id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19234v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19234v1
|
Multi-hop Question Answering over Knowledge Graphs using Large Language Models
| 2024-04-30T03:31:03 | 2024-04-30T03:31:03 |
Abir Chakraborty
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DB
|
Knowledge graphs (KGs) are large datasets with specific structures
representing large knowledge bases (KB) where each node represents a key entity
and relations amongst them are typed edges. Natural language queries formed to
extract information from a KB entail starting from specific nodes and reasoning
over multiple edges of the corresponding KG to arrive at the correct set of
answer nodes. Traditional approaches of question answering on KG are based on
(a) semantic parsing (SP), where a logical form (e.g., S-expression, SPARQL
query, etc.) is generated using node and edge embeddings and then reasoning
over these representations or tuning language models to generate the final
answer directly, or (b) information-retrieval based that works by extracting
entities and relations sequentially. In this work, we evaluate the capability
of (LLMs) to answer questions over KG that involve multiple hops. We show that
depending upon the size and nature of the KG we need different approaches to
extract and feed the relevant information to an LLM since every LLM comes with
a fixed context window. We evaluate our approach on six KGs with and without
the availability of example-specific sub-graphs and show that both the IR and
SP-based methods can be adopted by LLMs resulting in an extremely competitive
performance.
|
[
-0.5155302882194519,
-1.2905001640319824,
0.908989429473877,
0.18878014385700226,
-0.01696125976741314,
0.22981925308704376,
0.059636473655700684,
-0.4202665388584137,
0.15309688448905945,
0.5037052631378174,
-0.5454463362693787,
-0.4018441140651703,
-0.5470480918884277,
0.3601027727127075,
-0.056642066687345505,
0.5542758703231812,
-0.17087851464748383,
-0.060841213911771774,
-0.4854191541671753,
-0.269772469997406,
-0.5170677304267883,
-0.44749337434768677,
-0.7347702383995056,
-0.2933186888694763,
0.8080517053604126,
0.3637886345386505,
0.6828691363334656,
0.5987734198570251,
0.3718794584274292,
0.27377232909202576,
-0.3850264251232147,
0.34590449929237366,
-0.36657699942588806,
0.3975680470466614,
-0.008267943747341633,
-0.2946431636810303,
-0.32465651631355286,
-0.28043332695961,
0.5766324400901794,
1.0451172590255737,
0.229664146900177,
0.27265819907188416,
-0.24334122240543365,
0.7330942749977112,
-0.5619239211082458,
0.19219672679901123,
-0.5750734210014343,
-0.012610673904418945,
-0.010653871111571789,
-0.22612562775611877,
-0.5894825458526611,
-0.49866101145744324,
0.12908773124217987,
-0.6209363341331482,
-0.5194492936134338,
0.07184042036533356,
0.6388291120529175,
0.09618236124515533,
-0.7719331979751587,
-0.594100832939148,
-0.5877211689949036,
0.41133105754852295,
-0.5655544996261597,
0.6830357909202576,
0.33272454142570496,
0.6788235306739807,
-0.3273161053657532,
-0.7845155000686646,
-0.4119688868522644,
-0.038428038358688354,
-0.216191366314888,
-0.0049725864082574844,
0.05422180891036987,
-0.019597679376602173,
0.3975540101528168,
0.010597531683743,
-0.5508888959884644,
-0.1382710486650467,
-0.040277596563100815,
-0.13122844696044922,
0.4591354429721832,
0.13304267823696136,
0.25499770045280457,
-0.22562824189662933,
-0.3796702027320862,
-0.02819833718240261,
-0.5332110524177551,
0.2265021950006485,
0.26561927795410156,
0.363904744386673,
0.40232133865356445,
0.7983763813972473,
-0.5673709511756897,
1.1645594835281372,
-0.19229629635810852,
-0.4953272342681885,
0.12251487374305725,
-0.2117978185415268,
-0.09525810182094574,
-0.3100862205028534,
0.6437268853187561,
0.35811159014701843,
0.6267614960670471,
-0.6156042218208313,
0.09836093336343765,
-0.3590606153011322,
-0.09730171412229538,
-0.6551206707954407,
0.12135373055934906,
0.3194490075111389,
-0.3150681257247925,
-0.037096988409757614,
-0.3304256200790405,
-0.9058288335800171,
-0.29883673787117004,
-0.12651051580905914,
0.6433027386665344,
-0.5912303924560547,
-0.26694902777671814,
0.05354437604546547,
-0.3699869215488434,
0.6089312434196472,
0.2983837127685547,
-0.39833810925483704,
0.32705995440483093,
0.38440531492233276,
0.7572322487831116,
0.12482863664627075,
-0.3120662569999695,
-0.6003766655921936,
0.43339863419532776,
-0.20547831058502197,
0.701252818107605,
-0.6351528763771057,
-0.2344488799571991,
-0.13212989270687103,
-0.11902439594268799,
-0.4541633129119873,
-0.3178916573524475,
0.281783789396286,
-1.333477258682251,
-0.006744992453604937,
-0.5896289348602295,
-0.8738036751747131,
-0.2301771491765976,
0.7844909429550171,
-0.48546114563941956,
0.9446691274642944,
0.04436418414115906,
-1.0946589708328247,
-0.033399324864149094,
-0.739520251750946,
-0.580457866191864,
-0.05947219207882881,
-0.08143958449363708,
0.12180076539516449,
-0.34038200974464417,
0.533085823059082,
0.44675686955451965,
-0.23295393586158752,
0.15961426496505737,
-0.35363784432411194,
0.06405296176671982,
0.31324949860572815,
-0.17150184512138367,
0.6654120087623596,
0.35450172424316406,
0.1976790875196457,
-0.22576281428337097,
-0.7351042032241821,
0.4138546586036682,
0.3078610599040985,
-0.5556873083114624,
-0.4424826502799988,
0.09341590106487274,
-0.6569948792457581,
0.3706355094909668,
0.043525438755750656,
-0.6659521460533142,
0.4324599504470825,
-0.2194409817457199,
0.3868711590766907,
0.4860984981060028,
0.27778318524360657,
0.19801919162273407,
-0.16430282592773438,
0.5629951357841492,
-0.04775835946202278,
-0.013197417370975018,
-0.2553333640098572,
-0.7069742679595947,
-0.41570883989334106,
-0.12813535332679749,
0.2818094491958618,
0.6604940891265869,
-1.083032250404358,
0.05440609157085419,
-0.5243714451789856,
-0.4676174521446228,
-0.29718995094299316,
-0.03149889409542084,
0.12184945493936539,
0.8951398134231567,
0.4521155059337616,
0.1810370236635208,
-0.12933428585529327,
-0.7256619334220886,
-0.4194639325141907,
-0.12590035796165466,
0.12126549333333969,
0.6523910164833069,
0.49990367889404297,
-0.06046498566865921,
1.375160813331604,
-0.8880565166473389,
0.1707836389541626,
-0.39664754271507263,
-0.0718512311577797,
0.29873499274253845,
-0.028026578947901726,
0.38854971528053284,
-0.9270051121711731,
-0.663399875164032,
-0.020017042756080627,
-0.884157657623291,
0.03492679446935654,
0.09518072754144669,
-0.3020106554031372,
-0.11642181128263474,
0.6011885404586792,
-0.7905101776123047,
0.1781240850687027,
0.38174256682395935,
-0.32499244809150696,
0.5496899485588074,
0.23930421471595764,
0.2229529619216919,
-1.1200248003005981,
0.1548452079296112,
-0.4015449285507202,
-0.37130874395370483,
-0.7917327284812927,
0.18925628066062927,
-0.10969257354736328,
-0.15248069167137146,
-0.2813047170639038,
0.616273820400238,
-0.3790437877178192,
-0.3149329125881195,
-0.01281699538230896,
0.262289822101593,
0.16387374699115753,
0.5444380640983582,
0.09679025411605835,
0.5590978860855103,
0.5248100161552429,
-0.6881734132766724,
0.5646713972091675,
0.3293607234954834,
-0.10401221364736557,
0.27096131443977356,
-0.7047935128211975,
0.39145714044570923,
-0.358012318611145,
0.4063987135887146,
-1.1553455591201782,
-0.2513858675956726,
0.10970785468816757,
-0.6171706914901733,
0.05599449202418327,
-0.6555235981941223,
-0.5175256133079529,
-0.5860819816589355,
-0.124503493309021,
0.4163622558116913,
0.16310665011405945,
-0.46017709374427795,
0.8975458145141602,
0.22117243707180023,
-0.20842544734477997,
-0.7512592077255249,
-0.35801151394844055,
-0.011102020740509033,
-0.18961437046527863,
-1.158002257347107,
-0.14513537287712097,
-0.027383841574192047,
-0.21763412654399872,
0.313232958316803,
-0.11482752859592438,
-0.17628586292266846,
0.16172535717487335,
-0.21910884976387024,
-0.03373279422521591,
-0.2867400646209717,
0.266788125038147,
-0.16601072251796722,
-0.14697003364562988,
-0.07761514186859131,
-0.41769638657569885,
0.7397008538246155,
-0.0917772650718689,
-0.5340146422386169,
-0.004945519845932722,
0.5150438547134399,
0.7867152690887451,
-0.33622539043426514,
1.0246033668518066,
0.3948402404785156,
-0.29437506198883057,
0.0007707007462158799,
-0.5318505167961121,
0.08599527925252914,
-0.4183664917945862,
0.286237895488739,
-0.7246766686439514,
-0.9492930173873901,
0.726694643497467,
-0.35286131501197815,
-0.01784675382077694,
0.3593890368938446,
0.4744763672351837,
-0.11299101263284683,
0.9437413811683655,
0.30558061599731445,
-0.08399009704589844,
-0.002599026309326291,
-0.14429999887943268,
0.4520436227321625,
-0.6888242959976196,
-0.43066897988319397,
-0.6160245537757874,
-0.12266293168067932,
-0.3922397196292877,
-0.35168012976646423,
0.7327365875244141,
0.42466074228286743,
-0.28112417459487915,
0.17835654318332672,
0.04357948526740074,
0.5588687062263489,
0.5810652375221252,
-0.12368708103895187,
0.47589945793151855,
-0.1620500385761261,
-0.4787200391292572,
0.4067525267601013,
-0.9609811305999756,
-0.3266645073890686,
0.9455828070640564,
0.24551212787628174,
0.8651610016822815,
0.24833965301513672,
0.4241175651550293,
-0.1664564460515976,
0.026873640716075897,
-0.9483166337013245,
0.5194273591041565,
0.2175048142671585,
-0.6687983870506287,
-0.5559902787208557,
-0.8310558199882507,
-0.8163774609565735,
0.43738028407096863,
-0.06119972839951515,
-0.859259843826294,
-0.2109314501285553,
-0.010019704699516296,
-0.23459376394748688,
0.5138384699821472,
-0.804295003414154,
0.9228976368904114,
-0.23408427834510803,
-0.03881339356303215,
0.35052868723869324,
-0.9478753209114075,
0.2639468014240265,
0.11050182580947876,
0.3932616412639618,
0.051233768463134766,
0.27577921748161316,
0.7720434069633484,
-0.280691534280777,
0.537406861782074,
-0.2967946529388428,
0.09185892343521118,
0.6024906039237976,
0.21188890933990479,
0.7254308462142944,
-0.05731864646077156,
-0.09354272484779358,
-0.21345485746860504,
0.2574833333492279,
-0.27444618940353394,
-0.865146279335022,
0.4014849364757538,
-0.7857140898704529,
-0.5093386173248291,
-0.1447889357805252,
-0.7245304584503174,
-0.7962543964385986,
0.3542530834674835,
-0.008253472857177258,
0.6534005403518677,
0.27381178736686707,
0.22806963324546814,
0.5049378871917725,
-0.380097895860672,
0.372810423374176,
0.3893373906612396,
-0.3770228624343872,
-0.42384740710258484,
0.601044774055481,
0.31488218903541565,
0.5275174975395203,
0.6390853524208069,
0.42763257026672363,
-0.6108124256134033,
-0.40839195251464844,
-0.667539656162262,
0.2980615496635437,
-0.9645072817802429,
-0.3463154137134552,
-1.0799201726913452,
-0.28212788701057434,
-0.6909384727478027,
-0.01271011121571064,
-0.22422979772090912,
-0.4124909043312073,
0.3633134365081787,
-0.024669332429766655,
0.5134109854698181,
0.6186904907226562,
0.22871950268745422,
0.18696758151054382,
-1.099385142326355,
0.5682162046432495,
0.629864513874054,
0.5364736318588257,
0.13580936193466187,
-0.22528229653835297,
-0.062191110104322433,
-0.15628892183303833,
-0.06717157363891602,
-1.3027746677398682,
0.05707709491252899,
-0.044570110738277435,
0.6871770024299622,
0.1491105705499649,
0.08579307794570923,
0.8443940281867981,
-0.658503532409668,
0.5670356154441833,
-0.04615264758467674,
-0.6016656756401062,
0.4976542592048645,
-0.3777563273906708,
0.10870955884456635,
0.5609586238861084,
0.8188266754150391,
-0.8900853395462036,
-0.1900048702955246,
-0.3594481348991394,
-0.9664503335952759,
0.6912325024604797,
0.19309864938259125,
-0.1868269145488739,
-0.1383512318134308,
0.4799995720386505,
-0.13656175136566162,
0.26867544651031494,
-0.7486554384231567,
-0.3215305507183075,
0.052649062126874924,
-0.1026887446641922,
0.22633764147758484,
-0.21246328949928284,
-0.0829681009054184,
-0.06722771376371384,
0.5938712954521179,
-0.29695799946784973,
0.2686077654361725,
0.23356693983078003,
-0.23091557621955872,
0.07382761687040329,
0.3897164762020111,
-0.0885862484574318,
0.8016834259033203,
-0.16699719429016113,
0.3253989815711975,
0.13369368016719818,
-0.13250622153282166,
0.10181345790624619,
0.028824660927057266,
-0.23189842700958252,
-0.25199657678604126,
0.5428810119628906,
0.49618834257125854,
-0.38567984104156494,
-0.6491274833679199,
0.5159918069839478,
0.007595809642225504,
0.0022084678057581186,
0.08707579225301743,
-0.20893323421478271,
0.5387707948684692,
0.3196307420730591,
0.28521913290023804,
-0.36419105529785156,
-0.02038927562534809,
-0.5373533964157104,
0.14847031235694885,
0.5055297613143921,
-0.074544258415699,
0.08232326060533524,
0.371246874332428,
0.046729251742362976,
-0.16660378873348236,
0.7920264601707458,
-0.24992313981056213,
-0.6278501152992249,
0.6715540289878845,
0.7076005935668945,
0.4007333219051361,
0.08147666603326797,
0.1707119643688202,
0.306831955909729,
0.3182793855667114,
0.23080679774284363,
0.2102051079273224,
0.0661311224102974,
-1.0491538047790527,
-0.8240641355514526,
-0.8191941380500793,
-0.3897629976272583,
0.021698156371712685,
-0.5356862545013428,
-0.060215286910533905,
-0.03947872295975685,
0.07674142718315125,
-0.04162117838859558,
-0.12782835960388184,
-0.5267209410667419,
0.08783482015132904,
0.09891548752784729,
1.310196876525879,
-0.9855824708938599,
0.504659116268158,
0.9579192996025085,
-0.28567516803741455,
-1.0869007110595703,
-0.047299183905124664,
-0.29641687870025635,
-0.8592405319213867,
0.7051689028739929,
0.05399898812174797,
-0.20070965588092804,
0.16445034742355347,
-0.3932201862335205,
-1.1353838443756104,
1.1305698156356812,
0.26310667395591736,
-0.09162090718746185,
-0.0882195308804512,
0.27360448241233826,
0.2518935799598694,
-0.15373198688030243,
0.235699862241745,
0.5648946166038513,
0.5452168583869934,
0.526057243347168,
-0.7177467942237854,
-0.11027509719133377,
0.07864967733621597,
-0.2730461359024048,
0.22444865107536316,
-0.5647339820861816,
0.6256476640701294,
-0.11711231619119644,
0.05678278207778931,
-0.16974584758281708,
0.41716668009757996,
0.2876938581466675,
0.2636054754257202,
0.6634126305580139,
0.7385143637657166,
0.8230060338973999,
0.0597023107111454,
1.1841470003128052,
-0.26552480459213257,
0.40861350297927856,
0.9469937682151794,
-0.2792776823043823,
0.5509527921676636,
0.5005334615707397,
-0.31537124514579773,
0.31404659152030945,
0.5889131426811218,
0.5541223287582397,
0.41890832781791687,
0.2000952959060669,
-0.11639457195997238,
-0.44613713026046753,
-0.04064827412366867,
-0.30150818824768066,
0.5580341815948486,
0.237165167927742,
0.032364245504140854,
-0.6195130348205566,
-0.1101977750658989,
0.15833742916584015,
-0.22357940673828125,
-0.3289816975593567,
0.8558580875396729,
-0.1041797325015068,
-0.6924306750297546,
0.08895479142665863,
0.20940081775188446,
0.09470268338918686,
-0.9140865206718445,
0.05709952488541603,
-0.3232260048389435,
-0.2557200491428375,
-0.06128040701150894,
-0.9372221231460571,
0.2252528965473175,
0.18504054844379425,
-0.05068147927522659,
-0.15100736916065216,
0.9288246631622314,
-0.22314944863319397,
-0.5504679679870605,
0.4453079402446747,
1.0106078386306763,
0.1369558423757553,
0.002251244615763426,
-0.4834114909172058,
-0.29041558504104614,
-0.2743408679962158,
-0.5738744139671326,
0.20779140293598175,
0.8113912343978882,
-0.07525429874658585,
0.9875456094741821,
0.5476686358451843,
-0.11523540318012238,
0.38583099842071533,
0.055232107639312744,
1.1185742616653442,
-0.5210466980934143,
-0.5805395841598511,
-0.8353337645530701,
0.2569778263568878,
0.0034686115104705095,
0.038499996066093445,
0.8462358713150024,
0.5073971748352051,
0.5870692133903503,
0.17728710174560547,
0.6795638799667358,
-0.42385053634643555,
0.5500604510307312,
-0.6623575687408447,
0.1778201460838318,
-0.4227927327156067,
-0.02301526628434658,
-0.4118848741054535,
-0.7349746823310852,
-0.2907199561595917,
0.4704456329345703,
-0.40041688084602356,
0.12236986309289932,
0.5968765616416931,
0.6164565682411194,
0.004293476231396198,
-0.024696599692106247,
0.2916278839111328,
0.39623600244522095,
0.3772304058074951,
0.5206992030143738,
1.0817548036575317,
-0.1307397186756134,
0.8060286045074463,
-0.04820992797613144,
-0.15050256252288818,
0.13326695561408997,
-0.8546953797340393,
-0.6131120324134827,
-0.16937337815761566,
0.01636081375181675,
-0.4084349274635315,
-0.1035572960972786,
0.8291248083114624,
0.4142917990684509,
-0.5800079703330994,
-0.01712881028652191,
0.21066348254680634,
0.46929866075515747,
-0.10415612906217575,
-0.23524680733680725,
0.6206335425376892,
-0.5013903975486755,
-0.33844566345214844,
0.43411800265312195,
0.23244701325893402,
-0.2898852825164795,
0.11495591700077057,
0.1057758703827858,
-0.5470349192619324,
-0.03558063507080078,
0.8521971106529236,
0.10726063698530197,
-0.2180810272693634,
-0.6291242241859436,
0.4178979992866516,
0.225789874792099,
0.04528333619236946,
0.7656773328781128,
-0.7245908975601196,
0.4362337589263916,
0.6671744585037231,
1.2409673929214478,
0.5516102313995361,
0.2536574900150299,
0.19261309504508972,
-0.936924934387207,
-0.24999167025089264,
0.15543532371520996,
0.3015172779560089,
0.13937702775001526,
-0.24292370676994324,
0.49521198868751526,
0.40547433495521545,
-0.49862921237945557,
-0.43548059463500977,
0.5176376700401306,
-0.8883544206619263,
-0.5068209171295166,
1.4709246158599854,
-0.19195888936519623,
-0.08732037246227264,
-0.4243467152118683,
0.030721278861165047,
0.11931312829256058,
-0.0033887058962136507,
0.12882040441036224,
0.8325058221817017,
-0.6426404714584351,
0.22738847136497498,
-0.6538678407669067,
0.07986313849687576,
0.01958884857594967,
-0.7585691809654236,
0.060058824717998505,
0.5395916104316711,
0.4897257387638092,
0.1661270409822464,
1.0588120222091675,
-0.17704150080680847,
-0.1614045798778534,
-0.10745427757501602,
-0.3205990791320801,
-0.16386111080646515,
-0.5736172199249268,
0.17817817628383636,
0.6349033117294312,
0.17830950021743774,
-0.16620999574661255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19232v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19232v4
|
GRAMMAR: Grounded and Modular Methodology for Assessment of Domain-Specific Retrieval-Augmented Language Model
| 2024-04-30T03:29:30 | 2024-05-29T11:12:21 |
Xinzhe Li, Ming Liu, Shang Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-augmented Generation (RAG) systems have been actively studied and
deployed across various industries to query on domain-specific knowledge base.
However, evaluating these systems presents unique challenges due to the
scarcity of domain-specific queries and corresponding ground truths, as well as
a lack of systematic approaches to diagnosing the cause of failure cases --
whether they stem from knowledge deficits or issues related to system
robustness. To address these challenges, we introduce GRAMMAR (GRounded And
Modular Methodology for Assessment of RAG), an evaluation framework comprising
two key elements: 1) a data generation process that leverages relational
databases and LLMs to efficiently produce scalable query-answer pairs. This
method facilitates the separation of query logic from linguistic variations for
enhanced debugging capabilities; and 2) an evaluation framework that
differentiates knowledge gaps from robustness and enables the identification of
defective modules. Our empirical results underscore the limitations of current
reference-free evaluation approaches and the reliability of GRAMMAR to
accurately identify model vulnerabilities.
|
[
-0.2605813443660736,
-1.166433572769165,
0.5439916849136353,
0.15300352871418,
0.07679866254329681,
0.22435280680656433,
0.031553976237773895,
-0.11467761546373367,
-0.07798208296298981,
0.36544594168663025,
-0.5099848508834839,
-0.373152494430542,
-0.2638312876224518,
-0.07372232526540756,
-0.4861016273498535,
0.6631680130958557,
0.17675845324993134,
-0.03624499589204788,
-0.9426501989364624,
-0.04201177880167961,
-0.9640335440635681,
-0.6926790475845337,
-0.3547497093677521,
-0.07299678027629852,
-0.08406038582324982,
0.39572790265083313,
0.6085284948348999,
0.4787933826446533,
0.6317437291145325,
0.26462408900260925,
-0.24159221351146698,
0.17173883318901062,
-0.41273781657218933,
0.3927645981311798,
-0.38080930709838867,
-0.20019228756427765,
-0.6730872392654419,
-0.30548933148384094,
0.42354661226272583,
0.9005674123764038,
-0.1470392942428589,
0.44775447249412537,
-0.1503082662820816,
0.6831180453300476,
-0.7678676843643188,
0.05604761093854904,
-0.8027743697166443,
-0.06910187005996704,
-0.12863771617412567,
-0.08730065822601318,
-0.47052913904190063,
-0.2056814581155777,
-0.1073661670088768,
-0.30847254395484924,
0.12571068108081818,
-0.01544260885566473,
0.7910959124565125,
0.1532396823167801,
-0.5144590735435486,
-0.3177775740623474,
-0.4194183647632599,
0.7626094222068787,
-0.6486515402793884,
0.28846222162246704,
0.5615472197532654,
0.5032795667648315,
-0.29702380299568176,
-0.6451075673103333,
-0.34271925687789917,
-0.3750409185886383,
-0.10786931961774826,
-0.07953960448503494,
0.08130670338869095,
-0.20951609313488007,
0.12397631257772446,
0.5316764116287231,
-0.6702669858932495,
-0.27805009484291077,
-0.11353445053100586,
-0.18925142288208008,
0.45658740401268005,
0.3026215434074402,
0.6300821304321289,
-0.590156614780426,
-0.30106493830680847,
0.23286008834838867,
-0.7234213948249817,
-0.1629968136548996,
0.38042473793029785,
0.47975215315818787,
0.2640295624732971,
0.5839881896972656,
-0.24641837179660797,
0.9454725384712219,
0.15627193450927734,
-0.28586021065711975,
0.17736758291721344,
-0.36760637164115906,
-0.34911149740219116,
-0.49458765983581543,
0.41286543011665344,
0.1209387257695198,
-0.17799077928066254,
-0.4005168080329895,
-0.36278167366981506,
0.10462896525859833,
0.5689653754234314,
-0.3530491888523102,
0.185345858335495,
0.38026148080825806,
-0.28193315863609314,
-0.5852521061897278,
-0.08602462708950043,
-0.7817498445510864,
-0.37862256169319153,
-0.136838898062706,
0.5005022287368774,
-0.4223898947238922,
-0.5869126915931702,
-0.05025399103760719,
-0.05798855051398277,
0.2223639041185379,
-0.17711640894412994,
-0.7364178895950317,
0.4895903766155243,
0.8718851804733276,
0.4020155072212219,
-0.24950525164604187,
0.022783488035202026,
-0.41238120198249817,
0.0005981241120025516,
-0.2994532883167267,
0.865533709526062,
-0.5580976605415344,
-0.39487046003341675,
0.02377527393400669,
-0.14013884961605072,
-0.30313071608543396,
-0.7944380640983582,
0.7273479700088501,
-0.7223348617553711,
0.06359980255365372,
-0.0993899330496788,
-0.6078899502754211,
-0.049466878175735474,
0.6304340362548828,
-0.5106015801429749,
1.2857669591903687,
0.5642955899238586,
-0.7997751235961914,
0.2961898148059845,
-0.26250213384628296,
-0.36109429597854614,
0.1306001842021942,
-0.20197255909442902,
-0.4187217056751251,
0.13992981612682343,
0.032421380281448364,
0.31944385170936584,
-0.5591331720352173,
0.649734377861023,
-0.20680537819862366,
-0.10212065279483795,
0.13541772961616516,
-0.0874127522110939,
0.7410193085670471,
0.12478543817996979,
-0.32814839482307434,
-0.03425620123744011,
-1.2495743036270142,
0.3868769109249115,
0.17779196798801422,
-0.3163742125034332,
-0.46480581164360046,
0.2289845198392868,
-0.07954741269350052,
0.06990958750247955,
0.19269104301929474,
-0.1580076515674591,
0.06921068578958511,
-0.434298574924469,
0.02652748115360737,
0.5284242033958435,
0.1830669790506363,
0.36466971039772034,
-0.39541512727737427,
0.6873713731765747,
0.058444179594516754,
0.16736046969890594,
-0.3734224736690521,
-0.265383780002594,
-0.9070831537246704,
-0.17194673418998718,
0.3237386643886566,
0.6436163783073425,
-0.6073703765869141,
0.5116254687309265,
-0.21443690359592438,
-0.5406437516212463,
-0.11202362924814224,
-0.00972242746502161,
0.6892430186271667,
0.8096666932106018,
0.2633357048034668,
-0.24297142028808594,
-0.6950559616088867,
-0.7688339948654175,
-0.3897416889667511,
-0.4602258503437042,
0.13469095528125763,
0.47728967666625977,
0.3059948980808258,
-0.5465819239616394,
0.9947017431259155,
-0.2034115493297577,
0.03509049862623215,
-0.14826540648937225,
-0.056317977607250214,
0.2085617035627365,
0.47975412011146545,
0.5092368721961975,
-0.8204712271690369,
-0.2383844405412674,
0.09466405212879181,
-0.8739855885505676,
-0.30027124285697937,
0.21241414546966553,
-0.10554564744234085,
0.3101941645145416,
0.2892754077911377,
-0.4719252586364746,
0.35496315360069275,
0.35011592507362366,
-0.6423917412757874,
0.7595489621162415,
0.32513684034347534,
0.2712426483631134,
-0.9361223578453064,
0.2530939280986786,
-0.5076307058334351,
-0.42399832606315613,
-0.5993298888206482,
0.5762930512428284,
0.06559794396162033,
-0.2528599202632904,
-0.1917063444852829,
0.38051310181617737,
-0.4310322403907776,
-0.31979599595069885,
-0.03650345280766487,
0.04618508368730545,
0.15292468667030334,
0.16697846353054047,
-0.5460296273231506,
0.8392904996871948,
0.542803168296814,
-0.6652630567550659,
0.45861050486564636,
0.18237826228141785,
-0.34357744455337524,
0.6144030690193176,
-0.49683308601379395,
0.2846578359603882,
0.07465008646249771,
-0.4481094479560852,
-0.8780713081359863,
-0.3908456265926361,
-0.044747743755578995,
-0.5785455107688904,
0.456516295671463,
-0.2780965268611908,
-0.29015639424324036,
-0.12031757831573486,
-0.03409036248922348,
0.3928605020046234,
0.35968056321144104,
-0.37186938524246216,
0.6398784518241882,
0.5224493145942688,
-0.2676127851009369,
-0.7399477362632751,
-0.4183391034603119,
0.07968159765005112,
-0.22592423856258392,
-0.9930315017700195,
-0.10550190508365631,
0.06384646147489548,
-0.6595152020454407,
0.1975402981042862,
-0.41373640298843384,
-0.38113266229629517,
0.5448004603385925,
0.182426318526268,
0.1578633338212967,
-0.4468226432800293,
0.10151030123233795,
0.08159197866916656,
-0.11051499098539352,
0.16451211273670197,
-0.13570955395698547,
0.32874852418899536,
-0.2543797492980957,
-0.7210408449172974,
0.16213850677013397,
0.39107394218444824,
0.5707586407661438,
-0.15679143369197845,
0.43243318796157837,
0.023139620199799538,
-0.37386831641197205,
-0.37823885679244995,
-0.5760275721549988,
0.1691843420267105,
-0.4178232252597809,
0.315676748752594,
-0.5405026078224182,
-0.7184275984764099,
0.45903998613357544,
-0.35824939608573914,
-0.44791164994239807,
0.6237930059432983,
0.5566374659538269,
0.37793973088264465,
0.6290537118911743,
0.7842912673950195,
0.21044552326202393,
-0.06528361886739731,
0.028616616502404213,
0.25642257928848267,
-0.5515138506889343,
-0.392232209444046,
-0.5810974836349487,
0.30028820037841797,
-0.06008540838956833,
-0.5589078068733215,
0.3362548053264618,
0.4474985599517822,
-0.14079922437667847,
0.14428186416625977,
-0.2219514101743698,
0.5050131678581238,
0.19957426190376282,
-0.20111879706382751,
0.4808063507080078,
0.06989752501249313,
-0.6593573689460754,
-0.031179266050457954,
-0.523003101348877,
-0.829696774482727,
1.0232576131820679,
0.16194650530815125,
0.4720219671726227,
0.32898780703544617,
0.4695509970188141,
0.5072773098945618,
0.22615806758403778,
-0.918509304523468,
0.6141131520271301,
0.17477156221866608,
-0.8194719552993774,
-0.08701084554195404,
-0.4814583957195282,
-0.5314281582832336,
0.18422862887382507,
-0.09693243354558945,
-0.5174387693405151,
0.09341428428888321,
-0.04433279484510422,
-0.14898134768009186,
-0.022630896419286728,
-0.7151270508766174,
0.8970621228218079,
-0.1614450365304947,
-0.36675864458084106,
0.15370403230190277,
-0.5012940168380737,
0.6232651472091675,
-0.4362452030181885,
0.39263391494750977,
-0.1278975009918213,
0.12722013890743256,
0.38004979491233826,
-0.4808619022369385,
0.5936222672462463,
-0.17259883880615234,
0.020506028085947037,
0.4050651490688324,
0.4250580370426178,
0.18409135937690735,
0.24591496586799622,
-0.3163180649280548,
-0.1366017609834671,
0.07111790031194687,
-0.31211918592453003,
-0.7358824014663696,
0.649745523929596,
-0.5435394644737244,
-0.6834901571273804,
-0.4395678639411926,
-0.403887540102005,
-0.7968840003013611,
0.40807318687438965,
-0.07126934826374054,
0.4607594907283783,
-0.5330830812454224,
-0.02817337028682232,
0.5919710993766785,
-0.36044758558273315,
0.15063956379890442,
0.6653447151184082,
-0.4581198990345001,
-0.48435550928115845,
0.7346405982971191,
-0.04598978906869888,
0.3573759198188782,
0.05965286120772362,
-0.04244532063603401,
0.15896548330783844,
-0.4382721483707428,
-0.47294148802757263,
-0.05926244705915451,
-0.7630792856216431,
-0.6667146682739258,
-0.4323197305202484,
-0.18036426603794098,
-0.5519546270370483,
0.06873694062232971,
-0.3668510615825653,
-0.709110677242279,
-0.10145175457000732,
-0.2999332845211029,
0.18868187069892883,
0.7542425990104675,
0.10304290056228638,
-0.0008838999201543629,
-0.7816210389137268,
0.41255420446395874,
0.3637392818927765,
0.40168023109436035,
-0.1733345091342926,
-0.3696872591972351,
-0.2208493947982788,
-0.1396806240081787,
-0.36194679141044617,
-0.9655638933181763,
0.3053112328052521,
0.1689552515745163,
0.6716647744178772,
0.10703188925981522,
-0.07074824720621109,
0.7792955636978149,
-0.6804839372634888,
0.9337788224220276,
-0.16804847121238708,
-1.1018035411834717,
0.7201891541481018,
-0.5905802845954895,
-0.20673909783363342,
0.6074275374412537,
0.12104040384292603,
-0.20086364448070526,
-0.27667149901390076,
-0.7405072450637817,
-1.2380307912826538,
0.5101731419563293,
-0.0012483523460105062,
0.09580720216035843,
-0.3717212975025177,
0.5795488357543945,
0.03643938526511192,
0.13368354737758636,
-0.3400140404701233,
-0.32886824011802673,
-0.020397135987877846,
-0.06055426970124245,
0.3357984125614166,
-0.7069206833839417,
-0.17559273540973663,
-0.09850997477769852,
0.7529134154319763,
-0.02535966970026493,
0.23243999481201172,
0.08852101117372513,
-0.43206125497817993,
-0.23497526347637177,
0.40578514337539673,
0.43231654167175293,
1.0810106992721558,
-0.2645348012447357,
-0.017954008653759956,
-0.033792585134506226,
-0.34497585892677307,
0.3858160078525543,
-0.0900789350271225,
-0.20976175367832184,
0.164892315864563,
0.34158116579055786,
0.4929448664188385,
0.12395687401294708,
-0.8992648124694824,
0.707872748374939,
-0.0335562527179718,
0.055195946246385574,
-0.40353885293006897,
-0.06937749683856964,
-0.018969278782606125,
0.09423110634088516,
0.5045396089553833,
0.06892894208431244,
0.2482990175485611,
-0.41406378149986267,
0.5309273600578308,
0.40683531761169434,
-0.24352966248989105,
-0.24064292013645172,
0.38514164090156555,
0.03582218289375305,
-0.17347954213619232,
0.30186352133750916,
-0.17573906481266022,
-0.3558948338031769,
0.6736088395118713,
0.8007029294967651,
0.9078618884086609,
-0.27471306920051575,
0.17590545117855072,
0.21056433022022247,
0.430275022983551,
0.001566735445521772,
0.4712747037410736,
0.22293046116828918,
-0.5734521746635437,
-0.45447149872779846,
-0.8128212094306946,
-0.38142484426498413,
0.08000964671373367,
-0.9425954222679138,
0.212036594748497,
-0.4131670892238617,
-0.2914333939552307,
-0.423577219247818,
-0.10738682746887207,
-0.21003581583499908,
0.24074110388755798,
-0.24150803685188293,
0.9122834205627441,
-0.8414379954338074,
0.4156918227672577,
0.9168332815170288,
-0.4695113003253937,
-0.7851884961128235,
0.003369129030033946,
0.0034837445709854364,
-0.7372693419456482,
0.9765671491622925,
-0.1539526730775833,
-0.04958358779549599,
-0.2719092071056366,
-0.3330673277378082,
-0.9580135345458984,
0.9690102338790894,
0.5367503762245178,
-0.11815541982650757,
0.2180933803319931,
0.1807822287082672,
0.45301955938339233,
-0.2758080065250397,
0.0679931566119194,
0.7064539194107056,
0.41817766427993774,
-0.06946834921836853,
-1.0713074207305908,
0.04577481001615524,
-0.4134896397590637,
0.15134818851947784,
0.16344426572322845,
-0.38372594118118286,
0.8241893649101257,
0.18033918738365173,
-0.36836522817611694,
0.18734143674373627,
0.5067682862281799,
0.21067999303340912,
0.40631240606307983,
0.30240491032600403,
0.9396385550498962,
0.8319483399391174,
-0.07686083018779755,
1.0687586069107056,
-0.22510090470314026,
0.5471258759498596,
0.9547513127326965,
-0.32541874051094055,
0.9752911329269409,
0.3796098232269287,
-0.1246793121099472,
0.5030990839004517,
0.2081887274980545,
0.3077578842639923,
0.38951972126960754,
0.3154700696468353,
-0.31793275475502014,
-0.24025973677635193,
-0.016499314457178116,
-0.36896732449531555,
0.3624339997768402,
0.5026770234107971,
-0.15327191352844238,
-0.3171515166759491,
-0.035744525492191315,
-0.03593340888619423,
0.27055615186691284,
-0.26770082116127014,
0.860713541507721,
-0.09685405343770981,
-0.5633158087730408,
0.8587954640388489,
0.17138473689556122,
0.1898564249277115,
-0.3929934799671173,
-0.007211935240775347,
-0.5596472024917603,
0.1919475793838501,
-0.2738575339317322,
-0.16991493105888367,
0.7267065048217773,
0.29418185353279114,
-0.4732566475868225,
-0.019742703065276146,
1.1847267150878906,
0.013827243819832802,
-0.6277742385864258,
0.2234368622303009,
0.7863323092460632,
-0.046669721603393555,
0.1720234900712967,
-0.5052259564399719,
0.23915903270244598,
-0.2426145076751709,
-0.2685745656490326,
0.3758387267589569,
0.6735705733299255,
-0.1192471981048584,
0.5869268178939819,
0.3921392261981964,
0.01634783297777176,
0.2668024003505707,
-0.06096122786402702,
1.1567785739898682,
-0.6713536977767944,
-0.03330341726541519,
-0.6254076361656189,
0.7047252655029297,
-0.007418401539325714,
0.0352436788380146,
0.9687398076057434,
0.5262636542320251,
0.5699254870414734,
-0.08466034382581711,
0.8997668027877808,
-0.3025316894054413,
0.8899907469749451,
-0.47427019476890564,
0.6365874409675598,
-0.4368477165699005,
0.6235928535461426,
-0.3426424562931061,
-0.8698873519897461,
-0.5493773818016052,
0.49025800824165344,
-0.054799098521471024,
0.04260062798857689,
0.8041410446166992,
0.8057976365089417,
-0.1678360402584076,
-0.3692317605018616,
0.5034851431846619,
0.21054291725158691,
0.06228170171380043,
0.1289127767086029,
1.004576325416565,
-0.5854674577713013,
0.3692326247692108,
0.06166864186525345,
-0.2987704873085022,
-0.17010419070720673,
-0.9064186215400696,
-0.7746855020523071,
-0.2733435332775116,
-0.23136499524116516,
-0.5081959962844849,
0.285564124584198,
0.5090516805648804,
0.3654196858406067,
-0.7991938591003418,
-0.27649253606796265,
-0.06902763992547989,
0.23853817582130432,
-0.0863255113363266,
-0.28246742486953735,
0.277864009141922,
-1.0131293535232544,
-0.29802459478378296,
0.7499642968177795,
0.33963751792907715,
-0.35904523730278015,
-0.21907301247119904,
0.25880077481269836,
-0.22755371034145355,
0.104803666472435,
0.6569652557373047,
0.2420720010995865,
-0.560234010219574,
-0.18807461857795715,
0.17819522321224213,
-0.06229358911514282,
-0.2645410895347595,
0.8985647559165955,
-0.8768675923347473,
0.4572471082210541,
0.5449012517929077,
1.078342318534851,
-0.08166354149580002,
0.2589983344078064,
0.6328843235969543,
-1.0185703039169312,
0.17480655014514923,
0.34788092970848083,
0.23707066476345062,
0.3876858353614807,
-0.3757205605506897,
0.6282079815864563,
0.49760302901268005,
-0.6647796630859375,
-1.0974814891815186,
0.3571995198726654,
-0.8314548134803772,
-0.24689452350139618,
1.4075136184692383,
-0.19937145709991455,
-0.2367732673883438,
-0.30513960123062134,
0.021893786266446114,
-0.08012592792510986,
0.22497479617595673,
0.5725609064102173,
0.6977676749229431,
0.16581127047538757,
0.31196242570877075,
-0.5953479409217834,
0.38384440541267395,
0.4596574604511261,
-0.7468791604042053,
-0.0064188288524746895,
0.8776198029518127,
0.4147074818611145,
0.2868650555610657,
0.607681155204773,
-0.42862170934677124,
0.13416995108127594,
0.13940775394439697,
-0.07764218002557755,
-0.046248409897089005,
-0.24530580639839172,
-0.33675673604011536,
0.3674669861793518,
0.3359207212924957,
0.158501997590065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19221v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19221v1
|
Transcrib3D: 3D Referring Expression Resolution through Large Language Models
| 2024-04-30T02:48:20 | 2024-04-30T02:48:20 |
Jiading Fang, Xiangshan Tan, Shengjie Lin, Igor Vasiljevic, Vitor Guizilini, Hongyuan Mei, Rares Ambrus, Gregory Shakhnarovich, Matthew R Walter
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
If robots are to work effectively alongside people, they must be able to
interpret natural language references to objects in their 3D environment.
Understanding 3D referring expressions is challenging -- it requires the
ability to both parse the 3D structure of the scene and correctly ground
free-form language in the presence of distraction and clutter. We introduce
Transcrib3D, an approach that brings together 3D detection methods and the
emergent reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs). Transcrib3D
uses text as the unifying medium, which allows us to sidestep the need to learn
shared representations connecting multi-modal inputs, which would require
massive amounts of annotated 3D data. As a demonstration of its effectiveness,
Transcrib3D achieves state-of-the-art results on 3D reference resolution
benchmarks, with a great leap in performance from previous multi-modality
baselines. To improve upon zero-shot performance and facilitate local
deployment on edge computers and robots, we propose self-correction for
fine-tuning that trains smaller models, resulting in performance close to that
of large models. We show that our method enables a real robot to perform
pick-and-place tasks given queries that contain challenging referring
expressions. Project site is at https://ripl.github.io/Transcrib3D.
|
[
-0.15230509638786316,
-0.5548956394195557,
0.7442893385887146,
-0.03216906264424324,
-0.16557805240154266,
0.0023980336263775826,
0.15173251926898956,
-0.8682592511177063,
-0.04650840535759926,
0.766531229019165,
-0.509908139705658,
-0.3749832808971405,
-0.5159444808959961,
0.42557039856910706,
-0.39040258526802063,
0.3132513165473938,
-0.03965137153863907,
-0.10803797841072083,
-0.2641637921333313,
-0.29079198837280273,
-0.17564056813716888,
-0.4459798038005829,
-0.42187175154685974,
-0.10801385343074799,
0.3311234712600708,
0.3754689693450928,
1.143441915512085,
1.144797682762146,
0.6652913093566895,
0.3565159738063812,
0.024210698902606964,
0.236139714717865,
-0.18534055352210999,
-0.0681857094168663,
-0.32387784123420715,
-0.3394134044647217,
-0.3184449076652527,
-0.3398434817790985,
0.6958664059638977,
0.8806507587432861,
0.15956369042396545,
-0.024773579090833664,
-0.039745938032865524,
0.7664008140563965,
-0.5566439628601074,
-0.016833724454045296,
-0.3607032299041748,
0.16974976658821106,
-0.15322761237621307,
-0.02967884950339794,
-0.20158089697360992,
-0.05777750536799431,
0.1381411850452423,
-0.7636009454727173,
0.5701225399971008,
-0.14115139842033386,
0.548758327960968,
0.5292636752128601,
-0.3585444390773773,
-0.13244029879570007,
-0.8485102653503418,
0.6077043414115906,
-0.6119213700294495,
0.5511037707328796,
0.25405412912368774,
0.4711824655532837,
-0.10626491904258728,
-0.6304351091384888,
-0.6715909242630005,
-0.17182289063930511,
0.003574048401787877,
0.013732575811445713,
-0.23118583858013153,
0.03491208329796791,
0.38725948333740234,
0.3552882969379425,
-0.6297901272773743,
-0.06944488734006882,
-0.5764528512954712,
-0.4158863127231598,
0.4050912857055664,
0.08165097236633301,
0.26264888048171997,
0.006012250669300556,
-0.3234061002731323,
-0.31466910243034363,
-0.700192391872406,
-0.5198312401771545,
0.19358378648757935,
0.6548948287963867,
-0.12344113737344742,
0.6362653970718384,
-0.2644999921321869,
1.0905108451843262,
-0.003570832312107086,
0.12512275576591492,
0.33321210741996765,
-0.18963365256786346,
-0.09623079746961594,
0.03814315423369408,
0.809023380279541,
0.3299825191497803,
0.24189187586307526,
0.045944202691316605,
0.012058163993060589,
-0.22776912152767181,
0.3516496419906616,
-0.5325513482093811,
-0.10262922197580338,
0.06235884130001068,
-0.35435745120048523,
0.24340850114822388,
-0.2133493274450302,
-0.7183934450149536,
-0.7266453504562378,
-0.25918513536453247,
0.44099515676498413,
-0.29903414845466614,
-0.36921021342277527,
0.536031186580658,
-0.012815762311220169,
-0.07368452101945877,
0.6198663711547852,
-0.5976637601852417,
-0.007339355535805225,
0.3398669958114624,
0.9223729968070984,
0.05598637834191322,
-0.24716636538505554,
-0.601828932762146,
0.6811378002166748,
-0.3500646948814392,
1.0565773248672485,
-0.5404626727104187,
-0.6258094906806946,
0.08259237557649612,
-0.15351562201976776,
0.08125926554203033,
-0.88393634557724,
0.20595422387123108,
-0.08158848434686661,
0.46707287430763245,
0.4012153446674347,
-0.22274444997310638,
-0.26690372824668884,
0.3378932476043701,
-1.058226227760315,
0.8237500190734863,
0.3968522846698761,
-0.1766408532857895,
-0.22280290722846985,
-0.6842173337936401,
-0.4113686680793762,
0.15399985015392303,
-0.060513172298669815,
-0.045424215495586395,
0.10352277010679245,
0.2064785361289978,
0.45003706216812134,
-0.3739265203475952,
-0.24545493721961975,
-0.25252652168273926,
-0.10622513294219971,
-0.21222859621047974,
-0.08869089186191559,
0.4347074329853058,
0.11721494048833847,
-0.011831941083073616,
0.22085608541965485,
-0.6781614422798157,
-0.13449712097644806,
0.08338571339845657,
-0.10167139768600464,
-0.11800812929868698,
-0.22867634892463684,
-0.3866614103317261,
0.4249056875705719,
0.3259938657283783,
-0.4907910227775574,
0.045090124011039734,
-0.44468894600868225,
0.16220314800739288,
0.3406635820865631,
-0.3606768548488617,
0.35902997851371765,
-0.19831304252147675,
0.5084317326545715,
0.11062925308942795,
0.17270885407924652,
-0.20988993346691132,
-0.4078238308429718,
-0.45868033170700073,
-0.13615088164806366,
-0.011475367471575737,
0.4061835706233978,
-1.0524595975875854,
0.2613159120082855,
-0.4219898283481598,
-0.4523943364620209,
-0.44849035143852234,
0.2627372741699219,
0.20083966851234436,
0.7178063988685608,
0.659442663192749,
0.059647221118211746,
-0.4490669369697571,
-1.1179203987121582,
-0.2015734165906906,
-0.3465164303779602,
-0.7315383553504944,
0.03173648938536644,
0.060354553163051605,
-0.1397141069173813,
0.7513719797134399,
-0.342407763004303,
-0.6620694994926453,
-0.44475436210632324,
0.20717087388038635,
0.21625235676765442,
0.36978796124458313,
0.3975639343261719,
-0.8589931726455688,
-0.23147186636924744,
0.13198097050189972,
-0.5350542068481445,
-0.14926782250404358,
-0.21413610875606537,
0.015592096373438835,
0.1860690414905548,
0.9409680962562561,
-0.4295521378517151,
0.2618005871772766,
0.7977328896522522,
-0.30309370160102844,
0.052247632294893265,
-0.13073691725730896,
-0.07633565366268158,
-0.9654305577278137,
0.0717100277543068,
0.25463974475860596,
-0.4765821099281311,
-0.47112682461738586,
-0.021730683743953705,
-0.05058249831199646,
-0.11237052828073502,
-0.8160978555679321,
0.48827895522117615,
-0.5318108201026917,
-0.19825409352779388,
-0.361677885055542,
0.49390092492103577,
0.16318972408771515,
0.3843335211277008,
0.6142899394035339,
0.67908775806427,
0.24322479963302612,
-0.7255381941795349,
0.5217332243919373,
0.2580360770225525,
-0.2912291884422302,
0.3753003180027008,
-0.6163185238838196,
0.20534124970436096,
0.12578698992729187,
0.23553571105003357,
-0.765859067440033,
-0.11522013694047928,
0.31867510080337524,
-0.3734053671360016,
0.043831389397382736,
-0.0865112915635109,
-0.6112927794456482,
-0.2911287844181061,
-0.11462745070457458,
0.7183701395988464,
0.06339143216609955,
-0.5359573364257812,
1.1731675863265991,
0.44372907280921936,
0.22268790006637573,
-0.24185378849506378,
-0.4752345085144043,
0.14384956657886505,
0.13193672895431519,
-0.407072514295578,
0.44208768010139465,
-0.12288502603769302,
0.10443966835737228,
-0.026071805506944656,
-0.24938204884529114,
-0.06862801313400269,
-0.07157683372497559,
-0.05168455094099045,
0.2786235809326172,
-0.08795814961194992,
-0.17839165031909943,
-0.3836398124694824,
-0.3116570711135864,
0.05483538657426834,
0.013833829201757908,
0.5749486088752747,
-0.23256704211235046,
-0.35453155636787415,
-0.30915844440460205,
0.21389438211917877,
0.6340464353561401,
0.15331946313381195,
0.24147585034370422,
0.46006330847740173,
-0.541254460811615,
0.024195076897740364,
-0.39871081709861755,
0.01914074830710888,
-0.5052998065948486,
0.597877562046051,
-0.5487231612205505,
-0.8678567409515381,
0.34489795565605164,
-0.44595855474472046,
-0.03781917318701744,
0.5479965209960938,
0.44150155782699585,
0.014022823423147202,
1.122767448425293,
0.6257665157318115,
0.4450022578239441,
0.3721163272857666,
-0.06416302919387817,
0.26644840836524963,
-1.083067536354065,
-0.31029564142227173,
-0.7389519810676575,
-0.2351863980293274,
-0.31882935762405396,
-0.9035917520523071,
0.2867569625377655,
0.0014947936870157719,
-0.22928468883037567,
0.6608311533927917,
-0.548647403717041,
0.6021783947944641,
0.46214616298675537,
0.0788894072175026,
0.37527546286582947,
-0.2157001495361328,
-0.045311231166124344,
0.11430184543132782,
-0.478977233171463,
-0.5356661677360535,
0.44435471296310425,
0.3315328061580658,
0.600409209728241,
0.18901413679122925,
0.15037186443805695,
0.25137919187545776,
0.06501886248588562,
-0.8725954294204712,
0.9173846244812012,
-0.24888809025287628,
-0.5280212163925171,
-0.22269894182682037,
-0.5051808953285217,
-0.7559858560562134,
0.3052828907966614,
-0.14278259873390198,
-0.665484607219696,
0.10177161544561386,
0.07803431898355484,
-0.47416168451309204,
0.5842363238334656,
-0.4374751150608063,
0.9318611025810242,
-0.15418657660484314,
-0.5235627889633179,
-0.2748051583766937,
-0.7027834057807922,
0.09040714055299759,
0.06171775981783867,
0.05175435170531273,
-0.3840987980365753,
-0.09987414628267288,
0.4664026200771332,
-0.12550504505634308,
0.8832636475563049,
0.04147787019610405,
-0.5534537434577942,
0.2007775604724884,
0.7112386226654053,
0.11747679859399796,
-0.2073393017053604,
-0.1882982701063156,
0.6900743246078491,
0.08786172419786453,
-0.1222570613026619,
-0.8655049800872803,
0.4620509147644043,
-0.6107594966888428,
-0.7123726606369019,
-0.3429012894630432,
-0.7077450156211853,
-0.5217098593711853,
0.3933495879173279,
-0.10967690497636795,
0.24897947907447815,
-0.06615567207336426,
0.25782811641693115,
0.4405820667743683,
-0.32351452112197876,
0.25964581966400146,
0.6312988996505737,
-0.32637566328048706,
-0.22625988721847534,
0.6751689910888672,
-0.3142518401145935,
0.34468981623649597,
0.8251895308494568,
0.13936492800712585,
-0.5125147104263306,
-0.4310208857059479,
-0.6040701866149902,
0.3383145332336426,
-0.5349895358085632,
-0.5833969116210938,
-0.4765656590461731,
-0.14419203996658325,
-0.3332992196083069,
-0.21158356964588165,
-0.6836538314819336,
-0.6349376440048218,
-0.3257162868976593,
0.00698055699467659,
0.04699191078543663,
0.7861588597297668,
-0.4877689778804779,
0.29908305406570435,
-1.1843147277832031,
0.8604112863540649,
0.24234528839588165,
0.4754508137702942,
-0.3023969829082489,
-0.45624056458473206,
-0.3018713593482971,
0.25651729106903076,
-0.1686563789844513,
-0.2960311770439148,
0.2788867652416229,
-0.008295062929391861,
0.34414762258529663,
0.17757581174373627,
0.05432175099849701,
0.8827083110809326,
-0.3895537555217743,
0.7394134998321533,
0.290595680475235,
-1.0962632894515991,
0.7406516671180725,
-0.2454814910888672,
0.6900759339332581,
0.44400033354759216,
0.3405524492263794,
-0.7121397852897644,
-0.35678815841674805,
-0.2548726499080658,
-0.6862836480140686,
0.787322998046875,
-0.11709307134151459,
0.12483536452054977,
-0.07444363087415695,
0.30316418409347534,
-0.05271010100841522,
-0.18569305539131165,
-0.6362295746803284,
0.17181521654129028,
-0.28677406907081604,
-0.3916148245334625,
0.14753690361976624,
-0.16716797649860382,
-0.08256912231445312,
-0.14438489079475403,
0.3613971769809723,
-0.42028549313545227,
0.4165439009666443,
0.2620190978050232,
-0.20906274020671844,
-0.3720160722732544,
-0.3104138672351837,
0.6334683299064636,
0.6875550150871277,
-0.2708905041217804,
0.19438208639621735,
-0.004730567801743746,
-0.41960811614990234,
-0.2314174473285675,
-0.13770031929016113,
0.30668458342552185,
0.09885845333337784,
0.5793829560279846,
0.3561042249202728,
0.08301421254873276,
-0.7257854342460632,
0.3299426734447479,
-0.15196146070957184,
-0.2216978669166565,
-0.101291723549366,
0.08938606083393097,
-0.10597258806228638,
0.09562797099351883,
0.447383314371109,
0.1727035939693451,
0.1684647798538208,
-0.4618193507194519,
0.1315644383430481,
0.2870323956012726,
-0.5921444296836853,
-0.28264740109443665,
0.5446648597717285,
0.43619969487190247,
-0.3045441508293152,
0.8667843341827393,
0.35379302501678467,
-0.4480060636997223,
0.6246427297592163,
0.7331696152687073,
0.9508564472198486,
-0.39754289388656616,
0.22961150109767914,
0.5984920263290405,
0.2799088954925537,
-0.13611696660518646,
-0.06330666691064835,
-0.03224055469036102,
-1.1280890703201294,
-0.5884536504745483,
-0.2906731367111206,
-0.6917361617088318,
0.16858574748039246,
-0.46527421474456787,
0.19139675796031952,
-0.5884008407592773,
0.15722516179084778,
-0.1671089231967926,
-0.272579163312912,
-0.5551832914352417,
0.09001320600509644,
0.511435329914093,
0.9257099628448486,
-0.42684268951416016,
0.6448619365692139,
0.7987962365150452,
-0.10405130684375763,
-0.40849021077156067,
0.1495816856622696,
0.02407045103609562,
-0.9851019382476807,
0.6499005556106567,
0.4302898049354553,
-0.7590137720108032,
-0.04960709437727928,
-0.420911580324173,
-0.9087164402008057,
0.7001417875289917,
0.5285251140594482,
-0.5606920719146729,
0.042188793420791626,
0.5305235981941223,
0.5381401777267456,
-0.26172152161598206,
0.28751903772354126,
0.29683688282966614,
0.4497978985309601,
0.4798711836338043,
-1.0515310764312744,
0.1676020622253418,
-0.17594081163406372,
0.09646125137805939,
0.22356286644935608,
-0.5372739434242249,
0.37565574049949646,
-0.20438098907470703,
-0.4880475103855133,
-0.012357896193861961,
0.8953686356544495,
0.08431736379861832,
-0.07956398278474808,
0.7143115997314453,
0.47319304943084717,
0.29968133568763733,
0.08487918227910995,
0.9157848954200745,
-0.30256614089012146,
-0.027386434376239777,
1.1640925407409668,
-0.6558339595794678,
0.6647405624389648,
0.31218522787094116,
0.008577457629144192,
0.6019126176834106,
0.312626451253891,
0.12737351655960083,
0.45604178309440613,
-0.00723523274064064,
-0.1997683197259903,
-0.5760769248008728,
-0.3262048363685608,
-0.057825300842523575,
0.5406581163406372,
0.5578954815864563,
0.13083069026470184,
-0.612873911857605,
0.059305787086486816,
-0.33505409955978394,
0.41200193762779236,
-0.3992305099964142,
0.7563163638114929,
-0.11099660396575928,
-0.3562757074832916,
0.3128837049007416,
-0.23523691296577454,
0.3765442967414856,
-0.6279059648513794,
-0.5072944760322571,
-0.1587522178888321,
0.4676721394062042,
-0.14089153707027435,
-1.0491342544555664,
0.7080338597297668,
-0.3169521391391754,
0.037983238697052,
-0.4125703275203705,
0.3330937623977661,
-0.2612232267856598,
-0.5751911997795105,
0.5081468820571899,
0.45418840646743774,
0.008407333865761757,
-0.17732739448547363,
-0.7135757803916931,
0.07131087779998779,
0.08286099135875702,
0.013037383556365967,
0.184522345662117,
0.7146957516670227,
0.014547391794621944,
0.8725020289421082,
0.4922703802585602,
-0.08112049847841263,
-0.30290552973747253,
0.12196992337703705,
0.7080249190330505,
-0.7220401167869568,
-0.11170138418674469,
-0.6934511661529541,
0.3301893472671509,
-0.005636458285152912,
-0.2987478971481323,
0.5173186659812927,
0.8140425682067871,
1.0839073657989502,
-0.134809210896492,
0.3896355926990509,
0.05007663741707802,
0.869969367980957,
-0.4723271429538727,
-0.011077399365603924,
-0.5345844626426697,
0.11488784104585648,
-0.14856527745723724,
-0.8897181153297424,
-1.0460542440414429,
1.0046017169952393,
-0.15247951447963715,
0.009750574827194214,
0.649273157119751,
0.7966690063476562,
-0.13044942915439606,
-0.24362081289291382,
0.5304577946662903,
0.14218124747276306,
0.43110063672065735,
0.6903707981109619,
0.9548630118370056,
-0.43105605244636536,
0.8708238005638123,
-0.3092704713344574,
0.07726816833019257,
-0.12814295291900635,
-1.0870847702026367,
-0.755251944065094,
-0.7341652512550354,
-0.5937209725379944,
-0.3623915910720825,
-0.21272379159927368,
0.7835574150085449,
0.5235167145729065,
-0.6169773936271667,
-0.3261929154396057,
0.07367389649152756,
0.19969788193702698,
-0.27905142307281494,
-0.21488340198993683,
0.24684587121009827,
0.05581158027052879,
-0.9751342535018921,
0.615404486656189,
0.4745495319366455,
0.25467392802238464,
-0.2343529611825943,
0.1359170377254486,
-0.24844548106193542,
-0.12852957844734192,
0.675519585609436,
0.5300970077514648,
-0.3747937083244324,
-0.5148021578788757,
-0.1271848976612091,
-0.1547141820192337,
0.2384011447429657,
0.9263080954551697,
-1.1807185411453247,
0.4395650327205658,
0.4488430917263031,
0.46270132064819336,
0.48399272561073303,
0.08996645361185074,
0.8349543809890747,
-0.5622158646583557,
0.20908455550670624,
0.5558759570121765,
0.359250009059906,
0.6538525223731995,
-0.36905351281166077,
0.8930435180664062,
-0.05244457349181175,
-0.22060230374336243,
-0.5571362972259521,
0.43004918098449707,
-1.0795197486877441,
-0.4664527177810669,
0.9152014851570129,
0.1997268944978714,
-0.3901102840900421,
-0.25214242935180664,
-0.19801944494247437,
0.15613457560539246,
-0.08714069426059723,
0.8617430925369263,
0.44674795866012573,
-0.31322649121284485,
-0.4147633910179138,
-0.37632179260253906,
0.41013211011886597,
0.1634897142648697,
-0.5953513979911804,
0.44193699955940247,
0.817961573600769,
-0.10259079933166504,
0.594911515712738,
0.3456246554851532,
-0.36365941166877747,
0.2534850537776947,
-0.2528063952922821,
0.27050912380218506,
-0.25414982438087463,
-0.4329381287097931,
-0.21889449656009674,
0.14731812477111816,
-0.2729632556438446,
-0.20217680931091309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19192v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19192v1
|
Mix of Experts Language Model for Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-04-30T01:41:03 | 2024-04-30T01:41:03 |
Xinwei Chen, Kun Li, Tianyou Song, Jiangjian Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Named Entity Recognition (NER) is an essential steppingstone in the field of
natural language processing. Although promising performance has been achieved
by various distantly supervised models, we argue that distant supervision
inevitably introduces incomplete and noisy annotations, which may mislead the
model training process. To address this issue, we propose a robust NER model
named BOND-MoE based on Mixture of Experts (MoE). Instead of relying on a
single model for NER prediction, multiple models are trained and ensembled
under the Expectation-Maximization (EM) framework, so that noisy supervision
can be dramatically alleviated. In addition, we introduce a fair assignment
module to balance the document-model assignment process. Extensive experiments
on real-world datasets show that the proposed method achieves state-of-the-art
performance compared with other distantly supervised NER.
|
[
-0.49985963106155396,
-0.7589522004127502,
0.5782648921012878,
0.05284125730395317,
-0.13297483325004578,
0.07408151775598526,
-0.39032500982284546,
-0.784257709980011,
0.42104434967041016,
0.546713650226593,
-0.057962797582149506,
-0.3082374036312103,
-0.8429262638092041,
0.3252788782119751,
-0.4102422297000885,
1.086256980895996,
0.10164438933134079,
0.07498112320899963,
-0.16596285998821259,
-0.009142217226326466,
-0.3313901424407959,
-0.28459432721138,
-0.905389130115509,
-0.22051507234573364,
0.37017786502838135,
0.3732765018939972,
0.5176301002502441,
0.722736656665802,
0.692042350769043,
0.3263200521469116,
-0.22673828899860382,
0.2458333671092987,
-0.20301729440689087,
0.2118951380252838,
-0.2904209494590759,
-0.3581278622150421,
-0.9161830544471741,
-0.24565061926841736,
0.613666832447052,
0.6791859269142151,
-0.4667690098285675,
-0.2171870619058609,
-0.12677137553691864,
0.2945025861263275,
-0.6055047512054443,
0.13364899158477783,
-0.9468697905540466,
-0.20737311244010925,
-0.18637101352214813,
0.045701030641794205,
-0.5099027156829834,
-0.1448403000831604,
0.3649742007255554,
-0.7357761859893799,
0.3859389126300812,
0.2785149812698364,
1.1696100234985352,
0.2095247209072113,
-0.4266657531261444,
-0.17127899825572968,
-0.7748439311981201,
0.8285354375839233,
-0.7988353967666626,
0.4248049259185791,
0.4879777133464813,
0.2009924054145813,
-0.30633124709129333,
-0.3264220058917999,
-0.5975257754325867,
0.020152203738689423,
0.11204568296670914,
-0.01551753655076027,
-0.011844226159155369,
0.1692972332239151,
-0.06344114989042282,
0.45053383708000183,
-0.09211459755897522,
0.2618198096752167,
-0.40230894088745117,
-0.17024339735507965,
0.6822369694709778,
-0.11648266017436981,
0.3574032485485077,
0.06519461423158646,
-0.5791158676147461,
0.19964438676834106,
-0.2976512014865875,
-0.2150525003671646,
0.46414434909820557,
0.4648822546005249,
0.0015430417843163013,
0.48364895582199097,
-0.3943347930908203,
0.6852193474769592,
0.46644648909568787,
-0.3513633906841278,
0.238310307264328,
0.18301989138126373,
-0.08479335159063339,
0.379010409116745,
0.8282917737960815,
0.3949061632156372,
0.39911261200904846,
-0.5783380270004272,
-0.4934680759906769,
-0.06640113890171051,
0.1205957904458046,
-0.6729950308799744,
-0.5171595215797424,
-0.0019752206280827522,
-0.006531241349875927,
-0.3372933268547058,
0.07755530625581741,
-0.8920660614967346,
-0.2253064513206482,
-0.40388453006744385,
0.3718240261077881,
-0.513433039188385,
-0.7286621332168579,
-0.19439902901649475,
-0.06480614095926285,
-0.15843230485916138,
0.3992990553379059,
-1.0929272174835205,
0.6658973097801208,
0.6811597943305969,
0.5066732168197632,
-0.17454266548156738,
-0.19168631732463837,
-0.6760808229446411,
0.5300812721252441,
-0.06726625561714172,
0.9467911720275879,
-0.7628031373023987,
-0.11180572211742401,
-0.4049934446811676,
-0.2057129293680191,
-0.2647828459739685,
-0.6330912113189697,
0.28339067101478577,
-0.6108058094978333,
0.13352759182453156,
0.11196085065603256,
-0.8794587254524231,
-0.08888303488492966,
0.18976663053035736,
-0.815485417842865,
1.030570149421692,
0.13283057510852814,
-0.9713557958602905,
0.7426537871360779,
-0.3904014825820923,
-0.3829207122325897,
0.19480837881565094,
-0.24252992868423462,
-0.4208393394947052,
-0.02575094811618328,
0.43616098165512085,
0.6274737119674683,
0.0745062530040741,
0.8167706727981567,
-0.4502304792404175,
-0.027216767892241478,
0.2955039441585541,
-0.18239572644233704,
0.3179745674133301,
0.10974972695112228,
-0.12704844772815704,
-0.16847074031829834,
-1.1000584363937378,
-0.30003854632377625,
-0.0871756300330162,
-0.4688037633895874,
-0.8780539631843567,
0.01431348267942667,
0.10434894263744354,
0.050211239606142044,
0.11540762335062027,
-0.6058453321456909,
0.1019923985004425,
-0.4958784282207489,
0.33056068420410156,
0.5693063139915466,
0.20566241443157196,
0.9071515798568726,
-0.11285701394081116,
0.3916591703891754,
0.25903409719467163,
-0.2972087860107422,
0.08105814456939697,
-0.49794867634773254,
-0.9969996213912964,
-0.6123679280281067,
0.5687060952186584,
0.650485634803772,
-0.5408177375793457,
0.35759469866752625,
-0.43586310744285583,
-0.30295324325561523,
-0.5915251970291138,
0.3050127923488617,
0.2793154716491699,
0.6089707612991333,
0.49776729941368103,
-0.24564076960086823,
-0.5034443736076355,
-1.085800290107727,
-0.2823929190635681,
-0.233223557472229,
0.1739800125360489,
0.22596655786037445,
0.3355218172073364,
-0.15602505207061768,
1.10230553150177,
-0.1363060176372528,
-0.4700959622859955,
-0.1852840930223465,
0.1700679361820221,
0.1799691915512085,
0.5746861696243286,
0.24778097867965698,
-0.8497733473777771,
-0.422191321849823,
0.1045932024717331,
-0.5909152030944824,
0.02036258578300476,
-0.03793581202626228,
-0.1005515530705452,
0.02199474535882473,
0.508198618888855,
-0.5520755052566528,
0.000046309909521369264,
0.2308657467365265,
0.04463939741253853,
0.16159337759017944,
-0.13568682968616486,
-0.24749182164669037,
-1.461044430732727,
-0.18312154710292816,
0.25440770387649536,
-0.49647948145866394,
-0.5425001978874207,
0.09263040870428085,
-0.12812890112400055,
0.23379254341125488,
-0.1252608597278595,
0.6187699437141418,
-0.8955733180046082,
0.3155858814716339,
-0.2602870762348175,
0.23897604644298553,
-0.1549963802099228,
0.3126862943172455,
0.3466761112213135,
0.48579511046409607,
0.6847520470619202,
-0.6583666205406189,
0.20514830946922302,
0.12329699844121933,
-0.21595995128154755,
0.8111680150032043,
-0.5249247550964355,
0.10164675116539001,
-0.20227877795696259,
-0.10352212190628052,
-0.5274170637130737,
-0.6039760112762451,
0.17576466500759125,
-0.35788360238075256,
0.7878565788269043,
-0.33221733570098877,
-0.24424731731414795,
-0.004592580255120993,
0.35061347484588623,
0.33485671877861023,
0.2662598788738251,
-0.3303750455379486,
0.8225499987602234,
0.7867921590805054,
-0.5001461505889893,
-0.5686888694763184,
-0.7870412468910217,
0.27682143449783325,
-0.37884896993637085,
-0.4661937355995178,
0.5297563076019287,
0.33218368887901306,
-0.3964381814002991,
0.19452665746212006,
-0.1751042604446411,
-0.8076004385948181,
0.025363359600305557,
0.3393611013889313,
0.2708148956298828,
-0.3110882043838501,
0.07418404519557953,
0.1817876398563385,
-0.17892979085445404,
-0.0037516425363719463,
0.2123168557882309,
-0.034591302275657654,
-0.16574372351169586,
-0.043355777859687805,
-0.29108548164367676,
0.46559348702430725,
0.27898722887039185,
-0.21819397807121277,
0.7408928871154785,
0.5103169083595276,
-0.6580812335014343,
-0.38389265537261963,
-0.8654550313949585,
-0.05363253876566887,
-0.4264487326145172,
0.365102618932724,
-0.4621182382106781,
-0.8504971265792847,
0.5072317123413086,
-0.0717955082654953,
-0.07098861038684845,
0.35015782713890076,
0.2700999081134796,
0.11365881562232971,
0.5291727185249329,
0.8351681232452393,
-0.21828483045101166,
0.4147522449493408,
0.11441396921873093,
0.4660409986972809,
-0.7712202072143555,
-0.2748569846153259,
-0.26108506321907043,
-0.04055636003613472,
-0.4241202771663666,
-0.09376166760921478,
-0.1656876653432846,
0.47324338555336,
0.18858177959918976,
0.6607800722122192,
-0.5479129552841187,
0.5152484178543091,
0.5433200597763062,
0.16859757900238037,
0.34963762760162354,
0.10923583805561066,
-0.24323365092277527,
-0.015064544044435024,
-0.5846694111824036,
-0.7201282382011414,
0.7882178425788879,
0.2617628872394562,
0.7633647322654724,
0.01778934895992279,
1.301903247833252,
0.0916551724076271,
0.39087116718292236,
-0.48317453265190125,
0.6233077645301819,
0.1496395319700241,
-0.9313287734985352,
-0.20878730714321136,
-0.5202052593231201,
-0.8257295489311218,
0.16978861391544342,
-0.2376813143491745,
-0.9788450598716736,
0.496242880821228,
0.059945981949567795,
-0.4707254469394684,
0.4463191628456116,
-0.6339777112007141,
0.5419731140136719,
0.0607420951128006,
-0.10315810889005661,
0.019142528995871544,
-0.7068381905555725,
0.3814736008644104,
-0.21227124333381653,
0.46519097685813904,
-0.2678108513355255,
0.04353518784046173,
0.7982573509216309,
-0.355608195066452,
0.47193413972854614,
-0.027547454461455345,
-0.015223046764731407,
0.31300097703933716,
0.05156189575791359,
0.6059473156929016,
0.21156594157218933,
-0.1819731593132019,
0.050854749977588654,
-0.2730262875556946,
-0.20003348588943481,
-0.24927471578121185,
0.6992955207824707,
-0.6414913535118103,
-0.3345232307910919,
-0.3822179138660431,
-0.6029024124145508,
0.03725732862949371,
0.37909001111984253,
0.3030396103858948,
0.2960764169692993,
-0.18971256911754608,
-0.01815645769238472,
0.6892542839050293,
0.16900861263275146,
0.5643306374549866,
0.43543535470962524,
-0.2708291709423065,
-0.5844670534133911,
1.158529281616211,
0.28036388754844666,
0.12807194888591766,
0.5645312070846558,
-0.37272801995277405,
0.1395506113767624,
-0.5312630534172058,
-0.40790149569511414,
-0.006968841888010502,
-0.5140315890312195,
-0.17103759944438934,
-1.1153285503387451,
-0.17573606967926025,
-0.2872548997402191,
-0.12738968431949615,
-0.6745413541793823,
-0.3474799394607544,
-0.5718982815742493,
-0.27482929825782776,
0.3370278775691986,
0.5955221056938171,
0.0890166237950325,
0.37087613344192505,
-0.7027233242988586,
0.412646621465683,
0.3731635808944702,
0.3403642475605011,
-0.12059305608272552,
-0.35792335867881775,
-0.18867133557796478,
-0.08569823950529099,
0.05075264349579811,
-1.0518463850021362,
0.43684765696525574,
0.517291247844696,
0.783052921295166,
0.6158414483070374,
0.23170380294322968,
0.6369993686676025,
-0.4604915380477905,
0.36182212829589844,
0.03481733053922653,
-0.7566500902175903,
0.36261215806007385,
-0.534466564655304,
-0.3626444935798645,
0.814066469669342,
0.07964007556438446,
0.04517258331179619,
-0.8229402303695679,
-0.7627872824668884,
-1.2333033084869385,
0.6066762208938599,
0.17582885921001434,
-0.04559076577425003,
-0.2582763433456421,
0.1301034837961197,
0.2572284936904907,
0.1817988157272339,
-0.8942587971687317,
-0.21024318039417267,
0.27843135595321655,
-0.25139662623405457,
0.33855968713760376,
-0.2105308324098587,
0.24226444959640503,
-0.07047011703252792,
0.8938220739364624,
0.20500358939170837,
0.27170416712760925,
0.20075595378875732,
-0.35612207651138306,
-0.2410152703523636,
0.6939430832862854,
0.18032234907150269,
0.39499717950820923,
-0.5023983120918274,
0.13986346125602722,
0.31604599952697754,
-0.25834375619888306,
0.10811517387628555,
0.4795072674751282,
-0.27811601758003235,
0.3230324387550354,
0.21747931838035583,
0.7578163743019104,
0.37897789478302,
-0.2937735915184021,
0.5120052695274353,
0.1397871971130371,
-0.10245408862829208,
-0.34192824363708496,
0.29441094398498535,
0.17138564586639404,
0.2654431462287903,
0.5186338424682617,
0.511443018913269,
0.2112383395433426,
-0.1040312871336937,
0.32695579528808594,
0.2241387665271759,
-0.3111746609210968,
-0.27100297808647156,
0.9171066880226135,
0.20294189453125,
-0.33525410294532776,
0.6738266348838806,
-0.4923037588596344,
-0.47239363193511963,
0.7198290228843689,
0.46990880370140076,
0.7351499199867249,
-0.29805833101272583,
-0.031021472066640854,
0.25751033425331116,
0.3928599953651428,
-0.36360985040664673,
0.23116782307624817,
0.030603449791669846,
-0.8609340190887451,
-0.3913688063621521,
-0.7161190509796143,
-0.45946750044822693,
-0.11741213500499725,
-1.0179086923599243,
0.3942832350730896,
-0.3231593668460846,
-0.5024809837341309,
0.30250710248947144,
-0.36609721183776855,
-0.6625220775604248,
0.3575718104839325,
0.3535896837711334,
0.5176389813423157,
-0.7877480983734131,
0.893875777721405,
0.9901333451271057,
-0.39684566855430603,
-0.9882540106773376,
-0.2194546014070511,
-0.25092488527297974,
-0.34461668133735657,
0.6106594800949097,
0.4371190369129181,
0.15043854713439941,
0.2027987241744995,
-0.28350138664245605,
-0.8944202065467834,
0.8523655533790588,
0.4650202691555023,
-0.8548312783241272,
-0.15752340853214264,
-0.26263678073883057,
0.4840731918811798,
-0.45911869406700134,
0.38998571038246155,
0.053348109126091,
0.4043032228946686,
-0.17670033872127533,
-1.0455538034439087,
-0.1408882588148117,
-0.40751829743385315,
-0.1421976536512375,
0.37530314922332764,
-0.5636593699455261,
0.944835364818573,
-0.34266558289527893,
-0.2890198826789856,
0.08880646526813507,
1.0448609590530396,
0.2605707049369812,
0.5647239089012146,
0.5736573934555054,
0.8625048398971558,
0.9120070338249207,
0.08007557690143585,
0.830766499042511,
-0.25061720609664917,
0.39701908826828003,
1.5419366359710693,
-0.4861203134059906,
1.0169978141784668,
0.6021557450294495,
-0.3280755579471588,
0.5388889312744141,
0.5852336287498474,
-0.22162877023220062,
0.5036091804504395,
-0.08738579601049423,
-0.36665523052215576,
-0.47488588094711304,
-0.24347488582134247,
-0.3960874676704407,
0.19567283987998962,
0.3018951117992401,
-0.5255839228630066,
-0.24260030686855316,
-0.12506292760372162,
-0.09457102417945862,
0.0007816901197656989,
-0.20378360152244568,
0.9113760590553284,
0.33436280488967896,
-0.4730282425880432,
-0.008095663972198963,
0.10055314004421234,
0.8913547992706299,
-0.08275299519300461,
-0.07846404612064362,
0.041640862822532654,
0.20805723965168,
-0.22912275791168213,
-0.477535605430603,
-0.012297048233449459,
-0.04158051311969757,
-0.5371854901313782,
0.10255783796310425,
0.8724328279495239,
-0.8986338973045349,
-0.7553110718727112,
0.3491220772266388,
0.49621161818504333,
0.4752492904663086,
-0.053722742944955826,
-0.30307868123054504,
-0.7297674417495728,
-0.28466251492500305,
-0.32653626799583435,
0.364149272441864,
0.5517128705978394,
-0.04047853499650955,
0.7027847170829773,
0.513457179069519,
0.20237039029598236,
0.4960446357727051,
-0.04901668801903725,
0.7498587965965271,
-0.4044783413410187,
-0.45143869519233704,
-0.9131209850311279,
0.2861274480819702,
-0.12110922485589981,
-0.341035932302475,
0.736784815788269,
0.547543466091156,
0.9275779128074646,
0.11459846794605255,
0.5634965896606445,
-0.02537207305431366,
0.5910242795944214,
-0.2145240306854248,
0.6536656618118286,
-0.4076257348060608,
0.16803427040576935,
-0.6437594294548035,
-1.1603448390960693,
-0.3401027023792267,
0.5245702266693115,
-0.22491085529327393,
0.1408122330904007,
0.2898324429988861,
0.7961021661758423,
-0.36663052439689636,
-0.039717819541692734,
0.15993067622184753,
0.06480495631694794,
-0.014379756525158882,
0.4750024676322937,
0.7453763484954834,
-0.32965466380119324,
0.35045450925827026,
-0.46170657873153687,
0.22843223810195923,
-0.26344725489616394,
-0.8502717614173889,
-0.9398693442344666,
-0.15580527484416962,
-0.7161383628845215,
-0.04450225830078125,
0.07333774864673615,
1.0982284545898438,
0.7865384221076965,
-1.0314902067184448,
0.2702774107456207,
-0.2887364625930786,
0.0478086844086647,
-0.04423650726675987,
-0.2684628665447235,
0.1962745636701584,
-0.18206581473350525,
-0.8777137398719788,
0.5194973349571228,
0.2494587004184723,
-0.0030322286766022444,
0.2046026736497879,
-0.12693040072917938,
-0.4116349518299103,
-0.15832531452178955,
0.053549740463495255,
0.06475216895341873,
-0.8364636301994324,
0.0624501034617424,
-0.2841080129146576,
-0.3872867822647095,
0.1085522323846817,
0.2148323655128479,
-0.5138724446296692,
0.6318624019622803,
0.3820773959159851,
0.7491265535354614,
0.15575499832630157,
0.12934556603431702,
0.5942648649215698,
-0.6869986653327942,
-0.06729831546545029,
0.15892693400382996,
0.5894631147384644,
0.5151958465576172,
-0.6308974623680115,
0.4498263895511627,
0.15500669181346893,
-0.6418399214744568,
-0.9391192197799683,
-0.30567094683647156,
-1.2187596559524536,
0.07535610347986221,
1.1610080003738403,
-0.31046342849731445,
-0.049761783331632614,
-0.28759461641311646,
-0.023659005761146545,
0.49868419766426086,
-1.0306645631790161,
0.527168869972229,
0.876196026802063,
0.16493040323257446,
-0.3228820264339447,
-0.6339029669761658,
-0.07021975517272949,
0.5521546602249146,
-0.5241560935974121,
-0.4432481527328491,
0.3949509561061859,
0.5350659489631653,
0.16184872388839722,
0.505870521068573,
0.20343443751335144,
-0.05749652907252312,
0.016614099964499474,
0.30796483159065247,
-0.21219472587108612,
-0.4035545289516449,
-0.2260347455739975,
0.19691240787506104,
0.19998742640018463,
-0.05507645010948181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00740v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00740v3
|
Modeling Caption Diversity in Contrastive Vision-Language Pretraining
| 2024-04-30T01:19:18 | 2024-05-14T12:48:45 |
Samuel Lavoie, Polina Kirichenko, Mark Ibrahim, Mahmoud Assran, Andrew Gordon Wilson, Aaron Courville, Nicolas Ballas
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
There are a thousand ways to caption an image. Contrastive Language
Pretraining (CLIP) on the other hand, works by mapping an image and its caption
to a single vector -- limiting how well CLIP-like models can represent the
diverse ways to describe an image. In this work, we introduce Llip, Latent
Language Image Pretraining, which models the diversity of captions that could
match an image. Llip's vision encoder outputs a set of visual features that are
mixed into a final representation by conditioning on information derived from
the text. We show that Llip outperforms non-contextualized baselines like CLIP
and SigLIP on a variety of tasks even with large-scale encoders. Llip improves
zero-shot classification by an average of 2.9% zero-shot classification
benchmarks with a ViT-G/14 encoder. Specifically, Llip attains a zero-shot
top-1 accuracy of 83.5% on ImageNet outperforming a similarly sized CLIP by
1.4%. We also demonstrate improvement on zero-shot retrieval on MS-COCO by
6.0%. We provide a comprehensive analysis of the components introduced by the
method and demonstrate that Llip leads to richer visual representations.
|
[
-0.4289790391921997,
-0.1459578573703766,
0.2452877163887024,
0.29418468475341797,
-0.7247128486633301,
0.4262882471084595,
-0.04118112847208977,
-0.5175769329071045,
0.3931080400943756,
0.506815493106842,
-0.43204912543296814,
-0.5255157351493835,
-0.7586835622787476,
0.2060636430978775,
-0.25599998235702515,
0.7771711349487305,
-0.12071868032217026,
0.40753090381622314,
-0.23463694751262665,
-0.29736328125,
-0.5574325919151306,
-0.49937641620635986,
-0.04425246641039848,
-0.13488541543483734,
0.3390529155731201,
0.6179186105728149,
0.4297555983066559,
0.3938514292240143,
0.7626244425773621,
0.26836907863616943,
-0.017269330099225044,
-0.09171196818351746,
-0.6626224517822266,
-0.09518441557884216,
0.027166280895471573,
-0.854531466960907,
0.005367860198020935,
0.06938739866018295,
0.6523940563201904,
0.6345795392990112,
0.10830522328615189,
-0.268369197845459,
0.0966450646519661,
0.5045163631439209,
-0.7975773811340332,
-0.057490989565849304,
-0.7477095127105713,
0.3888816237449646,
-0.17079931497573853,
-0.311675101518631,
-0.222149059176445,
0.04006977006793022,
0.08218744397163391,
-0.5372074842453003,
0.3188660740852356,
0.08835900574922562,
1.0345624685287476,
0.3338122069835663,
-0.08382586389780045,
0.1651279777288437,
-0.4141712188720703,
1.0431747436523438,
-0.5644286870956421,
0.3333568572998047,
0.11074767261743546,
0.33251115679740906,
0.17375008761882782,
-0.5919072031974792,
-0.5866948962211609,
-0.09079889208078384,
0.09699878841638565,
0.42991992831230164,
0.00372875202447176,
0.09075729548931122,
0.10935530811548233,
0.5439496636390686,
-0.18259017169475555,
0.3693753480911255,
-0.48127397894859314,
-0.1171368956565857,
0.4508027136325836,
0.0801691859960556,
0.42896294593811035,
0.035795971751213074,
-0.5690935254096985,
-0.30489382147789,
-0.8437289595603943,
-0.11755212396383286,
0.22833667695522308,
0.04461592435836792,
-0.4548413157463074,
0.5746341943740845,
-0.11383532732725143,
0.5980246067047119,
0.019212789833545685,
-0.2445206493139267,
0.42261189222335815,
-0.3243483603000641,
-0.16039466857910156,
-0.2842103838920593,
0.7936108708381653,
0.8649906516075134,
0.4441598355770111,
-0.16766057908535004,
-0.12654919922351837,
-0.014974823221564293,
-0.096567302942276,
-0.9138731956481934,
-0.31143850088119507,
-0.06222238764166832,
-0.296744167804718,
-0.3485027551651001,
0.13354401290416718,
-0.8962439894676208,
-0.3420219123363495,
-0.10911622643470764,
0.2623295485973358,
-0.4269847869873047,
0.25423046946525574,
0.017145775258541107,
-0.26456141471862793,
0.630453884601593,
0.5208296179771423,
-0.8584461212158203,
0.4660486876964569,
0.16780123114585876,
1.0189844369888306,
-0.7564619779586792,
-0.4828912913799286,
-0.6580573916435242,
-0.007766269147396088,
-0.2916663587093353,
1.035490870475769,
-0.5915043354034424,
-0.246078759431839,
0.035832248628139496,
-0.14711539447307587,
0.07232827693223953,
-0.7286192178726196,
0.07039231061935425,
-0.48964568972587585,
0.0831470936536789,
-0.2185569703578949,
-0.36851829290390015,
0.034243278205394745,
0.28404220938682556,
-0.7751869559288025,
0.5208749771118164,
0.0660049095749855,
-0.9873427748680115,
0.5556279420852661,
-0.4526107907295227,
-0.33480146527290344,
0.2106138914823532,
-0.6335309147834778,
-0.4660029113292694,
0.11520197242498398,
0.6086385846138,
0.2434057742357254,
-0.06906533241271973,
0.05607001855969429,
-0.32924431562423706,
-0.6169496774673462,
0.289299875497818,
-0.3552689552307129,
0.47404807806015015,
-0.03507978096604347,
-0.08239950984716415,
0.18652428686618805,
-0.32903996109962463,
-0.2737463116645813,
0.20343871414661407,
-0.07794706523418427,
-0.02479797974228859,
-0.1511431336402893,
-0.016626348719000816,
0.021111950278282166,
0.07827144116163254,
-0.623745858669281,
0.13879917562007904,
-0.29107460379600525,
0.42868027091026306,
0.5453262329101562,
0.08146205544471741,
0.4604765772819519,
-0.3308510482311249,
0.7384899258613586,
0.30790480971336365,
0.22476164996623993,
-0.565920889377594,
-0.5081303715705872,
-0.7706633806228638,
-0.3957473933696747,
0.2475687712430954,
0.7523504495620728,
-0.8889373540878296,
0.24383826553821564,
-0.2818106412887573,
-0.14113719761371613,
-0.3783828318119049,
0.18167005479335785,
0.23736591637134552,
0.4086076617240906,
0.39886218309402466,
-0.9236221313476562,
-0.42150986194610596,
-0.9725123047828674,
0.18226544559001923,
0.08060367405414581,
-0.11161667108535767,
0.5339255928993225,
0.5287081003189087,
-0.06190476194024086,
0.8341789841651917,
-0.7089142799377441,
-0.5581383109092712,
-0.5529845952987671,
0.13319990038871765,
0.21151624619960785,
0.4105621874332428,
0.7294374108314514,
-0.8295578360557556,
-0.6208288073539734,
-0.1916743367910385,
-0.556215763092041,
-0.20410190522670746,
-0.19721810519695282,
0.06352321058511734,
-0.20250721275806427,
0.6224395632743835,
-0.1652326136827469,
0.405475914478302,
0.6006125211715698,
0.23771172761917114,
0.6434684991836548,
0.00010634322825353593,
0.20174993574619293,
-0.7622904181480408,
-0.08182106167078018,
-0.2420547604560852,
-0.17553836107254028,
-0.4325897693634033,
0.13439325988292694,
-0.2196098119020462,
-0.3591165244579315,
-0.8474896550178528,
0.22891050577163696,
-0.49685055017471313,
-0.3404185473918915,
-0.27583572268486023,
0.1663396954536438,
0.17969106137752533,
0.523749589920044,
0.4054846465587616,
1.052777647972107,
0.887136697769165,
-0.23693686723709106,
0.26572147011756897,
0.3148764669895172,
-0.4918910264968872,
0.4803048372268677,
-0.8288888335227966,
-0.016387365758419037,
-0.23639999330043793,
0.1885681450366974,
-1.1417269706726074,
-0.3029117286205292,
0.2735244929790497,
-0.28883060812950134,
0.37922438979148865,
-0.2962566018104553,
-0.2915043830871582,
-0.1812330186367035,
-0.5886037945747375,
0.6944930553436279,
0.46424248814582825,
-0.6180905103683472,
0.4095059335231781,
0.1942419856786728,
-0.28212687373161316,
-0.8718461990356445,
-0.8530638217926025,
0.15612457692623138,
-0.053530074656009674,
-0.2057851105928421,
0.7041437029838562,
-0.1775505244731903,
0.17454536259174347,
-0.07786282896995544,
-0.09581907093524933,
-0.4069991707801819,
-0.07773586362600327,
0.25000837445259094,
0.4101981818675995,
-0.08556821942329407,
-0.1022372767329216,
-0.12627153098583221,
0.14087136089801788,
-0.4123978614807129,
0.03417302668094635,
0.6930849552154541,
-0.23459932208061218,
-0.6180270910263062,
-0.3025251626968384,
0.527813732624054,
0.33228349685668945,
-0.3695302903652191,
0.45780235528945923,
0.3761199116706848,
-0.03072592057287693,
-0.0882103219628334,
-0.4967048168182373,
-0.11302819848060608,
-0.4440990090370178,
0.5117329955101013,
-0.28189998865127563,
-1.0327128171920776,
0.654934287071228,
-0.0775972232222557,
-0.0802575871348381,
0.16257525980472565,
0.1581011414527893,
-0.29376959800720215,
0.33301255106925964,
0.9697818160057068,
-0.15132583677768707,
0.9436460733413696,
-0.3946268558502197,
-0.0900280550122261,
-0.8305111527442932,
-0.11008176952600479,
-0.07174038887023926,
-0.3432619869709015,
-0.5259788036346436,
-0.753837525844574,
0.11776281893253326,
0.4230225384235382,
0.07074305415153503,
0.22071772813796997,
-0.3643206059932709,
1.0461745262145996,
0.6246440410614014,
0.24715283513069153,
0.1610761135816574,
0.3545915484428406,
-0.15117137134075165,
-0.508143424987793,
-0.6900826096534729,
-0.2050912082195282,
1.1689172983169556,
0.2871505320072174,
0.9363307952880859,
-0.22623851895332336,
1.0717793703079224,
0.230059415102005,
0.42891037464141846,
-0.7586012482643127,
0.6249352693557739,
-0.6706709861755371,
-0.12220945954322815,
-0.1166277676820755,
-0.19209948182106018,
-0.6619210839271545,
0.34249815344810486,
-0.48363208770751953,
-0.5639306902885437,
0.39527738094329834,
0.2622525990009308,
-0.14767558872699738,
0.33638736605644226,
-0.43001803755760193,
0.8300683498382568,
-0.6796926856040955,
-0.46085938811302185,
0.08019670844078064,
-0.7061325907707214,
0.2984679341316223,
-0.003910437226295471,
-0.10202402621507645,
-0.03728492558002472,
-0.14402563869953156,
0.5987789630889893,
-0.10759051144123077,
1.2087360620498657,
-0.0486326590180397,
0.21836945414543152,
0.3362601101398468,
-0.12349393218755722,
0.05239719897508621,
-0.33295100927352905,
0.3516719937324524,
0.4814673960208893,
-0.27346348762512207,
-0.4147939682006836,
-0.5147884488105774,
0.31476491689682007,
-0.8751693367958069,
-0.5002580881118774,
-0.37459853291511536,
-0.26917916536331177,
0.022073782980442047,
0.2203298658132553,
0.660396158695221,
0.17498882114887238,
-0.23338593542575836,
0.26307541131973267,
0.5130733847618103,
-0.6249629259109497,
0.33882030844688416,
0.29974815249443054,
-0.21743132174015045,
-0.7492586374282837,
0.8220342993736267,
-0.04252792149782181,
0.3638077974319458,
0.6914623379707336,
0.005351766478270292,
-0.17258994281291962,
-0.8635878562927246,
-0.11837857216596603,
0.3430115282535553,
-1.0220117568969727,
-0.29691144824028015,
-0.24394750595092773,
-0.20329420268535614,
-0.24460215866565704,
-0.47940483689308167,
-0.32932528853416443,
-0.2687973082065582,
-0.3700697720050812,
-0.05024028196930885,
-0.10230977833271027,
0.4433973431587219,
-0.04141828045248985,
0.7689154148101807,
-0.5532798171043396,
0.46244746446609497,
0.5150858759880066,
0.5443875193595886,
-0.29523754119873047,
-0.7324325442314148,
0.02215108834207058,
-0.41842329502105713,
-0.4549402892589569,
-1.026955246925354,
0.5805784463882446,
0.5029242634773254,
0.755841851234436,
0.54765385389328,
0.04205814376473427,
0.663334310054779,
-0.6957536935806274,
0.9463266730308533,
0.6823375821113586,
-0.9091236591339111,
0.6649516224861145,
0.07887813448905945,
0.2553659677505493,
0.6654289960861206,
0.38225409388542175,
-0.30816179513931274,
-0.4334893524646759,
-0.30221518874168396,
-1.0419929027557373,
0.39473792910575867,
-0.006731681991368532,
0.2923491597175598,
-0.016925087198615074,
0.134282648563385,
0.14570841193199158,
0.26643815636634827,
-1.2787367105484009,
0.05524493381381035,
-0.6451370120048523,
-0.16163602471351624,
0.030018070712685585,
-0.2723895013332367,
-0.25310102105140686,
-0.08800707757472992,
-0.00218949350528419,
-0.25746089220046997,
0.33484724164009094,
0.2690676748752594,
-0.3949282467365265,
0.15982960164546967,
0.35404694080352783,
0.6413305401802063,
0.4222932755947113,
-0.30786049365997314,
0.252201110124588,
0.23879824578762054,
-0.4849401116371155,
0.030501918867230415,
0.006615739781409502,
-0.29735714197158813,
-0.002232337836176157,
0.8420358896255493,
1.0197821855545044,
0.22427313029766083,
-0.8359730243682861,
0.9897000193595886,
0.13565926253795624,
-0.26193374395370483,
-0.1907724291086197,
0.06622382253408432,
-0.28897783160209656,
0.014601627364754677,
0.273610383272171,
0.044817034155130386,
0.13785088062286377,
-0.40946853160858154,
0.3256360590457916,
0.34406909346580505,
-0.37441185116767883,
-0.2457805871963501,
0.6066886782646179,
0.46676892042160034,
0.09769806265830994,
0.6377449631690979,
0.0048783160746097565,
-0.8535457849502563,
0.635840117931366,
0.6243410110473633,
0.7946913242340088,
0.059737350791692734,
0.15449365973472595,
0.31447041034698486,
0.3077660799026489,
0.08322246372699738,
0.2163543850183487,
-0.24963536858558655,
-1.024415373802185,
-0.5572499632835388,
-0.5195791721343994,
-0.8197854161262512,
0.10596760362386703,
-0.5559858679771423,
0.13155217468738556,
-0.5369916558265686,
0.024150630459189415,
-0.1933528035879135,
-0.30744463205337524,
-0.8102115392684937,
0.15186819434165955,
0.4063422679901123,
0.7142069935798645,
-1.2789019346237183,
0.6415302157402039,
0.7425388097763062,
-0.7095299959182739,
-0.3201257884502411,
0.14992652833461761,
-0.46206945180892944,
-1.0027674436569214,
1.0706251859664917,
0.5777385830879211,
-0.18451550602912903,
-0.3105016350746155,
-1.0627813339233398,
-0.6517705321311951,
0.9383533000946045,
0.4910268485546112,
-0.8372889161109924,
0.3654724955558777,
0.3484383523464203,
0.44053179025650024,
-0.8065616488456726,
0.15447664260864258,
0.11711731553077698,
0.005509435199201107,
0.4275570511817932,
-0.637973427772522,
-0.26064062118530273,
-0.15390875935554504,
0.07859349250793457,
-0.3943122327327728,
-0.5218686461448669,
0.8401582837104797,
-0.5798210501670837,
-0.33968988060951233,
-0.0607338584959507,
0.6568580269813538,
0.3335034251213074,
0.13786770403385162,
0.49435511231422424,
0.41469311714172363,
0.35188260674476624,
-0.004329288378357887,
0.9606441259384155,
-0.21667878329753876,
0.02407890371978283,
1.4100289344787598,
-0.36456233263015747,
1.1301711797714233,
0.7497584819793701,
-0.17869433760643005,
0.5435093641281128,
0.5664660930633545,
-0.5084248185157776,
0.8217942118644714,
0.22791408002376556,
-0.13663935661315918,
-0.4082723557949066,
-0.275635302066803,
-0.08264346420764923,
0.4176492691040039,
0.08734103292226791,
-0.39926087856292725,
-0.03399575874209404,
0.06428132951259613,
-0.4350697100162506,
0.09798633307218552,
-0.2737240195274353,
0.6997203826904297,
0.10946034640073776,
-0.4475603401660919,
0.517371416091919,
-0.2846622169017792,
0.9763290882110596,
-0.44131579995155334,
-0.25936365127563477,
-0.5005126595497131,
-0.04691189154982567,
-0.17183664441108704,
-1.164315938949585,
0.11388227343559265,
0.032466623932123184,
-0.07479826360940933,
-0.005461984314024448,
0.6117475032806396,
-0.5240870714187622,
-0.2902393639087677,
0.3068392276763916,
0.2421223670244217,
0.36369550228118896,
0.03506285697221756,
-0.5761628150939941,
0.2921178340911865,
0.11267867684364319,
0.30382609367370605,
0.20994329452514648,
0.14400342106819153,
-0.03367461636662483,
0.6219393014907837,
0.39728960394859314,
0.28694671392440796,
0.09075582772493362,
0.44111350178718567,
1.0660977363586426,
-0.5965697765350342,
-0.478509783744812,
-0.69319087266922,
0.4500148594379425,
-0.27736157178878784,
-0.16180329024791718,
0.24131397902965546,
0.47458115220069885,
0.8801766037940979,
-0.47971996665000916,
0.6825578808784485,
0.23180605471134186,
-0.014340036548674107,
-0.5475447177886963,
0.32066428661346436,
-0.4871279299259186,
0.3390349745750427,
-0.22446560859680176,
-0.9535368084907532,
-0.7679405808448792,
0.6880304217338562,
-0.3285347521305084,
-0.16856642067432404,
0.5464931130409241,
0.5534192323684692,
-0.19415058195590973,
-0.5818029642105103,
0.4417654573917389,
-0.17111364006996155,
0.20425817370414734,
0.6110731363296509,
0.9373258352279663,
-0.3428555428981781,
0.8820895552635193,
-0.22252066433429718,
-0.33022889494895935,
-0.25871172547340393,
-1.0847913026809692,
-1.0133545398712158,
-0.09536942839622498,
-0.4197487533092499,
0.33759254217147827,
-0.03386041522026062,
0.49512922763824463,
0.8637667894363403,
-0.9435442090034485,
-0.2599814236164093,
-0.04556272551417351,
-0.05393227934837341,
0.017334314063191414,
-0.14187011122703552,
0.2284875363111496,
-0.2754315435886383,
-0.5158057808876038,
0.2102627009153366,
0.5362499356269836,
0.5293775796890259,
-0.06832896918058395,
-0.1275453418493271,
0.1756037026643753,
-0.09503518044948578,
0.5682079792022705,
0.4062293469905853,
-0.7552229762077332,
-0.23706024885177612,
0.055904585868120193,
0.1266973912715912,
0.5765414834022522,
0.6225886940956116,
-0.6212822794914246,
0.5279994606971741,
0.4331817924976349,
0.5546626448631287,
0.7112752795219421,
0.16076155006885529,
0.521124541759491,
-0.9993820786476135,
0.4238613247871399,
0.1773102730512619,
0.5319293141365051,
0.6805959939956665,
0.1267942488193512,
0.4033943712711334,
0.49281826615333557,
-0.14464953541755676,
-0.5696401000022888,
0.5469101667404175,
-1.273321270942688,
-0.18768630921840668,
0.8020161986351013,
-0.4623269736766815,
-0.07634541392326355,
0.20009294152259827,
-0.3016730546951294,
-0.06832193583250046,
-0.27194321155548096,
0.566413938999176,
0.4338698089122772,
-0.1469658464193344,
-0.8706594109535217,
-0.14016418159008026,
0.18356972932815552,
0.39600345492362976,
-0.8297147154808044,
-0.16625604033470154,
0.5154146552085876,
0.4434765577316284,
0.24494017660617828,
0.7370024919509888,
-0.24277551472187042,
0.20759642124176025,
0.18462952971458435,
0.2481231987476349,
-0.05506395176053047,
-0.40313389897346497,
-0.2522863447666168,
0.15848839282989502,
0.2798020839691162,
-0.6007547974586487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19178v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19178v1
|
Revenge of the Fallen? Recurrent Models Match Transformers at Predicting Human Language Comprehension Metrics
| 2024-04-30T01:02:15 | 2024-04-30T01:02:15 |
James A. Michaelov, Catherine Arnett, Benjamin K. Bergen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Transformers have supplanted Recurrent Neural Networks as the dominant
architecture for both natural language processing tasks and, despite criticisms
of cognitive implausibility, for modelling the effect of predictability on
online human language comprehension. However, two recently developed recurrent
neural network architectures, RWKV and Mamba, appear to perform natural
language tasks comparably to or better than transformers of equivalent scale.
In this paper, we show that contemporary recurrent models are now also able to
match - and in some cases, exceed - performance of comparably sized
transformers at modeling online human language comprehension. This suggests
that transformer language models are not uniquely suited to this task, and
opens up new directions for debates about the extent to which architectural
features of language models make them better or worse models of human language
comprehension.
|
[
-0.6300967335700989,
-0.6467108130455017,
0.5255522727966309,
0.10236471146345139,
-0.023962734267115593,
0.5233261585235596,
0.2533571422100067,
-0.3834865689277649,
0.08707758784294128,
0.769428014755249,
-0.8393977880477905,
0.09817617386579514,
-0.471314400434494,
0.27090200781822205,
-0.8317646980285645,
0.8377186059951782,
0.1522667557001114,
-0.10756943374872208,
-0.40648412704467773,
-0.16008760035037994,
-0.35656261444091797,
-0.7190452218055725,
-0.7001822590827942,
-0.979489266872406,
0.7159850001335144,
-0.16950036585330963,
0.8777636289596558,
0.7337676882743835,
0.5616486072540283,
0.3497142195701599,
-0.06519193947315216,
-0.29122787714004517,
-0.610751748085022,
0.315456360578537,
-0.011525316163897514,
-0.5095270872116089,
0.016991281881928444,
-0.03860017657279968,
0.49797719717025757,
0.6727124452590942,
-0.5628565549850464,
-0.05129082128405571,
-0.2129664421081543,
0.8454917669296265,
-0.31079545617103577,
-0.21084874868392944,
-0.6173937320709229,
0.26798689365386963,
0.1162981390953064,
-0.27889183163642883,
-0.806501030921936,
-0.3316149115562439,
0.3192426562309265,
-0.5538166165351868,
0.42723414301872253,
0.025416014716029167,
0.7948768734931946,
0.6555045247077942,
-0.21137066185474396,
-0.009611343964934349,
-0.9681681394577026,
1.0719716548919678,
-0.7347220182418823,
0.18525616824626923,
0.1380273550748825,
0.49695947766304016,
-0.16547396779060364,
-1.091756820678711,
-0.58323073387146,
-0.28451019525527954,
-0.2700532078742981,
0.3277115225791931,
-0.7288939356803894,
-0.08654904365539551,
0.2766507565975189,
0.4587813913822174,
-0.43992358446121216,
0.11596573144197464,
-0.31123441457748413,
-0.08111973106861115,
0.16759087145328522,
0.646152913570404,
0.38435402512550354,
-0.4617675840854645,
-0.5740360021591187,
-0.19648246467113495,
-0.488770067691803,
0.17729692161083221,
0.4404001235961914,
0.1966705471277237,
0.08136424422264099,
0.2583751678466797,
-0.0897132009267807,
0.8224417567253113,
0.12681542336940765,
-0.22983556985855103,
-0.14447149634361267,
0.0021045247558504343,
-0.33819708228111267,
0.10946860909461975,
0.6654736995697021,
0.33522701263427734,
0.39664149284362793,
-0.39426741003990173,
0.10396643728017807,
0.2788415849208832,
1.0801455974578857,
-0.5051748156547546,
-0.15270249545574188,
-0.0063363341614604,
-0.5685907006263733,
-0.6954363584518433,
-0.021324124187231064,
-0.7472564578056335,
-0.4188249111175537,
-0.3631461560726166,
0.3432838022708893,
-0.47283056378364563,
-0.4235207140445709,
0.1942664086818695,
-0.3823219835758209,
0.3472582697868347,
0.16330161690711975,
-0.7654376029968262,
0.35931625962257385,
0.9535231590270996,
0.8904827237129211,
-0.29586082696914673,
-0.4317682385444641,
-0.15883080661296844,
-0.1961286962032318,
-0.18814262747764587,
0.6333873867988586,
-0.5640323162078857,
-0.30007368326187134,
0.11127796769142151,
-0.06683769077062607,
-0.07375575602054596,
-0.37395745515823364,
0.5484194755554199,
-0.7652486562728882,
0.2841722369194031,
0.07711891084909439,
-0.35414689779281616,
-0.5567574501037598,
0.3090873658657074,
-0.8525589108467102,
0.6875605583190918,
0.30544084310531616,
-0.9921318888664246,
0.050805091857910156,
-0.28050220012664795,
-0.6645939350128174,
-0.17335516214370728,
-0.08089128136634827,
-0.5222630500793457,
0.00848403014242649,
0.12093767523765564,
0.3545001149177551,
-0.3305767774581909,
0.0223909392952919,
-0.15946252644062042,
-0.6458541750907898,
0.2858026325702667,
-0.604353666305542,
0.8154958486557007,
0.22473783791065216,
-0.35895299911499023,
-0.23180481791496277,
-0.614790678024292,
-0.14117461442947388,
0.4077877402305603,
-0.45692941546440125,
-0.2781333029270172,
0.4390759766101837,
-0.2110566347837448,
0.02542070299386978,
-0.10916083306074142,
-0.4297901690006256,
0.0240339245647192,
-0.8533556461334229,
0.7627533078193665,
0.7145307660102844,
0.00941887404769659,
0.6348106861114502,
-0.5326705574989319,
0.9240128993988037,
-0.07634863257408142,
0.2741032838821411,
-0.33877015113830566,
-0.40130534768104553,
-0.7541950941085815,
0.000144466946949251,
-0.046548157930374146,
0.384600430727005,
-0.6644167900085449,
0.046418771147727966,
-0.4368419051170349,
-0.9186339378356934,
-0.5710053443908691,
-0.6655877232551575,
0.4041261076927185,
0.6361340880393982,
0.4704742729663849,
-0.28064581751823425,
-0.8195042610168457,
-1.056007981300354,
-0.4157748520374298,
-0.36693909764289856,
-0.018244948238134384,
0.23463594913482666,
0.13243474066257477,
-0.13545101881027222,
1.1365376710891724,
-0.22380252182483673,
-0.2011684626340866,
-0.438193678855896,
0.1694713979959488,
0.38974443078041077,
0.15101505815982819,
0.6293635368347168,
-0.8369559049606323,
-0.15827591717243195,
0.17188094556331635,
-0.5320031046867371,
0.22649972140789032,
-0.22560814023017883,
0.41647204756736755,
0.20118851959705353,
0.3620072603225708,
-0.5296235680580139,
0.2192339450120926,
0.6308392286300659,
0.0005502438871189952,
0.5715032815933228,
0.16991540789604187,
0.3181527554988861,
-1.2447810173034668,
0.11004200577735901,
-0.4418879449367523,
-0.3688478469848633,
-0.8156079053878784,
0.20922598242759705,
-0.17915436625480652,
-0.008983759209513664,
-0.6768035888671875,
0.2769339680671692,
-0.10658109188079834,
-0.21312467753887177,
-0.23810143768787384,
0.1865503489971161,
0.10916511714458466,
0.3925069570541382,
-0.1561027616262436,
0.5147222876548767,
0.5312109589576721,
-0.7418687343597412,
0.6851041913032532,
0.3434777557849884,
-0.4294600486755371,
0.2513728141784668,
-0.7613265514373779,
0.13753622770309448,
-0.20588141679763794,
0.40998023748397827,
-1.0180201530456543,
-0.1106429249048233,
0.0918734222650528,
-1.065391182899475,
0.06415191292762756,
-0.28400203585624695,
-0.10444512218236923,
-0.5242088437080383,
-0.1922350525856018,
0.4018343687057495,
0.736068069934845,
-0.49410301446914673,
1.1302977800369263,
0.09571423381567001,
0.10193976759910583,
-1.064202070236206,
-1.0187727212905884,
0.058862749487161636,
-0.31136584281921387,
-0.4505661725997925,
0.471097469329834,
0.2858451306819916,
-0.4098495543003082,
-0.19937510788440704,
0.1082737147808075,
0.05389980599284172,
0.19945813715457916,
0.4808080494403839,
0.09063684940338135,
-0.5901675224304199,
-0.10359089076519012,
-0.24731923639774323,
-0.39066818356513977,
0.15274864435195923,
0.08898662775754929,
0.7714558839797974,
0.13827352225780487,
-0.4165745973587036,
-0.37005576491355896,
0.18320490419864655,
1.078325867652893,
-0.13520479202270508,
0.7494308352470398,
0.21911898255348206,
-0.17175118625164032,
-0.11375314742326736,
-0.6752950549125671,
-0.254958838224411,
-0.4981290400028229,
0.4106166660785675,
-0.2662307322025299,
-0.7112475633621216,
0.6226806640625,
0.22321225702762604,
0.35581257939338684,
0.4494991600513458,
0.4652659595012665,
-0.009928528219461441,
1.1607345342636108,
0.5367414355278015,
-0.48759570717811584,
0.4784800708293915,
-0.033069729804992676,
0.2270292490720749,
-0.5647116303443909,
-0.016836442053318024,
-0.6723020076751709,
-0.42049750685691833,
-0.476482629776001,
0.1796795278787613,
-0.056268926709890366,
-0.30019471049308777,
-0.19896459579467773,
0.5638445615768433,
-0.5624083280563354,
0.33861902356147766,
0.5230839848518372,
-0.1888531893491745,
0.36775287985801697,
0.2983132600784302,
-0.005154774524271488,
-0.17697323858737946,
-0.58924400806427,
-0.5573322772979736,
0.6350622773170471,
0.398640900850296,
0.6802666187286377,
0.041023366153240204,
0.2928001582622528,
0.4466540217399597,
0.2176058143377304,
-0.6813088655471802,
0.3991450071334839,
-0.1953689008951187,
-0.5834402441978455,
-0.07324770092964172,
-0.514534056186676,
-1.2720575332641602,
0.1884116232395172,
0.20452497899532318,
-0.37775886058807373,
-0.08709203451871872,
-0.04582899808883667,
-0.6003381609916687,
0.5572155714035034,
-0.45253682136535645,
0.7743499279022217,
0.18737520277500153,
0.33455392718315125,
-0.4541809856891632,
-0.6568880081176758,
0.329932302236557,
0.07895471900701523,
0.08063666522502899,
0.1364487111568451,
-0.00450565991923213,
0.6595388054847717,
-0.13842619955539703,
0.6937142014503479,
0.07355529814958572,
0.16789154708385468,
0.25324973464012146,
0.4447868764400482,
0.44132378697395325,
-0.20087210834026337,
-0.2951945662498474,
0.024899916723370552,
0.08177876472473145,
-0.44638165831565857,
-0.7001705765724182,
0.694922685623169,
-0.7539629340171814,
-0.5425331592559814,
-0.5762006044387817,
-0.1637275367975235,
-0.03216294199228287,
-0.01598896086215973,
0.49980226159095764,
0.5378686785697937,
-0.39281290769577026,
0.32394447922706604,
0.4424007833003998,
-0.2515563666820526,
0.7379485964775085,
0.7528401613235474,
-0.3067406117916107,
-0.5774998664855957,
0.5416150689125061,
-0.25800400972366333,
0.5422730445861816,
0.44391539692878723,
0.012074656784534454,
-0.37665867805480957,
-0.39913785457611084,
-0.4811936616897583,
0.13062253594398499,
-0.8164454698562622,
-0.2502238154411316,
-0.7430186867713928,
-0.4678185284137726,
-0.2088003307580948,
-0.2505855858325958,
-0.38429713249206543,
-0.12277334928512573,
-0.3116108477115631,
-0.32376089692115784,
0.510073721408844,
1.1579633951187134,
0.23094038665294647,
0.34246349334716797,
-0.8030682802200317,
0.23747073113918304,
0.2171526700258255,
0.2530874013900757,
0.45263436436653137,
-1.1187735795974731,
-0.09778560698032379,
0.06826663017272949,
-0.34576913714408875,
-0.7834606766700745,
0.31842952966690063,
-0.22516997158527374,
0.4323213994503021,
0.32184940576553345,
0.13515104353427887,
0.5997191071510315,
-0.7131425738334656,
0.7949362397193909,
0.3534700870513916,
-0.5281586647033691,
0.17952242493629456,
-0.3106423616409302,
0.15346363186836243,
0.32477813959121704,
0.2665539085865021,
-0.833384096622467,
-0.5699576735496521,
-0.7411125302314758,
-0.6363965272903442,
1.045164704322815,
0.21543388068675995,
0.5789682865142822,
-0.021096762269735336,
0.41883036494255066,
0.24926705658435822,
-0.109102763235569,
-0.9207602739334106,
-0.5431613326072693,
-0.31865599751472473,
-0.021156203001737595,
-0.09809989482164383,
-0.084210105240345,
0.43960684537887573,
-0.09679874032735825,
0.49450424313545227,
0.2502930462360382,
0.3230492174625397,
0.24047723412513733,
0.12915775179862976,
-0.3807617127895355,
-0.049293141812086105,
0.6815941333770752,
0.5898507833480835,
0.024388480931520462,
0.1413254290819168,
0.24852953851222992,
-0.49744912981987,
0.37766340374946594,
-0.14720995724201202,
-0.3120788633823395,
0.13402444124221802,
0.5837592482566833,
0.9153998494148254,
0.46549758315086365,
-0.5846551656723022,
0.2812546193599701,
-0.23971788585186005,
-0.15577495098114014,
-0.6702538132667542,
0.1105053573846817,
0.20286022126674652,
0.20664602518081665,
0.6442167162895203,
0.4608100354671478,
-0.13778607547283173,
-0.4807538092136383,
0.43956732749938965,
0.17906241118907928,
-0.5241859555244446,
-0.15993352234363556,
0.4441893994808197,
0.013063404709100723,
-0.9006170630455017,
0.7480010390281677,
0.386654794216156,
-0.7114369869232178,
0.7136934995651245,
0.5779635310173035,
0.6967536807060242,
-0.49004918336868286,
0.2815913259983063,
0.5013918876647949,
0.3659316599369049,
-0.14221248030662537,
-0.4173634648323059,
0.24475905299186707,
-0.6783422827720642,
-0.6076446175575256,
-0.773810088634491,
-0.3821828365325928,
0.1906854212284088,
-0.8841685056686401,
0.0926264226436615,
-0.45912012457847595,
-0.10997947305440903,
0.041743822395801544,
-0.3908814787864685,
-0.21301943063735962,
0.22975005209445953,
-0.08761214464902878,
0.755429208278656,
-0.3892497420310974,
0.654134213924408,
0.4104256331920624,
-0.6153977513313293,
-0.624998152256012,
0.09596000611782074,
-0.45843133330345154,
-0.6307039260864258,
0.3217408359050751,
0.2489193230867386,
-0.2486436516046524,
0.44289740920066833,
0.04849795624613762,
-0.8937587738037109,
0.8330295085906982,
0.4355911314487457,
-0.4596054255962372,
-0.2759767770767212,
0.30644363164901733,
0.747951865196228,
-0.011784096248447895,
0.2625979483127594,
0.7288047075271606,
0.46490293741226196,
-0.2650599777698517,
-0.7627410888671875,
-0.15109562873840332,
0.2744186818599701,
-0.3191964030265808,
0.4891730844974518,
-0.40554389357566833,
0.6568951606750488,
-0.09715495258569717,
-0.4929320812225342,
0.33181628584861755,
0.5587999224662781,
-0.13901245594024658,
0.1704443097114563,
0.5518821477890015,
0.7372380495071411,
0.09844879806041718,
-0.2812980115413666,
1.5884109735488892,
0.16783855855464935,
0.37945958971977234,
0.8016770482063293,
-0.03515087440609932,
1.0927929878234863,
0.3546857237815857,
-0.7196418046951294,
0.7498577833175659,
0.6168281435966492,
-0.03303312882781029,
0.4470748007297516,
0.08932319283485413,
-0.10577196627855301,
-0.41901564598083496,
0.17401045560836792,
-0.2882976531982422,
0.39911216497421265,
-0.07115346938371658,
-0.3863978087902069,
-0.2096918374300003,
0.09659704566001892,
-0.24514204263687134,
0.5269669890403748,
-0.21947024762630463,
0.9988585114479065,
0.155034601688385,
-0.9345849752426147,
0.715063214302063,
0.0065551381558179855,
0.5920190811157227,
-0.501462459564209,
0.20051410794258118,
-0.42363086342811584,
0.4411579966545105,
-0.02394837886095047,
-0.7521082162857056,
0.6443532705307007,
-0.19331756234169006,
-0.4181135892868042,
-0.13250496983528137,
0.49573084712028503,
0.0696663185954094,
-0.4009110629558563,
0.7891361713409424,
0.18925593793392181,
-0.060634441673755646,
-0.25594183802604675,
-0.7798039317131042,
-0.11544431746006012,
0.1295434683561325,
-0.292268842458725,
0.23476959764957428,
-0.03017577715218067,
0.4630800187587738,
1.0624173879623413,
0.5379658937454224,
-0.3499005436897278,
0.3676108419895172,
0.2564657926559448,
0.6615670323371887,
-0.8059381246566772,
-0.30463624000549316,
-1.2395554780960083,
0.39989107847213745,
0.09700284898281097,
-0.13106898963451385,
0.5056508779525757,
0.39408254623413086,
0.5875570774078369,
-0.3305181860923767,
0.644982635974884,
0.08017468452453613,
0.9955763220787048,
-0.18454958498477936,
0.9961586594581604,
-0.7486506700515747,
-0.2145034819841385,
-0.23766465485095978,
-0.9199516177177429,
-0.21246764063835144,
0.48569780588150024,
0.006469545885920525,
0.06033451482653618,
0.598350465297699,
0.6060181260108948,
-0.0901447981595993,
0.05271798372268677,
0.5356694459915161,
0.32026728987693787,
0.28065168857574463,
0.5434005856513977,
1.2755669355392456,
-0.6012119054794312,
0.9909989237785339,
-0.0841325893998146,
0.30611714720726013,
-0.29062017798423767,
-0.6595638990402222,
-0.864249587059021,
-0.6459848880767822,
0.09320253133773804,
-0.23571541905403137,
-0.12009845674037933,
0.38054680824279785,
0.406729519367218,
-0.80838543176651,
0.09480641037225723,
-0.4508543014526367,
0.20681895315647125,
-0.3485570549964905,
-0.2905169129371643,
-0.028666088357567787,
-0.19486214220523834,
-0.6452329158782959,
0.620079755783081,
0.24371573328971863,
-0.010938714258372784,
-0.6099705696105957,
-0.26279568672180176,
-0.10118575394153595,
0.2998170554637909,
0.4913800060749054,
0.23373650014400482,
-1.380162000656128,
-0.2517116367816925,
0.16221903264522552,
-0.2826949656009674,
0.19373849034309387,
0.9500638246536255,
-1.1808503866195679,
0.2224959433078766,
0.6501826643943787,
0.8973674774169922,
0.1589687317609787,
0.17236079275608063,
0.8458268642425537,
-0.7718510627746582,
0.028760189190506935,
0.44894102215766907,
0.36804744601249695,
0.44488856196403503,
-0.10435622185468674,
0.42605680227279663,
0.08960457891225815,
-0.5838595032691956,
-1.039933204650879,
0.33031678199768066,
-0.7821058630943298,
-0.348956823348999,
0.7130599021911621,
-0.08052030950784683,
-0.05588727444410324,
-0.4245578646659851,
-0.33822935819625854,
0.38391679525375366,
-0.12204758077859879,
0.9268146753311157,
0.8179222941398621,
0.23155885934829712,
-0.327071875333786,
-0.4007018506526947,
0.4358048439025879,
0.695691704750061,
-0.34369704127311707,
0.34104233980178833,
0.21097563207149506,
0.1518813520669937,
0.5723353028297424,
0.15221908688545227,
0.00368617195636034,
0.5389906167984009,
-0.048908017575740814,
-0.06776024401187897,
-0.061430711299180984,
-0.087671659886837,
-0.3315723240375519,
0.2830410301685333,
0.06711407005786896,
0.02429843507707119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19175v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19175v1
|
Game-MUG: Multimodal Oriented Game Situation Understanding and Commentary Generation Dataset
| 2024-04-30T00:39:26 | 2024-04-30T00:39:26 |
Zhihao Zhang, Feiqi Cao, Yingbin Mo, Yiran Zhang, Josiah Poon, Caren Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The dynamic nature of esports makes the situation relatively complicated for
average viewers. Esports broadcasting involves game expert casters, but the
caster-dependent game commentary is not enough to fully understand the game
situation. It will be richer by including diverse multimodal esports
information, including audiences' talks/emotions, game audio, and game match
event information. This paper introduces GAME-MUG, a new multimodal game
situation understanding and audience-engaged commentary generation dataset and
its strong baseline. Our dataset is collected from 2020-2022 LOL game live
streams from YouTube and Twitch, and includes multimodal esports game
information, including text, audio, and time-series event logs, for detecting
the game situation. In addition, we also propose a new audience conversation
augmented commentary dataset by covering the game situation and audience
conversation understanding, and introducing a robust joint multimodal dual
learning model as a baseline. We examine the model's game situation/event
understanding ability and commentary generation capability to show the
effectiveness of the multimodal aspects coverage and the joint integration
learning approach.
|
[
-0.6744558811187744,
-0.7863191962242126,
0.015532787889242172,
0.4418332874774933,
-0.28538641333580017,
0.26768776774406433,
0.02971540577709675,
-0.28737539052963257,
0.3536762595176697,
0.34692245721817017,
-0.9034159183502197,
-0.2959423363208771,
-0.45974841713905334,
-0.12621374428272247,
0.3216995298862457,
1.2963178157806396,
0.184403195977211,
0.07455652207136154,
-0.2067585438489914,
-0.3107760548591614,
-0.6229149103164673,
-0.4823840260505676,
-0.5958864688873291,
-0.04849444702267647,
0.13653399050235748,
0.4225134551525116,
0.29842716455459595,
0.054782334715127945,
0.49499329924583435,
0.42364561557769775,
0.07743370532989502,
0.634134829044342,
-0.8024827837944031,
0.44727855920791626,
-0.11387374997138977,
-0.16997137665748596,
-0.6666213870048523,
-0.0926423892378807,
0.4187402129173279,
0.2937716245651245,
-0.07483930885791779,
0.28631317615509033,
0.16204498708248138,
0.0774562805891037,
-0.6216604113578796,
0.48501256108283997,
-0.4401244521141052,
0.4892991781234741,
0.03696692734956741,
-0.5193267464637756,
-0.5999472737312317,
0.5670080184936523,
-0.32587793469429016,
-0.945881724357605,
0.4390612542629242,
0.04645635932683945,
0.645846962928772,
0.2345544546842575,
-0.6905616521835327,
-0.15742012858390808,
-1.0142600536346436,
0.8024304509162903,
-0.27542370557785034,
0.22322843968868256,
0.10172034800052643,
0.46463674306869507,
-0.29891952872276306,
-0.29187509417533875,
-0.4912210702896118,
0.4196361303329468,
0.20084291696548462,
0.5708162784576416,
0.04644738510251045,
0.062185611575841904,
0.21940235793590546,
-0.1405523419380188,
-0.12242391705513,
-0.24541276693344116,
-0.35637038946151733,
-0.004445389844477177,
0.9114726781845093,
0.42855775356292725,
0.5644426941871643,
-0.061788447201251984,
-0.6924041509628296,
0.21469077467918396,
-0.40661507844924927,
0.13913066685199738,
0.4241207540035248,
0.12962402403354645,
-0.31588658690452576,
0.35290029644966125,
-0.15153178572654724,
0.40877342224121094,
0.1472170650959015,
-0.5794549584388733,
0.38055992126464844,
-0.5885149240493774,
0.041440077126026154,
0.1312435269355774,
0.4521629214286804,
0.9202415943145752,
-0.1292789876461029,
-0.10643491894006729,
0.1157112643122673,
-0.010085076093673706,
0.084821917116642,
-0.8803209066390991,
-0.2699480652809143,
0.6273660659790039,
-0.34043440222740173,
-0.3942316174507141,
0.19409582018852234,
-1.0993775129318237,
-0.7043541073799133,
-0.22716495394706726,
0.0668775737285614,
-0.028310338035225868,
-0.6359528303146362,
-0.08320007473230362,
-0.4857127070426941,
0.3796645402908325,
0.6772024035453796,
-0.6432982087135315,
-0.11304688453674316,
0.5914081931114197,
0.5895092487335205,
-0.1279904991388321,
-0.18062642216682434,
-0.8674721121788025,
0.5637876391410828,
-0.06186673417687416,
0.9420760273933411,
-0.34415072202682495,
-0.3730999529361725,
0.12005674839019775,
-0.0527779646217823,
0.23010793328285217,
-0.06022457405924797,
0.23416009545326233,
-0.3368140161037445,
0.009134582243859768,
-0.20118561387062073,
-0.43648260831832886,
0.03891090676188469,
0.5181851983070374,
-0.7749680280685425,
0.5778079628944397,
-0.41910505294799805,
-0.8983621001243591,
0.7560759782791138,
-0.6680943965911865,
-0.3458264172077179,
0.38965684175491333,
-0.1834614872932434,
-0.43420565128326416,
-0.06000463292002678,
0.43533679842948914,
0.34019002318382263,
0.1706707775592804,
0.31125766038894653,
-0.8044623136520386,
-0.19476136565208435,
0.21315762400627136,
-0.5780476927757263,
0.6591036915779114,
0.17596003413200378,
-0.04180100932717323,
-0.10655007511377335,
-0.6014809012413025,
-0.1437046378850937,
-0.08197423815727234,
-0.2403857260942459,
-0.010005504824221134,
0.5608519911766052,
-0.11329399794340134,
0.4043782949447632,
0.007636630907654762,
-0.7274345755577087,
0.028363073244690895,
0.2074185162782669,
0.34876346588134766,
0.3998146951198578,
0.3758978843688965,
0.3858242332935333,
0.059934429824352264,
0.4009661376476288,
0.21572332084178925,
0.4470932185649872,
-0.40031102299690247,
-0.46911782026290894,
-0.19659897685050964,
-0.34231534600257874,
-0.011746547184884548,
0.564744234085083,
-1.1857020854949951,
-0.07340195775032043,
-0.23465797305107117,
-0.15906597673892975,
-0.31592482328414917,
0.1652229130268097,
0.3239853084087372,
0.3334733843803406,
0.032602857798337936,
0.03194680064916611,
-0.7075501680374146,
-0.3543045222759247,
-0.013459448702633381,
-0.2626868784427643,
0.35775381326675415,
0.4089111387729645,
0.30183330178260803,
0.1880061775445938,
0.8057622313499451,
-0.4646700322628021,
-0.45949506759643555,
-0.7469445466995239,
0.38831332325935364,
-0.25921308994293213,
0.23395226895809174,
0.7017726898193359,
-1.2057337760925293,
-0.5643792748451233,
-0.22055703401565552,
-0.9982327222824097,
-0.10525789111852646,
-0.042770978063344955,
0.041194457560777664,
-0.06711850315332413,
0.7428379058837891,
-0.232353076338768,
0.5257236957550049,
0.6355764865875244,
-0.8258215188980103,
0.40131205320358276,
-0.10118560492992401,
0.5831143856048584,
-0.946264922618866,
-0.2681483328342438,
-0.060724012553691864,
-0.3430154621601105,
-0.8798069357872009,
0.0523490309715271,
-0.3808879852294922,
-0.34543880820274353,
-0.7731075882911682,
0.634125292301178,
-0.6270500421524048,
0.10097653418779373,
-0.46047714352607727,
0.4147810637950897,
0.4495986998081207,
0.5651484131813049,
0.3430875241756439,
0.6783316135406494,
0.2141343504190445,
-0.46370506286621094,
0.6880932450294495,
0.452107310295105,
-0.539196789264679,
0.7867720127105713,
-0.21653808653354645,
-0.11363574117422104,
-0.2600056827068329,
0.4362983703613281,
-1.1429836750030518,
-0.21697428822517395,
0.24783608317375183,
-0.5781423449516296,
0.18782012164592743,
-0.3484993875026703,
-0.12517741322517395,
-0.29923155903816223,
-0.3492611348628998,
0.52112877368927,
-0.06289682537317276,
-0.3416430354118347,
0.7183254361152649,
1.0167741775512695,
-0.22558140754699707,
-0.758195161819458,
-0.5339735746383667,
0.03636487200856209,
-0.31669461727142334,
-0.6433733701705933,
0.16678398847579956,
-0.17190763354301453,
-0.26956164836883545,
-0.08544657379388809,
0.052297625690698624,
-0.35698455572128296,
-0.13940854370594025,
0.18545950949192047,
0.19486068189144135,
-0.34468159079551697,
0.1650315821170807,
-0.15507374703884125,
0.0350271612405777,
-0.07838961482048035,
0.561600387096405,
0.20914985239505768,
0.05247671529650688,
-0.25597143173217773,
-0.2830164134502411,
0.7313188910484314,
0.11393977701663971,
-0.11552845686674118,
0.6954513192176819,
0.8449526429176331,
-0.049527209252119064,
-0.14395220577716827,
-0.44009336829185486,
-0.08238634467124939,
-0.4222319424152374,
0.750338613986969,
-0.5007957816123962,
-0.43124207854270935,
0.6072468161582947,
-0.007773824036121368,
0.24181248247623444,
0.12614181637763977,
0.4956103265285492,
-0.411719411611557,
1.5534080266952515,
0.12082554399967194,
0.17959977686405182,
0.427475243806839,
0.01664949767291546,
0.09016832709312439,
-0.7444425821304321,
-0.42726022005081177,
-0.18625500798225403,
-0.4960242211818695,
-0.1552066206932068,
-0.37497955560684204,
0.22418038547039032,
0.005925752688199282,
-0.23146645724773407,
-0.0275952760130167,
0.09897001087665558,
0.7571808695793152,
0.0178353413939476,
0.28406423330307007,
0.2859749495983124,
-0.39328116178512573,
0.42095229029655457,
-0.17601917684078217,
-0.7150188684463501,
0.10896741598844528,
0.8125218152999878,
0.1893804967403412,
0.6043072938919067,
0.613732635974884,
0.44784483313560486,
0.5613499879837036,
0.23045234382152557,
-0.5700961351394653,
0.27938708662986755,
0.08299127221107483,
-0.8850210309028625,
-0.4076031446456909,
-0.2734494209289551,
-0.6249952912330627,
0.3882788419723511,
-0.5587188601493835,
-0.5695367455482483,
0.2080615609884262,
0.23883098363876343,
-0.5595592260360718,
0.4136858582496643,
-0.8588989973068237,
0.6664639115333557,
-0.11159925162792206,
-0.6585242748260498,
0.3357146084308624,
-0.41475221514701843,
0.5552260279655457,
0.3614951968193054,
0.6583409905433655,
-0.33495384454727173,
-0.11334583163261414,
0.5218766331672668,
-0.36800721287727356,
0.9907475709915161,
-0.47496652603149414,
0.09330114722251892,
0.6500416994094849,
0.1798417717218399,
0.24964049458503723,
0.5734251141548157,
0.34016740322113037,
-0.1604461967945099,
-0.12678498029708862,
-0.42233818769454956,
-0.6843194365501404,
0.367896169424057,
-0.7080649733543396,
-0.6660378575325012,
-0.29961931705474854,
-0.5952228903770447,
-0.49173372983932495,
0.017778944224119186,
0.41970720887184143,
0.6947289705276489,
-0.4065343737602234,
0.38985854387283325,
0.5856163501739502,
-0.2726457417011261,
0.42296192049980164,
0.4845714569091797,
-0.18573056161403656,
-0.2895294725894928,
0.8314673900604248,
-0.1959563046693802,
0.02734403870999813,
0.27361205220222473,
-0.048861727118492126,
-0.1965171992778778,
-0.27563902735710144,
-0.5890524387359619,
-0.16652223467826843,
-0.6345418691635132,
-0.41625866293907166,
-0.3380768895149231,
-0.1685137301683426,
-0.26402994990348816,
0.10184192657470703,
-0.38081666827201843,
-0.0018549949163571,
0.015001011081039906,
-0.1773478090763092,
0.12142419070005417,
0.7072427272796631,
-0.10297545790672302,
0.44712555408477783,
-0.7249719500541687,
0.2539222538471222,
0.2076226770877838,
0.16802126169204712,
-0.26953649520874023,
-0.2768517732620239,
-0.11179398000240326,
0.1407400667667389,
-0.3841000497341156,
-0.9278390407562256,
0.3510693609714508,
0.3970282971858978,
0.5280047655105591,
0.7200023531913757,
0.062307629734277725,
0.7809513807296753,
-0.5388080477714539,
1.0388094186782837,
0.357409805059433,
-0.5338491201400757,
0.35789844393730164,
-0.5055597424507141,
0.05572213605046272,
0.4720912277698517,
-0.08387217670679092,
-0.3806437849998474,
-0.13132303953170776,
-0.5004645586013794,
-0.6124314069747925,
0.954803466796875,
-0.007031991612166166,
0.17553949356079102,
-0.08308640867471695,
-0.12310131639242172,
0.1607508361339569,
0.4252004623413086,
-0.672290563583374,
-0.1652574986219406,
-0.3330981135368347,
0.040784869343042374,
-0.33209535479545593,
-0.2249939739704132,
-0.23148907721042633,
-0.2514627277851105,
0.4700769782066345,
-0.08438588678836823,
0.44883158802986145,
-0.2391621172428131,
-0.0433151014149189,
0.17284564673900604,
-0.02398606948554516,
0.8710643649101257,
0.5659299492835999,
-0.2829820215702057,
0.01646563597023487,
0.40872758626937866,
-0.5153103470802307,
-0.11219632625579834,
-0.2962566614151001,
0.13630411028862,
-0.017739487811923027,
0.4292837679386139,
1.0564239025115967,
0.5676392316818237,
-0.6644412875175476,
0.9253882765769958,
-0.08264104276895523,
-0.3738360106945038,
-0.2578134834766388,
-0.0905776098370552,
-0.025472234934568405,
0.34364718198776245,
0.09577996283769608,
0.017096007242798805,
0.2902304530143738,
-0.6383377313613892,
0.41083070635795593,
0.3003305494785309,
-0.4965066611766815,
-0.3738645613193512,
0.767043948173523,
0.7462698221206665,
-0.10661567002534866,
0.28421270847320557,
-0.4100041091442108,
-0.5198041200637817,
0.6589057445526123,
0.6400225758552551,
0.38861560821533203,
-0.29304277896881104,
0.6464001536369324,
0.2521969974040985,
-0.26707035303115845,
0.23596078157424927,
0.392305850982666,
-0.06071018427610397,
-0.9795676469802856,
-0.6556293368339539,
-0.16012850403785706,
-0.2823580205440521,
0.22234036028385162,
-0.6420485973358154,
0.5548689961433411,
-0.08074314892292023,
-0.369695246219635,
0.03302827849984169,
0.002191140316426754,
-0.8180322647094727,
-0.016090460121631622,
0.3519739806652069,
0.5759677290916443,
-0.9983227849006653,
0.3485126495361328,
0.5441380143165588,
-0.5844274759292603,
-0.3576534688472748,
-0.3537701368331909,
0.2650832533836365,
-0.7101577520370483,
0.6573072671890259,
-0.24231472611427307,
-0.09361440688371658,
-0.2757120728492737,
-0.5357258915901184,
-0.4151330292224884,
0.9746695160865784,
0.19410516321659088,
-0.15678220987319946,
-0.20883408188819885,
0.024311937391757965,
0.31707170605659485,
-0.503720223903656,
0.4870273768901825,
0.19327284395694733,
0.3208039402961731,
0.4855925440788269,
-0.3651314973831177,
-0.6672526597976685,
-0.5188570022583008,
-0.14154788851737976,
0.2798708975315094,
-1.0182511806488037,
0.6761665344238281,
-0.19687487185001373,
-0.07045745849609375,
-0.3940331041812897,
0.8579991459846497,
0.21978642046451569,
0.5407552123069763,
0.2888408303260803,
0.09962453693151474,
0.3378004729747772,
-0.2801038920879364,
0.7039804458618164,
-0.1797926425933838,
0.34967944025993347,
1.2482486963272095,
-0.3747633397579193,
0.7700127959251404,
0.4234127998352051,
0.1268835961818695,
0.19156448543071747,
0.3846222162246704,
-0.07166973501443863,
0.5100694894790649,
-0.17437919974327087,
-0.3259273171424866,
-0.712582528591156,
-0.08078350871801376,
-0.29760462045669556,
0.8480163812637329,
0.5795648097991943,
-0.1064203679561615,
-0.40925952792167664,
0.4732697904109955,
0.14638257026672363,
-0.1057896837592125,
-0.34476739168167114,
1.0693378448486328,
-0.3116925060749054,
-0.5336167812347412,
-0.3201490640640259,
-0.24103574454784393,
0.5985077023506165,
-0.4381425082683563,
-0.2172900289297104,
-0.27724844217300415,
0.1685759723186493,
-0.09136363863945007,
-1.0318968296051025,
0.09371647983789444,
-0.053882576525211334,
-0.03407261148095131,
0.09096665680408478,
0.6813262104988098,
-0.45055630803108215,
-0.35822877287864685,
0.13805200159549713,
0.5688562989234924,
0.22012390196323395,
0.07886450737714767,
-0.5435543060302734,
0.3324083387851715,
-0.07617117464542389,
-0.25410178303718567,
0.4613519310951233,
0.7753166556358337,
0.29434531927108765,
0.3884601891040802,
-0.005789325572550297,
0.15436850488185883,
0.22928683459758759,
0.044726837426424026,
0.2925230860710144,
-0.14354777336120605,
-0.7135517597198486,
-0.5641367435455322,
0.4208461046218872,
-0.5739108324050903,
-0.4714758098125458,
0.6634172201156616,
0.6156324744224548,
0.5457479953765869,
-0.2673059105873108,
0.9970976114273071,
-0.013730216771364212,
0.26437586545944214,
-0.3546768128871918,
0.5901771187782288,
-0.5286936163902283,
-0.04598460718989372,
-0.1811278760433197,
-0.5435389876365662,
-0.26657214760780334,
0.34731176495552063,
0.0677451640367508,
-0.04793214425444603,
0.09826432168483734,
0.3595951199531555,
-0.3873586654663086,
0.26761624217033386,
0.3399123549461365,
-0.2700851857662201,
0.3481549024581909,
0.5315212607383728,
0.7926530241966248,
-0.2665967047214508,
0.8536478877067566,
-0.10258423537015915,
-0.3834204077720642,
-0.5090407729148865,
-0.9551437497138977,
-1.1447193622589111,
-0.844961941242218,
-0.5577390193939209,
-0.5565576553344727,
0.1104816198348999,
0.8383997678756714,
0.5389252305030823,
-0.8586195111274719,
-0.04144575819373131,
0.4867872893810272,
-0.15931443870067596,
-0.5026161074638367,
-0.3338052034378052,
0.2058313637971878,
-0.40202200412750244,
-0.9700406193733215,
0.22130413353443146,
0.2588255703449249,
-0.381155788898468,
-0.11924384534358978,
-0.052438512444496155,
-0.13597846031188965,
0.20609107613563538,
0.9835068583488464,
0.6072708368301392,
-0.3942264914512634,
-0.6039186716079712,
-0.11859505623579025,
0.21955588459968567,
0.2374676764011383,
0.8593922257423401,
-0.4069128930568695,
0.7536525726318359,
0.55098557472229,
0.472052663564682,
0.33543387055397034,
0.17220495641231537,
0.7240062952041626,
-0.9056395888328552,
0.41956421732902527,
-0.05525175482034683,
0.2817637026309967,
0.05726359412074089,
-0.28240764141082764,
0.44494667649269104,
0.40447351336479187,
-0.34424829483032227,
-0.9524437189102173,
0.2855149805545807,
-0.8472386598587036,
-0.2864764630794525,
1.4674372673034668,
-0.11953723430633545,
-0.09448910504579544,
-0.5806371569633484,
-0.39752721786499023,
0.4635705351829529,
-0.4433532655239105,
0.676324188709259,
0.9794663190841675,
-0.43843281269073486,
-0.06492207199335098,
-0.7608491778373718,
0.6992109417915344,
-0.18663838505744934,
-0.5228278040885925,
0.06701183319091797,
0.4681403338909149,
0.0874876081943512,
0.07455691695213318,
0.6291300058364868,
0.026337267830967903,
0.3429130017757416,
0.5695140957832336,
0.011792759411036968,
-0.40729907155036926,
-0.6327699422836304,
0.2619469463825226,
0.37281545996665955,
-0.5692436099052429,
-0.45335546135902405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19159v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19159v1
|
What Drives Performance in Multilingual Language Models?
| 2024-04-29T23:49:19 | 2024-04-29T23:49:19 |
Sina Bagheri Nezhad, Ameeta Agrawal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
This study investigates the factors influencing the performance of
multilingual large language models (MLLMs) across diverse languages. We study 6
MLLMs, including masked language models, autoregressive models, and
instruction-tuned LLMs, on the SIB-200 dataset, a topic classification dataset
encompassing 204 languages. Our analysis considers three scenarios: ALL
languages, SEEN languages (present in the model's pretraining data), and UNSEEN
languages (not present or documented in the model's pretraining data in any
meaningful way). We examine the impact of factors such as pretraining data
size, general resource availability, language family, and script type on model
performance. Decision tree analysis reveals that pretraining data size is the
most influential factor for SEEN languages. However, interestingly, script type
and language family are crucial for UNSEEN languages, highlighting the
importance of cross-lingual transfer learning. Notably, model size and
architecture do not significantly alter the most important features identified.
Our findings provide valuable insights into the strengths and limitations of
current MLLMs and hope to guide the development of more effective and equitable
multilingual NLP systems.
|
[
-0.4933777153491974,
-0.35957419872283936,
0.2488117516040802,
0.5825456976890564,
-0.0006814461667090654,
0.36484840512275696,
-0.39538466930389404,
-0.5622669458389282,
-0.11498436331748962,
0.5406613945960999,
-0.4408443868160248,
-0.242314875125885,
-0.7185656428337097,
0.17878907918930054,
-0.23469148576259613,
1.0468863248825073,
0.01392318494617939,
0.2143716663122177,
-0.0636819526553154,
-0.30083605647087097,
-0.31089121103286743,
-0.9943333268165588,
-0.37071582674980164,
-0.3900100290775299,
0.8597776889801025,
0.12489587813615799,
0.5954540371894836,
0.590229332447052,
0.45904871821403503,
0.2406366467475891,
-0.0025464792270213366,
0.02196711115539074,
-0.48870962858200073,
0.11656564474105835,
-0.192169189453125,
-0.48711615800857544,
-0.3165724277496338,
-0.07159700989723206,
1.0262209177017212,
0.8720942139625549,
0.05681974068284035,
0.37804678082466125,
0.16355863213539124,
0.44820356369018555,
-0.568241536617279,
0.2046380490064621,
-0.6212911605834961,
0.05620674788951874,
-0.5112101435661316,
-0.0755743756890297,
-0.455151230096817,
-0.10654345899820328,
0.18335969746112823,
-0.1993139684200287,
0.012640688568353653,
0.1458469033241272,
0.6215169429779053,
0.04452620446681976,
-0.7711254358291626,
-0.3640925884246826,
-0.8103228807449341,
0.8956753015518188,
-0.5765992403030396,
0.717129647731781,
0.24992580711841583,
-0.06955120712518692,
0.04708819091320038,
-0.45518118143081665,
-0.1578870713710785,
-0.14071185886859894,
-0.38452091813087463,
-0.24724186956882477,
0.10750334709882736,
-0.035740043967962265,
0.5409817695617676,
0.201116144657135,
-0.7380803823471069,
0.4758148193359375,
-0.46252915263175964,
-0.15269334614276886,
0.5841147899627686,
0.1835145205259323,
0.2446104884147644,
0.06206411123275757,
0.06637812405824661,
-0.008475962094962597,
-0.8808472752571106,
0.14525792002677917,
0.5772785544395447,
0.4157719910144806,
-0.15620477497577667,
0.47021883726119995,
-0.018395831808447838,
0.7509626150131226,
-0.45277848839759827,
-0.4046757221221924,
0.3034490942955017,
-0.4506511986255646,
0.07326097041368484,
0.06414328515529633,
0.499019980430603,
-0.03572562709450722,
0.44823434948921204,
-0.20635256171226501,
-0.22382082045078278,
-0.32023361325263977,
-0.10528599470853806,
-0.9586970806121826,
-0.08549550175666809,
-0.18440064787864685,
-0.449933797121048,
0.13673853874206543,
-0.05499962344765663,
-0.5373733043670654,
-0.33493778109550476,
-0.46929270029067993,
0.18709678947925568,
-0.17369034886360168,
-0.5822219252586365,
-0.19992299377918243,
0.13449978828430176,
0.272713840007782,
0.17365166544914246,
-0.9947177171707153,
0.3182877004146576,
0.5742396116256714,
0.6847304701805115,
-0.4661514163017273,
-0.5916692018508911,
-0.37745600938796997,
0.05264531821012497,
-0.521170973777771,
0.4727037847042084,
-0.7077725529670715,
-0.16810694336891174,
0.0019964745733886957,
0.24776902794837952,
-0.5774912238121033,
-0.4601811468601227,
-0.01053029578179121,
-0.4161662757396698,
0.32861393690109253,
-0.35358795523643494,
-0.4448477029800415,
-0.21558937430381775,
-0.04145146906375885,
-0.7748129367828369,
0.9574387669563293,
-0.151377335190773,
-0.7694627642631531,
0.5994134545326233,
-0.6663547158241272,
-0.646251916885376,
-0.02342567965388298,
-0.29572123289108276,
-0.24337460100650787,
0.2160734385251999,
-0.1305973380804062,
0.6591958403587341,
-0.1472056359052658,
0.387472003698349,
-0.2073196917772293,
-0.3623640835285187,
0.2282254695892334,
-0.6947821974754333,
0.6625643968582153,
0.2803500294685364,
-0.35579732060432434,
0.19386160373687744,
-0.8710051774978638,
-0.008565370924770832,
0.12065333127975464,
-0.4225788414478302,
-0.10430605709552765,
-0.050045195966959,
0.21531184017658234,
0.5643054842948914,
0.17123918235301971,
-0.3092966377735138,
-0.0175318643450737,
-0.08667347580194473,
0.1821744590997696,
0.5954968929290771,
-0.16487734019756317,
0.22477394342422485,
0.03963248431682587,
0.9490667581558228,
0.015258105471730232,
0.007893622852861881,
-0.4701997637748718,
-0.6047775745391846,
-0.6735595464706421,
-0.22149552404880524,
0.5952001214027405,
0.46995964646339417,
-0.32340356707572937,
-0.290279358625412,
-0.0877513736486435,
-0.4074726104736328,
-0.6726229786872864,
0.3109268844127655,
0.3919968605041504,
-0.03453553467988968,
-0.06242309883236885,
-0.06322159618139267,
-0.36692923307418823,
-1.1266560554504395,
-0.032683756202459335,
-0.016163844615221024,
0.3396018445491791,
0.39220815896987915,
0.3646939694881439,
-0.1884872168302536,
0.4837823510169983,
-0.2115979641675949,
0.1902598738670349,
-0.5349211692810059,
0.09881702065467834,
0.17022716999053955,
0.3511485755443573,
0.8211857080459595,
-0.8320727944374084,
-0.6757361888885498,
0.18753449618816376,
-0.5498793721199036,
-0.2576996088027954,
-0.055207569152116776,
0.14457391202449799,
0.696241021156311,
0.6305805444717407,
-0.39170703291893005,
0.3386198878288269,
0.953738272190094,
-0.2951483130455017,
0.5879666805267334,
-0.3809886872768402,
0.05390338972210884,
-0.7089789509773254,
0.1837751865386963,
-0.1774505227804184,
0.025796858593821526,
-0.6304876804351807,
0.031241925433278084,
0.18977122008800507,
-0.23665302991867065,
-0.6094262599945068,
0.6089364290237427,
-0.5738869905471802,
-0.5364314317703247,
0.002347822766751051,
-0.18306194245815277,
-0.0019023427739739418,
0.520776629447937,
0.11710655689239502,
0.9354241490364075,
0.6632131934165955,
-0.6549985408782959,
0.008050560019910336,
-0.294687420129776,
-0.44485989212989807,
0.03440237045288086,
-0.4843546748161316,
-0.08699137717485428,
-0.13453686237335205,
-0.10268322378396988,
-0.6958536505699158,
-0.04000274837017059,
-0.20024389028549194,
-0.1260633021593094,
0.5889942646026611,
-0.067319355905056,
-0.5736411213874817,
-0.14880308508872986,
0.13318833708763123,
0.29008355736732483,
0.017265772446990013,
-0.2111712545156479,
0.6333471536636353,
0.2810197174549103,
-0.3156625032424927,
-0.6645864248275757,
-0.47678878903388977,
0.028819525614380836,
-0.4572378695011139,
-0.3882652819156647,
0.12538574635982513,
-0.1749637871980667,
-0.353728711605072,
-0.31484436988830566,
0.15605315566062927,
-0.028852811083197594,
0.5165581703186035,
0.2863188683986664,
0.13450540602207184,
-0.4363265037536621,
0.392607182264328,
-0.14037108421325684,
0.03872261941432953,
-0.04178392142057419,
-0.0810370147228241,
0.8358504176139832,
-0.39798998832702637,
-0.41601479053497314,
-0.06278028339147568,
0.4309101402759552,
0.7918331027030945,
-0.5787954330444336,
1.2353678941726685,
0.8378583192825317,
-0.15914641320705414,
-0.11067696660757065,
-0.4367087185382843,
0.018514292314648628,
-0.3923092484474182,
0.8116174936294556,
-0.5888259410858154,
-0.9322184324264526,
0.7927447557449341,
0.15366193652153015,
0.047211602330207825,
0.4346696436405182,
0.7734544277191162,
0.127327561378479,
1.1298496723175049,
0.7542738318443298,
-0.17039400339126587,
0.6727328300476074,
0.03892337530851364,
0.16024106740951538,
-0.5781628489494324,
-0.33559995889663696,
-0.5807392597198486,
-0.10286583751440048,
-0.9548717737197876,
-0.2927226722240448,
0.14916037023067474,
0.12167757749557495,
-0.1704324185848236,
0.12177525460720062,
0.1677815467119217,
0.3890579640865326,
0.5308535099029541,
-0.47364166378974915,
0.27888479828834534,
0.000060760550695704296,
-0.30740201473236084,
-0.00360703282058239,
-0.9067299365997314,
-0.4585072994232178,
1.1919111013412476,
0.5410866737365723,
0.741094172000885,
0.26653802394866943,
0.45391762256622314,
-0.047721173614263535,
0.11984856426715851,
-0.3742373287677765,
0.35807740688323975,
-0.28984540700912476,
-0.8646478652954102,
-0.3883618712425232,
-0.3528352975845337,
-0.9648708701133728,
0.6244238615036011,
-0.21671806275844574,
-0.6832515001296997,
-0.01739543490111828,
-0.1484270691871643,
-0.06552400439977646,
0.19142520427703857,
-0.8466262817382812,
0.982464611530304,
-0.8004514575004578,
-0.326224148273468,
-0.2914074659347534,
-0.4578995406627655,
0.17668521404266357,
-0.6223400235176086,
0.21417877078056335,
-0.21744363009929657,
0.1147216185927391,
0.7492611408233643,
0.25379109382629395,
0.7025818228721619,
-0.00909331999719143,
-0.22424596548080444,
-0.14343377947807312,
-0.0727209523320198,
0.2824702262878418,
-0.14831416308879852,
-0.14353466033935547,
0.482527494430542,
0.06880127638578415,
-0.3405231237411499,
-0.3399249315261841,
0.6618959903717041,
-0.7843966484069824,
-0.5708669424057007,
-0.14706635475158691,
-0.528059184551239,
-0.4153668284416199,
0.30963897705078125,
0.15912272036075592,
0.6416829824447632,
-0.03925872966647148,
0.6487553715705872,
0.6380866765975952,
-0.5906171798706055,
0.6458209156990051,
0.7497478723526001,
-0.735085666179657,
0.192494198679924,
0.9692315459251404,
0.553152859210968,
0.5712005496025085,
0.306515097618103,
0.06210244446992874,
-0.2510937452316284,
-0.7246086597442627,
-0.500518262386322,
0.3208359479904175,
-0.7004302144050598,
0.24412834644317627,
-0.870746374130249,
-0.3638852834701538,
-0.46499621868133545,
0.17923575639724731,
-0.40326958894729614,
-0.3971821367740631,
-0.27802157402038574,
-0.10866177827119827,
0.08629666268825531,
0.8960410952568054,
0.0689278095960617,
0.3947524428367615,
-0.652081310749054,
0.07261082530021667,
0.0901084765791893,
0.523540735244751,
0.0842096284031868,
-0.5113235116004944,
-0.46604666113853455,
-0.18565866351127625,
0.005343508441001177,
-0.48503461480140686,
0.40780264139175415,
0.3941604197025299,
1.0613731145858765,
0.24539682269096375,
-0.2857806384563446,
0.5761376619338989,
-0.47516778111457825,
0.5981139540672302,
-0.09441465884447098,
-0.6808541417121887,
0.3071087598800659,
-0.3370477855205536,
0.34859195351600647,
0.2817263603210449,
0.5885844230651855,
-0.5113060474395752,
-0.3484048545360565,
-0.39497002959251404,
-0.6748255491256714,
0.8891092538833618,
0.07586439698934555,
0.09313618391752243,
0.28276342153549194,
-0.0026368338149040937,
0.2252027839422226,
0.4388723075389862,
-0.9239533543586731,
-0.35438072681427,
0.014380308799445629,
0.1111423596739769,
-0.3926597237586975,
-0.20044662058353424,
0.3296186327934265,
-0.1893082708120346,
0.5237551331520081,
-0.20270445942878723,
-0.07569144666194916,
-0.4744628667831421,
-0.39723533391952515,
0.028844179585576057,
0.2611633539199829,
0.825989842414856,
1.062551736831665,
-0.15102460980415344,
-0.05532291159033775,
0.1655023992061615,
-0.28568705916404724,
-0.11609532684087753,
-0.017667852342128754,
-0.008896078914403915,
0.0019825499039143324,
0.673873782157898,
1.181235671043396,
0.26205742359161377,
-0.6477365493774414,
0.18368738889694214,
-0.10690869390964508,
0.19719597697257996,
-0.13510774075984955,
0.11766326427459717,
0.07924390584230423,
0.19262216985225677,
0.30927330255508423,
-0.08655131608247757,
-0.12026906758546829,
-0.7245442271232605,
0.027589101344347,
0.3994210958480835,
-0.20590385794639587,
-0.3854316174983978,
0.3644903898239136,
-0.09414229542016983,
-0.23612596094608307,
0.5274888873100281,
0.15179196000099182,
-0.7574626803398132,
0.6653603315353394,
0.516007125377655,
0.4615037739276886,
-0.43879076838493347,
0.1991434544324875,
0.12679097056388855,
0.5663604140281677,
0.10895192623138428,
-0.018814999610185623,
0.07600437849760056,
-0.7225459814071655,
-0.5912794470787048,
-0.866841733455658,
-0.23571842908859253,
0.327343612909317,
-0.6123718619346619,
0.26814302802085876,
-0.2657058537006378,
-0.11038289964199066,
0.0580269880592823,
0.1091594472527504,
-0.9754989743232727,
0.2375640869140625,
0.5435763001441956,
0.674743115901947,
-0.9147480726242065,
1.0711431503295898,
0.543570876121521,
-0.09575051814317703,
-0.7358167767524719,
-0.1456523984670639,
-0.10246599465608597,
-0.8114684224128723,
0.9889225959777832,
0.10959303379058838,
-0.11429844796657562,
-0.005215378478169441,
-0.05562504380941391,
-1.23428213596344,
0.6178510189056396,
0.41503262519836426,
-0.4221489131450653,
0.012176425196230412,
0.36090031266212463,
0.5809305310249329,
-0.6090571880340576,
0.2873305380344391,
0.5531293153762817,
0.3801625072956085,
-0.010909720323979855,
-1.3213493824005127,
-0.40712425112724304,
-0.09722653031349182,
-0.02599175274372101,
0.15351884067058563,
-0.6099750995635986,
0.8667945861816406,
-0.1754579395055771,
-0.009180243127048016,
-0.2715527415275574,
0.2872811257839203,
0.3051118552684784,
0.12847919762134552,
0.23451855778694153,
0.05128183215856552,
0.8110377192497253,
-0.013215774670243263,
1.0683929920196533,
-0.46231716871261597,
0.059432536363601685,
1.0358492136001587,
-0.5883228778839111,
0.8429771065711975,
0.32867246866226196,
-0.2025557905435562,
0.4092370867729187,
0.7633326649665833,
0.013603780418634415,
0.3690946400165558,
0.11504518240690231,
0.05657079443335533,
-0.28406697511672974,
-0.2904236614704132,
-0.5583721399307251,
0.8479618430137634,
0.44006386399269104,
-0.5304998159408569,
-0.008493233472108841,
0.33057278394699097,
-0.06351630389690399,
-0.31253939867019653,
-0.4129948318004608,
0.6515651345252991,
-0.1006215438246727,
-0.6836776733398438,
0.4309317171573639,
0.11477568745613098,
0.6384103894233704,
-0.9177746176719666,
0.17395220696926117,
-0.16436080634593964,
0.1523367166519165,
-0.13612738251686096,
-0.6667516827583313,
0.2737109363079071,
-0.06850835680961609,
-0.3044637143611908,
-0.4505002796649933,
0.7078191637992859,
-0.4761841297149658,
-0.6551637053489685,
0.5720223784446716,
0.7234697937965393,
0.23475787043571472,
-0.0019944668747484684,
-0.6090745329856873,
0.336351603269577,
0.11074269562959671,
-0.44653597474098206,
0.6801276803016663,
0.6271297335624695,
-0.39505237340927124,
0.8946081399917603,
0.5888952612876892,
0.246907040476799,
0.42762550711631775,
0.19043688476085663,
0.5759755373001099,
-0.6991261839866638,
-0.366741806268692,
-0.7232091426849365,
0.29341235756874084,
0.08355172723531723,
-0.31804242730140686,
1.097875714302063,
0.6244961023330688,
0.8286311030387878,
-0.0675058513879776,
0.45297712087631226,
0.3018508851528168,
0.48976197838783264,
-0.5105405449867249,
0.8200764656066895,
-0.5430406928062439,
0.18603238463401794,
-0.24383261799812317,
-1.0744003057479858,
-0.05876760929822922,
0.4224885106086731,
-0.2966698706150055,
0.27338603138923645,
0.5522918701171875,
0.624832808971405,
0.21999549865722656,
-0.05892368033528328,
0.611272931098938,
0.059923700988292694,
0.25251340866088867,
0.2239324450492859,
0.8148035407066345,
-0.008008109405636787,
0.3837728798389435,
-0.19271546602249146,
0.021921465173363686,
-0.12228508293628693,
-0.8991934657096863,
-0.9271981120109558,
-0.5446752905845642,
-0.3277789354324341,
0.06295102834701538,
-0.16762959957122803,
0.6892098188400269,
0.8158029317855835,
-1.0064563751220703,
-0.4759153127670288,
0.38927891850471497,
0.26236239075660706,
0.2295219600200653,
-0.2336517870426178,
0.3218269944190979,
-0.24937830865383148,
-0.5289216637611389,
0.27237212657928467,
0.29794377088546753,
0.026821305975317955,
-0.5269426107406616,
-0.10622556507587433,
-0.3464750349521637,
-0.11868470162153244,
0.7515907883644104,
0.13254563510417938,
-0.7938969135284424,
0.17592082917690277,
0.09999938309192657,
-0.1548336148262024,
-0.27685990929603577,
0.8473520278930664,
-0.5734456181526184,
0.20481082797050476,
0.15065225958824158,
0.5255777835845947,
0.5376172065734863,
-0.3360692262649536,
0.6283247470855713,
-0.7979124784469604,
0.32119548320770264,
-0.033973414450883865,
0.4932843744754791,
0.39436110854148865,
-0.3057768940925598,
0.4442532956600189,
0.21446864306926727,
-0.43792542815208435,
-0.8775545954704285,
0.009077044203877449,
-0.32345810532569885,
-0.4533575177192688,
1.3064935207366943,
-0.13873076438903809,
0.05204836279153824,
-0.2540920674800873,
0.03395815193653107,
-0.1433524638414383,
0.031826939433813095,
0.1333802491426468,
1.0785856246948242,
-0.1724994033575058,
-0.5033055543899536,
-0.8150120973587036,
0.43571245670318604,
0.31377580761909485,
-0.5111021399497986,
0.24141071736812592,
0.45438244938850403,
0.2497316151857376,
0.18450789153575897,
0.3662658929824829,
-0.011659273877739906,
-0.11877503246068954,
-0.15352405607700348,
-0.16453441977500916,
0.054554715752601624,
-0.7479698061943054,
-0.4469069242477417,
0.23022888600826263,
0.1801074743270874,
0.23350749909877777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19154v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19154v2
|
RTF: Region-based Table Filling Method for Relational Triple Extraction
| 2024-04-29T23:36:38 | 2024-06-13T16:26:15 |
Ning An, Lei Hei, Yong Jiang, Weiping Meng, Jingjing Hu, Boran Huang, Feiliang Ren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Relational triple extraction is crucial work for the automatic construction
of knowledge graphs. Existing methods only construct shallow representations
from a token or token pair-level. However, previous works ignore local spatial
dependencies of relational triples, resulting in a weakness of entity pair
boundary detection. To tackle this problem, we propose a novel Region-based
Table Filling method (RTF). We devise a novel region-based tagging scheme and
bi-directional decoding strategy, which regard each relational triple as a
region on the relation-specific table, and identifies triples by determining
two endpoints of each region. We also introduce convolution to construct
region-level table representations from a spatial perspective which makes
triples easier to be captured. In addition, we share partial tagging scores
among different relations to improve learning efficiency of relation
classifier. Experimental results show that our method achieves state-of-the-art
with better generalization capability on three variants of two widely used
benchmark datasets.
|
[
-0.5803887248039246,
-0.8871719241142273,
0.4926970303058624,
0.16317155957221985,
-0.16427135467529297,
0.05547152832150459,
0.0020861767698079348,
-0.6592839956283569,
0.10419513285160065,
0.5314624905586243,
-0.19718529284000397,
-0.7329006791114807,
-0.32760781049728394,
0.14633697271347046,
0.02185530588030815,
0.7184444069862366,
-0.31158748269081116,
-0.13516747951507568,
-0.28118816018104553,
-0.13368861377239227,
-0.7133054733276367,
-0.3194672465324402,
-0.402480810880661,
-0.474026620388031,
0.3679251968860626,
0.9097356796264648,
0.6031160950660706,
0.8648267984390259,
0.4868045151233673,
0.21161922812461853,
0.3961469233036041,
0.4057171940803528,
-0.07982704788446426,
0.20906738936901093,
0.06701468676328659,
-0.4007851481437683,
-0.7181777358055115,
-0.1636030375957489,
0.7533726096153259,
0.7722000479698181,
-0.1912149041891098,
0.03941730037331581,
-0.180769145488739,
0.9871988892555237,
-0.38392138481140137,
0.7025899291038513,
-0.6548962593078613,
0.31748414039611816,
-0.618850588798523,
-0.4235574007034302,
-0.306942880153656,
-0.4189361333847046,
0.16368305683135986,
-0.6839995384216309,
0.43079614639282227,
0.2939794957637787,
0.827907919883728,
-0.003940684255212545,
-0.7397130727767944,
-0.021533966064453125,
-1.0199865102767944,
0.37422049045562744,
-0.18358848989009857,
0.5715546607971191,
0.5406996607780457,
0.40055355429649353,
-0.2418392151594162,
-0.5743259191513062,
-0.6709184646606445,
0.20030254125595093,
-0.5049303770065308,
-0.23126699030399323,
-0.1474062204360962,
-0.1469070315361023,
0.2587028443813324,
0.4005298316478729,
-0.6493008732795715,
-0.41889119148254395,
-0.12293315678834915,
0.05747701972723007,
0.32564324140548706,
-0.03861420229077339,
0.6316605806350708,
-0.2863336503505707,
-0.4327295422554016,
-0.042908139526844025,
-0.7869638800621033,
-0.3278559744358063,
0.018982503563165665,
0.5506746768951416,
-0.09396931529045105,
0.5393826365470886,
-0.12684394419193268,
1.0751078128814697,
-0.0723472461104393,
-0.17987823486328125,
0.31019747257232666,
-0.41552409529685974,
-0.11475754529237747,
-0.10453634709119797,
0.803129255771637,
0.43445679545402527,
0.1000138595700264,
-0.29174694418907166,
0.05485660210251808,
-0.39004620909690857,
-0.2814745306968689,
-0.3410143554210663,
-0.5705063343048096,
0.08442224562168121,
-0.1341254562139511,
-0.03631239011883736,
0.13224419951438904,
-0.9811611175537109,
-0.3743087947368622,
-0.20315176248550415,
0.08686120063066483,
-0.520919680595398,
-0.5631389021873474,
-0.015229079872369766,
-0.16256433725357056,
0.2905955910682678,
-0.020317336544394493,
-0.8206421732902527,
0.3454289138317108,
0.4937492609024048,
0.8413352370262146,
-0.08089176565408707,
-0.18344049155712128,
-0.5201920866966248,
0.8932443261146545,
0.04672785848379135,
1.0797654390335083,
-0.46005183458328247,
-0.31201639771461487,
-0.00776952737942338,
-0.3904978930950165,
0.259541392326355,
-0.6090493202209473,
0.19235792756080627,
-0.7215035557746887,
0.2938469648361206,
-0.561133623123169,
-0.2636494040489197,
-0.1297195702791214,
0.37855204939842224,
-1.0705815553665161,
1.2707760334014893,
0.23141968250274658,
-0.9185887575149536,
0.5764077305793762,
-0.5897355079650879,
-0.5804380774497986,
0.2623418867588043,
-0.38751593232154846,
-0.5890893340110779,
-0.5379772186279297,
0.6773297190666199,
0.5276317596435547,
-0.27187734842300415,
0.33383819460868835,
-0.4323323369026184,
-0.16877147555351257,
-0.022821754217147827,
0.21966031193733215,
0.4761999547481537,
-0.18111680448055267,
-0.12160573899745941,
-0.23810970783233643,
-0.5589416027069092,
-0.06017652899026871,
0.07513921707868576,
-0.23789037764072418,
-0.4599972069263458,
-0.1689104586839676,
-0.29957011342048645,
0.1340712606906891,
0.12095444649457932,
-0.43617504835128784,
0.28676915168762207,
-0.25200334191322327,
0.15430447459220886,
0.0718192458152771,
0.4478842616081238,
0.8235540986061096,
-0.14723338186740875,
0.2621420621871948,
0.32589030265808105,
-0.3725314140319824,
0.3675127923488617,
-0.5081130266189575,
-0.5666379928588867,
-0.34261617064476013,
0.5742339491844177,
0.5727494955062866,
-1.4409053325653076,
0.6133109331130981,
-0.488625168800354,
-0.4600551724433899,
-0.041244376450777054,
-0.017942961305379868,
0.2932182252407074,
0.7098861932754517,
0.603829562664032,
0.1380510777235031,
-0.6863148808479309,
-0.9166654348373413,
-0.12236129492521286,
-0.02699085883796215,
0.12621381878852844,
0.33422616124153137,
0.4325960874557495,
0.312434583902359,
1.1262987852096558,
-0.7147087454795837,
-0.7804808616638184,
-0.46900424361228943,
-0.0067952414974570274,
0.08616136014461517,
0.583191990852356,
0.5666234493255615,
-0.9936041831970215,
-0.8627373576164246,
0.15169964730739594,
-0.9338122010231018,
0.14952674508094788,
0.1642298400402069,
-0.4862516224384308,
0.2608691155910492,
0.3652808666229248,
-0.4795915484428406,
0.38893789052963257,
-0.1410418152809143,
-0.3642563223838806,
0.01765177585184574,
-0.030903156846761703,
0.0188689436763525,
-0.9164454936981201,
0.04160343483090401,
0.19279755651950836,
-0.3852458596229553,
-0.8238869309425354,
-0.0978725254535675,
0.25526392459869385,
-0.13445332646369934,
-0.1571773886680603,
0.49255797266960144,
-0.8608218431472778,
-0.333620548248291,
0.2707919776439667,
0.3244231343269348,
0.18908219039440155,
0.7126719355583191,
0.27863577008247375,
0.43127015233039856,
0.32401952147483826,
-0.3974732756614685,
0.3431052267551422,
0.4529476463794708,
0.017646968364715576,
0.643505871295929,
-0.25919026136398315,
0.18835128843784332,
-0.0967470183968544,
0.49330565333366394,
-0.5833927392959595,
-0.2401229292154312,
0.7077306509017944,
-0.35725733637809753,
0.6406911611557007,
-0.4922697842121124,
-0.46972915530204773,
-0.2743539810180664,
-0.30869218707084656,
0.47153759002685547,
-0.037693120539188385,
-0.67003333568573,
0.9018877148628235,
0.7589182257652283,
-0.017054229974746704,
-0.816250205039978,
-0.8884235620498657,
-0.0007786814239807427,
-0.3075512647628784,
-0.6628548502922058,
0.7342178821563721,
0.5111435651779175,
0.04594045132398605,
0.4540013372898102,
-0.30712124705314636,
-0.1362488716840744,
-0.12895368039608002,
0.11105836182832718,
0.30129534006118774,
-0.0770757794380188,
-0.004559493623673916,
-0.10228350758552551,
-0.2586638927459717,
0.048989810049533844,
-0.40074145793914795,
0.6100980043411255,
-0.29756322503089905,
-0.05647346004843712,
-0.4658072590827942,
0.6366382837295532,
0.15721163153648376,
-0.46042758226394653,
0.6940011382102966,
0.5599807500839233,
-0.9146680235862732,
-0.20350725948810577,
-0.4760257303714752,
0.19320642948150635,
-0.414147287607193,
0.3394957184791565,
-0.5627599358558655,
-0.6733382344245911,
0.5544689297676086,
0.24649149179458618,
-0.24369588494300842,
0.30359911918640137,
0.07036937028169632,
0.009366750717163086,
0.55638587474823,
0.6328955888748169,
0.10538390278816223,
0.26152893900871277,
-0.5359221696853638,
0.49885404109954834,
-0.6684346199035645,
-0.678276538848877,
-0.8323208093643188,
-0.15738072991371155,
-0.36085355281829834,
-0.44918209314346313,
0.5163794755935669,
0.22470463812351227,
-0.2616643011569977,
0.24731211364269257,
-0.49259817600250244,
0.7487288117408752,
0.45596298575401306,
0.2008335292339325,
0.5566655397415161,
0.45094943046569824,
0.0008049848838709295,
-0.13406842947006226,
-0.6504931449890137,
-0.17777398228645325,
0.846429169178009,
0.13751554489135742,
0.29860585927963257,
0.5539218187332153,
0.931888222694397,
0.2652343511581421,
0.3143678605556488,
-0.7153071165084839,
0.5419930815696716,
0.12581534683704376,
-0.4400014579296112,
-0.2956094741821289,
-0.8034660816192627,
-0.7058125138282776,
0.22957375645637512,
-0.4703793525695801,
-0.6062365174293518,
0.29089102149009705,
0.1652832329273224,
-0.15680745244026184,
0.6537711024284363,
-0.6961094737052917,
0.8250046968460083,
0.07947947829961777,
-0.249305859208107,
0.4796242117881775,
-0.4977116882801056,
0.5573742389678955,
0.12072258442640305,
0.0687626451253891,
-0.07861712574958801,
-0.025849122554063797,
0.8041852116584778,
-0.4091549217700958,
0.33905085921287537,
-0.6556385159492493,
0.21784541010856628,
0.22503194212913513,
0.21339882910251617,
0.36917901039123535,
0.535221517086029,
0.026681188493967056,
0.08115949481725693,
-0.06586186587810516,
-0.47945937514305115,
-0.8858082294464111,
0.6005359888076782,
-0.7422278523445129,
-0.4967285692691803,
-0.6791690587997437,
-0.6110447645187378,
-0.6647087335586548,
0.4379100799560547,
-0.19878682494163513,
0.6264939308166504,
0.0756518542766571,
0.019452866166830063,
0.5857378244400024,
0.022324461489915848,
0.417979896068573,
0.3243866264820099,
-0.2735324203968048,
-0.715681791305542,
0.9198756814002991,
-0.047682024538517,
-0.4136902391910553,
0.628557562828064,
-0.06449440866708755,
-0.433010458946228,
-0.4274311065673828,
-0.514340877532959,
0.478813499212265,
-0.5122871398925781,
-0.8616829514503479,
-0.7682757377624512,
-0.0286092609167099,
-0.27927276492118835,
-0.004664678126573563,
0.006384934298694134,
-0.3552464544773102,
-0.03735718876123428,
-0.10077869147062302,
0.24972571432590485,
0.8437638282775879,
-0.16448912024497986,
0.06052244454622269,
-0.9102392196655273,
0.4083876609802246,
0.3757461905479431,
0.4297597110271454,
0.11431785672903061,
0.2236296534538269,
-0.0718127116560936,
-0.23929044604301453,
-0.020121557638049126,
-1.258109211921692,
0.2661581039428711,
0.009182745590806007,
0.42933112382888794,
-0.10721121728420258,
0.025986528024077415,
0.7082546353340149,
-0.2839377224445343,
0.4250010550022125,
0.12388147413730621,
-0.8671929836273193,
0.41645336151123047,
-0.4266708791255951,
-0.053460076451301575,
0.488370418548584,
0.4481768310070038,
-0.3853452801704407,
0.13230150938034058,
-0.4294078052043915,
-0.8701651692390442,
0.9851526618003845,
0.15153859555721283,
-0.4710503816604614,
0.04396548867225647,
0.5293871760368347,
-0.15674583613872528,
-0.12992744147777557,
-0.9604442119598389,
-0.418385773897171,
0.03772542253136635,
-0.2541792094707489,
0.5754631757736206,
-0.37358760833740234,
-0.20065467059612274,
-0.16017141938209534,
0.7070990204811096,
0.08938363939523697,
0.5224327445030212,
0.3580024838447571,
-0.041169747710227966,
-0.1627824604511261,
0.1116875559091568,
0.1424141228199005,
0.5432063341140747,
-0.4488659203052521,
0.33775678277015686,
0.023637188598513603,
-0.4328981339931488,
-0.0024857367388904095,
0.46739163994789124,
-0.13952583074569702,
0.014779768884181976,
0.42692720890045166,
0.26018837094306946,
-0.2162317931652069,
0.23199564218521118,
0.625494658946991,
-0.4040132761001587,
-0.11165238171815872,
-0.38620999455451965,
-0.23226609826087952,
0.1926792860031128,
0.1698128879070282,
0.3690580427646637,
0.08426915109157562,
0.18811996281147003,
-0.3845391571521759,
0.3208022713661194,
0.32673683762550354,
-0.46531248092651367,
0.08853932470083237,
0.35045433044433594,
0.36762726306915283,
-0.21206064522266388,
0.6309266686439514,
-0.577282190322876,
-0.5062873959541321,
0.4723474979400635,
0.6072056293487549,
0.3953438997268677,
0.19018343091011047,
0.13321883976459503,
0.541289746761322,
0.17391479015350342,
0.05602099001407623,
0.5779497027397156,
-0.3082701861858368,
-0.8925710320472717,
-0.2555031180381775,
-0.35319316387176514,
-0.15300729870796204,
0.13231435418128967,
-0.7917914986610413,
0.2480156123638153,
-0.10428407788276672,
-0.020182332023978233,
-0.04912972450256348,
0.35778018832206726,
-0.6390301585197449,
-0.11222521215677261,
0.2564235031604767,
0.9181612133979797,
-0.7550775408744812,
0.9853771328926086,
0.7968552112579346,
-0.3613925576210022,
-1.0247266292572021,
0.017946472391486168,
-0.16501863300800323,
-0.41315534710884094,
0.5079869627952576,
0.13199347257614136,
-0.02705610729753971,
-0.11038387566804886,
-0.0998138040304184,
-0.9943864345550537,
1.2564418315887451,
-0.015572167932987213,
-0.124067023396492,
-0.25850820541381836,
0.4297919273376465,
0.14786210656166077,
-0.45964500308036804,
0.0995953306555748,
0.8430633544921875,
0.5892573595046997,
0.04928029701113701,
-0.43883123993873596,
0.3769069314002991,
-0.22035810351371765,
0.2657405138015747,
0.6368855834007263,
-0.18563248217105865,
0.3463582396507263,
0.000009845478416536935,
-0.44069159030914307,
-0.38836154341697693,
1.0258134603500366,
0.4086473882198334,
0.35704752802848816,
0.593174934387207,
0.6614621877670288,
0.8750901222229004,
-0.4359792470932007,
0.5881786942481995,
-0.15228606760501862,
0.32814157009124756,
1.3114279508590698,
-0.5253337621688843,
0.6882162690162659,
0.2941861152648926,
-0.1333104819059372,
0.5725948214530945,
0.37878677248954773,
0.03813846409320831,
0.5270997285842896,
-0.004059039056301117,
-0.2899487316608429,
-0.14699551463127136,
0.02139422856271267,
-0.5477839112281799,
0.3510740101337433,
0.6659843325614929,
0.20868298411369324,
-0.4625038206577301,
-0.278704971075058,
0.32992783188819885,
0.20945942401885986,
-0.12988239526748657,
0.5667644143104553,
-0.12916982173919678,
-0.6109810471534729,
0.21622881293296814,
-0.0034279164392501116,
0.3037635385990143,
-0.1198902502655983,
-0.4742932915687561,
-0.3777724504470825,
-0.23997966945171356,
-0.4676917791366577,
-0.963847279548645,
0.35057300329208374,
-0.24645398557186127,
-0.2139108031988144,
-0.04323369637131691,
0.832815945148468,
-0.8299318552017212,
-0.11264780908823013,
0.22611285746097565,
0.7692813277244568,
-0.2455710768699646,
0.12577077746391296,
-0.547776460647583,
-0.13729439675807953,
0.14943121373653412,
-0.06980153918266296,
-0.08500999212265015,
0.7558217644691467,
-0.14461110532283783,
0.29281342029571533,
0.44301149249076843,
0.020048849284648895,
-0.30442893505096436,
-0.09363903105258942,
0.7495011687278748,
-0.8165944814682007,
-0.38466644287109375,
-0.7380866408348083,
0.3585973381996155,
-0.45246243476867676,
0.06389878690242767,
0.4288715124130249,
0.6431664228439331,
0.76191645860672,
0.02879956178367138,
0.6800479292869568,
-0.41829589009284973,
0.44600364565849304,
-0.6217213869094849,
0.7022514343261719,
-0.2935599684715271,
0.4008799195289612,
-0.1337541788816452,
-1.1466214656829834,
-0.9815839529037476,
0.2790898382663727,
-0.4058237075805664,
0.187530055642128,
0.8511009812355042,
0.7531256079673767,
-0.1550673395395279,
0.1121836006641388,
-0.0346379317343235,
-0.020795976743102074,
0.42620041966438293,
0.5894425511360168,
0.6612407565116882,
-0.41990095376968384,
0.7794536352157593,
-0.6587236523628235,
-0.2890717089176178,
0.027156174182891846,
-0.9503876566886902,
-0.9005113840103149,
-0.7529687881469727,
-0.2686973810195923,
-0.48982030153274536,
-0.2388518750667572,
0.6334317922592163,
0.6822670102119446,
-0.4025220274925232,
-0.02687590755522251,
0.16822651028633118,
0.4396360218524933,
0.01643688604235649,
-0.2821170389652252,
0.7651546597480774,
0.08568041026592255,
-0.34978267550468445,
0.19844847917556763,
0.30065855383872986,
0.004125827457755804,
0.04708609730005264,
0.29478344321250916,
-0.5565322041511536,
-0.5804184079170227,
0.28876426815986633,
0.34752583503723145,
-0.29912662506103516,
-0.3567189574241638,
-0.2347743958234787,
-0.06051396206021309,
0.3365590572357178,
0.8023074865341187,
-0.699951171875,
0.15911290049552917,
0.49703603982925415,
0.33115658164024353,
0.7331798672676086,
0.022215500473976135,
0.5962704420089722,
-1.0320483446121216,
-0.024111837148666382,
0.12565529346466064,
0.5559495091438293,
0.7353639602661133,
-0.5283419489860535,
0.7113162875175476,
0.3630690574645996,
-0.4668487310409546,
-0.7782505750656128,
0.2560194432735443,
-1.1927552223205566,
0.07202699780464172,
0.9173572659492493,
0.042637523263692856,
-0.44715768098831177,
-0.47020912170410156,
0.04126489907503128,
0.4876815974712372,
-0.4733338952064514,
0.38921239972114563,
0.37545105814933777,
-0.39220377802848816,
0.10891363769769669,
-0.30080917477607727,
0.7502877116203308,
-0.03808171674609184,
-0.839131772518158,
0.08068213611841202,
0.47888633608818054,
0.396030455827713,
0.240101620554924,
0.7446446418762207,
-0.32705801725387573,
0.15529809892177582,
-0.14956597983837128,
0.3262403905391693,
-0.3294253349304199,
-0.4797377586364746,
-0.1365617960691452,
0.4502028226852417,
-0.05410491302609444,
0.11926694214344025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19128v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19128v1
|
Q-GroundCAM: Quantifying Grounding in Vision Language Models via GradCAM
| 2024-04-29T22:06:17 | 2024-04-29T22:06:17 |
Navid Rajabi, Jana Kosecka
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Vision and Language Models (VLMs) continue to demonstrate remarkable
zero-shot (ZS) performance across various tasks. However, many probing studies
have revealed that even the best-performing VLMs struggle to capture aspects of
compositional scene understanding, lacking the ability to properly ground and
localize linguistic phrases in images. Recent VLM advancements include scaling
up both model and dataset sizes, additional training objectives and levels of
supervision, and variations in the model architectures. To characterize the
grounding ability of VLMs, such as phrase grounding, referring expressions
comprehension, and relationship understanding, Pointing Game has been used as
an evaluation metric for datasets with bounding box annotations. In this paper,
we introduce a novel suite of quantitative metrics that utilize GradCAM
activations to rigorously evaluate the grounding capabilities of pre-trained
VLMs like CLIP, BLIP, and ALBEF. These metrics offer an explainable and
quantifiable approach for a more detailed comparison of the zero-shot
capabilities of VLMs and enable measuring models' grounding uncertainty. This
characterization reveals interesting tradeoffs between the size of the model,
the dataset size, and their performance.
|
[
-0.40237170457839966,
-0.6417747139930725,
0.6075687408447266,
0.14945651590824127,
-0.4534883499145508,
-0.15733499825000763,
0.08023692667484283,
-0.005563344340771437,
-0.25863155722618103,
0.24838194251060486,
-0.39827653765678406,
-0.8604009747505188,
-0.6699157357215881,
-0.4491162598133087,
-0.24410471320152283,
0.7126805782318115,
0.10953694581985474,
0.16151955723762512,
-0.7589824795722961,
-0.4302578270435333,
-0.8039166927337646,
-0.5392139554023743,
-0.024016356095671654,
-0.12105492502450943,
0.009352017194032669,
0.16621355712413788,
0.9852893948554993,
0.6230271458625793,
0.8642120957374573,
0.1353495568037033,
-0.1385699212551117,
-0.2410331666469574,
-0.49266335368156433,
-0.18114398419857025,
-0.09739614278078079,
-0.5053530931472778,
-0.242418110370636,
0.19078128039836884,
0.8522772192955017,
0.7111384868621826,
0.18857227265834808,
0.41606128215789795,
-0.2751818001270294,
0.6502746939659119,
-0.9730856418609619,
0.1261361688375473,
-0.6508474349975586,
0.24514634907245636,
0.11632388085126877,
-0.37585607171058655,
-0.15028545260429382,
-0.05567222461104393,
0.008335962891578674,
-0.5463767051696777,
0.3383447825908661,
-0.2143927663564682,
1.268333077430725,
0.5652732849121094,
-0.09955784678459167,
0.1199951022863388,
-0.42835888266563416,
0.7604351043701172,
-0.6953955888748169,
0.5468288660049438,
0.4200579524040222,
0.6134563088417053,
0.0032364337239414454,
-0.24454014003276825,
-0.36057940125465393,
-0.39426591992378235,
0.006830506958067417,
0.21591196954250336,
-0.05417795106768608,
0.31793099641799927,
0.4848950505256653,
0.42495039105415344,
-0.4979109764099121,
-0.3075801134109497,
-0.27533724904060364,
0.0013225054135546088,
0.1816416233778,
0.19528570771217346,
0.37743493914604187,
0.014396809041500092,
-0.25641682744026184,
-0.1848066747188568,
-0.41722625494003296,
0.2763627767562866,
0.030653992667794228,
0.002879154169932008,
-0.10530735552310944,
0.8343504667282104,
-0.6093835234642029,
1.1403058767318726,
0.008854137733578682,
-0.39481860399246216,
0.09656846523284912,
-0.13219907879829407,
-0.4254498779773712,
-0.33817216753959656,
0.4537490904331207,
1.0106528997421265,
0.21380412578582764,
-0.31700053811073303,
-0.07157191634178162,
0.42306920886039734,
0.06534793972969055,
-0.6847708225250244,
-0.08920112252235413,
0.287083238363266,
-0.2154141366481781,
-0.390179842710495,
0.13776153326034546,
-0.5207583904266357,
-0.2460024207830429,
-0.4032042622566223,
0.6489934921264648,
-0.43815481662750244,
-0.20762698352336884,
0.49666473269462585,
-0.3848353326320648,
0.7424335479736328,
0.3027102053165436,
-0.36037302017211914,
0.14284752309322357,
0.7344646453857422,
1.100093960762024,
0.1438906043767929,
-0.4410918056964874,
-0.7486605644226074,
0.002951123518869281,
-0.6483798027038574,
0.6738007068634033,
-0.41590091586112976,
-0.3403005003929138,
0.05043962225317955,
-0.1620820015668869,
-0.06483906507492065,
-0.45130690932273865,
0.40083494782447815,
-0.2804409861564636,
0.005542450118809938,
-0.22035153210163116,
-0.4301997423171997,
-0.16346605122089386,
0.6034933924674988,
-0.33489781618118286,
1.0889912843704224,
0.1507992148399353,
-0.7845230102539062,
0.6092808246612549,
-0.042058687657117844,
-0.056023579090833664,
0.36110976338386536,
-0.5874485373497009,
-0.33523690700531006,
0.6569333076477051,
0.169009268283844,
0.6092207431793213,
-0.2414238452911377,
0.6066867113113403,
-0.2993115186691284,
-0.4594365656375885,
-0.05999275669455528,
-0.025507017970085144,
0.6756452918052673,
-0.2533664107322693,
-0.3146243393421173,
0.07462550699710846,
-0.8875482678413391,
0.26814043521881104,
-0.0454445518553257,
0.21013030409812927,
-0.3953433930873871,
-0.04628036171197891,
-0.4961441159248352,
0.3589046597480774,
-0.07998715341091156,
-0.3237868547439575,
-0.13208907842636108,
0.046624865382909775,
0.13856665790081024,
0.0652398020029068,
0.0027172667905688286,
0.4046367108821869,
-0.15413084626197815,
0.6558783054351807,
-0.11145908385515213,
0.15566755831241608,
-0.5541521310806274,
-0.4971756041049957,
-0.6448391079902649,
-0.42593514919281006,
0.003553183050826192,
0.5723118185997009,
-0.6909571290016174,
0.3599478602409363,
-0.5986464023590088,
-0.6297141313552856,
-0.5044652223587036,
-0.31833502650260925,
0.6924252510070801,
0.711259663105011,
0.2460915595293045,
-0.2835391163825989,
-0.12215621769428253,
-0.7224814891815186,
-0.02701440453529358,
-0.29671040177345276,
-0.22015640139579773,
0.42122340202331543,
0.4131597578525543,
0.13902804255485535,
1.3934459686279297,
-0.43486645817756653,
-0.38837045431137085,
0.07557819783687592,
0.17201051115989685,
0.056171245872974396,
0.4841645061969757,
0.890139102935791,
-0.6608323454856873,
-0.1976407915353775,
-0.004867754876613617,
-1.1044714450836182,
-0.31791844964027405,
-0.1066320613026619,
-0.22513577342033386,
-0.2951284945011139,
0.5415613651275635,
-0.8589611649513245,
0.9441888332366943,
0.5242416858673096,
-0.6175331473350525,
0.8022324442863464,
-0.09669456630945206,
0.2832990884780884,
-0.13402032852172852,
0.05384800583124161,
0.07415061444044113,
-0.25678637623786926,
-0.6602607369422913,
0.5904923677444458,
0.10522304475307465,
-0.3099098801612854,
-0.754408061504364,
0.3842310905456543,
-0.6894912123680115,
-0.6625481247901917,
-0.159646138548851,
0.33106520771980286,
0.20049375295639038,
0.43428388237953186,
0.37086135149002075,
0.9202510714530945,
0.9379782676696777,
-0.7001246809959412,
0.2622741162776947,
0.2743228077888489,
-0.449402391910553,
0.7390050888061523,
-1.010816216468811,
-0.1111760064959526,
-0.3111119866371155,
0.0007285497849807143,
-1.1465049982070923,
0.027494065463542938,
0.08709394186735153,
-0.7805646061897278,
-0.2755773365497589,
-0.5868315696716309,
-0.22523190081119537,
-0.19897712767124176,
-0.24115270376205444,
0.5569611191749573,
0.7260701060295105,
-0.2825942635536194,
0.4804963767528534,
0.2562369704246521,
0.268241286277771,
-0.36678558588027954,
-0.46284982562065125,
0.22771531343460083,
-0.4139888286590576,
-0.6976321339607239,
0.15023013949394226,
0.08015850186347961,
-0.41299304366111755,
-0.022357730194926262,
-0.12059114873409271,
-0.0011218143627047539,
0.06427488476037979,
0.5065943598747253,
0.12189283967018127,
-0.3750392496585846,
-0.03244548663496971,
-0.27319419384002686,
-0.3101040720939636,
0.13716933131217957,
-0.3291303217411041,
0.3510403633117676,
-0.29081329703330994,
-0.372252881526947,
-0.28637808561325073,
0.01696588285267353,
0.7411079406738281,
-0.5012980699539185,
0.7621210217475891,
0.453783243894577,
-0.41810745000839233,
0.25563836097717285,
-0.4753456115722656,
0.17845654487609863,
-0.3824329972267151,
0.2886379063129425,
-0.7500297427177429,
-0.6026461720466614,
0.486531138420105,
0.035957567393779755,
-0.15045806765556335,
0.3505582809448242,
0.3754134476184845,
0.07478533685207367,
0.8335347771644592,
0.7118005752563477,
0.14513206481933594,
0.3227939307689667,
-0.3521897792816162,
-0.03252135589718819,
-0.7419868111610413,
-0.18947871029376984,
-0.31284868717193604,
0.09509474039077759,
-0.09574804455041885,
-0.8582785129547119,
0.11135782301425934,
0.47756248712539673,
-0.07565849274396896,
0.043387170881032944,
-0.20088070631027222,
0.795863926410675,
0.5012410283088684,
-0.0501931868493557,
0.0786411240696907,
0.10419996082782745,
-0.003094771411269903,
-0.2231159508228302,
-0.5695076584815979,
-0.567644476890564,
0.7783534526824951,
0.5020800828933716,
0.4676733613014221,
-0.20838302373886108,
0.1306285560131073,
0.14866065979003906,
-0.05861276388168335,
-0.9453721046447754,
0.6384342312812805,
-0.11278658360242844,
-0.29616543650627136,
-0.4993624687194824,
-0.1235215961933136,
-0.12897440791130066,
0.6134998798370361,
-0.11253305524587631,
-0.6369809508323669,
0.2372063249349594,
0.17258702218532562,
-0.4692451059818268,
0.1880224049091339,
-0.3792371451854706,
0.9796300530433655,
-0.21273955702781677,
-0.38937580585479736,
0.21407011151313782,
-0.7123491764068604,
0.2874685823917389,
0.3764019012451172,
0.1113547682762146,
-0.3859103322029114,
0.07578983157873154,
0.5653417706489563,
-0.21621809899806976,
0.6927981972694397,
-0.47139039635658264,
-0.2086959034204483,
0.3862953186035156,
0.1976936012506485,
0.024926114827394485,
0.11572443693876266,
0.21004895865917206,
0.6114211678504944,
0.02115490287542343,
-0.6472424864768982,
-0.6695237755775452,
0.30574125051498413,
-0.5965896248817444,
-0.5321064591407776,
-0.27980995178222656,
-0.4534507095813751,
-0.47342926263809204,
0.11477494239807129,
0.4584335386753082,
0.5714424252510071,
-0.17936664819717407,
0.37796229124069214,
0.6418069005012512,
-0.23763838410377502,
0.17234507203102112,
0.3536345660686493,
-0.4813096821308136,
-0.4255407750606537,
0.9484388828277588,
-0.0983978733420372,
0.4338914155960083,
0.40788525342941284,
0.04492322355508804,
-0.006561703514307737,
-0.6568523645401001,
-0.5026549696922302,
0.22743190824985504,
-0.7375961542129517,
-0.1916433721780777,
-0.6492188572883606,
-0.07111004739999771,
-0.3935929238796234,
-0.3174923062324524,
-0.22527936100959778,
-0.35469216108322144,
-0.10012231022119522,
-0.506051778793335,
0.14261379837989807,
0.16732850670814514,
0.036551639437675476,
0.8549312353134155,
-0.6311866044998169,
0.5639601945877075,
0.33193135261535645,
0.36299052834510803,
-0.34752899408340454,
-0.6362671852111816,
-0.22997944056987762,
0.19929321110248566,
0.14656001329421997,
-0.8917329907417297,
0.35728123784065247,
0.39945581555366516,
0.4801759421825409,
0.41104650497436523,
-0.1320931613445282,
1.0526665449142456,
-0.630547046661377,
1.0246219635009766,
0.20853297412395477,
-1.1102728843688965,
0.7378779649734497,
-0.42651253938674927,
0.2961715757846832,
0.655890166759491,
0.0795171782374382,
-0.31143420934677124,
-0.3779250681400299,
-0.48382267355918884,
-0.6226589679718018,
0.4158995747566223,
0.22321206331253052,
0.0200742706656456,
0.16391733288764954,
0.4402158558368683,
-0.24703261256217957,
0.3969527781009674,
-0.4554142951965332,
-0.12843254208564758,
-0.3382049798965454,
-0.041304949671030045,
-0.3518679141998291,
-0.5715610980987549,
-0.2482953816652298,
-0.2712349593639374,
0.2443617284297943,
-0.12463928014039993,
0.1523088812828064,
0.16944192349910736,
-0.4263923466205597,
-0.005760430358350277,
-0.20005489885807037,
0.7292384505271912,
0.7329562902450562,
-0.5167042016983032,
0.29109203815460205,
-0.11505180597305298,
-0.5611376166343689,
0.2251560539007187,
-0.3494665026664734,
-0.3851993978023529,
0.5958380103111267,
0.5618203282356262,
1.0711687803268433,
0.11510773003101349,
-0.8615716099739075,
0.8390375971794128,
0.05785168334841728,
-0.2564871311187744,
-0.10020401328802109,
-0.04922796040773392,
-0.5632893443107605,
-0.022926708683371544,
0.2653285264968872,
-0.32316750288009644,
0.14276377856731415,
-0.2793957591056824,
0.40635690093040466,
0.4603399932384491,
-0.6903817057609558,
-0.39780059456825256,
0.45645469427108765,
0.055476777255535126,
-0.1554369479417801,
0.3388262987136841,
-0.20862793922424316,
-0.6500675678253174,
0.8826735019683838,
0.36098891496658325,
0.8541935086250305,
0.0346800722181797,
0.567021369934082,
0.41373082995414734,
0.4645572304725647,
-0.018982134759426117,
0.08775487542152405,
-0.029945766553282738,
-0.7314718961715698,
-0.39186322689056396,
-0.36227384209632874,
-0.30322661995887756,
0.1128557100892067,
-0.9858231544494629,
0.3400099575519562,
-0.550255298614502,
-0.17859208583831787,
-0.41727012395858765,
-0.16474588215351105,
-0.746802031993866,
0.6881022453308105,
0.14277085661888123,
0.836749792098999,
-1.2192809581756592,
0.4307065010070801,
0.9789796471595764,
-0.24575765430927277,
-0.39070063829421997,
0.0007195898215286434,
-0.23938237130641937,
-0.7692974805831909,
0.90103679895401,
0.4145691394805908,
-0.3366726040840149,
0.0860883966088295,
-0.5545161962509155,
-0.6624364256858826,
1.078893780708313,
0.41686463356018066,
-0.32542917132377625,
0.052718788385391235,
0.15015040338039398,
0.47982046008110046,
-0.4496367871761322,
0.38854482769966125,
0.6030345559120178,
0.05152006074786186,
0.256467342376709,
-0.6372373104095459,
-0.3640713095664978,
-0.1635577529668808,
0.12583039700984955,
0.04949220269918442,
-0.3338855803012848,
0.7863667011260986,
-0.20605997741222382,
-0.2946997284889221,
-0.15409564971923828,
0.6875474452972412,
0.4761269688606262,
0.6009530425071716,
0.4592271149158478,
0.826432466506958,
0.39597275853157043,
-0.13050462305545807,
0.7659620642662048,
-0.4688417911529541,
0.5163640975952148,
1.1873000860214233,
-0.23199962079524994,
0.7140149474143982,
0.47363418340682983,
-0.0981164500117302,
-0.045491237193346024,
0.2685542702674866,
0.006397499702870846,
0.7237712144851685,
0.271846204996109,
-0.11143552511930466,
-0.48619091510772705,
-0.2801584005355835,
-0.46029555797576904,
0.3232950270175934,
0.33209091424942017,
0.0991973876953125,
-0.35999631881713867,
0.30503371357917786,
-0.2511366903781891,
0.084492027759552,
-0.3993840217590332,
0.6099751591682434,
-0.182573139667511,
-0.34289252758026123,
0.6318923234939575,
-0.14538882672786713,
0.33622509241104126,
-0.3741258680820465,
-0.18040339648723602,
-0.5107917785644531,
-0.16279113292694092,
-0.017762910574674606,
-0.7218345999717712,
0.11818743497133255,
0.15665395557880402,
0.023414548486471176,
0.03664498031139374,
0.6128015518188477,
-0.22876110672950745,
-0.43216925859451294,
0.16575953364372253,
0.5158703923225403,
0.3912506103515625,
-0.2880142331123352,
-0.4500044286251068,
0.27207884192466736,
-0.24328210949897766,
0.11972373723983765,
0.1262202113866806,
0.8536691665649414,
-0.03037990815937519,
0.8272351622581482,
0.47999101877212524,
0.22084598243236542,
0.4098498225212097,
0.13148991763591766,
0.6757290959358215,
-0.7579548358917236,
-0.5371630191802979,
-0.8215003609657288,
0.697232186794281,
0.06214014068245888,
-0.4831368923187256,
0.7909080386161804,
0.3745194673538208,
0.8133066892623901,
-0.3359552323818207,
0.5970817804336548,
0.06564165651798248,
0.1157841607928276,
-0.7330349087715149,
0.19873477518558502,
-0.36687546968460083,
-0.008618982508778572,
-0.366062194108963,
-1.0058255195617676,
-0.5952633023262024,
0.9122081398963928,
-0.4682596027851105,
-0.3157435655593872,
0.4697355031967163,
0.44545242190361023,
-0.06110292673110962,
-0.6667559146881104,
1.118277907371521,
-0.07665033638477325,
0.3167244791984558,
0.3438347280025482,
0.931020200252533,
-0.5070781707763672,
0.20648998022079468,
-0.3100326657295227,
-0.4918881058692932,
-0.1936502456665039,
-1.0568921566009521,
-1.0848684310913086,
-0.3335098624229431,
-0.6800493001937866,
-0.01425959262996912,
0.2302900105714798,
0.20870286226272583,
0.8248574733734131,
-0.5642290115356445,
-0.110733263194561,
-0.32586467266082764,
-0.17631545662879944,
-0.16877399384975433,
-0.18703344464302063,
0.2277982532978058,
-0.2925582230091095,
-0.3232974112033844,
0.06694117933511734,
0.355987012386322,
0.270719975233078,
-0.30594778060913086,
0.03372570127248764,
0.09311103075742722,
-0.045928217470645905,
0.6895433068275452,
0.24463433027267456,
-0.7658734321594238,
-0.3049495220184326,
0.0792260393500328,
-0.025273378938436508,
-0.09676197916269302,
0.7769225239753723,
-1.0800381898880005,
0.38256925344467163,
0.3855130076408386,
0.6633040308952332,
-0.08043424785137177,
0.442849725484848,
0.5648370385169983,
-0.7076528668403625,
0.6762397289276123,
0.03740738332271576,
0.22042115032672882,
0.3430405855178833,
-0.1592579334974289,
0.7429026365280151,
0.2851707637310028,
-0.2990509867668152,
-1.0285813808441162,
0.015681687742471695,
-0.7968774437904358,
0.15244480967521667,
1.173220157623291,
-0.560322642326355,
-0.14588871598243713,
0.2756061851978302,
-0.39363324642181396,
-0.043408069759607315,
0.10469058901071548,
0.5288436412811279,
0.771256148815155,
0.3785642981529236,
-0.41111624240875244,
-0.8122766017913818,
0.37281081080436707,
0.5083956122398376,
-0.5421419143676758,
-0.015723146498203278,
0.8604834675788879,
-0.012758616358041763,
0.21824012696743011,
0.5945484638214111,
-0.01951899379491806,
0.3646315336227417,
0.102023184299469,
0.09025868028402328,
-0.14299620687961578,
-0.6801244020462036,
-0.6570643186569214,
0.20363983511924744,
0.08719850331544876,
-0.734082043170929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19124v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19124v2
|
Accelerating Production LLMs with Combined Token/Embedding Speculators
| 2024-04-29T21:59:07 | 2024-06-06T18:38:34 |
Davis Wertheimer, Joshua Rosenkranz, Thomas Parnell, Sahil Suneja, Pavithra Ranganathan, Raghu Ganti, Mudhakar Srivatsa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This technical report describes the design and training of novel speculative
decoding draft models, for accelerating the inference speeds of large language
models in a production environment. By conditioning draft predictions on both
context vectors and sampled tokens, we can train our speculators to efficiently
predict high-quality n-grams, which the base model then accepts or rejects.
This allows us to effectively predict multiple tokens per inference forward
pass, accelerating wall-clock inference speeds of highly optimized base model
implementations by a factor of 2-3x. We explore these initial results and
describe next steps for further improvements.
|
[
-0.35073745250701904,
-0.6542216539382935,
0.5164082646369934,
0.3884156048297882,
-0.25507640838623047,
0.3846502900123596,
-0.1050347089767456,
-0.729708731174469,
0.49466222524642944,
0.6145845055580139,
-0.46741387248039246,
-0.3461988866329193,
-0.7657126188278198,
0.08475311845541,
-0.600648045539856,
0.6775527000427246,
-0.1884234994649887,
0.15280720591545105,
-0.01044787559658289,
0.31616973876953125,
-0.11180263012647629,
-0.7094874382019043,
-0.6858285069465637,
-0.20395848155021667,
0.31845006346702576,
0.3829602599143982,
0.5409335494041443,
0.9222871661186218,
0.3320208489894867,
0.2857421040534973,
-0.3384420573711395,
0.35761237144470215,
-0.49631360173225403,
0.27531367540359497,
0.2857663035392761,
-0.4458586871623993,
-0.7974216938018799,
0.0025088698603212833,
0.5780320167541504,
0.5611701607704163,
0.06814230978488922,
0.16271257400512695,
-0.29603660106658936,
0.22166158258914948,
-0.7538043856620789,
-0.037315044552087784,
-0.5753900408744812,
0.26247143745422363,
-0.070462167263031,
-0.509675145149231,
-0.967971682548523,
-0.19617906212806702,
-0.11109500378370285,
-0.8124895691871643,
0.4819711148738861,
0.38018593192100525,
0.5267022252082825,
0.0005098883993923664,
-0.37067529559135437,
-0.11012499779462814,
-0.6218428611755371,
0.8418225049972534,
-0.7137794494628906,
0.45336201786994934,
0.2775895297527313,
0.23509417474269867,
-0.26623931527137756,
-1.1073408126831055,
-0.1029789000749588,
-0.18085530400276184,
0.11186131089925766,
0.22611290216445923,
0.10223262012004852,
0.32298362255096436,
0.4338921010494232,
0.5918236970901489,
-0.13658034801483154,
0.3074825406074524,
-0.4271858334541321,
-0.5058107376098633,
0.5168554782867432,
0.38009166717529297,
-0.03148799389600754,
0.12132056802511215,
-0.5009232759475708,
0.05499688908457756,
-0.5940558910369873,
-0.32952427864074707,
0.5237328410148621,
0.09772168844938278,
-0.1014842689037323,
0.5088196396827698,
-0.42470303177833557,
0.7025458216667175,
0.10210191458463669,
0.09637407213449478,
0.2972520887851715,
-0.5247766971588135,
-0.3586404323577881,
0.005247798748314381,
0.3214801251888275,
0.46035897731781006,
-0.13709066808223724,
-0.4001447558403015,
-0.46555444598197937,
0.43971389532089233,
0.0677359402179718,
-1.1520968675613403,
-0.030448008328676224,
0.2943473160266876,
-0.41368889808654785,
-0.3369036614894867,
-0.07865963876247406,
-0.7585752010345459,
-0.3531568646430969,
-0.08831700682640076,
0.1896675080060959,
-0.32076558470726013,
-0.4934026002883911,
0.33279871940612793,
-0.7948861122131348,
0.29402193427085876,
0.16299405694007874,
-1.211862564086914,
0.2789815664291382,
0.8095207214355469,
0.8495575785636902,
-0.12774276733398438,
-0.1789369434118271,
-0.8041657209396362,
0.19413520395755768,
-0.6483874320983887,
1.0532859563827515,
-0.4689958095550537,
-0.6768214702606201,
-0.00482933409512043,
-0.22572678327560425,
0.04415976256132126,
-0.355971097946167,
0.9169895648956299,
-0.7346977591514587,
-0.22449052333831787,
-0.2852475643157959,
-0.9055834412574768,
-0.004968967754393816,
0.3021548092365265,
-0.5987054705619812,
0.9119585156440735,
0.09480109810829163,
-0.7133121490478516,
0.7282971143722534,
-0.4764508605003357,
-0.30097222328186035,
0.05730607733130455,
-0.03527488559484482,
-0.018335895612835884,
0.42897504568099976,
0.26176121830940247,
0.5921605229377747,
-0.22720471024513245,
-0.049935564398765564,
-0.3278355896472931,
-0.8222208619117737,
0.22595323622226715,
-0.31657078862190247,
0.21030959486961365,
0.40973666310310364,
0.08112015575170517,
0.27581822872161865,
-0.8433162569999695,
0.06006724759936333,
-0.09958165884017944,
-0.6842701435089111,
0.09831799566745758,
-0.05892038345336914,
0.08132977038621902,
-0.0863083153963089,
0.07752512395381927,
-0.6102724671363831,
0.03903328254818916,
-0.3709561824798584,
0.5954501628875732,
0.7440209984779358,
0.08828628808259964,
0.5611713528633118,
-0.28097784519195557,
0.7022637128829956,
0.04925176501274109,
0.1289965659379959,
-0.45079904794692993,
-0.46569132804870605,
-0.9602769017219543,
-0.2949400544166565,
0.3254922330379486,
0.19946996867656708,
-0.5403595566749573,
0.04733814671635628,
-0.2047717422246933,
-0.32398825883865356,
-0.44580724835395813,
0.1063336730003357,
0.3700586259365082,
0.17554867267608643,
-0.021650776267051697,
-0.28575584292411804,
-1.094456672668457,
-0.8150011897087097,
-0.3641194701194763,
0.09205476194620132,
0.09079685807228088,
-0.27414584159851074,
0.2646169066429138,
-0.2493501901626587,
0.5649482011795044,
-0.39355695247650146,
0.3807803988456726,
-0.3320003151893616,
0.4057295322418213,
0.40356385707855225,
0.3707980513572693,
0.42757922410964966,
-0.4150000512599945,
-0.3091277778148651,
-0.1486768275499344,
-0.659376859664917,
0.0452701710164547,
0.21772706508636475,
-0.35156676173210144,
0.2860916554927826,
0.959109365940094,
-0.5648928284645081,
0.14101135730743408,
0.7071521282196045,
-0.5362073183059692,
0.6946344971656799,
-0.13059712946414948,
-0.01379651390016079,
-1.1444321870803833,
-0.35841867327690125,
0.07648865133523941,
-0.3236446976661682,
-0.8297572135925293,
0.14630664885044098,
0.1285189837217331,
0.10419829934835434,
-0.6400332450866699,
0.42535170912742615,
-0.8510454297065735,
-0.31883570551872253,
-0.47461095452308655,
0.08715386688709259,
0.14145559072494507,
0.2556484341621399,
-0.02785654179751873,
1.1698369979858398,
0.5576565861701965,
-0.7215827107429504,
-0.017952963709831238,
0.06722134351730347,
-0.5266722440719604,
0.0654148980975151,
-0.43145978450775146,
0.3496394753456116,
-0.01762954331934452,
0.36394670605659485,
-0.8225549459457397,
-0.21117490530014038,
-0.05732983350753784,
-0.5221209526062012,
0.23441438376903534,
-0.18442995846271515,
-0.6752639412879944,
-0.551018238067627,
-0.2586687207221985,
0.15931124985218048,
0.5854450464248657,
-0.4984022080898285,
0.7943598031997681,
0.28600361943244934,
0.39839446544647217,
-0.6105999946594238,
-1.1037189960479736,
0.059328969568014145,
-0.08894885331392288,
-0.6330601572990417,
0.4922354221343994,
-0.13507559895515442,
-0.32959800958633423,
0.01531311310827732,
-0.04586333408951759,
0.14991651475429535,
0.19795332849025726,
0.2612701952457428,
0.20234087109565735,
-0.35631775856018066,
-0.04536712169647217,
-0.015515532344579697,
-0.3265211582183838,
0.17395739257335663,
-0.5447995066642761,
0.5215127468109131,
0.03426949679851532,
-0.12843795120716095,
-0.30895528197288513,
0.334421306848526,
0.5813260078430176,
0.1832207888364792,
0.8465299010276794,
0.7350698709487915,
-0.26692166924476624,
-0.3113897442817688,
-0.7488101720809937,
-0.1931294947862625,
-0.5605142116546631,
0.5307302474975586,
-0.5519004464149475,
-0.7697396278381348,
0.760293185710907,
-0.13544681668281555,
0.16558557748794556,
0.4755716919898987,
0.6770408749580383,
0.36371931433677673,
1.2879003286361694,
0.6919589042663574,
0.0525042898952961,
0.5647652745246887,
-0.5751054286956787,
0.06460443884134293,
-0.9554112553596497,
-0.12765106558799744,
-0.22006306052207947,
-0.22122177481651306,
-0.45241978764533997,
-0.846114456653595,
0.06531809270381927,
0.16849645972251892,
-0.19010810554027557,
0.11364110559225082,
-0.283207505941391,
0.5838174223899841,
0.6254590749740601,
0.09005772322416306,
0.27256566286087036,
0.03949835151433945,
-0.45269471406936646,
0.2909701466560364,
-0.6911847591400146,
-0.42856156826019287,
1.3179017305374146,
0.45651310682296753,
0.6351701021194458,
-0.13811832666397095,
0.5735442042350769,
0.24941371381282806,
0.5789878964424133,
-0.8196216821670532,
0.5788496136665344,
-0.20291505753993988,
-0.8265625834465027,
0.15298016369342804,
-0.1129717007279396,
-0.27967649698257446,
0.24764341115951538,
-0.17948144674301147,
-0.6347782611846924,
0.1312883049249649,
0.16393104195594788,
-0.3288629651069641,
0.5258084535598755,
-1.0192240476608276,
0.41029229760169983,
-0.013369009830057621,
-0.39207109808921814,
-0.4172050654888153,
-0.13735246658325195,
0.6173495054244995,
0.10280496627092361,
0.07732495665550232,
-0.36707913875579834,
-0.15448811650276184,
0.8916073441505432,
-0.23103506863117218,
0.9382214546203613,
-0.3022395670413971,
-0.009493757970631123,
0.3889157176017761,
0.0026780301705002785,
0.5571421384811401,
-0.06140376627445221,
-0.6845464110374451,
-0.03604938089847565,
-0.2369387298822403,
-0.550354540348053,
-0.2739047408103943,
0.6205379962921143,
-0.8190235495567322,
-0.7439039349555969,
-0.09881439059972763,
-0.7160008549690247,
-0.27584272623062134,
-0.048951297998428345,
0.4406302571296692,
0.41162288188934326,
-0.20761986076831818,
0.13616448640823364,
0.265840083360672,
0.13540157675743103,
0.5256124138832092,
0.36720821261405945,
-0.23922774195671082,
-0.5673546195030212,
0.4746239483356476,
0.10072865337133408,
0.5594282746315002,
0.27742859721183777,
-0.06262347102165222,
-0.2652961313724518,
-1.0084203481674194,
-0.4178246259689331,
0.006060668732970953,
-0.9632306694984436,
-0.23552978038787842,
-0.7570009827613831,
-0.47144806385040283,
-0.3561316728591919,
-0.17654219269752502,
-0.3311997056007385,
-0.5543121695518494,
-0.35865989327430725,
-0.6713623404502869,
0.5595507621765137,
0.8471828699111938,
-0.06830582767724991,
0.6900736093521118,
-0.6733716726303101,
0.13154643774032593,
-0.031951699405908585,
0.4637848734855652,
0.174683079123497,
-0.8476821780204773,
-0.6804718375205994,
-0.07540949434041977,
-0.3514974117279053,
-0.6132662892341614,
0.37768539786338806,
-0.029005562886595726,
0.7522678375244141,
0.6838560700416565,
-0.21402108669281006,
0.7048417329788208,
-0.32819879055023193,
0.7089987993240356,
0.23627468943595886,
-1.017350196838379,
0.33090740442276,
-0.35597559809684753,
0.05761205032467842,
0.23760592937469482,
0.08936357498168945,
-0.3787732720375061,
-0.4100272059440613,
-0.3475734293460846,
-0.8510091304779053,
0.5932382345199585,
-0.05189837887883186,
0.27099764347076416,
-0.3168809711933136,
0.5709432363510132,
0.29983699321746826,
0.026284271851181984,
-0.20121100544929504,
-0.18426375091075897,
0.04732205346226692,
0.18034890294075012,
-0.21836920082569122,
-0.8337226510047913,
0.014779960736632347,
-0.272050142288208,
0.6802193522453308,
-0.25566187500953674,
0.5730746388435364,
0.1526111662387848,
0.017452089115977287,
-0.34288540482521057,
0.048535317182540894,
0.5147480964660645,
0.7277733087539673,
-0.5220891833305359,
0.0869579166173935,
0.482075572013855,
-0.3573896884918213,
0.16309799253940582,
-0.09516917914152145,
0.05522069334983826,
-0.12443898618221283,
0.3633192479610443,
1.2085682153701782,
0.3664044141769409,
-0.46156007051467896,
0.09410453587770462,
-0.20258352160453796,
-0.6623539924621582,
-0.40452519059181213,
0.18312254548072815,
0.30578622221946716,
0.44541803002357483,
0.5246912837028503,
0.15598374605178833,
0.10316495597362518,
-0.48907744884490967,
0.2634681761264801,
0.29473552107810974,
-0.1514500230550766,
-0.5030742287635803,
0.8254164457321167,
0.2993607223033905,
-0.16527310013771057,
0.4827767610549927,
-0.3754957914352417,
-0.47388744354248047,
0.8357335925102234,
0.914283275604248,
1.0409576892852783,
0.11513277888298035,
0.032655440270900726,
0.26207566261291504,
0.08387923985719681,
-0.370145708322525,
0.5503600835800171,
0.13178189098834991,
-1.0943843126296997,
-0.7430660128593445,
-0.7726597785949707,
-0.7441702485084534,
-0.1537294238805771,
-0.6014186143875122,
0.2249891757965088,
-0.657539427280426,
-0.5729665160179138,
-0.03494312986731529,
0.1806059032678604,
-0.8361232876777649,
0.04254225641489029,
0.5674623847007751,
1.4576832056045532,
-0.8492514491081238,
0.934814989566803,
0.5524914860725403,
-0.18546368181705475,
-0.6978249549865723,
-0.058784693479537964,
-0.22969798743724823,
-0.9874832034111023,
0.8116568922996521,
0.2976607084274292,
-0.23041017353534698,
0.18929363787174225,
-0.3438478410243988,
-0.9411495327949524,
1.3138270378112793,
0.40663373470306396,
-0.5662491321563721,
0.023041019216179848,
-0.217238649725914,
0.47285792231559753,
-0.6863312721252441,
0.465970516204834,
0.8544742465019226,
0.4102858304977417,
0.17856740951538086,
-0.4172890782356262,
0.0765373557806015,
-0.3275119364261627,
0.021322166547179222,
0.20299366116523743,
-0.8117836117744446,
0.9497731328010559,
-0.18586848676204681,
-0.2924841642379761,
0.38106387853622437,
0.9955795407295227,
0.5114867091178894,
0.29805880784988403,
0.4391005039215088,
0.7112417817115784,
0.6564767360687256,
-0.028400225564837456,
1.1933097839355469,
-0.7540456056594849,
-0.01444602757692337,
0.7870181798934937,
-0.28619763255119324,
0.9448525905609131,
0.673403263092041,
-0.0880926325917244,
0.5839855670928955,
0.7743483185768127,
0.050375912338495255,
0.34653139114379883,
0.264279305934906,
-0.35203543305397034,
-0.2632408142089844,
-0.4842560589313507,
-0.36218729615211487,
0.2594827711582184,
0.6573467254638672,
-0.6156554222106934,
0.16909544169902802,
-0.3437495827674866,
-0.16679640114307404,
-0.09773033112287521,
-0.4110524356365204,
0.4109359383583069,
0.2124893069267273,
-0.608751654624939,
0.5923473238945007,
0.295930415391922,
0.9547567963600159,
-0.4739466905593872,
0.3990829288959503,
-0.29312586784362793,
0.36325621604919434,
0.029272081330418587,
-0.5335875749588013,
0.29166603088378906,
-0.11389917135238647,
-0.18278872966766357,
-0.38593295216560364,
0.6078639626502991,
-0.037606943398714066,
-0.7389596104621887,
0.773899257183075,
0.46851131319999695,
0.004584393464028835,
0.10910986363887787,
-0.2554360628128052,
0.34529608488082886,
-0.3400328457355499,
-0.4754265546798706,
0.1665002554655075,
0.42409080266952515,
0.11540789902210236,
0.511675238609314,
0.7759919166564941,
0.1792275458574295,
0.3990424871444702,
0.31059056520462036,
1.0706217288970947,
-0.8483197093009949,
-0.6471607685089111,
-0.8366162180900574,
0.32717165350914,
-0.061614204198122025,
-0.18485479056835175,
0.7950961589813232,
0.6258541345596313,
0.5676273703575134,
-0.12014610320329666,
0.7755405306816101,
0.3895203173160553,
0.2981407642364502,
-0.8180330395698547,
0.24116858839988708,
-0.18383292853832245,
0.16583094000816345,
0.14947040379047394,
-0.7219365835189819,
-0.09102661162614822,
-0.0975993275642395,
-0.20474527776241302,
0.01379862055182457,
0.7672033905982971,
0.8878559470176697,
0.04034869000315666,
0.23663607239723206,
0.4144904613494873,
0.3577066659927368,
0.2943135201931,
0.6611584424972534,
1.0810589790344238,
-0.565666913986206,
0.48683542013168335,
-0.32052868604660034,
0.09394317120313644,
-0.36866995692253113,
-1.092545986175537,
-0.9462025761604309,
-0.13849639892578125,
-0.11380165070295334,
-0.360506534576416,
0.12045975029468536,
0.8008918762207031,
1.102979302406311,
-0.6803868412971497,
-0.33702853322029114,
-0.29994356632232666,
-0.12950043380260468,
-0.21698160469532013,
-0.1912575215101242,
0.1019473746418953,
-0.4119703769683838,
-0.8478284478187561,
0.77290278673172,
0.25524991750717163,
0.1894887238740921,
-0.4872702956199646,
-0.21811909973621368,
-0.028324468061327934,
0.33692336082458496,
0.5196757912635803,
-0.1664613038301468,
-0.6657606363296509,
-0.07379349321126938,
0.08423641324043274,
0.05579384043812752,
-0.0011053576599806547,
1.0858724117279053,
-0.770844042301178,
0.21736286580562592,
0.8001811504364014,
0.5100032091140747,
0.8374395370483398,
0.04572069272398949,
0.970553994178772,
-0.8058261275291443,
0.7292240262031555,
-0.00751528050750494,
0.4804060757160187,
0.25599950551986694,
-0.646120548248291,
0.37989622354507446,
0.17233292758464813,
-0.28677359223365784,
-0.9535119533538818,
0.1572951078414917,
-0.6347948908805847,
-0.13523682951927185,
1.0794212818145752,
-0.10942242294549942,
-0.5054209232330322,
0.19140712916851044,
0.17261876165866852,
0.4268702566623688,
-0.5456699728965759,
0.4531592130661011,
0.5915536880493164,
0.0818411111831665,
-0.08230826258659363,
-0.8719753623008728,
0.40335503220558167,
0.47477155923843384,
-0.4553534686565399,
0.11687611043453217,
0.24880734086036682,
0.11798784136772156,
0.061689361929893494,
0.7110788822174072,
-0.0031964874360710382,
0.1799958348274231,
0.7071013450622559,
0.005260984878987074,
-0.2797314524650574,
-0.23591655492782593,
-0.12614981830120087,
0.14657004177570343,
0.333199143409729,
-0.3600344657897949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19119v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19119v1
|
Effects of Added Emphasis and Pause in Audio Delivery of Health Information
| 2024-04-29T21:36:16 | 2024-04-29T21:36:16 |
Arif Ahmed, Gondy Leroy, Stephen A. Rains, Philip Harber, David Kauchak, Prosanta Barai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Health literacy is crucial to supporting good health and is a major national
goal. Audio delivery of information is becoming more popular for informing
oneself. In this study, we evaluate the effect of audio enhancements in the
form of information emphasis and pauses with health texts of varying difficulty
and we measure health information comprehension and retention. We produced
audio snippets from difficult and easy text and conducted the study on Amazon
Mechanical Turk (AMT). Our findings suggest that emphasis matters for both
information comprehension and retention. When there is no added pause,
emphasizing significant information can lower the perceived difficulty for
difficult and easy texts. Comprehension is higher (54%) with correctly placed
emphasis for the difficult texts compared to not adding emphasis (50%). Adding
a pause lowers perceived difficulty and can improve retention but adversely
affects information comprehension.
|
[
-0.11399951577186584,
-0.8052286505699158,
0.7437981367111206,
0.4145272374153137,
-0.4024597406387329,
-0.30436620116233826,
-0.3331761658191681,
-0.7424671053886414,
0.5865760445594788,
0.2444211095571518,
-0.22218674421310425,
-0.2687253952026367,
-0.9785991311073303,
0.22403018176555634,
-0.31491538882255554,
1.2281466722488403,
0.25416165590286255,
0.1172725036740303,
-0.004008082672953606,
-0.22263522446155548,
-0.8686041831970215,
-0.34546220302581787,
-0.5043913722038269,
-0.17800167202949524,
0.5215699076652527,
0.5407465100288391,
0.9514846801757812,
0.9043794870376587,
0.614407479763031,
0.24128367006778717,
-0.6158517003059387,
-0.3190447986125946,
-0.23269358277320862,
0.42833632230758667,
0.005319660529494286,
-0.34040698409080505,
-0.3070448040962219,
-0.1456480622291565,
0.7605456113815308,
0.7773803472518921,
-0.01405154075473547,
0.19100068509578705,
0.29391658306121826,
0.8141876459121704,
-0.7378284335136414,
-0.20043706893920898,
0.008879724889993668,
0.11920437216758728,
-0.17083533108234406,
-0.7716740965843201,
-0.2340487539768219,
0.005604059901088476,
0.6738007068634033,
-0.8154797554016113,
-0.20666968822479248,
-0.12209974974393845,
0.7696631550788879,
0.8434256911277771,
-0.5479594469070435,
-0.6238842010498047,
-1.0929683446884155,
0.6239908337593079,
-0.47796696424484253,
0.628166675567627,
0.6475505828857422,
-0.21425369381904602,
-0.055003486573696136,
-0.4812992811203003,
-0.3435310423374176,
0.20995816588401794,
0.06241755932569504,
0.3829815983772278,
-0.11346377432346344,
0.29172787070274353,
0.39346078038215637,
0.44583234190940857,
0.010205881670117378,
-0.08049130439758301,
-0.6232252717018127,
0.1042359247803688,
0.4336696267127991,
-0.055395618081092834,
0.5078825950622559,
-0.47967663407325745,
-0.0838380977511406,
0.024132827296853065,
-0.43831828236579895,
0.39679816365242004,
0.2875989079475403,
0.08245324343442917,
0.058653831481933594,
0.7085161805152893,
-0.30350902676582336,
0.17340438067913055,
0.22450627386569977,
-0.818917453289032,
0.3893708288669586,
-0.5195667743682861,
-0.12095344066619873,
0.4314165413379669,
0.35679271817207336,
0.42812973260879517,
-0.08700016885995865,
0.22778290510177612,
0.17122167348861694,
-0.3584463596343994,
0.3824200928211212,
-0.6103917956352234,
-0.044229473918676376,
0.5934847593307495,
-0.9075492024421692,
0.07490267604589462,
-0.18569163978099823,
-0.5554788112640381,
-0.4657359719276428,
-0.3163732588291168,
0.5420666337013245,
-0.6298117637634277,
-0.023098427802324295,
0.2721922695636749,
-0.46752312779426575,
-0.2031317502260208,
0.3809156119823456,
-0.8510084748268127,
0.36994248628616333,
0.27112194895744324,
0.7948195338249207,
-0.3147431015968323,
0.10683242976665497,
-0.3537275493144989,
0.27133709192276,
0.008409128524363041,
0.7959355711936951,
-0.2987986207008362,
-0.532673180103302,
0.0002658584853634238,
0.1543809473514557,
-0.20552988350391388,
-0.5026779770851135,
1.1085323095321655,
-0.05453624203801155,
0.06946253776550293,
-0.3659933805465698,
-0.6877440810203552,
-0.2699930965900421,
-0.040850523859262466,
-0.848840594291687,
0.9172300100326538,
-0.1142786294221878,
-1.114888072013855,
0.46781429648399353,
-0.4623095393180847,
-0.9840719103813171,
-0.20442712306976318,
-0.11559762805700302,
-0.4836783707141876,
-0.10765130072832108,
0.3492264449596405,
-0.010808104649186134,
0.14310473203659058,
-0.2175564467906952,
0.1459071934223175,
-0.7885575294494629,
0.7331848740577698,
-0.5642899870872498,
0.40537309646606445,
-0.11565829813480377,
-0.8373483419418335,
-0.09217885881662369,
-0.5121934413909912,
-0.07442539930343628,
-0.20664404332637787,
-0.8062956929206848,
-0.572533369064331,
0.1245281919836998,
0.09756988286972046,
-0.05310207977890968,
-0.15337657928466797,
-0.3148893117904663,
-0.11861134320497513,
-0.2878039479255676,
0.2241177260875702,
0.28653019666671753,
0.5315702557563782,
0.08917011320590973,
-0.7301140427589417,
0.5422850847244263,
-0.04497412219643593,
0.3934450149536133,
-0.4912855923175812,
-0.789992094039917,
-0.5014090538024902,
-0.3684784471988678,
0.29861941933631897,
0.8637565970420837,
-0.26875317096710205,
0.11744004487991333,
-0.06031126528978348,
0.02165846712887287,
-1.0545347929000854,
0.08006008714437485,
0.3696630299091339,
0.5468869209289551,
0.6782166361808777,
-0.30797624588012695,
-0.23296575248241425,
-0.706283688545227,
-0.2866074740886688,
0.002910334151238203,
-0.2018386572599411,
0.674166202545166,
-0.035018134862184525,
-0.19300875067710876,
0.3624466061592102,
-0.2883499264717102,
-0.39676177501678467,
0.0013669715262949467,
0.1267206221818924,
0.07398936152458191,
0.45099300146102905,
0.18108759820461273,
-0.8268949389457703,
-0.1770494133234024,
-0.4399303197860718,
-0.19050756096839905,
-0.14953044056892395,
-0.20726829767227173,
0.11577808856964111,
-0.25020790100097656,
0.18619734048843384,
-0.5314036011695862,
0.7711792588233948,
0.1561119705438614,
-0.27654391527175903,
0.644306480884552,
-0.22416502237319946,
0.8876268267631531,
-0.5786918997764587,
-0.014092576690018177,
-0.19551271200180054,
0.05798106640577316,
-0.7729328274726868,
-0.5049400925636292,
-0.15372781455516815,
0.0028973885346204042,
-0.4689736068248749,
0.21877378225326538,
-0.42889782786369324,
-0.038333892822265625,
-0.5352857708930969,
0.15112607181072235,
0.48448386788368225,
-0.023457299917936325,
0.0843723937869072,
0.7496532201766968,
0.10960429161787033,
-0.8121658563613892,
-0.21918348968029022,
0.32528993487358093,
-0.3348689675331116,
0.8913149237632751,
-0.8268280625343323,
0.09826812148094177,
-0.1143135130405426,
0.2308160960674286,
-0.9466711282730103,
-0.5789749622344971,
0.10849983990192413,
-0.43580305576324463,
0.3834782838821411,
0.11913224309682846,
-0.18590500950813293,
-0.3505190312862396,
-0.34898966550827026,
0.584480345249176,
0.43816474080085754,
-0.056396327912807465,
-0.058586783707141876,
0.5931341052055359,
-0.4749066233634949,
-0.6136338114738464,
-0.852115273475647,
-0.11026350408792496,
-0.4841462969779968,
-0.42834141850471497,
0.45028194785118103,
-0.23399195075035095,
-0.2803373336791992,
0.14219941198825836,
-0.2975984811782837,
-0.4084796607494354,
0.25826239585876465,
0.47094589471817017,
-0.1163829118013382,
-0.03699760138988495,
0.7230277061462402,
0.3048984408378601,
0.024075224995613098,
-0.05299963057041168,
-0.09670604765415192,
0.005659237504005432,
0.14273770153522491,
-0.292998731136322,
-1.0937957763671875,
0.7613059878349304,
0.4855189919471741,
-0.008250732906162739,
0.680302619934082,
0.4476768970489502,
-0.3481205105781555,
0.6730206608772278,
-0.6441199779510498,
-0.5229854583740234,
-0.41497644782066345,
0.08609961718320847,
0.10545933991670609,
-0.8087105751037598,
0.09167514741420746,
0.08441773056983948,
-0.1952570378780365,
0.20772777497768402,
0.3384873867034912,
-0.6274108290672302,
1.112825870513916,
0.41103121638298035,
0.212511345744133,
0.6004078388214111,
0.12533940374851227,
-0.16962586343288422,
-0.9068290591239929,
-0.05845165625214577,
-0.6016338467597961,
-0.39624735713005066,
-0.33796417713165283,
-0.30066680908203125,
0.4946812391281128,
0.13834136724472046,
0.11688650399446487,
-0.1841268241405487,
-0.8804033994674683,
0.0924549549818039,
0.6085221171379089,
0.561638593673706,
0.5036183595657349,
-0.23910009860992432,
0.24193063378334045,
-0.4487657845020294,
-0.2993031144142151,
-0.284419447183609,
0.8817960023880005,
0.46264705061912537,
0.6313078999519348,
0.12487944215536118,
0.32278332114219666,
0.3850548267364502,
-0.11732335388660431,
-1.076894998550415,
-0.1215108260512352,
0.13019414246082306,
-0.6250097751617432,
-0.6421533823013306,
-0.06230618432164192,
-1.351986289024353,
-0.1709151268005371,
-0.3860272169113159,
-0.6440723538398743,
0.26203522086143494,
0.28439539670944214,
-0.7149946093559265,
-0.3345986008644104,
-0.5915543437004089,
0.473239004611969,
-0.1420760601758957,
-0.17764705419540405,
-0.2742675244808197,
-0.7950257062911987,
-0.07571900635957718,
0.21335949003696442,
0.7516736388206482,
-0.3321600556373596,
-0.16190510988235474,
1.0157663822174072,
-0.34009623527526855,
0.41181644797325134,
-0.003048049518838525,
0.21496738493442535,
0.41051220893859863,
-0.43023577332496643,
0.37748220562934875,
0.10637982934713364,
-0.10790775716304779,
-0.43922093510627747,
0.015414477325975895,
-0.42405375838279724,
-0.5736002326011658,
0.23591165244579315,
-0.5948624014854431,
-0.8446564674377441,
-0.1145947277545929,
-0.6378127336502075,
-0.005158317741006613,
0.22859719395637512,
0.5087890028953552,
0.5605817437171936,
0.06483560055494308,
0.4646216928958893,
0.9880353808403015,
-0.22688108682632446,
0.103029765188694,
0.32251161336898804,
0.4274682104587555,
-0.5115451812744141,
0.3772980868816376,
0.607795000076294,
0.25801485776901245,
0.1674477458000183,
0.552730143070221,
-0.23131130635738373,
-0.5607786178588867,
-0.2678709626197815,
0.28279995918273926,
-0.7354166507720947,
0.16534028947353363,
-0.9144504070281982,
-0.05258021131157875,
-0.6528269648551941,
-0.08919468522071838,
-0.24006710946559906,
-0.6583399176597595,
-0.4594821631908417,
-0.24172307550907135,
0.7964972257614136,
0.6275873780250549,
-0.014195109717547894,
0.538536787033081,
-0.8149542808532715,
0.10485123842954636,
0.32085102796554565,
0.14011350274085999,
-0.19763599336147308,
-0.6168608665466309,
-0.6951376795768738,
-0.2751307189464569,
-0.36845046281814575,
-1.4248982667922974,
-0.19883272051811218,
0.06888057291507721,
0.3527134358882904,
0.6094778180122375,
0.3694646656513214,
0.6359760165214539,
-0.41673141717910767,
0.8592746257781982,
0.0662837028503418,
-0.8562102317810059,
0.5550335049629211,
-0.381137877702713,
0.8750323057174683,
0.8918505907058716,
0.25228893756866455,
-0.8837792277336121,
-0.73555988073349,
-0.6492817401885986,
-1.0805381536483765,
0.40780767798423767,
0.460659384727478,
-0.011025572195649147,
-0.23947176337242126,
0.20330576598644257,
0.09157241135835648,
0.3359605073928833,
-0.490966796875,
-0.560767412185669,
-0.3072226047515869,
0.036567047238349915,
0.413786381483078,
-0.7402030825614929,
-0.23682212829589844,
-0.3732185363769531,
0.4781719446182251,
0.43600550293922424,
0.37134385108947754,
0.8554184436798096,
-0.19930271804332733,
-0.16120733320713043,
0.7576742172241211,
0.6267465949058533,
0.4055761694908142,
-0.29319408535957336,
0.32122281193733215,
0.12556946277618408,
-0.9028873443603516,
0.3957050144672394,
0.15078164637088776,
-0.3781662881374359,
0.409957617521286,
0.5215593576431274,
0.9025936126708984,
0.6711421012878418,
-0.6195398569107056,
0.4798866808414459,
0.08778593689203262,
-0.1194477379322052,
-0.22063122689723969,
-0.005841024219989777,
0.22709456086158752,
0.030558554455637932,
0.3908507823944092,
-0.1897743046283722,
0.9270026683807373,
-0.34359011054039,
0.42980584502220154,
-0.07653508335351944,
-0.6905562281608582,
0.05970196798443794,
0.7949641346931458,
0.19542142748832703,
-0.13505372405052185,
0.3494901657104492,
0.39176756143569946,
-0.3905562162399292,
0.5643504858016968,
0.6335692405700684,
0.4397452771663666,
-0.5398271083831787,
0.1389218121767044,
0.23448504507541656,
0.3751974105834961,
-0.00918041355907917,
0.5136286020278931,
-0.2691280245780945,
-0.06161339953541756,
-0.5771724581718445,
-0.034025974571704865,
-0.7895666360855103,
-0.06730233877897263,
-0.9274139404296875,
0.016522586345672607,
-0.23058579862117767,
-0.7571219205856323,
0.04133901372551918,
0.10277928411960602,
-0.6765376925468445,
0.5095368027687073,
-0.08536669611930847,
0.6065559983253479,
-0.6531881093978882,
0.33198854327201843,
0.7799500823020935,
-0.26769688725471497,
-1.058005452156067,
0.3843305706977844,
0.1467895358800888,
-0.134197399020195,
0.055390629917383194,
0.5167868733406067,
-0.014033467508852482,
-0.32304883003234863,
-0.13328370451927185,
-1.1717321872711182,
0.6978096961975098,
0.21354913711547852,
-0.29961133003234863,
0.30703893303871155,
-0.04356882721185684,
0.554222822189331,
-0.01339501328766346,
0.6167607307434082,
0.6512553095817566,
0.8462183475494385,
-0.11485899239778519,
-1.094475269317627,
0.08505531400442123,
-0.3140534460544586,
-0.4184788465499878,
0.059496328234672546,
-0.6005050539970398,
0.6581628322601318,
-0.20947343111038208,
-0.46558642387390137,
-0.3551620841026306,
0.45860934257507324,
0.04066571965813637,
0.7015310525894165,
0.7177863717079163,
0.22886072099208832,
1.1243077516555786,
0.08685412257909775,
1.271743893623352,
-0.03234005719423294,
-0.1047181561589241,
1.0676405429840088,
0.20396487414836884,
0.7406570911407471,
0.487982839345932,
-0.05647562816739082,
0.5481051206588745,
0.6592848896980286,
0.6559502482414246,
0.3433905839920044,
-0.0729631707072258,
-0.35010862350463867,
0.24590657651424408,
-0.7139173746109009,
-0.7380496859550476,
0.24787116050720215,
0.6841623783111572,
-0.5188770294189453,
0.4851433038711548,
0.5316517949104309,
0.4403895139694214,
-0.00866642314940691,
-0.02126925252377987,
0.7099475860595703,
0.0930553525686264,
-0.7331724762916565,
0.5573205947875977,
-0.45611560344696045,
0.31151044368743896,
0.017661577090620995,
0.11056294292211533,
0.10053449124097824,
-0.28497114777565,
-0.48087820410728455,
-0.7065908908843994,
0.32985708117485046,
-0.1458832025527954,
-0.6579655408859253,
-0.16134946048259735,
0.6891739368438721,
-0.6357093453407288,
-0.01228183414787054,
0.43201419711112976,
0.22409507632255554,
0.5425577759742737,
0.030270546674728394,
-0.5287302136421204,
0.2982132136821747,
-0.18037962913513184,
-0.5758318305015564,
-0.0942070335149765,
0.466111421585083,
0.2830539643764496,
0.15322312712669373,
0.5217650532722473,
0.31945478916168213,
-0.05351189151406288,
-0.002705504884943366,
0.5289987325668335,
-0.7973280549049377,
-0.7698535919189453,
-0.5361148715019226,
0.4166495203971863,
-0.22839786112308502,
-0.22032269835472107,
0.7763364315032959,
0.2642935812473297,
0.16726449131965637,
0.18547864258289337,
0.6989582777023315,
0.18169637024402618,
0.918803334236145,
-0.6017026305198669,
0.6638914942741394,
-0.6749280691146851,
0.042420901358127594,
-0.4325807988643646,
-0.6015200018882751,
-0.1589488685131073,
0.2228267937898636,
-0.26052913069725037,
-0.3363560438156128,
1.0498920679092407,
0.010367294773459435,
0.29032057523727417,
0.12731727957725525,
0.06130637601017952,
0.12319383025169373,
-0.02852039597928524,
0.15210987627506256,
0.6077716946601868,
-0.0752103328704834,
0.685703456401825,
-0.4469064772129059,
-0.3443789482116699,
-0.6740747690200806,
-0.5896367430686951,
-0.5822657942771912,
-0.10959405452013016,
-0.319722056388855,
-0.6185982823371887,
0.2879992425441742,
0.9361221790313721,
0.6229907274246216,
-0.46338388323783875,
0.16455146670341492,
0.48301324248313904,
0.5221924781799316,
-0.5442994832992554,
-0.2428707629442215,
0.6617563962936401,
0.016846198588609695,
-0.8058684468269348,
0.6056844592094421,
0.5618875622749329,
0.2475360631942749,
0.23998665809631348,
-0.026732027530670166,
-0.1850452572107315,
0.3980059325695038,
0.18204942345619202,
0.6141229867935181,
-0.4728914201259613,
-0.47519615292549133,
0.11361170560121536,
-0.32956281304359436,
0.6441121697425842,
0.9316701889038086,
-0.48432978987693787,
0.8368737101554871,
0.5299509167671204,
0.4874778985977173,
0.43512412905693054,
0.3572310209274292,
0.4301114082336426,
-0.553306519985199,
0.5740553140640259,
0.29027697443962097,
0.2927887439727783,
0.4492732584476471,
-0.8033680319786072,
0.16535897552967072,
0.12645772099494934,
-0.7410990595817566,
-0.6768661141395569,
-0.24411475658416748,
-0.8390097618103027,
-0.12801559269428253,
1.1967304944992065,
-0.0023307136725634336,
-0.15388354659080505,
-0.747539222240448,
-0.42659708857536316,
0.7567452192306519,
-0.6756544709205627,
0.8108843564987183,
0.8834479451179504,
-0.3336455821990967,
-0.1349555104970932,
-1.0271450281143188,
0.8443891406059265,
1.0147993564605713,
-0.6515867114067078,
-0.24082311987876892,
0.28488805890083313,
-0.00951104611158371,
0.20913083851337433,
1.0669606924057007,
0.004410438239574432,
0.7371765971183777,
-0.08358447253704071,
-0.257168173789978,
0.42950576543807983,
-0.36015358567237854,
-0.26763013005256653,
0.021111110225319862,
0.13069818913936615,
-0.20982356369495392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01592v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01592v1
|
Text and Audio Simplification: Human vs. ChatGPT
| 2024-04-29T21:00:33 | 2024-04-29T21:00:33 |
Gondy Leroy, David Kauchak, Philip Harber, Ankit Pal, Akash Shukla
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, H.4
|
Text and audio simplification to increase information comprehension are
important in healthcare. With the introduction of ChatGPT, an evaluation of its
simplification performance is needed. We provide a systematic comparison of
human and ChatGPT simplified texts using fourteen metrics indicative of text
difficulty. We briefly introduce our online editor where these simplification
tools, including ChatGPT, are available. We scored twelve corpora using our
metrics: six text, one audio, and five ChatGPT simplified corpora. We then
compare these corpora with texts simplified and verified in a prior user study.
