338074,
0.4053417146205902,
0.13558343052864075,
-0.20633858442306519,
-0.2372438907623291,
-0.9845304489135742,
-0.12869641184806824,
0.7157280445098877,
0.27380186319351196,
0.010717754252254963,
0.7228283286094666,
0.008576016873121262,
0.5277929902076721,
0.22238826751708984,
0.029101485386490822,
-0.416957825422287,
-0.24323412775993347,
-0.4151156544685364,
0.027478398755192757,
0.7246904969215393,
0.19485147297382355,
0.0976690798997879,
-0.4317730963230133,
-0.03473812714219093,
0.3112110197544098,
0.6651535034179688,
-0.7718420028686523,
-0.27936577796936035,
0.2779136896133423,
-0.17342129349708557,
-0.531542956829071,
-0.12149816006422043,
-0.6849827170372009,
-0.5801072716712952,
0.02320791967213154,
0.38380903005599976,
-0.42914879322052,
0.03078298270702362,
0.3249855637550354,
-0.08740770071744919,
0.20892231166362762,
0.2830413579940796,
-0.8599065542221069,
0.3879443407058716,
0.9318505525588989,
0.6464289426803589,
-0.16196449100971222,
-0.2544948160648346,
-0.48317235708236694,
0.09529684484004974,
-0.41978687047958374,
0.5790387988090515,
-0.5634555220603943,
-0.45227736234664917,
0.14512598514556885,
0.014625467360019684,
-0.24120531976222992,
-0.5017432570457458,
0.6987826824188232,
-0.6103975176811218,
0.2386978268623352,
0.16497202217578888,
-0.5119161605834961,
-0.18826544284820557,
0.7392334938049316,
-0.5692710280418396,
0.5828102231025696,
-0.2940923571586609,
-0.9038481712341309,
-0.08103518187999725,
-0.46585434675216675,
-0.5246695876121521,
-0.2256629914045334,
-0.007426675874739885,
-0.7178206443786621,
0.11058618128299713,
0.4085560142993927,
0.4134996235370636,
-0.29454511404037476,
0.09664454311132431,
-0.2975398600101471,
-0.06292922794818878,
0.49242839217185974,
-0.8030776977539062,
0.7302461266517639,
-0.048985935747623444,
-0.26466768980026245,
0.24846875667572021,
-0.3689119219779968,
-0.18078209459781647,
0.3715783655643463,
-0.13105341792106628,
-0.23495279252529144,
0.21498975157737732,
-0.41874343156814575,
-0.1355762928724289,
0.09357684850692749,
-0.5174739956855774,
0.19466912746429443,
-0.9647672772407532,
0.5357532501220703,
0.44959452748298645,
0.053581174463033676,
0.48222652077674866,
-0.3809472620487213,
0.6063290238380432,
0.06495415419340134,
0.43285608291625977,
-0.2644438147544861,
-0.5932766795158386,
-0.9514078497886658,
-0.028775636106729507,
0.33211469650268555,
0.6249280571937561,
-0.8370373845100403,
0.381684273481369,
-0.12282144278287888,
-0.6925695538520813,
-0.765774130821228,
0.021915728226304054,
0.3253350555896759,
0.20534735918045044,
0.3394235074520111,
0.15022976696491241,
-0.4238121509552002,
-0.918716549873352,
-0.6014001965522766,
-0.02421124279499054,
-0.06360326707363129,
0.07482795417308807,
0.42985260486602783,
-0.5136629343032837,
0.6433363556861877,
-0.5627869367599487,
-0.22832296788692474,
-0.22788351774215698,
-0.011663898825645447,
0.07142338156700134,
0.338810533285141,
0.5061489343643188,
-0.8926969766616821,
-0.4404805898666382,
-0.25124648213386536,
-0.4603779911994934,
0.18218110501766205,
-0.32411980628967285,
-0.1851818710565567,
0.12240493297576904,
0.6286851763725281,
-0.793412983417511,
0.44421255588531494,
0.7008381485939026,
-0.2557941675186157,
0.33340978622436523,
-0.09641294181346893,
-0.0634084939956665,
-0.977709949016571,
-0.41873887181282043,
-0.21760614216327667,
-0.2292173206806183,
-0.8582915663719177,
0.47138845920562744,
-0.22031478583812714,
-0.09803188592195511,
-0.39338913559913635,
0.15542595088481903,
0.028565527871251106,
0.5423018932342529,
-0.32676759362220764,
0.04663743078708649,
0.23214152455329895,
0.23775096237659454,
-0.30963999032974243,
0.559033215045929,
0.7205221056938171,
-0.6021363139152527,
0.42178845405578613,
0.4629456400871277,
-0.08515483140945435,
0.532565712928772,
-0.9523785710334778,
0.22947177290916443,
0.0487820990383625,
0.30687111616134644,
-0.7119853496551514,
0.02072812058031559,
0.23269963264465332,
-0.6467364430427551,
0.5721398591995239,
-0.17921797931194305,
-0.5196211338043213,
0.038854919373989105,
-0.39242568612098694,
-0.1064901202917099,
0.22225072979927063,
-0.6019041538238525,
0.8387851119041443,
0.5234565138816833,
0.09692975133657455,
-0.6518037915229797,
-0.8644630908966064,
0.5624461770057678,
-0.3750394284725189,
-0.7895482778549194,
0.5803622603416443,
0.125776469707489,
-0.39036715030670166,
-0.23692744970321655,
0.06597655266523361,
0.11824797093868256,
0.4442065954208374,
0.271202951669693,
0.04224523901939392,
-0.15448851883411407,
-0.16044743359088898,
-0.22429130971431732,
-0.06698007881641388,
0.301250159740448,
0.058030616492033005,
0.734834611415863,
-0.10828138142824173,
-0.6695042252540588,
-0.288519948720932,
0.2635335326194763,
0.6751900315284729,
-0.05325915291905403,
0.9601804614067078,
0.5116801261901855,
-0.44153890013694763,
-0.2773803770542145,
-0.516089916229248,
-0.33533328771591187,
-0.5157400369644165,
0.5854188799858093,
-0.39119207859039307,
-0.8196517825126648,
0.6122866272926331,
0.010290401987731457,
0.13829421997070312,
0.5431315898895264,
0.390262246131897,
0.05264538899064064,
1.2537102699279785,
0.5510229468345642,
-0.18811945617198944,
0.220160573720932,
-0.2354249656200409,
0.4654625952243805,
-0.8473642468452454,
-0.14265653491020203,
-0.552580714225769,
-0.05155136063694954,
-0.7884945273399353,
-0.2599411904811859,
0.24906635284423828,
-0.06569884717464447,
-0.18314103782176971,
0.48345908522605896,
-0.39139696955680847,
0.32603180408477783,
0.41746020317077637,
0.08055685460567474,
0.14560462534427643,
-0.18213829398155212,
0.2503405511379242,
-0.1661888062953949,
-0.6650266051292419,
-0.5485899448394775,
0.9300439357757568,
0.674832284450531,
1.0661650896072388,
0.45597609877586365,
0.3516237437725067,
0.1434207558631897,
0.019390171393752098,
-0.9533302783966064,
0.5675439834594727,
-0.32446521520614624,
-0.4330012798309326,
-0.36841243505477905,
-0.325914591550827,
-1.0619964599609375,
0.38281187415122986,
-0.44660645723342896,
-0.5007283091545105,
-0.07782681286334991,
0.0668673887848854,
-0.1568383425474167,
0.582389235496521,
-0.35815128684043884,
0.8310781717300415,
-0.18887798488140106,
-0.10301536321640015,
-0.2651931643486023,
-0.35085389018058777,
0.30554571747779846,
-0.05355527997016907,
-0.10014941543340683,
0.04030497744679451,
0.1269766241312027,
0.4971628785133362,
-0.25917160511016846,
1.0188218355178833,
0.07770616561174393,
-0.34800660610198975,
0.06407153606414795,
0.42803847789764404,
0.7315609455108643,
0.050921954214572906,
0.0748492181301117,
0.19788631796836853,
-0.09328631311655045,
-0.1486576795578003,
-0.688626229763031,
0.6728937029838562,
-0.5570288896560669,
-1.1012870073318481,
-0.19347451627254486,
-0.41454896330833435,
-0.23058141767978668,
-0.09836073964834213,
0.4325532019138336,
0.30127331614494324,
-0.32012739777565,
0.5622631311416626,
1.0331820249557495,
-0.3709854185581207,
0.21955054998397827,
0.38312268257141113,
0.15021438896656036,
-0.12789878249168396,
0.7256249785423279,
-0.17143313586711884,
0.5697187185287476,
0.5085234045982361,
0.28109854459762573,
-0.1460384726524353,
-0.6645558476448059,
-0.4216928780078888,
-0.06336095929145813,
-0.6322352290153503,
-0.4283539056777954,
-0.6848718523979187,
-0.24561084806919098,
-0.5157429575920105,
-0.040621738880872726,
-0.5843125581741333,
-0.28742799162864685,
-0.0848129615187645,
0.115040123462677,
0.20359967648983002,
0.5599284768104553,
0.5820751786231995,
0.46792712807655334,
-0.570533275604248,
0.28182876110076904,
0.4000732898712158,
-0.01934504695236683,
-0.11604969948530197,
-0.9483581781387329,
-0.09965167194604874,
0.41012781858444214,
-0.7699533700942993,
-0.8390210270881653,
0.5107360482215881,
0.35973677039146423,
0.5189969539642334,
0.3837411403656006,
0.18177562952041626,
0.47028741240501404,
-0.5905622243881226,
0.8767815828323364,
0.13624848425388336,
-0.8823366761207581,
0.6361375451087952,
-0.2845456004142761,
0.3363267481327057,
0.23818382620811462,
0.18420128524303436,
-0.4796093702316284,
-0.7502871155738831,
-0.8813031911849976,
-0.8777666687965393,
0.4457070231437683,
0.2810569703578949,
0.4272344708442688,
0.08435439318418503,
0.12204796075820923,
-0.15226471424102783,
0.13133321702480316,
-0.6592060923576355,
-0.4295588433742523,
-0.3125411868095398,
-0.05238991975784302,
0.07141664624214172,
-0.2273198515176773,
-0.5362944602966309,
-0.02676280215382576,
0.8051002025604248,
-0.15425321459770203,
0.22243767976760864,
0.03632262721657753,
-0.0710100531578064,
0.06803871691226959,
0.41364747285842896,
0.5468987822532654,
0.16121739149093628,
0.17147475481033325,
0.26251620054244995,
0.4178179204463959,
-0.3352234363555908,
-0.044281333684921265,
0.07071606069803238,
-0.33311912417411804,
-0.062101610004901886,
0.471472829580307,
0.9219006896018982,
0.16919104754924774,
-0.46956923604011536,
0.6331146359443665,
-0.2283257097005844,
-0.19444043934345245,
-0.31618282198905945,
0.1658053696155548,
0.08371860533952713,
0.1032685860991478,
0.16345657408237457,
0.30683788657188416,
0.10903371125459671,
-0.5290595293045044,
-0.0711364671587944,
0.8536478877067566,
-0.39252424240112305,
-0.15967358648777008,
0.6382505297660828,
-0.09289495646953583,
-0.46191275119781494,
0.35426485538482666,
0.059838976711034775,
-0.9195055961608887,
0.6730139255523682,
0.5990621447563171,
0.876733124256134,
-0.3272377848625183,
-0.02992679551243782,
0.015031998045742512,
0.6640548706054688,
-0.24195246398448944,
-0.34064480662345886,
0.40131810307502747,
-0.9945741295814514,
-0.3325311839580536,
-0.4106767177581787,
-0.8169004321098328,
0.2775459587574005,
-0.6129670143127441,
0.15093137323856354,
-0.3091415762901306,
-0.2142006903886795,
0.20123764872550964,
-0.39194294810295105,
-0.39324870705604553,
0.08624722063541412,
0.11514457315206528,
0.6296811103820801,
-0.4670659005641937,
0.6861562132835388,
0.41044408082962036,
-0.06071612238883972,
-0.30221089720726013,
0.20089034736156464,
-0.11699140071868896,
-0.5605573654174805,
0.5276946425437927,
0.017258156090974808,
-0.37305131554603577,
-0.4354173243045807,
-0.6859317421913147,
-0.6061457395553589,
0.6115375757217407,
0.6422826051712036,
-0.3870663642883301,
0.05460349842905998,
0.3205011487007141,
0.47676321864128113,
-0.23302608728408813,
0.09737501293420792,
0.5728942155838013,
0.28894877433776855,
-0.022091882303357124,
-0.864726185798645,
0.08849705010652542,
0.014796596020460129,
-0.12223265320062637,
0.2678644061088562,
-0.49801671504974365,
0.7175993323326111,
-0.13931193947792053,
-0.32702094316482544,
-0.17034780979156494,
0.6481204032897949,
-0.18083813786506653,
0.024648992344737053,
0.5328598022460938,
0.6227683424949646,
0.5210687518119812,
-0.354020357131958,
1.0197919607162476,
-0.2649269104003906,
0.051721248775720596,
1.038846492767334,
-0.08078224956989288,
0.9062995314598083,
0.3401104807853699,
-0.2799414098262787,
0.2131384313106537,
0.17605681717395782,
-0.08514402061700821,
0.31245118379592896,
0.32494404911994934,
-0.07044487446546555,
-0.18441176414489746,
0.12519250810146332,
-0.1813291758298874,
0.8037092089653015,
0.7066869139671326,
-0.10175216943025589,
-0.003741584485396743,
0.02459416165947914,
0.275690495967865,
0.3964080810546875,
-0.07339774817228317,
0.9180076718330383,
0.031224645674228668,
-0.7340359687805176,
0.7198675274848938,
0.20749850571155548,
1.0734691619873047,
-0.6917105317115784,
0.15535540878772736,
0.09134411066770554,
0.5014805793762207,
-0.16046547889709473,
-0.5315353870391846,
0.591838538646698,
-0.2487930953502655,
-0.006706568878144026,
-0.1365320235490799,
0.6513846516609192,
-0.5120019316673279,
-0.2538735568523407,
0.31119003891944885,
0.18855296075344086,
-0.3569013774394989,
-0.29775023460388184,
-0.8205825686454773,
-0.024579785764217377,
-0.006580556742846966,
-0.24625489115715027,
0.4276285767555237,
0.14815683662891388,
0.3067173957824707,
0.9915021657943726,
0.5355567336082458,
0.24722543358802795,
-0.07515499740839005,
0.23939906060695648,
0.8595578074455261,
-0.31326591968536377,
-0.25393903255462646,
-1.2550766468048096,
0.039351675659418106,
-0.22731582820415497,
-0.10279084742069244,
1.0939242839813232,
0.4128875434398651,
0.6530956625938416,
0.09591035544872284,
0.6144484281539917,
0.355305552482605,
0.4830244183540344,
-0.5481746792793274,
0.7873069643974304,
-0.2154785543680191,
0.4151122570037842,
-0.05780654028058052,
-0.5439062118530273,
-0.3434821665287018,
0.41180115938186646,
-0.18136709928512573,
-0.35345450043678284,
0.6009899973869324,
0.9587917923927307,
0.11106115579605103,
0.28075656294822693,
0.44847115874290466,
0.3036172688007355,
0.7346525192260742,
0.34995758533477783,
0.8484997153282166,
-0.7567667961120605,
0.721498966217041,
-0.13710781931877136,
0.11617834866046906,
-0.07860581576824188,
-0.8597841858863831,
-1.1396055221557617,
-0.33019551634788513,
-0.5460416078567505,
-0.657760739326477,
0.11762826144695282,
0.4619746804237366,
0.5103085041046143,
-0.9460349082946777,
-0.024436229839920998,
-0.027323132380843163,
0.07279929518699646,
-0.13018792867660522,
-0.24212254583835602,
0.244455948472023,
-0.35976603627204895,
-0.7148138284683228,
0.6882490515708923,
0.09983614832162857,
0.16112327575683594,
-0.5441743731498718,
0.054838187992572784,
-0.11581616848707199,
0.4408215582370758,
0.44475483894348145,
0.012587955221533775,
-0.9737223386764526,
-0.25403204560279846,
-0.03900009021162987,
-0.1350945085287094,
-0.09546813368797302,
0.7160555720329285,
-0.3728126883506775,
0.47351735830307007,
0.2625367343425751,
0.9720754623413086,
0.18412800133228302,
-0.14645947515964508,
0.766961395740509,
-0.7763117551803589,
0.1970001757144928,
0.3337841033935547,
0.49484768509864807,
0.5400770306587219,
-0.5548047423362732,
0.3474579453468323,
-0.060850631445646286,
-0.5171374678611755,
-0.9542981386184692,
0.49261075258255005,
-0.6488826274871826,
-0.3454899489879608,
1.133256196975708,
-0.26981404423713684,
-0.1494062840938568,
-0.14646171033382416,
-0.23383016884326935,
0.1322851926088333,
-0.10748154670000076,
0.8615273237228394,
0.7482525110244751,
0.17342610657215118,
0.031140891835093498,
-0.48642200231552124,
0.7753502130508423,
0.4616009593009949,
-0.7439625263214111,
0.2645331025123596,
-0.01143336109817028,
-0.099476657807827,
0.39104828238487244,
-0.0948982760310173,
-0.07957965135574341,
-0.102742500603199,
0.1103183850646019,
-0.32846635580062866,
-0.09359271079301834,
-0.06693414598703384,
-0.28377917408943176,
0.23996172845363617,
0.014910501427948475,
-0.28018635511398315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00273v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00273v1
|
Social Life Simulation for Non-Cognitive Skills Learning
| 2024-05-01T01:45:50 | 2024-05-01T01:45:50 |
Zihan Yan, Yaohong Xiang, Yun Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Non-cognitive skills are crucial for personal and social life well-being, and
such skill development can be supported by narrative-based (e.g., storytelling)
technologies. While generative AI enables interactive and role-playing
storytelling, little is known about how users engage with and perceive the use
of AI in social life simulation for non-cognitive skills learning. To this end,
we introduced SimuLife++, an interactive platform enabled by a large language
model (LLM). The system allows users to act as protagonists, creating stories
with one or multiple AI-based characters in diverse social scenarios. In
particular, we expanded the Human-AI interaction to a Human-AI-AI collaboration
by including a sage agent, who acts as a bystander to provide users with more
insightful perspectives on their choices and conversations. Through a
within-subject user study, we found that the inclusion of the sage agent
significantly enhanced narrative immersion, according to the narrative
transportation scale, leading to more messages, particularly in group chats.
Participants' interactions with the sage agent were also associated with
significantly higher scores in their perceived motivation, self-perceptions,
and resilience and coping, indicating positive impacts on non-cognitive skills
reflection. Participants' interview results further explained the sage agent's
aid in decision-making, solving ethical dilemmas, and problem-solving; on the
other hand, they suggested improvements in user control and balanced responses
from multiple characters. We provide design implications on the application of
generative AI in narrative solutions for non-cognitive skill development in
broader social contexts.
|
[
-0.2738296687602997,
-0.8862507939338684,
0.5905117392539978,
0.3455606997013092,
-0.052237555384635925,
0.4126344621181488,
-0.12666676938533783,
-0.6333297491073608,
0.7063344120979309,
0.08144156634807587,
-0.637753427028656,
-0.35889366269111633,
-0.3032403588294983,
-0.15163898468017578,
-0.015905054286122322,
0.9837618470191956,
0.28724128007888794,
0.2675398290157318,
-0.5002685785293579,
-0.057317353785037994,
-0.6678690314292908,
-0.4818283021450043,
-1.0776753425598145,
-0.7063230276107788,
0.7858878374099731,
0.51289302110672,
0.9225264191627502,
0.13377222418785095,
-0.08370047062635422,
0.2780536115169525,
0.20100758969783783,
0.2589081823825836,
-0.6313543319702148,
0.05574214830994606,
-0.14353811740875244,
-0.6152176856994629,
-0.47880318760871887,
-0.003998621832579374,
0.45709890127182007,
0.5855463147163391,
-0.22378304600715637,
0.20477424561977386,
0.18432210385799408,
0.3575737178325653,
-0.391844779253006,
0.4339669346809387,
0.04743620753288269,
0.14889265596866608,
0.03288228437304497,
-0.08616137504577637,
-0.27478933334350586,
-0.2770406901836395,
-0.05033253878355026,
-1.2792086601257324,
0.057205598801374435,
0.07623879611492157,
0.5589691400527954,
0.31171566247940063,
-0.35636743903160095,
-0.1870856136083603,
-0.7773841619491577,
0.789657473564148,
-0.3413439691066742,
0.037419725209474564,
0.41971731185913086,
0.3716350197792053,
-0.31085383892059326,
-0.21773600578308105,
-0.5980823636054993,
-0.43399712443351746,
0.020710652694106102,
0.43500661849975586,
0.26814597845077515,
0.12175004929304123,
0.30318745970726013,
-0.10000555217266083,
-0.481563001871109,
0.10695755481719971,
-0.3193187117576599,
-0.2596657872200012,
1.0316139459609985,
0.525321364402771,
0.4389323890209198,
-0.06856457144021988,
-0.15606500208377838,
-0.3682782053947449,
-0.43369829654693604,
0.399178147315979,
0.3725280165672302,
0.14614741504192352,
-0.3743874430656433,
0.5975334644317627,
-0.08741946518421173,
0.10923951864242554,
-0.2715986669063568,
-0.5160315036773682,
0.3414129316806793,
0.13634967803955078,
0.09025127440690994,
0.27444833517074585,
0.5334622263908386,
0.5884373784065247,
0.7303426861763,
-0.23592205345630646,
0.09342581033706665,
0.28798195719718933,
0.40751251578330994,
-0.6373502016067505,
0.1640145629644394,
-0.04263685271143913,
-0.48518386483192444,
-0.310183048248291,
-0.12838278710842133,
-1.0171486139297485,
-0.8301566243171692,
-0.25982362031936646,
0.23263399302959442,
-0.6734481453895569,
-0.35075274109840393,
0.021676652133464813,
-0.4237212538719177,
0.5264121890068054,
0.5983378291130066,
-0.630760669708252,
0.34724146127700806,
0.5020369291305542,
0.7962140440940857,
-0.015805013477802277,
-0.6639431715011597,
-0.5875780582427979,
0.29722702503204346,
-0.28556859493255615,
0.8080649375915527,
-0.8182258605957031,
-0.8379167318344116,
-0.08624579757452011,
-0.24450179934501648,
-0.11160562932491302,
-0.2929779887199402,
0.4451224207878113,
-0.304531067609787,
-0.20375652611255646,
-0.4082965850830078,
-0.39934101700782776,
-0.12829014658927917,
0.2903158664703369,
-0.5421510338783264,
0.8082209825515747,
0.1293749213218689,
-0.3661193251609802,
0.28994321823120117,
-1.0792783498764038,
-0.7759315967559814,
0.5347623229026794,
-0.3368002474308014,
-0.16987518966197968,
0.06004512682557106,
-0.014121419750154018,
0.1736016422510147,
-0.30030137300491333,
0.31656011939048767,
-0.3939932584762573,
-0.6909762024879456,
0.4124583899974823,
-0.564669668674469,
0.6406171917915344,
0.056369438767433167,
-0.3197139501571655,
0.025409987196326256,
-0.3958735167980194,
0.016741782426834106,
0.3515804409980774,
-0.12855051457881927,
-0.07984570413827896,
-0.02462810091674328,
0.09035495668649673,
0.01915009319782257,
-0.005561946891248226,
-0.5198113918304443,
-0.014997891150414944,
0.012267529964447021,
0.1876181662082672,
0.4534113109111786,
0.31685250997543335,
0.3129352629184723,
-1.037474513053894,
0.9073414206504822,
-0.1643664538860321,
0.2564266324043274,
-0.16299787163734436,
-0.8136641979217529,
-0.7276672720909119,
-0.16721373796463013,
-0.026992492377758026,
0.7559561133384705,
-1.3041470050811768,
-0.036782119423151016,
-0.16692659258842468,
-0.6472165584564209,
-0.5260044932365417,
0.015320373699069023,
0.4867469072341919,
0.3375406861305237,
0.3249380588531494,
-0.20927777886390686,
-0.0947965458035469,
-0.3795457184314728,
-0.42173221707344055,
-0.6117375493049622,
0.06685803830623627,
0.5355890393257141,
0.393650084733963,
-0.3139077425003052,
0.9319038987159729,
-0.41490063071250916,
-0.4069875478744507,
-0.5444512367248535,
0.49632716178894043,
-0.47133493423461914,
0.3897581994533539,
0.5188657641410828,
-0.7755903005599976,
-0.4397982656955719,
-0.0741846039891243,
-1.115736722946167,
0.025300875306129456,
-0.5649348497390747,
-0.01774050109088421,
0.11640012264251709,
0.19897447526454926,
-0.7540313005447388,
0.8132506608963013,
0.08826053142547607,
-0.20537042617797852,
0.4350508153438568,
-0.5269559025764465,
0.3046891987323761,
-0.8285487294197083,
-0.03518133610486984,
0.14008447527885437,
-0.19302645325660706,
-0.6926517486572266,
-0.1870691478252411,
-0.1764267385005951,
-0.3656427264213562,
-0.5959100127220154,
0.80073481798172,
-0.3050507605075836,
-0.26730963587760925,
-0.1630551815032959,
0.16932788491249084,
-0.045894887298345566,
0.5776153802871704,
0.1713200956583023,
1.1666653156280518,
0.45447608828544617,
-0.4653344750404358,
0.23681731522083282,
0.30761271715164185,
-0.2439855933189392,
0.704876720905304,
-0.5930162072181702,
0.1345684826374054,
-0.4739988446235657,
0.27281659841537476,
-0.6004968881607056,
-0.25673365592956543,
0.1588996946811676,
-0.6170501708984375,
-0.09450153261423111,
0.3240513801574707,
-0.772487223148346,
0.08740410208702087,
-0.4050999581813812,
0.13373534381389618,
0.6187034249305725,
-0.08972367644309998,
0.9434532523155212,
0.5706409811973572,
-0.17539000511169434,
-0.10505156219005585,
-0.8286433219909668,
0.26298773288726807,
-0.29009222984313965,
-0.6844162344932556,
0.2272818386554718,
-0.24403780698776245,
-0.4252682328224182,
-0.08897416293621063,
0.47291621565818787,
0.11518939584493637,
0.3000505864620209,
0.4520920217037201,
0.3522435128688812,
-0.03313262388110161,
0.16630680859088898,
0.4190898537635803,
-0.4465247094631195,
-0.03797944262623787,
0.22087670862674713,
0.33333051204681396,
-0.18166545033454895,
-0.46173733472824097,
-0.41189926862716675,
0.38463014364242554,
0.5957515835762024,
-0.17981426417827606,
1.0392664670944214,
0.3368545174598694,
-0.23129762709140778,
0.09820397198200226,
-0.4823934733867645,
-0.10895400494337082,
-0.4149118661880493,
-0.07460967451334,
0.0446774959564209,
-0.9824074506759644,
0.6318732500076294,
-0.22416166961193085,
-0.09996651113033295,
-0.006432417780160904,
0.3333298861980438,
-0.3946584463119507,
0.6225584149360657,
0.519400417804718,
-0.0348118394613266,
0.6260175108909607,
-0.02560320682823658,
0.10624267160892487,
-0.7395305037498474,
-0.3757823705673218,
0.20526327192783356,
-0.5219632983207703,
-0.23971867561340332,
-0.6304242014884949,
0.5640517473220825,
-0.2479005753993988,
-0.15558426082134247,
-0.11487021297216415,
-0.13059860467910767,
0.51117342710495,
0.4456213712692261,
0.043180547654628754,
0.44620010256767273,
-0.23192161321640015,
-0.004668895620852709,
-0.051316387951374054,
-0.5416924953460693,
-0.677143931388855,
0.7494386434555054,
0.1929783821105957,
0.8077040910720825,
-0.01198006235063076,
0.8607602119445801,
0.6865647435188293,
0.67316073179245,
-0.6090987324714661,
0.7911814451217651,
0.26170292496681213,
-0.718730092048645,
-0.4758788049221039,
-0.379075825214386,
-0.7986354231834412,
0.029887979850172997,
-0.472744345664978,
-0.6699713468551636,
0.1454520970582962,
-0.1397828608751297,
-0.8001916408538818,
0.0232450719922781,
-1.03551185131073,
0.6617974638938904,
-0.47265157103538513,
-0.5140694975852966,
-0.3591175377368927,
-0.8275399804115295,
-0.13601145148277283,
-0.07179951667785645,
0.3690457344055176,
-0.11048939824104309,
0.005075337830930948,
0.22043679654598236,
-0.015734568238258362,
1.3328142166137695,
-0.2701582610607147,
0.23305705189704895,
0.6152026653289795,
0.16923072934150696,
0.2974812686443329,
0.3487543761730194,
-0.301923930644989,
0.25682443380355835,
-0.08323700726032257,
-0.29086393117904663,
-0.610173225402832,
0.6334894895553589,
-1.1639535427093506,
-0.6765321493148804,
-0.4857889711856842,
-0.5264219045639038,
-0.13121028244495392,
-0.009896382689476013,
-0.0913136824965477,
-0.009977049194276333,
-0.713352620601654,
0.11708483844995499,
0.5703513026237488,
-0.4485092759132385,
0.45805785059928894,
0.6416881084442139,
-0.1656865030527115,
-0.4113618731498718,
1.0607070922851562,
0.4586663544178009,
0.25307682156562805,
0.08472587168216705,
0.05525188893079758,
0.025303205475211143,
0.030663030222058296,
-0.42708417773246765,
0.3007679879665375,
-0.5365301966667175,
-0.08408008515834808,
-0.7130691409111023,
-0.4042019844055176,
-0.21208836138248444,
-0.48844408988952637,
-0.011644049547612667,
-0.2158323973417282,
-0.4663052558898926,
-0.3876933157444,
0.4443270266056061,
0.6132020354270935,
-0.2126706838607788,
0.46333155035972595,
-0.7549850940704346,
0.2871004641056061,
0.34521210193634033,
0.0829572007060051,
0.324453204870224,
0.008867332711815834,
-0.23204950988292694,
0.22407729923725128,
-0.47216367721557617,
-0.734846293926239,
0.24870942533016205,
0.16102825105190277,
0.6184204816818237,
0.3854728043079376,
0.23824939131736755,
0.872253954410553,
-0.38921186327934265,
0.9240910410881042,
-0.052665386348962784,
-0.732345700263977,
0.2478906363248825,
-0.46721288561820984,
0.12055797874927521,
0.7895823121070862,
0.1602996289730072,
-0.8168455362319946,
-0.3606012165546417,
-0.5929809808731079,
-0.41465574502944946,
0.8009960651397705,
0.5369476675987244,
0.5072000026702881,
-0.1006060540676117,
0.6563320755958557,
0.09981998056173325,
0.23673297464847565,
-0.7282236814498901,
-0.35915499925613403,
-0.43989455699920654,
0.04753691330552101,
-0.24810966849327087,
-0.2618221044540405,
0.06331536918878555,
-0.20857544243335724,
0.6790067553520203,
-0.21993407607078552,
0.41965290904045105,
0.07417197525501251,
0.11612125486135483,
-0.26403042674064636,
0.05432537943124771,
0.49670082330703735,
0.31554678082466125,
0.25841236114501953,
-0.187774658203125,
0.5788241028785706,
-0.375427782535553,
0.10582412779331207,
0.04896503686904907,
0.03503590077161789,
-0.5105062127113342,
0.44728153944015503,
0.5507726073265076,
0.2893048822879791,
-0.9583103060722351,
0.4922617971897125,
-0.39535555243492126,
-0.2557833194732666,
-0.6318232417106628,
0.588459312915802,
0.3965453505516052,
0.6646460294723511,
0.25564852356910706,
-0.13849984109401703,
0.1237415224313736,
-0.5825088024139404,
0.07445504516363144,
0.3242809772491455,
-0.3396494388580322,
-0.16230954229831696,
0.5829720497131348,
0.3102710545063019,
-0.8439899682998657,
0.6211029887199402,
-0.49279534816741943,
-0.20733517408370972,
0.8381661176681519,
0.4582037627696991,
0.795145571231842,
-0.1021038293838501,
0.8629074692726135,
-0.16632026433944702,
0.32325199246406555,
-0.0324825793504715,
0.33395031094551086,
-0.22515282034873962,
-0.8350505232810974,
-0.25233739614486694,
-0.25549420714378357,
-0.6565359234809875,
-0.16410350799560547,
-0.5005751252174377,
0.2660195827484131,
-0.4750722646713257,
-0.15767507255077362,
-0.1766601800918579,
0.002648772671818733,
-0.43645915389060974,
0.07981472462415695,
0.24822264909744263,
0.611314594745636,
-0.9795156717300415,
0.9337584376335144,
0.904746413230896,
-0.685077965259552,
-0.6311386227607727,
0.5197212100028992,
-0.08618921041488647,
-0.6514867544174194,
0.31097301840782166,
0.2859986424446106,
-0.34362560510635376,
0.07874564081430435,
-0.4857148230075836,
-0.6360087394714355,
1.6196821928024292,
0.794401228427887,
-0.029965730383992195,
-0.11043325811624527,
0.436099648475647,
0.9859172701835632,
-0.46755996346473694,
0.3434405028820038,
0.10540792346000671,
0.415782630443573,
0.45107409358024597,
-0.633131742477417,
-0.17435921728610992,
-0.3431532084941864,
0.20837661623954773,
-0.18073967099189758,
-1.2824428081512451,
0.5728786587715149,
-0.19691315293312073,
-0.25700539350509644,
0.18533337116241455,
0.8124683499336243,
0.4702073931694031,
0.7451253533363342,
0.38419008255004883,
0.2190500944852829,
0.8929880857467651,
0.37696269154548645,
1.08340322971344,
-0.26133960485458374,
0.15428899228572845,
0.9368037581443787,
-0.7459602355957031,
0.3710087537765503,
0.3386204242706299,
0.32080620527267456,
0.7950118780136108,
0.43045926094055176,
0.38498640060424805,
0.3901048004627228,
0.002809010213240981,
-0.5454587340354919,
-0.5696921348571777,
-0.5108634829521179,
-0.18733356893062592,
0.20176176726818085,
0.3619658946990967,
0.008869902230799198,
-0.27478158473968506,
0.3319137990474701,
0.07300056517124176,
0.15517814457416534,
-0.12189735472202301,
0.8456283807754517,
0.27940452098846436,
-0.6865092515945435,
-0.12217561155557632,
0.0120076984167099,
0.18565315008163452,
-0.5969544649124146,
-0.30786508321762085,
-0.1236342191696167,
0.07740506529808044,
0.006729563698172569,
-0.8006477355957031,
0.34905433654785156,
0.04552564397454262,
0.02980702370405197,
-0.4454461634159088,
0.8518587946891785,
-0.13364045321941376,
-0.607898473739624,
0.682141125202179,
0.7119212746620178,
0.12629413604736328,
0.14075148105621338,
-0.627223551273346,
-0.11948377639055252,
-0.3352121412754059,
-0.0811464935541153,
0.514899730682373,
0.7546881437301636,
-0.4223802089691162,
0.8531318306922913,
0.78997802734375,
-0.32610955834388733,
-0.2904956340789795,
0.08178042620420456,
1.1326119899749756,
-0.7234426140785217,
-0.7163057923316956,
-0.7299174666404724,
0.5646012425422668,
-0.1634727120399475,
-0.34369683265686035,
0.5820722579956055,
0.4744095206260681,
0.4682736396789551,
0.20529022812843323,
0.8563817739486694,
0.0593113973736763,
0.053812477737665176,
-0.2009250968694687,
0.8306059837341309,
-0.5258320569992065,
0.15363344550132751,
-0.22980394959449768,
-0.7069593667984009,
-0.19653084874153137,
0.7054651379585266,
-0.514404296875,
0.2986272871494293,
0.5132466554641724,
0.6490942239761353,
0.35335275530815125,
0.43626469373703003,
0.6693726181983948,
-0.3638083040714264,
0.47801634669303894,
0.4494604468345642,
1.1671842336654663,
0.03348979726433754,
0.12732145190238953,
0.1697738915681839,
-0.38785815238952637,
-0.06752786785364151,
-0.7228192090988159,
-1.4390767812728882,
-0.3312150835990906,
-0.04343656450510025,
-0.06116249039769173,
0.31061384081840515,
1.1648881435394287,
0.3326817750930786,
-0.19699113070964813,
-0.44988659024238586,
-0.044891051948070526,
0.1320895552635193,
-0.22941367328166962,
-0.23945125937461853,
-0.29299798607826233,
-0.25499171018600464,
-0.30687376856803894,
0.4354932904243469,
0.3902093172073364,
0.08505727350711823,
-0.413570374250412,
-0.44889020919799805,
-0.13419440388679504,
0.4647330045700073,
0.4969862997531891,
0.3114294409751892,
-0.2335241585969925,
-0.31666749715805054,
0.0018959189765155315,
0.005784840788692236,
0.060123905539512634,
0.7534999847412109,
-0.9823482632637024,
0.24995476007461548,
-0.029615849256515503,
0.7501627206802368,
0.680461049079895,
0.09920112043619156,
0.42470628023147583,
-0.45311662554740906,
0.2453301101922989,
0.03446285426616669,
0.07158120721578598,
0.20054365694522858,
-0.9884090423583984,
0.43038514256477356,
0.25994253158569336,
-0.3246085047721863,
-0.3607245981693268,
0.13684995472431183,
-0.568871796131134,
-0.08962052315473557,
1.2863891124725342,
-0.22275540232658386,
-0.3375386893749237,
-0.2847352623939514,
-0.5235204696655273,
0.1499355137348175,
-0.871680498123169,
0.7832762598991394,
0.8497582674026489,
-0.4415253698825836,
-0.292640745639801,
-0.6781331300735474,
0.20228944718837738,
0.3968817889690399,
-1.0950173139572144,
-0.11722732335329056,
0.4019147455692291,
-0.012098712846636772,
0.29305344820022583,
0.850220263004303,
0.11425063759088516,
0.31553924083709717,
-0.0674305185675621,
0.08319812268018723,
-0.3020610809326172,
-0.4715680778026581,
-0.12658606469631195,
0.0002306613023392856,
0.003986250143498182,
0.11640933901071548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00263v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00263v1
|
Clover: Regressive Lightweight Speculative Decoding with Sequential Knowledge
| 2024-05-01T00:46:22 | 2024-05-01T00:46:22 |
Bin Xiao, Chunan Shi, Xiaonan Nie, Fan Yang, Xiangwei Deng, Lei Su, Weipeng Chen, Bin Cui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) suffer from low efficiency as the mismatch
between the requirement of auto-regressive decoding and the design of most
contemporary GPUs. Specifically, billions to trillions of parameters must be
loaded to the GPU cache through its limited memory bandwidth for computation,
but only a small batch of tokens is actually computed. Consequently, the GPU
spends most of its time on memory transfer instead of computation. Recently,
parallel decoding, a type of speculative decoding algorithms, is becoming more
popular and has demonstrated impressive efficiency improvement in generation.
It introduces extra decoding heads to large models, enabling them to predict
multiple subsequent tokens simultaneously and verify these candidate
continuations in a single decoding step. However, this approach deviates from
the training objective of next token prediction used during pre-training,
resulting in a low hit rate for candidate tokens. In this paper, we propose a
new speculative decoding algorithm, Clover, which integrates sequential
knowledge into the parallel decoding process. This enhancement improves the hit
rate of speculators and thus boosts the overall efficiency. Clover transmits
the sequential knowledge from pre-speculated tokens via the Regressive
Connection, then employs an Attention Decoder to integrate these speculated
tokens. Additionally, Clover incorporates an Augmenting Block that modifies the
hidden states to better align with the purpose of speculative generation rather
than next token prediction. The experiment results demonstrate that Clover
outperforms the baseline by up to 91% on Baichuan-Small and 146% on
Baichuan-Large, respectively, and exceeds the performance of the previously
top-performing method, Medusa, by up to 37% on Baichuan-Small and 57% on
Baichuan-Large, respectively.
|
[
0.061779871582984924,
-0.5544612407684326,
0.769076406955719,
0.5953237414360046,
-0.3528904318809509,
0.5310460925102234,
-0.12356498092412949,
-0.40749794244766235,
0.6085044145584106,
0.33576700091362,
-0.7873798608779907,
-0.71760094165802,
-0.7077273726463318,
0.25566068291664124,
-0.2644816040992737,
0.7459919452667236,
-0.07109510898590088,
-0.05513770505785942,
0.12969641387462616,
0.2388918399810791,
-0.41963282227516174,
-0.5040702223777771,
-0.6066914796829224,
0.025834467262029648,
0.7820926308631897,
0.5178467035293579,
0.5651623606681824,
1.0336297750473022,
0.5592651963233948,
0.2924928367137909,
-0.09774747490882874,
0.31999075412750244,
-0.8768328428268433,
-0.22622734308242798,
0.012557702139019966,
-0.8926647901535034,
-0.2635985314846039,
-0.41758498549461365,
0.8385018706321716,
0.587673008441925,
0.043868787586688995,
0.36619147658348083,
-0.16066449880599976,
0.4145188629627228,
-0.8229437470436096,
0.2399137318134308,
-0.8614609837532043,
0.06566229462623596,
-0.6222720146179199,
-0.521906316280365,
-0.7761306762695312,
-0.2828077971935272,
-0.3722412586212158,
-0.8427835702896118,
0.3154853284358978,
0.5679592490196228,
0.6741880774497986,
0.22376437485218048,
0.016896963119506836,
0.1313091218471527,
-0.5631231069564819,
0.9263983368873596,
-0.7774627208709717,
0.2842232882976532,
0.28684282302856445,
-0.03391604870557785,
-0.30578160285949707,
-0.7825659513473511,
-0.6277173161506653,
0.16931933164596558,
0.004835555795580149,
0.0790005624294281,
0.045602794736623764,
-0.0034368466585874557,
0.35903558135032654,
0.4427160620689392,
-0.5377128720283508,
0.2659362256526947,
-0.2316114753484726,
-0.4004429876804352,
0.21722735464572906,
0.6501649022102356,
0.003064163262024522,
-0.08459682017564774,
-0.5133801102638245,
-0.09778274595737457,
-0.5607626438140869,
0.09046559780836105,
0.4768725037574768,
0.21369248628616333,
0.02959664911031723,
0.2046499103307724,
-0.3430546522140503,
0.5651261210441589,
0.2661505341529846,
-0.26015254855155945,
0.307193785905838,
-0.3433077335357666,
-0.02750849723815918,
-0.10000187158584595,
0.7859197854995728,
0.21906057000160217,
-0.3560206890106201,
-0.31692036986351013,
-0.06943544000387192,
0.5654940605163574,
-0.18006408214569092,
-0.7475941181182861,
-0.45317572355270386,
0.2763018012046814,
-0.5742449164390564,
-0.08918386697769165,
-0.07217157632112503,
-0.8177657127380371,
-0.12650099396705627,
-0.07574702799320221,
0.09536835551261902,
-0.5773450136184692,
-0.2942611575126648,
0.6050068140029907,
-0.38273271918296814,
0.17945876717567444,
0.21304473280906677,
-1.2685962915420532,
0.5617966055870056,
0.863030731678009,
0.8710052371025085,
-0.17565137147903442,
-0.35388073325157166,
-0.8691010475158691,
0.25617289543151855,
-0.44518786668777466,
0.8062999248504639,
-0.6175585985183716,
-0.2387751340866089,
-0.2603752613067627,
-0.004281673114746809,
-0.14171206951141357,
-0.24203737080097198,
0.4969339668750763,
-0.7939462661743164,
-0.5856277942657471,
-0.654216468334198,
-0.3816414475440979,
-0.1601429283618927,
-0.19733746349811554,
-0.6313232779502869,
0.48188453912734985,
-0.1705770641565323,
-1.1639106273651123,
0.6252748370170593,
-0.23649416863918304,
-0.48947200179100037,
0.1454632580280304,
-0.18462668359279633,
-0.10906275361776352,
0.02681407704949379,
0.2727070152759552,
0.38801291584968567,
-0.18791672587394714,
-0.024543479084968567,
-0.745620608329773,
-0.673525333404541,
0.0907226949930191,
-0.3386903405189514,
0.4985235333442688,
0.2769910991191864,
-0.2634466886520386,
0.20895592868328094,
-0.7804872989654541,
0.014272474683821201,
0.03920738771557808,
0.197829931974411,
-0.44456636905670166,
-0.09065224230289459,
0.001489697489887476,
-0.27611854672431946,
0.3769240081310272,
-0.679217517375946,
0.012920093722641468,
-0.24727711081504822,
0.3716352880001068,
0.9639747142791748,
-0.0942925438284874,
0.21752648055553436,
-0.29078567028045654,
0.26204997301101685,
0.13568870723247528,
0.22315986454486847,
-0.5826624631881714,
-0.4597698450088501,
-0.8846330046653748,
-0.5053709149360657,
0.3445761501789093,
0.6506093144416809,
-0.7235344648361206,
0.21471668779850006,
-0.21411988139152527,
-0.26328107714653015,
-0.7084535360336304,
0.45391473174095154,
0.3776231110095978,
0.28576329350471497,
0.17885732650756836,
-0.2296716868877411,
-0.6453000903129578,
-0.6050717234611511,
-0.39326947927474976,
-0.15497642755508423,
0.45336803793907166,
-0.039370350539684296,
0.139067605137825,
-0.557705283164978,
0.7086726427078247,
-0.8778117299079895,
0.028718873858451843,
-0.028816957026720047,
0.4332362413406372,
0.5137616395950317,
0.6679837107658386,
0.2993588149547577,
-0.59340500831604,
-0.34198635816574097,
0.08083898574113846,
-0.8209069967269897,
0.3445901870727539,
-0.06097756698727608,
-0.3762763440608978,
-0.013947837054729462,
0.17170852422714233,
-0.7368300557136536,
0.34924808144569397,
0.4310940206050873,
-0.21201850473880768,
0.6108139753341675,
-0.337296724319458,
0.17361094057559967,
-0.8035207390785217,
0.04643235728144646,
-0.2588881552219391,
-0.23966656625270844,
-0.27887973189353943,
0.2006058245897293,
0.23895607888698578,
0.18086397647857666,
-0.0376705639064312,
0.22343692183494568,
-0.520706295967102,
-0.018458958715200424,
-0.27183809876441956,
-0.2677457332611084,
-0.1180221289396286,
0.3732450306415558,
0.2640655040740967,
0.9496192336082458,
0.4654283821582794,
-0.47327911853790283,
0.36921948194503784,
-0.02127298153936863,
-0.2577410638332367,
-0.21723215281963348,
-0.39448902010917664,
0.2955530285835266,
-0.1628728210926056,
0.2152431756258011,
-1.0006897449493408,
-0.22928839921951294,
0.0853671059012413,
-0.4085614085197449,
0.1395808458328247,
0.18325351178646088,
-0.9459625482559204,
-0.5863239765167236,
-0.19423803687095642,
0.8361940979957581,
0.8173381686210632,
-0.7125564217567444,
0.3073837161064148,
0.10252877324819565,
-0.14448459446430206,
-0.7007666230201721,
-0.7145609855651855,
0.06485883891582489,
-0.24410715699195862,
-0.6977391242980957,
0.002482519019395113,
-0.25906091928482056,
-0.14975933730602264,
0.0728454515337944,
0.08540649712085724,
0.1191546767950058,
-0.220188170671463,
0.06378348916769028,
0.35172605514526367,
-0.2938627302646637,
-0.20927982032299042,
0.09727054834365845,
-0.5011764764785767,
0.007090704049915075,
-0.908256471157074,
0.5060762763023376,
0.022089464589953423,
-0.23671694099903107,
-0.6854467988014221,
0.4372401535511017,
0.44160330295562744,
-0.20565307140350342,
0.7934001088142395,
0.8581492304801941,
-0.21890012919902802,
-0.4106099307537079,
-0.7078585624694824,
-0.21660728752613068,
-0.5129945278167725,
0.14081259071826935,
-0.572417676448822,
-0.8534107208251953,
0.9459706544876099,
-0.2571171522140503,
0.10497601330280304,
0.38426995277404785,
0.3285088539123535,
0.29771190881729126,
0.8768606185913086,
0.9154919981956482,
-0.31488707661628723,
0.24736922979354858,
-0.3822541832923889,
0.07881136238574982,
-0.554455578327179,
-0.17158876359462738,
-0.08820748329162598,
-0.13373850286006927,
-0.14176906645298004,
-0.645211398601532,
-0.18521322309970856,
0.02152605541050434,
-0.06246679648756981,
0.42005327343940735,
-0.19424745440483093,
0.19428548216819763,
0.512347400188446,
0.33827370405197144,
0.5846945643424988,
0.008070187643170357,
-0.2869073748588562,
-0.18363134562969208,
-0.8573532104492188,
0.02555502951145172,
1.2295533418655396,
0.5008828639984131,
1.1664302349090576,
-0.1892823725938797,
0.8713393807411194,
0.3058958947658539,
0.16539087891578674,
-0.4844408333301544,
0.4318927824497223,
-0.3001302480697632,
-0.22246390581130981,
-0.12301220744848251,
-0.6727542281150818,
-0.5028818845748901,
0.07554545253515244,
-0.005948124919086695,
-0.6661755442619324,
0.4159276783466339,
0.17727792263031006,
-0.8791394829750061,
0.5213977098464966,
-0.8063732385635376,
0.48006564378738403,
-0.040474675595760345,
-0.6054133176803589,
-0.31767722964286804,
-0.4530338644981384,
0.8921392560005188,
-0.3292704224586487,
0.2905917167663574,
0.1008695438504219,
-0.042260248214006424,
0.7541050910949707,
-0.5167272090911865,
0.9096795916557312,
0.02131890133023262,
-0.20974867045879364,
-0.015315413475036621,
-0.13490404188632965,
0.7830829620361328,
0.3681863248348236,
-0.05082389712333679,
0.1808285117149353,
0.07207983732223511,
-0.5355159640312195,
-0.5272883772850037,
0.7678878903388977,
-0.7788679003715515,
-0.6223399639129639,
-0.38831090927124023,
-0.6853542923927307,
-0.1945658028125763,
0.32550376653671265,
0.582949697971344,
0.45031583309173584,
0.3551308512687683,
-0.1736796498298645,
1.0719002485275269,
0.01757962815463543,
0.04418254643678665,
0.3951582908630371,
-0.3206157684326172,
-0.6434715390205383,
1.2085715532302856,
-0.027700040489435196,
0.303702712059021,
0.65651535987854,
-0.2113441675901413,
-0.08169665187597275,
-0.582015872001648,
-0.1900687962770462,
0.38558194041252136,
-0.6275845170021057,
-0.28452593088150024,
-0.7931720018386841,
-0.09000737220048904,
-0.48665785789489746,
-0.03076470084488392,
-0.29775097966194153,
-0.06563741713762283,
-0.42318516969680786,
-0.13828670978546143,
0.5450791716575623,
0.6096530556678772,
-0.19993877410888672,
0.5730655789375305,
-0.7473886013031006,
0.5821766257286072,
0.07574139535427094,
0.4446966350078583,
0.14000439643859863,
-0.28022247552871704,
-0.369228333234787,
-0.11338528990745544,
0.23784831166267395,
-0.5260721445083618,
0.3338179886341095,
-0.39776337146759033,
0.3474300801753998,
0.8910414576530457,
0.3400427997112274,
1.1928170919418335,
-0.711368978023529,
0.29853036999702454,
0.5091176629066467,
-0.7388909459114075,
0.18112269043922424,
-0.33280980587005615,
0.19648689031600952,
0.5351293683052063,
0.1644686609506607,
-0.08843909949064255,
-0.4897809624671936,
-0.40044519305229187,
-0.6828141808509827,
0.778167724609375,
0.0023553965147584677,
-0.27962085604667664,
-0.011673131957650185,
0.31627413630485535,
0.548349142074585,
0.014934482052922249,
-0.24766753613948822,
-0.22471410036087036,
0.11793313175439835,
-0.292753130197525,
-0.42289066314697266,
-0.5458118915557861,
-0.062227267771959305,
-0.1832612007856369,
0.2710804045200348,
0.029668765142560005,
0.396602600812912,
0.03942349925637245,
0.1690574288368225,
-0.3174998462200165,
-0.11312657594680786,
0.2601025104522705,
0.5264833569526672,
-0.4324285089969635,
0.025052901357412338,
0.13247591257095337,
-0.6643773913383484,
0.002051560441032052,
0.26698189973831177,
-0.2489328235387802,
0.14342427253723145,
0.29952874779701233,
0.960952877998352,
0.5320855975151062,
-0.4503787159919739,
0.1041671484708786,
-0.2746804654598236,
-0.1405700445175171,
-0.3932644724845886,
-0.0569019578397274,
-0.2858235239982605,
0.34920692443847656,
0.5131275653839111,
0.3711486756801605,
0.4077073633670807,
-0.4195127487182617,
0.28202056884765625,
0.33011481165885925,
0.20957563817501068,
-0.3891982138156891,
0.7829864621162415,
0.08704401552677155,
0.13304710388183594,
0.26860833168029785,
-0.15913252532482147,
-0.38132891058921814,
0.4460664689540863,
0.8391563296318054,
0.9295507073402405,
0.14554022252559662,
-0.04124550148844719,
0.2978987693786621,
0.25840723514556885,
-0.38424333930015564,
0.49065154790878296,
-0.25684022903442383,
-0.45816555619239807,
-0.688495397567749,
-0.8044220209121704,
-0.21975132822990417,
-0.12239893525838852,
-0.6438616514205933,
0.12245583534240723,
-0.8182776570320129,
-0.4154219627380371,
-0.3095068335533142,
0.14665667712688446,
-0.6977576017379761,
-0.10626198351383209,
0.026930395513772964,
1.2939081192016602,
-0.6593523025512695,
0.8474645614624023,
0.3222149908542633,
-0.21960727870464325,
-0.8657143115997314,
0.278032124042511,
-0.17345863580703735,
-0.779346764087677,
0.841151773929596,
0.23993979394435883,
-0.3346136510372162,
0.3166452646255493,
-0.3350110948085785,
-1.0802448987960815,
1.1238538026809692,
0.4133200943470001,
-0.749765157699585,
-0.2608124613761902,
-0.18419186770915985,
-0.00055230304133147,
-0.25287678837776184,
0.2417919933795929,
0.36672788858413696,
0.3141375482082367,
0.40181857347488403,
-0.6952463388442993,
0.1667824387550354,
-0.23941071331501007,
0.1405509114265442,
0.0370309017598629,
-1.0079463720321655,
1.213039517402649,
-0.5503274202346802,
-0.4668508768081665,
0.6652683615684509,
1.1837172508239746,
0.4005279839038849,
0.3532269299030304,
0.33230307698249817,
0.6692787408828735,
0.9339866042137146,
0.10535283386707306,
0.8951147794723511,
-0.5626403093338013,
0.09408536553382874,
0.5817914009094238,
-0.28379857540130615,
1.1011602878570557,
0.37367185950279236,
-0.30840733647346497,
0.7655378580093384,
0.7178806066513062,
0.32383885979652405,
0.662714421749115,
0.03395848348736763,
-0.30435749888420105,
-0.5922465920448303,
0.3475368916988373,
-0.5010628700256348,
-0.09553857892751694,
0.604360818862915,
-0.08543789386749268,
0.08867722749710083,
0.10042678564786911,
-0.1137484535574913,
0.04742543026804924,
-0.43272650241851807,
0.5613133311271667,
0.22352604568004608,
-0.4773836135864258,
0.6140512824058533,
0.09464873373508453,
1.0129693746566772,
-1.0052272081375122,
0.0119470851495862,
-0.19589124619960785,
0.6783771514892578,
-0.2984084486961365,
-0.47352564334869385,
-0.053413666784763336,
-0.17002853751182556,
-0.5354266166687012,
0.1712011843919754,
0.6179019808769226,
-0.30223867297172546,
-0.602581799030304,
0.42637965083122253,
-0.1515706181526184,
0.008503958582878113,
0.29288971424102783,
-0.13603512942790985,
0.7346187233924866,
-0.2108086198568344,
0.47032034397125244,
0.21396401524543762,
0.669687032699585,
0.2542179822921753,
0.6514604091644287,
1.066929578781128,
0.3372231721878052,
0.30052000284194946,
-0.2640456259250641,
1.094839334487915,
-0.8556700348854065,
-1.0859791040420532,
-0.6401450634002686,
0.23887546360492706,
-0.005225286353379488,
0.13112744688987732,
1.2195947170257568,
0.5713427066802979,
0.5905433297157288,
-0.16187453269958496,
0.8153877258300781,
0.36618807911872864,
0.5452232956886292,
-0.8510520458221436,
0.4044575095176697,
-0.17182691395282745,
0.41002157330513,
-0.42143887281417847,
-0.5545682907104492,
-0.08190858364105225,
0.20736432075500488,
-0.4535280764102936,
-0.25505825877189636,
0.7199723124504089,
0.5754735469818115,
0.09008168429136276,
0.3393317759037018,
0.2645871043205261,
0.2644343972206116,
-0.05521440878510475,
0.9249993562698364,
0.749920129776001,
-0.3009621798992157,
0.35594868659973145,
-0.053371816873550415,
-0.7136566638946533,
-0.18206748366355896,
-0.5300154685974121,
-0.8893486857414246,
-0.2730346918106079,
0.0074298568069934845,
-0.15873564779758453,
0.36379557847976685,
0.4920220971107483,
0.7163654565811157,
-0.705880880355835,
-0.3682917356491089,
-0.22540636360645294,
0.03269348293542862,
-0.40239426493644714,
-0.2178499400615692,
0.2632984220981598,
-0.8219336271286011,
-0.5235228538513184,
0.19163255393505096,
0.31620949506759644,
-0.4265591502189636,
-0.3212989568710327,
-0.262921541929245,
0.03061739355325699,
-0.020538317039608955,
0.5453757643699646,
0.5352069139480591,
-0.7239704132080078,
0.10861490666866302,
0.14367243647575378,
0.11754491925239563,
-0.32827574014663696,
0.9153506755828857,
-1.104920506477356,
0.282822847366333,
0.4627832770347595,
0.8767457008361816,
0.48159152269363403,
0.07416962087154388,
0.6506810188293457,
-0.12485923618078232,
0.45465177297592163,
-0.1132589653134346,
0.3248719274997711,
0.1333319991827011,
-0.764299750328064,
-0.21491017937660217,
0.8056480288505554,
-0.305357426404953,
-0.7665058374404907,
0.04370483383536339,
-0.8859685063362122,
-0.13031212985515594,
1.2935317754745483,
-0.31611794233322144,
-0.6948451399803162,
-0.028379809111356735,
-0.06319230049848557,
0.009818273596465588,
-0.5577913522720337,
0.4278998076915741,
0.3855699598789215,
0.14205750823020935,
-0.2117893546819687,
-0.3273705840110779,
0.45184218883514404,
0.3311059772968292,
-0.3509562313556671,
0.23139873147010803,
0.3115837872028351,
0.26597073674201965,
0.2989232540130615,
0.8795062303543091,
-0.045148465782403946,
0.28876936435699463,
0.6221504807472229,
-0.3155369460582733,
0.07987648993730545,
-0.5073951482772827,
0.0033902202267199755,
0.09564831852912903,
0.11745567619800568,
-0.43836960196495056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00253v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00253v2
|
CodeHalu: Code Hallucinations in LLMs Driven by Execution-based Verification
| 2024-04-30T23:56:38 | 2024-06-26T20:28:36 |
Yuchen Tian, Weixiang Yan, Qian Yang, Qian Chen, Wen Wang, Ziyang Luo, Lei Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SE
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have made significant progress in code
generation, providing developers with unprecedented automated programming
support. However, LLMs often generate code that is syntactically correct and
even semantically plausible but may not execute as expected or meet specified
requirements. This phenomenon of hallucinations in the code domain has not been
systematically explored. To enhance the community's understanding and research
on this issue, we introduce the concept of code hallucinations and propose a
classification method for code hallucination based on execution verification.
We classify code hallucinations into four main types: mapping, naming,
resource, and logic hallucinations, with each category further divided into
different subcategories to understand and address the unique challenges faced
by LLMs in code generation with finer granularity. Additionally, we develop a
dynamic detection algorithm named CodeHalu to quantify code hallucinations and
establish the CodeHaluEval benchmark, which includes 8,883 samples from 699
tasks to systematically and quantitatively evaluate code hallucinations. By
evaluating 17 popular LLMs on this benchmark, we reveal significant differences
in their accuracy and reliability in code generation and provide detailed
insights for further improving the code generation capabilities of LLMs. The
CodeHalu benchmark and code are publicly available at
https://github.com/yuchen814/CodeHalu.
|
[
-0.14891760051250458,
-0.9802490472793579,
0.4474545419216156,
0.42293813824653625,
-0.10120190680027008,
0.292275607585907,
-0.38658443093299866,
-0.6200708746910095,
0.28937453031539917,
0.7489354610443115,
-0.29974162578582764,
-0.7361684441566467,
-0.44883546233177185,
0.3522101044654846,
-0.7625305652618408,
0.6989611387252808,
-0.1659727543592453,
-0.06720572710037231,
-0.3189440071582794,
0.09254982322454453,
-0.8284770846366882,
-0.7027609348297119,
-0.08634664863348007,
-0.24322158098220825,
0.16718167066574097,
0.23218899965286255,
0.6075334548950195,
0.5132448077201843,
0.5208231806755066,
0.2913012206554413,
0.15691833198070526,
0.2899971008300781,
-0.6150848865509033,
0.2503051459789276,
0.48287972807884216,
-0.6094529628753662,
-0.3452873229980469,
-0.36091578006744385,
0.2446686029434204,
0.4159816801548004,
-0.43239253759384155,
0.02707572653889656,
-0.13763873279094696,
0.36148127913475037,
-0.6328144073486328,
0.1802125871181488,
-0.7826351523399353,
0.36179402470588684,
-0.10677393525838852,
-0.5669646859169006,
-0.569780707359314,
-0.7024540305137634,
-0.3602898120880127,
-0.2074526995420456,
-0.01761035993695259,
0.04188753291964531,
0.5639452338218689,
0.5447594523429871,
-0.1860489547252655,
-0.7872402667999268,
-0.6819635033607483,
0.5885135531425476,
-0.47150421142578125,
0.32627296447753906,
0.2747783064842224,
0.35463252663612366,
-0.17593960464000702,
-0.6332143545150757,
-0.5390349626541138,
-0.41878238320350647,
-0.050383321940898895,
-0.20869149267673492,
-0.052360642701387405,
-0.05262774974107742,
0.5762004852294922,
0.534269392490387,
-0.8587828278541565,
0.1212071105837822,
-0.3023242652416229,
-0.3447314500808716,
0.5138792395591736,
0.256653755903244,
0.3565453588962555,
-0.18588025867938995,
-0.2644329369068146,
0.24480870366096497,
-0.6896867752075195,
-0.34895771741867065,
0.45313191413879395,
-0.3037577271461487,
-0.013149913400411606,
0.383188933134079,
-0.22522781789302826,
0.5428934693336487,
-0.24573498964309692,
-0.10568755120038986,
0.42630863189697266,
0.05544036999344826,
-0.18707045912742615,
0.3802680969238281,
0.38795825839042664,
0.2730558514595032,
0.38313934206962585,
-0.32722294330596924,
-0.47089722752571106,
0.6227317452430725,
0.6625329852104187,
-0.7801691889762878,
-0.412677139043808,
0.42868927121162415,
-0.5572515726089478,
-0.7820942401885986,
0.14693060517311096,
-0.6902024149894714,
-0.5898151397705078,
-0.15509741008281708,
0.24543453752994537,
-0.35041213035583496,
-0.4274653196334839,
0.25417593121528625,
0.2551140785217285,
0.49401214718818665,
0.17524407804012299,
-0.5316251516342163,
0.16015861928462982,
0.8075944185256958,
0.47343409061431885,
-0.6132810711860657,
-0.44538813829421997,
-0.5208248496055603,
0.015117998234927654,
-0.5448294281959534,
0.8182960748672485,
-0.4520742893218994,
-0.2688864469528198,
0.3849267065525055,
-0.08612436801195145,
0.1724502146244049,
-0.9750190377235413,
0.15985840559005737,
-0.6255416870117188,
-0.23254495859146118,
0.061606984585523605,
-0.47429561614990234,
-0.22102445363998413,
0.2557430565357208,
-0.46930623054504395,
0.8428394794464111,
0.12633495032787323,
-0.4815356433391571,
0.3295501470565796,
-0.3215695023536682,
-0.5877392292022705,
0.4661644399166107,
-0.7190859913825989,
-0.3316742479801178,
0.32459092140197754,
-0.20431117713451385,
0.394167423248291,
-0.011258643120527267,
0.5191289186477661,
0.06048605591058731,
-0.8440664410591125,
0.6174255609512329,
-0.13929256796836853,
0.5254203081130981,
0.2986781597137451,
-0.7547858953475952,
0.28478750586509705,
-0.9063356518745422,
0.06155553087592125,
0.2154889702796936,
-0.1596301794052124,
0.11197461187839508,
-0.009589061141014099,
-0.027385441586375237,
-0.22770856320858002,
0.1307605803012848,
-0.046049974858760834,
0.25327789783477783,
-0.12578581273555756,
0.2697005867958069,
0.7029080986976624,
0.0613003671169281,
0.001309953979216516,
-0.3264912962913513,
0.7420017719268799,
-0.033344607800245285,
0.1960480958223343,
-0.12451668828725815,
-0.38607120513916016,
-0.8075459003448486,
-0.05935772508382797,
0.024149730801582336,
0.6213734745979309,
-0.8762028217315674,
0.5725924968719482,
-0.028037400916218758,
-0.2578795552253723,
-0.13539066910743713,
0.16042140126228333,
0.4007279574871063,
0.1386265605688095,
0.21177387237548828,
-0.14818885922431946,
-0.6912349462509155,
-0.6814354062080383,
-0.07102564722299576,
-0.3074951469898224,
0.26286494731903076,
0.1062786728143692,
0.5145429372787476,
-0.8874936699867249,
0.373853474855423,
-0.5574435591697693,
-0.23195216059684753,
-0.16072562336921692,
0.17916733026504517,
0.02662709169089794,
0.3595811724662781,
0.24385467171669006,
-0.7538012266159058,
0.03591165691614151,
-0.04984483867883682,
-1.1829922199249268,
-0.4247821867465973,
-0.31095680594444275,
0.05208129063248634,
0.7351608872413635,
0.6716012358665466,
-0.16930145025253296,
0.489766389131546,
0.6119316220283508,
-0.18065562844276428,
0.7790617942810059,
-0.0944007933139801,
0.25192996859550476,
-0.5735130310058594,
0.014176311902701855,
-0.5824152827262878,
-0.07539305090904236,
-0.3974710702896118,
0.5852323174476624,
0.010621463879942894,
-0.0272940993309021,
-0.11120143532752991,
-0.10767102241516113,
-0.43526458740234375,
-0.3398936986923218,
-0.4428580105304718,
-0.07327065616846085,
-0.31880685687065125,
0.4601757228374481,
0.024417683482170105,
0.5974434614181519,
0.6871935725212097,
-0.5222959518432617,
0.7022925019264221,
-0.02011200040578842,
-0.7486839294433594,
0.14732949435710907,
-0.32996419072151184,
0.369466096162796,
0.28351321816444397,
0.17294064164161682,
-0.6738168597221375,
-0.4485187828540802,
0.1811690330505371,
-0.2419600933790207,
0.08011717349290848,
0.13331982493400574,
-0.9919952154159546,
-0.1927739530801773,
-0.12144176661968231,
0.5640549063682556,
0.8416000604629517,
-0.584631085395813,
0.36787399649620056,
0.35237717628479004,
0.3334316611289978,
-0.45650792121887207,
-0.8034216165542603,
0.19475671648979187,
-0.190669447183609,
-0.4058782756328583,
0.19048011302947998,
-0.16860386729240417,
-0.41683074831962585,
-0.1967160552740097,
-0.17535272240638733,
-0.03476249799132347,
0.2305671125650406,
0.6372600197792053,
0.1481124311685562,
-0.16353952884674072,
-0.0685485303401947,
0.024894744157791138,
-0.1493038684129715,
0.4772058129310608,
0.03463178128004074,
0.7348212599754333,
-0.23896072804927826,
-0.5582128167152405,
-0.2525169551372528,
0.14678941667079926,
0.4593484103679657,
0.024052083492279053,
0.2567165493965149,
0.6205560564994812,
-0.5101732611656189,
-0.666364312171936,
-0.7673875689506531,
-0.19411303102970123,
-0.45454102754592896,
0.2909493148326874,
-0.5022748708724976,
-0.7491788268089294,
0.7107089161872864,
-0.07947464287281036,
-0.25000718235969543,
0.03130919113755226,
0.7551577687263489,
0.3058829605579376,
0.7802284955978394,
0.4731389880180359,
0.24674652516841888,
0.0074627273716032505,
-0.2580190896987915,
0.22466908395290375,
-0.19168978929519653,
-0.4532776474952698,
-0.26628655195236206,
-0.12667454779148102,
-0.5938037037849426,
-0.5336012244224548,
0.15184810757637024,
0.13793796300888062,
0.19619226455688477,
0.31925487518310547,
-0.8925995826721191,
0.6116833686828613,
0.13335976004600525,
-0.019267698749899864,
0.3827663064002991,
0.056754011660814285,
-0.02531207725405693,
0.16323138773441315,
-0.46647587418556213,
-0.5089758038520813,
0.7064371705055237,
0.2620266079902649,
0.9285688996315002,
0.08765006065368652,
1.0392653942108154,
0.7576239109039307,
0.19159190356731415,
-0.6701222658157349,
0.8193902373313904,
0.3890826404094696,
-0.15329517424106598,
0.10683158785104752,
-0.6427860856056213,
-0.7365224957466125,
-0.09975449740886688,
-0.028791464865207672,
-0.54660964012146,
0.08231914788484573,
-0.04253699630498886,
-0.2434988170862198,
0.08807966858148575,
-0.5254237055778503,
0.7021255493164062,
-0.3302304148674011,
0.036397989839315414,
-0.43703144788742065,
-0.28807532787323,
0.6470887660980225,
-0.43726637959480286,
0.3662472665309906,
0.04632602632045746,
0.10502877831459045,
0.5138514041900635,
-0.3776160478591919,
0.696376621723175,
-0.08929585665464401,
-0.6458267569541931,
0.3433336913585663,
0.5668232440948486,
0.4239865243434906,
0.14224620163440704,
0.11059027165174484,
0.49607035517692566,
0.026956705376505852,
-0.15838561952114105,
-0.4566898047924042,
1.00132155418396,
-0.4956759214401245,
-0.4328666627407074,
-0.47739678621292114,
-0.4875122010707855,
0.1410066783428192,
0.13772130012512207,
0.4113083481788635,
0.42934662103652954,
0.10345833003520966,
-0.05668201297521591,
0.7447095513343811,
-0.6206209063529968,
0.19981326162815094,
0.18702957034111023,
-0.8475583791732788,
-0.24712789058685303,
1.1039448976516724,
-0.012315494939684868,
-0.19035354256629944,
0.09819429367780685,
-0.15275608003139496,
0.07333994656801224,
-0.8704243898391724,
-0.1963178962469101,
0.05044439435005188,
-0.9135762453079224,
-0.3340955376625061,
-0.5966912508010864,
-0.43939200043678284,
-0.19613909721374512,
-0.3111226260662079,
-0.07188742607831955,
-0.052867915481328964,
-0.08136302977800369,
0.06261368840932846,
0.26398688554763794,
1.0332307815551758,
0.14871922135353088,
-0.10504304617643356,
-0.638994574546814,
0.5986093282699585,
0.10898163914680481,
0.5249844789505005,
-0.0495888777077198,
-0.37263035774230957,
-0.3208596110343933,
-0.3441246449947357,
-0.11549573391675949,
-0.8248531222343445,
0.1934170424938202,
-0.32501405477523804,
0.46999624371528625,
0.45052215456962585,
0.2255984991788864,
0.5502404570579529,
-0.39961743354797363,
0.7956043481826782,
0.0383974090218544,
-1.1480534076690674,
0.6765368580818176,
-0.008167100138962269,
0.07682197540998459,
0.3341808021068573,
0.012899442575871944,
-0.24747934937477112,
-0.669895589351654,
-0.4074389636516571,
-0.4701268970966339,
0.3034141957759857,
0.39542949199676514,
0.14452625811100006,
-0.19560681283473969,
0.4597443640232086,
0.39275267720222473,
0.0797949731349945,
-0.8486700057983398,
-0.21284280717372894,
-0.008362232707440853,
0.02524426393210888,
0.3560885488986969,
-0.38276636600494385,
-0.019635425880551338,
-0.062391478568315506,
0.3353116810321808,
-0.13690251111984253,
0.4184073507785797,
-0.007545581087470055,
-0.5597095489501953,
-0.24039988219738007,
-0.03638659045100212,
0.9738343358039856,
1.0353875160217285,
-0.18434497714042664,
0.3239409923553467,
0.16838471591472626,
-0.4664613902568817,
0.0593852661550045,
-0.3292849361896515,
0.09029360860586166,
0.15682712197303772,
0.562619149684906,
0.6408944725990295,
0.23810195922851562,
-0.9893773198127747,
0.5856007933616638,
-0.10956008732318878,
-0.2626817226409912,
-0.6762888431549072,
0.4545871913433075,
-0.36228176951408386,
0.3179868459701538,
0.41632506251335144,
-0.0011543091386556625,
0.22487549483776093,
-0.4336985647678375,
0.3299223780632019,
0.19813765585422516,
-0.031034914776682854,
-0.2791438400745392,
0.5584126710891724,
0.13805893063545227,
-0.5291045308113098,
0.5825597047805786,
-0.4469433128833771,
-0.5906850099563599,
0.6546123027801514,
0.4150596559047699,
1.1482378244400024,
0.010217693634331226,
0.04315250366926193,
0.020731614902615547,
0.2999216616153717,
0.010078824125230312,
0.5536573529243469,
-0.14990101754665375,
-0.6197290420532227,
-0.4434835910797119,
-0.7687464356422424,
-0.4127449691295624,
0.10648837685585022,
-0.662526547908783,
0.37499719858169556,
-0.34938037395477295,
0.029654616490006447,
-0.35547611117362976,
-0.12433383613824844,
-0.15560948848724365,
-0.1979980617761612,
0.4886910617351532,
0.683249294757843,
-0.5318844318389893,
0.9829187989234924,
0.4673563539981842,
-0.1385459154844284,
-0.37195923924446106,
0.36735299229621887,
-0.1807263344526291,
-0.8952245116233826,
0.6179942488670349,
0.5310691595077515,
-0.18579904735088348,
-0.058097027242183685,
-0.5284774303436279,
-0.2621041536331177,
0.940392255783081,
0.20884542167186737,
-0.3829101622104645,
-0.04919982701539993,
0.27733027935028076,
0.4475219249725342,
-0.4175854027271271,
-0.12812362611293793,
0.5214869976043701,
0.3473063111305237,
-0.04778089001774788,
-0.5588193535804749,
0.3488049805164337,
-0.12956778705120087,
0.160257488489151,
0.06125596910715103,
-0.3012990951538086,
0.34946706891059875,
-0.3751733601093292,
-0.20427460968494415,
0.1415206640958786,
0.5154999494552612,
0.6658628582954407,
0.36471447348594666,
0.36758700013160706,
0.38260191679000854,
0.6816413402557373,
-0.2055545300245285,
0.882093071937561,
-0.7331966161727905,
0.19381071627140045,
0.6701006889343262,
-0.586175262928009,
0.5920935273170471,
0.29174694418907166,
-0.06304740905761719,
0.8142704367637634,
0.5308587551116943,
-0.431810200214386,
0.2748793661594391,
0.635301947593689,
0.05905211716890335,
-0.1279250532388687,
0.09440593421459198,
-0.6128271222114563,
0.4303953945636749,
0.19795316457748413,
-0.21439339220523834,
0.2087818831205368,
0.21224506199359894,
-0.2163677215576172,
0.013105346821248531,
0.0859396755695343,
0.8127166628837585,
-0.001138780964538455,
-0.6811537742614746,
1.1620129346847534,
-0.1357937604188919,
0.7220478057861328,
-0.3381184935569763,
-0.32480546832084656,
-0.4435943067073822,
0.20542411506175995,
-0.4481948912143707,
-0.46035364270210266,
0.43239516019821167,
0.13285376131534576,
-0.02849666215479374,
-0.2988356053829193,
0.6081626415252686,
-0.18091066181659698,
-0.26366207003593445,
0.5415658354759216,
0.21395452320575714,
0.5592580437660217,
-0.11917493492364883,
-0.36244887113571167,
0.9457509517669678,
0.08096975088119507,
-0.008554916828870773,
0.10039262473583221,
0.5688745379447937,
0.1405491828918457,
0.5249446630477905,
0.42595645785331726,
0.09527698159217834,
0.22085611522197723,
0.15591250360012054,
0.6172831058502197,
-0.6393327713012695,
-0.37576809525489807,
-0.919062077999115,
0.07769527286291122,
0.14477640390396118,
-0.11153680086135864,
0.6519866585731506,
0.7767148017883301,
0.8979410529136658,
-0.34493765234947205,
0.46814000606536865,
0.01953676901757717,
-0.12879306077957153,
-0.6701343059539795,
0.8513851761817932,
-0.3830704987049103,
0.6183337569236755,
-0.2927524149417877,
-1.1262282133102417,
-0.5158824920654297,
0.7236883640289307,
-0.03286552429199219,
0.029386838898062706,
0.914718747138977,
0.9846997857093811,
0.22544695436954498,
0.08693382143974304,
0.5909340977668762,
0.32852840423583984,
0.12502652406692505,
0.6316691040992737,
1.268519639968872,
-0.4006950855255127,
0.5782281756401062,
-0.25981876254081726,
-0.1746385395526886,
-0.4760400354862213,
-0.6474922895431519,
-0.8264737129211426,
-0.5199001431465149,
-0.7790848612785339,
-0.6879855394363403,
-0.10688222199678421,
0.693803071975708,
0.5191779136657715,
-0.9448538422584534,
-0.5997297167778015,
-0.42318132519721985,
0.26690247654914856,
-0.2319304347038269,
-0.31525906920433044,
0.14589418470859528,
-0.6032267808914185,
-0.4672435522079468,
0.21495181322097778,
0.36064282059669495,
-0.11753172427415848,
-0.5809090733528137,
-0.41597771644592285,
0.38217198848724365,
0.0326433926820755,
0.6704407930374146,
-0.12487240880727768,
-1.0899890661239624,
-0.049159225076436996,
-0.02787562645971775,
-0.3519369661808014,
0.041418787091970444,
0.9702221751213074,
-0.8510503768920898,
0.21803799271583557,
0.3087006211280823,
0.7367838621139526,
0.1747673749923706,
-0.36726880073547363,
0.15989039838314056,
-0.5718734860420227,
-0.03776788339018822,
0.15472093224525452,
0.3092855215072632,
-0.03492981195449829,
-0.5615041851997375,
0.7057373523712158,
0.3629729449748993,
-0.659246563911438,
-1.3895773887634277,
0.2127683460712433,
-1.0116641521453857,
-0.46399280428886414,
1.3624457120895386,
0.17026783525943756,
-0.022284802049398422,
-0.033114053308963776,
-0.17071138322353363,
0.0822211503982544,
-0.04917074367403984,
1.1680296659469604,
0.516609251499176,
-0.1731395423412323,
-0.21974550187587738,
-0.49492090940475464,
0.7032479643821716,
0.22587570548057556,
-1.0274065732955933,
0.2495373785495758,
0.6441276669502258,
-0.09062721580266953,
0.3641478419303894,
0.3531162142753601,
-0.05485684797167778,
0.4059648811817169,
0.04322964325547218,
0.3235750198364258,
0.033019326627254486,
-0.4016433656215668,
-0.47728246450424194,
0.4505906105041504,
0.12188279628753662,
0.06164964661002159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00216v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00216v1
|
Graphical Reasoning: LLM-based Semi-Open Relation Extraction
| 2024-04-30T21:41:53 | 2024-04-30T21:41:53 |
Yicheng Tao, Yiqun Wang, Longju Bai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper presents a comprehensive exploration of relation extraction
utilizing advanced language models, specifically Chain of Thought (CoT) and
Graphical Reasoning (GRE) techniques. We demonstrate how leveraging in-context
learning with GPT-3.5 can significantly enhance the extraction process,
particularly through detailed example-based reasoning. Additionally, we
introduce a novel graphical reasoning approach that dissects relation
extraction into sequential sub-tasks, improving precision and adaptability in
processing complex relational data. Our experiments, conducted on multiple
datasets, including manually annotated data, show considerable improvements in
performance metrics, underscoring the effectiveness of our methodologies.
|
[
-0.5713773369789124,
-1.2782496213912964,
0.958769679069519,
-0.2008424699306488,
-0.2935348451137543,
-0.07010333240032196,
-0.0826694518327713,
-0.746970534324646,
-0.5928373336791992,
0.4712062478065491,
-0.4957112669944763,
-0.8172938227653503,
-0.40592727065086365,
-0.029540682211518288,
-0.036779142916202545,
1.0322996377944946,
-0.39426514506340027,
-0.10591758787631989,
-0.25456634163856506,
-0.17101599276065826,
-0.30050137639045715,
-0.44452187418937683,
-0.8852525353431702,
-0.31516632437705994,
0.38352102041244507,
0.2652560770511627,
0.7199928164482117,
0.5123080015182495,
0.4654354155063629,
0.2037937343120575,
-0.010648765601217747,
0.3800450563430786,
-0.5864591598510742,
0.20431403815746307,
-0.5505460500717163,
-0.23714302480220795,
-0.5265135169029236,
-0.028264595195651054,
0.39614245295524597,
0.612042248249054,
0.027182431891560555,
0.31597253680229187,
-0.2612929046154022,
0.542894184589386,
-0.589529275894165,
0.7583131790161133,
-0.543207049369812,
-0.006180444732308388,
-0.10917124897241592,
0.007275191135704517,
-0.5675213932991028,
-0.25416186451911926,
0.23237097263336182,
-0.5374761819839478,
0.06197667866945267,
-0.04307882860302925,
1.1109106540679932,
-0.1120864599943161,
-0.5334302186965942,
-0.26214203238487244,
-0.8065934777259827,
0.512158989906311,
-0.5398531556129456,
0.442527174949646,
0.1272948533296585,
0.5367566347122192,
-0.3288098871707916,
-1.2486017942428589,
-0.2969469726085663,
-0.07084152102470398,
-0.1879209578037262,
0.10424718260765076,
-0.14129573106765747,
0.21875910460948944,
0.7738381028175354,
0.6021330952644348,
-0.351071834564209,
-0.39172041416168213,
-0.13368074595928192,
0.22165463864803314,
0.6668143272399902,
-0.11201562732458115,
0.8140799403190613,
-0.19889143109321594,
-0.5127118825912476,
0.1646929830312729,
-0.9145880341529846,
-0.20536644756793976,
0.03175971657037735,
0.15762217342853546,
-0.11336565017700195,
0.6483485698699951,
0.011447066441178322,
0.743671715259552,
-0.5514213442802429,
-0.14709752798080444,
-0.2605932950973511,
-0.28197988867759705,
-0.4601728022098541,
-0.2935680150985718,
0.9564149379730225,
0.09645576775074005,
0.7415959239006042,
-0.35120177268981934,
-0.23574505746364594,
0.043818458914756775,
-0.3445900082588196,
-0.35645434260368347,
-0.497188538312912,
0.10472436249256134,
-0.5322502255439758,
0.03472533077001572,
0.14956270158290863,
-0.8198402523994446,
-0.0581820011138916,
-0.4821507930755615,
0.14457225799560547,
-0.6101992130279541,
-0.29034316539764404,
-0.26651009917259216,
-0.4055211842060089,
0.24564902484416962,
0.5733686685562134,
-0.767388641834259,
0.6027491688728333,
0.5129044055938721,
0.9844619631767273,
-0.13836245238780975,
0.18090863525867462,
-0.5307788848876953,
0.7223584651947021,
-0.10303059965372086,
0.7315567135810852,
-0.6416716575622559,
-0.22031795978546143,
-0.24994638562202454,
0.022402456030249596,
-0.09226736426353455,
-0.5121971964836121,
0.19245541095733643,
-0.6755441427230835,
0.38905516266822815,
-0.1671452671289444,
-0.6109870672225952,
-0.20534305274486542,
0.13761824369430542,
-0.8043107986450195,
1.2063186168670654,
0.5418192744255066,
-0.8675894737243652,
0.2758495509624481,
-0.7226355075836182,
-0.27466487884521484,
0.11772790551185608,
-0.7199059128761292,
-0.08586785942316055,
-0.1696578413248062,
0.6729736924171448,
0.4712072014808655,
-0.43988651037216187,
0.275644451379776,
-0.5849130749702454,
-0.1277298629283905,
-0.21015216410160065,
-0.058394644409418106,
0.8863570690155029,
0.3851868212223053,
-0.30697110295295715,
0.19828170537948608,
-0.6928765177726746,
-0.04334111884236336,
0.17949926853179932,
0.11391980201005936,
-0.35133200883865356,
-0.012557731941342354,
-0.23872418701648712,
0.5417673587799072,
0.10144871473312378,
-0.514104425907135,
0.5420010089874268,
-0.25751399993896484,
0.32624951004981995,
0.6958357095718384,
0.4332110583782196,
0.3974529206752777,
0.33188897371292114,
0.4576837420463562,
0.11147008836269379,
-0.022302839905023575,
0.0716378390789032,
-0.49868449568748474,
-0.3367493748664856,
-0.45940953493118286,
0.23602230846881866,
0.5961347818374634,
-1.1349842548370361,
-0.001431864919140935,
-0.15189699828624725,
-0.12095950543880463,
0.07636654376983643,
0.09520969539880753,
0.3157525658607483,
0.6264097690582275,
0.4315871000289917,
-0.20494294166564941,
-0.3387475609779358,
-0.7525928020477295,
-0.28729280829429626,
-0.24631460011005402,
-0.03364240378141403,
0.4907890856266022,
0.37063273787498474,
-0.07304584234952927,
1.116365671157837,
-1.0384286642074585,
-0.08846960216760635,
-0.495967298746109,
0.1912652850151062,
0.2552132308483124,
0.1710798442363739,
0.3699215054512024,
-0.7181782722473145,
-0.4687424302101135,
0.4015013873577118,
-1.4862507581710815,
0.054358940571546555,
-0.08452759683132172,
-0.38592031598091125,
-0.09353046864271164,
0.6833688020706177,
-0.6537481546401978,
0.7611616253852844,
-0.030725348740816116,
-0.14846540987491608,
0.49202167987823486,
-0.07940399646759033,
-0.24958379566669464,
-0.9181587100028992,
-0.14264200627803802,
0.47742024064064026,
-0.49502500891685486,
-0.5223667025566101,
0.04324962571263313,
-0.052258677780628204,
-0.15244655311107635,
-0.2458278387784958,
0.661270260810852,
-1.0852255821228027,
-0.4329105615615845,
0.02838403545320034,
0.4542364776134491,
-0.4024598300457001,
0.5424178838729858,
0.25546786189079285,
0.8229639530181885,
0.6135878562927246,
-0.47979143261909485,
0.5794535279273987,
0.39371874928474426,
-0.2166607528924942,
0.08717284351587296,
-0.34516972303390503,
0.21964748203754425,
-0.18090954422950745,
0.18744711577892303,
-0.9703527092933655,
-0.08852708339691162,
0.4263511896133423,
-0.0506451278924942,
0.38449349999427795,
-0.6022099852561951,
-0.665432870388031,
-0.18026874959468842,
-0.0006956562283448875,
0.3209588825702667,
0.3809567093849182,
-0.6967737674713135,
0.4580300748348236,
0.4781121611595154,
-0.3371565341949463,
-0.47623854875564575,
-0.2062755674123764,
-0.055253248661756516,
-0.1855994611978531,
-0.5454041957855225,
0.09401019662618637,
0.5375686883926392,
-0.5749841332435608,
0.19751325249671936,
-0.3015327751636505,
-0.1085214838385582,
-0.17610764503479004,
-0.09996215254068375,
0.5112518072128296,
-0.09542904794216156,
0.07868659496307373,
0.008706274442374706,
-0.14680811762809753,
0.24570687115192413,
-0.2071046233177185,
0.24302072823047638,
-0.18610583245754242,
-0.2564285099506378,
-0.17570549249649048,
0.18671995401382446,
0.26238909363746643,
-0.16925372183322906,
0.5109041929244995,
0.563187301158905,
-0.6871174573898315,
-0.2338070124387741,
-0.17758937180042267,
0.04940856620669365,
-0.3703226149082184,
0.29994893074035645,
-0.7394269108772278,
-0.6381446719169617,
0.5357025265693665,
-0.6866307854652405,
-0.07982892543077469,
0.29947832226753235,
0.4304085075855255,
0.11194105446338654,
1.0975141525268555,
0.7017661929130554,
-0.042664892971515656,
0.5813702344894409,
-0.42970308661460876,
0.5107492208480835,
-0.9051694869995117,
-0.38833844661712646,
-0.08027944713830948,
0.15908338129520416,
-0.7045401334762573,
-0.13057342171669006,
0.3997686207294464,
0.3630380630493164,
-0.23747693002223969,
0.2674333155155182,
-0.23678839206695557,
0.4304066598415375,
0.2062089592218399,
0.4061053991317749,
0.4705216586589813,
0.07219253480434418,
-0.20057052373886108,
0.24429884552955627,
-0.5037522315979004,
-0.8684594035148621,
0.8327924609184265,
0.26673033833503723,
0.8611383438110352,
0.25327175855636597,
0.5396900177001953,
0.11804383248090744,
0.622020423412323,
-0.660449743270874,
0.7558243274688721,
0.026895996183156967,
-0.49688485264778137,
-0.5394471883773804,
-0.7003353238105774,
-0.7452171444892883,
0.24331749975681305,
0.03930153697729111,
-1.554445743560791,
-0.03489284962415695,
-0.11179991066455841,
0.24811702966690063,
0.6847801208496094,
-0.7516815066337585,
0.8992586731910706,
-0.12722991406917572,
-0.7315058708190918,
0.23321394622325897,
-0.8785982728004456,
0.6972593069076538,
0.3837262690067291,
0.1493944376707077,
-0.29671308398246765,
0.04126373305916786,
0.4889973998069763,
-0.3655284643173218,
0.4723593294620514,
-0.2520504593849182,
-0.24590955674648285,
0.4860957860946655,
0.04377957433462143,
0.5826839208602905,
0.3663140535354614,
0.02167491242289543,
0.05076424777507782,
0.1996651589870453,
-0.35500574111938477,
-1.0118882656097412,
0.49482524394989014,
-0.5689701437950134,
-0.5027755498886108,
-0.4579037129878998,
-0.8141120672225952,
-0.5826151967048645,
0.3549572825431824,
-0.022361038252711296,
0.48310068249702454,
-0.2409065067768097,
-0.3527563810348511,
0.5159078240394592,
-0.11737576872110367,
0.3583351969718933,
-0.21026989817619324,
-0.4952039420604706,
-0.6742216944694519,
0.5748940110206604,
-0.04113372042775154,
0.44524186849594116,
0.4752565920352936,
-0.05976957082748413,
-0.549362063407898,
-0.25264739990234375,
-0.508129894733429,
0.545875072479248,
-1.0067222118377686,
-0.04041054844856262,
-0.5316475033760071,
-0.21361267566680908,
-0.221939355134964,
0.27361056208610535,
0.11947961151599884,
-0.4332873225212097,
-0.09513867646455765,
-0.190669983625412,
0.31077060103416443,
1.0643999576568604,
0.25492510199546814,
0.12506072223186493,
-0.7894934415817261,
0.5977194905281067,
0.1693103164434433,
0.2405337393283844,
0.0853874534368515,
0.19992928206920624,
-0.049674298614263535,
-0.07176075130701065,
-0.48350194096565247,
-1.1885571479797363,
0.2732914686203003,
-0.13302941620349884,
0.7422927021980286,
0.4771566390991211,
-0.2545902132987976,
0.8592421412467957,
-0.3350611925125122,
0.7524672150611877,
0.1783818155527115,
-0.848153293132782,
0.7673726081848145,
-0.5705565810203552,
-0.05208234116435051,
0.2710261940956116,
0.6291139125823975,
-0.09007347375154495,
-0.1760672926902771,
-1.044779658317566,
-0.7841600775718689,
0.6380042433738708,
0.47876274585723877,
-0.5201625823974609,
-0.16703066229820251,
0.6969099640846252,
-0.02614133432507515,
0.0946098268032074,
-0.6724343299865723,
-0.3689534366130829,
0.3908793330192566,
-0.2942178249359131,
0.08622875809669495,
-0.25262054800987244,
-0.107303187251091,
-0.5027653574943542,
0.5379306077957153,
-0.23489929735660553,
0.511734664440155,
0.23898902535438538,
-0.20380161702632904,
-0.048172544687986374,
0.27845537662506104,
0.08049312233924866,
1.2792021036148071,
-0.46970659494400024,
0.31602030992507935,
0.3629544675350189,
-0.20350965857505798,
0.13079872727394104,
0.12389402836561203,
0.033708274364471436,
-0.08455482870340347,
0.5984903573989868,
0.6084194779396057,
0.0014333445578813553,
-0.3351747989654541,
0.5177220106124878,
-0.08890584856271744,
0.05774599313735962,
0.030809296295046806,
-0.09232056140899658,
0.14515522122383118,
0.11764606088399887,
0.04530276358127594,
-0.4239438474178314,
0.17786481976509094,
-0.9066464304924011,
0.48927927017211914,
0.5478975772857666,
-0.4928974509239197,
-0.16390001773834229,
0.6999950408935547,
-0.14797934889793396,
0.11704473197460175,
0.9090079069137573,
-0.0162521805614233,
-0.1810477077960968,
0.5052562952041626,
0.8721981048583984,
0.8306410312652588,
0.22195787727832794,
0.13281673192977905,
0.45591622591018677,
0.029765931889414787,
-0.023561734706163406,
0.35780444741249084,
-0.3454535901546478,
-0.6362521052360535,
-0.5292709469795227,
-0.14781227707862854,
-0.5342147350311279,
0.17546924948692322,
-0.8456950783729553,
0.4543989896774292,
-0.3986629843711853,
-0.11197267472743988,
-0.22595106065273285,
-0.06152971833944321,
-0.5077043175697327,
0.3277696967124939,
0.12080459296703339,
0.9440620541572571,
-0.9052179455757141,
0.8672590851783752,
0.9272035360336304,
-0.7633806467056274,
-0.9154291749000549,
-0.05395957827568054,
-0.20648153126239777,
-0.6834332942962646,
0.6443755626678467,
-0.0022105209063738585,
-0.11778588593006134,
0.10424531996250153,
-0.6349919438362122,
-0.587570071220398,
1.2184771299362183,
0.5962870717048645,
-0.408246785402298,
-0.1752101182937622,
-0.06376675516366959,
0.4675634503364563,
-0.4660760760307312,
0.7631770968437195,
0.7439085841178894,
0.17015980184078217,
0.2101311832666397,
-0.5724144577980042,
0.33490562438964844,
-0.20077405869960785,
0.14768272638320923,
0.6415967345237732,
-0.458746999502182,
0.5799457430839539,
-0.24451425671577454,
-0.5339403748512268,
-0.17867155373096466,
0.8830599188804626,
0.40435510873794556,
0.5475528240203857,
0.39065057039260864,
0.5411807894706726,
0.8714579343795776,
-0.1296192854642868,
1.0745939016342163,
0.043693091720342636,
0.5433327555656433,
1.3344104290008545,
-0.3574506640434265,
0.5912401676177979,
0.5688447952270508,
-0.30885252356529236,
0.829368531703949,
0.9161622524261475,
0.24055345356464386,
0.46392902731895447,
0.04397452250123024,
-0.38407331705093384,
-0.2529369294643402,
0.13353264331817627,
-0.2603849172592163,
0.04561559110879898,
0.35312092304229736,
-0.559704601764679,
-0.6313780546188354,
-0.3610672652721405,
0.19658666849136353,
-0.10498445481061935,
-0.24652056396007538,
1.0771145820617676,
0.4472963213920593,
-0.5138257741928101,
0.21794837713241577,
-0.30772867798805237,
-0.20459440350532532,
-0.46395841240882874,
-0.5391436219215393,
0.010728470981121063,
0.06160281226038933,
-0.33434373140335083,
-0.983971893787384,
0.041848037391901016,
0.07345928251743317,
0.045234084129333496,
-0.02647683024406433,
1.182861328125,
-0.3323396146297455,
-0.2618732750415802,
0.4675877094268799,
1.0690457820892334,
0.2938191890716553,
0.029963215813040733,
-0.6835047602653503,
-0.36361950635910034,
0.10306701064109802,
-0.31347668170928955,
0.38044917583465576,
0.903887152671814,
-0.5663730502128601,
0.6976035237312317,
0.7116305232048035,
0.2736155092716217,
-0.2356836497783661,
0.3251260817050934,
1.1277756690979004,
-0.9054055213928223,
-0.17860670387744904,
-1.0759142637252808,
0.26361382007598877,
-0.5179903507232666,
0.015293091535568237,
0.7265671491622925,
0.6978771090507507,
0.8303345441818237,
-0.07223662734031677,
1.083755373954773,
-0.11040162295103073,
0.08506941795349121,
-0.6926020383834839,
0.16075779497623444,
-0.12749817967414856,
0.409349650144577,
-0.7505100965499878,
-1.1261463165283203,
-0.42508813738822937,
0.44704797863960266,
-0.8535281419754028,
0.1555752158164978,
1.0965638160705566,
0.5452947020530701,
-0.3597733676433563,
0.24066422879695892,
0.05196680873632431,
-0.07708141207695007,
0.7624010443687439,
0.722577691078186,
1.0056594610214233,
-0.4105563461780548,
0.4060746729373932,
-0.25418660044670105,
-0.47406572103500366,
0.6138928532600403,
-0.9739540219306946,
-1.018526554107666,
-0.25716227293014526,
-0.3490568995475769,
-0.266708642244339,
0.06245507672429085,
0.7018625140190125,
0.39027130603790283,
-0.5053746700286865,
-0.3777651786804199,
-0.4611891210079193,
0.38370800018310547,
-0.40189120173454285,
-0.3172294795513153,
0.664456307888031,
-0.42471858859062195,
-0.5388104319572449,
0.06526238471269608,
0.37730666995048523,
0.032685767859220505,
0.15590038895606995,
0.05989304929971695,
-0.6354034543037415,
-0.3274678587913513,
0.8366916179656982,
0.26611530780792236,
-0.4764522612094879,
-0.39487001299858093,
-0.5311076641082764,
0.10813385248184204,
0.2397511601448059,
0.8312423229217529,
-0.7152106761932373,
0.4581904411315918,
0.5888440012931824,
0.23247280716896057,
1.0417759418487549,
0.5631518959999084,
0.839166522026062,
-0.6207141280174255,
0.030578002333641052,
-0.08846220374107361,
0.4703068733215332,
0.1286475509405136,
-0.6448633670806885,
1.0891377925872803,
0.42989638447761536,
-0.37044334411621094,
-0.7302254438400269,
0.4411824941635132,
-1.0361106395721436,
-0.16298437118530273,
1.2299212217330933,
-0.3624034821987152,
-0.3370586037635803,
-0.28939613699913025,
-0.3773117661476135,
0.6367844939231873,
-0.16782550513744354,
0.26480650901794434,
0.641633927822113,
-0.9936929941177368,
-0.3850369453430176,
-0.6533969044685364,
0.4750424921512604,
-0.30412837862968445,
-1.3072739839553833,
0.05259648710489273,
0.4059440493583679,
0.34247562289237976,
-0.21552740037441254,
0.7600147724151611,
-0.49809175729751587,
0.030127638950943947,
-0.07614417374134064,
-0.11418136209249496,
-0.09242294728755951,
-0.28790193796157837,
0.12787331640720367,
0.2794645130634308,
0.07100844383239746,
-0.11333254724740982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00208v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00208v2
|
A Primer on the Inner Workings of Transformer-based Language Models
| 2024-04-30T21:20:17 | 2024-05-02T01:29:17 |
Javier Ferrando, Gabriele Sarti, Arianna Bisazza, Marta R. Costa-jussà
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid progress of research aimed at interpreting the inner workings of
advanced language models has highlighted a need for contextualizing the
insights gained from years of work in this area. This primer provides a concise
technical introduction to the current techniques used to interpret the inner
workings of Transformer-based language models, focusing on the generative
decoder-only architecture. We conclude by presenting a comprehensive overview
of the known internal mechanisms implemented by these models, uncovering
connections across popular approaches and active research directions in this
area.
|
[
-0.07178086787462234,
-0.6812685132026672,
0.3796471357345581,
-0.08811105042695999,
-0.0977298691868782,
0.09940449148416519,
-0.050371721386909485,
-0.0867023915052414,
-0.30319058895111084,
0.9715006947517395,
-0.5395499467849731,
0.04369954392313957,
-0.4830859899520874,
-0.010791298933327198,
-0.7756476998329163,
1.042418122291565,
0.07889444380998611,
0.08472852408885956,
-0.029356330633163452,
0.3497481346130371,
-0.41950032114982605,
-0.437467098236084,
-0.5051529407501221,
-0.5562687516212463,
-0.11321951448917389,
0.28693708777427673,
0.8022946119308472,
0.49617159366607666,
0.5119703412055969,
0.271529883146286,
-0.3956589698791504,
-0.3649531602859497,
-0.44821545481681824,
0.2746407389640808,
-0.13499291241168976,
-0.7974416017532349,
-0.15190652012825012,
-0.49321019649505615,
0.746213972568512,
0.7106385827064514,
0.009799255058169365,
-0.08489853888750076,
0.1653682440519333,
0.3917703330516815,
-0.4163590967655182,
0.3707631528377533,
-0.49790772795677185,
0.04687170311808586,
-0.5868831276893616,
-0.33629828691482544,
-0.8310878276824951,
-0.12273775786161423,
-0.003600749420002103,
0.06966421753168106,
0.6177158951759338,
-0.3297517001628876,
0.5667302012443542,
0.08710770308971405,
-0.5834201574325562,
-0.4386969804763794,
-1.1447794437408447,
0.6876348257064819,
-0.4030667543411255,
0.5844687819480896,
0.13367725908756256,
0.4103313684463501,
0.16263407468795776,
-0.8832892775535583,
-0.49293389916419983,
-0.2813596725463867,
-0.48875176906585693,
-0.17810803651809692,
-0.4243382513523102,
0.3192285895347595,
0.002489404985681176,
1.0216106176376343,
-0.3887776732444763,
0.045395493507385254,
-0.5555893182754517,
0.18994179368019104,
0.14193125069141388,
0.32253965735435486,
0.5028780102729797,
-0.1072167158126831,
-0.01792696677148342,
-0.15399886667728424,
-0.7788571715354919,
0.062054429203271866,
0.24373263120651245,
0.08863560855388641,
-0.24255234003067017,
0.6540776491165161,
0.209966242313385,
0.572519838809967,
0.2074991762638092,
0.13424919545650482,
-0.1487172394990921,
-0.4598679840564728,
-0.4316962659358978,
-0.2773107886314392,
0.6207386255264282,
0.022691715508699417,
0.21828576922416687,
-0.7544788718223572,
-0.5079852342605591,
0.2644334137439728,
0.5235162377357483,
-0.6125764846801758,
-0.4689752459526062,
0.19095362722873688,
-0.6117047071456909,
-0.4834190607070923,
0.10214424878358841,
-0.8327064514160156,
-0.19493840634822845,
-0.1808421015739441,
0.11888806521892548,
-0.36418816447257996,
-0.7463277578353882,
0.09352052956819534,
-0.11493554711341858,
0.6822004914283752,
-0.22363734245300293,
-1.038905143737793,
0.6108022332191467,
0.854429304599762,
0.7697449922561646,
-0.028248079121112823,
-0.11637300997972488,
-0.15368279814720154,
0.0726834088563919,
-0.22907479107379913,
0.986747682094574,
-0.7212086319923401,
-0.5471872091293335,
0.19859586656093597,
0.3316582143306732,
-0.15321199595928192,
-0.5728496313095093,
0.74151211977005,
-0.9569607377052307,
-0.07448038458824158,
0.01876336708664894,
-0.6915416717529297,
-0.15709885954856873,
-0.1667540967464447,
-0.9048478007316589,
0.6050995588302612,
0.20523671805858612,
-0.6049221158027649,
-0.05015139281749725,
-1.125792145729065,
-0.3342060446739197,
0.15045389533042908,
-0.03789175674319267,
0.000870032119564712,
0.6364555358886719,
0.10454954952001572,
0.05766952037811279,
-0.516071081161499,
0.36437729001045227,
0.3282308578491211,
-0.25710809230804443,
0.38089263439178467,
-0.5973932147026062,
0.9849203824996948,
0.21815253794193268,
-0.3307826817035675,
0.47800585627555847,
-0.7898786664009094,
-0.22841215133666992,
0.29443037509918213,
0.22518637776374817,
0.046691883355379105,
0.044441185891628265,
0.07398200035095215,
0.006879640277475119,
-0.024041181430220604,
-0.3533128798007965,
0.3437674343585968,
-0.4553975462913513,
0.48130542039871216,
0.43677085638046265,
-0.15188412368297577,
0.9656709432601929,
-0.06308048218488693,
0.8382447957992554,
-0.18935570120811462,
0.1915721744298935,
-0.9512087106704712,
-0.42292559146881104,
-1.0134671926498413,
0.05970508232712746,
0.02843143232166767,
0.5589550733566284,
-0.42344823479652405,
0.35467734932899475,
-0.32257550954818726,
-0.385903924703598,
-0.704092800617218,
-0.16781602799892426,
0.3838086724281311,
0.25565752387046814,
0.1869076043367386,
-0.23634213209152222,
-0.4327426850795746,
-0.8657271265983582,
0.0038158565293997526,
0.08000726252794266,
0.01229449175298214,
-0.25161615014076233,
0.46755996346473694,
-0.2931007444858551,
1.1037375926971436,
-0.38860443234443665,
0.011655931361019611,
-0.5282140970230103,
0.18888455629348755,
0.287152498960495,
0.4933229684829712,
0.4496849775314331,
-0.9085066914558411,
-0.384023517370224,
0.07548360526561737,
-0.6970527172088623,
-0.1699150651693344,
0.018096668645739555,
-0.07222364097833633,
-0.3418348729610443,
0.7981474995613098,
-0.703183114528656,
0.4154316782951355,
0.5790159702301025,
-0.3872362971305847,
0.5923828482627869,
0.07148191332817078,
-0.12593385577201843,
-0.643736720085144,
0.23176231980323792,
-0.15335822105407715,
0.252392053604126,
-1.2223082780838013,
0.5636891722679138,
0.26523080468177795,
-0.3199954032897949,
-0.1105138286948204,
0.5138498544692993,
-0.5935961008071899,
-0.1513175517320633,
-0.6851558685302734,
-0.46186187863349915,
-0.001033517182804644,
0.030576864257454872,
0.09361645579338074,
0.9905157685279846,
0.745508074760437,
-0.38440844416618347,
0.3524695336818695,
0.3617071807384491,
-0.42318910360336304,
0.3062637746334076,
-0.8434264063835144,
0.2483009696006775,
-0.4435358941555023,
0.2684820592403412,
-0.8070105910301208,
0.030022284016013145,
0.26414695382118225,
-0.1842058002948761,
0.5395867228507996,
-0.578342854976654,
-0.6687862873077393,
-0.3491547405719757,
0.3390395939350128,
0.3710443377494812,
0.5547267198562622,
-0.6002687215805054,
0.8523001074790955,
0.29502493143081665,
-0.06502217799425125,
-0.175912544131279,
-0.5936854481697083,
0.3014601469039917,
-0.07047685235738754,
-0.7613733410835266,
0.548035740852356,
-0.005158160347491503,
-0.7647364735603333,
0.06792893260717392,
0.11745929718017578,
-0.3515479266643524,
0.06727191060781479,
0.1992395520210266,
-0.017115769907832146,
-0.679093062877655,
-0.022495530545711517,
-0.1096586361527443,
-0.6373166441917419,
0.2742043137550354,
-0.2776073217391968,
0.5473595857620239,
-0.27963462471961975,
-0.29083138704299927,
-0.48583194613456726,
0.657855749130249,
0.8706673979759216,
-0.5710195302963257,
0.9838159084320068,
0.2157634049654007,
-0.00896693766117096,
-0.1372240036725998,
-0.4129358232021332,
-0.4256267547607422,
-0.52342289686203,
0.28931525349617004,
-0.815359890460968,
-0.5208906531333923,
0.6791207790374756,
-0.06017712503671646,
-0.006105631589889526,
0.49969056248664856,
0.5368450284004211,
0.3389457166194916,
0.8332785964012146,
1.3994797468185425,
0.13854041695594788,
0.5160638093948364,
-0.36377188563346863,
0.5600978136062622,
-0.7255851030349731,
-0.30970391631126404,
-0.5039998292922974,
0.39092132449150085,
-0.2613355219364166,
-0.4090619385242462,
0.2061401754617691,
0.36543041467666626,
-0.11567508429288864,
0.36080989241600037,
-0.4845041036605835,
0.5884743928909302,
0.37913164496421814,
-0.4022427797317505,
0.44553810358047485,
-0.2396748661994934,
-0.08381526917219162,
0.11665738373994827,
-0.7496776580810547,
-0.6311565637588501,
0.840837836265564,
0.5801483392715454,
0.889784038066864,
0.030448373407125473,
-0.020164690911769867,
0.05466008186340332,
0.5457809567451477,
-0.662601888179779,
0.20477145910263062,
-0.04239250347018242,
-0.6824790239334106,
0.14314910769462585,
-0.08145532757043839,
-0.7754659056663513,
0.5368903279304504,
0.1450181007385254,
-0.42682018876075745,
0.1250842660665512,
-0.003371213795617223,
0.006577788852155209,
0.8213427662849426,
-0.6785278916358948,
1.1192142963409424,
-0.36795347929000854,
0.30518385767936707,
-0.060116544365882874,
-0.562819242477417,
0.5046364068984985,
0.03470814973115921,
0.36417436599731445,
0.29657596349716187,
0.24187016487121582,
0.07979407161474228,
-0.08729881793260574,
0.9239752888679504,
0.004144810605794191,
-0.5812609195709229,
0.17585594952106476,
0.24084225296974182,
0.4755859076976776,
-0.5326880812644958,
-0.044719286262989044,
0.140280082821846,
-0.18028990924358368,
-0.13850650191307068,
-0.6021041870117188,
0.3075817823410034,
-0.5476043820381165,
-0.37431830167770386,
-0.14477641880512238,
-0.49636393785476685,
0.025946645066142082,
0.036930255591869354,
0.40631771087646484,
0.6982793211936951,
-0.32063987851142883,
0.21814824640750885,
0.6676701307296753,
-0.013442832045257092,
0.4478831887245178,
0.5143462419509888,
-0.1729745715856552,
-0.20187683403491974,
0.43324044346809387,
-0.3950612246990204,
0.29808634519577026,
0.9021394848823547,
0.04421931132674217,
-0.25725823640823364,
-0.6185135245323181,
-0.5591614842414856,
0.2000904679298401,
-1.0548450946807861,
0.05792633816599846,
-0.908054769039154,
-0.3277856111526489,
-0.3833487927913666,
-0.19122955203056335,
-0.39729180932044983,
0.019594041630625725,
-0.20507065951824188,
-0.17511750757694244,
0.09149785339832306,
1.1354033946990967,
0.12771056592464447,
0.8141101002693176,
-0.8451765775680542,
0.35435688495635986,
0.31550151109695435,
0.4562033712863922,
0.2780894935131073,
-0.4984283745288849,
-0.37362557649612427,
-0.07741986960172653,
-0.29196372628211975,
-1.0000275373458862,
0.29071834683418274,
0.09099199622869492,
0.5897310972213745,
0.47512614727020264,
-0.1632162630558014,
0.4711402654647827,
-0.6998395323753357,
0.7587249875068665,
-0.032856836915016174,
-1.048989176750183,
0.6018804311752319,
-0.17476363480091095,
0.1438685804605484,
0.04775663837790489,
0.08586200326681137,
-0.4774826765060425,
-0.269436240196228,
-0.4135902523994446,
-0.714236319065094,
0.6029247045516968,
0.15601389110088348,
0.3611040711402893,
0.009338424541056156,
0.3104608356952667,
0.16753269731998444,
0.010563354007899761,
-0.9623086452484131,
-0.5221259593963623,
-0.27773237228393555,
-0.09928344935178757,
-0.09839259833097458,
-0.4857266843318939,
-0.0849851742386818,
0.04294256493449211,
0.3916187584400177,
-0.303535133600235,
0.38257014751434326,
-0.2573128938674927,
-0.5222132205963135,
-0.3094616234302521,
0.47622576355934143,
0.3790745735168457,
0.7060665488243103,
-0.02453213930130005,
0.05434871464967728,
-0.18412655591964722,
-0.15706492960453033,
0.07017001509666443,
0.046246834099292755,
-0.29582679271698,
-0.03471815586090088,
0.35524457693099976,
1.1529752016067505,
0.4858610928058624,
-0.5457842946052551,
0.6041955947875977,
-0.06877367943525314,
0.3348954916000366,
-0.37994182109832764,
-0.13018445670604706,
-0.256706565618515,
0.46763959527015686,
0.6954364776611328,
0.06713339686393738,
0.06097261235117912,
-0.6050717234611511,
0.3994183838367462,
0.37941068410873413,
-0.5265260934829712,
-0.8320454359054565,
0.6377169489860535,
0.20859362185001373,
-0.22249409556388855,
0.6329079270362854,
0.05941534787416458,
-0.506472647190094,
0.50133216381073,
0.947139322757721,
1.2805752754211426,
-0.3062821924686432,
0.022096358239650726,
0.09898533672094345,
0.49464207887649536,
-0.022708304226398468,
-0.04499722644686699,
-0.1896834671497345,
-0.7441709637641907,
-0.8620895743370056,
-0.6614946126937866,
-0.4264661371707916,
0.14174601435661316,
-0.8038555979728699,
0.019404690712690353,
0.17289386689662933,
0.1259043961763382,
-0.06985089927911758,
-0.5103006958961487,
-0.4634028971195221,
0.04913483187556267,
0.22838129103183746,
0.9002947211265564,
-0.9116307497024536,
0.9987168908119202,
0.6108617186546326,
-0.5049579739570618,
0.025684304535388947,
0.3058137595653534,
-0.10081075131893158,
-0.8079850673675537,
0.8781863451004028,
-0.11385833472013474,
-0.33113300800323486,
0.07109773904085159,
-0.36552077531814575,
-0.9444946646690369,
0.5897341966629028,
0.2641788125038147,
-0.297200083732605,
-0.4169636070728302,
0.03182237967848778,
0.38860854506492615,
-0.35585540533065796,
0.4233378767967224,
0.6695016622543335,
0.39978355169296265,
-0.24139519035816193,
-0.9247807860374451,
-0.104060098528862,
-0.549462616443634,
0.13221079111099243,
0.39455923438072205,
-0.30615493655204773,
0.9476020932197571,
-0.11918262392282486,
-0.603135883808136,
0.31451669335365295,
0.9364036321640015,
-0.35696664452552795,
-0.24662820994853973,
0.29247725009918213,
0.33427998423576355,
0.12397680431604385,
-0.074053555727005,
1.1865822076797485,
-0.8830945491790771,
0.3091243803501129,
0.7743104696273804,
0.09687364101409912,
0.4242880642414093,
0.154804989695549,
-0.1808810830116272,
0.6645018458366394,
-0.1803969442844391,
-0.15883398056030273,
0.6529482007026672,
-0.002729639410972595,
-0.3569032549858093,
0.014536948874592781,
-0.032969821244478226,
-0.17334893345832825,
0.4179794192314148,
0.6002491116523743,
-0.4089576005935669,
-0.42529842257499695,
0.11130394786596298,
-0.16097959876060486,
-0.13158684968948364,
-0.1779385358095169,
0.8255214691162109,
0.11624738574028015,
-0.6160042881965637,
0.23055480420589447,
0.20811346173286438,
0.8743249177932739,
-0.6712652444839478,
-0.00030615527066402137,
-0.010659351944923401,
0.23886963725090027,
0.07173458486795425,
-0.9965082406997681,
0.744773805141449,
0.19577260315418243,
-0.48720160126686096,
-0.6110462546348572,
0.7841446399688721,
-0.3182791471481323,
-0.19523294270038605,
0.32373443245887756,
0.5465465188026428,
-0.21091021597385406,
-0.2411259114742279,
-0.45654842257499695,
0.328836053609848,
-0.15868942439556122,
0.15850092470645905,
-0.051103249192237854,
0.4937596619129181,
0.255779892206192,
0.5434714555740356,
0.5521372556686401,
-0.21035946905612946,
0.16019342839717865,
0.17843984067440033,
0.7194250822067261,
-1.0115301609039307,
-0.5266334414482117,
-0.7331725358963013,
0.7423826456069946,
0.3824845552444458,
-0.14407068490982056,
0.6638196110725403,
0.37928274273872375,
0.6512075066566467,
-0.11163195222616196,
0.8826964497566223,
-0.05706747993826866,
0.15789993107318878,
-0.4919866621494293,
0.5914684534072876,
-0.11094947159290314,
0.030869919806718826,
0.08572567254304886,
-0.6680974364280701,
-0.25006943941116333,
0.5786616206169128,
-0.06504356116056442,
-0.262670636177063,
0.5856510996818542,
0.8218843936920166,
-0.3046378493309021,
0.34462970495224,
0.1369318813085556,
0.38252726197242737,
0.43966612219810486,
0.11092599481344223,
1.1140155792236328,
-0.48507532477378845,
0.5002037882804871,
-0.3900076150894165,
-0.22632165253162384,
-0.24799005687236786,
-0.7156665921211243,
-0.7205202579498291,
-0.7328079342842102,
-0.14791475236415863,
-0.15198847651481628,
-0.13315194845199585,
0.32823145389556885,
0.7323381900787354,
-1.0235739946365356,
-0.43810218572616577,
-0.5795915126800537,
-0.026984281837940216,
-0.2528907358646393,
-0.3087407052516937,
0.2770847976207733,
-0.5556613802909851,
-0.5039463639259338,
0.7345150709152222,
0.2038516104221344,
0.027653133496642113,
-0.4239279627799988,
0.20090728998184204,
0.5444878339767456,
0.10937842726707458,
0.7043357491493225,
0.2839680016040802,
-0.9823573231697083,
0.27524837851524353,
0.18353776633739471,
0.07197416573762894,
0.25695472955703735,
1.5272884368896484,
-0.6292642951011658,
0.4577353894710541,
0.5010194778442383,
0.3985309898853302,
0.3877474367618561,
-0.4138105809688568,
0.9085819721221924,
-0.4317705035209656,
-0.10146306455135345,
0.26490476727485657,
0.3972048759460449,
0.48417720198631287,
-0.1047697365283966,
0.3127971291542053,
0.09153631329536438,
-0.44469067454338074,
-0.8729292750358582,
0.4572255313396454,
-0.46863096952438354,
-0.24442973732948303,
0.9698845148086548,
0.10251407325267792,
-0.1722932755947113,
-0.28932708501815796,
-0.08228140324354172,
0.26116684079170227,
0.08081494271755219,
0.31594231724739075,
0.3947826325893402,
0.0012548149097710848,
-0.6993478536605835,
-0.5267794132232666,
0.4041185975074768,
0.04142773896455765,
-0.610356867313385,
0.3597135543823242,
0.2685311436653137,
0.16728563606739044,
0.18811532855033875,
0.5781143307685852,
-0.3223218321800232,
-0.0669274851679802,
0.3273869454860687,
0.1182924211025238,
0.19534656405448914,
-0.47875431180000305,
-0.7264376282691956,
0.38279464840888977,
-0.09972348064184189,
0.2768018841743469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00204v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00204v1
|
General Purpose Verification for Chain of Thought Prompting
| 2024-04-30T21:15:17 | 2024-04-30T21:15:17 |
Robert Vacareanu, Anurag Pratik, Evangelia Spiliopoulou, Zheng Qi, Giovanni Paolini, Neha Anna John, Jie Ma, Yassine Benajiba, Miguel Ballesteros
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Many of the recent capabilities demonstrated by Large Language Models (LLMs)
arise primarily from their ability to exploit contextual information. In this
paper, we explore ways to improve reasoning capabilities of LLMs through (1)
exploration of different chains of thought and (2) validation of the individual
steps of the reasoning process. We propose three general principles that a
model should adhere to while reasoning: (i) Relevance, (ii) Mathematical
Accuracy, and (iii) Logical Consistency. We apply these constraints to the
reasoning steps generated by the LLM to improve the accuracy of the final
generation. The constraints are applied in the form of verifiers: the model
itself is asked to verify if the generated steps satisfy each constraint. To
further steer the generations towards high-quality solutions, we use the
perplexity of the reasoning steps as an additional verifier. We evaluate our
method on 4 distinct types of reasoning tasks, spanning a total of 9 different
datasets. Experiments show that our method is always better than vanilla
generation, and, in 6 out of the 9 datasets, it is better than best-of N
sampling which samples N reasoning chains and picks the lowest perplexity
generation.
|
[
-0.2892194986343384,
-0.8948953747749329,
1.1641864776611328,
-0.09313642233610153,
-0.12421438097953796,
-0.021710310131311417,
-0.3498803377151489,
-0.22297023236751556,
-0.20035269856452942,
0.8230901956558228,
-0.6498594880104065,
-0.48873820900917053,
-0.2983977198600769,
0.2567950189113617,
-0.3910658657550812,
0.7888508439064026,
-0.42089545726776123,
-0.29469001293182373,
-0.45218631625175476,
0.13505607843399048,
-0.3768966794013977,
-0.6339125037193298,
-0.41975030303001404,
-0.5784255862236023,
0.4495474696159363,
0.3424006402492523,
0.6361312866210938,
0.5927170515060425,
0.3233988881111145,
0.28723645210266113,
-0.3050139844417572,
0.8111284971237183,
-0.4118413031101227,
0.38004401326179504,
-0.6145337224006653,
-0.46744391322135925,
-0.38682985305786133,
-0.3662392497062683,
0.4093817472457886,
0.5401017665863037,
-0.1533769816160202,
0.1297304630279541,
0.0005883128615096211,
0.5159183144569397,
-0.7372484803199768,
-0.25939497351646423,
-0.7945595979690552,
-0.19729994237422943,
-0.014013810083270073,
-0.3279497027397156,
-0.5478084683418274,
-0.5959618091583252,
0.16640380024909973,
-0.4704410433769226,
0.09732287377119064,
0.225747749209404,
0.9961224794387817,
0.22764812409877777,
-0.6306893229484558,
-0.4970778822898865,
-0.9637037515640259,
0.6987828612327576,
-0.7031707763671875,
0.33566516637802124,
0.38446706533432007,
0.21031107008457184,
-0.47865596413612366,
-0.7926145792007446,
-0.6849295496940613,
-0.18078085780143738,
0.07807613164186478,
-0.2589256763458252,
-0.0630779042840004,
0.13653527200222015,
0.7276576161384583,
0.5456052422523499,
-0.2972353398799896,
-0.08110176026821136,
-0.1587350070476532,
-0.28762999176979065,
0.5022963881492615,
0.11764773726463318,
0.2597845494747162,
-0.0028052902780473232,
-0.2640325129032135,
-0.12450966984033585,
-1.196570873260498,
0.11325067281723022,
0.4355309009552002,
0.0032289547380059958,
0.30453598499298096,
0.614041268825531,
-0.4791364371776581,
0.8171620965003967,
0.09926645457744598,
-0.1973167508840561,
0.005675147753208876,
-0.5463361740112305,
-0.31521841883659363,
-0.25065580010414124,
0.4229300618171692,
0.26340988278388977,
0.48159781098365784,
0.04748070240020752,
-0.32785341143608093,
-0.04980986937880516,
0.44835352897644043,
-0.38253816962242126,
-0.1262882649898529,
0.35288164019584656,
0.01685500144958496,
-0.004594341851770878,
-0.15095044672489166,
-0.21469250321388245,
-0.27532318234443665,
-0.555554986000061,
0.31037062406539917,
-0.3847861588001251,
-0.05680012330412865,
0.3659810721874237,
0.009199771098792553,
0.22066356241703033,
0.623226523399353,
-0.8736472725868225,
0.1851460188627243,
0.8935219049453735,
0.4238411486148834,
0.07430251687765121,
-0.1962369829416275,
-0.46502503752708435,
0.352765828371048,
-0.4569739103317261,
0.8440617322921753,
-0.4446772634983063,
-0.06562937796115875,
0.09389440715312958,
-0.13060198724269867,
0.04046054556965828,
-0.4968693256378174,
0.7726724743843079,
-0.44888442754745483,
0.08335825800895691,
-0.7807398438453674,
-0.681054413318634,
-0.3177715539932251,
0.6686922907829285,
-0.34419870376586914,
0.8677027821540833,
-0.028078593313694,
-0.6946446299552917,
0.4478392004966736,
-0.3795548379421234,
-0.4459596872329712,
-0.016868801787495613,
-0.39162278175354004,
-0.057255759835243225,
0.3798640966415405,
0.481948584318161,
0.38288620114326477,
-0.593926191329956,
0.39713260531425476,
-0.2666171193122864,
-0.16955168545246124,
0.2760160267353058,
-0.25289666652679443,
0.6709819436073303,
0.24617475271224976,
-0.26757949590682983,
0.1340862661600113,
-0.7958439588546753,
0.4519348740577698,
-0.028279440477490425,
-0.3897128999233246,
-0.3017984926700592,
0.23123271763324738,
-0.6464981436729431,
0.18773993849754333,
-0.04158258065581322,
-0.29417362809181213,
0.4214567542076111,
-0.2922714650630951,
0.6454577445983887,
0.762534499168396,
0.3548847734928131,
0.055458348244428635,
-0.38035598397254944,
0.4570501446723938,
0.08397772908210754,
0.1801878660917282,
-0.24346774816513062,
-0.5125413537025452,
-1.0085052251815796,
0.0803401842713356,
0.23912301659584045,
0.536283016204834,
-0.8921436071395874,
0.6480953097343445,
-0.1267353594303131,
-0.14985321462154388,
-0.1125202402472496,
0.2668535113334656,
0.3502286970615387,
0.5221811532974243,
0.32329997420310974,
-0.06909196823835373,
-0.6661850810050964,
-0.6985113620758057,
-0.05149983614683151,
-0.43832510709762573,
-0.18210487067699432,
0.2532292604446411,
0.6705172061920166,
-0.36355480551719666,
0.907930850982666,
-0.16821858286857605,
0.62626713514328,
-0.23411718010902405,
-0.07623908668756485,
0.46321049332618713,
0.4547850787639618,
-0.06693053990602493,
-0.4779135286808014,
0.05646282061934471,
0.15463410317897797,
-0.947102427482605,
-0.1560979038476944,
-0.2413298785686493,
-0.26081740856170654,
-0.0000044445355342759285,
0.37818974256515503,
-0.46914955973625183,
0.42319682240486145,
0.3565281629562378,
-0.15020786225795746,
0.5964184999465942,
-0.4109402894973755,
0.18832401931285858,
-0.7137685418128967,
-0.08308451622724533,
-0.0025630458258092403,
-0.29369062185287476,
-0.73138427734375,
0.30629411339759827,
0.02698274701833725,
0.21859173476696014,
-0.1934937685728073,
0.13911287486553192,
-0.45470452308654785,
0.2824960947036743,
-0.1409093290567398,
0.1942654848098755,
0.2248333841562271,
0.16541647911071777,
-0.08749829232692719,
0.5954453945159912,
0.6209099292755127,
-1.027490496635437,
0.5667213797569275,
-0.0088378069922328,
-0.5701398253440857,
0.5631757378578186,
-0.8379662036895752,
0.4978768527507782,
-0.13715916872024536,
0.41220512986183167,
-1.007473111152649,
-0.21984992921352386,
0.12270225584506989,
0.01375070121139288,
-0.11180039495229721,
0.12393085658550262,
-0.7611362934112549,
-0.7624152898788452,
0.026632050052285194,
0.26929545402526855,
0.5312473177909851,
-0.7992622256278992,
0.7924925088882446,
0.026703692972660065,
0.2946852445602417,
-0.6098822355270386,
-0.4429450035095215,
0.0543912835419178,
-0.226833775639534,
-0.9425391554832458,
0.1460016369819641,
-0.1181614026427269,
-0.44932082295417786,
-0.3946646451950073,
-0.354768306016922,
0.1971379816532135,
0.11620163917541504,
0.07792561501264572,
0.18457451462745667,
-0.11242823302745819,
0.16189774870872498,
0.07526136189699173,
0.01091398298740387,
0.2108609676361084,
-0.5648582577705383,
0.43785423040390015,
-0.08802389353513718,
-0.6428528428077698,
-0.15834107995033264,
0.08240733295679092,
0.423235148191452,
-0.06334402412176132,
0.18993918597698212,
0.12948423624038696,
-0.4032615125179291,
-0.5420265793800354,
-1.07135808467865,
-0.137581467628479,
-0.49496990442276,
-0.10066352784633636,
-0.6702356338500977,
-1.0342904329299927,
0.6345972418785095,
-0.4130915701389313,
-0.035311367362737656,
0.2262449860572815,
0.5157794952392578,
0.09526287764310837,
0.988395094871521,
0.48115476965904236,
0.15731973946094513,
-0.2422359585762024,
-0.10317524522542953,
0.4254012107849121,
-0.9933573007583618,
-0.3187636733055115,
-0.41282156109809875,
-0.09365078061819077,
-0.4186471700668335,
-0.5604885220527649,
0.30795302987098694,
0.4628480076789856,
-0.29388394951820374,
0.2587969899177551,
-0.4460933208465576,
0.7671940326690674,
0.4666212797164917,
0.1601153165102005,
0.4277154207229614,
0.10551037639379501,
-0.7064248919487,
0.3011709153652191,
-0.601748526096344,
-0.9480992555618286,
0.8679565787315369,
0.4456019401550293,
0.7740581035614014,
0.06886035948991776,
0.7088214755058289,
0.00935598835349083,
0.03626364842057228,
-0.4421466290950775,
0.7850800156593323,
0.15193164348602295,
-0.7586572170257568,
-0.30956390500068665,
-0.4789268374443054,
-0.6206130385398865,
0.16048240661621094,
-0.015340838581323624,
-1.1716233491897583,
0.26787063479423523,
0.43641501665115356,
-0.3781653046607971,
0.3668619990348816,
-0.3040330410003662,
0.4425916373729706,
-0.27760598063468933,
-0.5087984800338745,
-0.269284725189209,
-0.44569769501686096,
0.6462989449501038,
0.11010625958442688,
0.06708499789237976,
0.12087993323802948,
0.18077826499938965,
0.16400781273841858,
-0.7979522347450256,
0.7637425661087036,
0.07595672458410263,
-0.6451003551483154,
0.6783565878868103,
0.07552214711904526,
0.9539834260940552,
-0.08145394921302795,
-0.08025846630334854,
-0.18195900321006775,
-0.26301151514053345,
-0.031090281903743744,
-0.794817328453064,
0.5597670078277588,
-0.3844744861125946,
-1.225693941116333,
-0.06713546812534332,
-0.5156259536743164,
-0.37625911831855774,
0.026725176721811295,
0.3157254457473755,
0.3114301860332489,
0.09407174587249756,
0.24839246273040771,
0.9241378903388977,
-0.0967753678560257,
0.00882341992110014,
0.04315485432744026,
-0.45930254459381104,
-0.5136731863021851,
0.5201261639595032,
-0.05568781495094299,
0.532154381275177,
0.35407450795173645,
0.3675972819328308,
-0.3964167535305023,
-0.6773656010627747,
-0.4130549132823944,
0.1362387239933014,
-1.1836886405944824,
-0.009950913488864899,
-0.5241889357566833,
-0.10088421404361725,
-0.33811047673225403,
-0.020650014281272888,
-0.050502579659223557,
-0.3224371671676636,
0.007733575068414211,
-0.1710847169160843,
0.25376883149147034,
0.9503985047340393,
0.003163508605211973,
0.019107285887002945,
-0.4179810583591461,
0.18706996738910675,
0.6432870626449585,
0.11040536314249039,
0.10776350647211075,
-0.5074445605278015,
0.089378222823143,
0.07213227450847626,
-0.3545101583003998,
-0.6196451783180237,
-0.2212475836277008,
-0.18140627443790436,
0.769436240196228,
0.5455339550971985,
-0.11756544560194016,
0.7792748808860779,
-0.48514237999916077,
0.8322583436965942,
0.16128306090831757,
-1.300718069076538,
0.9567535519599915,
-0.3296230435371399,
0.27890363335609436,
0.4125451147556305,
0.3559759557247162,
-0.3336501717567444,
-0.49476248025894165,
-0.6815507411956787,
-0.7269954681396484,
0.11144016683101654,
0.31597769260406494,
-0.036087874323129654,
-0.06112910807132721,
0.8260201811790466,
-0.15156739950180054,
0.07468022406101227,
-0.6781375408172607,
-0.03764395788311958,
-0.05142175778746605,
0.08791740238666534,
0.2332843393087387,
-0.38050615787506104,
-0.15326881408691406,
-0.27635881304740906,
0.6777260899543762,
-0.23165887594223022,
-0.2981642782688141,
0.37727290391921997,
0.05921531468629837,
-0.18372958898544312,
0.4464682340621948,
0.7640933990478516,
1.190909743309021,
0.007275942713022232,
0.4992254078388214,
0.5069722533226013,
-0.10743137449026108,
0.5324199795722961,
-0.5518770813941956,
-0.4218944013118744,
-0.12282656133174896,
0.4597051441669464,
0.8137229681015015,
-0.03876722231507301,
-0.48270469903945923,
0.18812842667102814,
0.10952210426330566,
-0.3074241578578949,
-0.06864730268716812,
0.5213083028793335,
0.05023068189620972,
0.2933034300804138,
0.16048650443553925,
-0.10994164645671844,
0.035844627767801285,
-0.5729441046714783,
0.050032805651426315,
0.29960936307907104,
0.08118206262588501,
-0.21356165409088135,
0.4346732199192047,
-0.02426234632730484,
-0.22717028856277466,
0.6944484710693359,
-0.25942182540893555,
-0.5867569446563721,
0.45014116168022156,
0.6276402473449707,
0.7765101790428162,
-0.1598075032234192,
0.10241641849279404,
0.5210373997688293,
0.5202699303627014,
-0.5611849427223206,
0.46066391468048096,
-0.2280338704586029,
-0.9400249123573303,
-0.7532248497009277,
-0.2867794334888458,
-0.7913420796394348,
0.2196165919303894,
-0.4573633074760437,
0.2839910686016083,
-0.6229009628295898,
-0.3725656270980835,
-0.23807327449321747,
-0.19457997381687164,
-0.5561319589614868,
0.31916141510009766,
0.2691093683242798,
0.7913484573364258,
-0.7005670666694641,
0.827921450138092,
0.6490294337272644,
-0.2513674199581146,
-0.9973610639572144,
-0.01028516050428152,
0.03211166337132454,
-0.751335084438324,
0.8224448561668396,
0.0895017459988594,
-0.34740668535232544,
-0.2251453846693039,
-0.7637525200843811,
-0.9166460633277893,
0.9711779356002808,
0.25696054100990295,
-0.9544490575790405,
-0.05693921446800232,
0.08424808830022812,
0.47572991251945496,
-0.507903516292572,
0.17912064492702484,
0.575517475605011,
0.6003469824790955,
0.4565120339393616,
-0.7140327095985413,
0.3128929138183594,
-0.1223406046628952,
0.30085450410842896,
-0.02476680465042591,
-0.05913986265659332,
0.8481429219245911,
-0.48616576194763184,
-0.34656020998954773,
0.058089375495910645,
0.7358826398849487,
0.9213024377822876,
0.12679217755794525,
0.7368369698524475,
0.6209105849266052,
1.323096752166748,
-0.2102157026529312,
1.18080472946167,
-0.11631100624799728,
0.13493387401103973,
1.1394354104995728,
-0.5524528622627258,
0.7041330933570862,
0.5839027762413025,
-0.15754497051239014,
0.8645005822181702,
0.3808942139148712,
-0.030908916145563126,
0.1718243956565857,
0.8300600051879883,
-0.18219000101089478,
-0.6108154654502869,
-0.1428600251674652,
-0.21735768020153046,
0.1504131555557251,
0.4787004590034485,
-0.32074788212776184,
-0.06574572622776031,
-0.1445486694574356,
0.0763503760099411,
0.16251146793365479,
-0.32494375109672546,
0.4899744391441345,
-0.05935187265276909,
-1.1062248945236206,
0.8330507278442383,
-0.20329539477825165,
0.34108901023864746,
-0.4403519630432129,
0.00200018216855824,
0.02782735601067543,
0.3608590066432953,
-0.14108306169509888,
-0.7399663925170898,
-0.026849621906876564,
0.1000402495265007,
-0.18598243594169617,
-0.2357705682516098,
0.8730260729789734,
-0.1946856826543808,
-0.4933362901210785,
0.05360087752342224,
0.5020933151245117,
0.15468904376029968,
0.04041937366127968,
-0.37276163697242737,
0.2855870723724365,
0.19572944939136505,
-0.2032754272222519,
-0.26359114050865173,
0.936007559299469,
-0.17529639601707458,
0.8101330995559692,
0.6268925070762634,
0.27536138892173767,
-0.10981369018554688,
0.3533647656440735,
0.8856066465377808,
-0.6699331402778625,
-0.22576335072517395,
-1.0769528150558472,
0.5144845247268677,
-0.24841780960559845,
-0.43876659870147705,
0.9123717546463013,
0.22905509173870087,
0.908191978931427,
0.07315359264612198,
0.7525472640991211,
0.17103849351406097,
0.2388273924589157,
-0.8877320885658264,
0.041616328060626984,
-0.18396812677383423,
0.572146475315094,
-0.18428801000118256,
-0.8772373199462891,
-0.375913143157959,
0.8396459221839905,
-0.5191401243209839,
0.12939909100532532,
1.006752371788025,
0.7037148475646973,
0.04967448115348816,
0.39164474606513977,
0.23751795291900635,
0.09532862156629562,
0.5469724535942078,
0.8184869289398193,
1.4196573495864868,
-0.28752538561820984,
0.16182661056518555,
-0.1865207701921463,
-0.09822287410497665,
0.10854175686836243,
-1.2638959884643555,
-1.1309529542922974,
-0.30582839250564575,
-0.547494113445282,
-0.5570421814918518,
0.03007352538406849,
0.8670806884765625,
0.6971381306648254,
-0.7846809029579163,
-0.3182760775089264,
-0.4498407244682312,
0.3793277144432068,
-0.29139161109924316,
-0.10642050206661224,
0.01251980196684599,
-0.5751517415046692,
-0.33339354395866394,
0.40523403882980347,
0.3888450562953949,
-0.04847019538283348,
-0.4942973256111145,
-0.07389567047357559,
-0.2600257992744446,
0.31118273735046387,
0.6148864030838013,
0.1321861743927002,
-1.2130308151245117,
-0.701574981212616,
-0.17155106365680695,
0.09781986474990845,
-0.04493575543165207,
1.1736549139022827,
-0.6147395372390747,
0.30631500482559204,
0.6941776871681213,
0.5123171806335449,
0.3502678871154785,
0.04026108980178833,
0.706476092338562,
-0.5708185434341431,
-0.4784995913505554,
0.08220551908016205,
0.6167441010475159,
0.28454849123954773,
-0.3904529809951782,
0.6626736521720886,
0.016964903101325035,
-0.7137999534606934,
-0.8749658465385437,
0.4947676360607147,
-0.7345078587532043,
-0.11938966065645218,
1.271582007408142,
-0.3295940160751343,
-0.3331417441368103,
-0.15304812788963318,
-0.04273079335689545,
-0.024272235110402107,
-0.006943676620721817,
0.5925057530403137,
1.0040045976638794,
-0.15126651525497437,
-0.07303725183010101,
-0.3299345374107361,
0.2938738167285919,
0.3110654354095459,
-0.9541175365447998,
0.33725449442863464,
0.4961620271205902,
0.23242609202861786,
0.46380341053009033,
0.4918387234210968,
0.02586989849805832,
0.10441813617944717,
-0.2794037461280823,
-0.1727481186389923,
0.08425430208444595,
-0.48189231753349304,
-0.12488238513469696,
0.2581263482570648,
0.12800286710262299,
0.2733984589576721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00201v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00201v1
|
SPAFIT: Stratified Progressive Adaptation Fine-tuning for Pre-trained Large Language Models
| 2024-04-30T21:07:32 | 2024-04-30T21:07:32 |
Samir Arora, Liangliang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Full fine-tuning is a popular approach to adapt Transformer-based pre-trained
large language models to a specific downstream task. However, the substantial
requirements for computational power and storage have discouraged its
widespread use. Moreover, increasing evidence of catastrophic forgetting and
overparameterization in the Transformer architecture has motivated researchers
to seek more efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods. Commonly known
parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods like LoRA and BitFit are typically
applied across all layers of the model. We propose a PEFT method, called
Stratified Progressive Adaptation Fine-tuning (SPAFIT), based on the
localization of different types of linguistic knowledge to specific layers of
the model. Our experiments, conducted on nine tasks from the GLUE benchmark,
show that our proposed SPAFIT method outperforms other PEFT methods while
fine-tuning only a fraction of the parameters adjusted by other methods.
|
[
-0.5237699151039124,
-1.102375864982605,
0.29258137941360474,
0.36930790543556213,
-0.15877702832221985,
-0.1342420130968094,
-0.6290823221206665,
-0.13011883199214935,
-0.14134344458580017,
0.6343607306480408,
-0.6074302196502686,
-0.3335149586200714,
-0.49147915840148926,
-0.0953650251030922,
-0.21307061612606049,
1.2330585718154907,
-0.1989274024963379,
-0.18769705295562744,
0.13119971752166748,
-0.013582025654613972,
-0.5798618197441101,
-0.25739118456840515,
-0.9394502639770508,
-0.4714590311050415,
0.29593273997306824,
0.4647098183631897,
0.6180287599563599,
0.37098249793052673,
0.44705459475517273,
0.3351510167121887,
-0.1836465448141098,
0.2748069167137146,
-0.758529543876648,
-0.0953316017985344,
-0.5175468921661377,
-0.3693012595176697,
-0.497727632522583,
-0.32949450612068176,
0.8366949558258057,
0.8227431178092957,
-0.3076464533805847,
0.379009872674942,
0.15326006710529327,
0.9138890504837036,
-0.6434398889541626,
-0.047333043068647385,
-0.7031216025352478,
0.041090045124292374,
-0.04103163257241249,
-0.20853291451931,
-0.45040562748908997,
-0.1582820862531662,
0.09659676253795624,
-0.6137422919273376,
0.4528980553150177,
-0.07393671572208405,
0.7571191191673279,
0.5704346299171448,
-0.29084110260009766,
0.14691630005836487,
-1.0161957740783691,
0.5977073311805725,
-0.6339685916900635,
0.45712336897850037,
0.4065149426460266,
0.25734785199165344,
-0.4119611978530884,
-0.6283699870109558,
-0.3381277918815613,
-0.34970003366470337,
-0.010001693852245808,
0.050900619477033615,
-0.14080071449279785,
0.16276392340660095,
0.25026166439056396,
0.36197206377983093,
-0.5544727444648743,
0.15843534469604492,
-0.11278031766414642,
-0.07902293652296066,
0.34206584095954895,
-0.2152630090713501,
-0.05858606472611427,
0.4159826338291168,
-0.3387332260608673,
-0.0061522177420556545,
-0.6408341526985168,
0.04544373229146004,
0.0979725643992424,
0.47432443499565125,
-0.08373620361089706,
0.32640719413757324,
-0.2937810719013214,
0.8569617867469788,
0.6242536306381226,
-0.0862143412232399,
0.20265629887580872,
-0.22164218127727509,
-0.3758556544780731,
-0.05299048125743866,
0.42563146352767944,
-0.11773795634508133,
0.4237263798713684,
-0.2776840031147003,
-0.29583004117012024,
-0.30861902236938477,
0.37649276852607727,
-0.6487164497375488,
-0.33930906653404236,
-0.1708640456199646,
-0.1610250025987625,
0.044008586555719376,
-0.19921156764030457,
-0.46984803676605225,
-0.24244895577430725,
-0.4063757359981537,
0.8431159257888794,
-0.41948404908180237,
-0.33500561118125916,
0.40775418281555176,
0.1242884173989296,
0.25508853793144226,
0.3146879971027374,
-0.8312473297119141,
0.43089017271995544,
0.7555360794067383,
0.8046578168869019,
-0.17812520265579224,
-0.5818720459938049,
-0.7939702272415161,
0.06078580766916275,
-0.2919972836971283,
1.127126693725586,
-0.6523319482803345,
-0.04551727697253227,
-0.18150977790355682,
0.3578869700431824,
-0.4856888949871063,
-0.6006259918212891,
0.5457196831703186,
-0.3888362646102905,
0.12612959742546082,
-0.04702211543917656,
-0.34448301792144775,
-0.09606850147247314,
-0.014031177386641502,
-0.4756488502025604,
1.2971209287643433,
0.47628557682037354,
-0.49216797947883606,
0.24773526191711426,
-0.6420401334762573,
-0.733126163482666,
-0.14346115291118622,
0.4098582863807678,
-0.6798112988471985,
0.4773256182670593,
0.19964170455932617,
0.35606035590171814,
-0.15348632633686066,
0.3751448094844818,
-0.11967185884714127,
-0.6260696053504944,
-0.0576121024787426,
-0.28011882305145264,
0.3263225853443146,
0.011921516619622707,
-0.6306002140045166,
0.2544611394405365,
-0.6036456227302551,
-0.3548019528388977,
-0.04571331664919853,
-0.2909700274467468,
-0.22661283612251282,
-0.1372041553258896,
-0.10268133878707886,
-0.02008339762687683,
0.176831915974617,
-0.29035136103630066,
0.2771454453468323,
-0.6668441891670227,
0.4332371652126312,
0.864253580570221,
0.0022850388195365667,
0.7706356644630432,
-0.24232691526412964,
0.36097392439842224,
0.030126016587018967,
0.16029120981693268,
-0.03411273658275604,
-0.15615518391132355,
-1.1413321495056152,
-0.22471322119235992,
0.5948241353034973,
0.49623438715934753,
-0.6946118474006653,
0.5745401382446289,
-0.25506463646888733,
-0.8120022416114807,
-0.3853610157966614,
0.09980148077011108,
0.2898111343383789,
0.5651434659957886,
0.4199627637863159,
-0.23093651235103607,
-0.119792141020298,
-1.0002999305725098,
-0.3384990990161896,
0.26166996359825134,
-0.21484574675559998,
0.20415465533733368,
0.45799437165260315,
-0.13455107808113098,
0.6813763976097107,
-0.48326176404953003,
-0.4540240466594696,
-0.036218125373125076,
0.11077900230884552,
0.44286832213401794,
0.5208320617675781,
0.6500831246376038,
-0.7030084729194641,
-0.5523972511291504,
0.18126074969768524,
0.05007878690958023,
-0.1580664962530136,
-0.25566744804382324,
-0.30696219205856323,
-0.038275282829999924,
0.35778120160102844,
-0.5904401540756226,
-0.05777156352996826,
0.7123798727989197,
-0.5718302130699158,
0.41363245248794556,
-0.4838983118534088,
0.23920372128486633,
-0.858347475528717,
0.06617199629545212,
0.10806885361671448,
-0.38523516058921814,
-0.8555840849876404,
0.027190571650862694,
0.1964571177959442,
-0.18427042663097382,
-0.39913874864578247,
0.3637547791004181,
-0.29812783002853394,
0.15037138760089874,
-0.22707201540470123,
-0.08575865626335144,
-0.1104070171713829,
0.6719147562980652,
0.2515742778778076,
0.9335333108901978,
0.5466976165771484,
-0.5349191427230835,
0.040809765458106995,
-0.03956872224807739,
-0.18262749910354614,
0.33103054761886597,
-0.6007353067398071,
0.2196323275566101,
-0.2481003850698471,
0.27836817502975464,
-0.9604212641716003,
-0.06653209030628204,
0.07519648224115372,
0.07590482383966446,
0.3527746796607971,
-0.28028011322021484,
-0.28892743587493896,
-0.03479001298546791,
-0.2179499864578247,
0.3678315281867981,
0.46847933530807495,
-0.40619149804115295,
0.9401049017906189,
0.3837421238422394,
-0.29895511269569397,
-0.26670411229133606,
-0.3213579058647156,
-0.2867797613143921,
-0.3589758276939392,
-0.41478145122528076,
0.41917476058006287,
-0.10784503072500229,
0.40481138229370117,
-0.3779069185256958,
-0.4313156306743622,
-0.14256814122200012,
0.28898173570632935,
0.13129770755767822,
0.007322836201637983,
-0.489755243062973,
0.032363858073949814,
0.21041220426559448,
-0.31175488233566284,
-0.5002336502075195,
-0.2619546055793762,
0.6983533501625061,
-0.2781795859336853,
-0.24561789631843567,
-0.12422271072864532,
0.24115817248821259,
0.4455135762691498,
-0.34185007214546204,
0.8310614228248596,
0.9353979825973511,
-0.44316744804382324,
-0.49877700209617615,
-0.7823733687400818,
-0.1100744754076004,
-0.5375820398330688,
0.46327221393585205,
-0.515705943107605,
-1.271194338798523,
0.4583216607570648,
-0.6129465103149414,
0.0028932522982358932,
0.47496259212493896,
0.6181586384773254,
0.02621135115623474,
0.7647168636322021,
1.0149973630905151,
-0.082642562687397,
0.7902182340621948,
0.00826751533895731,
0.30054232478141785,
-0.5228822231292725,
0.14322489500045776,
-0.8104366660118103,
-0.3774334788322449,
-0.4629702866077423,
-0.4536353051662445,
0.25245893001556396,
0.40669217705726624,
-0.6241177916526794,
0.6845174431800842,
-0.6314035058021545,
0.6899041533470154,
0.4022884666919708,
0.17977912724018097,
0.23210936784744263,
0.13134858012199402,
0.392551451921463,
0.14761006832122803,
-0.6761954426765442,
-0.08043118566274643,
0.5110986828804016,
0.4505198299884796,
0.6404799818992615,
-0.08331245929002762,
0.43771547079086304,
0.19024991989135742,
0.31706365942955017,
-0.5989159345626831,
0.2944624722003937,
-0.6068069934844971,
-0.43030253052711487,
-0.47577205300331116,
-0.4154638946056366,
-0.6649431586265564,
0.1022920310497284,
-0.21075530350208282,
-0.648529052734375,
0.29076650738716125,
0.3354075849056244,
-0.4712342619895935,
0.09869083762168884,
-0.9347663521766663,
0.9973756074905396,
-0.027133122086524963,
-0.08909062296152115,
-0.263240247964859,
-0.3044210970401764,
-0.0732119232416153,
-0.5496576428413391,
0.2935047447681427,
-0.293865442276001,
-0.01004660502076149,
0.7566669583320618,
0.0068360138684511185,
0.8695892095565796,
-0.4060181677341461,
-0.20315979421138763,
-0.10259462893009186,
0.16920335590839386,
0.821570098400116,
-0.0903473049402237,
-0.17386208474636078,
0.3379127085208893,
0.1065250113606453,
-0.5144965052604675,
-0.4464030861854553,
0.6815207004547119,
-0.7365908622741699,
-0.5829800963401794,
-0.022952988743782043,
-0.3343549072742462,
-0.49691042304039,
0.38576626777648926,
0.24698661267757416,
0.17700634896755219,
-0.11429430544376373,
0.2903587520122528,
0.8197961449623108,
-0.19881829619407654,
0.13863436877727509,
0.6466854214668274,
0.2323513627052307,
-0.22133080661296844,
0.9723526239395142,
0.17943474650382996,
0.09756577014923096,
0.5296671390533447,
0.246855691075325,
-0.010980208404362202,
-0.7171227335929871,
-0.29582300782203674,
0.36677950620651245,
-0.3747752904891968,
-0.4076205790042877,
-0.27570414543151855,
-0.21356283128261566,
-0.32642099261283875,
-0.44065073132514954,
-0.8099660873413086,
-0.32165807485580444,
-0.1702505648136139,
0.16667218506336212,
0.35526400804519653,
0.4553090035915375,
0.2379767745733261,
0.544842004776001,
-0.6204329133033752,
0.5161214470863342,
0.2081427276134491,
0.7316604256629944,
-0.3113817274570465,
-0.8854629397392273,
-0.3819240927696228,
-0.007924719713628292,
-0.1619735062122345,
-0.4182214140892029,
0.07498528063297272,
0.8919619917869568,
0.5306482911109924,
0.04830455034971237,
0.08439341932535172,
1.0435371398925781,
-0.7834240198135376,
0.6614771485328674,
-0.02277374267578125,
-0.9776979684829712,
0.6551370024681091,
-0.3280671238899231,
0.42071014642715454,
0.6334720253944397,
0.2562519609928131,
-0.2275913506746292,
-0.2914905250072479,
-0.3555995225906372,
-0.8693383932113647,
0.523087203502655,
0.0077586048282682896,
0.36735767126083374,
0.3079966604709625,
0.6163440942764282,
0.47566890716552734,
-0.03313293680548668,
-0.5367815494537354,
-0.0009436190593987703,
-0.14876005053520203,
-0.15918388962745667,
-0.39222338795661926,
-0.17767854034900665,
-0.05331237614154816,
-0.3215857148170471,
0.7037644386291504,
-0.35063445568084717,
0.11915718764066696,
0.06263063848018646,
-0.35578596591949463,
-0.4050571918487549,
0.3416183590888977,
0.553743839263916,
0.6000712513923645,
-0.05055250599980354,
0.08876719325780869,
0.7127571702003479,
-0.50608229637146,
0.15769174695014954,
0.13349485397338867,
-0.15108709037303925,
-0.20255370438098907,
0.3675800859928131,
0.9703615307807922,
0.533608615398407,
-0.47543615102767944,
0.4395678639411926,
-0.02630012296140194,
-0.32623904943466187,
-0.2556133270263672,
0.43050524592399597,
0.08259421586990356,
0.540000319480896,
0.2602998912334442,
0.2697509229183197,
-0.013537045568227768,
-0.20854619145393372,
0.26656946539878845,
0.25047239661216736,
-0.42833906412124634,
-0.3968389332294464,
0.3739810585975647,
0.07032754272222519,
-0.4066508412361145,
0.22013536095619202,
0.19656187295913696,
-0.1883808821439743,
0.20498794317245483,
0.6826119422912598,
0.8405835628509521,
-0.3914353847503662,
0.17723236978054047,
0.21725934743881226,
0.27606648206710815,
-0.4516192078590393,
-0.15235640108585358,
-0.20307807624340057,
-0.5938295722007751,
-0.8234313726425171,
-1.11394202709198,
-0.18398277461528778,
0.11567221581935883,
-0.45599430799484253,
0.29135048389434814,
-0.3828957676887512,
-0.32163405418395996,
0.08159095048904419,
-0.027721654623746872,
-0.7195386290550232,
0.0562286451458931,
0.1380005180835724,
1.3351322412490845,
-1.1491144895553589,
0.912585437297821,
0.8460311889648438,
0.08905297517776489,
-0.7037330269813538,
-0.003092129249125719,
-0.5901097655296326,
-0.6372271180152893,
0.13462844491004944,
-0.18054728209972382,
-0.18504369258880615,
0.3389894664287567,
-0.2689216732978821,
-0.8621051907539368,
0.9017356038093567,
0.8722788095474243,
-0.6952995657920837,
-0.13313604891300201,
0.05790012702345848,
0.6392802000045776,
-0.21554720401763916,
-0.00008255344437202439,
0.9733965396881104,
0.5227597951889038,
-0.04930475726723671,
-1.3822101354599,
-0.0021112982649356127,
-0.11113564670085907,
0.12745073437690735,
0.37647268176078796,
-0.7593293190002441,
0.606819212436676,
0.1882684975862503,
-0.015204543247818947,
-0.13493035733699799,
0.5417963266372681,
-0.029180768877267838,
-0.05335168167948723,
0.7695995569229126,
0.4450521767139435,
0.5522375106811523,
-0.19057540595531464,
0.5420021414756775,
-0.10330658406019211,
0.7029476165771484,
1.0357636213302612,
0.016522496938705444,
0.9118788838386536,
0.3969198167324066,
-0.2500517666339874,
0.34787553548812866,
0.6710445284843445,
-0.06867161393165588,
0.7155271172523499,
-0.016190873458981514,
-0.07589276134967804,
-0.5852369070053101,
0.08106118440628052,
-0.3495417833328247,
0.33843520283699036,
0.28308555483818054,
-0.06733960658311844,
-0.33813348412513733,
0.2487480640411377,
-0.1114998534321785,
-0.11173531413078308,
-0.4736926555633545,
1.060892105102539,
0.040956806391477585,
-0.7869943976402283,
0.9464459419250488,
-0.01013542152941227,
0.6446760892868042,
-0.6030113101005554,
0.07243139296770096,
-0.19511064887046814,
0.4191246032714844,
-0.19811423122882843,
-0.609981119632721,
0.221570685505867,
-0.13658717274665833,
-0.0998023971915245,
-0.23435577750205994,
0.9606887102127075,
-0.4740722179412842,
-0.42896702885627747,
0.21307408809661865,
0.26449280977249146,
-0.162364661693573,
-0.3455590605735779,
-0.7112460732460022,
-0.010331024415791035,
0.01908533275127411,
-0.8074765801429749,
0.5007776021957397,
0.44302159547805786,
-0.09006194770336151,
0.5742914080619812,
0.600978672504425,
0.24945200979709625,
-0.11218364536762238,
0.1200939267873764,
1.0847513675689697,
-0.5478819608688354,
-0.4505120515823364,
-0.6822214126586914,
0.7124421000480652,
0.21854735910892487,
-0.2861923575401306,
0.44988149404525757,
0.29505953192710876,
0.8165396451950073,
-0.2866283059120178,
0.4968605041503906,
0.10342583060264587,
0.39931339025497437,
-0.5331990718841553,
0.6341168284416199,
-0.5163873434066772,
0.02230810932815075,
-0.3080415725708008,
-1.3199092149734497,
-0.43258485198020935,
0.734968900680542,
-0.46700334548950195,
-0.048623282462358475,
0.49125611782073975,
0.8895911574363708,
-0.5254339575767517,
0.000500036112498492,
0.3061232566833496,
0.37194058299064636,
0.11991707980632782,
0.49662166833877563,
0.48159530758857727,
-0.38376566767692566,
0.35071223974227905,
-0.3349492847919464,
-0.5963339805603027,
-0.19759562611579895,
-0.9509226679801941,
-0.9392746686935425,
-0.6732511520385742,
-0.32052356004714966,
-0.0655864030122757,
0.25681251287460327,
0.6938306093215942,
0.8327942490577698,
-1.1068439483642578,
0.017385398969054222,
0.005740937776863575,
-0.22211235761642456,
-0.3809439241886139,
-0.14956188201904297,
0.5339571833610535,
-0.3500576913356781,
-0.48219552636146545,
0.45280033349990845,
0.39197906851768494,
-0.24520108103752136,
0.013747192919254303,
0.015294005163013935,
0.0837484672665596,
0.03642317280173302,
0.7235051393508911,
0.13756364583969116,
-0.35174471139907837,
-0.6899240612983704,
-0.03880460560321808,
0.26606035232543945,
0.08314204216003418,
0.9009369611740112,
-0.6537221074104309,
0.09249743074178696,
0.49385136365890503,
0.5964220762252808,
0.8185828328132629,
0.12924684584140778,
0.5332250595092773,
-0.80316561460495,
0.2594582736492157,
0.11458970606327057,
0.28346046805381775,
0.09531877934932709,
-0.25431403517723083,
0.40059682726860046,
-0.011358127929270267,
-0.7245848774909973,
-0.8604776859283447,
0.17298324406147003,
-0.9631632566452026,
-0.300542950630188,
1.0217735767364502,
-0.11627117544412613,
-0.314241886138916,
-0.17566411197185516,
-0.4279807507991791,
0.3122744858264923,
-0.2539898455142975,
0.8189780712127686,
0.4348784387111664,
-0.11055107414722443,
-0.26308879256248474,
-0.3861273527145386,
0.5275853872299194,
0.2937030494213104,
-0.5178099870681763,
0.36956313252449036,
0.10221830755472183,
0.551382839679718,
0.13811738789081573,
0.6596938967704773,
0.18382194638252258,
0.18089978396892548,
-0.18321853876113892,
-0.3273904323577881,
-0.054500773549079895,
-0.4419356882572174,
-0.34366336464881897,
0.3487880229949951,
0.2979459762573242,
0.29534754157066345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00200v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00200v1
|
In-Context Learning with Long-Context Models: An In-Depth Exploration
| 2024-04-30T21:06:52 | 2024-04-30T21:06:52 |
Amanda Bertsch, Maor Ivgi, Uri Alon, Jonathan Berant, Matthew R. Gormley, Graham Neubig
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As model context lengths continue to increase, the number of demonstrations
that can be provided in-context approaches the size of entire training
datasets. We study the behavior of in-context learning (ICL) at this extreme
scale on multiple datasets and models. We show that, for many datasets with
large label spaces, performance continues to increase with hundreds or
thousands of demonstrations. We contrast this with example retrieval and
finetuning: example retrieval shows excellent performance at low context
lengths but has diminished gains with more demonstrations; finetuning is more
data hungry than ICL but can sometimes exceed long-context ICL performance with
additional data. We use this ICL setting as a testbed to study several
properties of both in-context learning and long-context models. We show that
long-context ICL is less sensitive to random input shuffling than short-context
ICL, that grouping of same-label examples can negatively impact performance,
and that the performance boosts we see do not arise from cumulative gain from
encoding many examples together. We conclude that although long-context ICL can
be surprisingly effective, most of this gain comes from attending back to
similar examples rather than task learning.
|
[
-0.4850805997848511,
-0.794592022895813,
0.4678209125995636,
0.17068275809288025,
-0.26509687304496765,
-0.1856936663389206,
-0.3791053295135498,
-0.7325074076652527,
-0.4298313558101654,
0.21030233800411224,
-0.2696617543697357,
-0.26437515020370483,
-0.42551884055137634,
-0.08218170702457428,
-0.6137183308601379,
1.1722890138626099,
-0.024252306669950485,
0.07231505960226059,
-0.705507755279541,
-0.4773956537246704,
-0.35743024945259094,
-0.814828097820282,
-0.699556291103363,
-0.572732150554657,
0.564952552318573,
0.5986491441726685,
0.2726552486419678,
0.5541334748268127,
0.2191011607646942,
0.11840628832578659,
-0.12593939900398254,
0.015377632342278957,
-0.8753262162208557,
0.11899349838495255,
-0.11489701271057129,
-0.14930908381938934,
0.0024768414441496134,
-0.008712664246559143,
1.0485143661499023,
0.9054253101348877,
0.18571552634239197,
0.14510376751422882,
0.38850000500679016,
0.627228319644928,
-0.5305320620536804,
0.006887624505907297,
-0.19227483868598938,
0.06307526677846909,
-0.21273548901081085,
0.11779153347015381,
-0.5942140221595764,
0.017529554665088654,
0.4844493865966797,
-0.4558335840702057,
-0.024713678285479546,
0.09931020438671112,
0.3081834018230438,
0.07922568917274475,
-0.8196104168891907,
-0.4333176910877228,
-0.7835850715637207,
0.9088290333747864,
-0.5594245195388794,
0.4798890948295593,
0.3355962932109833,
0.38328874111175537,
-0.06390290707349777,
-0.8566275238990784,
-0.27225175499916077,
-0.44168925285339355,
0.0010578179499134421,
-0.066416896879673,
0.15292638540267944,
0.04330093041062355,
0.7576720118522644,
0.12913638353347778,
-0.31242653727531433,
0.4988003373146057,
-0.39177677035331726,
0.28546398878097534,
0.5545858144760132,
0.09983417391777039,
-0.19011256098747253,
0.3023568093776703,
-0.6131871938705444,
-0.37584754824638367,
-0.9757239818572998,
0.532800018787384,
-0.020999418571591377,
0.24966216087341309,
-0.08250941336154938,
0.2966397702693939,
-0.20073038339614868,
0.8462713360786438,
-0.06280172616243362,
-0.19090256094932556,
0.10506521165370941,
-0.13669036328792572,
-0.3267957866191864,
0.09620506316423416,
0.3426799476146698,
0.33823052048683167,
-0.1109064593911171,
-0.2824489176273346,
-0.3531606197357178,
-0.3969091773033142,
-0.09092027693986893,
-1.0772861242294312,
0.02626853995025158,
0.028562253341078758,
-0.483385294675827,
-0.07957938313484192,
0.06074663996696472,
-0.6071767807006836,
-0.39381954073905945,
-0.6892624497413635,
0.7895716428756714,
-0.48521319031715393,
0.13765351474285126,
0.22750689089298248,
-0.24426981806755066,
0.3050059676170349,
0.24337807297706604,
-0.6523429751396179,
0.6950923800468445,
0.7231460809707642,
0.7600942850112915,
-0.4707871079444885,
-0.49727168679237366,
-0.6991303563117981,
0.10386310517787933,
-0.31962674856185913,
0.3968118131160736,
-0.6009446978569031,
-0.4729819893836975,
0.004456294700503349,
-0.09890376031398773,
0.11292679607868195,
-0.8349791169166565,
0.09035443514585495,
-0.6734204292297363,
0.05267666280269623,
-0.35674378275871277,
-0.9674660563468933,
-0.14029991626739502,
0.21456460654735565,
-0.5863745212554932,
1.0692462921142578,
0.08331848680973053,
-0.3901076316833496,
0.8955057263374329,
-1.0050389766693115,
-0.6524226069450378,
-0.12466352432966232,
-0.23104508221149445,
-0.369947612285614,
0.07314282655715942,
-0.08243995159864426,
0.8105630278587341,
-0.13664907217025757,
0.2681255042552948,
-0.5154763460159302,
-0.7953643202781677,
0.45508262515068054,
-0.4227396547794342,
0.5765926837921143,
0.029846515506505966,
-0.4059281349182129,
-0.04258999973535538,
-0.7051108479499817,
-0.1023561954498291,
-0.11791864037513733,
-0.5125619769096375,
-0.5916568636894226,
0.11373651772737503,
0.059217989444732666,
0.38428589701652527,
-0.08873149752616882,
-0.5473121404647827,
0.3450019061565399,
-0.07591621577739716,
0.5082203149795532,
0.5758468508720398,
0.03920413926243782,
0.4897078275680542,
-0.2935806214809418,
0.14636021852493286,
0.3384532034397125,
0.14313805103302002,
-0.17611587047576904,
-0.0009534457931295037,
-0.5107927918434143,
-0.2113843560218811,
0.3286389410495758,
-0.08736306428909302,
-0.5804615616798401,
0.027526795864105225,
-0.28765806555747986,
-0.09491223096847534,
0.0013349102810025215,
0.09458393603563309,
0.44063788652420044,
0.7360849976539612,
0.5802203416824341,
-0.27444350719451904,
-0.07984472811222076,
-0.9609856009483337,
-0.1265002191066742,
0.3480873107910156,
-0.12464034557342529,
0.6249842643737793,
0.8099719285964966,
-0.09831926971673965,
0.9960574507713318,
-0.26664817333221436,
0.05078652501106262,
-0.11470438539981842,
0.09516928344964981,
0.13562655448913574,
0.5004430413246155,
0.6094489693641663,
-0.9118525981903076,
-0.5614379048347473,
-0.0347253680229187,
-0.6318269968032837,
0.40378686785697937,
-0.21739695966243744,
0.11340635269880295,
0.0802660807967186,
0.7055186033248901,
-0.17858578264713287,
0.4823555648326874,
0.1707478016614914,
-0.13585513830184937,
0.37412649393081665,
-0.2315933257341385,
-0.2413983792066574,
-0.8330149054527283,
-0.14935055375099182,
0.14210619032382965,
-0.2433006316423416,
-0.6864469647407532,
0.18652202188968658,
0.40936461091041565,
-0.06656941026449203,
-0.7010173201560974,
0.6943198442459106,
-0.25071752071380615,
-0.4159305691719055,
-0.17516407370567322,
-0.08367748558521271,
0.010885370895266533,
0.5185306668281555,
0.06792675703763962,
0.8556318879127502,
0.7784652709960938,
-0.893709659576416,
0.16366331279277802,
-0.12051010876893997,
-0.8406985998153687,
0.39811262488365173,
-0.48357927799224854,
0.14899449050426483,
-0.20097309350967407,
0.7617702484130859,
-0.8130269646644592,
-0.45829689502716064,
-0.24583128094673157,
0.19973397254943848,
0.5967839360237122,
0.0028072609566152096,
-0.5951289534568787,
-0.3548116981983185,
-0.23033642768859863,
0.7638096213340759,
0.4245685338973999,
-1.174416184425354,
0.050475526601076126,
0.06759122759103775,
0.4271969795227051,
-0.5961123108863831,
-0.6038005948066711,
-0.08899261057376862,
-0.7589229941368103,
-0.21442583203315735,
0.3561735451221466,
-0.2972274124622345,
-0.2308826446533203,
-0.49566856026649475,
-0.0720425695180893,
-0.07239095121622086,
0.20258770883083344,
0.25323113799095154,
-0.25525668263435364,
-0.1898888200521469,
0.63601154088974,
-0.004577914718538523,
0.36553722620010376,
0.10983634740114212,
-0.4838017523288727,
0.2974400222301483,
-0.30095696449279785,
-0.31200528144836426,
-0.3324373960494995,
0.7154844999313354,
0.5754923224449158,
0.07060016691684723,
0.7314853072166443,
0.27765151858329773,
-0.4057365655899048,
-0.44563916325569153,
-0.2612457871437073,
-0.3209313154220581,
-0.4248112440109253,
0.5610907673835754,
-0.54765784740448,
-0.7362442016601562,
0.44709888100624084,
-0.2900961637496948,
0.10084843635559082,
0.1293427050113678,
0.18826055526733398,
-0.4245976209640503,
1.1376937627792358,
0.7816546559333801,
-0.17343679070472717,
0.6793630123138428,
-0.6786008477210999,
-0.0980716422200203,
-0.9719358086585999,
-0.21818865835666656,
-0.1678844690322876,
-0.6880654096603394,
-0.2760333716869354,
-0.24521812796592712,
0.4953148365020752,
0.14888058602809906,
-0.5766000747680664,
0.08329974859952927,
-0.15892285108566284,
0.8604986667633057,
0.5655182600021362,
0.5140159130096436,
0.04306824877858162,
-0.003110861871391535,
0.07841305434703827,
0.07015497982501984,
-0.8972381353378296,
-0.10877303779125214,
1.01508629322052,
0.3460361063480377,
0.7921688556671143,
0.047842931002378464,
0.6010284423828125,
0.022836457937955856,
0.3859019875526428,
-0.819095253944397,
0.288566917181015,
-0.20047305524349213,
-0.4973256587982178,
-0.5456198453903198,
-0.17487144470214844,
-0.805274486541748,
0.11421352624893188,
0.054934486746788025,
-0.5519461035728455,
0.37666335701942444,
0.16980041563510895,
-0.38502463698387146,
0.3725728392601013,
-0.5975700616836548,
0.7908998131752014,
-0.3873009979724884,
-0.6053296327590942,
-0.20936325192451477,
-0.9186172485351562,
0.20779654383659363,
-0.057964690029621124,
0.03984380513429642,
0.3885765075683594,
0.0013385198544710875,
0.7249488234519958,
-0.05452914535999298,
0.9600900411605835,
-0.14525285363197327,
0.06035469099879265,
0.13920974731445312,
-0.08973491936922073,
0.45446649193763733,
0.12441342324018478,
-0.05919540673494339,
-0.1622299700975418,
-0.17093919217586517,
-0.5155730843544006,
-0.7221028804779053,
0.8145018815994263,
-0.7827341556549072,
-0.2408021241426468,
-0.0844406932592392,
-0.5619615316390991,
-0.36000296473503113,
-0.006915127392858267,
0.45139867067337036,
1.045844316482544,
-0.12317078560590744,
0.8981927633285522,
1.0168137550354004,
-0.03498042747378349,
0.5901811718940735,
0.12582039833068848,
-0.11356263607740402,
0.08496981114149094,
0.8223294019699097,
0.3479697108268738,
0.6003464460372925,
0.5056804418563843,
0.22955666482448578,
-0.3789743185043335,
-0.44121667742729187,
-0.44424426555633545,
-0.10051834583282471,
-0.9107465744018555,
-0.0647122785449028,
-0.5263148546218872,
-0.03589387610554695,
-0.05382878705859184,
-0.303085595369339,
-0.14643701910972595,
-0.32502907514572144,
-0.39197617769241333,
-0.10833247005939484,
0.12719541788101196,
0.8307962417602539,
0.09345284849405289,
0.3998028337955475,
-0.25258970260620117,
0.04956834763288498,
0.6078763008117676,
0.5057459473609924,
0.41021883487701416,
-0.5392609238624573,
-0.6830021142959595,
0.13195593655109406,
-0.4131712317466736,
-0.5032060146331787,
0.06630049645900726,
0.4317038655281067,
0.3563767969608307,
0.6375963687896729,
-0.06102609634399414,
0.9935380220413208,
-0.3800937235355377,
0.7635114192962646,
-0.06913971155881882,
-0.6836068034172058,
0.08445483446121216,
-0.24437925219535828,
0.5331190228462219,
0.5077412724494934,
0.6562374830245972,
-0.5178472399711609,
-0.03562631085515022,
-0.5867193937301636,
-0.8036618828773499,
0.7170127630233765,
-0.256698340177536,
0.23960189521312714,
0.0911954715847969,
0.5820959210395813,
0.4250190556049347,
0.06364395469427109,
-0.7766547203063965,
-0.06938541680574417,
-0.14943039417266846,
0.1388375610113144,
-0.35723069310188293,
-0.3109782040119171,
-0.3335866332054138,
-0.5131326913833618,
0.424720823764801,
-0.3273330330848694,
0.175399512052536,
0.08344554901123047,
-0.3325575292110443,
0.3215104043483734,
0.13456900417804718,
0.8216684460639954,
0.8118936419487,
-0.16477860510349274,
0.11644129455089569,
0.4578686058521271,
-0.007700663059949875,
-0.024361951276659966,
-0.1581329107284546,
0.18410611152648926,
-0.4222606420516968,
0.36042115092277527,
1.0268402099609375,
0.6815077066421509,
-0.6308715343475342,
0.5786865949630737,
0.026935551315546036,
-0.2742471694946289,
-0.39210328459739685,
-0.0165647491812706,
-0.05627252906560898,
0.35341352224349976,
0.4086223542690277,
-0.20387278497219086,
0.443337082862854,
-0.7780328989028931,
0.25189387798309326,
0.36422106623649597,
-0.5618263483047485,
-0.09688188880681992,
0.5226737856864929,
-0.2227095067501068,
-0.12079743295907974,
0.9844950437545776,
0.04941887781023979,
-0.2758420705795288,
1.0018426179885864,
0.8779593706130981,
0.5008977651596069,
0.35318228602409363,
-0.17492637038230896,
0.18895366787910461,
-0.35235801339149475,
-0.20754066109657288,
-0.22830039262771606,
-0.7065356969833374,
-0.31252649426460266,
-0.37548407912254333,
-0.23189829289913177,
-0.4409293830394745,
0.3383226990699768,
-0.947728157043457,
0.25388193130493164,
-0.15379483997821808,
0.060503389686346054,
-0.0722149983048439,
0.028392303735017776,
-0.7951321005821228,
0.2079203575849533,
0.14526842534542084,
1.027038335800171,
-0.7431545853614807,
1.0765845775604248,
0.6114714741706848,
0.022670922800898552,
-0.5702471733093262,
-0.05162089690566063,
-0.2718093693256378,
-0.3024112284183502,
0.8879839777946472,
0.5715410709381104,
0.08637499064207077,
-0.18183988332748413,
-0.9183921217918396,
-0.832947850227356,
1.3042404651641846,
-0.04349074512720108,
-0.4967823922634125,
-0.086276113986969,
0.09139908850193024,
0.6372510194778442,
-0.6724382042884827,
0.08147582411766052,
0.527725100517273,
0.08282161504030228,
-0.03846967592835426,
-0.6306265592575073,
-0.2516101002693176,
0.23755252361297607,
-0.06340949237346649,
0.11398539692163467,
-0.8459673523902893,
0.8200505971908569,
-0.11140436679124832,
0.0212557390332222,
-0.006552156060934067,
0.727813720703125,
0.3102688193321228,
0.6769660711288452,
0.5449022650718689,
0.2708229720592499,
0.5873912572860718,
0.18612822890281677,
1.2595019340515137,
-0.006074049510061741,
0.35835230350494385,
1.2960437536239624,
-0.320374459028244,
0.740023672580719,
0.5096542239189148,
0.0892619639635086,
0.33526331186294556,
0.8459672331809998,
0.2054579257965088,
0.6691128611564636,
0.21553710103034973,
-0.267716646194458,
-0.27609288692474365,
0.021723728626966476,
-0.3569223880767822,
0.35700786113739014,
0.5920843482017517,
-0.37646037340164185,
-0.2443586140871048,
0.7711910605430603,
-0.28016144037246704,
-0.14841638505458832,
-0.3497135639190674,
0.6876786351203918,
0.15095755457878113,
-0.4917309582233429,
0.502531886100769,
-0.3880164623260498,
0.5572571158409119,
-0.4098503887653351,
-0.16409701108932495,
-0.2196614146232605,
0.2056206911802292,
0.1804734319448471,
-0.740780234336853,
-0.16460534930229187,
-0.33396899700164795,
-0.4302678108215332,
-0.4306047856807709,
0.30121517181396484,
-0.47070053219795227,
-0.13170696794986725,
0.35994449257850647,
0.11706062406301498,
0.3560498058795929,
0.14801189303398132,
-0.366867333650589,
-0.24744291603565216,
-0.30511391162872314,
-0.3932279050350189,
0.9434589743614197,
0.4034767150878906,
-0.43058475852012634,
0.7235872149467468,
0.3677031397819519,
-0.4287561774253845,
0.1873810589313507,
-0.10816138982772827,
1.0011833906173706,
-0.5469861030578613,
-0.3845599591732025,
-0.8337741494178772,
0.2578970193862915,
-0.26989778876304626,
-0.42990410327911377,
0.569883406162262,
0.839932382106781,
1.323068618774414,
-0.08533292263746262,
0.4742734730243683,
0.09716809540987015,
0.2996228039264679,
-0.5714122653007507,
0.4496857821941376,
-0.7887844443321228,
-0.02181422710418701,
0.05299654230475426,
-0.707301676273346,
-0.29503992199897766,
0.3206061124801636,
-0.29135391116142273,
0.009960419498383999,
0.5510900020599365,
0.38310956954956055,
-0.47417086362838745,
0.06065194681286812,
0.5567492842674255,
0.1917400360107422,
0.39340338110923767,
0.6820134520530701,
0.9761302471160889,
-0.2556556463241577,
0.16528332233428955,
-0.5637111663818359,
-0.19034484028816223,
-0.3328603208065033,
-0.8157804608345032,
-0.9090510010719299,
-0.7812325954437256,
-0.0425848513841629,
-0.020027602091431618,
0.00963403657078743,
0.9179080724716187,
1.0008221864700317,
-0.5126236081123352,
-0.5919877886772156,
0.25358402729034424,
-0.04502875357866287,
-0.4719749987125397,
-0.2314031720161438,
0.5019407868385315,
-0.22270530462265015,
-0.7061351537704468,
0.6576626896858215,
-0.011103647761046886,
0.12800638377666473,
-0.09292517602443695,
0.02319156378507614,
-0.07185985893011093,
-0.22802864015102386,
1.0998612642288208,
0.4643932282924652,
-0.47416403889656067,
-0.38280412554740906,
-0.15788684785366058,
-0.06547249853610992,
0.12234822660684586,
0.9343294501304626,
-1.0193572044372559,
0.47518107295036316,
0.24302949011325836,
0.619559645652771,
0.9382472038269043,
0.03072597086429596,
0.29893505573272705,
-0.8837285041809082,
0.1875254511833191,
0.24277417361736298,
0.2674909830093384,
0.04544878005981445,
-0.2906041145324707,
0.35919877886772156,
-0.29233071208000183,
-0.8761893510818481,
-1.02335524559021,
0.18276198208332062,
-0.7302007675170898,
-0.4825878441333771,
1.1205787658691406,
-0.011782134883105755,
-0.05579167604446411,
0.036196257919073105,
-0.021870417520403862,
0.06150228902697563,
-0.3328775465488434,
0.7521004676818848,
0.8335471749305725,
-0.6235914826393127,
0.28066200017929077,
-0.8489699363708496,
0.6084702610969543,
0.3330244719982147,
-0.3856540620326996,
0.10777152329683304,
0.5009403824806213,
0.27241867780685425,
-0.13496153056621552,
0.2409139722585678,
0.06973302364349365,
0.2857201099395752,
-0.35551655292510986,
-0.4437299370765686,
-0.09413668513298035,
-0.8089720010757446,
-0.7444390654563904,
0.20889180898666382,
-0.029000872746109962,
-0.04837771877646446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00175v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00175v1
|
Towards a Search Engine for Machines: Unified Ranking for Multiple Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models
| 2024-04-30T19:51:37 | 2024-04-30T19:51:37 |
Alireza Salemi, Hamed Zamani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
This paper introduces uRAG--a framework with a unified retrieval engine that
serves multiple downstream retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) systems. Each
RAG system consumes the retrieval results for a unique purpose, such as
open-domain question answering, fact verification, entity linking, and relation
extraction. We introduce a generic training guideline that standardizes the
communication between the search engine and the downstream RAG systems that
engage in optimizing the retrieval model. This lays the groundwork for us to
build a large-scale experimentation ecosystem consisting of 18 RAG systems that
engage in training and 18 unknown RAG systems that use the uRAG as the new
users of the search engine. Using this experimentation ecosystem, we answer a
number of fundamental research questions that improve our understanding of
promises and challenges in developing search engines for machines.
|
[
-0.6971803307533264,
-0.4708792269229889,
0.7257997989654541,
0.01779033988714218,
0.11512330174446106,
0.14604055881500244,
-0.06840809434652328,
-0.2513553500175476,
0.006925242953002453,
0.6215810179710388,
-0.46297746896743774,
-0.262260377407074,
-0.3431369364261627,
0.10970545560121536,
-0.5289024710655212,
1.000592589378357,
0.1495247632265091,
-0.031193207949399948,
-0.16802529990673065,
-0.1968444138765335,
-0.39790472388267517,
-0.7449646592140198,
-0.6181266903877258,
-0.28283920884132385,
0.9281841516494751,
0.38468971848487854,
0.6629250645637512,
0.4146976172924042,
0.637891948223114,
0.2673999071121216,
0.02111847884953022,
0.3264385163784027,
-0.6602885127067566,
0.6059080958366394,
-0.4994235038757324,
-0.36604687571525574,
-0.14587968587875366,
0.07712527364492416,
0.837821364402771,
0.756472110748291,
-0.2011571079492569,
0.4434705078601837,
0.12326963245868683,
0.6206393241882324,
-1.0259286165237427,
-0.32434019446372986,
-0.7965905070304871,
-0.27344369888305664,
-0.2616521418094635,
-0.18053533136844635,
-0.7027647495269775,
-0.0812741294503212,
-0.21101583540439606,
-0.6350432634353638,
0.18845827877521515,
0.40758270025253296,
0.8269346356391907,
0.16868288815021515,
-0.466579407453537,
-0.1636013239622116,
-0.7173765301704407,
0.7948856949806213,
-0.2944740653038025,
0.5995290279388428,
0.18578515946865082,
0.42596516013145447,
-0.48551228642463684,
-0.9902387261390686,
-0.25424981117248535,
0.06181871518492699,
-0.10122984647750854,
-0.1837550848722458,
0.05826800316572189,
0.026305342093110085,
0.026556015014648438,
0.1803748905658722,
-0.7175481915473938,
0.04532725363969803,
-0.22024354338645935,
0.024937158450484276,
0.7470399737358093,
0.08494594693183899,
0.32711541652679443,
0.15907171368598938,
-0.2844475507736206,
-0.0156337209045887,
-0.670037031173706,
-0.18767975270748138,
0.3879201114177704,
0.4667925238609314,
0.4889239966869354,
0.6224914789199829,
-0.1633787304162979,
0.5890169143676758,
-0.19776219129562378,
0.0161748006939888,
0.16618649661540985,
-0.0065888166427612305,
-0.3617595136165619,
-0.09828519821166992,
0.5126673579216003,
-0.09067372232675552,
0.00878430437296629,
-0.5437972545623779,
-0.5401355028152466,
-0.11387725174427032,
0.8671998977661133,
-0.6770430207252502,
0.10199916362762451,
0.06331659108400345,
-0.3907434642314911,
-0.41809576749801636,
0.19956713914871216,
-0.898152232170105,
-0.331840842962265,
-0.3293083906173706,
0.7884001731872559,
-0.011723221279680729,
-0.20887504518032074,
-0.01809190958738327,
-0.5145244002342224,
0.2595897912979126,
0.15381869673728943,
-0.7288147211074829,
0.3639141023159027,
0.7199634909629822,
0.42276984453201294,
-0.03103037178516388,
-0.5651738047599792,
-0.6971760392189026,
0.36173340678215027,
-0.38325127959251404,
1.0076359510421753,
-0.8395499587059021,
-0.6363968253135681,
0.057906102389097214,
0.04388175904750824,
-0.18586890399456024,
-0.4461032748222351,
0.6924816966056824,
-0.9522402286529541,
0.39394381642341614,
-0.08419997245073318,
-0.5153325796127319,
-0.311059832572937,
0.038300417363643646,
-0.6066409349441528,
1.0818347930908203,
-0.15490415692329407,
-0.6683601140975952,
0.08357410132884979,
-1.002549409866333,
-0.32065436244010925,
0.2031739503145218,
-0.11159192025661469,
-0.18377253413200378,
0.30139783024787903,
0.1105571761727333,
0.17556074261665344,
-0.5805392265319824,
0.29565292596817017,
-0.4513574242591858,
-0.561474621295929,
-0.10144467651844025,
-0.2330455332994461,
0.788775622844696,
0.33100423216819763,
-0.28990212082862854,
0.036633264273405075,
-0.5122120976448059,
0.452269971370697,
0.17521898448467255,
-0.6296823620796204,
-0.47042396664619446,
0.0018981382017955184,
0.2730487585067749,
-0.20241743326187134,
0.5182336568832397,
-0.33547744154930115,
0.5844059586524963,
0.05586390942335129,
0.1596054583787918,
0.8417723774909973,
-0.13282319903373718,
0.42274805903434753,
-0.027913160622119904,
0.4210750162601471,
-0.5130771994590759,
0.037875015288591385,
-0.33507394790649414,
-0.575283408164978,
-0.7859707474708557,
-0.12579509615898132,
0.7880054116249084,
0.25085291266441345,
-0.34513142704963684,
0.28271129727363586,
-0.15644480288028717,
-0.35391169786453247,
-0.8352566957473755,
0.16583794355392456,
0.3886583149433136,
0.18003560602664948,
0.24775759875774384,
-0.1314239799976349,
-0.8670926690101624,
-0.8843058347702026,
-0.239234060049057,
-0.03855061158537865,
-0.3158257007598877,
0.4801807403564453,
0.5627152919769287,
-0.7266319394111633,
0.8376414179801941,
-0.35772937536239624,
-0.17942918837070465,
-0.018065432086586952,
0.43514373898506165,
-0.014927753247320652,
0.3263233006000519,
0.11670709401369095,
-1.287388563156128,
-0.26448774337768555,
0.13789013028144836,
-1.0161914825439453,
0.04898102954030037,
0.6300689578056335,
-0.2671658396720886,
0.4103644788265228,
0.5386225581169128,
-0.30994707345962524,
0.3820352256298065,
0.5929486155509949,
0.007472038269042969,
0.5134727358818054,
-0.19268226623535156,
0.3278953433036804,
-0.8548611998558044,
0.6777454018592834,
-0.39791256189346313,
-0.14007452130317688,
-0.33024314045906067,
0.6762691736221313,
-0.13368065655231476,
-0.3673150837421417,
-0.25172922015190125,
0.8101517558097839,
-0.2940085828304291,
-0.3722207248210907,
-0.37730148434638977,
0.15150044858455658,
0.011003697291016579,
0.3744381070137024,
-0.32846763730049133,
1.1867916584014893,
0.40532243251800537,
-0.8124455809593201,
0.14361931383609772,
0.026801876723766327,
0.17589497566223145,
0.566103458404541,
-0.6553192138671875,
0.4419545531272888,
-0.13137051463127136,
0.15699315071105957,
-0.9833646416664124,
-0.4909098446369171,
-0.361358106136322,
-0.6886258721351624,
0.17731888592243195,
-0.24805505573749542,
-0.6572317481040955,
-0.5390264987945557,
-0.056188736110925674,
0.3187826871871948,
0.5793652534484863,
-0.784401535987854,
0.6326721906661987,
0.8402001261711121,
0.1161726862192154,
-0.6905233263969421,
-0.049865663051605225,
0.10925538092851639,
-0.25498101115226746,
-0.6496977210044861,
0.25772207975387573,
-0.06433450430631638,
-0.03118673712015152,
0.2463252991437912,
-0.018847040832042694,
-0.4927597939968109,
0.36248746514320374,
0.24438482522964478,
0.1480858474969864,
-0.20008549094200134,
0.545577347278595,
-0.19056154787540436,
-0.15147453546524048,
-0.1282610148191452,
-0.47618916630744934,
0.6429569125175476,
-0.22998197376728058,
-0.3654605746269226,
-0.08279135823249817,
0.5182714462280273,
0.4508713185787201,
-0.46357256174087524,
0.4687052369117737,
0.7297759056091309,
-0.45283839106559753,
0.009377057664096355,
-0.6288540959358215,
-0.10916823148727417,
-0.4853387475013733,
0.11815008521080017,
-0.6322153210639954,
-1.144783616065979,
0.3596596121788025,
-0.3339524269104004,
0.24369119107723236,
0.7702640295028687,
0.48194584250450134,
-0.315388560295105,
1.6812787055969238,
1.0121006965637207,
-0.11226122826337814,
-0.0799248144030571,
-0.10996872931718826,
0.1321610063314438,
-1.208774447441101,
-0.2797037363052368,
-1.1523994207382202,
-0.44078171253204346,
-0.869844913482666,
-0.14999280869960785,
0.42703405022621155,
0.3276160955429077,
-0.6411489844322205,
0.28873446583747864,
-0.7632540464401245,
0.4557958245277405,
0.8904390335083008,
-0.2772829532623291,
0.3465462923049927,
0.08497054129838943,
-0.507850706577301,
0.11679636687040329,
-0.6284084916114807,
-0.56908118724823,
1.214911937713623,
-0.07652993500232697,
0.8440181016921997,
0.11305399984121323,
0.8592156171798706,
0.45630136132240295,
0.32923996448516846,
-0.44925883412361145,
0.3878673017024994,
-0.1394270360469818,
-1.3290787935256958,
-0.4741598665714264,
-0.3329002261161804,
-1.4832704067230225,
0.5416585206985474,
0.0429268479347229,
-0.8054068088531494,
-0.09687953442335129,
-0.25262340903282166,
0.13771235942840576,
0.42090535163879395,
-0.5160331130027771,
0.7134169936180115,
-0.29366520047187805,
-0.1516750603914261,
-0.36827147006988525,
-0.44442957639694214,
0.32222267985343933,
0.029627151787281036,
0.26016369462013245,
0.1771581470966339,
-0.11070559918880463,
0.6472436785697937,
0.09155436605215073,
0.40297627449035645,
0.007127000018954277,
0.12544392049312592,
0.2999195456504822,
-0.08289306610822678,
0.2244681417942047,
0.06471066176891327,
-0.03145113214850426,
-0.12192868441343307,
-0.2320307046175003,
-0.5362001657485962,
-0.5446621775627136,
0.824055552482605,
-0.7604068517684937,
-0.5728004574775696,
-0.41679683327674866,
-0.3948712646961212,
-0.13796889781951904,
0.6323973536491394,
0.025615286082029343,
0.20674847066402435,
-0.3875233232975006,
0.44568032026290894,
0.9310563802719116,
-0.04619469493627548,
0.2082124948501587,
0.4967222809791565,
-0.7076528668403625,
-0.25484901666641235,
0.9561550617218018,
-0.20627808570861816,
-0.2106996476650238,
0.38939595222473145,
0.02926800027489662,
-0.3558647632598877,
-0.037465259432792664,
-0.43293899297714233,
0.15536190569400787,
-0.4985584616661072,
-0.12240967154502869,
-0.6540125012397766,
-0.32937610149383545,
-0.5106923580169678,
-0.09766320139169693,
-0.39884495735168457,
-0.05662718415260315,
-0.0923248678445816,
0.4087657034397125,
0.13497617840766907,
1.1827911138534546,
-0.11946932226419449,
0.11006947606801987,
-0.7514861822128296,
0.2739429473876953,
0.5831893682479858,
0.5670860409736633,
-0.0987357646226883,
-0.47292324900627136,
-0.32050782442092896,
0.14282988011837006,
-0.6280393004417419,
-0.5375953912734985,
0.08133813738822937,
-0.041642554104328156,
0.9558213949203491,
0.1283966600894928,
-0.23244833946228027,
0.6497661471366882,
-0.8239996433258057,
0.560084342956543,
-0.028671789914369583,
-0.6858994960784912,
0.5138958692550659,
-0.37159085273742676,
0.022603513672947884,
0.6034778356552124,
0.6907621026039124,
-0.6192704439163208,
-0.04997244477272034,
-0.85149085521698,
-0.6902508735656738,
0.4699644446372986,
0.05182713270187378,
0.06773637980222702,
0.36508721113204956,
0.256158709526062,
-0.06844822317361832,
0.48926955461502075,
-0.2724761366844177,
-0.3398783504962921,
0.3063651919364929,
0.157087042927742,
-0.008094962686300278,
-0.08784861117601395,
-0.28898876905441284,
-0.07479894161224365,
0.8356351256370544,
-0.1097017303109169,
0.40997084975242615,
-0.025474876165390015,
-0.111400306224823,
-0.18342630565166473,
0.3313619792461395,
0.2573947310447693,
0.6099713444709778,
-0.29419970512390137,
0.0775226503610611,
-0.14944423735141754,
-0.22982250154018402,
0.40564414858818054,
0.14389395713806152,
-0.16657428443431854,
0.0835593119263649,
-0.1043081283569336,
0.521335780620575,
0.3629036247730255,
-0.7183933854103088,
0.06779950857162476,
-0.1822621077299118,
-0.09599842131137848,
-0.10731493681669235,
0.14134684205055237,
0.19335155189037323,
0.028837068006396294,
0.6590275168418884,
-0.10412558168172836,
0.5399251580238342,
-0.5253728032112122,
0.4338143765926361,
0.5604770183563232,
-0.4458952248096466,
-0.1182192787528038,
0.7213433384895325,
0.3638452887535095,
-0.6172471046447754,
0.7358081340789795,
-0.35680025815963745,
-0.5738852620124817,
0.24926312267780304,
0.3153829276561737,
1.0402592420578003,
-0.31590959429740906,
0.17310470342636108,
0.19535230100154877,
0.2824067771434784,
-0.1996414214372635,
-0.03271806612610817,
0.17580151557922363,
-0.35805732011795044,
-0.49641627073287964,
-0.8036801815032959,
-0.5659546256065369,
0.3485652506351471,
-0.6339147686958313,
0.300917387008667,
-0.07257838547229767,
-0.06111077591776848,
0.28073588013648987,
0.05694960430264473,
-0.6883071064949036,
0.16592693328857422,
0.09903567284345627,
0.7724471092224121,
-0.23841868340969086,
0.700986921787262,
1.1875911951065063,
-0.7149298191070557,
-0.6246404647827148,
-0.16603083908557892,
-0.08461758494377136,
-0.820225715637207,
0.7250655293464661,
0.25977277755737305,
-0.20654360949993134,
0.16720707714557648,
-0.81444251537323,
-0.9718635678291321,
0.9338349103927612,
0.3186791241168976,
-0.20496484637260437,
-0.3553592264652252,
-0.2877548336982727,
0.3356490731239319,
-0.5615087747573853,
0.25451305508613586,
0.28076624870300293,
0.6191676259040833,
-0.18265306949615479,
-0.9623880982398987,
-0.37045297026634216,
-0.2988903820514679,
0.1631881445646286,
0.40794163942337036,
-0.47413191199302673,
0.7066841125488281,
-0.20716789364814758,
-0.251547634601593,
0.3429466187953949,
0.3584555387496948,
0.3465396761894226,
0.37862613797187805,
0.42388585209846497,
0.8543693423271179,
0.7378843426704407,
0.06270572543144226,
1.1961580514907837,
-0.08553525805473328,
0.6015542149543762,
0.9770258665084839,
-0.3910009562969208,
1.0934951305389404,
0.36027389764785767,
-0.27624672651290894,
0.5890452265739441,
0.5031319260597229,
0.1810792088508606,
0.24881790578365326,
0.277392715215683,
-0.1955663114786148,
-0.3693188428878784,
-0.32545602321624756,
-0.43304774165153503,
0.5005154013633728,
0.11011271923780441,
-0.30235961079597473,
-0.4778554141521454,
-0.04714946076273918,
-0.17810137569904327,
0.10558338463306427,
-0.23985879123210907,
0.7612568140029907,
-0.18296100199222565,
-0.6527145504951477,
0.7138494849205017,
0.06538070738315582,
0.5643863677978516,
-0.3297663629055023,
-0.06275337189435959,
-0.08194226771593094,
0.13459309935569763,
-0.01602737046778202,
-0.584160327911377,
-0.06617545336484909,
-0.006936284713447094,
-0.4492979347705841,
0.0467088557779789,
0.8169766068458557,
-0.12942494451999664,
-0.5337842106819153,
0.3753854036331177,
0.47869378328323364,
0.37021052837371826,
-0.25391843914985657,
-0.7841916680335999,
0.2236841470003128,
-0.08205235004425049,
-0.32131800055503845,
0.7168551683425903,
0.5446543097496033,
0.06754974275827408,
0.6831739544868469,
0.6524048447608948,
-0.32244232296943665,
0.09496628493070602,
0.0027055025566369295,
0.8620814085006714,
-0.6484964489936829,
-0.2222105711698532,
-0.3338969647884369,
0.4747868478298187,
-0.04290156438946724,
-0.08933864533901215,
0.6973504424095154,
0.6370531916618347,
0.9873228073120117,
0.2724358141422272,
1.0131219625473022,
-0.20344607532024384,
0.6904756426811218,
-0.05110979080200195,
0.7505686283111572,
-1.0429141521453857,
-0.20172712206840515,
0.09074179083108902,
-1.1513205766677856,
0.000026390949642518535,
0.4208422005176544,
0.32132774591445923,
0.2467491775751114,
0.6518048048019409,
0.5955981612205505,
-0.1894187480211258,
-0.058223675936460495,
0.47124582529067993,
-0.11370173841714859,
0.37197446823120117,
0.15903779864311218,
0.5848289728164673,
-0.5761259198188782,
0.7501011490821838,
0.050330065190792084,
-0.04344535991549492,
-0.3871494233608246,
-0.508302628993988,
-0.5941402912139893,
-0.7432383298873901,
0.2650940716266632,
-0.2208416610956192,
0.47338739037513733,
0.44155704975128174,
0.6992062926292419,
-0.5795959234237671,
-0.5573299527168274,
0.001035927445627749,
0.2862318754196167,
0.06947576999664307,
-0.2607400417327881,
0.04242192581295967,
-1.1208665370941162,
-0.8547731041908264,
0.4097164273262024,
0.25280699133872986,
-0.39109930396080017,
-0.6616283059120178,
-0.1762426346540451,
-0.7058085799217224,
-0.06599996984004974,
0.4645732045173645,
0.4323572814464569,
-0.5819708704948425,
-0.12920594215393066,
0.14829021692276,
-0.21172016859054565,
-0.09310662746429443,
0.9994897842407227,
-0.9374251365661621,
0.5734924674034119,
0.33241984248161316,
1.0984761714935303,
0.2738572359085083,
-0.034790970385074615,
0.5314241647720337,
-0.6624296307563782,
-0.03550150617957115,
0.06257839500904083,
0.07295281440019608,
0.2577977180480957,
-0.14079810678958893,
0.834370493888855,
0.10475332289934158,
-1.1238949298858643,
-1.0991742610931396,
0.19984868168830872,
-0.3854345977306366,
-0.3118523359298706,
1.1475939750671387,
0.10085976868867874,
-0.20901380479335785,
0.02249077335000038,
-0.1174294650554657,
0.11670010536909103,
-0.5366494059562683,
0.671305775642395,
0.46201425790786743,
0.08309241384267807,
0.3183731436729431,
-0.8729301691055298,
0.30161046981811523,
0.3040372431278229,
-0.7407736778259277,
-0.11669362336397171,
0.32919690012931824,
0.13488221168518066,
0.5392667055130005,
0.34073230624198914,
-0.12644962966442108,
0.3643873929977417,
-0.1294713318347931,
0.40277230739593506,
0.3116326928138733,
-0.6521742939949036,
-0.26410216093063354,
0.2677972912788391,
0.1514354646205902,
-0.18988876044750214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00155v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00155v1
|
HistNERo: Historical Named Entity Recognition for the Romanian Language
| 2024-04-30T19:05:22 | 2024-04-30T19:05:22 |
Andrei-Marius Avram, Andreea Iuga, George-Vlad Manolache, Vlad-Cristian Matei, Răzvan-Gabriel Micliuş, Vlad-Andrei Muntean, Manuel-Petru Sorlescu, Dragoş-Andrei Şerban, Adrian-Dinu Urse, Vasile Păiş, Dumitru-Clementin Cercel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This work introduces HistNERo, the first Romanian corpus for Named Entity
Recognition (NER) in historical newspapers. The dataset contains 323k tokens of
text, covering more than half of the 19th century (i.e., 1817) until the late
part of the 20th century (i.e., 1990). Eight native Romanian speakers annotated
the dataset with five named entities. The samples belong to one of the
following four historical regions of Romania, namely Bessarabia, Moldavia,
Transylvania, and Wallachia. We employed this proposed dataset to perform
several experiments for NER using Romanian pre-trained language models. Our
results show that the best model achieved a strict F1-score of 55.69%. Also, by
reducing the discrepancies between regions through a novel domain adaption
technique, we improved the performance on this corpus to a strict F1-score of
66.80%, representing an absolute gain of more than 10%.
|
[
-0.3287923336029053,
-0.43647152185440063,
0.46616020798683167,
0.055276911705732346,
-0.12804727256298065,
-0.08832583576440811,
-0.4808043837547302,
-0.5263850092887878,
0.6621341705322266,
0.5365777015686035,
-0.245062455534935,
-0.4209781289100647,
-0.7035884857177734,
0.5554906725883484,
-0.46344974637031555,
1.0241891145706177,
0.05899164453148842,
0.35326915979385376,
0.36197876930236816,
-0.21758858859539032,
-0.20265725255012512,
-0.7079434990882874,
-0.6348826289176941,
0.010796201415359974,
0.4823274314403534,
0.3693352937698364,
0.19076813757419586,
0.6815784573554993,
0.7511970400810242,
0.4552181363105774,
-0.3162119388580322,
-0.10527308285236359,
-0.3935253918170929,
0.017744528129696846,
-0.2838708460330963,
-0.5352786183357239,
-0.2792440354824066,
-0.2480861246585846,
1.0218029022216797,
0.25939783453941345,
0.0045744627714157104,
0.06311994045972824,
-0.40349048376083374,
0.6862011551856995,
-0.4736982583999634,
0.0806601420044899,
-0.8927200436592102,
-0.03409101068973541,
-0.5098153352737427,
-0.5680146813392639,
-0.620384931564331,
-0.18972234427928925,
0.22032147645950317,
-0.5118017196655273,
0.22209523618221283,
0.2231459766626358,
1.5286554098129272,
0.1964615434408188,
-0.36241257190704346,
-0.2769765257835388,
-0.8197210431098938,
0.8133543729782104,
-0.4047348201274872,
0.5466387271881104,
0.3858555853366852,
0.5505548715591431,
-0.610590934753418,
-0.6881827712059021,
-0.497713178396225,
-0.15933582186698914,
-0.09888675063848495,
0.03378039970993996,
-0.7175902128219604,
-0.5410407781600952,
0.14002875983715057,
0.3789529502391815,
-0.5543756484985352,
0.2703436613082886,
-0.7691393494606018,
-0.4317901134490967,
0.27003213763237,
0.04938872531056404,
-0.08522934466600418,
-0.47002941370010376,
-0.6244792938232422,
0.2412363588809967,
-0.809275209903717,
-0.15762211382389069,
0.6025404930114746,
0.4145734906196594,
0.2407546043395996,
0.5561697483062744,
-0.326617032289505,
0.7506617903709412,
0.06335189938545227,
-0.3049783408641815,
0.27541056275367737,
-0.2509154677391052,
-0.2707747519016266,
0.3009997606277466,
0.6542949080467224,
-0.16103799641132355,
0.39478006958961487,
-0.39973121881484985,
-0.04870706796646118,
-0.17921783030033112,
0.24053345620632172,
-0.7066380977630615,
-0.11853897571563721,
-0.07706452161073685,
-0.28143224120140076,
-0.19326725602149963,
0.08999422192573547,
-0.733841598033905,
0.07161790877580643,
-0.29782211780548096,
0.007375167682766914,
-0.6056468486785889,
-0.15766765177249908,
-0.1630433201789856,
-0.11249679327011108,
0.31782108545303345,
0.5225756168365479,
-0.697784423828125,
0.36232689023017883,
0.7034679055213928,
0.5638813972473145,
-0.08423200249671936,
-0.4529462158679962,
-0.7278093099594116,
0.07385484129190445,
-0.16868935525417328,
1.0813980102539062,
-0.682662844657898,
-0.11887519061565399,
-0.23062893748283386,
0.4589625895023346,
0.19764070212841034,
-0.32302409410476685,
0.7098869681358337,
-0.8027812242507935,
0.5292132496833801,
0.11242565512657166,
-0.8999485969543457,
-0.2761020064353943,
0.21940545737743378,
-0.8641891479492188,
0.9724881649017334,
0.1314762830734253,
-0.9147771596908569,
0.5361357927322388,
-0.08765817433595657,
-0.2856852114200592,
0.3545626997947693,
-0.2344207763671875,
-0.2891530990600586,
-0.024565238505601883,
-0.09277785569429398,
0.4177549183368683,
-0.216705322265625,
0.4125112295150757,
0.1993299424648285,
0.1245812475681305,
0.23609371483325958,
-0.20030513405799866,
0.8035383224487305,
0.05721137672662735,
-0.35781893134117126,
-0.013335857540369034,
-0.9247581958770752,
-0.24842941761016846,
-0.17006906867027283,
-0.5155448317527771,
-0.5767192840576172,
-0.23038698732852936,
0.28197458386421204,
0.04987882450222969,
0.1505742073059082,
-0.522916853427887,
-0.05236545950174332,
-0.29696545004844666,
0.3111335039138794,
0.5441691875457764,
-0.1862172782421112,
0.535211443901062,
-0.12029607594013214,
0.4145733714103699,
0.11365243792533875,
-0.36072617769241333,
-0.2232586294412613,
-0.6196761131286621,
-0.8476611971855164,
-0.35738837718963623,
1.0391700267791748,
0.6908717751502991,
-0.5348996520042419,
0.7444131374359131,
-0.5168342590332031,
-0.5435785055160522,
-0.31085634231567383,
-0.15704819560050964,
0.1992592215538025,
0.88326096534729,
0.34895485639572144,
-0.2130511850118637,
-1.003245234489441,
-0.9520079493522644,
0.18670137226581573,
-0.2896568179130554,
0.11682386696338654,
0.4499530494213104,
0.9657353758811951,
-0.16393589973449707,
0.8503087162971497,
-0.334104061126709,
-0.7235865592956543,
-0.08029283583164215,
-0.0480065755546093,
0.13115864992141724,
0.531143069267273,
0.5005179643630981,
-0.7585942149162292,
-0.07258865982294083,
0.12480205297470093,
-0.55268394947052,
0.5134152173995972,
0.10151902586221695,
-0.41356155276298523,
0.6729399561882019,
0.4904506504535675,
-0.09545726329088211,
0.35645878314971924,
0.687026858329773,
-0.41734927892684937,
0.5603752732276917,
-0.41015076637268066,
0.27964892983436584,
-1.524376392364502,
0.2776685655117035,
0.18995150923728943,
-0.5073818564414978,
-0.5876733064651489,
-0.14757853746414185,
0.046158112585544586,
0.002908966736868024,
-0.640330970287323,
0.616427481174469,
-0.6412881016731262,
0.1614404171705246,
-0.16227616369724274,
0.3587273955345154,
-0.3315073549747467,
0.2547449469566345,
0.5425241589546204,
0.4964328706264496,
0.5987767577171326,
-0.5625407099723816,
0.28490301966667175,
0.4373641908168793,
-0.3890821635723114,
0.8117289543151855,
-0.44954535365104675,
0.06223346292972565,
-0.3495163023471832,
0.06255505234003067,
-0.5361689925193787,
-0.15902136266231537,
0.1505400687456131,
-0.7399665713310242,
0.3673976957798004,
-0.6639785766601562,
-0.2199157327413559,
-0.005600482691079378,
0.26473885774612427,
0.06672056019306183,
0.10919858515262604,
-0.5184209942817688,
0.6554153561592102,
0.6953622102737427,
-0.11444024741649628,
-0.6337563395500183,
-0.6584385633468628,
0.6215203404426575,
-0.5615431070327759,
-0.6251084804534912,
0.5683518052101135,
0.10337097942829132,
-0.0314691886305809,
0.11821665614843369,
0.14285290241241455,
-0.7010262608528137,
-0.17555606365203857,
0.017217030748724937,
0.42590272426605225,
-0.6677253842353821,
0.2797512412071228,
-0.3366510570049286,
-0.5410138368606567,
-0.6162108182907104,
-0.1369616538286209,
0.5115986466407776,
-0.35683730244636536,
0.5775182843208313,
-0.7830832004547119,
0.1342257410287857,
0.0482766218483448,
-0.38204342126846313,
0.6488662362098694,
0.33060431480407715,
-0.8008372187614441,
0.16221924126148224,
-0.6427343487739563,
-0.11309947073459625,
-0.37530335783958435,
0.06256061792373657,
-0.7945382595062256,
-0.9489367604255676,
0.3947412967681885,
-0.08302398771047592,
-0.31512850522994995,
0.5588221549987793,
0.4902152717113495,
0.0875481516122818,
0.07004964351654053,
0.7198430895805359,
-0.5193274021148682,
0.6128844022750854,
-0.21426238119602203,
-0.00803892221301794,
-0.7492466568946838,
0.03907613083720207,
-1.035448670387268,
-0.17289648950099945,
-1.099760890007019,
-0.2565559446811676,
-0.18607032299041748,
-0.1815270036458969,
0.2106049805879593,
1.0440127849578857,
-0.2376343309879303,
0.34405964612960815,
0.5634065866470337,
-0.20729240775108337,
0.5519669651985168,
0.013732414692640305,
0.44403326511383057,
-0.4553356468677521,
-0.35748183727264404,
-1.0074352025985718,
0.7927168607711792,
0.18028265237808228,
0.5950114727020264,
0.3575560450553894,
1.1578171253204346,
0.030881518498063087,
0.1277008354663849,
-0.8190075159072876,
0.2865695059299469,
-0.30269500613212585,
-0.8912599086761475,
-0.5258154273033142,
-0.5727334022521973,
-1.3901171684265137,
0.09093355387449265,
-0.3436976671218872,
-0.8306962251663208,
0.4340469241142273,
0.05653742700815201,
-0.2605002820491791,
0.037310853600502014,
-0.31164464354515076,
0.8161531686782837,
-0.19144420325756073,
-0.05036666989326477,
-0.10386975854635239,
-0.33824995160102844,
0.08449605107307434,
0.21348632872104645,
0.03716814145445824,
-0.18716102838516235,
-0.050602756440639496,
0.85540372133255,
-0.07877810299396515,
0.32022181153297424,
0.21049748361110687,
0.328091561794281,
0.10141972452402115,
0.14209316670894623,
0.4602479040622711,
0.26819854974746704,
-0.28700441122055054,
0.16871990263462067,
0.18805359303951263,
-0.3162693977355957,
-0.3420008718967438,
0.9227204918861389,
-0.37876570224761963,
-0.2429790496826172,
-0.7369681596755981,
-0.055046990513801575,
0.5038823485374451,
0.6635847091674805,
0.3964489996433258,
0.6848435401916504,
-0.6707738637924194,
0.32900723814964294,
0.5070151686668396,
0.2056642323732376,
0.4432598352432251,
0.7970978021621704,
0.08225765079259872,
-0.42881691455841064,
0.9961543083190918,
0.21842798590660095,
-0.48899319767951965,
0.6172618865966797,
0.08799148350954056,
0.019883958622813225,
-0.5453211665153503,
-0.8561896085739136,
0.2691992521286011,
-0.5498889684677124,
-0.32328084111213684,
-0.6123594045639038,
0.07756357640028,
-0.24793292582035065,
0.08309097588062286,
-0.47744515538215637,
-0.5764387249946594,
-0.6929259300231934,
-0.07431512326002121,
0.3326382040977478,
0.5694010853767395,
0.3708597421646118,
0.4119848310947418,
-0.580764651298523,
0.04040229320526123,
-0.26853394508361816,
0.24950487911701202,
-0.5221771597862244,
-0.615490734577179,
0.04800059273838997,
-0.3494313955307007,
0.14535774290561676,
-1.1436306238174438,
0.69024258852005,
0.2970309257507324,
0.7516870498657227,
0.4158305823802948,
-0.20147804915905,
0.5794568061828613,
-0.8358125686645508,
0.23148678243160248,
-0.12492232769727707,
-0.7508028149604797,
0.6273854374885559,
-0.02417311631143093,
-0.06990393251180649,
0.803529679775238,
0.8231804966926575,
-0.4621906876564026,
-0.171514630317688,
-0.9259417653083801,
-0.7203505039215088,
0.6383176445960999,
0.3331286609172821,
0.012493512593209743,
0.0013960635988041759,
0.3126136064529419,
0.1792084276676178,
0.12397461384534836,
-0.7011187672615051,
-0.2805480659008026,
0.15682737529277802,
-0.10904454439878464,
-0.0703640729188919,
-0.1112600639462471,
0.01782456785440445,
-0.03230620548129082,
0.8522982597351074,
-0.04972809553146362,
0.27341198921203613,
0.21009951829910278,
-0.7067111730575562,
0.2123602032661438,
0.4658275544643402,
0.7958616614341736,
0.7625571489334106,
-0.06592601537704468,
0.24334733188152313,
0.1770462542772293,
-0.23487690091133118,
-0.0579572431743145,
0.12571865320205688,
-0.1698840707540512,
0.5209536552429199,
0.28010061383247375,
1.0317974090576172,
0.35635146498680115,
-0.40930742025375366,
0.43151402473449707,
-0.3624437749385834,
0.12720264494419098,
-1.0801044702529907,
-0.13564752042293549,
-0.14093883335590363,
0.2041698843240738,
0.44741472601890564,
-0.019996605813503265,
0.23699255287647247,
-0.523866593837738,
0.4300273060798645,
0.1426299661397934,
-0.7445937991142273,
-0.38517892360687256,
0.31800734996795654,
0.12437207251787186,
-0.6036167144775391,
0.6735312342643738,
-0.3717029392719269,
-0.54947829246521,
0.6388669610023499,
0.4410116374492645,
0.6422939896583557,
-0.33916985988616943,
0.2316415160894394,
0.8568674325942993,
0.391154021024704,
-0.026214754208922386,
0.10899122059345245,
0.048476606607437134,
-0.8985421061515808,
0.014834584668278694,
-0.718985915184021,
-0.19184856116771698,
-0.004186368081718683,
-0.5684350728988647,
0.7805249691009521,
-0.317749559879303,
-0.42630061507225037,
0.5207306146621704,
-0.012591357342898846,
-0.7676520943641663,
0.3220365047454834,
-0.000345871812896803,
0.9579362869262695,
-0.5486747026443481,
0.9748410582542419,
0.6513729691505432,
-0.4961909055709839,
-0.2719813585281372,
-0.2309686839580536,
-0.021150080487132072,
-0.6236463785171509,
1.0237990617752075,
0.0037379772402346134,
-0.0633653849363327,
0.3099329173564911,
0.006148713640868664,
-1.2069969177246094,
0.8700281977653503,
0.04179120808839798,
-0.7489027380943298,
-0.012504702433943748,
-0.32812440395355225,
0.7628028392791748,
-0.6909484267234802,
0.37899550795555115,
0.6443721055984497,
0.638252854347229,
0.04145996272563934,
-0.9141353964805603,
-0.12528815865516663,
-0.1691654622554779,
-0.02173675410449505,
0.4898725152015686,
-0.40107250213623047,
0.37481069564819336,
-0.27036625146865845,
-0.4417526423931122,
0.3723137378692627,
1.0435116291046143,
-0.05760836973786354,
0.07621642202138901,
0.3498309254646301,
0.5894697308540344,
1.0495305061340332,
-0.5044434666633606,
0.8479382991790771,
-0.4379804730415344,
0.13966578245162964,
1.1595737934112549,
-0.09625106304883957,
1.1582512855529785,
0.655428946018219,
-0.15729330480098724,
0.6386400461196899,
0.586225688457489,
-0.23077981173992157,
0.375946968793869,
0.32322168350219727,
-0.15355399250984192,
0.09004970639944077,
-0.02072085253894329,
-0.21990303695201874,
0.9751960039138794,
0.16121801733970642,
-0.4440404176712036,
-0.13134856522083282,
-0.0994763970375061,
0.4062378406524658,
-0.032121676951646805,
-0.03652861341834068,
0.881144642829895,
-0.11928186565637589,
-0.5229019522666931,
0.3421829342842102,
0.11583573371171951,
0.747892439365387,
-0.507154643535614,
0.12005315721035004,
-0.17723068594932556,
0.18882513046264648,
-0.19961917400360107,
-0.4943784475326538,
0.3566083014011383,
0.04948849976062775,
-0.27372294664382935,
0.16898666322231293,
0.35355788469314575,
-0.4559749960899353,
-0.7644314169883728,
0.32698744535446167,
0.3648824691772461,
0.5659430027008057,
0.17302703857421875,
-0.1745867133140564,
-0.25600260496139526,
-0.17555254697799683,
-0.2227039486169815,
-0.04530519247055054,
0.4886191189289093,
-0.2932194173336029,
0.4017704129219055,
0.4680878818035126,
0.2441532164812088,
0.2596946060657501,
-0.043034788221120834,
0.5145307779312134,
-1.1127712726593018,
-0.5433980822563171,
-0.6613997220993042,
0.2649458348751068,
-0.10745043307542801,
-0.8703019618988037,
0.5866665244102478,
0.8373775482177734,
1.0401391983032227,
0.09121548384428024,
0.5350177884101868,
-0.19662778079509735,
0.5141537189483643,
-0.40826866030693054,
0.5816338658332825,
-0.3970564007759094,
-0.3012804687023163,
-0.37289562821388245,
-0.7556761503219604,
-0.3971630930900574,
0.5691921710968018,
-0.30940741300582886,
-0.31645822525024414,
0.8042933940887451,
0.846843957901001,
0.19250372052192688,
0.0030369313899427652,
0.35142096877098083,
0.11628977209329605,
0.08714061975479126,
0.32032468914985657,
0.7460711002349854,
-0.6228365898132324,
0.6821560859680176,
-0.40244051814079285,
-0.22659194469451904,
-0.30112403631210327,
-1.0528533458709717,
-0.7294047474861145,
-0.983758807182312,
-0.3228130042552948,
-0.3001972734928131,
0.30575132369995117,
0.7859206795692444,
0.6222649812698364,
-1.193668246269226,
-0.3090311288833618,
0.1481860727071762,
0.052050862461328506,
0.12168166041374207,
-0.11081785708665848,
0.3839207887649536,
-0.15650449693202972,
-1.086363673210144,
0.5890177488327026,
0.17169173061847687,
0.1711386889219284,
-0.08428674191236496,
-0.18818411231040955,
-0.4201122522354126,
-0.4372640550136566,
0.4611315131187439,
0.36505138874053955,
-0.6179100275039673,
-0.29080766439437866,
0.24294166266918182,
-0.19940070807933807,
0.5278701782226562,
0.9962128400802612,
-0.8495102524757385,
0.3646550476551056,
0.8047922253608704,
0.5032048225402832,
0.7032063007354736,
-0.056327980011701584,
0.4241369366645813,
-0.40874847769737244,
0.480974942445755,
0.32263511419296265,
0.7973490953445435,
0.5955847501754761,
-0.49263420701026917,
0.4821430742740631,
0.22002427279949188,
-0.48805123567581177,
-0.6333860754966736,
-0.04405101388692856,
-0.9721224308013916,
-0.0420752614736557,
0.8215226531028748,
-0.12014009058475494,
-0.5690420866012573,
-0.22766655683517456,
-0.17222653329372406,
0.22702106833457947,
-0.7246250510215759,
0.8061562776565552,
0.7293762564659119,
-0.06727588176727295,
-0.20812425017356873,
-0.6598103642463684,
0.39126765727996826,
0.17763954401016235,
-0.8483707904815674,
-0.5158587098121643,
0.5634300708770752,
0.40527456998825073,
0.36362946033477783,
0.6725310683250427,
-0.11714762449264526,
0.2920076549053192,
-0.1315792202949524,
0.15829811990261078,
0.2028920203447342,
-0.7038108110427856,
-0.47564077377319336,
-0.03893096745014191,
-0.03186303377151489,
-0.027378225699067116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00134v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00134v1
|
Transforming Dutch: Debiasing Dutch Coreference Resolution Systems for Non-binary Pronouns
| 2024-04-30T18:31:19 | 2024-04-30T18:31:19 |
Goya van Boven, Yupei Du, Dong Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Gender-neutral pronouns are increasingly being introduced across Western
languages. Recent evaluations have however demonstrated that English NLP
systems are unable to correctly process gender-neutral pronouns, with the risk
of erasing and misgendering non-binary individuals. This paper examines a Dutch
coreference resolution system's performance on gender-neutral pronouns,
specifically hen and die. In Dutch, these pronouns were only introduced in
2016, compared to the longstanding existence of singular they in English. We
additionally compare two debiasing techniques for coreference resolution
systems in non-binary contexts: Counterfactual Data Augmentation (CDA) and
delexicalisation. Moreover, because pronoun performance can be hard to
interpret from a general evaluation metric like LEA, we introduce an innovative
evaluation metric, the pronoun score, which directly represents the portion of
correctly processed pronouns. Our results reveal diminished performance on
gender-neutral pronouns compared to gendered counterparts. Nevertheless,
although delexicalisation fails to yield improvements, CDA substantially
reduces the performance gap between gendered and gender-neutral pronouns. We
further show that CDA remains effective in low-resource settings, in which a
limited set of debiasing documents is used. This efficacy extends to previously
unseen neopronouns, which are currently infrequently used but may gain
popularity in the future, underscoring the viability of effective debiasing
with minimal resources and low computational costs.
|
[
-0.5154423117637634,
-0.6414346098899841,
0.2529090344905853,
0.2343912571668625,
-0.3839525580406189,
-0.06762683391571045,
-0.37957537174224854,
-0.8822510838508606,
0.20893296599388123,
0.36471256613731384,
-0.24804925918579102,
-0.4922851026058197,
-0.7928466200828552,
0.5664504170417786,
-0.21169130504131317,
0.6778411269187927,
0.2873518764972687,
0.1425175815820694,
-0.2914382815361023,
-0.19194698333740234,
-0.7426971197128296,
-0.5152785778045654,
-0.05963868275284767,
-0.5318658947944641,
0.2709551155567169,
0.7123829126358032,
1.2072259187698364,
0.2980154752731323,
0.6094052791595459,
0.30193784832954407,
-0.17500987648963928,
0.2485920786857605,
-0.30799365043640137,
0.2660107910633087,
-0.34923428297042847,
-0.24904274940490723,
-0.3364621102809906,
0.273099809885025,
0.2961927354335785,
1.0720704793930054,
0.3339713513851166,
0.11034920066595078,
0.07413972914218903,
0.7736049890518188,
-1.028101921081543,
0.0684024915099144,
-0.4749757945537567,
0.18771719932556152,
0.10015837848186493,
0.028421593829989433,
-0.3610742390155792,
-0.45711109042167664,
0.285401850938797,
-0.5611997842788696,
0.26380616426467896,
-0.15317001938819885,
0.614641547203064,
0.09331119805574417,
-0.24350526928901672,
-0.2946138381958008,
-1.1047980785369873,
1.152591586112976,
-0.49725040793418884,
0.18002590537071228,
0.5155095458030701,
0.22364680469036102,
-0.07622673362493515,
-0.05612445995211601,
-0.4234711229801178,
-0.2623385488986969,
-0.07049740850925446,
0.09742782264947891,
-0.6430537104606628,
-0.07114612311124802,
0.08138556778430939,
0.22121934592723846,
-0.3672885298728943,
0.24135538935661316,
-0.2988223731517792,
-0.1508946716785431,
0.5743837356567383,
-0.2254418283700943,
0.04020421952009201,
-0.40164124965667725,
-0.12435422837734222,
-0.005596005357801914,
-0.5045529007911682,
-0.18972717225551605,
0.7066342234611511,
0.6995936036109924,
0.19539235532283783,
0.7639632225036621,
0.10916732251644135,
0.35858353972435,
0.5574050545692444,
-0.01243114285171032,
0.3946908712387085,
-0.1410333514213562,
-0.1507374346256256,
0.2809414267539978,
0.5260186195373535,
0.8001943230628967,
0.37773698568344116,
-0.2526133358478546,
-0.1443510502576828,
0.45404794812202454,
0.17827622592449188,
-0.5462638735771179,
-0.11123689264059067,
0.1729237139225006,
-0.41167929768562317,
-0.10062942653894424,
0.03390762209892273,
-0.433750718832016,
-0.434452623128891,
-0.47545573115348816,
0.339851438999176,
-0.6476141810417175,
-0.4507197141647339,
0.22472518682479858,
-0.2557920217514038,
0.11371704190969467,
0.45096254348754883,
-0.5847885012626648,
0.12551052868366241,
0.5641950964927673,
0.6321380138397217,
-0.053408533334732056,
0.1253991276025772,
-0.3625602722167969,
-0.18897834420204163,
-0.669931948184967,
0.5855766534805298,
-0.8192129135131836,
-0.7406321167945862,
0.05537038668990135,
0.009225823916494846,
0.2133464217185974,
-0.9242164492607117,
0.33667266368865967,
-0.2564489245414734,
0.24527636170387268,
-0.4966142177581787,
-0.2512959837913513,
-0.20359806716442108,
0.285163551568985,
-0.7219485640525818,
1.044627070426941,
-0.0656123086810112,
-0.7847885489463806,
0.5767621397972107,
-0.3505801558494568,
-0.27804961800575256,
-0.1540929526090622,
0.07179777324199677,
-0.04762081056833267,
0.18131768703460693,
0.19801513850688934,
0.5021013617515564,
-0.4388560354709625,
0.23765917122364044,
-0.2842459976673126,
-0.462896466255188,
-0.01105272863060236,
-0.22275274991989136,
0.8556069135665894,
-0.2628796696662903,
-0.2796594798564911,
-0.020929459482431412,
-0.8795179724693298,
-0.1967109739780426,
-0.25364065170288086,
0.09319441020488739,
-0.8368445634841919,
-0.24043749272823334,
0.011936245486140251,
0.30874934792518616,
0.260063111782074,
-0.7637829780578613,
0.02223222702741623,
-0.5010221004486084,
0.09519806504249573,
0.5383583307266235,
-0.25045475363731384,
0.6934081315994263,
-0.11541716009378433,
0.4381558299064636,
0.34632501006126404,
0.324535071849823,
0.24910010397434235,
-0.46119120717048645,
-0.7730076909065247,
-0.07858850061893463,
0.5096534490585327,
0.6547629833221436,
-0.8331965804100037,
0.8133476972579956,
-0.07651817798614502,
-0.709760844707489,
-0.4266411066055298,
0.03203524276614189,
0.39127305150032043,
0.524090051651001,
0.7364403605461121,
-0.30570295453071594,
-1.0013972520828247,
-1.3842954635620117,
-0.20564694702625275,
-0.5903385877609253,
-0.003959205001592636,
0.03056136704981327,
0.6721487045288086,
-0.28929010033607483,
0.9542197585105896,
0.024006061255931854,
-0.33193281292915344,
-0.13834653794765472,
0.37843289971351624,
0.5242266654968262,
0.6625602841377258,
0.8558940291404724,
-0.6610273718833923,
-0.242247074842453,
-0.19321218132972717,
-0.5750464200973511,
-0.1804579645395279,
-0.03160204738378525,
0.06451904773712158,
0.265732079744339,
0.14369416236877441,
-0.23845849931240082,
0.5128499269485474,
0.5066757798194885,
-0.5357521772384644,
0.9753596186637878,
-0.14692795276641846,
0.0720859169960022,
-0.5507206320762634,
0.20199228823184967,
-0.06662183254957199,
-0.4481886625289917,
-0.29190340638160706,
-0.3228590190410614,
-0.16063781082630157,
0.2699046730995178,
-0.5415546894073486,
0.28511330485343933,
-0.46839627623558044,
-0.13111940026283264,
-0.2956255376338959,
0.14240103960037231,
0.033499229699373245,
0.045574966818094254,
0.09842018783092499,
0.6842454671859741,
0.3791962265968323,
-0.7901845574378967,
0.26328903436660767,
0.3467705249786377,
-0.2904099225997925,
0.9676691889762878,
-0.6009348034858704,
0.13740502297878265,
-0.330344557762146,
-0.07590256631374359,
-0.9620707631111145,
0.5169132947921753,
0.1831883192062378,
-0.1873926818370819,
0.09260410070419312,
-0.03806041553616524,
-0.45561546087265015,
-0.3383752703666687,
-0.44671139121055603,
0.28011611104011536,
0.32297444343566895,
-0.3592950105667114,
0.45892420411109924,
0.3221754729747772,
0.12360686808824539,
-1.187750220298767,
-0.9253931045532227,
0.4723515510559082,
0.13933686912059784,
-0.3275536000728607,
0.49254027009010315,
0.0657639279961586,
-0.6222423315048218,
0.26552778482437134,
-0.20017960667610168,
0.084149569272995,
-0.06607786566019058,
0.3469465374946594,
0.09679292887449265,
0.01502406969666481,
0.19608578085899353,
0.13795731961727142,
-0.4900691509246826,
0.0341641791164875,
-0.12255766987800598,
0.20429953932762146,
-0.11698433756828308,
-0.12086904793977737,
-0.2779785096645355,
0.7122308611869812,
0.37368151545524597,
0.1632390171289444,
0.7044556140899658,
0.43114882707595825,
-0.3497627377510071,
-0.10588664561510086,
-0.7828951478004456,
-0.23406921327114105,
-0.34771573543548584,
0.06657739728689194,
-0.456630140542984,
-0.5943533182144165,
0.706160306930542,
0.053384628146886826,
0.2339308112859726,
0.7114230394363403,
0.37959209084510803,
-0.2038482427597046,
0.6200840473175049,
0.6789074540138245,
0.44750362634658813,
0.2731977105140686,
-0.23568303883075714,
0.1717061847448349,
-0.6027848720550537,
0.0003174592857249081,
-0.606536865234375,
-0.7073867321014404,
-0.7748066782951355,
-0.5952082276344299,
0.1292969137430191,
0.32197484374046326,
-0.114766925573349,
0.6080118417739868,
-0.47189417481422424,
0.44052329659461975,
0.6150747537612915,
0.11877040565013885,
0.4810922145843506,
-0.4352782666683197,
-0.15361171960830688,
-0.5617697238922119,
-0.4422931671142578,
-0.7870573401451111,
0.833344578742981,
0.01801791600883007,
0.44524165987968445,
0.08191243559122086,
0.5311965346336365,
0.7038753628730774,
0.20601220428943634,
-0.6334632039070129,
0.6612657308578491,
-0.7019665241241455,
-0.6158433556556702,
-0.16948534548282623,
-0.1781921684741974,
-0.8220248818397522,
0.2798132300376892,
-0.3049299716949463,
-0.377275675535202,
1.1070975065231323,
-0.046139515936374664,
-0.15856900811195374,
0.38858625292778015,
-0.4365735650062561,
0.505530059337616,
0.1695595234632492,
-0.2990395724773407,
-0.2191920131444931,
-0.6361876130104065,
0.24433231353759766,
-0.005586273968219757,
0.011006264947354794,
-0.4665500521659851,
-0.1639910340309143,
0.848650336265564,
-0.45641788840293884,
1.258198618888855,
-0.4513269364833832,
-0.3975120186805725,
0.29894885420799255,
0.40066832304000854,
0.2503589391708374,
-0.01229348685592413,
-0.5055476427078247,
0.6343457698822021,
0.13610556721687317,
-0.26145514845848083,
-0.5693162679672241,
0.6048949360847473,
-0.8173470497131348,
-0.5083304047584534,
-0.41877058148384094,
-0.2674587368965149,
-0.22749672830104828,
0.09042862802743912,
0.04592427983880043,
-0.026775628328323364,
-0.476998507976532,
0.3699045479297638,
0.32320693135261536,
-0.34234434366226196,
0.4309539198875427,
0.6555570363998413,
-0.048881132155656815,
-0.48677775263786316,
0.27117738127708435,
0.5649122595787048,
-0.06749965995550156,
0.3199295699596405,
0.270585298538208,
-0.4275416135787964,
-0.16251623630523682,
-0.2021569013595581,
0.06027577444911003,
-0.9417533278465271,
-0.3973352611064911,
-0.6499260067939758,
0.252293199300766,
-0.3873025178909302,
-0.2376362681388855,
-0.7128337621688843,
-0.761461079120636,
-0.31646883487701416,
-0.1863100528717041,
0.1916615217924118,
0.3923245370388031,
-0.7480435371398926,
0.024637984111905098,
-0.5531482696533203,
0.44975510239601135,
0.380222886800766,
0.018071476370096207,
-0.3995380699634552,
-0.47196096181869507,
-0.007307988125830889,
-0.14494791626930237,
-0.011976653710007668,
-1.0902520418167114,
0.16272498667240143,
0.167744442820549,
0.19758374989032745,
0.324768990278244,
0.5528842806816101,
0.7588186860084534,
-0.30000537633895874,
0.805985152721405,
0.29225462675094604,
-1.1675212383270264,
0.5041564106941223,
-0.11013594269752502,
0.15555614233016968,
0.8190011382102966,
0.265415221452713,
-0.6078941822052002,
-0.32327353954315186,
-0.4925287961959839,
-1.0100914239883423,
0.3711155951023102,
0.09467540681362152,
0.2343265861272812,
-0.27503299713134766,
0.563101053237915,
0.8448993563652039,
0.24675801396369934,
-0.3748931288719177,
-0.3990113437175751,
-0.15601888298988342,
0.30322232842445374,
-0.013677853159606457,
-0.6153480410575867,
0.03506099432706833,
-0.33254361152648926,
0.8124272227287292,
-0.1815277636051178,
0.25565892457962036,
0.34673136472702026,
-0.22122587263584137,
-0.19951801002025604,
0.4093431830406189,
0.21047651767730713,
0.7550577521324158,
-0.27337828278541565,
0.2843973934650421,
0.03410133719444275,
-0.3313181400299072,
0.45808693766593933,
-0.17643092572689056,
-0.4086529314517975,
0.573270320892334,
0.5409526228904724,
0.4630340337753296,
0.4428473114967346,
-0.27506279945373535,
0.5376061797142029,
0.09438078850507736,
-0.4278506934642792,
-0.390449583530426,
-0.15079712867736816,
-0.30121293663978577,
0.16718609631061554,
0.32334208488464355,
0.2522120773792267,
0.06262853741645813,
-0.3903580605983734,
0.061445195227861404,
0.33086875081062317,
-0.5218113660812378,
-0.4824521541595459,
0.3736118674278259,
0.4115024507045746,
0.048743732273578644,
0.41453850269317627,
-0.21239712834358215,
-0.22818663716316223,
0.41892728209495544,
0.5430192351341248,
1.1876022815704346,
-0.3685961365699768,
0.5534583926200867,
0.5572903752326965,
0.5686509013175964,
-0.04332781583070755,
0.6088611483573914,
-0.04422444477677345,
-1.015712022781372,
-0.7759361267089844,
-0.3439905345439911,
-0.5959416627883911,
0.0020092835184186697,
-0.7701501846313477,
0.2272079735994339,
-0.3425309658050537,
-0.545927107334137,
-0.14738240838050842,
0.18117162585258484,
-0.9174186587333679,
0.1747238039970398,
0.09791965782642365,
0.7331309914588928,
-1.0434523820877075,
0.36816152930259705,
0.8821418881416321,
-0.17011593282222748,
0.12007484585046768,
-0.4151098430156708,
-0.21683679521083832,
-0.42374831438064575,
1.0383988618850708,
0.3169976770877838,
-0.40120089054107666,
-0.44582632184028625,
-0.20533645153045654,
-0.5387858748435974,
0.5208835005760193,
0.7636190056800842,
-0.9103752374649048,
-0.013168036006391048,
0.38331055641174316,
0.6641051769256592,
-0.13436785340309143,
0.5197546482086182,
0.49995094537734985,
1.0274909734725952,
-0.3478449285030365,
-1.1846529245376587,
0.023465357720851898,
-0.21261170506477356,
0.05384809151291847,
-0.15340366959571838,
-0.35194581747055054,
0.6691665053367615,
-0.12150271236896515,
-0.37177181243896484,
-0.2047935277223587,
0.7292383909225464,
-0.2509084641933441,
0.011249578557908535,
0.8764349222183228,
0.3715554475784302,
0.746873676776886,
-0.06870763748884201,
0.6732310056686401,
-0.12428661435842514,
0.0429471917450428,
1.0605722665786743,
-0.4520213007926941,
0.6415347456932068,
0.7211151719093323,
-0.1896904557943344,
0.6258183121681213,
0.3145352303981781,
0.2513057291507721,
0.25078171491622925,
0.11061832308769226,
0.04937095195055008,
-0.7111584544181824,
-0.40794840455055237,
-0.20471704006195068,
0.8230656385421753,
0.30410224199295044,
-0.23565398156642914,
-0.4200798273086548,
0.39481455087661743,
-0.19838838279247284,
0.4400770664215088,
-0.11105682700872421,
0.7259758114814758,
-0.04035818949341774,
-0.30889633297920227,
0.6885991096496582,
-0.0008042308036237955,
0.8233085870742798,
-0.26001831889152527,
-0.12252200394868851,
-0.04423586651682854,
0.23785410821437836,
-0.19595617055892944,
-0.6219176054000854,
0.6894984841346741,
-0.012482082471251488,
-0.6809720396995544,
-0.2958216369152069,
0.6570016145706177,
-0.17054805159568787,
-0.6059913039207458,
0.7437068819999695,
0.8502456545829773,
0.10613605380058289,
-0.2090519666671753,
-0.7987316846847534,
-0.13629594445228577,
-0.2610794007778168,
-0.1538008600473404,
-0.11110340803861618,
0.46486884355545044,
-0.1894490271806717,
0.32745155692100525,
0.4517171382904053,
0.22754155099391937,
-0.3408210873603821,
0.12171246111392975,
0.6323474049568176,
-0.8495297431945801,
-0.38659238815307617,
-0.7600944638252258,
0.16117119789123535,
0.05648176744580269,
-0.47482728958129883,
0.8027691841125488,
0.4634346663951874,
0.7594276666641235,
-0.12693415582180023,
0.5973570346832275,
-0.06351012736558914,
0.5960490107536316,
-0.050978969782590866,
0.24056902527809143,
-0.1982128918170929,
0.17958229780197144,
-0.3720577359199524,
-1.2378973960876465,
-0.7154218554496765,
0.5828454494476318,
-0.6310179233551025,
-0.057742681354284286,
0.3420467972755432,
0.5121138095855713,
0.1084768995642662,
0.027879470959305763,
0.6264200210571289,
0.22943668067455292,
0.2696789801120758,
0.375119149684906,
0.7859985828399658,
-0.614151656627655,
0.3571076989173889,
-0.6404516696929932,
-0.07460562884807587,
-0.37899598479270935,
-1.1312553882598877,
-0.821792721748352,
-0.5052091479301453,
-0.65346759557724,
-0.27462807297706604,
0.31246820092201233,
1.0110889673233032,
0.6133638024330139,
-1.0329833030700684,
0.11663732677698135,
0.17328302562236786,
0.1312951296567917,
-0.7058834433555603,
-0.21958313882350922,
0.3573484718799591,
-0.22480149567127228,
-1.0322457551956177,
0.5761111378669739,
0.24198009073734283,
-0.2931627929210663,
-0.5665791630744934,
0.1473665088415146,
-0.22411894798278809,
-0.03258455917239189,
0.666211724281311,
0.0961194783449173,
-0.6556816101074219,
-0.45628389716148376,
-0.23630379140377045,
0.05113616958260536,
0.17332765460014343,
0.7854403853416443,
-1.0070796012878418,
0.6112509965896606,
0.7441985011100769,
0.3818117380142212,
-0.0731612965464592,
-0.01736338436603546,
0.6425142884254456,
-0.9071254730224609,
0.3217929005622864,
0.5768315196037292,
0.2524116039276123,
0.5332953333854675,
-0.355779230594635,
0.4834146201610565,
0.3654485046863556,
-0.2073925882577896,
-0.7738049030303955,
0.08441972732543945,
-0.6522603034973145,
-0.40388116240501404,
1.0872329473495483,
0.04101026430726051,
-0.22683995962142944,
-0.6561305522918701,
-0.1451188176870346,
0.15698610246181488,
-0.4343181848526001,
0.6877011060714722,
0.593900740146637,
-0.027500195428729057,
0.17869234085083008,
-0.3407205641269684,
0.21171431243419647,
0.6306765675544739,
-0.10783766210079193,
0.2460375726222992,
0.5128767490386963,
-0.022783227264881134,
0.6880565285682678,
0.24790462851524353,
-0.2443356066942215,
0.36775559186935425,
-0.058738432824611664,
0.41619303822517395,
-0.23466135561466217,
-0.31197431683540344,
-0.1306314468383789,
0.2423372119665146,
-0.2543375790119171,
-0.30829012393951416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00123v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00123v1
|
Graph Neural Network Approach to Semantic Type Detection in Tables
| 2024-04-30T18:17:44 | 2024-04-30T18:17:44 |
Ehsan Hoseinzade, Ke Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
This study addresses the challenge of detecting semantic column types in
relational tables, a key task in many real-world applications. While language
models like BERT have improved prediction accuracy, their token input
constraints limit the simultaneous processing of intra-table and inter-table
information. We propose a novel approach using Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) to
model intra-table dependencies, allowing language models to focus on
inter-table information. Our proposed method not only outperforms existing
state-of-the-art algorithms but also offers novel insights into the utility and
functionality of various GNN types for semantic type detection. The code is
available at https://github.com/hoseinzadeehsan/GAIT
|
[
-0.12339393049478531,
-0.7168339490890503,
0.599540114402771,
-0.11681003868579865,
-0.3875212073326111,
-0.03532291203737259,
0.29295095801353455,
-0.6385107040405273,
0.5101974606513977,
0.4497833251953125,
-0.4632531404495239,
-0.8003795742988586,
-0.7089225053787231,
-0.04925331845879555,
-0.7372446656227112,
0.7551008462905884,
-0.09295899420976639,
0.3032090663909912,
-0.6401834487915039,
-0.28692078590393066,
-0.3339070975780487,
-0.4740375876426697,
-0.41740575432777405,
-0.42837467789649963,
0.6192162036895752,
0.3916553854942322,
0.8241932392120361,
0.5927896499633789,
0.6277724504470825,
0.2997052073478699,
-0.0412331186234951,
0.18105857074260712,
-0.13108320534229279,
0.032412461936473846,
0.2736063301563263,
-0.2672421336174011,
-0.2678605020046234,
-0.4090172052383423,
0.6946523189544678,
0.591346025466919,
0.17298515141010284,
0.012498700059950352,
-0.08640014380216599,
0.5743894577026367,
-0.3509303033351898,
0.793792188167572,
-0.8537653088569641,
0.4819043278694153,
-0.4461601674556732,
0.10903095453977585,
-0.5209792256355286,
-0.3938602805137634,
0.13893921673297882,
-0.37417152523994446,
0.1856604814529419,
0.26844653487205505,
0.9138049483299255,
-0.1707024723291397,
-0.4811606705188751,
-0.28150737285614014,
-0.4830840528011322,
-0.11239588260650635,
-0.8106364011764526,
0.6640092134475708,
0.22827450931072235,
0.09565617889165878,
-0.4458891749382019,
-1.0624184608459473,
-0.8735995292663574,
-0.699788510799408,
-0.6266226768493652,
-0.22234001755714417,
-0.07469610869884491,
0.3190523087978363,
0.04719305410981178,
0.12871597707271576,
-0.8410729765892029,
0.11486473679542542,
-0.02702747844159603,
-0.3249336779117584,
0.027486519888043404,
0.21147160232067108,
0.886861264705658,
-0.14045758545398712,
-0.15816237032413483,
0.29714882373809814,
-0.5792735815048218,
0.07042986154556274,
0.317113995552063,
0.6118313074111938,
0.11579969525337219,
0.5260922312736511,
-0.37415680289268494,
1.0947872400283813,
-0.4395279884338379,
0.25853824615478516,
0.0531761534512043,
-0.4003986716270447,
-0.01995483972132206,
0.003504656720906496,
0.6886311173439026,
0.06250493228435516,
0.41608262062072754,
-0.7749291062355042,
0.06520168483257294,
0.32773351669311523,
0.06566610187292099,
-0.5535053014755249,
-0.53562992811203,
-0.06096399202942848,
-0.3300526440143585,
-0.4559983015060425,
-0.21013806760311127,
-0.6731616258621216,
-0.5633120536804199,
-0.3987523913383484,
0.5854243636131287,
-0.5081608891487122,
-0.20835763216018677,
-0.10703405737876892,
-0.1259004920721054,
0.1998509168624878,
0.22789804637432098,
-1.1369200944900513,
0.4326743483543396,
0.6601864099502563,
1.1456714868545532,
-0.021981991827487946,
-0.1546570360660553,
-0.7568150758743286,
0.3671906888484955,
-0.1897125542163849,
0.8010939359664917,
-0.6105283498764038,
-0.2505360543727875,
0.15342077612876892,
-0.28007158637046814,
-0.153305783867836,
-0.397474467754364,
0.28428539633750916,
-0.6486169695854187,
-0.10192620009183884,
-0.18935002386569977,
-0.636276125907898,
-0.28883183002471924,
0.33512336015701294,
-0.9563478827476501,
0.9269858598709106,
0.4755304157733917,
-1.0293357372283936,
0.7740704417228699,
-0.6179391741752625,
-0.6019657254219055,
0.2789711058139801,
-0.49449533224105835,
-0.6900832653045654,
0.037400051951408386,
0.16246332228183746,
0.3309668302536011,
-0.008285416290163994,
0.2910762429237366,
-0.8123340010643005,
-0.3580271005630493,
0.09841185808181763,
0.27168649435043335,
0.5581095218658447,
-0.30879542231559753,
0.047296445816755295,
0.631251871585846,
-0.9610981345176697,
0.23796561360359192,
0.12123171240091324,
-0.22635222971439362,
-0.1963934451341629,
0.17116697132587433,
-0.19486787915229797,
0.6002777218818665,
-0.16433952748775482,
-0.6394652128219604,
0.26563915610313416,
-0.17923793196678162,
0.7171716094017029,
0.5202909111976624,
-0.2594253122806549,
0.23301035165786743,
0.0842038244009018,
0.17299066483974457,
0.22352978587150574,
0.14691688120365143,
0.7230934500694275,
-0.6909558773040771,
-0.707497775554657,
-0.040260717272758484,
0.47990912199020386,
0.6869603991508484,
-0.8818233609199524,
0.31734445691108704,
-0.34703966975212097,
-0.3572246730327606,
-0.1245403066277504,
-0.05685214325785637,
0.3002829849720001,
1.0699646472930908,
0.5145977735519409,
-0.5052061676979065,
-0.508247971534729,
-0.7584689855575562,
-0.41997337341308594,
-0.366001695394516,
0.16640570759773254,
0.40412774682044983,
0.6707993745803833,
0.016306135803461075,
1.2813265323638916,
-0.10830598324537277,
-0.3819344937801361,
-0.25568631291389465,
0.10126038640737534,
0.10935240983963013,
0.5817409753799438,
0.6003023386001587,
-0.8478962779045105,
-0.7199590802192688,
0.14105145633220673,
-0.8171141743659973,
0.250699520111084,
0.4467926025390625,
-0.006254221778362989,
0.13975436985492706,
0.6726368069648743,
-0.697886049747467,
0.7624977231025696,
0.2385396659374237,
-0.49036163091659546,
0.48223981261253357,
-0.1342250108718872,
-0.43014517426490784,
-0.5172176957130432,
-0.012415173463523388,
-0.029369978234171867,
-0.2524555027484894,
-0.9643083214759827,
-0.3212091624736786,
0.14462357759475708,
-0.1922149509191513,
-0.2783016860485077,
0.31201764941215515,
-0.45293283462524414,
-0.5788949728012085,
0.3039829134941101,
0.16316190361976624,
0.14484424889087677,
0.5414833426475525,
0.1009482890367508,
0.5438451766967773,
0.3176073133945465,
-0.49457573890686035,
0.5111107230186462,
0.5245073437690735,
-0.5593820810317993,
0.10309956967830658,
-0.5569186210632324,
0.24301661550998688,
-0.3194783926010132,
0.41867703199386597,
-1.5276974439620972,
-0.10795744508504868,
0.7663352489471436,
-0.5657907128334045,
0.5932472944259644,
-0.5582441091537476,
-0.6407296061515808,
-0.7134891152381897,
0.13792213797569275,
0.04290622100234032,
-0.10288392007350922,
-0.497056245803833,
1.0141956806182861,
0.19408062100410461,
0.23165521025657654,
-0.6916378140449524,
-0.820486307144165,
0.15476007759571075,
-0.12241790443658829,
-1.0772963762283325,
0.33818289637565613,
0.3598240613937378,
-0.02188573218882084,
0.33849242329597473,
-0.2860795855522156,
-0.26940301060676575,
0.2377811223268509,
-0.009596576914191246,
0.4341663420200348,
-0.251143217086792,
0.36023616790771484,
-0.22517965734004974,
-0.13916775584220886,
0.13775485754013062,
-0.7879716157913208,
0.8213548064231873,
-0.2044810652732849,
-0.19752484560012817,
-0.6228892207145691,
0.17605501413345337,
0.33960238099098206,
-0.32757192850112915,
0.827582597732544,
0.6963558793067932,
-0.30243146419525146,
0.028670478612184525,
-0.11080183833837509,
-0.11294646561145782,
-0.4495263397693634,
0.8478585481643677,
-0.3670428395271301,
-0.7877011299133301,
0.8094857931137085,
0.22484584152698517,
-0.5788943767547607,
0.3706189692020416,
0.34092557430267334,
0.07834742218255997,
0.8886668682098389,
0.3609141707420349,
-0.33467260003089905,
0.5554459095001221,
-0.15891188383102417,
0.4930954575538635,
-0.6538447737693787,
-0.19477440416812897,
-0.7775154113769531,
-0.45803457498550415,
-0.4566013216972351,
-0.08564630895853043,
0.25175997614860535,
-0.14636056125164032,
-0.31996750831604004,
0.22442619502544403,
-0.6663725972175598,
0.3897716701030731,
0.6262436509132385,
0.2845059931278229,
0.29351112246513367,
-0.15275555849075317,
-0.5143616795539856,
0.36182183027267456,
-0.656473696231842,
0.02682671695947647,
0.9646216034889221,
0.15631690621376038,
0.31601282954216003,
0.0027588088996708393,
0.6264393329620361,
0.45739123225212097,
0.38551557064056396,
-0.7942911982536316,
0.6926857829093933,
-0.4630337655544281,
-0.43005314469337463,
-0.7120453119277954,
-0.508661687374115,
-0.5414695739746094,
0.3608234226703644,
-0.20285770297050476,
-1.1807901859283447,
0.0844697505235672,
0.24143120646476746,
-0.08779004216194153,
0.5886427164077759,
-0.6645536422729492,
1.2957361936569214,
-0.2218068391084671,
-0.16444137692451477,
0.2562124729156494,
-0.9233711361885071,
0.2557777166366577,
0.45997294783592224,
-0.07635553181171417,
-0.1700924038887024,
0.28671589493751526,
0.6327450275421143,
-0.7211276888847351,
0.6841669082641602,
-0.5801647901535034,
0.3041701912879944,
0.37381789088249207,
0.20242847502231598,
0.9657452702522278,
0.08203212171792984,
-0.00427563302218914,
0.13599318265914917,
-0.2725456953048706,
-0.14792396128177643,
-0.6181614995002747,
0.3569369912147522,
-0.5580450892448425,
-0.13959266245365143,
-0.2971828579902649,
-0.7844679951667786,
-0.7059526443481445,
0.2650792896747589,
0.38540446758270264,
0.5997298359870911,
0.08381713181734085,
-0.05811915546655655,
0.24292805790901184,
0.2714482545852661,
0.5127015113830566,
0.15502992272377014,
-0.3998912274837494,
-0.5965050458908081,
0.9350875020027161,
0.5681906342506409,
0.035443827509880066,
0.4707772135734558,
0.28521427512168884,
-0.5037477016448975,
-1.0755614042282104,
-0.7435563802719116,
-0.026244763284921646,
-0.7838113307952881,
-0.11697942763566971,
-0.6007424592971802,
-0.12553194165229797,
-0.4029909670352936,
0.22795037925243378,
0.2818084955215454,
-0.5736182332038879,
-0.2955760955810547,
-0.28782543540000916,
0.6488720774650574,
0.7666462063789368,
0.3180679678916931,
0.4141073226928711,
-0.7180888056755066,
0.014652274549007416,
0.5543175339698792,
0.7265906929969788,
0.22338537871837616,
-0.2602955102920532,
-0.08023224025964737,
-0.27365928888320923,
0.2780824303627014,
-0.8303044438362122,
0.34693998098373413,
0.25327837467193604,
0.5495444536209106,
0.09570538252592087,
-0.2788539230823517,
0.3491101562976837,
-0.43290460109710693,
0.4787096679210663,
0.1559886634349823,
-0.9541143178939819,
0.12193211913108826,
-0.4024706780910492,
-0.09225539118051529,
0.6867236495018005,
0.3343697488307953,
-0.74772709608078,
0.09471569955348969,
-0.24540331959724426,
-0.8680526614189148,
0.7699969410896301,
-0.027131784707307816,
-0.21712146699428558,
0.08880294114351273,
0.42592179775238037,
-0.12447641789913177,
0.2491612434387207,
-0.9195998311042786,
0.05751728639006615,
-0.20298486948013306,
-0.2483818680047989,
0.30411389470100403,
-0.18557623028755188,
0.11366889625787735,
-0.4218898415565491,
0.4769270718097687,
-0.40371909737586975,
0.4094898998737335,
0.1201336458325386,
-0.3167250454425812,
0.12290836125612259,
-0.054460909217596054,
0.7796047329902649,
0.5399055480957031,
-0.27879372239112854,
-0.10437922179698944,
0.08829197287559509,
-0.6597219705581665,
-0.11926332116127014,
0.18082840740680695,
-0.3962043523788452,
0.27022045850753784,
0.19972831010818481,
0.9875053763389587,
-0.022037815302610397,
0.12074645608663559,
0.34230929613113403,
-0.18266545236110687,
-0.10807623714208603,
-0.28523024916648865,
-0.1290399432182312,
0.30931147933006287,
-0.11564630270004272,
-0.2563435435295105,
-0.15912804007530212,
0.2846764624118805,
-0.3736911416053772,
0.4685074985027313,
0.6402509212493896,
-0.9483616948127747,
-0.08907704055309296,
0.5461132526397705,
-0.052994903177022934,
-0.45081377029418945,
1.0042494535446167,
-0.19687524437904358,
-0.6808353066444397,
0.9370444416999817,
0.6941738724708557,
0.8464927673339844,
0.04869673401117325,
0.2943829298019409,
-0.007601267192512751,
0.09295788407325745,
0.3709750771522522,
0.49777278304100037,
0.09597013890743256,
-1.0605061054229736,
-0.12957920134067535,
-0.4291594922542572,
-0.5183941721916199,
0.0618264302611351,
-0.2553974986076355,
0.2925277352333069,
-0.5960930585861206,
-0.06561888009309769,
0.2758833169937134,
-0.29616817831993103,
-0.40928736329078674,
0.08956027776002884,
0.2193899154663086,
0.8362756967544556,
-0.661382257938385,
1.1286659240722656,
0.4401908218860626,
-0.7600861191749573,
-0.868497908115387,
-0.3096822202205658,
-0.08514240384101868,
-0.9993199706077576,
0.8222953677177429,
0.17878153920173645,
0.150699645280838,
-0.07524546980857849,
-0.3294045925140381,
-1.039463758468628,
0.8561544418334961,
0.3246019184589386,
-0.20068714022636414,
-0.5710573792457581,
0.7411115169525146,
0.4279443025588989,
-0.3410865366458893,
0.3806919753551483,
0.6576184630393982,
0.7318419218063354,
-0.0704229548573494,
-0.6451424956321716,
-0.05645212158560753,
-0.2076292484998703,
0.2669193148612976,
0.6513361930847168,
-0.4945613443851471,
1.1135954856872559,
0.3089427947998047,
0.1816323846578598,
-0.0923735499382019,
0.7523263692855835,
-0.18868035078048706,
0.24429422616958618,
0.6767182946205139,
0.8027929067611694,
0.7751121520996094,
-0.315048485994339,
0.7037733197212219,
-0.4072088897228241,
0.3753032088279724,
1.2610336542129517,
-0.6132806539535522,
0.44761037826538086,
0.22471170127391815,
-0.32072150707244873,
0.8729261755943298,
0.5000055432319641,
-0.030854593962430954,
0.3463461399078369,
0.7914634346961975,
-0.35296088457107544,
-0.06808537989854813,
-0.10894173383712769,
-0.40942683815956116,
0.6012290120124817,
0.7192593216896057,
-0.33860084414482117,
-0.48153766989707947,
-0.20105834305286407,
0.060608383268117905,
-0.20763491094112396,
-0.3746725618839264,
0.655569851398468,
-0.2417357861995697,
-0.21848827600479126,
0.15244388580322266,
-0.4078886806964874,
0.15210463106632233,
-0.760298490524292,
-0.12122531980276108,
0.016284415498375893,
0.040105488151311874,
-0.3760927617549896,
-0.7509927749633789,
0.25589340925216675,
-0.7627812623977661,
-0.031632255762815475,
0.32656580209732056,
1.2703057527542114,
-0.4258377254009247,
-0.26892149448394775,
0.5320086479187012,
0.4003257751464844,
-0.34310200810432434,
-0.20931868255138397,
-0.36484915018081665,
-0.245332270860672,
-0.44072481989860535,
0.004445182625204325,
0.5621433258056641,
0.6810063123703003,
-0.22144931554794312,
0.577256977558136,
0.4967852830886841,
-0.26824867725372314,
0.2986679673194885,
0.13971784710884094,
0.9323828220367432,
-0.33209723234176636,
-0.8164693117141724,
-0.8018265962600708,
0.28690096735954285,
-0.23701055347919464,
-0.30929437279701233,
0.39130914211273193,
0.4576408863067627,
0.6261115670204163,
-0.3207693099975586,
0.6216996312141418,
-0.06454046815633774,
0.3291019797325134,
-0.5842936635017395,
0.9761821031570435,
-0.12329757958650589,
-0.21964295208454132,
-0.4729030430316925,
-0.5287607312202454,
-0.87875896692276,
0.3819722831249237,
-0.42727118730545044,
-0.049218833446502686,
0.7133605480194092,
0.6474791765213013,
0.10096041113138199,
0.41543498635292053,
0.07737841457128525,
0.001865969505161047,
0.3823041021823883,
0.4774351418018341,
0.7832381129264832,
-0.07128152996301651,
0.7816426753997803,
-0.30352649092674255,
0.09870199114084244,
-0.3539747893810272,
-0.9307965040206909,
-0.5843574404716492,
-0.5595172643661499,
-0.09706505388021469,
-0.7691037058830261,
0.11142908036708832,
0.6093789935112,
0.6164756417274475,
-1.0367438793182373,
-0.10953518003225327,
-0.6424432396888733,
0.3309096693992615,
-0.09452361613512039,
-0.19712549448013306,
0.6660721898078918,
-0.48360544443130493,
0.08321154862642288,
0.14315275847911835,
0.35942551493644714,
0.027173947542905807,
-0.05812174081802368,
0.22359123826026917,
-0.7009932994842529,
-0.17319366335868835,
0.5695350766181946,
0.4381798207759857,
-0.4981866478919983,
-1.05401611328125,
-0.15931709110736847,
-0.051727667450904846,
0.5312017202377319,
0.8579240441322327,
-0.9537067413330078,
0.2955731451511383,
0.8946399688720703,
0.6879974007606506,
0.6078819632530212,
-0.29064542055130005,
0.16159437596797943,
-0.7028478980064392,
0.19043876230716705,
0.4965623617172241,
0.7797227501869202,
0.08999515324831009,
-0.46697622537612915,
0.8621876239776611,
0.6833313703536987,
-0.5315580368041992,
-0.529686450958252,
0.3903716802597046,
-1.0143460035324097,
0.08460599184036255,
0.6746702194213867,
-0.08287963271141052,
-0.3213704526424408,
-0.513985276222229,
-0.07562755793333054,
0.315433531999588,
-0.3054688572883606,
0.6757501363754272,
0.7285994291305542,
-0.5580094456672668,
0.16826243698596954,
-0.2519402801990509,
0.5574365854263306,
0.10954326391220093,
-0.7344130873680115,
-0.11530821025371552,
0.41383764147758484,
0.09637414664030075,
0.2597326636314392,
0.6309326887130737,
-0.08823374658823013,
0.24320830404758453,
0.0005350757855921984,
0.05661497637629509,
-0.27756425738334656,
-0.4220428466796875,
-0.031439680606126785,
0.3588693141937256,
-0.08471296727657318,
-0.32452359795570374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00099v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00099v2
|
Creative Beam Search: LLM-as-a-Judge For Improving Response Generation
| 2024-04-30T18:00:02 | 2024-05-09T15:14:19 |
Giorgio Franceschelli, Mirco Musolesi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Large language models are revolutionizing several areas, including artificial
creativity. However, the process of generation in machines profoundly diverges
from that observed in humans. In particular, machine generation is
characterized by a lack of intentionality and an underlying creative process.
We propose a method called Creative Beam Search that uses Diverse Beam Search
and LLM-as-a-Judge to perform response generation and response validation. The
results of a qualitative experiment show how our approach can provide better
output than standard sampling techniques. We also show that the response
validation step is a necessary complement to the response generation step.
|
[
-0.567112922668457,
-0.7940932512283325,
0.8534259796142578,
0.2931630611419678,
-0.20566101372241974,
0.45316359400749207,
0.04386589303612709,
-0.3917073905467987,
0.2131711095571518,
0.4188675582408905,
-0.8480756282806396,
-0.13806957006454468,
-0.5144473910331726,
0.31000328063964844,
-0.4529145061969757,
0.5237982273101807,
-0.1182982325553894,
0.318895161151886,
-0.16693471372127533,
0.09083719551563263,
-0.7548043727874756,
-0.10132590681314468,
-0.6999508142471313,
-0.6155690550804138,
0.5908766984939575,
0.3895682692527771,
0.4950970709323883,
0.33105987310409546,
0.7183605432510376,
0.4003849923610687,
-0.1972488909959793,
0.5507115125656128,
-0.4062032699584961,
0.4284139573574066,
-0.5226012468338013,
-0.6199260354042053,
-0.14160816371440887,
0.05183616280555725,
0.42574459314346313,
0.48122650384902954,
-0.08462875336408615,
0.1042255312204361,
-0.26974642276763916,
0.8491023182868958,
-0.5573537945747375,
-0.0784483253955841,
-0.7466899752616882,
0.49282318353652954,
-0.12651777267456055,
-0.520297110080719,
-0.5783526301383972,
-0.7700702548027039,
-0.18766725063323975,
-0.4621015191078186,
0.5120256543159485,
0.3745458126068115,
0.511245846748352,
0.3493621051311493,
-0.5416982173919678,
-0.5514083504676819,
-1.0637041330337524,
0.6725781559944153,
-0.7953943610191345,
0.27985042333602905,
0.1318971961736679,
0.5360155701637268,
-0.5289936661720276,
-0.8384528756141663,
-0.7460017800331116,
-0.43719160556793213,
0.1102655902504921,
0.3700799345970154,
0.008850833401083946,
0.14409181475639343,
0.579831063747406,
0.41918662190437317,
-0.7543531060218811,
0.0713033378124237,
-0.04782354459166527,
-0.036560118198394775,
0.8728036284446716,
0.4333999752998352,
0.17977440357208252,
-0.1981932669878006,
-0.16880397498607635,
-0.19879670441150665,
-0.6122521162033081,
0.2754834294319153,
0.5318352580070496,
0.0752670094370842,
0.40919896960258484,
0.8732426166534424,
-0.6845237612724304,
0.6520451307296753,
0.2426450401544571,
-0.04533018171787262,
0.14149470627307892,
-0.3580932319164276,
-0.056319709867239,
-0.0395900160074234,
0.6028756499290466,
0.37046805024147034,
-0.040783267468214035,
-0.08097825944423676,
-0.6201825141906738,
0.21692438423633575,
0.49270033836364746,
-0.8718960285186768,
0.10478463023900986,
0.18712006509304047,
-0.5675114393234253,
-0.33351367712020874,
0.17870384454727173,
-0.53959721326828,
-0.6165242195129395,
-0.3397153913974762,
0.3277566134929657,
-0.1466394066810608,
-0.006370977032929659,
0.267088919878006,
-0.49419447779655457,
0.07050720602273941,
0.34676969051361084,
-0.7002949118614197,
0.07384057343006134,
0.38835981488227844,
0.4956246316432953,
0.06412100791931152,
-0.0198302511125803,
-1.036948800086975,
-0.2522428333759308,
-0.5885153412818909,
1.098867654800415,
-0.3942127227783203,
-0.5385861992835999,
-0.12081098556518555,
-0.4428926110267639,
0.1041790321469307,
-0.8793990612030029,
0.3826926052570343,
-0.9420691728591919,
0.4251733422279358,
-0.17390653491020203,
-0.5777302980422974,
-0.1414795070886612,
0.1953435242176056,
-0.5148513913154602,
0.8586452603340149,
0.2086460292339325,
-0.6888720393180847,
0.6359713077545166,
-0.7199161648750305,
-0.4802427589893341,
0.3693096339702606,
-0.45648443698883057,
-0.5158472061157227,
0.7094457149505615,
0.2651021182537079,
0.18258103728294373,
-0.40215003490448,
0.3915911614894867,
-0.6274741291999817,
-0.5177456736564636,
0.6616554260253906,
-0.14430901408195496,
0.495665043592453,
0.6325224041938782,
-0.44194290041923523,
0.25885117053985596,
-1.0854909420013428,
0.2840191423892975,
0.4331801235675812,
-0.8766732215881348,
0.24986238777637482,
0.36955368518829346,
0.10615167021751404,
0.3026770353317261,
0.14553415775299072,
-0.8063881397247314,
0.025364775210618973,
-0.8996087312698364,
0.30278193950653076,
0.7427720427513123,
0.09715152531862259,
0.2222047746181488,
-0.5341724753379822,
0.7021802067756653,
-0.17173698544502258,
-0.19571039080619812,
-0.14224527776241302,
-0.49911025166511536,
-0.5791885852813721,
0.0936942920088768,
-0.004321998916566372,
0.4115965962409973,
-1.129143476486206,
0.43220359086990356,
0.21522840857505798,
-0.44755300879478455,
-0.8640589714050293,
0.28391343355178833,
0.1927150934934616,
0.4641667306423187,
0.09272229671478271,
-0.520463764667511,
-1.004905104637146,
-0.8204668164253235,
-0.3917204737663269,
-0.14901669323444366,
-0.39919188618659973,
0.44514089822769165,
0.17277435958385468,
-0.28657281398773193,
1.2295490503311157,
-0.35336628556251526,
0.14646227657794952,
-0.4248383045196533,
0.30007144808769226,
0.47991520166397095,
0.12284177541732788,
0.49028611183166504,
-0.9451778531074524,
-0.3100990355014801,
-0.03198078274726868,
-0.8618696331977844,
-0.5015275478363037,
-0.14608721435070038,
0.1569443792104721,
0.0193766001611948,
0.3295323848724365,
-0.6452750563621521,
0.4774334728717804,
0.3695579767227173,
-0.3107249438762665,
0.46221309900283813,
0.02203402854502201,
0.1357123702764511,
-1.0226733684539795,
0.172959104180336,
-0.4451809823513031,
-0.24590922892093658,
-0.5673561692237854,
0.4639369547367096,
-0.004354117903858423,
-0.03093099221587181,
-0.595259964466095,
0.5273420214653015,
-0.27147963643074036,
-0.10573293268680573,
-0.9876081943511963,
0.39738625288009644,
0.06299461424350739,
0.10795819014310837,
-0.16917477548122406,
0.500881016254425,
0.25998538732528687,
-0.5763542652130127,
0.9620057344436646,
0.2514979839324951,
-0.5144229531288147,
0.4507703185081482,
-0.7273126244544983,
0.5213146805763245,
-0.5805079936981201,
0.3087531328201294,
-1.276789665222168,
-0.4345972537994385,
-0.11437518149614334,
-0.4610726237297058,
0.20786821842193604,
0.38315707445144653,
-0.6722160577774048,
-1.0645474195480347,
-0.49143674969673157,
0.28883323073387146,
0.345552533864975,
-0.5847045183181763,
0.657110333442688,
-0.03872877359390259,
-0.13154977560043335,
-0.22617647051811218,
-0.578916609287262,
0.055250439792871475,
-0.2576919198036194,
-0.7858072519302368,
0.32593175768852234,
-0.6953911185264587,
-0.34077855944633484,
-0.3894729018211365,
-0.005780111066997051,
0.5166002511978149,
0.4372199475765228,
0.10427279025316238,
0.06434546411037445,
-0.2903885841369629,
0.02389875054359436,
-0.23270167410373688,
0.010789277963340282,
0.1396353542804718,
0.08331838995218277,
0.9008767604827881,
0.14209969341754913,
-0.6960784196853638,
-0.32853999733924866,
0.4498772621154785,
0.30985957384109497,
-0.3146263062953949,
0.1754266321659088,
0.518173098564148,
-0.21617265045642853,
-0.3193701207637787,
-0.6917736530303955,
-0.43023258447647095,
-0.6335775256156921,
0.3613857626914978,
-0.295068621635437,
-0.9238541722297668,
0.3427255153656006,
0.054697975516319275,
0.04047715291380882,
0.2528965175151825,
1.0845154523849487,
-0.29699042439460754,
1.49656081199646,
0.46607673168182373,
0.3999415934085846,
0.6111570000648499,
0.1824420988559723,
0.5031511783599854,
-0.7855939865112305,
-0.2016456425189972,
-0.6740734577178955,
-0.6381528377532959,
-0.7005578875541687,
0.04852646589279175,
0.2478952407836914,
-0.06051900237798691,
-0.1936623752117157,
0.06569232046604156,
-0.490230917930603,
0.303864985704422,
0.8660548329353333,
0.135662242770195,
0.2368212789297104,
-0.25857269763946533,
-0.4196572005748749,
-0.08767502754926682,
-0.6075157523155212,
-0.4756090044975281,
0.8899627327919006,
0.25969648361206055,
0.8479495644569397,
0.06775932013988495,
1.0186290740966797,
-0.06687135994434357,
0.49850285053253174,
-1.0315420627593994,
0.7031354904174805,
0.19084270298480988,
-0.6481339931488037,
-0.13563993573188782,
-0.6124091148376465,
-0.9230783581733704,
0.17586877942085266,
-0.18303771317005157,
-0.5260754823684692,
-0.17191962897777557,
0.02833063155412674,
-0.526897132396698,
0.11274958401918411,
-0.5564592480659485,
0.2917833626270294,
-0.44231224060058594,
-0.1356026828289032,
-0.17238816618919373,
-0.47035151720046997,
0.26084205508232117,
-0.3705594837665558,
0.23015770316123962,
-0.21926510334014893,
0.4272077679634094,
0.5187200903892517,
-0.18840472400188446,
0.6036955118179321,
-0.28427186608314514,
0.08009606599807739,
0.43840089440345764,
0.40821853280067444,
0.6867644786834717,
0.05312466621398926,
-0.06600015610456467,
-0.8178675174713135,
-0.728449285030365,
-0.14231692254543304,
-0.6719095706939697,
0.5090703964233398,
-0.5427134037017822,
-1.0393650531768799,
0.11288484185934067,
-0.8050365447998047,
-0.373484343290329,
0.33238354325294495,
0.3923173248767853,
-0.1524362415075302,
-0.05357403680682182,
0.43677324056625366,
0.40023258328437805,
-0.2991885542869568,
0.6157877445220947,
0.6018613576889038,
-0.453407347202301,
-0.3972325623035431,
0.5285487174987793,
-0.107886403799057,
-0.013102676719427109,
0.38497766852378845,
0.4106397032737732,
-0.38155597448349,
-0.8128385543823242,
-0.3216364085674286,
0.01302111055701971,
-0.46574848890304565,
-0.3290945589542389,
-0.3839470446109772,
-0.18723703920841217,
-0.5469995737075806,
-0.14166249334812164,
-0.25912046432495117,
-0.4975309669971466,
-0.21563993394374847,
-0.3249936103820801,
-0.06233513355255127,
0.9768571853637695,
0.11637841165065765,
0.20220807194709778,
-0.6879591941833496,
0.4133054316043854,
0.5941916108131409,
0.24712474644184113,
-0.026731381192803383,
-0.6127708554267883,
-0.07839877158403397,
0.06206027418375015,
-1.0452122688293457,
-0.7986739277839661,
0.4883657991886139,
0.08510076254606247,
0.8479787111282349,
0.3243965208530426,
0.0025379012804478407,
0.46891117095947266,
-0.54241943359375,
0.8215299844741821,
0.3025091886520386,
-0.6907325983047485,
1.1417436599731445,
-0.183693528175354,
0.47921523451805115,
0.07280780375003815,
0.05771743506193161,
-0.4333643615245819,
-0.6914456486701965,
-0.5660865902900696,
-0.9222680330276489,
0.6256895661354065,
0.2527904212474823,
0.20674188435077667,
-0.023439859971404076,
0.1812078058719635,
-0.11792806535959244,
0.48360681533813477,
-0.6956382393836975,
0.22176215052604675,
-0.15804913640022278,
-0.05864671617746353,
0.04058331996202469,
0.050544314086437225,
-0.2713843584060669,
0.2818191349506378,
0.5440815687179565,
-0.3924315869808197,
0.17761853337287903,
0.210676372051239,
0.22436924278736115,
-0.6280471682548523,
0.15330062806606293,
0.5032732486724854,
0.37696608901023865,
0.016062362119555473,
0.27320757508277893,
0.22730159759521484,
0.054428618401288986,
0.2771719694137573,
0.0635707899928093,
-0.24208639562129974,
-0.1866724044084549,
0.39467132091522217,
0.631901204586029,
-0.04569527134299278,
-1.031661033630371,
0.29377901554107666,
-0.13259904086589813,
-0.3150727152824402,
-0.023725422099232674,
0.5200074315071106,
0.19600701332092285,
0.6883668899536133,
0.44587135314941406,
0.1350139081478119,
0.4154723286628723,
-0.49997827410697937,
0.31763821840286255,
0.5731614828109741,
0.06780068576335907,
-0.13095854222774506,
0.9803719520568848,
-0.1966884434223175,
-0.8474223017692566,
0.5984025597572327,
-0.3745652437210083,
-0.2654678523540497,
0.6811615824699402,
0.7312390208244324,
1.115556001663208,
-0.22437134385108948,
0.16461017727851868,
0.17113536596298218,
-0.026902824640274048,
-0.08964536339044571,
0.536887526512146,
-0.013712632469832897,
-0.8831628561019897,
-0.35247230529785156,
-0.7467983365058899,
-0.48473992943763733,
0.0599798709154129,
-0.5556303262710571,
0.2165757566690445,
-0.6007508039474487,
-0.5204007029533386,
-0.023269889876246452,
0.07435867190361023,
-0.8666915893554688,
0.33515018224716187,
0.38569706678390503,
0.7351641654968262,
-0.4019756317138672,
0.48965582251548767,
0.9330753684043884,
-0.25908640027046204,
-0.7038105130195618,
-0.25268715620040894,
0.0921371802687645,
-1.0154579877853394,
0.8322729468345642,
0.3047240972518921,
-0.21246805787086487,
-0.2887035310268402,
-0.6969244480133057,
-0.7916767001152039,
1.1372939348220825,
0.3764859437942505,
-0.4774785339832306,
-0.15422531962394714,
0.21131135523319244,
0.787479043006897,
-0.47902873158454895,
0.2337236851453781,
0.39291927218437195,
0.41266196966171265,
0.5000811815261841,
-0.888670027256012,
-0.11404327303171158,
-0.41653409600257874,
0.6436865329742432,
-0.14404168725013733,
-0.6242199540138245,
0.70234215259552,
-0.24157701432704926,
-0.2656420171260834,
0.24453918635845184,
0.6618865728378296,
0.8732010126113892,
0.7714999318122864,
0.22656144201755524,
0.4630930721759796,
0.7074734568595886,
-0.02908007800579071,
0.9277535080909729,
-0.0782560408115387,
0.3649754524230957,
0.8561773896217346,
-0.5631582736968994,
0.7909431457519531,
0.6549205780029297,
-0.039855435490608215,
0.23915426433086395,
0.7292662858963013,
-0.09128879755735397,
0.568775475025177,
0.5435681343078613,
-0.18564336001873016,
-0.2400600165128708,
-0.1546199470758438,
0.062119219452142715,
0.42299795150756836,
0.14136597514152527,
-0.4371546804904938,
-0.24067677557468414,
0.1017560139298439,
-0.3547820448875427,
0.5178115367889404,
-0.1802714467048645,
0.6578584909439087,
0.15226489305496216,
-0.8008407950401306,
0.42656370997428894,
0.2681984305381775,
0.5771495699882507,
-0.27097827196121216,
0.15662945806980133,
-0.4554775357246399,
0.28848809003829956,
-0.3043227791786194,
-0.7617435455322266,
0.3159683048725128,
-0.05921844020485878,
-0.17906564474105835,
-0.34861481189727783,
0.6863240599632263,
-0.022063640877604485,
-0.40457701683044434,
0.38457226753234863,
0.6373320817947388,
-0.2744253873825073,
0.0028468440286815166,
-0.49027732014656067,
0.004693533759564161,
0.10498468577861786,
-0.7818799018859863,
0.08839723467826843,
0.48067840933799744,
0.13375547528266907,
0.7947672009468079,
0.6578810811042786,
0.12717470526695251,
0.15162105858325958,
0.15250587463378906,
0.9584978818893433,
-0.7596865892410278,
-0.4006972312927246,
-0.6450366973876953,
0.40920865535736084,
-0.01946212165057659,
-0.12701481580734253,
0.5910313725471497,
0.5901925563812256,
0.9647217988967896,
-0.25820669531822205,
0.7950729727745056,
0.033869583159685135,
0.7426446676254272,
-0.7031107544898987,
0.3168027698993683,
-0.6114236116409302,
0.3179827928543091,
-0.12605346739292145,
-1.0582385063171387,
-0.4377520978450775,
0.7332421541213989,
-0.23426222801208496,
0.30653268098831177,
0.5096954703330994,
1.0270750522613525,
0.05797142535448074,
0.15198670327663422,
0.49519816040992737,
0.31639209389686584,
0.8909215331077576,
0.707231879234314,
1.3039671182632446,
-0.21291029453277588,
0.37260550260543823,
0.11961089074611664,
-0.25364285707473755,
-0.33224135637283325,
-0.708812415599823,
-0.9074453115463257,
-0.18442751467227936,
0.003581396769732237,
-0.28918805718421936,
-0.347063273191452,
1.1415059566497803,
0.532921552658081,
-0.7331674098968506,
-0.29709702730178833,
-0.211221382021904,
-0.14333829283714294,
-0.09445103257894516,
-0.2521194815635681,
-0.24018341302871704,
-0.6738432049751282,
-0.766723096370697,
0.8851432800292969,
0.26490432024002075,
0.1754995882511139,
-0.3474787771701813,
-0.05642363801598549,
0.22035345435142517,
0.3287995755672455,
0.6818233132362366,
-0.06810393929481506,
-0.5946376919746399,
-0.21318648755550385,
0.23433226346969604,
-0.16648143529891968,
0.1120135709643364,
0.9232822060585022,
-0.9250103831291199,
0.6809279918670654,
0.6292769312858582,
0.6724313497543335,
0.6009934544563293,
-0.17117805778980255,
0.5521873831748962,
-0.701118528842926,
-0.043045368045568466,
0.6212847232818604,
0.4114910364151001,
0.3516933023929596,
-0.33668607473373413,
0.42547839879989624,
0.47131744027137756,
-0.5835859179496765,
-0.6338257789611816,
0.6877750754356384,
-0.8454399108886719,
-0.17936892807483673,
0.92454993724823,
0.09812350571155548,
-0.0845021978020668,
0.17525874078273773,
-0.6255103945732117,
0.05681005120277405,
-0.26612588763237,
1.2638829946517944,
0.7862595319747925,
-0.48487669229507446,
0.0029199079144746065,
-0.4159741997718811,
0.18361817300319672,
0.4958273768424988,
-0.6602922677993774,
-0.20000699162483215,
0.43286749720573425,
0.0718669518828392,
0.36896654963493347,
0.6419443488121033,
0.016892075538635254,
0.5281978249549866,
-0.07315193861722946,
-0.0642874613404274,
0.13162921369075775,
-0.24258030951023102,
-0.14142492413520813,
0.4679875671863556,
0.5426564812660217,
0.011858946643769741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19753v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19753v1
|
DOCCI: Descriptions of Connected and Contrasting Images
| 2024-04-30T17:56:24 | 2024-04-30T17:56:24 |
Yasumasa Onoe, Sunayana Rane, Zachary Berger, Yonatan Bitton, Jaemin Cho, Roopal Garg, Alexander Ku, Zarana Parekh, Jordi Pont-Tuset, Garrett Tanzer, Su Wang, Jason Baldridge
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Vision-language datasets are vital for both text-to-image (T2I) and
image-to-text (I2T) research. However, current datasets lack descriptions with
fine-grained detail that would allow for richer associations to be learned by
models. To fill the gap, we introduce Descriptions of Connected and Contrasting
Images (DOCCI), a dataset with long, human-annotated English descriptions for
15k images that were taken, curated and donated by a single researcher intent
on capturing key challenges such as spatial relations, counting, text
rendering, world knowledge, and more. We instruct human annotators to create
comprehensive descriptions for each image; these average 136 words in length
and are crafted to clearly distinguish each image from those that are related
or similar. Each description is highly compositional and typically encompasses
multiple challenges. Through both quantitative and qualitative analyses, we
demonstrate that DOCCI serves as an effective training resource for
image-to-text generation -- a PaLI 5B model finetuned on DOCCI shows equal or
superior results compared to highly-performant larger models like LLaVA-1.5 7B
and InstructBLIP 7B. Furthermore, we show that DOCCI is a useful testbed for
text-to-image generation, highlighting the limitations of current text-to-image
models in capturing long descriptions and fine details.
|
[
-0.5725314617156982,
-0.28735655546188354,
0.6383813619613647,
-0.02580088935792446,
-0.6157530546188354,
-0.0746709555387497,
-0.1558230221271515,
-0.9226155877113342,
-0.06424698978662491,
0.35789886116981506,
-0.43971994519233704,
-0.3759554624557495,
-0.5432639122009277,
0.3516619801521301,
-0.4816579520702362,
1.0244979858398438,
-0.35693496465682983,
0.04391232132911682,
-0.5522165894508362,
-0.048893433064222336,
-0.6428254842758179,
0.1192985251545906,
-0.8495876789093018,
-0.17353861033916473,
0.7297341823577881,
0.35209357738494873,
0.5352277755737305,
0.7103479504585266,
0.897970974445343,
0.20021407306194305,
-0.009638655930757523,
0.3403927683830261,
-0.5395179986953735,
0.0893702358007431,
-0.2718619108200073,
-0.4097626805305481,
-0.015661507844924927,
0.2175716906785965,
0.6668688058853149,
0.7907475233078003,
0.3618760108947754,
-0.08707515895366669,
-0.13246941566467285,
0.6725994944572449,
-0.43279772996902466,
0.31310561299324036,
-0.5355443954467773,
0.14713357388973236,
-0.3093428313732147,
-0.08966433256864548,
-0.248556450009346,
-0.029897743836045265,
0.2728511095046997,
-0.9080255031585693,
0.5292932987213135,
0.0943494588136673,
1.2281737327575684,
0.2543202340602875,
-0.5033941268920898,
-0.41736868023872375,
-0.6507928967475891,
0.4188595712184906,
-0.30164068937301636,
-0.0797261968255043,
0.45031461119651794,
0.4808233678340912,
0.20933732390403748,
-0.9134531617164612,
-0.8542112112045288,
0.016458123922348022,
-0.3347226679325104,
0.47183331847190857,
0.18686909973621368,
-0.2570629119873047,
0.09728135168552399,
0.42898187041282654,
-0.2746041417121887,
0.3715054392814636,
-0.8493398427963257,
-0.017764046788215637,
0.7388212084770203,
0.4871196746826172,
0.17821601033210754,
-0.07733097672462463,
-0.5067976117134094,
-0.22293977439403534,
-0.9297037124633789,
-0.10344912856817245,
0.4083110988140106,
-0.13876134157180786,
-0.5382320880889893,
0.5687753558158875,
-0.0290389321744442,
0.6424551606178284,
-0.05700009688735008,
-0.05518815293908119,
0.05748740956187248,
-0.4241374731063843,
0.27892112731933594,
-0.154625803232193,
0.9107027053833008,
0.8984052538871765,
0.24028904736042023,
-0.333709180355072,
-0.2808842360973358,
0.22785109281539917,
0.10710739344358444,
-0.9646399021148682,
-0.14992694556713104,
-0.16771391034126282,
-0.6089510321617126,
-0.31069591641426086,
0.11369185894727707,
-0.812650740146637,
-0.48242032527923584,
-0.32148581743240356,
0.018795989453792572,
-0.32706403732299805,
-0.1291816234588623,
-0.26701369881629944,
-0.35285043716430664,
0.42621946334838867,
0.3217357099056244,
-0.7737494707107544,
0.44982272386550903,
0.6537340879440308,
0.8283761739730835,
-0.23790861666202545,
-0.5043123960494995,
-0.1930597722530365,
0.28772902488708496,
-0.6529885530471802,
1.0329004526138306,
-0.6377854347229004,
-0.7519903779029846,
0.0887225866317749,
0.05856785923242569,
0.2881357669830322,
-0.3580263555049896,
0.33351027965545654,
-0.11401908099651337,
0.47829189896583557,
-0.22549833357334137,
-0.51848965883255,
0.07158936560153961,
0.24624082446098328,
-0.7791823148727417,
0.7016248106956482,
0.07528729736804962,
-1.2462531328201294,
0.3397388756275177,
-0.6069891452789307,
-0.5280548334121704,
0.10307905822992325,
-0.8141807317733765,
-0.36127543449401855,
0.22908687591552734,
-0.062431689351797104,
0.5331201553344727,
-0.668595552444458,
0.06268426775932312,
-0.2014203667640686,
-0.4930494725704193,
0.4406730532646179,
-0.13654641807079315,
0.3419974148273468,
0.3276445269584656,
-0.20808763802051544,
-0.1404910534620285,
-0.8315337300300598,
-0.44640570878982544,
0.5514191389083862,
0.01938685216009617,
-0.387284517288208,
0.05073883756995201,
0.3178604543209076,
-0.012414678931236267,
0.2710431218147278,
-0.613075852394104,
-0.019775602966547012,
-0.17047147452831268,
0.6285353899002075,
0.6406524181365967,
-0.08959491550922394,
0.14914898574352264,
-0.2547181248664856,
0.21722868084907532,
0.36847928166389465,
0.14569178223609924,
-0.5250515937805176,
-0.4912889897823334,
-0.5828781127929688,
-0.16997605562210083,
0.1827751249074936,
0.362178236246109,
-0.916118323802948,
-0.07806258648633957,
-0.6177080869674683,
-0.46299028396606445,
-0.5710033178329468,
-0.14830107986927032,
0.6119971871376038,
1.0406092405319214,
0.2115352898836136,
-0.807231605052948,
-0.07503484934568405,
-1.3094151020050049,
0.4538925290107727,
-0.17853966355323792,
-0.17722144722938538,
0.6872382164001465,
0.5082012414932251,
-0.10167321562767029,
0.6522346138954163,
-0.57142174243927,
-0.4145745038986206,
0.46793922781944275,
0.2027694284915924,
-0.12330576032400131,
0.12162420153617859,
0.548086404800415,
-1.0721843242645264,
-0.6500338315963745,
0.13700373470783234,
-0.7548921704292297,
0.23309385776519775,
-0.28631359338760376,
0.1544792354106903,
-0.06914112716913223,
0.583457350730896,
-0.5583295226097107,
0.3959061801433563,
0.25080880522727966,
-0.404281884431839,
0.5904371738433838,
-0.42148447036743164,
0.29926514625549316,
-1.517853856086731,
0.29016223549842834,
0.1346706748008728,
0.0010266851168125868,
-0.22872455418109894,
0.27815014123916626,
-0.09205560386180878,
-0.21035519242286682,
-0.5088465809822083,
0.5639573335647583,
-0.6836255788803101,
-0.1913883090019226,
-0.21055638790130615,
0.2740631103515625,
0.1341228038072586,
0.1145700216293335,
0.4569533169269562,
1.1068898439407349,
0.956732451915741,
-0.21154969930648804,
0.5619600415229797,
0.6843640804290771,
-0.31583186984062195,
0.9294320940971375,
-0.76692134141922,
0.3754604458808899,
-0.02509511075913906,
0.35088807344436646,
-0.9437258839607239,
-0.3882788121700287,
0.02408887818455696,
-0.2282266616821289,
0.5416256785392761,
0.11588670313358307,
-0.47411423921585083,
-0.27111098170280457,
-0.3267277777194977,
0.7070571780204773,
0.4544767439365387,
-0.6623995304107666,
0.3841990530490875,
0.149351105093956,
-0.2244947850704193,
-0.35900816321372986,
-0.8032890558242798,
0.638259768486023,
-0.31524065136909485,
-0.5079213976860046,
0.5270584225654602,
0.13662782311439514,
-0.10903278738260269,
0.1219199150800705,
0.37156063318252563,
-0.1366311013698578,
-0.10329604148864746,
0.6103934049606323,
0.5268003344535828,
-0.02986370585858822,
0.2268335223197937,
-0.1854773610830307,
-0.1436927169561386,
0.059099312871694565,
-0.012448065914213657,
0.04385824501514435,
-0.023873699828982353,
-0.019997015595436096,
-0.31092509627342224,
0.8064107894897461,
0.16992822289466858,
-0.26520535349845886,
0.43223437666893005,
0.7687409520149231,
-0.19284069538116455,
0.3457474410533905,
-0.350859671831131,
0.027428749948740005,
-0.37975171208381653,
0.32498687505722046,
-0.7776437997817993,
-0.5442612767219543,
0.4558624029159546,
-0.15767604112625122,
0.02007238008081913,
0.492239773273468,
0.21708092093467712,
-0.5692473649978638,
0.563535213470459,
0.5850731730461121,
0.13732576370239258,
0.2861378788948059,
-0.25136420130729675,
0.03638650104403496,
-0.9027284979820251,
-0.4699953496456146,
-0.4706304371356964,
-0.24291430413722992,
-0.6145833134651184,
-0.3929513692855835,
0.1997094601392746,
-0.33008599281311035,
0.0008797347545623779,
0.054615940898656845,
-0.6269603967666626,
0.5909551382064819,
0.5717470049858093,
0.19924955070018768,
-0.029161470010876656,
0.2769981026649475,
0.06796162575483322,
-0.10524400323629379,
-0.2470678836107254,
-0.5286766886711121,
1.2541946172714233,
0.14064431190490723,
0.8144632577896118,
-0.21569423377513885,
0.7045848369598389,
0.20523874461650848,
0.02505018189549446,
-0.5225003361701965,
0.6149642467498779,
-0.7104366421699524,
-0.18842633068561554,
0.18895071744918823,
-0.2295597940683365,
-0.9130898714065552,
-0.5089967846870422,
-0.40549495816230774,
-0.33245590329170227,
0.2957967221736908,
-0.0014523533172905445,
-0.11009442806243896,
0.19855985045433044,
-0.7922319173812866,
0.5128298997879028,
-0.1997103989124298,
-0.5283822417259216,
-0.33950263261795044,
-1.1662923097610474,
0.09589032083749771,
0.012700957246124744,
-0.06755926460027695,
0.2112433910369873,
-0.17097985744476318,
0.5239977836608887,
-0.17815883457660675,
0.9517009854316711,
0.2409195452928543,
-0.0646132156252861,
0.24607153236865997,
-0.13712820410728455,
0.22121383249759674,
-0.17139586806297302,
0.30497655272483826,
0.3142637312412262,
0.08294733613729477,
-0.5078080296516418,
-0.23559358716011047,
0.7450466752052307,
-0.7894002795219421,
-0.45506203174591064,
0.013937542214989662,
-0.5885570645332336,
-0.09392201155424118,
0.02740178257226944,
0.5572532415390015,
0.685945451259613,
-0.3216642439365387,
0.012720336206257343,
0.5980405211448669,
-0.2613743841648102,
0.3511439263820648,
-0.11646606028079987,
0.06041917949914932,
-0.48084497451782227,
0.877417802810669,
-0.24742533266544342,
0.11177939176559448,
0.5056958198547363,
-0.0688362866640091,
-0.23689772188663483,
-0.6157339811325073,
-0.36201968789100647,
0.3177241384983063,
-0.7638821005821228,
-0.11779189854860306,
-0.1891801506280899,
-0.12512774765491486,
-0.2688290476799011,
-0.26809990406036377,
-0.14674116671085358,
-0.3699108958244324,
-0.46403977274894714,
-0.0707402303814888,
0.23006820678710938,
0.8727880716323853,
0.13925747573375702,
0.24551434814929962,
-0.4016777575016022,
0.47891172766685486,
0.4919973313808441,
0.4577466547489166,
-0.34234610199928284,
-0.10896280407905579,
-0.29583996534347534,
-0.10711240768432617,
-0.32102692127227783,
-0.7311990857124329,
-0.05781220272183418,
0.5128541588783264,
0.03598665073513985,
0.6968262195587158,
-0.04671304300427437,
0.7271550893783569,
-0.5942476391792297,
0.929865837097168,
0.7491215467453003,
-0.4469197392463684,
0.5549441576004028,
-0.2802278697490692,
-0.016207320615649223,
0.363558292388916,
0.22519898414611816,
-0.333425372838974,
-0.3723662793636322,
-0.5112738609313965,
-0.7970166206359863,
0.3412303030490875,
0.14957213401794434,
0.333011656999588,
-0.05914996191859245,
0.5471013188362122,
0.46857917308807373,
0.08797990530729294,
-0.5698240399360657,
-0.015164907090365887,
-0.4356463551521301,
-0.5743948221206665,
-0.2582249045372009,
-0.36527907848358154,
-0.6276531219482422,
0.24895451962947845,
0.34806370735168457,
-0.26660141348838806,
0.294163316488266,
0.4662317931652069,
0.07539251446723938,
0.04904685914516449,
0.08815843611955643,
0.4189184010028839,
0.5015050768852234,
0.030795764178037643,
0.4049193263053894,
-0.2153463214635849,
-0.5249661803245544,
-0.23038464784622192,
0.4321764409542084,
-0.2942313551902771,
-0.0713483914732933,
0.7799046635627747,
1.148366928100586,
-0.32971659302711487,
-0.6728332042694092,
0.5086411237716675,
-0.28214484453201294,
-0.3909966051578522,
-0.19589576125144958,
-0.08419445902109146,
0.18624469637870789,
0.25347086787223816,
0.09967825561761856,
-0.15750232338905334,
0.306418240070343,
-0.5443896055221558,
-0.1058015301823616,
0.29429537057876587,
-0.6320352554321289,
-0.3772910535335541,
0.6451810002326965,
0.4489460587501526,
-0.05119352042675018,
0.7702262997627258,
-0.034844402223825455,
-0.09199216216802597,
0.8772917985916138,
0.42028874158859253,
0.7040351033210754,
0.45101824402809143,
0.2024509608745575,
0.18078599870204926,
0.11962664127349854,
0.22924253344535828,
-0.06149858236312866,
-0.23449960350990295,
-0.45462968945503235,
0.050456684082746506,
-0.17630448937416077,
-0.2992592751979828,
-0.05982901528477669,
-0.6235454678535461,
0.19098201394081116,
-0.32577481865882874,
-0.1365620344877243,
0.28243690729141235,
0.15544205904006958,
-0.9345464110374451,
0.4587511718273163,
0.5103315711021423,
0.8675546646118164,
-1.0445796251296997,
0.715861439704895,
0.9783223867416382,
-0.7536110877990723,
-0.9067355990409851,
-0.1153869479894638,
-0.3857067823410034,
-0.566421627998352,
0.6944058537483215,
0.39345043897628784,
0.165479838848114,
-0.2510558068752289,
-0.7914745211601257,
0.0846097469329834,
1.3428949117660522,
0.2670431137084961,
-0.650751531124115,
-0.14453479647636414,
0.32030820846557617,
0.7494860887527466,
-0.8115693926811218,
0.3026912212371826,
0.17935214936733246,
0.2700299322605133,
0.20915603637695312,
-0.6674776673316956,
0.0616784542798996,
-0.35559406876564026,
0.22177442908287048,
-0.12183067202568054,
-0.7711949348449707,
0.728408694267273,
-0.5171961188316345,
-0.32503142952919006,
0.4328671097755432,
0.4183639585971832,
-0.09438633918762207,
0.5930183529853821,
0.5142533183097839,
0.5869057178497314,
0.2803116738796234,
-0.16229411959648132,
1.0850428342819214,
-0.09828122705221176,
0.07571649551391602,
1.3574490547180176,
-0.27462300658226013,
0.7390905022621155,
0.8601663112640381,
-0.076966792345047,
0.41133761405944824,
1.0848801136016846,
-0.4338080883026123,
0.7196028232574463,
-0.1340923011302948,
-0.28242769837379456,
-0.16700252890586853,
-0.47480764985084534,
-0.4870794117450714,
0.17390988767147064,
0.19930556416511536,
-0.5160173177719116,
-0.2078578770160675,
-0.01598672941327095,
-0.45717811584472656,
0.40317070484161377,
-0.13417309522628784,
1.0633697509765625,
0.18164336681365967,
-0.599481463432312,
0.2657637596130371,
-0.394324392080307,
0.31363824009895325,
-0.34853681921958923,
-0.27367696166038513,
-0.4659835696220398,
-0.09481222182512283,
-0.09038465470075607,
-1.1995631456375122,
0.17287206649780273,
0.019215673208236694,
-0.22327369451522827,
-0.01988130249083042,
0.7138497829437256,
-0.5693989396095276,
-0.42701730132102966,
0.21441172063350677,
-0.0019290064228698611,
0.3706776797771454,
0.38740605115890503,
-0.5954286456108093,
-0.3118800222873688,
-0.13250218331813812,
0.1863050013780594,
0.024815155193209648,
0.4974183142185211,
-0.14658179879188538,
0.5312438607215881,
0.2596971094608307,
0.28972646594047546,
-0.11952970176935196,
0.005124449729919434,
0.876798152923584,
-0.4444587230682373,
-0.4946215748786926,
-0.4173285663127899,
0.32103750109672546,
-0.2943897843360901,
-0.34081363677978516,
0.08810196071863174,
0.6322927474975586,
0.8716018199920654,
-0.3500700294971466,
0.7582303285598755,
-0.18946203589439392,
0.21420398354530334,
-0.537137508392334,
0.5204839706420898,
-0.7138217091560364,
0.03576583415269852,
0.13539162278175354,
-0.8593617081642151,
0.05240707844495773,
0.25027430057525635,
-0.04351409524679184,
-0.36388659477233887,
0.8425086736679077,
0.6504941582679749,
-0.2972569763660431,
-0.31804153323173523,
0.1303573101758957,
0.23629280924797058,
0.25728902220726013,
0.6981581449508667,
0.8907697796821594,
-0.4493444859981537,
0.6816247701644897,
-0.33304890990257263,
-0.007485504262149334,
0.2331327497959137,
-0.8656420111656189,
-0.9283040761947632,
-1.0051196813583374,
-0.5395092368125916,
-0.25503164529800415,
0.06882236152887344,
0.2756138741970062,
0.6649640798568726,
-0.4845186769962311,
-0.14834895730018616,
-0.03376869112253189,
-0.27423638105392456,
0.022749168798327446,
-0.08698305487632751,
0.5551837086677551,
-0.203298419713974,
-0.7572402954101562,
-0.2297394722700119,
0.3347640037536621,
0.2674880027770996,
-0.3023328483104706,
-0.22761432826519012,
0.10062186419963837,
0.005647681653499603,
0.23024888336658478,
0.1243572011590004,
-0.579833984375,
-0.15749388933181763,
-0.4744025468826294,
-0.2953425347805023,
0.19793963432312012,
0.7833799123764038,
-0.5271567106246948,
0.6729034781455994,
0.16187319159507751,
0.561090350151062,
0.64236980676651,
-0.1948723942041397,
0.3753730058670044,
-0.7150551080703735,
0.4413054585456848,
-0.08825159817934036,
0.4770868718624115,
0.8450647592544556,
-0.26586657762527466,
0.8252353072166443,
0.2646915018558502,
-0.1960594207048416,
-0.5593708753585815,
0.4645204246044159,
-1.3133889436721802,
-0.2694087326526642,
1.047402262687683,
-0.5563890337944031,
-0.23674359917640686,
0.3287164866924286,
-0.390753835439682,
0.3753056228160858,
0.023379867896437645,
1.0161161422729492,
0.7238171100616455,
0.47474536299705505,
-0.14057837426662445,
-0.22034648060798645,
0.26273083686828613,
0.09558325260877609,
-0.997682511806488,
-0.1812526136636734,
0.7998312711715698,
0.3384550213813782,
0.27147477865219116,
0.41816896200180054,
-0.21892699599266052,
0.19744963943958282,
0.27454349398612976,
0.1335786134004593,
-0.27435457706451416,
-0.21013617515563965,
0.06330487132072449,
-0.05704076215624809,
0.10954900830984116,
-0.4758862555027008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19737v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19737v1
|
Better & Faster Large Language Models via Multi-token Prediction
| 2024-04-30T17:33:57 | 2024-04-30T17:33:57 |
Fabian Gloeckle, Badr Youbi Idrissi, Baptiste Rozière, David Lopez-Paz, Gabriel Synnaeve
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models such as GPT and Llama are trained with a next-token
prediction loss. In this work, we suggest that training language models to
predict multiple future tokens at once results in higher sample efficiency.