Finally, a medical domain expert evaluated these texts and five, new ChatGPT
simplified versions. We found that simple corpora show higher similarity with
the human simplified texts. ChatGPT simplification moves metrics in the right
direction. The medical domain expert evaluation showed a preference for the
ChatGPT style, but the text itself was rated lower for content retention.
|
[
-0.21241505444049835,
-0.7039891481399536,
0.8369091153144836,
0.3600452244281769,
-0.5108599066734314,
0.11702138185501099,
-0.31381601095199585,
-0.6939067840576172,
-0.006989743560552597,
0.055319804698228836,
-0.6534080505371094,
-0.418092280626297,
-0.6630566120147705,
0.37447139620780945,
-0.059715960174798965,
1.2932050228118896,
-0.03588118031620979,
0.5216243863105774,
-0.3290554881095886,
0.041014958173036575,
-0.4498332738876343,
-0.555424153804779,
-0.9772505164146423,
-0.5459483861923218,
0.4344729483127594,
0.4061070382595062,
0.990652322769165,
0.6653526425361633,
1.0510238409042358,
0.2832452952861786,
-0.402322381734848,
-0.03389241546392441,
-0.2178480178117752,
-0.1804681420326233,
0.2756667733192444,
-0.18467532098293304,
-0.7534077763557434,
-0.19071613252162933,
-0.0036880658008158207,
1.208500862121582,
-0.21790502965450287,
0.08791861683130264,
-0.050274062901735306,
0.9974244832992554,
-0.3579281270503998,
0.3154197335243225,
0.031232979148626328,
0.2061164826154709,
0.2514435648918152,
-0.5503644347190857,
-0.07305212318897247,
-0.5518418550491333,
0.40723636746406555,
-0.953119158744812,
0.4003995358943939,
0.21007081866264343,
0.7230023741722107,
0.609049916267395,
-0.5649080872535706,
-0.7102900743484497,
-0.8598124384880066,
0.4378920793533325,
-0.4460013806819916,
0.5180309414863586,
0.17923280596733093,
0.32970234751701355,
-0.00429456727579236,
-0.9717926383018494,
-0.41335541009902954,
-0.20236265659332275,
-0.17553050816059113,
0.41137179732322693,
-0.417263001203537,
0.5388174057006836,
0.5290827751159668,
0.5092760920524597,
-0.7687399387359619,
-0.31520697474479675,
-0.9151057004928589,
-0.25535544753074646,
0.4804369807243347,
-0.07879611104726791,
0.7505672574043274,
-0.42399895191192627,
-0.5197681784629822,
-0.10358774662017822,
-0.7304716110229492,
-0.42863139510154724,
0.06950382888317108,
-0.19126594066619873,
0.10143639892339706,
0.5119528770446777,
-0.35563597083091736,
-0.04280911758542061,
-0.211776003241539,
-0.50525963306427,
0.45545974373817444,
-0.46372804045677185,
-0.3723667562007904,
0.41573312878608704,
0.8961960673332214,
0.7123106718063354,
0.39697232842445374,
-0.2247425615787506,
-0.04493182525038719,
0.2430294305086136,
0.30808159708976746,
-0.6722026467323303,
-0.39153653383255005,
0.22646351158618927,
-0.710097074508667,
0.039886634796857834,
-0.10377441346645355,
-0.3309502601623535,
-0.3989134728908539,
-0.5233719944953918,
0.460663765668869,
-0.7365664839744568,
0.04004505276679993,
0.5357967615127563,
-0.36250627040863037,
0.08233001083135605,
0.8516579270362854,
-0.674838662147522,
0.7568087577819824,
0.776718258857727,
0.8313693404197693,
-0.3687274754047394,
0.058145683258771896,
-0.006224411074072123,
-0.209385484457016,
-0.2132674753665924,
0.8846306800842285,
-0.024847477674484253,
-0.5451456308364868,
-0.3095354735851288,
-0.35582447052001953,
-0.014740148559212685,
-0.8871176838874817,
1.2430810928344727,
-0.04373984783887863,
0.5445767641067505,
-0.23567013442516327,
-0.7654049396514893,
-0.24258236587047577,
-0.07040243595838547,
-0.6612785458564758,
0.8420581817626953,
0.05477077141404152,
-0.9541128277778625,
0.5544183254241943,
-0.8365688920021057,
-0.3648732006549835,
0.1273968517780304,
-0.1824849396944046,
-0.4474836587905884,
-0.19119004905223846,
0.26826921105384827,
0.17791180312633514,
-0.32840970158576965,
0.1107783243060112,
0.04760764166712761,
-0.662121057510376,
0.11707471311092377,
-0.563331663608551,
0.5936111211776733,
0.44164571166038513,
-0.341135174036026,
-0.15118926763534546,
-0.7466808557510376,
0.02436174638569355,
-0.25982561707496643,
-0.5709857940673828,
-0.0840345025062561,
-0.013853837735950947,
0.3700450658798218,
0.04543042182922363,
-0.006248427554965019,
-0.45925354957580566,
0.013407381251454353,
-0.09822379052639008,
0.4493279755115509,
0.09894205629825592,
0.3488210141658783,
0.2446703016757965,
-0.6076418161392212,
0.6790333390235901,
-0.0932331532239914,
0.442623108625412,
-0.1553683876991272,
-0.8499029278755188,
-0.5531203150749207,
-0.4950188100337982,
0.5247597098350525,
0.9169325828552246,
-0.27537891268730164,
0.2233942449092865,
-0.43597644567489624,
-0.4964032471179962,
-0.9154614806175232,
-0.06674914062023163,
0.32953914999961853,
0.5322666764259338,
0.5826452374458313,
-0.5019543766975403,
-0.4267040193080902,
-1.1029694080352783,
-0.40762263536453247,
-0.42991772294044495,
-0.6870438456535339,
0.30270934104919434,
0.12168299406766891,
-0.35740387439727783,
0.656609833240509,
-0.4032299518585205,
-0.38220664858818054,
-0.15232378244400024,
0.3742664158344269,
-0.06646106392145157,
0.4108121991157532,
0.20460867881774902,
-1.041600227355957,
-0.42973214387893677,
0.08643422275781631,
-0.4924578070640564,
-0.2708374559879303,
-0.10366591066122055,
0.3936827778816223,
-0.18184791505336761,
0.6476434469223022,
-0.7029659748077393,
0.5601959824562073,
0.319934606552124,
-0.1407472938299179,
0.4610825181007385,
-0.5006530284881592,
0.5899115204811096,
-0.7753507494926453,
-0.005450436379760504,
-0.20617716014385223,
-0.5510125160217285,
-0.8186818361282349,
-0.17278830707073212,
0.13448108732700348,
-0.2947831153869629,
-0.5248633027076721,
0.1678709238767624,
-0.41449475288391113,
-0.026165224611759186,
-0.03696374595165253,
0.33171164989471436,
-0.005250783171504736,
0.3918280303478241,
-0.04787011444568634,
0.8451229929924011,
0.20871877670288086,
-0.3867345452308655,
0.4377504885196686,
0.38109225034713745,
-0.3815048336982727,
0.4473697245121002,
-1.1077358722686768,
0.06000488996505737,
-0.19646966457366943,
0.42152175307273865,
-1.0212914943695068,
-0.45988133549690247,
0.2611454725265503,
-0.4035433828830719,
0.15430232882499695,
0.03795672953128815,
-0.4574948251247406,
0.08663928508758545,
-0.37817251682281494,
0.5092976689338684,
0.7549111247062683,
-0.03191479668021202,
0.2591853141784668,
0.1621270477771759,
-0.4972952604293823,
-0.17237599194049835,
-0.7862369418144226,
0.1381734162569046,
-0.1730673909187317,
-0.6325914263725281,
0.4327579736709595,
-0.4300740659236908,
-0.3989259600639343,
-0.07788267731666565,
-0.33408015966415405,
-0.3625156581401825,
-0.015224345028400421,
0.2752011716365814,
0.09212939441204071,
-0.3173021376132965,
0.44078338146209717,
-0.008077826350927353,
-0.15276898443698883,
-0.040743812918663025,
0.3209766447544098,
0.29132571816444397,
-0.29451924562454224,
-0.5969645380973816,
-0.6763055324554443,
0.7352971434593201,
0.3791455626487732,
0.3507399260997772,
0.19256001710891724,
0.6319385170936584,
-0.07856999337673187,
0.5309305787086487,
-0.6094359755516052,
-0.2517545223236084,
-0.40270718932151794,
0.18586722016334534,
-0.18424443900585175,
-0.720459520816803,
0.2288823276758194,
-0.3538781404495239,
-0.15052708983421326,
0.6426931023597717,
0.4326089024543762,
-0.40532588958740234,
1.02814519405365,
0.42814311385154724,
0.39170223474502563,
0.16637039184570312,
0.30368539690971375,
0.1788468360900879,
-0.4917375147342682,
-0.350216269493103,
-0.5154637098312378,
-0.03593681380152702,
-1.0232023000717163,
-0.24426791071891785,
0.5200272798538208,
0.14875873923301697,
-0.051447801291942596,
0.21200871467590332,
-0.5779351592063904,
0.32421278953552246,
0.33766844868659973,
0.4117704927921295,
0.6617894768714905,
0.0236599612981081,
0.1399710327386856,
-0.13230398297309875,
-0.7095908522605896,
-0.7132998108863831,
0.8880950212478638,
0.5449115037918091,
0.8113793730735779,
0.3082225024700165,
0.7925560474395752,
0.3138639032840729,
0.2885304391384125,
-1.0862133502960205,
0.3209686577320099,
-0.10763026028871536,
-0.4357124865055084,
-0.15159344673156738,
-0.625403642654419,
-1.00101900100708,
0.08187264949083328,
-0.25038498640060425,
-0.31495335698127747,
-0.12966996431350708,
0.15956948697566986,
-0.4213409721851349,
-0.15333981812000275,
-1.489052176475525,
0.7541211247444153,
0.17770658433437347,
0.24757272005081177,
-0.03638176992535591,
-0.6686041355133057,
-0.03408297151327133,
-0.005333404988050461,
0.4062613546848297,
-0.1994432657957077,
-0.4362470209598541,
0.66653972864151,
-0.6167793869972229,
0.5409061312675476,
0.37912285327911377,
0.32328325510025024,
-0.04093350097537041,
-0.15342111885547638,
-0.040752895176410675,
0.060210615396499634,
0.24422916769981384,
-0.06275750696659088,
0.22966545820236206,
-0.36810219287872314,
-0.7532357573509216,
0.24932676553726196,
-0.7092539072036743,
-0.6700400710105896,
-0.3626598119735718,
-0.14312103390693665,
-0.13239233195781708,
0.18526586890220642,
0.47577303647994995,
0.5251412391662598,
-0.5439754128456116,
0.24559302628040314,
0.7272474765777588,
-0.2898460328578949,
0.07619921118021011,
-0.04266921803355217,
0.1589328497648239,
-0.23245751857757568,
0.5459453463554382,
-0.14505372941493988,
0.4764055013656616,
0.4747244417667389,
0.4514695405960083,
-0.2552226185798645,
-0.3678632080554962,
-0.4316272735595703,
0.2491954267024994,
-0.9375160336494446,
0.1343729943037033,
-0.6586982011795044,
-0.21010306477546692,
-0.4421500563621521,
0.08511824905872345,
0.03430511802434921,
-0.7772470712661743,
-0.19780755043029785,
0.1115671917796135,
0.36487531661987305,
0.8284077644348145,
0.1210596114397049,
0.42807304859161377,
-0.6650545597076416,
0.48200950026512146,
0.4768661856651306,
0.1888536810874939,
-0.7163495421409607,
-0.3146584630012512,
0.2815110385417938,
-0.19123117625713348,
-0.30466318130493164,
-1.0917234420776367,
0.1122908890247345,
0.37533387541770935,
0.318494588136673,
0.30735164880752563,
-0.05646282061934471,
0.7623002529144287,
-0.739981472492218,
0.7340607047080994,
0.4679875075817108,
-0.9392076730728149,
0.23300132155418396,
-0.2353479117155075,
0.5200362801551819,
0.6753972172737122,
0.5566055178642273,
-0.9912630915641785,
-0.3107892870903015,
-0.9379217624664307,
-0.8743451833724976,
0.2991657555103302,
0.506505012512207,
-0.11080697923898697,
0.1818159520626068,
0.2759893536567688,
0.03433570638298988,
0.258219450712204,
-0.4853309094905853,
-0.5132388472557068,
-0.2597845494747162,
-0.2964257001876831,
0.026728181168437004,
-0.2947656214237213,
-0.10197369009256363,
-0.17527936398983002,
0.2955434322357178,
0.04278809204697609,
0.5567308664321899,
0.7051287889480591,
-0.03598077967762947,
0.18043966591358185,
0.7149158120155334,
0.7171581387519836,
0.7628356218338013,
-0.27987927198410034,
0.1290951371192932,
0.41243478655815125,
-0.839934229850769,
-0.13180220127105713,
-0.03970301151275635,
-0.13476979732513428,
0.5674358606338501,
0.7185314893722534,
0.9844601154327393,
0.46372997760772705,
-0.750003457069397,
0.7766745686531067,
-0.4182271659374237,
-0.5822811722755432,
-0.2412988543510437,
0.023890148848295212,
0.2957713007926941,
-0.15199288725852966,
0.23035801947116852,
0.40985870361328125,
0.8107221722602844,
-0.5816016793251038,
0.16632120311260223,
-0.27961939573287964,
-0.6228864789009094,
0.04905446246266365,
0.5306395292282104,
0.05568313226103783,
-0.4461837410926819,
0.2667787969112396,
0.041896164417266846,
-0.3972325623035431,
0.37235262989997864,
0.17421196401119232,
0.7286789417266846,
-0.054820895195007324,
0.10882328450679779,
0.2915147840976715,
0.26283738017082214,
-0.23087619245052338,
0.322293221950531,
-0.20094528794288635,
-0.11349581927061081,
-0.5185474157333374,
-0.2141272872686386,
-0.9286440014839172,
-0.1599704921245575,
-0.6656967401504517,
0.3261905312538147,
-0.3263914883136749,
-0.21188662946224213,
0.4240841567516327,
0.11641599982976913,
-0.7701791524887085,
0.5208116769790649,
-0.11661265790462494,
1.000664472579956,
-0.6044158935546875,
0.46687766909599304,
0.879075288772583,
-0.41124624013900757,
-1.1143019199371338,
0.142734557390213,
0.2270878106355667,
-0.3710903227329254,
0.5053985714912415,
-0.056606441736221313,
0.019866017624735832,
-0.2852035462856293,
-0.22152447700500488,
-0.306483656167984,
1.045998215675354,
0.43353405594825745,
-0.4708074927330017,
-0.1598721444606781,
0.24671244621276855,
0.905541718006134,
0.0009295904310420156,
0.788258969783783,
0.5715798735618591,
0.4458017349243164,
0.04182429611682892,
-1.4348324537277222,
-0.05408518761396408,
-0.01429575216025114,
-0.3286724090576172,
0.0637127012014389,
-0.33301401138305664,
0.7898553013801575,
-0.14800694584846497,
-0.6099253296852112,
-0.3106732964515686,
0.3474710285663605,
-0.06686772406101227,
0.4267818331718445,
0.653569221496582,
0.043028995394706726,
0.8849273920059204,
-0.3199148178100586,
1.347313642501831,
0.14185857772827148,
0.36547183990478516,
0.8260974884033203,
0.23074135184288025,
0.8089786767959595,
0.5552131533622742,
-0.43567967414855957,
0.4271708130836487,
0.7853449583053589,
0.4282485842704773,
0.26198717951774597,
0.27328720688819885,
-0.5533466339111328,
-0.16330546140670776,
-0.06340838968753815,
-0.47298985719680786,
0.3290668725967407,
0.1528247892856598,
-0.14035683870315552,
-0.23201337456703186,
-0.09303689002990723,
0.2632333040237427,
0.13824838399887085,
-0.05509274825453758,
1.224800944328308,
0.28276851773262024,
-0.6221716403961182,
0.4789014160633087,
-0.021009381860494614,
0.4187409281730652,
-0.5222904682159424,
0.10260950028896332,
-0.15904301404953003,
0.01024188008159399,
-0.42702874541282654,
-0.5197820067405701,
0.28186556696891785,
-0.0023926179856061935,
-0.07384779304265976,
-0.28282082080841064,
0.6577295064926147,
-0.5816895961761475,
-0.14444270730018616,
0.15500980615615845,
0.5420224666595459,
0.5221466422080994,
-0.2359493225812912,
-0.7065306305885315,
-0.06254259496927261,
-0.02641386352479458,
-0.284404456615448,
-0.06405258923768997,
0.6132922172546387,
-0.09875468909740448,
0.7874678373336792,
0.6310381293296814,
0.32641181349754333,
0.03660761937499046,
0.1581430733203888,
0.8148715496063232,
-0.5695842504501343,
-0.47644534707069397,
-0.7666736245155334,
-0.10808767378330231,
-0.20499779284000397,
-0.42605623602867126,
0.4499240815639496,
0.5956138968467712,
0.6394452452659607,
-0.2807548940181732,
0.6265974044799805,
0.09889870882034302,
0.8238353133201599,
-0.6298263669013977,
0.767540693283081,
-0.6330771446228027,
0.09849230200052261,
-0.4591388702392578,
-0.6564713716506958,
-0.5598909854888916,
0.4036503732204437,
-0.11166530847549438,
0.0006898368010297418,
1.118776798248291,
0.590625524520874,
-0.34219831228256226,
0.18025238811969757,
0.35428571701049805,
-0.16535362601280212,
0.11763062328100204,
0.5407870411872864,
0.635586678981781,
-0.6127654314041138,
0.9057196378707886,
-0.16805696487426758,
-0.2268083244562149,
-0.3608911335468292,
-0.8964404463768005,
-0.600059986114502,
-0.3536843955516815,
-0.5254166126251221,
-0.013626566156744957,
0.07706054300069809,
1.2270461320877075,
0.7154343724250793,
-0.5336546301841736,
0.10620415955781937,
0.09150150418281555,
-0.06666193902492523,
-0.3864618241786957,
-0.17353728413581848,
0.5613577961921692,
-0.2150343805551529,
-0.6870976686477661,
0.3125098645687103,
0.37697991728782654,
0.09801256656646729,
0.14657165110111237,
-0.27436453104019165,
0.32104605436325073,
0.13587702810764313,
0.5602393746376038,
0.10796880722045898,
-0.6575142741203308,
-0.24943602085113525,
-0.015096276998519897,
-0.6960369348526001,
0.5048214197158813,
0.998528003692627,
-0.46246597170829773,
0.4553776681423187,
0.6705880761146545,
0.4392055571079254,
0.5160577297210693,
0.2975620627403259,
0.4746694564819336,
-0.6601542830467224,
0.11047737300395966,
0.2615155875682831,
0.312380850315094,
0.6740249395370483,
-0.26578155159950256,
0.5505313873291016,
0.3003607988357544,
-0.68352210521698,
-0.5571951866149902,
-0.030403127893805504,
-1.4210362434387207,
-0.13249094784259796,
1.159813642501831,
-0.13447032868862152,
-0.1537027806043625,
-0.642204761505127,
-0.8584364056587219,
0.24776792526245117,
-0.4713488221168518,
0.49012431502342224,
0.5687147974967957,
-0.3061319887638092,
-0.09706839174032211,
-1.0824452638626099,
1.1195963621139526,
0.5412228107452393,
-1.0305629968643188,
-0.24479269981384277,
0.27274972200393677,
0.38081490993499756,
0.3083660304546356,
1.0121608972549438,
-0.17529135942459106,
0.7619099020957947,
0.06385862082242966,
0.19669109582901,
0.12975305318832397,
0.11608070135116577,
-0.2946847081184387,
0.14856986701488495,
0.11338923126459122,
-0.027388278394937515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19094v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19094v1
|
In-Context Symbolic Regression: Leveraging Language Models for Function Discovery
| 2024-04-29T20:19:25 | 2024-04-29T20:19:25 |
Matteo Merler, Nicola Dainese, Katsiaryna Haitsiukevich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Symbolic Regression (SR) is a task which aims to extract the mathematical
expression underlying a set of empirical observations. Transformer-based
methods trained on SR datasets detain the current state-of-the-art in this
task, while the application of Large Language Models (LLMs) to SR remains
unexplored. This work investigates the integration of pre-trained LLMs into the
SR pipeline, utilizing an approach that iteratively refines a functional form
based on the prediction error it achieves on the observation set, until it
reaches convergence. Our method leverages LLMs to propose an initial set of
possible functions based on the observations, exploiting their strong
pre-training prior. These functions are then iteratively refined by the model
itself and by an external optimizer for their coefficients. The process is
repeated until the results are satisfactory. We then analyze Vision-Language
Models in this context, exploring the inclusion of plots as visual inputs to
aid the optimization process. Our findings reveal that LLMs are able to
successfully recover good symbolic equations that fit the given data,
outperforming SR baselines based on Genetic Programming, with the addition of
images in the input showing promising results for the most complex benchmarks.
|
[
-0.09275835007429123,
-0.45934897661209106,
0.7856419682502747,
0.11737987399101257,
-0.2943757176399231,
0.11446865648031235,
-0.27478814125061035,
-0.2582731544971466,
0.22502964735031128,
0.5999850630760193,
-0.7078747749328613,
-0.4318569302558899,
-0.935844898223877,
0.24971114099025726,
-0.4293645918369293,
0.4457857012748718,
-0.26613306999206543,
0.4462166130542755,
-0.2730537950992584,
0.07627703994512558,
-0.376097172498703,
-0.344102680683136,
-0.47703686356544495,
-0.2952961325645447,
0.4589751064777374,
-0.045388273894786835,
0.28777042031288147,
0.5115252137184143,
0.6853044033050537,
0.3454990088939667,
0.3321288824081421,
0.15901978313922882,
-0.7105645537376404,
0.10612915456295013,
0.16496405005455017,
-0.6643914580345154,
0.12835296988487244,
-0.1758238822221756,
0.750493049621582,
0.5983054637908936,
-0.06411270797252655,
0.41305431723594666,
0.13550972938537598,
0.4388665556907654,
-0.7374159097671509,
0.7761270403862,
-0.5247220396995544,
0.14656859636306763,
-0.007713496219366789,
-0.3212035298347473,
-0.5137787461280823,
-0.5604133605957031,
0.14335231482982635,
-0.434329628944397,
0.08043639361858368,
-0.23958690464496613,
0.8458136320114136,
0.7107567191123962,
-0.17157913744449615,
0.06599634885787964,
-0.8417332172393799,
1.0296061038970947,
-0.7277697324752808,
0.5641493201255798,
0.15796834230422974,
0.557748019695282,
-0.3883807957172394,
-1.0087649822235107,
-0.3630388379096985,
-0.5414278507232666,
-0.4570997357368469,
-0.01889597810804844,
-0.4394611716270447,
-0.19096551835536957,
0.3247247338294983,
-0.2720926105976105,
-0.33832186460494995,
-0.1644344925880432,
-0.4785906672477722,
-0.08042863011360168,
0.6687207818031311,
0.05027467757463455,
0.20601753890514374,
-0.056663427501916885,
-0.07259050011634827,
-0.2969716191291809,
-0.7441837787628174,
-0.003753892844542861,
-0.14051753282546997,
0.6674764752388,
-0.09175898879766464,
0.7386268377304077,
0.11943647265434265,
0.659775972366333,
-0.4182572364807129,
-0.20860902965068817,
0.1709326058626175,
-0.19304674863815308,
-0.3310256898403168,
-0.20063252747058868,
0.6270294785499573,
-0.15551020205020905,
0.7048182487487793,
0.01159345917403698,
-0.4254835546016693,
0.26292622089385986,
0.35572370886802673,
-0.7788877487182617,
-0.02756740152835846,
-0.24546264111995697,
-0.40784984827041626,
-0.11366157978773117,
0.06458444893360138,
-0.39984118938446045,
-0.24920959770679474,
-0.7690702080726624,
0.5895509123802185,
-0.45406457781791687,
0.03129859268665314,
-0.03162297233939171,
-0.20948520302772522,
0.05517951771616936,
0.357126921415329,
-0.415134459733963,
0.12020280957221985,
0.5380116105079651,
0.7481777667999268,
0.22300073504447937,
-0.1322237253189087,
-0.7805725932121277,
0.09620000422000885,
-0.3709630072116852,
0.5484278202056885,
-0.6581816077232361,
-0.39866194128990173,
-0.006743200588971376,
-0.008261449635028839,
-0.2488114833831787,
-0.460995078086853,
0.2301221787929535,
-0.3646553158760071,
-0.05820509046316147,
-0.1621350795030594,
-0.13528409600257874,
-0.1425085812807083,
-0.0016882127383723855,
-0.5580099821090698,
1.1471071243286133,
0.42661553621292114,
-0.5172004699707031,
0.38864561915397644,
-0.6289762854576111,
-0.3773038685321808,
0.05990559235215187,
-0.44878047704696655,
-0.49608972668647766,
0.43167003989219666,
0.2615682780742645,
0.5226826071739197,
-0.6073796153068542,
0.5236483812332153,
-0.38376012444496155,
-0.4609259366989136,
0.12160326540470123,
-0.041277218610048294,
0.5264544486999512,
0.10742667317390442,
-0.3392393887042999,
0.38773760199546814,
-0.5304489135742188,
-0.07796848565340042,
0.3431122899055481,
0.20266121625900269,
-0.4459073543548584,
0.23888693749904633,
-0.2131262570619583,
0.0798860415816307,
0.06365522742271423,
-0.5084871053695679,
0.09726066142320633,
-0.2109389305114746,
0.454849511384964,
0.7698074579238892,
-0.5346943736076355,
0.08658111840486526,
0.03187116980552673,
0.709150493144989,
-0.17704030871391296,
0.2195206731557846,
-0.16904552280902863,
-0.24484317004680634,
-0.7354133129119873,
-0.5471444129943848,
0.13590145111083984,
0.290244460105896,
-0.7099058032035828,
0.25536781549453735,
-0.4436893165111542,
-0.4268465042114258,
-0.4439370930194855,
0.05433722585439682,
0.20879817008972168,
0.672479510307312,
0.347057580947876,
-0.09886730462312698,
-0.613596498966217,
-1.0078974962234497,
-0.1238233745098114,
-0.10020396113395691,
-0.16942402720451355,
0.22798898816108704,
0.576251745223999,
-0.3631139099597931,
1.0791977643966675,
-0.7781559228897095,
-0.39256221055984497,
-0.3800044655799866,
0.030367236584424973,
0.24537059664726257,
0.14543795585632324,
0.644419252872467,
-0.6823171973228455,
-0.3682436943054199,
0.02542145550251007,
-1.066813588142395,
-0.22619862854480743,
0.13606910407543182,
0.19981883466243744,
-0.054959736764431,
0.5893927812576294,
-0.3191620409488678,
0.5217102766036987,
0.5372552275657654,
0.030601685866713524,
0.5767549276351929,
-0.12643757462501526,
-0.007089655380696058,
-0.9139866232872009,
0.09622732549905777,
0.5328917503356934,
-0.09446855634450912,
-0.5372964143753052,
0.11265102028846741,
0.06283080577850342,
-0.09141979366540909,
-0.26732274889945984,
0.6596325039863586,
-0.4529969096183777,
-0.25370728969573975,
-0.07576356828212738,
-0.044452495872974396,
-0.5132279396057129,
0.30171000957489014,
0.13043048977851868,
0.6429060697555542,
0.8405447602272034,
-0.21621480584144592,
-0.020863842219114304,
0.12129093706607819,
-0.06400473415851593,
0.036207713186740875,
-0.6376675367355347,
-0.23933015763759613,
-0.5465373992919922,
0.24413616955280304,
-1.009170413017273,
-0.1317318230867386,
0.25450265407562256,
-0.22617356479167938,
0.21555742621421814,
-0.319769948720932,
-0.5077264308929443,
-0.49055272340774536,
-0.2939910292625427,
0.29587480425834656,
0.6001578569412231,
-0.5461264252662659,
1.259640097618103,
0.3230651021003723,
-0.10047781467437744,
-0.5999729037284851,
-0.364470511674881,
-0.05262143164873123,
-0.3026006817817688,
-0.7400435209274292,
0.15775160491466522,
0.32869264483451843,
-0.19618511199951172,
-0.1541283130645752,
-0.19722391664981842,
0.1830795556306839,
-0.04047601670026779,
0.24211716651916504,
0.47994840145111084,
-0.25550922751426697,
-0.0567677803337574,
-0.1262173056602478,
-0.21165987849235535,
0.18354417383670807,
-0.25298669934272766,
0.6227591633796692,
-0.08128144592046738,
-0.30295199155807495,
-0.47366589307785034,
0.12826044857501984,
0.43401414155960083,
-0.4271045923233032,
0.4489540457725525,
0.4110506772994995,
-0.5223252773284912,
-0.522255003452301,
-0.4649309515953064,
-0.423456609249115,
-0.49779218435287476,
0.443097859621048,
-0.393205851316452,
-0.8652611374855042,
0.290801078081131,
-0.3101712465286255,
-0.010770542547106743,
0.20248842239379883,
0.33117902278900146,
-0.03269997984170914,
1.160441517829895,
1.0427101850509644,
0.32388195395469666,
0.6166887879371643,
-0.38940706849098206,
0.5042882561683655,
-0.5521740913391113,
-0.4518243074417114,
-0.5730692744255066,
-0.4615037441253662,
-0.40187492966651917,
-0.5920538306236267,
0.5469240546226501,
-0.02217583730816841,
-0.3378084897994995,
0.4245802164077759,
-0.3610777258872986,
0.2365938425064087,
0.5505409836769104,
0.13911186158657074,
0.09757775068283081,
0.09417024254798889,
0.007752018049359322,
-0.16148298978805542,
-0.6235665082931519,
-0.4278160035610199,
1.0820391178131104,
0.26282036304473877,
1.022821068763733,
-0.29214492440223694,
0.8545001149177551,
-0.03320842236280441,
0.8668728470802307,
-0.8332560062408447,
0.7413205504417419,
-0.6441696286201477,
0.23541617393493652,
-0.19540749490261078,
-0.573089599609375,
-0.7995880246162415,
0.24309051036834717,
-0.11048721522092819,
-0.9939154982566833,
0.030536716803908348,
0.382468581199646,
-0.0838828980922699,
-0.0028519900515675545,
-0.7678315043449402,
0.7870284914970398,
-0.5341958999633789,
-0.2270081341266632,
-0.16880637407302856,
-0.65235435962677,
0.34979766607284546,
-0.34705808758735657,
0.22333015501499176,
0.09489209949970245,
0.429057776927948,
0.6413576602935791,
-0.3162342607975006,
0.9797763824462891,
-0.2661196291446686,
-0.1268308162689209,
0.038516465574502945,
0.10970544815063477,
0.5177810192108154,
-0.23789523541927338,
0.1654406636953354,
0.2240060269832611,
0.04213715344667435,
-0.04773671552538872,
-0.7619213461875916,
0.5705655813217163,
-0.5721052885055542,
-0.7034708857536316,
-0.39834272861480713,
-0.5067185759544373,
-0.3498351573944092,
0.24079619348049164,
-0.22881269454956055,
0.2939998209476471,
0.1251128762960434,
0.2581483721733093,
0.313158243894577,
-0.21363598108291626,
0.39020633697509766,
0.25056949257850647,
-0.40656203031539917,
-0.042722202837467194,
0.6751452088356018,
-0.10113134235143661,
0.09234774112701416,
0.37517207860946655,
0.540229856967926,
-0.4325484335422516,
-0.36084240674972534,
-0.15061451494693756,
0.6327773928642273,
-0.6598738431930542,
-0.2781932055950165,
-0.4391573965549469,
-0.17486204206943512,
-0.33721843361854553,
-0.2641667127609253,
-0.25792694091796875,
-0.14117062091827393,
-0.18030013144016266,
0.13071244955062866,
0.2886221706867218,
0.6270501017570496,
0.08581412583589554,
0.5510472059249878,
-0.7852904796600342,
0.36903056502342224,
-0.17045582830905914,
0.2660895884037018,
-0.05129159614443779,
-0.15529271960258484,
-0.1280260980129242,
0.15095804631710052,
-0.043393880128860474,
-0.6812530755996704,
0.759449303150177,
0.04777698218822479,
0.6333763003349304,
0.12890328466892242,
-0.307162880897522,
0.8392446637153625,
-0.41588738560676575,
0.39370763301849365,
0.29652276635169983,
-0.8648882508277893,
0.6263879537582397,
-0.08807212114334106,
0.23538810014724731,
0.15454038977622986,
0.51884526014328,
-0.16926397383213043,
-0.39978840947151184,
-0.2874804139137268,
-0.6941977143287659,
0.6446570754051208,
0.0935441106557846,
0.06196265295147896,
0.215043842792511,
0.4082246422767639,
-0.07754917442798615,
0.22563670575618744,
-0.7565386295318604,
-0.1020139679312706,
-0.1678338199853897,
-0.43232664465904236,
-0.22039857506752014,
0.1541326344013214,
-0.3678792715072632,
-0.41701313853263855,
0.3555886447429657,
-0.4672044813632965,
0.1271994560956955,
-0.04294345900416374,
-0.18162238597869873,
-0.16300633549690247,
-0.23080974817276,
0.34803301095962524,
0.7168611288070679,
-0.029925744980573654,
0.06438947468996048,
-0.09954346716403961,
-0.3752797842025757,
-0.15114173293113708,
0.26204782724380493,
-0.09456784278154373,
-0.01847264915704727,
0.3889096975326538,
0.848575234413147,
0.35863959789276123,
-1.0738530158996582,
0.25770795345306396,
0.024267133325338364,
-0.08597689867019653,
-0.5028200149536133,
0.022611388936638832,
-0.024619335308670998,
0.462422251701355,
0.5512067675590515,
0.060129474848508835,
-0.02077239379286766,
-0.41755345463752747,
0.39959436655044556,
0.8915702700614929,
-0.1914268136024475,
-0.29178541898727417,
0.80597984790802,
-0.2090740203857422,
-0.21327081322669983,
0.589354395866394,
0.4548724889755249,
-0.6714664101600647,
0.7270058989524841,
0.7237919569015503,
0.9821217656135559,
-0.01390728261321783,
0.24402973055839539,
0.4408890902996063,
0.28185510635375977,
-0.17013123631477356,
0.3315836191177368,
0.1565333902835846,
-0.722515881061554,
-0.6238265633583069,
-0.9516361355781555,
0.03729955852031708,
-0.11825429648160934,
-0.359433650970459,
0.6708966493606567,
-0.26415666937828064,
-0.22009171545505524,
0.038788821548223495,
-0.47579726576805115,
-0.7999743819236755,
0.3163244426250458,
0.2606644332408905,
0.703729510307312,
-0.8782182335853577,
0.7655897736549377,
0.512922465801239,
-0.4205136001110077,
-0.997856616973877,
-0.05099683627486229,
0.012639297172427177,
-1.2653230428695679,
1.2646827697753906,
0.1623345911502838,
-0.5848240256309509,
0.18190889060497284,
-0.519859790802002,
-1.090842366218567,
1.1424235105514526,
0.7949195504188538,
-0.5346381664276123,
-0.22521866858005524,
0.3242381811141968,
0.658404529094696,
-0.5750810503959656,
0.1377844512462616,
0.6055793166160583,
0.5635741353034973,
0.395706444978714,
-0.7799784541130066,
0.16256046295166016,
-0.0723716989159584,
0.19470888376235962,
0.6543452143669128,
-0.27262625098228455,
0.6439363360404968,
-0.5006513595581055,
-0.20799900591373444,
-0.050805721431970596,
0.47418540716171265,
0.425773024559021,
0.05919928103685379,
0.4081975817680359,
0.39471039175987244,
0.2785402536392212,
-0.3060605227947235,
1.142012596130371,
-0.26338717341423035,
0.39189204573631287,
0.7469285130500793,
-0.17638063430786133,
0.8332328200340271,
0.8260706663131714,
-0.1273670196533203,
0.36937448382377625,
0.37324705719947815,
-0.2763495147228241,
0.5170990824699402,
0.6073474287986755,
0.03241829201579094,
-0.21719293296337128,
-0.11267291754484177,
0.008476070128381252,
0.33525481820106506,
0.2955600917339325,
-0.5734904408454895,
-0.3906393349170685,
-0.02498873509466648,
-0.18653202056884766,
-0.062220413237810135,
-0.19858983159065247,
0.4667176306247711,
0.20614327490329742,
-0.5585006475448608,
0.5604615211486816,
-0.22394320368766785,
0.4392775297164917,
-1.0003507137298584,
-0.2712094187736511,
-0.1722852885723114,
0.313324511051178,
-0.02594459056854248,
-0.5129906535148621,
0.30592039227485657,
-0.21873538196086884,
0.3124453127384186,
-0.37312644720077515,
0.6801204085350037,
-0.3236704468727112,
-0.8228778839111328,
0.5129833817481995,
0.5921601057052612,
-0.25064927339553833,
0.10797616839408875,
-0.27446064352989197,
0.29822900891304016,
0.07663966715335846,
-0.03832682594656944,
0.16436229646205902,
0.03927074000239372,
-0.37195974588394165,
0.996939480304718,
0.6892713308334351,
0.09161319583654404,
-0.026471806690096855,
0.2552511990070343,
0.8836396932601929,
-0.5395136475563049,
-0.2276633083820343,
-0.8412179350852966,
0.7017742991447449,
0.13001269102096558,
-0.023213578388094902,
0.49303001165390015,
0.45488399267196655,
0.8301202058792114,
-0.42970457673072815,
0.8266056776046753,
0.10792695730924606,
0.05759820714592934,
-0.5308268070220947,
0.444141149520874,
-0.9167848229408264,
0.2596595585346222,
-0.31250935792922974,
-1.0688998699188232,
-0.7398956418037415,
0.7083637118339539,
-0.353186696767807,
0.04794801026582718,
0.7058156132698059,
0.8460711240768433,
-0.15202680230140686,
-0.00033704086672514677,
0.12978334724903107,
0.13334424793720245,
0.4997310936450958,
0.18409967422485352,
0.7569836378097534,
-0.10628510266542435,
0.20504701137542725,
-0.26401156187057495,
-0.45448732376098633,
0.004481722135096788,
-1.0170879364013672,
-0.6475580334663391,
-0.6314375996589661,
-0.24545472860336304,
-0.1505284160375595,
0.15812422335147858,
0.9156589508056641,
0.5907472968101501,
-0.6144727468490601,
-0.6180544495582581,
0.0329773835837841,
-0.2955802381038666,
-0.2065383791923523,
-0.202708438038826,
0.3664205074310303,
-0.30172663927078247,
-0.829136312007904,
0.38260334730148315,
0.34707173705101013,
0.029303133487701416,
-0.37866485118865967,
0.057465363293886185,
0.1581299602985382,
0.03009553998708725,
0.7890385389328003,
0.19247902929782867,
-0.7759865522384644,
-0.34543874859809875,
0.2869502902030945,
0.2781223952770233,
-0.03288200497627258,
1.1561012268066406,
-1.1073030233383179,
0.32748666405677795,
0.303217351436615,
0.6828194260597229,
0.7201474905014038,
-0.12482855468988419,
1.016313076019287,
-0.6911739706993103,
-0.03180456906557083,
0.28898510336875916,
0.7074339985847473,
0.26015573740005493,
-0.12404479831457138,
0.7547640204429626,
0.13888205587863922,
-0.09892047196626663,
-1.0864596366882324,
0.2538157105445862,
-0.9416019916534424,
-0.29001885652542114,
0.9660925269126892,
0.13153475522994995,
-0.18213795125484467,
0.397875040769577,
-0.1503821611404419,
0.2146531045436859,
-0.09750363230705261,
0.9940930604934692,
0.38123852014541626,
-0.4129239022731781,
-0.31555160880088806,
-0.3429371416568756,
0.4320240914821625,
0.262378990650177,
-0.8526345491409302,
0.10465536266565323,
0.5271063446998596,
0.23943647742271423,
0.19238069653511047,
0.21871095895767212,
-0.15506446361541748,
-0.08435817062854767,
-0.32557031512260437,
-0.16638422012329102,
-0.010997436009347439,
-0.47287651896476746,
-0.09628741443157196,
0.17091645300388336,
-0.06788385659456253,
0.1928279548883438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19071v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19071v1
|
Blind Spots and Biases: Exploring the Role of Annotator Cognitive Biases in NLP
| 2024-04-29T19:28:35 | 2024-04-29T19:28:35 |
Sanjana Gautam, Mukund Srinath
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
With the rapid proliferation of artificial intelligence, there is growing
concern over its potential to exacerbate existing biases and societal
disparities and introduce novel ones. This issue has prompted widespread
attention from academia, policymakers, industry, and civil society. While
evidence suggests that integrating human perspectives can mitigate bias-related
issues in AI systems, it also introduces challenges associated with cognitive
biases inherent in human decision-making. Our research focuses on reviewing
existing methodologies and ongoing investigations aimed at understanding
annotation attributes that contribute to bias.
|
[
-0.924781322479248,
-0.8132013082504272,
0.5422829389572144,
0.44823092222213745,
0.29691243171691895,
-0.04105136916041374,
-0.06914835423231125,
-1.0134905576705933,
0.21535135805606842,
0.4778693616390228,
-0.4034847021102905,
-0.11184771358966827,
-0.8561917543411255,
0.13221745193004608,
-0.1855691522359848,
1.0378996133804321,
0.25254130363464355,
0.08130551129579544,
-0.35492926836013794,
-0.4113999307155609,
-0.844043493270874,
-0.8457793593406677,
-0.7823057174682617,
-0.46801552176475525,
0.41977956891059875,
0.16572344303131104,
0.9602081775665283,
0.3482777774333954,
0.6151943802833557,
0.25912976264953613,
-0.011195254512131214,
-0.14930960536003113,
0.2744937837123871,
0.09462306648492813,
-0.2855513393878937,
-0.48300281167030334,
-0.295723021030426,
0.2917833626270294,
0.4422675371170044,
1.0440478324890137,
0.3357335329055786,
0.18022474646568298,
0.09751451015472412,
0.6943594217300415,
-0.7932095527648926,
0.17580856382846832,
-0.6457319855690002,
0.4367160201072693,
-0.4055512547492981,
0.022471407428383827,
-0.29989224672317505,
-0.2084576040506363,
0.7236471772193909,
-0.7975428700447083,
0.5111925601959229,
0.14624468982219696,
0.4590682089328766,
1.003142237663269,
-0.27432477474212646,
-0.21835599839687347,
-0.7577248215675354,
1.0119202136993408,
-0.5325737595558167,
-0.07295458763837814,
0.6308594346046448,
0.13591255247592926,
0.07829795032739639,
-0.3205493092536926,
-0.6832464337348938,
0.03219275921583176,
-0.13918784260749817,
-0.1136188805103302,
-0.049875788390636444,
-0.001845861435867846,
0.6561145782470703,
-0.12443610280752182,
-0.22561891376972198,
0.1836477369070053,
-0.13491582870483398,
-0.16269472241401672,
0.9833641648292542,
-0.0749017745256424,
0.3985663652420044,
-0.19161295890808105,
-0.15092146396636963,
0.07730192691087723,
-0.3365563750267029,
-0.15899746119976044,
0.3514123558998108,
0.10148242115974426,
0.2755894660949707,
0.5850382447242737,
-0.23829327523708344,
0.7814687490463257,
-0.19280993938446045,
0.46452564001083374,
0.35832640528678894,
-0.19033263623714447,
-0.13438831269741058,
0.19702784717082977,
0.5681898593902588,
0.46119266748428345,
0.5628341436386108,
0.2654210329055786,
0.09898616373538971,
0.36637622117996216,
0.4928086996078491,
-0.07313026487827301,
-0.23976024985313416,
0.15430264174938202,
-0.2690959572792053,
-0.4073467254638672,
0.04648846760392189,
-0.9940261840820312,
-0.9211691617965698,
-0.24448630213737488,
0.18773069977760315,
-0.15196029841899872,
-0.1452084183692932,
-0.17773452401161194,
-0.5557283163070679,
0.20110276341438293,
0.6805869936943054,
-0.828193187713623,
0.13188746571540833,
0.6777347922325134,
0.6641392111778259,
-0.10274073481559753,
-0.30672842264175415,
0.024456795305013657,
-0.0815003514289856,
-0.2868017554283142,
0.8816531300544739,
-0.4767167568206787,
-0.10215161740779877,
0.23835544288158417,
-0.3762185871601105,
-0.1535729169845581,
-0.5803866386413574,
0.7581676840782166,
-0.25217509269714355,
0.24822816252708435,
-0.5601624846458435,
-0.25330305099487305,
-0.44875481724739075,
0.27850815653800964,
-0.7679731845855713,
1.119600772857666,
-0.06674283742904663,
-0.9624264240264893,
0.7647115588188171,
-1.151011347770691,
-0.47043871879577637,
0.1482827216386795,
-0.5491562485694885,
-0.3710312247276306,
-0.04720556363463402,
0.5044586062431335,
0.2829638719558716,
-0.14480452239513397,
0.15167178213596344,
-0.13732385635375977,
-0.20149913430213928,
0.592522382736206,
-0.4304037094116211,
1.059325098991394,
-0.15922313928604126,
-0.8149964809417725,
0.13705036044120789,
-0.5382447838783264,
-0.26137253642082214,
0.0631682425737381,
-0.11992363631725311,
-0.7643566131591797,
0.43336209654808044,
0.3158853054046631,
0.3032677173614502,
-0.06881920993328094,
-0.34601300954818726,
0.07276993989944458,
-0.20563703775405884,
0.7150908708572388,
0.7989750504493713,
0.1366337239742279,
0.4687422215938568,
-0.3471883237361908,
0.22610065340995789,
0.09570421278476715,
0.38735613226890564,
0.0009218755876645446,
-0.9396780133247375,
-0.8646847009658813,
0.03165207430720329,
0.3382592499256134,
0.8351724743843079,
-0.6967412829399109,
0.38817042112350464,
0.3219095766544342,
-0.09744300693273544,
-0.8225663900375366,
-0.045831192284822464,
0.2546161413192749,
0.5368257164955139,
0.5101541876792908,
-0.5067038536071777,
-0.41020017862319946,
-1.0507838726043701,
-0.44289037585258484,
-0.13095206022262573,
-0.24200639128684998,
0.5286785960197449,
0.6707059741020203,
-0.044825803488492966,
1.0443893671035767,
-0.23155856132507324,
-0.7161874175071716,
0.09624845534563065,
0.16103528439998627,
-0.2853015959262848,
0.8048433661460876,
0.6069476008415222,
-1.0163911581039429,
-0.16405196487903595,
-0.3690001368522644,
-1.0481696128845215,
-0.1787685602903366,
-0.5014441609382629,
-0.047399766743183136,
0.34512290358543396,
0.5920116901397705,
-0.7754053473472595,
0.7961423397064209,
-0.0123964324593544,
-0.5539746284484863,
0.30476778745651245,
0.22953271865844727,
0.09512750059366226,
-0.3887929916381836,
0.09395395219326019,
0.3065233826637268,
0.10107395797967911,
-0.560237467288971,
-0.30828240513801575,
-0.39328888058662415,
0.10200099647045135,
-0.23182989656925201,
0.38634204864501953,
-0.3440065383911133,
-0.2507178485393524,
-0.11510588228702545,
0.4625130593776703,
-0.00248906877823174,
0.2927911579608917,
-0.04008800536394119,
0.6678621768951416,
0.2979695498943329,
-0.4074401557445526,
-0.2194177806377411,
0.48382824659347534,
-0.1396142542362213,
0.7151200175285339,
-0.6164810657501221,
0.01966511644423008,
-0.3067852258682251,
0.10558833181858063,
-0.7038870453834534,
-0.2067616730928421,
0.3784913420677185,
-0.6133798360824585,
0.07179083675146103,
0.16760854423046112,
-0.3903026878833771,
-0.3770717680454254,
-0.5490041375160217,
0.5878502130508423,
0.13565503060817719,
-0.11802605539560318,
0.5904736518859863,
0.7933089137077332,
-0.35989880561828613,
-0.9085842967033386,
-0.9786089658737183,
0.2524431049823761,
-0.23402255773544312,
-0.40404486656188965,
0.33217233419418335,
0.17488031089305878,
-0.743492603302002,
-0.06281010806560516,
0.09835860878229141,
0.14915843307971954,
0.3708116114139557,
0.31992265582084656,
0.17149744927883148,
0.019558044150471687,
0.0014622643357142806,
-0.014600363560020924,
-0.278104692697525,
0.40412113070487976,
-0.22141112387180328,
0.2800850570201874,
0.09166500717401505,
-0.413411945104599,
-0.5400618314743042,
0.610470175743103,
0.5046549439430237,
-0.2325611263513565,
0.5652285218238831,
0.41088569164276123,
-0.5309376120567322,
-0.159689798951149,
-0.8377918004989624,
-0.0519898496568203,
-0.35629576444625854,
0.530428946018219,
0.34209033846855164,
-0.7280842065811157,
0.5745556950569153,
0.03978535905480385,
0.18433959782123566,
0.5144744515419006,
0.39898282289505005,
-0.198723703622818,
1.2728986740112305,
0.870406985282898,
-0.3033590316772461,
0.7266547679901123,
-0.09939764440059662,
0.22827187180519104,
-1.0602221488952637,
-0.17640671133995056,
-0.7384880185127258,
-0.41931504011154175,
-0.8131833076477051,
-0.3477737605571747,
0.16103944182395935,
-0.014150185510516167,
-0.18460150063037872,
-0.26882511377334595,
-0.9957398772239685,
0.49061980843544006,
0.9816824197769165,
-0.1528553068637848,
0.10657330602407455,
-0.44942960143089294,
0.24890893697738647,
-0.3142343759536743,
-0.6846320629119873,
-0.6451537609100342,
1.0136224031448364,
0.3875439167022705,
0.08576453477144241,
-0.23959402740001678,
0.34851667284965515,
0.8211606740951538,
0.46853330731391907,
-0.5251954793930054,
0.35081809759140015,
0.2941940724849701,
-1.0853114128112793,
-0.43864116072654724,
0.14511924982070923,
-0.61881023645401,
0.27659642696380615,
-0.5715085864067078,
-0.9131540656089783,
0.5992308259010315,
0.18933641910552979,
-0.36924847960472107,
0.051567524671554565,
-0.7913090586662292,
0.9034442901611328,
-0.16426467895507812,
-0.4816352128982544,
-0.010450251400470734,
-0.8879128694534302,
0.3267103135585785,
0.010442633181810379,
0.19108249247074127,
-0.2949214577674866,
0.040442969650030136,
1.1178447008132935,
-0.017520297318696976,
0.9247366786003113,
-0.523607611656189,
0.4148865342140198,
0.15465570986270905,
-0.2554212212562561,
0.18263159692287445,
0.27703821659088135,
-0.12492282688617706,
0.7136561870574951,
-0.3205702602863312,
-0.5464043021202087,
-0.2844107449054718,
0.32912150025367737,
-0.8646249771118164,
-0.6809177994728088,
-0.8796150088310242,
-0.8450676202774048,
-0.2352205216884613,
0.269700825214386,
0.023850925266742706,
-0.27408769726753235,
-0.08310183882713318,
-0.3298937678337097,
0.6501795053482056,
-0.5239745378494263,
0.6560983657836914,
0.09516340494155884,
0.09516705572605133,
-0.2835391163825989,
0.5664502382278442,
0.3476545214653015,
-0.031678978353738785,
-0.07673273235559464,
-0.2949400842189789,
0.15271593630313873,
-0.8564401268959045,
-0.3444652855396271,
0.009412971325218678,
-0.7252169847488403,
-0.06699249148368835,
-0.5533756017684937,
-0.22991260886192322,
-0.2143941968679428,
-0.5646696090698242,
-0.12355286628007889,
-0.6516025066375732,
-0.1626109778881073,
-0.1373378485441208,
0.2654799222946167,
0.896353542804718,
-0.0016328940400853753,
0.3232446014881134,
-0.2118808776140213,
0.054144058376550674,
0.15379279851913452,
0.17141501605510712,
0.19780869781970978,
0.18001940846443176,
-0.18042747676372528,
-0.14194923639297485,
-0.46014589071273804,
-0.6738369464874268,
0.2684621214866638,
-0.23780211806297302,
0.7561424374580383,
0.24451981484889984,
0.07250602543354034,
0.33937597274780273,
-0.45141106843948364,
1.124444603919983,
-0.1803923100233078,
-0.9041319489479065,
0.7912503480911255,
-0.2650468945503235,
0.16831471025943756,
0.799201488494873,
0.48173001408576965,
-0.3585013151168823,
-0.5857188105583191,
-0.6552025079727173,
-1.2149100303649902,
0.7677868604660034,
0.41078779101371765,
-0.18831318616867065,
0.041028205305337906,
0.3205771744251251,
-0.021747663617134094,
0.3645070791244507,
-0.7578085660934448,
-0.5205141305923462,
-0.2229558378458023,
-0.051093995571136475,
-0.01900455355644226,
-0.18448711931705475,
-0.2039370834827423,
-0.32582351565361023,
0.5046375393867493,
-0.0056844730861485004,
0.2604205310344696,
0.5220657587051392,
-0.2272452861070633,
0.034206558018922806,
0.08331785351037979,
0.7363055348396301,
0.7230452299118042,
-0.08779328316450119,
0.08142445236444473,
0.17284750938415527,
-0.7341221570968628,
-0.3115048408508301,
0.47839653491973877,
-0.8752574920654297,
-0.016432661563158035,
0.4740718603134155,
0.55838942527771,
-0.13312093913555145,
-0.4751863181591034,
0.43217167258262634,
0.04295935109257698,
-0.13127507269382477,
-0.8359284996986389,
-0.035592176020145416,
-0.2228180170059204,
0.4546039402484894,
0.8017070293426514,
0.647524893283844,
0.2693437337875366,
-0.3625936806201935,
0.09154155850410461,
0.5975920557975769,
-0.5486695170402527,
-0.07950704544782639,
0.8555262088775635,
0.40156885981559753,
-0.5249918699264526,
0.6958638429641724,
0.2541128993034363,
-0.7100356817245483,
0.7141276597976685,
0.0054209427908062935,
0.8334499001502991,
-0.1363186091184616,
-0.0761239230632782,
-0.01193724013864994,
0.7951424717903137,
0.17621378600597382,
-0.011752123013138771,
-0.33977943658828735,
-0.7803341746330261,
-0.36153924465179443,
-0.3382704257965088,
-0.4347933530807495,
-0.1672869324684143,
-0.597122073173523,
0.06568017601966858,
-0.5951341390609741,
-0.6988360285758972,
0.5433108806610107,
0.03693882003426552,
-0.8304771780967712,
0.0848652720451355,
0.36046117544174194,
0.8161000609397888,
-1.0777233839035034,
0.4951557517051697,
0.5518080592155457,
-0.7952528595924377,
-0.1831512749195099,
0.21518273651599884,
0.2648427188396454,
-0.6382046341896057,
0.54825359582901,
0.3582340180873871,
0.36402779817581177,
-0.20536677539348602,
-0.5926302671432495,
-0.7334606051445007,
1.011566400527954,
0.05868988856673241,
-0.3304829001426697,
-0.06354586035013199,
0.2570970952510834,
0.5053825378417969,
-0.34157440066337585,
0.3881855607032776,
0.9277012348175049,
0.8038726449012756,
-0.6506586670875549,
-0.9394446611404419,
0.061727289110422134,
-0.2605580985546112,
0.14886918663978577,
0.12350057810544968,
-0.5682857632637024,
0.7569004893302917,
-0.07795269042253494,
0.10744639486074448,
-0.46847131848335266,
0.3010976314544678,
0.24640606343746185,
0.7193630933761597,
0.3552998900413513,
0.4957309365272522,
0.7043444514274597,
-0.14191865921020508,
0.9290461540222168,
0.04447241872549057,
-0.09292648732662201,
0.9267987608909607,
-0.5992937088012695,
0.4952426552772522,
0.8931708931922913,
-0.10733382403850555,
0.4701107442378998,
0.3895202875137329,
-0.161785289645195,
0.29352089762687683,
0.09831789135932922,
-0.16977088153362274,
0.12076656520366669,
-0.40248361229896545,
-0.31034499406814575,
0.3033209443092346,
0.7251898050308228,
-0.4516369700431824,
0.2208598405122757,
0.08989036083221436,
0.025790926069021225,
0.23555180430412292,
-0.26164162158966064,
0.8670507669448853,
0.020526697859168053,
-0.7433141469955444,
-0.17981792986392975,
-0.1304936707019806,
1.085435390472412,
-0.25412261486053467,
-0.3164769411087036,
0.0033519479911774397,
0.12675513327121735,
-0.3255902826786041,
-0.8181402087211609,
0.6186951994895935,
-0.19268172979354858,
-0.4695264399051666,
-0.2716682255268097,
0.731784999370575,
0.05805794894695282,
-0.2981662452220917,
0.3259090483188629,
0.5300289392471313,
-0.09556041657924652,
-0.21810396015644073,
-0.9179753065109253,
0.23266303539276123,
-0.03523210436105728,
-0.39532577991485596,
0.31588077545166016,
0.3779142200946808,
-0.4990188479423523,
0.567946195602417,
0.5384335517883301,
0.0713457390666008,
0.12785007059574127,
0.09501727670431137,
0.5207512378692627,
-0.9103624224662781,
-0.35132890939712524,
-0.8457967638969421,
0.6516618132591248,
-0.49458783864974976,
-0.49593788385391235,
0.9407163858413696,
0.18990619480609894,
1.0490866899490356,
0.009606200270354748,
1.2340643405914307,
-0.2586117684841156,
0.35501840710639954,
-0.0641835555434227,
1.025481104850769,
-0.07896724343299866,
0.300197035074234,
-0.5990318655967712,
-0.7881312370300293,
-0.7363718152046204,
0.9585119485855103,
-0.5559012293815613,
0.21795953810214996,
0.4880768656730652,
0.4141273498535156,
0.463640034198761,
0.1305929571390152,
-0.0902983695268631,
-0.01940007507801056,
0.2760443687438965,
0.4297396242618561,
0.9341983795166016,
-0.4926765561103821,
0.09310656785964966,
-0.3038439154624939,
-0.3087586760520935,
-0.2602027356624603,
-0.7781386971473694,
-0.8150234222412109,
-0.5501400828361511,
-0.5227217674255371,
-0.08833835273981094,
0.007973071187734604,
0.6275307536125183,
0.5801866054534912,
-0.8325650691986084,
0.10168883949518204,
-0.1810852587223053,
0.545613706111908,
-0.4173290729522705,
-0.3755244016647339,
0.28790906071662903,
-0.2937360405921936,
-0.6167455315589905,
-0.3122835159301758,
0.37274739146232605,
-0.03929060697555542,
-0.5493735671043396,
0.2822972238063812,
-0.6106824278831482,
0.15963388979434967,
0.6200026273727417,
0.29656168818473816,
-0.8002787232398987,
-0.4613327085971832,
-0.35138022899627686,
0.09177550673484802,
-0.0731646940112114,
0.8470973968505859,
-1.0169215202331543,
0.1725398451089859,
0.28197336196899414,
0.6775732636451721,
0.1457546055316925,
-0.1288422793149948,
0.5989181399345398,
-0.8114525079727173,
0.4747816026210785,
0.7334770560264587,
0.21647806465625763,
0.6248202323913574,
-0.42682865262031555,
0.5754777193069458,
0.33252575993537903,
-0.8037253022193909,
-1.0228972434997559,
-0.00814144592732191,
-0.928154706954956,
-0.22333048284053802,
0.6325387954711914,
0.27945712208747864,
-0.1518033891916275,
-0.6814993619918823,
-0.2417674958705902,
0.1371486634016037,
-0.3360174000263214,
1.2452062368392944,
0.7770419716835022,
-0.5627325177192688,
0.02683219686150551,
-1.186294674873352,
0.8268316984176636,
0.794525146484375,
-0.7057209014892578,
0.17569057643413544,
0.6529005765914917,
-0.13469520211219788,
0.7137312293052673,
0.7536991238594055,
-0.08814891427755356,
0.23215241730213165,
0.21938909590244293,
0.31213364005088806,
0.11683592200279236,
-0.33518895506858826,
-0.3821597099304199,
0.07290420681238174,
0.35968583822250366,
-0.12188141793012619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19065v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19065v1
|
HELPER-X: A Unified Instructable Embodied Agent to Tackle Four Interactive Vision-Language Domains with Memory-Augmented Language Models
| 2024-04-29T19:12:42 | 2024-04-29T19:12:42 |
Gabriel Sarch, Sahil Somani, Raghav Kapoor, Michael J. Tarr, Katerina Fragkiadaki
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Recent research on instructable agents has used memory-augmented Large
Language Models (LLMs) as task planners, a technique that retrieves
language-program examples relevant to the input instruction and uses them as
in-context examples in the LLM prompt to improve the performance of the LLM in
inferring the correct action and task plans. In this technical report, we
extend the capabilities of HELPER, by expanding its memory with a wider array
of examples and prompts, and by integrating additional APIs for asking
questions. This simple expansion of HELPER into a shared memory enables the
agent to work across the domains of executing plans from dialogue, natural
language instruction following, active question asking, and commonsense room
reorganization. We evaluate the agent on four diverse interactive
visual-language embodied agent benchmarks: ALFRED, TEACh, DialFRED, and the
Tidy Task. HELPER-X achieves few-shot, state-of-the-art performance across
these benchmarks using a single agent, without requiring in-domain training,
and remains competitive with agents that have undergone in-domain training.
|
[
-0.32798343896865845,
-0.40036535263061523,
0.6332545876502991,
-0.19165082275867462,
0.009810922667384148,
0.11224790662527084,
-0.15473613142967224,
-0.44762250781059265,
0.23657861351966858,
0.6350211501121521,
-0.3115521967411041,
-0.204755499958992,
-0.48214054107666016,
-0.05928459018468857,
-0.2593606114387512,
0.6583396196365356,
-0.1939038634300232,
0.008648245595395565,
-0.4191032350063324,
-0.196491077542305,
-0.695228099822998,
-0.5304985642433167,
-0.5757196545600891,
-0.3213450312614441,
0.513041615486145,
0.5764070153236389,
0.9989322423934937,
0.31590983271598816,
0.16817019879817963,
0.4316897988319397,
0.3644929826259613,
0.20792877674102783,
-0.31926465034484863,
0.16125699877738953,
-0.21453091502189636,
-0.6170411705970764,
-0.6653950214385986,
-0.23207242786884308,
0.7286102175712585,
0.44220948219299316,
-0.0032311324030160904,
-0.14971157908439636,
-0.08773297071456909,
0.1961168795824051,
-0.7379847764968872,
0.5385056734085083,
-0.25482699275016785,
-0.1417533904314041,
0.14092272520065308,
-0.12739300727844238,
-0.39997056126594543,
0.09110114723443985,
0.13660846650600433,
-0.7617517709732056,
0.00794934667646885,
0.09353743493556976,
0.3830850124359131,
0.5271379947662354,
-0.19849058985710144,
-0.11841897666454315,
-0.43362921476364136,
0.9115229845046997,
-0.27994173765182495,
0.4849703311920166,
0.3145740330219269,
0.507253110408783,
-0.3196410536766052,
-0.8969118595123291,
-0.6939255595207214,
-0.34971240162849426,
-0.1425444632768631,
0.061787199229002,
-0.45526453852653503,
0.24217911064624786,
0.19145584106445312,
0.137086883187294,
-0.49215593934059143,
-0.26033124327659607,
0.035440489649772644,
0.04085499793291092,
0.4870283007621765,
0.3597795367240906,
0.6733158230781555,
0.15880756080150604,
-0.3075430691242218,
-0.38138696551322937,
-0.45432934165000916,
-0.21506313979625702,
-0.15020576119422913,
0.12546612322330475,
0.028952794149518013,
0.4116283059120178,
-0.1387445479631424,
0.6930766701698303,
-0.009015490300953388,
0.1636287271976471,
-0.15566860139369965,
-0.0006399965495802462,
-0.21487319469451904,
-0.07672693580389023,
0.3838667869567871,
0.4567801356315613,
0.14635640382766724,
-0.502780556678772,
-0.25732389092445374,
0.019267378374934196,
0.5700276494026184,
-0.6976998448371887,
-0.26575058698654175,
0.04371175915002823,
-0.068293496966362,
0.36310485005378723,
-0.18053598701953888,
-0.42604944109916687,
-0.40078216791152954,
-0.285989910364151,
0.7283143997192383,
-0.5382919907569885,
-0.2779958248138428,
0.24186423420906067,
-0.26314613223075867,
0.33021995425224304,
0.44930243492126465,
-0.7514866590499878,
0.7300171852111816,
0.6019620895385742,
0.38419803977012634,
-0.3255278766155243,
-0.4740974009037018,
-0.6234762668609619,
0.2764369249343872,
-0.24292558431625366,
0.8627161979675293,
-0.8423278331756592,
-0.3019271790981293,
0.08249981701374054,
0.10709382593631744,
-0.12025916576385498,
-0.5905410647392273,
0.17130577564239502,
-0.5490922331809998,
0.1576004922389984,
-0.3155083954334259,
-0.6173722147941589,
-0.28131425380706787,
0.2883673310279846,
-0.6843042373657227,
0.876950204372406,
0.42708101868629456,
-0.30568739771842957,
0.43684372305870056,
-0.6905410289764404,
0.029442230239510536,
0.6475996971130371,
-0.5581619143486023,
0.010667006485164165,
0.05745772644877434,
0.10996272414922714,
0.6673501133918762,
-0.2519407272338867,
-0.12249746173620224,
0.1267099231481552,
-0.6158449649810791,
0.16728082299232483,
-0.27174124121665955,
0.3977961242198944,
-0.36791810393333435,
-0.43217235803604126,
0.38667553663253784,
-0.7623350024223328,
0.10352542251348495,
0.19813108444213867,
0.043132200837135315,
-0.559501051902771,
-0.17021691799163818,
0.13931429386138916,
0.10189206898212433,
0.165723979473114,
-0.54302978515625,
0.490904837846756,
-0.17032195627689362,
-0.11665797978639603,
0.44919073581695557,
-0.19454538822174072,
0.6794108152389526,
-0.5079421997070312,
0.7587132453918457,
-0.36662524938583374,
0.08353588730096817,
-0.3954969048500061,
-0.5141844153404236,
-0.9563970565795898,
-0.5290249586105347,
-0.4250137209892273,
0.37073975801467896,
-1.1075176000595093,
-0.10470253229141235,
-0.22652223706245422,
-0.28169533610343933,
-0.25331372022628784,
0.04633006826043129,
0.6906697750091553,
0.13614365458488464,
0.41238513588905334,
-0.1760631501674652,
-0.291680246591568,
-0.5946525931358337,
0.030425846576690674,
-0.13791917264461517,
0.2141520380973816,
0.22099070250988007,
0.4911567270755768,
-0.20910920202732086,
0.8907058835029602,
-0.46648380160331726,
-0.1123054102063179,
-0.4639998972415924,
-0.17804385721683502,
-0.12800481915473938,
0.3648986518383026,
0.5542149543762207,
-0.8063309192657471,
-0.5055460929870605,
0.011807185597717762,
-0.6595765948295593,
0.13969369232654572,
-0.08009002357721329,
-0.15715515613555908,
0.15779827535152435,
0.26082709431648254,
-0.7306658029556274,
0.5401136875152588,
0.47668197751045227,
-0.48940733075141907,
0.4639705717563629,
-0.52801513671875,
0.15018200874328613,
-1.111750841140747,
-0.36705654859542847,
-0.27033883333206177,
-0.296759694814682,
-0.6774307489395142,
0.3842722475528717,
0.09328760206699371,
-0.038908813148736954,
-0.4007433354854584,
1.1571389436721802,
-0.8242002725601196,
-0.046921033412218094,
-0.7714201807975769,
-0.015361877158284187,
-0.25007012486457825,
0.7499526143074036,
0.20361413061618805,
0.9941450357437134,
0.8024584054946899,
-0.6125866770744324,
0.3391832709312439,
0.42866280674934387,
-0.266550213098526,
0.5645186901092529,
-0.5512505173683167,
0.42725226283073425,
-0.03400193899869919,
0.01663888245820999,
-0.8799900412559509,
-0.32154664397239685,
0.3973948359489441,
-0.026213515549898148,
0.43778204917907715,
-0.07273393124341965,
-0.6008464694023132,
-0.14709211885929108,
-0.10507135093212128,
0.4990371763706207,
0.48791128396987915,
-0.9073649644851685,
0.8184336423873901,
0.2969473600387573,
-0.02792121097445488,
-0.6200747489929199,
-0.40762877464294434,
0.15098214149475098,
0.09790406376123428,
-0.4965325891971588,
0.42466267943382263,
-0.2575812041759491,
-0.3987501263618469,
0.2653875946998596,
-0.20534618198871613,
-0.19047760963439941,
-0.30189943313598633,
0.5353136658668518,
0.21276411414146423,
-0.09683457762002945,
0.12140154093503952,
0.024152670055627823,
-0.32731929421424866,
-0.033859796822071075,
-0.19114001095294952,
0.4243660569190979,
-0.13527825474739075,
-0.5630152821540833,
-0.22623467445373535,
0.5180686116218567,
0.6173112988471985,
-0.12941068410873413,
0.6400262117385864,
0.01900125853717327,
-0.344154953956604,
-0.4391835927963257,
-0.522312581539154,
-0.13538220524787903,
-0.4619360566139221,
0.4407584071159363,
-0.4285942614078522,
-0.9280595779418945,
0.34774643182754517,
0.0756022110581398,
0.1386844515800476,
-0.24070128798484802,
0.3482006788253784,
0.14709588885307312,
0.8934926390647888,
0.9361829161643982,
0.07080920040607452,
0.780634343624115,
-0.4803718030452728,
-0.24587447941303253,
-0.6489199995994568,
-0.21941742300987244,
0.03809836506843567,
-0.09071663022041321,
-0.14101122319698334,
-1.0319433212280273,
0.2934080958366394,
-0.3786991536617279,
-0.17092405259609222,
0.6165298223495483,
-0.4103655517101288,
0.5372897386550903,
0.5405289530754089,
0.11908947676420212,
0.15171799063682556,
-0.09371469914913177,
0.08038061112165451,
0.24882644414901733,
-0.841213047504425,
-0.7247390747070312,
0.8085138201713562,
-0.0198587067425251,
0.723939836025238,
-0.02339152991771698,
0.7312270402908325,
0.08393655717372894,
0.30284348130226135,
-0.8155642747879028,
0.8999692797660828,
0.02256442978978157,
-0.6108454465866089,
-0.21896308660507202,
0.18571868538856506,
-0.9171284437179565,
0.4276999235153198,
0.04826388880610466,
-0.8811121582984924,
0.13876567780971527,
0.258868008852005,
-0.26202765107154846,
0.35337159037590027,
-0.7523983716964722,
0.8137707710266113,
-0.28969529271125793,
-0.5332354307174683,
-0.5414653420448303,
-0.34101712703704834,
-0.06338649243116379,
0.049141231924295425,
-0.38528990745544434,
0.09141965955495834,
-0.4288111925125122,
0.4181579053401947,
-0.3989296853542328,
1.0618956089019775,
-0.22994305193424225,
-0.08477021753787994,
0.3999018669128418,
-0.03160714730620384,
0.5018524527549744,
-0.2304394692182541,
-0.01660638488829136,
-0.03423352539539337,
0.005181599874049425,
-0.5272291302680969,
-1.0113787651062012,
0.6039379835128784,
-0.5536249279975891,
-0.7337010502815247,
-0.3187289237976074,
-0.9882498979568481,
-0.2964116036891937,
0.08820460736751556,
-0.24874603748321533,
0.7847365140914917,
-0.33871376514434814,
-0.06092500314116478,
0.47076091170310974,
-0.2335503250360489,
0.5179963707923889,
0.6849847435951233,
0.02530958503484726,
-0.28840768337249756,
0.8471994996070862,
0.0905769020318985,
0.2530469000339508,
0.7829000949859619,
-0.02345850318670273,
-0.13160920143127441,
-0.4217511713504791,
-0.4649626612663269,
0.11689616739749908,
-0.7223212122917175,
-0.07639171183109283,
-0.6965428590774536,
0.01690058968961239,
-0.0004792613908648491,
-0.34926527738571167,
-0.306204229593277,
-0.2679053843021393,
0.019871437922120094,
0.022547515109181404,
0.42890775203704834,
0.8891937136650085,
0.13272440433502197,
0.6008855104446411,
-0.7357097864151001,
0.38298299908638,
0.5733988881111145,
0.3096579909324646,
0.01225636899471283,
-0.26969191431999207,
-0.39562493562698364,
-0.22540420293807983,
-0.11396396160125732,
-0.8136376142501831,
0.3170899748802185,
-0.05454372614622116,
0.9723332524299622,
0.3648880422115326,
0.004103827755898237,
0.7571173906326294,
-0.5756405591964722,
0.5933233499526978,
0.15331760048866272,
-0.6559364199638367,
0.1869458109140396,
-0.1515301764011383,
0.3980715274810791,
0.28926265239715576,
0.2542097270488739,
-0.3145066201686859,
-0.5096012353897095,
-0.5706304907798767,
-0.5444567799568176,
0.8025487065315247,
0.27783098816871643,
0.42045876383781433,
-0.11779840290546417,
0.41160914301872253,
0.2848648428916931,
0.0780472531914711,
-0.2589948773384094,
-0.31870290637016296,
-0.028790000826120377,
-0.09201634675264359,
-0.13528959453105927,
-0.339863657951355,
0.10321591794490814,
-0.26432663202285767,
0.4502720236778259,
-0.3282010853290558,
0.4467863440513611,
0.03639356046915054,
-0.2950344979763031,
0.04054797813296318,
0.29523733258247375,
0.36554276943206787,
0.6121940016746521,
-0.01916617527604103,
0.15673531591892242,
0.3733368217945099,
-0.5171181559562683,
0.1453929990530014,
0.23157617449760437,
0.06866347044706345,
-0.20620936155319214,
0.4738794267177582,
0.7931520938873291,
0.6959142088890076,
-0.8984077572822571,
0.3391980230808258,
-0.22821080684661865,
0.08649636059999466,
-0.3491757810115814,
0.5265449285507202,
-0.18883879482746124,
0.6355504989624023,
0.35401451587677,
-0.09318212419748306,
0.0730336606502533,
-0.617699384689331,
0.37987712025642395,
0.39609724283218384,
-0.5960086584091187,
-0.5265730023384094,
0.5450018644332886,
0.07821915298700333,
-0.4037236273288727,
0.27622687816619873,
-0.3121638596057892,
-0.4244611859321594,
0.4213792681694031,
0.6722522974014282,
0.9939423203468323,
-0.14435172080993652,
0.12156786024570465,
0.0760149210691452,
0.0881800726056099,
0.0234014093875885,
0.6507641673088074,
-0.5257383584976196,
-0.8654661178588867,
-0.41972437500953674,
-0.0635489746928215,
-0.6211162209510803,
-0.21926653385162354,
-0.501681387424469,
-0.08904096484184265,
-0.19111350178718567,
-0.00866200402379036,
-0.2051859349012375,
0.0677790716290474,
-0.6995091438293457,
0.15457578003406525,
0.1828438639640808,
0.939725399017334,
-0.3935259282588959,
1.037291169166565,
1.2461532354354858,
-0.7099882960319519,
-0.7669252157211304,
0.04354221746325493,
-0.10335619002580643,
-0.9186971783638,
0.5468052625656128,
0.0591806024312973,
-0.5732008814811707,
-0.0434059239923954,
-0.7115113735198975,
-0.6951088905334473,
1.211186170578003,
0.69706130027771,
-0.39521515369415283,
-0.12571096420288086,
-0.020891616120934486,
0.46529626846313477,
-0.3561490774154663,
0.5165243148803711,
0.36182519793510437,
0.31748154759407043,
0.07088860869407654,
-0.863693356513977,
0.2623138129711151,
-0.41521281003952026,
-0.21561497449874878,
0.3192598223686218,
-0.7147538661956787,
0.4494079351425171,
-0.4322768449783325,
-0.1622477024793625,
0.5070990324020386,
0.7550880908966064,
0.2583048641681671,
0.48479118943214417,
0.6046367883682251,
0.24876132607460022,
0.6061915159225464,
0.2456226795911789,
1.2667274475097656,
-0.4099423587322235,
-0.22016941010951996,
1.3318675756454468,
-0.3166544437408447,
0.7949999570846558,
0.4997241795063019,
0.20978350937366486,
0.5456754565238953,
-0.18717661499977112,
0.3481944501399994,
0.40377774834632874,
-0.08796346187591553,
-0.5135172009468079,
-0.3591074049472809,
-0.23510344326496124,
-0.01851489022374153,
0.529128909111023,
0.2981686592102051,
0.0414416640996933,
-0.1259981244802475,
0.3096652030944824,
-0.04517441615462303,
0.04291725158691406,
-0.3569868206977844,
0.6727128028869629,
0.03302546590566635,
-0.7104935646057129,
0.3025625944137573,
-0.4356032609939575,
0.4780712425708771,
-0.6572019457817078,
-0.5581214427947998,
-0.19314196705818176,
0.48556646704673767,
0.11590997129678726,
-0.8895100355148315,
0.0172463059425354,
-0.12019024044275284,
-0.023886865004897118,
-0.4924423396587372,
0.9425182938575745,
-0.4221245348453522,
-0.0907173678278923,
0.5092476010322571,
0.5451369881629944,
0.3831794261932373,
-0.28201788663864136,
-0.3958934545516968,
-0.018866565078496933,
-0.32432693243026733,
0.06558362394571304,
0.3637816905975342,
0.3311231732368469,
-0.37026622891426086,
1.0224847793579102,
0.11516188830137253,
-0.25575491786003113,
0.184189572930336,
0.1001318171620369,
1.1549772024154663,
-0.6866062879562378,
-0.22482065856456757,
-0.39697974920272827,
0.7179471254348755,
-0.06978121399879456,
-0.1317909210920334,
0.8711178302764893,
0.45549479126930237,
0.9040571451187134,
-0.2101292908191681,
0.5744920372962952,
-0.04167862609028816,
0.009258733130991459,
-0.24586895108222961,
0.6304495930671692,
-0.7331716418266296,
-0.14693982899188995,
-0.3822581470012665,
-0.7181116938591003,
-0.17849959433078766,
0.5357043743133545,
-0.18627268075942993,
0.1341276913881302,
0.6586587429046631,
0.9470385909080505,
-0.14754299819469452,
-0.12104426324367523,
0.9056195020675659,
-0.1928558349609375,
0.19424773752689362,
0.6162307858467102,
1.1883132457733154,
-0.38768038153648376,
0.5931375622749329,
-0.28426381945610046,
-0.27384188771247864,
-0.02568318508565426,
-0.48325473070144653,
-1.0795034170150757,
-0.8350757360458374,
-0.5544209480285645,
0.09769679605960846,
0.19941829144954681,
1.137235164642334,
1.0831667184829712,
-0.5834406614303589,
-0.3168965280056,
0.07115110754966736,
0.08036824315786362,
-0.5056505799293518,
-0.08851761370897293,
0.2462415248155594,
-0.2501611113548279,
-1.0280238389968872,
0.7925946712493896,
0.4936346113681793,
-0.032368823885917664,
-0.2892751395702362,
-0.36548322439193726,
0.18806898593902588,
0.14902137219905853,
0.7924035787582397,
0.4847123920917511,
-0.6950908899307251,
-0.4006921350955963,
0.09913204610347748,
-0.01314883679151535,
-0.1301138997077942,
0.8744496703147888,
-0.8870179653167725,
0.7674227356910706,
0.25674402713775635,
0.6682440638542175,
0.36585521697998047,
-0.2791212201118469,
0.7702059149742126,
-0.6473291516304016,
0.34513238072395325,
0.11676356196403503,
0.5707235336303711,
0.10592065006494522,
-0.2637532949447632,
0.3531981110572815,
-0.24731747806072235,
-0.45452558994293213,
-0.3864233195781708,
0.046783022582530975,
-1.2220155000686646,
-0.18943364918231964,
1.1272953748703003,
-0.1397327482700348,
-0.3383687436580658,
-0.26548463106155396,
-0.6811667084693909,
0.18272632360458374,
-0.48154041171073914,
0.44070419669151306,
0.3538530468940735,
-0.3447369337081909,
-0.5658560991287231,
-0.4913090765476227,
0.31914934515953064,
0.31721723079681396,
-0.8779876828193665,
0.015569756738841534,
0.6811636090278625,
0.1043693795800209,
0.13040271401405334,
0.8776731491088867,
0.15447865426540375,
0.5599168539047241,
0.19083592295646667,
0.4364258646965027,
-0.27293622493743896,
-0.5264047980308533,
-0.1974233239889145,
0.15324781835079193,
0.13806045055389404,
-0.6265459060668945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19063v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19063v1
|
SuperCLUE-Fin: Graded Fine-Grained Analysis of Chinese LLMs on Diverse Financial Tasks and Applications
| 2024-04-29T19:04:35 | 2024-04-29T19:04:35 |
Liang Xu, Lei Zhu, Yaotong Wu, Hang Xue
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The SuperCLUE-Fin (SC-Fin) benchmark is a pioneering evaluation framework
tailored for Chinese-native financial large language models (FLMs). It assesses
FLMs across six financial application domains and twenty-five specialized
tasks, encompassing theoretical knowledge and practical applications such as
compliance, risk management, and investment analysis. Using multi-turn,
open-ended conversations that mimic real-life scenarios, SC-Fin measures models
on a range of criteria, including accurate financial understanding, logical
reasoning, clarity, computational efficiency, business acumen, risk perception,
and compliance with Chinese regulations.
In a rigorous evaluation involving over a thousand questions, SC-Fin
identifies a performance hierarchy where domestic models like GLM-4 and
MoonShot-v1-128k outperform others with an A-grade, highlighting the potential
for further development in transforming theoretical knowledge into pragmatic
financial solutions. This benchmark serves as a critical tool for refining FLMs
in the Chinese context, directing improvements in financial knowledge
databases, standardizing financial interpretations, and promoting models that
prioritize compliance, risk management, and secure practices.
We create a contextually relevant and comprehensive benchmark that drives the
development of AI in the Chinese financial sector. SC-Fin facilitates the
advancement and responsible deployment of FLMs, offering valuable insights for
enhancing model performance and usability for both individual and institutional
users in the Chinese market..~\footnote{Our benchmark can be found at
\url{https://www.CLUEbenchmarks.com}}.
|
[
-0.22743448615074158,
-0.8417298793792725,
0.0881054550409317,
0.11239953339099884,
-0.23084083199501038,
0.24115964770317078,
-0.20897077023983002,
-0.7095891833305359,
-0.060721155256032944,
0.5563082695007324,
-0.4367925822734833,
-0.5785391330718994,
-0.04151911288499832,
-0.3540947735309601,
-0.47153183817863464,
1.246671199798584,
0.17384073138237,
0.25057780742645264,
-0.008834830485284328,
0.11169423162937164,
0.14619722962379456,
-0.6547738909721375,
-0.8200417160987854,
-0.29536327719688416,
0.13001751899719238,
0.20748993754386902,
0.7187548279762268,
0.6773638129234314,
0.8913014531135559,
0.2077479213476181,
0.010556768625974655,
0.21803969144821167,
-0.5737342834472656,
-0.23743122816085815,
-0.313800573348999,
-0.2935933768749237,
-0.7713946104049683,
0.04423776641488075,
0.42652779817581177,
0.5262686610221863,
-0.3605961203575134,
0.5336715579032898,
0.05315990000963211,
0.8248141407966614,
-0.6177296042442322,
0.4449746906757355,
-0.290555477142334,
-0.15226836502552032,
-0.5759767889976501,
-0.09810438752174377,
-0.1730699986219406,
-0.5071337223052979,
0.42061150074005127,
-0.7310938835144043,
0.11652794480323792,
0.2285524159669876,
1.0389472246170044,
-0.1442084163427353,
-0.526970386505127,
-0.10246927291154861,
-0.5859848856925964,
0.7313241362571716,
-0.6613506078720093,
0.37321197986602783,
0.1176275759935379,
0.6639735698699951,
-0.19411881268024445,
-0.980800211429596,
-0.1823320835828781,
-0.1924949735403061,
-0.046659816056489944,
0.09868727624416351,
0.03344177082180977,
0.22001929581165314,
0.06354718655347824,
0.821304440498352,
-0.48434263467788696,
-0.22500860691070557,
-0.49924135208129883,
-0.5816941261291504,
0.9260083436965942,
0.31381696462631226,
0.15554949641227722,
0.2555544376373291,
-0.9219734072685242,
-0.28838860988616943,
-0.6679565906524658,
0.28012996912002563,
0.34471526741981506,
0.5544297099113464,
-0.2329489290714264,
0.062466010451316833,
-0.21515633165836334,
0.5001907348632812,
-0.06214074045419693,
-0.37323346734046936,
0.23081019520759583,
-0.48132142424583435,
-0.4088206887245178,
0.23600728809833527,
0.4747394919395447,
0.5122057795524597,
0.30738455057144165,
0.18607960641384125,
-0.49855121970176697,
-0.03060496412217617,
-0.16848161816596985,
-0.6598461866378784,
-0.2018744796514511,
0.1387096792459488,
-0.5115527510643005,
-0.23671261966228485,
0.44111528992652893,
-0.60670405626297,
-0.31116172671318054,
-0.3196046054363251,
0.19018931686878204,
-0.19650636613368988,
-0.3665044605731964,
0.23988811671733856,
-0.15011285245418549,
0.41027480363845825,
0.0793214663863182,
-0.871485710144043,
0.604179322719574,
1.1159356832504272,
0.5382951498031616,
-0.1770220696926117,
-0.19144891202449799,
-0.4924100935459137,
0.3318125009536743,
-0.5766090154647827,
1.0223184823989868,
-0.43659472465515137,
-0.23976635932922363,
-0.030312679708003998,
-0.09340621531009674,
-0.1534300297498703,
-0.6286514401435852,
0.5380966067314148,
-0.40273457765579224,
-0.22563715279102325,
-0.3939840495586395,
-0.5929177403450012,
-0.4871648848056793,
0.35039469599723816,
-0.37693846225738525,
1.303542137145996,
0.3830797076225281,
-0.7137137651443481,
0.5142709016799927,
-0.5832376480102539,
-0.1661704182624817,
0.4177997410297394,
-0.14136232435703278,
0.031037600710988045,
-0.03239281848073006,
-0.11071234196424484,
0.5165334939956665,
-0.7982423305511475,
0.5099618434906006,
-0.47468820214271545,
-0.8165280222892761,
0.20712026953697205,
-0.43437081575393677,
0.3971276879310608,
0.23388728499412537,
-0.3998001515865326,
0.4612746238708496,
-0.9873132705688477,
-0.007433888502418995,
-0.03868570923805237,
0.11968334764242172,
-0.8027524948120117,
-0.17725957930088043,
0.33219048380851746,
0.31479334831237793,
0.7435480356216431,
-0.43632084131240845,
-0.13347207009792328,
-0.6143936514854431,
0.6948788166046143,
0.8991184830665588,
-0.051765553653240204,
-0.15584217011928558,
-0.4164942502975464,
0.3565332889556885,
-0.2889336049556732,
0.4540101885795593,
-0.1746383160352707,
0.1619025468826294,
-0.6723307371139526,
-0.2431740164756775,
0.5191870331764221,
0.6212067008018494,
-0.45314061641693115,
0.008058758452534676,
0.04502672702074051,
-0.7950983047485352,
-0.2956848442554474,
0.24024254083633423,
0.5184875726699829,
0.3542345464229584,
0.3184943199157715,
-0.25251585245132446,
-0.33042725920677185,
-1.1016911268234253,
-0.3011474013328552,
-0.15216295421123505,
0.16463728249073029,
0.1863788217306137,
0.4022398591041565,
-0.001954355277121067,
0.5670376420021057,
-0.45888206362724304,
-0.2737024426460266,
-0.27790045738220215,
-0.011593608185648918,
0.23411375284194946,
0.4986879825592041,
0.6042974591255188,
-0.9568727016448975,
-0.3801957070827484,
0.3542793393135071,
-0.6156142950057983,
0.09866926819086075,
-0.27389979362487793,
-0.48182642459869385,
0.2843449115753174,
0.6599537134170532,
-0.07873031497001648,
0.3033926486968994,
0.4138679802417755,
-0.3613468408584595,
1.027706265449524,
-0.40781745314598083,
0.11965972930192947,
-0.38740068674087524,
0.3244498372077942,
0.21520811319351196,
0.09206192195415497,
-0.6870650053024292,
0.6148508787155151,
0.06130446493625641,
0.25463005900382996,
-0.6505982875823975,
0.6171758770942688,
-0.058386508375406265,
-0.4114379286766052,
-0.06612783670425415,
0.40675628185272217,
-0.16054490208625793,
0.5548803806304932,
-0.1854931116104126,
0.9890550374984741,
0.4296821653842926,
-0.5941505432128906,
0.3689696490764618,
-0.4682961106300354,
-0.2646440267562866,
0.8611049056053162,
-0.7429401278495789,
-0.10317256301641464,
0.5988423824310303,
0.06281901150941849,
-1.039154291152954,
-0.07698744535446167,
0.08423683047294617,
0.21577046811580658,
0.008755568414926529,
0.47450685501098633,
-0.48446890711784363,
-0.5394036769866943,
-0.5649065375328064,
0.472019761800766,
-0.10431405156850815,
-0.33853480219841003,
0.5573215484619141,
0.24211901426315308,
-0.09942009299993515,
-0.5278857946395874,
-0.6901935338973999,
-0.19467921555042267,
-0.31777265667915344,
-0.6983276605606079,
0.4320763647556305,
-0.19916653633117676,
-0.31542471051216125,
-0.16133147478103638,
-0.5995154976844788,
-0.06877458840608597,
0.2775275707244873,
0.014136414974927902,
0.8549627661705017,
-0.5374572277069092,
-0.2570561170578003,
0.056537482887506485,
-0.5416594743728638,
0.04377671703696251,
-0.4096873700618744,
0.42903512716293335,
-0.7438291907310486,
-0.26911604404449463,
-0.44445285201072693,
-0.13173933327198029,
0.7483683228492737,
-0.24624958634376526,
0.3778608739376068,
0.6250340938568115,
-0.5158981680870056,
0.02047700062394142,
-0.6554011702537537,
0.22368450462818146,
-0.5969119071960449,
0.10876356810331345,
-0.4515992999076843,
-1.1668126583099365,
0.7993634343147278,
-0.09187152981758118,
0.3288438618183136,
0.7392633557319641,
0.4121180772781372,
0.24723070859909058,
0.7608613967895508,
0.7818524837493896,
-0.10450964421033859,
0.3187471628189087,
-0.266044944524765,
0.08968112617731094,
-0.5945863723754883,
-0.14083021879196167,
-0.2278226763010025,
-0.1801861673593521,
-0.48744115233421326,
-0.18178558349609375,
0.2213624119758606,
0.2585715353488922,
-0.6230570077896118,
0.45127367973327637,
-0.42047393321990967,
0.3224424421787262,
0.4573097825050354,
-0.14848139882087708,
0.45004913210868835,
-0.21981091797351837,
-0.43184053897857666,
-0.05654501914978027,
-0.5257173180580139,
-0.6565389037132263,
1.087253451347351,
0.49042773246765137,
0.5104426145553589,
-0.3752077519893646,
0.48235568404197693,
0.5960358381271362,
0.36422106623649597,
-0.3893139958381653,
0.6641077995300293,
-0.4822334349155426,
-0.6546788215637207,
-0.14227807521820068,
-0.294525146484375,
-0.39378631114959717,
0.24611076712608337,
-0.08198439329862595,
-0.6790457963943481,
0.14333365857601166,
0.1309283971786499,
-0.8379737138748169,
0.2528977394104004,
-0.32654869556427,
1.1467697620391846,
-0.35253018140792847,
-0.41605764627456665,
-0.3442741334438324,
-0.4080717861652374,
0.8860052824020386,
-0.26820066571235657,
0.5191612243652344,
-0.25839313864707947,
-0.011830436065793037,
0.660560131072998,
-0.4158787131309509,
0.48180240392684937,
-0.10572361201047897,
-0.5111957788467407,
0.6056419014930725,
0.032748181372880936,
0.24613040685653687,
0.07407014071941376,
-0.27574777603149414,
0.3932305872440338,
0.5118520259857178,
-0.4427652359008789,
-0.40998560190200806,
0.7438565492630005,
-0.5182247161865234,
-0.3616454303264618,
-0.44966238737106323,
-0.5461616516113281,
0.00555827934294939,
0.2133084386587143,
-0.11258241534233093,
0.5248769521713257,
-0.30861055850982666,
0.0932755172252655,
0.35569801926612854,
-0.10203662514686584,
0.28719520568847656,
0.7133750319480896,
-0.42291969060897827,
-0.41585206985473633,
1.4191159009933472,
0.25463786721229553,
0.2968094050884247,
0.1945813149213791,
0.27876612544059753,
-0.38784879446029663,
-0.3870027959346771,
-0.4222550392150879,
0.14593666791915894,
-0.6161436438560486,
-0.042332492768764496,
0.010923797264695168,
-0.455024778842926,
-0.33599960803985596,
-0.41643813252449036,
-0.5666903853416443,
-0.3197982609272003,
0.06030307337641716,
-0.3407132029533386,
0.1409161239862442,
0.5854120850563049,
-0.2562784254550934,
0.1011928841471672,
-0.8067672848701477,
0.2239522933959961,
0.24248139560222626,
0.5029389262199402,
0.11428853124380112,
-0.3521067798137665,
-0.54066401720047,
0.008382887579500675,
0.0524744838476181,
-0.0855940654873848,
0.009615602903068066,
0.1703243851661682,
0.8863202333450317,
1.0589810609817505,
0.25517016649246216,
0.939591109752655,
0.12467651814222336,
0.928483247756958,
0.00856074970215559,
-1.0979152917861938,
0.3919183015823364,
-0.38105493783950806,
-0.1681201308965683,
0.7707303762435913,
0.10992377251386642,
-0.6202090978622437,
-0.45613932609558105,
-0.5985006093978882,
-1.1518930196762085,
0.6808390617370605,
-0.26584550738334656,
-0.07505032420158386,
0.07232556492090225,
0.5017659664154053,
0.29889267683029175,
0.36864173412323,
-0.5195712447166443,
-0.6165063381195068,
-0.08226864784955978,
0.11330655217170715,
-0.015097866766154766,
-0.4430123567581177,
-0.07166838645935059,
-0.17387571930885315,
0.8551021814346313,
-0.1494019478559494,
-0.23787394165992737,
0.08740166574716568,
0.03281085565686226,
-0.0517321415245533,
0.13177141547203064,
0.9694054126739502,
0.6513611674308777,
-0.35672810673713684,
0.09835990518331528,
0.2922273576259613,
-0.6336414217948914,
-0.009216885082423687,
0.19834378361701965,
-0.023161696270108223,
-0.427437961101532,
0.3164445757865906,
0.29559898376464844,
0.6329639554023743,
-1.0767470598220825,
0.28353559970855713,
0.023744018748402596,
-0.32351580262184143,
-0.3012070059776306,
0.49509885907173157,
-0.18113286793231964,
0.462661474943161,
0.8345838785171509,
0.055683694779872894,
0.29750722646713257,
-0.6092818379402161,
0.42472022771835327,
0.13373294472694397,
-0.7278738617897034,
-0.1551772952079773,
0.6311389803886414,
0.16383183002471924,
0.05253512039780617,
0.2298564612865448,
-0.24332141876220703,
-0.6184456944465637,
0.6594780683517456,
0.4945273697376251,
0.8645555973052979,
-0.15646512806415558,
0.06134384870529175,
0.13051928579807281,
0.3371652364730835,
-0.38994213938713074,
0.4471125304698944,
-0.09375066310167313,
-0.38129618763923645,
-0.1676439344882965,
-0.7141047120094299,
-0.5533959865570068,
-0.05677218735218048,
-1.0200474262237549,
0.18215908110141754,
-0.9383410215377808,
-0.1152888610959053,
-0.24262142181396484,
0.43680325150489807,
-0.32064539194107056,
0.22899216413497925,
0.40352150797843933,
1.4560407400131226,
-0.6840832829475403,
0.6888885498046875,
0.6394426822662354,
-0.15137284994125366,
-0.7231259942054749,
-0.24207690358161926,
0.16595366597175598,
-0.7531693577766418,
0.47016018629074097,
0.31512847542762756,
-0.444801926612854,
-0.1811491847038269,
-0.3911436200141907,
-1.0654468536376953,
1.2211791276931763,
0.5424867272377014,
-0.6718778014183044,
0.10794710367918015,
0.16795450448989868,
0.690334141254425,
-0.5782022476196289,
0.27436935901641846,
1.2264978885650635,
0.7209978103637695,
-0.1257287710905075,
-0.9706064462661743,
0.033777620643377304,
-0.5439509153366089,
0.06841565668582916,
0.07001472264528275,
-1.1876912117004395,
1.0001932382583618,
0.03626659885048866,
-0.20462961494922638,
-0.028707269579172134,
1.0066306591033936,
0.6656612157821655,
0.7471587657928467,
0.470720112323761,
0.11306995153427124,
0.8232625722885132,
-0.25999531149864197,
0.7805804014205933,
-0.9476310014724731,
0.4292473793029785,
0.9119670987129211,
-0.4013039469718933,
0.9132513403892517,
0.10355908423662186,
-0.32453206181526184,
0.8222146034240723,
0.9945130944252014,
-0.15461894869804382,
0.23542864620685577,
0.3448866903781891,
0.02009393833577633,
-0.5230829119682312,
-0.31896427273750305,
-0.6725702881813049,
0.4430139660835266,
0.5593354105949402,
0.11341594159603119,
-0.07939077913761139,
-0.22475723922252655,
-0.17598657310009003,
0.2776413559913635,
-0.6791282296180725,
0.19759544730186462,
0.24256274104118347,
-0.21837756037712097,
0.28909730911254883,
0.20683100819587708,
0.8830206990242004,
-0.9640586972236633,
0.1253385990858078,
-0.264080286026001,
0.29739701747894287,
-0.25388303399086,
-0.3846933841705322,
0.31194767355918884,
-0.20048324763774872,
0.019880054518580437,
-0.013524091802537441,
0.816727876663208,
-0.20785380899906158,
-0.5313032865524292,
0.4890718162059784,
0.17078769207000732,
0.2701268792152405,
0.06578503549098969,
-1.0418044328689575,
-0.012940489687025547,
-0.2693226933479309,
-0.3816643953323364,
0.3806072473526001,
0.42918306589126587,
-0.4018358290195465,
0.8355042338371277,
0.9640880227088928,
-0.095822274684906,
-0.40747928619384766,
0.14035028219223022,
0.7555626630783081,
-0.9564763307571411,
-0.8882501125335693,
-0.9215014576911926,
0.12358864396810532,
0.09780985116958618,
-0.5560210347175598,
0.812102198600769,
0.9174278974533081,
1.0681556463241577,
0.3665997087955475,
0.5909673571586609,
0.38249602913856506,
0.29462239146232605,
-0.3143392503261566,
0.7436319589614868,
-0.5999578237533569,
0.5404702425003052,
-0.7775152325630188,
-0.7651154398918152,
-0.26920080184936523,
0.540878415107727,
-0.39630424976348877,
-0.05795266479253769,
0.4591505527496338,
0.5341975688934326,
0.1889418363571167,
0.4979221522808075,
0.36051321029663086,
-0.11537595093250275,
0.04568986967206001,
0.6431249976158142,
0.6380707621574402,
-0.5793532133102417,
0.7242851257324219,
-0.4084198772907257,
-0.002685996936634183,
-0.47749680280685425,
-0.8142498135566711,
-0.804610013961792,
-0.08185531198978424,
-0.41343820095062256,
-0.04470345377922058,
-0.02848568744957447,
1.097414255142212,
0.5404351949691772,
-1.1511030197143555,
-0.7234371304512024,
0.20128320157527924,
0.11507661640644073,
-0.9429240226745605,
-0.2696681618690491,
0.7100748419761658,
-0.1850631982088089,
-0.41849485039711,
0.36065900325775146,
0.7876264452934265,
0.13740932941436768,
-0.686773419380188,
-0.05140622705221176,
0.14970934391021729,
0.23417381942272186,
0.46732813119888306,
0.177916020154953,
-0.6243730187416077,
-0.2947004735469818,
0.1728503555059433,
-0.4138936698436737,
-0.30685189366340637,
0.9211050271987915,
-0.3523067831993103,
0.11421351134777069,
0.1571195423603058,
0.4362976849079132,
0.29056912660598755,
0.19379767775535583,
0.6922162175178528,
-0.19596125185489655,
0.06638022512197495,
-0.36879289150238037,
0.24070890247821808,
-0.07482650876045227,
-0.5276848673820496,
0.6340216994285583,
0.436127245426178,
-0.35959193110466003,
-0.9314737915992737,
-0.41262179613113403,
-0.9332801699638367,
-0.347053200006485,
0.6923186779022217,
-0.5340664386749268,
-0.3494996428489685,
-0.26839590072631836,
-0.14447666704654694,
0.02755861170589924,
-0.48977038264274597,
0.4704894423484802,
0.7782648801803589,
-0.07761666178703308,
0.29287388920783997,
-0.8486506938934326,
0.551885187625885,
0.38843441009521484,
-0.4244331121444702,
0.5472208261489868,
0.16859300434589386,
0.07541268318891525,
0.04079187661409378,
0.6909465193748474,
-0.006587781943380833,
0.6995050311088562,
0.14218708872795105,
-0.028365107253193855,
-0.2890458106994629,
-0.4387192726135254,
-0.174334317445755,
0.45046451687812805,
-0.2503802180290222,
0.24108508229255676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19055v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19055v1
|
Plan of Thoughts: Heuristic-Guided Problem Solving with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-29T18:51:17 | 2024-04-29T18:51:17 |
Houjun Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While language models (LMs) offer significant capability in zero-shot
reasoning tasks across a wide range of domains, they do not perform
satisfactorily in problems which requires multi-step reasoning. Previous
approaches to mitigate this involves breaking a larger, multi-step task into
sub-tasks and asking the language model to generate proposals ("thoughts") for
each sub-task and using exhaustive planning approaches such as DFS to compose a
solution. In this work, we leverage this idea to introduce two new
contributions: first, we formalize a planning-based approach to perform
multi-step problem solving with LMs via Partially Observable Markov Decision
Processes (POMDPs), with the LM's own reflections about the value of a state
used as a search heuristic; second, leveraging the online POMDP solver POMCP,
we demonstrate a superior success rate of 89.4% on the Game of 24 task as
compared to existing approaches while also offering better anytime performance
characteristics than fixed tree-search which is used previously. Taken
together, these contributions allow modern LMs to decompose and solve
larger-scale reasoning tasks more effectively.
|
[
-0.4545438289642334,
-0.8974695205688477,
1.2686583995819092,
0.12596487998962402,
0.02299388125538826,
0.238289937376976,
-0.15481676161289215,
-0.027571137994527817,
0.18795831501483917,
0.6130920648574829,
-0.8610857725143433,
-0.3119015395641327,
-0.3067359924316406,
-0.07397795468568802,
-0.01024585496634245,
0.42363524436950684,
-0.43468451499938965,
-0.12498892098665237,
0.20104295015335083,
0.32752367854118347,
-0.35294845700263977,
-0.33565855026245117,
-0.6759031414985657,
-0.3599422872066498,
0.5702309012413025,
0.5312792062759399,
0.677987813949585,
0.3568046987056732,
0.5190964937210083,
0.17090611159801483,
-0.2500060200691223,
0.22655510902404785,
-0.34995657205581665,
0.30939021706581116,
-0.396167516708374,
-0.3465987741947174,
-0.44915279746055603,
-0.09560520201921463,
0.39872536063194275,
0.8644067645072937,
-0.6380304098129272,
0.09327709674835205,
-0.34351056814193726,
0.7228884100914001,
-0.8488662242889404,
0.49170351028442383,
-0.6201679110527039,
0.3881024420261383,
0.10747916996479034,
-0.3676086962223053,
-0.45521631836891174,
0.13656996190547943,
0.2981390655040741,
-0.520257830619812,
-0.2700081169605255,
-0.11829153448343277,
0.3291948139667511,
0.39933133125305176,
-0.09448125213384628,
-0.22730623185634613,
-1.0251799821853638,
0.9184204339981079,
-0.8325545191764832,
0.13144205510616302,
0.3500887155532837,
0.34642934799194336,
-0.5855535268783569,
-0.161802276968956,
-0.6261922121047974,
0.1520310342311859,
0.38188159465789795,
-0.05050194263458252,
-0.12773792445659637,
0.07598130404949188,
0.53291916847229,
0.1168261170387268,
-0.4103323519229889,
-0.21043115854263306,
-0.058640256524086,
0.071306511759758,
0.7227070331573486,
0.28410986065864563,
-0.04490707069635391,
0.1070287823677063,
-0.2487322837114334,
0.09330624341964722,
-0.45942649245262146,
0.07062125951051712,
0.16395506262779236,
0.3207818567752838,
0.29751867055892944,
0.6406998038291931,
-0.5421572327613831,
0.8103089928627014,
-0.20066845417022705,
-0.4469623863697052,
-0.07801195234060287,
-0.47228631377220154,
-0.2735632061958313,
-0.018561089411377907,
0.5954301953315735,
0.15568356215953827,
0.33330896496772766,
-0.010097400285303593,
-0.24340002238750458,
0.22469650208950043,
0.179893359541893,
-0.6102249026298523,
-0.3158124089241028,
0.5152904391288757,
-0.3277973532676697,
0.07132085412740707,
-0.5042508244514465,
-0.3868787884712219,
-0.37413471937179565,
-0.4153526723384857,
0.6002512574195862,
-0.5166123509407043,
-0.5543441772460938,
0.7848279476165771,
0.022196372970938683,
-0.14841018617153168,
0.4052261412143707,
-0.4373186230659485,
0.3181958496570587,
0.5387130975723267,
0.5130974650382996,
0.0858273133635521,
-0.271689236164093,
-0.41596969962120056,
0.2500454783439636,
-0.703725278377533,
0.8008221983909607,
-0.7030518651008606,
-0.4341268837451935,
0.16417576372623444,
-0.4360469579696655,
0.03521247208118439,
-0.47243064641952515,
0.5661228895187378,
-0.23701761662960052,
0.12007103115320206,
-0.6015156507492065,
-0.573076605796814,
-0.15979692339897156,
0.39075973629951477,
-0.5233737826347351,
0.9147223234176636,
-0.0946776419878006,
-0.7233762145042419,
0.23038826882839203,
-0.9229138493537903,
-0.3995150029659271,
0.024107862263917923,
-0.21376802027225494,
-0.20883435010910034,
0.18751643598079681,
0.2800050377845764,
0.7252490520477295,
-0.295457124710083,
0.08237424492835999,
-0.15943074226379395,
-0.114811472594738,
0.03130406513810158,
0.06379073113203049,
0.5976921916007996,
0.29501980543136597,
-0.4804894030094147,
0.39499643445014954,
-0.7288125157356262,
0.32432398200035095,
0.6490482091903687,
-0.5155477523803711,
-0.15059775114059448,
0.6334269046783447,
-0.5613316893577576,
0.4571904242038727,
0.13841448724269867,
-0.5624704957008362,
0.3868120312690735,
-0.31676265597343445,
0.44921374320983887,
0.34065327048301697,
0.1921001672744751,
0.5602007508277893,
-0.22305966913700104,
0.4681582450866699,
0.13497062027454376,
0.3731086552143097,
-0.554325520992279,
-0.7689277529716492,
-0.815333366394043,
-0.08239108324050903,
-0.32328400015830994,
0.4429766833782196,
-1.0966160297393799,
0.12920789420604706,
0.16571466624736786,
-0.40293270349502563,
-0.31627362966537476,
-0.3462713062763214,
0.40645933151245117,
0.25156596302986145,
0.4902326762676239,
-0.2618850767612457,
-0.5247737169265747,
-0.8057323694229126,
-0.2898608446121216,
-0.057184383273124695,
0.2677500247955322,
0.14111320674419403,
0.4794456958770752,
0.03831271827220917,
0.8791989684104919,
-1.000319480895996,
-0.312193900346756,
-0.40891674160957336,
0.20942522585391998,
0.18189451098442078,
0.10621925443410873,
0.0105389803647995,
-0.5623477101325989,
-0.438393771648407,
-0.40464073419570923,
-0.40464335680007935,
0.2064467817544937,
-0.053351569920778275,
-0.18428276479244232,
0.11943616718053818,
0.2585964798927307,
-0.6948745250701904,
0.3769240081310272,
0.21088175475597382,
-0.3524211645126343,
0.3876824378967285,
-0.3364538848400116,
0.05920298770070076,
-0.961885929107666,
-0.27940547466278076,
0.10879386216402054,
-0.08486539125442505,
-0.5926246047019958,
0.3084977865219116,
-0.11711904406547546,
-0.11872737854719162,
-0.42780813574790955,
0.2046026587486267,
-0.7449938058853149,
-0.033053457736968994,
-0.42528632283210754,
-0.034417882561683655,
-0.30390357971191406,
0.6900407075881958,
0.3247462213039398,
0.39213642477989197,
0.7187392711639404,
-0.5497540235519409,
0.32575756311416626,
0.06021422520279884,
-0.5250733494758606,
0.4711170494556427,
-0.17423859238624573,
0.3882610499858856,
-0.35264942049980164,
0.2927494943141937,
-0.8008298277854919,
0.15065859258174896,
0.2155425101518631,
-0.20126809179782867,
0.14797937870025635,
-0.15576794743537903,
-0.5935490727424622,
-0.4403475522994995,
-0.3711249828338623,
0.24052129685878754,
0.35840773582458496,
-0.038486186414957047,
0.44665825366973877,
0.5868148803710938,
-0.19162514805793762,
-0.47934532165527344,
-0.4723758399486542,
0.1784038543701172,
0.21079817414283752,
-0.3015175759792328,
0.39707621932029724,
-0.2248508334159851,
-0.5411540865898132,
0.2176065891981125,
-0.24211955070495605,
-0.042715489864349365,
0.03698418289422989,
-0.01622520014643669,
0.12883268296718597,
-0.16547565162181854,
-0.4362594783306122,
-0.22233009338378906,
-0.2712446451187134,
0.14392584562301636,
-0.5784487128257751,
0.7839394807815552,
0.18166504800319672,
-0.5341411232948303,
-0.2716675102710724,
0.7832942605018616,
0.4914979636669159,
-0.6261498928070068,
0.6448071002960205,
0.013307761400938034,
-0.6074299812316895,
-0.6119654774665833,
-0.43630990386009216,
-0.07776124775409698,
-0.3556462824344635,
0.22664965689182281,
-0.703425407409668,
-0.6386650800704956,
0.1945655196905136,
-0.21143770217895508,
0.3300018608570099,
0.15504054725170135,
0.728042721748352,
-0.185161754488945,
1.3105566501617432,
0.7566101551055908,
0.1284782737493515,
0.4167562425136566,
-0.4169752299785614,
0.5997677445411682,
-0.7320995330810547,
-0.3213357925415039,
-0.5088314414024353,
-0.37045401334762573,
-0.21454784274101257,
-1.06290602684021,
0.2902228832244873,
0.09008698910474777,
-0.06722824275493622,
0.43534326553344727,
-0.6002383232116699,
0.5826662182807922,
0.4825376272201538,
-0.11511865258216858,
0.32462629675865173,
-0.14540714025497437,
-0.46835777163505554,
0.08160696923732758,
-0.9186112284660339,
-0.40021905303001404,
1.0526020526885986,
0.19265177845954895,
0.6079185605049133,
0.04342716559767723,
0.7199203968048096,
-0.17274975776672363,
-0.19867531955242157,
-0.8815126419067383,
0.9061147570610046,
0.26895302534103394,
-0.7806727886199951,
-0.6114645600318909,
-0.4234428405761719,
-0.7637419104576111,
0.2484218031167984,
-0.06725208461284637,
-0.8886843919754028,
-0.03130694478750229,
-0.1320977807044983,
-0.46694469451904297,
0.5444865226745605,
-0.472324013710022,
0.5382139086723328,
-0.096749447286129,
-0.3056986927986145,
-0.5992517471313477,
-0.31262022256851196,
0.13693825900554657,
0.19213926792144775,
0.3988989591598511,
-0.3194116950035095,
-0.047866545617580414,
0.6586694717407227,
-0.31969210505485535,
0.34434813261032104,
-0.3361263871192932,
-0.32052043080329895,
0.4418064057826996,
0.40596163272857666,
0.7912752628326416,
-0.5118908882141113,
0.111881785094738,
-0.1738695651292801,
0.14139075577259064,
-0.365505576133728,
-0.3221319913864136,
0.6781485080718994,
-0.22008849680423737,
-0.6868011951446533,
-0.4031434953212738,
-0.7562724947929382,
-0.3963735103607178,
0.1853330135345459,
-0.2092507928609848,
0.2611996531486511,
0.12779943645000458,
-0.3452253043651581,
0.948419988155365,
-0.2123647779226303,
0.7555229663848877,
0.7506092190742493,
-0.5500580072402954,
-0.11296185106039047,
0.7287378311157227,
0.24039140343666077,
0.3397999703884125,
0.5751035213470459,
0.24440991878509521,
-0.17202752828598022,
-0.7953690886497498,
-0.29622790217399597,
0.2907598614692688,
-0.7723438143730164,
0.17612886428833008,
-0.5480892658233643,
-0.05049969628453255,
-0.021967634558677673,
0.05754709243774414,
-0.5267379879951477,
-0.3951982855796814,
0.20426902174949646,
0.1994585543870926,
-0.023375149816274643,
0.7197558283805847,
0.2053469717502594,
-0.16688118875026703,
-0.439922571182251,
0.4541202783584595,
0.01932544820010662,
0.35180649161338806,
0.019826829433441162,
0.001993337646126747,
-0.20384764671325684,
-0.1206732988357544,
-0.21235834062099457,
-1.0037803649902344,
0.31157630681991577,
-0.2804892361164093,
0.6621759533882141,
0.09891530871391296,
0.11186020076274872,
0.7529152631759644,
-0.8889949917793274,
0.5360466241836548,
0.2049912065267563,
-0.5581151843070984,
0.7669209241867065,
-0.45382505655288696,
0.4842980206012726,
0.3172057271003723,
0.7572066783905029,
-0.41020074486732483,
-0.21015869081020355,
-0.4161261022090912,
-0.6623860001564026,
0.8600032925605774,
0.29199475049972534,
-0.4228802025318146,
0.12490445375442505,
0.34146952629089355,
-0.10932742059230804,
0.2798861861228943,
-0.11850679665803909,
-0.3253183662891388,
0.32647791504859924,
0.035822298377752304,
-0.1289355307817459,
-0.33072173595428467,
-0.05534689873456955,
-0.2750460207462311,
0.638970673084259,
-0.2544524669647217,
0.38938409090042114,
0.3140217661857605,
0.237953782081604,
-0.44664040207862854,
0.4713072180747986,
0.5851929187774658,
0.8672278523445129,
-0.01850944198668003,
0.2201220840215683,
-0.10818835347890854,
-0.08916834741830826,
0.12878255546092987,
-0.05727729946374893,
-0.19870710372924805,
-0.09227811545133591,
-0.02172696590423584,
0.5625123977661133,
0.20859023928642273,
-0.6694194078445435,
0.1874532252550125,
-0.025456741452217102,
-0.3244714140892029,
-0.18924319744110107,
0.07329893857240677,
0.5690022110939026,
0.48219943046569824,
0.30322977900505066,
-0.014147023670375347,
0.09024173021316528,
-0.9127695560455322,
-0.13448388874530792,
0.4535949230194092,
-0.37148281931877136,
-0.2674542963504791,
0.41236549615859985,
0.063927061855793,
-0.6428110599517822,
0.15853850543498993,
-0.5921093225479126,
-0.6783672571182251,
0.28036272525787354,
0.5411821603775024,
0.890167236328125,
-0.15405982732772827,
0.38211989402770996,
0.2622697651386261,
0.32198548316955566,
-0.5334994792938232,
1.0378589630126953,
-0.20075282454490662,
-0.7152220010757446,
-0.9483012557029724,
-0.6327207088470459,
-0.4696374237537384,
0.28407201170921326,
-0.18838267028331757,
0.11941854655742645,
-0.6506658792495728,
-0.11104974895715714,
0.1106308326125145,
0.04692674055695534,
-0.3899884521961212,
0.14992418885231018,
0.4397721588611603,
0.8695904612541199,
-0.32947564125061035,
0.728374719619751,
0.8805170655250549,
-0.40948712825775146,
-0.96015864610672,
0.19541271030902863,
0.1611972600221634,
-0.43251439929008484,
0.3008265793323517,
-0.2877250611782074,
-0.3817428648471832,
0.08718977868556976,
-0.1418703943490982,
-1.0159786939620972,
0.7428807616233826,
0.32948240637779236,
-0.7759223580360413,
-0.23145654797554016,
0.1172180324792862,
0.07726353406906128,
-0.1439119279384613,
0.0023934405762702227,
0.5089204907417297,
0.4220183193683624,
0.30479446053504944,
-1.2150437831878662,
-0.02410673163831234,
0.07338988035917282,
-0.18359407782554626,
0.7137405872344971,
-0.22822202742099762,
1.0069581270217896,
-0.48944467306137085,
-0.2374265193939209,
-0.1617833524942398,
0.23097553849220276,
0.24252362549304962,
0.1413310170173645,
0.4114883244037628,
0.7477320432662964,
0.6519142985343933,
-0.005390746518969536,
1.000912070274353,
-0.14883121848106384,
0.2576715350151062,
1.0237935781478882,
-0.6105524897575378,
1.1766345500946045,
0.3994790315628052,
-0.433045893907547,
0.22982215881347656,
0.4773942530155182,
0.5720720887184143,
0.6980122327804565,
0.4505254626274109,
-0.28637728095054626,
-0.5075212121009827,
-0.050999850034713745,
0.022320827469229698,
0.26900312304496765,
0.20391340553760529,
0.05570545792579651,
-0.4067330062389374,
-0.09078678488731384,
0.23492184281349182,
0.35814401507377625,
-0.45677128434181213,
0.6083667874336243,
0.003664382267743349,
-1.008011817932129,
0.37603509426116943,
0.3075878620147705,
0.5230849981307983,
-0.5096663236618042,
-0.05843440443277359,
0.13152004778385162,
0.5700613260269165,
-0.13844262063503265,
-0.9713201522827148,
0.31677448749542236,
0.015402222983539104,
-0.21252478659152985,
-0.6207504272460938,
0.7317978739738464,
-0.25662463903427124,
-0.486415833234787,
0.2664952874183655,
0.7488430738449097,
0.07703328132629395,
-0.5445563197135925,
-0.6812407374382019,
-0.03807514160871506,
-0.0995011180639267,
-0.26192066073417664,
0.35459086298942566,
0.43303972482681274,
-0.19931569695472717,
0.8228503465652466,
0.642065167427063,
0.18403175473213196,
0.031239166855812073,
0.0465528778731823,
0.7037970423698425,
-0.8637967705726624,
-0.4513999819755554,
-0.8779464960098267,
0.353304386138916,
0.06154848262667656,
-0.11197362095117569,
0.5179767608642578,
0.624487042427063,
1.0690195560455322,
0.1306009292602539,
0.6583235263824463,
0.05188211798667908,
0.5681775808334351,
-0.5590789914131165,
0.41656553745269775,
-0.35531193017959595,
0.21092765033245087,
-0.42516613006591797,
-0.9619997143745422,
-0.17563104629516602,
0.7449768781661987,
-0.4557426869869232,
-0.17711713910102844,
0.9832315444946289,
0.5321567058563232,
0.32715150713920593,
0.024731935933232307,
0.48404160141944885,
0.06086472049355507,
0.3676539957523346,
1.0345416069030762,
1.1030454635620117,
0.012379912659525871,
0.2445111721754074,
-0.44427603483200073,
-0.26937663555145264,
-0.049583740532398224,
-0.8652325868606567,
-0.8331218957901001,
-0.793555498123169,
-0.45519524812698364,
0.12517458200454712,
-0.21576136350631714,
0.9772759079933167,
0.6472675800323486,
-0.5243606567382812,
-0.36772620677948,
-0.25235873460769653,
-0.018331728875637054,
-0.3224009573459625,
-0.11737500131130219,
-0.06431715190410614,
-0.36157986521720886,
-0.4071003496646881,
0.7394581437110901,
0.6672805547714233,
-0.3956766128540039,
-0.7619931101799011,
-0.12705956399440765,
-0.6730908751487732,
0.5212389230728149,
0.8131729364395142,
0.0001679518463788554,
-0.8497066497802734,
-0.030631834641098976,
0.26773756742477417,
0.06928503513336182,
0.030882271006703377,
1.1274346113204956,
-0.8455857634544373,
0.4620796740055084,
0.48578187823295593,
0.4153541028499603,
0.8524943590164185,
-0.4774172306060791,
0.3824061155319214,
-0.24754595756530762,
0.06823808699846268,
0.550691545009613,
0.5843493938446045,
0.08982202410697937,
0.08679300546646118,
0.4510960578918457,
0.028825944289565086,
-0.30887019634246826,
-0.6837719082832336,
0.5766171216964722,
-0.7758246064186096,
-0.7959039807319641,
1.1858017444610596,
-0.018325094133615494,
-0.34013503789901733,
-0.11321118474006653,
-0.5426005721092224,
0.08461116999387741,
-0.3231250047683716,
0.5686487555503845,
0.7647702693939209,
-0.5161467790603638,
-0.14545567333698273,
-0.641427218914032,
0.522472083568573,
0.49934670329093933,
-0.7920554280281067,
0.12808458507061005,
0.5190121531486511,
0.08276509493589401,
0.45079687237739563,
0.9087720513343811,
0.019614730030298233,
-0.06895153224468231,
0.07326735556125641,
-0.06969063729047775,
-0.1379227191209793,
-0.6819614768028259,
0.11852513253688812,
0.416454017162323,
0.2624058127403259,
-0.21632379293441772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19048v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19048v2
|
A Framework for Real-time Safeguarding the Text Generation of Large Language Model
| 2024-04-29T18:40:01 | 2024-05-01T19:53:12 |
Ximing Dong, Dayi Lin, Shaowei Wang, Ahmed E. Hassan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly advanced natural language
processing (NLP) tasks but also pose ethical and societal risks due to their
propensity to generate harmful content. To address this, various approaches
have been developed to safeguard LLMs from producing unsafe content. However,
existing methods have limitations, including the need for training specific
control models and proactive intervention during text generation, that lead to
quality degradation and increased computational overhead. To mitigate those
limitations, we propose LLMSafeGuard, a lightweight framework to safeguard LLM
text generation in real-time. LLMSafeGuard integrates an external validator
into the beam search algorithm during decoding, rejecting candidates that
violate safety constraints while allowing valid ones to proceed. We introduce a
similarity based validation approach, simplifying constraint introduction and
eliminating the need for control model training. Additionally, LLMSafeGuard
employs a context-wise timing selection strategy, intervening LLMs only when
necessary. We evaluate LLMSafeGuard on two tasks, detoxification and copyright
safeguarding, and demonstrate its superior performance over SOTA baselines. For
instance, LLMSafeGuard reduces the average toxic score of. LLM output by 29.7%
compared to the best baseline meanwhile preserving similar linguistic quality
as natural output in detoxification task. Similarly, in the copyright task,
LLMSafeGuard decreases the Longest Common Subsequence (LCS) by 56.2% compared
to baselines. Moreover, our context-wise timing selection strategy reduces
inference time by at least 24% meanwhile maintaining comparable effectiveness
as validating each time step. LLMSafeGuard also offers tunable parameters to
balance its effectiveness and efficiency.
|
[
-0.08602484315633774,
-0.8346645832061768,
0.5412849187850952,
0.2928743064403534,
-0.4368972182273865,
0.15652765333652496,
-0.11572737246751785,
-0.5082835555076599,
-0.12335065752267838,
0.6004524230957031,
-0.6560083031654358,
-0.4755302667617798,
-0.5378209352493286,
0.18845470249652863,
-0.4733542799949646,
0.8990340232849121,
-0.0882607251405716,
-0.09802192449569702,
-0.12218506634235382,
0.019224898889660835,
-0.18919281661510468,
-0.5561789870262146,
-0.8687549233436584,
-0.4065049886703491,
0.3875465989112854,
0.15572035312652588,
0.5748266577720642,
0.8166811466217041,
0.44637930393218994,
0.22075670957565308,
-0.35608920454978943,
0.30656754970550537,
-0.5615994334220886,
0.6310037970542908,
-0.32698559761047363,
-0.10795609652996063,
-0.32529327273368835,
-0.39079707860946655,
0.5319443941116333,
-0.08393911272287369,
-0.15665051341056824,
0.18793588876724243,
-0.012203200720250607,
0.43449366092681885,
-0.7220185995101929,
-0.22801783680915833,
-0.7632516026496887,
0.33476072549819946,
-0.21182875335216522,
-0.4635234773159027,
-0.4979395270347595,
-0.501951277256012,
-0.30784446001052856,
-0.26567044854164124,
-0.155683234333992,
0.11455469578504562,
1.2576980590820312,
0.36092594265937805,
-0.34195685386657715,
0.025609882548451424,
-0.6644275784492493,
0.8584877848625183,
-1.0674704313278198,
0.2521669864654541,
0.30745264887809753,
0.23926620185375214,
-0.2804800868034363,
-0.7157343029975891,
-0.6183631420135498,
-0.25631818175315857,
0.09212692081928253,
0.006054844707250595,
-0.02056836523115635,
0.1942126452922821,
0.34203699231147766,
-0.02641851082444191,
-0.629816472530365,
0.3134371042251587,
-0.046966273337602615,
-0.5621943473815918,
0.6530956625938416,
0.16593439877033234,
0.3999216854572296,
-0.3483965992927551,
-0.45210444927215576,
0.04949810728430748,
-1.2094465494155884,
-0.2857131361961365,
0.41142627596855164,
0.0025995145551860332,
0.01829550974071026,
0.515836775302887,
-0.19285151362419128,
0.20946744084358215,
-0.07983055710792542,
-0.5137666463851929,
0.14765635132789612,
-0.23986250162124634,
-0.21784813702106476,
0.30575165152549744,
1.0799567699432373,
0.258495032787323,
0.30441784858703613,
0.011752369813621044,
-0.2953422963619232,
0.08707147091627121,
0.3321381211280823,
-1.2288849353790283,
0.29034432768821716,
0.30252179503440857,
-0.3678484261035919,
-0.603557825088501,
-0.19210894405841827,
-0.48177677392959595,
-0.1279200166463852,
-0.2264949530363083,
0.3016042411327362,
-0.40628957748413086,
-0.0386725477874279,
0.04077839478850365,
0.3991910219192505,
0.03796181082725525,
0.019982188940048218,
-0.5197080969810486,
-0.017705651000142097,
0.7033126354217529,
0.7894089221954346,
-0.23820868134498596,
-0.2002234309911728,
-0.9352744221687317,
0.5773363709449768,
-0.18727467954158783,
0.6001647114753723,
-0.3179340362548828,
-0.3196873366832733,
0.02956787310540676,
0.07977809011936188,
0.20310468971729279,
-0.3961552679538727,
0.6713184118270874,
-0.7949440479278564,
-0.008913292549550533,
0.049363721162080765,
-0.4247645437717438,
0.12896564602851868,
0.34866660833358765,
-0.5049324035644531,
1.1324316263198853,
-0.2208145707845688,
-0.976950466632843,
0.31876620650291443,
-0.41364142298698425,
-0.7720299959182739,
0.012381406500935555,
-0.2720460295677185,
-0.8634008169174194,
-0.19216199219226837,
0.2136509120464325,
0.5742145776748657,
-0.20113816857337952,
0.755577027797699,
-0.21951597929000854,
-0.3191615343093872,
0.14901629090309143,
-0.7685614824295044,
0.577305793762207,
0.5383511781692505,
-0.4985252618789673,
0.1171591505408287,
-0.8019075989723206,
0.10560855269432068,
0.17739969491958618,
-0.7316761612892151,
-0.1187073215842247,
0.2030806541442871,
0.34907394647598267,
0.30872806906700134,
0.17554040253162384,
-0.7203868627548218,
-0.165653795003891,
-0.35429733991622925,
0.48867565393447876,
0.8313540816307068,
0.3820050358772278,
0.09349969774484634,
-0.4628567695617676,
0.643498420715332,
-0.1368599832057953,
0.15086419880390167,
-0.1155811995267868,
-0.15965574979782104,
-0.5222074389457703,
-0.3059123456478119,
0.2582685649394989,
0.8254091143608093,
-0.90886390209198,
0.7949001789093018,
-0.5926904082298279,
-0.47903791069984436,
-0.19521845877170563,
0.16205888986587524,
0.8983864188194275,
0.31398046016693115,
0.09638164192438126,
-0.03629365563392639,
-0.5198489427566528,
-0.8030416369438171,
-0.08952543139457703,
-0.07110956311225891,
-0.260172039270401,
0.10049150884151459,
0.38426485657691956,
-0.3776194751262665,
0.7406857013702393,
-0.35890913009643555,
-0.16773755848407745,
-0.19856394827365875,
0.057379744946956635,
0.02047819457948208,
0.6742177605628967,
0.5234867334365845,
-0.6646212935447693,
-0.1688666045665741,
-0.17981089651584625,
-0.951587975025177,
-0.49278849363327026,
-0.37376347184181213,
-0.3310069739818573,
0.28119999170303345,
0.9355201721191406,
-0.4637993276119232,
0.21341891586780548,
0.615437388420105,
-0.3243098556995392,
0.49123451113700867,
-0.14010019600391388,
0.07887298613786697,
-1.2316298484802246,
0.22526566684246063,
-0.4109485149383545,
-0.5930342674255371,
-0.43500781059265137,
0.3537186086177826,
0.03359600156545639,
-0.03713972866535187,
-0.9442001581192017,
0.6003345847129822,
-0.2002660632133484,
0.12133466452360153,
-0.103254035115242,
0.1936265081167221,
0.19558213651180267,
0.15316304564476013,
0.09180109202861786,
0.7119819521903992,
0.17607414722442627,
-0.651166558265686,
0.09876666963100433,
0.22136206924915314,
-0.519589364528656,
0.5698270201683044,
-0.6469050049781799,
0.0204150527715683,
-0.19469308853149414,
0.39432063698768616,
-0.4817644953727722,
-0.2514306604862213,
0.010191618464887142,
-0.14765647053718567,
0.38082608580589294,
-0.04259578138589859,
-0.7572939395904541,
-0.14790095388889313,
-0.23453164100646973,
0.2734721601009369,
0.3397562801837921,
-0.4931734800338745,
0.563038170337677,
0.20315870642662048,
-0.3769012689590454,
-0.715107262134552,
-0.9545454978942871,
0.2977432608604431,
-0.20536650717258453,
-0.6896546483039856,
0.3771391212940216,
-0.19061115384101868,
-0.20368798077106476,
-0.150600403547287,
-0.09002336859703064,
0.20650359988212585,
0.3725973069667816,
0.2877751886844635,
0.22798925638198853,
-0.05028681829571724,
0.08831760287284851,
0.5899959206581116,
-0.3148345649242401,
-0.10757556557655334,
-0.1069013699889183,
0.6206372380256653,
0.38397592306137085,
-0.6169682741165161,
-0.31679362058639526,
0.4158729612827301,
0.5565552115440369,
-0.28293389081954956,
0.7395666241645813,
0.7166522145271301,
-0.31152617931365967,
-0.3818916380405426,
-0.5273060202598572,
-0.3475172221660614,
-0.5409964919090271,
0.3256804943084717,
-0.0855330377817154,
-1.182744026184082,
0.266602486371994,
0.08318817615509033,
0.42521199584007263,
0.15340133011341095,
0.7066192030906677,
0.13562315702438354,
0.7943141460418701,
0.2465742975473404,
0.06215531378984451,
0.5113062262535095,
0.0003852224035654217,
0.47940000891685486,
-0.6662296652793884,
-0.1556536704301834,
-0.36886584758758545,
-0.2877776622772217,
-0.3435850143432617,
-0.30382096767425537,
0.4178641438484192,
-0.03134980425238609,
-0.3377075493335724,
0.3547614812850952,
-0.5080819725990295,
0.6819900870323181,
0.2678041160106659,
-0.024201834574341774,
0.3612534999847412,
-0.029272137209773064,
-0.32962650060653687,
-0.08378185331821442,
-0.5398638844490051,
-0.8411332368850708,
0.8805495500564575,
0.40776926279067993,
0.8216876983642578,
0.10307878255844116,
0.9865434169769287,
0.45065072178840637,
0.4580623209476471,
-0.47102150321006775,
0.8458973169326782,
0.0637132078409195,
-0.8552786707878113,
-0.105398990213871,
-0.6504330635070801,
-0.7247694134712219,
0.2552718222141266,
-0.4102131128311157,
-0.6417351365089417,
-0.19768956303596497,
0.13348396122455597,
-0.4181438386440277,
0.3740132749080658,
-0.3403274118900299,
0.435724139213562,
-0.33069854974746704,
-0.7527275681495667,
-0.1324586123228073,
-0.6377414464950562,
0.48545774817466736,
-0.3569663465023041,
0.5209699273109436,
-0.4341197907924652,
0.011609244160354137,
0.7042022943496704,
-0.27415287494659424,
0.6894175410270691,
-0.07670293748378754,
-0.4988546371459961,
0.28564417362213135,
0.5977451801300049,
0.6837624311447144,
0.2187657505273819,
-0.2502095103263855,
0.05391252040863037,
0.10687397420406342,
-0.12253448367118835,
0.000014369727068697102,
0.9816529154777527,
-0.2803504765033722,
-0.4183892607688904,
-0.31071558594703674,
-0.45893582701683044,
-0.019751081243157387,
0.45317378640174866,
0.5677550435066223,
0.4119233787059784,
-0.1792176067829132,
0.40282702445983887,
0.8624457120895386,
-0.42154353857040405,
0.6631984710693359,
0.3205617368221283,
-0.16869673132896423,
-0.3821309506893158,
0.946331262588501,
-0.08870752155780792,
0.4946226179599762,
0.5615752935409546,
0.19442252814769745,
-0.21824923157691956,
-0.6055136322975159,
-0.3176914155483246,
0.1586754322052002,
-0.783475935459137,
-0.6086047887802124,
-0.7842307686805725,
-0.44537532329559326,
-0.27224865555763245,
-0.3788483440876007,
-0.2203110009431839,
-0.2964828908443451,
-0.2822667062282562,
-0.3604585826396942,
0.29945623874664307,
0.36282551288604736,
0.06591085344552994,
0.3701867461204529,
-1.2538800239562988,
0.3769259452819824,
0.10844913125038147,
0.40153491497039795,
-0.17526713013648987,
-0.38789835572242737,
-0.12548524141311646,
-0.10028374195098877,
-0.34038567543029785,
-0.49467599391937256,
0.47377198934555054,
0.2264682650566101,
0.476759672164917,
0.4643714427947998,
0.3115997314453125,
0.1352904886007309,
-0.5978578329086304,
0.8209756016731262,
0.017093313857913017,
-0.9230586290359497,
0.32132822275161743,
-0.4266124665737152,
0.3021962344646454,
0.5487746000289917,
0.01038216520100832,
-0.3992576599121094,
-0.6783891916275024,
-0.48071736097335815,
-1.0912681818008423,
0.483877956867218,
0.5492865443229675,
0.16136842966079712,
-0.08654803782701492,
0.031321629881858826,
-0.19554132223129272,
0.2593926191329956,
-0.8128145933151245,
0.19711154699325562,
-0.010453800670802593,
-0.36481472849845886,
0.25381532311439514,
-0.31618309020996094,
-0.20904743671417236,
0.27511775493621826,
0.8496267199516296,
-0.1575721651315689,
0.0035332883708178997,
0.18680499494075775,
-0.1787678301334381,
-0.17542913556098938,
0.582209587097168,
0.5306352376937866,
0.28466928005218506,
-0.15732839703559875,
0.22572293877601624,
0.3091897964477539,
-0.662790060043335,
0.4455934762954712,
-0.10587892681360245,
-0.48975688219070435,
-0.13879796862602234,
0.5540918111801147,
0.4731470048427582,
0.3606114685535431,
-1.131024956703186,
0.4555811583995819,
-0.028054673224687576,
-0.37911325693130493,
-0.13877984881401062,
0.14804767072200775,
0.17208801209926605,
0.10320313274860382,
0.08297593891620636,
-0.20467114448547363,
-0.16359971463680267,
-0.21718983352184296,
0.3890731632709503,
0.3411172926425934,
-0.06633216142654419,
0.05598197877407074,
0.9124315977096558,
0.15880538523197174,
-0.09937822818756104,
0.14429645240306854,
-0.20203259587287903,
-0.49622872471809387,
0.45475342869758606,
0.5726498365402222,
0.9898012280464172,
-0.3137042820453644,
-0.10916201025247574,
0.25864943861961365,
0.37035563588142395,
-0.13494455814361572,
0.33911046385765076,
0.06261834502220154,
-0.5977111458778381,
-0.48160240054130554,
-1.089456558227539,
-0.10630251467227936,
0.21766111254692078,
-0.31844663619995117,
0.14388662576675415,
-0.822821319103241,
-0.31217506527900696,
-0.37910741567611694,
-0.312590628862381,
-0.16038113832473755,
0.28262025117874146,
0.17524965107440948,
0.826366662979126,
-0.8170680403709412,
0.8006556034088135,
0.18910208344459534,
0.00039756589103490114,
-0.6648427248001099,
0.04388826712965965,
0.28437113761901855,
-0.4744649827480316,
0.44261372089385986,
0.17841844260692596,
-0.3870907425880432,
-0.09932948648929596,
-0.5110791921615601,
-0.7581507563591003,
1.167236328125,
0.47078830003738403,
-0.8336217403411865,
-0.2190343588590622,
-0.09461275488138199,
0.47007134556770325,
-0.14976514875888824,
-0.2171372026205063,
0.4419681429862976,
0.4250612258911133,
0.29274874925613403,
-0.7726734280586243,
0.33775660395622253,
-0.24125872552394867,
0.0997719094157219,
0.2509959638118744,
-0.39511895179748535,
0.3914449214935303,
-0.050480786710977554,
-0.4403384327888489,
0.05434955283999443,
0.41689419746398926,
0.7556576728820801,
0.07259999215602875,
0.3996085822582245,
0.39232295751571655,
0.4521290361881256,
-0.042826153337955475,
1.029836654663086,
-0.3169790208339691,
0.10888148844242096,
0.9914590716362,
-0.5337680578231812,
0.8616514205932617,
0.5857717394828796,
0.1114232987165451,
0.22815635800361633,
0.2722340524196625,
0.001981776673346758,
0.4692175090312958,
0.3439118564128876,
-0.3506124019622803,
-0.4680784344673157,
-0.30301597714424133,
-0.2391822636127472,
0.11161595582962036,
0.2886314392089844,
-0.3954434394836426,
-0.21457399427890778,
0.10183339565992355,
0.6342743039131165,
0.3711391091346741,
0.03102969564497471,
0.6187025308609009,
0.1757298856973648,
-0.5912256240844727,
0.6429906487464905,
0.09096825867891312,
0.8850913047790527,
-0.8387060761451721,
0.162117600440979,
-0.03364095464348793,
0.35726627707481384,
-0.2411213517189026,
-0.7014707922935486,
0.3682330250740051,
0.24208036065101624,
0.11198137700557709,
-0.4342968463897705,
0.7162461280822754,
-0.3350480794906616,
-0.4538784325122833,
0.45881620049476624,
0.10389255732297897,
-0.20611165463924408,
0.24297459423542023,
-0.4427627623081207,
0.38583672046661377,
0.0534321665763855,
-0.5288113951683044,
0.4428003132343292,
0.2854374349117279,
-0.2746169865131378,
0.8164656162261963,
0.9286782145500183,
0.3881480395793915,
0.06520166993141174,
0.08896417915821075,
0.8039844632148743,
-0.3023117184638977,
-0.6021085381507874,
-0.8353408575057983,
0.2578202784061432,
-0.03839864209294319,
-0.012015859596431255,
0.5430829524993896,
0.512381911277771,
0.6035985946655273,
0.05347762629389763,
0.7606130242347717,
-0.045266371220350266,
0.4678719639778137,
-0.9841994047164917,
1.1236107349395752,
-0.4630778729915619,
0.45013099908828735,
-0.34200045466423035,
-0.9760887622833252,
-0.5013508200645447,
0.4377136528491974,
-0.045706648379564285,
-0.2794449031352997,
0.5897824168205261,
1.0117026567459106,
-0.0951852798461914,
-0.25584733486175537,
0.3015333414077759,
0.0825318694114685,
0.8985131978988647,
0.4254816174507141,
0.6645432710647583,
-0.15318366885185242,
0.7538169026374817,
-0.026851292699575424,
0.004172976594418287,
-0.16895252466201782,
-1.409650444984436,
-0.8453662991523743,
-0.18917883932590485,
-0.194833442568779,
-0.47217822074890137,
0.15005476772785187,
1.1045788526535034,
0.6686362028121948,
-0.6780884861946106,
-0.04314690828323364,
0.015608826652169228,
-0.09692969918251038,
-0.08455570042133331,
-0.22938835620880127,
0.3424527645111084,
-0.12027230113744736,
-0.4685613512992859,
0.48639023303985596,
0.3306428790092468,
0.20024947822093964,
-0.22800305485725403,
-0.19464147090911865,
-0.29947376251220703,
0.5207683444023132,
0.6028286814689636,
0.17400366067886353,
-0.6004644632339478,
-0.3539194166660309,
-0.21987910568714142,
-0.38691821694374084,
-0.21088539063930511,
0.6310954093933105,
-0.44679534435272217,
0.06735622137784958,
0.6893945336341858,
0.6629748940467834,
0.4508010745048523,
-0.06505043804645538,
0.5496931672096252,
-0.9311736226081848,
0.2675474286079407,
0.3926342725753784,
0.48627474904060364,
0.4526744782924652,
-0.5461065769195557,
0.4016067683696747,
0.09869839996099472,
-0.6147255301475525,
-0.9997573494911194,
0.4821910560131073,
-0.7950806617736816,
-0.22023870050907135,
1.3215597867965698,
-0.17314574122428894,
-0.2808428406715393,
-0.10417363792657852,
-0.3615213930606842,
0.2675451934337616,
-0.5113308429718018,
0.6605198979377747,
0.3798536956310272,
0.30824705958366394,
-0.029557308182120323,
-0.5184885859489441,
0.5086514353752136,
0.24752357602119446,
-1.039297103881836,
0.3509962260723114,
0.566816508769989,
0.43646952509880066,
0.18535596132278442,
0.5264414548873901,
-0.41854989528656006,
0.07153964042663574,
-0.2133055031299591,
0.023989185690879822,
-0.23297080397605896,
-0.3594299256801605,
-0.03820120543241501,
0.15970538556575775,
-0.09176929295063019,
0.20171917974948883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19007v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19007v1
|
How Did We Get Here? Summarizing Conversation Dynamics
| 2024-04-29T18:00:03 | 2024-04-29T18:00:03 |
Yilun Hua, Nicholas Chernogor, Yuzhe Gu, Seoyeon Julie Jeong, Miranda Luo, Cristian Danescu-Niculescu-Mizil
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Throughout a conversation, the way participants interact with each other is
in constant flux: their tones may change, they may resort to different
strategies to convey their points, or they might alter their interaction
patterns. An understanding of these dynamics can complement that of the actual
facts and opinions discussed, offering a more holistic view of the trajectory
of the conversation: how it arrived at its current state and where it is likely
heading.
In this work, we introduce the task of summarizing the dynamics of
conversations, by constructing a dataset of human-written summaries, and
exploring several automated baselines. We evaluate whether such summaries can
capture the trajectory of conversations via an established downstream task:
forecasting whether an ongoing conversation will eventually derail into toxic
behavior. We show that they help both humans and automated systems with this
forecasting task. Humans make predictions three times faster, and with greater
confidence, when reading the summaries than when reading the transcripts.
Furthermore, automated forecasting systems are more accurate when constructing,
and then predicting based on, summaries of conversation dynamics, compared to
directly predicting on the transcripts.
|
[
-0.4250943958759308,
-1.0283234119415283,
0.8893940448760986,
-0.23208101093769073,
-0.1755211502313614,
0.5545859336853027,
0.1348617821931839,
-0.5943413376808167,
0.43586617708206177,
0.5533146262168884,
-0.7698716521263123,
-0.2646028697490692,
-0.5840893387794495,
0.024321092292666435,
-0.4401158094406128,
1.2339587211608887,
0.5568909645080566,
-0.1432770937681198,
-0.19057348370552063,
0.24672776460647583,
-0.48959121108055115,
-0.499321848154068,
-0.4899684488773346,
-0.47249147295951843,
0.7423022389411926,
0.5911308526992798,
0.7443707585334778,
0.5709651112556458,
0.5149403810501099,
0.45078516006469727,
-0.3066783547401428,
-0.03720996156334877,
-0.7006511688232422,
0.4602733254432678,
0.06462471932172775,
-0.5555117726325989,
-0.21559280157089233,
0.2439277470111847,
0.16031131148338318,
1.0738396644592285,
-0.32980602979660034,
0.24068625271320343,
0.1473643183708191,
0.4688641428947449,
-0.314322292804718,
0.12678208947181702,
-0.4918459355831146,
0.11951179057359695,
0.16172128915786743,
-0.5380217432975769,
-0.165790855884552,
-0.26718541979789734,
0.5033215284347534,
-0.4210881292819977,
-0.0729544460773468,
-0.054481156170368195,
0.6496526598930359,
0.23367764055728912,
-0.9842290878295898,
-0.526554524898529,
-1.0226236581802368,
0.774078369140625,
-0.421624094247818,
0.03586740046739578,
0.48929280042648315,
0.3792630136013031,
-0.537784993648529,
-0.9485191106796265,
-0.19299082458019257,
-0.24701717495918274,
-0.27593356370925903,
0.38696396350860596,
-0.30195218324661255,
-0.0506361722946167,
0.009020039811730385,
-0.016288580372929573,
-0.20580342411994934,
-0.32448676228523254,
-0.7383158802986145,
-0.3456280827522278,
0.7789104580879211,
0.6232495903968811,
0.4871580898761749,
-0.008295681327581406,
0.043083298951387405,
0.14207987487316132,
-0.2764779031276703,
0.19691728055477142,
0.25444862246513367,
0.32809022068977356,
-0.07383892685174942,
0.28237998485565186,
-0.11265247315168381,
0.5393067598342896,
0.07867805659770966,
-0.15404538810253143,
-0.09841986745595932,
-0.5070021152496338,
0.05160610005259514,
-0.09626852720975876,
0.6932876706123352,
0.9496009945869446,
0.17465293407440186,
-0.27762752771377563,
0.3692944347858429,
-0.08252720534801483,
0.474975049495697,
-0.5838468074798584,
-0.21671295166015625,
0.3369176685810089,
-0.5593475103378296,
-0.5417152047157288,
-0.1302889585494995,
-0.9806468486785889,
-0.25513166189193726,
-0.626785397529602,
0.16484753787517548,
-0.06998603790998459,
-0.34325405955314636,
-0.19052118062973022,
-0.4413435757160187,
-0.09118232876062393,
0.473590612411499,
-0.8839426040649414,
0.4718666076660156,
0.7310664653778076,
1.061468243598938,
-0.2565719187259674,
-0.05347128584980965,
-0.43135279417037964,
-0.09354767948389053,
-0.28554821014404297,
1.0809999704360962,
-0.25014930963516235,
-0.7389258146286011,
-0.1105392798781395,
-0.1293037235736847,
0.21112750470638275,
-0.29681017994880676,
0.22150693833827972,
-0.42974597215652466,
0.4844905734062195,
-0.4567420184612274,
-0.27798834443092346,
-0.29802849888801575,
0.30337730050086975,
-0.15998020768165588,
0.5456507205963135,
-0.3798238933086395,
-0.933752715587616,
0.2639188766479492,
-0.503727376461029,
-0.5840762853622437,
-0.06658006459474564,
0.2353038787841797,
0.05212511122226715,
-0.04920606315135956,
-0.08951850235462189,
0.3207089304924011,
-0.019039073958992958,
0.20837141573429108,
-0.0536828450858593,
-0.2901019752025604,
0.29802438616752625,
-0.10652963072061539,
0.9004682898521423,
0.39219483733177185,
-0.10578040778636932,
0.1663404107093811,
-0.34664514660835266,
-0.07469451427459717,
-0.2768478989601135,
-0.226748526096344,
-0.29977619647979736,
0.3462594747543335,
-0.23908813297748566,
0.2627032995223999,
0.01931745745241642,
-0.2804279625415802,
-0.03566552698612213,
-0.2735637128353119,
0.5030084252357483,
0.597710132598877,
0.5682375431060791,
0.5922046303749084,
-0.5340476632118225,
0.7327325344085693,
0.10492422431707382,
0.14848411083221436,
-0.5743640065193176,
-0.6450788378715515,
-0.5721722841262817,
0.4199553430080414,
-0.17725029587745667,
0.8063188791275024,
-0.17087037861347198,
0.2966759502887726,
-0.4000040888786316,
-0.7529841065406799,
0.15484575927257538,
-0.16353721916675568,
0.34469765424728394,
0.5946688055992126,
0.1518254280090332,
-0.28448793292045593,
-0.37637242674827576,
-0.4805354177951813,
-0.4259593188762665,
-0.7441169023513794,
-0.33248066902160645,
0.12231292575597763,
0.4930512309074402,
-0.04424270987510681,
1.1173402070999146,
-0.8001746535301208,
0.15188516676425934,
-0.40300455689430237,
0.7284179925918579,
-0.019962240010499954,
0.23918873071670532,
0.3635355830192566,
-0.40328747034072876,
-0.5339563488960266,
-0.10260684788227081,
-0.5821309089660645,
-0.1452597677707672,
-0.2766435444355011,
-0.42656779289245605,
-0.28719860315322876,
0.6970363855361938,
-0.348024845123291,
0.29874032735824585,
0.15581277012825012,
-0.4552050232887268,
0.42220935225486755,
0.08014125376939774,
0.22472846508026123,
-1.2274917364120483,
-0.18510547280311584,
-0.08581775426864624,
-0.36366936564445496,
-0.6857377290725708,
-0.7483855485916138,
-0.3831283748149872,
0.06599355489015579,
-0.3421720564365387,
0.05242295563220978,
-0.3487647771835327,
-0.052275918424129486,
-0.1038319393992424,
0.17650820314884186,
-0.21132653951644897,
0.7330552339553833,
-0.14766256511211395,
0.6021615266799927,
0.5268362164497375,
-0.7199729681015015,
0.5418709516525269,
0.41685107350349426,
-0.09493926912546158,
0.5986728668212891,
-0.5017222762107849,
0.1915961354970932,
-0.5160918831825256,
0.42772194743156433,
-1.0855180025100708,
-0.3128048777580261,
0.1961018294095993,
-0.5750960111618042,
0.03559349104762077,
-0.21459093689918518,
0.07582089304924011,
-0.4176097810268402,
-0.1471063643693924,
-0.06517675518989563,
0.6455884575843811,
0.0071022664196789265,
0.8430825471878052,
1.089487910270691,
-0.5707393884658813,
-0.2369970679283142,
-0.6260425448417664,
0.408067911863327,
-0.37321099638938904,
-0.4810880124568939,
0.09710580855607986,
-0.15545795857906342,
-0.8684130311012268,
-0.42191246151924133,
-0.048066966235637665,
-0.1905563473701477,
0.1796099990606308,
0.5020139217376709,
0.14322054386138916,
-0.004689146764576435,
0.04268651083111763,
0.040045879781246185,
-0.0504281185567379,
0.6349796056747437,
-0.03808300569653511,
0.31713831424713135,
-0.0676436498761177,
0.06064901500940323,
-0.6707047820091248,
0.4436812698841095,
0.85712730884552,
0.2591265141963959,
0.6673685312271118,
0.11078165471553802,
-0.040359314531087875,
0.28663796186447144,
-0.17242467403411865,
-0.29193538427352905,
-0.48200395703315735,
0.33256399631500244,
0.14112816751003265,
-0.4419327676296234,
0.7057296633720398,
-0.3238666355609894,
0.39740365743637085,
0.20363686978816986,
0.5136421322822571,
-0.44657132029533386,
1.2523679733276367,
0.5501695871353149,
-0.057676658034324646,
0.6560946106910706,
-0.006364235654473305,
0.08445105701684952,
-0.31804975867271423,
-0.427390456199646,
-0.526707649230957,
-0.38065144419670105,
-0.4714577794075012,
0.13354060053825378,
0.4637908339500427,
-0.08997844159603119,
0.017703790217638016,
0.34312140941619873,
-0.22894081473350525,
0.6006165742874146,
0.6017451882362366,
0.0003324327408336103,
0.3594639301300049,
-0.3576189875602722,
0.08314821124076843,
-0.11747413128614426,
-0.37778857350349426,
-0.6267961263656616,
0.8309873342514038,
0.3051282465457916,
0.4775724709033966,
0.03729740530252457,
0.3595048487186432,
0.5280722379684448,
0.6845625042915344,
-0.7509326338768005,
0.577559769153595,
0.4524683654308319,
-0.3796271085739136,
-0.2718278169631958,
-0.2760631740093231,
-1.0779271125793457,
0.1944735050201416,
-0.23022903501987457,
-0.7824265956878662,
-0.13434164226055145,
0.17929404973983765,
-0.4084310531616211,
-0.044532183557748795,
-0.7970696091651917,
0.7928218245506287,
-0.34503042697906494,
-0.12684035301208496,
-0.32421374320983887,
-1.150213599205017,
0.3050075173377991,
0.19781936705112457,
0.5551914572715759,
-0.3949200510978699,
0.21839193999767303,
1.0108213424682617,
-0.5756704211235046,
1.00184965133667,
0.12122822552919388,
-0.31473931670188904,
0.5444371700286865,
0.07119236886501312,
0.09559890627861023,
-0.09437025338411331,
0.07772113382816315,
0.2359243631362915,
0.08431298285722733,
-0.15099768340587616,
-0.7007599472999573,
0.2859361469745636,
-0.47476255893707275,
-0.43552055954933167,
-0.31066861748695374,
-0.415903776884079,
-0.1416545808315277,
-0.007675917353481054,
0.35148295760154724,
0.591505229473114,
-0.39672723412513733,
-0.2845900058746338,
0.08632978051900864,
0.09540059417486191,
0.6824366450309753,
0.6604250073432922,
-0.29428988695144653,
-0.26588428020477295,
0.7134833931922913,
-0.07454393059015274,
0.2881286144256592,
0.23839685320854187,
0.38217630982398987,
-0.28670600056648254,
-0.3849644958972931,
-0.1527765691280365,
0.16084979474544525,
-0.6447433233261108,
-0.2575819194316864,
-0.8827506303787231,
0.061781127005815506,
-0.5613304972648621,
-0.06762906908988953,
-0.0643489733338356,
-0.2702789008617401,
-0.4647112488746643,
-0.3056672513484955,
0.30448758602142334,
1.0989313125610352,
-0.016857760027050972,
0.5006123781204224,
-1.0803827047348022,
-0.033096350729465485,
0.5510604381561279,
-0.09500494599342346,
0.05567707493901253,
-0.627702534198761,
-0.39246004819869995,
0.34754320979118347,
-0.9468964338302612,
-1.40966796875,
0.704697847366333,
0.2210744470357895,
0.19831733405590057,
0.31541723012924194,
0.22252720594406128,
0.903997540473938,
-0.39142850041389465,
1.1145174503326416,
0.012930233962833881,
-0.8996439576148987,
0.8353143334388733,
-0.5912589430809021,
0.23323173820972443,
0.4934089183807373,
0.38089990615844727,
-0.8415098190307617,
-0.8533979654312134,
-0.4132484495639801,
-0.6837912797927856,
0.4398040771484375,
0.25479063391685486,
0.5136812329292297,
-0.05399644374847412,
0.30174240469932556,
-0.1445806920528412,
0.06484191864728928,
-0.33381223678588867,
-0.40635207295417786,
-0.1692381501197815,
-0.04825093597173691,
-0.09442441910505295,
-0.170630544424057,
-0.12876170873641968,
-0.2671946585178375,
0.3160841166973114,
0.05469472333788872,
0.054032232612371445,
-0.036580994725227356,
0.020042937248945236,
-0.47436732053756714,
0.15396718680858612,
0.693021833896637,
0.606467604637146,
-0.21582771837711334,
-0.053616248071193695,
0.3349049985408783,
-0.6243143677711487,
-0.09688934683799744,
-0.37616968154907227,
0.0832252949476242,
0.11823917180299759,
0.6100695729255676,
0.734646737575531,
0.47403979301452637,
-0.8715239763259888,
0.40868833661079407,
-0.38540974259376526,
-0.11589937657117844,
-0.4053632915019989,
0.19105592370033264,
0.15306560695171356,
0.28504884243011475,
0.49146828055381775,
0.16736333072185516,
0.4208230674266815,
-0.9059205651283264,
0.2694573402404785,
0.4512271285057068,
-0.3723039925098419,
-0.541862964630127,
0.8556966781616211,
0.6317861676216125,
-0.6281813979148865,
0.5390977263450623,
0.23197418451309204,
-0.687341570854187,
0.5549805164337158,
0.37847885489463806,
0.7283297181129456,
-0.1935425102710724,
0.3311106860637665,
0.5772072076797485,
-0.1632731705904007,
-0.062178973108530045,
-0.08728478848934174,
-0.5079322457313538,
-0.6574510931968689,
-0.40529465675354004,
-0.480782151222229,
-0.7105226516723633,
-0.35074561834335327,
-0.8460919857025146,
0.07943670451641083,
-0.17638295888900757,
-0.5370262861251831,
-0.003369836835190654,
-0.11437387764453888,
-0.09680788218975067,
0.013230985030531883,
-0.039580415934324265,
0.6010154485702515,
-1.1234022378921509,
0.10169953107833862,
0.4729176163673401,
-0.4015359580516815,
-0.6159685254096985,
0.30010971426963806,
0.24267442524433136,
-0.462826669216156,
0.5596614480018616,
0.1818927526473999,
-0.3065398037433624,
0.014623641036450863,
-0.7166051864624023,
-1.06210458278656,
0.9357055425643921,
0.2630751430988312,
-0.3946569561958313,
-0.10258669406175613,
-0.19137582182884216,
0.8815428018569946,
0.04082919657230377,
0.4505721926689148,
0.8828845024108887,
0.34558066725730896,
0.4122411608695984,
-0.9487704634666443,
-0.28508976101875305,
-0.5680745840072632,
-0.411323606967926,
0.27973687648773193,
-0.3609241545200348,
0.5244897603988647,
-0.4407501518726349,
-0.479137122631073,
-0.03741289675235748,
0.8701342344284058,
-0.5594181418418884,
0.3320879638195038,
0.4511643350124359,
0.02870122902095318,
0.7122624516487122,
-0.11546571552753448,
1.1196542978286743,
-0.2012554407119751,
0.20209307968616486,
0.9812155365943909,
-0.04897867515683174,
0.8205446004867554,
0.3498621881008148,
-0.403632789850235,
0.8257194757461548,
0.6059852242469788,
0.4936700165271759,
0.4727672338485718,
0.16743029654026031,
-0.35155946016311646,
-0.38460060954093933,
-0.20704109966754913,
-0.06514152884483337,
0.5573912858963013,
0.5593260526657104,
-0.06008581817150116,
-0.2613752484321594,
0.08834812790155411,
0.04875617474317551,
-0.005794254131615162,
-0.10795539617538452,
1.3391047716140747,
-0.08576426655054092,
-1.2746437788009644,
0.07690738141536713,
-0.4913803040981293,
0.572108805179596,
-0.33858224749565125,
-0.06694142520427704,
-0.26537036895751953,
-0.2945917248725891,
-0.09657138586044312,
-1.006447434425354,
0.7279466390609741,
-0.0639510229229927,
0.14519789814949036,
-0.6251874566078186,
0.32363224029541016,
-0.5539321899414062,
-0.3492446839809418,
0.1433478444814682,
0.533730149269104,
0.45334526896476746,
0.09814952313899994,
-0.393711119890213,
-0.09393201768398285,
-0.07473012804985046,
-0.15492649376392365,
0.2288757860660553,
0.24346870183944702,
0.0616588294506073,
0.806474506855011,
0.7533734440803528,
-0.029508428648114204,
-0.05913512781262398,
-0.1320011466741562,
0.6692389845848083,
-0.7541972994804382,
-0.7288705110549927,
-0.9717483520507812,
0.7262018322944641,
-0.09778611361980438,
-0.3241675794124603,
0.4025406539440155,
0.24768522381782532,
0.2587641775608063,
0.2830277979373932,
0.6881963014602661,
0.08124914765357971,
0.9043872356414795,
-0.3238261640071869,
0.8325018286705017,
-0.4475555419921875,
0.2269272804260254,
-0.29579830169677734,
-0.47109243273735046,
-0.2925125062465668,
0.5791537761688232,
-0.1299070566892624,
-0.2462913990020752,
0.6099778413772583,
0.551230788230896,
0.31731653213500977,
0.2076663374900818,
0.06396441161632538,
0.445061594247818,
0.33597269654273987,
0.2955828309059143,
1.0123618841171265,
-0.04201988875865936,
0.7980925440788269,
-0.18420590460300446,
-0.1988396793603897,
-0.03587951883673668,
-0.9458370208740234,
-0.8437323570251465,
-0.8455905914306641,
-0.3503227233886719,
-0.38278308510780334,
-0.060956064611673355,
0.8057390451431274,
0.6464905738830566,
-0.71976637840271,
-0.32003065943717957,
-0.3793298304080963,
0.19091889262199402,
-0.028234492987394333,
-0.2913267910480499,
-0.058480292558670044,
-0.3572203516960144,
-0.8050085306167603,
0.2446778565645218,
0.287314236164093,
0.30504274368286133,
0.011211643926799297,
0.0033385700080543756,
0.08230353891849518,
0.08731964230537415,
0.3707980811595917,
0.5635387897491455,
-0.614670991897583,
-0.2057953178882599,
-0.08447784930467606,
-0.2495598942041397,
0.005757071543484926,
1.0037583112716675,
-0.8874822854995728,
0.14561444520950317,
0.6093549728393555,
0.1883438378572464,
0.31240248680114746,
0.32659685611724854,
1.2597575187683105,
-0.4717860221862793,
-0.06254258006811142,
0.1501503735780716,
0.1358046531677246,
0.15931390225887299,
-0.5031927227973938,
0.25438442826271057,
0.07047203928232193,
-0.7513170838356018,
-0.717836856842041,
0.16456609964370728,
-0.9910140037536621,
-0.14035344123840332,
0.6465914845466614,
-0.06905324757099152,
-0.16902387142181396,
-0.7440396547317505,
-0.5218806266784668,
0.4437809884548187,
-0.4099719524383545,
1.2158674001693726,
0.6006011366844177,
-0.5122410655021667,
-0.05465058609843254,
-0.24110613763332367,
0.5588005781173706,
0.22168387472629547,
-1.1072323322296143,
0.11664485931396484,
0.8133766651153564,
0.299877405166626,
0.4121953845024109,
0.8359918594360352,
0.2684330642223358,
0.18131469190120697,
-0.17409847676753998,
-0.5673291087150574,
0.4068966209888458,
-0.08600255846977234,
0.23535701632499695,
0.16510747373104095,
-0.4491090476512909,
-0.1809881329536438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18928v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18928v1
|
Stylus: Automatic Adapter Selection for Diffusion Models
| 2024-04-29T17:59:16 | 2024-04-29T17:59:16 |
Michael Luo, Justin Wong, Brandon Trabucco, Yanping Huang, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Zhifeng Chen, Ruslan Salakhutdinov, Ion Stoica
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GR, cs.LG
|
Beyond scaling base models with more data or parameters, fine-tuned adapters
provide an alternative way to generate high fidelity, custom images at reduced
costs. As such, adapters have been widely adopted by open-source communities,
accumulating a database of over 100K adapters-most of which are highly
customized with insufficient descriptions. This paper explores the problem of
matching the prompt to a set of relevant adapters, built on recent work that
highlight the performance gains of composing adapters. We introduce Stylus,
which efficiently selects and automatically composes task-specific adapters
based on a prompt's keywords. Stylus outlines a three-stage approach that first
summarizes adapters with improved descriptions and embeddings, retrieves
relevant adapters, and then further assembles adapters based on prompts'
keywords by checking how well they fit the prompt. To evaluate Stylus, we
developed StylusDocs, a curated dataset featuring 75K adapters with
pre-computed adapter embeddings. In our evaluation on popular Stable Diffusion
checkpoints, Stylus achieves greater CLIP-FID Pareto efficiency and is twice as
preferred, with humans and multimodal models as evaluators, over the base
model. See stylus-diffusion.github.io for more.
|
[
-0.5959794521331787,
-0.5188921093940735,
0.917018711566925,
0.19682198762893677,
-0.3309270143508911,
-0.3701164126396179,
-0.1479305624961853,
-0.3136731684207916,
0.3408454656600952,
0.2551979124546051,
-0.45138120651245117,
-0.2846779525279999,
-0.6799771785736084,
0.06395580619573593,
-0.011552304029464722,
0.8340969681739807,
-0.35795730352401733,
-0.26564496755599976,
-0.4667385518550873,
-0.399537056684494,
-0.6254767179489136,
0.5596250295639038,
-1.022031307220459,
-0.1336822509765625,
0.6512414813041687,
0.4127259850502014,
0.5890076756477356,
0.7467148303985596,
0.3711155354976654,
0.24540208280086517,
-0.20665082335472107,
0.07856769859790802,
-0.3153819441795349,
0.3080943524837494,
-0.3057924509048462,
-0.1294994354248047,
-0.23533184826374054,
0.003953414503484964,
0.37360095977783203,
0.30084630846977234,
-0.04714968800544739,
0.35913804173469543,
0.11268291622400284,
0.7399895787239075,
-0.7623206377029419,
-0.4181372821331024,
-0.3022025227546692,
0.22825421392917633,
0.019541064277291298,
0.12501627206802368,
-0.2825023829936981,
-0.44143813848495483,
0.3120068907737732,
-0.9236855506896973,
0.42123591899871826,
-0.1816081702709198,
0.5658135414123535,
0.3369988203048706,
-0.3108709454536438,
-0.35179534554481506,
-0.6871156096458435,
0.37323129177093506,
-0.34052959084510803,
0.24367602169513702,
0.04493413865566254,
0.6780585646629333,
-0.25894895195961,
-1.0158905982971191,
-0.36085787415504456,
-0.09618601202964783,
0.16567254066467285,
0.29745781421661377,
-0.09729389101266861,
0.0028951033018529415,
0.23244255781173706,
0.29905205965042114,
-0.47553446888923645,
-0.09996122866868973,
-0.28753119707107544,
-0.16562753915786743,
0.47217482328414917,
0.33172670006752014,
0.20043861865997314,
0.21982701122760773,
-0.1409146785736084,
0.01766151376068592,
-0.5122018456459045,
0.20930828154087067,
0.42169344425201416,
-0.07433981448411942,
-0.09138708561658859,
0.34832510352134705,
-0.08079539239406586,
0.9816396832466125,
0.5476359128952026,
0.043545085936784744,
-0.060050882399082184,
-0.5829982757568359,
-0.028454521670937538,
-0.4155644178390503,
0.9028897881507874,
0.48825523257255554,
-0.020596709102392197,
0.200158953666687,
-0.0792941004037857,
-0.27436134219169617,
0.38176625967025757,
-0.9611027836799622,
-0.7144606113433838,
0.3000059425830841,
-0.7382225394248962,
-0.2955910861492157,
-0.40905290842056274,
-1.0947743654251099,
-0.7056404948234558,
-0.06976372748613358,
0.6014264822006226,
-0.14485763013362885,
-0.25335893034935,
0.02613185904920101,
-0.7906454205513,
-0.42551344633102417,
0.8275747895240784,
-0.7328734993934631,
0.05365177243947983,
0.184590682387352,
1.2999018430709839,
-0.42546001076698303,
-0.25132128596305847,
-0.5703604817390442,
-0.01032303273677826,
-0.4268825352191925,
1.2244806289672852,
-0.9761103987693787,
-0.7680081725120544,
-0.12074961513280869,
0.22537103295326233,
-0.2436622828245163,
-0.562145471572876,
0.56086665391922,
-0.32542508840560913,
0.19263431429862976,
-0.387680321931839,
-0.6727341413497925,
-0.05548091605305672,
-0.1021791473031044,
-0.8705214262008667,
0.8800930976867676,
0.29943588376045227,
-0.6444243788719177,
0.688252329826355,
-0.9871378540992737,
-0.26938435435295105,
-0.02010957896709442,
0.17759419977664948,
-0.38375136256217957,
0.22782425582408905,
0.006601231638342142,
0.2943384051322937,
-0.17780034244060516,
-0.0876481831073761,
-0.5400201678276062,
-0.22809408605098724,
-0.16727012395858765,
0.031221158802509308,
0.6410559415817261,
0.3907512426376343,
-0.03183064982295036,
0.7153264284133911,
-0.42717814445495605,
-0.517332911491394,
-0.05800079554319382,
-0.3581756055355072,
-0.18544510006904602,
0.05917438492178917,
0.20226222276687622,
0.1851290464401245,
-0.009386785328388214,
-0.5660542249679565,
0.23730188608169556,
0.013795540668070316,
0.6763066649436951,
0.78180330991745,
0.13546407222747803,
0.9017819166183472,
-0.5806573033332825,
0.6037998795509338,
0.2503640055656433,
0.385692298412323,
-0.495511919260025,
-0.8106328845024109,
-0.4471486806869507,
-0.6490420699119568,
0.2077205777168274,
0.3190937638282776,
-0.5944674015045166,
0.21789875626564026,
-0.06961392611265182,
-0.9957223534584045,
-0.44622278213500977,
0.14550960063934326,
-0.19996877014636993,
0.9048240780830383,
0.27443355321884155,
-0.3874174654483795,
-0.09136147052049637,
-0.9067434072494507,
-0.2373039275407791,
0.07665720582008362,
-0.28518906235694885,
0.6838992834091187,
0.3412320017814636,
-0.29998907446861267,
1.0327776670455933,
-0.7549657225608826,
-0.3199739456176758,
-0.12691298127174377,
-0.06804948300123215,
0.31929728388786316,
0.44172680377960205,
0.7504327893257141,
-0.5004371404647827,
-0.6286383271217346,
-0.14731819927692413,
-0.31525158882141113,
-0.19045528769493103,
-0.2547079026699066,
-0.3369824290275574,
-0.22868822515010834,
0.2700112462043762,
-0.7528912425041199,
0.3158164620399475,
0.2804030179977417,
-0.5826801061630249,
0.6478327512741089,
-0.5795628428459167,
0.23426134884357452,
-1.0472663640975952,
0.2858330309391022,
0.4422203302383423,
-0.1782435029745102,
-0.6910889744758606,
-0.2195674180984497,
0.35239750146865845,
-0.11973347514867783,
-0.5772770047187805,
0.8948342204093933,
-0.1198209598660469,
0.21565032005310059,
-0.2724120020866394,
0.00896281935274601,
0.2713736891746521,
0.057920556515455246,
0.21129705011844635,
0.7422205209732056,
0.6097622513771057,
-0.7346889972686768,
0.2819520831108093,
0.23846778273582458,
-0.26521050930023193,
0.8572641015052795,
-0.7073132991790771,
0.07482217252254486,
-0.2490321844816208,
0.4886879622936249,
-1.2717185020446777,
-0.07526057213544846,
0.37173184752464294,
0.09025661647319794,
-0.135086789727211,
-0.494388610124588,
-0.18166978657245636,
-0.44155946373939514,
-0.5268623232841492,
0.5556267499923706,
0.6546945571899414,
-0.35962677001953125,
0.9295136332511902,
0.430016428232193,
-0.24535980820655823,
-0.020352955907583237,
-0.19509251415729523,
-0.09141062945127487,
-0.5402779579162598,
-0.6198050379753113,
0.13670150935649872,
-0.5276737213134766,
0.21656140685081482,
-0.12664179503917694,
0.15348230302333832,
-0.04654301330447197,
0.246003195643425,
0.3763881325721741,
0.22950157523155212,
-0.04219570755958557,
-0.145187646150589,
0.29083332419395447,
-0.11322054266929626,
-0.2574016749858856,
-0.5919657945632935,
0.10119906812906265,
0.4844707250595093,
-0.22138038277626038,
-0.46917083859443665,
0.09375739097595215,
0.6387895345687866,
0.25639259815216064,
0.10784102976322174,
0.8424716591835022,
-0.20362010598182678,
-0.03245718777179718,
-0.4551175832748413,
0.03391992300748825,
-0.5566012859344482,
0.04557940736413002,
-0.49034586548805237,
-0.5149508714675903,
0.6923501491546631,
-0.10621272772550583,
0.4840461015701294,
0.3168823719024658,
0.48639968037605286,
-0.12336049228906631,
0.9462125897407532,
0.5510209202766418,
0.03499096259474754,
0.9899157285690308,
0.04635683074593544,
-0.2084198296070099,
-0.9458447694778442,
0.16001535952091217,
-0.29616254568099976,
-0.7182157635688782,
-0.12709110975265503,
-0.4778776466846466,
0.3649677634239197,
-0.22014713287353516,
-0.07123642414808273,
0.35611000657081604,
-0.8364039659500122,
0.5317825078964233,
0.6281301975250244,
0.12468250840902328,
0.08184820413589478,
-0.07669520378112793,
-0.09980282187461853,
0.13217292726039886,
-0.5026721358299255,
-0.3298397660255432,
1.046216607093811,
0.3875073492527008,
0.5792843699455261,
0.01913982443511486,
0.27307814359664917,
0.4271005690097809,
0.2811819016933441,
-0.7964193224906921,
0.44934922456741333,
-0.22701862454414368,
-0.36710816621780396,
-0.20163334906101227,
-0.03186748921871185,
-1.0715749263763428,
0.29017430543899536,
-0.22866494953632355,
-0.47111767530441284,
0.768642246723175,
0.5014602541923523,
-0.8281999826431274,
0.1599396914243698,
-0.7011526226997375,
1.146159052848816,
0.21080432832241058,
-0.440716952085495,
-0.2528085708618164,
-0.3079414367675781,
-0.019681397825479507,
-0.12743307650089264,
0.056398674845695496,
-0.31072118878364563,
-0.36075252294540405,
0.9693727493286133,
-0.15853974223136902,
0.5348576903343201,
-0.6267132759094238,
0.0379650741815567,
0.2499220222234726,
0.31404468417167664,
0.45467379689216614,
-0.018585344776511192,
-0.15022483468055725,
-0.013981064781546593,
0.25702229142189026,
-0.31969645619392395,
-0.3237724304199219,
0.6776559352874756,
-0.33042874932289124,
-0.461506187915802,
0.06993889063596725,
-0.5770233273506165,
0.054321568459272385,
0.3812006413936615,
0.6111732721328735,
0.3443938195705414,
-0.18932005763053894,
-0.4285837411880493,
0.6683771014213562,
-0.14916500449180603,
0.5902355909347534,
0.3646101653575897,
-0.09960535168647766,
-0.6375381350517273,
0.9929479360580444,
0.1555703580379486,
0.163369283080101,
-0.2309652864933014,
0.4152318239212036,
-0.11198266595602036,
-0.8232514262199402,
-1.2711536884307861,
0.14778192341327667,
-0.6604722142219543,
-0.1470804214477539,
-0.7178808450698853,
0.26034918427467346,
-0.2932327687740326,
-0.5155549049377441,
-0.0902085080742836,
-0.41948893666267395,
-0.6819302439689636,
0.05235094204545021,
0.5233206152915955,
0.8727132081985474,
-0.05649745091795921,
0.37592431902885437,
-0.7685563564300537,
0.4119455814361572,
0.37758028507232666,
0.33416828513145447,
-0.04525165259838104,
-0.635776698589325,
-0.37634503841400146,
-0.23079241812229156,
-0.4002780020236969,
-0.9036965370178223,
0.20874297618865967,
0.5053374171257019,
0.5897724032402039,
0.6849492192268372,
0.05920037627220154,
0.8506044149398804,
-0.6613962054252625,
0.9320428967475891,
0.15715757012367249,
-0.6236879825592041,
0.7722209095954895,
-0.5351019501686096,
0.2917105257511139,
0.7705886363983154,
0.2587740123271942,
-0.4490303695201874,
-0.3778463900089264,
-0.4790748357772827,
-0.9535512924194336,
0.642006516456604,
-0.19809837639331818,
0.07267121225595474,
0.20600615441799164,
0.56231689453125,
0.4789486229419708,
0.09740535914897919,
-0.11498438566923141,
-0.016232991591095924,
-0.25138014554977417,
-0.7039788365364075,
-0.151066854596138,
-0.313812255859375,
-0.37702977657318115,
-0.1618107706308365,
0.1865413635969162,
-0.1739550530910492,
0.26158222556114197,
0.230162113904953,
-0.21943916380405426,
-0.35759449005126953,
-0.2603095471858978,
0.6676028966903687,
0.4426054358482361,
0.1102902814745903,
0.059798210859298706,
0.16472747921943665,
-0.7834279537200928,
0.24967484176158905,
0.02403152734041214,
-0.37883493304252625,
0.1484605222940445,
0.15467166900634766,
0.7772997617721558,
0.08492894470691681,
-0.5166558027267456,
0.6713461875915527,
-0.3460415303707123,
-0.26026010513305664,
-0.25347238779067993,
0.4553155303001404,
0.06910070776939392,
0.2985917627811432,
0.16051410138607025,
0.5248196721076965,
0.6482975482940674,
-0.034939803183078766,
0.2118254452943802,
0.4820779263973236,
-0.5937513709068298,
-0.518295168876648,
0.7413867712020874,
0.4627876281738281,
-0.36493706703186035,
0.22641490399837494,
-0.044783346354961395,
-0.020892508327960968,
0.6609128713607788,
0.31747931241989136,
0.9861193895339966,
-0.3134396970272064,
0.24489308893680573,
0.4385618567466736,
0.07605137676000595,
-0.39371877908706665,
0.031143568456172943,
-0.4554230868816376,
-0.37527379393577576,
0.09049949795007706,
-0.40038642287254333,
-0.40064263343811035,
-0.4402983784675598,
-0.4963395297527313,
0.44884204864501953,
-0.6406430602073669,
-0.5234646201133728,
0.03342568874359131,
-0.3517739474773407,
-0.7056726217269897,
-0.17898018658161163,
-0.03134024888277054,
1.5579839944839478,
-1.2477118968963623,
0.615693986415863,
0.8834165334701538,
-0.15542037785053253,
-0.10157112777233124,
-0.09857659786939621,
-0.06411397457122803,
-0.3505014479160309,
0.21721069514751434,
0.018932515755295753,
0.19411736726760864,
0.18060016632080078,
-0.08197038620710373,
-0.6832089424133301,
1.1439100503921509,
0.3364839255809784,
-0.28244665265083313,
0.07821298390626907,
-0.48385217785835266,
0.3485385775566101,
-0.5139696002006531,
0.7543258666992188,
0.6382440328598022,
0.5392543077468872,
0.30449798703193665,
-0.8879775404930115,
0.20920132100582123,
-0.31635189056396484,
0.06677021831274033,
0.09889274090528488,
-0.41534224152565,
0.6921261548995972,
-0.10802274942398071,
-0.17324532568454742,
0.14198696613311768,
0.35610321164131165,
0.20817261934280396,
0.5744918584823608,
0.8957681059837341,
0.6406322121620178,
0.6573778390884399,
0.10202716290950775,
0.6985883116722107,
-0.17446184158325195,
-0.0855264961719513,
0.869997501373291,
-0.2586919367313385,
0.7623347640037537,
0.31183236837387085,
-0.07808660715818405,
0.6076782941818237,
1.1522648334503174,
-0.17205312848091125,
0.7212334871292114,
-0.144769549369812,
-0.32970431447029114,
-0.2693527340888977,
0.0959443673491478,
-0.047080837190151215,
-0.3430462181568146,
0.36889880895614624,
-0.3421032428741455,
-0.17961707711219788,
0.4361342787742615,
-0.35463425517082214,
-0.44512709975242615,
-0.24278511106967926,
1.1951887607574463,
-0.11656337231397629,
-0.8139572143554688,
0.07058975100517273,
-0.43594422936439514,
0.677521824836731,
-0.43575572967529297,
0.005722635425627232,
-0.18864721059799194,
-0.017053978517651558,
-0.3221651315689087,
-1.0703245401382446,
0.3537032902240753,
-0.27617624402046204,
-0.20704470574855804,
-0.1852147877216339,
0.8481643199920654,
-0.345967561006546,
-0.36708691716194153,
0.11767621338367462,
0.10808216035366058,
0.09096430987119675,
-0.05665434151887894,
-0.6534327268600464,
0.018808241933584213,
-0.15048041939735413,
-0.34719616174697876,
0.3000699281692505,
0.3019489049911499,
0.23160265386104584,
0.6405279040336609,
0.6182718873023987,
0.2607074975967407,
-0.1841782033443451,
-0.32696521282196045,
0.8461533784866333,
-0.5555508732795715,
-0.670540988445282,
-0.7458436489105225,
0.8658795356750488,
-0.24301500618457794,
-0.34805187582969666,
0.5971371531486511,
0.49463728070259094,
0.2715734541416168,
-0.2887084484100342,
0.8687784075737,
0.08255231380462646,
0.30198654532432556,
-0.27159225940704346,
0.7026954889297485,
-0.561151385307312,
0.04210677370429039,
-0.1682385951280594,
-0.8685739040374756,
-0.1524660587310791,
0.695015013217926,
-0.3827541172504425,
-0.0782918930053711,
0.4116412401199341,
0.7770552039146423,
-0.3907407522201538,
-0.09916360676288605,
0.13460132479667664,
-0.30140048265457153,
0.34852492809295654,
0.46908536553382874,
0.720713198184967,
-0.2553759515285492,
0.4340415894985199,
-0.030342668294906616,
-0.2941753566265106,
-0.6214222311973572,
-0.9337966442108154,
-0.7930644750595093,
-0.7382751703262329,
-0.5782691240310669,
-0.4200085401535034,
-0.26667308807373047,
0.7213312387466431,
0.8897364139556885,
-0.6950917840003967,
-0.21533344686031342,
-0.10895952582359314,
0.2777992784976959,
-0.06126256659626961,
-0.14839422702789307,
0.21879270672798157,
-0.22256402671337128,
-0.7099932432174683,
0.308154433965683,
0.43416881561279297,
0.21960243582725525,
0.048047758638858795,
-0.08410913497209549,
0.354568213224411,
0.20841597020626068,
0.3947618901729584,
0.1881321221590042,
-0.3389717638492584,
-0.2044142335653305,
-0.11099479347467422,
0.04415445402264595,
0.08063279092311859,
0.9044021964073181,
-0.8284080028533936,
0.6237285137176514,
0.9396035671234131,
0.40692248940467834,
0.4416990876197815,
-0.17893317341804504,
0.6360676288604736,
-0.09395090490579605,
0.0010509405983611941,
0.007727489806711674,
0.5141618847846985,
0.09166537970304489,
-0.2593421936035156,
0.2838139235973358,
0.30539414286613464,
-0.7842884659767151,
-0.7666595578193665,
0.4792245924472809,
-0.8796550035476685,
-0.25359466671943665,
1.1339038610458374,
-0.21812503039836884,
-0.35188302397727966,
-0.4812597632408142,
-0.5584629774093628,
-0.06316599994897842,
-0.6042382717132568,
0.6904157996177673,
0.4448856711387634,
-0.3204135596752167,
-0.2758738398551941,
-0.2901281714439392,
0.6616012454032898,
0.017448199912905693,
-0.4246067702770233,
0.05361359566450119,
0.7566899657249451,
0.6751681566238403,
0.2575959861278534,
0.9071973562240601,
0.33939531445503235,
0.4360337257385254,
-0.06463237851858139,
-0.2148999124765396,
-0.14466671645641327,
-0.08953037858009338,
-0.5932607054710388,
0.2940002977848053,
0.38615500926971436,
-0.24050863087177277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18923v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18923v2
|
Holmes: Benchmark the Linguistic Competence of Language Models
| 2024-04-29T17:58:36 | 2024-05-22T08:36:49 |
Andreas Waldis, Yotam Perlitz, Leshem Choshen, Yufang Hou, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce Holmes, a benchmark to assess the linguistic competence of
language models (LMs) - their ability to grasp linguistic phenomena. Unlike
prior prompting-based evaluations, Holmes assesses the linguistic competence of
LMs via their internal representations using classifier-based probing. In doing
so, we disentangle specific phenomena (e.g., part-of-speech of words) from
other cognitive abilities, like following textual instructions, and meet recent
calls to assess LMs' linguistic competence in isolation. Composing Holmes, we
review over 250 probing studies and feature more than 200 datasets to assess
syntax, morphology, semantics, reasoning, and discourse phenomena. Analyzing
over 50 LMs reveals that, aligned with known trends, their linguistic
competence correlates with model size. However, surprisingly, model
architecture and instruction tuning also significantly influence performance,
particularly in morphology and syntax. Finally, we propose FlashHolmes, a
streamlined version of Holmes designed to lower the high computation load while
maintaining high-ranking precision.
|
[
-0.23223882913589478,
-0.9136072397232056,
0.5326213836669922,
0.169404998421669,
0.02848481386899948,
0.1222432479262352,
-0.30670592188835144,
-0.32398509979248047,
0.12928256392478943,
0.5248352289199829,
-0.23389706015586853,
-0.19469283521175385,
-0.6484466195106506,
0.1274070292711258,
-0.5943830013275146,
0.5190825462341309,
0.35363805294036865,
0.03177356719970703,
-0.40223369002342224,
-0.07353007793426514,
-0.23565907776355743,
-0.2457207292318344,
-0.6149411797523499,
-0.10866567492485046,
0.4953853189945221,
0.08883274346590042,
0.7500853538513184,
0.691817045211792,
0.6391523480415344,
0.32781389355659485,
-0.20594467222690582,
-0.11060388386249542,
-0.2766469120979309,
0.32648903131484985,
-0.33405888080596924,
-0.6026235818862915,
-0.5075839757919312,
-0.1835249811410904,
0.7723435163497925,
1.0717620849609375,
-0.09299733489751816,
0.4769471287727356,
0.14051547646522522,
0.6081545948982239,
-0.8130795359611511,
0.2802492380142212,
-0.8159665465354919,
-0.23250466585159302,
-0.5923267006874084,
-0.3786357343196869,
-0.5695661306381226,
-0.25515395402908325,
0.1683686375617981,
-0.2511771321296692,
0.3359074890613556,
-0.012938758358359337,
0.6247993111610413,
0.28645506501197815,
-0.5659014582633972,
-0.09618939459323883,
-0.3810120224952698,
0.814408004283905,
-0.6624969840049744,
0.5557985305786133,
0.5838311314582825,
0.37205055356025696,
0.056227412074804306,
-0.698482096195221,
-0.42285141348838806,
-0.4186883270740509,
-0.030290093272924423,
-0.009593120776116848,
-0.05775662511587143,
-0.06358232349157333,
0.3227379024028778,
0.3385840654373169,
-0.7177509069442749,
0.022491455078125,
-0.3623011112213135,
-0.00689234584569931,
0.7432973384857178,
0.29573795199394226,
0.15911394357681274,
-0.038340914994478226,
0.14296257495880127,
-0.19358348846435547,
-0.6051127314567566,
0.1801767647266388,
0.28842267394065857,
0.3752777874469757,
0.3281954526901245,
0.5326011776924133,
-0.25516894459724426,
0.5855899453163147,
-0.14938855171203613,
0.06266658008098602,
0.16436125338077545,
0.07019496709108353,
-0.23672270774841309,
-0.1672937273979187,
0.6679426431655884,
0.04662128910422325,
0.3656589090824127,
-0.08306574821472168,
-0.1185714527964592,
-0.08349114656448364,
0.5280793905258179,
-0.5023798942565918,
-0.23734094202518463,
0.34640488028526306,
-0.3929811716079712,
-0.2707766592502594,
-0.2918713390827179,
-0.881783127784729,
-0.413376122713089,
0.03201930224895477,
0.23970921337604523,
-0.258905291557312,
-0.4953186810016632,
0.12785835564136505,
0.0498964861035347,
0.2159515917301178,
0.05588938295841217,
-1.238038182258606,
0.598432183265686,
0.8683818578720093,
0.5199173092842102,
-0.12300144135951996,
-0.4351118206977844,
-0.4501546621322632,
-0.0944746658205986,
-0.7167049050331116,
0.5093526244163513,
-0.6292862296104431,
-0.39198383688926697,
0.31255537271499634,
0.03977808356285095,
-0.052010197192430496,
-0.5610427260398865,
0.4935775697231293,
-0.48106780648231506,
0.0021218149922788143,
-0.0958733856678009,
-0.9133527874946594,
-0.2562156319618225,
0.22201669216156006,
-0.740409255027771,
1.1252474784851074,
-0.04971347004175186,
-0.6422906517982483,
0.31298068165779114,
-0.44282448291778564,
-0.5035306215286255,
0.45101240277290344,
-0.2177184373140335,
-0.1356625109910965,
0.49731820821762085,
0.18619607388973236,
0.6325074434280396,
-0.2963207960128784,
0.3950592279434204,
-0.43164336681365967,
-0.18107594549655914,
0.22626928985118866,
-0.33575138449668884,
1.024888515472412,
-0.07196713238954544,
-0.15910661220550537,
0.18493004143238068,
-0.8158479928970337,
0.2865695655345917,
0.19912877678871155,
-0.12488135695457458,
-0.2999071478843689,
0.3185043931007385,
-0.0170945655554533,
-0.2727697491645813,
0.1437014639377594,
-0.26559409499168396,
-0.1575184315443039,
-0.36552804708480835,
0.42381998896598816,
0.3349496126174927,
-0.20924657583236694,
0.24074414372444153,
-0.4079749584197998,
0.5579938888549805,
-0.20929071307182312,
0.038763877004384995,
-0.45613399147987366,
-0.6713847517967224,
-0.789752185344696,
-0.21095311641693115,
0.30699190497398376,
0.5642781257629395,
-0.32678282260894775,
0.5702347755432129,
-0.37802988290786743,
-0.6444260478019714,
-0.6819139719009399,
0.0058241235092282295,
0.3669222891330719,
0.4984544813632965,
0.4209626019001007,
-0.37312865257263184,
-0.2458549290895462,
-0.8729217052459717,
-0.6318804621696472,
-0.2811732292175293,
0.0008277695160359144,
0.021999601274728775,
0.4661417603492737,
0.14491043984889984,
0.7670387029647827,
0.0422544963657856,
0.017794353887438774,
-0.18334880471229553,
0.11416120827198029,
0.1947789341211319,
0.4480147361755371,
0.2113543599843979,
-0.366013765335083,
-0.3647237718105316,
-0.1548783779144287,
-0.8101553320884705,
0.04772181436419487,
0.06745792180299759,
0.25565704703330994,
0.2764272093772888,
0.7979912757873535,
-0.5143965482711792,
0.2645402252674103,
0.5394015908241272,
-0.06656235456466675,
0.5301395654678345,
-0.1722944974899292,
0.10481280833482742,
-0.6885032057762146,
0.2403784692287445,
0.06154239550232887,
-0.2480732500553131,
-0.6197744011878967,
0.6043148040771484,
0.43711915612220764,
-0.018463686108589172,
-0.4288492798805237,
0.7039666175842285,
-0.5434109568595886,
-0.16978783905506134,
0.12261815369129181,
0.21166279911994934,
-0.283890038728714,
0.35046371817588806,
0.1850258857011795,
0.6348668932914734,
0.739244282245636,
-0.5607197284698486,
0.20385245978832245,
-0.17789918184280396,
-0.7961750626564026,
0.5225616693496704,
-0.7607167363166809,
0.16894979774951935,
0.04495327174663544,
-0.18413083255290985,
-0.9953598976135254,
-0.05905590578913689,
-0.5275631546974182,
-0.42405346035957336,
0.3252333402633667,
-0.26355481147766113,
-0.6011063456535339,
-0.1858082115650177,
-0.1614464819431305,
0.3857085406780243,
0.7853637337684631,
-0.2929527461528778,
0.588831901550293,
0.41758373379707336,
-0.18303748965263367,
-0.4245154857635498,
-0.765500545501709,
0.04014527052640915,
-0.2543947696685791,
-0.540824294090271,
0.08097634464502335,
0.11403964459896088,
-0.5730968713760376,
-0.18479537963867188,
0.11687536537647247,
-0.21173907816410065,
0.3498040735721588,
0.06355885416269302,
0.043330177664756775,
-0.5330089330673218,
0.1203920841217041,
0.0517013743519783,
-0.053848884999752045,
0.2563088536262512,
-0.06655734032392502,
0.39102089405059814,
-0.15977934002876282,
-0.4894663989543915,
-0.3903229236602783,
0.09531855583190918,
0.4101566672325134,
-0.3531138300895691,
0.5358837246894836,
0.340607613325119,
-0.3619484305381775,
-0.1955815702676773,
-0.6481626033782959,
-0.3993802070617676,
-0.442003071308136,
0.4961429834365845,
-0.6376232504844666,
-0.8838309049606323,
0.49002349376678467,
0.037978995591402054,
0.10896207392215729,
0.49628493189811707,
0.5446557402610779,
-0.1011323481798172,
1.1416620016098022,
0.4944254159927368,
0.0017319424077868462,
0.152136892080307,
-0.0028421280439943075,
0.29074394702911377,
-0.8335691690444946,
0.04686437174677849,
-0.7718566060066223,
-0.11227229237556458,
-0.6648468971252441,
-0.37186750769615173,
0.1321604996919632,
0.30404117703437805,
-0.036919258534908295,
0.3831213414669037,
-0.27986815571784973,
0.5428710579872131,
0.45328426361083984,
-0.16651810705661774,
0.33196821808815,
-0.3862296938896179,
-0.1048080250620842,
-0.25416943430900574,
-0.5031030178070068,
-0.6936547160148621,
1.2455888986587524,
0.5280696153640747,
0.5123439431190491,
0.2958085834980011,
0.5773555636405945,
0.19195185601711273,
0.030619217082858086,
-0.7538805603981018,
0.8049863576889038,
0.0016864477656781673,
-0.8087296485900879,
-0.34967201948165894,
-0.47045719623565674,
-0.9524478316307068,
0.41213664412498474,
-0.0862668827176094,
-0.8149747252464294,
-0.11865100264549255,
0.14252352714538574,
-0.2526196539402008,
0.08067487180233002,
-0.5741316676139832,
0.846336841583252,
-0.15855616331100464,
-0.45691314339637756,
-0.52911776304245,
-0.3152133822441101,
0.3633369505405426,
0.12113615870475769,
0.29784175753593445,
-0.3934720754623413,
-0.3395155370235443,
0.5698192715644836,
-0.12741072475910187,
0.810325026512146,
0.0869702398777008,
-0.09283380210399628,
-0.02686065062880516,
0.6309087872505188,
0.09334416687488556,
0.11466681212186813,
-0.09154010564088821,
0.20757009088993073,
0.42452478408813477,
-0.5637103915214539,
-0.5335035920143127,
0.45619693398475647,
-0.18037952482700348,
-0.5847188234329224,
-0.46485719084739685,
-0.2617301642894745,
-0.6483083963394165,
0.26424363255500793,
0.09980805218219757,
0.6802277565002441,
-0.4794684946537018,
0.17794173955917358,
0.837058424949646,
0.07937333732843399,
0.5833783745765686,
0.5384299755096436,
-0.5496681332588196,
0.06567257642745972,
0.750236988067627,
-0.09588900208473206,
0.20627298951148987,
0.5145913362503052,
0.20386309921741486,
-0.30982908606529236,
-0.9118449687957764,
-0.35780763626098633,
0.1389041692018509,
-0.7058409452438354,
0.07173983752727509,
-0.44094032049179077,
-0.15671327710151672,
-0.4178255498409271,
-0.020231496542692184,
-0.453712522983551,
-0.4381084442138672,
-0.008399332873523235,
0.16729088127613068,
0.1592978835105896,
0.689024031162262,
0.37117981910705566,
0.03525654226541519,
-0.7915949821472168,
-0.1226637065410614,
0.4661739766597748,
0.3821597695350647,
-0.03803553059697151,
-0.660286545753479,
-0.029031498357653618,
-0.13283587992191315,
-0.12814144790172577,
-0.7586021423339844,
0.3029792606830597,
0.3236398696899414,
0.7669689059257507,
0.20733460783958435,
-0.23588374257087708,
0.4280974566936493,
-0.5359528064727783,
1.0241159200668335,
-0.257526159286499,
-1.2134240865707397,
0.5444894433021545,
-0.48232194781303406,
0.5231004953384399,
0.6316824555397034,
0.546345591545105,
-0.49024373292922974,
-0.7375355362892151,
-0.6930094361305237,
-0.4577285945415497,
0.31113573908805847,
-0.024119483307003975,
0.20398260653018951,
-0.3428143858909607,
0.10119947046041489,
-0.09846694022417068,
0.13684114813804626,
-0.18819107115268707,
0.07943074405193329,
0.185491144657135,
-0.26988816261291504,
-0.22712230682373047,
-0.2866237461566925,
-0.11068044602870941,
-0.2062155306339264,
0.5716767311096191,
-0.38944903016090393,
-0.03378962725400925,
-0.036694008857011795,
-0.5866380929946899,
0.1585693657398224,
0.14863809943199158,
0.5935243368148804,
0.9523415565490723,
-0.17039640247821808,
0.31899523735046387,
0.21529753506183624,
-0.45055386424064636,
-0.3640744388103485,
-0.15910829603672028,
0.03398897498846054,
-0.03515110909938812,
0.8688259124755859,
0.36014753580093384,
0.4924905300140381,
-0.9490785598754883,
0.4586162567138672,
-0.14181694388389587,
-0.08076025545597076,
-0.0884016901254654,
0.10232318192720413,
0.12136544287204742,
0.04293680563569069,
0.13018274307250977,
-0.0924113318324089,
0.30914735794067383,
-0.7430738210678101,
0.1976381093263626,
0.39206966757774353,
-0.4230400323867798,
-0.3682015538215637,
0.46563032269477844,
0.25331583619117737,
-0.4723914861679077,
0.606927752494812,
-0.15142440795898438,
-0.372226744890213,
0.4812048077583313,
0.23667249083518982,
0.8240464925765991,
-0.45754653215408325,
-0.07688850164413452,
0.5055702328681946,
0.4380875825881958,
-0.29840168356895447,
0.4417828917503357,
-0.022310368716716766,
-0.6675059199333191,
-0.3811758756637573,
-0.3268042802810669,
-0.4126679599285126,
-0.007335658650845289,
-0.9667631983757019,
0.2141098976135254,
-0.6373894810676575,
-0.1631155014038086,
0.14570263028144836,
0.16464035212993622,
-0.5819025635719299,
0.05209962651133537,
-0.14543244242668152,
1.2499185800552368,
-0.5673140287399292,
1.0353219509124756,
0.5172452330589294,
-0.3429393172264099,
-0.38446539640426636,
-0.12455851584672928,
0.295626163482666,
-0.9077726006507874,
0.28579747676849365,
0.07949066162109375,
-0.12203676998615265,
0.02929314412176609,
-0.12089373171329498,
-0.5771769285202026,
0.7238180041313171,
0.2855181097984314,
-0.7291688919067383,
0.22837454080581665,
-0.09931958466768265,
0.7107266187667847,
-0.22295650839805603,
0.6529516577720642,
0.9324519634246826,
0.0070833549834787846,
-0.40033334493637085,
-1.3073103427886963,
-0.17076097428798676,
-0.39160600304603577,
0.16690152883529663,
0.24546167254447937,
-0.318581759929657,
0.7487691640853882,
0.005376648623496294,
-0.1712663322687149,
0.18659712374210358,
0.600095808506012,
0.12437673658132553,
-0.009630170650780201,
0.3715243935585022,
0.4735724925994873,
1.001248836517334,
-0.17132723331451416,
1.0619561672210693,
-0.47697246074676514,
0.31014788150787354,
1.1966193914413452,
-0.4444855749607086,
1.4860599040985107,
0.3655222952365875,
-0.33907362818717957,
0.47117915749549866,
0.3818967044353485,
0.3316406309604645,
0.33656951785087585,
0.29037612676620483,
-0.06237981840968132,
-0.1421343833208084,
0.2250620424747467,
-0.3027774393558502,
0.5362986326217651,
0.5855420827865601,
-0.21404367685317993,
0.041699957102537155,
-0.21090365946292877,
0.007930262945592403,
0.3919735252857208,
-0.14354097843170166,
0.8120125532150269,
-0.13275028765201569,
-0.7369999289512634,
0.5916666984558105,
-0.25678467750549316,
0.5533410310745239,
-0.6575223803520203,
0.24242505431175232,
-0.3146229088306427,
0.2684137225151062,
0.010858646593987942,
-1.0130802392959595,
0.553180456161499,
-0.15918733179569244,
0.09200669825077057,
-0.2533080577850342,
0.3994937241077423,
-0.4303179383277893,
-0.45344316959381104,
0.291063517332077,
0.5108876824378967,
0.35642749071121216,
0.04365209862589836,
-0.6491667628288269,
0.3755882680416107,
-0.4432424008846283,
-0.0984601303935051,
0.3051883578300476,
0.24373258650302887,
0.09901631623506546,
0.7134978771209717,
0.2250870019197464,
0.2691086530685425,
0.3527320623397827,
0.2819366157054901,
0.0576181635260582,
-0.6832584738731384,
-0.28441303968429565,
-0.6881456971168518,
0.5019881129264832,
-0.17320844531059265,
-0.6137790679931641,
0.8592105507850647,
0.5642066597938538,
0.9277021884918213,
0.06751228868961334,
0.6082763075828552,
0.05514116585254669,
0.7048023343086243,
-0.6351996064186096,
0.6414915323257446,
-0.5370210409164429,
0.1567445993423462,
0.013714213855564594,
-0.8481990694999695,
-0.3794732391834259,
0.742490291595459,
-0.2837778329849243,
0.15065841376781464,
0.9297270178794861,
0.8721714019775391,
-0.1317913979291916,
0.37291058897972107,
0.5353699922561646,
0.03845435380935669,
0.2823549211025238,
0.34782591462135315,
0.8799586892127991,
-0.3343260884284973,
0.042011577636003494,
-0.2853870391845703,
-0.3526265621185303,
-0.27827221155166626,
-1.0107749700546265,
-1.1495112180709839,
-0.9613603353500366,
-0.44659876823425293,
-0.16444145143032074,
0.00774565152823925,
0.6189379692077637,
1.0249768495559692,
-0.7914673686027527,
-0.6347148418426514,
-0.11939837783575058,
-0.11799730360507965,
-0.501649796962738,
-0.19316381216049194,
0.20906008780002594,
-0.8044528961181641,
-0.5365689396858215,
0.7125425338745117,
0.3230815529823303,
-0.2791063189506531,
-0.6651182174682617,
0.2394990473985672,
-0.07064488530158997,
0.2918364703655243,
0.5342903137207031,
0.26596277952194214,
-0.9493778944015503,
-0.08769875764846802,
-0.014559280127286911,
-0.2361457794904709,
-0.13101066648960114,
1.1301344633102417,
-0.6717945337295532,
0.6029033064842224,
0.6765801310539246,
0.7392807602882385,
0.3953873813152313,
-0.6165869235992432,
0.43310490250587463,
-0.5991396307945251,
0.10098252445459366,
0.4929618239402771,
0.48402562737464905,
0.287531316280365,
0.06884726136922836,
0.4398221969604492,
-0.023546727374196053,
-0.568034827709198,
-1.0475754737854004,
0.18445798754692078,
-0.7976987361907959,
-0.2369924634695053,
0.6544976234436035,
-0.08313630521297455,
-0.26641029119491577,
-0.18865709006786346,
0.28970664739608765,
-0.24799174070358276,
-0.046556394547224045,
0.8115447163581848,
0.7797545194625854,
0.06454715132713318,
-0.5033490061759949,
-0.9213040471076965,
0.6676287651062012,
0.8479379415512085,
-0.8578108549118042,
0.2622445225715637,
0.0694032683968544,
0.22767139971256256,
0.23451896011829376,
0.7331844568252563,
-0.19247974455356598,
0.24579589068889618,
0.25707805156707764,
-0.19492749869823456,
0.27479588985443115,
-0.42570066452026367,
-0.7046727538108826,
0.08180437982082367,
0.34596315026283264,
0.013451026752591133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18922v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18922v1
|
DPO Meets PPO: Reinforced Token Optimization for RLHF
| 2024-04-29T17:58:30 | 2024-04-29T17:58:30 |
Han Zhong, Guhao Feng, Wei Xiong, Li Zhao, Di He, Jiang Bian, Liwei Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
In the classical Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) framework,
Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) is employed to learn from sparse,
sentence-level rewards -- a challenging scenario in traditional deep
reinforcement learning. Despite the great successes of PPO in the alignment of
state-of-the-art closed-source large language models (LLMs), its open-source
implementation is still largely sub-optimal, as widely reported by numerous
research studies. To address these issues, we introduce a framework that models
RLHF problems as a Markov decision process (MDP), enabling the capture of
fine-grained token-wise information. Furthermore, we provide theoretical
insights that demonstrate the superiority of our MDP framework over the
previous sentence-level bandit formulation. Under this framework, we introduce
an algorithm, dubbed as Reinforced Token Optimization (\texttt{RTO}), which
learns the token-wise reward function from preference data and performs policy
optimization based on this learned token-wise reward signal. Theoretically,
\texttt{RTO} is proven to have the capability of finding the near-optimal
policy sample-efficiently. For its practical implementation, \texttt{RTO}
innovatively integrates Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) and PPO. DPO,
originally derived from sparse sentence rewards, surprisingly provides us with
a token-wise characterization of response quality, which is seamlessly
incorporated into our subsequent PPO training stage. Extensive real-world
alignment experiments verify the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
|
[
-0.2700779438018799,
-0.7437644004821777,
0.43414896726608276,
0.10121162980794907,
-0.21656757593154907,
0.13492362201213837,
-0.1784258633852005,
-0.19091205298900604,
0.17695923149585724,
0.6124765872955322,
-0.8649888634681702,
-0.3611455261707306,
-0.32687535881996155,
0.03700228035449982,
0.30621540546417236,
1.1172065734863281,
-0.08889908343553543,
-0.0033362230751663446,
-0.15478476881980896,
0.05882710590958595,
-0.48473644256591797,
-0.5659414529800415,
-0.6438546180725098,
-0.5954676866531372,
0.661438524723053,
0.6637169718742371,
0.5568581223487854,
0.7478145956993103,
0.3474188446998596,
0.2855612635612488,
-0.1379019021987915,
0.3483903110027313,
-0.5734139084815979,
0.0424705408513546,
-0.10025017708539963,
-0.1995484083890915,
-0.4298703372478485,
0.0381656140089035,
0.7200019359588623,
0.3736068904399872,
-0.5310347080230713,
-0.23704391717910767,
0.0761369839310646,
0.7304247617721558,
-0.8632203936576843,
0.190238818526268,
-0.4922560155391693,
0.44540029764175415,
0.24690738320350647,
-0.3239923119544983,
-0.35666340589523315,
-0.28053760528564453,
0.1598459631204605,
-0.8300760984420776,
-0.22616448998451233,
0.13558156788349152,
0.6674782633781433,
0.16449986398220062,
-0.3377927839756012,
-0.17914851009845734,
-0.5475711226463318,
0.9099590182304382,
-0.49536827206611633,
-0.0001673770893830806,
0.3336637318134308,
0.12605538964271545,
-0.7258567810058594,
-0.6029533743858337,
-0.7858814597129822,
-0.5269465446472168,
0.08097977936267853,
0.21625903248786926,
0.0045907991006970406,
0.5683314800262451,
-0.15598270297050476,
0.4028831422328949,
-0.4032537043094635,
0.4439457058906555,
0.0889727771282196,
-0.3095288574695587,
0.45666030049324036,
0.12302219867706299,
-0.12374955415725708,
-0.22953981161117554,
-0.6683135628700256,
-0.28014421463012695,
-0.5322189331054688,
0.2734680771827698,
0.6265150904655457,
0.36338457465171814,
0.1902741938829422,
0.5285423994064331,
-0.1686636358499527,
0.5740155577659607,
0.15965600311756134,
-0.24397435784339905,
0.07438553124666214,
-0.037444066256284714,
-0.10347940027713776,
0.11804953217506409,
0.8317601084709167,
0.27251386642456055,
0.21048985421657562,
-0.17115114629268646,
-0.6579498648643494,
-0.2847232520580292,
0.32706406712532043,
-0.5164471864700317,
0.06781948357820511,
0.28144997358322144,
-0.45647984743118286,
-0.6652257442474365,
0.03690898045897484,
-0.7075406908988953,
-0.2983511686325073,
-0.23522105813026428,
0.37734025716781616,
-0.01211690716445446,
-0.42030516266822815,
0.12421619147062302,
-0.09952593594789505,
0.06444896757602692,
-0.11733496189117432,
-1.126243233680725,
0.30572381615638733,
1.2302086353302002,
0.684604287147522,
-0.2815300524234772,
-0.40377914905548096,
-1.079667568206787,
-0.020406397059559822,
-0.32535114884376526,
0.5312507152557373,
-0.5071795582771301,
-0.45374545454978943,
0.33904996514320374,
-0.33013707399368286,
-0.14798706769943237,
-0.5891489386558533,
0.8238885402679443,
-0.5715306401252747,
0.40888816118240356,
-0.0701298713684082,
-0.4666503071784973,
0.17136608064174652,
0.5891698002815247,
-0.4445643126964569,
0.9576017260551453,
0.15090392529964447,
-0.8078108429908752,
0.49392107129096985,
-0.5582065582275391,
-0.21398621797561646,
-0.16333021223545074,
-0.040416840463876724,
-0.6356753706932068,
0.19561007618904114,
0.17857180535793304,
0.2856176197528839,
-0.015611493028700352,
0.5084167718887329,
-0.5084773898124695,
-0.5841222405433655,
0.43961915373802185,
-0.33053454756736755,
0.33899328112602234,
0.3172258734703064,
-0.16885101795196533,
0.7833811044692993,
-0.6522275805473328,
-0.24470502138137817,
0.0986705794930458,
-0.6119807958602905,
-0.1472306102514267,
0.1775488257408142,
-0.041925083845853806,
0.1275307834148407,
0.10817968845367432,
-0.5484476089477539,
0.37413784861564636,
-0.5348244309425354,
0.7656044363975525,
1.1694447994232178,
0.08353667706251144,
0.5521520972251892,
-0.3264913856983185,
0.6474179029464722,
-0.0888683870434761,
0.5098403692245483,
0.14002369344234467,
-0.06113444268703461,
-0.3815577030181885,
-0.5874323844909668,
0.3577671945095062,
0.5685860514640808,
-0.6644420027732849,
0.8020241856575012,
-0.049480583518743515,
0.09782901406288147,
-0.329522967338562,
-0.17707210779190063,
0.4293005168437958,
0.9415568113327026,
0.18828406929969788,
-0.38181227445602417,
-0.43415388464927673,
-0.9549373388290405,
-0.10282512754201889,
-0.46785083413124084,
0.19088339805603027,
0.33682331442832947,
0.36132222414016724,
-0.13046371936798096,
0.9426438212394714,
-0.4204292595386505,
-0.3919282555580139,
-0.48366981744766235,
0.11309743672609329,
0.18870003521442413,
0.6636532545089722,
0.11638712882995605,
-0.6274292469024658,
-0.10619041323661804,
-0.1907263696193695,
-0.30536195635795593,
0.09032587707042694,
-0.20161910355091095,
-0.15060076117515564,
0.3989931643009186,
0.25116297602653503,
-0.608666718006134,
-0.11607129126787186,
0.4563347399234772,
-0.15284812450408936,
0.5817092061042786,
-0.55329430103302,
0.03936213254928589,
-0.8948535919189453,
0.09326779097318649,
-0.2173328399658203,
-0.2740131914615631,
-0.24978797137737274,
0.030412210151553154,
-0.20324140787124634,
-0.25334006547927856,
-0.274679958820343,
0.46013689041137695,
-0.07346812635660172,
-0.19467374682426453,
-0.3902220129966736,
0.07762056589126587,
-0.22505484521389008,
0.9347329139709473,
0.238865464925766,
0.8309116363525391,
0.23321326076984406,
-0.547605574131012,
0.2416592240333557,
0.050962936133146286,
-0.21317265927791595,
0.4876388907432556,
-0.6520050168037415,
0.13407137989997864,
-0.11356047540903091,
0.3787931799888611,
-0.8910397887229919,
-0.10664700716733932,
0.5497608780860901,
-0.2593124508857727,
0.4113905429840088,
-0.23315875232219696,
-0.4915814697742462,
-0.276748925447464,
-0.5130152702331543,
0.28855112195014954,
0.448257178068161,
-0.49663814902305603,
0.40466591715812683,
0.6297758221626282,
0.10904783010482788,
-1.2158050537109375,
-0.125577911734581,
0.04766727611422539,
-0.4385536313056946,
-0.18915434181690216,
0.43901339173316956,
0.33441847562789917,
-0.001947434851899743,
-0.05177287384867668,
-0.33945584297180176,
-0.00671217730268836,
0.2632844150066376,
0.02747771330177784,
0.30769312381744385,
0.2035534530878067,
0.16977979242801666,
-0.04737843573093414,
-0.4423843324184418,
0.044172365218400955,
-0.7105600833892822,
0.49339619278907776,
-0.037183985114097595,
-0.12360581755638123,
-0.531860888004303,
0.15578506886959076,
0.2608601152896881,
-0.11842174828052521,
0.6279556155204773,
0.5491980314254761,
-0.04261912778019905,
-0.2335079461336136,
-0.28382107615470886,
-0.33170732855796814,
-0.4446229934692383,
0.46252405643463135,
-0.4956143796443939,
-1.02210533618927,
0.22395990788936615,
-0.18062426149845123,
0.08485355973243713,
0.2538694441318512,
0.30041074752807617,
-0.1018979474902153,
1.000356674194336,
0.658055305480957,
-0.19641892611980438,
0.9760537147521973,
-0.08644194155931473,
-0.10420063883066177,
-0.6936701536178589,
-0.38033610582351685,
-0.3304007053375244,
-0.4262411594390869,
-0.6767978668212891,
-0.18640723824501038,
0.24839532375335693,
0.2712468206882477,
-0.42820504307746887,
0.19794292747974396,
-0.44823309779167175,
0.3078957796096802,
0.8007528781890869,
0.24156542122364044,
0.2746485471725464,
0.06744519621133804,
-0.3109150230884552,
0.04686802998185158,
-1.0891083478927612,
-0.3555990159511566,
1.0009185075759888,
0.584745466709137,
0.6101256608963013,
-0.30713173747062683,
0.9993396401405334,
0.5897197127342224,
0.12078358978033066,
-0.9219311475753784,
0.6064481139183044,
0.1465928554534912,
-0.23214104771614075,
-0.30674275755882263,
-0.7187415361404419,
-1.103546380996704,
0.2387407124042511,
-0.5167185068130493,
-0.45262372493743896,
0.19527669250965118,
0.45911043882369995,
-0.2361888438463211,
0.07514646649360657,
-0.4984700381755829,
1.1250941753387451,
-0.22555895149707794,
-0.5271849632263184,
-0.5905966758728027,
-0.6151337027549744,
0.3143364191055298,
0.36600133776664734,
-0.0014044346753507853,
-0.08494887501001358,
-0.2197640836238861,
0.6861006021499634,
-0.5862682461738586,
0.7206118702888489,
-0.4358433783054352,
-0.08569712936878204,
0.3594945967197418,
-0.09468080848455429,
0.7805227041244507,
0.16897447407245636,
0.2133093774318695,
-0.16948583722114563,
-0.061088528484106064,
-0.5208976864814758,
-0.515870213508606,
0.6916191577911377,
-0.8998962044715881,
-0.38501450419425964,
-0.6183236241340637,
-0.4489995241165161,
-0.2922869622707367,
-0.018325326964259148,
-0.20313099026679993,
0.23558731377124786,
-0.31666073203086853,
-0.08130500465631485,
0.7070604562759399,
-0.2020435482263565,
0.40273338556289673,
0.30857646465301514,
-0.05510611832141876,
-0.8963868021965027,
0.8523774743080139,
-0.33130088448524475,
0.09327003359794617,
0.8671719431877136,
0.5198966860771179,
-0.5886792540550232,
-0.6605342626571655,
-0.3024677336215973,
0.2510129511356354,
-0.48271480202674866,
-0.03014596737921238,
-0.3056999146938324,
0.24643491208553314,
-0.22392235696315765,
0.034937549382448196,
-0.29333773255348206,
-0.5205482840538025,
-0.1954868882894516,
-0.12773266434669495,
0.006696070544421673,
0.39995279908180237,
-0.311219722032547,
0.15986308455467224,
-0.7078381776809692,
0.19477461278438568,
0.39163506031036377,
0.37350478768348694,
-0.0909254401922226,
-0.3816082179546356,
-0.13077911734580994,
-0.019113337621092796,
-0.2408326268196106,
-0.6538637280464172,
0.19247643649578094,
-0.058226343244314194,
0.6924950480461121,
0.3139249086380005,
0.3371260166168213,
0.6341320872306824,
-0.27874165773391724,
0.36329469084739685,
0.3126427233219147,
-0.7281903028488159,
0.4420815408229828,
-0.33909639716148376,
-0.1265544593334198,
0.6390354633331299,
0.14760322868824005,
-0.5095443725585938,
0.13740892708301544,
-0.4647553563117981,
-0.9009304642677307,
0.6898608207702637,
-0.011651666834950447,
0.1172487884759903,
-0.21521729230880737,
0.601432204246521,
0.021173397079110146,
0.38891276717185974,
-0.6887193918228149,
0.20248238742351532,
-0.1805066466331482,
-0.3040506839752197,
-0.005999471060931683,
-0.4023265540599823,
-0.4674704372882843,
0.20665857195854187,
0.6337820887565613,
-0.2968898117542267,
0.18800576031208038,
0.34998494386672974,
-0.1426481455564499,
-0.07103840261697769,
0.3203306198120117,
0.734673023223877,
0.38607603311538696,
-0.37389644980430603,
-0.06871484965085983,
-0.15251567959785461,
-0.3587987720966339,
0.10780743509531021,
0.06372376531362534,
-0.09347653388977051,
-0.5378895401954651,
0.3954432010650635,
0.8314638733863831,
0.25136199593544006,
-1.0449901819229126,
0.47217464447021484,
-0.035350337624549866,
-0.3019884526729584,
-0.37359094619750977,
0.11606159806251526,
-0.47023141384124756,
0.41284123063087463,
0.3716384768486023,
-0.262108713388443,
-0.0005063575808890164,
-0.6585537791252136,
0.31907814741134644,
0.5622325539588928,
-0.6103246808052063,
-0.050066255033016205,
0.4571235775947571,
0.5228073596954346,
-0.48461106419563293,
0.7261320948600769,
-0.1352192610502243,
-0.5605936050415039,
0.4706591069698334,
0.37456217408180237,
0.9873886108398438,
0.40231525897979736,
0.33705782890319824,
0.30582883954048157,
0.05420505627989769,
-0.1919766217470169,
0.16107697784900665,
-0.5467118620872498,
-0.6678922772407532,
-0.7142682671546936,
-0.5472651720046997,
-0.5421168804168701,
-0.09135493636131287,
-0.6052866578102112,
0.036103930324316025,
-0.6081329584121704,
-0.19090789556503296,
-0.6325879693031311,
0.32841670513153076,
-0.13754987716674805,
-0.13361741602420807,
0.0184687077999115,
0.707960307598114,
-0.6256950497627258,
0.7741873264312744,
0.5420398116111755,
-0.34066295623779297,
-0.47761091589927673,
0.11835154891014099,
-0.2528701722621918,
-1.0945875644683838,
0.6352660655975342,
0.013312168419361115,
-0.06471514701843262,
0.08465582132339478,
-0.2149115800857544,
-0.3767228424549103,
1.0299009084701538,
0.2524939477443695,
-0.609713077545166,
-0.023743584752082825,
-0.07046739757061005,
0.4013669490814209,
-0.4117913544178009,
-0.037707626819610596,
0.5392212867736816,
0.36737117171287537,
0.2815636992454529,
-0.8423040509223938,
-0.04701931029558182,
0.2447020709514618,
0.07533231377601624,
0.2803637981414795,
-0.5805633664131165,
0.39702102541923523,
-0.1906372606754303,
0.04728434234857559,
0.10945934057235718,
0.8422031402587891,
0.6059568524360657,
0.21503403782844543,
0.6845959424972534,
0.7857636213302612,
0.5807381868362427,
-0.04882180690765381,
1.047688364982605,
-0.20193560421466827,
0.43419674038887024,
0.9058178663253784,
-0.2038489282131195,
0.9462913870811462,
0.7838408350944519,
-0.1974593997001648,
0.46462368965148926,
0.9186782836914062,
0.28652989864349365,
0.87228924036026,
0.5673545002937317,
-0.35929515957832336,
-0.24558758735656738,
-0.2941470742225647,
-0.005058417562395334,
0.3367248475551605,
-0.0634152814745903,
-0.08084402978420258,
0.02719140239059925,
-0.043337564915418625,
-0.00900768581777811,
0.33503320813179016,
-0.39247748255729675,
1.0439083576202393,
-0.1747613102197647,
-1.0591968297958374,
0.4550836980342865,
0.004796935245394707,
0.7661929726600647,
-0.6759738922119141,
-0.09055149555206299,
-0.3757784068584442,
0.5640986561775208,
0.034681130200624466,
-0.7195208668708801,
0.2714020311832428,
-0.22704589366912842,
-0.04935973137617111,
-0.4996870458126068,
0.5310747623443604,
-0.326210081577301,
-0.015546126291155815,
0.15774691104888916,
0.15198002755641937,
-0.1116626039147377,
-0.034573715180158615,
-0.9087437391281128,
-0.021671613678336143,
-0.26236945390701294,
-0.3187124729156494,
0.6709834933280945,
0.3348434269428253,
0.17714683711528778,
0.6648194789886475,
0.6473111510276794,
0.13389843702316284,
-0.33583593368530273,
-0.05469948798418045,
0.6985698342323303,
-0.4539960026741028,
-0.6333385705947876,
-0.7355058193206787,
0.4494982361793518,
-0.054054081439971924,
-0.4385359287261963,
0.27539095282554626,
0.4472966492176056,
0.9102942943572998,
0.029403842985630035,
0.40438851714134216,
0.18495018780231476,
0.26863956451416016,
-0.7825904488563538,
0.24305513501167297,
-0.5619186758995056,
0.21502214670181274,
-0.091465525329113,
-0.8722224235534668,
-0.11221721768379211,
0.7069651484489441,
-0.16968274116516113,
-0.17404207587242126,
0.4580313265323639,
0.8035193681716919,
0.07768937945365906,
-0.40945932269096375,
0.12086357176303864,
-0.24042122066020966,
0.2757109999656677,
0.7809516787528992,
0.8979106545448303,
-0.08704468607902527,
0.8066776990890503,
-0.13640406727790833,
-0.2805623710155487,
-0.3122870624065399,
-1.0649583339691162,
-0.789792537689209,
-0.4581533372402191,
-0.16131055355072021,
-0.4144620895385742,
0.39168253540992737,
1.259264588356018,
0.7182421684265137,
-0.6145192980766296,
-0.3327805995941162,
-0.6314794421195984,
0.5355814099311829,
-0.5641674399375916,
-0.24018622934818268,
0.2638035714626312,
-0.5558401346206665,
-0.7594704031944275,
0.43982142210006714,
0.3816099762916565,
0.02014957368373871,
-0.3269367516040802,
-0.5193074345588684,
-0.19286981225013733,
-0.05725271999835968,
0.43445542454719543,
0.5016345977783203,
-0.6320512294769287,
-0.31026995182037354,
0.030202459543943405,
-0.08258365094661713,
-0.025985149666666985,
1.304267406463623,
-0.8209965229034424,
0.420523464679718,
0.6561030149459839,
0.8675008416175842,
0.48931586742401123,
0.09476140141487122,
0.7926476001739502,
-0.7338864803314209,
0.25356346368789673,
0.45352524518966675,
0.2375379353761673,
0.027123210951685905,
-0.1903294324874878,
0.30970489978790283,
0.5161463022232056,
-0.6142656803131104,
-1.0546700954437256,
0.5072377920150757,
-0.9369955658912659,
-0.4611389636993408,
0.9659932255744934,
-0.26656803488731384,
-0.0723605826497078,
0.0028699305839836597,
-0.27912575006484985,
0.1393086463212967,
-0.6684269905090332,
1.0653799772262573,
0.5500262975692749,
-0.13536210358142853,
-0.3526763319969177,
-0.17375317215919495,
0.5513348579406738,
0.5828193426132202,
-0.4698309302330017,
0.02334943227469921,
0.5266396999359131,
0.016781145706772804,
-0.30710944533348083,
0.8109787702560425,
0.08844450861215591,
0.13711492717266083,
-0.05011703073978424,
-0.06740831583738327,
-0.5603110194206238,
-0.4185207486152649,
-0.4846941828727722,
0.3656642735004425,
0.3001899719238281,
-0.5338456034660339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18911v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18911v1
|
Kangaroo: Lossless Self-Speculative Decoding via Double Early Exiting
| 2024-04-29T17:53:54 | 2024-04-29T17:53:54 |
Fangcheng Liu, Yehui Tang, Zhenhua Liu, Yunsheng Ni, Kai Han, Yunhe Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Speculative decoding has demonstrated its effectiveness in accelerating the
inference of large language models while maintaining a consistent sampling
distribution. However, the conventional approach of training a separate draft
model to achieve a satisfactory token acceptance rate can be costly. Drawing
inspiration from early exiting, we propose a novel self-speculative decoding
framework \emph{Kangaroo}, which uses a fixed shallow sub-network as a
self-draft model, with the remaining layers serving as the larger target model.