More specifically, at each position in the training corpus, we ask the model to
predict the following n tokens using n independent output heads, operating on
top of a shared model trunk. Considering multi-token prediction as an auxiliary
training task, we measure improved downstream capabilities with no overhead in
training time for both code and natural language models. The method is
increasingly useful for larger model sizes, and keeps its appeal when training
for multiple epochs. Gains are especially pronounced on generative benchmarks
like coding, where our models consistently outperform strong baselines by
several percentage points. Our 13B parameter models solves 12 % more problems
on HumanEval and 17 % more on MBPP than comparable next-token models.
Experiments on small algorithmic tasks demonstrate that multi-token prediction
is favorable for the development of induction heads and algorithmic reasoning
capabilities. As an additional benefit, models trained with 4-token prediction
are up to 3 times faster at inference, even with large batch sizes.
|
[
-0.47341352701187134,
-0.37009456753730774,
0.5429786443710327,
0.23688319325447083,
-0.3636194169521332,
0.2695508897304535,
-0.47893160581588745,
-0.6841012239456177,
0.05726499482989311,
0.3784639835357666,
-0.28507399559020996,
-0.24490943551063538,
-0.9077372550964355,
0.1916385143995285,
-0.2727653682231903,
0.821069061756134,
0.2874380648136139,
0.4267173111438751,
0.03398839384317398,
-0.06790709495544434,
-0.7431320548057556,
-0.9550008773803711,
-1.0638726949691772,
-0.2884567081928253,
0.7491397857666016,
0.26531657576560974,
0.5313339233398438,
0.7402908802032471,
0.5658340454101562,
0.296565979719162,
-0.13504070043563843,
0.03925274685025215,
-0.18225477635860443,
0.021922998130321503,
0.2519639730453491,
-0.5036314725875854,
-0.3290090262889862,
-0.1883051097393036,
0.6350236535072327,
0.667980432510376,
-0.03514667972922325,
0.12111548334360123,
-0.11826231330633163,
0.4317079484462738,
-0.34822431206703186,
0.3458120822906494,
-1.0129878520965576,
-0.03599082678556442,
-0.30133357644081116,
-0.13364087045192719,
-0.5796902775764465,
-0.06507031619548798,
-0.07429727166891098,
-0.42159050703048706,
0.13101264834403992,
0.2751263678073883,
0.4505082070827484,
0.036543022841215134,
-0.4422997236251831,
0.10278858244419098,
-0.35947564244270325,
0.8293249011039734,
-0.8771315217018127,
0.6660773754119873,
0.39841341972351074,
0.4528640806674957,
-0.13068075478076935,
-0.8989914655685425,
-0.7034264206886292,
-0.4127565026283264,
0.08408655226230621,
-0.2137862890958786,
0.11123760044574738,
0.16941122710704803,
0.2757902145385742,
0.18726807832717896,
-0.3019470274448395,
0.42994946241378784,
-0.362688809633255,
-0.5476848483085632,
0.44144126772880554,
0.09057363122701645,
0.01684527099132538,
0.005903236102312803,
-0.1932472437620163,
-0.08275003731250763,
-0.8109560012817383,
-0.20581239461898804,
0.45829159021377563,
0.5939481258392334,
0.045121654868125916,
0.5429131388664246,
-0.14618173241615295,
0.637395441532135,
-0.08718801289796829,
-0.34477663040161133,
0.3369281589984894,
-0.5623643398284912,
0.053000591695308685,
-0.055317655205726624,
0.49921295046806335,
0.23690906167030334,
0.2607881724834442,
-0.22551408410072327,
-0.20951487123966217,
0.02664417028427124,
0.005970897153019905,
-1.059651494026184,
-0.14923594892024994,
0.1314340978860855,
-0.5921880006790161,
-0.06572682410478592,
-0.22794213891029358,
-0.5051622986793518,
-0.41420823335647583,
-0.6625086665153503,
0.10014615207910538,
-0.5050649642944336,
-0.3144417107105255,
0.10948128998279572,
-0.3460265100002289,
0.12391883134841919,
0.3639525771141052,
-1.0295326709747314,
0.09885306656360626,
0.9248656034469604,
1.055062174797058,
-0.1918177306652069,
-0.5294499397277832,
-1.0927577018737793,
-0.018318455666303635,
-0.46536147594451904,
0.9791299700737,
-0.7327542304992676,
-0.14174075424671173,
-0.059306979179382324,
-0.17246410250663757,
-0.06410792469978333,
-0.34118831157684326,
0.45818865299224854,
-0.5395470261573792,
-0.09829641878604889,
-0.3941521644592285,
-0.4549003541469574,
-0.14098210632801056,
0.1610783487558365,
-0.8433435559272766,
0.9537031054496765,
-0.0941988155245781,
-0.7630556225776672,
0.6749721169471741,
-0.7069545984268188,
-0.46630215644836426,
-0.022901473566889763,
0.0081217922270298,
-0.2669241428375244,
0.250440388917923,
0.45018473267555237,
0.8894363045692444,
-0.2218637615442276,
0.3560895621776581,
-0.5898171663284302,
-0.3533073365688324,
0.02441534958779812,
-0.4994395077228546,
0.5156936645507812,
0.12728607654571533,
-0.24583972990512848,
0.37542805075645447,
-0.6521269083023071,
0.010837736539542675,
-0.060175154358148575,
-0.6462183594703674,
-0.1759699136018753,
-0.20011283457279205,
0.17430073022842407,
0.3019362688064575,
-0.04527418687939644,
-0.4558267295360565,
0.26733270287513733,
-0.30741986632347107,
0.5866134762763977,
1.1116191148757935,
-0.279903382062912,
0.34560921788215637,
-0.10800253599882126,
0.5310906171798706,
-0.09006723761558533,
0.05160865932703018,
-0.31054583191871643,
-0.8568047285079956,
-0.5937180519104004,
-0.4544563293457031,
0.5017375349998474,
0.09515430778265,
-0.6225410103797913,
0.2097676396369934,
-0.3644103407859802,
-0.49602222442626953,
-0.3034151792526245,
0.12226055562496185,
0.42131978273391724,
0.21305808424949646,
0.23510943353176117,
-0.5074212551116943,
-0.8503392934799194,
-0.6053942441940308,
-0.2086056023836136,
-0.30790767073631287,
0.14417417347431183,
0.03153989464044571,
0.5962314009666443,
-0.1877412497997284,
0.5819036960601807,
-0.2566528022289276,
-0.053413309156894684,
-0.5662155747413635,
0.21882440149784088,
0.2327011376619339,
0.41429880261421204,
0.4833325445652008,
-0.7282990217208862,
-0.5045483708381653,
0.06623905897140503,
-0.29180431365966797,
0.29563307762145996,
0.021840501576662064,
-0.23976148664951324,
0.33294451236724854,
0.5497807860374451,
-0.6403253078460693,
0.04811440780758858,
0.7067329287528992,
-0.2998957335948944,
0.7477651834487915,
-0.14039428532123566,
-0.10939615219831467,
-1.1902439594268799,
0.02048555575311184,
-0.22882205247879028,
-0.16296878457069397,
-0.6541665196418762,
-0.04474003240466118,
0.08878215402364731,
-0.07778938114643097,
-0.45421332120895386,
0.6956821084022522,
-0.5272054672241211,
-0.37460869550704956,
-0.19338661432266235,
-0.30712878704071045,
-0.12861044704914093,
0.602552056312561,
0.13299158215522766,
1.2008116245269775,
0.6662148237228394,
-0.6355924606323242,
0.17770443856716156,
0.15382973849773407,
-0.48305544257164,
0.05533165857195854,
-0.5779900550842285,
0.41587716341018677,
-0.15061260759830475,
0.47410738468170166,
-0.9847211837768555,
-0.19976550340652466,
-0.29120486974716187,
-0.5326229929924011,
0.3548034131526947,
0.010012057609856129,
-0.7122830748558044,
-0.5437929630279541,
-0.35403314232826233,
0.39387252926826477,
0.24168924987316132,
-0.7768986821174622,
0.6229013204574585,
0.3361101448535919,
-0.21187160909175873,
-0.9684113264083862,
-0.8201873302459717,
0.20894472301006317,
-0.3358241319656372,
-0.2981945276260376,
0.3459523022174835,
-0.048196155577898026,
0.11872569471597672,
-0.16266866028308868,
0.07152130454778671,
-0.10707006603479385,
0.12472860515117645,
0.09864293783903122,
0.17435584962368011,
-0.19489508867263794,
0.47327473759651184,
-0.1266465187072754,
-0.2848305404186249,
-0.2132653146982193,
-0.6638203859329224,
1.061277985572815,
-0.19482354819774628,
-0.36971282958984375,
-0.3520418405532837,
0.31266820430755615,
0.5849080085754395,
-0.5986779928207397,
1.0516009330749512,
0.8623170852661133,
-0.38197118043899536,
0.28273865580558777,
-0.7760310769081116,
-0.19456470012664795,
-0.4058966636657715,
0.654150128364563,
-0.5241526961326599,
-0.8910137414932251,
0.6760765910148621,
0.2068355679512024,
0.15116353332996368,
0.5064036250114441,
0.7971246838569641,
0.5260588526725769,
1.2631869316101074,
0.9089259505271912,
-0.476647287607193,
0.6850281953811646,
-0.3544703423976898,
0.2973821461200714,
-0.7877748012542725,
-0.31421247124671936,
-0.6393157839775085,
0.022019607946276665,
-0.4425382614135742,
-0.6749832630157471,
0.14595387876033783,
0.08679317682981491,
-0.3496670722961426,
0.42891332507133484,
-0.2802045941352844,
0.47386011481285095,
0.8380767107009888,
-0.20491322875022888,
0.373410165309906,
0.045443445444107056,
-0.34476155042648315,
0.2641598582267761,
-0.7258599400520325,
-0.3225025236606598,
1.6670562028884888,
0.37953275442123413,
0.3971938490867615,
-0.0574527233839035,
0.6785218119621277,
0.019861282780766487,
0.6706202030181885,
-0.7589183449745178,
0.32943323254585266,
-0.10713711380958557,
-0.7775983214378357,
-0.2754093110561371,
-0.3786236047744751,
-0.7800469994544983,
0.3788132667541504,
-0.1972491592168808,
-0.6507472395896912,
-0.10528941452503204,
0.20425568521022797,
-0.4510355591773987,
0.5343995094299316,
-0.8438270092010498,
0.7407553195953369,
-0.18707393109798431,
-0.0664215236902237,
-0.40557417273521423,
-0.6296745538711548,
0.352498322725296,
-0.3076808750629425,
0.12487141042947769,
-0.3514114320278168,
-0.10804331302642822,
0.7372869253158569,
-0.28423309326171875,
0.7282763123512268,
-0.2467646598815918,
0.09582436829805374,
0.2655002772808075,
-0.35350537300109863,
0.5194174647331238,
-0.06174435093998909,
-0.4346606731414795,
0.43400973081588745,
-0.20839861035346985,
-0.36636751890182495,
-0.28586944937705994,
0.49295127391815186,
-0.620988130569458,
-0.3528483808040619,
-0.09582459926605225,
-0.44396811723709106,
-0.25065383315086365,
0.2669876217842102,
0.22109301388263702,
0.6656473278999329,
0.2430744469165802,
0.30594027042388916,
0.09164723008871078,
-0.18344812095165253,
0.7058711051940918,
0.06847523152828217,
-0.07744276523590088,
-0.47828251123428345,
0.6473273634910583,
0.03972148895263672,
0.3566264510154724,
0.4397779405117035,
0.34058088064193726,
-0.7733517289161682,
-0.8361856341362,
-0.5609784126281738,
0.16988436877727509,
-0.8476725816726685,
-0.5748718976974487,
-0.864810585975647,
0.09105886518955231,
-0.6573457717895508,
0.17747804522514343,
-0.35325777530670166,
-0.5432481169700623,
0.10932224988937378,
-0.30504465103149414,
0.4563371241092682,
0.5316122174263,
-0.08539757132530212,
0.5776873826980591,
-0.8173746466636658,
0.17478196322917938,
0.21608342230319977,
0.5545596480369568,
0.31719622015953064,
-0.5367370247840881,
-0.34627407789230347,
-0.23519954085350037,
-0.1998484581708908,
-0.6614794731140137,
0.3807116150856018,
0.37051698565483093,
0.6104196906089783,
0.37449049949645996,
-0.36456188559532166,
0.9463495016098022,
-0.7729724645614624,
0.6988567113876343,
0.5343182682991028,
-0.9367163181304932,
0.03994440659880638,
-0.19398175179958344,
0.1212155669927597,
0.4203353226184845,
0.19702959060668945,
-0.6847249269485474,
-0.3459652364253998,
-0.40477123856544495,
-0.7266817092895508,
0.5487406849861145,
-0.15048186480998993,
0.3057922124862671,
-0.205648273229599,
0.21416395902633667,
0.5310533046722412,
0.4150243401527405,
-0.7255416512489319,
-0.016965409740805626,
-0.05048836022615433,
-0.07314064353704453,
-0.37290024757385254,
-0.27061736583709717,
0.38623329997062683,
-0.39591124653816223,
0.6277410984039307,
-0.4973633885383606,
0.679095447063446,
-0.26727572083473206,
0.17814959585666656,
0.016904687508940697,
0.06461473554372787,
0.4456091821193695,
0.7599486708641052,
0.1171002984046936,
0.11943943053483963,
0.4557133615016937,
-0.31762903928756714,
0.04101508483290672,
0.12341149896383286,
0.47672781348228455,
-0.007153226528316736,
0.5823952555656433,
0.9708216190338135,
-0.010630670003592968,
-0.7263526320457458,
0.45082250237464905,
-0.1438894122838974,
-0.02923799492418766,
-0.4104304313659668,
-0.2890651524066925,
0.21569937467575073,
0.27936339378356934,
0.37192296981811523,
0.22108261287212372,
0.1528649628162384,
-0.6506099700927734,
0.2428288459777832,
0.5394402146339417,
0.07136012613773346,
-0.20263278484344482,
0.8087601661682129,
0.029383666813373566,
-0.10111823678016663,
0.569646954536438,
-0.23039157688617706,
-0.7247450947761536,
0.7369329333305359,
0.6521320939064026,
0.7375932931900024,
-0.20181050896644592,
-0.009136390872299671,
0.42122888565063477,
0.016239965334534645,
-0.4198633134365082,
0.0037448471412062645,
0.04185604304075241,
-0.7492928504943848,
-1.1569817066192627,
-0.8018143773078918,
-0.38921934366226196,
0.2438182830810547,
-0.2695118486881256,
0.3148662745952606,
-0.40946295857429504,
-0.32606643438339233,
0.11243896931409836,
0.1210750862956047,
-0.8856667280197144,
-0.021981131285429,
0.259122371673584,
0.965766966342926,
-0.6995234489440918,
1.0643728971481323,
0.5176065564155579,
-0.31075721979141235,
-1.1208747625350952,
-0.15838588774204254,
-0.26607638597488403,
-1.0023571252822876,
0.8343357443809509,
0.8363810777664185,
0.05392467975616455,
-0.12034190446138382,
-0.3328877389431,
-1.1946582794189453,
0.9009097218513489,
0.6034129858016968,
-0.5691676139831543,
-0.10649629682302475,
-0.10980082303285599,
0.36369243264198303,
-0.4532569944858551,
0.35169506072998047,
0.6216315627098083,
0.46772176027297974,
0.032393112778663635,
-1.056644320487976,
-0.07056793570518494,
-0.0812094584107399,
0.20995819568634033,
0.3451312482357025,
-0.4310240149497986,
1.0827031135559082,
-0.4902040660381317,
-0.006000516004860401,
0.2445055991411209,
0.8544132113456726,
0.24271400272846222,
0.1826142966747284,
0.6129388213157654,
0.3623195290565491,
0.9382992386817932,
-0.03864576295018196,
1.3558049201965332,
-0.39608368277549744,
0.09331359714269638,
0.8585723638534546,
-0.035799965262413025,
1.0665853023529053,
0.46841099858283997,
-0.1185687780380249,
0.4209883213043213,
0.7377297878265381,
0.20657287538051605,
0.5126895904541016,
0.27291053533554077,
-0.17220060527324677,
-0.33466795086860657,
-0.10396397858858109,
-0.4735538065433502,
0.5651617646217346,
0.06380214542150497,
-0.13686418533325195,
0.1320730745792389,
0.22562824189662933,
0.030322281643748283,
-0.2279433012008667,
-0.399745911359787,
0.5522637963294983,
-0.08342214673757553,
-0.8373279571533203,
0.5417085289955139,
0.2902699112892151,
0.943788468837738,
-0.4302581250667572,
0.01847226172685623,
-0.22309786081314087,
0.3353479206562042,
0.06655305624008179,
-0.3398294150829315,
0.2361876368522644,
-0.00033931140205822885,
0.10832608491182327,
-0.16445426642894745,
0.6988610625267029,
-0.3102625012397766,
-0.6196925640106201,
0.30496034026145935,
0.47952476143836975,
0.18727737665176392,
-0.3953638970851898,
-0.5677308440208435,
-0.0200693067163229,
-0.20588171482086182,
-0.20687367022037506,
0.32056599855422974,
0.2954988479614258,
-0.19240789115428925,
0.8449434638023376,
1.0156655311584473,
0.2630625367164612,
0.5062795877456665,
0.29175227880477905,
0.9215264916419983,
-0.578676164150238,
-0.5396947264671326,
-0.9320416450500488,
0.27651792764663696,
-0.13142740726470947,
-0.3344353139400482,
0.4116167426109314,
0.6107723712921143,
0.9295607209205627,
-0.09767724573612213,
0.750307023525238,
0.08679899573326111,
0.5143766403198242,
-0.641964852809906,
0.324843168258667,
-0.4525955617427826,
0.024021293967962265,
-0.06491713225841522,
-0.9619963765144348,
-0.43483394384384155,
0.48272237181663513,
-0.19809353351593018,
0.18504062294960022,
0.8081510066986084,
0.5838855504989624,
0.06643509864807129,
-0.10315407067537308,
0.23654811084270477,
-0.19014394283294678,
0.5497173070907593,
0.5728212594985962,
0.800563395023346,
-0.18786948919296265,
0.6553959250450134,
-0.3000677525997162,
0.10744071751832962,
-0.24448423087596893,
-0.9433906674385071,
-1.0582109689712524,
-0.5269527435302734,
0.06171274930238724,
-0.02800251729786396,
0.015234814025461674,
1.0205079317092896,
1.0642811059951782,
-0.7953733205795288,
-0.045513685792684555,
-0.2850453853607178,
-0.05009680613875389,
-0.41943928599357605,
-0.12599211931228638,
0.3893669545650482,
-0.6795479655265808,
-0.8702423572540283,
0.2539617419242859,
0.10836257040500641,
-0.04808497801423073,
-0.18866528570652008,
-0.19880981743335724,
0.018424946814775467,
-0.08368504792451859,
0.78817218542099,
-0.11411386728286743,
-0.7147532105445862,
-0.40813109278678894,
-0.03369038179516792,
0.10392516851425171,
0.033672694116830826,
1.0141299962997437,
-0.7538050413131714,
0.1807062327861786,
0.35403355956077576,
1.0117230415344238,
0.5542188286781311,
-0.12655752897262573,
0.7404316663742065,
-0.748709499835968,
0.43764206767082214,
0.15419870615005493,
0.5847939848899841,
0.5231195092201233,
-0.27620789408683777,
0.5017511248588562,
0.0951819121837616,
-0.3324214220046997,
-0.8293464183807373,
0.11949455738067627,
-0.6486395597457886,
-0.11040325462818146,
1.2279105186462402,
-0.14308872818946838,
0.0332384929060936,
-0.03244848549365997,
-0.27037858963012695,
0.4310515820980072,
-0.5500571727752686,
0.5595223903656006,
0.715894877910614,
-0.08200382441282272,
-0.06039374694228172,
-0.80955570936203,
0.40297648310661316,
0.5974562168121338,
-0.8280215263366699,
0.20825357735157013,
0.4014463424682617,
0.0750560611486435,
0.11031006276607513,
0.8525537848472595,
-0.09933806955814362,
0.1377808153629303,
0.1268397718667984,
0.03996063023805618,
-0.32591181993484497,
-0.6754546761512756,
-0.24788719415664673,
0.15467846393585205,
0.47375884652137756,
-0.23554769158363342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19733v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19733v3
|
Iterative Reasoning Preference Optimization
| 2024-04-30T17:28:05 | 2024-06-26T01:28:35 |
Richard Yuanzhe Pang, Weizhe Yuan, Kyunghyun Cho, He He, Sainbayar Sukhbaatar, Jason Weston
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Iterative preference optimization methods have recently been shown to perform
well for general instruction tuning tasks, but typically make little
improvement on reasoning tasks (Yuan et al., 2024, Chen et al., 2024). In this
work we develop an iterative approach that optimizes the preference between
competing generated Chain-of-Thought (CoT) candidates by optimizing for winning
vs. losing reasoning steps that lead to the correct answer. We train using a
modified DPO loss (Rafailov et al., 2023) with an additional negative
log-likelihood term, which we find to be crucial. We show reasoning improves
across repeated iterations of this scheme. While only relying on examples in
the training set, our approach results in increasing accuracy on GSM8K, MATH,
and ARC-Challenge for Llama-2-70B-Chat, outperforming other Llama-2-based
models not relying on additionally sourced datasets. For example, we see a
large improvement from 55.6% to 81.6% on GSM8K and an accuracy of 88.7% with
majority voting out of 32 samples.
|
[
-0.43377652764320374,
-0.5418186187744141,
0.8600982427597046,
0.120213083922863,
-0.573789656162262,
0.2876023054122925,
-0.4312235713005066,
-0.07128443568944931,
-0.0004690154455602169,
0.39386722445487976,
-0.6480262875556946,
-0.5508554577827454,
-0.8582364916801453,
0.013323083519935608,
-0.036934543401002884,
0.8021799325942993,
-0.36910954117774963,
0.007929296232759953,
-0.17777089774608612,
0.028418099507689476,
-0.6450544595718384,
-0.5787405967712402,
-0.7216663956642151,
-0.5879039764404297,
0.4165056049823761,
0.8069639205932617,
0.45443034172058105,
0.5368992686271667,
0.19763734936714172,
0.2621282935142517,
-0.2715156376361847,
0.6069356203079224,
-0.7881830930709839,
0.053725071251392365,
-0.4362317621707916,
-0.6563593149185181,
-0.2056499570608139,
0.11515262722969055,
0.1415547877550125,
0.3464750349521637,
-0.4487053453922272,
0.2807358503341675,
-0.2870069146156311,
1.1160354614257812,
-0.7785054445266724,
-0.17565518617630005,
-1.1657524108886719,
0.04096302390098572,
-0.18426761031150818,
-0.8029590845108032,
-0.784855306148529,
-0.5533985495567322,
0.08659565448760986,
-0.6212846040725708,
0.12285345047712326,
0.36390599608421326,
0.6958822011947632,
0.46153950691223145,
-0.3763717710971832,
-0.5106146335601807,
-0.5546403527259827,
1.040475845336914,
-0.49178141355514526,
0.19971951842308044,
0.4909740388393402,
0.12330804020166397,
-0.3488086760044098,
-0.2270309180021286,
-0.5019893050193787,
-0.2987918555736542,
0.35259321331977844,
0.2692054510116577,
0.02603667415678501,
0.26050764322280884,
0.09380973130464554,
0.4370151162147522,
-0.23969286680221558,
0.10531729459762573,
-0.38343873620033264,
-0.034090809524059296,
0.7819398641586304,
0.11917291581630707,
-0.21890226006507874,
0.23889784514904022,
-0.3224743604660034,
-0.2505766749382019,
-0.7148734927177429,
0.2039937973022461,
0.5745523571968079,
0.0182050634175539,
0.3244425356388092,
0.6648598909378052,
-0.26412996649742126,
0.9608573913574219,
0.5477836728096008,
-0.32667121291160583,
0.13104841113090515,
-0.04338609799742699,
-0.05848756805062294,
0.29500988125801086,
0.3711094558238983,
0.5571356415748596,
0.32326996326446533,
-0.01081613078713417,
0.10369745641946793,
0.22976964712142944,
0.3388010561466217,
-0.40854766964912415,
-0.2375359684228897,
0.329000860452652,
-0.3132742643356323,
-0.3637026250362396,
-0.24916909635066986,
-0.31248950958251953,
-0.22204488515853882,
-0.5832127332687378,
0.32680216431617737,
-0.2873382270336151,
-0.1818917989730835,
0.5181946754455566,
-0.22086934745311737,
0.2929764986038208,
0.5299265384674072,
-0.9842633605003357,
0.13240846991539001,
0.6382022500038147,
0.6112635731697083,
-0.3982102572917938,
-0.0023011493030935526,
-0.6423199772834778,
-0.00831932295113802,
-0.749116063117981,
0.9479477405548096,
-0.6518124341964722,
-0.5353567004203796,
-0.4558491110801697,
-0.48012879490852356,
-0.4923003911972046,
-0.6322399973869324,
0.6191524863243103,
-0.6214314699172974,
0.1234203651547432,
-0.5363786816596985,
-0.760117769241333,
-0.04144074767827988,
0.5397547483444214,
-0.44989013671875,
1.035412311553955,
-0.1766156703233719,
-0.6006876826286316,
0.43633562326431274,
-0.44147711992263794,
-0.150855153799057,
-0.5048715472221375,
-0.18718953430652618,
-0.43276822566986084,
0.2098827213048935,
0.29813823103904724,
0.05063706636428833,
-0.44808945059776306,
0.08489379286766052,
-0.29385191202163696,
-0.7286026477813721,
0.02389402687549591,
-0.056134723126888275,
0.7088647484779358,
0.04125859588384628,
-0.7186968326568604,
0.105997733771801,
-0.5260471105575562,
0.4744229316711426,
0.21701791882514954,
-0.351546972990036,
-0.1878848671913147,
0.21608082950115204,
-0.8733190894126892,
0.09156059473752975,
-0.0610618069767952,
-0.5855004191398621,
0.5094562768936157,
-0.2641146183013916,
0.15740150213241577,
1.2718578577041626,
-0.03316209465265274,
0.4049037992954254,
-0.274300754070282,
0.35240694880485535,
0.16599631309509277,
0.33107858896255493,
0.5027331709861755,
-0.6836696863174438,
-1.0059324502944946,
0.025085149332880974,
0.16946952044963837,
0.4488411545753479,
-0.8767291307449341,
0.31905093789100647,
0.13966281712055206,
-0.3735523223876953,
-0.5718353986740112,
0.14420001208782196,
0.28299885988235474,
0.5866344571113586,
0.3545466363430023,
-0.08743640035390854,
-0.47341403365135193,
-0.6118414402008057,
-0.07283425331115723,
-0.3394045829772949,
0.34667035937309265,
0.5130178332328796,
0.15213525295257568,
-0.13879884779453278,
0.5148046612739563,
-0.5739530920982361,
-0.020211447030305862,
-0.23214617371559143,
-0.11908689141273499,
0.2790912687778473,
0.17227905988693237,
0.4520491659641266,
-0.6114581823348999,
-0.43073657155036926,
0.15033206343650818,
-0.44985151290893555,
0.09389329701662064,
-0.056359872221946716,
-0.5095119476318359,
0.30807533860206604,
-0.08510228246450424,
-0.2078772783279419,
0.5794953107833862,
0.4715818762779236,
-0.17549335956573486,
0.4224267601966858,
-0.08343241363763809,
0.3720431327819824,
-0.6792128086090088,
-0.21339614689350128,
-0.24740202724933624,
0.025756187736988068,
-0.21516822278499603,
-0.2462569624185562,
-0.18673525750637054,
0.20196248590946198,
-0.0673573687672615,
0.3494519591331482,
-0.22612032294273376,
-0.14129385352134705,
-0.30876055359840393,
0.37342125177383423,
0.046117618680000305,
0.6511802673339844,
0.3092714846134186,
0.9827762246131897,
0.4531632959842682,
-0.7468637228012085,
0.29553401470184326,
0.38639649748802185,
-0.29215115308761597,
0.28822922706604004,
-0.5443995594978333,
0.8075195550918579,
-0.07685548812150955,
0.23203149437904358,
-0.8605596423149109,
0.2646067440509796,
0.2901715636253357,
-0.41403084993362427,
-0.011588061228394508,
0.11773687601089478,
-0.111618272960186,
-0.5503869652748108,
-0.4956701099872589,
0.31137439608573914,
0.3280302882194519,
-1.029105305671692,
0.31420382857322693,
0.05132313445210457,
0.27841266989707947,
-0.9774773120880127,
-0.07279834896326065,
-0.06827888637781143,
-0.10687636584043503,
-0.42381852865219116,
0.4381422698497772,
-0.20509713888168335,
-0.24978290498256683,
-0.2420036792755127,
-0.5109646320343018,
0.19517529010772705,
-0.050366245210170746,
-0.11955070495605469,
0.2943350672721863,
0.009934880770742893,
0.2761586606502533,
0.26131588220596313,
-0.4748390316963196,
-0.22776108980178833,
-0.4039885997772217,
0.630366325378418,
-0.3031870126724243,
-0.3617372512817383,
-0.32529139518737793,
0.49831563234329224,
0.1300039291381836,
-0.11892437934875488,
0.5493950843811035,
0.2021787017583847,
0.18743814527988434,
-0.41450709104537964,
-0.6855350732803345,
-0.06846236437559128,
-0.4936697483062744,
-0.04492025077342987,
-0.6578181385993958,
-0.7948511242866516,
0.2467288225889206,
-0.2141786366701126,
0.06880801916122437,
0.29597240686416626,
0.6324213743209839,
-0.11561264097690582,
1.2050590515136719,
0.5812305212020874,
-0.0837387815117836,
0.3665722608566284,
-0.42359599471092224,
0.4037002921104431,
-0.8487178683280945,
-0.2697388827800751,
-0.3420712649822235,
-0.2102774679660797,
-0.6129739880561829,
-0.42800644040107727,
0.35627326369285583,
0.07124852389097214,
-0.4451192319393158,
0.2532201409339905,
-0.9522794485092163,
0.6778671741485596,
0.9121581315994263,
0.5900059342384338,
0.42226317524909973,
0.02801489643752575,
-0.21662969887256622,
0.17602139711380005,
-0.7948052287101746,
-0.575221061706543,
1.2455660104751587,
-0.03333888575434685,
0.8447217345237732,
-0.013495315797626972,
1.0814714431762695,
0.27944427728652954,
0.14020290970802307,
-0.8420174717903137,
0.467338502407074,
-0.15132813155651093,
-0.3562523126602173,
-0.03790641948580742,
-0.37363505363464355,
-0.640545129776001,
-0.0473361499607563,
0.10057558119297028,
-0.9136175513267517,
0.22591370344161987,
0.5244918465614319,
-0.17117559909820557,
0.4706058204174042,
-0.5463630557060242,
0.36051279306411743,
-0.42704692482948303,
-0.4097540080547333,
-0.5780972242355347,
-0.6144939661026001,
0.25856947898864746,
0.2642621099948883,
-0.49760136008262634,
-0.20796923339366913,
0.01205354928970337,
0.6210300922393799,
-0.4265371263027191,
0.3391103148460388,
-0.0294047798961401,
-0.16264677047729492,
0.6623155474662781,
-0.13049809634685516,
0.5818210244178772,
0.0568205900490284,
-0.5719103217124939,
0.16934765875339508,
-0.18238836526870728,
-0.5040985941886902,
-0.628422200679779,
0.6108906865119934,
-0.9515385031700134,
-1.0775257349014282,
-0.42826715111732483,
-0.238342747092247,
-0.3144034445285797,
-0.23341988027095795,
0.5416291356086731,
0.34418728947639465,
0.2665635645389557,
0.0797356441617012,
0.8385883569717407,
-0.013758735731244087,
0.20837737619876862,
-0.017963841557502747,
0.18485639989376068,
-0.5529847145080566,
0.7133695483207703,
-0.20071713626384735,
0.618340253829956,
0.38091936707496643,
0.40327417850494385,
-0.41441792249679565,
-0.5424384474754333,
-0.8599289655685425,
0.08883848041296005,
-0.9564656019210815,
-0.25577718019485474,
-0.3356163203716278,
-0.002190053230151534,
0.22453750669956207,
-0.39389845728874207,
-0.5378608703613281,
-0.4937986135482788,
-0.21087537705898285,
-0.20293453335762024,
0.31348931789398193,
0.48374882340431213,
0.13835714757442474,
0.21152953803539276,
-0.11287272721529007,
0.24908801913261414,
0.4560433328151703,
0.4171423017978668,
0.03366311639547348,
-0.42558375000953674,
0.06780596077442169,
0.08537231385707855,
-0.5889744758605957,
-0.7895377278327942,
-0.08759459853172302,
0.07233088463544846,
0.717795193195343,
0.29820558428764343,
0.18729163706302643,
0.9828260540962219,
-0.11867071688175201,
0.6906844973564148,
0.1553405225276947,
-0.9832064509391785,
0.8563604354858398,
-0.011519473046064377,
0.056151945143938065,
0.8471930623054504,
0.27559536695480347,
-0.003106997348368168,
-0.04700486361980438,
-0.6842989921569824,
-0.5793520212173462,
0.6165900230407715,
0.30841290950775146,
-0.13330410420894623,
-0.20987625420093536,
0.5276331901550293,
0.13257966935634613,
0.36258429288864136,
-0.36981359124183655,
-0.34873709082603455,
-0.22689741849899292,
0.0029053427278995514,
0.27727943658828735,
-0.23187436163425446,
-0.262871116399765,
-0.4355259835720062,
1.0030514001846313,
-0.40043798089027405,
0.47980788350105286,
0.2620994746685028,
0.15087255835533142,
-0.18421119451522827,
0.13728462159633636,
0.6623090505599976,
0.6943044066429138,
-0.2564985752105713,
0.07208952307701111,
0.2682032585144043,
-0.25270751118659973,
0.4429207742214203,
-0.39334529638290405,
-0.017250075936317444,
-0.07293573021888733,
0.012306136079132557,
1.0617141723632812,
-0.08109607547521591,
-0.5492634773254395,
0.3383959233760834,
-0.16825178265571594,
-0.3368932008743286,
-0.037677913904190063,
0.3380480408668518,
-0.06913495063781738,
0.1883440613746643,
0.25712448358535767,
0.3004312515258789,
0.21433374285697937,
-0.447280615568161,
-0.05544249713420868,
0.29476580023765564,
-0.06348121911287308,
0.08603938668966293,
0.38006463646888733,
0.30200931429862976,
-0.25757792592048645,
0.5272802114486694,
-0.2346573919057846,
-0.7186018228530884,
0.7574946284294128,
0.697513222694397,
0.8703126907348633,
-0.024734321981668472,
0.3692174255847931,
0.6793031692504883,
0.13239464163780212,
-0.3337991237640381,
0.32805001735687256,
-0.5589333772659302,
-0.9180724620819092,
-0.3511233329772949,
-0.20975852012634277,
-0.9018259644508362,
-0.2044246941804886,
-0.7044028639793396,
0.32658350467681885,
-0.6104650497436523,
-0.2433418333530426,
-0.24881325662136078,
0.2575397491455078,
-0.6148271560668945,
0.2878018319606781,
0.05853687599301338,
0.7220991253852844,
-0.3293852210044861,
0.7361083626747131,
0.4914366900920868,
0.06225581094622612,
-0.9456285238265991,
0.002782996278256178,
-0.0685170441865921,
-1.0699098110198975,
0.4646865129470825,
0.21234141290187836,
-0.6094930171966553,
0.0029344584327191114,
-0.4646424651145935,
-0.9781519770622253,
1.1087018251419067,
0.4196400046348572,
-0.8964548707008362,
0.14155009388923645,
-0.07876621931791306,
0.2222583144903183,
-0.5222756266593933,
0.3668307363986969,
0.8190470933914185,
0.20962414145469666,
0.5641559958457947,
-0.9140483736991882,
-0.26089707016944885,
-0.2649646997451782,
0.05535042658448219,
0.20455381274223328,
-0.939021110534668,
0.6417126655578613,
-0.7067186832427979,
0.07068983465433121,
-0.04644177109003067,
0.27459466457366943,
0.7893653512001038,
0.565565288066864,
0.6642448902130127,
0.5192312598228455,
1.0154368877410889,
-0.15309083461761475,
0.9178637862205505,
-0.11491667479276657,
0.34556856751441956,
1.2256089448928833,
-0.3331684470176697,
0.6464183926582336,
0.584938108921051,
-0.19597359001636505,
0.8032236099243164,
1.0189090967178345,
0.4091126620769501,
0.6689492464065552,
0.33803585171699524,
-0.33778810501098633,
-0.6255045533180237,
0.08164991438388824,
-0.27781203389167786,
0.6114072203636169,
0.19619214534759521,
-0.24196772277355194,
0.011692401021718979,
-0.19385898113250732,
-0.038259584456682205,
0.2444860339164734,
-0.36862245202064514,
0.9042375683784485,
-0.029077624902129173,
-0.9447081089019775,
1.0025266408920288,
-0.2246202826499939,
0.4237724840641022,
-0.38678663969039917,
-0.021576782688498497,
-0.24500271677970886,
0.3877670466899872,
-0.03500271961092949,
-0.6108940839767456,
0.09977163374423981,
-0.012363345362246037,
-0.1657480150461197,
-0.008055519312620163,
0.6557309627532959,
-0.22818391025066376,
-0.31762534379959106,
0.3153848350048065,
0.2357630729675293,
-0.17749153077602386,
0.14433106780052185,
-0.7390993237495422,
0.333244264125824,
0.3307516872882843,
-0.3844408392906189,
0.041546449065208435,
0.09474016726016998,
-0.2112591564655304,
0.8489853739738464,
0.43554940819740295,
-0.06117798015475273,
-0.0779920369386673,
0.09183548390865326,
1.1798053979873657,
-0.6760551929473877,
-0.41304725408554077,
-0.8555709719657898,
0.3462139666080475,
-0.5677602291107178,
-0.6362718343734741,
0.4584744870662689,
0.47530150413513184,
0.8970577120780945,
0.024814030155539513,
0.6977052688598633,
0.06213963031768799,
0.20028477907180786,
-0.6190188527107239,
-0.1336074024438858,
-0.3499418795108795,
0.4271133840084076,
-0.22341322898864746,
-0.8520259261131287,
0.12100609391927719,
0.8197489380836487,
-0.6206756830215454,
-0.09076542407274246,
0.7488206028938293,
0.5862334370613098,
0.283759206533432,
0.2638631761074066,
0.15214170515537262,
-0.4057351052761078,
0.3083191514015198,
1.0120105743408203,
0.7828269004821777,
-0.5250582695007324,
0.3785640001296997,
-0.4787186086177826,
-0.3967756927013397,
-0.1982698291540146,
-0.913554310798645,
-1.0664372444152832,
-0.38001102209091187,
-0.33687517046928406,
-0.21593736112117767,
0.33391302824020386,
1.1125801801681519,
0.6377674341201782,
-0.6844656467437744,
-0.22670575976371765,
-0.23995478451251984,
0.43322405219078064,
-0.4115232527256012,
-0.1040913462638855,
0.28622889518737793,
-0.47398802638053894,
-0.5427526235580444,
0.2627894878387451,
0.33674919605255127,
-0.2128562182188034,
0.14995914697647095,
-0.2164696305990219,
-0.22497926652431488,
0.3314071297645569,
0.7132049202919006,
0.10810694843530655,
-0.8955821394920349,
-0.6034196019172668,
0.3840771019458771,
0.2391117960214615,
0.19445239007472992,
0.8055564165115356,
-0.7534658312797546,
0.7586116194725037,
0.3148115873336792,
0.5771206021308899,
0.9353168606758118,
0.26458048820495605,
0.66576087474823,
-0.4787152409553528,
0.1415436863899231,
0.2819371521472931,
0.10966680198907852,
0.2907278835773468,
-0.4957899749279022,
0.8456587791442871,
0.186067596077919,
-0.7309484481811523,
-0.6439546942710876,
0.1466423124074936,
-1.1844288110733032,
-0.08504883199930191,
1.1711052656173706,
0.07708306610584259,
-0.12001077085733414,
0.13714756071567535,
-0.7196135520935059,
0.08314929902553558,
-0.5254508852958679,
1.2715494632720947,
0.5521740317344666,
-0.5672734975814819,
-0.21266154944896698,
-0.031861044466495514,
0.5839524269104004,
0.602581262588501,
-0.8009368181228638,
-0.12582586705684662,
0.1110311970114708,
0.13134539127349854,
-0.004174902569502592,
0.9395486116409302,
0.11184011399745941,
0.49325308203697205,
-0.012811320833861828,
-0.2494688779115677,
0.025110632181167603,
-0.40396741032600403,
0.2123485952615738,
-0.13607659935951233,
0.3029531240463257,
-0.4717394709587097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19721v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19721v2
|
PANGeA: Procedural Artificial Narrative using Generative AI for Turn-Based Video Games
| 2024-04-30T17:11:54 | 2024-06-30T20:54:57 |
Steph Buongiorno, Lawrence Jake Klinkert, Tanishq Chawla, Zixin Zhuang, Corey Clark
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This research introduces Procedural Artificial Narrative using Generative AI
(PANGeA), a structured approach for leveraging large language models (LLMs),
guided by a game designer's high-level criteria, to generate narrative content
for turn-based role-playing video games (RPGs). Distinct from prior
applications of LLMs used for video game design, PANGeA innovates by not only
generating game level data (which includes, but is not limited to, setting, key
items, and non-playable characters (NPCs)), but by also fostering dynamic,
free-form interactions between the player and the environment that align with
the procedural game narrative. The NPCs generated by PANGeA are
personality-biased and express traits from the Big 5 Personality Model in their
generated responses. PANGeA addresses challenges behind ingesting free-form
text input, which can prompt LLM responses beyond the scope of the game
narrative. A novel validation system that uses the LLM's intelligence evaluates
text input and aligns generated responses with the unfolding narrative. Making
these interactions possible, PANGeA is supported by a server that hosts a
custom memory system that supplies context for augmenting generated responses
thus aligning them with the procedural narrative. For its broad application,
the server has a REST interface enabling any game engine to integrate directly
with PANGeA, as well as an LLM interface adaptable with local or private LLMs.
PANGeA's ability to foster dynamic narrative generation by aligning responses
with the procedural narrative is demonstrated through an empirical study and
ablation test of two versions of a demo game. These are, a custom,
browser-based GPT and a Unity demo. As the results show, PANGeA holds potential
to assist game designers in using LLMs to generate narrative-consistent content
even when provided varied and unpredictable, free-form text input.
|
[
-0.42876148223876953,
-0.8868707418441772,
0.8815032243728638,
0.4595990777015686,
-0.4914633333683014,
0.374447762966156,
-0.1849316656589508,
-0.5312322974205017,
0.4811827540397644,
0.6863237023353577,
-0.8288272023200989,
-0.7800363898277283,
-0.2858045995235443,
0.3583013415336609,
-0.40022018551826477,
0.7388259172439575,
-0.07616637647151947,
-0.2679738998413086,
-0.19964295625686646,
-0.008348414674401283,
-0.3976733684539795,
-0.39623889327049255,
-0.6903671026229858,
-0.30724793672561646,
0.28046202659606934,
0.041956931352615356,
0.5901488661766052,
1.0526167154312134,
0.4305761456489563,
0.42211440205574036,
0.1133442372083664,
0.4643174409866333,
-0.6487016677856445,
0.24773424863815308,
-0.07973159104585648,
-0.6060522198677063,
-0.2071782648563385,
-0.14481115341186523,
0.20139016211032867,
0.011941428296267986,
-0.09118712693452835,
0.26042670011520386,
-0.26029065251350403,
0.25968706607818604,
-0.21453240513801575,
0.23408927023410797,
-0.3739332854747772,
0.2686058580875397,
-0.1408454030752182,
-0.29435884952545166,
-0.36410799622535706,
-0.6200293898582458,
0.2317306101322174,
-1.1125537157058716,
0.28912103176116943,
-0.013554589822888374,
0.5668613910675049,
0.5115680694580078,
-0.08511308580636978,
-0.8276166915893555,
-0.9899073839187622,
0.4304403066635132,
-1.0211725234985352,
-0.14373734593391418,
0.04439200833439827,
0.1596994549036026,
-0.2132180780172348,
-0.5480719208717346,
-0.7295358180999756,
-0.4343177080154419,
0.357022225856781,
0.40558508038520813,
0.12523232400417328,
0.2637869417667389,
0.0416635163128376,
0.4810463488101959,
-0.5879082083702087,
0.5155524015426636,
-0.21104253828525543,
-0.08280155062675476,
0.8943561315536499,
0.5226978063583374,
0.5973575711250305,
-0.2118123322725296,
-0.4004021883010864,
-0.10829330235719681,
-0.9181095957756042,
0.23842500150203705,
0.6380776166915894,
0.2832706868648529,
-0.24868059158325195,
0.6927939653396606,
0.17309723794460297,
0.468791127204895,
0.18826864659786224,
-0.3223799169063568,
-0.15781421959400177,
-0.24762457609176636,
-0.032137252390384674,
0.36206817626953125,
0.9286088943481445,
0.6297175884246826,
0.03389771282672882,
-0.2274424433708191,
-0.07046864181756973,
0.60189288854599,
0.47678929567337036,
-0.8387695550918579,
-0.12201039493083954,
0.4337010979652405,
-0.5207288861274719,
-0.5682193636894226,
0.06687941402196884,
-1.2380903959274292,
-0.9575092792510986,
-0.08838574588298798,
-0.2860221564769745,
-0.4516843259334564,
-0.14371246099472046,
-0.29397302865982056,
-0.2512608468532562,
0.22501912713050842,
0.17933975160121918,
-1.0381799936294556,
0.1699358969926834,
0.7557061910629272,
0.9889650940895081,
-0.5426766276359558,
-0.2332639992237091,
-0.33575981855392456,
0.38664376735687256,
-0.4745107591152191,
0.8700916767120361,
-0.5864740610122681,
-0.8677235841751099,
0.3086349070072174,
-0.18361817300319672,
0.436554491519928,
-0.7675428986549377,
0.201017364859581,
-0.2320612370967865,
-0.06369681656360626,
-0.10354213416576385,
-0.4332328140735626,
-0.14082646369934082,
0.36945608258247375,
-0.6656888127326965,
0.6722785830497742,
-0.023364899680018425,
-0.0377456359565258,
0.5290282368659973,
-0.6514106392860413,
-0.40079042315483093,
0.4181234836578369,
-0.27411478757858276,
-0.10693702101707458,
0.3726893961429596,
0.1300932914018631,
-0.22152025997638702,
-0.4712725877761841,
0.2475983202457428,
-0.17720282077789307,
-0.4067552387714386,
0.21386370062828064,
-0.2682918310165405,
0.29598140716552734,
-0.0598662905395031,
-0.47105538845062256,
0.45442670583724976,
-0.7595969438552856,
-0.06667974591255188,
0.18466930091381073,
-0.3729855716228485,
-0.01210431382060051,
0.43928998708724976,
-0.37374669313430786,
0.24440965056419373,
0.2243403047323227,
-0.5233407616615295,
0.520946204662323,
-0.4658719599246979,
0.5256713032722473,
0.7828524112701416,
0.19148248434066772,
0.3431829512119293,
-0.28345781564712524,
0.653263509273529,
-0.1702113300561905,
0.07228156924247742,
-0.310995489358902,
-0.4582303762435913,
-0.6061878204345703,
-0.2096792608499527,
-0.009373938664793968,
0.8175806999206543,
-1.0797255039215088,
0.21477289497852325,
0.046987127512693405,
-0.5562309622764587,
-0.6207954287528992,
0.15470901131629944,
0.2349606156349182,
0.4104756712913513,
0.23375199735164642,
-0.320705771446228,
-0.7858301997184753,
-0.4740428626537323,
0.22225520014762878,
-0.49021780490875244,
-0.1944999098777771,
0.5393268465995789,
0.14956460893154144,
-0.15887124836444855,
0.8053573966026306,
-0.46283406019210815,
-0.29296261072158813,
-0.3880312442779541,
0.4601436257362366,
0.0034371144138276577,
0.1687036007642746,
0.5239250659942627,
-0.4775068163871765,
-0.2048492580652237,
-0.03896539285778999,
-0.9646238684654236,
-0.299121230840683,
-0.3843819499015808,
0.17022092640399933,
0.24124448001384735,
0.20116865634918213,
-0.8006688356399536,
0.5144518613815308,
0.6202523112297058,
-0.26115062832832336,
0.8034718632698059,
-0.34358707070350647,
0.22516801953315735,
-0.9862632155418396,
-0.05770706385374069,
-0.10119092464447021,
0.142782524228096,
-0.3961595892906189,
0.2830835282802582,
-0.6179433465003967,
-0.22738128900527954,
-0.3702546954154968,
0.5375128984451294,
-0.23455330729484558,
-0.10938245803117752,
-0.3753666877746582,
0.5629968643188477,
-0.16781793534755707,
0.5140912532806396,
0.26022231578826904,
0.9145361185073853,
0.22009193897247314,
-0.5681011080741882,
0.8273183107376099,
0.3468809723854065,
-0.20854845643043518,
0.6196814775466919,
-0.7404661774635315,
0.28269699215888977,
0.04755758121609688,
0.21330727636814117,
-0.8008033037185669,
-0.06276257336139679,
0.08538468927145004,
-0.30458223819732666,
-0.4065011441707611,
-0.08653620630502701,
-0.5281100869178772,
-0.5795271396636963,
-0.2408725470304489,
0.18054679036140442,
0.609040379524231,
-0.4139252007007599,
0.8254891037940979,
0.30071982741355896,
-0.31515172123908997,
-0.052174538373947144,
-0.7231652140617371,
0.27125775814056396,
-0.4457114338874817,
-0.45390936732292175,
0.4045547842979431,
-0.2126876711845398,
-0.24531520903110504,
-0.017522575333714485,
0.18645025789737701,
0.02607671171426773,
-0.17261840403079987,
0.4709489941596985,
0.38974234461784363,
-0.4556749165058136,
-0.2355901151895523,
0.03377685323357582,
-0.0647478774189949,
0.21825437247753143,
-0.30806657671928406,
0.9392817616462708,
0.03297022730112076,
-0.2271323949098587,
-0.4540152847766876,
0.4107106626033783,
0.5950179100036621,
-0.2041628062725067,
0.3715862035751343,
0.2716258764266968,
-0.012519034557044506,
-0.17712928354740143,
-0.2808733880519867,
-0.012948578223586082,
-0.5043125748634338,
0.21579231321811676,
-0.2063525766134262,
-0.6688703894615173,
1.053946614265442,
-0.2948641777038574,
0.13372813165187836,
0.3240469992160797,
0.6740897297859192,
0.08624398708343506,
1.280055046081543,
0.6463836431503296,
-0.021274466067552567,
0.21222008764743805,
-0.22824464738368988,
0.09101534634828568,
-0.7369697690010071,
-0.32063600420951843,
-0.22253087162971497,
-0.49125856161117554,
-0.6608884930610657,
-0.2511556148529053,
0.1296657919883728,
-0.24083727598190308,
-0.26254597306251526,
0.07506909966468811,
-0.6762061715126038,
0.5056278109550476,
0.554510772228241,
-0.00568748265504837,
0.4129146337509155,
-0.40508130192756653,
-0.061291467398405075,
-0.027523700147867203,
-0.44782280921936035,
-0.6503546833992004,
0.7516314387321472,
0.03954464942216873,
0.5475116968154907,
0.21013760566711426,
0.774479866027832,
0.486614853143692,
0.3596588373184204,
-0.6647611856460571,
0.7774693369865417,
-0.24137182533740997,
-0.23975636065006256,
-0.36298668384552,
-0.2841190993785858,
-0.8826879858970642,
-0.08331137895584106,
-0.24795471131801605,
-0.7806114554405212,
-0.15322646498680115,
0.04814295470714569,
-0.7699924111366272,
0.3554896414279938,
-0.4713480770587921,
0.5176905393600464,
-0.4442143738269806,
-0.19210414588451385,
-0.14443659782409668,
-0.4280111789703369,
0.31674012541770935,
0.21601907908916473,
-0.22517545521259308,
0.055584732443094254,
-0.09714234620332718,
0.3732409179210663,
-0.4707483649253845,
1.0579429864883423,
-0.21561995148658752,
-0.18619167804718018,
0.642597496509552,
0.6790158152580261,
0.3897866904735565,
0.3009873926639557,
0.17774945497512817,
0.008898344822227955,
-0.10339323431253433,
-0.045292142778635025,
-0.6992077827453613,
0.7950432300567627,
-0.9606403112411499,
-0.6726515293121338,
-0.49683496356010437,
-0.7688674330711365,
-0.12302948534488678,
0.42716217041015625,
0.16420067846775055,
0.32594263553619385,
-0.5704442262649536,
-0.1130676344037056,
0.5760172009468079,
-0.41833165287971497,
0.4515378475189209,
0.29849937558174133,
-0.3437277376651764,
-0.5859530568122864,
1.0644968748092651,
-0.16862033307552338,
0.10848189145326614,
0.006918436381965876,
0.054807037115097046,
-0.2868404686450958,
-0.8422955870628357,
-0.8459365367889404,
0.09243757277727127,
-0.21998107433319092,
-0.10250628739595413,
-0.0307321734726429,
-0.15858741104602814,
-0.1739591509103775,
-0.4939277470111847,
-0.1605314314365387,
0.03692099079489708,
-0.4269757568836212,
-0.40097475051879883,
0.24807870388031006,
1.0372371673583984,
0.20627576112747192,
0.5580409169197083,
-0.6159065961837769,
0.39590176939964294,
-0.057308852672576904,
0.3156474232673645,
-0.05152120441198349,
0.00881512276828289,
0.43094363808631897,
0.1644679754972458,
-0.24589544534683228,
-0.9107038974761963,
0.5788227915763855,
-0.08219265192747116,
0.33324116468429565,
0.5721896886825562,
-0.325409859418869,
0.8175688982009888,
-0.6240412592887878,
1.2421197891235352,
0.10952025651931763,
-0.7264806628227234,
0.49240028858184814,
-0.47173765301704407,
0.46184563636779785,
0.5586797595024109,
0.04155435413122177,
-0.7171751856803894,
-0.5098829865455627,
-0.5358723998069763,
-0.754598081111908,
0.6085031628608704,
-0.0313195139169693,
0.10541242361068726,
-0.23475342988967896,
0.45825204253196716,
0.3312048017978668,
0.45553815364837646,
-0.3370719254016876,
0.060266755521297455,
-0.35154446959495544,
-0.4967755377292633,
-0.014686106704175472,
-0.14837750792503357,
-0.14245077967643738,
0.29817599058151245,
0.42071864008903503,
-0.2248854637145996,
0.15052169561386108,
0.166533961892128,
-0.03272336721420288,
-0.029074786230921745,
-0.3511491119861603,
0.8577094674110413,
0.5957862138748169,
0.14027687907218933,
-0.055684614926576614,
0.04111158847808838,
-0.5664593577384949,
0.02822311967611313,
-0.02313736267387867,
-0.618360161781311,
-0.22935763001441956,
0.2933277189731598,
0.8771249651908875,
-0.07434969395399094,
-0.9242605566978455,
-0.004755087662488222,
0.0042801168747246265,
-0.23487187922000885,
-0.3999534249305725,
0.014543959870934486,
-0.07197599112987518,
0.29571497440338135,
0.26800036430358887,
-0.19830791652202606,
-0.07441506534814835,
-0.7375146150588989,
0.0856463685631752,
0.17301508784294128,
-0.33951133489608765,
-0.4473913311958313,
0.7113803029060364,
0.49715790152549744,
-0.6346297264099121,
0.9671549201011658,
-0.22235921025276184,
-0.24867671728134155,
0.7865748405456543,
0.9641386270523071,
0.8283304572105408,
-0.24641667306423187,
0.7519629001617432,
0.1412205696105957,
0.31322479248046875,
0.31143027544021606,
0.2729266881942749,
0.24896696209907532,
-0.5141623020172119,
-0.5117399096488953,
-0.4732080399990082,
-0.43253612518310547,
0.20231424272060394,
-0.14860409498214722,
-0.04183504730463028,
-0.8877150416374207,
-0.07148081064224243,
-0.49309155344963074,
-0.010093459859490395,
-0.267287015914917,
-0.07157234847545624,
0.4512653052806854,
0.8764030337333679,
-0.6702622771263123,
0.05463863164186478,
0.4138280749320984,
-0.8683337569236755,
-0.6190704703330994,
-0.15199929475784302,
0.29662320017814636,
-0.833471417427063,
0.17136316001415253,
-0.019217202439904213,
-0.03788459673523903,
-0.054211266338825226,
-0.47342127561569214,
-0.5566427111625671,
1.14640212059021,
0.17232590913772583,
-0.17168286442756653,
-0.40598705410957336,
0.7125633955001831,
0.8762190937995911,
-0.6528482437133789,
0.048341572284698486,
0.5823405981063843,
0.45462483167648315,
0.3141539990901947,
-0.4913707971572876,
0.05272075906395912,
-0.1629374772310257,
0.19901691377162933,
0.18164469301700592,
-0.8354907035827637,
0.4041922986507416,
-0.10130608826875687,
-0.1386702060699463,
0.5798310041427612,
0.9053109884262085,
0.6662135124206543,
0.31661030650138855,
0.22954636812210083,
0.6644895076751709,
0.8359405994415283,
-0.4577310383319855,
1.07182776927948,
-0.3637712597846985,
-0.2291359007358551,
0.8084433078765869,
-0.542902946472168,
0.45239341259002686,
0.3510003387928009,
0.1155792698264122,
0.9804114103317261,
0.6532821655273438,
-0.2578894793987274,
0.4732897877693176,
0.3837936520576477,
-0.3056800663471222,
0.171343132853508,
-0.30519238114356995,
0.058245908468961716,
0.5005453824996948,
0.35060155391693115,
-0.08897147327661514,
-0.21395137906074524,
0.0819714218378067,
-0.039234016090631485,
0.2033231258392334,
-0.48442524671554565,
1.0029585361480713,
-0.1464719921350479,
-0.8957914710044861,
-0.12250582128763199,
-0.1500828117132187,
0.5191129446029663,
-0.8391091823577881,
-0.26322367787361145,
-0.41755491495132446,
0.1679660528898239,
-0.01726832240819931,
-0.6093602776527405,
0.07645834982395172,
0.1443917453289032,
-0.11060256510972977,
0.06311814486980438,
0.4507090151309967,
-0.39746177196502686,
-0.4974406063556671,
-0.17575177550315857,
0.3967060148715973,
0.07533536106348038,
0.060261014848947525,
-0.5605807304382324,
0.4622693955898285,
-0.15421749651432037,
0.13104578852653503,
0.13729900121688843,
0.5881302356719971,
-0.27316996455192566,
0.648704469203949,
0.7511823177337646,
0.34150564670562744,
0.12550058960914612,
0.15647245943546295,
0.6131264567375183,
-0.5961917042732239,
-0.7951192855834961,
-0.8950108885765076,
0.3069693148136139,
-0.2638400197029114,
-0.5401116609573364,
0.6088778376579285,
0.6815570592880249,
0.4076839089393616,
-0.09322043508291245,
0.9430797696113586,
-0.18137575685977936,
-0.03269625082612038,
-0.5523888468742371,
0.39412859082221985,
0.1254711002111435,
-0.13199253380298615,
0.020567918196320534,
-0.9829546809196472,
-0.19134779274463654,
0.2566927671432495,
-0.22490854561328888,
-0.07076223194599152,
0.6070798635482788,
0.4644612669944763,
0.24829082190990448,
0.04700073227286339,
0.02732081525027752,
0.2317422777414322,
0.7859063744544983,
0.6810862421989441,
0.8427616953849792,
0.14085479080677032,
0.43932995200157166,
-0.032475292682647705,
-0.3713099956512451,
-0.024042582139372826,
-0.8554032444953918,
-0.9079335331916809,
-0.46361202001571655,
-0.01083905529230833,
-0.280551552772522,
0.10502167046070099,
0.71979820728302,
0.3255692720413208,
-0.7083935737609863,
-0.38693082332611084,
-0.3122256100177765,
-0.1863003522157669,
-0.3493900001049042,
-0.2988445460796356,
0.19617165625095367,
-0.05689799040555954,
-0.795141875743866,
0.6096203923225403,
0.5100638270378113,
0.06819242238998413,
-0.8338855504989624,
-0.012539954856038094,
0.0331343337893486,
0.3702964782714844,
0.6332607865333557,
0.6974911093711853,
-0.8600934743881226,
-0.3649415969848633,
0.23159566521644592,
0.2110583335161209,
0.12700504064559937,
1.206043004989624,
-0.8679486513137817,
0.3943287134170532,
0.377370148897171,
0.7761857509613037,
0.5095922350883484,
0.3997441232204437,
0.9884040951728821,
-0.5150710344314575,
0.3203063905239105,
0.44494369626045227,
0.08179440349340439,
0.2644195258617401,
-0.5047162771224976,
0.3712398111820221,
0.11517921835184097,
-0.448552668094635,
-0.6191723942756653,
0.3862958550453186,
-0.9138442277908325,
0.022921932861208916,
1.095226526260376,
0.0408635288476944,
-0.45167621970176697,
0.11042845249176025,
-0.5662855505943298,
0.15385004878044128,
-0.42325451970100403,
1.2168446779251099,
0.9932940006256104,
-0.2797797620296478,
-0.1035468578338623,
-0.3369227647781372,
0.6685494184494019,
-0.007653022184967995,
-0.9877689480781555,
0.06338595598936081,
0.8335762619972229,
-0.26265227794647217,
0.4937496781349182,
0.3338203430175781,
-0.2006533145904541,
0.3214283883571625,
0.05814940482378006,
0.11716379970312119,
-0.4185086786746979,
-0.26816514134407043,
0.08404228836297989,
0.2297741323709488,
-0.23268535733222961,
0.09659227728843689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19714v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19714v1
|
ThangDLU at #SMM4H 2024: Encoder-decoder models for classifying text data on social disorders in children and adolescents
| 2024-04-30T17:06:20 | 2024-04-30T17:06:20 |
Hoang-Thang Ta, Abu Bakar Siddiqur Rahman, Lotfollah Najjar, Alexander Gelbukh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper describes our participation in Task 3 and Task 5 of the #SMM4H
(Social Media Mining for Health) 2024 Workshop, explicitly targeting the
classification challenges within tweet data. Task 3 is a multi-class
classification task centered on tweets discussing the impact of outdoor
environments on symptoms of social anxiety. Task 5 involves a binary
classification task focusing on tweets reporting medical disorders in children.
We applied transfer learning from pre-trained encoder-decoder models such as
BART-base and T5-small to identify the labels of a set of given tweets. We also
presented some data augmentation methods to see their impact on the model
performance. Finally, the systems obtained the best F1 score of 0.627 in Task 3
and the best F1 score of 0.841 in Task 5.
|
[
0.025163326412439346,
-0.36143118143081665,
0.5832447409629822,
0.07022867351770401,
-0.056959107518196106,
0.20448659360408783,
0.1651652753353119,
-0.795699417591095,
0.12741594016551971,
0.2501715123653412,
-0.5410831570625305,
-0.699174165725708,
-0.9825515151023865,
0.1475449502468109,
-0.5367684364318848,
0.8324106335639954,
-0.22281791269779205,
0.03103215992450714,
-0.14359286427497864,
0.21939727663993835,
-0.09713836759328842,
-0.7341921925544739,
-0.6970537304878235,
-0.125713050365448,
0.39564165472984314,
0.5383166074752808,
0.09430774301290512,
0.2854152023792267,
0.7367826104164124,
0.2056157886981964,
0.02667980082333088,
0.11717768758535385,
-0.6274832487106323,
-0.0023592524230480194,
-0.27324923872947693,
-0.2494962215423584,
-0.5168514251708984,
0.0315985232591629,
0.3445154130458832,
0.5323085784912109,
-0.034135621041059494,
0.28592225909233093,
0.27550777792930603,
0.25788378715515137,
-0.2580088973045349,
0.2984963059425354,
-0.33281877636909485,
0.06965017318725586,
-0.24942833185195923,
-0.4038427770137787,
-0.20075653493404388,
-0.21193894743919373,
-0.13745057582855225,
-0.23727048933506012,
0.35633864998817444,
0.02861570380628109,
0.7235776782035828,
0.28644272685050964,
-0.7412664294242859,
-0.25642552971839905,
-0.4847226142883301,
0.572859525680542,
-0.5433635711669922,
0.3235606849193573,
0.6816257238388062,
0.0899093896150589,
-0.005675025749951601,
-0.7688382863998413,
-0.33346056938171387,
0.48121917247772217,
0.029666954651474953,
-0.1272357702255249,
-0.19877415895462036,
0.11502112448215485,
0.17255020141601562,
-0.01261688582599163,
-0.48652663826942444,
-0.054991114884614944,
-0.9192123413085938,
-0.1044493094086647,
0.7338501811027527,
0.3256712257862091,
0.2730221152305603,
-0.23792684078216553,
0.11540000885725021,
0.31097346544265747,
-0.211100235581398,
0.044219717383384705,
-0.13826338946819305,
0.20314280688762665,
-0.2501658797264099,
0.3579251170158386,
0.04301344230771065,
0.3663979768753052,
0.25860098004341125,
-0.19096486270427704,
0.6215227246284485,
-0.3716810643672943,
-0.0076183718629181385,
-0.05390063673257828,
0.7020488381385803,
0.7241040468215942,
-0.09455110132694244,
-0.10884445160627365,
-0.3172683119773865,
0.20149731636047363,
0.4613092541694641,
-0.9580614566802979,
-0.28654900193214417,
0.019547726958990097,
-0.8336768746376038,
-0.5736842751502991,
-0.015633735805749893,
-0.8547078371047974,
-0.43777742981910706,
-0.18389427661895752,
0.48561593890190125,
-0.5106810927391052,
-0.23117367923259735,
0.036304183304309845,
-0.05300556495785713,
-0.09169720858335495,
0.2690032422542572,
-0.9436975121498108,
0.7038513422012329,
0.46394088864326477,
0.7485892176628113,
-0.3117372393608093,
-0.02575177513062954,
-0.10104778409004211,
0.2448311150074005,
-0.22461622953414917,
0.6029961705207825,
-0.7248474359512329,
-0.3448241949081421,
-0.12152086943387985,
0.507781445980072,
-0.48451122641563416,
-0.34217023849487305,
0.7072141170501709,
-0.25320565700531006,
0.02771245874464512,
-0.3970598876476288,
-0.47511643171310425,
-0.2634231746196747,
0.32927459478378296,
-0.5232875943183899,
0.9376432299613953,
0.4659424424171448,
-0.9464696645736694,
0.22483761608600616,
-0.811669111251831,
-0.5204715728759766,
0.14257177710533142,
0.10928348451852798,
-0.23499922454357147,
-0.044850971549749374,
0.2912234961986542,
0.825753390789032,
-0.07571083307266235,
0.1595604568719864,
-0.4893786907196045,
-0.5313965678215027,
0.11472998559474945,
-0.06484474986791611,
0.577712893486023,
0.09227395057678223,
-0.23900511860847473,
0.06559907644987106,
-0.6114755868911743,
-0.08277710527181625,
0.07433736324310303,
-0.20480108261108398,
-0.046688277274370193,
-0.06072376295924187,
0.26805832982063293,
0.23866121470928192,
0.26368871331214905,
-0.653705358505249,
-0.05968189239501953,
0.017626699060201645,
0.5818599462509155,
0.6836159229278564,
0.4026338756084442,
0.35027456283569336,
-0.585433304309845,
0.5888200998306274,
0.18545912206172943,
0.4104689955711365,
0.10545729845762253,
-0.6877351999282837,
-0.3061409294605255,
0.01566285453736782,
0.16546866297721863,
0.3339976370334625,
-1.086774230003357,
0.2985522150993347,
-0.3698808252811432,
-0.5165933966636658,
-0.5190465450286865,
-0.21170897781848907,
-0.007739688735455275,
0.13354989886283875,
0.4885439872741699,
0.05103323236107826,
-0.7982655763626099,
-0.4103657901287079,
-0.053688131272792816,
0.06437186896800995,
0.24219751358032227,
0.1525941640138626,
0.7600254416465759,
-0.8916455507278442,
0.38398054242134094,
-0.20129257440567017,
-0.33229467272758484,
-0.3117959201335907,
0.06282311677932739,
-0.186534121632576,
0.6079922318458557,
0.6559984683990479,
-0.7757995128631592,
-0.602905809879303,
0.04919017478823662,
-0.7355875372886658,
-0.21121636033058167,
0.5403371453285217,
0.11065071076154709,
0.16744817793369293,
0.5411118268966675,
-0.4648517370223999,
0.4854874908924103,
0.6618978977203369,
-0.3173494338989258,
0.18468131124973297,
0.201586052775383,
0.4731811285018921,
-1.142249584197998,
-0.12172798812389374,
0.09909617155790329,
-0.4428158700466156,
-0.8784758448600769,
-0.13071131706237793,
0.06896572560071945,
-0.09295260906219482,
-0.18090324103832245,
0.12147334218025208,
-0.2553972601890564,
0.18943312764167786,
-0.24264585971832275,
-0.43150922656059265,
-0.15911735594272614,
0.1510983258485794,
-0.33839961886405945,
0.09435328841209412,
0.7690373659133911,
-0.5392696261405945,
0.30562084913253784,
-0.23349089920520782,
-0.006138063035905361,
0.24415099620819092,
-0.32675740122795105,
0.2761428654193878,
-0.31174421310424805,
0.25510814785957336,
-0.8017632961273193,
-0.5098433494567871,
0.5593597888946533,
-0.8158794641494751,
0.38565126061439514,
0.08356393128633499,
-0.6117221713066101,
-0.7157046794891357,
-0.4127644896507263,
0.4987870752811432,
0.38993921875953674,
-0.42006734013557434,
0.5347607135772705,
0.7818140387535095,
0.15768320858478546,
-0.13281875848770142,
-0.6651111245155334,
-0.24038274586200714,
-0.43803271651268005,
-0.430033415555954,
0.8005046844482422,
0.0289311520755291,
0.1379752904176712,
0.463905394077301,
-0.10329408198595047,
-0.1778402030467987,
-0.027711965143680573,
0.44347715377807617,
-0.03737685829401016,
0.06618821620941162,
0.008820333518087864,
0.05628049746155739,
0.02724727988243103,
0.19165901839733124,
0.10578353703022003,
0.47452306747436523,
0.020794697105884552,
-0.07818596810102463,
-0.3400445878505707,
0.35139158368110657,
0.2816565930843353,
0.10784946382045746,
0.6975910067558289,
0.7631677985191345,
-0.995867908000946,
-0.14913499355316162,
-0.16234345734119415,
-0.2352212369441986,
-0.49905216693878174,
0.17603226006031036,
-0.3480507433414459,
-1.089004635810852,
0.3573884069919586,
0.017076905816793442,
-0.13103801012039185,
0.31725263595581055,
0.24370500445365906,
-0.29154443740844727,
1.2041343450546265,
0.7295726537704468,
-0.08849570155143738,
0.30799195170402527,
-0.3529583513736725,
0.28810226917266846,
-0.5028495788574219,
-0.4266243577003479,
-0.45488402247428894,
-0.33448776602745056,
-0.6481930017471313,
-0.5438610911369324,
0.18265822529792786,
-0.480161190032959,
-0.15748083591461182,
0.15976175665855408,
-0.5684595704078674,
0.1940157413482666,
0.13779769837856293,
0.4628194272518158,
-0.23716513812541962,
-0.19545623660087585,
0.3926902711391449,
-0.3583560287952423,
-0.7088592052459717,
-0.4091240167617798,
1.184859037399292,
0.5507377982139587,
0.5911568403244019,
0.06730552017688751,
0.9986035823822021,
0.3662199378013611,
0.7116159796714783,
-0.593190610408783,
0.5419114828109741,
-0.3497847020626068,
-0.6297041773796082,
-0.022527867928147316,
-0.5028796195983887,
-1.0634442567825317,
-0.010379782877862453,
-0.22535644471645355,
-0.9127163290977478,
0.28227829933166504,
-0.1992063820362091,
-0.29128599166870117,
0.24239793419837952,
-0.5448572635650635,
0.8925365805625916,
-0.1247931569814682,
0.0006410728092305362,
-0.11832553893327713,
-0.6846566796302795,
0.421305388212204,
-0.3326928913593292,
0.6850749850273132,
-0.19773994386196136,
-0.05286184698343277,
1.1150448322296143,
-0.05913841724395752,
0.8497424721717834,
-0.3625899851322174,
0.39229345321655273,
0.09727252274751663,
-0.34392282366752625,
0.05438098683953285,
-0.35306793451309204,
-0.006703929975628853,
-0.008989467285573483,
0.4074118137359619,
-0.34566348791122437,
-0.4405571222305298,
0.7433636784553528,
-0.913843035697937,
-0.16168823838233948,
-0.677726686000824,
-0.11097699403762817,
-0.16913481056690216,
0.19892549514770508,
0.35459333658218384,
0.336897075176239,
-0.03976638987660408,
0.34613192081451416,
0.440067857503891,
0.07825759798288345,
0.3266651928424835,
0.34345364570617676,
-0.22581957280635834,
-0.2569257915019989,
0.9797503352165222,
0.39997485280036926,
-0.11771345883607864,
0.1891435980796814,
-0.01890467293560505,
-0.04823114350438118,
-0.6996023654937744,
0.18219168484210968,
0.18337246775627136,
-0.8073711395263672,
-0.38143855333328247,
-0.742716908454895,
-0.5327283143997192,
-0.7792736291885376,
-0.05390410125255585,
-0.12340110540390015,
-0.13136856257915497,
-0.7911035418510437,
-0.5128241777420044,
0.11443539708852768,
1.1160550117492676,
-0.22548265755176544,
0.4922860264778137,
-0.946368396282196,
0.4478439688682556,
-0.1271531730890274,
0.33993566036224365,
0.02335263229906559,
-0.46604740619659424,
-0.486324280500412,
-0.06811749190092087,
-0.5971879959106445,
-1.0949574708938599,
0.6210139393806458,
0.1316414624452591,
0.5764042735099792,
0.5382497310638428,
0.21201109886169434,
0.695949137210846,
-0.268440842628479,
0.7421384453773499,
0.0670066550374031,
-0.7462313771247864,
0.4455375373363495,
-0.29854151606559753,
-0.10057128965854645,
0.5647546648979187,
0.8938949108123779,
-0.3546513020992279,
-0.11159384250640869,
-0.8857383131980896,
-0.6566811203956604,
0.9827855229377747,
0.2801092565059662,
-0.037820201367139816,
-0.05272235348820686,
0.4317362606525421,
-0.016712184995412827,
-0.08859420567750931,
-0.7561483383178711,
-0.07814639061689377,
-0.23642684519290924,
-0.6417648792266846,
-0.05906223878264427,
-0.5492918491363525,
0.22932638227939606,
-0.5944690704345703,
0.5195876359939575,
0.14465054869651794,
0.38297542929649353,
0.02991650439798832,
-0.042415812611579895,
-0.4113203287124634,
-0.11949184536933899,
0.13172221183776855,
0.4996865391731262,
-0.4885892868041992,
0.4279204308986664,
0.17891016602516174,
-0.46120068430900574,
0.15873925387859344,
0.2761959731578827,
0.08633144944906235,
0.0846802145242691,
0.4920409023761749,
0.7075161337852478,
0.42601075768470764,
-0.2086935192346573,
0.5414373874664307,
-0.29084789752960205,
-0.5579821467399597,
-0.25984758138656616,
0.09995586425065994,
0.08997570723295212,
0.06479261815547943,
0.4435597360134125,
0.08803100138902664,
0.6504269242286682,
-0.699610710144043,
0.28466710448265076,
-0.08812844008207321,
-0.48831707239151,
-0.7486386895179749,
0.5717281103134155,
0.19084037840366364,
-0.21322758495807648,
0.208823561668396,
-0.3326443135738373,
-0.8114420771598816,
0.5141228437423706,
0.5382857322692871,
0.6053351163864136,
-0.6406833529472351,
0.05808534100651741,
0.480750173330307,
0.5016934275627136,
-0.23979529738426208,
0.7036498785018921,
0.2780066430568695,
-0.8916265368461609,
-0.16348814964294434,
-0.42296674847602844,
-0.10234416276216507,
0.15646664798259735,
-0.6921877861022949,
0.3112999498844147,
-0.20531855523586273,
-0.5956633687019348,
0.13406816124916077,
-0.027473734691739082,
-0.639018177986145,
0.4808637499809265,
0.1707928627729416,
0.4465126395225525,
-0.9633864760398865,
0.8795758485794067,
0.8154063820838928,
0.05760890617966652,
-0.6829515695571899,
0.25897181034088135,
0.06163524091243744,
-0.27037513256073,
0.33188724517822266,
0.6013978719711304,
-0.001245024730451405,
0.11444828659296036,
-0.9016168117523193,
-0.9788718819618225,
0.9240694642066956,
-0.04930979385972023,
-0.25116562843322754,
-0.15150676667690277,
0.11670304834842682,
0.5301072001457214,
-0.5156136751174927,
-0.01460451539605856,
0.7549023628234863,
0.39686527848243713,
0.20786315202713013,
-0.8873280882835388,
0.18205146491527557,
-0.6384354829788208,
-0.02843587100505829,
-0.03314285725355148,
-0.24496722221374512,
0.6449169516563416,
-0.19597844779491425,
-0.40643733739852905,
-0.2080894559621811,
0.3872855007648468,
0.15177422761917114,
0.7365368604660034,
0.29529818892478943,
0.4137873947620392,
0.7025695443153381,
-0.15900848805904388,
0.992728054523468,
-0.3149658143520355,
0.3123099207878113,
0.6457720398902893,
-0.01903442107141018,
0.6803200840950012,
0.11747733503580093,
-0.264654278755188,
0.11927138268947601,
1.0589717626571655,
0.33732593059539795,
0.7209454774856567,
-0.08220887184143066,
-0.14580418169498444,
0.06427261978387833,
-0.09059840440750122,
-0.3387017846107483,
0.1004350334405899,
0.9478784203529358,
-0.2933305501937866,
0.11735592782497406,
0.3141399025917053,
-0.09370724111795425,
-0.25356319546699524,
-0.41720759868621826,
0.7312408685684204,
0.3982604742050171,
-0.1706516295671463,
0.47409361600875854,
0.36737117171287537,
0.8201141953468323,
-0.19852666556835175,
0.0016419464955106378,
0.16226686537265778,
0.2961714565753937,
-0.5406631827354431,
-0.8044138550758362,
0.7456079125404358,
-0.1787310242652893,
-0.08199947327375412,
-0.2716369926929474,
1.1139376163482666,
-0.5027129054069519,
-0.6764608025550842,
0.566372275352478,
0.054869282990694046,
0.3851170241832733,
-0.1364813894033432,
-0.6462960839271545,
0.233236625790596,
0.02750486135482788,
-0.03237595036625862,
0.17871537804603577,
0.7991712093353271,
-0.22061310708522797,
0.5903041362762451,
0.5073629021644592,
-0.09512697905302048,
0.14667923748493195,
0.1895027905702591,
0.8718075156211853,
-0.7976875901222229,
-0.3284730911254883,
-0.8080984950065613,
0.3197222650051117,
-0.004033506847918034,
0.16827616095542908,
0.701999306678772,
0.45744583010673523,
0.5476155877113342,
-0.008472433313727379,
0.8838493824005127,
-0.17773346602916718,
0.9104684591293335,
-0.005936183035373688,
0.6258271336555481,
-0.5445437431335449,
0.001282583107240498,
-0.24753768742084503,
-0.49920058250427246,
-0.3615083396434784,
0.5687301158905029,
-0.4001031517982483,
0.11191846430301666,
0.898685872554779,
0.5786364078521729,
0.0009442828013561666,
0.24057899415493011,
0.10074230283498764,
0.04620272293686867,
0.3691340982913971,
0.7349209785461426,
0.7458142042160034,
-0.545928955078125,
0.24523703753948212,
-0.43729686737060547,
-0.2517678439617157,
-0.32917749881744385,
-0.313294380903244,
-0.9674551486968994,
-0.6797847747802734,
-0.24285604059696198,
-0.44463440775871277,
0.3641495704650879,
0.9327465891838074,
0.6738330125808716,
-0.8048967719078064,
-0.05002693086862564,
0.14563441276550293,
0.03310271352529526,
-0.01329108327627182,
-0.25437021255493164,
0.2397780865430832,
-0.07723842561244965,
-0.43107497692108154,
0.094761922955513,
-0.05558329075574875,
0.25725001096725464,
0.2824387550354004,
-0.08059748262166977,
-0.12262760102748871,
-0.1797361671924591,
0.6382512450218201,
-0.2859767973423004,
-0.21209852397441864,
-0.20724627375602722,
-0.050671838223934174,
-0.15404297411441803,
0.014214430935680866,
0.41149815917015076,
-0.37041234970092773,
0.09901466965675354,
0.4305250644683838,
0.5077778100967407,
0.7382991909980774,
0.22080098092556,
0.36313596367836,
-0.5127477645874023,
-0.24790163338184357,
0.40373215079307556,
0.2140893042087555,
0.6572656035423279,
-0.44375598430633545,
0.6479573845863342,
0.3640469014644623,
-0.5560933351516724,
-0.9364016652107239,
-0.41765591502189636,
-1.0050021409988403,
-0.2504890561103821,
1.1772292852401733,
0.026545237749814987,
-0.4634455442428589,
-0.4948979318141937,
-0.18258072435855865,
0.3410591185092926,
-0.4058074653148651,
0.6638864874839783,
0.5830007195472717,
-0.12019772082567215,
-0.6575795412063599,
-0.6072266101837158,
0.7448843717575073,
-0.4076234698295593,
-0.9212533831596375,
-0.497036874294281,
0.15042860805988312,
0.41026338934898376,
-0.18582099676132202,
1.0459946393966675,
-0.15903080999851227,
0.2509465515613556,
-0.03789374977350235,
0.0705680325627327,
0.1454460471868515,
-0.23617036640644073,
-0.1586291790008545,
0.18165455758571625,
-0.15733182430267334,
-0.3173494338989258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19713v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19713v2
|
Automated Generation of High-Quality Medical Simulation Scenarios Through Integration of Semi-Structured Data and Large Language Models
| 2024-04-30T17:06:11 | 2024-05-06T17:58:48 |
Scott Sumpter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study introduces a transformative framework for medical education by
integrating semi-structured data with Large Language Models (LLMs), primarily
OpenAIs ChatGPT3.5, to automate the creation of medical simulation scenarios.
Traditionally, developing these scenarios was a time-intensive process with
limited flexibility to meet diverse educational needs. The proposed approach
utilizes AI to efficiently generate detailed, clinically relevant scenarios
that are tailored to specific educational objectives. This innovation has
significantly reduced the time and resources required for scenario development,
allowing for a broader variety of simulations. Preliminary feedback from
educators and learners has shown enhanced engagement and improved knowledge
acquisition, confirming the effectiveness of this AI-enhanced methodology in
simulation-based learning. The integration of structured data with LLMs not
only streamlines the creation process but also offers a scalable, dynamic
solution that could revolutionize medical training, highlighting the critical
role of AI in advancing educational outcomes and patient care standards.
|
[
-0.08980275690555573,
-1.0691465139389038,
0.8200522065162659,
-0.004063485190272331,
-0.10373345017433167,
0.2791964113712311,
-0.14816392958164215,
-0.24831622838974,
0.10523870587348938,
0.3111562728881836,
-0.42559829354286194,
-0.628384530544281,
-0.3053164482116699,
-0.0814262256026268,
-0.3010701537132263,
0.7021199464797974,
-0.37940555810928345,
0.37167179584503174,
-0.28924745321273804,
0.28718331456184387,
-0.2606520354747772,
-0.7722962498664856,
-0.7108469009399414,
-0.32712408900260925,
0.15504945814609528,
0.34207189083099365,
0.7055796384811401,
0.7859299778938293,
0.47559183835983276,
0.25703221559524536,
0.26912763714790344,
0.26175326108932495,
-0.38210123777389526,
0.03540029376745224,
-0.07123535871505737,
-0.08985293656587601,
-0.5759343504905701,
0.03531039133667946,
0.904827356338501,
1.006280541419983,
-0.6301372051239014,
0.055857911705970764,
-0.011637791059911251,
0.22078409790992737,
-0.22042754292488098,
0.37023067474365234,
-0.12614044547080994,
0.5010852813720703,
0.11469096690416336,
-0.4497348368167877,
-0.2297583520412445,
-0.289347767829895,
0.17125041782855988,
-0.6129056215286255,
0.03841617330908775,
-0.037893615663051605,
0.603844165802002,
0.1884225457906723,
-0.33379513025283813,
-0.20309659838676453,
-0.9326810240745544,
0.5371536612510681,
-0.6934356093406677,
0.2557728588581085,
-0.09764929115772247,
0.6794335246086121,
-0.478741317987442,
-1.0128992795944214,
-0.5789256691932678,
0.04449253901839256,
0.12467248737812042,
0.4946077764034271,
0.2286369949579239,
0.4202709496021271,
0.19446182250976562,
0.2961901128292084,
-0.5078538656234741,
0.3897348940372467,
-0.6733008623123169,
-0.0077193803153932095,
0.6682615280151367,
0.7797037363052368,
0.5198771357536316,
0.07970491051673889,
-0.3327633738517761,
0.020581403747200966,
-0.7134883403778076,
-0.036512333899736404,
0.051800891757011414,
0.3590468764305115,
-0.3648903965950012,
0.8182130455970764,
-0.042787786573171616,
0.5307916402816772,
-0.4820762872695923,
-0.4794331192970276,
0.25888118147850037,
-0.24254201352596283,
-0.5337554812431335,
0.2258061319589615,
0.8740562796592712,
0.4386296570301056,
0.16631892323493958,
0.07468535751104355,
-0.11075054109096527,
0.16624777019023895,
0.3423673212528229,
-0.8954079151153564,
-0.09179241955280304,
0.5128178000450134,
-0.5399981737136841,
-0.5426881909370422,
-0.13600799441337585,
-0.8769863843917847,
-0.16408148407936096,
-0.5539183020591736,
0.2533894181251526,
-0.4371045231819153,
0.03018289804458618,
0.44705677032470703,
0.18750342726707458,
0.06408251076936722,
0.5276389122009277,
-0.5127619504928589,
0.26842132210731506,
0.2949175536632538,
0.6938285827636719,
-0.3360047936439514,
-0.1440381407737732,
-0.2412801831960678,
0.5192941427230835,
-0.389832079410553,
0.4974972605705261,
-0.7014814615249634,
-0.8219677805900574,
0.31090787053108215,
-0.10687203705310822,
-0.05167054384946823,
-0.6820992827415466,
0.26748090982437134,
-0.12424823641777039,
0.36881664395332336,
0.6502172946929932,
-0.7697334289550781,
0.05061757192015648,
0.33674731850624084,
-0.40687498450279236,
0.8867920637130737,
0.2758471369743347,
-0.22804465889930725,
0.18721932172775269,
-0.8866554498672485,
-0.5931365489959717,
0.3850933313369751,
-0.7269350290298462,
-0.5471617579460144,
-0.15624107420444489,
0.18280228972434998,
0.607815146446228,
-0.5107600092887878,
0.7998071908950806,
-0.11262941360473633,
-0.3261510729789734,
0.14347955584526062,
-0.2237752377986908,
0.46847158670425415,
0.05146725848317146,
-0.13158608973026276,
0.0339239165186882,
-0.6763098835945129,
0.05777023732662201,
0.3599604070186615,
-0.5562524795532227,
0.01650945656001568,
0.10961233824491501,
0.09992276132106781,
0.4804341197013855,
-0.07817762345075607,
-0.46993616223335266,
0.41990697383880615,
-0.5284484624862671,
0.3141542077064514,
0.33811700344085693,
0.46484559774398804,
0.34689250588417053,
-0.48544952273368835,
0.7795196175575256,
0.3855646550655365,
0.43533289432525635,
-0.2524564564228058,
-0.4266202747821808,
-0.35579463839530945,
-0.2787034809589386,
0.22537554800510406,
0.6374785304069519,
-0.8016669750213623,
0.09749681502580643,
-0.21198034286499023,
-0.4336995780467987,
-0.6501436233520508,
-0.14739274978637695,
0.19562551379203796,
0.7983744740486145,
0.4582063853740692,
-0.18969106674194336,
-0.7304108738899231,
-0.7355140447616577,
0.24939163029193878,
-0.11418624967336655,
-0.04592537134885788,
0.39550039172172546,
0.6569703817367554,
-0.39512139558792114,
0.6423031091690063,
-0.41348281502723694,
-0.35881534218788147,
-0.36204713582992554,
-0.06215331330895424,
-0.005960794631391764,
0.7292088270187378,
0.5857295393943787,
-0.6347976922988892,
-0.27266907691955566,
-0.013797508552670479,
-1.0643534660339355,
0.2923383414745331,
-0.3388531506061554,
-0.08868035674095154,
-0.019946273416280746,
0.4750515818595886,
-0.20215854048728943,
0.6855741739273071,
0.4571816027164459,
-0.1021505743265152,
0.5015469193458557,
-0.5051305890083313,
0.4103161096572876,
-1.4402788877487183,
0.009522130712866783,
-0.15200354158878326,
0.037926848977804184,
-0.633737325668335,
-0.18615677952766418,
-0.029576679691672325,
-0.5075689554214478,
-0.5929136872291565,
0.7830728888511658,
-0.2555560767650604,
0.09696142375469208,
0.04486878588795662,
0.10263372957706451,
-0.18028369545936584,
0.2382645606994629,
0.27328556776046753,
0.8112581968307495,
0.7636871337890625,
-0.5184673070907593,
0.23110844194889069,
0.41774290800094604,
-0.33794599771499634,
0.4204729199409485,
-0.7706960439682007,
-0.4003290832042694,
0.09415299445390701,
0.4453050494194031,
-0.34318411350250244,
-0.7394351959228516,
0.1478452980518341,
-0.29483091831207275,
0.21692800521850586,
-0.2315245419740677,
-0.7596110105514526,
-0.32135942578315735,
-0.000943140359595418,
0.43534284830093384,
0.8919461369514465,
-0.33488351106643677,
0.6409283876419067,
0.6053127646446228,
-0.2636726498603821,
-0.2146952748298645,
-0.4765928089618683,
0.15373948216438293,
-0.04873279482126236,
-0.34754499793052673,
0.3408433198928833,
-0.09285993874073029,
-0.18031428754329681,
-0.1716790795326233,
0.17176611721515656,
-0.01745021343231201,
0.09762648493051529,
0.4455428719520569,
0.8251172304153442,
-0.1922958791255951,
0.03129759803414345,
0.6574115753173828,
0.15278083086013794,
0.1961212307214737,
-0.5492469072341919,
0.4202125370502472,
0.3924679458141327,
-0.6498647332191467,
-0.6575511693954468,
0.6112588047981262,
0.7159653902053833,
-0.1360270380973816,
0.9210970997810364,
0.07570216059684753,
-0.6725883483886719,
-0.2884468138217926,
-0.23225751519203186,
-0.22055350244045258,
-0.4157389998435974,
0.4164055585861206,
0.12122499197721481,
-0.8322397470474243,
0.3924666941165924,
-0.44171884655952454,
0.34328493475914,
0.15444216132164001,
0.9729500412940979,
-0.5150598883628845,
1.2739657163619995,
0.34717175364494324,
0.413752019405365,
0.14867980778217316,
-0.18916180729866028,
0.15606799721717834,
-0.6820985078811646,
-0.7376576066017151,
-0.22506414353847504,
-0.25413620471954346,
-0.33604878187179565,
-0.8684091567993164,
0.9067535400390625,
-0.35935017466545105,
-0.3523457646369934,
-0.5678895115852356,
-0.37526410818099976,
0.29966360330581665,
0.28062811493873596,
0.19845658540725708,
0.11617373675107956,
0.06573057919740677,
-0.29507508873939514,
0.1356690526008606,
-0.8904921412467957,
-0.6185781955718994,
1.2733708620071411,
0.3113865554332733,
0.7725483775138855,
-0.158600315451622,
0.7864201664924622,
0.22944408655166626,
0.38493648171424866,
-0.6209418773651123,
0.5443369746208191,
0.053598467260599136,
-0.5376641750335693,
-0.0731956958770752,
-0.32307833433151245,
-0.8996813893318176,
-0.2752545177936554,
-0.5024513602256775,
-0.4028540849685669,
-0.23669053614139557,
0.10790754109621048,
-0.5515153408050537,
0.43183091282844543,
-0.4739042818546295,
0.687364935874939,
-0.06811045855283737,
-0.3314220607280731,
-0.009386580437421799,
-0.8702792525291443,
0.1555899977684021,
-0.3536715507507324,
0.3267863988876343,
0.012957234866917133,
-0.17632338404655457,
0.7044093012809753,
-0.4307257831096649,
0.9975825548171997,
-0.1623915135860443,
-0.008972225710749626,
0.320573627948761,
0.05602685362100601,
0.1577356457710266,
0.32894259691238403,
0.02620951272547245,
0.13868418335914612,
-0.09353356808423996,
-0.45796674489974976,
-0.5385407209396362,
0.48355311155319214,
-0.7622600197792053,
-0.17212915420532227,
-0.2865503430366516,
-0.8638900518417358,
-0.47103098034858704,
0.05908019840717316,
-0.021720867604017258,
0.5831952095031738,
-0.389316201210022,
-0.18559692800045013,
0.7284152507781982,
-0.6109021902084351,
0.05940258502960205,
0.5221052765846252,
-0.2591783404350281,
-0.33074939250946045,
0.7514630556106567,
0.0680355355143547,
0.26819542050361633,
0.0772247314453125,
0.09449108690023422,
-0.09191163629293442,
-0.7423317432403564,
-0.753167450428009,
0.19756852090358734,
-0.5171836018562317,
-0.17902350425720215,
-0.5545943975448608,
-0.7196718454360962,
-0.3794371783733368,
-0.48465871810913086,
-0.23484039306640625,
-0.12311900407075882,
-0.18042193353176117,
-0.016832558438181877,
-0.0162564255297184,
0.8137577772140503,
0.29085251688957214,
0.3441893756389618,
-1.0515292882919312,
0.1759498119354248,
-0.11914417147636414,
0.29539725184440613,
-0.37427398562431335,
-0.5191148519515991,
-0.2542066276073456,
-0.054699741303920746,
-0.05295586958527565,
-0.7307755947113037,
0.2887974977493286,
0.10889828950166702,
0.5810730457305908,
0.2881036400794983,
-0.1337154358625412,
0.6075993776321411,
-0.7827134728431702,
0.8367381691932678,
0.2976560592651367,
-0.4125027358531952,
0.8722705245018005,
-0.36148494482040405,
0.0780583992600441,
0.3555806577205658,
0.4231877326965332,
-0.18832939863204956,
-0.515404462814331,
-0.7202575206756592,
-0.85036700963974,
0.6061139702796936,
0.12162400037050247,
0.13979771733283997,
-0.11095725744962692,
0.45974141359329224,
0.26172181963920593,
0.13692063093185425,
-0.1512938141822815,
-0.2383365035057068,
0.25501203536987305,
-0.7086916565895081,
-0.08419648557901382,
-0.09091483801603317,
-0.4348033666610718,
-0.3695465624332428,
0.7752377986907959,
-0.08484923839569092,
0.23889891803264618,
0.01975242979824543,
0.1718354970216751,
-0.0010137187782675028,
0.15948963165283203,
0.5201473832130432,
0.3216039538383484,
0.10020734369754791,
-0.29525166749954224,
0.1917819082736969,
-0.8447220325469971,
0.19788247346878052,
0.21907788515090942,
0.035123150795698166,
-0.09468258917331696,
0.2750318944454193,
0.6717532277107239,
0.20561514794826508,
-1.212246298789978,
0.40807661414146423,
-0.1669953465461731,
-0.40717971324920654,
-0.4485035240650177,
0.2586727440357208,
-0.0064743803814053535,
0.39267095923423767,
0.02173972874879837,
-0.16640400886535645,
0.16115985810756683,
-0.4113733172416687,
0.25529611110687256,
0.09112758934497833,
0.00696176290512085,
-0.1297786980867386,
0.7632693648338318,
0.14182163774967194,
-0.10790105164051056,
0.6959812641143799,
0.2540481686592102,
-0.06911519169807434,
0.7433866262435913,
0.7839791774749756,
0.2094264030456543,
-0.3982604146003723,
0.15122435986995697,
0.6290995478630066,
-0.016719145700335503,
-0.24980251491069794,
0.5996279716491699,
0.24186094105243683,
-0.35651448369026184,
-0.40079158544540405,
-0.8135712146759033,
-0.6490792632102966,
-0.005285695195198059,
-0.5854575634002686,
0.5770595073699951,
-0.534600555896759,
0.024462342262268066,
-0.0901608020067215,
-0.366749107837677,
-0.5753312110900879,
0.5682498216629028,
0.24363216757774353,
1.035406231880188,
-0.9077196717262268,
0.9453544020652771,
1.1287171840667725,
-0.4209340214729309,
-1.1662284135818481,
-0.08702801167964935,
0.008521538227796555,
-0.8894369602203369,
0.25046104192733765,
-0.15317140519618988,
0.13134139776229858,
0.05757436901330948,
-0.38828808069229126,
-0.2632791996002197,
1.1163649559020996,
0.2511799931526184,
-0.5691394805908203,
-0.5201433897018433,
0.42562973499298096,
0.664483368396759,
-0.5436313152313232,
0.18485011160373688,
0.5662025213241577,
0.1020856648683548,
0.25565141439437866,
-0.8113428354263306,
-0.24556639790534973,
-0.29968100786209106,
-0.13636313378810883,
0.2931339144706726,
-0.12515629827976227,
0.5040926933288574,
-0.44830629229545593,
-0.11781655251979828,
-0.13547764718532562,
0.5058764219284058,
0.29436203837394714,
0.43937811255455017,
0.06341409683227539,
0.49028968811035156,
0.6077132821083069,
-0.17922353744506836,
1.008020281791687,
-0.4690798223018646,
0.30242493748664856,
0.9756859540939331,
-0.3832533657550812,
0.5066871047019958,
0.5198484659194946,
-0.14834357798099518,
0.35612577199935913,
0.6691364049911499,
-0.033190712332725525,
0.08913261443376541,
0.1103254184126854,
-0.48609673976898193,
-0.303773432970047,
-0.10587386786937714,
-0.5170912146568298,
0.4722711741924286,
0.668982744216919,
-0.5413753986358643,
-0.21756233274936676,
0.4091290831565857,
0.025744644924998283,
0.12944786250591278,
-0.2698908746242523,
0.7978535890579224,
-0.03346684202551842,
-0.5838924050331116,
0.19203904271125793,
-0.11177629977464676,
0.016626227647066116,
-0.6465287804603577,
-0.3084411025047302,
-0.18241658806800842,
0.010257239453494549,
-0.21784353256225586,
-1.0190571546554565,
0.1684567779302597,
0.1074562519788742,
0.14430686831474304,
-0.1621442586183548,
0.31226637959480286,
-0.6042730808258057,
-0.6343531012535095,
-0.04420233517885208,
0.780493438243866,
0.2986566722393036,
0.599697470664978,
-0.5808227062225342,
0.11911632120609283,
-0.20668986439704895,
-0.08672212809324265,
0.5192397832870483,
0.4787575304508209,
-0.1595854014158249,
0.5489792227745056,
0.6416822075843811,
0.3143934905529022,
-0.16467715799808502,
0.14783476293087006,
0.9703325033187866,
-0.2651890218257904,
-0.5259066224098206,
-0.6932048201560974,
0.6033121347427368,
-0.07217628508806229,
-0.09423097968101501,
0.19254709780216217,
0.9066533446311951,
0.6435441970825195,
-0.0545753613114357,
0.9846405386924744,
-0.042362671345472336,
0.384540855884552,
-0.5514392256736755,
0.8482899069786072,
-0.6826680898666382,
0.2782963216304779,
-0.06806545704603195,
-0.3999808728694916,
-0.5224753618240356,
0.2732251286506653,
-0.11264855414628983,
0.10812567174434662,
0.579574704170227,
0.42398232221603394,
-0.2522364854812622,
-0.07247967272996902,
0.4422202706336975,
0.005919354502111673,
0.4809192419052124,
0.6221546530723572,
0.732254683971405,
-0.18802247941493988,
0.13440576195716858,
-0.16626717150211334,
-0.43805962800979614,
-0.14802667498588562,
-0.49417364597320557,
-1.119766354560852,
-0.5789263844490051,
-0.3504874110221863,
-0.27374014258384705,
0.18078970909118652,
1.2424311637878418,
0.5725312232971191,
-0.6082969903945923,
-0.14987210929393768,
0.2077132612466812,
-0.5135249495506287,
0.10183481127023697,
-0.1865437775850296,
0.41509002447128296,
-0.2330240160226822,
-0.9136970043182373,
0.5375920534133911,
0.5874693989753723,
0.4995170831680298,
-0.22127264738082886,
-0.1623319685459137,
0.05506165698170662,
0.33718058466911316,
0.5236364603042603,
0.1855296492576599,
-0.33314278721809387,
-0.1112862080335617,
-0.06316269189119339,
-0.3688238263130188,
0.11456426233053207,
0.8361228108406067,
-0.990984320640564,
0.5282205939292908,
-0.05973971635103226,
0.8255563974380493,
0.14036652445793152,
-0.01628991588950157,
0.6688164472579956,
-0.4174318313598633,
0.14599333703517914,
0.5204293131828308,
0.3238487243652344,
-0.06700132042169571,
-0.3548033833503723,
0.456817626953125,
0.2024834156036377,
-0.38145729899406433,
-1.0670149326324463,
0.07059267163276672,
-0.9581218361854553,
-0.14361418783664703,
0.9604157209396362,
-0.10077475011348724,
0.004149120766669512,
-0.11396600306034088,
-0.2818027138710022,
0.5250637531280518,
-0.00601909589022398,
0.9020696878433228,
0.31278371810913086,
-0.4644939601421356,
0.33038586378097534,
-1.1241832971572876,
0.38167059421539307,
0.15401175618171692,
-1.4722788333892822,
-0.36684945225715637,
0.6275825500488281,
0.2971751391887665,
-0.4026895761489868,
0.45551788806915283,
-0.5200185179710388,
0.41529494524002075,
-0.13661116361618042,
0.1670883744955063,
-0.232477605342865,
-0.5773623585700989,
-0.09041258692741394,
0.27278807759284973,
-0.2772388160228729,
-0.032262738794088364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19708v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19708v1
|
Harmonic LLMs are Trustworthy
| 2024-04-30T17:00:32 | 2024-04-30T17:00:32 |
Nicholas S. Kersting, Mohammad Rahman, Suchismitha Vedala, Yang Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
We introduce an intuitive method to test the robustness (stability and
explainability) of any black-box LLM in real-time, based upon the local
deviation from harmoniticity, denoted as $\gamma$. To the best of our knowledge
this is the first completely model-agnostic and unsupervised method of
measuring the robustness of any given response from an LLM, based upon the
model itself conforming to a purely mathematical standard. We conduct human
annotation experiments to show the positive correlation of $\gamma$ with false
or misleading answers, and demonstrate that following the gradient of $\gamma$
in stochastic gradient ascent efficiently exposes adversarial prompts.
Measuring $\gamma$ across thousands of queries in popular LLMs (GPT-4, ChatGPT,
Claude-2.1, Mixtral-8x7B, Smaug-72B, Llama2-7B, and MPT-7B) allows us to
estimate the liklihood of wrong or hallucinatory answers automatically and
quantitatively rank the reliability of these models in various objective
domains (Web QA, TruthfulQA, and Programming QA). Across all models and domains
tested, human ratings confirm that $\gamma \to 0$ indicates trustworthiness,
and the low-$\gamma$ leaders among these models are GPT-4, ChatGPT, and
Smaug-72B.
|
[
-0.6996312141418457,
-1.1598106622695923,
0.4150005280971527,
0.029260389506816864,
-0.27352792024612427,
0.13092750310897827,
-0.06797704100608826,
-0.6127189993858337,
-0.02083403430879116,
0.007204023655503988,
-0.6539687514305115,
-0.3924793303012848,
-0.44179075956344604,
0.11257126182317734,
-0.36405718326568604,
1.0098953247070312,
0.2432800829410553,
0.421609491109848,
-0.1820114254951477,
-0.28096169233322144,
-0.3081238567829132,
-0.5193727612495422,
-0.6682150363922119,
-0.4938660264015198,
0.36478233337402344,
-0.1943334937095642,
1.1675735712051392,
0.44416144490242004,
0.6786987781524658,
0.148996502161026,
-0.12327772378921509,
0.08142660558223724,
-0.544054388999939,
0.22494235634803772,
-0.16128063201904297,
-0.8970525860786438,
-0.7963506579399109,
0.3035423457622528,
0.13369810581207275,
0.398155152797699,
-0.4415386915206909,
0.5322210788726807,
0.30254361033439636,
0.36589622497558594,
-0.29739245772361755,
0.06593459844589233,
-0.7639039158821106,
0.15459544956684113,
-0.36327582597732544,
-0.35181713104248047,
-0.3473535478115082,
-0.5763629078865051,
0.022035052999854088,
-0.7057422995567322,
0.0005669497768394649,
0.29241040349006653,
0.9842919111251831,
0.5010271668434143,
-0.38839662075042725,
-0.17416532337665558,
-0.8779719471931458,
0.9668961763381958,
-0.7377930879592896,
0.37226444482803345,
0.6922665238380432,
0.7398123145103455,
-0.2396063506603241,
-0.7327457666397095,
-0.5065779685974121,
-0.5054730176925659,
0.25027579069137573,
0.4356660544872284,
-0.12964823842048645,
0.06217722222208977,
0.30790209770202637,
0.6058498620986938,
-0.3749820590019226,
0.01370012853294611,
-0.028026845306158066,
-0.4880291819572449,
0.5519086122512817,
0.3387610614299774,
0.35449156165122986,
-0.16568613052368164,
-0.49067923426628113,
0.13813146948814392,
-0.6455018520355225,
0.22815410792827606,
0.3580286204814911,
-0.07086826115846634,
-0.09362922608852386,
0.6055177450180054,
0.44602611660957336,
0.434691458940506,
0.40913501381874084,
-0.2364616096019745,
-0.36543986201286316,
-0.6849454641342163,
-0.35663866996765137,
-0.41131702065467834,
0.6851282715797424,
0.2693668603897095,
0.4322705566883087,
-0.24828621745109558,
-0.26263228058815,
0.36119142174720764,
0.5187350511550903,
-0.6194648742675781,
-0.17115159332752228,
0.18493327498435974,
-0.516768217086792,
-0.710602879524231,
0.08292990922927856,
-0.6008635759353638,
-0.3852873146533966,
-0.16934026777744293,
0.490134060382843,
-0.5288386344909668,
-0.02874661795794964,
-0.10810735076665878,
0.29910004138946533,
0.5862191319465637,
0.4415317177772522,
-0.7867250442504883,
0.42922359704971313,
0.9583494067192078,
0.5980914831161499,
-0.15078020095825195,
-0.11900448054075241,
-0.415304958820343,
-0.3876943290233612,
-0.5511709451675415,
0.5336195230484009,
-0.07097115367650986,
-0.3944091796875,
-0.18959173560142517,
-0.05558637157082558,
0.29991212487220764,
-0.40500345826148987,
0.8303853869438171,
-0.7809664607048035,
0.34597229957580566,
-0.219155952334404,
-0.6541422605514526,
-0.3628367781639099,
0.5015966892242432,
-0.33588865399360657,
1.154543399810791,
0.09906477481126785,
-0.8714612126350403,
0.31233951449394226,
-0.21189570426940918,
0.10930123925209045,
-0.12035565823316574,
-0.06952524185180664,
-0.4538663923740387,
0.09016643464565277,
0.1069684773683548,
0.19667162001132965,
-0.5355297923088074,
0.2690490782260895,
-0.8212367296218872,
-0.47388163208961487,
0.672691822052002,
-0.982378363609314,
1.2110339403152466,
0.18559087812900543,
-0.41522276401519775,
0.025719651952385902,
-0.6270342469215393,
0.13553065061569214,
0.035327713936567307,
-0.2044621706008911,
-0.11051888018846512,
-0.19536957144737244,
-0.24947042763233185,
0.10982607305049896,
0.2497696429491043,
-0.3556758165359497,
-0.15848255157470703,
-0.28902721405029297,
0.12536443769931793,
1.110665202140808,
0.15279315412044525,
0.13997280597686768,
-0.8775216341018677,
0.8678506016731262,
-0.051616545766592026,
0.3894610106945038,
0.11135731637477875,
-0.7170411944389343,
-0.500184178352356,
-0.31117865443229675,
0.3269588053226471,
0.6710652709007263,
-0.3942568004131317,
0.6958107352256775,
-0.16724365949630737,
-0.6286490559577942,
-0.5342525243759155,
0.17175433039665222,
0.28963273763656616,
0.7904308438301086,
0.17875853180885315,
-0.49959346652030945,
-0.028015458956360817,
-0.8242697715759277,
-0.2827013432979584,
-0.16079306602478027,
-0.2704671323299408,
0.5251054167747498,
0.29699504375457764,
-0.3902474045753479,
0.6638796925544739,
-0.20970898866653442,
-0.01499535795301199,
0.28842830657958984,
0.07833301275968552,
0.23308438062667847,
0.03145495429635048,
0.6243578791618347,
-0.41447222232818604,
-0.41157767176628113,
-0.18670225143432617,
-1.1506409645080566,
-0.044534411281347275,
0.13684411346912384,
-0.20169565081596375,
0.10655881464481354,
0.01264477800577879,
-0.6090684533119202,
0.3875666558742523,
0.5012863874435425,
-0.2785317301750183,
0.6629673838615417,
-0.16812439262866974,
0.29328352212905884,
-1.1378369331359863,
0.0041944473050534725,
0.18544700741767883,
-0.6137741804122925,
-0.3814248740673065,
0.23371754586696625,
0.04099976643919945,
0.14566291868686676,
-0.36990243196487427,
0.4656297266483307,
-0.20839646458625793,
-0.2806541621685028,
0.004504714626818895,
0.27455005049705505,
-0.2638006806373596,
0.43892383575439453,
-0.8508992791175842,
0.9071540832519531,
0.7684084177017212,
-0.6088359355926514,
0.8185014724731445,
0.23251527547836304,
-0.12920379638671875,
1.0634050369262695,
-0.7695946097373962,
0.1782592087984085,
0.0040507386438548565,
0.12496993690729141,
-1.1023433208465576,
-0.1700282096862793,
0.225261390209198,
-0.7671827673912048,
0.1631290316581726,
0.002353495918214321,
-0.41145265102386475,
-0.2897602617740631,
-0.6615137457847595,
0.42859187722206116,
0.8520376682281494,
-0.5618674159049988,
0.6328139901161194,
0.36805152893066406,
0.10780204087495804,
-0.6495465636253357,
-0.6450066566467285,
-0.06924959272146225,
-0.2971687912940979,
-0.9183972477912903,
-0.22437240183353424,
-0.3297862708568573,
-0.7001452445983887,
-0.20785431563854218,
-0.45494478940963745,
-0.2981061339378357,
0.6536794304847717,
0.4358197748661041,
0.6789911389350891,
-0.2740195691585541,
-0.32960712909698486,
-0.40785104036331177,
-0.26459360122680664,
0.3670542538166046,
-0.20937275886535645,
0.2182157188653946,
-0.4071381986141205,
-0.6576460599899292,
-0.7332673072814941,
-0.3591994047164917,
0.7574283480644226,
-0.0377381406724453,
0.29491186141967773,
0.6560677886009216,
-0.5794750452041626,
-0.3062196671962738,
-0.2889307141304016,
-0.4590895175933838,
-0.5142560005187988,
-0.02518349699676037,
-0.17102624475955963,
-0.6082937121391296,
0.9609099626541138,
0.20826490223407745,
0.1173720434308052,
0.21735194325447083,
0.6577781438827515,
-0.15264490246772766,
0.95943683385849,
0.24582351744174957,
-0.05652470886707306,
0.1476835161447525,
0.09818781912326813,
0.24548763036727905,
-0.6604733467102051,
-0.04677969589829445,
-0.4736779034137726,
-0.17239534854888916,
-0.7349495887756348,
-0.38570231199264526,
0.5056138038635254,
0.1259295493364334,
-0.16697660088539124,
0.02797296643257141,
-0.381947785615921,
0.18260858952999115,
0.5305681824684143,
0.23901645839214325,
0.38345852494239807,
-0.15601083636283875,
-0.0858670175075531,
-0.334221750497818,
-0.25415101647377014,
-0.6322217583656311,
1.3883949518203735,
0.5953653454780579,
1.1447073221206665,
0.2167312055826187,
0.3600892722606659,
0.37164705991744995,
0.5903039574623108,
-0.855253279209137,
0.5790437459945679,
0.37271562218666077,
-0.746470034122467,
-0.4581688642501831,
-0.3723796010017395,
-0.8289995789527893,
0.18825817108154297,
-0.2673167884349823,
-0.48306500911712646,
-0.2794041633605957,
0.11662934720516205,
-0.5105388164520264,
0.25396624207496643,
0.054776523262262344,
0.3441172242164612,
-0.44499093294143677,
-0.4423708915710449,
-0.15118606388568878,
-0.6769552826881409,
0.659787654876709,
-0.4088015854358673,
0.28667938709259033,
-0.1846107542514801,
0.0319095179438591,
0.49892657995224,
-0.36093559861183167,
0.6864643096923828,
0.049806445837020874,
-0.4554029405117035,
0.27153077721595764,
0.631935179233551,
0.5929340720176697,
0.34539249539375305,
-0.0886990949511528,
0.42405346035957336,
-0.07164496183395386,
-0.35220399498939514,
-0.8212106823921204,
0.6071768403053284,
-0.7930462956428528,
-0.6481660008430481,
-0.5422896146774292,
-0.37170228362083435,
-0.3812401592731476,
0.37396588921546936,
0.2819049656391144,
0.46485015749931335,
-0.2489912509918213,
0.28068807721138,
0.8762680292129517,
0.08642818033695221,
0.11923451721668243,
0.341329425573349,
-0.3366287350654602,
-0.5740628838539124,
0.4988122880458832,
-0.011374111287295818,
0.3636952042579651,
0.09476067870855331,
0.18655653297901154,
-0.30075016617774963,
-0.6263906359672546,
-0.2553163468837738,
0.11801964789628983,
-0.6448472738265991,
-0.1152704656124115,
-0.034470073878765106,
-0.29489749670028687,
0.08645380288362503,
-0.1946345716714859,
-0.38822880387306213,
-0.4679640233516693,
-0.25571516156196594,
-0.41270047426223755,
0.06478485465049744,
0.7793871760368347,
0.0500679649412632,
-0.24898310005664825,
-0.6432202458381653,
0.5033639073371887,
0.6122344136238098,
0.25870442390441895,
-0.10754675418138504,
-0.8485144972801208,
0.017082257196307182,
0.3916938900947571,
-0.4823931157588959,
-0.8452727198600769,
0.14009025692939758,
-0.02072668820619583,
0.7522974014282227,
0.5829432606697083,
0.12047117948532104,
0.5578122735023499,
-0.1668042242527008,
1.0795904397964478,
-0.04389578104019165,
-1.0083810091018677,
0.27165332436561584,
-0.712875247001648,
-0.3950860798358917,
0.43064624071121216,
0.2694269120693207,
-0.1390560269355774,
-0.7458896040916443,
-0.6940938830375671,
-0.46431997418403625,
0.376443475484848,
0.2481667548418045,
0.038886841386556625,
0.20432531833648682,
0.7082805633544922,
0.10590106248855591,
0.1739785522222519,
-0.8858253955841064,
-0.6631399989128113,
-0.3456431031227112,
-0.19912758469581604,
0.07534576207399368,
-0.3097604215145111,
-0.5979509353637695,
0.015540950931608677,
0.5208348035812378,
-0.2024109810590744,
0.15949563682079315,
0.02970755472779274,
0.07697436958551407,
-0.5010852217674255,
0.11498026549816132,
0.6229910850524902,
0.8743210434913635,
-0.45590952038764954,
0.4317842423915863,
0.4380475580692291,
-0.40242472290992737,
0.3891617953777313,
-0.17602834105491638,
-0.2606273293495178,
-0.24002981185913086,
0.429129421710968,
0.2700246274471283,
0.3301244080066681,
-0.22085076570510864,
0.717896044254303,
-0.3775100111961365,
-0.16333884000778198,
-0.4051409363746643,
0.13278844952583313,
-0.02662069909274578,
0.07156176120042801,
0.2620854675769806,
0.2934189438819885,
-0.0814317837357521,
-0.5531018376350403,
0.46838974952697754,
0.9565032124519348,
-0.5265148282051086,
-0.6835373640060425,
1.2643259763717651,
0.007449645549058914,
-0.4001160264015198,
0.3553977310657501,
-0.06397806853055954,
-0.3089587688446045,
0.4235092103481293,
0.39017635583877563,
0.9060842990875244,
-0.17913919687271118,
0.16988791525363922,
0.17684854567050934,
0.3867114782333374,
-0.16665604710578918,
0.21139578521251678,
0.06379938870668411,
-0.6435908079147339,
0.17018085718154907,
-0.4914396107196808,
-0.6936641335487366,
-0.23733709752559662,
-1.152353048324585,
0.06805552542209625,
-0.748245120048523,
-0.6108973622322083,
-0.15696564316749573,
0.1965952217578888,
-0.41182973980903625,
0.08568178117275238,
-0.058379314839839935,
0.9576530456542969,
-0.49239620566368103,
0.6450467705726624,
0.4816921651363373,
-0.22414253652095795,
-0.7637708187103271,
0.2497263252735138,
0.32364773750305176,
-1.2899644374847412,
0.375853955745697,
-0.2931646406650543,
-0.33972516655921936,
-0.13614003360271454,
-0.6965333223342896,
-0.705679178237915,
1.595611810684204,
0.5603443384170532,
-0.25697410106658936,
0.16619206964969635,
-0.2230219691991806,
0.7573304176330566,
0.196053609251976,
0.2793789207935333,
0.24783959984779358,
0.5165177583694458,
0.03430629521608353,
-1.1562507152557373,
0.20270182192325592,
0.08087389916181564,
0.07792439311742783,
-0.1272132694721222,
-0.7711569666862488,
0.8015227317810059,
-0.1910092830657959,
-0.46945786476135254,
0.2730507254600525,
0.5075094699859619,
0.5096985101699829,
0.26695314049720764,
0.293027400970459,
0.5550541281700134,
1.2955125570297241,
-0.15810942649841309,
1.236685037612915,
-0.8878752589225769,
0.6433226466178894,
0.7210606336593628,
-0.1712283492088318,
0.5141423344612122,
0.2463105022907257,
-0.35927024483680725,
0.08630342781543732,
0.8038173317909241,
-0.1326388418674469,
0.4045042097568512,
0.22098295390605927,
-0.16759279370307922,
-0.45499950647354126,
0.1451328843832016,
-0.2883673906326294,
0.10595111548900604,
0.06700251251459122,
0.011368868872523308,
-0.20015603303909302,
-0.40045222640037537,
0.3596893846988678,
-0.05282212421298027,
-0.207790344953537,
0.4745296239852905,
0.5569981932640076,
-0.6006814241409302,
0.8003425002098083,
-0.027627723291516304,
0.7631014585494995,
-0.6311452388763428,
0.3294250965118408,
-0.45250317454338074,
0.27366575598716736,
-0.24831774830818176,
-0.6831708550453186,
0.08475803583860397,
-0.1957954466342926,
0.18373854458332062,
0.050688307732343674,
0.6739389300346375,
-0.02674081176519394,
-0.3344574570655823,
0.38346388936042786,
0.6280277967453003,
-0.15416212379932404,
0.4278295338153839,
-0.6967152953147888,
-0.31183940172195435,
-0.0771624743938446,
-0.34904953837394714,
0.29273855686187744,
0.43362805247306824,
0.12936808168888092,
1.2559150457382202,
0.7930578589439392,
0.2615242004394531,
0.23284156620502472,
-0.37866878509521484,
0.4919557571411133,
-0.5721176862716675,
-0.3823971748352051,
-0.9772192239761353,
0.21057195961475372,
0.2932364046573639,
-0.14615724980831146,
1.4507999420166016,
0.2363530993461609,
0.47017374634742737,
0.24117746949195862,
0.7520545125007629,
0.6939567923545837,
0.20912355184555054,
-0.47126707434654236,
0.7173041105270386,
-0.3846825063228607,
0.5301650166511536,
-0.033536478877067566,
-0.9704760313034058,
-0.4601846933364868,
0.6711311340332031,
0.13425213098526,
0.1161150261759758,
0.6251647472381592,
0.8185915350914001,
-0.12889336049556732,
0.10544002801179886,
0.47463491559028625,
0.41269636154174805,
0.5755720734596252,
0.322024941444397,
0.9600123167037964,
-0.3119167387485504,
0.41332659125328064,
-0.07425638288259506,
-0.37822362780570984,
-0.18115320801734924,
-0.7222779393196106,
-0.9926438927650452,
0.03222738206386566,
-0.2415940761566162,
-0.8890208601951599,
-0.14373984932899475,
0.7260384559631348,
0.6868631839752197,
-0.76284259557724,
-0.02159801684319973,
-0.09511590003967285,
0.27400222420692444,
-0.29732832312583923,
-0.2279806286096573,
0.07523680478334427,
-0.18414951860904694,
-0.40470439195632935,
0.19323799014091492,
0.32461047172546387,
0.4223305583000183,
-0.6404716372489929,
-0.14127449691295624,
0.5276623964309692,
0.6611933708190918,
0.15850752592086792,
0.13357941806316376,
-0.8644912242889404,
-0.5553634166717529,
0.2519158124923706,
-0.4311964809894562,
0.10782389342784882,
0.45904698967933655,
-0.26615187525749207,
0.292255699634552,
0.3865954875946045,
0.5551264882087708,
0.1023450419306755,
0.4216260313987732,
0.6638010144233704,
-0.3355502784252167,
-0.08705537766218185,
0.35163962841033936,
0.4717654883861542,
0.19748882949352264,
-0.31375864148139954,
0.5030664205551147,
0.3397497236728668,
-0.9958354234695435,
-0.9584540724754333,
0.3103792667388916,
-1.098290205001831,
0.2279830425977707,
1.0253716707229614,
-0.31750157475471497,
-0.2417534440755844,
-0.2064160704612732,
-0.041706424206495285,
-0.1164635717868805,
-0.16100537776947021,
1.2160197496414185,
0.8445091843605042,
-0.2895071506500244,
0.1367608904838562,
-0.6414525508880615,
0.7248773574829102,
0.34501272439956665,
-0.7437043190002441,
0.03382473066449165,
0.46415847539901733,
0.5387520790100098,
0.306938499212265,
0.7054961919784546,
-0.37529808282852173,
0.43883568048477173,
0.06675363332033157,
-0.4495413601398468,
-0.28164735436439514,
-0.040143392980098724,
-0.5556707382202148,
0.2666320502758026,
0.44627442955970764,
-0.19755224883556366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19705v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19705v2
|
When to Retrieve: Teaching LLMs to Utilize Information Retrieval Effectively
| 2024-04-30T16:52:55 | 2024-05-06T19:08:10 |
Tiziano Labruna, Jon Ander Campos, Gorka Azkune
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
In this paper, we demonstrate how Large Language Models (LLMs) can
effectively learn to use an off-the-shelf information retrieval (IR) system
specifically when additional context is required to answer a given question.