We train a lightweight and efficient adapter module on top of the sub-network
to bridge the gap between the sub-network and the full model's representation
ability. It is noteworthy that the inference latency of the self-draft model
may no longer be negligible compared to the large model, necessitating
strategies to increase the token acceptance rate while minimizing the drafting
steps of the small model. To address this challenge, we introduce an additional
early exiting mechanism for generating draft tokens. Specifically, we halt the
small model's subsequent prediction during the drafting phase once the
confidence level for the current token falls below a certain threshold.
Extensive experiments on the Spec-Bench demonstrate the effectiveness of
Kangaroo. Under single-sequence verification, Kangaroo achieves speedups up to
$1.68\times$ on Spec-Bench, outperforming Medusa-1 with 88.7\% fewer additional
parameters (67M compared to 591M). The code for Kangaroo is available at
https://github.com/Equationliu/Kangaroo.
|
[
-0.26924046874046326,
-0.47849041223526,
0.23055489361286163,
0.48228663206100464,
-0.517687976360321,
0.3303177058696747,
-0.018916716799139977,
-0.27139347791671753,
0.33924877643585205,
0.7505465745925903,
-0.8152064681053162,
-0.12150517851114273,
-0.6652066111564636,
0.30688536167144775,
-0.27643147110939026,
0.6157328486442566,
0.023029068484902382,
-0.43981289863586426,
0.10701857507228851,
-0.13777093589305878,
-0.4537920355796814,
-0.8869597315788269,
-0.7287804484367371,
-0.23512688279151917,
0.3075222373008728,
0.543928861618042,
0.5855759978294373,
0.7155033946037292,
0.04986695200204849,
0.1831267774105072,
-0.2695574164390564,
0.15703131258487701,
-0.6599667072296143,
-0.1199783980846405,
-0.06160719320178032,
-0.7125455737113953,
-0.1356349140405655,
0.14213107526302338,
0.48484405875205994,
0.3616408705711365,
-0.30080947279930115,
0.2979549467563629,
-0.18528011441230774,
0.9180455803871155,
-0.6627297401428223,
0.3970330059528351,
-0.7485668063163757,
0.27837079763412476,
-0.4536146819591522,
-0.23319247364997864,
-0.8793073892593384,
0.18836773931980133,
-0.6536149978637695,
-0.7966672778129578,
0.10637886077165604,
0.32149961590766907,
0.506888210773468,
0.3035076856613159,
-0.25910064578056335,
0.013513905927538872,
-0.5278044939041138,
0.4796675443649292,
-0.5149326324462891,
0.16480770707130432,
0.3818797767162323,
0.2823275327682495,
-0.2372371405363083,
-0.8151726722717285,
-0.8054367303848267,
0.10112040489912033,
-0.10975778847932816,
0.23948900401592255,
-0.22061148285865784,
-0.06851498782634735,
0.18965037167072296,
0.30490052700042725,
-0.3351364731788635,
0.039966847747564316,
-0.44825777411460876,
-0.5974462628364563,
0.4957806468009949,
0.3637990355491638,
0.12633948028087616,
-0.6311537027359009,
-0.4445174038410187,
0.1241043359041214,
-0.451219379901886,
0.33398228883743286,
0.6426855325698853,
0.4301738142967224,
-0.3269962966442108,
0.7339591383934021,
-0.5041613578796387,
0.37168118357658386,
0.3169669508934021,
0.21765710413455963,
0.3342091143131256,
-0.3665245473384857,
-0.05648566782474518,
0.07644729316234589,
0.8868533372879028,
0.2808891236782074,
-0.20934927463531494,
0.06969337165355682,
-0.2511637210845947,
0.116288922727108,
0.16684645414352417,
-0.7839541435241699,
-0.5204629898071289,
0.505462110042572,
-0.8067493438720703,
-0.4569026827812195,
-0.30448150634765625,
-0.5103771090507507,
-0.06564643234014511,
0.1755618005990982,
0.3134075999259949,
-0.6958282589912415,
-0.6450893878936768,
0.41001737117767334,
-0.3941195011138916,
0.009038703516125679,
-0.011860406957566738,
-1.1651571989059448,
0.4499535858631134,
0.6303620338439941,
0.8917555212974548,
0.03381470590829849,
-0.36824116110801697,
-0.8531278371810913,
-0.11305129528045654,
-0.6557151675224304,
0.720732569694519,
-0.35772550106048584,
-0.47594118118286133,
-0.40847161412239075,
0.0038491578307002783,
-0.16276994347572327,
-0.2916513979434967,
0.6358070969581604,
-0.6654479503631592,
-0.08571810275316238,
0.12583324313163757,
-0.21179255843162537,
-0.15022878348827362,
0.16470187902450562,
-0.6581457257270813,
1.14394211769104,
0.24742460250854492,
-0.9266250133514404,
0.5116803646087646,
-0.7443626523017883,
-0.5281592607498169,
-0.07228640466928482,
0.013051963411271572,
-0.33688902854919434,
0.2005475014448166,
0.34772351384162903,
0.34697893261909485,
-0.14138402044773102,
-0.1406562775373459,
-0.3867303133010864,
-0.7164844274520874,
0.04390789568424225,
-0.45646584033966064,
0.9067923426628113,
0.5019357800483704,
-0.29404938220977783,
-0.12133543938398361,
-0.8887001276016235,
0.32092511653900146,
0.3381120562553406,
-0.24395303428173065,
-0.4013039469718933,
-0.3357035517692566,
-0.1822209656238556,
0.23188649117946625,
-0.02055499143898487,
-0.6899209022521973,
0.43936410546302795,
-0.39257746934890747,
0.6277075409889221,
0.514220654964447,
-0.02982545830309391,
0.5514757037162781,
0.049145374447107315,
0.4913564920425415,
0.08753814548254013,
0.5550205707550049,
-0.4672924280166626,
-0.5343003273010254,
-0.5503960847854614,
-0.47873541712760925,
0.5255563855171204,
0.2283441573381424,
-0.6319223046302795,
0.3950134217739105,
0.06951486319303513,
-0.4539850950241089,
-0.5285722017288208,
0.050556767731904984,
0.32669198513031006,
0.16731864213943481,
0.34401747584342957,
-0.3634447157382965,
-0.614257276058197,
-0.6125118732452393,
-0.30591288208961487,
-0.6066513061523438,
0.36268261075019836,
0.2328941524028778,
0.18729767203330994,
-0.3120628595352173,
0.8623729944229126,
-0.3307177722454071,
-0.03657245263457298,
-0.5418227314949036,
0.4868435561656952,
0.48660245537757874,
0.6485757827758789,
0.4387277066707611,
-0.7098224759101868,
-0.26641350984573364,
-0.20688150823116302,
-0.8920949101448059,
0.19004692137241364,
-0.3323672115802765,
-0.43003496527671814,
0.21585442125797272,
0.47108402848243713,
-0.9942290186882019,
0.6256487369537354,
0.4707896411418915,
-0.3670627772808075,
0.7103785872459412,
-0.4251917004585266,
-0.10408017784357071,
-0.7921810746192932,
0.08243680745363235,
-0.7855075001716614,
-0.05859120562672615,
-0.31135427951812744,
0.2999052405357361,
0.5148269534111023,
-0.3158627152442932,
-0.38243401050567627,
0.5842244029045105,
-0.6802657246589661,
0.12417837977409363,
-0.3747602701187134,
-0.1641107201576233,
0.3420930504798889,
0.1946878880262375,
0.09894245862960815,
0.9364139437675476,
0.4889909029006958,
-0.4648791253566742,
-0.026533080264925957,
0.33980822563171387,
0.11693484336137772,
-0.34444013237953186,
-0.2581234872341156,
0.20312578976154327,
-0.1479964554309845,
0.5852850675582886,
-0.8863030672073364,
-0.04725128784775734,
0.7746006846427917,
-0.4844793379306793,
0.2760136127471924,
-0.7488812208175659,
-0.2747994661331177,
-0.9548235535621643,
-0.18471862375736237,
0.7721283435821533,
0.8125931620597839,
-0.6738604307174683,
0.885394275188446,
0.023561710491776466,
-0.047068845480680466,
-0.9805213212966919,
-0.775271475315094,
0.5582402944564819,
0.040266405791044235,
-0.5208070278167725,
-0.116480253636837,
-0.11996147036552429,
0.22117096185684204,
0.11680341511964798,
0.04954816773533821,
0.17068395018577576,
-0.07764431089162827,
0.3479643762111664,
0.14380966126918793,
-0.35514628887176514,
-0.13062262535095215,
0.31881681084632874,
-0.6697549819946289,
0.14080466330051422,
-0.9440863728523254,
0.5625831484794617,
0.10126163065433502,
-0.18565548956394196,
-0.55899578332901,
0.44524461030960083,
0.7277222871780396,
-0.4015461504459381,
0.929439902305603,
0.5590677261352539,
0.014139449223876,
-0.35935065150260925,
-0.6381659507751465,
0.1451190859079361,
-0.4699939489364624,
-0.06300441175699234,
-0.8983160853385925,
-0.3608667552471161,
0.8236021399497986,
-0.24055123329162598,
-0.34787285327911377,
0.729021430015564,
0.3240774869918823,
0.3114714026451111,
0.6331572532653809,
1.0215507745742798,
-0.01629006117582321,
0.20680442452430725,
-0.6994573473930359,
0.2326788306236267,
-0.8553227782249451,
-0.40258416533470154,
-0.1766761690378189,
0.17561005055904388,
-0.08816429227590561,
-0.6916636228561401,
-0.15190389752388,
0.40549513697624207,
0.08813508599996567,
0.27050673961639404,
-0.5070698857307434,
0.4665198028087616,
0.4942227602005005,
0.003115426516160369,
0.3203745484352112,
-0.15734079480171204,
-0.5893016457557678,
0.2150259017944336,
-1.3028192520141602,
-0.12667356431484222,
1.3645591735839844,
0.1967398077249527,
1.0888506174087524,
-0.2421209067106247,
1.0994491577148438,
0.5141808390617371,
0.27180811762809753,
-0.6391326189041138,
0.3123741149902344,
-0.12058452516794205,
-0.709613561630249,
-0.36992669105529785,
-0.5666284561157227,
-0.5038831233978271,
0.16828913986682892,
-0.2509135603904724,
-0.3326200544834137,
0.3269578814506531,
0.2811621427536011,
-0.6062038540840149,
0.5175572037696838,
-0.7649465203285217,
0.9114353656768799,
-0.02858138270676136,
-0.3493993878364563,
-0.20772577822208405,
-0.6375294327735901,
0.7461305260658264,
-0.3641999363899231,
0.36120620369911194,
-0.22060196101665497,
-0.0031852649990469217,
0.5846418738365173,
-0.8292241096496582,
0.9225165247917175,
-0.33236995339393616,
0.2624674141407013,
0.839870810508728,
0.34249940514564514,
0.5597187876701355,
0.4208541214466095,
-0.5126223564147949,
0.38429728150367737,
0.08124309033155441,
-0.6297536492347717,
-0.4968927502632141,
0.17251987755298615,
-0.9150629639625549,
-0.2491881102323532,
-0.33273160457611084,
-0.15206272900104523,
0.22028091549873352,
0.46357017755508423,
0.7062497138977051,
0.7278252243995667,
0.01565449871122837,
-0.34064021706581116,
0.14255259931087494,
-0.0810183510184288,
0.40182188153266907,
0.3368382453918457,
-0.2971566915512085,
-0.3696783483028412,
0.8771117925643921,
-0.15094983577728271,
0.24610909819602966,
0.20156608521938324,
0.33110129833221436,
-0.5554583668708801,
-0.730873703956604,
-0.9757550358772278,
0.1805867850780487,
-0.7676354646682739,
-0.25374889373779297,
-1.0195273160934448,
-0.3442084491252899,
-0.3049592673778534,
0.14009243249893188,
-0.7526465654373169,
-0.7271086573600769,
-0.012336618266999722,
0.017491493374109268,
0.19308316707611084,
0.8545965552330017,
-0.6316853761672974,
0.30066239833831787,
-0.9472141265869141,
0.3669816255569458,
-0.12235412001609802,
0.3963621258735657,
0.12764111161231995,
-0.6280512809753418,
-0.23897528648376465,
-0.3207268714904785,
0.2567635774612427,
-0.29258009791374207,
0.17133262753486633,
0.044846996665000916,
0.6086214184761047,
0.6610506176948547,
0.6445320248603821,
0.6757413148880005,
-0.5617647171020508,
0.7837788462638855,
0.5709895491600037,
-0.8329665660858154,
0.3662402331829071,
-0.1933445781469345,
0.11258833110332489,
0.5820664167404175,
-0.011737477965652943,
-0.5340772867202759,
-0.3771258592605591,
-0.5083296298980713,
-0.7778831124305725,
0.8964685201644897,
0.315023809671402,
0.3027481436729431,
-0.35140588879585266,
0.668502926826477,
0.6517735123634338,
-0.032758649438619614,
-0.4687899053096771,
-0.2495603859424591,
-0.649293839931488,
0.03910312056541443,
-0.2545726001262665,
-0.5258625149726868,
-0.14267180860042572,
-0.05413307249546051,
0.3827127516269684,
-0.4800931215286255,
0.5177692174911499,
0.17985865473747253,
0.05019798129796982,
-0.3189980983734131,
0.050100479274988174,
0.09771831333637238,
0.17316453158855438,
-0.15898685157299042,
0.12235037237405777,
0.10515996813774109,
-0.35796165466308594,
0.5096393823623657,
0.05368807911872864,
-0.16257277131080627,
-0.009888432919979095,
0.3414514660835266,
0.5136383771896362,
0.2865401804447174,
-0.36720970273017883,
0.7363725304603577,
-0.7098783254623413,
-0.329218327999115,
-0.3101233243942261,
0.019630184397101402,
-0.20237670838832855,
0.035635724663734436,
0.5008294582366943,
0.6926885843276978,
0.16309654712677002,
-0.5044003129005432,
0.2803359925746918,
0.1677512377500534,
-0.07391475141048431,
-0.34447112679481506,
1.038575291633606,
0.26691412925720215,
-0.32365682721138,
0.5991845726966858,
-0.4149266481399536,
-0.45841535925865173,
0.5167742967605591,
0.827033281326294,
0.8614945411682129,
0.38005995750427246,
0.27209097146987915,
0.4390515089035034,
0.278114378452301,
-0.20397619903087616,
0.3268095850944519,
-0.31176894903182983,
-0.5219164490699768,
-0.6156213283538818,
-0.6412655115127563,
-0.4215353727340698,
-0.290458619594574,
-0.7092456221580505,
0.011950268410146236,
-0.5183482766151428,
-0.29865962266921997,
-0.5890860557556152,
-0.24990655481815338,
-0.7146173119544983,
0.19750650227069855,
0.3607132136821747,
1.4069641828536987,
-0.6916618943214417,
0.5433913469314575,
0.35734301805496216,
-0.2842588424682617,
-1.0708072185516357,
0.2387155145406723,
-0.08927738666534424,
-0.8848158121109009,
0.7142208218574524,
0.3671199381351471,
-0.4228808283805847,
-0.17893017828464508,
-0.32781365513801575,
-1.0344486236572266,
0.7679542303085327,
0.15593965351581573,
-0.33703291416168213,
-0.1859668642282486,
-0.110716313123703,
0.08658917248249054,
-0.4208889603614807,
0.526768684387207,
0.3605850636959076,
0.25776398181915283,
0.22803056240081787,
-0.42270779609680176,
0.33923882246017456,
-0.4408440589904785,
-0.32842981815338135,
0.01868799328804016,
-1.276528000831604,
0.8449733853340149,
-0.5856764912605286,
-0.3574279844760895,
0.5574395656585693,
0.7380378842353821,
-0.1304711103439331,
0.40738147497177124,
0.630832850933075,
0.33623960614204407,
0.7689098715782166,
0.27003419399261475,
1.1380243301391602,
-0.6772801280021667,
0.28951317071914673,
0.6786953210830688,
0.0109708271920681,
0.9824661016464233,
0.25259241461753845,
-0.04380783066153526,
0.5573152303695679,
0.7523426413536072,
0.5828822255134583,
0.5657714009284973,
-0.11565051227807999,
-0.04908832907676697,
-0.7228018641471863,
0.5301648378372192,
-0.5458940267562866,
0.5052693486213684,
0.2441205531358719,
0.06297379732131958,
0.023279190063476562,
0.012252367101609707,
-0.5132375955581665,
-0.15585003793239594,
-0.16907507181167603,
0.4539932906627655,
0.18165434896945953,
-0.5475454330444336,
0.8954307436943054,
-0.00910790916532278,
0.5312211513519287,
-0.7531780004501343,
0.2722319960594177,
-0.4309758245944977,
0.1278989166021347,
-0.07567458599805832,
-0.5652557015419006,
0.14991797506809235,
-0.30141520500183105,
-0.14840514957904816,
0.07271029055118561,
0.7847613096237183,
0.04619020223617554,
-0.6601467132568359,
0.6620685458183289,
0.5909443497657776,
0.2620065212249756,
-0.04370816424489021,
-0.6387335658073425,
0.40832215547561646,
-0.2420959174633026,
-0.3106434643268585,
0.07959412783384323,
0.8076287508010864,
0.2581709921360016,
0.841693103313446,
0.9478383660316467,
0.027939332649111748,
0.1602936089038849,
0.14220879971981049,
1.241532325744629,
-1.0078250169754028,
-1.1114697456359863,
-0.7631325125694275,
0.4284215271472931,
-0.008379904553294182,
-0.3656676411628723,
0.5398846864700317,
0.7147654294967651,
0.4019318222999573,
-0.07474856078624725,
0.9263996481895447,
0.042757321149110794,
0.27482062578201294,
-0.7264351844787598,
0.6646790504455566,
-0.6783642172813416,
0.14834699034690857,
-0.09571395069360733,
-0.5259783267974854,
-0.08327402174472809,
0.11185380816459656,
-0.11508046835660934,
-0.3402109444141388,
0.7706989645957947,
0.5141887664794922,
-0.2818922698497772,
0.20625627040863037,
0.3208359181880951,
0.19887332618236542,
0.08474145829677582,
0.29102444648742676,
1.1503411531448364,
-0.5059407353401184,
1.0519050359725952,
-0.22095482051372528,
-0.47821152210235596,
-0.5410453081130981,
-0.708312451839447,
-1.121727705001831,
-0.04176020994782448,
0.13280925154685974,
-0.426691472530365,
0.2390851527452469,
0.6422672271728516,
1.123990535736084,
-0.3595481514930725,
0.19602705538272858,
-0.06628827750682831,
-0.07831727713346481,
-0.516261637210846,
-0.1330227106809616,
0.19326210021972656,
-0.6109843850135803,
-0.08335661888122559,
0.6715970635414124,
0.49807459115982056,
-0.14449426531791687,
-0.03284834697842598,
-0.2874419391155243,
0.3711523711681366,
0.34795865416526794,
0.5012772083282471,
0.6884074211120605,
-0.6998941898345947,
-0.1480114459991455,
-0.10814110189676285,
0.027135584503412247,
0.21270975470542908,
1.0789093971252441,
-1.0303423404693604,
0.5498721599578857,
0.027232179418206215,
0.592674970626831,
0.896456778049469,
0.31812000274658203,
0.5206403136253357,
-0.2296300232410431,
0.6649217009544373,
-0.0004827928787562996,
0.25484776496887207,
0.11779453605413437,
-0.8021761178970337,
0.48829352855682373,
0.4824024736881256,
-0.2803691625595093,
-0.6638884544372559,
0.0972856730222702,
-0.8738409876823425,
-0.1758279800415039,
0.748530924320221,
-0.16818666458129883,
-0.6930167078971863,
-0.2936684787273407,
-0.36148861050605774,
0.0627870038151741,
-0.49135255813598633,
0.5864437222480774,
0.366701602935791,
-0.3641473948955536,
0.07178012281656265,
-0.11875861883163452,
0.3111104667186737,
0.40828633308410645,
-0.1678430587053299,
0.6509740352630615,
-0.03737159073352814,
0.46608343720436096,
0.1320834904909134,
1.373871922492981,
-0.13639242947101593,
0.3464684784412384,
1.0075689554214478,
-0.013916467316448689,
-0.4843134880065918,
-0.47195667028427124,
-0.19959960877895355,
0.22008967399597168,
0.20812439918518066,
-0.2521103024482727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18988v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18988v2
|
Markovian Agents for Informative Language Modeling
| 2024-04-29T17:36:58 | 2024-05-23T00:00:23 |
Scott Viteri, Max Lamparth, Peter Chatain, Clark Barrett
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning could in principle enable a deeper
understanding of a language model's (LM) internal reasoning. However, prior
work suggests that LMs can answer questions similarly despite changes in their
CoT, suggesting that those models are not truly using the CoT. We propose an
reinforcement learning technique to produce CoTs that are sufficient alone for
predicting future text, independent of other context. This methodology ensures
that if the LM can predict future tokens, then it must have used the CoT to
understand its context. We formalize the informativeness of a sender to a
receiver LM as the degree to which the sender helps the receiver predict their
future observations, and we define a "Markovian" LM as one which predicts
future text given only a CoT as context. We derive a "Markovian training"
procedure by applying our definition of informativeness to a Markovian LM and
optimizing via policy gradient and Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO). We
demonstrate our training algorithm's effectiveness on fifteen-term arithmetic
problems, show the model utilizes the CoT, and externally validate that the
generated CoT is meaningful and usable by another model.
|
[
-0.487200528383255,
-0.9006239175796509,
0.9289456605911255,
0.08393534272909164,
-0.296789288520813,
0.022025078535079956,
-0.4692913293838501,
-0.20616514980793,
0.04668056592345238,
0.6257949471473694,
-0.7682622075080872,
-0.44289982318878174,
-0.39059776067733765,
0.05727662891149521,
-0.2742045223712921,
1.2734400033950806,
-0.16579905152320862,
-0.05598493665456772,
-0.15073926746845245,
0.20161806046962738,
-0.42818960547447205,
-0.5760725140571594,
-0.6687459945678711,
-0.23760636150836945,
0.6079172492027283,
0.33625128865242004,
0.7088838219642639,
0.4087589681148529,
0.22113527357578278,
0.3063691556453705,
-0.02799687348306179,
0.2927723228931427,
-0.2896794378757477,
0.3253573775291443,
-0.5531066060066223,
-0.5546509623527527,
-0.09664083272218704,
-0.08307721465826035,
0.776178240776062,
0.5178088545799255,
-0.2542475163936615,
0.0022578539792448282,
-0.2686285376548767,
0.6793084740638733,
-0.9000831246376038,
0.31290021538734436,
-0.8332337141036987,
0.07294044643640518,
0.24485181272029877,
-0.4691503047943115,
-0.8617315292358398,
-0.3357422351837158,
0.10341111570596695,
-0.5700246691703796,
-0.4039347171783447,
0.1851542741060257,
0.45028790831565857,
0.16082626581192017,
-0.5074782967567444,
-0.4748706519603729,
-0.9030720591545105,
0.5895416736602783,
-0.537143886089325,
0.2214735597372055,
0.5053589344024658,
0.3405313491821289,
-0.5093461871147156,
-0.36248090863227844,
-0.9215412735939026,
-0.4279055893421173,
0.14707089960575104,
0.04591358080506325,
-0.010496030561625957,
0.18811050057411194,
-0.005453919060528278,
0.06596886366605759,
-0.4080256521701813,
-0.11146976798772812,
-0.29736843705177307,
0.07191547006368637,
0.4504683315753937,
0.28848469257354736,
0.1404319703578949,
0.18174701929092407,
-0.7423708438873291,
-0.12512801587581635,
-0.531907320022583,
0.08612452447414398,
0.4397473633289337,
0.1999179720878601,
-0.01475166529417038,
0.5298765301704407,
-0.07814839482307434,
0.6580894589424133,
-0.009350476786494255,
-0.04433677718043327,
-0.07839635014533997,
-0.09770157188177109,
-0.2334064394235611,
0.2382068634033203,
0.7694871425628662,
-0.15030308067798615,
0.3014281988143921,
-0.17094039916992188,
-0.5907970070838928,
0.23076477646827698,
0.44341960549354553,
-0.4877762496471405,
-0.32752811908721924,
0.34207990765571594,
-0.26418083906173706,
-0.5040780305862427,
0.013367568142712116,
-0.3288865089416504,
-0.24890105426311493,
-0.39566880464553833,
0.5713067054748535,
-0.5508657097816467,
-0.5092301368713379,
0.005808797664940357,
-0.0694447010755539,
-0.1459546685218811,
0.2060282677412033,
-0.8366928696632385,
0.6100401282310486,
0.4540421664714813,
0.6839333176612854,
-0.11555294692516327,
-0.40360119938850403,
-0.5884783267974854,
0.2753278613090515,
-0.8392736315727234,
0.8106328248977661,
-0.7346412539482117,
-0.22508123517036438,
-0.013322751969099045,
-0.12255938351154327,
-0.21533945202827454,
-0.2839421033859253,
0.08824022859334946,
-0.6920917630195618,
0.28143036365509033,
-0.0371716171503067,
-0.5467710494995117,
-0.10419964790344238,
0.31361061334609985,
-0.7197458148002625,
0.596880316734314,
0.2440868318080902,
-0.7612524032592773,
0.4532400965690613,
-0.6206111311912537,
-0.1109912171959877,
-0.08489178866147995,
-0.26471543312072754,
-0.3440295159816742,
0.06352613866329193,
0.10126693546772003,
0.3763289451599121,
-0.09894074499607086,
0.6477508544921875,
-0.2889499068260193,
-0.27222150564193726,
0.8455749750137329,
-0.4459114968776703,
0.37433144450187683,
0.4357565939426422,
-0.2349773496389389,
0.4529792070388794,
-0.742548942565918,
0.014522756449878216,
-0.03802347928285599,
-0.49564793705940247,
-0.11975853890180588,
0.19643224775791168,
-0.17892448604106903,
0.5319089889526367,
0.17908453941345215,
-0.3513016700744629,
0.21160514652729034,
-0.33813342452049255,
0.13623088598251343,
1.0917285680770874,
0.25475946068763733,
0.5473827719688416,
-0.5006147027015686,
0.7263742089271545,
0.39762598276138306,
0.16184872388839722,
-0.1646772027015686,
-0.2551689147949219,
-0.8111878037452698,
-0.1125560998916626,
-0.03562081977725029,
0.3654451370239258,
-1.2416964769363403,
0.2790086567401886,
-0.04141445457935333,
-0.24495527148246765,
-0.1866622418165207,
-0.17238126695156097,
0.58085697889328,
0.33041912317276,
0.15496893227100372,
-0.23517780005931854,
-0.6243741512298584,
-0.6605498790740967,
-0.3715149164199829,
-0.3778918385505676,
0.5281110405921936,
0.06428872048854828,
0.5162494778633118,
-0.10985150188207626,
0.6614592671394348,
-0.22919976711273193,
0.07965607196092606,
-0.4730609357357025,
0.05278724431991577,
0.37962591648101807,
0.4340260624885559,
-0.09530949592590332,
-0.7027119994163513,
-0.1436598151922226,
0.10425245016813278,
-0.6144735217094421,
0.3793485164642334,
-0.26771247386932373,
-0.08128759264945984,
0.40619125962257385,
0.3862619400024414,
-0.6094961762428284,
0.34315580129623413,
0.4322932958602905,
-0.43384528160095215,
0.6007579565048218,
-0.6559290289878845,
-0.06394680589437485,
-0.8907222747802734,
-0.09504199028015137,
-0.037036702036857605,
-0.3748282194137573,
-0.6432787179946899,
-0.20913609862327576,
-0.12139946222305298,
-0.04722026363015175,
-0.35671305656433105,
0.6329931616783142,
-0.4072525203227997,
-0.126608744263649,
-0.42201101779937744,
0.13800351321697235,
-0.39210236072540283,
0.759544312953949,
0.2566188871860504,
0.8740171790122986,
0.3422287106513977,
-1.0631591081619263,
0.14708803594112396,
-0.0885840430855751,
-0.6179044842720032,
0.3254084885120392,
-0.2129119336605072,
0.09542962163686752,
-0.35664379596710205,
0.4392448961734772,
-0.7837132811546326,
0.038692839443683624,
0.3465776741504669,
-0.47274017333984375,
0.11898139119148254,
-0.10204476863145828,
-0.4912523329257965,
-0.10405834764242172,
0.09687113016843796,
0.4105556309223175,
0.37030360102653503,
-0.5555075407028198,
0.3839109539985657,
0.5254489779472351,
-0.05696422979235649,
-0.665927529335022,
-0.26639339327812195,
-0.19662216305732727,
-0.22561858594417572,
-0.04247207194566727,
-0.020524103194475174,
0.055635299533605576,
-0.3069665729999542,
0.05763865262269974,
-0.047443728893995285,
-0.08523930609226227,
0.10706455260515213,
0.2061164230108261,
0.4563846290111542,
0.060204025357961655,
0.7070993185043335,
0.01768183335661888,
-0.28458744287490845,
0.28400567173957825,
-1.0568927526474,
0.6796415448188782,
-0.2465117871761322,
0.03463754430413246,
-0.30952781438827515,
0.11942398548126221,
0.16561950743198395,
-0.2322639524936676,
1.031508207321167,
0.5134785175323486,
-0.24557875096797943,
-0.5343681573867798,
-0.2056325525045395,
-0.09341934323310852,
-0.4409688711166382,
0.3243738114833832,
-0.650880753993988,
-0.5499328970909119,
0.10781342536211014,
-0.20405083894729614,
-0.23472973704338074,
0.4114150404930115,
0.7098740339279175,
-0.05799029394984245,
1.1498723030090332,
0.8256047368049622,
0.04455142840743065,
0.781001627445221,
-0.4285376965999603,
0.1584957391023636,
-0.8909994959831238,
-0.5526933073997498,
-0.1742311269044876,
0.01744484156370163,
-0.8594135642051697,
-0.41756048798561096,
0.4292750358581543,
0.01624559424817562,
-0.5529184341430664,
0.3736529052257538,
-0.4004465639591217,
0.6019136309623718,
0.4782341718673706,
0.17479918897151947,
0.18416433036327362,
-0.26787424087524414,
-0.46974626183509827,
0.5504398345947266,
-0.7972104549407959,
-0.807819664478302,
1.075718641281128,
0.22437238693237305,
0.9864845871925354,
0.09924156963825226,
0.6833317875862122,
0.308317631483078,
0.2283109426498413,
-0.4454181492328644,
0.5682335495948792,
0.34216031432151794,
-0.5707239508628845,
-0.3899235725402832,
-0.6339649558067322,
-0.9884462952613831,
0.2570159137248993,
-0.25690558552742004,
-1.1745132207870483,
0.2778206169605255,
0.21755261719226837,
0.15602858364582062,
0.398359090089798,
-0.369285523891449,
0.635358989238739,
-0.1771509349346161,
-0.30817940831184387,
-0.5527201890945435,
-0.6981229186058044,
0.30028825998306274,
0.1195458173751831,
0.3761766850948334,
-0.23093047738075256,
-0.28913745284080505,
0.6963702440261841,
-0.503494143486023,
0.6262022852897644,
-0.08660751581192017,
-0.19792486727237701,
0.4430358111858368,
0.3633057177066803,
0.6254324316978455,
0.08834432065486908,
-0.014851417392492294,
-0.46513357758522034,
0.29056572914123535,
-0.4118371307849884,
-0.7545862793922424,
0.6250988245010376,
-0.8653542399406433,
-0.5225433707237244,
-0.5293576121330261,
-0.6062019467353821,
-0.30395665764808655,
0.09715905040502548,
0.12382391840219498,
0.5519919395446777,
-0.20284026861190796,
-0.3058849573135376,
0.7154465913772583,
-0.01200275681912899,
0.43569159507751465,
0.3136020600795746,
-0.5469802021980286,
-0.4299086332321167,
1.1496235132217407,
-0.3152562379837036,
0.4956553280353546,
0.8592865467071533,
0.22231662273406982,
-0.39229127764701843,
-0.2984159588813782,
-0.24426241219043732,
0.0355924591422081,
-1.0497066974639893,
0.004847694654017687,
-0.5346127152442932,
-0.07534225285053253,
0.09022027254104614,
0.09211358428001404,
-0.18102431297302246,
-0.5810151100158691,
-0.1362999826669693,
-0.09672717750072479,
0.16460275650024414,
1.147533893585205,
0.11607714742422104,
0.28226006031036377,
-0.39185434579849243,
0.001079345354810357,
-0.012607642449438572,
0.21456551551818848,
-0.019336070865392685,
-0.27643269300460815,
-0.4911002516746521,
0.12155964225530624,
-0.43385520577430725,
-0.8995214104652405,
0.4914148151874542,
-0.07333873957395554,
0.5145172476768494,
0.3663502633571625,
0.11117102205753326,
0.3806116580963135,
-0.36659860610961914,
0.4598330855369568,
0.28391358256340027,
-1.0746363401412964,
0.8706538677215576,
-0.1937967836856842,
0.2505720853805542,
0.3914375603199005,
0.6422921419143677,
-0.3774963915348053,
-0.6195761561393738,
-0.8007417917251587,
-0.5167575478553772,
0.6368155479431152,
0.1066247969865799,
-0.05517083406448364,
-0.4191126227378845,
0.12618568539619446,
0.2314257025718689,
0.4639151096343994,
-0.7705774307250977,
0.08112076669931412,
0.145843043923378,
-0.3364332914352417,
-0.30361080169677734,
-0.027247244492173195,
0.14103247225284576,
0.056197550147771835,
0.9180145263671875,
-0.2778297960758209,
0.4730461835861206,
0.27766910195350647,
-0.2860035300254822,
-0.15589748322963715,
0.4169189929962158,
0.5860201120376587,
0.9964832663536072,
-0.1794736683368683,
0.33078980445861816,
0.17361663281917572,
-0.10781007260084152,
0.37978288531303406,
-0.39091941714286804,
0.2389739751815796,
-0.06836267560720444,
0.3329969346523285,
1.0141932964324951,
0.17380215227603912,
-0.8199263215065002,
0.49780696630477905,
-0.08764845132827759,
0.08075300604104996,
-0.6550086736679077,
0.29623591899871826,
-0.15262891352176666,
0.43071964383125305,
-0.08117689937353134,
0.17931142449378967,
0.09123844653367996,
-1.0412414073944092,
-0.009830408729612827,
0.37541472911834717,
-0.6553601622581482,
-0.17995436489582062,
0.4423750042915344,
-0.13872914016246796,
-0.44380617141723633,
0.47418755292892456,
-0.18127082288265228,
-0.5708522200584412,
0.6364279985427856,
0.8123140335083008,
0.7042109966278076,
-0.23490206897258759,
0.2245117723941803,
0.11632342636585236,
0.15147309005260468,
0.021520953625440598,
0.5448156595230103,
-0.522290050983429,
-0.7417275905609131,
-0.19253970682621002,
-0.334710955619812,
-0.5652230978012085,
-0.1646515429019928,
-0.5859538316726685,
0.21518321335315704,
-0.7294237613677979,
-0.2857590615749359,
-0.174019455909729,
0.06928195804357529,
-0.6646775603294373,
0.56520015001297,
0.1451212763786316,
0.7909015417098999,
-0.5316030383110046,
1.0687252283096313,
0.514122486114502,
-0.6315938234329224,
-0.7180107235908508,
0.026704911142587662,
-0.3006950616836548,
-0.7411420941352844,
0.7580540776252747,
0.06904422491788864,
-0.4185526371002197,
-0.14148570597171783,
-0.46333128213882446,
-0.8807910680770874,
1.0262502431869507,
0.22652244567871094,
-0.5497504472732544,
-0.1296066790819168,
-0.29462361335754395,
0.44037672877311707,
-0.7564694881439209,
0.5577848553657532,
0.34993162751197815,
0.13823440670967102,
0.03936335816979408,
-0.7138808369636536,
0.06971346586942673,
-0.19177775084972382,
0.2792748510837555,
0.4880690574645996,
-0.40335625410079956,
0.9619370698928833,
-0.579423189163208,
-0.23657925426959991,
0.19053161144256592,
0.6877735257148743,
0.23031267523765564,
0.16505320370197296,
0.46507441997528076,
0.19144859910011292,
1.0402439832687378,
0.18513843417167664,
1.44731867313385,
-0.2379886955022812,
0.2689414322376251,
1.209991693496704,
0.056160494685173035,
0.9902073740959167,
0.49803125858306885,
-0.06755151599645615,
0.9631837010383606,
0.5772473216056824,
0.4691348671913147,
0.8826653361320496,
0.584172785282135,
-0.4880101680755615,
-0.27821001410484314,
-0.059574998915195465,
-0.15104873478412628,
0.1973879337310791,
0.4761061370372772,
-0.4983089566230774,
0.28468629717826843,
0.07403312623500824,
-0.0080177066847682,
0.17884059250354767,
-0.3175813853740692,
1.1843154430389404,
0.10895412415266037,
-0.9200762510299683,
0.6152521371841431,
0.00689802598208189,
0.10370231419801712,
-0.5176903605461121,
-0.016894478350877762,
0.11062268167734146,
0.5523902177810669,
0.065568707883358,
-0.761622965335846,
0.044475067406892776,
-0.23199808597564697,
-0.13536067306995392,
-0.009611085057258606,
0.5501160025596619,
-0.6169974207878113,
-0.40505003929138184,
0.19174756109714508,
0.4349076747894287,
0.28608420491218567,
0.1765463948249817,
-0.35617953538894653,
-0.00527121452614665,
-0.3492174446582794,
-0.08625779300928116,
0.32466012239456177,
0.7049105763435364,
-0.14986957609653473,
1.1691052913665771,
0.6950555443763733,
0.40178820490837097,
-0.1827668994665146,
-0.08934155106544495,
1.0301979780197144,
-0.7845064401626587,
-0.8099117279052734,
-0.9467898607254028,
0.2780091464519501,
0.03723720833659172,
-0.33154770731925964,
0.295989990234375,
0.3583575189113617,
0.9740723967552185,
-0.06505158543586731,
0.7711507081985474,
0.41125455498695374,
0.08642425388097763,
-0.9194386601448059,
0.43074914813041687,
-0.13749487698078156,
0.4355895221233368,
-0.14544622600078583,
-0.8939659595489502,
0.26130449771881104,
0.7495466470718384,
-0.5488941669464111,
0.14554253220558167,
1.0787774324417114,
0.4924747347831726,
0.280087411403656,
0.195351704955101,
0.4434680640697479,
0.04585634171962738,
0.2721138000488281,
0.9936916828155518,
1.3034677505493164,
-0.14059118926525116,
0.3441285490989685,
-0.2754306495189667,
-0.14060591161251068,
0.003325136611238122,
-0.6386883854866028,
-1.1030076742172241,
-1.0267120599746704,
-0.06931192427873611,
-0.36790305376052856,
0.47347569465637207,
1.3305511474609375,
0.6707292795181274,
-0.5450929403305054,
-0.5123119950294495,
-0.5646414160728455,
0.4514741599559784,
-0.15764380991458893,
-0.1896488070487976,
0.10917097330093384,
-0.781984806060791,
-0.3215009570121765,
0.2322172373533249,
0.4159002900123596,
-0.026400355622172356,
-0.44141674041748047,
-0.24386245012283325,
-0.281730979681015,
0.4147171676158905,
0.4871460497379303,
-0.002833717502653599,
-0.7093820571899414,
-0.08428382128477097,
-0.4395899474620819,
-0.05206990987062454,
0.06921833008527756,
1.0760709047317505,
-1.2381421327590942,
0.6522635817527771,
0.1571418046951294,
0.40489575266838074,
0.6326287388801575,
-0.23270025849342346,
0.8513504266738892,
-0.40825155377388,
0.17341530323028564,
0.4417673945426941,
0.2991432547569275,
0.10208796709775925,
-0.5112058520317078,
0.1936945915222168,
-0.2017868608236313,
-0.5484138131141663,
-0.487627238035202,
0.39023318886756897,
-0.5427046418190002,
-0.5167523622512817,
1.0597560405731201,
-0.22111307084560394,
-0.5800987482070923,
-0.06459388881921768,
-0.26117250323295593,
0.25468969345092773,
-0.4513264000415802,
0.63396817445755,
0.5011035799980164,
0.030739828944206238,
-0.4020214378833771,
-0.23844800889492035,
0.6142380833625793,
0.16792763769626617,
-1.0888441801071167,
-0.11191511899232864,
0.21166175603866577,
0.09263992309570312,
-0.1442725956439972,
0.8418855667114258,
0.06427855789661407,
0.37046316266059875,
0.1315312683582306,
-0.1641523540019989,
0.01906118169426918,
-0.8185203075408936,
-0.26770517230033875,
-0.3548283278942108,
0.3035140037536621,
-0.1933915615081787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18880v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18880v1
|
Spivavtor: An Instruction Tuned Ukrainian Text Editing Model
| 2024-04-29T17:16:22 | 2024-04-29T17:16:22 |
Aman Saini, Artem Chernodub, Vipul Raheja, Vivek Kulkarni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce Spivavtor, a dataset, and instruction-tuned models for text
editing focused on the Ukrainian language. Spivavtor is the Ukrainian-focused
adaptation of the English-only CoEdIT model. Similar to CoEdIT, Spivavtor
performs text editing tasks by following instructions in Ukrainian. This paper
describes the details of the Spivavtor-Instruct dataset and Spivavtor models.
We evaluate Spivavtor on a variety of text editing tasks in Ukrainian, such as
Grammatical Error Correction (GEC), Text Simplification, Coherence, and
Paraphrasing, and demonstrate its superior performance on all of them. We
publicly release our best-performing models and data as resources to the
community to advance further research in this space.
|
[
0.2960761487483978,
-1.0381630659103394,
0.523338258266449,
0.38644811511039734,
-0.1706719994544983,
0.02077898010611534,
-0.31128644943237305,
0.030776889994740486,
0.07645011693239212,
0.5688413381576538,
-0.6932406425476074,
-0.8015854358673096,
-0.6840241551399231,
0.16941092908382416,
-0.5400120615959167,
1.2046104669570923,
-0.1943480521440506,
0.40999242663383484,
-0.3277117609977722,
0.03466715291142464,
-0.6360906958580017,
-0.47626420855522156,
-0.30994912981987,
0.001069137011654675,
0.2316853106021881,
0.6420414447784424,
0.47195520997047424,
0.7847709655761719,
0.48035404086112976,
0.4382176995277405,
0.08153723925352097,
-0.05169711634516716,
-0.5483450293540955,
0.0898791253566742,
-0.35681644082069397,
-0.631730318069458,
-0.450493723154068,
-0.2560521364212036,
0.49636730551719666,
0.36177751421928406,
-0.3182360529899597,
0.16532747447490692,
-0.130964457988739,
0.42394253611564636,
-0.4817439913749695,
-0.16174088418483734,
-0.576344907283783,
0.03611362352967262,
-0.12321971356868744,
-0.1252821832895279,
-0.7469971776008606,
-0.7247734069824219,
-0.11415031552314758,
-0.8359332084655762,
0.4088333547115326,
-0.2233199030160904,
0.8660184741020203,
0.4369622468948364,
-0.2853267192840576,
-0.5463950037956238,
-0.8097622990608215,
0.6333255171775818,
-0.06715216487646103,
0.47907400131225586,
0.0729939341545105,
0.1436391919851303,
-0.030052993446588516,
-0.939475953578949,
-0.159829780459404,
0.08954890817403793,
0.07030094414949417,
0.48641401529312134,
-0.4269213378429413,
0.2329723834991455,
0.028919843956828117,
0.30443546175956726,
-0.19285036623477936,
-0.06127452850341797,
-0.696353018283844,
-0.3230924904346466,
0.5504029989242554,
0.11506005376577377,
0.4911101460456848,
0.005393575876951218,
-0.30147024989128113,
0.38413020968437195,
-0.3047352731227875,
0.26632192730903625,
0.6540377140045166,
-0.023832591250538826,
0.19000494480133057,
0.6369613409042358,
-0.010079190135002136,
0.7625414133071899,
0.6295085549354553,
0.048055533319711685,
-0.05819542333483696,
-0.17991061508655548,
-0.49045902490615845,
0.08595307916402817,
0.48163172602653503,
0.4929811656475067,
-0.07752671837806702,
-0.3059111535549164,
-0.22706857323646545,
0.2514208257198334,
0.5376973152160645,
-0.76756751537323,
-0.23531091213226318,
0.09950681775808334,
-0.4709283411502838,
-0.42954424023628235,
0.1955435425043106,
-0.7746623754501343,
-0.045252397656440735,
-0.20860694348812103,
0.6667017936706543,
-0.6235902905464172,
0.010758381336927414,
0.5728228688240051,
0.039369136095047,
-0.14368779957294464,
0.3767140507698059,
-0.7265893220901489,
0.8013058304786682,
0.7935498952865601,
0.7724368572235107,
-0.26784244179725647,
-0.652208685874939,
-0.8764439821243286,
-0.39998796582221985,
-0.3604128360748291,
0.8815025687217712,
-0.912666916847229,
-0.6422164440155029,
0.02006494253873825,
0.48284658789634705,
-0.23476998507976532,
-0.1078692227602005,
0.8570771813392639,
-0.3671939969062805,
0.12935732305049896,
0.12038770318031311,
-1.0515193939208984,
-0.09801236540079117,
-0.3384236693382263,
-0.7592080235481262,
1.5231499671936035,
0.05351011082530022,
-0.7234145998954773,
0.3941556513309479,
-0.7527387142181396,
-0.4787314832210541,
0.2202790379524231,
0.19860288500785828,
-0.48837098479270935,
0.25635865330696106,
-0.1065099686384201,
0.4874240458011627,
0.2195594608783722,
0.42640215158462524,
0.24498027563095093,
-0.41663485765457153,
0.37021636962890625,
-0.0827513039112091,
0.7804019451141357,
-0.10330318659543991,
-0.12764404714107513,
0.6919823884963989,
-1.2010892629623413,
-0.27107617259025574,
-0.34134048223495483,
-0.646238386631012,
-0.13171592354774475,
0.03776151314377785,
0.3794924020767212,
0.14856432378292084,
0.4056718349456787,
-0.848244309425354,
0.40213391184806824,
-0.18178540468215942,
0.26231926679611206,
0.746697723865509,
0.1454005390405655,
0.7148696184158325,
-0.22853431105613708,
0.9904252290725708,
-0.19285941123962402,
0.3674796521663666,
0.03815167397260666,
-0.2313714623451233,
-1.057929515838623,
-0.35267725586891174,
0.3876011073589325,
0.7259020805358887,
-0.7146859765052795,
0.43180137872695923,
-0.1127835288643837,
-1.018680453300476,
-1.0308336019515991,
0.05491640791296959,
0.21553359925746918,
0.4149504005908966,
0.24798867106437683,
0.34661999344825745,
-0.609877347946167,
-0.8543773293495178,
-0.5319488048553467,
0.4193981885910034,
0.24662701785564423,
-0.07763557136058807,
0.6973743438720703,
0.05413297936320305,
0.523577868938446,
-0.344696968793869,
0.20084527134895325,
-0.5272703170776367,
0.020341916009783745,
0.002807132201269269,
0.3664780855178833,
0.5225908160209656,
-0.6629617810249329,
-0.8600181341171265,
0.16948401927947998,
-0.19057004153728485,
-0.3467836081981659,
-0.15271641314029694,
-0.293425977230072,
0.10251548886299133,
0.68356853723526,
-0.3909870982170105,
0.5619558095932007,
0.6189163327217102,
-0.6362049579620361,
0.7288929224014282,
-0.5466207265853882,
0.30763447284698486,
-1.3460155725479126,
0.006870648358017206,
-0.023635869845747948,
-0.4681207239627838,
-0.9803494811058044,
0.25749173760414124,
0.5685909390449524,
-0.2311086356639862,
-0.3581790328025818,
0.044653091579675674,
-0.24312308430671692,
0.15348833799362183,
-0.08565197885036469,
-0.06669400632381439,
0.022493669763207436,
0.13324004411697388,
-0.05625525489449501,
1.1366949081420898,
0.9124116897583008,
-0.45340293645858765,
0.47649139165878296,
0.44351938366889954,
-0.5024738311767578,
0.5322614312171936,
-0.7002361416816711,
0.2668389081954956,
-0.3272075057029724,
-0.10123801231384277,
-0.7066956162452698,
-0.2649047374725342,
0.10695712268352509,
-0.4409457743167877,
0.06146085634827614,
-0.236880823969841,
-0.37619858980178833,
0.1698339581489563,
-0.18561983108520508,
-0.4067014455795288,
0.1521250456571579,
-0.4183611273765564,
0.9057372808456421,
0.08636601269245148,
-0.4039028584957123,
-0.6138449311256409,
-0.553396999835968,
-0.0763092190027237,
-0.09749165177345276,
-0.47309714555740356,
0.36242520809173584,
-0.33339717984199524,
-0.08917012810707092,
0.052211400121450424,
0.18000036478042603,
-0.1991817206144333,
0.11217454820871353,
0.41597241163253784,
0.6830882430076599,
-0.10949907451868057,
0.31551533937454224,
0.09148866683244705,
-0.12402687966823578,
-0.24652597308158875,
0.013241312466561794,
0.2543753385543823,
0.07315366715192795,
0.17102588713169098,
-0.7514342665672302,
0.5425258874893188,
0.6600375175476074,
-0.6011200547218323,
0.7577441334724426,
0.33065661787986755,
-0.1633968949317932,
-0.31031620502471924,
-0.23959733545780182,
0.11655674874782562,
-0.4424879252910614,
0.6928112506866455,
-0.702625572681427,
-0.6269466876983643,
0.5019340515136719,
-0.18265025317668915,
0.014959490858018398,
0.3152236044406891,
0.4814012944698334,
0.3016379773616791,
0.796637237071991,
0.9830194711685181,
0.13288654386997223,
0.6800017952919006,
0.04457319900393486,
-0.025729531422257423,
-0.4891584515571594,
-0.09705328941345215,
-0.7120291590690613,
-0.15957236289978027,
-0.6264544129371643,
-0.2897788882255554,
-0.051828816533088684,
-0.27669376134872437,
0.27201929688453674,
0.3242291808128357,
-0.6737253665924072,
0.6776060461997986,
0.30398035049438477,
0.1293816864490509,
0.05499856173992157,
-0.3245563805103302,
-0.17408742010593414,
-0.35737621784210205,
-0.8258058428764343,
-0.6155973672866821,
0.9141343235969543,
0.0928453803062439,
0.6754472851753235,
-0.173235684633255,
0.46551281213760376,
0.10129287838935852,
0.10879554599523544,
-0.9378827810287476,
0.4828684329986572,
-0.4289766550064087,
-0.6598540544509888,
0.02728469856083393,
-0.008472878485918045,
-0.5590795278549194,
-0.013321681879460812,
-0.4332787096500397,
-0.7955605387687683,
0.21324752271175385,
0.035444226115942,
-0.3534051179885864,
0.2175503969192505,
-0.8449273705482483,
1.0842645168304443,
0.02157745510339737,
-0.5475855469703674,
-0.1322128027677536,
-0.2976652979850769,
0.04231419041752815,
0.11562889069318771,
0.07282162457704544,
0.2447143942117691,
-0.1907723844051361,
0.6330080628395081,
-0.4766157865524292,
0.5225970149040222,
-0.47503164410591125,
0.1794995367527008,
-0.0572645477950573,
0.16047561168670654,
0.7129393815994263,
-0.13879558444023132,
-0.36179766058921814,
-0.4333638548851013,
0.1390238255262375,
-0.28328293561935425,
-0.7537549734115601,
0.5064340829849243,
-0.8579698801040649,
-0.28549301624298096,
-0.22103706002235413,
-0.2841631770133972,
0.21220873296260834,
0.12296590209007263,
0.5220383405685425,
0.5771893858909607,
-0.5950716137886047,
0.5649774670600891,
0.5382704138755798,
-0.29669007658958435,
0.07968415319919586,
0.694561779499054,
-0.4097023606300354,
-0.24927572906017303,
0.7071172595024109,
0.29827144742012024,
0.22043058276176453,
0.2298412173986435,
0.02231616899371147,
0.17432034015655518,
-0.5647758841514587,
-0.6341378092765808,
-0.1298384964466095,
-0.925232470035553,
-0.07392266392707825,
-0.8031521439552307,
-0.22602805495262146,
0.11221209913492203,
-0.5103716850280762,
-0.5742656588554382,
-0.3745211660861969,
-0.3603179156780243,
-0.5053856372833252,
0.6305883526802063,
0.9592841267585754,
0.10558347404003143,
0.5980097651481628,
-0.371014267206192,
0.24486981332302094,
0.06836699694395065,
0.37497711181640625,
-0.5992707014083862,
-0.3739507496356964,
-0.5211896896362305,
-0.38652530312538147,
-0.012192377820611,
-1.048671841621399,
0.19303292036056519,
0.23123182356357574,
0.21242673695087433,
-0.059551119804382324,
-0.3286827504634857,
0.6797770857810974,
-0.8244678378105164,
0.6330511569976807,
-0.231783926486969,
-1.261550784111023,
0.6105278730392456,
-0.12298433482646942,
0.35286155343055725,
0.6802360415458679,
0.3730233311653137,
-0.6748383045196533,
-0.41065603494644165,
-0.5507548451423645,
-0.41097569465637207,
1.0154433250427246,
0.27334102988243103,
0.16298076510429382,
0.3731876015663147,
0.5748783946037292,
0.6697655320167542,
-0.0731101855635643,
-0.5568939447402954,
-0.24468354880809784,
-0.4812401533126831,
-0.5616024136543274,
0.13771992921829224,
-0.19076424837112427,
0.27069413661956787,
-0.3676187992095947,
0.9820238351821899,
0.17862404882907867,
0.09555517882108688,
0.22792918980121613,
-0.4449891149997711,
-0.27587446570396423,
0.582780659198761,
0.5679233074188232,
0.670582115650177,
-0.08438079059123993,
-0.21288055181503296,
0.20691750943660736,
-0.8027200102806091,
0.22126276791095734,
0.3019905686378479,
-0.6104803681373596,
0.3476777672767639,
-0.07894105464220047,
1.0285100936889648,
0.4552755355834961,
-0.3346651494503021,
0.6139341592788696,
-0.5840646624565125,
-0.29944050312042236,
0.03122534416615963,
0.2934851348400116,
0.20788055658340454,
-0.0744810402393341,
0.2630610764026642,
0.42198002338409424,
0.3552389442920685,
-0.2634202837944031,
0.15498779714107513,
-0.2481832206249237,
-0.540632963180542,
-0.574189305305481,
0.5045212507247925,
0.41483789682388306,
-0.8534240126609802,
-0.051785845309495926,
0.06198182329535484,
-0.5847318768501282,
0.4488793611526489,
0.6124764680862427,
0.5966179370880127,
-0.5736583471298218,
0.40457332134246826,
0.41771915555000305,
0.23874613642692566,
0.043523795902729034,
0.608002781867981,
0.029835663735866547,
-0.678520679473877,
-0.41128087043762207,
-0.5917326807975769,
-0.2335594892501831,
0.13901162147521973,
-1.1765363216400146,
0.5271162390708923,
-0.4681575298309326,
0.013706869445741177,
0.5032894015312195,
0.06897478550672531,
-0.6870750784873962,
0.3047455847263336,
-0.6752230525016785,
1.0959209203720093,
-0.8399618864059448,
0.9356354475021362,
0.9315121173858643,
-0.04563720524311066,
-0.6801085472106934,
-0.234507754445076,
-0.12634961307048798,
-0.41291019320487976,
0.28162819147109985,
-0.013022826984524727,
-0.4680364429950714,
0.3393845558166504,
-0.6854326725006104,
-0.3908030092716217,
0.7837201952934265,
0.3686715364456177,
-0.7740480899810791,
0.14448955655097961,
-0.24611032009124756,
0.3704391121864319,
-0.3315851092338562,
-0.33544036746025085,
0.7972269058227539,
0.30466753244400024,
-0.39907434582710266,
-0.5298057794570923,
-0.2862323820590973,
-0.6221863031387329,
-0.16958792507648468,
0.3468862771987915,
-0.7068256735801697,
0.491038978099823,
0.37511327862739563,
-0.1686376929283142,
0.45804068446159363,
0.3653099238872528,
-0.20096725225448608,
-0.1510271579027176,
0.1613609790802002,
0.2599662244319916,
0.8382017016410828,
-0.020447377115488052,
0.9173519611358643,
-0.5472468137741089,
0.3144741952419281,
1.3020212650299072,
-0.14212220907211304,
0.8531671762466431,
0.3552076518535614,
-0.050667278468608856,
0.5869006514549255,
0.42991480231285095,
-0.19404645264148712,
0.30407029390335083,
-0.3362799882888794,
-0.3040882647037506,
-0.04448385909199715,
0.056456953287124634,
0.23051919043064117,
0.7810177206993103,
0.21922720968723297,
-0.3718097507953644,
0.1562565565109253,
0.3068539798259735,
0.38295456767082214,
0.5177873969078064,
-0.34710976481437683,
0.9869953393936157,
-0.6955825090408325,
-0.730826199054718,
-0.06613077968358994,
0.4620845317840576,
0.5653122663497925,
-0.7946577668190002,
0.15672974288463593,
-0.03943958878517151,
0.1479402631521225,
-0.21694287657737732,
-0.6299911737442017,
0.323914498090744,
0.6688745021820068,
-0.2955484986305237,
-0.29372403025627136,
1.122552752494812,
-0.553666889667511,
-1.1149168014526367,
0.2094145268201828,
0.1907844990491867,
-0.027452457696199417,
0.2632840871810913,
-0.6297126412391663,
0.18455268442630768,
0.10022391378879547,
-0.13173268735408783,
-0.35235267877578735,
0.7786373496055603,
0.5489293336868286,
0.32671603560447693,
0.38620099425315857,
0.43645232915878296,
0.30292457342147827,
0.09722673892974854,
0.5844093561172485,
-0.6117802858352661,
-0.6618745923042297,
-0.8612402081489563,
0.876747190952301,
-0.1089392751455307,
-0.49660998582839966,
0.8939911723136902,
0.7929177284240723,
0.6549256443977356,
-0.3494676649570465,
0.9988315105438232,
0.07841939479112625,
0.5454368591308594,
-0.4928217828273773,
0.8990533351898193,
-0.2889103293418884,
-0.5364539623260498,
-0.06287318468093872,
-0.671204686164856,
-0.26178833842277527,
0.5662886500358582,
-0.41455405950546265,
-0.325031578540802,
0.6415364146232605,
0.9284943342208862,
-0.3056197166442871,
-0.009090936742722988,
0.5371711254119873,
0.3691723048686981,
-0.2093290239572525,
0.029967568814754486,
0.8296994566917419,
-0.6224411129951477,
0.44993674755096436,
-0.29340848326683044,
-0.10067746043205261,
-0.3224894106388092,
-0.42367079854011536,
-0.9424002766609192,
-0.7008517384529114,
-0.16011705994606018,
-0.039036016911268234,
0.35390785336494446,
1.0388145446777344,
0.53470379114151,
-0.5594819188117981,
-0.12091917544603348,
-0.35417819023132324,
-0.2627805471420288,
-0.10774306207895279,
-0.20251962542533875,
0.2574598491191864,
-0.2603774070739746,
-0.8800336718559265,
0.4288750886917114,
0.5902981162071228,
-0.12151259183883667,
-0.05271200090646744,
-0.058723170310258865,
-0.41248416900634766,
0.5197504758834839,
0.3200508654117584,
-0.3817833662033081,
-0.4986427426338196,
-0.2603691816329956,
0.3270634114742279,
0.03969908133149147,
0.5617539882659912,
0.8079290986061096,
-0.2847490608692169,
0.9119641184806824,
0.16978856921195984,
0.4989519715309143,
0.5637969970703125,
0.03773976489901543,
0.7086045742034912,
-0.7936373353004456,
0.28038305044174194,
-0.029248466715216637,
0.3441970944404602,
0.6718376278877258,
-0.574801504611969,
0.09396089613437653,
-0.11752234399318695,
-0.6903908252716064,
-0.4423443675041199,
-0.02359667979180813,
-0.5596232414245605,
-0.19008712470531464,
0.8770987391471863,
-0.30045658349990845,
-0.6850459575653076,
-0.047331590205430984,
-0.851722240447998,
0.6188767552375793,
-0.4703883230686188,
0.7564257979393005,
1.2408305406570435,
0.21637283265590668,
-0.3284042477607727,
-0.7655851244926453,
0.6458349823951721,
0.20134952664375305,
-0.977264404296875,
0.18363095819950104,
0.5389108657836914,
0.6297901272773743,
-0.2183970808982849,
0.33201441168785095,
0.1296319216489792,
0.9110250473022461,
0.23401740193367004,
0.24551980197429657,
0.0941103994846344,
-0.4488969147205353,
-0.7086977958679199,
0.017393942922353745,
0.02502627857029438,
-0.16400128602981567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18870v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18870v1
|
More RLHF, More Trust? On The Impact of Human Preference Alignment On Language Model Trustworthiness
| 2024-04-29T17:00:53 | 2024-04-29T17:00:53 |
Aaron J. Li, Satyapriya Krishna, Himabindu Lakkaraju
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The surge in Large Language Models (LLMs) development has led to improved
performance on cognitive tasks as well as an urgent need to align these models
with human values in order to safely exploit their power. Despite the
effectiveness of preference learning algorithms like Reinforcement Learning
From Human Feedback (RLHF) in aligning human preferences, their assumed
improvements on model trustworthiness haven't been thoroughly testified. Toward
this end, this study investigates how models that have been aligned with
general-purpose preference data on helpfulness and harmlessness perform across
five trustworthiness verticals: toxicity, stereotypical bias, machine ethics,
truthfulness, and privacy. For model alignment, we focus on three widely used
RLHF variants: Supervised Finetuning (SFT), Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO),
and Direct Preference Optimization (DPO). Through extensive empirical
investigations, we discover that the improvement in trustworthiness by RLHF is
far from guaranteed, and there exists a complex interplay between preference
data, alignment algorithms, and specific trustworthiness aspects. Together, our
results underscore the need for more nuanced approaches for model alignment. By
shedding light on the intricate dynamics of these components within model
alignment, we hope this research will guide the community towards developing
language models that are both capable and trustworthy.
|
[
-0.19226083159446716,
-0.4698749780654907,
0.7249085903167725,
-0.09033641219139099,
0.0024089734070003033,
-0.037411559373140335,
-0.17706021666526794,
-0.8099750280380249,
-0.30202388763427734,
0.5961900353431702,
-0.5580152869224548,
-0.23870538175106049,
-0.507908284664154,
-0.07953429222106934,
-0.05457674711942673,
1.21254563331604,
0.15657171607017517,
0.10843604803085327,
-0.34034305810928345,
-0.09386561810970306,
-0.2942855656147003,
-0.7385494112968445,
-0.42496007680892944,
-0.8528482913970947,
0.5799853801727295,
0.42313581705093384,
1.2946642637252808,
0.9417527318000793,
0.701900839805603,
0.18744200468063354,
0.09181226044893265,
0.08024109899997711,
-0.4871613383293152,
0.15169577300548553,
-0.20029565691947937,
-0.41249093413352966,
-0.7166596055030823,
0.2654115855693817,
0.33122020959854126,
0.44185811281204224,
-0.3219349980354309,
-0.055955637246370316,
0.25182294845581055,
0.7718478441238403,
-0.4332212209701538,
0.14236459136009216,
-0.4332520067691803,
-0.15728934109210968,
0.11355839669704437,
-0.056145213544368744,
-0.45843058824539185,
-0.6769974231719971,
0.5658954381942749,
-0.6515185832977295,
-0.20010989904403687,
0.34016308188438416,
0.9989210963249207,
0.39725494384765625,
-0.3560484051704407,
-0.2212514877319336,
-0.5284343957901001,
1.0971050262451172,
-0.7777770757675171,
0.40855956077575684,
0.4695800244808197,
-0.042894456535577774,
-0.29381707310676575,
-0.2962632477283478,
-0.3347765803337097,
-0.5990855693817139,
-0.05260259285569191,
-0.10825537890195847,
-0.0024281085934489965,
0.22919413447380066,
0.07576987892389297,
0.09068555384874344,
-0.30338791012763977,
0.39183956384658813,
0.12753663957118988,
-0.48601004481315613,
0.6748651266098022,
0.1032361313700676,
0.22098417580127716,
-0.18720334768295288,
-0.422828733921051,
-0.4142225980758667,
-0.6749440431594849,
0.26068031787872314,
0.7327061891555786,
0.357517808675766,
-0.13861945271492004,
0.4555240273475647,
-0.090341717004776,
0.6393164396286011,
0.11443302035331726,
-0.438246488571167,
0.023154105991125107,
-0.3139161765575409,
-0.07484019547700882,
0.0613793283700943,
0.8466020822525024,
0.7154731154441833,
0.7098509669303894,
-0.12584258615970612,
-0.15502707660198212,
0.061781514436006546,
0.46529895067214966,
-0.5222322344779968,
-0.216935932636261,
0.24364492297172546,
-0.4634849429130554,
-0.8267282247543335,
0.11445590853691101,
-0.3934837579727173,
-0.5937506556510925,
-0.532280683517456,
0.09064138680696487,
-0.490966796875,
-0.25559377670288086,
0.019410470500588417,
0.19039060175418854,
0.23829910159111023,
0.317503422498703,
-0.8518247008323669,
0.20512282848358154,
1.0439531803131104,
0.4455498456954956,
-0.49174633622169495,
-0.4358786642551422,
-0.5135166049003601,
0.0515512153506279,
-0.3822568953037262,
0.43196502327919006,
-0.6631639003753662,
-0.31005871295928955,
-0.03328050300478935,
-0.14446556568145752,
0.048102669417858124,
-0.40788549184799194,
0.7364495992660522,
-0.5270909667015076,
0.3183751106262207,
-0.48071637749671936,
-0.5857346057891846,
-0.21423470973968506,
0.29548829793930054,
-0.5481082797050476,
0.9332590699195862,
-0.09933847188949585,
-0.7530802488327026,
0.410560667514801,
-0.4416998624801636,
-0.19712696969509125,
-0.3794199526309967,
-0.12647710740566254,
-0.526918888092041,
0.013246727176010609,
0.009265096858143806,
0.5396912693977356,
-0.3067200183868408,
0.5909319519996643,
-0.7022699117660522,
-0.2973868250846863,
0.7206405401229858,
-0.5424774885177612,
0.6929526925086975,
0.22046977281570435,
-0.27469775080680847,
0.42701196670532227,
-0.5422372817993164,
-0.028008483350276947,
0.024912085384130478,
-0.27126744389533997,
-0.33781927824020386,
-0.09663096070289612,
0.0809125006198883,
0.3037644922733307,
0.3975265324115753,
-0.27870306372642517,
-0.1103241816163063,
-0.3448801636695862,
0.39640581607818604,
1.0455456972122192,
-0.17807473242282867,
0.6367254257202148,
-0.635025680065155,
0.5159467458724976,
0.041905779391527176,
0.46852096915245056,
0.3665459156036377,
-0.5012766718864441,
-0.3814822733402252,
-0.029073936864733696,
0.28027579188346863,
0.34798023104667664,
-0.04904482141137123,
0.3901725709438324,
-0.3057100474834442,
-0.24282485246658325,
-0.6941035985946655,
0.14865028858184814,
0.7584875822067261,
0.8143132328987122,
0.22958900034427643,
-0.3071455955505371,
-0.27037501335144043,
-1.278175950050354,
-0.35579952597618103,
-0.34801027178764343,
0.2477102279663086,
0.49620920419692993,
0.12765157222747803,
-0.18593759834766388,
1.0336270332336426,
-0.3545573353767395,
-0.011523725464940071,
0.08521553128957748,
-0.1009356901049614,
-0.19965608417987823,
0.4405580759048462,
0.44862237572669983,
-0.6691109538078308,
-0.4399782419204712,
0.07580873370170593,
-0.3599891662597656,
0.014728154055774212,
0.3195632994174957,
-0.04746181517839432,
0.5422443151473999,
0.2468499094247818,
-0.299032598733902,
-0.15174871683120728,
0.7897621989250183,
-0.1667947620153427,
0.5093010067939758,
-0.20827122032642365,
0.1111319288611412,
-0.9470274448394775,
0.0007910937420092523,
0.02471855841577053,
-0.458008736371994,
-0.6202476024627686,
0.18565423786640167,
0.1505987048149109,
0.28725722432136536,
-0.453616738319397,
0.3990809917449951,
-0.26698532700538635,
-0.06654754281044006,
-0.2138649821281433,
0.1554323136806488,
-0.11071745306253433,
0.3895825147628784,
0.11211070418357849,
0.8471187353134155,
0.42432960867881775,
-0.4691207706928253,
0.12763836979866028,
0.024583643302321434,
-0.0705881118774414,
0.5315628051757812,
-0.6081680059432983,
0.33634138107299805,
0.10240620374679565,
0.09258202463388443,
-0.8008382320404053,
-0.36362412571907043,
0.3104628622531891,
-0.3483937084674835,
0.2875390648841858,
-0.06447163224220276,
-0.32228800654411316,
0.16147172451019287,
-0.4617387056350708,
0.21228191256523132,
0.5480818152427673,
-0.417173832654953,
0.3714021146297455,
0.5613824129104614,
0.045140091329813004,
-0.9755690097808838,
-0.4659912884235382,
-0.10888011753559113,
-0.4078097939491272,
-0.5297247171401978,
0.20448438823223114,
0.02277856320142746,
-0.45029133558273315,
-0.06252235919237137,
-0.24064785242080688,
0.029413258656859398,
0.3282427489757538,
0.34143131971359253,
0.5786426663398743,
0.09431213140487671,
-0.11393149197101593,
-0.2712768018245697,
-0.31028181314468384,
0.07704877108335495,
-0.13631132245063782,
0.3531869053840637,
-0.4246709942817688,
-0.20205944776535034,
-0.4702378213405609,
0.013493755832314491,
0.46816569566726685,
-0.12428947538137436,
0.6815839409828186,
0.3900296986103058,
-0.13230226933956146,
0.05873074382543564,
-0.594431459903717,
-0.4594665467739105,
-0.43747302889823914,
0.2715478241443634,
-0.13028565049171448,
-1.2665026187896729,
0.24488763511180878,
0.24754929542541504,
0.11168759316205978,
0.20725509524345398,
0.31776097416877747,
-0.17461568117141724,
1.079133152961731,
0.7229323387145996,
-0.4139535427093506,
0.44033879041671753,
0.4278762638568878,
0.21379901468753815,
-0.6604849696159363,
-0.06865532696247101,
-0.4550473093986511,
-0.07891230285167694,
-0.9062595367431641,
-0.16548165678977966,
0.04067882522940636,
-0.08228631317615509,
-0.2508227825164795,
0.28653109073638916,
-0.3813937306404114,
0.29589107632637024,
0.4185386598110199,
0.1355973333120346,
0.5184968709945679,
-0.07818856835365295,
-0.10380489379167557,
-0.20173457264900208,
-0.5087275505065918,
-0.734095573425293,
1.157699704170227,
0.7017332911491394,
0.8529992699623108,
0.12571613490581512,
0.7629764676094055,
0.03709939122200012,
0.3241147994995117,
-0.7694138288497925,
0.4015306234359741,
-0.13243070244789124,
-0.5417370200157166,
-0.42079511284828186,
-0.2742231786251068,
-0.6230832934379578,
-0.05454937368631363,
-0.3287069797515869,
-0.6796408891677856,
0.08959182351827621,
0.5583018064498901,
-0.4170183837413788,
-0.16004504263401031,
-0.7863391637802124,
0.6927481889724731,
-0.31020230054855347,
-0.5109036564826965,
-0.31258562207221985,
-0.8771222829818726,
0.4960077404975891,
0.00869652722030878,
0.25811466574668884,
-0.20575088262557983,
-0.04855797067284584,
0.5970406532287598,
-0.05770762264728546,
0.8690664172172546,
0.034653130918741226,
-0.4615437388420105,
-0.13017350435256958,
0.10309270024299622,
0.7412641048431396,
-0.07266651839017868,
-0.09595179557800293,
0.21573641896247864,
0.1671278178691864,
-0.19876661896705627,
-0.3952096104621887,
0.9532347321510315,
-0.8796720504760742,
-0.8108823299407959,
-0.47376298904418945,
-0.7390875816345215,
-0.5263676643371582,
0.295566588640213,
-0.10376372188329697,
0.09128160029649734,
-0.2532879710197449,
0.2327369600534439,
1.0751512050628662,
-0.013535277917981148,
0.27638596296310425,
0.30308762192726135,
-0.27327871322631836,
-0.23966820538043976,
0.7623368501663208,
-0.15470483899116516,
0.5395175814628601,
0.3649601936340332,
0.2858811318874359,
-0.4381011426448822,
-0.30482977628707886,
-0.14309172332286835,
0.2890315353870392,
-0.5838768482208252,
-0.062484290450811386,
-0.38947218656539917,
-0.023585356771945953,
-0.5499491691589355,
-0.13534237444400787,
-0.48772916197776794,
-0.43784788250923157,
-0.2500474452972412,
-0.23074184358119965,
0.4139539897441864,
0.6414840221405029,
0.14016325771808624,
0.07581112533807755,
-0.6477802991867065,
0.060632094740867615,
0.2348616123199463,
0.5665755867958069,
-0.10467029362916946,
-0.4612656533718109,
-0.12288957089185715,
0.06001967564225197,
-0.18605390191078186,
-0.6182843446731567,
-0.06430238485336304,
-0.1845577508211136,
0.4603478014469147,
0.4168482720851898,
0.10250650346279144,
0.6006077527999878,
-0.21605238318443298,
0.5530468821525574,
0.15050028264522552,
-0.7838969230651855,
0.07426197081804276,
-0.453598290681839,
-0.21120311319828033,
0.6218622326850891,
0.27479466795921326,
-0.3347281217575073,
-0.16229119896888733,
-0.5955290198326111,
-0.4422855079174042,
0.7145732045173645,
-0.01861746795475483,
0.08216898888349533,
0.3649366497993469,
0.4546940326690674,
0.1606711894273758,
0.15061625838279724,
-0.7204713225364685,
-0.22626104950904846,
-0.13484810292720795,
-0.2634643018245697,
-0.15832707285881042,
-0.3952314853668213,
-0.4545327126979828,
0.10354593396186829,
0.7483300566673279,
-0.16531731188297272,
-0.06674264371395111,
0.021651901304721832,
0.07813603430986404,
-0.2630311846733093,
0.574004590511322,
0.721638023853302,
0.5878397226333618,
-0.26443371176719666,
0.06930212676525116,
-0.20381030440330505,
-0.38136914372444153,
0.12980841100215912,
0.016335004940629005,
-0.1673554629087448,
-0.7174773812294006,
0.21807272732257843,
0.6134223341941833,
0.2828758955001831,
-0.5244139432907104,
0.4749893546104431,
-0.11140205711126328,
-0.22697122395038605,
-0.1360095888376236,
0.5006309747695923,
0.3368385136127472,
0.047069381922483444,
-0.04615535959601402,
0.0538509264588356,
-0.046162836253643036,
-0.5032444596290588,
0.1459875851869583,
0.7125747799873352,
-0.644591748714447,
-0.16444486379623413,
0.5955625772476196,
0.06844622641801834,
-0.3210677206516266,
0.4579063057899475,
0.2228154093027115,
-0.41551923751831055,
0.24273188412189484,
0.3344167470932007,
0.7870317697525024,
-0.11993464827537537,
0.24745473265647888,
0.016859302297234535,
0.28692230582237244,
-0.31653010845184326,
0.0028147974517196417,
-0.021172696724534035,
-1.0608874559402466,
-0.28725335001945496,
-0.47577300667762756,
-0.683018684387207,
-0.03237244486808777,
-0.8567869663238525,
-0.036304596811532974,
-0.37162840366363525,
-0.3241522014141083,
-0.25600865483283997,
0.24652308225631714,
-0.435189813375473,
0.15933749079704285,
-0.11646121740341187,
0.5026872754096985,
-0.6959550976753235,
1.115893840789795,
0.7461769580841064,
-0.2623239755630493,
-1.0386478900909424,
0.3005329966545105,
0.14093728363513947,
-0.9766431450843811,
0.2774115800857544,
-0.05506684258580208,
-0.39684686064720154,
-0.01687256619334221,
-0.568573534488678,
-0.8713851571083069,
1.1100258827209473,
0.5534412264823914,
-0.6920666694641113,
0.018927445635199547,
0.10558164864778519,
0.5904073715209961,
-0.43909257650375366,
-0.03846892714500427,
0.6796971559524536,
0.636329174041748,
-0.2479419708251953,
-0.9976671934127808,
0.24307996034622192,
0.19016598165035248,
0.14660196006298065,
0.03123655915260315,
-0.812078595161438,
0.31831610202789307,
-0.28076520562171936,
0.08119349181652069,
-0.086511991918087,
0.5489916801452637,
0.5197633504867554,
0.04279962182044983,
0.5435164570808411,
0.5735140442848206,
0.8307841420173645,
0.046686965972185135,
1.1234368085861206,
-0.40110865235328674,
0.16037864983081818,
1.2250679731369019,
-0.4135793447494507,
0.7714654803276062,
0.7473610043525696,
-0.10333943367004395,
0.39877596497535706,
0.6203978061676025,
0.2214093953371048,
0.5399698615074158,
-0.13291266560554504,
0.1545649915933609,
-0.3914131820201874,
-0.2985561788082123,
-0.21425041556358337,
0.30170542001724243,
-0.04449525102972984,
-0.31769174337387085,
0.13343998789787292,
-0.4092593193054199,
0.30563199520111084,
0.21443869173526764,
0.04651915282011032,
0.73186194896698,
0.13585907220840454,
-1.1039646863937378,
0.2861287295818329,
0.00004254125815350562,
0.7446390390396118,
-0.44715917110443115,
0.15295332670211792,
-0.011115231551229954,
0.21352776885032654,
-0.38338276743888855,
-0.8790677785873413,
0.13867314159870148,
-0.1587110161781311,
-0.31097546219825745,
-0.3176913857460022,
0.6785626411437988,
-0.25647687911987305,
0.022476838901638985,
0.465280145406723,
0.30909162759780884,
-0.15985609591007233,
0.1981382817029953,
-0.8509242534637451,
0.1413947492837906,
0.14421384036540985,
-0.28311142325401306,
0.7479369640350342,
0.022052880376577377,
-0.15103106200695038,
0.7079212069511414,
0.7455956339836121,
0.013144060969352722,
-0.14556697010993958,
0.06863652169704437,
0.5151205062866211,
-0.4631160497665405,
-0.2842070460319519,
-0.8735381364822388,
0.36782005429267883,
0.029716331511735916,
-0.26042667031288147,
0.8728036880493164,
0.2259145975112915,
0.8281756639480591,
0.1229923665523529,
0.7305212616920471,
0.40194350481033325,
0.3719094693660736,
-0.5017849802970886,
0.7011011838912964,
-0.29631081223487854,
0.25420433282852173,
-0.33098214864730835,
-0.8361166715621948,
-0.24423500895500183,
0.5257342457771301,
-0.34506478905677795,
0.17938604950904846,
0.6148812174797058,
0.986031711101532,
0.07821959257125854,
0.0784836858510971,
0.3704860210418701,
0.1371341496706009,
0.33288440108299255,
0.267336905002594,
0.6781489849090576,
-0.10253188014030457,
0.4211104214191437,
-0.5630134344100952,
-0.19888827204704285,
-0.23373094201087952,
-1.295894980430603,
-0.6020157337188721,
-0.47907018661499023,
-0.2950618267059326,
-0.36199435591697693,
0.11111586540937424,
1.0645545721054077,
0.6804733276367188,
-0.8617143034934998,
-0.2581486105918884,
-0.21322877705097198,
0.17878468334674835,
-0.26529163122177124,
-0.25218209624290466,
0.25702258944511414,
-0.21027816832065582,
-0.6026033759117126,
0.22950950264930725,
0.14399634301662445,
0.16053414344787598,
-0.3039581775665283,
-0.5100956559181213,
0.057856593281030655,
0.1154680848121643,
0.24776628613471985,
0.2089722603559494,
-0.9756826162338257,
-0.6121330857276917,
0.291841596364975,
-0.40706637501716614,
0.05732735991477966,
0.6827126741409302,
-0.35156527161598206,
0.25529274344444275,
0.26608917117118835,
0.6008875966072083,
-0.05676545575261116,
0.30755192041397095,
0.8303484916687012,
-0.3631250262260437,
-0.23816229403018951,
0.024896306917071342,
0.3145693838596344,
0.48174771666526794,
-0.6400722861289978,
0.34968075156211853,
-0.13531601428985596,
-0.8984131217002869,
-0.869059681892395,
0.42544063925743103,
-0.8843220472335815,
-0.07819909602403641,
1.1848253011703491,
-0.11451762169599533,
-0.17938750982284546,
-0.09685669094324112,
-0.17395849525928497,
0.12459157407283783,
-0.7378588318824768,
0.9249476194381714,
0.9365211725234985,
-0.4570128619670868,
-0.16591744124889374,
-0.27923130989074707,
0.8293598294258118,
0.6028300523757935,
-0.5432756543159485,
0.40674808621406555,
0.6855332255363464,
0.4937629699707031,
0.1065681055188179,
0.5285032987594604,
-0.25664693117141724,
0.2385292500257492,
-0.5473499298095703,
-0.17261876165866852,
-0.17339317500591278,
-0.33419880270957947,
-0.6226670742034912,
0.09257142245769501,
0.6619188189506531,
0.1542017012834549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18865v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18865v1
|
Truth-value judgment in language models: belief directions are context sensitive
| 2024-04-29T16:52:57 | 2024-04-29T16:52:57 |
Stefan F. Schouten, Peter Bloem, Ilia Markov, Piek Vossen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent work has demonstrated that the latent spaces of large language models
(LLMs) contain directions predictive of the truth of sentences. Multiple
methods recover such directions and build probes that are described as getting
at a model's "knowledge" or "beliefs". We investigate this phenomenon, looking
closely at the impact of context on the probes. Our experiments establish where
in the LLM the probe's predictions can be described as being conditional on the
preceding (related) sentences. Specifically, we quantify the responsiveness of
the probes to the presence of (negated) supporting and contradicting sentences,
and score the probes on their consistency. We also perform a causal
intervention experiment, investigating whether moving the representation of a
premise along these belief directions influences the position of the hypothesis
along that same direction. We find that the probes we test are generally
context sensitive, but that contexts which should not affect the truth often
still impact the probe outputs. Our experiments show that the type of errors
depend on the layer, the (type of) model, and the kind of data. Finally, our
results suggest that belief directions are (one of the) causal mediators in the
inference process that incorporates in-context information.
|
[
-0.01371823437511921,
-0.9401217699050903,
1.1035207509994507,
0.11826176196336746,
0.08003317564725876,
-0.4742736220359802,
-0.1594560146331787,
-0.21264250576496124,
0.018270457163453102,
0.6288262605667114,
-0.2990390956401825,
-0.46641018986701965,
-0.6578174829483032,
-0.1440800428390503,
-0.283706396818161,
0.7682075500488281,
0.10093823820352554,
0.09535346925258636,
-0.4582885503768921,
-0.16703154146671295,
-0.5493319034576416,
-0.5777102708816528,
-0.44051873683929443,
-0.1945948600769043,
0.6777824759483337,
0.4379187226295471,
0.6454473733901978,
0.4877660870552063,
0.34863927960395813,
0.3029738664627075,
-0.1463695913553238,
-0.2799155116081238,
-0.2688337564468384,
0.5160893201828003,
-0.3368074595928192,
-0.9423186182975769,
-0.3057335913181305,
0.5088423490524292,
0.7435257434844971,
0.8480013608932495,
0.1014278456568718,
-0.133630633354187,
-0.16234731674194336,
0.3126249611377716,
-0.7049189209938049,
0.10490977019071579,
-0.579328715801239,
-0.20146270096302032,
0.09788240492343903,
-0.3680787980556488,
-0.6417548060417175,
-0.4329259395599365,
0.4448627829551697,
-0.16592642664909363,
0.21168608963489532,
0.10860558599233627,
0.838400661945343,
0.2398041933774948,
-1.0533015727996826,
-0.32770857214927673,
-0.7164649963378906,
1.0159029960632324,
-0.9401766061782837,
0.4873570501804352,
0.5960006713867188,
0.36819928884506226,
-0.3697814345359802,
-0.5735561847686768,
-0.598581850528717,
-0.3120081424713135,
-0.16343796253204346,
0.19152382016181946,
0.04598594084382057,
0.031230304390192032,
0.5501384735107422,
0.1485183835029602,
-0.17998871207237244,
-0.06294011324644089,
0.010417074896395206,
-0.03817969188094139,
0.44846591353416443,
-0.004800703842192888,
-0.028918331488966942,
-0.2682574689388275,
-0.30195555090904236,
-0.143450066447258,
-1.0545645952224731,
0.23458747565746307,
0.15625044703483582,
0.24829737842082977,
0.009584203362464905,
0.6968863606452942,
-0.2627961039543152,
0.8261451125144958,
0.2062964290380478,
-0.4466457664966583,
0.037135254591703415,
-0.4545722007751465,
-0.2645736634731293,
0.17638832330703735,
0.4871889650821686,
0.4786798357963562,
0.057085491716861725,
-0.008815279230475426,
-0.2490081489086151,
0.24496173858642578,
0.23999685049057007,
-0.6611754894256592,
-0.01691480167210102,
0.023323852568864822,
-0.2847960591316223,
-0.2633526921272278,
-0.021132217720150948,
-0.34259045124053955,
-0.4145427346229553,
-0.2566741108894348,
0.39868244528770447,
-0.2504448890686035,
-0.18601001799106598,
0.09240859746932983,
-0.04109187796711922,
0.4110683798789978,
0.45165780186653137,
-0.739000141620636,
0.2093905657529831,
0.6148727536201477,
0.5091072916984558,
0.04603411257266998,
-0.31341487169265747,
-0.6518413424491882,
0.18407079577445984,
-0.48827749490737915,
0.8533523082733154,
-0.7272787690162659,
-0.42788684368133545,
-0.0023327351082116365,
0.1110711619257927,
-0.06247059628367424,
-0.34222614765167236,
0.8031062483787537,
-0.688849925994873,
0.5567794442176819,
-0.9108108878135681,
-0.9398578405380249,
-0.47388550639152527,
0.2965477705001831,
-0.4527360200881958,
0.602766215801239,
-0.05918782576918602,
-0.8848029971122742,
0.6069325804710388,
-0.39072221517562866,
-0.6006117463111877,
-0.3245027959346771,
-0.5815171003341675,
-0.03934783861041069,
0.24826784431934357,
-0.13489988446235657,
0.5528451800346375,
-0.26711225509643555,
0.3949510455131531,
-0.34258508682250977,
-0.280213862657547,
0.5911696553230286,
-0.592893123626709,
0.5534714460372925,
-0.1606673151254654,
-0.7481931447982788,
0.17942026257514954,
-0.6559681296348572,
-0.1794622242450714,
0.11082370579242706,
-0.32372215390205383,
-0.6363435387611389,
0.5296375155448914,
-0.32435810565948486,
0.2041001170873642,
-0.18509745597839355,
-0.610083818435669,
0.1710166335105896,
-0.3381493389606476,
0.09544554352760315,
0.7627538442611694,
0.10120591521263123,
0.47112002968788147,
-0.1374402493238449,
0.3076896667480469,
0.10807283222675323,
-0.1148509830236435,
-0.12522488832473755,
-0.5997952222824097,
-0.7614384889602661,
0.2385527342557907,
0.1088198572397232,
0.25544673204421997,
-0.3587755858898163,
0.29755547642707825,
-0.11255089938640594,
-0.20384186506271362,
-0.1375443935394287,
-0.4606603682041168,
0.4154982566833496,
1.1284356117248535,
0.270830363035202,
0.1343834400177002,
-0.31585994362831116,
-0.9712310433387756,
-0.2718501687049866,
-0.507196843624115,
0.17356501519680023,
0.5067636370658875,
0.5693325996398926,
-0.1250254213809967,
1.1152901649475098,
-0.7952712774276733,
-0.022318463772535324,
-0.028119295835494995,
0.15894775092601776,
0.3647054433822632,
0.30490753054618835,
0.584530234336853,
-1.1947484016418457,
-0.1277693510055542,
-0.3305221498012543,
-0.6843459010124207,
-0.3177940249443054,
-0.044081270694732666,
0.19167056679725647,
0.2870244085788727,
0.5311185717582703,
-0.37453341484069824,
0.5300995707511902,
0.8630809187889099,
-0.7013439536094666,
0.7051641941070557,
0.11850020289421082,
0.32493749260902405,
-0.9562665224075317,
-0.1080687940120697,
0.04118412360548973,
-0.14936956763267517,
-0.6029631495475769,
-0.17487916350364685,
0.06175488978624344,
0.7643693089485168,
-0.21247534453868866,
0.5048600435256958,
-0.05170578509569168,
-0.08173905313014984,
-0.4662136435508728,
0.19607675075531006,
0.22677728533744812,
0.2374977469444275,
0.40347668528556824,
0.8622872829437256,
0.35418543219566345,
-0.7549410462379456,
0.26940783858299255,
0.06571107357740402,
-0.26767557859420776,
0.690597653388977,
-0.7306943535804749,
-0.026195017620921135,
-0.08738826215267181,
0.16659100353717804,
-1.1655144691467285,
-0.08304475992918015,
0.20010673999786377,
-0.521874725818634,
0.10277292877435684,
-0.29458752274513245,
-0.3570972681045532,
0.07168105989694595,
0.12381081283092499,
0.40050312876701355,
0.24383455514907837,
-0.4799725115299225,
0.5201069116592407,
0.39536479115486145,
-0.007233313750475645,
-0.707538366317749,
-0.8327085971832275,
-0.09568626433610916,
-0.3699113428592682,
-0.40648359060287476,
0.25950440764427185,
-0.1252155601978302,
-0.7679835557937622,
0.04331086203455925,
-0.1953466385602951,
0.04343397915363312,
0.2563842833042145,
0.45746228098869324,
0.2876893877983093,
-0.2910013794898987,
0.32758116722106934,
0.028576308861374855,
-0.05337422713637352,
0.5008639693260193,
-0.4498317539691925,
0.23534037172794342,
-0.25791656970977783,
-0.6591123342514038,
0.2240028828382492,
0.15499956905841827,
0.42599883675575256,
-0.03808487579226494,
0.8434369564056396,
0.010161226615309715,
-0.34689027070999146,
0.04271895810961723,
-0.8024565577507019,
-0.23677806556224823,
-0.45911312103271484,
0.13153839111328125,
-0.5243707299232483,
-0.9876607060432434,
0.526540219783783,
-0.011421993374824524,
-0.2584061622619629,
0.40427112579345703,
0.5162674188613892,
-0.13226106762886047,
1.0158346891403198,
0.5039868950843811,
0.022024549543857574,
0.14410409331321716,
-0.076948381960392,
0.3152303695678711,
-0.887725830078125,
-0.1305147409439087,
-0.6141104102134705,
0.11113182455301285,
-0.6934524774551392,
-0.264666885137558,
0.5013044476509094,
0.06653863936662674,
-0.04227457568049431,
0.02673734538257122,
0.12431418150663376,
0.4278571903705597,
0.4309288263320923,
-0.12401673197746277,
0.27576109766960144,
-0.46765923500061035,
-0.4557989239692688,
-0.1933813840150833,
-0.6854656934738159,
-0.6288043856620789,
0.9662457704544067,
0.2947475016117096,
0.6529229879379272,
0.36464041471481323,
0.26821398735046387,
-0.11638892441987991,
0.31639590859413147,
-1.073221206665039,
0.4334855079650879,
0.31047773361206055,
-0.8476834893226624,
-0.27668213844299316,
-0.3129536211490631,
-0.7156807780265808,
0.3806416690349579,
-0.10168392956256866,
-0.6442850232124329,
0.3256292939186096,
0.04981505870819092,
-0.29902637004852295,
0.16411757469177246,
-0.5884271860122681,
0.8128666877746582,
-0.23897801339626312,
-0.6312777996063232,
-0.1099458634853363,
-0.7113549113273621,
0.13705292344093323,
-0.006166399922221899,
0.09779775142669678,
0.06265666335821152,
0.24252767860889435,
0.7127068042755127,
-0.08862227946519852,
0.9933325052261353,
-0.2424561232328415,
-0.38544759154319763,
0.15155434608459473,
0.26920583844184875,
0.40487247705459595,
0.0701477974653244,
-0.10118051618337631,
-0.07779336720705032,
0.0743316262960434,
-0.25831031799316406,
-0.7600088715553284,
0.6285589337348938,
-0.37128233909606934,
-1.0104970932006836,
-0.5372878313064575,
-0.5634473562240601,
-0.4696720838546753,
0.36318087577819824,
0.2541627883911133,
0.4929986000061035,
-0.3515441119670868,
0.3109518885612488,
0.9110879302024841,
-0.32053667306900024,
0.21788613498210907,
0.801099419593811,
-0.3225061893463135,
0.1941893994808197,
0.2731081247329712,
0.1502932757139206,
0.5196503400802612,
0.5455339550971985,
0.49918943643569946,
-0.5630364418029785,
-0.5100565552711487,
0.08101604133844376,
0.3195664584636688,
-0.9298842549324036,
0.014945024624466896,
-0.33188924193382263,
0.038017548620700836,
-0.47064802050590515,
-0.06821203231811523,
-0.4475618004798889,
-0.11567968130111694,
-0.03091641701757908,
-0.44458746910095215,
0.2280067801475525,
0.7438226342201233,
0.020750869065523148,
0.19957539439201355,
-0.5552852153778076,
-0.12543384730815887,
0.4306305944919586,
0.24565736949443817,
-0.2921442985534668,
-0.5355949997901917,
-0.22916854918003082,
0.2351350635290146,
0.0783119723200798,
-1.046090841293335,
0.25282829999923706,
-0.20425660908222198,
0.5039351582527161,
0.5102694034576416,
0.08991944789886475,
0.3917606770992279,
-0.49387243390083313,
0.7365889549255371,
-0.1454172283411026,
-1.0574878454208374,
0.7496947050094604,
-0.5004678964614868,
0.2302001416683197,
0.3481367230415344,
0.352302223443985,
-0.7941166162490845,
-0.4464305639266968,
-0.5493870377540588,
-0.3709687292575836,
0.4149799942970276,
0.016959108412265778,
-0.036083120852708817,
-0.18423093855381012,
0.4631221294403076,
0.10265135020017624,
0.32115861773490906,
-0.6608209013938904,
-0.22530700266361237,
-0.1280655562877655,
0.18615202605724335,
-0.2907928228378296,
-0.518563449382782,
-0.3151750862598419,
-0.14901140332221985,
0.2605889141559601,
-0.38546454906463623,
0.27191758155822754,
0.43397289514541626,
0.03212735056877136,
-0.17303653061389923,
0.357774019241333,
0.7419062852859497,
0.8657952547073364,
-0.3721175491809845,
0.5938395261764526,
0.09968483448028564,
-0.14228680729866028,
0.1133187785744667,
-0.1883421242237091,
-0.3874030113220215,
-0.039310116320848465,
0.7261305451393127,
0.8198639750480652,
0.2701176106929779,
-0.29763269424438477,
0.8653196096420288,
-0.10895504057407379,
-0.003328493097797036,
-0.3587323725223541,
0.04481416940689087,
-0.014702869579195976,
0.38655808568000793,
0.22134844958782196,
0.06590703874826431,
0.2941526770591736,
-0.6205210089683533,
0.22398480772972107,
0.4260738492012024,
-0.26851245760917664,
-0.559136688709259,
0.5881120562553406,
-0.18017315864562988,
0.10630366951227188,
0.4897006154060364,
-0.12726229429244995,
-0.8829627633094788,
0.5782230496406555,
0.7660545110702515,
0.7636475563049316,
-0.43136757612228394,
0.1414525806903839,
0.17051199078559875,
0.135165274143219,
0.02403784915804863,
0.2562865614891052,
0.16054882109165192,
-1.2624638080596924,
-0.6595081686973572,
-0.27347010374069214,
-0.33986568450927734,
0.04206477850675583,
-0.6000880599021912,
-0.018753625452518463,
-0.24051032960414886,
-0.19101235270500183,
-0.17618346214294434,
-0.05347722768783569,
-0.39876610040664673,
0.5361998677253723,
0.11985833942890167,
0.8126264214515686,
-0.9719213843345642,
1.0927318334579468,
0.5827560424804688,
-0.33434879779815674,
-1.0155975818634033,
0.404995322227478,
0.16837528347969055,
-0.6305060386657715,
1.0567706823349,
0.07588493824005127,
-0.5961884260177612,
-0.3536667227745056,
-0.6562809348106384,
-1.086690902709961,
0.8923155069351196,
0.28113365173339844,
-0.3432314097881317,
0.09304484724998474,
-0.05626700073480606,
0.6134441494941711,
-0.43279775977134705,
0.28047385811805725,
0.3999069035053253,
0.5647099614143372,
0.26791805028915405,
-0.8032380938529968,
0.2214362621307373,
-0.00569867342710495,
-0.18631695210933685,
-0.08328181505203247,
-0.4835566282272339,
0.9960181713104248,
-0.3317929208278656,
-0.12825998663902283,
-0.20411422848701477,
0.6388394832611084,
0.288625031709671,
0.2455262541770935,
0.5987774729728699,
0.38019609451293945,
0.7455449104309082,
-0.13967593014240265,
1.2818279266357422,
-0.15977156162261963,
0.2780871093273163,
1.0808329582214355,
-0.3206155300140381,
0.8224993944168091,
0.6411644220352173,
-0.030316395685076714,
0.6583134531974792,
0.5285515785217285,
0.2258443683385849,
0.7014628648757935,
-0.0667332261800766,
-0.016323454678058624,
-0.09178270399570465,
-0.439654141664505,
-0.27558276057243347,
0.5305187702178955,
0.4963284134864807,
-0.2798159420490265,
0.15023422241210938,
-0.2842406630516052,
0.2778495252132416,
0.0977199450135231,
0.06457369774580002,
0.39308130741119385,
0.08737002313137054,
-0.8377779126167297,
0.40254348516464233,
0.07525641471147537,
0.3289210796356201,
-0.5442585349082947,
-0.20734860002994537,
-0.27965301275253296,
0.14965839684009552,
-0.1760302484035492,
-0.9786097407341003,
0.2847440242767334,
-0.338283509016037,
-0.21964216232299805,
-0.22908779978752136,
0.7962905168533325,
-0.29974105954170227,
-0.13125872611999512,
0.571808934211731,
0.5515395998954773,
-0.13357013463974,
-0.11600913852453232,
-0.2774624228477478,
0.009737197309732437,
-0.06985948234796524,
-0.5282822251319885,
0.09298790246248245,
0.44159871339797974,
-0.026573222130537033,
0.5615122318267822,
0.468790739774704,
0.30417966842651367,
-0.07312682271003723,
0.14124742150306702,
0.8154160976409912,
-0.7389979958534241,
-0.39448362588882446,
-0.8240142464637756,
0.2609950602054596,
0.16177630424499512,
-0.11551129817962646,
1.0815454721450806,
0.19067154824733734,
0.8605982661247253,
0.27927252650260925,
0.7062627077102661,
0.1583516150712967,
0.5730132460594177,
-0.8756141662597656,
0.4462452232837677,
-0.5205283761024475,
0.3574684262275696,
-0.3140074610710144,
-0.8390888571739197,
-0.33683085441589355,
0.8268256783485413,
-0.9334388971328735,
0.14747777581214905,
1.0085800886154175,
0.6766546368598938,
0.08804453164339066,
0.14699169993400574,
0.3240472972393036,
0.5314196944236755,
0.38197246193885803,
0.3181067705154419,
1.1274983882904053,
-0.28542041778564453,
-0.14305050671100616,
-0.15970538556575775,
-0.3431706726551056,
-0.17194221913814545,
-0.9640341401100159,
-0.6993000507354736,
-0.7570312023162842,
-0.1933976262807846,
-0.5056552886962891,
-0.15174083411693573,
0.5416797399520874,
0.6526497006416321,
-0.8263258337974548,
-0.35184553265571594,
-0.1700611710548401,
0.3414073884487152,
-0.018251080065965652,
-0.26583781838417053,
0.3875761032104492,
-0.16346244513988495,
-0.5988929271697998,
0.6176417469978333,
0.2425026148557663,
-0.0372297465801239,
-0.2305087447166443,
-0.19701001048088074,
-0.3608390688896179,
0.10319975763559341,
0.6456365585327148,
-0.0735355019569397,
-0.8904030919075012,
-0.7388240098953247,
0.2164081186056137,
-0.32054412364959717,
0.055212318897247314,
0.6670902967453003,
-0.8374845385551453,
0.3894120156764984,
0.5041924715042114,
0.45964929461479187,
0.2508202791213989,
-0.1055578961968422,
0.903125524520874,
-0.6411576867103577,
0.036058153957128525,
0.24525070190429688,
0.5749999284744263,
0.22828418016433716,
-0.46494701504707336,
0.3932013511657715,
0.47250109910964966,
-0.636887788772583,
-0.6876451373100281,
0.6558994650840759,
-0.7523325681686401,
-0.4513340890407562,
1.369684100151062,
-0.31204646825790405,
-0.18822364509105682,
0.1637071818113327,
-0.06414024531841278,
0.1867031306028366,
-0.16376139223575592,
0.5981643795967102,
0.8482493758201599,
-0.15360049903392792,
-0.07326853275299072,
-0.6245833039283752,
0.43831774592399597,
0.6882649660110474,
-0.45432543754577637,
-0.029874010011553764,
0.8359695672988892,
0.2206755131483078,
0.282064288854599,
0.47490665316581726,
0.06265514343976974,
-0.02014554664492607,
-0.03261421620845795,
-0.3261515200138092,
0.3906551003456116,
-0.46763187646865845,
-0.36752113699913025,
-0.014006230048835278,
0.373614639043808,
-0.0233444906771183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18851v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18851v1
|
A Comprehensive Rubric for Annotating Pathological Speech
| 2024-04-29T16:44:27 | 2024-04-29T16:44:27 |
Mario Corrales-Astorgano, David Escudero-Mancebo, Lourdes Aguilar, Valle Flores-Lucas, Valentín Cardeñoso-Payo, Carlos Vivaracho-Pascual, César González-Ferreras
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Rubrics are a commonly used tool for labeling voice corpora in speech quality
assessment, although their application in the context of pathological speech
remains relatively limited. In this study, we introduce a comprehensive rubric
based on various dimensions of speech quality, including phonetics, fluency,
and prosody. The objective is to establish standardized criteria for
identifying errors within the speech of individuals with Down syndrome, thereby
enabling the development of automated assessment systems. To achieve this
objective, we utilized the Prautocal corpus. To assess the quality of
annotations using our rubric, two experiments were conducted, focusing on
phonetics and fluency. For phonetic evaluation, we employed the Goodness of
Pronunciation (GoP) metric, utilizing automatic segmentation systems and
correlating the results with evaluations conducted by a specialized speech
therapist. While the obtained correlation values were not notably high, a
positive trend was observed. In terms of fluency assessment, deep learning
models like wav2vec were used to extract audio features, and we employed an SVM
classifier trained on a corpus focused on identifying fluency issues to
categorize Prautocal corpus samples. The outcomes highlight the complexities of
evaluating such phenomena, with variability depending on the specific type of
disfluency detected.
|
[
-0.14653655886650085,
-0.8811805844306946,
0.25988680124282837,
0.5418844819068909,
0.04524867236614227,
0.5257312059402466,
-0.33122703433036804,
-0.0992698222398758,
0.5835787653923035,
0.5019382834434509,
-0.20142081379890442,
-0.6937631368637085,
-0.5714503526687622,
-0.04018254578113556,
-0.3207079768180847,
1.16033935546875,
0.20698484778404236,
0.5149648785591125,
-0.03076445870101452,
0.03196519985795021,
-0.7654733657836914,
-0.38447508215904236,
-0.38818150758743286,
-0.009830835275352001,
0.2879513204097748,
0.6280021667480469,
0.8567755818367004,
0.32579052448272705,
0.763947606086731,
0.3808484673500061,
-0.25290894508361816,
-0.04324554279446602,
-0.12793312966823578,
0.49225127696990967,
-0.13477468490600586,
-0.006689534522593021,
-0.8725866079330444,
0.2848013639450073,
0.6886053085327148,
0.8889915347099304,
-0.3362399935722351,
0.17862941324710846,
-0.040684375911951065,
0.35939863324165344,
-0.1052219495177269,
0.013682061806321144,
-0.2853311598300934,
-0.013403628021478653,
-0.5984050035476685,
-0.2362489402294159,
-0.0200872290879488,
-0.4961494505405426,
0.10579290241003036,
-0.7232722043991089,
0.213283509016037,
-0.46571436524391174,
0.7198125720024109,
0.28743425011634827,
0.08322729915380478,
-0.4793694019317627,
-0.39414727687835693,
0.7429124116897583,
-0.7059630155563354,
0.3474086821079254,
0.7367700934410095,
0.41946670413017273,
-0.25576260685920715,
-0.5940945148468018,
-0.3303390145301819,
-0.897589921951294,
-0.09930088371038437,
0.2262044996023178,
0.13129922747612,
0.2002929002046585,
-0.0005085329175926745,
0.4915824830532074,
-1.0269153118133545,
0.09183865785598755,
-0.4254378378391266,
-0.7437773942947388,
0.6325258612632751,
0.13560563325881958,
0.5684249997138977,
-0.20788513123989105,
-0.10353410243988037,
0.0357043519616127,
0.01219150796532631,
0.06643084436655045,
0.5472270846366882,
0.6325846910476685,
-0.06121901422739029,
0.28357037901878357,
0.14028623700141907,
0.5029231905937195,
-0.08865663409233093,
-0.8401040434837341,
0.6032043099403381,
-0.36683085560798645,
-0.05327782407402992,
-0.0498102568089962,
0.537765622138977,
-0.0469934418797493,
0.21879848837852478,
-0.3698887825012207,
-0.08049221336841583,
0.08713354170322418,
0.41887280344963074,
-0.25855863094329834,
-0.4801163375377655,
0.2792072296142578,
-0.12894900143146515,
-0.29081910848617554,
-0.2517640292644501,
-0.7655302882194519,
-0.5453385710716248,
-0.6594861149787903,
0.4753510355949402,
-0.6547567844390869,
-0.3502435088157654,
-0.3084355890750885,
-0.19827960431575775,
-0.28167229890823364,
0.30727607011795044,
-0.7031105756759644,
0.48059216141700745,
0.5711755156517029,
0.8065322637557983,
-0.14430642127990723,
-0.2346055805683136,
-0.6841108202934265,
-0.25484374165534973,
-0.27063673734664917,
0.6758273243904114,
-0.8249626159667969,
-0.2538678050041199,
-0.22678659856319427,
-0.22604058682918549,
-0.31941545009613037,
-0.7341443300247192,
0.8957425951957703,
0.003017488168552518,
-0.12374068796634674,
0.07995565235614777,
-0.5521193146705627,
-0.08940931409597397,
-0.11954012513160706,
-0.6146506667137146,
0.8709211349487305,
0.5815873146057129,
-0.5509976744651794,
0.41734495759010315,
-0.5777063369750977,
-0.688493013381958,
0.5091680288314819,
-0.26861825585365295,
-0.3103417158126831,
-0.0674889013171196,
-0.23516620695590973,
0.44278568029403687,
-0.024211779236793518,
0.5982350707054138,
-0.00857624039053917,
-0.27361881732940674,
0.6665999889373779,
-0.0027354268822818995,
0.6311107277870178,
0.17681676149368286,
-0.20493052899837494,
0.20233741402626038,
-1.0723955631256104,
0.099572092294693,
-0.607789933681488,
-0.27938053011894226,
-0.0819670706987381,
-0.3520807921886444,
0.11442247033119202,
0.014907127246260643,
0.013514525257050991,
-0.4130813181400299,
-0.17839282751083374,
-0.2788245677947998,
0.5338490605354309,
0.2545604407787323,
0.13657203316688538,
0.07654725760221481,
-0.3706897795200348,
0.6383957862854004,
0.18835878372192383,
0.2511065900325775,
0.12573480606079102,
-0.5805846452713013,
-0.5140924453735352,
-0.8156275749206543,
0.6030319929122925,
0.5822986960411072,
-0.1424349993467331,
0.5452353358268738,
-0.013974652625620365,
-0.7234474420547485,
-0.6507073044776917,
0.14698676764965057,
0.6382659077644348,
0.835026204586029,
0.6378529071807861,
-0.6020012497901917,
-0.5146808624267578,
-0.7342115640640259,
0.002372679067775607,
-0.11694589257240295,
-0.061605870723724365,
0.12115433812141418,
0.47629308700561523,
0.014462071470916271,
0.5891380310058594,
0.08217183500528336,
-0.978336751461029,
-0.05730757862329483,
0.4230031967163086,
0.19699536263942719,
0.6702865362167358,
0.11471910774707794,
-0.598903477191925,
-0.2831786274909973,
0.03557390347123146,
-0.1934649497270584,
-0.3751560151576996,
0.08839955180883408,
0.003115834901109338,
0.12121231108903885,
0.030815834179520607,
-0.37335488200187683,
0.4373125433921814,
0.5631042718887329,
-0.23681595921516418,
0.8080369830131531,
-0.0864679142832756,
0.4515566825866699,
-0.5687422752380371,
0.23727932572364807,
0.15106670558452606,
-0.0821760818362236,
-0.8452773094177246,
-0.2635134756565094,
-0.22566087543964386,
0.022576216608285904,
-0.09966741502285004,
0.03199901059269905,
0.0978124663233757,
-0.08555428683757782,
0.1725824773311615,
0.5637218356132507,
0.18211796879768372,
0.13466009497642517,
0.06621184200048447,
0.79185950756073,
0.6839858889579773,
-0.532394528388977,
0.32916709780693054,
0.17505694925785065,
-0.10066776722669601,
0.844508707523346,
-0.47295835614204407,
-0.042114920914173126,
0.23693221807479858,
0.16597871482372284,
-1.1837033033370972,
-0.4562806487083435,
0.1500556468963623,
-0.9103215336799622,
0.6582569479942322,
0.007285518571734428,
-0.23140494525432587,
-0.14966212213039398,
-0.16848863661289215,
0.1063828095793724,
0.36346954107284546,
0.12038739025592804,
0.22470299899578094,
0.9458070397377014,
-0.27952301502227783,
-0.447780966758728,
-0.7142734527587891,
0.04658466577529907,
-0.389861136674881,
-0.7351075410842896,
0.39568614959716797,
0.1776576191186905,
-0.3332034945487976,
-0.40462252497673035,
-0.030176576226949692,
-0.44936510920524597,
0.18267938494682312,
0.25084906816482544,
-0.03055529296398163,
-0.14811362326145172,
0.32976603507995605,
-0.22590859234333038,
-0.2525603175163269,
-0.20109783113002777,
0.1540604829788208,
0.2849891781806946,
-0.11036305874586105,
0.017188500612974167,
-0.6682010293006897,
0.013934330083429813,
0.37737134099006653,
-0.149178147315979,
-0.07241741567850113,
0.7030635476112366,
-0.28755614161491394,
-0.0296259056776762,
-0.5318020582199097,
-0.08351343125104904,
-0.3222186863422394,
0.3439754843711853,
-0.4122239947319031,
-0.5000750422477722,
0.8487992286682129,
0.15638045966625214,
-0.3583463728427887,
0.1702674925327301,
0.5358723402023315,
-0.3242875933647156,
0.7185823917388916,
0.20524032413959503,
0.35202455520629883,
0.2171345055103302,
-0.1193043515086174,
0.0018544275080785155,
-0.9190928936004639,
-0.21492545306682587,
-0.7677870988845825,
-0.19907644391059875,
-0.5561575293540955,
-0.7164502739906311,
0.11792312562465668,
0.04837814345955849,
-0.10666172206401825,
0.39889949560165405,
-0.9200922846794128,
-0.003447576193138957,
0.2208157628774643,
0.0623665489256382,
0.26290997862815857,
-0.21067574620246887,
-0.2226536124944687,
-0.5366668701171875,
-0.23173990845680237,
-0.8384734988212585,
0.9796746373176575,
0.7062371969223022,
0.49249550700187683,
0.18425415456295013,
0.6303927302360535,
0.5424437522888184,
0.46782568097114563,
-0.7422884106636047,
0.5097803473472595,
-0.30157625675201416,
-0.9318703413009644,
-0.6351777911186218,
-0.47187304496765137,
-0.832362711429596,
0.2345636785030365,
-0.017029281705617905,
-1.2156668901443481,
0.29672080278396606,
0.07544450461864471,
-0.5246111154556274,
-0.16675534844398499,
-0.478620707988739,
0.8995777368545532,
-0.3859844207763672,
-0.18280470371246338,
-0.11932842433452606,
-0.7636472582817078,
0.4029848277568817,
-0.16810031235218048,
0.28045031428337097,
-0.4502693712711334,
-0.04406800493597984,
0.99824458360672,
-0.1978379338979721,
0.5957770347595215,
-0.2628294825553894,
0.0031585032120347023,
0.16284091770648956,
0.2509746253490448,
-0.183335542678833,
0.10359854251146317,
-0.21491731703281403,
0.3145439326763153,
0.3244161903858185,
-0.06506325304508209,
-0.38697806000709534,
0.4161214828491211,
-0.7114932537078857,
-0.3639492690563202,
-0.4772352874279022,
-0.4276137053966522,
-0.4999232590198517,
-0.05036977306008339,
-0.08708620071411133,
0.49304577708244324,
-0.4104425609111786,
0.030347511172294617,
0.5310639142990112,
-0.20315031707286835,
-0.026842661201953888,
0.47206827998161316,
-0.10327671468257904,
-0.5885809659957886,
1.329303503036499,
0.4814489781856537,
0.08232396841049194,
0.228095144033432,
0.34700295329093933,
-0.4348500669002533,
-0.850067675113678,
-0.3350028097629547,
0.1857253611087799,
-0.771528422832489,
-0.27444562315940857,
-0.3411595821380615,
-0.17138166725635529,
-0.6000370979309082,
0.2825542390346527,
-0.15870842337608337,
-0.5077117681503296,
-0.41145503520965576,
-0.02942085638642311,
0.2247663140296936,
0.43473970890045166,
-0.39037689566612244,
0.12510141730308533,
-0.4519089460372925,
0.446850448846817,
-0.0836540013551712,
0.20057974755764008,
-0.34176361560821533,
-1.052388072013855,
-0.046161044389009476,
0.0018754396587610245,
-0.5004905462265015,
-0.923590362071991,
0.606158971786499,
0.34867677092552185,
0.6507178544998169,
0.16116391122341156,
0.020505385473370552,
0.8742482662200928,
-0.06305133551359177,
0.8194739818572998,
0.21345186233520508,
-1.099014401435852,
0.6997768878936768,
-0.08724786341190338,
-0.2716817259788513,
0.8382890224456787,
0.3125934302806854,
-0.3735373914241791,
-0.9453561305999756,
-0.8015385270118713,
-0.7815908789634705,
0.5655370950698853,
0.2724767029285431,
-0.2651982009410858,
-0.024538449943065643,
-0.006623541470617056,
0.30688992142677307,
-0.024322040379047394,
-0.2700630724430084,
-0.08497264236211777,
-0.3648395538330078,
-0.16132450103759766,
-0.1324438601732254,
0.05624201521277428,
-0.6677680611610413,
-0.4525149464607239,
0.6400501132011414,
-0.05125861242413521,
-0.06713753938674927,
0.4228054881095886,
-0.36569902300834656,
-0.04343266040086746,
0.4804885685443878,
0.7705981135368347,
1.0871919393539429,
-0.385487824678421,
-0.029258759692311287,
0.12743546068668365,
-0.9592695236206055,
0.20348858833312988,
0.3934076428413391,
0.0642457827925682,
0.30169206857681274,
0.40342822670936584,
0.3820132315158844,
0.111232228577137,
-0.692231297492981,
0.7058218121528625,
-0.046834129840135574,
-0.24957291781902313,
-0.4264104962348938,
0.03168598189949989,
-0.05898372083902359,
0.0529877208173275,
0.43631088733673096,
-0.059866223484277725,
0.43535280227661133,
-0.3313841223716736,
0.28507092595100403,
0.3146137297153473,
-0.505639374256134,
-0.22024855017662048,
0.22250650823116302,
0.3709586262702942,
-0.5126725435256958,
0.2823856770992279,
-0.2159825712442398,
-0.2846473455429077,
0.5177264213562012,
0.20868784189224243,
0.7050879001617432,
-0.36790895462036133,
0.6370686292648315,
0.16659660637378693,
0.2011336237192154,
0.4291325509548187,
0.3648999333381653,
-0.13137948513031006,
-0.24056340754032135,
-0.5276318788528442,
-0.9411224722862244,
-0.5971203446388245,
0.39559584856033325,
-0.6047784686088562,
0.15984800457954407,
-0.44305992126464844,
-0.4926324486732483,
0.5880210995674133,
0.3639645278453827,
-0.42763790488243103,
0.657230794429779,
0.2722254693508148,
0.5570986866950989,
-0.6826472878456116,
0.8636894226074219,
0.7957804203033447,
-0.7472512722015381,
-1.05449378490448,
-0.11272580921649933,
0.05555673688650131,
-0.7671089172363281,
0.9893539547920227,
0.058494336903095245,
-0.06546375900506973,
-0.24436883628368378,
0.09596910327672958,
-0.7830992937088013,
0.897455096244812,
0.29706260561943054,
-0.4821161925792694,
0.46272265911102295,
0.25302016735076904,
0.9631836414337158,
-0.2675550580024719,
0.699950098991394,
1.0588566064834595,
0.8099543452262878,
-0.038268595933914185,
-1.4568320512771606,
0.1032479852437973,
0.0768541544675827,
-0.03344390168786049,
-0.2504529654979706,
-0.10475972294807434,
0.62602299451828,
-0.23360058665275574,
-0.5081947445869446,
0.29865625500679016,
0.17572645843029022,
0.34181472659111023,
0.48281848430633545,
0.1880926936864853,
0.6082322597503662,
1.122346043586731,
-0.2945769727230072,
0.4460723400115967,
-0.13666711747646332,
0.14023086428642273,
0.7686471343040466,
-0.12687629461288452,
0.6730177998542786,
0.3741934597492218,
-0.3786713480949402,
0.37766554951667786,
0.586885392665863,
0.18427011370658875,
0.15666887164115906,
0.6800637245178223,
0.09501824527978897,
-0.16347230970859528,
-0.20926761627197266,
-0.4890822768211365,
0.45155951380729675,
0.7579365968704224,
-0.28225189447402954,
-0.026117905974388123,
-0.02240959368646145,
0.07393358647823334,
0.3590705692768097,
-0.1752375215291977,
0.674296498298645,
-0.057352568954229355,
-0.6295599937438965,
0.6406774520874023,
-0.36352282762527466,
0.380445271730423,
-0.32404008507728577,
-0.09109082072973251,
-0.29212573170661926,
0.1545097827911377,
-0.6658016443252563,
-0.9893912672996521,
0.3745408058166504,
-0.19382107257843018,
0.09009484946727753,
0.025630971416831017,
0.40982332825660706,
-0.4171745777130127,
-0.3673195242881775,
0.09533442556858063,
0.3115380108356476,
0.7006196975708008,
0.30688345432281494,
-0.7648328542709351,
0.28190910816192627,
-0.2756315767765045,
-0.16454125940799713,
0.23508696258068085,
0.31355005502700806,
0.0447603277862072,
0.6128439903259277,
0.5150031447410583,
0.2963643968105316,
-0.21595977246761322,
0.5724018812179565,
0.7084102630615234,
-0.5326495170593262,
-0.2892579734325409,
-0.4316633939743042,
0.7632203698158264,
-0.08375808596611023,
-0.7048999667167664,
0.5628286004066467,
0.11731484532356262,
0.39534643292427063,
0.3275958299636841,
0.48904240131378174,
-0.023628246039152145,
1.0505242347717285,
-0.20557071268558502,
0.5223361849784851,
-0.27869394421577454,
0.24121539294719696,
-0.6089574098587036,
-0.5717113018035889,
-0.7070944309234619,
1.0426814556121826,
-0.4663509130477905,
-0.0026809603441506624,
0.7564092874526978,
0.9497062563896179,
0.17821022868156433,
0.1825985163450241,
0.5698195695877075,
0.18232686817646027,
0.1876060515642166,
0.36016398668289185,
1.0087807178497314,
-0.12085715681314468,
0.5812028050422668,
-0.29830801486968994,
-0.6377516388893127,
-0.38147661089897156,
-0.6079663634300232,
-0.6111769080162048,
-0.6836065053939819,
-0.6232808828353882,
-0.601962149143219,
0.4066075086593628,
0.5177109241485596,
0.7409146428108215,
-0.8406087160110474,
-0.23614341020584106,
-0.030966714024543762,
0.14342068135738373,
-0.43995773792266846,
-0.32237502932548523,
0.40481457114219666,
-0.674426794052124,
-0.29611435532569885,
0.43276476860046387,
0.3621026873588562,
-0.0807960107922554,
-0.44289934635162354,
-0.08847332000732422,
0.01656559482216835,
-0.11013322323560715,
0.1558813452720642,
0.33804652094841003,
-0.792385995388031,
-0.1419178992509842,
-0.29403653740882874,
-0.28801724314689636,
0.1555420309305191,
0.6534478068351746,
-0.6238009333610535,
0.4040294885635376,
0.4293331801891327,
0.12434839457273483,
0.010680983774363995,
0.2082270085811615,
0.26306506991386414,
-0.6472852826118469,
-0.08111991733312607,
1.166943907737732,
0.06034557893872261,
0.6100980639457703,
-0.08909393846988678,
0.39393025636672974,
0.06983394920825958,
-0.7953925132751465,
-1.0763605833053589,
-0.059642575681209564,
-1.1536190509796143,
-0.06550995260477066,
1.0648022890090942,
-0.43969613313674927,
0.0032798792235553265,
-0.6639339923858643,
-0.36062249541282654,
0.27828100323677063,
-0.4852159023284912,
0.7115460634231567,
0.5639514327049255,
-0.5694520473480225,
0.14825837314128876,
-0.5884116888046265,
0.7766415476799011,
0.4038297235965729,
-0.441828191280365,
0.02260417304933071,
0.5325000882148743,
0.2922585606575012,
0.6826956272125244,
0.5726279616355896,
-0.36289340257644653,
0.4331981837749481,
0.04459841176867485,
-0.044357869774103165,
0.17208485305309296,
-0.36431753635406494,
-0.3712500333786011,
0.0948147103190422,
-0.004207415971904993,
-0.16360005736351013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18848v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18848v3
|
FeDeRA:Efficient Fine-tuning of Language Models in Federated Learning Leveraging Weight Decomposition
| 2024-04-29T16:42:26 | 2024-05-25T06:55:19 |
Yuxuan Yan, Qianqian Yang, Shunpu Tang, Zhiguo Shi
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Despite their exceptional performance on various tasks after fine-tuning,
pre-trained language models (PLMs) face significant challenges due to growing
privacy concerns with data in centralized training methods. We consider
federated learning (FL) to fine-tune PLMs in this paper. However, the
substantial number of parameters in PLMs poses significant difficulties for
client devices with limited communication and computational resources. One
promising solution is to exploit parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) into
FL, which trains a much smaller set of parameters than full parameter
fine-tuning (FFT). Although remarkably improving training efficiency, PEFT
methods may lead to degraded performance especially when data across different
clients are non i.i.d, as revealed by experimental results. To overcome this,
we propose FeDeRA, which extends and improves a widely used PEFT method, i.e.,
low-rank adaption (LoRA). FeDeRA follows LoRA by decomposing the weight
matrices of the PLMs into low-rank matrices, which allows for more efficient
computation and parameter updates during fine-tuning. Different from LoRA which
simply initializes these low-rank matrices by random sampling or zeros, the
proposed FeDeRA initializes these matrices by the results of performing
singular value decomposition (SVD) on the pre-trained weight matrices.
Extensive experiments across various tasks and datasets show that FeDeRA
outperforms the considered PEFT baselines and is comparable to or even
surpasses FFT method within the FL setting in terms of task performance.
Moreover, FeDeRA requires only 1% trainable paramentes compared to FFT,
significantly reducing training time costs by more than 90% to achieve the same
task performance level. The experimental results also highlight the robustness
of FeDeRA against data heterogeneity, as it maintains stable task performance
even as data heterogeneity increases.
|
[
-0.5043465495109558,
-0.7095182538032532,
0.23412731289863586,
0.2513314485549927,
-0.17640678584575653,
0.08349897712469101,
-0.3543986976146698,
-0.20642369985580444,
-0.14282818138599396,
0.4112115502357483,
-0.6183735728263855,
-0.3528803586959839,
-0.4712942838668823,
0.06427779048681259,
-0.2709295451641083,
1.103723406791687,
-0.052983202040195465,
-0.03467849642038345,
-0.3243522644042969,
-0.41646066308021545,
-0.124577097594738,
-0.25700706243515015,
-0.5285406112670898,
-0.4373634159564972,
0.5292350053787231,
0.5851246118545532,
0.34758350253105164,
0.5276448726654053,
0.688267707824707,
0.35616883635520935,
0.14051683247089386,
0.17733757197856903,
-0.8709805011749268,
0.21161580085754395,
-0.23534570634365082,
-0.6240615248680115,
-0.6023142337799072,
0.25000274181365967,
0.8768416047096252,
0.9685194492340088,
-0.1461881846189499,
0.4543036222457886,
0.14327724277973175,
0.766539454460144,
-0.7682009935379028,
0.38471701741218567,
-0.4850609600543976,
0.12906333804130554,
-0.4116727113723755,
-0.3364708721637726,
-0.46324822306632996,
-0.11934619396924973,
0.05080290883779526,
-0.5797239542007446,
0.2508019804954529,
0.15041594207286835,
0.8315142393112183,
0.540928840637207,
0.05568103864789009,
0.30303022265434265,
-0.9962156414985657,
0.7547345161437988,
-0.40769636631011963,
0.4740263819694519,
0.17942140996456146,
0.3213650584220886,
-0.14975227415561676,
-0.6957429647445679,
-0.26789402961730957,
0.18349754810333252,
-0.14680172502994537,
-0.18128161132335663,
-0.42932915687561035,
0.16795554757118225,
0.34732291102409363,
0.7279658317565918,
-0.3834820091724396,
0.3372034430503845,
-0.040755100548267365,
-0.011175141669809818,
0.47216707468032837,
-0.02642945758998394,
-0.05313250049948692,
0.3855031132698059,
-0.25478318333625793,
-0.316948264837265,
-0.7442035675048828,
0.24093177914619446,
0.5137392282485962,
0.7483212947845459,
0.044404078274965286,
0.31974920630455017,
-0.5197604298591614,
0.6714378595352173,
0.5607296824455261,
-0.38033294677734375,
0.3142487406730652,
-0.09304717183113098,
-0.5892785787582397,
-0.2846631705760956,
0.5854604244232178,
-0.12199655175209045,
-0.021196657791733742,
-0.3997538983821869,
-0.41103944182395935,
-0.07631842792034149,
0.04815307632088661,
-0.9316366910934448,
-0.20058517158031464,
-0.003208640730008483,
-0.5155375003814697,
-0.27200207114219666,
0.04317018762230873,
-0.468038946390152,
-0.10657433420419693,
-0.26011407375335693,
0.5251150727272034,
-0.344179630279541,
-0.16015417873859406,
-0.001560312695801258,
0.3045161962509155,
0.2767386734485626,
0.44171175360679626,
-1.0313597917556763,
0.6133997440338135,
0.983211874961853,
0.6364791393280029,
-0.09308052062988281,
-0.38030755519866943,
-1.3121166229248047,
-0.28059664368629456,
0.08071029186248779,
0.7434306144714355,
-0.37661346793174744,
0.015537717379629612,
-0.2867732644081116,
0.14106041193008423,
-0.4374244511127472,
-0.40521717071533203,
0.3780207931995392,
-0.41064468026161194,
0.5005858540534973,
-0.288489431142807,
-0.5345430970191956,
-0.09035240113735199,
0.16095231473445892,
-0.5267400741577148,
0.6980756521224976,
0.41789963841438293,
-0.7799310088157654,
0.37981510162353516,
-0.7950098514556885,
-0.5750650763511658,
0.10912743955850601,
0.04672450199723244,
-0.7512328624725342,
0.21327035129070282,
0.294109046459198,
0.6809840202331543,
-0.3937838077545166,
0.14097724854946136,
-0.3775120973587036,
-0.6336897015571594,
-0.3924601674079895,
-0.11375591903924942,
0.6357030868530273,
0.33260923624038696,
-0.4686623811721802,
0.15754082798957825,
-0.7615673542022705,
0.011220915243029594,
0.13033394515514374,
-0.31274905800819397,
-0.5076211094856262,
0.13227900862693787,
-0.03410567343235016,
0.06547655910253525,
0.13229946792125702,
-0.6007695198059082,
0.11290527880191803,
-0.8366255164146423,
0.21112406253814697,
0.7916046977043152,
-0.22670450806617737,
0.731827437877655,
-0.45729219913482666,
0.6055989861488342,
-0.11552552133798599,
0.21144931018352509,
0.06571724265813828,
-0.003341491799801588,
-0.800350546836853,
-0.2848028540611267,
0.3644924759864807,
0.22281871736049652,
-0.7083112597465515,
0.27828094363212585,
-0.3849692642688751,
-0.5178065299987793,
-0.6080248951911926,
0.28199779987335205,
0.47367632389068604,
0.6483961939811707,
0.2602454125881195,
-0.06918749213218689,
-0.3490893542766571,
-0.7481762170791626,
-0.24340938031673431,
-0.0578816682100296,
-0.10097645223140717,
0.2481127381324768,
0.29995670914649963,
-0.10717449337244034,
0.9070711731910706,
-0.327717661857605,
-0.5392979383468628,
-0.05857931450009346,
0.22817453742027283,
0.09857934713363647,
0.6212157607078552,
0.8745914697647095,
-0.5931812524795532,
-0.6047356724739075,
0.11514554172754288,
-0.25947481393814087,
-0.17043542861938477,
0.08205411583185196,
0.14548011124134064,
0.35000669956207275,
0.053174201399087906,
-0.029176773503422737,
-0.042673829942941666,
0.7914485931396484,
-0.41664206981658936,
0.230048269033432,
-0.25285011529922485,
-0.023205971345305443,
-0.8275095224380493,
0.31761252880096436,
-0.09317313134670258,
-0.3999820351600647,
-0.4421658515930176,
0.23410148918628693,
-0.2276047021150589,
-0.1815250813961029,
-0.2640955150127411,
0.24976518750190735,
-0.3436425030231476,
-0.21275155246257782,
-0.2921178340911865,
-0.28617388010025024,
-0.10056660324335098,
0.6471853256225586,
-0.1747230738401413,
0.9198278784751892,
0.5901724696159363,
-0.18259583413600922,
0.05271078646183014,
0.2147723287343979,
-0.1383654773235321,
0.8213814496994019,
-0.5807983875274658,
-0.009650124236941338,
-0.10846658051013947,
0.10323859006166458,
-0.6980394124984741,
-0.14049218595027924,
0.196365624666214,
0.0060080490075051785,
0.17442499101161957,
-0.16663877665996552,
-0.691344141960144,
-0.08867910504341125,
-0.23901516199111938,
0.10706206411123276,
0.4845219552516937,
-0.7157310247421265,
0.5965829491615295,
0.42028895020484924,
-0.01403079368174076,
-0.5727276802062988,
-0.3785572946071625,
-0.5300406217575073,
-0.2544177770614624,
-0.6798162460327148,
0.3026449382305145,
-0.1397797167301178,
-0.2515585124492645,
-0.2586481273174286,
-0.2826010584831238,
-0.015365163795650005,
0.42823526263237,
0.45834577083587646,
-0.11108249425888062,
-0.4183380603790283,
0.09656938165426254,
0.36667197942733765,
-0.13737210631370544,
-0.07045434415340424,
-0.1650494635105133,
0.5486281514167786,
-0.7001657485961914,
-0.30383989214897156,
-0.3133189380168915,
0.2763317823410034,
0.6708856821060181,
-0.49987396597862244,
0.9847868084907532,
0.8908141255378723,
-0.2639380693435669,
-0.45469918847084045,
-0.47879692912101746,
-0.2304118275642395,
-0.4867490530014038,
-0.14254309237003326,
-0.3937535881996155,
-1.2281262874603271,
0.6595017313957214,
-0.2849707007408142,
0.3087504506111145,
0.32156869769096375,
0.41054481267929077,
-0.2598881721496582,
0.9313023686408997,
1.0884418487548828,
-0.2523823380470276,
0.7580785751342773,
-0.30531400442123413,
0.025231987237930298,
-0.44419369101524353,
0.02169802226126194,
-0.556282103061676,
-0.574988842010498,
-0.6137088537216187,
-0.31775620579719543,
0.2905949652194977,
-0.17081798613071442,
-0.2942376732826233,
0.2563941478729248,
-0.4083462357521057,
0.4729965627193451,
0.5192737579345703,
0.07150335609912872,
0.3860282599925995,
0.17360244691371918,
-0.067652128636837,
0.18175242841243744,
-0.7980886101722717,
0.04333307221531868,
0.9573158621788025,
0.441288560628891,
0.8119614124298096,
-0.22669881582260132,
0.9114435315132141,
0.11620574444532394,
0.3880957365036011,
-0.6206573843955994,
0.3206632137298584,
-0.3800242245197296,
-0.2092849761247635,
-0.2676376402378082,
-0.6626575589179993,
-0.7428349256515503,
0.36930519342422485,
-0.33234918117523193,
-0.5929825305938721,
0.4184468686580658,
0.19378013908863068,
-0.5796816945075989,
0.27890655398368835,
-0.728947639465332,
0.7016343474388123,
0.021603669971227646,
-0.46680426597595215,
-0.2168997973203659,
-0.5930382609367371,
0.2721295952796936,
-0.14957104623317719,
-0.13098132610321045,
-0.1825307458639145,
0.23829694092273712,
0.9370372295379639,
-0.7671740055084229,
0.6638901233673096,
-0.5188084840774536,
-0.1425701230764389,
-0.23537993431091309,
-0.2679564654827118,
0.6495411396026611,
0.11516288667917252,
-0.1311226636171341,
0.025270799174904823,
0.05735630914568901,
-0.49080154299736023,
-0.47832366824150085,
0.9409315586090088,
-0.8781083822250366,
-0.3575127422809601,
-0.30841264128685,
-0.7381781935691833,
-0.4488438665866852,
0.36504459381103516,
0.04736379534006119,
0.3237636983394623,
-0.12061810493469238,
0.5430546998977661,
0.742764413356781,
0.10786045342683792,
0.39888641238212585,
0.8414852023124695,
0.05502515658736229,
-0.20839343965053558,
0.7595872282981873,
0.03722866624593735,
0.13136190176010132,
0.5372318029403687,
0.0983758270740509,
0.061702415347099304,
-0.7312646508216858,
0.1387643665075302,
0.3515384793281555,
-0.3575284481048584,
-0.4292283058166504,
-0.3927055299282074,
0.04585954546928406,
-0.20261387526988983,
-0.315104216337204,
-0.832624614238739,
-0.21127648651599884,
-0.32855483889579773,
0.08333687484264374,
0.35520318150520325,
0.116401307284832,
0.01872331276535988,
0.7738695740699768,
-0.3877381682395935,
0.09619734436273575,
0.23919470608234406,
0.8358198404312134,
-0.3385978937149048,
-0.1826617568731308,
-0.2876410186290741,
0.12003205716609955,
0.0708460584282875,
-0.18416015803813934,
0.2789801359176636,
0.4752812087535858,
0.5398469567298889,
0.5558595061302185,
0.34530967473983765,
0.8791802525520325,
-0.19358521699905396,
0.18499797582626343,
-0.18398897349834442,
-0.8715190291404724,
0.4427526593208313,
-0.5243631601333618,
0.29146960377693176,
0.9764294624328613,
0.12006363272666931,
-0.07318630814552307,
-0.4215068221092224,
-0.6745184063911438,
-0.5253770351409912,
1.0937389135360718,
0.27189144492149353,
-0.20152826607227325,
0.5181201100349426,
0.19152261316776276,
0.299718976020813,
0.12732237577438354,
-0.4962608516216278,
-0.3526366651058197,
0.009168766438961029,
0.06803755462169647,
-0.20674386620521545,
0.07541990280151367,
-0.21688522398471832,
-0.5943326354026794,
0.5960042476654053,
-0.43983879685401917,
0.25771811604499817,
-0.18288952112197876,
-0.23830915987491608,
-0.6035482287406921,
0.15306201577186584,
0.5138835906982422,
0.5667188763618469,
-0.3812513053417206,
-0.07672029733657837,
0.013769480399787426,
-0.32275959849357605,
-0.018322361633181572,
0.6659815311431885,
-0.20735269784927368,
-0.14734110236167908,
0.17389488220214844,
0.9365063905715942,
0.5202912092208862,
-0.5799432992935181,
0.37906962633132935,
-0.2806928753852844,
-0.2937943935394287,
-0.009234772995114326,
0.3558383285999298,
-0.23205219209194183,
0.338312029838562,
0.3685850501060486,
0.37064582109451294,
-0.24236620962619781,
-0.34355053305625916,
0.30644047260284424,
0.4919028580188751,
-0.10347751528024673,
-0.5048604011535645,
0.6523739695549011,
0.34855934977531433,
-0.08087180554866791,
0.4168339967727661,
-0.058654312044382095,
-0.15693782269954681,
0.17956189811229706,
0.34321802854537964,
0.7178941369056702,
-0.4020504951477051,
0.34724774956703186,
0.045146871358156204,
0.24857865273952484,
-0.26174917817115784,
0.30048415064811707,
-0.37189874053001404,
-0.5263344645500183,
-0.4758338928222656,
-0.9475408792495728,
-0.33315274119377136,
0.19684693217277527,
-0.768089771270752,
0.07573676109313965,
-0.6832113265991211,
0.08405878394842148,
-0.07724203914403915,
0.5304079055786133,
-0.7920509576797485,
-0.12479201704263687,
0.13309356570243835,
0.8560737371444702,
-1.0938762426376343,
1.0728522539138794,
0.6413522958755493,
-0.20578983426094055,
-0.8569453954696655,
-0.13224419951438904,
-0.27995386719703674,
-0.5511087775230408,
0.272186815738678,
-0.047197941690683365,
0.009109619073569775,
0.3299383521080017,
-0.37601158022880554,
-0.8193209767341614,
1.2464655637741089,
0.8217579126358032,
-0.5061606168746948,
-0.15698878467082977,
0.2735414505004883,
0.6706680655479431,
-0.4305625259876251,
-0.12701565027236938,
0.6805049777030945,
0.5239281058311462,
0.013382505625486374,
-1.093132734298706,
-0.031643614172935486,
-0.1704544723033905,
-0.13677924871444702,
0.28742629289627075,
-0.7039825916290283,
1.1153699159622192,
0.1082887202501297,
-0.26425719261169434,
-0.129257932305336,
0.6890807151794434,
-0.08351040631532669,
0.28390347957611084,
0.672741711139679,
0.5287790298461914,
0.8652852177619934,
-0.22089563310146332,
0.7808400988578796,
-0.18112437427043915,
0.6755214929580688,
1.0981872081756592,
-0.3341219425201416,
0.6976591348648071,
0.5873516798019409,
-0.10676652193069458,
0.4569706320762634,
0.2796679139137268,
-0.0552084855735302,
0.5680555701255798,
-0.22631964087486267,
-0.07697727531194687,
-0.24029338359832764,
0.11960349977016449,
-0.236501082777977,
0.8839735984802246,
0.20668925344944,
-0.5137678980827332,
-0.7445805072784424,
0.43504875898361206,
-0.013456614688038826,
0.16485829651355743,
-0.44236913323402405,
0.7463130354881287,
-0.1378282755613327,
-0.5318465828895569,
0.8287206888198853,
0.13908083736896515,
0.7066577672958374,
-0.5825201869010925,
0.2668251395225525,
-0.41073018312454224,
0.5488682389259338,
-0.18188205361366272,
-0.1005416139960289,
0.39814770221710205,
-0.009995738975703716,
-0.2709272801876068,
-0.7554861903190613,
0.7336516380310059,
-0.41706833243370056,
-0.3341977000236511,
0.05250341445207596,
0.6332841515541077,
-0.29082855582237244,
-0.25043684244155884,
-0.5965562462806702,
0.13209369778633118,
-0.23555117845535278,
-0.3167218565940857,
0.7172514796257019,
-0.044241175055503845,
0.07809580862522125,
0.6441259980201721,
0.6277142763137817,
-0.08139683306217194,
-0.23675231635570526,
-0.22931593656539917,
1.0403938293457031,
-0.07760239392518997,
-0.6513185501098633,
-0.5764176249504089,
0.18721932172775269,
0.14805001020431519,
-0.10528045892715454,
0.8240522742271423,
0.42532649636268616,
0.9663507342338562,
-0.12454121559858322,
0.35574251413345337,
-0.13132047653198242,
0.5067765116691589,
-0.1840759515762329,
1.160943627357483,
-0.5267274975776672,
0.20340953767299652,
-0.3851687014102936,
-0.7536935210227966,
-0.33498576283454895,
0.5893537402153015,
-0.47948235273361206,
-0.3097497820854187,
0.4500660002231598,
0.5169395804405212,
-0.34592369198799133,
0.05538133904337883,
0.18263965845108032,
0.06534559279680252,
0.27135777473449707,
0.5800438523292542,
0.09485611319541931,
-0.4521133601665497,
0.3293270170688629,
-0.7168192267417908,
-0.12397507578134537,
-0.4464257061481476,
-0.6179234385490417,
-0.8887366056442261,
-0.7366402745246887,
-0.3358519971370697,
0.21493200957775116,
0.08359846472740173,
0.8159018754959106,
0.8955031037330627,
-0.9082690477371216,
-0.0364978052675724,
-0.12467257678508759,
0.21390756964683533,
-0.6575911045074463,
-0.23176957666873932,
0.23067764937877655,
-0.32772329449653625,
-0.8422788381576538,
0.5131699442863464,
0.13629823923110962,
-0.13984674215316772,
-0.43319544196128845,
-0.1642906665802002,
-0.10973118990659714,
-0.2715539038181305,
0.5629187822341919,
0.4210364520549774,
-0.42596858739852905,
-0.37476661801338196,
-0.09505300968885422,
0.09353949129581451,
0.015556282363831997,
0.704489529132843,
-1.0881931781768799,
0.3212239444255829,
0.6174406409263611,
0.6932581663131714,
0.37202510237693787,
0.23210816085338593,
0.7030860185623169,
-1.0919939279556274,
0.3411772847175598,
0.3477177321910858,
0.38096678256988525,
0.11894431710243225,
-0.32063084840774536,
0.43694278597831726,
0.20960304141044617,
-0.4767128825187683,
-1.169914722442627,
-0.16210004687309265,
-1.0972177982330322,
0.014865183271467686,
0.6811292171478271,
-0.4186983108520508,
-0.371309757232666,
0.2613823115825653,
0.20631031692028046,
0.1634572297334671,
-0.24446538090705872,
0.7050615549087524,
0.3713720738887787,
-0.1067541316151619,
-0.30671679973602295,
0.0017326845554634929,
0.6245296001434326,
0.3863154947757721,
-0.8153092265129089,
0.11458338052034378,
0.4148164391517639,
0.4623751640319824,
-0.02388627454638481,
0.5815649628639221,
0.13265471160411835,
0.25610536336898804,
-0.27072155475616455,
-0.31144586205482483,
-0.5628609657287598,
-0.3584645688533783,
-0.45461663603782654,
0.6106199026107788,
-0.05534922331571579,
-0.16633957624435425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18832v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18832v1
|
It's Difficult to be Neutral -- Human and LLM-based Sentiment Annotation of Patient Comments
| 2024-04-29T16:19:47 | 2024-04-29T16:19:47 |
Petter Mæhlum, David Samuel, Rebecka Maria Norman, Elma Jelin, Øyvind Andresen Bjertnæs, Lilja Øvrelid, Erik Velldal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sentiment analysis is an important tool for aggregating patient voices, in
order to provide targeted improvements in healthcare services. A prerequisite
for this is the availability of in-domain data annotated for sentiment. This
article documents an effort to add sentiment annotations to free-text comments
in patient surveys collected by the Norwegian Institute of Public Health
(NIPH). However, annotation can be a time-consuming and resource-intensive
process, particularly when it requires domain expertise. We therefore also
evaluate a possible alternative to human annotation, using large language
models (LLMs) as annotators. We perform an extensive evaluation of the approach
for two openly available pretrained LLMs for Norwegian, experimenting with
different configurations of prompts and in-context learning, comparing their
performance to human annotators. We find that even for zero-shot runs, models
perform well above the baseline for binary sentiment, but still cannot compete
with human annotators on the full dataset.
|
[
-0.39455410838127136,
-0.21712249517440796,
0.6666145324707031,
0.09113869071006775,
-0.5750625133514404,
0.09752792119979858,
-0.37078940868377686,
-0.7015612721443176,
0.38530540466308594,
0.5330231785774231,
-0.4887144863605499,
-0.4532526731491089,
-0.7017860412597656,
0.4424728751182556,
0.1202830821275711,
1.2429637908935547,
0.015219142660498619,
0.614841639995575,
-0.29228973388671875,
-0.5264126658439636,
-0.09626929461956024,
-0.9811320900917053,
-0.46320095658302307,
-0.6057802438735962,
0.7516974806785583,
0.3614453077316284,
0.6821495890617371,
0.004837188869714737,
0.6187111735343933,
0.17125298082828522,
-0.17058002948760986,
-0.10735617578029633,
-0.32744601368904114,
0.17054150998592377,
-0.13670961558818817,
-0.2533307373523712,
-0.5562184453010559,
0.2320404052734375,
0.2824743688106537,
1.1494812965393066,
0.2712375819683075,
-0.08230328559875488,
-0.05316546931862831,
0.6612485647201538,
-0.32156655192375183,
0.08475113660097122,
-0.3201656937599182,
0.37277573347091675,
0.0012574292486533523,
0.01723306067287922,
-0.3441586494445801,
-0.4218652844429016,
0.4321468770503998,
-0.4626629948616028,
0.14313189685344696,
-0.2352573573589325,
0.825512707233429,
0.24573186039924622,
-0.32565754652023315,
-0.2948763072490692,
-0.6265217065811157,
1.0580381155014038,
-0.8295988440513611,
0.19250410795211792,
0.2576068639755249,
0.10043217986822128,
0.09562470763921738,
-0.2221754938364029,
-0.41479405760765076,
-0.438407838344574,
-0.1314522624015808,
0.0799938216805458,
0.047712694853544235,
0.22203010320663452,
0.2805284559726715,
0.1755416840314865,
-0.06276848912239075,
0.17864450812339783,
-0.06990518420934677,
-0.2471754401922226,
0.7628697752952576,
0.1135670617222786,
0.2702691853046417,
-0.501897394657135,
-0.496516615152359,
0.3899523913860321,
-0.6690468788146973,
-0.0892670676112175,
0.09686653316020966,
0.48694664239883423,
-0.21282516419887543,
0.6531128883361816,
-0.2665904760360718,
0.5423538088798523,
-0.18656039237976074,
-0.15010452270507812,
0.46205514669418335,
0.26810741424560547,
-0.12325353175401688,
-0.08496762067079544,
0.7851840257644653,
0.6966434717178345,
0.3830110728740692,
-0.35118362307548523,
-0.2969754636287689,
0.3740498423576355,
0.25104114413261414,
-0.9190164804458618,
-0.3563924729824066,
0.3199232518672943,
-0.5088289380073547,
-0.5460931658744812,
-0.07476414740085602,
-0.7973735928535461,
-0.6960408091545105,
-0.36553195118904114,
0.19007724523544312,
0.0033978749997913837,
-0.2359800934791565,
-0.0163304191082716,
-0.05310788005590439,
0.11725989729166031,
0.5517283082008362,
-0.5588067770004272,
0.34907907247543335,
0.5719336271286011,
0.8044533133506775,
-0.10411150753498077,
0.11302054673433304,
-0.3571566939353943,
-0.3279339373111725,
-0.3616439402103424,
0.7854946255683899,
-0.4799039959907532,
-0.6620740294456482,
-0.0822671577334404,
0.033444974571466446,
0.31333351135253906,
-0.6091378331184387,
0.5431188941001892,
-0.3933553397655487,
0.4615776836872101,
-0.6388182044029236,
-0.6575133204460144,
-0.2127508819103241,
0.3715992867946625,
-0.4937942326068878,
0.5613778829574585,
0.6221939325332642,
-0.9437237977981567,
0.2886449992656708,
-0.7352907061576843,
-0.3748093545436859,
0.30936309695243835,
-0.332454651594162,
-0.24625030159950256,
0.33730557560920715,
0.18295514583587646,
0.6765083074569702,
-0.4126022160053253,
0.32665953040122986,
-0.5755998492240906,
-0.2775697708129883,
0.5561648011207581,
-0.02870292402803898,
0.9257174730300903,
0.11635735630989075,
-0.32088232040405273,
-0.09120973944664001,
-0.5097015500068665,
-0.2940465807914734,
-0.12255953997373581,
-0.38522112369537354,
-0.3520718514919281,
0.05494663119316101,
0.15661689639091492,
0.4399889409542084,
0.07508520036935806,
-0.8177797198295593,
0.26174724102020264,
-0.554688572883606,
0.24001389741897583,
0.7465525269508362,
0.19308815896511078,
0.4428747892379761,
-0.285046249628067,
0.7092021703720093,
0.04911795258522034,
0.2849084138870239,
0.24371585249900818,
-0.7222791314125061,
-0.6227474212646484,
-0.47252029180526733,
0.4169188141822815,
0.5825361609458923,
-0.8461835384368896,
0.08729303628206253,
-0.26570042967796326,
-0.28797075152397156,
-0.7493149638175964,
0.2748963534832001,
0.41104352474212646,
0.8895703554153442,
0.33972299098968506,
-0.575714111328125,
-0.47412189841270447,
-0.9084652066230774,
-0.356314480304718,
-0.3025053143501282,
-0.05381179228425026,
0.36408644914627075,
0.40390732884407043,
-0.49264875054359436,
0.8059278726577759,
-0.4281300902366638,
-0.1281113177537918,
-0.14475315809249878,
0.22166043519973755,
0.1504337638616562,
0.19181294739246368,
0.29689323902130127,
-0.442066490650177,
-0.5803973078727722,
-0.062449224293231964,
-0.9513362646102905,
-0.36956915259361267,
0.11412043124437332,
0.11815234273672104,
0.2593715786933899,
0.34826141595840454,
-0.45668473839759827,
0.14473751187324524,
0.42326655983924866,
-0.14061801135540009,
0.2533489167690277,
0.11838018149137497,
-0.001047032536007464,
-0.8217398524284363,
0.2187836468219757,
0.17138360440731049,
-0.17269819974899292,
-0.9286625385284424,
-0.0581025704741478,
-0.16601349413394928,
-0.1798221617937088,
-0.5049389600753784,
0.7306297421455383,
-0.39556223154067993,
0.3066757619380951,
-0.36368998885154724,
0.05287109315395355,
0.03531961888074875,
0.3251579999923706,
0.14866705238819122,
0.45097067952156067,
0.46066224575042725,
-0.2151966542005539,
0.17478981614112854,
0.20230625569820404,
-0.22069349884986877,
0.7904184460639954,
-0.6018875241279602,
0.1277530938386917,
-0.36007851362228394,
0.22756804525852203,
-0.7329491972923279,
-0.5857080221176147,
0.5176562666893005,
-0.4708113372325897,
0.21661819517612457,
-0.3238649070262909,
-0.23364338278770447,
-0.12337767332792282,
-0.5433270931243896,
0.2810809910297394,
0.5325348377227783,
-0.30042681097984314,
0.38800477981567383,
0.6692895889282227,
-0.38233238458633423,
-0.5578624606132507,
-0.8175991177558899,
0.40702003240585327,
-0.21552376449108124,
-0.2758464515209198,
-0.02361239492893219,
0.11296732723712921,
-0.5415724515914917,
-0.009251777082681656,
0.3693317174911499,
-0.04623999074101448,
0.17520862817764282,
0.4439273178577423,
0.35337480902671814,
-0.01996835134923458,
0.37833884358406067,
-0.18803055584430695,
-0.33885735273361206,
0.2013181746006012,
0.03928745910525322,
0.16603374481201172,
-0.037530820816755295,
-0.2604808509349823,
-0.6287341713905334,
0.6443919539451599,
0.5961933732032776,
0.0964464396238327,
0.5577338933944702,
0.1636243760585785,
-0.5529219508171082,
-0.08360221982002258,
-0.5744320750236511,
-0.2122739553451538,
-0.36769139766693115,
0.14092038571834564,
0.2055724710226059,
-1.050912618637085,
0.3268362283706665,
-0.011975470930337906,
0.02909460850059986,
0.41115251183509827,
0.5156140923500061,
-0.30112218856811523,
1.128638744354248,
0.3962768614292145,
-0.2540188729763031,
0.13489000499248505,
0.011156256310641766,
0.17780070006847382,
-0.8503729701042175,
-0.08197847753763199,
-0.4309229850769043,
-0.29892250895500183,
-0.7165683507919312,
-0.5156140327453613,
0.5272297859191895,
-0.09505419433116913,
-0.14281690120697021,
-0.39586591720581055,
-0.605915904045105,
0.0881626233458519,
0.23647215962409973,
0.20922261476516724,
0.06651095300912857,
0.018654674291610718,
0.17905209958553314,
-0.3179149925708771,
-0.4677329659461975,
-0.6124079823493958,
0.9192743301391602,
0.5953786373138428,
0.5848827362060547,
-0.14897119998931885,
0.7748711109161377,
0.047334861010313034,
0.9559004306793213,
-0.987260639667511,
0.5937904715538025,
-0.38721227645874023,
-0.584600031375885,
-0.03418827801942825,
-0.4604800343513489,
-0.5858717560768127,
0.09291315078735352,
-0.38134482502937317,
-0.43899789452552795,
0.2801097631454468,
0.14909718930721283,
-0.6460549235343933,
0.39771580696105957,
-0.6530613899230957,
0.5199763178825378,
-0.08173342049121857,
-0.20862765610218048,
0.4207545816898346,
-0.7800599932670593,
0.09220503270626068,
0.06512385606765747,
0.32531610131263733,
-0.33376234769821167,
-0.22172722220420837,
0.7099789977073669,
-0.6475539207458496,
1.1907310485839844,
-0.8001329302787781,
-0.05364421755075455,
0.27373647689819336,
-0.055296964943408966,
0.24205811321735382,
0.019645916298031807,
-0.2130907028913498,
0.3068060278892517,
-0.4591972231864929,
-0.46665945649147034,
-0.4073413014411926,
0.6249163746833801,
-0.9294719099998474,
-0.412151962518692,
-0.5758721232414246,
-0.2760712504386902,
-0.5833675861358643,
-0.0475195050239563,
0.18229660391807556,
0.31739187240600586,
-0.14499399065971375,
0.01366279274225235,
0.5085499882698059,
-0.3800060451030731,
0.16731780767440796,
0.2950981557369232,
-0.14130569994449615,
-0.6280806660652161,
0.8077043890953064,
0.31096380949020386,
0.061973266303539276,
0.2173694521188736,
0.45810171961784363,
-0.3142105042934418,
-0.4855695962905884,
-0.4406992495059967,
0.38116684556007385,
-0.7921216487884521,
-0.22563260793685913,
-0.7973337173461914,
-0.019865121692419052,
-0.129938542842865,
-0.36706462502479553,
-0.08038825541734695,
-0.6244359612464905,
-0.6052728891372681,
-0.17382127046585083,
0.5491967797279358,
0.876679539680481,
0.04147709533572197,
0.36094430088996887,
-0.7244521975517273,
0.3228979706764221,
0.4364784061908722,
0.5030868649482727,
-0.06808742880821228,
-0.21259437501430511,
-0.15732069313526154,
-0.10541661828756332,
0.06428569555282593,
-1.0997732877731323,
0.23779891431331635,
-0.04110440984368324,
0.08602125197649002,
0.4848760962486267,
0.06319727748632431,
0.43767762184143066,
-0.2858758270740509,
1.0725688934326172,
0.3493947684764862,
-0.8737426400184631,
0.31633853912353516,
-0.4580017328262329,
0.17163319885730743,
0.8678032159805298,
0.6036213636398315,
-0.6572169661521912,
-0.31064388155937195,
-0.44951215386390686,
-0.9411125779151917,
0.5299780368804932,
-0.38194021582603455,
0.2763292193412781,
-0.23660078644752502,
0.5688913464546204,
0.2907213866710663,
0.28497493267059326,
-0.7824624180793762,
0.030793648213148117,
-0.2946586012840271,
-0.2112807184457779,
-0.3158808648586273,
-0.615638017654419,
-0.1466115266084671,
-0.2367590218782425,
0.634296715259552,
-0.18967817723751068,
0.22495779395103455,
0.48976829648017883,
-0.04384111985564232,
-0.3257598280906677,
0.3919960856437683,
0.32125160098075867,
0.36083561182022095,
-0.31563204526901245,
0.2586730718612671,
0.3658718466758728,
-0.26528701186180115,
0.13699322938919067,
-0.1190803274512291,
-0.421379417181015,
0.32861649990081787,
0.43584078550338745,
0.6557828783988953,
0.20488882064819336,
-0.4898991882801056,
0.8742339611053467,
0.058290526270866394,
-0.345529168844223,
-0.29240480065345764,
-0.261636883020401,
0.20650601387023926,
-0.056967657059431076,
-0.013378038071095943,
-0.07562480866909027,
0.04009086638689041,
-0.4022984206676483,
-0.06148600950837135,
0.5447437167167664,
-1.0511109828948975,
-0.46885111927986145,
0.4518386125564575,
0.47506585717201233,
-0.2649792730808258,
0.6125702261924744,
-0.23441468179225922,
-0.47011256217956543,
0.1008482426404953,
0.1089618057012558,
1.0308287143707275,
-0.1846630722284317,
0.3886324167251587,
0.14065364003181458,
0.1373050957918167,
-0.1419159471988678,
0.7220637798309326,
0.3888718783855438,
-0.46530282497406006,
-0.7426573634147644,
-0.42206820845603943,
-0.8659448623657227,
-0.12039803713560104,
-0.7090504765510559,
0.1562468260526657,
-0.6977566480636597,
-0.5622502565383911,
0.09265757352113724,
0.03489275276660919,
-0.7292980551719666,
0.48565399646759033,
0.2558863162994385,
0.737866222858429,
-0.8968485593795776,
0.578420877456665,
0.9409545063972473,
-0.27695298194885254,
-0.5063467025756836,
-0.10288750380277634,
-0.01882554404437542,
-0.487194299697876,
0.5217207670211792,
0.23978164792060852,
-0.07992549240589142,
-0.6121933460235596,
-0.688739001750946,
0.01902732253074646,
0.5816970467567444,
0.44975388050079346,
-0.5033144950866699,
-0.03239784762263298,
0.2562772035598755,
0.930554211139679,
-0.3053237199783325,
0.25016096234321594,
0.1246851310133934,
0.3238562345504761,
-0.368580162525177,
-0.5644887685775757,
0.11893682181835175,
-0.25157567858695984,
-0.15913373231887817,
0.08368748426437378,
-0.6233629584312439,
1.1913117170333862,
0.010116669349372387,
0.0006552189588546753,
-0.23983950912952423,
0.42601659893989563,
-0.21726590394973755,
0.30447062849998474,
0.6891183257102966,
0.5474579334259033,
0.6549345254898071,
0.04795211926102638,
1.0167275667190552,
-0.21827879548072815,
0.3357974588871002,
0.9552547931671143,
-0.6719361543655396,
0.797773540019989,
0.6889153122901917,
0.03850116208195686,
0.7010641098022461,
0.14131930470466614,
0.17639945447444916,
0.3270992934703827,
0.3721780776977539,
-0.8472346067428589,
-0.34471461176872253,
-0.43353086709976196,
-0.18351863324642181,
0.3095017373561859,
0.24198618531227112,
-0.2532583475112915,
-0.2150566726922989,
-0.08218890428543091,
0.37391284108161926,
-0.03194408491253853,
-0.2876446545124054,
0.9783242344856262,
0.45512357354164124,
-0.5603381991386414,
0.4177144467830658,
0.052159685641527176,
0.7812567949295044,
-0.4327992796897888,
-0.011381067335605621,
-0.1354132890701294,
-0.047419264912605286,
-0.397022545337677,
-0.5916773080825806,
0.29440006613731384,
0.40903693437576294,
-0.23823858797550201,
-0.25027063488960266,
0.6748051047325134,
-0.03674754500389099,
-0.49814367294311523,
0.3897690176963806,
0.649786651134491,
0.26570194959640503,
-0.11117469519376755,
-0.6052055954933167,
-0.09057675302028656,
0.08898715674877167,
-0.3731174170970917,
0.3970562517642975,
0.3723840117454529,
-0.2224770486354828,
0.3887863755226135,
0.5646538138389587,
0.4309116005897522,
-0.40250054001808167,
0.26747581362724304,
1.0432319641113281,
-0.8137158155441284,
-0.15895690023899078,
-0.8859823346138,
0.5752952694892883,
-0.08393137156963348,
-0.40846049785614014,
0.5331739187240601,
0.18777082860469818,
0.7333133220672607,
-0.22334028780460358,
1.147887945175171,
0.15646305680274963,
1.1065418720245361,
-0.14808954298496246,
0.638420820236206,
-0.5476872324943542,
0.13560879230499268,
-0.36676356196403503,
-0.5402866005897522,
-0.7786833643913269,
0.6748068928718567,
-0.36501544713974,
-0.008753740228712559,
0.2798827886581421,
0.7392429709434509,
0.1487148255109787,
0.14578695595264435,
0.19181887805461884,
0.24573926627635956,
0.40376701951026917,
0.5436158180236816,
1.1795861721038818,
-0.00965221505612135,
-0.13693906366825104,
-0.49690648913383484,
-0.3465125262737274,
-0.32118481397628784,
-1.202828288078308,
-1.062234878540039,
0.00919654592871666,
-0.4696047604084015,
-0.40381717681884766,
-0.02860591560602188,
1.3868454694747925,
0.4876093864440918,
-0.9899866580963135,
-0.07768990099430084,
0.30531811714172363,
-0.15448610484600067,
0.22653912007808685,
-0.15542738139629364,
0.2613081932067871,
-0.22510427236557007,
-0.37041744589805603,
0.10021183639764786,
0.24747687578201294,
-0.002864694222807884,
-0.4129577577114105,
-0.08531584590673447,
0.17161782085895538,
0.1499882936477661,
0.5743809342384338,
0.30198055505752563,
-0.5822006464004517,
-0.48674097657203674,
0.004294290207326412,
-0.09884030371904373,
0.20715689659118652,
0.7969481945037842,
-0.7220399975776672,
0.6120280623435974,
0.31984683871269226,
0.6000564694404602,
-0.05049150809645653,
0.10766167938709259,
0.1913478672504425,
-0.7060658931732178,
0.12786854803562164,
0.7484204173088074,
0.3240298330783844,
0.847387969493866,
-0.23593415319919586,
0.22972866892814636,
0.1681131273508072,
-0.5796283483505249,
-1.002709984779358,
0.1858794242143631,
-0.9614901542663574,
-0.20318427681922913,
1.1785376071929932,
-0.224839985370636,
-0.058076173067092896,
-0.3201647996902466,
-0.33197879791259766,
0.12068208307027817,
-0.4256570041179657,
0.8933212757110596,
0.6118640899658203,
-0.34814372658729553,
0.1227075606584549,
-0.7110997438430786,
0.667510986328125,
0.4738844037055969,
-0.7676637172698975,
0.03914947062730789,
0.4697529673576355,
0.30584776401519775,
0.15521323680877686,
1.1777417659759521,
-0.27242133021354675,
0.05516920983791351,
-0.3314458727836609,
0.4167976975440979,
0.17665213346481323,
-0.26883894205093384,
-0.7602408528327942,
0.35885900259017944,
0.49088308215141296,
0.11630524694919586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18824v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18824v1
|
Benchmarking Benchmark Leakage in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-29T16:05:36 | 2024-04-29T16:05:36 |
Ruijie Xu, Zengzhi Wang, Run-Ze Fan, Pengfei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Amid the expanding use of pre-training data, the phenomenon of benchmark
dataset leakage has become increasingly prominent, exacerbated by opaque
training processes and the often undisclosed inclusion of supervised data in
contemporary Large Language Models (LLMs). This issue skews benchmark
effectiveness and fosters potentially unfair comparisons, impeding the field's
healthy development. To address this, we introduce a detection pipeline
utilizing Perplexity and N-gram accuracy, two simple and scalable metrics that
gauge a model's prediction precision on benchmark, to identify potential data
leakages. By analyzing 31 LLMs under the context of mathematical reasoning, we
reveal substantial instances of training even test set misuse, resulting in
potentially unfair comparisons. These findings prompt us to offer several
recommendations regarding model documentation, benchmark setup, and future
evaluations. Notably, we propose the "Benchmark Transparency Card" to encourage
clear documentation of benchmark utilization, promoting transparency and
healthy developments of LLMs. we have made our leaderboard, pipeline
implementation, and model predictions publicly available, fostering future
research.
|
[
-0.28300079703330994,
-0.28914710879325867,
0.7477253675460815,
0.05514314025640488,
-0.06409917771816254,
-0.038036640733480453,
-0.17730514705181122,
-0.4833739101886749,
-0.37431707978248596,
0.7003185153007507,
-0.4865674376487732,
-0.7041231989860535,
-1.0420823097229004,
-0.14236263930797577,
-0.733965277671814,
0.7660465240478516,
-0.30498239398002625,
0.14165034890174866,
-0.3822536766529083,
-0.2867489755153656,
-0.3623866140842438,
-0.5559963583946228,
-0.20927534997463226,
-0.4143728017807007,
0.4034530818462372,
0.36390557885169983,
0.49080854654312134,
0.960842490196228,
0.5471122860908508,
0.262643963098526,
-0.08236553519964218,
-0.13552738726139069,
-0.5580534338951111,
0.21973952651023865,
-0.10472656041383743,
-0.8738532662391663,
-0.4697330594062805,
-0.0029143441934138536,
0.9410203099250793,
0.6389480233192444,
-0.1088302880525589,
0.4960775375366211,
0.10817045718431473,
0.6114847660064697,
-1.0050197839736938,
0.3702683448791504,
-0.814501166343689,
0.1028243899345398,
-0.7655743956565857,
0.15024490654468536,
-0.2552672326564789,
-0.4352930188179016,
-0.23118382692337036,
-0.3736925721168518,
0.1713598072528839,
-0.12365298718214035,
0.7025301456451416,
0.44469472765922546,
0.013362370431423187,
-0.1533447653055191,
-0.2999800443649292,
0.6627233028411865,
-0.8399501442909241,
0.5344826579093933,
0.4570034444332123,
0.6771925687789917,
-0.063002809882164,
-0.7649884223937988,
-0.5157924294471741,
-0.1113583892583847,
0.20196059346199036,
-0.0885540246963501,
-0.27211764454841614,
-0.3432069420814514,
0.49546873569488525,
0.35840320587158203,
-0.4121021032333374,
0.30907949805259705,
0.060315825045108795,
-0.23072364926338196,
0.6242084503173828,
0.10580632835626602,
0.02317887544631958,
0.27157315611839294,
-0.3135656714439392,
-0.32791978120803833,
-1.0149967670440674,
-0.22174741327762604,
0.6616638898849487,
0.17683474719524384,
-0.18160012364387512,
0.39254745841026306,
-0.33496084809303284,
0.372581422328949,
-0.37859734892845154,
0.07581533491611481,
0.5951766967773438,
-0.15215270221233368,
-0.16390061378479004,
-0.03699512034654617,
0.759696364402771,
0.09991106390953064,
0.42937153577804565,
-0.27759504318237305,
-0.32840463519096375,
0.14682720601558685,
0.008276375010609627,
-0.7887434363365173,
-0.22177810966968536,
0.12548920512199402,
-0.10761893540620804,
-0.38693785667419434,
0.12344226986169815,
-0.760221540927887,
-0.5409680008888245,
-0.17882877588272095,
0.2734241783618927,
-0.06942538172006607,
-0.3787890076637268,
0.15059204399585724,
-0.11405233293771744,
-0.15683527290821075,
0.016306160017848015,
-0.7682655453681946,
0.33580291271209717,
1.049014925956726,
0.5600022673606873,
-0.14295360445976257,
-0.3560495972633362,
-0.5354006886482239,
0.14142224192619324,
-0.22379298508167267,
0.7984176278114319,
-0.6336138248443604,
-0.2227550595998764,
0.24926497042179108,
0.03895600512623787,
0.21408717334270477,
-0.9611907005310059,
0.7591351866722107,
-0.13121038675308228,
-0.022223573178052902,
-0.31104305386543274,
-0.6894199848175049,
0.28154832124710083,
0.24491292238235474,
-0.5774312019348145,
0.996146023273468,
-0.14309872686862946,
-0.7819767594337463,
0.5578761696815491,
-0.39911532402038574,
0.08384665101766586,
0.23411191999912262,
-0.3789384961128235,
-0.6055836081504822,
0.2093202918767929,
0.2452470362186432,
0.4838482439517975,
-0.2523411214351654,
0.451694518327713,
-0.5969560146331787,
-0.5262138843536377,
0.30367085337638855,
-0.6411757469177246,
0.620107889175415,
0.12745261192321777,
-0.25305768847465515,
-0.10918884724378586,
-0.5961621403694153,
0.16763728857040405,
0.1804029494524002,
-0.11345668882131577,
-0.04418417438864708,
-0.26962023973464966,
-0.2800356447696686,
0.03089730069041252,
0.24254655838012695,
-0.35449695587158203,
-0.03848189860582352,
-0.03868943452835083,
0.22936305403709412,
0.8840562701225281,
-0.4315807521343231,
0.15330183506011963,
-0.3880442976951599,
0.5735617876052856,
0.07375387847423553,
0.1782461255788803,
-0.2635737955570221,
-0.3536013662815094,
-0.5389237403869629,
-0.19738301634788513,
0.6102785468101501,
0.28375929594039917,
-0.27499866485595703,
0.43762069940567017,
-0.3706809878349304,
-0.610145628452301,
-0.6077054738998413,
0.3264184594154358,
0.5329514741897583,
0.5074273347854614,
0.23328278958797455,
-0.38794705271720886,
-0.10035949945449829,
-0.9613416790962219,
-0.8146108388900757,
0.05522884055972099,
-0.2933602035045624,
0.24178321659564972,
0.521558940410614,
-0.03333723917603493,
0.557482123374939,
-0.45187628269195557,
-0.29295942187309265,
-0.013258036226034164,
0.27824023365974426,
0.17516709864139557,
0.5012585520744324,
0.2606711983680725,
-0.4865740239620209,
-0.33405783772468567,
-0.40100306272506714,
-0.937743067741394,
-0.36306893825531006,
0.35710272192955017,
-0.025318527594208717,
-0.08992178738117218,
0.7964367270469666,
-0.3146195709705353,
0.31629055738449097,
0.9131677150726318,
-0.040215201675891876,
0.7232557535171509,
-0.027699043974280357,
-0.33623644709587097,
-0.625735878944397,
0.12895351648330688,
-0.06249099224805832,
-0.1443551778793335,
-0.39059972763061523,
0.11683569848537445,
0.4355880320072174,
0.028034018352627754,
-0.4140585660934448,
0.4203738868236542,
-0.4598694443702698,
-0.16219767928123474,
-0.10594816505908966,
0.12732112407684326,
-0.05329835042357445,
-0.02085871621966362,
-0.2548656761646271,
0.7200015187263489,
0.6935173273086548,
-0.20618928968906403,
0.08693180978298187,
0.11251749098300934,
-0.6997994780540466,
0.3955727815628052,
-0.5306490659713745,
0.18344388902187347,
-0.015146838501095772,
0.3921792805194855,
-0.6848366260528564,
-0.03961072489619255,
0.14510244131088257,
-0.3946516513824463,
0.5046849846839905,
-0.3190479874610901,
-0.8722200989723206,
-0.028258467093110085,
-0.23709523677825928,
0.4730302095413208,
0.4904487431049347,
-0.5154820084571838,
0.028815273195505142,
0.46238741278648376,
-0.043559327721595764,
-0.8325086832046509,
-0.8985437154769897,
0.0478229895234108,
-0.22302748262882233,
-0.5645233392715454,
0.31898096203804016,
-0.03339224308729172,
-0.20309865474700928,
0.011815237812697887,
-0.4666711091995239,
-0.1508626490831375,
0.20787617564201355,
0.299441397190094,
-0.042732711881399155,
-0.3047344386577606,
0.31133216619491577,
-0.2048460990190506,
-0.2879195511341095,
0.43356940150260925,
-0.0940948948264122,
0.5729587078094482,
-0.15647466480731964,
-0.5732964277267456,
-0.37335702776908875,
0.05904700979590416,
0.5445364713668823,
-0.36264944076538086,
0.6608788967132568,
0.4150427281856537,
-0.3951995372772217,
-0.36020514369010925,
-0.7303216457366943,
-0.21242259442806244,
-0.47566890716552734,
0.38479897379875183,
-0.3699846565723419,
-0.5662702322006226,
0.5253211855888367,
-0.4448995888233185,
-0.1831568330526352,
0.2605350911617279,
0.3522278666496277,
0.17143021523952484,
0.9287675619125366,
0.5951351523399353,
-0.14959736168384552,
0.38453373312950134,
-0.23411737382411957,
0.18127451837062836,
-0.7577072978019714,
-0.2356470376253128,
-0.6956213116645813,
-0.16758142411708832,
-0.656221330165863,
-0.5670174360275269,
0.14083656668663025,
0.32791200280189514,
-0.25522175431251526,
0.13689830899238586,
-0.20998108386993408,
0.8419941067695618,
0.33721786737442017,
-0.1671535074710846,
0.45758721232414246,
-0.11422235518693924,
-0.41111138463020325,
-0.12867732346057892,
-0.6062343716621399,
-0.6315004825592041,
1.4723541736602783,
0.6185117363929749,
0.6546083688735962,
0.060098420828580856,
0.8655198216438293,
-0.06057582050561905,
0.49840983748435974,
-0.3945983946323395,
0.440827876329422,
-0.2678762674331665,
-0.5632592439651489,
-0.22546952962875366,
-0.4129824638366699,
-0.8030555248260498,
0.20825205743312836,
-0.2891467809677124,
-0.8627740740776062,
0.28173667192459106,
-0.020217962563037872,
0.1214926540851593,
0.33170536160469055,
-0.611197829246521,
1.0570117235183716,
-0.1761329472064972,
-0.5625514984130859,
0.054201699793338776,
-0.3828895390033722,
0.546821653842926,
-0.27268683910369873,
0.16944076120853424,
-0.541821300983429,
0.027902813628315926,
0.48759925365448,
-0.4565137028694153,
0.5493544936180115,
-0.0812264159321785,
-0.24879470467567444,
-0.24635112285614014,
0.10067186504602432,
0.6537976861000061,
0.13106411695480347,
-0.22935298085212708,
0.7477211356163025,
-0.15508338809013367,
-0.5152692198753357,
-0.38851308822631836,
0.7246294021606445,
-0.5661581754684448,
-0.506915807723999,
-0.5091722011566162,
-0.6248600482940674,
-0.6526817083358765,
0.2887865900993347,
0.39334312081336975,
0.24049942195415497,
0.07581865787506104,
0.21233829855918884,
0.8151535391807556,
-0.0633232370018959,
0.1314265877008438,
0.5680434107780457,
-0.20985668897628784,
0.08607394993305206,
0.8052331805229187,
0.07016436010599136,
0.3940235376358032,
0.08486507833003998,
0.3344062864780426,
-0.41226914525032043,
-0.9953662157058716,
-0.21474944055080414,
0.41534262895584106,
-0.678620457649231,
-0.22391057014465332,
-0.3107914924621582,
-0.2755812108516693,
-0.41628390550613403,
0.2113894671201706,
-0.6090239882469177,
-0.1726653277873993,
0.11385594308376312,
-0.05181276798248291,
-0.06359966844320297,
0.7141552567481995,
0.00015873175289016217,
0.1748398095369339,
-0.6048515439033508,
0.1282762885093689,
0.10269807279109955,
0.7824734449386597,
-0.05148712545633316,
-0.4454752504825592,
-0.023824475705623627,
0.034449558705091476,
-0.2535935342311859,
-0.5318110585212708,
0.1913892924785614,
-0.10497929155826569,
0.9005677103996277,
0.5547195076942444,
-0.02754056639969349,
0.38137125968933105,
-0.5331912636756897,
0.3498693108558655,
0.25986576080322266,
-1.096137285232544,
0.42866677045822144,
-0.2924877405166626,
0.5055927634239197,
0.7072924375534058,
0.38383054733276367,
-0.4482273459434509,
-0.7559680342674255,
-0.5906006693840027,
-0.8248049020767212,
0.6046209335327148,
0.02846325933933258,
0.031223976984620094,
0.35989439487457275,
0.01592884585261345,
0.27689704298973083,
0.46606454253196716,
-0.6046482920646667,
-0.2669719159603119,
-0.13511604070663452,
-0.0772545263171196,
-0.18620657920837402,
-0.32261428236961365,
-0.3047919273376465,
-0.09492181241512299,
0.3715934455394745,
-0.07313481718301773,
-0.07939916104078293,
-0.2519712746143341,
-0.27624693512916565,
0.1408044695854187,
0.3030732274055481,
0.34772083163261414,
0.9189717769622803,
-0.2132209986448288,
0.3095903694629669,
0.1929466426372528,
-0.5745124220848083,
-0.067418172955513,
0.16835010051727295,
0.03644872456789017,
-0.06640961021184921,
0.5174708962440491,
0.4242563247680664,
0.19531816244125366,
-0.8294726014137268,
0.6701329946517944,
-0.056418970227241516,
-0.3126310408115387,
-0.33802860975265503,
0.10895556211471558,
0.3339993357658386,
0.118074432015419,
0.125265970826149,
-0.09163667261600494,
0.03056427463889122,
-0.590484082698822,
0.3299017548561096,
0.32213959097862244,
-0.4881391227245331,
-0.08176758140325546,
0.6606951951980591,
-0.061532747000455856,
-0.09349685907363892,
0.5704439878463745,
-0.06636102497577667,
-0.5006130337715149,
0.4615040719509125,
0.3084666132926941,
0.7345755696296692,
-0.21360543370246887,
0.11022597551345825,
0.09276837110519409,
0.3580922484397888,
-0.3953472375869751,
0.09124039858579636,
0.025216927751898766,
-0.7437580227851868,
-0.35597366094589233,
-0.43707525730133057,
-0.42505040764808655,
0.3501524329185486,
-0.861805260181427,
0.27444779872894287,
-0.5628823637962341,
0.09180127084255219,
0.24650420248508453,
-0.020351842045783997,
-0.7323790192604065,
-0.03128664940595627,
0.5072797536849976,
1.0613316297531128,
-0.8880378603935242,
1.0411696434020996,
0.103687584400177,
-0.2555757164955139,
-0.6713388562202454,
0.31761834025382996,
0.240966796875,
-1.0960074663162231,
0.7341084480285645,
0.36652663350105286,
-0.03903952240943909,
-0.46844348311424255,
-0.5697778463363647,
-0.6905730962753296,
1.0200388431549072,
0.8144744634628296,
-0.8985878825187683,
0.3328140377998352,
0.5423039793968201,
0.4695996046066284,
-0.28634628653526306,
0.2667631506919861,
0.7966282367706299,
0.6925332546234131,
-0.08155260980129242,
-0.8517332077026367,
0.3106842041015625,
-0.17269037663936615,
-0.20779570937156677,
0.3118721544742584,
-0.5971481204032898,
1.0514938831329346,
0.15798653662204742,
-0.3123781979084015,
-0.07915403693914413,
0.023299628868699074,
0.40254661440849304,
0.4272025227546692,
0.4399564564228058,
0.8266553282737732,
0.955970048904419,
-0.29798081517219543,
1.0859242677688599,
-0.13545745611190796,
0.1337548941373825,
1.3493657112121582,
-0.5298239588737488,
0.9668184518814087,
0.23986224830150604,
-0.19106122851371765,
0.3399394452571869,
0.1466381698846817,
-0.24644382297992706,
0.4119730591773987,
0.7558630704879761,
-0.2942827641963959,
-0.1980278640985489,
-0.21578608453273773,
-0.6348342895507812,
0.43197184801101685,
0.33611735701560974,
-0.3677448332309723,
-0.47879818081855774,
-0.6156833171844482,
0.2500520646572113,
0.1755754053592682,
-0.14621786773204803,
0.4968661665916443,
0.0856127217411995,
-0.47679603099823,
0.620133101940155,
-0.19492439925670624,
0.5472646355628967,
-0.541854977607727,
-0.0085097411647439,
-0.32194459438323975,
0.37788376212120056,
-0.2664842903614044,
-0.7808712124824524,
0.1507795751094818,
0.09879841655492783,
0.0950009822845459,
-0.38764965534210205,
0.47227856516838074,
-0.4257986843585968,
-0.48998281359672546,
0.4529075026512146,
0.6317328214645386,
0.31107887625694275,
-0.43050265312194824,
-0.7465502619743347,
0.39648860692977905,
-0.3289419710636139,
0.23107044398784637,
0.5881005525588989,
0.4525473117828369,
-0.14748090505599976,
0.7948643565177917,
0.6103237271308899,
0.42047685384750366,
0.12100321054458618,
0.3191688656806946,
0.7885338664054871,
-0.4553936719894409,
-0.2597762942314148,
-0.7442116737365723,
0.18023762106895447,
-0.3276118040084839,
-0.39308223128318787,
0.8925706744194031,
0.6212576031684875,
0.9773470163345337,
0.31481075286865234,
0.7891631126403809,
0.6868776082992554,
0.4880838096141815,
-0.5430768728256226,
0.9529721736907959,
-0.39539605379104614,
0.661462128162384,
-0.12015169858932495,
-0.9203905463218689,
-0.30878689885139465,
0.1758141666650772,
-0.4610569477081299,
-0.06934352964162827,
0.8813092708587646,
0.7005395293235779,
-0.19346877932548523,
0.12217888981103897,
0.3494662940502167,
0.3802315890789032,
0.31022533774375916,
0.6922872066497803,
0.8065004944801331,
-0.39251118898391724,
0.6300888061523438,
-0.22633211314678192,
-0.1465301364660263,
-0.27312421798706055,
-1.1572520732879639,
-0.690363883972168,
-0.1801074892282486,
-0.43807825446128845,
-0.1525348275899887,
0.3040035367012024,
0.07407353818416595,
0.7550823092460632,
-0.8811818361282349,
-0.31007546186447144,
-0.34211021661758423,
0.18441949784755707,
-0.14281027019023895,
-0.13424769043922424,
0.22011640667915344,
-0.27965980768203735,
-0.6343894004821777,
0.34463343024253845,
0.016508666798472404,
0.002306888345628977,
-0.5405672788619995,
0.17072372138500214,
0.17308950424194336,
-0.12772957980632782,
0.051078565418720245,
0.26990997791290283,
-0.5433973670005798,
-0.1285269856452942,
-0.37496769428253174,
0.10271678119897842,
-0.055108994245529175,
0.7657003998756409,
-0.7016878724098206,
0.452732652425766,
0.3579314351081848,
0.649238646030426,
0.7150351405143738,
-0.206557497382164,
0.7008638381958008,
-0.7363539934158325,
0.16930446028709412,
0.24207890033721924,
0.2477121651172638,
0.32704609632492065,
-0.09581650048494339,
0.5588471293449402,
-0.0503794401884079,
-0.3476773798465729,
-1.3284327983856201,
0.24819931387901306,
-0.4073213040828705,
-0.33392345905303955,
0.8353570103645325,
-0.4482208788394928,
-0.15647976100444794,
-0.01657048799097538,
0.569514811038971,
0.01302899420261383,
-0.3155132830142975,
0.6625877618789673,
1.0115545988082886,
0.23744478821754456,
0.01639990694820881,
-0.9695776104927063,
0.5187950730323792,
0.46695539355278015,
-0.8787376880645752,
0.3812730312347412,
0.2190215140581131,
0.42404940724372864,
-0.036105867475271225,
0.1985604465007782,
-0.5002323985099792,
0.01366711687296629,
0.2595047056674957,
-0.11943160742521286,
-0.23765219748020172,
-0.2958260178565979,
-0.520643949508667,
0.16810427606105804,
0.10576744377613068,
-0.1460101306438446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18810v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18810v2
|
Unknown Script: Impact of Script on Cross-Lingual Transfer
| 2024-04-29T15:48:01 | 2024-05-07T12:23:39 |
Wondimagegnhue Tsegaye Tufa, Ilia Markov, Piek Vossen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Cross-lingual transfer has become an effective way of transferring knowledge
between languages. In this paper, we explore an often overlooked aspect in this
domain: the influence of the source language of a language model on language
transfer performance. We consider a case where the target language and its
script are not part of the pre-trained model. We conduct a series of
experiments on monolingual and multilingual models that are pre-trained on
different tokenization methods to determine factors that affect cross-lingual
transfer to a new language with a unique script. Our findings reveal the
importance of the tokenizer as a stronger factor than the shared script,
language similarity, and model size.
|
[
-0.26227352023124695,
-0.3064378798007965,
0.3216007351875305,
0.39249008893966675,
0.06962598115205765,
0.339730441570282,
-0.08706889301538467,
-0.8908710479736328,
0.3680906891822815,
0.36711856722831726,
-0.3866479694843292,
-0.034732136875391006,
-0.8370258212089539,
-0.009904417209327221,
-0.6736977100372314,
0.8959404230117798,
-0.15642262995243073,
0.26737913489341736,
0.031752604991197586,
-0.15607507526874542,
-0.1758519560098648,
-0.726439356803894,
-0.3095846474170685,
-0.27839013934135437,
0.5104659795761108,
0.07203057408332825,
0.5456373691558838,
0.4078044295310974,
0.6392041444778442,
0.277140736579895,
0.3410862684249878,
-0.5394119024276733,
-0.5212517976760864,
-0.3706717789173126,
-0.45188817381858826,
-0.8757157325744629,
-0.22764478623867035,
-0.10339099913835526,
0.8796467185020447,
1.1428295373916626,
0.24014653265476227,
0.1918879896402359,
-0.2965768277645111,
0.30381712317466736,
-0.5805888175964355,
0.12276779115200043,
-0.43838372826576233,
0.04420468956232071,
-0.37187039852142334,
-0.21352390944957733,
-0.46368780732154846,
-0.1586802899837494,
0.4513233006000519,
-0.6881038546562195,
0.19263550639152527,
0.062111739069223404,
0.7025840878486633,
0.005133399739861488,
-0.5295484066009521,
-0.2632518708705902,
-1.0281940698623657,
0.8585809469223022,
-0.5143298506736755,
0.2604151964187622,
0.28604796528816223,
0.13024234771728516,
0.17279914021492004,
-0.8321032524108887,
-0.6917105913162231,
-0.044009435921907425,
-0.47133442759513855,
-0.1596912443637848,
-0.28778472542762756,
-0.03487309068441391,
0.17999106645584106,
0.04521698132157326,
-0.2392101287841797,
0.18583185970783234,
-0.6642391681671143,
-0.4256676733493805,
0.22523336112499237,
-0.1402396708726883,
1.0310630798339844,
-0.24809034168720245,
-0.4915952980518341,
-0.012334740720689297,
-0.684935450553894,
0.25341787934303284,
0.4906964600086212,
0.43878158926963806,
-0.10629303753376007,
0.5615295767784119,
0.19172169268131256,
0.6258166432380676,
-0.17091478407382965,
-0.003987275063991547,
0.06810782104730606,
-0.8805333375930786,
0.08822930604219437,
0.42559564113616943,
0.3903881013393402,
0.11787909269332886,
0.5419876575469971,
-0.36583927273750305,
-0.07001853734254837,
0.003116190666332841,
0.02382061257958412,
-0.7136238813400269,
-0.0968131348490715,
-0.3674529790878296,
-0.3733571469783783,
-0.10962318629026413,
0.29820311069488525,
-0.5307369232177734,
-0.1178077980875969,
-0.1303880661725998,
0.43241527676582336,
-0.28499799966812134,
-0.6014958620071411,
-0.26575201749801636,
-0.3655531704425812,
0.5193830728530884,
0.23280659317970276,
-1.1552348136901855,
0.4397205710411072,
0.5701590180397034,
0.700799822807312,
-0.6504193544387817,
-0.7671188116073608,
-0.6785255670547485,
0.15942591428756714,
-0.5516148209571838,
0.9024791717529297,
-0.6843921542167664,
-0.3623325824737549,
0.11064808070659637,
0.3264825642108917,
-0.6089999079704285,
-0.16380910575389862,
-0.030708033591508865,
-0.33009612560272217,
0.4367212951183319,
-0.311416357755661,
-0.30408552289009094,
-0.27474886178970337,
-0.43506520986557007,
-0.7993171215057373,
0.6445218920707703,
0.4119064211845398,
-0.5478009581565857,
0.5630300641059875,
-0.6195628643035889,
-0.8114105463027954,
-0.05980723723769188,
0.04225178062915802,
0.19597771763801575,
0.1523427665233612,
0.05181602016091347,
0.04653637111186981,
0.07615035772323608,
0.10241173207759857,
-0.22722665965557098,
-0.6788092255592346,
0.3861095905303955,
-0.3144063949584961,
0.7556151151657104,
-0.035166479647159576,
-0.3334823548793793,
-0.09042956680059433,
-0.9116180539131165,
0.10723930597305298,
-0.05868476256728172,
-0.3165385127067566,
-0.5954234600067139,
-0.6862850785255432,
0.45670607686042786,
0.2873997390270233,
0.23843508958816528,
-0.5202013850212097,
0.012383578345179558,
-0.31214213371276855,
-0.038622066378593445,
0.5257615447044373,
-0.020554853603243828,
0.8555916547775269,
-0.2658579349517822,
0.9431657791137695,
-0.09264741092920303,
-0.15701352059841156,
-0.2942483127117157,
-0.1861175000667572,
-0.873691201210022,
-0.12202490121126175,
0.6864768266677856,
0.3761466443538666,
-0.7454249858856201,
-0.42316702008247375,
-0.1562471240758896,
-0.33545011281967163,
-0.7153443098068237,
0.14617875218391418,
0.4762103259563446,
0.03586440160870552,
0.05730200931429863,
-0.3635897934436798,
-0.7123951315879822,
-0.8340709805488586,
-0.624860405921936,
-0.2266981452703476,
0.371367484331131,
-0.04144492372870445,
0.1469803899526596,
-0.040325604379177094,
0.8674299120903015,
-0.19164389371871948,
-0.28100481629371643,
-0.8236328363418579,
0.35830897092819214,
-0.06728988885879517,
0.6620048880577087,
1.0233927965164185,
-0.37205883860588074,
-0.7518686056137085,
0.33131319284439087,
-0.29935896396636963,
-0.5774385333061218,
-0.24047444760799408,
-0.13986288011074066,
0.42004579305648804,
0.7412835359573364,
-0.5574736595153809,
0.42770376801490784,
0.9984561204910278,
-0.26414623856544495,
0.5226741433143616,
-0.3208487331867218,
0.21655166149139404,
-1.0005908012390137,
0.5508530139923096,
-0.43552297353744507,
-0.09414465725421906,
-0.9258578419685364,
-0.19134335219860077,
0.14308977127075195,
-0.13768954575061798,
-0.9475716948509216,
0.976669192314148,
-0.6077665090560913,
-0.33461928367614746,
-0.23935142159461975,
-0.018306389451026917,
-0.058147214353084564,
0.6196609139442444,
0.0875232145190239,
0.9351852536201477,
0.7215012907981873,
-0.4526072144508362,
0.02807038649916649,
-0.021797478199005127,
-0.390521764755249,
0.6045165061950684,
-0.5523943305015564,
0.06308863312005997,
0.19909359514713287,
-0.1625833809375763,
-0.8963201642036438,
-0.01321338675916195,
0.07648739218711853,
-0.40197882056236267,
0.6290342211723328,
-0.5320046544075012,
-0.16741108894348145,
0.10831422358751297,
0.11122741550207138,
0.5232667326927185,
0.3232206106185913,
-0.33981576561927795,
0.5242250561714172,
0.35608160495758057,
-0.04474091902375221,
-0.7421542406082153,
-0.8009161949157715,
0.06729228049516678,
-0.1977001428604126,
-0.4852368235588074,
0.1576472967863083,
-0.03321914002299309,
-0.2914672791957855,
0.11521068215370178,
-0.2904528081417084,
-0.29142749309539795,
-0.04414275661110878,
0.19570741057395935,
0.26442161202430725,
-0.3781958222389221,
0.04675178602337837,
0.10628251731395721,
-0.07815870642662048,
0.18843334913253784,
-0.19644948840141296,
0.48348647356033325,
0.11899307370185852,
-0.511850893497467,
-0.31152841448783875,
0.31380996108055115,
0.7406033873558044,
-0.23343533277511597,
0.8390870094299316,
0.8337404727935791,
-0.09076857566833496,
-0.30566951632499695,
-0.2257055938243866,
0.10589629411697388,
-0.4096125662326813,
0.5110156536102295,
-0.48990967869758606,
-0.4923641085624695,
0.71097332239151,
-0.18617695569992065,
-0.5676472187042236,
0.42395392060279846,
0.30411848425865173,
0.3945207893848419,
0.8920663595199585,
1.121822476387024,
0.0270937979221344,
0.8986386060714722,
-0.005245226435363293,
0.21095646917819977,
-0.5152224898338318,
-0.0508270300924778,
-0.48593226075172424,
-0.09647994488477707,
-0.6335055828094482,
-0.34964096546173096,
-0.09601123631000519,
-0.06978001445531845,
0.36362597346305847,
0.6526511311531067,
0.3289475739002228,
0.40273424983024597,
0.5556331276893616,
-0.5791409015655518,
0.40233558416366577,
-0.10448498278856277,
-0.3582024872303009,
0.16000723838806152,
-0.9291771650314331,
-0.06503400206565857,
1.1134108304977417,
0.1909840703010559,
0.8718861937522888,
0.14543083310127258,
0.3884672522544861,
0.23960822820663452,
0.010402236133813858,
-0.4509355127811432,
0.46249276399612427,
-0.019070684909820557,
-0.5590951442718506,
-0.29181772470474243,
-0.3085705637931824,
-1.2434892654418945,
0.4003976583480835,
-0.11803029477596283,
-0.718235194683075,
0.30036023259162903,
-0.4717382788658142,
-0.1256486028432846,
0.16629770398139954,
-1.1237963438034058,
0.9964900612831116,
-0.25845974683761597,
-0.1686020791530609,
-0.13889677822589874,
-0.5562819838523865,
0.19523948431015015,
-0.6237801909446716,
0.2732430100440979,
0.08219566941261292,
0.12726961076259613,
0.946091890335083,
-0.4142889380455017,
0.7286073565483093,
0.023104334250092506,
0.02803424559533596,
0.20960552990436554,
0.4105919897556305,
0.3744608759880066,
-0.304801881313324,
0.23148572444915771,
0.5651598572731018,
0.36124446988105774,
-0.4619656503200531,
-0.7180267572402954,
0.7683963775634766,
-0.8726162910461426,
-0.7725225687026978,
-0.36876389384269714,
-0.5813571214675903,
-0.10599642246961594,
0.7248169183731079,
0.08543711155653,
0.48452627658843994,
-0.3526846468448639,
0.035055194050073624,
0.14409814774990082,
-0.308515340089798,
0.6840909719467163,
0.8341335654258728,
-0.6536893248558044,
0.11022590845823288,
0.8745145797729492,
0.3546445071697235,
0.8709034323692322,
0.41910049319267273,
0.054741039872169495,
-0.1280321627855301,
-0.4408368468284607,
-0.5716158747673035,
0.3696468770503998,
-0.9681033492088318,
0.4014054536819458,
-0.7501751780509949,
-0.34287920594215393,
-0.6792271733283997,
-0.17227432131767273,
-0.5626005530357361,
-0.8143277168273926,
-0.14627522230148315,
-0.20948275923728943,
0.021327294409275055,
0.8406713604927063,
-0.2728852927684784,
0.3571644723415375,
-0.7928541302680969,
-0.024009764194488525,
0.23547546565532684,
0.34596189856529236,
-0.17470289766788483,
-0.5195696949958801,
-0.402497798204422,
-0.16605834662914276,
0.5509843230247498,
-0.6233143210411072,
0.4251338243484497,
0.06948056817054749,
0.9202287793159485,
0.281136155128479,
0.14828287065029144,
0.6696329116821289,
-0.1479908972978592,
0.6256623864173889,
0.21948817372322083,
-1.1922893524169922,
0.1745762825012207,
-0.1811700165271759,
0.47406208515167236,
0.35890018939971924,
0.33809566497802734,
-0.7212268710136414,
-0.47017401456832886,
-0.5393482446670532,
-0.5070242285728455,
1.1507681608200073,
0.14895270764827728,
0.19956444203853607,
0.2537987232208252,
-0.4127154052257538,
0.37191736698150635,
0.19334876537322998,
-0.8268541097640991,
-0.07339969277381897,
0.03334067016839981,
0.3704591989517212,
-0.12489975243806839,
0.037638116627931595,
0.21670086681842804,
-0.1737549751996994,
0.10230112820863724,
0.06035997346043587,
-0.023817433044314384,
0.007900921627879143,
-0.5309645533561707,
-0.5637555718421936,
0.03962421789765358,
0.6256955862045288,
0.9242305755615234,
-0.1557028740644455,
0.2955596446990967,
0.20702964067459106,
-0.6368663311004639,
-0.10991927981376648,
-0.09104559570550919,
-0.01479057502001524,
0.2548806965351105,
0.7534925937652588,
0.964034914970398,
0.576482355594635,
-0.5738218426704407,
0.5900223851203918,
0.02841639518737793,
0.13695232570171356,
-0.21418197453022003,
0.03915770724415779,
-0.1737348884344101,
-0.05979020893573761,
0.2686712145805359,
0.5074147582054138,
-0.13952380418777466,
-0.8881452679634094,
0.21879753470420837,
0.2634566128253937,
-0.6109376549720764,
-0.579708993434906,
0.3160708248615265,
0.17052525281906128,
-0.3434700667858124,
0.33707091212272644,
0.17404963076114655,
-0.8307845592498779,
0.7076628804206848,
0.7808061838150024,
0.48502370715141296,
-0.4225560426712036,
0.2470783293247223,
0.20525556802749634,
0.5299909114837646,
0.13237334787845612,
-0.29523006081581116,
-0.019732410088181496,
-0.552262544631958,
-0.49560603499412537,
-0.3326503038406372,
-0.3126426935195923,
-0.3063947558403015,
-0.5095243453979492,
0.5413957834243774,
-0.10430900007486343,
0.09404131025075912,
-0.13603827357292175,
-0.2148636430501938,
-0.890812873840332,
-0.20437049865722656,
0.03805257007479668,
0.708641529083252,
-0.9207431077957153,
1.136759638786316,
0.43337899446487427,
-0.6173483729362488,
-0.9523659348487854,
0.018357060849666595,
-0.3359939455986023,
-1.116538643836975,
0.9301849603652954,
-0.08312993496656418,
-0.1706143617630005,
0.10062345862388611,
0.14821757376194,
-1.3469775915145874,
0.6851654052734375,
0.28192684054374695,
-0.06299526244401932,
-0.09549029171466827,
0.527804970741272,
0.883406400680542,
-0.4891243577003479,
0.3885343074798584,
0.4872525632381439,
0.5276792645454407,
0.23129819333553314,
-1.5186480283737183,
0.1469990462064743,
-0.2405732423067093,
-0.049094464629888535,
0.21807987987995148,
-0.4426949620246887,
0.9556728005409241,
-0.5250421762466431,
-0.5308861136436462,
-0.1382453739643097,
0.20866040885448456,
-0.49573710560798645,
0.2620506286621094,
0.126487597823143,
0.03784460946917534,
0.4271298348903656,
0.34139907360076904,
1.2943795919418335,
-0.46592769026756287,
0.052383825182914734,
0.8519829511642456,
-0.34325820207595825,
0.738450288772583,
0.7833975553512573,
-0.1861942708492279,
0.6153578758239746,
0.12588389217853546,
0.17751412093639374,
0.5238476991653442,
0.19374459981918335,
0.06109262630343437,
0.06205841526389122,
-0.2122943252325058,
-0.5151952505111694,
0.832225501537323,
0.06946535408496857,
-0.5257236957550049,
-0.24385510385036469,
0.2514878213405609,
0.048231691122055054,
-0.18454623222351074,
-0.2567793130874634,
0.6764441132545471,
0.022224683314561844,
-1.014135718345642,
0.4838869273662567,
-0.09678276628255844,
0.48084914684295654,
-0.9249248504638672,
0.006686809938400984,
-0.3647427558898926,
0.24663680791854858,
-0.1729702353477478,
-0.49257099628448486,
0.5213748812675476,
-0.25632333755493164,
0.07051151245832443,
-0.39303719997406006,
0.9831079244613647,
-0.5801886320114136,
-0.5218477249145508,
0.6357842087745667,
1.0687605142593384,
0.20315726101398468,
0.10389876365661621,
-0.17685158550739288,
-0.06512468308210373,
-0.02788075990974903,
-0.11879361420869827,
0.8337419033050537,
0.5880248546600342,
-0.10324594378471375,
0.5332735180854797,
1.0467664003372192,
0.4136834740638733,
0.42178380489349365,
0.14792463183403015,
0.6017771363258362,
-0.5636456608772278,
-0.4909953773021698,
-0.5157529711723328,
0.11143679171800613,
0.1658540815114975,
-0.20072585344314575,
1.1812851428985596,
0.33466869592666626,
1.0878852605819702,
-0.3503446578979492,
0.7287794947624207,
-0.046307194977998734,
0.3227359652519226,
-0.365744024515152,
0.9755169749259949,
-0.3414168357849121,
0.2266325056552887,
-0.5646839141845703,
-0.9601840376853943,
-0.14687854051589966,
0.3266630172729492,
-0.3226878345012665,
0.04782576858997345,
1.1746906042099,
0.7704410552978516,
0.0954386293888092,
-0.2860609292984009,
0.6680421233177185,
-0.06581594049930573,
0.02739780768752098,
0.4739908277988434,
1.0473673343658447,
-0.28593316674232483,
0.8260293006896973,
-0.14445100724697113,
-0.10112595558166504,
-0.031620968133211136,
-0.8942793011665344,
-0.9901946783065796,
-0.6155910491943359,
-0.2700508236885071,
-0.19022059440612793,
-0.07094870507717133,
0.6601495146751404,
0.7042962908744812,
-0.7309336066246033,
-0.5600201487541199,
0.11028622835874557,
0.4243653118610382,
-0.27904170751571655,
-0.23393400013446808,
0.327783465385437,
-0.3651134669780731,
-0.9413250684738159,
0.31962621212005615,
0.1584656536579132,
0.13989774882793427,
-0.5482704639434814,
0.0296003557741642,
-0.31521493196487427,
0.20614489912986755,
0.42033445835113525,
0.3404863178730011,
-0.47695446014404297,
-0.240774005651474,
0.2859204113483429,
-0.19863508641719818,
-0.11810819059610367,
1.295310139656067,
-0.6795934438705444,
0.5621607303619385,
0.5563449263572693,
0.4477727711200714,
0.5025169849395752,
-0.24929320812225342,
1.0004217624664307,
-0.6445041298866272,
0.27158793807029724,
-0.2316882610321045,
0.3993118405342102,
0.18544144928455353,
-0.44799819588661194,
0.39137768745422363,
0.624008297920227,
-0.09645740687847137,
-0.8345293402671814,
-0.06001150608062744,
-0.8814886212348938,
-0.4470674693584442,
1.473915457725525,
-0.2035028636455536,
-0.35219743847846985,
-0.34031495451927185,
-0.34260180592536926,
0.2106403112411499,
-0.12004914879798889,
0.43501973152160645,
1.0547734498977661,
-0.01974571868777275,
-0.28937768936157227,
-0.3965776562690735,
0.4794079065322876,
0.4420401453971863,
-0.5162181258201599,
-0.08621827512979507,
0.06283480674028397,
0.488071084022522,
0.2238752543926239,
0.6216710209846497,
-0.09454506635665894,
0.2130434364080429,
0.4776056408882141,
0.04810405522584915,
-0.01800459437072277,
-0.3012022376060486,
-0.1778835952281952,
0.20375004410743713,
0.07316503673791885,
-0.07420118898153305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18796v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18796v2
|
Replacing Judges with Juries: Evaluating LLM Generations with a Panel of Diverse Models
| 2024-04-29T15:33:23 | 2024-05-01T15:37:11 |
Pat Verga, Sebastian Hofstatter, Sophia Althammer, Yixuan Su, Aleksandra Piktus, Arkady Arkhangorodsky, Minjie Xu, Naomi White, Patrick Lewis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) have become more advanced, they have outpaced
our abilities to accurately evaluate their quality. Not only is finding data to
adequately probe particular model properties difficult, but evaluating the
correctness of a model's freeform generation alone is a challenge. To address
this, many evaluations now rely on using LLMs themselves as judges to score the
quality of outputs from other LLMs. Evaluations most commonly use a single
large model like GPT4. While this method has grown in popularity, it is costly,
has been shown to introduce intramodel bias, and in this work, we find that
very large models are often unnecessary. We propose instead to evaluate models
using a Panel of LLm evaluators (PoLL). Across three distinct judge settings
and spanning six different datasets, we find that using a PoLL composed of a
larger number of smaller models outperforms a single large judge, exhibits less
intra-model bias due to its composition of disjoint model families, and does so
while being over seven times less expensive.
|
[
-0.549156904220581,
-0.08281407505273819,
1.0138577222824097,
0.04046488180756569,
-0.45527008175849915,
0.1857001781463623,
-0.25203943252563477,
-0.2449471354484558,
-0.1043819859623909,
0.6175777316093445,
-0.33568885922431946,
-0.1992253214120865,
-0.5930939316749573,
0.024322211742401123,
-0.31002628803253174,
0.9516841769218445,
0.010851912200450897,
0.46297401189804077,
-0.3714953064918518,
-0.08234448730945587,
-0.08587108552455902,
-0.24144764244556427,
-0.3651587665081024,
-0.5968908071517944,
0.4360213577747345,
0.19900552928447723,
0.7663740515708923,
0.16275137662887573,
0.31795936822891235,
0.3183797597885132,
-0.3886622190475464,
0.3081657290458679,
-0.5987163782119751,
-0.0451924204826355,
-0.3587014973163605,
-0.565482497215271,
-0.19207656383514404,
0.4305962026119232,
0.6048601269721985,
0.9063851833343506,
0.04499615728855133,
0.046749163419008255,
0.2120964080095291,
0.66762375831604,
-0.48119017481803894,
0.19038446247577667,
-0.8026940226554871,
0.0905144065618515,
-0.1476290076971054,
-0.18425767123699188,
-0.600126326084137,
-0.7484798431396484,
-0.06924016773700714,
-0.2556614875793457,
0.26147839426994324,
-0.07983078062534332,
0.5728912353515625,
0.10238263756036758,
-0.708957314491272,
0.13062945008277893,
-0.6945327520370483,
0.7386628985404968,
-1.0252139568328857,
0.22707024216651917,
0.3368220329284668,
0.4418344795703888,
-0.344251424074173,
-0.5172068476676941,
-0.36998915672302246,
-0.5585078597068787,
0.15991468727588654,
0.235385924577713,
-0.319992333650589,
0.10390862822532654,
0.14398832619190216,
0.5221883654594421,
-0.33568549156188965,
0.4623364508152008,
-0.396247923374176,
-0.09795007109642029,
0.6366986632347107,
0.27519491314888,
0.13208669424057007,
-0.11045015603303909,
-0.21543797850608826,
0.07015513628721237,
-0.9310410022735596,
-0.05645934119820595,
0.8442801833152771,
0.436479389667511,
0.20191307365894318,
0.5261957049369812,
-0.31987234950065613,
0.5807809233665466,
0.3398530185222626,
-0.11929935216903687,
0.11557425558567047,
-0.4109969139099121,
-0.138962522149086,
-0.39679887890815735,
0.8330624103546143,
0.40287864208221436,
0.1467747688293457,
-0.08750399202108383,
-0.3829811215400696,
-0.014108236879110336,
0.19551067054271698,
-0.7886598110198975,
-0.14086191356182098,
-0.008301250636577606,
-0.7034035921096802,
-0.4573017954826355,
-0.02805599942803383,
-0.8723282217979431,
-0.608250081539154,
-0.43122440576553345,
0.40702739357948303,
-0.00221534026786685,
-0.09018448740243912,
-0.1823590099811554,
-0.2530181407928467,
0.041186921298503876,
0.7073239088058472,
-0.695405900478363,
0.2187463641166687,
0.5908527970314026,
0.5627037882804871,
-0.10352367162704468,
-0.08380799740552902,
-0.7998648285865784,
-0.43877607583999634,
-0.49354031682014465,
0.8538084030151367,
-0.8452986478805542,
-0.685295820236206,
-0.20483826100826263,
-0.21242734789848328,
0.08340821415185928,
-0.8411464691162109,
0.3478149473667145,
-0.6035528779029846,
0.6399429440498352,
-0.3654629588127136,
-0.7419999241828918,
-0.0357428677380085,
0.11244390159845352,
-0.7723578810691833,
0.7552661299705505,
0.5220609903335571,
-0.5117046236991882,
0.6565316915512085,
-0.3734719753265381,
-0.05675783380866051,
0.005321720149368048,
-0.3314468562602997,
-0.3675227463245392,
0.48378390073776245,
0.5719912648200989,
0.2761935591697693,
-0.519957423210144,
0.5263698697090149,
-0.7476549744606018,
-0.5538005828857422,
0.1629718542098999,
-0.8697317838668823,
0.7153831124305725,
0.2786499559879303,
-0.3611704409122467,
0.26376765966415405,
-0.7966059446334839,
-0.0537528395652771,
-0.23436878621578217,
-0.5691919922828674,
-0.2931903004646301,
0.06054093316197395,
-0.08049102127552032,
0.3029792606830597,
-0.2288280427455902,
-0.6442562341690063,
0.18546143174171448,
-0.5188078284263611,
0.35499605536460876,
1.1222705841064453,
0.08148142695426941,
0.4283113181591034,
-0.4497223496437073,
0.8146682381629944,
0.00442644115537405,
0.25789907574653625,
0.2618480324745178,
-0.6329730749130249,
-0.6547800302505493,
-0.3200090229511261,
0.3744063377380371,
-0.06802836805582047,
-0.8195782899856567,
0.22147969901561737,
-0.3272157311439514,
-0.7629154324531555,
-0.5102095603942871,
0.21484492719173431,
0.1592818796634674,
0.12039685249328613,
0.09873631596565247,
-0.35365206003189087,
-0.1323472261428833,
-0.9788328409194946,
-0.35627907514572144,
-0.3099409341812134,
-0.10978014022111893,
0.2003495842218399,
0.4921870529651642,
-0.04551837593317032,
0.9785207509994507,
-0.03352208808064461,
0.3610038459300995,
-0.4478420615196228,
-0.08970731496810913,
0.35420143604278564,
0.25554582476615906,
0.6384251117706299,
-0.3168364465236664,
-0.2805120348930359,
0.015077387914061546,
-0.22621002793312073,
-0.4948650002479553,
0.036960452795028687,
0.08285457640886307,
-0.036904476583004,
0.19020766019821167,
-0.5848972797393799,
0.3231431841850281,
0.841795027256012,
-0.3498077392578125,
0.7274064421653748,
0.1276015043258667,
0.213771253824234,
-0.6731976270675659,
-0.1640157252550125,
-0.07002800703048706,
-0.34018102288246155,
-0.4160724878311157,
0.14094501733779907,
-0.0336519256234169,
-0.10599180310964584,
-0.4727940261363983,
0.8257178068161011,
-0.6641695499420166,
-0.18037232756614685,
-0.3882450461387634,
0.22687889635562897,
0.3246663212776184,
0.20989185571670532,
-0.5101127028465271,
0.9710268974304199,
-0.028860382735729218,
-0.3872404098510742,
0.4531262218952179,
0.2016492784023285,
-0.9217786192893982,
0.39927423000335693,
-0.19252069294452667,
0.09348668158054352,
-0.27143141627311707,
0.629148006439209,
-1.1013530492782593,
-0.06577073037624359,
-0.0052541708573699,
-0.023826709017157555,
0.30171701312065125,
-0.14469119906425476,
-0.263370543718338,
-0.5576515197753906,
-0.5331488847732544,
0.2612459361553192,
0.3687155246734619,
-1.0515222549438477,
0.5854872465133667,
0.14591366052627563,
-0.26429441571235657,
-0.3822404742240906,
-0.47198861837387085,
0.15713539719581604,
-0.3988625109195709,
-0.6190781593322754,
0.13851486146450043,
-0.009909005835652351,
-0.538884699344635,
0.0207578856498003,
-0.337099552154541,
0.1650451421737671,
0.09814555943012238,
0.0222129225730896,
0.21962232887744904,
-0.21192245185375214,
0.13697731494903564,
0.08373631536960602,
-0.014327962882816792,
-0.13798275589942932,
-0.08135109394788742,
0.5769644379615784,
0.10728354007005692,
-0.8445242643356323,
-0.3519943952560425,
0.24635449051856995,
0.7291579246520996,
-0.35472214221954346,
0.2847934067249298,
0.20604275166988373,
0.06972898542881012,
-0.4628923535346985,
-0.925001323223114,
-0.1304483711719513,
-0.4755791425704956,
0.3624846041202545,
-0.4580259621143341,
-1.2498679161071777,
0.3516712486743927,
0.0021320264786481857,
0.10350165516138077,
0.5033566951751709,
0.7394084334373474,
0.20993967354297638,
0.9750244617462158,
0.3134872615337372,
-0.2683686316013336,
0.4938270151615143,
0.19678251445293427,
0.3910115957260132,
-0.9755263328552246,
0.0757426992058754,
-0.6114611029624939,
-0.34491291642189026,
-0.7252917885780334,
-0.5482661724090576,
0.4927672743797302,
-0.07546083629131317,
-0.25002697110176086,
-0.018679140135645866,
-0.18431448936462402,
0.4347262382507324,
0.7876136898994446,
0.27913698554039,
0.415448397397995,
-0.11536554247140884,
-0.2776392996311188,
0.1861257404088974,
-0.6272428631782532,
-0.7349192500114441,
1.4339470863342285,
0.32627594470977783,
0.8921069502830505,
0.09857148677110672,
0.8344637751579285,
-0.011212926357984543,
0.8823902606964111,
-0.6708084940910339,
0.6127070188522339,
-0.4352647662162781,
-0.6105385422706604,
-0.12494198977947235,
-0.7763373255729675,
-0.7668224573135376,
0.8856584429740906,
0.06937394291162491,
-0.7769902348518372,
0.4925330579280853,
-0.14000707864761353,
-0.7129063606262207,
0.586004376411438,
-0.44616276025772095,
0.6607361435890198,
-0.23806005716323853,
-0.3950027525424957,
-0.23141588270664215,
-0.24605000019073486,
0.8902561664581299,
-0.2914692163467407,
0.20048771798610687,
-0.32817915081977844,
0.3174421191215515,
0.507233738899231,
-0.6968907713890076,
0.8145594000816345,
-0.2561291754245758,
-0.18461452424526215,
0.41696199774742126,
0.12098611891269684,
0.4159485101699829,
-0.05169250816106796,
-0.39197951555252075,
-0.20872244238853455,
-0.018105754628777504,
-0.06389656662940979,
-0.592397153377533,
0.7401419878005981,
-0.8376395106315613,
-0.8391032218933105,
-0.27795279026031494,
-0.42831552028656006,
-0.634740948677063,
-0.3014112412929535,
0.09333473443984985,
0.4486636519432068,
-0.20658233761787415,
0.2975858747959137,
0.07784102857112885,
-0.39987286925315857,
0.433756947517395,
0.3323923945426941,
-0.5212871432304382,
-0.5534932613372803,
0.6247376799583435,
-0.017142295837402344,
0.4967554211616516,
0.1247907355427742,
0.5156036615371704,
-0.41738569736480713,
-0.4451179802417755,
-0.39893287420272827,
0.045309606939554214,
-0.6620546579360962,
-0.1936941295862198,
-0.4135415256023407,
0.05462431535124779,
-0.2475757896900177,
0.2382453829050064,
-0.3077424168586731,
-0.5974607467651367,
-0.18706531822681427,
-0.3804771304130554,
-0.060512974858284,
0.6822148561477661,
0.006456004921346903,
0.42932772636413574,
-0.7613622546195984,
0.19856835901737213,
0.7697665691375732,
0.35776591300964355,
-0.022116994485259056,
-0.6822564005851746,
0.25334134697914124,
-0.1869998425245285,
-0.3262481987476349,
-0.893770158290863,
0.21245262026786804,
-0.017079008743166924,
0.8071156144142151,
0.5174360275268555,
-0.30504730343818665,
0.7479007244110107,
-0.49019381403923035,
0.9956889152526855,
0.26191794872283936,
-0.9372233748435974,
0.25359848141670227,
-0.31266504526138306,
0.19855637848377228,
0.690024197101593,
-0.12558551132678986,
-0.32704466581344604,
-0.6276409029960632,
-0.5483680367469788,
-0.7186771631240845,
0.703654944896698,
-0.08491958677768707,
0.2821909487247467,
0.07787414640188217,
0.1235269084572792,
0.493510901927948,
0.39372649788856506,
-0.9131146669387817,
0.30566754937171936,
-0.09282714128494263,
-0.0824286937713623,
-0.09524013847112656,
-0.37764936685562134,
-0.19860900938510895,
-0.30684006214141846,
0.7927998900413513,
-0.1589643657207489,
-0.05295362323522568,
-0.08914066851139069,
0.15164321660995483,
-0.12919625639915466,
0.6409612894058228,
0.30671170353889465,
0.781521737575531,
-0.035108551383018494,
0.12602250277996063,
0.006637978833168745,
0.15121743083000183,
0.36030593514442444,
0.15245456993579865,
-0.3256981372833252,
0.152719646692276,
0.33960115909576416,
1.0983225107192993,
0.13564257323741913,
-0.5713995695114136,
0.6840886473655701,
0.1756373792886734,
-0.2972705662250519,
0.08736451715230942,
0.16306762397289276,
0.16398602724075317,
0.45848548412323,
0.016449352726340294,
0.02587662823498249,
0.03433695808053017,
-0.7347129583358765,
0.15295124053955078,
0.5767000317573547,
-0.3700975477695465,
-0.04646965488791466,
0.776026725769043,
0.35315462946891785,
0.10525987297296524,
0.5467548370361328,
-0.231609508395195,
-0.4904671013355255,
0.5789754986763,
0.2624971270561218,
0.9959099292755127,
-0.3219737112522125,
0.30520665645599365,
0.07370025664567947,
0.4609586298465729,
-0.30765002965927124,
0.11127355694770813,
0.23665088415145874,
-0.8283965587615967,
-0.6229093074798584,
-0.8206455707550049,
-0.6476253867149353,
0.42275741696357727,
-0.30529919266700745,
0.04459865018725395,
-0.41573014855384827,
-0.3948432207107544,
-0.14515522122383118,
-0.11358713358640671,
-0.7521770000457764,
0.13015766441822052,
0.35579994320869446,
0.90659099817276,
-0.9909536242485046,
0.57700115442276,
0.4247278869152069,
-0.397816926240921,
-0.7785050868988037,
-0.047467008233070374,
0.15554089844226837,
-0.6548005938529968,
0.6409399509429932,
0.17425785958766937,
0.05519941449165344,
-0.434423565864563,
-0.5231221914291382,
-0.7517204284667969,
0.6310622692108154,
0.31828057765960693,
-0.8978683948516846,
0.01752813160419464,
-0.12508994340896606,
0.49416399002075195,
-0.3453642427921295,
0.6740259528160095,
0.7041288614273071,
0.7464277148246765,
-0.21679431200027466,
-1.0631428956985474,
-0.045374225825071335,
-0.1393478959798813,
0.23592418432235718,
0.054685648530721664,
-0.7953734397888184,
1.0606199502944946,
0.01976492628455162,
-0.07385121285915375,
0.15460553765296936,
0.40719690918922424,
0.4792271852493286,
0.14187122881412506,
0.8007804155349731,
0.38048070669174194,
0.7162109613418579,
-0.20157259702682495,
1.0432684421539307,
-0.16855968534946442,
0.35950013995170593,
1.324375867843628,
-0.7336969971656799,
0.607644259929657,
0.5581117272377014,
-0.5515714287757874,
0.240428164601326,
0.5447154641151428,
-0.22246870398521423,
0.35151204466819763,
0.6081196665763855,
-0.4499029219150543,
-0.5495898127555847,
0.2693610191345215,
-0.13767369091510773,
0.6947000026702881,
-0.05772308260202408,
-0.4252827763557434,
-0.6768420338630676,
0.023577718064188957,
0.011316095478832722,
0.2686610519886017,
-0.21791775524616241,
0.46036556363105774,
0.23190723359584808,
-0.725311279296875,
0.016898667439818382,
0.08418425917625427,
0.5370498299598694,
-0.561112105846405,
0.18813596665859222,
-0.5217956900596619,
0.12302672117948532,
-0.06650765240192413,
-0.6464186310768127,
-0.05139407142996788,
0.1536996215581894,
0.052508872002363205,
-0.2766609489917755,
0.4606947898864746,
-0.3176061511039734,
-0.7708325982093811,
0.3721589148044586,
0.9633848071098328,
0.1948704570531845,
-0.2363748848438263,
-0.4000985622406006,
0.010495031252503395,
0.20259982347488403,
-0.7256399989128113,
0.33781713247299194,
0.18626941740512848,
-0.3063332736492157,
0.6157594919204712,
0.7402625679969788,
0.3074544370174408,
0.1027282327413559,
0.7067995071411133,
1.1242518424987793,
-0.5714584589004517,
-0.30177783966064453,
-0.8368396759033203,
0.33627402782440186,
-0.13731561601161957,
-0.3645539879798889,
0.6176325678825378,
0.5450229048728943,
0.7607616186141968,
-0.010312396101653576,
1.0101429224014282,
0.31217268109321594,
0.5860775113105774,
-0.5568779706954956,
0.6415181756019592,
-0.570426344871521,
0.36914533376693726,
-0.2573905289173126,
-1.2531514167785645,
-0.09458766877651215,
0.44087663292884827,
-0.4794330298900604,
0.4456879496574402,
0.5305402874946594,
0.7023836374282837,
-0.1202811524271965,
0.3113762140274048,
0.5143099427223206,
0.28307512402534485,
0.8327401876449585,
0.496616393327713,
1.286400556564331,
-0.01827794872224331,
0.3629905581474304,
-0.08979067951440811,
-0.38191092014312744,
-0.15919238328933716,
-0.7400690913200378,
-0.8675982356071472,
0.015928249806165695,
-0.12296053767204285,
-0.06267037242650986,
-0.06376320123672485,
1.0035394430160522,
0.40165916085243225,
-0.7653758525848389,
-0.23875580728054047,
0.4258735775947571,
0.04217608645558357,
-0.07000797241926193,
-0.20458555221557617,
0.24261502921581268,
-0.44508159160614014,
-0.9920685887336731,
0.9546837210655212,
0.29227662086486816,
-0.3231891393661499,
-0.4495379626750946,
0.2734580934047699,
0.18364058434963226,
0.13045930862426758,
0.6856716275215149,
-0.24299079179763794,
-0.9261283874511719,
-0.6424161195755005,
-0.5534724593162537,
-0.1049819365143776,
0.13308216631412506,
0.6371605396270752,
-0.77224200963974,
0.6206814050674438,
0.5923185348510742,
0.5722153186798096,
0.6456906795501709,
0.2597208023071289,
0.7030348777770996,
-0.2586463987827301,
-0.21107184886932373,
0.28125718235969543,
0.6822854280471802,
0.3623660206794739,
0.15884247422218323,
0.5841614007949829,
0.16281156241893768,
-0.6316056251525879,
-0.7917332649230957,
0.2603817582130432,
-0.8550238609313965,
-0.35058802366256714,
1.1710939407348633,
0.03907468169927597,
0.08555055409669876,
0.09304740279912949,
-0.24528081715106964,
-0.1103065237402916,
-0.1980668008327484,
0.6763664484024048,
0.9192637801170349,
-0.21556220948696136,
-0.10956541448831558,
-0.6570664644241333,
0.06328367441892624,
0.42384350299835205,
-0.7045475244522095,
-0.10944366455078125,
0.734872579574585,
0.5631358027458191,
-0.1192455142736435,
0.7739506959915161,
-0.4655449092388153,
-0.06680044531822205,
-0.013951617293059826,
0.060452669858932495,
0.08443853259086609,
-0.14180520176887512,
-0.4980296492576599,
0.36041688919067383,
0.2857719361782074,
0.1361682116985321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18784v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18784v1
|
Where on Earth Do Users Say They Are?: Geo-Entity Linking for Noisy Multilingual User Input
| 2024-04-29T15:18:33 | 2024-04-29T15:18:33 |
Tessa Masis, Brendan O'Connor
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Geo-entity linking is the task of linking a location mention to the
real-world geographic location. In this paper we explore the challenging task
of geo-entity linking for noisy, multilingual social media data. There are few
open-source multilingual geo-entity linking tools available and existing ones
are often rule-based, which break easily in social media settings, or
LLM-based, which are too expensive for large-scale datasets. We present a
method which represents real-world locations as averaged embeddings from
labeled user-input location names and allows for selective prediction via an
interpretable confidence score. We show that our approach improves geo-entity
linking on a global and multilingual social media dataset, and discuss progress
and problems with evaluating at different geographic granularities.