Given the performance of IR systems, the optimal strategy for question
answering does not always entail external information retrieval; rather, it
often involves leveraging the parametric memory of the LLM itself. Prior
research has identified this phenomenon in the PopQA dataset, wherein the most
popular questions are effectively addressed using the LLM's parametric memory,
while less popular ones require IR system usage. Following this, we propose a
tailored training approach for LLMs, leveraging existing open-domain question
answering datasets. Here, LLMs are trained to generate a special token, <RET>,
when they do not know the answer to a question. Our evaluation of the Adaptive
Retrieval LLM (Adapt-LLM) on the PopQA dataset showcases improvements over the
same LLM under three configurations: (i) retrieving information for all the
questions, (ii) using always the parametric memory of the LLM, and (iii) using
a popularity threshold to decide when to use a retriever. Through our analysis,
we demonstrate that Adapt-LLM is able to generate the <RET> token when it
determines that it does not know how to answer a question, indicating the need
for IR, while it achieves notably high accuracy levels when it chooses to rely
only on its parametric memory.
|
[
-0.476979523897171,
-0.5235417485237122,
0.5377283692359924,
-0.09165734797716141,
-0.17448437213897705,
-0.014681953005492687,
-0.2551708221435547,
-0.12008699029684067,
-0.014506865292787552,
0.4846027195453644,
-0.30592915415763855,
-0.2500661611557007,
-0.3986964821815491,
0.03688463568687439,
-0.30147093534469604,
0.7942650318145752,
0.008528143167495728,
0.13942980766296387,
-0.2290128469467163,
-0.27110549807548523,
-0.6415959000587463,
-0.6347423195838928,
-0.7195228338241577,
-0.09722799807786942,
0.5546483397483826,
0.7039881944656372,
0.43454569578170776,
0.626246452331543,
0.4001348316669464,
0.18783403933048248,
0.009905112907290459,
0.22512798011302948,
-0.8154112100601196,
0.0944862812757492,
-0.26522397994995117,
-0.7656177878379822,
0.028287434950470924,
-0.32809486985206604,
0.5986024737358093,
0.6187745332717896,
-0.3989923596382141,
0.3189907968044281,
-0.035787053406238556,
0.591903567314148,
-0.8630093336105347,
-0.07539089769124985,
-1.1705600023269653,
-0.06842110306024551,
-0.06369512528181076,
-0.6426885724067688,
-0.5956565737724304,
-0.33902502059936523,
0.3498461842536926,
-0.6212131977081299,
-0.004684966057538986,
0.2649649679660797,
0.6049577593803406,
0.1362701952457428,
-0.6147003769874573,
-0.48765847086906433,
-0.6365828514099121,
0.7953535318374634,
-0.3911844491958618,
0.461163192987442,
0.5385255813598633,
0.47784367203712463,
-0.22813749313354492,
-0.6563847064971924,
-0.20566119253635406,
-0.11436630040407181,
0.14178051054477692,
0.04219209402799606,
-0.05625945329666138,
-0.21833136677742004,
0.21717026829719543,
0.15439878404140472,
-0.4500112533569336,
-0.13006727397441864,
-0.43126869201660156,
-0.00561487628147006,
0.11738688498735428,
0.1821327805519104,
0.1282745748758316,
-0.023439321666955948,
-0.6167906522750854,
0.16831155121326447,
-0.9211450219154358,
0.002977658761665225,
0.03178882598876953,
0.3814532458782196,
0.4406370520591736,
0.6328560709953308,
0.131541907787323,
0.7905591726303101,
0.14203855395317078,
-0.0017416381742805243,
0.024428632110357285,
-0.12213430553674698,
0.0937202200293541,
-0.03137021139264107,
0.303074449300766,
0.14152057468891144,
0.4466313421726227,
-0.23169617354869843,
-0.5164496302604675,
-0.7497103810310364,
0.4377096891403198,
-0.760209321975708,
-0.042189452797174454,
-0.009021773934364319,
-0.49804770946502686,
0.18219104409217834,
-0.005094077438116074,
-0.6063193082809448,
-0.2133599817752838,
-0.273821085691452,
0.9086933135986328,
-0.4965543746948242,
-0.13259054720401764,
0.26857396960258484,
-0.18048928678035736,
0.4024057686328888,
0.24744562804698944,
-0.9447740912437439,
0.3644465506076813,
0.3139711916446686,
0.6472969055175781,
-0.3512409031391144,
-0.11970836669206619,
-1.0059924125671387,
0.3434922695159912,
-0.3256048262119293,
0.8710808157920837,
-0.4799843728542328,
-0.2955913245677948,
0.08845590800046921,
0.07443854957818985,
-0.25295722484588623,
-0.8881911039352417,
0.28846126794815063,
-0.9606148600578308,
0.17473062872886658,
-0.41954147815704346,
-0.6365388631820679,
-0.017238901928067207,
0.3478087782859802,
-0.6173929572105408,
0.9242991209030151,
0.11517709493637085,
-0.758635938167572,
0.15856815874576569,
-0.5918830037117004,
-0.17919838428497314,
-0.1067916601896286,
0.029550446197390556,
-0.052170608192682266,
0.19464118778705597,
0.2996617257595062,
0.27080366015434265,
-0.21910792589187622,
0.10540636628866196,
-0.1000499576330185,
-0.4925616383552551,
0.318499892950058,
-0.17242582142353058,
0.4574001729488373,
0.3109204173088074,
0.15128794312477112,
-0.15273863077163696,
-0.7049362063407898,
0.07679757475852966,
0.22926701605319977,
-0.9299332499504089,
-0.437965452671051,
0.18575522303581238,
-0.29149094223976135,
-0.06669401377439499,
0.4052915573120117,
-0.5652429461479187,
-0.01824089325964451,
-0.3095548152923584,
0.3274555504322052,
0.6695852279663086,
0.07860737293958664,
0.47619304060935974,
-0.5677652955055237,
0.514392077922821,
-0.10232017189264297,
-0.09788735955953598,
-0.25189733505249023,
-0.09699448198080063,
-0.8201463222503662,
-0.011641659773886204,
0.09219839423894882,
0.5446452498435974,
-1.040683627128601,
0.015430347993969917,
-0.11524226516485214,
-0.22096562385559082,
-0.3542681038379669,
0.3573974072933197,
0.15279987454414368,
0.6747320294380188,
0.4900028705596924,
-0.08127827942371368,
-0.6914681196212769,
-0.5701621770858765,
-0.4277779459953308,
-0.311996728181839,
-0.05583372712135315,
0.7046027779579163,
0.2752794325351715,
0.22824852168560028,
1.0185054540634155,
-0.576661229133606,
-0.00728366244584322,
-0.4093044698238373,
-0.06957242637872696,
0.11039826273918152,
0.06250140815973282,
0.3696839213371277,
-0.8870205283164978,
-0.2641759216785431,
-0.2774096131324768,
-0.6719014644622803,
-0.05344800651073456,
-0.06187252327799797,
-0.20094242691993713,
0.07511211186647415,
0.5522947311401367,
-0.477030485868454,
0.24666818976402283,
0.08846709132194519,
-0.16748569905757904,
0.27321186661720276,
-0.3647279739379883,
0.05467362701892853,
-1.0847939252853394,
0.1941412389278412,
-0.144118994474411,
-0.2542564570903778,
-0.4381265640258789,
0.02288040705025196,
0.23739774525165558,
-0.1371280550956726,
-0.6283475160598755,
0.8118775486946106,
-0.7202538251876831,
-0.2649514973163605,
-0.5210981369018555,
0.20898959040641785,
0.04000816494226456,
0.29110467433929443,
0.15777164697647095,
1.1682475805282593,
0.1990271508693695,
-0.9169734716415405,
0.18216481804847717,
0.34285667538642883,
-0.4441428780555725,
0.4930463135242462,
-0.37223801016807556,
0.3433586359024048,
-0.4616527259349823,
0.10016614198684692,
-1.0006331205368042,
-0.06076924130320549,
-0.0626947283744812,
-0.48544150590896606,
0.3304835855960846,
-0.13996398448944092,
-0.3804647922515869,
-0.3539663851261139,
-0.1818639487028122,
0.32726404070854187,
0.5086187124252319,
-0.994674801826477,
0.6986227631568909,
0.38035425543785095,
-0.0986543595790863,
-0.7776857018470764,
-0.4617490768432617,
-0.04208328202366829,
-0.4966592788696289,
-0.34003421664237976,
0.15854011476039886,
-0.3157646656036377,
0.00020971977210137993,
-0.09513930231332779,
-0.17640310525894165,
-0.26726654171943665,
0.32677730917930603,
-0.22977334260940552,
0.1036904901266098,
-0.5230025053024292,
0.5186771750450134,
-0.21594280004501343,
0.008726298809051514,
0.02310936525464058,
-0.26076754927635193,
0.6012837290763855,
-0.032476142048835754,
-0.3401399552822113,
0.04824857786297798,
0.2612576484680176,
0.324655145406723,
-0.15488703548908234,
0.9499620795249939,
0.24772892892360687,
-0.30401602387428284,
-0.12263055890798569,
-0.7081964015960693,
-0.40364477038383484,
-0.4559406042098999,
0.5050952434539795,
-0.4048057794570923,
-0.7519790530204773,
0.49263614416122437,
-0.10968610644340515,
0.10658099502325058,
0.07942283153533936,
0.5252436995506287,
-0.17451833188533783,
0.783674955368042,
0.4567635953426361,
-0.07892394065856934,
0.705069363117218,
0.032638367265462875,
-0.02342108264565468,
-1.0379469394683838,
-0.40714502334594727,
-0.5610750913619995,
-0.22100131213665009,
-0.08367876708507538,
-0.3759273886680603,
0.2178625762462616,
0.24756745994091034,
-0.4758521318435669,
0.23891285061836243,
-0.19945411384105682,
0.4919939637184143,
0.5872572660446167,
0.2663920819759369,
0.2620483934879303,
0.19348809123039246,
-0.12714721262454987,
0.06927128881216049,
-0.8139599561691284,
-0.37164589762687683,
1.5013105869293213,
0.20015332102775574,
1.0666229724884033,
0.13113467395305634,
0.6264419555664062,
-0.0017253945115953684,
0.36758217215538025,
-0.8104757070541382,
0.5641148090362549,
-0.004559861961752176,
-0.6663572192192078,
-0.1144881397485733,
-0.5182751417160034,
-1.1859123706817627,
0.23975200951099396,
0.03717494383454323,
-0.4889259338378906,
0.09952300786972046,
0.08401443064212799,
-0.300753116607666,
0.35157227516174316,
-0.7174230813980103,
0.3946111500263214,
-0.4590872526168823,
-0.18658430874347687,
-0.04015732556581497,
-0.4921542704105377,
-0.10681714862585068,
-0.21819265186786652,
-0.0004327289934735745,
0.08572866767644882,
-0.45925575494766235,
0.7470685243606567,
-0.030344055965542793,
0.5679792165756226,
-0.3979460299015045,
0.1493620127439499,
0.5065059065818787,
0.03222665190696716,
0.36634698510169983,
-0.13792794942855835,
-0.5034361481666565,
-0.4716564416885376,
0.1170230358839035,
-0.45840978622436523,
-0.7497804760932922,
0.5996560454368591,
-0.6710615158081055,
-0.9754443168640137,
-0.2131175994873047,
-0.6297287940979004,
-0.3776260018348694,
0.10018449276685715,
0.09281309694051743,
0.3285973072052002,
-0.2184045910835266,
0.5275260210037231,
0.9932420253753662,
-0.3793998956680298,
0.30600669980049133,
0.9487056136131287,
-0.25036486983299255,
-0.428724080324173,
0.8863725662231445,
0.22988104820251465,
0.41237562894821167,
0.6020967960357666,
0.3615489900112152,
-0.3819563686847687,
-0.553593099117279,
-0.43360453844070435,
0.19896461069583893,
-0.9597457051277161,
-0.36993685364723206,
-0.5691651105880737,
-0.3147398829460144,
-0.15956029295921326,
0.22072148323059082,
-0.04822017252445221,
-0.24458646774291992,
-0.587357759475708,
-0.001056768000125885,
0.5648983120918274,
0.3547426462173462,
0.022848837077617645,
0.3312072455883026,
-0.8437871932983398,
0.22969430685043335,
0.2692996561527252,
0.16977818310260773,
0.03128581866621971,
-0.9998714327812195,
-0.14795880019664764,
-0.05081169307231903,
-0.36126822233200073,
-0.6392473578453064,
0.28231513500213623,
0.4933221936225891,
0.8835047483444214,
0.1419365555047989,
0.17164961993694305,
0.5463448166847229,
-0.46671202778816223,
0.45177724957466125,
-0.22728806734085083,
-0.49158596992492676,
0.7027909755706787,
-0.3232177495956421,
0.4132459759712219,
0.6340150833129883,
0.7305761575698853,
-0.37569376826286316,
-0.035990871489048004,
-0.27802708745002747,
-0.8336995840072632,
0.7387683987617493,
-0.2621712386608124,
0.48494482040405273,
-0.4313710331916809,
0.8127638697624207,
0.26586252450942993,
0.3665946424007416,
-0.6957029700279236,
-0.12786947190761566,
0.04025886580348015,
-0.4236815869808197,
0.17126305401325226,
-0.47791123390197754,
0.017217114567756653,
-0.01643231511116028,
0.5622583627700806,
-0.30331677198410034,
0.486785888671875,
-0.004551060032099485,
-0.24752821028232574,
-0.09915724396705627,
0.2108674943447113,
0.17143991589546204,
0.9039881229400635,
-0.4103911817073822,
0.19780921936035156,
0.2793516516685486,
-0.32713091373443604,
0.11870164424180984,
-0.12523706257343292,
0.015944207087159157,
-0.23917552828788757,
0.018393559381365776,
0.6568902134895325,
0.2823469042778015,
-1.0218397378921509,
0.43982699513435364,
-0.16681696474552155,
-0.05330885574221611,
-0.26981034874916077,
0.22811461985111237,
0.34693196415901184,
0.24291649460792542,
0.6279521584510803,
-0.30823788046836853,
0.014579963870346546,
-0.6464758515357971,
0.3325071632862091,
0.5903738141059875,
-0.21850287914276123,
-0.043980613350868225,
0.4198533892631531,
-0.08721756935119629,
-0.5504360198974609,
0.6813121438026428,
0.29757407307624817,
-0.28607791662216187,
0.4768916666507721,
0.9854028224945068,
0.4759772717952728,
-0.4497120976448059,
0.04250381514430046,
0.22192570567131042,
0.048721861094236374,
-0.2217622548341751,
0.5153290033340454,
-0.053153958171606064,
-0.6972528696060181,
-0.11010372638702393,
-0.4739348888397217,
-0.33950257301330566,
0.27845725417137146,
-0.8408133387565613,
0.21742281317710876,
-0.5584630370140076,
-0.005290050525218248,
-0.4870093762874603,
-0.19428741931915283,
-0.5576155781745911,
0.19516955316066742,
-0.2096155285835266,
1.1484824419021606,
-0.4928103983402252,
0.7101688981056213,
0.7251225113868713,
-0.306716650724411,
-0.7180440425872803,
0.19465629756450653,
-0.2573927044868469,
-1.2419153451919556,
0.7054507732391357,
0.03983238339424133,
-0.017047639936208725,
0.14379481971263885,
-0.5078232884407043,
-1.2148786783218384,
1.1424846649169922,
0.5610520839691162,
-0.3380054533481598,
-0.04174620658159256,
-0.0653296634554863,
0.40352895855903625,
-0.4839891493320465,
0.2600436508655548,
0.46124276518821716,
0.0948929637670517,
0.5600529313087463,
-0.6137346625328064,
-0.08726505935192108,
0.011979899369180202,
-0.06072100251913071,
0.20599539577960968,
-0.6115530133247375,
0.731680691242218,
-0.2953304946422577,
-0.12425152212381363,
0.3364759385585785,
0.610451340675354,
0.3923839330673218,
0.3093838393688202,
0.46768057346343994,
0.261004775762558,
0.8280781507492065,
0.17923517525196075,
0.8684512376785278,
-0.17269378900527954,
0.105188749730587,
1.193917155265808,
-0.20493772625923157,
1.287986159324646,
0.6405699849128723,
0.11885091662406921,
0.2105541080236435,
0.7292428612709045,
0.24563995003700256,
0.7643887996673584,
0.36703360080718994,
-0.2933059632778168,
-0.3089422583580017,
-0.06616510450839996,
-0.20663008093833923,
0.31132379174232483,
0.5175250172615051,
-0.4723189175128937,
-0.43758630752563477,
0.40125802159309387,
-0.2069339156150818,
0.12016331404447556,
-0.37360644340515137,
0.952971875667572,
0.22191660106182098,
-0.7763736844062805,
0.7460440993309021,
-0.1497325301170349,
0.31516486406326294,
-0.5619475245475769,
0.2103787064552307,
-0.5086416602134705,
0.27515047788619995,
-0.01960751786828041,
-0.7573719620704651,
0.13220712542533875,
-0.008881540969014168,
-0.2857724726200104,
-0.04090951010584831,
0.642571210861206,
-0.46033743023872375,
-0.3355496823787689,
0.4131101667881012,
0.555822491645813,
0.26741769909858704,
0.13462838530540466,
-0.6284483075141907,
-0.12148703634738922,
-0.000020355812011985108,
-0.44643455743789673,
0.6169469356536865,
0.6224566698074341,
0.05083128809928894,
1.064192533493042,
0.36135536432266235,
0.1387767493724823,
0.20272238552570343,
0.010339255444705486,
1.0381923913955688,
-0.5833917856216431,
-0.19139455258846283,
-0.6223979592323303,
0.15707410871982574,
0.2497178316116333,
-0.06755076348781586,
0.6639140248298645,
0.651162326335907,
0.6843623518943787,
0.05254785344004631,
0.6861935257911682,
0.2591519057750702,
0.8482651114463806,
-0.7670629620552063,
0.34034690260887146,
-0.7881598472595215,
0.5887062549591064,
0.20266033709049225,
-1.016406774520874,
-0.039950888603925705,
0.6062754392623901,
-0.586243212223053,
0.19037987291812897,
0.6310511231422424,
0.7460593581199646,
-0.08539403975009918,
0.05638303980231285,
0.2624889314174652,
-0.05669303238391876,
0.31822359561920166,
0.8017959594726562,
1.1035373210906982,
-0.23546482622623444,
0.9453774094581604,
0.3314606547355652,
-0.04663267731666565,
-0.2555609345436096,
-0.6650311350822449,
-0.8569270372390747,
-0.39961645007133484,
0.03142028674483299,
-0.439953088760376,
0.2810707092285156,
0.8631842732429504,
0.4156804084777832,
-0.5847536325454712,
-0.39258214831352234,
0.14238318800926208,
0.07353589683771133,
0.31003525853157043,
-0.1656283289194107,
0.2948611378669739,
-0.5886502265930176,
-0.46402913331985474,
0.41065162420272827,
0.1424233317375183,
-0.04250836744904518,
0.01882348209619522,
0.012167626991868019,
-0.4317414164543152,
0.22560589015483856,
0.3099691867828369,
0.46466538310050964,
-0.460995614528656,
-0.3830680549144745,
0.4276871979236603,
-0.04970008134841919,
0.492794007062912,
0.8994073867797852,
-0.8286388516426086,
0.524902880191803,
0.3912721574306488,
1.1349583864212036,
0.4811357259750366,
0.18770016729831696,
0.6621547937393188,
-0.5639097094535828,
-0.09717824310064316,
0.2865615487098694,
0.220527783036232,
0.4021340608596802,
-0.431396484375,
0.19993090629577637,
-0.11035686731338501,
-0.6387060284614563,
-0.7274140119552612,
0.06043851003050804,
-0.48217928409576416,
-0.4086974561214447,
1.2919334173202515,
-0.24466510117053986,
-0.1802080124616623,
-0.3776625394821167,
-0.32374444603919983,
-0.07641268521547318,
-0.2934994399547577,
0.7481964230537415,
0.6902201771736145,
-0.07250051200389862,
-0.34421810507774353,
-0.585864245891571,
0.2895854711532593,
0.5108489990234375,
-0.613359272480011,
-0.00020998147374484688,
0.19841410219669342,
0.7804028391838074,
-0.18637721240520477,
0.7651118636131287,
-0.059579186141490936,
0.21184812486171722,
-0.40600088238716125,
-0.36423420906066895,
0.018982907757163048,
-0.34674933552742004,
-0.19403980672359467,
0.24268470704555511,
0.4969629943370819,
-0.3549601435661316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19696v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19696v1
|
Naturally Supervised 3D Visual Grounding with Language-Regularized Concept Learners
| 2024-04-30T16:44:18 | 2024-04-30T16:44:18 |
Chun Feng, Joy Hsu, Weiyu Liu, Jiajun Wu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
3D visual grounding is a challenging task that often requires direct and
dense supervision, notably the semantic label for each object in the scene. In
this paper, we instead study the naturally supervised setting that learns from
only 3D scene and QA pairs, where prior works underperform. We propose the
Language-Regularized Concept Learner (LARC), which uses constraints from
language as regularization to significantly improve the accuracy of
neuro-symbolic concept learners in the naturally supervised setting. Our
approach is based on two core insights: the first is that language constraints
(e.g., a word's relation to another) can serve as effective regularization for
structured representations in neuro-symbolic models; the second is that we can
query large language models to distill such constraints from language
properties. We show that LARC improves performance of prior works in naturally
supervised 3D visual grounding, and demonstrates a wide range of 3D visual
reasoning capabilities-from zero-shot composition, to data efficiency and
transferability. Our method represents a promising step towards regularizing
structured visual reasoning frameworks with language-based priors, for learning
in settings without dense supervision.
|
[
-0.31763243675231934,
-0.8705660700798035,
0.5298422574996948,
0.03330623358488083,
-0.3687047064304352,
-0.07132712751626968,
-0.15700261294841766,
-0.3317900598049164,
0.041956037282943726,
0.5187668204307556,
-0.18569786846637726,
-0.7213650345802307,
-0.29752492904663086,
0.1881892830133438,
0.1328984647989273,
0.7054449319839478,
-0.24676665663719177,
0.012227172963321209,
-0.3556152880191803,
-0.08752801269292831,
-0.5820680260658264,
-0.5458023548126221,
-0.5796306133270264,
-0.09667035937309265,
0.551748514175415,
0.3393900692462921,
0.7598274350166321,
0.7970137596130371,
0.6373664140701294,
0.27060121297836304,
-0.12690557539463043,
0.30167844891548157,
-0.6265301704406738,
-0.14036987721920013,
-0.06165172532200813,
-0.5827032327651978,
-0.11236216127872467,
0.013909748755395412,
0.6732917428016663,
1.0334466695785522,
0.015465485863387585,
-0.3892567455768585,
-0.06794305145740509,
0.8681212067604065,
-0.7192032337188721,
0.391170471906662,
-0.4003016948699951,
0.2778030037879944,
0.22343868017196655,
-0.06644384562969208,
-0.08352085947990417,
-0.3663533926010132,
0.022753765806555748,
-0.952854335308075,
0.6056283116340637,
0.03207189962267876,
1.0951318740844727,
0.7881210446357727,
-0.2702464163303375,
0.2556631565093994,
-0.5872564315795898,
0.5263685584068298,
-0.303392231464386,
0.676558792591095,
0.612467348575592,
0.4732568562030792,
-0.07566218823194504,
-0.5426395535469055,
-0.5059911012649536,
-0.4470195174217224,
-0.1953621208667755,
0.20064598321914673,
0.30289480090141296,
0.32235321402549744,
0.6584054231643677,
0.5383466482162476,
-0.4428142011165619,
-0.05426734685897827,
-0.585207462310791,
-0.13645786046981812,
0.47255071997642517,
-0.22847440838813782,
0.36295652389526367,
-0.12256201356649399,
-0.2114701122045517,
-0.468253493309021,
-0.7379468083381653,
0.11594162881374359,
-0.06476316601037979,
0.45070451498031616,
-0.3523572087287903,
0.6537439823150635,
-0.39069658517837524,
1.0318259000778198,
-0.10973820090293884,
-0.029641281813383102,
0.12065324932336807,
-0.13728009164333344,
-0.2829841375350952,
0.06705983728170395,
0.4368569254875183,
0.441400408744812,
0.4757586419582367,
-0.2769319713115692,
-0.11931714415550232,
0.4020921587944031,
0.2471158802509308,
-0.666523277759552,
-0.47775813937187195,
-0.14524869620800018,
0.057351987808942795,
0.10062653571367264,
0.40058043599128723,
-0.35289159417152405,
-0.5215273499488831,
-0.6115191578865051,
0.11073176562786102,
-0.35256120562553406,
-0.17133896052837372,
0.4532310366630554,
-0.15623241662979126,
0.30725881457328796,
0.4659889340400696,
-0.5367516279220581,
0.3310312032699585,
0.4517039656639099,
0.8897765874862671,
-0.0803297758102417,
-0.0885259360074997,
-0.7656888365745544,
0.4146232008934021,
-0.6384604573249817,
0.623849630355835,
-0.3239986300468445,
-0.34116920828819275,
-0.14643801748752594,
0.0037928675301373005,
0.05491981282830238,
-0.4798036217689514,
0.34965774416923523,
-0.46633654832839966,
0.17957504093647003,
-0.24350370466709137,
-0.28646019101142883,
-0.23047088086605072,
0.4024200439453125,
-0.7373291254043579,
0.808210551738739,
0.1731397956609726,
-0.7780483961105347,
0.4145760238170624,
-0.21203339099884033,
-0.4740723669528961,
0.12791545689105988,
-0.5896949172019958,
0.007763597648590803,
0.1946275681257248,
0.4397551119327545,
0.48152029514312744,
0.00700001884251833,
0.3697594702243805,
-0.21734675765037537,
-0.49973931908607483,
-0.4109460413455963,
0.09016851335763931,
0.40325433015823364,
-0.06634894013404846,
-0.13213545083999634,
0.08307605236768723,
-0.8835258483886719,
-0.11643063277006149,
0.14488251507282257,
-0.021870143711566925,
-0.48910096287727356,
-0.08461137861013412,
-0.18476396799087524,
0.3415106236934662,
-0.04583381116390228,
-0.3331403136253357,
-0.0136029701679945,
-0.7179722189903259,
0.08758231997489929,
0.3232452869415283,
0.01340307667851448,
0.7405953407287598,
-0.026432093232870102,
0.33940625190734863,
-0.05348363518714905,
-0.23167197406291962,
-0.0003036801645066589,
-0.2720601558685303,
-0.815684974193573,
-0.503052294254303,
0.12738226354122162,
0.5684443712234497,
-0.9349536299705505,
0.5742697715759277,
-0.2956100106239319,
-0.08898323774337769,
-0.21629451215267181,
0.2952573001384735,
0.39850446581840515,
0.7905516028404236,
0.5909793972969055,
-0.08265584707260132,
-0.43772631883621216,
-1.1102606058120728,
0.21351933479309082,
-0.02484886161983013,
-0.3683519661426544,
0.10434063524007797,
0.3670630156993866,
-0.1248999685049057,
1.0702424049377441,
-0.6364061832427979,
-0.7351176738739014,
-0.16102178394794464,
-0.027746936306357384,
0.23499302566051483,
0.6994126439094543,
0.42187413573265076,
-1.0309940576553345,
-0.44004327058792114,
0.19425836205482483,
-0.9789956212043762,
0.016321007162332535,
-0.13239780068397522,
-0.16572843492031097,
0.0767531618475914,
0.8905434608459473,
-0.381285160779953,
0.5521652698516846,
0.2084828019142151,
-0.21073462069034576,
-0.09998644888401031,
-0.3197025656700134,
-0.18739034235477448,
-0.6312287449836731,
-0.05996355414390564,
0.26965466141700745,
-0.18258394300937653,
-0.5307105779647827,
0.21765971183776855,
-0.02930804342031479,
-0.08418101817369461,
-0.5110979676246643,
0.5805680751800537,
-0.43344154953956604,
0.12329162657260895,
-0.19667936861515045,
0.25597068667411804,
0.199778214097023,
0.7589733004570007,
0.9568368196487427,
0.34835851192474365,
0.7981323599815369,
-0.7258588075637817,
0.06905540078878403,
0.344705730676651,
-0.30372029542922974,
0.6482804417610168,
-0.9388859272003174,
0.20284834504127502,
-0.2888348698616028,
0.3349219858646393,
-0.6287379860877991,
-0.20806320011615753,
0.21967610716819763,
-0.13871818780899048,
0.1134757325053215,
-0.257967472076416,
-0.6301302909851074,
-0.15190862119197845,
-0.07479394227266312,
0.24182532727718353,
0.3585880994796753,
-0.5739718079566956,
0.5043419003486633,
0.1736110895872116,
0.36983686685562134,
-0.2734346091747284,
-0.6373152732849121,
0.058774758130311966,
-0.06257682293653488,
-0.6039449572563171,
0.4035155177116394,
0.1093938872218132,
-0.36813226342201233,
0.033664654940366745,
-0.6585221886634827,
-0.2333446592092514,
0.001855842536315322,
0.375385046005249,
0.17242848873138428,
-0.22086268663406372,
-0.17135870456695557,
-0.1547417938709259,
-0.19211317598819733,
0.027758261188864708,
0.019084975123405457,
0.12301609665155411,
-0.39235368371009827,
-0.2572786211967468,
-0.6176276206970215,
0.22030331194400787,
0.1791214793920517,
-0.17915816605091095,
0.6708488464355469,
0.5421118140220642,
-0.7029261589050293,
-0.08219701051712036,
-0.5469775795936584,
-0.29420390725135803,
-0.45986148715019226,
0.34511876106262207,
-0.6409343481063843,
-1.0665453672409058,
0.22687482833862305,
0.17673276364803314,
-0.1896975189447403,
0.151496022939682,
0.07679308205842972,
-0.22184744477272034,
1.1991429328918457,
0.9501489400863647,
0.19279514253139496,
0.3255595564842224,
-0.5980779528617859,
0.12809032201766968,
-0.786675751209259,
-0.3593021631240845,
-0.18904833495616913,
-0.13840332627296448,
-0.2169632464647293,
-0.7475687861442566,
0.258861243724823,
0.70570307970047,
-0.32101544737815857,
0.046763088554143906,
-0.40773558616638184,
0.6888786554336548,
0.4923185408115387,
0.2805216908454895,
0.1044437512755394,
0.09636003524065018,
-0.20904836058616638,
-0.06597983092069626,
-0.6885963678359985,
-0.42669036984443665,
0.47461944818496704,
0.20569375157356262,
0.49017536640167236,
-0.1364344358444214,
0.5138999223709106,
-0.2407771497964859,
0.20071372389793396,
-0.695035457611084,
0.3586159348487854,
-0.017341552302241325,
-0.23625323176383972,
-0.25264912843704224,
-0.5432416796684265,
-0.6689965724945068,
0.5916469693183899,
-0.3204648494720459,
-0.6260954737663269,
0.33324670791625977,
0.1876525729894638,
-0.47798940539360046,
0.2606877088546753,
-0.6117792129516602,
0.9787774682044983,
-0.2125726193189621,
-0.6499400734901428,
-0.0226979348808527,
-0.8563796281814575,
0.3805899918079376,
0.043938424438238144,
0.2873186767101288,
-0.018488677218556404,
0.09833994507789612,
0.4011758863925934,
-0.36224931478500366,
0.9941118955612183,
-0.33415254950523376,
-0.29178330302238464,
0.21646784245967865,
0.16364625096321106,
0.4141139090061188,
0.5890820622444153,
0.32051220536231995,
0.06998061388731003,
-0.09687153995037079,
-0.45454126596450806,
-0.9065564274787903,
0.5403552651405334,
-0.7315208911895752,
-0.8301267027854919,
-0.4352336525917053,
-0.5808438062667847,
-0.552946150302887,
0.3519548773765564,
0.06504327803850174,
0.13406972587108612,
-0.19286668300628662,
0.4180792570114136,
0.8272119164466858,
-0.17355653643608093,
-0.031253039836883545,
0.28102508187294006,
-0.21494080126285553,
-0.2927258014678955,
0.8883156776428223,
-0.27876439690589905,
0.1084364652633667,
0.6625432968139648,
0.20229457318782806,
-0.26968321204185486,
-0.5443105697631836,
-0.10942813009023666,
0.24258235096931458,
-0.7376530170440674,
-0.0960116907954216,
-0.5747323632240295,
-0.21600836515426636,
-0.1521846354007721,
-0.716636598110199,
-0.37049081921577454,
-0.3300738036632538,
-0.2943432927131653,
-0.311240017414093,
0.0792892724275589,
0.3665688633918762,
-0.1507866382598877,
0.3808654546737671,
-0.6135942339897156,
1.0965750217437744,
0.5237156748771667,
0.5188603401184082,
-0.5540212392807007,
-0.3534204661846161,
-0.10200099647045135,
0.360209196805954,
0.33010074496269226,
-0.36563172936439514,
0.2346290498971939,
0.20695656538009644,
0.6077321767807007,
0.48973020911216736,
-0.011694450862705708,
0.8761484622955322,
-0.361167311668396,
0.491019606590271,
0.2625708281993866,
-0.6409692764282227,
0.7518516182899475,
-0.3217232823371887,
0.4517557919025421,
0.7354000210762024,
0.22161157429218292,
-0.3768942356109619,
-0.4321262538433075,
-0.436987966299057,
-0.6975376009941101,
0.6498908996582031,
0.2736673355102539,
0.07365347445011139,
-0.15531732141971588,
0.47115951776504517,
-0.2856290936470032,
-0.06292743235826492,
-0.7782966494560242,
0.012479626573622227,
-0.588077962398529,
0.11069201678037643,
-0.3617049753665924,
0.02910030260682106,
-0.2970024645328522,
-0.6211491227149963,
0.20002080500125885,
-0.3338891863822937,
-0.2563249170780182,
0.3362252116203308,
-0.4647856056690216,
0.019308656454086304,
-0.3475589454174042,
0.4884415566921234,
0.5025911927223206,
-0.5090875625610352,
0.3927749991416931,
0.12838473916053772,
-0.2647104561328888,
-0.12723912298679352,
-0.08693830668926239,
-0.23507003486156464,
-0.06756577640771866,
0.4519856870174408,
0.915124237537384,
0.22618237137794495,
-0.6483942270278931,
0.4165559411048889,
-0.09324020892381668,
-0.4227314591407776,
-0.03351317346096039,
0.13109132647514343,
-0.1769648939371109,
-0.025114385411143303,
0.0768112987279892,
0.07423833757638931,
-0.14260950684547424,
-0.07112226635217667,
0.21624520421028137,
0.31301915645599365,
-0.5878344178199768,
-0.32006391882896423,
0.7754225134849548,
0.1035335585474968,
0.18466950953006744,
0.7125169038772583,
-0.10988078266382217,
-0.3180638551712036,
0.7986199855804443,
0.5589297413825989,
0.6237663626670837,
0.09069771319627762,
0.23169976472854614,
0.6510154008865356,
0.4383493959903717,
-0.5083611607551575,
0.17830324172973633,
-0.22667254507541656,
-1.058607578277588,
-0.5552983283996582,
-0.4015877842903137,
-0.2483075112104416,
0.022834954783320427,
-0.6755165457725525,
0.43250975012779236,
-0.7319338321685791,
0.22735081613063812,
-0.37076205015182495,
-0.19915145635604858,
-0.7664533257484436,
0.409595251083374,
0.5783120393753052,
0.674216628074646,
-0.8149360418319702,
0.8914156556129456,
0.9966093301773071,
-0.5110248923301697,
-0.5618096590042114,
-0.2997756600379944,
-0.16976182162761688,
-0.4600030183792114,
0.9074028134346008,
0.4618910551071167,
-0.5459415912628174,
0.10888270288705826,
-0.5016806125640869,
-0.9136068820953369,
0.6522121429443359,
0.5054284334182739,
-0.3666287958621979,
0.03950769454240799,
0.14714844524860382,
0.7598199248313904,
-0.16190099716186523,
-0.27525201439857483,
0.389730304479599,
0.46732211112976074,
0.45436039566993713,
-0.46796083450317383,
-0.05112165957689285,
-0.4063977599143982,
0.14628566801548004,
0.014770511537790298,
-0.28007814288139343,
0.28941890597343445,
-0.2692003548145294,
-0.5578807592391968,
-0.3535082936286926,
1.0190984010696411,
0.4580354392528534,
0.06898487359285355,
0.6879745125770569,
0.7900885343551636,
0.557368278503418,
-0.012633813545107841,
0.9537841081619263,
-0.15404048562049866,
-0.05465361103415489,
1.250008463859558,
-0.3980635702610016,
0.5790103673934937,
0.6835476160049438,
0.0968037098646164,
0.36609622836112976,
0.5575151443481445,
0.06894022971391678,
0.6896938681602478,
0.4298768937587738,
0.2503541111946106,
-0.5768853425979614,
-0.23823243379592896,
-0.39439964294433594,
0.3629698157310486,
0.5046003460884094,
0.2955830991268158,
-0.28829288482666016,
-0.031475793570280075,
-0.31573572754859924,
0.511682391166687,
-0.37945690751075745,
0.6155878305435181,
0.28217267990112305,
-0.37192028760910034,
0.9365373253822327,
-0.16808731853961945,
0.5608922839164734,
-0.40044406056404114,
-0.3200805187225342,
-0.3463101387023926,
-0.12208282947540283,
-0.2887704074382782,
-0.32986631989479065,
0.44826337695121765,
-0.22820977866649628,
0.038955219089984894,
-0.4388696551322937,
0.3533296287059784,
-0.43863388895988464,
-0.6221520900726318,
0.029658295214176178,
0.5250704884529114,
-0.05437862128019333,
-0.26228830218315125,
-0.37437334656715393,
-0.17787480354309082,
-0.3125397264957428,
-0.10438428074121475,
0.1588933914899826,
0.46675121784210205,
-0.4122450351715088,
0.624809205532074,
0.6031460165977478,
0.06601529568433762,
-0.0810711607336998,
0.259014368057251,
0.8860824108123779,
-0.5730764865875244,
-0.5766729712486267,
-0.5728941559791565,
0.33962440490722656,
-0.08355867862701416,
-0.11934074014425278,
0.6411758661270142,
0.7522444725036621,
1.0473946332931519,
-0.07966798543930054,
0.4241926074028015,
0.030656246468424797,
0.09306783974170685,
-0.8061328530311584,
0.35015103220939636,
-0.5400764346122742,
0.24753284454345703,
-0.13880646228790283,
-1.1353206634521484,
-1.1509991884231567,
1.193323016166687,
-0.2588556110858917,
-0.19928428530693054,
0.9697548747062683,
0.7555323243141174,
-0.14076192677021027,
-0.27537330985069275,
0.4584736227989197,
-0.11323723196983337,
0.13087612390518188,
0.5599089860916138,
0.9984484910964966,
0.015630003064870834,
0.1361723244190216,
-0.8495582342147827,
-0.07824228703975677,
0.2510022521018982,
-0.8627392053604126,
-1.368172526359558,
-0.4544197916984558,
-0.6996281743049622,
-0.05039678141474724,
0.022158941254019737,
0.7742874622344971,
0.6602478623390198,
-0.8442349433898926,
-0.07731017470359802,
-0.5207641124725342,
0.27560800313949585,
-0.3481224775314331,
-0.19629396498203278,
0.7039573192596436,
-0.3039292097091675,
-0.7522525191307068,
0.6753535866737366,
0.20189134776592255,
0.19337110221385956,
-0.0026666242629289627,
-0.07279496639966965,
-0.10755322128534317,
-0.41462042927742004,
0.5226992964744568,
0.4407742917537689,
-0.7230959534645081,
-0.4254250228404999,
-0.016484495252370834,
-0.2146863490343094,
0.2024632692337036,
0.8551139235496521,
-1.0954021215438843,
0.4114253520965576,
0.4390363395214081,
0.5153977870941162,
0.4510399401187897,
0.09691457450389862,
0.7694413065910339,
-0.9806955456733704,
0.684956967830658,
0.3225010335445404,
0.3990921974182129,
0.431816428899765,
-0.30259963870048523,
0.8150826096534729,
0.2776579260826111,
0.1479346752166748,
-0.9117209911346436,
0.14807219803333282,
-0.9712023735046387,
-0.20499780774116516,
1.2322332859039307,
0.03465113788843155,
-0.13309720158576965,
-0.13554033637046814,
-0.3357480764389038,
0.2663806676864624,
0.013953147456049919,
0.7075080275535583,
0.2181733101606369,
0.12197622656822205,
-0.44411036372184753,
-0.6932533979415894,
0.708541214466095,
0.2585614323616028,
-0.6806017756462097,
-0.22782878577709198,
0.8184850215911865,
-0.12826907634735107,
0.14196835458278656,
0.32677653431892395,
0.10311823338270187,
0.23796895146369934,
-0.2907645106315613,
0.2745496332645416,
-0.3304220139980316,
-0.5863407254219055,
-0.3336661458015442,
0.21146993339061737,
-0.1951092630624771,
-0.07228492945432663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01597v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01597v1
|
Improving Disease Detection from Social Media Text via Self-Augmentation and Contrastive Learning
| 2024-04-30T15:24:54 | 2024-04-30T15:24:54 |
Pervaiz Iqbal Khan, Andreas Dengel, Sheraz Ahmed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Detecting diseases from social media has diverse applications, such as public
health monitoring and disease spread detection. While language models (LMs)
have shown promising performance in this domain, there remains ongoing research
aimed at refining their discriminating representations. In this paper, we
propose a novel method that integrates Contrastive Learning (CL) with language
modeling to address this challenge. Our approach introduces a self-augmentation
method, wherein hidden representations of the model are augmented with their
own representations. This method comprises two branches: the first branch, a
traditional LM, learns features specific to the given data, while the second
branch incorporates augmented representations from the first branch to
encourage generalization. CL further refines these representations by pulling
pairs of original and augmented versions closer while pushing other samples
away. We evaluate our method on three NLP datasets encompassing binary,
multi-label, and multi-class classification tasks involving social media posts
related to various diseases. Our approach demonstrates notable improvements
over traditional fine-tuning methods, achieving up to a 2.48% increase in
F1-score compared to baseline approaches and a 2.1% enhancement over
state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.008993178606033325,
-0.601015567779541,
0.36580801010131836,
0.07522762566804886,
-0.49891918897628784,
0.22396519780158997,
-0.053310804069042206,
-0.8164523839950562,
0.7787079811096191,
0.4359746277332306,
-0.32648196816444397,
-0.7203364372253418,
-0.7143298387527466,
0.1806311011314392,
-0.23482142388820648,
1.027913212776184,
0.2696499526500702,
0.07184542715549469,
-0.040438540279865265,
-0.29122763872146606,
-0.0677143931388855,
-0.2941944897174835,
-0.7772766947746277,
-0.36714938282966614,
0.5972902774810791,
0.41553670167922974,
0.4832197427749634,
0.7577736377716064,
0.5979393124580383,
0.29475411772727966,
-0.03031279519200325,
0.5243844985961914,
-0.45320141315460205,
0.16322074830532074,
-0.4536839723587036,
-0.17375588417053223,
-0.08001809567213058,
-0.12379859387874603,
0.30561986565589905,
0.6736682057380676,
0.22164611518383026,
-0.01952410489320755,
0.44420021772384644,
0.8158972263336182,
-0.5031987428665161,
0.09626460820436478,
-0.4248582720756531,
-0.06404152512550354,
0.03986331820487976,
-0.43827009201049805,
-0.07873586565256119,
-0.08776772022247314,
0.08120550960302353,
-0.4589025378227234,
0.3193124532699585,
-0.38824862241744995,
0.6806247234344482,
0.3246750235557556,
-0.5614157915115356,
-0.41802772879600525,
-0.45692768692970276,
0.6046144366264343,
-0.6550434827804565,
0.2834210991859436,
0.5091559290885925,
0.2824658751487732,
0.18107576668262482,
-0.752353310585022,
-0.2225707620382309,
-0.08785597234964371,
-0.3327798843383789,
0.20291723310947418,
-0.3586789071559906,
-0.04513850063085556,
-0.1079624816775322,
0.4747648537158966,
-0.5433555841445923,
0.1393340677022934,
-0.4986979365348816,
-0.26228493452072144,
0.7281524538993835,
-0.23189933598041534,
0.5397135615348816,
-0.34310784935951233,
-0.19512318074703217,
-0.026300549507141113,
-0.3692058324813843,
-0.3244207501411438,
-0.00953085906803608,
0.5212812423706055,
-0.5577492117881775,
0.15734770894050598,
-0.2622792720794678,
0.38297683000564575,
0.21445031464099884,
-0.015223607420921326,
0.734809160232544,
-0.359225332736969,
-0.11422823369503021,
-0.16857336461544037,
0.7389287352561951,
0.5563540458679199,
-0.10730381309986115,
0.12053822726011276,
-0.09537975490093231,
0.0513150617480278,
0.06470626592636108,
-0.9397283792495728,
-0.898064136505127,
0.14866819977760315,
-0.7814751267433167,
-0.4610375761985779,
-0.3503969609737396,
-0.8128784894943237,
-0.7070489525794983,
-0.1907951682806015,
0.40264394879341125,
-0.7012431025505066,
-0.44306570291519165,
0.09807384759187698,
0.010491265915334225,
-0.2995481491088867,
0.37378549575805664,
-0.9929520487785339,
0.09658155590295792,
0.3572719991207123,
0.8656761050224304,
-0.33110183477401733,
0.23559124767780304,
-0.604399561882019,
0.12540027499198914,
-0.3151620030403137,
1.0102009773254395,
-0.5980711579322815,
-0.33733806014060974,
0.1528741866350174,
-0.05783332511782646,
0.15005533397197723,
-0.7046036124229431,
0.44410473108291626,
-0.28144535422325134,
0.05727330222725868,
-0.222686767578125,
-0.4633692502975464,
0.020139463245868683,
0.16550567746162415,
-0.761271595954895,
0.9509164690971375,
0.12543243169784546,
-0.9964865446090698,
0.135965034365654,
-0.4319225251674652,
-0.5799816846847534,
0.26132044196128845,
-0.40609458088874817,
-0.6863951683044434,
0.037277884781360626,
0.6844087839126587,
0.693408191204071,
0.2821652293205261,
-0.03466702252626419,
-0.5713483691215515,
-0.2861410081386566,
-0.07386273145675659,
-0.19749344885349274,
0.5800642371177673,
0.30022871494293213,
-0.18617811799049377,
0.23849914968013763,
-0.611676037311554,
-0.23805704712867737,
0.2188958376646042,
-0.15797145664691925,
-0.710264265537262,
0.08469076454639435,
-0.12304133176803589,
0.08073172718286514,
0.19930461049079895,
-0.4449000358581543,
0.02433537133038044,
-0.7559851408004761,
0.15610285103321075,
0.6068800687789917,
0.2144135981798172,
0.3280169665813446,
-0.5102639198303223,
0.25931516289711,
0.2946942150592804,
0.012427901849150658,
-0.46995142102241516,
-0.39867761731147766,
-0.5270090103149414,
-0.3684340715408325,
0.2852756381034851,
0.2870418429374695,
-1.2334797382354736,
0.5139094591140747,
-0.09318184107542038,
-0.3365524113178253,
-0.9474438428878784,
0.3854009509086609,
0.3256707489490509,
0.3844605088233948,
0.8531036376953125,
0.022737419232726097,
-0.4666430354118347,
-0.6605703830718994,
-0.36788374185562134,
0.026628321036696434,
-0.1138116717338562,
0.2783864438533783,
0.3021288812160492,
-0.6170512437820435,
0.28412675857543945,
-0.5527236461639404,
-0.456980437040329,
-0.3338010013103485,
0.260628879070282,
-0.027260322123765945,
0.7509223818778992,
0.6227144002914429,
-0.8945876955986023,
-0.7400140166282654,
0.31252193450927734,
-0.7347773909568787,
-0.28319084644317627,
0.03713781014084816,
0.34110745787620544,
-0.09834302216768265,
0.6573911905288696,
0.21539907157421112,
0.4549316167831421,
0.840884804725647,
-0.23724351823329926,
0.26464080810546875,
-0.3399195969104767,
0.25846925377845764,
-1.1688437461853027,
-0.2195664495229721,
0.5582242608070374,
-0.5859577059745789,
-0.6952623724937439,
0.08413898199796677,
0.21258822083473206,
-0.10681794583797455,
-0.2052190601825714,
0.6642194986343384,
-0.39862436056137085,
0.405880868434906,
-0.5462415218353271,
0.0394228994846344,
0.004439547657966614,
0.0026526451110839844,
-0.1554001122713089,
0.5626064538955688,
0.6199655532836914,
-0.532630443572998,
0.08244118094444275,
-0.26262903213500977,
-0.11479856818914413,
0.293407678604126,
-0.5574418306350708,
-0.05053544044494629,
-0.45759013295173645,
0.08030382543802261,
-1.1846686601638794,
-0.19261416792869568,
0.4985239505767822,
-0.6595814824104309,
0.2635675370693207,
0.2003161907196045,
-0.39296969771385193,
-0.3633143901824951,
-0.5151722431182861,
0.3982390761375427,
0.3031611144542694,
-0.9462624192237854,
0.675923764705658,
0.4955228567123413,
-0.013158832676708698,
-0.36623355746269226,
-0.8468872904777527,
-0.19703562557697296,
-0.14027824997901917,
-0.43177226185798645,
0.6840397715568542,
-0.0802595317363739,
-0.023351583629846573,
0.18165230751037598,
-0.3225693106651306,
-0.09291777014732361,
0.026999033987522125,
0.0077135805040597916,
-0.07463886588811874,
-0.009271752089262009,
0.6604695916175842,
0.2905157804489136,
0.07576051354408264,
-0.24211667478084564,
0.18355600535869598,
0.5150420069694519,
0.07245171070098877,
-0.33989959955215454,
-0.584075927734375,
0.4512043595314026,
0.033092863857746124,
-0.3257735073566437,
0.4547567665576935,
0.7593144178390503,
-0.582542359828949,
-0.3579038679599762,
-0.5622883439064026,
-0.4518112242221832,
-0.564699113368988,
0.2544853985309601,
-0.2903822958469391,
-1.0283156633377075,
0.39398881793022156,
-0.2561502456665039,
-0.2936047911643982,
0.49011772871017456,
0.21897125244140625,
-0.32210832834243774,
1.0594875812530518,
0.8221769332885742,
-0.27805790305137634,
0.6424107551574707,
-0.16199460625648499,
-0.0005012983456254005,
-0.6911860108375549,
-0.02740621380507946,
-0.35162100195884705,
-0.016586244106292725,
-0.8520481586456299,
-0.6888241171836853,
0.40400585532188416,
0.05424267053604126,
0.24830828607082367,
0.013871054165065289,
-0.7989822030067444,
0.49752077460289,
0.3176944851875305,
0.9561806917190552,
0.2539353370666504,
0.11344079673290253,
-0.21812626719474792,
-0.24840161204338074,
-0.633492648601532,
-0.16338536143302917,
1.1725361347198486,
0.4136362075805664,
0.6429319977760315,
0.022216802462935448,
1.1796393394470215,
0.6751160025596619,
0.6791394948959351,
-0.3277270495891571,
0.167220801115036,
-0.7527192234992981,
-0.3268141746520996,
-0.13556425273418427,
-0.5713218450546265,
-1.0852855443954468,
0.3682204484939575,
-0.4830203056335449,
-0.6036551594734192,
0.25147855281829834,
0.4532681703567505,
-0.43036407232284546,
0.12753133475780487,
-0.7056905627250671,
0.7627362012863159,
-0.2974371612071991,
-0.35121050477027893,
-0.34447139501571655,
-0.6435641646385193,
0.2890857756137848,
0.06273642927408218,
0.34966734051704407,
-0.1940375566482544,
0.0668821707367897,
0.5573209524154663,
-0.09947289526462555,
1.1604557037353516,
0.13413158059120178,
-0.03216179832816124,
-0.09688282012939453,
-0.20833338797092438,
0.2510625422000885,
0.037383098155260086,
-0.23927795886993408,
-0.015529834665358067,
-0.12331081926822662,
-0.6077675819396973,
-0.530353844165802,
0.9621800780296326,
-0.6361051797866821,
-0.5456521511077881,
-0.47525742650032043,
-0.2465406209230423,
-0.02024327777326107,
0.2587929964065552,
-0.07842154800891876,
0.21794968843460083,
-0.18811152875423431,
0.10235194861888885,
0.6703236103057861,
-0.39341628551483154,
0.2774980962276459,
0.5330451130867004,
-0.3848412036895752,
-0.513001024723053,
1.1938809156417847,
-0.07815270870923996,
0.248921200633049,
0.3485487997531891,
0.6069797277450562,
-0.33346694707870483,
-0.5447348952293396,
0.07744237035512924,
0.556133508682251,
-0.9783201217651367,
-0.23584313690662384,
-0.7476586699485779,
-0.20604875683784485,
-0.8458511233329773,
0.0038274740800261497,
-0.05474080517888069,
0.06394089758396149,
-0.7942138314247131,
-0.09607011824846268,
0.2998826205730438,
0.7398597002029419,
-0.5770745873451233,
0.3618125915527344,
-0.6982280015945435,
0.7815154790878296,
0.38396650552749634,
0.28556254506111145,
-0.0677298903465271,
-0.4679572284221649,
-0.14083154499530792,
0.13288231194019318,
-0.34403935074806213,
-1.225530743598938,
0.5326975584030151,
0.2320016473531723,
0.5992294549942017,
0.6608730554580688,
0.22599893808364868,
0.5756624937057495,
-0.06715521216392517,
0.35865119099617004,
0.34290841221809387,
-0.7019976377487183,
0.7575106024742126,
-0.27934256196022034,
0.37388595938682556,
0.7087369561195374,
0.7930628061294556,
-0.450061172246933,
-0.3383014500141144,
-0.4847722053527832,
-0.5239367485046387,
0.19600586593151093,
0.05443456768989563,
0.2809051275253296,
-0.3247390389442444,
0.2574745714664459,
-0.12324538826942444,
-0.2037002146244049,
-0.9817363023757935,
-0.47027164697647095,
-0.29258838295936584,
-0.43452808260917664,
-0.15452350676059723,
-0.3183135986328125,
0.10072236508131027,
-0.4975820481777191,
0.5879243612289429,
-0.30031806230545044,
-0.12886273860931396,
0.5292326211929321,
-0.008987821638584137,
-0.05601087212562561,
0.01040899008512497,
0.1775594800710678,
0.4387430250644684,
-0.11968102306127548,
0.46377986669540405,
0.08837538957595825,
-0.14602455496788025,
-0.28995463252067566,
0.5394447445869446,
-0.027204878628253937,
0.2777354121208191,
0.3928871154785156,
0.38673320412635803,
0.2216082513332367,
-0.48778605461120605,
0.6819770932197571,
0.21575796604156494,
0.1072315201163292,
0.19416075944900513,
0.001513927010819316,
0.2791779041290283,
0.30084550380706787,
0.37620946764945984,
-0.1046425923705101,
0.5825509428977966,
-0.5762268304824829,
0.5105780363082886,
0.4079190790653229,
-0.6982974410057068,
-0.19689609110355377,
0.4489322602748871,
0.5154787302017212,
-0.17546303570270538,
0.035427674651145935,
-0.30194804072380066,
-0.4480544626712799,
0.4899902641773224,
0.7058345675468445,
0.4310503304004669,
-0.8941568732261658,
0.4639753997325897,
0.4483490288257599,
0.3225831985473633,
0.13007128238677979,
0.2895735800266266,
-0.020690836012363434,
-0.8252878785133362,
-0.42292138934135437,
-0.4941323399543762,
-0.08366560935974121,
0.4725593626499176,
-0.4071422219276428,
0.33489349484443665,
-0.14385508000850677,
-0.03325901925563812,
0.5892519354820251,
0.04278581216931343,
-0.40101027488708496,
0.5546873807907104,
0.2421032041311264,
0.6420773863792419,
-1.155226707458496,
0.8899526596069336,
0.5536296963691711,
-0.46375519037246704,
-0.4550583064556122,
0.414813369512558,
-0.08610732108354568,
-0.7674946188926697,
0.49632707238197327,
0.684372067451477,
-0.16793964803218842,
-0.10451528429985046,
-0.42383548617362976,
-0.7163525223731995,
0.6357687711715698,
0.24163484573364258,
-0.6581467390060425,
0.01394206378608942,
0.0034274887293577194,
0.723767101764679,
-0.45504558086395264,
0.13273972272872925,
0.2990928590297699,
0.08496581017971039,
0.01808839850127697,
-0.6451802849769592,
0.07586702704429626,
-0.28008896112442017,
-0.03133509308099747,
0.010427703149616718,
-0.37839579582214355,
0.5224034190177917,
-0.31774070858955383,
-0.5588880181312561,
-0.19270236790180206,
0.8458700180053711,
0.21979767084121704,
0.4273025691509247,
0.3892003893852234,
0.4268944263458252,
0.8109074234962463,
0.25988176465034485,
0.8642045855522156,
-0.4017963707447052,
0.36757954955101013,
1.2014901638031006,
-0.013497890904545784,
0.7074829339981079,
0.15940232574939728,
0.06723223626613617,
0.6318793296813965,
0.6987483501434326,
0.03189321234822273,
0.6198399662971497,
0.24520553648471832,
-0.4441151022911072,
-0.4043929874897003,
-0.25509896874427795,
-0.4848599433898926,
0.20936167240142822,
0.6739429235458374,
-0.8919275999069214,
-0.5188217163085938,
0.22583533823490143,
-0.023750053718686104,
0.6736183762550354,
-0.44104060530662537,
0.8282569050788879,
0.09797444939613342,
-0.1689043790102005,
0.6057806611061096,
-0.10045714676380157,
0.9111695289611816,
-0.28265827894210815,
-0.4069903790950775,
-0.12593427300453186,
0.17561037838459015,
-0.2837927043437958,
-0.6387655138969421,
0.49177977442741394,
-0.43108153343200684,
-0.0010930467396974564,
0.07192628085613251,
1.1921461820602417,
-0.780173122882843,
-0.7518348693847656,
0.7316311001777649,
0.5085905194282532,
0.08206447958946228,
-0.1789512038230896,
-0.9457982182502747,
0.12615133821964264,
0.09494639188051224,
0.29710057377815247,
0.16046242415905,
0.3260762393474579,
0.12522585690021515,
0.7349247336387634,
0.6182248592376709,
0.20068947970867157,
-0.38584402203559875,
0.17423051595687866,
1.1387908458709717,
-0.41934865713119507,
-0.49148836731910706,
-0.9550195336341858,
0.1656169891357422,
-0.4921824634075165,
-0.03818688541650772,
0.7027530670166016,
0.578170895576477,
0.7485222220420837,
0.07920060306787491,
0.8695222735404968,
0.4162539839744568,
0.987515389919281,
-0.35533955693244934,
0.8037309646606445,
-0.8405594229698181,
0.17718720436096191,
-0.23335358500480652,
-0.011779900640249252,
-0.6283217072486877,
0.5774747133255005,
-0.3366032540798187,
-0.030308207497000694,
0.7325541377067566,
0.7284020781517029,
-0.06221093237400055,
-0.2650848627090454,
0.41954901814460754,
0.13434520363807678,
0.16621845960617065,
0.24217748641967773,
0.44542497396469116,
-0.30437925457954407,
0.3533521890640259,
-0.5819720029830933,
-0.40667128562927246,
-0.42455238103866577,
-0.6304842233657837,
-1.2579693794250488,
-0.4975196123123169,
-0.5530221462249756,
-0.4909805655479431,
0.524893045425415,
0.9584691524505615,
0.7768290638923645,
-0.8660508990287781,
0.18703453242778778,
0.17279300093650818,
0.17017781734466553,
-0.28558164834976196,
-0.17894726991653442,
0.6859134435653687,
-0.4464702308177948,
-0.5335081815719604,
0.45365819334983826,
0.1996646374464035,
0.1566721498966217,
-0.1412881314754486,
0.1670682728290558,
-0.39303866028785706,
-0.05141233280301094,
0.6542285680770874,
0.301484614610672,
-0.5591954588890076,
-0.14232364296913147,
-0.26318931579589844,
-0.266150563955307,
0.35397765040397644,
0.43625742197036743,
-0.8135178685188293,
0.7219128608703613,
0.3915737569332123,
0.7001562714576721,
0.5322999954223633,
0.40019258856773376,
0.20815880596637726,
-0.7826547622680664,
-0.13838067650794983,
0.38354647159576416,
0.23742221295833588,
0.7799274325370789,
-0.5229544043540955,
0.2861112952232361,
0.2749946415424347,
-0.277305006980896,
-0.5440565347671509,
0.23311369121074677,
-0.8739355802536011,
-0.7074523568153381,
1.1673738956451416,
-0.03255666792392731,
-0.17689159512519836,
-0.3571394681930542,
-0.14376623928546906,
0.4221576750278473,
-0.4983951151371002,
1.1596490144729614,
0.04345712810754776,
-0.21883024275302887,
-0.34625059366226196,
-0.12354342639446259,
0.6600989699363708,
0.32132723927497864,
-1.0108225345611572,
-0.1318507045507431,
0.243297278881073,
0.4307178556919098,
0.19862239062786102,
0.9102343320846558,
-0.013951950706541538,
0.31769078969955444,
-0.3786708414554596,
0.10416898131370544,
0.20778010785579681,
-0.14573217928409576,
-0.5277913808822632,
-0.027373380959033966,
-0.3579935133457184,
-0.3110879957675934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19597v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19597v1
|
Transferring Troubles: Cross-Lingual Transferability of Backdoor Attacks in LLMs with Instruction Tuning
| 2024-04-30T14:43:57 | 2024-04-30T14:43:57 |
Xuanli He, Jun Wang, Qiongkai Xu, Pasquale Minervini, Pontus Stenetorp, Benjamin I. P. Rubinstein, Trevor Cohn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
The implications of backdoor attacks on English-centric large language models
(LLMs) have been widely examined - such attacks can be achieved by embedding
malicious behaviors during training and activated under specific conditions
that trigger malicious outputs. However, the impact of backdoor attacks on
multilingual models remains under-explored. Our research focuses on
cross-lingual backdoor attacks against multilingual LLMs, particularly
investigating how poisoning the instruction-tuning data in one or two languages
can affect the outputs in languages whose instruction-tuning data was not
poisoned. Despite its simplicity, our empirical analysis reveals that our
method exhibits remarkable efficacy in models like mT5, BLOOM, and
GPT-3.5-turbo, with high attack success rates, surpassing 95% in several
languages across various scenarios. Alarmingly, our findings also indicate that
larger models show increased susceptibility to transferable cross-lingual
backdoor attacks, which also applies to LLMs predominantly pre-trained on
English data, such as Llama2, Llama3, and Gemma. Moreover, our experiments show
that triggers can still work even after paraphrasing, and the backdoor
mechanism proves highly effective in cross-lingual response settings across 25
languages, achieving an average attack success rate of 50%. Our study aims to
highlight the vulnerabilities and significant security risks present in current
multilingual LLMs, underscoring the emergent need for targeted security
measures.
|
[
-0.053303152322769165,
-0.6914516091346741,
0.29346758127212524,
0.31790080666542053,
0.11915786564350128,
0.17293991148471832,
-0.22991421818733215,
-0.6630761623382568,
-0.09881503880023956,
0.5770989060401917,
-0.608380138874054,
-0.6492461562156677,
-0.759147584438324,
0.05771913379430771,
-0.463056743144989,
1.046006679534912,
-0.001936099142767489,
0.19828259944915771,
0.12739545106887817,
0.08139370381832123,
-0.6545739769935608,
-0.8276158571243286,
-0.6134788990020752,
-0.13467881083488464,
0.6714505553245544,
0.38191190361976624,
0.6613531708717346,
0.15314660966396332,
0.5206893682479858,
0.25722232460975647,
0.23316948115825653,
-0.3737914562225342,
-0.7353746294975281,
0.14520969986915588,
-0.3927878141403198,
-0.7577434182167053,
-0.32858970761299133,
-0.11596103012561798,
0.4704371690750122,
0.33384251594543457,
-0.1201326847076416,
0.037842072546482086,
0.023336486890912056,
0.48979997634887695,
-0.6041250824928284,
-0.1439131647348404,
-1.0512199401855469,
0.26084405183792114,
-0.3775870203971863,
-0.37255749106407166,
-0.7090614438056946,
-0.1400151401758194,
-0.2606421113014221,
-0.37712767720222473,
0.01534876599907875,
0.12945301830768585,
0.6333404779434204,
-0.008795657195150852,
-0.29237663745880127,
-0.4235093891620636,
-0.34209808707237244,
0.7529296875,
-0.633823812007904,
0.6685304045677185,
0.3279206156730652,
0.171688511967659,
-0.14100037515163422,
-0.5349283218383789,
-0.17650505900382996,
-0.2706066966056824,
-0.16968658566474915,
-0.005693653132766485,
-0.5038946866989136,
-0.2601107358932495,
0.252061128616333,
0.2133045494556427,
-0.7573265433311462,
0.49665147066116333,
-0.49853765964508057,
-0.5142168998718262,
0.5409110188484192,
0.26449859142303467,
0.7031784653663635,
0.14412017166614532,
-0.3713855445384979,
-0.1392933577299118,
-1.2930208444595337,
0.010209844447672367,
0.7236605882644653,
0.3811141848564148,
-0.28577920794487,
0.3175337314605713,
0.30220910906791687,
0.4409368634223938,
-0.03234325349330902,
-0.16996929049491882,
-0.03421875089406967,
-0.48704060912132263,
0.09496216475963593,
0.16779178380966187,
0.661479115486145,
0.3519834280014038,
0.31698769330978394,
-0.5568268895149231,
-0.24233342707157135,
-0.240679532289505,
0.2908001244068146,
-0.8505734801292419,
-0.14677566289901733,
0.15926595032215118,
-0.18802224099636078,
-0.30780550837516785,
0.017702696844935417,
-0.9885202050209045,
-0.20836924016475677,
0.3827175796031952,
0.5035334825515747,
-0.5262368321418762,
-0.20208050310611725,
0.04981091991066933,
0.046227890998125076,
0.5362676978111267,
0.05611995980143547,
-0.9699631929397583,
0.11623047292232513,
0.8717367649078369,
0.7899361252784729,
-0.43506139516830444,
-0.7874962687492371,
-0.6530044674873352,
0.43168431520462036,
-0.49857649207115173,
0.38507574796676636,
-0.6461976766586304,
-0.6123781800270081,
0.222852423787117,
0.4163016676902771,
-0.3869616389274597,
-0.37099236249923706,
0.047912128269672394,
-0.7964648008346558,
0.2727527320384979,
-0.23747149109840393,
-0.16918917000293732,
-0.06795467436313629,
0.4019542634487152,
-0.5700742602348328,
0.6339468955993652,
-0.37995675206184387,
-0.7622336745262146,
-0.11685814708471298,
-0.18952451646327972,
-0.9114320874214172,
-0.2766246199607849,
0.04976338893175125,
-0.2505670487880707,
0.07748148590326309,
0.08849909901618958,
0.44111812114715576,
-0.15653836727142334,
-0.21156403422355652,
-0.23549267649650574,
-0.319055438041687,
0.36863675713539124,
-0.6592616438865662,
0.9831348061561584,
0.023856621235609055,
-0.3837907314300537,
-0.1519996076822281,
-0.5993692278862,
-0.13817007839679718,
0.17726723849773407,
-0.1942979246377945,
-0.49873197078704834,
-0.39925825595855713,
-0.28061071038246155,
0.32537975907325745,
0.34460219740867615,
-0.5595162510871887,
0.15035699307918549,
-0.4024909436702728,
0.20813919603824615,
0.7034265398979187,
0.09364885836839676,
0.19354870915412903,
-0.23766957223415375,
0.9525465965270996,
0.08415859937667847,
0.190819650888443,
-0.40477216243743896,
-0.6082744598388672,
-0.27474695444107056,
-0.04920176416635513,
0.20094124972820282,
1.0180633068084717,
-0.833895742893219,
-0.13672876358032227,
-0.18347059190273285,
-0.520205557346344,
-0.42477136850357056,
0.14387807250022888,
0.8180063962936401,
0.27302902936935425,
0.14991718530654907,
-0.10274612903594971,
-0.11783631145954132,
-0.725555956363678,
-0.6382986307144165,
-0.05225474759936333,
0.24543632566928864,
0.2124684751033783,
0.5996286869049072,
-0.2506787180900574,
0.17286880314350128,
-0.38128945231437683,
-0.16778405010700226,
-0.08781366050243378,
0.04235593229532242,
0.012054909020662308,
0.5143316388130188,
0.7362241148948669,
-0.5133268237113953,
-0.7230835556983948,
0.30463317036628723,
-0.567184329032898,
-0.18381884694099426,
-0.16257670521736145,
-0.1963101476430893,
0.34304702281951904,
0.6683900952339172,
-0.5014117360115051,
0.3884703814983368,
0.9294365048408508,
-0.22365254163742065,
0.6867673993110657,
-0.0094748605042696,
0.2698584794998169,
-1.2887358665466309,
-0.14653342962265015,
-0.25692465901374817,
0.04624151811003685,
-0.7448400855064392,
0.41907548904418945,
0.32798823714256287,
-0.28878942131996155,
-0.7896878123283386,
0.5764726996421814,
-0.5621052384376526,
-0.18534567952156067,
0.11911492049694061,
-0.09316063672304153,
0.006847566459327936,
0.5999400019645691,
-0.25939664244651794,
1.054367184638977,
0.7479808330535889,
-0.36443763971328735,
0.5465282201766968,
-0.041038308292627335,
-0.08540208637714386,
0.6596683263778687,
-0.5315607786178589,
0.3034365773200989,
0.37407100200653076,
-0.013678550720214844,
-1.0769282579421997,
-0.06879136711359024,
0.5380735993385315,
-0.5763424038887024,
0.9173822402954102,
-0.3938952386379242,
-0.32371145486831665,
0.07952100783586502,
-0.4903714656829834,
0.32905641198158264,
0.2475285530090332,
-0.6341915130615234,
0.5763164758682251,
0.07088728249073029,
-0.40420836210250854,
-0.8023829460144043,
-0.9804815649986267,
0.4238923490047455,
-0.3872990310192108,
-0.766700267791748,
0.30395928025245667,
0.05214855447411537,
-0.14888566732406616,
-0.14537255465984344,
0.032322000712156296,
0.026513120159506798,
0.18977759778499603,
0.11875082552433014,
0.13873867690563202,
-0.2597789168357849,
-0.17122545838356018,
0.1425613909959793,
-0.007327538449317217,
0.40235164761543274,
-0.15856924653053284,
0.41955557465553284,
0.01603385992348194,
-0.7101012468338013,
-0.26074665784835815,
0.7035083770751953,
0.7774474620819092,
-0.29416725039482117,
0.8991891145706177,
0.5357683897018433,
-0.16611348092556,
-0.14440491795539856,
-0.3165273070335388,
-0.29708436131477356,
-0.4770875871181488,
0.6196867227554321,
-0.7165785431861877,
-0.6115207076072693,
0.7965462803840637,
0.2445099800825119,
0.29753780364990234,
0.0803690105676651,
0.6175927519798279,
0.21948674321174622,
1.0508285760879517,
0.7218040823936462,
-0.2103763222694397,
0.3294731378555298,
0.10187956690788269,
0.18448090553283691,
-0.6488434076309204,
-0.21188440918922424,
-0.5828210115432739,
-0.10653506964445114,
-0.843734622001648,
-0.04055846482515335,
0.1912004053592682,
-0.2867915630340576,
0.023800350725650787,
0.24071896076202393,
0.03886331617832184,
0.46546226739883423,
0.29241445660591125,
-0.13705937564373016,
0.39153507351875305,
0.11668805032968521,
-0.23469527065753937,
-0.14998134970664978,
-0.7386411428451538,
-0.0946483165025711,
1.182555913925171,
0.4853064715862274,
1.2400041818618774,
0.49727359414100647,
0.6778419613838196,
-0.032771166414022446,
0.2617839276790619,
-0.572579026222229,
0.4232938289642334,
-0.23528453707695007,
-0.7236314415931702,
-0.05878085270524025,
-0.4489181637763977,
-1.2416608333587646,
0.23424914479255676,
0.18393217027187347,
-0.9030093550682068,
0.07230813056230545,
0.016197582706809044,
-0.20386362075805664,
0.6001473665237427,
-0.7815134525299072,
0.9203629493713379,
-0.5674186944961548,
-0.5158990025520325,
-0.24289925396442413,
-0.6975699067115784,
0.6694309115409851,
-0.5326620936393738,
0.38204652070999146,
0.17693570256233215,
-0.01675689034163952,
0.7311657071113586,
-0.10317366570234299,
1.1089773178100586,
0.04422128200531006,
-0.8279040455818176,
-0.4798949956893921,
0.39895516633987427,
0.6986357569694519,
0.05558660253882408,
0.2034018337726593,
0.7214496731758118,
0.21643108129501343,
-0.39099952578544617,
-0.652611255645752,
0.9306673407554626,
-0.664989709854126,
-1.201856255531311,
-0.433430939912796,
-0.5535334944725037,
-0.33195972442626953,
0.07140704989433289,
0.5526926517486572,
0.29181498289108276,
0.17162761092185974,
0.12518459558486938,
0.7610777020454407,
-0.5809792876243591,
0.42155176401138306,
0.8538053631782532,
-0.37030932307243347,
-0.27775999903678894,
1.1406079530715942,
0.1648036539554596,
0.6072722673416138,
0.39447906613349915,
0.09570832550525665,
0.04254484176635742,
-0.5013749599456787,
-0.614741861820221,
0.3647608458995819,
-0.6581562757492065,
-0.23036715388298035,
-0.37224870920181274,
-0.3384820818901062,
-0.5473666191101074,
-0.07259412109851837,
-0.5291937589645386,
-0.19862563908100128,
-0.15085382759571075,
0.03199681267142296,
0.4131675362586975,
0.5924758315086365,
-0.11364144831895828,
0.2932908236980438,
-1.1432186365127563,
0.08882473409175873,
0.32125696539878845,
0.22474569082260132,
0.022158166393637657,
-0.825042724609375,
-0.524124026298523,
-0.03034382499754429,
-0.21443305909633636,
-1.3940380811691284,
0.39570188522338867,
0.09769926965236664,
0.5447129607200623,
0.19335037469863892,
-0.08460378646850586,
0.4833272099494934,
-0.5930582284927368,
0.7882781624794006,
0.07216154038906097,
-0.7390048503875732,
0.31249675154685974,
-0.19855019450187683,
0.03658764436841011,
0.2343786656856537,
0.6167850494384766,
-0.7097377777099609,
-0.5621927976608276,
-0.32153648138046265,
-0.7706846594810486,
0.7901991605758667,
-0.06050296500325203,
0.37222135066986084,
0.346821665763855,
0.11327166855335236,
0.3324052691459656,
0.07902377098798752,
-0.7335770130157471,
-0.3116951882839203,
-0.10446900874376297,
0.050705377012491226,
-0.01577857695519924,
-0.2055884748697281,
-0.17911332845687866,
0.052883170545101166,
0.7123004794120789,
0.133761465549469,
-0.032425373792648315,
-0.19390591979026794,
-0.38361847400665283,
-0.0787300169467926,
0.38796183466911316,
0.6671236753463745,
0.44643113017082214,
0.2184845209121704,
0.1384705901145935,
0.3954969048500061,
-0.834036111831665,
0.28399425745010376,
0.10586252063512802,
-0.07180511206388474,
-0.16210044920444489,
0.6274064183235168,
0.5895090699195862,
0.5368742346763611,
-0.4020789861679077,
0.432313472032547,
-0.22661073505878448,
0.11486553400754929,
-0.06221074238419533,
-0.00965837575495243,
-0.023187754675745964,
0.2694825232028961,
0.2443324774503708,
-0.27720940113067627,
-0.16591978073120117,
-0.7940755486488342,
0.10775911062955856,
0.5998151302337646,
-0.2082146555185318,
-0.6523681282997131,
0.2507529556751251,
0.11870833486318588,
-0.44471248984336853,
0.47175878286361694,
0.18391858041286469,
-0.9119832515716553,
0.4489053189754486,
0.942251980304718,
0.9196635484695435,
-0.6877615451812744,
-0.26152709126472473,
-0.108952596783638,
0.7557552456855774,
0.28078681230545044,
0.012796658091247082,
0.09065566211938858,
-0.7230185270309448,
-0.29664719104766846,
-0.30472150444984436,
-0.5143522620201111,
0.12362345308065414,
-0.7259342074394226,
0.010484685190021992,
-0.23114901781082153,
0.10830869525671005,
-0.42903774976730347,
-0.1250641644001007,
-0.33106735348701477,
-0.1646900475025177,
0.29578277468681335,
0.8176435828208923,
-1.0244359970092773,
0.9494040608406067,
0.599790632724762,
-0.09614967554807663,
-0.7333008646965027,
0.3080640733242035,
-0.0339188277721405,
-1.1339060068130493,
0.7127452492713928,
0.06468328833580017,
-0.3791552782058716,
0.03038177825510502,
-0.3245680034160614,
-0.8943424224853516,
0.7742988467216492,
0.5013557076454163,
-0.722197413444519,
-0.11424193531274796,
0.2647048234939575,
0.23577825725078583,
-0.028167393058538437,
-0.27102482318878174,
0.7422122359275818,
0.5465668439865112,
0.015488991513848305,
-0.9095376133918762,
0.1112435981631279,
-0.22043095529079437,
-0.2548559308052063,
0.2364834100008011,
-0.6863175630569458,
0.9423856139183044,
-0.13117727637290955,
-0.26861703395843506,
-0.18387746810913086,
0.3708406388759613,
0.24980618059635162,
0.3617455065250397,
0.1408257633447647,
0.6460135579109192,
0.491007536649704,
0.03908354789018631,
1.039035677909851,
-0.7175297141075134,
-0.15588660538196564,
0.9981762766838074,
-0.49212217330932617,
0.8036637306213379,
0.5648270845413208,
-0.0778089389204979,
0.41943982243537903,
0.4828260540962219,
-0.01072563137859106,
0.5717604160308838,
-0.034387603402137756,
0.07796470820903778,
0.2024756371974945,
0.22255469858646393,
-0.7386590242385864,
0.37819740176200867,
0.5207604169845581,
-0.13936586678028107,
-0.18733246624469757,
0.32048454880714417,
0.4870641231536865,
-0.22707250714302063,
-0.3514082133769989,
0.6451952457427979,
0.21709312498569489,
-0.696946918964386,
0.6139591336250305,
0.15375560522079468,
0.8010400533676147,
-0.7666444182395935,
0.13609378039836884,
-0.5337790250778198,
0.04415320232510567,
-0.32638993859291077,
-0.775272011756897,
0.3549423813819885,
0.13154855370521545,
0.09985609352588654,
-0.17756667733192444,
0.5971871018409729,
-0.5457728505134583,
-0.32775869965553284,
0.6003972291946411,
0.3967339098453522,
0.24910970032215118,
0.04986507445573807,
-0.6558475494384766,
0.2445565015077591,
0.1125536784529686,
-0.43175187706947327,
0.7153553366661072,
0.5982323884963989,
-0.11428806185722351,
0.6166993379592896,
0.7133668065071106,
0.4406591057777405,
0.4567195475101471,
-0.03550288453698158,
0.7304162979125977,
-0.7095040082931519,
-0.5069617629051208,
-1.1374849081039429,
0.17910797894001007,
0.25159990787506104,
-0.06239621341228485,
1.343970775604248,
0.43609803915023804,
1.0359641313552856,
0.05217697098851204,
0.6722710728645325,
0.4454963207244873,
0.13191105425357819,
-0.8745688796043396,
0.8766040205955505,
-0.6038002967834473,
0.6158616542816162,
-0.23529571294784546,
-0.6102688312530518,
-0.10392150282859802,
0.09222094714641571,
-0.48975035548210144,
0.0935695469379425,
0.7753861546516418,
1.1029906272888184,
-0.04316993057727814,
-0.11971677839756012,
0.5876353979110718,
0.4297732710838318,
0.34485533833503723,
0.8413304090499878,
0.9901756644248962,
-0.3137606978416443,
0.8482487201690674,
-0.22678616642951965,
-0.014887426048517227,
-0.21016837656497955,
-0.7268653512001038,
-0.99775230884552,
-0.1902196854352951,
-0.20448076725006104,
-0.42899978160858154,
0.46807947754859924,
0.33102598786354065,
0.4337732791900635,
-0.8341993689537048,
-0.3261409103870392,
0.3910042643547058,
0.39500176906585693,
-0.04724172502756119,
-0.19251857697963715,
0.2418583780527115,
-0.34898078441619873,
-0.5398504137992859,
0.4846383035182953,
0.2686058580875397,
0.06286276131868362,
-0.5970009565353394,
-0.0588945671916008,
-0.02987968549132347,
0.0772726833820343,
0.37913814187049866,
0.3994697034358978,
-0.6264471411705017,
-0.23017245531082153,
0.06712676584720612,
-0.3753964900970459,
-0.060762543231248856,
0.7155554890632629,
-0.2784155309200287,
0.1061820387840271,
0.32157981395721436,
0.8528205752372742,
0.190029576420784,
-0.37716832756996155,
0.784188985824585,
-1.0147738456726074,
0.32624131441116333,
0.008850221522152424,
0.3516542315483093,
0.37706658244132996,
-0.5953108668327332,
0.1618441641330719,
0.2832799255847931,
-0.3012497127056122,
-1.0269700288772583,
0.39557594060897827,
-0.34450578689575195,
-0.5438979268074036,
1.2975807189941406,
-0.48422279953956604,
-0.4563080966472626,
-0.08055926859378815,
-0.034060653299093246,
0.006342187523841858,
-0.15733496844768524,
0.7288661003112793,
0.8848467469215393,
0.3284291625022888,
-0.12454868108034134,
-0.5951092839241028,
0.3856423497200012,
0.5151022672653198,
-0.7520476579666138,
0.22332966327667236,
0.1983402967453003,
0.39075639843940735,
0.1481168419122696,
-0.096647709608078,
-0.2898033857345581,
0.43554913997650146,
0.03949031978845596,
-0.20503643155097961,
-0.10693027079105377,
-0.5788612961769104,
-0.6514133214950562,
0.2785544693470001,
-0.055026888847351074,
-0.15201742947101593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19563v1
|
RepEval: Effective Text Evaluation with LLM Representation
| 2024-04-30T13:50:55 | 2024-04-30T13:50:55 |
Shuqian Sheng, Yi Xu, Tianhang Zhang, Zanwei Shen, Luoyi Fu, Jiaxin Ding, Lei Zhou, Xinbing Wang, Chenghu Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic evaluation metrics for generated texts play an important role in
the NLG field, especially with the rapid growth of LLMs. However, existing
metrics are often limited to specific scenarios, making it challenging to meet
the evaluation requirements of expanding LLM applications. Therefore, there is
a demand for new, flexible, and effective metrics. In this study, we introduce
RepEval, the first metric leveraging the projection of LLM representations for
evaluation. RepEval requires minimal sample pairs for training, and through
simple prompt modifications, it can easily transition to various tasks. Results
on ten datasets from three tasks demonstrate the high effectiveness of our
method, which exhibits stronger correlations with human judgments compared to
previous metrics, even outperforming GPT-4. Our work underscores the richness
of information regarding text quality embedded within LLM representations,
offering insights for the development of new metrics.
|
[
-0.135240837931633,
-0.24108180403709412,
0.4563981592655182,
0.34918293356895447,
-0.47423455119132996,
0.31346651911735535,
-0.3278093636035919,
-0.28432878851890564,
0.25751906633377075,
0.16106535494327545,
-0.28916919231414795,
-1.0653825998306274,
-0.739136278629303,
0.2969376742839813,
-0.538998544216156,
0.9443193674087524,
-0.2169908732175827,
0.00018562465265858918,
-0.36016881465911865,
-0.35074901580810547,
-0.429561585187912,
-0.5695226788520813,
-0.34317776560783386,
-0.44455087184906006,
0.597954273223877,
0.16191834211349487,
0.5073535442352295,
0.5801455974578857,
0.8151635527610779,
0.22219489514827728,
0.24776799976825714,
0.37645915150642395,
-0.6166415214538574,
0.27141711115837097,
-0.09073271602392197,
-0.3275061547756195,
-0.26392266154289246,
0.42518728971481323,
0.9715821743011475,
0.45433104038238525,
-0.3034866750240326,
0.3797524571418762,
0.4618735611438751,
0.876100480556488,
-0.5072252750396729,
-0.057885125279426575,
-0.511837363243103,
0.22279119491577148,
-0.13288383185863495,
-0.485984206199646,
-0.5630968809127808,
-0.5904850959777832,
0.18503479659557343,
-0.705797553062439,
0.12405470013618469,
0.2415788620710373,
0.8469560146331787,
0.28383588790893555,
-0.24110670387744904,
-0.28369247913360596,
-0.32452717423439026,
1.0002830028533936,
-0.594891369342804,
0.6756824254989624,
0.18706762790679932,
0.347547709941864,
-0.03765374794602394,
-1.1317400932312012,
-0.21580173075199127,
-0.46376216411590576,
-0.15103699266910553,
0.4317140579223633,
-0.1783246248960495,
-0.13197354972362518,
-0.11228745430707932,
0.4010661840438843,
-0.3181631565093994,
0.03633488714694977,
0.13034720718860626,
-0.33626893162727356,
0.5603474974632263,
0.22294414043426514,
0.1412552297115326,
-0.3420636057853699,
-0.6261017322540283,
-0.18296025693416595,
-0.8595635294914246,
-0.40922287106513977,
0.13703954219818115,
0.10396099090576172,
0.1269533932209015,
0.6339457631111145,
0.19724634289741516,
0.5346996784210205,
-0.09278150647878647,
-0.019642608240246773,
0.30599480867385864,
-0.5678662061691284,
-0.33822426199913025,
-0.16828668117523193,
0.9392264485359192,
0.5368030071258545,
-0.18886396288871765,
-0.1320149302482605,
-0.3519480526447296,
-0.1441216915845871,
0.6129804253578186,
-0.7011353373527527,
-0.07341268658638,
-0.31812214851379395,
-0.7603781223297119,
-0.363363653421402,
0.19752658903598785,
-0.8110610842704773,
-0.7930319309234619,
-0.16415861248970032,
0.27872076630592346,
-0.44503071904182434,
-0.05361287668347359,
-0.16994933784008026,
0.06086909770965576,
0.2390371561050415,
0.4573288857936859,
-0.6902797818183899,
0.2169138789176941,
0.7159278988838196,
0.9347471594810486,
-0.5470901727676392,
-0.20560146868228912,
-0.6523796916007996,
-0.23844869434833527,
-0.5702876448631287,
0.8097168207168579,
-0.38226303458213806,
-0.47778305411338806,
0.28024813532829285,
-0.20069573819637299,
0.08940199762582779,
-0.4943184554576874,
0.9920967817306519,
-0.496639609336853,
0.28336066007614136,
-0.011811614036560059,
-0.7765376567840576,
-0.06129055842757225,
0.5206151604652405,
-0.6785538196563721,
1.2706856727600098,
0.43451830744743347,
-0.7154635787010193,
0.676685631275177,
-0.4158838391304016,
-0.18594147264957428,
0.18575841188430786,
-0.30004629492759705,
-0.4946126639842987,
0.2940986752510071,
0.33810222148895264,
0.384395033121109,
-0.42276012897491455,
-0.1758991777896881,
0.15663795173168182,
-0.3613540232181549,
0.09768478572368622,
-0.6529728770256042,
0.16790705919265747,
-0.04639798775315285,
-0.019794747233390808,
0.17795297503471375,
-0.5410180687904358,
0.21652111411094666,
-0.15548528730869293,
-0.6404574513435364,
-0.4227883219718933,
-0.05610926076769829,
0.030837399885058403,
-0.32939624786376953,
0.4395366609096527,
-0.4393547475337982,
0.19768846035003662,
-0.604282021522522,
0.0040644495747983456,
0.5067068338394165,
0.023950353264808655,
0.5537263751029968,
-0.22771236300468445,
0.650234580039978,
-0.6262953281402588,
-0.14785367250442505,
-0.20430082082748413,
-0.4015108048915863,
-0.5504243969917297,
-0.07673373818397522,
0.5926700830459595,
0.4020508825778961,
-0.6776993274688721,
0.3886769413948059,
-0.3112559914588928,
-0.7392137050628662,
-0.8431897163391113,
0.246629536151886,
0.5208185315132141,
0.4276468753814697,
0.3730238676071167,
-0.15563014149665833,
-0.5721423029899597,
-0.868439793586731,
-0.648537278175354,
-0.3554808795452118,
-0.27502310276031494,
0.21191813051700592,
0.2570035755634308,
-0.11009498685598373,
0.790924072265625,
-0.31813564896583557,
-0.5360420346260071,
-0.34632572531700134,
0.5334877371788025,
0.27327167987823486,
0.2122436761856079,
0.5288904309272766,
-0.5739424228668213,
-0.5211620926856995,
-0.0539739690721035,
-0.7482519745826721,
-0.3245159089565277,
-0.3528478145599365,
-0.18696489930152893,
0.17018945515155792,
0.350119948387146,
-0.056768838316202164,
0.42337632179260254,
0.76405930519104,
-0.3782941401004791,
0.8307037353515625,
-0.3622798025608063,
0.5037959814071655,
-0.8065477013587952,
-0.17574478685855865,
0.1912207007408142,
-0.451762855052948,
-0.3572236895561218,
-0.0020409924909472466,
0.25615400075912476,
0.2823129892349243,
-0.2832182049751282,
0.5262559652328491,
-0.5383936166763306,
-0.1854851394891739,
-0.10855173319578171,
0.6927428245544434,
0.3130890130996704,
0.03261425346136093,
-0.07946617156267166,
0.9957144856452942,
-0.05936717987060547,
-0.20388329029083252,
0.33734771609306335,
0.2568272650241852,
-0.7671124339103699,
0.7453468441963196,
-0.6373477578163147,
0.22694449126720428,
0.14324600994586945,
0.14355987310409546,
-1.0559709072113037,
0.018744517117738724,
0.13865798711776733,
-0.659401535987854,
0.28574338555336,
0.026380345225334167,
-0.5728172659873962,
-0.20637553930282593,
-0.2860027253627777,
0.2978895902633667,
0.5771873593330383,
-0.8814694285392761,
0.3921116888523102,
0.3783723711967468,
0.18066242337226868,
-0.5780297517776489,
-0.828214704990387,
0.32867005467414856,
-0.23291301727294922,
-0.3988265097141266,
0.7509661912918091,
0.27248209714889526,
-0.09902328252792358,
-0.09914513677358627,
-0.24349044263362885,
0.13693903386592865,
-0.19154492020606995,
0.05723537877202034,
0.2827844023704529,
-0.18746431171894073,
0.28759658336639404,
-0.01189056783914566,
-0.3312157094478607,
0.01375818345695734,
-0.22484725713729858,
0.2581430673599243,
-0.302749365568161,
-0.4893503487110138,
-0.47466766834259033,
0.031091803684830666,
0.16859783232212067,
-0.08109740912914276,
0.5475122332572937,
0.5726144313812256,
-0.2987537682056427,
-0.1194431409239769,
-0.5175365209579468,
0.13015305995941162,
-0.443481981754303,
0.5283564925193787,
-0.020179875195026398,
-0.8082209229469299,
0.14122049510478973,
-0.23989582061767578,
0.20815622806549072,
0.5019142031669617,
0.42209407687187195,
-0.22831237316131592,
0.8732239007949829,
0.5898431539535522,
0.13932693004608154,
0.5299884676933289,
-0.18469709157943726,
-0.16875286400318146,
-1.1543550491333008,
-0.37186509370803833,
-0.2712692320346832,
-0.42244526743888855,
-0.4870891869068146,
-0.7574173808097839,
0.22120952606201172,
0.31690630316734314,
-0.06084992736577988,
0.4426730275154114,
-0.8424773216247559,
0.4993164539337158,
0.2333097904920578,
0.02619161643087864,
0.5263830423355103,
0.09531184285879135,
-0.11348796635866165,
-0.5764603018760681,
-0.533616840839386,
-0.9532216787338257,
1.0289278030395508,
0.5525802373886108,
0.6207395195960999,
-0.154630646109581,
1.1483969688415527,
0.6105987429618835,
1.1428608894348145,
-0.8420188426971436,
0.501430869102478,
-0.34993621706962585,
-0.09996810555458069,
-0.300622820854187,
-0.5471697449684143,
-0.9324179887771606,
0.4434599280357361,
-0.3945015072822571,
-0.4822874367237091,
0.012672211974859238,
0.02601701207458973,
-0.267106831073761,
0.17940568923950195,
-0.5887588262557983,
0.6880216002464294,
-0.3200315833091736,
-0.24459929764270782,
-0.2548470199108124,
-0.17520277202129364,
0.007337998133152723,
0.028732893988490105,
0.06143340468406677,
-0.1815216839313507,
-0.5842112898826599,
1.0949527025222778,
-0.20280727744102478,
0.48810893297195435,
-0.25921404361724854,
-0.1279604583978653,
0.4020797312259674,
0.1729346066713333,
0.50490403175354,
0.2083621770143509,
-0.4289202094078064,
0.25274595618247986,
-0.07179837673902512,
-0.04438056796789169,
-0.9350125193595886,
0.7520186901092529,
-0.567808985710144,
-0.4254695475101471,
-0.4737612009048462,
-0.2682744264602661,
-0.25954362750053406,
0.19648608565330505,
0.2386559247970581,
0.27324628829956055,
-0.5834972858428955,
0.3599971532821655,
0.16382651031017303,
-0.5439176559448242,
0.185045525431633,
0.3442463278770447,
-0.48936927318573,
-0.8825747966766357,
0.8053240180015564,
-0.11720269173383713,
0.10919532179832458,
0.36513951420783997,
0.2653813362121582,
-0.7180236577987671,
-0.744513750076294,
-0.28610527515411377,
0.050766121596097946,
-0.6789271831512451,
-0.6221269369125366,
-0.21633899211883545,
-0.2791213095188141,
0.07400396466255188,
-0.1520502269268036,
-0.46556591987609863,
-0.41636985540390015,
-0.3434159457683563,
-0.35842448472976685,
0.1944313496351242,
0.7791489958763123,
-0.07360795885324478,
0.33578500151634216,
-0.8300896286964417,
0.25043028593063354,
0.040490929037332535,
0.5572996735572815,
-0.18526960909366608,
-0.6565421223640442,
-0.3471548855304718,
-0.1388615369796753,
-0.18051563203334808,
-0.7909704446792603,
0.6806769371032715,
0.34467998147010803,
0.6405715346336365,
0.19928784668445587,
0.034088749438524246,
0.47773265838623047,
-0.5392282605171204,
0.8627436757087708,
0.4763230085372925,
-0.7818511128425598,
0.4453883767127991,
-0.13974547386169434,
0.06559184938669205,
0.8723536133766174,
0.15824337303638458,
-0.631565272808075,
-0.35154423117637634,
-0.396067351102829,
-0.8249446749687195,
0.22286958992481232,
0.4155257046222687,
0.24835149943828583,
-0.19006319344043732,
0.4606201946735382,
0.36382243037223816,
0.13445468246936798,
-0.5845648050308228,
-0.16545383632183075,
-0.3179987370967865,
-0.33438652753829956,
0.0921136662364006,
-0.350923627614975,
-0.016688600182533264,
-0.26763713359832764,
0.2551729679107666,
0.10620389878749847,
0.3018873333930969,
0.41880762577056885,
-0.22744013369083405,
0.35035839676856995,
0.13223126530647278,
0.33018311858177185,
0.5354136228561401,
-0.14191904664039612,
0.14891317486763,
0.4058314859867096,
-0.5645954012870789,
0.17705979943275452,
-0.11798682063817978,
0.09980406612157822,
0.14969615638256073,
0.6920760869979858,
0.5499787330627441,
0.4235388934612274,
-0.365703821182251,
0.5017691254615784,
-0.15188132226467133,
-0.1561070680618286,
-0.2829113304615021,
-0.1516866236925125,
-0.22243726253509521,
0.15405641496181488,
0.5667803883552551,
-0.14018914103507996,
-0.005960905458778143,
-0.11955723166465759,
0.5652368664741516,
0.21585191786289215,
-0.7550657391548157,
0.04356888681650162,
0.5304266810417175,
0.44978779554367065,
-0.5806612968444824,
0.6201909780502319,
-0.34538885951042175,
-0.3956716060638428,
0.4259661138057709,
0.5784255266189575,
0.9923074841499329,
-0.007447564043104649,
0.4243817925453186,
0.6034238338470459,
0.4509934186935425,
-0.0026490753516554832,
-0.06364721059799194,
0.18626002967357635,
-0.7317079901695251,
-0.5153425335884094,
-0.799019455909729,
-0.5073636770248413,
-0.18885743618011475,
-0.5673170685768127,
0.09769758582115173,
-0.4327716827392578,
-0.3670857548713684,
-0.47895509004592896,
0.18520976603031158,
-0.6925709247589111,
0.11187001317739487,
0.03211602196097374,
1.1494450569152832,
-0.37222808599472046,
0.60158371925354,
0.5578076243400574,
-0.3170218765735626,
-0.45796284079551697,
0.032942019402980804,
-0.04753241688013077,
-0.9375856518745422,
0.7108722925186157,
0.32078278064727783,
-0.25068554282188416,
0.11395011842250824,
-0.2487868368625641,
-0.5530595183372498,
1.2858390808105469,
0.3959392309188843,
-0.6452562808990479,
0.21328674256801605,
0.1349160373210907,
0.8171588182449341,
-0.6882904767990112,
0.26050838828086853,
0.7331449389457703,
0.5805489420890808,
-0.15826110541820526,
-0.5205972790718079,
0.04006894677877426,
-0.13587303459644318,
0.08019232749938965,
0.1592647135257721,
-0.3104729652404785,
0.12517257034778595,
-0.1733570694923401,
-0.6516616344451904,
0.31295546889305115,
0.9981266856193542,
0.469231516122818,
0.30306220054626465,
0.4860091507434845,
0.4115835428237915,
1.045209288597107,
-0.39243239164352417,
1.2259231805801392,
-0.307903528213501,
0.47747424244880676,
1.150810718536377,
-0.015766384080052376,
1.0219895839691162,
0.34765470027923584,
-0.3498532772064209,
0.6359823346138,
0.5935248136520386,
-0.21692979335784912,
0.4723021388053894,
0.3531544506549835,
-0.29492729902267456,
-0.22014227509498596,
-0.14860907196998596,
-0.3047848045825958,
0.2602119743824005,
0.41783607006073,
-0.5252106189727783,
-0.28679129481315613,
-0.12138214707374573,
-0.2688889801502228,
0.6189455986022949,
-0.10763029754161835,
0.6638650298118591,
0.24449272453784943,
-0.46141570806503296,
0.556170642375946,
-0.016593823209404945,
0.806834876537323,
-0.4676205515861511,
-0.31976568698883057,
-0.3006318211555481,
-0.05466488376259804,
-0.32149630784988403,
-1.1333976984024048,
0.4969204068183899,
0.11785849928855896,
0.07475055754184723,
-0.569311261177063,
0.8405173420906067,
-0.3798975646495819,
-0.5162153840065002,
0.4221917986869812,
0.3959481120109558,
0.2097121775150299,
-0.07043326646089554,
-0.6019323468208313,
-0.016517823562026024,
-0.12631765007972717,
-0.31237462162971497,
0.1414923518896103,
0.49535098671913147,
0.2417432963848114,
0.5435688495635986,
0.4948759078979492,
0.23777705430984497,
-0.13119260966777802,
0.30850884318351746,
0.5752180814743042,
-0.7927303314208984,
0.003985418006777763,
-0.9448487162590027,
0.4542064964771271,
-0.3511554002761841,
-0.3456153869628906,
0.9420181512832642,
0.6041989326477051,
0.33845841884613037,
0.23568138480186462,
0.8260841369628906,
0.18761201202869415,
0.4956660568714142,
-0.3997417390346527,
1.063011884689331,
-0.4796370565891266,
0.4543898403644562,
-0.2972604036331177,
-1.1296162605285645,
-0.564802885055542,
0.8427214026451111,
-0.3116532862186432,
-0.18848679959774017,
0.7762346863746643,
0.45775309205055237,
0.27501341700553894,
-0.18042534589767456,
0.334090918302536,
-0.10132918506860733,
0.4079684317111969,
0.4658604562282562,
1.0055248737335205,
-0.5248926281929016,
0.8103030920028687,
0.06717098504304886,
-0.4154883921146393,
-0.05977557599544525,
-1.1763615608215332,
-0.7218914031982422,
-0.41024306416511536,
-0.29999208450317383,
-0.4182586371898651,
-0.01081102155148983,
0.8111470937728882,
0.4815637469291687,
-0.5891482830047607,
-0.04066178947687149,
-0.0420222282409668,
0.30181607604026794,
-0.22225262224674225,
-0.18637502193450928,
0.6541407704353333,
-0.411056786775589,
-0.5088233947753906,
0.5348882079124451,
0.4193466901779175,
-0.21850599348545074,
-0.41609352827072144,
-0.30551230907440186,
0.1459478735923767,
-0.0072653829120099545,
0.7771434783935547,
0.03812741860747337,
-0.5401229858398438,
-0.5042795538902283,
-0.06534872204065323,
-0.2809761166572571,
0.30928337574005127,
0.7067031860351562,
-0.9563024044036865,
0.4993360936641693,
0.5518662929534912,
0.8561885952949524,
0.37782707810401917,
0.25597459077835083,
0.7592381238937378,
-0.9744631052017212,
-0.27465754747390747,
0.4002875089645386,
0.2464694380760193,
0.6053285598754883,
-0.11374180763959885,
0.8219267129898071,
0.04035749286413193,
-0.6390599608421326,
-0.8396467566490173,
0.11830251663923264,
-0.689353346824646,
0.28135162591934204,
1.1837430000305176,
-0.28475403785705566,
0.052979689091444016,
0.11987734586000443,
-0.43267878890037537,
0.25186875462532043,
-0.403900682926178,
0.9229049682617188,
0.8168067336082458,
-0.2962337136268616,
-0.28039440512657166,
-0.407512903213501,
0.4708753824234009,
0.28896230459213257,
-0.9848878383636475,
0.14128680527210236,
0.3473021388053894,
-0.052364930510520935,
0.17364707589149475,
0.5989950299263,
-0.386968195438385,
-0.047295138239860535,
0.016591422259807587,
-0.07009036839008331,
-0.03543516620993614,
-0.10000292956829071,
-0.16038867831230164,
0.1539035141468048,
0.09629582613706589,
-0.17252500355243683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19553v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19553v1
|
Extending Llama-3's Context Ten-Fold Overnight
| 2024-04-30T13:25:20 | 2024-04-30T13:25:20 |
Peitian Zhang, Ninglu Shao, Zheng Liu, Shitao Xiao, Hongjin Qian, Qiwei Ye, Zhicheng Dou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We extend the context length of Llama-3-8B-Instruct from 8K to 80K via QLoRA
fine-tuning. The entire training cycle is super efficient, which takes 8 hours
on one 8xA800 (80G) GPU machine. The resulted model exhibits superior
performances across a broad range of evaluation tasks, such as NIHS, topic
retrieval, and long-context language understanding; meanwhile, it also well
preserves the original capability over short contexts. The dramatic context
extension is mainly attributed to merely 3.5K synthetic training samples
generated by GPT-4 , which indicates the LLMs' inherent (yet largely
underestimated) potential to extend its original context length. In fact, the
context length could be extended far beyond 80K with more computation
resources. Therefore, the team will publicly release the entire resources
(including data, model, data generation pipeline, training code) so as to
facilitate the future research from the community:
\url{https://github.com/FlagOpen/FlagEmbedding}.
|
[
-0.544154167175293,
-0.5967713594436646,
0.786760151386261,
0.3448166847229004,
-0.6465454697608948,
0.15836209058761597,
-0.3184506595134735,
-0.8980140089988708,
-0.12310762703418732,
0.46127134561538696,
-0.5083867907524109,
-0.3228453993797302,
-0.4605027735233307,
0.13702665269374847,
-0.2786392867565155,
1.1805436611175537,
-0.18648579716682434,
-0.33574673533439636,
0.22038140892982483,
-0.31674253940582275,
-0.4263457953929901,
-0.32725515961647034,
-0.7138931155204773,
-0.18723560869693756,
0.4958275854587555,
0.5394076108932495,
0.38188135623931885,
0.7819827198982239,
0.2818244695663452,
0.2311173528432846,
-0.13942767679691315,
0.13283878564834595,
-0.7793579697608948,
-0.07010994106531143,
0.23547998070716858,
-0.5940982103347778,
-0.7761440873146057,
0.10144984722137451,
0.7649892568588257,
0.4710288643836975,
-0.10851745307445526,
0.4879850149154663,
0.23407624661922455,
0.8195073008537292,
-0.6536680459976196,
0.4103163182735443,
-0.5157098174095154,
-0.07945053279399872,
-0.290546178817749,
-0.03650200366973877,
-0.21444480121135712,
-0.12147040665149689,
0.01712050475180149,
-0.7093492150306702,
-0.08766162395477295,
0.06425131112337112,
0.7011530995368958,
0.24124528467655182,
-0.5167223811149597,
0.10445692390203476,
-0.5535320043563843,
0.6405738592147827,
-0.5772932767868042,
0.11276403069496155,
0.315240740776062,
0.5521091818809509,
-0.1606154888868332,
-0.6744316220283508,
-0.7239173650741577,
-0.13540904223918915,
0.25721463561058044,
-0.07247833907604218,
-0.0075575439259409904,
0.19625920057296753,
0.46368715167045593,
0.511435866355896,
-0.21454879641532898,
0.09110186994075775,
-0.5192357301712036,
0.1265081763267517,
0.5541554093360901,
0.1802840232849121,
0.11304500699043274,
0.09705176949501038,
-0.4753570854663849,
-0.053774990141391754,
-1.0609242916107178,
0.012887801975011826,
0.3926662802696228,
-0.08238343894481659,
-0.4160009026527405,
0.3600303530693054,
-0.5151876211166382,
0.5448104739189148,
-0.02761627919971943,
-0.026636753231287003,
0.3583028018474579,
-0.35539814829826355,
-0.3016815185546875,
-0.030195441097021103,
0.3550901412963867,
0.5671678185462952,
-0.37897729873657227,
-0.0579175241291523,
-0.28443482518196106,
0.1591091901063919,
0.16050948202610016,
-0.9735967516899109,
-0.013939404860138893,
0.15413826704025269,
-0.25511229038238525,
-0.1539503037929535,
-0.18195638060569763,
-0.3670790195465088,
-0.11804874241352081,
-0.39018845558166504,
0.44843369722366333,
-0.42068150639533997,
-0.14792434871196747,
0.28758811950683594,
0.07183610647916794,
0.5525596737861633,
0.5074784159660339,
-0.6740012168884277,
0.26032888889312744,
0.830449640750885,
0.8332429528236389,
-0.3705759346485138,
-0.264191210269928,
-0.49251875281333923,
0.26497453451156616,
-0.43119585514068604,
0.6735826730728149,
-0.36653614044189453,
-0.19398599863052368,
-0.21625308692455292,
0.23281621932983398,
0.18101102113723755,
-0.3275325894355774,
0.4901651442050934,
-0.8045463562011719,
0.18237505853176117,
-0.39349791407585144,
-0.3818919360637665,
-0.5254388451576233,
0.1773163080215454,
-0.7165606021881104,
1.0681771039962769,
0.38872671127319336,
-0.19942140579223633,
0.3612205684185028,
-0.9862881898880005,
-0.18365232646465302,
0.36988556385040283,
0.028186682611703873,
-0.4239616096019745,
0.1575092077255249,
0.3912469148635864,
0.4882263243198395,
-0.31927233934402466,
0.23142072558403015,
-0.13178381323814392,
-0.7305223345756531,
-0.017590079456567764,
-0.18315602838993073,
0.7107992172241211,
0.20000672340393066,
-0.7509045004844666,
0.1376791000366211,
-0.7502622008323669,
-0.06170797720551491,
-0.08387885987758636,
-0.5183712244033813,
-0.026308909058570862,
-0.3898470103740692,
-0.01713448204100132,
0.10339847207069397,
0.3153130114078522,
-0.6151101589202881,
0.2822510004043579,
-0.25155043601989746,
0.5583654046058655,
0.8493426442146301,
-0.01239548809826374,
0.4597318470478058,
-0.26337122917175293,
0.696040689945221,
-0.3222499191761017,
0.45538198947906494,
-0.1586100161075592,
-0.5204852223396301,
-0.9314115643501282,
-0.36060062050819397,
-0.054367054253816605,
0.08426013588905334,
-0.7018199563026428,
0.27343639731407166,
-0.43687963485717773,
-0.4125991761684418,
-0.3661358952522278,
0.23473021388053894,
0.46918535232543945,
0.3381955921649933,
0.5638923048973083,
-0.23927509784698486,
-0.6773148775100708,
-0.8971315026283264,
0.09737280756235123,
-0.04246111214160919,
-0.22980885207653046,
0.13698895275592804,
0.7091643810272217,
-0.48287007212638855,
0.7211911678314209,
-0.44246727228164673,
-0.19516593217849731,
-0.31038612127304077,
-0.39065423607826233,
0.48954901099205017,
0.45004981756210327,
0.572496771812439,
-0.49298572540283203,
-0.39083537459373474,
-0.019221993163228035,
-0.6913413405418396,
-0.0035931819584220648,
0.013443605042994022,
-0.411808043718338,
0.15025392174720764,
0.42492273449897766,
-0.5099341869354248,
0.24289366602897644,
0.7373661994934082,
-0.2801419794559479,
0.6992338299751282,
0.037500202655792236,
0.053519949316978455,
-1.0116143226623535,
-0.20717741549015045,
-0.5285924673080444,
-0.23934246599674225,
-0.5135042071342468,
0.40820974111557007,
0.16407740116119385,
-0.057294730097055435,
-0.4905102252960205,
0.6002609133720398,
-0.7062631845474243,
-0.2303391993045807,
-0.5114535689353943,
0.14362701773643494,
-0.005865003447979689,
0.5762475728988647,
-0.30588003993034363,
1.0665748119354248,
0.4834539294242859,
-0.6569972634315491,
0.02953731268644333,
0.049108270555734634,
-0.5099398493766785,
0.328087717294693,
-0.6246181130409241,
0.27912837266921997,
0.17042692005634308,
0.667930006980896,
-0.6641404032707214,
-0.2816479802131653,
0.17197954654693604,
-0.130912646651268,
0.014993146061897278,
-0.022144977003335953,
-0.2784174382686615,
-0.1875368058681488,
-0.6838486790657043,
0.7435293793678284,
0.5761694312095642,
-0.9349891543388367,
0.5359788537025452,
0.452583372592926,
0.13423237204551697,
-0.39390692114830017,
-0.3699946403503418,
0.46321457624435425,
-0.5194550156593323,
-0.22049583494663239,
0.5555905699729919,
-0.08923482149839401,
-0.09425794333219528,
-0.1447487622499466,
-0.17859496176242828,
0.3632463812828064,
0.13155020773410797,
0.42076486349105835,
0.26288387179374695,
-0.29517582058906555,
0.0008822725503705442,
0.1431933492422104,
0.02312294766306877,
0.0448356531560421,
-0.24479956924915314,
0.5588904619216919,
-0.674210250377655,
-0.10361342877149582,
-0.4897756576538086,
0.11366866528987885,
0.22143340110778809,
0.07997381687164307,
0.7998948097229004,
0.6234099864959717,
-0.3562617599964142,
-0.07676535844802856,
-0.6857776045799255,
-0.16251954436302185,
-0.5456510186195374,
0.3439057171344757,
-0.43744009733200073,
-1.2778843641281128,
0.45753905177116394,
0.07529237121343613,
0.029652493074536324,
0.5499060750007629,
0.4252103269100189,
0.0060089523904025555,
0.7136342525482178,
0.9369327425956726,
-0.15175208449363708,
0.6315013766288757,
-0.5944046974182129,
0.00893531646579504,
-1.557607889175415,
-0.22782233357429504,
-0.02374357171356678,
-0.3260727524757385,
-0.6454519033432007,
-0.8476900458335876,
0.4363260567188263,
0.33574652671813965,
-0.4333386719226837,
0.4913921356201172,
-0.39578425884246826,
0.5959902405738831,
0.19082772731781006,
0.449560284614563,
0.12821605801582336,
-0.052389297634363174,
0.27482733130455017,
0.3443987965583801,
-0.6163309812545776,
-0.5831910967826843,
1.3012701272964478,
0.4444076716899872,
0.16479875147342682,
0.15930406749248505,
0.6451062560081482,
0.10065355151891708,
0.716119110584259,
-0.48312827944755554,
0.7088404297828674,
0.3051814138889313,
-0.33199191093444824,
-0.26525065302848816,
-0.04773196205496788,
-0.794175386428833,
0.21599151194095612,
0.12194398045539856,
-0.702727198600769,
0.09420718252658844,
0.0041576046496629715,
-0.39467790722846985,
0.20637214183807373,
-0.5276515483856201,
0.45329219102859497,
-0.12813825905323029,
-0.45581871271133423,
-0.44787418842315674,
-0.5202322006225586,
0.5812497138977051,
-0.1597530096769333,
0.09550939500331879,
-0.5561031699180603,
-0.467171847820282,
1.0824426412582397,
-0.45045608282089233,
0.8969393968582153,
-0.1328723430633545,
-0.27646297216415405,
0.35842087864875793,
-0.2657119035720825,
0.33384445309638977,
0.3217836618423462,
0.002991161774843931,
0.515557050704956,
-0.37050363421440125,
-0.6249411702156067,
-0.5066198706626892,
0.6950439214706421,
-0.7431361675262451,
-0.790063738822937,
-0.2840111553668976,
-0.4995492696762085,
-0.3243296146392822,
0.036084163933992386,
-0.11962119489908218,
0.21763749420642853,
0.06586059927940369,
0.44900989532470703,
0.3145674765110016,
-0.015459105372428894,
0.6398327350616455,
0.5143123269081116,
-0.14464619755744934,
-0.4719772934913635,
0.5967591404914856,
-0.30149582028388977,
0.1318914294242859,
0.2045014649629593,
0.2260097712278366,
-0.2644631564617157,
-0.6733261346817017,
-0.45161041617393494,
0.241679847240448,
-0.7112683057785034,
-0.2824183702468872,
-0.528530478477478,
-0.05307093635201454,
-0.091620072722435,
-0.2560146749019623,
-0.31479379534721375,
-0.655439555644989,
-0.2026761919260025,
-0.3958820700645447,
0.5459100008010864,
0.775507926940918,
0.01388879306614399,
0.8630012273788452,
-0.5701977014541626,
0.1569800078868866,
0.2997114658355713,
0.28868868947029114,
0.05041387677192688,
-0.7485417723655701,
-0.4693385064601898,
-0.04995453730225563,
-0.2819735109806061,
-0.5940625667572021,
0.22622206807136536,
0.2892140746116638,
0.4812900722026825,
0.5655795335769653,
-0.2077527791261673,
1.0318254232406616,
-0.5862966179847717,
0.9687147736549377,
0.10971331596374512,
-0.8679462671279907,
0.4391469955444336,
-0.4193921983242035,
0.44956544041633606,
0.3382265269756317,
0.25008267164230347,
-0.06203293055295944,
-0.3000759482383728,
-0.4951269030570984,
-0.9466875791549683,
0.438037633895874,
0.411559134721756,
0.20714108645915985,
0.04886427894234657,
0.7918843030929565,
0.3266753554344177,
0.1046973392367363,
-0.5902298092842102,
-0.09837079048156738,
-0.18923628330230713,
0.23672597110271454,
-0.41664746403694153,
-0.4397357404232025,
-0.38209861516952515,
-0.5091813206672668,
0.6515788435935974,
-0.516579806804657,
0.40069717168807983,
-0.059827931225299835,
-0.26768848299980164,
0.23280039429664612,
0.16639630496501923,
0.8425896763801575,
0.8767539262771606,
-0.12984442710876465,
0.16143658757209778,
0.6054189205169678,
-0.6537409424781799,
0.20400916039943695,
0.05041336640715599,
0.13609835505485535,
-0.5134073495864868,
0.5584477782249451,
1.0640062093734741,
0.3998138904571533,
-0.541510283946991,
0.12417715787887573,
0.016714608296751976,
0.031167397275567055,
-0.2141389697790146,
0.3080698251724243,
0.11641205102205276,
0.49066051840782166,
0.7129199504852295,
-0.26217931509017944,
0.21233732998371124,
-0.505001425743103,
0.18601471185684204,
0.15234282612800598,
-0.10163068771362305,
-0.5628800988197327,
0.7629552483558655,
0.23215383291244507,
0.11135166138410568,
0.35675573348999023,
-0.18354570865631104,
-0.7278696894645691,
0.644413948059082,
0.6324650049209595,
0.8648591041564941,
-0.05487526208162308,
0.0028095694724470377,
0.4271138310432434,
0.17289835214614868,
-0.1473405510187149,
0.33747512102127075,
-0.4938507378101349,
-0.5720641016960144,
-0.503904402256012,
-0.8263236880302429,
-0.3795132040977478,
0.1652163565158844,
-0.6625708341598511,
0.044371332973241806,
-0.35229194164276123,
-0.059740908443927765,
-0.5973418951034546,
0.34671416878700256,
-0.7118675708770752,
0.21761737763881683,
0.02836560644209385,
0.8972932696342468,
-0.49963346123695374,
0.9571690559387207,
0.46601587533950806,
-0.0651136264204979,
-0.7087898850440979,
-0.05822935700416565,
-0.2092500925064087,
-1.1302272081375122,
0.6461705565452576,
0.6613625884056091,
-0.312165766954422,
-0.05562026426196098,
-0.6531434059143066,
-0.8244516253471375,
1.60232412815094,
0.34170788526535034,
-0.820205569267273,
0.12817636132240295,
-0.011480920948088169,
0.6061645746231079,
-0.7022401690483093,
0.09575637429952621,
0.8084371089935303,
0.18332161009311676,
-0.29230889678001404,
-0.733263373374939,
0.45019444823265076,
-0.16441227495670319,
0.29622384905815125,
-0.21012303233146667,
-0.75764000415802,
0.5957967042922974,
-0.43326646089553833,
-0.16757486760616302,
-0.049810461699962616,
0.9031558632850647,
0.3958520293235779,
-0.014940373599529266,
0.660685658454895,
0.5182921886444092,
0.6668557524681091,
0.06330578029155731,
1.1905871629714966,
-0.6491580605506897,
0.2536182701587677,
1.0259897708892822,
-0.13006919622421265,
1.039726972579956,
0.5317187905311584,
-0.2453291416168213,
0.6306788325309753,
0.8469437956809998,
0.2388950139284134,
0.5157491564750671,
-0.0035946411080658436,
-0.6156407594680786,
-0.12235824018716812,
-0.1322443187236786,
-0.5598136782646179,
0.37318331003189087,
0.5100106000900269,
0.03417816013097763,
-0.02856690064072609,
0.0657612606883049,
0.06592487543821335,
-0.4083482325077057,
-0.40755197405815125,
0.49741265177726746,
0.23522749543190002,
-0.6007830500602722,
0.8020011782646179,
-0.15195316076278687,
0.6161502003669739,
-0.30724841356277466,
-0.0606706365942955,
-0.38368716835975647,
0.10275424271821976,
-0.046375397592782974,
-0.7190126180648804,
0.017755422741174698,
-0.18532566726207733,
0.15948383510112762,
-0.185178741812706,
0.446320503950119,
-0.2256888747215271,
-0.16869132220745087,
0.23192407190799713,
0.26117995381355286,
0.08073192834854126,
-0.20432829856872559,
-0.4169587790966034,
0.45135873556137085,
-0.04353800415992737,
-0.4953926205635071,
0.44625410437583923,
0.07445261627435684,
-0.2982823848724365,
0.7813615798950195,
0.7856447696685791,
-0.05746087059378624,
0.1219903752207756,
0.02250974252820015,
1.3163435459136963,
-0.5739196538925171,
-0.4491763412952423,
-0.8413910269737244,
0.16114123165607452,
-0.09020859748125076,
-0.32647931575775146,
0.7720986604690552,
0.7541090250015259,
0.940523087978363,
-0.047700755298137665,
0.5293042659759521,
0.11123275011777878,
-0.09364867210388184,
-0.6780679821968079,
0.5317268967628479,
-0.48121407628059387,
0.41151076555252075,
-0.030051877722144127,
-1.0202131271362305,
-0.026368889957666397,
0.44723477959632874,
-0.25497356057167053,
-0.12980639934539795,
0.8272312879562378,
0.5211870670318604,
0.09353327751159668,
0.031830884516239166,
0.2234622985124588,
0.14955681562423706,
0.5483170747756958,
0.8062244057655334,
0.8029592633247375,
-0.5745559334754944,
0.4681251645088196,
-0.42432159185409546,
-0.48804208636283875,
-0.34184059500694275,
-1.071607232093811,
-0.8704142570495605,
-0.4999673664569855,
-0.1725761890411377,
0.02158334106206894,
0.2277701199054718,
0.5957894325256348,
0.6873236894607544,
-0.6052602529525757,
-0.30225035548210144,
0.005275909788906574,
-0.04802820086479187,
-0.28045397996902466,
-0.2143113762140274,
0.5101595520973206,
-0.2616991698741913,
-0.6829366683959961,
0.6950145363807678,
0.5225769877433777,
-0.15597620606422424,
-0.306565523147583,
-0.20058093965053558,
-0.04153446853160858,
-0.23249518871307373,
0.9877089262008667,
0.14756247401237488,
-0.6451622247695923,
-0.4806313216686249,
-0.14085698127746582,
0.09225138276815414,
0.10688763111829758,
0.5584818124771118,
-0.8230994343757629,
0.12734611332416534,
0.14973397552967072,
0.6464883089065552,
0.6994630098342896,
0.03858061879873276,
0.727888822555542,
-0.49764585494995117,
0.22373981773853302,
0.0012829130282625556,
0.39137887954711914,
0.25548383593559265,
-0.35940879583358765,
0.75197833776474,
0.04389011859893799,
-0.5769214630126953,
-0.9144335985183716,
0.09678035229444504,
-0.9937586188316345,
-0.005906073376536369,
1.1703344583511353,
-0.14275798201560974,
-0.42135944962501526,
0.14917588233947754,
-0.2120928168296814,
0.27269217371940613,
-0.3588436245918274,
0.9603686928749084,
0.42565831542015076,
-0.434068500995636,
-0.2254650890827179,
-0.9872187376022339,
0.7639955878257751,
0.18143194913864136,
-0.9303675889968872,
-0.24316151440143585,
0.31930384039878845,
0.48753881454467773,
-0.09949100017547607,
0.7880017161369324,
-0.02682582475244999,
0.5333825945854187,
-0.1634516716003418,
-0.055837199091911316,
-0.16191844642162323,
-0.32361260056495667,
-0.2933156192302704,
0.1244136393070221,
-0.055200397968292236,
-0.39878323674201965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19543v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19543v1
|
RAG and RAU: A Survey on Retrieval-Augmented Language Model in Natural Language Processing
| 2024-04-30T13:14:51 | 2024-04-30T13:14:51 |
Yucheng Hu, Yuxing Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have catalyzed significant advancements in
Natural Language Processing (NLP), yet they encounter challenges such as
hallucination and the need for domain-specific knowledge. To mitigate these,
recent methodologies have integrated information retrieved from external
resources with LLMs, substantially enhancing their performance across NLP
tasks. This survey paper addresses the absence of a comprehensive overview on
Retrieval-Augmented Language Models (RALMs), both Retrieval-Augmented
Generation (RAG) and Retrieval-Augmented Understanding (RAU), providing an
in-depth examination of their paradigm, evolution, taxonomy, and applications.
The paper discusses the essential components of RALMs, including Retrievers,
Language Models, and Augmentations, and how their interactions lead to diverse
model structures and applications. RALMs demonstrate utility in a spectrum of
tasks, from translation and dialogue systems to knowledge-intensive
applications. The survey includes several evaluation methods of RALMs,
emphasizing the importance of robustness, accuracy, and relevance in their
assessment. It also acknowledges the limitations of RALMs, particularly in
retrieval quality and computational efficiency, offering directions for future
research. In conclusion, this survey aims to offer a structured insight into
RALMs, their potential, and the avenues for their future development in NLP.