|
[
-0.6318857669830322,
-1.0181410312652588,
0.8039979934692383,
0.3311716914176941,
-0.3642350137233734,
0.13900993764400482,
-0.5070691108703613,
-1.002705693244934,
0.681684672832489,
0.0187373086810112,
-0.5398629903793335,
-0.9129539728164673,
-0.4209606945514679,
0.09835044294595718,
-0.2300758957862854,
0.6689424514770508,
-0.20159979164600372,
-0.19683019816875458,
-0.13274535536766052,
-0.05388706922531128,
0.0286950021982193,
-0.5194947123527527,
-0.5699113011360168,
0.06097647547721863,
0.7976855039596558,
0.4528982639312744,
1.0578583478927612,
0.4305187463760376,
0.25257590413093567,
0.16634993255138397,
0.02881104126572609,
0.4188336730003357,
-0.5156692862510681,
0.43032458424568176,
-0.34944915771484375,
-0.024597078561782837,
-0.05929068475961685,
-0.1877088099718094,
0.5989485383033752,
0.720055103302002,
0.010470661334693432,
0.3958095908164978,
-0.06556180864572525,
0.03228098154067993,
-0.5345995426177979,
0.3111332356929779,
-0.6624208688735962,
-0.13270404934883118,
-0.2206442803144455,
-0.015071889385581017,
0.0871005579829216,
-0.6907560229301453,
0.028894541785120964,
-0.6033421158790588,
0.3522765040397644,
0.4881448447704315,
1.0378310680389404,
0.11559890955686569,
-0.4511890411376953,
-0.2063300609588623,
-0.8189178109169006,
0.5089152455329895,
0.10528700053691864,
0.7470186352729797,
0.7682055234909058,
0.0891423225402832,
-0.10232666879892349,
-0.15912549197673798,
-0.3942131996154785,
-0.010211853310465813,
-0.08101008087396622,
-0.1989908069372177,
-0.0725829228758812,
-0.2694111764431,
0.12419184297323227,
-0.12792471051216125,
-0.22573548555374146,
-0.10600880533456802,
-0.42894184589385986,
-0.10459160059690475,
0.6561741232872009,
-0.46234938502311707,
0.28688907623291016,
-0.2143828570842743,
-0.1522107869386673,
0.35242682695388794,
-0.8751990795135498,
-0.215754434466362,
0.7382022142410278,
0.6146119832992554,
-0.15518708527088165,
0.5538511276245117,
-0.23510250449180603,
0.17782078683376312,
0.0911748930811882,
-0.07328639924526215,
0.3003382682800293,
-0.2667158544063568,
0.24263587594032288,
0.3942430317401886,
0.8703644275665283,
0.5979977250099182,
0.5159990191459656,
-0.5726726055145264,
-0.1002638190984726,
-0.2954743504524231,
0.10281071811914444,
-0.5936030149459839,
-0.26942700147628784,
0.17073574662208557,
-0.12922024726867676,
0.027966218069195747,
0.2676798105239868,
-0.601736843585968,
-0.3485916554927826,
-0.05724717676639557,
0.011761064641177654,
-0.1815601885318756,
-0.19589918851852417,
-0.2238241285085678,
0.35384029150009155,
-0.41003620624542236,
0.22696062922477722,
-0.8764760494232178,
0.06970784068107605,
0.4947037398815155,
0.7931947112083435,
0.36675217747688293,
-0.6005191802978516,
-0.20486506819725037,
0.3009999990463257,
-0.22146305441856384,
1.0663713216781616,
-0.6041306257247925,
-0.47040897607803345,
0.2793516516685486,
0.3016911447048187,
0.1730707436800003,
-0.47915881872177124,
0.6093661785125732,
-0.624073326587677,
-0.13705813884735107,
-0.8858384490013123,
0.030551761388778687,
-0.18832890689373016,
0.04123955965042114,
-0.7227610349655151,
1.5542041063308716,
-0.17021499574184418,
-0.5410394668579102,
0.671497642993927,
-0.333678275346756,
-0.7307321429252625,
0.10882505774497986,
0.12954990565776825,
-0.20047955214977264,
0.017813077196478844,
0.5346127152442932,
0.47206029295921326,
0.00972134992480278,
0.586887776851654,
-0.7093435525894165,
-0.4640192985534668,
0.2456626445055008,
-0.3120051324367523,
0.4893668293952942,
0.2794140577316284,
-0.16331110894680023,
-0.41212257742881775,
-0.5936459302902222,
-0.12306923419237137,
0.05049003288149834,
-0.4414481818675995,
-0.5194467306137085,
0.37821006774902344,
-0.17962399125099182,
0.2042197436094284,
0.4137153625488281,
-0.5082470178604126,
-0.04121299460530281,
0.02863203175365925,
0.13761931657791138,
0.40893012285232544,
0.17946721613407135,
0.5535184741020203,
0.01503639668226242,
0.29874804615974426,
-0.08674388378858566,
-0.18879295885562897,
0.15476520359516144,
-0.6409379839897156,
-0.22347292304039001,
-0.053220976144075394,
0.337350070476532,
0.465539813041687,
-0.7031087875366211,
0.20852141082286835,
-0.6485827565193176,
-0.4735299050807953,
-0.7245646715164185,
0.49103254079818726,
0.0401030108332634,
0.5048586130142212,
0.5851927995681763,
0.20437298715114594,
-0.584006130695343,
-0.5955691933631897,
-0.4183751344680786,
-0.6486234664916992,
-0.16501712799072266,
0.5646889209747314,
0.27096298336982727,
-0.05918404832482338,
0.4172501564025879,
-0.5369570851325989,
-0.22092056274414062,
-0.03169391676783562,
-0.0323093980550766,
-0.26621755957603455,
-0.11797706037759781,
0.49073296785354614,
-0.8519570231437683,
-0.8666263222694397,
-0.0996999442577362,
-0.6426012516021729,
-0.2663002014160156,
0.06519629806280136,
-0.3707204759120941,
-0.06936775892972946,
0.480342298746109,
-0.6147267818450928,
0.0713263750076294,
0.5572295784950256,
-0.22972486913204193,
0.2435779571533203,
0.04529925435781479,
0.41979169845581055,
-1.0439196825027466,
-0.227947399020195,
0.5306337475776672,
-0.2867927849292755,
-0.18395625054836273,
-0.053663212805986404,
-0.17611365020275116,
-0.1347065567970276,
-0.345753937959671,
0.48255351185798645,
-0.662711501121521,
-0.2035842388868332,
0.31561219692230225,
0.5116084218025208,
-0.15092270076274872,
0.23961259424686432,
0.08111999183893204,
0.6665541529655457,
0.49680835008621216,
-0.36412903666496277,
0.3929973244667053,
0.02160271629691124,
-0.3895076513290405,
0.6127885580062866,
-0.31632664799690247,
0.03111141547560692,
-0.1301024854183197,
0.16411659121513367,
-1.0097813606262207,
-0.5797086954116821,
0.2198653519153595,
-0.3869437873363495,
-0.0009660981013439596,
-0.48876237869262695,
-0.7686198353767395,
-0.17489050328731537,
-0.16721194982528687,
0.38640037178993225,
0.0005452100303955376,
-0.6505048274993896,
0.35535064339637756,
0.7712132334709167,
-0.4030640423297882,
-0.4022991955280304,
-0.7017883658409119,
0.3396410346031189,
-0.4345119297504425,
-0.6029621958732605,
0.4373094141483307,
0.16612106561660767,
-0.3692241907119751,
0.46961259841918945,
0.13075314462184906,
-0.2806186378002167,
0.1528286188840866,
0.4706665575504303,
-0.02935565821826458,
-0.09435136616230011,
0.40460193157196045,
-0.0050310962833464146,
0.07872441411018372,
0.29894182085990906,
-0.33146607875823975,
0.09853826463222504,
0.02841414511203766,
-0.3124772906303406,
-0.19766303896903992,
0.5162641406059265,
0.19195158779621124,
-0.029475413262844086,
0.8434140086174011,
0.7408021688461304,
-0.7692846655845642,
-0.0724601149559021,
-0.5663719773292542,
0.21671977639198303,
-0.4136427640914917,
0.3604376018047333,
-0.34331491589546204,
-0.7131556868553162,
0.7030246257781982,
-0.4103112816810608,
-0.18195633590221405,
0.13680706918239594,
0.4500598907470703,
-0.36276906728744507,
0.6829870343208313,
0.6326420307159424,
-0.16618230938911438,
0.32141417264938354,
0.34654441475868225,
0.7274411916732788,
-0.2727504372596741,
-0.32609277963638306,
-0.5856430530548096,
-0.6628385186195374,
-0.7858237624168396,
-0.4929673969745636,
0.2822085916996002,
0.22577205300331116,
-0.0713997483253479,
0.43025273084640503,
-0.04540852829813957,
0.7384774088859558,
0.5177305340766907,
0.11567037552595139,
0.13288401067256927,
0.48940223455429077,
-0.22172844409942627,
-0.2812170088291168,
-0.5551257729530334,
-0.38274508714675903,
0.703606128692627,
0.1249217614531517,
0.9463316798210144,
0.43680840730667114,
0.6574466228485107,
0.06119435280561447,
0.25574809312820435,
-0.6680132746696472,
0.2923552691936493,
-0.012049262411892414,
-0.6736109852790833,
-0.38646167516708374,
-0.22697162628173828,
-0.8787700533866882,
0.12437461316585541,
-0.6097952127456665,
-0.9643830060958862,
-0.007634076755493879,
0.1440156102180481,
-0.4309094548225403,
0.5553395748138428,
-0.6812518239021301,
0.5142754912376404,
-0.1497766375541687,
-0.499694287776947,
0.25826355814933777,
-0.5197914838790894,
0.067798912525177,
-0.06277616322040558,
0.6043022871017456,
-0.34480220079421997,
0.07809523493051529,
0.2340402752161026,
-0.04892764613032341,
0.856433629989624,
-0.23334744572639465,
-0.25436466932296753,
0.5755313038825989,
-0.03613827005028725,
0.4308122992515564,
0.40422874689102173,
-0.0913500264286995,
0.6530212163925171,
-0.4311501383781433,
-0.07196997851133347,
-0.28506192564964294,
1.2853788137435913,
-0.7824065685272217,
-0.12045196443796158,
0.05741553008556366,
-0.3499833047389984,
-0.24540658295154572,
0.07114217430353165,
0.3365703225135803,
0.3179203271865845,
-0.21065959334373474,
0.08361151069402695,
0.7544532418251038,
0.06301803886890411,
0.14964282512664795,
0.2186652421951294,
-0.13294439017772675,
-0.2655378580093384,
0.8406441807746887,
0.6130513548851013,
-0.32781052589416504,
0.28315454721450806,
-0.2256603240966797,
-0.8530843257904053,
0.013488502241671085,
-0.4048919677734375,
0.3073834776878357,
-0.7660660147666931,
-0.08484087884426117,
-0.6776173710823059,
0.14964911341667175,
-0.4006586968898773,
-0.5615745782852173,
-0.29753854870796204,
-0.23876464366912842,
-0.1391686201095581,
-0.46404045820236206,
0.058764345943927765,
0.5810037851333618,
-0.1961844563484192,
0.26511576771736145,
-0.4643321633338928,
0.45134541392326355,
-0.0980866327881813,
0.6641227006912231,
-0.26758241653442383,
0.04408613592386246,
-0.5564342737197876,
0.020529452711343765,
-0.005504245404154062,
-1.0192053318023682,
0.17138177156448364,
0.35125353932380676,
0.4597998261451721,
0.23177944123744965,
0.04841538518667221,
0.9838187098503113,
-0.6876785755157471,
0.7015454769134521,
-0.13577137887477875,
-0.46276137232780457,
0.5840904116630554,
0.02242138981819153,
0.07284079492092133,
0.5039084553718567,
0.8549748063087463,
-0.550718367099762,
-0.606238603591919,
-0.3902600109577179,
-1.031333327293396,
0.07095347344875336,
-0.2549073100090027,
0.35227054357528687,
-0.3894912302494049,
0.5232670307159424,
-0.17031849920749664,
0.018175721168518066,
-0.7704684734344482,
-0.44817426800727844,
0.06807320564985275,
-0.1968587040901184,
-0.11787061393260956,
-0.4542991816997528,
-0.16384832561016083,
0.029295986518263817,
0.74063640832901,
-0.15581579506397247,
0.07805068790912628,
0.19770655035972595,
-0.3857889473438263,
-0.5807920098304749,
0.29086416959762573,
0.10155592858791351,
0.7189849615097046,
-0.23626621067523956,
0.3823986351490021,
0.33848416805267334,
-0.3340173363685608,
0.07393363863229752,
0.35533684492111206,
-0.5351719260215759,
0.3123689889907837,
0.04233374074101448,
0.466071754693985,
0.7481958866119385,
-0.13452525436878204,
0.23215095698833466,
-0.12599040567874908,
-0.04140647500753403,
-0.4433783292770386,
-0.1991480141878128,
0.4790732264518738,
0.3229178190231323,
0.3176749646663666,
-0.05917918309569359,
0.045350395143032074,
-0.36996281147003174,
0.04917551577091217,
0.21453331410884857,
-0.6043317914009094,
-0.5744380354881287,
1.0450085401535034,
0.22367481887340546,
-0.14383848011493683,
0.4929504692554474,
-0.4982496500015259,
-0.3640992045402527,
0.06468934565782547,
0.4719356894493103,
0.8935034871101379,
-0.19371788203716278,
0.1849362850189209,
0.85555499792099,
0.5223768353462219,
-0.022312242537736893,
0.5685492753982544,
0.015768378973007202,
-0.7895563840866089,
-0.41887417435646057,
-0.6374455094337463,
-0.18998998403549194,
-0.15742383897304535,
-0.6473230123519897,
0.5604707598686218,
-0.3864450752735138,
-0.4301699697971344,
-0.025288447737693787,
0.01028407085686922,
-0.7878263592720032,
0.15874537825584412,
0.4740433394908905,
0.5798397660255432,
-1.008358120918274,
0.5256642699241638,
1.200448751449585,
0.038808297365903854,
-0.5599330067634583,
0.13256986439228058,
0.42454177141189575,
-0.5165119767189026,
0.29664838314056396,
0.14812394976615906,
-0.4464162588119507,
-0.13342031836509705,
-0.8534033894538879,
-1.017958164215088,
0.9636846780776978,
0.3821929395198822,
-0.25986459851264954,
0.052611179649829865,
0.05450316146016121,
0.4166460335254669,
-0.23910728096961975,
-0.09739799797534943,
0.11318444460630417,
0.3295442461967468,
-0.10589396953582764,
-0.6967846751213074,
0.23066255450248718,
-0.005198672879487276,
-0.15326333045959473,
0.26990562677383423,
-0.7871497869491577,
0.3901544213294983,
-0.5894660949707031,
-0.44510987401008606,
-0.3638173043727875,
0.9079134464263916,
0.17831313610076904,
0.2593625783920288,
0.5504459738731384,
0.5469096302986145,
1.1665802001953125,
-0.3446727991104126,
0.808763325214386,
-0.7196087837219238,
0.6227792501449585,
1.233606219291687,
-0.37554818391799927,
0.9306900501251221,
0.23520325124263763,
-0.14853663742542267,
0.6442964673042297,
0.794450044631958,
-0.14973002672195435,
0.5766066908836365,
-0.1293947994709015,
-0.4139935374259949,
-0.35007625818252563,
-0.4000099003314972,
-0.049118123948574066,
0.2926020324230194,
0.5545173287391663,
-0.12984630465507507,
-0.5143322944641113,
-0.5948825478553772,
0.26484668254852295,
0.02454856038093567,
-0.2021798938512802,
0.46035832166671753,
0.06198699027299881,
-0.465760737657547,
0.08350642025470734,
0.06154468655586243,
0.4219372570514679,
-0.5371240973472595,
0.02574409358203411,
0.08583399653434753,
-0.3797045350074768,
-0.36069434881210327,
-0.91032874584198,
0.43263310194015503,
0.11291598528623581,
-0.230465829372406,
-0.15243126451969147,
0.8720275163650513,
-0.8226277232170105,
-0.6114636659622192,
0.5333938002586365,
0.5555533170700073,
0.4155339300632477,
-0.19141408801078796,
-0.6622802019119263,
-0.11701428890228271,
-0.14701628684997559,
-0.19285400211811066,
0.18280752003192902,
0.7947933077812195,
-0.3198171555995941,
0.7833330631256104,
0.8091985583305359,
0.1271558254957199,
0.1347818225622177,
0.27684032917022705,
0.5532863140106201,
-0.6851815581321716,
-0.5304630398750305,
-0.6945933699607849,
0.20481310784816742,
0.14779189229011536,
-0.34234869480133057,
0.7217895984649658,
0.4985315799713135,
1.1546790599822998,
0.43756723403930664,
0.9727008938789368,
-0.061037853360176086,
0.3350523114204407,
-0.285309761762619,
0.5531827807426453,
-0.5253380537033081,
0.23293103277683258,
-0.14779406785964966,
-1.2533833980560303,
-0.4069407880306244,
0.49647843837738037,
-0.18824493885040283,
0.013659833930432796,
0.4380681812763214,
0.7419894337654114,
-0.30829867720603943,
-0.33145463466644287,
0.34984102845191956,
0.16619649529457092,
-0.06414154917001724,
0.330390602350235,
0.709211528301239,
-0.11433491855859756,
0.5293732285499573,
-0.61623615026474,
0.13085107505321503,
-0.22325852513313293,
-0.8684353232383728,
-0.5881584882736206,
-0.3843228816986084,
-0.581164538860321,
-0.5416722297668457,
-0.10879022628068924,
0.9219135642051697,
0.5867204666137695,
-0.826279878616333,
0.1921040415763855,
0.7916886210441589,
0.4339733123779297,
-0.016959261149168015,
-0.18119555711746216,
0.3153059780597687,
-0.08210388571023941,
-0.9078665375709534,
0.2819614112377167,
0.30894988775253296,
0.10841979086399078,
-0.28297320008277893,
0.16039744019508362,
-0.3190317451953888,
-0.16374492645263672,
0.3910321891307831,
0.15436367690563202,
-0.81817227602005,
-0.5731828808784485,
-0.013833909295499325,
-0.23258303105831146,
-0.10824261605739594,
0.2382156103849411,
-0.36018651723861694,
0.4349793791770935,
0.17466111481189728,
0.25299644470214844,
0.15310829877853394,
0.5486346483230591,
0.18582719564437866,
-1.1400706768035889,
-0.043991271406412125,
-0.3463228940963745,
0.6786357164382935,
0.6857183575630188,
-0.7781530618667603,
0.5557131171226501,
0.19484451413154602,
-0.5652612447738647,
-0.38398978114128113,
-0.1420312374830246,
-0.497409462928772,
0.03487304970622063,
1.537226915359497,
-0.3802381753921509,
-0.2253432720899582,
-0.3436025381088257,
0.0723738893866539,
0.13734708726406097,
-0.49136754870414734,
0.8664395809173584,
0.9506394267082214,
0.30438390374183655,
0.10412533581256866,
-0.9460029006004333,
0.3182090222835541,
-0.1751789003610611,
-0.3463957905769348,
-0.10545431077480316,
0.6827735900878906,
0.5461224317550659,
0.4207291305065155,
0.663951575756073,
0.010413706302642822,
-0.09157230705022812,
0.18641921877861023,
0.07679910212755203,
0.17262227833271027,
-0.49017009139060974,
-0.06445267796516418,
0.143480122089386,
0.037323638796806335,
0.09176138788461685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18759v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18759v2
|
Towards A Structured Overview of Use Cases for Natural Language Processing in the Legal Domain: A German Perspective
| 2024-04-29T14:56:47 | 2024-05-02T09:56:51 |
Juraj Vladika, Stephen Meisenbacher, Martina Preis, Alexandra Klymenko, Florian Matthes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
In recent years, the field of Legal Tech has risen in prevalence, as the
Natural Language Processing (NLP) and legal disciplines have combined forces to
digitalize legal processes. Amidst the steady flow of research solutions
stemming from the NLP domain, the study of use cases has fallen behind, leading
to a number of innovative technical methods without a place in practice. In
this work, we aim to build a structured overview of Legal Tech use cases,
grounded in NLP literature, but also supplemented by voices from legal practice
in Germany. Based upon a Systematic Literature Review, we identify seven
categories of NLP technologies for the legal domain, which are then studied in
juxtaposition to 22 legal use cases. In the investigation of these use cases,
we identify 15 ethical, legal, and social aspects (ELSA), shedding light on the
potential concerns of digitally transforming the legal domain.
|
[
-0.5269299745559692,
-0.8331149220466614,
0.6841740608215332,
-0.04985387995839119,
-0.4676022231578827,
0.10942669957876205,
-0.11539743095636368,
-0.563503623008728,
0.1835944950580597,
0.8329632878303528,
-0.2802093029022217,
-0.7621593475341797,
-0.3833569586277008,
0.11948040872812271,
-0.8241144418716431,
1.0223382711410522,
0.05796852707862854,
0.192612886428833,
0.03093884512782097,
-0.27539849281311035,
-0.6238386631011963,
-0.7686464190483093,
-0.5909370183944702,
-0.3296924829483032,
0.19996093213558197,
0.15862974524497986,
0.6846611499786377,
0.27464747428894043,
0.4395889937877655,
0.31345510482788086,
-0.20563817024230957,
-0.48097172379493713,
0.03721184283494949,
0.06887073814868927,
-0.21583160758018494,
-0.3091437518596649,
-0.5409601926803589,
-0.07760682702064514,
0.4611949026584625,
0.5762605667114258,
-0.5640294551849365,
0.07924523204565048,
-0.2507301867008209,
0.6190348267555237,
-0.4499005377292633,
-0.04992471635341644,
-0.4122280478477478,
0.5240500569343567,
-0.24095380306243896,
-0.34104999899864197,
-0.22308601438999176,
-0.13234567642211914,
0.09472029656171799,
-0.5952067971229553,
0.4388170838356018,
0.05780770257115364,
0.7750318646430969,
0.1998058557510376,
-0.6211940050125122,
-0.4699840843677521,
-1.0033026933670044,
0.4380472004413605,
-0.868350625038147,
0.24529221653938293,
0.2721812427043915,
0.5881655812263489,
-0.3053779900074005,
-1.0703126192092896,
-0.5739622116088867,
-0.029589302837848663,
-0.1715116649866104,
0.06882254034280777,
-0.5379273891448975,
0.19815637171268463,
0.45508572459220886,
0.14034782350063324,
-0.5919461250305176,
0.1439213901758194,
-0.5032373070716858,
-0.28121495246887207,
0.7073341012001038,
-0.10815820097923279,
0.5134873986244202,
0.06434521824121475,
0.20652659237384796,
0.12323115766048431,
-0.5546982288360596,
0.23824840784072876,
0.5463399291038513,
0.1890091896057129,
0.04224509745836258,
0.7019528150558472,
-0.013854669407010078,
0.880420982837677,
-0.034532755613327026,
-0.06613780558109283,
0.497624933719635,
-0.40549808740615845,
-0.2762227952480316,
0.22685982286930084,
0.6523096561431885,
0.3117507994174957,
0.5262593030929565,
-0.10419631004333496,
-0.3187702000141144,
-0.4518023133277893,
0.8160157799720764,
-0.5141962170600891,
0.42753270268440247,
0.6024388670921326,
-0.5453249216079712,
-0.0750485360622406,
0.22383710741996765,
-0.4045053720474243,
-0.3984534740447998,
-0.4723875820636749,
-0.31895577907562256,
-0.3617423474788666,
-0.25112706422805786,
0.4746253490447998,
-0.44972938299179077,
0.5288522839546204,
0.060341235250234604,
-0.6939955949783325,
0.6351800560951233,
0.9738438129425049,
0.5495594143867493,
0.3082009553909302,
0.16525574028491974,
-0.4342881441116333,
0.10659672319889069,
-0.2500612735748291,
0.8870432376861572,
-0.4277118444442749,
-0.559550404548645,
0.6582485437393188,
0.020886942744255066,
0.25410085916519165,
-0.6639275550842285,
1.130395531654358,
-0.7532915472984314,
0.28337758779525757,
0.10102139413356781,
-0.5227504968643188,
-0.43699148297309875,
0.12385397404432297,
-0.8843103051185608,
0.8833664059638977,
-0.24801836907863617,
-0.8736626505851746,
0.9590042233467102,
-1.0418521165847778,
-0.9563694000244141,
0.6085699796676636,
-0.2592443823814392,
-0.3239665925502777,
0.3119889199733734,
-0.12288959324359894,
0.36559268832206726,
0.05613001063466072,
0.8298746347427368,
-0.014440716244280338,
-0.3935110569000244,
-0.13480891287326813,
0.36855974793434143,
1.0915838479995728,
0.2220812886953354,
-0.36485543847084045,
0.2848624885082245,
-0.8734431266784668,
-0.2125277817249298,
-0.04460378736257553,
-0.1555059254169464,
-0.6654638051986694,
0.1433219164609909,
0.3390909731388092,
0.5590114593505859,
-0.17596805095672607,
-0.5765796303749084,
-0.21542604267597198,
-0.40743640065193176,
0.6617498397827148,
0.1325731873512268,
0.06829579919576645,
0.5552316904067993,
-0.16321997344493866,
0.7883822917938232,
-0.1995096653699875,
0.10616540163755417,
0.09928619116544724,
-0.6232585310935974,
-0.4203413724899292,
-0.1036207303404808,
0.493890643119812,
0.6648679971694946,
-0.7562609314918518,
0.5312167406082153,
-0.3353065252304077,
-0.30210810899734497,
-0.8196541666984558,
-0.16941142082214355,
0.032517045736312866,
0.4676738381385803,
0.11201229691505432,
-0.07457392662763596,
-0.540630578994751,
-1.323889970779419,
-0.48617470264434814,
-0.2704063057899475,
-0.21729148924350739,
0.4675973951816559,
0.7220462560653687,
-0.18868549168109894,
1.204397201538086,
0.11810213327407837,
-0.4771657884120941,
-0.3209995925426483,
0.17537876963615417,
0.46497321128845215,
0.03604887053370476,
0.5563815832138062,
-1.2598190307617188,
-0.36817821860313416,
0.06010543927550316,
-0.874675452709198,
-0.20358909666538239,
-0.17189709842205048,
0.13589484989643097,
0.3318590819835663,
0.6274223923683167,
-0.40090352296829224,
0.3641792833805084,
-0.06764257699251175,
-0.822509229183197,
0.27228397130966187,
-0.25982800126075745,
0.18542921543121338,
-0.7340205311775208,
0.14206549525260925,
0.19074338674545288,
-0.5073838829994202,
-0.9505022764205933,
0.23916859924793243,
0.03415455296635628,
-0.057794056832790375,
-0.8812804222106934,
0.4343976378440857,
-0.17202316224575043,
-0.29304561018943787,
-0.2900072932243347,
0.08324836939573288,
-0.004256919026374817,
0.12813879549503326,
0.12222668528556824,
0.6672008037567139,
0.3179924488067627,
-0.4219297468662262,
0.2084558606147766,
0.2116497904062271,
-0.34945088624954224,
0.9585126042366028,
-0.6730407476425171,
-0.0011006384156644344,
-0.09252671897411346,
-0.0024370551109313965,
-0.14264681935310364,
0.06763873249292374,
0.2563107907772064,
-0.06657391786575317,
0.30180349946022034,
-0.5123850107192993,
-1.0553849935531616,
-0.2653670608997345,
-0.28208470344543457,
0.05314107984304428,
0.4486536383628845,
0.2559368312358856,
0.9373893737792969,
0.8225525617599487,
-0.4242164194583893,
-0.3140702247619629,
-0.8189674019813538,
0.650851845741272,
-0.6821961998939514,
-0.88453209400177,
0.7310606837272644,
0.33474260568618774,
-0.6749693155288696,
0.35141944885253906,
0.07811068743467331,
-0.4538829028606415,
0.3543144166469574,
0.12556643784046173,
-0.2213413417339325,
-0.06805869936943054,
0.012992176227271557,
0.13168838620185852,
0.05395524203777313,
0.24024762213230133,
-0.29591798782348633,
0.4476904571056366,
-0.22687149047851562,
-0.22205010056495667,
-0.3766282796859741,
0.7040212154388428,
0.0662100687623024,
0.18174120783805847,
0.41187354922294617,
0.3910052180290222,
-0.4523342251777649,
-0.1361306756734848,
-0.47770625352859497,
0.11891074478626251,
-0.42565926909446716,
0.0737379640340805,
-0.3526090383529663,
-1.0828379392623901,
0.5753555297851562,
0.1401771456003189,
0.5004550814628601,
0.7694372534751892,
0.500551164150238,
-0.4042392075061798,
0.3883397877216339,
1.2257956266403198,
0.32384032011032104,
0.6871932744979858,
0.08114579319953918,
0.5115993022918701,
-0.17974737286567688,
-0.21846254169940948,
-0.7481165528297424,
0.04050188139081001,
-0.7154208421707153,
0.1465364694595337,
0.3330843448638916,
-0.019404366612434387,
0.04805176705121994,
0.7379835844039917,
-0.1197168380022049,
0.17030119895935059,
0.7764967679977417,
-0.3146100640296936,
0.6417951583862305,
0.1433354914188385,
-0.23616576194763184,
0.014742975123226643,
-0.8528844118118286,
-1.0585013628005981,
0.7408090829849243,
0.2816247045993805,
-0.06730196624994278,
-0.1458170861005783,
0.9818696975708008,
0.829505205154419,
-0.05979258939623833,
-0.9890390038490295,
0.6296576261520386,
-0.16853374242782593,
-0.7862056493759155,
-0.22092880308628082,
-0.09379462897777557,
-1.2431191205978394,
-0.03956227004528046,
-0.04180653765797615,
-0.5077712535858154,
0.04096027836203575,
-0.15614961087703705,
-0.4974740445613861,
0.02980787679553032,
-0.6206637620925903,
0.815165102481842,
-0.029350386932492256,
-0.2844867408275604,
-0.4630988836288452,
-0.6776058673858643,
0.14614246785640717,
-0.21432402729988098,
0.7031221389770508,
0.07720406353473663,
0.12133185565471649,
0.8880032300949097,
-0.6346370577812195,
0.6890984177589417,
-0.07861779630184174,
-0.32131046056747437,
0.6501404047012329,
-0.11992672085762024,
0.08759628236293793,
-0.10505468398332596,
0.028652891516685486,
0.276445597410202,
0.4423539340496063,
-0.17413468658924103,
-0.5219820737838745,
0.2604368031024933,
-0.059383660554885864,
-0.5636613368988037,
-0.6304230093955994,
-0.1869772970676422,
-0.0771973580121994,
0.565062403678894,
-0.07011882960796356,
0.032780759036540985,
-0.2758110761642456,
-0.04952232912182808,
0.20343714952468872,
-0.05157778412103653,
0.631720781326294,
0.8014230132102966,
0.026100611314177513,
-0.054965656250715256,
0.3584286570549011,
0.2734135687351227,
-0.41068097949028015,
-0.05206764489412308,
0.056401219218969345,
-0.3564215898513794,
-0.865502119064331,
-0.3319079279899597,
0.20845459401607513,
-0.8763912320137024,
0.1776283085346222,
-0.5942870378494263,
-0.19628816843032837,
-0.357406347990036,
-0.33043572306632996,
0.05333706736564636,
-0.5002415180206299,
0.0023029018193483353,
-0.15243786573410034,
0.211558535695076,
0.771704912185669,
0.23027920722961426,
0.23451103270053864,
-0.877613365650177,
0.5040622353553772,
-0.1230546161532402,
0.581023633480072,
-0.5833011269569397,
-0.44838497042655945,
-0.06809556484222412,
-0.2114965170621872,
0.021687693893909454,
-0.43209126591682434,
0.4403693675994873,
0.0021046106703579426,
0.6444755792617798,
0.06678702682256699,
-0.004050552379339933,
0.4769282042980194,
-0.8642802238464355,
0.6671221852302551,
-0.09572865068912506,
-0.7847933173179626,
0.6166568398475647,
-0.4023474156856537,
-0.014241150580346584,
0.8234373331069946,
0.2394137978553772,
-0.8599270582199097,
-0.34531766176223755,
-0.9839416742324829,
-1.1563163995742798,
0.625154972076416,
0.4688088893890381,
0.2840454876422882,
0.4189130961894989,
0.36936718225479126,
0.03881276026368141,
0.5096086859703064,
-0.6932421922683716,
-0.08889586478471756,
0.07896684110164642,
0.07016951590776443,
0.2582559883594513,
-0.12732848525047302,
-0.37784162163734436,
-0.05461109057068825,
0.6885925531387329,
0.1517079770565033,
0.027295038104057312,
0.09788279235363007,
-0.39934924244880676,
0.33541104197502136,
0.5066461563110352,
0.4608510732650757,
0.6754696369171143,
-0.030536996200680733,
0.020410820841789246,
-0.19407540559768677,
-0.4614443778991699,
-0.04371048882603645,
0.19960498809814453,
-0.7275633811950684,
0.3800755739212036,
0.42320334911346436,
0.4584462642669678,
0.15545417368412018,
-0.8307329416275024,
0.370685875415802,
-0.2000512033700943,
-0.4995807707309723,
-0.8175694942474365,
-0.1843762844800949,
0.011658556759357452,
0.35909515619277954,
0.2583405673503876,
-0.14467352628707886,
0.7613884210586548,
-0.5947452783584595,
0.4020752012729645,
0.2980228662490845,
-0.38640210032463074,
-0.18194250762462616,
0.36114394664764404,
0.2775280177593231,
-0.7386751174926758,
0.14033058285713196,
-0.33493027091026306,
-0.21845002472400665,
0.47941455245018005,
0.17555265128612518,
1.2169231176376343,
0.52656090259552,
0.32216259837150574,
-0.05111655965447426,
0.13850654661655426,
-0.24725401401519775,
0.568213939666748,
-0.2253081500530243,
-0.5219067335128784,
-0.48150354623794556,
-0.3777589797973633,
-0.1669260561466217,
-0.03448082506656647,
-0.5262978076934814,
0.5347052216529846,
-0.35887157917022705,
-0.5190708041191101,
0.2168521136045456,
0.011112350039184093,
-0.6085652112960815,
-0.3621971905231476,
0.039893779903650284,
0.953362226486206,
-0.6325745582580566,
0.8223876357078552,
0.8819251656532288,
-0.2673484683036804,
0.016304947435855865,
0.035626623779535294,
0.15546372532844543,
-0.32783445715904236,
0.4779376983642578,
-0.03908717632293701,
-0.3875071108341217,
-0.17512819170951843,
-0.44777989387512207,
-0.19050876796245575,
0.7850872278213501,
0.15113282203674316,
-0.506091296672821,
0.02988644875586033,
0.3665904402732849,
1.0515851974487305,
-0.10442475229501724,
-0.14482207596302032,
0.9034914374351501,
0.412626177072525,
-0.018269050866365433,
-0.8425084352493286,
-0.03353198617696762,
-0.5435793995857239,
-0.14843882620334625,
0.06762460619211197,
0.13091012835502625,
-0.0034766532480716705,
0.1432434469461441,
-0.8107280731201172,
-0.42031851410865784,
0.33568644523620605,
0.02133258245885372,
0.4936872720718384,
0.4655555188655853,
0.3477855622768402,
0.6149758696556091,
0.11432288587093353,
1.182678461074829,
-0.4298190474510193,
0.012439020909368992,
0.9099189043045044,
-0.47739315032958984,
0.5377004742622375,
0.7088930010795593,
-0.20496951043605804,
0.4383150041103363,
0.47670307755470276,
-0.2116282880306244,
0.21780015528202057,
0.28313368558883667,
-0.20311476290225983,
-0.07504137605428696,
-0.42413806915283203,
0.08153118193149567,
0.3471967875957489,
0.3036403954029083,
-0.13715560734272003,
-0.41905641555786133,
-0.15774480998516083,
0.19669249653816223,
0.37458136677742004,
-0.2077629417181015,
1.071327805519104,
0.1296197921037674,
-0.71323162317276,
0.12223491072654724,
0.471181720495224,
0.6238947510719299,
-0.4237733781337738,
-0.20077486336231232,
-0.040889717638492584,
-0.3917882740497589,
-0.3195970356464386,
-1.0829493999481201,
0.7914618253707886,
0.43795186281204224,
0.08867428451776505,
-0.7797642946243286,
0.8322908282279968,
0.13975834846496582,
-0.5162227153778076,
0.4347963333129883,
0.6224055886268616,
0.3158254623413086,
-0.04355451837182045,
-0.6597820520401001,
-0.5422731041908264,
-0.4673926830291748,
-0.2989369034767151,
0.23485636711120605,
0.46709540486335754,
-0.5268482565879822,
0.551828920841217,
0.5196762681007385,
0.044061943888664246,
0.2439350187778473,
0.465869665145874,
0.7159621119499207,
-1.05549955368042,
-0.5642118453979492,
-0.8956590294837952,
0.6091546416282654,
-0.2563636898994446,
-0.25401827692985535,
0.60867840051651,
0.5223723649978638,
0.8537738919258118,
0.20936137437820435,
0.7751604318618774,
-0.3808734714984894,
0.276493102312088,
-0.6557647585868835,
0.5494406819343567,
-0.23415450751781464,
0.2016170620918274,
-0.11478579044342041,
-0.6391331553459167,
-0.6927209496498108,
0.47013819217681885,
-0.1037960946559906,
-0.14633174240589142,
0.46938058733940125,
0.180039644241333,
-0.1458238810300827,
0.11286920309066772,
0.4687129259109497,
-0.12760716676712036,
0.3215419352054596,
-0.0551694892346859,
0.3676410913467407,
-0.2452048659324646,
0.3800588548183441,
-0.38119202852249146,
0.15530015528202057,
-0.19142678380012512,
-1.060486078262329,
-0.7110263109207153,
-0.5553303360939026,
-0.28046226501464844,
-0.32627972960472107,
-0.17523296177387238,
0.6935057044029236,
0.55767422914505,
-1.0068023204803467,
-0.4042075574398041,
-0.15737223625183105,
0.17923517525196075,
-0.12559939920902252,
-0.22078974545001984,
0.06023278087377548,
-0.5788031816482544,
-0.5896991491317749,
0.3845703899860382,
0.3835948705673218,
0.02408665418624878,
0.06682810187339783,
0.20783960819244385,
-0.2846946716308594,
-0.16621872782707214,
0.7076107859611511,
0.5013611912727356,
-0.6665118932723999,
0.05188632011413574,
-0.1483200639486313,
-0.04962265491485596,
0.2750697731971741,
1.474993109703064,
-0.7015438079833984,
0.4327785074710846,
0.4325163960456848,
0.574299693107605,
0.6251673698425293,
-0.17701144516468048,
0.9004128575325012,
-0.6558670997619629,
0.2612743377685547,
0.6937147974967957,
0.7696461081504822,
0.0087120421230793,
-0.12026649713516235,
0.7254853844642639,
0.2015409618616104,
-0.10490821301937103,
-0.7176752686500549,
0.20674985647201538,
-0.9180129170417786,
-0.46068400144577026,
1.1637470722198486,
-0.08509994298219681,
-0.06903164088726044,
-0.8493173122406006,
-0.004807155579328537,
0.19480721652507782,
-0.592129647731781,
0.8338189125061035,
1.0252269506454468,
0.033349502831697464,
0.09075463563203812,
-1.473624348640442,
0.5303187370300293,
-0.015368734486401081,
-0.7499359846115112,
-0.22476232051849365,
0.5455496311187744,
0.0963982492685318,
0.2642785608768463,
0.6642820239067078,
-0.4351368546485901,
0.05974481254816055,
-0.218726247549057,
0.2922820746898651,
0.016373643651604652,
-0.2671767771244049,
-0.8317816853523254,
0.3900723457336426,
-0.050560954958200455,
0.347959041595459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18977v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18977v1
|
Computational Job Market Analysis with Natural Language Processing
| 2024-04-29T14:52:38 | 2024-04-29T14:52:38 |
Mike Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
[Abridged Abstract]
Recent technological advances underscore labor market dynamics, yielding
significant consequences for employment prospects and increasing job vacancy
data across platforms and languages. Aggregating such data holds potential for
valuable insights into labor market demands, new skills emergence, and
facilitating job matching for various stakeholders. However, despite prevalent
insights in the private sector, transparent language technology systems and
data for this domain are lacking. This thesis investigates Natural Language
Processing (NLP) technology for extracting relevant information from job
descriptions, identifying challenges including scarcity of training data, lack
of standardized annotation guidelines, and shortage of effective extraction
methods from job ads. We frame the problem, obtaining annotated data, and
introducing extraction methodologies. Our contributions include job description
datasets, a de-identification dataset, and a novel active learning algorithm
for efficient model training. We propose skill extraction using weak
supervision, a taxonomy-aware pre-training methodology adapting multilingual
language models to the job market domain, and a retrieval-augmented model
leveraging multiple skill extraction datasets to enhance overall performance.
Finally, we ground extracted information within a designated taxonomy.
|
[
-0.11695589125156403,
-0.8501508831977844,
0.23459309339523315,
0.14996302127838135,
0.015111414715647697,
0.0849883183836937,
-0.3834095001220703,
-0.8615365624427795,
0.0948234423995018,
0.6278035640716553,
-0.4111112356185913,
-0.4380723536014557,
-0.5308167934417725,
0.0704992488026619,
-0.3026005029678345,
0.8154031038284302,
0.22740165889263153,
-0.3006754219532013,
-0.14254151284694672,
0.2195850908756256,
-0.2731582820415497,
-0.5099115967750549,
-0.7748206853866577,
-0.03341025859117508,
0.14807166159152985,
0.43838444352149963,
0.622687816619873,
1.0157383680343628,
0.3697485029697418,
0.29055002331733704,
0.11026540398597717,
-0.02886507473886013,
-0.09401765465736389,
0.2881070673465729,
-0.014399627223610878,
-0.1319490373134613,
-0.46351009607315063,
0.30378323793411255,
0.6099691390991211,
1.0196988582611084,
-0.20667733252048492,
0.3177255392074585,
-0.04294376075267792,
0.3791601061820984,
-0.6386425495147705,
0.6910470128059387,
-0.8958778977394104,
-0.06584752351045609,
-0.4193752110004425,
-0.13472089171409607,
-0.1825934797525406,
-0.19751474261283875,
0.5341304540634155,
-0.4320816397666931,
0.35803210735321045,
-0.16974440217018127,
1.0641406774520874,
0.10211393237113953,
-0.26816558837890625,
-0.5620207786560059,
-0.8135311603546143,
0.84597247838974,
-0.5486204624176025,
0.23073284327983856,
0.6885256767272949,
0.4493030607700348,
0.08514446765184402,
-0.7411966919898987,
-0.102857306599617,
0.1090078204870224,
-0.23615571856498718,
-0.04810958355665207,
-0.07208317518234253,
0.08599474281072617,
0.09574802964925766,
0.6020445823669434,
-0.34052762389183044,
0.4690078794956207,
-0.8021084070205688,
0.054842956364154816,
0.6109928488731384,
-0.021314406767487526,
0.15570756793022156,
-0.040239572525024414,
-0.10178643465042114,
-0.09455494582653046,
-0.2148735225200653,
0.15103471279144287,
0.7181788682937622,
0.5557907819747925,
0.02471321076154709,
0.6289544701576233,
-0.30567505955696106,
0.9770686626434326,
-0.5522804856300354,
-0.10295070707798004,
0.07557261735200882,
-0.1862867772579193,
-0.2880207896232605,
-0.049583371728658676,
0.8869896531105042,
-0.23544929921627045,
0.04814164340496063,
-0.26770004630088806,
-0.3316742777824402,
0.014949099160730839,
0.6804247498512268,
-0.24097199738025665,
-0.09235551208257675,
0.14797861874103546,
-0.39340153336524963,
-0.3158477246761322,
0.1330079883337021,
-1.048195719718933,
-0.36841797828674316,
-0.39927157759666443,
0.04584715887904167,
-0.002633338561281562,
-0.3831382095813751,
0.07867535203695297,
-0.3134615421295166,
0.3687750995159149,
-0.06059327349066734,
-1.0182899236679077,
0.6066845059394836,
0.9379064440727234,
0.8082760572433472,
-0.22131752967834473,
0.16342490911483765,
-0.2046811282634735,
0.00009552021219860762,
-0.029756836593151093,
0.4783574938774109,
-0.7388060092926025,
0.06664903461933136,
0.15552382171154022,
0.15131893754005432,
-0.3961646258831024,
-0.604493260383606,
0.4909416437149048,
-0.8158556818962097,
0.23013246059417725,
0.23598377406597137,
-0.22197464108467102,
-0.3534178137779236,
0.49854034185409546,
-1.0099272727966309,
1.0956586599349976,
0.3098023533821106,
-0.656724750995636,
0.20720720291137695,
-1.0196988582611084,
-0.33564597368240356,
0.12887898087501526,
-0.24755556881427765,
-0.42398884892463684,
-0.002603692701086402,
0.07692611962556839,
0.5939738154411316,
-0.2676409184932709,
0.2357550710439682,
-0.029840020462870598,
-0.3584904670715332,
0.24824188649654388,
-0.39389917254447937,
0.8621309399604797,
0.33155229687690735,
-0.16130253672599792,
-0.21211983263492584,
-0.7093498706817627,
-0.2929410934448242,
0.1864745020866394,
-0.2554905414581299,
-0.21974964439868927,
-0.041259437799453735,
-0.03658674284815788,
0.29522955417633057,
0.3105078339576721,
-0.346660315990448,
0.08060845732688904,
-0.6683831214904785,
0.2944455146789551,
0.47531914710998535,
-0.13817110657691956,
0.5025143623352051,
0.0628964900970459,
0.790303647518158,
-0.38622695207595825,
0.10102779418230057,
0.10618530213832855,
-0.44801685214042664,
-0.10770191997289658,
-0.273518830537796,
0.40029141306877136,
0.8267480134963989,
-0.8390839695930481,
0.23055213689804077,
-0.10445733368396759,
-0.5093222856521606,
-0.762361466884613,
0.06779403239488602,
0.09504321962594986,
0.47658875584602356,
0.25278329849243164,
-0.43203046917915344,
-0.9001979231834412,
-1.0628607273101807,
-0.530488908290863,
0.13158559799194336,
0.14181476831436157,
-0.21268382668495178,
0.029835063964128494,
-0.1755785197019577,
1.1665256023406982,
-0.6898387670516968,
-0.46480369567871094,
-0.3012648820877075,
0.1917179524898529,
0.7130084037780762,
0.3280724287033081,
0.10148545354604721,
-1.0510650873184204,
-0.20836536586284637,
0.3533552587032318,
-0.7734706401824951,
-0.018583299592137337,
-0.16715581715106964,
0.1404561549425125,
0.015987463295459747,
0.3462502956390381,
-0.6001485586166382,
0.44948771595954895,
0.49487560987472534,
-0.018933149054646492,
0.685722291469574,
-0.17997001111507416,
-0.17678576707839966,
-0.811927080154419,
0.5224007964134216,
0.3754042983055115,
-0.0849870890378952,
-0.7510592341423035,
-0.056454695761203766,
-0.42372918128967285,
-0.3370915651321411,
-0.30722811818122864,
0.6192320585250854,
-0.7639697790145874,
-0.38839757442474365,
-0.5799790024757385,
0.10341255366802216,
-0.2199963480234146,
0.4947393536567688,
0.24383996427059174,
0.6020035147666931,
0.5826572775840759,
-0.5174726247787476,
0.4270639419555664,
0.35733339190483093,
-0.2684125602245331,
-0.04991783946752548,
-0.32782113552093506,
0.05708158016204834,
-0.1394871026277542,
-0.14103147387504578,
-0.5652316212654114,
-0.3658003807067871,
0.2967996597290039,
-0.1117510050535202,
0.1450563371181488,
-0.3504765033721924,
-0.4934846758842468,
-0.43585875630378723,
-0.16442860662937164,
0.17674270272254944,
0.3387224078178406,
-0.011846878565847874,
0.25744736194610596,
0.7918779253959656,
-0.7299498319625854,
-1.0083519220352173,
-0.7126035094261169,
0.10360034555196762,
-0.17404720187187195,
-0.15514212846755981,
0.3646836578845978,
0.6006460189819336,
-0.3388965129852295,
-0.10213686525821686,
-0.20584021508693695,
-0.8888724446296692,
0.5028353929519653,
0.06468234956264496,
0.5919193029403687,
0.05279878154397011,
-0.08489985018968582,
-0.05444151908159256,
-0.42153286933898926,
0.3494698107242584,
-0.2826696038246155,
0.16341552138328552,
0.06976748257875443,
-0.005243822932243347,
-0.2989140450954437,
-0.0405297726392746,
0.37832099199295044,
-0.09517792612314224,
0.8544937968254089,
0.9622856378555298,
-0.609322726726532,
0.049760498106479645,
-0.4364550709724426,
0.03519190847873688,
-0.4637834131717682,
0.17706535756587982,
0.10369885712862015,
-0.7287905812263489,
0.2793785333633423,
-0.13623344898223877,
0.2717697024345398,
0.5293154716491699,
0.3717261552810669,
0.2082436978816986,
0.7365638613700867,
0.8765276074409485,
0.05988878011703491,
0.5963501930236816,
-0.32190194725990295,
0.3430868983268738,
-0.3426201045513153,
-0.35299599170684814,
-0.5877430438995361,
-0.23814766108989716,
-0.5496709942817688,
-0.2076619416475296,
0.1829264760017395,
-0.014793497510254383,
0.3907252550125122,
0.5632463693618774,
-0.7268797159194946,
0.3931107223033905,
0.6250653862953186,
-0.22381210327148438,
0.2770763635635376,
0.1942194253206253,
0.22447335720062256,
-0.16252954304218292,
-0.3225851356983185,
-0.802239716053009,
1.0086512565612793,
0.3829011917114258,
0.257764607667923,
-0.20411694049835205,
0.1874469518661499,
0.32671308517456055,
0.1667821854352951,
-0.5261296629905701,
0.3174252510070801,
-0.38278111815452576,
-0.5520949363708496,
-0.40418606996536255,
-0.4661456048488617,
-1.0186570882797241,
0.2622850835323334,
-0.5188024640083313,
-0.6469084620475769,
0.24038831889629364,
-0.11043999344110489,
-0.34534090757369995,
0.18239378929138184,
-0.6678766012191772,
1.0353050231933594,
-0.15796782076358795,
-0.25966352224349976,
0.008991364389657974,
-0.677270233631134,
0.2690854072570801,
-0.5281571745872498,
0.6371201276779175,
-0.19449162483215332,
0.04127851873636246,
0.8464465737342834,
-0.13699111342430115,
0.8604845404624939,
-0.32414695620536804,
-0.08418428897857666,
0.18607507646083832,
-0.2563246488571167,
0.33261728286743164,
-0.07168545573949814,
-0.8368995189666748,
0.23540015518665314,
0.24469588696956635,
-0.4123719036579132,
-0.193027526140213,
0.2571709454059601,
-0.4782693088054657,
0.01418802235275507,
-0.21274344623088837,
-0.4066595435142517,
-0.3039236068725586,
0.3831818699836731,
0.13182218372821808,
0.10150326788425446,
-0.24211204051971436,
0.038809601217508316,
0.16294175386428833,
-0.1824028044939041,
0.2594490349292755,
0.1737462878227234,
0.09097954630851746,
-0.16368336975574493,
1.0027198791503906,
0.22045324742794037,
-0.22223053872585297,
0.15579645335674286,
-0.15354105830192566,
-0.3336417078971863,
-0.42395997047424316,
0.010873728431761265,
0.19903770089149475,
-0.4322353005409241,
-0.0800059586763382,
-0.6543028354644775,
-0.30326059460639954,
-0.5127623677253723,
-0.05968816950917244,
-0.26090705394744873,
-0.3564540147781372,
-0.2733909785747528,
-0.019573744386434555,
0.07675549387931824,
0.8114683628082275,
-0.00926282163709402,
0.45142826437950134,
-0.7498976588249207,
0.4495885968208313,
0.2232421636581421,
0.6587544083595276,
-0.14013272523880005,
0.2561541199684143,
-0.7793107628822327,
0.259692907333374,
-0.22632098197937012,
-0.7441596984863281,
0.7383778095245361,
0.16835135221481323,
0.7726795673370361,
0.1546490341424942,
-0.1548907458782196,
0.5146997570991516,
0.07483787089586258,
0.7046599388122559,
-0.04595022648572922,
-0.5622331500053406,
0.460594117641449,
-0.3771764636039734,
0.042419202625751495,
0.6688233613967896,
0.5054768323898315,
-0.6668135523796082,
-0.19253993034362793,
-0.770777702331543,
-1.1213840246200562,
1.1221096515655518,
0.476942241191864,
-0.027049658820033073,
-0.12493196129798889,
0.4668179154396057,
0.5247689485549927,
0.4817277193069458,
-0.5613618493080139,
0.04990047216415405,
0.20200929045677185,
-0.5111543536186218,
0.1089925616979599,
-0.1433393955230713,
0.19885210692882538,
-0.17717194557189941,
0.5493000745773315,
0.037128519266843796,
0.23063300549983978,
-0.21383316814899445,
-0.29307132959365845,
0.11212284117937088,
0.2445923537015915,
0.29059022665023804,
0.6761947274208069,
-0.18758004903793335,
0.06612621247768402,
-0.030421745032072067,
-0.5409561991691589,
-0.3144865930080414,
0.3951994478702545,
0.2209349423646927,
0.06588888168334961,
0.20656590163707733,
0.48733389377593994,
0.06827664375305176,
-0.976902961730957,
0.6777200102806091,
-0.01529390923678875,
-0.22109943628311157,
-0.6294249296188354,
-0.0032475560437887907,
-0.20941069722175598,
0.1717483103275299,
0.7305992245674133,
0.057777926325798035,
0.22066473960876465,
-0.3288404047489166,
0.22704164683818817,
0.34296172857284546,
-0.58525151014328,
-0.4700647294521332,
0.5492451190948486,
-0.07658528536558151,
-0.20411576330661774,
0.8134989738464355,
-0.140381321310997,
-0.18755654990673065,
0.6622626185417175,
0.3521628975868225,
0.7317897081375122,
-0.01707473024725914,
0.12703335285186768,
0.09505581110715866,
0.21231849491596222,
-0.4060656726360321,
0.145727276802063,
-0.042101986706256866,
-0.5135796666145325,
-0.7562547922134399,
-0.537884533405304,
-0.5383236408233643,
0.08205357193946838,
-0.7665785551071167,
0.29378366470336914,
-0.4208815097808838,
-0.18471452593803406,
0.031832873821258545,
-0.0836513414978981,
-0.964958906173706,
0.27682730555534363,
0.22781965136528015,
0.42282208800315857,
-0.8901484608650208,
0.6322249174118042,
0.8601198792457581,
-0.1892169564962387,
-0.3442743420600891,
-0.43953555822372437,
-0.0527406707406044,
-0.6231279373168945,
0.5155300498008728,
0.43629056215286255,
0.11568479239940643,
-0.014304901473224163,
-0.5025720596313477,
-0.5312802195549011,
0.817498505115509,
0.5665180087089539,
-0.06950721144676208,
-0.39831581711769104,
0.28497105836868286,
0.5343188643455505,
-0.2560783326625824,
0.1432742029428482,
0.8419294357299805,
0.40668705105781555,
-0.2730036973953247,
-0.9067806601524353,
-0.2960849702358246,
-0.3138495683670044,
-0.1690710037946701,
0.20592667162418365,
0.14774248003959656,
0.635209321975708,
0.4618748426437378,
-0.4940868616104126,
-0.3570849299430847,
0.3350273668766022,
-0.06053435429930687,
0.3669203817844391,
0.4928934872150421,
0.14083346724510193,
0.6938087940216064,
-0.02372182533144951,
0.6191405653953552,
-0.26544052362442017,
0.440173476934433,
0.8000568747520447,
-0.2273675799369812,
0.6713675260543823,
0.23254704475402832,
-0.100282683968544,
0.7229519486427307,
0.5792144536972046,
-0.10565102100372314,
0.17746837437152863,
0.026047969236969948,
-0.026359103620052338,
-0.031007196754217148,
-0.16003860533237457,
-0.07761222124099731,
0.7527406215667725,
0.49358904361724854,
-0.31865373253822327,
-0.3836827874183655,
0.07011935114860535,
-0.35675695538520813,
0.15303348004817963,
-0.17093001306056976,
0.8925281763076782,
0.08778660744428635,
-0.40082377195358276,
0.1849406212568283,
0.21276427805423737,
0.6525319814682007,
-0.5788629651069641,
-0.4402227997779846,
0.30135515332221985,
-0.1460837870836258,
-0.3495211601257324,
-0.6397725939750671,
0.9466518759727478,
0.09808210283517838,
-0.05589044839143753,
-0.7480469942092896,
0.9685845971107483,
-0.3950653076171875,
-0.2564657926559448,
0.20677076280117035,
0.6301056742668152,
0.32824552059173584,
-0.17954260110855103,
-0.8465760350227356,
-0.12504534423351288,
-0.24333937466144562,
-0.06460734456777573,
0.2032625675201416,
0.378434956073761,
-0.026143644005060196,
0.5215244889259338,
0.698293924331665,
0.3810954689979553,
0.06624751538038254,
-0.3422694802284241,
0.4834681451320648,
-0.8649421334266663,
-0.7623580098152161,
-0.7205724716186523,
0.4409777820110321,
-0.41934749484062195,
-0.16360411047935486,
0.46551620960235596,
0.5125918388366699,
0.6403010487556458,
-0.007196364924311638,
0.657051682472229,
-0.05820607393980026,
0.6651419997215271,
-0.41247451305389404,
0.46328306198120117,
-0.24059778451919556,
0.5068286657333374,
-0.23109708726406097,
-0.9431232213973999,
-0.24286790192127228,
0.3608432710170746,
-0.6122520565986633,
-0.11913451552391052,
0.32208842039108276,
0.632696270942688,
-0.1957170069217682,
0.09840276092290878,
0.018589569255709648,
-0.02353294938802719,
0.008696598000824451,
-0.05761251971125603,
0.5776408910751343,
-0.35715290904045105,
0.5549588203430176,
-0.2999120354652405,
0.08398136496543884,
-0.3963618576526642,
-0.6573303937911987,
-0.23790140450000763,
-0.4598041772842407,
-0.4307786524295807,
-0.1284962296485901,
-0.21323436498641968,
0.7040904760360718,
0.5828292369842529,
-0.5936915874481201,
-0.6935898661613464,
0.05813717097043991,
0.1950804889202118,
-0.8036764860153198,
-0.36943456530570984,
0.3096862733364105,
-0.4431626796722412,
-0.5152906179428101,
0.7486153244972229,
0.32855868339538574,
-0.08122038841247559,
-0.16002950072288513,
0.3285039961338043,
-0.39001229405403137,
-0.3293808698654175,
0.4141434133052826,
0.5715805888175964,
-0.3430435359477997,
0.19963273406028748,
-0.2744947075843811,
-0.21427185833454132,
-0.09161297976970673,
0.8451752066612244,
-0.657322347164154,
0.5390595197677612,
0.0831146165728569,
0.9374755024909973,
0.3579845428466797,
0.11681882292032242,
0.781639575958252,
-1.261960744857788,
0.2975052297115326,
0.2663063406944275,
-0.051126912236213684,
0.3964155912399292,
-0.5039926171302795,
0.8492527604103088,
0.2149195522069931,
-0.3099389374256134,
-0.8234366774559021,
-0.033135708421468735,
-0.8241562247276306,
-0.5508575439453125,
0.8621900081634521,
0.329036146402359,
-0.44487258791923523,
-0.7952345013618469,
0.05670834705233574,
0.5359477400779724,
-0.1310776323080063,
0.6025169491767883,
0.48440122604370117,
0.044442180544137955,
-0.11549650132656097,
-1.0728214979171753,
0.3967137932777405,
-0.057249199599027634,
-0.6581104397773743,
0.2580573260784149,
0.43430885672569275,
-0.0078103323467075825,
0.14706644415855408,
0.8632820844650269,
-0.0665174052119255,
0.17650841176509857,
-0.15510155260562897,
0.2828109562397003,
-0.08583232015371323,
0.007548357825726271,
-0.6600902676582336,
0.6098439693450928,
0.19990336894989014,
-0.19966335594654083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18976v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18976v1
|
Foundations of Multisensory Artificial Intelligence
| 2024-04-29T14:45:28 | 2024-04-29T14:45:28 |
Paul Pu Liang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM
|
Building multisensory AI systems that learn from multiple sensory inputs such
as text, speech, video, real-world sensors, wearable devices, and medical data
holds great promise for impact in many scientific areas with practical
benefits, such as in supporting human health and well-being, enabling
multimedia content processing, and enhancing real-world autonomous agents. By
synthesizing a range of theoretical frameworks and application domains, this
thesis aims to advance the machine learning foundations of multisensory AI. In
the first part, we present a theoretical framework formalizing how modalities
interact with each other to give rise to new information for a task. These
interactions are the basic building blocks in all multimodal problems, and
their quantification enables users to understand their multimodal datasets,
design principled approaches to learn these interactions, and analyze whether
their model has succeeded in learning. In the second part, we study the design
of practical multimodal foundation models that generalize over many modalities
and tasks, which presents a step toward grounding large language models to
real-world sensory modalities. We introduce MultiBench, a unified large-scale
benchmark across a wide range of modalities, tasks, and research areas,
followed by the cross-modal attention and multimodal transformer architectures
that now underpin many of today's multimodal foundation models. Scaling these
architectures on MultiBench enables the creation of general-purpose
multisensory AI systems, and we discuss our collaborative efforts in applying
these models for real-world impact in affective computing, mental health,
cancer prognosis, and robotics. Finally, we conclude this thesis by discussing
how future work can leverage these ideas toward more general, interactive, and
safe multisensory AI.
|
[
-0.37153634428977966,
-0.6891595721244812,
0.6447221636772156,
0.2622355818748474,
0.3606123626232147,
-0.05003479868173599,
-0.2136090248823166,
-0.6456811428070068,
0.09157191216945648,
-0.0235033817589283,
-0.42924854159355164,
-0.13665451109409332,
-0.4949662983417511,
-0.30859553813934326,
-0.3143462836742401,
0.5671443343162537,
0.06268829107284546,
0.25335851311683655,
-0.10672225803136826,
-0.424270898103714,
-0.31996020674705505,
-0.41503289341926575,
-0.4547624886035919,
-0.21047340333461761,
0.6381218433380127,
0.4097321927547455,
0.5358127951622009,
0.34423837065696716,
0.3394661545753479,
0.34702348709106445,
0.394176185131073,
0.029120802879333496,
0.07589610666036606,
0.21495920419692993,
0.03534892573952675,
-0.39648663997650146,
-0.0766129195690155,
0.128909170627594,
0.39759108424186707,
0.7605347037315369,
0.04088390991091728,
0.05178803205490112,
-0.08887732028961182,
0.38819289207458496,
-0.6244021654129028,
0.6389228105545044,
0.004657157696783543,
0.18877576291561127,
0.13712827861309052,
0.1308017373085022,
-0.424196720123291,
0.19622135162353516,
-0.11919527500867844,
-0.4889412820339203,
0.050476159900426865,
-0.040233973413705826,
0.39951515197753906,
0.5567995309829712,
-0.7984524965286255,
-0.03832366317510605,
-0.7243214249610901,
0.9414798617362976,
-0.17003048956394196,
1.042409062385559,
0.46285220980644226,
0.31577104330062866,
0.033520910888910294,
-0.7791921496391296,
-0.5628687143325806,
-0.563566267490387,
-0.09534537047147751,
0.1903432160615921,
-0.11703059077262878,
0.09115952998399734,
0.06353967636823654,
0.045258719474077225,
-0.5587143301963806,
0.0024561244063079357,
-0.2068377286195755,
-0.0732947289943695,
0.5471307039260864,
0.08530879020690918,
0.19356803596019745,
-0.03769884631037712,
-0.35382789373397827,
-0.42096781730651855,
-0.1694326102733612,
0.22631831467151642,
-0.11319439858198166,
0.08820056170225143,
-0.254411518573761,
0.3467804789543152,
-0.19014552235603333,
0.6418589353561401,
0.1108878031373024,
-0.31039026379585266,
0.42657470703125,
-0.7068213224411011,
-0.07592644542455673,
-0.23276172578334808,
0.6886065602302551,
0.107193723320961,
0.025179725140333176,
-0.2008347511291504,
0.015722012147307396,
0.5260952115058899,
0.4744824469089508,
-0.4946354329586029,
-0.26323890686035156,
0.32181069254875183,
-0.7106691598892212,
-0.21991366147994995,
0.08873816579580307,
-0.6932142376899719,
-0.43706345558166504,
-0.755423903465271,
0.5198544859886169,
-0.4546697735786438,
-0.4246652126312256,
0.07462576031684875,
-0.08491343259811401,
0.07504643499851227,
0.21839749813079834,
-0.9901090860366821,
0.13520051538944244,
0.4089835286140442,
0.43735694885253906,
-0.0007111660670489073,
-0.6342411041259766,
-0.3908133804798126,
0.34615644812583923,
-0.17412924766540527,
0.5180599689483643,
-0.6780126094818115,
-0.19668962061405182,
-0.33338233828544617,
0.019230565056204796,
-0.2396838665008545,
-0.2663220465183258,
0.4428427517414093,
-0.35068008303642273,
0.06640197336673737,
0.13195621967315674,
-0.09725291281938553,
-0.4152302145957947,
0.38065171241760254,
-0.8581963777542114,
0.5555301308631897,
0.09866110980510712,
-0.4344291090965271,
0.21236072480678558,
-1.0722899436950684,
-0.9057933688163757,
-0.42796245217323303,
-0.2687423527240753,
-0.29012998938560486,
0.41347432136535645,
0.0026727882213890553,
0.5654907822608948,
-0.20193198323249817,
0.4578656852245331,
-0.29730457067489624,
-0.027577685192227364,
0.1915433555841446,
-0.738262951374054,
0.7147972583770752,
0.24951454997062683,
-0.5430524945259094,
0.38771122694015503,
-0.9964656233787537,
0.03220063075423241,
-0.1031191423535347,
-0.43201786279678345,
-0.014210042543709278,
0.23125185072422028,
0.47804123163223267,
0.34323951601982117,
-0.03184734657406807,
-0.37321874499320984,
-0.11876492947340012,
0.03559856861829758,
0.7331684231758118,
0.5490292310714722,
-0.19875046610832214,
0.33385327458381653,
-0.35702797770500183,
0.23198170959949493,
0.16866973042488098,
0.2997068762779236,
-0.5840411186218262,
-0.32550984621047974,
-0.5619597434997559,
-0.4406105875968933,
0.16996175050735474,
0.5854492783546448,
-0.5324105024337769,
0.3068864643573761,
0.03585497662425041,
-0.41146329045295715,
-0.30653810501098633,
0.01246782299131155,
0.2656928300857544,
0.4998691976070404,
0.47166815400123596,
-0.2884352207183838,
-0.4172665774822235,
-0.7611965537071228,
-0.06543239951133728,
-0.19933171570301056,
0.04798389598727226,
0.4573247730731964,
0.27813103795051575,
-0.5968332290649414,
0.7938958406448364,
-0.3368028402328491,
-0.03709359094500542,
0.10070883482694626,
0.289983332157135,
-0.04357154667377472,
0.754966139793396,
0.6521983742713928,
-1.381002426147461,
-0.12595753371715546,
0.10586471110582352,
-0.9196357727050781,
0.28438878059387207,
-0.12054724246263504,
0.12559936940670013,
-0.20710237324237823,
0.43468302488327026,
-0.8003473877906799,
0.47093260288238525,
0.4566684663295746,
-0.27010786533355713,
0.5646021962165833,
-0.07004629820585251,
0.3897598087787628,
-1.0874682664871216,
0.18430949747562408,
0.15728594362735748,
0.046404771506786346,
-0.8242947459220886,
0.2847501039505005,
0.06806512922048569,
-0.3065170347690582,
-0.451492577791214,
0.6891156435012817,
-0.24802759289741516,
-0.0825127512216568,
-0.1677982658147812,
-0.41505447030067444,
0.09181446582078934,
0.6356893181800842,
-0.12139584124088287,
0.375149130821228,
0.5926756858825684,
-0.8459568023681641,
0.6462941765785217,
0.08376695960760117,
-0.04923512786626816,
0.7953466773033142,
-0.5977543592453003,
-0.2033236026763916,
-0.22282066941261292,
0.10072676092386246,
-1.0207401514053345,
-0.5362136363983154,
0.27638891339302063,
-0.6418194770812988,
0.26564857363700867,
0.23948124051094055,
-0.5197696685791016,
-0.3508918881416321,
-0.14224259555339813,
0.6746001839637756,
0.022284306585788727,
-0.573794424533844,
1.1555901765823364,
0.5063862800598145,
0.11955838650465012,
-0.4908791184425354,
-0.7554495930671692,
-0.009277702309191227,
-0.13062216341495514,
-0.6112773418426514,
0.32912173867225647,
-0.35523369908332825,
-0.34580451250076294,
0.0689721331000328,
0.02587319165468216,
-0.25038206577301025,
0.4144922196865082,
0.5179475545883179,
-0.028311999514698982,
-0.24913614988327026,
0.452059805393219,
-0.07814096659421921,
-0.3980283737182617,
0.04897630959749222,
-0.30727413296699524,
0.47264978289604187,
-0.4484964609146118,
-0.8878331184387207,
-0.5658388733863831,
0.5251440405845642,
0.8952001333236694,
-0.5524986386299133,
0.475362628698349,
1.0167664289474487,
-0.5049920678138733,
0.2849631607532501,
-0.36300182342529297,
-0.4423706531524658,
-0.38703054189682007,
0.5176458358764648,
-0.5986934304237366,
-0.6861084699630737,
0.30785515904426575,
-0.21264442801475525,
-0.002250916790217161,
0.3627175986766815,
0.7407533526420593,
-0.1850925087928772,
1.3252979516983032,
0.8419581055641174,
-0.28953006863594055,
0.6724767684936523,
-0.15412646532058716,
0.2703753709793091,
-0.5728944540023804,
-0.3698326051235199,
-0.3923810124397278,
-0.6968627572059631,
-0.4561759829521179,
-0.3846215605735779,
0.6488193869590759,
-0.05077572911977768,
-0.3406738340854645,
0.04404406249523163,
-0.3653436601161957,
0.24920989573001862,
0.9513093829154968,
0.1821615844964981,
0.10629385709762573,
-0.0016167555004358292,
-0.20165617763996124,
0.299173504114151,
-0.5654017329216003,
-0.10044578462839127,
0.9743595719337463,
0.265288770198822,
0.8253418207168579,
0.18991081416606903,
0.1674417108297348,
0.3184581398963928,
0.08507076650857925,
-0.7277411222457886,
0.14898552000522614,
0.005328179802745581,
-0.7056314945220947,
-0.20371782779693604,
-0.08195187151432037,
-0.9067767858505249,
0.44105425477027893,
-0.3011133372783661,
-0.46316617727279663,
0.35912570357322693,
0.2072698026895523,
-0.24297328293323517,
0.1535934954881668,
-0.9906386137008667,
0.892598569393158,
-0.8224634528160095,
-0.42298421263694763,
-0.6385219693183899,
-1.1017529964447021,
0.35569635033607483,
-0.005347412079572678,
0.3657815158367157,
0.05707782134413719,
0.042354170233011246,
0.33618423342704773,
0.41654396057128906,
1.0974676609039307,
-0.31502023339271545,
0.22019603848457336,
0.016119208186864853,
-0.05603721737861633,
-0.18876956403255463,
0.2597598135471344,
-0.0374484620988369,
0.22908344864845276,
-0.01455283910036087,
-0.3131061792373657,
-0.48894739151000977,
0.4895252585411072,
-0.8535054326057434,
-0.20339293777942657,
-0.14410075545310974,
-0.6080275774002075,
-0.4668753743171692,
0.4883923828601837,
-0.20828492939472198,
0.5630157589912415,
-0.2725916802883148,
0.4088801145553589,
0.6816538572311401,
0.10902954638004303,
0.5404313206672668,
0.2320556789636612,
0.1339552402496338,
-0.32767704129219055,
1.1124111413955688,
-0.379253089427948,
-0.177571102976799,
0.5506739020347595,
0.14814721047878265,
-0.1302601546049118,
-0.07128928601741791,
-0.5870150923728943,
-0.05711359530687332,
-0.6482186913490295,
-0.05049557238817215,
-0.6422138214111328,
-0.06235918402671814,
-0.42516618967056274,
-0.06364047527313232,
-0.10768477618694305,
-0.37468966841697693,
-0.3786053955554962,
-0.09465900808572769,
0.13449952006340027,
0.7409677505493164,
-0.4773634672164917,
0.22384074330329895,
-0.7356580495834351,
0.7821884751319885,
0.5580023527145386,
0.3588932454586029,
0.14631693065166473,
0.09962978214025497,
-0.34465155005455017,
0.18910057842731476,
-0.4081158936023712,
-0.6744232773780823,
0.02052234672009945,
0.21668028831481934,
1.023882269859314,
0.6382490992546082,
-0.14916540682315826,
0.3128637969493866,
-0.46014946699142456,
0.6600538492202759,
0.40876173973083496,
-0.7671118974685669,
0.5348198413848877,
-0.08851480484008789,
0.047306228429079056,
0.5391417145729065,
0.5779107213020325,
-0.6017704606056213,
0.2543960511684418,
-0.5054651498794556,
-0.5259585976600647,
0.5341596007347107,
-0.192000150680542,
0.0852004736661911,
0.12592822313308716,
0.16271555423736572,
0.1334078162908554,
0.4040655791759491,
-0.7155631184577942,
-0.15757256746292114,
-0.6242979168891907,
-0.8419981598854065,
-0.26913613080978394,
0.05559304729104042,
-0.39745035767555237,
-0.22849051654338837,
0.23267322778701782,
-0.41740715503692627,
0.3548547327518463,
-0.15207211673259735,
-0.3553648889064789,
0.2145453542470932,
0.04109378531575203,
0.8294876217842102,
0.5379772186279297,
0.2681553363800049,
0.5261985063552856,
-0.2623063921928406,
-0.23605917394161224,
0.4040331244468689,
0.34718072414398193,
0.12719860672950745,
-0.5137542486190796,
0.3571973443031311,
0.9127941727638245,
0.35725006461143494,
-0.8448502421379089,
0.3092915415763855,
-0.05841340497136116,
-0.017071668058633804,
-0.10127115994691849,
0.06211438775062561,
0.09671945124864578,
0.6263642311096191,
0.36422351002693176,
0.3997349143028259,
0.14420175552368164,
-0.5940985083580017,
0.40798741579055786,
0.5843522548675537,
-0.44135206937789917,
-0.5899949073791504,
0.7861457467079163,
0.14601528644561768,
-0.16969110071659088,
0.4082149863243103,
0.23958821594715118,
-0.485317587852478,
0.6943677663803101,
0.3551437258720398,
0.6298008561134338,
-0.41603967547416687,
0.03167179971933365,
-0.03386271372437477,
0.2593035399913788,
0.20632337033748627,
0.12897276878356934,
-0.5007913708686829,
-0.8235625624656677,
-0.1629885584115982,
-0.4874747395515442,
-0.3486853241920471,
-0.18263030052185059,
-0.3968305289745331,
-0.1040792316198349,
-0.501693844795227,
-0.19673952460289001,
0.11174406856298447,
-0.1679307371377945,
-0.7250288724899292,
0.4603564441204071,
0.2547467052936554,
0.39673635363578796,
-0.9877592325210571,
0.449078768491745,
0.7620011568069458,
-0.5789498090744019,
-0.41711828112602234,
-0.16457554697990417,
0.0948391780257225,
-0.9996035695075989,
0.6064131259918213,
0.2524416744709015,
-0.20394237339496613,
-0.011944041587412357,
-0.6249997615814209,
-0.8943654298782349,
0.855310320854187,
0.07613805681467056,
-0.05676610767841339,
0.05955004692077637,
-0.036843474954366684,
0.35540246963500977,
-0.25265318155288696,
0.1225140392780304,
0.3251705765724182,
0.8173406720161438,
-0.16671758890151978,
-0.7684542536735535,
-0.20789885520935059,
-0.3682529926300049,
-0.3016866445541382,
0.028623132035136223,
-0.8700115084648132,
1.0002965927124023,
-0.3015053868293762,
0.1438342034816742,
-0.061583079397678375,
0.4537622332572937,
0.2123168408870697,
0.5107409954071045,
0.47434231638908386,
0.810591995716095,
0.644370436668396,
-0.029530823230743408,
0.8070147633552551,
-0.4994259476661682,
-0.015139332972466946,
0.7663694620132446,
-0.2848418951034546,
0.5796142816543579,
0.3694150149822235,
-0.1277811974287033,
0.42784392833709717,
0.5369462966918945,
0.020725935697555542,
0.5100681185722351,
0.030423833057284355,
-0.3084976375102997,
-0.09328466653823853,
-0.19193992018699646,
-0.3101125955581665,
0.6919187307357788,
0.5598993301391602,
-0.2234136015176773,
0.00493262056261301,
0.7362356781959534,
-0.47707927227020264,
-0.15102939307689667,
-0.11739175766706467,
0.7578295469284058,
-0.06881169229745865,
-0.3583607077598572,
0.03173614665865898,
0.2811959385871887,
0.5263081192970276,
-0.5201154947280884,
-0.1576649248600006,
0.05314069986343384,
0.3429214358329773,
-0.1272640973329544,
-0.4646437168121338,
0.11462176591157913,
-0.5302358269691467,
-0.7565215826034546,
-0.17778907716274261,
0.7352880239486694,
-0.3360126316547394,
-0.5126472115516663,
0.295783132314682,
0.6715983152389526,
-0.12066078186035156,
-0.008174180053174496,
-0.7093391418457031,
0.268830806016922,
-0.2889818549156189,
-0.20391510426998138,
0.27090179920196533,
0.33299416303634644,
-0.19765472412109375,
0.6963860988616943,
0.7627442479133606,
-0.3176974356174469,
0.19843846559524536,
-0.0410054586827755,
0.775844931602478,
-0.8748120665550232,
-0.40710416436195374,
-0.5925598740577698,
0.4572996199131012,
0.30993425846099854,
-0.09837333112955093,
0.40764662623405457,
0.29904797673225403,
0.7079572677612305,
0.031924717128276825,
0.8137118816375732,
-0.22768613696098328,
0.25681769847869873,
-0.3506786525249481,
0.6418755650520325,
-0.7540273666381836,
-0.5084637999534607,
-0.047197744250297546,
-0.6202927231788635,
-0.5996251702308655,
0.8539727330207825,
0.1772889643907547,
0.3841259777545929,
0.5648258924484253,
0.49851542711257935,
-0.22621501982212067,
0.09462105482816696,
0.39175406098365784,
0.18819522857666016,
0.45908355712890625,
0.5451005697250366,
0.7619888186454773,
-0.28004172444343567,
0.2574269771575928,
-0.29698115587234497,
-0.3410991430282593,
-0.31427961587905884,
-0.5773870348930359,
-0.5017892122268677,
-0.885766327381134,
0.0566188208758831,
-0.01067766547203064,
-0.26439937949180603,
0.6814483404159546,
1.194106936454773,
-0.8138105869293213,
-0.22987890243530273,
0.0027366180438548326,
0.1878412812948227,
-0.32462868094444275,
-0.20762844383716583,
0.2167494297027588,
-0.24622102081775665,
-0.6728568077087402,
0.8377372026443481,
0.23491328954696655,
0.07826200872659683,
-0.40999218821525574,
-0.306222140789032,
-0.33914434909820557,
-0.31355762481689453,
0.9157657623291016,
0.5548247694969177,
-0.8427913784980774,
-0.22384586930274963,
0.07574443519115448,
-0.018043018877506256,
0.07050634175539017,
0.6770362854003906,
-1.070292353630066,
0.4585816264152527,
0.2757572531700134,
1.070150375366211,
0.3556288480758667,
-0.022657956928014755,
0.2196432501077652,
-0.6663104891777039,
0.43697798252105713,
0.27169036865234375,
0.4119502007961273,
0.20961569249629974,
-0.13252325356006622,
0.5517310500144958,
0.47126245498657227,
-0.3219497501850128,
-0.6037534475326538,
0.3394140303134918,
-0.9801491498947144,
-0.4586678147315979,
0.6459574103355408,
0.19592858850955963,
-0.26240435242652893,
-0.04575321823358536,
-0.11270762979984283,
0.2293151617050171,
-0.09320228546857834,
0.5631809830665588,
0.5648012757301331,
-0.5994248390197754,
-0.44062647223472595,
-0.3283528685569763,
0.051244910806417465,
0.5443320274353027,
-0.9278326034545898,
-0.21027088165283203,
0.8190409541130066,
0.0061521404422819614,
0.629188597202301,
0.40316230058670044,
0.12362975627183914,
0.4630807042121887,
0.1665026992559433,
0.20003291964530945,
-0.18942230939865112,
-0.8688381910324097,
-0.4723241925239563,
0.5624290108680725,
-0.14047202467918396,
-0.410613477230072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18739v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18739v1
|
Towards Dog Bark Decoding: Leveraging Human Speech Processing for Automated Bark Classification
| 2024-04-29T14:41:59 | 2024-04-29T14:41:59 |
Artem Abzaliev, Humberto Pérez Espinosa, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Similar to humans, animals make extensive use of verbal and non-verbal forms
of communication, including a large range of audio signals. In this paper, we
address dog vocalizations and explore the use of self-supervised speech
representation models pre-trained on human speech to address dog bark
classification tasks that find parallels in human-centered tasks in speech
recognition. We specifically address four tasks: dog recognition, breed
identification, gender classification, and context grounding. We show that
using speech embedding representations significantly improves over simpler
classification baselines. Further, we also find that models pre-trained on
large human speech acoustics can provide additional performance boosts on
several tasks.
|
[
-0.41818472743034363,
-0.15982139110565186,
0.21881107985973358,
0.4003065526485443,
-0.0510605126619339,
0.23920302093029022,
-0.1325029879808426,
-0.9058783054351807,
-0.06437166780233383,
0.34702596068382263,
-0.2897293269634247,
-0.6597862243652344,
-0.2836384177207947,
0.020095882937312126,
-0.3539559543132782,
0.6525959968566895,
0.44737380743026733,
0.4045834243297577,
-0.09695718437433243,
0.029313286766409874,
-0.44539183378219604,
-1.1509090662002563,
-0.8527410626411438,
-0.8130851984024048,
0.4190268814563751,
0.02827891893684864,
0.3098085820674896,
0.8207283020019531,
-0.07631979882717133,
0.28707608580589294,
0.27601346373558044,
-0.2211226373910904,
0.18926098942756653,
-0.11260917782783508,
0.02246752753853798,
-0.6086111664772034,
-0.5119374394416809,
0.746501088142395,
0.21157144010066986,
0.5344485640525818,
-0.5423263907432556,
0.030763054266572,
-0.09947769343852997,
0.18898309767246246,
-0.44972801208496094,
0.5240043997764587,
-0.5027233362197876,
0.12306512892246246,
-0.09348978847265244,
-0.3455969989299774,
-0.5777663588523865,
-0.053767088800668716,
0.09400364011526108,
-0.5458401441574097,
0.48492228984832764,
-0.06138060241937637,
0.5750643014907837,
0.3162280023097992,
-0.374176949262619,
-0.6009949445724487,
-0.6864550709724426,
0.7439102530479431,
-0.6847571134567261,
0.4839513301849365,
1.2672128677368164,
0.19480541348457336,
-0.15737836062908173,
-0.9108422994613647,
-0.026977412402629852,
-0.527472734451294,
-0.2613135278224945,
0.06422992050647736,
-0.5135217905044556,
0.3741297721862793,
0.28467118740081787,
0.26156672835350037,
-0.06943457573652267,
0.29823413491249084,
-0.1425730288028717,
-0.4412238895893097,
0.9070858955383301,
0.05884270370006561,
0.3293766379356384,
0.044448062777519226,
0.3573172390460968,
-0.5167919397354126,
-0.1584949791431427,
0.7265055179595947,
0.03293324261903763,
0.27594974637031555,
0.18529503047466278,
0.304718941450119,
0.10406661778688431,
0.8138630390167236,
0.36708348989486694,
-0.19662737846374512,
0.23975011706352234,
0.05134722217917442,
-0.1495707929134369,
0.5847088694572449,
0.30675193667411804,
0.09844087064266205,
0.08705396950244904,
-0.2693973183631897,
-0.05813593417406082,
0.2577076256275177,
0.5696479678153992,
-0.32180261611938477,
-0.3111369013786316,
0.013591493479907513,
-0.5160847306251526,
-0.36131685972213745,
-0.24313266575336456,
-0.023135103285312653,
-0.2483021765947342,
-0.5093816518783569,
0.2679123282432556,
-0.4360378384590149,
-0.1095370352268219,
0.3859870433807373,
-0.5311316847801208,
0.7050056457519531,
0.23743772506713867,
-1.0509352684020996,
0.5597645044326782,
0.47250011563301086,
0.42159903049468994,
0.6446348428726196,
-0.459951788187027,
-0.6513369083404541,
0.5492726564407349,
-0.5154594779014587,
0.4866624176502228,
-0.5761040449142456,
-0.3059108257293701,
-0.41736501455307007,
0.21796581149101257,
0.1544746309518814,
-0.656450092792511,
0.647946298122406,
-0.2385311722755432,
0.07727918028831482,
-0.08269522339105606,
-0.5112488865852356,
-0.5504061579704285,
0.09811374545097351,
-0.5315468311309814,
0.8462687730789185,
-0.0772995576262474,
-0.7226817011833191,
0.2091689258813858,
-0.6512407660484314,
-0.7256314754486084,
-0.07253006100654602,
-0.20080368220806122,
-0.24442967772483826,
0.21556949615478516,
0.3950020968914032,
0.8921709060668945,
0.018817339092493057,
-0.03542692959308624,
-0.08041314035654068,
-0.1985088437795639,
0.05933827906847,
0.08077581971883774,
0.6162711381912231,
0.036282509565353394,
-0.5137177109718323,
0.11479666829109192,
-0.7937806844711304,
0.27619457244873047,
0.228615865111351,
-0.17700549960136414,
-0.6918376684188843,
0.20674434304237366,
-0.1797255277633667,
0.050122056156396866,
0.04841579869389534,
-0.49864354729652405,
0.006031041964888573,
-0.3578953146934509,
0.7095383405685425,
0.2780706286430359,
-0.342990517616272,
0.4596518576145172,
-0.3359203338623047,
0.26174935698509216,
-0.354453444480896,
-0.3283715546131134,
-0.19073906540870667,
-0.30701690912246704,
-0.34328362345695496,
-0.49222174286842346,
0.37221866846084595,
0.6056877970695496,
0.12951232492923737,
0.8823568820953369,
0.29180601239204407,
-0.6202681064605713,
-0.7777389287948608,
-0.20233972370624542,
0.17721708118915558,
0.1877732276916504,
0.3583971858024597,
-0.33457058668136597,
-0.6404314041137695,
-0.8504998683929443,
-0.01737157069146633,
-0.26087477803230286,
-0.2979387640953064,
0.24716851115226746,
0.20470686256885529,
-0.32593369483947754,
1.230191946029663,
-0.25394895672798157,
-0.6739338040351868,
-0.24274131655693054,
0.7877013087272644,
-0.06483424454927444,
0.5081478953361511,
0.5641178488731384,
-0.5768674612045288,
-0.1928010731935501,
-0.042373981326818466,
-0.7752740979194641,
-0.12475704401731491,
-0.004197234753519297,
0.27827996015548706,
-0.03689732402563095,
0.78616863489151,
-0.393229603767395,
0.533183217048645,
0.3142009973526001,
-0.05187024921178818,
0.21917901933193207,
-0.4487968683242798,
0.050226155668497086,
-0.5344769954681396,
-0.2773906886577606,
-0.030035322532057762,
-0.6315169930458069,
-0.7229881286621094,
-0.5791047215461731,
-0.10585488379001617,
-0.20057745277881622,
-0.050915155559778214,
0.1649717092514038,
-0.7669817209243774,
-0.4957067370414734,
-0.5843698978424072,
-0.15689268708229065,
-0.021304527297616005,
0.23163804411888123,
0.6720955967903137,
0.6078137159347534,
0.8932507038116455,
-0.44954225420951843,
0.47939351201057434,
0.11865941435098648,
0.1692975014448166,
0.3556234836578369,
-0.6554641723632812,
0.407259076833725,
-0.0581892766058445,
0.6708511710166931,
-0.701298713684082,
-0.22636032104492188,
-0.05902539938688278,
-0.7269519567489624,
0.4907403886318207,
-0.2633572518825531,
-0.48698440194129944,
-0.42577028274536133,
-0.207862988114357,
0.1840793341398239,
0.7142729759216309,
-0.7713498473167419,
0.638779878616333,
0.6220625638961792,
0.12410794198513031,
-0.18490226566791534,
-0.5758517384529114,
0.11828518658876419,
-0.39334121346473694,
-0.5893605947494507,
0.5525786280632019,
0.3624112904071808,
0.006044342182576656,
0.034796006977558136,
-0.02685772068798542,
-0.0976993590593338,
0.12058302015066147,
0.4718859791755676,
-0.4102499783039093,
-0.02810143493115902,
0.42737796902656555,
-0.2983088195323944,
-0.09402678161859512,
0.30081358551979065,
-0.2955802381038666,
0.6546337008476257,
-0.4376002848148346,
-0.17911593616008759,
-0.9138970971107483,
0.5402168035507202,
0.4398997724056244,
-0.49480968713760376,
0.2962810695171356,
1.001416802406311,
-0.49524596333503723,
-0.1002671867609024,
-0.6325221657752991,
-0.4754888713359833,
-0.46238774061203003,
0.2785741090774536,
-0.5383093357086182,
-0.6442262530326843,
0.3233639597892761,
-0.325812429189682,
-0.3429569602012634,
0.06520380824804306,
0.2214285284280777,
-0.8323432207107544,
1.4359235763549805,
0.9543306231498718,
-0.40493327379226685,
0.4900383949279785,
-0.08244222402572632,
-0.05741407349705696,
-0.7831732034683228,
-0.18542733788490295,
-0.6510952711105347,
0.062315039336681366,
-0.44465258717536926,
-0.34082722663879395,
-0.030541110783815384,
0.3406386077404022,
-0.11519434303045273,
0.2039705365896225,
-0.7515159249305725,
0.3799743950366974,
0.8340736031532288,
0.00534674059599638,
0.09153418242931366,
0.2386496514081955,
0.2504443824291229,
-0.1898256540298462,
-0.7614516019821167,
-0.5958350896835327,
0.7680778503417969,
0.7450111508369446,
0.9016934037208557,
-0.4828358292579651,
0.930933952331543,
0.6051883697509766,
0.10217228531837463,
-1.1280999183654785,
0.30753272771835327,
-0.31533604860305786,
-0.6355417966842651,
-0.38918986916542053,
0.04469954967498779,
-1.1968551874160767,
0.2647556662559509,
-0.07359881699085236,
-0.8595383167266846,
-0.11774902790784836,
0.07040965557098389,
0.06212642416357994,
0.1695684939622879,
-0.6013858318328857,
0.6058453917503357,
-0.43382886052131653,
0.18076880276203156,
-0.5714145302772522,
-0.6667807102203369,
0.012482849881052971,
0.21654532849788666,
0.22380957007408142,
-0.14550720155239105,
0.26747575402259827,
1.0799757242202759,
-0.1283719688653946,
1.1498016119003296,
-0.41380253434181213,
-0.030265523120760918,
0.4898858070373535,
-0.38328561186790466,
0.4749949872493744,
-0.2765093743801117,
0.07110460102558136,
0.11490867286920547,
0.2549067735671997,
-0.3727830946445465,
-0.5255972146987915,
0.016474397853016853,
-0.7922579050064087,
-0.6804668307304382,
-0.7054955959320068,
-0.18579845130443573,
-0.4040343761444092,
-0.07194225490093231,
0.23647406697273254,
0.4937855899333954,
-0.18009737133979797,
0.12833242118358612,
0.19783170521259308,
-0.08474156260490417,
0.4661581814289093,
0.7457907199859619,
-0.12855027616024017,
-0.3911980986595154,
0.7207586765289307,
-0.12100150436162949,
-0.156074658036232,
-0.012902245856821537,
0.2096615880727768,
-0.6970980763435364,
-0.4292795956134796,
-0.30110880732536316,
0.4576913118362427,
-0.8543815612792969,
-0.004500380251556635,
-0.5718598961830139,
-0.3725798726081848,
-0.4827444851398468,
-0.21944104135036469,
-0.5002753138542175,
0.09442964941263199,
-0.560318648815155,
-0.19339603185653687,
0.2784724831581116,
1.1893692016601562,
-0.5211613774299622,
0.6871352791786194,
-1.038102388381958,
0.3966752886772156,
0.6962574124336243,
0.07092853635549545,
0.14297178387641907,
-0.3988717794418335,
-0.2742652893066406,
0.03587381914258003,
-0.1777011603116989,
-1.132821798324585,
0.5186688303947449,
0.3512442708015442,
1.0546958446502686,
-0.032441023737192154,
0.18987800180912018,
0.7759237885475159,
-0.4762475788593292,
0.4584304988384247,
0.2509393095970154,
-1.3227589130401611,
0.8748728632926941,
-0.22898678481578827,
-0.10474400967359543,
0.40768274664878845,
0.5317087173461914,
-0.4206518232822418,
-0.36930009722709656,
-0.507846474647522,
-0.4488866329193115,
1.0690491199493408,
0.14695702493190765,
0.08798570185899734,
0.23532089591026306,
0.3342646658420563,
-0.11088456958532333,
-0.016637077555060387,
-0.6925473213195801,
-0.12968406081199646,
-0.5468423366546631,
0.01397209893912077,
-0.38704392313957214,
-0.10105492174625397,
-0.108260877430439,
-0.7476543188095093,
0.40476271510124207,
-0.17289523780345917,
0.3434503674507141,
0.46293094754219055,
-0.08839952945709229,
0.01578489877283573,
0.36487406492233276,
0.25108960270881653,
0.018837492913007736,
-0.6476485133171082,
0.21251577138900757,
0.2845395505428314,
-0.372657835483551,
0.7175646424293518,
-0.020133748650550842,
0.5586228966712952,
-0.019131803885102272,
0.6025223135948181,
0.6672819256782532,
-0.05154212564229965,
-0.42151662707328796,
0.3613792657852173,
-0.36446094512939453,
-0.18191629648208618,
-0.5419324636459351,
-0.10996787995100021,
0.31616732478141785,
0.36500585079193115,
0.4604969024658203,
-0.17018239200115204,
0.5084649920463562,
-0.806451678276062,
0.41721731424331665,
0.44492006301879883,
-0.40942537784576416,
-0.34773877263069153,
0.3840237259864807,
0.12797683477401733,
-0.32027554512023926,
0.6763005256652832,
-0.2722190320491791,
-0.7518911361694336,
0.6038956642150879,
0.9460055232048035,
0.9734538793563843,
-0.38404715061187744,
0.2047991156578064,
0.2610573470592499,
0.06929851323366165,
-0.19431781768798828,
-0.046815238893032074,
-0.6411038041114807,
-0.46734750270843506,
-0.2930257022380829,
-0.5155805349349976,
-0.28936338424682617,
0.0649552270770073,
-1.0810158252716064,
0.19331522285938263,
-0.32487231492996216,
-0.5246238708496094,
0.3095867931842804,
-0.08666791766881943,
-0.18601827323436737,
0.4758126437664032,
0.6566067337989807,
0.5884050726890564,
-0.8008681535720825,
1.3427810668945312,
1.0077998638153076,
-0.054659660905599594,
-1.0983906984329224,
0.1020534560084343,
-0.351108580827713,
-0.32753342390060425,
1.0321173667907715,
0.5317304134368896,
-0.8696483373641968,
0.3005213439464569,
-0.759824812412262,
-0.5212871432304382,
0.9823752641677856,
0.08109816163778305,
-0.31039756536483765,
-0.09218864142894745,
-0.004596942104399204,
0.7646344900131226,
-0.47554314136505127,
0.009228070266544819,
0.6903867721557617,
0.27173230051994324,
0.13126637041568756,
-1.1735413074493408,
-0.08911273628473282,
-0.26001280546188354,
-0.3385006785392761,
-0.5260365009307861,
-0.3433760404586792,
0.7045525312423706,
-0.030497178435325623,
-0.37875181436538696,
-0.22703805565834045,
0.6232234835624695,
0.2505435049533844,
0.6548654437065125,
0.7196829319000244,
0.4463229775428772,
1.0001296997070312,
0.09955228865146637,
0.8129374384880066,
0.055780503898859024,
0.13987277448177338,
1.2313328981399536,
-0.19708122313022614,
0.9347450137138367,
-0.14958010613918304,
-0.5045830011367798,
0.18685467541217804,
0.7277319431304932,
0.06677119433879852,
0.6942770481109619,
0.4069961607456207,
-0.2815196216106415,
-0.6130425930023193,
-0.2265092432498932,
-0.6775469779968262,
1.0051093101501465,
0.6232543587684631,
-0.18337790668010712,
-0.2273450493812561,
0.3627496063709259,
-0.6320369839668274,
-0.11274675279855728,
-0.43687519431114197,
1.1110107898712158,
0.2161734402179718,
-0.40511924028396606,
0.94139564037323,
0.16282467544078827,
0.8102770447731018,
-0.3807717263698578,
-0.17589892446994781,
0.22987103462219238,
0.09577479213476181,
-0.3616025447845459,
-0.6676039099693298,
0.5377890467643738,
-0.14033521711826324,
-0.3520061671733856,
-0.33968400955200195,
0.9831897616386414,
-0.27122756838798523,
-0.005546947475522757,
0.9059590697288513,
0.11026104539632797,
0.38347530364990234,
-0.5918349623680115,
-0.507789134979248,
-0.2557041049003601,
0.03552224487066269,
0.11496458947658539,
0.250733345746994,
0.15398092567920685,
-0.2976463735103607,
0.7814383506774902,
0.4251607358455658,
-0.0009422641596756876,
0.46950966119766235,
0.09045212715864182,
0.6672025918960571,
-1.237614631652832,
-0.7216252684593201,
-0.5821117162704468,
0.10560090094804764,
0.1251894235610962,
0.40933212637901306,
0.5274826288223267,
0.2642139792442322,
0.580237090587616,
-0.2074320912361145,
0.8624112010002136,
0.1307414025068283,
0.6585560441017151,
-0.3498476445674896,
0.6277241706848145,
-0.5250023603439331,
-0.07547866553068161,
-0.0033617508597671986,
-0.6128169894218445,
-0.232118621468544,
0.9954403638839722,
-0.41857314109802246,
-0.04129308462142944,
0.3487792909145355,
0.506335437297821,
-0.07861538231372833,
0.3194519281387329,
0.5578697919845581,
-0.2460934966802597,
0.36034005880355835,
0.28472286462783813,
1.517266035079956,
-0.04926242679357529,
0.4947357773780823,
-0.40212729573249817,
-0.0672098845243454,
0.023621108382940292,
-0.4901656210422516,
-1.153270959854126,
-0.7546520829200745,
-0.2325814664363861,
-0.11524847149848938,
-0.17749881744384766,
0.953117311000824,
1.6204063892364502,
-0.6496981978416443,
-0.4723876416683197,
0.00005779104685643688,
-0.2996481657028198,
0.00941214058548212,
-0.1777123361825943,
0.27774232625961304,
-0.6879147887229919,
-0.5626846551895142,
0.6157605051994324,
0.13629300892353058,
0.38468945026397705,
-0.029891500249505043,
-0.19590544700622559,
0.06424806267023087,
-0.0717892050743103,
0.5908130407333374,
0.5301632881164551,
-0.8943051099777222,
-0.006113085430115461,
-0.20956474542617798,
-0.33408239483833313,
0.39095792174339294,
0.9928825497627258,
-0.9570632576942444,
0.1722756326198578,
0.22402547299861908,
0.506070613861084,
0.9973888397216797,
0.41799819469451904,
0.5360046029090881,
-0.8107447624206543,
0.3358003497123718,
0.34679558873176575,
0.05859330669045448,
0.47335922718048096,
-0.2809738218784332,
0.41880741715431213,
-0.0853848084807396,
-0.3918963670730591,
-0.6301955580711365,
0.055678386241197586,
-1.2630810737609863,
-0.3361045718193054,
0.5425266623497009,
-0.4223502576351166,
-0.3349214494228363,
-0.3986418545246124,
-0.5782953500747681,
0.4551209807395935,
-0.5199524164199829,
0.3932691216468811,
0.6728578209877014,
-0.7476999163627625,
-0.41031327843666077,
-0.38546478748321533,
0.706661581993103,
0.2793058753013611,
-0.8885457515716553,
0.052152860909700394,
0.2610703110694885,
0.45166945457458496,
0.32728299498558044,
0.893105685710907,
-0.047482363879680634,
0.16372284293174744,
0.19987916946411133,
0.3131926357746124,
-0.01014732476323843,
-0.27851006388664246,
-0.5499546527862549,
0.16246455907821655,
0.4804387390613556,
-0.6143328547477722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18726v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18726v1
|
The Constant in HATE: Analyzing Toxicity in Reddit across Topics and Languages
| 2024-04-29T14:14:33 | 2024-04-29T14:14:33 |
Wondimagegnhue Tsegaye Tufa, Ilia Markov, Piek Vossen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Toxic language remains an ongoing challenge on social media platforms,
presenting significant issues for users and communities. This paper provides a
cross-topic and cross-lingual analysis of toxicity in Reddit conversations. We
collect 1.5 million comment threads from 481 communities in six languages:
English, German, Spanish, Turkish,Arabic, and Dutch, covering 80 topics such as
Culture, Politics, and News. We thoroughly analyze how toxicity spikes within
different communities in relation to specific topics. We observe consistent
patterns of increased toxicity across languages for certain topics, while also
noting significant variations within specific language communities.
|
[
-0.39023667573928833,
-1.0712591409683228,
0.3595104217529297,
0.6486645340919495,
-0.09293689578771591,
0.2816993296146393,
-0.07896441221237183,
-0.7889516949653625,
0.5236800312995911,
0.43426477909088135,
-0.6193091869354248,
-0.332504004240036,
-0.831158459186554,
0.34324660897254944,
-0.2419319748878479,
1.1680108308792114,
-0.02735082432627678,
0.24576063454151154,
0.06484434008598328,
-0.4664861857891083,
-0.4473772644996643,
-0.5493142604827881,
-0.7931551933288574,
-0.1391824334859848,
1.2771375179290771,
0.7198567986488342,
0.5409973859786987,
0.021443691104650497,
0.6736564636230469,
0.2955109477043152,
-0.13836711645126343,
-0.30270639061927795,
-0.7188256978988647,
0.37778374552726746,
-0.628751814365387,
-0.2251836210489273,
0.17833484709262848,
-0.16104954481124878,
0.20228414237499237,
0.4537547528743744,
0.1558588445186615,
0.18244408071041107,
-0.11987011879682541,
0.601885199546814,
-0.5586156845092773,
-0.31423360109329224,
-0.7723660469055176,
0.049893513321876526,
-0.434752494096756,
-0.042187221348285675,
-0.21767829358577728,
-0.5613670349121094,
0.03567194938659668,
-0.44304177165031433,
-0.2551495432853699,
-0.4279199242591858,
0.8623515963554382,
0.03969471529126167,
-0.6691032648086548,
-0.7378148436546326,
-0.6310107707977295,
1.1329960823059082,
-0.3025233745574951,
0.24776910245418549,
0.030594948679208755,
0.16287921369075775,
-0.11092443019151688,
-0.3586792051792145,
-0.47280237078666687,
-0.06840911507606506,
-0.28174445033073425,
-0.16663824021816254,
-0.551414966583252,
-0.3388640284538269,
-0.1498679518699646,
0.10341325402259827,
-0.5273333787918091,
-0.09734652936458588,
-0.5688284039497375,
-0.011224715039134026,
0.821190595626831,
0.2032407820224762,
1.0151727199554443,
-0.19105608761310577,
-0.022306350991129875,
0.4806995093822479,
-0.5050499439239502,
-0.5319908261299133,
0.6226535439491272,
0.0905950739979744,
-0.10429246723651886,
0.33432984352111816,
0.31421688199043274,
0.5262383222579956,
-0.15015189349651337,
-0.08088402450084686,
0.14575359225273132,
-0.3608974814414978,
0.2132248729467392,
-0.20627130568027496,
0.8592666387557983,
0.8955385088920593,
0.5009287595748901,
-0.1350039541721344,
0.4523985683917999,
0.5220381021499634,
0.4680291414260864,
-0.6581411957740784,
-0.24275976419448853,
0.1613166630268097,
-0.23777972161769867,
-0.4533287286758423,
-0.4269053339958191,
-1.2539623975753784,
-0.7552584409713745,
0.3172324001789093,
-0.1205231249332428,
-0.021274369210004807,
-0.4895571172237396,
-0.19544871151447296,
-0.30586549639701843,
-0.21188707649707794,
0.1536865085363388,
-0.4321020543575287,
0.19271904230117798,
0.48624956607818604,
0.7858753204345703,
-0.4683523178100586,
-0.39878958463668823,
-0.3218839764595032,
-0.0932326391339302,
-0.37917861342430115,
0.9485822916030884,
-0.7324122786521912,
-0.26672959327697754,
0.285023033618927,
0.14044682681560516,
0.20658713579177856,
-0.7295162677764893,
0.4766610562801361,
-0.5394929647445679,
0.07393929362297058,
-0.3283798098564148,
-0.02508506551384926,
-0.2728109359741211,
0.3811648488044739,
-0.47567155957221985,
0.775597095489502,
0.0990857258439064,
-0.9540979266166687,
0.38835811614990234,
-0.6097243428230286,
-0.5936244130134583,
0.08567774295806885,
0.0920170471072197,
-0.20328471064567566,
-0.07122154533863068,
-0.5167860984802246,
0.049178604036569595,
-0.19925422966480255,
-0.016434889286756516,
-0.33631449937820435,
-0.13559278845787048,
0.23005206882953644,
0.050747379660606384,
0.9728181958198547,
0.4966616630554199,
-0.44783270359039307,
0.31706932187080383,
-0.6375131607055664,
-0.3745708465576172,
0.09670741856098175,
-0.40136417746543884,
-0.7752335071563721,
0.16743698716163635,
0.3531651794910431,
0.7199281454086304,
-0.026316681876778603,
-0.9055307507514954,
-0.3379789888858795,
-0.2277131825685501,
0.6524541974067688,
0.4586729407310486,
0.5925655364990234,
0.15606984496116638,
-0.42334696650505066,
0.5617462992668152,
0.23153312504291534,
0.29784560203552246,
0.31200626492500305,
-0.6878530383110046,
-0.6577132344245911,
0.38173311948776245,
-0.5275486707687378,
0.5762497782707214,
-0.4172654449939728,
-0.068793386220932,
-0.06758899241685867,
-0.7536967396736145,
-0.29795026779174805,
0.23125116527080536,
0.5143166184425354,
0.10100298374891281,
0.27654919028282166,
-0.31921809911727905,
-0.7756657004356384,
-0.845111072063446,
-0.6290338635444641,
-0.22557327151298523,
0.34847521781921387,
0.4768419563770294,
0.3900566101074219,
-0.5611165165901184,
0.4658691883087158,
-0.25421956181526184,
-0.2797602117061615,
-0.2731921374797821,
0.4818262755870819,
-0.008454297669231892,
0.1293945610523224,
0.7976773977279663,
-0.6302339434623718,
-1.5059821605682373,
0.4156956970691681,
-0.6045264005661011,
-0.5708191394805908,
-0.16453425586223602,
-0.4253842234611511,
0.34506168961524963,
0.7009703516960144,
-0.05139598995447159,
0.08958278596401215,
0.776637852191925,
-0.536815345287323,
0.394452303647995,
0.4171311855316162,
0.3436441421508789,
-0.8370577096939087,
-0.023775329813361168,
0.3495325446128845,
0.17397528886795044,
-0.8123649954795837,
0.1320512592792511,
-0.382925808429718,
0.01103144884109497,
-0.8641376495361328,
0.7750208973884583,
-0.16497395932674408,
0.6016225218772888,
-0.11061198264360428,
0.03455686941742897,
-0.35250064730644226,
0.1783817559480667,
-0.06458010524511337,
0.5936302542686462,
0.10372067242860794,
-0.34375613927841187,
0.5837875008583069,
-0.030141575261950493,
-0.18037675321102142,
0.5576453804969788,
-0.3793793320655823,
-0.023308591917157173,
-0.17555829882621765,
0.06729681044816971,
-0.9095790982246399,
-0.22160662710666656,
0.5115256309509277,
-0.34122776985168457,
-0.29688823223114014,
-0.24215593934059143,
-0.46816781163215637,
-0.45614492893218994,
-0.15211397409439087,
0.4534391164779663,
0.15410207211971283,
0.13939735293388367,
0.38536903262138367,
0.8662778735160828,
-0.4354082942008972,
-0.5757386684417725,
-0.8257044553756714,
0.09209008514881134,
-0.48414674401283264,
-0.5036914944648743,
-0.12849272787570953,
-0.4855647385120392,
-0.9851123094558716,
0.07263898849487305,
0.015806760638952255,
-0.3517206609249115,
-0.0017945647705346346,
0.29367366433143616,
-0.3600012958049774,
0.07433678954839706,
0.009974811226129532,
-0.07406440377235413,
0.11811818927526474,
0.35447314381599426,
0.3088473081588745,
0.750589907169342,
-0.0635170042514801,
0.04047613963484764,
-0.1348017007112503,
0.9047308564186096,
1.0471142530441284,
0.3116041123867035,
0.8195082545280457,
0.10807029157876968,
-0.08612310141324997,
-0.27529722452163696,
-0.46608617901802063,
0.129643976688385,
-0.4837033450603485,
0.5455426573753357,
-0.01935451291501522,
-0.9273504614830017,
0.8821585178375244,
0.42695847153663635,
0.22292767465114594,
0.4566953182220459,
0.8498853445053101,
-0.024432245641946793,
0.752013623714447,
0.6285656690597534,
-0.48290953040122986,
0.5937583446502686,
0.4434591829776764,
0.2996588349342346,
0.19669175148010254,
-0.09178300946950912,
-0.6081680059432983,
-0.32319560647010803,
-0.577783465385437,
-0.2514525055885315,
0.3722791075706482,
-0.4541971981525421,
-0.676763117313385,
0.2606826722621918,
-0.46815234422683716,
0.7915900349617004,
0.11905041337013245,
-0.05216890946030617,
0.33878985047340393,
0.200484499335289,
0.05308062210679054,
-0.7290481925010681,
-0.7253287434577942,
-0.12865190207958221,
0.5661059617996216,
0.564134955406189,
0.6946989297866821,
0.25276193022727966,
0.27649766206741333,
0.32477957010269165,
0.8969936966896057,
-0.6589122414588928,
0.3576754629611969,
-0.2184380441904068,
-0.9589269757270813,
-0.09487175196409225,
-0.44085410237312317,
-0.740085780620575,
0.10364831238985062,
0.16266462206840515,
-0.38333064317703247,
0.006861129309982061,
-0.1334185004234314,
-0.07009968161582947,
0.4970252215862274,
-0.6931008696556091,
0.9660730361938477,
-0.17706601321697235,
-0.3732283413410187,
-0.4747701585292816,
-0.6313198804855347,
0.4724227488040924,
-0.23171716928482056,
0.6277896165847778,
-0.09110467880964279,
0.07110723853111267,
0.7238737940788269,
-0.1250605434179306,
0.9399527907371521,
0.2623516023159027,
-0.4059928059577942,
0.31042686104774475,
0.22187907993793488,
0.1229584738612175,
-0.03376386687159538,
-0.14133591949939728,
0.43328848481178284,
-0.28075289726257324,
-0.5678114295005798,
-0.13022300601005554,
0.9939159154891968,
-0.7266939878463745,
-0.36046352982521057,
-0.610744833946228,
-0.44673293828964233,
-0.1303291767835617,
0.15474332869052887,
0.4186065196990967,
-0.19371913373470306,
-0.23711177706718445,
-0.15152481198310852,
0.5851373076438904,
-0.7537654638290405,
0.11109986156225204,
0.7711562514305115,
-0.33538147807121277,
-0.16827794909477234,
1.1511766910552979,
0.03780195489525795,
0.4504689574241638,
0.008723186329007149,
0.13906130194664001,
0.22852836549282074,
-0.2525748610496521,
-0.39581170678138733,
0.5560185313224792,
-0.8583472967147827,
-0.1369004100561142,
-0.8973448276519775,
-0.3118722438812256,
-0.036233462393283844,
-0.5175166726112366,
-0.5103768110275269,
0.2984328269958496,
0.02127275988459587,
0.06840991228818893,
0.4409584403038025,
1.045345664024353,
-0.22882232069969177,
0.11572417616844177,
-0.8685041666030884,
-0.04833602160215378,
0.4522750973701477,
0.6130130290985107,
-0.0969383493065834,
-0.36635908484458923,
-0.16864293813705444,
-0.1949741244316101,
-0.15466538071632385,
-1.4507265090942383,
0.34696733951568604,
-0.14426879584789276,
0.32913947105407715,
0.43919864296913147,
0.05759761482477188,
0.5339447259902954,
-0.3831504285335541,
0.9357222318649292,
0.2034424990415573,
-0.5937870740890503,
0.536600649356842,
-0.7080963850021362,
0.08593636006116867,
0.6392803192138672,
1.020140528678894,
-1.4507744312286377,
-1.130440354347229,
-0.47413283586502075,
-0.8579359650611877,
0.4726186990737915,
-0.09024497121572495,
0.8269685506820679,
-0.5262836813926697,
-0.08662018924951553,
0.06018228083848953,
-0.021809441968798637,
-1.149715542793274,
-0.7593816518783569,
-0.03729915991425514,
0.17455922067165375,
0.1855347901582718,
-0.6955780386924744,
-0.38486728072166443,
-0.5146912336349487,
0.7852787971496582,
0.43618425726890564,
0.02479526773095131,
-0.3896636366844177,
-0.16674131155014038,
-0.8638108372688293,
0.28424835205078125,
0.7096192240715027,
0.9133240580558777,
-0.1353989541530609,
0.13017140328884125,
0.22069735825061798,
-0.7271970510482788,
0.14494532346725464,
-0.5021549463272095,
-0.13033677637577057,
0.4176207482814789,
0.18503475189208984,
0.2530525326728821,
0.5427706241607666,
-0.8962945342063904,
0.38535237312316895,
0.013695617206394672,
-0.18039236962795258,
-0.3013418912887573,
-0.25337329506874084,
0.2175671011209488,
0.13790802657604218,
0.15174750983715057,
-0.009129079058766365,
-0.2715061604976654,
-0.8198567628860474,
0.5748215913772583,
0.1521008461713791,
-0.7055171132087708,
-0.2336985468864441,
0.49291524291038513,
0.5079384446144104,
-0.030796870589256287,
0.23278246819972992,
-0.18610116839408875,
-0.767906904220581,
0.3827879726886749,
0.40283727645874023,
0.7459757328033447,
-0.21469755470752716,
0.5642395615577698,
0.7699545621871948,
0.3956384062767029,
0.5764802694320679,
0.24677222967147827,
0.4289311468601227,
-0.7347596883773804,
-0.30682173371315,
-0.8785196542739868,
-0.2753245532512665,
0.42432454228401184,
-0.1550246775150299,
0.024522893130779266,
-0.42670339345932007,
0.16962097585201263,
0.2876402735710144,
0.010113934054970741,
-0.04520415514707565,
-0.13578161597251892,
-0.01220098976045847,
0.8261731266975403,
-1.2947434186935425,
0.5465885400772095,
0.9725677371025085,
-0.6087566018104553,
-0.2698686122894287,
0.1677578240633011,
0.3648563027381897,
-0.47541216015815735,
0.9009972810745239,
-0.30308640003204346,
-0.14470931887626648,
-0.2757655680179596,
-0.6495065689086914,
-0.6654759645462036,
0.19995319843292236,
-0.0013915246818214655,
-0.32548969984054565,
0.3343760371208191,
0.27246642112731934,
0.8874338269233704,
-0.12599781155586243,
0.11023400723934174,
0.4942992627620697,
0.5841397643089294,
-0.0352921225130558,
-0.8798283338546753,
-0.2212323397397995,
-0.6784025430679321,
-0.23997166752815247,
0.28866004943847656,
-0.7687555551528931,
0.8216940760612488,
0.33753159642219543,
-0.42432093620300293,
-0.34955236315727234,
0.2972048819065094,
-0.044651828706264496,
0.09475994110107422,
0.48675620555877686,
0.3693785071372986,
0.1555306613445282,
0.21117521822452545,
0.7017683386802673,
-0.38711512088775635,
0.37574493885040283,
0.8268817067146301,
-0.0870286226272583,
0.6012762784957886,
0.5559769868850708,
-0.11730042099952698,
0.8417324423789978,
0.41957393288612366,
0.18915554881095886,
0.3703763484954834,
0.41707199811935425,
-0.5296617746353149,
-0.10493776202201843,
-0.5149886012077332,
-0.3037708103656769,
0.0807153657078743,
0.4123104512691498,
-0.3124680519104004,
-0.76447993516922,
0.28186121582984924,
0.6635669469833374,
0.41593068838119507,
-0.25572720170021057,
0.7115470767021179,
-0.015578792430460453,
-0.6926416754722595,
0.5662378072738647,
0.029133150354027748,
1.0406526327133179,
-0.5043715834617615,
0.04503151401877403,
-0.48919475078582764,
0.12399772554636002,
-0.212255597114563,
-0.9656255841255188,
1.060006022453308,
0.38529813289642334,
-0.11738573759794235,
-0.20439191162586212,
0.6143177151679993,
-0.5039281845092773,
-0.32078614830970764,
0.8257724642753601,
0.41018325090408325,
0.2838425934314728,
-0.23132561147212982,
-0.8975716829299927,
0.4304567575454712,
-0.031719524413347244,
-0.10775376856327057,
0.5426217317581177,
0.5036991238594055,
-0.18381698429584503,
0.6806057691574097,
0.37809574604034424,
0.09556730836629868,
0.41739222407341003,
-0.12080323696136475,
0.9410104155540466,
-0.475754976272583,
-0.2075122892856598,
-0.7660850286483765,
0.41715487837791443,
-0.024950016289949417,
-0.6083939075469971,
0.8700432181358337,
0.3705464005470276,
1.0972708463668823,
-0.02100985124707222,
0.9468839168548584,
-0.5026078224182129,
0.853172779083252,
0.28941649198532104,
1.1013882160186768,
-0.891366720199585,
-0.14687754213809967,
-0.5522165894508362,
-0.6378372311592102,
-0.6107804179191589,
0.5896231532096863,
-0.31011608242988586,
-0.19351154565811157,
0.855404257774353,
0.8926859498023987,
0.1818336397409439,
-0.2701658606529236,
0.24200162291526794,
0.6649085283279419,
0.07301236689090729,
0.5398621559143066,
0.9940590262413025,
-0.22672714293003082,
0.7706325650215149,
-0.42160382866859436,
0.06493128836154938,
-0.23114895820617676,
-0.5533366799354553,
-0.7675319314002991,
-0.5433226227760315,
-0.41204366087913513,
-0.7731180787086487,
0.1418524831533432,
0.6266152262687683,
0.09867513179779053,
-1.134626865386963,
-0.44500836730003357,
-0.154825821518898,
0.7030641436576843,
-0.0262607429176569,
-0.34434112906455994,
-0.29644113779067993,
-0.3202686309814453,
-0.8917495608329773,
-0.11101541668176651,
0.385604590177536,
-0.48333021998405457,
-0.2504035532474518,
-0.09075696021318436,
-0.6246821880340576,
0.09215544164180756,
0.8036664724349976,
0.64260333776474,
-0.6106057167053223,
-0.4995647370815277,
-0.11929269134998322,
-0.5719586610794067,
-0.048460375517606735,
0.9004218578338623,
-0.08929570019245148,
0.43337082862854004,
0.7911532521247864,
0.300454318523407,
-0.09231381118297577,
-0.22528105974197388,
0.46887779235839844,
-0.64898282289505,
0.28972405195236206,
0.37890976667404175,
-0.25885382294654846,
0.056664589792490005,
-0.27098631858825684,
0.4062947630882263,
0.5720158219337463,
-0.6464307904243469,
-0.8194901347160339,
0.4504426419734955,
-0.7594311237335205,
-0.6518031358718872,
1.5556063652038574,
-0.010558716021478176,
-0.009625951759517193,
-0.801472544670105,
-0.009745204821228981,
0.03741242364048958,
-0.46889257431030273,
0.9744471907615662,
1.0296069383621216,
0.07320158183574677,
-0.4180595874786377,
-0.9199481010437012,
0.7519171237945557,
0.38363152742385864,
-0.7109982371330261,
-0.027921514585614204,
0.645442008972168,
0.6572205424308777,
0.41256415843963623,
0.8597542643547058,
-0.23690946400165558,
0.4781336486339569,
0.001925648539327085,
-0.061672501266002655,
0.8822466135025024,
-0.402959942817688,
-0.0022371693048626184,
0.2564760148525238,
-0.17561128735542297,
0.3306178152561188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18722v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18722v1
|
Improving Automatic Text Recognition with Language Models in the PyLaia Open-Source Library
| 2024-04-29T14:11:16 | 2024-04-29T14:11:16 |
Solène Tarride, Yoann Schneider, Marie Generali-Lince, Mélodie Boillet, Bastien Abadie, Christopher Kermorvant
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
PyLaia is one of the most popular open-source software for Automatic Text
Recognition (ATR), delivering strong performance in terms of speed and
accuracy. In this paper, we outline our recent contributions to the PyLaia
library, focusing on the incorporation of reliable confidence scores and the
integration of statistical language modeling during decoding. Our
implementation provides an easy way to combine PyLaia with n-grams language
models at different levels. One of the highlights of this work is that language
models are completely auto-tuned: they can be built and used easily without any
expert knowledge, and without requiring any additional data. To demonstrate the
significance of our contribution, we evaluate PyLaia's performance on twelve
datasets, both with and without language modelling. The results show that
decoding with small language models improves the Word Error Rate by 13% and the
Character Error Rate by 12% in average. Additionally, we conduct an analysis of
confidence scores and highlight the importance of calibration techniques. Our
implementation is publicly available in the official PyLaia repository at
https://gitlab.teklia.com/atr/pylaia, and twelve open-source models are
released on Hugging Face.
|
[
0.10830778628587723,
-0.3652866780757904,
0.4860319495201111,
0.36969178915023804,
-0.2782614827156067,
-0.017746036872267723,
-0.10909027606248856,
-0.7498851418495178,
0.16271108388900757,
0.2504226267337799,
0.249848872423172,
-0.5260456204414368,
-0.6478918194770813,
0.325741171836853,
-0.5201140642166138,
0.6162142753601074,
-0.4154947102069855,
-0.011258685030043125,
0.02717939205467701,
-0.165635347366333,
-0.03249518573284149,
-0.5603283047676086,
-0.33691659569740295,
-0.25873127579689026,
0.42491504549980164,
0.2885408103466034,
0.6959738731384277,
1.0329560041427612,
0.6158115863800049,
0.2437705099582672,
-0.14197465777397156,
0.08322614431381226,
-0.1650714874267578,
-0.06727556884288788,
0.06726420670747757,
-0.4655647277832031,
-0.5687753558158875,
0.048157211393117905,
1.0381133556365967,
0.550507128238678,
-0.08601188659667969,
0.1647554337978363,
0.2533278465270996,
0.49554958939552307,
-0.6486810445785522,
0.446449875831604,
-0.4751717448234558,
-0.39754992723464966,
-0.33223405480384827,
-0.08614613115787506,
-0.5713813304901123,
-0.48315075039863586,
0.13466444611549377,
-0.5943418145179749,
0.07591830939054489,
0.05520721897482872,
0.8948999643325806,
0.2642635703086853,
-0.32073530554771423,
-0.6528343558311462,
-0.640720784664154,
0.7927164435386658,
-0.48680877685546875,
0.4501860737800598,
0.44398409128189087,
0.12822875380516052,
-0.286348819732666,
-0.5491440296173096,
-0.5269215106964111,
-0.09934823215007782,
-0.12539920210838318,
-0.22716277837753296,
-0.4952501654624939,
-0.14189578592777252,
-0.0448598638176918,
0.6054435968399048,
-0.46095240116119385,
-0.1345808207988739,
-0.15199866890907288,
-0.5118058919906616,
0.5630323886871338,
-0.0024132428225129843,
0.3807809054851532,
0.0660194680094719,
0.2723199725151062,
-0.5002899765968323,
-0.5610991716384888,
0.030542101711034775,
0.542997419834137,
0.2808360159397125,
-0.09639772772789001,
0.6090387105941772,
-0.018425296992063522,
0.7440878748893738,
-0.2058441936969757,
0.13521885871887207,
0.535440981388092,
-0.1692311018705368,
-0.14823393523693085,
-0.08004196733236313,
0.7876467704772949,
0.04205795004963875,
0.41181594133377075,
-0.09745296090841293,
-0.39872080087661743,
0.38061535358428955,
0.11845367401838303,
-0.7920065522193909,
-0.822963535785675,
0.09697709232568741,
-0.7681630253791809,
-0.47242116928100586,
0.12934863567352295,
-0.7203822731971741,
-0.5079987049102783,
-0.052703674882650375,
0.5193596482276917,
-0.314424604177475,
-0.4649691879749298,
0.2959771752357483,
0.12007264792919159,
-0.11935388296842575,
0.45776334404945374,
-0.638674795627594,
0.45755094289779663,
0.3715786337852478,
0.9955213665962219,
0.02703363262116909,
-0.2743922472000122,
-0.6261860728263855,
-0.19452537596225739,
-0.44176697731018066,
0.895529568195343,
-0.32023119926452637,
-0.2464156150817871,
-0.09432973712682724,
0.12339933216571808,
-0.20106233656406403,
-0.5667796730995178,
0.5835279822349548,
-0.30223211646080017,
0.2127019613981247,
0.030975384637713432,
-0.5649005174636841,
-0.1370822936296463,
-0.1292036920785904,
-0.9153249859809875,
0.8075538277626038,
-0.09750223159790039,
-0.7056254148483276,
0.12272440642118454,
-0.6292099356651306,
-0.2883976697921753,
0.04026824235916138,
0.2443583458662033,
-0.6429752111434937,
0.31135299801826477,
0.2645011246204376,
0.15292587876319885,
-0.11378389596939087,
-0.04299597814679146,
-0.33562055230140686,
-0.44288262724876404,
0.30358538031578064,
-0.4721854329109192,
0.7283402681350708,
0.32728564739227295,
-0.0513191781938076,
0.14887303113937378,
-0.818385899066925,
0.12850375473499298,
0.04899086803197861,
-0.5646931529045105,
-0.23204950988292694,
0.039406634867191315,
0.6359336972236633,
-0.06133924052119255,
0.30666813254356384,
-0.564446747303009,
0.04491443186998367,
-0.6323135495185852,
0.30341967940330505,
0.34477072954177856,
-0.20036372542381287,
0.7508672475814819,
-0.25301966071128845,
0.22487643361091614,
-0.07069488614797592,
0.01894441246986389,
-0.20583917200565338,
-0.8881264925003052,
-0.6053212881088257,
-0.3741231858730316,
0.7080048322677612,
0.5882765650749207,
-0.7147078514099121,
0.46480825543403625,
-0.046713583171367645,
-0.5980713367462158,
-0.4622829854488373,
0.15958701074123383,
0.4427071511745453,
0.24008437991142273,
0.29998093843460083,
-0.5883336663246155,
-0.494608998298645,
-0.5840961337089539,
-0.3375612497329712,
-0.7669473886489868,
-0.3308095633983612,
0.11302519589662552,
0.5216422080993652,
-0.10464177280664444,
0.8651242852210999,
-0.4339067339897156,
-0.28915053606033325,
-0.15369434654712677,
0.39160946011543274,
0.17683763802051544,
0.5449678897857666,
0.4987846314907074,
-0.6852408051490784,
-0.6097360849380493,
-0.14263394474983215,
-0.5364354252815247,
-0.2835124731063843,
0.2547888159751892,
-0.000646039959974587,
0.4982951581478119,
0.1381465643644333,
-0.39481550455093384,
0.5361652970314026,
0.625557005405426,
-0.46485891938209534,
0.420071542263031,
-0.4347081482410431,
0.14091338217258453,
-1.0158169269561768,
0.4249572157859802,
0.38512516021728516,
-0.3069818913936615,
-0.6749889254570007,
0.06819996237754822,
0.483726441860199,
0.014455456286668777,
-0.22936785221099854,
0.6499476432800293,
-0.4610380232334137,
-0.18788479268550873,
-0.519498884677887,
-0.23349528014659882,
-0.07538663595914841,
0.13498477637767792,
0.30678293108940125,
0.7551847696304321,
0.5649206042289734,
-0.5869946479797363,
0.26739221811294556,
0.3060470521450043,
-0.6201915144920349,
0.08093991875648499,
-0.5458348989486694,
0.11876338720321655,
0.0721723735332489,
0.37849190831184387,
-0.9506429433822632,
-0.5105865001678467,
0.6541708111763,
-0.6322027444839478,
0.15029507875442505,
-0.11964194476604462,
-0.6519648432731628,
-0.13927453756332397,
-0.14750346541404724,
0.36924487352371216,
0.4652080237865448,
-0.5440472364425659,
0.907306432723999,
0.7602198719978333,
0.0022055332083255053,
-0.31775686144828796,
-0.6337720155715942,
0.2539178729057312,
-0.018813014030456543,
-0.38561058044433594,
0.48656272888183594,
-0.15755726397037506,
-0.295553594827652,
-0.029744679108262062,
0.017865335568785667,
-0.3216513395309448,
-0.04397033900022507,
0.2542918622493744,
0.19806085526943207,
-0.22815176844596863,
0.018948735669255257,
-0.30440834164619446,
-0.22420634329319,
-0.18508121371269226,
-0.2777782380580902,
0.29667454957962036,
-0.3695194721221924,
0.13131676614284515,
-0.7889490127563477,
0.06484011560678482,
0.5858182311058044,
-0.40926676988601685,
0.6823866963386536,
0.44771841168403625,
-0.6657465100288391,
0.019499322399497032,
-0.34470903873443604,
0.04097731411457062,
-0.40237459540367126,
0.10093998163938522,
-0.429533451795578,
-0.526006281375885,
0.47719475626945496,
0.3662775456905365,
-0.11270860582590103,
0.34465837478637695,
0.4068692624568939,
-0.09283895790576935,
1.0632109642028809,
1.0233322381973267,
-0.41749030351638794,
0.7170173525810242,
0.1772659868001938,
-0.01638840138912201,
-0.5012460350990295,
0.043622635304927826,
-0.7742184996604919,
0.1147555485367775,
-0.5578970313072205,
-0.4530477225780487,
0.15408830344676971,
-0.10022670030593872,
0.07581871002912521,
0.4109587073326111,
-0.39894402027130127,
0.5697540640830994,
0.4666256308555603,
0.2337740808725357,
0.3499159514904022,
0.1975623518228531,
0.190586656332016,
0.14770784974098206,
-0.5773168802261353,
-0.7441443800926208,
1.2003130912780762,
0.8621490001678467,
0.7496458292007446,
-0.014280715025961399,
0.59962397813797,
0.12487831711769104,
0.40055519342422485,
-0.9099136590957642,
0.38416895270347595,
-0.41606199741363525,
-0.2569093406200409,
-0.136368066072464,
-0.6405235528945923,
-0.7562440037727356,
-0.026011519134044647,
-0.25685518980026245,
-0.7136145830154419,
0.3779045641422272,
0.4350755512714386,
-0.3913743197917938,
0.13804461061954498,
-0.8207079172134399,
0.8651120066642761,
0.09581748396158218,
-0.18546162545681,
-0.17346282303333282,
-0.5013826489448547,
0.04273427277803421,
-0.05983498692512512,
0.056838493794202805,
0.07694076746702194,
-0.03374044597148895,
0.7531213760375977,
-0.13813278079032898,
0.6777538657188416,
-0.24452650547027588,
-0.464408814907074,
0.3913547992706299,
0.0917593315243721,
0.5636351108551025,
-0.1585277020931244,
-0.18628735840320587,
0.32439666986465454,
0.10639981925487518,
-0.2739085853099823,
-0.41054707765579224,
0.6263846755027771,
-0.6423860192298889,
0.0864376574754715,
-0.6307653784751892,
-0.6255080103874207,
0.03041965886950493,
0.15884704887866974,
0.0409211628139019,
0.5878562927246094,
-0.19793586432933807,
0.1638619601726532,
0.7628211975097656,
-0.3114768862724304,
0.33327576518058777,
0.44236981868743896,
-0.3382500410079956,
-0.4053080677986145,
1.0263476371765137,
0.013697170652449131,
-0.11960561573505402,
0.3472725749015808,
0.045168254524469376,
-0.44053182005882263,
-0.6436498761177063,
-0.7298516035079956,
0.26695090532302856,
-0.7564821243286133,
-0.08218805491924286,
-0.7027271389961243,
0.004725682083517313,
-0.4525909721851349,
0.21722564101219177,
-0.40957334637641907,
-0.44576311111450195,
-0.40318185091018677,
0.3618212640285492,
0.2018602043390274,
0.8202820420265198,
0.10654297471046448,
0.42132651805877686,
-0.7434995770454407,
0.2955174148082733,
-0.157514289021492,
0.5863506197929382,
-0.2678816318511963,
-0.4720737338066101,
-0.4470137059688568,
-0.19181294739246368,
0.08367184549570084,
-0.9296490550041199,
0.5864618420600891,
0.24582818150520325,
0.3402639627456665,
-0.07947753369808197,
-0.20412221550941467,
0.21399173140525818,
-0.346579372882843,
0.2854604423046112,
-0.13625910878181458,
-1.061383843421936,
0.30303624272346497,
-0.30226626992225647,
0.447365403175354,
0.4583025872707367,
0.17548732459545135,
-0.2414454072713852,
-0.3839189410209656,
-0.2631300091743469,
-0.51152104139328,
0.732535719871521,
0.4518023729324341,
-0.09681474417448044,
0.30515098571777344,
0.3025898039340973,
-0.32290521264076233,
0.024614408612251282,
-0.6968168020248413,
-0.04996906965970993,
-0.19457192718982697,
-0.8347827792167664,
-0.16286642849445343,
-0.3277779221534729,
0.21721568703651428,
-0.16542543470859528,
0.9390949606895447,
-0.3132185637950897,
0.23176860809326172,
0.014052538201212883,
-0.45688602328300476,
-0.3230903744697571,
-0.1993425190448761,
0.12489743530750275,
0.36290472745895386,
-0.45697468519210815,
-0.004923299886286259,
-0.11675997078418732,
-0.8417888283729553,
0.05015333741903305,
0.2909017503261566,
-0.1031259074807167,
0.15005257725715637,
0.15911643207073212,
0.486660897731781,
0.1703447550535202,
-0.46932920813560486,
0.38397496938705444,
-0.5295889377593994,
0.05978519842028618,
-0.06515663117170334,
-0.10304802656173706,
-0.2163856029510498,
0.24102883040905,
0.36703458428382874,
0.16514569520950317,
0.19306045770645142,
-0.4416138827800751,
0.2864779829978943,
0.26614585518836975,
-0.026537906378507614,
-0.14065977931022644,
0.4441705644130707,
0.14309552311897278,
-0.2920122742652893,
0.5429257154464722,
-0.0718960165977478,
-0.4578513503074646,
0.49294379353523254,
0.586714506149292,
0.7871301770210266,
-0.4670616686344147,
0.2865462601184845,
0.5615262985229492,
0.34712108969688416,
-0.5189000964164734,
0.2058311253786087,
-0.07575120776891708,
-0.8417736887931824,
-0.1621151864528656,
-1.0249533653259277,
-0.6561939716339111,
-0.007204814814031124,
-0.4146236181259155,
0.38360387086868286,
-0.2617247998714447,
-0.05678270757198334,
0.015508006326854229,
0.20652277767658234,
-0.1943870484828949,
0.42719197273254395,
0.293448269367218,
1.0563268661499023,
-0.9605981111526489,
1.230413794517517,
0.7552441358566284,
-0.298380583524704,
-0.6900843381881714,
0.40018510818481445,
0.07498905807733536,
-0.19954049587249756,
0.27058911323547363,
0.3119705021381378,
-0.32436177134513855,
0.1814601719379425,
-0.3252476751804352,
-0.9358829259872437,
0.6871282458305359,
0.299300879240036,
-0.428215891122818,
-0.20006804168224335,
0.05737202987074852,
0.6593998670578003,
-0.44339483976364136,
0.3557766079902649,
0.5671733617782593,
0.29235130548477173,
-0.04778553545475006,
-1.227237343788147,
-0.10909140855073929,
-0.5900331139564514,
0.028639646247029305,
0.08744806796312332,
-0.056612756103277206,
0.7493522763252258,
0.09531684964895248,
-0.40471258759498596,
0.690841019153595,
0.7222127318382263,
0.08046761155128479,
0.2785719633102417,
0.5214089751243591,
0.27040478587150574,
0.728009819984436,
-0.0013383254408836365,
0.9733638763427734,
-0.5165181159973145,
0.2050826996564865,
0.8792060613632202,
-0.0857333391904831,
1.1569446325302124,
0.2127263844013214,
0.009996880777180195,
0.49372243881225586,
0.4506371319293976,
-0.01729166880249977,
0.3866528272628784,
0.02118808589875698,
-0.3823153078556061,
-0.14735834300518036,
0.1120818555355072,
-0.13447605073451996,
0.532101035118103,
0.44069117307662964,
-0.6186996102333069,
-0.1436017006635666,
0.0011828109854832292,
-0.12334192544221878,
0.19871196150779724,
-0.36525842547416687,
0.5448163747787476,
0.025298619642853737,
-0.37051481008529663,
0.5156583189964294,
0.39932045340538025,
0.8188745975494385,
-0.47431275248527527,
0.07346693426370621,
0.03825977444648743,
0.5703719854354858,
-0.20457516610622406,
-0.6616024971008301,
0.43817487359046936,
0.264882892370224,
-0.21825142204761505,
-0.28882014751434326,
1.0828500986099243,
-0.5661073327064514,
-0.6582431793212891,
0.19771993160247803,
0.3565237820148468,
0.40154334902763367,
-0.3150384724140167,
-0.5393974781036377,
0.3763265609741211,
-0.25222015380859375,
-0.16530175507068634,
0.3147900402545929,
0.12489467859268188,
-0.07194602489471436,
0.48097243905067444,
0.5521953105926514,
0.1318994164466858,
-0.1471899300813675,
-0.11240238696336746,
0.6823205351829529,
-0.310983270406723,
-0.4911882281303406,
-0.544123649597168,
0.21075326204299927,
0.05006670951843262,
-0.26472604274749756,
0.8763346672058105,
0.5530815720558167,
0.7411220669746399,
-0.09462597221136093,
0.5650904774665833,
-0.0024931381922215223,
0.47484686970710754,
-0.4324747920036316,
1.2466214895248413,
-0.3981972634792328,
-0.033760566264390945,
-0.5431981086730957,
-0.9274412393569946,
-0.8379621505737305,
0.9370706677436829,
-0.3654736578464508,
-0.2295854389667511,
0.5453713536262512,
1.0130400657653809,
-0.07633259892463684,
-0.00190056674182415,
0.01546833198517561,
0.16853630542755127,
0.28605857491493225,
0.5793101191520691,
0.5649952292442322,
-0.7089805603027344,
0.5919479727745056,
-0.24899744987487793,
-0.487115740776062,
-0.18671272695064545,
-0.9273964166641235,
-0.6261746287345886,
-0.7121589779853821,
-0.5159463882446289,
-0.5656829476356506,
0.2391662746667862,
0.8364430665969849,
0.5794249773025513,
-0.9964914917945862,
-0.4158466160297394,
-0.20632168650627136,
-0.031360771507024765,
-0.02079479955136776,
-0.13548484444618225,
0.29732540249824524,
-0.20477280020713806,
-0.9535375237464905,
0.5852893590927124,
0.14216922223567963,
0.0832243412733078,
-0.062334153801202774,
-0.10964171588420868,
-0.1207711324095726,
0.11753107607364655,
0.3354664444923401,
0.5101354718208313,
-0.20719967782497406,
0.0661521703004837,
-0.190713569521904,
-0.16538584232330322,
0.12904776632785797,
0.6093373894691467,
-0.8557088375091553,
0.40266409516334534,
0.7167708277702332,
0.49308714270591736,
0.20758432149887085,
-0.07241009175777435,
0.796278715133667,
-0.3089037835597992,
0.10331865400075912,
0.07603707909584045,
0.4393184781074524,
0.6254481673240662,
-0.23281189799308777,
0.36617761850357056,
0.20764677226543427,
-0.5901930928230286,
-1.0993767976760864,
0.060027189552783966,
-0.43564027547836304,
-0.010980483144521713,
1.018871545791626,
-0.3825104832649231,
-0.5985748767852783,
-0.13988639414310455,
-0.24661874771118164,
0.4179675877094269,
-0.2770969569683075,
0.8513452410697937,
0.7393747568130493,
0.19673596322536469,
-0.11364453285932541,
-0.2477230280637741,
0.6858373284339905,
0.4830271303653717,
-0.7548428773880005,
0.20737546682357788,
0.7428484559059143,
0.3521077334880829,
0.24186982214450836,
0.7456619143486023,
-0.3182414770126343,
0.4001508355140686,
0.09209256619215012,
0.08672025799751282,
0.043963730335235596,
-0.9322628974914551,
-0.8551887273788452,
0.1389807164669037,
0.19285309314727783,
-0.0630643218755722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18708v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18708v1
|
Iconic Gesture Semantics
| 2024-04-29T13:58:03 | 2024-04-29T13:58:03 |
Andy Lücking, Alexander Henlein, Alexander Mehler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The "meaning" of an iconic gesture is conditioned on its informational
evaluation. Only informational evaluation lifts a gesture to a quasi-linguistic
level that can interact with verbal content. Interaction is either vacuous or
regimented by usual lexicon-driven inferences. Informational evaluation is
spelled out as extended exemplification (extemplification) in terms of
perceptual classification of a gesture's visual iconic model. The iconic model
is derived from Frege/Montague-like truth-functional evaluation of a gesture's
form within spatially extended domains. We further argue that the perceptual
classification of instances of visual communication requires a notion of
meaning different from Frege/Montague frameworks. Therefore, a heuristic for
gesture interpretation is provided that can guide the working semanticist. In
sum, an iconic gesture semantics is introduced which covers the full range from
kinematic gesture representations over model-theoretic evaluation to
inferential interpretation in dynamic semantic frameworks.
|
[
-0.16629017889499664,
-0.6433121562004089,
0.39131641387939453,
-0.1089617908000946,
-0.3529772162437439,
-0.12415603548288345,
0.052992019802331924,
-0.8794645071029663,
0.44220441579818726,
0.1568193882703781,
-0.45747849345207214,
-0.4025413691997528,
-0.9965145587921143,
-0.33716893196105957,
-0.6215033531188965,
0.8403649926185608,
-0.2674333453178406,
-0.18654996156692505,
0.13892138004302979,
-0.4828566014766693,
-0.22934077680110931,
-0.36003339290618896,
-0.29739367961883545,
-0.22202885150909424,
0.37986913323402405,
0.3837563991546631,
1.2215505838394165,
0.525884747505188,
0.5714440941810608,
0.2893446087837219,
-0.12130841612815857,
-0.3894549608230591,
-0.49804824590682983,
-0.1147468313574791,
-0.37972357869148254,
-0.4359830617904663,
-0.19051122665405273,
0.30015289783477783,
0.6590033173561096,
1.173357367515564,
0.11003758013248444,
0.185153990983963,
-0.042885009199380875,
0.49855056405067444,
-0.5709598064422607,
0.5310965180397034,
-0.2571428716182709,
0.0768512561917305,
-0.118716299533844,
-0.2114245444536209,
-0.06966746598482132,
-0.5016449093818665,
0.42915698885917664,
-0.5273475050926208,
-0.272887259721756,
-0.15531964600086212,
1.0999025106430054,
-0.14518536627292633,
-0.32689741253852844,
-0.26309919357299805,
-0.6027725338935852,
0.46438485383987427,
-0.30467262864112854,
0.5528586506843567,
-0.018549690023064613,
0.638813316822052,
-0.06767342239618301,
-0.7479690909385681,
-0.820131778717041,
-0.4969228208065033,
0.13185809552669525,
0.07521293312311172,
-0.33813905715942383,
0.21460945904254913,
0.5293525457382202,
0.2478296011686325,
-0.16149498522281647,
0.039799440652132034,
-0.21803438663482666,
0.17198750376701355,
0.4025186598300934,
-0.006307198666036129,
0.4117949903011322,
-0.3010736405849457,
-0.8158756494522095,
-0.001288801897317171,
-0.6368367671966553,
0.2845953404903412,
0.26135361194610596,
0.04141705110669136,
-0.29706689715385437,
0.490681916475296,
-0.20676283538341522,
0.6164488792419434,
-0.006146442145109177,
0.16944971680641174,
0.3771020174026489,
-0.2500789761543274,
-0.3754686415195465,
-0.10719624906778336,
0.5541026592254639,
0.44249430298805237,
0.41050323843955994,
-0.2949678599834442,
0.19725406169891357,
0.047057680785655975,
-0.007585958112031221,
-0.4402278959751129,
-0.170020192861557,
-0.011384427547454834,
-0.56480872631073,
-0.31066128611564636,
0.49330705404281616,
-0.32781049609184265,
-0.3562464416027069,
-0.28788071870803833,
0.49623173475265503,
-0.5683786273002625,
-0.47229185700416565,
0.21144570410251617,
-0.5579122304916382,
0.4273771643638611,
0.5473082661628723,
-0.8733209371566772,
-0.018765445798635483,
0.7585058808326721,
0.3809475600719452,
-0.03272105008363724,
-0.4401455223560333,
-0.020637579262256622,
0.5432680249214172,
-0.397746741771698,
0.7493715882301331,
-0.9300498962402344,
-0.29602953791618347,
-0.06873984634876251,
-0.006777757313102484,
-0.21212303638458252,
-0.4203372895717621,
0.6930822730064392,
-0.422293096780777,
-0.009054969996213913,
-0.21071754395961761,
-0.6202313899993896,
-0.6608856916427612,
-0.16121986508369446,
-0.5937702655792236,
0.6270026564598083,
0.1666487604379654,
-0.3942885100841522,
1.1674120426177979,
-0.7872520089149475,
-0.3274136483669281,
0.47234129905700684,
-0.47359079122543335,
0.18352384865283966,
0.3795216679573059,
-0.4062277674674988,
0.5474820733070374,
-0.05324201285839081,
-0.0072487094439566135,
-0.35935908555984497,
-0.09394074976444244,
0.40984225273132324,
-0.21369224786758423,
0.4706924855709076,
0.19599205255508423,
-0.5568935871124268,
0.23036439716815948,
-0.5521886348724365,
0.10171768069267273,
-0.11361502856016159,
-0.21507404744625092,
-0.4955092966556549,
-0.05062684416770935,
-0.09704773128032684,
0.1185716763138771,
0.20029160380363464,
-0.41658255457878113,
0.19461965560913086,
-0.283884197473526,
0.2670963704586029,
0.6111758947372437,
-0.06125791743397713,
0.5887484550476074,
-0.05754166468977928,
0.34490326046943665,
-0.21827062964439392,
0.395479291677475,
-0.06725968420505524,
-0.48400741815567017,
-0.4328523278236389,
-0.48031333088874817,
0.004738764371722937,
0.29588302969932556,
-0.5722717642784119,
0.4005884528160095,
-0.702146053314209,
-0.3144936263561249,
0.017411302775144577,
-0.1192263811826706,
0.396199494600296,
0.16055525839328766,
-0.24527285993099213,
-0.35944148898124695,
-0.14772556722164154,
-0.9746450185775757,
-0.4000435769557953,
-0.49129727482795715,
0.21710661053657532,
0.07198990136384964,
0.4099788963794708,
0.2956966459751129,
0.5412900447845459,
-0.0990913063287735,
-0.24991127848625183,
-0.14042681455612183,
0.5233219861984253,
0.32117801904678345,
0.23397231101989746,
0.6984280347824097,
-1.1706126928329468,
-0.05903379246592522,
0.08990368992090225,
-0.8418708443641663,
0.1449175626039505,
-0.22578734159469604,
-0.3257726728916168,
-0.04281869903206825,
0.6185818314552307,
-0.5550262331962585,
0.6260262727737427,
0.258776992559433,
-0.6185068488121033,
0.29371747374534607,
0.1683937907218933,
0.5968977808952332,
-0.48005086183547974,
-0.04693417251110077,
-0.4193585515022278,
-0.03467592969536781,
-0.5911585092544556,
0.49198758602142334,
-0.053302567452192307,
0.09104657918214798,
-0.46602797508239746,
0.6421908140182495,
-0.5616670250892639,
-0.1639166623353958,
-0.1234755590558052,
0.24548040330410004,
-0.18470190465450287,
0.19270916283130646,
0.4452235996723175,
-0.02787177823483944,
0.5774486660957336,
-0.5082718729972839,
0.291670560836792,
0.07168722152709961,
-0.6807202696800232,
0.9937260150909424,
-0.2118396908044815,
-0.3740481436252594,
-0.0968269407749176,
-0.20377686619758606,
-1.4707566499710083,
-0.3317408263683319,
0.27951404452323914,
-0.673474133014679,
0.4093022048473358,
0.052164226770401,
-0.4246801435947418,
-0.40441572666168213,
-0.2848849296569824,
0.4246092140674591,
0.23328986763954163,
-0.7536815404891968,
0.7249882221221924,
0.3027662932872772,
0.05354844778776169,
-0.5279172658920288,
-0.5528424382209778,
0.30478042364120483,
-0.2967296540737152,
-0.7902508974075317,
0.0077954684384167194,
0.28613755106925964,
-0.2503127455711365,
-0.04579301178455353,
-0.058349985629320145,
0.0387299582362175,
0.0382126085460186,
0.5108324289321899,
0.18664708733558655,
0.04784958437085152,
0.11099060624837875,
0.10245980322360992,
-0.14732062816619873,
-0.09694170206785202,
-0.0013276144163683057,
0.1313079446554184,
-0.1569163054227829,
-0.6633833646774292,
-0.6237948536872864,
0.47425737977027893,
0.8855303525924683,
0.2509681284427643,
0.3968386650085449,
0.2060624063014984,
-0.4413195848464966,
0.4751398265361786,
-0.2997514009475708,
-0.18454080820083618,
-0.3506162762641907,
0.40879175066947937,
-0.7957748770713806,
-0.5000990629196167,
0.40657588839530945,
-0.18562129139900208,
0.1399424821138382,
0.2761862576007843,
0.2445484697818756,
-0.165120929479599,
0.7854360342025757,
0.5453616380691528,
0.3702673017978668,
0.7128834128379822,
-0.2842966318130493,
0.2725144922733307,
-0.616709291934967,
-0.3533485233783722,
-0.3230285048484802,
-0.573922336101532,
-0.1708597093820572,
-0.31151270866394043,
0.35100024938583374,
0.44023552536964417,
-0.17672576010227203,
0.521399736404419,
-0.14980700612068176,
0.17328782379627228,
0.35860374569892883,
-0.06871257722377777,
0.38889074325561523,
0.07114873826503754,
-0.1605326384305954,
-0.09288852661848068,
-0.5409371852874756,
-0.7786229848861694,
0.5077760815620422,
0.4137239158153534,
0.8477985858917236,
0.5764023065567017,
0.3765851557254791,
0.18005050718784332,
0.38760489225387573,
-1.010999083518982,
0.7662832140922546,
0.04982687532901764,
-0.4382696747779846,
-0.14912064373493195,
0.032656364142894745,
-0.9390003085136414,
0.1271795779466629,
-0.4676849842071533,
-1.2135593891143799,
0.44511160254478455,
0.1538236141204834,
-0.17205284535884857,
0.17263080179691315,
-0.7527603507041931,
0.9713084101676941,
-0.13953393697738647,
-0.2051461935043335,
-0.4111173450946808,
-0.6234825849533081,
0.3522214889526367,
0.18668913841247559,
0.20857399702072144,
-0.22239702939987183,
-0.1857459396123886,
0.7130740284919739,
-0.38031256198883057,
0.9916468858718872,
-0.3430928587913513,
0.09289055317640305,
0.2858252227306366,
0.5104894042015076,
0.3476850092411041,
-0.5640220642089844,
0.09595497697591782,
0.5138954520225525,
0.20489215850830078,
-0.2654856741428375,
-1.0684891939163208,
0.35216814279556274,
-0.33507686853408813,
-0.4181591868400574,
-0.15032663941383362,
-0.36138325929641724,
-0.15948399901390076,
-0.030574489384889603,
0.367195188999176,
0.5550349950790405,
-0.37812986969947815,
0.012308593839406967,
0.2008485496044159,
0.13163623213768005,
0.1997646540403366,
0.5437517762184143,
-0.231290802359581,
0.1847255527973175,
0.5519676804542542,
0.1245134025812149,
0.5919857025146484,
0.6903741955757141,
0.1979411542415619,
-0.4566017985343933,
-0.5801270008087158,
-0.46526771783828735,
0.005981392692774534,
-1.063072681427002,
0.2844572961330414,
-0.4183834493160248,
0.31874412298202515,
-0.08186309784650803,
-0.4763496220111847,
0.04684574529528618,
-0.9303412437438965,
0.15340816974639893,
-0.5525292754173279,
0.33621829748153687,
0.5227652788162231,
-0.3669610321521759,
0.3524817228317261,
-0.6055383086204529,
0.3538404703140259,
0.03589992597699165,
0.17717081308364868,
-0.03904685378074646,
-0.527279794216156,
0.16423316299915314,
-0.17813746631145477,
0.07608292251825333,
-0.9092183113098145,
-0.2538411021232605,
0.32781004905700684,
1.083135724067688,
1.0310828685760498,
-0.22993521392345428,
0.5432698130607605,
-0.1573556512594223,
0.8670040965080261,
0.7038532495498657,
-0.8443067669868469,
0.3888460099697113,
-0.4024617373943329,
0.19209995865821838,
0.31062984466552734,
0.44281476736068726,
-0.6460980772972107,
-0.43799540400505066,
-0.8749698996543884,
-0.9938968420028687,
0.2806337773799896,
-0.034390635788440704,
0.3960159420967102,
-0.39219269156455994,
0.4240903854370117,
0.3424893319606781,
0.26046866178512573,
-0.4715786278247833,
-0.09582799673080444,
-0.05849010869860649,
-0.18327516317367554,
0.2645470201969147,
-0.265928715467453,
-0.3398817479610443,
-0.3125855624675751,
0.35256513953208923,
-0.09950608760118484,
0.5408241152763367,
-0.2430139034986496,
-0.2564663589000702,
0.034185584634542465,
0.1518060564994812,
0.37683990597724915,
0.6710675954818726,
0.09076714515686035,
0.31188687682151794,
-0.09523333609104156,
-0.3709213137626648,
-0.0688629299402237,
-0.17022787034511566,
0.07343103736639023,
-0.06458566337823868,
0.5433149933815002,
0.8047284483909607,
0.6041943430900574,
-0.590620219707489,
0.8759563565254211,
0.2314111739397049,
0.11122189462184906,
-0.25628861784935,
0.055675096809864044,
-0.18443432450294495,
0.30291029810905457,
0.4864358901977539,
0.18804533779621124,
0.4153161942958832,
-0.87956702709198,
0.30696821212768555,
0.684013843536377,
-0.6269283890724182,
-0.3700055181980133,
0.6102948784828186,
-0.004686068743467331,
0.33241018652915955,
0.15888266265392303,
0.0027497587725520134,
-0.3808482885360718,
0.5357053279876709,
0.060593921691179276,
0.9511911273002625,
-0.13481676578521729,
0.28053826093673706,
0.29784584045410156,
0.13077415525913239,
0.19390684366226196,
0.5181783437728882,
-0.4632596969604492,
-0.8056893944740295,
-0.08249527215957642,
-0.4032033383846283,
-0.3412693738937378,
-0.44825688004493713,
-0.8064610362052917,
0.36133891344070435,
-0.3174627721309662,
-0.06359831243753433,
0.4846436679363251,
-0.8180510401725769,
-0.5545435547828674,
0.3380323350429535,
0.26047882437705994,
0.9960591197013855,
-0.844929575920105,
0.43184372782707214,
0.8364995718002319,
-0.41804084181785583,
-0.8334389925003052,
-0.17862394452095032,
0.10986755788326263,
-1.1648930311203003,
1.260875940322876,
-0.011807303875684738,
-0.5265902280807495,
-0.2420049011707306,
-0.5317196846008301,
-0.9139307141304016,
0.6659058332443237,
0.4859101474285126,
-0.10481205582618713,
-0.02578887715935707,
-0.0439741425216198,
0.4094909727573395,
-0.4469006657600403,
0.46704912185668945,
0.463619589805603,
0.5519495606422424,
0.7422923445701599,
-1.1416081190109253,
0.20620709657669067,
-0.1746593862771988,
0.12502442300319672,
0.26255929470062256,
-0.3006739020347595,
0.3445890545845032,
-0.5896844863891602,
-0.5749897360801697,
0.3696471154689789,
0.8024665117263794,
-0.32832086086273193,
-0.12182269990444183,
0.41226547956466675,
0.34560489654541016,
0.6655287146568298,
-0.36927592754364014,
1.228281021118164,
-0.25638139247894287,
0.08865512907505035,
0.8454010486602783,
0.07349532097578049,
0.9281876087188721,
0.44963568449020386,
-0.02157001756131649,
0.587620735168457,
0.46291327476501465,
0.3380289673805237,
0.48578914999961853,
0.08366160094738007,
-0.415091335773468,
-0.10944852977991104,
-0.08439674228429794,
-0.07842308282852173,
0.9340377449989319,
0.6922748684883118,
-0.762952983379364,
-0.6388283967971802,
0.3335849344730377,
0.054435327649116516,
0.07850641012191772,
-0.5256415009498596,
0.5977294445037842,
-0.057861726731061935,
-0.4871721565723419,
0.612387478351593,
-0.3261689841747284,
0.2217807024717331,
-0.6297429800033569,
-0.18953263759613037,
0.4703664183616638,
0.019775686785578728,
-0.41741514205932617,
-1.2236812114715576,
0.3412320911884308,
-0.5329633355140686,
0.025023171678185463,
-0.10617631673812866,
0.6101979613304138,
-0.09350013732910156,
-0.06527725607156754,
0.3899386525154114,
0.3110804855823517,
0.7685956954956055,
0.04349852353334427,
-0.6606025695800781,
0.08928736299276352,
-0.321707159280777,
-0.2172963172197342,
-0.10170920938253403,
0.3207576870918274,
-0.5052826404571533,
0.46405595541000366,
0.17800061404705048,
-0.09868355840444565,
0.2496749758720398,
0.20585580170154572,
0.4849487543106079,
-0.7036464214324951,
-0.5196505784988403,
-0.5797458291053772,
0.3915503919124603,
-0.08793020248413086,
-0.1688537895679474,
0.5276416540145874,
0.2742341458797455,
0.6584429740905762,
-0.1034046858549118,
0.8601810932159424,
-0.331978976726532,
0.3363574147224426,
-0.604499340057373,
0.4057016670703888,
-0.273594468832016,
-0.25143787264823914,
-0.6630565524101257,
-0.7847407460212708,
-0.2557646632194519,
0.9271128177642822,
-0.7191545367240906,
0.2870292663574219,
0.6041030287742615,
0.3209817409515381,
-0.008356805890798569,
0.44251227378845215,
0.7941397428512573,
0.2724880576133728,
-0.002184756565839052,
0.620843231678009,
1.0256915092468262,
-0.15504182875156403,
0.12785665690898895,
0.19211705029010773,
-0.9632281064987183,
-0.2299736738204956,
-1.127624750137329,
-0.5150762796401978,
-0.9072366952896118,
-0.6478257775306702,
-0.22077511250972748,
-0.040815502405166626,
0.8567382097244263,
0.757485032081604,
-0.47191348671913147,
-0.12571729719638824,
0.15266934037208557,
-0.00446759257465601,
-0.6156911253929138,
-0.28218480944633484,
0.41214171051979065,
0.14078663289546967,
-0.9132182598114014,
0.11020365357398987,
0.6332318186759949,
0.1730170100927353,
0.024824485182762146,
0.2721517086029053,
0.06261714547872543,
-0.05153913050889969,
0.9115051031112671,
0.6341201066970825,
-0.615580677986145,
-0.9287720322608948,
-0.4329332113265991,
0.09875477105379105,
0.07426198571920395,
0.641452431678772,
-0.5685591697692871,
0.5656835436820984,
0.5079594254493713,
-0.03669562563300133,
0.2627527713775635,
-0.0015239766798913479,
0.4355587363243103,
-0.24781490862369537,
0.20561252534389496,
-0.0009110646205954254,
0.4967450201511383,
0.17755624651908875,
-0.3128698170185089,
0.3703594207763672,
0.4293328523635864,
0.15343141555786133,
-0.3514864146709442,
0.8778889179229736,
-1.2676690816879272,
-0.15449726581573486,
1.1943761110305786,
-0.2327539026737213,
-0.3081081509590149,
-0.2862734794616699,
-0.20491382479667664,
-0.10829243063926697,
-0.23488199710845947,
0.45580437779426575,
0.6087551116943359,
-0.6946442723274231,
-0.2473393827676773,
-0.40295371413230896,
0.2845309376716614,
0.10123585164546967,
-0.3757131099700928,
-0.018073249608278275,
0.7174040675163269,
0.26173388957977295,
0.388702392578125,
0.5771620869636536,
-0.5504315495491028,
0.5258946418762207,
-0.0058615016750991344,
0.20056958496570587,
0.018202880397439003,
-0.30496159195899963,
-0.07608022540807724,
0.3844473659992218,
0.27697035670280457,
-0.406131774187088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18971v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18971v1
|
Credible, Unreliable or Leaked?: Evidence Verification for Enhanced Automated Fact-checking
| 2024-04-29T13:47:04 | 2024-04-29T13:47:04 |
Zacharias Chrysidis, Stefanos-Iordanis Papadopoulos, Symeon Papadopoulos, Panagiotis C. Petrantonakis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.IR, cs.SI
|
Automated fact-checking (AFC) is garnering increasing attention by
researchers aiming to help fact-checkers combat the increasing spread of
misinformation online. While many existing AFC methods incorporate external
information from the Web to help examine the veracity of claims, they often
overlook the importance of verifying the source and quality of collected
"evidence". One overlooked challenge involves the reliance on "leaked
evidence", information gathered directly from fact-checking websites and used
to train AFC systems, resulting in an unrealistic setting for early
misinformation detection. Similarly, the inclusion of information from
unreliable sources can undermine the effectiveness of AFC systems. To address
these challenges, we present a comprehensive approach to evidence verification
and filtering. We create the "CREDible, Unreliable or LEaked" (CREDULE)
dataset, which consists of 91,632 articles classified as Credible, Unreliable
and Fact checked (Leaked). Additionally, we introduce the EVidence VERification
Network (EVVER-Net), trained on CREDULE to detect leaked and unreliable
evidence in both short and long texts. EVVER-Net can be used to filter evidence
collected from the Web, thus enhancing the robustness of end-to-end AFC
systems. We experiment with various language models and show that EVVER-Net can
demonstrate impressive performance of up to 91.5% and 94.4% accuracy, while
leveraging domain credibility scores along with short or long texts,
respectively. Finally, we assess the evidence provided by widely-used
fact-checking datasets including LIAR-PLUS, MOCHEG, FACTIFY, NewsCLIPpings+ and
VERITE, some of which exhibit concerning rates of leaked and unreliable
evidence.
|
[
-0.2972204089164734,
-0.8467726707458496,
0.6886153221130371,
-0.05513397231698036,
-0.40843701362609863,
0.2607758641242981,
0.08053003251552582,
-0.8578999042510986,
-0.006594336591660976,
0.46048828959465027,
-0.30809491872787476,
-0.38705724477767944,
-0.9001065492630005,
0.367844820022583,
-0.7447150349617004,
0.8980309367179871,
-0.19906923174858093,
-0.06849212944507599,
-0.12584315240383148,
-0.2437843680381775,
-0.020076550543308258,
-0.294411301612854,
-0.5073645114898682,
-0.6138296127319336,
-0.016800489276647568,
0.4606216549873352,
0.7183054685592651,
0.8934913873672485,
0.4081414043903351,
0.30052968859672546,
0.1656392216682434,
0.6470752954483032,
-0.38025134801864624,
0.09201186150312424,
-0.32308679819107056,
-0.2607938051223755,
-0.414407342672348,
0.2726221978664398,
0.051739707589149475,
0.12554143369197845,
-0.16366013884544373,
0.23366892337799072,
-0.11690160632133484,
0.5069781541824341,
-0.7666441202163696,
0.21702393889427185,
-0.7754896283149719,
-0.1584179699420929,
-0.31765273213386536,
-0.1788419485092163,
-0.45171213150024414,
-0.6672455072402954,
0.09009617567062378,
-0.6703857183456421,
0.3581106960773468,
0.16311247646808624,
1.3469189405441284,
0.3229687511920929,
-0.5549482703208923,
-0.7134529948234558,
-0.705668568611145,
0.3609269857406616,
-0.5194686651229858,
0.48384860157966614,
0.6507416367530823,
0.30732107162475586,
-0.06359589844942093,
-0.9674915075302124,
-0.7486156821250916,
-0.2569130063056946,
-0.255462646484375,
0.16382528841495514,
-0.07249915599822998,
-0.15258494019508362,
0.11613025516271591,
0.36619696021080017,
-0.5810357928276062,
-0.11516810208559036,
0.15193066000938416,
-0.7789818048477173,
0.51484215259552,
-0.29274824261665344,
0.3103981912136078,
0.20479312539100647,
-0.47751834988594055,
-0.358642578125,
-1.0286809206008911,
-0.1579986810684204,
0.514708399772644,
0.050404004752635956,
0.05702279880642891,
0.5440289974212646,
-0.5791372656822205,
0.46108347177505493,
0.3973037302494049,
-0.13220711052417755,
-0.07144090533256531,
-0.5776636600494385,
-0.04714960977435112,
0.2767616808414459,
0.604683518409729,
0.08795369416475296,
-0.2257409691810608,
0.004489396698772907,
-0.35833561420440674,
0.1803911030292511,
0.030866144225001335,
-0.8505528569221497,
-0.4403349459171295,
0.4264650046825409,
-0.35904785990715027,
-0.43163803219795227,
0.4270837604999542,
-0.8479021787643433,
-0.47534874081611633,
-0.1017133891582489,
0.5809196829795837,
-0.36279043555259705,
-0.22129245102405548,
0.11792150884866714,
-0.4080280661582947,
-0.25521427392959595,
0.648952066898346,
-0.2020215094089508,
0.22101156413555145,
0.6617358326911926,
0.6781743168830872,
0.03708498179912567,
-0.09930071234703064,
-0.8146932125091553,
0.02756848931312561,
-0.3424299359321594,
1.4461272954940796,
-0.5013101100921631,
0.49869781732559204,
0.47081613540649414,
0.16551236808300018,
0.38625475764274597,
-0.3887879252433777,
1.327695369720459,
-0.7745288610458374,
0.4127958416938782,
-0.3930617570877075,
-0.8101375102996826,
-0.2284993976354599,
0.4041597545146942,
-0.9914408326148987,
0.922860860824585,
-0.22257724404335022,
-0.751155436038971,
0.7189216017723083,
-0.486894816160202,
-0.5269854068756104,
0.10015565901994705,
-0.0622723363339901,
-0.5167468190193176,
-0.2125898152589798,
0.5454665422439575,
0.11382012069225311,
-0.1991575062274933,
0.13454808294773102,
-0.13938499987125397,
-0.12931473553180695,
0.2571141719818115,
-0.5974122881889343,
0.7039954662322998,
0.1100664958357811,
-0.6181914806365967,
-0.24788063764572144,
-0.8692567348480225,
-0.01743263378739357,
0.11597186326980591,
-0.5160253643989563,
-0.3788074553012848,
0.1151961237192154,
-0.05527661740779877,
-0.012647395953536034,
0.24442872405052185,
-0.8356295228004456,
-0.21810826659202576,
0.0049281069077551365,
0.12652362883090973,
0.49984461069107056,
0.017936570569872856,
0.22636036574840546,
-0.4743839204311371,
0.13782210648059845,
0.18938395380973816,
0.1588779091835022,
-0.3456210196018219,
-0.286314994096756,
-0.705240786075592,
-0.03310452774167061,
0.598054826259613,
0.4805956482887268,
-1.1513131856918335,
0.5733183026313782,
-0.33347687125205994,
-0.4385093152523041,
-0.14646218717098236,
-0.2141011506319046,
0.20336002111434937,
0.5607412457466125,
0.5239483118057251,
-0.17863580584526062,
-0.2803010642528534,
-0.6805485486984253,
-0.5380271673202515,
-0.5688198804855347,
0.0004269334895070642,
0.10474827140569687,
0.44047313928604126,
0.18324775993824005,
0.894548773765564,
-0.16348375380039215,
-0.3360610008239746,
-0.016571786254644394,
0.3525196611881256,
-0.007668908219784498,
0.19725659489631653,
0.3146381080150604,
-0.5991654992103577,
-0.4095539152622223,
-0.079063281416893,
-0.6842273473739624,
-0.2260926067829132,
-0.3999071419239044,
0.17014670372009277,
0.20062407851219177,
0.07343149930238724,
-0.7258917689323425,
0.41970402002334595,
0.6673198938369751,
-0.7079176306724548,
0.7831770181655884,
-0.050835635513067245,
0.6056204438209534,
-0.2692468762397766,
-0.0715319886803627,
-0.10025859624147415,
-0.8745537400245667,
-0.5370483994483948,
0.11406897753477097,
0.288047194480896,
0.35918232798576355,
-0.3401211202144623,
0.2585541903972626,
-0.6303902864456177,
0.20772959291934967,
-0.6078713536262512,
0.3061593770980835,
0.3691980242729187,
-0.06077512726187706,
-0.000021522575480048545,
0.7050495743751526,
0.3619670867919922,
-0.6166701912879944,
0.45918434858322144,
0.34264224767684937,
-0.5722147822380066,
0.5717745423316956,
-0.5948066115379333,
0.17149482667446136,
0.24277326464653015,
0.7554407715797424,
-0.47995656728744507,
-0.49339231848716736,
0.3428976833820343,
-0.36679813265800476,
0.31202706694602966,
-0.44846656918525696,
-0.4931477904319763,
-0.1386033296585083,
-0.11767997592687607,
0.03289690241217613,
0.0408833771944046,
-0.9795154333114624,
0.4362882375717163,
0.45764440298080444,
-0.0988268107175827,
-0.9861889481544495,
-0.4067319333553314,
0.5629857182502747,
0.15422028303146362,
-0.7214146256446838,
0.4199123680591583,
0.32635390758514404,
-0.382756769657135,
0.22286179661750793,
-0.3789408504962921,
-0.5619050860404968,
-0.05551210418343544,
-0.03976650908589363,
0.010659256018698215,
-0.19656868278980255,
0.024985607713460922,
0.292820006608963,
0.021449271589517593,
0.11215812712907791,
-0.21625001728534698,
0.2911590337753296,
-0.053882237523794174,
-0.8033507466316223,
-0.7319665551185608,
0.2676856815814972,
0.6689600944519043,
-0.03419547155499458,
0.6902791857719421,
0.6658808588981628,
-0.49361953139305115,
-0.31443777680397034,
-0.8403591513633728,
-0.6382684111595154,
-0.4819212257862091,
0.1669178158044815,
0.08696147054433823,
-0.6054741740226746,
0.5121045112609863,
-0.40558964014053345,
0.3165055215358734,
0.515904426574707,
0.12087336927652359,
0.07366883009672165,
0.6621958613395691,
0.3954017162322998,
0.09962289780378342,
0.1426590085029602,
0.011789663694798946,
0.10795392841100693,
-0.09802162647247314,
-0.07410284131765366,
-0.671071469783783,
0.07112709432840347,
-0.015444151125848293,
-0.1909688264131546,
0.12118923664093018,
-0.1832929253578186,
-0.07067296653985977,
0.347308486700058,
-0.3093249797821045,
0.6231231093406677,
0.3397437632083893,
0.35109472274780273,
0.6607962846755981,
0.03745182231068611,
0.12832601368427277,
0.26362502574920654,
-0.5638061761856079,
-0.5685089230537415,
0.9743456244468689,
0.46908441185951233,
0.7244939804077148,
0.11411198228597641,
0.2258514016866684,
0.8845610022544861,
0.3443015217781067,
-0.29605358839035034,
0.35644227266311646,
0.1058013066649437,
-0.8492556810379028,
-0.33615878224372864,
-0.3199002146720886,
-0.5124797224998474,
-0.00503241503611207,
-0.46249207854270935,
-0.060784127563238144,
0.5691806077957153,
0.3152860701084137,
-0.1363140493631363,
0.32534682750701904,
-0.3708936870098114,
0.1853557527065277,
-0.31507280468940735,
-0.4276265799999237,
-0.5845057368278503,
-0.2787002623081207,
0.4291474223136902,
-0.00940745696425438,
0.1295456737279892,
-0.13646730780601501,
-0.0015882966108620167,
0.39936044812202454,
-0.669585108757019,
0.655996561050415,
-0.21326807141304016,
0.02295868843793869,
0.4155287742614746,
0.297871470451355,
1.249072551727295,
0.4887574017047882,
-0.010457372292876244,
0.561080276966095,
-0.22941957414150238,
-0.15482372045516968,
-0.3175092041492462,
0.4324050843715668,
-0.6550339460372925,
-0.46601539850234985,
-0.8744575381278992,
-0.004289156757295132,
0.060345351696014404,
0.30035144090652466,
0.43729010224342346,
0.7308958172798157,
-0.276109904050827,
0.18428660929203033,
0.771759033203125,
-0.03546348959207535,
0.41390350461006165,
0.7461541295051575,
0.24697154760360718,
-0.44412294030189514,
0.5656716823577881,
-0.029239166527986526,
0.10730569809675217,
0.35983726382255554,
0.17022483050823212,
-0.5090222954750061,
-0.8573189377784729,
-0.8488547205924988,
-0.0029593934305012226,
-0.6892931461334229,
-0.6155375838279724,
-0.5157584547996521,
-0.3057478964328766,
-0.2016688734292984,
0.3785964846611023,
-0.8811745643615723,
-0.6572602987289429,
0.0065223746933043,
-0.20961430668830872,
0.35798004269599915,
0.9410266280174255,
-0.21907486021518707,
0.008721706457436085,
-0.7846276164054871,
0.4360159933567047,
0.21915605664253235,
0.43816184997558594,
-0.4801013171672821,
-0.6342061758041382,
-0.368219256401062,
0.32656750082969666,
-0.1908908188343048,
-1.0857651233673096,
0.16667968034744263,
0.5300244092941284,
0.5706786513328552,
0.7247483730316162,
0.5487036108970642,
0.4090816378593445,
-0.5593202114105225,
0.9187265038490295,
-0.12290234863758087,
-0.9032955765724182,
0.3079868257045746,
-0.11658906191587448,
-0.34447139501571655,
0.7588916420936584,
0.22370527684688568,
-0.08215151727199554,
-0.4684438407421112,
-0.5578600168228149,
-0.7023423314094543,
0.6464808583259583,
0.4961928427219391,
-0.40766146779060364,
0.1251082569360733,
0.31039080023765564,
0.48712679743766785,
0.11290787905454636,
-0.6289648413658142,
-0.47482800483703613,
-0.6241798400878906,
-0.08573346585035324,
0.6267505288124084,
-0.39913639426231384,
-0.5580922365188599,
0.1987617015838623,
0.939148485660553,
-0.2958664298057556,
0.33347177505493164,
0.6891595721244812,
-0.5569279789924622,
-0.2989651560783386,
0.16737869381904602,
0.6747974157333374,
0.8226734399795532,
-0.05798833817243576,
0.4455243945121765,
-0.07400653511285782,
-0.8431121706962585,
0.32078343629837036,
0.18607614934444427,
-0.3720192015171051,
0.4360491931438446,
0.4026510417461395,
0.2893298268318176,
-0.2780586779117584,
-0.5338292717933655,
0.6987796425819397,
-0.23494108021259308,
-0.04953521490097046,
-0.6301469802856445,
-0.08598465472459793,
-0.3683529794216156,
-0.15107418596744537,
0.6690868139266968,
0.410643607378006,
0.30176371335983276,
-0.46960151195526123,
0.5283637642860413,
0.24557234346866608,
-0.2892574369907379,
-0.4672218859195709,
0.36979302763938904,
0.39879435300827026,
0.0146884610876441,
0.5233614444732666,
-0.23758472502231598,
-0.8522753119468689,
0.6377366185188293,
0.2845558524131775,
0.7268288731575012,
-0.21768319606781006,
0.4992929995059967,
0.4098508059978485,
0.6828107237815857,
-0.488695353269577,
-0.03616957366466522,
0.19161424040794373,
-0.8861784338951111,
-0.6020088195800781,
-0.19992457330226898,
-0.5548484325408936,
0.3344942331314087,
-0.3069744408130646,
0.008479946292936802,
-0.2760487496852875,
-0.19734954833984375,
-0.2534377872943878,
0.006440469995141029,
-0.668389618396759,
0.1814950704574585,
-0.10960644483566284,
1.08296799659729,
-1.01775324344635,
0.5087059736251831,
0.5639615654945374,
-0.032919108867645264,
-0.5319766402244568,
0.17529945075511932,
0.29695793986320496,
-0.5607696771621704,
0.299281507730484,
-0.008274311199784279,
-0.16622309386730194,
-0.451723575592041,
-0.61507248878479,
-0.9616590142250061,
0.9518296122550964,
0.43811866641044617,
-0.34477323293685913,
0.44555965065956116,
0.2795536518096924,
0.33113107085227966,
-0.19099171459674835,
0.7285891771316528,
0.49649348855018616,
0.7501790523529053,
-0.012692119926214218,
-0.8560146689414978,
0.3346725404262543,
-0.043114401400089264,
-0.9996249079704285,
-0.15145093202590942,
-0.7447735071182251,
0.5506783723831177,
0.06369083374738693,
-0.4531325399875641,
-0.17673593759536743,
0.7917681336402893,
0.0026954221539199352,
0.5294336676597595,
0.9072859287261963,
0.5447328686714172,
0.8992719650268555,
-0.32643163204193115,
0.7127637267112732,
-0.5252506732940674,
0.11880318075418472,
1.1061041355133057,
-0.42641961574554443,
0.6723540425300598,
-0.01656237430870533,
0.053894203156232834,
0.8209513425827026,
0.5890927910804749,
-0.03889530897140503,
0.39053788781166077,
-0.6466056108474731,
-0.2835065722465515,
-0.4249996542930603,
-0.2381172776222229,
-0.20958906412124634,
0.37904566526412964,
0.48383674025535583,
-0.28980234265327454,
-0.31857728958129883,
-0.43190866708755493,
0.06244466081261635,
0.029661530628800392,
0.09095383435487747,
0.7856901288032532,
-0.1847752034664154,
-0.719563364982605,
0.19826649129390717,
-0.23643137514591217,
0.2699843645095825,
-0.4902397096157074,
-0.2834019958972931,
-0.1933404952287674,
0.11704590916633606,
-0.3625921607017517,
-0.7934783697128296,
0.13429862260818481,
0.17766539752483368,
0.12491019815206528,
-0.16635847091674805,
1.2232509851455688,
-0.38854461908340454,
-0.06188076362013817,
-0.03286578506231308,
0.7315617799758911,
-0.061889536678791046,
-0.35003572702407837,
-0.6299150586128235,
0.045151837170124054,
-0.1063806563615799,
-0.2785365581512451,
0.032702431082725525,
0.34887218475341797,
0.22338922321796417,
0.8694323897361755,
0.9173015356063843,
0.3687440752983093,
-0.1552397906780243,
0.010767513886094093,
0.7740961909294128,
-0.13001486659049988,
-0.5526031851768494,
-0.6570723652839661,
0.21082858741283417,
-0.6441357135772705,
0.08257478475570679,
0.8240563273429871,
0.6008793115615845,
0.4672323763370514,
0.09684974700212479,
0.8596213459968567,
-0.2461409717798233,
0.5546948313713074,
-0.3786182701587677,
1.105027437210083,
-0.06155626103281975,
0.3284457325935364,
0.09066136926412582,
-0.7994841933250427,
-0.02306484617292881,
0.4133276343345642,
0.2913551926612854,
-0.19298091530799866,
1.005730390548706,
0.5101000666618347,
-0.2505682110786438,
0.404878705739975,
-0.01797805353999138,
0.3955680727958679,
0.5967646837234497,
0.015626657754182816,
0.9315112829208374,
-0.5121868848800659,
0.7941755652427673,
-0.3848865032196045,
-0.30817878246307373,
-0.2616681754589081,
-1.2080916166305542,
-0.7133540511131287,
-0.29900869727134705,
-0.6956748366355896,
-0.5291942358016968,
0.24890929460525513,
0.7100661993026733,
0.9694641828536987,
-1.0113701820373535,
0.40523239970207214,
-0.272666335105896,
0.33152833580970764,
-0.5042725205421448,
-0.19561000168323517,
0.5541540384292603,
-0.023090241476893425,
-0.43613213300704956,
0.68333500623703,
0.09536033123731613,
-0.044379036873579025,
-0.1919107437133789,
0.23607882857322693,
0.04922904446721077,
0.324520081281662,
0.25647422671318054,
0.4299432933330536,
-0.44965365529060364,
-0.7578619122505188,
-0.16783243417739868,
-0.03700747340917587,
-0.03787444531917572,
0.8278147578239441,
-0.9033624529838562,
0.19626456499099731,
0.641944169998169,
0.6005973219871521,
0.2260398417711258,
0.3393253684043884,
0.5219421982765198,
-0.5314154028892517,
0.0011626376071944833,
0.29810386896133423,
0.5006519556045532,
0.37247899174690247,
-0.6322158575057983,
0.47488293051719666,
0.20738008618354797,
-0.9161226153373718,
-0.9006820917129517,
0.20522283017635345,
-0.856985330581665,
-0.017542824149131775,
1.0490939617156982,
-0.4370403289794922,
-0.05091604217886925,
-0.8515215516090393,
0.2405587136745453,
0.27300766110420227,
-0.706679105758667,
1.2510523796081543,
0.637550950050354,
0.04567567631602287,
-0.06534762680530548,
-0.25810301303863525,
0.9245962500572205,
0.03826669976115227,
-0.8855038285255432,
0.2253311574459076,
0.6202836632728577,
0.34362733364105225,
0.292256236076355,
0.1737377941608429,
-0.03420982509851456,
0.4661577045917511,
0.22825466096401215,
-0.14185716211795807,
-0.34844598174095154,
-0.462288498878479,
0.09056272357702255,
0.29861733317375183,
-0.23027589917182922,
0.015630220994353294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18684v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18684v2
|
Work Smarter...Not Harder: Efficient Minimization of Dependency Length in SOV Languages
| 2024-04-29T13:30:27 | 2024-05-11T03:51:38 |
Sidharth Ranjan, Titus von der Malsburg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, econ.TH, math.OC
|
Dependency length minimization is a universally observed quantitative
property of natural languages. However, the extent of dependency length
minimization, and the cognitive mechanisms through which the language processor
achieves this minimization remain unclear. This research offers mechanistic
insights by postulating that moving a short preverbal constituent next to the
main verb explains preverbal constituent ordering decisions better than global
minimization of dependency length in SOV languages. This approach constitutes a
least-effort strategy because it's just one operation but simultaneously
reduces the length of all preverbal dependencies linked to the main verb. We
corroborate this strategy using large-scale corpus evidence across all seven
SOV languages that are prominently represented in the Universal Dependency
Treebank. These findings align with the concept of bounded rationality, where
decision-making is influenced by 'quick-yet-economical' heuristics rather than
exhaustive searches for optimal solutions. Overall, this work sheds light on
the role of bounded rationality in linguistic decision-making and language
evolution.
|
[
-0.42958465218544006,
-0.7576061487197876,
0.7792572379112244,
0.27607712149620056,
-0.06205826997756958,
-0.16820673644542694,
-0.454316109418869,
-0.3774298131465912,
0.28233087062835693,
0.2622372508049011,
-0.6449201703071594,
-0.13832159340381622,
-0.553274929523468,
0.1302921026945114,
0.2001754343509674,
0.7606114745140076,
0.22466011345386505,
-0.08261173218488693,
-0.3110964894294739,
-0.3842063248157501,
-0.34722426533699036,
-0.4840770661830902,
-0.3827889859676361,
-0.13799187541007996,
0.5881124138832092,
0.6512508988380432,
1.1666526794433594,
1.0184208154678345,
0.3435599207878113,
0.32838165760040283,
-0.19289369881153107,
-0.2800007462501526,
-0.4904274344444275,
0.019483620300889015,
-0.15147438645362854,
-0.7285442352294922,
-0.09597304463386536,
-0.0409022718667984,
0.4293140470981598,
0.8732684850692749,
-0.07539145648479462,
0.21523398160934448,
-0.18918801844120026,
1.2772586345672607,
-0.8037055134773254,
0.1146155297756195,
-0.11948223412036896,
-0.15394507348537445,
-0.5662813186645508,
-0.05074865370988846,
-0.41762787103652954,
-0.18474282324314117,
0.40301650762557983,
-0.44858047366142273,
-0.031227117404341698,
-0.043332476168870926,
0.7064367532730103,
0.4960988461971283,
-0.4125979542732239,
-0.18957240879535675,
-0.748338520526886,
1.002543330192566,
-0.2642793357372284,
0.6972899436950684,
0.3067712187767029,
0.1671927571296692,
-0.12768374383449554,
-0.46085861325263977,
-0.4573058784008026,
-0.32009434700012207,
-0.15482619404792786,
-0.17250455915927887,
-0.17655782401561737,
0.38054803013801575,
0.5490454435348511,
-0.057586245238780975,
-0.5541998147964478,
0.21258677542209625,
-0.492513507604599,
-0.25618699193000793,
0.38779085874557495,
-0.027290940284729004,
0.379290372133255,
-0.28900453448295593,
-0.1487765610218048,
0.06903278082609177,
-0.6574419140815735,
0.46053773164749146,
0.17599503695964813,
0.23606987297534943,
0.36805015802383423,
0.653107225894928,
-0.4949645400047302,
0.6420238018035889,
-0.2686743438243866,
-0.253023624420166,
-0.04725082963705063,
-0.6142815351486206,
-0.07538550347089767,
0.1682477742433548,
0.5960327386856079,
0.15659618377685547,
0.2991979122161865,
-0.02172134444117546,
-0.21341069042682648,
0.3159186840057373,
-0.02027454413473606,
-0.8643242716789246,
-0.045356303453445435,
-0.011941637843847275,
-0.588549017906189,
0.06177714839577675,
-0.177787184715271,
-0.3882914185523987,
-0.010172982700169086,
-0.4140542149543762,
-0.0021571642719209194,
-0.49007052183151245,
-0.00425596721470356,
0.20636294782161713,
-0.020337263122200966,
0.2542169690132141,
0.19658394157886505,
-1.084169626235962,
0.5084516406059265,
0.9262986183166504,
0.781375527381897,
0.05069473758339882,
-0.18783795833587646,
-0.7393655776977539,
-0.015086853876709938,
-0.4170781075954437,
0.7547953724861145,
-0.5804885625839233,
-0.15460501611232758,
-0.2967313528060913,
-0.2328627109527588,
0.09068909287452698,
-0.4544423520565033,
0.3859975337982178,
-0.48397937417030334,
0.2263285368680954,
-0.5149392485618591,
-0.43533483147621155,
-0.4130171537399292,
-0.2076999545097351,
-0.4561718702316284,
0.6283292174339294,
0.0765814557671547,
-0.4607597291469574,
0.592887282371521,
-0.44060683250427246,
-0.7597408890724182,
0.032755013555288315,
-0.3460732400417328,
-0.12438572198152542,
0.3470070958137512,
-0.3731426000595093,
0.3082089424133301,
-0.4824964106082916,
0.08152520656585693,
-0.10792728513479233,
-0.07594002038240433,
0.1545647233724594,
-0.1945429891347885,
0.8905825018882751,
0.21925997734069824,
-0.38055363297462463,
0.25384557247161865,
-0.5561801791191101,
-0.15939530730247498,
0.03357314690947533,
-0.38942283391952515,
-0.6486769914627075,
0.11724228411912918,
-0.19281364977359772,
0.15015429258346558,
0.20359021425247192,
-0.4420710802078247,
0.31324589252471924,
-0.5172601342201233,
0.3405154347419739,
0.8262932300567627,
-0.1565234661102295,
0.9598858952522278,
-0.18170204758644104,
0.5592029690742493,
-0.5710849761962891,
0.6591537594795227,
0.24782347679138184,
-0.2949182093143463,
-0.7796961665153503,
-0.6245813369750977,
0.31990155577659607,
0.6562232971191406,
-0.5454680919647217,
0.09896203875541687,
-0.32405227422714233,
-0.20523321628570557,
-0.27535682916641235,
0.19238416850566864,
0.5626242160797119,
0.2756541073322296,
0.2522677779197693,
-0.34920892119407654,
-0.49981632828712463,
-1.0185233354568481,
-0.3045063614845276,
-0.213151752948761,
0.10746146738529205,
-0.017085757106542587,
0.288479208946228,
-0.24790970981121063,
1.1148136854171753,
-0.6609079837799072,
-0.19838400185108185,
-0.30809053778648376,
-0.05377735197544098,
0.23575958609580994,
0.4474892020225525,
0.6948272585868835,
-0.6958696246147156,
-0.476595938205719,
-0.142313614487648,
-0.31862449645996094,
-0.14477504789829254,
-0.1391071379184723,
-0.28821566700935364,
0.3898225724697113,
0.5092808604240417,
-1.0182387828826904,
0.614702045917511,
0.058674830943346024,
-0.4625951051712036,
0.5616028308868408,
-0.3878537714481354,
-0.2545391321182251,
-0.355397492647171,
-0.2786238193511963,
-0.28277865052223206,
-0.30055245757102966,
-0.8610937595367432,
-0.01744423434138298,
-0.09997067600488663,
0.403281033039093,
-0.5308824181556702,
0.27828526496887207,
-0.6318137645721436,
-0.12955059111118317,
-0.13794264197349548,
0.07153862714767456,
-0.14434267580509186,
0.5441476106643677,
-0.2324659675359726,
0.6086445450782776,
0.4770125150680542,
-0.8715008497238159,
0.08352894335985184,
0.23306907713413239,
-0.40496188402175903,
0.40408703684806824,
-0.3734172582626343,
-0.03843573480844498,
-0.38880667090415955,
-0.01744743250310421,
-0.6053333282470703,
0.12086904048919678,
0.06292196363210678,
-0.4165646433830261,
0.25063368678092957,
-0.19586564600467682,
-0.49792805314064026,
0.07690481841564178,
-0.25111839175224304,
0.45018911361694336,
0.8068966269493103,
-0.2639542520046234,
0.4500677287578583,
0.4240655303001404,
-0.3251986503601074,
-0.3413066267967224,
-0.6346500515937805,
-0.21198613941669464,
-0.14039169251918793,
-0.9250516295433044,
0.1789424568414688,
-0.1025722399353981,
-0.7501581311225891,
-0.15657939016819,
-0.4504592716693878,
0.038127873092889786,
0.1829690784215927,
0.013674716465175152,
0.15064994990825653,
-0.2576068639755249,
0.28791385889053345,
-0.12242394685745239,
-0.3438267409801483,
-0.013306754641234875,
-0.3591509461402893,
0.42663097381591797,
-0.32203176617622375,
0.04353012517094612,
-0.24801135063171387,
0.3480801284313202,
0.657065212726593,
-0.17960822582244873,
0.7237309813499451,
0.06724854558706284,
-0.11676040291786194,
0.0047140284441411495,
-0.6167812943458557,
-0.11926079541444778,
-0.502289354801178,
0.2804279029369354,
-0.4902503788471222,
-0.9830067157745361,
0.3458392024040222,
-0.04090005159378052,
0.0032984116114676,
0.32851332426071167,
0.3158624470233917,
0.09880663454532623,
1.1939291954040527,
0.5725269317626953,
0.0665750578045845,
0.6586478352546692,
-0.14824074506759644,
0.2321871817111969,
-0.39316028356552124,
-0.03801557049155235,
-0.573029100894928,
-0.08818874508142471,
-0.8119759559631348,
-0.579887866973877,
0.0870034322142601,
0.19032824039459229,
-0.1355399489402771,
0.2543231248855591,
-0.29149487614631653,
0.6196502447128296,
0.4342612624168396,
-0.20156867802143097,
0.1291145235300064,
-0.386648029088974,
-0.0480072982609272,
-0.0741579681634903,
-0.855316162109375,
-0.36710014939308167,
0.4542800188064575,
0.06947094202041626,
0.41188374161720276,
0.4170058071613312,
0.7040719985961914,
0.18343044817447662,
0.07367460429668427,
-1.1173850297927856,
0.7831547856330872,
-0.2106279730796814,
-0.2920961380004883,
-0.6024571657180786,
-0.5441293716430664,
-1.313260793685913,
0.196695476770401,
-0.20940940082073212,
-0.5282540321350098,
0.17538632452487946,
0.01868705451488495,
-0.4443749785423279,
-0.13733792304992676,
-0.6986075043678284,
0.9301891326904297,
-0.41285979747772217,
-0.4163271188735962,
-0.564845085144043,
-0.7554035782814026,
0.0458635613322258,
0.15875723958015442,
0.5998830795288086,
-0.27915066480636597,
-0.3076835572719574,
0.8161762356758118,
-1.0587184429168701,
0.2342320829629898,
-0.31389281153678894,
0.3035912811756134,
0.3982792794704437,
0.2091466337442398,
0.5800451636314392,
-0.21865136921405792,
0.23705163598060608,
-0.1893143504858017,
-0.01575603522360325,
-0.8721960783004761,
-0.6232826113700867,
0.6179164052009583,
-0.4597424864768982,
-0.7939699292182922,
-0.4916417896747589,
-0.035511139780282974,
-0.09627488255500793,
0.48079371452331543,
0.2753814160823822,
0.3126065731048584,
-0.2992917597293854,
0.13896135985851288,
0.557221531867981,
-0.1141948401927948,
0.6440257430076599,
0.5430132150650024,
-0.19403769075870514,
-0.14732113480567932,
0.9412623643875122,
0.6605774164199829,
0.34582147002220154,
0.39794909954071045,
0.5141183733940125,
-0.2276509404182434,
-0.4089043140411377,
-0.304212749004364,
0.30744606256484985,
-0.6568366885185242,
0.16003268957138062,
-0.5830497741699219,
0.3211738169193268,
-0.5081366300582886,
-0.45399269461631775,
-0.6107640266418457,
-0.6714462041854858,
-0.08328145742416382,
-0.33548590540885925,
0.3731808662414551,
0.7643193006515503,
-0.16768193244934082,
0.1364348977804184,
-0.8810850381851196,
0.22291508316993713,
0.6110914945602417,
0.22619575262069702,
-0.06143810227513313,
-0.09703098237514496,
-0.17263729870319366,
-0.15234841406345367,
0.1869625300168991,
-0.7327326536178589,
0.193927600979805,
0.17170991003513336,
0.47858336567878723,
0.31653422117233276,
0.1209176778793335,
0.6784566640853882,
-0.49498066306114197,
0.4836040437221527,
0.504472017288208,
-1.0957351922988892,
0.37772136926651,
-0.24696636199951172,
0.5269003510475159,
0.7972928881645203,
0.20081444084644318,
-0.5164030194282532,
0.020573513582348824,
-0.6925578713417053,
-0.9388508796691895,
0.5798444747924805,
0.3532267212867737,
-0.1283818781375885,
-0.035207461565732956,
0.21340011060237885,
0.16608135402202606,
0.04383716732263565,
-0.23436802625656128,
-0.3124682307243347,
0.24175424873828888,
0.0045496635138988495,
0.17801599204540253,
-0.2948858141899109,
0.26664575934410095,
-0.346825510263443,
0.5050234198570251,
-0.11335737258195877,
0.12151037901639938,
0.18881544470787048,
-0.5155599117279053,
0.2910785377025604,
0.37945687770843506,
0.8531264662742615,
0.548809826374054,
-0.005891981068998575,
0.20928877592086792,
0.161992147564888,
-0.34048596024513245,
0.2051713466644287,
-0.17755930125713348,
-0.32124388217926025,
-0.047541454434394836,
0.2636253237724304,
0.7115814089775085,
-0.0650540441274643,
-0.6862949728965759,
0.6687824726104736,
-0.16571253538131714,
-0.04051141440868378,
-0.41604453325271606,
-0.026516970247030258,
-0.021643631160259247,
0.33786237239837646,
0.006183997727930546,
0.558855414390564,
0.295073539018631,
-0.5706355571746826,
0.15937112271785736,
0.28848177194595337,
-0.5195299983024597,
-0.4910232424736023,
0.3110358417034149,
0.03696807473897934,
-0.336419016122818,
0.5820215940475464,
-0.36344704031944275,
-0.5731493830680847,
0.5787000060081482,
-0.04290229454636574,
0.8166590332984924,
-0.1115759089589119,
0.19991537928581238,
0.060299839824438095,
0.39121246337890625,
-0.3785991966724396,
0.37954002618789673,
-0.308482825756073,
-0.5378317832946777,
-0.7425615191459656,
-0.40753933787345886,
-0.14606523513793945,
-0.4520021677017212,
-0.5838674902915955,
0.32250499725341797,
-0.7195181846618652,
-0.20392419397830963,
0.018332935869693756,
-0.30392923951148987,
-0.7543578147888184,
0.14959412813186646,
0.12573622167110443,
0.6526196002960205,
-0.5641956329345703,
0.7705782651901245,
0.4160597026348114,
-0.4657960534095764,
-0.7435954213142395,
-0.08148076385259628,
0.008177762851119041,
-0.7144727110862732,
0.7269916534423828,
0.41864797472953796,
-0.36640605330467224,
-0.17484183609485626,
-0.5378704071044922,
-1.0361326932907104,
0.6794791221618652,
0.46214228868484497,
-0.3419966697692871,
0.2542882561683655,
0.08411464095115662,
0.5636823773384094,
-0.03400404006242752,
0.15587228536605835,
0.8563601970672607,
0.595008373260498,
-0.06031809374690056,
-0.7768336534500122,
0.32045936584472656,
-0.11922041326761246,
0.16825956106185913,
0.6109538674354553,
-0.992918074131012,
0.48080208897590637,
-0.44674617052078247,
-0.5035143494606018,
-0.1379445195198059,
0.8677990436553955,
-0.069062739610672,
0.15881796181201935,
0.8238714933395386,
0.40234705805778503,
0.7717264890670776,
0.028478821739554405,
0.9716930985450745,
-0.1427197903394699,
0.06347959488630295,
0.7990263104438782,
-0.04637093096971512,
0.5559775829315186,
0.6744333505630493,
-0.18583638966083527,
0.5821969509124756,
0.5336443185806274,
0.4133932292461395,
0.6663234829902649,
0.5872788429260254,
-0.1599254459142685,
-0.24838721752166748,
-0.46079185605049133,
0.09956692159175873,
0.5944972634315491,
0.24257349967956543,
0.14486204087734222,
0.3744406998157501,
0.18023324012756348,
0.43442708253860474,
-0.06316900998353958,
-0.2388402223587036,
0.822495698928833,
0.042868953198194504,
-1.065550684928894,
0.7583168745040894,
-0.19766353070735931,
0.6081058979034424,
-0.5502275824546814,
0.2630489766597748,
-0.1736096739768982,
0.04584454745054245,
-0.30936598777770996,
-0.4573751986026764,
0.4859592020511627,
-0.14639829099178314,
-0.41026344895362854,
-0.7256887555122375,
0.6382218599319458,
-0.06857090443372726,
0.1351783275604248,
0.47133663296699524,
0.5267752408981323,
0.008200190030038357,
-0.037346139550209045,
-0.3319787383079529,
-0.19473062455654144,
0.16506198048591614,
-0.5198853015899658,
0.40512973070144653,
0.5746500492095947,
-0.26283326745033264,
0.6469128131866455,
0.7957316637039185,
0.1066032275557518,
0.05598992854356766,
0.04123479500412941,
0.6756577491760254,
-0.7851132154464722,
-0.574371337890625,
-0.9961355924606323,
0.4199991822242737,
0.06252898275852203,
-0.18924441933631897,
0.6000115871429443,
0.515878438949585,
0.9703646302223206,
-0.012508681043982506,
0.7222248911857605,
-0.2539733648300171,
0.08861277997493744,
-0.4574030935764313,
0.2764999270439148,
-0.5750749707221985,
0.2867441177368164,
-0.1345965564250946,
-0.9399856328964233,
-0.45417988300323486,
0.6680861115455627,
-0.5170431733131409,
-0.2801603078842163,
0.9217225909233093,
0.7580239176750183,
0.29315561056137085,
-0.058884359896183014,
0.30248966813087463,
0.2858688533306122,
0.0785539373755455,
0.30571743845939636,
0.8210622072219849,
0.09410452097654343,
0.632439136505127,
-0.43340545892715454,
-0.4919188320636749,
-0.2371690571308136,
-0.5423557162284851,
-0.6046054363250732,
-0.3412081301212311,
-0.42062240839004517,
-0.2127186357975006,
-0.18725621700286865,
1.2067551612854004,
0.6387337446212769,
-0.6696653962135315,
-0.33738046884536743,
-0.41047999262809753,
0.3693583011627197,
-0.3071955740451813,
-0.21305279433727264,
0.22584331035614014,
-0.32235416769981384,
-0.3484002351760864,
0.5051575303077698,
0.6884874701499939,
-0.06351534277200699,
0.0696077048778534,
-0.30414319038391113,
-0.48887690901756287,
0.27060985565185547,
0.6573324799537659,
0.5811185240745544,
-0.603358805179596,
-0.4232768714427948,
0.4189707338809967,
-0.3569289445877075,
0.13195911049842834,
0.8563715815544128,
-0.5409172773361206,
0.6062330603599548,
1.2132636308670044,
0.4878261685371399,
0.33539798855781555,
-0.35447967052459717,
0.6172502636909485,
-0.6049738526344299,
0.2599436640739441,
0.13248319923877716,
0.35910385847091675,
0.0879734456539154,
-0.20453274250030518,
0.6170137524604797,
0.43655121326446533,
-0.622753918170929,
-0.5157387852668762,
0.5547476410865784,
-0.7169122099876404,
-0.37996602058410645,
1.1406795978546143,
0.07384274154901505,
-0.46560919284820557,
-0.35391712188720703,
-0.4012954831123352,
0.3237210512161255,
-0.3700975775718689,
0.384040892124176,
0.48064887523651123,
-0.5507062673568726,
0.00761837512254715,
-0.46891993284225464,
0.684735894203186,
0.9671570062637329,
-0.4627430737018585,
-0.031143246218562126,
0.5180612206459045,
-0.0017172435764223337,
0.394029438495636,
0.8756042718887329,
0.4339085519313812,
0.21668170392513275,
-0.120281882584095,
-0.04633943736553192,
0.30577442049980164,
-0.2967924475669861,
-0.0917486622929573,
-0.07776039838790894,
0.3071003258228302,
-0.09595388174057007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01591v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01591v1
|
Simplifying Multimodality: Unimodal Approach to Multimodal Challenges in Radiology with General-Domain Large Language Model
| 2024-04-29T13:23:33 | 2024-04-29T13:23:33 |
Seonhee Cho, Choonghan Kim, Jiho Lee, Chetan Chilkunda, Sujin Choi, Joo Heung Yoon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, eess.IV
|
Recent advancements in Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) have attracted interest
in their generalization capability with only a few samples in the prompt. This
progress is particularly relevant to the medical domain, where the quality and
sensitivity of data pose unique challenges for model training and application.
However, the dependency on high-quality data for effective in-context learning
raises questions about the feasibility of these models when encountering with
the inevitable variations and errors inherent in real-world medical data. In
this paper, we introduce MID-M, a novel framework that leverages the in-context
learning capabilities of a general-domain Large Language Model (LLM) to process
multimodal data via image descriptions. MID-M achieves a comparable or superior
performance to task-specific fine-tuned LMMs and other general-domain ones,
without the extensive domain-specific training or pre-training on multimodal
data, with significantly fewer parameters. This highlights the potential of
leveraging general-domain LLMs for domain-specific tasks and offers a
sustainable and cost-effective alternative to traditional LMM developments.
Moreover, the robustness of MID-M against data quality issues demonstrates its
practical utility in real-world medical domain applications.
|
[
-0.26884666085243225,
-0.7189245820045471,
0.8292267322540283,
-0.0868094339966774,
-0.584715723991394,
-0.17329157888889313,
-0.3425581753253937,
-0.3539695739746094,
0.04342454671859741,
0.26901280879974365,
-0.6418870687484741,
-0.5109009742736816,
-0.8242027163505554,
0.08980509638786316,
-0.02291281707584858,
0.8361138701438904,
-0.14195699989795685,
0.5358877182006836,
-0.40093690156936646,
-0.3840732276439667,
-0.2740602493286133,
-0.5436025857925415,
-0.35380521416664124,
-0.2938755750656128,
0.7188635468482971,
0.505866289138794,
0.9874629974365234,
0.48573049902915955,
0.4920354187488556,
0.2636357247829437,
0.39730820059776306,
0.30945271253585815,
-0.13707633316516876,
0.07457494735717773,
-0.15691998600959778,
-0.04292023181915283,
-0.5611085891723633,
-0.019518088549375534,
0.6154841184616089,
1.069987177848816,
0.07534424215555191,
-0.004017702303826809,
-0.14552940428256989,
0.5931242108345032,
-0.6982707977294922,
0.21791163086891174,
-0.3217540681362152,
-0.14335975050926208,
-0.24762064218521118,
-0.5540948510169983,
-0.30890128016471863,
0.21160030364990234,
0.3146817684173584,
-0.6463679671287537,
-0.018294693902134895,
-0.0012920625740662217,
0.8848055601119995,
0.11697668582201004,
-0.7698308825492859,
-0.50419682264328,
-0.8146852850914001,
0.883651077747345,
-0.45106709003448486,
0.5602725744247437,
0.31731852889060974,
0.6456618309020996,
0.05770081281661987,
-0.9084048271179199,
-0.5123751163482666,
-0.16174300014972687,
-0.08285167068243027,
0.1446504294872284,
-0.323665976524353,
0.31685081124305725,
-0.010116884484887123,
0.2093108892440796,
-0.6623587608337402,
-0.0386703722178936,
-0.2032356709241867,
-0.2005106508731842,
0.14616620540618896,
0.2852398455142975,
0.4133415222167969,
-0.09796110540628433,
-0.689337968826294,
0.027316806837916374,
-0.9356887936592102,
-0.13876309990882874,
-0.21082080900669098,
0.19348929822444916,
-0.2635854184627533,
0.6092879772186279,
-0.3058735430240631,
0.5475644469261169,
-0.3102956712245941,
-0.46639931201934814,
0.34378018975257874,
-0.3753441870212555,
-0.39155834913253784,
-0.4444415867328644,
0.5348581671714783,
0.4085729420185089,
0.01364261656999588,
-0.13403671979904175,
-0.34986329078674316,
-0.0075605688616633415,
-0.12559063732624054,
-0.9248406291007996,
-0.010181897319853306,
0.2507314682006836,
-0.7980557680130005,
-0.003158177947625518,
-0.27293074131011963,
-0.5651206970214844,
-0.028960758820176125,
-0.6094438433647156,
0.6906675696372986,
-0.4270632863044739,
-0.057300157845020294,
0.3618750274181366,
0.3822081983089447,
-0.059023503214120865,
0.4318893849849701,
-0.5577736496925354,
0.08893106132745743,
0.07904326915740967,
0.7941465973854065,
0.25155019760131836,
-0.1590421199798584,
-0.5132582783699036,
0.43181633949279785,
-0.0908697098493576,
0.5886756181716919,
-0.7264857888221741,
-0.2619367837905884,
-0.1760229617357254,
0.1362282782793045,
-0.23666635155677795,
-0.5771216750144958,
0.4426806569099426,
-0.3233199417591095,
0.3658381402492523,
0.08144403249025345,
-0.2508353590965271,
-0.10509514808654785,
0.3742651045322418,
-0.5387750267982483,
0.3394182622432709,
0.2284429669380188,
-0.49973568320274353,
0.1347724050283432,
-0.53716641664505,
-0.39479759335517883,
-0.012353010475635529,
-0.4986262619495392,
-0.4734964668750763,
0.09529545903205872,
0.42870402336120605,
0.8648334741592407,
-0.583281934261322,
0.45042556524276733,
-0.3768824636936188,
-0.1588217169046402,
0.4257493019104004,
-0.5452113151550293,
0.3467658460140228,
0.46705004572868347,
0.11552444100379944,
0.08231194317340851,
-0.704716145992279,
-0.1466061770915985,
0.17381934821605682,
-0.3895988166332245,
-0.33752766251564026,
-0.2203378826379776,
0.23548035323619843,
0.5301894545555115,
0.1317308247089386,
-0.589887261390686,
0.10741639137268066,
0.03009488619863987,
0.21119381487369537,
0.4843871593475342,
-0.04924209415912628,
0.4553380310535431,
-0.6454511880874634,
0.5317330956459045,
0.3674179017543793,
0.6106676459312439,
-0.33352425694465637,
-0.368895024061203,
-0.4703409969806671,
-0.8318676948547363,
0.3707175552845001,
0.3233412802219391,
-1.1916041374206543,
-0.24652589857578278,
-0.4330913722515106,
-0.23576349020004272,
-0.6221043467521667,
0.13179288804531097,
0.6257513761520386,
0.5406102538108826,
0.5347193479537964,
-0.4078431725502014,
-0.6163262724876404,
-1.008396029472351,
0.26006707549095154,
0.2849820554256439,
-0.1891462206840515,
0.5908344388008118,
0.1503361314535141,
-0.8333228230476379,
0.5472401976585388,
-0.49639660120010376,
-0.6660712361335754,
-0.16633130609989166,
0.20337462425231934,
0.16197849810123444,
0.4066551923751831,
0.4112685024738312,
-0.9539618492126465,
-0.3361763060092926,
-0.01325176376849413,
-0.9388623833656311,
-0.07981689274311066,
-0.25693631172180176,
0.11090157181024551,
0.09800239652395248,
0.4709948003292084,
-0.6633785963058472,
0.24368003010749817,
0.7546040415763855,
-0.09795776009559631,
0.5507678389549255,
-0.6532702445983887,
0.29786166548728943,
-1.2170227766036987,
0.13951072096824646,
0.06306230276823044,
-0.11691401153802872,
-0.6559960842132568,
-0.012884399853646755,
0.1809988021850586,
-0.19365961849689484,
-0.5114175081253052,
0.5145145058631897,
-0.8405508995056152,
0.04836444556713104,
-0.2946406304836273,
-0.2665771245956421,
0.02661789022386074,
0.3663268983364105,
-0.06238040328025818,
0.45808249711990356,
0.8692415952682495,
-0.5047845244407654,
0.09823376685380936,
-0.0286218523979187,
-0.12989507615566254,
0.6700950860977173,
-0.46688711643218994,
0.010462095029652119,
-0.5134767889976501,
0.2765042185783386,
-0.8665760159492493,
-0.4618116319179535,
-0.08354862034320831,
-0.44038498401641846,
0.720607578754425,
-0.3816501200199127,
-0.5139360427856445,
-0.12953858077526093,
-0.060607027262449265,
0.8080222606658936,
0.3511338233947754,
-0.41721057891845703,
0.7342003583908081,
0.3261707127094269,
-0.19463075697422028,
-0.7891892194747925,
-0.4611034095287323,
0.2439085990190506,
-0.023267019540071487,
-0.757724940776825,
0.3938303291797638,
-0.3129926025867462,
0.08552096039056778,
-0.10209468752145767,
0.02520465850830078,
-0.1774008870124817,
-0.05330917611718178,
0.2964334487915039,
0.3135746121406555,
-0.2177828699350357,
0.2739390432834625,
0.06308530271053314,
-0.3001537621021271,
-0.16338121891021729,
-0.006725612562149763,
0.4730690121650696,
0.0006842458387836814,
-0.4526328444480896,
-0.2965345084667206,
0.4400287866592407,
0.8104940056800842,
0.005036426708102226,
0.35612279176712036,
0.6131206154823303,
-0.5380493402481079,
0.0320587232708931,
-0.41031187772750854,
-0.11312838643789291,
-0.45122942328453064,
0.5228020548820496,
-0.5800325870513916,
-0.9323422908782959,
0.23829621076583862,
-0.4558619260787964,
-0.2711213529109955,
0.06796849519014359,
0.7383108735084534,
-0.4726230800151825,
1.266610026359558,
0.5788622498512268,
0.11899334192276001,
0.16471132636070251,
-0.06982697546482086,
0.04481728374958038,
-0.8876776695251465,
-0.45334893465042114,
-0.19358883798122406,
-0.27921733260154724,
-0.2620135545730591,
-0.6862737536430359,
0.7700080275535583,
-0.26024818420410156,
0.08433345705270767,
-0.2825291156768799,
-0.2663680613040924,
0.4658006429672241,
0.2004012018442154,
0.33589592576026917,
0.3295641839504242,
0.0037391013465821743,
-0.24798710644245148,
-0.13956697285175323,
-0.5587606430053711,
-0.542015552520752,
1.4287502765655518,
0.32388216257095337,
1.1203945875167847,
0.18194718658924103,
0.2213779091835022,
0.2375456839799881,
0.15554064512252808,
-0.578533411026001,
0.45420318841934204,
-0.453063040971756,
-0.4978685677051544,
-0.057967659085989,
-0.32770493626594543,
-1.144545555114746,
0.39330703020095825,
-0.4389592111110687,
-0.058933332562446594,
0.11987274140119553,
0.12037136405706406,
-0.39665573835372925,
0.40374115109443665,
-0.566226065158844,
0.6258345246315002,
-0.2973115146160126,
-0.2317272424697876,
-0.16611236333847046,
-0.9864175915718079,
0.2564340829849243,
-0.17962515354156494,
0.6801841259002686,
-0.35288935899734497,
-0.29111042618751526,
0.2899630069732666,
-0.11494456976652145,
0.9267082214355469,
-0.3250183165073395,
0.216852068901062,
-0.15153765678405762,
0.14635248482227325,
0.07248879224061966,
0.1254519522190094,
0.537053108215332,
0.06494079530239105,
0.04513714089989662,
-0.5562432408332825,
-0.4156048595905304,
0.6438150405883789,
-0.9149850010871887,
-0.23056748509407043,
-0.2832253873348236,
-0.8429394960403442,
-0.5264365673065186,
0.2060624659061432,
0.27529028058052063,
0.8454738855361938,
-0.18066523969173431,
0.29256585240364075,
0.7371924519538879,
-0.3652302920818329,
0.27400296926498413,
0.43177294731140137,
-0.0293025691062212,
-0.4609419107437134,
0.7665945291519165,
0.037983931601047516,
0.2503005564212799,
0.6639326810836792,
0.21697299182415009,
-0.2436905801296234,
-0.7843225002288818,
-0.6324239373207092,
0.22297795116901398,
-0.816655695438385,
-0.28646281361579895,
-0.6942208409309387,
0.034604620188474655,
-0.11971156299114227,
-0.16223809123039246,
-0.3545222580432892,
-0.27731212973594666,
-0.09298601746559143,
0.30810546875,
-0.19946099817752838,
0.4827522933483124,
-0.027264636009931564,
0.4215468764305115,
-0.9729886651039124,
0.22939710319042206,
0.36050280928611755,
0.2996302843093872,
-0.17427325248718262,
-0.49259722232818604,
-0.5865923762321472,
0.1314273178577423,
-0.1810230314731598,
-0.4789653420448303,
0.44207751750946045,
0.33272039890289307,
0.5255116820335388,
0.46951067447662354,
-0.16039340198040009,
0.6066518425941467,
-0.34137678146362305,
0.42936891317367554,
0.47540444135665894,
-0.692891538143158,
0.28517869114875793,
-0.39859074354171753,
0.39927080273628235,
0.22495973110198975,
0.6224718689918518,
-0.491510272026062,
-0.06384914368391037,
-0.4064026176929474,
-0.8344734311103821,
0.2844068109989166,
-0.019793132320046425,
0.14926333725452423,
0.12457156926393509,
0.19797343015670776,
0.22641798853874207,
0.13279840350151062,
-0.6655257344245911,
-0.06806332617998123,
-0.008348795585334301,
-0.34103941917419434,
-0.1858588606119156,
-0.43970298767089844,
-0.3836994767189026,
-0.26198047399520874,
0.35392138361930847,
-0.4866620600223541,
0.43606504797935486,
0.2677779197692871,
-0.6515079736709595,
-0.1584753841161728,
0.5542804002761841,
0.8396621942520142,
0.6692649126052856,
-0.25689467787742615,
0.5501610636711121,
0.018411103636026382,
-0.4576372504234314,
0.13277553021907806,
-0.11661997437477112,
0.20182298123836517,
0.0869324579834938,
0.3572242259979248,
0.5637308359146118,
0.48054543137550354,
-0.7424144744873047,
0.9507042765617371,
-0.1338740587234497,
-0.24320422112941742,
-0.15435366332530975,
-0.4943676292896271,
0.0669121965765953,
0.3631811738014221,
0.5239630341529846,
0.23420679569244385,
0.26820361614227295,
-0.5027753114700317,
0.39914190769195557,
0.482839971780777,
-0.33837923407554626,
-0.584103524684906,
0.6356427073478699,
-0.014654788188636303,
0.5292412638664246,
0.5458833575248718,
0.25364580750465393,
0.04709082096815109,
0.37516075372695923,
0.5848115682601929,
0.5157751441001892,
-0.1010817363858223,
-0.02706659957766533,
0.13254950940608978,
0.1422494649887085,
0.12949572503566742,
0.3424270451068878,
0.20712874829769135,
-0.7139621376991272,
-0.5793584585189819,
-0.3332364559173584,
-0.4103676378726959,
0.09383470565080643,
-0.574496328830719,
0.20984794199466705,
-0.5954576730728149,
-0.3844287097454071,
0.11984002590179443,
-0.38194170594215393,
-0.6946528553962708,
0.6405776143074036,
0.5145416259765625,
0.569572925567627,
-0.6880730390548706,
1.26010262966156,
0.8282782435417175,
-0.4415378272533417,
-0.4805673062801361,
-0.22009438276290894,
0.029032325372099876,
-0.865003228187561,
0.5869949460029602,
0.13367272913455963,
-0.0512385331094265,
-0.3361363112926483,
-0.6491164565086365,
-0.7861623764038086,
1.347306251525879,
0.4189904034137726,
-0.35034993290901184,
-0.24654635787010193,
0.30878275632858276,
0.3622661232948303,
-0.6881725192070007,
0.2894948720932007,
0.11731649935245514,
0.200973778963089,
0.3053569197654724,
-0.9852218627929688,
0.18299545347690582,
-0.11594832688570023,
0.04484953358769417,
0.09335781633853912,
-0.4688742160797119,
1.0813133716583252,
-0.476275771856308,
-0.25034642219543457,
-0.06700266152620316,
0.37826311588287354,
0.1860904097557068,
0.5010203719139099,
0.4483068883419037,
0.42745473980903625,
0.5322397351264954,
-0.11381122469902039,
0.9466614723205566,
-0.29374566674232483,
0.36741557717323303,
0.7745872139930725,
-0.23977501690387726,
0.5306663513183594,
0.6708254218101501,
0.09534472227096558,
0.3335820436477661,
0.47006165981292725,
0.2525831460952759,
0.7163726687431335,
-0.21773217618465424,
-0.43528151512145996,
-0.4450991749763489,
-0.09213057160377502,
-0.2758578360080719,
0.5093602538108826,
0.5907970666885376,
-0.31571897864341736,
-0.5400914549827576,
0.45577433705329895,
0.028098948299884796,
-0.10646890103816986,
-0.4107144773006439,
0.6395814418792725,
0.2888813316822052,
-0.13899870216846466,
0.6658524870872498,
0.0291579719632864,
0.9216374754905701,
-0.7629207372665405,
-0.003532236674800515,
-0.2120550572872162,
0.26107296347618103,
-0.2520299553871155,
-0.5584955811500549,
0.36486905813217163,
-0.3670864701271057,
-0.3575688302516937,
-0.15037691593170166,
0.65438312292099,
-0.6405704617500305,
-0.12249825894832611,
0.32206863164901733,
0.6522743105888367,
0.05800792574882507,
0.002382035832852125,
-0.5790782570838928,
0.04771975055336952,
-0.14092718064785004,
-0.06550899893045425,
0.7466351389884949,
0.4132818281650543,
-0.1466677486896515,
0.858940064907074,
0.6794946789741516,
-0.026091482490301132,
-0.2271326780319214,
0.0792974904179573,
0.9352235198020935,
-0.5390844941139221,
-0.1006583496928215,
-0.7043377161026001,
0.4912625551223755,
0.26150789856910706,
-0.20539362728595734,
0.3766826391220093,
0.6151686906814575,
0.9307960271835327,
-0.1751273274421692,
0.6441137790679932,
0.11369113624095917,
0.4622877538204193,
-0.7590181827545166,
0.652253270149231,
-0.8882485032081604,
0.1814795881509781,
0.010556825436651707,
-0.4564134478569031,
-0.6845213174819946,
0.20946678519248962,
-0.13139188289642334,
0.14945371448993683,
0.7820254564285278,
0.8429451584815979,
-0.36487749218940735,
-0.4119350016117096,
0.8780210018157959,
0.07053136080503464,
0.198177769780159,
0.828210711479187,
0.7690062522888184,
-0.2552332580089569,
0.5687586665153503,
-0.24547690153121948,
-0.3302482068538666,
-0.2461562156677246,
-0.5778979063034058,
-0.685289740562439,
-0.7377116084098816,
-0.17219026386737823,
-0.3151097893714905,
-0.09636407345533371,
1.0729892253875732,
0.9235190153121948,
-0.500120997428894,
-0.12597276270389557,
0.8747225999832153,
-0.34403395652770996,
0.028413105756044388,
-0.06019042059779167,
0.4807233512401581,
-0.2758926451206207,
-0.7028626203536987,
0.44886428117752075,
0.562650203704834,
0.3100123405456543,
0.015717070549726486,
-0.22775952517986298,
-0.16018956899642944,
0.14209483563899994,
0.8266453146934509,
0.15127141773700714,
-0.511616051197052,
-0.09418269991874695,
-0.024820588529109955,
-0.4305170476436615,
0.22862307727336884,
0.8484428524971008,
-0.46286848187446594,
0.8332672715187073,
0.08096835017204285,
0.5457212328910828,
0.48577964305877686,
-0.2099243700504303,
0.430350124835968,
-0.911345899105072,
0.3068467080593109,
0.23814687132835388,
0.6813475489616394,
0.5094139575958252,
-0.24824053049087524,
0.3370327353477478,
0.26736578345298767,
-0.5934851765632629,
-0.6506349444389343,
0.3187864422798157,
-1.2010506391525269,
-0.5625314116477966,
1.0946683883666992,
-0.1127883717417717,
-0.13962534070014954,
-0.2931725084781647,
-0.07683433592319489,
0.1902530938386917,
-0.001324078650213778,
0.5613126754760742,
0.3173801898956299,
-0.15613923966884613,
-0.29881998896598816,
-0.5737076997756958,
0.33018553256988525,
0.3448948860168457,
-0.6054548621177673,
-0.3118722438812256,
0.736195981502533,
0.6519029140472412,
-0.16534724831581116,
0.864658534526825,
-0.5044720768928528,
0.5202895998954773,
-0.44677770137786865,
0.3721625506877899,
-0.2842473089694977,
-0.5162513852119446,
-0.37702998518943787,
0.29939723014831543,
0.15869440138339996,
-0.26592114567756653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01590v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01590v1
|
101 Billion Arabic Words Dataset
| 2024-04-29T13:15:03 | 2024-04-29T13:15:03 |
Manel Aloui, Hasna Chouikhi, Ghaith Chaabane, Haithem Kchaou, Chehir Dhaouadi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, Large Language Models have revolutionized the field of
natural language processing, showcasing an impressive rise predominantly in
English-centric domains. These advancements have set a global benchmark,
inspiring significant efforts toward developing Arabic LLMs capable of
understanding and generating the Arabic language with remarkable accuracy.