The paper is supplemented with a Github Repository containing the surveyed
works and resources for further study:
https://github.com/2471023025/RALM_Survey.
|
[
-0.4586470425128937,
-0.9711887836456299,
0.39318978786468506,
-0.05240741744637489,
0.05095377564430237,
0.40340903401374817,
-0.3232637643814087,
-0.7934510707855225,
0.3024027347564697,
0.7865813374519348,
-0.2668207883834839,
-0.17052268981933594,
-0.631302535533905,
0.2772751748561859,
-0.42698922753334045,
0.8303990960121155,
0.1746976226568222,
-0.1401880830526352,
-0.33726876974105835,
-0.36774638295173645,
-0.5655636191368103,
-0.5975542664527893,
-0.38092371821403503,
-0.5581228733062744,
0.5041839480400085,
0.017423177137970924,
0.5841749906539917,
0.250448614358902,
0.5728052258491516,
0.21948936581611633,
-0.3603830337524414,
0.44292864203453064,
-0.3302989900112152,
0.7250383496284485,
-0.20105114579200745,
-0.26779013872146606,
-0.4086606502532959,
0.009565041400492191,
0.8100261688232422,
0.796764612197876,
-0.22993643581867218,
0.2428264319896698,
0.1812414526939392,
0.8628495931625366,
-0.9125663042068481,
-0.07424881309270859,
-0.627833366394043,
-0.12609371542930603,
-0.28035080432891846,
-0.2111542820930481,
-0.6704596281051636,
-0.33943596482276917,
0.03024442121386528,
-0.282156378030777,
0.15840908885002136,
0.3011018633842468,
0.6442204713821411,
0.1514407992362976,
-0.3482348918914795,
-0.48324063420295715,
-0.8884738087654114,
1.0499742031097412,
-0.6804326772689819,
0.6344237327575684,
0.6201115250587463,
0.22811532020568848,
-0.3633754551410675,
-0.6905908584594727,
-0.22887302935123444,
-0.428244411945343,
-0.2922465205192566,
-0.0016111326403915882,
-0.2491375207901001,
-0.002847862895578146,
0.07863537967205048,
0.6401033401489258,
-0.6080692410469055,
0.08166036009788513,
-0.07980100065469742,
0.05846766382455826,
0.5753535628318787,
0.254204124212265,
0.31635186076164246,
-0.422882080078125,
-0.3372493088245392,
0.15975938737392426,
-0.5175018906593323,
-0.1956736445426941,
0.07971084117889404,
0.27714186906814575,
0.0795959085226059,
0.7703776955604553,
-0.09839138388633728,
1.0718594789505005,
-0.40490129590034485,
-0.15757682919502258,
0.11203742027282715,
-0.45803597569465637,
-0.1915069818496704,
-0.4123275578022003,
0.7228803634643555,
-0.13167047500610352,
-0.12001419067382812,
-0.3511461913585663,
-0.5271169543266296,
-0.17918702960014343,
0.3411228656768799,
-0.39049839973449707,
0.0793147012591362,
0.05133397504687309,
-0.3849361538887024,
-0.1754382699728012,
-0.09867717325687408,
-0.7798407673835754,
-0.4563332200050354,
-0.5140987634658813,
0.20289522409439087,
-0.3125898241996765,
-0.4616818428039551,
0.03369450196623802,
0.09939291328191757,
0.28522273898124695,
0.24577227234840393,
-0.5964029431343079,
0.5031505823135376,
0.8987608551979065,
0.6425140500068665,
-0.3714865446090698,
0.08942698687314987,
-0.6485288143157959,
-0.048022445291280746,
-0.16932468116283417,
0.9169694185256958,
-0.8283858895301819,
-0.4063914716243744,
0.1545981615781784,
-0.3329385817050934,
-0.13868767023086548,
-0.7192973494529724,
0.8549918532371521,
-0.9959673285484314,
0.17621904611587524,
-0.12411755323410034,
-0.4671487808227539,
-0.4064168930053711,
0.4614269733428955,
-0.7443884015083313,
1.364288330078125,
-0.10662338882684708,
-0.9448363780975342,
-0.08917181938886642,
-0.5341907739639282,
-0.39191195368766785,
0.2467891126871109,
-0.054350145161151886,
-0.166357159614563,
0.3556152284145355,
0.12258429825305939,
0.3675718307495117,
-0.7009142637252808,
0.3641904294490814,
-0.09251217544078827,
-0.23523850739002228,
0.3698188364505768,
-0.4027900695800781,
0.6797645688056946,
0.3941773772239685,
0.22317010164260864,
0.13882926106452942,
-0.754996120929718,
-0.013560657389461994,
0.11872736364603043,
-0.3299477696418762,
-0.7046377658843994,
-0.028796125203371048,
0.19005925953388214,
-0.0298073198646307,
0.3349877893924713,
-0.337935209274292,
0.251835435628891,
-0.4102470576763153,
0.07542537152767181,
0.4240049123764038,
-0.017108162865042686,
0.6135312914848328,
-0.2305099368095398,
0.7609230279922485,
-0.4637748897075653,
0.04872941970825195,
-0.0981941670179367,
-0.44169625639915466,
-0.6786831617355347,
-0.23194646835327148,
0.2686951458454132,
0.4240439236164093,
-0.7372007966041565,
0.20949938893318176,
-0.16857588291168213,
-0.39626824855804443,
-0.6649328470230103,
0.17027725279331207,
0.4072079658508301,
0.4514133930206299,
0.36531874537467957,
-0.010370681062340736,
-0.7402690649032593,
-0.7289425134658813,
-0.46451640129089355,
0.029915276914834976,
0.1985517144203186,
0.47886034846305847,
0.3702875077724457,
-0.4019770324230194,
1.0815939903259277,
-0.3628159165382385,
-0.2475772202014923,
-0.5468431115150452,
0.24438154697418213,
0.26263588666915894,
0.10922478884458542,
0.2714022994041443,
-0.8968443870544434,
-0.3244660794734955,
-0.028030455112457275,
-0.6895294189453125,
-0.1554698497056961,
0.36397334933280945,
0.10041510313749313,
0.3670068383216858,
0.186367005109787,
-0.6723910570144653,
0.4405154883861542,
0.6257994174957275,
-0.032680053263902664,
0.6388795375823975,
-0.28454726934432983,
0.06823796778917313,
-0.8558334708213806,
0.39677000045776367,
-0.14805464446544647,
-0.3209773600101471,
-0.8156764507293701,
0.52159184217453,
-0.0681479275226593,
0.1322936713695526,
-0.06913743913173676,
0.8910298943519592,
-0.7454057931900024,
-0.43051445484161377,
-0.5312058329582214,
0.4653351902961731,
0.13274769484996796,
0.007667813915759325,
0.035557374358177185,
0.7824766635894775,
0.1288692057132721,
-0.6269311904907227,
0.2168634682893753,
0.2259691059589386,
-0.38116416335105896,
0.20926253497600555,
-0.40792593359947205,
0.39747247099876404,
-0.17630545794963837,
0.1550905406475067,
-0.670574963092804,
-0.10880062729120255,
0.27277645468711853,
-0.5562652945518494,
0.41847196221351624,
-0.2564639449119568,
-0.6559748649597168,
-0.13564175367355347,
-0.19332186877727509,
0.48456355929374695,
0.5335607528686523,
-0.3074418008327484,
0.8360369801521301,
0.5979605317115784,
-0.15605886280536652,
-0.9381874799728394,
-0.528960645198822,
0.19835427403450012,
-0.049959760159254074,
-0.39420977234840393,
0.18022164702415466,
0.09822144359350204,
-0.6232138872146606,
0.12796661257743835,
0.07612919807434082,
-0.019418280571699142,
0.038783811032772064,
0.06790490448474884,
0.45686861872673035,
-0.13198834657669067,
0.17834408581256866,
-0.3758443593978882,
-0.0411965511739254,
-0.05475585162639618,
0.18336734175682068,
0.6332595944404602,
-0.09148649871349335,
-0.32445892691612244,
-0.016573317348957062,
0.28186237812042236,
0.1656292974948883,
-0.6615117192268372,
0.7577818632125854,
0.6272931098937988,
-0.4010150134563446,
-0.04436684399843216,
-0.9074100255966187,
-0.09794072061777115,
-0.35219523310661316,
0.17727243900299072,
-0.17444270849227905,
-0.9582670331001282,
0.5521215200424194,
0.094972163438797,
0.16182072460651398,
0.4401223361492157,
0.4727144241333008,
0.03147558495402336,
0.7210227251052856,
0.6414511203765869,
-0.09771879017353058,
0.40133967995643616,
-0.2570205628871918,
0.24188557267189026,
-1.2804464101791382,
-0.23926638066768646,
-0.820702075958252,
-0.015174909494817257,
-0.36205601692199707,
-0.5749419927597046,
0.16958825290203094,
0.23406937718391418,
0.12252511829137802,
0.06466098129749298,
-0.4226798415184021,
0.17235933244228363,
0.31994691491127014,
-0.3586580753326416,
0.7185730934143066,
-0.004351536277681589,
-0.00626937672495842,
-0.19863474369049072,
-0.6117070317268372,
-0.5908282995223999,
0.8140577077865601,
0.25422319769859314,
0.8332935571670532,
0.0643962025642395,
0.5921714901924133,
0.3641974925994873,
0.41091009974479675,
-0.8308382630348206,
0.5122079253196716,
-0.015080698765814304,
-0.6895458102226257,
-0.053782496601343155,
-0.46973004937171936,
-1.2266454696655273,
0.447176992893219,
-0.3253973126411438,
-0.5629982948303223,
-0.003125129034742713,
-0.07309651374816895,
-0.09695496410131454,
0.37012094259262085,
-0.31311100721359253,
0.36938169598579407,
-0.13380807638168335,
-0.26835739612579346,
-0.42235255241394043,
-0.5489724278450012,
0.6660143136978149,
-0.018972670659422874,
0.5758093595504761,
-0.1294562667608261,
-0.09212730824947357,
0.6374223232269287,
-0.07188517600297928,
0.3765523135662079,
-0.0002944219158962369,
-0.14125347137451172,
0.4453318119049072,
0.18857330083847046,
0.5366473197937012,
-0.05800158903002739,
-0.22735972702503204,
-0.04230760782957077,
-0.10884709656238556,
-0.021424295380711555,
-0.6502642035484314,
0.7422847747802734,
-0.35868364572525024,
-0.47410836815834045,
-0.6926893591880798,
-0.7296103239059448,
-0.170143261551857,
0.15181395411491394,
-0.10488604009151459,
0.5432317852973938,
-0.01611100696027279,
0.2364235371351242,
0.7336061000823975,
-0.36286044120788574,
0.2829316258430481,
0.5667803883552551,
-0.8118671178817749,
-0.3923858106136322,
0.7319589257240295,
0.06304498761892319,
0.25335317850112915,
0.5087417960166931,
0.016510482877492905,
-0.35406363010406494,
-0.6583400964736938,
-0.09382837265729904,
0.45561161637306213,
-0.5779236555099487,
-0.48541948199272156,
-0.7468574047088623,
-0.34794628620147705,
-0.40644845366477966,
0.18054448068141937,
-0.3541364371776581,
-0.27973294258117676,
-0.40539029240608215,
0.12437134981155396,
0.5761479139328003,
1.0957303047180176,
0.05501248687505722,
-0.15096226334571838,
-0.892367422580719,
0.6212338805198669,
-0.03819163888692856,
0.3783867359161377,
0.23343922197818756,
-0.6588129997253418,
-0.23329438269138336,
0.021177144721150398,
0.03801712766289711,
-0.692595362663269,
0.615739643573761,
-0.019724318757653236,
0.5882571935653687,
-0.04376581683754921,
0.2615598440170288,
0.5094389915466309,
-0.41984403133392334,
0.6078041195869446,
-0.20134450495243073,
-0.4455919563770294,
0.4134603440761566,
-0.17046061158180237,
0.04583711549639702,
0.44838324189186096,
0.22170966863632202,
-0.6049952507019043,
-0.26982784271240234,
-0.4617713987827301,
-0.8985029458999634,
0.6414395570755005,
0.132514089345932,
0.07887465506792068,
-0.07566500455141068,
0.38082796335220337,
0.03880427032709122,
0.023745698854327202,
-0.531433641910553,
-0.4641237258911133,
0.4788367748260498,
0.011904407292604446,
0.10052455961704254,
-0.5505654215812683,
0.11827921122312546,
0.019315119832754135,
0.7307702302932739,
0.2803284525871277,
0.13534590601921082,
0.10363408178091049,
-0.447068989276886,
0.014735348522663116,
0.5442423224449158,
0.41864579916000366,
0.6152002215385437,
-0.4005545675754547,
0.04918009787797928,
0.06463708728551865,
-0.6186254024505615,
-0.02838379703462124,
0.08114670217037201,
-0.2402147650718689,
0.15541835129261017,
0.31911271810531616,
0.5763925909996033,
0.293348491191864,
-0.7396448850631714,
0.22092042863368988,
-0.10412830859422684,
0.21769700944423676,
-0.40754690766334534,
-0.1632147580385208,
-0.025030430406332016,
0.14780989289283752,
0.6162466406822205,
0.08359517902135849,
0.3306503891944885,
-0.4311744272708893,
-0.03008502721786499,
0.7520394325256348,
-0.2305561751127243,
-0.2640288770198822,
0.4706951081752777,
-0.09210613369941711,
-0.5817388892173767,
0.620413064956665,
-0.2648768126964569,
-0.3239227831363678,
0.0011041488032788038,
0.549979567527771,
0.9459763765335083,
-0.11157628148794174,
-0.06689096242189407,
0.25399377942085266,
0.2635546624660492,
-0.04829556867480278,
0.10627983510494232,
-0.0647747665643692,
-0.6796372532844543,
-0.8187574148178101,
-0.8909133076667786,
-0.4297868609428406,
0.19107824563980103,
-0.9576367735862732,
0.12591905891895294,
-0.12322710454463959,
-0.2882382571697235,
-0.37839725613594055,
0.13159440457820892,
-0.47505250573158264,
-0.10302887111902237,
-0.0326908603310585,
0.8968340754508972,
-0.4575795829296112,
0.8221427202224731,
0.8287582397460938,
-0.4509783089160919,
-0.31260576844215393,
-0.269288033246994,
-0.3236091136932373,
-0.5534418821334839,
0.7668002843856812,
-0.16409476101398468,
-0.34040096402168274,
-0.07112884521484375,
-0.2189093679189682,
-0.8334542512893677,
0.7951652407646179,
0.1835445761680603,
-0.24809858202934265,
-0.19044551253318787,
0.06573747843503952,
0.5809266567230225,
-0.08606007695198059,
0.2720016539096832,
0.6216026544570923,
0.42475426197052,
0.04715815186500549,
-0.7980003952980042,
-0.2248261570930481,
-0.1793338805437088,
0.20799604058265686,
0.2828417718410492,
-0.20129799842834473,
0.4756651520729065,
-0.08687153458595276,
-0.2938862442970276,
0.29594579339027405,
0.7508212924003601,
0.49338749051094055,
0.1907038390636444,
0.22506307065486908,
0.6997323632240295,
0.5038925409317017,
-0.037156153470277786,
1.281539797782898,
-0.1199478954076767,
0.3502550423145294,
1.2323808670043945,
-0.25433215498924255,
1.2058916091918945,
0.43775349855422974,
-0.3781227171421051,
0.33414599299430847,
0.12536358833312988,
0.41462981700897217,
0.1315293163061142,
-0.07077045738697052,
-0.38475239276885986,
-0.17389127612113953,
-0.3281693458557129,
-0.40315431356430054,
0.2917254567146301,
0.5548344254493713,
-0.2352953553199768,
-0.24838148057460785,
0.18919312953948975,
-0.21788981556892395,
0.32340526580810547,
-0.19979305565357208,
0.8984673619270325,
0.24403081834316254,
-0.5514141321182251,
0.5669123530387878,
0.14632610976696014,
0.8118498921394348,
-0.5625939965248108,
-0.19727583229541779,
-0.3407757580280304,
-0.005084214266389608,
-0.15679922699928284,
-0.8209339380264282,
0.5024662613868713,
0.2673848867416382,
-0.24151583015918732,
-0.32354819774627686,
1.0237101316452026,
-0.20782802999019623,
-0.3833886981010437,
0.435674786567688,
0.5580514073371887,
0.11134444177150726,
0.06001842021942139,
-0.6355531215667725,
0.34621307253837585,
-0.19290320575237274,
-0.43867167830467224,
0.4381091296672821,
0.19165761768817902,
0.07153567671775818,
0.9001339673995972,
0.5204941034317017,
0.1847154051065445,
0.2534101903438568,
0.21837347745895386,
0.6277446150779724,
-0.6860864162445068,
0.15684449672698975,
-0.6872884035110474,
0.3885595202445984,
0.17045815289020538,
0.09317708015441895,
0.9490806460380554,
0.7127256989479065,
0.5280978679656982,
0.09326551109552383,
0.587710440158844,
-0.041559893637895584,
1.1395227909088135,
-0.4826008975505829,
0.6625643372535706,
-0.5050739049911499,
0.37370026111602783,
-0.2645491063594818,
-1.0898946523666382,
-0.4665526747703552,
0.5321098566055298,
-0.3440649211406708,
0.056788038462400436,
0.36973315477371216,
0.5993978977203369,
-0.015900742262601852,
-0.009587785229086876,
0.2432204633951187,
0.15008383989334106,
0.2792748212814331,
-0.05712296813726425,
1.0635018348693848,
-0.5076175332069397,
0.3610324561595917,
-0.1206221729516983,
0.127736434340477,
-0.3725232183933258,
-0.7979636192321777,
-0.47576045989990234,
-0.6221992373466492,
-0.12235862016677856,
-0.2420906275510788,
0.021724751219153404,
0.8353297114372253,
0.1299300491809845,
-0.5717630982398987,
-0.34933650493621826,
0.12718655169010162,
0.30240121483802795,
0.11994637548923492,
-0.24450793862342834,
0.3477815091609955,
-0.6697999238967896,
-0.6988511681556702,
0.5354339480400085,
0.30174773931503296,
-0.22856581211090088,
-0.3700490891933441,
-0.12567488849163055,
-0.6528732180595398,
-0.1308647245168686,
0.8632712364196777,
0.47698351740837097,
-1.052574872970581,
0.10160721838474274,
0.21477903425693512,
-0.12470472604036331,
0.06348269432783127,
0.6646299362182617,
-1.015483021736145,
0.5389671325683594,
0.6516770720481873,
0.9110699892044067,
0.38939738273620605,
0.03065035305917263,
0.3738277852535248,
-0.621944785118103,
0.00817097071558237,
0.5196283459663391,
0.3977135121822357,
0.540753960609436,
0.013755256310105324,
0.5850746035575867,
-0.018886379897594452,
-0.7406439185142517,
-1.1581147909164429,
0.1592743992805481,
-0.858486533164978,
-0.07854597270488739,
1.2407541275024414,
0.07998832315206528,
0.06140768527984619,
-0.2326112985610962,
-0.23380689322948456,
0.18062418699264526,
-0.03245626017451286,
0.2946545481681824,
0.5648447871208191,
-0.10152875632047653,
-0.25963273644447327,
-0.9280010461807251,
0.3682929575443268,
0.311611145734787,
-0.6917935609817505,
0.3024338185787201,
0.6385905742645264,
0.05610759183764458,
0.1565694957971573,
0.5008288025856018,
-0.282101571559906,
-0.1048019677400589,
-0.5172147154808044,
0.1905890256166458,
0.06704537570476532,
-0.15746377408504486,
-0.5871388912200928,
0.07911571115255356,
0.4776292145252228,
0.24247883260250092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19509v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19509v1
|
Do Large Language Models Understand Conversational Implicature -- A case study with a chinese sitcom
| 2024-04-30T12:43:53 | 2024-04-30T12:43:53 |
Shisen Yue, Siyuan Song, Xinyuan Cheng, Hai Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, J.5
|
Understanding the non-literal meaning of an utterance is critical for large
language models (LLMs) to become human-like social communicators. In this work,
we introduce SwordsmanImp, the first Chinese multi-turn-dialogue-based dataset
aimed at conversational implicature, sourced from dialogues in the Chinese
sitcom $\textit{My Own Swordsman}$. It includes 200 carefully handcrafted
questions, all annotated on which Gricean maxims have been violated. We test
eight close-source and open-source LLMs under two tasks: a multiple-choice
question task and an implicature explanation task. Our results show that GPT-4
attains human-level accuracy (94%) on multiple-choice questions. CausalLM
demonstrates a 78.5% accuracy following GPT-4. Other models, including GPT-3.5
and several open-source models, demonstrate a lower accuracy ranging from 20%
to 60% on multiple-choice questions. Human raters were asked to rate the
explanation of the implicatures generated by LLMs on their reasonability, logic
and fluency. While all models generate largely fluent and self-consistent text,
their explanations score low on reasonability except for GPT-4, suggesting that
most LLMs cannot produce satisfactory explanations of the implicatures in the
conversation. Moreover, we find LLMs' performance does not vary significantly
by Gricean maxims, suggesting that LLMs do not seem to process implicatures
derived from different maxims differently. Our data and code are available at
https://github.com/sjtu-compling/llm-pragmatics.
|
[
-0.13205298781394958,
-0.8033648133277893,
0.6543356776237488,
0.11114480346441269,
-0.21972709894180298,
-0.0816039964556694,
-0.1967642605304718,
-0.09437385946512222,
0.07261378318071365,
0.6956103444099426,
-0.45990756154060364,
-0.27448686957359314,
-0.4675246477127075,
-0.05380833148956299,
-0.2652069330215454,
0.9327091574668884,
-0.07412470132112503,
0.20343908667564392,
0.0030363344121724367,
-0.13344068825244904,
-0.30750954151153564,
-0.5973621606826782,
-0.5241779685020447,
-0.5309631824493408,
0.5862582921981812,
0.5480940341949463,
0.9741128087043762,
0.6836456656455994,
0.6289902925491333,
0.29601407051086426,
-0.002008188748732209,
0.37755972146987915,
-0.6832212209701538,
0.152399942278862,
-0.369568407535553,
-0.5403554439544678,
-0.12169690430164337,
0.20466023683547974,
0.6738691926002502,
0.6820040345191956,
-0.17345131933689117,
0.10519292950630188,
0.27562418580055237,
0.37082263827323914,
-0.1309373825788498,
0.17640578746795654,
-0.82187819480896,
0.04767927527427673,
-0.2999950647354126,
-0.4504093527793884,
-0.6126505136489868,
-0.3763439953327179,
0.15098045766353607,
-0.6038613319396973,
0.27692458033561707,
0.10336688160896301,
1.0633277893066406,
-0.04972933605313301,
-0.4030255079269409,
-0.44555556774139404,
-0.5833553671836853,
0.579190731048584,
-1.052947998046875,
-0.02877473644912243,
0.2775231897830963,
0.33178025484085083,
-0.6170014142990112,
-0.7095128893852234,
-0.7988722324371338,
-0.5096800923347473,
-0.21792688965797424,
0.04239189624786377,
0.04655066505074501,
0.3401852548122406,
0.4745127260684967,
0.4359779953956604,
-0.8551669716835022,
-0.050138067454099655,
-0.15990333259105682,
0.012102990411221981,
0.7554557919502258,
0.4033043682575226,
0.3812634348869324,
-0.24486884474754333,
-0.43797314167022705,
-0.09578430652618408,
-0.7365054488182068,
0.09475745260715485,
0.45077720284461975,
0.24182909727096558,
-0.2729845345020294,
0.48101601004600525,
0.28714799880981445,
0.49386832118034363,
0.21558889746665955,
-0.2852124571800232,
0.02172028459608555,
-0.35043615102767944,
-0.35717830061912537,
-0.09355664998292923,
0.9608864784240723,
0.3616012632846832,
0.5111358761787415,
-0.00834951363503933,
0.14072173833847046,
-0.24288858473300934,
0.15089547634124756,
-0.7895269393920898,
-0.37176403403282166,
0.23144905269145966,
-0.36497950553894043,
-0.11358483880758286,
-0.08251361548900604,
-0.33449384570121765,
-0.7276607751846313,
-0.37699005007743835,
0.3862880766391754,
-0.5525831580162048,
-0.28941088914871216,
0.10513776540756226,
-0.23120199143886566,
0.39507269859313965,
0.38623499870300293,
-0.7687271237373352,
0.05906272679567337,
0.7260995507240295,
1.1068994998931885,
0.03465927764773369,
-0.5181090831756592,
-0.35374170541763306,
0.21318842470645905,
-0.5764224529266357,
0.621983528137207,
-0.5422922968864441,
-0.18140237033367157,
-0.1444227397441864,
0.19350945949554443,
-0.47673535346984863,
-0.5374970436096191,
0.6353126168251038,
-0.06397342681884766,
0.0888940617442131,
-0.24270504713058472,
-0.5617378950119019,
-0.5058024525642395,
0.27861830592155457,
-0.37424084544181824,
0.44196468591690063,
-0.09182408452033997,
-0.7056955695152283,
0.020875217393040657,
-0.618598997592926,
-0.36289966106414795,
0.22668690979480743,
-0.2644270956516266,
-0.22877100110054016,
0.015113932080566883,
-0.09521513432264328,
0.6441136002540588,
-0.556217610836029,
0.9364137053489685,
-0.5302690863609314,
-0.51556795835495,
0.5870074033737183,
-0.927655816078186,
0.8560462594032288,
0.12602849304676056,
-0.19277538359165192,
0.0494980663061142,
-0.17824701964855194,
-0.1412361115217209,
0.43182992935180664,
0.2765558362007141,
-0.18617995083332062,
0.05873296037316322,
-0.4531475007534027,
0.40333327651023865,
0.14498008787631989,
-0.5102632641792297,
0.021419303491711617,
-0.5521223545074463,
0.4356153905391693,
0.7870491743087769,
0.07318295538425446,
-0.01958923600614071,
-0.7610445618629456,
0.5648387670516968,
0.15130269527435303,
0.029634665697813034,
-0.5330579876899719,
-0.46617603302001953,
-0.7560840845108032,
-0.16662336885929108,
-0.2746050953865051,
0.5165351629257202,
-0.8953353762626648,
-0.05670325458049774,
-0.35392093658447266,
-0.7864802479743958,
-0.2207372635602951,
-0.024875877425074577,
0.506493330001831,
0.5106126070022583,
0.026578065007925034,
-0.014582007192075253,
-0.18818345665931702,
-1.1213732957839966,
-0.6263911128044128,
-0.4215834438800812,
0.03918367996811867,
0.4687727391719818,
0.46622610092163086,
0.26130977272987366,
0.8170741200447083,
-0.39536798000335693,
-0.05493578314781189,
-0.43967515230178833,
0.269735187292099,
0.5619848370552063,
0.2092178463935852,
0.3837240934371948,
-0.8192196488380432,
-0.6278184056282043,
0.0621192567050457,
-0.8773660659790039,
-0.06210704520344734,
-0.28611403703689575,
-0.005130480974912643,
-0.3657742440700531,
0.19167284667491913,
-0.5411900281906128,
0.14369697868824005,
0.509192943572998,
-0.14633236825466156,
0.7604374885559082,
-0.2508285939693451,
0.21958018839359283,
-1.2247809171676636,
-0.004232964478433132,
0.33932116627693176,
-0.08079471439123154,
-0.9455732703208923,
0.26850223541259766,
-0.07587914168834686,
-0.19745440781116486,
-0.47580820322036743,
0.5239745378494263,
-0.14341865479946136,
0.22386060655117035,
-0.1390966773033142,
0.36811232566833496,
0.08140645176172256,
0.7653684616088867,
-0.11663606762886047,
0.8258697390556335,
0.232232928276062,
-0.5537111759185791,
0.6393281817436218,
0.16684302687644958,
-0.05325436219573021,
0.677996814250946,
-0.7510105967521667,
0.20427730679512024,
-0.2384539544582367,
0.2836402952671051,
-1.312728762626648,
-0.6710782051086426,
0.540867805480957,
-0.4214555323123932,
0.10026709735393524,
-0.4308447539806366,
-0.6029388904571533,
-0.21116149425506592,
-0.3547966182231903,
0.12422564625740051,
0.0006903574103489518,
-0.5934362411499023,
0.3969404101371765,
0.5554347038269043,
-0.3744058907032013,
-0.3340540826320648,
-0.5747602581977844,
0.2840369641780853,
-0.5082280039787292,
-0.8786179423332214,
0.0499100498855114,
-0.28233063220977783,
-0.3838169574737549,
-0.5587033629417419,
0.30736544728279114,
-0.13376033306121826,
0.08626174926757812,
0.3906841576099396,
0.22368480265140533,
-0.25899118185043335,
0.11967211216688156,
0.05891541391611099,
0.19419819116592407,
0.056192461401224136,
0.08250529319047928,
0.6098531484603882,
-0.06179330497980118,
-0.5678316950798035,
-0.4308944642543793,
0.19447579979896545,
0.6219452023506165,
0.02931816503405571,
0.6219362616539001,
0.10949688404798508,
-0.1698150634765625,
-0.07835172116756439,
-0.4164707660675049,
-0.0930333286523819,
-0.4731590449810028,
0.315477579832077,
-0.5301988124847412,
-0.7190040349960327,
0.5920582413673401,
0.046530406922101974,
0.33106106519699097,
0.14009135961532593,
0.6078594326972961,
0.15972428023815155,
1.2430593967437744,
0.01304948516190052,
-0.021299347281455994,
0.3398851752281189,
0.012039173394441605,
0.4392193555831909,
-0.7101567387580872,
0.08136216551065445,
-0.2711280286312103,
-0.20913203060626984,
-0.6896416544914246,
-0.3527113199234009,
0.5534289479255676,
-0.33434829115867615,
-0.3114161193370819,
0.43052348494529724,
-0.2628314197063446,
0.39229336380958557,
0.2912706136703491,
-0.049647651612758636,
0.34130218625068665,
-0.11220818758010864,
0.09379648417234421,
-0.21990616619586945,
-0.6808594465255737,
-0.589775562286377,
0.8294132351875305,
0.6605761051177979,
0.7565723657608032,
0.19597117602825165,
0.3061518371105194,
0.1424088329076767,
0.2032509297132492,
-0.6807221174240112,
0.6228303909301758,
-0.2959649860858917,
-0.5937769412994385,
-0.23028169572353363,
-0.47319915890693665,
-0.8885736465454102,
0.7302474975585938,
0.3472476899623871,
-0.7100567817687988,
0.11700986325740814,
0.1505470871925354,
-0.2340119630098343,
0.2540784478187561,
-0.8408075571060181,
0.8660337328910828,
-0.23333793878555298,
-0.40483492612838745,
-0.06605212390422821,
-0.6015243530273438,
0.7849007844924927,
-0.02973460964858532,
0.25226348638534546,
-0.3947400748729706,
0.46394670009613037,
0.5558810830116272,
-0.36876174807548523,
0.8518309593200684,
-0.19480718672275543,
-0.33030667901039124,
0.1599258929491043,
0.26434773206710815,
0.7101148962974548,
0.005710481200367212,
-0.1925809532403946,
0.2492351084947586,
0.18840569257736206,
-0.09822999686002731,
-0.7624564170837402,
0.6302981376647949,
-0.4439081847667694,
-0.8164991140365601,
-0.5532906651496887,
-0.8295712471008301,
-0.14441755414009094,
-0.10138711333274841,
0.17010323703289032,
0.6889901161193848,
0.028620461001992226,
0.2335796058177948,
0.6316174864768982,
-0.23238924145698547,
0.18601730465888977,
0.7709367871284485,
-0.22947750985622406,
-0.13645100593566895,
1.0870349407196045,
0.3933520019054413,
0.5371618866920471,
0.05706864222884178,
0.37606602907180786,
-0.04369909316301346,
-0.43639013171195984,
-0.723318338394165,
0.4645536243915558,
-0.6201646327972412,
0.03644638881087303,
-0.5005114078521729,
-0.4763760268688202,
-0.24011391401290894,
0.007574484217911959,
-0.1264984905719757,
-0.04521233215928078,
-0.030666140839457512,
0.05146031081676483,
0.11503547430038452,
0.5498878359794617,
0.13580051064491272,
0.43491867184638977,
-0.6102256178855896,
0.4192619323730469,
-0.02777337096631527,
0.05778972804546356,
0.004315229598432779,
-1.092750072479248,
-0.24958375096321106,
0.5647866129875183,
-0.3021050691604614,
-0.8954822421073914,
0.5289127826690674,
0.19607391953468323,
0.46197575330734253,
0.606895387172699,
0.1626027524471283,
0.9443109035491943,
-0.4372861981391907,
0.8619773983955383,
-0.0987020954489708,
-0.7195445895195007,
0.2420334666967392,
-0.5893755555152893,
0.23924760520458221,
0.2925988435745239,
0.2998422384262085,
-0.9791080355644226,
-0.8509346842765808,
-0.5898676514625549,
-0.5758275389671326,
0.9438096284866333,
0.014038890600204468,
0.44229811429977417,
-0.08418133854866028,
0.2271602600812912,
0.1753252148628235,
0.10140688717365265,
-0.7320092916488647,
-0.2598988115787506,
0.08831405639648438,
-0.2328503131866455,
-0.042340438812971115,
-0.3077255189418793,
-0.22436560690402985,
-0.013376343064010143,
0.702606201171875,
-0.32224351167678833,
0.1250002533197403,
0.06698265671730042,
-0.13298256695270538,
-0.13471774756908417,
0.1255398839712143,
0.76246178150177,
0.8728114366531372,
0.038353849202394485,
0.12377205491065979,
0.042771827429533005,
-0.4765092730522156,
0.13550953567028046,
0.17141835391521454,
0.048972055315971375,
0.16894303262233734,
0.4585714340209961,
0.8736668229103088,
0.1589132398366928,
-0.7317493557929993,
0.8100941181182861,
-0.06603401154279709,
-0.09057677537202835,
-0.583816647529602,
0.029190294444561005,
-0.0982375368475914,
0.3066540062427521,
0.31355777382850647,
-0.4195540249347687,
0.19690893590450287,
-0.5657569766044617,
0.04769338294863701,
0.6293317079544067,
-0.1760704070329666,
-0.3143962621688843,
0.4615298807621002,
-0.09434186667203903,
-0.15299443900585175,
0.22493602335453033,
-0.296764075756073,
-0.5476982593536377,
0.4973670244216919,
0.5768948197364807,
0.7523697018623352,
-0.28795284032821655,
0.5729519724845886,
0.22806181013584137,
0.21605916321277618,
-0.07393921911716461,
0.00701977638527751,
0.11474233120679855,
-0.8968520760536194,
-0.4824111759662628,
-0.28805816173553467,
-0.7154667973518372,
0.3220793306827545,
-0.3579970896244049,
0.3377271294593811,
-0.4971790909767151,
0.17915309965610504,
0.05495138093829155,
-0.1770869642496109,
-0.17785659432411194,
-0.05081221088767052,
0.037683337926864624,
0.5724495649337769,
-0.7801868915557861,
0.6838493943214417,
0.2975613474845886,
-0.4151281416416168,
-1.1041269302368164,
0.24490292370319366,
0.10863087326288223,
-0.9076788425445557,
0.4557203948497772,
0.1488848626613617,
-0.20717254281044006,
-0.09242962300777435,
-0.8003577589988708,
-0.6737435460090637,
0.8417380452156067,
0.8246274590492249,
-0.5226364135742188,
-0.1903504729270935,
0.3846474587917328,
0.4257000684738159,
-0.13462316989898682,
0.5690286159515381,
0.5767585635185242,
0.4010375738143921,
0.23633915185928345,
-1.2047513723373413,
-0.02803031913936138,
-0.23457694053649902,
-0.1254863440990448,
0.21316826343536377,
-0.7730503678321838,
0.9774674773216248,
-0.000023823864466976374,
-0.2952728569507599,
0.09286085516214371,
0.32338008284568787,
0.3707349896430969,
0.35913440585136414,
0.11610445380210876,
0.18247666954994202,
0.7414590120315552,
0.0484088696539402,
1.1262238025665283,
-0.4306659400463104,
0.1869417428970337,
1.1050773859024048,
-0.4723494350910187,
0.4216119050979614,
0.2951582372188568,
-0.17237979173660278,
0.41164541244506836,
0.47928065061569214,
0.21316878497600555,
0.04972188547253609,
0.2445610612630844,
-0.24193720519542694,
-0.16500462591648102,
-0.4020952582359314,
-0.1402159482240677,
0.4805960953235626,
0.5135157704353333,
-0.5371650457382202,
-0.22094044089317322,
0.1339855045080185,
0.5983150005340576,
-0.04495973885059357,
-0.17472738027572632,
0.8278994560241699,
0.2970322072505951,
-0.7411987781524658,
0.6880900263786316,
0.07829904556274414,
0.38359105587005615,
-0.7755746245384216,
-0.2234690934419632,
-0.2509876787662506,
0.23351836204528809,
-0.09096764773130417,
-0.9795951843261719,
0.04922099784016609,
-0.11196864396333694,
0.12606988847255707,
-0.07558035850524902,
0.6293619275093079,
-0.7340357899665833,
-0.3075557351112366,
0.0022157863713800907,
0.2422732561826706,
0.5224147439002991,
-0.14565737545490265,
-0.6355279684066772,
-0.20304718613624573,
0.05794360488653183,
-0.0740588828921318,
0.30917322635650635,
0.6419264078140259,
-0.16140982508659363,
0.8275110125541687,
0.6281225681304932,
0.15826784074306488,
-0.10841889679431915,
-0.05222281813621521,
0.7107539772987366,
-0.463079571723938,
-0.33383551239967346,
-1.1665031909942627,
0.28574103116989136,
-0.19554327428340912,
-0.2724608778953552,
1.0045467615127563,
0.5063573122024536,
0.5757620930671692,
0.08159847557544708,
0.816929817199707,
0.2567893862724304,
0.750045657157898,
-0.5079298615455627,
0.5790664553642273,
-0.3846365511417389,
0.1700940877199173,
-0.2970513701438904,
-0.514758825302124,
-0.051716458052396774,
0.5220233798027039,
-0.6155734658241272,
-0.21753418445587158,
0.4727509617805481,
0.9474477171897888,
-0.021342379972338676,
0.28925687074661255,
0.5238360166549683,
0.2632000744342804,
0.5508704781532288,
0.6934345364570618,
0.9586375951766968,
-0.11182451993227005,
0.3717367649078369,
-0.15106095373630524,
-0.026516828685998917,
-0.27207842469215393,
-0.5521402955055237,
-0.8984563946723938,
-0.6388133764266968,
0.016529275104403496,
-0.1948319971561432,
0.12243086844682693,
1.17405366897583,
0.37541210651397705,
-0.615101158618927,
-0.5714734196662903,
0.02806445024907589,
0.17074410617351532,
-0.027293406426906586,
-0.27810898423194885,
0.1190493106842041,
-0.30040332674980164,
-0.7747148871421814,
0.46272313594818115,
0.3662504553794861,
-0.23826181888580322,
-0.3847411572933197,
-0.05440215766429901,
-0.19021621346473694,
0.3311291038990021,
0.5163437128067017,
0.1221972331404686,
-0.7676709294319153,
-0.5259743928909302,
-0.15840615332126617,
-0.014584682881832123,
0.18609052896499634,
0.9655495285987854,
-0.32490214705467224,
0.5916496515274048,
0.4271809160709381,
0.4104318618774414,
0.15277314186096191,
0.12173096090555191,
0.7626513838768005,
-0.5610005259513855,
0.06839283555746078,
0.21552856266498566,
0.3780948221683502,
0.4364771246910095,
-0.34789490699768066,
0.30932244658470154,
0.3266145586967468,
-0.6168040037155151,
-0.9081448912620544,
0.4056188464164734,
-0.48969364166259766,
-0.10014528036117554,
1.1837228536605835,
-0.42783230543136597,
-0.012363768182694912,
-0.34468579292297363,
-0.5522915124893188,
0.1870252639055252,
-0.2753429710865021,
0.42255836725234985,
0.9916635155677795,
-0.19567395746707916,
-0.2956234812736511,
-0.7738214731216431,
0.3077428638935089,
0.3066265881061554,
-0.5611764192581177,
0.5172151923179626,
0.33837103843688965,
0.06539932638406754,
0.08600829541683197,
0.43060302734375,
0.08608080446720123,
0.2254021316766739,
-0.14692042768001556,
-0.35329389572143555,
-0.05362195521593094,
-0.11928338557481766,
-0.25635063648223877,
0.11699037253856659,
0.20339089632034302,
-0.07652179151773453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19505v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19505v1
|
Context-Aware Machine Translation with Source Coreference Explanation
| 2024-04-30T12:41:00 | 2024-04-30T12:41:00 |
Huy Hien Vu, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite significant improvements in enhancing the quality of translation,
context-aware machine translation (MT) models underperform in many cases. One
of the main reasons is that they fail to utilize the correct features from
context when the context is too long or their models are overly complex. This
can lead to the explain-away effect, wherein the models only consider features
easier to explain predictions, resulting in inaccurate translations. To address
this issue, we propose a model that explains the decisions made for translation
by predicting coreference features in the input. We construct a model for input
coreference by exploiting contextual features from both the input and
translation output representations on top of an existing MT model. We evaluate
and analyze our method in the WMT document-level translation task of
English-German dataset, the English-Russian dataset, and the multilingual TED
talk dataset, demonstrating an improvement of over 1.0 BLEU score when compared
with other context-aware models.
|
[
-0.49418431520462036,
-0.7343699336051941,
0.774566650390625,
-0.07482032477855682,
-0.6624540686607361,
-0.2954832911491394,
-0.5227841138839722,
-0.6324660778045654,
-0.16308976709842682,
0.5083727836608887,
-0.4908024072647095,
-0.43481191992759705,
-0.9549421668052673,
0.1928783804178238,
-0.2900841236114502,
1.0420838594436646,
-0.1987389326095581,
0.09040971100330353,
-0.38660523295402527,
-0.3159325122833252,
-1.009458065032959,
-0.5693292021751404,
-0.1859448403120041,
-0.703305721282959,
0.30855751037597656,
0.6375308036804199,
0.8417354226112366,
0.6689403653144836,
0.5050299763679504,
0.1921396255493164,
-0.1989201456308365,
0.17517489194869995,
0.00758409546688199,
0.02481909841299057,
-0.5032164454460144,
-0.3176195025444031,
-0.41597798466682434,
0.02218596450984478,
0.45310765504837036,
0.8429937958717346,
0.2618231475353241,
0.1653539538383484,
0.1376231461763382,
0.3209044635295868,
-0.33159229159355164,
0.14477944374084473,
-0.6217873096466064,
-0.17102305591106415,
-0.05403923988342285,
-0.36112165451049805,
-0.5515692830085754,
0.013575066812336445,
0.23899444937705994,
-0.3523131012916565,
0.311130553483963,
0.10887012630701065,
0.6010180115699768,
0.33839255571365356,
-0.6765134334564209,
-0.4502204656600952,
-0.7457181215286255,
0.8327766060829163,
-0.6037423610687256,
0.32429930567741394,
0.5198047757148743,
0.25876694917678833,
0.05469715967774391,
-0.46371540427207947,
-0.6745690107345581,
-0.05811884254217148,
-0.42372748255729675,
0.14901253581047058,
-0.24569174647331238,
-0.23589833080768585,
0.16548435389995575,
0.19917428493499756,
-0.5298938751220703,
0.006066922564059496,
-0.21160171926021576,
-0.04004758223891258,
0.1642611175775528,
-0.08252136409282684,
0.05043137073516846,
-0.4820973873138428,
-0.3406990170478821,
0.14500842988491058,
-0.5788630247116089,
0.0990222916007042,
-0.4459806978702545,
0.4624144732952118,
0.054075032472610474,
0.5779202580451965,
-0.04838564619421959,
0.7978373169898987,
0.3226154148578644,
-0.17778567969799042,
0.2419435977935791,
-0.42343997955322266,
-0.2772996425628662,
0.3200569450855255,
0.40023475885391235,
0.4880477786064148,
-0.09272929280996323,
-0.27341923117637634,
-0.02690272033214569,
-0.24881340563297272,
0.036221232265233994,
-0.8258790373802185,
0.3367723524570465,
0.4391896426677704,
-0.43754398822784424,
-0.07277795672416687,
-0.08025765419006348,
-0.1669127345085144,
-0.1464904099702835,
-0.5258461236953735,
0.1976194977760315,
-0.5921667218208313,
-0.09078505635261536,
-0.16027116775512695,
-0.10385077446699142,
-0.08436012268066406,
0.41663891077041626,
-0.4583640992641449,
-0.14982356131076813,
0.4950876832008362,
0.9060883522033691,
-0.37580111622810364,
-0.34630411863327026,
-0.5383675694465637,
0.4206724464893341,
-0.20215070247650146,
0.7372742295265198,
-0.5370152592658997,
-0.7166842818260193,
-0.2362070381641388,
0.21786829829216003,
-0.1353149563074112,
-0.5887157917022705,
0.8853298425674438,
-0.21368499100208282,
0.48432669043540955,
-0.3955816924571991,
-0.573216438293457,
-0.48599275946617126,
0.2353111207485199,
-0.3415951430797577,
0.877687931060791,
0.11937830597162247,
-0.7238516211509705,
0.29327014088630676,
-0.8855612874031067,
-0.7084430456161499,
0.09665172547101974,
0.3172600567340851,
-0.1869814395904541,
0.38982436060905457,
0.4497073292732239,
0.6850948333740234,
-0.4089783728122711,
0.7207631468772888,
-0.13452841341495514,
-0.19440409541130066,
0.46960023045539856,
-0.1156952902674675,
0.663404643535614,
0.3105393052101135,
-0.3013085424900055,
0.4367538094520569,
-0.45300859212875366,
-0.20414520800113678,
0.022012729197740555,
-0.04815319553017616,
-0.5967196822166443,
-0.01779934950172901,
-0.0005026980070397258,
0.5919148325920105,
0.26165086030960083,
-0.46362385153770447,
0.05806741863489151,
-0.054427068680524826,
0.6892522573471069,
0.42833995819091797,
-0.045558854937553406,
0.8227235078811646,
-0.14603815972805023,
0.36258581280708313,
0.31541258096694946,
0.05431312695145607,
-0.3419997990131378,
-0.39161887764930725,
-0.4193938374519348,
-0.10468363761901855,
0.33131447434425354,
0.6041007041931152,
-0.8317304253578186,
0.5612503290176392,
-0.4902452826499939,
-0.3658386766910553,
-0.35950782895088196,
0.10846203565597534,
0.4303411543369293,
1.0153981447219849,
0.6175113916397095,
-0.12193011492490768,
-0.4043283760547638,
-1.0640764236450195,
-0.21348458528518677,
0.02937280759215355,
-0.09080992639064789,
0.23698344826698303,
0.733322024345398,
-0.40992411971092224,
0.9931031465530396,
-0.31221577525138855,
-0.2676435112953186,
-0.47168439626693726,
0.10138003528118134,
0.19401931762695312,
0.7879090309143066,
0.41609805822372437,
-0.8393186926841736,
-0.2349347323179245,
0.23613660037517548,
-0.6290535926818848,
-0.15094143152236938,
-0.09304267168045044,
-0.24019138514995575,
0.0066842748783528805,
0.2644285261631012,
-0.7683385014533997,
0.1838207095861435,
0.6682342886924744,
-0.29090484976768494,
0.4894058406352997,
-0.07068366557359695,
0.1537667214870453,
-1.5419752597808838,
0.4273965656757355,
-0.20342496037483215,
-0.5536361336708069,
-0.5194363594055176,
-0.0019008509116247296,
0.30521464347839355,
-0.3411039113998413,
-0.4824046790599823,
0.5970011949539185,
-0.23333342373371124,
0.05253613740205765,
-0.43905767798423767,
0.39705440402030945,
0.33398357033729553,
0.29606547951698303,
0.1568138748407364,
0.8621741533279419,
0.21668240427970886,
-0.6287307143211365,
-0.007129684090614319,
0.4873621463775635,
-0.1228880062699318,
0.9316807985305786,
-0.6048632264137268,
0.04238472878932953,
-0.01444834191352129,
0.4560166001319885,
-0.795602023601532,
-0.1696351170539856,
0.10743936151266098,
-0.7242894768714905,
0.4277254641056061,
-0.1944550722837448,
-0.44265216588974,
-0.14034228026866913,
0.29510191082954407,
0.21734803915023804,
0.28510433435440063,
-0.5246142148971558,
0.6130238771438599,
0.23288995027542114,
-0.07062391191720963,
-0.554496169090271,
-0.7168750166893005,
0.18734653294086456,
-0.34839949011802673,
-0.6129858493804932,
0.680585503578186,
-0.1446400284767151,
-0.031345345079898834,
0.14300552010536194,
-0.12899498641490936,
-0.22301717102527618,
0.22282907366752625,
0.4757351279258728,
0.07475028187036514,
-0.04135502874851227,
0.24729397892951965,
0.3600178062915802,
-0.2617185711860657,
0.03719837963581085,
-0.4927694797515869,
0.32548388838768005,
-0.20127622783184052,
-0.05993255227804184,
-0.307789146900177,
0.6741605401039124,
0.759462833404541,
-0.35447877645492554,
0.7322881817817688,
0.8198296427726746,
-0.3873664438724518,
0.01996944658458233,
-0.26495087146759033,
-0.2695806920528412,
-0.3514915406703949,
0.4179227948188782,
-0.6833489537239075,
-0.8844523429870605,
0.6089702248573303,
-0.2753375172615051,
-0.04412749037146568,
0.646531879901886,
0.556567370891571,
-0.2927435636520386,
0.987440288066864,
0.5500839352607727,
0.3052368760108948,
0.46770212054252625,
-0.015501495450735092,
0.18328501284122467,
-1.096744418144226,
-0.1138252392411232,
-0.5409491062164307,
-0.26101556420326233,
-0.30683398246765137,
-0.40707120299339294,
0.18684151768684387,
0.43786558508872986,
0.19888192415237427,
0.7705555558204651,
-0.4258422255516052,
0.2801615297794342,
0.67643141746521,
-0.000413157424191013,
0.3612789511680603,
-0.19432345032691956,
-0.26355496048927307,
-0.12449723482131958,
-0.7724329233169556,
-0.5700002312660217,
0.6435439586639404,
0.13089489936828613,
0.09509585052728653,
0.047475654631853104,
0.30173206329345703,
0.2982880771160126,
0.48227301239967346,
-0.7310293912887573,
0.34344494342803955,
-0.05607893317937851,
-0.84531569480896,
-0.045343831181526184,
-0.5234641432762146,
-0.810548722743988,
0.29742056131362915,
-0.21532602608203888,
-0.410854309797287,
0.10711789131164551,
0.26044535636901855,
-0.02246512658894062,
-0.03317077085375786,
-0.6848840117454529,
1.1609176397323608,
-0.2662918269634247,
-0.17014898359775543,
-0.26654350757598877,
-0.6525507569313049,
0.315032035112381,
-0.09548185765743256,
0.4259909987449646,
-0.20556803047657013,
0.24400372803211212,
0.5995476245880127,
-0.14922495186328888,
0.7228500843048096,
-0.06646999716758728,
0.1722778081893921,
0.2495972067117691,
0.39575663208961487,
0.35263770818710327,
0.010023795999586582,
-0.16035374999046326,
0.4651292562484741,
-0.03140179440379143,
-0.38861697912216187,
-0.6025368571281433,
0.6507385969161987,
-0.5847160220146179,
-0.535478413105011,
-0.07834568619728088,
-0.7218924164772034,
-0.15666711330413818,
0.3718085289001465,
0.619775652885437,
0.39630740880966187,
-0.18848079442977905,
0.34890487790107727,
0.3670569658279419,
-0.05857919901609421,
0.5638158917427063,
0.5029696226119995,
-0.07478874921798706,
-0.4175502061843872,
0.6108694672584534,
0.21276547014713287,
0.18339017033576965,
0.40710774064064026,
0.41547390818595886,
-0.34679532051086426,
-0.4463253915309906,
-0.8464828729629517,
0.09331399202346802,
-1.0276247262954712,
-0.17269667983055115,
-0.5806326270103455,
0.2453077733516693,
-0.44835707545280457,
-0.35498368740081787,
-0.28814050555229187,
-0.6077884435653687,
-0.2023610919713974,
-0.17099377512931824,
-0.05605665221810341,
0.43288329243659973,
0.24657867848873138,
0.6697049140930176,
-0.9513572454452515,
-0.10781002789735794,
0.038739364594221115,
0.0862816795706749,
-0.1792481541633606,
-0.9549424052238464,
-0.5786699652671814,
-0.057135723531246185,
-0.45542067289352417,
-1.000135898590088,
0.3963698148727417,
0.1058284118771553,
0.5775371193885803,
0.35315367579460144,
0.08015839010477066,
0.6714977622032166,
-0.581458568572998,
0.8306164741516113,
0.16435301303863525,
-1.400744915008545,
0.7647128105163574,
-0.15156777203083038,
0.7518245577812195,
0.42332541942596436,
0.29859599471092224,
-0.6995643973350525,
-0.23734305799007416,
-0.6492828130722046,
-0.568192720413208,
0.5260116457939148,
0.373687207698822,
-0.042063578963279724,
0.06434883177280426,
0.32842200994491577,
0.399709552526474,
0.2916490435600281,
-0.622467041015625,
-0.07492785155773163,
-0.2969508767127991,
-0.11911416798830032,
-0.3021104633808136,
-0.294503390789032,
-0.15614153444766998,
-0.17649628221988678,
0.6680346727371216,
-0.18599598109722137,
0.20043756067752838,
0.3568718731403351,
-0.5837442278862,
-0.16336636245250702,
0.5289507508277893,
1.0923266410827637,
0.9900866746902466,
-0.2663075923919678,
0.4550993740558624,
0.266886830329895,
-0.12605130672454834,
-0.2609706223011017,
0.07586008310317993,
-0.33588719367980957,
0.4892677068710327,
0.5073306560516357,
0.7745934724807739,
0.08358265459537506,
-0.48249536752700806,
0.3849838376045227,
0.10641206800937653,
0.09174270927906036,
-0.1871393322944641,
-0.26654526591300964,
0.14493529498577118,
0.01690198853611946,
0.4582172632217407,
0.4802590012550354,
0.19363664090633392,
-0.40953049063682556,
0.18555206060409546,
0.24567101895809174,
-0.6933165788650513,
-0.5409894585609436,
0.538789689540863,
0.4397560656070709,
-0.2687985897064209,
0.22178922593593597,
0.005402905400842428,
-0.7870798707008362,
0.3268395662307739,
0.6831367015838623,
0.8378093838691711,
-0.20738649368286133,
-0.10215183347463608,
0.5513115525245667,
0.38982313871383667,
0.09722721576690674,
-0.14616632461547852,
-0.21166974306106567,
-0.7049297094345093,
-0.6786949038505554,
-0.3413272500038147,
-0.5632224678993225,
-0.08440866321325302,
-0.8345947861671448,
0.10871163755655289,
0.03670001029968262,
-0.41683101654052734,
-0.1494448035955429,
-0.279630184173584,
-0.7421108484268188,
0.2665119767189026,
0.026036711409687996,
0.6346138119697571,
-0.8403891921043396,
1.0248794555664062,
0.8021618127822876,
-0.2830294370651245,
-0.29164859652519226,
-0.166768416762352,
-0.24235419929027557,
-0.552182137966156,
0.6063586473464966,
0.4190203547477722,
-0.10581488162279129,
-0.043555907905101776,
-0.4383352994918823,
-0.8186619877815247,
0.9195511937141418,
0.46220603585243225,
-0.31614598631858826,
0.15757408738136292,
-0.00281597045250237,
0.23185700178146362,
-0.6708735227584839,
0.02058153785765171,
0.4140714704990387,
0.5583833456039429,
-0.08095287531614304,
-1.1415215730667114,
0.27767419815063477,
-0.09234128892421722,
0.03710184246301651,
0.015539891086518764,
-0.09017890691757202,
0.5897846817970276,
-0.12561459839344025,
-0.1951359510421753,
-0.4069922864437103,
0.5642542243003845,
-0.0919812023639679,
0.4672430753707886,
0.39500701427459717,
0.3624264895915985,
0.5472131371498108,
-0.1323590874671936,
1.188711166381836,
-0.5865729451179504,
0.35658854246139526,
1.5159748792648315,
0.03754723072052002,
0.90718674659729,
0.611583411693573,
0.3643063008785248,
0.3614582121372223,
0.752327561378479,
0.38211485743522644,
0.3615472912788391,
-0.5025379061698914,
0.07996019721031189,
-0.41290968656539917,
-0.40066397190093994,
-0.3452286124229431,
0.48547568917274475,
0.5051497220993042,
-0.7580738067626953,
-0.2265477031469345,
0.3906930387020111,
0.17452791333198547,
0.06989910453557968,
-0.1880827397108078,
0.6721882224082947,
0.16248172521591187,
-0.9256626963615417,
0.6785303354263306,
0.32249000668525696,
0.3524775803089142,
-0.3260705769062042,
0.06348986178636551,
-0.19060538709163666,
0.12762397527694702,
-0.09925651550292969,
-0.8041234612464905,
0.6582384705543518,
-0.10771597176790237,
-0.6383344531059265,
-0.4870700240135193,
0.4914288818836212,
-0.4787368178367615,
-0.34181126952171326,
0.25091487169265747,
0.6777194142341614,
0.16178233921527863,
-0.412384033203125,
-0.775564432144165,
-0.016308827325701714,
-0.1888042688369751,
0.0359320193529129,
0.0653889924287796,
0.5817636251449585,
-0.21446357667446136,
0.4862355589866638,
0.7030573487281799,
-0.267206609249115,
-0.18904860317707062,
-0.28982067108154297,
0.5250840187072754,
-0.6955439448356628,
-0.5014976859092712,
-0.9452060461044312,
0.5310952067375183,
-0.135698139667511,
-0.5962028503417969,
0.7269179821014404,
0.39546915888786316,
0.7544748187065125,
-0.14501507580280304,
0.7446961402893066,
-0.1331721991300583,
0.4561011493206024,
-0.2682707905769348,
0.4452388286590576,
-0.38220763206481934,
0.056593939661979675,
-0.12251824140548706,
-1.041890025138855,
-0.28568196296691895,
0.3739798963069916,
-0.4140842854976654,
-0.3500894010066986,
0.9946778416633606,
0.28280243277549744,
-0.15637902915477753,
-0.16598422825336456,
0.5272626280784607,
0.19504953920841217,
0.2952275574207306,
0.41055405139923096,
0.44063395261764526,
-0.32422009110450745,
0.5750389695167542,
-0.43152403831481934,
-0.10903467237949371,
-0.4738915264606476,
-1.096533179283142,
-0.8860471248626709,
-0.7522194385528564,
-0.32657763361930847,
-0.49671146273612976,
-0.32341310381889343,
0.8895196318626404,
1.014577031135559,
-0.9155387878417969,
-0.023441195487976074,
0.19331346452236176,
0.38243424892425537,
-0.6103247404098511,
-0.1542632132768631,
0.35833740234375,
-0.21373651921749115,
-0.7580509185791016,
0.4504563808441162,
0.20412380993366241,
-0.025184379890561104,
0.052184686064720154,
-0.04376841336488724,
0.06824794411659241,
-0.014008942991495132,
0.882737398147583,
-0.17026565968990326,
-1.0185785293579102,
-0.44325023889541626,
0.10381454974412918,
-0.2902541756629944,
0.2417486310005188,
0.9882433414459229,
-0.47584155201911926,
0.6045857071876526,
0.3395560085773468,
0.5710131525993347,
0.3778701424598694,
0.25297170877456665,
0.7063025236129761,
-0.7313957214355469,
0.19957739114761353,
0.07712072134017944,
0.49983805418014526,
0.6071981191635132,
-0.4892214238643646,
0.41858044266700745,
0.3630560040473938,
-0.34849071502685547,
-0.5882575511932373,
0.42126578092575073,
-1.301344633102417,
-0.6235085129737854,
0.9624714851379395,
-0.28521254658699036,
-0.30423876643180847,
-0.18886293470859528,
-0.30547189712524414,
0.387336790561676,
-0.3683396577835083,
0.6062699556350708,
0.7856408357620239,
-0.03473182022571564,
-0.312447726726532,
-0.5807629227638245,
0.19759182631969452,
0.48490723967552185,
-0.42122793197631836,
0.20511983335018158,
0.46212953329086304,
0.30857357382774353,
0.4187008738517761,
0.10217013955116272,
-0.04247729107737541,
0.29353880882263184,
-0.2748645842075348,
0.33472511172294617,
-0.40428781509399414,
-0.11279062181711197,
-0.2893389165401459,
0.2012215405702591,
0.05436944589018822,
-0.1939719170331955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19486v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19486v1
|
Safe Training with Sensitive In-domain Data: Leveraging Data Fragmentation To Mitigate Linkage Attacks
| 2024-04-30T12:09:55 | 2024-04-30T12:09:55 |
Mariia Ignashina, Julia Ive
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Current text generation models are trained using real data which can
potentially contain sensitive information, such as confidential patient
information and the like. Under certain conditions output of the training data
which they have memorised can be triggered, exposing sensitive data. To
mitigate against this risk we propose a safer alternative which sees fragmented
data in the form of domain-specific short phrases randomly grouped together
shared instead of full texts. Thus, text fragments that could re-identify an
individual cannot be reproduced by the model in one sequence, giving
significant protection against linkage attacks. We fine-tune several
state-of-the-art LLMs using meaningful syntactic chunks to explore their
utility. In particular, we fine-tune BERT-based models to predict two
cardiovascular diagnoses. Our results demonstrate the capacity of LLMs to
benefit from the pre-trained knowledge and deliver classification results when
fine-tuned with fragmented data comparable to fine-tuning with full training
data.
|
[
-0.2968525290489197,
-0.9091134071350098,
0.3210434913635254,
-0.26811984181404114,
-0.60886150598526,
0.08361872285604477,
-0.04605960473418236,
-0.8669768571853638,
-0.010454257018864155,
0.6466590166091919,
-0.6794745326042175,
-0.4693230092525482,
-0.6574309468269348,
0.03502795472741127,
-0.587780237197876,
1.1618770360946655,
0.08381107449531555,
0.47679901123046875,
-0.44832509756088257,
-0.13784478604793549,
-0.25566184520721436,
-0.8894437551498413,
-0.5895248055458069,
-0.3215045630931854,
0.6066510081291199,
0.2468445748090744,
0.45825305581092834,
0.6680912375450134,
0.8992018699645996,
0.16584472358226776,
-0.06554346531629562,
0.16662266850471497,
-0.6427927613258362,
0.38008829951286316,
-0.01865318976342678,
-0.4479851722717285,
-0.5406526923179626,
-0.28689292073249817,
0.42566582560539246,
0.8432841300964355,
-0.002580666681751609,
-0.027410192415118217,
0.1271360218524933,
0.7207165956497192,
-0.40354156494140625,
-0.19618235528469086,
-0.794723629951477,
0.14055395126342773,
-0.34755271673202515,
-0.3614717125892639,
-0.39243677258491516,
-0.44087907671928406,
0.3724927008152008,
-0.2959892451763153,
0.484083354473114,
0.2751355469226837,
0.8355210423469543,
0.40450233221054077,
-0.35865283012390137,
-0.15713706612586975,
-0.44823458790779114,
0.6499438285827637,
-0.3840608298778534,
0.480932354927063,
0.5226010084152222,
0.11633966863155365,
-0.284590482711792,
-0.6659926176071167,
-0.20135827362537384,
0.2724986970424652,
0.12840722501277924,
-0.06287790089845657,
-0.1229318380355835,
0.3303850591182709,
0.08324051648378372,
0.3357633948326111,
-0.6907697916030884,
0.29834645986557007,
-0.34725695848464966,
-0.40131130814552307,
0.6484163403511047,
0.23879936337471008,
0.49173039197921753,
0.004817374516278505,
-0.7864403128623962,
0.03771313279867172,
-1.080894947052002,
-0.35792699456214905,
0.29270610213279724,
0.480908066034317,
-0.1725054532289505,
0.3990502953529358,
0.15472811460494995,
0.588936448097229,
0.049877166748046875,
-0.2824096977710724,
0.17367006838321686,
-0.20438964664936066,
-0.35920250415802,
0.27840131521224976,
0.7253607511520386,
0.2827158272266388,
0.3888058066368103,
-0.43090713024139404,
-0.03831440582871437,
0.03630809858441353,
0.464425653219223,
-0.9508607387542725,
-0.40638071298599243,
0.42679858207702637,
-0.5065114498138428,
-0.5256973505020142,
-0.1705990582704544,
-0.5164491534233093,
-0.15329916775226593,
-0.07681382447481155,
0.2088233232498169,
-0.7769397497177124,
0.1362549066543579,
0.1931934952735901,
-0.03219132125377655,
-0.25345665216445923,
0.2958700656890869,
-0.8442853689193726,
0.24616433680057526,
0.7704566121101379,
0.5618990659713745,
-0.44050613045692444,
-0.13242731988430023,
-0.312260240316391,
0.35788655281066895,
-0.08104762434959412,
0.8716278076171875,
-0.06594302505254745,
-0.6541598439216614,
0.22656770050525665,
-0.09659991413354874,
-0.07738032191991806,
-0.6788365840911865,
0.4887964725494385,
-0.5842545628547668,
0.041384827345609665,
-0.06686744093894958,
-0.9801303148269653,
0.08745955675840378,
0.28209108114242554,
-0.8281680345535278,
0.8421470522880554,
0.06065032631158829,
-1.0887444019317627,
0.6896791458129883,
-0.11105967313051224,
-0.6207227110862732,
0.09888138622045517,
-0.18106400966644287,
-0.9283401966094971,
0.01426730863749981,
0.21765361726284027,
0.5606840252876282,
-0.08766062557697296,
0.21514049172401428,
-0.5405744314193726,
0.006732060108333826,
0.4963389039039612,
-0.40906673669815063,
0.33278653025627136,
0.13970045745372772,
0.19590091705322266,
0.050473734736442566,
-0.7618116140365601,
0.217937633395195,
-0.14071586728096008,
-0.4143560230731964,
-0.4541761875152588,
0.10061516612768173,
0.07121695578098297,
-0.030155358836054802,
0.1965671181678772,
-0.5867031216621399,
0.051370780915021896,
-0.3393329679965973,
0.24517162144184113,
0.6920355558395386,
0.5804567337036133,
0.28474727272987366,
-0.8291736245155334,
0.3719380497932434,
0.3438698649406433,
0.56695556640625,
0.0935080349445343,
-0.5082049369812012,
-0.4176196753978729,
-0.4729291498661041,
0.2649706304073334,
0.3071083426475525,
-0.6896399855613708,
0.5660114884376526,
-0.3891627788543701,
-0.3079676628112793,
-0.44746243953704834,
0.16812096536159515,
0.31376805901527405,
0.7411909103393555,
0.5338571071624756,
-0.4352075159549713,
-0.36970508098602295,
-0.718338668346405,
-0.20856352150440216,
-0.12504011392593384,
-0.08767201006412506,
0.3317966163158417,
0.3154703676700592,
-0.3992023169994354,
0.6407669186592102,
-0.5602706670761108,
-0.20997299253940582,
-0.3273161053657532,
-0.04778751730918884,
-0.31465792655944824,
0.739205539226532,
0.29980966448783875,
-0.7795944213867188,
-0.39992383122444153,
-0.304364413022995,
-0.6147387623786926,
0.28398916125297546,
-0.1918332278728485,
-0.3369094431400299,
-0.3430713415145874,
0.49848589301109314,
-0.316910982131958,
0.4108006954193115,
0.3374810814857483,
-0.17725501954555511,
0.13640987873077393,
-0.3075329661369324,
-0.25936055183410645,
-1.1558630466461182,
-0.13167783617973328,
-0.17632466554641724,
-0.4282459318637848,
-0.8919519186019897,
0.00988522544503212,
0.07726795971393585,
-0.002893902827054262,
-0.4183696210384369,
0.3090756833553314,
-0.20742937922477722,
0.358828604221344,
-0.18122068047523499,
-0.2410893738269806,
-0.1325216293334961,
0.10114068537950516,
0.06572794914245605,
0.451106458902359,
0.5358856320381165,
-0.5012655258178711,
-0.22320835292339325,
0.5786667466163635,
-0.49396225810050964,
0.4724985659122467,
-0.6332876086235046,
0.27934685349464417,
-0.1583293229341507,
0.08396963775157928,
-0.6088095903396606,
-0.47857844829559326,
0.0055104391649365425,
-0.32641053199768066,
0.6534302234649658,
-0.06731484085321426,
-0.564423680305481,
-0.11688166111707687,
-0.40334534645080566,
0.6776348352432251,
0.45610395073890686,
-0.6653636693954468,
0.09094845503568649,
0.6382483243942261,
-0.09239648282527924,
-0.4460771679878235,
-0.7778305411338806,
-0.29772675037384033,
-0.48461535573005676,
-0.7559012174606323,
0.27462098002433777,
-0.2948603928089142,
0.24538879096508026,
-0.14982274174690247,
-0.24193038046360016,
-0.54270339012146,
0.4485263228416443,
0.5839858651161194,
0.48563799262046814,
0.1845203936100006,
0.24783921241760254,
0.25035396218299866,
0.1496056318283081,
0.10655750334262848,
-0.15564265847206116,
0.4231669306755066,
0.3080742359161377,
-0.41616666316986084,
-0.405988484621048,
0.5705862641334534,
0.329558789730072,
0.0006400838610716164,
0.6994277834892273,
0.6073623299598694,
-0.5228052735328674,
-0.5569691061973572,
-0.2314823567867279,
-0.42270785570144653,
-0.4871656596660614,
0.22173741459846497,
0.031508829444646835,
-1.188704013824463,
0.27477917075157166,
-0.3418383002281189,
-0.14333809912204742,
0.17878524959087372,
0.40761664509773254,
-0.5525428056716919,
0.6314414143562317,
0.9164126515388489,
-0.13816477358341217,
0.4989752471446991,
-0.07626616954803467,
0.16499528288841248,
-0.7097137570381165,
-0.5160425901412964,
-0.40322345495224,
-0.3723362982273102,
-0.5034801959991455,
-0.4932217597961426,
0.6151339411735535,
0.18672606348991394,
-0.10036221891641617,
-0.11461861431598663,
-0.5646559000015259,
0.5439218282699585,
0.30995073914527893,
0.6499487161636353,
-0.0004828467790503055,
0.2576090395450592,
-0.14303340017795563,
0.0036575172562152147,
-0.822393536567688,
-0.3054935038089752,
1.5207853317260742,
0.34344547986984253,
1.155393123626709,
-0.16456158459186554,
1.1258697509765625,
0.36393263936042786,
0.287558376789093,
-0.6260249018669128,
0.3538881838321686,
-0.2010558843612671,
-0.7698324918746948,
-0.10972459614276886,
-0.4794906675815582,
-1.2146414518356323,
-0.20782212913036346,
-0.41649916768074036,
-0.7150049805641174,
0.13540126383304596,
0.056306663900613785,
-0.44067642092704773,
0.4746105372905731,
-0.4222410023212433,
0.5818924903869629,
-0.28758758306503296,
-0.1680685430765152,
-0.009085660800337791,
-0.9499859809875488,
0.30353808403015137,
-0.6002607345581055,
0.1011640727519989,
-0.3043975532054901,
-0.06590262055397034,
0.7543788552284241,
-0.75059974193573,
1.0725667476654053,
0.264358252286911,
0.039226286113262177,
0.2280660718679428,
-0.07891901582479477,
0.26599517464637756,
-0.06709356606006622,
0.24672074615955353,
0.356740802526474,
-0.13721969723701477,
-0.5262778401374817,
-0.35687729716300964,
0.678486168384552,
-0.9424710273742676,
-0.17070284485816956,
-0.3388504385948181,
-0.5396573543548584,
-0.479694128036499,
0.052612584084272385,
0.5801006555557251,
0.4898754060268402,
-0.1792880892753601,
0.07418163120746613,
0.9815990328788757,
0.11285565793514252,
0.34124132990837097,
0.35296040773391724,
0.5042374730110168,
-0.6101993322372437,
0.8892943263053894,
-0.19331204891204834,
0.40549126267433167,
0.4826223850250244,
0.05270548537373543,
-0.2916416525840759,
-0.9462611079216003,
-0.23710310459136963,
0.18465667963027954,
-0.7569022178649902,
-0.5167827010154724,
-0.3864053189754486,
-0.26167914271354675,
-0.07622198760509491,
-0.32283711433410645,
-0.13978609442710876,
-0.3634154796600342,
-0.4766908586025238,
-0.3459595739841461,
0.357911080121994,
0.7235217094421387,
0.0766347125172615,
0.4643687903881073,
-1.2913610935211182,
0.07993625104427338,
-0.013394800946116447,
0.2321351319551468,
-0.33162954449653625,
-0.17424750328063965,
-0.5910882949829102,
-0.29571282863616943,
-0.10520362108945847,
-0.7825195789337158,
0.413397878408432,
0.33502840995788574,
0.4775618016719818,
0.3475911021232605,
0.1824597716331482,
0.5416345596313477,
-0.5933349132537842,
0.8102740049362183,
0.3994481861591339,
-0.6642573475837708,
0.6513103246688843,
-0.17954732477664948,
-0.025732073932886124,
0.9159070253372192,
0.6159135103225708,
-0.09851069003343582,
-0.4441060423851013,
-0.8128691911697388,
-0.9749671220779419,
0.3278850018978119,
-0.007333197630941868,
-0.14152716100215912,
-0.228455051779747,
0.5626569986343384,
0.3216756284236908,
0.24149519205093384,
-0.5013327598571777,
-0.2876306176185608,
0.2358490228652954,
-0.5926716327667236,
0.12036892026662827,
-0.40565723180770874,
-0.5438270568847656,
-0.0803140252828598,
0.42092204093933105,
-0.10781897604465485,
0.2501908838748932,
0.3824256658554077,
-0.22089940309524536,
-0.31296229362487793,
0.10262090712785721,
0.19762848317623138,
0.32911044359207153,
-0.2006080001592636,
0.17676790058612823,
0.10691150277853012,
-0.9032206535339355,
0.25824257731437683,
-0.008751299232244492,
-0.21957187354564667,
0.12535594403743744,
0.6247851252555847,
0.4720919728279114,
0.4643053412437439,
-0.7285259366035461,
0.5858058929443359,
-0.1735934168100357,
-0.2562813460826874,
-0.060510069131851196,
0.27632269263267517,
-0.171793594956398,
0.10691414773464203,
-0.10811136662960052,
0.34365832805633545,
-0.1106196790933609,
-0.21025656163692474,
0.6389733552932739,
0.30866605043411255,
-0.44654256105422974,
-0.3390752673149109,
0.7795517444610596,
0.2728983759880066,
0.037671007215976715,
0.46744489669799805,
0.27745071053504944,
-0.41427528858184814,
0.3942563533782959,
0.4714703857898712,
0.8793439865112305,
-0.3044676184654236,
-0.020074136555194855,
0.1298818439245224,
0.23105983436107635,
-0.03588845208287239,
0.548666775226593,
-0.018774356693029404,
-0.7402517795562744,
-0.1275092214345932,
-0.6043819785118103,
-0.4356658458709717,
-0.060517266392707825,
-1.0352959632873535,
0.015937766060233116,
-0.682152509689331,
-0.3471996486186981,
-0.11276987195014954,
-0.08112500607967377,
-0.6455516219139099,
0.529644250869751,
0.31274837255477905,
0.9661268591880798,
-0.7787126302719116,
1.3917640447616577,
0.5938227772712708,
-0.30394887924194336,
-0.8089598417282104,
0.14634239673614502,
-0.05646388605237007,
-0.7915295362472534,
0.565397322177887,
-0.019296789541840553,
0.3344986140727997,
-0.5581868290901184,
-0.423372745513916,
-0.7525933980941772,
0.9670718312263489,
0.2293807566165924,
-0.6135837435722351,
-0.18032985925674438,
0.559381902217865,
0.4782721698284149,
-0.1807684302330017,
-0.19793345034122467,
0.49325689673423767,
-0.00516133476048708,
-0.08306927978992462,
-0.783621072769165,
0.17070196568965912,
0.1119585782289505,
-0.3081244230270386,
0.4113093614578247,
-0.569237232208252,
0.8884947299957275,
-0.1805081069469452,
-0.10318863391876221,
0.051526691764593124,
0.41079455614089966,
0.04993510618805885,
0.3171827495098114,
0.4135395288467407,
0.7663892507553101,
1.2672951221466064,
-0.20188841223716736,
1.1344115734100342,
-0.572890043258667,
0.16410022974014282,
1.173147439956665,
-0.1063094437122345,
1.0259251594543457,
0.29733091592788696,
-0.10021893680095673,
0.303804874420166,
0.7637539505958557,
0.11793926358222961,
0.7705731391906738,
0.20714125037193298,
-0.7338194847106934,
-0.3407299220561981,
-0.02029172144830227,
-0.42942720651626587,
0.2271806299686432,
0.4512487053871155,
-0.3775589168071747,
-0.1800628900527954,
0.0011060027172788978,
0.0829218178987503,
-0.19337503612041473,
-0.27172407507896423,
0.9416181445121765,
0.2334228903055191,
-0.1320214718580246,
0.54061359167099,
-0.3210587799549103,
0.566112756729126,
-0.8139411807060242,
0.35140976309776306,
-0.20245668292045593,
0.1680627167224884,
-0.43240463733673096,
-0.4866269528865814,
0.24216806888580322,
0.059376221150159836,
-0.2502346336841583,
-0.1842944175004959,
0.9249812364578247,
-0.6540335416793823,
-0.260110080242157,
0.08382415026426315,
0.542214572429657,
0.1926351636648178,
0.04814371466636658,
-0.7217214107513428,
0.14657104015350342,
0.20014993846416473,
0.09074392914772034,
0.7334999442100525,
0.5144065022468567,
0.10954531282186508,
0.694642961025238,
0.6728309988975525,
0.37856829166412354,
-0.005861516110599041,
0.11480241268873215,
1.1019600629806519,
-0.6468710899353027,
-0.404050350189209,
-0.7218757271766663,
0.35061097145080566,
-0.09797194600105286,
-0.2310635894536972,
0.6092720031738281,
0.6870459914207458,
0.82218337059021,
0.2243453711271286,
0.9031375646591187,
0.6874869465827942,
0.6009384989738464,
-0.520952582359314,
0.9178057909011841,
-0.5006657838821411,
0.37532737851142883,
-0.014865010045468807,
-0.34894269704818726,
-0.4764229655265808,
0.17801226675510406,
-0.054884426295757294,
-0.31344205141067505,
0.7591956257820129,
0.47999995946884155,
0.09186657518148422,
0.20047502219676971,
0.32306963205337524,
-0.0373012013733387,
0.5812980532646179,
0.5817342400550842,
0.6853925585746765,
-0.3204555809497833,
0.45399174094200134,
-0.3948361873626709,
0.008449659682810307,
-0.24509063363075256,
-0.7262927293777466,
-1.2164008617401123,
-0.2068065106868744,
-0.43987080454826355,
-0.28862178325653076,
0.12688474357128143,
0.7814728617668152,
0.9832020401954651,
-0.6057511568069458,
0.10081077367067337,
-0.026410069316625595,
0.08336302638053894,
0.1287240982055664,
-0.06618158519268036,
0.5645241737365723,
-0.43366390466690063,
-0.3968704044818878,
0.596534252166748,
0.31680968403816223,
0.6354897022247314,
0.014812521636486053,
0.12140248715877533,
0.28441929817199707,
0.12045833468437195,
0.3401540219783783,
0.07832818478345871,
-0.34163740277290344,
-0.316826194524765,
-0.322013795375824,
-0.22179098427295685,
0.08427217602729797,
0.9076003432273865,
-0.6945043802261353,
0.44865942001342773,
0.22882282733917236,
0.8396809697151184,
0.2611178457736969,
0.22527974843978882,
0.5232594609260559,
-0.9602290987968445,
0.1968836486339569,
0.5954306125640869,
0.4579871594905853,
0.37869614362716675,
-0.7072724103927612,
0.4273901581764221,
0.2342642992734909,
-0.6858218908309937,
-0.8838006258010864,
0.034943562000989914,
-1.204252004623413,
-0.39577189087867737,
0.9011332392692566,
-0.33602431416511536,
-0.4030153453350067,
-0.226309671998024,
0.16852357983589172,
0.07963892072439194,
-0.23143403232097626,
0.7463652491569519,
0.28494465351104736,
-0.29601484537124634,
0.47664034366607666,
-0.31518012285232544,
0.9382244348526001,
0.5111390352249146,
-1.0410406589508057,
-0.13719895482063293,
0.32846733927726746,
0.5174691081047058,
-0.327075332403183,
0.49669352173805237,
-0.15628069639205933,
0.10425405949354172,
-0.048151880502700806,
-0.2050665020942688,
0.1048346757888794,
-0.4103330671787262,
-0.27631062269210815,
0.4101799726486206,
0.05670447647571564,
-0.4092790484428406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19484v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19484v2
|
More Compute Is What You Need
| 2024-04-30T12:05:48 | 2024-05-02T01:58:15 |
Zhen Guo
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language model pre-training has become increasingly expensive, with
most practitioners relying on scaling laws to allocate compute budgets for
model size and training tokens, commonly referred to as Compute-Optimal or
Chinchilla Optimal. In this paper, we hypothesize a new scaling law that
suggests model performance depends mostly on the amount of compute spent for
transformer-based models, independent of the specific allocation to model size
and dataset size. Using this unified scaling law, we predict that (a) for
inference efficiency, training should prioritize smaller model sizes and larger
training datasets, and (b) assuming the exhaustion of available web datasets,
scaling the model size might be the only way to further improve model
performance.
|
[
-0.33415719866752625,
-0.34205499291419983,
0.528761625289917,
0.31869837641716003,
-0.009448355063796043,
-0.3215968608856201,
-0.45119771361351013,
-0.35942989587783813,
0.11549314111471176,
0.6578424572944641,
-0.36952126026153564,
0.4670885503292084,
-0.6444417238235474,
-0.19525215029716492,
-0.4859079420566559,
0.729021430015564,
0.46659332513809204,
0.2043134868144989,
-0.4120216369628906,
0.17966040968894958,
-0.21141068637371063,
-0.47474780678749084,
-0.5708214044570923,
-0.6461002826690674,
0.3195574879646301,
0.3136309087276459,
1.0633866786956787,
1.017545223236084,
0.690561056137085,
0.35196587443351746,
0.01910337246954441,
-0.3840104043483734,
-0.5058621168136597,
-0.2033938616514206,
-0.0437065027654171,
-0.9444600939750671,
-0.40714845061302185,
-0.002304020104929805,
0.5395871996879578,
0.7571532726287842,
-0.44050103425979614,
0.2575695812702179,
-0.34593096375465393,
0.5530200004577637,
-0.8903533816337585,
0.12423865497112274,
-0.5424948930740356,
-0.2234971821308136,
-0.2709324061870575,
0.09497995674610138,
-0.5987693667411804,
-0.21449320018291473,
0.04074437916278839,
-0.8067928552627563,
0.25449785590171814,
0.005449105054140091,
0.9497559666633606,
0.5072080492973328,
-0.3564195930957794,
-0.10247405618429184,
-0.6224976181983948,
0.8912159204483032,
-0.7981988787651062,
0.5726673007011414,
0.36471468210220337,
0.2987291216850281,
0.2641814649105072,
-1.1485940217971802,
-0.5566115975379944,
-0.3492864966392517,
-0.21170970797538757,
-0.0499190092086792,
-0.4509909749031067,
0.12770976126194,
0.5876120328903198,
0.3315402865409851,
-0.2542141079902649,
0.5261234045028687,
-0.3599030375480652,
-0.11036024242639542,
0.5646128058433533,
0.18749822676181793,
0.4632198214530945,
0.009948140010237694,
0.16347455978393555,
-0.30748122930526733,
-0.6056681871414185,
-0.03029065765440464,
0.30424636602401733,
0.5494152307510376,
-0.15770253539085388,
0.3691847026348114,
-0.01577233150601387,
0.7410297989845276,
0.17626234889030457,
-0.19181685149669647,
0.14511093497276306,
-0.1694701611995697,
-0.3028934597969055,
0.00009525418136036023,
0.6989582180976868,
0.18480727076530457,
0.5709022283554077,
-0.10822157561779022,
-0.016826894134283066,
-0.08796761184930801,
0.7544521689414978,
-1.1987512111663818,
-0.35771727561950684,
-0.012382032349705696,
-0.3611051142215729,
-0.09584565460681915,
-0.2213832437992096,
-0.6681290864944458,
-0.4559210240840912,
-0.5838450193405151,
0.40842747688293457,
0.02003638632595539,
-0.5010775923728943,
0.01956254616379738,
-0.18992897868156433,
0.09910813719034195,
0.24966558814048767,
-1.2370774745941162,
0.3805669844150543,
0.6360043287277222,
0.8326064944267273,
0.2855469584465027,
-0.3040511906147003,
-0.29006072878837585,
-0.2745359241962433,
-0.6153862476348877,
0.5242686867713928,
-0.5049065351486206,
-0.1528366059064865,
-0.027184631675481796,
0.07052378356456757,
-0.3010806143283844,
-0.4809020459651947,
0.5398585200309753,
-0.5630227327346802,
-0.1525861769914627,
-0.36143559217453003,
-0.5783649682998657,
0.07987766712903976,
-0.38560789823532104,
-1.0698575973510742,
0.7460887432098389,
0.400491863489151,
-0.7194799780845642,
0.423431932926178,
-0.7340250015258789,
-0.8584117889404297,
0.13879087567329407,
0.0977700799703598,
-0.4424918591976166,
0.39652249217033386,
0.07576341927051544,
0.5488041639328003,
-0.9741614460945129,
0.4419039785861969,
-0.17273616790771484,
-0.3276323676109314,
-0.07275284081697464,
-0.14131346344947815,
1.0451840162277222,
0.4354483187198639,
-0.6020856499671936,
0.028420180082321167,
-0.6749991178512573,
0.12388088554143906,
0.2197832316160202,
-0.2839002013206482,
-0.16945545375347137,
0.21932177245616913,
0.014369988813996315,
-0.21213901042938232,
0.18327316641807556,
-0.4786660671234131,
0.02486199513077736,
-0.29201874136924744,
0.7017493844032288,
0.6401851773262024,
-0.533028244972229,
0.9232384562492371,
-0.06900306791067123,
0.6881855130195618,
-0.336260586977005,
0.2038259506225586,
-0.13170836865901947,
-0.16233372688293457,
-0.8423731923103333,
-0.3833974301815033,
0.2781146466732025,
0.23443813621997833,
-0.19635216891765594,
0.12344931066036224,
-0.4224003851413727,
-0.5849897265434265,
-0.5012187957763672,
-0.18337556719779968,
0.26891380548477173,
0.34975534677505493,
0.3409196734428406,
-0.04726048931479454,
-0.7497449517250061,
-1.0226470232009888,
-0.14082062244415283,
0.16076768934726715,
-0.0031923099886626005,
0.3234196901321411,
0.4508073925971985,
-0.07850923389196396,
0.9814287424087524,
-0.5700989365577698,
-0.018701504915952682,
-0.49525126814842224,
-0.1286563128232956,
0.37507960200309753,
0.4501515030860901,
0.7234821319580078,
-0.9540644884109497,
-0.6252560615539551,
0.11625071614980698,
-0.42353326082229614,
-0.07493312656879425,
-0.18347665667533875,
0.0666816234588623,
-0.13143673539161682,
0.7400835156440735,
-0.6045118570327759,
0.045194465667009354,
0.5734637379646301,
0.22219455242156982,
0.5293574333190918,
-0.3585675358772278,
-0.18378932774066925,
-0.743995726108551,
0.01975584402680397,
-0.04288850724697113,
-0.1695142388343811,
-0.699765145778656,
0.4312310814857483,
0.41625136137008667,
-0.075912244617939,
-0.17452025413513184,
0.44031041860580444,
-0.5272125005722046,
0.044526420533657074,
-0.3074161112308502,
-0.13073378801345825,
-0.148193821310997,
0.40536341071128845,
0.11081507056951523,
1.0918090343475342,
0.6525717377662659,
-0.6139523983001709,
0.23231390118598938,
-0.18055462837219238,
-0.47070199251174927,
0.4487886428833008,
-0.8893066644668579,
-0.16902698576450348,
0.05733122304081917,
0.20600919425487518,
-0.5806535482406616,
-0.4890952706336975,
-0.6887998580932617,
-0.2995036542415619,
0.4730168282985687,
-0.07112519443035126,
-0.2721331715583801,
-0.6503607034683228,
-0.14948342740535736,
0.1907619833946228,
0.712675929069519,
-0.814727783203125,
0.9306156039237976,
0.7595804929733276,
0.3027213513851166,
-0.6768255829811096,
-0.816733717918396,
-0.20521597564220428,
-0.09862402826547623,
-0.5024964809417725,
0.22067709267139435,
0.07715752720832825,
-0.18285691738128662,
-0.10063904523849487,
0.2762938141822815,
-0.4054211974143982,
0.18135075271129608,
0.3080257773399353,
-0.03291398659348488,
-0.6296700239181519,
0.07960335910320282,
-0.20733174681663513,
0.09261446446180344,
0.3101506531238556,
-0.3549686670303345,
0.8536038398742676,
-0.21821613609790802,
-0.17182984948158264,
-0.38744860887527466,
0.0016454763244837523,
0.7908725738525391,
-0.2765350043773651,
0.8471707105636597,
0.3787616491317749,
-0.27049940824508667,
-0.01417197473347187,
-0.6452553272247314,
-0.005834674928337336,
-0.5183660387992859,
0.7573937773704529,
-0.4561502933502197,
-0.5696943998336792,
0.4838084578514099,
-0.12972107529640198,
0.08048082143068314,
0.8169458508491516,
0.7692850828170776,
0.1571107804775238,
0.9948376417160034,
0.855267345905304,
-0.49541568756103516,
0.620380699634552,
-0.2837081849575043,
0.26214927434921265,
-0.7593597173690796,
0.03522666543722153,
-0.8544427156448364,
-0.02429245598614216,
-0.8040376901626587,
-0.4289121627807617,
-0.04602416604757309,
-0.20658648014068604,
-0.7270174622535706,
0.646378755569458,
-0.5178185701370239,
0.7832337617874146,
0.8053733110427856,
0.07383417338132858,
0.024014001712203026,
-0.12613001465797424,
0.05692845582962036,
-0.001071239821612835,
-0.9077080488204956,
0.015303948894143105,
1.243609070777893,
0.07090696692466736,
0.8417622447013855,
-0.03355485200881958,
0.39035066962242126,
-0.07676072418689728,
0.35829633474349976,
-0.8767974972724915,
0.2811315655708313,
-0.2165069580078125,
-0.9158668518066406,
-0.5578553676605225,
-0.7172456383705139,
-1.256057620048523,
0.28164902329444885,
0.019244816154241562,
-0.5957871675491333,
0.041466109454631805,
0.17969229817390442,
-0.2930589020252228,
0.4887351989746094,
-0.8022869229316711,
0.8371187448501587,
-0.14247310161590576,
-0.1834220439195633,
-0.5126565098762512,
-0.5779902338981628,
0.21847769618034363,
-0.21828687191009521,
0.43400320410728455,
0.18021109700202942,
0.10811197757720947,
0.8474739193916321,
-0.6707904934883118,
0.731700599193573,
-0.2243361473083496,
0.18467509746551514,
0.4484938085079193,
-0.2095988541841507,
0.4537985920906067,
-0.44753819704055786,
-0.04093272611498833,
0.014671063050627708,
-0.09148913621902466,
-0.5573939085006714,
-0.39086422324180603,
0.3791886568069458,
-1.0559651851654053,
-0.46440666913986206,
-0.14954699575901031,
-0.4317997992038727,
-0.13106414675712585,
0.32976096868515015,
0.7795370817184448,
0.46065622568130493,
-0.09992889314889908,
0.5558162331581116,
0.6276656985282898,
-0.006209576036781073,
0.48965463042259216,
0.3734946548938751,
-0.05262842774391174,
-0.1096678227186203,
0.8440922498703003,
0.37735602259635925,
0.3826187252998352,
0.4650995135307312,
0.5242651700973511,
-0.22054652869701385,
-0.4270680546760559,
-0.25063076615333557,
0.27074047923088074,
-0.5747023820877075,
-0.23708084225654602,
-0.7282785177230835,
-0.35556474328041077,
-0.5225873589515686,
-0.4855100214481354,
-0.9526616334915161,
-0.39643242955207825,
-0.24182172119617462,
0.05047537758946419,
0.31167492270469666,
0.525688648223877,
-0.22910280525684357,
0.8675374984741211,
-0.21673241257667542,
0.20847053825855255,
0.2687285840511322,
0.391165167093277,
0.39214593172073364,
-0.9131719470024109,
-0.5070525407791138,
0.02173556573688984,
-0.13659034669399261,
-0.28871846199035645,
0.23718181252479553,
0.2636680603027344,
0.7147663235664368,
0.4183804392814636,
-0.13770432770252228,
0.744184136390686,
-0.7752322554588318,
0.4688892960548401,
0.6122332811355591,
-0.9799930453300476,
0.2009279727935791,
-0.183627188205719,
0.38785287737846375,
0.38550350069999695,
0.44433480501174927,
-0.36448580026626587,
-0.23860737681388855,
-0.8481267690658569,
-0.79679936170578,
0.7813645601272583,
-0.18255557119846344,
0.8385592699050903,
0.20270207524299622,
0.4190976023674011,
-0.2728983163833618,
0.15275266766548157,
-0.7696207761764526,
-0.13278117775917053,
-0.161533385515213,
-0.05619623139500618,
-0.11812444031238556,
-0.13582880795001984,
0.16299837827682495,
-0.454899400472641,
0.5908320546150208,
-0.23712830245494843,
0.27355480194091797,
-0.36292606592178345,
-0.23015239834785461,
-0.07578976452350616,
-0.0025643110275268555,
0.3606732189655304,
0.8591662645339966,
0.1647256314754486,
-0.07826214283704758,
0.12069859355688095,
-0.7919436693191528,
0.15903587639331818,
-0.17721378803253174,
-0.1978781372308731,
-0.33151060342788696,
0.504173755645752,
1.0151327848434448,
0.2798643112182617,
-0.6905781030654907,
0.6843305826187134,
0.049593593925237656,
-0.3204769492149353,
-0.2061256468296051,
0.3819423317909241,
0.4350680410861969,
0.18765565752983093,
0.2324725091457367,
0.05428825691342354,
-0.05933128669857979,
-0.3844301402568817,
0.20344313979148865,
0.31314077973365784,
-0.12156011909246445,
-0.1663638949394226,
0.7670131921768188,
0.012729408219456673,
-0.3548928201198578,
0.8344422578811646,
0.1326269805431366,
-0.5897508859634399,
0.8316400647163391,
0.6465243697166443,
0.5280379056930542,
-0.5355993509292603,
0.13223180174827576,
0.7120509147644043,
0.5008664727210999,
-0.6134341955184937,
-0.17928120493888855,
-0.02020004391670227,
-0.6623045206069946,
-0.6049450039863586,
-0.6455670595169067,
-0.43763822317123413,
0.024780776351690292,
-0.8211263418197632,
0.2695591151714325,
-0.5489881038665771,
-0.3352399468421936,
0.29413488507270813,
-0.03957265242934227,
-0.7445341944694519,
0.5353831052780151,
-0.08654409646987915,
0.5947996377944946,
-0.5828941464424133,
0.73933345079422,
0.22905579209327698,
-0.35639283061027527,
-1.041135311126709,
-0.4550305902957916,
-0.08458922058343887,
-1.0189199447631836,
0.5657767653465271,
0.02295517735183239,
-0.17971768975257874,
-0.05843621492385864,
-0.43467968702316284,
-1.2021329402923584,
0.8420903086662292,
0.9037887454032898,
-0.7954826354980469,
-0.18752972781658173,
-0.0635322704911232,
0.6273441910743713,
-0.33327049016952515,
0.5679842233657837,
0.6894529461860657,
0.23459038138389587,
0.13275587558746338,
-1.0350353717803955,
-0.06540483236312866,
-0.07665833830833435,
-0.01233462430536747,
0.5590010285377502,
-0.7739123106002808,
1.22837495803833,
-0.5090314745903015,
-0.09845883399248123,
-0.24110940098762512,
0.572992742061615,
-0.4546588063240051,
-0.1504966914653778,
0.5328313112258911,
0.5928016304969788,
1.0910810232162476,
0.08878420293331146,
1.472954511642456,
-0.259504109621048,
0.5275965929031372,
1.3859022855758667,
-0.13667061924934387,
0.834075927734375,
0.06100301072001457,
-0.7068172693252563,
0.4417218267917633,
0.6326422095298767,
-0.24869295954704285,
0.2425532341003418,
0.39018338918685913,
0.2567858397960663,
-0.25645309686660767,
-0.09571658074855804,
-0.308855801820755,
0.5248934626579285,
-0.05191004276275635,
-0.37801745533943176,
0.00672247726470232,
-0.07842889428138733,
0.4154226779937744,
-0.09139177948236465,
-0.3084559142589569,
0.5457469820976257,
-0.19305893778800964,
-0.7272050976753235,
0.66375732421875,
-0.12621575593948364,
0.5179811120033264,
-0.6693578958511353,
0.6384989023208618,
-0.12082584947347641,
0.31445226073265076,
-0.12010934203863144,
-0.26283708214759827,
0.07875096797943115,
-0.004153863526880741,
-0.2685728967189789,
-0.019266214221715927,
0.3869629502296448,
0.026115944609045982,
-0.7167953252792358,
0.4031244218349457,
0.2426161766052246,
0.12933453917503357,
-0.30084744095802307,
-0.39974603056907654,
-0.26307442784309387,
-0.03121446631848812,
-0.5789312124252319,
0.582828164100647,
0.1328303962945938,
-0.046830810606479645,
0.7220948338508606,
0.701644241809845,
0.32647445797920227,
0.28367704153060913,
0.3762226998806,
0.8418258428573608,
-0.3530566394329071,
-0.6905663013458252,
-0.9111752510070801,
0.32062792778015137,
-0.3414546251296997,
-0.18272528052330017,
0.538366973400116,
0.5820972919464111,
0.6277962327003479,
0.23309442400932312,
0.7224317789077759,
-0.1847318708896637,
0.28307145833969116,
-0.25893712043762207,
0.6634628176689148,
-0.8799424171447754,
-0.16614797711372375,
-0.13558758795261383,
-0.75151526927948,
-0.08664900064468384,
0.7774728536605835,
-0.21776649355888367,
0.09204721450805664,
0.6585027575492859,
0.6588062644004822,
-0.2337365448474884,
0.33590996265411377,
0.3412497043609619,
0.1283072680234909,
0.2227766066789627,
0.35591861605644226,
0.3071165680885315,
-0.19741220772266388,
0.30399876832962036,
-0.3487449884414673,
-0.41384807229042053,
-0.15003803372383118,
-0.7450356483459473,
-0.7390981912612915,
-0.6354874968528748,
-0.2175455540418625,
-0.15034732222557068,
-0.42114371061325073,
0.5986584424972534,
1.1226589679718018,
-0.6707185506820679,
-0.5955894589424133,
-0.2556133270263672,
-0.13962684571743011,
-0.24494138360023499,
-0.15647903084754944,
0.3410324156284332,
-0.7587835192680359,
-0.7499141693115234,
-0.04474462941288948,
-0.017673231661319733,
-0.21220381557941437,
-0.07291550934314728,
0.06772962957620621,
-0.10984748601913452,
0.4207794666290283,
0.6122114658355713,
0.23396971821784973,
-0.44475990533828735,
0.10751529783010483,
0.10509272664785385,
-0.27817243337631226,
0.2789272964000702,
1.3412436246871948,
-0.3731100261211395,
0.5412980318069458,
0.2149907648563385,
0.9742170572280884,
0.9885293841362,
-0.41401052474975586,
0.6552882790565491,
-0.29549479484558105,
0.2957349717617035,
0.08546364307403564,
0.4123684763908386,
0.16632768511772156,
-0.492335706949234,
0.64426189661026,
-0.0976349264383316,
-0.6602103114128113,
-0.8381338119506836,
0.06198496371507645,
-0.491769403219223,
-0.4326384663581848,
0.8346511125564575,
-0.20465703308582306,
-0.34203189611434937,
0.3082377314567566,
0.0843011736869812,
0.19329296052455902,
-0.14413896203041077,
0.35054105520248413,
0.7184364199638367,
-0.19167253375053406,
-0.18221630156040192,
-0.7833856344223022,
0.44356590509414673,
0.5578783750534058,
-0.8318376541137695,
0.35538896918296814,
0.32822883129119873,
0.15252116322517395,
0.33996695280075073,
0.6956847906112671,
0.16376373171806335,
0.14212360978126526,
0.4624110162258148,
-0.05169963836669922,
0.19483903050422668,
-0.2526322305202484,
-0.07918296754360199,
0.3010847568511963,
0.01716631092131138,
0.3000602722167969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19482v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19482v1
|
FactCheck Editor: Multilingual Text Editor with End-to-End fact-checking
| 2024-04-30T11:55:20 | 2024-04-30T11:55:20 |
Vinay Setty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce 'FactCheck Editor', an advanced text editor designed to automate
fact-checking and correct factual inaccuracies. Given the widespread issue of
misinformation, often a result of unintentional mistakes by content creators,
our tool aims to address this challenge. It supports over 90 languages and
utilizes transformer models to assist humans in the labor-intensive process of
fact verification. This demonstration showcases a complete workflow that
detects text claims in need of verification, generates relevant search engine
queries, and retrieves appropriate documents from the web. It employs Natural
Language Inference (NLI) to predict the veracity of claims and uses LLMs to
summarize the evidence and suggest textual revisions to correct any errors in
the text. Additionally, the effectiveness of models used in claim detection and
veracity assessment is evaluated across multiple languages.
|
[
-0.11356507986783981,
-0.8332228660583496,
0.7184116244316101,
0.13576631247997284,
-0.04161052778363228,
0.33158403635025024,
0.007467030081897974,
-0.5522257089614868,
0.21342605352401733,
0.6246257424354553,
-0.5239224433898926,
-0.5549312233924866,
-0.6152077913284302,
0.530001699924469,
-0.5154410600662231,
1.1600836515426636,
-0.35108813643455505,
-0.1753840446472168,
-0.43717971444129944,
-0.05550597235560417,
-0.20119033753871918,
-0.2645602524280548,
-0.5816152691841125,
-0.32716381549835205,
0.432186484336853,
0.6105790138244629,
0.7315762042999268,
0.320529967546463,
0.28282320499420166,
0.41526898741722107,
0.022832902148365974,
0.5069248676300049,
-0.20519636571407318,
-0.08014457672834396,
-0.3329300582408905,
-0.7994057536125183,
-0.47079193592071533,
0.06515020877122879,
0.16779983043670654,
0.09477096796035767,
-0.07543281465768814,
0.23242220282554626,
-0.39588403701782227,
0.43246427178382874,
-0.7722905278205872,
0.09608716517686844,
-0.45214417576789856,
0.00046460810699500144,
0.05331261828541756,
-0.024086086079478264,
-0.5459598302841187,
-0.9024266004562378,
-0.07079880684614182,
-0.46415895223617554,
0.4583923816680908,
0.08493863791227341,
1.0034561157226562,
0.4254469573497772,
-0.8837980628013611,
-0.39332839846611023,
-0.514419674873352,
0.4589397609233856,
-0.6760894656181335,
0.5933995246887207,
0.4015963077545166,
0.2467900812625885,
0.07703382521867752,
-0.661480188369751,
-0.9158774614334106,
-0.05455892160534859,
-0.4606194496154785,
0.3167475163936615,
-0.23457878828048706,
0.03265886753797531,
0.39298948645591736,
0.22705113887786865,
-0.6185182332992554,
-0.031607773154973984,
-0.32423636317253113,
-0.7396612763404846,
0.795782208442688,
-0.10327110439538956,
0.5254322290420532,
-0.23389264941215515,
-0.1198246031999588,
0.03024694323539734,
-0.6931332349777222,
-0.0349467433989048,
0.48557227849960327,
-0.21589921414852142,
-0.2524643838405609,
0.7266868948936462,
-0.4493691921234131,
0.612463116645813,
-0.12061146646738052,
-0.4634810984134674,
0.17385169863700867,
-0.6233852505683899,
-0.37503600120544434,
0.4396221935749054,
0.7745696306228638,
0.45876801013946533,
-0.29881712794303894,
-0.2420860230922699,
-0.16593678295612335,
0.13673333823680878,
0.10321067273616791,
-0.6063268184661865,
-0.09910301864147186,
0.4470522105693817,
-0.14015080034732819,
-0.4753625988960266,
0.15505997836589813,
-0.7583319544792175,
-0.5654727816581726,
-0.21069243550300598,
0.44785818457603455,
-0.1342361867427826,
-0.06759578734636307,
0.3236459195613861,
-0.3344952166080475,
-0.15816165506839752,
0.6206743121147156,
-0.3667760193347931,
-0.0971626564860344,
0.31667402386665344,
0.7253602147102356,
0.013910122215747833,
-0.29631662368774414,
-0.4627583920955658,
-0.028456661850214005,
-0.46878892183303833,
1.0891283750534058,
-0.22761011123657227,
-0.11314120143651962,
0.15674908459186554,
0.24774019420146942,
0.15138037502765656,
-0.19801858067512512,
1.2613836526870728,
-0.7058749198913574,
0.4510001540184021,
-0.2539650797843933,
-0.4997846186161041,
-0.535423994064331,
0.5584650039672852,
-1.102920651435852,
1.1125682592391968,
-0.08995106816291809,
-0.8756643533706665,
0.3023093640804291,
-0.7710563540458679,
-0.3253001570701599,
-0.03458784148097038,
0.09612265974283218,
-0.6573664546012878,
-0.024663493037223816,
0.2525308132171631,
0.2324838638305664,
-0.273907870054245,
0.595862090587616,
0.04847671836614609,
0.1633482724428177,
0.408875972032547,
-0.5039924383163452,
0.9526655673980713,
0.0586688369512558,
-0.3106391429901123,
0.2668311595916748,
-0.9996232390403748,
-0.29347220063209534,
0.037868682295084,
-0.6169934272766113,
-0.10595152527093887,
0.1171962320804596,
0.07588472962379456,
0.23967468738555908,
0.3658514618873596,
-1.0454484224319458,
0.11983808130025864,
-0.15618661046028137,
0.12293548882007599,
0.2888030707836151,
0.21152521669864655,
-0.14883849024772644,
-0.33683061599731445,
0.33041343092918396,
0.04826897755265236,
0.19110603630542755,
-0.263530433177948,
-0.3527718186378479,
-1.0615711212158203,
-0.17548218369483948,
0.5526111721992493,
0.9957708716392517,
-0.8922992944717407,
0.6024207472801208,
-0.287793904542923,
-0.5359660983085632,
-0.46993985772132874,
0.15905724465847015,
0.15253987908363342,
0.6308621764183044,
0.24188190698623657,
0.20844890177249908,
-0.7584489583969116,
-0.9785193800926208,
-0.5957282781600952,
-0.12272707372903824,
0.09312129020690918,
-0.34655359387397766,
0.8494541049003601,
-0.5548031330108643,
1.225013256072998,
-0.5950424075126648,
-0.00680597685277462,
-0.2332538366317749,
0.3624604344367981,
0.1619872897863388,
-0.034011874347925186,
0.418474406003952,
-0.8609938621520996,
-0.4962416887283325,
0.1517120599746704,
-0.7853473424911499,
-0.3055734634399414,
-0.45205575227737427,
0.008911915123462677,
0.47494685649871826,
0.3520340323448181,
-0.7732632160186768,
0.4769057333469391,
0.6729233264923096,
-0.5185757875442505,
0.7138695120811462,
-0.18201540410518646,
0.43187662959098816,
-0.8828096985816956,
0.11026664823293686,
0.0783739984035492,
-0.6326287388801575,
-0.4975612163543701,
0.03938600420951843,
0.5074527263641357,
0.10360199213027954,
-0.4506964683532715,
0.27552530169487,
-0.33699148893356323,
0.2941978871822357,
-0.22476010024547577,
-0.0038551795296370983,
0.3913228213787079,
0.31407874822616577,
-0.051089148968458176,
0.9739887714385986,
0.31514906883239746,
-0.5749372243881226,
0.6722907423973083,
0.31463822722435,
-0.4074001908302307,
0.49744030833244324,
-0.5884124636650085,
-0.14663313329219818,
-0.10400103777647018,
0.32190394401550293,
-0.9594682455062866,
-0.4132794439792633,
-0.0910656675696373,
-0.34659624099731445,
0.04636041820049286,
0.04029974713921547,
-0.8417317867279053,
-0.30587801337242126,
-0.39332225918769836,
-0.2838403880596161,
-0.09468815475702286,
-0.7256446480751038,
0.8209620714187622,
0.41415882110595703,
-0.10275723040103912,
-0.6397201418876648,
-0.6545516848564148,
0.4513975977897644,
0.2579634487628937,
-0.5648971796035767,
0.12116122990846634,
-0.13084867596626282,
-0.3970755934715271,
0.053204454481601715,
-0.18433986604213715,
-0.3666296899318695,
0.10248134285211563,
-0.05551951006054878,
0.4650440812110901,
0.0036265847738832235,
0.0995175689458847,
0.29918134212493896,
-0.12940195202827454,
0.25082576274871826,
0.08559220284223557,
-0.13003632426261902,
-0.008256405591964722,
-0.6047245264053345,
-0.34983697533607483,
0.37061768770217896,
0.7848466634750366,
-0.4003159701824188,
0.58154296875,
0.4699496626853943,
-0.470615416765213,
0.12935195863246918,
-1.004822850227356,
0.15266092121601105,
-0.4054047465324402,
0.42305678129196167,
-0.1711510270833969,
-0.880666971206665,
0.453227698802948,
-0.2056587189435959,
0.45476019382476807,
0.8972473740577698,
0.47936153411865234,
0.1619458943605423,
0.7421810030937195,
0.6911004185676575,
0.12217707186937332,
-0.13963817059993744,
-0.05520953983068466,
0.43666785955429077,
-0.2828090488910675,
-0.30136966705322266,
-0.6029146909713745,
0.14181040227413177,
-0.5366286635398865,
-0.3631105422973633,
0.6133734583854675,
-0.3216609060764313,
0.1029081866145134,
0.24446210265159607,
-0.21744532883167267,
0.859849214553833,
0.34050923585891724,
0.0803530365228653,
0.7024345993995667,
-0.25566089153289795,
0.10606463253498077,
-0.011002589948475361,
-0.4879162609577179,
-0.5520322322845459,
0.8531134128570557,
0.26919078826904297,
0.6786461472511292,
0.5085576176643372,
0.41736868023872375,
0.530687153339386,
0.47813063859939575,
-0.641120195388794,
0.18948645889759064,
0.13788554072380066,
-0.8084771037101746,
-0.18995971977710724,
-0.04901827871799469,
-0.38844534754753113,
0.16642528772354126,
-0.49563363194465637,
-0.2992883622646332,
0.22687162458896637,
0.2623133659362793,
-0.39385825395584106,
0.5600119829177856,
-0.8319171071052551,
0.7801176905632019,
-0.38509610295295715,
-0.3841732442378998,
-0.34543901681900024,
-0.5036062002182007,
0.5975717306137085,
-0.2751149833202362,
0.4646398425102234,
0.1692333072423935,
0.01780438795685768,
0.3857943117618561,
-0.30672669410705566,
1.0267695188522339,
0.17126265168190002,
-0.34572529792785645,
0.33539602160453796,
0.26842546463012695,
0.7468466758728027,
0.3504333794116974,
0.013155746273696423,
0.23211292922496796,
-0.1182180643081665,
-0.023474151268601418,
-0.5249953269958496,
0.39334356784820557,
-0.710430383682251,
-0.436005175113678,
-0.632253885269165,
-0.2609387934207916,
-0.06974168121814728,
0.39403200149536133,
0.24604161083698273,
0.4005506932735443,
-0.5617133975028992,
-0.026591753587126732,
0.9533781409263611,
-0.3159104287624359,
0.42799264192581177,
0.9640129804611206,
-0.2566719055175781,
-0.29241788387298584,
0.7171981930732727,
-0.004822211340069771,
-0.04352602735161781,
0.7709413766860962,
0.20391087234020233,
-0.47536128759384155,
-0.26048094034194946,
-0.7096152901649475,
0.19955262541770935,
-0.8660215139389038,
-0.445423424243927,
-0.9469627141952515,
-0.19330647587776184,
-0.2156502902507782,
-0.09155489504337311,
-0.43098148703575134,
-0.5666419267654419,
0.11014926433563232,
-0.4132213592529297,
0.4785408675670624,
0.9756730794906616,
-0.11537332087755203,
0.28888723254203796,
-0.7988248467445374,
0.6831963658332825,
0.5848724842071533,
0.49729135632514954,
-0.7329451441764832,
-0.31080448627471924,
-0.5194268226623535,
-0.05941441282629967,
-0.48342227935791016,
-1.2783621549606323,
0.08664251118898392,
0.16590729355812073,
0.44506388902664185,
0.21986046433448792,
-0.10588101297616959,
0.18029282987117767,
-0.5661302804946899,
0.9328427314758301,
0.1186298057436943,
-1.0656137466430664,
0.5602432489395142,
0.09361962229013443,
0.17987798154354095,
0.4781917333602905,
0.5122146010398865,
-0.6936612725257874,
-0.4718177914619446,
-0.6069309115409851,
-0.35837334394454956,
0.6126055121421814,
0.020828528329730034,
-0.3248681128025055,
0.11097482591867447,
0.1278487890958786,
0.2700473964214325,
0.12947909533977509,
-0.6889792680740356,
-0.36256736516952515,
-0.48301956057548523,
-0.23619061708450317,
0.12110000848770142,
-0.7186778783798218,
-0.5189149379730225,
-0.0845838338136673,
1.106723427772522,
-0.40232670307159424,
0.04516972228884697,
0.5528112053871155,
-0.4942381978034973,
-0.1645248830318451,
0.8066800832748413,
0.8378763794898987,
0.9313693046569824,
-0.16738730669021606,
0.389757364988327,
0.5049287676811218,
-0.4728381931781769,
0.19187137484550476,
0.07450373470783234,
-0.3802673816680908,
0.47527799010276794,
0.38300639390945435,
0.7419951558113098,
0.21547487378120422,
-0.6483076810836792,
0.5803583264350891,
-0.31109699606895447,
-0.25951793789863586,
-0.24136845767498016,
-0.07055526971817017,
0.1932707130908966,
-0.02512597292661667,
0.21122239530086517,
0.3309073746204376,
0.3859703540802002,
-0.30367985367774963,
0.21037141978740692,
0.11162375658750534,
0.03268963098526001,
-0.31689348816871643,
0.6593191027641296,
0.36286672949790955,
-0.19963215291500092,
0.23188479244709015,
-0.31499579548835754,
-0.8728109002113342,
0.5288504362106323,
0.39708060026168823,
1.0073552131652832,
-0.16469237208366394,
0.40269866585731506,
0.49285662174224854,
0.7899512648582458,
-0.0930381566286087,
0.13317367434501648,
0.32139474153518677,
-0.7902796864509583,
-0.9398618340492249,
-0.32396936416625977,
-0.6319071054458618,
0.16506274044513702,
-0.24018655717372894,
0.35832831263542175,
-0.08587027341127396,
-0.02731984667479992,
0.2785082757472992,
-0.06703953444957733,
-0.653288722038269,
0.34108707308769226,
-0.08777432888746262,
1.0741612911224365,
-1.0804405212402344,
0.6181537508964539,
0.6853898167610168,
-0.35709407925605774,
-0.47855740785598755,
-0.1799074411392212,
0.48452675342559814,
-0.5407724976539612,
0.5320161581039429,
-0.05348086729645729,
-0.450639545917511,
-0.30647900700569153,
-0.8814772367477417,
-0.7900970578193665,
0.8489665389060974,
0.6027922034263611,
-0.5903469324111938,
0.29944881796836853,
0.11981695890426636,
0.35323256254196167,
0.05761462822556496,
0.5384964942932129,
0.6970227956771851,
0.6415358781814575,
-0.22241482138633728,
-0.9474415183067322,
-0.027849536389112473,
-0.10410910099744797,
-0.46287670731544495,
0.06931573897600174,
-0.548470139503479,
0.6608652472496033,
-0.22841876745224,
-0.22078937292099,
-0.5250006914138794,
0.6500017642974854,
-0.1734710931777954,
0.1450919657945633,
0.6459457278251648,
0.6557936668395996,
0.8608378171920776,
0.01076971460133791,
0.9699047207832336,
-0.5065139532089233,
0.502995491027832,
1.0758556127548218,
-0.18410331010818481,
0.3253070116043091,
0.19773466885089874,
-0.18651582300662994,
0.7603688836097717,
0.43795129656791687,
0.022399572655558586,
-0.05398108810186386,
-0.5738732218742371,
-0.29759231209754944,
-0.28888359665870667,
-0.23838667571544647,
0.06519371271133423,
0.5061125159263611,
0.2920776605606079,
0.10214570164680481,
-0.395484060049057,
-0.32332226634025574,
0.29713794589042664,
0.13886886835098267,
0.019649585708975792,
0.7488698363304138,
-0.5182300209999084,
-0.7497037649154663,
0.176964670419693,
0.3126785457134247,
0.6080302596092224,
-0.7243233919143677,
-0.23030783236026764,
-0.10794505476951599,
-0.1543453335762024,
-0.5195052027702332,
-1.031818151473999,
0.46857327222824097,
0.32084354758262634,
-0.48642078042030334,
-0.04418865218758583,
0.8444338440895081,
-0.671316921710968,
-0.5819470882415771,
-0.08384090662002563,
0.5016245245933533,
-0.1916542500257492,
-0.13174833357334137,
-0.7028327584266663,
0.13041289150714874,
0.1910247951745987,
-0.04804550111293793,
-0.22284917533397675,
0.5170170664787292,
-0.05579030513763428,
0.6349419355392456,
0.6887654662132263,
0.07363338768482208,
-0.11363426595926285,
0.06971266865730286,
0.5093390345573425,
-0.39258646965026855,
-0.6540216207504272,
-0.9127573370933533,
0.6835372447967529,
-0.39479944109916687,
-0.15559610724449158,
0.8177492022514343,
1.006925106048584,
0.7246743440628052,
-0.22355538606643677,
1.156114101409912,
-0.12817125022411346,
0.6573857069015503,
-0.5208097100257874,
0.7765220999717712,
-0.4094706177711487,
-0.21546965837478638,
0.11017633229494095,
-0.41280192136764526,
-0.36123207211494446,
0.2837270498275757,
0.09461358189582825,
-0.512467622756958,
0.981318473815918,
0.8136398792266846,
-0.10547773540019989,
0.2521810233592987,
0.2679092288017273,
0.37800344824790955,
0.36229902505874634,
0.1037028580904007,
0.5445997714996338,
-0.601531445980072,
0.39833545684814453,
-0.22830317914485931,
-0.18425627052783966,
-0.173225536942482,
-1.0818452835083008,
-0.8222184181213379,
-0.3548506200313568,
-0.6582844853401184,
-0.31334513425827026,
-0.2923963963985443,
0.9666455984115601,
0.37200069427490234,
-1.053877830505371,
0.005642683710902929,
0.17765913903713226,
0.6573755741119385,
-0.028811290860176086,
-0.1993044763803482,
0.4179546535015106,
-0.2076038271188736,
-0.5945935249328613,
0.2885875105857849,
0.34174874424934387,
-0.07733301818370819,
-0.3104628324508667,
0.13904038071632385,
-0.46803221106529236,
0.2699028551578522,
0.6937408447265625,
0.2322889268398285,
-0.711181104183197,
-0.29639932513237,
-0.20332318544387817,
-0.1493472456932068,
0.0897088497877121,
0.972904622554779,
-0.45295876264572144,
0.7941915392875671,
0.5114632844924927,
0.8117861747741699,
0.20729553699493408,
-0.24406825006008148,
0.31288594007492065,
-0.7954413294792175,
0.0975734144449234,
-0.2730075418949127,
0.5405495166778564,
0.5757890343666077,
-0.7366036176681519,
0.5057053565979004,
0.3517194986343384,
-0.5350661277770996,
-0.6871271133422852,
0.2070218026638031,
-0.7710803151130676,
-0.13444902002811432,
0.7538282871246338,
0.0362827405333519,
-0.36500975489616394,
-0.4182950556278229,
-0.3863612115383148,
0.4517628848552704,
-0.22706599533557892,
0.8846060037612915,
1.002506136894226,
0.05137886479496956,
-0.10911785811185837,
-0.8366402387619019,
0.6742585301399231,
0.09120261669158936,
-1.1779694557189941,
0.1310262531042099,
0.5573540925979614,
0.3915403187274933,
0.38678619265556335,
0.3965744376182556,
0.090561643242836,
0.4802219569683075,
-0.12128158658742905,
0.5977523326873779,
0.013651669025421143,
-0.2174215018749237,
-0.20339591801166534,
-0.12305609881877899,
-0.15179553627967834,
0.04444717988371849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19442v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19442v1
|
Which Nigerian-Pidgin does Generative AI speak?: Issues about Representativeness and Bias for Multilingual and Low Resource Languages
| 2024-04-30T10:45:40 | 2024-04-30T10:45:40 |
David Ifeoluwa Adelani, A. Seza Doğruöz, Iyanuoluwa Shode, Anuoluwapo Aremu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Naija is the Nigerian-Pidgin spoken by approx. 120M speakers in Nigeria and
it is a mixed language (e.g., English, Portuguese and Indigenous languages).
Although it has mainly been a spoken language until recently, there are
currently two written genres (BBC and Wikipedia) in Naija. Through statistical
analyses and Machine Translation experiments, we prove that these two genres do
not represent each other (i.e., there are linguistic differences in word order
and vocabulary) and Generative AI operates only based on Naija written in the
BBC genre. In other words, Naija written in Wikipedia genre is not represented
in Generative AI.
|
[
-0.8324674963951111,
-0.7917696833610535,
0.14361274242401123,
0.67515629529953,
-0.07192221283912659,
0.2770508825778961,
-0.527155876159668,
-0.6134210228919983,
0.7885842323303223,
0.5772028565406799,
-0.7553895115852356,
-0.32111677527427673,
-0.6190873384475708,
0.6814306378364563,
-0.29996663331985474,
1.010993480682373,
0.18003547191619873,
0.20056648552417755,
-0.13558676838874817,
-0.3294031023979187,
-0.34542959928512573,
-0.46492642164230347,
-0.5457558631896973,
-0.14846818149089813,
0.18186624348163605,
0.333911657333374,
0.953022301197052,
0.1900400072336197,
0.3152889609336853,
0.36269935965538025,
-0.1669779121875763,
0.0630788579583168,
-0.385601669549942,
0.30660003423690796,
-0.16354016959667206,
-0.571557343006134,
-0.210798978805542,
-0.04674583300948143,
0.45068418979644775,
0.7063431739807129,
-0.23074443638324738,
-0.07423888891935349,
-0.10905249416828156,
0.46772345900535583,
-0.5433030724525452,
0.1055319607257843,
-0.5808127522468567,
0.07430136203765869,
-0.4508539140224457,
0.162697434425354,
-0.13829652965068817,
-0.10756968706846237,
-0.09034809470176697,
-0.8079390525817871,
0.43594253063201904,
-0.2533116936683655,
0.6673879027366638,
0.4822354316711426,
-0.39326557517051697,
-0.8286582827568054,
-0.45212432742118835,
0.764415979385376,
-0.38223889470100403,
0.07981165498495102,
0.6358994245529175,
0.2856294810771942,
-0.3604498505592346,
-0.3823385536670685,
-0.7964221835136414,
-0.3050113916397095,
-0.058617133647203445,
0.1634473204612732,
-0.09163277596235275,
-0.12039117515087128,
0.22628182172775269,
0.6100508570671082,
-0.42195409536361694,
0.20736277103424072,
-0.5882023572921753,
-0.38318559527397156,
0.8839380741119385,
-0.16159512102603912,
0.3325660228729248,
-0.4001214802265167,
-0.2131706178188324,
0.15828584134578705,
-0.6261063814163208,
-0.25093594193458557,
0.897903323173523,
0.29432806372642517,
-0.26620206236839294,
0.4775613844394684,
-0.21098347008228302,
0.9674158096313477,
0.17226435244083405,
-0.5533636212348938,
0.45290860533714294,
-0.0952545627951622,
0.16008463501930237,
0.36556607484817505,
1.3361244201660156,
0.19749996066093445,
0.15039445459842682,
-0.19316492974758148,
-0.17377732694149017,
0.23333995044231415,
0.26411280035972595,
-0.4924144148826599,
-0.1853215992450714,
0.1150764748454094,
-0.3317674398422241,
-0.008246640674769878,
-0.18483982980251312,
-0.7344411015510559,
-0.47899043560028076,
0.20365919172763824,
0.13429181277751923,
-0.21387511491775513,
-0.4746297001838684,
-0.33638033270835876,
0.07414741069078445,
0.03462117165327072,
0.13101767003536224,
-1.1153438091278076,
-0.04341365769505501,
0.41455620527267456,
0.790317952632904,
-0.19589312374591827,
-0.07769091427326202,
-0.012915244325995445,
-0.24290861189365387,
-0.3649672567844391,
0.7768494486808777,
-0.4294237494468689,
-0.577833890914917,
-0.09022823721170425,
-0.01573176495730877,
-0.0034895155113190413,
-0.6433581709861755,
0.5719841718673706,
-0.3705928921699524,
0.4197823107242584,
-0.027323691174387932,
0.06146927550435066,
-0.2052934765815735,
-0.14784114062786102,
-0.8505592346191406,
0.899383544921875,
0.35989493131637573,
-0.6168379783630371,
0.4919400215148926,
-0.6058905720710754,
-0.4431765377521515,
0.13382840156555176,
-0.5192290544509888,
-0.22994506359100342,
-0.023628810420632362,
0.1913624256849289,
0.29410168528556824,
-0.06498579680919647,
0.46639284491539,
-0.1994539201259613,
-0.2923276126384735,
0.3057708144187927,
-0.6053365468978882,
1.0526067018508911,
0.3477107882499695,
-0.33691874146461487,
-0.04272930324077606,
-0.8540358543395996,
-0.20812685787677765,
-0.13433119654655457,
-0.48096245527267456,
-0.1713462471961975,
-0.13323819637298584,
0.31158652901649475,
0.40710172057151794,
0.2208985835313797,
-0.925361692905426,
0.43231630325317383,
-0.5317988395690918,
0.65872722864151,
0.3477468192577362,
-0.07856860011816025,
0.5711575746536255,
-0.3064996004104614,
0.937416672706604,
0.07480274140834808,
-0.28956159949302673,
0.06370678544044495,
-1.0057971477508545,
-0.4926486015319824,
-0.3599744439125061,
0.651427149772644,
0.5364194512367249,
-1.297581434249878,
-0.010730408132076263,
0.0033922113943845034,
-0.20395712554454803,
-1.0146074295043945,
0.19560636579990387,
0.21660035848617554,
0.24784858524799347,
0.23346787691116333,
-0.15794363617897034,
-0.47074154019355774,
-1.2581948041915894,
-0.06425511091947556,
-0.17595629394054413,
0.03758303076028824,
0.011269780807197094,
0.4188624620437622,
-0.2692396640777588,
0.5696724057197571,
0.2010878175497055,
-0.44276732206344604,
-0.35364407300949097,
0.2219201773405075,
0.5298563241958618,
0.16654814779758453,
1.0575066804885864,
-0.9886343479156494,
-0.8384106159210205,
0.025515049695968628,
-0.7136111855506897,
-0.22053396701812744,
-0.24586400389671326,
0.05932685732841492,
0.3815130889415741,
0.35342711210250854,
-0.21511779725551605,
0.47653114795684814,
1.129668116569519,
-0.15077584981918335,
0.18361197412014008,
0.036639560014009476,
-0.013051220215857029,
-1.097603678703308,
-0.3579976260662079,
-0.10176500678062439,
-0.09557992219924927,
-0.4927939772605896,
-0.05495355650782585,
-0.23487170040607452,
-0.07731262594461441,
-0.2789928913116455,
0.664612352848053,
-0.6691610217094421,
-0.0952407717704773,
-0.3650229573249817,
0.23465290665626526,
-0.43192964792251587,
0.37233272194862366,
0.4706401824951172,
1.3859344720840454,
0.7146572470664978,
-0.6295022964477539,
0.44844114780426025,
0.4474870562553406,
-0.6194285750389099,
0.7951599359512329,
-0.5266203880310059,
-0.1107041984796524,
-0.151271790266037,
0.11578719317913055,
-0.7246528267860413,
-0.45414772629737854,
0.7699024081230164,
-0.43212732672691345,
0.48635247349739075,
-0.20721274614334106,
-0.22521160542964935,
-0.20358431339263916,
0.3525191843509674,
0.37078890204429626,
-0.02547767572104931,
-0.25112879276275635,
0.45712774991989136,
0.7805019617080688,
-0.5572701096534729,
-1.0488252639770508,
-0.8965960741043091,
0.25607675313949585,
-0.08501669764518738,
-0.5708541870117188,
0.37405481934547424,
0.16517123579978943,
-0.3927997648715973,
0.10140188783407211,
0.18124623596668243,
-0.2901184558868408,
0.17253005504608154,
0.6192694902420044,
-0.1488388031721115,
-0.44663533568382263,
0.046719763427972794,
0.3290267586708069,
0.06836842000484467,
-0.03808213397860527,
0.11515389382839203,
0.6317355632781982,
-0.1467723548412323,
-0.1137859970331192,
-0.2774868905544281,
0.6397411227226257,
0.4111112952232361,
-0.11065618693828583,
1.098140835762024,
0.6144965887069702,
-0.03503068536520004,
-0.15062786638736725,
-0.1537645310163498,
0.013720009475946426,
-0.355646014213562,
0.32661759853363037,
-0.6597307920455933,
-0.6740487813949585,
0.5943487882614136,
0.23969486355781555,
-0.053708210587501526,
0.8489448428153992,
0.8359675407409668,
-0.23671476542949677,
0.5213109850883484,
0.3781667649745941,
-0.03556537628173828,
0.3350202739238739,
-0.45656904578208923,
-0.007920114323496819,
-0.9613744020462036,
-0.24004672467708588,
-0.6745101809501648,
-0.5425009727478027,
-1.3758450746536255,
0.03308487683534622,
0.5416513681411743,
0.07609191536903381,
-0.0030022310093045235,
0.37991973757743835,
-0.35683345794677734,
0.26278460025787354,
0.7239671349525452,
0.05154040455818176,
0.24392859637737274,
0.3720400035381317,
-0.03709544986486435,
-0.07386749237775803,
-1.1476564407348633,
-0.5608240365982056,
1.3461816310882568,
-0.0015563409542664886,
0.5381120443344116,
0.3720603287220001,
0.7640492916107178,
0.39307716488838196,
0.6386640667915344,
-0.8116831183433533,
0.002455847803503275,
-0.03712039068341255,
-1.13052237033844,
-0.4163726568222046,
-0.4630838930606842,
-1.009758710861206,
0.4645216166973114,
-0.4909307658672333,
-0.5149393081665039,
0.7799760699272156,
-0.08722926676273346,
-0.0868411511182785,
0.35138630867004395,
-0.3082702159881592,
0.7130147218704224,
-0.10933101177215576,
-0.15323211252689362,
0.10611017048358917,
-0.530269205570221,
0.5660827159881592,
-0.016114555299282074,
0.4849463105201721,
0.04410003125667572,
0.23095911741256714,
0.8236292600631714,
-0.3138715326786041,
0.5263912677764893,
0.05855879932641983,
-0.30867478251457214,
0.5350300669670105,
-0.03491229563951492,
-0.16246141493320465,
0.2615279257297516,
-0.42035427689552307,
0.6674461364746094,
0.06350933015346527,
-0.7215090990066528,
-0.1057300791144371,
0.6755982041358948,
-1.0435199737548828,
-0.514098048210144,
-0.8446539044380188,
-0.4555897116661072,
-0.2433609962463379,
0.11884251981973648,
0.7754434943199158,
0.25451308488845825,
-0.4225256145000458,
0.4719971716403961,
0.44930151104927063,
-0.43316370248794556,
0.45491620898246765,
0.0720406025648117,
-0.14204737544059753,
-0.5368087291717529,
0.8392651081085205,
0.10721499472856522,
0.17429490387439728,
0.25323915481567383,
-0.2701699733734131,
-0.4404461979866028,
-0.26415860652923584,
-1.0309834480285645,
0.38126346468925476,
-0.4707314074039459,
0.019263537600636482,
-0.6257876753807068,
-0.1261860877275467,
-0.19001702964305878,
0.019755210727453232,
-0.2604464292526245,
-0.6651902794837952,
-0.20249390602111816,
0.16971904039382935,
0.08542321622371674,
0.9383106827735901,
-0.2341926246881485,
0.7726699709892273,
-0.2027548849582672,
0.6719810962677002,
0.015073916874825954,
0.10153282433748245,
-0.40058815479278564,
-0.5836897492408752,
-0.07243560254573822,
0.5087602734565735,
-0.30982157588005066,
-1.1994839906692505,
0.3897187411785126,
0.44631966948509216,
0.7142977714538574,
0.5344632267951965,
0.019753865897655487,
0.11281152814626694,
-0.05867818370461464,
0.6384034752845764,
0.19561277329921722,
-0.5607658624649048,
0.21531885862350464,
-0.22203417122364044,
0.11822036653757095,
0.47419843077659607,
0.6676981449127197,
-0.6280047297477722,
-0.5570660829544067,
-0.4560616612434387,
-0.4769552946090698,
0.806647539138794,
0.21939967572689056,
0.3028568625450134,
-0.2793061137199402,
-0.010908844880759716,
0.4824576675891876,
0.6143582463264465,
-0.7717946171760559,
-0.6191080808639526,
-0.6570291519165039,
0.010670346207916737,
-0.18799299001693726,
-0.33066967129707336,
-0.07813742011785507,
0.015126907266676426,
0.645358145236969,
-0.13110998272895813,
0.39378300309181213,
-0.02247271127998829,
-0.1247510239481926,
0.0019295545062050223,
0.35060349106788635,
0.6124585866928101,
0.8525617122650146,
-0.00515031348913908,
-0.36276406049728394,
-0.4592093229293823,
-0.8686354160308838,
0.2953926622867584,
-0.03278736025094986,
-0.7673997282981873,
0.5418550372123718,
0.3844570219516754,
0.9512035846710205,
-0.060613829642534256,
-0.3347676694393158,
0.36925840377807617,
-0.08323463797569275,
-0.3508344888687134,
-0.5004273056983948,
0.07741165161132812,
0.06189331039786339,
-0.1541622430086136,
0.36086758971214294,
0.0709853321313858,
0.03424694389104843,
-0.863743245601654,
-0.28326085209846497,
0.3906826972961426,
-0.15706516802310944,
0.03187181055545807,
0.7188901901245117,
0.5553844571113586,
-0.08259467035531998,
0.9621965885162354,
-0.42716825008392334,
-0.4710973799228668,
0.7799313068389893,
0.4591303765773773,
0.471770316362381,
-0.14468863606452942,
0.7444915175437927,
0.26538383960723877,
0.4208395183086395,
0.31089523434638977,
0.5709831118583679,
-0.2105819433927536,
-0.9706766605377197,
-0.29702702164649963,
-0.8321430087089539,
-0.3074476420879364,
0.08054335415363312,
-0.9628335237503052,
-0.17292289435863495,
-0.2797960042953491,
-0.6383268237113953,
0.35796627402305603,
-0.050507716834545135,
-0.7172681093215942,
0.15402647852897644,
-0.11455580592155457,
0.4806245267391205,
-0.8302392959594727,
0.6260554790496826,
1.0554174184799194,
-0.37405532598495483,
-0.24616026878356934,
-0.11124932765960693,
-0.26509854197502136,
-0.5591645240783691,
0.8622644543647766,
-0.17210187017917633,
0.15987686812877655,
-0.12787407636642456,
-0.41407251358032227,
-0.7950671315193176,
0.6319588422775269,
0.21750743687152863,
-0.5384908318519592,
0.30630773305892944,
0.09721232950687408,
0.5479075908660889,
-0.3959757387638092,
0.33745065331459045,
0.08881346881389618,
0.5368208289146423,
-0.18534965813159943,
-1.331919550895691,
-0.7525367736816406,
-0.2760584354400635,
0.05782395228743553,
0.2000211924314499,
-0.7634670734405518,
1.0943090915679932,
-0.052399974316358566,
-0.356329083442688,
0.10968321561813354,
0.864773690700531,
-0.03816751763224602,
0.3782746195793152,
0.06474395096302032,
0.3415589928627014,
0.7633780241012573,
-0.5113808512687683,
1.1362860202789307,
-0.44005027413368225,
0.05101177096366882,
1.1596336364746094,
-0.07051405310630798,
0.42863819003105164,
0.4462280869483948,
-0.44178298115730286,
0.7652194499969482,
0.7042137384414673,
0.09875022619962692,
0.5396915674209595,
0.00818394310772419,
-0.43581610918045044,
-0.044802114367485046,
-0.14453288912773132,
-0.4984239339828491,
0.945377767086029,
0.6163021922111511,
-0.46655601263046265,
-0.01651916280388832,
0.24067233502864838,
-0.09242656081914902,
0.4025261402130127,
-0.46848517656326294,
0.8570886850357056,
0.04921102151274681,
-0.5153319239616394,
0.768172562122345,
0.31467264890670776,
0.7478609681129456,
-0.2897683084011078,
-0.05936827510595322,
-0.36760270595550537,
-0.26575300097465515,
-0.19359885156154633,
-0.9018411636352539,
0.5144559741020203,
-0.05320526286959648,
-0.5029703974723816,
0.03803014010190964,
0.17084825038909912,
-0.6063993573188782,
-0.5208892226219177,
-0.0869794562458992,
0.4719671607017517,
0.42522233724594116,
-0.2150837481021881,
-0.5717865824699402,
0.01842181384563446,
-0.12383528798818588,
0.11680781841278076,
0.22479215264320374,
0.454163521528244,
-0.41064149141311646,
0.7971309423446655,
0.37062811851501465,
0.485645592212677,
0.34199365973472595,
-0.27906879782676697,
0.4335387647151947,
-0.178633913397789,
-0.6577160358428955,
-0.23607294261455536,
0.05471796542406082,
0.06118268892168999,
-0.7018961310386658,
0.6736491322517395,
0.41135185956954956,
1.143123745918274,
-0.44502493739128113,
0.9762393236160278,
-0.4133020043373108,
0.29433274269104004,
-0.5694149732589722,
0.7657057642936707,
-0.15938113629817963,
-0.21755008399486542,
-0.09098054468631744,
-1.2132049798965454,
0.23952257633209229,
1.0148745775222778,
-0.33728501200675964,
0.022095268592238426,
0.3321486711502075,
0.6833791732788086,
-0.028551466763019562,
-0.07759705930948257,
0.35670584440231323,
0.46115490794181824,
-0.2714197337627411,
0.31000155210494995,
0.8045732975006104,
-0.528342604637146,
0.2133278101682663,
-0.4488956034183502,
-0.10027866810560226,
-0.039838675409555435,
-0.6174032092094421,
-0.7682515382766724,
-0.6097956299781799,
-0.2658065855503082,
-0.39822471141815186,
-0.0018408948089927435,
0.6374558210372925,
0.45107629895210266,
-1.260770320892334,
-0.2546626329421997,
0.2770077884197235,
0.35390955209732056,
-0.046160269528627396,
-0.25037914514541626,
0.09978952258825302,
0.29416191577911377,
-1.0112860202789307,
0.4026157855987549,
0.19460391998291016,
-0.19738434255123138,
-0.7343111634254456,
-0.1400783210992813,
-0.18184113502502441,
-0.37585538625717163,
0.33390137553215027,
0.6376069188117981,
-0.9707008600234985,
0.31432902812957764,
-0.22634588181972504,
-0.2091972678899765,
0.08057411015033722,
0.3657306134700775,
-0.7756146788597107,
0.7432445883750916,
0.3487544059753418,
0.3136758804321289,
0.2961370646953583,
0.19799256324768066,
0.4978448152542114,
-0.44538846611976624,
0.708441436290741,
0.22556546330451965,
0.2511143982410431,
0.48252034187316895,
-0.37971845269203186,
0.37318840622901917,
0.41663655638694763,
-0.40931010246276855,
-0.4951891303062439,
0.3710183799266815,
-0.7813733816146851,
-0.11458831280469894,
1.0079121589660645,
-0.02159608155488968,
-0.17887748777866364,
-0.3164476454257965,
-0.2771706283092499,
-0.06258396059274673,
-0.5474051833152771,
0.7357941269874573,
0.8916535377502441,
-0.019071562215685844,
-0.11817329376935959,
-0.7851901650428772,
0.5422207117080688,
-0.11811865866184235,
-0.23655670881271362,
-0.8185982704162598,
0.5510442852973938,
0.25734442472457886,
0.44867444038391113,
0.5998947620391846,
0.12227798253297806,
0.365994393825531,
0.2425818145275116,
0.08977293968200684,
0.03389584273099899,
-0.5177068710327148,
-0.1526191681623459,
0.04444386065006256,
-0.33426380157470703,
-0.10670875012874603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19432v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19432v1
|
Can Large Language Models put 2 and 2 together? Probing for Entailed Arithmetical Relationships
| 2024-04-30T10:28:04 | 2024-04-30T10:28:04 |
D. Panas, S. Seth, V. Belle
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Two major areas of interest in the era of Large Language Models regard
questions of what do LLMs know, and if and how they may be able to reason (or
rather, approximately reason). Since to date these lines of work progressed
largely in parallel (with notable exceptions), we are interested in
investigating the intersection: probing for reasoning about the implicitly-held
knowledge. Suspecting the performance to be lacking in this area, we use a very
simple set-up of comparisons between cardinalities associated with elements of
various subjects (e.g. the number of legs a bird has versus the number of
wheels on a tricycle). We empirically demonstrate that although LLMs make
steady progress in knowledge acquisition and (pseudo)reasoning with each new
GPT release, their capabilities are limited to statistical inference only. It
is difficult to argue that pure statistical learning can cope with the
combinatorial explosion inherent in many commonsense reasoning tasks,
especially once arithmetical notions are involved. Further, we argue that
bigger is not always better and chasing purely statistical improvements is
flawed at the core, since it only exacerbates the dangerous conflation of the
production of correct answers with genuine reasoning ability.
|
[
-0.42108726501464844,
-0.9855958223342896,
1.0869189500808716,
0.16708698868751526,
-0.09571585804224014,
-0.25327858328819275,
-0.2519936263561249,
-0.6733435392379761,
-0.10296286642551422,
0.4619367718696594,
-0.33326610922813416,
0.08672282099723816,
-0.7939170598983765,
0.12020806223154068,
-0.33526134490966797,
0.7199203372001648,
0.24318334460258484,
0.21156805753707886,
-0.5014619827270508,
-0.1443123072385788,
-0.23040716350078583,
-0.594845175743103,
-0.8323295712471008,
-0.36029931902885437,
0.586792528629303,
0.17791149020195007,
0.7842077612876892,
0.6184519529342651,
0.7073945999145508,
0.32077479362487793,
-0.130852609872818,
0.38215354084968567,
-0.5695253610610962,
0.13535098731517792,
-0.20591163635253906,
-0.6542066931724548,
-0.3947207033634186,
0.0332791842520237,
0.6998473405838013,
1.1377263069152832,
0.13461856544017792,
-0.02549111098051071,
-0.0009606734965927899,
0.9268400073051453,
-0.44472455978393555,
0.1642596572637558,
-0.6921237111091614,
-0.3530622124671936,
-0.19311007857322693,
-0.1275012195110321,
-0.3782843351364136,
-0.4583459794521332,
0.08898194879293442,
-0.5107473134994507,
0.026255475357174873,
0.1606760174036026,
0.46218904852867126,
0.32306328415870667,
-0.8337541222572327,
-0.5320188999176025,
-0.6161453127861023,
0.7623531222343445,
-0.5862120985984802,
0.33123141527175903,
0.5981778502464294,
0.2374780774116516,
-0.25191396474838257,
-0.58955317735672,
-0.6107699871063232,
-0.3417438268661499,
-0.15576915442943573,
-0.04467230290174484,
-0.1416797637939453,
0.0251487847417593,
0.5809455513954163,
0.37905120849609375,
-0.7454410791397095,
-0.008039974607527256,
-0.6107114553451538,
0.07189168781042099,
0.7562173008918762,
0.12923479080200195,
0.3071821331977844,
0.21033886075019836,
-0.23563316464424133,
-0.014815764501690865,
-1.2181384563446045,
-0.07731612771749496,
0.4892719089984894,
-0.017657315358519554,
-0.05206786468625069,
0.8624189496040344,
-0.02157466486096382,
0.6369935274124146,
-0.10831280052661896,
0.14398634433746338,
-0.1610662192106247,
-0.25245949625968933,
-0.09173084795475006,
-0.010199913755059242,
0.694638729095459,
0.06776110827922821,
0.8350152969360352,
-0.14188581705093384,
-0.14179165661334991,
0.17098765075206757,
-0.05977005511522293,
-0.7349918484687805,
-0.38080263137817383,
0.27750274538993835,
-0.03231511265039444,
-0.028489062562584877,
0.11709973216056824,
-0.48862817883491516,
-0.19750112295150757,
-0.743755578994751,
0.4782847464084625,
-0.3237541913986206,
-0.42630478739738464,
0.2168332040309906,
-0.09241953492164612,
0.24967704713344574,
0.32840201258659363,
-1.0510450601577759,
0.3893062174320221,
1.346474051475525,
0.7026526927947998,
0.047133225947618484,
-0.3673252463340759,
-0.36915168166160583,
0.1147112026810646,
-0.8032130002975464,
0.8603920936584473,
-0.6386213898658752,
-0.31454578042030334,
-0.01218499056994915,
-0.1706218272447586,
-0.11859960108995438,
-0.5596316456794739,
0.13245750963687897,
-0.6126499176025391,
0.16311950981616974,
-0.7385323643684387,
-0.7068869471549988,
-0.2191029191017151,
0.27845829725265503,
-0.5554506182670593,
0.9448508024215698,
-0.10791795700788498,
-0.6488061547279358,
0.2974129915237427,
-0.32189327478408813,
-0.5013145208358765,
-0.1115482747554779,
-0.5299644470214844,
-0.09950855374336243,
0.2536679804325104,
-0.034734249114990234,
0.2769908607006073,
-0.6375723481178284,
0.23556362092494965,
-0.7246828675270081,
-0.4404382109642029,
0.5034803748130798,
-0.5077037215232849,
0.895134687423706,
0.1510809361934662,
-0.12411320954561234,
-0.2114264965057373,
-0.6080918908119202,
-0.019396211951971054,
0.12781187891960144,
-0.1201392263174057,
-0.3957239091396332,
0.19252841174602509,
-0.6862503886222839,
-0.012034273706376553,
0.30890828371047974,
-0.2570364475250244,
0.20277148485183716,
-0.3574729859828949,
0.3982641100883484,
0.6914040446281433,
-0.07365220785140991,
0.5224719047546387,
-0.4565460979938507,
0.18338368833065033,
-0.16229435801506042,
-0.128357395529747,
0.04559580981731415,
-0.5531365871429443,
-1.0015389919281006,
-0.022488908842206,
0.17805977165699005,
0.5354323387145996,
-0.6051002740859985,
0.19643381237983704,
-0.26379895210266113,
-0.3389440178871155,
-0.07694137841463089,
0.07465114444494247,
0.42136916518211365,
0.21078072488307953,
0.1528170108795166,
-0.0905071273446083,
-0.2919362783432007,
-0.7088161706924438,
-0.3731045722961426,
-0.4440980553627014,
-0.06390917301177979,
0.3807862102985382,
0.5258688926696777,
0.19648629426956177,
0.6922752261161804,
-0.42235440015792847,
0.1727253645658493,
-0.23141609132289886,
0.09799925237894058,
0.235833078622818,
0.2862838804721832,
0.49377939105033875,
-0.6990213990211487,
-0.3007373511791229,
0.002074830001220107,
-0.9589396119117737,
-0.12159598618745804,
0.31876665353775024,
-0.1318216770887375,
0.06072181463241577,
0.37579554319381714,
-0.9215133190155029,
0.1306716501712799,
0.3709830343723297,
-0.33664387464523315,
0.5637435913085938,
-0.376029908657074,
-0.00003947882942156866,
-0.5659877061843872,
-0.33448535203933716,
0.08449311554431915,
0.06734171509742737,
-0.7294763326644897,
-0.04494142532348633,
0.03626015782356262,
0.09929662197828293,
-0.11665482074022293,
0.47869738936424255,
-0.5549507737159729,
-0.4357726275920868,
-0.3047157824039459,
0.11961358785629272,
-0.13009953498840332,
0.305097371339798,
-0.06587114930152893,
0.8499884605407715,
0.7097768783569336,
-0.7157094478607178,
0.2828789949417114,
-0.08863844722509384,
-0.30885908007621765,
0.48364952206611633,
-0.7549635171890259,
0.1444227248430252,
-0.1699151247739792,
0.3337920904159546,
-1.1168067455291748,
-0.43057578802108765,
0.05220659449696541,
-0.6978351473808289,
0.23469899594783783,
-0.21047049760818481,
-0.6295018196105957,
-0.06649122387170792,
-0.01842799410223961,
0.6346762776374817,
0.7564053535461426,
-0.48902714252471924,
0.34312790632247925,
0.35739606618881226,
-0.421894907951355,
-0.30482983589172363,
-0.5912322998046875,
-0.13011698424816132,
-0.3752462565898895,
-0.9379704594612122,
-0.44821467995643616,
0.15965591371059418,
-1.022435188293457,
-0.05888121947646141,
-0.13915687799453735,
-0.12200817465782166,
-0.10469434410333633,
-0.12686394155025482,
0.4028675854206085,
-0.5183242559432983,
0.48589450120925903,
-0.1888846904039383,
-0.2971635162830353,
0.45002710819244385,
-0.28764182329177856,
0.37453436851501465,
-0.09727955609560013,
-0.5983668565750122,
0.13381721079349518,
0.2520134150981903,
0.5845127701759338,
-0.32585278153419495,
0.6319817900657654,
0.2307090312242508,
-0.3585079312324524,
-0.1007487028837204,
-0.777219831943512,
-0.3931754529476166,
-0.4613145589828491,
0.2869044840335846,
-0.6088898777961731,
-1.105833888053894,
0.3154013752937317,
0.02300737239420414,
-0.06547585129737854,
0.573445200920105,
0.5442502498626709,
-0.06583210080862045,
1.1586699485778809,
0.22512619197368622,
0.21599215269088745,
-0.10375730693340302,
-0.19323024153709412,
0.39183667302131653,
-0.7123727798461914,
-0.10872238874435425,
-0.5289075374603271,
-0.03723207116127014,
-0.758594274520874,
-0.49857327342033386,
0.5207109451293945,
0.19066430628299713,
-0.5622100830078125,
0.010301267728209496,
-0.1571093201637268,
0.6694527268409729,
0.4428859055042267,
0.08705577999353409,
0.4375941753387451,
-0.18604019284248352,
0.32854679226875305,
0.026692157611250877,
-0.6035058498382568,
-0.3707450330257416,
1.2180944681167603,
0.2965957522392273,
0.4986625015735626,
0.5766831636428833,
0.3351376950740814,
-0.11383546143770218,
0.26678168773651123,
-0.7449944019317627,
0.6599223613739014,
-0.290985107421875,
-0.6210290789604187,
-0.5301885008811951,
-0.833434522151947,
-0.8344045877456665,
0.6791874170303345,
0.011094593442976475,
-0.6918321847915649,
0.1344267725944519,
0.17309099435806274,
0.03629056736826897,
0.34749603271484375,
-0.6289472579956055,
0.6384584903717041,
-0.5713837742805481,
-0.576252818107605,
-0.4271206855773926,
-0.4907332956790924,
0.8044869303703308,
-0.0924060195684433,
0.4147675633430481,
-0.3214535117149353,
-0.04406590014696121,
0.6142528057098389,
-0.449017196893692,
0.6835526823997498,
0.08002826571464539,
-0.1554083377122879,
0.36536142230033875,
0.33879250288009644,
0.6905113458633423,
0.024073146283626556,
0.1647280603647232,
0.03581199049949646,
0.19972215592861176,
-0.5661728382110596,
-0.7647882699966431,
0.6320247650146484,
-0.5736075639724731,
-0.731038510799408,
-0.5566755533218384,
-0.6076754331588745,
-0.4532620906829834,
-0.06453002989292145,
0.030306605622172356,
0.6955119967460632,
0.12669381499290466,
0.1877455711364746,
0.9939129948616028,
0.1128099262714386,
0.15994147956371307,
0.5654776692390442,
-0.24030305445194244,
-0.2287372201681137,
0.9312509298324585,
0.22733020782470703,
0.5580095648765564,
0.4020080864429474,
0.36745402216911316,
-0.641340970993042,
-0.4970890283584595,
-0.39663004875183105,
0.6382434964179993,
-0.5644897222518921,
0.22821536660194397,
-0.5763338804244995,
0.02650977112352848,
-0.4235959053039551,
0.07663029432296753,
-0.13171729445457458,
-0.4970981478691101,
0.02391773834824562,
-0.11852579563856125,
0.46657270193099976,
1.0297303199768066,
-0.31114763021469116,
-0.06340543925762177,
-0.4387214183807373,
0.12378286570310593,
0.6793451905250549,
-0.035288967192173004,
0.2651352882385254,
-0.5398885607719421,
0.07218065857887268,
0.12741737067699432,
-0.0737847164273262,
-0.8949024081230164,
0.05439659580588341,
0.022183071821928024,
0.31858915090560913,
0.5069738030433655,
-0.09562578052282333,
0.7191011309623718,
-0.4666953384876251,
0.5319602489471436,
0.2191920429468155,
-0.5124870538711548,
0.13456836342811584,
-0.6418277621269226,
-0.08735320717096329,
0.17048557102680206,
0.5801045894622803,
-0.3010480999946594,
-0.3348225951194763,
-0.6499226093292236,
-0.5584326386451721,
0.4272913932800293,
0.1368802785873413,
0.06095580384135246,
-0.1845172941684723,
0.11591590195894241,
-0.07760734111070633,
0.03933056816458702,
-0.5258499383926392,
-0.045590028166770935,
0.38253238797187805,
-0.15398164093494415,
-0.17230726778507233,
-0.49822917580604553,
-0.2506997287273407,
-0.3313722610473633,
0.557901918888092,
-0.06521741300821304,
0.1617143750190735,
-0.03500787541270256,
-0.009106243029236794,
-0.06187476962804794,
0.2303129881620407,
0.49791035056114197,
1.2359051704406738,
-0.1226750984787941,
0.487261563539505,
0.16997626423835754,
-0.29874566197395325,
0.07090657949447632,
0.09542785584926605,
0.16221337020397186,
-0.40829455852508545,
0.5922539830207825,
0.6269009709358215,
0.3888740539550781,
-0.6511162519454956,
0.5029951333999634,
0.3374256491661072,
-0.4707924723625183,
-0.5132781863212585,
0.0869109258055687,
0.21065206825733185,
0.3184793293476105,
0.3687281906604767,
-0.3046484589576721,
0.08489512652158737,
-1.0079923868179321,
0.20137162506580353,
0.554258406162262,
-0.20294269919395447,
-0.2746162414550781,
0.5014181733131409,
0.06464935094118118,
-0.2285754531621933,
0.6114681959152222,
-0.28822728991508484,
-0.770462155342102,
0.8976913690567017,
0.4791170060634613,
0.5131914615631104,
0.030887633562088013,
-0.06794510781764984,
0.39373713731765747,
0.49207139015197754,
-0.4198896288871765,
0.1553826481103897,
-0.1147635206580162,
-0.8437394499778748,
-0.7418038249015808,
-0.3695339560508728,
-0.47723349928855896,
0.07334169745445251,
-0.497090607881546,
-0.048277322202920914,
-0.1560637354850769,
0.20870375633239746,
-0.035077352076768875,
0.058642707765102386,
-0.4618454873561859,
0.2022939771413803,
-0.07771528512239456,
0.6763405799865723,
-0.8827776908874512,
0.5778743624687195,
0.5382524728775024,
-0.548613965511322,
-0.8534430861473083,
0.0016494345618411899,
0.049968186765909195,
-1.0379058122634888,
0.6168779730796814,
0.1766994446516037,
0.09876982122659683,
-0.013822652399539948,
-0.4564268887042999,
-0.9327372908592224,
0.7789539098739624,
0.1765058934688568,
-0.6283366084098816,
0.15746206045150757,
0.4400191307067871,
0.5604345202445984,
-0.14737790822982788,
0.4874798059463501,
0.7608913779258728,
0.5972467064857483,
0.417207807302475,
-0.9341680407524109,
0.008390297181904316,
-0.0027903711888939142,
-0.4052387773990631,
0.6674076914787292,
-0.7071737051010132,
1.0907469987869263,
-0.38234809041023254,
-0.16341789066791534,
0.059246741235256195,
0.561526894569397,
0.4236183166503906,
0.6502222418785095,
0.4078439474105835,
0.9300174117088318,
0.6861258745193481,
-0.36675766110420227,
1.1875650882720947,
-0.12902508676052094,
0.2825484871864319,
0.923132598400116,
-0.24027785658836365,
0.731153666973114,
0.3637804388999939,
-0.8355314135551453,
-0.1055629551410675,
0.7579126954078674,
0.25866004824638367,
0.22360636293888092,
0.25284838676452637,
-0.41132214665412903,
-0.6141523718833923,
0.3410353660583496,
-0.4532064199447632,
0.13665421307086945,
0.5831562876701355,
-0.1122521236538887,
-0.16082391142845154,
-0.6201545000076294,
0.16722090542316437,
-0.06385301053524017,
-0.2684786021709442,
0.8800076246261597,
0.4782206118106842,
-0.889719545841217,
0.32882580161094666,
-0.30032041668891907,
0.26324519515037537,
-0.6318654417991638,
-0.10417842119932175,
-0.304121732711792,
0.10808134078979492,
-0.08253248780965805,
-1.0093051195144653,
0.33246535062789917,
-0.03166065365076065,
-0.01355221401900053,
0.2520557641983032,
0.7036330103874207,
-0.5554580688476562,
-0.6572386622428894,
0.17450366914272308,
0.7792502045631409,
0.5990098714828491,
-0.09756040573120117,
-0.28344017267227173,
-0.04549568146467209,
-0.04953015223145485,
-0.08418235927820206,
0.5067451000213623,
0.9106446504592896,
-0.06555291265249252,
0.6906446218490601,
0.8679742217063904,
0.3174251616001129,
0.2696758508682251,
0.032773714512586594,
0.6029983758926392,
-0.48742029070854187,
-0.20768296718597412,
-1.0356793403625488,
0.2958711087703705,
-0.023634374141693115,
-0.2487572878599167,
0.6928755640983582,
0.6201995611190796,
0.730523407459259,
0.30844104290008545,
0.8224473595619202,
0.035826049745082855,
0.46692442893981934,
-0.7820598483085632,
0.2610514163970947,
-0.587049663066864,
0.3474125266075134,
0.18267865478992462,
-1.0382962226867676,
-0.06808637082576752,
0.6608276963233948,
-0.6936661005020142,
0.17259691655635834,
0.9038039445877075,
0.8212745785713196,
-0.21571366488933563,
0.27928540110588074,
0.4708918631076813,
0.33848315477371216,
0.2521859109401703,
0.7755725383758545,
1.0113931894302368,
-0.13901670277118683,
0.4353032112121582,
0.0014824534300714731,
-0.3994346559047699,
-0.033337268978357315,
-0.5221132040023804,
-0.9356812834739685,
-0.4468480348587036,
0.04009474813938141,
-0.16811583936214447,
0.22756773233413696,
0.5500820279121399,
0.2929616868495941,
-0.5038859248161316,
-0.3402923345565796,
-0.31952589750289917,
0.14856953918933868,
0.10241161286830902,
-0.19250957667827606,
0.3711860179901123,
-0.3866252899169922,
-0.6800833344459534,
0.23522956669330597,
0.27598461508750916,
-0.0012247657869011164,
-0.4115239381790161,
-0.17198532819747925,
0.15541760623455048,
0.31350424885749817,
0.6618801951408386,
0.3077895939350128,
-0.6894620060920715,
-0.2651539742946625,
-0.08617843687534332,
0.10094527900218964,
-0.2399853616952896,
0.9792475700378418,
-0.29341354966163635,
0.20128507912158966,
0.6578889489173889,
0.6496875286102295,
0.5138214826583862,
0.05449135601520538,
0.5084737539291382,
-0.19386149942874908,
0.1150359958410263,
0.036951880902051926,
0.4748426675796509,
0.24558115005493164,
-0.057519517838954926,
0.8130569458007812,
0.34586524963378906,
-0.8830875158309937,
-0.8326385617256165,
0.4769437909126282,
-0.8319836258888245,
-0.27308711409568787,
1.408739447593689,
0.07787073403596878,
-0.010397654958069324,
-0.11093959212303162,
0.10340995341539383,
-0.053459301590919495,
-0.12270472198724747,
0.6427755951881409,
0.7862371802330017,
-0.3632911741733551,
-0.09065096825361252,
-0.8870550394058228,
0.2705279588699341,
0.4746825098991394,
-0.6701632738113403,
-0.048363231122493744,
0.6922138333320618,
0.23937515914440155,
-0.0017276584403589368,
0.7036591172218323,
-0.1351022571325302,
0.37782108783721924,
0.20434041321277618,
-0.6392155289649963,
0.1250213235616684,
-0.4208272099494934,
0.023832127451896667,
-0.013861635699868202,
0.21976253390312195,
0.05871785804629326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19430v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19430v1
|
Sõnajaht: Definition Embeddings and Semantic Search for Reverse Dictionary Creation
| 2024-04-30T10:21:14 | 2024-04-30T10:21:14 |
Aleksei Dorkin, Kairit Sirts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present an information retrieval based reverse dictionary system using
modern pre-trained language models and approximate nearest neighbors search
algorithms. The proposed approach is applied to an existing Estonian language
lexicon resource, S\~onaveeb (word web), with the purpose of enhancing and
enriching it by introducing cross-lingual reverse dictionary functionality
powered by semantic search.
The performance of the system is evaluated using both an existing labeled
English dataset of words and definitions that is extended to contain also
Estonian and Russian translations, and a novel unlabeled evaluation approach
that extracts the evaluation data from the lexicon resource itself using
synonymy relations.
Evaluation results indicate that the information retrieval based semantic
search approach without any model training is feasible, producing median rank
of 1 in the monolingual setting and median rank of 2 in the cross-lingual
setting using the unlabeled evaluation approach, with models trained for
cross-lingual retrieval and including Estonian in their training data showing
superior performance in our particular task.
|
[
-0.6337941288948059,
-0.7586343884468079,
0.27559441328048706,
0.04445610195398331,
-0.5462749004364014,
-0.20138685405254364,
-0.13566191494464874,
-0.49381211400032043,
0.8365707993507385,
0.5709039568901062,
-0.34866654872894287,
-0.6461328268051147,
-0.7307043075561523,
0.32408711314201355,
-0.6956842541694641,
0.5963940620422363,
-0.11908774822950363,
0.34197765588760376,
-0.15582765638828278,
-0.1786203682422638,
-0.4300421178340912,
-0.28176936507225037,
-0.08942624926567078,
-0.1664266288280487,
0.19738909602165222,
0.7482736110687256,
0.8547934889793396,
0.54388827085495,
0.46822860836982727,
0.2910931706428528,
0.05512033775448799,
-0.20803803205490112,
-0.5340489745140076,
0.3968680202960968,
-0.6662127375602722,
-0.3969368636608124,
-0.022060977295041084,
-0.18509739637374878,
0.6490910649299622,
0.4027121067047119,
-0.22294928133487701,
0.3294830620288849,
-0.22990038990974426,
0.3769865334033966,
-0.8011806011199951,
-0.19328846037387848,
-0.7595615983009338,
0.019474001601338387,
-0.312715083360672,
-0.2916307747364044,
0.03542941436171532,
-0.48250100016593933,
0.2306870073080063,
-0.4775596261024475,
0.23483958840370178,
0.19471235573291779,
0.9201852083206177,
-0.22043408453464508,
-0.25884589552879333,
-0.3633059859275818,
-0.21480906009674072,
0.8878870010375977,
-0.44608181715011597,
1.067352533340454,
0.43157777190208435,
0.46990466117858887,
-0.1335531622171402,
-0.5499724745750427,
-0.9007130861282349,
-0.08092732727527618,
0.014890143647789955,
0.05757822468876839,
-0.005215323995798826,
-0.14667478203773499,
-0.3661953806877136,
0.3806847035884857,
-0.5931361317634583,
-0.13716545701026917,
-0.31108301877975464,
0.0047030970454216,
0.44971874356269836,
0.24455539882183075,
0.3854913115501404,
-0.597002387046814,
-0.5093831419944763,
-0.17431315779685974,
-0.764445424079895,
-0.6942689418792725,
0.4734380841255188,
0.6016604900360107,
0.1118810772895813,
1.0100458860397339,
-0.2931137979030609,
0.42554572224617004,
-0.1074914038181305,
-0.2314615249633789,
0.27993205189704895,
-0.3076070547103882,
-0.12711110711097717,
0.1837533563375473,
0.25264477729797363,
0.21322116255760193,
0.05676555261015892,
-0.37320196628570557,
-0.5357002019882202,
-0.0007419900503009558,
0.3850786089897156,
-0.6126781702041626,
0.17020298540592194,
-0.06901954114437103,
-0.8121774792671204,
-0.5196231603622437,
0.20364710688591003,
-0.5928027033805847,
-0.16683699190616608,
-0.3112669289112091,
1.0039676427841187,
-0.5338512659072876,
-0.5349838733673096,
-0.037054721266031265,
-0.4111754298210144,
0.5051631331443787,
0.02013777196407318,
-0.5691922903060913,
0.5749176144599915,
0.650571882724762,
0.6443978548049927,
-0.2467922568321228,
-0.3945607542991638,
0.05677318572998047,
0.16133752465248108,
-0.4608215093612671,
0.7437384128570557,
-0.7398577332496643,
-0.6914012432098389,
-0.011058725416660309,
0.16759338974952698,
0.3136226534843445,
-0.6646600961685181,
0.309469610452652,
-0.8854992985725403,
0.2635042667388916,
0.07764937728643417,
-0.6442217230796814,
-0.36957401037216187,
0.34656795859336853,
-0.5491001605987549,
1.1545536518096924,
0.06909461319446564,
-0.9833799004554749,
0.3016986846923828,
-0.516954779624939,
-0.5475631952285767,
0.1489700824022293,
-0.02407252974808216,
0.03111124224960804,
0.17528750002384186,
0.12950477004051208,
0.5638647079467773,
-0.8496126532554626,
0.1639162003993988,
0.040397290140390396,
-0.4426731765270233,
-0.47307610511779785,
-0.013302857987582684,
0.6477433443069458,
0.23760835826396942,
-0.25867190957069397,
-0.20178766548633575,
-0.7976765632629395,
0.10294286906719208,
0.3474558889865875,
-0.34675830602645874,
-0.8899399638175964,
-0.33427995443344116,
0.3735103905200958,
-0.08017751574516296,
0.3970085382461548,
-0.9572888612747192,
-0.023831278085708618,
-0.6939388513565063,
-0.2982464134693146,
0.6375038623809814,
0.03737916052341461,
0.019200049340724945,
-0.06071699783205986,
0.6649519205093384,
0.0007328114588744938,
0.12066969275474548,
0.34201619029045105,
-0.4130233824253082,
-0.6477848291397095,
0.05054684728384018,
0.5925400257110596,
0.7843294739723206,
-0.9770549535751343,
0.49852830171585083,
-0.6196089386940002,
-0.798577070236206,
-0.698442280292511,
0.11165344715118408,
0.6020283699035645,
0.5101906061172485,
0.6274164319038391,
-0.35481730103492737,
-0.7179063558578491,
-1.2186965942382812,
-0.21344895660877228,
-0.06547976285219193,
0.05949133634567261,
0.2340906262397766,
0.6179980039596558,
-0.5042832493782043,
0.6731637716293335,
-0.3240075409412384,
-0.4078606069087982,
-0.34672778844833374,
0.02688523568212986,
0.26180514693260193,
0.4482886493206024,
0.19643400609493256,
-1.0752092599868774,
-0.2829844653606415,
-0.0797671526670456,
-0.5039403438568115,
-0.1263849139213562,
0.6519343256950378,
-0.20887531340122223,
0.27800217270851135,
0.36598122119903564,
-0.13679583370685577,
0.6389444470405579,
0.540542721748352,
-0.27701544761657715,
0.3913058638572693,
-0.02410615049302578,
0.32116150856018066,
-1.501550555229187,
0.2640235424041748,
-0.4854004383087158,
-0.2737143635749817,
-0.1779497116804123,
0.46940386295318604,
-0.08731509745121002,
-0.04160994291305542,
-0.5047914385795593,
0.655811607837677,
-0.3486345708370209,
-0.20155951380729675,
-0.14592717587947845,
0.5065245032310486,
-0.30336955189704895,
0.04898018762469292,
0.18009650707244873,
0.8240295648574829,
0.41180530190467834,
-0.7112923264503479,
0.8239983916282654,
0.49922600388526917,
-0.34877458214759827,
0.8554345369338989,
-0.5159927010536194,
-0.05621851608157158,
-0.2685766816139221,
-0.11893065273761749,
-0.8630248308181763,
0.10861869156360626,
-0.10280431061983109,
-0.5212401747703552,
0.3032764196395874,
-0.15424472093582153,
-0.5942178964614868,
-0.1342284083366394,
-0.3396296203136444,
0.5033035278320312,
0.36348918080329895,
-0.7550070881843567,
0.7164949774742126,
0.8270396590232849,
-0.1321527361869812,
-0.698710560798645,
-0.8935648798942566,
0.24717281758785248,
-0.13940030336380005,
-0.6925929188728333,
0.38570624589920044,
0.6440463066101074,
-0.15522710978984833,
0.24349400401115417,
0.07775172591209412,
-0.08401688933372498,
-0.16579796373844147,
0.07142193615436554,
0.12725333869457245,
-0.2199048548936844,
0.6324631571769714,
0.00512980530038476,
-0.14047107100486755,
-0.35079941153526306,
-0.4322701394557953,
0.6255910992622375,
-0.20853988826274872,
-0.21651433408260345,
-0.08771111071109772,
0.5112999081611633,
-0.10597822070121765,
-0.0400567501783371,
0.8147329092025757,
0.4082874655723572,
-0.40003228187561035,
-0.00014128847396932542,
-0.8514938354492188,
-0.23866671323776245,
-0.38117456436157227,
0.2210865020751953,
-0.8914069533348083,
-0.5132768750190735,
0.555239737033844,
-0.1360471397638321,
-0.3482898473739624,
0.639778733253479,
0.4539448618888855,
0.10402629524469376,
0.6042627692222595,
0.7226940989494324,
0.28506144881248474,
0.25833913683891296,
-0.26435956358909607,
-0.0024982707109302282,
-0.7664132714271545,
-0.33019953966140747,
-0.5875321626663208,
-0.3233407735824585,
-0.9591756463050842,
-0.2982495427131653,
0.3703139126300812,
-0.20648865401744843,
0.022224681451916695,
0.801115095615387,
-0.2593919634819031,
0.32599949836730957,
0.6723136305809021,
0.14662523567676544,
0.35667404532432556,
-0.08523968607187271,
-0.6021831035614014,
-0.15983617305755615,
-0.6903648972511292,
-0.25960874557495117,
1.1769253015518188,
0.007215847261250019,
1.1101415157318115,
0.3928779363632202,
1.0796374082565308,
0.29022058844566345,
0.005800407379865646,
-0.7000905871391296,
0.5977871417999268,
-0.10145621746778488,
-0.6895921230316162,
-0.5447795391082764,
-0.3021537661552429,
-1.149551510810852,
0.18651287257671356,
-0.3571731448173523,
-0.40743714570999146,
0.11247041076421738,
-0.269736111164093,
0.3533713221549988,
0.2421785295009613,
-0.5033891201019287,
0.646155595779419,
0.009652224369347095,
-0.26256415247917175,
-0.7833473682403564,
-0.7676594257354736,
0.05916592851281166,
-0.011421513743698597,
0.08254577219486237,
0.23014016449451447,
-0.2841767370700836,
1.1348814964294434,
-0.5814360976219177,
0.31888702511787415,
-0.20492345094680786,
-0.1680084466934204,
0.15856307744979858,
0.5129846334457397,
0.3433775007724762,
-0.029026132076978683,
0.008656447753310204,
0.10634312033653259,
0.5067909955978394,
-0.5310474038124084,
-0.653320848941803,
0.9303127527236938,
-0.5156386494636536,
-0.6441697478294373,
-0.2358746975660324,
0.052920252084732056,
-0.28151360154151917,
0.5587714314460754,
0.1938094198703766,
0.46329909563064575,
-0.29673680663108826,
0.2358763962984085,
0.5362431406974792,
-0.301150381565094,
-0.1921197474002838,
0.45900869369506836,
-0.6368858814239502,
-0.4231983423233032,
0.9277331233024597,
0.20810602605342865,
-0.08633802086114883,
0.7068785429000854,
0.40303513407707214,
-0.5746449828147888,
-0.19053885340690613,
-0.2812671363353729,
0.2621934711933136,
-0.8974650502204895,
-0.3677501380443573,
-0.42787712812423706,
0.11625540256500244,
-0.7085278034210205,
0.04240544140338898,
-0.62575364112854,
-0.7763810157775879,
0.20586208999156952,
-0.007966123521327972,
0.40409359335899353,
0.962284505367279,
-0.17411264777183533,
-0.023794002830982208,
-0.765620768070221,
0.6858855485916138,
0.2035977989435196,
0.7903057932853699,
0.03987281396985054,
-0.548378050327301,
-0.25398683547973633,
-0.15165714919567108,
0.10046122223138809,
-0.9022576212882996,
0.13916882872581482,
0.0795096755027771,
0.4729425609111786,
-0.04094002768397331,
0.0001010531050269492,
0.7431918978691101,
-0.3411608040332794,
0.6047458052635193,
-0.15941697359085083,
-0.9637451171875,
0.6329401731491089,
0.003806615946814418,
0.1884554922580719,
0.669734001159668,
0.5317898392677307,
-0.6496243476867676,
-0.16270305216312408,
-0.7601779699325562,
-0.8041669130325317,
0.42040205001831055,
-0.04475872218608856,
0.2689899206161499,
-0.15555992722511292,
0.06673745065927505,
0.4743664562702179,
0.15322279930114746,
-0.011840980499982834,
-0.0211724191904068,
-0.2469293177127838,
-0.21311907470226288,
0.23599377274513245,
-0.36215266585350037,
0.135078564286232,
-0.2920958995819092,
1.159767508506775,
0.12705561518669128,
0.2827117443084717,
0.37892693281173706,
-0.3083095848560333,
-0.027829870581626892,
0.17655663192272186,
0.15322957932949066,
0.48811981081962585,
-0.1832878440618515,
0.25040802359580994,
0.4517081081867218,
-0.6548714637756348,
0.07915231585502625,
-0.0550069622695446,
-0.02097911201417446,
0.2368258386850357,
0.2567827105522156,
0.37452271580696106,
0.3958800435066223,
-0.789259135723114,
0.8030261397361755,
-0.08483218401670456,
0.087864451110363,
-0.5548762083053589,
-0.40490180253982544,
-0.06285853683948517,
0.11887471377849579,
0.29807084798812866,
-0.47740834951400757,
0.3883490562438965,
-0.5035387873649597,
0.4251359701156616,
0.5636402368545532,
-0.11892237514257431,
-0.042066920548677444,
0.2587921917438507,
0.061862390488386154,
-0.06022845208644867,
0.5033321976661682,
0.18724603950977325,
-0.594079852104187,
0.08022195845842361,
0.5993768572807312,
0.7911587357521057,
-0.3356848657131195,
0.01768328994512558,
0.22403603792190552,
0.1969311237335205,
0.12666137516498566,
0.8130555152893066,
-0.1946096569299698,
-0.7533970475196838,
0.07156739383935928,
-0.8236218690872192,
-0.18617628514766693,
-0.20987026393413544,
-0.5225778818130493,
0.8797665238380432,
-0.28312981128692627,
-0.032108038663864136,
-0.4316522479057312,
-0.09541656821966171,
-0.8150620460510254,
0.4554596543312073,
-0.2443823367357254,
1.291184902191162,
-0.48906099796295166,
0.6254335641860962,
0.8228715658187866,
-0.4622057378292084,
-0.6305772662162781,
-0.07009616494178772,
-0.33480170369148254,
-1.046628475189209,
1.0066306591033936,
-0.21561981737613678,
-0.6569877862930298,
0.2018985003232956,
-0.32197338342666626,
-1.120489239692688,
0.8709572553634644,
0.13281726837158203,
0.004330420400947332,
-0.07392456382513046,
-0.09176676720380783,
0.6765424013137817,
-0.16162395477294922,
0.38704702258110046,
0.326437383890152,
0.48511990904808044,
0.03151042386889458,
-1.1151429414749146,
0.11333149671554565,
-0.25789546966552734,
0.4665285646915436,
0.28275245428085327,
-0.2507892847061157,
0.3886660039424896,
0.12824666500091553,
-0.5748113989830017,
0.2178083062171936,
0.6013315916061401,
-0.2259281724691391,
-0.2219327986240387,
0.3426399528980255,
0.9057567119598389,
0.04447483271360397,
0.2828659415245056,
1.0456221103668213,
-0.3124629259109497,
0.3315838575363159,
0.8749662637710571,
0.09149138629436493,
1.1227604150772095,
0.8458433747291565,
-0.10980044305324554,
0.3931405544281006,
0.18840689957141876,
0.2658412754535675,
0.6478165984153748,
0.20373833179473877,
0.16392655670642853,
-0.1803036779165268,
-0.3728642165660858,
-0.494657427072525,
0.8723103404045105,
0.2193632274866104,
-0.49394407868385315,
-0.5639060139656067,
0.18361830711364746,
-0.21727043390274048,
0.32684072852134705,
-0.07807055115699768,
0.9710790514945984,
-0.1962965875864029,
-0.3321439325809479,
0.971694827079773,
0.3263993561267853,
0.8163244724273682,
-0.39081981778144836,
-0.22370977699756622,
-0.08847808837890625,
-0.11838014423847198,
-0.15474708378314972,
-0.831658124923706,
0.45891764760017395,
-0.24713602662086487,
0.3803088665008545,
0.14817145466804504,
0.7429468035697937,
-0.40678781270980835,
-0.41273534297943115,
0.5377891063690186,
0.6082399487495422,
0.3654674291610718,
0.3039199113845825,
-0.28325220942497253,
-0.07063795626163483,
-0.46090614795684814,
-0.3529135286808014,
-0.027035072445869446,
0.354363352060318,
-0.1393912434577942,
0.5341517925262451,
0.30485278367996216,
0.3848001956939697,
0.11546246707439423,
-0.09558340162038803,
0.7195769548416138,
-0.857574462890625,
-0.6725314855575562,
-0.40234559774398804,
-0.18448695540428162,
0.3006135821342468,
-0.3540351986885071,
0.5508596301078796,
0.6754499673843384,
1.1927826404571533,
-0.220272034406662,
0.8364660143852234,
-0.3139473795890808,
0.9915162324905396,
-0.608795166015625,
0.5890111327171326,
-0.850982129573822,
-0.021019499748945236,
-0.36228737235069275,
-1.2194033861160278,
-0.2465590238571167,
0.5384922623634338,
-0.20785245299339294,
-0.08564674854278564,
0.42221492528915405,
1.0164484977722168,
-0.3785642385482788,
0.18563242256641388,
0.47461485862731934,
0.151341050863266,
-0.12378057837486267,
0.19019797444343567,
0.659324049949646,
-0.7722594738006592,
0.35754162073135376,
-0.31252750754356384,
-0.05579335615038872,
-0.3713052570819855,
-0.5846192240715027,
-0.5248355269432068,
-1.030318260192871,
0.3917727768421173,
-0.2954784035682678,
0.3158990442752838,
1.1487343311309814,
0.35444337129592896,
-0.8891546726226807,
-0.20603220164775848,
-0.05959263816475868,
0.13628502190113068,
0.10668809711933136,
-0.2613179385662079,
0.31728655099868774,
-0.04540527984499931,
-0.6514583826065063,
0.2416350394487381,
0.015303975902497768,
0.05991746112704277,
-0.4801885485649109,
0.018185973167419434,
-0.6381803750991821,
0.0977335199713707,
0.33969956636428833,
-0.025123756378889084,
-0.7429848313331604,
-0.3855081796646118,
-0.24490369856357574,
-0.15026268362998962,
-0.1390380710363388,
0.5961296558380127,
-1.0598260164260864,
0.6725865602493286,
0.9893859028816223,
0.86329185962677,
0.39988937973976135,
0.16885824501514435,
0.5583701133728027,
-0.624890148639679,
0.36953333020210266,
0.30308619141578674,
0.04573037475347519,
0.5170461535453796,
-0.2362712025642395,
0.4749164879322052,
0.28828364610671997,
0.015448101796209812,
-0.5432917475700378,
0.22707873582839966,
-0.24074852466583252,
-0.2688543498516083,
0.9438763856887817,
0.23184387385845184,
-0.4182342290878296,
-0.17158707976341248,
-0.1375415027141571,
0.405551940202713,
-0.16107779741287231,
0.8838733434677124,
0.6243070960044861,
0.0413285456597805,
0.1302608996629715,
-0.17563307285308838,
0.29266396164894104,
0.4729290008544922,
-0.2099362462759018,
-0.31244367361068726,
0.09481833875179291,
0.30648279190063477,
0.38507530093193054,
0.15149474143981934,
-0.5423693060874939,
0.2817334234714508,
0.09086812287569046,
0.19864201545715332,
-0.009573706425726414,
-0.3423665761947632,
-0.14056754112243652,
0.008980696089565754,
-0.05812631919980049,
-0.16911034286022186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19409v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19409v1
|
Countering Reward Over-optimization in LLM with Demonstration-Guided Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-04-30T09:57:21 | 2024-04-30T09:57:21 |
Mathieu Rita, Florian Strub, Rahma Chaabouni, Paul Michel, Emmanuel Dupoux, Olivier Pietquin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While Reinforcement Learning (RL) has been proven essential for tuning large
language models (LLMs), it can lead to reward over-optimization (ROO). Existing
approaches address ROO by adding KL regularization, requiring computationally
expensive hyperparameter tuning. Additionally, KL regularization focuses solely
on regularizing the language policy, neglecting a potential source of
regularization: the reward function itself. Inspired by demonstration-guided
RL, we here introduce the Reward Calibration from Demonstration (RCfD), which
leverages human demonstrations and a reward model to recalibrate the reward
objective. Formally, given a prompt, the RCfD objective minimizes the distance
between the demonstrations' and LLM's rewards rather than directly maximizing
the reward function. This objective shift avoids incentivizing the LLM to
exploit the reward model and promotes more natural and diverse language
generation. We show the effectiveness of RCfD on three language tasks, which
achieves comparable performance to carefully tuned baselines while mitigating
ROO.
|
[
-0.3005373179912567,
-0.5858185887336731,
0.3794999420642853,
0.2603573799133301,
-0.3467833697795868,
0.1118544414639473,
-0.5827287435531616,
0.06487448513507843,
-0.1209503635764122,
0.619195282459259,
-0.8134065270423889,
-0.3244543671607971,
-0.4898732900619507,
-0.07480329275131226,
0.2812432646751404,
1.3755278587341309,
-0.10087073594331741,
-0.1791759729385376,
-0.4099957346916199,
-0.04391232877969742,
-0.3987252712249756,
-0.3842402696609497,
-0.8345668911933899,
-0.7410275936126709,
0.6917462944984436,
0.5938623547554016,
0.4315055310726166,
0.7631503939628601,
-0.10266315191984177,
0.20931033790111542,
0.19509422779083252,
0.36178460717201233,
-0.912341833114624,
0.0891493707895279,
-0.19774438440799713,
-0.5758907198905945,
0.29273390769958496,
0.094285748898983,
0.6638590097427368,
0.4050409197807312,
-0.2962189018726349,
-0.1550404131412506,
-0.0663163810968399,
0.9044328331947327,
-1.1313151121139526,
0.19658125936985016,
-0.36327874660491943,
0.10205573588609695,
0.1855921447277069,
-0.46002042293548584,
-0.5953415036201477,
-0.6667189598083496,
-0.09571336954832077,
-0.6279510855674744,
-0.04577910527586937,
0.06122229993343353,
0.8223156929016113,
0.6522209644317627,
-0.2696368098258972,
-0.16728833317756653,
-0.8917970061302185,
1.1933619976043701,
-0.5082663297653198,
0.44665879011154175,
0.4169524610042572,
0.39460813999176025,
-0.2914150059223175,
-0.32323795557022095,
-0.41380980610847473,
-0.6000753045082092,
0.013217499479651451,
0.2557571530342102,
-0.1728733330965042,
0.09647971391677856,
0.44372108578681946,
0.17324864864349365,
-0.5585918426513672,
0.26639336347579956,
-0.2260570377111435,
-0.1828845739364624,
0.5991958379745483,
0.020116843283176422,
-0.012481538578867912,
0.06363281607627869,
-0.5112677216529846,
-0.7989927530288696,
-0.9341518878936768,
0.489059180021286,
0.5576430559158325,
0.23548780381679535,
0.07975472509860992,
0.40092456340789795,
-0.33856844902038574,
0.5394865870475769,
0.06927599012851715,
-0.17245016992092133,
0.03945042937994003,
-0.17031583189964294,
-0.20172351598739624,
0.14853891730308533,
0.6908626556396484,
0.34476956725120544,
0.518406093120575,
-0.126217320561409,
-0.5066728591918945,
0.24233277142047882,
0.32547006011009216,
-0.9057186245918274,
-0.12618182599544525,
-0.043389998376369476,
-0.16024604439735413,
-0.5453732013702393,
-0.1605958342552185,
-0.5501103401184082,
-0.23911239206790924,
-0.23957809805870056,
0.4960002899169922,
-0.1760973334312439,
-0.15019649267196655,
0.299873024225235,
-0.22346659004688263,
0.08088873326778412,
-0.039489295333623886,
-1.136757731437683,
0.45287737250328064,
0.7266476154327393,
0.4670659899711609,
-0.22269490361213684,
-0.3516002595424652,
-1.1276110410690308,
0.2081369012594223,
-0.5695198178291321,
0.5932611227035522,
-0.37625131011009216,
-0.49827805161476135,
0.026232944801449776,
-0.1568010002374649,
-0.10077482461929321,
-0.7492519617080688,
0.6214935183525085,
-0.5251508951187134,
0.2865796685218811,
-0.2697164714336395,
-0.46937456727027893,
-0.045793842524290085,
0.41468819975852966,
-0.45362699031829834,
0.8604543805122375,
0.18697930872440338,
-0.29097121953964233,
0.7111399173736572,
-0.624243974685669,
-0.6265013217926025,
-0.10272710770368576,
-0.39637458324432373,
-0.5293340682983398,
0.0037836492992937565,
0.3038727343082428,
0.2095772922039032,
-0.19920703768730164,
0.34012287855148315,
0.1235160082578659,
-0.4973137080669403,
0.1333569437265396,
-0.34792837500572205,
0.21625612676143646,
0.2536858916282654,
-0.4462086260318756,
0.46239224076271057,
-0.5819373726844788,
0.12088359892368317,
0.0725829154253006,
-0.5892820954322815,
-0.30433088541030884,
0.16169928014278412,
-0.11035905033349991,
0.21745774149894714,
0.02854836732149124,
-0.602276623249054,
0.1467936486005783,
-0.9096781015396118,
0.30399489402770996,
0.8587119579315186,
0.11668315529823303,
0.2954903841018677,
-0.6027680039405823,
0.942966103553772,
-0.31598585844039917,
0.14630630612373352,
-0.0011451398022472858,
-0.08593342453241348,
-0.5632069706916809,
-0.3730109632015228,
0.2958296835422516,
0.37695521116256714,
-0.712683916091919,
0.3290405571460724,
-0.18492773175239563,
-0.34635278582572937,
-0.47002512216567993,
0.16039709746837616,
0.7230568528175354,
0.3939787447452545,
0.39009103178977966,
-0.18962107598781586,
-0.28997543454170227,
-0.913824200630188,
-0.20635443925857544,
-0.06655142456293106,
-0.07419859617948532,
0.3807896673679352,
0.28510934114456177,
0.10503708571195602,
0.8333777189254761,
-0.5410727262496948,
-0.3502599895000458,
-0.43240049481391907,
0.37994977831840515,
0.14118462800979614,
0.6047248244285583,
0.40618062019348145,
-0.7795458436012268,
-0.5542911887168884,
0.10430285334587097,
-0.039302315562963486,
-0.16043324768543243,
-0.4454772472381592,
0.0772838369011879,
0.39673301577568054,
0.5143449902534485,
-0.28261798620224,
0.30962109565734863,
0.37332960963249207,
0.04287514090538025,
0.5858305096626282,
-0.5427955985069275,
0.17131610214710236,
-0.5844605565071106,
-0.07747570425271988,
-0.12851454317569733,
-0.4039528965950012,
-0.23382438719272614,
0.1450662612915039,
0.08872929215431213,
-0.02055526152253151,
-0.24361446499824524,
0.5482068657875061,
-0.058676719665527344,
-0.01754610985517502,
-0.6538332104682922,
0.12331714481115341,
-0.005279342643916607,
0.8024172782897949,
0.39600327610969543,
0.7767574191093445,
0.3201940059661865,
-0.6543684601783752,
0.3930070996284485,
-0.09132415801286697,
-0.25480180978775024,
0.3762487471103668,
-0.8471089005470276,
-0.18551982939243317,
-0.08170394599437714,
0.3126629590988159,
-0.8667021989822388,
-0.08357558399438858,
0.16891950368881226,
-0.43495306372642517,
0.2464962899684906,
-0.03789552301168442,
-0.28623253107070923,
-0.08013029396533966,
-0.6688957214355469,
0.46945732831954956,
0.8707537055015564,
-0.751160204410553,
0.23389051854610443,
-0.20149464905261993,
0.1164017841219902,
-0.6289030313491821,
-0.422926664352417,
-0.31997445225715637,
-0.27383068203926086,
-0.28138184547424316,
0.5364708304405212,
-0.055144116282463074,
0.0913766473531723,
-0.28362372517585754,
-0.15511687099933624,
0.493842214345932,
0.1873890459537506,
0.2556646466255188,
-0.06844066828489304,
-0.1211477592587471,
0.14796103537082672,
0.13079003989696503,
-0.2173098474740982,
0.14645697176456451,
-0.11844715476036072,
0.7584802508354187,
0.2430415153503418,
-0.4122288227081299,
-0.43152081966400146,
0.15819664299488068,
0.2686302959918976,
-0.18072694540023804,
0.6133221387863159,
0.5012936592102051,
-0.19795939326286316,
-0.43132269382476807,
-0.3552275598049164,
-0.42597484588623047,
-0.4869493544101715,
0.4896908104419708,
-0.2845500707626343,
-0.7378821969032288,
-0.013491345569491386,
-0.3422936201095581,
0.06292089819908142,
0.03733852505683899,
0.5244830250740051,
0.2462739646434784,
1.3511455059051514,
0.644950807094574,
-0.1773594170808792,
0.6792007088661194,
-0.17051829397678375,
-0.03480897098779678,
-0.6711959838867188,
-0.15256759524345398,
-0.5105835199356079,
-0.26367518305778503,
-0.5587437152862549,
-0.15923559665679932,
0.2248089462518692,
0.27331265807151794,
-0.39979228377342224,
0.15480467677116394,
-0.30749207735061646,
0.6803264021873474,
0.8813850283622742,
0.11791342496871948,
0.1837569922208786,
-0.07922579348087311,
-0.1995304971933365,
-0.3057253658771515,
-0.7291146516799927,
-0.38121673464775085,
1.0560120344161987,
0.18178510665893555,
0.9032156467437744,
-0.03638095036149025,
0.9548447728157043,
0.2951522767543793,
0.3261878490447998,
-0.7122498750686646,
0.3104029595851898,
-0.04649181663990021,
0.040021393448114395,
-0.45050400495529175,
-0.6288578510284424,
-1.0208661556243896,
0.09566567838191986,
-0.15081584453582764,
-0.5962399244308472,
0.1073393002152443,
0.4334748089313507,
-0.35841816663742065,
-0.15120702981948853,
-0.649379551410675,
1.0683013200759888,
-0.27549582719802856,
-0.3791607618331909,
-0.6598576307296753,
-0.4821418523788452,
0.300066202878952,
0.18442896008491516,
0.18841105699539185,
0.23407024145126343,
0.06366611272096634,
0.620978832244873,
-0.32541972398757935,
0.658916711807251,
-0.2862858474254608,
-0.11125575751066208,
-0.2725488841533661,
0.08720089495182037,
0.9356070160865784,
0.024429935961961746,
0.24340806901454926,
-0.9449229836463928,
-0.22325991094112396,
-0.47971272468566895,
-0.9963606595993042,
0.9340835809707642,
-0.7704887390136719,
-0.46506181359291077,
-0.24576881527900696,
-0.5517191886901855,
-0.35282251238822937,
-0.09724484384059906,
0.03111879527568817,
0.33487120270729065,
-0.16612470149993896,
0.1377287060022354,
0.7421104311943054,
-0.43995678424835205,
0.1877557635307312,
0.38046780228614807,
-0.1165505200624466,
-0.5067322850227356,
1.374089241027832,
-0.4145311117172241,
0.8497309684753418,
0.5782119631767273,
0.5411844253540039,
-0.6084035634994507,
-0.35842087864875793,
-0.49213096499443054,
0.187015101313591,
-0.59000164270401,
0.030111657455563545,
-0.3138662576675415,
0.0856415405869484,
-0.3568646311759949,
-0.40342769026756287,
-0.42551419138908386,
-0.28694865107536316,
-0.15840855240821838,
-0.04650398716330528,
0.19859832525253296,
0.5045179128646851,
-0.22148500382900238,
0.35993483662605286,
-0.3310031294822693,
0.28275996446609497,
0.48201075196266174,
0.12751315534114838,
-0.09674493968486786,
-0.4629133939743042,
-0.09311528503894806,
0.22341197729110718,
-0.4531983435153961,
-0.34559953212738037,
0.3926565945148468,
0.14704284071922302,
0.6925525665283203,
0.5685035586357117,
0.4060664474964142,
0.585014820098877,
-0.32193419337272644,
0.6244635581970215,
0.32189854979515076,
-0.6516988277435303,
0.6089933514595032,
0.036455072462558746,
0.24285078048706055,
0.3502039313316345,
0.4686967730522156,
-0.6749799251556396,
-0.4493664801120758,
-0.5301567316055298,
-0.8493465781211853,
0.7941203713417053,
-0.11345815658569336,
0.189028799533844,
-0.07149860262870789,
0.13532094657421112,
-0.024667702615261078,
0.22776485979557037,
-0.9482753276824951,
-0.11238294094800949,
-0.3521575629711151,
-0.15852034091949463,
-0.2988308072090149,
-0.09861317276954651,
-0.3814065158367157,
-0.008702828548848629,
1.0002126693725586,
-0.32581785321235657,
-0.16784316301345825,
0.09397021681070328,
-0.19592256844043732,
-0.41307902336120605,
0.3490848243236542,
1.1728960275650024,
0.39111974835395813,
-0.2889220118522644,
-0.05038825795054436,
-0.10397360473871231,
-0.015095044858753681,
0.0685352012515068,
0.004314815159887075,
-0.21276840567588806,
-0.40526697039604187,
0.15186382830142975,
1.130471110343933,
0.2904828190803528,
-1.0740485191345215,
0.6109479069709778,
0.14894592761993408,
-0.364399254322052,
-0.011405606754124165,
0.47266995906829834,
-0.02549881301820278,
0.41076895594596863,
0.2879865765571594,
-0.23449541628360748,
-0.13969726860523224,
-0.42121031880378723,
0.20698849856853485,
0.5861566066741943,
-0.4257521331310272,
0.13595817983150482,
0.6890780329704285,
-0.15718573331832886,
-0.49310365319252014,
0.38827526569366455,
-0.23305699229240417,
-0.6886100769042969,
0.6403993368148804,
0.7892050743103027,
0.6559861898422241,
0.12715603411197662,
0.39470332860946655,
0.37374454736709595,
0.2620617747306824,
-0.21963724493980408,
0.11547435820102692,
-0.42703408002853394,
-0.7239366769790649,
-0.8252663612365723,
-0.3770240843296051,
-0.5548765063285828,
0.2359773963689804,
-0.8099817633628845,
0.24335719645023346,
-0.5555644035339355,
0.2672121822834015,
-0.13070683181285858,
0.11403799057006836,
-0.15128932893276215,
0.2516711354255676,
-0.05416008457541466,
0.590105414390564,
-0.9737861156463623,
0.760292112827301,
0.5023268461227417,
-0.44153010845184326,
-0.6369026899337769,
-0.09287214279174805,
-0.516514241695404,
-0.8508104681968689,
1.0067999362945557,
-0.05940524861216545,
-0.310383141040802,
0.20517393946647644,
-0.6019706130027771,
-0.29323163628578186,
0.9136812686920166,
0.33847424387931824,
-0.42961275577545166,
0.3346208333969116,
0.10867629945278168,
0.5485619306564331,
-0.390670508146286,
0.16189561784267426,
0.3956280052661896,
0.5378450751304626,
0.22739297151565552,
-0.6905391216278076,
0.09019909799098969,
0.20500299334526062,
0.04469415172934532,
0.37928885221481323,
-0.4876993000507355,
0.5417691469192505,
-0.31017568707466125,
-0.18912610411643982,
0.06603004783391953,
0.508193850517273,
0.808494508266449,
0.02237480692565441,
0.73989337682724,
0.4600921869277954,
0.3454333245754242,
0.024727286770939827,
1.1349796056747437,
0.022181954234838486,
0.3122556209564209,
0.9726186990737915,
-0.28423210978507996,
0.7155093550682068,
0.7709932923316956,
-0.1635562628507614,
0.39918339252471924,
0.5104333162307739,
0.08425337076187134,
0.920042872428894,
0.7362588047981262,
-0.25287315249443054,
-0.6125305891036987,
-0.2896897494792938,
-0.1634896695613861,
0.007637494709342718,
0.1971084475517273,
-0.16948202252388,
-0.4320557415485382,
0.17363235354423523,
-0.32132911682128906,
0.7841135859489441,
-0.18737059831619263,
0.7032211422920227,
-0.2910584509372711,
-0.8584494590759277,
0.9735539555549622,
0.135785311460495,
0.8171361088752747,
-0.735325038433075,
-0.2893889844417572,
-0.2619098722934723,
0.23694346845149994,
0.12201619893312454,
-0.30819863080978394,
-0.008852020837366581,
-0.2632189691066742,
-0.18252097070217133,
-0.6097431778907776,
0.4064851403236389,
-0.7010297179222107,
-0.10212254524230957,
0.11107024550437927,
0.1219605803489685,
0.1381777822971344,
-0.041385501623153687,
-0.4905658960342407,
-0.13979819416999817,
0.16285403072834015,
-0.3174349367618561,
0.6296072602272034,
0.2310740351676941,
-0.2529807388782501,
0.9577669501304626,
0.7529082894325256,
0.2381884604692459,
-0.15746554732322693,
0.2426036298274994,
0.866837739944458,
-0.6190537214279175,
-0.6948320865631104,
-0.8376582860946655,
0.15113498270511627,
-0.03337755799293518,
-0.32531410455703735,
0.28334400057792664,
0.6492930054664612,
1.2006733417510986,
-0.2360113263130188,
0.5502604842185974,
0.22400997579097748,
0.4788455665111542,
-0.7481278777122498,
0.45442894101142883,
-0.8223458528518677,
0.06877592951059341,
-0.09462489932775497,
-0.5538668036460876,
-0.17366263270378113,
0.7736439108848572,
-0.2524343430995941,
-0.03652585670351982,
0.5077450275421143,
1.0389440059661865,
0.018407728523015976,
-0.14879243075847626,
0.5773202776908875,
-0.27264073491096497,
0.3350830376148224,
0.7598105669021606,
1.0357598066329956,
-0.0551719143986702,
0.725044310092926,
-0.40873125195503235,
-0.19746094942092896,
-0.19140850007534027,
-1.0515748262405396,
-0.7794658541679382,
-0.20755352079868317,
-0.4075039029121399,
-0.06745178252458572,
0.26652419567108154,
1.2063850164413452,
0.6224039793014526,
-0.8594168424606323,
-0.3509540557861328,
-0.3292512595653534,
0.35851988196372986,
-0.5783663392066956,
-0.30039793252944946,
0.24110157787799835,
-0.600111722946167,
-0.8321294188499451,
0.5994373559951782,
0.15930481255054474,
-0.006026634946465492,
-0.3902369737625122,
-0.5730527639389038,
-0.18439780175685883,
-0.0915311649441719,
0.3414037525653839,
0.6832510232925415,
-0.6812694072723389,
-0.4017484784126282,
-0.14007049798965454,
-0.18683500587940216,
0.015925265848636627,
0.9691449999809265,
-1.082002878189087,
0.22094103693962097,
0.3478800654411316,
0.9689667820930481,
0.7197234034538269,
0.1599590927362442,
0.8781917095184326,
-1.1425881385803223,
0.060697633773088455,
0.24367354810237885,
-0.036499474197626114,
0.12742237746715546,
-0.19377918541431427,
0.25984400510787964,
0.18939651548862457,
-0.6513028740882874,
-1.0655587911605835,
0.46902912855148315,
-0.7078980803489685,
-0.2578343152999878,
1.1535035371780396,
-0.14224615693092346,
-0.11547575891017914,
0.09606775641441345,
-0.37649884819984436,
0.17276981472969055,
-0.5581056475639343,
0.7959041595458984,
0.5800754427909851,
-0.0716179758310318,
-0.29335078597068787,
-0.49407151341438293,
0.8940329551696777,
0.8559538722038269,
-0.67888343334198,
0.21584102511405945,
0.4868376553058624,
0.21891197562217712,
-0.055428992956876755,
0.5158828496932983,
0.20585277676582336,
0.6111389398574829,
-0.39050641655921936,
0.306832879781723,
-0.29660287499427795,
-0.3160485029220581,
-0.4005337357521057,
-0.0940457135438919,
0.4782309830188751,
-0.4276154041290283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19369v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19369v1
|
Evaluating Telugu Proficiency in Large Language Models_ A Comparative Analysis of ChatGPT and Gemini
| 2024-04-30T08:55:01 | 2024-04-30T08:55:01 |
Katikela Sreeharsha Kishore, Rahimanuddin Shaik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
The growing prominence of large language models (LLMs) necessitates the
exploration of their capabilities beyond English. This research investigates
the Telugu language proficiency of ChatGPT and Gemini, two leading LLMs.
Through a designed set of 20 questions encompassing greetings, grammar,
vocabulary, common phrases, task completion, and situational reasoning, the
study delves into their strengths and weaknesses in handling Telugu. The
analysis aims to identify the LLM that demonstrates a deeper understanding of
Telugu grammatical structures, possesses a broader vocabulary, and exhibits
superior performance in tasks like writing and reasoning. By comparing their
ability to comprehend and use everyday Telugu expressions, the research sheds
light on their suitability for real-world language interaction. Furthermore,
the evaluation of adaptability and reasoning capabilities provides insights
into how each LLM leverages Telugu to respond to dynamic situations. This
comparative analysis contributes to the ongoing discussion on multilingual
capabilities in AI and paves the way for future research in developing LLMs
that can seamlessly integrate with Telugu-speaking communities.
|
[
-0.2594374716281891,
-0.8456851840019226,
0.44282880425453186,
0.4069441258907318,
-0.16935022175312042,
0.46161672472953796,
-0.3646567463874817,
-0.5954766869544983,
0.20070600509643555,
0.15930938720703125,
-0.30188998579978943,
-0.2060203105211258,
-0.7457672953605652,
0.09929359704256058,
-0.48678386211395264,
0.724790096282959,
0.036117564886808395,
0.18220944702625275,
-0.1960974782705307,
0.0359492227435112,
-0.5850186347961426,
-0.41637346148490906,
-1.0831294059753418,
-0.32485273480415344,
0.36511385440826416,
0.23196274042129517,
0.8466467261314392,
0.17702683806419373,
0.587481677532196,
0.47077494859695435,
-0.2517413794994354,
-0.006748398765921593,
-0.5237380266189575,
0.2956800162792206,
-0.09121668338775635,
-0.3864959180355072,
-0.4097138047218323,
-0.2186213731765747,
1.1349220275878906,
0.5052697658538818,
0.009384388104081154,
0.058965202420949936,
0.11276793479919434,
0.26376399397850037,
-0.22029249370098114,
0.5846794843673706,
-0.6417121291160583,
0.010400311090052128,
-0.20474804937839508,
0.1761460155248642,
-0.2842567563056946,
-0.4754489064216614,
0.026249365881085396,
-0.30148595571517944,
-0.349468469619751,
-0.11847482621669769,
0.8357145190238953,
0.1640685498714447,
-0.39548978209495544,
-0.15409371256828308,
-0.70998215675354,
0.6955730319023132,
-0.5832224488258362,
0.37265774607658386,
0.04267206788063049,
0.3708224594593048,
-0.020347457379102707,
-0.6047478914260864,
-0.5294584035873413,
-0.6870824098587036,
-0.01525830291211605,
0.3320921063423157,
-0.1929195374250412,
-0.09239710867404938,
0.12605570256710052,
0.47318771481513977,
-0.6813417077064514,
0.42980608344078064,
-0.41653284430503845,
-0.31159737706184387,
0.5794203877449036,
0.23864907026290894,
0.41591742634773254,
-0.22851456701755524,
-0.03659388795495033,
-0.026131663471460342,
-0.6955443024635315,
-0.003871957305818796,
0.22905704379081726,
0.16555297374725342,
-0.2927214503288269,
0.8822800517082214,
0.18814879655838013,
0.6428093314170837,
-0.3068855404853821,
-0.3414580821990967,
-0.04499378427863121,
-0.23684103786945343,
-0.11795256286859512,
-0.17528074979782104,
0.7230494618415833,
0.12861713767051697,
0.4750463664531708,
-0.1046605333685875,
-0.19143477082252502,
-0.019525500014424324,
0.14556746184825897,
-0.6309065222740173,
0.34424668550491333,
0.20217205584049225,
-0.3201616704463959,
0.1374220848083496,
-0.07266555726528168,
-0.4730178415775299,
-0.5123157501220703,
-0.23388519883155823,
0.4497396945953369,
-0.6312061548233032,
-0.5621283054351807,
-0.3008384704589844,
-0.12093954533338547,
0.7084783315658569,
0.23248358070850372,
-0.8382235765457153,
0.32513561844825745,
1.3456541299819946,
0.9144819974899292,
-0.5796836018562317,
-0.7236155271530151,
-0.3128504753112793,
-0.1945626586675644,
-0.3164292275905609,
0.8240452408790588,
-0.5402149558067322,
-0.48213115334510803,
0.0013257658574730158,
-0.390340119600296,
-0.38649848103523254,
-0.6831284165382385,
0.5064266920089722,
-0.6040759086608887,
-0.12288285791873932,
-0.026448680087924004,
-0.5115199089050293,
0.08693106472492218,
0.5057834982872009,
-0.44628527760505676,
0.8873141407966614,
0.39496099948883057,
-0.7130393385887146,
0.1837463676929474,
-0.4964480698108673,
-0.47587850689888,
0.340373158454895,
-0.22348366677761078,
-0.13340361416339874,
-0.003787992289289832,
-0.15271137654781342,
0.5294627547264099,
-0.22737956047058105,
0.27354326844215393,
-0.11203087121248245,
-0.48077821731567383,
0.6031387448310852,
-0.37620317935943604,
0.4572007954120636,
0.3014282286167145,
0.06594002991914749,
0.37772512435913086,
-0.5748928785324097,
0.14927364885807037,
0.025681093335151672,
-0.49120938777923584,
-0.030065538361668587,
-0.18131953477859497,
0.06462568044662476,
0.1470092236995697,
0.3890901505947113,
-0.3181445300579071,
0.043325275182724,
-0.5891768336296082,
0.5265046954154968,
0.6473094820976257,
-0.2578102946281433,
0.38033950328826904,
-0.30786025524139404,
0.7629873752593994,
-0.08444485068321228,
0.1353694349527359,
-0.11335378885269165,
-0.8133463263511658,
-0.8251926898956299,
-0.2250719517469406,
0.40262898802757263,
0.6651037931442261,
-0.6791531443595886,
0.09266937524080276,
-0.42391687631607056,
-0.6803800463676453,
-0.5113118886947632,
0.10212769359350204,
0.5601862668991089,
0.32041293382644653,
0.12428030371665955,
-0.44615763425827026,
-0.47654810547828674,
-0.9164271950721741,
-0.2963027358055115,
-0.283551961183548,
0.19168734550476074,
0.2722373306751251,
0.5732898712158203,
-0.06941653788089752,
0.6510543823242188,
-0.344366192817688,
0.09592239558696747,
-0.8372222185134888,
-0.22577841579914093,
0.2555786669254303,
0.17629610002040863,
0.372917503118515,
-0.9493062496185303,
-0.760140597820282,
0.11472335457801819,
-0.6349658966064453,
0.07476071268320084,
0.18643924593925476,
0.10112730413675308,
0.386199027299881,
0.5007779002189636,
-0.8180111050605774,
0.25860893726348877,
0.6648852825164795,
-0.45709842443466187,
0.8016742467880249,
-0.31290385127067566,
0.08167819678783417,
-1.0848690271377563,
0.015893548727035522,
-0.010439639911055565,
-0.0006665062392130494,
-0.8130158185958862,
0.2910904884338379,
-0.04736700654029846,
-0.1729007363319397,
-0.4385068416595459,
0.7957044839859009,
-0.420545369386673,
-0.5417603850364685,
-0.19368764758110046,
0.31372329592704773,
-0.4831475019454956,
-0.003757941536605358,
0.27651363611221313,
0.8538981676101685,
0.7674912810325623,
-0.4303474426269531,
0.5134941935539246,
0.09025460481643677,
-0.41241368651390076,
0.7673346996307373,
-0.786296010017395,
-0.08337754011154175,
-0.10321260243654251,
-0.05829579755663872,
-1.1980314254760742,
-0.3201635777950287,
0.04994881525635719,
-0.7769834995269775,
0.305658221244812,
-0.2867286801338196,
-0.38520681858062744,
-0.2229475975036621,
-0.0761384591460228,
-0.012317621149122715,
0.5669655203819275,
-0.004031370859593153,
0.7285968065261841,
0.412125825881958,
-0.5084943771362305,
-0.542182981967926,
-0.5948516130447388,
0.3133832514286041,
-0.3943040370941162,
-0.723060667514801,
0.2462611049413681,
-0.05594651401042938,
-0.8305962681770325,
-0.35117483139038086,
0.14291726052761078,
-0.1868131309747696,
0.08824189007282257,
0.3518203794956207,
0.42760583758354187,
-0.5305750966072083,
0.09771314263343811,
-0.04214826598763466,
-0.2984548509120941,
0.014798169024288654,
0.002173942979425192,
0.9138839840888977,
-0.5126713514328003,
-0.33853334188461304,
-0.1415126770734787,
0.15947020053863525,
0.5502998232841492,
-0.3711479604244232,
1.0241293907165527,
0.6425666213035583,
-0.22808681428432465,
0.2528941035270691,
-0.5746247172355652,
0.11505839973688126,
-0.44003579020500183,
0.5225316882133484,
-0.47322455048561096,
-0.8523111343383789,
0.6908303499221802,
0.3021940290927887,
0.0984625443816185,
0.47617828845977783,
0.8180149793624878,
0.14361988008022308,
0.4816194772720337,
0.4734942317008972,
-0.2300151288509369,
0.35724684596061707,
-0.20162010192871094,
0.06726507842540741,
-0.7857041954994202,
-0.37071195244789124,
-0.5809169411659241,
-0.13138388097286224,
-0.6998380422592163,
-0.48353320360183716,
0.32799115777015686,
-0.45143255591392517,
-0.36642295122146606,
0.3137615919113159,
-0.11573328822851181,
0.41800615191459656,
0.4162157475948334,
-0.30481117963790894,
0.4661295413970947,
-0.2089112401008606,
-0.16119384765625,
-0.06524312496185303,
-0.4811614453792572,
-0.48708680272102356,
0.8899992108345032,
0.31219378113746643,
0.5858203768730164,
0.42152369022369385,
0.43222030997276306,
0.007139459252357483,
0.3346204459667206,
-0.9658591151237488,
0.7540932297706604,
-0.08962253481149673,
-0.5218867659568787,
-0.33945390582084656,
-0.44448962807655334,
-1.0813801288604736,
0.5051075220108032,
-0.2827058434486389,
-0.7509114146232605,
-0.47676002979278564,
-0.25045156478881836,
-0.11533521860837936,
0.03495514765381813,
-0.97345370054245,
0.7570867538452148,
-0.26310744881629944,
-0.1994364857673645,
-0.4057106077671051,
-0.4985854923725128,
0.2411891222000122,
-0.07076338678598404,
0.20046217739582062,
-0.08712087571620941,
-0.350774884223938,
0.45378580689430237,
-0.006894527468830347,
0.7084092497825623,
0.16940940916538239,
-0.10011334717273712,
0.2678111791610718,
0.0532950833439827,
-0.06596601754426956,
0.1730060875415802,
-0.32422560453414917,
0.03311249986290932,
-0.025732265785336494,
-0.26546111702919006,
-0.27523860335350037,
1.0349725484848022,
-0.9845992922782898,
-0.500586211681366,
-0.6239742040634155,
-0.6178756952285767,
-0.4360288083553314,
0.22847482562065125,
0.004420577548444271,
0.16626159846782684,
-0.4638864994049072,
-0.02641315758228302,
0.48501724004745483,
-0.25015637278556824,
0.6327111124992371,
0.7120779156684875,
-0.47126874327659607,
-0.22759082913398743,
0.7737536430358887,
0.1946176141500473,
0.4267880618572235,
0.5566808581352234,
0.2185605764389038,
-0.4988955557346344,
-0.7053094506263733,
-0.43966391682624817,
0.40891942381858826,
-0.7106102705001831,
0.20939312875270844,
-0.40342339873313904,
-0.5418106913566589,
-0.5263317227363586,
0.19071748852729797,
-0.39417797327041626,
-0.4237894117832184,
0.03170807659626007,
0.19680140912532806,
0.17710815370082855,
0.8679121136665344,
0.26658526062965393,
0.3479279577732086,
-0.7498993873596191,
0.24465623497962952,
0.3000499904155731,
0.3668094873428345,
0.029726577922701836,
-0.8151652216911316,
-0.009245633147656918,
-0.14051173627376556,
-0.4277343153953552,
-0.8557826280593872,
0.3224483132362366,
0.20139934122562408,
0.767073929309845,
0.27968263626098633,
-0.5055928230285645,
0.6801065802574158,
-0.18491938710212708,
0.7092157006263733,
-0.10221747308969498,
-1.007252812385559,
0.4080258011817932,
-0.37226003408432007,
0.39056238532066345,
0.16498011350631714,
0.6256454586982727,
-0.7718521356582642,
-0.3262600302696228,
-0.649791419506073,
-0.5874980688095093,
0.43840232491493225,
0.43266549706459045,
0.218588724732399,
0.20345386862754822,
0.5877653956413269,
-0.08239059895277023,
0.05295930802822113,
-0.7555487155914307,
-0.21306957304477692,
0.10221926867961884,
-0.02002248540520668,
-0.3414132595062256,
-0.10663863271474838,
0.3345503807067871,
-0.4079023003578186,
0.5164168477058411,
-0.11243078857660294,
0.159551203250885,
-0.26129409670829773,
-0.1253100484609604,
0.33532100915908813,
0.4288010001182556,
0.4728655219078064,
0.8550767302513123,
0.2905794382095337,
0.04761940613389015,
0.5961777567863464,
-0.7468769550323486,
-0.044352564960718155,
0.15526291728019714,
-0.0572078600525856,
-0.22307497262954712,
0.5836823582649231,
0.4855087697505951,
0.15866991877555847,
-0.9161407351493835,
0.2297734022140503,
-0.23341119289398193,
0.3995749354362488,
-0.5730547904968262,
0.3098823130130768,
0.5389696359634399,
0.31058192253112793,
0.16690663993358612,
-0.19351576268672943,
-0.14789526164531708,
-0.8859962821006775,
-0.22492654621601105,
0.6216179728507996,
-0.25569719076156616,
-0.2506411075592041,
0.13798454403877258,
0.019686806946992874,
-0.542461097240448,
0.8834980726242065,
-0.05227076634764671,
-0.47086435556411743,
0.8532668948173523,
0.6930994987487793,
0.4868958294391632,
-0.5419103503227234,
0.10282988101243973,
0.33043140172958374,
0.32036787271499634,
0.01730741374194622,
0.38159313797950745,
0.2761279046535492,
-0.8882461786270142,
-0.6545315384864807,
-0.6747010350227356,
-0.7643294930458069,
0.15250058472156525,
-0.3622673749923706,
0.3937905430793762,
-0.3447287976741791,
-0.2247636616230011,
0.1811036765575409,
0.14037124812602997,
-0.19361676275730133,
0.17330382764339447,
0.24832352995872498,
0.8181924223899841,
-0.5316991806030273,
0.8848134875297546,
0.8448179364204407,
-0.31943953037261963,
-0.7599349617958069,
-0.13341587781906128,
-0.07517427951097488,
-1.0818372964859009,
0.5352892875671387,
0.1657785326242447,
0.01438995823264122,
-0.12842202186584473,
-0.07071266323328018,
-0.6639202833175659,
0.8988963961601257,
0.5065169930458069,
-0.29275861382484436,
0.06530392169952393,
0.5921372771263123,
0.9852566719055176,
-0.30448052287101746,
0.7086289525032043,
0.8671319484710693,
0.581447958946228,
0.292544960975647,
-1.3953328132629395,
-0.3462604284286499,
-0.3025825321674347,
0.0008616360137239099,
0.180266335606575,
-0.9130117297172546,
0.8013451099395752,
-0.2944478392601013,
0.03544536232948303,
0.2752932906150818,
0.7107790112495422,
0.3204040229320526,
0.1807970255613327,
0.21974171698093414,
0.299886554479599,
0.5345583558082581,
-0.4238307774066925,
0.9772359132766724,
-0.251985639333725,
0.016185907647013664,
0.95604407787323,
-0.253953218460083,
1.1845601797103882,
0.37149712443351746,
-0.38994377851486206,
0.2640899419784546,
0.4343963861465454,
-0.02246096357703209,
-0.11354653537273407,
0.3625503480434418,
-0.21874681115150452,
-0.1917893886566162,
0.015145832672715187,
-0.2915326654911041,
0.9449527263641357,
0.5291574597358704,
-0.1319827139377594,
-0.1265418827533722,
-0.07381041347980499,
0.271444171667099,
0.056929994374513626,
-0.46431493759155273,
0.7605043649673462,
0.31066668033599854,
-1.3054369688034058,
0.4303644895553589,
0.23835861682891846,
0.6481879353523254,
-0.784612238407135,
0.10778315365314484,
-0.38056716322898865,
0.4470173418521881,
-0.15358354151248932,
-1.31597900390625,
0.7394486665725708,
0.1675460934638977,
0.3962220251560211,
-0.12986239790916443,
0.8911919593811035,
-0.1446717530488968,
-0.3827641010284424,
0.13711346685886383,
0.7038164138793945,
0.3896951377391815,
-0.14142312109470367,
-0.697413444519043,
0.29045823216438293,
-0.21965692937374115,
0.08310546725988388,
0.554166316986084,
0.15632280707359314,
-0.060553405433893204,
1.1127550601959229,
0.28510648012161255,
0.20877063274383545,
0.06657052785158157,
0.1074618548154831,
0.7271732091903687,
-0.6661623120307922,
-0.301326185464859,
-1.0192005634307861,
0.20874431729316711,
-0.07357633113861084,
-0.5078364014625549,
1.0236233472824097,
0.8389731049537659,
0.5043770670890808,
-0.10771292448043823,
0.643035352230072,
-0.1855965107679367,
0.38253408670425415,
-0.38515034317970276,
0.8033903241157532,
-0.19940835237503052,
0.3432579040527344,
-0.13591255247592926,
-0.943107008934021,
-0.14993049204349518,
0.6288757920265198,
-0.38149064779281616,
0.313300758600235,
0.5218440890312195,
0.7026364207267761,
0.10229059308767319,
0.03987544775009155,
0.41980692744255066,
0.4808676242828369,
0.2779333293437958,
0.7080344557762146,
1.3705919981002808,
-0.11773911118507385,
0.6439855098724365,
-0.014465147629380226,
-0.20913663506507874,
0.05664040893316269,
-0.8930146098136902,
-1.0951412916183472,
-0.6597170829772949,
-0.12808547914028168,
-0.3440747857093811,
-0.012185564264655113,
0.6586539149284363,
0.37413379549980164,
-0.6115463972091675,
-0.5109730362892151,
0.3154895305633545,
0.3389483690261841,
-0.068668894469738,
-0.16992603242397308,
0.2899799048900604,
-0.08218269795179367,
-0.8807522058486938,
0.232089564204216,
0.31935998797416687,
0.12319298088550568,
-0.6340406537055969,
-0.1890755593776703,
0.10511169582605362,
0.2240065187215805,
0.7727806568145752,
0.18715812265872955,
-0.5755483508110046,
0.020179666578769684,
0.09704011678695679,
-0.05558376386761665,
0.12556421756744385,
0.557611882686615,
-0.6463612914085388,
-0.06714130192995071,
0.5997435450553894,
0.19819670915603638,
0.4600090980529785,
-0.2452467679977417,
0.19775564968585968,
-0.35471341013908386,
0.14401964843273163,
0.26714450120925903,
0.4482410252094269,
0.49007800221443176,
-0.08355484902858734,
0.3231733441352844,
-0.015584677457809448,
-0.5456713438034058,
-0.4730725586414337,
0.17957854270935059,
-1.068153977394104,
-0.050817303359508514,
1.3793118000030518,
-0.3092152178287506,
0.03731561079621315,
-0.3289811909198761,
-0.4355839490890503,
0.034833457320928574,
-0.25543278455734253,
0.7905495762825012,
0.8788675665855408,
-0.22179871797561646,
-0.22465503215789795,
-0.5030452609062195,
0.24019864201545715,
0.22171831130981445,
-1.1051244735717773,
-0.20819345116615295,
0.23224833607673645,
0.37970834970474243,
0.13939259946346283,
0.6301960349082947,
-0.22484293580055237,
0.3066159188747406,
-0.04983964189887047,
-0.5003825426101685,
0.11005298793315887,
-0.16427332162857056,
-0.3008803427219391,
0.15059685707092285,
0.5785766243934631,
0.46593332290649414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19364v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19364v1
|
Navigating Brain Language Representations: A Comparative Analysis of Neural Language Models and Psychologically Plausible Models
| 2024-04-30T08:48:07 | 2024-04-30T08:48:07 |
Yunhao Zhang, Shaonan Wang, Xinyi Dong, Jiajun Yu, Chengqing Zong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Neural language models, particularly large-scale ones, have been consistently
proven to be most effective in predicting brain neural activity across a range
of studies. However, previous research overlooked the comparison of these
models with psychologically plausible ones. Moreover, evaluations were reliant
on limited, single-modality, and English cognitive datasets. To address these
questions, we conducted an analysis comparing encoding performance of various
neural language models and psychologically plausible models. Our study utilized
extensive multi-modal cognitive datasets, examining bilingual word and
discourse levels. Surprisingly, our findings revealed that psychologically
plausible models outperformed neural language models across diverse contexts,
encompassing different modalities such as fMRI and eye-tracking, and spanning
languages from English to Chinese. Among psychologically plausible models, the
one incorporating embodied information emerged as particularly exceptional.
This model demonstrated superior performance at both word and discourse levels,
exhibiting robust prediction of brain activation across numerous regions in
both English and Chinese.
|
[
-0.1914556622505188,
-0.6998743414878845,
0.6952685713768005,
0.6530755162239075,
0.10446654260158539,
-0.0887286439538002,
-0.7384642362594604,
-0.44746753573417664,
0.044567208737134933,
0.0121831763535738,
-0.3242291808128357,
-0.21598482131958008,
-0.6840481758117676,
0.01698978804051876,
-0.3260554373264313,
0.4280630052089691,
0.2737354338169098,
0.5039163827896118,
-0.3806312680244446,
-0.07980605959892273,
-0.6989060640335083,
-0.8238825798034668,
-0.8269765973091125,
-0.8280304670333862,
0.633629560470581,
-0.6249752640724182,
0.8360137343406677,
0.4099051058292389,
0.1758446842432022,
0.32171666622161865,
-0.11556090414524078,
0.015487574972212315,
-0.17402192950248718,
-0.09180387109518051,
-0.10286542773246765,
-0.6452397108078003,
-0.3790890872478485,
-0.0701637864112854,
0.5446937084197998,
0.9788544178009033,
-0.32652929425239563,
-0.2651832699775696,
0.22744794189929962,
0.30462372303009033,
-0.5523115992546082,
0.3355032801628113,
-0.6291421055793762,
0.10481587052345276,
0.0408475436270237,
-0.038575250655412674,
-0.8968077898025513,
-0.0018938463181257248,
0.3318961560726166,
-0.4939838647842407,
-0.21896737813949585,
-0.25288572907447815,
0.7338603734970093,
-0.16378812491893768,
-0.7460355162620544,
-0.25882893800735474,
-0.7675548791885376,
0.7269131541252136,
-0.7581227421760559,
0.7853534817695618,
0.6907357573509216,
0.10500384867191315,
-0.004143129102885723,
-0.6221112012863159,
-0.5453696846961975,
-0.5057659149169922,
-0.25149300694465637,
0.08892151713371277,
-0.33051738142967224,
0.24235643446445465,
0.3101322054862976,
0.015341346152126789,
-0.677419126033783,
0.23721006512641907,
-0.008256617933511734,
-0.3849017918109894,
0.4430738389492035,
0.21987520158290863,
0.5034792423248291,
-0.27970221638679504,
-0.09921494126319885,
-0.26777470111846924,
-0.5429831743240356,
0.04978705942630768,
0.08902852982282639,
0.47230789065361023,
-0.2583029866218567,
0.5433279871940613,
0.194473534822464,
0.6164216995239258,
0.026341421529650688,
-0.13541565835475922,
0.06785212457180023,
-0.22513246536254883,
-0.16649644076824188,
-0.049555521458387375,
0.80682373046875,
0.3835529088973999,
0.28598254919052124,
-0.5623826384544373,
-0.32621046900749207,
0.2887312173843384,
0.3543321490287781,
-0.5228589773178101,
-0.19011946022510529,
0.14350943267345428,
-0.7572419047355652,
0.2771483361721039,
0.01779290661215782,
-0.42746803164482117,
-0.5213587284088135,
-0.25985950231552124,
0.25251612067222595,
-0.8298308253288269,
-0.6253318190574646,
0.22925344109535217,
0.005608722567558289,
0.2425757199525833,
0.17628587782382965,
-1.0875201225280762,
0.1858798712491989,
0.8000299334526062,
0.8916142582893372,
-0.1578628122806549,
-0.41671717166900635,
0.19452954828739166,
0.009889360517263412,
-0.5062195062637329,
0.6126830577850342,
-0.6031413674354553,
-0.1670645922422409,
0.26008400321006775,
-0.20782427489757538,
-0.3133067488670349,
-0.31706884503364563,
0.24044910073280334,
-0.7730985879898071,
0.26108741760253906,
-0.6458338499069214,
-0.4447668492794037,
-0.3680973947048187,
0.22492840886116028,
-0.86496502161026,
0.7189568877220154,
-0.06896621733903885,
-0.6760605573654175,
0.39415937662124634,
-0.3374141752719879,
-0.49592849612236023,
-0.24845165014266968,
-0.34055671095848083,
0.231125146150589,
0.3992695212364197,
0.05113639682531357,
0.6222310662269592,
-0.3904738426208496,
0.4076709449291229,
-0.15553322434425354,
-0.331211656332016,
0.665874719619751,
-0.7148594260215759,
0.9846059083938599,
0.025043342262506485,
-0.21881769597530365,
-0.21087640523910522,
-0.46756482124328613,
-0.02185528166592121,
0.11596067249774933,
-0.3713001608848572,
-0.4822809100151062,
0.20535090565681458,
0.13799329102039337,
0.269698828458786,
0.27973151206970215,
-0.5714704394340515,
-0.07231129705905914,
-0.3710974454879761,
0.43284907937049866,
0.5323187112808228,
-0.40533682703971863,
0.7333790063858032,
-0.028470804914832115,
0.48527273535728455,
0.09064901620149612,
-0.3038046360015869,
-0.35930949449539185,
-0.5728842616081238,
-0.4708200991153717,
-0.1266336590051651,
0.4869367480278015,
0.44381216168403625,
-0.6719766855239868,
0.14161984622478485,
-0.45002463459968567,
-0.35239294171333313,
-0.4602638781070709,
-0.3995274603366852,
0.3908671736717224,
0.26364436745643616,
0.292195588350296,
-0.06831701099872589,
-0.49608197808265686,
-0.9868253469467163,
-0.3757264316082001,
-0.48311707377433777,
-0.1553771048784256,
0.15027880668640137,
0.2616182267665863,
-0.21042531728744507,
0.5138213634490967,
-0.20635321736335754,
0.07801435887813568,
-0.21562664210796356,
0.42435386776924133,
0.19954811036586761,
0.3805896043777466,
0.7426080703735352,
-0.5069875121116638,
-0.30477356910705566,
0.36099034547805786,
-0.9307422041893005,
0.2392323762178421,
-0.47489407658576965,
0.0970047190785408,
0.2752901613712311,
0.3788383901119232,
-0.6583536863327026,
0.46957480907440186,
0.6083933711051941,
-0.3213884234428406,
0.42885464429855347,
-0.4325876235961914,
0.2827489376068115,
-0.7357746958732605,
0.12059906125068665,
0.007865717634558678,
0.017103103920817375,
-0.7984079718589783,
-0.13525131344795227,
0.447936475276947,
0.1460484117269516,
0.057879526168107986,
0.39817360043525696,
-0.6898622512817383,
0.09564373642206192,
-0.3808511197566986,
-0.07947205752134323,
-0.36085328459739685,
0.703727662563324,
0.26717525720596313,
0.6806626915931702,
0.9097619652748108,
-0.4581346809864044,
0.06094624102115631,
-0.09000378102064133,
-0.3687760531902313,
0.16722068190574646,
-0.6085039973258972,
0.09917272627353668,
-0.41088560223579407,
0.20851247012615204,
-1.156357765197754,
-0.20969434082508087,
-0.19477562606334686,
-0.4827950894832611,
0.4272556006908417,
0.19908668100833893,
-0.5926989912986755,
-0.06858598440885544,
0.042591553181409836,
0.6046985387802124,
0.5087042450904846,
-0.25081178545951843,
0.8015961050987244,
0.409507155418396,
0.08881057053804398,
-0.43801236152648926,
-1.2133643627166748,
0.3119252026081085,
-0.06396602839231491,
-0.4984288811683655,
0.6379712224006653,
0.09317473322153091,
-0.0826854407787323,
-0.22388538718223572,
0.02059333212673664,
-0.17375515401363373,
-0.09109687060117722,
0.22054170072078705,
0.15536528825759888,
-0.5049071907997131,
0.0008971587521955371,
-0.08425973355770111,
-0.018403101712465286,
0.5913475155830383,
-0.09234284609556198,
0.6034123301506042,
-0.12322185188531876,
-0.40682950615882874,
-0.25031739473342896,
0.4799676239490509,
0.6504551768302917,
-0.1781654953956604,
0.9641778469085693,
0.44220173358917236,
-0.8515172600746155,
-0.05229784548282623,
-0.46333688497543335,
-0.3405402898788452,
-0.42463183403015137,
0.510657548904419,
-0.5269445776939392,
-0.5686565637588501,
0.77218097448349,
0.11140618473291397,
-0.15729689598083496,
0.029899759218096733,
0.38608476519584656,
-0.02303238958120346,
1.5825304985046387,
0.6973340511322021,
0.07878731191158295,
0.5637317895889282,
-0.17367671430110931,
0.30993202328681946,
-0.7747109532356262,
-0.39279094338417053,
-0.2711847722530365,
-0.19623926281929016,
-0.6916386485099792,
-0.4677092730998993,
0.2539692223072052,
-0.26504549384117126,
-0.09366226941347122,
0.4303281605243683,
-0.21342891454696655,
0.3541329503059387,
0.276481032371521,
0.052102066576480865,
-0.006607867777347565,
0.22172094881534576,
-0.5425414443016052,
-0.43107929825782776,
-1.0254191160202026,
-0.48607534170150757,
1.0786354541778564,
0.36976301670074463,
0.513827919960022,
0.006059390492737293,
0.12437234818935394,
-0.09905198961496353,
0.2811906933784485,
-0.6319258809089661,
0.6657200455665588,
-0.17745853960514069,
-0.6874761581420898,
0.07601980865001678,
-0.17643322050571442,
-1.0314301252365112,
0.4422825574874878,
-0.3680722415447235,
-0.9528380036354065,
0.24515503644943237,
-0.20014525949954987,
-0.3724158704280853,
0.30472707748413086,
-0.666728138923645,
0.7092052102088928,
-0.3758402168750763,
-0.2642715871334076,
-0.5023607611656189,
-0.42461031675338745,
0.32507967948913574,
-0.05802641436457634,
0.1786847710609436,
0.33457422256469727,
-0.2912469804286957,
0.5964841246604919,
0.10510610789060593,
0.7900716662406921,
-0.11297478526830673,
-0.27163609862327576,
-0.0775633156299591,
0.21514493227005005,
-0.12066424638032913,
-0.11007887125015259,
-0.4246426522731781,
0.46016213297843933,
0.054121293127536774,
-0.33155930042266846,
-0.8572601675987244,
0.7404932975769043,
-0.7424118518829346,
-0.3947364389896393,
-0.44759824872016907,
-0.4760531783103943,
-0.3008452355861664,
0.20091605186462402,
0.3440714180469513,
0.4994368255138397,
-0.33573687076568604,
0.1462467759847641,
0.5859150886535645,
-0.3215550482273102,
0.640743613243103,
0.14588946104049683,
-0.2691561281681061,
-0.46012917160987854,
0.750265896320343,
0.31321582198143005,
-0.00130726327188313,
0.6095660328865051,
-0.0897151455283165,
-0.42251646518707275,
-0.5915567278862,
-0.20982351899147034,
0.39681369066238403,
-0.6106319427490234,
0.08063280582427979,
-0.5168681740760803,
-0.09142372757196426,
-0.3133717477321625,
0.014589516445994377,
-0.44489365816116333,
-0.1627742499113083,
0.05346332862973213,
-0.10676147043704987,
-0.07478878647089005,
0.7042854428291321,
-0.1826983392238617,
0.2976170778274536,
-0.37274467945098877,
0.11394430696964264,
0.10732081532478333,
0.4395310580730438,
0.5991660952568054,
-0.2549777030944824,
-0.6150147914886475,
0.4457607567310333,
-0.05524195730686188,
-1.3584071397781372,
0.2543624937534332,
0.019485466182231903,
0.8036036491394043,
0.5271291732788086,
-0.4030294716358185,
0.8334373235702515,
-0.6129675507545471,
1.0018645524978638,
0.37249213457107544,
-0.7774578928947449,
0.23212841153144836,
-0.38472896814346313,
0.47948476672172546,
0.31010371446609497,
0.6134122014045715,
-0.5209016799926758,
-0.2564467489719391,
-0.44340017437934875,
-0.7583326697349548,
0.594956636428833,
0.13949717581272125,
0.24760979413986206,
-0.25748410820961,
0.29449763894081116,
0.1457158923149109,
0.05827388912439346,
-0.9750905632972717,
-0.3485525846481323,
-0.1403641700744629,
0.013599316589534283,
-0.06373937427997589,
0.0023199429269880056,
0.1867905706167221,
-0.36462798714637756,
0.18431901931762695,
-0.0913853570818901,
0.8662024140357971,
0.10045188665390015,
-0.09829173237085342,
0.2748027443885803,
-0.11504016816616058,
0.45354965329170227,
0.6323182582855225,
0.011319020763039589,
0.3113402724266052,
0.23900969326496124,
-0.4132007360458374,
-0.05710405483841896,
-0.20003199577331543,
-0.010676783509552479,
0.1680547595024109,
0.660206139087677,
0.8872091770172119,
0.33029288053512573,
-0.6557096242904663,
0.3207554817199707,
-0.2423686385154724,
0.09730595350265503,
-0.32679426670074463,
-0.222230926156044,
0.5037668347358704,
0.2356945425271988,
0.22000309824943542,
0.16106577217578888,
0.07083169370889664,
-0.6688815355300903,
-0.11172091960906982,
0.6035683751106262,
-0.22821582853794098,
-0.6700277328491211,
0.6840298771858215,
-0.11836213618516922,
-0.34147679805755615,
0.7632282376289368,
-0.021634727716445923,
-0.5376686453819275,
0.5139536261558533,
0.7576510310173035,
0.9569845795631409,
-0.1762397438287735,
0.015490381978452206,
0.7118080258369446,
0.44314995408058167,
-0.19431816041469574,
0.26766350865364075,
-0.14022096991539001,
-0.9415826797485352,
-0.539222240447998,
-0.20355446636676788,
0.08057466894388199,
0.2748008072376251,
-0.7232971787452698,
-0.10176599770784378,
-0.3375415503978729,
-0.6675865054130554,
-0.016705961897969246,
-0.3286314308643341,
-0.8017934560775757,
0.22291594743728638,
0.6496759653091431,
1.0382965803146362,
-0.9442476034164429,
1.0086523294448853,
1.064757227897644,
-0.365776389837265,
-0.8573428392410278,
0.10565498471260071,
-0.2707391381263733,
-0.5730758905410767,
0.4506450593471527,
0.16548800468444824,
-0.2126655876636505,
-0.3052673935890198,
-0.2046082764863968,
-0.7884568572044373,
1.0123306512832642,
0.7049784064292908,
-0.07467573136091232,
-0.35081228613853455,
0.351082444190979,
0.8593336343765259,
-0.48862090706825256,
0.6453053951263428,
0.4541352391242981,
0.5405222177505493,
-0.3425177335739136,
-0.8683001399040222,
0.21682225167751312,
-0.42358916997909546,
0.30339476466178894,
-0.21357867121696472,
-0.3972240686416626,
0.8099787831306458,
-0.0023165694437921047,
-0.4246944487094879,
0.10131149739027023,
1.0981876850128174,
0.23857393860816956,
0.2159692496061325,
0.39816349744796753,
0.11418677866458893,
0.8353940844535828,
-0.08615996688604355,
1.0779496431350708,
-0.5316929221153259,
-0.03843208774924278,
0.7179251909255981,
-0.08629581332206726,
0.9586414098739624,
0.6084626913070679,
-0.12090633809566498,
0.6976682543754578,
0.5684447884559631,
0.3492502272129059,
0.6185362935066223,
-0.004326052498072386,
-0.07592978328466415,
-0.3821883201599121,
0.015296821482479572,
-0.273029625415802,
0.5750784277915955,
0.48618581891059875,
-0.30599334836006165,
-0.1092567890882492,
0.1322999745607376,
-0.006632945965975523,
0.23980674147605896,
-0.07603372633457184,
0.5613217949867249,
0.16754932701587677,
-1.0906312465667725,
0.8092643022537231,
0.2622101306915283,
0.9168129563331604,
-0.7851603031158447,
0.07223403453826904,
-0.34580084681510925,
-0.10434176027774811,
0.02851158380508423,
-0.6948375701904297,
0.24435414373874664,
0.006092607509344816,
-0.16075603663921356,
-0.6775935888290405,
0.7790992856025696,
-0.49277210235595703,
-0.1444198340177536,
0.6937706470489502,
0.5792546272277832,
-0.028564412146806717,
-0.1325310319662094,
-0.6322813034057617,
0.13995449244976044,
-0.039075817912817,
-0.2900392711162567,
0.40189921855926514,
0.5245016813278198,
-0.07664921134710312,
0.6869943737983704,
0.38185885548591614,
0.32185062766075134,
0.31997305154800415,
-0.09486495703458786,
0.49165767431259155,
-0.9045085310935974,
-0.5341812372207642,
-0.880342423915863,
0.619998037815094,
-0.030432626605033875,
-0.30118221044540405,
0.779306948184967,
0.45150455832481384,
0.7448291182518005,
-0.22438330948352814,
0.598646342754364,
-0.07203446328639984,
-0.16877630352973938,
-0.44886940717697144,
0.834821343421936,
-0.49524345993995667,
0.12847581505775452,
-0.2720237076282501,
-0.7493425011634827,
-0.1632668673992157,
0.9495901465415955,
-0.2260759323835373,
0.25863346457481384,
0.9433443546295166,
0.9185798168182373,
-0.2783210873603821,
0.30531811714172363,
0.3949239253997803,
0.39201819896698,
0.03156059607863426,
0.7973477840423584,
1.0428203344345093,
-0.4341699182987213,
0.07555003464221954,
-0.2390061616897583,
-0.28331658244132996,
0.18725937604904175,
-1.0337955951690674,
-0.8046512603759766,
-0.9411730170249939,
-0.26414474844932556,
-0.25571775436401367,
-0.25804880261421204,
0.8450019955635071,
0.9490456581115723,
-0.6242892146110535,
-0.6197633743286133,
0.04433564096689224,
-0.1268647462129593,
-0.46075406670570374,
-0.16819435358047485,
0.1889898031949997,
-0.03967985138297081,
-0.7454491257667542,
0.653400719165802,
0.11879204958677292,
-0.10939526557922363,
-0.5471885204315186,
-0.10973798483610153,
-0.19563601911067963,
0.28744930028915405,
0.7989450693130493,
0.08504555374383926,
-0.8532875776290894,
-0.13123807311058044,
0.39070746302604675,
-0.47796329855918884,
-0.12497273087501526,
0.8690152168273926,
-0.9429031610488892,
0.24085965752601624,
0.6793385744094849,
0.6920313835144043,
0.3469892740249634,
-0.5886867642402649,
0.9638102054595947,
-0.39196839928627014,
0.11896537989377975,
0.11958158761262894,
0.5512712597846985,
0.36760348081588745,
-0.2595592141151428,
0.2755863070487976,
-0.13809484243392944,
-0.2314496487379074,
-0.875883162021637,
0.13495858013629913,
-1.1870719194412231,
-0.4129277765750885,
1.1938551664352417,
-0.143545463681221,
-0.38842055201530457,
0.16877491772174835,
-0.16267193853855133,
0.279995858669281,
-0.10699029266834259,
0.8401644825935364,
1.070913553237915,
-0.2066735476255417,
0.11120842397212982,
-0.622433602809906,
0.21473202109336853,
0.7731267809867859,
-0.22032830119132996,
0.14864347875118256,
0.4526563286781311,
-0.029278365895152092,
0.3344874382019043,
0.5320789813995361,
-0.089415542781353,
0.31313610076904297,
0.19449403882026672,
-0.20796003937721252,
0.2292061597108841,
-0.31544291973114014,
-0.5026625394821167,
0.29498711228370667,
-0.02748008258640766,
0.05531921610236168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19363v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19363v1
|
Expressivity and Speech Synthesis
| 2024-04-30T08:47:24 | 2024-04-30T08:47:24 |
Andreas Triantafyllopoulos, Björn W. Schuller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Imbuing machines with the ability to talk has been a longtime pursuit of
artificial intelligence (AI) research. From the very beginning, the community
has not only aimed to synthesise high-fidelity speech that accurately conveys
the semantic meaning of an utterance, but also to colour it with inflections
that cover the same range of affective expressions that humans are capable of.
After many years of research, it appears that we are on the cusp of achieving
this when it comes to single, isolated utterances. This unveils an abundance of
potential avenues to explore when it comes to combining these single utterances
with the aim of synthesising more complex, longer-term behaviours. In the
present chapter, we outline the methodological advances that brought us so far
and sketch out the ongoing efforts to reach that coveted next level of
artificial expressivity. We also discuss the societal implications coupled with
rapidly advancing expressive speech synthesis (ESS) technology and highlight
ways to mitigate those risks and ensure the alignment of ESS capabilities with
ethical norms.
|
[
-0.4074650704860687,
-0.7137479186058044,
0.33984121680259705,
0.28090953826904297,
0.33528581261634827,
0.5990087985992432,
-0.3601298928260803,
-0.761034369468689,
0.5267188549041748,
0.500765860080719,
-0.4852633774280548,
-0.05583716183900833,
-0.5112267732620239,
0.1454661786556244,
-0.6045334935188293,
0.5967315435409546,
0.2439749836921692,
-0.20709900557994843,
-0.2561233341693878,
-0.4522852897644043,
-0.03710482642054558,
-0.9624722599983215,
-0.6144726276397705,
-0.06916878372430801,
0.3542436957359314,
0.41926127672195435,
0.7524278163909912,
0.4228341579437256,
0.22920940816402435,
0.3988358676433563,
-0.19478121399879456,
0.21781302988529205,
-0.18168479204177856,
0.5840975642204285,
-0.08076443523168564,
-0.4153163433074951,
-0.2953471541404724,
0.09488381445407867,
0.6069794297218323,
0.7552696466445923,
0.1647300124168396,
0.1336609274148941,
0.009906117804348469,
0.6768378615379333,
-0.2795150876045227,
0.01809675805270672,
-0.5230590105056763,
0.08659296482801437,
-0.060021743178367615,
0.040660008788108826,
-0.3531193435192108,
-0.17457562685012817,
0.0269888024777174,
-0.44788211584091187,
-0.11668488383293152,
-0.025374818593263626,
0.35861825942993164,
0.3245689570903778,
-0.18861420452594757,
-0.5543891191482544,
-0.9056853652000427,
0.8200014233589172,
-0.7476966977119446,
0.3102303147315979,
0.18811239302158356,
0.21477186679840088,
-0.08157971501350403,
-1.1835144758224487,
-0.7080376148223877,
-0.4455179274082184,
-0.017160890623927116,
-0.0021702630911022425,
-0.5243594646453857,
0.21993617713451385,
0.3476220965385437,
0.08546210080385208,
-0.0399857722222805,
0.08315672725439072,
-0.7776933908462524,
-0.22753511369228363,
0.8211325407028198,
0.08380251377820969,
0.6675435900688171,
0.08887680619955063,
0.010412430390715599,
0.060200512409210205,
-0.8541774749755859,
0.11140556633472443,
0.6553585529327393,
0.5339534878730774,
0.16658014059066772,
0.5878488421440125,
-0.29956182837486267,
0.4421151578426361,
-0.15230722725391388,
0.333234965801239,
0.20275945961475372,
-0.35765761137008667,
0.05065640062093735,
0.18800795078277588,
0.6017917394638062,
0.08049240708351135,
-0.036861248314380646,
-0.12090789526700974,
-0.15080684423446655,
0.3896827697753906,
0.3800436854362488,
-0.6922649145126343,
0.22631244361400604,
0.477455198764801,
-0.35910844802856445,
-0.2899518609046936,
-0.12379637360572815,
-0.7534653544425964,
-0.36168527603149414,
-0.80485600233078,
0.433649480342865,
-0.19710075855255127,
-0.4713907837867737,
-0.003944695927202702,
-0.35635697841644287,
0.1708293855190277,
0.0818658247590065,
-1.0586827993392944,
0.7201719880104065,
0.7948543429374695,
0.5631540417671204,
-0.16323140263557434,
-0.26250410079956055,
-0.5130820870399475,
0.2719714641571045,
-0.36187148094177246,
0.48136261105537415,
-0.7707303166389465,
-0.4814554750919342,
-0.019387483596801758,
-0.14473989605903625,
0.25268661975860596,
-0.7363442182540894,
0.6970868706703186,
0.09803088009357452,
0.3029542565345764,
-0.2554263770580292,
-0.40155890583992004,
-0.10560532659292221,
-0.23113654553890228,
-0.4375782608985901,
0.7947158217430115,
-0.024839693680405617,
-0.15195441246032715,
-0.22635413706302643,
-1.1597027778625488,
-0.8087338805198669,
-0.05751936510205269,
-0.2881959080696106,
-0.11711250245571136,
0.5167333483695984,
-0.056512340903282166,
0.17998386919498444,
0.01800370216369629,
-0.08748988062143326,
0.019094880670309067,
-0.1809311956167221,
0.4976537227630615,
-0.2801298201084137,
0.5320032835006714,
0.2926377058029175,
-0.4602721631526947,
0.40942904353141785,
-0.5654710531234741,
0.1219584122300148,
-0.3671448826789856,
0.21163277328014374,
-0.05603105574846268,
0.36446264386177063,
0.11862768232822418,
0.29826194047927856,
0.23375637829303741,
-0.5483411550521851,
-0.34330546855926514,
-0.7896808385848999,
1.3899811506271362,
0.7310155034065247,
-0.15311448276042938,
0.5271479487419128,
-0.4670861065387726,
0.6006855368614197,
-0.21841731667518616,
0.3134983777999878,
-0.33589473366737366,
-0.4667156934738159,
-0.6476543545722961,
-0.22106841206550598,
-0.17857567965984344,
0.4512646198272705,
-0.13632439076900482,
0.28055447340011597,
0.0739126205444336,
-0.5553759932518005,
-0.9592335820198059,
-0.34975406527519226,
0.1514226645231247,
0.3512818515300751,
0.1863694041967392,
-0.18683205544948578,
-0.616901159286499,
-1.1979097127914429,
-0.44004586338996887,
-0.27444031834602356,
0.05196196585893631,
0.21540121734142303,
0.17568057775497437,
0.05527028068900108,
0.7489529252052307,
-0.14294394850730896,
-0.09553917497396469,
-0.081193707883358,
0.1337483823299408,
0.1567048281431198,
0.7804151773452759,
0.27042442560195923,
-1.0714483261108398,
-0.22666537761688232,
0.1306241750717163,
-0.7214150428771973,
0.13755285739898682,
-0.13220161199569702,
0.003330943873152137,
0.04714466258883476,
0.8393604159355164,
-0.7385322451591492,
0.35140904784202576,
0.28900349140167236,
0.01901612989604473,
0.23015271127223969,
-0.04107726365327835,
0.4609804153442383,
-0.6983486413955688,
-0.032055456191301346,
-0.42060044407844543,
-0.10517402738332748,
-0.9119776487350464,
0.004033826757222414,
-0.4802907109260559,
-0.4972817897796631,
-0.753809928894043,
0.5691251754760742,
-0.5358591079711914,
-0.14279785752296448,
-0.2758403420448303,
0.3217863440513611,
-0.16673628985881805,
0.3356727957725525,
-0.3090035319328308,
0.7744712233543396,
0.7137791514396667,
-0.5683318376541138,
0.48324087262153625,
0.3336721658706665,
-0.02689920738339424,
0.6788719892501831,
-0.8589922189712524,
0.39745578169822693,
-0.19271954894065857,
-0.18808907270431519,
-0.8774558901786804,
-0.37492311000823975,
0.0340004563331604,
-0.8566731214523315,
0.09590950608253479,
0.2522655725479126,
-0.105430006980896,
-0.2698124349117279,
-0.11072806268930435,
0.2773630917072296,
0.8075518012046814,
-0.12465985119342804,
0.9434512257575989,
0.9071505069732666,
-0.7943295240402222,
-0.21901923418045044,
-0.9955539703369141,
0.5269042253494263,
-0.4883503317832947,
-0.6903635263442993,
0.2850608825683594,
-0.14783138036727905,
-0.5714187622070312,
-0.16635626554489136,
0.01969669945538044,
0.09483680129051208,
0.20131509006023407,
0.4755423665046692,
-0.28562822937965393,
0.16250286996364594,
0.0669066309928894,
0.46845361590385437,
-0.14922143518924713,
0.2471442073583603,
0.010994535870850086,
0.2501572370529175,
-0.25359463691711426,
-0.45918700098991394,
-0.7001793384552002,
1.1468162536621094,
0.8817790746688843,
-0.24374690651893616,
0.30378976464271545,
0.19190064072608948,
-0.5316142439842224,
-0.1549924612045288,
-0.12417136877775192,
-0.40635037422180176,
-0.5012272000312805,
0.4468689262866974,
-0.34032079577445984,
-0.8185674548149109,
0.49979355931282043,
-0.3807893693447113,
0.03873749449849129,
0.09787729382514954,
0.4661361575126648,
-0.12859870493412018,
1.3335942029953003,
0.43890559673309326,
0.30012351274490356,
0.6849592924118042,
0.11447758972644806,
0.4442022442817688,
-0.9061444997787476,
-0.1258012056350708,
-0.7128836512565613,
-0.39155057072639465,
-0.9564458131790161,
-0.06270689517259598,
0.5850718021392822,
-0.287341833114624,
-0.35387560725212097,
0.044614892452955246,
-0.8604686856269836,
0.3136031925678253,
0.7637946605682373,
0.12424056977033615,
-0.029157966375350952,
-0.08943253010511398,
0.5060877799987793,
-0.10629795491695404,
-0.3550567030906677,
-0.7442154288291931,
0.8530459403991699,
0.1549631804227829,
0.3316602110862732,
0.255720853805542,
0.7211781144142151,
0.4770837128162384,
0.3641081154346466,
-0.673568606376648,
0.6930155158042908,
-0.17739237844944,
-0.553610622882843,
-0.26529374718666077,
0.15221989154815674,
-0.9272441864013672,
0.17936226725578308,
-0.2038578987121582,
-0.6465421915054321,
-0.07056191563606262,
0.2536703944206238,
0.04882321134209633,
-0.03900892660021782,
-0.7430950403213501,
0.6079104542732239,
-0.22240068018436432,
-0.5009958744049072,
-0.3836725354194641,
-1.054054856300354,
-0.022329041734337807,
0.43002963066101074,
0.2888626754283905,
-0.13479986786842346,
-0.21537669003009796,
0.582243800163269,
0.030397864058613777,
0.8488417267799377,
-0.03550038859248161,
0.09821833670139313,
0.3171333968639374,
-0.19025713205337524,
0.318284273147583,
-0.5127297043800354,
-0.3141949474811554,
-0.058466050773859024,
-0.00245982245542109,
-0.29124709963798523,
-0.4802480638027191,
0.5293079614639282,
-0.6138084530830383,
-0.8721736073493958,
-0.07832200080156326,
-0.26340803503990173,
-0.32116755843162537,
0.18737830221652985,
0.07552071660757065,
0.5478879809379578,
-0.6672161221504211,
-0.05524899810552597,
0.6610926389694214,
-0.12467837333679199,
0.39470216631889343,
-0.0340871587395668,
-0.21386675536632538,
-0.6027473211288452,
0.9320248365402222,
-0.00967915914952755,
0.515458881855011,
0.20555147528648376,
0.23677973449230194,
-0.3348199725151062,
-0.37293392419815063,
-0.39178478717803955,
0.17286130785942078,
-0.8049263954162598,
0.11448340117931366,
-0.5690440535545349,
-0.0565071627497673,
-0.6985921859741211,
-0.3575294613838196,
-0.33813291788101196,
-0.8974459767341614,
-0.40015557408332825,
-0.37332025170326233,
0.1872551143169403,
1.0349491834640503,
-0.3254985511302948,
-0.029640385881066322,
-0.5298008918762207,
0.3252049386501312,
0.33624646067619324,
-0.26003697514533997,
-0.167412668466568,
-0.18585897982120514,
0.14896434545516968,
0.303478479385376,
-0.28561556339263916,
-0.9783216118812561,
0.4407770037651062,
0.3408759534358978,
0.7487471103668213,
0.002286014147102833,
0.026502633467316628,
0.3868950605392456,
-0.5204527378082275,
1.1763150691986084,
0.17608128488063812,
-1.3604803085327148,
0.8062511682510376,
-0.25044405460357666,
-0.045643046498298645,
0.3915686011314392,
0.16203425824642181,
-0.7780338525772095,
-0.7745240926742554,
-0.842210590839386,
-1.1470756530761719,
0.3087383210659027,
0.30216410756111145,
0.586456835269928,
-0.010978290811181068,
0.02268778160214424,
0.23500721156597137,
0.49233466386795044,
-0.3340893089771271,
-0.23745357990264893,
-0.14658914506435394,
-0.40663355588912964,
0.14068566262722015,
0.16431398689746857,
-0.6352309584617615,
-0.2138952761888504,
0.5694524049758911,
-0.142771914601326,
0.4906666874885559,
0.2052442729473114,
0.16445572674274445,
0.12133988738059998,
0.4307651221752167,
0.7182299494743347,
0.7262367010116577,
0.363996684551239,
0.14882610738277435,
-0.2570222318172455,
-0.008633716031908989,
0.2386517971754074,
0.0957978293299675,
-0.15391281247138977,
-0.029321517795324326,
-0.01889333315193653,
0.8341019749641418,
-0.31883737444877625,
-0.8409105539321899,
0.33975833654403687,
0.20305147767066956,
0.07685461640357971,
-0.5151570439338684,
0.10913977771997452,
0.17825689911842346,
0.24911248683929443,
0.1901879906654358,
0.3470098078250885,
0.3080548346042633,
-0.9132421612739563,
0.1429993063211441,
0.5214962363243103,
-0.4056813716888428,
-0.4188748598098755,
0.8747226595878601,
0.5045339465141296,
-0.7491062879562378,
0.4791114032268524,
0.07766135782003403,
-0.4637250006198883,
0.678266704082489,
0.3496463894844055,
1.1449906826019287,
-0.259007066488266,
-0.026533253490924835,
0.10730410367250443,
0.33536481857299805,
0.16340579092502594,
0.47079911828041077,
-0.3825054466724396,
-0.4876580834388733,
-0.23311573266983032,
-0.30391326546669006,
-0.7226542830467224,
-0.4480455815792084,
-0.7007060050964355,
0.033961277455091476,
-0.2750261723995209,
-0.16021235287189484,
0.20574958622455597,
-0.5080465078353882,
-0.36704152822494507,
-0.004118054639548063,
0.3009438216686249,
0.5112733244895935,
-0.8676491379737854,
0.26367828249931335,
0.7244716286659241,
-0.36312034726142883,
-0.527086079120636,
-0.36791911721229553,
-0.06489936262369156,
-0.5696767568588257,
0.5813961625099182,
0.30451077222824097,
-0.5124292373657227,
0.16371576488018036,
-0.8531247973442078,
-0.7263525724411011,
0.6226929426193237,
0.4201802909374237,
-0.13864441215991974,
0.29680395126342773,
0.24448828399181366,
0.6196657419204712,
-0.39983081817626953,
0.10246904194355011,
0.6307347416877747,
0.5836180448532104,
-0.10002227872610092,
-0.8455850481987,
0.03973166272044182,
-0.39439189434051514,
-0.06940530985593796,
0.18001416325569153,
-0.7255591154098511,
0.6314595937728882,
-0.2999832332134247,
-0.46723809838294983,
0.35942748188972473,
1.0572147369384766,
-0.17042477428913116,
0.41851484775543213,
0.1418893039226532,
0.20663593709468842,
0.7919549345970154,
-0.19138607382774353,
0.7045939564704895,
-0.13043706119060516,
-0.27807822823524475,
0.7365053296089172,
-0.43345415592193604,
0.7302741408348083,
0.6090019941329956,
-0.22374337911605835,
0.20564015209674835,
0.22486957907676697,
0.572879433631897,
0.3262626528739929,
0.5600060224533081,
-0.8030893802642822,
-0.05219221115112305,
-0.4557908773422241,
-0.18643678724765778,
0.6216997504234314,
0.7806084752082825,
-0.31159430742263794,
0.48010241985321045,
0.42087438702583313,
-0.05714383348822594,
0.4459128975868225,
-0.20524396002292633,
0.9396610856056213,
-0.02554638497531414,
-0.8947155475616455,
0.13097158074378967,
-0.45353204011917114,
0.5543248653411865,
-0.611518383026123,
-0.31587767601013184,
0.04680037871003151,
-0.20833829045295715,
-0.1849922388792038,
-0.7508217096328735,
0.5855579376220703,
-0.3240981698036194,
-0.026080327108502388,
-0.7334004044532776,
0.6411269903182983,
-0.44688087701797485,
-0.13367325067520142,
0.0718349814414978,
0.5688507556915283,
0.29539546370506287,
0.10047291219234467,
-0.5049338936805725,
0.36586204171180725,
0.06893536448478699,
-0.09171481430530548,
0.044923875480890274,
0.33704283833503723,
0.12211743742227554,
0.7656735777854919,
0.5997300744056702,
0.4335537552833557,
0.13685911893844604,
-0.15379895269870758,
0.9028225541114807,
-0.8365452885627747,
-0.5474211573600769,
-0.5448786020278931,
0.6253829598426819,
-0.211283341050148,
-0.40388691425323486,
0.36774158477783203,
0.3665933609008789,
0.6204230785369873,
0.1406053602695465,
1.3071329593658447,
-0.44388213753700256,
0.47176393866539,
-0.4037008285522461,
0.467764675617218,
-0.34006255865097046,
-0.11386122554540634,
-0.09536442905664444,
-0.33826327323913574,
-0.027540093287825584,
0.6024416089057922,
0.19976724684238434,
-0.14540840685367584,
0.39800116419792175,
0.8983111381530762,
0.38597360253334045,
0.47518667578697205,
0.5329193472862244,
0.2957446575164795,
0.44218531250953674,
0.29638025164604187,
1.2035363912582397,
-0.2554253041744232,
0.07503267377614975,
-0.10358098894357681,
-0.3561430871486664,
0.2659773826599121,
-0.7587476968765259,
-0.1771857887506485,
-0.8278217315673828,
-0.32982897758483887,
-0.264737993478775,
0.14466749131679535,
0.9420996904373169,
0.8272134065628052,
-0.5153723359107971,
-0.42461779713630676,
-0.1297774612903595,
0.16994155943393707,
-0.5953956246376038,
-0.19953297078609467,
0.09701447933912277,
-0.3711259961128235,
-1.312690258026123,
0.7047043442726135,
0.5852996110916138,
0.07755153626203537,
-0.30398693680763245,
0.20362628996372223,
0.14842651784420013,
0.2974231541156769,
0.6940485835075378,
0.7672749161720276,
-0.7490149736404419,
-0.40616220235824585,
-0.04915204644203186,
0.19940723478794098,
0.11477451026439667,
0.8958042860031128,
-0.7591817378997803,
0.5343257784843445,
0.4008433520793915,
0.7596079707145691,
0.23396317660808563,
-0.14933975040912628,
0.7621368765830994,
-0.44100478291511536,
0.2931731045246124,
0.8425588607788086,
0.1753777712583542,
0.5006045699119568,
-0.1899879276752472,
0.37287700176239014,
-0.045303598046302795,
-0.7198078036308289,
-0.9178423285484314,
0.8195883631706238,
-0.966315507888794,
-0.21257494390010834,
0.8588683009147644,
0.2183002084493637,
-0.24986979365348816,
0.1086985245347023,
-0.447025865316391,
0.3052197992801666,
-0.36312076449394226,
0.5461861491203308,
0.5561093688011169,
-0.9718949198722839,
0.12511657178401947,
-0.41617345809936523,
0.6645267605781555,
0.578279435634613,
-1.231399416923523,
0.2614614963531494,
0.6094550490379333,
-0.15321318805217743,
0.3601488471031189,
0.633508026599884,
-0.31097355484962463,
-0.005577157251536846,
0.15752221643924713,
-0.11934501677751541,
0.13095492124557495,
-0.20232915878295898,
-0.21483056247234344,
0.20749591290950775,
0.043358154594898224,
-0.26224398612976074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19360v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19360v1
|
Large Language Model Informed Patent Image Retrieval
| 2024-04-30T08:45:16 | 2024-04-30T08:45:16 |
Hao-Cheng Lo, Jung-Mei Chu, Jieh Hsiang, Chun-Chieh Cho
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
In patent prosecution, image-based retrieval systems for identifying
similarities between current patent images and prior art are pivotal to ensure
the novelty and non-obviousness of patent applications. Despite their growing
popularity in recent years, existing attempts, while effective at recognizing
images within the same patent, fail to deliver practical value due to their
limited generalizability in retrieving relevant prior art. Moreover, this task
inherently involves the challenges posed by the abstract visual features of
patent images, the skewed distribution of image classifications, and the
semantic information of image descriptions. Therefore, we propose a
language-informed, distribution-aware multimodal approach to patent image
feature learning, which enriches the semantic understanding of patent image by
integrating Large Language Models and improves the performance of
underrepresented classes with our proposed distribution-aware contrastive
losses. Extensive experiments on DeepPatent2 dataset show that our proposed
method achieves state-of-the-art or comparable performance in image-based
patent retrieval with mAP +53.3%, Recall@10 +41.8%, and MRR@10 +51.9%.
Furthermore, through an in-depth user analysis, we explore our model in aiding
patent professionals in their image retrieval efforts, highlighting the model's
real-world applicability and effectiveness.
|
[
-0.04785293713212013,
-0.354481041431427,
0.5976688861846924,
0.2216532826423645,
-0.4894527494907379,
-0.07376956939697266,
-0.15595224499702454,
-0.7647560238838196,
0.20682187378406525,
0.7232441902160645,
0.031226174905896187,
-0.597581684589386,
-0.8510447144508362,
-0.41848114132881165,
-0.20850224792957306,
0.37155860662460327,
0.19582194089889526,
0.0987180694937706,
0.007596761453896761,
-0.26293423771858215,
-0.45279186964035034,
-0.39346885681152344,
-0.21816810965538025,
-0.38765186071395874,
0.5439730286598206,
0.2123202234506607,
0.5956717729568481,
0.4127555787563324,
0.6965644955635071,
0.34149491786956787,
-0.36937132477760315,
-0.12487780302762985,
-0.17902664840221405,
0.026808353140950203,
-0.325178861618042,
-0.6091368198394775,
-0.0949525237083435,
-0.05276858061552048,
0.33156323432922363,
0.5062748193740845,
-0.09394966810941696,
-0.06821731477975845,
-0.18178588151931763,
0.34892332553863525,
-0.8037664294242859,
0.3859921097755432,
-0.9483862519264221,
0.23219509422779083,
-0.14761090278625488,
-0.22782212495803833,
-0.6963935494422913,
0.1813630610704422,
0.36722517013549805,
-0.7391803860664368,
0.5137618780136108,
0.18641653656959534,
0.7815884947776794,
-0.0931144505739212,
-0.5264233350753784,
-0.303768515586853,
-0.3658933937549591,
0.736266016960144,
-0.4612361788749695,
0.38547641038894653,
0.1670108288526535,
0.37696462869644165,
-0.15343214571475983,
-1.0775374174118042,
-0.8065128326416016,
-0.28170591592788696,
-0.058919068425893784,
-0.05344870314002037,
-0.15122917294502258,
0.025159234181046486,
0.2432740032672882,
0.23757663369178772,
-0.6171218156814575,
0.2534542977809906,
-0.41373568773269653,
-0.3300454020500183,
0.3003164529800415,
-0.34454432129859924,
0.3128921091556549,
-0.24595694243907928,
-0.5680944323539734,
-0.4363941252231598,
-0.8950702548027039,
-0.13507463037967682,
0.1517592966556549,
0.2465977668762207,
0.12985679507255554,
0.6042826771736145,
-0.12301243096590042,
0.31165581941604614,
-0.21193364262580872,
-0.03284493833780289,
0.47878533601760864,
-0.08843446522951126,
-0.10142602771520615,
-0.004965116269886494,
0.7230903506278992,
0.2566940486431122,
-0.009378715418279171,
0.07695462554693222,
-0.47553449869155884,
-0.20849838852882385,
-0.21490028500556946,
-1.1113550662994385,
-0.415492445230484,
-0.027645302936434746,
-0.8127266764640808,
0.11812072992324829,
0.27227848768234253,
-0.7991445660591125,
-1.0510233640670776,
-0.12723848223686218,
0.7152963280677795,
-0.45093175768852234,
-0.4502143859863281,
0.25612831115722656,
-0.5333734154701233,
0.1545896977186203,
0.31545138359069824,
-0.8429027199745178,
-0.27381667494773865,
0.8839606046676636,
0.7449022531509399,
0.47198396921157837,
-0.13176797330379486,
-0.5119640827178955,
0.2134707272052765,
-0.31356650590896606,
0.9192739725112915,
-0.6784469485282898,
-0.48890987038612366,
-0.11930525302886963,
0.12955544888973236,
-0.08091872185468674,
-0.8891313076019287,
0.3446102738380432,
-0.9002280235290527,
-0.012258384376764297,
-0.14631283283233643,
-0.3122059106826782,
-0.20236283540725708,
0.0527629517018795,
-0.7955400347709656,
0.2896837294101715,
-0.45539283752441406,
-0.786496102809906,
0.85724937915802,
-0.6276841759681702,
-0.5688502192497253,
0.21944668889045715,
-0.3762839436531067,
-0.49888432025909424,
0.28600233793258667,
0.3733893036842346,
0.5409283638000488,
-0.1738341748714447,
0.3340620994567871,
-0.6213688254356384,
-0.10886985063552856,
0.0830274373292923,
-0.2010975331068039,
0.6536564230918884,
0.38569703698158264,
-0.21107743680477142,
0.07583323866128922,
-0.6436358690261841,
-0.20690950751304626,
0.3032635748386383,
0.006304593291133642,
-0.686130940914154,
-0.04249788448214531,
-0.04269072040915489,
0.3764672875404358,
0.401446133852005,
-0.8452574014663696,
0.036908503621816635,
-0.36525383591651917,
0.4251849353313446,
0.6756459474563599,
0.0027703610248863697,
0.4245430827140808,
0.17449137568473816,
0.36730054020881653,
0.21547949314117432,
0.36035481095314026,
-0.5170581340789795,
-0.692897379398346,
-0.4599228501319885,
-0.7297941446304321,
0.4393584132194519,
0.4221959114074707,
-0.7976563572883606,
0.29865404963493347,
-0.45074063539505005,
-0.3317507803440094,
-0.6900863647460938,
0.25786519050598145,
0.42498040199279785,
0.533159077167511,
0.2132008969783783,
-0.6192265748977661,
-0.203008234500885,
-1.1718679666519165,
0.03533055633306503,
-0.032117486000061035,
-0.08855345100164413,
0.7197517156600952,
0.6964018940925598,
-0.2630195617675781,
0.7276545763015747,
-0.7719255089759827,
-0.45991259813308716,
-0.21047762036323547,
0.5878097414970398,
0.5105957388877869,
0.38012146949768066,
0.4570463001728058,
-1.1996549367904663,
-0.44924765825271606,
0.4656202793121338,
-0.4935760498046875,
0.11691517382860184,
0.14800170063972473,
0.04553225636482239,
-0.03265708312392235,
0.37385445833206177,
-0.9197508096694946,
0.5144510865211487,
0.13527211546897888,
-0.22946946322917938,
0.24019290506839752,
-0.5956538915634155,
0.2870814800262451,
-1.1511859893798828,
0.3970589339733124,
0.24479785561561584,
0.09759664535522461,
-0.14120222628116608,
0.10835911333560944,
0.6107800602912903,
-0.48569485545158386,
-0.5327539443969727,
0.7515584230422974,
-0.5608211159706116,
-0.14020897448062897,
-0.1957981139421463,
-0.07736589759588242,
0.41690829396247864,
-0.014124440029263496,
0.1500502973794937,
0.8625102043151855,
0.7236497402191162,
-0.24758972227573395,
0.30184265971183777,
0.10688824206590652,
-0.7172060608863831,
0.6485196948051453,
-0.7327736616134644,
0.021361714228987694,
-0.4057236909866333,
0.2171579897403717,
-0.88407301902771,
-0.1912873089313507,
-0.057302940636873245,
-0.11182374507188797,
0.692118763923645,
-0.4086998999118805,
-0.8907265663146973,
-0.4032481610774994,
-0.2124052494764328,
0.12543107569217682,
0.35045337677001953,
-0.9246833920478821,
0.6638877987861633,
0.4333895742893219,
-0.42889323830604553,
-0.9097545146942139,
-0.594315767288208,
0.2589817941188812,
-0.18305766582489014,
-0.768003523349762,
0.5398764610290527,
0.17431439459323883,
-0.021694757044315338,
0.12184470146894455,
0.2430737018585205,
-0.4054485261440277,
-0.10180391371250153,
0.22053562104701996,
0.2151191085577011,
-0.1890251785516739,
0.4744061827659607,
-0.09966393560171127,
-0.0810973197221756,
-0.25313225388526917,
-0.19696249067783356,
0.33145615458488464,
0.34326133131980896,
-0.505304753780365,
-0.40433865785598755,
0.42586466670036316,
0.5923510193824768,
-0.44101712107658386,
0.4983106553554535,
0.5233216285705566,
-0.15895229578018188,
-0.35894501209259033,
-0.5659347176551819,
-0.08757620304822922,
-0.5434245467185974,
0.585761308670044,
-0.5682168006896973,
-0.7203003764152527,
0.6025215983390808,
-0.23574382066726685,
-0.374412477016449,
0.4486856460571289,
0.279177188873291,
0.02655620314180851,
0.9312160611152649,
0.9499930143356323,
-0.05176423862576485,
0.6019688844680786,
-0.45514246821403503,
0.6880912184715271,
-0.6483874917030334,
-0.570470929145813,
-0.46180835366249084,
-0.27518323063850403,
-0.1711094230413437,
-0.4483586549758911,
0.17137333750724792,
0.02086973935365677,
0.02881115861237049,
0.3368481695652008,
-0.553753137588501,
0.640855610370636,
0.8397036194801331,
0.3070095479488373,
0.19392766058444977,
0.20935040712356567,
-0.43485525250434875,
-0.03620145469903946,
-0.3610462248325348,
-0.19166819751262665,
1.0957378149032593,
0.42098432779312134,
1.105110764503479,
0.03703435882925987,
0.5250841975212097,
0.14602835476398468,
0.19705753028392792,
-0.7655805349349976,
0.5079472064971924,
-0.4793547987937927,
-0.635055661201477,
0.09856536239385605,
-0.23990978300571442,
-1.0071927309036255,
0.3218437731266022,
-0.17385055124759674,
-0.5850675702095032,
0.7715467214584351,
0.21933574974536896,
-0.21048492193222046,
0.03747069463133812,
-1.1761709451675415,
0.8685957193374634,
-0.4249362647533417,
-0.25623828172683716,
-0.681459367275238,
-0.6630499958992004,
0.25655415654182434,
-0.26101452112197876,
0.047268837690353394,
-0.010973935015499592,
0.14315766096115112,
0.39269810914993286,
-0.2665160596370697,
0.9096629619598389,
-0.40826067328453064,
0.04169159382581711,
-0.027361717075109482,
-0.138042613863945,
0.27124160528182983,
-0.23448477685451508,
-0.175169438123703,
-0.10040536522865295,
-0.17752623558044434,
-0.16157059371471405,
-0.7786809802055359,
0.801386833190918,
-0.3337615430355072,
-0.6148772239685059,
-0.11203580349683762,
-0.44179385900497437,
0.1741449236869812,
0.3582612872123718,
0.1938973218202591,
0.3261358141899109,
0.13361844420433044,
0.47753816843032837,
0.6975051164627075,
-0.6374971866607666,
0.2279490828514099,
0.5318431854248047,
0.015014320611953735,
-0.5104775428771973,
1.0053677558898926,
0.20085595548152924,
-0.1471072882413864,
0.5932812690734863,
0.22372618317604065,
-0.8498626947402954,
-0.6634103059768677,
-0.2080826461315155,
0.3763774335384369,
-1.2511411905288696,
-0.19111545383930206,
-0.6335392594337463,
0.08644179254770279,
-0.5911623239517212,
0.13591793179512024,
-0.21163281798362732,
-0.3630583584308624,
-0.29154476523399353,
0.1075243204832077,
0.30964142084121704,
0.6696409583091736,
0.20895572006702423,
0.1665201187133789,
-0.47303637862205505,
0.22669562697410583,
0.5261693000793457,
0.736047625541687,
0.005892719607800245,
-0.5071035027503967,
-0.02008673921227455,
-0.17918996512889862,
-0.39395660161972046,
-0.4339718520641327,
0.3451787233352661,
0.43998658657073975,
0.8210482597351074,
0.5933993458747864,
-0.06634248793125153,
0.5928981304168701,
-0.5963676571846008,
0.6377229690551758,
0.40406128764152527,
-0.6579669713973999,
0.7341999411582947,
0.1341407299041748,
-0.05563492700457573,
0.10296716541051865,
0.23842859268188477,
-0.10729093104600906,
0.028509212657809258,
-0.47112026810646057,
-1.1236425638198853,
0.2786572277545929,
-0.30966636538505554,
0.5359051823616028,
0.032126471400260925,
0.025916455313563347,
0.07535755634307861,
0.16974684596061707,
-0.769578218460083,
0.3792872130870819,
-0.22911633551120758,
-0.2839404046535492,
0.1340683251619339,
-0.3193419575691223,
-0.22230860590934753,
-0.14641767740249634,
0.4920055568218231,
-0.0861235111951828,
0.1622001975774765,
0.19151683151721954,
-0.37248921394348145,
0.3241516649723053,
0.4227884113788605,
0.6235653162002563,
0.5825454592704773,
-0.2304929494857788,
0.35489773750305176,
-0.46033844351768494,
-0.44581159949302673,
-0.09742226451635361,
0.5111790895462036,
0.20834322273731232,
0.02636309340596199,
0.24801374971866608,
0.8290080428123474,
-0.09396044909954071,
-0.8564345240592957,
0.9301448464393616,
0.04357867315411568,
-0.29725146293640137,
0.089044488966465,
-0.14083027839660645,
-0.05519050359725952,
0.6529314517974854,
0.690129816532135,
-0.03766413778066635,
0.4981946349143982,
-0.29620587825775146,
0.45477598905563354,
0.8030992150306702,
-0.18681590259075165,
-0.2153729498386383,
0.5106166005134583,
0.11217314004898071,
0.06872275471687317,
0.31823301315307617,
-0.08560235798358917,
-0.3868779242038727,
0.7894774079322815,
0.627067506313324,
0.812171220779419,
0.06979070603847504,
0.2226078361272812,
0.0006597934989258647,
0.3155383765697479,
-0.31892576813697815,
0.10061496496200562,
-0.027898501604795456,
-0.5987722873687744,
-0.30146950483322144,
-0.2722700536251068,
-0.2667958736419678,
0.08302441984415054,
0.07081519067287445,
0.36535051465034485,
-0.5151694416999817,
-0.39583179354667664,
0.298918217420578,
-0.3677769899368286,
-0.6361160278320312,
0.032888296991586685,
0.1538383811712265,
0.8520153164863586,
-0.8103132843971252,
0.8062402606010437,
0.5868536829948425,
-0.5602191090583801,
-0.6266432404518127,
-0.19042624533176422,
-0.28510984778404236,
-0.8008154034614563,
1.329496145248413,
0.3313711881637573,
-0.0623907595872879,
-0.24115286767482758,
-0.5691888928413391,
-0.6475709676742554,
1.2512356042861938,
0.48856866359710693,
-0.3969916105270386,
0.5043635964393616,
-0.057309675961732864,
0.5591890215873718,
-0.4506368637084961,
0.20864088833332062,
-0.1797405630350113,
0.11482544243335724,
0.6537142395973206,
-0.961171567440033,
-0.017101453617215157,
-0.4827202260494232,
0.35472503304481506,
0.08169388025999069,
-0.1856391280889511,
0.7884273529052734,
-0.4548053443431854,
-0.29676908254623413,
0.07820753753185272,
0.3151084780693054,
0.18197044730186462,
0.5207912921905518,
0.40408840775489807,
0.7326045632362366,
0.6064714193344116,
0.17670050263404846,
1.0812487602233887,
-0.29558631777763367,
0.3723006248474121,
0.9408147931098938,
-0.6187642216682434,
1.1439324617385864,
0.5108293890953064,
0.22740325331687927,
0.21380256116390228,
0.2991154193878174,
-0.3082515001296997,
0.8819511532783508,
0.04621965438127518,
-0.4462326467037201,
-0.1063101515173912,
-0.49780285358428955,
-0.3698692321777344,
0.16192157566547394,
0.3556355834007263,
-0.9872568845748901,
-0.1907154619693756,
0.17262676358222961,
-0.35576173663139343,
-0.07326250523328781,
0.03630053251981735,
0.6233709454536438,
0.1154308170080185,
-0.13573600351810455,
0.4617809057235718,
-0.16668877005577087,
0.7868282198905945,
-0.34870684146881104,
-0.17266537249088287,
-0.01748344860970974,
0.42303818464279175,
0.007354299537837505,
-1.036145567893982,
-0.14414827525615692,
-0.24601995944976807,
-0.21685579419136047,
-0.020531048998236656,
0.806896448135376,
-0.42409977316856384,
-0.3651103675365448,
0.45491087436676025,
0.07170294225215912,
-0.08536653965711594,
-0.1054229736328125,
-0.7347914576530457,
-0.11506596207618713,
-0.27696409821510315,
-0.13542817533016205,
0.2030671387910843,
0.6394265294075012,
-0.16494964063167572,
0.9365763664245605,
0.6187761425971985,
0.15256907045841217,
0.07464440912008286,
0.2926274836063385,
0.9253758788108826,
-0.23182696104049683,
-0.45409637689590454,
-0.4340561628341675,
0.577628493309021,
-0.5069642663002014,
-0.03045564889907837,
0.14247223734855652,
0.5320038199424744,
0.5786004662513733,
-0.45046940445899963,
0.6836751699447632,
0.08226896822452545,
0.31921568512916565,
-0.4667344093322754,
0.8776489496231079,
-0.5656952857971191,
0.35217729210853577,
-0.33803266286849976,
-0.6347724795341492,
-0.7833982706069946,
0.5893931984901428,
-0.4652276039123535,
-0.17297004163265228,
0.40344613790512085,
1.3609766960144043,
-0.5651516914367676,
-0.42727911472320557,
0.379661500453949,
0.05786177143454552,
0.6002054810523987,
0.13092473149299622,
0.682601809501648,
-0.3331565856933594,
0.5576750040054321,
-0.2952878773212433,
-0.22449974715709686,
-0.18156935274600983,
-0.9073846936225891,
-0.5997080206871033,
-0.5653823018074036,
-0.2428574413061142,
-0.009615805000066757,
-0.05496736243367195,
0.8214466571807861,
0.9897753000259399,
-0.7222119569778442,
0.14390212297439575,
0.17747780680656433,
-0.006356200203299522,
0.35853347182273865,
-0.20116165280342102,
0.4534080922603607,
-0.20756976306438446,
-0.4060179889202118,
0.11965779960155487,
0.5746942162513733,
0.1433538794517517,
0.04857708141207695,
0.05091262236237526,
-0.07764754444360733,
-0.24561689794063568,
0.849723219871521,
0.2756444811820984,
-0.8375148773193359,
-0.1528553068637848,
0.05545475333929062,
-0.20928166806697845,
0.08659779280424118,
0.8504313230514526,
-0.45638707280158997,
0.8837116956710815,
0.7233288288116455,
0.747918963432312,
0.34080058336257935,
-0.21452175080776215,
0.35433506965637207,
-0.7924770712852478,
0.7989516854286194,
0.2655841112136841,
0.7672309279441833,
0.41969117522239685,
-0.3755100667476654,
0.0535176545381546,
0.47051525115966797,
-0.3786398470401764,
-0.43704938888549805,
0.22654597461223602,
-0.9246806502342224,
-0.5876897573471069,
0.8096194863319397,
-0.3479600250720978,
-0.17087295651435852,
-0.04082050547003746,
-0.3491894006729126,
-0.20208410918712616,
-0.5609070062637329,
0.8961555361747742,
0.45838016271591187,
0.3084343373775482,
-0.6919988989830017,
-0.40888354182243347,
0.0036740312352776527,
0.23590277135372162,
-0.39424389600753784,
-0.048060014843940735,
0.6331579089164734,
0.2698451280593872,
0.4085681140422821,
0.5290375351905823,
-0.4509689211845398,
0.09455500543117523,
-0.14230598509311676,
0.5238038301467896,
0.1752183735370636,
-0.37106725573539734,
-0.24681557714939117,
0.3532074987888336,
0.5227439999580383,
-0.34206336736679077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19359v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19359v1
|
Evaluating Lexicon Incorporation for Depression Symptom Estimation
| 2024-04-30T08:41:06 | 2024-04-30T08:41:06 |
Kirill Milintsevich, Gaël Dias, Kairit Sirts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper explores the impact of incorporating sentiment, emotion, and
domain-specific lexicons into a transformer-based model for depression symptom
estimation. Lexicon information is added by marking the words in the input
transcripts of patient-therapist conversations as well as in social media
posts. Overall results show that the introduction of external knowledge within
pre-trained language models can be beneficial for prediction performance, while
different lexicons show distinct behaviours depending on the targeted task.
Additionally, new state-of-the-art results are obtained for the estimation of
depression level over patient-therapist interviews.
|
[
-0.49773064255714417,
-0.4176463186740875,
0.8633925318717957,
0.2833012640476227,
-0.19208712875843048,
-0.289078027009964,
-0.25048643350601196,
-0.5022801160812378,
0.6309669613838196,
0.09503208100795746,
-0.4328160583972931,
-0.5526454448699951,
-1.1090373992919922,
0.4033966064453125,
-0.3336814045906067,
0.9715200662612915,
0.04118695110082626,
0.35596564412117004,
-0.37024420499801636,
0.3945143222808838,
-0.5969146490097046,
-0.7191699743270874,
-0.56675785779953,
-0.125934436917305,
0.3280799984931946,
0.08216504752635956,
0.9037076234817505,
-0.2492072582244873,
0.5145894289016724,
0.3336697518825531,
-0.568466067314148,
-0.1433395892381668,
-0.26301202178001404,
-0.05719193443655968,
-0.3996225595474243,
-0.6906029582023621,
-0.44570329785346985,
0.08470294624567032,
0.23611950874328613,
0.7278558015823364,
-0.0939682200551033,
-0.11340125650167465,
0.36902618408203125,
0.10848449915647507,
-0.8757550716400146,
0.1308666616678238,
-0.14271214604377747,
0.29316210746765137,
0.296489417552948,
0.14230011403560638,
-0.09637901186943054,
-0.39524751901626587,
0.36504697799682617,
-0.1054416298866272,
0.17940901219844818,
-0.7008190751075745,
0.8103286027908325,
0.3166366219520569,
-0.32828283309936523,
-0.7238690853118896,
-0.7521657347679138,
0.6041086316108704,
-0.772523045539856,
0.3655027747154236,
0.4645741581916809,
0.14426930248737335,
0.1293608546257019,
-0.812587559223175,
-0.3039337694644928,
-0.032715555280447006,
-0.5907147526741028,
0.44171392917633057,
-0.36228784918785095,
0.1334848254919052,
0.11439953744411469,
0.6729412078857422,
-0.04723040387034416,
-0.20052175223827362,
-0.2219184935092926,
0.012626753188669682,
0.45286476612091064,
0.2580209970474243,
0.5010517835617065,
-0.7389895915985107,
0.04866659268736839,
0.2503988444805145,
0.05529732629656792,
0.05446534976363182,
-0.03522857651114464,
0.24847306311130524,
-0.29597464203834534,
0.623831033706665,
0.07347972691059113,
0.37354883551597595,
0.0800950676202774,
-0.21511892974376678,
0.13171498477458954,
-0.3215360641479492,
-0.1286374181509018,
0.030952097848057747,
0.7605152130126953,
0.4742906391620636,
0.016533315181732178,
-0.15136325359344482,
-0.22489431500434875,
0.5390122532844543,
0.6428700089454651,
-0.6695367693901062,
-0.603232204914093,
0.27268126606941223,
-0.3686574101448059,
-0.1540454477071762,
0.007549647241830826,
-1.3162784576416016,
-0.8242231011390686,
-0.3035549819469452,
0.38818126916885376,
-0.47896483540534973,
-0.5586180090904236,
0.022982681170105934,
-0.4743562936782837,
-0.16267473995685577,
0.22906096279621124,
-0.515510618686676,
0.41759610176086426,
0.7369205355644226,
0.9967233538627625,
-0.005780922714620829,
0.22590403258800507,
-0.3127765357494354,
-0.2389950305223465,
-0.2868095636367798,
1.0006704330444336,
-0.4759998023509979,
-0.7803656458854675,
0.3278913199901581,
0.2155972123146057,
-0.21901986002922058,
-0.4305554926395416,
0.6277333498001099,
0.059202734380960464,
0.4704294204711914,
0.039784397929906845,
-0.8344882130622864,
0.13081826269626617,
0.04171158745884895,
-0.7437661290168762,
0.8892769813537598,
0.6204703450202942,
-1.0622142553329468,
0.05168921500444412,
-0.4386642575263977,
-0.37126535177230835,
0.043983444571495056,
0.0881095752120018,
-0.040722981095314026,
0.7019676566123962,
0.15629124641418457,
0.5973055362701416,
-0.17511671781539917,
0.056743886321783066,
-0.10897218436002731,
-0.017512980848550797,
0.6107511520385742,
0.17413346469402313,
0.4663216173648834,
0.12168829888105392,
0.006004034541547298,
-0.24789291620254517,
-0.47458505630493164,
-0.3959498107433319,
-0.15283143520355225,
-0.056883804500103,
-0.760390043258667,
0.07695192098617554,
-0.13773655891418457,
0.23027600347995758,
0.26055967807769775,
-0.4464600384235382,
-0.22688116133213043,
-0.6631901860237122,
0.10600113123655319,
0.40833333134651184,
0.34019437432289124,
0.2891850173473358,
0.09034940600395203,
0.9267882108688354,
0.22846946120262146,
0.3978636562824249,
0.1118372306227684,
-0.6135006546974182,
-0.42289188504219055,
-0.3872973322868347,
0.2617446780204773,
0.3767361640930176,
-0.40360376238822937,
0.5292510986328125,
-0.18086616694927216,
-0.6922123432159424,
-0.42626717686653137,
-0.020841654390096664,
0.17250476777553558,
0.22439391911029816,
0.4055768847465515,
-0.36794573068618774,
-0.6074517369270325,
-0.43716806173324585,
-0.3674696385860443,
0.02998645231127739,
-0.05613630264997482,
0.24239787459373474,
0.26099902391433716,
-0.5334508419036865,
0.7584180235862732,
-0.9306633472442627,
-0.19309045374393463,
-0.6468894481658936,
0.09803751111030579,
0.34683650732040405,
0.17413051426410675,
0.4688754975795746,
-0.36277738213539124,
-0.535783588886261,
-0.16101080179214478,
-0.42776328325271606,
-0.03155951574444771,
0.027187999337911606,
-0.2285638451576233,
-0.020933015272021294,
0.23768141865730286,
-0.7023346424102783,
0.7587331533432007,
0.8163004517555237,
-0.6848966479301453,
0.5687834024429321,
0.04313237965106964,
0.06422185152769089,
-1.4832686185836792,
-0.3355824053287506,
0.46577882766723633,
-0.10088618099689484,
-0.622096836566925,
-0.45309197902679443,
0.020219802856445312,
-0.18558019399642944,
-0.3313608765602112,
0.2988647222518921,
-0.1887209266424179,
0.13715171813964844,
-0.3156341314315796,
0.3445568382740021,
0.13864335417747498,
0.008015953935682774,
0.0656379982829094,
0.4408488869667053,
0.7977177500724792,
-0.5790123343467712,
0.32209616899490356,
0.4133502244949341,
-0.5400025248527527,
0.6011422276496887,
-0.3672734200954437,
-0.2428397834300995,
-0.3201158046722412,
-0.007383025251328945,
-0.9843720197677612,
-0.12910129129886627,
0.2453993260860443,
-0.42023372650146484,
0.19272546470165253,
0.06847573071718216,
-0.1091359555721283,
-0.4419270157814026,
0.024788664653897285,
0.1936543732881546,
0.4863641560077667,
-0.19123780727386475,
0.6398473381996155,
0.4160463511943817,
-0.2154189944267273,
-0.02959221415221691,
-0.689956784248352,
0.217610165476799,
-0.4536678194999695,
-0.14094802737236023,
0.5856462121009827,
0.10506660491228104,
-0.39676716923713684,
0.11182399839162827,
-0.023961206898093224,
-0.15762172639369965,
-0.026213234290480614,
0.4000849425792694,
0.13017314672470093,
0.043196652084589005,
0.44485563039779663,
0.06990710645914078,
-0.07528193295001984,
0.44112923741340637,
0.4160764813423157,
0.643120288848877,
0.09859330952167511,
0.11596671491861343,
-0.7337347269058228,
0.43074291944503784,
0.3384430706501007,
0.1663365513086319,
0.9945039749145508,
0.28444528579711914,
-0.45454418659210205,
-0.20267613232135773,
-0.3068118095397949,
-0.31370729207992554,
-0.3754611909389496,
0.18519748747348785,
-0.3679031431674957,
-0.43812528252601624,
0.3684413433074951,
-0.5192334055900574,
-0.6451662182807922,
0.36456233263015747,
0.3514738082885742,
-0.0180608369410038,
1.281150221824646,
0.709193229675293,
0.08089148998260498,
0.7003777623176575,
-0.3032741844654083,
0.5152391791343689,
-0.7913265228271484,
0.05247800052165985,
-0.5255486965179443,
-0.20113687217235565,
-0.6236022710800171,
-0.3163731098175049,
0.28779253363609314,
0.28965213894844055,
0.15970556437969208,
0.5665332078933716,
-0.44272276759147644,
-0.22951528429985046,
0.09370994567871094,
0.44609227776527405,
0.12182915955781937,
-0.4305134117603302,
-0.010515928268432617,
-0.3556801378726959,
-0.5918421745300293,
-0.18984928727149963,
0.898348331451416,
0.48145943880081177,
0.6781688332557678,
0.05609211325645447,
0.7475062012672424,
0.2667953372001648,
0.6213241219520569,
-1.2239315509796143,
0.320536345243454,
-0.22757460176944733,
-0.14375963807106018,
0.05184430629014969,
-0.25041553378105164,
-0.747391939163208,
-0.10348744690418243,
-0.10902004688978195,
-0.7910191416740417,
0.4760323464870453,
-0.20667366683483124,
-0.5676249265670776,
-0.1473148614168167,
-0.8189144134521484,
0.9474368095397949,
-0.1466190069913864,
0.5318986177444458,
-0.4994082748889923,
-0.21997302770614624,
0.2730100750923157,
-0.1506538987159729,
0.44451257586479187,
-0.19584760069847107,
-0.04303254932165146,
0.7455069422721863,
-0.653914213180542,
0.8728609681129456,
-0.17525342106819153,
-0.35153499245643616,
0.2312769889831543,
0.04679363593459129,
0.3015969395637512,
0.19311600923538208,
-0.07398423552513123,
0.22203029692173004,
0.48149779438972473,
0.008625270798802376,
-0.9299699068069458,
0.4922384023666382,
-0.8878504037857056,
-0.6737598776817322,
-0.3150672912597656,
-0.3512006998062134,
-0.5523582100868225,
-0.26448237895965576,
0.16924887895584106,
0.44137927889823914,
-0.3527901768684387,
-0.12627722322940826,
0.19873444736003876,
-0.522191047668457,
0.13180014491081238,
0.2942253351211548,
-0.2720746397972107,
-0.7761382460594177,
0.46593087911605835,
0.068839892745018,
0.2682676315307617,
0.1425722986459732,
0.6294664740562439,
0.009272348135709763,
0.13748277723789215,
0.31507906317710876,
0.5888928771018982,
-0.9149677753448486,
-0.3131881356239319,
-0.6823286414146423,
-0.2713918685913086,
-0.6971650719642639,
-0.06753972917795181,
-0.46447357535362244,
-0.36732953786849976,
-0.5638984441757202,
-0.32377442717552185,
0.49727654457092285,
0.754071056842804,
-0.24833635985851288,
0.5758159756660461,
-0.970282256603241,
0.23852278292179108,
0.03854188695549965,
0.4762513041496277,
-0.0999041497707367,
-0.6442388892173767,
-0.5791372656822205,
0.037502508610486984,
-0.16285842657089233,
-1.3223263025283813,
0.7403991222381592,
0.14925377070903778,
0.36313939094543457,
0.5642223358154297,
0.1010897234082222,
0.6673539280891418,
-0.24046891927719116,
0.994866669178009,
0.6246250867843628,
-1.3080592155456543,
0.9414785504341125,
0.3082296848297119,
0.2768559157848358,
0.34729886054992676,
0.9666008949279785,
-0.9060984253883362,
-0.5466285347938538,
-0.6994745135307312,
-0.5067458748817444,
0.6278006434440613,
-0.12820696830749512,
0.3889862895011902,
-0.47888657450675964,
0.40557581186294556,
0.009908086620271206,
-0.2487305849790573,
-0.43620219826698303,
-0.18945232033729553,
-0.4096624553203583,
-0.4250068664550781,
-0.3155837059020996,
-0.6451238393783569,
-0.11595549434423447,
-0.5353149175643921,
0.47264742851257324,
0.1467723697423935,
0.6842072606086731,
0.3437172472476959,
-0.11824192106723785,
-0.00405914569273591,
0.050246722996234894,
0.10077071189880371,
0.5750781297683716,
-0.10446462035179138,
0.2975183129310608,
0.228276789188385,
-0.3445720076560974,
-0.2842507064342499,
0.053691159933805466,
0.28819888830184937,
0.7116020917892456,
0.20754684507846832,
0.7885175943374634,
0.40574267506599426,
-0.595285952091217,
0.7211388945579529,
-0.1386738419532776,
-0.13773249089717865,
-0.47247427701950073,
-0.015655560418963432,
0.17447422444820404,
0.3893827497959137,
-0.17536261677742004,
-0.14329198002815247,
0.30010101199150085,
-0.530447781085968,
0.017275596037507057,
0.35129156708717346,
-0.9223155975341797,
-0.6897507905960083,
0.22253917157649994,
0.05172916501760483,
-0.3860674798488617,
0.33135104179382324,
0.26515910029411316,
-0.6297257542610168,
0.3602817952632904,
0.49356749653816223,
0.9395118355751038,
-0.6881877779960632,
0.4436982572078705,
0.5371652245521545,
-0.13202577829360962,
-0.2253352254629135,
0.4195452928543091,
0.1217992976307869,
-0.9308304190635681,
-0.26005819439888,
-0.7849730253219604,
-0.2184847593307495,
-0.12506046891212463,
-0.7512679696083069,
0.5737136006355286,
-0.2010391503572464,
-0.7946637868881226,
-0.034794580191373825,
-0.29151931405067444,
-0.8406020402908325,
0.4535617530345917,
0.5179677605628967,
0.8708168864250183,
-0.9032096266746521,
0.49788495898246765,
0.9250553250312805,
-0.592693567276001,
-0.6880373358726501,
0.1792236715555191,
-0.1214047446846962,
-0.43915674090385437,
0.4863855838775635,
0.319728285074234,
0.25719818472862244,
-0.08138119429349899,
-0.07791805267333984,
-1.2850104570388794,
0.8664966225624084,
0.1733860820531845,
0.004995947238057852,
-0.1797855943441391,
0.41813933849334717,
0.7625830173492432,
-0.23974788188934326,
0.47943341732025146,
0.5746627449989319,
0.29102063179016113,
-0.18516406416893005,
-0.9184814095497131,
0.07892241328954697,
-0.2645457983016968,
0.3104792535305023,
0.22006645798683167,
-0.09021929651498795,
0.6729971170425415,
0.27886539697647095,
-0.7271683216094971,
-0.18272919952869415,
0.5269568562507629,
-0.49265700578689575,
-0.270205020904541,
0.6713051199913025,
0.6576681733131409,
0.6249899864196777,
0.13503433763980865,
1.3338959217071533,
-0.8975613117218018,
0.45511019229888916,
0.7905268669128418,
0.1144871637225151,
0.6506684422492981,
0.4010912775993347,
-0.373407781124115,
1.025307536125183,
0.49184828996658325,
0.18893080949783325,
0.6469150185585022,
0.050276998430490494,
-0.5829834342002869,
-0.08224734663963318,
-0.515299379825592,
-0.2375747412443161,
0.3354465067386627,
0.8374694585800171,
-0.8219329714775085,
-0.2414073646068573,
0.2280280739068985,
0.11320746690034866,
-0.09429359436035156,
-0.40054938197135925,
1.105567216873169,
0.5343924760818481,
-0.6429821848869324,
0.49941104650497437,
-0.05701470002532005,
0.5079762935638428,
-0.2216564565896988,
0.27185970544815063,
-0.29570379853248596,
0.3171243965625763,
-0.36942774057388306,
-0.7205250263214111,
0.8084576725959778,
0.17084893584251404,
0.0008808614802546799,
-0.0027300564106553793,
0.6797821521759033,
-0.2509322166442871,
-0.6757397055625916,
0.5913986563682556,
0.786483108997345,
0.2507341206073761,
-0.3926355540752411,
-0.35436543822288513,
-0.2598915100097656,
-0.35293886065483093,
-0.3319653868675232,
0.4012329578399658,
0.7573791146278381,
0.339814156293869,
0.2752819061279297,
0.035041362047195435,
0.27698108553886414,
-0.26268908381462097,
0.34708622097969055,
0.8797881603240967,
-0.7366671562194824,
-0.47847241163253784,
-0.7529109716415405,
0.6759732365608215,
-0.07748062908649445,
-0.407087504863739,
0.704280436038971,
0.04250099137425423,
0.47700485587120056,
-0.21758529543876648,
0.8588589429855347,
-0.2037142515182495,
0.5958525538444519,
0.001728799077682197,
0.34155380725860596,
-0.5252002477645874,
-0.23378020524978638,
-0.5923841595649719,
-0.6743585467338562,
-0.1873490959405899,
0.48861467838287354,
-0.6482569575309753,
-0.3223498463630676,
0.9590225219726562,
0.6100893020629883,
0.19252905249595642,
0.24749918282032013,
0.2591438889503479,
0.10037875175476074,
0.12285804748535156,
0.37197059392929077,
0.9658083319664001,
-0.36240309476852417,
0.304054856300354,
-0.8122999668121338,
-0.2801254093647003,
-0.035357143729925156,
-0.5904052257537842,
-0.7231602668762207,
-0.4670458734035492,
-0.5583798885345459,
-0.5394733548164368,
-0.24285487830638885,
0.8453196287155151,
0.06329438835382462,
-0.9318539500236511,
-0.3032401502132416,
-0.03557460755109787,
0.13801828026771545,
-0.42080554366111755,
-0.323439359664917,
0.24952860176563263,
-0.642098605632782,
-0.7889050245285034,
0.005822258535772562,
-0.13999690115451813,
-0.09026871621608734,
-0.16441461443901062,
0.21037404239177704,
-0.098872110247612,
0.13701093196868896,
0.764178454875946,
-0.4298868179321289,
-0.4942227900028229,
-0.2014908343553543,
-0.29595500230789185,
-0.13835342228412628,
0.129615917801857,
0.7920888662338257,
-0.8052712082862854,
0.348958820104599,
0.4290926456451416,
0.4326687455177307,
0.13011150062084198,
0.26064005494117737,
0.8609947562217712,
-0.4038659334182739,
-0.10634342581033707,
0.2060575634241104,
0.6102067828178406,
0.398675799369812,
-0.661219596862793,
0.4192948341369629,
0.35605812072753906,
-0.18932095170021057,
-0.6025270819664001,
0.08335351943969727,
-0.5020047426223755,
-0.67530757188797,
1.184441089630127,
-0.23143213987350464,
-0.13264380395412445,
-0.008723330684006214,
-0.12431154400110245,
0.5288650989532471,
-0.24318204820156097,
1.029361605644226,
0.6685055494308472,
-0.46552979946136475,
-0.3228629529476166,
-0.34108129143714905,
0.8002195358276367,
0.24176406860351562,
-0.6687333583831787,
-0.11483383923768997,
0.48227348923683167,
0.05202483758330345,
0.3415314257144928,
0.18952172994613647,
-0.10370977967977524,
-0.0691320076584816,
0.032819122076034546,
0.4441849887371063,
0.6799562573432922,
0.15082088112831116,
-0.43344852328300476,
0.20587405562400818,
-0.19126814603805542,
0.18596415221691132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19335v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19335v1
|
StablePT: Towards Stable Prompting for Few-shot Learning via Input Separation
| 2024-04-30T08:01:49 | 2024-04-30T08:01:49 |
Xiaoming Liu, Chen Liu, Zhaohan Zhang, Chengzhengxu Li, Longtian Wang, Yu Lan, Chao Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models have shown their ability to become effective few-shot
learners with prompting, revoluting the paradigm of learning with data
scarcity. However, this approach largely depends on the quality of prompt
initialization, and always exhibits large variability among different runs.