Despite these advancements, a critical challenge persists: the potential bias
in Arabic LLMs, primarily attributed to their reliance on datasets comprising
English data that has been translated into Arabic. This reliance not only
compromises the authenticity of the generated content but also reflects a
broader issue -the scarcity of original quality Arabic linguistic data. This
study aims to address the data scarcity in the Arab world and to encourage the
development of Arabic Language Models that are true to both the linguistic and
nuances of the region. We undertook a large-scale data mining project,
extracting a substantial volume of text from the Common Crawl WET files,
specifically targeting Arabic content. The extracted data underwent a rigorous
cleaning and deduplication process, using innovative techniques to ensure the
integrity and uniqueness of the dataset. The result is the 101 Billion Arabic
Words Dataset, the largest Arabic dataset available to date, which can
significantly contribute to the development of authentic Arabic LLMs. This
study not only highlights the potential for creating linguistically and
culturally accurate Arabic LLMs but also sets a precedent for future research
in enhancing the authenticity of Arabic language models.
|
[
-0.2949618399143219,
-0.602898120880127,
0.3439984917640686,
-0.03126465901732445,
-0.21103517711162567,
0.19462013244628906,
-0.2386588603258133,
-0.42969366908073425,
0.01409292221069336,
0.7099626660346985,
-0.2850458323955536,
-0.9284521341323853,
-0.8920921087265015,
0.31041622161865234,
-0.5720950365066528,
1.0142405033111572,
-0.16766200959682465,
0.04200325161218643,
0.022897548973560333,
-0.6156738996505737,
-0.4175052046775818,
-0.46662577986717224,
-0.43435776233673096,
-0.16691988706588745,
0.23218996822834015,
0.5435593724250793,
0.999616801738739,
0.8368939161300659,
0.2101159244775772,
0.23949794471263885,
-0.08355752378702164,
0.4761796295642853,
-0.44556868076324463,
0.10046481341123581,
-0.20663125813007355,
-0.20266054570674896,
-0.24448788166046143,
-0.061337098479270935,
0.5722330212593079,
0.6631820201873779,
-0.18785345554351807,
0.3067014217376709,
0.05294251814484596,
1.0069313049316406,
-0.5072055459022522,
0.13836432993412018,
-0.7131432890892029,
-0.2315274477005005,
-0.392022043466568,
0.06790748983621597,
-0.09120811522006989,
-0.40834736824035645,
0.09378489851951599,
-0.15147601068019867,
0.13726606965065002,
-0.07088037580251694,
0.7401848435401917,
0.1602340042591095,
-0.44415774941444397,
-0.517936110496521,
-0.616363525390625,
0.8278701901435852,
-0.6618021726608276,
0.24263130128383636,
0.5717079639434814,
0.07790921628475189,
-0.3114001452922821,
-0.5759176015853882,
-0.6273841857910156,
-0.0983448326587677,
0.14048929512500763,
-0.3129548132419586,
-0.03168743848800659,
-0.22812217473983765,
-0.04373469203710556,
0.38787826895713806,
-0.5757191777229309,
-0.05782129243016243,
0.0845676064491272,
-0.2603033185005188,
0.6973437666893005,
0.19970577955245972,
0.526010274887085,
-0.051374245434999466,
-0.030459271743893623,
0.018005192279815674,
-1.0154144763946533,
-0.1393044888973236,
0.3286368250846863,
0.26527684926986694,
0.004862901754677296,
0.4972665011882782,
-0.6065067648887634,
0.4430267810821533,
-0.49338188767433167,
-0.38316529989242554,
0.16134652495384216,
-0.368679940700531,
0.0073845176957547665,
0.2721826136112213,
0.5180005431175232,
0.2330758273601532,
0.6027127504348755,
-0.15143677592277527,
-0.2000342607498169,
-0.18886415660381317,
0.05681749805808067,
-0.7786574959754944,
0.10291879624128342,
0.3933963477611542,
-0.36290404200553894,
-0.19940590858459473,
0.07302110642194748,
-0.6381535530090332,
-0.4519660174846649,
-0.38335657119750977,
0.2552221715450287,
-0.452679842710495,
-0.10061909258365631,
0.1404477059841156,
0.17447887361049652,
0.08242718130350113,
0.27271193265914917,
-0.4826255142688751,
0.1704021394252777,
0.5712346434593201,
0.9108771085739136,
-0.10075823962688446,
-0.14118121564388275,
0.014268443919718266,
0.395376056432724,
-0.4745631814002991,
0.42879122495651245,
-0.6057752370834351,
-0.3026272654533386,
0.3162635564804077,
-0.08896724879741669,
0.5314931869506836,
-0.8101565837860107,
0.8838702440261841,
-0.8852033019065857,
-0.1867474764585495,
-0.2106587439775467,
-0.5057264566421509,
-0.4371803402900696,
0.2259574830532074,
-0.8318727612495422,
0.9530296325683594,
0.0277174711227417,
-0.6909188628196716,
0.34036579728126526,
-0.37409377098083496,
-0.40092167258262634,
0.3072015345096588,
-0.13487493991851807,
-0.3301648199558258,
0.2188115268945694,
0.4179798364639282,
0.19182713329792023,
-0.40102633833885193,
0.42715907096862793,
0.1051994040608406,
-0.5030435919761658,
0.4711708128452301,
-0.5842270255088806,
0.4475124180316925,
0.303241491317749,
-0.3572031855583191,
-0.4087288975715637,
-0.8102562427520752,
-0.04129636660218239,
0.23683497309684753,
-0.39548400044441223,
-0.35606902837753296,
-0.0206924956291914,
0.16691167652606964,
0.14776258170604706,
0.5111624002456665,
-0.536637544631958,
0.2084393948316574,
-0.3424767255783081,
0.15751583874225616,
0.7702831625938416,
-0.007334842346608639,
0.12424270808696747,
-0.5931954383850098,
0.4955500662326813,
0.07118644565343857,
-0.4206092655658722,
-0.3259371221065521,
-0.29739925265312195,
-0.8085580468177795,
-0.5112545490264893,
0.5712377429008484,
0.43473976850509644,
-0.5860851407051086,
0.4957728087902069,
-0.660053551197052,
-0.5593091249465942,
-0.849148690700531,
0.31049051880836487,
0.05013454705476761,
0.23602217435836792,
0.275325745344162,
-0.19842669367790222,
-0.4633232057094574,
-0.9954800605773926,
-0.3147643208503723,
0.1989108920097351,
0.014040406793355942,
0.34078729152679443,
0.40190389752388,
-0.4864047169685364,
1.1792997121810913,
-0.3614635765552521,
-0.3703018128871918,
-0.3307483494281769,
0.18311531841754913,
0.40172743797302246,
0.4286736249923706,
0.20413024723529816,
-0.6800639033317566,
-0.5895554423332214,
-0.02943992055952549,
-0.6594460606575012,
-0.374142050743103,
0.03946569561958313,
-0.2006816565990448,
0.5175806283950806,
0.31302812695503235,
-0.5799339413642883,
0.6540229320526123,
0.5768943428993225,
-0.19313392043113708,
0.35458624362945557,
-0.007945884950459003,
0.23282486200332642,
-0.8584111332893372,
0.24112044274806976,
-0.23472388088703156,
-0.16055923700332642,
-0.4265996813774109,
-0.0911422148346901,
-0.09137940406799316,
-0.0005432963371276855,
-0.2483624964952469,
0.7476708292961121,
-0.4160873591899872,
0.35081493854522705,
-0.5830580592155457,
-0.22638168931007385,
-0.1534588634967804,
0.1385924220085144,
-0.044782206416130066,
0.94533371925354,
0.405272513628006,
-0.46585968136787415,
0.2772063910961151,
0.3710695803165436,
-0.6724824905395508,
0.075483538210392,
-0.5808051824569702,
0.28746652603149414,
-0.3223732113838196,
0.1891026645898819,
-0.9908680319786072,
-0.1845313310623169,
0.053415268659591675,
-0.3501167893409729,
0.2409352958202362,
-0.08712879568338394,
-0.7001899480819702,
0.04607773944735527,
-0.25801900029182434,
0.4539354741573334,
0.5471956133842468,
-0.43298643827438354,
0.4087389409542084,
0.4481689929962158,
-0.5958262085914612,
-0.7860835790634155,
-0.38620424270629883,
0.3995339870452881,
-0.21991044282913208,
-0.49416473507881165,
0.2147706300020218,
0.19232922792434692,
-0.4375380575656891,
-0.01871844194829464,
-0.253699392080307,
0.12891870737075806,
0.10216642171144485,
0.5048232078552246,
0.11983878165483475,
0.07029113918542862,
0.2531265318393707,
0.003682818729430437,
-0.11154661327600479,
-0.007044685538858175,
-0.44809669256210327,
0.77359539270401,
0.14757660031318665,
-0.22476786375045776,
-0.39358797669410706,
0.39377036690711975,
0.7411224246025085,
-0.0848907008767128,
1.1886327266693115,
0.40172335505485535,
-0.5432698726654053,
-0.3597460389137268,
-0.698563814163208,
0.16282811760902405,
-0.4571956694126129,
0.49744313955307007,
-0.30143967270851135,
-0.7229573726654053,
0.35045668482780457,
-0.2638972997665405,
-0.05910423398017883,
0.4352107644081116,
0.5388643145561218,
0.05781861022114754,
0.92022705078125,
0.6037680506706238,
-0.8681307435035706,
-0.059532225131988525,
-0.14179250597953796,
0.21775248646736145,
-0.383643239736557,
-0.14198310673236847,
-0.6406567692756653,
-0.4708554148674011,
-0.7311015725135803,
-0.37175509333610535,
0.29618632793426514,
-0.10998889803886414,
-0.2621012032032013,
-0.03680504485964775,
-0.06568532437086105,
0.4617235064506531,
0.4708583950996399,
0.07773339748382568,
0.5518367290496826,
0.5428457260131836,
-0.07303358614444733,
-0.23548372089862823,
-0.44892603158950806,
-1.2429035902023315,
1.3126271963119507,
0.2606472074985504,
0.5296143889427185,
0.3569452464580536,
0.5426977872848511,
0.7306724190711975,
0.45132163166999817,
-0.5611048936843872,
0.5242409110069275,
-0.057147037237882614,
-0.56331866979599,
-0.2522318363189697,
-0.30020570755004883,
-1.0069248676300049,
-0.10023500770330429,
0.020821548998355865,
-0.38904210925102234,
-0.3764256536960602,
-0.2197590172290802,
0.11151455342769623,
0.1464768648147583,
-0.1777820885181427,
0.42353948950767517,
-0.136252760887146,
-0.5371765494346619,
-0.33805030584335327,
-0.3784094750881195,
0.09324996918439865,
-0.4867216944694519,
0.48254913091659546,
-0.3202342689037323,
-0.440110445022583,
0.7889784574508667,
-0.6028982400894165,
0.4962337613105774,
-0.02557443268597126,
-0.4303663372993469,
0.5304052829742432,
0.3436841070652008,
0.6508008241653442,
0.10889371484518051,
-0.3394348919391632,
0.6176510453224182,
-0.23048320412635803,
-0.7082708477973938,
-0.14316140115261078,
0.821021556854248,
-0.9003217220306396,
-0.49466660618782043,
-0.6517348289489746,
-0.6959433555603027,
-0.3144935369491577,
0.02813173644244671,
0.06984487920999527,
0.332221120595932,
-0.3815830945968628,
-0.0008001868845894933,
0.39942750334739685,
-0.523385226726532,
0.48342910408973694,
0.8111664056777954,
-0.09756576269865036,
-0.4683276116847992,
0.9255006909370422,
0.32453590631484985,
-0.1525888293981552,
0.2317253202199936,
-0.19203807413578033,
-0.31574922800064087,
-0.9719578623771667,
-0.5035839080810547,
0.2841233015060425,
-0.5294101238250732,
-0.32341834902763367,
-0.6283373832702637,
-0.21482442319393158,
-0.1720242202281952,
-0.009470699355006218,
-0.10722453147172928,
-0.13207171857357025,
-0.07155293971300125,
-0.029368357732892036,
0.5702140927314758,
0.7638698220252991,
-0.03636780381202698,
0.23542504012584686,
-1.1870661973953247,
0.3013749420642853,
0.08818031847476959,
0.1988358497619629,
0.12120842188596725,
-0.6916295289993286,
-0.371660053730011,
0.31523397564888,
-0.1809457391500473,
-0.6264745593070984,
0.7800512313842773,
0.2966747283935547,
0.29130426049232483,
0.4061438739299774,
-0.03237459063529968,
0.5085204243659973,
-0.5726159811019897,
0.754351794719696,
-0.45337975025177,
-0.9475688338279724,
0.5059799551963806,
-0.37916290760040283,
0.40861907601356506,
0.8317793607711792,
0.8307207226753235,
-0.8146790862083435,
-0.2592269480228424,
-0.6290328502655029,
-1.0708566904067993,
0.6354002952575684,
0.32667168974876404,
0.3396478295326233,
0.09434423595666885,
0.41042521595954895,
0.5302485823631287,
0.4676252603530884,
-0.358773410320282,
-0.39572417736053467,
0.32950645685195923,
-0.6707636713981628,
0.016844095662236214,
-0.4500291347503662,
0.10236304253339767,
-0.030478643253445625,
0.9209991693496704,
-0.08394972234964371,
-0.12576143443584442,
0.029868029057979584,
-0.41611921787261963,
0.0254753977060318,
0.2615056037902832,
0.1790223866701126,
0.7515879273414612,
-0.14802151918411255,
0.25229039788246155,
0.3099248707294464,
-0.943572461605072,
0.4001074433326721,
-0.054630350321531296,
-0.4187816381454468,
0.20034778118133545,
0.4897267520427704,
0.18029232323169708,
-0.4568558633327484,
-1.2883237600326538,
0.3043196499347687,
0.10811738669872284,
0.2103927582502365,
-0.37824517488479614,
-0.1712707132101059,
0.0717635452747345,
-0.1291656345129013,
0.8121621608734131,
-0.22620846331119537,
0.04047224298119545,
-0.4448794722557068,
0.3917081654071808,
0.4884193539619446,
-0.13767200708389282,
-0.05496515706181526,
0.18415561318397522,
0.1115049347281456,
-0.06138278543949127,
0.8102025389671326,
-0.11013863980770111,
-0.6178320646286011,
0.4836404621601105,
0.23695339262485504,
0.5280444622039795,
0.0035523350816220045,
0.15680067241191864,
0.3994036316871643,
0.24745799601078033,
-0.028924189507961273,
0.3585503399372101,
0.07118000090122223,
-0.8704280257225037,
-0.42902982234954834,
-0.9463827610015869,
-0.34019336104393005,
0.45147621631622314,
-0.2992381453514099,
0.17212481796741486,
-0.38300684094429016,
0.07035017758607864,
-0.5154337286949158,
0.2935910224914551,
-0.6406874656677246,
0.3292925953865051,
0.37371912598609924,
0.8885955214500427,
-0.7342865467071533,
0.8072363138198853,
0.4758313298225403,
-0.11869794130325317,
-0.5036556720733643,
-0.02428443729877472,
-0.08127356320619583,
-1.1337887048721313,
0.7463414669036865,
0.31248700618743896,
-0.01903494819998741,
0.039685916155576706,
-0.8988167643547058,
-1.033397912979126,
0.7935271859169006,
0.16595353186130524,
-0.5811121463775635,
0.4712652564048767,
0.711068868637085,
0.4763846695423126,
-0.22825485467910767,
0.06743457913398743,
0.7763240337371826,
0.4481810927391052,
0.03655759617686272,
-0.5503348112106323,
0.12828503549098969,
-0.20302577316761017,
-0.02044505439698696,
0.1998119354248047,
-0.528056800365448,
0.5624567270278931,
-0.03169240429997444,
-0.2851696014404297,
0.30754992365837097,
0.6913020610809326,
0.3108403980731964,
0.10771441459655762,
0.16066475212574005,
0.8139564394950867,
0.7372958660125732,
-0.07611560076475143,
0.7169745564460754,
-0.5172497034072876,
0.03768473491072655,
0.9446284770965576,
-0.47526854276657104,
0.6961385011672974,
0.2300957441329956,
-0.28030484914779663,
0.4347744286060333,
0.36146432161331177,
0.15999242663383484,
0.4377261996269226,
0.4367636442184448,
-0.714871346950531,
-0.0651569813489914,
-0.7891143560409546,
-0.3720145523548126,
0.723408043384552,
0.3327144682407379,
-0.3634513318538666,
-0.07692670077085495,
-0.22709237039089203,
0.42852285504341125,
0.135557159781456,
-0.3538745045661926,
0.6446517705917358,
-0.12905195355415344,
-0.41312482953071594,
0.4745011627674103,
0.25070106983184814,
0.7170109152793884,
-0.5975170731544495,
-0.17872726917266846,
-0.5322822332382202,
0.06107678636908531,
-0.18554691970348358,
-0.4468096196651459,
0.18310964107513428,
0.3564716875553131,
-0.08384662121534348,
-0.18568675220012665,
0.5728986263275146,
-0.49217134714126587,
-0.7088375091552734,
-0.11412053555250168,
0.6741222143173218,
0.2632017433643341,
-0.2642110586166382,
-0.2973843216896057,
0.35983216762542725,
0.16548539698123932,
-0.11432651430368423,
0.2763899564743042,
0.6543547511100769,
0.0825682058930397,
0.7797434329986572,
0.6699231266975403,
0.5942138433456421,
-0.20862506330013275,
-0.18544097244739532,
0.5575630068778992,
-0.9858220219612122,
-0.2177777886390686,
-1.0555906295776367,
0.3527793288230896,
-0.01855172961950302,
-0.09414122998714447,
0.9145303964614868,
0.6429975628852844,
0.6884952187538147,
0.05406072363257408,
1.1265833377838135,
0.12700927257537842,
0.6191052794456482,
-0.4645529091358185,
0.8890044689178467,
-0.3643026649951935,
0.24130158126354218,
-0.21264785528182983,
-0.8728668689727783,
0.005578170996159315,
0.46273285150527954,
0.03852051869034767,
0.07232501357793808,
0.438178688287735,
0.8875314593315125,
0.3540392220020294,
0.0930003821849823,
0.1107250526547432,
0.24620744585990906,
0.1750129759311676,
0.5882817506790161,
0.8543140292167664,
-0.6000598073005676,
0.3381972014904022,
0.05109008401632309,
-0.11564682424068451,
-0.09926731884479523,
-0.8887194395065308,
-0.4923422634601593,
-0.49673736095428467,
-0.372442364692688,
-0.3494943082332611,
-0.06460726261138916,
1.0059701204299927,
0.32716819643974304,
-1.1117403507232666,
-0.24877816438674927,
-0.07098860293626785,
0.14361682534217834,
0.06756728887557983,
-0.1782894730567932,
0.507183849811554,
0.046381205320358276,
-0.8981873393058777,
0.26277947425842285,
0.11934348940849304,
0.2975409924983978,
-0.09910253435373306,
-0.11876245588064194,
-0.15674784779548645,
0.18038074672222137,
0.5185913443565369,
0.03176525607705116,
-0.3781193196773529,
-0.11507203429937363,
-0.1751861274242401,
-0.31399625539779663,
-0.10556691884994507,
0.4219854772090912,
-1.045756459236145,
0.1563616693019867,
0.15941070020198822,
0.8975397944450378,
0.23799118399620056,
0.041940346360206604,
0.5727756023406982,
-0.5467193126678467,
0.17822407186031342,
0.20835468173027039,
0.2918095588684082,
0.6047853827476501,
-0.1368291676044464,
0.655397891998291,
0.1531573086977005,
-0.4707816541194916,
-0.6274545192718506,
0.08715971559286118,
-0.6232299208641052,
-0.22139419615268707,
1.2962181568145752,
0.02027703821659088,
0.13446807861328125,
-0.42153599858283997,
-0.5488054752349854,
0.28716209530830383,
-0.4826096296310425,
0.9464663863182068,
1.1065839529037476,
0.35260510444641113,
0.2138897329568863,
-0.45771369338035583,
0.5573323369026184,
0.5625141263008118,
-0.6020306348800659,
0.15564775466918945,
0.5705716609954834,
0.06681618094444275,
-0.020043781027197838,
0.28319206833839417,
0.012888923287391663,
-0.13734015822410583,
-0.239204540848732,
0.09732557088136673,
0.03426136448979378,
-0.2564551532268524,
-0.4792312979698181,
0.4684390723705292,
0.37720292806625366,
-0.08642583340406418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18655v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18655v1
|
Revealing the Parametric Knowledge of Language Models: A Unified Framework for Attribution Methods
| 2024-04-29T12:38:26 | 2024-04-29T12:38:26 |
Haeun Yu, Pepa Atanasova, Isabelle Augenstein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Language Models (LMs) acquire parametric knowledge from their training
process, embedding it within their weights. The increasing scalability of LMs,
however, poses significant challenges for understanding a model's inner
workings and further for updating or correcting this embedded knowledge without
the significant cost of retraining. This underscores the importance of
unveiling exactly what knowledge is stored and its association with specific
model components. Instance Attribution (IA) and Neuron Attribution (NA) offer
insights into this training-acquired knowledge, though they have not been
compared systematically. Our study introduces a novel evaluation framework to
quantify and compare the knowledge revealed by IA and NA. To align the results
of the methods we introduce the attribution method NA-Instances to apply NA for
retrieving influential training instances, and IA-Neurons to discover important
neurons of influential instances discovered by IA. We further propose a
comprehensive list of faithfulness tests to evaluate the comprehensiveness and
sufficiency of the explanations provided by both methods. Through extensive
experiments and analysis, we demonstrate that NA generally reveals more diverse
and comprehensive information regarding the LM's parametric knowledge compared
to IA. Nevertheless, IA provides unique and valuable insights into the LM's
parametric knowledge, which are not revealed by NA. Our findings further
suggest the potential of a synergistic approach of combining the diverse
findings of IA and NA for a more holistic understanding of an LM's parametric
knowledge.
|
[
-0.07959438860416412,
-0.4269951581954956,
0.7000635266304016,
0.0271307323127985,
0.014538438990712166,
-0.05945618450641632,
-0.39551830291748047,
-0.14425456523895264,
-0.005527992267161608,
0.3708561658859253,
-0.2230835258960724,
-0.47922617197036743,
-0.34856951236724854,
-0.3302574157714844,
-0.6190144419670105,
0.8314574360847473,
0.010659079067409039,
0.1798858344554901,
-0.7053102850914001,
-0.4221985638141632,
-0.019544625654816628,
-0.6025640964508057,
-0.6078568696975708,
-0.8917157053947449,
0.6777101159095764,
0.22557371854782104,
0.5859603881835938,
0.5712923407554626,
0.24770130217075348,
0.3018453121185303,
-0.10111680626869202,
-0.21329574286937714,
-0.04608188197016716,
-0.1492880880832672,
-0.32597288489341736,
-0.6725758910179138,
-0.31782066822052,
-0.071174256503582,
0.7172712683677673,
0.8136076331138611,
-0.45297983288764954,
0.4927801787853241,
0.3012603521347046,
0.5226805806159973,
-0.8940513730049133,
0.1198044866323471,
-0.750390887260437,
-0.1999727189540863,
-0.13455641269683838,
-0.30182984471321106,
-0.4033287763595581,
-0.38766801357269287,
0.028693940490484238,
-0.4839218258857727,
0.23117871582508087,
-0.11589490622282028,
0.9423317909240723,
0.08917424082756042,
-0.4660278558731079,
-0.2754371464252472,
-0.5318454504013062,
1.0146609544754028,
-0.8126094937324524,
0.22441859543323517,
0.4995247423648834,
0.37172624468803406,
0.2063518613576889,
-0.6107750535011292,
-0.3511195778846741,
-0.3144948482513428,
-0.07452660799026489,
-0.26226240396499634,
-0.16801424324512482,
-0.10894383490085602,
-0.04976079985499382,
0.35698989033699036,
-0.3851305842399597,
0.04496711865067482,
-0.2271777242422104,
-0.31097856163978577,
0.48394596576690674,
0.10674873739480972,
0.4482252299785614,
-0.12400487065315247,
-0.29646891355514526,
-0.17754141986370087,
-0.774523913860321,
0.08969492465257645,
0.5581245422363281,
0.10675647854804993,
-0.14716558158397675,
0.32845813035964966,
-0.08521605283021927,
0.6550708413124084,
-0.2378382682800293,
0.06918543577194214,
0.28228437900543213,
-0.3352528512477875,
0.23004215955734253,
-0.09874172508716583,
1.0432300567626953,
0.23048223555088043,
0.5416997671127319,
-0.484438955783844,
-0.3658975660800934,
-0.06605210900306702,
0.3170216977596283,
-0.308788537979126,
-0.12066579610109329,
-0.34525343775749207,
-0.6427767872810364,
-0.5063705444335938,
-0.10240106284618378,
-0.7350500226020813,
-0.23159968852996826,
-0.2933587431907654,
0.46183109283447266,
-0.38745036721229553,
-0.4461631774902344,
0.024352917447686195,
-0.0835827887058258,
0.3066675662994385,
0.13058683276176453,
-1.0243470668792725,
0.5069037079811096,
0.61954265832901,
0.8358227014541626,
-0.18553824722766876,
-0.49970558285713196,
-0.05140019208192825,
0.1009768545627594,
-0.3661816418170929,
0.8591515421867371,
-0.41529715061187744,
0.23067134618759155,
0.1092151403427124,
-0.36283665895462036,
-0.034968212246894836,
-0.5974070429801941,
0.3327575922012329,
-0.49912339448928833,
-0.0964859277009964,
-0.4998275339603424,
-0.39148053526878357,
-0.24327664077281952,
0.03927144035696983,
-0.5446991920471191,
0.8224295377731323,
0.09025850892066956,
-0.6602895855903625,
0.5353609919548035,
-0.41875553131103516,
-0.07059474289417267,
-0.13106273114681244,
-0.49981603026390076,
-0.20391148328781128,
0.38244739174842834,
0.25453341007232666,
0.4147411584854126,
-0.7328227758407593,
0.46531474590301514,
-0.3389262855052948,
0.08459765464067459,
0.3572137653827667,
-0.6402458548545837,
1.0483570098876953,
-0.015588833019137383,
-0.2647743821144104,
0.03440168499946594,
-0.9056711792945862,
0.12330712378025055,
0.13954496383666992,
-0.19236868619918823,
-0.6268829107284546,
0.12910667061805725,
-0.09640569984912872,
0.10524580627679825,
0.1744227409362793,
-0.5255877375602722,
-0.09685081988573074,
-0.265920490026474,
0.4292985200881958,
0.6548451781272888,
0.0051942612044513226,
0.6917958855628967,
-0.21439893543720245,
0.5794533491134644,
-0.10101433098316193,
0.07203171402215958,
0.0799378976225853,
-0.2582551836967468,
-0.7068494558334351,
0.33024710416793823,
0.3238358199596405,
0.1162838265299797,
-0.5730762481689453,
0.2733193635940552,
-0.29507020115852356,
-0.6074014902114868,
-0.43024811148643494,
0.22823333740234375,
0.696792721748352,
0.5528640747070312,
0.3207322359085083,
-0.36280232667922974,
-0.2154415398836136,
-1.1933567523956299,
-0.5913975834846497,
-0.4530055820941925,
-0.09411659836769104,
0.19186313450336456,
0.5318779349327087,
0.3328053057193756,
0.9090141654014587,
-0.21957816183567047,
0.06515411287546158,
-0.2567627429962158,
0.48170244693756104,
0.023669466376304626,
0.5531722903251648,
0.6180064678192139,
-0.4074372947216034,
-0.3799896240234375,
0.10046495497226715,
-1.0296262502670288,
-0.13499653339385986,
-0.1091887503862381,
0.19803979992866516,
-0.2523564100265503,
0.6094062924385071,
-0.16248027980327606,
0.33461982011795044,
0.4795033037662506,
-0.2134893834590912,
0.5370242595672607,
-0.33967551589012146,
0.002055507618933916,
-0.8300819993019104,
-0.015987684950232506,
0.0038227452896535397,
-0.06129962205886841,
-0.6165212988853455,
-0.01799899712204933,
0.38521453738212585,
0.09014587849378586,
-0.30269506573677063,
0.5996924042701721,
-0.7308622002601624,
-0.13522610068321228,
-0.06772052496671677,
-0.07193635404109955,
-0.0599190853536129,
0.6298904418945312,
-0.10016920417547226,
0.7036697864532471,
0.7520996332168579,
-0.5388323664665222,
0.31505900621414185,
0.08903059363365173,
-0.7176306247711182,
0.18198208510875702,
-0.8323322534561157,
0.15366576611995697,
-0.003988340031355619,
-0.15178997814655304,
-0.8375481367111206,
0.03302380442619324,
0.03969716280698776,
-0.5980462431907654,
0.06689192354679108,
0.00004913046723231673,
-0.6074317097663879,
0.008175836876034737,
0.031534045934677124,
0.7130090594291687,
0.43851783871650696,
-0.44915416836738586,
0.7616158127784729,
0.3039972186088562,
-0.07400798052549362,
-0.5979245901107788,
-0.7442407011985779,
-0.03713398799300194,
-0.522074818611145,
-0.4573630690574646,
0.3454008400440216,
0.42560115456581116,
-0.45249584317207336,
0.036974258720874786,
-0.20007286965847015,
-0.36850348114967346,
0.00445985933765769,
0.05420709773898125,
-0.1564445048570633,
-0.5382627248764038,
0.23308317363262177,
-0.12092467397451401,
-0.2769949436187744,
0.560651421546936,
0.08024550974369049,
0.4937649071216583,
-0.40805503726005554,
-0.7890204787254333,
-0.48981860280036926,
0.19869723916053772,
0.49627822637557983,
-0.3197224736213684,
0.8870673179626465,
0.44016021490097046,
-0.40726572275161743,
-0.19718939065933228,
-0.6590325236320496,
-0.41400131583213806,
-0.4240414500236511,
0.38572800159454346,
-0.2731289565563202,
-0.2915664315223694,
0.966965913772583,
0.07067449390888214,
-0.2644176483154297,
0.48701420426368713,
0.5180495381355286,
0.3270568549633026,
0.967958927154541,
0.7760047316551208,
-0.2571406960487366,
0.4745792746543884,
-0.19482135772705078,
0.07984799891710281,
-0.8776453733444214,
-0.41359877586364746,
-0.6716158986091614,
-0.2396574765443802,
-0.020898668095469475,
-0.0701717957854271,
0.1056632399559021,
0.20108403265476227,
-0.1564815789461136,
0.48241350054740906,
-0.14378204941749573,
0.6156042814254761,
0.5160172581672668,
0.23553034663200378,
0.3555009663105011,
0.058918341994285583,
-0.13379789888858795,
-0.03803945705294609,
-0.8888988494873047,
-0.5947990417480469,
1.5676484107971191,
0.4296431839466095,
0.8185570240020752,
0.17628967761993408,
0.5590188503265381,
-0.020734932273626328,
0.256537526845932,
-0.6353511214256287,
0.49747857451438904,
0.17813949286937714,
-0.7221924662590027,
-0.2826354205608368,
-0.39635470509529114,
-0.6445722579956055,
0.1018897220492363,
0.04407617077231407,
-1.1041498184204102,
0.4481298625469208,
0.12923352420330048,
-0.48763713240623474,
0.3339104950428009,
-0.6488181948661804,
0.9021785259246826,
-0.3402957022190094,
-0.36733993887901306,
-0.2831115126609802,
-0.5369511246681213,
0.25344064831733704,
-0.16667333245277405,
0.05423520505428314,
-0.015044746920466423,
-0.25682416558265686,
1.059918999671936,
-0.2678202688694,
0.7905893325805664,
-0.06570308655500412,
-0.25296324491500854,
0.24911119043827057,
-0.07229393720626831,
0.2784290313720703,
0.1842583566904068,
-0.2687864601612091,
0.22808963060379028,
-0.12866349518299103,
-0.30032476782798767,
-1.0881245136260986,
0.6193347573280334,
-0.6688668131828308,
-0.4088994562625885,
-0.36515533924102783,
-0.7585135102272034,
-0.3005819618701935,
0.00433703325688839,
0.3619450330734253,
0.7197856903076172,
-0.10630283504724503,
0.5354533195495605,
0.5856173634529114,
-0.17331664264202118,
0.2656744122505188,
0.5245728492736816,
-0.26833224296569824,
-0.09900302439928055,
0.9383533596992493,
-0.06618808209896088,
0.5408904552459717,
0.2175956666469574,
0.289597749710083,
-0.29024261236190796,
-0.7223818302154541,
-0.21692706644535065,
0.3053891658782959,
-0.9293962121009827,
-0.0879996120929718,
-0.41999128460884094,
-0.044065434485673904,
-0.22199644148349762,
-0.12058376520872116,
-0.6534284949302673,
-0.20552422106266022,
-0.16030798852443695,
0.14711466431617737,
0.2500685453414917,
0.7182626724243164,
-0.17454025149345398,
0.5628204345703125,
-0.5205974578857422,
0.05773050710558891,
0.22573423385620117,
0.21320536732673645,
0.38259974122047424,
-0.6412240862846375,
-0.3320142924785614,
0.17995518445968628,
-0.3061968684196472,
-1.2044012546539307,
0.34192025661468506,
0.3733677268028259,
0.974345326423645,
0.6387236714363098,
-0.24766847491264343,
0.6224249005317688,
-0.30819982290267944,
0.6758920550346375,
0.2596854567527771,
-0.9491615891456604,
0.3643604815006256,
-0.3952418565750122,
-0.009103656746447086,
0.7742062211036682,
0.46562397480010986,
-0.26208728551864624,
-0.2417503297328949,
-0.9057183265686035,
-0.8995082378387451,
0.8843898773193359,
0.20464126765727997,
0.21168877184391022,
0.1770542562007904,
0.5266737937927246,
-0.03292282298207283,
0.19119666516780853,
-0.8997336030006409,
-0.4445081651210785,
0.1337125599384308,
-0.17598935961723328,
-0.32123199105262756,
-0.18137168884277344,
-0.23145274817943573,
-0.6134002208709717,
0.4892536997795105,
-0.045285895466804504,
0.3452867865562439,
-0.21493953466415405,
-0.3377905786037445,
0.05894119292497635,
0.10322145372629166,
0.32369834184646606,
1.0745705366134644,
-0.14108847081661224,
0.24175681173801422,
0.3232705891132355,
-0.005533779505640268,
0.2316237837076187,
-0.34720271825790405,
0.02173183485865593,
0.20034024119377136,
0.7030786871910095,
0.7843193411827087,
0.37177348136901855,
-0.44049927592277527,
0.805446445941925,
0.1258237212896347,
-0.30978649854660034,
-0.2773593068122864,
-0.07456604391336441,
0.303294837474823,
0.188551127910614,
0.21821646392345428,
0.05494802072644234,
0.2487765997648239,
-0.7110804915428162,
0.33210793137550354,
0.4336535632610321,
-0.5539748668670654,
-0.44982683658599854,
0.3861830532550812,
-0.16753268241882324,
-0.24348515272140503,
0.48687824606895447,
0.044260501861572266,
-0.5041825771331787,
0.7616824507713318,
0.6291771531105042,
0.879875898361206,
-0.33153143525123596,
0.40726545453071594,
0.27892664074897766,
0.12806232273578644,
-0.22606541216373444,
-0.0928398072719574,
-0.2278584986925125,
-0.9206525087356567,
-0.2283627837896347,
-0.6230410933494568,
-0.07804536819458008,
0.3836563229560852,
-1.2501927614212036,
-0.009584995917975903,
-0.21197405457496643,
-0.035716306418180466,
0.15216243267059326,
-0.45090293884277344,
-0.43242332339286804,
-0.08871202170848846,
-0.11107292771339417,
0.6463435888290405,
-1.2108595371246338,
0.8106944561004639,
0.7787790298461914,
-0.6631602048873901,
-0.9173225164413452,
0.18429496884346008,
0.05791390687227249,
-1.1179702281951904,
0.8870310187339783,
-0.14668600261211395,
-0.0183761827647686,
0.004623487126082182,
-0.3396063446998596,
-0.9412791728973389,
0.9656445980072021,
0.5769550800323486,
-0.24311873316764832,
-0.211732417345047,
0.12456465512514114,
0.5357186794281006,
-0.5152996778488159,
0.4915502071380615,
0.5331697463989258,
0.1869179755449295,
-0.19773513078689575,
-0.7858734726905823,
0.05117389187216759,
-0.2999710738658905,
0.174261212348938,
0.24670426547527313,
-0.17785482108592987,
0.8977746963500977,
-0.024012243375182152,
-0.06534472852945328,
-0.10034863650798798,
0.8250014185905457,
0.09358540177345276,
0.0782022699713707,
0.48282384872436523,
0.3422917425632477,
0.3965504765510559,
0.08022630959749222,
0.8949142694473267,
-0.3201230764389038,
0.42361006140708923,
1.122223138809204,
0.22209973633289337,
0.8254951238632202,
0.9237151145935059,
-0.2886407673358917,
0.6276113986968994,
0.4366166889667511,
0.1419263780117035,
0.6849591732025146,
0.43777957558631897,
-0.2905336618423462,
-0.3787813186645508,
-0.015662916004657745,
-0.28649088740348816,
0.3508950471878052,
0.29215601086616516,
-0.6231648325920105,
-0.6346917748451233,
0.12931513786315918,
-0.0855497494339943,
0.2696577310562134,
-0.24394376575946808,
0.8507069945335388,
0.26859140396118164,
-0.5896031260490417,
0.7858697772026062,
-0.1469099223613739,
0.4820736050605774,
-0.711886465549469,
0.0914463922381401,
-0.06466484814882278,
0.3676382899284363,
-0.10440436750650406,
-0.6937230825424194,
0.5482478141784668,
-0.052885618060827255,
-0.18329019844532013,
-0.3190283179283142,
0.6729576587677002,
-0.40487849712371826,
-0.32361361384391785,
0.4701792299747467,
0.5829949378967285,
0.25350016355514526,
-0.4257829487323761,
-0.8390097618103027,
-0.19856730103492737,
0.12369014322757721,
-0.3994154930114746,
0.39055389165878296,
0.4956020712852478,
-0.1164187639951706,
0.932558536529541,
0.32656580209732056,
0.30704471468925476,
0.08668510615825653,
0.11709972470998764,
0.8547126054763794,
-0.3418874740600586,
-0.06460641324520111,
-0.961919903755188,
0.5576971173286438,
-0.08068350702524185,
-0.5292102694511414,
0.7682626247406006,
0.36920374631881714,
0.6420478224754333,
0.009641142562031746,
0.7022585272789001,
0.025564299896359444,
0.16812041401863098,
-0.5474169850349426,
0.8857374787330627,
-0.9137077331542969,
0.3881472647190094,
-0.16399134695529938,
-0.9373984336853027,
-0.09950178116559982,
0.7587481737136841,
-0.6336719393730164,
0.027397628873586655,
0.9488353729248047,
0.8425914645195007,
-0.2711239159107208,
-0.10219807922840118,
0.24605196714401245,
-0.13567395508289337,
-0.01494097150862217,
0.515059232711792,
0.8331500887870789,
-0.546604335308075,
0.5576669573783875,
-0.41371339559555054,
-0.33294105529785156,
0.13110293447971344,
-0.7972533106803894,
-0.8308473229408264,
-0.8840685486793518,
-0.2667299509048462,
-0.03580012917518616,
0.22293289005756378,
0.5480896234512329,
0.4776996672153473,
-0.839644193649292,
-0.5220102071762085,
-0.5194516181945801,
-0.14347660541534424,
-0.3038064241409302,
-0.18775063753128052,
0.4578859210014343,
-0.5767862200737,
-0.32869166135787964,
0.301746129989624,
-0.046089667826890945,
-0.20126226544380188,
-0.4184408187866211,
-0.1859743744134903,
-0.2951405346393585,
-0.1430259495973587,
0.15403790771961212,
0.24720174074172974,
-0.8157198429107666,
-0.10162662714719772,
-0.17328020930290222,
0.010676729492843151,
-0.005258390214294195,
0.9941893815994263,
-0.530165433883667,
0.16415204107761383,
0.637718141078949,
0.6081740260124207,
0.18603841960430145,
-0.12722912430763245,
1.1098703145980835,
-0.6465876698493958,
0.13829590380191803,
0.2411363422870636,
0.4859256446361542,
0.20388095080852509,
-0.13039924204349518,
0.19410498440265656,
-0.022162243723869324,
-0.6534096598625183,
-0.8422286510467529,
0.3529805839061737,
-0.6497079730033875,
-0.22000457346439362,
1.3030396699905396,
-0.42837467789649963,
-0.27802321314811707,
-0.21748121082782745,
0.31929925084114075,
0.3606778383255005,
-0.33894193172454834,
0.5776210427284241,
0.89972984790802,
0.1171308234333992,
-0.1907670646905899,
-0.7047771215438843,
0.691683292388916,
0.8710503578186035,
-0.5345236659049988,
0.23165194690227509,
0.08101615309715271,
0.377803236246109,
0.30516517162323,
0.37887513637542725,
-0.26604169607162476,
0.018915660679340363,
0.1923425942659378,
0.287129670381546,
-0.02575448341667652,
-0.47382989525794983,
-0.5253252983093262,
0.07998935133218765,
0.18637864291667938,
-0.06371503323316574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02563v1
|
A cost minimization approach to fix the vocabulary size in a tokenizer for an End-to-End ASR system
| 2024-04-29T12:16:21 | 2024-04-29T12:16:21 |
Sunil Kumar Kopparapu, Ashish Panda
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
Unlike hybrid speech recognition systems where the use of tokens was
restricted to phones, biphones or triphones the choice of tokens in the
end-to-end ASR systems is derived from the text corpus of the training data.
The use of tokenization algorithms like Byte Pair Encoding (BPE) and WordPiece
is popular in identifying the tokens that are used in the overall training
process of the speech recognition system. Popular toolkits, like ESPNet use a
pre-defined vocabulary size (number of tokens) for these tokenization
algorithms, but there is no discussion on how vocabulary size was derived. In
this paper, we build a cost function, assuming the tokenization process to be a
black-box to enable choosing the number of tokens which might most benefit
building an end-to-end ASR. We show through experiments on LibriSpeech 100 hour
set that the performance of an end-to-end ASR system improves when the number
of tokens are chosen carefully.
|
[
-0.5939707159996033,
-0.1014937311410904,
-0.26837480068206787,
0.002031985204666853,
-0.6754125356674194,
0.2758192718029022,
-0.26776963472366333,
-0.6309712529182434,
0.5027288198471069,
0.14132310450077057,
-0.16073393821716309,
0.2505251169204712,
-0.5195496082305908,
0.1282639056444168,
-0.2676984667778015,
0.9809101223945618,
-0.05682506412267685,
0.13411711156368256,
0.023066475987434387,
-0.2250712364912033,
-0.34772688150405884,
-0.6737546920776367,
-1.1084742546081543,
-0.24248206615447998,
0.3352985978126526,
0.4504743218421936,
0.45443829894065857,
0.8585336208343506,
0.5136613249778748,
0.25897398591041565,
-0.435080349445343,
0.17939604818820953,
-0.2005762755870819,
-0.3901362717151642,
-0.16873759031295776,
-0.31769534945487976,
-0.172504261136055,
-0.15916092693805695,
0.4009310007095337,
0.779303789138794,
0.048506446182727814,
0.5558284521102905,
-0.1275782585144043,
0.45431050658226013,
-0.5889943838119507,
-0.35085129737854004,
-0.6055813431739807,
0.02349739335477352,
-0.25945591926574707,
-0.38419121503829956,
-0.33264175057411194,
0.27274197340011597,
0.10692034661769867,
-0.45619773864746094,
0.06816935539245605,
0.40863698720932007,
0.790260910987854,
0.37223702669143677,
-0.22713588178157806,
-0.3898818790912628,
-0.8257392048835754,
0.6852032542228699,
-0.46396031975746155,
0.5377606749534607,
0.2161535918712616,
0.08430418372154236,
-0.041994884610176086,
-0.4682382643222809,
-0.659951388835907,
0.0969124436378479,
-0.07186733186244965,
0.09077176451683044,
-0.19822996854782104,
0.3559637665748596,
0.30913469195365906,
0.352447509765625,
-0.5473372936248779,
0.2096412628889084,
-0.867670476436615,
-0.4775896966457367,
0.43002116680145264,
-0.25833258032798767,
0.25846990942955017,
-0.024112539365887642,
-0.5064265727996826,
0.08664532005786896,
-0.48769184947013855,
0.20147345960140228,
0.2666371166706085,
0.25187361240386963,
0.1258746087551117,
0.8040149211883545,
-0.09805605560541153,
0.6277642250061035,
0.19273638725280762,
-0.2617771625518799,
0.17447248101234436,
-0.4578206241130829,
-0.3715880811214447,
0.5709042549133301,
0.4630058705806732,
0.22048990428447723,
0.35799843072891235,
-0.511322557926178,
-0.46250179409980774,
0.40394020080566406,
0.15998928248882294,
-0.7008516192436218,
0.4738870859146118,
0.4842665195465088,
-0.4700559377670288,
-0.07112014293670654,
-0.12137628346681595,
-0.3047315776348114,
0.05870547890663147,
-0.33990049362182617,
0.8372408747673035,
-0.41737639904022217,
0.0024611628614366055,
0.3031954765319824,
-0.5432701706886292,
0.4579123854637146,
-0.0973767340183258,
-0.696310818195343,
0.7444847822189331,
0.44061416387557983,
1.3466074466705322,
-0.1563217043876648,
0.06371527910232544,
-0.7742941379547119,
0.26119500398635864,
-0.5770571827888489,
0.7433102130889893,
-0.11863180994987488,
-0.842736005783081,
-0.17698709666728973,
-0.34652164578437805,
0.12027282267808914,
-0.5968421697616577,
0.31880685687065125,
-0.49140599370002747,
0.11802902817726135,
-0.1770562380552292,
-0.795294463634491,
0.21848751604557037,
-0.2967004179954529,
-0.44958996772766113,
0.8681082129478455,
-0.2149742841720581,
-0.761225163936615,
0.6647453308105469,
-0.951475977897644,
-0.5756874680519104,
0.3527543544769287,
0.06653052568435669,
-0.3061550259590149,
0.29848209023475647,
-0.005475752521306276,
0.033730655908584595,
-0.11125854402780533,
-0.014836478978395462,
0.39497920870780945,
-0.7294673919677734,
0.18030956387519836,
-0.2774885594844818,
0.7000341415405273,
0.3987712264060974,
-0.3626098036766052,
0.20980077981948853,
-0.9134752154350281,
-0.2129804939031601,
-0.19339041411876678,
-0.7648237943649292,
-0.276408314704895,
0.05829499289393425,
0.1874845325946808,
0.024770746007561684,
0.44274213910102844,
-1.1306241750717163,
-0.40760257840156555,
-0.8711761236190796,
0.34190633893013,
0.6731300354003906,
-0.1121492013335228,
0.45541250705718994,
-0.4188995063304901,
0.23892264068126678,
0.03547917306423187,
0.14825209975242615,
0.04163304343819618,
-0.28546255826950073,
-1.152382254600525,
-0.4308728277683258,
0.6909123659133911,
0.5227391719818115,
-0.5869739651679993,
0.5958330035209656,
-0.4165744483470917,
-0.13411171734333038,
-0.4702622890472412,
-0.05392443761229515,
0.463509738445282,
0.19160839915275574,
0.26985836029052734,
-0.5255067348480225,
-0.6987524032592773,
-0.8148444294929504,
-0.070046566426754,
-0.10371106117963791,
-0.14068563282489777,
0.15733088552951813,
0.37732207775115967,
0.3165023922920227,
1.1958637237548828,
-0.08512513339519501,
-0.4987328350543976,
-0.17471128702163696,
-0.19592398405075073,
0.17113421857357025,
0.5041434168815613,
0.3961774408817291,
-0.5249848961830139,
-0.4971541464328766,
0.2562077045440674,
-0.07316050678491592,
-0.10711022466421127,
-0.165810689330101,
-0.026956357061862946,
0.310626745223999,
0.6814717054367065,
-0.4254976212978363,
0.593749463558197,
0.3437480926513672,
-0.46293655037879944,
0.42694488167762756,
-0.48735901713371277,
-0.4411998391151428,
-0.9853745698928833,
0.35223349928855896,
-0.14275306463241577,
-0.20688092708587646,
-0.6993241906166077,
-0.14887703955173492,
-0.21677103638648987,
-0.1825471818447113,
-0.28171584010124207,
0.7201232314109802,
-0.5653772950172424,
-0.45813626050949097,
-0.3505885899066925,
0.052349794656038284,
-0.21900683641433716,
0.599218487739563,
0.016249464824795723,
1.1151312589645386,
0.26131168007850647,
-0.5781974792480469,
0.24021562933921814,
0.2176869511604309,
0.01908135786652565,
0.45792943239212036,
-0.8281821012496948,
0.1300971359014511,
-0.29159608483314514,
0.12274254858493805,
-0.9230936169624329,
0.16328997910022736,
0.016834205016493797,
-0.7374976873397827,
0.34336820244789124,
-0.25219258666038513,
-0.46607303619384766,
-0.2590613067150116,
-0.33701881766319275,
0.2582550346851349,
0.4904464781284332,
-0.604092001914978,
0.569058358669281,
0.5682786703109741,
0.023041069507598877,
-0.5680809020996094,
-0.4870152473449707,
0.1419360339641571,
-0.21986615657806396,
-0.33952444791793823,
0.4798024892807007,
-0.25784391164779663,
0.03977638855576515,
-0.12493295967578888,
-0.4408608376979828,
0.1415276974439621,
-0.21117064356803894,
0.1328384131193161,
0.22066965699195862,
-0.10633017122745514,
0.42626452445983887,
0.06546026468276978,
-0.3890147805213928,
-0.1683415323495865,
-0.7315930724143982,
0.7371368408203125,
0.09635265171527863,
-0.273188978433609,
-0.23303769528865814,
0.33865100145339966,
0.4518549144268036,
-0.6343086361885071,
0.6532408595085144,
0.4341967701911926,
-0.6319772601127625,
-0.1569870412349701,
-0.6870314478874207,
-0.01530828420072794,
-0.5394086241722107,
0.36218059062957764,
-0.4318948984146118,
-0.7191933393478394,
0.6108134984970093,
0.040528181940317154,
0.2297201007604599,
0.11380790919065475,
0.4127785265445709,
0.19563491642475128,
0.34706035256385803,
0.3015230894088745,
-0.19770866632461548,
0.5371199250221252,
-0.12547890841960907,
0.25040680170059204,
-0.9027959108352661,
-0.2965947985649109,
-0.45527392625808716,
-0.5841174721717834,
-0.32785677909851074,
-0.5380286574363708,
0.48224136233329773,
-0.06090841442346573,
-0.25301802158355713,
0.3672439157962799,
-0.7258287072181702,
0.5262254476547241,
0.9754283428192139,
0.06414797902107239,
0.1685047298669815,
0.2463872730731964,
-0.17169541120529175,
0.39681124687194824,
-0.6306087970733643,
-0.15644246339797974,
1.1385105848312378,
0.18189705908298492,
0.14366963505744934,
0.32044777274131775,
0.8659629225730896,
0.22058741748332977,
-0.2084645926952362,
-1.0056277513504028,
0.5640416741371155,
-0.385318398475647,
-0.4922125041484833,
-0.7923123240470886,
-0.26128333806991577,
-1.011789321899414,
0.19774127006530762,
-0.0744861364364624,
-0.8627928495407104,
0.43035703897476196,
0.16282950341701508,
-0.4459855556488037,
0.38723090291023254,
-0.5564583539962769,
0.41691911220550537,
-0.09096384048461914,
0.004606565460562706,
-0.20496457815170288,
-0.5121350884437561,
-0.43233683705329895,
-0.1808890849351883,
0.1723913699388504,
0.2699960470199585,
-0.33850738406181335,
1.19954514503479,
-0.8259903192520142,
0.6432196497917175,
-0.29959362745285034,
0.43762707710266113,
0.4107131063938141,
-0.035978615283966064,
0.39859315752983093,
-0.3032546043395996,
0.13528858125209808,
0.1403293013572693,
0.17467981576919556,
-0.42828235030174255,
-0.22082871198654175,
0.3091236352920532,
-0.8408971428871155,
-0.41055187582969666,
-0.23399700224399567,
-0.2426643818616867,
-0.3245425522327423,
0.1492532193660736,
0.5166639685630798,
0.8918092250823975,
0.13534334301948547,
0.2550623416900635,
0.5597279667854309,
-0.3201349973678589,
0.7406031489372253,
0.2829410433769226,
0.1068492904305458,
-0.5057442784309387,
1.0961085557937622,
0.5421782732009888,
0.22810733318328857,
0.3679308593273163,
0.36641308665275574,
-0.3013966381549835,
-0.779315173625946,
-0.6280471086502075,
0.2868572175502777,
-0.49718764424324036,
-0.39500969648361206,
-0.4108862280845642,
-0.405713826417923,
-0.04840584844350815,
-0.4391223192214966,
-0.3757658004760742,
-0.5254996418952942,
-0.312876433134079,
-0.3557482957839966,
0.6022936105728149,
0.15920279920101166,
-0.39307406544685364,
0.6649470329284668,
-0.35884469747543335,
-0.094185970723629,
0.10476899147033691,
0.5329562425613403,
0.07016989588737488,
-0.887475848197937,
-0.44015008211135864,
-0.1984439641237259,
0.200917586684227,
-0.5879814028739929,
0.2523706555366516,
0.45492175221443176,
0.3045710325241089,
0.2752973139286041,
-0.049263760447502136,
0.7392875552177429,
-0.6300665140151978,
0.5723385810852051,
0.5445980429649353,
-1.1934864521026611,
0.3343096673488617,
-0.004272182006388903,
0.008433477953076363,
0.25860705971717834,
0.0004151556931901723,
-0.8483791947364807,
0.10310312360525131,
-0.47962599992752075,
-1.0131125450134277,
0.5660726428031921,
0.05836297944188118,
0.2114691287279129,
0.04220927506685257,
0.4585232436656952,
-0.15785333514213562,
0.16357697546482086,
-0.30053630471229553,
-0.25715675950050354,
-0.18303118646144867,
-0.35084599256515503,
0.00479500088840723,
-0.402133584022522,
0.13969917595386505,
-0.1736413985490799,
0.6745136976242065,
-0.2092856764793396,
0.4136740267276764,
0.14003199338912964,
-0.05484042316675186,
-0.21970264613628387,
0.22296281158924103,
0.4392404854297638,
0.27036377787590027,
-0.12068935483694077,
-0.12105578929185867,
0.4417964816093445,
-0.4103824496269226,
0.14482775330543518,
-0.07264196872711182,
-0.09905494749546051,
0.1538274735212326,
0.08299048990011215,
0.9479911923408508,
0.12580394744873047,
-0.862503707408905,
0.7484802007675171,
0.4843612611293793,
-0.2636748254299164,
-0.5398537516593933,
-0.2595762610435486,
-0.04010498896241188,
0.06379859894514084,
0.2572438716888428,
0.07730400562286377,
0.40284714102745056,
-0.1767527461051941,
0.3807883560657501,
0.6639731526374817,
-0.4494099020957947,
-0.08251704275608063,
0.5626804828643799,
0.22336946427822113,
-0.5646460652351379,
0.2682102918624878,
-0.21675628423690796,
-0.40094852447509766,
0.42958778142929077,
0.60105961561203,
0.6050844788551331,
-0.15209978818893433,
0.18873782455921173,
0.23338095843791962,
0.3414206802845001,
0.11359560489654541,
0.2855590283870697,
-0.03158179298043251,
-0.8959493637084961,
-0.5625438690185547,
-0.9160380363464355,
-0.2455494999885559,
-0.08140332996845245,
-0.6456579566001892,
0.49067360162734985,
-0.7486612796783447,
-0.2804184556007385,
0.13875868916511536,
0.03607092425227165,
-0.4677143096923828,
0.3768017292022705,
0.15053635835647583,
1.0357704162597656,
-0.38221627473831177,
0.48438605666160583,
0.606252133846283,
-0.4151792824268341,
-0.8767181634902954,
-0.5154289603233337,
-0.13335692882537842,
-0.7837303876876831,
0.6138734221458435,
-0.22049033641815186,
-0.18398690223693848,
0.10592632740736008,
-0.10135387629270554,
-1.11313796043396,
0.886529266834259,
-0.08612125366926193,
-0.49815633893013,
-0.23674137890338898,
0.1782442182302475,
0.49914005398750305,
-0.09677513688802719,
0.017694542184472084,
0.37875401973724365,
0.08282220363616943,
0.49010327458381653,
-1.3239765167236328,
-0.16300033032894135,
-0.19858814775943756,
0.257263720035553,
0.3642203211784363,
-0.6429111957550049,
0.5071670413017273,
-0.17499646544456482,
-0.24676062166690826,
-0.1497734934091568,
0.40382954478263855,
0.030296873301267624,
0.008309871889650822,
0.6062992811203003,
0.2916054427623749,
0.4674868881702423,
0.258164644241333,
0.6140021085739136,
-0.43051791191101074,
0.12065558135509491,
0.8263762593269348,
-0.05214812234044075,
1.0247079133987427,
0.7772945165634155,
-0.2956930696964264,
0.018644794821739197,
0.5933637022972107,
-0.05265207588672638,
0.4876444935798645,
0.6744311451911926,
-0.29180416464805603,
0.12752115726470947,
-0.12778796255588531,
0.008105876855552197,
0.5832850337028503,
0.3771461248397827,
-0.0690653920173645,
-0.007021353580057621,
0.08950094133615494,
-0.006015441846102476,
-0.3364737629890442,
-0.41592857241630554,
1.0771998167037964,
0.023078344762325287,
-0.12655624747276306,
0.5327415466308594,
0.11274465918540955,
0.958071231842041,
-0.6034474968910217,
0.514678418636322,
-0.23460502922534943,
-0.0008538024849258363,
-0.1770075410604477,
-0.05723783001303673,
0.44770753383636475,
0.007387205958366394,
-0.007250651251524687,
0.18227918446063995,
0.564929723739624,
-0.3418896496295929,
-0.5806015729904175,
0.12991315126419067,
0.512423038482666,
0.21715408563613892,
0.0788872092962265,
-0.15232844650745392,
0.019964413717389107,
0.03910462185740471,
0.001688703428953886,
0.40650951862335205,
0.3042767345905304,
0.015729345381259918,
0.6455022096633911,
0.897641658782959,
0.6618024110794067,
0.2639046907424927,
-0.0355079211294651,
0.722490131855011,
-0.4094976782798767,
-0.8093764185905457,
-0.6058186292648315,
0.5027778744697571,
-0.15823335945606232,
-0.34638720750808716,
0.12958289682865143,
0.8196826577186584,
0.8827486634254456,
0.1196005642414093,
0.8227072954177856,
-0.020217038691043854,
0.6415366530418396,
-0.280281126499176,
0.4201754033565521,
-0.6483430862426758,
0.2735773026943207,
-0.021316703408956528,
-0.6475178003311157,
-0.319699764251709,
0.7732037305831909,
-0.034899644553661346,
-0.3149197995662689,
0.4847217798233032,
0.8052977323532104,
0.11700509488582611,
0.09259473532438278,
0.5655019879341125,
-0.23111151158809662,
0.21963335573673248,
0.08071328699588776,
0.24623091518878937,
-0.3101109564304352,
0.8264613151550293,
-0.0534430667757988,
-0.5844433903694153,
-0.11669158935546875,
-0.3309520483016968,
-0.7830121517181396,
-0.5887151956558228,
-0.35283198952674866,
-0.2351353019475937,
0.20019102096557617,
1.3516889810562134,
0.4854032099246979,
-0.8923485279083252,
-0.4953497648239136,
0.0995524600148201,
-0.5207080245018005,
-0.20215636491775513,
-0.14632205665111542,
0.5784538388252258,
-0.37643545866012573,
-0.5596880316734314,
0.10686551034450531,
0.5347063541412354,
0.10479840636253357,
0.0070726205594837666,
-0.0957646518945694,
0.1707139015197754,
0.5335108041763306,
0.6312247514724731,
0.254250705242157,
-0.6751871109008789,
-0.6919236779212952,
0.09172622859477997,
0.40086910128593445,
0.2267271876335144,
0.7913174033164978,
-0.6243883371353149,
0.46433791518211365,
0.06174279376864433,
0.9090543389320374,
0.567561149597168,
-0.27926474809646606,
0.48555105924606323,
-1.013403296470642,
0.28015562891960144,
-0.02104499377310276,
0.5460668206214905,
0.24149872362613678,
-0.29750069975852966,
0.4491919279098511,
0.3130849599838257,
-0.3188423812389374,
-0.8378859758377075,
0.08576798439025879,
-1.0033516883850098,
-0.20212200284004211,
1.0784101486206055,
0.16855068504810333,
-0.0223291777074337,
-0.37296169996261597,
-0.46375495195388794,
0.2975434362888336,
-0.4325628876686096,
0.467612624168396,
0.5143113136291504,
-0.20241692662239075,
0.006476020906120539,
0.03269202634692192,
0.47310200333595276,
0.15153686702251434,
-0.372656911611557,
-0.14872626960277557,
0.27751433849334717,
0.3383753299713135,
0.42422375082969666,
0.6690652966499329,
0.037211887538433075,
0.08079434186220169,
0.28123751282691956,
0.126506507396698,
-0.0737401619553566,
0.048966970294713974,
0.036377765238285065,
-0.09289433807134628,
0.06145040690898895,
-0.79234379529953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18638v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18638v1
|
Reinforcement Learning Problem Solving with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-29T12:16:08 | 2024-04-29T12:16:08 |
Sina Gholamian, Domingo Huh
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) encapsulate an extensive amount of world
knowledge, and this has enabled their application in various domains to improve
the performance of a variety of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks. This
has also facilitated a more accessible paradigm of conversation-based
interactions between humans and AI systems to solve intended problems. However,
one interesting avenue that shows untapped potential is the use of LLMs as
Reinforcement Learning (RL) agents to enable conversational RL problem solving.
Therefore, in this study, we explore the concept of formulating Markov Decision
Process-based RL problems as LLM prompting tasks. We demonstrate how LLMs can
be iteratively prompted to learn and optimize policies for specific RL tasks.
In addition, we leverage the introduced prompting technique for episode
simulation and Q-Learning, facilitated by LLMs. We then show the practicality
of our approach through two detailed case studies for "Research Scientist" and
"Legal Matter Intake" workflows.
|
[
-0.22725152969360352,
-1.0585861206054688,
0.9293984770774841,
0.1880614161491394,
0.032384779304265976,
0.20060323178768158,
-0.4767025113105774,
-0.09719540178775787,
0.016062360256910324,
0.6023522019386292,
-1.0217286348342896,
-0.3174910843372345,
-0.3526495397090912,
0.14063827693462372,
0.10068001598119736,
0.8872525691986084,
-0.06279461085796356,
0.21706511080265045,
-0.11652771383523941,
0.26341673731803894,
-0.6805394887924194,
-0.2663268744945526,
-1.2697211503982544,
-0.7268134951591492,
1.0180292129516602,
0.5444769263267517,
0.48173636198043823,
0.3723940849304199,
0.08918040245771408,
0.33939000964164734,
-0.13272882997989655,
0.3843674659729004,
-0.35725870728492737,
0.6414358615875244,
-0.3560754060745239,
-0.5136643052101135,
0.14191271364688873,
-0.09018460661172867,
0.6721602082252502,
0.5938766598701477,
-0.5312607288360596,
-0.11392538249492645,
-0.18418002128601074,
0.6983665823936462,
-0.30563056468963623,
0.4870505630970001,
-0.559966504573822,
0.34083235263824463,
0.40852591395378113,
-0.5301762223243713,
-0.5843459963798523,
-0.13583038747310638,
0.21575459837913513,
-0.7127107381820679,
-0.2565092146396637,
0.4017278552055359,
0.49719473719596863,
0.3464868366718292,
-0.16496427357196808,
-0.40738582611083984,
-0.8380058407783508,
0.8892500996589661,
-0.6942461133003235,
0.1070963591337204,
0.3673473000526428,
0.2421293705701828,
-0.7104215621948242,
-0.415132999420166,
-0.699539065361023,
-0.6094479560852051,
0.1871434450149536,
-0.1515880525112152,
-0.14105768501758575,
0.11100848019123077,
0.4582211375236511,
-0.15772433578968048,
-0.3988943099975586,
0.5771815180778503,
-0.38810285925865173,
-0.04196111857891083,
0.5571880340576172,
0.5372540950775146,
0.062065981328487396,
-0.06639643013477325,
-0.20781390368938446,
-0.22431235015392303,
-0.7364605069160461,
0.16564740240573883,
0.11629252135753632,
0.45176541805267334,
0.08598354458808899,
0.48959189653396606,
-0.1416284590959549,
0.5393203496932983,
-0.07891130447387695,
-0.13365782797336578,
-0.08011910319328308,
0.16574256122112274,
-0.22182737290859222,
-0.09583280980587006,
0.7030696272850037,
-0.0007314615650102496,
0.5197303891181946,
0.14735691249370575,
-0.2993755042552948,
-0.2958470582962036,
0.33401086926460266,
-0.49960654973983765,
-0.10431677103042603,
0.3837669789791107,
-0.14577443897724152,
-0.1579899787902832,
-0.49214425683021545,
-0.4609001576900482,
-0.5148797035217285,
-0.5065677165985107,
0.7138946056365967,
-0.3438607156276703,
-0.22244377434253693,
0.1029290184378624,
-0.08668961375951767,
0.23060831427574158,
0.4549800753593445,
-0.7964240908622742,
-0.0072938911616802216,
0.6341411471366882,
0.5506802201271057,
-0.2713105380535126,
-0.2895839810371399,
-0.821510910987854,
0.051777418702840805,
-0.5626877546310425,
0.6316142082214355,
-0.5734100937843323,
-0.6431150436401367,
0.3018929660320282,
-0.07399753481149673,
-0.13502192497253418,
-0.8528603315353394,
0.17113818228244781,
-0.6913486123085022,
0.017375988885760307,
-0.2171332985162735,
-0.5092154145240784,
-0.13251785933971405,
0.5913206338882446,
-0.5882615447044373,
0.8295983076095581,
-0.1860830932855606,
-0.3118687570095062,
0.18959495425224304,
-0.8683072328567505,
-0.2719995677471161,
0.20165203511714935,
-0.2970414161682129,
-0.325711727142334,
-0.2493596225976944,
0.3063603937625885,
0.7822467088699341,
-0.09498713165521622,
0.4195438027381897,
-0.02333836629986763,
-0.04324490204453468,
0.5599249005317688,
-0.3248581290245056,
0.41728711128234863,
0.30267301201820374,
0.009817852638661861,
0.6031780242919922,
-0.37898650765419006,
0.09248150140047073,
0.41116246581077576,
-0.7244922518730164,
0.038444895297288895,
0.24126794934272766,
-0.40672001242637634,
0.23090201616287231,
-0.016032258048653603,
-0.1782190054655075,
0.3898918926715851,
-0.23833024501800537,
0.5922179818153381,
0.7815359234809875,
0.4994404911994934,
0.19620764255523682,
-0.5834246873855591,
0.7393864989280701,
0.1433544009923935,
-0.0729161724448204,
-0.19503311812877655,
-0.4209152162075043,
-0.8571724891662598,
-0.21835587918758392,
-0.08421757072210312,
0.5602735877037048,
-1.1809881925582886,
0.0010972643503919244,
0.16080361604690552,
-0.16373158991336823,
-0.3365291655063629,
0.041166193783283234,
0.29122647643089294,
0.2915182113647461,
0.22097936272621155,
0.07583753764629364,
-0.4437072277069092,
-0.6443853378295898,
-0.17982830107212067,
-0.2918228209018707,
0.17159664630889893,
0.4610167145729065,
0.5985771417617798,
-0.1576288491487503,
0.754260241985321,
-0.2560423016548157,
-0.13461816310882568,
-0.6272761225700378,
0.3596552014350891,
0.29351532459259033,
0.37936830520629883,
-0.2950145900249481,
-0.5663658380508423,
-0.30228903889656067,
-0.14590534567832947,
-0.5067460536956787,
0.05675434693694115,
-0.20029163360595703,
0.1826503425836563,
0.45027753710746765,
0.7821599841117859,
-0.6154162287712097,
0.07848148792982101,
0.35721027851104736,
-0.05591629073023796,
0.7931035757064819,
-0.6676206588745117,
0.01956983096897602,
-0.7314804196357727,
-0.10765919089317322,
0.17577773332595825,
-0.4330938756465912,
-0.6966656446456909,
-0.02791125327348709,
-0.2679172158241272,
-0.3057090640068054,
-0.7385804653167725,
0.5456598401069641,
-0.39051175117492676,
-0.19379156827926636,
-0.35343509912490845,
0.17703557014465332,
-0.3258153200149536,
0.82126784324646,
0.428220272064209,
0.8879782557487488,
0.4455810785293579,
-1.0158034563064575,
0.4748040437698364,
0.06316790729761124,
-0.2836097776889801,
0.3716273009777069,
-0.47484371066093445,
-0.02149583213031292,
-0.286722868680954,
0.31446897983551025,
-0.60215824842453,
-0.027909880504012108,
0.3999722898006439,
-0.19892023503780365,
0.18579287827014923,
-0.05962153524160385,
-0.5060741901397705,
-0.278852254152298,
-0.014506685547530651,
0.07604031264781952,
0.5947467088699341,
-0.4430370032787323,
0.34341689944267273,
0.2313271462917328,
-0.3300549387931824,
-0.4802182614803314,
-0.143757626414299,
0.10970412939786911,
-0.3009301722049713,
-0.19918674230575562,
0.10308250784873962,
-0.17682284116744995,
-0.3784632980823517,
-0.11641377955675125,
0.2768845558166504,
0.05410820245742798,
0.06311111152172089,
0.23410287499427795,
0.324791818857193,
0.024249402806162834,
0.3117629885673523,
-0.3026047945022583,
-0.17958958446979523,
0.3473284840583801,
-0.3502257466316223,
0.5796127319335938,
-0.009729594923555851,
-0.4152592420578003,
-0.5012498497962952,
0.3695477545261383,
0.3240778148174286,
-0.12728753685951233,
0.6480252742767334,
0.30070072412490845,
-0.1286173313856125,
-0.6345633864402771,
-0.4386224150657654,
-0.40856051445007324,
-0.47421929240226746,
0.46393683552742004,
-0.2688279151916504,
-1.0869498252868652,
0.28539055585861206,
-0.352363258600235,
0.19218753278255463,
0.03522175922989845,
0.9310877323150635,
-0.2493005245923996,
1.1292318105697632,
0.3710956573486328,
-0.09268524497747421,
0.6844039559364319,
-0.2967272698879242,
0.2589740753173828,
-0.6743274331092834,
-0.5234420299530029,
-0.44829872250556946,
-0.1268383115530014,
-0.36040055751800537,
-0.7530792951583862,
0.5533917546272278,
-0.19444036483764648,
-0.33685848116874695,
-0.03562013432383537,
-0.1347402036190033,
0.6479183435440063,
0.6618689894676208,
0.09883509576320648,
0.37402889132499695,
-0.02136913500726223,
-0.31017622351646423,
0.0028057775925844908,
-0.9888513684272766,
-0.36747729778289795,
0.7594292163848877,
0.48653703927993774,
0.764658510684967,
-0.07300462573766708,
0.7239967584609985,
0.4852339029312134,
0.02656669169664383,
-1.0909286737442017,
0.779807448387146,
0.4820764660835266,
-0.2791826128959656,
-0.643121600151062,
-0.4105275273323059,
-1.2983527183532715,
0.2869234085083008,
-0.44201040267944336,
-0.8131876587867737,
-0.1746811419725418,
0.13110637664794922,
-0.30914708971977234,
0.22192808985710144,
-0.27442803978919983,
0.7073698043823242,
-0.09159652888774872,
-0.2764768600463867,
-0.8055968284606934,
-0.3316364586353302,
0.1274365484714508,
0.2857438325881958,
0.3341493010520935,
-0.20740902423858643,
0.08787211775779724,
0.7282317280769348,
-0.236578106880188,
0.8609057664871216,
-0.3152269124984741,
-0.33670249581336975,
0.3343842327594757,
0.2467283010482788,
0.8642149567604065,
0.021904995664954185,
0.1361524760723114,
-0.4855647385120392,
0.035762883722782135,
-0.16088956594467163,
-0.732115626335144,
0.4242488443851471,
-0.647651195526123,
-0.944502055644989,
-0.407946914434433,
-0.8416604399681091,
-0.3827801048755646,
-0.16732047498226166,
-0.38785502314567566,
0.13771101832389832,
-0.10959234833717346,
-0.19124634563922882,
1.0395457744598389,
-0.4374293088912964,
0.4693699777126312,
0.982412576675415,
-0.49584490060806274,
-0.01932877115905285,
1.0202021598815918,
-0.1907472014427185,
0.3551373779773712,
0.26134955883026123,
0.3349841237068176,
-0.32359352707862854,
-0.5923669934272766,
-0.29434871673583984,
0.39203718304634094,
-0.7504732608795166,
0.0030256477184593678,
-0.5012425780296326,
-0.2714368402957916,
0.0008440017700195312,
-0.056122757494449615,
-0.017684057354927063,
0.013981224969029427,
-0.2977660894393921,
0.038319043815135956,
0.43415719270706177,
0.7471230626106262,
-0.14375638961791992,
0.07503680139780045,
-0.732568085193634,
0.16941997408866882,
0.5332773923873901,
-0.08285950124263763,
0.19450311362743378,
-0.5711634159088135,
-0.23142626881599426,
-0.11921772360801697,
-0.24436120688915253,
-0.7484371662139893,
0.6867222189903259,
-0.006928283255547285,
0.6946569681167603,
0.25259414315223694,
0.06989706307649612,
0.36716869473457336,
-0.6386168003082275,
0.6035032272338867,
0.0016133349854499102,
-0.6179966926574707,
0.6222436428070068,
-0.518122673034668,
0.11780458688735962,
0.20608632266521454,
0.596269965171814,
-0.8808339834213257,
-0.4893856644630432,
-0.4808979034423828,
-0.724454402923584,
0.7234402894973755,
-0.09706937521696091,
0.005219761282205582,
-0.15497149527072906,
0.349714070558548,
-0.08275673538446426,
0.2599795460700989,
-0.6235522627830505,
0.03916154056787491,
0.5076255202293396,
0.06482204794883728,
-0.0618121400475502,
-0.1255948692560196,
-0.18172916769981384,
-0.08284470438957214,
1.0823613405227661,
-0.18607273697853088,
0.198913112282753,
0.24878890812397003,
-0.18297165632247925,
-0.06016698479652405,
0.611966609954834,
0.5911803245544434,
0.4210059344768524,
0.14436131715774536,
-0.19003838300704956,
0.3209913969039917,
0.19875803589820862,
0.29474008083343506,
-0.35910409688949585,
0.163532093167305,
-0.3870031535625458,
-0.07705705612897873,
0.9177533388137817,
0.17348921298980713,
-1.2747118473052979,
0.14640584588050842,
0.054889362305402756,
-0.34804368019104004,
-0.4714963734149933,
0.34076863527297974,
0.2963637709617615,
0.8962003588676453,
0.37424108386039734,
-0.592667818069458,
-0.1299382895231247,
-0.7729756236076355,
0.034584298729896545,
0.6071398854255676,
-0.3588002324104309,
0.3289777934551239,
0.1439783275127411,
0.16766268014907837,
-0.7975337505340576,
0.8029413223266602,
-0.28515395522117615,
-0.7027097940444946,
0.6730161309242249,
0.7224891185760498,
0.4236273765563965,
0.11748839914798737,
0.5259243249893188,
0.18089640140533447,
-0.004174438305199146,
-0.3079068660736084,
0.2950187027454376,
-0.13074176013469696,
-0.7481295466423035,
-0.850532591342926,
-0.3542214632034302,
-0.9436898827552795,
0.3068068027496338,
-0.5408483743667603,
0.0013635646319016814,
-0.63516765832901,
0.13129612803459167,
-0.17801092565059662,
0.12346524745225906,
-0.42814892530441284,
-0.05205461382865906,
0.2326463758945465,
0.6433879733085632,
-0.693588376045227,
0.7546204328536987,
0.6231644153594971,
-0.2220652848482132,
-1.166224479675293,
-0.23342175781726837,
-0.015796054154634476,
-0.9585752487182617,
1.015461802482605,
-0.09640544652938843,
0.04596313089132309,
0.19047163426876068,
-0.6257255673408508,
-0.4585387110710144,
0.9016891121864319,
0.13768011331558228,
-0.5951101183891296,
-0.007155867293477058,
-0.009047403931617737,
0.3709549307823181,
-0.4271317720413208,
0.13025043904781342,
0.6125087141990662,
0.5002686381340027,
0.18431547284126282,
-0.8734967708587646,
0.0770936980843544,
-0.02066703885793686,
-0.04366288334131241,
0.16472415626049042,
-0.3560132086277008,
0.7318178415298462,
-0.5123331546783447,
0.019588151946663857,
-0.05331195145845413,
0.7279137372970581,
0.7913854122161865,
0.0673035979270935,
0.5697658061981201,
0.2478058785200119,
0.9029956459999084,
0.16649094223976135,
0.7903316617012024,
0.08970823138952255,
0.21150384843349457,
0.7241185903549194,
-0.40951916575431824,
0.9728368520736694,
0.6186367869377136,
-0.2563362717628479,
0.5962051153182983,
0.7128750681877136,
-0.021139707416296005,
0.26471930742263794,
0.7397531270980835,
-0.46886783838272095,
-0.5015043616294861,
-0.30971789360046387,
0.17607858777046204,
0.05771308019757271,
0.6839349269866943,
-0.1010356917977333,
-0.2617934048175812,
0.22925102710723877,
0.10593023896217346,
0.08370161056518555,
-0.6502928137779236,
0.9005106091499329,
0.20376704633235931,
-1.092628002166748,
0.35289666056632996,
0.12704630196094513,
0.4635167717933655,
-0.704902708530426,
-0.24302338063716888,
0.10030600428581238,
-0.08831271529197693,
0.04964642971754074,
-0.8419538736343384,
-0.05026567727327347,
-0.0645611584186554,
-0.173238605260849,
-0.4233303666114807,
0.5059933066368103,
-0.6260474920272827,
-0.03527023270726204,
0.1378299593925476,
0.6249675154685974,
0.3857974410057068,
0.11731384694576263,
-0.8349431753158569,
-0.10507236421108246,
-0.13716477155685425,
-0.2849535644054413,
0.5720650553703308,
0.3118727505207062,
-0.16425685584545135,
1.2570995092391968,
0.7306897044181824,
0.3321218490600586,
-0.038089051842689514,
0.13485774397850037,
0.6790634989738464,
-0.7506794333457947,
-0.6531449556350708,
-0.7344958186149597,
0.3694119155406952,
0.1673571616411209,
0.11925169825553894,
0.36750924587249756,
-0.006498383823782206,
0.6068487167358398,
-0.09657865762710571,
0.7727500200271606,
0.20911051332950592,
0.43979471921920776,
-1.0889906883239746,
0.23617152869701385,
-0.24247367680072784,
0.41294002532958984,
0.23349684476852417,
-0.7303075194358826,
-0.05396901071071625,
0.7096850275993347,
-0.41001224517822266,
0.03882836550474167,
0.8022717237472534,
0.9662882685661316,
0.5038761496543884,
-0.09178251773118973,
0.5240114331245422,
-0.033415138721466064,
0.4825570285320282,
0.8402025699615479,
1.1711636781692505,
0.3490775227546692,
0.41300728917121887,
0.1843978762626648,
0.15023963153362274,
-0.3877476453781128,
-0.8713435530662537,
-1.100881576538086,
-0.5726906061172485,
-0.3212651312351227,
-0.4040378928184509,
0.38419461250305176,
1.437219500541687,
0.44691479206085205,
-0.5287405252456665,
-0.34185853600502014,
-0.1477142721414566,
0.3004654049873352,
-0.2091289460659027,
-0.2092316895723343,
0.026237035170197487,
-0.8260374069213867,
-0.6942052841186523,
0.7918131351470947,
0.13364601135253906,
-0.012058728374540806,
-0.6705738306045532,
-0.5025541186332703,
-0.23553897440433502,
0.20263659954071045,
0.4034208357334137,
0.7370139360427856,
-0.7364888787269592,
-0.11851475387811661,
-0.31140151619911194,
0.04994784668087959,
0.11538835614919662,
1.2683031558990479,
-1.0102180242538452,
0.16344909369945526,
0.28640156984329224,
0.800704836845398,
0.6554062962532043,
-0.22991196811199188,
0.6674198508262634,
-0.6394991874694824,
0.025623727589845657,
0.47508350014686584,
0.19151584804058075,
0.13359855115413666,
-0.10046755522489548,
0.07638821005821228,
-0.09499316662549973,
-0.7573534846305847,
-0.6594544649124146,
0.46695563197135925,
-0.6605027914047241,
-0.4619899094104767,
1.3708747625350952,
-0.09479286521673203,
-0.25680071115493774,
-0.30716705322265625,
-0.4058416187763214,
0.0709834024310112,
-0.7398388385772705,
0.5975603461265564,
0.5227475166320801,
-0.2817089855670929,
-0.4839715361595154,
-0.8434523940086365,
0.608457624912262,
0.683739960193634,
-0.843672513961792,
0.19305101037025452,
0.5079099535942078,
0.23999039828777313,
-0.13613717257976532,
0.7566426992416382,
0.24330295622348785,
0.08121694624423981,
-0.3698778748512268,
-0.014730592258274555,
-0.2079828679561615,
-0.5053253769874573,
-0.5721766352653503,
-0.044675517827272415,
0.5153380036354065,
0.0635981634259224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18624v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18624v2
|
Do Vision & Language Decoders use Images and Text equally? How Self-consistent are their Explanations?
| 2024-04-29T11:52:20 | 2024-06-10T10:43:20 |
Letitia Parcalabescu, Anette Frank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG, 68Txx, I.2.7; I.2.10
|
Vision and language model (VLM) decoders are currently the best-performing
architectures on multimodal tasks. Next to predictions, they can also produce
explanations, either in post-hoc or CoT settings. However, it is not clear how
much they use the vision and text modalities when generating predictions or
explanations. In this work, we investigate if VLMs rely on modalities
differently when they produce explanations as opposed to providing answers. We
also evaluate the self-consistency of VLM decoders in both post-hoc and CoT
explanation settings, by extending existing unimodal tests and measures to VLM
decoders. We find that VLMs are less self-consistent than LLMs. Text
contributions in VL decoders are more important than image contributions in all
examined tasks. Moreover, the contributions of images are significantly
stronger for explanation generation compared to answer generation. This
difference is even larger in CoT compared to post-hoc explanations. Lastly, we
provide an up-to-date benchmarking of state-of-the-art VL decoders on the VALSE
benchmark, which before only covered VL encoders. We find that VL decoders
still struggle with most phenomena tested by VALSE.
|
[
-0.25499215722084045,
-0.4937637746334076,
0.7297098636627197,
0.19533947110176086,
-0.4752698242664337,
-0.4949650466442108,
-0.044288210570812225,
-0.5141720175743103,
-0.26052865386009216,
0.43428000807762146,
-0.5004234910011292,
-0.24131008982658386,
-0.5073876976966858,
0.31563735008239746,
-0.4247100353240967,
0.8139147758483887,
-0.4239092469215393,
0.2591060996055603,
-0.5873752236366272,
-0.18478581309318542,
-0.6406011581420898,
-0.7248455286026001,
-0.18240980803966522,
-0.2609867751598358,
0.5048644542694092,
-0.17445576190948486,
0.5457984805107117,
0.8435727953910828,
0.3923730254173279,
0.316198468208313,
0.1353256106376648,
0.31017446517944336,
-0.2425079047679901,
0.24888305366039276,
-0.19751624763011932,
-0.16039668023586273,
-0.051135070621967316,
-0.40486788749694824,
0.3332635462284088,
0.38440972566604614,
0.17310857772827148,
0.010974738746881485,
0.11083249747753143,
0.493058979511261,
-0.9344442486763,
0.15766920149326324,
-0.47509321570396423,
0.15242312848567963,
0.03911009803414345,
-0.44398224353790283,
-0.6151202321052551,
0.25256145000457764,
-0.09458920359611511,
-0.39930805563926697,
0.17710354924201965,
0.09251614660024643,
0.8763492703437805,
0.4266231954097748,
-0.5927736163139343,
-0.31735730171203613,
-0.8663410544395447,
0.7141585946083069,
-0.4176517128944397,
0.6163350939750671,
0.39085841178894043,
0.30017367005348206,
0.08000344038009644,
-0.7114730477333069,
-0.5033749938011169,
0.04683049023151398,
-0.322370707988739,
0.3239745795726776,
-0.3044866919517517,
0.21959541738033295,
0.14703984558582306,
0.41389164328575134,
-0.5844582915306091,
-0.04864846169948578,
-0.40541887283325195,
-0.5159952044487,
0.38214072585105896,
0.4117095172405243,
0.07900241762399673,
-0.2945241332054138,
-0.7606077194213867,
-0.11448147147893906,
-0.542966365814209,
0.23836304247379303,
-0.21565239131450653,
-0.4992241859436035,
-0.1517140120267868,
0.6742357015609741,
0.05441167578101158,
0.955431342124939,
-0.0869985893368721,
0.01391458511352539,
0.08235473930835724,
-0.8442898988723755,
-0.4442453682422638,
-0.1836855262517929,
0.8593336939811707,
0.5370234847068787,
0.1726132035255432,
-0.1804845631122589,
-0.5084114074707031,
0.3450976014137268,
0.273124098777771,
-0.439107745885849,
-0.18569976091384888,
0.10421339422464371,
-0.7549991011619568,
-0.1609189361333847,
-0.22360621392726898,
-0.7517905235290527,
-0.29286548495292664,
-0.39430224895477295,
0.549788773059845,
-0.3681809902191162,
-0.1572917103767395,
0.20760586857795715,
-0.13413076102733612,
0.5738287568092346,
0.542755663394928,
-1.0392102003097534,
0.19477029144763947,
0.27272194623947144,
0.546564519405365,
-0.18796218931674957,
-0.43398886919021606,
-0.42767107486724854,
-0.028364263474941254,
-0.5513676404953003,
1.014621376991272,
-0.19139975309371948,
-0.2669394016265869,
0.1510409116744995,
0.06268281489610672,
-0.12110305577516556,
-0.3936120867729187,
0.2895606756210327,
-0.29438167810440063,
0.2848413586616516,
-0.6846141815185547,
-0.4579847753047943,
-0.1454257220029831,
0.05446579307317734,
-0.5030649900436401,
0.7933552861213684,
-0.03710317984223366,
-0.5974400043487549,
0.4194033741950989,
-0.3782859444618225,
-0.2389337718486786,
-0.08565318584442139,
-0.4666316509246826,
-0.13727343082427979,
0.4418719410896301,
0.2893211543560028,
0.3303085267543793,
-0.16049468517303467,
-0.02590254694223404,
-0.0911295935511589,
-0.4957272708415985,
0.5473660826683044,
-0.9666281938552856,
0.602803647518158,
0.3537004590034485,
-0.468593031167984,
0.07753563672304153,
-0.666786253452301,
0.09256041049957275,
0.2659604847431183,
-0.3259904086589813,
0.002372062299400568,
0.32935914397239685,
-0.0591573603451252,
0.14511655271053314,
0.3583986759185791,
-0.4618815779685974,
-0.20566493272781372,
0.08216183632612228,
0.316122829914093,
0.927054762840271,
-0.3139488995075226,
0.2304864525794983,
-0.12139314413070679,
0.32619595527648926,
0.22851629555225372,
0.2993856370449066,
-0.7053829431533813,
-0.3221370279788971,
-0.6896570920944214,
-0.1707446575164795,
-0.030699344351887703,
0.26608237624168396,
-0.950753927230835,
-0.38118547201156616,
-0.12942425906658173,
0.07206135243177414,
-0.6520823240280151,
0.0010781504679471254,
0.7683408856391907,
0.558027982711792,
0.39705321192741394,
-0.15700557827949524,
-0.6603121757507324,
-0.8039934039115906,
-0.28696590662002563,
-0.25324422121047974,
0.13055025041103363,
0.12935501337051392,
0.2979363799095154,
-0.16433385014533997,
0.6561128497123718,
0.16959169507026672,
0.11767840385437012,
-0.049748487770557404,
0.011082623153924942,
-0.13409675657749176,
0.06672479212284088,
0.7539721727371216,
-1.0177345275878906,
-0.29299694299697876,
-0.10664472728967667,
-1.148970127105713,
-0.13202466070652008,
-0.1842092126607895,
0.31196334958076477,
0.7506709098815918,
0.5383371114730835,
-0.294029176235199,
0.6692008972167969,
0.8817772269248962,
-0.7084288597106934,
0.7121593356132507,
-0.542792022228241,
0.3351711332798004,
-0.5813223719596863,
-0.2911195158958435,
-0.07863764464855194,
-0.512886643409729,
-0.6078135967254639,
0.02124500647187233,
0.15492959320545197,
0.31063902378082275,
-0.4501248598098755,
0.42587214708328247,
-0.7639129161834717,
-0.3596076965332031,
-0.37875187397003174,
0.16205626726150513,
0.3196296691894531,
0.4468136727809906,
0.1129802018404007,
0.8910742998123169,
0.7821459174156189,
-0.5335204005241394,
0.44202032685279846,
-0.019525617361068726,
-0.15997791290283203,
0.36326372623443604,
-0.9499611854553223,
0.05472785234451294,
-0.45186692476272583,
-0.08517881482839584,
-1.2568538188934326,
0.03799526393413544,
0.26094526052474976,
-0.3610231280326843,
0.07174425572156906,
-0.05240624025464058,
-0.426830530166626,
-0.33650654554367065,
-0.2855810821056366,
0.3858816623687744,
0.6728672981262207,
-0.7203541994094849,
0.744841456413269,
-0.10462687909603119,
0.5220186710357666,
-0.5876432657241821,
-0.9500412940979004,
0.034707676619291306,
0.044213563203811646,
-0.42328083515167236,
0.06984583288431168,
-0.3138335049152374,
-0.4082055985927582,
0.2433854043483734,
-0.2856314778327942,
-0.13628092408180237,
-0.08697223663330078,
0.4920284152030945,
0.30332136154174805,
-0.6021319031715393,
0.21986030042171478,
-0.2938534617424011,
-0.13966284692287445,
0.10705415904521942,
-0.05637696757912636,
0.35219916701316833,
-0.5263373255729675,
-0.5162501335144043,
-0.4973554015159607,
0.3976496160030365,
0.7182148694992065,
-0.3314796984195709,
0.8567037582397461,
0.5782132744789124,
0.06813865900039673,
0.2668139934539795,
-0.5445056557655334,
0.038625482469797134,
-0.4674752652645111,
0.08097133040428162,
-0.8066680431365967,
-0.7921010255813599,
0.5319815874099731,
0.20553719997406006,
0.016694149002432823,
0.6588078737258911,
0.6715409755706787,
-0.4358964264392853,
1.2053606510162354,
0.5909378528594971,
0.40445035696029663,
0.40274158120155334,
-0.002664056373760104,
0.08768980205059052,
-0.8561478853225708,
-0.2812400460243225,
-0.22878937423229218,
0.11567573994398117,
-0.4168645739555359,
-0.3653392493724823,
0.15341883897781372,
0.08898231387138367,
0.23616474866867065,
0.11569659411907196,
-0.5451433062553406,
0.5162020325660706,
0.46729719638824463,
-0.18429869413375854,
0.27735719084739685,
0.1744285225868225,
0.0973363146185875,
-0.10994675010442734,
-0.7858479619026184,
-0.5508564114570618,
0.9991360902786255,
0.2483963817358017,
0.9115650653839111,
-0.07142462581396103,
0.4967030882835388,
0.2746540307998657,
0.054340168833732605,
-0.5035459399223328,
0.3406089246273041,
-0.33167439699172974,
-0.4615113437175751,
-0.15991248190402985,
-0.14662481844425201,
-1.026904582977295,
0.7538051605224609,
-0.18027706444263458,
-0.5801981687545776,
0.24871507287025452,
0.42245444655418396,
0.0686313733458519,
0.09208346158266068,
-0.6527312994003296,
0.9638711810112,
-0.3199821412563324,
-0.21348914504051208,
0.018220329657197,
-0.5307676196098328,
0.26714885234832764,
0.19117365777492523,
0.3231580853462219,
0.19472992420196533,
0.04552425444126129,
0.46477648615837097,
-0.313008576631546,
0.7690762877464294,
0.060824863612651825,
-0.1971735954284668,
0.3684626519680023,
0.10373833030462265,
0.13571900129318237,
-0.23191754519939423,
-0.008661515079438686,
0.3549547493457794,
0.3621782660484314,
-0.45998990535736084,
-0.682086706161499,
0.4104558229446411,
-0.764209508895874,
-0.6496508717536926,
-0.30517855286598206,
-0.3049076497554779,
0.2184903472661972,
0.11691214889287949,
0.6878983974456787,
1.0977107286453247,
0.14149586856365204,
0.27349746227264404,
0.9303913116455078,
-0.026302067562937737,
0.6989345550537109,
0.48890024423599243,
-0.28480392694473267,
-0.2413276582956314,
0.7501915097236633,
-0.13077914714813232,
0.4224392771720886,
0.3105045258998871,
0.1524735987186432,
-0.4484446048736572,
-0.6648495197296143,
-0.794517457485199,
0.0801914855837822,
-1.1934598684310913,
-0.02655014395713806,
-0.4458649456501007,
-0.21121007204055786,
-0.40759778022766113,
-0.27830949425697327,
-0.42652034759521484,
0.032929275184869766,
-0.14882826805114746,
0.026884039863944054,
0.1278694123029709,
0.9223148822784424,
-0.21383275091648102,
0.05206175893545151,
-0.7041373252868652,
0.7063267827033997,
0.3849368691444397,
0.19936193525791168,
-0.20974457263946533,
-0.3888276517391205,
-0.23391112685203552,
0.34635642170906067,
0.12636888027191162,
-1.0720292329788208,
0.006729097571223974,
0.04745502024888992,
0.6337124109268188,
0.28116410970687866,
-0.08536592125892639,
0.6844741106033325,
-0.47324901819229126,
1.091883659362793,
0.24664819240570068,
-1.0354701280593872,
0.4315442740917206,
-0.02698928490281105,
0.49292635917663574,
0.2360822707414627,
-0.01682196743786335,
-0.4765510559082031,
-0.3863734006881714,
-0.38168126344680786,
-0.41579318046569824,
0.5986753106117249,
0.19843964278697968,
0.21938782930374146,
0.02129332348704338,
0.2920539379119873,
0.209660142660141,
-0.1055569276213646,
-1.0098916292190552,
-0.31103241443634033,
-0.6003800630569458,
-0.4402594268321991,
-0.05252010375261307,
-0.7050926685333252,
-0.2394067645072937,
0.031230516731739044,
0.04620290920138359,
-0.09181173145771027,
0.48808416724205017,
0.6815342307090759,
-0.3671536445617676,
-0.18192782998085022,
0.08545587211847305,
0.9997256994247437,
0.9620928168296814,
0.353439599275589,
0.7816355228424072,
0.030293762683868408,
-0.1972063183784485,
-0.06204872205853462,
-0.4412885308265686,
0.02501479722559452,
0.4292612671852112,
0.9024405479431152,
1.2567317485809326,
0.09500756859779358,
-0.7724797129631042,
0.7540585398674011,
-0.4667454957962036,
-0.35847771167755127,
-0.2008967250585556,
0.022594010457396507,
-0.14616404473781586,
0.2391166239976883,
0.12435188889503479,
0.047916773706674576,
0.04568220674991608,
-0.6890405416488647,
-0.07538996636867523,
0.4226284623146057,
-0.40006890892982483,
-0.42113688588142395,
0.7489551305770874,
-0.13983014225959778,
-0.32365477085113525,
0.30985474586486816,
0.10035088658332825,
-0.41330820322036743,
0.5387952923774719,
0.6253491640090942,
0.6351814866065979,
-0.10901839286088943,
0.25161615014076233,
-0.15030217170715332,
0.33388376235961914,
0.08728048950433731,
0.38300183415412903,
-0.5214807391166687,
-0.750916063785553,
-0.5557777285575867,
-0.5179455280303955,
-0.19970931112766266,
-0.018429884687066078,
-0.611419677734375,
-0.1453181356191635,
-0.11479534953832626,
0.23328255116939545,
0.06929107755422592,
-0.5744771957397461,
-0.6618813276290894,
0.3988957405090332,
0.32898586988449097,
0.49538058042526245,
-0.628097653388977,
0.6020826101303101,
0.7658730149269104,
-0.40389031171798706,
-0.7908104062080383,
-0.1646118313074112,
-0.023086680099368095,
-1.1277449131011963,
0.7049738764762878,
-0.09026798605918884,
-0.5442265868186951,
-0.21964357793331146,
-0.4926338791847229,
-0.7873832583427429,
0.8482756018638611,
0.35206103324890137,
-0.28077155351638794,
0.23610079288482666,
0.08721782267093658,
0.7779079079627991,
-0.29111534357070923,
0.29334813356399536,
-0.004951480310410261,
0.49489685893058777,
0.08628875762224197,
-1.0641182661056519,
-0.006674666423350573,
-0.20348626375198364,
0.2459973692893982,
0.026640310883522034,
-0.3400587737560272,
0.7609492540359497,
-0.19296927750110626,
-0.27298715710639954,
-0.028876792639493942,
0.6111301779747009,
-0.03260430693626404,
0.4290119409561157,
0.3876715898513794,
0.16789278388023376,
0.12590940296649933,
-0.14386750757694244,
1.4405962228775024,
-0.1701149046421051,
0.3581363260746002,
0.8495178818702698,
0.17201368510723114,
0.6752073168754578,
0.6677123308181763,
0.06018243357539177,
0.6173701286315918,
0.5901320576667786,
-0.002712004352360964,
0.6606540083885193,
-0.2517094910144806,
-0.03477873280644417,
-0.45271939039230347,
0.0016892155399546027,
-0.3182186782360077,
0.6747065782546997,
-0.03157423436641693,
-0.4652441143989563,
-0.3164452314376831,
0.40693381428718567,
-0.3757568895816803,
0.05349445715546608,
-0.39247196912765503,
0.9384993314743042,
0.04086156561970711,
-0.6699109077453613,
1.0563143491744995,
-0.18465279042720795,
0.29834234714508057,
-0.47563788294792175,
0.05429275333881378,
-0.24868835508823395,
0.3005668818950653,
-0.0246586874127388,
-1.0470246076583862,
0.37710297107696533,
-0.058162007480859756,
-0.3095344007015228,
-0.6688795685768127,
0.8644897937774658,
-0.4685792028903961,
-0.14343184232711792,
0.22931542992591858,
0.4563525915145874,
0.41508984565734863,
0.09532632678747177,
-0.4560105800628662,
0.6329997181892395,
0.03064938634634018,
-0.28179115056991577,
0.13967901468276978,
0.7010911703109741,
0.04281536117196083,
0.5848641991615295,
0.1554214358329773,
-0.17385463416576385,
0.4584517776966095,
-0.03794103488326073,
0.61078280210495,
-0.5041909217834473,
-0.07109496742486954,
-1.0766719579696655,
0.7131611704826355,
0.08891201764345169,
-0.32321202754974365,
0.9059447646141052,
0.3359811007976532,
0.8248976469039917,
-0.27137491106987,
0.546481728553772,
0.1077607199549675,
-0.11241669207811356,
-0.9652403593063354,
0.2143477499485016,
-0.9282103180885315,
-0.03416344150900841,
0.007437319494783878,
-0.759244441986084,
0.08038526773452759,
0.6226460337638855,
-0.008655414916574955,
-0.08807169646024704,
1.0930850505828857,
0.4345691204071045,
0.032132185995578766,
0.037417422980070114,
0.6236279606819153,
0.2089972198009491,
0.26514992117881775,
0.32105153799057007,
0.8681339025497437,
-0.5489119291305542,
0.5904206037521362,
-0.08897073566913605,
-0.005132884252816439,
-0.2770673930644989,
-0.7100622057914734,
-0.8194629549980164,
-0.8383826613426208,
-0.27335789799690247,
-0.12765046954154968,
0.19976168870925903,
0.1524333655834198,
0.6012504696846008,
-0.5029516816139221,
-0.08222537487745285,
-0.16050373017787933,
0.2203381508588791,
-0.20919975638389587,
-0.17717643082141876,
0.188759446144104,
-0.4237542748451233,
-0.39333513379096985,
0.3500036597251892,
0.6387357115745544,
0.24295437335968018,
-0.4248548448085785,
-0.1403474509716034,
0.47180864214897156,
0.17202657461166382,
0.9268593788146973,
0.20604577660560608,
-1.2702897787094116,
-0.5076077580451965,
0.27066025137901306,
-0.28039464354515076,
0.25502437353134155,
0.8436598181724548,
-0.8697437047958374,
0.8447504043579102,
0.46723759174346924,
0.3651822507381439,
0.49923041462898254,
-0.17883345484733582,
0.5858326554298401,
-0.20556338131427765,
-0.04841006174683571,
0.011097963899374008,
0.5426728129386902,
0.26221826672554016,
-0.2459278404712677,
0.21074184775352478,
0.21712404489517212,
-0.394441157579422,
-0.6957363486289978,
0.27790141105651855,
-1.0556520223617554,
-0.43688347935676575,
1.2164844274520874,
-0.20378735661506653,
-0.6620656251907349,
-0.10296180099248886,
-0.31233781576156616,
0.018165230751037598,
0.20356225967407227,
0.5882989764213562,
0.7525872588157654,
-0.22348825633525848,
-0.7799044251441956,
-0.47564008831977844,
0.37706583738327026,
0.46951866149902344,
-0.5391504168510437,
0.19951175153255463,
0.6157777309417725,
0.2979208827018738,
0.08843928575515747,
0.9546747207641602,
-0.17979922890663147,
0.6333759427070618,
0.24685350060462952,
-0.07211336493492126,
-0.108902707695961,
-0.3756089210510254,
-0.4885246157646179,
0.005196212325245142,
-0.06651515513658524,
-0.44806838035583496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18615v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18615v1
|
The SAMER Arabic Text Simplification Corpus
| 2024-04-29T11:34:06 | 2024-04-29T11:34:06 |
Bashar Alhafni, Reem Hazim, Juan Piñeros Liberato, Muhamed Al Khalil, Nizar Habash
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present the SAMER Corpus, the first manually annotated Arabic parallel
corpus for text simplification targeting school-aged learners. Our corpus
comprises texts of 159K words selected from 15 publicly available Arabic
fiction novels most of which were published between 1865 and 1955. Our corpus
includes readability level annotations at both the document and word levels, as
well as two simplified parallel versions for each text targeting learners at
two different readability levels. We describe the corpus selection process, and
outline the guidelines we followed to create the annotations and ensure their
quality. Our corpus is publicly available to support and encourage research on
Arabic text simplification, Arabic automatic readability assessment, and the
development of Arabic pedagogical language technologies.
|
[
-0.4556184709072113,
-0.259011447429657,
0.34621119499206543,
0.25367313623428345,
-0.37712687253952026,
0.09621702134609222,
-0.009606622159481049,
-0.410116046667099,
0.07650968432426453,
0.32891324162483215,
-0.473550021648407,
-0.6468365788459778,
-0.6602208614349365,
0.7307319045066833,
-0.4977857172489166,
1.0254164934158325,
-0.2627325654029846,
-0.0778706893324852,
-0.15990634262561798,
-0.3051772713661194,
0.015206798911094666,
-0.554314136505127,
-0.4176735281944275,
-0.08117784559726715,
0.878429114818573,
0.622590184211731,
0.8862713575363159,
0.9021800756454468,
0.6739140748977661,
0.3336368799209595,
-0.3485545217990875,
-0.12517395615577698,
-0.3125954270362854,
-0.151666522026062,
-0.09997154772281647,
-0.053089726716279984,
-0.20927897095680237,
-0.3777676224708557,
0.8288017511367798,
0.7237182855606079,
0.2646210491657257,
0.34183433651924133,
0.10147587209939957,
1.0304534435272217,
-0.8038957715034485,
0.002878334606066346,
0.09000799804925919,
-0.16559341549873352,
-0.5759230852127075,
0.24808521568775177,
-0.19246558845043182,
-0.6813068985939026,
-0.19718435406684875,
-0.5919046401977539,
0.09371722489595413,
-0.04992345720529556,
0.6679297685623169,
0.2568124532699585,
-0.397165983915329,
-0.3460659384727478,
-0.6565214395523071,
0.8765825033187866,
-0.3572235703468323,
0.10897628962993622,
0.5808138847351074,
0.46932411193847656,
0.19660459458827972,
-1.0865236520767212,
-0.8849081993103027,
-0.0737340971827507,
-0.2915332317352295,
-0.0694638043642044,
-0.022844795137643814,
0.08220411092042923,
0.35865551233291626,
0.25874024629592896,
-0.746801495552063,
-0.37124237418174744,
-0.8864365816116333,
-0.27236345410346985,
0.5703760981559753,
-0.06801383197307587,
0.404546320438385,
-0.14698836207389832,
-0.4353140890598297,
-0.12452910840511322,
-0.6879312992095947,
-0.12487953901290894,
0.43733301758766174,
0.029100924730300903,
0.03187224268913269,
0.5718626976013184,
-0.49050360918045044,
0.2978743612766266,
-0.519390881061554,
-0.09200511872768402,
0.30531203746795654,
-0.36251378059387207,
-0.2651698887348175,
0.5091718435287476,
0.649021327495575,
0.16432739794254303,
0.4583425521850586,
0.15069690346717834,
-0.1948259323835373,
0.06780596077442169,
0.20542080700397491,
-1.0236730575561523,
0.08728110790252686,
0.2129669189453125,
-0.6053768396377563,
-0.0703914538025856,
0.19359314441680908,
-0.5221307873725891,
-0.08881242573261261,
-0.026816565543413162,
0.17859923839569092,
-0.5590683221817017,
0.03938557952642441,
0.28564491868019104,
-0.16400925815105438,
-0.06950901448726654,
0.33420321345329285,
-0.6004332304000854,
0.4523842930793762,
0.6104238629341125,
0.5829267501831055,
-0.002345928456634283,
-0.48960942029953003,
0.20255932211875916,
0.404695987701416,
-0.18018731474876404,
0.569149911403656,
-0.5592148900032043,
-0.32621699571609497,
0.35450389981269836,
-0.3034200668334961,
0.11022559553384781,
-0.4033800959587097,
1.3605849742889404,
-0.6788551807403564,
-0.11198139190673828,
-0.06820652633905411,
-0.36956045031547546,
-0.4979032874107361,
-0.058389097452163696,
-0.9178045988082886,
0.9818390011787415,
-0.01500695664435625,
-1.0395032167434692,
0.1771739423274994,
-0.5281745791435242,
-0.4719488024711609,
0.2714035212993622,
-0.11701814085245132,
-0.37351226806640625,
-0.23617415130138397,
0.28295406699180603,
0.09755188226699829,
-0.18395401537418365,
0.0270802341401577,
0.372466504573822,
-0.6258901357650757,
0.11476055532693863,
-0.3252214789390564,
0.7479841709136963,
0.7227911353111267,
-0.0584738627076149,
0.14529940485954285,
-0.7839253544807434,
0.09353794157505035,
-0.16429588198661804,
-0.26995718479156494,
-0.2788463234901428,
-0.3297584056854248,
0.9377339482307434,
0.002689018379896879,
0.849272608757019,
-0.9069421887397766,
0.10733966529369354,
-0.10891014337539673,
0.0186806321144104,
0.12888479232788086,
-0.16634462773799896,
-0.2624650299549103,
-0.9354297518730164,
0.751366913318634,
0.056942153722047806,
-0.022702906280755997,
-0.4057474136352539,
-0.3252986967563629,
-0.47195830941200256,
-0.6063121557235718,
0.595624566078186,
0.5287637710571289,
-0.3753984570503235,
0.3204052746295929,
-0.20435082912445068,
-0.6886831521987915,
-0.6840597987174988,
0.13439904153347015,
0.6878749132156372,
-0.020123373717069626,
0.4537065029144287,
-0.012893552891910076,
-0.6910670399665833,
-1.009521245956421,
-0.5190607309341431,
-0.15138864517211914,
0.1792830526828766,
-0.208833247423172,
0.42427054047584534,
-0.45915770530700684,
0.6733444929122925,
-0.5093387961387634,
-0.48354411125183105,
-0.36710378527641296,
0.3888356685638428,
-0.00168691948056221,
0.5397718548774719,
0.5639985799789429,
-1.0093247890472412,
-0.8616271018981934,
0.04246922954916954,
-0.5806968808174133,
-0.24511078000068665,
0.097099170088768,
0.0741056427359581,
0.2950300872325897,
0.9211871027946472,
-0.1566876471042633,
0.818932831287384,
0.3311420679092407,
-0.17123329639434814,
0.27880793809890747,
-0.3255823254585266,
0.41270342469215393,
-0.7957161664962769,
0.11344005912542343,
-0.22663910686969757,
-0.40696024894714355,
-0.4450453817844391,
0.19810286164283752,
0.23903170228004456,
0.1512451320886612,
-0.24996605515480042,
0.5257325172424316,
-0.4210382401943207,
0.5651216506958008,
-0.36808502674102783,
0.1012859120965004,
-0.22715672850608826,
0.1345047652721405,
-0.10712222754955292,
0.9211440086364746,
0.31648093461990356,
-0.1892317533493042,
-0.08822540193796158,
0.3690026104450226,
-0.46326178312301636,
0.06336845457553864,
-0.7590054273605347,
0.10474354028701782,
-0.5982692837715149,
0.03306378796696663,
-1.1875022649765015,
-0.2482006847858429,
0.02988852933049202,
-0.08899357169866562,
-0.06507878005504608,
0.246433824300766,
-0.6051909327507019,
-0.03459696099162102,
-0.3197139799594879,
0.9126531481742859,
0.4757370352745056,
-0.358494371175766,
0.6237549781799316,
0.11624560505151749,
-0.8010672330856323,
-0.7396286725997925,
-0.7090877890586853,
-0.23484130203723907,
0.15141409635543823,
-0.48079004883766174,
0.19121965765953064,
-0.2940526604652405,
-0.23934510350227356,
-0.0570896677672863,
-0.20055539906024933,
-0.45446762442588806,
-0.22892813384532928,
0.664645254611969,
0.2209073007106781,
-0.26226943731307983,
0.042113132774829865,
0.47302326560020447,
-0.09080225229263306,
-0.24931669235229492,
0.4018200933933258,
0.47987252473831177,
-0.18145503103733063,
-0.22238659858703613,
-0.5499396324157715,
0.7442864179611206,
0.2890922427177429,
-0.1402839869260788,
0.9780482053756714,
0.4394989013671875,
-0.3676219582557678,
0.036842457950115204,
-0.5410815477371216,
0.2330891191959381,
-0.49393731355667114,
0.17253664135932922,
-0.7896467447280884,
-0.8757351040840149,
0.315631240606308,
-0.16616633534431458,
0.12931182980537415,
0.8074413537979126,
0.35609716176986694,
0.16044171154499054,
0.49586790800094604,
0.642928957939148,
-0.09458202123641968,
0.2444646805524826,
0.21334120631217957,
-0.0362052246928215,
-0.12631170451641083,
-0.3093584179878235,
-0.6888105273246765,
-0.3835177421569824,
-0.5959389209747314,
-0.2488437443971634,
0.2064829170703888,
0.3902401030063629,
-0.4372654855251312,
0.13876314461231232,
-0.3575844168663025,
0.7378910183906555,
0.5911568403244019,
0.014363761059939861,
0.8274052739143372,
0.061617542058229446,
-0.42849159240722656,
-0.23948661983013153,
-0.17537257075309753,
-1.056938648223877,
1.216077208518982,
0.13256576657295227,
0.44879332184791565,
0.5481976866722107,
1.1950331926345825,
0.4979126453399658,
0.5971665382385254,
-0.3447202742099762,
0.5623725652694702,
-0.06271839141845703,
-0.641219437122345,
-0.29398223757743835,
-0.2692038118839264,
-1.0788865089416504,
-0.11456523835659027,
0.02122717723250389,
-0.3789527416229248,
-0.20851393043994904,
-0.30645787715911865,
-0.29900437593460083,
-0.2148302048444748,
-0.5792895555496216,
0.78133624792099,
0.4578370451927185,
-0.03292836993932724,
-0.3392317295074463,
-0.860181450843811,
0.035735923796892166,
-0.4445168972015381,
0.22477427124977112,
0.047900598496198654,
-0.29735130071640015,
0.8177337646484375,
-0.40031957626342773,
0.5713769197463989,
0.29925084114074707,
0.3429040014743805,
0.47130489349365234,
0.0849122405052185,
0.059752799570560455,
-0.15403695404529572,
-0.30893462896347046,
0.2621136009693146,
0.4610743522644043,
-0.6244145631790161,
-0.1715051829814911,
0.6107902526855469,
-1.0252325534820557,
-0.6113702058792114,
-0.832713782787323,
-0.6399725675582886,
0.22094468772411346,
0.7063701748847961,
-0.08028380572795868,
0.40275782346725464,
-0.4417180120944977,
0.1693807989358902,
0.12713223695755005,
0.1892559677362442,
0.5653647184371948,
0.3532361388206482,
-0.6722586750984192,
-0.4126462936401367,
0.7770915031433105,
0.11173101514577866,
-0.09281948953866959,
0.42811936140060425,
0.18274490535259247,
-0.23313498497009277,
-0.6721034646034241,
-0.40964871644973755,
0.27670958638191223,
-0.5692623853683472,
0.09094639122486115,
-0.6389831304550171,
-0.5151594281196594,
-0.5044963955879211,
-0.2536139190196991,
0.05156628414988518,
-0.6454364061355591,
-0.16104896366596222,
-0.16161008179187775,
0.44685086607933044,
1.21575927734375,
-0.09298748522996902,
0.5912848114967346,
-0.8283730745315552,
0.4598148763179779,
0.09248317778110504,
0.010171890258789062,
-0.6626750230789185,
-0.5285165309906006,
-0.13413342833518982,
-0.17794309556484222,
-0.3107389211654663,
-0.6666774153709412,
0.3622564673423767,
0.23650261759757996,
0.1364370733499527,
0.4994522035121918,
0.34599360823631287,
0.2531740069389343,
-0.612111508846283,
0.513846755027771,
0.14544688165187836,
-0.8474239110946655,
0.26547005772590637,
-0.3146694600582123,
0.6170181035995483,
0.9429842233657837,
0.9954558610916138,
-0.45178622007369995,
-0.22982943058013916,
-0.5185945630073547,
-0.7237840890884399,
0.48784032464027405,
0.3364218771457672,
0.034646980464458466,
0.1457137018442154,
0.1961469054222107,
0.4386751055717468,
0.3889864385128021,
-0.5176124572753906,
-0.8888214230537415,
-0.0481976680457592,
-0.9826152920722961,
-0.1351812332868576,
-0.7309660911560059,
-0.19058093428611755,
-0.11187909543514252,
0.48075518012046814,
0.11374159157276154,
-0.2655630111694336,
0.34112080931663513,
-0.0887654572725296,
-0.06596895307302475,
0.563518762588501,
0.5626080632209778,
0.9737139940261841,
-0.36971932649612427,
0.1330108940601349,
-0.20843783020973206,
-1.1144840717315674,
0.1147397980093956,
0.561721682548523,
-0.6808371543884277,
0.2906376123428345,
0.24463121592998505,
0.24256272614002228,
-0.06817953288555145,
-1.1773731708526611,
0.5485674142837524,
0.024847103282809258,
-0.17530448734760284,
-0.6395086050033569,
-0.04359317198395729,
0.0935804545879364,
0.35817956924438477,
0.6157006025314331,
-0.03957394137978554,
0.29607564210891724,
-0.3860892355442047,
0.3118431866168976,
-0.015542675741016865,
-0.4078146517276764,
0.16337445378303528,
0.49064940214157104,
-0.09153199195861816,
-0.3936595022678375,
0.04234543442726135,
-0.3605228364467621,
-0.37932711839675903,
0.4722948968410492,
0.5808275938034058,
0.6107407808303833,
-0.2712274193763733,
0.3150225579738617,
0.43340834975242615,
0.39048275351524353,
-0.08755667507648468,
0.7451977729797363,
0.03155092895030975,
-0.5309209227561951,
-0.07044445723295212,
-0.831116795539856,
-0.5591617226600647,
-0.2310885637998581,
-0.6455705761909485,
0.21517877280712128,
-0.6872214078903198,
0.022921297699213028,
0.21881623566150665,
0.1413206160068512,
-0.5576080083847046,
0.41477474570274353,
0.009207077324390411,
0.8880847692489624,
-0.5671993494033813,
0.904565691947937,
1.0565650463104248,
-0.7679413557052612,
-0.4969373345375061,
0.05458185076713562,
-0.01619851589202881,
-0.5852658748626709,
0.9356403350830078,
0.24851851165294647,
-0.32465022802352905,
0.3575268089771271,
-0.4212353229522705,
-0.7073701620101929,
0.7680391073226929,
0.11967158317565918,
-0.6448049545288086,
0.05172748118638992,
0.4765668511390686,
0.5500284433364868,
-0.27702054381370544,
0.5462334752082825,
0.35631686449050903,
0.5024251937866211,
0.21768781542778015,
-0.8213577270507812,
0.1330796778202057,
-0.2877148985862732,
-0.056981395930051804,
0.2663521468639374,
-0.5467318296432495,
0.8292156457901001,
-0.17266058921813965,
-0.4280870854854584,
0.4799686372280121,
1.153163194656372,
0.14284685254096985,
0.6078651547431946,
0.2449771612882614,
0.7050966024398804,
0.5607407093048096,
0.18669450283050537,
0.8470805883407593,
-0.3241143226623535,
0.042070936411619186,
0.9797232747077942,
0.12820832431316376,
1.1887816190719604,
0.6243406534194946,
-0.354631245136261,
0.6445715427398682,
0.24682676792144775,
0.3913666605949402,
0.5221344232559204,
0.382556289434433,
-0.6888513565063477,
0.0494246743619442,
-0.42028743028640747,
-0.40516185760498047,
0.06682133674621582,
0.04234993830323219,
-0.3307284712791443,
-0.29738232493400574,
0.04712795466184616,
0.21117369830608368,
0.6508855223655701,
-0.5029750466346741,
0.537970244884491,
0.11936267465353012,
-0.4306369423866272,
0.4160735011100769,
0.21582791209220886,
0.47776103019714355,
-0.4590577483177185,
0.0576816089451313,
-0.0027271367143839598,
0.3012186884880066,
-0.22691404819488525,
-0.7335097789764404,
0.3596891462802887,
0.10075683891773224,
-0.3084636330604553,
-0.09334608912467957,
0.5995269417762756,
-0.7420756816864014,
-0.8342679738998413,
0.12855152785778046,
0.5336467623710632,
0.4822009205818176,
-0.15976515412330627,
-0.22922353446483612,
0.2822222411632538,
0.06207818537950516,
-0.13569697737693787,
0.15238440036773682,
0.6095572710037231,
0.11418426036834717,
0.5742343664169312,
0.4662168025970459,
0.10609747469425201,
0.281141072511673,
-0.05220040678977966,
0.8137365579605103,
-1.0595192909240723,
-0.3322423994541168,
-0.5880438089370728,
0.2792109251022339,
0.14603953063488007,
-0.6422398686408997,
0.6862080097198486,
0.7978214025497437,
0.8845473527908325,
-0.07760242372751236,
0.869952380657196,
0.11939754337072372,
0.9059581756591797,
-0.12691135704517365,
0.9123806953430176,
-0.5368584394454956,
-0.13391830027103424,
-0.1340622752904892,
-0.8033103942871094,
-0.32417136430740356,
0.5834342241287231,
-0.135379359126091,
0.06701119989156723,
1.0672054290771484,
0.762351393699646,
0.16954739391803741,
0.4874516427516937,
0.4972807466983795,
0.04778580740094185,
-0.5910042524337769,
0.3994455337524414,
0.6568619012832642,
-0.5885940790176392,
0.5903439521789551,
-0.11985471099615097,
-0.06539954990148544,
-0.3717919886112213,
-0.681458055973053,
-1.0318119525909424,
-0.6344186067581177,
-0.5134899020195007,
-0.25232231616973877,
0.24282026290893555,
1.1071300506591797,
-0.16636009514331818,
-0.9976496696472168,
-0.2768281102180481,
0.03417467325925827,
0.009447447024285793,
-0.22249159216880798,
-0.1553945690393448,
0.4984135031700134,
-0.025693077594041824,
-0.963679313659668,
0.0615522563457489,
-0.06845283508300781,
0.029554272070527077,
-0.01426749862730503,
0.03652243688702583,
-0.38851338624954224,
0.2494800090789795,
0.18071533739566803,
0.3670012056827545,
-0.40925702452659607,
-0.1280643790960312,
-0.5081295371055603,
-0.9119684100151062,
0.1604318916797638,
0.6427381634712219,
-0.6678127646446228,
0.32368120551109314,
0.42569977045059204,
0.7694113850593567,
0.5676881074905396,
0.010944300331175327,
0.2153424322605133,
-0.4823470711708069,
0.48715147376060486,
0.29269659519195557,
0.2045854777097702,
0.209415003657341,
-0.076204814016819,
0.44003909826278687,
-0.08358288556337357,
-0.6592978835105896,
-0.4654959738254547,
0.17909103631973267,
-1.2128897905349731,
-0.16948279738426208,
0.8612278699874878,
-0.3457694947719574,
-0.33606982231140137,
-0.5397105813026428,
-0.6010819673538208,
0.3943500220775604,
-0.5043039917945862,
0.5713452100753784,
0.5446057915687561,
0.3563244044780731,
-0.23260538280010223,
-0.40316399931907654,
0.7658236622810364,
0.704437255859375,
-0.7852391004562378,
-0.36896440386772156,
0.41187429428100586,
-0.006293305661529303,
0.2688850164413452,
0.45485419034957886,
-0.0027184649370610714,
0.215396910905838,
0.2982262969017029,
0.4718170166015625,
-0.1876591145992279,
-0.4015769958496094,
-0.3362712264060974,
0.4722086489200592,
0.15261825919151306,
-0.1120343953371048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18585v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18585v1
|
FREB-TQA: A Fine-Grained Robustness Evaluation Benchmark for Table Question Answering
| 2024-04-29T10:55:08 | 2024-04-29T10:55:08 |
Wei Zhou, Mohsen Mesgar, Heike Adel, Annemarie Friedrich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Table Question Answering (TQA) aims at composing an answer to a question
based on tabular data. While prior research has shown that TQA models lack
robustness, understanding the underlying cause and nature of this issue remains
predominantly unclear, posing a significant obstacle to the development of
robust TQA systems. In this paper, we formalize three major desiderata for a
fine-grained evaluation of robustness of TQA systems. They should (i) answer
questions regardless of alterations in table structure, (ii) base their
responses on the content of relevant cells rather than on biases, and (iii)
demonstrate robust numerical reasoning capabilities. To investigate these
aspects, we create and publish a novel TQA evaluation benchmark in English. Our
extensive experimental analysis reveals that none of the examined
state-of-the-art TQA systems consistently excels in these three aspects. Our
benchmark is a crucial instrument for monitoring the behavior of TQA systems
and paves the way for the development of robust TQA systems. We release our
benchmark publicly.
|
[
-0.6366909146308899,
-1.136039137840271,
0.6056457757949829,
0.17389684915542603,
-0.41654130816459656,
-0.0966576412320137,
0.2664366364479065,
-0.42454057931900024,
-0.3237416446208954,
0.030803542584180832,
-0.3085465431213379,
-0.5086836814880371,
-0.03933573141694069,
0.09834263473749161,
-0.37981852889060974,
0.8680517673492432,
-0.03975087031722069,
0.20029932260513306,
-0.46483343839645386,
-0.3289879858493805,
-0.6564291715621948,
-0.27033451199531555,
-0.3081406354904175,
-0.026022691279649734,
0.45464274287223816,
0.4762365520000458,
0.7303674817085266,
0.39532193541526794,
0.6358346343040466,
0.2543990910053253,
-0.0430169515311718,
-0.04409845918416977,
-0.3272304832935333,
0.3194824159145355,
-0.21292930841445923,
-0.4763169288635254,
-0.6103739738464355,
-0.3614250123500824,
0.6448061466217041,
0.4592118263244629,
-0.290946900844574,
0.6518200039863586,
0.10432742536067963,
0.8452286720275879,
-0.6669840812683105,
0.339232474565506,
-0.8700786232948303,
-0.12350603193044662,
-0.3865390419960022,
0.24036115407943726,
-0.33094722032546997,
-0.9709081649780273,
-0.18306387960910797,
-0.13540019094944,
-0.13253153860569,
-0.2947661280632019,
0.9668068885803223,
0.18132317066192627,
-0.25601890683174133,
0.19521357119083405,
-0.8286487460136414,
0.41084372997283936,
-0.6853051781654358,
0.7143564820289612,
0.17744052410125732,
0.7000951766967773,
-0.08518306910991669,
-0.8478322625160217,
-0.4766903817653656,
-0.20422133803367615,
0.07739540934562683,
-0.026775909587740898,
-0.25857827067375183,
-0.18138037621974945,
0.18981142342090607,
0.2946125864982605,
-0.7015293836593628,
-0.13155120611190796,
-0.16211141645908356,
-0.06351632624864578,
0.24637046456336975,
0.2987825572490692,
0.16771911084651947,
0.06219753995537758,
-0.40243229269981384,
-0.21037207543849945,
-0.3035043179988861,
0.29071399569511414,
-0.03910646587610245,
0.396337628364563,
-0.06852494925260544,
0.19627097249031067,
-0.42358365654945374,
0.7036328911781311,
-0.07766107469797134,
0.12267670035362244,
-0.047848720103502274,
-0.054806746542453766,
-0.4079899787902832,
-0.49528566002845764,
0.583236038684845,
0.31200551986694336,
0.03934365138411522,
-0.5973179340362549,
-0.4572224020957947,
0.19538985192775726,
0.43349000811576843,
-0.7516422271728516,
0.024751584976911545,
0.37067511677742004,
-0.3152645230293274,
-0.28583061695098877,
0.15207219123840332,
-1.0186845064163208,
-0.01621657982468605,
0.1325901448726654,
0.7154332399368286,
-0.4047528803348541,
0.02869504503905773,
-0.17363135516643524,
0.10118503123521805,
0.6442092657089233,
0.2799421548843384,
-0.7531508803367615,
0.5467970371246338,
0.8834193348884583,
0.5133808851242065,
-0.10708510875701904,
-0.27540117502212524,
-0.6371415853500366,
0.11440956592559814,
-0.4732185900211334,
1.1826258897781372,
-0.45596861839294434,
-0.09935202449560165,
-0.11332306265830994,
-0.1593879759311676,
0.018893806263804436,
-0.5283668041229248,
0.7584284543991089,
-0.7050516605377197,
-0.00421270402148366,
-0.48739925026893616,
-0.1248491182923317,
-0.13975949585437775,
0.5798275470733643,
-0.5245664119720459,
0.9648398160934448,
0.5434571504592896,
-0.7679376006126404,
0.4853587746620178,
-0.3670433461666107,
-0.1747077852487564,
-0.21632149815559387,
0.018444502726197243,
-0.49523502588272095,
0.18549269437789917,
0.1354324072599411,
0.22361046075820923,
-0.545020580291748,
0.5575740933418274,
-0.6046502590179443,
-0.39281508326530457,
0.5762900710105896,
-0.48999980092048645,
0.3246521055698395,
0.41972556710243225,
-0.06787271797657013,
0.08651549369096756,
-0.7894662618637085,
0.6203550696372986,
-0.10027451813220978,
-0.21159103512763977,
-0.1276557445526123,
-0.06188449636101723,
-0.131017804145813,
0.14492590725421906,
0.11438097059726715,
-0.4270932376384735,
-0.010423476807773113,
-0.11688918620347977,
0.3730250298976898,
0.7210617661476135,
0.11902876198291779,
-0.0007680578273721039,
-0.537736713886261,
0.4220900237560272,
0.006030334159731865,
0.3593967854976654,
0.5052737593650818,
-0.22080959379673004,
-0.2221411168575287,
-0.012121419422328472,
0.7530621290206909,
0.5378609895706177,
-0.7354562282562256,
-0.11598914861679077,
-0.17434148490428925,
-0.8717557191848755,
0.006131533533334732,
-0.24866807460784912,
0.49424847960472107,
0.5678980946540833,
0.4176775813102722,
-0.4238525927066803,
-0.13539522886276245,
-1.1685823202133179,
-0.4707369804382324,
-0.3069987893104553,
-0.285643070936203,
0.018328433856368065,
0.39208948612213135,
0.08537864685058594,
0.721052885055542,
-0.4526783525943756,
-0.04965446516871452,
-0.21853013336658478,
0.10372962802648544,
0.06099066510796547,
0.5705917477607727,
0.6427158713340759,
-0.507491946220398,
-0.48871374130249023,
-0.08720684796571732,
-0.5648156404495239,
-0.1249108612537384,
-0.03673314303159714,
-0.49130871891975403,
0.0672372505068779,
0.2232494056224823,
-0.45833805203437805,
0.16104841232299805,
0.05217144265770912,
-0.32412290573120117,
0.41518163681030273,
0.13910914957523346,
0.18369852006435394,
-0.8610852956771851,
0.40497082471847534,
-0.09706398099660873,
-0.039311133325099945,
-0.7369142174720764,
0.40088579058647156,
0.1759164184331894,
-0.06833695620298386,
-0.4245336353778839,
0.34736600518226624,
-0.08281403034925461,
-0.20419225096702576,
0.22817374765872955,
0.2386162281036377,
0.1584538221359253,
0.6069174408912659,
-0.3463253676891327,
0.7423989772796631,
0.210626021027565,
-0.5628512501716614,
-0.15897879004478455,
0.3964124023914337,
-0.13311105966567993,
0.9032391309738159,
-0.8481258153915405,
0.23125462234020233,
-0.020833466202020645,
-0.1898883432149887,
-0.8753991723060608,
-0.21028251945972443,
0.14801356196403503,
-0.49873021245002747,
0.3684033751487732,
-0.015899525955319405,
-0.19532014429569244,
-0.4685794711112976,
-0.4704815447330475,
0.08230748027563095,
0.22140885889530182,
-0.04102076590061188,
0.5799475312232971,
0.5128162503242493,
-0.07633727043867111,
-0.439977765083313,
-0.6365682482719421,
-0.2606053650379181,
-0.26970770955085754,
-0.5807942748069763,
0.13915473222732544,
0.12212260067462921,
-0.44725027680397034,
-0.24098427593708038,
-0.8305963277816772,
-0.7875003814697266,
0.4047921895980835,
-0.0640428364276886,
0.0014494170900434256,
-0.4389004707336426,
-0.09545216709375381,
0.1942194700241089,
-0.014058202505111694,
0.34473833441734314,
0.14842481911182404,
0.5286253690719604,
-0.6175282001495361,
0.04157606512308121,
-0.646480917930603,
0.24864113330841064,
0.7441098093986511,
-0.33131784200668335,
0.4327028691768646,
0.5063440799713135,
-0.6126425266265869,
0.06949993222951889,
-0.39938563108444214,
-0.2390916347503662,
-0.47175854444503784,
0.2177160084247589,
-0.5682739615440369,
-0.3650088310241699,
0.9572504162788391,
0.20400741696357727,
0.16572317481040955,
0.5127304196357727,
0.13388459384441376,
-0.08814335614442825,
0.7412443161010742,
0.36141669750213623,
0.37228140234947205,
0.1434619277715683,
0.09655342251062393,
-0.2689293920993805,
-0.5838712453842163,
-0.42199280858039856,
-1.3146342039108276,
-0.26384133100509644,
-0.590723991394043,
-0.20754292607307434,
0.3733070492744446,
0.08584630489349365,
-0.5903319120407104,
0.19194157421588898,
-0.44974377751350403,
0.4266902804374695,
0.6413974761962891,
0.1479918360710144,
0.2905026376247406,
-0.31958577036857605,
-0.2034006267786026,
0.0903165265917778,
-0.5224108099937439,
-0.8216540217399597,
0.5526082515716553,
0.36127933859825134,
0.9275283217430115,
0.22845599055290222,
0.5946207642555237,
0.255264014005661,
0.44663316011428833,
-0.455973744392395,
0.630144476890564,
-0.15971575677394867,
-0.6151512265205383,
-0.5214194655418396,
-0.500809371471405,
-0.7673022150993347,
0.12457642704248428,
-0.14661619067192078,
-1.0330417156219482,
0.3494652807712555,
0.11541528254747391,
-0.459428071975708,
0.28949257731437683,
-0.766124963760376,
1.3387832641601562,
-0.06849034130573273,
-0.713661253452301,
0.3159957528114319,
-0.7132385969161987,
0.3186626434326172,
-0.09059013426303864,
-0.06451546400785446,
-0.20442667603492737,
0.17860007286071777,
0.8094037175178528,
-0.392448365688324,
0.5154414772987366,
-0.45520395040512085,
-0.12694983184337616,
0.3924655020236969,
0.5109284520149231,
0.40522533655166626,
0.4350367784500122,
-0.2905677258968353,
0.07929731905460358,
0.8052787184715271,
-0.4896804094314575,
-0.5836445093154907,
0.5445457696914673,
-0.5231059789657593,
-0.5273751616477966,
-0.39800140261650085,
-0.4466162919998169,
-0.9650306105613708,
0.40094658732414246,
-0.25642725825309753,
0.6764098405838013,
-0.4930444359779358,
0.42589932680130005,
0.519787609577179,
0.033255647867918015,
0.28475505113601685,
0.5665248036384583,
0.04891276732087135,
-0.5780938267707825,
0.6474533677101135,
0.1958823949098587,
0.1005517989397049,
0.674426257610321,
0.15341700613498688,
-0.5330637097358704,
-0.866992712020874,
-0.7972279787063599,
-0.1487279087305069,
-0.4437183737754822,
-0.6639743447303772,
-0.4171353876590729,
0.042648255825042725,
-0.07652201503515244,
-0.07506759464740753,
-0.2635806202888489,
-0.5435462594032288,
0.16025418043136597,
-0.05246152728796005,
0.03440297394990921,
0.6423150897026062,
0.10438045859336853,
0.009072015061974525,
-1.1949330568313599,
0.7212479710578918,
0.7582507729530334,
1.0535728931427002,
0.09096831828355789,
-0.27196967601776123,
-0.021374450996518135,
0.05645081400871277,
-0.48480382561683655,
-1.104831576347351,
-0.12048255652189255,
0.06172608584165573,
0.757251501083374,
0.32939550280570984,
0.4290868043899536,
0.6084874868392944,
-0.27321118116378784,
0.6646156907081604,
-0.3828378915786743,
-1.2600723505020142,
0.5441529750823975,
-0.5811957716941833,
0.38671261072158813,
1.1529765129089355,
0.13416896760463715,
-0.10683231055736542,
-0.6905601620674133,
-0.37581220269203186,
-0.7119771242141724,
0.642353892326355,
0.19950395822525024,
-0.06159562990069389,
-0.036940813064575195,
0.4074415862560272,
0.4088793992996216,
0.21638420224189758,
-0.7071859836578369,
-0.05289381369948387,
-0.26989781856536865,
0.0679466500878334,
0.4796786308288574,
-0.41779929399490356,
-0.05498470366001129,
0.08267056941986084,
0.5680636763572693,
-0.1703929454088211,
0.20783738791942596,
0.2152842879295349,
-0.0275743268430233,
-0.14531588554382324,
0.7439896464347839,
0.5264426469802856,
0.8081724643707275,
-0.6250110864639282,
0.0662502869963646,
0.36780864000320435,
-0.6744628548622131,
0.20780934393405914,
0.2547518014907837,
-0.5689456462860107,
-0.22447621822357178,
-0.15068675577640533,
0.3056875169277191,
-0.0642894059419632,
-0.37489840388298035,
-0.029421793296933174,
-0.4877983033657074,
-0.06507433205842972,
0.2386540174484253,
0.04440762475132942,
-0.17289215326309204,
0.27254047989845276,
0.4938395023345947,
-0.022834736853837967,
0.34132054448127747,
-0.6559804081916809,
0.4574078619480133,
0.5352715849876404,
-0.5255229473114014,
-0.2877439260482788,
0.9642559289932251,
0.06855517625808716,
-0.10937543213367462,
0.2598358392715454,
-0.12446660548448563,
-0.2733466625213623,
0.6166837811470032,
0.4316304624080658,
0.9651602506637573,
-0.20086351037025452,
0.4967461824417114,
0.21290934085845947,
0.6493747234344482,
0.20897267758846283,
0.8649238348007202,
-0.009996341541409492,
-0.33252570033073425,
0.18538899719715118,
-0.6939420700073242,
-0.6296483278274536,
0.094843789935112,
-1.1193177700042725,
-0.09339836239814758,
-0.4326484203338623,
-0.29675155878067017,
0.14731289446353912,
0.13562768697738647,
-0.4195372462272644,
0.39441680908203125,
-0.24657294154167175,
1.1560441255569458,
-0.7141582369804382,
0.5627695918083191,
0.7571228742599487,
-0.35833147168159485,
-0.9190922379493713,
0.2254747450351715,
-0.5323988199234009,
-0.3433903753757477,
-0.04172834753990173,
0.06731913238763809,
-0.03205596283078194,
-0.22045336663722992,
-0.3439999222755432,
-0.7681509256362915,
0.9339266419410706,
0.6106756925582886,
-0.16948647797107697,
0.14397719502449036,
0.3351544141769409,
0.7733839750289917,
0.2596290409564972,
0.13029302656650543,
0.7846774458885193,
0.6647005677223206,
-0.15812036395072937,
-0.8646522760391235,
0.40011346340179443,
-0.13368280231952667,
0.03787205368280411,
0.37566325068473816,
-0.9030206799507141,
0.49549442529678345,
-0.1274975836277008,
-0.21115700900554657,
0.24165229499340057,
0.792835533618927,
0.05550503730773926,
0.7025900483131409,
0.3662984371185303,
0.46672534942626953,
0.6119377613067627,
-0.6677206754684448,
0.6112282872200012,
-0.1968652307987213,
0.1584465652704239,
1.213034987449646,
-0.42906782031059265,
1.0548230409622192,
0.3641209304332733,
-0.47320497035980225,
0.513136088848114,
0.5816969275474548,
0.12157148122787476,
0.45350417494773865,
0.2983039319515228,
0.08908326923847198,
-0.19784237444400787,
0.02797003835439682,
-0.5218634605407715,
0.7421808838844299,
0.2183254063129425,
0.17447565495967865,
-0.5051324367523193,
-0.32466235756874084,
-0.18821610510349274,
0.1377679407596588,
-0.34722575545310974,
0.9420647621154785,
-0.16782982647418976,
-0.6618930101394653,
0.7914460897445679,
-0.1161913052201271,
-0.1094595193862915,
-0.5980736017227173,
0.18233193457126617,
-0.7510892152786255,
-0.024515651166439056,
-0.10189385712146759,
-0.8401073217391968,
0.6460714936256409,
0.22040335834026337,
-0.012335218489170074,
0.20415310561656952,
0.4223249852657318,
-0.08102027326822281,
-0.19832098484039307,
-0.24376961588859558,
0.9173460006713867,
-0.046214137226343155,
0.04277503862977028,
-0.5380174517631531,
0.06906009465456009,
-0.12769721448421478,
-0.02426840178668499,
0.23350727558135986,
0.7928249835968018,
-0.29677674174308777,
0.6867830157279968,
0.19897086918354034,
-0.44653162360191345,
-0.23040981590747833,
0.0657053217291832,
1.0677871704101562,
-0.7565506100654602,
-0.40925803780555725,
-0.5972729325294495,
0.3730003535747528,
0.12086724489927292,
-0.22585329413414001,
0.5963844656944275,
0.6511914134025574,
0.5189415812492371,
-0.15562497079372406,
0.24375662207603455,
-0.1899612843990326,
0.32998761534690857,
-0.4317252039909363,
0.9163906574249268,
-0.4533063471317291,
0.1571974903345108,
-0.6973432898521423,
-0.9971995949745178,
-0.45831626653671265,
0.28201791644096375,
-0.05393797531723976,
0.09978675097227097,
0.6827664375305176,
0.5670854449272156,
0.031851112842559814,
0.06554479897022247,
0.37617596983909607,
0.33556100726127625,
0.04183452948927879,
0.33306050300598145,
0.7558185458183289,
-0.5242059826850891,
0.7666486501693726,
-0.5132082104682922,
0.014940585941076279,
0.034094396978616714,
-0.7166129350662231,
-0.5771126747131348,
-0.5527347922325134,
-0.28501978516578674,
-0.38022327423095703,
0.18554513156414032,
0.427389532327652,
0.32574963569641113,
-1.140876054763794,
0.01150593627244234,
-0.08300816267728806,
0.4220591187477112,
-0.5363743305206299,
-0.2960919439792633,
0.57724928855896,
-0.24260228872299194,
-0.5163792371749878,
0.036301854997873306,
0.16643530130386353,
0.26800209283828735,
-0.04417325556278229,
0.5880810618400574,
-0.026121223345398903,
0.33431369066238403,
0.46349719166755676,
0.37099120020866394,
-0.284992516040802,
-0.4229559600353241,
0.20680873095989227,
-0.1346074342727661,
0.1862085908651352,
0.34346434473991394,
-0.6940005421638489,
0.18435285985469818,
0.5629439353942871,
0.6041774153709412,
0.13175970315933228,
0.3251190185546875,
0.5045795440673828,
-0.5182808041572571,
-0.16442416608333588,
0.4666748642921448,
0.19194450974464417,
0.03570016473531723,
-0.013141311705112457,
0.6082697510719299,
-0.30498334765434265,
-0.6451089978218079,
-1.280074954032898,
-0.027599284425377846,
-1.1908661127090454,
-0.03509220853447914,
0.6127299070358276,
-0.1291709989309311,
-0.33626553416252136,
-0.3018316626548767,
-0.10915586352348328,
0.17905950546264648,
-0.5200909972190857,
1.244444489479065,
0.4527330994606018,
-0.11386135220527649,
0.22711311280727386,
-0.3193403482437134,
0.5543222427368164,
0.2580395042896271,
-1.2625174522399902,
0.21858926117420197,
0.5877522826194763,
0.19407889246940613,
0.024360228329896927,
0.4981713593006134,
-0.3438616991043091,
0.6792278289794922,
0.1731291115283966,
-0.3297412693500519,
0.027291985228657722,
-0.40400901436805725,
-0.091866634786129,
0.6942686438560486,
0.4671206772327423,
-0.23789054155349731
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04585v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04585v1
|
PoPE: Legendre Orthogonal Polynomials Based Position Encoding for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-29T10:30:59 | 2024-04-29T10:30:59 |
Arpit Aggarwal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
There are several improvements proposed over the baseline Absolute Positional
Encoding (APE) method used in original transformer. In this study, we aim to
investigate the implications of inadequately representing positional encoding
in higher dimensions on crucial aspects of the attention mechanism, the model's
capacity to learn relative positional information, and the convergence of
models, all stemming from the choice of sinusoidal basis functions. Through a
combination of theoretical insights and empirical analyses, we elucidate how
these challenges extend beyond APEs and may adversely affect the performance of
Relative Positional Encoding (RPE) methods, such as Rotatory Positional
Encoding (RoPE).
Subsequently, we introduce an innovative solution termed Orthogonal
Polynomial Based Positional Encoding (PoPE) to address some of the limitations
associated with existing methods. The PoPE method encodes positional
information by leveraging Orthogonal Legendre polynomials. Legendre polynomials
as basis functions offers several desirable properties for positional encoding,
including improved correlation structure, non-periodicity, orthogonality, and
distinct functional forms among polynomials of varying orders. Our experimental
findings demonstrate that transformer models incorporating PoPE outperform
baseline transformer models on the $Multi30k$ English-to-German translation
task, thus establishing a new performance benchmark. Furthermore, PoPE-based
transformers exhibit significantly accelerated convergence rates.
Additionally, we will present novel theoretical perspectives on position
encoding based on the superior performance of PoPE.
|
[
-0.3212588131427765,
-0.12033312022686005,
0.2581871449947357,
0.5517395734786987,
-0.10107968002557755,
-0.17433495819568634,
-0.33832186460494995,
-0.5430567860603333,
-0.00822579488158226,
0.41072580218315125,
0.029742460697889328,
0.013915251940488815,
-0.8713969588279724,
0.3421541452407837,
-0.26326996088027954,
0.6836429238319397,
0.11996077001094818,
0.13575290143489838,
0.20548777282238007,
-0.0729866623878479,
-0.06995736062526703,
-0.8843568563461304,
-0.258658766746521,
-0.3924795687198639,
0.24452857673168182,
0.3823816180229187,
0.9851083159446716,
0.855356752872467,
0.688107430934906,
0.2846008241176605,
-0.04955257475376129,
0.018823474645614624,
-0.6857247352600098,
-0.04234060272574425,
-0.09001899510622025,
-0.5253176093101501,
-0.5728753209114075,
-0.04724791646003723,
0.8999003767967224,
0.9114279747009277,
0.003423633286729455,
0.20847053825855255,
0.14406388998031616,
0.7044454216957092,
-0.4757528603076935,
0.2214042842388153,
-0.6992201805114746,
0.19395676255226135,
-0.04191981628537178,
-0.6037002801895142,
-0.5593506693840027,
-0.13866424560546875,
0.1645837128162384,
-0.25655224919319153,
0.46274334192276,
-0.09488606452941895,
0.6510919332504272,
0.1580866277217865,
-0.41968876123428345,
-0.05462915822863579,
-0.9510744214057922,
0.9830302596092224,
-0.7389453649520874,
0.9729716181755066,
0.4427454471588135,
0.0025755921378731728,
-0.22240480780601501,
-0.3988834321498871,
-0.3942665457725525,
-0.25807732343673706,
0.016111141070723534,
-0.00950420368462801,
-0.08432907611131668,
-0.14841288328170776,
0.3308977484703064,
0.36693811416625977,
-0.389166921377182,
-0.04723189026117325,
-0.5662156939506531,
0.22341102361679077,
0.6840150952339172,
-0.2745697498321533,
0.020330678671598434,
-0.20787514746189117,
-0.43606454133987427,
-0.4035838544368744,
-0.7651489973068237,
0.3626840114593506,
0.38709163665771484,
0.12585824728012085,
-0.12377684563398361,
0.47711002826690674,
0.2603587210178375,
0.5728732347488403,
0.45657801628112793,
-0.38612258434295654,
0.13412968814373016,
0.24530164897441864,
-0.0800972655415535,
0.126630038022995,
0.6087012887001038,
0.3790183663368225,
0.30306047201156616,
-0.36479467153549194,
-0.19106809794902802,
-0.48214319348335266,
0.4717923104763031,
-0.67038893699646,
-0.051062483340501785,
0.0009886667830869555,
-0.640869677066803,
-0.3274155855178833,
0.40364304184913635,
-0.7224363088607788,
-0.09397634863853455,
-0.31246742606163025,
0.04884995147585869,
-0.4893497824668884,
-0.06301429867744446,
-0.033049240708351135,
0.0037642917595803738,
0.4461091160774231,
0.12450826168060303,
-1.2772022485733032,
0.38319817185401917,
0.7309135794639587,
0.5456363558769226,
-0.30309200286865234,
-0.509800374507904,
-0.3558618724346161,
0.4023149609565735,
-0.49991488456726074,
0.663558304309845,
-0.4632330536842346,
-0.34251323342323303,
0.03791927173733711,
0.11625821888446808,
-0.33810797333717346,
-0.6379432082176208,
0.5728545188903809,
-0.5303518772125244,
-0.16716575622558594,
-0.0679553672671318,
-0.22145810723304749,
-0.40180718898773193,
-0.14765805006027222,
-0.8589158058166504,
0.9567047357559204,
0.21236567199230194,
-0.5237356424331665,
-0.011661972850561142,
-0.2542455196380615,
-0.6076789498329163,
-0.1416037529706955,
-0.27714917063713074,
-0.1885271966457367,
0.5370066165924072,
0.23787929117679596,
0.3532809913158417,
-0.5764074325561523,
0.3302270174026489,
-0.19504642486572266,
-0.5237935185432434,
0.545447587966919,
-0.7575364708900452,
0.6504220366477966,
-0.04396522417664528,
-0.661565899848938,
-0.16730540990829468,
-0.7585437893867493,
-0.04479941725730896,
0.03853346407413483,
-0.2183958888053894,
-0.17149662971496582,
0.1404193788766861,
-0.03231246396899223,
0.1791549026966095,
0.2605946958065033,
-0.24467159807682037,
0.16056393086910248,
-0.27444028854370117,
0.5976429581642151,
0.5852165818214417,
-0.2822355329990387,
0.5795115828514099,
-0.05329754948616028,
0.5823277831077576,
-0.3584206998348236,
0.1454535573720932,
-0.043150413781404495,
-0.5606085062026978,
-0.4855285584926605,
0.08438960462808609,
0.2835186719894409,
0.8168339133262634,
-0.4147145450115204,
0.35894089937210083,
-0.33332574367523193,
-0.19501470029354095,
-0.25914135575294495,
0.0009527493384666741,
0.1683099865913391,
0.5521078705787659,
0.29120275378227234,
-0.26307427883148193,
-0.4021713137626648,
-0.9967479705810547,
0.10801247507333755,
-0.45847833156585693,
-0.16003422439098358,
0.4334718883037567,
0.1974285989999771,
0.22483330965042114,
0.7232958078384399,
-0.3325200080871582,
-0.21692532300949097,
-0.38231053948402405,
0.23662133514881134,
0.48960018157958984,
0.5574079155921936,
0.7392727136611938,
-1.0557889938354492,
-0.3224702477455139,
0.0834491103887558,
-0.6691226959228516,
-0.05677293986082077,
-0.2252219170331955,
0.276142418384552,
0.165756955742836,
0.34739693999290466,
-0.5845893025398254,
0.3497060239315033,
0.7735859155654907,
0.2036885768175125,
0.5682922601699829,
-0.4824214279651642,
0.40839290618896484,
-0.5387351512908936,
0.1861811727285385,
-0.18768441677093506,
-0.12123759835958481,
-0.8705521821975708,
0.08483120054006577,
0.324282169342041,
-0.5005359053611755,
-0.3487606346607208,
0.004789141938090324,
-0.33539798855781555,
-0.09249426424503326,
-0.3798137307167053,
-0.13482750952243805,
-0.18874700367450714,
0.911125659942627,
0.3502592146396637,
0.9983466267585754,
0.3710666298866272,
-0.38783183693885803,
-0.06521040201187134,
0.15978208184242249,
0.15646366775035858,
0.2372117042541504,
-0.908514142036438,
0.18141314387321472,
-0.18550680577754974,
0.19844231009483337,
-0.837165117263794,
0.17715522646903992,
0.24522484838962555,
-0.5464612245559692,
0.43602535128593445,
-0.21339242160320282,
-0.1841728538274765,
-0.41146785020828247,
-0.3790234327316284,
0.5525241494178772,
0.4279564619064331,
-0.4708101451396942,
0.3979436457157135,
0.29257285594940186,
-0.24929426610469818,
-0.8387387990951538,
-0.40201079845428467,
0.16112364828586578,
-0.31726545095443726,
-0.532673180103302,
0.6968775987625122,
0.08731270581483841,
-0.024007314816117287,
-0.2269880622625351,
-0.3195803165435791,
-0.19678258895874023,
-0.19573400914669037,
0.09234657138586044,
0.21179775893688202,
-0.4571828544139862,
-0.10357209295034409,
-0.33228251338005066,
-0.24846559762954712,
0.023106371983885765,
-0.6083549857139587,
0.5790559649467468,
-0.1889207512140274,
-0.19639064371585846,
-0.3680765926837921,
0.6987500786781311,
0.8264272212982178,
-0.3752206861972809,
0.7528725862503052,
0.3804536759853363,
-0.3948352634906769,
-0.1872122585773468,
-0.558285117149353,
-0.1394818127155304,
-0.4710251986980438,
0.32522717118263245,
-0.2943929135799408,
-0.7375404238700867,
0.4812536835670471,
-0.051176682114601135,
-0.2798917889595032,
0.31588077545166016,
0.2615264058113098,
-0.024327339604496956,
1.2379140853881836,
1.1119160652160645,
-0.11153533309698105,
0.3250468671321869,
-0.31574949622154236,
0.6675670146942139,
-0.8915321826934814,
-0.12172607332468033,
-0.6832687854766846,
-0.2732658386230469,
-0.49777573347091675,
-0.6113137602806091,
0.28390175104141235,
0.7516144514083862,
-0.1906561255455017,
0.5553072094917297,
-0.42064300179481506,
0.16789047420024872,
0.4839269816875458,
-0.21713073551654816,
0.15886498987674713,
0.1524663120508194,
-0.01217748038470745,
-0.45454341173171997,
-0.8989386558532715,
-0.5937069058418274,
0.9567039012908936,
0.5233756303787231,
0.8313735127449036,
-0.019673608243465424,
0.19300279021263123,
0.19935324788093567,
0.0901406928896904,
-0.7654798626899719,
0.28237077593803406,
-0.480268657207489,
-0.08708712458610535,
-0.333482027053833,
-0.05513901263475418,
-0.5273817777633667,
0.24782447516918182,
0.11590706557035446,
-0.8704355359077454,
0.8408310413360596,
0.20975925028324127,
-0.35120561718940735,
0.30807065963745117,
-0.3482750356197357,
0.7596570253372192,
-0.4367983639240265,
-0.1496126800775528,
-0.00973542034626007,
-0.48124122619628906,
0.06566312164068222,
-0.10718578845262527,
0.09542188048362732,
0.1773342788219452,
-0.019454414024949074,
0.5348141193389893,
-0.25184366106987,
0.8815706968307495,
0.02839895337820053,
-0.5417010188102722,
-0.04089707136154175,
-0.11321641504764557,
0.7019422650337219,
0.35429704189300537,
-0.2658607065677643,
0.6097481846809387,
-0.2601067125797272,
-0.19918175041675568,
-0.6748642921447754,
0.4352082312107086,
-0.7994673848152161,
-0.8219414353370667,
-0.3326156437397003,
-0.8186773061752319,
-0.2251507043838501,
0.0840732678771019,
0.5751490592956543,
0.6131316423416138,
0.1617187261581421,
0.36931276321411133,
0.7727946043014526,
-0.24946625530719757,
0.35919061303138733,
0.4469875991344452,
0.01817585900425911,
-0.6686233282089233,
0.8149793744087219,
0.10627985000610352,
0.2485901415348053,
0.7280834913253784,
-0.01922059804201126,
-0.1841326504945755,
-0.756109356880188,
-0.4060077965259552,
0.36940765380859375,
-0.5271677374839783,
-0.15808144211769104,
-0.44233769178390503,
-0.2681828737258911,
-0.6245818138122559,
-0.3121485114097595,
-0.5379477143287659,
-0.6199297308921814,
-0.034666892141103745,
0.26688528060913086,
-0.0687674880027771,
0.5724824666976929,
-0.2611885666847229,
0.3320297300815582,
-0.7217458486557007,
0.40128448605537415,
0.3262433707714081,
0.32715293765068054,
0.2444949746131897,
-0.48258110880851746,
-0.17188295722007751,
-0.03310201317071915,
-0.2835320830345154,
-0.9847413301467896,
0.5674375891685486,
0.20285853743553162,
0.7087597250938416,
0.5305262804031372,
0.14467589557170868,
0.8136478662490845,
-1.1219109296798706,
0.5930051207542419,
0.02790069580078125,
-1.0223678350448608,
0.22732755541801453,
-0.14347875118255615,
0.0575932152569294,
0.2532758414745331,
0.5413106083869934,
-0.6392377614974976,
-0.4237006902694702,
-0.4528999328613281,
-0.8289868831634521,
0.8240326046943665,
0.32822680473327637,
0.044485900551080704,
-0.04966500401496887,
0.29532578587532043,
0.21706102788448334,
0.17010550200939178,
-0.6164848208427429,
-0.3122793436050415,
-0.39771977066993713,
0.21438735723495483,
-0.18507829308509827,
-0.3765450417995453,
0.0037816918920725584,
-0.2659532427787781,
0.6207303404808044,
-0.21544775366783142,
0.6872039437294006,
0.5102997422218323,
-0.2785734236240387,
-0.335334450006485,
0.28412824869155884,
1.117218255996704,
0.9776066541671753,
-0.19602662324905396,
0.21172259747982025,
0.17874695360660553,
-0.4290149509906769,
0.023883650079369545,
0.22173462808132172,
-0.1636073887348175,
0.11748728156089783,
0.5461298227310181,
0.8471497893333435,
0.5300251245498657,
-0.5292526483535767,
0.44490429759025574,
0.11135278642177582,
0.0410601943731308,
-0.6252251863479614,
-0.24819989502429962,
-0.10131523013114929,
0.2685296833515167,
1.020853042602539,
0.22790496051311493,
0.04958873242139816,
-0.2225484699010849,
0.37683117389678955,
0.3075801730155945,
-0.5865291357040405,
-0.5083023905754089,
0.849380612373352,
-0.10294950753450394,
-0.5804535150527954,
0.4419668912887573,
0.08086356520652771,
-0.8579568266868591,
0.7439273595809937,
1.0324997901916504,
0.6031041145324707,
-0.622858464717865,
0.25891369581222534,
0.2665620744228363,
0.4229777157306671,
-0.14877891540527344,
0.15870407223701477,
-0.2955567538738251,
-0.5693944096565247,
-0.5027361512184143,
-0.569832444190979,
-0.27977249026298523,
0.24322596192359924,
-0.6876415014266968,
0.06216505914926529,
-0.2704230844974518,
0.0081425029784441,
-0.14640691876411438,
-0.4422883093357086,
-0.19447539746761322,
-0.18618403375148773,
0.24231082201004028,
0.9191240072250366,
-0.6369494795799255,
1.0724904537200928,
0.7540937662124634,
-0.03826208785176277,
-0.9394346475601196,
0.1756351888179779,
-0.3096453845500946,
-0.7657924890518188,
1.050379991531372,
0.2216675728559494,
-0.3435524106025696,
-0.12369247525930405,
-0.25519102811813354,
-1.0100008249282837,
0.8561599254608154,
0.5797710418701172,
-0.443447470664978,
-0.10244016349315643,
0.7169525027275085,
0.5776755809783936,
-0.5479496717453003,
-0.024248884990811348,
0.2902860641479492,
0.3312690854072571,
-0.12502475082874298,
-1.1068474054336548,
-0.18561473488807678,
-0.40345314145088196,
0.4603111743927002,
0.19299505650997162,
-0.538539707660675,
1.01775324344635,
-0.005015890579670668,
0.09421820193529129,
0.18194913864135742,
0.7158313393592834,
0.11066232621669769,
-0.3733031749725342,
0.3414748013019562,
0.22525514662265778,
0.4499083161354065,
0.22006690502166748,
0.9950470924377441,
-0.7712808847427368,
0.4724954068660736,
0.7186684608459473,
-0.16203856468200684,
0.9129465222358704,
0.5326768755912781,
-0.1931232213973999,
0.24902501702308655,
0.035216789692640305,
-0.11989782005548477,
0.4110877513885498,
-0.17505574226379395,
-0.009461715817451477,
-0.26641741394996643,
-0.11591318994760513,
-0.6549762487411499,
0.4721798598766327,
0.2879650890827179,
-0.6481698751449585,
-0.23501060903072357,
0.17855115234851837,
-0.27047640085220337,
0.18057012557983398,
-0.28245809674263,
0.28895094990730286,
0.17071306705474854,
-0.6581932902336121,
1.1744170188903809,
0.10031894594430923,
0.6323477029800415,
-0.6118595004081726,
-0.27548617124557495,
-0.10733575373888016,
0.37318184971809387,
0.006298282649368048,
-0.4752730131149292,
0.14428488910198212,
-0.23180945217609406,
-0.445577472448349,
-0.5272964239120483,
0.6151337027549744,
-0.5415686964988708,
-0.5431903004646301,
0.28499114513397217,
-0.004658099263906479,
0.03702211380004883,
0.12565989792346954,
-0.5045788288116455,
0.16446931660175323,
-0.04209607094526291,
0.041837166994810104,
0.0830404981970787,
0.3521009683609009,
-0.27774396538734436,
0.4372798502445221,
0.4390953481197357,
0.17054541409015656,
0.04523899406194687,
-0.09660740941762924,
0.2840315103530884,
-0.7406912446022034,
-0.7331339120864868,
-0.554746687412262,
0.094817616045475,
0.07925189286470413,
-0.2108420878648758,
0.5803302526473999,
0.36220306158065796,
0.760004460811615,
-0.43919292092323303,
0.4901064336299896,
-0.039742276072502136,
0.18168120086193085,
-0.20017410814762115,
0.7034661769866943,
-0.2312656044960022,
0.29237645864486694,
-0.25250765681266785,
-1.1203190088272095,
-0.35675787925720215,
0.8667883276939392,
-0.24932259321212769,
-0.2921872138977051,
0.7970600724220276,
0.4643670916557312,
-0.1589808315038681,
0.32285749912261963,
0.3435691297054291,
0.10914406180381775,
0.19327417016029358,
0.7681201696395874,
0.6266359686851501,
-0.6460177302360535,
0.597135603427887,
-0.6639085412025452,
-0.3286856412887573,
-0.16805680096149445,
-1.0081915855407715,
-0.7520546913146973,
-0.6373459696769714,
0.05842192843556404,
0.16058704257011414,
0.16248397529125214,
0.8928046226501465,
0.8167751431465149,
-1.1080141067504883,
-0.6565951108932495,
0.1366291493177414,
-0.0011548581533133984,
-0.7499616146087646,
-0.164084792137146,
0.6562792062759399,
-0.3408924341201782,
-0.850641131401062,
0.49010321497917175,
0.5163935422897339,
-0.06949128955602646,
-0.10386890172958374,
-0.2192840278148651,
-0.07128607481718063,
-0.2132040411233902,
0.7290897369384766,
0.5505728721618652,
-0.7288267612457275,
-0.5149264931678772,
0.2933874726295471,
-0.06346234679222107,
0.46302351355552673,
1.1883602142333984,
-0.7592619061470032,
-0.3022383749485016,
0.5105534791946411,
0.5657588243484497,
0.1880207657814026,
0.11820904910564423,
1.0872167348861694,
-0.3134619891643524,
0.39050260186195374,
0.20497047901153564,
0.32053059339523315,
0.24196209013462067,
-0.582631528377533,
0.37701308727264404,
0.11883680522441864,
-0.4244522154331207,
-0.7751282453536987,
0.1447213888168335,
-0.9912175536155701,
-0.18705476820468903,
0.8023723363876343,
-0.1495535969734192,
-0.3210415840148926,
-0.005960944574326277,
-0.05830736830830574,
0.06992258876562119,
-0.3122030794620514,
0.9448060393333435,
0.5692344307899475,
-0.35474443435668945,
-0.2867383658885956,
-0.7018149495124817,
0.4899766147136688,
0.5840074419975281,
-0.21113528311252594,
0.27981480956077576,
0.1667548567056656,
0.0882033035159111,
0.4876353144645691,
0.2045762985944748,
-0.3431909680366516,
0.5331369042396545,
-0.23613077402114868,
-0.09832711517810822,
-0.030951378867030144,
-0.5443388223648071,
-0.568488359451294,
0.6787792444229126,
0.052888307720422745,
0.27437812089920044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18570v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18570v1
|
Analyzing Semantic Change through Lexical Replacements
| 2024-04-29T10:20:41 | 2024-04-29T10:20:41 |
Francesco Periti, Pierluigi Cassotti, Haim Dubossarsky, Nina Tahmasebi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modern language models are capable of contextualizing words based on their
surrounding context. However, this capability is often compromised due to
semantic change that leads to words being used in new, unexpected contexts not
encountered during pre-training. In this paper, we model \textit{semantic
change} by studying the effect of unexpected contexts introduced by
\textit{lexical replacements}. We propose a \textit{replacement schema} where a
target word is substituted with lexical replacements of varying relatedness,
thus simulating different kinds of semantic change. Furthermore, we leverage
the replacement schema as a basis for a novel \textit{interpretable} model for
semantic change. We are also the first to evaluate the use of LLaMa for
semantic change detection.
|
[
-0.06900399178266525,
-0.9580575227737427,
0.6197423934936523,
-0.06085627153515816,
-0.5101657509803772,
-0.2703339159488678,
-0.0321943424642086,
-0.8674576878547668,
0.686359703540802,
0.45654386281967163,
-0.658449649810791,
-0.23211151361465454,
-0.8912724852561951,
0.4687274396419525,
-0.7331858277320862,
0.7566757202148438,
-0.3382467031478882,
0.05367773771286011,
0.34109872579574585,
-0.2555133104324341,
-0.9110960364341736,
-0.10495118051767349,
-0.35177353024482727,
-0.5632181763648987,
0.7116708755493164,
0.27018818259239197,
0.9427351355552673,
0.5685805082321167,
0.3455500602722168,
0.31184282898902893,
-0.4979790449142456,
-0.1419801414012909,
-0.385940819978714,
0.2773369252681732,
-0.41242915391921997,
-0.6450297236442566,
-0.294615238904953,
0.15301881730556488,
0.7419040203094482,
0.8782413601875305,
-0.26483607292175293,
-0.15404005348682404,
-0.2586425542831421,
0.24479742348194122,
-0.7632529139518738,
0.28327852487564087,
-1.651775598526001,
0.18788310885429382,
-0.3770884573459625,
-0.49027013778686523,
-0.16059552133083344,
0.33735647797584534,
0.11279900372028351,
-0.9760854840278625,
0.15309283137321472,
-0.14033202826976776,
0.7950879335403442,
0.4873166084289551,
-0.24991828203201294,
-0.4121397137641907,
-0.7255676984786987,
0.6840463280677795,
-0.7366312146186829,
0.47469013929367065,
0.2879739999771118,
0.3623293340206146,
-0.709430992603302,
-0.9449021816253662,
-0.9236017465591431,
-0.47752705216407776,
0.006221523974090815,
0.030827408656477928,
-0.18348008394241333,
-0.09274011850357056,
-0.027812927961349487,
0.15730753540992737,
0.3313233554363251,
-0.014140595681965351,
-0.08360056579113007,
-0.09046648442745209,
0.29015520215034485,
0.5234004259109497,
0.790737509727478,
-0.1966540813446045,
-0.33744126558303833,
-0.3044856786727905,
-0.6619744896888733,
-0.23850776255130768,
0.18061015009880066,
0.28233733773231506,
0.3080233633518219,
0.6544273495674133,
-0.5525645613670349,
0.7848670482635498,
-0.14871296286582947,
-0.2439015805721283,
0.3343285024166107,
-0.5225558876991272,
-0.4347466826438904,
0.32395410537719727,
-0.14061389863491058,
0.5042150020599365,
-0.003374111372977495,
-0.2899291515350342,
-0.3269917070865631,
0.6594237089157104,
0.19128216803073883,
-0.21327005326747894,
0.07921016216278076,
-0.20748993754386902,
-0.2890591621398926,
-0.4805010259151459,
-0.1766950637102127,
-0.272510826587677,
-0.5887655019760132,
-0.5319152474403381,
0.3862203061580658,
-0.5892344117164612,
-0.21955706179141998,
0.6499898433685303,
-0.2877897620201111,
0.49223169684410095,
0.7819031476974487,
-0.8001216650009155,
0.08122054487466812,
0.4481113851070404,
0.5075845122337341,
-0.08603179454803467,
-0.7407588958740234,
-0.04961152747273445,
0.18992365896701813,
-0.510983407497406,
0.9502485990524292,
-0.8140128254890442,
-0.638434648513794,
-0.0038951474707573652,
0.2383577972650528,
-0.104561947286129,
-0.4950009882450104,
0.10223834216594696,
-0.8108648657798767,
-0.21347232162952423,
-0.33375343680381775,
-0.40885674953460693,
0.025832580402493477,
0.38436582684516907,
-0.6966081261634827,
1.1223102807998657,
0.11940348893404007,
-1.0110342502593994,
0.6084348559379578,
-0.3240993916988373,
-0.061315733939409256,
-0.05145028233528137,
0.27560165524482727,
-0.23338967561721802,
0.21797189116477966,
-0.2541797161102295,
-0.0032971869222819805,
0.01266892533749342,
0.23980987071990967,
-0.08994584530591965,
-0.7251864075660706,
0.6999398469924927,
-0.08978624641895294,
0.5843823552131653,
0.055891141295433044,
-0.05605865642428398,
0.05067331716418266,
-0.938758134841919,
-0.3232533633708954,
0.16473568975925446,
-0.3412131369113922,
-0.7960814237594604,
0.32028764486312866,
0.1281130313873291,
-0.09995093196630478,
0.3439575731754303,
-0.682327389717102,
0.1460389792919159,
-0.326968789100647,
0.36633890867233276,
0.6653981804847717,
0.07191497832536697,
0.6751980185508728,
-0.26144781708717346,
0.3083849549293518,
0.1822541356086731,
0.09986446052789688,
-0.19196803867816925,
-0.592610776424408,
-0.7616786956787109,
0.0632159560918808,
0.23842157423496246,
0.33175230026245117,
-0.8083148002624512,
-0.25171393156051636,
-0.18343254923820496,
-0.4287712275981903,
-0.2688806653022766,
0.06382013857364655,
-0.24681805074214935,
0.4370103180408478,
0.7029396891593933,
-0.31991711258888245,
-0.878309965133667,
-0.6554720997810364,
-0.7085525393486023,
-0.29233166575431824,
0.1615782231092453,
-0.10114632546901703,
0.6142829656600952,
-1.0979005098342896,
1.3085490465164185,
-0.4443987309932709,
-0.3068946301937103,
-0.10429214686155319,
-0.08548643440008163,
-0.24724723398685455,
0.367075115442276,
0.17183691263198853,
-0.5985708236694336,
0.1705799698829651,
-0.0986076071858406,
-0.4576815664768219,
-0.4787755310535431,
-0.41473254561424255,
-0.03833961859345436,
-0.17519856989383698,
1.214985966682434,
-0.48937538266181946,
0.7006470561027527,
0.33218076825141907,
-0.34654325246810913,
0.7873722314834595,
-0.13592873513698578,
-0.17545951902866364,
-0.9273542165756226,
-0.3238413631916046,
-0.544800341129303,
0.176856130361557,
-0.6125847697257996,
0.2404080331325531,
0.0018089552177116275,
0.16197562217712402,
-0.7844482064247131,
0.8384335041046143,
-0.32287725806236267,
-0.1667131930589676,
-0.23052319884300232,
0.31539416313171387,
-0.2158091962337494,
-0.018840650096535683,
-0.08235341310501099,
0.5942260026931763,
0.24786914885044098,
-0.5912051200866699,
0.05871760472655296,
0.41458210349082947,
-0.3877071142196655,
0.5228079557418823,
-0.5385133028030396,
-0.14701589941978455,
-0.5492572784423828,
0.6221703886985779,
-0.9015315175056458,
-0.37135049700737,
0.518345832824707,
-0.1863342970609665,
-0.2144192010164261,
0.16445480287075043,
-0.6717214584350586,
0.1423192024230957,
-0.239305779337883,
0.4759654104709625,
-0.0868271142244339,
-0.45239919424057007,
0.5958871841430664,
0.21285530924797058,
0.26499849557876587,
-0.28912603855133057,
-0.8573326468467712,
0.5739786028862,
-0.25831732153892517,
-0.4956037104129791,
0.8378270864486694,
0.029762284830212593,
-0.5135549306869507,
0.2865290343761444,
-0.04249538853764534,
-0.045108865946531296,
0.4650135934352875,
0.1162300780415535,
0.31712907552719116,
-0.11974875628948212,
0.4145332872867584,
0.28303828835487366,
-0.260143905878067,
-0.22485318779945374,
0.03558875247836113,
0.36886560916900635,
-0.10797173529863358,
-0.23350051045417786,
-0.379398375749588,
0.2743273079395294,
0.3548995852470398,
-0.18075552582740784,
0.7740089297294617,
0.4253438115119934,
-0.5906118154525757,
0.22779850661754608,
-0.3577914535999298,
-0.08808067440986633,
-0.4454689025878906,
0.5329088568687439,
-0.3015446066856384,
-0.5881539583206177,
0.7095375657081604,
-0.13918258249759674,
-0.19508978724479675,
0.39409711956977844,
0.5411278009414673,
0.03288491070270538,
0.7044180631637573,
0.48705267906188965,
0.5378842353820801,
0.9222065210342407,
0.1010422334074974,
0.11991287022829056,
-1.0037970542907715,
-0.20689749717712402,
-0.2048201858997345,
-0.39446359872817993,
-0.7626394629478455,
-0.5745542049407959,
0.35875654220581055,
0.17431731522083282,
0.023536836728453636,
0.6733876466751099,
-0.06978810578584671,
0.5718097686767578,
0.1979009509086609,
0.12405018508434296,
0.4919745624065399,
-0.17918705940246582,
-0.06943683326244354,
0.018152492120862007,
-0.37468501925468445,
-0.5080221891403198,
0.7862145304679871,
0.08408834785223007,
1.0143693685531616,
0.11369920521974564,
0.6795594096183777,
0.2304365634918213,
0.5147379636764526,
-0.8990461826324463,
0.8605554103851318,
0.1906367987394333,
-0.19393637776374817,
-0.3213944435119629,
0.07793630659580231,
-1.4186564683914185,
0.6208023428916931,
-0.5519823431968689,
-0.7964542508125305,
-0.04336779937148094,
0.02300226502120495,
0.34138554334640503,
0.41179442405700684,
-0.4553660750389099,
0.5606603622436523,
0.2933305501937866,
-0.029301544651389122,
-0.3717750310897827,
-0.4201161563396454,
0.18106801807880402,
-0.07816604524850845,
0.08224106580018997,
-0.06313450634479523,
-0.345721572637558,
0.42620211839675903,
-0.47836825251579285,
1.0494017601013184,
0.0659923180937767,
-0.19494779407978058,
0.3125152587890625,
0.3952653408050537,
0.4847601354122162,
-0.10340433567762375,
-0.12320628017187119,
0.2107124775648117,
0.13501371443271637,
-0.4052528738975525,
-0.4988389015197754,
0.6017547845840454,
-0.6291080117225647,
-0.7179594039916992,
-0.6372668743133545,
-0.8891188502311707,
-0.2642446458339691,
-0.02789311856031418,
0.08438032120466232,
0.029553739354014397,
-0.3491967022418976,
-0.3301602602005005,
0.23350773751735687,
-0.2971833050251007,
0.32618027925491333,
0.47200876474380493,
-0.012508438900113106,
0.22005197405815125,
0.4833790957927704,
0.04066665470600128,
0.2798196077346802,
0.07231027632951736,
0.373629629611969,
-0.1297483593225479,
-0.18617460131645203,
-0.5027189254760742,
0.20371051132678986,
-0.87754225730896,
-0.005967693403363228,
-0.45318737626075745,
0.08373694121837616,
-0.06385670602321625,
-0.30473554134368896,
-0.0861947163939476,
-0.3035666048526764,
-0.5280921459197998,
0.022172361612319946,
0.3469170928001404,
0.8982682824134827,
0.027772264555096626,
0.5816017985343933,
-0.49173274636268616,
-0.22695697844028473,
0.5318254828453064,
0.0955062061548233,
0.045451950281858444,
-0.5389384031295776,
-0.13929784297943115,
0.004346370697021484,
-0.08166465163230896,
-1.360561728477478,
0.18739190697669983,
0.15325438976287842,
0.4800235331058502,
-0.05685172602534294,
-0.24802610278129578,
0.6785185933113098,
-0.8727830052375793,
0.7577180862426758,
0.180974543094635,
-1.1185957193374634,
0.546873927116394,
-0.3127133846282959,
0.6506634950637817,
0.4560013711452484,
-0.36843231320381165,
-1.1079379320144653,
-0.38051867485046387,
-0.5574973225593567,
-0.7845987677574158,
0.36288461089134216,
-0.03020971082150936,
0.6817114949226379,
-0.2355969399213791,
0.48329660296440125,
0.14023083448410034,
0.054041966795921326,
-0.6931971311569214,
0.05290113016963005,
-0.2474265843629837,
0.07106276601552963,
0.28644853830337524,
-0.34496238827705383,
0.17332994937896729,
0.020697444677352905,
0.49195677042007446,
-0.002253094920888543,
0.17770357429981232,
0.22561541199684143,
-0.5132666826248169,
0.04966852068901062,
0.41969504952430725,
0.679688036441803,
0.6546080112457275,
0.08976899087429047,
0.3316585123538971,
0.6841492056846619,
-0.29604148864746094,
0.0047470573335886,
-0.22954650223255157,
-0.28295087814331055,
0.32661789655685425,
0.47890862822532654,
0.6991332173347473,
1.0096924304962158,
-0.7079939842224121,
0.28328001499176025,
0.20143824815750122,
0.2927357852458954,
-0.47625717520713806,
0.10628709197044373,
0.1418614387512207,
-0.050383079797029495,
0.04818207025527954,
0.17075423896312714,
0.1416027694940567,
-0.9321403503417969,
0.14896360039710999,
0.11910402774810791,
-0.6566311120986938,
-0.41302689909935,
0.6419583559036255,
-0.20915007591247559,
-0.3329086899757385,
0.10564536601305008,
-0.24523743987083435,
-0.6168741583824158,
0.5025669932365417,
0.8253216743469238,
0.43322810530662537,
-0.6815683245658875,
0.2888942360877991,
0.05288209393620491,
0.07965733110904694,
-0.035933904349803925,
-0.098077692091465,
0.04557587206363678,
-1.1642165184020996,
-0.18126823008060455,
-0.5120413303375244,
-0.4293726980686188,
-0.12111732363700867,
-0.5098826289176941,
0.5549653768539429,
-0.30057454109191895,
0.009206194430589676,
-0.058981046080589294,
-0.7982190847396851,
-0.6466737389564514,
0.3229430317878723,
-0.05711834132671356,
0.9714358448982239,
-0.9399979710578918,
0.9580879211425781,
1.055884838104248,
-0.3742443323135376,
-0.4928836226463318,
0.23843476176261902,
0.016445672139525414,
-1.0813870429992676,
0.8665707111358643,
-0.11932793259620667,
-0.5549436807632446,
-0.3193379342556,
-0.4472386837005615,
-0.7654291391372681,
1.0193737745285034,
0.15935005247592926,
-0.12615101039409637,
-0.018696531653404236,
0.3309188783168793,
0.7323577404022217,
-0.2601315677165985,
0.048822131007909775,
0.7150030732154846,
0.3580167889595032,
0.044048674404621124,
-0.5708135366439819,
-0.03429301083087921,
0.11204731464385986,
0.5864962935447693,
0.13957202434539795,
-0.09346663951873779,
1.2249512672424316,
-0.1679564118385315,
-0.33483099937438965,
0.36193016171455383,
0.557533323764801,
0.013391165994107723,
0.37282058596611023,
0.9465845823287964,
0.5362609624862671,
0.687345027923584,
0.21842153370380402,
1.013714075088501,
-0.2215927243232727,
0.4670791029930115,
1.1852494478225708,
-0.2602200508117676,
1.054608941078186,
0.9052903652191162,
-0.03084343858063221,
0.8826876282691956,
0.7022386193275452,
0.3841751217842102,
0.6309182047843933,
0.4733388423919678,
-0.5320610404014587,
-0.28582096099853516,
-0.16478198766708374,
-0.5572129487991333,
0.9304479956626892,
0.7033291459083557,
-0.09026701003313065,
-0.7045725584030151,
-0.0010350854136049747,
0.35478875041007996,
0.11552441120147705,
-0.39036649465560913,
0.37667009234428406,
0.011880479753017426,
-0.2963734567165375,
0.4067784249782562,
0.41221120953559875,
0.6319090723991394,
-0.6351016163825989,
-0.26161566376686096,
-0.2188093662261963,
0.18179309368133545,
-0.08420828729867935,
-0.39708462357521057,
0.577107310295105,
-0.3688355088233948,
0.07515974342823029,
-0.12253715097904205,
0.8526391983032227,
-0.3630523383617401,
-0.5060096979141235,
0.7434751987457275,
0.30940568447113037,
-0.041256483644247055,
0.04752418398857117,
-0.5847457051277161,
0.4592977464199066,
-0.17537200450897217,
0.00868175458163023,
0.47715893387794495,
0.3927468955516815,
-0.3859439790248871,
0.4032997488975525,
0.6518645882606506,
-0.00046750466572120786,
0.2536754906177521,
-0.10362564772367477,
0.8705871105194092,
-0.5889227986335754,
-0.687968373298645,
-0.5269463062286377,
0.20074914395809174,
0.1558590829372406,
-0.6674878001213074,
0.4303548336029053,
-0.18799254298210144,
0.9170313477516174,
-0.07287765294313431,
0.39632877707481384,
-0.006652147509157658,
0.1659460812807083,
-0.7437459826469421,
0.47805240750312805,
-0.8760891556739807,
0.6052876114845276,
-0.503123939037323,
-0.8637256026268005,
-0.4525761008262634,
0.7494081854820251,
-0.19919399917125702,
-0.4918142557144165,
0.8464983701705933,
1.1276650428771973,
-0.23375970125198364,
0.3883918523788452,
0.4468190371990204,
0.6402063965797424,
0.020027732476592064,
0.1218479797244072,
1.0107377767562866,
-0.5711731314659119,
0.2541314661502838,
0.21376381814479828,
-0.2322111427783966,
-0.3829067349433899,
-0.9112775921821594,
-0.26147326827049255,
-0.9727588891983032,
-0.34245386719703674,
-0.5675865411758423,
0.24744141101837158,
0.8028597235679626,
0.09895358234643936,
-0.6247643232345581,
-0.06627024710178375,
-0.19113215804100037,
0.10616180300712585,
-0.11632013320922852,
-0.23116514086723328,
0.11407981067895889,
-0.5241725444793701,
-0.6710051894187927,
0.6619055867195129,
0.07920202612876892,
0.09439248591661453,
-0.2507913112640381,
0.18524949252605438,
-0.26657745242118835,
0.382723331451416,
0.7830815315246582,
0.13757209479808807,
-1.1316150426864624,
-0.9870555996894836,
-0.021802566945552826,
-0.11220096051692963,
-0.006977838929742575,
0.8853804469108582,
-0.9736133813858032,
0.5927777886390686,
0.3592212498188019,
0.762001097202301,
0.45580360293388367,
-0.6001662611961365,
0.22952432930469513,
-0.3290547728538513,
0.47173941135406494,
-0.27573469281196594,
0.748972475528717,
0.5325562357902527,
-0.061413124203681946,
0.6098828911781311,
0.6254818439483643,
-0.042341917753219604,
-0.7361929416656494,
0.5905754566192627,
-1.0026828050613403,
-0.45494869351387024,
1.2889589071273804,
0.11488533020019531,
-0.3033200204372406,
-0.125754252076149,
-0.5087284445762634,
0.2402678281068802,
-0.00048414309276267886,
1.0339879989624023,
0.8180727958679199,
-0.17699487507343292,
0.3058526813983917,
-0.4257819354534149,
0.1828552782535553,
0.7092692852020264,
-0.6148820519447327,
-0.3924925625324249,
0.4382193386554718,
0.598574161529541,
0.1319788545370102,
0.5946974158287048,
-0.17421725392341614,
0.25569093227386475,
0.14095091819763184,
-0.06608987599611282,
0.4056253731250763,
0.11617789417505264,
-0.09897331148386002,
-0.5508338809013367,
-0.02740740217268467,
-0.2515738904476166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18564v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18564v1
|
Injecting Salesperson's Dialogue Strategies in Large Language Models with Chain-of-Thought Reasoning
| 2024-04-29T10:12:04 | 2024-04-29T10:12:04 |
Wen-Yu Chang, Yun-Nung Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent research in dialogue systems and corpora has focused on two main
categories: task-oriented (TOD) and open-domain (chit-chat) dialogues. TOD
systems help users accomplish specific tasks, while open-domain systems aim to
create engaging conversations. However, in real-world scenarios, user intents
are often revealed during interactions. A recent study introduced SalesBot,
which simulates dialogues transitioning from chit-chat to task-oriented
scenarios to train sales agents. Unfortunately, the initial data lacked smooth
transitions and coherent long-turn dialogues, resulting in poor naturalness in
sales-customer interactions. To address these issues, this paper presents
SalesBot 2.0, an improved dataset. It leverages commonsense knowledge from
large language models (LLMs) through strategic prompting. Additionally, we
introduce a novel model called SalesAgent, trained on salesperson's
interactions, using chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning. This model excels in
transitioning topics, understanding user intents, and selecting appropriate
strategies. Experiments using diverse user simulations validate the
effectiveness of our method in controlling dialogue strategies in LLMs.
Furthermore, SalesBot 2.0 enhances coherence and reduces aggression,
facilitating better model learning for sales-customer interactions.
|
[
-0.23021481931209564,
-0.9862521886825562,
0.5641265511512756,
-0.021510953083634377,
-0.2922505736351013,
0.18264508247375488,
-0.3873818814754486,
-0.4102238714694977,
-0.14876769483089447,
0.8610207438468933,
-0.6825922131538391,
-0.3866855800151825,
-0.01716637797653675,
-0.2558135688304901,
-0.041292931884527206,
1.0887267589569092,
0.1503717452287674,
0.058267366141080856,
-0.3483046293258667,
0.08682705461978912,
-0.6093072891235352,
-0.6173480153083801,
-0.9075505137443542,
-0.319406658411026,
0.3106965720653534,
0.4474722445011139,
0.8817837238311768,
-0.12215057015419006,
0.1382123827934265,
0.2535286545753479,
0.09422092884778976,
0.34625157713890076,
-0.6617628335952759,
0.5535982251167297,
-0.5306968688964844,
-0.47999152541160583,
-0.6159105896949768,
-0.2168102115392685,
0.008340288884937763,
0.573577344417572,
-0.3533647656440735,
-0.0022086617536842823,
-0.042550135403871536,
0.23849497735500336,
-0.4484204351902008,
0.2520337998867035,
-0.7939096689224243,
-0.28213366866111755,
0.3952828049659729,
-0.2647962272167206,
-0.7669675350189209,
-0.08121751993894577,
0.36001455783843994,
-0.5827217698097229,
0.0002134425303665921,
-0.15757052600383759,
0.7624096274375916,
-0.008278223685920238,
-0.5161551237106323,
-0.3416779637336731,
-0.9937183856964111,
0.7406149506568909,
-0.6358292102813721,
0.5380158424377441,
0.2731025516986847,
0.3699229657649994,
-0.3906465768814087,
-0.5300091505050659,
-0.33504995703697205,
-0.2801452875137329,
0.09929916262626648,
0.14638686180114746,
-0.4471588730812073,
0.10554087907075882,
0.23380354046821594,
-0.16940398514270782,
-0.24445977807044983,
0.07053149491548538,
-0.2810564339160919,
0.17995361983776093,
0.7162559628486633,
0.19852198660373688,
-0.01583760604262352,
0.07335685938596725,
-0.591627836227417,
-0.16028961539268494,
-0.4136587381362915,
0.0972302258014679,
0.2512563467025757,
0.4199608564376831,
-0.039771050214767456,
0.37852394580841064,
-0.36009207367897034,
0.6387282609939575,
0.24197699129581451,
-0.19744224846363068,
-0.16771864891052246,
-0.4068046510219574,
-0.29975736141204834,
-0.0013005455257371068,
0.6489057540893555,
0.47303563356399536,
0.4732971787452698,
-0.11836712807416916,
-0.3913755416870117,
0.006688775960355997,
0.21740762889385223,
-0.5297240614891052,
-0.11703824996948242,
0.4082968235015869,
-0.1309681087732315,
-0.32456421852111816,
-0.11512317508459091,
-0.6074872612953186,
-0.2261960357427597,
-0.4111884832382202,
0.31292614340782166,
-0.33563271164894104,
-0.28629881143569946,
0.12647657096385956,
-0.1819228231906891,
0.1804068684577942,
0.5477888584136963,
-0.7719005942344666,
0.7770193219184875,
0.8033697009086609,
0.4948202073574066,
-0.00003745393405552022,
-0.06706176698207855,
-0.5578542947769165,
0.4286229610443115,
-0.43096327781677246,
0.6198521852493286,
-0.558493971824646,
-0.1929241269826889,
0.08830437809228897,
-0.22173531353473663,
-0.06856532394886017,
-0.6607720255851746,
0.03200620040297508,
-0.5859895944595337,
0.3187960684299469,
0.092435322701931,
-0.3513181507587433,
-0.10642998665571213,
0.5937108397483826,
-0.1944124847650528,
0.8466776609420776,
0.24161893129348755,
-0.09829143434762955,
0.13889943063259125,
-0.685808002948761,
-0.5569709539413452,
0.17006227374076843,
-0.1326674520969391,
-0.045804668217897415,
-0.04738903045654297,
0.16613811254501343,
0.34906458854675293,
-0.3614695370197296,
0.5457866787910461,
-0.0339675135910511,
-0.042561616748571396,
0.4235002398490906,
-0.4405035674571991,
0.6297853589057922,
0.14817321300506592,
-0.44638487696647644,
0.009937291964888573,
-0.3947102427482605,
-0.058978091925382614,
0.19479838013648987,
0.13524150848388672,
-0.26495909690856934,
-0.0887853354215622,
-0.19265389442443848,
0.32557329535484314,
0.16326220333576202,
-0.22326843440532684,
0.40347373485565186,
-0.48060524463653564,
0.40446192026138306,
0.6969302892684937,
0.17995569109916687,
0.464374840259552,
-0.24063417315483093,
0.7469210624694824,
0.1101461872458458,
0.3012717664241791,
-0.08467115461826324,
-0.7041342258453369,
-0.8007866144180298,
-0.03977219760417938,
-0.03624410182237625,
0.4442460238933563,
-0.7435647249221802,
0.37474915385246277,
-0.3927438259124756,
-0.515766441822052,
0.03947141394019127,
0.07389771193265915,
0.1602543592453003,
0.32946130633354187,
0.1865861415863037,
-0.2651890814304352,
-0.20376257598400116,
-0.6128964424133301,
-0.23174822330474854,
-0.3070130944252014,
0.04528781771659851,
0.4333827495574951,
0.3193264901638031,
-0.19966016709804535,
1.0896040201187134,
-0.685756504535675,
-0.06832000613212585,
-0.7491921782493591,
-0.001602868433110416,
0.0953126773238182,
0.29392021894454956,
0.024356232956051826,
-0.5616501569747925,
-0.4319770932197571,
0.10540532320737839,
-0.37627941370010376,
0.008388122543692589,
-0.5871403217315674,
-0.41589516401290894,
0.32744133472442627,
0.5101816058158875,
-0.8125596046447754,
0.521308422088623,
0.27774861454963684,
-0.21623097360134125,
0.5447935461997986,
-0.25043582916259766,
-0.08915204554796219,
-1.033097743988037,
-0.3472359776496887,
-0.013756129890680313,
-0.34427791833877563,
-0.7304163575172424,
-0.3213467001914978,
-0.30659326910972595,
-0.3791114091873169,
-0.4970771372318268,
0.5996707677841187,
-0.28807029128074646,
-0.24643674492835999,
-0.11104810982942581,
0.2732701301574707,
0.24204859137535095,
0.8002452850341797,
0.29482603073120117,
0.8990610241889954,
0.297567754983902,
-0.8507674932479858,
0.25978243350982666,
0.7050948143005371,
-0.3791196644306183,
0.6866840124130249,
-0.7153680324554443,
0.31764349341392517,
0.08237005025148392,
0.6972820162773132,
-0.9807924032211304,
-0.16056326031684875,
0.4813176691532135,
-0.14885979890823364,
-0.10288343578577042,
-0.27265816926956177,
-0.47870883345603943,
-0.3516993522644043,
0.08027811348438263,
0.23739859461784363,
0.5693954229354858,
-0.5297802090644836,
0.5421640276908875,
0.16273461282253265,
-0.34760141372680664,
-0.11210384964942932,
-0.4434454143047333,
0.2188369333744049,
-0.07142750918865204,
-0.7325329184532166,
-0.0010421036276966333,
0.09429674595594406,
-0.30498600006103516,
-0.44449037313461304,
0.07284161448478699,
-0.05451209470629692,
0.04293130710721016,
-0.08073165267705917,
0.39855441451072693,
0.1263359636068344,
0.3895350396633148,
0.14416198432445526,
0.016612600535154343,
0.21626363694667816,
-0.6008388996124268,
0.9477455019950867,
0.1596929430961609,
-0.2735462188720703,
-0.6646726131439209,
0.23622006177902222,
0.6624020934104919,
-0.2984689176082611,
0.5284915566444397,
0.13416427373886108,
-0.06656846404075623,
-0.3323726952075958,
-0.37084174156188965,
-0.544097900390625,
-0.508571207523346,
0.5030734539031982,
-0.47177496552467346,
-0.5319028496742249,
0.20333708822727203,
-0.4059920310974121,
0.00490938825532794,
-0.053266048431396484,
0.7114539742469788,
-0.13436409831047058,
1.2854069471359253,
0.1918259561061859,
0.45378148555755615,
0.4728303849697113,
-0.47408807277679443,
0.8441745638847351,
-0.730628490447998,
-0.5383155345916748,
-0.11680994182825089,
-0.294883131980896,
-0.1477118730545044,
-0.6578083634376526,
0.2559927701950073,
0.034699879586696625,
-0.408894419670105,
0.45609331130981445,
-0.2330687940120697,
0.22399915754795074,
0.4833536446094513,
0.22844024002552032,
0.16312789916992188,
0.09853367507457733,
0.14695334434509277,
0.18896004557609558,
-0.8228674530982971,
-0.5051178932189941,
0.7330476641654968,
0.4577030539512634,
0.9707907438278198,
0.2787361145019531,
0.48685503005981445,
-0.00031535321613773704,
-0.09207084774971008,
-1.2131257057189941,
0.840397298336029,
0.20702777802944183,
-0.5669076442718506,
-0.23991361260414124,
-0.3660455644130707,
-1.0465527772903442,
0.0054758451879024506,
0.1141786277294159,
-0.9662920832633972,
0.31015583872795105,
0.16817152500152588,
-0.4879346191883087,
0.18294654786586761,
-0.6906894445419312,
0.8368986248970032,
-0.6014687418937683,
-0.5293549299240112,
-0.37262454628944397,
-0.49542418122291565,
0.12982717156410217,
0.14637228846549988,
0.08900967240333557,
-0.09680180251598358,
0.005282099358737469,
0.6970006227493286,
-0.681850790977478,
1.0246789455413818,
-0.042840130627155304,
-0.5316600203514099,
0.5071753263473511,
0.2603503167629242,
1.0522903203964233,
-0.2310480922460556,
0.17681467533111572,
-0.21234160661697388,
-0.24838872253894806,
-0.37117859721183777,
-0.9504224061965942,
0.38495874404907227,
-0.3641144633293152,
-0.7659680247306824,
-0.19724270701408386,
-0.7655060887336731,
-0.7202398777008057,
-0.06873706728219986,
0.02858540415763855,
0.4984809458255768,
-0.3177410662174225,
0.02170882746577263,
0.2851543426513672,
-0.028178749606013298,
-0.016950411722064018,
0.30015963315963745,
-0.08685804158449173,
-0.36360156536102295,
0.7561641931533813,
-0.12816977500915527,
0.8897223472595215,
0.1471392959356308,
0.3060552775859833,
-0.6914657354354858,
-0.10896192491054535,
-0.281947523355484,
0.21028076112270355,
-0.6579310297966003,
-0.18052133917808533,
-0.6677916646003723,
0.07204873114824295,
-0.5927108526229858,
-0.1500633955001831,
-0.08692929148674011,
-0.3840613067150116,
-0.10342495143413544,
-0.030954455956816673,
0.48831525444984436,
0.7731952667236328,
0.4128416180610657,
0.4578252136707306,
-0.7355756759643555,
-0.04861392825841904,
0.5609795451164246,
0.08178455382585526,
0.3281043469905853,
-0.47913697361946106,
-0.2910040616989136,
0.3975040316581726,
-0.42187511920928955,
-0.7006024122238159,
0.28068315982818604,
-0.04528304561972618,
0.4152606725692749,
0.7062549591064453,
0.29324567317962646,
0.5246461033821106,
-0.18685628473758698,
0.9200809001922607,
0.36911165714263916,
-0.8621991276741028,
0.7032362222671509,
-0.6545169353485107,
0.2521947920322418,
0.578353226184845,
0.32882821559906006,
-0.6428551077842712,
-0.24158647656440735,
-0.7219997644424438,
-0.6403362154960632,
0.905870795249939,
0.0045453282073140144,
0.33156657218933105,
-0.2083100825548172,
-0.26111114025115967,
0.17445950210094452,
0.4616958498954773,
-0.25774019956588745,
0.15508529543876648,
0.01532312948256731,
-0.19477149844169617,
0.07357436418533325,
0.04846854507923126,
-0.15896917879581451,
-0.21209624409675598,
0.6621917486190796,
-0.27590301632881165,
0.03515475243330002,
0.08277112245559692,
-0.07213447242975235,
0.058482199907302856,
0.35866278409957886,
0.4327196776866913,
0.7571895718574524,
-0.10053297877311707,
-0.1517001837491989,
0.006973769515752792,
-0.12252457439899445,
0.2392033189535141,
-0.2849505841732025,
-0.1014842763543129,
-0.21357585489749908,
-0.14314253628253937,
0.9751618504524231,
0.3069659471511841,
-1.0210307836532593,
0.526728093624115,
0.34174561500549316,
-0.352344274520874,
-0.12221000343561172,
0.06830914318561554,
-0.03863830864429474,
0.4251005947589874,
-0.015459060668945312,
0.12109697610139847,
0.13981160521507263,
-1.024701714515686,
-0.08303549885749817,
0.43568935990333557,
-0.6051544547080994,
-0.1396201103925705,
0.3811400532722473,
0.5965651273727417,
-0.6707491278648376,
0.609937846660614,
-0.2826029360294342,
-0.9292365312576294,
0.35615336894989014,
0.7458437085151672,
0.783814549446106,
0.005421267356723547,
0.6217575073242188,
0.12357174605131149,
-0.1224152222275734,
-0.201311856508255,
0.056388434022665024,
-0.35524439811706543,
-0.6853659749031067,
-0.27025148272514343,
0.0203395988792181,
-0.6396490335464478,
0.04352620989084244,
-0.41803500056266785,
0.391620010137558,
-0.37441980838775635,
-0.20834039151668549,
-0.14826278388500214,
-0.07953647524118423,
-0.5666826367378235,
0.09591645002365112,
0.07857605069875717,
0.9012938737869263,
-0.5019017457962036,
0.7335132956504822,
0.3850734829902649,
-0.2743770480155945,
-0.7163380980491638,
0.08549825102090836,
-0.23947201669216156,
-0.630948007106781,
0.7958643436431885,
-0.006867023650556803,
-0.3669533431529999,
-0.029984088614583015,
-0.5136721730232239,
-0.31741857528686523,
0.9077150225639343,
0.16737180948257446,
-0.7650887966156006,
0.07868016511201859,
0.28418615460395813,
0.42136862874031067,
-0.5367753505706787,
0.1981588900089264,
0.6136298775672913,
0.3323275148868561,
0.34252187609672546,
-0.5866608619689941,
-0.017598070204257965,
-0.049576856195926666,
-0.1430668830871582,
0.34841808676719666,
-0.7152693271636963,
0.6036662459373474,
-0.36104094982147217,
-0.05311127379536629,
0.3996638059616089,
0.33906233310699463,
0.3998945355415344,
0.5788410305976868,
0.8279902935028076,
0.46167704463005066,
0.9106360673904419,
0.044474612921476364,
0.9005488753318787,
-0.12868687510490417,
0.16336902976036072,
1.3210151195526123,
-0.6144916415214539,
1.0014610290527344,
0.3823992908000946,
-0.04167746379971504,
0.918325662612915,
0.3260287344455719,
-0.04918438196182251,
0.291964590549469,
0.24747496843338013,
-0.34842875599861145,
-0.6129396557807922,
-0.30944177508354187,
-0.07904336601495743,
0.672825038433075,
0.3726525604724884,
-0.08849792927503586,
-0.030726272612810135,
0.03080497309565544,
0.1012144610285759,
0.028067294508218765,
0.0159611813724041,
0.9987871646881104,
-0.09572456032037735,
-0.977303683757782,
0.6489520072937012,
-0.3479584753513336,
0.39770275354385376,
-0.6927546858787537,
0.016922451555728912,
-0.03036077506840229,
0.27173471450805664,
0.10781649500131607,
-0.7847678065299988,
-0.19615140557289124,
-0.03348592668771744,
0.1409815102815628,
-0.21735823154449463,
0.6666136980056763,
-0.7313558459281921,
-0.24772870540618896,
0.250649094581604,
0.5455855131149292,
0.22187809646129608,
-0.26412060856819153,
-0.708859920501709,
-0.10775629431009293,
-0.04818866029381752,
0.033714327961206436,
0.06203543394804001,
0.3358132839202881,
-0.3284401297569275,
0.7323614954948425,
0.8707665801048279,
-0.22323882579803467,
-0.4493870735168457,
0.5403406620025635,
0.8005242347717285,
-0.5758541226387024,
-0.6836457848548889,
-0.37082940340042114,
0.38115352392196655,
-0.43480128049850464,
-0.20787784457206726,
0.7435998320579529,
0.5755970478057861,
0.6861108541488647,
-0.029973721131682396,
0.6684263944625854,
0.39265498518943787,
0.2981371283531189,
-0.25844302773475647,
0.4472093880176544,
-0.4375373125076294,
0.3143269717693329,
-0.1508774757385254,
-0.8575859069824219,
0.20474249124526978,
0.4027433693408966,
-0.5767686367034912,
0.1936415582895279,
0.5438957810401917,
0.7306839227676392,
-0.1211177185177803,
0.05752357095479965,
0.349007248878479,
0.30115994811058044,
0.4640227258205414,
0.5896130800247192,
1.0939300060272217,
-0.421214759349823,
0.8396936655044556,
-0.0880594253540039,
-0.16431400179862976,
-0.38982638716697693,
-0.34711000323295593,
-1.0252978801727295,
-0.24709640443325043,
-0.443267285823822,
-0.5475685596466064,
0.2547001540660858,
1.1724179983139038,
0.71820068359375,
-0.5930655002593994,
-0.6256436705589294,
-0.31617018580436707,
-0.051638294011354446,
-0.36903464794158936,
-0.24358075857162476,
-0.11902816593647003,
-0.5654289722442627,
-0.755413293838501,
0.4679577946662903,
0.3614477813243866,
0.19871465861797333,
-0.28242212533950806,
-0.40965110063552856,
-0.26066216826438904,
0.5443058609962463,
0.7229518890380859,
0.03400026634335518,
-0.6652412414550781,
-0.014219808392226696,
0.19174617528915405,
0.013859781436622143,
0.11447601765394211,
0.9690386652946472,
-0.9181011915206909,
0.4526435434818268,
0.44495290517807007,
0.35733088850975037,
0.36804261803627014,
0.12840232253074646,
0.9664983749389648,
-0.41996705532073975,
0.18228638172149658,
0.42069610953330994,
-0.01600615307688713,
0.2199908196926117,
-0.3745693862438202,
0.4350138306617737,
0.03990868106484413,
-0.3537413477897644,
-0.5580169558525085,
0.6290709972381592,
-1.0426442623138428,
-0.4657924175262451,
1.2394479513168335,
0.14726564288139343,
-0.16255244612693787,
-0.43706396222114563,
-0.5362045168876648,
0.0686161145567894,
-0.7634339928627014,
0.4289628863334656,
0.4424807131290436,
-0.05443212389945984,
-0.0806967094540596,
-0.24190761148929596,
0.4228326976299286,
0.46021804213523865,
-0.8416396379470825,
0.37981998920440674,
0.2784576416015625,
-0.1532025784254074,
0.08540129661560059,
0.7044063806533813,
0.29913872480392456,
0.2883051037788391,
-0.03350982815027237,
-0.3116091191768646,
0.09967179596424103,
-0.4045634865760803,
0.048638150095939636,
-0.16879770159721375,
-0.04778517782688141,
-0.12905792891979218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18557v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18557v1
|
Can GPT-4 do L2 analytic assessment?
| 2024-04-29T10:00:00 | 2024-04-29T10:00:00 |
Stefano Bannò, Hari Krishna Vydana, Kate M. Knill, Mark J. F. Gales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automated essay scoring (AES) to evaluate second language (L2) proficiency
has been a firmly established technology used in educational contexts for
decades. Although holistic scoring has seen advancements in AES that match or
even exceed human performance, analytic scoring still encounters issues as it
inherits flaws and shortcomings from the human scoring process. The recent
introduction of large language models presents new opportunities for automating
the evaluation of specific aspects of L2 writing proficiency. In this paper, we
perform a series of experiments using GPT-4 in a zero-shot fashion on a
publicly available dataset annotated with holistic scores based on the Common
European Framework of Reference and aim to extract detailed information about
their underlying analytic components. We observe significant correlations
between the automatically predicted analytic scores and multiple features
associated with the individual proficiency components.
|
[
-0.2511436641216278,
-1.07626473903656,
0.8413677215576172,
0.07263720035552979,
0.019770286977291107,
0.2796589434146881,
-0.17529748380184174,
-1.114050269126892,
0.044818710535764694,
0.1994355022907257,
-0.12897507846355438,
-0.5380655527114868,
-0.5238169431686401,
0.2293306291103363,
-0.3459865152835846,
0.9608392119407654,
-0.46380048990249634,
-0.16309839487075806,
-0.102198526263237,
-0.21149346232414246,
-0.5285994410514832,
-0.3573002517223358,
-0.8120958209037781,
-0.3475508987903595,
0.5614542365074158,
0.4837600886821747,
0.3484622836112976,
0.4261990189552307,
0.7129335403442383,
0.2671847939491272,
0.6946858167648315,
-0.21858082711696625,
-0.1852683424949646,
0.13243570923805237,
-0.2788541913032532,
-0.3718535006046295,
-0.766108512878418,
0.36621740460395813,
0.6146204471588135,
0.3947870433330536,
0.14956319332122803,
0.509976327419281,
0.40706828236579895,
0.45311665534973145,
-0.32516002655029297,
0.512387216091156,
-0.6228099465370178,
-0.15537486970424652,
-0.2520877420902252,
-0.004379340447485447,
-0.41031304001808167,
-0.29618823528289795,
0.21049214899539948,
-0.610895037651062,
0.22521546483039856,
-0.26386016607284546,
0.8052129149436951,
0.2527104616165161,
-0.35094910860061646,
-0.4257570207118988,
-0.6838321685791016,
0.743721604347229,
-0.5375869274139404,
-0.08727722615003586,
0.4732351303100586,
0.39679738879203796,
0.4869646430015564,
-0.5281520485877991,
-0.5568597912788391,
-0.10048218816518784,
-0.0971866250038147,
0.33444127440452576,
-0.09610442072153091,
-0.02618885226547718,
0.19287873804569244,
0.0589795857667923,
-0.753029465675354,
0.22092793881893158,
-0.5228090882301331,
-0.47785672545433044,
1.110408902168274,
0.21407905220985413,
0.08927930146455765,
0.16514988243579865,
0.004655915312469006,
0.08812035620212555,
-0.4953332841396332,
0.26091399788856506,
0.6653728485107422,
0.2737211585044861,
-0.15602803230285645,
0.6301307678222656,
0.052536025643348694,
0.4302719533443451,
0.1407938003540039,
0.06268088519573212,
0.26712799072265625,
-0.3209392726421356,
0.1323193609714508,
0.01026008278131485,
0.7028065919876099,
0.5995474457740784,
0.46089667081832886,
0.14464007318019867,
-0.29021844267845154,
0.5443078279495239,
0.20746025443077087,
-0.6182029247283936,
-0.33503642678260803,
0.2233753204345703,
0.029460366815328598,
-0.2938075363636017,
-0.025820082053542137,
-0.9958916902542114,
-0.11695921421051025,
-0.4032624661922455,
0.5278347730636597,
-0.11721297353506088,
-0.12808609008789062,
-0.12053795903921127,
-0.02431192249059677,
0.6689634919166565,
0.41735509037971497,
-0.9128859639167786,
0.5720625519752502,
0.6747329235076904,
0.8870521783828735,
-0.47685232758522034,
-0.4150668680667877,
-0.35273292660713196,
-0.15955306589603424,
-0.6539568901062012,
1.1598517894744873,
-0.7316773533821106,
-0.42656654119491577,
0.1913922131061554,
-0.2827858626842499,
0.019734466448426247,
-0.25171685218811035,
0.622481644153595,
-0.4283771812915802,
0.41807928681373596,
-0.43727388978004456,
-0.7486918568611145,
-0.17552132904529572,
0.17241528630256653,
-0.5440025329589844,
1.46792471408844,
0.4263981282711029,
-0.6192114949226379,
0.2965715527534485,
-0.6827503442764282,
-0.4720001220703125,
0.19554489850997925,
-0.4787500500679016,
-0.4273110628128052,
-0.0040106093510985374,
-0.12141712754964828,
0.31838685274124146,
-0.014082157053053379,
-0.054073579609394073,
-0.24691061675548553,
-0.6103089451789856,
-0.05823826044797897,
-0.5099166035652161,
0.22156232595443726,
-0.2855883240699768,
-0.7779421806335449,
-0.2404063493013382,
-0.6831420063972473,
0.32135847210884094,
0.023794639855623245,
-0.2768028676509857,
-0.04518294706940651,
-0.4236563742160797,
-0.00547232897952199,
0.23807798326015472,
0.38465940952301025,
-0.5278670191764832,
0.27188965678215027,
-0.4332823157310486,
0.06766881048679352,
0.6509761214256287,
0.32241734862327576,
0.296355277299881,
-0.32267454266548157,
0.6545676589012146,
-0.4045863747596741,
-0.34749048948287964,
-0.10699161142110825,
-0.9819300174713135,
-0.5363511443138123,
-0.1694207787513733,
0.23853106796741486,
0.8179610371589661,
-0.4320697486400604,
0.7135950326919556,
0.0007154083577916026,
-0.7009497284889221,
-0.7431187629699707,
0.2014637142419815,
0.5157560110092163,
0.49680840969085693,
0.41848525404930115,
-0.3027147650718689,
-0.1300104707479477,
-0.8649646043777466,
-0.493022084236145,
-0.18280881643295288,
-0.02044019289314747,
0.040909070521593094,
0.6338492035865784,
-0.0471714548766613,
0.8859191536903381,
-0.4487476646900177,
-0.5960390567779541,
-0.3030037581920624,
0.5715633630752563,
-0.12888577580451965,
0.1380440592765808,
0.6888072490692139,
-0.1682208627462387,
-0.9637125730514526,
0.00848605390638113,
-0.8277381062507629,
-0.47983548045158386,
0.044046349823474884,
0.06747989356517792,
0.49641260504722595,
0.2358078956604004,
-0.33815935254096985,
0.7068616151809692,
0.4573098421096802,
-0.3539904057979584,
0.735584557056427,
-0.3745526373386383,
0.19067063927650452,
-0.553322970867157,
0.026099558919668198,
0.2408296912908554,
-0.08437832444906235,
-0.5208023190498352,
-0.1821833848953247,
0.02154964953660965,
0.12304318696260452,
-0.07516860216856003,
0.8560656309127808,
-0.1856229454278946,
-0.4513506591320038,
-0.3775509297847748,
0.2979908585548401,
0.29865339398384094,
0.520125687122345,
0.02760159596800804,
0.8782281279563904,
0.5125916600227356,
-0.1410702019929886,
0.13306432962417603,
-0.025168031454086304,
-0.24184350669384003,
0.7205395698547363,
-0.716009259223938,
0.5095230340957642,
0.04104258865118027,
0.1721753031015396,
-1.2107644081115723,
-0.5066447257995605,
-0.0648709088563919,
-0.4970230162143707,
0.47050783038139343,
0.30594173073768616,
-0.18252407014369965,
-0.18010184168815613,
-0.6231937408447266,
0.32361119985580444,
0.4647701382637024,
0.05695265531539917,
0.48808762431144714,
0.4009641408920288,
-0.5413305163383484,
-0.25807279348373413,
-0.6291094422340393,
0.05669813230633736,
-0.20626719295978546,
-0.42732226848602295,
0.1363764852285385,
-0.10449875146150589,
-0.40748125314712524,
-0.01602008566260338,
0.1962658315896988,
-0.03049444407224655,
-0.07537107914686203,
0.1779477447271347,
0.4110628068447113,
-0.14943461120128632,
0.0067618065513670444,
0.19645170867443085,
-0.35729527473449707,
0.13865265250205994,
-0.17525576055049896,
0.1887609213590622,
-0.3671886622905731,
-0.5766394734382629,
-0.8123323917388916,
0.5262613892555237,
0.6096199154853821,
-0.2938966155052185,
0.20026950538158417,
0.5884056687355042,
-0.5729437470436096,
-0.23258709907531738,
-0.5665585994720459,
-0.11124781519174576,
-0.4346959888935089,
0.5440665483474731,
-0.47665056586265564,
-0.6680741310119629,
0.514555811882019,
0.29828712344169617,
0.2489568293094635,
0.9109981060028076,
0.7202224135398865,
-0.30870670080184937,
0.9487439393997192,
0.4077272117137909,
-0.11703873425722122,
-0.010317855514585972,
-0.42186400294303894,
0.5198842287063599,
-0.6968367695808411,
-0.04992500692605972,
-0.5026893615722656,
-0.31009984016418457,
-0.6121524572372437,
-0.3049573600292206,
0.6759860515594482,
-0.06595548242330551,
-0.1898137629032135,
0.019842281937599182,
-0.4706690013408661,
0.6018460392951965,
0.16289952397346497,
-0.2864246666431427,
0.13570536673069,
-0.044220708310604095,
-0.2903348505496979,
-0.21843507885932922,
-0.010065746493637562,
-0.8789000511169434,
1.3618645668029785,
0.5610528588294983,
0.07111795246601105,
-0.007807969581335783,
0.6720730662345886,
0.695162296295166,
0.6200951933860779,
-0.7883459329605103,
0.49857982993125916,
0.019400127232074738,
-0.6028680205345154,
-0.5792251229286194,
0.11785824596881866,
-0.5399807691574097,
0.015853770077228546,
0.03095770627260208,
-0.8878616690635681,
-0.16974680125713348,
0.1708400845527649,
-0.6492230892181396,
-0.16736215353012085,
-0.7414737939834595,
0.8490691184997559,
-0.4782520830631256,
-0.7889173626899719,
-0.071134053170681,
-0.3726710081100464,
0.1878439038991928,
-0.6248019933700562,
0.3174394965171814,
-0.13706748187541962,
-0.04011658579111099,
0.9297831058502197,
0.17329643666744232,
0.8066911697387695,
-0.42147982120513916,
-0.33570313453674316,
0.7028790712356567,
0.14372625946998596,
0.48501133918762207,
-0.14342328906059265,
-0.4741048812866211,
0.3605711758136749,
0.18945157527923584,
-0.3722771406173706,
-0.7573532462120056,
0.727001965045929,
-0.9111998677253723,
-0.4481291174888611,
-0.7752825617790222,
-0.027419229969382286,
-0.38811221718788147,
0.115067258477211,
0.2549969553947449,
0.4641641080379486,
-0.1764535754919052,
-0.3215689957141876,
0.057808708399534225,
0.05621171370148659,
0.3672961890697479,
0.544857919216156,
-0.1353030651807785,
-0.1733475625514984,
0.8631082773208618,
0.32020002603530884,
0.16342514753341675,
-0.04124343395233154,
0.27046677470207214,
-0.7109178900718689,
-0.5746209025382996,
-0.4375026822090149,
0.37158453464508057,
-0.839870810508728,
-0.013796820305287838,
-0.33037275075912476,
-0.04619486257433891,
-0.4882269501686096,
-0.4906919598579407,
-0.25219929218292236,
-0.22783496975898743,
-0.06893831491470337,
-0.6191942095756531,
-0.028240637853741646,
1.1559116840362549,
-0.15086381137371063,
0.024302303791046143,
-0.6581273078918457,
0.10813344269990921,
0.07199215888977051,
0.27512800693511963,
-0.25782909989356995,
-0.6848714351654053,
-0.26485922932624817,
-0.0960080698132515,
-0.4991815984249115,
-0.7400597333908081,
0.09031081199645996,
0.2973642945289612,
0.4222939908504486,
0.5178816318511963,
-0.417523056268692,
0.4899955689907074,
-0.6701163649559021,
1.1192513704299927,
-0.11972130089998245,
-1.0361684560775757,
0.3616428077220917,
-0.454009085893631,
0.036427680402994156,
0.9601194858551025,
0.4497818648815155,
-0.17884910106658936,
-0.34760886430740356,
-0.4275263249874115,
-0.5794088244438171,
0.4824317395687103,
0.08019571751356125,
0.03595711663365364,
0.16578668355941772,
0.7701793909072876,
0.27223581075668335,
-0.030754264444112778,
-0.6863201856613159,
0.1242574155330658,
-0.003989019431173801,
-0.6203537583351135,
-0.32547155022621155,
-0.1867813766002655,
0.15295664966106415,
-0.4387659728527069,
0.7032844424247742,
-0.23033462464809418,
0.31621435284614563,
0.2497190535068512,
0.2747536599636078,
-0.26106348633766174,
0.11403186619281769,
0.4867062270641327,
0.6063397526741028,
-0.08690488338470459,
0.0563892126083374,
0.20663776993751526,
-0.6107369661331177,
0.30661439895629883,
-0.052490971982479095,
-0.17762549221515656,
-0.19955167174339294,
0.921179473400116,
0.3408469259738922,
0.09539802372455597,
-0.5926654934883118,
0.6488404870033264,
0.04469829052686691,
-0.5150623917579651,
-0.7209228873252869,
0.12804047763347626,
-0.14781352877616882,
0.06776271015405655,
0.1291278451681137,
-0.15277384221553802,
0.17829343676567078,
-0.817741870880127,
0.4002188742160797,
0.331028550863266,
-0.42400532960891724,
-0.8264424800872803,
0.4365910589694977,
0.3127126097679138,
-0.42429736256599426,
0.34360387921333313,
-0.6030306220054626,
-0.6319741606712341,
0.4325508773326874,
0.35598188638687134,
0.9391487240791321,
-0.6464787721633911,
0.2570246756076813,
0.41534918546676636,
0.3817903995513916,
0.04345966875553131,
0.49308785796165466,
0.034876592457294464,
-0.7234740257263184,
-0.303937703371048,
-0.8560909032821655,
-0.33165645599365234,
0.18199720978736877,
-0.6090801954269409,
0.4026241898536682,
-0.2793344259262085,
-0.0670902207493782,
0.12223193049430847,
0.37712568044662476,
-0.8635230660438538,
0.3428778052330017,
0.17035818099975586,
0.45406827330589294,
-1.167156457901001,
0.8812323212623596,
0.6022464036941528,
-0.3977806866168976,
-1.0210999250411987,
0.1422303318977356,
0.3238847255706787,
-0.6596512198448181,
0.6324985027313232,
0.42254459857940674,
-0.4268239140510559,
0.14534877240657806,
-0.02657894603908062,
-0.6333773732185364,
1.093701720237732,
-0.05820828303694725,
-0.42251649498939514,
-0.2160562127828598,
0.637935996055603,
1.0718514919281006,
-0.510746419429779,
0.6845096945762634,
1.0632164478302002,
0.7716009020805359,
-0.16076184809207916,
-1.0383275747299194,
-0.3403668999671936,
-0.27588504552841187,
-0.5483535528182983,
-0.06384976208209991,
-0.32941704988479614,
0.6635266542434692,
-0.059177860617637634,
-0.16195166110992432,
-0.08499017357826233,
0.20592565834522247,
-0.10875307768583298,
0.735295295715332,
0.20098862051963806,
0.6349624991416931,
0.8088406324386597,
0.0003662286326289177,
1.0206297636032104,
-0.49737170338630676,
0.4069529175758362,
1.012780785560608,
-1.219495177268982,
1.1494907140731812,
-0.03665755316615105,
-0.316220760345459,
0.5682820677757263,
0.4433107376098633,
0.043453019112348557,
0.35570457577705383,
0.1596074402332306,
-0.4201819598674774,
0.10631056129932404,
0.27378854155540466,
0.010876831598579884,
0.9432346820831299,
0.5746374726295471,
-0.03385823220014572,
-0.18026311695575714,
-0.12129606306552887,
0.06495065242052078,
0.23301953077316284,
-0.1281939446926117,
0.830482542514801,
-0.01486197579652071,
-1.11847984790802,
0.16603074967861176,
0.2218383401632309,
0.23732604086399078,
-0.5436282753944397,
-0.32291415333747864,
-0.11459533125162125,
0.22585497796535492,
-0.20875409245491028,
-1.07856285572052,
0.6487449407577515,
0.28696054220199585,
0.2700907289981842,
-0.09187591820955276,
0.8306419253349304,
-0.3908020555973053,
-0.7229822874069214,
0.5491161346435547,
0.5744441747665405,
0.24486684799194336,
0.010827509686350822,
-0.438343346118927,
-0.058762770146131516,
-0.20109567046165466,
-0.21027648448944092,
0.19921064376831055,
0.3819846212863922,
-0.11267703026533127,
0.0645524263381958,
0.47063910961151123,
0.08598285168409348,
-0.15465593338012695,
-0.029990065842866898,
0.35512566566467285,
-0.4346172511577606,
-0.46531566977500916,
-0.7456943988800049,
0.43547502160072327,
-0.07578945904970169,
-0.4191429913043976,
0.7150475382804871,
0.7852964997291565,
0.7374026775360107,
0.17164091765880585,
1.3121036291122437,
0.3678412437438965,
0.7747004628181458,
-0.37502631545066833,
0.4827350080013275,
-0.300476610660553,
0.1424945443868637,
-0.3133247196674347,
-1.0745757818222046,
-0.3074570298194885,
0.7730869650840759,
-0.6376317739486694,
0.15427114069461823,
1.0185590982437134,
0.6477277278900146,
0.24586759507656097,
0.16957853734493256,
0.5183466672897339,
0.1774269938468933,
0.4891400635242462,
0.40740928053855896,
0.6305816769599915,
-0.31703972816467285,
-0.13983036577701569,
-0.08298806101083755,
-0.6713230609893799,
-0.09072168916463852,
-0.6877697110176086,
-0.9751692414283752,
-0.6453943252563477,
-0.29335588216781616,
-0.11225050687789917,
-0.021807335317134857,
0.6354604363441467,
0.025366125628352165,
-0.7147241234779358,
-0.034163035452365875,
0.11033686250448227,
-0.612053632736206,
0.033041588962078094,
-0.2963218092918396,
0.6894891858100891,
-0.18582850694656372,
-0.609483003616333,
0.2835772633552551,
0.6218205690383911,
-0.14225488901138306,
-0.6007802486419678,
0.07589941471815109,
0.15508559346199036,
0.46721377968788147,
0.5022901892662048,
0.028708623722195625,
-0.6081364154815674,
-0.8636605143547058,
0.10640820115804672,
-0.012082606554031372,
-0.0422634482383728,
0.8617812991142273,
-0.5933774709701538,
0.2596298158168793,
0.16451548039913177,
0.5849283933639526,
0.24878646433353424,
0.1133284941315651,
0.2563459277153015,
-0.43122830986976624,
-0.10572297126054764,
0.44591695070266724,
0.36363485455513,
0.31575071811676025,
-0.4927576184272766,
0.29621756076812744,
0.3491033911705017,
-0.8256100416183472,
-0.43580836057662964,
0.13519293069839478,
-0.8982288837432861,
0.19502252340316772,
1.1969993114471436,
-0.35681915283203125,
0.2031204253435135,
-0.4501285254955292,
-0.20027479529380798,
0.16274066269397736,
-0.2627002000808716,
1.0278160572052002,
1.047938585281372,
-0.48693591356277466,
0.21545864641666412,
-0.8878064155578613,
0.6168469786643982,
0.22097116708755493,
-1.1551306247711182,
-0.04425452649593353,
0.451357901096344,
0.3515799045562744,
0.37051528692245483,
0.9827768802642822,
-0.10538936406373978,
0.20690979063510895,
-0.0009650648571550846,
-0.13721461594104767,
0.1977669894695282,
-0.4856239855289459,
-0.4721857011318207,
0.2735675573348999,
0.20386169850826263,
0.13038654625415802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18543v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18543v1
|
Time Machine GPT
| 2024-04-29T09:34:25 | 2024-04-29T09:34:25 |
Felix Drinkall, Eghbal Rahimikia, Janet B. Pierrehumbert, Stefan Zohren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CE, cs.LG, I.2.1, I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) are often trained on extensive, temporally
indiscriminate text corpora, reflecting the lack of datasets with temporal
metadata. This approach is not aligned with the evolving nature of language.
Conventional methods for creating temporally adapted language models often
depend on further pre-training static models on time-specific data. This paper
presents a new approach: a series of point-in-time LLMs called Time Machine GPT
(TiMaGPT), specifically designed to be nonprognosticative. This ensures they
remain uninformed about future factual information and linguistic changes. This
strategy is beneficial for understanding language evolution and is of critical
importance when applying models in dynamic contexts, such as time-series
forecasting, where foresight of future information can prove problematic. We
provide access to both the models and training datasets.
|
[
-0.10516269505023956,
-0.8033429384231567,
0.6115075349807739,
0.22280780971050262,
-0.2914990186691284,
0.3365013301372528,
-0.1922575831413269,
-0.4573894143104553,
-0.14008598029613495,
0.3884011209011078,
-0.7297327518463135,
-0.2607225477695465,
-0.577515721321106,
-0.06758332252502441,
-0.6124549508094788,
1.094628095626831,
-0.10496767610311508,
-0.2493678480386734,
0.3891570270061493,
-0.11306172609329224,
-0.3418641686439514,
-0.6729989647865295,
-0.7809932231903076,
-0.6628470420837402,
0.3505328297615051,
-0.032602306455373764,
0.7587199211120605,
0.6294209957122803,
0.12427378445863724,
0.14679892361164093,
0.036159977316856384,
0.022713113576173782,
-0.28996726870536804,
0.27206951379776,
-0.24969235062599182,
-0.14517463743686676,
-0.26786187291145325,
-0.012915365397930145,
0.8621118664741516,
0.8862015604972839,
-0.19691282510757446,
0.20736493170261383,
0.18950524926185608,
0.33226093649864197,
-0.2754274010658264,
0.34653300046920776,
-0.8042293787002563,
0.3205166459083557,
-0.1626047044992447,
-0.5972084403038025,
-0.4707042872905731,
-0.27834898233413696,
0.19478657841682434,
-0.41063129901885986,
0.3622095286846161,
0.0476839505136013,
0.6361373066902161,
0.3263723850250244,
-0.2543891668319702,
0.10027826577425003,
-1.0289299488067627,
0.917672872543335,
-0.6501048803329468,
0.4297931492328644,
0.09756772965192795,
0.4761911630630493,
-0.44241824746131897,
-0.6811038255691528,
-0.3746626377105713,
-0.4124489724636078,
0.19257792830467224,
-0.1519651561975479,
-0.05734977126121521,
-0.14385630190372467,
0.1699240505695343,
-0.03574960678815842,
-0.7397927641868591,
0.3482535481452942,
0.13566428422927856,
-0.030353926122188568,
0.2422042191028595,
0.23570503294467926,
0.05679170414805412,
0.03974469378590584,
-0.37171614170074463,
0.284246027469635,
-0.7324257493019104,
-0.2678050994873047,
0.09728115051984787,
0.5335186719894409,
-0.022546878084540367,
0.413787305355072,
0.11283818632364273,
0.6575781106948853,
0.004204094875603914,
-0.40087753534317017,
-0.01308397389948368,
-0.03457757830619812,
-0.3208392262458801,
0.1598508656024933,
0.6496590971946716,
-0.10195109248161316,
0.39311322569847107,
-0.4471006989479065,
-0.283819317817688,
-0.20359842479228973,
0.029196392744779587,
-0.7021344304084778,
-0.24355058372020721,
0.15437336266040802,
-0.38232970237731934,
-0.4277113080024719,
-0.26042404770851135,
-0.7441974878311157,
-0.256156325340271,
-0.38187941908836365,
0.24803197383880615,
-0.6166155338287354,
-0.3101961314678192,
-0.22098970413208008,
0.08918295800685883,
0.17789073288440704,
0.3226422965526581,
-0.9223666191101074,
0.013340855948626995,
0.5616136193275452,
1.0690498352050781,
-0.016552018001675606,
-0.44573643803596497,
-0.4388384222984314,
0.6206619143486023,
-0.5616943836212158,
0.7970265746116638,
-0.6765634417533875,
-0.5931959748268127,
0.03993023931980133,
0.35659894347190857,
-0.07947815209627151,
-0.4218786954879761,
0.2056359350681305,
-0.5390712022781372,
0.47119736671447754,
0.20894308388233185,
-0.4096789062023163,
-0.2468956559896469,
0.24320152401924133,
-0.2676784098148346,
1.1313483715057373,
0.4434764087200165,
-0.6894646286964417,
0.5426498055458069,
-0.9405689239501953,
-0.47122201323509216,
0.15206071734428406,
0.006407998502254486,
-0.4040543735027313,
0.0817519947886467,
0.43388235569000244,
0.6384746432304382,
-0.3492562472820282,
0.9390442371368408,
-0.4032050371170044,
-0.19625097513198853,
0.2594510614871979,
-0.573442280292511,
0.5790109038352966,
0.35590699315071106,
-0.36976152658462524,
-0.04334103316068649,
-0.6851238012313843,
0.025971323251724243,
0.3387623131275177,
-0.34352943301200867,
-0.18829065561294556,
0.24460798501968384,
-0.0027817925438284874,
0.2671329379081726,
0.3805908262729645,
-0.2448856681585312,
0.35649359226226807,
-0.1560380905866623,
0.7419398427009583,
0.9290562868118286,
0.1896955668926239,
0.06545466184616089,
-0.3748985826969147,
0.6480692625045776,
0.07085936516523361,
0.33636799454689026,
-0.18874523043632507,
-0.38613662123680115,
-0.6386561989784241,
-0.050794538110494614,
0.13755613565444946,
0.7601819038391113,
-0.8964877128601074,
0.2752915024757385,
-0.5165558457374573,
-0.4518713355064392,
-0.10552025586366653,
-0.049291640520095825,
0.043783076107501984,
0.4455520808696747,
0.21209804713726044,
0.011917751282453537,
-0.5413874983787537,
-0.7040522694587708,
-0.2799355685710907,
-0.2554108798503876,
-0.31081199645996094,
0.012847567908465862,
0.35930201411247253,
-0.41638532280921936,
0.7775200009346008,
-0.3658306300640106,
0.16131490468978882,
-0.3429848253726959,
0.42919284105300903,
0.3592483699321747,
0.18825726211071014,
0.6351168751716614,
-0.3216428756713867,
-0.17678478360176086,
-0.05733134225010872,
-0.8712359666824341,
-0.28913506865501404,
-0.2016378492116928,
0.3613624572753906,
0.4089689254760742,
0.39644894003868103,
-0.28638404607772827,
-0.07850151509046555,
0.8514668345451355,
-0.16119347512722015,
0.30545473098754883,
-0.11210323870182037,
0.0666094496846199,
-1.1912245750427246,
0.15953300893306732,
-0.13249635696411133,
-0.4750611484050751,
-0.5903517603874207,
-0.4781993329524994,
-0.24231117963790894,
-0.47786983847618103,
-0.449788361787796,
0.7719420790672302,
-0.41421952843666077,
-0.09581227600574493,
-0.34163936972618103,
0.030146192759275436,
-0.384305477142334,
0.4534132480621338,
0.1668364703655243,
0.8626459836959839,
0.3505576252937317,
-0.597456693649292,
0.11190800368785858,
-0.11747904866933823,
-0.33096784353256226,
0.2607691287994385,
-0.4776514768600464,
0.3439449369907379,
-0.1352487951517105,
-0.013482506386935711,
-0.6482862234115601,
-0.04430403932929039,
0.18093077838420868,
-0.43513768911361694,
0.6394619941711426,
-0.39359816908836365,
-0.6179719567298889,
-0.27060168981552124,
-0.031614068895578384,
0.2219552844762802,
0.4720798432826996,
-0.6462342143058777,
0.3971567153930664,
0.3907802999019623,
-0.5299909114837646,
-0.5866315364837646,
-0.5422431230545044,
0.09594739973545074,
-0.39034515619277954,
-0.4406503438949585,
0.04542429745197296,
0.0928386002779007,
-0.27260780334472656,
-0.020195912569761276,
0.1275983601808548,
-0.19926521182060242,
0.11692716926336288,
0.1390521228313446,
0.2856940031051636,
-0.3007773458957672,
0.3552300035953522,
-0.18119679391384125,
-0.19291582703590393,
-0.22258971631526947,
-0.7578685283660889,
0.7517022490501404,
0.11573005467653275,
-0.0484459325671196,
-0.2935730516910553,
0.34569624066352844,
0.4867429733276367,
0.07537911087274551,
0.8315379619598389,
0.637414813041687,
-0.538143515586853,
-0.21374645829200745,
-0.47789931297302246,
0.010775992646813393,
-0.46486207842826843,
0.40492093563079834,
-0.13733594119548798,
-0.9873281717300415,
0.34998923540115356,
-0.23392954468727112,
0.0835539922118187,
0.5512347221374512,
0.7160400748252869,
-0.03439781814813614,
0.7627447843551636,
0.8152385950088501,
-0.28478384017944336,
0.8869566321372986,
0.10662286728620529,
0.18927261233329773,
-0.4689801335334778,
-0.2534275949001312,
-0.28378668427467346,
-0.03325716033577919,
-0.6852852702140808,
-0.28816020488739014,
0.2473607063293457,
-0.20134945213794708,
-0.5884398818016052,
0.1997440904378891,
-0.4620552361011505,
0.2858976423740387,
0.3433208763599396,
-0.14329470694065094,
0.27800026535987854,
0.18572290241718292,
0.04893543943762779,
-0.13664008677005768,
-0.5738989114761353,
-0.6582003831863403,
1.2232924699783325,
0.45171305537223816,
0.7447110414505005,
-0.09352947026491165,
0.24515564739704132,
0.38491472601890564,
0.4312824606895447,
-0.5552915334701538,
0.36358919739723206,
-0.30395856499671936,
-0.5829803943634033,
-0.4190887212753296,
-0.45186251401901245,
-1.0648739337921143,
-0.11443407088518143,
0.05331834778189659,
-0.7747161388397217,
-0.06004374846816063,
-0.037950821220874786,
-0.18521128594875336,
0.6045991778373718,
-0.6059359908103943,
0.711189329624176,
-0.3884192109107971,
-0.11454761773347855,
0.0187838077545166,
-0.5344564318656921,
0.2034384161233902,
-0.5319331288337708,
0.23039156198501587,
-0.39705348014831543,
-0.14810630679130554,
0.926596999168396,
-0.4296099841594696,
0.8275585174560547,
-0.4546930491924286,
-0.0022780015133321285,
0.2581745684146881,
0.2938656508922577,
0.556097686290741,
0.09001081436872482,
0.03456292673945427,
0.2953988015651703,
0.08141186833381653,
-0.43647196888923645,
-0.49635788798332214,
0.6744624376296997,
-0.88703852891922,
-0.4783964157104492,
-0.6515733003616333,
-0.7160167694091797,
-0.4140840172767639,
0.13665185868740082,
0.10826154053211212,
0.40276840329170227,
-0.3396652340888977,
-0.2126999795436859,
0.5355089902877808,
-0.320732980966568,
0.7082882523536682,
0.6541467308998108,
-0.18360792100429535,
-0.23644226789474487,
0.6001672148704529,
0.27385997772216797,
0.20094148814678192,
0.7653549313545227,
0.2855159640312195,
-0.3552698493003845,
-0.826443612575531,
0.025008097290992737,
0.4281255006790161,
-0.5652990937232971,
0.04171131178736687,
-0.47765791416168213,
-0.24595002830028534,
-0.4215075373649597,
-0.1273234784603119,
-0.26559627056121826,
-0.6007582545280457,
-0.22041155397891998,
0.07519090175628662,
0.6326113343238831,
0.887951672077179,
0.10654822736978531,
0.6396071910858154,
-0.8286073207855225,
-0.04352418705821037,
0.07000093907117844,
0.3003413677215576,
-0.3786963224411011,
-0.7750609517097473,
-0.1775124967098236,
-0.21391136944293976,
-0.3761600852012634,
-0.6772575974464417,
0.7301809191703796,
0.2550615966320038,
0.4996546506881714,
0.27344605326652527,
-0.24195587635040283,
0.5114902853965759,
-0.6653400659561157,
0.9285610318183899,
-0.005455974023789167,
-0.893545389175415,
0.6886622309684753,
-0.6518363356590271,
0.41641706228256226,
0.11936644464731216,
0.4878630042076111,
-0.7737070322036743,
-0.17122386395931244,
-0.5917676687240601,
-0.5403461456298828,
0.5050944089889526,
-0.22647012770175934,
-0.16457436978816986,
0.06510954350233078,
0.5025520920753479,
0.3553793728351593,
0.4423554837703705,
-0.6468160152435303,
0.10540799051523209,
-0.3335382342338562,
-0.12198018282651901,
-0.6148843169212341,
-0.35296231508255005,
-0.0241637472063303,
-0.10431923717260361,
0.5996044874191284,
-0.20668570697307587,
0.638007402420044,
-0.1818678230047226,
0.02264159917831421,
-0.06283371895551682,
0.44780483841896057,
0.5254188179969788,
0.9025301933288574,
-0.3008972406387329,
-0.07601537555456161,
0.32634466886520386,
-0.4880458414554596,
0.3305562734603882,
0.31260910630226135,
-0.03560136258602142,
0.16332656145095825,
0.5440841317176819,
0.7052158117294312,
0.1390959620475769,
-0.4861328601837158,
0.27080124616622925,
0.2502996325492859,
-0.042021285742521286,
-0.8156573176383972,
-0.31911519169807434,
-0.21930436789989471,
0.48041027784347534,
0.3134436309337616,
-0.2615031599998474,
-0.3516102135181427,
-0.678864598274231,
0.10283317416906357,
0.15767070651054382,
-0.25142765045166016,
-0.5567702054977417,
0.8429630994796753,
-0.15750886499881744,
-0.23075789213180542,
0.8319807648658752,
-0.01566123031079769,
-0.295869380235672,
0.1584821492433548,
0.6677154898643494,
1.040104866027832,
-0.6460311412811279,
0.2371404469013214,
-0.008090290240943432,
0.40290799736976624,
-0.11464162170886993,
0.35364797711372375,
0.42282694578170776,
-0.6424384713172913,
-0.5264217853546143,
-0.6203196048736572,
-0.2655750811100006,
0.6366022825241089,
-0.12357454001903534,
0.38700518012046814,
-0.8262636661529541,
-0.367646187543869,
-0.1857510209083557,
0.06386853754520416,
-0.6708334684371948,
0.23586086928844452,
-0.13017989695072174,
0.6963637471199036,
-0.9009729027748108,
1.2954808473587036,
0.40538397431373596,
-0.1344190537929535,
-0.5539488196372986,
0.21484655141830444,
-0.06964841485023499,
-1.2265413999557495,
0.6921233534812927,
-0.1340734362602234,
0.048977360129356384,
-0.06129704415798187,
-0.4937952160835266,
-0.7680202722549438,
1.2014037370681763,
0.6968685388565063,
-0.6300262808799744,
-0.490568608045578,
0.0774354338645935,
0.5183020234107971,
-0.2681044936180115,
-0.09915826469659805,
0.46652209758758545,
0.42274072766304016,
0.0015928882639855146,
-0.8518255949020386,
-0.050593387335538864,
0.05106513947248459,
0.11196251958608627,
0.7091404795646667,
-0.4800806939601898,
0.8623253107070923,
-0.08530361950397491,
-0.3370254933834076,
-0.025652993470430374,
0.41547825932502747,
-0.10454139113426208,
0.16195426881313324,
0.3794739246368408,
0.3828071355819702,
0.8614485263824463,
-0.30786973237991333,
1.106769323348999,
-0.4226030707359314,
0.2664976418018341,
1.0808007717132568,
-0.1823747456073761,
0.7297546863555908,
0.5158208012580872,
-0.3340698778629303,
0.2690868079662323,
1.0426568984985352,
-0.1818893700838089,
0.6896906495094299,
0.04040197655558586,
-0.4502450227737427,
-0.28396928310394287,
-0.2739367187023163,
-0.442890465259552,
0.19385595619678497,
0.5226013660430908,
-0.44565415382385254,
-0.2821451425552368,
-0.004595660138875246,
0.2735741138458252,
-0.23795896768569946,
-0.21945014595985413,
0.5278677344322205,
0.10283052921295166,
-0.43950867652893066,
0.6114145517349243,
-0.0750490203499794,
0.4171844720840454,
-0.8112869262695312,
0.2913186252117157,
-0.0924733579158783,
0.24075418710708618,
0.012035170570015907,
-0.7860463857650757,
0.38662949204444885,
-0.03691434487700462,
-0.10707488656044006,
-0.19807226955890656,
0.3794144093990326,
-0.33723029494285583,
-0.6209602952003479,
0.39563027024269104,
0.6335664987564087,
0.21180497109889984,
0.0017926241271197796,
-0.7207175493240356,
-0.1371491253376007,
-0.18125270307064056,
-0.19955863058567047,
0.31416237354278564,
0.6556342244148254,
-0.31273114681243896,
0.9260703325271606,
0.3755322992801666,
0.18436507880687714,
-0.039209481328725815,
0.161065012216568,
0.644729495048523,
-0.8542554378509521,
-0.3487418293952942,
-1.0044004917144775,
-0.006953958421945572,
0.34191304445266724,
-0.10439037531614304,
0.3748028874397278,
0.369302898645401,
0.5720638036727905,
0.021225115284323692,
1.0566730499267578,
0.37310242652893066,
0.8659279942512512,
-0.7774800062179565,
0.4517224431037903,
-0.5195430517196655,
0.22719964385032654,
-0.13781404495239258,
-0.9394396543502808,
-0.41706717014312744,
0.18002834916114807,
-0.45395728945732117,
0.24945786595344543,
0.9224847555160522,
0.45760369300842285,
0.10477561503648758,
0.1209111362695694,
0.361297070980072,
0.38546183705329895,
0.588653028011322,
0.7126258611679077,
1.0670310258865356,
0.09563809633255005,
0.5006382465362549,
0.10906840860843658,
-0.30709806084632874,
-0.13962142169475555,
-1.1714518070220947,
-1.0800586938858032,
-0.6031993627548218,
-0.2538684606552124,
0.004251908045262098,
0.4531586170196533,
0.9471573233604431,
0.4795529842376709,
-0.7041725516319275,
-0.14502958953380585,
0.22824065387248993,
-0.28080159425735474,
-0.009424630552530289,
-0.20598942041397095,
0.4183579683303833,
-0.37072956562042236,
-0.6073439717292786,
0.6593296527862549,
0.35794922709465027,
0.5702357888221741,
-0.34974750876426697,
0.2913862466812134,
-0.06765476614236832,
0.013718290254473686,
0.7383331656455994,
0.35754871368408203,
-0.4377484619617462,
-0.649156928062439,
-0.05564914271235466,
0.4840235412120819,
0.21466468274593353,
0.9437318444252014,
-0.6783744692802429,
0.23893210291862488,
0.20388345420360565,
0.5062841773033142,
0.5713402628898621,
-0.2629367411136627,
0.8434082865715027,
-0.7931129336357117,
0.5336198806762695,
0.29294222593307495,
0.49893918633461,
0.5738837718963623,
-0.3466147482395172,
0.5263845324516296,
0.44658610224723816,
-0.7516273260116577,
-0.7643795609474182,
0.2505382001399994,
-0.6147447824478149,
-0.38421598076820374,
0.9787397980690002,
-0.06029621139168739,
-0.12419115751981735,
-0.3869217336177826,
0.2562837600708008,
0.38840463757514954,
-0.43697741627693176,
0.8229703903198242,
0.7758753895759583,
-0.22756655514240265,
-0.17245513200759888,
-0.8839501142501831,
0.36559027433395386,
-0.08520263433456421,
-0.7521160840988159,
0.12419639527797699,
0.03352413699030876,
0.6072242856025696,
-0.104815274477005,
0.6442391276359558,
-0.25592517852783203,
-0.2894645035266876,
-0.1321101039648056,
-0.27989616990089417,
-0.045733027160167694,
-0.5208098888397217,
-0.40920987725257874,
0.1349019855260849,
0.45109230279922485,
-0.178207129240036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18534v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18534v2
|
Evaluating and Mitigating Linguistic Discrimination in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-29T09:22:54 | 2024-05-10T07:09:02 |
Guoliang Dong, Haoyu Wang, Jun Sun, Xinyu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.SE
|
By training on text in various languages, large language models (LLMs)
typically possess multilingual support and demonstrate remarkable capabilities
in solving tasks described in different languages. However, LLMs can exhibit
linguistic discrimination due to the uneven distribution of training data
across languages. That is, LLMs are hard to keep the consistency of responses
when faced with the same task but depicted in different languages.
In this study, we first explore the consistency in the LLMs' outputs
responding to queries in various languages from two aspects: safety and
quality. We conduct this analysis with two datasets (AdvBench and NQ) based on
four LLMs (Llama2-13b, Gemma-7b, GPT-3.5-turbo and Gemini-pro). The results
show that LLMs exhibit stronger human alignment capabilities with queries in
English, French, Russian, and Spanish (only 1.04\% of harmful queries
successfully jailbreak on average) compared to queries in Bengali, Georgian,
Nepali and Maithili (27.7\% of harmful queries jailbreak successfully on
average). Moreover, for queries in English, Danish, Czech and Slovenian, LLMs
tend to produce responses with a higher quality (with 0.1494 $F_1$ score on
average) compared to the other languages. Upon these findings, we propose
LDFighter, a similarity-based voting, to mitigate the linguistic discrimination
in LLMs. LDFighter ensures consistent service for different language speakers.
We evaluate LDFighter with both benign queries and harmful queries. The results
show that LDFighter not only significantly reduces the jailbreak success rate
but also improve the response quality on average, demonstrating its
effectiveness.
|
[
-0.29245564341545105,
-0.6715351939201355,
0.460568368434906,
0.42966708540916443,
-0.25651952624320984,
0.31668099761009216,
-0.43485188484191895,
-0.6454923748970032,
0.30732548236846924,
0.6532692313194275,
-0.23949413001537323,
-0.5672219395637512,
-0.6664519906044006,
0.23038627207279205,
-0.31303682923316956,
0.9030471444129944,
-0.16366887092590332,
0.2843921482563019,
-0.015788385644555092,
-0.43258318305015564,
-0.5886107087135315,
-0.8494964241981506,
-0.7051841020584106,
-0.2358226180076599,
0.5637457966804504,
0.1018536239862442,
0.708791971206665,
0.4687402844429016,
0.5920946002006531,
0.3455256223678589,
-0.27726560831069946,
0.047104593366384506,
-0.5264847874641418,
0.31359657645225525,
-0.42963483929634094,
-0.636495053768158,
-0.08926992118358612,
-0.19276319444179535,
0.560428261756897,
0.4281010031700134,
-0.28128302097320557,
-0.17323368787765503,
0.06643887609243393,
0.8209408521652222,
-0.6533698439598083,
-0.09087657928466797,
-0.9088757634162903,
-0.052558425813913345,
-0.4081469178199768,
0.20502081513404846,
-0.37436583638191223,
-0.5597049593925476,
-0.3799682557582855,
-0.28290218114852905,
0.09233836084604263,
0.0828019231557846,
0.9464008808135986,
0.1451989859342575,
-0.39617106318473816,
-0.3407081663608551,
-0.4773949086666107,
0.7682103514671326,
-0.841594398021698,
0.6016303300857544,
0.6014206409454346,
0.3499622046947479,
-0.19262829422950745,
-0.08661366254091263,
-0.48938068747520447,
-0.26742759346961975,
0.010882644914090633,
-0.08521566540002823,
0.05394388735294342,
-0.06631289422512054,
0.15449406206607819,
0.058173321187496185,
-0.7630658745765686,
0.8215830326080322,
-0.15212774276733398,
-0.5494228005409241,
0.7387294769287109,
0.17229832708835602,
0.3481588661670685,
-0.08335206657648087,
-0.15643389523029327,
-0.07604716718196869,
-0.9996583461761475,
0.08282177150249481,
0.7859463691711426,
0.4006120562553406,
-0.10621537268161774,
0.5944703221321106,
-0.30925047397613525,
0.7822299003601074,
-0.1312595009803772,
-0.2435750663280487,
0.29193153977394104,
-0.2348903864622116,
-0.026250263676047325,
-0.029024139046669006,
1.0102665424346924,
0.5340020060539246,
0.4283059537410736,
-0.15823033452033997,
-0.3573552370071411,
0.2306375354528427,
-0.03133513778448105,
-0.7427623867988586,
0.07215965539216995,
0.08992021530866623,
-0.43111690878868103,
-0.104692742228508,
-0.09914686530828476,
-0.713938295841217,
-0.5763798952102661,
-0.06693219393491745,
0.22497108578681946,
-0.2147950977087021,
-0.3356989622116089,
0.09890824556350708,
0.25985386967658997,
0.2846658229827881,
0.2565794587135315,
-1.0200929641723633,
0.1562117636203766,
0.7302310466766357,
0.6781930923461914,
-0.33565887808799744,
-0.20065324008464813,
-0.568475604057312,
-0.016058610752224922,
-0.382564514875412,
0.5799422860145569,
-0.46865183115005493,
-0.2645472586154938,
0.045044973492622375,
0.07733713090419769,
-0.1694376915693283,
-0.9333239793777466,
0.5426415801048279,
-0.770975649356842,
0.06832326948642731,
-0.3562278747558594,
-0.5405762791633606,
0.014883546158671379,
0.46881774067878723,
-0.655336320400238,
0.887105405330658,
-0.19860711693763733,
-0.8797404766082764,
0.5111169815063477,
-0.09918537735939026,
-0.3944576680660248,
-0.10242162644863129,
-0.3596411943435669,
-0.5391402840614319,
-0.007350449915975332,
0.21215005218982697,
0.3325393497943878,
-0.2617515027523041,
0.32681459188461304,
-0.4071013033390045,
-0.4707508385181427,
0.2736489772796631,
-0.2869599163532257,
0.7950095534324646,
0.20741358399391174,
-0.3816600441932678,
0.11951897293329239,
-0.5742661356925964,
0.03111470490694046,
0.1539440006017685,
-0.6559758186340332,
-0.40285274386405945,
0.21655447781085968,
0.018614234402775764,
0.396659255027771,
0.027195505797863007,
-0.9056111574172974,
-0.06016914173960686,
-0.6228518486022949,
0.2455565482378006,
0.8349539637565613,
-0.2965950667858124,
0.12419568747282028,
-0.21024204790592194,
0.5979277491569519,
-0.003434141166508198,
0.05636024475097656,
0.3559972047805786,
-0.5153595805168152,
-0.5647270083427429,
-0.1214771494269371,
0.30708444118499756,
0.6830025315284729,
-0.8567259907722473,
0.3124283254146576,
-0.2334447205066681,
-0.3607381582260132,
-0.5671135187149048,
0.4606136977672577,
0.5482961535453796,
0.25589242577552795,
0.019899295642971992,
-0.42080479860305786,
-0.4721304476261139,
-0.945217490196228,
-0.37082943320274353,
-0.4814974069595337,
0.09046818315982819,
0.15023578703403473,
0.28569495677948,
-0.09083680808544159,
0.6553972959518433,
-0.18944209814071655,
-0.13318587839603424,
-0.35316258668899536,
-0.42035698890686035,
0.22885702550411224,
0.3976345360279083,
0.8501254320144653,
-0.9114571809768677,
-0.736442506313324,
0.211605966091156,
-0.6924377679824829,
-0.1940993070602417,
0.22515669465065002,
-0.05808117613196373,
0.55417400598526,
0.45901477336883545,
-0.4386101961135864,
0.30106595158576965,
0.7058677077293396,
-0.40555739402770996,
0.5139588713645935,
0.01396238710731268,
0.36278289556503296,
-0.9921064972877502,
-0.146356001496315,
-0.10285519063472748,
-0.18452341854572296,
-0.5022590160369873,
0.2622621953487396,
0.08134612441062927,
0.18520113825798035,
-0.5276118516921997,
0.7188796401023865,
-0.10759712755680084,
-0.03528700768947601,
-0.366878479719162,
0.3211376368999481,
-0.1838921308517456,
0.156956747174263,
0.0012706138659268618,
0.7397448420524597,
0.4793119430541992,
-0.32953956723213196,
0.4799552261829376,
0.22335051000118256,
-0.6001347899436951,
0.6070069074630737,
-0.6955825686454773,
0.17213056981563568,
-0.32388895750045776,
-0.04089938849210739,
-1.049949288368225,
-0.06314998120069504,
0.15462422370910645,
-0.495746910572052,
0.08530601859092712,
-0.15696874260902405,
-0.7624123692512512,
-0.215846449136734,
-0.2282835990190506,
0.23897303640842438,
0.33621907234191895,
-0.6104497909545898,
0.1856646090745926,
0.4065980911254883,
-0.19619499146938324,
-0.7459426522254944,
-0.7087068557739258,
0.08379194140434265,
-0.37495237588882446,
-0.6472398042678833,
-0.0937691256403923,
-0.14580489695072174,
-0.38764044642448425,
-0.1693052500486374,
-0.06739436835050583,
-0.21120375394821167,
0.3296424448490143,
0.12266061455011368,
0.3569180965423584,
-0.12155337631702423,
0.003745060646906495,
-0.07862450182437897,
0.09170958399772644,
-0.05480854958295822,
-0.055935945361852646,
0.5977740287780762,
0.1274939328432083,
-0.5082027912139893,
-0.053458139300346375,
0.3740946054458618,
0.519262969493866,
-0.32837730646133423,
1.1138978004455566,
0.5362265706062317,
-0.1116214394569397,
-0.0755065456032753,
-0.7668408155441284,
-0.0943879559636116,
-0.4624572694301605,
0.4477696716785431,
-0.42024096846580505,
-1.3268779516220093,
0.7713778018951416,
0.2844536304473877,
0.20324300229549408,
0.18822859227657318,
0.833844006061554,
0.0031581867951899767,
1.1266244649887085,
0.6301243305206299,
-0.393319696187973,
0.4864868223667145,
0.41791465878486633,
0.1992255449295044,
-0.5507383942604065,
-0.3676227033138275,
-0.962400496006012,
-0.2591024935245514,
-0.9199901819229126,
-0.26291701197624207,
0.15814843773841858,
0.2818855047225952,
-0.24066711962223053,
0.34718772768974304,
-0.29966768622398376,
0.6953887343406677,
0.2610305845737457,
0.0242649856954813,
0.2830948233604431,
0.2406739592552185,
-0.4701146185398102,
-0.35359737277030945,
-0.5776813626289368,
-0.42315542697906494,
1.0250214338302612,
0.2370373159646988,
0.9278885722160339,
0.5711734294891357,
0.8609136343002319,
0.019849492236971855,
0.30398914217948914,
-0.5686724185943604,
0.5826855897903442,
-0.32511410117149353,
-0.8462640047073364,
-0.18793274462223053,
-0.8265119194984436,
-0.9293267130851746,
0.6463516354560852,
-0.20003129541873932,
-0.9261825084686279,
0.08068440854549408,
-0.07479589432477951,
0.16624562442302704,
0.33753085136413574,
-0.5627651214599609,
0.6953933835029602,
-0.39179033041000366,
-0.4964001476764679,
-0.17965462803840637,
-0.4976309835910797,
0.346946120262146,
-0.46342501044273376,
0.3973247706890106,
-0.45595571398735046,
0.11251713335514069,
0.6988202333450317,
-0.3427240252494812,
0.7799957394599915,
-0.2533271908760071,
-0.299803227186203,
0.07635940611362457,
0.20940740406513214,
0.5060760974884033,
-0.014787131920456886,
-0.5671862959861755,
0.20432798564434052,
-0.07777480036020279,
-0.5109750628471375,
-0.45043233036994934,
0.8372836112976074,
-0.744438111782074,
-0.7300649881362915,
-0.16286689043045044,
-0.43506333231925964,
-0.2290804535150528,
0.19743481278419495,
0.21213455498218536,
-0.01261412538588047,
-0.08506480604410172,
0.13212954998016357,
0.6042957901954651,
-0.5766245126724243,
0.3111923038959503,
0.9663325548171997,
-0.5638002753257751,
-0.19067229330539703,
0.8129022717475891,
-0.033662863075733185,
0.41698095202445984,
0.30950239300727844,
0.2051561325788498,
-0.4429830312728882,
-0.7268871068954468,
-0.5697023868560791,
0.28869736194610596,
-0.7215257287025452,
-0.29628393054008484,
-0.4039994478225708,
-0.08756054192781448,
-0.26743608713150024,
0.02504301629960537,
-0.3049773573875427,
-0.33877843618392944,
0.18200065195560455,
-0.09773648530244827,
0.19141258299350739,
0.6571686267852783,
0.039254579693078995,
0.12532880902290344,
-0.7152107357978821,
0.3046156167984009,
0.06401103734970093,
0.5268734693527222,
-0.08156172931194305,
-0.604238748550415,
-0.2012404501438141,
-0.13570120930671692,
-0.1816704124212265,
-0.84779953956604,
0.18800634145736694,
0.18657703697681427,
0.8231040239334106,
0.17924784123897552,
-0.02297712117433548,
0.4372674226760864,
-0.48660480976104736,
0.6646349430084229,
0.25070908665657043,
-0.830034613609314,
0.5893653035163879,
-0.2104504406452179,
0.11309405416250229,
0.6911285519599915,
0.4154932200908661,
-0.6174688339233398,
-0.8800135254859924,
0.011012648232281208,
-0.8240141868591309,
0.7249867916107178,
0.23499606549739838,
0.26493701338768005,
-0.15272769331932068,
0.2889895439147949,
0.05064709112048149,
0.1413353979587555,
-0.971855103969574,
-0.07718277722597122,
0.031083274632692337,
-0.19553054869174957,
-0.052606623619794846,
-0.22836269438266754,
-0.006465421989560127,
-0.08176039904356003,
0.4481765925884247,
0.047030188143253326,
-0.155517578125,
-0.12399949878454208,
-0.18636161088943481,
0.11582477390766144,
0.5074862241744995,
0.5553744435310364,
0.5086128115653992,
-0.051745619624853134,
0.08596475422382355,
-0.007226202636957169,
-0.4927971363067627,
0.5336330533027649,
-0.036311741918325424,
-0.17738300561904907,
0.032239191234111786,
0.40681198239326477,
0.6071244478225708,
-0.11116336286067963,
-0.8268060088157654,
0.36353835463523865,
-0.18317043781280518,
-0.02319670468568802,
0.2898958623409271,
0.24186068773269653,
0.2044753134250641,
0.16653871536254883,
-0.024936731904745102,
-0.19088348746299744,
-0.09628463536500931,
-0.473183810710907,
0.008661248721182346,
0.5389214158058167,
-0.20711667835712433,
-0.09748345613479614,
0.7126885056495667,
0.22936569154262543,
-0.2363482117652893,
0.6938470005989075,
-0.16066515445709229,
-0.6294853091239929,
0.6847933530807495,
0.6070327162742615,
0.5952284336090088,
-0.47006669640541077,
0.03072284907102585,
0.42809978127479553,
0.5869101881980896,
-0.17956629395484924,
0.387226402759552,
0.15576040744781494,
-0.9743698239326477,
-0.535162091255188,
-0.7786563634872437,
-0.2900219261646271,
-0.15333887934684753,
-0.6730567216873169,
-0.020007917657494545,
-0.5494980812072754,
-0.24777159094810486,
-0.08721311390399933,
-0.0002799715439323336,
-0.42466798424720764,
-0.025819657370448112,
0.15176787972450256,
0.8490884900093079,
-0.9157701134681702,
1.0081408023834229,
0.7580605149269104,
-0.18566367030143738,
-0.7712860107421875,
-0.1684284657239914,
0.10718173533678055,
-0.8366014957427979,
0.895938515663147,
0.16926990449428558,
-0.017632178962230682,
-0.47726884484291077,
-0.3113327920436859,
-0.6154922842979431,
0.506748616695404,
0.7612864971160889,
-0.9074339866638184,
0.3546198606491089,
0.47746098041534424,
0.6240369081497192,
-0.09297589957714081,
0.0554257370531559,
0.6208155155181885,
0.37750008702278137,
-0.1628761887550354,
-1.2593483924865723,
0.0072033642791211605,
-0.10026174783706665,
0.07310988008975983,
0.41520360112190247,
-0.5851911902427673,
0.6140996217727661,
-0.20231881737709045,
-0.07088217884302139,
0.1624375730752945,
0.15613383054733276,
0.5575425624847412,
0.1021604835987091,
0.45555946230888367,
0.5793625712394714,
0.7003244757652283,
-0.31101569533348083,
0.995111882686615,
-0.06819141656160355,
0.3804062306880951,
1.0720242261886597,
-0.6431832909584045,
0.9276766180992126,
0.4226688742637634,
-0.2493424415588379,
0.31668639183044434,
0.49976712465286255,
0.0525595024228096,
0.5174973607063293,
0.3985327482223511,
-0.22887437045574188,
-0.2258453369140625,
-0.20042166113853455,
-0.1962471455335617,
0.5560011863708496,
0.11744195967912674,
-0.2263968139886856,
-0.2611335515975952,
0.13821172714233398,
0.10995236039161682,
0.48519328236579895,
-0.24122129380702972,
0.7590358853340149,
0.025469643995165825,
-0.49931955337524414,
0.7837055921554565,
0.2933601140975952,
0.8857520222663879,
-0.5518567562103271,
0.14875905215740204,
-0.64567631483078,
0.09227419644594193,
-0.36382877826690674,
-0.9999619126319885,
0.400561660528183,
0.30738070607185364,
-0.3541640043258667,
0.044924791902303696,
0.413595587015152,
-0.4438781440258026,
-0.5354907512664795,
0.6533315181732178,
0.34494921565055847,
0.27750054001808167,
0.07471778988838196,
-0.8453785181045532,
0.674626350402832,
0.1282602846622467,
0.007737325970083475,
0.6079201102256775,
0.21827703714370728,
-0.2817061245441437,
0.7322707176208496,
0.5071458220481873,
0.3589031398296356,
0.23992888629436493,
0.24510100483894348,
0.7120087742805481,
-0.45417895913124084,
-0.4840240478515625,
-0.9404792189598083,
0.11830438673496246,
-0.007617394905537367,
-0.07120168954133987,
0.8845208287239075,
0.5926491618156433,
1.007171392440796,
0.12212701141834259,
0.49504756927490234,
-0.07312410324811935,
0.5681208968162537,
-0.7101367712020874,
0.7561762928962708,
-0.5050382018089294,
0.575814425945282,
-0.2584902048110962,
-1.083757758140564,
-0.28239762783050537,
0.5871025919914246,
-0.32216399908065796,
0.09263830631971359,
0.3252965211868286,
0.9109145998954773,
0.14269277453422546,
-0.41210946440696716,
0.5559449791908264,
0.15962383151054382,
0.5274379253387451,
0.7305643558502197,
0.9721017479896545,
-0.24586698412895203,
0.5825976729393005,
0.04316875338554382,
0.06382003426551819,
-0.08001590520143509,
-0.5205172300338745,
-0.9766625165939331,
-0.19916492700576782,
-0.19669786095619202,
-0.5303564667701721,
0.19185009598731995,
0.6654899716377258,
0.6320040822029114,
-0.9613947868347168,
-0.4598214626312256,
0.26293954253196716,
0.42111456394195557,
0.1710444986820221,
-0.24006816744804382,
0.21689988672733307,
-0.2075941115617752,
-0.7123093008995056,
0.2791205048561096,
0.2754022777080536,
-0.15119729936122894,
-0.11700619757175446,
-0.2904975712299347,
-0.024960307404398918,
-0.1405836045742035,
0.5859206318855286,
0.3235423266887665,
-0.8678154349327087,
-0.2796710431575775,
-0.1923026591539383,
-0.38538292050361633,
0.05570579320192337,
0.6814913749694824,
-0.5972976088523865,
0.5293511152267456,
0.40052106976509094,
0.8372425436973572,
0.2107699066400528,
-0.14956924319267273,
0.44899895787239075,
-0.7072504162788391,
0.41494646668434143,
0.19495351612567902,
0.37467193603515625,
0.5895430445671082,
-0.29436755180358887,
0.4540204405784607,
0.010201082564890385,
-0.6487489342689514,
-0.765684187412262,
0.42352110147476196,
-0.6246387958526611,
-0.28672686219215393,
1.1363450288772583,
-0.29013291001319885,
0.05495472624897957,
-0.27597635984420776,
-0.13713505864143372,
-0.11214563250541687,
-0.2126912772655487,
0.7627604007720947,
0.8211517930030823,
0.0011154187377542257,
-0.09116458147764206,
-0.644507884979248,
0.31729599833488464,
0.6026988625526428,
-0.748196542263031,
0.05342734605073929,
0.4155656099319458,
0.6734757423400879,
-0.1261391043663025,
0.6168733239173889,
-0.3678044378757477,
0.22992026805877686,
-0.35957714915275574,
-0.060311198234558105,
0.2980554699897766,
-0.09129714965820312,
-0.4882103502750397,
0.020970428362488747,
0.44513362646102905,
0.06338705122470856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18532v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18532v2
|
MileBench: Benchmarking MLLMs in Long Context
| 2024-04-29T09:19:05 | 2024-05-15T05:43:30 |
Dingjie Song, Shunian Chen, Guiming Hardy Chen, Fei Yu, Xiang Wan, Benyou Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Despite the advancements and impressive performance of Multimodal Large
Language Models (MLLMs) on benchmarks, their effectiveness in real-world,
long-context, and multi-image tasks is unclear due to the benchmarks' limited
scope. Existing benchmarks often focus on single-image and short-text samples,
and when assessing multi-image tasks, they either limit the image count or
focus on specific task (e.g time-series captioning), potentially obscuring the
performance challenges of MLLMs. To address these limitations, we introduce
MileBench, a pioneering benchmark designed to test the MultImodal Long-contExt
capabilities of MLLMs. This benchmark comprises not only multimodal long
contexts, but also multiple tasks requiring both comprehension and generation.
We establish two distinct evaluation sets, diagnostic and realistic, to
systematically assess MLLMs' long-context adaptation capacity and their ability
to complete tasks in long-context scenarios. Our experimental results, obtained
from testing 22 models, revealed that while the closed-source GPT-4o
outperforms others, most open-source MLLMs struggle in long-context situations.
Interestingly, the performance gap tends to widen with an increase in the
number of images. We strongly encourage an intensification of research efforts
towards enhancing MLLMs' long-context capabilities, especially in scenarios
involving multiple images.
|
[
-0.6626400947570801,
-0.6216551065444946,
0.7168444991111755,
0.5201992988586426,
-0.3537631928920746,
-0.049003053456544876,
-0.4498395025730133,
-0.6996178030967712,
-0.30816400051116943,
0.3897712826728821,
-0.5623831748962402,
-0.44793716073036194,
-0.49123263359069824,
0.11196772754192352,
-0.2924019694328308,
0.8182229399681091,
-0.36280882358551025,
0.022396543994545937,
-0.590531587600708,
-0.7690657377243042,
-0.5086266994476318,
-0.5282784104347229,
-0.5345627665519714,
0.08262401074171066,
0.8537968397140503,
0.06092570349574089,
0.4608960747718811,
0.2490784227848053,
0.5235040187835693,
0.2751850187778473,
0.250293493270874,
0.1920640617609024,
-0.4043966829776764,
0.3343886733055115,
-0.17368851602077484,
0.02412049099802971,
-0.21037334203720093,
-0.0480818971991539,
0.9576709866523743,
0.6519603133201599,
0.04245968535542488,
0.3319272994995117,
0.07545140385627747,
0.8877583742141724,
-0.8997359871864319,
0.01701553538441658,
-0.3052959144115448,
-0.003846629522740841,
-0.21324744820594788,
0.1357111632823944,
-0.19145101308822632,
0.009581063874065876,
-0.047850482165813446,
-0.45956358313560486,
0.1001356691122055,
0.31498220562934875,
0.555509626865387,
0.23412907123565674,
-0.6109157800674438,
-0.042356811463832855,
-0.7058172821998596,
0.8401568531990051,
-0.6417098045349121,
0.7652589678764343,
0.2681962251663208,
0.755122184753418,
-0.044490884989500046,
-0.7751213908195496,
-0.5679202675819397,
-0.5734930038452148,
0.07709934562444687,
-0.009253466501832008,
-0.14482882618904114,
-0.09769774228334427,
0.4776245951652527,
0.09601683914661407,
-0.6850582957267761,
0.05291066691279411,
-0.41948145627975464,
-0.14404620230197906,
0.409023642539978,
0.11337471753358841,
-0.1270824521780014,
0.003324889810755849,
-0.7326831817626953,
-0.21473737061023712,
-0.5841508507728577,
0.022274544462561607,
0.04675153270363808,
0.12010524421930313,
-0.19445686042308807,
0.475435733795166,
-0.4483681321144104,
0.7623370885848999,
-0.5893189311027527,
-0.09304102510213852,
0.4493034780025482,
-0.36114558577537537,
-0.2424314171075821,
-0.2050635665655136,
0.6722284555435181,
0.7460702657699585,
0.011464488692581654,
-0.19840288162231445,
-0.3010197877883911,
-0.08565504848957062,
0.104742132127285,
-1.0433988571166992,
0.05333005636930466,
0.26091986894607544,
-0.34590885043144226,
-0.00533372163772583,
-0.23502561450004578,
-0.9646914601325989,
-0.5054702758789062,
-0.25927913188934326,
0.47022223472595215,
-0.2602016031742096,
-0.19712617993354797,
-0.1438141018152237,
-0.18279701471328735,
0.08908801525831223,
0.15450744330883026,
-0.4609215259552002,
0.1612393856048584,
0.5664041042327881,
1.0130764245986938,
-0.453018456697464,
-0.8912419676780701,
-0.8882555365562439,
0.024943513795733452,
-0.3083343505859375,
0.7167168259620667,
-0.3393908441066742,
-0.15316545963287354,
-0.07313255965709686,
0.21371984481811523,
-0.15010634064674377,
-0.5855789184570312,
0.5209664702415466,
-0.45639747381210327,
0.09214694052934647,
-0.33816757798194885,
-0.4968911409378052,
-0.04525955766439438,
0.6427521705627441,
-0.8923761248588562,
1.0965826511383057,
0.38090354204177856,
-0.5462566614151001,
0.46118617057800293,
-0.9288548231124878,
-0.37617984414100647,
-0.14687557518482208,
-0.15661457180976868,
-0.29651114344596863,
0.1746170073747635,
0.13024991750717163,
0.5764651298522949,
-0.3590600788593292,
0.21250522136688232,
-0.6349776387214661,
-0.29009008407592773,
0.2321578860282898,
-0.6086089015007019,
0.32775190472602844,
0.11480988562107086,
-0.40324464440345764,
0.5102092027664185,
-0.709516704082489,
0.0906725749373436,
0.2142653912305832,
-0.22506336867809296,
-0.2664579749107361,
0.02225041575729847,
0.45076024532318115,
0.526337206363678,
0.058588504791259766,
-0.635974109172821,
-0.04592425748705864,
0.13372784852981567,
0.35282251238822937,
0.6222298741340637,
-0.2114001363515854,
0.05751766264438629,
-0.26950207352638245,
0.4602830708026886,
0.13652822375297546,
0.25173771381378174,
-0.3089674115180969,
-0.18403947353363037,
-0.7313989996910095,
-0.2924802601337433,
0.09241054952144623,
0.15205366909503937,
-0.8245566487312317,
0.031204236671328545,
-0.533498227596283,
-0.3706212341785431,
-0.25089991092681885,
0.2067214697599411,
0.41101446747779846,
0.41258877515792847,
0.5609756112098694,
-0.40818455815315247,
-0.31963253021240234,
-1.1019920110702515,
-0.21705198287963867,
0.2723647654056549,
-0.14881882071495056,
0.5455390214920044,
0.6553149223327637,
-0.18910342454910278,
0.7638717889785767,
-0.25724875926971436,
-0.11040851473808289,
0.006462742108851671,
-0.03553014248609543,
-0.10105865448713303,
0.3475895822048187,
0.6209328174591064,
-0.7926685810089111,
-0.36670029163360596,
-0.15578237175941467,
-0.7103179693222046,
0.24560324847698212,
-0.17729932069778442,
-0.04833092540502548,
0.4993841350078583,
0.5247898697853088,
-0.6405221223831177,
0.24001115560531616,
1.0426905155181885,
-0.3748573660850525,
0.8808016180992126,
-0.25281116366386414,
0.18097776174545288,
-0.8388857841491699,
0.40039199590682983,
-0.16423380374908447,
-0.43611007928848267,
-0.5571563243865967,
0.2249862253665924,
0.3938262462615967,
-0.16088254749774933,
-0.5189537405967712,
0.6817643046379089,
-0.4932321012020111,
-0.3685644567012787,
-0.218488872051239,
0.13634276390075684,
0.19376902282238007,
0.4760861098766327,
-0.11239373683929443,
0.923122227191925,
0.5081511735916138,
-0.40883976221084595,
0.53580641746521,
-0.1899229884147644,
-0.7411834597587585,
0.7039031386375427,
-0.5888029932975769,
0.11004507541656494,
0.025698192417621613,
0.4982038140296936,
-0.8087915778160095,
-0.24067218601703644,
-0.0202761460095644,
0.23025834560394287,
0.17307698726654053,
0.03652589023113251,
-0.7292490005493164,
-0.4988985061645508,
-0.32271987199783325,
0.5750359892845154,
0.27790310978889465,
-0.7125489711761475,
0.5633770823478699,
-0.030810870230197906,
0.023973004892468452,
-0.3948177993297577,
-0.32983383536338806,
0.38174375891685486,
-0.4537574350833893,
-0.5653277635574341,
0.21491312980651855,
-0.34256184101104736,
-0.09751181304454803,
-0.24781794846057892,
-0.1371564120054245,
0.11727507412433624,
0.02395220473408699,
0.42540743947029114,
0.01678275689482689,
-0.35131239891052246,
0.3619241416454315,
-0.22539201378822327,
0.059346411377191544,
0.04052194952964783,
-0.05064549297094345,
0.5950184464454651,
-0.5605634450912476,
-0.6712401509284973,
0.1551491916179657,
0.5189754366874695,
0.9020219445228577,
-0.5162301659584045,
0.6501829028129578,
0.9088506102561951,
-0.04952636733651161,
-0.14667156338691711,
-0.8764951825141907,
0.03698908910155296,
-0.4636913239955902,
0.5855726599693298,
-0.5556622743606567,
-0.9831883907318115,
0.30590030550956726,
-0.30149248242378235,
-0.024324921891093254,
0.2700639069080353,
0.33658260107040405,
-0.1487998515367508,
0.7262088656425476,
0.617713212966919,
-0.24431607127189636,
0.2750571668148041,
0.01830703765153885,
-0.14519506692886353,
-0.9868757128715515,
0.043031979352235794,
-0.06456183642148972,
-0.29675641655921936,
-0.38954898715019226,
-0.7757644057273865,
0.45963212847709656,
0.14165207743644714,
-0.3228667080402374,
0.18892017006874084,
-0.22490189969539642,
0.5480703711509705,
0.40134283900260925,
0.11014532297849655,
0.18023021519184113,
-0.08710040152072906,
-0.049112468957901,
0.20171642303466797,
-0.5870246291160583,
-0.31063467264175415,
1.049168348312378,
0.37014591693878174,
0.21941809356212616,
0.26741692423820496,
0.3568178117275238,
0.18839916586875916,
0.4614664912223816,
-0.593829333782196,
0.5435267686843872,
0.03205298259854317,
-0.7000595927238464,
-0.37229862809181213,
-0.2200223207473755,
-0.9093725681304932,
0.5038795471191406,
-0.005747450049966574,
-0.511775553226471,
-0.04756762087345123,
0.02758590690791607,
-0.2018023580312729,
0.3092079162597656,
-0.4554373025894165,
1.3031009435653687,
-0.6094518303871155,
-0.6933087706565857,
-0.2511555254459381,
-0.8235990405082703,
0.291852742433548,
-0.35013240575790405,
0.3581394553184509,
-0.494331955909729,
-0.14428164064884186,
0.4948788583278656,
-0.06093009188771248,
0.6932538747787476,
-0.3115962743759155,
-0.08148595690727234,
0.022771211341023445,
0.00535533856600523,
0.4784892797470093,
-0.2878760099411011,
-0.032469797879457474,
0.3259830176830292,
0.294386088848114,
-0.4933234751224518,
-0.38548481464385986,
0.832271933555603,
-0.3971076011657715,
-0.3590150773525238,
-0.2032400667667389,
-0.6324605941772461,
-0.5221137404441833,
0.41218137741088867,
-0.04325484484434128,
0.4071514308452606,
-0.4818017780780792,
0.41687968373298645,
0.12419771403074265,
-0.13855144381523132,
0.6761289238929749,
0.4069538712501526,
-0.49932533502578735,
-0.2723731994628906,
0.8653227686882019,
-0.34794145822525024,
0.44142961502075195,
0.028003785759210587,
0.13068421185016632,
-0.3784531354904175,
-0.589605450630188,
-0.8468292355537415,
0.03518436849117279,
-0.9226894974708557,
0.058592524379491806,
-0.3253304362297058,
0.13274024426937103,
0.032800763845443726,
0.04931095242500305,
-0.48355409502983093,
-0.2071424424648285,
0.08250688761472702,
0.3088136613368988,
0.10662278532981873,
0.4698689877986908,
0.2224280834197998,
-0.16398997604846954,
-0.9218164086341858,
0.28063082695007324,
0.28458380699157715,
0.7580848932266235,
0.042657170444726944,
-0.20720286667346954,
-0.3867046535015106,
-0.12951570749282837,
-0.1807900071144104,
-0.4419400095939636,
0.05182468518614769,
0.21106751263141632,
0.4772060811519623,
0.2957638204097748,
-0.023568429052829742,
0.8918734788894653,
-0.7712230682373047,
0.815363347530365,
0.28771185874938965,
-0.6772539615631104,
0.09992697089910507,
-0.35598576068878174,
0.545124888420105,
0.6443105936050415,
0.30408379435539246,
-0.6074839234352112,
-0.12421514093875885,
-0.2303321361541748,
-0.788032054901123,
0.22257661819458008,
0.2821837067604065,
0.16450318694114685,
0.16344816982746124,
-0.10904034972190857,
0.11429228633642197,
0.3493058383464813,
-0.6131983995437622,
0.08682085573673248,
-0.3801715672016144,
-0.02139955572783947,
-0.5565345883369446,
-0.2540171146392822,
-0.4541158080101013,
-0.22648738324642181,
0.2446214109659195,
-0.34163522720336914,
0.013828147202730179,
0.25499412417411804,
-0.2640954852104187,
0.04369442164897919,
0.49537932872772217,
1.1238281726837158,
0.9514718651771545,
-0.21266023814678192,
0.2269868701696396,
0.37317562103271484,
-0.15088997781276703,
-0.07529022544622421,
0.4970426559448242,
0.4420674443244934,
-0.002791989827528596,
0.4645760953426361,
1.0144034624099731,
0.22583931684494019,
-1.0384576320648193,
0.5385521650314331,
0.11864806711673737,
-0.17847977578639984,
-0.3791959881782532,
-0.1460934579372406,
0.2928958237171173,
0.47323986887931824,
0.24147692322731018,
-0.028341809287667274,
0.06732344627380371,
-0.42601948976516724,
0.13770808279514313,
0.5288832783699036,
-0.19994650781154633,
-0.06971368193626404,
0.5382887721061707,
0.20493870973587036,
-0.06294038891792297,
0.5311824679374695,
-0.1386609971523285,
-0.39671632647514343,
0.6517828106880188,
0.46124619245529175,
0.7555033564567566,
0.19513393938541412,
-0.2579101026058197,
0.258074015378952,
0.19394807517528534,
-0.1281624585390091,
-0.041965045034885406,
-0.3821881413459778,
-0.43664929270744324,
-0.3920811414718628,
-0.7084395289421082,
-0.387630432844162,
0.20773257315158844,
-0.558719277381897,
-0.11591829359531403,
-0.1554396003484726,
-0.17082998156547546,
0.15571348369121552,
-0.23285812139511108,
-0.751990556716919,
0.04614431783556938,
0.43092769384384155,
0.9085273146629333,
-0.4071228504180908,
0.8975719809532166,
0.4460645616054535,
-0.015646353363990784,
-0.4136965870857239,
-0.14102835953235626,
-0.09696608036756516,
-0.6065264344215393,
0.6277865767478943,
0.6813945174217224,
-0.29478755593299866,
-0.10441087186336517,
-0.36431989073753357,
-0.833422839641571,
1.3368980884552002,
-0.03963819891214371,
-0.8467192649841309,
0.16064445674419403,
0.23791195452213287,
0.5123509168624878,
-0.4560665190219879,
-0.0799688920378685,
0.5386881828308105,
0.6855772137641907,
-0.11010430753231049,
-1.1878125667572021,
0.2913164496421814,
-0.17763791978359222,
0.12849456071853638,
0.3687354326248169,
-0.667235255241394,
0.7296638488769531,
-0.22456088662147522,
-0.10605521500110626,
0.3244076073169708,
0.4547281861305237,
0.3938297927379608,
0.661766529083252,
0.8188382387161255,
0.3728366792201996,
0.4292237162590027,
0.09410044550895691,
1.1663122177124023,
-0.4581567347049713,
0.37174731492996216,
1.3736199140548706,
-0.5568916201591492,
1.094014048576355,
0.6499133706092834,
-0.2452073097229004,
0.49270099401474,
0.4129627048969269,
-0.3196161985397339,
0.3822987377643585,
0.19313789904117584,
-0.526863694190979,
-0.19192512333393097,
-0.03845564275979996,
-0.3722994923591614,
0.40166959166526794,
0.1604621410369873,
-0.36794573068618774,
-0.33582010865211487,
0.3073848485946655,
-0.25139710307121277,
-0.3245161473751068,
-0.13040325045585632,
0.44014057517051697,
0.01601357012987137,
-0.8248471021652222,
0.806424617767334,
-0.10114336013793945,
0.5758581757545471,
-0.6578229665756226,
0.12552009522914886,
-0.035356566309928894,
0.25896331667900085,
0.0841589942574501,
-0.734936535358429,
0.15488021075725555,
-0.09966553747653961,
-0.11313866823911667,
-0.033220723271369934,
0.677338182926178,
-0.43929415941238403,
-0.503450334072113,
0.3726450502872467,
0.522376537322998,
0.2082095593214035,
-0.5072053074836731,
-0.6982794404029846,
0.36544880270957947,
-0.18824666738510132,
-0.526267945766449,
0.5191903114318848,
0.06330372393131256,
-0.1987590342760086,
0.6783090233802795,
0.7561394572257996,
-0.3064310550689697,
0.0065620290115475655,
0.26132187247276306,
0.9794500470161438,
-0.7760124206542969,
-0.13081508874893188,
-0.975648820400238,
0.48124393820762634,
-0.2741050720214844,
-0.3677375316619873,
0.8722022771835327,
0.8121837973594666,
0.7295530438423157,
-0.11195987462997437,
0.6007307171821594,
0.06091351807117462,
0.18330931663513184,
-0.5347373485565186,
0.7644016146659851,
-0.8556188344955444,
-0.11290591955184937,
-0.02567199617624283,
-0.9011350870132446,
-0.2864905893802643,
0.04563669487833977,
-0.193679541349411,
0.15016649663448334,
0.9131350517272949,
0.6175355911254883,
-0.3026288151741028,
-0.10316380858421326,
0.5808618664741516,
-0.02960263192653656,
0.31161388754844666,
0.5712432861328125,
0.9534730315208435,
-0.12962709367275238,
0.6513525247573853,
-0.5191007256507874,
-0.0029021434020251036,
-0.10541195422410965,
-1.2122923135757446,
-0.9842382073402405,
-0.5541972517967224,
0.07847517728805542,
-0.09995096176862717,
0.044238027185201645,
0.6409479379653931,
0.8564196825027466,
-0.5684812664985657,
-0.17421792447566986,
0.1201920136809349,
-0.30235689878463745,
-0.2754875719547272,
-0.1657753884792328,
0.5009494423866272,
-0.09337915480136871,
-0.4661976099014282,
0.6176968812942505,
0.38520291447639465,
0.05039210245013237,
-0.4285837709903717,
-0.12671631574630737,
0.15520107746124268,
-0.19399182498455048,
1.1375551223754883,
0.2669026255607605,
-0.8183761239051819,
-0.37112554907798767,
-0.1554410308599472,
-0.08274601399898529,
0.0369681753218174,
0.7722231149673462,
-0.7522218823432922,
0.6077845096588135,
0.024816570803523064,
0.5613912343978882,
0.7913820147514343,
-0.017349787056446075,
0.25138962268829346,
-0.8071339726448059,
0.24550242722034454,
0.2101207822561264,
0.35531795024871826,
0.49717381596565247,
0.19731611013412476,
0.5472436547279358,
0.0008246523793786764,
-0.6474494338035583,
-0.9054929614067078,
0.17218376696109772,
-1.1179808378219604,
-0.5210182666778564,
1.2008651494979858,
-0.09920263290405273,
0.005530628375709057,
0.02687033824622631,
-0.020622404292225838,
-0.08099350333213806,
-0.05749417841434479,
0.5003284811973572,
0.7545669078826904,
-0.09185345470905304,
-0.2771240174770355,
-1.0444122552871704,
0.23379141092300415,
0.4397381842136383,
-0.8718171119689941,
0.2809058725833893,
0.7945019006729126,
0.5104849338531494,
0.10812704265117645,
0.4551781117916107,
0.18194079399108887,
0.2487148940563202,
-0.013211412355303764,
0.04559227451682091,
-0.4231736958026886,
-0.29798224568367004,
-0.25983408093452454,
0.30050233006477356,
0.13468381762504578,
-0.22978511452674866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01589v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01589v2
|
GPT-4 passes most of the 297 written Polish Board Certification Examinations
| 2024-04-29T09:08:22 | 2024-05-09T10:21:57 |
Jakub Pokrywka, Jeremi Kaczmarek, Edward Gorzelańczyk
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Introduction: Recently, the effectiveness of Large Language Models (LLMs) has
increased rapidly, allowing them to be used in a great number of applications.
However, the risks posed by the generation of false information through LLMs
significantly limit their applications in sensitive areas such as healthcare,
highlighting the necessity for rigorous validations to determine their utility
and reliability. To date, no study has extensively compared the performance of
LLMs on Polish medical examinations across a broad spectrum of specialties on a
very large dataset. Objectives: This study evaluated the performance of three
Generative Pretrained Transformer (GPT) models on the Polish Board
Certification Exam (Pa\'nstwowy Egzamin Specjalizacyjny, PES) dataset, which
consists of 297 tests. Methods: We developed a software program to download and
process PES exams and tested the performance of GPT models using OpenAI
Application Programming Interface. Results: Our findings reveal that GPT-3.5
did not pass any of the analyzed exams. In contrast, the GPT-4 models
demonstrated the capability to pass the majority of the exams evaluated, with
the most recent model, gpt-4-0125, successfully passing 222 (75%) of them. The
performance of the GPT models varied significantly, displaying excellence in
exams related to certain specialties while completely failing others.
Conclusions: The significant progress and impressive performance of LLM models
hold great promise for the increased application of AI in the field of medicine
in Poland. For instance, this advancement could lead to the development of
AI-based medical assistants for healthcare professionals, enhancing the
efficiency and accuracy of medical services.
|
[
-0.3526858985424042,
-0.6306342482566833,
0.9569114446640015,
0.27480190992355347,
-0.3167440593242645,
-0.11214104294776917,
-0.1087002232670784,
-0.4032994508743286,
-0.21209245920181274,
0.4174988865852356,
-0.4301350712776184,
-0.7690169811248779,
-0.6549234986305237,
0.36230695247650146,
-0.186847984790802,
0.8464502692222595,
-0.3701463043689728,
0.4943380653858185,
0.034141991287469864,
0.4399600327014923,
-0.34291818737983704,
-0.6507354378700256,
-0.24863243103027344,
-0.5776313543319702,
-0.08818770945072174,
-0.012488692998886108,
0.5214360952377319,
-0.050786420702934265,
0.7251240015029907,
0.2983047366142273,
0.011219886131584644,
-0.12665177881717682,
-0.1476074606180191,
-0.1983940452337265,
0.03295278549194336,
-0.5461240410804749,
-0.682953417301178,
0.29939281940460205,
0.6911733746528625,
0.5439358353614807,
-0.3389934301376343,
-0.030101938173174858,
-0.06794178485870361,
0.47060203552246094,
-0.18974696099758148,
0.33564499020576477,
-0.45147573947906494,
0.26413583755493164,
-0.26923635601997375,
0.07837461680173874,
-0.6416678428649902,
-0.3809329867362976,
0.03762821853160858,
-0.6625230312347412,
0.26500093936920166,
-0.301028311252594,
0.9680103063583374,
0.06585006415843964,
-0.372085839509964,
-0.34147098660469055,
-0.7132521271705627,
0.5446445941925049,
-0.7208688259124756,
0.5413885712623596,
0.221462681889534,
0.3157804310321808,
-0.18422669172286987,
-1.17007315158844,
-0.43380963802337646,
-0.3229192793369293,
0.17654775083065033,
0.46025994420051575,
-0.03455205634236336,
0.35743051767349243,
0.3284810781478882,
0.4843008816242218,
-0.7726308703422546,
0.21133065223693848,
-0.5909185409545898,
-0.230337992310524,
0.3477606475353241,
0.45682087540626526,
0.4346567988395691,
0.050672877579927444,
-0.45861390233039856,
-0.10912857204675674,
-0.8507869839668274,
-0.14130546152591705,
0.2726031243801117,
0.08819382637739182,
-0.12045225501060486,
0.4228338897228241,
0.006734647322446108,
0.7916660904884338,
-0.100472092628479,
-0.36691930890083313,
0.5888193249702454,
-0.6166254281997681,
-0.35453513264656067,
-0.2680874168872833,
0.9756909012794495,
0.26235395669937134,
0.22644628584384918,
-0.16235218942165375,
0.009687469340860844,
0.1415511667728424,
0.37152528762817383,
-0.6980428695678711,
-0.32413169741630554,
0.05647027865052223,
-0.3973686099052429,
-0.23352593183517456,
0.15206502377986908,
-0.7859729528427124,
0.05046660825610161,
-0.30603063106536865,
0.5225518941879272,
-0.3112885057926178,
-0.06553720682859421,
0.5171244144439697,
0.2990141212940216,
0.7293945550918579,
0.49422696232795715,
-0.7971305847167969,
0.5108457207679749,
0.6795904040336609,
0.757948100566864,
-0.41203421354293823,
-0.23252354562282562,
-0.00010425665095681325,
-0.22547000646591187,
-0.6478978991508484,
0.5543152093887329,
-0.3990077078342438,
-0.5239900350570679,
-0.1909485012292862,
0.16925527155399323,
-0.6577346324920654,
-0.4511410892009735,
0.7150822877883911,
-0.6374676823616028,
0.2923581302165985,
-0.05775003135204315,
-0.44362422823905945,
-0.07850196957588196,
0.4360986649990082,
-0.5801035165786743,
0.9062747955322266,
0.36067867279052734,
-0.5102344751358032,
0.41526544094085693,
-0.5238246321678162,
-0.41151753067970276,
0.1371593326330185,
-0.3686293661594391,
-0.6819150447845459,
-0.05019020661711693,
0.04624621942639351,
0.3592580258846283,
-0.4549647569656372,
0.251555472612381,
0.027611320838332176,
-0.6796505451202393,
-0.08386950939893723,
-0.4191778302192688,
0.6588609218597412,
-0.06663674861192703,
-0.4410082995891571,
0.15802092850208282,
-0.5852856636047363,
0.19443494081497192,
0.1049858033657074,
-0.3895789086818695,
0.17552080750465393,
-0.32816627621650696,
-0.0944201722741127,
0.614471971988678,
-0.07443135231733322,
-0.8431774377822876,
0.3099447190761566,
-0.4899710416793823,
0.23941954970359802,
0.7122276425361633,
0.012630327604711056,
-0.07510439306497574,
-0.10411346703767776,
0.9689266681671143,
-0.16156917810440063,
0.5649442076683044,
0.24421878159046173,
-1.1619594097137451,
-0.30600953102111816,
0.012014592066407204,
0.45717763900756836,
0.6797637343406677,
-0.6459527015686035,
0.5072584748268127,
-0.21600241959095,
-0.7176320552825928,
-0.5108653903007507,
-0.042161617428064346,
0.3081759810447693,
0.8204629421234131,
0.28048014640808105,
0.0047233267687261105,
-0.17081432044506073,
-0.8626192212104797,
-0.13473902642726898,
-0.07418306171894073,
-0.17216633260250092,
0.1591775119304657,
0.6003195643424988,
-0.18382258713245392,
0.38139608502388,
-0.42754554748535156,
-0.4684726595878601,
-0.4467693567276001,
-0.16719374060630798,
0.596486508846283,
0.32909664511680603,
0.6454789638519287,
-0.6396790146827698,
-0.8428189754486084,
-0.07403375953435898,
-0.5170645117759705,
-0.032818395644426346,
0.20802736282348633,
-0.05323832109570503,
0.12409913539886475,
0.1241568848490715,
-0.5708593726158142,
0.4907394349575043,
0.8001938462257385,
-0.5692711472511292,
0.7416147589683533,
-0.4920230805873871,
0.3056042492389679,
-0.5747990012168884,
0.06074728071689606,
-0.2803983986377716,
-0.17822836339473724,
-0.7921590209007263,
-0.12483870983123779,
0.2360401153564453,
-0.2801094949245453,
-0.5601526498794556,
0.3737201690673828,
-0.28701087832450867,
-0.07884594053030014,
0.06820715963840485,
-0.17186342179775238,
-0.025880515575408936,
0.41762182116508484,
-0.0977751761674881,
0.9277605414390564,
0.6631152629852295,
-0.3344610333442688,
0.2518293559551239,
0.5797109007835388,
-0.5137376189231873,
0.14719918370246887,
-0.6272402405738831,
0.0886702686548233,
0.3219680190086365,
0.06418916583061218,
-0.8839033246040344,
-0.1658385694026947,
0.13495446741580963,
-0.21238790452480316,
0.39558151364326477,
0.06254598498344421,
-0.6127824783325195,
-0.7664565443992615,
-0.1549779772758484,
-0.030948234722018242,
0.928945004940033,
-0.377219557762146,
0.8046695590019226,
0.054212786257267,
-0.1566413938999176,
-0.3125591576099396,
-0.827707827091217,
-0.11124244332313538,
0.04609302058815956,
-0.7416236400604248,
0.29148295521736145,
-0.06475844234228134,
0.07938209176063538,
-0.3037043809890747,
-0.008772963657975197,
-0.04318772256374359,
0.07798384130001068,
0.2086612582206726,
0.6527599096298218,
-0.22696642577648163,
-0.179891899228096,
-0.14027583599090576,
-0.2552623152732849,
0.2543700039386749,
0.04723261669278145,
0.6555235385894775,
-0.4736679792404175,
-0.7303555011749268,
-0.7388227581977844,
0.1279595047235489,
0.8215763568878174,
-0.1411784142255783,
0.7689096331596375,
0.45236366987228394,
-0.06086719408631325,
0.251112163066864,
-0.7345123291015625,
0.03782730922102928,
-0.4869496524333954,
0.5125353336334229,
-0.5560573935508728,
-0.690401017665863,
0.6495549082756042,
-0.06789398193359375,
-0.20513612031936646,
0.7142044305801392,
0.7657957673072815,
0.09561066329479218,
1.0993338823318481,
0.2886298894882202,
0.09108791500329971,
0.1261378824710846,
-0.18722286820411682,
0.35078153014183044,
-0.8048120141029358,
-0.2610708177089691,
-0.34368565678596497,
0.10394372791051865,
-0.7790749073028564,
-0.39262980222702026,
0.8182356357574463,
-0.1972815990447998,
-0.3445788621902466,
-0.2731010615825653,
-0.538666307926178,
0.42380666732788086,
0.44226697087287903,
0.3502233326435089,
0.4194349944591522,
-0.07660481333732605,
-0.14795751869678497,
-0.13423776626586914,
-0.6915408372879028,
-0.6634256839752197,
1.5880177021026611,
0.45283225178718567,
0.6330843567848206,
-0.03628529608249664,
0.5436160564422607,
-0.15898610651493073,
0.7340959310531616,
-0.5650508403778076,
0.41027775406837463,
-0.4650346040725708,
-0.6194950342178345,
-0.4101591408252716,
-0.27605172991752625,
-0.6791080236434937,
0.3231865167617798,
0.11137063056230545,
-0.39970988035202026,
0.0829387828707695,
0.054635945707559586,
-0.35504260659217834,
0.5727983713150024,
-0.6108438968658447,
1.0012383460998535,
-0.2933610677719116,
-0.13660697638988495,
0.2179120033979416,
-0.6890316009521484,
0.4977886378765106,
-0.662123441696167,
0.06633376330137253,
-0.05077855661511421,
-0.1177469789981842,
0.8311059474945068,
-0.38911306858062744,
0.5878166556358337,
-0.37437117099761963,
-0.05964777618646622,
0.16914056241512299,
-0.21902255713939667,
0.5089451670646667,
-0.1881183683872223,
-0.3936777114868164,
0.42255786061286926,
0.03009854070842266,
-0.2114233374595642,
-0.37321025133132935,
0.49952518939971924,
-0.8924780488014221,
-0.6090373992919922,
-0.40163278579711914,
-0.1860920488834381,
-0.5933538675308228,
0.38307589292526245,
0.6167585253715515,
0.39598655700683594,
-0.1913554072380066,
-0.15575796365737915,
0.6411134600639343,
-0.3327256441116333,
0.16929355263710022,
0.652267336845398,
0.02304285764694214,
-0.43525028228759766,
0.34619009494781494,
0.13385067880153656,
0.4686272442340851,
-0.11884637176990509,
0.2473079115152359,
-0.31619319319725037,
-0.8313133120536804,
-0.45119744539260864,
0.6145738959312439,
-0.8393055200576782,
-0.07876332849264145,
-0.5289685726165771,
-0.33135607838630676,
-0.328864187002182,
-0.02121696062386036,
-0.4965786933898926,
0.04300922900438309,
-0.05338650569319725,
-0.20959128439426422,
0.1038767397403717,
1.0057730674743652,
0.3007414638996124,
0.3007992208003998,
-0.5811221599578857,
0.10998707264661789,
0.15225185453891754,
0.6748216152191162,
-0.2420763075351715,
-0.5203215479850769,
0.10974833369255066,
-0.37787914276123047,
-0.5079039931297302,
-0.8897548317909241,
0.2883523106575012,
0.023449938744306564,
0.7833614945411682,
0.1779874712228775,
-0.17885833978652954,
0.4272838532924652,
-0.8004350662231445,
1.0792948007583618,
0.197642520070076,
-1.000116229057312,
0.431970477104187,
-0.47989872097969055,
0.1402900069952011,
0.7608371376991272,
0.39666110277175903,
-0.050326157361269,
-0.2738032042980194,
-0.6119245886802673,
-0.6349258422851562,
0.7017724514007568,
0.23235264420509338,
0.1378517746925354,
0.0381021723151207,
0.5292079448699951,
0.09369155764579773,
0.0012812133645638824,
-0.8273648619651794,
-0.1818423867225647,
-0.0715494230389595,
-0.2525758445262909,
-0.08197160810232162,
-0.2925991714000702,
-0.020060712471604347,
-0.2590787410736084,
0.8526170253753662,
0.12837034463882446,
0.41593101620674133,
0.36614182591438293,
0.18923543393611908,
0.11107631027698517,
0.4054657816886902,
0.8673040270805359,
0.9152398705482483,
-0.1440257430076599,
-0.23519344627857208,
0.2036919742822647,
-1.1904345750808716,
0.45539557933807373,
0.07957971841096878,
0.007323330268263817,
0.17362739145755768,
0.4320010244846344,
0.5723335146903992,
0.11036517471075058,
-0.4561769366264343,
0.952317476272583,
-0.14586810767650604,
-0.7387680411338806,
-0.4393637478351593,
-0.0353773832321167,
-0.03946525976061821,
-0.09253872185945511,
0.137963205575943,
-0.25441989302635193,
0.029203705489635468,
-0.36230868101119995,
0.22041703760623932,
0.1300414651632309,
-0.2763018310070038,
-0.43272826075553894,
0.6442884206771851,
0.09056749939918518,
0.011933299712836742,
0.990544855594635,
0.10419919341802597,
-0.7241567373275757,
0.6365864276885986,
0.6753626465797424,
0.49413660168647766,
-0.7312379479408264,
-0.1532975286245346,
0.3615224361419678,
0.40930402278900146,
-0.43468037247657776,
0.7169792056083679,
0.2657855749130249,
-0.5792533755302429,
-0.6918835043907166,
-0.5071640610694885,
-0.555607259273529,
0.38682886958122253,
-0.7464334964752197,
0.16633237898349762,
-0.3277798593044281,
-0.49082204699516296,
-0.4784013032913208,
-0.02520938403904438,
-0.8318862915039062,
0.3296927809715271,
0.1045510321855545,
0.9948947429656982,
-1.246928334236145,
0.8276692032814026,
0.5418648719787598,
-0.37574532628059387,
-1.1623400449752808,
-0.13279734551906586,
-0.3881255090236664,
-0.8752748370170593,
0.7978705763816833,
-0.03894450515508652,
0.2123272866010666,
-0.0360664427280426,
-0.06736741214990616,
-0.7341074347496033,
1.1316109895706177,
0.4311349093914032,
-0.7346784472465515,
-0.3973553478717804,
0.4008834958076477,
0.6073732972145081,
-0.07425880432128906,
0.3317595422267914,
0.6722592115402222,
0.5780448317527771,
-0.07830499857664108,
-1.5317708253860474,
-0.1259240359067917,
-0.28032633662223816,
-0.10488476604223251,
0.2083277702331543,
-0.49372637271881104,
1.0632548332214355,
0.052777860313653946,
0.15243114531040192,
0.02774839848279953,
-0.008851995691657066,
0.6588714718818665,
0.19633379578590393,
0.2869752049446106,
0.5510589480400085,
0.630379855632782,
-0.35325345396995544,
1.4122523069381714,
-0.4864831864833832,
0.40296828746795654,
0.8252683281898499,
-0.5793206095695496,
0.5945758819580078,
0.26498812437057495,
-0.7391218543052673,
0.5308929681777954,
0.5080744028091431,
-0.26926371455192566,
0.4076516330242157,
0.13677813112735748,
-0.21247586607933044,
-0.3992502987384796,
0.5228651165962219,
-0.5837582945823669,
0.3961019515991211,
0.38498860597610474,
-0.5805738568305969,
-0.15863461792469025,
0.45683661103248596,
-0.2008352130651474,
-0.19667300581932068,
-0.4442383646965027,
0.5630999207496643,
0.09834066033363342,
-0.5558420419692993,
0.2864428162574768,
-0.2519516050815582,
0.4145564138889313,
-0.8627464771270752,
-0.1170625388622284,
-0.03817636892199516,
0.3105868101119995,
-0.19967705011367798,
-0.8025661706924438,
0.2291376143693924,
0.05400574207305908,
0.05926643684506416,
-0.3211197853088379,
0.6231710314750671,
0.025768738240003586,
-0.634996235370636,
0.1831587851047516,
0.406607061624527,
0.48358285427093506,
0.06092415004968643,
-0.6464414000511169,
0.018946463242173195,
-0.055839989334344864,
-0.3699958622455597,
0.2301061749458313,
0.09728505462408066,
-0.07159897685050964,
0.5377247333526611,
0.29907262325286865,
0.5094089508056641,
0.12285792082548141,
0.3378717601299286,
0.8239132165908813,
-0.3134167492389679,
-0.8230904936790466,
-0.805328369140625,
0.24132294952869415,
0.1749875545501709,
-0.10791491717100143,
0.7887148261070251,
0.6653568744659424,
0.6425963640213013,
-0.3785914480686188,
0.6648204922676086,
0.5224142670631409,
0.5667481422424316,
-0.7583947777748108,
0.7529487609863281,
-0.045848455280065536,
0.24639935791492462,
-0.36360758543014526,
-0.5926526784896851,
-0.42307615280151367,
0.6728909015655518,
-0.7575515508651733,
0.32820364832878113,
0.6752011775970459,
0.4023285210132599,
-0.02417868934571743,
0.03013945184648037,
0.6299938559532166,
0.13779307901859283,
0.4524537920951843,
0.8170967698097229,
0.7363550662994385,
-0.6273428797721863,
0.2855513095855713,
-0.17149700224399567,
-0.18445530533790588,
0.10135757178068161,
-0.5121940970420837,
-0.746592104434967,
-0.17670105397701263,
-0.2563071548938751,
-0.32761678099632263,
0.025453442707657814,
0.535107433795929,
0.6369721293449402,
-0.7934680581092834,
0.09726574271917343,
-0.15421162545681,
-0.4408358335494995,
0.024181513115763664,
-0.15320858359336853,
0.8707199096679688,
-0.11000394821166992,
-0.406472384929657,
0.3744889199733734,
0.060547199100255966,
0.3483571708202362,
-0.1559496521949768,
-0.10106091946363449,
0.16829656064510345,
-0.13398246467113495,
0.3104023039340973,
-0.19070960581302643,
-0.8532823324203491,
0.03600303456187248,
0.047464750707149506,
-0.15120330452919006,
0.39451295137405396,
0.8159487247467041,
-0.6864022612571716,
0.5694465637207031,
0.4753504693508148,
0.2520025968551636,
0.5366125106811523,
0.04913627728819847,
0.5277655124664307,
-0.030514663085341454,
0.08320634812116623,
0.4284864664077759,
0.47027692198753357,
0.1485426276922226,
-0.49061810970306396,
0.5630881786346436,
0.2945999801158905,
-0.5847200155258179,
-0.7293989658355713,
-0.23862217366695404,
-0.7264313101768494,
-0.1820201277732849,
0.9020588397979736,
-0.3866211771965027,
-0.08571090549230576,
-0.29209959506988525,
0.11754462867975235,
0.16814643144607544,
0.16331934928894043,
0.4570784270763397,
0.8105977773666382,
-0.5972796678543091,
0.13366925716400146,
-1.0323452949523926,
0.5894691348075867,
0.44097188115119934,
-0.9893226623535156,
-0.14147771894931793,
0.10965017974376678,
0.8441619277000427,
0.020661981776356697,
1.021350383758545,
-0.8199387192726135,
0.5501776337623596,
-0.13481967151165009,
0.23457102477550507,
-0.26455962657928467,
-0.04246263578534126,
-0.6450319886207581,
0.27593258023262024,
0.10390834510326385,
-0.12417647242546082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18518v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18518v1
|
From ChatGPT, DALL-E 3 to Sora: How has Generative AI Changed Digital Humanities Research and Services?
| 2024-04-29T09:03:19 | 2024-04-29T09:03:19 |
Jiangfeng Liu, Ziyi Wang, Jing Xie, Lei Pei
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Generative large-scale language models create the fifth paradigm of
scientific research, organically combine data science and computational
intelligence, transform the research paradigm of natural language processing
and multimodal information processing, promote the new trend of AI-enabled
social science research, and provide new ideas for digital humanities research
and application. This article profoundly explores the application of
large-scale language models in digital humanities research, revealing their
significant potential in ancient book protection, intelligent processing, and
academic innovation. The article first outlines the importance of ancient book
resources and the necessity of digital preservation, followed by a detailed
introduction to developing large-scale language models, such as ChatGPT, and
their applications in document management, content understanding, and
cross-cultural research. Through specific cases, the article demonstrates how
AI can assist in the organization, classification, and content generation of
ancient books. Then, it explores the prospects of AI applications in artistic
innovation and cultural heritage preservation. Finally, the article explores
the challenges and opportunities in the interaction of technology, information,
and society in the digital humanities triggered by AI technologies.
|
[
-0.6008698344230652,
-1.0084989070892334,
0.31237033009529114,
-0.4044591188430786,
0.08701664954423904,
0.09058534353971481,
-0.2032453417778015,
-0.7391136884689331,
-0.23593172430992126,
0.5106948018074036,
-0.4801567494869232,
-0.022590400651097298,
-0.5050754547119141,
0.14745843410491943,
-0.8328668475151062,
1.1913599967956543,
0.23552310466766357,
0.2845764756202698,
-0.08260994404554367,
-0.030221927911043167,
-0.06392334401607513,
-0.5382792949676514,
-0.7223056554794312,
-0.20616838335990906,
0.31602463126182556,
0.21187472343444824,
0.99210524559021,
0.527688205242157,
0.8687707781791687,
0.44841402769088745,
-0.13525396585464478,
0.0060820020735263824,
-0.3634386956691742,
0.20443393290042877,
0.05053573474287987,
-0.6633115410804749,
-0.4702182412147522,
0.1073632538318634,
0.7541431784629822,
0.34027791023254395,
-0.22109831869602203,
0.04131809622049332,
-0.1052466407418251,
0.8792962431907654,
-0.2569786608219147,
0.2735138535499573,
-0.27142685651779175,
0.05033113807439804,
-0.5632262825965881,
-0.284188449382782,
-0.409194678068161,
-0.503401517868042,
0.269336462020874,
-0.8604229688644409,
0.37017014622688293,
0.2554033100605011,
0.6631174683570862,
0.28711628913879395,
-0.01660383678972721,
-0.4587535858154297,
-1.2230991125106812,
0.7600207328796387,
-0.6590837240219116,
0.2441672384738922,
0.6084080934524536,
0.35535866022109985,
-0.21555212140083313,
-0.8602438569068909,
-1.2369943857192993,
-0.23625557124614716,
0.3097800016403198,
0.11984042823314667,
-0.32054635882377625,
-0.06373104453086853,
0.2792256474494934,
0.7686962485313416,
-0.5763984322547913,
0.27133673429489136,
-0.5106141567230225,
0.17200760543346405,
0.7543259263038635,
0.29947638511657715,
0.8500850796699524,
0.06657784432172775,
0.08532080054283142,
-0.264610230922699,
-0.7091488242149353,
-0.2598835825920105,
0.243989959359169,
-0.14481686055660248,
0.06109558790922165,
0.659003734588623,
0.197670578956604,
0.5366671681404114,
-0.1871505081653595,
-0.1103113442659378,
-0.10794702172279358,
-0.3800332844257355,
-0.11582163721323013,
-0.1476113200187683,
0.7824001908302307,
0.1601196825504303,
0.345083087682724,
-0.019933149218559265,
0.23416468501091003,
0.2939961552619934,
0.230239138007164,
-0.6184165477752686,
-0.3373487889766693,
0.01911831460893154,
-0.5889533162117004,
-0.1608130931854248,
-0.25440821051597595,
-0.6067883968353271,
-0.9381639957427979,
-0.3359120190143585,
-0.10828317701816559,
-0.6879338622093201,
-0.5092330574989319,
0.27675995230674744,
-0.20593692362308502,
0.4446165859699249,
0.4201942980289459,
-1.155391812324524,
0.11463388055562973,
0.8269878625869751,
0.7819744944572449,
-0.02979174256324768,
-0.48195353150367737,
0.1471518725156784,
0.2378348410129547,
-0.41221219301223755,
0.7606703639030457,
-0.5657292008399963,
-0.43157458305358887,
0.23464074730873108,
-0.2175670862197876,
0.3146091401576996,
-0.4291900396347046,
0.6421060562133789,
-0.857776403427124,
0.16311950981616974,
-0.020983317866921425,
-0.33154475688934326,
-0.3353922665119171,
0.372068852186203,
-1.0299906730651855,
0.8642135262489319,
-0.09727239608764648,
-0.8113627433776855,
0.07998882234096527,
-0.9198793768882751,
-0.2560977041721344,
0.4412933886051178,
-0.08646052330732346,
-0.6464331746101379,
0.10209731012582779,
-0.1496892124414444,
0.23069506883621216,
-0.9270444512367249,
0.28143322467803955,
-0.3049491345882416,
-0.220017209649086,
0.4299185872077942,
-0.48852381110191345,
0.9152559041976929,
0.2914476692676544,
-0.3395838141441345,
0.050707921385765076,
-0.655738890171051,
-0.22882144153118134,
0.24206973612308502,
-0.32897675037384033,
-0.45866355299949646,
0.21114881336688995,
0.47391384840011597,
-0.05924786999821663,
0.11543839424848557,
-0.3732430040836334,
0.4578269124031067,
-0.2159414291381836,
0.9261313080787659,
0.6152136921882629,
-0.6273834705352783,
0.5716212391853333,
-0.5792498588562012,
0.3615136742591858,
-0.30111414194107056,
0.10464931279420853,
-0.22226031124591827,
-0.557307243347168,
-0.6996214389801025,
-0.26834794878959656,
0.35758379101753235,
0.28161242604255676,
-0.9803993105888367,
0.09035931527614594,
-0.3245319724082947,
-0.73050457239151,
-0.662739634513855,
-0.44269612431526184,
-0.10219424217939377,
-0.08629113435745239,
0.13769471645355225,
-0.1574505865573883,
-0.3821185231208801,
-0.4537826180458069,
-0.0316772386431694,
-0.41735878586769104,
-0.021737895905971527,
0.11095115542411804,
0.3075871467590332,
-0.3665316104888916,
0.816537618637085,
-0.12222594767808914,
-0.2606891095638275,
-0.10754481703042984,
0.4635167419910431,
-0.1949520856142044,
0.335088312625885,
0.3043754994869232,
-1.3321447372436523,
-0.22651077806949615,
0.2270553559064865,
-0.8773562908172607,
0.10195252299308777,
-0.0027291211299598217,
0.049406517297029495,
0.4555504620075226,
0.4450303018093109,
-0.7438476085662842,
0.32089290022850037,
0.5975945591926575,
-0.3109438419342041,
0.5894556641578674,
-0.29219862818717957,
0.40530475974082947,
-1.0957213640213013,
0.09015168994665146,
-0.16004765033721924,
0.36543717980384827,
-0.7683869004249573,
0.2543083131313324,
-0.133335679769516,
-0.354170560836792,
-0.06456737220287323,
0.6177414655685425,
-0.4871389865875244,
-0.05838194862008095,
-0.5076227188110352,
-0.08130274713039398,
-0.29572317004203796,
-0.019946498796343803,
0.09779398143291473,
0.7854569554328918,
0.4919886291027069,
-0.4784068167209625,
0.2954282760620117,
0.4252455532550812,
-0.43007057905197144,
0.39462944865226746,
-0.20125320553779602,
0.2931113541126251,
-0.20441606640815735,
0.3357570171356201,
-0.697155237197876,
-0.14440694451332092,
0.11366305500268936,
-0.29354384541511536,
0.0915462002158165,
0.2788592576980591,
-0.7523762583732605,
-0.38184911012649536,
-0.3748805820941925,
0.7908824682235718,
0.38470259308815,
-0.17124523222446442,
0.8432660102844238,
0.6407276391983032,
-0.7359321713447571,
-0.3064253032207489,
-0.5370810031890869,
0.32551509141921997,
-0.31433573365211487,
-0.6498594880104065,
0.48028701543807983,
-0.4666369557380676,
-0.43645837903022766,
0.0324815958738327,
0.28330960869789124,
-0.09173843264579773,
0.17188775539398193,
0.20390434563159943,
0.5901871919631958,
-0.2642311453819275,
0.004425407852977514,
-0.3719516098499298,
-0.1297779083251953,
-0.0504404716193676,
-0.3600037693977356,
0.8604175448417664,
-0.20461979508399963,
-0.3250584602355957,
-0.6154743432998657,
0.42709365487098694,
0.9976245164871216,
-0.34803563356399536,
0.73580002784729,
0.5858291387557983,
-0.29079577326774597,
0.16534166038036346,
-0.7195612788200378,
-0.10661348700523376,
-0.44006115198135376,
0.3076865077018738,
-0.07101667672395706,
-1.1194653511047363,
0.3025673031806946,
-0.037644434720277786,
0.1657559722661972,
0.5910187363624573,
0.790966808795929,
-0.16206598281860352,
0.7155098915100098,
0.7523416876792908,
-0.2934476435184479,
0.8663584589958191,
-0.5159258842468262,
0.5534623861312866,
-0.6169018745422363,
-0.06357931345701218,
-0.8593480587005615,
-0.16932280361652374,
-0.8887689113616943,
-0.15206705033779144,
0.5688387155532837,
-0.054369084537029266,
-0.4007945954799652,
-0.1440572887659073,
-0.5014248490333557,
0.19022749364376068,
0.725261926651001,
-0.20886439085006714,
0.5939372181892395,
0.2375688999891281,
0.6711001992225647,
0.16920484602451324,
-0.6553723812103271,
-0.7667288184165955,
1.0435104370117188,
0.3287794291973114,
0.8201957941055298,
0.10982991009950638,
0.215359166264534,
0.8323633074760437,
0.457146018743515,
-0.6800445318222046,
0.4660487174987793,
-0.23364214599132538,
-0.5415574908256531,
-0.743590235710144,
0.013771053403615952,
-0.8371354341506958,
-0.18244412541389465,
-0.18655893206596375,
-0.3002861738204956,
0.14580291509628296,
-0.14476323127746582,
-0.3572220802307129,
0.27218350768089294,
-0.3449251055717468,
0.4328818619251251,
-0.1698571890592575,
-0.15422455966472626,
-0.6636517643928528,
-0.3385482132434845,
0.06920342892408371,
-0.08952981233596802,
0.47472071647644043,
0.029908915981650352,
0.38407108187675476,
0.6570810079574585,
0.14259587228298187,
0.632636308670044,
0.30493101477622986,
-0.2252224236726761,
0.42828303575515747,
0.22681261599063873,
0.40856656432151794,
-0.3098226487636566,
-0.3088785707950592,
0.37842607498168945,
0.1940438598394394,
-0.2321321964263916,
-0.31594064831733704,
0.49150341749191284,
-1.0675615072250366,
-0.7664922475814819,
-0.4293217957019806,
-0.8512569665908813,
0.13734062016010284,
0.13077405095100403,
-0.03029707632958889,
0.17416223883628845,
-0.42827463150024414,
0.14651453495025635,
0.5996386408805847,
-0.2531099021434784,
0.5877114534378052,
0.39697322249412537,
0.20121879875659943,
-0.060972489416599274,
0.8928990364074707,
0.18986500799655914,
0.05273110046982765,
0.2699056565761566,
0.18552440404891968,
-0.06159912422299385,
-0.7363559007644653,
-0.6101131439208984,
0.01864546909928322,
-0.5352059006690979,
-0.008233537897467613,
-0.5997449159622192,
-0.39177343249320984,
-0.3219812214374542,
-0.3337235152721405,
-0.08088325709104538,
-0.21594823896884918,
-0.20437562465667725,
0.1863933652639389,
0.4851907193660736,
0.9439230561256409,
0.007700973190367222,
0.2651611864566803,
-0.7234825491905212,
0.271112322807312,
0.2791531980037689,
0.06609005481004715,
0.31998735666275024,
-0.10609754920005798,
-0.24698685109615326,
-0.03903656825423241,
-0.32157567143440247,
-0.48797735571861267,
0.3285648226737976,
0.13006143271923065,
0.25583183765411377,
0.37763479351997375,
-0.06679636985063553,
0.18492674827575684,
-0.8394396901130676,
0.7989662885665894,
0.1292165368795395,
-0.5410882830619812,
0.06140338256955147,
-0.698294460773468,
0.05228092893958092,
-0.0043755569495260715,
0.3829609751701355,
-0.7689721584320068,
-0.15198427438735962,
-0.460092157125473,
-0.7867158651351929,
0.7262991666793823,
0.06594361364841461,
0.35470062494277954,
0.2601691782474518,
0.06364334374666214,
0.26315805315971375,
0.04193028435111046,
-0.8300673961639404,
-0.07378223538398743,
-0.22484242916107178,
-0.13820980489253998,
0.07950160652399063,
-0.42913877964019775,
-0.09734533727169037,
-0.059452444314956665,
0.8032326102256775,
-0.062047868967056274,
0.11202562600374222,
-0.1770450621843338,
0.20634350180625916,
0.054123714566230774,
0.5039085745811462,
0.2725933790206909,
0.3860059082508087,
0.4080442786216736,
-0.014222917146980762,
-0.23835082352161407,
-0.6735161542892456,
0.03241570666432381,
0.4235285222530365,
-0.5820928812026978,
-0.48629245162010193,
0.20113013684749603,
0.5383774638175964,
-0.38604724407196045,
-0.5791048407554626,
-0.03548717126250267,
-0.02306399866938591,
0.06436964124441147,
-0.7926459908485413,
-0.007097679190337658,
0.09088437259197235,
0.6581461429595947,
0.45928502082824707,
-0.06834014505147934,
0.3208830952644348,
-0.9886605739593506,
-0.2267119288444519,
0.5159394145011902,
0.06912391632795334,
-0.08492115139961243,
0.5959110260009766,
-0.005716136656701565,
-0.48188772797584534,
0.810960054397583,
0.151022270321846,
-0.3116743862628937,
0.560183048248291,
0.6320650577545166,
0.7131326198577881,
-0.18483084440231323,
0.3718497157096863,
-0.07611767947673798,
0.0648743063211441,
-0.22640551626682281,
0.025944313034415245,
-0.07598112523555756,
-0.8476635813713074,
-0.08444022387266159,
-0.7626894116401672,
-0.3382362723350525,
0.1109527200460434,
-0.11028723418712616,
0.18425653874874115,
-0.30012649297714233,
-0.1859675794839859,
0.3832424283027649,
-0.14236068725585938,
-0.5895419120788574,
0.010060249827802181,
0.398051381111145,
0.5404324531555176,
-0.5570398569107056,
0.7729085683822632,
0.6576825380325317,
-0.5456889867782593,
-0.5518959760665894,
0.11354599893093109,
0.08118125796318054,
-0.5447039604187012,
0.6339200735092163,
-0.34442561864852905,
-0.12951023876667023,
0.3743339478969574,
-0.6607583165168762,
-0.8409208059310913,
1.0072811841964722,
0.1908586025238037,
-0.4224778413772583,
-0.24345357716083527,
0.17030487954616547,
0.8242805600166321,
0.019614439457654953,
0.4834516942501068,
0.674788236618042,
0.49363240599632263,
0.06623785197734833,
-0.9463315606117249,
-0.30057185888290405,
-0.5418621897697449,
0.2337719053030014,
0.08703956007957458,
-0.5003775358200073,
0.8221846222877502,
0.04168926179409027,
-0.2593062222003937,
0.5841144323348999,
0.5811126232147217,
0.3623143136501312,
0.27616485953330994,
-0.015709664672613144,
0.40397077798843384,
0.6466295123100281,
-0.20444998145103455,
1.3414512872695923,
-0.1489574909210205,
0.10817006230354309,
0.39342090487480164,
-0.27181336283683777,
0.6056311130523682,
0.07300963997840881,
-0.23397180438041687,
0.5602834820747375,
0.5908532738685608,
-0.3262386620044708,
0.3139360249042511,
0.2706209421157837,
-0.7176434397697449,
0.21365806460380554,
-0.6237015128135681,
-0.4915062487125397,
0.4219707250595093,
0.5006453394889832,
-0.02382219024002552,
0.10450542718172073,
0.41365090012550354,
0.21787723898887634,
0.1709001511335373,
-0.48837149143218994,
0.8956279158592224,
-0.0907774567604065,
-0.5738064050674438,
0.41325733065605164,
0.23288492858409882,
0.5506079792976379,
-0.45814183354377747,
-0.13754235208034515,
-0.13581077754497528,
0.22564053535461426,
-0.07241956144571304,
-0.5128061771392822,
0.09448722749948502,
-0.07447775453329086,
-0.43760278820991516,
-0.21000908315181732,
0.6136680245399475,
-0.09733477234840393,
-0.4875960350036621,
0.03464093804359436,
0.38422438502311707,
0.09361893683671951,
0.04865020886063576,
-0.3932686150074005,
0.19780369102954865,
-0.3324022591114044,
-0.14595875144004822,
0.25171220302581787,
0.6852670311927795,
-0.4864639639854431,
0.7738251686096191,
0.8010314702987671,
0.2521320879459381,
-0.05564287304878235,
0.13394863903522491,
0.8868069648742676,
-0.6713452935218811,
-0.420742392539978,
-0.9978518486022949,
0.21243439614772797,
0.12883979082107544,
-0.09575936943292618,
0.5605851411819458,
0.3558945655822754,
0.9711510539054871,
-0.04770125448703766,
1.1922029256820679,
-0.4724959135055542,
0.08537910878658295,
-0.38804829120635986,
1.196679711341858,
-0.28171879053115845,
-0.16856877505779266,
-0.34996235370635986,
-0.7707107663154602,
-0.3669333755970001,
0.32912540435791016,
-0.517026960849762,
0.027678873389959335,
0.5487122535705566,
0.5717401504516602,
0.19943730533123016,
0.4983411431312561,
0.23624663054943085,
0.4124200642108917,
0.4509396553039551,
-0.09869290143251419,
1.1372562646865845,
-0.23612642288208008,
0.31252288818359375,
0.383121520280838,
-0.33439508080482483,
-0.18391846120357513,
-0.5236257910728455,
-0.7378703951835632,
-1.1037288904190063,
-0.11987491697072983,
-0.21888010203838348,
0.16580185294151306,
0.62983238697052,
0.4001503586769104,
-0.8472262620925903,
-0.30444416403770447,
-0.09608378261327744,
-0.18852896988391876,
-0.19752870500087738,
-0.15075866878032684,
0.6303063631057739,
-0.013035908341407776,
-0.981631338596344,
0.05338704213500023,
0.3948862850666046,
0.13703279197216034,
-0.6634784936904907,
-0.022733207792043686,
-0.1582811176776886,
-0.0949055626988411,
0.6385339498519897,
0.4850221574306488,
-0.8329818844795227,
0.05776651203632355,
-0.010824532248079777,
-0.19807732105255127,
-0.05417310446500778,
1.0252500772476196,
-0.4921117424964905,
0.41527223587036133,
0.45375677943229675,
0.9747437238693237,
0.5903039574623108,
-0.3053184449672699,
0.708314836025238,
0.3255499601364136,
0.09448648989200592,
0.44750431180000305,
0.3086985945701599,
0.4920971989631653,
-0.21838489174842834,
0.6038824319839478,
0.18977035582065582,
-0.7798164486885071,
-0.6912147402763367,
0.27610355615615845,
-0.4877205193042755,
-0.340198278427124,
0.8582447171211243,
0.0022092624567449093,
-0.11167746782302856,
-0.3273547291755676,
-0.5345218181610107,
0.4918666183948517,
-0.002533263061195612,
1.5858405828475952,
0.9488093256950378,
0.0078751090914011,
-0.5973879098892212,
-0.8800535798072815,
0.7500003576278687,
0.34779202938079834,
-0.9990876317024231,
0.07986503839492798,
0.6524360775947571,
-0.2726007401943207,
0.4352702796459198,
0.7082662582397461,
-0.3365263044834137,
0.24848757684230804,
-0.15738171339035034,
0.4256001114845276,
-0.013039800338447094,
-0.312947541475296,
-0.15647543966770172,
0.19706344604492188,
0.37175700068473816,
0.2154054045677185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18510v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18510v2
|
Explainability of machine learning approaches in forensic linguistics: a case study in geolinguistic authorship profiling
| 2024-04-29T08:52:52 | 2024-07-01T15:58:11 |
Dana Roemling, Yves Scherrer, Aleksandra Miletic
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Forensic authorship profiling uses linguistic markers to infer
characteristics about an author of a text. This task is paralleled in dialect
classification, where a prediction is made about the linguistic variety of a
text based on the text itself. While there have been significant advances in
recent years in variety classification, forensic linguistics rarely relies on
these approaches due to their lack of transparency, among other reasons. In
this paper we therefore explore the explainability of machine learning
approaches considering the forensic context. We focus on variety classification
as a means of geolinguistic profiling of unknown texts based on social media
data from the German-speaking area. For this, we identify the lexical items
that are the most impactful for the variety classification. We find that the
extracted lexical features are indeed representative of their respective
varieties and note that the trained models also rely on place names for
classifications.
|
[
-0.5264953374862671,
-0.7932618260383606,
0.8463841080665588,
-0.13819658756256104,
-0.10995422303676605,
0.2353641837835312,
-0.49440106749534607,
-0.6335858702659607,
0.10334304720163345,
0.5004613995552063,
-0.49053797125816345,
-0.7491863965988159,
-0.8498553037643433,
0.13375458121299744,
-0.7871166467666626,
1.1563106775283813,
0.10605061799287796,
0.18272964656352997,
0.1055767685174942,
-0.5691791772842407,
-0.15506111085414886,
-0.9349820017814636,
-0.2936793863773346,
-0.12520459294319153,
0.38162851333618164,
0.09614861011505127,
0.7609314322471619,
0.8414119482040405,
0.5187879204750061,
0.4303608536720276,
-0.08650851994752884,
-0.056212592869997025,
-0.49285203218460083,
0.15711645781993866,
-0.2197592854499817,
-0.5893517732620239,
0.3654164671897888,
0.07808195799589157,
0.16912996768951416,
1.1694667339324951,
-0.016436146572232246,
-0.030172163620591164,
-0.08497557789087296,
0.5679056644439697,
-0.6907120943069458,
-0.10352130234241486,
-0.7270446419715881,
-0.014610192738473415,
-0.38937175273895264,
-0.12140081077814102,
-0.4186267852783203,
-0.44467753171920776,
0.35610124468803406,
-0.6317785978317261,
0.984332263469696,
-0.023641804233193398,
0.7690644860267639,
0.013367085717618465,
-0.2479497492313385,
-0.6207897067070007,
-1.0615854263305664,
0.62168949842453,
-0.19607175886631012,
0.1791943609714508,
0.6652624607086182,
0.7136670351028442,
-0.02992263063788414,
-0.5256511569023132,
-0.4242446720600128,
-0.1802668273448944,
-0.5376374125480652,
-0.32100170850753784,
-0.05233205109834671,
0.0000037075903946970357,
0.26446905732154846,
0.6504346132278442,
-0.5545463562011719,
0.26725953817367554,
-0.20498882234096527,
-0.2970758080482483,
0.7814253568649292,
-0.02474762126803398,
0.31553903222084045,
-0.036233775317668915,
0.0509868860244751,
0.1369139403104782,
-0.5246807932853699,
0.2812093496322632,
0.7119017243385315,
0.5294181704521179,
-0.16077327728271484,
0.28737592697143555,
-0.2862282395362854,
0.5952672958374023,
-0.10331269353628159,
-0.1406794637441635,
0.3729776442050934,
-0.1604786068201065,
-0.10936872661113739,
0.11003830283880234,
0.8736759424209595,
-0.12712612748146057,
0.276526540517807,
-0.2896762192249298,
0.11001448333263397,
-0.30187365412712097,
0.2751317322254181,
-0.5535879731178284,
-0.48349595069885254,
0.38717731833457947,
-0.5632761716842651,
-0.3360321819782257,
0.32019221782684326,
-0.6078821420669556,
-0.7898752689361572,
-0.024930370971560478,
0.21108730137348175,
-0.7388712167739868,
-0.2918553054332733,
-0.02345031499862671,
-0.2566920816898346,
0.07643765211105347,
0.4634605348110199,
-1.001246690750122,
0.14296860992908478,
0.817653238773346,
0.8047806620597839,
-0.11840410530567169,
-0.2347632795572281,
-0.5156471729278564,
-0.22587385773658752,
-0.17301245033740997,
0.578540563583374,
-0.41732752323150635,
-0.28783541917800903,
0.09543676674365997,
0.16322332620620728,
0.14285656809806824,
-0.6039945483207703,
0.24024079740047455,
-0.6382753849029541,
0.42040690779685974,
-0.10854411870241165,
-0.4197818636894226,
-0.8503244519233704,
-0.12432699650526047,
-0.7227447032928467,
0.9141833186149597,
0.2901875376701355,
-0.9581262469291687,
0.6793674230575562,
-0.46764901280403137,
-0.7053279876708984,
0.34031882882118225,
-0.10032953321933746,
-0.6103397607803345,
0.1471909135580063,
-0.0004106874985154718,
0.7932689189910889,
0.12810952961444855,
0.6948593258857727,
-0.5238316059112549,
-0.15223738551139832,
0.5518414974212646,
-0.321389377117157,
1.2387419939041138,
0.34831544756889343,
-0.6565287113189697,
-0.3106940984725952,
-1.0408530235290527,
-0.38574451208114624,
0.15850704908370972,
-0.20558688044548035,
-0.4953226149082184,
0.15900284051895142,
0.07993853092193604,
-0.2157270759344101,
0.0065382253378629684,
-0.6041656136512756,
-0.35040387511253357,
-0.32550981640815735,
0.25247156620025635,
0.284889817237854,
-0.11430565267801285,
0.4887382388114929,
-0.38616400957107544,
0.5664817690849304,
-0.06575251370668411,
-0.3120579719543457,
-0.20823688805103302,
-0.44681355357170105,
-0.4493730664253235,
-0.6134868264198303,
0.6668403744697571,
0.7197563052177429,
-0.5382710695266724,
0.41149163246154785,
-0.24394828081130981,
-0.7977703213691711,
-0.6617537140846252,
0.15045006573200226,
0.33693256974220276,
0.43793684244155884,
0.1491437405347824,
-0.10679978877305984,
-0.7884491086006165,
-1.1078532934188843,
-0.6765410900115967,
-0.21714849770069122,
-0.30657845735549927,
0.5742550492286682,
0.40872156620025635,
0.12145870178937912,
1.1377453804016113,
-0.05664455145597458,
0.17480289936065674,
-0.4041675329208374,
0.45058920979499817,
0.19656561315059662,
0.35655677318573,
0.6958935856819153,
-1.0618704557418823,
-0.3886139392852783,
0.3252861797809601,
-1.0544087886810303,
-0.07512204349040985,
-0.07078088819980621,
0.23571880161762238,
0.15384875237941742,
0.32889944314956665,
-0.176352858543396,
0.6121000051498413,
0.16371867060661316,
-0.20884598791599274,
0.676749050617218,
0.026046132668852806,
0.1468099057674408,
-0.8213271498680115,
-0.049942370504140854,
0.0379951074719429,
-0.5463972091674805,
-1.0523861646652222,
-0.01467518787831068,
-0.21174503862857819,
0.0331483818590641,
-0.4759882092475891,
0.05821136012673378,
-0.2791910767555237,
-0.2123156636953354,
-0.08654654771089554,
0.03921389579772949,
-0.42330309748649597,
0.16990883648395538,
0.07407967001199722,
0.4528580605983734,
0.7114787101745605,
-0.561578094959259,
0.2682124376296997,
-0.018018780276179314,
-0.6011554598808289,
0.39210566878318787,
-0.15962378680706024,
-0.04983113706111908,
-0.35376736521720886,
-0.02283632382750511,
-1.2124115228652954,
-0.5638653039932251,
-0.022132687270641327,
-0.8170117139816284,
0.1805289387702942,
-0.5306344032287598,
-0.39508092403411865,
0.010206548497080803,
-0.06664697825908661,
0.14677037298679352,
0.5326277017593384,
-0.6055197715759277,
0.7887142300605774,
0.46236148476600647,
-0.23863008618354797,
-0.38857531547546387,
-0.7564883828163147,
0.1233922466635704,
-0.7673039436340332,
-0.7441790699958801,
0.21681076288223267,
0.24803240597248077,
-0.7395032048225403,
-0.06731104850769043,
0.4105544984340668,
-0.3535667955875397,
0.8533552885055542,
0.4678642153739929,
0.0008628158248029649,
-0.355765163898468,
0.1554575264453888,
-0.05418283864855766,
0.10281208157539368,
0.1563005894422531,
-0.09709230065345764,
0.6383808255195618,
-0.048757538199424744,
-0.0666872039437294,
-0.5424218773841858,
0.5619719624519348,
0.2848796248435974,
0.2400856912136078,
0.9123578667640686,
0.5638127326965332,
-0.19232384860515594,
-0.3310607671737671,
-0.46299007534980774,
-0.11720181256532669,
-0.4392068088054657,
0.22020402550697327,
-0.40107467770576477,
-1.1151846647262573,
0.8805219531059265,
-0.10204889625310898,
-0.024094605818390846,
0.7529511451721191,
0.6619389653205872,
-0.2875431776046753,
0.47324785590171814,
0.7571284174919128,
-0.08629526942968369,
0.2692963778972626,
-0.08093249052762985,
0.29714691638946533,
-0.08569607883691788,
-0.05595836415886879,
-0.7709485292434692,
-0.18509817123413086,
-1.1447254419326782,
0.24712657928466797,
0.2858932614326477,
0.0040786415338516235,
0.12878261506557465,
0.46976780891418457,
-0.30074477195739746,
0.5756128430366516,
0.7667450904846191,
-0.09818032383918762,
0.28398001194000244,
0.3736094832420349,
-0.0449373759329319,
0.17941929399967194,
-0.5635812282562256,
-0.7160708904266357,
1.1336896419525146,
0.3527912497520447,
0.22122211754322052,
0.05795358866453171,
0.7915400862693787,
0.4312678277492523,
0.04932994768023491,
-0.8483813405036926,
0.24092522263526917,
-0.3703305423259735,
-0.8889498114585876,
-0.5755863189697266,
-0.3886289596557617,
-0.9443737268447876,
0.2757491171360016,
-0.2846439480781555,
-0.9910207986831665,
0.20501269400119781,
-0.018608158454298973,
-0.43392542004585266,
0.3983909487724304,
-0.5295764803886414,
0.4536593556404114,
-0.17762665450572968,
-0.035187266767024994,
0.016235459595918655,
-0.9576456546783447,
0.23601996898651123,
-0.26168298721313477,
0.7631322145462036,
0.046858105808496475,
0.46995973587036133,
1.0481839179992676,
-0.48851916193962097,
0.940327525138855,
-0.3540215790271759,
-0.011839667335152626,
0.16425809264183044,
0.4556243121623993,
0.008158396929502487,
-0.08192434161901474,
-0.05460582301020622,
0.5300833582878113,
-0.10824288427829742,
-0.17528896033763885,
-0.6786264181137085,
0.2823406457901001,
-0.6205925345420837,
-0.6015715003013611,
-0.011621805839240551,
-0.5800320506095886,
-0.17145542800426483,
0.05057698115706444,
0.7346392869949341,
0.4624776244163513,
-0.12917928397655487,
0.24760784208774567,
0.6859223246574402,
-0.2081906646490097,
0.4827653765678406,
0.46670660376548767,
-0.08349411934614182,
-0.2786124050617218,
0.9845218658447266,
0.2105918675661087,
-0.13734909892082214,
0.252252459526062,
0.35731348395347595,
0.04716449975967407,
-0.9732213020324707,
-0.5445860624313354,
0.13226361572742462,
-0.781683623790741,
0.4628375172615051,
-0.8556901812553406,
-0.15584971010684967,
-0.29444319009780884,
-0.4157044589519501,
0.05958179011940956,
-0.7711352705955505,
-0.3634314239025116,
-0.14237864315509796,
0.40147286653518677,
0.9086562991142273,
0.07469429075717926,
0.7139679789543152,
-0.4956870675086975,
0.1614532172679901,
-0.16637296974658966,
0.09887586534023285,
-0.2703068256378174,
-0.7173373103141785,
-0.1834321916103363,
-0.2319762259721756,
-0.2132035195827484,
-1.0749980211257935,
0.30129215121269226,
0.1530352681875229,
0.5122942328453064,
0.5651026964187622,
-0.15093061327934265,
0.07726620882749557,
-0.3521479070186615,
1.0318148136138916,
-0.16710889339447021,
-0.8586429357528687,
0.5767877697944641,
-0.664028525352478,
-0.29834458231925964,
0.7149448394775391,
0.836932897567749,
-0.3162637948989868,
-0.693932056427002,
-0.8403504490852356,
-0.835286021232605,
0.7104111313819885,
0.19717833399772644,
0.005625380668789148,
0.36021411418914795,
0.3415553569793701,
1.0230237245559692,
0.23942117393016815,
-0.7148147225379944,
-0.37390977144241333,
-0.1441311240196228,
-0.21533796191215515,
-0.3860626518726349,
-0.18848153948783875,
-0.3577159345149994,
-0.08264848589897156,
0.629108190536499,
-0.03993846848607063,
0.14693230390548706,
-0.008369202725589275,
-0.33450713753700256,
0.40660446882247925,
0.2728515565395355,
0.6361504793167114,
0.8075882196426392,
0.08020171523094177,
0.28416162729263306,
-0.00039094837848097086,
-0.45346054434776306,
0.16409100592136383,
0.3137550354003906,
-0.4455871284008026,
0.4012303650379181,
0.7630954384803772,
0.7484564781188965,
-0.35375577211380005,
-0.47511234879493713,
0.43801695108413696,
0.22971013188362122,
-0.6292983889579773,
-0.533604085445404,
0.08073677867650986,
-0.03604254126548767,
0.116615429520607,
0.5456569194793701,
-0.03037877194583416,
0.7102237939834595,
-0.4295925796031952,
-0.08188687264919281,
0.3996080160140991,
-0.44108816981315613,
-0.3028099536895752,
0.3822038769721985,
-0.21101778745651245,
-0.5158491134643555,
0.5053097605705261,
-0.3638685345649719,
-0.876069962978363,
0.626838207244873,
0.23145602643489838,
1.0312957763671875,
-0.14937736093997955,
0.44283759593963623,
0.11185754835605621,
0.2652364671230316,
0.1803809553384781,
0.15504658222198486,
-0.25947368144989014,
-0.7017220258712769,
-0.17450746893882751,
-0.6324641108512878,
-0.29597118496894836,
0.19634868204593658,
-0.6297687292098999,
0.045322634279727936,
-0.6507568955421448,
0.0059163435362279415,
0.4838922917842865,
-0.5596315264701843,
-0.5448306202888489,
0.13144350051879883,
0.20318441092967987,
0.48863232135772705,
-1.240866780281067,
0.5072699785232544,
0.650502622127533,
0.012149498797953129,
-0.5150161385536194,
-0.158224418759346,
0.36665573716163635,
-0.7864676713943481,
0.7617620229721069,
0.40846019983291626,
0.024468882009387016,
-0.3686842620372772,
-0.8210651874542236,
-0.6881949305534363,
0.5709408521652222,
0.3190476596355438,
-0.23372991383075714,
0.21813037991523743,
0.4427593946456909,
0.6343445181846619,
-0.2995384931564331,
-0.07938592880964279,
0.6270096898078918,
0.3440598249435425,
0.007300801575183868,
-0.9082884192466736,
0.030950037762522697,
-0.19210122525691986,
-0.06485491245985031,
0.33101731538772583,
-0.11567919701337814,
0.7685673832893372,
-0.12572142481803894,
-0.39074471592903137,
0.01223033294081688,
0.5232919454574585,
0.00974348932504654,
0.6801303029060364,
0.46205630898475647,
0.4282201826572418,
1.0713144540786743,
-0.35506558418273926,
1.207842230796814,
0.01162937842309475,
0.36995169520378113,
1.012786865234375,
0.036011066287755966,
0.389032781124115,
0.25319233536720276,
-0.4599337875843048,
0.8990375399589539,
0.9031309485435486,
-0.29756686091423035,
0.537290096282959,
0.35111650824546814,
-0.3010861575603485,
-0.16032160818576813,
0.07922015339136124,
0.07994142919778824,
0.7606425285339355,
0.3940841257572174,
-0.6891109347343445,
-0.20572862029075623,
0.3654484152793884,
0.20380768179893494,
0.1361798793077469,
-0.22281421720981598,
0.9961363673210144,
-0.26959070563316345,
-0.5221614837646484,
0.4480482339859009,
-0.001875504618510604,
0.4999023377895355,
-0.26068782806396484,
0.26754865050315857,
0.1342507153749466,
-0.11769311130046844,
-0.5465649366378784,
-0.797773540019989,
0.38933253288269043,
-0.11840859055519104,
-0.435146689414978,
-0.029378855600953102,
0.499681293964386,
-0.24631072580814362,
-0.37836575508117676,
0.039857327938079834,
0.40554630756378174,
0.6093220710754395,
-0.14808803796768188,
-0.30828794836997986,
-0.5441044569015503,
0.03393038734793663,
-0.06281589716672897,
0.25991547107696533,
0.6643117666244507,
-0.21200712025165558,
0.7146388292312622,
0.5449990630149841,
0.05778836831450462,
0.15876781940460205,
-0.2866077125072479,
0.4191834032535553,
-0.5657727122306824,
-0.6265280246734619,
-1.2227137088775635,
0.30617472529411316,
-0.028970440849661827,
-0.206314817070961,
0.9655196070671082,
0.5611985921859741,
0.8177669048309326,
0.017711224034428596,
1.2544786930084229,
-0.2184167057275772,
0.8368300795555115,
-0.6368167400360107,
0.8281441926956177,
-0.29664772748947144,
0.13582201302051544,
0.02832811325788498,
-0.4062529504299164,
-0.38076743483543396,
0.34417399764060974,
-0.525536298751831,
0.23294661939144135,
0.743992269039154,
0.5485610365867615,
-0.16099579632282257,
0.42112913727760315,
0.31395071744918823,
0.0826096311211586,
0.02619132585823536,
0.11034813523292542,
0.7939612865447998,
0.049477118998765945,
0.42723292112350464,
-0.6076341867446899,
-0.2819913327693939,
-0.21068158745765686,
-0.7713982462882996,
-0.9014163017272949,
-0.9060051441192627,
-0.2383861392736435,
-0.46287521719932556,
-0.10655761510133743,
0.371253103017807,
0.7624706029891968,
-1.1157605648040771,
-0.15794707834720612,
0.002418462885543704,
0.08287997543811798,
0.009981431998312473,
-0.2967955768108368,
0.4793194532394409,
-0.1700325608253479,
-0.4047573506832123,
0.32991456985473633,
0.1349586695432663,
0.1259138584136963,
-0.1301499903202057,
0.3531760573387146,
0.09111329168081284,
-0.3980399966239929,
0.34306564927101135,
0.3147072196006775,
-0.9308224320411682,
-0.08740062266588211,
-0.19167734682559967,
0.14832782745361328,
0.23198671638965607,
1.0411889553070068,
-0.8283376097679138,
0.4356254041194916,
0.32077062129974365,
0.9261188507080078,
0.3949418067932129,
0.11008741706609726,
0.4349100589752197,
-0.5972334742546082,
-0.04372633993625641,
0.10137130320072174,
0.4495411515235901,
0.5409066677093506,
-0.8354805707931519,
0.506080687046051,
0.5129645466804504,
-0.5377254486083984,
-0.5593200325965881,
0.32031312584877014,
-0.8600223660469055,
-0.5162464380264282,
1.1126309633255005,
-0.4446283280849457,
-0.24089811742305756,
-0.7874201536178589,
0.16791535913944244,
0.08905473351478577,
-0.11695654690265656,
1.0079545974731445,
0.9853410124778748,
0.009768244810402393,
0.15194916725158691,
-0.6948051452636719,
0.5393307209014893,
0.3195546567440033,
-0.5487414002418518,
0.16044026613235474,
0.5913042426109314,
0.5029000043869019,
0.4994942247867584,
0.2893402874469757,
-0.18341697752475739,
0.36230525374412537,
-0.25831469893455505,
-0.15468686819076538,
0.042405419051647186,
-0.21296240389347076,
-0.582756519317627,
0.7620728611946106,
-0.14629428088665009,
-0.06151527911424637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18470v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18470v1
|
ECC Analyzer: Extract Trading Signal from Earnings Conference Calls using Large Language Model for Stock Performance Prediction
| 2024-04-29T07:11:39 | 2024-04-29T07:11:39 |
Yupeng Cao, Zhi Chen, Qingyun Pei, Prashant Kumar, K. P. Subbalakshmi, Papa Momar Ndiaye
|
cs.CE
|
cs.CE, cs.AI, cs.CL, q-fin.RM, q-fin.TR
|
In the realm of financial analytics, leveraging unstructured data, such as
earnings conference calls (ECCs), to forecast stock performance is a critical
challenge that has attracted both academics and investors. While previous
studies have used deep learning-based models to obtain a general view of ECCs,
they often fail to capture detailed, complex information. Our study introduces
a novel framework: \textbf{ECC Analyzer}, combining Large Language Models
(LLMs) and multi-modal techniques to extract richer, more predictive insights.
The model begins by summarizing the transcript's structure and analyzing the
speakers' mode and confidence level by detecting variations in tone and pitch
for audio. This analysis helps investors form an overview perception of the
ECCs. Moreover, this model uses the Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) based
methods to meticulously extract the focuses that have a significant impact on
stock performance from an expert's perspective, providing a more targeted
analysis. The model goes a step further by enriching these extracted focuses
with additional layers of analysis, such as sentiment and audio segment
features. By integrating these insights, the ECC Analyzer performs multi-task
predictions of stock performance, including volatility, value-at-risk (VaR),
and return for different intervals. The results show that our model outperforms
traditional analytic benchmarks, confirming the effectiveness of using advanced
LLM techniques in financial analytics.
|
[
-0.17939138412475586,
-0.8437806367874146,
0.2710843086242676,
0.03843042626976967,
-0.4349825978279114,
0.6462141871452332,
-0.25875943899154663,
-0.8492788672447205,
0.45266252756118774,
0.4067508280277252,
-0.7182301878929138,
-0.6309361457824707,
-0.5995312333106995,
-0.0494246706366539,
-0.5341780185699463,
1.001617193222046,
0.32563892006874084,
0.27285027503967285,
-0.1336655467748642,
0.16250136494636536,
-0.27074456214904785,
-0.6467717289924622,
-0.738498866558075,
0.009802402928471565,
0.19781824946403503,
0.41611093282699585,
0.35912972688674927,
0.53636234998703,
0.6144050359725952,
0.33552277088165283,
-0.2547268867492676,
0.4367150068283081,
-0.21730300784111023,
0.176949605345726,
0.34655481576919556,
-0.3150574564933777,
-0.966251790523529,
-0.2159622609615326,
0.4021436870098114,
0.6835929751396179,
-0.3852449953556061,
0.30171096324920654,
0.3438691198825836,
0.3837297260761261,
-0.5178261399269104,
0.44965219497680664,
-0.619637131690979,
-0.04823365435004234,
-0.3411932587623596,
-0.7044744491577148,
-0.5767804384231567,
0.021211782470345497,
0.1025557667016983,
-0.31511858105659485,
0.11139758676290512,
0.30621060729026794,
0.6961619257926941,
0.0008037243387661874,
-0.3992355763912201,
-0.2007712870836258,
-1.042602777481079,
0.8684884309768677,
-0.7527551651000977,
0.4552289545536041,
0.22466842830181122,
0.23504818975925446,
0.09319671243429184,
-0.7255728244781494,
-0.14317570626735687,
-0.22685572504997253,
0.15979492664337158,
0.3315075635910034,
-0.13274531066417694,
0.05322440341114998,
0.02840174175798893,
0.4696190655231476,
-0.16137421131134033,
0.4775424301624298,
-0.6989542841911316,
0.08271291851997375,
0.6603367924690247,
0.34687191247940063,
-0.114944688975811,
0.1479734629392624,
-0.4664321839809418,
-0.06627950817346573,
-0.6398758888244629,
0.16571186482906342,
0.4220527112483978,
0.4541543424129486,
0.08316513150930405,
0.33150190114974976,
-0.0028400009032338858,
0.33651474118232727,
-0.0002128222113242373,
-0.17801982164382935,
0.20867832005023956,
-0.013181705959141254,
-0.06669546663761139,
0.355890691280365,
0.46996039152145386,
0.25914084911346436,
-0.038880713284015656,
-0.10206731408834457,
-0.2724838852882385,
-0.17390070855617523,
0.1905180811882019,
-0.8818204998970032,
-0.19331210851669312,
0.3985658288002014,
-0.896955132484436,
-0.3629075586795807,
0.2436082810163498,
-1.2008492946624756,
-0.1804344654083252,
-0.5967391729354858,
-0.04965733736753464,
-0.2227770984172821,
-0.2480175495147705,
-0.04370177909731865,
-0.16141104698181152,
0.5397682785987854,
0.09995435923337936,
-0.8854976296424866,
0.6600235104560852,
0.9829514622688293,
0.7448028922080994,
-0.4193267822265625,
-0.09046707302331924,
-0.9759545922279358,
0.08952497690916061,
-0.19514228403568268,
1.103555679321289,
-0.6559286117553711,
-0.6281912922859192,
0.027091294527053833,
-0.19744792580604553,
0.18163704872131348,
-0.3933437466621399,
0.5181161761283875,
-0.6742478609085083,
-0.20399737358093262,
-0.10277944803237915,
-0.8174679279327393,
-0.10821636021137238,
-0.15509803593158722,
-0.780213475227356,
0.906663179397583,
-0.45783179998397827,
-0.5804515480995178,
0.4454203248023987,
-0.9383763074874878,
-0.297121524810791,
0.38488689064979553,
-0.35702431201934814,
-0.3459203243255615,
0.005942599382251501,
0.20709769427776337,
0.5510220527648926,
-0.2991582453250885,
-0.11748844385147095,
-0.5935433506965637,
-0.1149095669388771,
0.7104384899139404,
-0.5444858074188232,
0.1423599272966385,
0.21544249355793,
-0.3074852228164673,
0.1771797090768814,
-0.9411767721176147,
0.21528083086013794,
0.024372709915041924,
-0.03452755883336067,
-0.3433052897453308,
0.6014991998672485,
0.31051987409591675,
0.015097947791218758,
0.19858433306217194,
-0.4255005419254303,
-0.13787874579429626,
-0.5033993721008301,
0.11720916628837585,
0.8266242742538452,
-0.06104455143213272,
0.21306125819683075,
0.017266983166337013,
0.7938601970672607,
-0.08797197043895721,
0.08171714097261429,
-0.22021029889583588,
-0.21703357994556427,
-0.3794223368167877,
-0.44648122787475586,
0.49198272824287415,
0.5925918221473694,
0.03071065992116928,
0.6569579839706421,
-0.15661682188510895,
-0.5026245713233948,
-0.3989548683166504,
0.1841568797826767,
0.04200844466686249,
0.15399590134620667,
0.25214073061943054,
-0.41310060024261475,
-0.6504864692687988,
-0.8594188094139099,
-0.31197863817214966,
0.279173880815506,
-0.07929931581020355,
0.03383951261639595,
0.2898290753364563,
0.06707792729139328,
0.5908629298210144,
-0.7852813601493835,
-0.1485583335161209,
-0.47518739104270935,
0.3635644316673279,
0.39637619256973267,
0.04820837080478668,
0.2112467885017395,
-0.7883070707321167,
-0.20711649954319,
0.2303003966808319,
-0.32136645913124084,
0.06652122735977173,
-0.08871767669916153,
0.0018351878970861435,
0.21091601252555847,
0.7560096383094788,
-0.07538087666034698,
0.670164167881012,
0.7472160458564758,
-0.46403923630714417,
0.7128610610961914,
-0.03679298236966133,
-0.03291701152920723,
-0.9937000870704651,
0.2545384168624878,
0.2168506234884262,
-0.23546051979064941,
-0.43365249037742615,
-0.42387819290161133,
-0.1563577950000763,
0.07324569672346115,
-0.23146086931228638,
0.24418537318706512,
-0.4778781831264496,
-0.40070396661758423,
-0.712417483329773,
0.19836241006851196,
-0.11312724649906158,
0.32959166169166565,
-0.03296876698732376,
0.6497635245323181,
0.4665515124797821,
-0.6845676898956299,
0.2522875964641571,
0.10769858956336975,
-0.5516347885131836,
0.20648407936096191,
-0.5674957633018494,
0.12825383245944977,
0.2089221179485321,
0.017645329236984253,
-0.9648460745811462,
0.13543125987052917,
-0.12580236792564392,
-0.33587518334388733,
0.4127804636955261,
0.12019223719835281,
-0.29907676577568054,
-0.08251692354679108,
-0.31528860330581665,
0.237112358212471,
0.32726430892944336,
-0.4258846938610077,
0.9764070510864258,
0.5527452826499939,
-0.6653996109962463,
-0.6103503108024597,
-0.49552497267723083,
0.018987197428941727,
-0.21949723362922668,
-0.3447035849094391,
0.5699635744094849,
-0.14248508214950562,
-0.41369324922561646,
-0.09045355021953583,
-0.2297181785106659,
-0.12032682448625565,
0.297841340303421,
0.383475124835968,
1.0863693952560425,
-0.04405970498919487,
-0.03159167245030403,
0.006868469528853893,
-0.2741004228591919,
0.2700926959514618,
-0.040570955723524094,
0.6118247509002686,
-0.29478543996810913,
-0.276599258184433,
-0.5189188718795776,
0.5082256197929382,
0.47740837931632996,
-0.44351547956466675,
0.8247292637825012,
0.3556039333343506,
-0.16199858486652374,
-0.15401765704154968,
-0.48685264587402344,
-0.2900930643081665,
-0.5145649313926697,
0.6628993153572083,
-0.17609933018684387,
-0.5798919796943665,
0.8046783804893494,
-0.35444340109825134,
0.15581169724464417,
0.6665018796920776,
0.6415600776672363,
-0.09383004903793335,
1.335906744003296,
0.8571951389312744,
-0.0017410367727279663,
0.6422363519668579,
-0.3378027379512787,
0.38841453194618225,
-0.758448600769043,
-0.38501691818237305,
-0.42090630531311035,
-0.5229014754295349,
-0.5085520148277283,
0.019844165071845055,
0.19720344245433807,
-0.04740746319293976,
-0.04153401404619217,
0.06752540916204453,
-0.4699726700782776,
0.45785844326019287,
0.5083876252174377,
-0.09961630403995514,
0.5465931296348572,
0.008961565792560577,
0.07200001925230026,
-0.02790270745754242,
-0.2963152229785919,
-0.6533414721488953,
1.3410364389419556,
0.5718730092048645,
0.71170574426651,
-0.2708871364593506,
0.32818129658699036,
0.3296111226081848,
0.33796927332878113,
-0.9022113084793091,
0.3630535900592804,
-0.3071574568748474,
-0.3802010118961334,
0.05233911797404289,
-0.4373525381088257,
-0.6648971438407898,
0.20208953320980072,
-0.3078696131706238,
-0.7837115526199341,
0.3314354121685028,
-0.13915199041366577,
-0.5707448124885559,
0.38552454113960266,
-0.5180891156196594,
0.5506742596626282,
-0.6432591676712036,
-0.04662065953016281,
-0.3473893404006958,
-0.20691272616386414,
0.13058817386627197,
-0.24499870836734772,
0.3893687427043915,
-0.07172852009534836,
-0.2122553288936615,
1.0945180654525757,
-0.26918914914131165,
0.9054408669471741,
0.09471346437931061,
-0.1355392038822174,
0.17171329259872437,
0.01976042240858078,
0.5333353877067566,
0.012959307990968227,
0.029744034633040428,
0.32858574390411377,
0.24339686334133148,
-0.17236731946468353,
-0.3092752993106842,
0.5366321206092834,
-0.607033371925354,
-0.2039957344532013,
-0.36150842905044556,
-0.31871169805526733,
-0.2350892275571823,
-0.08606784045696259,
0.16125743091106415,
0.446622759103775,
-0.2756214141845703,
0.38248857855796814,
0.0729413628578186,
0.09551650285720825,
0.5890836715698242,
0.3010273873806,
-0.12050708383321762,
-0.49484848976135254,
0.5981776118278503,
0.056915223598480225,
0.07297882437705994,
0.24868614971637726,
-0.05015271157026291,
-0.45056167244911194,
-0.6617262363433838,
0.17274273931980133,
-0.06727700680494308,
-0.5834245681762695,
-0.44225725531578064,
-0.4327397346496582,
-0.23300422728061676,
-0.3243972063064575,
0.0003244785184506327,
-0.7328561544418335,
-0.16812150180339813,
-0.37612560391426086,
-0.49825331568717957,
0.4114069938659668,
0.6445204615592957,
0.03469524160027504,
0.31653523445129395,
-1.059714436531067,
0.14846722781658173,
0.15481609106063843,
0.4230155944824219,
0.06766290962696075,
-0.4564487338066101,
-0.4951764643192291,
0.1376839429140091,
-0.7802578210830688,
-0.8188666701316833,
0.8847799897193909,
0.1224898174405098,
0.4324641525745392,
0.6191548109054565,
-0.03684226796030998,
0.703451931476593,
-0.22065646946430206,
0.4621274471282959,
0.3490748405456543,
-0.9410834908485413,
0.34177783131599426,
-0.09685978293418884,
-0.18695823848247528,
0.3297208249568939,
0.1981913149356842,
-0.3939055800437927,
-0.34545043110847473,
-0.6465041637420654,
-1.3152542114257812,
0.655380368232727,
0.04405772686004639,
-0.1812954992055893,
0.0672154650092125,
0.17107100784778595,
0.2475011795759201,
0.2919608950614929,
-0.5291165709495544,
-0.3292825520038605,
0.01841716282069683,
-0.21504643559455872,
0.00010139208461623639,
-0.4655252993106842,
-0.12338804453611374,
-0.10337129980325699,
0.5171571373939514,
-0.2626211941242218,
0.3386475741863251,
0.12755507230758667,
0.2569187581539154,
-0.22662147879600525,
0.1834038645029068,
0.30595993995666504,
0.8645608425140381,
-0.3277052342891693,
-0.34666159749031067,
0.5359005331993103,
-0.29194116592407227,
-0.581067681312561,
0.3873312771320343,
0.44531774520874023,
-0.20590049028396606,
0.41085413098335266,
0.6300027966499329,
0.3342306315898895,
-1.0921919345855713,
0.3615586757659912,
-0.15979130566120148,
-0.18094107508659363,
-0.7902278304100037,
-0.15927398204803467,
-0.08710924535989761,
0.5269919037818909,
0.9176179766654968,
-0.0029749106615781784,
0.4427635073661804,
-0.4762440323829651,
0.27369341254234314,
0.3324878215789795,
-0.3291131556034088,
-0.31764018535614014,
0.6619595885276794,
0.23011863231658936,
-0.09431759268045425,
0.5698650479316711,
0.09894555062055588,
-0.6293114423751831,
0.8507852554321289,
0.22300784289836884,
1.1652135848999023,
-0.10504762083292007,
-0.08828196674585342,
0.044557664543390274,
-0.12343303859233856,
0.07309851050376892,
0.21387995779514313,
0.14637932181358337,
-0.4536933898925781,
-1.077789068222046,
-0.5722019672393799,
-0.5887443423271179,
0.09992778301239014,
-0.8900003433227539,
0.3756852149963379,
-0.33543065190315247,
-0.2741709351539612,
0.3425595760345459,
0.1923305243253708,
-0.773705005645752,
-0.012588691897690296,
0.5046760439872742,
0.772610068321228,
-0.5745667219161987,
0.5475861430168152,
0.3922632038593292,
-0.16270048916339874,
-0.8310847282409668,
-0.244411438703537,
-0.05228222906589508,
-0.5014328956604004,
0.6717451214790344,
0.2064569741487503,
-0.3488948941230774,
-0.32337555289268494,
-0.5837472677230835,
-0.6104691028594971,
1.1347249746322632,
0.13292908668518066,
-0.8702168464660645,
0.17488816380500793,
-0.1643647849559784,
0.289122074842453,
-0.8312669396400452,
0.41064125299453735,
0.7096757888793945,
0.2939857542514801,
0.30850446224212646,
-0.8905569314956665,
-0.2215522825717926,
-0.3268308937549591,
-0.34990403056144714,
0.2926681339740753,
-0.5621532797813416,
0.7134623527526855,
0.04335780814290047,
-0.10570400208234787,
-0.06389260292053223,
0.9343745112419128,
0.21599330008029938,
0.6217814683914185,
0.40079620480537415,
0.14703811705112457,
0.7614622116088867,
0.0722428560256958,
1.1113041639328003,
-0.6402991414070129,
0.442047655582428,
1.1562329530715942,
-0.30197423696517944,
1.3004519939422607,
0.3053878843784332,
-0.06802254170179367,
0.5735710263252258,
0.4829558730125427,
-0.28199926018714905,
0.4390474557876587,
-0.1653001308441162,
-0.24991236627101898,
-0.45951133966445923,
0.045843951404094696,
-0.27293622493743896,
0.911629319190979,
0.5425194501876831,
-0.48007333278656006,
0.20253627002239227,
-0.3660721480846405,
-0.16066157817840576,
-0.04199855402112007,
-0.4475364685058594,
0.8933616876602173,
0.226506769657135,
-0.19866088032722473,
0.04555442929267883,
0.01569974608719349,
0.8041819334030151,
-0.6272246241569519,
0.0015860979910939932,
0.06895419955253601,
0.3812362551689148,
-0.056165143847465515,
-0.48765435814857483,
0.4101717472076416,
0.03829803690314293,
0.0740329697728157,
-0.1308135986328125,
0.7475888133049011,
-0.3673442304134369,
-0.6440452337265015,
0.6006034016609192,
0.4609690010547638,
0.029536906629800797,
-0.15487892925739288,
-0.5687713623046875,
0.01927768625319004,
0.035666994750499725,
-0.2788591682910919,
0.2895045578479767,
0.26063767075538635,
0.5121889114379883,
0.703744649887085,
1.0176618099212646,
0.3225436210632324,
-0.1268235594034195,
-0.11909759789705276,
0.7913040518760681,
-1.1074570417404175,
-0.5944913029670715,
-0.9152934551239014,
0.48110610246658325,
-0.302415132522583,
-0.2619931101799011,
0.4692380726337433,
0.8084678053855896,
0.44639265537261963,
0.050641391426324844,
0.5617308020591736,
0.5018549561500549,
0.6137361526489258,
-0.4955075979232788,
0.5938305258750916,
-0.4052731692790985,
0.5879076719284058,
-0.18261589109897614,
-0.8423917889595032,
-0.10573878884315491,
0.15100307762622833,
-0.4485706388950348,
0.06619393825531006,
0.7596280574798584,
0.6102639436721802,
0.0070047639310359955,
0.5259129405021667,
0.2748749852180481,
0.30605843663215637,
0.3911324441432953,
-0.046596769243478775,
0.7863186001777649,
-0.3534640669822693,
0.9418478012084961,
-0.2500605583190918,
-0.27030476927757263,
-0.47922050952911377,
-0.8387924432754517,
-0.6030026078224182,
-0.34073206782341003,
-0.4582183063030243,
-0.3056577742099762,
-0.1973944902420044,
0.9967147707939148,
0.477905809879303,
-0.7754639983177185,
-0.459638386964798,
0.2930513024330139,
-0.3200458884239197,
-0.46944695711135864,
-0.29529547691345215,
0.6671176552772522,
-0.3460884094238281,
-0.930731475353241,
0.49534615874290466,
0.3238259553909302,
-0.03306625783443451,
-0.02026602253317833,
0.07204329967498779,
0.1468210518360138,
0.15031909942626953,
0.6960070133209229,
0.2028457075357437,
-0.3430926501750946,
0.019522754475474358,
0.14631830155849457,
0.2492026537656784,
-0.09129638224840164,
0.8216197490692139,
-0.4668221175670624,
0.033552926033735275,
0.2353983372449875,
0.5814501643180847,
0.4389232099056244,
0.11100757122039795,
0.6183763146400452,
-0.5512186288833618,
0.11652738600969315,
0.37356677651405334,
0.49018511176109314,
-0.12774956226348877,
-0.47028395533561707,
0.06571243703365326,
-0.0531800352036953,
-0.690788745880127,
-0.7251794934272766,
-0.2677493989467621,
-1.307961344718933,
-0.4573577344417572,
1.120034098625183,
0.32941603660583496,
-0.5423424243927002,
0.11771442741155624,
-0.21550635993480682,
0.18136116862297058,
-0.7311317324638367,
0.8244104385375977,
0.511568009853363,
-0.18792104721069336,
0.017663614824414253,
-0.7858694791793823,
0.25867390632629395,
0.48223793506622314,
-0.6698503494262695,
0.3325200378894806,
0.24829943478107452,
0.09222488850355148,
0.007356464862823486,
0.27931466698646545,
-0.1967933624982834,
0.3016141653060913,
-0.057383496314287186,
0.16885359585285187,
0.010342729277908802,
-0.2734484374523163,
-0.21053172647953033,
0.3178281784057617,
0.036734700202941895,
-0.5783073306083679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18466v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18466v1
|
HFT: Half Fine-Tuning for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-29T07:07:58 | 2024-04-29T07:07:58 |
Tingfeng Hui, Zhenyu Zhang, Shuohuan Wang, Weiran Xu, Yu Sun, Hua Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) with one or more fine-tuning phases have become
a necessary step to unlock various capabilities, enabling LLMs to follow
natural language instructions or align with human preferences. However, it
carries the risk of catastrophic forgetting during sequential training, the
parametric knowledge or the ability learned in previous stages may be
overwhelmed by incoming training data. In this paper, we find that by regularly
resetting partial parameters, LLMs can restore some of the original knowledge.
Inspired by this, we introduce Half Fine-Tuning (HFT) for LLMs, as a substitute
for full fine-tuning (FFT), to mitigate the forgetting issues, where half of
the parameters are selected to learn new tasks while the other half are frozen
to remain previous knowledge. We provide a feasibility analysis from the
perspective of optimization and interpret the parameter selection operation as
a regularization term. Without changing the model architecture, HFT could be
seamlessly integrated into existing fine-tuning frameworks. Extensive
experiments and analysis on supervised fine-tuning, direct preference
optimization, and continual learning consistently demonstrate the
effectiveness, robustness, and efficiency of HFT. Compared with FFT, HFT not
only significantly alleviates the forgetting problem, but also achieves the
best performance in a series of downstream benchmarks, with an approximately
30% reduction in training time.
|
[
-0.5084696412086487,
-0.9678637981414795,
0.5422395467758179,
0.02460472285747528,
-0.46367907524108887,
0.06742262095212936,
-0.5862930417060852,
-0.04882229119539261,
-0.09933122992515564,
0.6201273798942566,
-0.7649345993995667,
-0.15786872804164886,
-0.37253937125205994,
-0.0035265986807644367,
-0.24869951605796814,
0.9560767412185669,
-0.23553773760795593,
-0.26123562455177307,
-0.09137877076864243,
-0.06988765299320221,
-0.44333159923553467,
-0.24460625648498535,
-1.3190075159072876,
-0.6961434483528137,
0.5322956442832947,
0.4938106834888458,
0.6279154419898987,
0.9835442304611206,
0.18496336042881012,
0.21788261830806732,
0.01107726339250803,
0.003130866214632988,
-0.9094677567481995,
0.025423046201467514,
-0.3297343850135803,
-0.485036700963974,
-0.32474759221076965,
-0.0362510159611702,
0.8180391192436218,
0.8729809522628784,
-0.5040411353111267,
0.19525454938411713,
0.20035050809383392,
1.252846360206604,
-0.565462052822113,
0.26034390926361084,
-0.8392013311386108,
0.15948736667633057,
-0.03013068251311779,
-0.4137260317802429,
-0.03881475701928139,
-0.0746055394411087,
0.15133817493915558,
-0.6322203278541565,
0.39833304286003113,
0.3384973704814911,
0.902730405330658,
0.7481926083564758,
-0.07066621631383896,
0.06978759169578552,
-0.7676107287406921,
0.8436975479125977,
-0.6909188628196716,
0.6580870747566223,
0.6340042352676392,
0.2213822305202484,
-0.3151932656764984,
-0.24570679664611816,
-0.5078291296958923,
-0.042497992515563965,
0.10485450178384781,
0.000727337843272835,
-0.05099727213382721,
0.3162471354007721,
0.3166627883911133,
0.45003387331962585,
-0.42331475019454956,
0.0903361588716507,
-0.1469651758670807,
-0.45310935378074646,
0.3394951820373535,
0.0796617940068245,
-0.19420014321804047,
0.3106759190559387,
-0.2244301587343216,
-0.047755785286426544,
-0.9394351840019226,
-0.003315811511129141,
0.2614540457725525,
0.3618849515914917,
-0.0011204028269276023,
0.16689293086528778,
-0.4512028694152832,
0.7480342388153076,
0.39555397629737854,
-0.4180331230163574,
0.025011824443936348,
-0.11166562885046005,
-0.43176892399787903,
-0.19072763621807098,
0.5739505290985107,
0.04708187282085419,
0.5467406511306763,
-0.188102126121521,
-0.43002060055732727,
-0.38185009360313416,
0.08755358308553696,
-0.6411116719245911,
-0.22990106046199799,
0.013157525099813938,
-0.3168819546699524,
0.15487024188041687,
-0.33039459586143494,
-0.6013039946556091,
-0.19383928179740906,
-0.6996132135391235,
0.4755713641643524,
-0.4792707860469818,
-0.0762535110116005,
0.5837516784667969,
0.006815297529101372,
0.016810232773423195,
0.3696384131908417,
-1.0498796701431274,
0.3258184492588043,
0.6048387289047241,
0.5167175531387329,
-0.2377626895904541,
-0.7279921174049377,
-0.6348928213119507,
0.09833889454603195,
-0.33393457531929016,
0.4381544589996338,
-0.32180964946746826,
-0.13810518383979797,
-0.044349320232868195,
0.05396650359034538,
-0.08966784924268723,
-0.7300158739089966,
0.548331618309021,
-0.6769422888755798,
0.030007554218173027,
-0.43990999460220337,
-0.5394745469093323,
-0.006277398206293583,
0.35432010889053345,
-0.5478447675704956,
1.0632604360580444,
0.23364917933940887,
-0.5107318162918091,
0.39145973324775696,
-0.04175729304552078,
-0.6558617353439331,
-0.21544331312179565,
0.11743827909231186,
-0.8019025921821594,
0.11398236453533173,
0.0015567096415907145,
0.3533075749874115,
-0.5504409074783325,
0.26860928535461426,
-0.3547377288341522,
-0.4955000579357147,
-0.3648028075695038,
-0.3580256998538971,
0.30026692152023315,
0.03678622096776962,
-0.22672104835510254,
-0.0240329559892416,
-0.6053304076194763,
-0.30062830448150635,
0.12028989940881729,
-0.7668756246566772,
-0.25611791014671326,
0.034223563969135284,
-0.21885347366333008,
0.10481120645999908,
0.4219048023223877,
-0.5811987519264221,
0.0025516580790281296,
-0.5902532935142517,
0.5611695647239685,
0.737445056438446,
0.14663811028003693,
0.5928528904914856,
-0.4957358241081238,
0.4490756094455719,
0.0326041579246521,
0.28554850816726685,
-0.263682097196579,
0.019097600132226944,
-1.1712576150894165,
-0.1322416514158249,
0.37697774171829224,
0.38698136806488037,
-0.7324424386024475,
0.5332592725753784,
0.11649305373430252,
-0.10321732610464096,
-0.44997438788414,
0.5411185026168823,
0.370397686958313,
0.5161331295967102,
0.2875102460384369,
0.0804109200835228,
-0.7373545169830322,
-0.9747486114501953,
-0.11418800801038742,
-0.06550870835781097,
-0.05339783802628517,
0.08115687966346741,
0.34339168667793274,
-0.08502750843763351,
0.9163720607757568,
-0.3692195415496826,
-0.5181094408035278,
-0.014750692062079906,
-0.05811706557869911,
0.11754809319972992,
0.382558137178421,
0.3422970473766327,
-0.6076626181602478,
-0.4933914840221405,
-0.21625331044197083,
-0.32822442054748535,
0.1727076768875122,
-0.28084051609039307,
-0.2797815501689911,
0.3569454550743103,
0.5728188753128052,
-0.5331929922103882,
0.05129010230302811,
0.25086644291877747,
-0.09430226683616638,
0.2898200452327728,
-0.5183574557304382,
-0.11990700662136078,
-0.73763507604599,
-0.07527513056993484,
-0.05263504013419151,
-0.4015165865421295,
-0.3357052206993103,
-0.08223141729831696,
0.2825775146484375,
0.14432069659233093,
-0.195456862449646,
0.6873207092285156,
-0.46812427043914795,
0.3544250726699829,
-0.4668430685997009,
-0.10328566282987595,
-0.1322406381368637,
0.7347085475921631,
-0.0787658840417862,
0.6808405518531799,
0.5781868696212769,
-0.5489641427993774,
0.18033038079738617,
-0.03539913520216942,
-0.15297923982143402,
0.28639915585517883,
-0.39769136905670166,
0.15122175216674805,
-0.3103167712688446,
0.06370019167661667,
-0.6644734740257263,
-0.052975669503211975,
-0.20184464752674103,
-0.04270365461707115,
0.5063762068748474,
-0.2348538488149643,
-0.7824270129203796,
-0.2757549583911896,
-0.3475171625614166,
0.09803244471549988,
0.7322224378585815,
-0.39860275387763977,
0.47302836179733276,
0.398969829082489,
-0.0423017293214798,
-0.27943214774131775,
-0.23918215930461884,
-0.05546386539936066,
-0.20281089842319489,
-0.21829915046691895,
0.289430171251297,
-0.05814520642161369,
0.22667959332466125,
-0.23989272117614746,
-0.4209137558937073,
0.12742315232753754,
0.18030549585819244,
-0.02316904067993164,
0.09306793659925461,
-0.12005414068698883,
0.16566231846809387,
0.36608272790908813,
-0.23932379484176636,
-0.29508647322654724,
-0.5852941870689392,
0.710121750831604,
-0.04538966342806816,
-0.22542749345302582,
-0.38020968437194824,
0.2609047293663025,
0.5353780388832092,
-0.23085671663284302,
0.5529742240905762,
0.49533751606941223,
-0.657277524471283,
-0.35176610946655273,
-0.8602105975151062,
-0.41382911801338196,
-0.5018323659896851,
0.41929444670677185,
-0.3237464129924774,
-1.324549913406372,
0.4153868556022644,
-0.0875927060842514,
0.10037289559841156,
0.2824684679508209,
0.6397071480751038,
-0.38653331995010376,
0.7805143594741821,
1.0633084774017334,
-0.3561207056045532,
0.6657645106315613,
0.06736599653959274,
0.16778865456581116,
-0.5233832597732544,
0.049627117812633514,
-0.40066787600517273,
-0.2764311730861664,
-0.39411497116088867,
-0.11965741217136383,
0.4776316285133362,
0.42409369349479675,
-0.5613008141517639,
0.1853361874818802,
-0.09451277554035187,
0.761768639087677,
0.630469799041748,
0.1097702607512474,
0.28212371468544006,
0.0696222111582756,
0.07845306396484375,
0.12555788457393646,
-0.7159168720245361,
-0.23401594161987305,
0.7810101509094238,
0.4660177528858185,
0.8745655417442322,
-0.2791798412799835,
0.6857634782791138,
0.01978527382016182,
-0.17544521391391754,
-0.8296406865119934,
0.3761115074157715,
-0.3271433115005493,
-0.5690969228744507,
-0.7602459192276001,
-0.43038538098335266,
-0.7300008535385132,
-0.013415476307272911,
-0.16670912504196167,
-0.5339256525039673,
0.035565804690122604,
0.6166922450065613,
-0.8250109553337097,
0.19926781952381134,
-0.5317739844322205,
0.5902508497238159,
0.08437860012054443,
-0.4425347149372101,
-0.3074879050254822,
-0.5812523365020752,
0.10537298023700714,
-0.5907608866691589,
0.03805070370435715,
-0.3807333707809448,
0.07552977651357651,
0.762569785118103,
-0.06762997806072235,
0.949600100517273,
-0.2877238988876343,
-0.08307001739740372,
-0.030646391212940216,
0.14013883471488953,
0.6203869581222534,
0.18771815299987793,
-0.1906960904598236,
-0.11895862221717834,
0.3267796039581299,
-0.5037675499916077,
-0.5986350774765015,
0.6690007448196411,
-0.5651817917823792,
-0.7842918038368225,
-0.054982058703899384,
-0.6402034759521484,
-0.6829362511634827,
0.4619560241699219,
0.04727312549948692,
-0.07567568123340607,
0.034217819571495056,
0.14121754467487335,
1.0482226610183716,
-0.12564393877983093,
0.4871484339237213,
0.7095432281494141,
-0.13908760249614716,
-0.27160465717315674,
0.9195192456245422,
-0.01542302593588829,
0.3376059830188751,
0.42762333154678345,
0.3570560812950134,
-0.007820296101272106,
-0.7342813014984131,
-0.45516452193260193,
0.480704128742218,
-0.18371109664440155,
-0.35291093587875366,
-0.43518680334091187,
-0.15349061787128448,
-0.05472526699304581,
-0.13567039370536804,
-0.6560490727424622,
-0.32334232330322266,
-0.3386308252811432,
0.03520135581493378,
0.19410012662410736,
0.2271062284708023,
0.04850051924586296,
0.39335963129997253,
-0.7759385704994202,
0.40009641647338867,
0.34117916226387024,
0.6606322526931763,
0.049301113933324814,
-0.6739972233772278,
-0.5957710146903992,
0.18867900967597961,
-0.2371223270893097,
-0.20912493765354156,
0.1012076660990715,
0.547292947769165,
0.45271942019462585,
0.3903261721134186,
-0.03743726760149002,
0.7154433131217957,
-0.7528722286224365,
0.33015045523643494,
0.11345555633306503,
-0.8271934986114502,
0.31177929043769836,
-0.557420551776886,
0.6449378728866577,
0.8739449977874756,
0.22987288236618042,
-0.5381894707679749,
-0.22171488404273987,
-0.22813324630260468,
-0.6572730541229248,
0.6964009404182434,
0.023250946775078773,
0.184384286403656,
0.25986364483833313,
0.8119312524795532,
0.30912864208221436,
0.25032538175582886,
-0.129611536860466,
-0.18273542821407318,
0.06668850034475327,
-0.1619725525379181,
-0.2025132030248642,
-0.44273102283477783,
-0.14138607680797577,
-0.6115247011184692,
0.7889009714126587,
-0.2742833197116852,
0.07746832817792892,
-0.219708651304245,
0.0813458189368248,
-0.5987657904624939,
0.19195933640003204,
0.42349880933761597,
0.7475703358650208,
-0.332411527633667,
0.1115059107542038,
0.35999077558517456,
-0.3290278911590576,
-0.014403999783098698,
0.060905370861291885,
-0.2057836502790451,
-0.4056660532951355,
0.2594794034957886,
0.8733832240104675,
0.39357203245162964,
-0.6338976621627808,
0.21246549487113953,
0.14054524898529053,
-0.31183087825775146,
-0.2715992331504822,
0.22257286310195923,
0.29887890815734863,
0.1502593457698822,
0.3779016435146332,
0.05756024271249771,
-0.08862405270338058,
-0.7035105228424072,
0.4021860361099243,
0.3951769769191742,
-0.48545902967453003,
-0.24947614967823029,
0.4476960599422455,
-0.014010461047291756,
-0.30059337615966797,
0.524795651435852,
-0.11094047874212265,
-0.555891752243042,
0.3623907268047333,
0.553165078163147,
0.644074559211731,
-0.04043431207537651,
-0.05239615589380264,
0.446789026260376,
0.4483851194381714,
-0.5539096593856812,
0.33661943674087524,
-0.00393848679959774,
-0.8034176230430603,
-0.35752221941947937,
-1.1841708421707153,
-0.26435625553131104,
0.03422205150127411,
-0.6526231169700623,
0.25264230370521545,
-0.7044865489006042,
-0.05123298242688179,
-0.0312640480697155,
0.004390134010463953,
-0.5710107088088989,
0.20873267948627472,
0.01572101004421711,
1.061816692352295,
-0.6911163926124573,
1.3287873268127441,
0.5215221643447876,
-0.1919354349374771,
-0.5262453556060791,
0.13083307445049286,
-0.014009674079716206,
-0.6712740063667297,
0.029820190742611885,
-0.35776805877685547,
-0.1422077715396881,
0.1520879566669464,
-0.400949627161026,
-0.9731926918029785,
0.9208758473396301,
0.7872515320777893,
-1.019965410232544,
-0.28852131962776184,
0.20643877983093262,
0.5998014211654663,
-0.04673534631729126,
-0.34881332516670227,
1.3131334781646729,
0.3726687729358673,
0.2860678732395172,
-1.2040528059005737,
0.0706142783164978,
0.217704176902771,
-0.0001288140338147059,
0.661130428314209,
-0.8902236819267273,
0.7629244327545166,
-0.10035253316164017,
-0.16041599214076996,
-0.0334436371922493,
0.40834784507751465,
0.1529964953660965,
0.07984122633934021,
0.733846127986908,
0.5374000072479248,
0.6370074152946472,
-0.1453339010477066,
0.6011788845062256,
-0.2565646767616272,
0.6257896423339844,
1.2530481815338135,
-0.2065005749464035,
0.8378295302391052,
0.7860727906227112,
-0.2710409462451935,
-0.2518778145313263,
0.7456650137901306,
0.12477153539657593,
0.6999140381813049,
0.18069162964820862,
0.00892536249011755,
-0.6705605983734131,
0.280406653881073,
0.007687688805162907,
0.1999460905790329,
0.12958773970603943,
0.07017092406749725,
-0.3785310983657837,
0.3198308050632477,
0.2036857008934021,
0.015562172047793865,
-0.17296931147575378,
0.8924776911735535,
0.3462640047073364,
-0.6624281406402588,
0.9282236099243164,
0.12162141501903534,
0.755398690700531,
-0.5815795660018921,
0.0719231441617012,
-0.4809224307537079,
0.2892583906650543,
-0.00867350585758686,
-0.44565558433532715,
0.38642850518226624,
-0.2879793643951416,
-0.4692293703556061,
-0.42685848474502563,
0.34680426120758057,
-0.658214271068573,
-0.3127247393131256,
0.20603470504283905,
0.24387185275554657,
-0.4075738489627838,
-0.27582234144210815,
-0.6946227550506592,
0.007493134122341871,
0.2587822377681732,
-0.29430484771728516,
0.48757752776145935,
0.32504260540008545,
-0.0029005445539951324,
0.7543768882751465,
0.4438464343547821,
0.12276284396648407,
-0.040873441845178604,
-0.029414407908916473,
0.8464629650115967,
-0.6973330974578857,
-0.26678067445755005,
-0.8986557126045227,
0.0437832735478878,
0.20052970945835114,
-0.36587607860565186,
0.4705561697483063,
0.6732690334320068,
0.9688789248466492,
-0.010223125107586384,
0.7175599336624146,
0.25139686465263367,
0.7759373188018799,
-0.8757092356681824,
1.0042648315429688,
-0.7039985656738281,
0.2811679542064667,
0.06994345039129257,
-0.8615948557853699,
-0.28971222043037415,
0.23059701919555664,
-0.12272490561008453,
0.024215467274188995,
0.7909749150276184,
0.7256720066070557,
-0.23542478680610657,
0.08485043793916702,
0.6467128992080688,
0.26904359459877014,
0.1643366515636444,
0.7455562353134155,
0.5202037692070007,
-0.2409762740135193,
0.24071304500102997,
-0.5273985266685486,
-0.28799867630004883,
-0.008872495964169502,
-0.6098455190658569,
-1.0665745735168457,
-0.8388462066650391,
-0.2826947271823883,
0.007416548673063517,
0.30120179057121277,
0.9664368033409119,
0.8425013422966003,
-0.8376051783561707,
-0.22587448358535767,
0.06009509414434433,
0.003209587885066867,
-0.07807706296443939,
-0.10073116421699524,
0.39684227108955383,
-0.4989774525165558,
-0.6310160756111145,
0.39149224758148193,
0.4779311716556549,
0.07544681429862976,
-0.3304572105407715,
-0.051683876663446426,
-0.1433318704366684,
0.19925111532211304,
0.5600769519805908,
0.40319758653640747,
-0.6567950248718262,
-0.3020593225955963,
-0.10138103365898132,
0.08302031457424164,
0.0644475594162941,
0.7712134122848511,
-0.7179491519927979,
0.2458782196044922,
0.29224833846092224,
0.7584573030471802,
0.9234937429428101,
-0.25790002942085266,
0.6758694052696228,
-0.5697783827781677,
0.1002071276307106,
0.14995966851711273,
0.4560583829879761,
0.24911315739154816,
-0.299437016248703,
0.18640878796577454,
-0.016227692365646362,
-0.47885578870773315,
-0.6989616751670837,
0.17740440368652344,
-0.8089669346809387,
-0.17717203497886658,
1.118851900100708,
0.03782651945948601,
-0.16862019896507263,
-0.09614049643278122,
-0.2796785235404968,
0.25117725133895874,
-0.3856378197669983,
0.9734601378440857,
0.733811616897583,
-0.008666477166116238,
-0.27009764313697815,
-0.5573498010635376,
0.8119239211082458,
0.6202277541160583,
-0.6255879402160645,
0.2649420201778412,
0.2588036060333252,
0.6436394453048706,
-0.3724837303161621,
0.631438672542572,
0.13510824739933014,
0.10504106432199478,
-0.43348026275634766,
-0.09618251770734787,
-0.09694460779428482,
-0.442818820476532,
-0.3681495487689972,
0.18534010648727417,
0.2918246388435364,
0.0798104852437973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18963v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18963v1
|
RE-GrievanceAssist: Enhancing Customer Experience through ML-Powered Complaint Management
| 2024-04-29T07:03:23 | 2024-04-29T07:03:23 |
Venkatesh C, Harshit Oberoi, Anurag Kumar Pandey, Anil Goyal, Nikhil Sikka
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
In recent years, digital platform companies have faced increasing challenges
in managing customer complaints, driven by widespread consumer adoption. This
paper introduces an end-to-end pipeline, named RE-GrievanceAssist, designed
specifically for real estate customer complaint management. The pipeline
consists of three key components: i) response/no-response ML model using TF-IDF
vectorization and XGBoost classifier ; ii) user type classifier using fasttext
classifier; iii) issue/sub-issue classifier using TF-IDF vectorization and
XGBoost classifier. Finally, it has been deployed as a batch job in Databricks,
resulting in a remarkable 40% reduction in overall manual effort with monthly
cost reduction of Rs 1,50,000 since August 2023.
|
[
-0.48194488883018494,
-0.3491694927215576,
0.044661059975624084,
-0.005560307297855616,
-0.16899685561656952,
0.520178496837616,
0.25038301944732666,
-0.34215229749679565,
0.5836813449859619,
0.6942107677459717,
-0.6044341325759888,
-0.5881834030151367,
-0.31467193365097046,
-0.15419378876686096,
-0.605976402759552,
1.2933787107467651,
-0.3192494511604309,
-0.3427516520023346,
-0.1430141031742096,
-0.03561132401227951,
-0.419849157333374,
-0.4927847385406494,
-0.6787715554237366,
-0.3135237991809845,
0.6571592688560486,
0.23116247355937958,
0.664786696434021,
0.12893317639827728,
0.4791552424430847,
0.3770676553249359,
0.36897483468055725,
-0.0676804706454277,
-0.3368832767009735,
0.4073084592819214,
-0.19935400784015656,
-0.5347524881362915,
-0.14658983051776886,
-0.06790298968553543,
0.2910598814487457,
0.21128158271312714,
-0.36993980407714844,
0.4863281548023224,
-0.2898348569869995,
0.9387359619140625,
-0.9899324178695679,
0.07968389987945557,
-0.2950247824192047,
0.37466126680374146,
0.3244178891181946,
-0.16428564488887787,
-0.06833506375551224,
-0.2389712929725647,
-0.13440056145191193,
-0.42659586668014526,
0.4112681746482849,
0.19767460227012634,
1.1510103940963745,
0.7777154445648193,
-0.2161211520433426,
-0.2553129494190216,
-0.786691427230835,
0.5746914744377136,
-0.4304427206516266,
0.48929330706596375,
-0.1937161684036255,
0.9935123324394226,
-0.1820489913225174,
-1.1353967189788818,
-0.2194732278585434,
0.0563226044178009,
-0.20135360956192017,
0.14240548014640808,
-0.2972351908683777,
-0.10430293530225754,
0.14002040028572083,
0.554911732673645,
-0.5375434756278992,
-0.09716004133224487,
-0.24030406773090363,
-0.33443281054496765,
0.613174319267273,
0.6299731135368347,
-0.08342531323432922,
-0.3340323567390442,
-0.4119667708873749,
0.2042004019021988,
-0.275971382856369,
0.26193952560424805,
0.6269155144691467,
-0.028761833906173706,
0.3182964026927948,
0.18188628554344177,
-0.3773753046989441,
0.5223696231842041,
-0.08772115409374237,
0.020037785172462463,
0.1285540610551834,
0.05371641740202904,
-0.39510050415992737,
0.392024427652359,
0.4002489149570465,
0.3926093876361847,
0.12030979990959167,
-0.23926237225532532,
-0.6855759620666504,
0.5989146828651428,
0.5818525552749634,
-0.9269218444824219,
-0.5592154860496521,
0.6648289561271667,
-0.48092833161354065,
-0.4906498193740845,
0.1895635426044464,
-1.0425819158554077,
-0.5002620220184326,
-0.4945885241031647,
-0.15302850306034088,
0.1781989485025406,
-0.5157765746116638,
0.013743028976023197,
-0.2056637704372406,
0.24358578026294708,
0.5121290683746338,
-0.3819552958011627,
0.40318092703819275,
0.9478297829627991,
0.6032196879386902,
0.18631669878959656,
0.009808216243982315,
-0.6043906211853027,
0.007736937142908573,
-0.23602136969566345,
1.0843480825424194,
-0.645892858505249,
-0.3154570758342743,
0.1730876863002777,
-0.03138849884271622,
0.13415807485580444,
-0.9637288451194763,
0.5256332755088806,
-0.31341397762298584,
0.3720552921295166,
0.18013997375965118,
-0.3671419620513916,
-0.2259615659713745,
0.8608852624893188,
-0.26527437567710876,
0.9612908959388733,
0.7391127943992615,
-0.2655515968799591,
0.5226783752441406,
-0.6155612468719482,
0.06145693361759186,
0.33664315938949585,
-0.15334664285182953,
-0.6484189629554749,
0.2511328458786011,
0.2592053711414337,
0.3705177903175354,
-0.36328765749931335,
0.08594828844070435,
0.008848688565194607,
-0.5226837396621704,
-0.17592734098434448,
0.07857267558574677,
0.49384817481040955,
0.5478594899177551,
-0.2409062683582306,
0.10937223583459854,
-0.8588051795959473,
-0.09796591848134995,
0.09927503764629364,
-0.19797265529632568,
0.040917281061410904,
-0.2979930341243744,
-0.012364381924271584,
0.46529248356819153,
0.3870994746685028,
-0.9544240236282349,
0.1682053804397583,
0.16565382480621338,
0.2544345557689667,
0.756629467010498,
-0.07141804695129395,
0.003146997420117259,
-0.48516157269477844,
0.8855037093162537,
0.14670155942440033,
0.34449291229248047,
-0.14929302036762238,
-0.25573989748954773,
-0.7411659955978394,
-0.5673335790634155,
0.23919428884983063,
0.5650469660758972,
-0.44234609603881836,
0.13197602331638336,
-0.5221738219261169,
-0.7496073842048645,
-0.6906078457832336,
0.13296455144882202,
0.09335021674633026,
0.3329719305038452,
0.0496378056704998,
-0.22626705467700958,
-0.5833067297935486,
-0.7269639372825623,
-0.5422990322113037,
-0.3308127224445343,
-0.15002958476543427,
0.485321044921875,
0.025448068976402283,
-0.5948905944824219,
1.2428373098373413,
-0.6483269929885864,
-0.5306581854820251,
0.08559811115264893,
0.3488720953464508,
0.32630422711372375,
-0.09079529345035553,
0.7399888038635254,
-0.7617140412330627,
-0.5812655091285706,
0.17635387182235718,
-0.9187087416648865,
-0.5033190250396729,
-0.2694944739341736,
0.28072524070739746,
0.49033093452453613,
0.4005785882472992,
-0.5136559009552002,
0.5603317618370056,
0.2765653729438782,
-0.44852620363235474,
0.8417595028877258,
0.13318182528018951,
0.42927467823028564,
-1.0967662334442139,
-0.07613436877727509,
0.36900246143341064,
-0.4491802752017975,
-0.5098792910575867,
0.09839169681072235,
-0.3401920199394226,
-0.4189853072166443,
-0.3831509053707123,
0.1610969454050064,
-0.3056914508342743,
-0.42431649565696716,
-0.35767242312431335,
-0.12252674996852875,
0.0023713288828730583,
0.8874672651290894,
-0.14489077031612396,
0.6201657056808472,
0.24716578423976898,
-0.6461383700370789,
0.8902631998062134,
0.21043682098388672,
-0.28376781940460205,
0.5960615873336792,
-0.46870166063308716,
0.09471265226602554,
-0.37064841389656067,
0.33201539516448975,
-1.3597921133041382,
0.07690133899450302,
0.5875352621078491,
-0.41444629430770874,
0.06700249016284943,
-0.2648591995239258,
-0.38354289531707764,
-0.5186396241188049,
-0.3414880633354187,
0.026490096002817154,
0.5467634201049805,
-0.9253531694412231,
1.1460936069488525,
0.009298931807279587,
-0.1642947793006897,
-0.5431766510009766,
-0.5828217267990112,
0.46976906061172485,
-0.25898152589797974,
-0.5771752595901489,
0.18516108393669128,
0.31337398290634155,
-0.30799400806427,
0.01195619348436594,
-0.08823273330926895,
0.0267851073294878,
-0.2006538212299347,
0.40914639830589294,
-0.22379866242408752,
-0.00731368362903595,
0.007175610400736332,
-0.15905068814754486,
-0.6166352033615112,
0.434185653924942,
-0.005719988606870174,
0.43494224548339844,
-0.09049871563911438,
-0.5049350261688232,
-0.518122136592865,
0.2603831887245178,
1.0563876628875732,
0.13828298449516296,
0.2238616943359375,
0.6470489501953125,
-0.37548133730888367,
0.3570363521575928,
-0.7755405902862549,
-0.10926801711320877,
-0.5091729760169983,
0.38855499029159546,
-0.3073110580444336,
-0.8510284423828125,
0.9111746549606323,
-0.869935154914856,
0.6471369862556458,
0.030324388295412064,
0.46523162722587585,
0.08356200903654099,
0.7404718399047852,
0.28876885771751404,
-0.24367354810237885,
0.609406054019928,
-0.13161171972751617,
0.874607503414154,
-0.4987701177597046,
-0.5115401148796082,
-0.7080783843994141,
-0.6448836922645569,
-0.5699185132980347,
0.22994455695152283,
0.0868082195520401,
-0.06321291625499725,
-0.2904020845890045,
0.5313248038291931,
-0.5836318135261536,
-0.038025856018066406,
0.044340912252664566,
0.06220399588346481,
0.06420066207647324,
0.0961194783449173,
0.36313310265541077,
-0.2737859785556793,
-0.5966874957084656,
-0.32931017875671387,
0.48141682147979736,
0.7244793176651001,
0.7931234240531921,
0.5596581697463989,
0.7861574292182922,
0.6291671395301819,
0.48197486996650696,
-1.0679970979690552,
0.5343485474586487,
0.02145584300160408,
-0.2798818051815033,
0.051286809146404266,
-0.3293178677558899,
-0.6983617544174194,
0.2589775323867798,
-0.1338171809911728,
-0.6660576462745667,
0.5456016063690186,
-0.05623861029744148,
-0.3210009038448334,
0.5247498154640198,
-0.7812322378158569,
0.5709843635559082,
0.2953801453113556,
-0.3515324592590332,
-0.2643399238586426,
-0.10396324098110199,
0.23769515752792358,
-0.19530324637889862,
0.21194162964820862,
-0.20342054963111877,
-0.018488338217139244,
0.701261579990387,
-0.9830537438392639,
0.5388078093528748,
-0.6522011756896973,
-0.20326165854930878,
0.4615357220172882,
0.07456884533166885,
0.8798632621765137,
0.013470719568431377,
0.14376236498355865,
0.2496815025806427,
-0.08758868277072906,
-0.5059985518455505,
-0.8605297207832336,
0.6931188702583313,
-0.6409475207328796,
-0.6608213782310486,
-0.25584009289741516,
-0.2434956282377243,
-0.00033894923399202526,
-0.2759194076061249,
0.05589074641466141,
0.26974907517433167,
0.09026451408863068,
0.08077379316091537,
0.3757815361022949,
0.057465311139822006,
0.6816362142562866,
0.5211450457572937,
-0.6777816414833069,
-0.4162800908088684,
1.242240071296692,
-0.028583239763975143,
-0.3141089081764221,
0.21517525613307953,
0.1363421529531479,
-0.47616252303123474,
-0.09309174120426178,
-0.2596736550331116,
-0.20694772899150848,
-0.6744346618652344,
-0.5332896709442139,
-0.9537140130996704,
0.04372324422001839,
-0.436641663312912,
-0.33052268624305725,
-0.6794115900993347,
-0.2235102504491806,
-0.07305654138326645,
0.023760994896292686,
0.19876453280448914,
0.6681181192398071,
0.17373231053352356,
0.5769124031066895,
-1.0992083549499512,
0.43802279233932495,
0.6031463146209717,
0.2646985948085785,
-0.3097379207611084,
-0.7408504486083984,
-0.4211888611316681,
-0.2181391417980194,
-0.20513570308685303,
-0.38526415824890137,
0.7579740881919861,
-0.10334401577711105,
0.5218768119812012,
0.5837684869766235,
0.3035096228122711,
0.49766987562179565,
0.0343230664730072,
1.1146818399429321,
0.37236911058425903,
-0.5659237504005432,
0.2554982602596283,
-0.2597924470901489,
0.16803427040576935,
0.44925764203071594,
0.17842046916484833,
-0.7130178213119507,
-0.20404139161109924,
-0.5624101161956787,
-0.9086586236953735,
0.1988847702741623,
-0.19222091138362885,
0.11338096857070923,
-0.02757379040122032,
0.4126572608947754,
0.0677165612578392,
0.4542471170425415,
-0.026014765724539757,
-0.3410434126853943,
-0.39409253001213074,
0.2772623598575592,
0.4280220866203308,
-0.5054930448532104,
0.03628155216574669,
-0.252002090215683,
0.8709641695022583,
-0.04397844150662422,
0.3008759915828705,
-0.07773350179195404,
0.030327120795845985,
-0.14916452765464783,
0.44648459553718567,
0.5145561099052429,
0.6577995419502258,
-0.463948130607605,
-0.42254242300987244,
-0.08734209835529327,
-0.2711232602596283,
0.3757581412792206,
-0.02847602218389511,
0.3681514263153076,
0.5295528769493103,
-0.16411203145980835,
0.6436432600021362,
-0.044380415230989456,
-0.1724603921175003,
0.3778825104236603,
-0.34228596091270447,
-0.6505573987960815,
-0.5511295199394226,
-0.3211457133293152,
-0.37758222222328186,
0.3254510164260864,
0.602723240852356,
0.13140812516212463,
0.2474907785654068,
-0.387127161026001,
0.3018221855163574,
-0.07972054183483124,
-0.7573390603065491,
0.1613672524690628,
0.27561935782432556,
0.35305315256118774,
-0.6058713793754578,
0.879677951335907,
0.00432177260518074,
-0.5862177014350891,
0.35528430342674255,
0.19783979654312134,
1.3171460628509521,
-0.11446791887283325,
0.23234136402606964,
0.0645882785320282,
0.15370987355709076,
0.3539741039276123,
0.05700542405247688,
0.2555364668369293,
-0.6739993095397949,
-0.5265222787857056,
-0.35384267568588257,
-0.5181916356086731,
-0.15333156287670135,
-0.8338045477867126,
0.18821193277835846,
-1.1317590475082397,
-0.18125471472740173,
-0.3231317102909088,
0.19488586485385895,
-0.36790651082992554,
0.3385714888572693,
-0.2169785052537918,
1.026787519454956,
-0.7972010970115662,
0.18169809877872467,
0.9813307523727417,
-0.1119026243686676,
-0.3502753973007202,
-0.10355255007743835,
-0.2537645697593689,
-0.6261114478111267,
0.8571196794509888,
0.21726901829242706,
-0.09356524795293808,
-0.08957409858703613,
-0.5092261433601379,
-0.0636574998497963,
1.1187796592712402,
0.49592143297195435,
-0.8759407997131348,
0.7317923903465271,
0.18272502720355988,
0.6672598719596863,
-0.3042868673801422,
0.25924527645111084,
0.5349923372268677,
0.487727552652359,
0.208469957113266,
-0.2604122757911682,
-0.17655694484710693,
-0.5432108640670776,
-0.041177403181791306,
0.64002525806427,
-0.9066343307495117,
0.4495725631713867,
0.19022108614444733,
0.057877447456121445,
-0.2923291325569153,
0.7850192785263062,
-0.03350083902478218,
0.448229044675827,
0.6477396488189697,
1.033530354499817,
0.630309522151947,
-0.3954763114452362,
0.9010437726974487,
-0.617845892906189,
0.5646471381187439,
0.7887353897094727,
-0.14823640882968903,
0.35877034068107605,
0.7835418581962585,
-0.4954772889614105,
0.7984850406646729,
0.8276633620262146,
0.001152464421465993,
0.3717607855796814,
0.6810173988342285,
-0.7227877378463745,
-0.5402705073356628,
-0.7358474135398865,
-0.4113871455192566,
0.28899481892585754,
0.3492377698421478,
-0.06409520655870438,
-0.4891940653324127,
-0.20266030728816986,
-0.27894386649131775,
0.07480735331773758,
-0.3583747148513794,
0.8164738416671753,
-0.00026117044035345316,
-0.04836743697524071,
0.3763147294521332,
-0.07764071971178055,
0.8459926843643188,
-0.5141141414642334,
-0.3022429049015045,
-0.3818456828594208,
0.2331060916185379,
-0.6710001826286316,
-0.7143028378486633,
0.5485909581184387,
-0.3149769902229309,
-0.3721950948238373,
-0.20896393060684204,
0.8101062178611755,
-0.028887150809168816,
-0.279601514339447,
0.3376604914665222,
-0.039154645055532455,
0.47742563486099243,
-0.5546183586120605,
-0.961814820766449,
0.03651881963014603,
-0.0431332103908062,
-0.2605334520339966,
0.39862415194511414,
0.4361385107040405,
-0.09437673538923264,
0.9206666946411133,
0.6142902374267578,
-0.2555701434612274,
-0.0727914497256279,
0.24633294343948364,
1.1750757694244385,
-0.5682917237281799,
-0.418705016374588,
-0.4248306155204773,
0.4873546361923218,
-0.18743552267551422,
-0.16671663522720337,
0.1443716436624527,
0.49461811780929565,
0.536461353302002,
-0.10576902329921722,
0.8125677108764648,
0.17852187156677246,
0.614608108997345,
-0.008971557021141052,
0.3317565321922302,
-0.389132559299469,
0.3706541061401367,
-0.23293960094451904,
-1.2183549404144287,
-0.2580890953540802,
0.38283222913742065,
-0.30589935183525085,
0.22785112261772156,
0.440848708152771,
0.887750506401062,
0.3107008635997772,
0.16487951576709747,
0.6463301777839661,
-0.36728963255882263,
0.716156005859375,
0.47479918599128723,
0.7174134850502014,
-0.885200560092926,
0.6656169891357422,
-0.019224554300308228,
-0.014063437469303608,
-0.3801366090774536,
-0.7841336727142334,
-0.5691540837287903,
0.15982162952423096,
-0.8309717178344727,
-0.5452187657356262,
0.04343797639012337,
0.9569803476333618,
0.3692776560783386,
-1.1576120853424072,
0.02932785637676716,
-0.13132110238075256,
0.11232700943946838,
-0.2791331112384796,
-0.30824679136276245,
0.05398707091808319,
-0.5904417634010315,
-0.5911133289337158,
-0.20777527987957,
0.4294568598270416,
-0.25088757276535034,
-0.6243314146995544,
-0.3032597005367279,
0.10341515392065048,
-0.40759381651878357,
0.42743968963623047,
0.4449259638786316,
-0.49791738390922546,
-0.296098917722702,
-0.4401966631412506,
-0.027693359181284904,
-0.031715232878923416,
1.1472665071487427,
-0.9459031224250793,
0.10930214822292328,
0.5996602773666382,
1.0860471725463867,
0.3360435962677002,
0.007523328065872192,
0.6497091054916382,
-0.8423749208450317,
0.1553441286087036,
-0.09730732440948486,
0.6052538752555847,
0.23160599172115326,
-1.0679545402526855,
0.5879814624786377,
0.5503239631652832,
-0.4672015309333801,
-0.33450576663017273,
0.08960598707199097,
-0.6396839022636414,
-0.285268098115921,
0.7752693295478821,
-0.38027510046958923,
-0.20300352573394775,
-0.5906012654304504,
-0.38467174768447876,
0.11553337424993515,
-0.8726255297660828,
1.0535292625427246,
0.5279541611671448,
-0.20095397531986237,
-0.7102137804031372,
-0.25857529044151306,
0.15445281565189362,
0.6934777498245239,
-0.6800705194473267,
0.24155274033546448,
0.6227951049804688,
0.036566946655511856,
0.5239609479904175,
0.32534345984458923,
-0.09408757835626602,
0.2246597409248352,
0.162839874625206,
0.23155300319194794,
-0.5768259763717651,
-0.443024605512619,
-0.27062544226646423,
0.4090879559516907,
-0.31428322196006775,
-0.6215885281562805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18460v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18460v1
|
Ethical Reasoning and Moral Value Alignment of LLMs Depend on the Language we Prompt them in
| 2024-04-29T06:42:27 | 2024-04-29T06:42:27 |
Utkarsh Agarwal, Kumar Tanmay, Aditi Khandelwal, Monojit Choudhury
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Ethical reasoning is a crucial skill for Large Language Models (LLMs).
However, moral values are not universal, but rather influenced by language and
culture. This paper explores how three prominent LLMs -- GPT-4, ChatGPT, and
Llama2-70B-Chat -- perform ethical reasoning in different languages and if
their moral judgement depend on the language in which they are prompted. We
extend the study of ethical reasoning of LLMs by Rao et al. (2023) to a
multilingual setup following their framework of probing LLMs with ethical
dilemmas and policies from three branches of normative ethics: deontology,
virtue, and consequentialism. We experiment with six languages: English,
Spanish, Russian, Chinese, Hindi, and Swahili. We find that GPT-4 is the most
consistent and unbiased ethical reasoner across languages, while ChatGPT and
Llama2-70B-Chat show significant moral value bias when we move to languages
other than English. Interestingly, the nature of this bias significantly vary
across languages for all LLMs, including GPT-4.
|
[
-0.010931884869933128,
-0.4707975685596466,
0.9475164413452148,
0.2316124588251114,
-0.39686504006385803,
0.1548743098974228,
-0.18112696707248688,
-0.739555299282074,
-0.19819511473178864,
0.5549669861793518,
-0.28801390528678894,
-0.23839597404003143,
-0.5494505167007446,
0.2891269028186798,
0.5602070689201355,
0.9291852116584778,
0.0365072563290596,
0.7728924751281738,
0.09628607332706451,
-0.6840386986732483,
-0.26745790243148804,
-0.8531034588813782,
-0.8321185111999512,
-0.5426390171051025,
0.541047990322113,
0.2631610333919525,
0.9118531346321106,
0.4026429355144501,
0.4707515835762024,
0.2570154070854187,
-0.1294003129005432,
-0.019790057092905045,
-0.41797876358032227,
0.0609348900616169,
-0.5704700946807861,
-0.547446608543396,
-0.16862452030181885,
0.34050318598747253,
0.22813186049461365,
0.24545927345752716,
-0.12011498957872391,
0.10433273762464523,
-0.15949676930904388,
0.5611134767532349,
-0.30644479393959045,
-0.00795117300003767,
-0.6148437261581421,
-0.11797193437814713,
-0.07623796164989471,
-0.34745100140571594,
-0.16557271778583527,
-0.8877834677696228,
0.08074109256267548,
-0.33094626665115356,
-0.485419362783432,
-0.16764779388904572,
0.9591449499130249,
0.309391587972641,
-0.6501855850219727,
-0.5231359004974365,
-0.2909310460090637,
1.250854253768921,
-0.6590838432312012,
0.4995046854019165,
0.5561198592185974,
0.0037903841584920883,
0.10168168693780899,
-0.2666921019554138,
-0.48425641655921936,
-0.04760519415140152,
-0.05816639959812164,
-0.04701321944594383,
0.11966312676668167,
0.05844222754240036,
0.0350903756916523,
0.1797272115945816,
-0.0943496823310852,
0.4220254123210907,
-0.24398021399974823,
-0.0809982419013977,
0.487209290266037,
-0.1091821938753128,
0.2897454798221588,
-0.178275927901268,
-0.27202108502388,
0.11154032498598099,
-1.0309146642684937,
0.4275263845920563,
0.9003714323043823,
-0.03830982744693756,
-0.14697931706905365,
0.31684160232543945,
0.4129149615764618,
0.4514230489730835,
-0.05001797154545784,
-0.3397810757160187,
0.1131921038031578,
-0.488065630197525,
-0.02698344923555851,
0.15353183448314667,
0.8909041881561279,
0.8452345132827759,
0.896034300327301,
0.4603537321090698,
0.09628323465585709,
-0.04932650923728943,
-0.02671540342271328,
-0.5789946913719177,
0.14072701334953308,
0.2829029858112335,
-0.44753003120422363,
-0.38028261065483093,
-0.322133332490921,
-0.3261086642742157,
-0.2673249840736389,
-0.3617476522922516,
-0.014474036172032356,
-0.44751060009002686,
-0.19537293910980225,
0.4439276158809662,
0.11678871512413025,
0.7738454341888428,
0.4867781400680542,
-0.7802205085754395,
-0.28903651237487793,
0.7106720209121704,
0.43162402510643005,
0.13669566810131073,
-0.195275217294693,
-0.5581586360931396,
0.27309656143188477,
-0.5050134062767029,
0.6523903012275696,
-0.9834498167037964,
-0.2953139841556549,
-0.09670905023813248,
0.1819370687007904,
0.31285667419433594,
0.027475431561470032,
0.9754456281661987,
-0.3779555857181549,
0.40428417921066284,
-0.800388514995575,
-0.30188220739364624,
-0.5975211262702942,
0.33971065282821655,
-0.32086485624313354,
0.5864119529724121,
-0.3250479996204376,
-0.6102166175842285,
0.4513542354106903,
-0.4140150845050812,
-0.42325305938720703,
0.25086405873298645,
-0.6451104879379272,
-0.1756868064403534,
-0.14683644473552704,
0.09827350080013275,
0.49991267919540405,
-0.5127937197685242,
0.4735913574695587,
-0.22405906021595,
-0.4427318274974823,
0.28416135907173157,
-0.6331336498260498,
1.3067052364349365,
0.2246771603822708,
-0.35112088918685913,
-0.1968831866979599,
-0.3977225124835968,
0.23617057502269745,
0.16243021190166473,
-0.331833153963089,
-0.4402492046356201,
0.1929798275232315,
-0.13655497133731842,
0.3225913941860199,
0.20501087605953217,
-0.49851319193840027,
-0.08424223959445953,
-0.1405045986175537,
0.8043361902236938,
0.9355486631393433,
0.054980479180812836,
0.22428230941295624,
-0.3798166811466217,
0.49335676431655884,
-0.3134891986846924,
0.315399706363678,
0.2154160439968109,
-0.6848390102386475,
-0.5292080640792847,
-0.12581950426101685,
-0.16434454917907715,
0.87197345495224,
-0.2607506215572357,
-0.04521358758211136,
-0.028390249237418175,
-0.14964888989925385,
-0.7628145813941956,
-0.07197479158639908,
0.45549172163009644,
0.02731318213045597,
0.21545733511447906,
0.15639209747314453,
-0.2094654142856598,
-1.0745718479156494,
-0.5890330672264099,
-0.4319368302822113,
0.2713066339492798,
0.31558758020401,
0.383697509765625,
0.14043787121772766,
0.34741705656051636,
0.06996116042137146,
0.049216266721487045,
-0.18721677362918854,
-0.2266833782196045,
0.4349289834499359,
0.35860133171081543,
0.6429787874221802,
-0.8120097517967224,
-0.38154318928718567,
0.2732696831226349,
-0.7906263470649719,
-0.23847529292106628,
-0.1793408989906311,
-0.2280176430940628,
0.2633952498435974,
0.26962271332740784,
-0.35229721665382385,
0.06647155433893204,
0.7561768889427185,
-0.3756542205810547,
0.40914463996887207,
-0.08859554678201675,
0.5442754626274109,
-1.0299288034439087,
-0.34178662300109863,
-0.27181312441825867,
-0.12690836191177368,
-0.3811391592025757,
-0.051162239164114,
0.04459121823310852,
0.3679038882255554,
-0.6872704029083252,
0.6738861203193665,
-0.5270369052886963,
0.04452986270189285,
0.09628769755363464,
0.08460603654384613,
0.13037776947021484,
0.14627161622047424,
0.09515935927629471,
0.8404737710952759,
0.4868207275867462,
-0.4468867778778076,
0.41790011525154114,
0.3797461688518524,
-0.1504465490579605,
0.9836645126342773,
-0.655906081199646,
0.11595400422811508,
0.02451443299651146,
0.22363516688346863,
-0.40453946590423584,
-0.04740558937191963,
0.3363927900791168,
-0.38734304904937744,
-0.13353480398654938,
-0.6044467091560364,
-0.4342814087867737,
0.10179605334997177,
-0.4808099567890167,
0.5559285283088684,
0.5523051619529724,
-0.44591888785362244,
0.3816797137260437,
0.4210817813873291,
-0.12117026746273041,
-1.1544688940048218,
-0.8621841669082642,
0.06312377005815506,
-0.49640512466430664,
-0.7877824306488037,
-0.18858082592487335,
-0.007776316720992327,
-0.8292121291160583,
-0.184703066945076,
0.013564275577664375,
0.049404438585042953,
-0.02994372881948948,
0.02029016800224781,
0.24825915694236755,
-0.09789164364337921,
0.11534471064805984,
0.15638969838619232,
0.06213142350316048,
0.08320338279008865,
-0.3447066843509674,
0.29810643196105957,
-0.8433010578155518,
-0.5219568014144897,
-0.11851819604635239,
0.4319361448287964,
0.6353219747543335,
-0.45050013065338135,
0.7028364539146423,
0.2913190424442291,
-0.19289608299732208,
0.32146966457366943,
-1.021344780921936,
0.037667203694581985,
-0.5042154788970947,
-0.11677321791648865,
-0.24816001951694489,
-1.133545160293579,
0.5476796627044678,
0.40094202756881714,
0.22520722448825836,
0.21932265162467957,
0.8228229284286499,
-0.19207078218460083,
0.7798296213150024,
0.31130194664001465,
0.25561246275901794,
0.1575917750597,
0.03274853155016899,
0.4424990713596344,
-0.7140263915061951,
-0.10383763909339905,
-0.41691854596138,
0.03409697487950325,
-1.1318076848983765,
-0.5637342929840088,
0.32981863617897034,
0.16494204103946686,
-0.44691312313079834,
-0.11973797529935837,
-0.41499271988868713,
1.0692611932754517,
0.18501698970794678,
-0.2859303057193756,
0.6100640296936035,
-0.15856823325157166,
-0.21443937718868256,
0.010740984231233597,
-0.3720458149909973,
-1.1040972471237183,
0.6539736390113831,
0.31275537610054016,
0.5994713306427002,
0.3814477324485779,
0.510395884513855,
-0.2579904794692993,
0.06573478132486343,
-0.5865457653999329,
0.47002264857292175,
-0.23972992599010468,
-0.6553317308425903,
-0.1725361943244934,
-0.2425006777048111,
-0.9879793524742126,
0.41118085384368896,
0.1544537991285324,
-0.7715662717819214,
0.25014182925224304,
-0.14476877450942993,
-0.22371824085712433,
0.43736281991004944,
-0.5684370994567871,
0.5375877618789673,
-0.7936950922012329,
-0.4847365617752075,
-0.3051789700984955,
-0.9735389947891235,
0.3575100302696228,
0.07860854268074036,
0.4967273473739624,
-0.5871739387512207,
-0.10828499495983124,
0.4056815505027771,
-0.10383555293083191,
0.6960927248001099,
0.2396990805864334,
-0.5820158123970032,
0.24127976596355438,
0.12490938603878021,
0.34394022822380066,
0.6197865605354309,
-0.32727235555648804,
0.6595721244812012,
0.32830727100372314,
-0.3083292841911316,
-0.06770670413970947,
0.8425101041793823,
-0.7621351480484009,
-0.9419889450073242,
-0.6572898626327515,
-0.5205672383308411,
-0.36131876707077026,
0.30537810921669006,
0.32024073600769043,
-0.01592942140996456,
-0.08630304038524628,
0.1673610508441925,
0.52979576587677,
-0.624171257019043,
0.24967694282531738,
0.6491807699203491,
-0.04787536710500717,
-0.2406698316335678,
0.451569527387619,
-0.05697241052985191,
0.6063417196273804,
0.18623612821102142,
0.4664660394191742,
-0.4506303369998932,
-0.14524424076080322,
-0.637259840965271,
0.6178662776947021,
-1.1194217205047607,
-0.08285516500473022,
-0.6057121157646179,
-0.06638358533382416,
0.07342024147510529,
-0.8363163471221924,
-0.2998616099357605,
-0.23210279643535614,
-0.06345637142658234,
-0.28187739849090576,
0.7091933488845825,
0.6025866270065308,
-0.20508873462677002,
-0.21391671895980835,
-1.0484740734100342,
0.0165423434227705,
0.2673078775405884,
0.44210678339004517,
-0.47179844975471497,
-0.21097208559513092,
0.5082055330276489,
0.3056439161300659,
-0.07747354358434677,
-0.8444387912750244,
-0.16939498484134674,
-0.04629797115921974,
0.7202379703521729,
0.32657939195632935,
-0.30690157413482666,
0.39032432436943054,
-0.6044811010360718,
0.8151764869689941,
0.12149420380592346,
-0.864427387714386,
0.3552650511264801,
-0.7453076243400574,
-0.02372830919921398,
0.5803256630897522,
0.5512005090713501,
-0.7213122248649597,
-0.6738807559013367,
-0.548234224319458,
-0.3959798812866211,
0.6001850962638855,
0.3330976068973541,
0.4419248402118683,
-0.25648894906044006,
0.26701247692108154,
0.26130425930023193,
0.03426924720406532,
-0.9852454662322998,
0.05670439079403877,
-0.2348812371492386,
-0.03776497766375542,
0.18833968043327332,
-0.18083253502845764,
-0.33764857053756714,
-0.1404968798160553,
0.3511999845504761,
-0.03806678578257561,
-0.005713413003832102,
0.0011486756848171353,
0.1116114929318428,
-0.16737134754657745,
0.6364115476608276,
0.6424934267997742,
0.8214734792709351,
0.07026290893554688,
0.10827384889125824,
0.3144529461860657,
-0.3589470684528351,
0.5235356092453003,
-0.23422947525978088,
0.041560735553503036,
-0.2732532024383545,
0.23005343973636627,
0.5474628210067749,
0.13966062664985657,
-0.4677076041698456,
0.5281949043273926,
-0.15827947854995728,
-0.06258810311555862,
-0.24251745641231537,
-0.2225608378648758,
0.35526400804519653,
0.3818681240081787,
-0.04370123893022537,
-0.2543167471885681,
-0.14478248357772827,
-0.6963648796081543,
-0.18579018115997314,
0.667420506477356,
0.016331003978848457,
-0.21750083565711975,
0.6514591574668884,
0.34297415614128113,
-0.09540095925331116,
0.5158436298370361,
-0.2897438406944275,
-0.7847127914428711,
0.5452659726142883,
0.19269655644893646,
0.6104178428649902,
-0.4314471185207367,
0.25307974219322205,
0.18682114779949188,
0.5871776938438416,
-0.21380391716957092,
0.6312646865844727,
0.28299158811569214,
-1.151313304901123,
-0.8394085764884949,
-0.5902808308601379,
-0.5548875331878662,
0.0017536564264446497,
-0.30923402309417725,
0.25809696316719055,
-0.2292848825454712,
-0.010655352845788002,
-0.2633100748062134,
-0.11207462847232819,
-0.5041899085044861,
-0.038525842130184174,
0.059714093804359436,
0.1278778314590454,
-0.36080577969551086,
0.725325882434845,
0.5784215927124023,
-0.33647990226745605,
-0.8394465446472168,
-0.06205086410045624,
0.20484155416488647,
-1.256966233253479,
0.6805827617645264,
0.11887140572071075,
-0.6665237545967102,
-0.00979392696171999,
-0.4718649685382843,
-0.7598667144775391,
0.839940071105957,
0.6133137941360474,
-0.33542880415916443,
0.21682588756084442,
0.17762014269828796,
0.4606695771217346,
-0.14872483909130096,
0.18259941041469574,
0.5365400910377502,
0.8283625841140747,
-0.06790869683027267,
-1.1719247102737427,
-0.08091000467538834,
0.00893331691622734,
-0.18408383429050446,
0.3476152718067169,
-0.8268349766731262,
0.7134180665016174,
-0.5526259541511536,
-0.05580084025859833,
-0.2640934884548187,
-0.010037114843726158,
0.6309418082237244,
-0.03886178508400917,
0.2815874516963959,
0.23686151206493378,
0.7612831592559814,
-0.11822663247585297,
1.0290535688400269,
-0.3565632104873657,
0.16492435336112976,
0.6628766655921936,
-0.3929249048233032,
0.2747482359409332,
0.5479548573493958,
-0.07015662640333176,
0.41660794615745544,
0.6553998589515686,
-0.11188077926635742,
0.15494035184383392,
0.03176121786236763,
-0.04457688704133034,
-0.2846296727657318,
-0.4047728180885315,
-0.4072079062461853,
0.7009398341178894,
0.4368283748626709,
-0.08825729787349701,
0.06344463676214218,
-0.21408069133758545,
0.5882098078727722,
-0.17273299396038055,
-0.33794283866882324,
0.45129984617233276,
0.3790615499019623,
-0.6048707962036133,
0.6301325559616089,
0.012287124991416931,
0.5368148684501648,
-0.5163019895553589,
-0.10015933960676193,
-0.13024920225143433,
0.0018263445235788822,
-0.27629926800727844,
-1.297524333000183,
0.12985199689865112,
0.2426140457391739,
0.34060347080230713,
-0.5963195562362671,
0.46457239985466003,
-0.3446410894393921,
-0.38993731141090393,
0.4622194170951843,
0.6906194090843201,
0.30945974588394165,
0.30721166729927063,
-0.6768248677253723,
-0.02101053111255169,
0.23478592932224274,
-0.31923118233680725,
0.2017800211906433,
0.707478940486908,
-0.5138314962387085,
0.74652099609375,
0.8753504157066345,
0.07288019359111786,
-0.0902770534157753,
0.25930818915367126,
0.3834743797779083,
-0.5720275044441223,
-0.40722861886024475,
-1.094436764717102,
0.2919190227985382,
0.07034943997859955,
-0.35189008712768555,
0.5660569667816162,
0.19087430834770203,
0.8498771786689758,
0.18618828058242798,
0.6382765769958496,
0.10442359745502472,
-0.0467238686978817,
-0.9854953289031982,
0.683936357498169,
-0.49368199706077576,
0.379360556602478,
-0.22298160195350647,
-0.7938335537910461,
-0.06827966123819351,
1.002197027206421,
-0.4877472519874573,
0.380124032497406,
0.9110541939735413,
0.3803245425224304,
0.2789904773235321,
0.29283615946769714,
0.3451164662837982,
-0.013975689187645912,
0.4862837493419647,
0.5772553086280823,
1.1853152513504028,
-0.009028335101902485,
0.4945460259914398,
-0.10445854812860489,
-0.014928536489605904,
0.17467786371707916,
-1.2803884744644165,
-0.7141660451889038,
-0.32818543910980225,
-0.03965255618095398,
-0.18039368093013763,
-0.02771366387605667,
0.9407590627670288,
0.34078654646873474,
-0.543842613697052,
-0.2748899757862091,
0.05664999783039093,
0.3564472496509552,
0.0030270784627646208,
-0.1889466941356659,
0.2382735162973404,
-0.1320151686668396,
-0.663847029209137,
0.18457408249378204,
0.5839220881462097,
0.04222147539258003,
-0.028662262484431267,
-0.13266775012016296,
-0.265531063079834,
0.42599934339523315,
0.601719319820404,
0.014940512366592884,
-1.1674273014068604,
-0.750413715839386,
0.020070184022188187,
-0.2339400202035904,
0.2500692903995514,
0.7427676320075989,
-0.11060348153114319,
0.08143260329961777,
0.3012676537036896,
0.43702444434165955,
-0.16197487711906433,
-0.0872545838356018,
0.7651276588439941,
-0.2724255323410034,
0.23481133580207825,
0.6175704598426819,
0.6667959094047546,
0.4389481842517853,
-0.5632110834121704,
0.8321095705032349,
-0.022614307701587677,
-0.9294467568397522,
-0.5873519778251648,
0.5975725650787354,
-0.8903101682662964,
-0.2541653513908386,
1.6076703071594238,
0.06486278772354126,
0.2656032145023346,
-0.3711616098880768,
-0.33365920186042786,
-0.0772179663181305,
-0.2870534658432007,
0.30782899260520935,
1.0432473421096802,
-0.26250383257865906,
-0.26106417179107666,
-0.8927246928215027,
0.6358009576797485,
0.4860789477825165,
-0.7437323927879333,
0.07705622911453247,
0.5474802255630493,
0.4532611668109894,
-0.13372042775154114,
0.821288526058197,
-0.5200228691101074,
0.39788031578063965,
-0.53045654296875,
-0.040950097143650055,
0.23276644945144653,
0.15367300808429718,
-0.14864736795425415,
-0.42145082354545593,
0.04740569368004799,
0.2490205317735672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18443v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18443v1
|
BMRetriever: Tuning Large Language Models as Better Biomedical Text Retrievers
| 2024-04-29T05:40:08 | 2024-04-29T05:40:08 |
Ran Xu, Wenqi Shi, Yue Yu, Yuchen Zhuang, Yanqiao Zhu, May D. Wang, Joyce C. Ho, Chao Zhang, Carl Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, q-bio.QM
|
Developing effective biomedical retrieval models is important for excelling
at knowledge-intensive biomedical tasks but still challenging due to the
deficiency of sufficient publicly annotated biomedical data and computational
resources. We present BMRetriever, a series of dense retrievers for enhancing
biomedical retrieval via unsupervised pre-training on large biomedical corpora,
followed by instruction fine-tuning on a combination of labeled datasets and
synthetic pairs. Experiments on 5 biomedical tasks across 11 datasets verify
BMRetriever's efficacy on various biomedical applications. BMRetriever also
exhibits strong parameter efficiency, with the 410M variant outperforming
baselines up to 11.7 times larger, and the 2B variant matching the performance
of models with over 5B parameters. The training data and model checkpoints are
released at \url{https://huggingface.co/BMRetriever} to ensure transparency,
reproducibility, and application to new domains.
|
[
-0.08472137898206711,
-0.7445489764213562,
0.5275608897209167,
0.29127636551856995,
-0.17783798277378082,
0.10166984051465988,
-0.5508729219436646,
-0.608316957950592,
-0.013033989816904068,
0.6169734597206116,
-0.2573646605014801,
-0.4671671986579895,
-0.8406417369842529,
0.253726601600647,
-0.3477016091346741,
0.9940956830978394,
0.24544893205165863,
0.3901467025279999,
-0.37604981660842896,
-0.1316334754228592,
-0.3605048954486847,
-0.4780741333961487,
-0.3825802505016327,
-0.6376901268959045,
0.7876317501068115,
0.41130727529525757,
0.7431108951568604,
0.5955767631530762,
1.0172959566116333,
0.26106542348861694,
-0.17706482112407684,
0.2548811435699463,
-0.9267948865890503,
0.427595317363739,
-0.7393593192100525,
-0.17781248688697815,
-0.1802332103252411,
-0.17623847723007202,
0.6758794188499451,
1.123673439025879,
-0.16987216472625732,
0.17511390149593353,
-0.14448824524879456,
0.8502435088157654,
-0.7950232028961182,
-0.18073441088199615,
-0.49446728825569153,
-0.23040379583835602,
-0.3299640417098999,
-0.3143176734447479,
-0.6784413456916809,
-0.39141419529914856,
0.25417569279670715,
-0.47232723236083984,
0.4768349528312683,
0.32195529341697693,
0.8474189639091492,
0.4201839566230774,
-0.37272265553474426,
-0.12028718739748001,
-0.7990896105766296,
0.7914237380027771,
-0.4079970121383667,
0.8266646265983582,
0.531843364238739,
0.3682248592376709,
-0.32503440976142883,
-1.0899370908737183,
-0.0278392992913723,
-0.09715437144041061,
-0.20136654376983643,
0.0661039724946022,
-0.45377540588378906,
0.23533616960048676,
0.3531650900840759,
0.35841047763824463,
-0.8537136316299438,
0.07326370477676392,
-0.4834108352661133,
-0.27850142121315,
0.5436177253723145,
0.020642796531319618,
0.13028301298618317,
0.07307392358779907,
-0.12461022287607193,
-0.2324603646993637,
-0.7684887647628784,
-0.44316190481185913,
-0.15264596045017242,
0.18682065606117249,
0.22995468974113464,
0.8693180680274963,
-0.3466654121875763,
0.7655467987060547,
0.010471890680491924,
0.17543372511863708,
0.40687042474746704,
-0.423629492521286,
-0.30719441175460815,
0.09669845551252365,
0.5322670340538025,
0.15219943225383759,
-0.09775849431753159,
-0.45286521315574646,
-0.27787119150161743,
-0.20944921672344208,
0.4894544780254364,
-1.422545075416565,
-0.47958123683929443,
0.3165537416934967,
-0.7468682527542114,
0.08349348604679108,
-0.12379271537065506,
-0.7915289998054504,
-0.3656665086746216,
-0.30594000220298767,
0.5049709677696228,
-0.6496061086654663,
-0.041278596967458725,
0.6273732781410217,
-0.3802412450313568,
-0.12171085923910141,
0.2196972668170929,
-0.6987325549125671,
0.1448492407798767,
0.5296791195869446,
0.770741879940033,
0.0015446944162249565,
-0.09107847511768341,
-0.9111706018447876,
0.4384106993675232,
-0.12933650612831116,
0.7334548234939575,
-0.8680500984191895,
-0.5747912526130676,
-0.23202843964099884,
0.17160961031913757,
-0.12885816395282745,
-0.7814793586730957,
0.4999243915081024,
-0.6387412548065186,
-0.12775428593158722,
-0.3853593170642853,
-0.7709556221961975,
-0.08636094629764557,
-0.01385539025068283,
-0.6285891532897949,
0.9127169251441956,
0.10276376456022263,
-0.7609953880310059,
0.3061360716819763,
-0.6289026141166687,
-0.5183103084564209,
0.37266799807548523,
0.16568227112293243,
-0.3344009816646576,
0.32669124007225037,
-0.022359322756528854,
0.5494037866592407,
-0.240859255194664,
0.2601405382156372,
-0.48955851793289185,
-0.3237929046154022,
0.1941874921321869,
-0.009305939078330994,
0.566702663898468,
0.1722584217786789,
-0.11203724890947342,
0.11048679053783417,
-0.6757324934005737,
-0.1233086958527565,
-0.04378064349293709,
-0.4104178547859192,
-0.6739484071731567,
0.04654887318611145,
0.4633267819881439,
-0.041623812168836594,
0.42542871832847595,
-0.8854535818099976,
0.023163532838225365,
-0.3683791756629944,
0.4111230671405792,
0.23298019170761108,
-0.08103258907794952,
0.29896533489227295,
-0.332199364900589,
0.38767102360725403,
-0.20706674456596375,
0.11296874284744263,
0.033434804528951645,
-0.3196326792240143,
-0.2009788453578949,
-0.6636120080947876,
0.635608434677124,
0.38810470700263977,
-0.6000390648841858,
0.34457632899284363,
-0.1947324573993683,
-0.7114696502685547,
-0.7125710844993591,
0.194713294506073,
0.6799139380455017,
0.5716766119003296,
0.7858433723449707,
-0.16831359267234802,
-0.6753494143486023,
-0.8695819973945618,
-0.05837950110435486,
0.18143580853939056,
-0.07144968956708908,
0.44315284490585327,
0.6345676779747009,
-0.9385598301887512,
0.6645166873931885,
-0.698895275592804,
-0.10357680171728134,
-0.11391105502843857,
0.08873455226421356,
-0.10917677730321884,
0.5084642767906189,
0.40317633748054504,
-0.8045653700828552,
0.04509000852704048,
0.2866470217704773,
-0.7773854732513428,
-0.04492051899433136,
0.4462573528289795,
-0.4953558146953583,
0.038510214537382126,
0.6764546036720276,
-0.6270573139190674,
0.10962167382240295,
0.5481351017951965,
-0.3586938679218292,
0.5682584047317505,
-0.5577359199523926,
-0.06346835941076279,
-0.964552104473114,
0.7683199048042297,
-0.09122590720653534,
-0.48908334970474243,
-0.32851162552833557,
0.06729231029748917,
0.27421024441719055,
-0.021743685007095337,
-0.1899411827325821,
0.8276371955871582,
-0.5084176659584045,
0.057673100382089615,
-0.3310129940509796,
-0.060986924916505814,
0.1289120465517044,
-0.30673182010650635,
-0.031052326783537865,
0.6644476056098938,
0.37097975611686707,
-0.48502057790756226,
0.1566060334444046,
0.6955413818359375,
-0.2659717798233032,
0.30966717004776,
-0.9298276305198669,
0.08901479095220566,
-0.41391721367836,
0.34447866678237915,
-0.6321628093719482,
-0.4625052809715271,
-0.14114336669445038,
-0.3417763113975525,
0.3718360960483551,
-0.2596715986728668,
-0.6307287216186523,
-0.42388132214546204,
-0.02857332117855549,
0.48534390330314636,
0.4644975960254669,
-0.6745642423629761,
0.3345459997653961,
0.48243948817253113,
-0.2983629107475281,
-0.5744329690933228,
-0.574108898639679,
-0.04068370535969734,
0.1634986251592636,
-0.34711453318595886,
0.3623756170272827,
-0.36980360746383667,
0.04191097989678383,
0.010314653627574444,
0.10817551612854004,
0.01624249666929245,
0.009986864402890205,
0.2271512895822525,
0.1925085335969925,
-0.23534105718135834,
0.30623963475227356,
0.287019282579422,
-0.08337634056806564,
-0.1062312200665474,
-0.2382441610097885,
0.35640114545822144,
0.2356751710176468,
-0.12306471914052963,
-0.03239241614937782,
0.31061139702796936,
0.23864790797233582,
-0.5340432524681091,
0.745564341545105,
0.7075217366218567,
-0.4685923755168915,
0.01823553815484047,
-0.7461773157119751,
-0.42296740412712097,
-0.49252480268478394,
0.5492734909057617,
-0.08170084655284882,
-1.1619312763214111,
0.23473262786865234,
-0.17891795933246613,
-0.07400818169116974,
0.07531750202178955,
0.7610862255096436,
-0.02088771015405655,
1.0772274732589722,
0.6021153926849365,
-0.03661254048347473,
0.32225173711776733,
-0.11528617888689041,
-0.13264910876750946,
-0.7332895994186401,
-0.4945821166038513,
-0.6586394906044006,
-0.31972724199295044,
-0.3910911977291107,
-0.5158456563949585,
0.2295234650373459,
0.11312656104564667,
-0.1917489618062973,
0.08030222356319427,
-0.5240650773048401,
0.5700401067733765,
0.5314300656318665,
0.40378159284591675,
0.2885737419128418,
-0.05733606964349747,
-0.13092941045761108,
0.0317503996193409,
-0.7424795031547546,
-0.4130472242832184,
1.1871204376220703,
0.19613228738307953,
0.8089456558227539,
0.12670427560806274,
0.5195941925048828,
-0.02005738392472267,
0.32975661754608154,
-0.6342596411705017,
0.24298551678657532,
-0.45294851064682007,
-0.9413666129112244,
-0.10502610355615616,
-0.7115305662155151,
-1.3953417539596558,
0.03610478714108467,
-0.4368455708026886,
-0.3955756425857544,
0.2782694101333618,
0.338816374540329,
-0.2611978054046631,
-0.11141020804643631,
-0.5894925594329834,
1.0636801719665527,
0.0665798932313919,
-0.49939990043640137,
-0.4007188081741333,
-0.7885997295379639,
0.16698619723320007,
-0.06651543825864792,
-0.07156245410442352,
-0.04257728159427643,
-0.04714025557041168,
0.4679136574268341,
-0.22646498680114746,
0.48723387718200684,
-0.26290854811668396,
0.283823698759079,
-0.23295606672763824,
0.08998093008995056,
0.2455369234085083,
0.1448155790567398,
-0.385614812374115,
0.11221487820148468,
0.2660316824913025,
-0.773051381111145,
-0.3032900393009186,
0.6228480339050293,
-0.5199413299560547,
-0.2026844173669815,
-0.22353407740592957,
-0.723685085773468,
-0.2614932954311371,
0.5562909841537476,
0.3825250267982483,
0.6614881753921509,
-0.4211978316307068,
0.6194021701812744,
1.0061242580413818,
-0.33359402418136597,
0.16609130799770355,
0.6657623052597046,
-0.12083810567855835,
-0.32208573818206787,
0.893698513507843,
-0.2227950543165207,
-0.007776570972055197,
0.587047815322876,
0.10579753667116165,
-0.4214184582233429,
-0.9119983315467834,
-0.3502069115638733,
0.5603785514831543,
-0.28152748942375183,
-0.5425938963890076,
-0.8016200065612793,
-0.22027631103992462,
-0.2519908547401428,
0.035076942294836044,
-0.40271106362342834,
-0.2165049910545349,
-0.29680487513542175,
-0.05642421916127205,
0.6891862154006958,
0.7144359946250916,
-0.1879158914089203,
0.2989959120750427,
-1.0118985176086426,
0.30630651116371155,
-0.11558853834867477,
0.549297034740448,
-0.3162778317928314,
-0.5004244446754456,
-0.6354978084564209,
0.052478767931461334,
0.0030331399757415056,
-0.434597909450531,
0.4540545344352722,
0.31703025102615356,
0.38452786207199097,
0.23641733825206757,
-0.1355496644973755,
0.5342907309532166,
-0.770112156867981,
0.11843181401491165,
-0.1398414820432663,
-0.5234695672988892,
0.7163374423980713,
-0.4475323259830475,
0.19781887531280518,
0.9192349910736084,
0.548772931098938,
-0.2233058214187622,
-0.318241149187088,
-0.36094722151756287,
-0.8979507684707642,
0.5237987041473389,
0.15167644619941711,
-0.021982047706842422,
-0.08205670118331909,
0.6699523329734802,
0.19797061383724213,
0.24744005501270294,
0.1482800543308258,
-0.04041280597448349,
-0.051117170602083206,
-0.4203405976295471,
-0.47137370705604553,
-0.26344212889671326,
-0.18174569308757782,
-0.37104880809783936,
0.6350984573364258,
-0.04212624952197075,
0.20937302708625793,
0.44646427035331726,
-0.5025842189788818,
-0.11598069965839386,
-0.025076953694224358,
0.5883325934410095,
0.56541508436203,
-0.5514316558837891,
0.10471781343221664,
-0.2504083514213562,
-0.8121964335441589,
-0.15868023037910461,
0.7251894474029541,
0.009015949442982674,
0.08401060104370117,
0.22310082614421844,
0.5068007111549377,
0.37867456674575806,
-1.028740406036377,
0.40885573625564575,
-0.14540168642997742,
-0.13888607919216156,
0.1307920515537262,
0.05523846298456192,
0.15409229695796967,
0.398699551820755,
0.25027918815612793,
0.028069529682397842,
0.5772578716278076,
-0.05804916098713875,
0.47937148809432983,
0.5669635534286499,
-0.4423397481441498,
-0.2614487111568451,
0.9000359773635864,
0.12866593897342682,
-0.002550705336034298,
0.6025727987289429,
-0.19807599484920502,
-0.0033820047974586487,
0.13821710646152496,
0.691373348236084,
0.28312137722969055,
-0.3762434720993042,
0.13197195529937744,
0.30994340777397156,
0.12031719088554382,
-0.6065137386322021,
0.24009530246257782,
0.2834579646587372,
-0.5814573168754578,
-0.5694381594657898,
-0.9015825986862183,
-0.5480731725692749,
-0.04335218667984009,
-0.8023306727409363,
0.08410686254501343,
-0.3484162986278534,
-0.34361034631729126,
0.3600221872329712,
0.12263381481170654,
-0.4983418881893158,
0.19887784123420715,
-0.09882582724094391,
1.0927026271820068,
-0.5193115472793579,
0.7970223426818848,
0.8892892599105835,
-0.41439539194107056,
-0.3807930052280426,
-0.3749023377895355,
-0.25293755531311035,
-0.5759420990943909,
0.6909359693527222,
-0.0656960979104042,
0.025678936392068863,
0.34832221269607544,
-0.49310407042503357,
-0.8483508229255676,
0.9897850155830383,
0.7630542516708374,
-0.8331707715988159,
-0.0981365516781807,
-0.23642688989639282,
0.6584163904190063,
-0.04431435465812683,
0.2597903907299042,
0.5582703351974487,
0.4953220784664154,
0.09038104116916656,
-0.8364173769950867,
0.12731413543224335,
-0.3086090385913849,
-0.012450696900486946,
0.3004373013973236,
-0.5862871408462524,
0.277506023645401,
-0.16141222417354584,
0.29402369260787964,
0.25803810358047485,
0.49953988194465637,
0.5732713937759399,
0.4524010419845581,
-0.02883870340883732,
0.48443618416786194,
1.122071385383606,
0.008125322870910168,
1.2861453294754028,
-0.1942850947380066,
0.30919691920280457,
0.8554122447967529,
-0.37348026037216187,
0.9057199954986572,
0.1784200221300125,
0.20697617530822754,
0.4025518596172333,
0.5450186729431152,
-0.14955133199691772,
0.2869446873664856,
0.10377466678619385,
-0.20300771296024323,
-0.2696790099143982,
-0.20652234554290771,
-0.42545363306999207,
0.25665512681007385,
0.5394977331161499,
-0.4279395639896393,
-0.045473966747522354,
0.36397072672843933,
0.11053099483251572,
0.09175407886505127,
-0.2703145742416382,
0.605488657951355,
0.015309460461139679,
-0.38686859607696533,
0.5562087297439575,
-0.06853342056274414,
0.5186195969581604,
-0.44527944922447205,
0.05864976346492767,
-0.1965850442647934,
0.40055516362190247,
-0.24397985637187958,
-0.45494556427001953,
0.22619475424289703,
-0.14186342060565948,
-0.5285598039627075,
-0.1174541786313057,
0.8510192632675171,
-0.6122930645942688,
-0.6809127330780029,
0.6265543103218079,
0.43533235788345337,
0.16640552878379822,
-0.160936176776886,
-0.7171645760536194,
0.18579979240894318,
-0.33095577359199524,
-0.23682700097560883,
0.32600080966949463,
0.5020183324813843,
0.13998989760875702,
0.6624699831008911,
0.7044529914855957,
0.3017760217189789,
0.02196280099451542,
0.2772163450717926,
0.842714786529541,
-0.7501121163368225,
0.10883703827857971,
-0.6869503259658813,
0.12522512674331665,
-0.11705692112445831,
-0.07533153891563416,
0.5753417611122131,
1.1970659494400024,
0.711207926273346,
-0.06990310549736023,
0.562320351600647,
0.22123868763446808,
0.8684180378913879,
-0.5093758702278137,
1.025632381439209,
-0.6005129814147949,
-0.1260126382112503,
-0.1089114174246788,
-0.7607956528663635,
-0.5668609142303467,
0.5630966424942017,
-0.22364604473114014,
0.23791971802711487,
0.6882935762405396,
1.004631519317627,
-0.3762519061565399,
-0.012177280150353909,
0.29408586025238037,
0.49315115809440613,
0.0448237806558609,
0.36356082558631897,
0.5502658486366272,
-0.21564151346683502,
0.36311712861061096,
-0.08259806036949158,
-0.3086743950843811,
-0.5686435103416443,
-0.5080607533454895,
-1.0051058530807495,
-0.32687056064605713,
-0.2284289300441742,
-0.4849799871444702,
0.5624321103096008,
0.9448633790016174,
1.0036509037017822,
-0.691910982131958,
-0.1066889539361,
0.17589989304542542,
-0.2320062518119812,
0.12334634363651276,
-0.15277071297168732,
0.22591373324394226,
-0.5656704902648926,
-0.5610060691833496,
0.5853613018989563,
0.2667692303657532,
-0.0025392144452780485,
0.09167754650115967,
0.04820309951901436,
-0.2584480345249176,
-0.011678197421133518,
0.8740398287773132,
0.3567216098308563,
-0.20164503157138824,
-0.109162837266922,
0.18350718915462494,
-0.3339540958404541,
-0.0927993506193161,
0.819627046585083,
-0.8514796495437622,
0.335808664560318,
0.3401446044445038,
1.0671322345733643,
0.8286218643188477,
0.1119476705789566,
0.5735025405883789,
-0.6633205413818359,
0.16290266811847687,
0.3772590458393097,
0.28525421023368835,
0.596012532711029,
-0.43693822622299194,
0.506066083908081,
0.05311458930373192,
-0.9108042120933533,
-0.9572781324386597,
-0.07055802643299103,
-1.088430643081665,
-0.46092289686203003,
1.1553958654403687,
0.2570156455039978,
-0.15977077186107635,
-0.2549862861633301,
-0.19506382942199707,
0.2637840211391449,
-0.4331679344177246,
0.7085617184638977,
0.3569353222846985,
-0.044903650879859924,
0.11752628535032272,
-0.7811565399169922,
0.6098048090934753,
0.6463379263877869,
-0.8009634017944336,
0.19540509581565857,
0.6451869606971741,
0.40858152508735657,
-0.22236554324626923,
0.6835885643959045,
-0.17125824093818665,
0.3785651922225952,
-0.4940589964389801,
0.16695667803287506,
-0.0005800702492706478,
-0.3135850727558136,
-0.3350922167301178,
-0.13032807409763336,
0.1437293291091919,
0.20234885811805725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18416v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18416v2
|
Capabilities of Gemini Models in Medicine
| 2024-04-29T04:11:28 | 2024-05-01T17:12:10 |
Khaled Saab, Tao Tu, Wei-Hung Weng, Ryutaro Tanno, David Stutz, Ellery Wulczyn, Fan Zhang, Tim Strother, Chunjong Park, Elahe Vedadi, Juanma Zambrano Chaves, Szu-Yeu Hu, Mike Schaekermann, Aishwarya Kamath, Yong Cheng, David G. T. Barrett, Cathy Cheung, Basil Mustafa, Anil Palepu, Daniel McDuff, Le Hou, Tomer Golany, Luyang Liu, Jean-baptiste Alayrac, Neil Houlsby, Nenad Tomasev, Jan Freyberg, Charles Lau, Jonas Kemp, Jeremy Lai, Shekoofeh Azizi, Kimberly Kanada, SiWai Man, Kavita Kulkarni, Ruoxi Sun, Siamak Shakeri, Luheng He, Ben Caine, Albert Webson, Natasha Latysheva, Melvin Johnson, Philip Mansfield, Jian Lu, Ehud Rivlin, Jesper Anderson, Bradley Green, Renee Wong, Jonathan Krause, Jonathon Shlens, Ewa Dominowska, S. M. Ali Eslami, Katherine Chou, Claire Cui, Oriol Vinyals, Koray Kavukcuoglu, James Manyika, Jeff Dean, Demis Hassabis, Yossi Matias, Dale Webster, Joelle Barral, Greg Corrado, Christopher Semturs, S. Sara Mahdavi, Juraj Gottweis, Alan Karthikesalingam, Vivek Natarajan
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Excellence in a wide variety of medical applications poses considerable
challenges for AI, requiring advanced reasoning, access to up-to-date medical
knowledge and understanding of complex multimodal data. Gemini models, with
strong general capabilities in multimodal and long-context reasoning, offer
exciting possibilities in medicine. Building on these core strengths of Gemini,
we introduce Med-Gemini, a family of highly capable multimodal models that are
specialized in medicine with the ability to seamlessly use web search, and that
can be efficiently tailored to novel modalities using custom encoders. We
evaluate Med-Gemini on 14 medical benchmarks, establishing new state-of-the-art
(SoTA) performance on 10 of them, and surpass the GPT-4 model family on every
benchmark where a direct comparison is viable, often by a wide margin. On the
popular MedQA (USMLE) benchmark, our best-performing Med-Gemini model achieves
SoTA performance of 91.1% accuracy, using a novel uncertainty-guided search
strategy. On 7 multimodal benchmarks including NEJM Image Challenges and MMMU
(health & medicine), Med-Gemini improves over GPT-4V by an average relative
margin of 44.5%. We demonstrate the effectiveness of Med-Gemini's long-context
capabilities through SoTA performance on a needle-in-a-haystack retrieval task
from long de-identified health records and medical video question answering,
surpassing prior bespoke methods using only in-context learning. Finally,
Med-Gemini's performance suggests real-world utility by surpassing human
experts on tasks such as medical text summarization, alongside demonstrations
of promising potential for multimodal medical dialogue, medical research and
education. Taken together, our results offer compelling evidence for
Med-Gemini's potential, although further rigorous evaluation will be crucial
before real-world deployment in this safety-critical domain.
|
[
-0.36128225922584534,
-0.49611350893974304,
0.8965123891830444,
0.0052594817243516445,
-0.198955237865448,
-0.1269838660955429,
-0.03559339419007301,
-0.5534029603004456,
0.29429227113723755,
0.34755778312683105,
-0.7236628532409668,
-0.4726119339466095,
-0.9926785230636597,
0.08809366077184677,
-0.46372726559638977,
1.0649352073669434,
0.12482020258903503,
0.518417239189148,
-0.3048942983150482,
-0.20255298912525177,
-0.31630444526672363,
-0.5652624368667603,
-0.39741432666778564,
0.015028507448732853,
0.6210945248603821,
0.08048722892999649,
1.0222752094268799,
0.6069434285163879,
0.9446051716804504,
0.27553895115852356,
0.072994165122509,
0.15682880580425262,
-0.05683198943734169,
0.28655070066452026,
-0.29308226704597473,
-0.33307158946990967,
-0.574068546295166,
0.10194546729326248,
0.356589674949646,
0.5594837665557861,
-0.24130336940288544,
-0.13383914530277252,
-0.6001489162445068,
0.6084921360015869,
-0.44007426500320435,
0.06551506370306015,
-0.33077824115753174,
-0.043412912636995316,
-0.18696936964988708,
0.07038476318120956,
0.06455614417791367,
-0.1727018803358078,
0.46593695878982544,
-0.6989194750785828,
0.017458483576774597,
-0.09421025961637497,
0.7966153025627136,
0.6156697869300842,
-0.6063974499702454,
-0.45331475138664246,
-0.5203216671943665,
0.3511654734611511,
-0.5818914175033569,
0.39102545380592346,
0.06574854999780655,
0.6184344291687012,
-0.2215290516614914,
-1.144278645515442,
-0.30450817942619324,
-0.5022501349449158,
0.1714034527540207,
0.5062272548675537,
0.0522061362862587,
0.05528560280799866,
0.06731060147285461,
0.19911567866802216,
-0.40223872661590576,
-0.053714819252491,
-0.6260018944740295,
-0.10065971314907074,
0.22508394718170166,
0.3344174325466156,
0.2545795440673828,
-0.25785204768180847,
-0.28617537021636963,
0.09880349040031433,
-0.34431740641593933,
-0.02931620180606842,
-0.21040283143520355,
-0.17035087943077087,
-0.11539410799741745,
0.597029447555542,
0.04549621418118477,
0.5066177845001221,
-0.1078672707080841,
-0.26453453302383423,
0.17763003706932068,
-0.3213029205799103,
-0.05473953112959862,
-0.40974995493888855,
0.6680221557617188,
0.3329497277736664,
-0.16377891600131989,
0.0261056087911129,
-0.09847835451364517,
0.4977993369102478,
0.5067653059959412,
-0.714680016040802,
-0.12712591886520386,
0.5232014656066895,
-0.8711342811584473,
-0.06297149509191513,
0.01580503210425377,
-0.3007607161998749,
-0.4288289546966553,
-0.2123861461877823,
0.7956273555755615,
-0.7807105779647827,
-0.2429453432559967,
0.32602858543395996,
-0.40419700741767883,
-0.34302017092704773,
0.2273816615343094,
-0.7377317547798157,
0.22529007494449615,
0.7349292635917664,
0.6066343188285828,
-0.24448959529399872,
-0.17358338832855225,
-0.1298491358757019,
-0.1371886283159256,
-0.47623270750045776,
0.49286091327667236,
-0.6169239282608032,
-0.4312177002429962,
-0.2837759554386139,
-0.2664586007595062,
-0.19971705973148346,
-0.6977644562721252,
0.5328056812286377,
-0.15160143375396729,
0.32795798778533936,
-0.08816428482532501,
-0.41709578037261963,
0.0026594996452331543,
0.4928373098373413,
-0.5579664707183838,
0.5673159956932068,
0.2538330852985382,
-0.5634999871253967,
0.3775790333747864,
-0.9815181493759155,
-0.3723877966403961,
-0.19460555911064148,
-0.3744955062866211,
-0.3396482467651367,
0.32511889934539795,
0.3900984227657318,
0.5810226202011108,
-0.4085172712802887,
0.477865993976593,
-0.20467565953731537,
-0.3295089602470398,
0.5472198128700256,
-0.42212456464767456,
0.22838401794433594,
0.2740911543369293,
-0.09531759470701218,
0.31529054045677185,
-0.7351444959640503,
-0.24344901740550995,
-0.041332170367240906,
-0.4092758297920227,
-0.25345033407211304,
-0.10067620128393173,
0.1598237156867981,
0.5882161259651184,
0.14953802525997162,
-0.49333828687667847,
0.22406314313411713,
-0.5080468058586121,
0.6775361895561218,
0.4193773567676544,
-0.14487667381763458,
0.13508424162864685,
-0.31755274534225464,
0.4958035945892334,
0.24944616854190826,
1.0045957565307617,
-0.37485450506210327,
-0.8070149421691895,
-0.4243478775024414,
-0.7635669708251953,
0.389158695936203,
0.18680764734745026,
-0.8825816512107849,
0.03233446553349495,
-0.2060147523880005,
-0.5074480175971985,
-0.8340516686439514,
-0.39786601066589355,
0.40250474214553833,
0.7127584218978882,
0.45505768060684204,
-0.5924315452575684,
-0.16876696050167084,
-1.1437526941299438,
-0.20933635532855988,
0.056402064859867096,
-0.08527005463838577,
0.6578668355941772,
0.6583929657936096,
-0.8956891894340515,
0.6582565307617188,
-0.20884937047958374,
-0.2263449877500534,
-0.11816057562828064,
0.11440560966730118,
0.6112689971923828,
0.26731181144714355,
0.4586426019668579,
-1.207593560218811,
-0.26945191621780396,
-0.1272372305393219,
-0.7591452598571777,
0.19086390733718872,
-0.0380355603992939,
0.034526556730270386,
0.1742064356803894,
0.12485180050134659,
-0.7453349828720093,
0.40217599272727966,
0.7547458410263062,
-0.5685779452323914,
0.4218091666698456,
-0.5525004863739014,
0.2553287446498871,
-1.196488380432129,
0.3863050937652588,
-0.01265730895102024,
-0.14072413742542267,
-0.6490636467933655,
0.17924994230270386,
0.4640115797519684,
-0.059144679456949234,
-0.3897278308868408,
0.42402321100234985,
-0.10805067420005798,
-0.09330730140209198,
-0.10515911877155304,
-0.06746148318052292,
-0.1904003769159317,
0.06564103811979294,
-0.05120355635881424,
0.3686952292919159,
0.7314904928207397,
-0.5712903738021851,
0.34976327419281006,
0.24368828535079956,
-0.25669875741004944,
0.6814161539077759,
-0.43007513880729675,
-0.240566685795784,
-0.40754687786102295,
0.3387033939361572,
-0.8115055561065674,
-0.4151307940483093,
0.09802207350730896,
-0.6864646673202515,
0.43540459871292114,
-0.060860320925712585,
-0.2359674870967865,
-0.6589155793190002,
-0.18641193211078644,
0.21375051140785217,
0.38106414675712585,
-0.3654162585735321,
0.8938519358634949,
0.23394596576690674,
-0.12811961770057678,
-0.9237229824066162,
-0.3228273093700409,
0.31837281584739685,
0.06538135558366776,
-0.6759158372879028,
0.7405900359153748,
-0.0735180452466011,
0.025158995762467384,
-0.012627205811440945,
-0.33696091175079346,
0.02024775929749012,
0.058594875037670135,
0.5156821608543396,
0.7957538366317749,
-0.05723129212856293,
0.25144797563552856,
0.13234880566596985,
-0.46972525119781494,
0.057048872113227844,
-0.3104337453842163,
0.32882213592529297,
-0.13088953495025635,
-0.5365844368934631,
-0.361054927110672,
0.27896296977996826,
1.1570801734924316,
-0.17511233687400818,
0.7453504204750061,
0.7285708785057068,
-0.4771060645580292,
0.5360320210456848,
-0.7295584082603455,
-0.38281068205833435,
-0.3803205192089081,
0.6263885498046875,
-0.3211227059364319,
-0.6839258670806885,
0.3837963342666626,
-0.06675364822149277,
0.006977887358516455,
0.6032924652099609,
0.5531742572784424,
-0.384602814912796,
1.2059234380722046,
0.39447730779647827,
0.0021397757809609175,
0.20045608282089233,
-0.2848171889781952,
-0.23017297685146332,
-0.7503833174705505,
-0.6553894281387329,
-0.31328341364860535,
-0.4008620083332062,
-0.5646481513977051,
-0.4721256196498871,
1.0918328762054443,
-0.55332350730896,
-0.20743131637573242,
-0.19333267211914062,
-0.554265558719635,
0.06045151874423027,
0.685525119304657,
0.4487634599208832,
0.21890270709991455,
-0.38769569993019104,
-0.46970611810684204,
-0.09451770782470703,
-0.6904968023300171,
-0.0612914003431797,
1.437322974205017,
0.38241371512413025,
0.8155732750892639,
0.06828437000513077,
0.39334070682525635,
0.038230203092098236,
0.7403813004493713,
-0.7314919829368591,
0.2016170173883438,
-0.5451757311820984,
-1.2146378755569458,
0.03278204798698425,
-0.4599631428718567,
-0.7898290157318115,
0.2335989773273468,
-0.8453805446624756,
-0.19835804402828217,
-0.24252550303936005,
0.04450050741434097,
-0.6577701568603516,
0.05751773715019226,
-0.32601863145828247,
0.8165825009346008,
-0.4906826913356781,
-0.2847802937030792,
-0.4164641201496124,
-1.1604926586151123,
0.21711283922195435,
-0.10984624177217484,
0.2690961956977844,
0.05368117243051529,
-0.40717604756355286,
0.3574984073638916,
-0.1672791838645935,
0.5096004009246826,
-0.11087861657142639,
0.486593633890152,
-0.23788854479789734,
-0.21923065185546875,
0.01650046743452549,
0.13228735327720642,
0.2372126579284668,
0.1774020940065384,
0.32787635922431946,
-0.2403598427772522,
-0.45632046461105347,
0.6884247064590454,
-0.9061709642410278,
-0.3882136046886444,
-0.5616071820259094,
-0.4782685935497284,
-0.19167156517505646,
0.15835313498973846,
0.34400230646133423,
0.6488730907440186,
-0.0915103629231453,
0.2515997588634491,
0.40582093596458435,
-0.4437640905380249,
0.18069960176944733,
0.5099268555641174,
-0.29243651032447815,
-0.6005988121032715,
0.5433540344238281,
0.020264051854610443,
0.07108625769615173,
0.5268108248710632,
0.30759018659591675,
-0.6109000444412231,
-0.5940576791763306,
-0.5942917466163635,
0.33654749393463135,
-0.575999915599823,
0.02635762467980385,
-0.7787879109382629,
-0.20912666618824005,
-0.20843657851219177,
0.03764672204852104,
-0.717851996421814,
-0.520203173160553,
-0.03419557958841324,
0.38559967279434204,
0.006798744201660156,
0.7550597190856934,
0.06921175122261047,
0.06533170491456985,
-0.9624361991882324,
0.6832348108291626,
0.11260297149419785,
0.5049606561660767,
-0.5415246486663818,
-0.2354716807603836,
-0.12733244895935059,
-0.2419043779373169,
-0.469341516494751,
-0.8130786418914795,
0.298546701669693,
-0.10614234209060669,
0.6262103915214539,
0.5321674942970276,
-0.33065786957740784,
0.6228010058403015,
-0.21812103688716888,
0.6205918192863464,
0.4816218614578247,
-0.6426944136619568,
0.3886251151561737,
-0.41700005531311035,
0.2245153933763504,
0.32437995076179504,
0.6053141951560974,
-0.6524243950843811,
-0.0919378399848938,
-0.5971859693527222,
-0.6898828744888306,
0.40334975719451904,
0.3426697850227356,
-0.026530442759394646,
-0.12052976340055466,
0.8094878196716309,
0.2992906868457794,
0.30791372060775757,
-0.33402693271636963,
-0.25196370482444763,
-0.28754109144210815,
-0.4976373016834259,
-0.12348249554634094,
0.05643976107239723,
-0.1148483082652092,
-0.20581428706645966,
0.4490145742893219,
-0.1938808560371399,
0.36136192083358765,
0.39954185485839844,
0.24800458550453186,
0.1986212283372879,
0.2286985218524933,
0.48578980565071106,
0.5721278786659241,
-0.14901494979858398,
-0.15549226105213165,
-0.022310826927423477,
-0.7271652817726135,
-0.19193831086158752,
0.3778284192085266,
0.28080981969833374,
-0.1908358335494995,
0.11082742363214493,
0.31634584069252014,
0.27055859565734863,
-0.8412489891052246,
0.6601874828338623,
-0.4389817714691162,
-0.11773429065942764,
-0.26238659024238586,
0.10311004519462585,
0.29113009572029114,
0.426462858915329,
0.27567559480667114,
0.7832456827163696,
0.441783607006073,
-0.6754393577575684,
0.056043364107608795,
0.5256926417350769,
-0.3543860614299774,
-0.14326685667037964,
1.0064126253128052,
0.2392062246799469,
0.014883484691381454,
0.9042655229568481,
0.5259726047515869,
-0.25684669613838196,
0.778546929359436,
0.4813269078731537,
0.15744704008102417,
-0.2409690022468567,
-0.040176548063755035,
0.2518780827522278,
0.13242658972740173,
-0.4647155702114105,
0.518219530582428,
0.21443122625350952,
-0.5919551253318787,
-0.3381524682044983,
-0.1344539225101471,
-0.6587308645248413,
-0.09138526767492294,
-0.5650441646575928,
0.19932568073272705,
-0.5082271695137024,
-0.8527722358703613,
0.21380819380283356,
-0.22365379333496094,
-0.7438629865646362,
0.49662140011787415,
0.30714190006256104,
1.174046516418457,
-0.2903074324131012,
0.7467947602272034,
0.8073921203613281,
-0.23594895005226135,
-0.3612079918384552,
-0.33572256565093994,
0.10514343529939651,
-0.7680838108062744,
0.2706075608730316,
0.47085076570510864,
0.025847095996141434,
-0.37424349784851074,
-0.3764290511608124,
-0.9023866057395935,
1.2594560384750366,
0.32963523268699646,
-0.4661973714828491,
-0.21913671493530273,
-0.20675037801265717,
0.662098228931427,
-0.4809548258781433,
0.5860645174980164,
0.4993017911911011,
0.3202657997608185,
0.27721378207206726,
-1.1099272966384888,
-0.1693582981824875,
-0.32911697030067444,
-0.043114401400089264,
0.12752094864845276,
-0.6086062788963318,
0.9332623481750488,
-0.5055139660835266,
0.11757536977529526,
0.5007141828536987,
0.08062133938074112,
0.3684295415878296,
0.6538538336753845,
0.18390043079853058,
0.3910300135612488,
0.6383641362190247,
-0.33109354972839355,
1.2981650829315186,
-0.5144843459129333,
0.043569859117269516,
0.45710909366607666,
0.009758973494172096,
0.8325013518333435,
0.511350154876709,
0.041774846613407135,
0.42053496837615967,
0.4381868839263916,
0.1948969066143036,
0.4342809319496155,
-0.15620185434818268,
-0.19923433661460876,
-0.30099135637283325,
0.12575756013393402,
-0.4609852135181427,
0.47733813524246216,
0.8156356811523438,
-0.7132046222686768,
0.49576133489608765,
0.14887729287147522,
-0.08113870024681091,
-0.09932725876569748,
-0.40484675765037537,
0.5084859728813171,
0.09682270139455795,
-0.8616880178451538,
0.21043428778648376,
0.2132003903388977,
0.8757258057594299,
-0.856465756893158,
0.10819888114929199,
-0.03618805110454559,
0.5138286352157593,
-0.12300682812929153,
-0.5383347272872925,
0.23168644309043884,
-0.3116338849067688,
0.017372293397784233,
0.06315878033638,
0.7327840924263,
0.11120490729808807,
-0.4902555048465729,
0.2821228802204132,
0.5475881099700928,
0.09110479056835175,
-0.1814039647579193,
-0.6813075542449951,
-0.1490638107061386,
-0.3467333912849426,
-0.08961474150419235,
0.28492555022239685,
0.14293897151947021,
0.10787153244018555,
1.086870551109314,
0.7070780992507935,
0.04493037611246109,
-0.08166559040546417,
-0.042490653693675995,
1.0589388608932495,
-0.9229584336280823,
-0.36420387029647827,
-0.8261626958847046,
0.5257768630981445,
-0.0017657375428825617,
-0.5091524720191956,
0.23921258747577667,
0.45402732491493225,
0.4218519628047943,
-0.2328825443983078,
0.7723495364189148,
-0.0045564486645162106,
0.48629993200302124,
-0.39559149742126465,
0.8668368458747864,
-0.7833862900733948,
0.0044772326946258545,
0.046938203275203705,
-0.4267256259918213,
-0.6657081842422485,
0.6291929483413696,
-0.17810969054698944,
0.2767835557460785,
0.7330465912818909,
0.6747076511383057,
-0.12039671093225479,
0.1323564201593399,
0.4945274293422699,
0.3894363343715668,
0.2334323525428772,
0.7752029299736023,
1.1512341499328613,
-0.30403459072113037,
0.5369260907173157,
-0.021551169455051422,
-0.6136749386787415,
-0.33171120285987854,
-0.4937032461166382,
-1.043456792831421,
-0.4116595387458801,
0.10315922647714615,
-0.3398597836494446,
0.22843754291534424,
1.1751885414123535,
1.083153486251831,
-0.4255809783935547,
0.31360986828804016,
0.41724205017089844,
-0.30541667342185974,
-0.4148200750350952,
-0.015539824962615967,
0.24658824503421783,
0.07484371960163116,
-0.5105950832366943,
0.47036808729171753,
0.7282289266586304,
-0.04655146971344948,
-0.30222073197364807,
-0.243810772895813,
0.14837273955345154,
0.039974506944417953,
0.4016248285770416,
-0.021959295496344566,
-0.86004638671875,
0.13072510063648224,
0.3733147084712982,
-0.38200363516807556,
0.048609428107738495,
0.8024314641952515,
-0.9274207949638367,
0.6198640465736389,
0.14036405086517334,
0.41068896651268005,
0.6902338266372681,
-0.12232933938503265,
0.34923407435417175,
-0.21401767432689667,
-0.20015132427215576,
0.41291317343711853,
0.6176580786705017,
0.22940440475940704,
-0.30499041080474854,
0.47295907139778137,
0.1858285665512085,
-0.4472386837005615,
-0.23094871640205383,
0.17076589167118073,
-0.868401050567627,
-0.5723059177398682,
0.7518600225448608,
-0.02605457231402397,
-0.003270734567195177,
-0.18815802037715912,
-0.3931938111782074,
0.23133455216884613,
-0.32194679975509644,
1.1508957147598267,
0.32758113741874695,
-0.3944723606109619,
0.10053505748510361,
-0.6334571242332458,
0.24509449303150177,
0.3862491548061371,
-0.7912272810935974,
-0.5927121043205261,
0.4528521001338959,
0.6134733557701111,
0.23504340648651123,
0.6732098460197449,
-0.7364050149917603,
0.7203364372253418,
-0.0645059123635292,
-0.1754232794046402,
-0.39046546816825867,
-0.7215794324874878,
-0.09671146422624588,
0.33192193508148193,
-0.19064149260520935,
-0.13767176866531372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00732v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00732v1
|
LoRA Land: 310 Fine-tuned LLMs that Rival GPT-4, A Technical Report
| 2024-04-29T04:01:45 | 2024-04-29T04:01:45 |
Justin Zhao, Timothy Wang, Wael Abid, Geoffrey Angus, Arnav Garg, Jeffery Kinnison, Alex Sherstinsky, Piero Molino, Travis Addair, Devvret Rishi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Low Rank Adaptation (LoRA) has emerged as one of the most widely adopted
methods for Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) of Large Language Models
(LLMs). LoRA reduces the number of trainable parameters and memory usage while
achieving comparable performance to full fine-tuning. We aim to assess the
viability of training and serving LLMs fine-tuned with LoRA in real-world
applications. First, we measure the quality of LLMs fine-tuned with quantized
low rank adapters across 10 base models and 31 tasks for a total of 310 models.