Such property makes prompt tuning highly unreliable and vulnerable to poorly
constructed prompts, which limits its extension to more real-world
applications. To tackle this issue, we propose to treat the hard prompt and
soft prompt as separate inputs to mitigate noise brought by the prompt
initialization. Furthermore, we optimize soft prompts with contrastive learning
for utilizing class-aware information in the training process to maintain model
performance. Experimental results demonstrate that \sysname outperforms
state-of-the-art methods by 7.20% in accuracy and reduces the standard
deviation by 2.02 on average. Furthermore, extensive experiments underscore its
robustness and stability across 7 datasets covering various tasks.
|
[
-0.2534152865409851,
-0.9743126034736633,
0.35911867022514343,
-0.14873014390468597,
-0.3668193817138672,
-0.14069458842277527,
-0.5637576580047607,
-0.06525221467018127,
-0.5136235356330872,
-0.13918259739875793,
-0.6775081157684326,
-0.22830109298229218,
-0.5171263813972473,
0.26797592639923096,
0.11809620261192322,
1.008788824081421,
0.21829505264759064,
0.30238473415374756,
0.05783858522772789,
-0.16988880932331085,
-0.6565450429916382,
-0.05000244453549385,
-1.0401161909103394,
-0.1802835464477539,
0.8262179493904114,
0.6732863783836365,
0.6460191607475281,
0.6390291452407837,
0.22618798911571503,
0.3247763216495514,
-0.23597919940948486,
0.1312817633152008,
-0.5815590023994446,
0.9244038462638855,
-0.1356864869594574,
-0.4025161564350128,
0.04918709024786949,
-0.02307100221514702,
0.9398946166038513,
0.8131139874458313,
-0.031927019357681274,
-0.12143970280885696,
0.5911135673522949,
0.38270804286003113,
-0.9542450308799744,
0.1955602765083313,
-0.574792742729187,
-0.07306578755378723,
-0.26400700211524963,
0.36071011424064636,
-0.6634253263473511,
-0.2975415289402008,
0.11538252234458923,
-0.559847891330719,
0.14629408717155457,
-0.43518805503845215,
0.8821456432342529,
0.22948311269283295,
-0.028832774609327316,
0.21046653389930725,
-0.6194794178009033,
0.9033199548721313,
-0.43293043971061707,
0.44405195116996765,
0.47828438878059387,
0.38012373447418213,
-0.33841004967689514,
-0.4919581413269043,
-0.30316126346588135,
-0.10671388357877731,
0.18621037900447845,
0.0559869259595871,
-0.08265070617198944,
0.24398541450500488,
0.3106045424938202,
-0.147988960146904,
-0.37310075759887695,
0.47142118215560913,
-0.4007473587989807,
-0.3606477975845337,
0.11441163718700409,
0.22219529747962952,
0.12648969888687134,
0.01506992056965828,
-0.28093987703323364,
-0.09699869155883789,
-0.7368698716163635,
0.4163006842136383,
0.3772256076335907,
1.1256957054138184,
-0.3216647803783417,
0.3383823037147522,
-0.16883018612861633,
0.9439335465431213,
0.37136176228523254,
-0.47890013456344604,
0.11865725368261337,
-0.1316932737827301,
-0.05356379598379135,
-0.10224275290966034,
0.7486801743507385,
0.06893718987703323,
0.12094131857156754,
0.037196673452854156,
-0.2716522812843323,
0.2873240113258362,
-0.08308134227991104,
-0.9331350922584534,
-0.23019231855869293,
0.3736126720905304,
-0.29532894492149353,
-0.32743364572525024,
-0.11182698607444763,
-0.9542896151542664,
-0.5315173268318176,
-0.22226691246032715,
0.4502793848514557,
-0.5687645077705383,
-0.20845311880111694,
-0.27137812972068787,
-0.017993256449699402,
0.1057695597410202,
0.5734723210334778,
-1.136929988861084,
0.3154028654098511,
0.5690000057220459,
0.859695315361023,
-0.4083915948867798,
-0.328605979681015,
-1.1515203714370728,
-0.2949310541152954,
-0.2925580143928528,
0.7876511216163635,
-0.6433081030845642,
-0.3092953562736511,
0.0645880252122879,
-0.07016207277774811,
-0.05991652235388756,
-0.4245758652687073,
0.2891490161418915,
-0.21648728847503662,
0.4805871248245239,
-0.27754485607147217,
-0.40704599022865295,
0.28909099102020264,
0.3064000606536865,
-0.5988759994506836,
0.862267792224884,
0.21753330528736115,
-0.6416633129119873,
0.6127198338508606,
-0.24097636342048645,
-0.44053134322166443,
0.2666398584842682,
-0.3454720377922058,
-0.6031729578971863,
0.04032839462161064,
0.17886506021022797,
0.33966517448425293,
0.18950238823890686,
0.16116991639137268,
-0.5596989989280701,
-0.41565659642219543,
0.07405044138431549,
-0.5158732533454895,
0.7195550799369812,
0.2588595747947693,
-0.2797017991542816,
0.1935679167509079,
-0.7852861881256104,
-0.08611050248146057,
0.01958821713924408,
-0.35110849142074585,
-0.19195368885993958,
-0.11507666110992432,
-0.15514221787452698,
0.2153165340423584,
-0.05871010571718216,
-0.42057088017463684,
0.4470227062702179,
-0.5512046813964844,
0.2773216664791107,
0.9681514501571655,
-0.0962667241692543,
0.6666443943977356,
-0.37602499127388,
0.8000248670578003,
0.31724804639816284,
0.1429024338722229,
-0.6067200303077698,
-0.388756662607193,
-0.5747074484825134,
-0.5041636228561401,
0.5411129593849182,
0.5676167011260986,
-0.8644199371337891,
0.1716860979795456,
0.22122736275196075,
-0.311344712972641,
-0.3827941417694092,
0.34999316930770874,
0.32912677526474,
0.946672260761261,
0.2811931371688843,
-0.048498112708330154,
-0.48799246549606323,
-0.5112508535385132,
-0.09270384907722473,
-0.26507923007011414,
-0.051665451377630234,
0.032255906611680984,
0.0215184073895216,
0.08757780492305756,
0.8513872027397156,
-0.16818922758102417,
-0.09223027527332306,
-0.7145876288414001,
0.017154214903712273,
0.40520134568214417,
0.7357794642448425,
0.3095064163208008,
-0.3350914418697357,
-0.3973484933376312,
-0.5308074355125427,
-0.44162052869796753,
-0.18109941482543945,
-0.17452390491962433,
-0.08658786118030548,
0.1709994524717331,
0.28670114278793335,
-0.8154921531677246,
0.16869954764842987,
0.24471960961818695,
-0.21750912070274353,
0.4987138509750366,
0.2361169010400772,
-0.15959970653057098,
-1.0933250188827515,
-0.08943116664886475,
0.14935749769210815,
-0.26098281145095825,
-0.4676169157028198,
-0.1012706384062767,
-0.07502119988203049,
-0.25089287757873535,
-0.9137635231018066,
0.699060320854187,
-0.4179849922657013,
0.37645789980888367,
-0.22511954605579376,
0.2581983804702759,
0.029442129656672478,
0.2528819441795349,
0.12929388880729675,
0.6945138573646545,
0.9381195306777954,
-0.6843703389167786,
0.03271617740392685,
0.2204386442899704,
-0.019995735958218575,
0.6300361156463623,
-0.7874262928962708,
0.05835247412323952,
-0.19021111726760864,
0.2557184398174286,
-1.1928530931472778,
-0.2982098460197449,
0.49229323863983154,
-0.3618868887424469,
0.6197128891944885,
-0.5385250449180603,
-0.3402516543865204,
0.09400667250156403,
-0.3404722809791565,
0.4593375623226166,
0.6235290765762329,
-0.5188033580780029,
0.194425567984581,
0.18384791910648346,
-0.4536122977733612,
-0.640374481678009,
-0.4338751435279846,
-0.3768196403980255,
-0.18865379691123962,
-0.35473936796188354,
-0.13080744445323944,
-0.0503731369972229,
-0.28126293420791626,
-0.3091385066509247,
-0.20915479958057404,
-0.2419544756412506,
0.17557302117347717,
0.38462382555007935,
0.5074920058250427,
-0.4609415829181671,
0.40523022413253784,
0.31092432141304016,
-0.3638307452201843,
-0.34554511308670044,
-0.2696148455142975,
0.4754386246204376,
-0.12081950157880783,
0.02174023725092411,
-0.738915205001831,
0.2167680412530899,
0.4632822871208191,
0.17756353318691254,
0.8023338913917542,
0.4647276699542999,
-0.43480128049850464,
-0.3404426872730255,
-0.15999935567378998,
-0.6408312320709229,
-0.5442478656768799,
0.03913673385977745,
-0.4689633846282959,
-0.9175811409950256,
0.49029335379600525,
-0.11592302471399307,
0.27007198333740234,
0.2824912667274475,
0.4569564461708069,
-0.28466030955314636,
1.0567706823349,
0.5069916248321533,
0.06270549446344376,
0.7608054876327515,
0.16372992098331451,
-0.20846334099769592,
-0.2569178640842438,
-0.07101134210824966,
-0.6567457318305969,
-0.4793098270893097,
-0.41206833720207214,
0.16094473004341125,
0.18489539623260498,
0.19976237416267395,
-0.34069129824638367,
0.054119836539030075,
-0.5098931193351746,
0.7552774548530579,
0.540466845035553,
0.30153384804725647,
0.006898509804159403,
-0.011295651085674763,
-0.3107978403568268,
-0.33471864461898804,
-0.9244374632835388,
-0.33579105138778687,
0.7060180306434631,
0.30261918902397156,
1.010022759437561,
-0.08741544932126999,
0.7942947745323181,
-0.010607435368001461,
-0.19848285615444183,
-0.9142690300941467,
0.4496143162250519,
-0.034787073731422424,
-0.5446100234985352,
-0.44031020998954773,
-0.41105005145072937,
-1.389638066291809,
0.2944641411304474,
-0.49050140380859375,
-0.734311580657959,
0.3178994059562683,
0.3640597462654114,
-0.863235592842102,
0.08455351740121841,
-0.7466482520103455,
0.8232839107513428,
0.04951382055878639,
-0.9904161095619202,
0.25941014289855957,
-0.9581303000450134,
0.33588454127311707,
0.3266325891017914,
-0.015080591663718224,
-0.1374741941690445,
-0.12102395296096802,
0.7165924906730652,
-0.6127694845199585,
1.095125675201416,
-0.3186505138874054,
0.13667528331279755,
0.2938385009765625,
0.29048123955726624,
0.5527350306510925,
0.2005160003900528,
-0.1063428595662117,
-0.08432023227214813,
-0.006205834448337555,
-0.5404226183891296,
-0.4884611666202545,
0.4438251256942749,
-0.7549780011177063,
-0.2623697817325592,
-0.4916393756866455,
-0.2630094587802887,
-0.30541884899139404,
0.42452293634414673,
0.6069042086601257,
0.6123334169387817,
0.1880211979150772,
0.04712099954485893,
0.8199339509010315,
0.053293805569410324,
0.58184415102005,
0.31530043482780457,
0.00039880338590592146,
-0.5076115131378174,
0.6983947157859802,
0.05984271690249443,
0.2779907286167145,
-0.04216727986931801,
0.5012792348861694,
-0.2897965610027313,
-0.4955122470855713,
-0.5835939645767212,
0.08449337631464005,
-0.6812580823898315,
-0.5119501352310181,
-0.2694490849971771,
0.009792594239115715,
-0.32746773958206177,
-0.24435104429721832,
-0.5611625909805298,
-0.5614824891090393,
-0.6187642216682434,
-0.0754978135228157,
0.21826525032520294,
0.4858497083187103,
-0.03774920105934143,
0.657347559928894,
-0.9266588687896729,
0.39181286096572876,
0.3133615553379059,
0.47213268280029297,
-0.51942378282547,
-0.5153207182884216,
0.03315746784210205,
-0.14078731834888458,
-0.1562223583459854,
-0.9532796144485474,
0.03008916974067688,
0.4569236934185028,
0.5295084118843079,
0.7723212242126465,
0.3721460998058319,
0.5238627791404724,
-0.44083696603775024,
0.9786199331283569,
0.402820348739624,
-0.9291132092475891,
0.8753581643104553,
-0.4577368199825287,
0.7846238613128662,
1.3511366844177246,
0.24650254845619202,
-0.2180950790643692,
-0.45651835203170776,
-0.6229044795036316,
-0.7525160312652588,
0.9504687190055847,
-0.14951325953006744,
0.12415590137243271,
-0.04095416143536568,
0.3213807940483093,
0.6691247820854187,
0.08903617411851883,
-0.6985073685646057,
-0.10233261436223984,
-0.04085569828748703,
-0.3908262252807617,
0.3284420669078827,
-0.2337474673986435,
-0.053664106875658035,
-0.18965697288513184,
0.5406440496444702,
-0.18335963785648346,
-0.1866082400083542,
-0.29955923557281494,
-0.04940557852387428,
-0.3155573308467865,
0.4293237626552582,
0.53391432762146,
0.5980728268623352,
0.1256808489561081,
0.47744718194007874,
0.05791543796658516,
-0.5925473570823669,
0.377113401889801,
-0.0035791329573839903,
-0.45359909534454346,
0.14075681567192078,
0.30190935730934143,
0.6842928528785706,
0.29388946294784546,
-0.4608035385608673,
0.6256704926490784,
-0.17844945192337036,
-0.13324692845344543,
0.22029739618301392,
0.3770599365234375,
-0.5411921143531799,
0.21280892193317413,
0.09555897861719131,
0.32320642471313477,
-0.16451433300971985,
-0.16533321142196655,
0.3236728012561798,
0.23354780673980713,
-0.5053490400314331,
-0.44098034501075745,
0.5181490778923035,
0.5332256555557251,
-0.26680538058280945,
0.8523863554000854,
-0.2595829665660858,
-0.29018184542655945,
0.19067299365997314,
0.5409692525863647,
0.9610335826873779,
-0.45689940452575684,
0.2609255313873291,
0.5626047253608704,
0.19719108939170837,
-0.39945995807647705,
0.29896125197410583,
-0.3366595506668091,
-0.5528819561004639,
-0.29222434759140015,
-0.3616614043712616,
-0.6545571684837341,
0.24600253999233246,
-0.4799655079841614,
0.8327445983886719,
-0.8484601378440857,
-0.27542802691459656,
-0.4125889539718628,
-0.14169904589653015,
-0.44033223390579224,
0.006808646023273468,
0.23861464858055115,
0.7119325995445251,
-1.024143934249878,
0.7488619089126587,
0.6042201519012451,
-0.4203663468360901,
-0.8123725056648254,
-0.13573452830314636,
0.2024076133966446,
-0.3694329559803009,
0.39887943863868713,
0.38640841841697693,
-0.12543918192386627,
-0.24275366961956024,
-0.9559684991836548,
-0.6972910165786743,
0.550117015838623,
0.7128866910934448,
-0.8135728240013123,
0.16507039964199066,
-0.31106820702552795,
0.20344671607017517,
0.06801331788301468,
0.23993538320064545,
0.41746005415916443,
0.4110517203807831,
0.3688370883464813,
-0.6422807574272156,
-0.020756741985678673,
-0.22619232535362244,
-0.3927982449531555,
0.06717543303966522,
-0.5694245100021362,
0.8574936389923096,
-0.3484175205230713,
-0.4579837918281555,
0.05105482041835785,
0.6849303841590881,
0.7728539705276489,
0.453441858291626,
0.7444536089897156,
0.1715887188911438,
0.8999822735786438,
-0.22549550235271454,
0.5037159323692322,
-0.08051925897598267,
0.1515813171863556,
1.4040570259094238,
-0.21892477571964264,
0.8136134743690491,
0.5876742601394653,
-0.22615006566047668,
0.4321502149105072,
0.9690870046615601,
0.03252698853611946,
0.6475743055343628,
0.07330146431922913,
-0.34273749589920044,
-0.4786275327205658,
0.014988962560892105,
-0.3447101414203644,
0.3758751153945923,
0.30476638674736023,
-0.11411748826503754,
-0.4102768003940582,
0.10914509743452072,
0.18103832006454468,
-0.14932438731193542,
-0.16087843477725983,
0.8160117864608765,
0.09120288491249084,
-0.7971408367156982,
0.6619234681129456,
-0.36583876609802246,
0.6579565405845642,
-0.8744046688079834,
-0.16152817010879517,
-0.29173460602760315,
0.09293676167726517,
-0.25559502840042114,
-0.5247960090637207,
-0.05973726511001587,
-0.06964033842086792,
-0.10211475193500519,
-0.22385644912719727,
0.9266272187232971,
-0.5280824899673462,
-0.3100931942462921,
-0.3003726899623871,
0.6289358735084534,
0.07741371542215347,
0.288448303937912,
-0.6216194033622742,
0.2398664802312851,
-0.40328875184059143,
-0.2603907883167267,
0.4044911563396454,
0.37038418650627136,
0.17363934218883514,
0.47481128573417664,
0.4114042818546295,
0.17248156666755676,
-0.025443846359848976,
0.1385059356689453,
0.820048451423645,
-0.25716352462768555,
-0.7105530500411987,
-1.0662710666656494,
0.8136897683143616,
0.1712283492088318,
-0.5395890474319458,
0.6439059376716614,
0.2956216037273407,
0.5647002458572388,
0.0759914293885231,
0.7671610713005066,
0.14950443804264069,
0.2841915786266327,
-0.5431835651397705,
0.6209805011749268,
-0.18378640711307526,
0.3394009470939636,
-0.40344324707984924,
-0.8623450398445129,
-0.5856440663337708,
0.6259812712669373,
-0.019845115020871162,
0.1747981309890747,
0.5312184691429138,
0.5575830936431885,
-0.06606344133615494,
-0.030773302540183067,
0.3695664703845978,
0.026507951319217682,
0.10215149819850922,
0.370039165019989,
1.067286729812622,
-0.12975627183914185,
0.5322307348251343,
-0.26304861903190613,
-0.2694892883300781,
-0.23878087103366852,
-0.7681377530097961,
-0.8605241179466248,
-0.3626404404640198,
-0.5614964365959167,
-0.6224144697189331,
0.19801956415176392,
1.214107871055603,
1.0350695848464966,
-0.9655742049217224,
0.060089997947216034,
-0.27505749464035034,
0.49634823203086853,
-0.36513906717300415,
-0.22881700098514557,
0.2261013239622116,
-0.9691457748413086,
-0.773594856262207,
0.5683832168579102,
0.14734205603599548,
0.3096443712711334,
-0.15901361405849457,
-0.021495100110769272,
0.26481589674949646,
-0.08734575659036636,
0.39947816729545593,
0.5512524843215942,
-0.4748935401439667,
-0.19704724848270416,
-0.04777884483337402,
-0.19067536294460297,
0.1518624722957611,
0.6312058568000793,
-1.1172418594360352,
0.6664621233940125,
0.7185299396514893,
0.6647500395774841,
0.08966126292943954,
0.0971040427684784,
0.5311826467514038,
-0.945903480052948,
0.3805623948574066,
0.35205045342445374,
0.2609764635562897,
0.2951882779598236,
-0.3962557017803192,
0.22085615992546082,
0.4379950165748596,
-0.4855753779411316,
-1.0302647352218628,
0.21217899024486542,
-1.0873044729232788,
-0.2683722972869873,
1.2652649879455566,
-0.18423430621623993,
-0.19236916303634644,
-0.22630299627780914,
-0.28663039207458496,
0.2493332177400589,
-0.8983409404754639,
0.6173617839813232,
0.6943864822387695,
-0.2544800043106079,
-0.5624839663505554,
-0.0060903471894562244,
0.5748544931411743,
0.47711148858070374,
-0.6073642373085022,
0.048334430903196335,
0.7129258513450623,
0.25351229310035706,
-0.1742730736732483,
0.4266694486141205,
0.1135173961520195,
0.5971198678016663,
0.2891855835914612,
-0.2817671597003937,
-0.08116865903139114,
-0.6722223162651062,
-0.9162464141845703,
0.5485103130340576,
0.24186314642429352,
-0.5830320119857788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19328v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19328v2
|
Computational Approaches for Integrating out Subjectivity in Cognate Synonym Selection
| 2024-04-30T07:52:26 | 2024-06-05T15:56:26 |
Luise Häuser, Gerhard Jäger, Alexandros Stamatakis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, q-bio.PE
|
Working with cognate data involves handling synonyms, that is, multiple words
that describe the same concept in a language. In the early days of language
phylogenetics it was recommended to select one synonym only. However, as we
show here, binary character matrices, which are used as input for computational
methods, do allow for representing the entire dataset including all synonyms.
Here we address the question how one can and if one should include all synonyms
or whether it is preferable to select synonyms a priori. To this end, we
perform maximum likelihood tree inferences with the widely used RAxML-NG tool
and show that it yields plausible trees when all synonyms are used as input.
Furthermore, we show that a priori synonym selection can yield topologically
substantially different trees and we therefore advise against doing so. To
represent cognate data including all synonyms, we introduce two types of
character matrices beyond the standard binary ones: probabilistic binary and
probabilistic multi-valued character matrices. We further show that it is
dataset-dependent for which character matrix type the inferred RAxML-NG tree is
topologically closest to the gold standard. We also make available a Python
interface for generating all of the above character matrix types for cognate
data provided in CLDF format.
|
[
-0.5824711322784424,
-0.7597737908363342,
0.671997606754303,
0.12298154085874557,
-0.3280143141746521,
-0.0705191120505333,
-0.35164356231689453,
-0.44050082564353943,
0.4544755220413208,
0.34939178824424744,
-0.6335019469261169,
-0.4478701651096344,
-0.5756517648696899,
0.3783770203590393,
-0.37513336539268494,
0.8671666979789734,
-0.05957908183336258,
-0.03291700407862663,
-0.3829742670059204,
-0.46310117840766907,
-0.3066509962081909,
-1.0546334981918335,
-0.22435054183006287,
-0.34864187240600586,
0.8392814993858337,
0.531652569770813,
0.9353193044662476,
0.5343378782272339,
0.649873673915863,
0.25474992394447327,
0.06815069913864136,
-0.1989845484495163,
-0.3222631514072418,
0.6257031559944153,
-0.3371717631816864,
-0.5022950172424316,
-0.2962888777256012,
0.23705098032951355,
0.7490645051002502,
0.8475932478904724,
-0.10280588269233704,
0.0511908195912838,
-0.10367246717214584,
0.4538402855396271,
-0.740913450717926,
-0.011330198496580124,
-0.8042293787002563,
0.41823697090148926,
-0.49044761061668396,
-0.19143646955490112,
-0.1939106583595276,
-0.27662914991378784,
0.26354122161865234,
-0.6694756150245667,
0.19302314519882202,
0.11682284623384476,
0.8813535571098328,
0.1644717901945114,
-0.2430078238248825,
-0.42694953083992004,
-0.4941580295562744,
0.9686977863311768,
-0.4708098769187927,
0.5282865166664124,
0.40437087416648865,
0.3201654851436615,
-0.2994532883167267,
-0.5516484379768372,
-0.7005759477615356,
-0.41844165325164795,
-0.3367573320865631,
0.1295042335987091,
-0.3305937945842743,
0.3209867775440216,
0.2803042232990265,
0.5062019228935242,
-0.6253687739372253,
0.132893905043602,
-0.03710979223251343,
-0.22908006608486176,
0.4831421673297882,
0.1844535917043686,
0.1507769376039505,
-0.15131698548793793,
-0.23075509071350098,
-0.4507870078086853,
-0.9917397499084473,
-0.29702848196029663,
0.34971779584884644,
0.3603525459766388,
0.10984137654304504,
0.9425262808799744,
0.045966871082782745,
0.7829846739768982,
0.015718773007392883,
-0.018391713500022888,
0.020567215979099274,
-0.35226112604141235,
-0.2360319197177887,
-0.008590846322476864,
0.9683898091316223,
-0.10782143473625183,
0.04328082129359245,
-0.39501339197158813,
0.2031249701976776,
0.4092795252799988,
-0.045908935368061066,
-0.6859369277954102,
-0.29952022433280945,
0.3898569643497467,
-0.3460494577884674,
-0.019135378301143646,
-0.05139650031924248,
-0.7729120254516602,
-0.16430795192718506,
-0.3268587291240692,
0.3153349757194519,
-0.4222353994846344,
-0.33411499857902527,
-0.07409881800413132,
-0.49091386795043945,
0.02603667601943016,
0.25865525007247925,
-0.6668038964271545,
0.36823123693466187,
0.881889820098877,
0.6775320172309875,
-0.2979424297809601,
-0.32343438267707825,
-0.5097135901451111,
0.07382906228303909,
-0.4237091839313507,
0.5781497955322266,
-1.042468786239624,
-0.6078264713287354,
-0.40579867362976074,
-0.15684670209884644,
-0.10651154816150665,
-0.5256637930870056,
0.811257541179657,
-0.3173784017562866,
0.4839978814125061,
-0.47278881072998047,
-0.6116205453872681,
-0.5610945224761963,
0.12321636080741882,
-0.6842914819717407,
0.9687567949295044,
0.329253226518631,
-1.0547951459884644,
0.3902629613876343,
-0.3401545584201813,
-0.5543392300605774,
0.12179001420736313,
-0.45461106300354004,
-0.28897517919540405,
0.044279661029577255,
-0.3622574806213379,
0.7208880186080933,
-0.23275235295295715,
0.37633347511291504,
-0.6194232702255249,
-0.07761727273464203,
0.4123709201812744,
0.06263541430234909,
0.637802243232727,
0.29429155588150024,
-0.23664307594299316,
-0.0635625496506691,
-0.5404740571975708,
0.13944381475448608,
-0.12444748729467392,
-0.05751025676727295,
-0.5146754384040833,
0.2999761700630188,
0.13774244487285614,
0.23496483266353607,
0.05579186603426933,
-0.6866182088851929,
0.11421618610620499,
-0.36551886796951294,
0.391826331615448,
0.33973202109336853,
-0.30685144662857056,
0.3253415524959564,
-0.3096570074558258,
0.7006393671035767,
0.05798478052020073,
-0.4647487699985504,
0.1911669224500656,
-0.6417480111122131,
-0.6423429846763611,
-0.45762956142425537,
0.3178284168243408,
0.42354828119277954,
-0.6883286833763123,
0.6865322589874268,
-0.37111127376556396,
-0.5554157495498657,
-0.3597705364227295,
-0.22347919642925262,
0.3844433128833771,
0.4317440688610077,
0.28627657890319824,
-0.6118898391723633,
-0.7150887250900269,
-0.8267226219177246,
-0.0865427702665329,
-0.24949589371681213,
0.16365298628807068,
0.6488099694252014,
0.45127788186073303,
-0.03004780039191246,
1.2775797843933105,
-0.6158237457275391,
-0.20888137817382812,
-0.24127213656902313,
0.04848005622625351,
0.4110817611217499,
0.47474148869514465,
0.4927378296852112,
-0.7845572829246521,
-0.47829824686050415,
0.22647787630558014,
-0.6190029382705688,
0.10118062049150467,
0.1364227533340454,
-0.21154043078422546,
0.04946073517203331,
0.08509677648544312,
-0.5679435133934021,
0.36235493421554565,
0.6031374931335449,
-0.24574176967144012,
0.6270692944526672,
-0.16611434519290924,
0.00920017808675766,
-1.3040612936019897,
0.44659116864204407,
-0.042683325707912445,
-0.22381922602653503,
-0.718149721622467,
0.6221151947975159,
-0.2901338040828705,
-0.01139860786497593,
-0.2066657990217209,
0.5284931063652039,
-0.27583226561546326,
-0.35521596670150757,
0.0726829469203949,
0.15482480823993683,
-0.06064397469162941,
0.41588857769966125,
0.6466943025588989,
0.7770073413848877,
0.5935497283935547,
-0.527445912361145,
0.49679452180862427,
0.39299440383911133,
-0.14421722292900085,
0.58903968334198,
-0.642852246761322,
0.093080535531044,
-0.06635072082281113,
0.2700600326061249,
-0.8195791840553284,
-0.06955385953187943,
0.504530131816864,
-0.38341301679611206,
0.27609729766845703,
-0.06179485842585564,
-0.395363450050354,
-0.09256003051996231,
-0.30484703183174133,
0.4393506646156311,
0.17508645355701447,
-0.3594855070114136,
0.3360288143157959,
0.5467773079872131,
-0.253020316362381,
-0.6252264380455017,
-0.8003526329994202,
0.44538331031799316,
-0.42782148718833923,
-0.4252781569957733,
0.4482915997505188,
-0.1519128978252411,
-0.20351795852184296,
-0.05743115395307541,
0.327080100774765,
-0.2740384638309479,
0.19936898350715637,
0.2169269174337387,
0.18544262647628784,
-0.2769504189491272,
-0.09096061438322067,
0.19780853390693665,
-0.08528725802898407,
-0.3021582365036011,
-0.20938193798065186,
0.5358791947364807,
-0.1403089463710785,
-0.2133302390575409,
-0.18413123488426208,
0.8278089761734009,
0.32065269351005554,
-0.3564907908439636,
0.44046497344970703,
0.43245235085487366,
-0.2292318493127823,
0.02565591037273407,
-0.2983439266681671,
-0.20221948623657227,
-0.3896293640136719,
0.4341496527194977,
-0.5580527186393738,
-1.2144871950149536,
0.3745315670967102,
0.1997523456811905,
-0.07244899123907089,
0.3078981339931488,
0.6654529571533203,
0.009440972469747066,
0.7226530313491821,
0.44910186529159546,
0.07536600530147552,
0.23165318369865417,
-0.20544245839118958,
0.3182990252971649,
-0.9803088307380676,
0.011929227970540524,
-0.8856656551361084,
-0.29846540093421936,
-0.9540557861328125,
-0.5139210820198059,
0.3293255567550659,
-0.08895034343004227,
0.017761901021003723,
0.599852979183197,
-0.6028361320495605,
-0.019772764295339584,
0.5133684873580933,
-0.13395889103412628,
0.19668863713741302,
0.3849124014377594,
-0.41514819860458374,
-0.2360137403011322,
-0.7287703156471252,
-0.24364368617534637,
0.9350969791412354,
0.08445513248443604,
0.6531749963760376,
0.1863594651222229,
0.8330270051956177,
-0.027712441980838776,
0.3082267642021179,
-1.0500118732452393,
0.7587378025054932,
-0.47878196835517883,
-0.6804835200309753,
-0.11315833032131195,
-0.4285934269428253,
-1.2712810039520264,
0.4657849669456482,
-0.42260780930519104,
-0.8973369598388672,
0.6924771666526794,
0.17818278074264526,
-0.2355218529701233,
0.10276402533054352,
-0.41752398014068604,
0.848727285861969,
0.15821482241153717,
-0.26520806550979614,
-0.4715874493122101,
-0.765653669834137,
0.39469870924949646,
-0.0834636241197586,
0.015485367737710476,
0.08080197870731354,
-0.21032282710075378,
0.6236141324043274,
-0.43500301241874695,
0.4648011326789856,
0.2114103138446808,
-0.09611693024635315,
0.2938380539417267,
0.41156959533691406,
0.1794772446155548,
-0.2965618968009949,
-0.2279314398765564,
0.4382132291793823,
0.5749813914299011,
-0.04399208351969719,
-0.3040926158428192,
0.582112193107605,
-0.6970860362052917,
-0.44036468863487244,
-0.7660346031188965,
-0.578070342540741,
-0.18200375139713287,
0.05875696241855621,
0.25140380859375,
0.5313494801521301,
-0.41022413969039917,
0.28982338309288025,
0.2708725035190582,
-0.057102445513010025,
0.333051472902298,
0.2629967927932739,
-0.2559075653553009,
-0.47144436836242676,
1.22266685962677,
0.15056787431240082,
0.17356015741825104,
0.6375538110733032,
0.49866172671318054,
-0.34230244159698486,
-0.3614952862262726,
-0.2644643485546112,
0.07374171167612076,
-0.6237243413925171,
-0.03342825919389725,
-0.7375903725624084,
0.007876540534198284,
-0.06618134677410126,
0.017521917819976807,
0.20310041308403015,
-0.8324022889137268,
-0.15311893820762634,
0.2378809005022049,
0.4125511944293976,
0.6801270246505737,
-0.07291604578495026,
0.2539766728878021,
-0.7054320573806763,
0.21439777314662933,
0.17059366405010223,
0.12879392504692078,
-0.011630420573055744,
-0.01576092094182968,
0.0076112463138997555,
0.13772033154964447,
-0.1908508688211441,
-1.1450444459915161,
0.3538171052932739,
0.7244567275047302,
0.4481808841228485,
0.3555722236633301,
-0.18684296309947968,
0.5913090705871582,
-0.5160689949989319,
0.7568626403808594,
0.2158997356891632,
-0.7332255244255066,
0.20793984830379486,
-0.3496669828891754,
-0.11267285794019699,
0.6972571015357971,
0.6010462641716003,
-1.034402847290039,
-0.45958226919174194,
-0.5489441752433777,
-0.4681272804737091,
0.6142948269844055,
0.31592509150505066,
-0.1578950136899948,
-0.16624554991722107,
0.40050458908081055,
0.40597599744796753,
0.3988049626350403,
-0.46614059805870056,
-0.21825441718101501,
-0.12840449810028076,
-0.4675293564796448,
-0.32102420926094055,
-0.030802397057414055,
-0.023448480293154716,
-0.4626995623111725,
0.4554215967655182,
-0.2381225973367691,
0.37832367420196533,
0.2655878961086273,
-0.18439219892024994,
0.017399031668901443,
0.4424523115158081,
0.3833247125148773,
0.5756967663764954,
-0.12694114446640015,
0.308135449886322,
-0.08229415863752365,
-0.7521218061447144,
0.16422218084335327,
0.05880361795425415,
-0.19044731557369232,
0.3557928502559662,
0.2885957360267639,
0.49090275168418884,
0.15791960060596466,
-0.5579606890678406,
0.3935716152191162,
-0.018676647916436195,
-0.0632789134979248,
-0.038229621946811676,
0.019192729145288467,
0.14286202192306519,
-0.21741290390491486,
-0.04758754372596741,
0.08322811126708984,
0.3077975809574127,
-0.7576239705085754,
0.18316157162189484,
0.9486241936683655,
-0.20939886569976807,
-0.41931667923927307,
0.3073121905326843,
-0.1220216378569603,
-0.19979442656040192,
0.4980440139770508,
-0.2101316899061203,
-0.6719858050346375,
0.4674206078052521,
0.3729986846446991,
1.0559552907943726,
-0.29087668657302856,
0.12065167725086212,
0.4374501407146454,
-0.08084962517023087,
0.19127075374126434,
0.4545174241065979,
-0.3578692674636841,
-0.848141074180603,
-0.440103679895401,
-0.8121613264083862,
-0.524746835231781,
-0.19075638055801392,
-0.6214106678962708,
0.2217722088098526,
-0.46199068427085876,
-0.2669741213321686,
0.07945667207241058,
0.020371530205011368,
-0.5005089044570923,
0.210012286901474,
0.12313305586576462,
0.6022833585739136,
-0.7326546311378479,
0.9684224724769592,
0.7567028403282166,
-0.2446299046278,
-0.7560685276985168,
-0.11275686323642731,
-0.1432802528142929,
-0.6946857571601868,
0.7372047305107117,
0.053965989500284195,
-0.11283409595489502,
-0.011331997811794281,
-0.3530574440956116,
-1.0267754793167114,
0.8549095988273621,
0.3116801381111145,
-0.4400372803211212,
-0.007691558916121721,
0.29943639039993286,
0.5012888312339783,
-0.31427663564682007,
0.501968502998352,
0.5608126521110535,
0.5436672568321228,
0.4387975037097931,
-0.8099496364593506,
0.04422978684306145,
-0.031207917258143425,
0.028368527069687843,
0.3167414963245392,
-0.10453306138515472,
1.0935617685317993,
0.1339755356311798,
-0.603010356426239,
0.35711270570755005,
0.5655257701873779,
0.18558256328105927,
-0.03531281650066376,
0.46818315982818604,
0.9233664870262146,
0.6861014366149902,
-0.13941043615341187,
0.9874479174613953,
-0.4845219552516937,
0.47883567214012146,
1.1893483400344849,
-0.40102559328079224,
1.0873479843139648,
0.5073820352554321,
-0.6207267045974731,
0.6282798647880554,
0.8834736347198486,
0.0012678629718720913,
0.29971784353256226,
0.10602326691150665,
-0.3540276288986206,
-0.36768823862075806,
-0.29273706674575806,
-0.5113630890846252,
0.5911379456520081,
0.5701153874397278,
-0.14069412648677826,
-0.5319304466247559,
-0.40128961205482483,
0.14742743968963623,
-0.03914785385131836,
-0.014496749266982079,
0.7269377708435059,
0.23777593672275543,
-1.0597330331802368,
0.6071851849555969,
0.1289888322353363,
0.6711124777793884,
-0.8604483008384705,
-0.14145603775978088,
0.08411065489053726,
0.08851088583469391,
-0.3429178297519684,
-0.9376906156539917,
0.3552716076374054,
-0.25602471828460693,
0.11110062152147293,
-0.12314105033874512,
0.5834407806396484,
-0.7547870874404907,
-0.5629883408546448,
0.14183229207992554,
0.568825900554657,
0.3939884901046753,
0.027274081483483315,
-0.6027971506118774,
-0.22872455418109894,
-0.485895574092865,
0.19155599176883698,
0.2588638365268707,
0.15632487833499908,
-0.14627432823181152,
0.5251187682151794,
0.6255033612251282,
0.30767369270324707,
-0.08156554400920868,
-0.3010925352573395,
0.8050823211669922,
-0.410264790058136,
-0.6508010625839233,
-0.9825857281684875,
0.04385700449347496,
0.15574224293231964,
-0.21177653968334198,
0.8365224599838257,
0.5607241988182068,
0.6457210779190063,
0.14247705042362213,
0.6661542057991028,
-0.3394005596637726,
0.44594433903694153,
-0.3101920485496521,
0.5249279141426086,
-0.5690203905105591,
-0.38381338119506836,
-0.6052644848823547,
-1.0070675611495972,
-0.1740146428346634,
0.7266179919242859,
-0.11323388665914536,
-0.12407521903514862,
0.973753035068512,
0.8325532674789429,
-0.07860267162322998,
0.19767335057258606,
0.3310622274875641,
0.05929211527109146,
0.1638748049736023,
0.7274414896965027,
0.8244945406913757,
-0.12123490869998932,
-0.1169644370675087,
-0.10480223596096039,
-0.221086323261261,
-0.13645561039447784,
-1.1033087968826294,
-0.7478405833244324,
-0.9616574645042419,
-0.11793487519025803,
-0.5121411681175232,
-0.06644708663225174,
1.1591993570327759,
0.6633161902427673,
-0.864526093006134,
-0.5730133056640625,
-0.0760994404554367,
0.35563167929649353,
-0.2541787028312683,
-0.16570915281772614,
0.39022210240364075,
-0.12208722531795502,
-0.55376797914505,
0.25318560004234314,
0.3728839159011841,
-0.18802806735038757,
-0.479178786277771,
-0.09902970492839813,
-0.4043941795825958,
-0.09151189774274826,
0.6150796413421631,
0.3642764985561371,
-0.8106202483177185,
-0.38437047600746155,
-0.06703431159257889,
0.03616274520754814,
0.37298741936683655,
1.1064040660858154,
-0.9461645483970642,
0.5747345685958862,
0.6627439856529236,
0.453409343957901,
0.2556603252887726,
-0.213185116648674,
0.8405649662017822,
-0.6848580241203308,
0.2708703875541687,
0.46918609738349915,
0.5870375633239746,
0.42718905210494995,
-0.2379157841205597,
0.3084166944026947,
0.4706050157546997,
-0.21640907227993011,
-0.6876915693283081,
0.6176689863204956,
-1.1096488237380981,
-0.26411598920822144,
1.1551892757415771,
-0.2071337252855301,
-0.31021302938461304,
-0.21908754110336304,
-0.21781855821609497,
-0.014095175080001354,
-0.007188968360424042,
0.23992377519607544,
0.8130432367324829,
-0.01288948766887188,
0.12067292630672455,
-0.1646437793970108,
0.5733380317687988,
0.5112420916557312,
-0.7284933924674988,
-0.01270344015210867,
0.4588823914527893,
0.25210312008857727,
0.3132069408893585,
0.45058807730674744,
-0.04018881171941757,
0.3050522208213806,
-0.33098360896110535,
-0.007479140534996986,
0.24502024054527283,
-0.17188696563243866,
-0.45783862471580505,
0.10472716391086578,
0.15335780382156372,
0.1732746958732605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19319v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19319v1
|
Knowledge Distillation vs. Pretraining from Scratch under a Fixed (Computation) Budget
| 2024-04-30T07:40:35 | 2024-04-30T07:40:35 |
Minh Duc Bui, Fabian David Schmidt, Goran Glavaš, Katharina von der Wense
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Compared to standard language model (LM) pretraining (i.e., from scratch),
Knowledge Distillation (KD) entails an additional forward pass through a
teacher model that is typically substantially larger than the target student
model. As such, KD in LM pretraining materially slows down throughput of
pretraining instances vis-a-vis pretraining from scratch. Scaling laws of LM
pretraining suggest that smaller models can close the gap to larger
counterparts if trained on more data (i.e., processing more tokens)-and under a
fixed computation budget, smaller models are able be process more data than
larger models. We thus hypothesize that KD might, in fact, be suboptimal to
pretraining from scratch for obtaining smaller LMs, when appropriately
accounting for the compute budget. To test this, we compare pretraining from
scratch against several KD strategies for masked language modeling (MLM) in a
fair experimental setup, with respect to amount of computation as well as
pretraining data. Downstream results on GLUE, however, do not confirm our
hypothesis: while pretraining from scratch performs comparably to ordinary KD
under a fixed computation budget, more sophisticated KD strategies, namely
TinyBERT (Jiao et al., 2020) and MiniLM (Wang et al., 2023), outperform it by a
notable margin. We further find that KD yields larger gains over pretraining
from scratch when the data must be repeated under the fixed computation budget.
|
[
-0.4176217019557953,
-0.6224806904792786,
0.6304841637611389,
-0.07147333025932312,
-0.32421234250068665,
0.3262166678905487,
-0.5145974159240723,
-0.2624237835407257,
0.11934776604175568,
0.3970825970172882,
-0.5967839956283569,
0.0479586161673069,
-0.807485044002533,
-0.11516492813825607,
-0.235502690076828,
0.927714467048645,
-0.020629018545150757,
0.17723143100738525,
-0.7824257612228394,
0.1978849619626999,
-0.4685016870498657,
-0.7549335956573486,
-0.49237218499183655,
-0.7528099417686462,
0.5047926306724548,
0.4635123014450073,
0.4486142694950104,
0.6457785964012146,
0.27399003505706787,
0.3215405344963074,
0.1119125559926033,
-0.2987140119075775,
-0.5737786889076233,
-0.14263395965099335,
0.04794250801205635,
-0.6681530475616455,
-0.10953254252672195,
0.40013545751571655,
0.1768738180398941,
0.9832191467285156,
-0.30509352684020996,
0.07489194720983505,
0.19950300455093384,
1.1045668125152588,
-0.9347918033599854,
-0.039703257381916046,
-0.6049613356590271,
0.07418480515480042,
-0.12622815370559692,
0.14328783750534058,
-0.4276168942451477,
-0.46065497398376465,
0.38396283984184265,
-0.5852723717689514,
0.30516570806503296,
-0.33390161395072937,
0.9666174054145813,
0.5132481455802917,
-0.14760947227478027,
-0.40601199865341187,
-0.9454682469367981,
0.6569187045097351,
-0.6974338293075562,
0.6200886964797974,
0.5425049066543579,
0.33712807297706604,
0.13087867200374603,
-1.1496295928955078,
-0.5551486015319824,
-0.3591334819793701,
-0.05728054419159889,
-0.07631848007440567,
-0.04914652556180954,
0.11872689425945282,
0.4651065170764923,
0.499217689037323,
-0.18926763534545898,
0.13366064429283142,
-0.7228487133979797,
-0.11097388714551926,
0.39801475405693054,
-0.28150054812431335,
0.00839844811707735,
0.23691998422145844,
-0.48834484815597534,
-0.3021165132522583,
-0.7869248390197754,
-0.09334329515695572,
0.23685680329799652,
0.2572993338108063,
0.12003987282514572,
0.30945199728012085,
-0.30841732025146484,
0.4751463532447815,
0.2986486852169037,
-0.44484928250312805,
0.07854167371988297,
-0.27963390946388245,
-0.3421008586883545,
0.26988139748573303,
0.540894091129303,
0.1874833106994629,
0.7789304256439209,
-0.2740967571735382,
-0.1557541787624359,
0.011460786685347557,
0.20265264809131622,
-1.1208628416061401,
-0.8057044744491577,
-0.05728793889284134,
-0.19048061966896057,
-0.2052309811115265,
-0.2201886773109436,
-0.3544345498085022,
-0.3801833987236023,
-0.6835027933120728,
0.6014382839202881,
-0.24716322124004364,
-0.22889399528503418,
0.06142479553818703,
-0.14818598330020905,
-0.22352267801761627,
0.34826549887657166,
-0.896786630153656,
0.3294135630130768,
0.35533660650253296,
0.8018938302993774,
-0.10148373991250992,
-0.312203586101532,
-0.09155973047018051,
-0.37902775406837463,
-0.46308380365371704,
0.43361401557922363,
-0.23390169441699982,
-0.28721562027931213,
-0.3202885687351227,
-0.3222845792770386,
-0.3156265616416931,
-0.8499534726142883,
-0.03613733872771263,
-0.684775173664093,
0.14093469083309174,
-0.44243690371513367,
-0.7677041888237,
0.13715456426143646,
-0.028961677104234695,
-0.6683744788169861,
1.0064908266067505,
0.2271178960800171,
-0.7931193113327026,
1.0199596881866455,
-0.3975587785243988,
-0.36007004976272583,
-0.14028888940811157,
-0.11734753102064133,
-0.25866422057151794,
0.057783957570791245,
-0.03599731996655464,
0.41230565309524536,
-0.25274890661239624,
0.2372937798500061,
-0.4279378652572632,
-0.36378857493400574,
0.22763901948928833,
-0.2751087546348572,
0.6258468627929688,
0.43937233090400696,
-0.3630741834640503,
-0.335123211145401,
-0.8294246792793274,
0.05695194751024246,
-0.00789629202336073,
-0.5647128224372864,
-0.5323060154914856,
0.029841868206858635,
-0.43646031618118286,
0.42211130261421204,
0.25922679901123047,
-0.528767466545105,
0.19696034491062164,
-0.3840606212615967,
0.30824318528175354,
0.8948565721511841,
-0.18112607300281525,
0.679129958152771,
-0.17289799451828003,
0.5079024434089661,
0.15922805666923523,
-0.180794358253479,
-0.10565625876188278,
-0.14996197819709778,
-0.9145891070365906,
-0.38582339882850647,
0.7623805999755859,
0.31258440017700195,
-0.8952091932296753,
-0.14454466104507446,
-0.16557297110557556,
-0.6251272559165955,
-0.6378118395805359,
0.16286931931972504,
0.5581868290901184,
0.5056086182594299,
0.33593830466270447,
-0.29827815294265747,
-0.6245545744895935,
-0.7442190647125244,
-0.22125133872032166,
0.020967375487089157,
-0.14572925865650177,
0.15309450030326843,
0.4602894186973572,
0.2229788899421692,
1.114633560180664,
-0.7397435903549194,
-0.2500764727592468,
-0.2632240355014801,
-0.007304816972464323,
0.075897715985775,
0.6657301187515259,
0.6199297904968262,
-0.4326714873313904,
-0.9196781516075134,
-0.09889604896306992,
-0.4309360682964325,
-0.03052508644759655,
0.08550655096769333,
0.16866286098957062,
0.4077417254447937,
0.833725094795227,
-0.6789767742156982,
0.5866088271141052,
0.3718888759613037,
-0.17595674097537994,
0.7056800723075867,
-0.33555513620376587,
0.05505862087011337,
-0.8837673664093018,
-0.040592774748802185,
-0.4904002845287323,
-0.15968680381774902,
-0.7884777784347534,
-0.08065018802881241,
-0.053756654262542725,
-0.039237361401319504,
-0.3793522119522095,
0.22940059006214142,
-0.47989732027053833,
0.05978139862418175,
-0.46481266617774963,
-0.039726607501506805,
-0.0014674006961286068,
0.5356817245483398,
0.1657191514968872,
0.7453094124794006,
0.37248411774635315,
-0.707699179649353,
0.1829744577407837,
-0.4631982743740082,
-0.7722007632255554,
0.04379957541823387,
-0.775800347328186,
0.3230953514575958,
0.03883270546793938,
0.12001855671405792,
-0.7682889699935913,
-0.013401204720139503,
-0.03540819510817528,
-0.2576388716697693,
0.5028771162033081,
-0.12126083672046661,
-0.3281072974205017,
-0.2974456250667572,
-0.10283380001783371,
0.46443799138069153,
0.8491410613059998,
-0.45264512300491333,
0.1881992667913437,
0.0937555581331253,
-0.07422740012407303,
-0.5963293313980103,
-0.7278710603713989,
-0.3128775656223297,
-0.34667640924453735,
-0.4504266381263733,
0.18123796582221985,
-0.07541922479867935,
-0.32101306319236755,
0.05103857070207596,
-0.3475353419780731,
-0.2832324802875519,
0.3667774498462677,
0.14378277957439423,
0.04626917466521263,
-0.4203939139842987,
0.017760759219527245,
-0.30804410576820374,
-0.10288037359714508,
0.17286038398742676,
-0.489077091217041,
0.7118433117866516,
0.17490053176879883,
-0.4242088496685028,
-0.1758946031332016,
-0.09047824144363403,
0.49424979090690613,
0.1490820348262787,
1.1167004108428955,
0.3194231688976288,
-0.26584741473197937,
-0.2695043981075287,
-0.6395944952964783,
-0.41334351897239685,
-0.5033963918685913,
0.1939442902803421,
-0.4356081783771515,
-0.8764436841011047,
0.3134157657623291,
-0.17154689133167267,
-0.02064724825322628,
0.3862016201019287,
0.5151053667068481,
-0.25243526697158813,
0.6083855032920837,
0.8879408836364746,
-0.05427313596010208,
0.3435022830963135,
-0.22115381062030792,
0.2776980996131897,
-0.3327547013759613,
-0.13424457609653473,
-0.5950027108192444,
-0.4989973306655884,
-0.4313494563102722,
-0.5198779106140137,
0.0330057255923748,
0.5802338123321533,
-0.28352877497673035,
0.1659204512834549,
-0.2624717354774475,
0.8408798575401306,
0.9603556990623474,
-0.02086867205798626,
0.30683931708335876,
0.061316847801208496,
-0.2680801749229431,
-0.23436443507671356,
-1.0924546718597412,
-0.23439225554466248,
1.4338054656982422,
0.1886756271123886,
0.8448137044906616,
-0.3346991539001465,
0.9337633848190308,
0.07138484716415405,
0.3470238745212555,
-0.5455728769302368,
0.33980682492256165,
-0.10710635036230087,
-0.5912150144577026,
-0.3871927857398987,
-0.493704229593277,
-0.8267326951026917,
0.2740232050418854,
-0.08018015325069427,
-0.748728334903717,
0.3269321918487549,
0.49188321828842163,
-0.2605731189250946,
0.5311710834503174,
-1.1133514642715454,
0.8862101435661316,
0.07243071496486664,
-0.05809740349650383,
-0.14745354652404785,
-0.5776087045669556,
0.45902299880981445,
-0.5531030893325806,
0.24581123888492584,
0.0742732584476471,
0.4127618670463562,
0.9467060565948486,
-0.9849122762680054,
0.7190873026847839,
-0.5164408683776855,
-0.014820513315498829,
0.32987353205680847,
-0.07349099218845367,
0.2699611783027649,
-0.37800925970077515,
0.26792123913764954,
-0.00708971731364727,
0.3113599717617035,
-0.4765987694263458,
-0.6935257911682129,
0.391387939453125,
-0.9653047919273376,
-0.7503315210342407,
-0.2610468864440918,
-0.39656421542167664,
-0.17077262699604034,
0.17452430725097656,
0.5155121088027954,
0.3032805621623993,
-0.027872378006577492,
0.40836694836616516,
0.7189367413520813,
-0.03669406473636627,
0.5189979076385498,
0.4421055018901825,
-0.3293790817260742,
-0.1312776356935501,
0.8694023489952087,
0.6031162142753601,
0.8761868476867676,
0.15406785905361176,
0.3131279945373535,
-0.17610961198806763,
-0.5023334622383118,
-0.19650232791900635,
-0.05004670470952988,
-0.7463523745536804,
0.0051663778722286224,
-0.394779235124588,
-0.2871513068675995,
-0.4232325553894043,
-0.1946921944618225,
-0.8451622724533081,
-0.698062002658844,
-0.0607629269361496,
-0.11020996421575546,
0.22884804010391235,
0.5867407917976379,
-0.2157294601202011,
0.2972601354122162,
-0.4432726800441742,
0.1451413333415985,
0.47431331872940063,
0.28694409132003784,
0.25646770000457764,
-0.5137364864349365,
-0.6662689447402954,
0.37084314227104187,
-0.158078134059906,
-0.5386343002319336,
0.07134363800287247,
0.2632334232330322,
0.3675718903541565,
0.6592923998832703,
0.33177515864372253,
0.9407624006271362,
-0.697540283203125,
0.8087262511253357,
0.32643482089042664,
-0.6210302114486694,
0.29613643884658813,
0.15626952052116394,
0.47192347049713135,
0.8210034966468811,
0.6321178078651428,
-0.30641382932662964,
-0.43052390217781067,
-0.6995029449462891,
-0.7063568830490112,
0.8710169792175293,
0.041780985891819,
0.01811945252120495,
0.338858425617218,
0.2365754246711731,
0.12926171720027924,
0.4427903890609741,
-0.6566442251205444,
-0.42970484495162964,
-0.12454250454902649,
0.1742299646139145,
-0.41920551657676697,
-0.2866169512271881,
0.07662240415811539,
-0.49431586265563965,
0.6804088950157166,
0.1992487758398056,
0.08991764485836029,
0.08261416852474213,
-0.35009244084358215,
0.10165785998106003,
0.101771779358387,
0.4972849190235138,
0.8781173825263977,
-0.2462654411792755,
0.3221271336078644,
0.19441722333431244,
-0.8981449007987976,
0.25228577852249146,
-0.08674605190753937,
-0.20628894865512848,
-0.011238016188144684,
0.5187049508094788,
1.0027799606323242,
0.15065526962280273,
-0.5136395692825317,
0.37827369570732117,
0.1459621638059616,
-0.5701890587806702,
0.05529043823480606,
0.16925914585590363,
0.364818274974823,
0.12289665639400482,
0.2903915047645569,
0.12467477470636368,
-0.3169599771499634,
-0.500117838382721,
0.15384140610694885,
0.14747588336467743,
-0.22429853677749634,
-0.19856125116348267,
0.5866247415542603,
-0.06642380356788635,
-0.12336256355047226,
0.7540562748908997,
-0.027245162054896355,
-0.46167173981666565,
0.5557978749275208,
0.3563288450241089,
0.7217522263526917,
-0.28769105672836304,
0.1105678603053093,
0.1832192838191986,
0.4293540120124817,
-0.1079719066619873,
-0.10833783447742462,
-0.36902037262916565,
-0.8318794369697571,
-0.5727220773696899,
-0.8586966395378113,
-0.13921505212783813,
0.3442740738391876,
-0.7159367799758911,
-0.02608555182814598,
-0.5407621264457703,
-0.023105718195438385,
-0.02817884273827076,
0.21195536851882935,
-0.7041683197021484,
0.34008553624153137,
-0.08122443407773972,
0.8646575212478638,
-0.8197999596595764,
1.1041254997253418,
0.6142917275428772,
-0.25617992877960205,
-1.1329195499420166,
-0.22021962702274323,
-0.19913378357887268,
-0.6768826246261597,
0.9736831188201904,
0.051173239946365356,
0.14514027535915375,
0.00502056535333395,
-0.260776162147522,
-0.8416908979415894,
1.1880135536193848,
0.5508728623390198,
-0.7397223711013794,
-0.13022156059741974,
0.4595542550086975,
0.4348023235797882,
-0.25049829483032227,
-0.07309246063232422,
0.8711413145065308,
0.11489202827215195,
0.4296766221523285,
-1.1848523616790771,
-0.1302461326122284,
0.11057081073522568,
-0.17697708308696747,
0.2740016281604767,
-0.21273073554039001,
1.1917026042938232,
-0.2982048988342285,
-0.34998807311058044,
-0.3949395716190338,
0.4407794773578644,
0.2213309407234192,
0.5052046179771423,
0.5324836373329163,
0.9383879899978638,
0.7410041093826294,
-0.15756575763225555,
0.8750356435775757,
-0.2949904501438141,
0.2845461964607239,
1.2507729530334473,
-0.11273537576198578,
0.6617435812950134,
0.6906763315200806,
-0.6941594481468201,
0.4809964895248413,
0.7065545320510864,
0.3633328080177307,
0.7807998657226562,
0.28524085879325867,
-0.12212897092103958,
-0.21765939891338348,
0.31407979130744934,
-0.6315098404884338,
0.16316862404346466,
-0.13599279522895813,
-0.09905900061130524,
-0.24106808006763458,
0.25701189041137695,
0.25342148542404175,
0.07679614424705505,
-0.43277910351753235,
0.9228524565696716,
0.3618410527706146,
-0.7558409571647644,
0.8507481813430786,
-0.13101254403591156,
0.5797306299209595,
-0.5688268542289734,
0.3394455313682556,
-0.377142071723938,
0.3810311555862427,
-0.00915850605815649,
-0.12450522929430008,
0.28962385654449463,
0.0246686153113842,
-0.30470407009124756,
-0.4659552574157715,
0.968917191028595,
-0.5575527548789978,
-0.27068763971328735,
-0.044930458068847656,
0.5782516598701477,
0.2661653459072113,
-0.20642490684986115,
-0.39308932423591614,
-0.11739721894264221,
-0.02135281264781952,
-0.4544222056865692,
0.8679813146591187,
0.42533618211746216,
0.08359315991401672,
0.6758913993835449,
0.7812938094139099,
0.1934807449579239,
0.36720696091651917,
-0.02227196842432022,
1.0446985960006714,
-0.12763819098472595,
-0.5378929972648621,
-1.1759637594223022,
0.435632586479187,
0.1302480548620224,
0.049295879900455475,
0.9271328449249268,
0.4378747045993805,
1.196467399597168,
-0.3534996509552002,
0.5480188131332397,
0.0072730230167508125,
0.29632943868637085,
-0.7212460041046143,
0.9947014451026917,
-0.45413681864738464,
0.21150386333465576,
-0.270931601524353,
-1.0090281963348389,
0.2977011501789093,
0.5486407279968262,
-0.3507596552371979,
0.2876851260662079,
0.738625168800354,
0.5377913117408752,
-0.09276998788118362,
-0.1667196899652481,
0.25910279154777527,
0.09360279887914658,
-0.025046564638614655,
0.4456111192703247,
0.8652082085609436,
-0.12939050793647766,
0.2884954512119293,
-0.5706064105033875,
-0.044033393263816833,
0.029664840549230576,
-0.8375287652015686,
-1.0198707580566406,
-0.6402484178543091,
-0.38881224393844604,
-0.27337998151779175,
-0.12560084462165833,
0.6797532439231873,
0.7559471130371094,
-0.6497204303741455,
-0.26407256722450256,
-0.2882387936115265,
0.15755078196525574,
-0.08476782590150833,
-0.20727716386318207,
0.2801012694835663,
-0.5588744878768921,
-0.47812870144844055,
0.22316080331802368,
-0.13943277299404144,
0.0194587130099535,
-0.2662549316883087,
-0.1787167489528656,
-0.30245324969291687,
0.2509689927101135,
0.5570594668388367,
0.23897233605384827,
-0.4065881669521332,
-0.07762166857719421,
-0.04986780136823654,
-0.008594267070293427,
-0.1105986088514328,
1.0270897150039673,
-1.1148995161056519,
0.47963088750839233,
0.31084200739860535,
0.694878876209259,
0.9807273149490356,
-0.17474403977394104,
0.5897107720375061,
-0.9095655083656311,
0.32993650436401367,
0.00359932379797101,
-0.06720242649316788,
0.035746123641729355,
-0.03771656006574631,
0.2681328356266022,
0.4512613117694855,
-0.532463550567627,
-1.1589775085449219,
0.12782512605190277,
-0.22807440161705017,
-0.678943395614624,
0.7833688855171204,
-0.36061233282089233,
0.09581757336854935,
0.00884245615452528,
0.04647931456565857,
0.20332016050815582,
0.06886027008295059,
0.6677252054214478,
1.0687896013259888,
0.1025920957326889,
0.029518818482756615,
-0.5882397890090942,
1.0252858400344849,
0.3818366825580597,
-0.38847407698631287,
-0.04076758772134781,
0.3131836950778961,
0.44348886609077454,
0.21203139424324036,
1.0683135986328125,
0.2560110092163086,
0.1389755755662918,
0.2600781321525574,
-0.0019631150644272566,
-0.26942726969718933,
-0.6457844972610474,
0.023030823096632957,
0.15829366445541382,
0.20245476067066193,
-0.2967141270637512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19318v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19318v1
|
Enhancing Trust in LLM-Generated Code Summaries with Calibrated Confidence Scores
| 2024-04-30T07:38:08 | 2024-04-30T07:38:08 |
Yuvraj Virk, Premkumar Devanbu, Toufique Ahmed
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
A good summary can often be very useful during program comprehension. While a
brief, fluent, and relevant summary can be helpful, it does require significant
human effort to produce. Often, good summaries are unavailable in software
projects, thus making maintenance more difficult. There has been a considerable
body of research into automated AI-based methods, using Large Language models
(LLMs), to generate summaries of code; there also has been quite a bit work on
ways to measure the performance of such summarization methods, with special
attention paid to how closely these AI-generated summaries resemble a summary a
human might have produced. Measures such as BERTScore and BLEU have been
suggested and evaluated with human-subject studies.
However, LLMs often err and generate something quite unlike what a human
might say. Given an LLM-produced code summary, is there a way to gauge whether
it's likely to be sufficiently similar to a human produced summary, or not? In
this paper, we study this question, as a calibration problem: given a summary
from an LLM, can we compute a confidence measure, which is a good indication of
whether the summary is sufficiently similar to what a human would have produced
in this situation? We examine this question using several LLMs, for several
languages, and in several different settings. We suggest an approach which
provides well-calibrated predictions of likelihood of similarity to human
summaries.
|
[
-0.226720929145813,
-0.1297459453344345,
0.646561861038208,
0.15602129697799683,
-0.2403256893157959,
0.18485237658023834,
-0.2895214855670929,
-0.6008424758911133,
0.29769307374954224,
0.4948466420173645,
-0.19197200238704681,
-0.5664672255516052,
-0.5714675188064575,
0.3344618082046509,
-0.45872512459754944,
1.0413293838500977,
-0.14258596301078796,
0.0852808877825737,
-0.5437419414520264,
0.02137312851846218,
-0.20698349177837372,
-0.4960940480232239,
-0.3734598457813263,
-0.8345767855644226,
0.22366809844970703,
0.27835986018180847,
0.749000072479248,
0.5384737253189087,
0.5589536428451538,
0.21309642493724823,
0.10388956218957901,
0.33218663930892944,
-0.620101273059845,
0.11659596860408783,
0.11576411873102188,
-0.8502079248428345,
-0.5157563090324402,
0.09422727674245834,
0.45315372943878174,
0.5208660364151001,
0.07676108181476593,
0.35870885848999023,
0.4682875871658325,
0.697864830493927,
-0.4921450614929199,
0.40110889077186584,
-0.5694020986557007,
-0.08193350583314896,
0.22410735487937927,
-0.603668212890625,
-0.38786202669143677,
-0.7869429588317871,
-0.037273306399583817,
-0.43484845757484436,
0.17464055120944977,
0.0062906257808208466,
0.8094240427017212,
0.3299753963947296,
-0.18821075558662415,
-0.4064515233039856,
-0.6378266215324402,
0.9621731042861938,
-0.991479218006134,
-0.14337792992591858,
0.680047869682312,
0.1439841389656067,
-0.26560038328170776,
-0.38827818632125854,
-0.4894278347492218,
-0.6178826093673706,
-0.17226988077163696,
0.30008748173713684,
0.24710287153720856,
-0.025059515610337257,
0.30634790658950806,
0.31693828105926514,
-0.47572651505470276,
-0.12792235612869263,
-0.22619861364364624,
-0.5566777586936951,
0.976215660572052,
0.12017105519771576,
0.08301787078380585,
-0.25601062178611755,
-0.26115137338638306,
-0.2880263924598694,
-0.9520635604858398,
0.12690608203411102,
0.5803134441375732,
-0.07925008237361908,
-0.06649306416511536,
0.7368656992912292,
-0.11169952154159546,
0.41627323627471924,
-0.05047236755490303,
-0.3547619879245758,
0.19090941548347473,
-0.3829800486564636,
-0.1257348358631134,
0.11635667085647583,
0.5301686525344849,
0.9226318597793579,
0.9713019728660583,
-0.1492195427417755,
-0.3680298924446106,
0.2110319584608078,
0.29489877820014954,
-0.7522441744804382,
-0.40385761857032776,
0.31184953451156616,
-0.5024970769882202,
-0.42377349734306335,
0.5043290853500366,
-0.2463289499282837,
-0.3802359700202942,
-0.4177395701408386,
0.2764791250228882,
-0.3545955717563629,
0.08184344321489334,
-0.30727729201316833,
-0.031367331743240356,
0.45235997438430786,
0.40329986810684204,
-0.5557065010070801,
0.12756218016147614,
0.7799966931343079,
0.5835282802581787,
-0.29938364028930664,
-0.42449572682380676,
-0.5774070620536804,
0.11547543853521347,
-0.6279407739639282,
0.5807176232337952,
-0.22008207440376282,
-0.6716015934944153,
-0.12576016783714294,
-0.37677887082099915,
0.1222316175699234,
-0.5108428597450256,
0.10094363242387772,
-0.46664008498191833,
0.09388510137796402,
-0.20926399528980255,
-0.8054014444351196,
-0.16193285584449768,
0.5711768865585327,
-0.5555242300033569,
0.9089249968528748,
0.02662642113864422,
-0.9056752920150757,
0.23969058692455292,
-0.19225187599658966,
-0.514420747756958,
-0.21244776248931885,
-0.5953216552734375,
-0.4424043297767639,
0.23632510006427765,
0.13188181817531586,
0.5782853364944458,
-0.09897397458553314,
0.14241011440753937,
-0.32613006234169006,
-0.6490784883499146,
0.7881212830543518,
-0.44927313923835754,
0.5490488409996033,
0.198735311627388,
-0.20726850628852844,
-0.1461278349161148,
-0.4727807343006134,
0.3904051184654236,
-0.28627505898475647,
-0.36606746912002563,
-0.2933026850223541,
-0.03789989650249481,
-0.2197510302066803,
-0.18814775347709656,
0.6015142202377319,
-0.3133907914161682,
-0.18508295714855194,
-0.5286369919776917,
-0.05158640071749687,
0.7362996935844421,
0.2739841639995575,
0.314612478017807,
-0.9087539911270142,
0.6249217391014099,
-0.21743243932724,
-0.029516898095607758,
-0.47261109948158264,
-0.4423602819442749,
-0.6250033974647522,
-0.02592277154326439,
0.39312806725502014,
0.6333469748497009,
-0.6486139893531799,
0.5444109439849854,
-0.44033122062683105,
-0.48188039660453796,
-0.31569984555244446,
0.3459480404853821,
0.6437143087387085,
0.46506357192993164,
-0.00329436338506639,
-0.6268925070762634,
-0.28379568457603455,
-0.9013688564300537,
-0.40151143074035645,
-0.5932206511497498,
-0.3965309262275696,
0.33834636211395264,
0.3776462972164154,
0.0008714312571100891,
1.0461771488189697,
-0.6406862139701843,
-0.11700168251991272,
-0.05290248990058899,
0.3723736107349396,
0.19490094482898712,
0.38435620069503784,
0.6029647588729858,
-0.6661296486854553,
-0.6551191806793213,
-0.05499611049890518,
-0.7090662717819214,
-0.1587827205657959,
-0.18425534665584564,
0.0855722427368164,
0.2272513210773468,
0.5640342831611633,
-0.2850113809108734,
0.4743284583091736,
0.5979995131492615,
0.07286590337753296,
0.677047073841095,
-0.5116721391677856,
0.4786432683467865,
-1.5155482292175293,
0.30037543177604675,
-0.08805467188358307,
-0.5713062286376953,
-0.20411886274814606,
0.28772252798080444,
0.07286739349365234,
0.3036070764064789,
-0.2244407832622528,
0.26639559864997864,
-0.38374945521354675,
-0.3065415024757385,
-0.363374799489975,
0.11545494943857193,
0.06605584174394608,
0.20041026175022125,
-0.09865300357341766,
0.9694674015045166,
0.3970043957233429,
-0.49575990438461304,
0.22085070610046387,
0.07531487941741943,
-0.434602826833725,
0.5546234846115112,
-0.8458766341209412,
0.1505565196275711,
0.004613101482391357,
0.2639666497707367,
-1.0766905546188354,
-0.35501620173454285,
-0.17365792393684387,
-0.91766357421875,
0.24823428690433502,
-0.06492337584495544,
-0.5708101391792297,
0.005744731053709984,
-0.7733968496322632,
0.25467073917388916,
0.6451906561851501,
-0.15981300175189972,
0.571706235408783,
0.18724563717842102,
-0.4089038074016571,
-0.6824156045913696,
-0.9982585310935974,
0.07033383846282959,
-0.15398263931274414,
-0.5296592116355896,
0.20883139967918396,
-0.2715493440628052,
-0.42063453793525696,
-0.17632988095283508,
-0.1471141278743744,
-0.12978717684745789,
0.1929435431957245,
0.658476710319519,
0.41434839367866516,
-0.10061747580766678,
-0.06673436611890793,
0.007362057454884052,
-0.0963936597108841,
0.3075157403945923,
0.16881997883319855,
0.23227863013744354,
-0.14418965578079224,
-0.550590991973877,
-0.25649306178092957,
0.280830979347229,
0.7677320241928101,
-0.10156886279582977,
0.4001156687736511,
0.46859169006347656,
-0.30244141817092896,
-0.19024506211280823,
-0.627334713935852,
-0.3961397409439087,
-0.41073206067085266,
0.12788818776607513,
-0.15621159970760345,
-0.7245286703109741,
0.6970327496528625,
-0.04808879643678665,
0.08039387315511703,
0.18765367567539215,
0.6807463765144348,
-0.36326679587364197,
0.8790656924247742,
0.7506195306777954,
-0.4813181161880493,
0.2647691071033478,
-0.12908227741718292,
-0.02308223582804203,
-0.6314571499824524,
-0.08517099171876907,
-0.6022610068321228,
-0.23352976143360138,
-0.6682424545288086,
-0.4738469123840332,
0.4930935800075531,
-0.03078651987016201,
0.1329721212387085,
0.3399885594844818,
-0.11525645107030869,
0.7342310547828674,
0.7005004286766052,
0.05719510093331337,
0.5187541842460632,
-0.02902456559240818,
-0.07814931124448776,
0.18627728521823883,
-0.3158056437969208,
-0.9469383358955383,
1.2657861709594727,
0.23712672293186188,
0.9971805810928345,
0.03842388838529587,
1.13499915599823,
0.5437527298927307,
0.5516449213027954,
-0.5264222025871277,
0.4553426206111908,
0.06078236922621727,
-0.3118741810321808,
-0.21782967448234558,
-0.6491374969482422,
-0.800076961517334,
-0.19823329150676727,
-0.20133569836616516,
-0.7732850909233093,
-0.2769951820373535,
0.4183797240257263,
-0.4519380033016205,
-0.20168469846248627,
-0.7009835243225098,
0.27593833208084106,
-0.08736421912908554,
-0.024798210710287094,
-0.40306705236434937,
-0.6779055595397949,
0.33990663290023804,
-0.2913040518760681,
0.19520048797130585,
-0.13601644337177277,
0.022663742303848267,
0.5593394637107849,
-0.28171953558921814,
0.8995711803436279,
0.18335650861263275,
-0.1444523185491562,
0.45644012093544006,
0.4280724823474884,
0.4693329334259033,
0.31212201714515686,
-0.3653769791126251,
0.013843781314790249,
0.18736793100833893,
-0.3083471953868866,
-0.5899224281311035,
0.7863965034484863,
-0.6985385417938232,
-0.43341684341430664,
-0.29583293199539185,
-0.6394934058189392,
-0.1040862649679184,
0.12552957236766815,
0.3814723491668701,
0.30111896991729736,
-0.248778834939003,
0.09113165736198425,
0.5317516922950745,
-0.15471182763576508,
0.432782381772995,
0.2345731258392334,
-0.16764673590660095,
-0.3678867220878601,
0.6733335256576538,
-0.15653587877750397,
0.4362039268016815,
0.4161909222602844,
0.06449998170137405,
-0.2793858051300049,
-0.4533167779445648,
-0.30250680446624756,
0.15485575795173645,
-0.5769709348678589,
-0.4908803701400757,
0.0650738775730133,
-0.28143540024757385,
-0.3790833353996277,
-0.26607391238212585,
-0.19284933805465698,
-0.42322584986686707,
-0.3212684094905853,
-0.01815519854426384,
0.28249457478523254,
0.7190974354743958,
0.10832129418849945,
0.021493731066584587,
-0.9939298033714294,
0.266059935092926,
0.15582580864429474,
0.30104202032089233,
0.017824286594986916,
-0.5507950186729431,
-0.3099513053894043,
0.3143356442451477,
-0.23653434216976166,
-0.8119051456451416,
0.37426576018333435,
0.16746261715888977,
0.5656852722167969,
0.31677770614624023,
0.3624749183654785,
0.5909934639930725,
-0.22895607352256775,
0.8974519371986389,
0.12023317813873291,
-0.9247795939445496,
0.46481749415397644,
-0.10250751674175262,
0.17823205888271332,
0.8116334676742554,
0.2744497060775757,
-0.1398334801197052,
-0.8642460703849792,
-0.5210675597190857,
-0.5254882574081421,
0.2411268949508667,
0.5423068404197693,
0.3084970712661743,
0.13781578838825226,
0.43124035000801086,
0.03951100632548332,
0.28555357456207275,
-0.6252461075782776,
-0.21343448758125305,
0.06434138864278793,
-0.3440530300140381,
-0.3933764398097992,
-0.07929003238677979,
-0.1785641461610794,
0.28868362307548523,
0.5440644025802612,
-0.34651637077331543,
0.07163885235786438,
0.3394249677658081,
-0.2685079872608185,
-0.19036485254764557,
0.22451850771903992,
0.6896213889122009,
0.931598961353302,
-0.34224167466163635,
0.2807322144508362,
0.21568000316619873,
-0.5322075486183167,
-0.08379579335451126,
-0.10692174732685089,
-0.25644391775131226,
-0.08610183745622635,
0.6884849071502686,
0.22243483364582062,
0.010786664672195911,
-0.834879457950592,
0.7036824822425842,
-0.05939106270670891,
-0.16061843931674957,
-0.4888475239276886,
0.25923389196395874,
0.041448213160037994,
0.24591590464115143,
0.34334173798561096,
0.19948790967464447,
0.09071668237447739,
-0.4800757169723511,
0.45942267775535583,
0.3137296736240387,
-0.20445416867733002,
-0.13099068403244019,
0.38408705592155457,
0.1806001216173172,
-0.3268639147281647,
0.5475214719772339,
-0.1570371389389038,
-0.5728870630264282,
0.805553138256073,
0.3182685375213623,
0.7879998683929443,
-0.028099142014980316,
0.09347805380821228,
0.29455703496932983,
0.32494020462036133,
-0.255306601524353,
0.35566970705986023,
-0.07813438773155212,
-0.7221643924713135,
-0.6997801661491394,
-0.4804229736328125,
-0.7413830161094666,
-0.3376246988773346,
-0.8231515884399414,
-0.020992211997509003,
-0.27795687317848206,
-0.25903216004371643,
-0.5172119736671448,
0.18977554142475128,
-0.48801442980766296,
0.12126810103654861,
0.24962341785430908,
0.8760659098625183,
-0.9671007990837097,
0.872617781162262,
0.566245436668396,
-0.30530524253845215,
-1.082045078277588,
0.31819406151771545,
-0.19347615540027618,
-0.7551466822624207,
0.20688496530056,
0.2056218534708023,
-0.32824426889419556,
-0.24303174018859863,
-0.4719148576259613,
-0.5673161149024963,
1.417762041091919,
0.49988558888435364,
-0.43494999408721924,
0.1254548281431198,
0.17107278108596802,
0.7267594337463379,
-0.3629298210144043,
0.24094952642917633,
0.3596360981464386,
0.3776308000087738,
0.03207309544086456,
-1.1176859140396118,
0.03923097252845764,
-0.12294461578130722,
0.06363757699728012,
-0.09814495593309402,
-0.39332208037376404,
0.6731141209602356,
-0.3981718420982361,
0.00460765790194273,
0.40076079964637756,
0.6304697394371033,
0.49473145604133606,
0.4620590806007385,
0.46957576274871826,
0.16734614968299866,
0.8669644594192505,
0.2203766405582428,
1.2832716703414917,
-0.642228364944458,
0.40640899538993835,
1.3436269760131836,
-0.34540361166000366,
0.987521231174469,
0.52628093957901,
-0.11775034666061401,
0.4435276687145233,
0.38844260573387146,
-0.0047455341555178165,
0.22375890612602234,
0.3662950396537781,
-0.04500803351402283,
-0.2995249032974243,
0.09814564883708954,
-0.35668933391571045,
0.4280122220516205,
0.18067176640033722,
-0.68089359998703,
-0.10587143898010254,
-0.5699970126152039,
-0.06435447931289673,
0.40698373317718506,
-0.26877447962760925,
0.7871467471122742,
0.4920884370803833,
-1.0006824731826782,
0.3479938805103302,
0.015795152634382248,
0.5459778308868408,
-0.5577496290206909,
-0.09069289267063141,
-0.30768635869026184,
0.13359439373016357,
-0.2707252502441406,
-0.8652015328407288,
0.3122135102748871,
0.2230570763349533,
-0.19637203216552734,
-0.10145559161901474,
0.6241610050201416,
-0.38339728116989136,
-0.5739120244979858,
0.05177152156829834,
0.680052638053894,
0.4507432281970978,
-0.10645440965890884,
-0.39966335892677307,
-0.02204471081495285,
0.24930115044116974,
-0.14362196624279022,
0.3272286653518677,
0.1369878202676773,
0.021324384957551956,
0.7199395895004272,
0.5268559455871582,
0.3395927846431732,
-0.09017235040664673,
0.056837305426597595,
0.5189926624298096,
-0.4029328525066376,
-0.4524393677711487,
-0.9536126852035522,
0.19425112009048462,
-0.19705860316753387,
-0.09678364545106888,
0.9064817428588867,
0.6423430442810059,
0.8183532953262329,
-0.10489670187234879,
0.8002217411994934,
0.2815561592578888,
0.3776790499687195,
-0.6040958166122437,
0.9384793639183044,
-0.2444787472486496,
0.4437790513038635,
-0.4560382664203644,
-1.1853833198547363,
-0.3388940989971161,
0.7794449329376221,
-0.11437281966209412,
0.12399336695671082,
0.5292230844497681,
1.1116939783096313,
0.12022843211889267,
-0.19216175377368927,
0.3857771158218384,
0.03160541132092476,
0.2401527464389801,
0.6881217360496521,
0.7369819283485413,
-0.31838712096214294,
0.5568851828575134,
-0.2106558233499527,
-0.29571664333343506,
-0.3014175295829773,
-1.2777979373931885,
-0.9073746204376221,
-0.33616307377815247,
-0.3502013683319092,
-0.42077916860580444,
-0.19560445845127106,
0.9763319492340088,
0.6923918724060059,
-0.8255373239517212,
-0.3812260925769806,
0.1285480260848999,
0.1839403212070465,
-0.12668739259243011,
-0.1420976221561432,
0.3424420654773712,
0.019107110798358917,
-0.6273810267448425,
0.06545382738113403,
0.12331295758485794,
0.30185550451278687,
-0.38669437170028687,
-0.4225345253944397,
0.5159952044487,
0.3643440008163452,
0.3850219249725342,
0.04899761453270912,
-0.6600990295410156,
-0.5204014182090759,
-0.05509842187166214,
-0.33162644505500793,
-0.05509753152728081,
0.7322831153869629,
-0.7680104970932007,
0.29033708572387695,
0.5938348174095154,
0.6104559302330017,
0.2890217900276184,
0.3597739040851593,
0.9040251970291138,
-1.0084768533706665,
-0.331500381231308,
0.23983734846115112,
0.4328230023384094,
0.40226590633392334,
-0.42465490102767944,
0.4149962365627289,
-0.3681751489639282,
-0.695229709148407,
-0.6552107334136963,
0.23501114547252655,
-1.103827953338623,
0.06120448186993599,
1.139678716659546,
-0.6174585819244385,
-0.07913593202829361,
0.09071441739797592,
-0.20571310818195343,
0.1577000617980957,
-0.38802462816238403,
1.0597858428955078,
0.7021114230155945,
-0.1680571436882019,
0.22640448808670044,
-0.18652281165122986,
0.33335039019584656,
0.300504207611084,
-0.875035285949707,
0.09731701016426086,
0.515322208404541,
0.4209440052509308,
0.3900200426578522,
0.5267146229743958,
-0.15973077714443207,
0.5976995229721069,
-0.08440609276294708,
-0.04878000542521477,
-0.11363208293914795,
-0.19281058013439178,
-0.17575155198574066,
0.1788543313741684,
0.557901918888092,
-0.09888860583305359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19317v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19317v1
|
Revisiting N-Gram Models: Their Impact in Modern Neural Networks for Handwritten Text Recognition
| 2024-04-30T07:37:48 | 2024-04-30T07:37:48 |
Solène Tarride, Christopher Kermorvant
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
In recent advances in automatic text recognition (ATR), deep neural networks
have demonstrated the ability to implicitly capture language statistics,
potentially reducing the need for traditional language models. This study
directly addresses whether explicit language models, specifically n-gram
models, still contribute to the performance of state-of-the-art deep learning
architectures in the field of handwriting recognition. We evaluate two
prominent neural network architectures, PyLaia and DAN, with and without the
integration of explicit n-gram language models. Our experiments on three
datasets - IAM, RIMES, and NorHand v2 - at both line and page level,
investigate optimal parameters for n-gram models, including their order,
weight, smoothing methods and tokenization level. The results show that
incorporating character or subword n-gram models significantly improves the
performance of ATR models on all datasets, challenging the notion that deep
learning models alone are sufficient for optimal performance. In particular,
the combination of DAN with a character language model outperforms current
benchmarks, confirming the value of hybrid approaches in modern document
analysis systems.
|
[
0.07041432708501816,
-0.4835350215435028,
0.6223539113998413,
-0.36544668674468994,
-0.158499613404274,
-0.04062690585851669,
-0.05553312972187996,
-0.774311363697052,
0.0361233688890934,
0.5165321826934814,
-0.04588443040847778,
-0.6153601408004761,
-0.7811247706413269,
0.17091681063175201,
-0.5301517248153687,
0.7067687511444092,
-0.12696419656276703,
0.11315581947565079,
-0.18457713723182678,
-0.08542809635400772,
0.27260875701904297,
-0.6220703721046448,
-0.6586836576461792,
-0.3502084016799927,
0.6539351940155029,
0.2343231439590454,
0.5873348712921143,
0.7331030368804932,
0.7761874198913574,
0.34716710448265076,
-0.20520144701004028,
0.19876477122306824,
0.10456836968660355,
-0.03496425598859787,
0.5805615186691284,
-0.4760800004005432,
-0.8893031477928162,
0.22969530522823334,
0.8338629007339478,
0.8197684288024902,
0.26565617322921753,
-0.16161894798278809,
0.0261478740721941,
0.37529757618904114,
-0.6589131951332092,
0.06477560847997665,
-0.1346379816532135,
-0.047535739839076996,
-0.36696261167526245,
0.1654752790927887,
-0.48507174849510193,
-0.5707821249961853,
0.39037638902664185,
-0.6064402461051941,
0.36556753516197205,
-0.3042646050453186,
0.7385281324386597,
-0.10666579008102417,
-0.37009820342063904,
-0.6922399997711182,
-0.5855674147605896,
0.5227836966514587,
-1.0533447265625,
0.3780043423175812,
0.3076232075691223,
0.2669455409049988,
-0.12141232937574387,
-0.869864284992218,
-0.6076482534408569,
-0.4418250024318695,
-0.19516034424304962,
-0.007429073099046946,
-0.14714469015598297,
0.22794616222381592,
0.22397440671920776,
0.6628579497337341,
-0.2154180109500885,
0.45027631521224976,
-0.23920834064483643,
-0.18810588121414185,
0.6376932859420776,
0.2612427771091461,
0.4801817834377289,
0.08325465023517609,
0.011896790005266666,
-0.1882144957780838,
-0.5076713562011719,
0.234147846698761,
0.7225614190101624,
0.5001774430274963,
-0.12385265529155731,
0.3583436906337738,
0.06553156673908234,
0.8619490265846252,
-0.019587764516472816,
-0.17436619102954865,
0.12466467916965485,
-0.2247668206691742,
-0.34287795424461365,
-0.22549404203891754,
0.8787027597427368,
0.0702538713812828,
0.3926120102405548,
-0.3340843915939331,
-0.20501336455345154,
0.05015958845615387,
0.06573028862476349,
-0.9275302886962891,
-0.4218243658542633,
-0.33972665667533875,
-0.796069324016571,
-0.48539045453071594,
0.29999014735221863,
-0.9099701642990112,
-0.824927031993866,
-0.5021569728851318,
0.09964859485626221,
-0.160570427775383,
-0.48339974880218506,
0.18242894113063812,
-0.25661686062812805,
0.2002946138381958,
0.45882922410964966,
-0.9977630376815796,
0.6167561411857605,
0.5741127729415894,
0.7251166701316833,
0.04584452882409096,
-0.11437801271677017,
-0.33544763922691345,
-0.44565096497535706,
-0.4723539650440216,
0.5367333292961121,
-0.5101271271705627,
-0.46589359641075134,
0.06164058670401573,
-0.17040535807609558,
-0.23179076611995697,
-0.5795670747756958,
0.6464632153511047,
-0.37892842292785645,
0.04282763600349426,
-0.18441002070903778,
-0.559686005115509,
-0.08718810230493546,
0.004737124312669039,
-0.9156875014305115,
0.7966882586479187,
-0.20905235409736633,
-0.5423716306686401,
0.6238015294075012,
-0.35665860772132874,
-0.7379241585731506,
-0.03235586732625961,
-0.033353302627801895,
-0.7277718186378479,
0.5452500581741333,
0.1673065423965454,
0.9146865010261536,
-0.36957815289497375,
-0.07827956229448318,
-0.45306649804115295,
-0.5169152617454529,
0.2484566569328308,
-0.8710496425628662,
0.8419957160949707,
-0.04191991686820984,
-0.0784602165222168,
-0.13287247717380524,
-1.342174768447876,
-0.09252820163965225,
0.005715528037399054,
-0.7755663394927979,
-0.2724226713180542,
-0.21346794068813324,
0.34025365114212036,
-0.026381587609648705,
0.16777995228767395,
-0.8800052404403687,
0.19231918454170227,
-0.30331704020500183,
0.4809280037879944,
0.3210068941116333,
-0.3432386517524719,
0.6383742094039917,
-0.055194828659296036,
0.3557646870613098,
-0.32971471548080444,
-0.12077353149652481,
-0.19159048795700073,
-0.44111794233322144,
-0.833025336265564,
-0.3213544189929962,
0.6126657128334045,
0.355550080537796,
-0.41550567746162415,
0.24707436561584473,
-0.24249683320522308,
-0.5088751912117004,
-0.4125412404537201,
0.03491339087486267,
0.6746495366096497,
0.2963649034500122,
0.09291481971740723,
-0.4430045485496521,
-0.4093063175678253,
-0.7789648175239563,
-0.32354119420051575,
-0.28716379404067993,
-0.04220377653837204,
0.46421700716018677,
0.2552044689655304,
0.1950434446334839,
0.5437949895858765,
-0.18345101177692413,
-0.2221982777118683,
-0.3246413469314575,
0.46925896406173706,
0.2775217294692993,
0.18946844339370728,
0.4599117934703827,
-0.6077497005462646,
-0.6877732872962952,
0.12025436758995056,
-0.7696794271469116,
-0.14299018681049347,
-0.049709830433130264,
0.3690311312675476,
0.551243782043457,
0.7664297819137573,
-0.2502456307411194,
0.7341697812080383,
0.3719198703765869,
-0.21834293007850647,
0.38711270689964294,
-0.45095932483673096,
-0.15192469954490662,
-0.7147126197814941,
0.35865670442581177,
0.2128901183605194,
-0.016550466418266296,
-0.8843235373497009,
-0.08138280361890793,
0.5256524682044983,
-0.03120594657957554,
-0.19455891847610474,
0.5844462513923645,
-0.9817723035812378,
-0.41829779744148254,
-0.5755875110626221,
-0.3446974754333496,
0.0310905072838068,
0.4084881544113159,
0.3018229007720947,
0.8296228647232056,
0.39291632175445557,
-0.45459097623825073,
0.019922733306884766,
-0.009163533337414265,
-0.5194383859634399,
0.4833492636680603,
-0.4944303035736084,
0.33135178685188293,
-0.18663080036640167,
0.1863735467195511,
-1.1392393112182617,
-0.11674349009990692,
0.15078434348106384,
-0.4904833734035492,
0.7808547019958496,
-0.11073152720928192,
-0.47681859135627747,
-0.3887491822242737,
-0.1280360370874405,
0.2509154975414276,
0.36524656414985657,
-0.5783671140670776,
1.1550952196121216,
0.25244539976119995,
0.22037553787231445,
-0.4133859872817993,
-0.6487099528312683,
0.39543280005455017,
-0.048730019479990005,
-0.4569016695022583,
0.38509345054626465,
0.4102887809276581,
-0.18755702674388885,
-0.2826160788536072,
-0.13055473566055298,
-0.18752877414226532,
0.2824563682079315,
0.3391473591327667,
0.31339195370674133,
-0.30395326018333435,
-0.19834086298942566,
-0.3480069041252136,
-0.35590559244155884,
0.05510779470205307,
-0.2824919819831848,
0.3198621869087219,
-0.012819969095289707,
0.00900939479470253,
-0.9116101861000061,
0.15208803117275238,
0.8819689750671387,
-0.4287129044532776,
0.5626702308654785,
0.29712650179862976,
-0.3066210448741913,
-0.10913113504648209,
-0.39434435963630676,
0.11500110477209091,
-0.41355347633361816,
0.17970974743366241,
-0.5420057773590088,
-0.4611777067184448,
0.45050927996635437,
0.13318173587322235,
0.06898879259824753,
0.3828461766242981,
0.3002367913722992,
-0.18977750837802887,
0.36786749958992004,
0.5029692649841309,
-0.33922916650772095,
0.6646779775619507,
-0.21731147170066833,
0.3667532205581665,
-0.9199593663215637,
-0.02074177749454975,
-0.5278969407081604,
-0.4273713529109955,
-0.34002426266670227,
-0.1830786019563675,
0.06742209196090698,
-0.3452012240886688,
0.20703630149364471,
0.43150198459625244,
-0.1698429137468338,
0.6472384333610535,
0.6148753762245178,
0.09326711297035217,
0.11449339240789413,
-0.10512866079807281,
-0.18296274542808533,
0.32026076316833496,
-0.48567652702331543,
-0.7822901606559753,
1.6499321460723877,
0.47636616230010986,
0.5984459519386292,
-0.17742493748664856,
0.8448936343193054,
-0.028172414749860764,
0.34167495369911194,
-0.7475346922874451,
0.6529722213745117,
-0.930853545665741,
-0.30682703852653503,
-0.2098631113767624,
-0.15909327566623688,
-0.8382498621940613,
0.24272452294826508,
-0.23658375442028046,
-0.3342894911766052,
0.6046633720397949,
-0.059210434556007385,
-0.7187516093254089,
0.4723562002182007,
-0.5711144804954529,
0.5276983380317688,
-0.2774219810962677,
-0.3157815933227539,
0.4141855835914612,
-0.49432194232940674,
0.15102213621139526,
0.20205406844615936,
-0.13940300047397614,
0.10933570563793182,
-0.05246204882860184,
0.6020092964172363,
-0.3255615532398224,
1.1028556823730469,
-0.16793261468410492,
-0.4637899100780487,
0.30116865038871765,
-0.0814896747469902,
0.5021610260009766,
-0.40893131494522095,
-0.29217320680618286,
0.3429548442363739,
-0.41878244280815125,
0.03642313927412033,
-0.4891670346260071,
0.5282381176948547,
-0.6666268706321716,
-0.08490069210529327,
-0.2571532130241394,
-0.3808116018772125,
0.1171921044588089,
0.255597323179245,
0.24768191576004028,
0.9921073317527771,
-0.20989049971103668,
0.1828984022140503,
0.5016626119613647,
-0.01862417720258236,
0.817191481590271,
0.2396264523267746,
0.07427028566598892,
-0.5406583547592163,
0.8060760498046875,
0.5487672090530396,
0.25318676233291626,
0.2937162518501282,
0.05097188428044319,
-0.2372586727142334,
-0.9852405786514282,
-0.6704889535903931,
0.04379287362098694,
-0.7269883155822754,
0.1621917486190796,
-0.8778294920921326,
-0.2041500359773636,
-0.2751021087169647,
-0.10919047892093658,
0.05470690503716469,
-0.4223390519618988,
-0.7330603003501892,
-0.055154066532850266,
-0.04300215095281601,
0.8056997060775757,
0.18242000043392181,
0.41851431131362915,
-0.6468904614448547,
0.28668639063835144,
0.1799146831035614,
0.4599619507789612,
0.35383111238479614,
-0.22200943529605865,
-0.061080459505319595,
-0.36436089873313904,
0.0953737422823906,
-0.8251919746398926,
0.0801127701997757,
0.19627399742603302,
0.5427701473236084,
0.3858090341091156,
-0.41279107332229614,
0.2999785840511322,
-0.4819823205471039,
0.30460062623023987,
-0.02909410186111927,
-0.738898754119873,
-0.20377567410469055,
-0.6793599128723145,
0.15846650302410126,
0.6910088658332825,
0.04675789922475815,
-0.36801013350486755,
-0.06428109854459763,
-0.4031168818473816,
-0.6307812929153442,
0.597467303276062,
0.12212517857551575,
0.16881439089775085,
0.19184261560440063,
0.5497226119041443,
0.1567193567752838,
0.13210676610469818,
-0.6665567755699158,
0.014102492481470108,
0.11367109417915344,
-0.641801118850708,
-0.06932223588228226,
-0.39425182342529297,
0.5954217910766602,
-0.23177751898765564,
0.41300085186958313,
-0.04513561725616455,
0.21522516012191772,
0.01968398690223694,
-0.09117769449949265,
0.18970777094364166,
-0.1154230535030365,
0.4895326793193817,
0.1669985055923462,
-0.10180442780256271,
-0.08869238197803497,
-0.08020586520433426,
-0.7743070125579834,
0.292411744594574,
0.1363828182220459,
-0.35024747252464294,
-0.0388483852148056,
0.7765502333641052,
0.9549936056137085,
0.2780255675315857,
-0.13768532872200012,
0.4207956790924072,
-0.06959197670221329,
-0.6460448503494263,
-0.2996624708175659,
0.16513691842556,
-0.015444551594555378,
0.20686383545398712,
0.0815187618136406,
-0.015681147575378418,
0.2910284101963043,
-0.5011309385299683,
0.06613560765981674,
0.6431721448898315,
-0.008471757173538208,
-0.12578226625919342,
0.47470325231552124,
0.2244197428226471,
-0.6358819007873535,
0.6388819217681885,
0.13332833349704742,
-0.4838043451309204,
0.9275608062744141,
0.4358487129211426,
1.153010368347168,
-0.08953024446964264,
0.13894027471542358,
0.34174391627311707,
0.1315455585718155,
-0.09350374341011047,
0.27093926072120667,
-0.289171427488327,
-0.5853105187416077,
0.06251689046621323,
-0.6290621757507324,
-0.3765840232372284,
-0.02957548014819622,
-0.44942548871040344,
0.2559393644332886,
-0.9620981216430664,
-0.28523221611976624,
0.30465933680534363,
0.08739058673381805,
-0.47726917266845703,
0.4423660933971405,
0.49610191583633423,
0.6492174863815308,
-0.859446108341217,
0.8010632991790771,
0.3583180010318756,
-0.38647526502609253,
-0.569282591342926,
0.2691642642021179,
0.06315262615680695,
-0.5941970944404602,
0.6286807656288147,
0.5002517104148865,
-0.26586368680000305,
0.0638638511300087,
-0.03325721248984337,
-0.9910847544670105,
0.9233298897743225,
-0.030833853408694267,
-0.6316429972648621,
-0.1865512877702713,
0.215374156832695,
0.830700159072876,
-0.27676624059677124,
0.3995039165019989,
0.5975919961929321,
0.4122614860534668,
0.1072453111410141,
-0.8727569580078125,
-0.2196549028158188,
-0.4955575466156006,
0.05956730246543884,
0.6355916261672974,
-0.40609341859817505,
1.1447882652282715,
0.05213062837719917,
-0.4017104208469391,
0.5321251153945923,
0.6628098487854004,
-0.17427760362625122,
0.3235832154750824,
0.25742825865745544,
0.7618023753166199,
0.8575516939163208,
-0.024147622287273407,
1.181395173072815,
0.0207695122808218,
-0.3698076009750366,
0.8594094514846802,
-0.4526129364967346,
0.947492778301239,
0.25366759300231934,
-0.23220868408679962,
0.5663096904754639,
0.21036580204963684,
-0.15992780029773712,
0.23876690864562988,
0.5255837440490723,
-0.29088184237480164,
-0.028642721474170685,
0.26468634605407715,
0.04713401198387146,
0.5317511558532715,
0.0026490893214941025,
-0.7462587952613831,
-0.3082740604877472,
0.10009527951478958,
0.21145747601985931,
0.2025388479232788,
-0.4220520555973053,
0.9545505046844482,
-0.05677558854222298,
-0.544877290725708,
0.34794381260871887,
0.3120463192462921,
0.9112534523010254,
-0.3189733624458313,
0.08643286675214767,
-0.2779827117919922,
0.5241104364395142,
-0.200482577085495,
-0.3452436923980713,
0.24984776973724365,
0.07557954639196396,
-0.23547551035881042,
-0.2608347237110138,
0.9980605244636536,
-0.3627420663833618,
-1.04972505569458,
0.237684428691864,
0.048716384917497635,
0.10151860117912292,
0.028722772374749184,
-0.20445284247398376,
-0.10667368769645691,
-0.36993807554244995,
-0.018749652430415154,
0.3301067352294922,
0.2934235632419586,
-0.07345443218946457,
0.15208099782466888,
0.9082633256912231,
-0.017511658370494843,
0.36073780059814453,
-0.03492420166730881,
0.6158626675605774,
-0.34706053137779236,
-0.5269729495048523,
-0.9939425587654114,
0.3566674292087555,
-0.16447336971759796,
-0.4152984917163849,
0.7873034477233887,
0.4171139597892761,
0.48465821146965027,
0.06344062834978104,
0.791742205619812,
0.31778353452682495,
0.4252146780490875,
-0.7683050036430359,
1.0443276166915894,
-0.5391970872879028,
-0.09715487062931061,
-0.4982592463493347,
-0.7991740107536316,
-0.7100624442100525,
0.7609270811080933,
-0.5271776914596558,
0.2533257007598877,
0.48144033551216125,
0.501430332660675,
-0.05182893946766853,
0.2640227973461151,
0.1678200215101242,
-0.2968161106109619,
0.34477442502975464,
0.6850307583808899,
0.5496789813041687,
-0.7167355418205261,
0.14011941850185394,
0.032027918845415115,
-0.14671292901039124,
-0.19651924073696136,
-0.9527806043624878,
-1.135776400566101,
-0.4881362318992615,
-0.18242256343364716,
-0.10572346299886703,
-0.10485823452472687,
0.49010926485061646,
0.35509684681892395,
-0.4576725959777832,
-0.33188286423683167,
-0.35828033089637756,
-0.3716138005256653,
0.03846651688218117,
-0.01791168749332428,
0.518757700920105,
-0.056917790323495865,
-0.7865408062934875,
0.43641015887260437,
0.19115975499153137,
0.4568175971508026,
-0.13599756360054016,
0.028999490663409233,
-0.06307712197303772,
0.17572124302387238,
0.23629577457904816,
0.3530706763267517,
-0.6424958109855652,
0.4066890478134155,
0.18824414908885956,
-0.28045597672462463,
0.08500504493713379,
1.0631002187728882,
-0.6260177493095398,
0.22876572608947754,
0.6195840239524841,
0.9539556503295898,
0.31286463141441345,
-0.15078935027122498,
0.5757607817649841,
-0.27939578890800476,
-0.013626866973936558,
0.1287558674812317,
0.4634508490562439,
0.41383376717567444,
-0.3620718717575073,
0.2859833240509033,
0.1410771757364273,
-0.20852512121200562,
-0.8344713449478149,
0.04003359004855156,
-0.3412860929965973,
-0.20058520138263702,
1.0096129179000854,
-0.3180701732635498,
-0.3297254145145416,
-0.15651346743106842,
-0.2531835734844208,
0.19813282787799835,
-0.045132290571928024,
0.4278525710105896,
1.0086939334869385,
0.20639240741729736,
-0.32501065731048584,
-0.30552399158477783,
0.4831453263759613,
0.38762712478637695,
-0.7058400511741638,
0.35438475012779236,
0.7228271961212158,
0.04033137485384941,
0.11214099079370499,
0.9214422702789307,
-0.19788858294487,
0.20020829141139984,
0.08743004500865936,
0.05899987742304802,
-0.6055930256843567,
-0.9122714400291443,
-0.7515577077865601,
0.3484205901622772,
-0.09745451807975769,
-0.2990991473197937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19316v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19316v1
|
QLSC: A Query Latent Semantic Calibrator for Robust Extractive Question Answering
| 2024-04-30T07:34:42 | 2024-04-30T07:34:42 |
Sheng Ouyang, Jianzong Wang, Yong Zhang, Zhitao Li, Ziqi Liang, Xulong Zhang, Ning Cheng, Jing Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Extractive Question Answering (EQA) in Machine Reading Comprehension (MRC)
often faces the challenge of dealing with semantically identical but
format-variant inputs. Our work introduces a novel approach, called the ``Query
Latent Semantic Calibrator (QLSC)'', designed as an auxiliary module for
existing MRC models. We propose a unique scaling strategy to capture latent
semantic center features of queries. These features are then seamlessly
integrated into traditional query and passage embeddings using an attention
mechanism. By deepening the comprehension of the semantic queries-passage
relationship, our approach diminishes sensitivity to variations in text format
and boosts the model's capability in pinpointing accurate answers. Experimental
results on robust Question-Answer datasets confirm that our approach
effectively handles format-variant but semantically identical queries,
highlighting the effectiveness and adaptability of our proposed method.
|
[
-0.159086674451828,
-0.6796228885650635,
0.5232064723968506,
-0.21026895940303802,
-0.3344349265098572,
-0.038103796541690826,
0.1735629141330719,
-0.08830031752586365,
0.1462072730064392,
0.6731554865837097,
-0.8941759467124939,
-0.38248080015182495,
-0.4903663694858551,
0.08920934051275253,
-0.157621830701828,
0.9320123791694641,
0.08594685792922974,
0.015451125800609589,
-0.5026730895042419,
-0.4948970079421997,
-0.2359561026096344,
-0.3023636043071747,
-0.486492782831192,
0.13263611495494843,
0.7562716603279114,
0.3117879331111908,
0.8283780217170715,
0.41717806458473206,
0.6070650219917297,
0.18126924335956573,
-0.1752931922674179,
0.4621250629425049,
-0.3482452630996704,
0.43105876445770264,
-0.16975204646587372,
-0.8689913749694824,
-0.48715224862098694,
-0.017517730593681335,
0.7691011428833008,
0.6717838048934937,
-0.2539174258708954,
0.21520760655403137,
0.0689534991979599,
0.7057790756225586,
-0.8479049801826477,
-0.17218132317066193,
-0.7744435667991638,
0.04495476931333542,
0.2854137420654297,
-0.47680792212486267,
-0.6189891695976257,
-0.29046931862831116,
0.10318724066019058,
-0.6935822367668152,
0.15993545949459076,
0.03580336272716522,
0.6748761534690857,
0.784432590007782,
-0.605316162109375,
-0.284234881401062,
-0.42481765151023865,
0.9621332287788391,
-0.6250918507575989,
0.4740542769432068,
0.6945516467094421,
0.6817141175270081,
0.24467606842517853,
-0.9454010128974915,
-0.45961546897888184,
-0.0278763584792614,
-0.19283179938793182,
0.33915287256240845,
0.1721443384885788,
-0.2736333906650543,
0.2245960831642151,
0.24672041833400726,
-0.9566556811332703,
-0.33073803782463074,
-0.19891156256198883,
-0.2953566312789917,
0.2091064602136612,
0.45717087388038635,
0.2562717795372009,
-0.04274071007966995,
-0.1369059532880783,
-0.16744735836982727,
-0.617992103099823,
0.20562875270843506,
0.14040391147136688,
0.3370421826839447,
0.19333013892173767,
0.6570934057235718,
-0.3188849985599518,
0.9461446404457092,
0.03638266772031784,
0.11983834207057953,
-0.06318299472332001,
-0.4933640658855438,
-0.027046263217926025,
-0.12656041979789734,
0.30546101927757263,
0.16992083191871643,
-0.08981277793645859,
-0.22884409129619598,
-0.3106059432029724,
-0.4267762303352356,
0.587066650390625,
-0.9429556727409363,
-0.4134909212589264,
0.3003076910972595,
-0.2947683334350586,
-0.27767446637153625,
0.2191716879606247,
-0.546612024307251,
0.05258539691567421,
-0.18059103190898895,
0.5098746418952942,
-0.08450634032487869,
0.1397814303636551,
-0.10735074430704117,
-0.021198030561208725,
0.7730116844177246,
0.358893483877182,
-0.7733179926872253,
0.25255846977233887,
0.5408974289894104,
0.5915362238883972,
-0.13256670534610748,
0.19128407537937164,
-1.0186375379562378,
0.11000005155801773,
-0.29161155223846436,
0.8795259594917297,
-0.6285901069641113,
-0.18152308464050293,
-0.1623716950416565,
0.32825198769569397,
-0.11885420978069305,
-0.3421742618083954,
0.5837432146072388,
-1.3721723556518555,
0.545526385307312,
-0.1840813308954239,
-0.40678706765174866,
0.15181148052215576,
0.6712851524353027,
-0.838078498840332,
1.099037766456604,
0.29958850145339966,
-1.020543098449707,
0.04635476693511009,
-0.21127623319625854,
-0.12627378106117249,
0.04023565724492073,
-0.030406685546040535,
-0.4393301010131836,
-0.2553716003894806,
0.5548322200775146,
-0.04335949569940567,
-0.16267836093902588,
-0.27962201833724976,
-0.13664494454860687,
-0.2242473065853119,
0.6467761397361755,
-0.4594082236289978,
0.7289041876792908,
0.34241244196891785,
0.01844615302979946,
0.2595657706260681,
-0.6864150762557983,
0.7008122801780701,
0.06663169711828232,
-0.22617463767528534,
-0.2686297297477722,
0.03170621395111084,
-0.22136810421943665,
0.10819314420223236,
0.42834940552711487,
-0.4666294455528259,
-0.2483810931444168,
-0.586333692073822,
0.5122160911560059,
0.38481447100639343,
0.1841658055782318,
0.6398468017578125,
-0.32893308997154236,
0.6373843550682068,
-0.11928335577249527,
0.11448782682418823,
-0.3245551586151123,
-0.23453648388385773,
-0.4794204533100128,
-0.23900644481182098,
0.33540287613868713,
0.6201336979866028,
-0.8059017062187195,
0.43240198493003845,
-0.05476375296711922,
-0.5319387316703796,
-0.6445737481117249,
-0.16326990723609924,
0.23657220602035522,
0.7207514643669128,
0.5021347999572754,
-0.024643342941999435,
-0.01841876655817032,
-0.6498180031776428,
-0.49645641446113586,
-0.11831420660018921,
-0.2807786762714386,
0.48923930525779724,
0.0866791233420372,
0.385143905878067,
1.0868643522262573,
-0.7390584349632263,
-0.031162012368440628,
-0.032270126044750214,
-0.16594000160694122,
-0.021991869434714317,
0.40941122174263,
0.3020205497741699,
-1.250656247138977,
-0.48205095529556274,
-0.23286451399326324,
-0.4946686029434204,
-0.12181040644645691,
0.019037574529647827,
-0.5315367579460144,
0.006446809507906437,
0.7917476296424866,
-0.25106558203697205,
0.347118079662323,
0.36136966943740845,
-0.49849367141723633,
0.41027072072029114,
-0.17108681797981262,
0.2701750099658966,
-1.0746465921401978,
0.23015344142913818,
-0.44223904609680176,
-0.39016827940940857,
-0.4171030819416046,
0.43653884530067444,
0.6130664348602295,
0.016768228262662888,
-0.5538517832756042,
0.34278392791748047,
-0.23914529383182526,
-0.06578102707862854,
-0.034195080399513245,
0.5651382803916931,
0.7337920069694519,
0.2553861737251282,
-0.2735576927661896,
0.8612973093986511,
0.013885694555938244,
-0.44903746247291565,
0.3144975006580353,
0.2914268672466278,
0.11273447424173355,
0.6270149946212769,
-0.9232021570205688,
0.5041266679763794,
-0.1338234394788742,
0.28491297364234924,
-1.3790470361709595,
0.024368373677134514,
0.07390914112329483,
-0.7745846509933472,
0.2406909167766571,
-0.13134637475013733,
-0.3735078275203705,
-0.17894554138183594,
-0.34323635697364807,
0.4639764726161957,
0.2326992005109787,
-0.4550471603870392,
0.8524684906005859,
0.038198549300432205,
-0.2426227629184723,
-0.5896803736686707,
-0.9581814408302307,
-0.34237775206565857,
-0.017712490633130074,
-0.6471976041793823,
0.217912957072258,
-0.2577497661113739,
0.20605920255184174,
-0.01817900687456131,
-0.2702483534812927,
-0.33484163880348206,
0.16948136687278748,
-0.131697416305542,
0.4087936580181122,
-0.6041328310966492,
0.15729187428951263,
0.4696904420852661,
-0.050058797001838684,
0.0004761276941280812,
-0.42940714955329895,
0.38628721237182617,
-0.008397651836276054,
-0.35273557901382446,
-0.38538065552711487,
0.5604871511459351,
0.5471115112304688,
-0.9090557098388672,
0.8742223381996155,
0.44653111696243286,
-0.26261085271835327,
0.015784742310643196,
-0.23567278683185577,
-0.5050097107887268,
-0.4485773742198944,
0.49599775671958923,
-0.7206822633743286,
-0.975631594657898,
0.5673032402992249,
0.31380337476730347,
0.129476398229599,
0.5209906101226807,
0.41785553097724915,
-0.12702862918376923,
1.1684300899505615,
0.42135971784591675,
0.6418270468711853,
0.3210391402244568,
0.11696278303861618,
0.1451646238565445,
-1.026584267616272,
-0.3146863877773285,
-0.8377324342727661,
-0.06905920803546906,
-0.33672282099723816,
-0.5691878795623779,
0.25130221247673035,
0.13206921517848969,
-0.23524758219718933,
0.10010189563035965,
-0.577583372592926,
0.4069325029850006,
0.10266033560037613,
0.21960704028606415,
0.42325806617736816,
-0.04459540918469429,
-0.22865302860736847,
-0.4222835898399353,
-0.43439966440200806,
-0.6801880598068237,
1.1375535726547241,
0.14710916578769684,
0.7507591843605042,
0.5067175626754761,
0.4692724645137787,
0.07813710719347,
0.10969946533441544,
-0.7155176401138306,
0.17749282717704773,
-0.11058899015188217,
-0.6694353222846985,
-0.588070809841156,
-0.5156333446502686,
-0.6878467202186584,
0.5382237434387207,
-0.07327449321746826,
-0.5916351675987244,
0.0797988623380661,
-0.11900471150875092,
-0.5747621655464172,
0.06748846918344498,
-0.7490670680999756,
1.094467043876648,
-0.018493182957172394,
-0.5108993053436279,
0.02195206843316555,
-0.8912615776062012,
-0.24068009853363037,
-0.13585014641284943,
-0.12153524905443192,
0.036493562161922455,
-0.5192393660545349,
0.5947556495666504,
-0.2022876739501953,
0.5718790292739868,
-0.08612814545631409,
0.047562748193740845,
0.5012872219085693,
0.26536694169044495,
0.5542361736297607,
0.15794901549816132,
-0.3010345995426178,
-0.6977208852767944,
0.6796486377716064,
-0.8298048973083496,
-1.054046630859375,
0.4684012234210968,
-0.7783200144767761,
-0.5124689936637878,
-0.1657107025384903,
-0.6323437094688416,
-0.47901788353919983,
0.1375194489955902,
-0.1002369374036789,
0.47505828738212585,
-0.3363189101219177,
0.32856953144073486,
0.7455081939697266,
0.036353714764118195,
0.14833594858646393,
0.6447699069976807,
0.08513756096363068,
-0.44556310772895813,
0.634617805480957,
-0.06155221536755562,
0.6374889016151428,
0.6791070699691772,
0.13704968988895416,
-0.6456369161605835,
-0.313959002494812,
-0.5863115787506104,
0.16348597407341003,
-0.8377406001091003,
-0.21945051848888397,
-0.9906603097915649,
-0.29142627120018005,
-0.6150156855583191,
0.09191624075174332,
-0.15112870931625366,
-0.5163553953170776,
-0.4853542149066925,
0.06236192211508751,
0.21256449818611145,
0.24974675476551056,
0.3508947193622589,
0.4034713804721832,
-0.9155896306037903,
0.15520942211151123,
0.5690252184867859,
-0.040616054087877274,
-0.20645922422409058,
-1.0818097591400146,
-0.08938048779964447,
-0.06108745560050011,
-0.3467922508716583,
-0.8579843044281006,
0.3921825885772705,
0.338925302028656,
0.5110600590705872,
0.15096861124038696,
0.5855046510696411,
0.3507165014743805,
-0.14665855467319489,
0.8805985450744629,
-0.10138797014951706,
-0.4688960611820221,
0.6252943873405457,
-0.013404344208538532,
0.6385168433189392,
0.8826567530632019,
0.4512907564640045,
-0.4020576775074005,
-0.2990298867225647,
-0.39283081889152527,
-0.6957226395606995,
0.4965517818927765,
0.007491712924093008,
0.17259518802165985,
0.23099973797798157,
0.5764000415802002,
0.07865668088197708,
-0.011930761858820915,
-0.26051729917526245,
-0.020462626591324806,
-0.2540603280067444,
-0.560735285282135,
0.09710093587636948,
-0.2736039161682129,
-0.15598054230213165,
0.10567200183868408,
0.38713088631629944,
-0.5915520787239075,
-0.0477176308631897,
0.6265575885772705,
-0.29673343896865845,
0.07171210646629333,
0.30848491191864014,
0.2116512805223465,
0.49484267830848694,
-0.30203717947006226,
0.3705783486366272,
0.046848684549331665,
-0.7384522557258606,
-0.20893068611621857,
0.2410234957933426,
-0.2790496349334717,
-0.3823578953742981,
0.23806536197662354,
0.3233846127986908,
-0.04408584535121918,
-0.6950106024742126,
0.4704740345478058,
-0.5146262049674988,
-0.05265803635120392,
-0.03167227283120155,
-0.02314024791121483,
0.12913115322589874,
0.25086432695388794,
0.4222725033760071,
-0.18075256049633026,
0.20693397521972656,
-0.2744136452674866,
0.5393106937408447,
0.19049730896949768,
-0.9249871373176575,
-0.007134023122489452,
0.5579306483268738,
0.03510797396302223,
-0.15327303111553192,
0.7773754000663757,
-0.18689751625061035,
-0.5910170674324036,
0.7383236885070801,
0.4666619300842285,
0.5008420348167419,
-0.17726720869541168,
0.17913182079792023,
0.4330331087112427,
0.3509359359741211,
0.5264783501625061,
0.36928805708885193,
-0.4776903986930847,
-0.5462256669998169,
-0.38616642355918884,
-0.591549813747406,
-0.3853464126586914,
-0.5351890921592712,
-0.960413932800293,
-0.03897031396627426,
-0.31541067361831665,
0.05702734366059303,
-0.08715178072452545,
0.25279510021209717,
-0.4098506271839142,
0.34289854764938354,
-0.16965147852897644,
0.7986270189285278,
-0.6163986921310425,
0.8533971905708313,
0.7800275683403015,
-0.5161613821983337,
-1.0910749435424805,
0.1671115905046463,
-0.1940656304359436,
-0.47972041368484497,
0.278628408908844,
0.0565418004989624,
-0.14976541697978973,
0.27184441685676575,
-0.4434009790420532,
-0.9064939022064209,
1.1501644849777222,
0.035183824598789215,
-0.21353866159915924,
0.035021401941776276,
0.16286946833133698,
0.4558979272842407,
-0.630332350730896,
0.6085940003395081,
0.6540552377700806,
0.26212602853775024,
0.5532611608505249,
-0.4919261634349823,
0.20106175541877747,
-0.07120618224143982,
-0.2272387593984604,
-0.018756911158561707,
-0.3814316391944885,
0.6607702970504761,
-0.34107452630996704,
-0.12284042686223984,
0.3288573622703552,
0.827731728553772,
0.24925753474235535,
0.32236573100090027,
0.49899306893348694,
0.37525105476379395,
0.9179713129997253,
-0.045653946697711945,
0.9047931432723999,
-0.18996137380599976,
0.3638163208961487,
1.4024285078048706,
-0.17134393751621246,
1.15749990940094,
0.6838678121566772,
-0.26418212056159973,
0.44940027594566345,
0.8240613341331482,
0.31323593854904175,
0.679361879825592,
0.13017182052135468,
-0.19139397144317627,
-0.4836524426937103,
-0.06317969411611557,
-0.1526389867067337,
0.2517739534378052,
0.4649157226085663,
-0.1925252228975296,
-0.16185089945793152,
-0.3692795932292938,
-0.30565711855888367,
0.3028510808944702,
-0.08619225770235062,
0.8213809132575989,
0.017881810665130615,
-0.7155550122261047,
0.4403311312198639,
-0.09962642937898636,
0.17463713884353638,
-0.5302730202674866,
0.05002595856785774,
-0.3838411271572113,
0.15987184643745422,
-0.34290316700935364,
-0.8949221968650818,
0.6250573992729187,
-0.20628425478935242,
-0.30087047815322876,
0.27430933713912964,
0.49383530020713806,
-0.47475382685661316,
-0.28860318660736084,
-0.022169524803757668,
0.6805441975593567,
0.21234004199504852,
-0.4062500596046448,
-0.7492343187332153,
-0.15212231874465942,
0.15105733275413513,
-0.1544111669063568,
0.24416963756084442,
0.7372792363166809,
0.04192822054028511,
0.34601572155952454,
0.5730303525924683,
-0.2965620160102844,
0.3666839897632599,
0.21590958535671234,
0.971388578414917,
-0.6779497861862183,
-0.6467458009719849,
-0.2663383483886719,
0.5238727927207947,
-0.1442188024520874,
-0.3358936905860901,
0.3024575412273407,
0.4456406235694885,
0.3028298020362854,
0.2589336931705475,
0.15160517394542694,
0.15381066501140594,
0.5546439290046692,
-0.3953673839569092,
0.8367416262626648,
-0.8517629504203796,
0.16758650541305542,
0.18684034049510956,
-1.0707322359085083,
-0.38637158274650574,
0.45512282848358154,
-0.3211502432823181,
-0.029660603031516075,
0.9784704446792603,
1.1251546144485474,
0.14011238515377045,
0.14336352050304413,
0.49752867221832275,
-0.03968490660190582,
0.3788743019104004,
0.47618454694747925,
0.7605541944503784,
-0.6468600630760193,
1.0314770936965942,
0.09448917210102081,
-0.34160616993904114,
-0.08405663073062897,
-0.4993904232978821,
-0.7213567495346069,
-0.5585853457450867,
-0.32623010873794556,
-0.5714235901832581,
0.035796888172626495,
0.3329465687274933,
0.5647334456443787,
-0.7891091704368591,
0.3936474621295929,
0.2612570524215698,
0.14140093326568604,
-0.016478968784213066,
-0.2776459753513336,
0.625947892665863,
-0.49505603313446045,
-0.6197026371955872,
0.06122186407446861,
0.2032935470342636,
-0.11104360967874527,
-0.40967074036598206,
0.01994929276406765,
-0.20480580627918243,
0.1952236443758011,
0.4588892161846161,
0.06068241596221924,
-0.5891640186309814,
-0.1783328503370285,
0.5476532578468323,
-0.598054826259613,
0.061543095856904984,
0.7637730836868286,
-0.7675282955169678,
0.6396359205245972,
0.622228741645813,
0.9633858799934387,
0.5642803907394409,
0.0835108533501625,
0.19917917251586914,
-0.6500173211097717,
0.09094018489122391,
0.6093206405639648,
-0.18055149912834167,
0.3742402195930481,
-0.35818591713905334,
0.27297890186309814,
0.011145679280161858,
-0.5349698066711426,
-0.5383733510971069,
0.286424458026886,
-1.2114636898040771,
-0.24691179394721985,
0.8013614416122437,
-0.37873074412345886,
-0.6340911388397217,
-0.13044431805610657,
-0.2524760961532593,
0.15116675198078156,
-0.2988841235637665,
0.3162139356136322,
0.49426159262657166,
0.14764612913131714,
-0.3701106309890747,
-0.5580929517745972,
0.09532492607831955,
0.7713925242424011,
-0.5800507068634033,
0.06476917862892151,
0.27184194326400757,
0.1458698958158493,
0.03234441950917244,
0.30121204257011414,
-0.6357729434967041,
0.2634441554546356,
0.13470105826854706,
-0.31299474835395813,
0.19458939135074615,
-0.02700796350836754,
-0.3209400773048401,
0.37344151735305786,
0.2002551257610321,
-0.16913223266601562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19315v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19315v1
|
Modeling Orthographic Variation in Occitan's Dialects
| 2024-04-30T07:33:51 | 2024-04-30T07:33:51 |
Zachary William Hopton, Noëmi Aepli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Effectively normalizing textual data poses a considerable challenge,
especially for low-resource languages lacking standardized writing systems. In
this study, we fine-tuned a multilingual model with data from several Occitan
dialects and conducted a series of experiments to assess the model's
representations of these dialects. For evaluation purposes, we compiled a
parallel lexicon encompassing four Occitan dialects. Intrinsic evaluations of
the model's embeddings revealed that surface similarity between the dialects
strengthened representations. When the model was further fine-tuned for
part-of-speech tagging and Universal Dependency parsing, its performance was
robust to dialectical variation, even when trained solely on part-of-speech
data from a single dialect. Our findings suggest that large multilingual models
minimize the need for spelling normalization during pre-processing.
|
[
-0.3264980614185333,
-0.4330158233642578,
0.40763023495674133,
-0.1319548636674881,
-0.15383726358413696,
-0.3966817557811737,
-0.6262531280517578,
-0.7019888758659363,
0.35257911682128906,
0.5754268169403076,
-0.22632430493831635,
-0.7249823212623596,
-0.3522176146507263,
0.15798814594745636,
0.22120898962020874,
0.7239311337471008,
0.019780917093157768,
0.2812732756137848,
0.466930627822876,
-0.5189088582992554,
-0.2866358160972595,
-0.6771396398544312,
-0.2811844050884247,
-0.2799608111381531,
0.7111623287200928,
0.7106953263282776,
0.7246229648590088,
0.9481112360954285,
0.33052217960357666,
0.2923600971698761,
-0.3291883170604706,
0.18195627629756927,
-0.5400274991989136,
0.2991534173488617,
-0.2931778132915497,
-0.7579716444015503,
-0.4691803753376007,
-0.15462851524353027,
0.6834399104118347,
1.1023143529891968,
-0.34830522537231445,
0.0029897838830947876,
-0.11248667538166046,
0.3526729941368103,
-0.682011067867279,
0.16721279919147491,
-0.46127849817276,
-0.21064937114715576,
-0.59324049949646,
0.3243838846683502,
-0.16099998354911804,
-0.240947887301445,
0.05243074893951416,
-0.502996563911438,
0.33455395698547363,
-0.05789965018630028,
0.828789472579956,
-0.28723961114883423,
-0.40041786432266235,
-0.09429853409528732,
-0.6657449007034302,
0.7359039783477783,
-0.9000547528266907,
0.4535445272922516,
0.38382285833358765,
0.25961461663246155,
0.0928921028971672,
-0.3934324383735657,
-0.31343260407447815,
-0.5384818315505981,
-0.14536835253238678,
-0.0019508436089381576,
0.3660930395126343,
0.21057464182376862,
0.23326490819454193,
0.38721463084220886,
-0.4245370328426361,
0.2806079685688019,
-0.3002434968948364,
0.21000142395496368,
0.46498188376426697,
0.25485682487487793,
0.28643327951431274,
-0.42069151997566223,
0.08956894278526306,
-0.16856098175048828,
-0.5987111330032349,
0.09846632182598114,
0.8117063045501709,
0.9342651963233948,
-0.020895864814519882,
0.8100172281265259,
-0.4141131341457367,
0.7449257969856262,
-0.14645200967788696,
-0.2360193282365799,
0.0580049604177475,
-0.3579743802547455,
-0.35821953415870667,
-0.24581778049468994,
0.652032732963562,
0.00594131276011467,
0.22708892822265625,
0.07535295933485031,
-0.20351934432983398,
0.022481467574834824,
0.0017839900683611631,
-0.658998966217041,
-0.3751242160797119,
-0.2478475570678711,
-0.2307416796684265,
0.04475634545087814,
0.3701007068157196,
-0.7571549415588379,
-0.6801002025604248,
-0.3336145877838135,
-0.01946723274886608,
-0.783759355545044,
-0.3330973982810974,
0.4734589755535126,
-0.1758051961660385,
-0.2087021768093109,
0.25936129689216614,
-1.1469357013702393,
0.3548884391784668,
0.44303345680236816,
0.7776861190795898,
0.003876898903399706,
-0.45077767968177795,
-0.14974279701709747,
0.008923479355871677,
-0.37721168994903564,
0.6787531971931458,
-0.7232505679130554,
-0.3887629210948944,
0.04268969967961311,
-0.01614995114505291,
-0.35832101106643677,
-0.5683428645133972,
0.42207345366477966,
-0.07806215435266495,
-0.07854922115802765,
-0.27536922693252563,
-0.3805786073207855,
-0.25159749388694763,
0.08285073190927505,
-0.9684696197509766,
0.838237464427948,
0.17457492649555206,
-0.6918642520904541,
0.39180511236190796,
-0.330653578042984,
-0.4087045192718506,
-0.27958944439888,
-0.321605920791626,
-0.24230371415615082,
0.6238511800765991,
0.2148696482181549,
0.29941681027412415,
-0.3442704677581787,
0.045241829007864,
-0.39638471603393555,
-0.09498290717601776,
0.06645216047763824,
-0.24844865500926971,
0.8886899948120117,
-0.04914422333240509,
-0.22691726684570312,
-0.13309302926063538,
-0.8782094120979309,
-0.18155406415462494,
-0.07010726630687714,
-0.34860318899154663,
-0.6028751134872437,
0.018527576699852943,
0.36171773076057434,
-0.2546134889125824,
-0.013842019252479076,
-0.8336147665977478,
0.46027761697769165,
-0.6728141903877258,
0.6177626252174377,
0.32269376516342163,
-0.35587412118911743,
0.42275214195251465,
-0.5919249057769775,
0.512304425239563,
0.026217881590127945,
-0.11497531086206436,
-0.2794613540172577,
-0.38257279992103577,
-1.0376496315002441,
-0.5455034971237183,
0.5136622786521912,
0.25747236609458923,
-0.3018030822277069,
0.11341676861047745,
-0.44994741678237915,
-0.6796748042106628,
-0.47077131271362305,
-0.07245456427335739,
0.25015515089035034,
0.13327407836914062,
0.23259171843528748,
-0.5595208406448364,
-0.3032737970352173,
-0.7592136859893799,
-0.303650438785553,
-0.052146706730127335,
0.058072444051504135,
0.15004828572273254,
0.09973948448896408,
0.05128313601016998,
0.7963889837265015,
-0.3421969413757324,
-0.38399457931518555,
-0.35228684544563293,
0.4086942672729492,
0.2677604854106903,
0.46035632491111755,
0.8384517431259155,
-0.5232528448104858,
-0.7042117714881897,
0.513224720954895,
-0.19243082404136658,
-0.038338612765073776,
0.12858925759792328,
0.09838256239891052,
0.26760420203208923,
0.5641805529594421,
-0.44736164808273315,
0.7202733755111694,
0.348941445350647,
-0.1080624908208847,
0.6297895908355713,
-0.3682655096054077,
0.19753561913967133,
-0.8559997081756592,
0.1776667833328247,
-0.27841097116470337,
-0.24670355021953583,
-0.8457760214805603,
0.40488308668136597,
0.2233441323041916,
-0.2778467833995819,
-0.23289816081523895,
0.3002021610736847,
-0.539959728717804,
0.34156060218811035,
0.16778813302516937,
-0.09632699936628342,
0.12592940032482147,
0.3106902539730072,
0.23615503311157227,
0.48197048902511597,
0.45567864179611206,
-0.18196605145931244,
0.3484582304954529,
-0.2060428261756897,
-0.5053695440292358,
0.7435048818588257,
-0.6421887874603271,
-0.009169047698378563,
-0.3730185925960541,
-0.18841490149497986,
-1.22439706325531,
-0.7322936654090881,
-0.11309969425201416,
-0.13386015594005585,
0.2441249042749405,
-0.25650057196617126,
-0.5944005846977234,
0.17157794535160065,
-0.2653540372848511,
0.6677151918411255,
0.028743449598550797,
-0.3599169850349426,
0.6804328560829163,
0.14505745470523834,
-0.4576098918914795,
0.015375505201518536,
-0.7083286643028259,
-0.28665295243263245,
-0.36098694801330566,
-0.547067403793335,
0.3778500258922577,
0.3010932207107544,
-0.23389405012130737,
-0.22521622478961945,
0.14301039278507233,
-0.3581303656101227,
-0.20073182880878448,
0.27009743452072144,
-0.02492477558553219,
-0.44866982102394104,
0.3620416224002838,
-0.04175363853573799,
0.2723052501678467,
-0.44176414608955383,
-0.39131975173950195,
0.6648216247558594,
0.06344395875930786,
-0.4841759204864502,
-0.3681161403656006,
0.6161355972290039,
0.5671142935752869,
-0.3128822147846222,
0.6759099960327148,
0.16344386339187622,
-0.3201659321784973,
-0.08446167409420013,
-0.5581618547439575,
0.1392681747674942,
-0.39681845903396606,
0.46409615874290466,
-0.5653473734855652,
-0.6652121543884277,
0.6480434536933899,
0.20162594318389893,
-0.12551245093345642,
0.46053487062454224,
0.41265764832496643,
-0.07279911637306213,
0.7892857193946838,
0.8682345151901245,
-0.26584744453430176,
0.6036556363105774,
0.047198712825775146,
0.03399592265486717,
-0.3044819235801697,
-0.2517450749874115,
-0.9108290672302246,
-0.1443285197019577,
-0.8017815947532654,
-0.3685947358608246,
0.5142423510551453,
0.19160613417625427,
-0.15353316068649292,
0.4522571861743927,
-0.021551484242081642,
0.45621347427368164,
0.6648566722869873,
0.191245436668396,
0.39932844042778015,
0.23608428239822388,
-0.35384097695350647,
-0.1251983642578125,
-0.7761721014976501,
-0.3518573045730591,
1.0266661643981934,
0.10502113401889801,
1.1526600122451782,
0.3091297447681427,
0.683383584022522,
-0.3316700756549835,
0.03216151148080826,
-0.6241494417190552,
-0.03759832680225372,
-0.5829862952232361,
-0.5144928693771362,
-0.5449832677841187,
-0.377986341714859,
-0.9295521974563599,
0.31898894906044006,
-0.048169784247875214,
-0.91804039478302,
0.6071956157684326,
0.11898703873157501,
-0.6627432703971863,
0.27523237466812134,
-0.8108522295951843,
0.814156711101532,
0.11352194845676422,
0.05120312049984932,
-0.2595705986022949,
-0.5248916149139404,
-0.0020603672601282597,
0.11671058088541031,
0.2695697844028473,
-0.1346004158258438,
0.06791258603334427,
0.194549098610878,
-0.5017859935760498,
1.110891342163086,
0.30641400814056396,
-0.11234436184167862,
0.07635954022407532,
0.1220427006483078,
-0.03162052482366562,
0.2500891387462616,
-0.46077290177345276,
0.1563766598701477,
0.22957047820091248,
-0.5664626955986023,
-0.43499240279197693,
0.5534074306488037,
-0.8939327001571655,
-0.3769981563091278,
-0.2140359878540039,
-0.42779460549354553,
-0.2296808511018753,
0.23738789558410645,
0.5331048965454102,
0.6171072721481323,
-0.6394861936569214,
0.041285209357738495,
0.3415733873844147,
-0.052619658410549164,
0.28815725445747375,
0.2261659801006317,
-0.3227498233318329,
-0.37819725275039673,
0.6914923787117004,
0.4886327087879181,
0.47782158851623535,
0.2992551922798157,
0.20912134647369385,
-0.07163242995738983,
-0.15739266574382782,
-0.5607202053070068,
0.4708015024662018,
-0.5931949019432068,
-0.11490368843078613,
-0.33083850145339966,
-0.0310776699334383,
-0.7738543748855591,
0.07822153717279434,
-0.4808187186717987,
-0.6501238346099854,
-0.38927358388900757,
0.04601491242647171,
0.11996208131313324,
1.1366780996322632,
-0.10992245376110077,
0.4614557921886444,
-0.5541461110115051,
0.2730593681335449,
0.3790602684020996,
0.26980406045913696,
-0.14794766902923584,
-0.6454339027404785,
-0.361579567193985,
0.2338232398033142,
-0.17363019287586212,
-0.9627817273139954,
0.21872086822986603,
0.5804845094680786,
0.22638258337974548,
0.4315599501132965,
-0.08799981325864792,
0.8602232336997986,
-0.49520984292030334,
0.6172117590904236,
0.14631985127925873,
-1.0999746322631836,
0.3806757628917694,
-0.6031357049942017,
0.49700412154197693,
0.5525514483451843,
0.3331126272678375,
-0.6944761276245117,
-0.5047188997268677,
-0.4311462640762329,
-0.8060243129730225,
0.767619788646698,
-0.040680892765522,
0.20419438183307648,
0.20556309819221497,
0.34353524446487427,
0.37884339690208435,
0.17317010462284088,
-0.7350526452064514,
0.19924627244472504,
-0.3130608797073364,
-0.035682208836078644,
-0.41360729932785034,
-0.34972959756851196,
0.0019084959058091044,
-0.27483701705932617,
0.12291025370359421,
0.17458918690681458,
0.014413750730454922,
0.09955175220966339,
-0.23298780620098114,
0.14889104664325714,
0.2835642695426941,
0.6570951342582703,
0.5439748764038086,
-0.11738159507513046,
0.503644585609436,
-0.013163712806999683,
-0.43754151463508606,
0.07551044970750809,
0.2752004861831665,
-0.08068303018808365,
0.3614906072616577,
0.6454034447669983,
0.8545424938201904,
-0.13751593232154846,
-0.537219226360321,
0.24363569915294647,
0.19105398654937744,
0.08690834790468216,
0.13773034512996674,
0.0803946778178215,
0.059999749064445496,
0.1005275547504425,
-0.14417722821235657,
0.18262268602848053,
0.08939938992261887,
-0.7510439157485962,
-0.3102830946445465,
-0.006514756940305233,
-0.30590105056762695,
-0.538974940776825,
0.2858009934425354,
-0.21722513437271118,
-0.08908037096261978,
0.4209429621696472,
-0.00985504686832428,
-0.4091358184814453,
0.690558910369873,
0.19762736558914185,
0.4061089754104614,
-0.6710297465324402,
0.09481008350849152,
0.3880895972251892,
0.4133681356906891,
-0.18509429693222046,
0.40115997195243835,
0.2053319215774536,
-0.5530393719673157,
-0.0895371288061142,
-0.35232263803482056,
-0.24573390185832977,
-0.0853603258728981,
-1.0784406661987305,
0.5466400384902954,
-0.4377824068069458,
-0.46721091866493225,
0.22285081446170807,
-0.45264631509780884,
-0.838067889213562,
0.26533007621765137,
-0.021434012800455093,
0.6901882290840149,
-0.8602321147918701,
1.0376434326171875,
0.859667181968689,
-0.27997612953186035,
-0.8985711932182312,
0.05455843731760979,
-0.171206995844841,
-0.5241343379020691,
0.5269728899002075,
0.3018262982368469,
-0.20351818203926086,
-0.2590048909187317,
-0.14562012255191803,
-0.7982271909713745,
0.4358784258365631,
0.7947196364402771,
-0.5486562848091125,
0.0466064028441906,
0.6530858278274536,
0.7104631066322327,
-0.3004700541496277,
0.4362083673477173,
0.7480158805847168,
0.32271596789360046,
-0.30363020300865173,
-1.2017877101898193,
-0.2941746115684509,
-0.11874286085367203,
0.4781649112701416,
0.10919158160686493,
-0.5728954672813416,
1.4457613229751587,
-0.018131433054804802,
-0.3308258652687073,
0.42810919880867004,
0.4586351215839386,
-0.3883473575115204,
-0.4118582308292389,
0.26433107256889343,
0.5117372274398804,
0.6836735010147095,
-0.012540344148874283,
0.9068596959114075,
-0.05763324722647667,
0.4028152823448181,
1.37217378616333,
-0.1760801076889038,
0.9198529720306396,
0.465249240398407,
0.040374986827373505,
0.46662452816963196,
0.5628730058670044,
0.3283013701438904,
0.4411628246307373,
0.38330361247062683,
-0.24534636735916138,
-0.21313539147377014,
-0.37584373354911804,
-0.4615621268749237,
0.8408948183059692,
0.32000821828842163,
-0.2778779864311218,
-0.3047325909137726,
0.07662023603916168,
0.11585617810487747,
0.3545939326286316,
-0.2500759959220886,
0.6461732983589172,
-0.1906498372554779,
-0.5775923728942871,
0.9392312169075012,
0.44725301861763,
0.41663190722465515,
-0.44969597458839417,
0.19879433512687683,
-0.6645804643630981,
0.1098271980881691,
-0.08546004444360733,
-0.11834335327148438,
0.23314006626605988,
-0.09109499305486679,
-0.1678152233362198,
-0.031288836151361465,
0.09078725427389145,
-0.8579070568084717,
-0.6233734488487244,
0.2951826751232147,
0.24753524363040924,
-0.12071350961923599,
-0.11166305094957352,
0.05033426731824875,
0.1395975947380066,
-0.10464616864919662,
-0.1364029496908188,
0.07868128269910812,
0.7940855026245117,
-0.06419286876916885,
0.1434723287820816,
0.08490662276744843,
0.4356871247291565,
0.34573793411254883,
0.2550768256187439,
0.935176432132721,
-0.5519927144050598,
-0.5319175720214844,
-0.8206025958061218,
0.38092297315597534,
0.02717837132513523,
-0.595212459564209,
0.6990317106246948,
0.477983295917511,
1.1178370714187622,
-0.24649682641029358,
0.7132470607757568,
-0.025379536673426628,
0.6327194571495056,
-0.6080960631370544,
0.6550063490867615,
-0.7255383133888245,
-0.13809356093406677,
-0.08573965728282928,
-0.8734305500984192,
-0.5132220387458801,
0.7796821594238281,
-0.19796229898929596,
-0.07312002032995224,
0.742347776889801,
0.9572546482086182,
-0.44094908237457275,
0.02022477611899376,
0.4871841073036194,
0.19334547221660614,
-0.08603090047836304,
0.44290056824684143,
0.7772758603096008,
-0.05251525714993477,
0.17799241840839386,
-0.38846275210380554,
-0.293043315410614,
-0.1817546933889389,
-0.7874273657798767,
-1.1552692651748657,
-0.4581042230129242,
0.1696174591779709,
-0.1061592847108841,
0.21636274456977844,
0.8645816445350647,
0.8991835117340088,
-1.0213795900344849,
-0.9833052158355713,
0.004847624804824591,
-0.14746056497097015,
-0.1398596614599228,
-0.06535758823156357,
0.11707441508769989,
-0.4159184992313385,
-0.8892561197280884,
0.2940948009490967,
0.22499772906303406,
0.03943868353962898,
-0.19342096149921417,
0.45041900873184204,
0.02789890207350254,
0.07223338633775711,
0.21160905063152313,
0.13340625166893005,
-0.7794421911239624,
-0.29639381170272827,
-0.011551856063306332,
-0.4743775725364685,
0.25736796855926514,
1.1161236763000488,
-0.09954746812582016,
0.8595558404922485,
0.5471088290214539,
0.25233194231987,
0.5411285758018494,
-0.08581970632076263,
0.7413621544837952,
-0.7923313975334167,
0.6843320727348328,
0.07759589701890945,
0.37495067715644836,
0.3590448796749115,
-0.1781911551952362,
0.20551936328411102,
0.26149681210517883,
-0.07254274189472198,
-0.43890950083732605,
0.5456221103668213,
-0.5353149175643921,
-0.22753392159938812,
1.0343482494354248,
-0.6041839122772217,
0.1840103566646576,
-0.19148191809654236,
-0.3719905912876129,
0.18933649361133575,
-0.2610558867454529,
0.7761985659599304,
0.8574224710464478,
0.04666568338871002,
0.129721537232399,
-0.2866087555885315,
0.43623483180999756,
0.6141201257705688,
-0.6256473064422607,
0.09874492138624191,
0.5366021394729614,
0.22551898658275604,
0.2947569489479065,
0.44179555773735046,
0.16876891255378723,
0.031901486217975616,
0.07089808583259583,
0.060057349503040314,
0.11121179908514023,
-0.565034031867981,
-0.5059969425201416,
0.2802160680294037,
0.3503389060497284,
0.09616010636091232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19310v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19310v2
|
Does Whisper understand Swiss German? An automatic, qualitative, and human evaluation
| 2024-04-30T07:29:40 | 2024-05-09T11:54:04 |
Eyal Liron Dolev, Clemens Fidel Lutz, Noëmi Aepli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Whisper is a state-of-the-art automatic speech recognition (ASR) model
(Radford et al., 2022). Although Swiss German dialects are allegedly not part
of Whisper's training data, preliminary experiments showed that Whisper can
transcribe Swiss German quite well, with the output being a speech translation
into Standard German. To gain a better understanding of Whisper's performance
on Swiss German, we systematically evaluate it using automatic, qualitative,
and human evaluation. We test its performance on three existing test sets:
SwissDial (Dogan-Sch\"onberger et al., 2021), STT4SG-350 (Pl\"uss et al.,
2023), and Swiss Parliaments Corpus (Pl\"uss et al., 2021). In addition, we
create a new test set for this work, based on short mock clinical interviews.