We find that 4-bit LoRA fine-tuned models outperform base models by 34 points
and GPT-4 by 10 points on average. Second, we investigate the most effective
base models for fine-tuning and assess the correlative and predictive
capacities of task complexity heuristics in forecasting the outcomes of
fine-tuning. Finally, we evaluate the latency and concurrency capabilities of
LoRAX, an open-source Multi-LoRA inference server that facilitates the
deployment of multiple LoRA fine-tuned models on a single GPU using shared base
model weights and dynamic adapter loading. LoRAX powers LoRA Land, a web
application that hosts 25 LoRA fine-tuned Mistral-7B LLMs on a single NVIDIA
A100 GPU with 80GB memory. LoRA Land highlights the quality and
cost-effectiveness of employing multiple specialized LLMs over a single,
general-purpose LLM.
|
[
-0.5600584149360657,
-0.9261975884437561,
0.5703109502792358,
0.0835864469408989,
-0.28771156072616577,
0.058604542165994644,
-0.3689303696155548,
-0.5843483209609985,
-0.04227730259299278,
0.6428925395011902,
-0.1447874903678894,
-0.41112133860588074,
-0.5049025416374207,
-0.05772940814495087,
-0.2989499270915985,
1.0004236698150635,
-0.03555741161108017,
-0.24984300136566162,
0.3037460744380951,
-0.2706611454486847,
-0.38004428148269653,
-0.41766300797462463,
-0.7188528776168823,
-0.42167577147483826,
0.8417311906814575,
0.4476222097873688,
0.7332921028137207,
0.4409038722515106,
0.472881019115448,
0.2517498731613159,
-0.1380898654460907,
0.3447146415710449,
-0.8582181334495544,
-0.1760629564523697,
-0.26090067625045776,
-0.5852260589599609,
-1.0156927108764648,
-0.07132542878389359,
0.665511965751648,
0.5489233136177063,
-0.21008947491645813,
0.3109886050224304,
0.11585034430027008,
0.7739477157592773,
-0.6826168894767761,
-0.0658770501613617,
-1.024566411972046,
-0.03583068400621414,
-0.29517021775245667,
-0.32837197184562683,
-0.279631644487381,
-0.3587307035923004,
-0.0694359615445137,
-0.7722270488739014,
-0.06281181424856186,
0.10055679827928543,
0.8659021258354187,
0.5760921835899353,
-0.2225072681903839,
0.14447055757045746,
-0.8176169395446777,
0.7672563195228577,
-0.8843221068382263,
0.17380042374134064,
0.3784022331237793,
0.40044325590133667,
-0.34407415986061096,
-0.5114650726318359,
-0.2874956727027893,
0.011507736518979073,
0.5688807368278503,
0.08520197868347168,
-0.24429422616958618,
0.0962718054652214,
0.3605962097644806,
0.5372301340103149,
-0.23604553937911987,
0.5498045086860657,
-0.22060717642307281,
0.058416273444890976,
0.3649999797344208,
0.05538136884570122,
-0.11444735527038574,
0.20559369027614594,
-0.08612572401762009,
0.16786295175552368,
-1.158578634262085,
-0.05003903806209564,
0.5444230437278748,
0.5991733074188232,
-0.10482190549373627,
0.5108239650726318,
-0.3714826703071594,
0.9682224988937378,
0.28336572647094727,
-0.3742888867855072,
-0.14979460835456848,
-0.2624094486236572,
-0.33808445930480957,
-0.21892186999320984,
0.5486960411071777,
0.1602143794298172,
0.4162118136882782,
-0.23325590789318085,
-0.3420713245868683,
0.03612801060080528,
0.12061205506324768,
-0.7077706456184387,
-0.09431002289056778,
-0.09034999459981918,
-0.18420319259166718,
-0.17930692434310913,
-0.30303093791007996,
-0.6982187032699585,
-0.4239714741706848,
-0.23899714648723602,
0.5847241282463074,
-0.3549971580505371,
0.05021996796131134,
0.34237366914749146,
0.11002609133720398,
0.4154455065727234,
0.6888288855552673,
-0.9915584921836853,
0.537584125995636,
0.670023500919342,
0.7122617959976196,
-0.40627774596214294,
-0.3135871887207031,
-0.8603556156158447,
0.03189021721482277,
-0.11904951184988022,
1.0708318948745728,
-0.273970365524292,
-0.1110326275229454,
-0.21879111230373383,
0.016712920740246773,
-0.12012902647256851,
-0.7308157086372375,
0.49018433690071106,
-0.7102137207984924,
-0.21031856536865234,
-0.1537282019853592,
-0.2665681540966034,
-0.06233201548457146,
0.2606547772884369,
-0.7228813171386719,
1.0151222944259644,
0.40016746520996094,
-0.3263339400291443,
0.282135009765625,
-0.6904283165931702,
-0.35829874873161316,
-0.09819183498620987,
0.16470567882061005,
-0.42832285165786743,
0.3619001805782318,
0.09534896165132523,
0.20878642797470093,
-0.5105592608451843,
-0.11822979152202606,
-0.3858201205730438,
-0.6919636130332947,
0.021959573030471802,
-0.39690807461738586,
0.1085832342505455,
0.2971865236759186,
-0.3126310706138611,
0.04059891402721405,
-0.6433860063552856,
0.17384052276611328,
-0.021084388718008995,
-0.8377982378005981,
-0.003474147291854024,
0.055980224162340164,
0.039424825459718704,
-0.06749266386032104,
0.45755937695503235,
-0.3303273022174835,
0.28545162081718445,
-0.4527413249015808,
0.6306124925613403,
0.7090014219284058,
-0.15895503759384155,
0.3669264018535614,
-0.364609032869339,
0.5666273236274719,
-0.14855988323688507,
0.15637588500976562,
0.20531685650348663,
-0.5184870362281799,
-0.9717581272125244,
-0.10550377517938614,
0.4441051483154297,
0.40619996190071106,
-0.5563406348228455,
0.3254372775554657,
-0.41002196073532104,
-0.5219659805297852,
-0.3791295289993286,
0.3861401081085205,
0.3337715268135071,
0.18037913739681244,
0.2576775848865509,
-0.2263747751712799,
-0.3656202554702759,
-0.7186890244483948,
-0.376015305519104,
0.1467563807964325,
0.3159189522266388,
0.31716105341911316,
0.3782585859298706,
-0.13662174344062805,
0.8485906720161438,
-0.28594911098480225,
-0.18922093510627747,
-0.1586376130580902,
-0.05774407088756561,
0.45316237211227417,
0.18666553497314453,
0.7938369512557983,
-0.4239175617694855,
-0.6102313995361328,
0.42390868067741394,
-0.4312647879123688,
0.031674887984991074,
0.40922027826309204,
0.014822883531451225,
0.22725948691368103,
0.21132761240005493,
-0.26249152421951294,
0.29713982343673706,
0.8835079073905945,
-0.30521413683891296,
0.22611860930919647,
-0.5406542420387268,
-0.04887492582201958,
-0.8125383853912354,
-0.054155174642801285,
-0.15559665858745575,
-0.4893680512905121,
-0.268081933259964,
0.070998415350914,
-0.2206980437040329,
-0.05791895464062691,
-0.3257664442062378,
0.5401471257209778,
-0.2148885726928711,
-0.42978987097740173,
-0.3960575461387634,
0.11759316176176071,
-0.07872430980205536,
0.48867687582969666,
-0.292059987783432,
1.1546021699905396,
0.3114780783653259,
-0.6309145092964172,
0.17872576415538788,
0.04359376057982445,
-0.44693270325660706,
0.4969455599784851,
-0.6312355399131775,
0.3273930549621582,
0.1984935849905014,
0.02937219850718975,
-0.643321692943573,
-0.23897552490234375,
-0.07382529228925705,
0.09825411438941956,
-0.25809207558631897,
-0.4617898762226105,
-0.5314130187034607,
-0.022941354662179947,
-0.18348784744739532,
0.1734062135219574,
0.7712351679801941,
-0.5445669293403625,
0.6374794840812683,
0.34129324555397034,
-0.05029366910457611,
-0.2992188036441803,
-0.522705614566803,
-0.01401564572006464,
-0.44992610812187195,
-0.3043641149997711,
0.18182241916656494,
-0.23403629660606384,
-0.17286452651023865,
-0.2732228934764862,
-0.08700992912054062,
-0.05330363288521767,
0.360483855009079,
0.47623351216316223,
-0.12850521504878998,
-0.5795467495918274,
-0.34129029512405396,
0.12198078632354736,
-0.08490248769521713,
-0.3850156366825104,
-0.2381814420223236,
0.5411826968193054,
-0.541802167892456,
-0.4833923280239105,
-0.2169044464826584,
-0.1319516897201538,
0.6410945653915405,
0.016429979354143143,
0.6302352547645569,
0.45228317379951477,
-0.3547274172306061,
-0.2613683044910431,
-0.5134274363517761,
0.2096695899963379,
-0.4889271557331085,
0.31736427545547485,
-0.592430830001831,
-0.9596257209777832,
0.5974311828613281,
-0.4675360918045044,
0.07966364920139313,
0.530611515045166,
0.5438777804374695,
-0.223162442445755,
0.6960369944572449,
0.739875078201294,
-0.20805497467517853,
0.59991055727005,
-0.2466135025024414,
0.1590975672006607,
-0.6554480195045471,
0.21526961028575897,
-0.45046335458755493,
-0.5406044125556946,
-0.6453590393066406,
-0.5185065865516663,
0.4067070186138153,
0.33744189143180847,
-0.449771523475647,
0.33234381675720215,
-0.27113673090934753,
0.6930946111679077,
0.4607078433036804,
0.17735114693641663,
0.7278867959976196,
0.3247270882129669,
0.3328877091407776,
0.08027563989162445,
-0.6623835563659668,
-0.5579330325126648,
1.0463873147964478,
0.37084367871284485,
1.0230833292007446,
0.2641220688819885,
0.46917036175727844,
0.40645739436149597,
0.17676594853401184,
-0.8262449502944946,
0.5116147398948669,
-0.6687172651290894,
-0.28961607813835144,
-0.47594720125198364,
-0.1369364857673645,
-0.9142754077911377,
0.07456205785274506,
-0.1644863486289978,
-0.6243445873260498,
0.0630345419049263,
0.25850147008895874,
-0.7719386219978333,
0.4212113916873932,
-0.7487297654151917,
0.495402067899704,
-0.3967072069644928,
-0.42231786251068115,
-0.43686842918395996,
-0.13120585680007935,
0.10926364362239838,
-0.5655679702758789,
0.10013370215892792,
-0.4544886350631714,
-0.05655030161142349,
0.7546020150184631,
-0.28874802589416504,
0.805763304233551,
-0.25734254717826843,
-0.5113441944122314,
0.046646516770124435,
-0.14083437621593475,
0.6476715207099915,
0.08123132586479187,
-0.4498912990093231,
0.15544399619102478,
0.11523488163948059,
-0.4049924910068512,
-0.4422158896923065,
1.1565603017807007,
-1.286862850189209,
-0.42064574360847473,
-0.1592991203069687,
-0.5239844918251038,
-0.5307125449180603,
0.2910029888153076,
0.19607770442962646,
0.21827064454555511,
-0.2512281835079193,
0.09530460834503174,
0.7280654311180115,
-0.16757172346115112,
0.28646188974380493,
0.6050952076911926,
-0.2768062949180603,
-0.31829458475112915,
0.9482678771018982,
0.09556544572114944,
0.41455578804016113,
0.31673482060432434,
0.06241856887936592,
0.1676744818687439,
-1.0606374740600586,
-0.3378354012966156,
0.11908549815416336,
-0.5427191257476807,
-0.24563653767108917,
-0.17795123159885406,
-0.30664464831352234,
0.062444306910037994,
-0.12110927700996399,
-0.7361360788345337,
-0.41137492656707764,
-0.23990793526172638,
0.29686474800109863,
0.7193719148635864,
1.050916075706482,
0.29056063294410706,
0.8914421200752258,
-0.3423425257205963,
0.5809922814369202,
0.37166911363601685,
0.6609045267105103,
-0.40357697010040283,
-0.9683440923690796,
-0.2417803406715393,
0.14692947268486023,
-0.23232905566692352,
-0.18549004197120667,
0.17777839303016663,
0.4481762647628784,
0.3274421691894531,
0.24143625795841217,
-0.17500938475131989,
1.044280767440796,
-0.5916221141815186,
0.48538458347320557,
-0.1495765745639801,
-0.7751802802085876,
0.4713951349258423,
-0.6550537943840027,
0.31128960847854614,
0.7452321648597717,
-0.1062430888414383,
0.022770458832383156,
0.03817092627286911,
-0.32521551847457886,
-0.5228338241577148,
0.5813837051391602,
-0.14160120487213135,
0.07914544641971588,
0.44788795709609985,
0.656974196434021,
0.37916478514671326,
-0.020058248192071915,
-0.7153860330581665,
-0.11107832193374634,
-0.045186847448349,
0.05100730434060097,
-0.2126670628786087,
-0.22731295228004456,
-0.214565247297287,
-0.31048819422721863,
0.5816572904586792,
-0.47763514518737793,
0.1860671490430832,
-0.3294987976551056,
-0.06888245046138763,
-0.27032992243766785,
0.40374958515167236,
0.6488977670669556,
0.8158125281333923,
-0.40735718607902527,
0.055512815713882446,
0.6059798002243042,
-0.38861551880836487,
-0.03453252837061882,
0.0836966410279274,
-0.017052840441465378,
-0.24185168743133545,
0.13251234591007233,
1.0029574632644653,
0.4827551245689392,
-0.525394082069397,
0.10609276592731476,
-0.008089440874755383,
-0.21479372680187225,
-0.2045290470123291,
0.5100981593132019,
0.18060022592544556,
0.30201148986816406,
0.23319348692893982,
0.14467236399650574,
-0.20159722864627838,
-0.4695134162902832,
-0.3157694637775421,
0.5001354813575745,
-0.2364436686038971,
-0.5136827826499939,
0.449485182762146,
0.3126303553581238,
-0.19827677309513092,
0.28947266936302185,
0.019263438880443573,
-0.06272919476032257,
0.3934817612171173,
0.5219672918319702,
0.4321776330471039,
0.11240940541028976,
-0.13986296951770782,
0.18829616904258728,
0.2915076017379761,
-0.20602861046791077,
0.44794195890426636,
0.23341043293476105,
-0.7042995095252991,
-0.5705388188362122,
-0.8558304309844971,
-0.6668097376823425,
0.3112054169178009,
-0.48307323455810547,
0.26973047852516174,
-0.6445493102073669,
-0.3463170826435089,
-0.052003998309373856,
0.1344412863254547,
-0.6561605930328369,
-0.0854719877243042,
0.2617281675338745,
1.0580410957336426,
-0.7477537989616394,
1.1653589010238647,
0.7815898656845093,
-0.06937182694673538,
-0.6891927719116211,
-0.18382404744625092,
-0.4548783600330353,
-1.0118602514266968,
0.44112613797187805,
-0.36758479475975037,
-0.46779516339302063,
0.37578779458999634,
-0.5390862226486206,
-0.9944522976875305,
1.180069088935852,
0.8330450654029846,
-0.7287858724594116,
-0.10963523387908936,
0.3324299156665802,
0.5265167951583862,
-0.09260556101799011,
-0.036481115967035294,
0.7647207379341125,
0.5534545183181763,
-0.06767278909683228,
-1.2924330234527588,
-0.2699287533760071,
0.12199617177248001,
-0.05160481855273247,
0.2379274070262909,
-0.7225895524024963,
0.8792364597320557,
-0.1699952632188797,
0.2141331136226654,
0.5088537335395813,
0.4379512071609497,
0.49883362650871277,
0.009226434864103794,
0.5615906119346619,
0.5386554598808289,
0.8088169693946838,
-0.29321593046188354,
0.9027698636054993,
-0.4211941361427307,
0.3803578019142151,
1.1308982372283936,
-0.46960991621017456,
1.1281847953796387,
0.6400173306465149,
-0.40609464049339294,
0.5094833970069885,
0.5469515323638916,
0.1561274379491806,
0.6110769510269165,
0.13554219901561737,
-0.17541776597499847,
-0.38340872526168823,
-0.03477378562092781,
-0.4862765669822693,
0.5741953253746033,
0.4481339752674103,
0.03437318652868271,
-0.3388303816318512,
0.0022766171023249626,
-0.12519137561321259,
-0.14390788972377777,
-0.5243517160415649,
0.7096109390258789,
0.16990835964679718,
-0.7077666521072388,
0.8479653000831604,
0.1357581615447998,
0.7954269051551819,
-0.7296261191368103,
0.07123051583766937,
-0.45828312635421753,
0.5507580637931824,
-0.2991064786911011,
-0.5878571271896362,
-0.06841816753149033,
0.13324673473834991,
-0.2046636939048767,
-0.15639035403728485,
0.6871033906936646,
-0.012277089059352875,
-0.18728861212730408,
0.25819364190101624,
0.6909120082855225,
0.19785237312316895,
-0.31010371446609497,
-0.5218860507011414,
0.2887393832206726,
-0.17076629400253296,
-0.28330379724502563,
0.7524766325950623,
0.5098819136619568,
-0.21540232002735138,
0.6858929395675659,
0.6326794624328613,
0.29143792390823364,
0.13069099187850952,
0.07355744391679764,
0.9363970160484314,
-0.7354663014411926,
-0.3225007951259613,
-0.5962766408920288,
-0.017550699412822723,
0.32749322056770325,
-0.33308276534080505,
0.6904581189155579,
0.5602657794952393,
0.4390372633934021,
-0.0963398665189743,
0.8273623585700989,
0.11529266089200974,
0.3460695743560791,
-0.6516128182411194,
0.5084256529808044,
-0.4648531377315521,
0.2910136282444,
0.05616562068462372,
-1.096601963043213,
-0.03249600902199745,
0.40061303973197937,
-0.48139700293540955,
0.10417326539754868,
0.4525429904460907,
0.5499913692474365,
-0.4057885706424713,
-0.22391970455646515,
0.5762844085693359,
0.23290839791297913,
0.04192546382546425,
0.8055194020271301,
0.8934555649757385,
-0.652845561504364,
0.4525740146636963,
-0.018084945157170296,
-0.04185853898525238,
-0.3419952988624573,
-1.0160119533538818,
-0.821150541305542,
-0.1410982459783554,
-0.25517845153808594,
-0.13883017003536224,
0.4042614698410034,
0.510084331035614,
0.95489501953125,
-0.9236050844192505,
-0.24632924795150757,
-0.03941013291478157,
-0.019350722432136536,
-0.10402882844209671,
-0.12083152681589127,
0.1523396074771881,
-0.07293244451284409,
-0.753760039806366,
0.6381444334983826,
0.3002263009548187,
-0.05397665873169899,
-0.2550946772098541,
-0.3272070288658142,
0.029037445783615112,
0.03628603741526604,
0.710728108882904,
0.4691660702228546,
-0.9003490805625916,
-0.34721502661705017,
-0.15917690098285675,
-0.1793936938047409,
0.1395246833562851,
0.5422560572624207,
-0.8600494265556335,
-0.02455330826342106,
0.20598559081554413,
0.644311785697937,
0.551285982131958,
0.061304640024900436,
0.45973432064056396,
-0.45824867486953735,
0.12896037101745605,
-0.08267589658498764,
0.47003406286239624,
0.05752970278263092,
-0.1181907206773758,
0.6913414001464844,
-0.07547005265951157,
-0.6649852395057678,
-0.6779241561889648,
0.041835106909275055,
-1.3845000267028809,
0.030744066461920738,
1.2512052059173584,
-0.011567204259335995,
-0.06723204255104065,
-0.13508008420467377,
-0.2755184769630432,
-0.0880451574921608,
-0.34115684032440186,
0.5009382367134094,
0.4535731077194214,
-0.26376938819885254,
-0.10365117341279984,
-0.8846355080604553,
0.38750946521759033,
0.48745644092559814,
-1.1205830574035645,
-0.049990493804216385,
0.17580938339233398,
0.4626549780368805,
0.018960613757371902,
0.4943222403526306,
0.1218719631433487,
0.20130550861358643,
-0.3795449435710907,
-0.09446460008621216,
-0.035805605351924896,
-0.060857657343149185,
-0.4240104854106903,
0.2159474939107895,
0.8556602001190186,
0.09764419496059418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18410v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18410v1
|
Mixture-of-Instructions: Comprehensive Alignment of a Large Language Model through the Mixture of Diverse System Prompting Instructions
| 2024-04-29T03:58:12 | 2024-04-29T03:58:12 |
Bowen Xu, Shaoyu Wu, Kai Liu, Lulu Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the proliferation of large language models (LLMs), the comprehensive
alignment of such models across multiple tasks has emerged as a critical area
of research. Existing alignment methodologies primarily address single task,
such as multi-turn dialogue, coding, mathematical problem-solving, and tool
usage. However, AI-driven products that leverage language models usually
necessitate a fusion of these abilities to function effectively in real-world
scenarios. Moreover, the considerable computational resources required for
proper alignment of LLMs underscore the need for a more robust, efficient, and
encompassing approach to multi-task alignment, ensuring improved generative
performance. In response to these challenges, we introduce a novel technique
termed Mixture-of-Instructions (MoI), which employs a strategy of instruction
concatenation combined with diverse system prompts to boost the alignment
efficiency of language models. We have also compiled a diverse set of seven
benchmark datasets to rigorously evaluate the alignment efficacy of the
MoI-enhanced language model. Our methodology was applied to the open-source
Qwen-7B-chat model, culminating in the development of Qwen-SFT-MoI. This
enhanced model demonstrates significant advancements in generative capabilities
across coding, mathematics, and tool use tasks.
|
[
-0.24034515023231506,
-0.8705273270606995,
0.49317455291748047,
0.29309213161468506,
-0.21048659086227417,
0.50433349609375,
-0.1403229832649231,
-0.0846802294254303,
-0.06452374160289764,
0.5839545726776123,
-0.7488015294075012,
-0.4991528391838074,
-0.5085278749465942,
-0.04042430967092514,
-0.5234251022338867,
0.6861993670463562,
0.08632300049066544,
0.22496366500854492,
-0.38503554463386536,
-0.19913296401500702,
-0.8417640328407288,
-0.3147243559360504,
-0.1478196233510971,
-0.25372782349586487,
0.28470954298973083,
0.6668484807014465,
0.5348736643791199,
0.7593334317207336,
0.6867734789848328,
0.3824302554130554,
0.23420152068138123,
0.4979725182056427,
-0.5940697193145752,
0.22920487821102142,
-0.10831265896558762,
-0.5096766352653503,
-0.46454259753227234,
-0.2476080060005188,
0.7088720798492432,
0.830093264579773,
-0.5033933520317078,
-0.22042816877365112,
0.4376157522201538,
0.5496097207069397,
-0.6569944620132446,
-0.2842938303947449,
-0.3873830735683441,
-0.21293672919273376,
-0.21492941677570343,
-0.18735851347446442,
-0.4826752841472626,
-0.25273779034614563,
0.08070801943540573,
-0.6774540543556213,
-0.16849255561828613,
0.05728660896420479,
0.3971056640148163,
0.2147587388753891,
-0.08988256007432938,
-0.1948785036802292,
-0.8117690086364746,
1.1631585359573364,
-0.6518279910087585,
0.3935837149620056,
-0.2204512506723404,
0.3355447053909302,
-0.3755127787590027,
-0.4061540365219116,
-0.5826329588890076,
-0.08166766166687012,
0.19127768278121948,
0.28508979082107544,
-0.20852753520011902,
0.2607400715351105,
0.10053637623786926,
0.518756091594696,
-0.5731102228164673,
0.3388742506504059,
-0.1481657475233078,
-0.10647799074649811,
0.31358277797698975,
0.31883758306503296,
0.7434317469596863,
0.19573453068733215,
-0.681388795375824,
-0.19383619725704193,
-0.5947696566581726,
-0.3379593789577484,
0.41226333379745483,
0.226562038064003,
-0.5643883943557739,
0.9234857559204102,
-0.22161762416362762,
0.9015164971351624,
0.3065923750400543,
-0.41825324296951294,
0.06750386953353882,
-0.5944828391075134,
-0.18009203672409058,
0.17303691804409027,
1.110576868057251,
0.34352171421051025,
-0.1916169375181198,
-0.14778047800064087,
-0.13316486775875092,
0.028422608971595764,
0.26616692543029785,
-0.5793669819831848,
-0.032440535724163055,
0.24335840344429016,
-0.35642266273498535,
-0.21660825610160828,
0.005181571934372187,
-0.7475160360336304,
-0.38180938363075256,
-0.5730595588684082,
0.48637324571609497,
-0.7884377837181091,
-0.10948313772678375,
0.23402893543243408,
-0.16821570694446564,
0.18544772267341614,
0.43038979172706604,
-0.8223920464515686,
0.22942785918712616,
1.0278842449188232,
0.756250262260437,
-0.2533508241176605,
-0.28414687514305115,
-0.7772341966629028,
0.19374710321426392,
-0.16291432082653046,
0.5371384024620056,
-0.9519841074943542,
-0.5067687034606934,
-0.20958276093006134,
-0.4394630491733551,
-0.1579519510269165,
-0.49844521284103394,
0.28141048550605774,
-0.16381002962589264,
0.5537010431289673,
-0.07102670520544052,
-0.6701080799102783,
-0.19757620990276337,
0.10760874301195145,
-0.5339301228523254,
1.1429829597473145,
0.3663232922554016,
-0.6602374911308289,
-0.20331375300884247,
-0.5910435914993286,
-0.4080040752887726,
0.07023221254348755,
-0.37248778343200684,
-0.00461095105856657,
0.2426604926586151,
0.16763277351856232,
0.3172481656074524,
-0.5798614025115967,
0.3420329988002777,
-0.2146424800157547,
-0.48784899711608887,
0.44871312379837036,
-0.6891287565231323,
0.9105903506278992,
0.06786346435546875,
-0.4047089219093323,
0.3135329484939575,
-0.7179834246635437,
-0.21515345573425293,
-0.32127171754837036,
-0.09077134728431702,
-0.293580561876297,
-0.10226624459028244,
-0.40880152583122253,
0.08478809893131256,
0.43806225061416626,
-0.3599962294101715,
0.3308801054954529,
-0.178047314286232,
0.26626089215278625,
0.6063693165779114,
-0.25591638684272766,
0.7016712427139282,
-0.3926449716091156,
0.6594752073287964,
0.11441212892532349,
0.12430097907781601,
-0.501549482345581,
-0.46864402294158936,
-0.8031931519508362,
-0.5989795923233032,
0.34985944628715515,
0.8948711156845093,
-0.8624375462532043,
0.7726722955703735,
-0.406601220369339,
-0.5562410950660706,
-0.7593821287155151,
0.10165493190288544,
0.6296870112419128,
0.5436574220657349,
0.3232073187828064,
-0.2840329706668854,
-0.4449433982372284,
-0.950054943561554,
0.3067827820777893,
-0.04757927730679512,
-0.00042704842053353786,
0.023212336003780365,
0.10806089639663696,
-0.15930823981761932,
0.4849112629890442,
-0.30034616589546204,
0.3293567895889282,
-0.282746285200119,
0.2695835828781128,
-0.13798008859157562,
0.7645780444145203,
0.2592991590499878,
-0.39878350496292114,
-0.4086313843727112,
0.3289106786251068,
-0.6612831354141235,
-0.29445406794548035,
-0.09924424439668655,
-0.7576581239700317,
-0.24677206575870514,
0.3553105592727661,
-0.4952949583530426,
-0.04537278041243553,
0.7996203303337097,
0.3231548070907593,
0.5814965963363647,
-0.15320022404193878,
0.533551812171936,
-1.3977011442184448,
-0.1133505180478096,
-0.11652348935604095,
-0.1482812762260437,
-0.5883366465568542,
0.30934786796569824,
-0.007909088395535946,
-0.1036139726638794,
-0.42040273547172546,
0.24399466812610626,
-0.5748774409294128,
0.2612105906009674,
-0.35850417613983154,
0.074209064245224,
0.10211347043514252,
0.34053343534469604,
-0.2726171910762787,
1.007676124572754,
0.8138874173164368,
-0.5740149021148682,
0.4476146697998047,
0.049169812351465225,
-0.2902179956436157,
0.8720889687538147,
-0.3791877329349518,
0.2732158899307251,
-0.09873221814632416,
0.11122561246156693,
-0.9730018377304077,
-0.27070534229278564,
0.44979438185691833,
-0.019224371761083603,
0.44292548298835754,
0.146180659532547,
-0.43147242069244385,
-0.05560886859893799,
-0.2595252990722656,
0.6113784313201904,
0.6995847225189209,
-0.2522358000278473,
1.0197960138320923,
0.23684823513031006,
-0.11281020194292068,
-0.7695145010948181,
-0.48339295387268066,
-0.06149742752313614,
-0.3972693085670471,
-0.6980398297309875,
0.7537546157836914,
-0.02506331354379654,
-0.2934771478176117,
-0.043745510280132294,
-0.03643586114048958,
0.24929307401180267,
0.11600601673126221,
0.037239834666252136,
0.5086271166801453,
-0.46273788809776306,
-0.2659178674221039,
0.2808184325695038,
-0.015159794129431248,
-0.34630149602890015,
-0.3491048216819763,
0.8444913625717163,
0.3223121464252472,
-0.6771531105041504,
-0.7610202431678772,
0.7458292841911316,
0.7205509543418884,
-0.3813090920448303,
0.7567387819290161,
0.39798304438591003,
-0.31249338388442993,
-0.08072901517152786,
-0.6709450483322144,
-0.08619473874568939,
-0.4697534143924713,
0.3633365333080292,
-0.22482740879058838,
-0.8199691772460938,
0.5134130120277405,
-0.1799863576889038,
0.17284198105335236,
0.2496272176504135,
0.36532407999038696,
-0.2135796844959259,
1.0596895217895508,
0.71958327293396,
-0.15557244420051575,
0.6861343383789062,
0.028797701001167297,
0.3357381820678711,
-1.0074759721755981,
-0.1522413194179535,
-0.5946619510650635,
-0.510329008102417,
-0.5715554356575012,
-0.806870698928833,
0.3503129482269287,
0.34137678146362305,
-0.12837128341197968,
0.3928511142730713,
-0.6404623985290527,
0.45749032497406006,
0.6018722057342529,
0.1597309112548828,
0.07264912873506546,
0.15741923451423645,
-0.21929237246513367,
0.16090743243694305,
-0.9172759652137756,
-0.5808091163635254,
0.825938880443573,
0.003410999197512865,
0.8751111626625061,
0.0034175594337284565,
0.9671943783760071,
0.058485161513090134,
0.2360294908285141,
-0.604128897190094,
0.6503862738609314,
-0.4851473867893219,
-0.1318988800048828,
-0.13438770174980164,
-0.4629986584186554,
-0.7144802212715149,
0.23945176601409912,
-0.18452517688274384,
-1.0103490352630615,
0.03597523272037506,
0.05331684276461601,
-0.752074658870697,
0.02279755100607872,
-0.8348330855369568,
0.847865879535675,
-0.46917903423309326,
-0.2867863178253174,
-0.3077344000339508,
-0.6430529952049255,
0.6495820879936218,
0.07614675909280777,
0.20685510337352753,
-0.062275126576423645,
-0.07446017861366272,
0.39549505710601807,
-0.4327172040939331,
0.9049202799797058,
0.27323880791664124,
-0.27867698669433594,
0.33897238969802856,
0.07376591116189957,
0.386514276266098,
-0.5755174160003662,
-0.01066095381975174,
-0.06344237923622131,
-0.2842302620410919,
-0.29596906900405884,
-0.8172587752342224,
0.6967811584472656,
-0.6328428983688354,
-0.5985045433044434,
0.03566250205039978,
-0.8408129811286926,
-0.07514841109514236,
-0.06615503877401352,
0.20159752666950226,
0.7820079922676086,
-0.19773395359516144,
0.2569926977157593,
0.831548810005188,
-0.3667038679122925,
0.09727814048528671,
0.22376374900341034,
-0.11418470740318298,
-0.546000063419342,
1.2883057594299316,
-0.08093734830617905,
0.6953197121620178,
0.7750304341316223,
0.10125110298395157,
-0.08544443547725677,
-0.37205445766448975,
-0.7307765483856201,
-0.028975678607821465,
-0.5814839005470276,
-0.23618635535240173,
-0.654249906539917,
-0.15688946843147278,
-0.18113893270492554,
-0.22510139644145966,
-0.2352249175310135,
-0.28460386395454407,
-0.295889675617218,
0.2702673077583313,
0.09010203927755356,
0.3974248766899109,
0.29533225297927856,
0.7675020098686218,
-1.25357985496521,
0.29064711928367615,
0.09342245012521744,
0.03682365640997887,
0.061389777809381485,
-0.23326049745082855,
-0.19292263686656952,
0.42374953627586365,
-0.47399812936782837,
-1.1198358535766602,
-0.0353940986096859,
0.020663168281316757,
0.7754415273666382,
0.4182107150554657,
-0.24884474277496338,
0.982643723487854,
-0.42633044719696045,
0.781919002532959,
0.5148224830627441,
-1.0209509134292603,
0.24735607206821442,
-0.36202913522720337,
0.3399202525615692,
0.46052777767181396,
0.09855955094099045,
-0.5504658222198486,
-0.6318062543869019,
-0.38811904191970825,
-0.7216662764549255,
0.6656140089035034,
0.2322729229927063,
0.18743470311164856,
0.017139827832579613,
0.07648834586143494,
0.4552614092826843,
0.2883553206920624,
-0.10382168740034103,
-0.04839826375246048,
0.2853523790836334,
-1.0080506801605225,
0.39692389965057373,
-0.0557839497923851,
-0.3031264841556549,
-0.01948763057589531,
0.5992616415023804,
-0.03844870254397392,
0.3416344225406647,
-0.34747573733329773,
-0.17271095514297485,
0.09396540373563766,
0.3163427412509918,
0.7951233983039856,
0.5390572547912598,
0.29650503396987915,
0.18505977094173431,
-0.09737038612365723,
-0.26972347497940063,
0.2907578647136688,
0.24422745406627655,
-0.13982851803302765,
-0.3088826537132263,
0.39187079668045044,
0.803104043006897,
0.41292688250541687,
-0.6302968263626099,
0.19691964983940125,
0.15653401613235474,
0.11013715714216232,
0.4446521997451782,
0.5738727450370789,
0.22339805960655212,
0.13408803939819336,
0.15764828026294708,
0.024627672508358955,
0.21744206547737122,
-0.6392033100128174,
0.05001217499375343,
0.501539945602417,
-0.15254512429237366,
-0.15793932974338531,
0.414716899394989,
0.4771323502063751,
-0.3203640878200531,
0.7280265092849731,
-0.07432662695646286,
-0.5742030739784241,
0.5182595252990723,
0.5016975402832031,
0.9529691934585571,
-0.42619046568870544,
0.20668798685073853,
0.14455558359622955,
0.17261144518852234,
-0.31230878829956055,
0.39801785349845886,
-0.049877870827913284,
-0.7683651447296143,
-0.7641012668609619,
-0.40641844272613525,
-0.3770023286342621,
-0.16635452210903168,
-0.4053594768047333,
0.22783353924751282,
-0.02044305019080639,
0.09582558274269104,
-0.026293089613318443,
-0.5050454139709473,
-0.4465789198875427,
0.028631946071982384,
0.3491757810115814,
0.5140806436538696,
-0.7174211740493774,
0.5023764967918396,
0.5825848579406738,
-0.258077472448349,
-0.8118774890899658,
0.047683972865343094,
0.10352976620197296,
-0.8082796335220337,
0.10721982270479202,
0.3432796001434326,
-0.2362012267112732,
-0.0688568502664566,
-0.5769441723823547,
-0.7455823421478271,
0.8731128573417664,
0.634002149105072,
-0.9898138046264648,
0.11445113271474838,
0.24565532803535461,
0.1956206113100052,
-0.6263906955718994,
0.2183951735496521,
0.5312501788139343,
0.2771049439907074,
0.08704473078250885,
-0.8706351518630981,
0.013857542537152767,
-0.14511723816394806,
-0.054595597088336945,
0.49500709772109985,
-0.6018792390823364,
0.6615930795669556,
0.0497656874358654,
-0.29062822461128235,
0.18267430365085602,
0.7897741198539734,
0.37752363085746765,
-0.08980367332696915,
0.5195363759994507,
0.6476064324378967,
0.9464428424835205,
-0.19897815585136414,
1.0103665590286255,
-0.4973905682563782,
-0.28454411029815674,
1.1276466846466064,
-0.436382532119751,
0.5722666382789612,
0.442577064037323,
-0.10749167948961258,
0.6257243752479553,
0.35302236676216125,
0.3444954454898834,
0.507493257522583,
0.06854604184627533,
-0.4882308542728424,
-0.3381586968898773,
-0.20075097680091858,
-0.24429967999458313,
0.3968449831008911,
0.38282567262649536,
-0.07428938150405884,
-0.10429549962282181,
0.03011573851108551,
-0.2925111651420593,
-0.05614517256617546,
-0.10241875052452087,
0.880413293838501,
0.013164029456675053,
-0.9619100689888,
0.2871098816394806,
-0.08008354157209396,
0.6805275082588196,
-0.521949052810669,
-0.34538382291793823,
-0.03110748715698719,
-0.0009222464286722243,
-0.07930858433246613,
-0.765405535697937,
-0.02268802374601364,
0.0017097069649025798,
-0.12164457887411118,
-0.06789349764585495,
0.4565390348434448,
-0.8104621767997742,
-0.658823549747467,
-0.03573140129446983,
0.6093271970748901,
0.01004110649228096,
0.1572485715150833,
-0.6543434262275696,
0.28988364338874817,
0.11566349864006042,
0.3228667676448822,
0.29767268896102905,
0.6284561157226562,
-0.16032515466213226,
0.5833373665809631,
0.4959869384765625,
-0.42042607069015503,
0.25140103697776794,
0.2529184818267822,
0.8751875758171082,
-0.33778491616249084,
-0.32026800513267517,
-1.1499898433685303,
0.9540879130363464,
-0.126573845744133,
-0.17102421820163727,
0.6029177904129028,
0.6079899072647095,
0.6545926332473755,
0.20208020508289337,
0.8689386248588562,
-0.01851007342338562,
-0.04026484861969948,
-0.7343578338623047,
0.0620315819978714,
-0.48894453048706055,
0.2222852259874344,
-0.14909455180168152,
-1.1052584648132324,
0.04004073888063431,
0.40102171897888184,
0.028595857322216034,
0.027688199654221535,
0.5709850788116455,
0.907450795173645,
-0.38620293140411377,
0.13685715198516846,
0.07801058143377304,
-0.33650314807891846,
0.1510450690984726,
0.3611452877521515,
1.0042318105697632,
-0.11748221516609192,
0.3520810902118683,
-0.4245128631591797,
-0.3112718164920807,
-0.27755680680274963,
-0.8105103373527527,
-0.5873836874961853,
-0.4288424551486969,
-0.6064988374710083,
-0.19499626755714417,
-0.011094151996076107,
1.083199381828308,
0.5666604042053223,
-0.5727238059043884,
-0.3902250826358795,
-0.0777873694896698,
0.058141179382801056,
-0.6603004336357117,
-0.19652315974235535,
0.037947941571474075,
-0.42070701718330383,
-0.8638081550598145,
0.6140984892845154,
0.6857064366340637,
0.1439519077539444,
-0.3275018036365509,
-0.07872195541858673,
-0.027328209951519966,
0.1972385197877884,
0.42601102590560913,
-0.20700599253177643,
-0.7210240364074707,
0.03602994605898857,
0.3493078351020813,
-0.4748938977718353,
0.15348109602928162,
0.7948206067085266,
-0.21995766460895538,
0.6989576816558838,
0.7613921761512756,
0.7449101805686951,
-0.053219735622406006,
0.3234044015407562,
1.2218800783157349,
-0.6599171161651611,
-0.010139847174286842,
0.1132541298866272,
0.3936942219734192,
0.6182166934013367,
-0.3247353732585907,
0.15639816224575043,
-0.20923015475273132,
-0.3097805976867676,
-0.7422240376472473,
0.2224999964237213,
-1.2336227893829346,
0.014340593479573727,
0.9560290575027466,
-0.00261688488535583,
-0.4087681770324707,
0.22485072910785675,
-0.6089931130409241,
0.4309614300727844,
-0.45051100850105286,
0.5559489130973816,
0.9458973407745361,
-0.06669752299785614,
-0.1045083999633789,
-0.2739332318305969,
-0.12899790704250336,
0.5142065286636353,
-0.8622573018074036,
-0.058402035385370255,
0.6744705438613892,
-0.0164002925157547,
0.2880255877971649,
0.33739492297172546,
-0.11133859306573868,
0.22799496352672577,
0.052248913794755936,
0.1946553885936737,
0.2255832701921463,
-0.2754216492176056,
-0.13197597861289978,
0.10898348689079285,
-0.1532084196805954,
-0.6090994477272034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18400v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18400v2
|
LLM-SR: Scientific Equation Discovery via Programming with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-29T03:30:06 | 2024-06-02T20:17:59 |
Parshin Shojaee, Kazem Meidani, Shashank Gupta, Amir Barati Farimani, Chandan K Reddy
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.NE
|
Mathematical equations have been unreasonably effective in describing complex
natural phenomena across various scientific disciplines. However, discovering
such insightful equations from data presents significant challenges due to the
necessity of navigating extremely high-dimensional combinatorial and nonlinear
hypothesis spaces. Traditional methods of equation discovery, commonly known as
symbolic regression, largely focus on extracting equations from data alone,
often neglecting the rich domain-specific prior knowledge that scientists
typically depend on. To bridge this gap, we introduce LLM-SR, a novel approach
that leverages the extensive scientific knowledge and robust code generation
capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) to discover scientific equations
from data in an efficient manner. Specifically, LLM-SR treats equations as
programs with mathematical operators and combines LLMs' scientific priors with
evolutionary search over equation programs. The LLM iteratively proposes new
equation skeleton hypotheses, drawing from its physical understanding, which
are then optimized against data to estimate skeleton parameters. We demonstrate
LLM-SR's effectiveness across three diverse scientific domains, where it
discovers physically accurate equations that provide significantly better fits
to in-domain and out-of-domain data compared to the well-established symbolic
regression baselines. Incorporating scientific prior knowledge also enables
LLM-SR to search the equation space more efficiently than baselines. Code is
available at: https://github.com/deep-symbolic-mathematics/LLM-SR
|
[
0.05515608936548233,
-0.6131685972213745,
1.0619010925292969,
0.4820263385772705,
-0.18394900858402252,
0.4317302405834198,
-0.15982122719287872,
-0.29781797528266907,
0.37907829880714417,
0.21312493085861206,
-0.637600302696228,
-0.6349908113479614,
-0.7064257264137268,
0.31236034631729126,
-0.1052107959985733,
0.5667034387588501,
-0.27910152077674866,
0.509886622428894,
-0.5054932236671448,
0.24156300723552704,
-0.006602832116186619,
-0.43581584095954895,
-0.331656277179718,
-0.5336308479309082,
0.47517117857933044,
-0.060046516358852386,
0.38833749294281006,
0.6475725769996643,
0.7823479175567627,
0.2751533091068268,
0.014475486241281033,
0.33444035053253174,
-0.6956996917724609,
0.44191980361938477,
0.030521593987941742,
-0.5338875651359558,
0.10528383404016495,
-0.2316606491804123,
0.7916660308837891,
0.6770519614219666,
-0.09273791313171387,
0.1747957468032837,
-0.3627927005290985,
0.6271509528160095,
-0.46130430698394775,
0.6954495906829834,
-0.7342643737792969,
0.11897088587284088,
-0.24981766939163208,
-0.527130126953125,
-0.2872732877731323,
-0.3594895303249359,
0.13886746764183044,
-0.8088719248771667,
0.3417103886604309,
0.018882744014263153,
0.6298273801803589,
0.4957534372806549,
-0.2425464540719986,
-0.293424516916275,
-0.7575448155403137,
1.0574003458023071,
-0.5807567238807678,
0.5627099871635437,
0.19329486787319183,
0.19949331879615784,
-0.7784628868103027,
-0.725051760673523,
-0.27158448100090027,
-0.5274417400360107,
0.09923110902309418,
0.014019427821040154,
-0.32366466522216797,
-0.2695355713367462,
0.202357679605484,
-0.06017354875802994,
-0.7014690637588501,
-0.014134140685200691,
-0.4328994154930115,
-0.2820238471031189,
0.7600430846214294,
0.17166265845298767,
0.3719520568847656,
-0.11736057698726654,
-0.18217574059963226,
-0.0008706086664460599,
-0.9884216785430908,
-0.2516346573829651,
0.18636147677898407,
0.5762948989868164,
-0.0771559402346611,
0.8081306219100952,
0.1302611082792282,
0.42196789383888245,
-0.49621716141700745,
-0.2573980391025543,
0.01865978166460991,
-0.09643615037202835,
0.03584809601306915,
0.025858569890260696,
0.6370344758033752,
-0.10670758783817291,
0.047615647315979004,
-0.1685551106929779,
-0.2930832505226135,
0.32791247963905334,
-0.09140519052743912,
-0.7557704448699951,
-0.3308240473270416,
-0.0764053538441658,
-0.3449985384941101,
-0.09986864775419235,
-0.27721190452575684,
-0.5751547813415527,
-0.493564248085022,
-0.6055843830108643,
0.5210065841674805,
-0.19669780135154724,
-0.11986634880304337,
0.09954387694597244,
-0.15973113477230072,
-0.19713608920574188,
0.48635542392730713,
-0.3217025697231293,
0.10085185617208481,
0.6820216178894043,
1.039207935333252,
-0.07668644189834595,
0.03922538459300995,
-0.5279815196990967,
0.08602246642112732,
-0.4505300521850586,
0.5770776867866516,
-0.8444925546646118,
-0.42316263914108276,
-0.32898908853530884,
-0.3074997663497925,
-0.009036987088620663,
-0.5742125511169434,
0.3398464322090149,
-0.5151108503341675,
-0.10042278468608856,
0.08029118180274963,
-0.5201829075813293,
0.17535574734210968,
-0.1838684380054474,
-0.5255817770957947,
1.1535441875457764,
0.08094068616628647,
-0.5634259581565857,
-0.11638829857110977,
-0.7149463891983032,
-0.164463073015213,
0.18588107824325562,
-0.3039788007736206,
-0.39237406849861145,
0.48668453097343445,
0.18117298185825348,
0.21869094669818878,
-0.6973991990089417,
0.46019279956817627,
-0.4748404324054718,
-0.23896081745624542,
0.22469767928123474,
-0.06320173293352127,
0.5463992357254028,
0.29192009568214417,
0.029360130429267883,
-0.018293488770723343,
-0.5682671070098877,
-0.026782069355249405,
0.6427018046379089,
-0.017465628683567047,
-0.6923000812530518,
0.24185128509998322,
-0.3585882782936096,
-0.12291480600833893,
0.3520856499671936,
-0.6780641674995422,
0.39706501364707947,
-0.16604866087436676,
0.5679470300674438,
0.7506118416786194,
-0.1915932148694992,
0.2114231288433075,
0.02358395792543888,
0.5703927278518677,
-0.35461318492889404,
-0.0289261806756258,
-0.03573906049132347,
-0.5175419449806213,
-0.3002355694770813,
-0.3500676453113556,
0.06679954379796982,
0.17428742349147797,
-0.5939489006996155,
0.13523782789707184,
-0.4708205461502075,
-0.5559861660003662,
-0.4444678723812103,
0.19621682167053223,
0.35183656215667725,
0.602060079574585,
0.5316656827926636,
0.25658532977104187,
-0.8543052077293396,
-0.8427821397781372,
-0.15869921445846558,
-0.15032708644866943,
-0.127287358045578,
0.5312076210975647,
0.6686612367630005,
-0.5038661360740662,
0.8914529085159302,
-0.9599742293357849,
-0.060490552335977554,
-0.07250664383172989,
0.1886819303035736,
0.23294119536876678,
0.3669152557849884,
0.28197816014289856,
-0.7310839891433716,
-0.3973486125469208,
0.030141694471240044,
-0.9507419466972351,
-0.4663272202014923,
0.12306757271289825,
-0.030621355399489403,
-0.04961712285876274,
0.4649111330509186,
-0.5977017283439636,
0.13397793471813202,
0.6078999638557434,
0.1498449742794037,
0.6728606224060059,
-0.13323894143104553,
-0.13330861926078796,
-0.8278427124023438,
0.08231273293495178,
0.5119534134864807,
0.07334792613983154,
-0.4911539554595947,
0.45870861411094666,
0.12457060068845749,
-0.10788596421480179,
-0.2272930145263672,
0.5590544939041138,
-0.6846531629562378,
-0.17868037521839142,
-0.004244867712259293,
0.10412492603063583,
-0.35854479670524597,
0.17748615145683289,
0.25569838285446167,
0.6976819634437561,
0.6521176695823669,
-0.394079327583313,
0.2650240659713745,
0.09151162207126617,
-0.09058725833892822,
0.08590273559093475,
-0.6976149082183838,
0.14141622185707092,
-0.4847429096698761,
0.39749452471733093,
-0.6782020330429077,
-0.17629314959049225,
-0.054555680602788925,
-0.45600321888923645,
0.29342320561408997,
-0.4921899735927582,
-0.4478670656681061,
-0.3690163195133209,
-0.3007839620113373,
0.5891481041908264,
0.4489179253578186,
-0.6447538733482361,
0.8383344411849976,
0.5271083116531372,
-0.4765167832374573,
-0.524146318435669,
-0.003031365340575576,
0.07515998929738998,
-0.06319917738437653,
-0.6975929141044617,
0.43119415640830994,
-0.2039528340101242,
-0.3529087007045746,
0.023007832467556,
-0.8497275114059448,
-0.07901714742183685,
-0.0305339302867651,
0.11852529644966125,
0.42871996760368347,
-0.24370978772640228,
0.020429009571671486,
0.059459760785102844,
-0.2345028668642044,
0.3242458403110504,
-0.4270857870578766,
0.7405702471733093,
-0.07617903500795364,
-0.24526673555374146,
-0.10692029446363449,
0.1681196093559265,
0.4664423167705536,
-0.10191526263952255,
0.20731188356876373,
0.16055819392204285,
-0.6693432331085205,
-0.46927523612976074,
-0.3281451165676117,
-0.25482815504074097,
-0.4533674120903015,
0.5388919711112976,
-0.24004873633384705,
-0.8251587748527527,
0.39116808772087097,
-0.4708254337310791,
-0.042736444622278214,
0.18073642253875732,
0.37046730518341064,
0.03734147176146507,
1.3535715341567993,
0.5969610810279846,
0.17340922355651855,
0.19519151747226715,
-0.1865595430135727,
0.497610867023468,
-0.5866586565971375,
-0.668857753276825,
-0.8492386937141418,
-0.1896122843027115,
-0.16405928134918213,
-0.6208178997039795,
0.6787458658218384,
0.17200914025306702,
-0.4148414433002472,
0.3367100954055786,
-0.44389963150024414,
0.4854870140552521,
0.4014952480792999,
0.2150905877351761,
0.19663850963115692,
0.05348355323076248,
-0.26437175273895264,
-0.3437333405017853,
-0.4679456353187561,
-0.30773216485977173,
1.0115324258804321,
0.33620885014533997,
1.224457859992981,
0.07550135254859924,
0.9130926728248596,
0.0714295357465744,
0.6030424237251282,
-0.8392257690429688,
0.5040332078933716,
-0.21457059681415558,
-0.12403050065040588,
-0.11340111494064331,
-0.9884569048881531,
-0.9732958078384399,
0.3554266095161438,
-0.24713771045207977,
-0.7028653025627136,
-0.3025897443294525,
0.292976975440979,
0.009151470847427845,
0.13070321083068848,
-0.6320815682411194,
0.4726201891899109,
-0.617910623550415,
-0.2680553197860718,
-0.19842076301574707,
-0.6465321183204651,
0.49953320622444153,
-0.41715294122695923,
0.42674320936203003,
-0.14152555167675018,
0.004486254416406155,
0.5789198279380798,
-0.37247365713119507,
0.7300977110862732,
-0.20236065983772278,
-0.31609514355659485,
-0.04455464333295822,
0.3949992060661316,
0.7630285620689392,
0.2518395185470581,
0.13131029903888702,
0.16388939321041107,
0.02619900368154049,
-0.3391994833946228,
-0.8979631662368774,
1.1142380237579346,
-0.6714743971824646,
-0.7248912453651428,
-0.5058006048202515,
-0.8052619099617004,
-0.0772530734539032,
0.21211953461170197,
-0.24370703101158142,
0.15908585488796234,
0.25910571217536926,
0.2665320038795471,
0.7758139371871948,
-0.33120936155319214,
0.09324496239423752,
0.7337696552276611,
-0.3544134795665741,
-0.33524802327156067,
0.9799444079399109,
-0.047050878405570984,
-0.10191716998815536,
0.6204532980918884,
0.591840386390686,
-0.5180613994598389,
-0.6340723037719727,
-0.11676929891109467,
0.503221869468689,
-0.44037163257598877,
-0.6500556468963623,
-0.5613616704940796,
-0.14412176609039307,
-0.22828154265880585,
-0.14133214950561523,
-0.30126819014549255,
-0.3629709780216217,
-0.16288621723651886,
0.022951453924179077,
0.292228639125824,
0.6032381057739258,
-0.0950920581817627,
0.010254866443574429,
-0.7724500894546509,
0.5417319536209106,
-0.11638709157705307,
0.2097020149230957,
-0.1912691742181778,
-0.0521661713719368,
-0.022191453725099564,
0.24683637917041779,
0.035633385181427,
-0.7818279266357422,
0.7751633524894714,
0.07732522487640381,
0.8069121837615967,
-0.02121485397219658,
0.04761001840233803,
0.8771266341209412,
-0.4515405595302582,
0.5311731696128845,
0.3950836658477783,
-1.0577445030212402,
0.5165161490440369,
-0.15006858110427856,
-0.16499119997024536,
-0.25345999002456665,
0.762930691242218,
-0.18291637301445007,
-0.3348313271999359,
-0.32462644577026367,
-0.9738433361053467,
0.3886277973651886,
0.23759059607982635,
-0.026953207328915596,
0.16915172338485718,
0.5202627778053284,
0.11792324483394623,
0.13872435688972473,
-0.8305681347846985,
-0.22111286222934723,
-0.053128212690353394,
-0.4299050271511078,
-0.02539345994591713,
0.08145131170749664,
-0.34453293681144714,
-0.3176894187927246,
0.5658064484596252,
-0.2820512056350708,
0.2202303558588028,
0.26939916610717773,
-0.23727911710739136,
-0.46869105100631714,
-0.12953098118305206,
0.7017548084259033,
0.6708678603172302,
-0.1777692586183548,
0.5164632797241211,
-0.13511183857917786,
-0.5760467052459717,
-0.11297290027141571,
0.29056450724601746,
-0.07426171004772186,
0.022876061499118805,
0.41758278012275696,
0.46036991477012634,
0.3290366232395172,
-1.0615228414535522,
0.08219819515943527,
0.01817711628973484,
-0.34328922629356384,
-0.3951404392719269,
-0.05237715691328049,
0.20495426654815674,
0.32736650109291077,
0.7969101071357727,
0.16660936176776886,
-0.04060008004307747,
-0.2799701392650604,
0.09054844081401825,
0.8897687196731567,
0.21883565187454224,
-0.37700220942497253,
0.7620419263839722,
-0.13963699340820312,
-0.2460125833749771,
0.4714154303073883,
0.16670842468738556,
-0.6310018301010132,
0.7534173130989075,
0.8930943608283997,
0.5135210156440735,
0.026784956455230713,
0.31890612840652466,
0.22018346190452576,
0.04744415730237961,
-0.22363677620887756,
0.30644461512565613,
0.1083749532699585,
-0.5528920888900757,
-0.5741065144538879,
-0.7466302514076233,
-0.2776380479335785,
0.21361443400382996,
-0.395877480506897,
0.20603129267692566,
-0.41033634543418884,
0.026790659874677658,
0.29189884662628174,
0.1319182813167572,
-0.4621894657611847,
-0.18578188121318817,
0.07743967324495316,
0.8696637749671936,
-0.822950541973114,
0.6210726499557495,
0.6455950736999512,
-0.184637650847435,
-0.7854894399642944,
-0.3490809500217438,
0.15686845779418945,
-1.2044298648834229,
1.193070650100708,
-0.08271653205156326,
-0.42620283365249634,
0.18924406170845032,
-1.1710889339447021,
-1.2962162494659424,
1.1315244436264038,
0.714422881603241,
-0.5923094153404236,
0.022635795176029205,
-0.16354696452617645,
0.7144758701324463,
-0.38931208848953247,
-0.01899329200387001,
0.19574269652366638,
0.5684177279472351,
0.37738606333732605,
-0.757847249507904,
0.06262517720460892,
-0.389372855424881,
-0.02805239148437977,
0.6086658835411072,
-0.24254919588565826,
0.7479842305183411,
-0.5394359230995178,
-0.24312224984169006,
0.1507105529308319,
0.4972357451915741,
0.8092056512832642,
0.5393393635749817,
0.06539653241634369,
0.4631568193435669,
0.7107557058334351,
-0.11980212479829788,
0.7461923956871033,
-0.3819863200187683,
0.6604858636856079,
0.6634705066680908,
-0.5725624561309814,
0.7060767412185669,
0.7430907487869263,
-0.3289492428302765,
0.3462170958518982,
0.5202773213386536,
-0.10914821177721024,
0.4622167646884918,
0.8322013020515442,
-0.3158302903175354,
-0.462837815284729,
-0.19050244987010956,
-0.27616745233535767,
-0.12356312572956085,
0.5717418193817139,
-0.2510787546634674,
-0.33284011483192444,
-0.3440416157245636,
0.030341677367687225,
0.1634342223405838,
-0.35743293166160583,
0.2771646976470947,
0.20335406064987183,
-0.23822160065174103,
0.611443817615509,
-0.04896536096930504,
0.575468122959137,
-0.9212437272071838,
-0.516192615032196,
-0.1556016206741333,
0.030091552063822746,
-0.19396615028381348,
-0.6392858028411865,
0.03623625263571739,
0.025212598964571953,
-0.042504433542490005,
-0.15290039777755737,
0.5935661196708679,
-0.44087615609169006,
-0.6678852438926697,
0.2125057876110077,
0.5548261404037476,
0.1517881602048874,
0.3282778263092041,
-0.3746258318424225,
0.23087003827095032,
-0.06143784150481224,
0.0029308393131941557,
0.22743205726146698,
0.1625969558954239,
-0.21793638169765472,
1.2376457452774048,
1.1065949201583862,
0.21672150492668152,
0.21635492146015167,
-0.08533686399459839,
1.0719213485717773,
-0.4164905250072479,
-0.04067446291446686,
-0.6767504215240479,
0.07717695832252502,
0.10318354517221451,
0.10954859107732773,
0.5868860483169556,
0.7825143933296204,
0.7529119253158569,
-0.41004475951194763,
0.8731294870376587,
0.0917351022362709,
0.29712191224098206,
-0.6600766777992249,
0.2624119818210602,
-0.638384997844696,
0.48029783368110657,
-0.2781624495983124,
-0.9584253430366516,
-0.837384819984436,
0.8247212171554565,
-0.2504799962043762,
-0.11822309345006943,
0.6465720534324646,
0.8584035038948059,
-0.08630836009979248,
-0.05912163853645325,
-0.09487840533256531,
0.2881639003753662,
0.5631725788116455,
0.35386401414871216,
0.8951497077941895,
0.16532769799232483,
0.30770188570022583,
-0.17212270200252533,
-0.3334781229496002,
-0.042884357273578644,
-1.195273756980896,
-0.5258908271789551,
-0.43937382102012634,
-0.22886261343955994,
-0.2763740122318268,
0.18676263093948364,
1.3896490335464478,
0.5420497059822083,
-0.6379812955856323,
-0.17452889680862427,
-0.26294535398483276,
0.16323508322238922,
-0.1446254849433899,
-0.28728434443473816,
0.34668681025505066,
-0.2843691408634186,
-0.6906724572181702,
0.8258771300315857,
0.2763494551181793,
0.2246669977903366,
-0.2758753001689911,
-0.3925362229347229,
0.1830955147743225,
0.1873350739479065,
0.5436948537826538,
0.5067446827888489,
-0.5612021088600159,
-0.014264716766774654,
0.39486879110336304,
0.14348088204860687,
-0.22126130759716034,
1.2202391624450684,
-0.7069469094276428,
0.20280423760414124,
0.522358238697052,
0.5719218850135803,
0.6599797606468201,
-0.09444271773099899,
0.7341086864471436,
-0.6471750736236572,
-0.2171689122915268,
0.49198800325393677,
0.6359401345252991,
0.17450957000255585,
-0.22095882892608643,
0.5908191204071045,
0.4954919219017029,
-0.38211748003959656,
-1.2381764650344849,
0.45078322291374207,
-1.0717581510543823,
-0.5201922059059143,
1.0095583200454712,
-0.110688716173172,
-0.07578884810209274,
0.07546954602003098,
-0.1333940476179123,
-0.06781735271215439,
-0.3997514545917511,
1.117585301399231,
0.23518936336040497,
-0.5642492771148682,
-0.2802514135837555,
-0.4027213454246521,
0.29337361454963684,
0.14159050583839417,
-0.5586751699447632,
0.09701189398765564,
0.5678727030754089,
0.3532620370388031,
0.29962489008903503,
0.0405411422252655,
-0.23903043568134308,
-0.19706183671951294,
-0.21205124258995056,
-0.07265733927488327,
-0.4232245981693268,
-0.4236839711666107,
0.06848577409982681,
0.1942911297082901,
-0.17971821129322052,
0.4839009940624237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18398v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18398v1
|
MM-TTS: A Unified Framework for Multimodal, Prompt-Induced Emotional Text-to-Speech Synthesis
| 2024-04-29T03:19:39 | 2024-04-29T03:19:39 |
Xiang Li, Zhi-Qi Cheng, Jun-Yan He, Xiaojiang Peng, Alexander G. Hauptmann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Emotional Text-to-Speech (E-TTS) synthesis has gained significant attention
in recent years due to its potential to enhance human-computer interaction.
However, current E-TTS approaches often struggle to capture the complexity of
human emotions, primarily relying on oversimplified emotional labels or
single-modality inputs. To address these limitations, we propose the Multimodal
Emotional Text-to-Speech System (MM-TTS), a unified framework that leverages
emotional cues from multiple modalities to generate highly expressive and
emotionally resonant speech. MM-TTS consists of two key components: (1) the
Emotion Prompt Alignment Module (EP-Align), which employs contrastive learning
to align emotional features across text, audio, and visual modalities, ensuring
a coherent fusion of multimodal information; and (2) the Emotion
Embedding-Induced TTS (EMI-TTS), which integrates the aligned emotional
embeddings with state-of-the-art TTS models to synthesize speech that
accurately reflects the intended emotions. Extensive evaluations across diverse
datasets demonstrate the superior performance of MM-TTS compared to traditional
E-TTS models. Objective metrics, including Word Error Rate (WER) and Character
Error Rate (CER), show significant improvements on ESD dataset, with MM-TTS
achieving scores of 7.35% and 3.07%, respectively. Subjective assessments
further validate that MM-TTS generates speech with emotional fidelity and
naturalness comparable to human speech. Our code and pre-trained models are
publicly available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/MMTTS-D214
|
[
-0.5755137801170349,
-0.6975752711296082,
0.48678240180015564,
0.4158199727535248,
-0.2667107880115509,
0.2792533338069916,
-0.32809847593307495,
-0.08740736544132233,
0.43791064620018005,
-0.02430993691086769,
-0.9540309906005859,
-0.5729150176048279,
-0.36388877034187317,
0.6244277954101562,
-0.23009005188941956,
0.9409939050674438,
0.14350125193595886,
-0.0003142495988868177,
0.19053396582603455,
-0.09820158034563065,
-0.3296840786933899,
-0.5845863223075867,
-0.3559551239013672,
0.023024898022413254,
0.7946223020553589,
0.4790459871292114,
0.29299086332321167,
0.2865186929702759,
0.2255796194076538,
0.2925434112548828,
0.06795412302017212,
0.35711973905563354,
-0.11164319515228271,
0.6491686105728149,
0.1341252475976944,
-0.017465712502598763,
-0.6411449313163757,
-0.11085657775402069,
0.3768562972545624,
0.05608946084976196,
-0.27760204672813416,
0.003464220790192485,
0.040121838450431824,
0.4587889611721039,
-0.6384759545326233,
-0.1764395833015442,
-0.31399720907211304,
0.19937710464000702,
-0.11627454310655594,
-0.39243096113204956,
-0.6140193343162537,
-0.15993370115756989,
0.2976111173629761,
-0.5323038101196289,
-0.224673330783844,
0.12433643639087677,
0.23053084313869476,
0.2942122519016266,
-0.9229573607444763,
-0.37516704201698303,
-0.5402011275291443,
0.5857298374176025,
-0.36050382256507874,
0.7471378445625305,
-0.11868342757225037,
0.2537674009799957,
0.17904043197631836,
-0.5930262207984924,
-0.7208443284034729,
-0.23599542677402496,
0.2904335558414459,
0.6406405568122864,
-0.3838336765766144,
0.327555775642395,
-0.015078830532729626,
-0.04741036891937256,
-0.7477876543998718,
0.0724138393998146,
0.012242517434060574,
-0.2278548777103424,
0.2142881155014038,
0.30401936173439026,
0.4874831736087799,
-0.37005046010017395,
-0.48803701996803284,
-0.2232109159231186,
-0.3965229094028473,
-0.1300131231546402,
0.2816797196865082,
0.686190664768219,
-0.42118632793426514,
0.8408820033073425,
0.029857022687792778,
0.26179492473602295,
0.036413490772247314,
-0.15470220148563385,
0.3915192484855652,
-0.23533913493156433,
-0.23589707911014557,
0.16745580732822418,
1.032665729522705,
0.6522111296653748,
0.10419502854347229,
-0.011696302331984043,
-0.2198970764875412,
0.47979405522346497,
0.012681526131927967,
-0.8928083181381226,
0.3579215407371521,
0.501466691493988,
-0.2059289813041687,
-0.22644540667533875,
-0.023855503648519516,
-1.3080037832260132,
-0.260536253452301,
-0.5237343907356262,
0.41982346773147583,
-0.4836323857307434,
-0.4699338674545288,
-0.012632369995117188,
-0.3253076374530792,
-0.2576332092285156,
0.1267312616109848,
-0.7131219506263733,
-0.08171982318162918,
0.3085381090641022,
0.873444676399231,
0.030680472031235695,
-0.3976413607597351,
-0.5989653468132019,
0.2143285870552063,
-0.16464628279209137,
0.5826717019081116,
-0.6230089664459229,
-0.5921761393547058,
0.06574688106775284,
-0.2375161200761795,
0.039776511490345,
-0.17529715597629547,
0.8642905354499817,
0.06560174375772476,
0.39022204279899597,
-0.1846722811460495,
-0.33807113766670227,
0.27923327684402466,
-0.033685505390167236,
-0.43979981541633606,
0.9258038997650146,
-0.31193527579307556,
-0.5104276537895203,
0.042508892714977264,
-0.8806308507919312,
-0.3710812032222748,
-0.44323456287384033,
0.03566332161426544,
-0.17422641813755035,
0.36123722791671753,
0.3814949095249176,
0.4940926134586334,
-0.47447261214256287,
0.3261062800884247,
-0.32147201895713806,
-0.07408661395311356,
0.3606035113334656,
-0.7913164496421814,
0.1637815237045288,
0.5744553804397583,
-0.37393009662628174,
0.24076847732067108,
-0.7876765131950378,
0.07786155492067337,
0.08350691199302673,
-0.13650231063365936,
-0.07119002938270569,
-0.15828439593315125,
0.403006911277771,
0.4614669978618622,
-0.06984356790781021,
-0.6666439175605774,
-0.15456682443618774,
-0.20454655587673187,
0.525202751159668,
0.8823431730270386,
-0.19750851392745972,
0.3096621632575989,
-0.22884896397590637,
0.567139744758606,
0.1403178572654724,
-0.060247309505939484,
-0.7760142683982849,
-0.4149390161037445,
-0.43515390157699585,
-0.5690479278564453,
-0.038592543452978134,
0.5635637640953064,
-0.6970167756080627,
0.42532187700271606,
-0.13398392498493195,
-0.5412479043006897,
-0.7954492568969727,
-0.6911250948905945,
0.438018262386322,
0.6020733118057251,
0.4468418061733246,
0.08210988342761993,
-0.74809730052948,
-0.6290442943572998,
-0.13630488514900208,
-0.24007190763950348,
-0.2937605679035187,
0.12103667110204697,
0.20951062440872192,
-0.36596667766571045,
0.8616604804992676,
-0.21148698031902313,
-0.34718140959739685,
0.22433148324489594,
0.6046044826507568,
-0.36189210414886475,
0.4183313250541687,
0.4371142089366913,
-0.5552060008049011,
-0.3080641031265259,
0.0017930519534274936,
-0.49953973293304443,
-0.5879692435264587,
-0.07644466310739517,
0.1151285320520401,
0.23387260735034943,
0.3441407084465027,
-0.6821851134300232,
-0.006579340901225805,
0.6930663585662842,
-0.4648800194263458,
0.7615177035331726,
-0.18435071408748627,
0.6316283345222473,
-1.3579035997390747,
0.11491679400205612,
0.14995071291923523,
-0.06798415631055832,
-0.6692958474159241,
-0.23740358650684357,
-0.0711316242814064,
-0.4194211959838867,
-0.5081073641777039,
0.44801950454711914,
-0.3240893483161926,
-0.006322883535176516,
0.042712751775979996,
0.5040570497512817,
0.14780007302761078,
0.6038095355033875,
-0.20282988250255585,
0.7439935207366943,
0.5531639456748962,
-0.3416256010532379,
0.5594417452812195,
0.2740798592567444,
0.23868730664253235,
1.4197379350662231,
-0.5240284204483032,
0.20775996148586273,
-0.3016853332519531,
0.3770425319671631,
-0.9692281484603882,
-0.2606167495250702,
0.13576066493988037,
-0.6913122534751892,
0.1539008915424347,
0.12844763696193695,
-0.3692186176776886,
-0.2435104250907898,
-0.30787530541419983,
0.1973123550415039,
0.4860551953315735,
-0.48288825154304504,
1.147029995918274,
0.3437527120113373,
-0.6843008399009705,
-0.3122689127922058,
-0.8010420799255371,
0.30121615529060364,
-0.3078352212905884,
-0.6458425521850586,
0.4435330033302307,
-0.4608690142631531,
0.07086575031280518,
-0.09405743330717087,
0.1063704863190651,
-0.03913785517215729,
-0.26230594515800476,
0.27914294600486755,
0.1472960114479065,
-0.13137654960155487,
0.4042667746543884,
0.4956631362438202,
-0.22146327793598175,
0.05132373049855232,
-0.01214254554361105,
0.4442017674446106,
-0.1992928385734558,
-0.5588882565498352,
-0.826848030090332,
0.7954716086387634,
1.3081321716308594,
-0.44612255692481995,
0.23215000331401825,
0.8485056161880493,
-0.38934871554374695,
0.030877284705638885,
-0.3467091917991638,
-0.16069206595420837,
-0.4564865529537201,
0.5834693908691406,
-0.482930064201355,
-0.8902788758277893,
0.3501497805118561,
-0.22801202535629272,
-0.02988259121775627,
0.34245118498802185,
0.7178956866264343,
-0.15765413641929626,
1.579317569732666,
0.27146852016448975,
0.09111892431974411,
0.6245725750923157,
0.37780505418777466,
-0.03676585480570793,
-0.8204135298728943,
-0.4075557291507721,
-0.6562169790267944,
-0.21381418406963348,
-0.43893730640411377,
-0.1575196385383606,
0.5792357921600342,
-0.5427296161651611,
-0.4508259892463684,
-0.20674383640289307,
-0.6375017762184143,
0.1304619163274765,
0.3469342589378357,
0.10528834909200668,
-0.016588086262345314,
0.04776616767048836,
-0.3289646506309509,
-0.45386600494384766,
-0.2983548641204834,
-0.569444477558136,
0.9943758845329285,
0.2286493182182312,
0.5091858506202698,
0.3157893419265747,
0.5196003317832947,
0.2598010003566742,
0.2628892958164215,
-0.6471647620201111,
0.4338582754135132,
-0.20714186131954193,
-0.3718019425868988,
-0.012401648797094822,
-0.5309188961982727,
-0.6862752437591553,
0.27858975529670715,
-0.5626261234283447,
-0.6669371128082275,
-0.1610148549079895,
0.045725006610155106,
-0.38556236028671265,
0.11366502940654755,
-1.1216917037963867,
0.6672639846801758,
-0.28571152687072754,
-0.190446138381958,
-0.046488288789987564,
-0.8337130546569824,
0.1018814966082573,
-0.11726827919483185,
0.4151625633239746,
-0.16852067410945892,
-0.1321248561143875,
0.6295333504676819,
-0.140353724360466,
0.7911239266395569,
-0.16300928592681885,
-0.11501052975654602,
0.06849490851163864,
0.1286647915840149,
0.3981950283050537,
-0.1432386040687561,
-0.04798199236392975,
-0.198403462767601,
-0.12980243563652039,
0.11206799745559692,
-0.6148844957351685,
0.5513466000556946,
-0.5273252725601196,
-0.18311892449855804,
-0.2114514410495758,
-0.45795494318008423,
-0.40594482421875,
0.1046776995062828,
0.22012446820735931,
0.7936803102493286,
-0.40318527817726135,
0.10376906394958496,
0.5408740639686584,
-0.2286502867937088,
0.44053229689598083,
0.3713207244873047,
-0.37979474663734436,
-1.0110656023025513,
0.98681640625,
-0.15699826180934906,
0.23653540015220642,
0.38522449135780334,
0.17764639854431152,
-0.5173212289810181,
0.09520116448402405,
-0.5363186597824097,
0.15283134579658508,
-0.5469887256622314,
-0.2817586362361908,
-0.7431315183639526,
0.24576380848884583,
-0.3621028959751129,
-0.35658127069473267,
-0.5764111280441284,
-0.19180597364902496,
-0.7058996558189392,
-0.2949899435043335,
0.37614676356315613,
0.5655291080474854,
-0.21155831217765808,
0.22289681434631348,
-1.1688013076782227,
0.554004967212677,
0.35800668597221375,
0.28620392084121704,
-0.1835935413837433,
-0.433244526386261,
0.14898903667926788,
0.3483494222164154,
-0.30505698919296265,
-1.2253590822219849,
0.5533326864242554,
0.3088642656803131,
0.043939027935266495,
0.40813878178596497,
0.1646677851676941,
0.7547398805618286,
-0.757058322429657,
0.9203799366950989,
0.8215188980102539,
-1.351944088935852,
0.5439695119857788,
-0.35256290435791016,
0.2574068307876587,
0.08365555852651596,
0.05332205444574356,
-0.8502471446990967,
-0.5198052525520325,
-0.3622036576271057,
-0.9610650539398193,
0.6376810073852539,
0.39652881026268005,
0.011970444582402706,
-0.05430665239691734,
-0.039118971675634384,
-0.026528578251600266,
0.2580466866493225,
-0.35159116983413696,
-0.3964157998561859,
-0.3500538170337677,
-0.9350734353065491,
-0.01886339671909809,
-0.3177544176578522,
-0.030920589342713356,
0.1937229484319687,
0.5737730264663696,
-0.2294088751077652,
0.6339825391769409,
0.24027109146118164,
0.0998096913099289,
-0.26624149084091187,
0.6978397369384766,
0.8425448536872864,
-0.15207581222057343,
-0.21233192086219788,
0.32477837800979614,
-0.0035152891650795937,
-0.2317143827676773,
0.40995660424232483,
0.2681649625301361,
0.318231463432312,
0.18492509424686432,
-0.1500517725944519,
0.8882423043251038,
0.19339428842067719,
-0.8127273321151733,
0.463314950466156,
-0.17152030766010284,
0.056254539638757706,
0.19368799030780792,
-0.49375319480895996,
0.1673242598772049,
0.38627249002456665,
0.41273534297943115,
0.25079265236854553,
0.04154716059565544,
-0.36857205629348755,
0.27715420722961426,
0.1491476446390152,
-0.48980292677879333,
-0.7482320666313171,
0.8452746868133545,
0.682197630405426,
-0.40504035353660583,
0.26064327359199524,
-0.08891008049249649,
-0.6016314625740051,
0.37907251715660095,
0.644019603729248,
1.1636534929275513,
-0.6545748710632324,
0.28897765278816223,
0.22002056241035461,
0.3342588245868683,
0.21200984716415405,
0.6629688739776611,
0.12253724038600922,
-0.34170976281166077,
-0.14975768327713013,
-0.335821270942688,
-0.6543368101119995,
-0.44897615909576416,
-0.6069076061248779,
0.30475178360939026,
-0.13717642426490784,
-0.5006785988807678,
-0.16809450089931488,
-0.6927991509437561,
-0.39651069045066833,
0.5566741824150085,
0.4264380633831024,
0.5068198442459106,
-0.8323549628257751,
0.26622599363327026,
0.6836875081062317,
-0.3203337788581848,
-0.6871651411056519,
-0.26896294951438904,
0.4905029535293579,
-0.32873520255088806,
0.3595995008945465,
0.33043333888053894,
-0.4600363075733185,
0.28306645154953003,
-0.19118262827396393,
-0.5935766696929932,
1.0279749631881714,
0.7707564830780029,
-0.5516400933265686,
0.07039956748485565,
0.21157371997833252,
0.5122537612915039,
-0.5298821926116943,
0.5673816800117493,
0.14514799416065216,
0.4206809401512146,
0.13716553151607513,
-0.9560551643371582,
-0.05532381683588028,
-0.3085905611515045,
-0.17869460582733154,
0.1593352109193802,
-0.5645551085472107,
0.6319689154624939,
-0.21153032779693604,
-0.42190122604370117,
0.0013629321474581957,
0.6253119707107544,
0.5449231863021851,
0.36325928568840027,
0.42239394783973694,
0.5987235903739929,
0.8493441939353943,
-0.3993260860443115,
0.6550300121307373,
-0.2879006266593933,
0.19715897738933563,
0.7531349062919617,
-0.4475642442703247,
0.8932393193244934,
0.5099188089370728,
-0.07645115256309509,
0.21614746749401093,
0.42154520750045776,
0.5517405867576599,
0.48666203022003174,
-0.16326817870140076,
-0.4176912307739258,
-0.09260726720094681,
-0.4920846223831177,
-0.5080453157424927,
0.2650698125362396,
0.39082157611846924,
-0.16905982792377472,
0.002072680741548538,
0.4189014434814453,
-0.06788131594657898,
-0.22543160617351532,
-0.024730123579502106,
0.6216180324554443,
0.10631855577230453,
-0.39952734112739563,
0.07030878961086273,
-0.1421917825937271,
0.8776273727416992,
-0.7916361093521118,
0.12972785532474518,
0.015525631606578827,
-0.2542060911655426,
-0.02536606788635254,
-0.8017702698707581,
0.1400885283946991,
0.41329389810562134,
-0.15844307839870453,
-0.4660094380378723,
0.36143773794174194,
-0.6594617962837219,
-0.0939272940158844,
0.2827828824520111,
0.5481714606285095,
-0.270757257938385,
-0.1868743747472763,
-0.5572863817214966,
0.32244423031806946,
-0.01862051524221897,
-0.4269169569015503,
0.12144417315721512,
1.0077064037322998,
0.5157687067985535,
0.5831478238105774,
0.7339744567871094,
-0.23076291382312775,
0.0233090128749609,
0.2756781578063965,
0.7200097441673279,
-0.6800121665000916,
-0.7321677207946777,
-0.7478033304214478,
1.0371804237365723,
0.2650677263736725,
-0.47741028666496277,
0.3770604133605957,
0.23910477757453918,
0.22732095420360565,
0.008533183485269547,
0.7723143100738525,
0.025569647550582886,
0.36358878016471863,
-0.6074806451797485,
0.5315540432929993,
-0.8503296375274658,
-0.11455665528774261,
-0.810783326625824,
-0.7728424668312073,
-0.3323816657066345,
0.33857250213623047,
0.4609210193157196,
0.007550277281552553,
0.7451790571212769,
0.7449287176132202,
0.3398827314376831,
0.310048907995224,
0.4445626437664032,
0.21772395074367523,
0.38481929898262024,
0.4889719486236572,
1.081748604774475,
-0.19505856931209564,
0.6648153066635132,
0.04257030040025711,
-0.3241758942604065,
-0.13534072041511536,
-1.0166871547698975,
-0.3227662444114685,
-0.8495945334434509,
-0.2583177983760834,
-0.10074612498283386,
-0.059901218861341476,
1.3735758066177368,
0.4722784757614136,
-0.4364751875400543,
0.01966140978038311,
0.13649065792560577,
-0.14766313135623932,
0.0723692998290062,
-0.19931945204734802,
0.04650614783167839,
-0.10367520153522491,
-0.9020445346832275,
0.5770328044891357,
0.6992273926734924,
0.4261309802532196,
0.03897947072982788,
-0.20777305960655212,
0.0758843943476677,
0.344270259141922,
0.8184594511985779,
-0.05195094645023346,
-0.7939048409461975,
-0.1810859590768814,
0.3162536919116974,
-0.2491283416748047,
-0.00937273632735014,
0.6589916348457336,
-0.39652904868125916,
0.8009718060493469,
0.23100602626800537,
0.6253673434257507,
-0.08793281018733978,
-0.29099956154823303,
0.5890763998031616,
-0.9280897378921509,
0.036403656005859375,
0.2823397219181061,
0.5969717502593994,
0.3162098228931427,
-0.0368114709854126,
0.07763271033763885,
0.2982608675956726,
-0.5123481154441833,
-0.9309036731719971,
0.4436691701412201,
-1.2869610786437988,
-0.0003771326446440071,
1.073325276374817,
0.11528738588094711,
-0.056342996656894684,
0.1925216168165207,
-0.753014087677002,
0.6048511266708374,
-0.9204103350639343,
0.4855729043483734,
0.526620090007782,
0.024096757173538208,
-0.07304984331130981,
-0.09539113193750381,
0.12838523089885712,
0.5801759362220764,
-0.9864904284477234,
0.27424657344818115,
0.934785008430481,
-0.24444064497947693,
0.1853906512260437,
0.41018179059028625,
0.05038921535015106,
0.20237258076667786,
-0.08045066148042679,
0.3174246549606323,
-0.1044909805059433,
-0.46224504709243774,
-0.4723900854587555,
0.38288843631744385,
-0.5296754837036133,
-0.11107028275728226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18384v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18384v1
|
Exploring the Limits of Fine-grained LLM-based Physics Inference via Premise Removal Interventions
| 2024-04-29T02:43:23 | 2024-04-29T02:43:23 |
Jordan Meadows, Tamsin James, Andre Freitas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models can hallucinate when performing complex and detailed
mathematical reasoning. Physics provides a rich domain for assessing
mathematical reasoning capabilities where physical context imbues the use of
symbols which needs to satisfy complex semantics (\textit{e.g.,} units,
tensorial order), leading to instances where inference may be algebraically
coherent, yet unphysical. In this work, we assess the ability of Language
Models (LMs) to perform fine-grained mathematical and physical reasoning using
a curated dataset encompassing multiple notations and Physics subdomains. We
improve zero-shot scores using synthetic in-context examples, and demonstrate
non-linear degradation of derivation quality with perturbation strength via the
progressive omission of supporting premises. We find that the models'
mathematical reasoning is not physics-informed in this setting, where physical
context is predominantly ignored in favour of reverse-engineering solutions.
|
[
-0.20705705881118774,
-1.100996971130371,
0.9229245185852051,
0.04852263629436493,
-0.15173912048339844,
-0.15558674931526184,
-0.08130042254924774,
-0.5764455795288086,
-0.17161190509796143,
0.5717591643333435,
-0.4069502353668213,
-0.340404212474823,
-0.3471571207046509,
-0.02326844446361065,
-0.4924401640892029,
0.9280868172645569,
-0.2941899299621582,
0.0894080251455307,
-0.3423859179019928,
0.2608601152896881,
-0.0869133472442627,
-0.17884346842765808,
-0.09034957736730576,
-0.7757198214530945,
0.15488195419311523,
0.3194919526576996,
0.6656281352043152,
0.5676551461219788,
0.4213975965976715,
0.13312077522277832,
-0.30713948607444763,
0.01880018599331379,
-0.6034846305847168,
-0.13618354499340057,
-0.5008537769317627,
-0.2669127881526947,
-0.4287845194339752,
0.06378437578678131,
0.6386275291442871,
1.3292732238769531,
0.042938828468322754,
0.05062173679471016,
0.08197705447673798,
0.31736284494400024,
-0.8054694533348083,
0.05597420036792755,
-0.8043862581253052,
0.17064212262630463,
0.30998602509498596,
-0.20348316431045532,
-0.5939953327178955,
0.1816163808107376,
0.17035788297653198,
-0.6854372620582581,
0.24950538575649261,
-0.16880439221858978,
1.1219362020492554,
0.05318528413772583,
-0.12358947098255157,
-0.008335607126355171,
-1.0289251804351807,
1.0949009656906128,
-0.5760860443115234,
0.38829606771469116,
0.6538721919059753,
0.08440717309713364,
-0.2854967415332794,
-0.41212305426597595,
-0.1987179070711136,
-0.1281270831823349,
0.04673845320940018,
0.1496763974428177,
-0.028600435703992844,
0.10940279811620712,
0.5071489810943604,
0.2504909038543701,
-0.26693183183670044,
0.14074139297008514,
-0.49325650930404663,
-0.23806573450565338,
0.5486348271369934,
0.13408051431179047,
0.16794268786907196,
-0.2895497679710388,
-0.1375129520893097,
0.17673127353191376,
-1.073905348777771,
-0.04459287226200104,
0.16784682869911194,
0.4175790846347809,
-0.034594833850860596,
1.117164134979248,
-0.3886585533618927,
0.36195826530456543,
-0.010755974799394608,
-0.19792836904525757,
-0.20587065815925598,
-0.07090990245342255,
-0.5843181014060974,
0.1139182448387146,
0.6587152481079102,
0.2062070071697235,
0.2490627020597458,
-0.32802316546440125,
-0.2518867254257202,
-0.06399786472320557,
-0.11146523803472519,
-0.8841145038604736,
-0.12770672142505646,
0.36045750975608826,
-0.24770209193229675,
-0.1025279089808464,
-0.20111601054668427,
-0.5515068769454956,
-0.49496573209762573,
-0.4288409650325775,
0.5863742828369141,
-0.5367001295089722,
-0.09410614520311356,
0.6033068895339966,
-0.20206819474697113,
0.29582929611206055,
0.4470452070236206,
-0.7678797245025635,
0.3735554814338684,
0.7496399283409119,
0.5422658920288086,
0.5458236932754517,
-0.32416731119155884,
-0.13706228137016296,
0.31548693776130676,
-0.3526289463043213,
0.8155198693275452,
-0.7050974369049072,
-0.6991631388664246,
-0.5750604867935181,
-0.11228689551353455,
0.16574408113956451,
-0.6495782732963562,
0.6332672238349915,
-0.19956433773040771,
0.1953364610671997,
-0.10319295525550842,
-0.6673675179481506,
-0.20935773849487305,
0.018940918147563934,
-0.2615889012813568,
0.6806463599205017,
-0.14117883145809174,
-0.22501258552074432,
0.18257386982440948,
-0.4039045572280884,
-0.5900453329086304,
-0.22939766943454742,
-0.22217947244644165,
-0.2999456524848938,
0.5911241173744202,
0.17836406826972961,
0.3323807418346405,
-0.37669628858566284,
0.4988548457622528,
-0.7821499109268188,
-0.30501842498779297,
0.11664945632219315,
-0.6921641230583191,
0.37205803394317627,
0.4047048091888428,
-0.3199630677700043,
-0.27241331338882446,
-1.0984386205673218,
-0.16205307841300964,
0.1541791707277298,
0.25214239954948425,
-0.47971317172050476,
0.29842233657836914,
-0.29267334938049316,
0.16277475655078888,
0.04404809698462486,
-0.749389111995697,
0.14878202974796295,
-0.7207364439964294,
0.280629426240921,
0.5727198123931885,
-0.02017715573310852,
0.6573003530502319,
-0.15782269835472107,
0.2514491081237793,
-0.17706996202468872,
0.0012024366296827793,
0.01282897125929594,
-0.490681529045105,
-0.41239842772483826,
-0.5606246590614319,
-0.20270949602127075,
0.35272106528282166,
-0.37557506561279297,
0.14596298336982727,
-0.3181810975074768,
-0.3592657446861267,
-0.18803730607032776,
-0.056575797498226166,
0.43475884199142456,
0.9603820443153381,
0.6089891791343689,
0.3118305206298828,
-0.39637136459350586,
-0.8961145281791687,
-0.6820629835128784,
-0.02739708498120308,
-0.3612723648548126,
0.14865809679031372,
0.5383879542350769,
0.09578440338373184,
1.1503419876098633,
-0.44813576340675354,
0.14378027617931366,
-0.07881942391395569,
-0.06099063903093338,
0.18336042761802673,
0.41247278451919556,
0.13049575686454773,
-0.4566304683685303,
0.10505065321922302,
0.10738951712846756,
-1.1934046745300293,
-0.40155118703842163,
-0.2691865563392639,
0.023282088339328766,
-0.1176726296544075,
0.32229602336883545,
-0.8117879033088684,
0.7312586307525635,
0.11010042577981949,
-0.45018601417541504,
0.8907902240753174,
0.09758125990629196,
0.02645290456712246,
-0.5704789757728577,
0.03907746076583862,
0.2614782154560089,
-0.1976516842842102,
-0.6859486699104309,
0.36370569467544556,
-0.19284756481647491,
-0.32235395908355713,
-0.6403766870498657,
0.9878673553466797,
-0.21548227965831757,
-0.1940605193376541,
-0.23649202287197113,
0.22196616232395172,
0.5037245154380798,
-0.007976913824677467,
0.4200906753540039,
0.42729121446609497,
0.6169687509536743,
-0.7925152778625488,
-0.2740738093852997,
-0.1408763974905014,
-0.10539926588535309,
0.3152380585670471,
-0.7645391225814819,
-0.429609090089798,
-0.0611867718398571,
0.012188673950731754,
-0.9363592863082886,
-0.399017870426178,
0.21065032482147217,
-0.09410815685987473,
0.3151951730251312,
-0.21518652141094208,
-0.5050779581069946,
-0.008999812416732311,
-0.28214365243911743,
0.5001277923583984,
0.551282525062561,
-0.3330830931663513,
0.7101878523826599,
-0.023985758423805237,
0.18159323930740356,
-0.30709001421928406,
-0.9142714142799377,
-0.08188958466053009,
-0.20782434940338135,
-0.3835572302341461,
0.06722510606050491,
0.011205109767615795,
-0.8006122708320618,
0.12179520726203918,
-0.4545268714427948,
-0.05732707306742668,
0.40848302841186523,
0.23579010367393494,
0.2803950607776642,
-0.2492390125989914,
0.10152240842580795,
0.34446221590042114,
-0.11878292262554169,
0.1833033412694931,
-0.2732155919075012,
0.35047799348831177,
-0.20904633402824402,
-0.7210351824760437,
-0.6536515951156616,
-0.022756004706025124,
0.6618530750274658,
0.1394922435283661,
0.7160236835479736,
0.1550324708223343,
-0.6607074737548828,
-0.09673934429883957,
-0.35515058040618896,
-0.4354540705680847,
-0.4710824489593506,
0.2797326445579529,
-0.8497006893157959,
-0.6525348424911499,
0.6241515874862671,
-0.051841944456100464,
0.13242630660533905,
0.6423179507255554,
0.44195443391799927,
-0.16390982270240784,
0.9503947496414185,
-0.08736402541399002,
0.3585461974143982,
0.09958673268556595,
-0.328563392162323,
0.4433911144733429,
-0.8756309151649475,
-0.1996970921754837,
-0.34280475974082947,
0.0072045703418552876,
-0.263998419046402,
-0.24116289615631104,
0.03004138357937336,
0.5468028783798218,
-0.33668267726898193,
0.2940574884414673,
-0.30884724855422974,
0.7852128744125366,
-0.17262564599514008,
0.31319811940193176,
0.2777728736400604,
0.3656949996948242,
-0.07500936836004257,
0.0017166109755635262,
-0.26467618346214294,
-0.6755080819129944,
0.9995853900909424,
0.5166460275650024,
0.9934766888618469,
-0.030788062140345573,
0.6384949088096619,
-0.29687049984931946,
0.29104068875312805,
-1.0337706804275513,
0.6870244741439819,
-0.05643720552325249,
-0.6237583160400391,
-0.20311254262924194,
-0.7536234855651855,
-0.6317960023880005,
0.4301304519176483,
-0.06752036511898041,
-1.0700860023498535,
-0.14585457742214203,
-0.14681197702884674,
-0.49791544675827026,
0.6415550112724304,
-0.8374562859535217,
0.5341578125953674,
0.03597985580563545,
-0.8052096366882324,
-0.3149334788322449,
-0.06765416264533997,
0.7327491044998169,
-0.1455288529396057,
0.5214223861694336,
-0.4301528036594391,
0.20491284132003784,
0.28334835171699524,
-0.49283403158187866,
0.9084873795509338,
-0.1369362324476242,
-0.49327412247657776,
0.6296699643135071,
0.7401583194732666,
0.28163793683052063,
0.13416385650634766,
-0.4156414866447449,
0.24787180125713348,
0.21364979445934296,
-0.5427570939064026,
-0.6115416884422302,
0.8211850523948669,
-0.7383601665496826,
-0.6401373744010925,
0.07182807475328445,
-0.7964319586753845,
-0.32772964239120483,
0.262574702501297,
-0.012060328386723995,
0.6359351277351379,
0.06428340077400208,
0.10558294504880905,
0.5800870656967163,
-0.35315749049186707,
0.3269742429256439,
0.4563109874725342,
-0.49525636434555054,
-0.08874373883008957,
0.8570842146873474,
0.0629335343837738,
0.5373389720916748,
0.4294186532497406,
0.6869595050811768,
-0.5270640254020691,
-0.5619173049926758,
0.015654422342777252,
0.37819844484329224,
-0.8160756826400757,
0.1550454944372177,
-0.38637447357177734,
-0.19025547802448273,
-0.4400593638420105,
-0.28119954466819763,
-0.47606804966926575,
-0.7584671974182129,
-0.48870933055877686,
-0.2041671723127365,
0.11720699071884155,
0.5277605056762695,
0.1368228942155838,
0.13731682300567627,
-0.688031017780304,
0.4895183742046356,
-0.15166211128234863,
0.39211541414260864,
-0.16186738014221191,
-0.9037910103797913,
0.029245128855109215,
0.24868200719356537,
-0.3157528340816498,
-0.29741165041923523,
0.15578627586364746,
0.15594887733459473,
0.3743843138217926,
0.5806059241294861,
-0.0902310162782669,
1.1979023218154907,
-0.5942375659942627,
0.7560408115386963,
0.23807862401008606,
-1.0917128324508667,
0.590951681137085,
-0.3605577051639557,
0.33751922845840454,
0.1188226267695427,
0.19910870492458344,
0.11039713025093079,
-0.566457211971283,
-0.7154742479324341,
-0.35665836930274963,
0.32653748989105225,
0.24433456361293793,
0.15384341776371002,
-0.02873021923005581,
1.0131127834320068,
0.14527849853038788,
0.013454601168632507,
-0.7793424725532532,
0.009197099134325981,
-0.11193772405385971,
-0.052792660892009735,
0.05633656308054924,
-0.0773802101612091,
-0.04096619039773941,
-0.46842890977859497,
0.5371232628822327,
-0.19399066269397736,
-0.02155694179236889,
0.4801051914691925,
-0.14839930832386017,
-0.3923448920249939,
0.30958378314971924,
0.8695871233940125,
0.7285510301589966,
-0.2586878836154938,
0.3107088804244995,
0.11699280887842178,
-0.26183459162712097,
-0.00127843813970685,
-0.053518861532211304,
-0.3296518325805664,
-0.3248673975467682,
0.5756986737251282,
0.4500712752342224,
0.41608700156211853,
-0.8047735095024109,
-0.00161260599270463,
0.19898520410060883,
-0.44878217577934265,
0.16570927202701569,
-0.054820362478494644,
-0.2206200659275055,
0.08040927350521088,
0.3571941554546356,
0.2223156988620758,
0.24816212058067322,
-0.5683227777481079,
0.35407015681266785,
0.6772712469100952,
-0.3270603120326996,
-0.6867536306381226,
0.669276237487793,
-0.5152819156646729,
0.09549359977245331,
0.1307191401720047,
-0.10800346732139587,
-0.15967324376106262,
0.5455528497695923,
0.5891397595405579,
0.8194097876548767,
0.1634577512741089,
0.07853682339191437,
0.41026875376701355,
0.2830634117126465,
-0.1703214794397354,
0.19537605345249176,
0.2123601734638214,
-0.7546274662017822,
-0.7151458263397217,
-0.7809942364692688,
-0.3418218791484833,
0.3608884811401367,
-0.5462251305580139,
0.5545956492424011,
-0.9095212817192078,
0.03114398941397667,
0.06722651422023773,
0.016078034415841103,
-0.3095962107181549,
0.22713758051395416,
0.34384796023368835,
0.6620837450027466,
-0.9161072373390198,
0.6518955230712891,
0.4296942949295044,
-0.46197327971458435,
-0.7300567030906677,
-0.12021797150373459,
0.16785934567451477,
-0.6848740577697754,
0.6754053831100464,
0.06594312191009521,
-0.5354753732681274,
-0.14424997568130493,
-0.7111138105392456,
-0.696817934513092,
0.5738587379455566,
0.6556302309036255,
-0.4425545930862427,
0.057194579392671585,
0.1770133227109909,
0.6623674631118774,
0.08410970121622086,
0.4598937928676605,
0.37965336441993713,
0.2871841788291931,
0.32104066014289856,
-0.9872586131095886,
-0.009484963491559029,
0.2987600564956665,
-0.5322073101997375,
0.07458536326885223,
-0.33634835481643677,
0.9729999303817749,
-0.2069910615682602,
-0.26329469680786133,
0.3755706250667572,
0.4835890531539917,
0.6464119553565979,
0.5283236503601074,
0.03745220974087715,
0.7677962183952332,
0.49066460132598877,
0.017327826470136642,
1.148834466934204,
-0.2429952323436737,
0.8429709672927856,
1.1033872365951538,
-0.7422693967819214,
0.7166868448257446,
0.7814370393753052,
-0.15622541308403015,
0.4072912931442261,
0.44186580181121826,
0.16896256804466248,
0.4656558036804199,
0.1676490306854248,
-0.23926487565040588,
-0.5714818239212036,
-0.29796963930130005,
-0.02235354483127594,
0.5322773456573486,
0.6598548293113708,
-0.045088984072208405,
-0.824871301651001,
0.01802857406437397,
0.08538306504487991,
0.17329083383083344,
-0.35787978768348694,
0.2892455458641052,
0.38408586382865906,
-0.357448548078537,
0.780682384967804,
-0.1153608188033104,
0.03932955116033554,
-0.5518262982368469,
-0.024662433192133904,
-0.13613930344581604,
0.341162770986557,
-0.37748491764068604,
-0.8975762724876404,
0.46749505400657654,
0.04579740762710571,
-0.08865699917078018,
-0.23622703552246094,
0.671023964881897,
-0.11842898279428482,
-0.544833242893219,
0.20899611711502075,
0.504977285861969,
0.4085647761821747,
0.036429040133953094,
-0.5784879326820374,
-0.11861136555671692,
-0.32381483912467957,
-0.36686718463897705,
0.4529496133327484,
0.5522932410240173,
-0.026648851111531258,
0.8722514510154724,
0.6446326375007629,
0.2574472427368164,
-0.1386423408985138,
0.30507636070251465,
0.7576731443405151,
-0.5566723346710205,
0.07955896854400635,
-1.2358605861663818,
0.12767912447452545,
0.2218833714723587,
0.03972267732024193,
0.9674249291419983,
0.682407557964325,
0.6040708422660828,
-0.03600217029452324,
0.5399107933044434,
0.24960112571716309,
0.06343358010053635,
-0.7975015044212341,
0.38116946816444397,
-0.7496573328971863,
0.6843290328979492,
-0.38859134912490845,
-0.7532839775085449,
-0.7634602785110474,
0.5794180035591125,
-0.7640601992607117,
-0.023896094411611557,
0.6208516955375671,
0.6747575998306274,
-0.468331515789032,
0.020711101591587067,
0.7073965668678284,
0.3500186502933502,
0.6978486776351929,
0.5600907802581787,
1.0687857866287231,
-0.5608515739440918,
0.12992309033870697,
-0.34158992767333984,
-0.08790794014930725,
-0.05649397522211075,
-0.9473787546157837,
-0.9121345281600952,
0.10524771362543106,
-0.39818859100341797,
-0.45277050137519836,
-0.42554908990859985,
0.8722870349884033,
0.447470486164093,
-0.8806284666061401,
-0.06484168022871017,
-0.36586251854896545,
0.14917558431625366,
-0.05058363080024719,
-0.3189300298690796,
0.3333146870136261,
-0.2866242527961731,
-0.5426816940307617,
0.6991972923278809,
0.43973714113235474,
0.10249491035938263,
-0.25773856043815613,
0.16482143104076385,
-0.02561539225280285,
0.3246786594390869,
0.8890857696533203,
0.44313526153564453,
-1.1372758150100708,
-0.7174069881439209,
0.22327527403831482,
0.01996678113937378,
-0.10694831609725952,
0.58144211769104,
-0.8221678137779236,
0.45488566160202026,
0.4085399806499481,
0.47458165884017944,
0.1794293224811554,
0.036156490445137024,
0.3306340277194977,
-0.6998633742332458,
0.4120844900608063,
0.12916302680969238,
0.5753926038742065,
-0.03887000307440758,
-0.23442022502422333,
0.2595948278903961,
0.6603156924247742,
-0.2100187987089157,
-1.124880313873291,
0.25846976041793823,
-0.738639771938324,
-0.7505316138267517,
1.3454334735870361,
0.02066684328019619,
-0.3770555257797241,
-0.008763146586716175,
0.06362855434417725,
0.02284100651741028,
-0.06532607972621918,
0.6334741711616516,
0.8485357165336609,
-0.35994476079940796,
-0.2723745107650757,
-0.5606092810630798,
0.12310398370027542,
0.6618228554725647,
-0.628991961479187,
0.2877275049686432,
0.513786256313324,
0.3926950991153717,
0.3107728958129883,
0.13319872319698334,
-0.28437918424606323,
0.10774113237857819,
0.04587911441922188,
-0.01071192231029272,
-0.013061019591987133,
-0.5179831981658936,
-0.5770828127861023,
0.29619941115379333,
-0.008534077554941177,
0.2644476294517517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01588v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01588v1
|
Towards Unbiased Evaluation of Detecting Unanswerable Questions in EHRSQL
| 2024-04-29T02:26:15 | 2024-04-29T02:26:15 |
Yongjin Yang, Sihyeon Kim, SangMook Kim, Gyubok Lee, Se-Young Yun, Edward Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Incorporating unanswerable questions into EHR QA systems is crucial for
testing the trustworthiness of a system, as providing non-existent responses
can mislead doctors in their diagnoses. The EHRSQL dataset stands out as a
promising benchmark because it is the only dataset that incorporates
unanswerable questions in the EHR QA system alongside practical questions.
However, in this work, we identify a data bias in these unanswerable questions;
they can often be discerned simply by filtering with specific N-gram patterns.
Such biases jeopardize the authenticity and reliability of QA system
evaluations. To tackle this problem, we propose a simple debiasing method of
adjusting the split between the validation and test sets to neutralize the
undue influence of N-gram filtering. By experimenting on the MIMIC-III dataset,
we demonstrate both the existing data bias in EHRSQL and the effectiveness of
our data split strategy in mitigating this bias.
|
[
-0.5091719627380371,
-0.697130024433136,
0.7186261415481567,
-0.1809806376695633,
-0.44317740201950073,
0.15060491859912872,
0.45272818207740784,
-0.09666795283555984,
0.3208513557910919,
0.6173895597457886,
-0.502956211566925,
-0.3524179756641388,
-0.3190977871417999,
0.204061821103096,
-0.40997079014778137,
1.0069644451141357,
0.11054962128400803,
0.3323206901550293,
-0.23053036630153656,
-0.5786693692207336,
-0.37047702074050903,
-0.30470702052116394,
-0.1460942029953003,
-0.5869277119636536,
-0.004785895347595215,
0.48561421036720276,
0.8370954394340515,
0.38038313388824463,
0.3234092891216278,
0.0022549214772880077,
-0.1590471863746643,
0.24006690084934235,
-0.148115873336792,
0.16388624906539917,
0.11561567336320877,
-0.5542910695075989,
-0.2530766725540161,
-0.2890145182609558,
0.490823894739151,
0.5092483162879944,
-0.2557736933231354,
0.588904082775116,
0.3643002212047577,
1.016036033630371,
-0.6548047065734863,
-0.20248742401599884,
-0.33914369344711304,
0.21658855676651,
-0.2332225888967514,
-0.216776505112648,
-0.22554808855056763,
-0.5588390231132507,
-0.22931817173957825,
-0.38433054089546204,
0.12074051797389984,
0.07671652734279633,
0.7402604818344116,
0.42253419756889343,
-0.40994971990585327,
0.25348469614982605,
-0.7322150468826294,
0.6678699254989624,
-0.6744442582130432,
0.3204045295715332,
0.47031769156455994,
0.4372381567955017,
-0.10981617867946625,
-0.1975296139717102,
-0.4156173765659332,
0.21832826733589172,
-0.05163383111357689,
0.04706285521388054,
-0.6133537888526917,
-0.09113173931837082,
0.42724037170410156,
0.25373780727386475,
-0.4826330840587616,
-0.1529461145401001,
-0.23651012778282166,
0.007121101953089237,
0.3774030804634094,
-0.01052026730030775,
0.49818122386932373,
-0.2084406316280365,
-0.14751988649368286,
0.011673539876937866,
-0.4710409939289093,
-0.0164298377931118,
0.29326534271240234,
0.10639235377311707,
0.20806412398815155,
0.5415142178535461,
-0.38500210642814636,
0.5249620079994202,
0.6481996178627014,
0.25208017230033875,
0.6527249217033386,
0.020510070025920868,
-0.2583980858325958,
0.06368056684732437,
0.6580020189285278,
0.415138840675354,
0.12278592586517334,
-0.1441020518541336,
-0.441839337348938,
0.2606574594974518,
0.43298792839050293,
-0.4676172137260437,
-0.06509023904800415,
0.7459710836410522,
-0.6127378344535828,
-0.4799911677837372,
0.24114824831485748,
-1.1804696321487427,
-0.5163106918334961,
0.08424273133277893,
0.5486767888069153,
-0.16463913023471832,
-0.16692771017551422,
0.17908360064029694,
-0.10994958132505417,
0.12226763367652893,
0.09967176616191864,
-0.41763150691986084,
0.6173790097236633,
0.4352628290653229,
0.3024332523345947,
0.11635414510965347,
0.1992599219083786,
-1.0040512084960938,
-0.3666541278362274,
-0.26831936836242676,
0.9024851322174072,
-0.39787721633911133,
-0.44330519437789917,
-0.01693584769964218,
0.008750415407121181,
0.11834295094013214,
-0.7621733546257019,
0.6854204535484314,
-0.7621248960494995,
0.2318815290927887,
-0.3877260088920593,
-0.5282371044158936,
-0.14058685302734375,
0.5466188192367554,
-0.8547824025154114,
1.0881786346435547,
0.10203899443149567,
-1.00789213180542,
0.4016103744506836,
-0.6517848372459412,
-0.14893677830696106,
0.04324522987008095,
-0.2447328120470047,
-0.6804822087287903,
0.06748650968074799,
0.7790173888206482,
-0.04755052924156189,
-0.32068270444869995,
0.13863615691661835,
-0.5414309501647949,
-0.39129576086997986,
0.37076252698898315,
-0.32188019156455994,
0.7603127360343933,
0.16265609860420227,
-0.3662755489349365,
-0.21323297917842865,
-0.7754189968109131,
0.7367880940437317,
-0.21825772523880005,
0.010301216505467892,
-0.39824235439300537,
-0.19138702750205994,
0.02878452278673649,
0.031993575394153595,
-0.12652671337127686,
-0.8740633130073547,
-0.1830623596906662,
-0.14467278122901917,
-0.08032961189746857,
0.55661541223526,
0.4966464638710022,
0.13119393587112427,
-0.6998218894004822,
0.8475132584571838,
0.2212909609079361,
0.6535599231719971,
0.4124615490436554,
-0.41331011056900024,
-0.31894779205322266,
0.021808745339512825,
0.5098205208778381,
0.3677038848400116,
-0.8385634422302246,
0.40616875886917114,
0.08270258456468582,
-0.3398185670375824,
-0.9564859867095947,
0.1616319864988327,
0.5745779871940613,
0.6240592002868652,
0.7225031852722168,
-0.42683732509613037,
-0.321981817483902,
-0.9892180562019348,
-0.6597127318382263,
-0.08323665708303452,
-0.275698184967041,
0.064117930829525,
0.3876042664051056,
-0.2487339973449707,
0.787570595741272,
-0.5808212757110596,
-0.48790788650512695,
-0.03368551284074783,
-0.03553684055805206,
0.13384124636650085,
0.37258848547935486,
0.2563645541667938,
-0.637093186378479,
-0.37480929493904114,
-0.22748741507530212,
-0.6797788739204407,
-0.3407219648361206,
0.32522183656692505,
-0.13648533821105957,
-0.10720928013324738,
0.30363672971725464,
-0.3465348184108734,
0.5223524570465088,
0.3603789508342743,
-0.5230706334114075,
0.2996918559074402,
-0.30430328845977783,
0.40487203001976013,
-0.7396152019500732,
0.06760519742965698,
0.0781974270939827,
-0.036707278341054916,
-0.4958648979663849,
-0.12031316012144089,
0.2699401378631592,
0.3413594365119934,
-0.18704189360141754,
0.36264151334762573,
-0.6312082409858704,
0.023356223478913307,
-0.06851646304130554,
0.09257794916629791,
0.4404279291629791,
0.18892629444599152,
-0.48763102293014526,
0.13815991580486298,
0.5759844779968262,
-0.32629138231277466,
0.10620705038309097,
0.6133297681808472,
-0.4946044087409973,
0.8217243552207947,
-0.7283000946044922,
0.3012552559375763,
-0.3437705934047699,
0.2691781520843506,
-0.6350975036621094,
-0.07087238132953644,
0.29785335063934326,
-0.4433698058128357,
-0.009524439461529255,
-0.49948129057884216,
-0.5387132167816162,
-0.2291674017906189,
-0.4143121540546417,
0.6131027340888977,
0.848683774471283,
-0.6354958415031433,
0.502156138420105,
0.5253543257713318,
0.5252072215080261,
-0.7746055126190186,
-0.6029178500175476,
-0.5121670961380005,
-0.2521699368953705,
-0.19780398905277252,
0.10034824907779694,
0.09705295413732529,
-0.5608277320861816,
0.2685745358467102,
-0.4161657392978668,
-0.4219082295894623,
0.028954101726412773,
0.5322784781455994,
0.4159598648548126,
-0.08184695243835449,
0.142412468791008,
0.16109755635261536,
-0.09405237436294556,
0.2240043431520462,
-0.18879207968711853,
0.13728275895118713,
0.1509048342704773,
-0.8457147479057312,
-0.5781779289245605,
0.20959727466106415,
0.8817076086997986,
-0.3654046654701233,
0.2852379083633423,
0.1351473331451416,
-0.4566769301891327,
-0.35254019498825073,
-0.6374313831329346,
-0.2533453106880188,
-0.3395191729068756,
0.011238480918109417,
0.1508871167898178,
-0.5806732177734375,
0.4997847080230713,
0.26123878359794617,
-0.010654148645699024,
0.4659837782382965,
0.09321784973144531,
0.07845670729875565,
1.1437660455703735,
-0.00829777866601944,
-0.13319146633148193,
-0.049378398805856705,
0.316326767206192,
0.18040738999843597,
-1.0698456764221191,
-0.24724984169006348,
-0.5903156995773315,
-0.16593946516513824,
-0.6316957473754883,
-0.5584275126457214,
0.5931657552719116,
0.02658260054886341,
-0.026354262605309486,
-0.42561987042427063,
-0.47744542360305786,
0.5825983285903931,
0.4099155068397522,
0.5439715385437012,
0.5080878734588623,
-0.1927907019853592,
-0.29450905323028564,
0.273905873298645,
-0.4978175759315491,
-0.42539480328559875,
1.4724398851394653,
0.2930290400981903,
0.7588448524475098,
0.009164650924503803,
0.6504417061805725,
0.3697853982448578,
0.24968412518501282,
-0.3859107792377472,
0.10459250211715698,
-0.10747848451137543,
-0.7078348994255066,
-0.4087461531162262,
-0.2428048998117447,
-0.75838303565979,
0.4288996756076813,
-0.3074340522289276,
-0.5578504800796509,
0.32382094860076904,
0.18959732353687286,
-0.8776934742927551,
0.47313207387924194,
-0.4653235077857971,
0.6371609568595886,
-0.06178440898656845,
-0.27651843428611755,
0.13530775904655457,
-0.4865512549877167,
0.16122186183929443,
-0.3089093863964081,
0.49744662642478943,
0.05690553039312363,
0.35861122608184814,
0.7386864423751831,
-0.5815391540527344,
0.436978816986084,
-0.41367948055267334,
0.10876186192035675,
0.3949366807937622,
0.157589852809906,
0.3724883496761322,
0.33585304021835327,
-0.0881848931312561,
0.026747215539216995,
0.5037114024162292,
-0.49266260862350464,
-0.7956575155258179,
0.3829953670501709,
-0.6762042045593262,
-0.3429912328720093,
-0.5361750721931458,
0.026727663353085518,
-0.7230450510978699,
0.2605593204498291,
0.14236757159233093,
0.5073774456977844,
-0.35200437903404236,
0.01578831486403942,
0.8239668607711792,
-0.13378922641277313,
-0.16561071574687958,
0.7116300463676453,
-0.3807470500469208,
-0.18680571019649506,
0.15423040091991425,
0.15494440495967865,
0.10251855105161667,
0.21031317114830017,
0.18491002917289734,
-0.517440915107727,
-0.4650013744831085,
-0.5188449621200562,
0.110898956656456,
-0.4853106141090393,
-0.18483573198318481,
-0.5826147198677063,
0.03699641674757004,
-0.1996760070323944,
0.4526757597923279,
-0.22795851528644562,
-0.16990210115909576,
-0.2419145554304123,
-0.26590731739997864,
0.36381012201309204,
0.7282145619392395,
-0.07065071165561676,
0.02265559881925583,
-0.9996981620788574,
0.669754683971405,
0.42091691493988037,
0.6106890439987183,
-0.11231742799282074,
-0.8279396295547485,
0.05904112383723259,
0.1066974624991417,
-0.12092678248882294,
-1.1032546758651733,
0.17421604692935944,
-0.34995633363723755,
0.47993162274360657,
0.55079585313797,
0.4920373558998108,
0.46451207995414734,
-0.4184562563896179,
0.5173037052154541,
-0.1492137312889099,
-0.9996457099914551,
0.5164983868598938,
-0.2760108709335327,
0.3475266396999359,
1.0068997144699097,
0.1535007804632187,
-0.3926417827606201,
-0.1888982355594635,
-0.8362430930137634,
-0.5910872220993042,
0.40054062008857727,
0.12744967639446259,
-0.2748223841190338,
-0.06632944196462631,
0.38333889842033386,
-0.02227439545094967,
0.18632318079471588,
-0.2876769006252289,
-0.4949526786804199,
0.06970874220132828,
0.03862524777650833,
0.07496237009763718,
-0.5837290287017822,
-0.4009315073490143,
-0.03772757574915886,
0.7068771719932556,
-0.10388033092021942,
-0.06781727075576782,
0.35891085863113403,
-0.015643607825040817,
-0.46543774008750916,
0.6695123910903931,
-0.15279333293437958,
0.4646044373512268,
-0.4749588966369629,
0.15834100544452667,
0.08756408095359802,
-0.5720050930976868,
0.2744075357913971,
-0.038673363626003265,
-0.5170698165893555,
0.18362289667129517,
0.003093474078923464,
0.28077760338783264,
-0.12839597463607788,
-0.569311797618866,
0.551669716835022,
-0.1481395661830902,
-0.33592453598976135,
-0.13936848938465118,
-0.19268487393856049,
-0.3716767728328705,
0.1934947669506073,
0.35182031989097595,
0.05302107706665993,
0.22625823318958282,
-0.18186235427856445,
0.6014081835746765,
0.4917867183685303,
-0.9406617879867554,
-0.26062631607055664,
0.5348960757255554,
-0.038932595402002335,
0.01227846834808588,
0.6372582912445068,
-0.03415803611278534,
-0.48902279138565063,
0.5412290692329407,
0.17142637073993683,
0.9612657427787781,
-0.43592315912246704,
0.6233664751052856,
0.31348371505737305,
0.3677317500114441,
-0.3894481956958771,
0.5826974511146545,
0.2554088234901428,
-0.8283091187477112,
-0.05494211986660957,
-0.33454132080078125,
-0.42936971783638,
0.2673792243003845,
-1.450514793395996,
0.1142849326133728,
-0.5407883524894714,
-0.2446787804365158,
-0.08078817278146744,
-0.09998471289873123,
-0.5232366919517517,
0.44044750928878784,
-0.32317307591438293,
0.6546855568885803,
-0.960547149181366,
0.5086922645568848,
0.6915793418884277,
-0.18536773324012756,
-0.8117182850837708,
0.3528943359851837,
0.1833249032497406,
-0.8106447458267212,
0.422838032245636,
-0.03242291510105133,
0.0008621139568276703,
-0.2993831932544708,
-0.2962724268436432,
-0.6669290661811829,
0.7507237792015076,
0.14937317371368408,
-0.3666960597038269,
0.3676374554634094,
0.07429145276546478,
0.600141167640686,
-0.0020497723016887903,
0.497171014547348,
0.6757882237434387,
0.5186768770217896,
-0.26738741993904114,
-0.9543868899345398,
0.2767793536186218,
-0.4212842285633087,
-0.3812883794307709,
0.44819173216819763,
-0.5120484828948975,
0.6933633685112,
-0.27308017015457153,
-0.3044999837875366,
-0.21338783204555511,
-0.053365807980298996,
0.18688200414180756,
0.4984865188598633,
0.756574809551239,
0.6393705010414124,
0.9505854249000549,
0.03987181559205055,
0.8403267860412598,
-0.18627221882343292,
0.3358056843280792,
1.2496962547302246,
-0.5085353851318359,
0.5337889790534973,
0.761891782283783,
-0.21697767078876495,
0.5164092183113098,
0.26165950298309326,
-0.17225149273872375,
0.4460635483264923,
0.4322197139263153,
-0.1582307070493698,
-0.25052669644355774,
-0.3352264165878296,
-0.552299439907074,
0.4873429834842682,
-0.10622333735227585,
-0.2897184193134308,
-0.3873230814933777,
-0.13654106855392456,
0.057608671486377716,
0.08225829899311066,
-0.13182996213436127,
0.6343736052513123,
-0.0984281599521637,
-0.5355043411254883,
0.35796982049942017,
-0.18428446352481842,
0.22273766994476318,
-0.22495903074741364,
-0.09464719146490097,
-0.43265780806541443,
0.20036573708057404,
-0.4754857122898102,
-0.6458628177642822,
0.08633154630661011,
0.23782581090927124,
-0.2338850349187851,
-0.0716811791062355,
0.4426816403865814,
-0.05946248769760132,
-0.31994256377220154,
0.1996665596961975,
1.0652637481689453,
-0.08006951957941055,
-0.4842020571231842,
-0.6994858980178833,
-0.17426395416259766,
0.2329765111207962,
-0.09244275093078613,
0.4820961356163025,
0.6306397318840027,
0.030192965641617775,
0.6756196618080139,
0.5426362752914429,
0.15429586172103882,
-0.3094084560871124,
0.1715657114982605,
0.8787874579429626,
-0.4294283986091614,
-0.7655325531959534,
-0.7110814452171326,
0.4597155749797821,
0.11086367070674896,
-0.12868061661720276,
1.0131453275680542,
0.4768606126308441,
0.5071768760681152,
0.08932269364595413,
0.84040766954422,
0.2823178172111511,
1.019418716430664,
-0.4056047201156616,
0.78037428855896,
-0.46566012501716614,
0.5156245231628418,
-0.41477274894714355,
-0.4381484091281891,
-0.3618486821651459,
0.16965003311634064,
-0.0686340257525444,
0.13962462544441223,
0.7196281552314758,
0.5491013526916504,
0.1553419530391693,
0.22211730480194092,
0.33160915970802307,
0.06142089515924454,
-0.04314638301730156,
0.33380457758903503,
0.8126216530799866,
-0.7560320496559143,
0.2274027019739151,
-0.3224077820777893,
-0.30312541127204895,
0.08938693255186081,
-0.5611483454704285,
-0.7650511860847473,
-0.12117406725883484,
-0.49524590373039246,
-0.8765560388565063,
0.06054478883743286,
0.6031227111816406,
0.2612735629081726,
-0.9769980907440186,
0.07805956900119781,
0.2303827553987503,
0.3883516490459442,
-0.40714186429977417,
-0.1829344630241394,
0.41766467690467834,
0.14215798676013947,
-0.28708621859550476,
0.16344569623470306,
0.07522460073232651,
0.0978519394993782,
-0.10192226618528366,
0.33064165711402893,
0.1253357231616974,
-0.02270984835922718,
0.06336875259876251,
0.35364842414855957,
-0.31728753447532654,
-0.14970862865447998,
0.18657341599464417,
0.32675862312316895,
0.2030838280916214,
0.5816952586174011,
-0.9547591209411621,
0.5331918597221375,
0.14916129410266876,
0.48310795426368713,
0.08716069161891937,
0.42267829179763794,
0.20767298340797424,
-0.38506582379341125,
-0.4165389835834503,
0.2889854907989502,
0.15099845826625824,
0.13644707202911377,
-0.5156766176223755,
0.2623189091682434,
-0.06680480390787125,
-0.5889822244644165,
-1.1679154634475708,
0.014368519186973572,
-0.7079229950904846,
-0.1311470866203308,
1.2461715936660767,
0.23024463653564453,
-0.23597413301467896,
-0.55092853307724,
0.10158248245716095,
0.05198261886835098,
-0.4102783799171448,
1.0194190740585327,
0.5605180263519287,
-0.4239111542701721,
0.10762564837932587,
-0.6583712697029114,
0.6088835000991821,
0.7098124623298645,
-0.8510251641273499,
-0.02499079331755638,
0.5902819037437439,
0.4836881160736084,
-0.08518747985363007,
0.6856688261032104,
-0.6269680261611938,
0.3496417999267578,
-0.12710316479206085,
-0.0390971377491951,
0.1225455030798912,
0.12610796093940735,
-0.7377566695213318,
0.251920610666275,
0.15117789804935455,
-0.7170292139053345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18371v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18371v1
|
QANA: LLM-based Question Generation and Network Analysis for Zero-shot Key Point Analysis and Beyond
| 2024-04-29T02:17:31 | 2024-04-29T02:17:31 |
Tomoki Fukuma, Koki Noda, Toshihide Ubukata Kousuke Hoso, Yoshiharu Ichikawa, Kyosuke Kambe, Yu Masubuch, Fujio Toriumi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The proliferation of social media has led to information overload and
increased interest in opinion mining. We propose "Question-Answering Network
Analysis" (QANA), a novel opinion mining framework that utilizes Large Language
Models (LLMs) to generate questions from users' comments, constructs a
bipartite graph based on the comments' answerability to the questions, and
applies centrality measures to examine the importance of opinions. We
investigate the impact of question generation styles, LLM selections, and the
choice of embedding model on the quality of the constructed QA networks by
comparing them with annotated Key Point Analysis datasets. QANA achieves
comparable performance to previous state-of-the-art supervised models in a
zero-shot manner for Key Point Matching task, also reducing the computational
cost from quadratic to linear. For Key Point Generation, questions with high
PageRank or degree centrality align well with manually annotated key points.
Notably, QANA enables analysts to assess the importance of key points from
various aspects according to their selection of centrality measure. QANA's
primary contribution lies in its flexibility to extract key points from a wide
range of perspectives, which enhances the quality and impartiality of opinion
mining.
|
[
-0.32243746519088745,
-0.9739546775817871,
0.8581163287162781,
-0.016736578196287155,
-0.35553720593452454,
-0.04095902666449547,
0.13604934513568878,
-0.20960325002670288,
0.5971823930740356,
0.5489891767501831,
-0.5350726842880249,
-0.8582621216773987,
-0.2350737303495407,
0.04362814500927925,
-0.4416763484477997,
0.8910346627235413,
0.21066579222679138,
-0.08361999690532684,
-0.24134108424186707,
-0.2987150251865387,
-0.36463794112205505,
-0.5259042382240295,
-0.8547954559326172,
0.09505122900009155,
0.8229942321777344,
0.4234786331653595,
0.7693819999694824,
0.19703900814056396,
0.42335760593414307,
0.21933680772781372,
0.00007391580584226176,
0.2578013837337494,
-0.42027387022972107,
0.5130943655967712,
-0.11995181441307068,
-0.887185275554657,
-0.7899876832962036,
-0.08213172107934952,
0.531328558921814,
0.5333126783370972,
0.21388299763202667,
0.6079765558242798,
-0.20906296372413635,
0.7638154029846191,
-0.6169179081916809,
-0.0002775278699118644,
-0.7778043746948242,
-0.03419353812932968,
-0.15500059723854065,
-0.4478183686733246,
-0.059545718133449554,
-0.8038857579231262,
0.031231023371219635,
-0.3641663193702698,
0.10158778727054596,
-0.0072741094045341015,
0.727715253829956,
0.06265422701835632,
-0.5045772194862366,
-0.3792979419231415,
-0.7293556332588196,
0.4476865231990814,
-0.9277903437614441,
-0.271396279335022,
0.1564515084028244,
0.5436657071113586,
-0.01660052500665188,
-0.49292805790901184,
-1.0095056295394897,
0.38951370120048523,
0.3051083981990814,
0.2437041997909546,
-0.24427823722362518,
0.033017389476299286,
-0.032357148826122284,
0.30962997674942017,
-0.679538369178772,
-0.13316868245601654,
-0.383825421333313,
0.2709585130214691,
0.9063626527786255,
0.3146257698535919,
0.31739646196365356,
-0.6267487406730652,
0.14388751983642578,
-0.04171949625015259,
-0.9973524808883667,
0.17952929437160492,
0.7353643774986267,
0.3052993416786194,
0.27268171310424805,
0.6155574917793274,
-0.6141221523284912,
0.5368600487709045,
0.08224239945411682,
0.09944010525941849,
0.02982746995985508,
-0.2740328013896942,
-0.36795780062675476,
-0.22831659018993378,
1.00458824634552,
0.6582109928131104,
0.14507561922073364,
-0.007951128296554089,
0.06979145854711533,
-0.04363526403903961,
0.09636241942644119,
-0.9128832817077637,
-0.3053939938545227,
0.7216126918792725,
-0.5445165634155273,
-0.7277172207832336,
0.009273067116737366,
-0.5732777118682861,
-0.3580736219882965,
-0.0821298286318779,
0.3783411383628845,
0.07824165374040604,
-0.6621150970458984,
-0.13970167934894562,
-0.008375974372029305,
0.44916439056396484,
0.2894981801509857,
-0.3321395218372345,
0.06715889275074005,
0.5674337148666382,
0.9596117734909058,
0.1039278656244278,
0.1987539678812027,
-0.44033047556877136,
-0.15232019126415253,
-0.5874632596969604,
1.09122633934021,
-0.44319796562194824,
-0.3453831970691681,
0.3150855600833893,
-0.08284009993076324,
0.07098217308521271,
-0.602517306804657,
-0.0644693449139595,
-1.0296177864074707,
-0.00833895243704319,
-0.6663693189620972,
-0.6285534501075745,
-0.29407942295074463,
0.7655282020568848,
-0.5699076056480408,
0.8851178288459778,
-0.14536052942276,
-0.48952385783195496,
0.21828104555606842,
-0.6653997898101807,
-0.12542317807674408,
0.09662695229053497,
-0.41037625074386597,
-0.3983434736728668,
-0.043756917119026184,
0.30297228693962097,
0.6463150382041931,
-0.35095304250717163,
0.12760460376739502,
-0.6270816922187805,
-0.05387440323829651,
0.6740173101425171,
-0.11059949547052383,
0.827385663986206,
0.0702141523361206,
-0.1718922257423401,
0.3359284996986389,
-0.7749000787734985,
0.2941555976867676,
0.2070462554693222,
-0.019044505432248116,
-0.24147367477416992,
0.01838497258722782,
-0.1780022233724594,
0.456367552280426,
0.14633816480636597,
-0.6416681408882141,
-0.02830943465232849,
-0.4454362392425537,
0.4516376256942749,
0.5618215799331665,
0.8192760348320007,
0.23357529938220978,
-0.28513914346694946,
0.7694395184516907,
-0.00565252685919404,
0.287356436252594,
-0.03424159437417984,
-0.62532639503479,
-0.6098514795303345,
0.25890788435935974,
0.12482141703367233,
0.46604686975479126,
-0.7138106226921082,
0.26003339886665344,
-0.2883468270301819,
-0.6468946933746338,
-0.565240740776062,
0.2545750141143799,
0.22073061764240265,
0.32344353199005127,
0.09221942722797394,
-0.41643109917640686,
-0.17913217842578888,
-0.8611503839492798,
0.0692279189825058,
-0.5521388649940491,
0.09874642640352249,
0.2846648395061493,
0.24030138552188873,
0.3048820197582245,
1.2038700580596924,
-0.6451786756515503,
-0.07641489803791046,
-0.4873104989528656,
0.14357461035251617,
0.20406851172447205,
-0.024646194651722908,
0.5654885172843933,
-0.7590388059616089,
-0.6420779824256897,
-0.24803973734378815,
-0.9307224154472351,
-0.1866661161184311,
-0.1330678015947342,
-0.31444022059440613,
-0.28009355068206787,
0.37794357538223267,
-0.6463850736618042,
0.30887290835380554,
0.44437819719314575,
-0.04569914937019348,
0.44366341829299927,
0.3806065320968628,
0.20106661319732666,
-1.5434730052947998,
0.1368974894285202,
-0.08010667562484741,
-0.155409574508667,
-0.8130553960800171,
-0.08496766537427902,
-0.12823843955993652,
-0.4362403154373169,
-0.5364559888839722,
0.44388577342033386,
-0.23650230467319489,
-0.18874575197696686,
-0.5274004936218262,
0.5418785214424133,
0.2152450978755951,
0.6999053359031677,
-0.23575298488140106,
0.4343203902244568,
0.14604413509368896,
-0.41256678104400635,
0.39468830823898315,
0.30662405490875244,
-0.13759495317935944,
0.8051589131355286,
-0.9363254308700562,
0.47330525517463684,
-0.19615554809570312,
-0.026915881782770157,
-1.4135180711746216,
-0.10277779400348663,
0.17651934921741486,
-0.8840906023979187,
0.05034344643354416,
-0.25573036074638367,
-0.48508673906326294,
0.0020263211335986853,
-0.5928457379341125,
0.49785175919532776,
0.16809529066085815,
-0.22002717852592468,
0.235591858625412,
0.530798614025116,
-0.40751704573631287,
-0.3565605580806732,
-0.17715561389923096,
-0.0031489599496126175,
-0.04523368179798126,
-0.9015035629272461,
-0.0826205462217331,
-0.026522252708673477,
-0.38125044107437134,
0.39652764797210693,
0.12242259085178375,
-0.06626348197460175,
0.15793833136558533,
0.4695465564727783,
0.21317511796951294,
-0.2889018952846527,
0.1607772260904312,
0.3359795808792114,
0.1499132663011551,
0.3585848808288574,
0.013669874519109726,
0.5394341349601746,
-0.1711910516023636,
-0.2795463502407074,
-0.45249834656715393,
0.29458048939704895,
0.4768695533275604,
-0.4286673367023468,
0.5395743250846863,
0.08224327862262726,
-0.15811187028884888,
-0.43374794721603394,
-0.30987876653671265,
-0.009216120466589928,
-0.40621432662010193,
0.3160317540168762,
-0.15444636344909668,
-0.9024027585983276,
0.6344317197799683,
0.008446842432022095,
0.3641359210014343,
0.538655698299408,
0.7666253447532654,
-0.3183981776237488,
0.8697821497917175,
0.3949558138847351,
-0.11622761934995651,
0.5318189263343811,
-0.41392308473587036,
0.4300695061683655,
-0.7058854103088379,
0.09170899540185928,
-0.2599438726902008,
-0.4222608506679535,
-0.47821563482284546,
-0.24800339341163635,
0.5428330302238464,
0.14267224073410034,
-0.04293956980109215,
0.059533677995204926,
-0.2733311951160431,
0.34519219398498535,
0.4013845920562744,
0.027140745893120766,
0.195853129029274,
-0.26706358790397644,
0.4141566753387451,
0.4494725465774536,
-0.45680171251296997,
-0.66082763671875,
1.7671117782592773,
0.2831128239631653,
0.09816668182611465,
0.3150392472743988,
0.7722287178039551,
0.31813812255859375,
0.547184407711029,
-0.8436287045478821,
0.7029127478599548,
0.34563833475112915,
-0.8800063729286194,
-0.5783242583274841,
-0.37189003825187683,
-0.7446655035018921,
0.3119657039642334,
-0.3923187255859375,
-0.45377054810523987,
0.36345070600509644,
0.12064502388238907,
-0.9472415447235107,
0.39001694321632385,
-0.31841954588890076,
0.6643558740615845,
0.11889879405498505,
-0.27904435992240906,
-0.1813773363828659,
-0.5493790507316589,
0.5852548480033875,
0.16818635165691376,
-0.11837580800056458,
-0.3478986620903015,
0.46178603172302246,
0.8568706512451172,
-0.5510768294334412,
0.8626528978347778,
-0.4244023263454437,
0.12760838866233826,
0.8800106644630432,
0.1038791686296463,
0.25102049112319946,
0.2932089567184448,
-0.09568838775157928,
0.13977648317813873,
0.20900608599185944,
-0.3478085398674011,
-0.942668080329895,
0.6291883587837219,
-0.8773340582847595,
-0.5764570832252502,
-0.1291266232728958,
-0.44869112968444824,
-0.442269504070282,
0.1077006459236145,
-0.044056106358766556,
0.5170029401779175,
-0.1506306529045105,
0.15682701766490936,
0.5904349088668823,
-0.17140412330627441,
0.2664512097835541,
0.2158016860485077,
-0.2749175727367401,
-0.6426166296005249,
0.787384033203125,
0.47751179337501526,
0.3347933292388916,
0.3634797930717468,
-0.02404325269162655,
-0.17616623640060425,
-0.7771283984184265,
-0.41061657667160034,
0.2631560266017914,
-0.6530628204345703,
-0.5010911226272583,
-0.5190228819847107,
-0.3765249252319336,
-0.39981988072395325,
0.051482170820236206,
-0.28592532873153687,
-0.5867905020713806,
-0.06539606302976608,
-0.44362276792526245,
0.2503124475479126,
0.6035409569740295,
0.17647488415241241,
0.6419154405593872,
-0.7032591700553894,
0.18514446914196014,
0.5681890249252319,
0.015812229365110397,
0.12590466439723969,
-0.10609398782253265,
-0.2080814093351364,
-0.19191324710845947,
-0.5635563135147095,
-1.3152300119400024,
0.3361382782459259,
-0.08043023943901062,
0.15076430141925812,
0.5724059343338013,
0.13769951462745667,
0.3743942677974701,
-0.0272732675075531,
0.8557214736938477,
0.04242522642016411,
-0.6068897843360901,
0.6278568506240845,
-0.36566776037216187,
-0.04535970091819763,
0.7303943037986755,
0.29523906111717224,
-0.5521560907363892,
-0.45165127515792847,
-0.6713077425956726,
-0.9086912274360657,
0.17168910801410675,
0.3138682544231415,
0.11442797631025314,
-0.349629670381546,
0.7112522125244141,
-0.22684243321418762,
0.5179923176765442,
-0.5036278963088989,
-0.17313140630722046,
-0.22934886813163757,
-0.3638940453529358,
0.3207249343395233,
-0.34855595231056213,
-0.042853113263845444,
0.23161406815052032,
0.6266188621520996,
-0.306689977645874,
0.11519068479537964,
0.2938627302646637,
-0.10567440837621689,
-0.2618076801300049,
0.3346990942955017,
0.14497406780719757,
0.7775879502296448,
-0.4654383957386017,
-0.042272090911865234,
-0.03296425938606262,
-0.12596912682056427,
0.030407646670937538,
-0.2892969250679016,
-0.6161937713623047,
-0.01131889596581459,
0.1931399405002594,
0.5939007997512817,
-0.3029504716396332,
-0.4166203737258911,
0.7170130610466003,
-0.10887262970209122,
-0.3087964653968811,
-0.3673165738582611,
0.0018566526705399156,
0.08998529613018036,
0.38896095752716064,
0.32375645637512207,
-0.3169441819190979,
0.15105867385864258,
-0.7422509789466858,
-0.12721677124500275,
0.6332302093505859,
-0.42758092284202576,
-0.662656307220459,
0.427113801240921,
0.19773688912391663,
-0.08978498727083206,
0.3972139060497284,
-0.2973560094833374,
-0.29271215200424194,
0.7393690943717957,
0.06265387684106827,
1.0504744052886963,
-0.08783073723316193,
0.5793620944023132,
0.4369881749153137,
0.2720027267932892,
0.4157949388027191,
0.6522057056427002,
-0.08424972742795944,
-0.7895108461380005,
-0.3080640137195587,
-0.6043820381164551,
-0.6802831888198853,
0.14441733062267303,
-0.6909031271934509,
-0.0897771567106247,
-0.8634417057037354,
-0.3776845335960388,
-0.10063992440700531,
0.2739410400390625,
-0.5618769526481628,
0.5328156352043152,
-0.2013455331325531,
0.4340013265609741,
-1.0517057180404663,
0.6514127254486084,
0.6268312335014343,
-0.681188702583313,
-0.8438113927841187,
0.03591093420982361,
0.001613832893781364,
-0.6172192096710205,
0.5156460404396057,
-0.0405239500105381,
0.027344170957803726,
-0.10485091060400009,
-0.5759725570678711,
-0.7930770516395569,
1.5350960493087769,
0.012201900593936443,
-0.4185357689857483,
-0.002662522252649069,
0.41096439957618713,
0.5193526744842529,
-0.4065735340118408,
0.27686673402786255,
0.3101402521133423,
0.008369054645299911,
0.13616777956485748,
-0.3382532596588135,
0.22950609028339386,
-0.45411521196365356,
0.0027704343665391207,
0.17587709426879883,
-0.8038485050201416,
0.7850944995880127,
0.027585146948695183,
-0.26857683062553406,
-0.14734140038490295,
0.9122621417045593,
0.3213447630405426,
0.47578638792037964,
0.5412209033966064,
0.298745721578598,
0.9187160134315491,
0.315757155418396,
0.7843217849731445,
-0.5890098214149475,
0.17106153070926666,
1.0294640064239502,
-0.417588472366333,
1.2248159646987915,
0.4519272446632385,
-0.10271051526069641,
0.5927005410194397,
0.6744174957275391,
0.2514494061470032,
0.3240404427051544,
0.2030252367258072,
-0.1433032900094986,
-0.2457333654165268,
0.011823761276900768,
-0.13287274539470673,
0.15459732711315155,
0.20635025203227997,
-0.1885087937116623,
-0.14622575044631958,
-0.4540039002895355,
0.02521149069070816,
-0.04392991587519646,
-0.43749910593032837,
0.832247257232666,
0.25507137179374695,
-0.31782233715057373,
0.017781604081392288,
-0.021571427583694458,
0.22018012404441833,
-0.5031334161758423,
0.1165260374546051,
-0.6365960240364075,
-0.3021635413169861,
-0.33866456151008606,
-0.8065077066421509,
0.4170882999897003,
0.07965455204248428,
-0.26827681064605713,
0.2808787524700165,
0.6196823120117188,
-0.1543191373348236,
-0.49374067783355713,
0.04815416410565376,
0.8083502650260925,
0.17999160289764404,
-0.47542476654052734,
-0.46179014444351196,
-0.3624127209186554,
-0.29142358899116516,
-0.5624131560325623,
0.344497948884964,
0.44634926319122314,
-0.20185674726963043,
0.3682418167591095,
0.8677071332931519,
0.28528404235839844,
0.1088525727391243,
0.09579478204250336,
0.8594821095466614,
-0.6983197927474976,
-0.3221065402030945,
-0.7936635613441467,
0.4673842191696167,
-0.38288670778274536,
-0.4516797959804535,
0.8193065524101257,
0.4074576199054718,
0.6339291930198669,
0.2564172148704529,
0.9948216080665588,
0.06573694199323654,
0.5330870747566223,
-0.3970353901386261,
0.7754181027412415,
-0.5788245797157288,
0.23495492339134216,
-0.28651610016822815,
-1.078040599822998,
-0.3821650743484497,
0.26160264015197754,
-0.5847667455673218,
-0.2525441348552704,
0.5388616323471069,
1.1110234260559082,
0.20001952350139618,
-0.022662092000246048,
0.40983784198760986,
0.07895177602767944,
0.6665081977844238,
0.4668205976486206,
0.8006478548049927,
-0.5299296975135803,
0.6461232304573059,
-0.06271767616271973,
-0.2769366204738617,
-0.1502767950296402,
-0.49572765827178955,
-1.0547465085983276,
-0.4603654146194458,
-0.32693392038345337,
-0.3922868072986603,
-0.26199623942375183,
0.8958631157875061,
0.5326818227767944,
-0.8166361451148987,
-0.254715234041214,
0.02739546447992325,
0.21669688820838928,
0.030314428731799126,
-0.2541848421096802,
0.6594971418380737,
-0.3712277114391327,
-0.3978794813156128,
0.282582551240921,
0.5042387247085571,
-0.45620444416999817,
-0.6195383071899414,
0.15533006191253662,
-0.07237326353788376,
0.5949374437332153,
0.6728907227516174,
0.43368926644325256,
-0.40034717321395874,
-0.21996168792247772,
0.35094937682151794,
0.09140361100435257,
0.08927178382873535,
0.6828729510307312,
-0.25956007838249207,
0.4634992182254791,
0.6807780265808105,
0.6975953578948975,
0.47806161642074585,
0.1351524293422699,
0.51629638671875,
-0.5931746959686279,
-0.3892458975315094,
0.1362309455871582,
0.15186648070812225,
0.3537173569202423,
-0.24086764454841614,
0.1792728304862976,
0.1549033373594284,
-0.5414135456085205,
-0.7134438753128052,
0.279437392950058,
-0.9591777920722961,
-0.24827633798122406,
1.2484378814697266,
-0.1355854570865631,
-0.6049821376800537,
-0.01624871790409088,
-0.2272588163614273,
0.20436213910579681,
-0.18279066681861877,
0.9425395131111145,
0.5179093480110168,
-0.12763504683971405,
-0.15897619724273682,
-0.5742279291152954,
0.30378708243370056,
0.31981202960014343,
-0.9649854898452759,
-0.16377413272857666,
0.36849257349967957,
0.5226358771324158,
0.24469444155693054,
1.052123785018921,
-0.17364029586315155,
0.3250350058078766,
-0.25872498750686646,
0.17141953110694885,
-0.12680111825466156,
-0.25477781891822815,
-0.2625967264175415,
0.9402604103088379,
0.3620418906211853,
-0.3433169424533844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18359v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18359v1
|
FoundaBench: Evaluating Chinese Fundamental Knowledge Capabilities of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-29T01:49:07 | 2024-04-29T01:49:07 |
Wei Li, Ren Ma, Jiang Wu, Chenya Gu, Jiahui Peng, Jinyang Len, Songyang Zhang, Hang Yan, Dahua Lin, Conghui He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the burgeoning field of large language models (LLMs), the assessment of
fundamental knowledge remains a critical challenge, particularly for models
tailored to Chinese language and culture. This paper introduces FoundaBench, a
pioneering benchmark designed to rigorously evaluate the fundamental knowledge
capabilities of Chinese LLMs. FoundaBench encompasses a diverse array of 3354
multiple-choice questions across common sense and K-12 educational subjects,
meticulously curated to reflect the breadth and depth of everyday and academic
knowledge. We present an extensive evaluation of 12 state-of-the-art LLMs using
FoundaBench, employing both traditional assessment methods and our CircularEval
protocol to mitigate potential biases in model responses. Our results highlight
the superior performance of models pre-trained on Chinese corpora, and reveal a
significant disparity between models' reasoning and memory recall capabilities.
The insights gleaned from FoundaBench evaluations set a new standard for
understanding the fundamental knowledge of LLMs, providing a robust framework
for future advancements in the field.
|
[
-0.14232945442199707,
-0.7881540656089783,
0.49068766832351685,
0.39964133501052856,
-0.058111272752285004,
0.029609760269522667,
-0.5240012407302856,
-0.25998714566230774,
-0.042787689715623856,
0.5675752758979797,
-0.3893100321292877,
-0.6206476092338562,
-0.3534359633922577,
-0.1214359849691391,
-0.2991427779197693,
0.5063406825065613,
-0.12262023985385895,
0.19972023367881775,
-0.10625496506690979,
-0.22927947342395782,
-0.3347099721431732,
-0.39657115936279297,
-0.4120757281780243,
-0.3984764516353607,
0.5658379793167114,
0.39856287837028503,
0.544194757938385,
0.45137128233909607,
0.698226273059845,
0.16623471677303314,
-0.43429532647132874,
0.5011974573135376,
-0.6713320016860962,
-0.07694535702466965,
-0.2213907390832901,
-0.28689128160476685,
-0.3806464672088623,
0.020018931478261948,
0.8343340158462524,
0.995980441570282,
-0.4014965891838074,
0.23517896234989166,
0.028251301497220993,
0.7177563309669495,
-0.5117499232292175,
-0.06444201618432999,
-0.8323945999145508,
0.06941253691911697,
-0.2670947313308716,
0.0919082909822464,
-0.289385050535202,
-0.6421070694923401,
0.25411713123321533,
-0.7393828630447388,
0.24799203872680664,
-0.14031106233596802,
0.6933863759040833,
-0.18289020657539368,
-0.46785274147987366,
-0.40847083926200867,
-0.3768186569213867,
0.7745744585990906,
-0.8106688261032104,
0.5028638243675232,
0.2123386263847351,
0.4581134617328644,
0.016720617190003395,
-0.9744420647621155,
-0.46093326807022095,
-0.6769008636474609,
0.019185062497854233,
0.0811871811747551,
0.2622815668582916,
-0.011936012655496597,
0.1865081638097763,
0.6272644400596619,
-0.6845784187316895,
0.1957799196243286,
-0.3107520043849945,
-0.433016300201416,
0.6195375323295593,
0.13924235105514526,
0.356388121843338,
-0.267665296792984,
-0.3012511432170868,
0.0730140209197998,
-0.8063727617263794,
0.044804926961660385,
0.13796114921569824,
0.25449705123901367,
0.06187645345926285,
0.18502090871334076,
-0.3730018436908722,
0.5109109282493591,
-0.06365898996591568,
-0.2121233493089676,
0.10993021726608276,
-0.4550839960575104,
-0.11547493189573288,
-0.11824255436658859,
0.7152106761932373,
0.19505006074905396,
0.2530382573604584,
-0.07740183919668198,
-0.2994978427886963,
-0.18890362977981567,
0.08738572895526886,
-0.7146669626235962,
-0.10630211234092712,
-0.05200647935271263,
-0.3993609845638275,
-0.13739562034606934,
0.2029947191476822,
-0.5740260481834412,
-0.5173326730728149,
-0.19891522824764252,
-0.0006180315976962447,
-0.36860063672065735,
-0.42270180583000183,
-0.016013704240322113,
-0.08716435730457306,
0.4616607129573822,
0.5023375749588013,
-0.7715453505516052,
0.1317051202058792,
1.0224601030349731,
0.8866241574287415,
-0.1459956169128418,
-0.46254995465278625,
-0.23997505009174347,
0.06101510301232338,
-0.7955389022827148,
0.7574108242988586,
-0.31132954359054565,
-0.36540764570236206,
0.26603320240974426,
-0.07779650390148163,
0.10100262612104416,
-0.8951482772827148,
0.8076940178871155,
-0.5685110092163086,
-0.39087849855422974,
-0.6744690537452698,
-0.4761650860309601,
-0.4578585922718048,
0.6641928553581238,
-0.7295289039611816,
1.0447542667388916,
-0.015356232412159443,
-0.5853255391120911,
0.29023468494415283,
-0.3197515308856964,
-0.4163719415664673,
0.2573307454586029,
-0.30154260993003845,
0.013996793888509274,
-0.11232662200927734,
-0.042586568742990494,
0.42196038365364075,
-0.6747642159461975,
0.6701129078865051,
-0.6014461517333984,
-0.35174453258514404,
0.3646692633628845,
-0.6597428321838379,
1.0381280183792114,
-0.036123115569353104,
-0.3096860349178314,
0.0774616077542305,
-0.7102550268173218,
0.18289169669151306,
0.08059919625520706,
-0.2751486003398895,
-0.2915382981300354,
-0.2563120722770691,
0.01044771820306778,
-0.022734524682164192,
0.65134596824646,
-0.42858272790908813,
0.07509925216436386,
-0.1833760142326355,
0.3842145502567291,
0.8707478046417236,
-0.2669242322444916,
0.1606689989566803,
-0.25086233019828796,
0.12662498652935028,
-0.2360871434211731,
0.15763260424137115,
-0.1802750527858734,
-0.054928410798311234,
-0.7518385052680969,
-0.13828407227993011,
0.25074949860572815,
0.3513180911540985,
-0.4402329921722412,
0.1891109049320221,
-0.3081538677215576,
-1.0987576246261597,
-0.472533255815506,
0.5480940937995911,
0.3442387878894806,
0.3392941951751709,
0.07502143830060959,
-0.08893842250108719,
-0.18293723464012146,
-1.0112794637680054,
-0.1565370112657547,
-0.21612127125263214,
-0.267381489276886,
0.49948275089263916,
0.44848063588142395,
-0.5211708545684814,
0.5082041025161743,
-0.41640400886535645,
-0.04487839713692665,
-0.28608858585357666,
0.002747449791058898,
0.17768874764442444,
0.21496610343456268,
0.3816147744655609,
-0.6830679774284363,
-0.414794921875,
0.4774375259876251,
-1.0222572088241577,
-0.2056782841682434,
0.04941082000732422,
-0.09151320904493332,
-0.18332846462726593,
0.40651804208755493,
-0.6008516550064087,
0.005901412572711706,
0.34142738580703735,
0.06563708931207657,
0.9460602402687073,
-0.13619780540466309,
0.09369876980781555,
-0.5073742270469666,
0.5485054850578308,
-0.3183820843696594,
0.03188254311680794,
-0.6076594591140747,
0.5111917853355408,
0.44324791431427,
0.07421767711639404,
-0.3469046950340271,
0.7905074954032898,
-0.5486835837364197,
-0.1154279112815857,
-0.19062083959579468,
0.7584095597267151,
-0.020644957199692726,
0.3988644480705261,
0.013867848552763462,
0.6113303303718567,
0.4573794901371002,
-0.8956725001335144,
0.7446824908256531,
0.018453966826200485,
-0.6553799510002136,
0.3314724266529083,
-0.6718938946723938,
0.3576938807964325,
0.22125951945781708,
0.15938888490200043,
-0.9105457067489624,
-0.2189951092004776,
-0.1011301726102829,
-0.3248674273490906,
0.11671734601259232,
0.23564237356185913,
-0.5558788776397705,
-0.43348491191864014,
-0.34125688672065735,
0.29620838165283203,
0.10420537739992142,
-0.6965172290802002,
0.587533712387085,
0.36926376819610596,
-0.14094576239585876,
-0.6385983228683472,
-0.3905336260795593,
-0.05329219251871109,
0.004482847172766924,
-0.8190258741378784,
0.2168588936328888,
-0.18896053731441498,
-0.3371758460998535,
-0.38458052277565,
-0.2931555211544037,
-0.21305058896541595,
0.4159334897994995,
-0.08173693716526031,
0.23919080197811127,
-0.4953783452510834,
0.01691843941807747,
0.00345845939591527,
0.0774611234664917,
0.14299343526363373,
-0.07371051609516144,
0.5215699672698975,
-0.3672909736633301,
-0.5581453442573547,
0.15487107634544373,
-0.1277410238981247,
0.5882217884063721,
-0.11844594776630402,
0.4554586410522461,
0.44463270902633667,
-0.4488006830215454,
-0.3456060290336609,
-0.674521803855896,
-0.08881738036870956,
-0.5001202821731567,
0.6476852893829346,
-0.07626926898956299,
-0.7939138412475586,
0.7451400756835938,
-0.15382042527198792,
0.42689672112464905,
0.3435957431793213,
0.6002437472343445,
0.26242583990097046,
0.4609498679637909,
0.34750014543533325,
-0.04867137596011162,
0.09795534610748291,
-0.018380194902420044,
0.18658661842346191,
-0.8347791433334351,
-0.31208667159080505,
-0.3164607584476471,
0.047139402478933334,
-0.46613460779190063,
-0.5853439569473267,
0.11906739324331284,
0.11780133098363876,
-0.44584232568740845,
0.21312381327152252,
-0.16208818554878235,
0.2403668612241745,
0.5212163925170898,
0.23810118436813354,
0.48599693179130554,
-0.43933919072151184,
-0.4367656111717224,
0.0793037936091423,
-0.6791448593139648,
-0.8328003287315369,
1.1379772424697876,
0.47283056378364563,
0.5308709144592285,
0.11245548725128174,
0.17296423017978668,
0.1280018836259842,
0.5501058101654053,
-0.7287647128105164,
0.8499218225479126,
-0.19707460701465607,
-0.9296427369117737,
-0.4935119152069092,
-0.5251209139823914,
-0.47162216901779175,
0.4017072916030884,
0.2911217212677002,
-0.4353731572628021,
-0.3042512536048889,
-0.0018622062634676695,
-0.3408063054084778,
0.24970710277557373,
-0.37726277112960815,
0.7889708876609802,
-0.6111412644386292,
-0.4208489954471588,
-0.39464661478996277,
-0.25977638363838196,
0.721975564956665,
-0.3412458598613739,
0.15649253129959106,
-0.18734309077262878,
0.06852496415376663,
1.0223815441131592,
0.001884132856503129,
0.7787557244300842,
-0.05516224727034569,
-0.24576705694198608,
0.43577882647514343,
0.10414016991853714,
0.21600757539272308,
0.22806592285633087,
-0.20303742587566376,
0.519604504108429,
0.18090561032295227,
-0.4473421573638916,
-0.6180486679077148,
0.8265681266784668,
-0.6326507329940796,
-0.8035088777542114,
-0.2865927815437317,
-0.300199419260025,
-0.0937260091304779,
0.47385174036026,
0.006114281248301268,
0.2254975438117981,
-0.8777480721473694,
0.45537516474723816,
0.808956503868103,
-0.5324704051017761,
0.1489538699388504,
0.9003903269767761,
-0.5410106778144836,
-0.33233559131622314,
0.7650086283683777,
0.401445209980011,
0.3586275577545166,
0.42140746116638184,
0.2780728340148926,
-0.07865035533905029,
-0.16142655909061432,
-0.2205757200717926,
0.25370141863822937,
-0.9556242227554321,
-0.009043174795806408,
-0.42663827538490295,
-0.5688103437423706,
-0.4570094347000122,
-0.12061740458011627,
-0.6708370447158813,
-0.018532058224081993,
-0.14774905145168304,
-0.3419487476348877,
-0.07020065933465958,
0.5400405526161194,
-0.15418778359889984,
0.2564985752105713,
-0.6979739665985107,
0.3670303225517273,
0.5633620619773865,
0.4948577582836151,
0.47569531202316284,
-0.7788425087928772,
-0.4708676040172577,
0.15593555569648743,
-0.4502744972705841,
-0.5922136306762695,
0.11283480376005173,
-0.10200506448745728,
0.9658295512199402,
0.8748736381530762,
0.06278161704540253,
0.5947105884552002,
-0.37934261560440063,
0.7734885215759277,
0.03810786083340645,
-0.9383006691932678,
0.18879075348377228,
-0.3117573857307434,
0.23191647231578827,
0.50459223985672,
0.23509640991687775,
-0.9234133958816528,
-0.07435137778520584,
-0.5169525742530823,
-0.46964484453201294,
0.3722257614135742,
-0.08583515882492065,
0.16562174260616302,
0.12179926037788391,
0.16683265566825867,
0.16321280598640442,
0.18133428692817688,
-0.7162929177284241,
-0.18825720250606537,
-0.14360621571540833,
0.06776495277881622,
0.1800391674041748,
-0.4380669593811035,
0.11720779538154602,
-0.18490909039974213,
0.49055245518684387,
-0.01726587302982807,
0.058901913464069366,
0.004342351108789444,
-0.22302326560020447,
0.05867120996117592,
0.20943386852741241,
0.5514732003211975,
0.9895859956741333,
-0.16258634626865387,
0.035850491374731064,
0.35182997584342957,
-0.6051137447357178,
-0.17939621210098267,
-0.048923566937446594,
-0.3358566462993622,
0.07646192610263824,
0.7811862826347351,
0.7278397679328918,
0.5354737639427185,
-0.9573870897293091,
0.261604368686676,
0.07407822459936142,
-0.10957609862089157,
-0.5528382062911987,
0.07624172419309616,
0.2208372950553894,
-0.06254680454730988,
0.5927684307098389,
-0.2858619689941406,
-0.052940983325242996,
-0.6623433232307434,
0.32665833830833435,
0.4690147638320923,
-0.46075141429901123,
-0.4092485010623932,
0.21098202466964722,
0.3336065411567688,
-0.132842555642128,
0.6662639379501343,
0.15327388048171997,
-0.8894906640052795,
0.6012431383132935,
0.2124764323234558,
0.7055110931396484,
-0.3620753288269043,
0.22324803471565247,
0.6005603671073914,
0.6951159834861755,
-0.19017933309078217,
-0.17803090810775757,
-0.035162732005119324,
-0.9963919520378113,
0.07885362952947617,
-0.31115853786468506,
-0.4775678813457489,
0.29530224204063416,
-0.6108335852622986,
0.32964327931404114,
-0.8432064652442932,
0.06966889649629593,
-0.2470090687274933,
0.4469988942146301,
-0.5500147342681885,
0.03727808967232704,
0.19391503930091858,
1.217631459236145,
-0.685487687587738,
0.7315514087677002,
0.35752224922180176,
-0.19185979664325714,
-0.8035438060760498,
0.06358712166547775,
-0.08717796951532364,
-1.0697274208068848,
0.8760903477668762,
0.49266716837882996,
-0.035107843577861786,
-0.22341065108776093,
-0.5958359837532043,
-0.8165625333786011,
1.1664340496063232,
0.25958943367004395,
-0.6692530512809753,
0.014652786776423454,
-0.010150652378797531,
0.49433866143226624,
-0.10959406942129135,
0.7142899632453918,
0.7633288502693176,
0.5914270877838135,
0.06064809486269951,
-1.035577654838562,
-0.1139640286564827,
-0.18172204494476318,
-0.18801692128181458,
-0.19416795670986176,
-0.9648856520652771,
0.7251542210578918,
-0.18273606896400452,
-0.44096776843070984,
-0.08833931386470795,
0.9067259430885315,
0.7789349555969238,
0.623981237411499,
0.08615683019161224,
0.07141531258821487,
1.2510987520217896,
0.04077180102467537,
0.7168440222740173,
-0.26937785744667053,
0.2789974510669708,
0.8566964864730835,
-0.5685960054397583,
0.7644791007041931,
0.15303637087345123,
-0.13433155417442322,
0.3632054030895233,
0.6774778962135315,
0.0448111817240715,
0.29537785053253174,
0.33050283789634705,
-0.11400376260280609,
-0.30807623267173767,
-0.17063069343566895,
-0.3470931053161621,
0.14651137590408325,
0.3502216041088104,
0.0062260436825454235,
-0.1523403525352478,
-0.2892571985721588,
0.08245601505041122,
0.31356754899024963,
-0.33416473865509033,
0.545669436454773,
0.3185175657272339,
-0.6232315897941589,
0.7057443261146545,
0.031374190002679825,
0.7967968583106995,
-0.7189207673072815,
0.11184287816286087,
-0.7534602284431458,
0.09900079667568207,
0.03525669872760773,
-0.7649257183074951,
-0.08854534476995468,
0.09657212346792221,
-0.11392740160226822,
0.11995106935501099,
0.584990918636322,
-0.2860860824584961,
-0.5748324394226074,
0.624625563621521,
0.19858238101005554,
-0.1518498957157135,
-0.03876142576336861,
-0.5805840492248535,
0.02008277364075184,
0.17314748466014862,
-0.20911386609077454,
0.09674447774887085,
0.8413048386573792,
0.011729458346962929,
1.1009104251861572,
0.5703098177909851,
0.21939006447792053,
0.08062540739774704,
-0.061088014394044876,
0.6759923100471497,
-0.8354264497756958,
-0.300812691450119,
-0.7328106760978699,
0.0411846749484539,
-0.14504669606685638,
-0.342591792345047,
0.9426723718643188,
0.5862815380096436,
0.8968007564544678,
0.03439857438206673,
0.8753302693367004,
0.21133016049861908,
0.800733745098114,
-0.43896758556365967,
0.9339758157730103,
-0.4503808915615082,
0.4714287519454956,
-0.31194525957107544,
-0.8234304785728455,
-0.04800576716661453,
0.6583195328712463,
-0.5255647301673889,
0.03214279189705849,
0.6762691736221313,
0.8485813140869141,
0.003728631418198347,
-0.06575211137533188,
0.5783136487007141,
0.18150046467781067,
0.3873744010925293,
0.5357419848442078,
0.947145402431488,
-0.31763696670532227,
0.450466513633728,
-0.16635948419570923,
-0.3716118037700653,
-0.18392686545848846,
-0.6666802763938904,
-1.0645281076431274,
-0.49423715472221375,
-0.02328149415552616,
0.1406942754983902,
-0.09536775946617126,
0.7494561672210693,
0.4115651845932007,
-0.829781174659729,
-0.5900372266769409,
0.11736202985048294,
0.30816224217414856,
-0.1480514109134674,
-0.22209447622299194,
0.48863062262535095,
-0.12126253545284271,
-0.3220951557159424,
0.3050391972064972,
0.2029370814561844,
-0.33108919858932495,
-0.5938049554824829,
-0.19287681579589844,
-0.21607352793216705,
0.08136509358882904,
0.6024141311645508,
0.22006723284721375,
-0.9534972906112671,
0.010778378695249557,
0.39303672313690186,
-0.4629788398742676,
-0.28965631127357483,
0.8117434978485107,
-0.4705561399459839,
0.171825110912323,
0.43489232659339905,
0.6633914113044739,
0.19958971440792084,
-0.21208183467388153,
0.6033670902252197,
-0.32224389910697937,
0.1482638269662857,
0.15926869213581085,
0.2454804629087448,
0.5973389148712158,
-0.07955165207386017,
0.447135865688324,
0.2608301043510437,
-0.40617576241493225,
-0.9941180348396301,
-0.1113143339753151,
-0.7328184247016907,
-0.38533830642700195,
1.1686383485794067,
-0.3207199275493622,
-0.03507796674966812,
0.1490878015756607,
-0.17514483630657196,
0.25132447481155396,
-0.1339021772146225,
0.9063112139701843,
0.878932535648346,
0.7025813460350037,
-0.28451967239379883,
-0.6918045282363892,
0.23214185237884521,
0.41928085684776306,
-0.5159258246421814,
0.5694653391838074,
0.4181199073791504,
0.15690863132476807,
0.19502708315849304,
0.4677703380584717,
0.11376513540744781,
0.43432745337486267,
-0.0358298197388649,
-0.06161220371723175,
0.11019936203956604,
-0.38870853185653687,
0.0883897989988327,
0.04299503192305565,
0.22295737266540527,
0.3578704595565796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18311v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18311v4
|
Towards Incremental Learning in Large Language Models: A Critical Review
| 2024-04-28T20:44:53 | 2024-05-05T08:46:32 |
Mladjan Jovanovic, Peter Voss
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Incremental learning is the ability of systems to acquire knowledge over
time, enabling their adaptation and generalization to novel tasks. It is a
critical ability for intelligent, real-world systems, especially when data
changes frequently or is limited. This review provides a comprehensive analysis
of incremental learning in Large Language Models. It synthesizes the
state-of-the-art incremental learning paradigms, including continual learning,
meta-learning, parameter-efficient learning, and mixture-of-experts learning.
We demonstrate their utility for incremental learning by describing specific
achievements from these related topics and their critical factors. An important
finding is that many of these approaches do not update the core model, and none
of them update incrementally in real-time. The paper highlights current
problems and challenges for future research in the field. By consolidating the
latest relevant research developments, this review offers a comprehensive
understanding of incremental learning and its implications for designing and
developing LLM-based learning systems.
|
[
-0.17418025434017181,
-1.0084903240203857,
0.36195963621139526,
0.13868477940559387,
0.055789764970541,
0.39382079243659973,
-0.4155614376068115,
-0.6520565152168274,
-0.36654335260391235,
0.2669737935066223,
-0.5180739164352417,
-0.2362053245306015,
-0.593819260597229,
-0.02946348674595356,
-0.50552898645401,
0.6988795399665833,
-0.09848426282405853,
0.07104817777872086,
-0.1001427099108696,
-0.2138529270887375,
-0.695440948009491,
-0.5759012699127197,
-0.9133374094963074,
-0.5327221751213074,
0.3731478154659271,
0.5796869993209839,
0.3427886664867401,
0.5108577013015747,
0.42297014594078064,
0.2640233039855957,
-0.13185779750347137,
-0.006663840264081955,
-0.5169910192489624,
0.6194726824760437,
-0.3392997980117798,
-0.3744361400604248,
-0.2744601368904114,
-0.17309457063674927,
1.1555733680725098,
0.9487301111221313,
-0.2011290192604065,
0.1243961974978447,
0.27654722332954407,
0.7521312832832336,
-0.3043805658817291,
0.3115321397781372,
-0.7689135074615479,
0.19781213998794556,
0.022633003070950508,
0.04090603440999985,
-0.3592144250869751,
-0.47760799527168274,
0.30877843499183655,
-0.19295243918895721,
0.03165522590279579,
-0.4075363874435425,
0.3341076076030731,
0.013805643655359745,
-0.25369569659233093,
-0.6194672584533691,
-0.9928811192512512,
0.8221143484115601,
-0.732322096824646,
0.5318661332130432,
-0.1499820500612259,
0.3189117908477783,
-0.03316838666796684,
-0.6947891712188721,
-0.40235909819602966,
-0.7276425361633301,
0.42366206645965576,
-0.029036663472652435,
0.31138885021209717,
-0.20457133650779724,
0.20178267359733582,
0.46129897236824036,
-0.29139846563339233,
0.33209317922592163,
-0.14212974905967712,
0.09178537875413895,
0.4985182285308838,
0.3964137136936188,
0.29980847239494324,
0.4309857487678528,
-0.3320387899875641,
-0.014594943262636662,
-1.008729100227356,
-0.01639937050640583,
0.0034584158565849066,
0.23483669757843018,
-0.08195575326681137,
0.1651182621717453,
-0.27875739336013794,
0.7207790613174438,
0.0038193846121430397,
-0.5792567133903503,
0.19000431895256042,
-0.3481004238128662,
-0.026501359418034554,
-0.26277732849121094,
0.2993922829627991,
-0.49320390820503235,
0.3329566419124603,
-0.223086878657341,
-0.3187171518802643,
-0.2906748354434967,
0.1307356357574463,
-0.39332693815231323,
0.012476880103349686,
0.21775025129318237,
-0.0378599688410759,
-0.1139858216047287,
-0.08101868629455566,
-0.5508418679237366,
-0.14656369388103485,
-0.6808551549911499,
0.3699449300765991,
-0.5957401394844055,
-0.5251489281654358,
-0.046751681715250015,
0.37799596786499023,
0.28996333479881287,
0.7274648547172546,
-0.7352055907249451,
0.12332116067409515,
0.7458481192588806,
0.7140564918518066,
-0.20553402602672577,
-0.7480869293212891,
-0.23494349420070648,
0.0699806958436966,
-0.5626917481422424,
0.6130133867263794,
-0.6014050245285034,
-0.310819149017334,
0.26881226897239685,
-0.00037629532744176686,
-0.16502095758914948,
-0.7583978176116943,
-0.07490523904561996,
-0.6281816959381104,
-0.09431479871273041,
-0.20294500887393951,
-0.6485053300857544,
-0.3371947407722473,
0.38213786482810974,
-0.2743760645389557,
0.8769086599349976,
0.08187967538833618,
-0.3524048328399658,
0.36390113830566406,
-0.458962619304657,
-0.44993269443511963,
0.289466917514801,
-0.0461934395134449,
-0.3156030774116516,
0.0986533910036087,
-0.42636433243751526,
0.5851696729660034,
-0.1775926947593689,
0.5961184501647949,
-0.43107840418815613,
-0.02600918710231781,
0.4314787983894348,
-0.3027932941913605,
0.5534018874168396,
0.21022264659404755,
-0.38898247480392456,
0.1017441377043724,
-0.5897138118743896,
-0.24760980904102325,
0.18860091269016266,
-0.671227753162384,
-0.13669997453689575,
0.3680780231952667,
-0.28569290041923523,
0.3470112383365631,
0.3516616225242615,
-0.259076863527298,
0.44521820545196533,
-0.07898156344890594,
0.5655515789985657,
0.9146038889884949,
0.165940523147583,
0.5050175786018372,
-0.2639104723930359,
0.33717697858810425,
0.1074334979057312,
0.3872706890106201,
-0.5746327638626099,
-0.06260143965482712,
-0.943631112575531,
-0.006406439933925867,
0.5000170469284058,
0.6206454634666443,
-0.7827329039573669,
0.17006038129329681,
-0.34370240569114685,
-0.4798882305622101,
-0.15042981505393982,
0.3962182104587555,
0.27698710560798645,
0.33212634921073914,
0.30501750111579895,
-0.299609512090683,
-0.12377743422985077,
-0.41744381189346313,
0.041414450854063034,
-0.0035956844221800566,
0.28747424483299255,
0.19227325916290283,
0.6762659549713135,
-0.3947141170501709,
0.5094882249832153,
-0.20626676082611084,
-0.13657838106155396,
-0.4037420451641083,
-0.05145883187651634,
-0.053429361432790756,
0.7124970555305481,
0.16981454193592072,
-0.6540195345878601,
-0.5396222472190857,
0.25966572761535645,
-1.0543484687805176,
0.3504987955093384,
-0.3139835000038147,
0.4453103840351105,
0.09719332307577133,
0.7209228873252869,
-0.3060297966003418,
-0.058911681175231934,
0.26970264315605164,
-0.021733233705163002,
0.5651051998138428,
-0.3698076009750366,
-0.1753920614719391,
-0.6595917344093323,
-0.04979583993554115,
0.09623565524816513,
-0.20989327132701874,
-0.6576366424560547,
0.5933522582054138,
0.14140847325325012,
-0.0928599089384079,
-0.34737372398376465,
0.6761687397956848,
-0.5182321667671204,
0.028335077688097954,
-0.32111191749572754,
0.09063279628753662,
-0.5389679670333862,
0.40786248445510864,
0.01489328034222126,
0.4977096915245056,
0.588162362575531,
-1.0167282819747925,
0.3559795320034027,
-0.18726415932178497,
-0.46254321932792664,
0.4701452851295471,
-0.3859681487083435,
0.17049308121204376,
-0.0686958059668541,
0.24351446330547333,
-0.8040590882301331,
-0.19976270198822021,
0.09989280253648758,
-0.3661901354789734,
0.6550429463386536,
0.19216659665107727,
-0.6657742261886597,
-0.02505779080092907,
-0.010798596777021885,
0.23851998150348663,
0.316394567489624,
-0.2735055685043335,
0.37641769647598267,
0.6007581353187561,
-0.4772220253944397,
-0.44331902265548706,
-0.28108423948287964,
0.11539998650550842,
0.02628716081380844,
-0.20497523248195648,
-0.0909143015742302,
-0.06981711834669113,
-0.47588589787483215,
-0.06495847553014755,
0.037048012018203735,
0.026133473962545395,
0.28802600502967834,
-0.01028800942003727,
0.16115610301494598,
0.02419677935540676,
0.6579219698905945,
-0.14744369685649872,
-0.2429487407207489,
-0.23057176172733307,
-0.7017935514450073,
0.4830644726753235,
-0.0720643624663353,
-0.23020870983600616,
-0.2994590103626251,
0.3733051121234894,
0.682471513748169,
-0.11717692762613297,
0.6667371988296509,
0.43959179520606995,
-0.3209489583969116,
-0.32318422198295593,
-0.735922634601593,
-0.1475268453359604,
-0.37108319997787476,
0.526485800743103,
-0.45894762873649597,
-1.1216800212860107,
0.3029857277870178,
-0.3443503975868225,
0.3637619614601135,
0.5439794659614563,
0.6197348833084106,
-0.06757941097021103,
0.8954667448997498,
1.1644777059555054,
-0.20733311772346497,
0.686763346195221,
-0.2821677625179291,
-0.07514414936304092,
-0.8076531887054443,
-0.48071011900901794,
-0.45772573351860046,
-0.12578018009662628,
-0.38288161158561707,
-0.160597026348114,
0.3917829990386963,
-0.1502731442451477,
-0.4197721481323242,
0.0049127559177577496,
-0.141380175948143,
0.08905121684074402,
0.3353928029537201,
-0.016826488077640533,
0.46826544404029846,
-0.14152754843235016,
-0.13680139183998108,
0.1324283927679062,
-0.7443076372146606,
-0.20383039116859436,
0.7389530539512634,
0.42054328322410583,
0.7090588808059692,
-0.012407636269927025,
0.2298927754163742,
0.3857676386833191,
0.5834717750549316,
-0.7765447497367859,
0.4493066370487213,
0.08138369768857956,
-0.6609393358230591,
-0.4814215302467346,
-0.5119975805282593,
-0.8140223026275635,
0.24369794130325317,
-0.18577244877815247,
-0.3616257309913635,
0.19491468369960785,
0.02808576077222824,
-0.04641943797469139,
0.5079371333122253,
-0.4191567301750183,
0.45054471492767334,
-0.32055041193962097,
-0.40712234377861023,
-0.6055947542190552,
-0.5541636943817139,
0.31522688269615173,
-0.4433666467666626,
0.3118390738964081,
0.07289832830429077,
-0.3529176115989685,
0.4902011752128601,
0.04979441687464714,
0.9503341317176819,
-0.26672857999801636,
-0.34557968378067017,
0.38647082448005676,
0.17467506229877472,
0.6337045431137085,
-0.1147264614701271,
0.07642580568790436,
0.12845905125141144,
-0.06258390098810196,
-0.5045604705810547,
-0.23807720839977264,
0.7502688765525818,
-0.6482520699501038,
-0.45142126083374023,
-0.48971572518348694,
-0.47778743505477905,
-0.45080819725990295,
-0.06364341825246811,
-0.009817908518016338,
0.4749692380428314,
-0.16318194568157196,
0.28363287448883057,
1.2587966918945312,
-0.24189302325248718,
0.3612203598022461,
0.6598284244537354,
-0.3731388449668884,
-0.37177008390426636,
1.0888642072677612,
0.7224713563919067,
0.521835446357727,
0.47860878705978394,
0.00029309612000361085,
-0.11907948553562164,
-0.881757915019989,
-0.23204576969146729,
0.5039361715316772,
-0.8540244698524475,
0.1505594551563263,
-0.7952743172645569,
-0.22041428089141846,
-0.28776416182518005,
-0.06557425856590271,
-0.2895483374595642,
-0.2492348700761795,
-0.3345509469509125,
-0.042618416249752045,
-0.015278046019375324,
1.041195034980774,
-0.1517755389213562,
0.011241110973060131,
-0.8293693661689758,
-0.04044674336910248,
0.5920553803443909,
0.09922676533460617,
0.6383126974105835,
-0.7349570989608765,
-0.5929214954376221,
-0.152463898062706,
-0.32012245059013367,
-0.46617934107780457,
0.17032285034656525,
0.25538691878318787,
0.6349793076515198,
0.3356253206729889,
-0.2351222187280655,
0.5367246270179749,
-0.5485206842422485,
0.6916935443878174,
0.13822469115257263,
-0.8915438652038574,
0.3321276009082794,
-0.32058200240135193,
0.5069695115089417,
0.5936105847358704,
0.5211489796638489,
-0.8133230209350586,
-0.22075214982032776,
-0.6100176572799683,
-0.9840379357337952,
0.26608553528785706,
-0.6249879598617554,
0.4169165790081024,
0.22291408479213715,
0.6649319529533386,
0.5177693963050842,
0.32745635509490967,
-0.8491148948669434,
0.003293720306828618,
0.3459116518497467,
0.06604419648647308,
-0.13408148288726807,
-0.45918142795562744,
0.18616937100887299,
-0.3228302001953125,
0.8653783798217773,
-0.17174024879932404,
0.04919935017824173,
0.022933855652809143,
-0.5134738683700562,
0.047625426203012466,
0.2810765504837036,
0.5844606161117554,
1.1592639684677124,
0.03071325458586216,
-0.21156568825244904,
0.4705309271812439,
-0.4433289170265198,
0.3595813512802124,
-0.5061576962471008,
-0.22210019826889038,
-0.1991870105266571,
0.5074427127838135,
0.6050246357917786,
0.41016384959220886,
-0.679019570350647,
0.22572338581085205,
0.26155126094818115,
-0.16713900864124298,
-0.6474559903144836,
0.09261244535446167,
-0.13612200319766998,
0.33533239364624023,
0.6000484824180603,
0.044275421649217606,
-0.2389334887266159,
-0.9628506898880005,
0.16337527334690094,
0.4623904824256897,
-0.797569990158081,
-0.5499247908592224,
0.291790634393692,
0.14560213685035706,
-0.19648313522338867,
0.5850052237510681,
0.0014152785297483206,
-0.28633102774620056,
0.37602782249450684,
0.5021585822105408,
0.8635808825492859,
-0.46174243092536926,
0.11029460281133652,
0.37881365418434143,
0.3567834496498108,
-0.3162778615951538,
-0.020699607208371162,
-0.44263485074043274,
-0.5472279787063599,
-0.6554737091064453,
-0.5352963209152222,
-0.8553675413131714,
0.2762256860733032,
-0.3039993941783905,
-0.06601226329803467,
-0.7048740983009338,
0.14722441136837006,
-0.3270651698112488,
-0.04588479548692703,
-0.4536915421485901,
0.3711444139480591,
0.03795613721013069,
1.0587555170059204,
-0.6466392874717712,
1.0540101528167725,
0.573191225528717,
-0.2940922677516937,
-0.5363897085189819,
-0.023142321035265923,
-0.09557311981916428,
-0.6000994443893433,
0.6626108884811401,
-0.12293326109647751,
-0.03272642195224762,
0.2366064041852951,
-0.6618972420692444,
-0.8614529967308044,
0.9055176377296448,
0.24197901785373688,
-0.47892558574676514,
-0.06859239190816879,
-0.17785613238811493,
0.4762174189090729,
-0.5860697627067566,
-0.007139437831938267,
0.3866574764251709,
0.33483150601387024,
0.1331031769514084,
-0.6579082608222961,
-0.2337794005870819,
-0.028685009106993675,
0.042241185903549194,
0.15807436406612396,
-0.8335567712783813,
0.9953957796096802,
-0.19484910368919373,
-0.258232057094574,
-0.04824891686439514,
0.6577543616294861,
-0.04541590064764023,
0.18334150314331055,
0.2975163161754608,
0.5455060005187988,
0.6260579228401184,
-0.057670094072818756,
0.9852219820022583,
-0.1184491440653801,
0.5275946259498596,
1.0766124725341797,
-0.505354642868042,
0.9415356516838074,
0.14586743712425232,
-0.4009239673614502,
0.5973132848739624,
0.8210247159004211,
0.17752090096473694,
0.3606889843940735,
0.014768083579838276,
-0.48217329382896423,
-0.29638415575027466,
0.08890148252248764,
-0.5976822972297668,
0.14605127274990082,
0.6274659633636475,
-0.096317358314991,
-0.17059500515460968,
0.36471858620643616,
-0.007345233112573624,
-0.18810346722602844,
-0.46819931268692017,
1.1008315086364746,
0.17091988027095795,
-0.655832052230835,
0.45255541801452637,
-0.20005977153778076,
0.497594952583313,
-0.8188491463661194,
-0.08530380576848984,
-0.16496466100215912,
0.41256386041641235,
-0.02741304412484169,
-0.5134437680244446,
0.16496329009532928,
-0.09279941767454147,
-0.1844848245382309,
-0.16115638613700867,
0.5570952296257019,
-0.3587192893028259,
-0.3927939832210541,
0.399568110704422,
0.6750746965408325,
-0.09990652650594711,
0.12818029522895813,
-0.8572094440460205,
0.20380328595638275,
-0.037630222737789154,
-0.08805985748767853,
0.7087604403495789,
0.4422813653945923,
0.20552094280719757,
1.1619280576705933,
0.6564680933952332,
0.2415960133075714,
0.0664273276925087,
-0.20326872169971466,
0.6821074485778809,
-0.7786061763763428,
-0.25384262204170227,
-0.881886899471283,
0.4849065840244293,
0.23567649722099304,
-0.08226325362920761,
0.7306203842163086,
0.18472257256507874,
1.1250495910644531,
-0.08533699065446854,
1.0175470113754272,
0.05366850271821022,
0.6820049285888672,
-0.5943976640701294,
0.3104468286037445,
-0.5459979772567749,
0.3737128973007202,
-0.015487438067793846,
-0.9675271511077881,
-0.2701334059238434,
0.3612866997718811,
-0.4469023048877716,
-0.04932517930865288,
0.6810935735702515,
0.34576791524887085,
0.1444701999425888,
-0.10680066049098969,
0.40124595165252686,
0.3451867997646332,
0.2252277135848999,
0.39521875977516174,
1.0877020359039307,
-0.07724925875663757,
0.07478143274784088,
-0.0002180356823373586,
-0.2794392704963684,
-0.3017258048057556,
-0.5692366361618042,
-0.35233408212661743,
-0.8342600464820862,
-0.40789851546287537,
-0.14011244475841522,
0.02343107759952545,
0.9902112483978271,
0.5880122780799866,
-0.8601398468017578,
-0.6280911564826965,
-0.07321222871541977,
0.4477745592594147,
-0.44822221994400024,
-0.22259578108787537,
0.08760707080364227,
-0.9253774285316467,
-0.7339569926261902,
0.31035786867141724,
0.7602749466896057,
-0.0291401669383049,
-0.6242302656173706,
0.07252959907054901,
-0.4203323423862457,
0.02185354381799698,
0.8216601610183716,
0.7762480974197388,
-0.34767135977745056,
-0.2168506234884262,
-0.213655024766922,
0.04949052631855011,
0.11812929809093475,
0.8584713935852051,
-0.8597143292427063,
0.4570549726486206,
0.3803863525390625,
0.8582733869552612,
0.5010362863540649,
-0.32938456535339355,
0.18776609003543854,
-0.14560873806476593,
0.04647142067551613,
0.2396239936351776,
0.1965765804052353,
0.5376471877098083,
-0.13998541235923767,
0.43424761295318604,
0.41876107454299927,
-0.7827440500259399,
-0.8490046858787537,
0.4074464440345764,
-0.5783664584159851,
-0.3575780391693115,
1.008044958114624,
-0.2009100615978241,
0.011765573173761368,
-0.49977919459342957,
0.17313919961452484,
0.0002652347320690751,
-0.1366422176361084,
0.7860626578330994,
0.6892548203468323,
-0.07879688590765,
-0.1358156055212021,
-0.8322299718856812,
0.19002605974674225,
0.015315461903810501,
-0.7395554184913635,
0.13011302053928375,
0.3685200810432434,
0.5360409021377563,
0.16448628902435303,
0.5836208462715149,
-0.27936550974845886,
0.1382952481508255,
-0.08526437729597092,
-0.16153539717197418,
0.287874698638916,
-0.6344800591468811,
-0.6884333491325378,
0.394330233335495,
0.3772599995136261,
0.2918411195278168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18286v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18286v2
|
Comparing LLM prompting with Cross-lingual transfer performance on Indigenous and Low-resource Brazilian Languages
| 2024-04-28T19:24:28 | 2024-04-30T10:00:44 |
David Ifeoluwa Adelani, A. Seza Doğruöz, André Coneglian, Atul Kr. Ojha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models are transforming NLP for a variety of tasks. However,
how LLMs perform NLP tasks for low-resource languages (LRLs) is less explored.
In line with the goals of the AmericasNLP workshop, we focus on 12 LRLs from
Brazil, 2 LRLs from Africa and 2 high-resource languages (HRLs) (e.g., English
and Brazilian Portuguese). Our results indicate that the LLMs perform worse for
the part of speech (POS) labeling of LRLs in comparison to HRLs. We explain the
reasons behind this failure and provide an error analysis through examples
observed in our data set.
|
[
-0.3242839574813843,
-0.5799382925033569,
0.28274354338645935,
0.5237070322036743,
-0.1287272572517395,
0.4236105680465698,
-0.5279772281646729,
-0.8575661778450012,
0.12396248430013657,
0.41647446155548096,
-0.5350035429000854,
-0.4040033519268036,
-0.556841254234314,
0.718791663646698,
-0.3816981911659241,
0.9716634750366211,
-0.040090162307024,
-0.2070874273777008,
-0.11699530482292175,
-0.1861816644668579,
-0.22579406201839447,
-0.39359259605407715,
-1.1065983772277832,
-0.5240848064422607,
0.8392745852470398,
0.26742297410964966,
0.8122845888137817,
0.20107434689998627,
0.31556931138038635,
0.20184558629989624,
-0.5140637159347534,
0.17174673080444336,
-0.3980044424533844,
0.036775439977645874,
-0.32353395223617554,
-0.5380017757415771,
-0.3789181411266327,
-0.12326844036579132,
0.6399411559104919,
0.8153324127197266,
0.03572845831513405,
0.1815173625946045,
0.3963737189769745,
0.6215360164642334,
-0.5285972952842712,
0.05699130520224571,
-0.551017701625824,
0.4029536545276642,
-0.1455077975988388,
-0.35570821166038513,
-0.42260420322418213,
-0.3530485928058624,
0.30289068818092346,
-0.29382315278053284,
0.23321004211902618,
0.17275360226631165,
0.6789172887802124,
0.3745371699333191,
-0.19864802062511444,
-0.33058053255081177,
-0.6748026013374329,
0.8738030195236206,
-0.6071608066558838,
0.40655869245529175,
0.47863948345184326,
-0.1151006892323494,
0.19526882469654083,
-0.37282904982566833,
-0.3145434260368347,
-0.31876668334007263,
-0.14781548082828522,
-0.23089784383773804,
-0.4178584814071655,
0.006930828094482422,
0.54393470287323,
0.2018018662929535,
-0.5208691358566284,
0.6705583930015564,
-0.5360442996025085,
-0.2517399489879608,
0.573138952255249,
-0.06312227994203568,
0.13284574449062347,
-0.1718711107969284,
-0.5380448698997498,
0.04707062989473343,
-1.1774816513061523,
0.09891609847545624,
0.24258211255073547,
0.7724466323852539,
-0.35446467995643616,
0.4794880449771881,
-0.0681716576218605,
1.1005046367645264,
-0.3258737325668335,
-0.4047307074069977,
-0.025148559361696243,
-0.35372141003608704,
-0.22160033881664276,
-0.016423147171735764,
0.7959662079811096,
0.29342490434646606,
0.37733593583106995,
-0.1755799502134323,
-0.2902742326259613,
-0.33313435316085815,
-0.162663534283638,
-0.382017582654953,
0.30361202359199524,
-0.04359126836061478,
-0.3456842601299286,
0.21589656174182892,
-0.5078752040863037,
-0.6947545409202576,
-0.4178730249404907,
-0.21044540405273438,
0.21795985102653503,
-0.20309872925281525,
0.1254437118768692,
-0.18714235723018646,
0.05775368586182594,
0.35834646224975586,
0.39361047744750977,
-0.9702634215354919,
0.2575998604297638,
0.4406193494796753,
0.9633256196975708,
-0.6479117274284363,
-0.5390242338180542,
-0.5293533802032471,
-0.23618000745773315,
-0.19576606154441833,
0.8601998686790466,
-0.32196155190467834,
-0.5759023427963257,
0.42806321382522583,
0.07241437584161758,
-0.21167752146720886,
-0.800842821598053,
0.6155475974082947,
-0.46401816606521606,
-0.010676774196326733,
-0.9894434213638306,
0.06855176389217377,
-0.02481178194284439,
0.1497613787651062,
-0.4898821711540222,
1.1792467832565308,
0.3498572111129761,
-0.4443178176879883,
0.3710654079914093,
-0.5536738634109497,
-0.5615586042404175,
-0.033635709434747696,
-0.147854283452034,
0.14115376770496368,
-0.024645786732435226,
0.2542414665222168,
0.47885286808013916,
-0.6112048625946045,
-0.11828482151031494,
-0.014492630027234554,
-0.5053340792655945,
0.35453087091445923,
-0.66937255859375,
1.0357239246368408,
0.2942671775817871,
-0.11099208891391754,
-0.15501433610916138,
-0.5230334997177124,
-0.05453016981482506,
0.10811323672533035,
-0.7987154722213745,
-0.09490439295768738,
-0.247696191072464,
-0.05735598877072334,
0.41592830419540405,
0.16094759106636047,
-0.39733925461769104,
0.44017845392227173,
-0.24007950723171234,
0.48053446412086487,
0.5649321675300598,
-0.3335593640804291,
0.6172459125518799,
-0.24390965700149536,
0.8694911003112793,
-0.37501847743988037,
-0.17869357764720917,
0.0976978987455368,
-0.5763377547264099,
-1.0065950155258179,
0.18729862570762634,
0.3157252073287964,
0.8234080672264099,
-0.9833661913871765,
0.1390048712491989,
-0.2634098529815674,
-0.13357873260974884,
-0.6622894406318665,
0.4172798693180084,
0.44599491357803345,
0.5122328400611877,
0.5628345012664795,
-0.2690301537513733,
-0.4189017117023468,
-0.9880596399307251,
-0.15741673111915588,
-0.13797368109226227,
-0.17557081580162048,
0.2559599280357361,
0.20718969404697418,
0.08089057356119156,
0.6028873920440674,
0.0635879635810852,
-0.4962824881076813,
-0.563829779624939,
0.03517554700374603,
0.18071573972702026,
0.20254887640476227,
0.8113386034965515,
-0.1455320566892624,
-0.6713626384735107,
0.039568398147821426,
-0.33265456557273865,
-0.5530878305435181,
-0.015251737087965012,
0.28304511308670044,
0.7774518132209778,
0.5567670464515686,
-0.28489741683006287,
0.3168388307094574,
0.9544814825057983,
-0.03844377025961876,
0.3515213131904602,
-0.16220615804195404,
0.0999997928738594,
-0.6246634125709534,
0.0719461590051651,
-0.07890331745147705,
-0.08798374235630035,
-0.297986775636673,
-0.29163724184036255,
-0.30518004298210144,
-0.18438439071178436,
-0.805367112159729,
0.679950475692749,
-0.7685104608535767,
-0.6920961737632751,
-0.24599584937095642,
0.2842572331428528,
-0.10023731738328934,
0.5455399751663208,
0.3371559679508209,
0.978959321975708,
0.4048501253128052,
-0.6818093061447144,
0.5061026811599731,
0.07425706833600998,
-0.21752113103866577,
0.728497326374054,
-0.6807351112365723,
0.15201129019260406,
0.2235451489686966,
0.2087414562702179,
-0.6748488545417786,
0.1886799931526184,
0.23380453884601593,
-0.10508047789335251,
0.3695827126502991,
-0.5512693524360657,
-0.3946523666381836,
-0.3839711844921112,
0.001272446010261774,
0.3589530289173126,
0.5556179881095886,
-0.5657727718353271,
0.20437388122081757,
0.1019059345126152,
-0.5514785647392273,
-0.8860088586807251,
-1.0977997779846191,
0.33601462841033936,
-0.25417569279670715,
-0.4882236123085022,
0.28567010164260864,
0.2616339921951294,
-0.24998338520526886,
-0.05127377808094025,
0.21172043681144714,
0.14203551411628723,
0.030754107981920242,
-0.1156359538435936,
-0.012761267833411694,
-0.3635987937450409,
0.02172824554145336,
-0.1386028677225113,
-0.03509638458490372,
0.0328165665268898,
0.014958548359572887,
0.7488545179367065,
-0.21719291806221008,
-0.6060939431190491,
-0.40105050802230835,
0.3207761347293854,
0.023417014628648758,
-0.16230711340904236,
0.7109370231628418,
0.6843892335891724,
0.026301423087716103,
-0.26163268089294434,
-0.4620945453643799,
-0.015544219873845577,
-0.42080312967300415,
0.21128086745738983,
-0.22892671823501587,
-0.8695240616798401,
0.6504875421524048,
0.03584408387541771,
0.22253809869289398,
0.3267925977706909,
0.4989062249660492,
-0.0056260619312524796,
0.5464481711387634,
0.587511420249939,
-0.09294120967388153,
0.5394787192344666,
-0.4363885521888733,
0.05783480778336525,
-0.904983639717102,
-0.097075454890728,
-0.9035535454750061,
-0.5076057314872742,
-0.7198734879493713,
-0.7008256316184998,
0.2657111883163452,
0.00232876930385828,
0.14959584176540375,
0.5011952519416809,
-0.39853113889694214,
0.47952187061309814,
0.7733152508735657,
-0.3221409320831299,
0.4336048662662506,
0.3099086880683899,
0.009926170110702515,
-0.15847891569137573,
-1.2237179279327393,
-0.6204862594604492,
0.8068827390670776,
0.20959419012069702,
0.8719431757926941,
-0.003661043243482709,
0.7162398099899292,
0.33814796805381775,
0.313373863697052,
-0.8618860840797424,
0.6965031027793884,
-0.23238299787044525,
-0.29870980978012085,
-0.2712867259979248,
-0.08567989617586136,
-1.4453164339065552,
0.35587644577026367,
-0.47530293464660645,
-0.7886961698532104,
0.25638410449028015,
0.06929869204759598,
-0.41520291566848755,
0.327741801738739,
-0.47709742188453674,
0.6234225630760193,
-0.4578315019607544,
-0.41406717896461487,
-0.14505405724048615,
-0.5317355394363403,
0.1119600310921669,
0.1731635183095932,
0.2125951200723648,
-0.20184770226478577,
-0.2833985388278961,
0.9590429663658142,
-0.14726467430591583,
0.8439216613769531,
-0.03048061579465866,
-0.5855821371078491,
0.48663952946662903,
0.15952423214912415,
0.506855845451355,
-0.19494231045246124,
-0.24779342114925385,
0.275810182094574,
-0.33644795417785645,
-0.41652849316596985,
-0.2681187689304352,
0.7029494047164917,
-0.5522183775901794,
-0.640264093875885,
-0.4716915488243103,
-0.5368518829345703,
-0.3297184109687805,
-0.11748982965946198,
0.399972140789032,
0.05393320322036743,
-0.06788328289985657,
0.13407620787620544,
0.4527769684791565,
-0.4970225989818573,
0.7881433367729187,
0.6275050044059753,
-0.15222735702991486,
-0.08178477734327316,
0.719488799571991,
0.3251957893371582,
0.5167990326881409,
0.31140318512916565,
-0.01825099065899849,
-0.4280780255794525,
-0.7025375962257385,
-0.5834704637527466,
0.29245781898498535,
-0.6930432915687561,
-0.1100182980298996,
-0.3425208628177643,
-0.0844682976603508,
-0.520521342754364,
-0.35264357924461365,
-0.2726615369319916,
-0.41239112615585327,
-0.23480509221553802,
-0.07443410158157349,
0.2421271651983261,
0.6120495200157166,
-0.3866252601146698,
0.4347684681415558,
-0.9502645134925842,
-0.024215037003159523,
0.4094747006893158,
-0.0675964429974556,
-0.02518606185913086,
-0.8845446109771729,
-0.299353688955307,
-0.026785951107740402,
-0.16191981732845306,
-0.9236767888069153,
0.48961740732192993,
0.17560933530330658,
0.5423570871353149,
0.2875564992427826,
0.14645756781101227,
0.6327258348464966,
-0.2846144139766693,
0.9302321672439575,
-0.03329699486494064,
-0.847222089767456,
0.6428017020225525,
-0.10806737095117569,
0.26541200280189514,
0.2853040397167206,
0.5830917954444885,
-0.7689639329910278,
-0.33937013149261475,
-0.6230881810188293,
-0.8793197870254517,
0.9612900018692017,
-0.06713023036718369,
0.034028150141239166,
0.04994780570268631,
0.06478873640298843,
0.04636739194393158,
0.09565325081348419,
-0.9744246006011963,
-0.305003821849823,
0.4495032727718353,
0.43947815895080566,
-0.20360302925109863,
-0.32525399327278137,
-0.28397059440612793,
0.13420812785625458,
0.5666958689689636,
-0.20737029612064362,
0.24178749322891235,
0.4071672558784485,
-0.19464221596717834,
-0.265668123960495,
0.5727333426475525,
0.6856306195259094,
0.6813958883285522,
0.10492346435785294,
0.166476771235466,
0.7601895332336426,
-0.00837756972759962,
0.13161501288414001,
0.10739168524742126,
-0.30623483657836914,
0.08511173725128174,
0.9726431369781494,
0.9726623892784119,
0.2029438018798828,
-0.6011413335800171,
0.16014128923416138,
0.2087356150150299,
0.13060466945171356,
0.01753501035273075,
0.10573961585760117,
0.11019517481327057,
0.15457318723201752,
0.3935234248638153,
-0.12732186913490295,
-0.15053828060626984,
-0.7117141485214233,
-0.4151855409145355,
0.39374595880508423,
-0.30693405866622925,
-0.3945416212081909,
0.3590601682662964,
0.6767807602882385,
-0.5332915782928467,
0.6123033165931702,
-0.195721834897995,
-0.533783495426178,
0.4918983578681946,
0.4989378750324249,
0.5405242443084717,
-0.2747460603713989,
0.1398811638355255,
0.341468870639801,
0.6341419816017151,
0.16506248712539673,
0.26704999804496765,
-0.3455796539783478,
-0.658505380153656,
-0.8473626375198364,
-0.6612662672996521,
-0.5613539218902588,
0.20043137669563293,
-0.6395172476768494,
0.20903435349464417,
-0.19537419080734253,
-0.2211308777332306,
-0.2911703288555145,
0.01938241347670555,
-0.8323090076446533,
0.05402865633368492,
0.3661090135574341,
0.7673875093460083,
-1.2111461162567139,
0.5960934162139893,
0.7408580183982849,
-0.24867238104343414,
-0.5521606206893921,
-0.32229557633399963,
-0.06884798407554626,
-1.1946337223052979,
0.8917669653892517,
-0.21694980561733246,
-0.0560481920838356,
-0.20171360671520233,
-0.3101152181625366,
-0.8875306844711304,
0.8558595776557922,
0.5573452711105347,
-0.5855494141578674,
-0.10390973091125488,
0.6352660655975342,
0.729863166809082,
-0.10167425870895386,
0.13220888376235962,
0.5499745011329651,
0.5732828378677368,
0.045684922486543655,
-1.5804144144058228,
0.033316005021333694,
0.40657466650009155,
-0.0764097198843956,
-0.06523153930902481,
-0.6946350336074829,
0.786492645740509,
-0.5403735637664795,
-0.3410656154155731,
-0.07109522819519043,
0.7086246013641357,
0.26883429288864136,
0.21572676301002502,
0.4797518849372864,
0.34537991881370544,
0.6532050967216492,
-0.3312233090400696,
0.9889116287231445,
-0.09387415647506714,
0.00842907465994358,
1.005321979522705,
-0.45139279961586,
0.9795028567314148,
0.6446930170059204,
-0.7510287761688232,
0.23421941697597504,
0.6826190948486328,
0.16962455213069916,
-0.03548767790198326,
0.22549311816692352,
-0.21723806858062744,
-0.14293980598449707,
-0.45118844509124756,
-0.569749116897583,
0.484809547662735,
0.5017642378807068,
-0.4071285128593445,
-0.34518858790397644,
-0.016685128211975098,
0.0007152447360567749,
-0.15688879787921906,
-0.4428079128265381,
0.662357747554779,
0.3605983555316925,
-0.9843635559082031,
1.0566396713256836,
-0.11246798932552338,
0.8402358889579773,
-0.48871758580207825,
0.1670624017715454,
-0.3499213755130768,
-0.18248166143894196,
-0.3250664174556732,
-1.024670958518982,
0.5058812499046326,
0.19398240745067596,
0.10739778727293015,
-0.6192945241928101,
0.6303231120109558,
-0.529672384262085,
0.0053984965197741985,
0.552497386932373,
0.8903785943984985,
0.43372246623039246,
0.19344033300876617,
-0.8960059285163879,
0.19964347779750824,
0.13512863218784332,
-0.09864557534456253,
0.48775410652160645,
0.3400808572769165,
-0.1310826987028122,
0.8860347270965576,
0.6275617480278015,
0.47370415925979614,
0.11856689304113388,
0.20875941216945648,
0.3709358274936676,
-0.6793705821037292,
-0.25516924262046814,
-0.6464349031448364,
-0.02044832706451416,
0.14615179598331451,
-0.38397401571273804,
0.7888166308403015,
0.3889951705932617,
0.9371455311775208,
-0.11026796698570251,
0.5571759939193726,
-0.1611362099647522,
0.505287230014801,
-0.8145099878311157,
0.35238930583000183,
-0.4832755923271179,
0.5229023694992065,
0.01592255011200905,
-1.1502329111099243,
0.01980680227279663,
0.5729386806488037,
-0.2438930869102478,
-0.07401221990585327,
0.7207826972007751,
0.6788374185562134,
0.18789713084697723,
-0.3854949474334717,
0.4565865695476532,
0.17984385788440704,
0.039419058710336685,
0.6533282399177551,
1.112765908241272,
-0.006351657677441835,
0.7766909599304199,
-0.47261056303977966,
0.07048916816711426,
-0.24742616713047028,
-1.0351026058197021,
-0.679765522480011,
-0.36323899030685425,
-0.4207196533679962,
-0.5117678642272949,
0.02388395555317402,
0.9429285526275635,
0.4224494397640228,
-0.7488107681274414,
-0.42938223481178284,
0.3352493643760681,
0.45059603452682495,
-0.12565813958644867,
-0.2202494889497757,
0.36013996601104736,
-0.3156990110874176,
-1.1410162448883057,
0.7350897789001465,
0.1901053935289383,
0.2943589389324188,
-0.3756054937839508,
-0.0467408187687397,
-0.1456461101770401,
-0.2549231946468353,
0.6801439523696899,
0.8474724888801575,
-0.9329693913459778,
-0.11709026247262955,
-0.09178608655929565,
-0.16785958409309387,
0.056524794548749924,
0.721610963344574,
-0.8665501475334167,
-0.16504992544651031,
0.639016330242157,
0.3853279650211334,
0.24894645810127258,
-0.29848626255989075,
0.5389720797538757,
-0.9165236353874207,
0.41448774933815,
0.45518985390663147,
0.4782690405845642,
0.5947921872138977,
0.024551745504140854,
0.7113760113716125,
0.19148534536361694,
-0.6747848987579346,
-0.7879787087440491,
0.18388573825359344,
-1.082696795463562,
-0.015113466419279575,
1.5687884092330933,
-0.1930008977651596,
-0.1766340583562851,
-0.1961345076560974,
-0.2618217468261719,
-0.013713414780795574,
-0.4599061608314514,
0.57453852891922,
0.6717514395713806,
-0.42191189527511597,
0.017350727692246437,
-0.46327611804008484,
0.7486262917518616,
0.5517765879631042,
-0.6630482077598572,
0.02743367850780487,
0.390896737575531,
0.19636717438697815,
0.3672788441181183,
0.8582963943481445,
0.2258700430393219,
0.203763946890831,
-0.18529948592185974,
-0.05651507526636124,
0.29871124029159546,
-0.06110118329524994,
-0.5102553367614746,
-0.06064819544553757,
0.2655816674232483,
0.22643737494945526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01587v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01587v1
|
Improve Academic Query Resolution through BERT-based Question Extraction from Images
| 2024-04-28T19:11:08 | 2024-04-28T19:11:08 |
Nidhi Kamal, Saurabh Yadav, Jorawar Singh, Aditi Avasthi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Providing fast and accurate resolution to the student's query is an essential
solution provided by Edtech organizations. This is generally provided with a
chat-bot like interface to enable students to ask their doubts easily. One
preferred format for student queries is images, as it allows students to
capture and post questions without typing complex equations and information.
However, this format also presents difficulties, as images may contain multiple
questions or textual noise that lowers the accuracy of existing single-query
answering solutions. In this paper, we propose a method for extracting
questions from text or images using a BERT-based deep learning model and
compare it to the other rule-based and layout-based methods. Our method aims to
improve the accuracy and efficiency of student query resolution in Edtech
organizations.
|
[
-0.646148145198822,
-1.4064805507659912,
0.6410998106002808,
-0.15955102443695068,
-0.3945746123790741,
0.23087523877620697,
-0.13510386645793915,
-0.5411930680274963,
0.2282380759716034,
0.4682297110557556,
-0.6654890775680542,
-0.3574911057949066,
-0.2696714997291565,
-0.03311571478843689,
-0.4636375308036804,
0.46610552072525024,
0.00007326767808990553,
0.24240320920944214,
-0.7669611573219299,
0.13428613543510437,
-0.4045087695121765,
-0.27580875158309937,
-1.0484825372695923,
-0.011304613202810287,
0.32568782567977905,
0.4969433844089508,
0.2926413416862488,
0.2140388935804367,
0.9660629034042358,
0.32225653529167175,
-0.04450371861457825,
0.329825222492218,
-0.14606864750385284,
0.3454541265964508,
0.21022585034370422,
-0.3210633099079132,
0.09662740677595139,
-0.027566883713006973,
0.5572937726974487,
0.6502231359481812,
-0.02293035015463829,
0.06335188448429108,
0.02984493039548397,
0.6060676574707031,
-0.2825201153755188,
0.02262621745467186,
-0.6796233057975769,
0.11536160856485367,
0.26766452193260193,
-0.17477470636367798,
-0.4676458239555359,
-0.7494258880615234,
0.3259797692298889,
-0.7204045653343201,
0.38188180327415466,
-0.2905288338661194,
1.3358595371246338,
0.14488957822322845,
-0.18175236880779266,
-0.3324117064476013,
-0.4812253415584564,
0.5420745015144348,
-0.6621870994567871,
0.2735222280025482,
0.41194719076156616,
0.5504199266433716,
-0.0848834440112114,
-0.9106783866882324,
-0.5220154523849487,
0.2432655394077301,
-0.16992099583148956,
0.2934252619743347,
0.19477078318595886,
0.016610130667686462,
0.2037540227174759,
0.09183235466480255,
-0.585356593132019,
0.044952280819416046,
-0.7744199633598328,
-0.19287404417991638,
0.4863732159137726,
-0.1064981073141098,
0.259711891412735,
-0.22038967907428741,
-0.33590835332870483,
-0.36542657017707825,
-0.2927033007144928,
0.22386065125465393,
0.07222867012023926,
0.18039219081401825,
0.5648807287216187,
0.19162975251674652,
0.0024610739201307297,
0.7506210207939148,
0.14253561198711395,
0.20179392397403717,
-0.15036523342132568,
0.11711389571428299,
-0.11509686708450317,
-0.033926207572221756,
0.5657065510749817,
0.2759716510772705,
0.174587219953537,
0.15083199739456177,
-0.0542435348033905,
-0.16668559610843658,
0.2943086326122284,
-0.9847856163978577,
-0.35082778334617615,
0.3290947675704956,
-0.634827733039856,
0.048259906470775604,
0.04461389780044556,
-0.9946384429931641,
-0.18012787401676178,
-0.36809366941452026,
0.591529905796051,
-0.7807738780975342,
-0.002792356302961707,
-0.25989946722984314,
-0.14866165816783905,
0.6381187438964844,
0.9363698363304138,
-0.40339112281799316,
0.17171837389469147,
0.44683074951171875,
0.4835149347782135,
-0.07229524850845337,
0.24542267620563507,
-0.18394355475902557,
-0.34830358624458313,
-0.2827049195766449,
0.9551516771316528,
-0.5691418051719666,
-0.4701783359050751,
0.23199427127838135,
-0.0521114319562912,
-0.04971281811594963,
-0.4649735391139984,
0.4589543640613556,
-1.0226051807403564,
0.5706673264503479,
-0.27952128648757935,
-1.0078225135803223,
-0.2958014905452728,
0.5364946126937866,
-0.4169488251209259,
1.1226612329483032,
-0.3143914043903351,
-0.26415887475013733,
0.2448069006204605,
-0.7861782908439636,
-0.32792025804519653,
0.4596402645111084,
-0.4195038080215454,
-0.2841009497642517,
-0.2783665060997009,
0.7907047271728516,
0.5100754499435425,
0.030971825122833252,
0.30624696612358093,
-0.02727329172194004,
-0.5009526014328003,
0.10010979324579239,
-0.22802734375,
0.9036969542503357,
0.31526294350624084,
0.09469297528266907,
-0.19661447405815125,
-0.6377272009849548,
0.5111860632896423,
0.3100641667842865,
-0.46337762475013733,
-0.48893609642982483,
0.03610597923398018,
-0.13203342258930206,
-0.09495342522859573,
0.41343143582344055,
-0.8582395911216736,
0.3234514892101288,
-0.0591697059571743,
0.12595045566558838,
0.7664888501167297,
0.06179308891296387,
0.17440557479858398,
-0.031158512458205223,
0.24772675335407257,
-0.2322482317686081,
0.23862557113170624,
-0.25645601749420166,
-0.7176467776298523,
-0.6420794725418091,
-0.36679795384407043,
0.40676480531692505,
0.3857520818710327,
-0.924981415271759,
0.1675504446029663,
0.03156266734004021,
-0.7016786932945251,
-0.7554858326911926,
-0.018131030723452568,
0.07488150894641876,
0.9918122887611389,
0.5524621605873108,
-0.13425549864768982,
-0.40300899744033813,
-0.7442366480827332,
-0.07561268657445908,
-0.22502195835113525,
-0.08740409463644028,
0.7893563508987427,
0.49153196811676025,
0.18720676004886627,
1.1175832748413086,
-0.8606036901473999,
-0.16475360095500946,
-0.04857008904218674,
0.5122940540313721,
0.3214667737483978,
0.6838032603263855,
0.6206192970275879,
-1.0975661277770996,
-0.735720694065094,
-0.2215476930141449,
-0.8504703044891357,
0.15519969165325165,
-0.2865058481693268,
-0.14577257633209229,
0.3066035807132721,
0.49968019127845764,
-0.5934067964553833,
0.46297505497932434,
-0.18557098507881165,
-0.2373674064874649,
0.4542788863182068,
-0.23698048293590546,
0.40813183784484863,
-0.8180427551269531,
0.004975253716111183,
0.22539646923542023,
-0.15730178356170654,
-0.3491296172142029,
0.16381604969501495,
0.3705272376537323,
-0.45447400212287903,
-0.313995361328125,
0.260814905166626,
-0.24974146485328674,
0.026976171880960464,
-0.027740001678466797,
0.27460211515426636,
0.3547936677932739,
0.44454142451286316,
0.14373797178268433,
0.9397767186164856,
0.5508870482444763,
-0.5978114008903503,
0.44184398651123047,
0.571280837059021,
-0.5254913568496704,
0.54551100730896,
-0.934797465801239,
0.4992310106754303,
-0.4033101797103882,
0.12690283358097076,
-1.452247142791748,
-0.13612745702266693,
-0.2234368771314621,
-0.5307769775390625,
0.42511749267578125,
-0.016491349786520004,
-0.6158237457275391,
-0.5876420140266418,
-0.3301026523113251,
0.23912543058395386,
0.680873453617096,
-0.8180112242698669,
0.4220927655696869,
0.015960857272148132,
-0.42131924629211426,
-0.4777706265449524,
-0.5021599531173706,
0.02538849040865898,
0.15205851197242737,
-0.5990764498710632,
0.4657188653945923,
-0.18594884872436523,
-0.023440923541784286,
0.15915334224700928,
-0.046679191291332245,
-0.6993234753608704,
0.15873774886131287,
-0.07742227613925934,
0.6604827642440796,
-0.29639774560928345,
0.4624302387237549,
0.34913453459739685,
0.5617461800575256,
0.27887699007987976,
0.009601712226867676,
0.5196760892868042,
0.01900336891412735,
-0.37550970911979675,
-0.7008483409881592,
0.7154361605644226,
0.4891076683998108,
-0.33407387137413025,
0.44892629981040955,
0.4133901596069336,
-0.4579229950904846,
-0.03749385476112366,
-0.8463947772979736,
-0.6184085011482239,
-0.4994601309299469,
0.2590491771697998,
-0.15552183985710144,
-0.5581668019294739,
0.49800705909729004,
-0.26626601815223694,
0.23966719210147858,
0.4653702676296234,
0.06788915395736694,
-0.8957269787788391,
0.9097083806991577,
0.5237461924552917,
0.2724362015724182,
0.7175708413124084,
-0.3715577721595764,
-0.11337334662675858,
-0.5309033989906311,
-0.5019510984420776,
-0.8489499092102051,
-0.5014020204544067,
-0.12229475378990173,
0.003476289100944996,
0.3279015123844147,
-0.12554247677326202,
-0.25325170159339905,
0.300995409488678,
-0.8149937391281128,
0.4135652184486389,
0.8547506928443909,
0.6364234089851379,
0.005666838027536869,
0.341217041015625,
-0.2870618402957916,
-0.22986820340156555,
-0.46458926796913147,
-0.43963685631752014,
0.7871537804603577,
0.08388982713222504,
0.7388404607772827,
0.05173274502158165,
0.8090009093284607,
0.239404559135437,
0.13413409888744354,
-0.7516652345657349,
0.6856701970100403,
-0.08090072870254517,
-1.0080089569091797,
-0.590897262096405,
-0.4020867645740509,
-0.832817792892456,
0.2393377423286438,
-0.2728517949581146,
-0.8044540882110596,
0.44809287786483765,
-0.3277040719985962,
-0.44526299834251404,
0.4356938302516937,
-0.7505555748939514,
0.616330087184906,
-0.3836243450641632,
-0.32038891315460205,
0.12062181532382965,
-0.7004277110099792,
-0.11353486031293869,
-0.1592743694782257,
-0.09416419267654419,
-0.0342358760535717,
0.3814762532711029,
1.1061067581176758,
-0.3759968876838684,
0.8426254987716675,
-0.24080178141593933,
0.020790180191397667,
0.5895134806632996,
-0.14210495352745056,
0.31800565123558044,
-0.11079207062721252,
-0.1869627684354782,
-0.14629285037517548,
0.17329667508602142,
-0.3905036449432373,
-0.6299208402633667,
0.4296662509441376,
-0.8825680017471313,
-0.7073091268539429,
-0.015146120451390743,
-0.5992788672447205,
-0.18348148465156555,
0.28391847014427185,
0.11970511078834534,
0.4161469638347626,
-0.1178210899233818,
0.45101815462112427,
0.9269097447395325,
-0.37152764201164246,
0.7462081909179688,
0.37532758712768555,
-0.19296415150165558,
-0.07907263189554214,
0.6265616416931152,
0.4023798108100891,
-0.1236528679728508,
0.2417910248041153,
0.02268975041806698,
-0.6750485301017761,
-0.22440654039382935,
-0.48429766297340393,
0.0306451003998518,
-0.7825810313224792,
-0.5133128762245178,
-0.5444403290748596,
-0.3257783353328705,
-0.6613564491271973,
-0.2432958036661148,
-0.13466045260429382,
-0.42582830786705017,
-0.6568162441253662,
0.07407639920711517,
0.3737668991088867,
0.20132212340831757,
0.23596633970737457,
0.262138694524765,
-0.7743313908576965,
0.2921011745929718,
0.7949173450469971,
0.37137892842292786,
-0.18176591396331787,
-0.6208381652832031,
0.2604671120643616,
0.01631559431552887,
-0.5821605920791626,
-0.98699951171875,
0.25412848591804504,
0.6464312076568604,
0.5618356466293335,
0.5055543184280396,
0.2985211908817291,
0.860276460647583,
-0.27430590987205505,
0.7497588396072388,
0.20092490315437317,
-0.640470027923584,
1.2093812227249146,
-0.03883024677634239,
-0.06899087131023407,
0.727188229560852,
0.552606999874115,
-0.13733763992786407,
-0.08062144368886948,
-0.6307222247123718,
-0.7944968342781067,
0.4701571762561798,
0.008856740780174732,
0.4921903610229492,
0.1392151117324829,
0.7199257612228394,
0.20514315366744995,
-0.032598286867141724,
-0.42810988426208496,
-0.26619163155555725,
-0.19543540477752686,
-0.21206429600715637,
0.44250187277793884,
-0.36884334683418274,
0.052369531244039536,
-0.6574855446815491,
0.5948912501335144,
-0.024338645860552788,
0.26095956563949585,
0.583139955997467,
0.01795008033514023,
-0.030775325372815132,
0.2243994027376175,
0.18323127925395966,
0.5244272947311401,
-0.5802720189094543,
-0.25069138407707214,
-0.02831697091460228,
-0.5303550958633423,
-0.17836356163024902,
0.3034505844116211,
-0.2949075996875763,
0.3838576376438141,
0.05283545330166817,
0.104617178440094,
-0.442062109708786,
-0.6092621088027954,
0.5281071066856384,
-0.38398900628089905,
-0.6014284491539001,
-0.2026691734790802,
-0.08820923417806625,
-0.25886496901512146,
0.21790292859077454,
0.7787775993347168,
-0.21343950927257538,
0.17947261035442352,
-0.5072034001350403,
0.41120895743370056,
0.5218793153762817,
-0.4956030249595642,
0.43978238105773926,
0.5934457182884216,
0.40970379114151,
-0.4033086895942688,
1.1488466262817383,
0.3114469051361084,
-0.3115597367286682,
1.156846046447754,
0.5853913426399231,
0.3752022385597229,
0.0257054902613163,
0.5367753505706787,
0.5004473924636841,
0.15126916766166687,
0.20137885212898254,
0.7351502180099487,
-0.015118959359824657,
-0.701333224773407,
-0.443059504032135,
-0.2539864182472229,
-0.6874675154685974,
0.07254175841808319,
-0.8809720277786255,
0.036524269729852676,
-0.712885320186615,
-0.23881976306438446,
0.24900899827480316,
0.17749032378196716,
-0.5557008385658264,
0.4338846802711487,
-0.004516052547842264,
1.1177256107330322,
-0.30756911635398865,
0.6800652742385864,
1.1746830940246582,
-0.4965185821056366,
-0.6991437673568726,
-0.38900479674339294,
-0.48087945580482483,
-0.624899685382843,
0.789676308631897,
0.3609275221824646,
0.3586170971393585,
0.10534562170505524,
-1.1872320175170898,
-0.48566117882728577,
0.8954493999481201,
0.1702965945005417,
-0.5450302958488464,
0.22269213199615479,
-0.06932740658521652,
0.4512757360935211,
-0.04812774062156677,
0.23429597914218903,
0.20922547578811646,
0.35909485816955566,
0.38092735409736633,
-0.31806543469429016,
-0.17887061834335327,
-0.3973380923271179,
-0.3317113518714905,
0.1721084862947464,
-0.21536949276924133,
0.8354703187942505,
-0.11485224962234497,
-0.18039242923259735,
0.0334935188293457,
0.6951603293418884,
-0.061280857771635056,
0.38308480381965637,
0.36077430844306946,
0.3844735622406006,
1.0612268447875977,
-0.4072580933570862,
0.7756139636039734,
-0.0731930136680603,
0.595976710319519,
0.921566903591156,
-0.028866350650787354,
0.8461605906486511,
0.7446824908256531,
-0.118577741086483,
0.5319024920463562,
0.9840778112411499,
-0.4643029272556305,
0.6008613109588623,
0.03087283857166767,
0.00447004335001111,
-0.5461398363113403,
-0.224300354719162,
-0.5927522778511047,
0.4888818860054016,
0.5814444422721863,
-0.21298058331012726,
-0.1992536038160324,
-0.0294391717761755,
-0.19047479331493378,
0.3150351047515869,
-0.3458820879459381,
1.0552358627319336,
-0.2535449266433716,
-0.6470526456832886,
0.2694988250732422,
-0.3259381651878357,
0.5149378776550293,
-0.17592670023441315,
-0.414693683385849,
-0.5182211399078369,
-0.08445185422897339,
-0.04922832176089287,
-0.9318762421607971,
0.05556216835975647,
-0.03959771990776062,
0.07840908318758011,
-0.12690113484859467,
1.0808454751968384,
-0.275046169757843,
-0.8184318542480469,
-0.11612959951162338,
0.7243155241012573,
0.3212146759033203,
-0.06845973432064056,
-0.9099535346031189,
-0.4024507403373718,
-0.12478276342153549,
-0.010263076052069664,
-0.1720883846282959,
0.43478280305862427,
0.4696371853351593,
0.5525156855583191,
0.7147701382637024,
-0.21315184235572815,
0.14362399280071259,
-0.19098727405071259,
0.9239487648010254,
-0.45460039377212524,
-0.13875874876976013,
-0.5996925234794617,
0.34299343824386597,
-0.601909875869751,
-0.12123832106590271,
0.27127605676651,
0.258613258600235,
0.5764409303665161,
-0.03009653091430664,
0.5304388999938965,
-0.19180510938167572,
0.308610200881958,
-0.16022655367851257,
0.9435625672340393,
-0.9441527128219604,
0.21417252719402313,
-0.38845258951187134,
-0.5853917002677917,
-0.3853203356266022,
0.9111261963844299,
-0.21998265385627747,
-0.10460740327835083,
0.38584718108177185,
0.4957377016544342,
0.0493956059217453,
0.2460320144891739,
0.14891685545444489,
-0.048121124505996704,
0.4686005115509033,
0.1925036609172821,
0.7977648973464966,
-0.5958670377731323,
0.8007993102073669,
-0.5622926354408264,
0.033059943467378616,
-0.3967042565345764,
-0.6365919709205627,
-0.866582989692688,
-0.4908020496368408,
-0.5717997550964355,
-0.11308163404464722,
0.001181934610940516,
0.7237037420272827,
0.6159228682518005,
-0.8791659474372864,
0.21518026292324066,
0.16730426251888275,
0.39258018136024475,
-0.20913653075695038,
-0.263420045375824,
0.8662796020507812,
-0.6449875235557556,
-0.7142661809921265,
0.01589554361999035,
-0.15389107167720795,
0.21099090576171875,
0.2315531224012375,
0.5267003178596497,
-0.6663668751716614,
0.20895430445671082,
0.5186153650283813,
0.15512168407440186,
-0.4125541150569916,
-0.3995501697063446,
0.2749476730823517,
-0.26412835717201233,
0.24455143511295319,
0.3934369385242462,
-0.7607858777046204,
0.4601541757583618,
0.42712149024009705,
1.0427926778793335,
0.44522222876548767,
0.13625018298625946,
0.09034258127212524,
-1.082511305809021,
-0.13407275080680847,
0.3741426467895508,
0.2663743793964386,
0.16956456005573273,
-0.5413447618484497,
0.5299296379089355,
0.19431759417057037,
-0.4538325369358063,
-0.4852684438228607,
-0.14175067842006683,
-1.0638338327407837,
-0.7700157165527344,
0.6529189944267273,
-0.31080859899520874,
-0.13137802481651306,
-0.007349858060479164,
-0.5930096507072449,
0.2512547969818115,
-0.5800911784172058,
1.0508337020874023,
0.5101255178451538,
-0.24015474319458008,
-0.4158121347427368,
-0.5252190232276917,
-0.03420766815543175,
0.519752025604248,
-0.8513955473899841,
-0.5799746513366699,
0.42946910858154297,
-0.0025772310327738523,
0.3315654993057251,
0.26671484112739563,
-0.13667534291744232,
0.306624174118042,
-0.2613373100757599,
0.16896717250347137,
-0.003335947170853615,
-0.1544550508260727,
0.2109137922525406,
0.698463499546051,
-0.3521726727485657,
-0.6596589684486389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18276v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18276v1
|
Bias Neutralization Framework: Measuring Fairness in Large Language Models with Bias Intelligence Quotient (BiQ)
| 2024-04-28T18:47:14 | 2024-04-28T18:47:14 |
Malur Narayan, John Pasmore, Elton Sampaio, Vijay Raghavan, Gabriella Waters
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, D.1; I.2
|
The burgeoning influence of Large Language Models (LLMs) in shaping public
discourse and decision-making underscores the imperative to address inherent
biases within these AI systems. In the wake of AI's expansive integration
across sectors, addressing racial bias in LLMs has never been more critical.
This paper introduces a novel framework called Comprehensive Bias
Neutralization Framework (CBNF) which embodies an innovative approach to
quantifying and mitigating biases within LLMs. Our framework combines the Large
Language Model Bias Index (LLMBI) [Oketunji, A., Anas, M., Saina, D., (2023)]
and Bias removaL with No Demographics (BLIND) [Orgad, H., Belinkov, Y. (2023)]
methodologies to create a new metric called Bias Intelligence Quotient
(BiQ)which detects, measures, and mitigates racial bias in LLMs without
reliance on demographic annotations.