For automatic evaluation, we used word error rate (WER) and BLEU. In the
qualitative analysis, we discuss Whisper's strengths and weaknesses and anylyze
some output examples. For the human evaluation, we conducted a survey with 28
participants who were asked to evaluate Whisper's performance.
All of our evaluations suggest that Whisper is a viable ASR system for Swiss
German, so long as the Standard German output is desired.
|
[
-0.10709179937839508,
-0.6254759430885315,
0.48922979831695557,
0.4574028551578522,
-0.3895418345928192,
0.27932828664779663,
-0.23154526948928833,
-0.756736159324646,
-0.08115603029727936,
0.1793937385082245,
-0.7025191187858582,
-0.5110661387443542,
-0.7961502075195312,
0.2275259792804718,
-0.648886501789093,
0.7140528559684753,
-0.03362619876861572,
0.5799046158790588,
0.3301941752433777,
-0.17140857875347137,
-0.21165291965007782,
-0.5507674217224121,
-0.6680728793144226,
-0.6139650940895081,
0.06894601136445999,
0.30453193187713623,
0.4284675419330597,
0.3263738751411438,
0.14302340149879456,
0.38221925497055054,
-0.27682316303253174,
-0.2706390917301178,
-0.5376101732254028,
-0.263011634349823,
0.20530495047569275,
-0.06732364743947983,
-0.22372213006019592,
0.03527155518531799,
0.7187277674674988,
0.7378600835800171,
-0.5745249390602112,
0.2358100563287735,
0.07901721447706223,
0.7164117693901062,
-0.18392576277256012,
0.19767551124095917,
-0.5744622945785522,
-0.0790499895811081,
-0.30739811062812805,
0.24185346066951752,
-0.391104131937027,
-0.4485146701335907,
0.8128854036331177,
-0.4962139129638672,
0.6630094647407532,
0.1147996261715889,
1.0345951318740845,
-0.011093555949628353,
-0.5094107985496521,
-0.4211340546607971,
-0.8408514857292175,
0.5671566724777222,
-0.5325755476951599,
0.6377658843994141,
0.588205099105835,
0.5921785235404968,
0.14915162324905396,
-0.6175790429115295,
-0.43473395705223083,
-0.08759502321481705,
0.0858420804142952,
0.4198923707008362,
-0.6551376581192017,
-0.010011089034378529,
0.119405098259449,
0.3859564960002899,
-0.5102164149284363,
0.10085666924715042,
-0.6228109002113342,
-0.6698152422904968,
0.834437906742096,
-0.049419790506362915,
0.13975493609905243,
-0.03781116008758545,
-0.26381033658981323,
-0.06906317919492722,
-0.26347988843917847,
0.3827578127384186,
0.5052403211593628,
0.18332767486572266,
-0.1574399322271347,
0.16273383796215057,
-0.31406086683273315,
0.8029631972312927,
0.2931687831878662,
-0.05252040922641754,
0.26275092363357544,
-0.049200914800167084,
-0.08338014036417007,
0.550589919090271,
0.8283475041389465,
0.2790805399417877,
0.433960497379303,
-0.39786335825920105,
-0.27579233050346375,
0.12780526280403137,
0.32350319623947144,
-0.7098888158798218,
-0.34287819266319275,
0.0626068264245987,
-0.5381187796592712,
-0.05139758810400963,
0.04395870119333267,
-0.12271221727132797,
-0.07039456069469452,
-0.14320065081119537,
0.6991571187973022,
-0.8079655170440674,
-0.2661088705062866,
0.5580924153327942,
-0.5743888020515442,
0.32854777574539185,
0.40752100944519043,
-0.6032223701477051,
0.6254695653915405,
0.35691627860069275,
0.6522566080093384,
-0.252976655960083,
-0.4702188968658447,
-0.5815684199333191,
-0.06588542461395264,
-0.27115145325660706,
1.1028051376342773,
-0.12896095216274261,
-0.9799559712409973,
0.15804414451122284,
0.019512321799993515,
-0.39758461713790894,
-0.8627866506576538,
0.6323482990264893,
-0.5502915382385254,
0.19202908873558044,
-0.1743001639842987,
-0.5471033453941345,
-0.4207890033721924,
-0.35460102558135986,
-0.4360864758491516,
0.6666526198387146,
0.0842457041144371,
-0.5692875385284424,
0.3383025825023651,
-0.38552072644233704,
-0.9795752167701721,
0.0788181722164154,
0.3135172128677368,
-0.07942493259906769,
0.33924517035484314,
0.07906359434127808,
0.21890191733837128,
-0.13606950640678406,
0.09351012855768204,
0.01454378291964531,
-0.6912097930908203,
0.6906909942626953,
-0.3706877529621124,
0.7999930381774902,
-0.09367416799068451,
-0.23234331607818604,
0.04605821520090103,
-0.8074790835380554,
0.478023499250412,
-0.1889944225549698,
-0.2535169720649719,
0.06672879308462143,
-0.0018108498770743608,
0.20238617062568665,
-0.1328682154417038,
-0.02161250449717045,
-0.891764760017395,
-0.47946032881736755,
-0.5461440086364746,
0.6428464651107788,
0.5499614477157593,
0.07655633240938187,
0.3323321044445038,
-0.23475509881973267,
0.47106924653053284,
-0.3277316987514496,
0.30820751190185547,
0.03689466044306755,
-0.28865402936935425,
-0.869087278842926,
-0.32099607586860657,
0.6538205146789551,
0.8354382514953613,
-0.3095211386680603,
0.5699148178100586,
-0.1616354137659073,
-0.6303479671478271,
-1.070786714553833,
-0.062432702630758286,
0.7145087718963623,
0.6854057312011719,
0.26856768131256104,
-0.2211841344833374,
-0.28033965826034546,
-1.1761564016342163,
-0.13523875176906586,
-0.4037116467952728,
-0.13529393076896667,
0.05541619658470154,
0.3656812608242035,
-0.15208888053894043,
0.7484791278839111,
-0.6037174463272095,
-0.3862765431404114,
-0.21038322150707245,
0.49507594108581543,
0.09975177049636841,
0.11373572796583176,
0.14606407284736633,
-0.6619734764099121,
-0.5391986966133118,
-0.02914268523454666,
-0.5839946269989014,
-0.13242113590240479,
0.44463399052619934,
0.14604897797107697,
0.2673189342021942,
0.11723648011684418,
-0.25552529096603394,
0.39910224080085754,
0.5400385856628418,
-0.30631524324417114,
0.7457408905029297,
-0.3425884246826172,
0.10007116198539734,
-0.6512917876243591,
-0.058640241622924805,
-0.04818487912416458,
-0.2131851315498352,
-0.7178459167480469,
-0.3803079128265381,
0.18962103128433228,
-0.2356613576412201,
-0.445213258266449,
0.5768812894821167,
-0.28599995374679565,
-0.15632760524749756,
-0.2167816162109375,
-0.0739147961139679,
0.025014953687787056,
0.0449221134185791,
0.43327322602272034,
0.8061695694923401,
0.7260801792144775,
-0.5293024778366089,
0.1301196813583374,
0.4189508557319641,
-0.5493177771568298,
0.8494937419891357,
-0.9647142291069031,
0.37261882424354553,
0.2726217806339264,
0.08594480156898499,
-0.8026502132415771,
-0.3071899712085724,
-0.16026683151721954,
-0.8158805966377258,
0.38266363739967346,
-0.15105807781219482,
-0.5347815752029419,
-0.304404079914093,
0.07435069978237152,
-0.2765375077724457,
0.9061563611030579,
-0.321858674287796,
0.5826009511947632,
0.40261149406433105,
-0.20634284615516663,
-0.10615364462137222,
-0.3229891061782837,
0.10535011440515518,
-0.1318347156047821,
-0.8185033798217773,
0.19332540035247803,
-0.08823266625404358,
-0.4312642812728882,
-0.15959683060646057,
-0.3821432888507843,
-0.5077897906303406,
0.01696142926812172,
0.2594074010848999,
0.31646528840065,
-0.05162553861737251,
-0.07310549914836884,
0.1340538114309311,
-0.41875213384628296,
0.11335698515176773,
-0.05001334846019745,
0.2483721375465393,
-0.5775910019874573,
-0.4563966989517212,
-0.9944269061088562,
0.5014505982398987,
0.35512417554855347,
-0.10565686225891113,
-0.05201950669288635,
0.6674417853355408,
-0.2206670492887497,
-0.18368595838546753,
-0.87038254737854,
-0.2645975351333618,
-0.47496724128723145,
0.20879685878753662,
-0.5664883255958557,
-0.9573920369148254,
0.7549671530723572,
-0.04731771722435951,
-0.3625972867012024,
0.4983883798122406,
0.11185242235660553,
-0.6462452411651611,
1.2514370679855347,
0.6606810092926025,
-0.13754016160964966,
-0.12435425072908401,
-0.1896570473909378,
-0.07838351279497147,
-0.6366483569145203,
-0.15939554572105408,
-0.7819139361381531,
-0.02261018007993698,
-0.18850162625312805,
0.08430346846580505,
0.5052341818809509,
0.2522503435611725,
-0.051152076572179794,
0.17293715476989746,
-0.37056392431259155,
-0.0008118882542476058,
0.43156522512435913,
0.0631534531712532,
0.4094516634941101,
0.05154213681817055,
0.06574758887290955,
-0.39357706904411316,
-0.5951266288757324,
-0.584576427936554,
0.48390406370162964,
0.3656506836414337,
0.7779020071029663,
-0.10986324399709702,
0.7812588810920715,
0.37807586789131165,
0.18337775766849518,
-1.002220869064331,
0.5235466361045837,
-0.1976153552532196,
-0.35791173577308655,
-0.36612096428871155,
-0.10152740031480789,
-0.9226569533348083,
0.1860969215631485,
-0.034855179488658905,
-0.5449410080909729,
-0.020478766411542892,
0.12787355482578278,
-0.3966811001300812,
-0.24962455034255981,
-1.135246753692627,
0.6474241018295288,
-0.2862986922264099,
0.39262551069259644,
-0.43493086099624634,
-0.5681598782539368,
0.06638352572917938,
-0.31142696738243103,
0.19093380868434906,
-0.12107465416193008,
0.07147728651762009,
1.0081819295883179,
-0.41090095043182373,
0.9404314756393433,
-0.3235929310321808,
0.015781639143824577,
0.378371000289917,
0.12767496705055237,
0.1737649291753769,
-0.16439437866210938,
-0.295257568359375,
0.6316192150115967,
0.2515439987182617,
-0.19390566647052765,
-0.6781350374221802,
0.2275826334953308,
-0.8149667382240295,
-0.43683671951293945,
-0.556311845779419,
-0.11967870593070984,
-0.3878047466278076,
0.2579522728919983,
0.585274875164032,
0.6613534092903137,
-0.7103558778762817,
-0.2578545808792114,
0.7011135220527649,
0.03273771330714226,
0.07981272786855698,
1.582356572151184,
-0.06723563373088837,
-0.5290163159370422,
0.8510487079620361,
0.2984844744205475,
0.28932562470436096,
-0.11676357686519623,
0.49850136041641235,
-0.5549024939537048,
-0.9232246279716492,
-0.9594236612319946,
0.38600674271583557,
-0.5607590675354004,
0.14374326169490814,
-0.7417207956314087,
-0.43571576476097107,
-0.19176796078681946,
-0.19898492097854614,
-0.021211091428995132,
-0.1937423199415207,
-0.2421797215938568,
-0.23099328577518463,
0.5623794198036194,
0.9795317649841309,
-0.036282673478126526,
0.599321722984314,
-1.0298928022384644,
0.1579732894897461,
0.44491422176361084,
0.1351526826620102,
-0.12512528896331787,
-0.8919329047203064,
-0.11386622488498688,
-0.09035509079694748,
0.07461536675691605,
-0.8681398034095764,
0.17930005490779877,
0.38659366965293884,
0.6535477638244629,
0.4693252742290497,
0.2299339920282364,
0.949040412902832,
-1.0774309635162354,
0.739142119884491,
0.2235371321439743,
-1.3639538288116455,
0.6243413686752319,
-0.2625778317451477,
0.2255505621433258,
0.8439581990242004,
0.15670141577720642,
-0.5187613368034363,
-0.4984685778617859,
-0.9044195413589478,
-0.37934422492980957,
0.7336179614067078,
0.04379716515541077,
0.20605593919754028,
0.14063765108585358,
0.2582235634326935,
0.38232719898223877,
0.23810580372810364,
-0.08207078278064728,
-0.14439968764781952,
-0.14188973605632782,
0.06393629312515259,
-0.16063891351222992,
-0.2765514552593231,
-0.29311808943748474,
-0.2917952239513397,
0.5077815651893616,
-0.06032830849289894,
0.20048469305038452,
0.21320487558841705,
-0.1601821780204773,
-0.1462976485490799,
0.2732706665992737,
0.2828122675418854,
0.6980652809143066,
-0.3292597830295563,
-0.0887710452079773,
0.44668588042259216,
-0.6070582866668701,
0.2595851719379425,
0.5426344871520996,
-0.42134422063827515,
0.3316573202610016,
0.8393222689628601,
0.8715985417366028,
0.40642598271369934,
-0.790880560874939,
0.5930381417274475,
-0.12720070779323578,
-0.5283674597740173,
-0.5219186544418335,
0.07987575232982635,
0.23105935752391815,
0.15359541773796082,
0.5885618329048157,
0.15360914170742035,
0.49817848205566406,
-0.4681413173675537,
0.24383363127708435,
0.45081889629364014,
-0.9681564569473267,
-0.7169697284698486,
0.3435104787349701,
0.3774649202823639,
-0.6116299629211426,
0.67767733335495,
-0.29299747943878174,
-0.9317331910133362,
0.17604777216911316,
0.7954437136650085,
1.0318779945373535,
-0.38563334941864014,
0.5014094710350037,
0.18197974562644958,
0.25648149847984314,
-0.22125814855098724,
0.7236780524253845,
-0.28135985136032104,
-0.768835723400116,
-0.42378026247024536,
-0.6827386617660522,
-0.5507169365882874,
-0.2802301347255707,
-1.2943115234375,
-0.07300212234258652,
-0.024383315816521645,
-0.2773745656013489,
0.18844589591026306,
-0.050768960267305374,
-0.5938549041748047,
0.14566414058208466,
-0.2609381079673767,
1.2193007469177246,
-0.9361488223075867,
0.9117811322212219,
0.6938700079917908,
0.07805689424276352,
-0.7849216461181641,
0.1614815890789032,
0.10720109939575195,
-1.2781394720077515,
0.9077652096748352,
0.13302287459373474,
-0.688700258731842,
0.1863240748643875,
-0.23506179451942444,
-0.586580753326416,
0.7894779443740845,
0.2597687542438507,
-0.3605339527130127,
0.28513216972351074,
-0.3944024443626404,
0.7399374842643738,
-0.046762362122535706,
-0.17311285436153412,
0.5664791464805603,
0.6753612756729126,
0.09958566725254059,
-1.562656044960022,
-0.3803698420524597,
-0.20913736522197723,
-0.07305734604597092,
-0.01060547772794962,
-0.5479244589805603,
0.17510227859020233,
-0.41154050827026367,
-0.6675711274147034,
0.11994816362857819,
0.5264091491699219,
-0.08407625555992126,
0.49179840087890625,
0.7886952757835388,
0.36880549788475037,
0.8950247168540955,
-0.183247372508049,
1.1915919780731201,
0.03615369275212288,
-0.18490242958068848,
1.0281047821044922,
-0.8566609025001526,
1.2080820798873901,
0.08142413944005966,
-0.5009321570396423,
0.5628488659858704,
0.5726951956748962,
0.17800888419151306,
0.6319389343261719,
0.08927442878484726,
-0.3832452893257141,
-0.34421253204345703,
-0.03366125375032425,
-0.20617040991783142,
0.6544719934463501,
0.2595842778682709,
0.038999538868665695,
-0.15772613883018494,
0.32993465662002563,
0.01177156250923872,
0.17441041767597198,
-0.05472303926944733,
1.2308626174926758,
0.1342196762561798,
-0.46007466316223145,
0.6767665147781372,
0.025483904406428337,
0.4569934606552124,
-1.1284372806549072,
0.22406110167503357,
0.30007439851760864,
0.166237011551857,
-0.000988416955806315,
-0.6119555234909058,
0.3394330143928528,
0.11399944871664047,
-0.3079585134983063,
-0.25567635893821716,
0.7794661521911621,
-0.23984447121620178,
-0.626147449016571,
0.40086790919303894,
0.713226318359375,
0.4975343942642212,
-0.24187685549259186,
-0.7143083810806274,
0.14908446371555328,
0.1643335074186325,
0.2382398098707199,
0.3621433675289154,
0.24037356674671173,
0.14168120920658112,
0.6121055483818054,
0.5650985240936279,
0.5057255625724792,
-0.17137236893177032,
0.3337390720844269,
0.6027339100837708,
-0.6117798089981079,
-0.6762720346450806,
-0.6665753722190857,
0.2733767628669739,
-0.2699476480484009,
-0.38001278042793274,
0.9653851985931396,
0.6518471240997314,
0.523043692111969,
0.023553119972348213,
0.9557203650474548,
0.3010508418083191,
1.028437852859497,
-0.49717074632644653,
0.7698593139648438,
-0.0082689318805933,
-0.31470558047294617,
-0.03117029368877411,
-0.4414788484573364,
0.07571735233068466,
0.8546662330627441,
-0.2580382823944092,
-0.4229106307029724,
0.6585659980773926,
0.4449155628681183,
0.17290933430194855,
0.5705959796905518,
0.17487148940563202,
0.11495290696620941,
-0.07239068299531937,
0.03161633759737015,
1.0131750106811523,
-0.2825740873813629,
0.6846028566360474,
-0.14429117739200592,
-0.44397449493408203,
0.07301964610815048,
-0.6534963846206665,
-0.82646644115448,
-0.597667396068573,
-0.39258822798728943,
-0.4252825975418091,
0.3499799370765686,
0.4245702624320984,
0.9577916860580444,
-0.7467268109321594,
-0.6316407322883606,
0.556671679019928,
-0.31273022294044495,
-0.6210116147994995,
-0.17994403839111328,
0.6850986480712891,
-0.04033955931663513,
-0.5374003648757935,
0.763283908367157,
0.2471056878566742,
0.27434420585632324,
-0.22586636245250702,
-0.2280592918395996,
0.5101626515388489,
-0.22154422104358673,
0.6388168931007385,
0.12182839214801788,
-0.932336688041687,
-0.3805268108844757,
0.43561944365501404,
0.11271364986896515,
-0.12283296883106232,
0.7856677174568176,
-0.8097981810569763,
0.7180320620536804,
0.18338704109191895,
0.3432946801185608,
0.6941942572593689,
0.0684003233909607,
0.7511314153671265,
-0.27038082480430603,
-0.08260847628116608,
0.23702628910541534,
0.2713194787502289,
0.46029165387153625,
-0.15760491788387299,
0.26401546597480774,
0.19374823570251465,
-0.39674273133277893,
-0.8115231394767761,
0.11749102920293808,
-1.0353550910949707,
-0.014240323565900326,
1.0820403099060059,
-0.11189939826726913,
-0.11633303016424179,
-0.5857421159744263,
-0.47239693999290466,
-0.02864520065486431,
-0.682930052280426,
0.6358473300933838,
0.9822502136230469,
-0.4159905016422272,
0.18889456987380981,
-0.6771185994148254,
0.4540996849536896,
0.041412390768527985,
-0.2906419336795807,
-0.004446535836905241,
0.5202682018280029,
0.5563753843307495,
0.11715076863765717,
1.0236780643463135,
-0.11447698622941971,
0.41562792658805847,
-0.08800684660673141,
-0.0748608410358429,
-0.058250751346349716,
0.14822228252887726,
-0.7580605745315552,
-0.14466433227062225,
0.24764615297317505,
-0.3309464156627655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19296v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19296v1
|
Octopus v4: Graph of language models
| 2024-04-30T06:55:45 | 2024-04-30T06:55:45 |
Wei Chen, Zhiyuan Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models have been effective in a wide range of applications, yet the
most sophisticated models are often proprietary. For example, GPT-4 by OpenAI
and various models by Anthropic are expensive and consume substantial energy.
In contrast, the open-source community has produced competitive models, like
Llama3. Furthermore, niche-specific smaller language models, such as those
tailored for legal, medical or financial tasks, have outperformed their
proprietary counterparts. This paper introduces a novel approach that employs
\textit{functional tokens} to integrate \textbf{multiple open-source models},
each optimized for particular tasks. Our newly developed Octopus v4 model
leverages \textit{functional tokens} to intelligently direct user queries to
the most appropriate vertical model and reformat the query to achieve the best
performance. Octopus v4, an evolution of the Octopus v1, v2, and v3 models,
excels in selection and parameter understanding and reformatting. Additionally,
we explore the use of graph as a versatile data structure that effectively
coordinates multiple open-source models by harnessing the capabilities of the
Octopus model and \textit{functional tokens}. Use our open-sourced GitHub
(\url{https://www.nexa4ai.com/}) to try Octopus v4 models
(\url{https://huggingface.co/NexaAIDev/Octopus-v4}), and contrite to a larger
graph of language models. By activating models less than 10B parameters, we
achieved SOTA MMLU score of 74.8 among the same level models.
|
[
-0.21389707922935486,
-0.5822458863258362,
0.6181889772415161,
0.021540679037570953,
-0.17136895656585693,
-0.13805124163627625,
-0.0036623389460146427,
-0.6903119683265686,
0.42291224002838135,
0.9182854890823364,
-0.24405920505523682,
-0.7079797387123108,
-0.171066015958786,
0.2198900282382965,
-0.2513215243816376,
0.8305487632751465,
0.11796140670776367,
0.05949809402227402,
0.040030524134635925,
-0.6704961061477661,
-0.1790209263563156,
-0.40139520168304443,
-0.48732638359069824,
-0.2253064215183258,
0.5944806933403015,
0.5031964182853699,
0.7040421962738037,
0.6843043565750122,
0.46198898553848267,
0.35121679306030273,
-0.10391703248023987,
-0.3013556897640228,
-0.5813382267951965,
-0.03956713527441025,
-0.19534273445606232,
-0.569660484790802,
-0.6985976696014404,
-0.08752462267875671,
0.6329433917999268,
0.6491489410400391,
-0.15302948653697968,
0.16245144605636597,
-0.34881922602653503,
0.3554544746875763,
-0.2839520275592804,
0.5922772288322449,
-0.7841297388076782,
-0.12156746536493301,
-0.38198208808898926,
0.24549245834350586,
-0.37446826696395874,
-0.3957050144672394,
0.06977878510951996,
-0.8843410015106201,
-0.4178354740142822,
0.18546824157238007,
0.8192809820175171,
0.09871178865432739,
-0.46780791878700256,
-0.22162842750549316,
-0.43300366401672363,
0.6612753868103027,
-0.995030403137207,
0.6103073954582214,
0.18112345039844513,
0.45151862502098083,
-0.13709649443626404,
-1.139052391052246,
-0.6008268594741821,
-0.3180020749568939,
0.169529527425766,
-0.11015977710485458,
-0.39873969554901123,
0.14781223237514496,
0.04767106845974922,
0.21569372713565826,
-0.3699493110179901,
0.4349869191646576,
-0.7693373560905457,
-0.18888109922409058,
0.4742230772972107,
0.14204472303390503,
0.4612427055835724,
-0.12323043495416641,
-0.3457792401313782,
0.26408007740974426,
-0.955624520778656,
0.02899140678346157,
0.7613008618354797,
0.516204297542572,
-0.07616806030273438,
0.8537449240684509,
-0.29315945506095886,
0.6766199469566345,
-0.31329891085624695,
-0.22661229968070984,
0.5158159732818604,
-0.539243757724762,
0.21614119410514832,
-0.2200922966003418,
0.9617780447006226,
0.2295667976140976,
0.17720593512058258,
0.06420469284057617,
-0.24013304710388184,
-0.11171510815620422,
0.24810762703418732,
-0.6972804069519043,
-0.22345508635044098,
0.24024352431297302,
-0.43369606137275696,
-0.44307470321655273,
-0.2896168828010559,
-0.6319875717163086,
-0.15536010265350342,
-0.31106457114219666,
0.3583593964576721,
-0.4494797885417938,
-0.4708176851272583,
0.1503535956144333,
-0.086672842502594,
-0.17208227515220642,
0.1422986537218094,
-0.9345182776451111,
0.6813750267028809,
0.8136330246925354,
0.9531392455101013,
-0.07597475498914719,
-0.09473146498203278,
-0.4630333185195923,
0.11226826161146164,
-0.24035753309726715,
0.5678175091743469,
-1.0202209949493408,
-0.1652110069990158,
-0.12027177214622498,
-0.2284308820962906,
0.04790691286325455,
-0.3198396861553192,
0.3922576904296875,
-0.587121844291687,
0.2903975248336792,
-0.07028418034315109,
-0.6091340780258179,
-0.5163143873214722,
0.1391969919204712,
-1.1260054111480713,
1.0110673904418945,
0.2773245871067047,
-0.9276387691497803,
0.24471518397331238,
-1.2667502164840698,
0.016238102689385414,
0.3951008915901184,
-0.29196494817733765,
-0.4131985008716583,
-0.18342086672782898,
0.08508910983800888,
0.18090209364891052,
-0.29844215512275696,
-0.06877967715263367,
-0.849990963935852,
-0.14559374749660492,
-0.15018343925476074,
0.3781394958496094,
0.7721489071846008,
0.35628458857536316,
-0.08458882570266724,
0.4258660674095154,
-0.6609410047531128,
-0.14582425355911255,
0.1505795568227768,
-0.32353007793426514,
-0.6052255630493164,
0.15075445175170898,
-0.09820418059825897,
-0.00041368932579644024,
0.33240094780921936,
-0.6346996426582336,
0.4958493113517761,
-0.5749433040618896,
1.1041851043701172,
0.5992523431777954,
-0.08956467360258102,
0.38668113946914673,
0.047631699591875076,
0.5225728750228882,
0.049017950892448425,
0.17000094056129456,
-0.3169437646865845,
-0.9774079918861389,
-0.2380901724100113,
-0.44264429807662964,
0.3088640570640564,
0.3638438284397125,
-0.7710782885551453,
0.009730462916195393,
-0.254555881023407,
-0.7378854155540466,
-0.46982893347740173,
-0.052778732031583786,
0.08405983448028564,
0.5394237041473389,
0.3239394724369049,
-0.3266071081161499,
-0.2655492126941681,
-0.775108277797699,
-0.36985671520233154,
-0.4680890738964081,
0.07499446719884872,
0.5297968983650208,
0.5953561663627625,
-0.4211329519748688,
0.9842044115066528,
-0.498820960521698,
-0.06500642746686935,
-0.4061029851436615,
0.029115287587046623,
0.5898559093475342,
0.2739185690879822,
0.8884693384170532,
-0.8927986025810242,
-0.2739652395248413,
0.3570943772792816,
-0.3218432366847992,
-0.2712773382663727,
0.3730754852294922,
0.11705107986927032,
0.09209476411342621,
0.30339425802230835,
-0.612657368183136,
0.07451467961072922,
0.6309994459152222,
-0.3646389842033386,
0.6091326475143433,
-0.14601154625415802,
-0.21451866626739502,
-1.0464072227478027,
0.35020074248313904,
0.04489433020353317,
-0.38445037603378296,
-0.6802579760551453,
0.36043253540992737,
0.0010579577647149563,
-0.3542807996273041,
-0.4994093179702759,
0.6820143461227417,
-0.2589642405509949,
-0.30278921127319336,
0.12831436097621918,
0.09001877158880234,
-0.20790405571460724,
0.4158342778682709,
-0.08733745664358139,
0.5132067799568176,
0.5882825255393982,
-0.26498377323150635,
0.2736143469810486,
0.06267820298671722,
-0.07482992112636566,
0.17924603819847107,
-0.9027849435806274,
0.0734722837805748,
0.07867002487182617,
0.13707531988620758,
-0.9569333791732788,
-0.1934838593006134,
0.4879997670650482,
-0.09313074499368668,
-0.19977407157421112,
-0.2507762312889099,
-0.4761706590652466,
-0.31628936529159546,
-0.324020117521286,
0.5357133746147156,
0.322488933801651,
-0.3428843915462494,
0.730120062828064,
0.7013037204742432,
-0.4693964421749115,
-0.3688056170940399,
-0.21557871997356415,
-0.047909047454595566,
-0.4408390522003174,
-0.7220878005027771,
0.3108176290988922,
-0.05976933613419533,
-0.08403842896223068,
0.3286650776863098,
-0.01968350075185299,
-0.22591549158096313,
-0.08103577792644501,
0.020166806876659393,
0.13480807840824127,
-0.6153138875961304,
-0.09926832467317581,
0.08910693973302841,
-0.34138545393943787,
-0.27295178174972534,
-0.7908959984779358,
0.41139814257621765,
-0.3096923530101776,
-0.4507158100605011,
-0.462851345539093,
0.23012158274650574,
0.9211874604225159,
-0.6102718710899353,
0.44757720828056335,
0.16953182220458984,
-0.4558369219303131,
0.009183254092931747,
-0.5237606763839722,
-0.15149423480033875,
-0.4906838536262512,
0.19279804825782776,
-0.5427626371383667,
-1.064626932144165,
0.6617894172668457,
-0.08723482489585876,
0.2920532524585724,
0.3787643015384674,
0.7064250707626343,
0.3377440571784973,
0.9785012602806091,
0.7478498220443726,
-0.05942080542445183,
0.6039431691169739,
-0.17644697427749634,
0.4385894238948822,
-0.36157941818237305,
-0.14217114448547363,
-0.6500872373580933,
-0.06656084954738617,
-0.700330913066864,
-0.3406205177307129,
0.4914590120315552,
-0.10522667318582535,
-0.24305911362171173,
0.6135818958282471,
-0.3339284658432007,
0.4525989294052124,
0.49480223655700684,
-0.3475235104560852,
0.38088980317115784,
0.015685176476836205,
-0.5748338103294373,
-0.023975739255547523,
-0.6624820232391357,
-0.662551999092102,
1.3122915029525757,
0.6543134450912476,
0.6339304447174072,
0.12314030528068542,
0.7423946261405945,
-0.08994110673666,
0.3001161217689514,
-0.49785420298576355,
0.4649386703968048,
-0.11853211373090744,
-0.6053803563117981,
-0.4961448013782501,
-0.5946398377418518,
-1.0685124397277832,
0.6083933115005493,
-0.0017521185800433159,
-1.1126708984375,
0.14950473606586456,
0.12434551119804382,
-0.24926656484603882,
0.212686687707901,
-0.7699849605560303,
1.2344499826431274,
-0.14109867811203003,
-0.22925534844398499,
-0.18089811503887177,
-0.4697478413581848,
0.34578388929367065,
-0.22218015789985657,
0.5077418088912964,
-0.3622061014175415,
-0.3616687059402466,
0.36174702644348145,
-0.6223025918006897,
0.6815877556800842,
-0.18177592754364014,
0.05667899176478386,
0.34002310037612915,
-0.0338197760283947,
0.3603466749191284,
0.13098344206809998,
-0.5441802740097046,
0.5121527910232544,
0.22130197286605835,
-0.23097555339336395,
-0.40677860379219055,
0.6960182189941406,
-0.7553860545158386,
-0.24666446447372437,
-0.059194862842559814,
-0.30618131160736084,
0.1901601254940033,
0.8442582488059998,
-0.09699757397174835,
0.3582814335823059,
-0.020501524209976196,
0.17411397397518158,
0.08131435513496399,
-0.12730807065963745,
0.285277396440506,
0.6441738605499268,
-0.44812825322151184,
-0.5711595416069031,
0.9998496770858765,
0.36673250794410706,
0.16551415622234344,
0.1289217323064804,
0.3946331739425659,
-0.5185909867286682,
-0.6177727580070496,
-0.3452378809452057,
0.5791990160942078,
-0.5755935907363892,
-0.05144096538424492,
-0.7038808465003967,
0.23329469561576843,
-0.4509070813655853,
0.12707975506782532,
-0.43485966324806213,
-0.6778317093849182,
-0.2043834626674652,
-0.2947874963283539,
0.32834044098854065,
0.9478846788406372,
0.02806251309812069,
0.16863656044006348,
-0.6220493912696838,
0.37485143542289734,
0.01461450383067131,
0.6735778450965881,
-0.34879785776138306,
0.21587663888931274,
0.052030932158231735,
-0.0779636949300766,
-0.3823029398918152,
-1.2227879762649536,
0.32226866483688354,
0.1908925473690033,
0.7029461860656738,
0.5167484283447266,
-0.046671390533447266,
0.442571759223938,
-0.7310739159584045,
0.8187272548675537,
0.3343835175037384,
-1.1226497888565063,
0.29764482378959656,
-0.5894752144813538,
-0.031328991055488586,
0.3353002071380615,
0.4955613911151886,
-0.39140820503234863,
-0.587493896484375,
-0.5856325626373291,
-1.0883632898330688,
0.8154100775718689,
0.3781298100948334,
0.03991207852959633,
0.21118280291557312,
0.4770144820213318,
0.2639519274234772,
0.34562253952026367,
-1.0430145263671875,
0.1681278645992279,
-0.4335530400276184,
-0.41647201776504517,
0.17547491192817688,
-0.0008207758655771613,
-0.0010655297664925456,
-0.36709463596343994,
0.44776013493537903,
-0.43131110072135925,
-0.005377940367907286,
-0.19449928402900696,
0.19639833271503448,
0.1394987851381302,
-0.1020214855670929,
0.5181177854537964,
0.7228312492370605,
0.13849934935569763,
-0.04140922799706459,
0.1573256403207779,
-0.25793763995170593,
-0.18030571937561035,
0.15638138353824615,
0.039393071085214615,
0.058709342032670975,
0.2614409029483795,
0.7846106290817261,
0.44657766819000244,
-0.5921035408973694,
0.5287117958068848,
-0.07536230236291885,
-0.04270315170288086,
-0.3085993826389313,
0.14291667938232422,
0.4757702052593231,
0.3568688929080963,
-0.001125162816606462,
-0.22025662660598755,
0.34167051315307617,
-0.49149376153945923,
0.1720774918794632,
0.18398725986480713,
-0.30150943994522095,
-0.6172411441802979,
0.9762377142906189,
0.353152334690094,
-0.39818137884140015,
0.5132107734680176,
-0.046433813869953156,
-0.3482350707054138,
0.36112505197525024,
0.5022565126419067,
0.5132411122322083,
-0.29458087682724,
0.12530334293842316,
0.23190072178840637,
0.24007904529571533,
0.014734392054378986,
0.7448616623878479,
0.010184464044868946,
-0.509185254573822,
-0.3746980130672455,
-0.47856080532073975,
-0.5446336269378662,
0.09863335639238358,
-0.21024635434150696,
0.6880790591239929,
-0.2925621569156647,
-0.24186472594738007,
0.2571646273136139,
-0.20002441108226776,
-0.4979434013366699,
-0.18431992828845978,
-0.008518246002495289,
1.0252735614776611,
-0.7027772665023804,
0.8602538704872131,
0.9427736401557922,
-0.7922873497009277,
-0.868449866771698,
-0.37565097212791443,
0.03375539556145668,
-0.6906094551086426,
0.509476900100708,
0.22710373997688293,
-0.018436595797538757,
0.10782217979431152,
-0.5302992463111877,
-1.0072792768478394,
0.8998970985412598,
0.7072859406471252,
-0.4277246594429016,
-0.17597363889217377,
0.37179142236709595,
0.6716327667236328,
-0.7205914855003357,
0.5193572640419006,
0.4323892891407013,
0.5476979613304138,
0.12571513652801514,
-1.040424108505249,
0.025963585823774338,
-0.3176429271697998,
0.0679008737206459,
0.25848132371902466,
-0.45579931139945984,
1.140758991241455,
-0.18391743302345276,
-0.05164102092385292,
0.08332512527704239,
0.49840039014816284,
0.25866979360580444,
0.2551945447921753,
0.6385464668273926,
0.5771459341049194,
0.7692544460296631,
-0.02106303535401821,
0.9028871655464172,
-0.6645311713218689,
0.4051113426685333,
0.6440067887306213,
-0.40697231888771057,
0.9875904321670532,
0.3485112488269806,
0.09911990165710449,
0.5878567099571228,
0.4510272443294525,
0.12073154002428055,
0.3103286623954773,
0.22943787276744843,
0.08987044543027878,
0.026150835677981377,
0.27568772435188293,
-0.25915634632110596,
0.42844319343566895,
0.5491700172424316,
-0.16241909563541412,
-0.2231409251689911,
-0.12353023886680603,
0.19249114394187927,
-0.20598439872264862,
0.013746894896030426,
0.8339536190032959,
0.09197551012039185,
-0.6001040935516357,
0.38297757506370544,
0.2773771286010742,
0.1360478401184082,
-0.6649916768074036,
-0.15002703666687012,
-0.19883719086647034,
0.10947936028242111,
-0.25373128056526184,
-0.5838653445243835,
0.32978275418281555,
-0.01968293823301792,
0.2941807508468628,
-0.15364380180835724,
0.5498211979866028,
-0.356036901473999,
-0.3758053779602051,
0.4455895721912384,
0.10352857410907745,
0.36683645844459534,
0.11608491092920303,
-0.7306779026985168,
0.3375256657600403,
-0.19443120062351227,
-0.20206406712532043,
-0.15255723893642426,
0.5883399248123169,
-0.2622894048690796,
0.765164315700531,
0.8154504299163818,
0.11620127409696579,
0.10406587272882462,
-0.17458295822143555,
1.0801745653152466,
-0.4928579032421112,
-1.0427377223968506,
-0.6914602518081665,
0.6836054921150208,
-0.2167285829782486,
-0.370887815952301,
0.5241813659667969,
0.6565486192703247,
0.721755862236023,
0.08362405002117157,
0.6344752907752991,
0.18662944436073303,
0.4759870767593384,
-0.39606690406799316,
0.6980946063995361,
-0.8161072731018066,
0.3044906556606293,
-0.5258067846298218,
-1.0385633707046509,
-0.4648800194263458,
0.4243299663066864,
-0.40593087673187256,
-0.18504521250724792,
0.5028766989707947,
0.7216981053352356,
-0.38526567816734314,
0.23537462949752808,
0.07880017161369324,
0.3559752404689789,
0.6997209787368774,
0.17748837172985077,
0.6145358085632324,
0.019878052175045013,
0.5169326066970825,
0.1884937435388565,
-0.3571949303150177,
-0.5878119468688965,
-0.9052077531814575,
-0.6269441246986389,
-0.5692254900932312,
-0.32437634468078613,
0.13181081414222717,
-0.03574163466691971,
0.632816731929779,
0.9585970044136047,
-0.6526151895523071,
-0.48066413402557373,
-0.10212107747793198,
0.4130888879299164,
-0.13387945294380188,
-0.1610856056213379,
0.0003811685019172728,
-0.35676729679107666,
-0.6598756313323975,
0.49311941862106323,
0.4939349591732025,
-0.23003460466861725,
-0.4431705176830292,
-0.14900866150856018,
0.011316200718283653,
0.34776413440704346,
0.5199397206306458,
0.4713220000267029,
-0.8610987067222595,
-0.3682944178581238,
-0.09729788452386856,
0.10492575168609619,
0.14412946999073029,
0.852665901184082,
-0.5716124773025513,
0.5669479370117188,
0.7372142672538757,
0.397809773683548,
0.570151686668396,
-0.239673912525177,
0.7458033561706543,
-0.3322661221027374,
0.13071377575397491,
0.3625544011592865,
0.6348962783813477,
0.09003835171461105,
-0.05227451026439667,
0.6360040903091431,
0.3313975930213928,
-0.42606744170188904,
-1.0378345251083374,
0.4497053027153015,
-0.7905520796775818,
-0.26725879311561584,
0.9425029158592224,
-0.22364011406898499,
-0.25759848952293396,
-0.15346422791481018,
-0.37692493200302124,
-0.17514559626579285,
-0.5060922503471375,
0.34315791726112366,
0.5160537362098694,
-0.35659611225128174,
-0.05836128443479538,
-0.6674243807792664,
0.19972561299800873,
0.02807042747735977,
-0.7178762555122375,
-0.34520936012268066,
0.4919048845767975,
0.6138952374458313,
0.3600059449672699,
0.8153719305992126,
-0.3648846745491028,
-0.049301471561193466,
-0.05843789130449295,
-0.0034228856675326824,
-0.16190332174301147,
-0.3119424283504486,
-0.10144501179456711,
0.584831178188324,
0.15326203405857086,
-0.06546005606651306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01593v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01593v1
|
Large Language Model Agent for Fake News Detection
| 2024-04-30T06:55:27 | 2024-04-30T06:55:27 |
Xinyi Li, Yongfeng Zhang, Edward C. Malthouse
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
In the current digital era, the rapid spread of misinformation on online
platforms presents significant challenges to societal well-being, public trust,
and democratic processes, influencing critical decision making and public
opinion. To address these challenges, there is a growing need for automated
fake news detection mechanisms. Pre-trained large language models (LLMs) have
demonstrated exceptional capabilities across various natural language
processing (NLP) tasks, prompting exploration into their potential for
verifying news claims. Instead of employing LLMs in a non-agentic way, where
LLMs generate responses based on direct prompts in a single shot, our work
introduces FactAgent, an agentic approach of utilizing LLMs for fake news
detection. FactAgent enables LLMs to emulate human expert behavior in verifying
news claims without any model training, following a structured workflow. This
workflow breaks down the complex task of news veracity checking into multiple
sub-steps, where LLMs complete simple tasks using their internal knowledge or
external tools. At the final step of the workflow, LLMs integrate all findings
throughout the workflow to determine the news claim's veracity. Compared to
manual human verification, FactAgent offers enhanced efficiency. Experimental
studies demonstrate the effectiveness of FactAgent in verifying claims without
the need for any training process. Moreover, FactAgent provides transparent
explanations at each step of the workflow and during final decision-making,
offering insights into the reasoning process of fake news detection for end
users. FactAgent is highly adaptable, allowing for straightforward updates to
its tools that LLMs can leverage within the workflow, as well as updates to the
workflow itself using domain knowledge. This adaptability enables FactAgent's
application to news verification across various domains.
|
[
-0.14898766577243805,
-1.052010178565979,
0.784967839717865,
0.21831287443637848,
-0.24255143105983734,
0.32260966300964355,
-0.07815654575824738,
-0.5284070372581482,
0.371501624584198,
0.47821947932243347,
-0.32101374864578247,
-0.4399975836277008,
-0.5558674335479736,
0.02094140090048313,
-0.5729843974113464,
0.8545823097229004,
0.08443819731473923,
-0.015116007998585701,
-0.16926878690719604,
0.12485398352146149,
-0.13212181627750397,
-0.43804216384887695,
-0.8149295449256897,
-0.41781848669052124,
0.47023850679397583,
0.284952312707901,
0.7332535982131958,
0.37100884318351746,
0.054543234407901764,
0.46880587935447693,
0.2896447479724884,
0.49584710597991943,
-0.2920060455799103,
-0.16216419637203217,
-0.3239997923374176,
-0.533562421798706,
-0.46946054697036743,
0.21364304423332214,
0.33296096324920654,
-0.05862439051270485,
-0.17882631719112396,
0.16091051697731018,
-0.4804894030094147,
0.3004941940307617,
-0.34310173988342285,
0.18541932106018066,
-0.714504063129425,
-0.10377158224582672,
0.030538618564605713,
-0.29139119386672974,
-0.5027797222137451,
-0.47620120644569397,
-0.026626337319612503,
-0.45319053530693054,
0.4296192228794098,
0.16354727745056152,
0.9918498992919922,
0.25732704997062683,
-0.6834242939949036,
-0.21830132603645325,
-0.7222529649734497,
0.3986591100692749,
-0.8411206603050232,
0.46983733773231506,
0.23745690286159515,
0.49836403131484985,
-0.3109516203403473,
-0.6584973335266113,
-1.0837682485580444,
-0.6072822213172913,
-0.06730931252241135,
-0.022984424605965614,
-0.2427206039428711,
-0.18125222623348236,
0.22324980795383453,
0.06632687896490097,
-0.7583958506584167,
0.06724098324775696,
-0.05398331955075264,
-0.6316300630569458,
0.7070375680923462,
-0.21539442241191864,
0.3983932137489319,
-0.08821976184844971,
-0.3080657124519348,
0.04643452167510986,
-0.5288556814193726,
-0.42783600091934204,
0.45990613102912903,
0.13215301930904388,
-0.1545579731464386,
0.4587777256965637,
-0.37571197748184204,
0.5693002343177795,
0.049155768007040024,
-0.6065410375595093,
0.29299673438072205,
-0.04797627404332161,
-0.15771116316318512,
0.3109986186027527,
0.7158161401748657,
0.00027720999787561595,
0.10574183613061905,
0.03838609904050827,
-0.4832688868045807,
0.2587100565433502,
0.24635666608810425,
-0.7306734919548035,
0.0801105871796608,
0.23508796095848083,
-0.2788856625556946,
-0.46446606516838074,
0.1250341236591339,
-0.5224000811576843,
-0.628656804561615,
-0.5406078100204468,
0.6480204463005066,
-0.266613632440567,
-0.34697067737579346,
0.13300029933452606,
-0.05372261628508568,
0.14214131236076355,
0.7752087116241455,
-0.0041229985654354095,
0.0269904937595129,
0.5860377550125122,
0.7748728394508362,
0.05549510195851326,
-0.2625617980957031,
-0.9059102535247803,
-0.04947135969996452,
-0.5096036195755005,
0.9611431360244751,
-0.3070032298564911,
0.3107066750526428,
0.05273015424609184,
0.11178164929151535,
0.10928771644830704,
-0.36187994480133057,
0.661896824836731,
-1.05772864818573,
0.043646421283483505,
-0.11043042689561844,
-0.6101366281509399,
-0.29157325625419617,
0.6802586317062378,
-0.8847082257270813,
0.827802836894989,
-0.02385002188384533,
-0.7011362910270691,
0.28402864933013916,
-0.7435409426689148,
-0.5297427773475647,
0.12273284047842026,
0.10469084978103638,
-0.5030413866043091,
-0.12426063418388367,
0.27464133501052856,
0.33001160621643066,
0.04561891034245491,
0.2305280864238739,
-0.17940446734428406,
-0.09133537113666534,
0.3564882278442383,
-0.6927830576896667,
0.5286182761192322,
0.191360741853714,
-0.4534686803817749,
0.18300065398216248,
-0.7589297890663147,
-0.32995814085006714,
0.19599607586860657,
-0.3453128933906555,
-0.20959556102752686,
0.008424455299973488,
-0.0318852961063385,
0.33766865730285645,
0.1485438495874405,
-0.7946190237998962,
0.15695708990097046,
-0.271831750869751,
0.09766808897256851,
0.5434867143630981,
0.16152064502239227,
0.11165111511945724,
-0.4027188718318939,
0.22652867436408997,
0.15958048403263092,
0.08939432352781296,
-0.09166146069765091,
-0.16876882314682007,
-0.8381121754646301,
-0.3565256893634796,
0.4682565927505493,
0.703822910785675,
-1.2991435527801514,
0.36641764640808105,
-0.19833454489707947,
-0.5602299571037292,
-0.29062238335609436,
0.001901787705719471,
0.18363730609416962,
0.39581069350242615,
0.20248593389987946,
0.15760894119739532,
-0.5470442771911621,
-0.754631519317627,
-0.5347534418106079,
-0.15195190906524658,
0.039318930357694626,
-0.3316984474658966,
0.8008706569671631,
-0.16656430065631866,
1.0272780656814575,
-0.2811414897441864,
-0.1796395629644394,
-0.28113821148872375,
0.3628273010253906,
0.1579032689332962,
-0.0026572744827717543,
0.47587424516677856,
-1.1736477613449097,
-0.476408451795578,
-0.042244117707014084,
-0.6847847104072571,
-0.0872664600610733,
-0.3115118443965912,
0.1858457326889038,
0.7526640295982361,
0.3952726423740387,
-1.141436219215393,
0.6441578269004822,
0.5289574861526489,
-0.4686596095561981,
0.811732292175293,
-0.18498864769935608,
0.4451352059841156,
-0.9222995638847351,
-0.14629505574703217,
0.2293180674314499,
-0.9060407280921936,
-0.7887455224990845,
0.01663404516875744,
0.027970129624009132,
-0.03809165954589844,
-0.6520385146141052,
0.7033687829971313,
-0.4855648875236511,
-0.1962990164756775,
-0.7301762700080872,
0.09707444161176682,
0.08969899266958237,
0.2666468918323517,
0.13080447912216187,
0.6655501127243042,
0.39683058857917786,
-0.6370956301689148,
0.7115210890769958,
-0.06733468174934387,
-0.2683033347129822,
0.5148289799690247,
-0.5988539457321167,
0.03703494742512703,
-0.2594568729400635,
0.6888483166694641,
-0.7040609121322632,
-0.3956119120121002,
0.3495229482650757,
-0.7227901816368103,
-0.007269407156854868,
-0.14605312049388885,
-1.1470460891723633,
-0.43845856189727783,
-0.12719793617725372,
-0.24945168197155,
0.2693648934364319,
-0.7279374599456787,
0.8168128728866577,
0.07537394016981125,
0.15379728376865387,
-0.44787102937698364,
-0.45328861474990845,
0.4171755909919739,
0.16267617046833038,
-0.6838241219520569,
0.058592524379491806,
0.00907979067414999,
-0.48529496788978577,
0.07883806526660919,
-0.36090463399887085,
-0.18376338481903076,
-0.1349170207977295,
0.021145058795809746,
0.3339400887489319,
-0.28923970460891724,
0.21852485835552216,
-0.15259739756584167,
0.03893636167049408,
0.010931337252259254,
-0.23191969096660614,
0.32718369364738464,
-0.1156236082315445,
-0.5252679586410522,
-0.5705214738845825,
0.1719978153705597,
0.9568420052528381,
-0.2661415636539459,
1.0731309652328491,
0.739885151386261,
-0.4506882429122925,
-0.46100905537605286,
-0.911696195602417,
-0.33177849650382996,
-0.4579277038574219,
0.31504637002944946,
-0.1096610501408577,
-0.6649094820022583,
0.30022165179252625,
-0.02885304018855095,
-0.0005797612247988582,
0.2996752858161926,
0.7320381999015808,
0.36388641595840454,
1.008487582206726,
0.46311768889427185,
-0.20199204981327057,
0.22511133551597595,
0.04673956334590912,
0.28788045048713684,
0.16366204619407654,
-0.03071758709847927,
-0.23793870210647583,
0.10752694308757782,
-0.27177006006240845,
-0.6932600736618042,
0.37422412633895874,
-0.5084822177886963,
-0.0014331607380881906,
0.027034660801291466,
-0.13819579780101776,
0.6042546033859253,
0.42161741852760315,
0.18420885503292084,
0.6454346179962158,
0.06713313609361649,
0.3436278998851776,
0.3603495657444,
-0.4547916650772095,
-0.6331308484077454,
0.7652766108512878,
0.5142642855644226,
0.7425768375396729,
0.2228497564792633,
0.3252599239349365,
0.8663977980613708,
0.5874459743499756,
-0.8524708151817322,
0.6226116418838501,
0.22523851692676544,
-0.7911871671676636,
-0.3247300684452057,
-0.34828534722328186,
-0.5594383478164673,
0.44224250316619873,
-0.2863439917564392,
-0.2333400994539261,
-0.20226146280765533,
0.19887538254261017,
-0.1504545360803604,
0.5411471724510193,
-0.5774968266487122,
0.4624950587749481,
-0.23289136588573456,
-0.20151883363723755,
-0.38622933626174927,
-0.3664577007293701,
0.5026344656944275,
-0.30536550283432007,
0.2679251730442047,
-0.0810721218585968,
-0.04796180501580238,
0.23501096665859222,
-0.5257382988929749,
1.17031729221344,
-0.2550685703754425,
-0.1633160412311554,
0.3777341842651367,
0.17488045990467072,
1.022829532623291,
0.12671349942684174,
0.08614394813776016,
0.05174142122268677,
-0.2649247944355011,
-0.3359672725200653,
-0.49445393681526184,
0.6293764710426331,
-0.7317127585411072,
-0.6509411334991455,
-0.7225744128227234,
-0.5982167720794678,
-0.08371852338314056,
0.25423723459243774,
-0.019114317372441292,
0.27079376578330994,
-0.2359514832496643,
-0.06301772594451904,
0.757079005241394,
-0.1715019941329956,
0.35391244292259216,
1.1730848550796509,
-0.2584715485572815,
0.00794222578406334,
0.9451834559440613,
0.13897252082824707,
0.014698456041514874,
0.43632030487060547,
0.2519059479236603,
-0.34884390234947205,
-0.4271223545074463,
-0.4289124310016632,
0.32594066858291626,
-0.6240302324295044,
-0.23056595027446747,
-0.7209670543670654,
-0.42147186398506165,
-0.5049415826797485,
0.11296863108873367,
-0.5033918023109436,
-0.22678592801094055,
-0.07481300085783005,
-0.18800485134124756,
0.39182209968566895,
0.6969980597496033,
-0.0785842314362526,
0.3222386837005615,
-0.7588024735450745,
0.8482093811035156,
0.5786038637161255,
0.12454286217689514,
-0.2644791901111603,
-0.5921216607093811,
-0.2683562636375427,
0.12715093791484833,
-0.2846718430519104,
-1.060062289237976,
0.5387451648712158,
-0.03381075710058212,
0.7058297395706177,
0.45153164863586426,
0.22600893676280975,
0.12110812216997147,
-0.3290843069553375,
0.5888564586639404,
-0.1292874813079834,
-0.8978136777877808,
0.41043469309806824,
-0.5115761756896973,
-0.12987183034420013,
0.12996935844421387,
0.5369641184806824,
-0.3177991509437561,
-0.48874929547309875,
-0.5684772729873657,
-0.35305723547935486,
0.6332547664642334,
0.17248909175395966,
0.025333303958177567,
0.18037107586860657,
0.1586933434009552,
0.11971580237150192,
0.347797155380249,
-0.9811376333236694,
-0.21630215644836426,
-0.42452943325042725,
-0.11740673333406448,
0.06380729377269745,
-0.14869733154773712,
-0.2327788919210434,
-0.0381254106760025,
0.9684917330741882,
-0.33413830399513245,
0.1485130786895752,
0.4127442538738251,
-0.551658034324646,
-0.05497590824961662,
0.35634514689445496,
0.9373289346694946,
0.9721012711524963,
0.05458772927522659,
0.2882377803325653,
0.14642219245433807,
-0.33365491032600403,
0.28236865997314453,
0.15152329206466675,
-0.2094106674194336,
0.44452643394470215,
0.5163443088531494,
0.6879608631134033,
-0.17225435376167297,
-0.563230037689209,
0.8725593686103821,
0.04844743013381958,
-0.36258116364479065,
-0.5746526718139648,
-0.09415582567453384,
0.07083892077207565,
0.47490283846855164,
0.6612794399261475,
0.06866759806871414,
0.08543898165225983,
-0.6608501076698303,
0.23719704151153564,
0.32697176933288574,
-0.13287478685379028,
-0.4227726459503174,
0.33032092452049255,
0.2676236629486084,
-0.3990710973739624,
0.2335129827260971,
-0.49819043278694153,
-0.9030628800392151,
0.7829530239105225,
0.6777023077011108,
0.5648041367530823,
-0.3721769154071808,
0.7319537401199341,
-0.017458094283938408,
0.6967991590499878,
-0.46039828658103943,
-0.019678516313433647,
0.47109851241111755,
-0.9811052083969116,
-0.6983940005302429,
-0.46156975626945496,
-0.33009082078933716,
0.4962148666381836,
0.09083567559719086,
0.2856718599796295,
-0.333115816116333,
0.07991431653499603,
0.010224660858511925,
0.04576924815773964,
-0.4664616882801056,
0.28978073596954346,
0.3538602292537689,
1.2247751951217651,
-1.1294479370117188,
0.8241188526153564,
0.7158889770507812,
-0.30665352940559387,
-0.7789077758789062,
0.27363723516464233,
0.5172753930091858,
-0.6668310165405273,
0.6432406306266785,
0.1474904865026474,
-0.13533495366573334,
-0.1189238429069519,
-0.7830426096916199,
-0.5845307111740112,
0.8526022434234619,
0.7229676842689514,
-0.5173522233963013,
0.06387048214673996,
0.19201959669589996,
0.5895195603370667,
-0.44943860173225403,
0.18033693730831146,
0.29348260164260864,
0.8216645121574402,
0.2943479120731354,
-0.7403049468994141,
0.21932081878185272,
0.0068885572254657745,
-0.39722156524658203,
0.08010947704315186,
-0.7592651844024658,
0.9032938480377197,
-0.1532227098941803,
-0.06083497405052185,
-0.23612132668495178,
0.839928925037384,
0.3508976697921753,
0.694962739944458,
0.6815928816795349,
0.48743391036987305,
0.6745645999908447,
0.2505936622619629,
1.0527161359786987,
-0.13287313282489777,
0.2685627043247223,
0.9435750842094421,
-0.37755832076072693,
0.48234105110168457,
0.15653227269649506,
0.07160421460866928,
0.7167139053344727,
0.41916364431381226,
-0.1462995409965515,
0.014246024191379547,
0.032929204404354095,
-0.4789038598537445,
-0.5300884246826172,
-0.1643095165491104,
-0.010223009623587132,
0.5984752178192139,
0.12057602405548096,
-0.1698543131351471,
-0.42226308584213257,
0.164740189909935,
0.3537921905517578,
0.21292828023433685,
-0.43846723437309265,
0.35709598660469055,
-0.18831337988376617,
-0.6057425737380981,
0.25350990891456604,
0.2305886596441269,
0.5571926236152649,
-0.7646229863166809,
-0.30041369795799255,
-0.1383552849292755,
0.06667263805866241,
-0.26663362979888916,
-0.47774815559387207,
0.06423468142747879,
-0.035438552498817444,
-0.2897281050682068,
-0.004541341215372086,
1.2484744787216187,
-0.5096166133880615,
-0.4747696816921234,
0.06928865611553192,
0.7163002490997314,
0.0967932641506195,
-0.5891686081886292,
-0.6239169836044312,
0.09886158257722855,
-0.21402908861637115,
-0.5958550572395325,
0.07294906675815582,
0.4744652807712555,
-0.23989900946617126,
0.8616883754730225,
0.9498962759971619,
0.2824251651763916,
-0.052124954760074615,
0.14497849345207214,
0.7770541310310364,
-0.4014464020729065,
-0.6099084615707397,
-0.8246288895606995,
0.19125083088874817,
-0.40194395184516907,
0.3558761179447174,
0.8919215202331543,
0.5362136363983154,
0.41150638461112976,
-0.2764783501625061,
0.9631374478340149,
-0.013408112339675426,
0.7157184481620789,
-0.5469095706939697,
0.9403333067893982,
-0.42229458689689636,
0.18642176687717438,
0.12518170475959778,
-0.8576927781105042,
-0.12367040663957596,
0.3159710168838501,
-0.2423136681318283,
0.08858916908502579,
0.7365000247955322,
1.0031901597976685,
-0.19790421426296234,
-0.14674468338489532,
0.4729517102241516,
0.4876226782798767,
0.41462045907974243,
0.036245573312044144,
0.8545146584510803,
-0.2469625025987625,
0.5983423590660095,
0.21578095853328705,
-0.1549309343099594,
-0.5221717953681946,
-1.0499459505081177,
-1.1440340280532837,
-0.23278667032718658,
-0.46954959630966187,
-0.4017105996608734,
0.13531316816806793,
1.0388187170028687,
1.0131713151931763,
-0.5430985689163208,
0.2257509082555771,
0.1279030740261078,
0.4922029972076416,
-0.0037957692984491587,
-0.32449010014533997,
0.17437629401683807,
-0.1004529520869255,
-0.5869570374488831,
0.5667455196380615,
-0.0047372253611683846,
0.08881446719169617,
-0.3915855884552002,
-0.14421868324279785,
-0.4666690528392792,
0.6425946354866028,
0.7675827741622925,
0.43698710203170776,
-0.7144526839256287,
-0.5014225840568542,
-0.2738249599933624,
-0.19371937215328217,
-0.16322383284568787,
0.7500407695770264,
-0.9329602718353271,
0.0841325893998146,
0.4046282470226288,
0.599197506904602,
0.46860116720199585,
0.04384075477719307,
0.21122510731220245,
-0.8465765118598938,
0.22030335664749146,
0.09991521388292313,
0.08163509517908096,
0.40333786606788635,
-0.6731769442558289,
0.283109188079834,
0.4884911775588989,
-0.47403451800346375,
-0.854497492313385,
0.20158937573432922,
-0.9176444411277771,
-0.43760815262794495,
1.2300516366958618,
0.14643241465091705,
-0.5355446934700012,
-0.41142967343330383,
-0.2563401162624359,
0.3432006537914276,
-0.6422649621963501,
0.7687990069389343,
0.5840479731559753,
0.11746136844158173,
-0.26929017901420593,
-0.8222576379776001,
0.4130677282810211,
-0.15516173839569092,
-1.1554080247879028,
-0.2146184891462326,
0.5344396233558655,
0.6366449594497681,
0.2273922562599182,
0.6341294646263123,
0.16280244290828705,
0.43209904432296753,
0.09435650706291199,
0.3357698619365692,
-0.36838555335998535,
-0.44809824228286743,
0.05838974565267563,
0.09413498640060425,
-0.20052525401115417,
-0.09149680286645889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19260v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19260v1
|
Aspect and Opinion Term Extraction Using Graph Attention Network
| 2024-04-30T04:53:59 | 2024-04-30T04:53:59 |
Abir Chakraborty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work we investigate the capability of Graph Attention Network for
extracting aspect and opinion terms. Aspect and opinion term extraction is
posed as a token-level classification task akin to named entity recognition. We
use the dependency tree of the input query as additional feature in a Graph
Attention Network along with the token and part-of-speech features. We show
that the dependency structure is a powerful feature that in the presence of a
CRF layer substantially improves the performance and generates the best result
on the commonly used datasets from SemEval 2014, 2015 and 2016. We experiment
with additional layers like BiLSTM and Transformer in addition to the CRF
layer. We also show that our approach works well in the presence of multiple
aspects or sentiments in the same query and it is not necessary to modify the
dependency tree based on a single aspect as was the original application for
sentiment classification.
|
[
-0.7822739481925964,
-0.9881208539009094,
0.43196120858192444,
0.25795623660087585,
-0.345284640789032,
0.18491846323013306,
0.05157919228076935,
-0.5519998669624329,
0.7148703932762146,
0.7781554460525513,
-0.3246992826461792,
-0.5796759128570557,
-0.7159600853919983,
-0.029979707673192024,
-0.2939482033252716,
1.0799907445907593,
-0.010492715984582901,
0.11083801835775375,
-0.2407684326171875,
-0.4492005407810211,
-0.26965102553367615,
-0.8344510197639465,
-0.9688469767570496,
-0.38815397024154663,
0.8300321698188782,
0.18423639237880707,
0.2960093021392822,
0.4572530686855316,
0.5770652890205383,
0.29450058937072754,
-0.34610840678215027,
0.10280777513980865,
-0.18759147822856903,
0.2873578369617462,
-0.3740495443344116,
-0.1303447186946869,
-0.6435547471046448,
0.06609659641981125,
0.5685146450996399,
0.6486513018608093,
0.24503116309642792,
0.13672727346420288,
0.3146739900112152,
0.8713203072547913,
-0.2931850850582123,
0.6505919694900513,
-0.5121347904205322,
0.20959028601646423,
-0.14055772125720978,
-0.2466965764760971,
-0.29100722074508667,
-0.17444486916065216,
0.3650917708873749,
-0.03882816806435585,
0.40463846921920776,
0.23458026349544525,
1.0312821865081787,
-0.11051638424396515,
-0.4975678324699402,
-0.02073804847896099,
-0.6701754331588745,
0.39382264018058777,
-0.5614798665046692,
0.595212459564209,
0.058060191571712494,
-0.018771128728985786,
-0.009173670783638954,
-0.9120233654975891,
-0.50640469789505,
0.1990014910697937,
-0.18167856335639954,
0.2705119848251343,
-0.11413389444351196,
0.4416915774345398,
0.014415491372346878,
0.8190582394599915,
-0.14832958579063416,
-0.13526993989944458,
-0.15237191319465637,
-0.4327736496925354,
0.27213725447654724,
0.1164698600769043,
-0.041034113615751266,
-1.045539140701294,
-0.27096500992774963,
0.02927176095545292,
-0.5497159361839294,
0.4552609920501709,
0.3160364627838135,
0.5763455629348755,
0.2803221642971039,
0.5990712642669678,
-0.3441239297389984,
0.5115761160850525,
0.11543679982423782,
0.01685839518904686,
0.5081596374511719,
-0.3465408980846405,
-0.33109286427497864,
0.05215434357523918,
0.9441918134689331,
0.11154154688119888,
-0.322030633687973,
-0.1729305386543274,
-0.18300031125545502,
-0.1579051911830902,
0.3002551794052124,
-0.7512227892875671,
-0.27008435130119324,
0.39384549856185913,
-0.4824031889438629,
-0.4374862015247345,
0.27988630533218384,
-0.867573082447052,
-0.4552326798439026,
-0.41978833079338074,
0.03603058680891991,
-0.2805112898349762,
-0.48378562927246094,
-0.37242400646209717,
-0.11493818461894989,
0.11113370954990387,
0.17917822301387787,
-0.40670472383499146,
0.27134785056114197,
1.0201274156570435,
0.8228604197502136,
-0.3217455744743347,
0.12600953876972198,
-0.5962910652160645,
-0.22750012576580048,
-0.03258809447288513,
0.962474524974823,
-0.70804762840271,
-0.24267591536045074,
-0.17671780288219452,
0.4737052321434021,
-0.09599725157022476,
-0.42146793007850647,
0.3688347339630127,
-0.789692223072052,
0.36133190989494324,
-0.1502765566110611,
-0.529714047908783,
-0.700577974319458,
0.594735860824585,
-0.8710423111915588,
1.1405062675476074,
0.3070543706417084,
-1.030990719795227,
0.28187665343284607,
-0.8875545263290405,
-0.6503393650054932,
0.15732000768184662,
-0.2463524043560028,
-0.43405967950820923,
-0.07777240127325058,
0.3702228367328644,
0.3725293278694153,
0.019346769899129868,
-0.1039203554391861,
-0.48072758316993713,
0.31200921535491943,
0.23730896413326263,
-0.13543257117271423,
0.7021220922470093,
-0.0010938291670754552,
-0.34636780619621277,
0.34002685546875,
-0.5042792558670044,
0.1168564110994339,
-0.0997839942574501,
-0.3446299135684967,
-0.36441895365715027,
-0.00155546423047781,
0.17928685247898102,
0.3245477080345154,
0.19998714327812195,
-0.7432426810264587,
-0.10747905820608139,
-0.7013249397277832,
0.739730179309845,
0.6232932209968567,
0.722873330116272,
0.41667911410331726,
0.457693487405777,
0.625696063041687,
0.5507431626319885,
0.18955953419208527,
0.13002151250839233,
-0.3476180136203766,
-1.0087982416152954,
0.03476062789559364,
0.6927406191825867,
0.4468236565589905,
-0.9027338027954102,
0.4721797704696655,
-0.24642470479011536,
-0.15844684839248657,
-0.44003430008888245,
0.13135650753974915,
0.3665015697479248,
0.7220219373703003,
0.11617594212293625,
-0.7367095351219177,
-0.4829559624195099,
-0.9985018372535706,
-0.06333385407924652,
-0.534195065498352,
0.39281728863716125,
0.8008520603179932,
0.14765731990337372,
0.2585315704345703,
1.1202170848846436,
-0.5783224701881409,
-0.32537174224853516,
-0.45933181047439575,
0.1250094324350357,
0.19411827623844147,
0.07855748385190964,
0.4364567995071411,
-1.017748236656189,
-0.13276852667331696,
0.18918399512767792,
-0.5693010091781616,
0.14016194641590118,
0.36297816038131714,
-0.30711695551872253,
0.1270151138305664,
0.15783415734767914,
-0.4770737886428833,
0.24525606632232666,
0.21915201842784882,
-0.2915521562099457,
0.1282782256603241,
0.32202664017677307,
0.17697235941886902,
-1.2645171880722046,
-0.07740217447280884,
0.23794522881507874,
-0.7624527215957642,
-0.4022524356842041,
0.04950378090143204,
-0.10184051841497421,
-0.17781367897987366,
-0.627250611782074,
0.18791809678077698,
-0.32103249430656433,
-0.2655467391014099,
-0.4040602743625641,
0.42856088280677795,
0.5468059182167053,
0.7339571118354797,
0.0837552398443222,
0.386288046836853,
0.41675394773483276,
-0.4332636594772339,
0.4824063777923584,
0.17179228365421295,
-0.07000480592250824,
0.43292784690856934,
-0.5321140289306641,
0.6325192451477051,
-0.14269033074378967,
0.09198214113712311,
-0.8348340392112732,
-0.09944015741348267,
0.6605365872383118,
-0.3271648585796356,
0.45745715498924255,
-0.28371649980545044,
-0.316606730222702,
-0.5300859808921814,
-0.23854754865169525,
-0.0102278683334589,
-0.06781487911939621,
-0.2787652611732483,
0.7880146503448486,
0.7959576845169067,
-0.2444198876619339,
-0.49287381768226624,
-0.2898451089859009,
0.2180294245481491,
-0.295775830745697,
-0.2752969563007355,
0.23596231639385223,
0.5512705445289612,
0.09615650027990341,
0.4387415051460266,
-0.11323821544647217,
-0.04484285041689873,
0.00022405291383620352,
0.5638758540153503,
0.17633779346942902,
-0.38212862610816956,
0.10904315859079361,
-0.014703894034028053,
-0.05685260891914368,
0.05042529106140137,
-0.2763986587524414,
0.7156349420547485,
-0.28915345668792725,
-0.018575018271803856,
-0.31399425864219666,
0.4735536575317383,
0.46473443508148193,
-0.5413590669631958,
0.45210251212120056,
0.38742804527282715,
-0.3364626467227936,
-0.02543369121849537,
-0.3589255213737488,
-0.005145343020558357,
-0.3810689151287079,
0.8155221939086914,
-0.30430176854133606,
-1.1036864519119263,
0.5624005794525146,
-0.1261344999074936,
-0.023366201668977737,
0.6870315074920654,
0.255715936422348,
0.04571028798818588,
1.0998775959014893,
0.6250389814376831,
-0.45491737127304077,
0.8766810297966003,
-0.30159321427345276,
0.38595306873321533,
-1.2316513061523438,
-0.21517160534858704,
-0.48706457018852234,
-0.4279532730579376,
-0.38753968477249146,
0.028463536873459816,
0.267938494682312,
0.3520005941390991,
-0.02899753674864769,
0.46523213386535645,
-0.7483328580856323,
0.07054653763771057,
0.28336212038993835,
0.5283474922180176,
0.09017288684844971,
0.17326559126377106,
0.2088865488767624,
0.15000833570957184,
-0.3035608232021332,
-0.4104647636413574,
0.6722623109817505,
0.48587626218795776,
0.10836897045373917,
-0.1876879334449768,
0.6352921724319458,
0.2741948366165161,
0.3667168915271759,
-1.2537708282470703,
0.5936388969421387,
-0.14356790482997894,
-0.4436807930469513,
-0.3911292254924774,
-0.5729401707649231,
-0.7935382723808289,
0.27544790506362915,
0.07099377363920212,
-0.8741400241851807,
0.36649662256240845,
-0.008987241424620152,
-0.19577659666538239,
0.14199233055114746,
-0.6133822798728943,
0.7642000913619995,
0.11014053970575333,
0.031677741557359695,
-0.10822489112615585,
-0.6408120393753052,
0.038996558636426926,
0.21668757498264313,
-0.0471544973552227,
-0.1430092453956604,
0.22530856728553772,
1.1609230041503906,
-0.3867858052253723,
0.7830333113670349,
-0.32635319232940674,
0.3257906436920166,
0.5415458679199219,
-0.13314390182495117,
0.3925442695617676,
0.28572148084640503,
-0.15162421762943268,
0.49838826060295105,
-0.2553527057170868,
0.045198339968919754,
-0.7738428711891174,
0.6542946696281433,
-0.691579282283783,
-0.8741869330406189,
-0.13042421638965607,
-0.23089070618152618,
-0.37395238876342773,
0.470232754945755,
0.0782734677195549,
0.8363451957702637,
-0.11611641943454742,
0.07017232477664948,
0.2278904765844345,
0.29157671332359314,
0.6875754594802856,
0.04387848451733589,
-0.4944170117378235,
-0.8233055472373962,
0.9485754370689392,
0.3065517842769623,
0.08267919719219208,
0.3936469554901123,
0.13523243367671967,
-0.2946697771549225,
-0.5364171862602234,
-0.5897356271743774,
0.012300209142267704,
-0.8262113332748413,
-0.546261727809906,
-1.0876290798187256,
-0.6999880075454712,
-0.6012492775917053,
0.6644713282585144,
-0.31771108508110046,
-0.6875693798065186,
-0.15692071616649628,
-0.39289921522140503,
0.5821325778961182,
0.8439661860466003,
0.545862078666687,
0.27112141251564026,
-0.7972115278244019,
-0.054754458367824554,
0.18155686557292938,
0.24204522371292114,
0.13502685725688934,
-0.23142430186271667,
-0.2723251283168793,
-0.2338564246892929,
-0.7222530841827393,
-0.961642861366272,
0.15480023622512817,
0.1681203544139862,
0.41558119654655457,
0.5445888638496399,
-0.013571350835263729,
0.4670628011226654,
-0.15526096522808075,
0.9353597164154053,
0.19141338765621185,
-0.9917150139808655,
0.5561116933822632,
0.1097525879740715,
0.001757413032464683,
0.563700258731842,
0.049993548542261124,
-0.44923216104507446,
-0.6104385256767273,
-0.7843896150588989,
-0.9638363718986511,
0.9598653316497803,
0.20892789959907532,
-0.004298805724829435,
-0.13032007217407227,
0.6621956825256348,
-0.041974153369665146,
0.46235543489456177,
-0.4068595767021179,
-0.47877535223960876,
-0.4323558807373047,
-0.21452730894088745,
0.29898887872695923,
-0.2195868343114853,
-0.002777464222162962,
-0.24266059696674347,
0.5737892389297485,
-0.04152878373861313,
0.3096294105052948,
0.4063740372657776,
0.1934690773487091,
0.06965567916631699,
0.2950397729873657,
-0.09651588648557663,
0.48366788029670715,
0.046438444405794144,
0.49780261516571045,
0.05774084851145744,
-0.6417255401611328,
-0.17556586861610413,
0.08251389116048813,
-0.15111680328845978,
0.02992897666990757,
0.3519423007965088,
1.0533097982406616,
-0.09384502470493317,
0.3135278820991516,
0.5212047696113586,
-0.02064061351120472,
-0.010305742733180523,
-0.09441016614437103,
0.03834536671638489,
0.18089105188846588,
0.37563425302505493,
0.02037094533443451,
0.256280779838562,
0.5192719101905823,
-0.4333934187889099,
0.11386490613222122,
0.37963101267814636,
-1.1770576238632202,
-0.3994556665420532,
0.27231553196907043,
0.13962918519973755,
-0.6017050743103027,
0.3994446098804474,
-0.24853931367397308,
-1.0894789695739746,
0.7749752402305603,
0.33187657594680786,
1.1004257202148438,
-0.03291875123977661,
0.3957858979701996,
0.119092658162117,
-0.16005367040634155,
0.33791229128837585,
0.32269448041915894,
0.03581283614039421,
-0.7451775670051575,
-0.33762750029563904,
-0.6978115439414978,
-0.21057476103305817,
0.194537952542305,
-0.7164146900177002,
0.15591977536678314,
-0.6301628947257996,
-0.6015499234199524,
0.46554189920425415,
-0.04369420185685158,
-0.678552508354187,
0.27041423320770264,
-0.11762795597314835,
0.3502272665500641,
-0.48728567361831665,
0.6542031168937683,
1.0812137126922607,
-0.5303396582603455,
-1.168639898300171,
-0.07533399015665054,
-0.25067049264907837,
-0.5006881356239319,
0.5944733619689941,
0.33682116866111755,
-0.2247004210948944,
-0.023938145488500595,
-0.28263673186302185,
-0.6388170123100281,
0.8573251366615295,
-0.006269325036555529,
-0.25217148661613464,
-0.03469421714544296,
0.10951652377843857,
0.5013582706451416,
-0.8003461956977844,
0.09947145730257034,
0.5037460923194885,
0.24465906620025635,
0.0951068103313446,
-0.6053912043571472,
0.15866263210773468,
-0.2946960926055908,
0.03811969608068466,
0.526275098323822,
-0.7112597227096558,
0.6774476766586304,
0.3353545069694519,
-0.3744960427284241,
-0.632057249546051,
1.0055209398269653,
-0.3135615885257721,
0.3993349075317383,
1.0560731887817383,
0.3617154061794281,
0.6340736150741577,
-0.06416063755750656,
0.7899740934371948,
-0.511081874370575,
0.7293550968170166,
1.03242027759552,
-0.18334078788757324,
0.8409945964813232,
0.45154544711112976,
-0.18670780956745148,
0.5684922933578491,
1.0064375400543213,
0.2763596475124359,
0.6351743936538696,
-0.1219215989112854,
-0.15526250004768372,
-0.2834942936897278,
-0.47305798530578613,
-0.2170456200838089,
0.3532911539077759,
0.3529127836227417,
-0.6702359914779663,
-0.07694556564092636,
0.2942654490470886,
0.12635570764541626,
-0.5515633225440979,
-0.4597989320755005,
1.1140389442443848,
0.3878863751888275,
-0.5393718481063843,
-0.28180474042892456,
-0.2510010600090027,
0.042226046323776245,
-0.026350682601332664,
-0.15918755531311035,
-0.06493502855300903,
0.07026094943284988,
-0.47515127062797546,
-0.9555131793022156,
0.2456361949443817,
-0.30994248390197754,
-0.4249805212020874,
0.1251489520072937,
0.7636206746101379,
-0.26056036353111267,
-0.5892520546913147,
0.3553767800331116,
0.43028461933135986,
0.11623930186033249,
-0.20796102285385132,
-0.7089298963546753,
-0.35036948323249817,
0.04068899527192116,
-0.752044677734375,
0.03809979185461998,
0.7224874496459961,
0.02258657105267048,
0.10215337574481964,
0.3622499108314514,
0.30981341004371643,
-0.3184400200843811,
0.32707205414772034,
1.146663784980774,
-0.6571714878082275,
-0.7160025238990784,
-0.8385428786277771,
0.040395256131887436,
-0.6000658869743347,
-0.3739948570728302,
0.6405454874038696,
0.5818431377410889,
0.4776589870452881,
0.4891902506351471,
0.7594862580299377,
-0.2639443576335907,
0.5090186595916748,
-0.355764240026474,
0.5593603849411011,
-0.41796228289604187,
0.14654627442359924,
-0.44515395164489746,
-1.224531888961792,
-0.1806860864162445,
0.07478263974189758,
-0.4985339939594269,
0.0341922752559185,
1.1534249782562256,
0.6392039060592651,
0.02664904110133648,
0.5566246509552002,
-0.15439346432685852,
0.14010193943977356,
0.5921990275382996,
0.1885339915752411,
0.5131383538246155,
-0.28422582149505615,
0.37294358015060425,
-0.44215643405914307,
-0.200452983379364,
0.009870256297290325,
-0.6971702575683594,
-0.8161941766738892,
-0.5943758487701416,
-0.6485130786895752,
-0.8191830515861511,
-0.36505818367004395,
0.7954826354980469,
0.680851936340332,
-1.0474551916122437,
0.43558046221733093,
-0.10635214298963547,
0.35073286294937134,
-0.18774175643920898,
-0.36105701327323914,
0.9454120397567749,
-0.37110528349876404,
-0.6548166275024414,
0.06849577277898788,
0.5732887983322144,
-0.2570212483406067,
-0.47727951407432556,
0.38988539576530457,
0.0953579768538475,
-0.16640309989452362,
0.6777282953262329,
-0.01948148012161255,
-0.5849018692970276,
-1.015380859375,
-0.0016713457880541682,
-0.11347004771232605,
0.4670507311820984,
1.1293329000473022,
-0.5685192346572876,
0.34903430938720703,
0.688517153263092,
0.6114761829376221,
0.6153936982154846,
0.2740820348262787,
0.24028466641902924,
-0.6672926545143127,
-0.05325063690543175,
0.2581196427345276,
0.5752036571502686,
0.47066840529441833,
-0.7607506513595581,
0.3646807372570038,
0.40974554419517517,
-0.5037193894386292,
-0.3515530526638031,
0.2383110225200653,
-1.2693822383880615,
0.0702381506562233,
1.1350712776184082,
-0.361819326877594,
-0.6670039296150208,
-0.49576395750045776,
-0.34092408418655396,
0.42293015122413635,
-0.6299144625663757,
0.6280452013015747,
0.8321074843406677,
-0.6370752453804016,
-0.3175742030143738,
-0.2365480214357376,
0.10395660251379013,
0.1962648630142212,
-0.770740270614624,
0.05624537169933319,
0.20896366238594055,
0.22453263401985168,
0.48715516924858093,
0.5006299018859863,
-0.4877477288246155,
-0.35755422711372375,
-0.2051977962255478,
0.07503139972686768,
-0.2208261489868164,
-0.3287971615791321,
-0.1523723304271698,
0.7228949069976807,
0.05491269379854202,
-0.39631950855255127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19254v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19254v1
|
Suvach -- Generated Hindi QA benchmark
| 2024-04-30T04:19:17 | 2024-04-30T04:19:17 |
Vaishak Narayanan, Prabin Raj KP, Saifudheen Nouphal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Current evaluation benchmarks for question answering (QA) in Indic languages
often rely on machine translation of existing English datasets. This approach
suffers from bias and inaccuracies inherent in machine translation, leading to
datasets that may not reflect the true capabilities of EQA models for Indic
languages. This paper proposes a new benchmark specifically designed for
evaluating Hindi EQA models and discusses the methodology to do the same for
any task. This method leverages large language models (LLMs) to generate a
high-quality dataset in an extractive setting, ensuring its relevance for the
target language. We believe this new resource will foster advancements in Hindi
NLP research by providing a more accurate and reliable evaluation tool.
|
[
-0.3570135533809662,
-0.5034533739089966,
0.3226219117641449,
0.31155410408973694,
-0.34715569019317627,
0.3511459231376648,
0.15762121975421906,
-0.4170428216457367,
-0.05607171729207039,
0.19433677196502686,
-0.45465174317359924,
-0.4324765205383301,
-0.39698028564453125,
0.49711984395980835,
-0.7542073726654053,
0.45322293043136597,
-0.11314308643341064,
0.26768845319747925,
-0.32700252532958984,
-0.39215216040611267,
-0.592332661151886,
-0.25393080711364746,
-0.6311219930648804,
-0.24529559910297394,
0.13677987456321716,
0.40509772300720215,
0.5438827276229858,
0.3354288935661316,
0.500200629234314,
0.20931914448738098,
-0.018664589151740074,
0.2783246636390686,
-0.25870564579963684,
0.2603432536125183,
0.03869849815964699,
-0.5400387048721313,
-0.07574965804815292,
0.013461587019264698,
0.7353822588920593,
0.4068785607814789,
-0.618280291557312,
0.6095283031463623,
-0.35298487544059753,
0.5160391926765442,
-0.6577202081680298,
0.08513570576906204,
-0.6419312953948975,
0.014503533020615578,
-0.026043782010674477,
-0.03437637537717819,
-0.28703275322914124,
-0.9649947285652161,
-0.24687130749225616,
-0.4197625517845154,
-0.152668297290802,
0.2768316864967346,
1.121168851852417,
0.4309825003147125,
-0.3141332268714905,
-0.1564936339855194,
-0.7166157960891724,
0.7520617246627808,
-0.8704918622970581,
0.6411372423171997,
0.07815821468830109,
0.9012959599494934,
0.07863759994506836,
-0.6346225738525391,
-0.8064545392990112,
-0.13103435933589935,
0.22406354546546936,
0.09083372354507446,
-0.20537662506103516,
-0.3885827958583832,
0.025067469105124474,
0.5733634829521179,
-0.5135474801063538,
0.05308803170919418,
-0.3475133776664734,
0.1820780336856842,
0.5752763748168945,
0.25831106305122375,
0.5722018480300903,
-0.3140026330947876,
-0.3618912696838379,
-0.3245202898979187,
-1.0097591876983643,
0.04980513080954552,
0.29322463274002075,
0.04875561594963074,
0.07294310629367828,
0.95964515209198,
-0.42398685216903687,
0.582172691822052,
0.09356029331684113,
-0.1600770205259323,
0.31643903255462646,
-0.3569912016391754,
-0.39195898175239563,
0.05359963700175285,
0.5199260115623474,
0.3243076205253601,
0.20703549683094025,
-0.3651406168937683,
-0.1841071993112564,
-0.23093095421791077,
0.18866832554340363,
-0.7058795094490051,
0.08940839767456055,
0.22908762097358704,
-0.13635200262069702,
-0.04895035922527313,
-0.14790940284729004,
-1.0192186832427979,
-0.2794759273529053,
-0.25306135416030884,
0.19359275698661804,
-0.2622348964214325,
-0.23586733639240265,
-0.10526516288518906,
0.2074325829744339,
1.2850000858306885,
0.13014118373394012,
-0.5035845041275024,
0.4778220057487488,
0.45757636427879333,
0.5177233219146729,
-0.41050633788108826,
-0.17613983154296875,
-0.7720276713371277,
-0.04712425917387009,
-0.6499439477920532,
1.1308703422546387,
-0.7545790672302246,
-0.3310418128967285,
0.03512908145785332,
-0.26613718271255493,
0.050325434654951096,
-0.9078277349472046,
0.7440304756164551,
-0.8242389559745789,
-0.006746632046997547,
-0.4328625798225403,
-0.44914302229881287,
-0.1351088583469391,
0.25530290603637695,
-0.5115043520927429,
1.3590179681777954,
0.3330955505371094,
-0.3414660096168518,
0.558486819267273,
-0.2977736294269562,
-0.1887054443359375,
0.22967267036437988,
-0.38985204696655273,
-0.32452934980392456,
-0.13334967195987701,
0.7338185906410217,
0.08188652247190475,
-1.062555193901062,
0.38160261511802673,
0.024808213114738464,
-0.22622406482696533,
0.2328527718782425,
-0.2044769525527954,
0.5484325885772705,
0.4915548264980316,
-0.04155202955007553,
0.04475384205579758,
-0.8556414842605591,
0.6024160981178284,
0.1904556006193161,
-0.2845192849636078,
-0.010209287516772747,
-0.3387775719165802,
-0.13631878793239594,
0.41266298294067383,
0.056586265563964844,
-0.7194010019302368,
-0.17106764018535614,
-0.6393769979476929,
-0.0037795142270624638,
0.7410760521888733,
0.14727336168289185,
0.09018304198980331,
-0.2531534731388092,
1.0438024997711182,
-0.13326065242290497,
-0.05230673402547836,
0.3433140814304352,
-0.4847152829170227,
-0.6332107782363892,
-0.126346617937088,
0.554674506187439,
0.5689283609390259,
-0.6399116516113281,
0.011857142671942711,
-0.2819681763648987,
-0.76378333568573,
-0.8917791247367859,
0.31067925691604614,
0.6249310374259949,
0.2628210484981537,
0.3011487126350403,
-0.3328542113304138,
-0.40896114706993103,
-0.9609333276748657,
-0.4362582564353943,
-0.21512408554553986,
-0.10991787910461426,
0.2834695279598236,
0.2205963432788849,
0.13218694925308228,
0.7572025060653687,
-0.5181025266647339,
0.0729314535856247,
-0.40103259682655334,
0.15529420971870422,
-0.05672731250524521,
0.21774092316627502,
0.38676586747169495,
-0.8310858607292175,
-0.5397132635116577,
-0.25283414125442505,
-0.7826324701309204,
-0.45491823554039,
0.14846846461296082,
-0.28944483399391174,
-0.1850210577249527,
0.5275167226791382,
-0.6719304323196411,
0.30572837591171265,
0.4350423216819763,
-0.10468439012765884,
0.6679377555847168,
0.1487504243850708,
0.4805830121040344,
-1.3423793315887451,
0.13103097677230835,
0.08054455369710922,
-0.045102037489414215,
-0.3273552656173706,
0.4039541780948639,
-0.027258122339844704,
-0.26119264960289,
-0.563625156879425,
0.715175211429596,
-0.4198998808860779,
-0.44595152139663696,
-0.04199622943997383,
0.29494357109069824,
-0.011384829878807068,
0.2597742974758148,
-0.37213194370269775,
1.355705976486206,
0.2899361252784729,
-0.35319769382476807,
0.34334033727645874,
0.6685797572135925,
-0.4575851559638977,
0.699978768825531,
-1.065010666847229,
0.21688289940357208,
-0.016769012436270714,
-0.18207231163978577,
-1.0233442783355713,
-0.19620256125926971,
0.12024649232625961,
-0.525253176689148,
0.2706310451030731,
0.1354445070028305,
-0.8430575132369995,
-0.16716404259204865,
-0.018882211297750473,
0.6403920650482178,
0.7722666263580322,
-0.6055643558502197,
0.7133592367172241,
0.6299002170562744,
-0.3326389789581299,
-0.4777757525444031,
-0.48594340682029724,
0.12015996128320694,
-0.2681778073310852,
-0.3085256516933441,
0.034782372415065765,
-0.0021975368726998568,
-0.357954740524292,
-0.28899404406547546,
-0.19962875545024872,
-0.3408295214176178,
-0.2334575653076172,
0.14698615670204163,
0.023421000689268112,
-0.24484841525554657,
0.09418032318353653,
0.16877809166908264,
0.09797386080026627,
0.2346121072769165,
0.30907490849494934,
0.6103976964950562,
-0.22685392200946808,
-0.5107749700546265,
-0.3533296585083008,
0.41480398178100586,
0.525978684425354,
-0.626796305179596,
0.496338427066803,
0.44665828347206116,
-0.3596579134464264,
-0.06263270974159241,
-0.7327377796173096,
0.17722955346107483,
-0.4424685835838318,
0.30873751640319824,
-0.5374180674552917,
-0.26639190316200256,
0.5409805178642273,
-0.2528305947780609,
-0.07823015749454498,
0.736055850982666,
0.6462970972061157,
0.35102012753486633,
1.0999555587768555,
0.5057353973388672,
-0.051541656255722046,
-0.15209324657917023,
0.08282529562711716,
0.4436241090297699,
-1.0751216411590576,
-0.37318193912506104,
-0.856070876121521,
0.20552149415016174,
-0.5261748433113098,
-0.42205381393432617,
0.38395896553993225,
0.009359988383948803,
-0.21267040073871613,
0.3284958600997925,
-0.6562143564224243,
0.333178848028183,
0.40074101090431213,
-0.22540681064128876,
0.3712652921676636,
-0.2167065143585205,
-0.2196815311908722,
0.07515467703342438,
-0.5427491664886475,
-0.5569730401039124,
1.1937706470489502,
-0.024573642760515213,
0.7747933268547058,
0.3418619632720947,
0.4432311952114105,
0.25672778487205505,
0.46117329597473145,
-0.23216037452220917,
0.6927657723426819,
0.24657268822193146,
-0.5180556178092957,
-0.2514646351337433,
-0.25882095098495483,
-0.7665036916732788,
0.20102433860301971,
-0.04439022019505501,
-0.7096956372261047,
0.0862991064786911,
-0.34848013520240784,
-0.18555350601673126,
0.13102807104587555,
-0.7634029388427734,
0.6303837299346924,
-0.1021805852651596,
-0.17072860896587372,
-0.005617546383291483,
-0.3466845154762268,
0.4547555446624756,
-0.048195980489254,
-0.2016504555940628,
-0.46728602051734924,
-0.09154849499464035,
0.8466789126396179,
-0.22728486359119415,
0.3314889967441559,
-0.03835723549127579,
-0.019197115674614906,
0.5181344151496887,
-0.003634844673797488,
0.37559884786605835,
0.29852989315986633,
-0.35386794805526733,
-0.198237806558609,
0.3320859968662262,
-0.6228452920913696,
-0.4589707851409912,
0.6955382823944092,
-0.9165776371955872,
-0.5507912039756775,
-0.4827125668525696,
-0.6015869379043579,
-0.6007534861564636,
-0.011139768175780773,
-0.18995264172554016,
0.3148869276046753,
-0.1400001347064972,
0.004172688815742731,
0.4469519555568695,
-0.4350038468837738,
-0.014772924594581127,
0.5319861173629761,
-0.2654305398464203,
-0.1888354867696762,
0.6530500054359436,
-0.1460280567407608,
0.19203627109527588,
0.31246912479400635,
-0.1119304746389389,
-0.677497386932373,
-0.6851340532302856,
-0.8473531603813171,
0.0928305834531784,
-1.0953924655914307,
-0.3764025568962097,
-0.52519690990448,
-0.48346051573753357,
-0.3482864201068878,
0.18069511651992798,
-0.42798441648483276,
-0.18715491890907288,
0.22986960411071777,
-0.14591273665428162,
0.3730965852737427,
0.8153053522109985,
0.3823978900909424,
-0.12420365959405899,
-0.7342043519020081,
0.5321753025054932,
0.574337363243103,
0.39957210421562195,
0.05701537802815437,
-0.6304563879966736,
0.06678622961044312,
-0.14853183925151825,
-0.3102710545063019,
-0.8375099301338196,
0.49127262830734253,
0.2348591834306717,
0.7679063677787781,
-0.2241552174091339,
-0.021802790462970734,
0.6223787665367126,
-0.34045618772506714,
0.9144401550292969,
-0.018883202224969864,
-0.7706514000892639,
0.47350016236305237,
-0.09647969901561737,
0.7049528956413269,
0.8224066495895386,
0.42172345519065857,
-0.2910563349723816,
-0.4573563039302826,
-0.27502453327178955,
-0.8577088117599487,
0.022596677765250206,
0.3912348449230194,
-0.0001346837671007961,
-0.2357819825410843,
0.6136612892150879,
0.35277658700942993,
0.43045559525489807,
-0.46370023488998413,
-0.17691220343112946,
0.044831518083810806,
-0.2640717029571533,
0.03972969204187393,
-0.22665581107139587,
0.10374785959720612,
-0.392475426197052,
0.5760324001312256,
-0.09051071107387543,
0.3122474253177643,
0.22724811732769012,
-0.17394010722637177,
-0.2221945971250534,
0.46900424361228943,
0.23967070877552032,
1.1068456172943115,
-0.07570689916610718,
-0.21148018538951874,
0.5654064416885376,
-0.3442755341529846,
0.43491512537002563,
0.3512935936450958,
-0.3027939200401306,
-0.12951624393463135,
-0.13317272067070007,
0.2424781322479248,
0.020930122584104538,
-1.15102219581604,
0.27364158630371094,
-0.2956720292568207,
0.15256306529045105,
-0.4271288812160492,
-0.058710478246212006,
0.041925158351659775,
0.08366471529006958,
0.6802452802658081,
-0.2743830680847168,
0.1807800829410553,
-0.3993975520133972,
0.28942233324050903,
0.29795756936073303,
-0.34622395038604736,
-0.15347662568092346,
0.9009506106376648,
0.059321917593479156,
-0.20407390594482422,
0.7059978246688843,
-0.29320672154426575,
-0.3764415979385376,
0.6543854475021362,
0.34696120023727417,
0.9977256655693054,
-0.2733686566352844,
0.2949088513851166,
0.6334919929504395,
0.2896175980567932,
0.24572208523750305,
0.5272839069366455,
0.22764532268047333,
-0.34853464365005493,
-0.6262859106063843,
-0.9957600831985474,
-0.6068429350852966,
0.04585650935769081,
-0.6618384122848511,
0.07258526235818863,
-0.19154293835163116,
0.2500176727771759,
-0.03697812557220459,
0.0494612492620945,
-0.8977757692337036,
0.5760762095451355,
-0.09966124594211578,
0.8942311406135559,
-0.7504869103431702,
0.7090421915054321,
0.6126289367675781,
-0.6491105556488037,
-1.119336724281311,
0.07275822013616562,
-0.28333818912506104,
-0.9267281293869019,
0.7093703746795654,
-0.07962293922901154,
-0.27100273966789246,
0.051836855709552765,
-0.48832717537879944,
-1.1191989183425903,
1.1050597429275513,
0.32229483127593994,
-0.1433028131723404,
0.06802825629711151,
0.3708450198173523,
0.7214227914810181,
-0.48639845848083496,
0.28045493364334106,
0.5555496215820312,
0.3676465153694153,
0.08608773350715637,
-0.7719576954841614,
0.3145957291126251,
-0.5682496428489685,
0.0799342542886734,
0.15954582393169403,
-0.6030423045158386,
0.6301504373550415,
-0.121775783598423,
-0.4260978698730469,
0.43991002440452576,
0.7913483381271362,
0.271476686000824,
0.12812921404838562,
0.2708704173564911,
0.7442436218261719,
0.4925673007965088,
-0.16303865611553192,
1.2814133167266846,
-0.33963724970817566,
-0.0869402289390564,
1.194178581237793,
-0.6482452750205994,
1.0031753778457642,
0.6014523506164551,
-0.5641114115715027,
0.3042340874671936,
0.6152378916740417,
-0.1333371102809906,
0.44337567687034607,
0.43993982672691345,
0.033874161541461945,
-0.20656569302082062,
-0.375640332698822,
-0.41125497221946716,
0.6739869117736816,
-0.08753371983766556,
0.01540575921535492,
-0.4170446991920471,
-0.2676128149032593,
-0.37172606587409973,
0.3652772605419159,
-0.16961029171943665,
0.8299296498298645,
0.0037413649260997772,
-0.97198086977005,
0.6842511892318726,
0.04526835307478905,
0.1357172727584839,
-0.43549832701683044,
-0.3314336836338043,
-0.2673296332359314,
-0.2114439457654953,
0.08987487107515335,
-0.7265458703041077,
0.42501014471054077,
0.14674536883831024,
0.28780537843704224,
0.22348034381866455,
0.4617081582546234,
-0.27029046416282654,
-0.6444737315177917,
0.08925280719995499,
0.924657940864563,
0.2431037873029709,
0.1356343924999237,
-0.7121118307113647,
-0.11432671546936035,
-0.257127970457077,
-0.1361331194639206,
0.3778115212917328,
0.09519004821777344,
0.05395232513546944,
0.9815570712089539,
0.4747854173183441,
0.030364155769348145,
0.392972469329834,
0.1788366734981537,
0.8457332849502563,
-0.5607577562332153,
-0.16080957651138306,
-0.34800827503204346,
0.15113821625709534,
-0.1934271901845932,
-0.6644612550735474,
0.9308043718338013,
0.719448447227478,
0.7924700379371643,
0.09353817999362946,
0.598149836063385,
-0.1233566552400589,
0.720248281955719,
-0.4805475175380707,
0.546704888343811,
-0.5959608554840088,
0.411274254322052,
-0.09165455400943756,
-1.0149686336517334,
-0.007031172513961792,
0.0709591880440712,
-0.30089637637138367,
0.30027031898498535,
0.654002845287323,
0.8267022371292114,
0.11521676927804947,
0.03164687007665634,
0.3256757855415344,
0.032137442380189896,
0.2405204474925995,
0.496337354183197,
0.884101390838623,
-0.749648928642273,
0.7103869318962097,
-0.14891642332077026,
0.2273797243833542,
0.12004391849040985,
-0.6436079740524292,
-0.7055387496948242,
-0.7577884197235107,
-0.2658109962940216,
-0.209209606051445,
0.14535664021968842,
0.7677406072616577,
0.5326200723648071,
-0.9750520586967468,
-0.12740695476531982,
0.01608835533261299,
0.0935005396604538,
-0.39212220907211304,
-0.23018474876880646,
0.611794114112854,
-0.18890424072742462,
-0.7673594355583191,
0.2466314285993576,
0.1728384643793106,
-0.11291897296905518,
-0.3881753087043762,
-0.0009210184216499329,
-0.6948164701461792,
0.3493214547634125,
0.31423988938331604,
0.43431520462036133,
-0.7395404577255249,
-0.2755313813686371,
0.19982269406318665,
-0.09694620221853256,
0.43633967638015747,
0.41559290885925293,
-0.7291573286056519,
0.4816287159919739,
0.292277991771698,
0.9952079057693481,
0.344197541475296,
0.22349008917808533,
0.8553981781005859,
-0.6039899587631226,
-0.19864830374717712,
0.36598649621009827,
0.08280651271343231,
0.6177334189414978,
-0.17872396111488342,
0.6339242458343506,
-0.3645172417163849,
-0.5320395231246948,
-0.9914147257804871,
0.060902245342731476,
-0.7957450747489929,
0.07404973357915878,
1.1845535039901733,
-0.060460470616817474,
-0.3815143406391144,
-0.05292108654975891,
-0.14655613899230957,
0.31738191843032837,
-0.2222403585910797,
0.9470980763435364,
0.5216611623764038,
0.06826265156269073,
-0.3630978465080261,
-0.7072588205337524,
0.4885018467903137,
0.5794024467468262,
-1.246544599533081,
-0.12114139646291733,
0.11590001732110977,
0.2047208994626999,
-0.1436629295349121,
0.3950923979282379,
-0.4138542711734772,
0.5292791724205017,
0.06559427082538605,
0.12354656308889389,
0.24826431274414062,
-0.10991742461919785,
-0.12158916145563126,
0.28105348348617554,
0.5247379541397095,
-0.008676072582602501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19252v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19252v1
|
Exploiting Hatred by Targets for Hate Speech Detection on Vietnamese Social Media Texts
| 2024-04-30T04:16:55 | 2024-04-30T04:16:55 |
Cuong Nhat Vo, Khanh Bao Huynh, Son T. Luu, Trong-Hop Do
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The growth of social networks makes toxic content spread rapidly. Hate speech
detection is a task to help decrease the number of harmful comments. With the
diversity in the hate speech created by users, it is necessary to interpret the
hate speech besides detecting it. Hence, we propose a methodology to construct
a system for targeted hate speech detection from online streaming texts from
social media. We first introduce the ViTHSD - a targeted hate speech detection
dataset for Vietnamese Social Media Texts. The dataset contains 10K comments,
each comment is labeled to specific targets with three levels: clean,
offensive, and hate. There are 5 targets in the dataset, and each target is
labeled with the corresponding level manually by humans with strict annotation
guidelines. The inter-annotator agreement obtained from the dataset is 0.45 by
Cohen's Kappa index, which is indicated as a moderate level. Then, we construct
a baseline for this task by combining the Bi-GRU-LSTM-CNN with the pre-trained
language model to leverage the power of text representation of BERTology.
Finally, we suggest a methodology to integrate the baseline model for targeted
hate speech detection into the online streaming system for practical
application in preventing hateful and offensive content on social media.
|
[
-0.33713915944099426,
-0.9281913638114929,
0.212387353181839,
0.03043244406580925,
-0.6293477416038513,
-0.003200214821845293,
-0.30619576573371887,
-0.44176530838012695,
0.40991318225860596,
0.7991011142730713,
-0.42606469988822937,
-0.5783045291900635,
-0.9304288029670715,
-0.03406643867492676,
-0.51233971118927,
1.2372368574142456,
0.3491477370262146,
-0.1522858589887619,
0.43847009539604187,
-0.22509175539016724,
-0.19726577401161194,
-0.4813275933265686,
-0.49448198080062866,
0.05825474485754967,
0.9645450115203857,
0.4279843866825104,
0.3080773949623108,
0.5093762874603271,
0.5676974654197693,
0.26260510087013245,
-0.14793738722801208,
0.16393736004829407,
-0.8842341899871826,
0.3276379704475403,
-0.22615975141525269,
-0.20437785983085632,
-0.01609129086136818,
-0.09175955504179001,
0.5070575475692749,
-0.328131765127182,
0.3548867106437683,
0.261502742767334,
0.13178950548171997,
0.20900332927703857,
-0.48487934470176697,
-0.1778091937303543,
-0.9175220727920532,
-0.028582248836755753,
-0.3860264718532562,
-0.2214575558900833,
-0.2188938707113266,
-0.4971481263637543,
0.09386808425188065,
-0.21783240139484406,
0.13113822042942047,
-0.4821484684944153,
0.6166328191757202,
0.2601916193962097,
-0.3030887842178345,
-0.25746577978134155,
-0.8830193877220154,
0.724599301815033,
-0.6409539580345154,
0.24354836344718933,
0.26827123761177063,
0.46385183930397034,
0.32127317786216736,
-0.19705015420913696,
-0.6080788969993591,
-0.26997214555740356,
0.10489116609096527,
-0.035097960382699966,
-0.4524645507335663,
0.0075980788096785545,
0.17410558462142944,
0.09570711851119995,
-0.633273184299469,
0.2751324772834778,
-0.6090024709701538,
-0.26442623138427734,
0.9126650094985962,
-0.2718334197998047,
0.33341920375823975,
-0.4906976819038391,
-0.5372579097747803,
0.25883713364601135,
-0.18158914148807526,
-0.5621641278266907,
0.5780152678489685,
0.8211541771888733,
-0.055128831416368484,
0.7189745903015137,
-0.14767295122146606,
0.3865474760532379,
-0.1674119532108307,
-0.2150689959526062,
0.34893375635147095,
0.05220286548137665,
-0.04528717324137688,
0.2518423795700073,
0.6842936873435974,
0.7418482899665833,
0.7684980034828186,
0.08147510141134262,
-0.07738738507032394,
0.6353845596313477,
0.5054640173912048,
-0.5741894245147705,
0.018586406484246254,
-0.04531688615679741,
-0.39418601989746094,
-0.6399966478347778,
-0.23393845558166504,
-0.8737354278564453,
-0.8989594578742981,
-0.15003237128257751,
0.4777851104736328,
-0.4759887158870697,
-0.5447813868522644,
-0.48145490884780884,
-0.4242006540298462,
0.03268590196967125,
0.07812616229057312,
-0.3829157054424286,
0.14944753050804138,
0.5689762234687805,
0.9277681708335876,
-0.42092806100845337,
-0.052334755659103394,
-0.8847265839576721,
0.2198641151189804,
0.22278383374214172,
0.7347922921180725,
-0.5538442730903625,
-0.20621487498283386,
0.47306111454963684,
-0.3366512656211853,
0.43974798917770386,
-0.6395887136459351,
0.9388436675071716,
-0.5652769207954407,
-0.17288610339164734,
0.060654208064079285,
-0.6826027035713196,
-0.15257255733013153,
0.2360977828502655,
-0.4753018319606781,
0.9481121301651001,
0.1714501529932022,
-0.949928879737854,
0.30790746212005615,
-0.530720591545105,
-0.4096810221672058,
0.3629637062549591,
0.14004331827163696,
-0.5594832897186279,
-0.09236474335193634,
-0.031392257660627365,
0.6235248446464539,
0.08823442459106445,
0.011974716559052467,
-0.5015438795089722,
-0.26004838943481445,
-0.01955011487007141,
-0.23762905597686768,
0.9017875790596008,
0.6195096373558044,
-0.5488108396530151,
0.4003220200538635,
-0.5562670230865479,
-0.30428263545036316,
0.26588335633277893,
-0.20944643020629883,
-0.6896029710769653,
0.03496122732758522,
0.633195698261261,
0.32914480566978455,
-0.05418427661061287,
-0.8060275316238403,
-0.30633804202079773,
-0.043474774807691574,
0.2728137969970703,
1.0109975337982178,
0.0820017084479332,
0.0690668448805809,
-0.3051657974720001,
0.48625221848487854,
0.17449729144573212,
0.2698448896408081,
0.3474385738372803,
-0.4778679609298706,
-0.5893791913986206,
-0.23683610558509827,
-0.49813205003738403,
0.5294340252876282,
-0.741010844707489,
0.2460680902004242,
-0.09052562713623047,
-0.7651966214179993,
-0.5167180299758911,
0.16542038321495056,
0.3756028711795807,
0.37102848291397095,
0.6103280782699585,
0.07610297203063965,
-1.020110011100769,
-0.8579633831977844,
-0.6332234740257263,
-0.5167405009269714,
-0.005578433163464069,
0.1363881230354309,
0.11296818405389786,
-0.3596820831298828,
0.7355025410652161,
-0.39946967363357544,
-0.6273003220558167,
-0.276564359664917,
0.19067102670669556,
-0.35277050733566284,
0.071149080991745,
0.524189293384552,
-1.1772077083587646,
-0.8926277160644531,
-0.07637544721364975,
-0.46249285340309143,
-0.5777809619903564,
0.2519310414791107,
-0.19935843348503113,
-0.17170478403568268,
0.5401373505592346,
0.09612394124269485,
0.2644571363925934,
0.45395687222480774,
-0.25016114115715027,
0.49975138902664185,
0.5609226226806641,
0.23666532337665558,
-0.9908323884010315,
-0.5318918824195862,
0.5696592330932617,
-0.3445121645927429,
-0.9935013651847839,
-0.005871241446584463,
-0.5580998063087463,
0.04422527551651001,
-0.8320843577384949,
0.33219119906425476,
0.1580388844013214,
0.3786454498767853,
-0.43357357382774353,
0.30646759271621704,
-0.49299728870391846,
0.2274491786956787,
0.05076497420668602,
0.05373583361506462,
0.07474427670240402,
-0.44500890374183655,
0.5389005541801453,
-0.1630750298500061,
-0.13794605433940887,
0.8619851469993591,
-0.2772029936313629,
-0.02373962663114071,
-0.23609167337417603,
0.007674664258956909,
-0.7800260186195374,
0.056682880967855453,
0.6848193407058716,
-0.6245409250259399,
-0.34887248277664185,
-0.3235716223716736,
-0.28626561164855957,
-0.2880995571613312,
-0.3529222309589386,
0.35856175422668457,
0.14243566989898682,
-0.28525474667549133,
0.4073672294616699,
0.8030524253845215,
-0.07070442289113998,
-0.18141651153564453,
-0.714538037776947,
0.03354033827781677,
-0.8398399949073792,
-0.4038833677768707,
0.3138841688632965,
-0.023281563073396683,
-0.4394267499446869,
0.038762710988521576,
0.3999350368976593,
-0.23394626379013062,
-0.20304785668849945,
0.3635377585887909,
0.017342472448945045,
-0.2267138808965683,
-0.013212229125201702,
-0.15622466802597046,
0.24352967739105225,
0.08751555532217026,
-0.42426177859306335,
0.5357956290245056,
0.1484135389328003,
0.06075240299105644,
-0.5151946544647217,
0.4862014353275299,
0.6302842497825623,
0.004865669179707766,
0.48912471532821655,
0.9791173934936523,
-0.605585515499115,
-0.23651738464832306,
-0.7874457240104675,
-0.012969683855772018,
-0.39977073669433594,
0.3776179850101471,
0.0962086170911789,
-1.239560604095459,
0.13037556409835815,
0.4584908187389374,
-0.008709831163287163,
0.48323798179626465,
0.803688108921051,
0.08033864945173264,
0.7570041418075562,
0.46838992834091187,
-0.3299770951271057,
0.828684389591217,
0.09286192059516907,
0.07299461215734482,
-0.22982807457447052,
0.03511744737625122,
-0.5699747204780579,
-0.11801877617835999,
-0.7625812888145447,
-0.7125173807144165,
0.17328542470932007,
-0.388157457113266,
-0.32984375953674316,
0.5259913206100464,
-0.6725949048995972,
0.3504502773284912,
0.4079994559288025,
0.15167264640331268,
0.24915935099124908,
0.4860880970954895,
0.14694499969482422,
-0.39716947078704834,
-0.27410659193992615,
-0.3809155523777008,
0.8902572989463806,
0.4539168179035187,
0.30997538566589355,
-0.0019154733745381236,
0.7741808295249939,
0.853456974029541,
0.604779839515686,
-0.7300297617912292,
0.4538887143135071,
-0.3983660638332367,
-0.658425509929657,
-0.3602173328399658,
-0.4390653967857361,
-0.4631272852420807,
0.12722352147102356,
-0.03649557754397392,
-0.7836530804634094,
-0.09577187150716782,
-0.017661603167653084,
-0.053269512951374054,
0.6080485582351685,
-0.6298768520355225,
0.642000675201416,
-0.06363633275032043,
-0.13334113359451294,
-0.3687626123428345,
-0.27984896302223206,
0.39339739084243774,
-0.022230027243494987,
0.4373202919960022,
-0.2646210789680481,
0.13960647583007812,
0.9269276857376099,
-0.3295261263847351,
0.8856794834136963,
-0.407179057598114,
-0.1657177060842514,
0.5425637364387512,
-0.12858620285987854,
0.15997111797332764,
-0.39902937412261963,
-0.18872053921222687,
0.27493515610694885,
-0.47354796528816223,
-0.335418701171875,
-0.2746511995792389,
0.5815553665161133,
-0.6922106742858887,
-0.258810430765152,
-0.21019074320793152,
-0.24099239706993103,
0.08558467030525208,
0.19159536063671112,
0.2376975417137146,
-0.1073942482471466,
-0.43311354517936707,
-0.12713058292865753,
0.36459943652153015,
-0.12006937712430954,
-0.08570216596126556,
0.3219401240348816,
-0.3331339359283447,
-0.3829277455806732,
1.3759299516677856,
0.24880586564540863,
0.2422695904970169,
0.36649462580680847,
0.23123836517333984,
-0.1927008479833603,
-0.395400732755661,
-0.13418257236480713,
0.19260968267917633,
-0.5539802312850952,
-0.15424196422100067,
-0.8101748824119568,
-0.4405520260334015,
-0.5469889640808105,
-0.27763548493385315,
-0.10550446063280106,
0.026948627084493637,
-0.21648550033569336,
-0.13904255628585815,
0.46920183300971985,
0.9401582479476929,
-0.4627014696598053,
0.5607362985610962,
-0.5785732269287109,
0.6527971625328064,
0.39302369952201843,
0.18823425471782684,
-0.09358611702919006,
-0.8599053025245667,
-0.31841081380844116,
0.25739753246307373,
-0.2076777070760727,
-1.2705312967300415,
0.5041918158531189,
-0.14243711531162262,
0.09118560701608658,
0.7238491773605347,
0.22064177691936493,
0.5153250098228455,
-0.3664804995059967,
0.48134368658065796,
0.09648710489273071,
-0.5156571865081787,
0.824002742767334,
-0.5414993166923523,
-0.12096657603979111,
0.30961039662361145,
0.7565688490867615,
-0.8533673286437988,
-0.912628173828125,
-0.5497346520423889,
-0.4751129746437073,
0.5519925355911255,
0.37200647592544556,
0.1367887705564499,
-0.18826358020305634,
-0.07654338330030441,
-0.10643375664949417,
-0.07952672243118286,
-0.884709894657135,
-0.42123979330062866,
-0.2842012047767639,
0.03107675537467003,
-0.1341044306755066,
-0.5305987596511841,
-0.008256377652287483,
-0.2482670247554779,
0.7543795108795166,
0.20390649139881134,
0.05508065223693848,
-0.11447225511074066,
-0.33135995268821716,
-0.14285674691200256,
0.04412710294127464,
0.36724942922592163,
0.2110392302274704,
-0.2494134157896042,
0.09347188472747803,
-0.10406652837991714,
-0.584714412689209,
0.1199631616473198,
0.1333063691854477,
-0.26390784978866577,
0.480243980884552,
0.16711248457431793,
0.5802667140960693,
-0.08239741623401642,
-0.5608987808227539,
0.49101659655570984,
-0.031587470322847366,
-0.004177373368293047,
-0.34525159001350403,
-0.10069458931684494,
0.06876605749130249,
0.33520179986953735,
0.36170694231987,
-0.3331882059574127,
0.11746113747358322,
-0.21292482316493988,
0.48198220133781433,
0.16069607436656952,
-0.8805720210075378,
-0.09858651459217072,
0.664584219455719,
0.16606281697750092,
-0.6238893270492554,
0.2571532726287842,
-0.17405781149864197,
-0.9424708485603333,
0.469326913356781,
0.35420578718185425,
0.9623547792434692,
-0.6233612895011902,
0.8640584945678711,
0.43287330865859985,
0.44041651487350464,
0.6602296233177185,
0.09739701449871063,
0.11773048341274261,
-0.8212711215019226,
-0.21073231101036072,
-0.8241975903511047,
-0.007946893572807312,
0.4640582203865051,
-0.5181671977043152,
0.5504148006439209,
-0.5269139409065247,
0.004426615312695503,
0.39406222105026245,
-0.17149220407009125,
-0.4486686587333679,
0.2316102236509323,
0.6863924264907837,
0.43180403113365173,
-1.0819042921066284,
0.46910563111305237,
0.4115488529205322,
-0.3949957489967346,
-0.4100838601589203,
0.02399151772260666,
0.5246720910072327,
-0.8452292084693909,
0.6389489769935608,
0.3366996645927429,
-0.1105097234249115,
0.007197401486337185,
-0.6280212998390198,
-0.37417522072792053,
0.11745379120111465,
0.3327195942401886,
-0.34091782569885254,
0.29395103454589844,
0.5308095812797546,
0.740929901599884,
-0.45105549693107605,
0.03207257762551308,
0.49820590019226074,
0.284525603055954,
-0.10601631551980972,
-0.5765963792800903,
0.012761084362864494,
-0.24410225450992584,
-0.11700662970542908,
0.00969679094851017,
-0.6083889007568359,
0.6819347143173218,
0.2723172605037689,
-0.20559535920619965,
-0.4275040328502655,
0.7196846008300781,
0.1114213839173317,
0.26920053362846375,
0.9033533930778503,
0.39111027121543884,
0.4276396930217743,
0.383224219083786,
0.5780394673347473,
0.3403816819190979,
0.17900043725967407,
0.9350085258483887,
-0.013193693943321705,
0.6927942633628845,
0.264834463596344,
0.035227272659540176,
0.3674834072589874,
0.42856770753860474,
-0.12107488512992859,
0.22882676124572754,
0.6633734703063965,
-0.603178083896637,
-0.09590700268745422,
-0.8444095849990845,
-0.28614524006843567,
0.5087141990661621,
0.5105881094932556,
-0.3763476312160492,
-0.3561129868030548,
0.38089314103126526,
0.07430493831634521,
0.4883602559566498,
-0.46092769503593445,
0.7662732005119324,
0.03627140074968338,
-0.20471937954425812,
0.49278953671455383,
0.18574510514736176,
0.9440209269523621,
-0.3631097376346588,
-0.0054327379912137985,
0.1209447905421257,
0.035360950976610184,
-0.2495667040348053,
-0.5286830067634583,
0.4734465181827545,
0.6233742237091064,
-0.11548136174678802,
-0.23238229751586914,
0.8392345905303955,
-0.6138680577278137,
-0.362591028213501,
0.684161901473999,
0.11251936852931976,
0.25959792733192444,
-0.6573354005813599,
-0.8056051135063171,
0.3740491569042206,
0.13287504017353058,
0.24941237270832062,
0.16701336205005646,
0.38176819682121277,
-0.015202697366476059,
0.377878338098526,
0.5230129957199097,
0.34813615679740906,
0.27532872557640076,
0.282833993434906,
1.1148662567138672,
-0.500311017036438,
-0.5408026576042175,
-0.9562868475914001,
0.28005608916282654,
-0.28551653027534485,
-0.33537960052490234,
0.7852321267127991,
0.5873502492904663,
1.2600189447402954,
0.1469959318637848,
1.1542526483535767,
-0.04841132462024689,
0.9844171404838562,
0.01940200664103031,
0.8052024841308594,
-0.5906645655632019,
-0.15594430267810822,
-0.8013436794281006,
-1.0413811206817627,
-0.4464679956436157,
0.5478076338768005,
-0.35168319940567017,
-0.2577062249183655,
0.329542338848114,
0.8213730454444885,
0.057368721812963486,
-0.035153552889823914,
0.45278143882751465,
0.6316587328910828,
0.5965756773948669,
0.1960856318473816,
0.7804959416389465,
-0.2721084654331207,
0.9335834980010986,
-0.39146751165390015,
-0.23456496000289917,
-0.5565353631973267,
-0.43054330348968506,
-0.8821154832839966,
-0.5836141705513,
-0.3791435956954956,
-0.6528196334838867,
0.32305338978767395,
0.8011714220046997,
0.340497761964798,
-0.8960541486740112,
-0.38854601979255676,
0.3771416246891022,
0.33492472767829895,
-0.015768561512231827,
-0.32814469933509827,
0.10445291548967361,
-0.030527474358677864,
-0.8596135377883911,
0.10633586347103119,
0.3056293725967407,
-0.2129344940185547,
-0.2630203366279602,
-0.060780517756938934,
-0.7401604056358337,
-0.1085125133395195,
0.76816725730896,
0.2807284891605377,
-0.5964441299438477,
-0.41792795062065125,
-0.29742613434791565,
-0.15453988313674927,
-0.06505259871482849,
0.8118393421173096,
-0.4351089894771576,
0.4596584439277649,
0.3211677372455597,
0.7153041958808899,
0.4104396104812622,
0.0753619447350502,
0.15990205109119415,
-0.5758919715881348,
0.26108938455581665,
0.5389002561569214,
-0.08482883870601654,
0.3691178262233734,
-0.275436669588089,
0.1891205906867981,
0.46595439314842224,
-0.2406243234872818,
-0.9266659021377563,
0.2510119378566742,
-0.8256677985191345,
-0.15859225392341614,
1.3095024824142456,
0.019276071339845657,
-0.08036675304174423,
-0.4184044301509857,
-0.37223005294799805,
0.7297315001487732,
-0.5458749532699585,
0.8641240000724792,
0.608788251876831,
0.33252257108688354,
0.08003991097211838,
-0.39501050114631653,
0.6055058240890503,
0.29362553358078003,
-0.5893459320068359,
0.04891667142510414,
0.5942782163619995,
-0.02907387726008892,
0.06452730298042297,
0.7026464939117432,
0.17929495871067047,
0.12415007501840591,
-0.09335582703351974,
-0.15213267505168915,
0.4418486952781677,
-0.25047487020492554,
-0.2516763508319855,
0.32431039214134216,
-0.4930056631565094,
-0.12095589935779572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19245v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19245v2
|
HydraLoRA: An Asymmetric LoRA Architecture for Efficient Fine-Tuning
| 2024-04-30T04:01:09 | 2024-05-23T15:06:02 |
Chunlin Tian, Zhan Shi, Zhijiang Guo, Li Li, Chengzhong Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Adapting Large Language Models (LLMs) to new tasks through fine-tuning has
been made more efficient by the introduction of Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning
(PEFT) techniques, such as LoRA. However, these methods often underperform
compared to full fine-tuning, particularly in scenarios involving complex
datasets. This issue becomes even more pronounced in complex domains,
highlighting the need for improved PEFT approaches that can achieve better
performance. Through a series of experiments, we have uncovered two critical
insights that shed light on the training and parameter inefficiency of LoRA.
Building on these insights, we have developed HydraLoRA, a LoRA framework with
an asymmetric structure that eliminates the need for domain expertise. Our
experiments demonstrate that HydraLoRA outperforms other PEFT approaches, even
those that rely on domain knowledge during the training and inference phases.
|
[
-0.39160388708114624,
-0.7798023819923401,
0.44867855310440063,
0.2270345240831375,
-0.31151774525642395,
0.24295446276664734,
-0.4324018061161041,
-0.6140998005867004,
-0.027894901111721992,
0.4288415014743805,
-0.3631501793861389,
-0.48441311717033386,
-0.4692155420780182,
-0.14589069783687592,
-0.38542547821998596,
0.9520588517189026,
-0.21217262744903564,
-0.06529472023248672,
0.21911320090293884,
-0.33419281244277954,
-0.2517912983894348,
-0.25381559133529663,
-0.9875496625900269,
-0.7542726397514343,
0.7807121872901917,
0.4967219829559326,
0.5926748514175415,
0.6313560605049133,
0.18649083375930786,
0.225188747048378,
-0.08958422392606735,
0.4695868492126465,
-0.5754609704017639,
0.056439388543367386,
-0.4602660834789276,
-0.5949327349662781,
-0.579948365688324,
-0.17868971824645996,
0.4768923819065094,
0.8883755803108215,
0.010783792473375797,
0.3995971977710724,
0.24728769063949585,
1.0415765047073364,
-0.8256790637969971,
0.11374401301145554,
-0.9352164268493652,
-0.2666293680667877,
-0.46276792883872986,
-0.3851977288722992,
-0.0376487672328949,
-0.16133880615234375,
0.19132329523563385,
-0.5843410491943359,
0.07317323237657547,
0.17349256575107574,
1.0364937782287598,
0.6406067609786987,
-0.17901794612407684,
-0.24073295295238495,
-0.8286028504371643,
0.6683624386787415,
-0.5741875171661377,
0.37664595246315,
0.11515413224697113,
0.3424024283885956,
-0.1904299259185791,
-0.4905513525009155,
-0.358346164226532,
0.18004301190376282,
0.46646469831466675,
-0.17368267476558685,
-0.3788069188594818,
0.02240593358874321,
0.11999724060297012,
0.06336815655231476,
-0.3600977957248688,
0.40581321716308594,
-0.27630460262298584,
0.19743035733699799,
0.5339818000793457,
-0.1608697474002838,
0.14267496764659882,
0.30346986651420593,
-0.24601885676383972,
0.12271668016910553,
-1.173118233680725,
0.04359825700521469,
0.4832073152065277,
0.6555298566818237,
-0.02109557017683983,
0.552882194519043,
-0.3631173074245453,
0.6621124744415283,
0.12595975399017334,
0.06937412172555923,
-0.06510657072067261,
0.1438184678554535,
-0.46460986137390137,
0.30849194526672363,
0.32779771089553833,
-0.06659835577011108,
0.500882089138031,
-0.2776450216770172,
-0.15847361087799072,
0.225843608379364,
0.08548056334257126,
-0.7364887595176697,
-0.37625691294670105,
0.34705352783203125,
-0.16995927691459656,
-0.08024773001670837,
-0.053957149386405945,
-0.6614315509796143,
-0.23530790209770203,
-0.44660648703575134,
0.3924219608306885,
-0.34900224208831787,
0.17791347205638885,
0.48843005299568176,
-0.02025333046913147,
0.24369995296001434,
0.6261675953865051,
-0.6906283497810364,
0.5699450969696045,
0.8565582633018494,
0.630776047706604,
-0.519149899482727,
-0.4434588551521301,
-0.7085538506507874,
0.30155637860298157,
-0.205929234623909,
1.2021534442901611,
-0.5922079086303711,
0.09893151372671127,
-0.07180549204349518,
-0.2012828290462494,
-0.15386219322681427,
-0.8345746994018555,
0.5060660243034363,
-0.8825907111167908,
-0.05888357385993004,
-0.3208095133304596,
-0.44470950961112976,
-0.19829198718070984,
-0.015848727896809578,
-0.538862407207489,
0.7677159905433655,
0.27638500928878784,
-0.6023849844932556,
0.14607103168964386,
-0.7807215452194214,
-0.34290391206741333,
-0.14568063616752625,
-0.03498997911810875,
-0.48584797978401184,
0.2408187985420227,
0.03601925075054169,
0.1694353222846985,
-0.8307426571846008,
0.009732690639793873,
-0.40945887565612793,
-0.4629773795604706,
0.029699841514229774,
-0.1526642143726349,
0.7138571739196777,
0.3585360050201416,
-0.5875688791275024,
0.2987781763076782,
-0.7814022898674011,
0.3189394474029541,
0.06308111548423767,
-0.7023802995681763,
-0.4378257691860199,
-0.09171046316623688,
0.2838108241558075,
-0.1096300482749939,
0.26946595311164856,
-0.3344336152076721,
0.17739498615264893,
-0.53566974401474,
0.610134482383728,
0.6669146418571472,
-0.17294035851955414,
0.4672207832336426,
-0.18094468116760254,
0.47613656520843506,
-0.17576681077480316,
0.03386605903506279,
0.4423394501209259,
-0.388764351606369,
-1.0457607507705688,
-0.2238904982805252,
0.4223027229309082,
0.36496564745903015,
-0.7135698795318604,
0.2606390714645386,
-0.04371197521686554,
-0.5220182538032532,
-0.4171900451183319,
0.7210068702697754,
0.5742706060409546,
0.3684854805469513,
0.37601837515830994,
-0.16296856105327606,
-0.4705336093902588,
-0.8811648488044739,
-0.7154574394226074,
0.028357360512018204,
0.20214055478572845,
0.1465994119644165,
0.35745784640312195,
-0.40357041358947754,
0.8548026084899902,
-0.4415075480937958,
-0.24723057448863983,
-0.23417137563228607,
-0.1909659057855606,
0.3899032771587372,
0.43264415860176086,
0.6611360907554626,
-0.6959432363510132,
-0.828667938709259,
0.25282663106918335,
-0.48126718401908875,
-0.39018476009368896,
0.27522730827331543,
-0.18166734278202057,
0.26386377215385437,
0.5075947642326355,
-0.6908574104309082,
0.06653720885515213,
0.736528754234314,
-0.5436315536499023,
0.33882951736450195,
-0.21738286316394806,
-0.23559129238128662,
-0.7779121994972229,
0.2710570693016052,
-0.11534497886896133,
-0.23959708213806152,
-0.7420912981033325,
0.21510694921016693,
0.12398102879524231,
0.042017772793769836,
-0.28096818923950195,
0.6195216774940491,
-0.47077685594558716,
-0.11304479092359543,
-0.4963250458240509,
0.19307754933834076,
0.11600036174058914,
0.5909522175788879,
-0.12174319475889206,
0.7913256883621216,
0.4003429114818573,
-0.6500962972640991,
0.2051938772201538,
0.05928364396095276,
-0.47682973742485046,
0.5369976758956909,
-0.8590070605278015,
0.15141260623931885,
0.06980784237384796,
-0.06765817850828171,
-0.5483458042144775,
-0.2688460350036621,
0.15972988307476044,
0.1583847999572754,
0.1756918728351593,
-0.12724360823631287,
-0.5254709124565125,
-0.06504031270742416,
-0.2705044448375702,
0.4863518178462982,
0.42150968313217163,
-0.7082412838935852,
0.6769895553588867,
0.3933662474155426,
-0.07572454959154129,
-0.45472288131713867,
-0.36304375529289246,
-0.1776505559682846,
-0.5770812630653381,
-0.3006410002708435,
0.5257323384284973,
-0.1468236744403839,
-0.5147284269332886,
-0.22080275416374207,
-0.20802918076515198,
-0.2706677317619324,
0.293963223695755,
0.27303844690322876,
-0.12941645085811615,
-0.503612220287323,
0.06844717264175415,
0.3002021014690399,
-0.0918467566370964,
-0.10814348608255386,
-0.250969797372818,
0.827989399433136,
-0.1808251291513443,
-0.48082810640335083,
-0.6633096933364868,
0.12786950170993805,
0.6867895126342773,
-0.1713031828403473,
0.51569002866745,
0.2916174829006195,
-0.30695420503616333,
-0.7620038390159607,
-0.475041925907135,
0.10624217987060547,
-0.5574102401733398,
0.27791154384613037,
-0.5294502973556519,
-0.7518744468688965,
0.5673860311508179,
-0.4192710816860199,
0.022683920338749886,
0.3807603120803833,
0.41927143931388855,
-0.13355517387390137,
0.5464242100715637,
0.767383337020874,
-0.22526173293590546,
0.6638185977935791,
-0.18213647603988647,
0.146819606423378,
-0.7861935496330261,
-0.12502582371234894,
-0.7286534905433655,
-0.3337045907974243,
-0.28759196400642395,
-0.5666082501411438,
0.28569701313972473,
0.404162734746933,
-0.6963744759559631,
0.36179089546203613,
-0.1532323658466339,
0.49981120228767395,
0.47481533885002136,
0.1428578495979309,
0.638128399848938,
0.2677460312843323,
0.4618113338947296,
0.2896123230457306,
-1.0588113069534302,
-0.4553214907646179,
0.9915090203285217,
0.512540876865387,
0.9567168951034546,
0.1689097285270691,
0.5326122641563416,
0.019560176879167557,
0.20445692539215088,
-0.7135280966758728,
0.22656364738941193,
-0.311062216758728,
-0.25678926706314087,
-0.4119418263435364,
-0.2147180438041687,
-0.9867736101150513,
0.10562098771333694,
-0.01615777611732483,
-0.4985876977443695,
0.4160950779914856,
0.309621661901474,
-0.6225067377090454,
0.2986527383327484,
-0.6146376132965088,
0.6356890797615051,
-0.20992057025432587,
-0.44504785537719727,
-0.3060550093650818,
-0.14866861701011658,
-0.0052102976478636265,
-0.4388216435909271,
-0.014616522006690502,
-0.26791322231292725,
-0.22651763260364532,
0.6083990335464478,
-0.3522317409515381,
0.8821721076965332,
-0.21585336327552795,
-0.6064690351486206,
0.2439861297607422,
0.03882798179984093,
0.6208782196044922,
0.10109907388687134,
-0.307624489068985,
0.038611605763435364,
-0.05446448177099228,
-0.557954728603363,
-0.7890996932983398,
1.0272771120071411,
-1.0062012672424316,
-0.5718057751655579,
-0.022651754319667816,
-0.7600740790367126,
-0.6989383101463318,
0.18544425070285797,
0.13595931231975555,
0.1263810247182846,
-0.0657024011015892,
0.1495172083377838,
0.99832683801651,
-0.16564735770225525,
0.13248670101165771,
0.5371564626693726,
-0.10620809346437454,
-0.023038392886519432,
0.7694111466407776,
0.10672800242900848,
0.3035983443260193,
0.3353068232536316,
0.0541314072906971,
0.05355149507522583,
-0.7595353126525879,
-0.30497753620147705,
0.41521501541137695,
-0.6479585766792297,
-0.30465030670166016,
-0.4068491458892822,
-0.1144680306315422,
-0.09139369428157806,
-0.2528711259365082,
-0.7794250845909119,
-0.384413480758667,
-0.43130916357040405,
0.38900426030158997,
0.4438296854496002,
0.7320441603660583,
0.5354033708572388,
0.43241795897483826,
-0.37541070580482483,
0.34898579120635986,
0.47048112750053406,
0.5020989775657654,
-0.009999927133321762,
-0.6879153847694397,
-0.16386224329471588,
-0.03758973628282547,
-0.019150767475366592,
-0.48011794686317444,
0.27948084473609924,
0.6146510243415833,
0.40610912442207336,
0.4814174771308899,
-0.06905547529459,
1.102057933807373,
-0.6417422890663147,
0.2841325104236603,
-0.20820128917694092,
-1.1249439716339111,
0.5212222337722778,
-0.4909675717353821,
0.4167185425758362,
0.5972710251808167,
0.20966459810733795,
-0.011777353473007679,
0.005516578443348408,
-0.41337472200393677,
-0.7357323169708252,
0.40706294775009155,
0.1194695457816124,
0.09255961328744888,
0.688957929611206,
0.737419605255127,
0.21487973630428314,
0.37871161103248596,
-0.36318355798721313,
-0.2644332945346832,
0.12243897467851639,
-0.2015727311372757,
-0.24625401198863983,
-0.22311368584632874,
-0.34849247336387634,
-0.33785808086395264,
0.6062575578689575,
-0.5506274104118347,
0.0272896159440279,
-0.06467926502227783,
-0.017496392130851746,
-0.29784974455833435,
0.10650357604026794,
0.418667197227478,
0.7518072128295898,
-0.03270573541522026,
0.29023560881614685,
0.4131942689418793,
-0.11472399532794952,
-0.17832718789577484,
-0.09110675752162933,
-0.0009820765117183328,
-0.20662954449653625,
0.466560959815979,
0.7584731578826904,
0.4291089177131653,
-0.954441487789154,
-0.015326600521802902,
0.23650893568992615,
-0.054525990039110184,
-0.1629652976989746,
0.5903593301773071,
0.19689545035362244,
0.7741115093231201,
0.25763022899627686,
0.09890297800302505,
-0.028913481160998344,
-0.8595919013023376,
-0.015481364913284779,
0.49852481484413147,
-0.3540918529033661,
-0.45171216130256653,
0.49141302704811096,
-0.00833004992455244,
-0.38949039578437805,
0.15216831862926483,
0.29216837882995605,
-0.3807362914085388,
0.46684518456459045,
0.6837751269340515,
0.6795924305915833,
-0.15336285531520844,
0.04288936033844948,
-0.22416001558303833,
-0.009443518705666065,
-0.15015502274036407,
0.644733726978302,
-0.04977884516119957,
-0.7398097515106201,
0.009575854986906052,
-0.9075454473495483,
-0.3299142122268677,
-0.022623857483267784,
-0.6793635487556458,
0.04619879275560379,
-0.7198631763458252,
-0.07491331547498703,
0.052357420325279236,
0.18388864398002625,
-0.6875126957893372,
-0.05632735416293144,
-0.1445123553276062,
1.239309310913086,
-0.7907044291496277,
1.2616229057312012,
0.7050039172172546,
0.04156303405761719,
-0.7088770866394043,
0.02649735100567341,
-0.2508041560649872,
-0.8686529397964478,
0.7926898002624512,
-0.27988898754119873,
-0.5649029612541199,
0.046293653547763824,
-0.5377743244171143,
-1.0802689790725708,
1.1474920511245728,
1.00650954246521,
-0.6475993394851685,
-0.20360465347766876,
0.19209501147270203,
0.8122165203094482,
-0.6116337776184082,
-0.6321095824241638,
0.8269797563552856,
0.43933406472206116,
-0.2253834307193756,
-1.0545309782028198,
-0.014372908510267735,
-0.2144630402326584,
0.08289117366075516,
-0.08309860527515411,
-0.8985203504562378,
0.9293286204338074,
-0.10534588247537613,
-0.14838047325611115,
0.2047375589609146,
0.629530131816864,
0.39735233783721924,
0.2742113471031189,
0.4540061056613922,
0.26931315660476685,
0.8656290173530579,
-0.04578179121017456,
0.9319717884063721,
-0.48170384764671326,
0.23496773838996887,
1.4329947233200073,
-0.368460088968277,
1.1278060674667358,
0.8419184684753418,
-0.12166792154312134,
0.6088898181915283,
0.5830974578857422,
0.17530030012130737,
0.49466079473495483,
0.14266428351402283,
-0.02784224972128868,
-0.48420611023902893,
-0.16436205804347992,
-0.14713157713413239,
0.5810986161231995,
0.39759156107902527,
-0.23467279970645905,
-0.2988159656524658,
-0.09628559648990631,
-0.02359738200902939,
0.2471391260623932,
-0.47157248854637146,
0.4986129403114319,
0.33055710792541504,
-0.5078051090240479,
0.8548814654350281,
0.09301482141017914,
0.5500978231430054,
-0.5488651394844055,
0.09434833377599716,
-0.12721368670463562,
0.4135059416294098,
-0.2969456613063812,
-0.4201486110687256,
0.12383896857500076,
0.09165774285793304,
-0.19891908764839172,
-0.03208156302571297,
0.5836147665977478,
-0.3946024775505066,
-0.08391907811164856,
0.5615650415420532,
0.7017982602119446,
-0.04083428159356117,
-0.5173501968383789,
-0.8315483927726746,
0.37904447317123413,
-0.08948124945163727,
-0.322623610496521,
0.4153185188770294,
0.4649949371814728,
-0.1681033968925476,
0.9317418932914734,
0.6002281308174133,
0.32615381479263306,
-0.09141260385513306,
0.17654049396514893,
1.2270491123199463,
-0.45299032330513,
-0.250245064496994,
-0.7453015446662903,
0.020143873989582062,
0.1029297485947609,
-0.37342774868011475,
0.8658304214477539,
0.5111552476882935,
0.7249699831008911,
-0.0003760700346902013,
0.5793695449829102,
0.3179236352443695,
0.3408191204071045,
-0.7531501054763794,
0.8503990769386292,
-0.6541849970817566,
0.5689384937286377,
-0.169235497713089,
-1.16596519947052,
-0.3052658140659332,
0.38345664739608765,
-0.3031453788280487,
-0.04142076149582863,
0.59217369556427,
0.6866970658302307,
-0.34231504797935486,
-0.09243212640285492,
0.22554467618465424,
0.3777436912059784,
0.3100323975086212,
0.647506058216095,
0.48183736205101013,
-0.5602767467498779,
0.1307157427072525,
-0.06017705053091049,
-0.048375945538282394,
-0.29458916187286377,
-0.5519522428512573,
-1.1981548070907593,
-0.48018401861190796,
-0.30879339575767517,
-0.19542047381401062,
0.4140810966491699,
0.996846079826355,
0.7078466415405273,
-1.1842917203903198,
-0.4065544009208679,
-0.06774147599935532,
0.0848175659775734,
-0.1669275313615799,
-0.1098252385854721,
0.6129906177520752,
-0.37061601877212524,
-0.9882403016090393,
0.633953332901001,
0.4302805960178375,
-0.04570835456252098,
-0.30582502484321594,
-0.12237545102834702,
0.02343396283686161,
0.3061392903327942,
0.7171454429626465,
0.5208501815795898,
-0.6423283815383911,
-0.2519114911556244,
-0.30660557746887207,
-0.05057498812675476,
0.04875112697482109,
0.7622919678688049,
-0.6354944109916687,
0.02533395029604435,
0.2908572256565094,
0.7491275072097778,
0.3711022734642029,
0.032921988517045975,
0.7095063924789429,
-0.26297855377197266,
0.0875968337059021,
-0.05765005573630333,
0.37501972913742065,
0.05060884729027748,
-0.2181752324104309,
0.45190393924713135,
-0.02104817144572735,
-0.3401195704936981,
-1.0217876434326172,
0.27114343643188477,
-1.0704536437988281,
-0.5126110911369324,
1.2844055891036987,
-0.14935462176799774,
-0.5862627029418945,
-0.43014949560165405,
-0.23436114192008972,
0.10021797567605972,
-0.3356751501560211,
1.1005299091339111,
0.10790111869573593,
-0.3692720830440521,
0.13237541913986206,
-0.4982776939868927,
0.884856641292572,
0.5083726644515991,
-1.0833454132080078,
0.2306978702545166,
0.05350149795413017,
0.6163685321807861,
0.16812367737293243,
0.37365633249282837,
0.22316843271255493,
0.22295013070106506,
-0.2679908871650696,
-0.3897468149662018,
-0.05737997591495514,
-0.6761924624443054,
-0.4475112557411194,
0.6509509682655334,
0.5293903350830078,
0.37830469012260437
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.