By introducing a new metric called BiQ that enhances LLMBI with additional
fairness metrics, CBNF offers a multi-dimensional metric for bias assessment,
underscoring the necessity of a nuanced approach to fairness in AI [Mehrabi et
al., 2021]. This paper presents a detailed analysis of Latimer AI (a language
model incrementally trained on black history and culture) in comparison to
ChatGPT 3.5, illustrating Latimer AI's efficacy in detecting racial, cultural,
and gender biases through targeted training and refined bias mitigation
strategies [Latimer & Bender, 2023].
|
[
-0.5150816440582275,
-0.8157269358634949,
0.21398770809173584,
0.26824483275413513,
0.0028587549459189177,
0.19869348406791687,
-0.2881442904472351,
-0.40482428669929504,
0.01529934536665678,
0.45275628566741943,
-0.30562588572502136,
-0.2792859673500061,
-0.42478659749031067,
-0.31244391202926636,
-0.29686903953552246,
1.2802331447601318,
0.1681302934885025,
0.644701361656189,
-0.18861286342144012,
-0.3494754135608673,
-0.37733355164527893,
-0.7330406904220581,
-0.7013320922851562,
-0.7990761399269104,
0.37791526317596436,
0.11146356165409088,
0.8282080888748169,
0.5879098176956177,
0.42994871735572815,
0.25135186314582825,
-0.2745121121406555,
-0.285055935382843,
-0.7155291438102722,
-0.22414985299110413,
-0.2563140392303467,
-0.4208748936653137,
-0.454944908618927,
-0.02654917724430561,
0.7847866415977478,
1.1140164136886597,
-0.12830260396003723,
0.2791229784488678,
-0.09107576310634613,
0.6677331328392029,
-0.7704282402992249,
0.013306657783687115,
-0.5511068105697632,
0.23931315541267395,
-0.5617890357971191,
0.19338899850845337,
-0.13105687499046326,
-0.6653919219970703,
-0.18243475258350372,
-0.1347670704126358,
0.22216635942459106,
-0.06484177708625793,
0.6971607804298401,
0.2350037395954132,
-0.7913811802864075,
0.10535190254449844,
-0.8644276261329651,
0.8901880979537964,
-0.8279946446418762,
0.40281325578689575,
0.1645088791847229,
0.33213523030281067,
-0.10858242213726044,
-0.4287565052509308,
-0.8152433633804321,
0.09528547525405884,
0.1506616324186325,
0.11328118294477463,
0.20127767324447632,
0.21664434671401978,
0.4157130718231201,
0.41121867299079895,
-0.26352420449256897,
0.19411605596542358,
-0.5549625754356384,
-0.44423356652259827,
0.5442995429039001,
0.2980955243110657,
0.16537214815616608,
-0.05994676426053047,
-0.2106446623802185,
0.28890150785446167,
-0.7032519578933716,
0.24147307872772217,
0.6808960437774658,
0.01784350350499153,
-0.1423453688621521,
0.5177149772644043,
-0.29981154203414917,
0.4035223424434662,
-0.12802250683307648,
-0.24526330828666687,
0.3894626200199127,
-0.4489723742008209,
-0.14801232516765594,
0.15384942293167114,
0.714464545249939,
0.4735240638256073,
0.43305593729019165,
-0.2620317041873932,
-0.22919757664203644,
0.35241642594337463,
0.06790108978748322,
-0.9233595132827759,
0.01631472259759903,
0.14022992551326752,
-0.6036670207977295,
-0.34383517503738403,
-0.12578581273555756,
-0.9174388647079468,
-0.7589040398597717,
-0.19219239056110382,
-0.09028307348489761,
-0.05556828901171684,
-0.11934328824281693,
-0.10887850821018219,
0.0646793320775032,
0.6687644124031067,
0.16756021976470947,
-0.731016218662262,
0.190552219748497,
0.8775375485420227,
0.5258574485778809,
-0.09638777375221252,
-0.04698963463306427,
-0.46880003809928894,
0.2284258008003235,
-0.3252505958080292,
0.451712429523468,
-0.5087189078330994,
-0.29379352927207947,
0.16367214918136597,
-0.2364865094423294,
0.32391345500946045,
-0.5821152925491333,
0.8023073077201843,
-0.6003232002258301,
0.0833667665719986,
-0.3498794734477997,
-0.35195234417915344,
-0.25152382254600525,
0.2892162501811981,
-0.5776621699333191,
0.762349545955658,
0.07971838116645813,
-0.8493520617485046,
0.48543938994407654,
-0.5534467697143555,
-0.44562989473342896,
-0.05187412351369858,
-0.21495868265628815,
-0.5920573472976685,
-0.025719566270709038,
0.28591644763946533,
-0.10861130058765411,
-0.3533112704753876,
0.6908390522003174,
-0.7856120467185974,
-0.6294363141059875,
0.197874516248703,
-0.6116151809692383,
1.2559369802474976,
0.10860129445791245,
-0.6596795320510864,
0.11416332423686981,
-0.5922865271568298,
-0.050775110721588135,
0.09442992508411407,
-0.3625413775444031,
-0.13305816054344177,
0.047805044800043106,
0.00754495058208704,
0.15825363993644714,
0.190583273768425,
-0.5397946834564209,
-0.34298574924468994,
-0.6787057518959045,
0.3722097873687744,
1.0258418321609497,
-0.39435943961143494,
0.7156438231468201,
-0.2845548093318939,
0.4180530309677124,
-0.0051137893460690975,
0.2942770719528198,
0.08335856348276138,
-0.2786332964897156,
-1.0564438104629517,
-0.4048645794391632,
0.3615182936191559,
0.6513468027114868,
-0.4735255241394043,
0.3960288465023041,
-0.24423328042030334,
-0.129536435008049,
-0.7706151604652405,
0.0625610500574112,
0.33220821619033813,
0.5217230319976807,
0.06637256592512131,
-0.4042642414569855,
-0.4189288318157196,
-0.9723260402679443,
-0.2970530092716217,
-0.17089824378490448,
0.04025658592581749,
0.10836954414844513,
0.40590742230415344,
-0.22179146111011505,
0.9861100316047668,
0.16630378365516663,
-0.1818259060382843,
-0.05855787545442581,
-0.015267589129507542,
0.3058511018753052,
0.2710025906562805,
0.6480873227119446,
-0.5897371172904968,
-0.16703462600708008,
-0.19976650178432465,
-0.6605196595191956,
-0.34541836380958557,
0.18268363177776337,
-0.2657098174095154,
0.1202135905623436,
0.4113076329231262,
-0.3352079689502716,
0.7197831869125366,
0.32933107018470764,
-0.4385316073894501,
0.33615604043006897,
0.342193067073822,
0.210656076669693,
-0.555530846118927,
0.15285688638687134,
-0.2063392549753189,
-0.34573113918304443,
-0.724317729473114,
-0.05085509642958641,
-0.09667070209980011,
0.024839812889695168,
-0.42578259110450745,
0.8243932127952576,
-0.20050640404224396,
-0.27325791120529175,
-0.36245861649513245,
0.36777570843696594,
-0.028370263054966927,
0.4016660153865814,
-0.37627190351486206,
0.5462311506271362,
0.004767806269228458,
-0.4135328531265259,
0.2661735415458679,
0.08566354960203171,
-0.4059984087944031,
0.7730213403701782,
-0.7516034245491028,
0.21940621733665466,
-0.4418267607688904,
0.33063504099845886,
-0.6786552667617798,
0.20665191113948822,
0.5312756299972534,
-0.4004121720790863,
0.009024237282574177,
0.020091194659471512,
-0.3160911500453949,
-0.3532843291759491,
-0.346903532743454,
0.7712339758872986,
0.2441604733467102,
-0.5639705657958984,
0.5220858454704285,
0.6937930583953857,
-0.23048275709152222,
-1.0296040773391724,
-0.7263271808624268,
-0.06052680313587189,
-0.1380370706319809,
-0.6534116268157959,
0.277065247297287,
-0.258026659488678,
-0.5920976400375366,
-0.07499737292528152,
0.027415309101343155,
-0.04065067321062088,
0.32880672812461853,
0.0934164747595787,
0.3214160203933716,
-0.033539317548274994,
-0.18607653677463531,
0.06479529291391373,
0.09865746647119522,
0.2643110156059265,
-0.02791793830692768,
0.6293846964836121,
-0.09828684478998184,
-0.5832306146621704,
-0.1576181799173355,
0.17331381142139435,
0.3223901093006134,
-0.4582267701625824,
0.8619992733001709,
0.9796761274337769,
-0.4971788227558136,
0.15717779099941254,
-0.7630594968795776,
-0.010740475729107857,
-0.40067607164382935,
0.468252956867218,
0.10939010232686996,
-1.1225488185882568,
0.628162682056427,
0.302205890417099,
0.2007855623960495,
0.018178923055529594,
0.8175926208496094,
0.22980442643165588,
1.116007685661316,
0.6099604368209839,
-0.5040724277496338,
0.486939013004303,
0.0058069308288395405,
0.7362076044082642,
-0.7713466882705688,
-0.4076952338218689,
-0.7045046091079712,
-0.4150046706199646,
-0.6096010208129883,
-0.41063159704208374,
0.1471709907054901,
0.22331923246383667,
-0.7154059410095215,
-0.7675003409385681,
-0.2877426743507385,
0.6102023124694824,
0.6236801147460938,
-0.1097019836306572,
0.24253886938095093,
-0.06831654906272888,
-0.057320866733789444,
-0.05095449462532997,
-0.3671552836894989,
-0.6072670221328735,
1.1510013341903687,
0.6327614784240723,
0.366730272769928,
0.18512988090515137,
0.4340023100376129,
0.4653855860233307,
0.6864474415779114,
-0.6152607798576355,
0.4943925738334656,
0.04777296632528305,
-0.9616301655769348,
-0.24769452214241028,
-0.6961687803268433,
-0.6083123683929443,
0.38037601113319397,
-0.3419415056705475,
-0.598006546497345,
0.2624146640300751,
0.054999496787786484,
-0.20770113170146942,
0.44412723183631897,
-0.6250126957893372,
0.7741636037826538,
-0.37551751732826233,
-0.5653340816497803,
-0.2593291997909546,
-0.3600432574748993,
0.6986621022224426,
-0.06735783815383911,
0.5364514589309692,
-0.5151363611221313,
0.00046888942597433925,
0.7091428637504578,
-0.27096495032310486,
0.6998195648193359,
-0.40191328525543213,
0.13321414589881897,
0.07480567693710327,
-0.02929111011326313,
0.23481133580207825,
0.28156229853630066,
-0.3740342855453491,
0.7584479451179504,
-0.2642447352409363,
-0.7067996859550476,
-0.23751410841941833,
0.6357553005218506,
-0.7976482510566711,
-0.5449442267417908,
-0.5900161266326904,
-0.576444149017334,
-0.04355188459157944,
0.3764212727546692,
-0.10152197629213333,
0.19223274290561676,
-0.5722200870513916,
0.02047584019601345,
0.5804846882820129,
-0.574643611907959,
0.42259466648101807,
0.4405246675014496,
-0.3108545243740082,
-0.6139512658119202,
0.5485393404960632,
-0.17051561176776886,
-0.052423980087041855,
0.16819792985916138,
-0.021293632686138153,
-0.23915719985961914,
-0.4943070709705353,
-0.2033427506685257,
0.2921142280101776,
-0.639743983745575,
-0.27110084891319275,
-0.48553434014320374,
-0.3621668517589569,
-0.5761975646018982,
-0.08618458360433578,
-0.04684891551733017,
-0.40677013993263245,
0.02429525926709175,
-0.10574717819690704,
-0.06282919645309448,
0.5929921269416809,
0.007017205469310284,
0.34073615074157715,
-0.2984355092048645,
0.3099372088909149,
0.14314638078212738,
0.46250298619270325,
0.11277225613594055,
-0.6110550761222839,
-0.25846022367477417,
0.23466162383556366,
-0.3729538321495056,
-0.5520465970039368,
0.22443363070487976,
-0.07395469397306442,
0.7005967497825623,
0.41435930132865906,
-0.04651063680648804,
0.49460533261299133,
-0.5646112561225891,
0.757778525352478,
0.3604065179824829,
-1.1803096532821655,
0.15038980543613434,
-0.2619308531284332,
0.349134624004364,
0.4567378759384155,
0.049689460545778275,
-0.6745083332061768,
-0.5269381403923035,
-0.1684449464082718,
-0.8583091497421265,
0.7976908683776855,
-0.054326847195625305,
0.255282998085022,
-0.1187746673822403,
0.3533925712108612,
-0.1320606917142868,
0.5311946868896484,
-1.1994608640670776,
-0.511141300201416,
-0.3009696304798126,
-0.3983139395713806,
0.052920058369636536,
-0.5040748715400696,
-0.2514711022377014,
-0.20280922949314117,
0.676786482334137,
0.052195388823747635,
0.14987586438655853,
-0.1126331239938736,
-0.1252916157245636,
0.010558653622865677,
0.39917510747909546,
0.2220897674560547,
0.8034477829933167,
-0.1311003863811493,
-0.09339818358421326,
0.21534936130046844,
-0.4097195863723755,
0.10427770018577576,
0.30023494362831116,
-0.7285427451133728,
-0.22277747094631195,
0.2633635103702545,
0.7033784985542297,
-0.25077134370803833,
-0.5698238611221313,
0.6177655458450317,
-0.04150398448109627,
0.08571171015501022,
-0.423173725605011,
-0.09403479099273682,
-0.059808921068906784,
0.3759288489818573,
0.020154373720288277,
-0.02916700579226017,
0.2437572330236435,
-0.46272754669189453,
-0.08997584134340286,
0.7121800184249878,
-0.5542404055595398,
-0.05824660882353783,
0.7228631973266602,
0.6154596209526062,
-0.10123244673013687,
0.7606176733970642,
-0.29188549518585205,
-0.6430327892303467,
0.4888070523738861,
0.23985932767391205,
0.5919266939163208,
-0.32764551043510437,
0.18197600543498993,
0.2424570471048355,
0.6328539848327637,
0.20193105936050415,
0.048149436712265015,
0.15420213341712952,
-1.0771089792251587,
-0.3720947504043579,
-0.682030200958252,
-0.13506224751472473,
0.1508055329322815,
-0.39045119285583496,
0.2657618522644043,
-0.815877377986908,
-0.39401328563690186,
-0.18707042932510376,
0.1336723417043686,
-0.8058829307556152,
0.058584507554769516,
0.3951120972633362,
0.6701107025146484,
-0.5762761235237122,
0.4590362012386322,
0.5032198429107666,
-0.3816079795360565,
-0.2578234374523163,
0.04735618084669113,
0.2114909142255783,
-0.6412237882614136,
0.48204305768013,
0.12776806950569153,
0.0764126107096672,
-0.4552493393421173,
-0.42669644951820374,
-0.510749101638794,
0.871898889541626,
0.763452410697937,
-0.5557425618171692,
0.18168701231479645,
0.42725592851638794,
0.47482478618621826,
-0.22471308708190918,
0.7375397086143494,
0.8642139434814453,
0.5127080678939819,
-0.36020180583000183,
-0.8482435941696167,
-0.11851200461387634,
-0.14147362112998962,
0.25002366304397583,
0.23670868575572968,
-0.8828209638595581,
0.6332749724388123,
-0.20943643152713776,
-0.12111413478851318,
-0.0957031324505806,
0.7921794056892395,
0.21418990194797516,
0.6833041906356812,
0.4811038374900818,
0.5043038129806519,
0.9198060035705566,
-0.3919186294078827,
0.7325181365013123,
-0.14257767796516418,
0.12712633609771729,
1.0566928386688232,
-0.5818073749542236,
0.18304060399532318,
0.33856451511383057,
-0.17399875819683075,
0.4019082188606262,
0.48661690950393677,
0.12096020579338074,
0.264646053314209,
0.6109836101531982,
-0.40240952372550964,
-0.033192962408065796,
-0.5909512042999268,
-0.3079818785190582,
0.38827624917030334,
0.16146732866764069,
-0.017058612778782845,
-0.0324321985244751,
0.008625364862382412,
0.4014630615711212,
0.4116840362548828,
-0.5777815580368042,
0.4544285833835602,
0.04205471649765968,
-0.5137702226638794,
0.24355871975421906,
0.3333466053009033,
0.8182520866394043,
-0.426937460899353,
0.1323409527540207,
-0.6260020732879639,
0.30594533681869507,
-0.1275579184293747,
-0.6333162188529968,
0.20885346829891205,
0.055671922862529755,
-0.5140746831893921,
0.07082128524780273,
0.4919012188911438,
-0.4291572868824005,
-0.6234970092773438,
0.6559057831764221,
0.2858617305755615,
-0.16615289449691772,
0.34962642192840576,
-0.9043106436729431,
0.3766340911388397,
0.14141130447387695,
0.1140938475728035,
0.14798679947853088,
0.5309639573097229,
-0.1938440203666687,
0.7037943601608276,
0.45383936166763306,
0.341033399105072,
0.10572797060012817,
0.5484585165977478,
0.6334925293922424,
-0.5821452140808105,
-0.34879085421562195,
-0.612065315246582,
0.38139423727989197,
-0.27972981333732605,
-0.005463749635964632,
0.4851640462875366,
0.5063134431838989,
1.0825432538986206,
0.4618842303752899,
0.8788366913795471,
0.061431415379047394,
0.6571056842803955,
-0.36310654878616333,
0.6285637021064758,
-0.37425723671913147,
0.503674328327179,
-0.2836942672729492,
-1.1021441221237183,
-0.19413083791732788,
0.5255900621414185,
-0.4214518070220947,
0.5726023316383362,
0.33134859800338745,
0.9267979860305786,
0.1259137988090515,
0.05184464156627655,
0.14669910073280334,
0.40085968375205994,
0.46102118492126465,
0.40275663137435913,
0.9012136459350586,
-0.2388060986995697,
0.705416202545166,
-0.08878366649150848,
-0.39236733317375183,
-0.05695419758558273,
-0.7259147763252258,
-1.1187219619750977,
0.09452837705612183,
-0.15402136743068695,
-0.4476556181907654,
0.28676560521125793,
0.7604919672012329,
0.5367172956466675,
-0.9279336929321289,
-0.41880303621292114,
0.47752290964126587,
0.507829487323761,
0.07432544231414795,
-0.26423001289367676,
0.07586727291345596,
-0.11863834410905838,
-0.7769801616668701,
-0.12759646773338318,
0.266834557056427,
-0.3042239844799042,
-0.3915230333805084,
-0.27206411957740784,
-0.0597967728972435,
0.21326927840709686,
0.5235690474510193,
0.1367211788892746,
-0.656710147857666,
-0.2502630054950714,
-0.3584175407886505,
-0.08630447089672089,
-0.10361174494028091,
0.8794747591018677,
-0.6794732213020325,
0.4004085958003998,
0.3686580955982208,
0.734315037727356,
0.2774676978588104,
-0.19046476483345032,
0.6556642055511475,
-0.4138067066669464,
0.4019405245780945,
0.341548353433609,
0.41278544068336487,
0.6045642495155334,
-0.25750046968460083,
0.4727224111557007,
0.2379487305879593,
-0.6972139477729797,
-0.9721279144287109,
0.3145633041858673,
-0.5424975156784058,
-0.03610435128211975,
0.8882214426994324,
0.2127356231212616,
-0.14691218733787537,
-0.2917344272136688,
0.02045905776321888,
0.3213178813457489,
-0.49434182047843933,
0.9792179465293884,
0.6596231460571289,
0.33649298548698425,
-0.022969651967287064,
-0.5512222051620483,
0.3235367238521576,
0.5726265907287598,
-0.6637905240058899,
-0.020259786397218704,
0.654148280620575,
0.11398959159851074,
-0.09902433305978775,
1.0041139125823975,
-0.44609159231185913,
0.23537996411323547,
-0.5490943193435669,
0.35311347246170044,
0.16227348148822784,
-0.08078205585479736,
-0.4566194713115692,
-0.18825389444828033,
-0.010280981659889221,
0.30282995104789734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18271v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18271v1
|
Parameter-Efficient Tuning Large Language Models for Graph Representation Learning
| 2024-04-28T18:36:59 | 2024-04-28T18:36:59 |
Qi Zhu, Da Zheng, Xiang Song, Shichang Zhang, Bowen Jin, Yizhou Sun, George Karypis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Text-rich graphs, which exhibit rich textual information on nodes and edges,
are prevalent across a wide range of real-world business applications. Large
Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable abilities in understanding
text, which also introduced the potential for more expressive modeling in
text-rich graphs. Despite these capabilities, efficiently applying LLMs to
representation learning on graphs presents significant challenges. Recently,
parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods for LLMs have enabled efficient new
task generalization with minimal time and memory consumption. Inspired by this,
we introduce Graph-aware Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning - GPEFT, a novel
approach for efficient graph representation learning with LLMs on text-rich
graphs. Specifically, we utilize a graph neural network (GNN) to encode
structural information from neighboring nodes into a graph prompt. This prompt
is then inserted at the beginning of the text sequence. To improve the quality
of graph prompts, we pre-trained the GNN to assist the frozen LLM in predicting
the next token in the node text. Compared with existing joint GNN and LMs, our
method directly generate the node embeddings from large language models with an
affordable fine-tuning cost. We validate our approach through comprehensive
experiments conducted on 8 different text-rich graphs, observing an average
improvement of 2% in hit@1 and Mean Reciprocal Rank (MRR) in link prediction
evaluations. Our results demonstrate the efficacy and efficiency of our model,
showing that it can be smoothly integrated with various large language models,
including OPT, LLaMA and Falcon.
|
[
-0.2818901240825653,
-0.7038455605506897,
0.48441821336746216,
-0.18719302117824554,
-0.6398848295211792,
0.19627825915813446,
-0.5507321357727051,
-0.4372982382774353,
0.30563461780548096,
0.5024294853210449,
-0.42820319533348083,
-0.7830467820167542,
-0.7676165103912354,
0.03136853128671646,
0.1009071096777916,
0.9504553079605103,
0.06343521922826767,
-0.00808293092995882,
0.08293353021144867,
-0.08958606421947479,
-0.26072147488594055,
-0.23522911965847015,
-0.9347047209739685,
-0.22575032711029053,
0.7498515248298645,
0.18660137057304382,
0.7811669111251831,
0.9413102269172668,
-0.03211327642202377,
0.3636504113674164,
-0.233018696308136,
0.7238426804542542,
-0.8106454014778137,
0.0178080927580595,
-0.18590088188648224,
-0.047266457229852676,
-0.4055230915546417,
-0.08981534093618393,
0.8457486033439636,
1.011590600013733,
0.12472459673881531,
0.016009889543056488,
0.30948323011398315,
0.3535817861557007,
-0.20860883593559265,
0.6533817648887634,
-1.0145596265792847,
-0.27535560727119446,
-0.015506991185247898,
-0.11685158312320709,
-0.5641350746154785,
-0.23323185741901398,
-0.09506847709417343,
-0.6917141079902649,
0.12604650855064392,
0.23073828220367432,
1.003271460533142,
0.16411107778549194,
-0.26643094420433044,
-0.060954101383686066,
-0.23047280311584473,
0.5528560280799866,
-0.5132174491882324,
0.5809471011161804,
0.22927606105804443,
0.14677368104457855,
-0.23111647367477417,
-0.8785545825958252,
-0.23403508961200714,
-0.2573739290237427,
-0.029350867494940758,
-0.2347579449415207,
-0.09272442013025284,
0.3651013970375061,
0.2193506956100464,
0.08435627073049545,
-0.44027650356292725,
0.4987941384315491,
0.04253692924976349,
-0.34710246324539185,
0.32532066106796265,
0.1096028983592987,
0.21009883284568787,
-0.10302882641553879,
0.0944569781422615,
-0.09567732363939285,
-0.6015607714653015,
-0.17220814526081085,
0.5487408638000488,
0.8519211411476135,
0.23255005478858948,
0.40856102108955383,
-0.32921090722084045,
0.9764350056648254,
0.07068397104740143,
0.2126139998435974,
0.0874212458729744,
-0.23748882114887238,
-0.23025095462799072,
-0.07162997126579285,
0.7550351619720459,
0.17289870977401733,
0.619644045829773,
-0.41600149869918823,
-0.16166119277477264,
-0.04986482858657837,
-0.03505093604326248,
-1.091760516166687,
-0.40554770827293396,
-0.16920463740825653,
-0.29427358508110046,
-0.0043023135513067245,
-0.17301911115646362,
-0.4950752854347229,
-0.4321991205215454,
-0.3036353588104248,
0.10883571952581406,
-0.39966851472854614,
-0.009619779884815216,
0.2792084813117981,
0.015139807015657425,
-0.20533625781536102,
0.5033952593803406,
-0.940695583820343,
0.0666026696562767,
0.6689103245735168,
0.7719393372535706,
0.12273510545492172,
-0.3090742230415344,
-1.0043762922286987,
0.2562893033027649,
-0.38831424713134766,
0.4799797236919403,
-0.9003781080245972,
-0.031882572919130325,
-0.04783296585083008,
0.20851825177669525,
-0.2346629500389099,
-0.4648761749267578,
0.2783161401748657,
-0.6706600785255432,
-0.19393561780452728,
-0.0661904439330101,
-0.7002403736114502,
-0.17218132317066193,
0.21779227256774902,
-0.7319123148918152,
0.8151682019233704,
0.2025635689496994,
-0.6952419281005859,
0.4122823178768158,
-0.2505987882614136,
-0.456454873085022,
0.1702975630760193,
-0.14647692441940308,
-0.45964643359184265,
-0.09079550951719284,
0.5799430012702942,
0.8447309732437134,
-0.24332918226718903,
0.19934402406215668,
-0.3747538924217224,
-0.4176802933216095,
-0.12314806133508682,
-0.3463682532310486,
0.4041270315647125,
-0.09525166451931,
-0.08207795023918152,
0.31658658385276794,
-0.6226274967193604,
0.14930008351802826,
0.27600908279418945,
-0.331513911485672,
-0.319070965051651,
-0.05309542268514633,
-0.17984400689601898,
-0.08614213764667511,
0.38241204619407654,
-0.36403122544288635,
0.30884554982185364,
-0.6762002110481262,
0.6682209372520447,
0.8647617697715759,
0.03225455433130264,
0.3547411859035492,
0.1404467076063156,
0.28181448578834534,
-0.33175110816955566,
-0.12181942909955978,
-0.31144940853118896,
-0.6356233358383179,
-0.3664351999759674,
-0.3115806579589844,
0.5141493082046509,
0.1758907437324524,
-0.7749427556991577,
0.40158313512802124,
-0.37303584814071655,
-0.37227925658226013,
-0.37492090463638306,
0.3868751525878906,
0.2829984724521637,
0.7248406410217285,
0.3919767439365387,
-0.060263022780418396,
-0.16497743129730225,
-0.4492906630039215,
-0.37982746958732605,
-0.14767052233219147,
0.07576952874660492,
0.7604193091392517,
0.27783918380737305,
-0.3386091887950897,
0.6205369830131531,
-0.6541107296943665,
-0.07598107308149338,
-0.42786088585853577,
0.055450715124607086,
0.36776965856552124,
0.33400699496269226,
0.48478955030441284,
-0.57176673412323,
-0.6608505845069885,
0.21983720362186432,
-0.2508704364299774,
0.08314704895019531,
0.02879406325519085,
-0.08903864771127701,
0.06854435056447983,
0.5715621709823608,
-0.5591618418693542,
0.1061905100941658,
0.6485665440559387,
-0.36399632692337036,
0.40485644340515137,
-0.3514494299888611,
-0.06749498099088669,
-0.9891032576560974,
-0.06598641723394394,
0.12112977355718613,
-0.5497932434082031,
-0.29030168056488037,
-0.09316921979188919,
0.08975336700677872,
-0.40844807028770447,
-0.09387308359146118,
0.7371734380722046,
-0.6160427927970886,
0.06812601536512375,
-0.0639171376824379,
0.3993659019470215,
0.039020784199237823,
0.6399621367454529,
-0.23739558458328247,
0.7025790810585022,
0.6476156711578369,
-0.5795512199401855,
0.30721569061279297,
0.08496788144111633,
-0.2594393491744995,
0.045402225106954575,
-0.7945793867111206,
0.2263624370098114,
-0.2581862807273865,
0.26621386408805847,
-1.0809625387191772,
-0.29170501232147217,
0.39122840762138367,
-0.34664449095726013,
0.6669030785560608,
-0.5686014890670776,
-0.6852375268936157,
-0.32405534386634827,
-0.08185554295778275,
0.29287266731262207,
0.2660125494003296,
-0.7724218964576721,
0.5459261536598206,
0.22523479163646698,
-0.22553814947605133,
-0.39132261276245117,
-0.3355850875377655,
0.20614583790302277,
0.016680745407938957,
-0.6511461734771729,
0.4824771583080292,
0.03511859476566315,
0.4046255648136139,
0.029329104349017143,
0.014896655455231667,
0.13933153450489044,
0.1891077756881714,
-0.08251000195741653,
-0.038727905601263046,
-0.0628204345703125,
0.2677176892757416,
0.34258833527565,
-0.4551706910133362,
-0.27715736627578735,
-0.657212495803833,
0.8802419304847717,
-0.0810621976852417,
-0.3454969823360443,
-0.3735574185848236,
0.0941193699836731,
0.36123064160346985,
-0.5242403149604797,
0.7662729620933533,
0.6461642384529114,
-0.3726595640182495,
-0.36595022678375244,
-0.14315403997898102,
-0.19952288269996643,
-0.5039493441581726,
0.824863612651825,
-0.24359548091888428,
-1.2327688932418823,
0.6013450622558594,
-0.5332986116409302,
-0.34347715973854065,
0.3514360785484314,
0.30630072951316833,
0.2090032696723938,
1.363179326057434,
0.4744115173816681,
-0.4055598974227905,
0.6542174816131592,
-0.4224412441253662,
0.17074893414974213,
-0.7192891240119934,
-0.12651312351226807,
-0.5913036465644836,
-0.23275913298130035,
-0.6725435853004456,
-0.6371031403541565,
0.1204412654042244,
0.2656007707118988,
-0.47631117701530457,
0.2639162540435791,
-0.5161643624305725,
0.5950698852539062,
0.17912602424621582,
0.28133538365364075,
0.10866378992795944,
0.1703718602657318,
-0.29963329434394836,
0.029238540679216385,
-0.7352723479270935,
-0.30693596601486206,
0.8199766278266907,
0.4283665716648102,
0.7657827138900757,
-0.21304164826869965,
0.6766931414604187,
0.02847808040678501,
0.08384697884321213,
-0.8379383087158203,
0.6209038496017456,
-0.4768085181713104,
0.15678369998931885,
-0.549168586730957,
-0.7502799034118652,
-1.0170142650604248,
0.08122806251049042,
-0.17131407558918,
-0.9999693632125854,
-0.1499059647321701,
0.363492876291275,
0.01778261549770832,
0.38204869627952576,
-0.5412279367446899,
1.0011987686157227,
-0.15180741250514984,
-0.29803553223609924,
-0.2297673523426056,
-0.36602380871772766,
-0.2225649356842041,
0.14327451586723328,
-0.16067133843898773,
-0.2813510298728943,
-0.11217892169952393,
0.5178275108337402,
-0.3598986864089966,
1.0078812837600708,
-0.46803632378578186,
-0.021942878141999245,
0.09107448160648346,
-0.056930769234895706,
1.1939109563827515,
0.30585357546806335,
-0.3502880036830902,
0.0977100282907486,
-0.7344862222671509,
-0.3323614299297333,
-0.7775129675865173,
0.7621683478355408,
-0.6371639370918274,
-0.3629389703273773,
0.14917361736297607,
-0.44112348556518555,
-0.3871471881866455,
0.4487448036670685,
0.14431244134902954,
0.6924790143966675,
-0.17640024423599243,
0.09693020582199097,
0.749380350112915,
-0.23080922663211823,
0.2836466133594513,
0.021830620244145393,
-0.22078637778759003,
-0.6114473938941956,
1.0557976961135864,
0.1926337033510208,
0.13153932988643646,
0.38267436623573303,
0.23438754677772522,
-0.46513113379478455,
-0.8078741431236267,
-0.7842146754264832,
0.5089794397354126,
-0.7349624037742615,
-0.3799273669719696,
-0.7580658197402954,
-0.09506012499332428,
-0.26536616683006287,
-0.11566628515720367,
-0.3269372284412384,
-0.21151749789714813,
-0.6790295243263245,
-0.15830308198928833,
0.5612568855285645,
0.5370638370513916,
0.41886401176452637,
0.396541029214859,
-0.6142385601997375,
0.14756041765213013,
0.32905909419059753,
0.7511568665504456,
0.13275116682052612,
-0.3646166920661926,
-0.4864586293697357,
0.06547006219625473,
0.1358618140220642,
-0.7198187112808228,
0.23116253316402435,
0.5170851945877075,
0.6815189719200134,
0.38640233874320984,
-0.12785865366458893,
0.675424337387085,
-0.5824952125549316,
0.5007818937301636,
0.14162960648536682,
-0.9432389736175537,
0.3813343048095703,
-0.5473916530609131,
0.11571335047483444,
0.5146440267562866,
0.4780544936656952,
-0.3288489580154419,
-0.33719533681869507,
-0.27301934361457825,
-0.9564015865325928,
0.5098783373832703,
-0.20350980758666992,
0.5410071611404419,
-0.1839890033006668,
0.6978337168693542,
-0.01735835336148739,
0.18769855797290802,
-0.5650901794433594,
-0.08896789699792862,
-0.28227582573890686,
-0.3092847466468811,
-0.2509656846523285,
-0.16483893990516663,
0.1621273159980774,
-0.5276724696159363,
0.5078287124633789,
-0.8784768581390381,
0.07290150225162506,
-0.21508361399173737,
-0.1192479059100151,
-0.011255878023803234,
-0.02894057147204876,
0.1672508418560028,
0.6871051788330078,
0.009268317371606827,
0.13989147543907166,
0.22824521362781525,
-0.18541371822357178,
-0.16109517216682434,
0.43536731600761414,
-0.006275529973208904,
-0.010188017971813679,
0.25845304131507874,
1.1512242555618286,
0.3180636167526245,
-0.4965265095233917,
0.4345797300338745,
-0.04984012618660927,
0.028887862339615822,
0.4361252188682556,
0.10345510393381119,
0.31189966201782227,
0.18764536082744598,
0.10697413235902786,
-0.2008356750011444,
-0.052109867334365845,
-0.36799970269203186,
0.1066071167588234,
0.6168428659439087,
-0.4492967128753662,
-0.14819826185703278,
0.6919539570808411,
0.07827462255954742,
-0.1957128494977951,
0.7626386284828186,
-0.46188652515411377,
-0.6163744926452637,
0.4788017272949219,
0.8194184303283691,
0.7724582552909851,
-0.0793798416852951,
0.5258846282958984,
0.4001830816268921,
0.07933315634727478,
0.1396123766899109,
0.24556897580623627,
0.08909903466701508,
-0.6808719635009766,
-0.6197206377983093,
-0.6828872561454773,
-0.29445138573646545,
-0.23177316784858704,
-0.19185993075370789,
0.19131651520729065,
-0.5912913680076599,
-0.17685812711715698,
-0.07781627774238586,
0.19298090040683746,
-0.6404907703399658,
0.1333252340555191,
-0.09749011695384979,
0.8123152256011963,
-0.7494047284126282,
0.7965759634971619,
0.6971682906150818,
-0.18381504714488983,
-1.043319821357727,
0.0009979595197364688,
-0.5501493215560913,
-0.8986643552780151,
0.37907135486602783,
0.31240877509117126,
-0.1664915680885315,
0.4024636149406433,
-0.6466271877288818,
-0.8695643544197083,
0.9988832473754883,
0.9144970178604126,
-0.6719962358474731,
0.055031850934028625,
0.09866778552532196,
0.5324156284332275,
-0.5144644975662231,
0.1613157093524933,
0.207112118601799,
0.4513499438762665,
0.12572342157363892,
-0.6251230239868164,
0.2899613678455353,
-0.10551813244819641,
0.3169911801815033,
0.44188156723976135,
-0.7093481421470642,
0.8233652710914612,
-0.2362692803144455,
-0.16435132920742035,
-0.0666661411523819,
0.7349022626876831,
0.18962398171424866,
0.06646409630775452,
0.45446181297302246,
0.3467608690261841,
1.3394910097122192,
-0.0728251114487648,
1.1119658946990967,
-0.5750707983970642,
0.3247637450695038,
1.0232805013656616,
-0.03844984993338585,
0.537578821182251,
0.09262202680110931,
0.2636042535305023,
0.5125995874404907,
0.7880846261978149,
0.06152665242552757,
0.4036411643028259,
0.40778759121894836,
0.1464286595582962,
-0.4945673942565918,
-0.25534406304359436,
-0.2706882953643799,
0.39091062545776367,
0.38277149200439453,
-0.49606025218963623,
-0.2539016902446747,
-0.17873886227607727,
0.16456103324890137,
0.03730766475200653,
-0.5633919835090637,
0.6573812365531921,
-0.01782996766269207,
-0.2729892432689667,
0.6533926129341125,
0.1740642935037613,
0.330392062664032,
-0.6427867412567139,
-0.12170381098985672,
-0.01782691478729248,
-0.05448609218001366,
-0.042564667761325836,
-0.5428205728530884,
-0.06469840556383133,
-0.1644236296415329,
-0.20076723396778107,
-0.13656355440616608,
0.8512127995491028,
-0.5608058571815491,
-0.419577956199646,
0.6021382212638855,
0.2885211706161499,
-0.10257667303085327,
-0.27389800548553467,
-0.6968607306480408,
0.17917796969413757,
-0.06662154942750931,
-0.15445347130298615,
0.3615545630455017,
0.7040307521820068,
0.013054118491709232,
0.5511528849601746,
0.4942641854286194,
0.2296416014432907,
-0.11675386130809784,
0.3881639838218689,
1.2739143371582031,
-0.519848644733429,
-0.6454464793205261,
-0.759543240070343,
0.32815393805503845,
-0.1855490654706955,
-0.24692150950431824,
0.5702094435691833,
0.45928025245666504,
0.7126247882843018,
0.24093055725097656,
0.516527533531189,
0.4348818361759186,
0.09638446569442749,
-0.7742026448249817,
0.7966946959495544,
-0.5254056453704834,
0.1054874137043953,
-0.519467830657959,
-1.0560582876205444,
-0.3604922890663147,
0.46398043632507324,
-0.3208298981189728,
0.4070776700973511,
0.29698774218559265,
0.7940706610679626,
-0.150655597448349,
-0.16581003367900848,
0.14921846985816956,
0.22172805666923523,
0.3760313093662262,
0.381881445646286,
0.4191875755786896,
-0.17019495368003845,
0.5511612296104431,
0.16925522685050964,
-0.21027082204818726,
-0.20064927637577057,
-1.0356793403625488,
-0.9977701902389526,
-0.4247331917285919,
-0.38050612807273865,
-0.3597518503665924,
0.2021208107471466,
0.9448509216308594,
0.8040035963058472,
-0.5301317572593689,
0.14056356251239777,
-0.1507025957107544,
0.33123648166656494,
-0.11350981891155243,
-0.16121865808963776,
0.6070200800895691,
-0.49714645743370056,
-0.7224814295768738,
0.4780212640762329,
0.3495786190032959,
-0.0592033676803112,
-0.12247421592473984,
-0.3371531367301941,
0.06000637263059616,
0.03869112581014633,
0.5035094022750854,
0.1110309287905693,
-0.3940408229827881,
-0.6304245591163635,
-0.021336041390895844,
0.010246163234114647,
0.10533317178487778,
0.6134644746780396,
-0.6573224663734436,
0.48368722200393677,
0.4425835609436035,
0.9440852403640747,
0.6572926640510559,
0.016615089029073715,
0.3644848167896271,
-0.8798527717590332,
0.019695373252034187,
0.25994256138801575,
0.5158032178878784,
0.4521411955356598,
-0.4832761883735657,
0.2470894455909729,
0.2067524790763855,
-0.44806310534477234,
-0.6031321287155151,
0.4107614755630493,
-0.878522515296936,
-0.2808449864387512,
0.9279554486274719,
-0.19376550614833832,
-0.20599579811096191,
0.09262149035930634,
-0.24792112410068512,
0.4399479031562805,
-0.5058467388153076,
0.4519185721874237,
0.20356684923171997,
-0.031462326645851135,
-0.18386545777320862,
-0.05052018165588379,
0.41331860423088074,
0.048274971544742584,
-0.5155004858970642,
0.3353605568408966,
0.437158465385437,
0.1291925013065338,
-0.1477397084236145,
0.5933235287666321,
0.23343044519424438,
-0.1019180491566658,
-0.1479186862707138,
-0.35567474365234375,
-0.4960421919822693,
-0.6167343854904175,
-0.15537799894809723,
0.2215091586112976,
0.2865060567855835,
0.034022849053144455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.15784v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.15784v1
|
CLARINET: Augmenting Language Models to Ask Clarification Questions for Retrieval
| 2024-04-28T18:21:31 | 2024-04-28T18:21:31 |
Yizhou Chi, Jessy Lin, Kevin Lin, Dan Klein
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Users often make ambiguous requests that require clarification. We study the
problem of asking clarification questions in an information retrieval setting,
where systems often face ambiguous search queries and it is challenging to turn
the uncertainty in the retrieval model into a natural language question. We
present CLARINET, a system that asks informative clarification questions by
choosing questions whose answers would maximize certainty in the correct
candidate. Our approach works by augmenting a large language model (LLM) to
condition on a retrieval distribution, finetuning end-to-end to generate the
question that would have maximized the rank of the true candidate at each turn.
When evaluated on a real-world retrieval dataset of users searching for books,
our system outperforms traditional heuristics such as information gain on
retrieval success by 17% and vanilla-prompted LLMs by 39% relative.
|
[
-0.5269851088523865,
-1.1355284452438354,
0.7649456858634949,
0.2661854922771454,
-0.4492303133010864,
-0.23087164759635925,
-0.3880077302455902,
-0.5983876585960388,
-0.02355668693780899,
0.7551215291023254,
-0.7447587847709656,
-0.422685444355011,
-0.38918423652648926,
0.04579496756196022,
-0.4428378939628601,
0.7773825526237488,
0.28487974405288696,
-0.0589354932308197,
-0.2839862108230591,
-0.18341004848480225,
-0.5643448829650879,
-0.39646977186203003,
-0.6552976369857788,
-0.2730786204338074,
0.41481390595436096,
0.4795515835285187,
0.8662611246109009,
0.5379371047019958,
0.6003764271736145,
0.25675666332244873,
-0.2911367118358612,
0.1028284952044487,
-0.46549782156944275,
0.5857025980949402,
-0.4093250334262848,
-0.786413311958313,
0.14166657626628876,
-0.3901662230491638,
0.49448445439338684,
1.1844277381896973,
-0.187246635556221,
0.4340497851371765,
-0.3171357214450836,
0.6192376613616943,
-0.6389623880386353,
0.06676531583070755,
-0.5720430612564087,
-0.1451229304075241,
-0.31184157729148865,
-0.25368428230285645,
-0.424406498670578,
-0.7872743010520935,
0.5344688892364502,
-0.5052574872970581,
0.0877041146159172,
0.17224059998989105,
0.7406162619590759,
0.209213525056839,
-0.6995933055877686,
-0.48051318526268005,
-0.8161195516586304,
0.5906359553337097,
-0.5038461089134216,
0.5863733291625977,
0.40169891715049744,
0.6671500205993652,
-0.18760034441947937,
-0.6107675433158875,
-0.3523184061050415,
-0.31587472558021545,
-0.1440763622522354,
0.07020353525876999,
-0.09917683154344559,
0.057996734976768494,
0.22741343080997467,
0.26122528314590454,
-0.7395630478858948,
-0.40199288725852966,
-0.4426233470439911,
-0.12485483288764954,
0.40542367100715637,
-0.2387441247701645,
0.22964778542518616,
-0.0540209598839283,
-0.19665884971618652,
-0.15027779340744019,
-0.49568861722946167,
0.4006304442882538,
0.706264317035675,
0.29379507899284363,
0.6143076419830322,
0.6618310213088989,
-0.39307907223701477,
1.3954609632492065,
0.30388763546943665,
0.08099205791950226,
-0.10892078280448914,
-0.1980084627866745,
0.06760808825492859,
0.12350642681121826,
-0.04167289286851883,
0.30453842878341675,
0.014865926466882229,
-0.08900628983974457,
-0.34956347942352295,
-0.21352286636829376,
0.14047148823738098,
-0.6847629547119141,
0.07084370404481888,
0.31176233291625977,
-0.2713949382305145,
0.08154754340648651,
0.19340379536151886,
-0.6338898539543152,
-0.2981305718421936,
-0.5739268064498901,
0.5766887664794922,
-0.360551118850708,
-0.22946517169475555,
0.2700364589691162,
-0.34868502616882324,
0.08172295242547989,
0.2872851490974426,
-0.9115208983421326,
0.25571438670158386,
0.5040344595909119,
0.261550635099411,
0.10279769450426102,
0.3760409355163574,
-0.6057491898536682,
0.25471043586730957,
-0.3300233483314514,
0.8566659092903137,
-0.7992758750915527,
-0.44408082962036133,
0.15787042677402496,
0.031179234385490417,
0.3667061924934387,
-0.7192589640617371,
0.7932431697845459,
-1.0340381860733032,
0.12546613812446594,
-0.40392354130744934,
-0.7681899666786194,
-0.2627076208591461,
0.28638583421707153,
-0.6928163766860962,
0.9845143556594849,
0.20132699608802795,
-0.4375738501548767,
0.3706974685192108,
-0.23671738803386688,
-0.35216912627220154,
0.21135810017585754,
0.01155094988644123,
-0.022937558591365814,
0.08659470826387405,
0.33305323123931885,
0.024293959140777588,
-0.3333798944950104,
0.39542990922927856,
-0.2587783932685852,
-0.3918820023536682,
0.40743306279182434,
-0.46471911668777466,
0.6102617979049683,
0.2718598544597626,
0.07021152228116989,
-0.09240087866783142,
-0.7021368145942688,
0.3770386576652527,
-0.19084709882736206,
-0.6421532034873962,
-0.4428996443748474,
-0.3778553307056427,
-0.28447818756103516,
-0.36432573199272156,
0.880146861076355,
-0.4608922302722931,
0.3249203860759735,
-0.5731253623962402,
0.09606649726629257,
0.5128485560417175,
0.37090954184532166,
0.5768994092941284,
-0.45220980048179626,
0.5747368335723877,
-0.4117696285247803,
0.372720330953598,
-0.18185105919837952,
-0.6328967213630676,
-0.5385820269584656,
0.14104579389095306,
0.5656837224960327,
0.6137394309043884,
-0.6115491986274719,
0.22518756985664368,
0.16003955900669098,
-0.4458960294723511,
-0.8063938021659851,
0.16561447083950043,
0.3175300061702728,
0.6368110775947571,
0.36587464809417725,
0.148969367146492,
-0.47552821040153503,
-1.1163774728775024,
-0.2699963450431824,
-0.40093153715133667,
0.08065267652273178,
0.49521148204803467,
0.0347597636282444,
-0.09887006133794785,
1.127565860748291,
-0.5770659446716309,
0.21847982704639435,
-0.23439320921897888,
0.23123742640018463,
0.44205304980278015,
0.2904471457004547,
0.3992581367492676,
-1.3804022073745728,
-0.32483306527137756,
-0.012468506582081318,
-0.37313732504844666,
-0.5309978127479553,
-0.08118797093629837,
-0.23319177329540253,
0.1398235708475113,
0.41869908571243286,
-0.636933445930481,
0.4165442883968353,
0.19644013047218323,
0.04762841761112213,
0.5499573349952698,
-0.3819710612297058,
0.09103909879922867,
-0.5516582131385803,
0.1950463503599167,
-0.30009374022483826,
-0.292235791683197,
-0.6057984828948975,
0.3383011221885681,
0.08130534738302231,
0.007007407955825329,
-0.025075320154428482,
0.7947845458984375,
-0.31725165247917175,
-0.13056735694408417,
-0.23199352622032166,
0.5731103420257568,
0.07121309638023376,
0.15220169723033905,
-0.19028834998607635,
0.6247265934944153,
0.5818665027618408,
-1.0013103485107422,
0.5595665574073792,
0.20785897970199585,
-0.3399091362953186,
0.6464468240737915,
-0.5856962203979492,
-0.1318773329257965,
-0.46602073311805725,
0.16743655502796173,
-1.2190451622009277,
-0.6016067266464233,
-0.1064542606472969,
-0.337036669254303,
0.24956801533699036,
-0.26907023787498474,
-0.38891488313674927,
-0.6919456720352173,
0.05487079173326492,
0.6159287095069885,
0.37510228157043457,
-0.7591633200645447,
0.355804443359375,
0.355948805809021,
-0.34800606966018677,
-0.762309730052948,
-0.4641576409339905,
-0.18866658210754395,
-0.028620876371860504,
-0.9525156617164612,
0.3087612986564636,
-0.5476651191711426,
-0.37661656737327576,
0.005661867558956146,
-0.5259304046630859,
-0.27946045994758606,
0.10674397647380829,
-0.11078556627035141,
0.23694397509098053,
-0.12552767992019653,
0.4668496549129486,
0.11114950478076935,
0.03175065293908119,
-0.24536478519439697,
-0.5180980563163757,
0.5685795545578003,
-0.29664042592048645,
-0.601287305355072,
-0.20904332399368286,
0.35290923714637756,
0.13569305837154388,
-0.16012471914291382,
0.11125337332487106,
0.49405980110168457,
-0.1819915920495987,
-0.1862388700246811,
-0.9022443294525146,
-0.4261690080165863,
-0.51002436876297,
0.03780670091509819,
-0.45890238881111145,
-0.9946075081825256,
0.7756592035293579,
-0.05167190730571747,
-0.21267737448215485,
-0.04341612756252289,
0.2797938585281372,
-0.08662835508584976,
1.3428183794021606,
0.3900737166404724,
0.34734994173049927,
0.39962437748908997,
0.053079016506671906,
0.1805836409330368,
-0.5549690127372742,
-0.25640323758125305,
-0.5219547748565674,
-0.3008289933204651,
-0.3361169993877411,
-0.1941046118736267,
0.4950658977031708,
0.32624706625938416,
0.15686717629432678,
0.3287656605243683,
-0.5525147914886475,
0.4776722490787506,
1.0801485776901245,
0.3150617778301239,
0.36715182662010193,
-0.34686344861984253,
-0.1617327183485031,
0.0751677080988884,
-0.39688876271247864,
-0.46584320068359375,
0.8795235753059387,
-0.1913241744041443,
0.6585269570350647,
0.6120439767837524,
0.6743594408035278,
0.2475324273109436,
0.0632859542965889,
-0.5922616124153137,
0.6451364755630493,
0.2689622640609741,
-1.1140954494476318,
-0.4886855185031891,
-0.34821343421936035,
-1.073676347732544,
0.2022981494665146,
-0.008988742716610432,
-0.7383317947387695,
0.4227895736694336,
0.2084050178527832,
-0.4978713095188141,
-0.25955891609191895,
-0.4823630452156067,
0.6883069276809692,
-0.42053505778312683,
-0.35119497776031494,
0.14507298171520233,
-0.8756058812141418,
0.3638027310371399,
-0.13510635495185852,
0.2387610524892807,
0.08120153099298477,
-0.08096633106470108,
0.23898839950561523,
-0.4082193672657013,
0.45651641488075256,
-0.22059430181980133,
-0.08752688020467758,
0.6408036351203918,
0.3808564245700836,
0.5470166802406311,
0.21950627863407135,
-0.524264931678772,
-0.6439868211746216,
0.3030124008655548,
-0.35372963547706604,
-1.130321741104126,
0.4544799327850342,
-0.4381902515888214,
-1.21088445186615,
-0.14338798820972443,
-0.6104177832603455,
-0.35734936594963074,
0.4611022472381592,
0.11024884879589081,
0.5194631218910217,
0.08670515567064285,
0.39630094170570374,
0.7449586391448975,
-0.12544482946395874,
0.0318349152803421,
0.7439666390419006,
-0.660912275314331,
-0.13675208389759064,
0.7174451947212219,
0.08667147159576416,
0.257485955953598,
0.4220108389854431,
0.2963005602359772,
-0.6399465799331665,
-0.5958069562911987,
-0.4904136657714844,
0.41590192914009094,
-0.9147195219993591,
-0.14534711837768555,
-0.26433631777763367,
0.07002697885036469,
-0.5566076636314392,
-0.07361525297164917,
0.1738518625497818,
-0.6065497994422913,
-0.36001718044281006,
-0.2459166795015335,
0.14072974026203156,
0.7321159839630127,
-0.09684303402900696,
0.5387760996818542,
-0.7647886872291565,
0.21072763204574585,
0.43121498823165894,
0.22423842549324036,
-0.42646312713623047,
-0.7962692975997925,
0.0393681600689888,
0.11417628079652786,
-0.20363880693912506,
-1.0895777940750122,
0.30949386954307556,
0.14251458644866943,
0.8511186838150024,
0.504107654094696,
0.34922608733177185,
0.9206586480140686,
-0.21535354852676392,
0.7879652976989746,
-0.16975872218608856,
-0.6773908734321594,
0.7597910165786743,
-0.45493370294570923,
0.39884763956069946,
0.9230830669403076,
0.30991697311401367,
-0.39916759729385376,
-0.5275014638900757,
-0.5545304417610168,
-0.9340596199035645,
0.7284590601921082,
0.09864264726638794,
0.03597972169518471,
-0.0322708822786808,
0.6792421340942383,
0.11955934762954712,
0.44197192788124084,
-0.6256457567214966,
-0.09315305203199387,
0.08417144417762756,
-0.2584037482738495,
0.42369362711906433,
-0.3091564476490021,
-0.08554565906524658,
-0.14420728385448456,
0.8304425477981567,
-0.01723647117614746,
-0.12157617509365082,
0.26671549677848816,
-0.10024003684520721,
-0.13203410804271698,
0.40020471811294556,
0.47459661960601807,
0.7475109100341797,
-0.5199049711227417,
0.05314509943127632,
-0.04373525455594063,
-0.0004576217324938625,
0.017033899202942848,
0.14521841704845428,
-0.5169551372528076,
0.07841627299785614,
0.06454053521156311,
0.661705732345581,
0.24954956769943237,
-0.9527629017829895,
0.48797717690467834,
-0.01921912468969822,
0.021716643124818802,
-0.34852486848831177,
0.24229426681995392,
0.11964515596628189,
0.4054388105869293,
0.5085871815681458,
-0.05778847634792328,
0.4292004406452179,
-0.7369467616081238,
0.3965594470500946,
0.553888201713562,
-0.27253639698028564,
0.06756414473056793,
0.38448747992515564,
-0.15988360345363617,
-0.46445173025131226,
0.43304601311683655,
-0.4018084704875946,
-0.48812180757522583,
0.4733639359474182,
0.7227035760879517,
0.22713279724121094,
-0.2438698261976242,
0.34704339504241943,
0.31232020258903503,
0.28900837898254395,
-0.4134097397327423,
0.5740242004394531,
-0.3422893285751343,
-0.31422820687294006,
-0.10349178314208984,
-0.7112897038459778,
-0.6366474628448486,
-0.11487127840518951,
-0.7626173496246338,
0.405291885137558,
-0.29165583848953247,
-0.5795422792434692,
-0.16338638961315155,
-0.19262197613716125,
-0.414096474647522,
0.12702906131744385,
-0.02506624534726143,
1.0181841850280762,
-0.2524420917034149,
0.4103328585624695,
0.6626783609390259,
-0.7496563792228699,
-0.718775749206543,
-0.09088368713855743,
-0.29165682196617126,
-0.5320152044296265,
0.8982358574867249,
0.0024328308645635843,
-0.0686672031879425,
0.03256705030798912,
-0.7548391819000244,
-1.3074194192886353,
1.001460313796997,
0.44034695625305176,
-0.34896284341812134,
-0.1041027083992958,
0.1421166956424713,
0.6209501624107361,
-0.12587641179561615,
0.5419790744781494,
0.6616904139518738,
1.0022854804992676,
0.51883864402771,
-0.7468636631965637,
-0.19164712727069855,
-0.05386769771575928,
-0.11760461330413818,
0.1449417769908905,
-0.44904643297195435,
0.7891124486923218,
-0.13743798434734344,
-0.24821117520332336,
0.5061814785003662,
0.6403799653053284,
0.25063005089759827,
0.3785974979400635,
0.5060524940490723,
0.36313682794570923,
1.4559779167175293,
-0.17003625631332397,
1.2576133012771606,
-0.3749080002307892,
0.06498569995164871,
1.2333276271820068,
-0.22328169643878937,
0.7828774452209473,
0.44348540902137756,
0.04003346711397171,
0.3697878122329712,
0.8820213079452515,
0.22320280969142914,
0.5634647011756897,
0.3746098279953003,
-0.4479852616786957,
-0.6248407363891602,
-0.259981244802475,
-0.20404115319252014,
0.21273420751094818,
0.591841459274292,
0.012714377604424953,
-0.3940979540348053,
0.20524024963378906,
-0.36673277616500854,
0.3244685232639313,
-0.15422086417675018,
0.7025431990623474,
-0.13951323926448822,
-1.166895866394043,
0.4773692786693573,
-0.050232838839292526,
0.1294313669204712,
-0.6952145099639893,
0.02385667897760868,
-0.22780469059944153,
0.09134936332702637,
-0.08749215304851532,
-0.8120144605636597,
0.07992156594991684,
-0.3136732876300812,
-0.37208786606788635,
0.11581491678953171,
0.654367208480835,
-0.6435607671737671,
-0.6360273957252502,
0.15716750919818878,
0.24743826687335968,
0.30290624499320984,
-0.01894235797226429,
-0.6131119728088379,
0.02695789746940136,
0.1733713448047638,
-0.07447374612092972,
-0.09486948698759079,
0.6872574090957642,
-0.07395242154598236,
1.0304092168807983,
0.7173656821250916,
0.30134233832359314,
0.32322385907173157,
0.08886989951133728,
0.638974130153656,
-0.26800185441970825,
-0.458560585975647,
-0.4554924964904785,
0.2619854807853699,
-0.27523112297058105,
-0.10126366466283798,
0.7823550701141357,
0.40371012687683105,
0.6897258162498474,
0.04963993281126022,
0.7332587242126465,
0.16954617202281952,
0.878514289855957,
-0.43705108761787415,
0.13035990297794342,
-0.6529811024665833,
0.5909213423728943,
0.09002751111984253,
-1.0452547073364258,
-0.3805343508720398,
0.6713845729827881,
-0.4763675928115845,
0.05450106039643288,
0.41599130630493164,
0.8668484091758728,
-0.1310289353132248,
0.35646504163742065,
0.21511197090148926,
0.17022962868213654,
0.3709202706813812,
0.21737690269947052,
0.7908593416213989,
-0.1446419507265091,
0.9161664843559265,
-0.20529229938983917,
-0.15712986886501312,
-0.6894639730453491,
-0.7082757353782654,
-0.5468196272850037,
-0.556300938129425,
-0.1203964576125145,
-0.12581941485404968,
0.14603391289710999,
1.0164493322372437,
0.5950319170951843,
-0.7119027376174927,
-0.2984994649887085,
0.06308628618717194,
0.3233032524585724,
0.04217095300555229,
-0.2715916335582733,
0.19144612550735474,
-0.6696798801422119,
-0.8300406336784363,
0.507818341255188,
0.12141405045986176,
0.07494886964559555,
-0.2593207359313965,
0.22582286596298218,
-0.3289305865764618,
0.2857666015625,
0.2729984521865845,
0.3682946264743805,
-0.7447667717933655,
-0.44077083468437195,
0.2342841774225235,
0.0021701992955058813,
-0.26982957124710083,
0.6709149479866028,
-0.7612632513046265,
0.7775881290435791,
0.4936475455760956,
0.902276873588562,
0.6735173463821411,
0.5411121845245361,
0.6390843987464905,
-1.027222990989685,
-0.03197309002280235,
0.45260924100875854,
0.2801021933555603,
0.3175191283226013,
-0.42657655477523804,
0.391373872756958,
0.0022970219142735004,
-0.7799490690231323,
-0.9039183855056763,
0.459336519241333,
-1.1460661888122559,
-0.4369770288467407,
1.1490063667297363,
0.1782962530851364,
-0.4552800953388214,
-0.33691492676734924,
-0.625048816204071,
0.11114059388637543,
-0.6180709600448608,
0.5849454402923584,
0.927031397819519,
-0.1649732142686844,
0.1055150255560875,
-0.6004592776298523,
0.38518810272216797,
0.6027209162712097,
-0.30698150396347046,
0.05407748371362686,
0.703386664390564,
0.04994530603289604,
0.40638014674186707,
0.41292229294776917,
0.18455670773983002,
0.3397754430770874,
-0.4417681097984314,
-0.2964511811733246,
0.10130470246076584,
-0.21345163881778717,
-0.02029922604560852,
0.4900802969932556,
0.20737141370773315,
0.26239213347435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18264v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18264v1
|
Modeling Orthographic Variation Improves NLP Performance for Nigerian Pidgin
| 2024-04-28T18:07:13 | 2024-04-28T18:07:13 |
Pin-Jie Lin, Merel Scholman, Muhammed Saeed, Vera Demberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Nigerian Pidgin is an English-derived contact language and is traditionally
an oral language, spoken by approximately 100 million people. No orthographic
standard has yet been adopted, and thus the few available Pidgin datasets that
exist are characterised by noise in the form of orthographic variations. This
contributes to under-performance of models in critical NLP tasks. The current
work is the first to describe various types of orthographic variations commonly
found in Nigerian Pidgin texts, and model this orthographic variation. The
variations identified in the dataset form the basis of a phonetic-theoretic
framework for word editing, which is used to generate orthographic variations
to augment training data. We test the effect of this data augmentation on two
critical NLP tasks: machine translation and sentiment analysis. The proposed
variation generation framework augments the training data with new orthographic
variants which are relevant for the test set but did not occur in the training
set originally. Our results demonstrate the positive effect of augmenting the
training data with a combination of real texts from other corpora as well as
synthesized orthographic variation, resulting in performance improvements of
2.1 points in sentiment analysis and 1.4 BLEU points in translation to English.
|
[
-0.3641277253627777,
-0.8535533547401428,
-0.09512920677661896,
0.20919901132583618,
-0.09209053963422775,
-0.12470732629299164,
-0.357322096824646,
-0.7896709442138672,
0.44629618525505066,
0.5758055448532104,
-0.5191375017166138,
-0.5109795928001404,
-0.4850177764892578,
0.36110439896583557,
-0.17412257194519043,
0.7968026995658875,
-0.07769916206598282,
0.2064756155014038,
0.25527137517929077,
-0.2964969575405121,
-0.5215455293655396,
-0.5236470699310303,
-0.4107266962528229,
-0.45232251286506653,
0.42554593086242676,
0.39294737577438354,
0.894821047782898,
0.5301517844200134,
0.45336318016052246,
0.21584714949131012,
-0.3804723918437958,
0.3548303246498108,
-0.41707557439804077,
0.42381221055984497,
-0.28688037395477295,
-0.8005770444869995,
-0.49664196372032166,
-0.012854463420808315,
0.6426628828048706,
1.044022560119629,
-0.24161000549793243,
-0.21637235581874847,
-0.1096576452255249,
0.8522471189498901,
-0.5786228179931641,
-0.05331572890281677,
-0.5465084910392761,
0.2432686686515808,
-0.47738736867904663,
-0.023135151714086533,
0.22576016187667847,
-0.07740257680416107,
0.28946346044540405,
-0.6146048903465271,
0.49581044912338257,
-0.2940830588340759,
0.6021090745925903,
0.2880599796772003,
-0.07336512953042984,
-0.5028386116027832,
-0.37921789288520813,
0.4694969058036804,
-1.0002034902572632,
0.4990186393260956,
0.3164459764957428,
-0.28640976548194885,
-0.3825779855251312,
-0.5627945065498352,
-0.5871379971504211,
-0.09501295536756516,
-0.05792686715722084,
0.08018769323825836,
0.3147568702697754,
0.053667254745960236,
0.46366527676582336,
0.8178234696388245,
-0.3543102741241455,
0.10474114120006561,
-0.20905476808547974,
0.12625084817409515,
0.8090763092041016,
0.09061457961797714,
0.45000919699668884,
-0.3045423626899719,
0.23707638680934906,
-0.26809200644493103,
-0.6754041910171509,
0.2614707052707672,
0.8997893929481506,
0.49764829874038696,
-0.09315009415149689,
0.8413278460502625,
-0.24022991955280304,
0.7413942813873291,
0.0036665285006165504,
-0.295503705739975,
0.5154885053634644,
0.022078385576605797,
-0.13358443975448608,
0.020659737288951874,
0.8321132063865662,
0.19154098629951477,
-0.03817581385374069,
0.04960847273468971,
-0.4254777431488037,
0.1532348394393921,
0.2061418741941452,
-0.6779325604438782,
-0.2808244526386261,
0.06420742720365524,
-0.2531417906284332,
-0.34968283772468567,
0.09515339136123657,
-0.7656785249710083,
-0.7176031470298767,
-0.22334136068820953,
0.03479599580168724,
-0.8279311656951904,
-0.5385846495628357,
0.48256492614746094,
-0.13747866451740265,
-0.033016107976436615,
0.258767306804657,
-1.1068572998046875,
-0.046730589121580124,
0.6993052959442139,
0.6822705268859863,
-0.422391414642334,
-0.3077556788921356,
-0.24439476430416107,
-0.4966389536857605,
-0.5144689679145813,
0.5675399303436279,
-0.6847060322761536,
-0.6818950176239014,
0.1477377712726593,
-0.25464433431625366,
-0.46222764253616333,
-0.8489665389060974,
0.8092522621154785,
-0.3173759877681732,
0.3380747437477112,
-0.12088876217603683,
-0.6598825454711914,
-0.41130292415618896,
0.076815664768219,
-0.7525065541267395,
1.3480616807937622,
0.34431740641593933,
-0.9119870066642761,
0.28927168250083923,
-0.8310621976852417,
-0.647846519947052,
0.1847730576992035,
-0.3958556354045868,
-0.44179874658584595,
0.5763277411460876,
0.19003382325172424,
0.27304765582084656,
-0.03242766112089157,
0.03683854639530182,
-0.2648794949054718,
-0.22453361749649048,
0.43484023213386536,
-0.3950313329696655,
0.8455061316490173,
-0.10364291816949844,
-0.4303167760372162,
-0.35068923234939575,
-0.9186660051345825,
-0.08440142124891281,
-0.23920854926109314,
-0.49411964416503906,
-0.2354397475719452,
-0.0034041223116219044,
0.34926924109458923,
0.042105987668037415,
-0.07285363972187042,
-0.7123964428901672,
0.2844211459159851,
-0.8351850509643555,
0.44722336530685425,
0.0023848905693739653,
0.07668209075927734,
0.4314272105693817,
-0.27415910363197327,
0.8140075206756592,
0.021622858941555023,
-0.16506114602088928,
-0.26465100049972534,
-0.5764315128326416,
-0.7079904675483704,
-0.2741635739803314,
0.8261491656303406,
0.47203338146209717,
-0.7038118839263916,
0.16185452044010162,
-0.22405053675174713,
-0.23271454870700836,
-0.7784233093261719,
0.02540738135576248,
-0.0921405628323555,
0.6267120838165283,
0.18124595284461975,
-0.6881618499755859,
-0.5856809020042419,
-0.6534185409545898,
-0.38206058740615845,
-0.15064653754234314,
-0.12452255189418793,
0.25139299035072327,
0.2894201874732971,
-0.24915960431098938,
0.9446796774864197,
-0.014729431830346584,
-0.31340575218200684,
-0.2767421007156372,
0.3123828172683716,
0.3671710789203644,
0.6230836510658264,
0.40422502160072327,
-1.0884993076324463,
-0.5737742781639099,
0.01178141962736845,
-0.5667789578437805,
-0.22543011605739594,
-0.3053431808948517,
0.09013818204402924,
0.5161762237548828,
0.4468099772930145,
-0.4193991720676422,
0.769838273525238,
0.6546746492385864,
-0.13064150512218475,
0.601109504699707,
0.021901119500398636,
0.08121224492788315,
-0.7322221994400024,
0.08687428385019302,
-0.2514832615852356,
-0.3483039438724518,
-0.7438632845878601,
0.15982340276241302,
0.11365313827991486,
-0.2629255950450897,
-0.3710343837738037,
0.1733829826116562,
-0.3416522741317749,
0.21952126920223236,
-0.2846984565258026,
-0.018977275118231773,
-0.137928307056427,
0.21349020302295685,
0.45599785447120667,
0.7972445487976074,
0.5544566512107849,
-0.3571230173110962,
0.05200390890240669,
0.17460547387599945,
-0.3766671121120453,
0.941644012928009,
-0.720388650894165,
0.05774971470236778,
0.005129777826368809,
-0.04322909936308861,
-0.840549647808075,
-0.5678715109825134,
0.35565444827079773,
-0.46637022495269775,
0.6536224484443665,
-0.11338002979755402,
-0.4410366714000702,
0.003854046342894435,
-0.22600340843200684,
0.23151208460330963,
-0.1106925681233406,
-0.26630690693855286,
0.6756365299224854,
0.35122695565223694,
-0.3173874318599701,
-0.5517624616622925,
-0.7901431322097778,
0.16167700290679932,
-0.19352741539478302,
-0.6959224939346313,
0.5704185366630554,
-0.016639403998851776,
0.02257339097559452,
-0.07845433801412582,
-0.03670375049114227,
0.0856693908572197,
0.0885239765048027,
0.47136247158050537,
0.19604428112506866,
-0.44155052304267883,
0.20770534873008728,
0.13411228358745575,
0.1554688811302185,
-0.028067344799637794,
-0.13457544147968292,
0.5743541121482849,
-0.14119158685207367,
-0.15839959681034088,
-0.33590418100357056,
0.562117874622345,
0.2475953996181488,
-0.1824050098657608,
0.8520861268043518,
0.6326468586921692,
-0.1502050757408142,
-0.02520548738539219,
-0.49718859791755676,
0.008313304744660854,
-0.42769524455070496,
0.5609567165374756,
-0.5368272066116333,
-0.7511240839958191,
0.4135068356990814,
-0.10174503922462463,
0.08365454524755478,
0.40023359656333923,
0.379458487033844,
-0.3494386076927185,
0.597866415977478,
0.6759871244430542,
-0.0280928798019886,
0.7435991168022156,
-0.37735188007354736,
0.04694855213165283,
-1.071913242340088,
-0.004185456316918135,
-0.2932431697845459,
-0.5246991515159607,
-1.0025124549865723,
-0.32282397150993347,
0.4918562173843384,
0.4279700517654419,
0.3326970934867859,
0.03516077995300293,
-0.140252947807312,
0.3717256486415863,
0.5417287945747375,
0.35375577211380005,
0.11270491033792496,
0.2728506326675415,
-0.10946133732795715,
-0.23424814641475677,
-1.0396499633789062,
-0.4430401027202606,
1.3897970914840698,
0.08220233768224716,
0.4529733955860138,
-0.046755075454711914,
0.7628618478775024,
0.24861571192741394,
0.2910310924053192,
-0.670125424861908,
-0.008355495519936085,
-0.17617733776569366,
-0.5493810772895813,
-0.49525579810142517,
-0.3943193256855011,
-0.8707656264305115,
0.36958569288253784,
-0.48245349526405334,
-0.6324709057807922,
0.760482907295227,
0.15023194253444672,
-0.2811703085899353,
0.19035477936267853,
-0.35661056637763977,
0.6416345834732056,
0.07420920580625534,
-0.08399583399295807,
-0.0003350564220454544,
-0.6682991981506348,
0.14050695300102234,
-0.1157502755522728,
0.08118823170661926,
0.12348808348178864,
-0.20574557781219482,
0.6265972852706909,
-0.4373370110988617,
0.9292708039283752,
0.17200854420661926,
-0.2451556921005249,
0.1043485775589943,
0.004735921043902636,
0.4009801745414734,
0.3047860264778137,
-0.5113821625709534,
0.3494783937931061,
-0.278955340385437,
-0.31884458661079407,
-0.46002498269081116,
0.5158236026763916,
-0.7877639532089233,
-0.42078208923339844,
-0.287875771522522,
-0.719811737537384,
-0.2347291260957718,
-0.04974880814552307,
0.6570651531219482,
0.321418434381485,
-0.4001385569572449,
0.44114384055137634,
0.7921189069747925,
-0.18017247319221497,
0.445451945066452,
0.32025250792503357,
-0.015255717560648918,
-0.6674742698669434,
0.5531370043754578,
0.2453225702047348,
0.09541960805654526,
0.3039470314979553,
0.09644008427858353,
-0.2808062434196472,
-0.42260950803756714,
-0.5036904811859131,
0.4495362937450409,
-0.3954554796218872,
-0.09895575046539307,
-0.7282286882400513,
-0.07443416863679886,
-0.45386943221092224,
0.08087798953056335,
-0.5088015198707581,
-0.8362504243850708,
-0.5004470944404602,
0.17122279107570648,
0.19502057135105133,
0.555880069732666,
-0.45603179931640625,
0.46218985319137573,
-0.4638691246509552,
0.3686012029647827,
0.1317063868045807,
0.3011839687824249,
-0.2610001266002655,
-0.852134644985199,
-0.2258942425251007,
0.2940206527709961,
-0.4366743862628937,
-1.0721482038497925,
0.5629732608795166,
0.5369720458984375,
0.26049432158470154,
0.10444100946187973,
0.08041681349277496,
0.4567664861679077,
-0.30409514904022217,
0.779365599155426,
0.16678498685359955,
-0.9739381074905396,
0.45204997062683105,
-0.4450449049472809,
0.20679697394371033,
0.5969663858413696,
0.33357536792755127,
-0.8881996273994446,
-0.4620193541049957,
-0.8475164771080017,
-1.0504870414733887,
0.8268470764160156,
0.4439932405948639,
0.1336795538663864,
0.24456655979156494,
0.5486276149749756,
0.42753928899765015,
0.5728051662445068,
-0.4576379954814911,
-0.39204660058021545,
-0.3916442096233368,
0.024484720081090927,
-0.19020551443099976,
-0.43780913949012756,
0.007132074795663357,
-0.04265029355883598,
0.8691504597663879,
0.16412608325481415,
0.036518458276987076,
0.35539841651916504,
-0.2690608501434326,
-0.08401332795619965,
0.16908352077007294,
0.7369270324707031,
0.6342961192131042,
-0.16303564608097076,
-0.18166467547416687,
-0.03948946297168732,
-0.844853937625885,
-0.2160484939813614,
0.24643100798130035,
-0.6076139807701111,
0.49595603346824646,
0.37358465790748596,
0.9125410914421082,
-0.19180592894554138,
-0.45304301381111145,
0.12332401424646378,
0.018103206530213356,
-0.2209201455116272,
-0.01390151958912611,
0.21565262973308563,
-0.005780394654721022,
0.21724669635295868,
0.2175249606370926,
0.30794334411621094,
0.23913201689720154,
-0.4431554675102234,
-0.08014407753944397,
-0.07537395507097244,
-0.21911929547786713,
-0.303184449672699,
0.31627747416496277,
0.08122172951698303,
-0.6981773972511292,
0.5802415013313293,
0.0891425758600235,
-0.6145355701446533,
0.3829007148742676,
0.3242844045162201,
0.5840110778808594,
-0.40080004930496216,
0.4638977646827698,
0.09095717966556549,
0.27157095074653625,
-0.06480526179075241,
0.5675612688064575,
0.061559759080410004,
-0.7907506823539734,
-0.28004199266433716,
-0.4945066273212433,
-0.45799118280410767,
0.32074400782585144,
-0.9528982639312744,
0.16273313760757446,
-0.15949895977973938,
-0.30426135659217834,
-0.02296716719865799,
-0.07334523648023605,
-0.7859826683998108,
0.4430239498615265,
-0.03430255502462387,
0.5717902779579163,
-0.698900043964386,
0.6198394298553467,
0.9710429310798645,
-0.16782572865486145,
-0.7459345459938049,
-0.025564631447196007,
-0.3375990688800812,
-0.4496957063674927,
0.5239928960800171,
0.09869091212749481,
0.2275930941104889,
-0.2564040720462799,
-0.19285820424556732,
-0.5690882205963135,
0.4448997974395752,
0.4871135652065277,
-0.7004451155662537,
0.4485635757446289,
0.8631865978240967,
0.7201946377754211,
-0.6027675867080688,
0.28885936737060547,
0.7982847094535828,
0.1718621850013733,
-0.12219136953353882,
-0.7607836127281189,
-0.3214832544326782,
-0.3746589124202728,
0.5241237282752991,
0.1161373183131218,
-0.20419220626354218,
0.9179668426513672,
0.19802483916282654,
-0.06362216174602509,
0.06526541709899902,
0.7396637201309204,
0.041279129683971405,
-0.013608407229185104,
0.39638814330101013,
0.51186603307724,
1.0371559858322144,
0.002222346607595682,
1.0761104822158813,
-0.3604736626148224,
0.1867234706878662,
1.494837760925293,
-0.02410900592803955,
0.9225661158561707,
0.5722751021385193,
-0.11439171433448792,
0.36985522508621216,
0.723956286907196,
0.38479748368263245,
0.21379603445529938,
0.0824921652674675,
-0.3329148292541504,
-0.06187320500612259,
-0.28325971961021423,
-0.6623229384422302,
0.5937275886535645,
0.5935477018356323,
-0.5263379216194153,
0.07300523668527603,
0.09851144999265671,
0.008917152881622314,
0.18164196610450745,
-0.17733892798423767,
0.6268442273139954,
-0.06159123778343201,
-0.4239852726459503,
0.9280514121055603,
0.2097172737121582,
0.6977186799049377,
-0.34777072072029114,
0.021122712641954422,
-0.7046465277671814,
0.008481655269861221,
-0.3128908574581146,
-0.5279420018196106,
0.3343617618083954,
-0.038043174892663956,
-0.3217684328556061,
-0.17491590976715088,
0.31851133704185486,
-0.720754086971283,
-0.6766640543937683,
-0.18426859378814697,
0.11041133105754852,
0.0532437302172184,
-0.3673097491264343,
-0.707021176815033,
0.10852790623903275,
0.11423309892416,
-0.2910580039024353,
0.19058331847190857,
0.8375859260559082,
0.17383162677288055,
0.2690291702747345,
0.4348497688770294,
0.6619488596916199,
0.27761390805244446,
0.017110053449869156,
0.8993675112724304,
-0.2863492965698242,
-0.5242550373077393,
-0.6201525330543518,
0.39747539162635803,
-0.18531501293182373,
-0.642963707447052,
0.527878999710083,
0.6063340306282043,
1.0284899473190308,
-0.25459787249565125,
0.7824981808662415,
-0.13721199333667755,
0.7137438058853149,
-0.49771010875701904,
0.5102490186691284,
-0.48350095748901367,
0.3026599884033203,
-0.21330204606056213,
-0.9349760413169861,
-0.3579380512237549,
0.8839598298072815,
-0.2834714353084564,
-0.44659218192100525,
0.6327804923057556,
0.9631636142730713,
-0.17597082257270813,
0.3714149594306946,
0.401216983795166,
0.0733940377831459,
0.1613597869873047,
0.17333672940731049,
0.6655070781707764,
-0.8010286092758179,
0.16897465288639069,
-0.4902852177619934,
-0.15704602003097534,
-0.1832898110151291,
-0.8077578544616699,
-0.8528369665145874,
-0.20432376861572266,
-0.4743257462978363,
-0.28665676712989807,
0.18747368454933167,
0.8848433494567871,
0.48360416293144226,
-0.8718328475952148,
-0.5305207371711731,
-0.2785913050174713,
0.03615482524037361,
-0.21916905045509338,
-0.22264200448989868,
0.40271908044815063,
-0.41595450043678284,
-0.7713180780410767,
0.32084763050079346,
0.16890808939933777,
0.11622115224599838,
-0.048584528267383575,
0.030455516651272774,
-0.04222024977207184,
-0.04924752935767174,
0.306906133890152,
0.5104023218154907,
-0.5158830881118774,
0.1536681056022644,
-0.13627339899539948,
0.06915949285030365,
0.3328728973865509,
0.9223581552505493,
-0.46721911430358887,
0.7365667223930359,
0.4548243284225464,
0.6522282958030701,
0.500567615032196,
-0.1459120661020279,
0.8720481991767883,
-0.8129932284355164,
0.47872284054756165,
0.3182353973388672,
0.3252232074737549,
0.6399292349815369,
-0.44423675537109375,
0.6242724657058716,
0.4427768290042877,
-0.1518036276102066,
-0.7016675472259521,
0.24363429844379425,
-0.5107955932617188,
0.016679976135492325,
1.0331717729568481,
-0.4616002142429352,
-0.06093268841505051,
0.06433270126581192,
-0.21312081813812256,
0.15579338371753693,
-0.5625903606414795,
1.020550012588501,
0.7423598170280457,
-0.04478685185313225,
0.027639124542474747,
-0.3502643406391144,
0.6062443256378174,
0.6529181599617004,
-0.5419130921363831,
-0.14164143800735474,
0.29193738102912903,
0.09748539328575134,
0.17375901341438293,
0.23926259577274323,
-0.07358153909444809,
0.37055084109306335,
-0.053170494735240936,
0.0009146076044999063,
-0.021458487957715988,
-0.10517071932554245,
-0.43478795886039734,
0.22637593746185303,
-0.30323633551597595,
-0.07350616157054901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18257v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18257v1
|
Mapping 'when'-clauses in Latin American and Caribbean languages: an experiment in subtoken-based typology
| 2024-04-28T17:43:24 | 2024-04-28T17:43:24 |
Nilo Pedrazzini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, 68T50, 68U15, 68T35, (Primary), 86A32, 15A03 (Secondary), I.2.7
|
Languages can encode temporal subordination lexically, via subordinating
conjunctions, and morphologically, by marking the relation on the predicate.
Systematic cross-linguistic variation among the former can be studied using
well-established token-based typological approaches to token-aligned parallel
corpora. Variation among different morphological means is instead much harder
to tackle and therefore more poorly understood, despite being predominant in
several language groups. This paper explores variation in the expression of
generic temporal subordination ('when'-clauses) among the languages of Latin
America and the Caribbean, where morphological marking is particularly common.
It presents probabilistic semantic maps computed on the basis of the languages
of the region, thus avoiding bias towards the many world's languages that
exclusively use lexified connectors, incorporating associations between
character $n$-grams and English $when$. The approach allows capturing
morphological clause-linkage devices in addition to lexified connectors, paving
the way for larger-scale, strategy-agnostic analyses of typological variation
in temporal subordination.
|
[
-0.42163988947868347,
-0.4576598107814789,
0.5798916220664978,
0.5784592628479004,
-0.656885027885437,
0.3811612129211426,
-0.13214418292045593,
-0.5505440831184387,
0.8083839416503906,
0.3316419720649719,
-0.6519030332565308,
-0.7258809208869934,
-0.5325689911842346,
0.3792877197265625,
-0.3645555377006531,
0.5656314492225647,
0.06631075590848923,
-0.13818763196468353,
-0.24100594222545624,
-0.27328118681907654,
-0.06614937633275986,
-1.0191148519515991,
-0.42101603746414185,
-0.18428879976272583,
0.745899498462677,
0.16668671369552612,
0.9604811072349548,
0.6630895733833313,
0.5011327862739563,
0.333172470331192,
-0.0182917732745409,
0.24093973636627197,
0.1941165030002594,
-0.020341476425528526,
-0.5079159736633301,
-0.7422894239425659,
-0.374849796295166,
0.13468673825263977,
0.17604558169841766,
0.9756888151168823,
0.03988512605428696,
0.03969777375459671,
-0.360592782497406,
0.34163761138916016,
-0.6929032206535339,
0.5423406362533569,
-0.7493952512741089,
0.03707762807607651,
-0.6647781133651733,
-0.7992424964904785,
-0.051804546266794205,
-0.33820757269859314,
-0.01587780751287937,
-0.4256240427494049,
0.2570011019706726,
0.2866131663322449,
0.6933708190917969,
0.3352417051792145,
-0.46234795451164246,
-0.1915741115808487,
-0.4485272765159607,
0.7525143027305603,
-0.49261051416397095,
0.5041409134864807,
0.4408265948295593,
0.09781359881162643,
-0.33282944560050964,
-0.5487309694290161,
-0.3155546188354492,
-0.1752261370420456,
-0.16637136042118073,
0.2941959798336029,
0.007398440036922693,
-0.012524645775556564,
-0.023986442014575005,
0.11724031716585159,
-0.4738531708717346,
0.04126930981874466,
-0.28344887495040894,
-0.17271322011947632,
0.40503981709480286,
-0.11899693310260773,
0.34486693143844604,
-0.31579384207725525,
-0.10768914222717285,
0.43871331214904785,
-0.8504398465156555,
-0.10126814246177673,
0.6190406084060669,
0.6927486658096313,
-0.07366174459457397,
0.9405845403671265,
0.030682547017931938,
0.6946679949760437,
0.05591963976621628,
-0.09555097669363022,
0.12442369014024734,
-0.6578266620635986,
-0.007662512362003326,
-0.051331937313079834,
0.7064143419265747,
0.18930761516094208,
0.4653790593147278,
-0.2523549795150757,
-0.15843836963176727,
0.3348747789859772,
-0.029013551771640778,
-0.06474743783473969,
0.18993133306503296,
0.09097959101200104,
-0.3570004403591156,
-0.06730514019727707,
-0.05436086282134056,
-0.8541694283485413,
-0.06139209493994713,
-0.32889461517333984,
-0.060390446335077286,
-0.30624303221702576,
-0.07110925018787384,
0.4121897220611572,
-0.0844569057226181,
0.3032420873641968,
-0.15594296157360077,
-0.7550258636474609,
0.6295691132545471,
0.6831475496292114,
0.7622103691101074,
-0.29254287481307983,
-0.41721946001052856,
-0.3319666087627411,
-0.11508630961179733,
-0.4653007686138153,
0.9260610342025757,
-0.7108670473098755,
-0.5760228037834167,
0.1767585277557373,
0.23688359558582306,
-0.2674013376235962,
-0.5932158827781677,
0.5653383731842041,
-0.43874040246009827,
0.20380151271820068,
-0.1881822645664215,
-0.26118409633636475,
0.1036423072218895,
0.06750515103340149,
-0.25728821754455566,
0.6761136651039124,
0.2227693498134613,
-0.7155076265335083,
0.46729564666748047,
-0.13365566730499268,
-0.5684147477149963,
0.02226676233112812,
-0.4680135250091553,
-0.14156687259674072,
0.22887684404850006,
0.28411033749580383,
-0.23200634121894836,
-0.5723592042922974,
0.3174293339252472,
-0.29930463433265686,
-0.22113721072673798,
0.37173986434936523,
-0.12271276861429214,
1.0715163946151733,
0.002899296348914504,
-0.6301547288894653,
-0.035993095487356186,
-0.4894237518310547,
0.012311398051679134,
-0.025661597028374672,
0.07895214855670929,
-0.3383788764476776,
0.31424227356910706,
-0.10204815864562988,
0.20905987918376923,
0.3483141362667084,
-0.6062292456626892,
0.29984602332115173,
-0.11281543970108032,
0.519835352897644,
0.06129619851708412,
0.33337539434432983,
0.2347162514925003,
-0.27635520696640015,
0.7053333520889282,
0.2847374975681305,
0.6337330341339111,
0.1596449613571167,
-0.6350299715995789,
-1.0847538709640503,
-0.11383478343486786,
0.5477200150489807,
0.6496407985687256,
-0.6917965412139893,
0.3984692692756653,
-0.20654377341270447,
-0.49094274640083313,
-0.2204117327928543,
-0.38810083270072937,
0.5075492262840271,
0.056867875158786774,
0.49628210067749023,
-0.3628794550895691,
-0.7279244065284729,
-1.0540374517440796,
-0.13127031922340393,
-0.8048804998397827,
0.43190258741378784,
0.11732932925224304,
0.2541557550430298,
-0.07454492896795273,
0.8780417442321777,
-0.35768064856529236,
-0.2935684621334076,
-0.2948746085166931,
0.3543706238269806,
0.09537854790687561,
0.3500044047832489,
0.8974131345748901,
-0.6590124368667603,
-0.12212804704904556,
-0.00365519430488348,
-0.3468296527862549,
-0.6641011834144592,
-0.026138223707675934,
0.1318630874156952,
0.4743525981903076,
0.9941891431808472,
-0.32232093811035156,
0.5958547592163086,
0.45493283867836,
-0.2658595144748688,
0.6024783849716187,
-0.4985601603984833,
0.34440502524375916,
-0.6354892253875732,
-0.37897321581840515,
-0.2451297640800476,
-0.1948683261871338,
-0.10127080231904984,
0.15225723385810852,
0.03057914599776268,
0.04923102632164955,
-0.5237221717834473,
0.23190556466579437,
-0.6276138424873352,
-0.378853440284729,
-0.0717635229229927,
-0.008112916722893715,
-0.24871869385242462,
0.4945918917655945,
0.2594480514526367,
0.7147510647773743,
0.3971131443977356,
-0.429366797208786,
-0.21026058495044708,
-0.15646536648273468,
-0.2990681231021881,
0.44566699862480164,
-0.6622944474220276,
0.00813456904143095,
-0.12745919823646545,
0.1195496916770935,
-0.703703761100769,
0.11545751988887787,
0.09930779784917831,
-0.45577266812324524,
-0.033048003911972046,
-0.724092423915863,
-0.7404606938362122,
-0.09462979435920715,
0.19950081408023834,
0.8354556560516357,
0.4508858323097229,
-0.20608332753181458,
0.4298820197582245,
0.5556128025054932,
0.0086349006742239,
-0.4414865970611572,
-0.6284624934196472,
-0.0681181475520134,
-0.4649166464805603,
-0.38677406311035156,
0.6243912577629089,
0.15425829589366913,
-0.4947172701358795,
-0.12695010006427765,
-0.09967821091413498,
-0.15240886807441711,
0.0801273062825203,
0.1946909874677658,
0.2915307879447937,
-0.17972487211227417,
-0.1765121966600418,
0.2344934642314911,
0.05518374592065811,
0.010566041804850101,
-0.7281956076622009,
0.8682453632354736,
0.008513796143233776,
-0.5623012185096741,
0.04311050847172737,
0.6789011359214783,
0.8272175788879395,
-0.53647780418396,
0.6952553391456604,
-0.02405446022748947,
-0.3578644096851349,
0.1585509181022644,
-0.5024627447128296,
0.3066837787628174,
-0.42994529008865356,
-0.09983404725790024,
-0.4216364026069641,
-0.42818453907966614,
0.8428788781166077,
-0.054212458431720734,
-0.023928910493850708,
0.498025506734848,
0.25223296880722046,
-0.10635551065206528,
0.6907353401184082,
0.30676043033599854,
0.20543678104877472,
0.4170936048030853,
-0.06515544652938843,
0.24019461870193481,
-0.4521219730377197,
-0.5766098499298096,
-0.9039051532745361,
-0.06716164201498032,
-1.1108652353286743,
-0.719757616519928,
0.2582951486110687,
-0.08222343027591705,
-0.032306820154190063,
0.4940931797027588,
0.18816028535366058,
0.5263774991035461,
0.39024773240089417,
-0.39019134640693665,
0.11037851870059967,
-0.211099773645401,
-0.6435497403144836,
-0.3799075782299042,
-0.6419677138328552,
-0.13762450218200684,
0.7833392024040222,
-0.41371098160743713,
0.6204739212989807,
0.16041484475135803,
0.7465420961380005,
0.387020081281662,
-0.19074557721614838,
-0.5832460522651672,
0.6497008800506592,
-0.44261103868484497,
-0.43184128403663635,
0.09056362509727478,
-0.09939473122358322,
-1.3523536920547485,
0.19073085486888885,
-0.19865258038043976,
-0.7201864719390869,
0.8698268532752991,
-0.02683580107986927,
0.23899058997631073,
0.01499467995017767,
-0.7605987787246704,
0.5599817037582397,
-0.3127535879611969,
0.030225424095988274,
0.10312377661466599,
-0.7764754295349121,
-0.13256393373012543,
-0.214997798204422,
0.48661428689956665,
-0.04368950054049492,
-0.36797550320625305,
0.30016764998435974,
-0.4748755395412445,
0.7793035507202148,
0.1280236393213272,
0.2584516704082489,
0.5999606251716614,
0.3170913755893707,
0.1514107584953308,
0.09676498919725418,
0.1654125452041626,
0.2892114520072937,
0.09184864163398743,
-0.5627482533454895,
-0.7286948561668396,
0.5091166496276855,
-0.7257315516471863,
-0.713064968585968,
-0.6758781671524048,
-0.37134605646133423,
-0.3934081792831421,
0.055410221219062805,
0.5898159742355347,
0.6293410658836365,
-0.009614716283977032,
-0.14166179299354553,
0.2920840382575989,
-0.17717842757701874,
0.5678389668464661,
0.3392331302165985,
-0.4341169595718384,
-0.32805827260017395,
0.7289088368415833,
0.41404104232788086,
0.1585931032896042,
0.6802304983139038,
-0.13319747149944305,
-0.5558418035507202,
-0.5941123962402344,
0.12676358222961426,
0.5705276131629944,
-0.48867928981781006,
-0.10891985893249512,
-0.492281049489975,
-0.275359183549881,
-0.601548433303833,
-0.3518722653388977,
-0.2935982644557953,
-0.8237020969390869,
-0.022564630955457687,
0.07713958621025085,
-0.08597457408905029,
0.12447916716337204,
0.07921063154935837,
0.20028620958328247,
-0.45870068669319153,
-0.07684238255023956,
0.046711407601833344,
0.013727840967476368,
-0.443390429019928,
-0.1836804449558258,
0.15395903587341309,
-0.45252376794815063,
0.2243758589029312,
-1.0206032991409302,
0.46408310532569885,
0.18734319508075714,
0.564455509185791,
0.10299389809370041,
-0.010160106234252453,
0.8488714098930359,
-0.5252025127410889,
0.6450834274291992,
-0.049035754054784775,
-1.0853707790374756,
0.5492579936981201,
-0.6451258063316345,
0.5705106854438782,
0.47130173444747925,
0.31259727478027344,
-0.7102636098861694,
-1.1213257312774658,
-0.8425920009613037,
-1.0542163848876953,
0.21598570048809052,
0.3806048035621643,
-0.3124818801879883,
-0.7192788124084473,
0.41557204723358154,
0.22628165781497955,
0.1560024917125702,
-0.6780193448066711,
-0.4458806812763214,
-0.22294408082962036,
-0.010303777642548084,
-0.27352994680404663,
-0.08709506690502167,
0.08430711179971695,
-0.03708011656999588,
0.19148239493370056,
-0.06190069019794464,
0.43404409289360046,
0.3950902819633484,
-0.46900859475135803,
0.3276374638080597,
0.47553160786628723,
0.7300480008125305,
0.8203874230384827,
-0.20154333114624023,
0.6260082125663757,
-0.30654215812683105,
-0.18131375312805176,
0.2053976207971573,
0.15714998543262482,
-0.2862783968448639,
0.3057515025138855,
0.6560385227203369,
0.3463396430015564,
0.3160471022129059,
-0.4588891863822937,
0.09822933375835419,
-0.06219000369310379,
0.04515539109706879,
-0.46048209071159363,
-0.0858326405286789,
0.1577194780111313,
0.21723558008670807,
0.2965734601020813,
-0.005024667363613844,
0.1228535920381546,
-0.811489999294281,
-0.0176372267305851,
0.20732726156711578,
-0.2590100169181824,
-0.4794248044490814,
0.5353106260299683,
-0.10282181203365326,
-0.6142309904098511,
0.3458036482334137,
-0.05411572381854057,
-0.6948535442352295,
0.7748322486877441,
0.7378655672073364,
0.7064489126205444,
0.011327220126986504,
0.2986355721950531,
0.1335824877023697,
0.6533815860748291,
0.2751918435096741,
0.7497498989105225,
0.052289366722106934,
-0.452432245016098,
-0.19682955741882324,
-0.3850921094417572,
-0.13680322468280792,
-0.1610097438097,
-0.6282548904418945,
0.333089143037796,
-0.41981732845306396,
-0.629667341709137,
-0.023139581084251404,
-0.24632136523723602,
-0.593389630317688,
0.1426153928041458,
-0.18445616960525513,
0.6961947083473206,
-0.9551770687103271,
0.6216573119163513,
0.6418514251708984,
-0.3882247507572174,
-0.15517190098762512,
0.3931521475315094,
0.013986022211611271,
-0.7588856816291809,
0.7414509057998657,
-0.422055721282959,
-0.33714619278907776,
-0.3649946451187134,
-0.1917586475610733,
-1.1178141832351685,
0.5894690752029419,
0.30620914697647095,
-0.27585238218307495,
0.13718336820602417,
0.5695652365684509,
0.9683884382247925,
-0.6263159513473511,
0.22202937304973602,
0.6789506077766418,
0.28642359375953674,
-0.08155287802219391,
-0.8761435151100159,
-0.13223086297512054,
-0.1527225375175476,
0.01149885356426239,
0.7592888474464417,
-0.7911381721496582,
0.7942397594451904,
0.031247945502400398,
-0.3445693254470825,
-0.18039633333683014,
0.7732933759689331,
0.1634681075811386,
-0.027895482257008553,
0.7200208902359009,
0.19493098556995392,
0.4797948896884918,
-0.34265613555908203,
0.9848097562789917,
-0.4180034399032593,
-0.00792254414409399,
1.1991760730743408,
0.011913339607417583,
0.5380673408508301,
0.701494574546814,
-0.25359442830085754,
0.5772930383682251,
1.0156668424606323,
0.454776406288147,
0.6079477071762085,
0.262882262468338,
-0.10202467441558838,
-0.4000464677810669,
-0.3601134419441223,
-0.26226606965065,
0.5782363414764404,
0.5184723734855652,
-0.1355607807636261,
-0.2553595006465912,
-0.45813849568367004,
0.05635812506079674,
-0.09675461798906326,
-0.20798802375793457,
0.3295845687389374,
0.017405984923243523,
-1.201219916343689,
0.5102135539054871,
0.004222394898533821,
0.112298883497715,
-0.4815485179424286,
0.3573090732097626,
-0.9061117768287659,
-0.31710249185562134,
-0.033992599695920944,
-0.4905047118663788,
0.4610036611557007,
0.054809097200632095,
0.0724644660949707,
-0.04654427617788315,
0.1623816341161728,
-0.5798066854476929,
-0.5476709604263306,
0.5545467734336853,
0.691340446472168,
0.10742150992155075,
0.5046749114990234,
-0.44297319650650024,
-0.13631296157836914,
-0.2311973124742508,
0.49323588609695435,
0.2277989685535431,
0.6285784840583801,
-0.7387945055961609,
0.6587917804718018,
0.22085101902484894,
0.2919602692127228,
0.6106027364730835,
0.45847102999687195,
0.3865349292755127,
-0.5412991642951965,
-0.45608240365982056,
-0.5589125752449036,
0.15398338437080383,
0.13377195596694946,
-0.47373953461647034,
0.4003492295742035,
0.6884928345680237,
0.774160623550415,
0.019231978803873062,
0.2029627412557602,
0.04277167469263077,
-0.039264976978302,
-0.642305850982666,
0.1814897209405899,
-0.8181764483451843,
0.14140585064888,
-0.10082346200942993,
-1.0135509967803955,
-0.526891827583313,
0.09201332926750183,
-0.19039928913116455,
-0.24502281844615936,
1.457406759262085,
0.3441798985004425,
-0.09317608922719955,
-0.20971733331680298,
0.21860545873641968,
-0.17303737998008728,
0.29716500639915466,
0.19301210343837738,
0.5891890525817871,
0.04334909841418266,
0.5936984419822693,
-0.20064225792884827,
-0.11057797074317932,
0.052831754088401794,
-0.6993414759635925,
-0.7471622228622437,
-0.8928475379943848,
-0.5266131162643433,
-0.3623161017894745,
0.24292290210723877,
1.0465620756149292,
0.35597601532936096,
-0.5669898390769958,
-0.57731032371521,
-0.17597293853759766,
0.24808548390865326,
-0.33895501494407654,
-0.13446883857250214,
0.37216609716415405,
-0.56227707862854,
-1.0041170120239258,
0.37809282541275024,
0.5985866189002991,
0.4314311146736145,
-0.15462304651737213,
0.6400405764579773,
-0.22314178943634033,
0.5016713738441467,
0.22189024090766907,
0.4545670449733734,
-0.7677063941955566,
-0.24346928298473358,
0.24460141360759735,
-0.08496527373790741,
0.2808927595615387,
1.3142749071121216,
-0.7479132413864136,
0.32981565594673157,
0.47199347615242004,
0.2420693337917328,
0.5274190306663513,
-0.3642270565032959,
0.7431998252868652,
-0.8656454682350159,
0.7010650038719177,
0.1881396323442459,
0.8859943151473999,
0.2383228987455368,
-0.0020267846994102,
0.5959534049034119,
0.5214238166809082,
-0.2565564513206482,
-0.42315950989723206,
0.6526398062705994,
-1.1681087017059326,
-0.1791488081216812,
1.107541561126709,
-0.25997453927993774,
-0.40488874912261963,
-0.5679681897163391,
0.22552761435508728,
0.1859114021062851,
-0.02896478958427906,
1.0533138513565063,
0.7115949392318726,
-0.05752139165997505,
0.11985445767641068,
-0.024460444226861,
0.45643091201782227,
0.44147542119026184,
-0.9994435906410217,
-0.3192217946052551,
0.24563176929950714,
0.038357581943273544,
0.2873592972755432,
0.6940051913261414,
-0.46993371844291687,
0.11351082473993301,
-0.02154153399169445,
-0.4280715584754944,
0.48151063919067383,
-0.5103219151496887,
0.26330873370170593,
0.18112865090370178,
-0.0670478492975235,
-0.1948861926794052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18255v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18255v5
|
PatentGPT: A Large Language Model for Intellectual Property
| 2024-04-28T17:36:43 | 2024-06-05T03:02:48 |
Zilong Bai, Ruiji Zhang, Linqing Chen, Qijun Cai, Yuan Zhong, Cong Wang, Yan Fang, Jie Fang, Jing Sun, Weikuan Wang, Lizhi Zhou, Haoran Hua, Tian Qiu, Chaochao Wang, Cheng Sun, Jianping Lu, Yixin Wang, Yubin Xia, Meng Hu, Haowen Liu, Peng Xu, Licong Xu, Fu Bian, Xiaolong Gu, Lisha Zhang, Weilei Wang, Changyang Tu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
In recent years, large language models(LLMs) have attracted significant
attention due to their exceptional performance across a multitude of natural
language process tasks, and have been widely applied in various fields.
However, the application of large language models in the Intellectual Property
(IP) domain is challenging due to the strong need for specialized knowledge,
privacy protection, processing of extremely long text in this field. In this
technical report, we present for the first time a low-cost, standardized
procedure for training IP-oriented LLMs, meeting the unique requirements of the
IP domain. Using this standard process, we have trained the PatentGPT series
models based on open-source pretrained models. By evaluating them on the
open-source IP-oriented benchmark MOZIP, our domain-specific LLMs outperforms
GPT-4, indicating the effectiveness of the proposed training procedure and the
expertise of the PatentGPT models in the IP domain. Remarkably, our model
surpassed GPT-4 on the 2019 China Patent Agent Qualification Examination,
scoring 65 and matching human expert levels. Additionally, the PatentGPT model,
which utilizes the SMoE architecture, achieves performance comparable to that
of GPT-4 in the IP domain and demonstrates a better cost-performance ratio on
long-text tasks, potentially serving as an alternative to GPT-4 within the IP
domain.
|
[
-0.21457307040691376,
-0.3036409318447113,
0.4438643455505371,
0.24036094546318054,
-0.5503667593002319,
-0.01222977228462696,
-0.19884619116783142,
-0.582734227180481,
-0.16621464490890503,
0.6752169132232666,
-0.038818664848804474,
-0.5440618991851807,
-0.8308780789375305,
-0.08106077462434769,
-0.009790952317416668,
0.9920180439949036,
-0.2972676455974579,
0.11655887216329575,
0.13662944734096527,
0.0209958516061306,
-0.09982851147651672,
-0.7552662491798401,
-0.45076051354408264,
-0.5772063136100769,
0.24575185775756836,
0.06466737389564514,
0.17396236956119537,
0.5786940455436707,
0.7313969135284424,
0.10931998491287231,
-0.11682455986738205,
-0.14987872540950775,
-0.25569868087768555,
-0.3319172263145447,
-0.47972917556762695,
-0.1830906867980957,
-0.7241939902305603,
0.42062705755233765,
0.5122634768486023,
0.3748801350593567,
-0.20560143887996674,
0.19691243767738342,
0.002596974838525057,
0.4533393085002899,
-0.2897302806377411,
0.3481590449810028,
-0.9429070353507996,
0.08243884891271591,
-0.29558947682380676,
-0.21787625551223755,
-0.557063639163971,
0.012141644023358822,
0.41512420773506165,
-0.3754718601703644,
0.27215492725372314,
0.17860598862171173,
0.857593297958374,
-0.024535901844501495,
-0.31345704197883606,
-0.046324536204338074,
-0.28915074467658997,
0.6455070972442627,
-0.8171390891075134,
0.1787450909614563,
0.06984096765518188,
0.13467660546302795,
-0.07390408217906952,
-1.1429691314697266,
-0.6078224182128906,
-0.8279638290405273,
0.3571796715259552,
-0.11314357817173004,
0.067707858979702,
0.18918904662132263,
0.39090681076049805,
0.17613527178764343,
-0.6533687710762024,
0.32801640033721924,
-0.46419620513916016,
0.01615019701421261,
0.394189715385437,
-0.26393067836761475,
0.31604185700416565,
0.10229750722646713,
-0.7627260684967041,
0.2623053193092346,
-1.1893295049667358,
-0.16883939504623413,
0.2728997468948364,
0.2993987798690796,
0.08957595378160477,
0.63090980052948,
-0.30708667635917664,
0.42095449566841125,
-0.1388532817363739,
-0.1298145353794098,
0.1522122025489807,
0.1084614098072052,
-0.21958591043949127,
0.0524914525449276,
0.6943753361701965,
0.07789136469364166,
0.28951460123062134,
-0.19909287989139557,
-0.3626817464828491,
-0.420552521944046,
0.003165839472785592,
-1.2607388496398926,
-0.426247239112854,
-0.05896880850195885,
-0.36845099925994873,
-0.15383678674697876,
-0.048808496445417404,
-0.4007595479488373,
-0.4982658922672272,
-0.3658248484134674,
0.5991576313972473,
-0.37463080883026123,
-0.1557949185371399,
0.2610553503036499,
-0.10500024259090424,
0.41773849725723267,
0.2575380504131317,
-0.9697050452232361,
0.3668272793292999,
0.9441263675689697,
0.9035505652427673,
-0.3618781268596649,
-0.6485840678215027,
-0.46909528970718384,
0.3009836673736572,
0.0010472586145624518,
0.7690228223800659,
-0.40363389253616333,
-0.20988152921199799,
-0.33389097452163696,
-0.1076597049832344,
-0.22278979420661926,
-0.5831742882728577,
0.6232593059539795,
-0.8417651653289795,
0.023349469527602196,
0.1091931164264679,
-0.5983936786651611,
0.08924387395381927,
0.5631702542304993,
-0.4670407474040985,
0.3597162961959839,
-0.11371912062168121,
-0.8854844570159912,
0.4363206923007965,
-0.9778792858123779,
-0.2917759418487549,
0.3968246877193451,
-0.04920192062854767,
-0.5110934376716614,
-0.4141963720321655,
0.1757846176624298,
0.5622540712356567,
-0.7005837559700012,
0.24377547204494476,
-0.17549340426921844,
-0.405025452375412,
0.007674945052713156,
-0.2553206980228424,
0.8707932829856873,
0.08625752478837967,
-0.5407519340515137,
0.033211421221494675,
-0.7080793976783752,
0.07091398537158966,
0.2297242432832718,
-0.3346062898635864,
-0.09244640916585922,
-0.25878384709358215,
-0.47680091857910156,
0.1468762755393982,
0.6212961673736572,
-0.733227014541626,
0.360212117433548,
-0.30384576320648193,
0.7053282260894775,
0.8745241165161133,
-0.04420770704746246,
0.3201994299888611,
0.002316196681931615,
0.5693743228912354,
-0.10392065346240997,
0.11909137666225433,
-0.2411092072725296,
-0.7057821750640869,
-0.5649378299713135,
-0.6070895195007324,
0.5930561423301697,
0.48824331164360046,
-0.518297016620636,
0.3064751625061035,
-0.4479389786720276,
-0.5920385122299194,
-0.18745186924934387,
0.020378626883029938,
0.34112870693206787,
0.3690686821937561,
0.12957763671875,
-0.46780750155448914,
-0.05931617319583893,
-0.7142212390899658,
-0.24722562730312347,
-0.12280583381652832,
-0.04170561209321022,
0.29211902618408203,
0.6993025541305542,
-0.09618520736694336,
0.6750006675720215,
-0.5415342450141907,
-0.3444543778896332,
-0.20121482014656067,
0.7246695756912231,
0.29814690351486206,
0.3151761293411255,
0.37742483615875244,
-0.5392811298370361,
-0.8842313289642334,
0.38913431763648987,
-0.3423845171928406,
-0.24507015943527222,
0.36571961641311646,
0.14036864042282104,
0.1594102680683136,
0.23970730602741241,
-0.9245173335075378,
0.28211089968681335,
0.46429741382598877,
-0.03522223234176636,
0.8205887079238892,
-0.3162405788898468,
0.052500657737255096,
-0.7335509061813354,
0.3238593637943268,
-0.06384207308292389,
-0.08228090405464172,
-0.4420740604400635,
0.285517156124115,
0.1530018448829651,
-0.6733347773551941,
-0.6887137293815613,
0.7503308653831482,
-0.5629642009735107,
0.033274754881858826,
-0.38190051913261414,
-0.08084588497877121,
-0.03202594816684723,
0.4638727009296417,
0.15222400426864624,
1.1538641452789307,
0.5821393728256226,
-0.3271118402481079,
0.5642532110214233,
-0.05373246967792511,
-0.4219874143600464,
0.4295539855957031,
-0.7302977442741394,
0.5685310363769531,
0.08301583677530289,
0.019902881234884262,
-0.2669403553009033,
-0.11424059420824051,
0.22234953939914703,
-0.10271838307380676,
0.4150807559490204,
-0.5537219047546387,
-0.6755362749099731,
-0.38425412774086,
-0.14500591158866882,
0.08148504793643951,
0.6079080104827881,
-0.7563897371292114,
0.32944735884666443,
0.2844531834125519,
-0.5324066877365112,
-0.7809609770774841,
-0.35884353518486023,
0.1927100419998169,
-0.2881467342376709,
-0.7745511531829834,
0.5172927975654602,
0.032682351768016815,
0.13338454067707062,
-0.0320078581571579,
0.10265429317951202,
-0.6108877658843994,
-0.21574711799621582,
-0.02222619764506817,
0.012365831062197685,
-0.3678862452507019,
-0.009192675352096558,
-0.3863055109977722,
-0.2096337080001831,
-0.07295967638492584,
-0.7449758052825928,
0.5240728855133057,
-0.15300112962722778,
-0.4737298786640167,
-0.39071789383888245,
0.1733279526233673,
0.48474830389022827,
-0.5159261226654053,
0.6771585941314697,
0.1241135448217392,
-0.19083383679389954,
-0.6480515599250793,
-0.3289566934108734,
0.09129002690315247,
-0.4697684049606323,
0.3861800730228424,
-0.6081777215003967,
-1.0147428512573242,
0.34060850739479065,
-0.3478754758834839,
-0.21849308907985687,
0.25694340467453003,
0.49758201837539673,
0.3740018904209137,
0.6098743081092834,
0.8397958278656006,
-0.3764131963253021,
0.28876766562461853,
-0.07433608174324036,
0.8811885714530945,
-0.49509918689727783,
-0.05032780021429062,
-0.45955562591552734,
0.15099018812179565,
-0.22510486841201782,
-0.4433060884475708,
0.29895785450935364,
0.11872857064008713,
-0.5246257185935974,
0.42917147278785706,
-0.5691166520118713,
0.8140091896057129,
0.8199869990348816,
0.019702909514307976,
0.4370954930782318,
0.10323044657707214,
-0.0913560763001442,
-0.016864173114299774,
-0.3979140520095825,
-0.854236900806427,
1.21730375289917,
0.5650589466094971,
0.8543994426727295,
-0.1298515945672989,
0.6857260465621948,
0.20850719511508942,
0.5328431129455566,
-0.7048330307006836,
0.7129344344139099,
-0.3860568106174469,
-0.5168684720993042,
-0.40760764479637146,
-0.3020181655883789,
-0.5187892913818359,
0.14016622304916382,
0.4975945055484772,
-0.7922412157058716,
-0.0772268995642662,
0.1468019038438797,
-0.09662413597106934,
0.48224204778671265,
-0.7738824486732483,
1.032961130142212,
-0.46914079785346985,
-0.2681812047958374,
-0.1278686821460724,
-0.41608306765556335,
0.4836794435977936,
-0.4892818033695221,
-0.4350653290748596,
-0.3215446174144745,
0.05835999920964241,
0.5979558825492859,
-0.4074111878871918,
0.6673229336738586,
-0.3625062108039856,
0.036647021770477295,
0.37736865878105164,
-0.2860133945941925,
0.8328610062599182,
-0.23694470524787903,
-0.3100537359714508,
0.28715652227401733,
-0.27275514602661133,
-0.20322778820991516,
-0.2568073570728302,
0.6442968249320984,
-0.6108673810958862,
-0.7489714026451111,
-0.6043307781219482,
-0.30368614196777344,
-0.03290042281150818,
0.585242509841919,
0.29170310497283936,
-0.05100555717945099,
-0.36279210448265076,
0.0030698797199875116,
0.7554358243942261,
-0.3478669226169586,
0.10645865648984909,
0.7116414308547974,
0.2336290180683136,
-0.21925023198127747,
0.9369614124298096,
0.20546318590641022,
0.21380314230918884,
0.4233361482620239,
0.12710872292518616,
-0.24471038579940796,
-0.9682467579841614,
-0.21135684847831726,
0.3358989953994751,
-0.7947031855583191,
-0.16953253746032715,
-0.6338807940483093,
-0.6591448187828064,
-0.44255441427230835,
0.19210025668144226,
-0.3062626123428345,
-0.36573517322540283,
-0.1634567677974701,
-0.08089357614517212,
0.13598139584064484,
0.5446009635925293,
0.19067098200321198,
0.45041757822036743,
-0.6473149657249451,
0.3343254029750824,
0.6951367855072021,
0.7199227213859558,
-0.22566816210746765,
-0.6669960021972656,
-0.2412714660167694,
-0.19805531203746796,
-0.6129031181335449,
-0.28001272678375244,
0.4805874228477478,
0.29676756262779236,
0.5652883052825928,
0.20615965127944946,
0.009637034498155117,
0.2200428694486618,
-1.1110600233078003,
0.9250310063362122,
0.23145335912704468,
-1.002105712890625,
0.3531048595905304,
-0.5063813924789429,
-0.2150757759809494,
0.12146414816379547,
0.3473958969116211,
-0.1882745921611786,
0.02732010744512081,
-0.5224621891975403,
-0.850775957107544,
0.6624955534934998,
-0.07373252511024475,
0.3082314133644104,
0.23599283397197723,
0.3961518704891205,
0.17855501174926758,
0.4357697069644928,
-1.2749112844467163,
0.2730584740638733,
-0.03138290345668793,
0.030230794101953506,
0.39512118697166443,
-0.3477316200733185,
-0.18700097501277924,
0.09894860535860062,
0.947730302810669,
-0.06491188704967499,
0.4404820203781128,
-0.15696696937084198,
-0.08252480626106262,
0.2366490364074707,
0.5065818428993225,
0.6024682521820068,
0.871666431427002,
-0.32205942273139954,
0.08702197670936584,
-0.18963316082954407,
-0.4927760362625122,
0.2545233964920044,
0.5998415350914001,
-0.09551394730806351,
-0.2230803668498993,
0.023683859035372734,
0.7256925702095032,
-0.4649306535720825,
-0.7221552133560181,
0.9944946765899658,
0.27836328744888306,
-0.40138494968414307,
-0.25168153643608093,
0.006469291169196367,
-0.041526734828948975,
0.32356134057044983,
0.18801799416542053,
-0.33667290210723877,
0.06578244268894196,
-0.29867470264434814,
0.32020342350006104,
0.35280641913414,
-0.07879754900932312,
-0.2782392203807831,
0.7651179432868958,
0.3623374402523041,
-0.15779219567775726,
0.47700247168540955,
-0.36058443784713745,
-0.6941580772399902,
0.5944179892539978,
0.6642855405807495,
1.0173674821853638,
-0.030960427597165108,
0.1755446195602417,
-0.10718752443790436,
0.4151194393634796,
-0.31723156571388245,
0.1143655925989151,
0.2015896886587143,
-0.5773308277130127,
-0.49568435549736023,
-0.40506210923194885,
-0.8177840113639832,
0.46410423517227173,
0.07560502737760544,
0.48921653628349304,
-0.8202918767929077,
-0.09047583490610123,
-0.1097937822341919,
-0.07183629274368286,
-0.5679153800010681,
0.07195402681827545,
0.05660787597298622,
1.1111310720443726,
-0.583519697189331,
1.2048274278640747,
0.5031034350395203,
-0.39950528740882874,
-0.6842354536056519,
0.11261887103319168,
-0.45575857162475586,
-0.8335514664649963,
1.2197108268737793,
0.2398233711719513,
-0.04127970710396767,
0.14604085683822632,
-0.8644391298294067,
-0.5535223484039307,
0.9625659584999084,
0.6406834721565247,
-0.40946629643440247,
0.08304747194051743,
0.46811044216156006,
0.5251525044441223,
-0.4537215828895569,
-0.36668214201927185,
0.4126814305782318,
0.18687400221824646,
-0.08594579249620438,
-1.1483664512634277,
-0.163993701338768,
-0.2036523073911667,
-0.1542455106973648,
0.09965918958187103,
-0.6895584464073181,
0.938755452632904,
-0.08951300382614136,
-0.01037088967859745,
0.3465299904346466,
0.4233287572860718,
0.5404808521270752,
0.33625996112823486,
0.14218538999557495,
0.633102297782898,
0.7385377287864685,
-0.10252745449542999,
0.8653519153594971,
-0.5145265460014343,
0.30898869037628174,
1.2066073417663574,
-0.8370224833488464,
0.898029088973999,
0.2835732400417328,
-0.1067327931523323,
0.024082444608211517,
0.36686569452285767,
-0.19653122127056122,
0.7461533546447754,
0.562525749206543,
-0.6572500467300415,
0.21841639280319214,
-0.1607273370027542,
-0.3737899661064148,
0.004340573213994503,
0.15981155633926392,
-0.5475051999092102,
0.0368950180709362,
-0.036944761872291565,
-0.03620778024196625,
-0.23047079145908356,
-0.2220941036939621,
0.5065099000930786,
0.41019514203071594,
-0.37813639640808105,
0.34434738755226135,
0.40487003326416016,
0.6423379182815552,
-0.6466458439826965,
0.02657642774283886,
-0.03722298890352249,
0.19187943637371063,
0.19937334954738617,
-0.6695629358291626,
-0.23668736219406128,
0.3836648762226105,
-0.14409410953521729,
-0.36210277676582336,
0.6578347682952881,
-0.2414344996213913,
-0.13860559463500977,
0.19194835424423218,
0.030971599742770195,
0.31150659918785095,
-0.39633968472480774,
-0.6269338130950928,
-0.3367849886417389,
-0.19819526374340057,
-0.24568159878253937,
0.23612700402736664,
0.808444082736969,
-0.09294256567955017,
0.6641857624053955,
0.4718921482563019,
0.4620855152606964,
0.41943857073783875,
0.23313675820827484,
0.8441858887672424,
-0.6038097739219666,
-0.5373224020004272,
-0.46767038106918335,
0.4783381223678589,
-0.2688947319984436,
-0.16869378089904785,
0.31493011116981506,
0.37408825755119324,
0.7241251468658447,
-0.3386661112308502,
1.1047914028167725,
0.09547840803861618,
0.5767407417297363,
-0.5874441862106323,
0.7806452512741089,
-0.04684235900640488,
0.46844276785850525,
0.10352619737386703,
-1.061408281326294,
-0.4350889325141907,
0.4734485447406769,
-0.5457440614700317,
-0.0772705227136612,
0.7358138561248779,
0.6897289752960205,
-0.2813647985458374,
-0.19016389548778534,
0.3341843783855438,
0.05795024335384369,
0.7588688135147095,
0.4871199429035187,
0.7957165837287903,
-0.28022125363349915,
0.41124188899993896,
-0.1987258791923523,
-0.3047134280204773,
-0.009233180433511734,
-1.2564854621887207,
-0.9974367618560791,
-0.0509539432823658,
-0.32378265261650085,
0.11348928511142731,
0.22510845959186554,
0.9060980677604675,
0.6962612867355347,
-0.7136480808258057,
-0.12705841660499573,
-0.06753659248352051,
-0.30812403559684753,
0.12575015425682068,
-0.1583067625761032,
0.5673189163208008,
-0.23015287518501282,
-0.6567263603210449,
0.2980545461177826,
0.5385173559188843,
0.2809576988220215,
-0.07724744826555252,
-0.058553650975227356,
0.19604913890361786,
-0.015138044953346252,
0.5989668965339661,
0.40910571813583374,
-0.6695352792739868,
-0.22554680705070496,
-0.10754185169935226,
-0.20515325665473938,
0.21304649114608765,
1.000266432762146,
-0.1841583251953125,
0.44774961471557617,
0.5345349907875061,
0.7462509870529175,
0.6319348812103271,
-0.18278712034225464,
0.7052919268608093,
-0.6881983876228333,
0.4995758831501007,
0.3756934404373169,
0.4866619110107422,
0.2560054063796997,
-0.32330942153930664,
0.563271164894104,
0.21394170820713043,
-0.8273654580116272,
-0.6604435443878174,
0.24561558663845062,
-0.883026659488678,
-0.0854133889079094,
0.9006779193878174,
-0.6975457072257996,
0.030164023861289024,
0.05918516591191292,
-0.32007983326911926,
-0.09508057683706284,
-0.3276447653770447,
0.8010731935501099,
0.7494561076164246,
-0.0006992220878601074,
-0.40827199816703796,
-0.5130459666252136,
0.2687213718891144,
-0.031976744532585144,
-0.8176380395889282,
0.09901466220617294,
0.1136925220489502,
0.37728193402290344,
-0.054612670093774796,
0.8865962028503418,
-0.4046041965484619,
0.07403488457202911,
-0.1138974130153656,
0.3996664881706238,
-0.19086185097694397,
-0.43930381536483765,
-0.2326480746269226,
0.38784468173980713,
0.7106621265411377,
-0.14959579706192017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01586v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01586v1
|
Transfer Learning and Transformer Architecture for Financial Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-04-28T17:15:07 | 2024-04-28T17:15:07 |
Tohida Rehman, Raghubir Bose, Samiran Chattopadhyay, Debarshi Kumar Sanyal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Financial sentiment analysis allows financial institutions like Banks and
Insurance Companies to better manage the credit scoring of their customers in a
better way. Financial domain uses specialized mechanisms which makes sentiment
analysis difficult. In this paper, we propose a pre-trained language model
which can help to solve this problem with fewer labelled data. We extend on the
principles of Transfer learning and Transformation architecture principles and
also take into consideration recent outbreak of pandemics like COVID. We apply
the sentiment analysis to two different sets of data. We also take smaller
training set and fine tune the same as part of the model.
|
[
-0.40378108620643616,
-0.5098362565040588,
-0.05561927706003189,
0.28635555505752563,
-0.198023721575737,
0.21531502902507782,
0.06410041451454163,
-0.6198564767837524,
0.07797487825155258,
0.5875992774963379,
-0.5025031566619873,
-0.4433840811252594,
-0.7422530055046082,
-0.25520995259284973,
-0.3069893419742584,
1.5597350597381592,
0.18219169974327087,
0.2419363260269165,
-0.11141041666269302,
-0.04335334151983261,
-0.005898119881749153,
-0.6793030500411987,
-1.005368709564209,
-0.4511491358280182,
0.08574593812227249,
0.3412119746208191,
0.7496469020843506,
-0.19117191433906555,
1.0822850465774536,
0.21992802619934082,
0.24798333644866943,
-0.29555544257164,
-0.48005378246307373,
-0.42402660846710205,
-0.2153247892856598,
-0.4800908863544464,
-0.7379913330078125,
0.17741648852825165,
0.02584121748805046,
0.6093019247055054,
-0.04209079593420029,
0.38418588042259216,
0.19090844690799713,
0.7896994948387146,
-0.39723140001296997,
0.4727742373943329,
-0.1412392556667328,
0.15750931203365326,
0.07263461500406265,
-0.13908755779266357,
-0.647308349609375,
-0.41636747121810913,
0.829038679599762,
-0.37829896807670593,
0.11068882048130035,
-0.032425958663225174,
0.9089527726173401,
0.1851179599761963,
-0.49259403347969055,
-0.2630104422569275,
-0.9407572746276855,
0.7213560342788696,
-0.33744868636131287,
0.128225639462471,
0.25222650170326233,
0.534177303314209,
0.449825257062912,
-0.7506945729255676,
-0.1619870513677597,
-0.010642890818417072,
-0.10317053645849228,
0.29342079162597656,
-0.4082561731338501,
-0.23948468267917633,
-0.2731720507144928,
0.2789100706577301,
-0.3139827251434326,
-0.022212915122509003,
-0.6489912867546082,
-0.2567715048789978,
0.836928129196167,
0.0939670205116272,
0.08523795753717422,
-0.14548484981060028,
-0.6894930005073547,
-0.6754087209701538,
-0.4756518602371216,
0.3200787305831909,
0.22203262150287628,
0.24023619294166565,
-0.37430381774902344,
-0.1714971512556076,
0.2825640141963959,
0.45975613594055176,
0.10886340588331223,
-0.21384075284004211,
0.40596482157707214,
-0.05459322780370712,
-0.4594307541847229,
0.22033390402793884,
0.624578595161438,
0.21509188413619995,
0.2501319348812103,
0.10617341846227646,
-0.2564881145954132,
0.10399531573057175,
0.5953071117401123,
-0.5449599027633667,
-0.37144750356674194,
-0.07852315902709961,
-0.7183399200439453,
-0.5861135125160217,
0.24815353751182556,
-1.050864577293396,
-0.23121115565299988,
-0.3867548108100891,
0.3000349998474121,
-0.42164942622184753,
-0.308633953332901,
0.271791934967041,
-0.20792756974697113,
0.7405206561088562,
0.20084498822689056,
-0.5805267095565796,
0.7239394783973694,
0.7545163035392761,
0.4483395218849182,
-0.1351989209651947,
0.1670147329568863,
-0.5654428005218506,
-0.081352099776268,
0.00809136126190424,
0.9263309240341187,
-0.7157809138298035,
-0.4433014988899231,
-0.047367170453071594,
-0.3219713866710663,
-0.12874223291873932,
-0.2601277232170105,
0.4331294000148773,
-0.6478819251060486,
0.37838050723075867,
0.0032062693499028683,
-0.35049042105674744,
-0.5042895674705505,
0.2005004733800888,
-0.6489526629447937,
0.5936164855957031,
0.6601612567901611,
-0.7697438597679138,
0.22019100189208984,
-0.9793643951416016,
-0.6749253273010254,
-0.10775887966156006,
0.30013999342918396,
-0.6469034552574158,
0.080142542719841,
0.20520402491092682,
0.4267895817756653,
-0.38955071568489075,
0.15873612463474274,
-0.45794230699539185,
-0.009796049445867538,
0.3679339587688446,
-0.2127908170223236,
0.43442222476005554,
0.433061420917511,
-0.24686557054519653,
-0.054512444883584976,
-0.8076452612876892,
-0.3481476902961731,
-0.1782550811767578,
0.02348153665661812,
-0.6905978918075562,
-0.015032727271318436,
0.38844597339630127,
0.1524898111820221,
0.23182542622089386,
-0.2804160714149475,
0.25549831986427307,
-0.7129920721054077,
0.3944905400276184,
0.6310561299324036,
0.04342618212103844,
0.7997596859931946,
-0.32420873641967773,
0.823862612247467,
0.5545979738235474,
0.45545512437820435,
0.3781915605068207,
-0.12110918760299683,
-0.6937384605407715,
-0.2522715926170349,
0.13468290865421295,
0.9019354581832886,
-0.503217339515686,
0.23612332344055176,
-0.30364617705345154,
-0.5482147932052612,
-0.5670080184936523,
-0.022006312385201454,
0.07598084211349487,
0.584019660949707,
0.5304775238037109,
-0.12309277057647705,
-0.7417590022087097,
-0.8570894002914429,
-0.290877103805542,
0.020498929545283318,
0.3786500096321106,
-0.023199312388896942,
0.25834882259368896,
-0.40583446621894836,
0.8705577850341797,
-0.7058289051055908,
-0.39899998903274536,
-0.5255894660949707,
0.2854726016521454,
0.3168896734714508,
0.3784780204296112,
0.8899146318435669,
-0.9308745861053467,
-0.4697404205799103,
0.3475523889064789,
-0.4314568340778351,
0.20651139318943024,
-0.29190465807914734,
0.14992493391036987,
0.0012349613243713975,
0.45574599504470825,
-0.09684738516807556,
0.5114226937294006,
0.6282631158828735,
-0.28792545199394226,
0.17410463094711304,
0.003322206437587738,
-0.0948217436671257,
-1.574479103088379,
-0.011878560297191143,
0.33564284443855286,
-0.4341103732585907,
-0.818529486656189,
-0.1785973459482193,
-0.24090030789375305,
-0.19914139807224274,
-0.13601697981357574,
0.5493557453155518,
-0.09420038014650345,
0.051964420825242996,
-0.45499253273010254,
-0.11017509549856186,
0.1781093031167984,
0.25890761613845825,
-0.01894518919289112,
0.5448536276817322,
0.8725984692573547,
-0.531589686870575,
0.4543449282646179,
0.24029725790023804,
-0.39412960410118103,
0.6779460906982422,
-0.49957749247550964,
0.02037888951599598,
-0.037233639508485794,
0.06594493985176086,
-1.0479861497879028,
0.161835715174675,
0.4071423411369324,
-0.15358291566371918,
0.34370946884155273,
0.2124367505311966,
0.25438418984413147,
-0.49672627449035645,
-0.1627132147550583,
0.23205476999282837,
0.6867907047271729,
-0.4830501973628998,
0.806594967842102,
0.24648889899253845,
-0.34006914496421814,
-0.7638347744941711,
-0.7502903342247009,
-0.1774442493915558,
-0.590172529220581,
-0.5483051538467407,
0.41353678703308105,
0.18921715021133423,
-0.4859350323677063,
0.17095595598220825,
-0.0072491769678890705,
-0.17360691726207733,
0.20677338540554047,
0.14210030436515808,
0.5682761073112488,
-0.43903648853302,
0.2498006373643875,
-0.0070047639310359955,
-0.38882291316986084,
0.14437131583690643,
-0.26558223366737366,
0.4284982681274414,
-0.31238365173339844,
0.01263576652854681,
-0.5160897970199585,
0.2573603093624115,
0.623551607131958,
-0.2772546708583832,
0.8383566737174988,
0.3635539412498474,
-0.030584339052438736,
-0.1674320101737976,
-0.34005942940711975,
0.09123431146144867,
-0.527747392654419,
0.2670244872570038,
-0.40149059891700745,
-0.7697954177856445,
0.5318069458007812,
-0.25490275025367737,
-0.18990939855575562,
0.773709237575531,
0.5225794911384583,
0.017127223312854767,
0.49302300810813904,
1.1959574222564697,
-0.774140477180481,
0.7241463661193848,
-0.13283123075962067,
0.5502309203147888,
-0.2823624312877655,
-0.20718061923980713,
-0.5450042486190796,
-0.29513734579086304,
-0.38074004650115967,
-0.02640097588300705,
0.4375515878200531,
0.058373577892780304,
-0.07729765772819519,
0.4471883773803711,
-0.1992957592010498,
0.16627100110054016,
0.18503329157829285,
0.18559525907039642,
0.006595117039978504,
0.17282287776470184,
-0.04525279998779297,
0.27736184000968933,
-0.32106712460517883,
-0.38270577788352966,
0.8337755799293518,
0.6153232455253601,
1.0255355834960938,
-0.18788214027881622,
0.7135025262832642,
0.6755002737045288,
0.6219429969787598,
-0.6916520595550537,
0.13574257493019104,
-0.533484160900116,
-0.07067599892616272,
-0.12124486267566681,
-0.45019668340682983,
-0.6534393429756165,
-0.30463433265686035,
-0.21432781219482422,
-0.13373331725597382,
0.5248907208442688,
-0.05329420045018196,
-0.6206991672515869,
-0.06070088967680931,
-0.6829172372817993,
0.6495129466056824,
-0.019912194460630417,
0.21938706934452057,
-0.4430225193500519,
-0.44123589992523193,
0.37991800904273987,
-0.18808649480342865,
0.4737010598182678,
0.1589776873588562,
0.3688277304172516,
0.6493836641311646,
-0.4459336996078491,
1.1026098728179932,
-0.26411503553390503,
-0.20448023080825806,
0.4511939287185669,
-0.127592533826828,
0.42566248774528503,
0.046509504318237305,
-0.17607709765434265,
-0.0689966231584549,
0.18554946780204773,
-0.43049734830856323,
-0.6011170148849487,
0.41198965907096863,
-1.0892431735992432,
-0.4326513707637787,
-0.30005696415901184,
-0.4259357452392578,
-0.40308913588523865,
-0.36017748713493347,
0.21297989785671234,
0.10312309861183167,
-0.4858001172542572,
-0.032564304769039154,
0.46321049332618713,
-0.029489025473594666,
0.49283474683761597,
0.2778114080429077,
-0.09463855624198914,
-0.3460058271884918,
0.7422184348106384,
-0.14163020253181458,
0.0737893208861351,
0.4858134388923645,
0.5110798478126526,
-0.16046372056007385,
-0.06317489594221115,
0.08583623915910721,
0.02719896286725998,
-0.7616310119628906,
-0.4617438018321991,
-0.41328099370002747,
-0.3288710117340088,
-0.7799460887908936,
-0.28722304105758667,
-0.3527583181858063,
-0.22337067127227783,
-0.38273048400878906,
-0.47438129782676697,
0.7725492715835571,
0.711114764213562,
-0.11893564462661743,
0.6499249339103699,
-1.1981710195541382,
0.22520872950553894,
0.3050061762332916,
0.19247248768806458,
-0.10240860283374786,
-0.6203880310058594,
-0.23958368599414825,
-0.16826702654361725,
-0.05863172560930252,
-0.7285686135292053,
0.7257792353630066,
0.3737625777721405,
0.3577309846878052,
0.7988446950912476,
0.11692045629024506,
0.6251410841941833,
0.032964788377285004,
0.5082071423530579,
0.4236990511417389,
-1.2327513694763184,
0.6206091642379761,
0.20727460086345673,
-0.007895190268754959,
0.6473702192306519,
0.7353914976119995,
-0.554037868976593,
-0.2167077213525772,
-0.6972804665565491,
-0.41126275062561035,
0.6074342131614685,
-0.4186549186706543,
0.31688493490219116,
0.16426295042037964,
0.6000521779060364,
0.3793548047542572,
-0.11758618801832199,
-0.5995770692825317,
-0.16649308800697327,
-0.4815434217453003,
-0.4559089243412018,
-0.2410983443260193,
-0.34897440671920776,
-0.06092988699674606,
-0.5416646003723145,
0.5922207236289978,
-0.07866989076137543,
0.12483134120702744,
0.08360475301742554,
-0.017575152218341827,
-0.09459532797336578,
0.3086894452571869,
0.54795902967453,
0.47660180926322937,
0.07953751087188721,
-0.0722346231341362,
0.051091019064188004,
-0.5036733150482178,
0.1380809098482132,
-0.08096393942832947,
0.19876879453659058,
-0.22501444816589355,
0.5105727910995483,
0.998012900352478,
0.186113640666008,
-0.3651774525642395,
0.8476414084434509,
-0.08962322026491165,
-0.41268032789230347,
-0.31549209356307983,
0.021304981783032417,
0.000814062193967402,
0.37528911232948303,
0.43787074089050293,
0.6810824275016785,
0.14664606750011444,
-0.6703941226005554,
0.45756393671035767,
0.25096893310546875,
-0.7159581184387207,
-0.6972829103469849,
0.1969911903142929,
0.23993515968322754,
-0.1117980033159256,
0.8339505195617676,
0.2760540246963501,
-0.5543854236602783,
0.4360857903957367,
0.609677255153656,
0.9526913166046143,
-0.5858897566795349,
0.5421058535575867,
0.048957664519548416,
0.16846750676631927,
-0.26518553495407104,
0.405423104763031,
0.1453976184129715,
-0.8661176562309265,
-0.6017892956733704,
-0.9553064107894897,
-0.3051687479019165,
-0.06162988394498825,
-1.2684367895126343,
0.400944322347641,
-0.6502862572669983,
-0.15709370374679565,
0.05241406336426735,
-0.25803834199905396,
-0.8604311347007751,
0.5067472457885742,
0.3015669286251068,
0.9594916105270386,
-1.2362958192825317,
1.0059545040130615,
0.6863895654678345,
-0.31517457962036133,
-0.7717145681381226,
-0.35431158542633057,
-0.5152757167816162,
-0.9691458344459534,
0.9320971965789795,
0.018257517367601395,
-0.2291477620601654,
-0.2376202642917633,
-0.6278733611106873,
-0.7549750208854675,
0.6150144338607788,
0.254956990480423,
-0.5827792286872864,
-0.05421843379735947,
0.2931460440158844,
0.8567635416984558,
-0.781982958316803,
-0.22502237558364868,
0.8222948312759399,
0.566379725933075,
0.2580748498439789,
-0.6303001642227173,
-0.3929899036884308,
-0.29658836126327515,
-0.4095439612865448,
0.11080014705657959,
-0.6591331362724304,
0.8147342205047607,
0.0798245519399643,
0.0017792955040931702,
-0.449570894241333,
0.8639546632766724,
-0.5880112648010254,
0.5221514701843262,
0.40850773453712463,
0.5296446084976196,
0.871579647064209,
-0.08100344985723495,
1.139958143234253,
-0.3198167681694031,
0.5779441595077515,
0.9397057890892029,
-0.3933188021183014,
0.9821099042892456,
0.32259443402290344,
-0.19315584003925323,
0.9131327867507935,
0.49938592314720154,
-0.05342073366045952,
0.6244010329246521,
0.07127580791711807,
-0.15804089605808258,
-0.38441383838653564,
0.16479697823524475,
-0.3168736696243286,
0.8349925875663757,
0.453521192073822,
-0.5288053154945374,
-0.16851557791233063,
0.8461059927940369,
-0.21393342316150665,
-0.05220821499824524,
-0.5768678784370422,
0.9242995381355286,
0.48528438806533813,
-0.3197663426399231,
-0.10005344450473785,
-0.04772032052278519,
0.5095494389533997,
-0.6790764331817627,
0.2565446197986603,
-0.3459475338459015,
0.33033299446105957,
-0.17952638864517212,
-0.4349290728569031,
0.9690520167350769,
-0.2426593154668808,
-0.3731357455253601,
-0.39884471893310547,
0.847730278968811,
-0.0039021179545670748,
-0.7455381155014038,
0.5655316114425659,
0.5344341397285461,
-0.02175002172589302,
-0.02138219214975834,
-0.6524530649185181,
-0.47646740078926086,
-0.11597465723752975,
-0.47524112462997437,
0.47438931465148926,
0.48084530234336853,
-0.21518832445144653,
0.6292277574539185,
0.5383431911468506,
0.05075070261955261,
-0.09756407141685486,
0.17519204318523407,
0.792546272277832,
-1.0114147663116455,
-0.7021100521087646,
-0.9830483198165894,
0.04923579841852188,
0.06041032820940018,
-0.16183169186115265,
0.46564653515815735,
0.2513027489185333,
0.5777287483215332,
-0.4678848683834076,
0.7522282004356384,
0.22585082054138184,
0.3920052647590637,
-0.2986890971660614,
0.6290207505226135,
-0.14981360733509064,
0.13764162361621857,
-0.22180423140525818,
-0.8889503479003906,
-0.5397568345069885,
0.5715371370315552,
-0.7663285136222839,
-0.32430174946784973,
0.5568885803222656,
0.41619178652763367,
0.035275332629680634,
0.27522119879722595,
0.27707523107528687,
0.034831903874874115,
0.09482280164957047,
0.32722827792167664,
0.7439547777175903,
-0.47784504294395447,
0.5894041657447815,
-0.08302224427461624,
-0.07360470294952393,
-0.24803803861141205,
-0.752148449420929,
-0.8409080505371094,
-0.22953380644321442,
-0.5626177787780762,
-0.39662793278694153,
-0.33438363671302795,
0.8174512386322021,
0.4544624984264374,
-1.012094497680664,
-0.25584056973457336,
0.17333035171031952,
-0.0779237225651741,
-0.5108634829521179,
-0.29033052921295166,
0.5302138328552246,
-0.5689477920532227,
-0.4284810423851013,
0.20677655935287476,
0.44351688027381897,
0.09595507383346558,
-0.3231339156627655,
0.14099512994289398,
0.2858266830444336,
0.3023756742477417,
0.7447064518928528,
0.02562560886144638,
-0.012806997634470463,
-0.5635561347007751,
-0.14974212646484375,
-0.2136525958776474,
0.3210102319717407,
1.0334612131118774,
-0.6989063024520874,
0.010069353505969048,
0.567358136177063,
0.9398710131645203,
0.30391910672187805,
0.10438776761293411,
0.6585708260536194,
-0.5598723888397217,
0.04768122732639313,
0.14928947389125824,
0.2344755083322525,
0.07774405926465988,
-0.7386150360107422,
0.14631333947181702,
0.12745867669582367,
-0.23325680196285248,
-0.16971948742866516,
0.06193872168660164,
-1.2009607553482056,
-0.401622474193573,
0.8226184248924255,
-0.19994153082370758,
-0.5744397044181824,
-0.15389607846736908,
-0.11960804462432861,
0.05525030195713043,
-0.16888226568698883,
0.8330370783805847,
0.6518213748931885,
-0.12741558253765106,
-0.21378831565380096,
0.10420099645853043,
0.683625340461731,
0.26867708563804626,
-0.9076893925666809,
-0.2514171898365021,
-0.034660398960113525,
0.5061619877815247,
0.2918713688850403,
0.5137937664985657,
-0.09733308851718903,
0.266853928565979,
-0.007177432999014854,
0.0747707262635231,
0.14262497425079346,
-0.37001532316207886,
-0.49601438641548157,
0.6964070200920105,
-0.24611705541610718,
-0.0746644139289856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18243v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18243v1
|
LEGENT: Open Platform for Embodied Agents
| 2024-04-28T16:50:12 | 2024-04-28T16:50:12 |
Zhili Cheng, Zhitong Wang, Jinyi Hu, Shengding Hu, An Liu, Yuge Tu, Pengkai Li, Lei Shi, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) and Large Multimodal
Models (LMMs), their integration into language-grounded, human-like embodied
agents remains incomplete, hindering complex real-life task performance in
physical environments. Existing integrations often feature limited open
sourcing, challenging collective progress in this field. We introduce LEGENT,
an open, scalable platform for developing embodied agents using LLMs and LMMs.
LEGENT offers a dual approach: a rich, interactive 3D environment with
communicable and actionable agents, paired with a user-friendly interface, and
a sophisticated data generation pipeline utilizing advanced algorithms to
exploit supervision from simulated worlds at scale. In our experiments, an
embryonic vision-language-action model trained on LEGENT-generated data
surpasses GPT-4V in embodied tasks, showcasing promising generalization
capabilities.
|
[
-0.275390088558197,
-0.5062092542648315,
0.7372437119483948,
0.1645558476448059,
-0.11186058819293976,
0.0482175350189209,
0.022083137184381485,
-0.7575068473815918,
0.41666266322135925,
0.6241829991340637,
-0.36342090368270874,
-0.6644426584243774,
-0.19129115343093872,
-0.1906338334083557,
-0.2497567981481552,
0.5799219608306885,
-0.32688021659851074,
0.03645442798733711,
-0.5219393372535706,
-0.6770036220550537,
-0.16985012590885162,
-0.6343982219696045,
-0.3513197898864746,
-0.28674256801605225,
0.6514179706573486,
0.2783833146095276,
0.7997056841850281,
0.5342831611633301,
0.37859514355659485,
0.395026832818985,
0.5142592787742615,
0.2569287121295929,
-0.29888078570365906,
0.33534669876098633,
-0.37515705823898315,
-0.4199152886867523,
-0.8260402083396912,
-0.14762189984321594,
0.5331957936286926,
0.6902748346328735,
0.0034916363656520844,
0.17718276381492615,
-0.08047735691070557,
0.27502602338790894,
-0.5960073471069336,
0.38872313499450684,
0.14804664254188538,
0.13081657886505127,
0.06869545578956604,
0.19410964846611023,
-0.12295787781476974,
-0.14939671754837036,
-0.17556020617485046,
-0.7572804093360901,
0.14081120491027832,
-0.09169286489486694,
0.36549603939056396,
0.39934206008911133,
-0.18666790425777435,
0.13500675559043884,
-0.7967211008071899,
0.5023205876350403,
-0.5551542043685913,
0.7955531477928162,
-0.05681890249252319,
0.5060828328132629,
-0.007234583608806133,
-1.0330560207366943,
-0.615188479423523,
-0.3655928671360016,
0.14848339557647705,
-0.0963580384850502,
0.05177537351846695,
0.35751911997795105,
0.15340784192085266,
0.07187725603580475,
-0.5404961109161377,
0.1329018473625183,
-0.15515664219856262,
-0.033895839005708694,
0.36312881112098694,
0.2456185519695282,
0.6722885966300964,
0.22249256074428558,
-0.5743275284767151,
-0.37969765067100525,
-0.6149844527244568,
-0.13720184564590454,
0.1840970516204834,
0.545665442943573,
-0.44800934195518494,
0.9873074293136597,
-0.12237980216741562,
0.5126228332519531,
-0.1989126354455948,
0.2391597330570221,
0.019122058525681496,
-0.1905946582555771,
-0.044079698622226715,
-0.1129830852150917,
0.7211633324623108,
0.2395225316286087,
-0.1309456080198288,
-0.2826918065547943,
-0.4765629172325134,
0.11118776351213455,
0.2857412099838257,
-0.8530482649803162,
-0.08341573178768158,
0.5344454646110535,
-0.3792758584022522,
-0.22657698392868042,
0.12472881376743317,
-0.9062683582305908,
-0.8221909403800964,
-0.50471031665802,
0.49717533588409424,
-0.10050556808710098,
-0.5317286849021912,
0.24678902328014374,
-0.15095457434654236,
0.47198039293289185,
0.426500529050827,
-0.6638371348381042,
0.4029560983181,
0.7454057335853577,
1.1100465059280396,
-0.14856651425361633,
-0.5217686295509338,
-0.5816521644592285,
0.24067555367946625,
-0.40456849336624146,
0.5502500534057617,
-0.576722264289856,
-0.3782584071159363,
-0.03158172592520714,
0.01841689459979534,
0.12960754334926605,
-0.1963273584842682,
0.3946583867073059,
-0.2845824956893921,
0.07368196547031403,
-0.28846296668052673,
-0.17490161955356598,
0.07649347931146622,
0.24491897225379944,
-0.9530644416809082,
0.7601624131202698,
0.2945254445075989,
-0.7514601945877075,
0.5078495740890503,
-1.0628238916397095,
-0.07429517805576324,
0.2243719846010208,
-0.49522706866264343,
-0.06121949851512909,
0.15803313255310059,
0.0805450826883316,
0.41637006402015686,
-0.12373705208301544,
0.04435859993100166,
-0.22108934819698334,
-0.5704472064971924,
0.062078893184661865,
-0.17620110511779785,
0.454898476600647,
0.013471949845552444,
-0.6435971260070801,
0.5612689256668091,
-0.7279813289642334,
-0.1587928682565689,
0.16827043890953064,
-0.1577300727367401,
-0.3053874671459198,
0.07946223020553589,
0.15746749937534332,
0.13129264116287231,
0.519244909286499,
-0.7566783428192139,
0.3591102957725525,
-0.47848474979400635,
0.34143954515457153,
0.6585472226142883,
-0.35249632596969604,
0.5979592204093933,
-0.2061569094657898,
0.5963808298110962,
-0.20902934670448303,
-0.004772197920829058,
-0.04937221109867096,
-0.2577173411846161,
-0.8945774435997009,
-0.46920856833457947,
-0.07523006945848465,
0.10240355134010315,
-1.283708930015564,
0.005695539992302656,
-0.49848929047584534,
-0.43188783526420593,
-0.4765646159648895,
-0.1216970905661583,
0.42065533995628357,
0.00564417103305459,
0.1080537885427475,
-0.1317901313304901,
-0.2939722239971161,
-0.8042435050010681,
0.2037961632013321,
-0.33558911085128784,
-0.33343350887298584,
0.3216884136199951,
0.656937301158905,
-0.3571096658706665,
0.9944481253623962,
-0.17908883094787598,
0.17272616922855377,
-0.17112725973129272,
0.004268379881978035,
-0.10230975598096848,
0.5038376450538635,
0.6748398542404175,
-0.7916960120201111,
-0.0746443048119545,
0.5029360055923462,
-1.2562857866287231,
0.12348514050245285,
0.12337169051170349,
-0.2252247929573059,
-0.07657790184020996,
0.2688148319721222,
-1.0203548669815063,
0.21435561776161194,
0.8140998482704163,
-0.5023483633995056,
0.5900476574897766,
-0.43662071228027344,
0.2099529355764389,
-0.9591929912567139,
0.3739094138145447,
-0.3782939612865448,
-0.3224084675312042,
-0.7829245924949646,
0.65212482213974,
-0.1100509911775589,
-0.5862999558448792,
-0.7680857181549072,
1.0439561605453491,
-0.5468448996543884,
-0.5546179413795471,
-0.3650776743888855,
0.23806330561637878,
0.1464674323797226,
0.5154039859771729,
0.327968955039978,
0.9130046963691711,
0.644692063331604,
-0.6452316641807556,
0.642038881778717,
0.41501766443252563,
-0.047562893480062485,
0.5617551207542419,
-0.9662559032440186,
0.4587581753730774,
0.10877954214811325,
0.2878453731536865,
-0.5581904649734497,
-0.5794305801391602,
0.5178844928741455,
-0.19496625661849976,
0.05593501776456833,
0.15747380256652832,
-0.5083305239677429,
-0.42417988181114197,
-0.2479041963815689,
0.7394113540649414,
0.17249040305614471,
-0.9883171916007996,
0.9052815437316895,
0.25135666131973267,
0.048060737550258636,
-0.4962097406387329,
-0.6813361644744873,
0.291937917470932,
-0.046649523079395294,
-0.6412324905395508,
-0.06414495408535004,
0.1423277109861374,
-0.5348128080368042,
-0.21664579212665558,
-0.16126663982868195,
-0.038024451583623886,
-0.3052702844142914,
0.39727434515953064,
0.07161542028188705,
-0.45222967863082886,
0.06666051596403122,
-0.015592600218951702,
-0.10253036767244339,
0.20043142139911652,
-0.5649799704551697,
0.4366913139820099,
-0.35289448499679565,
-0.9376671314239502,
-0.2000686526298523,
0.32267752289772034,
1.1300703287124634,
-0.27976784110069275,
0.5369754433631897,
0.4669502079486847,
-0.4482477903366089,
-0.2368481457233429,
-0.2810922861099243,
-0.13762132823467255,
-0.5066268444061279,
0.19837726652622223,
-0.5212639570236206,
-0.8151947855949402,
0.4798508882522583,
-0.08804044127464294,
0.2139997035264969,
-0.10887549072504044,
0.4882601499557495,
0.140214204788208,
0.9238299131393433,
0.7976130247116089,
0.3152447044849396,
0.20541538298130035,
-0.2719581425189972,
0.015582671388983727,
-0.7295200228691101,
-0.36910852789878845,
-0.30218300223350525,
-0.4914056956768036,
-0.4243732988834381,
-1.147125244140625,
0.2645452916622162,
-0.2595537602901459,
-0.3126468360424042,
0.49556106328964233,
-0.6878027319908142,
0.17224957048892975,
0.572531521320343,
0.3363010585308075,
0.11834698170423508,
-0.30248087644577026,
-0.2244904488325119,
0.10055354237556458,
-0.5358047485351562,
-0.7900643944740295,
0.8763847947120667,
0.4800112843513489,
0.7373674511909485,
0.19983753561973572,
0.5484040379524231,
0.3713485300540924,
0.20518940687179565,
-0.5779301524162292,
0.8410655856132507,
0.2356746792793274,
-0.48498424887657166,
-0.3619813024997711,
-0.0731734037399292,
-0.8123321533203125,
0.6658633947372437,
-0.1257924735546112,
-0.7121009826660156,
0.5194388628005981,
-0.07697664201259613,
-0.013656136579811573,
0.623380184173584,
-0.3433581292629242,
0.8296153545379639,
-0.4830234944820404,
-0.7709779143333435,
-0.11320433765649796,
-0.6484135389328003,
0.2980460226535797,
0.032435595989227295,
0.05664670094847679,
-0.08350024372339249,
-0.6058120131492615,
0.3245362341403961,
-0.5333369374275208,
1.116021990776062,
-0.5137773156166077,
-0.4483209252357483,
0.3898245692253113,
0.18993687629699707,
0.5921253561973572,
-0.001147649367339909,
0.05568597838282585,
0.36222943663597107,
-0.12331297248601913,
-0.6349173784255981,
-0.5220263600349426,
0.7117001414299011,
-0.7351438403129578,
-0.2344946712255478,
-0.28155678510665894,
-0.4934285879135132,
-0.4697352945804596,
0.16263540089130402,
-0.19839249551296234,
0.31852367520332336,
-0.797346293926239,
0.19178855419158936,
0.5710715651512146,
-0.3789387047290802,
0.25942960381507874,
0.5338589549064636,
-0.5395799279212952,
-0.37846633791923523,
1.021403193473816,
-0.6025049686431885,
0.1393747329711914,
0.4243103861808777,
0.10515047609806061,
-0.3154175877571106,
-0.18770502507686615,
-0.704896092414856,
0.2734196186065674,
-0.5520089268684387,
0.048691049218177795,
-0.6587445139884949,
-0.06960077583789825,
-0.08330428600311279,
-0.47857174277305603,
-0.5064916610717773,
-0.2431662380695343,
-0.17527872323989868,
-0.3808785378932953,
0.1197597086429596,
0.9725310802459717,
-0.25513383746147156,
0.19229836761951447,
-0.8353922367095947,
0.6010509729385376,
0.3975375294685364,
0.4740195572376251,
-0.13550251722335815,
0.1714923083782196,
-0.17141616344451904,
0.4073946177959442,
0.09447746723890305,
-0.47581222653388977,
0.15347859263420105,
0.04764899984002113,
0.6324384808540344,
0.6164327263832092,
-0.025745930150151253,
0.31231313943862915,
-0.2835633158683777,
0.9822530746459961,
0.4342349171638489,
-0.6627027988433838,
0.33198848366737366,
-0.8250902891159058,
0.2123488187789917,
0.20059259235858917,
0.11297035217285156,
-0.3491457402706146,
-0.4651647210121155,
-0.3769490718841553,
-0.5618148446083069,
0.5620931386947632,
0.2894445061683655,
0.3567555248737335,
0.05331357941031456,
0.1509511023759842,
0.42439407110214233,
0.49495598673820496,
-0.5956277251243591,
0.21152444183826447,
-0.43140971660614014,
-0.06082838028669357,
-0.09926467388868332,
-0.04556867480278015,
-0.2232830822467804,
-0.11734286695718765,
0.07814878970384598,
-0.37924253940582275,
0.37490585446357727,
0.15259921550750732,
-0.028009848669171333,
-0.027395278215408325,
-0.006314045749604702,
0.6399182081222534,
0.6429527997970581,
0.07348164916038513,
0.0810881033539772,
-0.007069935090839863,
-0.4296524226665497,
0.25477761030197144,
-0.06399920582771301,
-0.025079360231757164,
-0.04863326996564865,
0.45703989267349243,
1.009706974029541,
0.5665532350540161,
-0.9818285703659058,
0.5384402871131897,
0.08372781425714493,
-0.3841675817966461,
-0.0865369588136673,
0.024140048772096634,
0.19400706887245178,
0.6531547904014587,
-0.026006270200014114,
-0.07345431298017502,
0.05737733840942383,
-0.3989916443824768,
0.26901865005493164,
0.3047809302806854,
-0.6912623643875122,
-0.6351163983345032,
1.2070221900939941,
0.6127840280532837,
-0.20439068973064423,
0.3849474787712097,
0.297345906496048,
-0.08225449919700623,
0.5499688982963562,
0.30543479323387146,
1.1314576864242554,
-0.07590795308351517,
0.4715064764022827,
0.14594334363937378,
0.1587003916501999,
-0.19371715188026428,
0.28613847494125366,
-0.20180606842041016,
-0.6722742319107056,
-0.24796386063098907,
-0.8175320625305176,
-0.6293124556541443,
-0.2634485960006714,
-0.3783653676509857,
0.2149750143289566,
-0.3561153709888458,
-0.05982084572315216,
-0.5573040843009949,
-0.32747793197631836,
-0.5804965496063232,
-0.12332431972026825,
0.2936151921749115,
0.8600263595581055,
-0.7069075703620911,
0.6213107705116272,
1.042298436164856,
-0.7316463589668274,
-0.3154117166996002,
-0.11053332686424255,
-0.10616210103034973,
-0.6962860822677612,
0.41183722019195557,
0.09779546409845352,
-0.4574745297431946,
-0.04630298167467117,
-0.59842449426651,
-0.5879850387573242,
1.2388741970062256,
0.680076003074646,
-0.26726776361465454,
-0.4037770926952362,
0.5161097645759583,
0.7692251205444336,
-0.3674536347389221,
0.14260753989219666,
0.2616591453552246,
0.710697591304779,
0.21761316061019897,
-0.8034319877624512,
0.05858542025089264,
-0.12800084054470062,
-0.09909456223249435,
0.25653764605522156,
-0.8439021706581116,
0.8938338756561279,
-0.2445468306541443,
-0.13992765545845032,
0.3716921806335449,
0.6781716346740723,
0.39763617515563965,
0.4321698546409607,
0.34170007705688477,
0.3638788163661957,
0.4887881278991699,
-0.1008186861872673,
0.9212850332260132,
-0.2412281036376953,
0.02404780499637127,
0.8959472179412842,
-0.6186960339546204,
0.7839141488075256,
0.2704009711742401,
-0.005543234292417765,
0.43528661131858826,
0.20082110166549683,
0.2788848876953125,
0.16295868158340454,
0.11002478003501892,
-0.6095661520957947,
-0.202286034822464,
-0.13460370898246765,
-0.13286879658699036,
0.6701450347900391,
0.244153693318367,
0.09017236530780792,
-0.2535730004310608,
0.42947784066200256,
-0.3638424873352051,
0.24482199549674988,
-0.2171649932861328,
0.5970973372459412,
0.12274143844842911,
-0.14478833973407745,
0.20010627806186676,
-0.3320201635360718,
0.3442710041999817,
-0.5684929490089417,
-0.5718986392021179,
-0.21378393471240997,
0.11870335787534714,
0.05852032080292702,
-0.5276615619659424,
-0.028844326734542847,
-0.14152401685714722,
0.2947865426540375,
-0.37854406237602234,
0.8766146898269653,
-0.3023185729980469,
-0.2591090798377991,
0.43560442328453064,
0.9814287424087524,
0.327825129032135,
-0.2517337203025818,
-0.4757884740829468,
0.20382548868656158,
-0.48261597752571106,
-0.31288108229637146,
0.3650146722793579,
0.6249120831489563,
-0.23064926266670227,
0.9187811017036438,
0.5774667263031006,
-0.054861702024936676,
-0.17341995239257812,
-0.09307064116001129,
1.0472360849380493,
-0.6586418151855469,
-0.413353830575943,
-0.335028737783432,
0.6922697424888611,
-0.11245013028383255,
0.044017184525728226,
0.5343482494354248,
0.7049217820167542,
0.4255078136920929,
-0.15947383642196655,
0.7742573618888855,
-0.2631724774837494,
0.2582220435142517,
-0.31577956676483154,
0.9315410256385803,
-0.4829142689704895,
-0.03483422100543976,
-0.08883961290121078,
-1.1873894929885864,
-0.12637333571910858,
0.36664244532585144,
0.16385763883590698,
0.07703948765993118,
0.6273159384727478,
0.5599570870399475,
-0.420560747385025,
-0.27790868282318115,
0.7676684856414795,
0.03184749186038971,
0.4094037115573883,
0.32726213335990906,
0.8881016373634338,
-0.10447912663221359,
0.3151029050350189,
0.07830013334751129,
-0.21112032234668732,
-0.16816985607147217,
-0.6242858171463013,
-0.8976572155952454,
-0.6473097205162048,
-0.09459594637155533,
-0.02228839322924614,
0.30431801080703735,
0.6805277466773987,
0.6083343029022217,
-0.6178312301635742,
-0.4022934138774872,
-0.30474022030830383,
-0.22461572289466858,
-0.2501806616783142,
-0.1785908192396164,
0.14189055562019348,
-0.05468123406171799,
-1.0112090110778809,
0.7858134508132935,
0.3505918085575104,
0.03924132138490677,
-0.795895516872406,
-0.30985695123672485,
0.17432168126106262,
0.0959961861371994,
0.6958584785461426,
0.5631697177886963,
-0.6923616528511047,
-0.6335064768791199,
-0.008789163082838058,
-0.2844337224960327,
-0.10272884368896484,
1.0307278633117676,
-0.8740726113319397,
0.664893388748169,
0.3919682502746582,
0.5366516709327698,
0.36369264125823975,
0.19211696088314056,
1.0330880880355835,
-0.6987417340278625,
0.4994085133075714,
0.3547711968421936,
0.29831019043922424,
0.24532939493656158,
-0.05536181852221489,
0.7679513096809387,
0.06835004687309265,
-0.4010266661643982,
-0.7944912314414978,
0.07610142230987549,
-1.0182420015335083,
-0.24264858663082123,
1.1569454669952393,
-0.10588494688272476,
-0.2747929096221924,
0.006727162282913923,
-0.43358445167541504,
0.09641824662685394,
-0.10320308059453964,
0.35314512252807617,
0.4382548928260803,
-0.13382592797279358,
-0.17518219351768494,
-0.7589101791381836,
0.1349572390317917,
-0.32075008749961853,
-0.9095510840415955,
0.23991678655147552,
0.9495335817337036,
-0.06852017343044281,
0.13504908978939056,
0.6394810080528259,
0.027024192735552788,
0.2549475133419037,
0.6614118814468384,
0.6873965263366699,
-0.32864898443222046,
-0.48305970430374146,
-0.08210146427154541,
0.21160674095153809,
0.20175163447856903,
-0.4805193841457367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18239v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18239v4
|
SOUL: Unlocking the Power of Second-Order Optimization for LLM Unlearning
| 2024-04-28T16:31:32 | 2024-06-24T20:24:53 |
Jinghan Jia, Yihua Zhang, Yimeng Zhang, Jiancheng Liu, Bharat Runwal, James Diffenderfer, Bhavya Kailkhura, Sijia Liu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have highlighted the necessity of effective
unlearning mechanisms to comply with data regulations and ethical AI practices.
LLM unlearning aims at removing undesired data influences and associated model
capabilities without compromising utility beyond the scope of unlearning. While
interest in studying LLM unlearning is growing, the impact of the optimizer
choice for LLM unlearning remains unexplored. In this work, we shed light on
the significance of optimizer selection in LLM unlearning for the first time,
establishing a clear connection between second-order optimization and influence
unlearning (a classical approach using influence functions to update the model
for data influence removal). This insight propels us to develop a second-order
optimization-based LLM unlearning framework, termed Second-Order UnLearning
(SOUL), which extends the static, one-shot model update using influence
unlearning to a dynamic, iterative unlearning process. Our extensive
experiments show that SOUL consistently outperforms conventional first-order
methods across various unlearning tasks, models, and metrics, indicating that
second-order optimization offers an effective and broadly applicable solution
for LLM unlearning. Codes are available at https://github.com/OPTML-Group/SOUL.
|
[
-0.1338246464729309,
-0.336722195148468,
0.4871049225330353,
-0.12003370374441147,
-0.6513822078704834,
0.3060877323150635,
-0.4588248133659363,
-0.2347850203514099,
-0.45003145933151245,
0.731502115726471,
-0.7692493200302124,
-0.44379758834838867,
-0.7516002058982849,
-0.41349726915359497,
-0.10443902015686035,
0.955575168132782,
0.3313872218132019,
0.5775126218795776,
-0.2363024652004242,
-0.08174992352724075,
-0.2248576581478119,
-0.32575395703315735,
-0.9110612869262695,
-0.776155412197113,
0.2562112510204315,
0.5688944458961487,
0.35963064432144165,
0.5049442648887634,
0.40082600712776184,
0.22210575640201569,
-0.12873394787311554,
0.2599947154521942,
-0.8798773288726807,
0.21986329555511475,
-0.18386617302894592,
-0.6851522326469421,
-0.2818852365016937,
-0.009528796188533306,
0.2623182535171509,
0.6664949059486389,
-0.10076102614402771,
0.3510045111179352,
0.025886351242661476,
1.2338017225265503,
-0.7233436107635498,
0.08892115205526352,
-1.0497708320617676,
0.11534322798252106,
-0.11319730430841446,
-0.3021198809146881,
-0.5036038756370544,
-0.15319988131523132,
0.04821190983057022,
-0.3747188448905945,
-0.09710626304149628,
-0.17964358627796173,
0.20793946087360382,
0.976673424243927,
-0.19849342107772827,
-0.270009845495224,
-0.6416935920715332,
1.0615311861038208,
-0.46052804589271545,
0.6257191300392151,
0.25925594568252563,
0.1919236034154892,
-0.11017953604459763,
-0.7449812889099121,
-0.3506719768047333,
0.35803383588790894,
0.25177183747291565,
0.30260610580444336,
-0.08116725087165833,
0.16581298410892487,
-0.010151670314371586,
0.17199885845184326,
-0.2314748764038086,
0.4550894796848297,
-0.4118782579898834,
0.021666206419467926,
0.6758277416229248,
-0.004458829294890165,
0.0443422794342041,
-0.050850119441747665,
-0.17980538308620453,
-0.005822166800498962,
-0.7007128596305847,
0.19170720875263214,
0.27575239539146423,
-0.03170861676335335,
0.31296172738075256,
0.5034362077713013,
0.04702334851026535,
0.3220733404159546,
0.029388191178441048,
-0.28763195872306824,
0.09111478179693222,
0.2553265690803528,
-0.053984709084033966,
0.03410930186510086,
0.48854413628578186,
0.621303379535675,
0.5236250162124634,
-0.4470209777355194,
-0.35776516795158386,
-0.03057737648487091,
0.4433160424232483,
-0.9411398768424988,
0.028459137305617332,
0.24089878797531128,
-0.6252272129058838,
-0.37750813364982605,
0.012652241624891758,
-0.856785774230957,
-0.4102868139743805,
-0.47739705443382263,
0.27797573804855347,
-0.20886355638504028,
-0.1673680692911148,
0.04404151067137718,
0.04376297816634178,
0.3716760575771332,
0.1176520362496376,
-0.8342882394790649,
0.21263737976551056,
1.0059874057769775,
0.6665109992027283,
-0.18539460003376007,
-0.08608347177505493,
-0.31675395369529724,
-0.10325954109430313,
-0.2985023856163025,
0.3442037105560303,
-0.5835465788841248,
-0.7572799921035767,
-0.22530461847782135,
-0.15372973680496216,
0.27461010217666626,
-0.5653112530708313,
0.7326783537864685,
-0.7600666880607605,
-0.07464349269866943,
-0.33965736627578735,
-0.6158058047294617,
-0.361857146024704,
-0.5173874497413635,
-0.06770266592502594,
0.96758633852005,
0.22093985974788666,
-0.3885200619697571,
0.46299853920936584,
-0.4722956120967865,
-0.4397732615470886,
-0.009799392893910408,
-0.1961750090122223,
-0.4578891396522522,
0.6663739681243896,
-0.2999608516693115,
0.46207940578460693,
-0.2642577290534973,
0.26941007375717163,
-0.2309810221195221,
-0.4418472945690155,
-0.029419412836432457,
-0.5320652723312378,
0.6984515190124512,
0.26030582189559937,
-0.5221631526947021,
-0.0871758982539177,
-0.6612263321876526,
0.26340100169181824,
0.3036237955093384,
-0.32075178623199463,
-0.4785420894622803,
0.32287219166755676,
-0.08371330052614212,
0.13911619782447815,
0.24710185825824738,
-0.3433586359024048,
0.1581854373216629,
-0.6068153381347656,
0.5005460381507874,
0.950786292552948,
0.038376398384571075,
0.6652405261993408,
0.06110048666596413,
0.16218510270118713,
-0.39115381240844727,
0.19059860706329346,
0.21777361631393433,
-0.14105717837810516,
-0.7425580024719238,
0.13518622517585754,
0.03393102064728737,
0.5490590929985046,
-0.19174803793430328,
0.21322138607501984,
-0.10804788768291473,
-0.572769284248352,
-0.8993284702301025,
0.5050814151763916,
0.8585212230682373,
0.4743505120277405,
0.42301732301712036,
-0.10432828962802887,
-0.7188180088996887,
-0.8764396905899048,
-0.5126990675926208,
-0.10160823911428452,
0.19319355487823486,
0.24972093105316162,
0.43456652760505676,
-0.40189048647880554,
0.919068455696106,
-0.4923194348812103,
-0.14998126029968262,
-0.28427654504776,
-0.15950599312782288,
0.20339743793010712,
0.3813851773738861,
0.33466804027557373,
-0.8883649110794067,
-0.4423481523990631,
-0.028058085590600967,
-0.7919374704360962,
-0.25792446732521057,
0.01885117031633854,
-0.3257175385951996,
0.32274383306503296,
0.4950275719165802,
-0.29906216263771057,
0.4629342555999756,
0.21680758893489838,
0.10024692118167877,
0.429341197013855,
-0.28986817598342896,
-0.3191967308521271,
-1.0328459739685059,
0.0006376029341481626,
-0.36981162428855896,
-0.02400078810751438,
-0.7426280975341797,
0.038603734225034714,
0.01432572491466999,
0.06977667659521103,
-0.3430454134941101,
0.5921069383621216,
-0.659948468208313,
-0.3799164891242981,
-0.6521244645118713,
0.14793376624584198,
-0.19850023090839386,
0.6924226880073547,
0.10884729772806168,
0.7872154116630554,
0.3834932744503021,
-0.5832383036613464,
-0.18095073103904724,
0.3100565969944,
-0.1916312873363495,
0.35463759303092957,
-0.6960235834121704,
0.5305476188659668,
-0.2899291515350342,
-0.16504411399364471,
-0.553657591342926,
0.18567468225955963,
-0.09422184526920319,
-0.42043253779411316,
0.47383835911750793,
-0.37934181094169617,
-0.398597776889801,
-0.12793846428394318,
-0.1517353504896164,
0.1454472541809082,
0.7923646569252014,
-0.7069130539894104,
0.5174815654754639,
0.6210014224052429,
0.31388506293296814,
-0.8338199257850647,
-0.5613112449645996,
-0.11959720402956009,
-0.15658801794052124,
-0.39202961325645447,
0.36312195658683777,
-0.38594698905944824,
-0.5072556138038635,
-0.30731967091560364,
-0.6255757212638855,
0.168532595038414,
0.4206634759902954,
0.46305549144744873,
0.07149636745452881,
0.2339267134666443,
-0.06698015332221985,
0.36368098855018616,
-0.48904648423194885,
0.353354275226593,
-0.5300795435905457,
0.6529595255851746,
0.04976987466216087,
-0.25771233439445496,
-0.24709942936897278,
0.10749147087335587,
0.79897540807724,
-0.32397282123565674,
0.7151641249656677,
0.6455969214439392,
-0.33806878328323364,
-0.5400758981704712,
-0.4248737394809723,
-0.3035067021846771,
-0.5299209356307983,
0.6237281560897827,
-0.28184229135513306,
-0.5724974274635315,
0.24702854454517365,
-0.2410295307636261,
0.5615489482879639,
-0.053196314722299576,
0.5482519268989563,
-0.02681519091129303,
1.099086046218872,
0.6229349374771118,
-0.18516798317432404,
0.4093407988548279,
-0.4297757148742676,
0.142421156167984,
-1.2208318710327148,
-0.54182368516922,
-0.14653846621513367,
-0.38051939010620117,
-0.4313819706439972,
-0.1725488305091858,
0.3774304986000061,
0.5710621476173401,
-0.07417654246091843,
-0.04877419397234917,
-0.4654500186443329,
0.8813076615333557,
0.4863924980163574,
0.25895363092422485,
0.2273746132850647,
0.013592470437288284,
-0.0214554276317358,
0.02551620453596115,
-0.15106657147407532,
-0.5498400926589966,
1.4277005195617676,
0.07594075798988342,
0.49873486161231995,
0.23854610323905945,
0.714788019657135,
0.08501137793064117,
0.13992853462696075,
-0.9531148076057434,
0.5651242733001709,
-0.6433750987052917,
-0.2290671169757843,
-0.04824142903089523,
-0.18418307602405548,
-0.7577411532402039,
0.5096400380134583,
-0.029534701257944107,
-0.8130741119384766,
-0.16297312080860138,
0.04173678532242775,
-0.30842265486717224,
0.34742698073387146,
-0.46791720390319824,
0.595227062702179,
-0.5284818410873413,
-0.6180606484413147,
-0.4678093492984772,
-0.876179039478302,
0.2471921145915985,
-0.3205840289592743,
0.14605113863945007,
0.05246018245816231,
-0.18094976246356964,
0.775547981262207,
-0.44716694951057434,
0.6650949120521545,
-0.42655619978904724,
-0.1814204454421997,
0.12935009598731995,
0.2211340069770813,
0.607166588306427,
0.29315802454948425,
-0.18875274062156677,
0.01213238574564457,
-0.31406885385513306,
-0.13088996708393097,
-0.6276296973228455,
0.444108247756958,
-0.9202593564987183,
-0.7113878130912781,
0.1071166843175888,
-0.1861949861049652,
-0.4497467875480652,
0.37188851833343506,
0.5203109979629517,
0.4040745496749878,
0.02922871522605419,
0.2546440064907074,
0.8290822505950928,
0.05823523551225662,
0.5926176309585571,
0.7773991227149963,
-0.16260142624378204,
-0.3373561203479767,
1.050229549407959,
-0.09757886826992035,
0.41970908641815186,
0.3344765603542328,
0.3346766233444214,
-0.24466261267662048,
-0.8494871258735657,
-0.17990252375602722,
0.32209476828575134,
-0.7423785924911499,
0.021442310884594917,
-0.8407245874404907,
-0.02356828562915325,
-0.2580309510231018,
-0.38446488976478577,
-0.47922420501708984,
-0.10024526715278625,
-0.5840017199516296,
-0.14648397266864777,
-0.08024287968873978,
0.6094515919685364,
-0.17094431817531586,
0.39741265773773193,
-0.6135177612304688,
0.13616019487380981,
0.16304385662078857,
0.11289507895708084,
0.02265731804072857,
-0.6718897819519043,
-0.15798097848892212,
-0.005013363901525736,
-0.14917196333408356,
-0.902858555316925,
0.2610423266887665,
0.11801636219024658,
0.6701550483703613,
0.8166999220848083,
-0.11359414458274841,
0.6257553696632385,
-0.5093259811401367,
0.3339915871620178,
0.02147769369184971,
-0.9592488408088684,
0.4836002290248871,
-0.183902308344841,
0.1600581854581833,
0.9751038551330566,
0.020899634808301926,
-0.606690526008606,
0.06895994395017624,
-0.545592725276947,
-0.939665675163269,
0.7795757055282593,
-0.06251063197851181,
-0.11798277497291565,
0.4512149691581726,
0.8764097094535828,
0.321127712726593,
0.6854845881462097,
-0.28017958998680115,
-0.6584135293960571,
-0.04912608116865158,
-0.13422459363937378,
-0.30455195903778076,
-0.3017449378967285,
0.3016411364078522,
-0.2186838537454605,
0.8950662016868591,
-0.18612010776996613,
0.023261893540620804,
-0.1389225274324417,
-0.4365846812725067,
-0.2644042670726776,
0.16200779378414154,
0.4607725441455841,
0.5198154449462891,
-0.0222757700830698,
-0.054779309779405594,
0.2515556216239929,
-0.6134806871414185,
-0.0527481883764267,
-0.4423912763595581,
-0.5061036944389343,
-0.41847407817840576,
0.05819247290492058,
0.8472307920455933,
0.34947359561920166,
-0.6985599398612976,
0.2936021387577057,
0.13087795674800873,
0.0024742113891988993,
-0.546985924243927,
0.34873974323272705,
-0.20252321660518646,
0.4085965156555176,
0.48063239455223083,
0.26182281970977783,
0.2229023426771164,
-0.42192238569259644,
0.32708990573883057,
0.852001428604126,
-0.4271533489227295,
-0.42404618859291077,
0.6270456910133362,
0.07160118222236633,
-0.3523472547531128,
0.53267902135849,
-0.21306851506233215,
-0.984417200088501,
0.47720521688461304,
0.43110284209251404,
1.0247383117675781,
-0.13603800535202026,
0.1277974247932434,
0.14433065056800842,
0.43624353408813477,
-0.18650348484516144,
0.2463245838880539,
-0.0969451442360878,
-0.711973249912262,
-0.10720910876989365,
-0.7873299717903137,
-0.34753167629241943,
0.259333997964859,
-0.8931393027305603,
0.06337258964776993,
-0.6119681000709534,
0.06646374613046646,
-0.365166038274765,
0.448572039604187,
-0.5977585315704346,
0.1864345222711563,
0.03446342051029205,
0.5606040358543396,
-0.3856731057167053,
0.6466894745826721,
0.5698722004890442,
0.004718097858130932,
-0.5194198489189148,
0.03700636699795723,
0.6081852912902832,
-1.2345569133758545,
0.7000118494033813,
0.238255575299263,
-0.3626941442489624,
0.3938378095626831,
-0.36230793595314026,
-0.73126220703125,
1.1534225940704346,
0.3686104714870453,
-0.7239999175071716,
0.0009793892968446016,
-0.10058324784040451,
0.44312307238578796,
-0.3440883755683899,
0.43117064237594604,
0.7085272073745728,
0.41931062936782837,
0.01873563602566719,
-0.2778717875480652,
-0.2503764033317566,
-0.14133764803409576,
-0.11042693257331848,
0.5013837218284607,
-1.0113329887390137,
0.4718475937843323,
-0.7788099646568298,
-0.2896387577056885,
-0.051536235958337784,
0.6725330948829651,
0.018459251150488853,
0.322765976190567,
0.5458344221115112,
0.47313785552978516,
0.86806720495224,
0.028253430500626564,
0.44625574350357056,
-0.5434502363204956,
0.29435715079307556,
1.0368837118148804,
-0.33845460414886475,
0.7382972836494446,
0.6532029509544373,
-0.16977496445178986,
0.2278830111026764,
0.7952742576599121,
0.012636656872928143,
0.7073674201965332,
0.2861175239086151,
-0.18644572794437408,
-0.2802039384841919,
-0.024742068722844124,
-0.1083565279841423,
0.5591975450515747,
0.22242817282676697,
-0.266786128282547,
-0.08677767217159271,
-0.0009639380150474608,
0.31304192543029785,
-0.22028225660324097,
-0.28365257382392883,
1.0109241008758545,
0.1711423099040985,
-0.586703360080719,
0.3789864182472229,
-0.045215535908937454,
0.6636030077934265,
-0.5383956432342529,
0.1814931482076645,
-0.35748282074928284,
0.5257933139801025,
-0.31083789467811584,
-0.3939869999885559,
0.07402484863996506,
0.1310325562953949,
-0.19346094131469727,
-0.31217503547668457,
0.6391173005104065,
-0.3834858536720276,
-0.1734713912010193,
0.7087549567222595,
0.5264436602592468,
0.20431587100028992,
0.04847417026758194,
-0.7807371020317078,
-0.15045733749866486,
0.14665287733078003,
-0.5282076597213745,
0.48437321186065674,
0.1672404706478119,
0.38911187648773193,
0.787558376789093,
0.8522434830665588,
0.06610284000635147,
-0.18156875669956207,
0.12007688730955124,
0.6055128574371338,
-0.3218364417552948,
-0.16467688977718353,
-1.024303913116455,
0.4847106337547302,
0.09843704849481583,
-0.3197152316570282,
0.6182969808578491,
0.596733570098877,
0.9925822615623474,
0.2911752760410309,
0.8795087933540344,
0.21597346663475037,
0.21644870936870575,
-0.7790300250053406,
0.815975546836853,
-0.9628300666809082,
0.42434656620025635,
-0.016132263466715813,
-1.0180168151855469,
0.09161971509456635,
0.30853185057640076,
-0.06622587144374847,
0.21596693992614746,
0.6523051261901855,
0.7810667157173157,
0.14391691982746124,
0.2061595767736435,
0.4961581826210022,
0.09171833842992783,
0.03790785372257233,
0.4754151999950409,
0.38381990790367126,
-0.11333621293306351,
0.2282525599002838,
-0.5298790335655212,
-0.21493488550186157,
-0.014712154865264893,
-0.4630412757396698,
-1.2075968980789185,
-0.5391124486923218,
0.06273888796567917,
-0.3074645400047302,
0.21131518483161926,
1.2296420335769653,
0.42648062109947205,
-0.5808922052383423,
-0.2393956184387207,
-0.3277854919433594,
0.03655361756682396,
-0.053498126566410065,
-0.1739899069070816,
0.3046034872531891,
-0.33205747604370117,
-0.8496935367584229,
0.7384046912193298,
0.2655717432498932,
-0.05600671097636223,
-0.4146278500556946,
-0.32662105560302734,
0.2811804711818695,
0.038386374711990356,
0.5725398063659668,
0.15230289101600647,
-0.8140392303466797,
0.13748961687088013,
0.1688278466463089,
0.08031053841114044,
-0.058946460485458374,
1.097754955291748,
-0.5618287324905396,
0.19458012282848358,
0.25804033875465393,
0.8994564414024353,
0.2659592926502228,
-0.002686227671802044,
0.25977104902267456,
-0.7008468508720398,
-0.20838238298892975,
-0.01281676534563303,
0.3693845272064209,
-0.008142962120473385,
-0.543674647808075,
0.754970371723175,
0.3299142122268677,
-0.615612268447876,
-1.0187187194824219,
0.339469850063324,
-0.6012423634529114,
-0.47616294026374817,
1.278761863708496,
0.22630557417869568,
-0.34885939955711365,
0.0235875453799963,
-0.14772909879684448,
0.44816330075263977,
-0.5517075657844543,
0.5253167748451233,
0.34054994583129883,
-0.11109555512666702,
-0.2460026741027832,
-0.5076028108596802,
0.6028274297714233,
0.821704089641571,
-0.8396403789520264,
0.3895164430141449,
0.29903677105903625,
0.18389974534511566,
-0.12665621936321259,
0.45855024456977844,
-0.050323035567998886,
0.05674704909324646,
-0.4662926495075226,
-0.1304437667131424,
-0.31181153655052185,
-0.6207886338233948,
-0.45844200253486633,
-0.0781928300857544,
-0.13013359904289246,
0.12455404549837112
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18231v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18231v1
|
From Persona to Personalization: A Survey on Role-Playing Language Agents
| 2024-04-28T15:56:41 | 2024-04-28T15:56:41 |
Jiangjie Chen, Xintao Wang, Rui Xu, Siyu Yuan, Yikai Zhang, Wei Shi, Jian Xie, Shuang Li, Ruihan Yang, Tinghui Zhu, Aili Chen, Nianqi Li, Lida Chen, Caiyu Hu, Siye Wu, Scott Ren, Ziquan Fu, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have significantly
boosted the rise of Role-Playing Language Agents (RPLAs), i.e., specialized AI
systems designed to simulate assigned personas. By harnessing multiple advanced
abilities of LLMs, including in-context learning, instruction following, and
social intelligence, RPLAs achieve a remarkable sense of human likeness and
vivid role-playing performance. RPLAs can mimic a wide range of personas,
ranging from historical figures and fictional characters to real-life
individuals. Consequently, they have catalyzed numerous AI applications, such
as emotional companions, interactive video games, personalized assistants and
copilots, and digital clones. In this paper, we conduct a comprehensive survey
of this field, illustrating the evolution and recent progress in RPLAs
integrating with cutting-edge LLM technologies. We categorize personas into
three types: 1) Demographic Persona, which leverages statistical stereotypes;
2) Character Persona, focused on well-established figures; and 3)
Individualized Persona, customized through ongoing user interactions for
personalized services. We begin by presenting a comprehensive overview of
current methodologies for RPLAs, followed by the details for each persona type,
covering corresponding data sourcing, agent construction, and evaluation.
Afterward, we discuss the fundamental risks, existing limitations, and future
prospects of RPLAs. Additionally, we provide a brief review of RPLAs in AI
applications, which reflects practical user demands that shape and drive RPLA
research. Through this work, we aim to establish a clear taxonomy of RPLA
research and applications, and facilitate future research in this critical and
ever-evolving field, and pave the way for a future where humans and RPLAs
coexist in harmony.
|
[
-0.44814997911453247,
-0.820939302444458,
0.5687587857246399,
0.3889600932598114,
0.3393171429634094,
0.513344943523407,
-0.14004842936992645,
-0.5225017070770264,
0.43858829140663147,
0.7888863682746887,
-0.5855256915092468,
-0.17394766211509705,
-0.26612865924835205,
-0.013125774450600147,
-0.016480591148138046,
0.6343444585800171,
0.4773949980735779,
0.06252502650022507,
-0.3520442843437195,
-0.014467782340943813,
-0.628655195236206,
-0.8503164052963257,
-0.7985696196556091,
-0.5782688856124878,
0.8003372550010681,
0.38184595108032227,
0.5957698225975037,
0.6429556012153625,
0.24225859344005585,
0.4158576428890228,
0.1885709911584854,
0.08394207060337067,
-0.2054339051246643,
0.5352470874786377,
-0.19448789954185486,
-0.5185056924819946,
-0.6071381568908691,
0.1774972379207611,
0.5258298516273499,
0.634037435054779,
0.061275023967027664,
0.04197566956281662,
-0.2769884169101715,
0.519458532333374,
-0.28512609004974365,
0.33647939562797546,
-0.19678951799869537,
0.1597297638654709,
-0.3121858537197113,
-0.35149234533309937,
-0.503380298614502,
-0.2951463758945465,
0.18034300208091736,
-0.5312275290489197,
-0.01935180276632309,
-0.013203673996031284,
0.24977736175060272,
0.11912035197019577,
-0.5184751152992249,
-0.3224434554576874,
-1.1032594442367554,
0.8273261189460754,
-0.45520004630088806,
0.26170235872268677,
0.32848024368286133,
0.5251989960670471,
-0.29627367854118347,
-0.6301853060722351,
-0.2367945909500122,
-0.5529568195343018,
-0.10439036786556244,
0.08955052495002747,
0.018950700759887695,
-0.05486132204532623,
0.16752219200134277,
0.11473444849252701,
-0.5148553848266602,
0.3491400182247162,
-0.020901203155517578,
-0.025930339470505714,
0.7921726107597351,
0.1930042803287506,
0.7577398419380188,
0.3024137020111084,
-0.09857092797756195,
-0.1896880716085434,
-0.695067286491394,
0.1849195659160614,
0.5722090601921082,
0.1474546641111374,
-0.027677971869707108,
0.4428502321243286,
-0.1398320496082306,
0.46566155552864075,
-0.0154257882386446,
-0.4182727634906769,
0.11459030956029892,
0.09914108365774155,
-0.011580810882151127,
-0.2842485308647156,
0.749470591545105,
0.023475997149944305,
0.6509360671043396,
-0.19255800545215607,
-0.05150502920150757,
-0.2574801445007324,
0.2721068263053894,
-0.4045746922492981,
-0.1627456247806549,
0.21335265040397644,
-0.559775710105896,
-0.23732802271842957,
-0.10272161662578583,
-1.0215976238250732,
-0.838141918182373,
-0.2760300636291504,
-0.10098522156476974,
-0.15928219258785248,
-0.17226386070251465,
-0.397722989320755,
0.31990641355514526,
0.40497300028800964,
0.3500981330871582,
-0.9969099164009094,
0.2989659309387207,
0.8937425017356873,
0.46641817688941956,
-0.2195238620042801,
-0.5978582501411438,
-0.42044052481651306,
0.10624075680971146,
-0.27926769852638245,
1.0085090398788452,
-0.6410356760025024,
-0.4764983057975769,
0.34457096457481384,
-0.238264262676239,
-0.01635258086025715,
-0.660639762878418,
0.14738470315933228,
-0.6310513019561768,
0.2888745963573456,
-0.18948766589164734,
-0.3223617970943451,
0.09991391003131866,
0.3346308171749115,
-0.5782319903373718,
0.5860084891319275,
-0.07679246366024017,
-0.24200551211833954,
0.15146470069885254,
-0.6655013561248779,
-0.4284164011478424,
0.3828868567943573,
-0.32153788208961487,
-0.3422287404537201,
-0.023294219747185707,
-0.09299053251743317,
0.5328037738800049,
-0.3386448323726654,
0.20066767930984497,
-0.16417141258716583,
-0.24426577985286713,
0.7124005556106567,
-0.16276027262210846,
0.6055299639701843,
0.24669809639453888,
-0.15122658014297485,
0.33181703090667725,
-0.3740570843219757,
-0.18842270970344543,
0.1900593787431717,
-0.19790850579738617,
-0.14249132573604584,
0.2759588956832886,
0.06166907399892807,
0.24890011548995972,
0.46019017696380615,
-0.3017736077308655,
0.21114283800125122,
-0.17294935882091522,
0.39157241582870483,
0.8105012774467468,
0.05537886172533035,
0.5271461009979248,
-0.39557379484176636,
0.8585532903671265,
-0.3283538520336151,
0.3053217828273773,
-0.3567250370979309,
-0.7357262372970581,
-0.4629005789756775,
-0.40861621499061584,
0.07660737633705139,
0.6661595106124878,
-0.43626654148101807,
0.4107561409473419,
-0.15307074785232544,
-0.5100786685943604,
-0.22493869066238403,
-0.07511516660451889,
0.2787240743637085,
0.15877586603164673,
0.0015223812079057097,
-0.33899226784706116,
-0.3070223331451416,
-0.9442098140716553,
-0.4905208349227905,
-0.5304689407348633,
0.005188373848795891,
0.6323615312576294,
0.08238379657268524,
-0.3568480610847473,
1.0596466064453125,
-0.4743741750717163,
-0.48682472109794617,
-0.6170321702957153,
-0.08553615212440491,
-0.21890456974506378,
0.36561688780784607,
0.6598638296127319,
-0.7128946781158447,
-0.7760398387908936,
0.1278417557477951,
-0.61989825963974,
-0.30661922693252563,
-0.3628453314304352,
0.3095596730709076,
0.04891388118267059,
0.3908649682998657,
-0.43989044427871704,
0.0642547681927681,
0.456327348947525,
-0.37926122546195984,
0.4212912321090698,
-0.3287643790245056,
0.030764946714043617,
-0.9945088624954224,
0.2821239233016968,
0.01285649836063385,
-0.38064298033714294,
-1.0166754722595215,
0.10322096943855286,
-0.46452265977859497,
-0.16410282254219055,
-0.2816177010536194,
0.9159041047096252,
-0.4226723909378052,
-0.5359387993812561,
-0.38240140676498413,
0.302254319190979,
-0.49045518040657043,
0.4515255093574524,
-0.020903950557112694,
0.8941218852996826,
0.444582998752594,
-0.3882609009742737,
0.44455572962760925,
0.28386762738227844,
0.006823380012065172,
0.5121596455574036,
-0.4757445752620697,
0.36064350605010986,
-0.18170928955078125,
0.4291626214981079,
-0.5836656093597412,
-0.3581538796424866,
0.4731732904911041,
-0.27806469798088074,
0.03421137481927872,
-0.01896887645125389,
-0.5805778503417969,
0.00578323332592845,
-0.22691696882247925,
0.3362346887588501,
0.6248636245727539,
-0.25673845410346985,
0.9966844320297241,
0.6731158494949341,
-0.5389339327812195,
-0.5357447862625122,
-0.5656135678291321,
0.3665791451931,
-0.37020590901374817,
-0.3044963479042053,
0.333773672580719,
-0.3976290822029114,
-0.5847472548484802,
-0.26942530274391174,
0.376922607421875,
-0.20965231955051422,
0.24514015018939972,
0.1870628446340561,
-0.07039687037467957,
0.12000524252653122,
-0.12636472284793854,
-0.2919585108757019,
-0.19706059992313385,
0.040600113570690155,
0.2117140293121338,
0.7558410167694092,
-0.1366148442029953,
-0.2487211972475052,
-0.4820621609687805,
0.3751639425754547,
0.5116853713989258,
-0.3352847695350647,
0.6147819757461548,
0.5277026295661926,
-0.06877309828996658,
-0.2567746341228485,
-0.5874877572059631,
-0.05835986137390137,
-0.4266868829727173,
0.2072398066520691,
-0.3967140316963196,
-0.8306007385253906,
0.854357123374939,
-0.15728186070919037,
0.22847707569599152,
-0.03707641735672951,
0.6800629496574402,
-0.03969641029834747,
0.8539853096008301,
0.6759547591209412,
-0.1082003191113472,
0.894615650177002,
0.02772442251443863,
0.3017102777957916,
-0.5507064461708069,
-0.4786767363548279,
-0.4435034394264221,
-0.2798462510108948,
-0.7791686654090881,
-0.4309322237968445,
0.12639622390270233,
-0.5538303852081299,
-0.08478032052516937,
0.09372404962778091,
-0.10160254687070847,
0.40062251687049866,
0.5830671191215515,
-0.31083282828330994,
0.26804953813552856,
-0.325034499168396,
0.5003838539123535,
-0.06064312532544136,
-0.32184943556785583,
-0.7867975234985352,
0.9004337787628174,
0.7094838619232178,
0.6890494227409363,
0.32594093680381775,
0.6911618113517761,
0.7204792499542236,
0.5906665325164795,
-0.8070066571235657,
0.8550874590873718,
-0.13076002895832062,
-0.45838648080825806,
-0.2786315679550171,
-0.19261431694030762,
-0.8505709767341614,
0.2794012129306793,
-0.05128580331802368,
-0.7816105484962463,
0.1694820672273636,
0.3197162449359894,
-0.20108608901500702,
-0.010974044911563396,
-0.4822717308998108,
0.8215503096580505,
-0.3869006931781769,
-0.26289740204811096,
-0.2556179165840149,
-0.6940413117408752,
0.3720757067203522,
-0.007184297312051058,
0.20840667188167572,
-0.09690501540899277,
-0.2950955927371979,
0.3625074625015259,
0.016029614955186844,
1.013159990310669,
-0.264121949672699,
-0.293870747089386,
0.16201253235340118,
0.06461898237466812,
0.4713265895843506,
0.03202982619404793,
0.03083185665309429,
-0.18880178034305573,
0.07206382602453232,
-0.34070900082588196,
-0.5819706320762634,
0.7796288132667542,
-0.8568946123123169,
-0.6110896468162537,
-0.6430147290229797,
-0.5553134083747864,
-0.48925644159317017,
0.1462458223104477,
-0.2899647653102875,
0.05761037394404411,
-0.858161985874176,
0.0524781197309494,
0.8472064137458801,
-0.5476530194282532,
0.336946040391922,
0.50167316198349,
-0.3634127080440521,
-0.2791787385940552,
1.1274361610412598,
-0.19102953374385834,
0.0524437315762043,
0.5613073706626892,
0.21145214140415192,
-0.24554234743118286,
-0.36665210127830505,
-0.1420680433511734,
0.5011724233627319,
-0.6069275736808777,
0.1920366883277893,
-0.6327914595603943,
-0.022065315395593643,
-0.6997622847557068,
-0.15525974333286285,
-0.291194885969162,
-0.028829239308834076,
-0.41389164328575134,
0.2085050642490387,
-0.10595691204071045,
0.9991747140884399,
0.20780663192272186,
0.43485936522483826,
-0.42384442687034607,
0.21088312566280365,
0.6778804063796997,
0.2717383801937103,
-0.09970836341381073,
-0.10371413081884384,
0.0641140416264534,
-0.26918402314186096,
-0.005353877320885658,
-0.8151143789291382,
0.5040112137794495,
0.22531913220882416,
0.8608110547065735,
0.41005104780197144,
-0.34372779726982117,
0.3037433922290802,
-0.49455854296684265,
0.9420403242111206,
-0.30676063895225525,
-0.6617653965950012,
0.21460963785648346,
-0.4061059355735779,
-0.029332952573895454,
0.3314879536628723,
-0.049250222742557526,
-0.9289490580558777,
-0.08485767245292664,
-0.3864060938358307,
-0.4406336843967438,
0.7082676887512207,
-0.11504896730184555,
0.35240453481674194,
0.28803229331970215,
0.4948725998401642,
0.11240676790475845,
0.20259149372577667,
-0.7977116107940674,
-0.4902973473072052,
-0.13123780488967896,
-0.12221028655767441,
-0.3316552937030792,
-0.19960837066173553,
-0.04903386905789375,
0.3570508360862732,
0.5987258553504944,
-0.37392109632492065,
0.2845420837402344,
-0.12182004749774933,
0.017739560455083847,
0.08486849069595337,
0.36429518461227417,
0.8821382522583008,
0.5819984078407288,
-0.07873189449310303,
0.021273085847496986,
-0.24398843944072723,
-0.3567853569984436,
0.1492016613483429,
-0.052589233964681625,
-0.32454174757003784,
-0.4624495804309845,
0.3419725000858307,
0.519780158996582,
-0.006784956436604261,
-1.091684103012085,
0.4315890073776245,
-0.2635183036327362,
0.09133350849151611,
-0.6921453475952148,
0.03897085040807724,
0.02000994049012661,
0.34618717432022095,
0.24407969415187836,
-0.15107516944408417,
-0.07310767471790314,
-0.9521170854568481,
0.033835187554359436,
0.5036942362785339,
-0.18793898820877075,
-0.5728752613067627,
0.4475031793117523,
0.4150366187095642,
-0.8481940627098083,
0.1471996158361435,
-0.011791878379881382,
-0.1334773600101471,
0.5478529334068298,
0.4814114272594452,
1.1918861865997314,
-0.43748652935028076,
0.5118702054023743,
-0.3033811151981354,
0.18306809663772583,
0.09250552952289581,
-0.02818106673657894,
0.023433217778801918,
-0.7093422412872314,
-0.0040859924629330635,
-0.33728328347206116,
-0.6615409255027771,
0.33080852031707764,
-0.21338105201721191,
-0.10398595035076141,
-0.6837874054908752,
-0.03698297590017319,
-0.1491515338420868,
0.2062716782093048,
-0.5055418014526367,
0.044107839465141296,
0.11555194854736328,
0.6068313121795654,
-0.8224213719367981,
0.8757259249687195,
1.1043473482131958,
-0.3461322784423828,
-0.17364804446697235,
0.3517000675201416,
-0.13721947371959686,
-0.5159167647361755,
0.5084096789360046,
-0.15215960144996643,
0.01718812994658947,
0.08669264614582062,
-0.20931075513362885,
-0.6732189059257507,
1.2171891927719116,
0.2410772740840912,
-0.045457471162080765,
-0.11706077307462692,
0.40747588872909546,
0.982596218585968,
-0.8144599199295044,
0.1914084404706955,
0.6868337392807007,
0.47238609194755554,
-0.19757354259490967,
-0.493802934885025,
-0.23446471989154816,
-0.08279944211244583,
0.28753340244293213,
-0.3464873433113098,
-0.9725713729858398,
0.6108890175819397,
0.17448414862155914,
-0.05971895903348923,
0.3596195578575134,
0.7593482136726379,
0.4226917624473572,
0.3362511694431305,
0.47660011053085327,
-0.09315510094165802,
0.34117430448532104,
0.11440080404281616,
0.8984729051589966,
-0.25542497634887695,
-0.06661169975996017,
0.9284012317657471,
-0.5957692861557007,
0.5405951142311096,
0.4434621334075928,
-0.12056954205036163,
0.5899178981781006,
0.5795599818229675,
0.06889745593070984,
0.29717400670051575,
0.1284683346748352,
-0.33274418115615845,
-0.21515974402427673,
-0.3946598172187805,
0.013766516931355,
0.4337657392024994,
0.34054550528526306,
-0.363002747297287,
0.08418110758066177,
0.22439144551753998,
-0.08760014176368713,
0.5492070913314819,
-0.022547906264662743,
0.8828526139259338,
-0.0341353714466095,
-0.9640951156616211,
-0.4234158992767334,
0.17633438110351562,
0.5726830363273621,
-0.7174076437950134,
-0.041925862431526184,
-0.47788575291633606,
0.12014661729335785,
0.09029535204172134,
-0.6781291365623474,
0.07397700846195221,
-0.029524503275752068,
-0.023937268182635307,
-0.7855475544929504,
0.8727260231971741,
-0.32100412249565125,
-0.027566982433199883,
0.26383474469184875,
0.8174222707748413,
0.24653850495815277,
0.21699249744415283,
-0.7523062825202942,
0.17261724174022675,
-0.1522037833929062,
-0.2711831331253052,
0.5647897720336914,
-0.022536907345056534,
-0.12175506353378296,
1.0780436992645264,
0.3267231285572052,
0.17739185690879822,
0.11247152835130692,
0.22352387011051178,
0.6374158263206482,
-0.6373599171638489,
-0.5270620584487915,
-0.4349234700202942,
0.2767874300479889,
0.1812874674797058,
-0.32565075159072876,
0.7051994800567627,
0.47051361203193665,
0.5622172951698303,
-0.3187677562236786,
0.7386094927787781,
-0.07673102617263794,
0.5227640271186829,
-0.14556348323822021,
0.5903674960136414,
-0.2492358386516571,
0.2241256833076477,
-0.1978456825017929,
-0.8979543447494507,
-0.26963579654693604,
0.3514646291732788,
-0.21330119669437408,
0.37149909138679504,
0.11483773589134216,
0.6208057999610901,
0.09477562457323074,
-0.29036945104599,
0.5414671301841736,
0.001305146375671029,
0.8053990006446838,
0.0663599893450737,
0.932651698589325,
0.0062214466743171215,
0.08129972219467163,
-0.27756574749946594,
-0.4470981955528259,
-0.4575294256210327,
-0.649066686630249,
-0.9683144688606262,
-0.6759153008460999,
-0.31959274411201477,
0.1385435163974762,
0.04600641503930092,
1.0122519731521606,
0.5750989317893982,
-0.6377375721931458,
-0.6344161629676819,
-0.058380309492349625,
0.21109142899513245,
-0.31095412373542786,
-0.27748602628707886,
-0.11727409809827805,
-0.274347186088562,
-1.1466830968856812,
0.7486032247543335,
0.21388372778892517,
0.10029128938913345,
-0.9930447340011597,
-0.10121062397956848,
-0.17216117680072784,
0.39194756746292114,
0.7089897394180298,
0.8995119333267212,
-0.9363248944282532,
-0.2157634198665619,
0.01832871325314045,
-0.19411121308803558,
-0.12950566411018372,
1.1931711435317993,
-0.8830410838127136,
0.27850157022476196,
0.5674453377723694,
0.5923188924789429,
0.12088897079229355,
0.20792214572429657,
0.7294136881828308,
-0.7674000263214111,
0.1027325987815857,
0.3982614576816559,
0.040951669216156006,
0.30997800827026367,
-0.44454285502433777,
0.3878377676010132,
0.13713957369327545,
-0.7343341112136841,
-0.8537799119949341,
0.6041938066482544,
-1.016525387763977,
-0.19559645652770996,
0.9496815204620361,
-0.19102038443088531,
-0.039460018277168274,
-0.22514651715755463,
-0.21302294731140137,
-0.08320625871419907,
-0.46051666140556335,
0.7693449854850769,
0.41183236241340637,
-0.5778042078018188,
-0.41581857204437256,
-0.527213990688324,
0.6586525440216064,
0.269967257976532,
-1.2235338687896729,
0.2144237607717514,
0.5621812343597412,
0.2816932499408722,
0.2746114134788513,
0.8649787306785583,
0.0792875587940216,
0.063502736389637,
-0.43452444672584534,
0.1443774700164795,
0.046846404671669006,
-0.49180617928504944,
-0.4147833287715912,
0.2980327308177948,
0.4714202880859375,
0.25052639842033386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18228v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18228v1
|
TextGram: Towards a better domain-adaptive pretraining
| 2024-04-28T15:44:57 | 2024-04-28T15:44:57 |
Sharayu Hiwarkhedkar, Saloni Mittal, Vidula Magdum, Omkar Dhekane, Raviraj Joshi, Geetanjali Kale, Arnav Ladkat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
For green AI, it is crucial to measure and reduce the carbon footprint
emitted during the training of large language models. In NLP, performing
pre-training on Transformer models requires significant computational
resources. This pre-training involves using a large amount of text data to gain
prior knowledge for performing downstream tasks. Thus, it is important that we
select the correct data in the form of domain-specific data from this vast
corpus to achieve optimum results aligned with our domain-specific tasks. While
training on large unsupervised data is expensive, it can be optimized by
performing a data selection step before pretraining. Selecting important data
reduces the space overhead and the substantial amount of time required to
pre-train the model while maintaining constant accuracy. We investigate the
existing selection strategies and propose our own domain-adaptive data
selection method - TextGram - that effectively selects essential data from
large corpora. We compare and evaluate the results of finetuned models for text
classification task with and without data selection. We show that the proposed
strategy works better compared to other selection methods.
|
[
-0.38349753618240356,
-0.439388245344162,
0.3369928300380707,
-0.03505145385861397,
-0.2160462737083435,
0.3003924489021301,
-0.3841782510280609,
-0.43899983167648315,
-0.20322556793689728,
0.5691267848014832,
-0.4075910449028015,
-0.4593127369880676,
-0.7541084885597229,
0.21931295096874237,
-0.22809718549251556,
1.179728627204895,
-0.11633158475160599,
-0.09157863259315491,
-0.37334975600242615,
-0.054278187453746796,
-0.6777083873748779,
-0.41766172647476196,
-0.8131946921348572,
-0.5419880151748657,
0.17334842681884766,
0.27795812487602234,
0.5109816193580627,
0.22382640838623047,
0.6821054220199585,
0.32933181524276733,
0.14965608716011047,
0.3773236572742462,
-0.6186954379081726,
-0.06951005011796951,
-0.38335859775543213,
-0.4230441153049469,
-0.2841885983943939,
0.060993559658527374,
0.3167695999145508,
0.7374759912490845,
0.19651682674884796,
0.14470483362674713,
0.15303663909435272,
0.7870230078697205,
-0.5545044541358948,
0.16646960377693176,
-0.9236034154891968,
0.23833389580249786,
-0.06769423931837082,
-0.40970858931541443,
-0.46405029296875,
-0.13973906636238098,
0.11685909330844879,
-0.9942800998687744,
0.308435320854187,
0.3639819025993347,
0.96625816822052,
0.480665922164917,
-0.09517589211463928,
-0.3114732801914215,
-0.827057957649231,
0.9574049115180969,
-0.2384614497423172,
0.49513348937034607,
0.7446537613868713,
0.1250392496585846,
0.261015921831131,
-0.7898851037025452,
-0.49577853083610535,
-0.04551752656698227,
-0.1799517720937729,
0.417986661195755,
-0.41974690556526184,
0.12513045966625214,
0.13502411544322968,
0.13392044603824615,
-0.8121806979179382,
0.21492527425289154,
-0.4399607479572296,
-0.30701351165771484,
0.5069063901901245,
-0.009758821688592434,
0.17495959997177124,
0.09973528236150742,
-0.012874643318355083,
-0.38364455103874207,
-0.3660261631011963,
-0.3822330832481384,
0.34814009070396423,
0.42620575428009033,
0.1210191547870636,
0.2477429211139679,
-0.07400713860988617,
0.8106314539909363,
0.15087996423244476,
0.13697294890880585,
0.36609190702438354,
-0.47518736124038696,
-0.29842856526374817,
0.039147261530160904,
0.5363612771034241,
0.17408038675785065,
0.5080702304840088,
-0.16976504027843475,
-0.05638934299349785,
0.20016950368881226,
0.588506281375885,
-1.035912036895752,
-0.569585919380188,
0.3372182846069336,
-0.5394315719604492,
-0.0017136525129899383,
-0.17055442929267883,
-0.8167849779129028,
0.006021241657435894,
-0.6308828592300415,
0.1241622045636177,
-0.5253757238388062,
-0.05192810669541359,
0.2758578658103943,
-0.14710986614227295,
-0.16619323194026947,
0.3708640933036804,
-0.985867977142334,
0.3548215329647064,
0.4138084650039673,
0.8026519417762756,
-0.41606706380844116,
-0.17753995954990387,
-0.465386301279068,
0.02437189407646656,
-0.45436713099479675,
0.999319851398468,
-0.8355481624603271,
-0.5831736326217651,
-0.17832611501216888,
-0.06743328273296356,
-0.34260302782058716,
-0.5689959526062012,
0.540122389793396,
-0.7224432229995728,
0.336344450712204,
0.1387614607810974,
-0.5427708625793457,
-0.14588923752307892,
0.18053516745567322,
-0.6739900708198547,
1.006088376045227,
0.4299719035625458,
-0.9886532425880432,
0.5971294641494751,
-0.8952429294586182,
-0.5138068199157715,
0.08914975821971893,
0.020476240664720535,
-0.5154774785041809,
-0.22318129241466522,
0.3022797107696533,
0.7401760220527649,
-0.06397442519664764,
0.07279022783041,
0.008018872700631618,
-0.2834269404411316,
-0.2667703926563263,
-0.33155059814453125,
0.6356732845306396,
0.5735433101654053,
-0.1430990993976593,
0.16715797781944275,
-0.8716574907302856,
0.20903536677360535,
0.05133529007434845,
-0.327452689409256,
-0.5637683868408203,
0.06256784498691559,
0.34961384534835815,
-0.11067911982536316,
-0.0035102867987006903,
-0.25426754355430603,
0.07718422263860703,
-0.45909562706947327,
0.3145926296710968,
0.7168287038803101,
-0.21769703924655914,
0.5458369255065918,
-0.30072152614593506,
0.6696555614471436,
-0.17294825613498688,
-0.14389003813266754,
0.12562961876392365,
-0.021426964551210403,
-0.5353972911834717,
-0.25604164600372314,
0.6371870636940002,
0.6597033739089966,
-0.9265904426574707,
0.7770296931266785,
-0.4313620328903198,
-0.7331575155258179,
-0.37358200550079346,
0.09225926548242569,
0.10279211401939392,
0.21712252497673035,
0.6104789972305298,
-0.18593943119049072,
-0.558290421962738,
-0.2828594446182251,
-0.13372065126895905,
0.010738578625023365,
-0.16827164590358734,
0.4349013566970825,
0.510844349861145,
-0.5993601083755493,
1.0025657415390015,
-1.0063235759735107,
-0.38815340399742126,
-0.30685552954673767,
0.11978799104690552,
0.1164293959736824,
0.44752001762390137,
0.7265464067459106,
-1.1370936632156372,
-0.5291919112205505,
0.2149433195590973,
-0.4275006651878357,
-0.049608126282691956,
-0.3068382143974304,
-0.32791194319725037,
0.004510796163231134,
0.5748175382614136,
-0.49316832423210144,
0.32266366481781006,
0.7619277834892273,
-0.3227067291736603,
0.30220282077789307,
-0.42584171891212463,
0.15175580978393555,
-0.8581864833831787,
0.2971445620059967,
-0.07795485109090805,
-0.47775813937187195,
-0.44989249110221863,
-0.35409849882125854,
-0.05282983183860779,
-0.1709434688091278,
-0.2536931037902832,
0.6386247873306274,
-0.4242473542690277,
0.061366721987724304,
-0.3822699785232544,
0.020265499129891396,
0.08102823048830032,
0.36640867590904236,
0.3771015405654907,
0.8426004648208618,
0.5385057926177979,
-0.9184138774871826,
0.08721090108156204,
0.7530204653739929,
-0.3968380093574524,
0.2696114182472229,
-0.32305729389190674,
0.39830970764160156,
-0.21612851321697235,
0.24536971747875214,
-0.7899633646011353,
0.07540552318096161,
-0.029805097728967667,
-0.39095625281333923,
0.39410653710365295,
0.31785833835601807,
-0.23426154255867004,
-0.35625705122947693,
0.03224201127886772,
0.42957189679145813,
0.5071907639503479,
-0.6068161129951477,
0.64472496509552,
0.5113354921340942,
-0.25837934017181396,
-0.18111823499202728,
-0.5123247504234314,
-0.1370764672756195,
-0.22744546830654144,
-0.0791415125131607,
0.632979154586792,
-0.32438409328460693,
0.059012722223997116,
-0.05434911325573921,
-0.14161577820777893,
-0.2922113537788391,
0.26713672280311584,
-0.017514614388346672,
0.244816392660141,
0.055247146636247635,
0.11671742796897888,
-0.037439122796058655,
-0.3828001618385315,
-0.2163635939359665,
-0.4987773597240448,
0.6728364825248718,
0.3538951277732849,
0.004899294581264257,
-0.37077435851097107,
0.1511044055223465,
0.24428631365299225,
-0.4202604293823242,
0.4885198473930359,
0.5875999927520752,
-0.28695496916770935,
-0.5821746587753296,
0.02237171120941639,
0.04395978897809982,
-0.501858115196228,
0.6141467690467834,
-0.053475502878427505,
-0.8716345429420471,
-0.1832895576953888,
-0.44214925169944763,
0.16230328381061554,
0.4599858224391937,
0.4087616503238678,
0.04186366870999336,
0.7346087694168091,
0.9887614250183105,
-0.22973711788654327,
0.7629262804985046,
-0.2034093141555786,
0.3816809356212616,
-0.570403516292572,
0.07175852358341217,
-1.0016601085662842,
0.09962843358516693,
-0.44940319657325745,
-0.49733930826187134,
0.04365100711584091,
-0.1722727119922638,
-0.2813660502433777,
0.47402793169021606,
-0.9229558706283569,
0.45494550466537476,
0.3084515631198883,
-0.02200750634074211,
0.009700450114905834,
0.08391544967889786,
0.2880858778953552,
-0.07455537468194962,
-0.7066660523414612,
-0.5436225533485413,
1.1254750490188599,
0.023447133600711823,
0.5803821682929993,
-0.4931800365447998,
0.2951850891113281,
0.383037805557251,
0.3057284653186798,
-0.7713842988014221,
0.4033092260360718,
-0.6079823970794678,
-0.3658975064754486,
-0.42010143399238586,
-0.530451238155365,
-1.2699531316757202,
0.1806667447090149,
-0.36826959252357483,
-0.40564996004104614,
-0.2392457127571106,
0.2689273953437805,
-0.5184255242347717,
0.16864030063152313,
-0.585784375667572,
0.8576351404190063,
-0.2591894865036011,
0.163839191198349,
-0.33704036474227905,
-0.4776184558868408,
-0.3474245071411133,
-0.7019898891448975,
0.29653894901275635,
-0.05506402999162674,
0.2662256956100464,
1.0645488500595093,
-0.17236338555812836,
0.6151028871536255,
-0.2955741882324219,
0.13949982821941376,
0.2839328944683075,
-0.17908699810504913,
0.4785749316215515,
-0.3400977849960327,
-0.21780191361904144,
0.38499388098716736,
-0.06848019361495972,
-0.27551206946372986,
-0.3579518795013428,
0.10018958896398544,
-0.8048443794250488,
-0.3230006992816925,
-0.3239628076553345,
-0.3135312795639038,
-0.5202269554138184,
0.3702288568019867,
0.5069602727890015,
0.1464630663394928,
-0.33311212062835693,
0.4138655364513397,
0.5986895561218262,
-0.37030884623527527,
0.45410841703414917,
0.19315098226070404,
0.018928874284029007,
-0.2036563605070114,
0.8188908100128174,
0.15187381207942963,
0.25289997458457947,
0.6876727342605591,
0.15902094542980194,
-0.06785143166780472,
-1.0294278860092163,
-0.049000054597854614,
-0.2079917937517166,
-0.5838601589202881,
-0.46771496534347534,
-0.9291735887527466,
-0.29195743799209595,
-0.28821250796318054,
-0.39193418622016907,
-0.2704388499259949,
-0.07703553885221481,
-0.5330325365066528,
-0.26984140276908875,
0.35890012979507446,
0.3418964445590973,
0.31280580163002014,
0.5218892097473145,
-0.8709720969200134,
0.5107848644256592,
0.16701450943946838,
0.22219811379909515,
-0.256348192691803,
-0.48663130402565,
-0.31267184019088745,
-0.07332576811313629,
-0.245858296751976,
-0.21549834311008453,
0.48771440982818604,
0.39481648802757263,
0.47800934314727783,
0.04790597781538963,
0.07417814433574677,
0.5940283536911011,
-0.9064433574676514,
0.6226615309715271,
0.2285914570093155,
-0.9369816184043884,
0.7118721604347229,
-0.1562281996011734,
0.3619018793106079,
0.8452651500701904,
0.6391773819923401,
-0.41978368163108826,
-0.17094390094280243,
-0.5520551204681396,
-0.9444601535797119,
0.7170048952102661,
0.2746092975139618,
0.41729921102523804,
0.12851038575172424,
0.21674665808677673,
0.41563382744789124,
0.17475497722625732,
-0.4829648733139038,
0.02472066879272461,
-0.40833356976509094,
-0.47423112392425537,
-0.3650156557559967,
0.24407006800174713,
0.1831790953874588,
-0.27866408228874207,
0.8095211386680603,
-0.48022976517677307,
0.32951363921165466,
0.12988683581352234,
-0.12657734751701355,
0.0469745509326458,
-0.004639003425836563,
0.1577891856431961,
0.7523488402366638,
-0.04602738469839096,
-0.15723514556884766,
0.34620094299316406,
-1.0313379764556885,
-0.03444986790418625,
0.08025428652763367,
-0.005226002540439367,
0.09153620153665543,
0.3782198429107666,
0.9919190406799316,
-0.03228404372930527,
-0.8223676085472107,
0.5351400375366211,
-0.17011114954948425,
-0.3554304838180542,
-0.14809061586856842,
0.40522927045822144,
-0.18282826244831085,
-0.07196061313152313,
0.1598070114850998,
0.5010114908218384,
-0.022700093686580658,
-0.2246488332748413,
0.3253175616264343,
0.26034992933273315,
-0.24062521755695343,
-0.14806309342384338,
0.675139307975769,
0.24491621553897858,
-0.19465869665145874,
0.7121285200119019,
0.04327571019530296,
-0.4539563059806824,
0.5725014209747314,
0.49603620171546936,
0.6927395462989807,
-0.1473141312599182,
0.30148008465766907,
0.349683552980423,
0.07484161108732224,
-0.16108103096485138,
0.024024907499551773,
0.09855365008115768,
-1.1011017560958862,
-0.4234354794025421,
-0.870447039604187,
-0.29905474185943604,
0.22367718815803528,
-0.4172201156616211,
0.2592394948005676,
-0.616902768611908,
-0.13514630496501923,
0.11307595670223236,
0.25073495507240295,
-1.0489346981048584,
0.826830267906189,
-0.0213475301861763,
0.8697616457939148,
-0.7600954174995422,
0.8856170773506165,
0.4654465317726135,
0.08456745743751526,
-0.7405166029930115,
0.14359475672245026,
-0.4824058711528778,
-0.830437958240509,
0.722023069858551,
0.11059587448835373,
-0.15012723207473755,
0.2661662995815277,
-0.6074082851409912,
-0.8327863812446594,
0.9144744277000427,
0.26495370268821716,
-0.7308711409568787,
0.03325314819812775,
-0.14566132426261902,
0.509752631187439,
-0.24983106553554535,
0.10529715567827225,
0.4929821491241455,
0.5362809896469116,
0.08112078160047531,
-0.72013920545578,
-0.06536213308572769,
-0.058165859431028366,
0.08854422718286514,
0.26287898421287537,
-0.6083020567893982,
0.5071344971656799,
0.15180934965610504,
-0.3197888731956482,
-0.25313809514045715,
0.7075716257095337,
0.05032555013895035,
0.19037671387195587,
0.8208527565002441,
0.20173993706703186,
1.195622444152832,
0.0972091555595398,
0.9794104099273682,
-0.3070566952228546,
0.3987234830856323,
0.8815114498138428,
-0.5633912682533264,
0.7928948402404785,
0.2307662069797516,
-0.5014510154724121,
0.05238770321011543,
0.8603569269180298,
-0.25678059458732605,
0.8129293322563171,
0.22527313232421875,
0.04743001610040665,
-0.17695428431034088,
0.05877900496125221,
-0.156986266374588,
0.6922781467437744,
0.18396133184432983,
-0.010930530726909637,
-0.0464257076382637,
0.24300558865070343,
0.10187909752130508,
0.19236037135124207,
-0.447477251291275,
0.8633549213409424,
-0.01134092640131712,
-0.7652238607406616,
0.5319632887840271,
-0.06382172554731369,
0.8772275447845459,
-0.8003491163253784,
0.08801290392875671,
0.09697248041629791,
0.12321121245622635,
-0.3547501862049103,
-0.5141623020172119,
0.541157603263855,
0.1567811816930771,
-0.1642570048570633,
-0.6346360445022583,
0.8860659599304199,
-0.28603458404541016,
-0.4068303406238556,
0.353740930557251,
0.2790774703025818,
0.08008348196744919,
-0.19122445583343506,
-0.6875895261764526,
-0.11090178787708282,
0.2127237468957901,
-0.23583774268627167,
0.22215405106544495,
0.3011464774608612,
-0.16221998631954193,
0.2949238121509552,
0.9199904203414917,
0.1751725822687149,
-0.37856829166412354,
-0.024229228496551514,
0.8135085105895996,
-0.5331805348396301,
-0.8330174684524536,
-0.5961990356445312,
0.28716760873794556,
-0.16273823380470276,
-0.3619765043258667,
0.42453521490097046,
0.5406562089920044,
1.1362991333007812,
-0.001526244217529893,
1.144951343536377,
0.03998628258705139,
0.4991539716720581,
-0.8965833187103271,
0.7940228581428528,
-0.3903471827507019,
-0.10360651463270187,
-0.35189783573150635,
-1.1587074995040894,
-0.32826900482177734,
0.8538761138916016,
-0.41487494111061096,
0.2179570347070694,
0.9635326266288757,
0.6179344058036804,
-0.08163243532180786,
0.1715204268693924,
0.33150458335876465,
0.03670203685760498,
0.28251829743385315,
0.47047367691993713,
0.5352662801742554,
-0.20370545983314514,
0.3372248411178589,
0.2960694432258606,
-0.16439680755138397,
0.05616861954331398,
-0.9507684111595154,
-0.9186124205589294,
-0.642970621585846,
-0.5169787406921387,
-0.016997573897242546,
-0.15795166790485382,
0.9682034254074097,
0.9429255723953247,
-0.8974204659461975,
0.09442374855279922,
-0.20706301927566528,
-0.1819874495267868,
-0.20246128737926483,
-0.11182904243469238,
0.5700785517692566,
-0.4500839114189148,
-0.7754912972450256,
0.30050426721572876,
0.13934218883514404,
0.08739974349737167,
0.4197770953178406,
0.07118405401706696,
-0.071014404296875,
0.15141840279102325,
0.5807681679725647,
0.09145080298185349,
0.10872075706720352,
-0.4461231827735901,
-0.37196919322013855,
0.08542302250862122,
0.3157193064689636,
0.8742446899414062,
-0.7357010245323181,
0.21212512254714966,
0.37470781803131104,
1.2104237079620361,
0.6068189740180969,
-0.024924827739596367,
0.37255164980888367,
-0.6178802847862244,
0.343554824590683,
0.4576111435890198,
0.16872766613960266,
0.4071255326271057,
-0.6380789279937744,
0.6288914680480957,
0.1262475550174713,
-0.7034453749656677,
-0.4964977204799652,
-0.0917578637599945,
-0.8544280529022217,
-0.8387771844863892,
1.1281527280807495,
-0.08356284350156784,
-0.20794552564620972,
-0.3711664378643036,
-0.43434038758277893,
0.20684252679347992,
-0.054868850857019424,
0.5340046882629395,
0.6525781750679016,
-0.09220892935991287,
0.2906678318977356,
-0.6610023379325867,
0.7668517827987671,
0.429730623960495,
-1.261071801185608,
0.25491863489151,
0.33602115511894226,
0.13858573138713837,
0.22977712750434875,
0.9165328741073608,
0.23788106441497803,
-0.15074816346168518,
0.0124985221773386,
-0.09123831242322922,
0.14320911467075348,
-0.5172264575958252,
-0.18062354624271393,
0.20307208597660065,
-0.10885079205036163,
-0.18560069799423218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18216v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18216v1
|
L3Cube-MahaNews: News-based Short Text and Long Document Classification Datasets in Marathi
| 2024-04-28T15:20:45 | 2024-04-28T15:20:45 |
Saloni Mittal, Vidula Magdum, Omkar Dhekane, Sharayu Hiwarkhedkar, Raviraj Joshi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The availability of text or topic classification datasets in the low-resource
Marathi language is limited, typically consisting of fewer than 4 target
labels, with some achieving nearly perfect accuracy. In this work, we introduce
L3Cube-MahaNews, a Marathi text classification corpus that focuses on News
headlines and articles. This corpus stands out as the largest supervised
Marathi Corpus, containing over 1.05L records classified into a diverse range
of 12 categories. To accommodate different document lengths, MahaNews comprises
three supervised datasets specifically designed for short text, long documents,
and medium paragraphs. The consistent labeling across these datasets
facilitates document length-based analysis. We provide detailed data statistics
and baseline results on these datasets using state-of-the-art pre-trained BERT
models. We conduct a comparative analysis between monolingual and multilingual
BERT models, including MahaBERT, IndicBERT, and MuRIL. The monolingual MahaBERT
model outperforms all others on every dataset. These resources also serve as
Marathi topic classification datasets or models and are publicly available at
https://github.com/l3cube-pune/MarathiNLP .
|
[
-0.48648515343666077,
-0.7679972648620605,
0.6402075886726379,
0.3873542547225952,
-0.3769347071647644,
0.058374859392642975,
-0.5260285139083862,
-0.5457468628883362,
0.2655365467071533,
0.581075131893158,
-0.35616931319236755,
-0.6001955270767212,
-0.7795936465263367,
0.10225158929824829,
-0.6198258399963379,
1.3104315996170044,
0.13956616818904877,
-0.05817683786153793,
-0.2096337527036667,
-0.28895652294158936,
-0.47394034266471863,
-0.5519167184829712,
-0.42288491129875183,
0.1394844502210617,
0.8036826252937317,
0.6983572840690613,
0.7428072690963745,
0.09920483827590942,
0.4897923171520233,
0.15964332222938538,
0.0036524375900626183,
0.32442545890808105,
-0.07859255373477936,
0.026411620900034904,
-0.15748858451843262,
-0.35797715187072754,
-0.1252874881029129,
-0.028206733986735344,
0.5240543484687805,
0.4862523376941681,
-0.10977800190448761,
0.0756058394908905,
0.20274487137794495,
0.8846094012260437,
-0.6632732152938843,
0.3452778458595276,
-0.24509067833423615,
-0.1328868418931961,
-0.8999624252319336,
0.12476078420877457,
-0.6340880393981934,
-0.6823633313179016,
-0.15450899302959442,
-0.22325003147125244,
0.16714784502983093,
0.01083362102508545,
1.0242847204208374,
-0.0785238966345787,
-0.6975519061088562,
-0.5420554280281067,
-0.5416483283042908,
0.9331132769584656,
-0.5627057552337646,
0.38088205456733704,
0.48066043853759766,
0.4388270378112793,
0.1398451328277588,
-0.6167820692062378,
-0.4002283811569214,
0.025347422808408737,
-0.22363153100013733,
0.10519822686910629,
-0.10126940160989761,
-0.1403452306985855,
0.1049761027097702,
0.43070197105407715,
-0.6297503113746643,
0.2625586688518524,
-0.590054988861084,
-0.24993450939655304,
0.34085318446159363,
0.14844374358654022,
0.19652730226516724,
-0.7180721759796143,
-0.08649855107069016,
0.1780128926038742,
-0.22452305257320404,
0.043729137629270554,
0.32947051525115967,
0.4812657833099365,
-0.15018053352832794,
0.6501805186271667,
-0.3426835536956787,
1.0481271743774414,
-0.3265637457370758,
-0.40124717354774475,
0.3478868007659912,
-0.2826576232910156,
0.008844510652124882,
0.2689138352870941,
0.7028191685676575,
0.12731091678142548,
0.021658441051840782,
0.18838703632354736,
0.06823764741420746,
0.22937749326229095,
0.20290368795394897,
-0.6977596282958984,
-0.11946293711662292,
0.009665640071034431,
-0.5041373372077942,
-0.4371338188648224,
-0.045015763491392136,
-0.8971074223518372,
-0.5711848139762878,
-0.2671543061733246,
0.2264258861541748,
-0.4441210627555847,
0.08665265142917633,
0.15288174152374268,
0.16037145256996155,
0.36198505759239197,
0.4328456223011017,
-1.0253031253814697,
0.2767563760280609,
0.5973509550094604,
0.8881617784500122,
-0.39780378341674805,
-0.025499915704131126,
-0.37342941761016846,
0.03142346069216728,
-0.24848009645938873,
0.6413540840148926,
-0.4186893403530121,
-0.305930495262146,
0.09298953413963318,
-0.029121089726686478,
0.18369163572788239,
-0.15694837272167206,
1.1386942863464355,
-0.49398067593574524,
0.3819411098957062,
-0.006096802186220884,
-0.5279501676559448,
-0.19030247628688812,
0.26804375648498535,
-0.8989709615707397,
0.9782858490943909,
0.19525110721588135,
-1.217228889465332,
0.35487863421440125,
-0.5294753313064575,
-0.725749135017395,
-0.10311352461576462,
-0.271275132894516,
-0.672588586807251,
-0.04882774129509926,
0.6219791769981384,
0.6324275135993958,
-0.1953640878200531,
0.3783460259437561,
-0.1645699292421341,
-0.12594781816005707,
-0.004493323620408773,
-0.3977247476577759,
0.8950300812721252,
0.47632306814193726,
0.008669203147292137,
0.05682728439569473,
-0.89274001121521,
-0.19135940074920654,
-0.04580940678715706,
-0.38755568861961365,
-0.5535829663276672,
0.10389600694179535,
0.16519653797149658,
0.06293971836566925,
0.312833309173584,
-0.9094763398170471,
0.2781369984149933,
0.05476608872413635,
0.2698338031768799,
0.4462287425994873,
0.1448676735162735,
0.3593011796474457,
-0.30846670269966125,
0.31938695907592773,
0.21424660086631775,
0.4780714809894562,
-0.01607644557952881,
-0.7955995798110962,
-0.7866199016571045,
-0.42912766337394714,
0.6075581312179565,
0.4488576650619507,
-0.8280829787254333,
0.18519563972949982,
-0.5750865936279297,
-0.6135334968566895,
-0.4482213854789734,
-0.010143797844648361,
-0.020873485133051872,
0.453590452671051,
0.39376235008239746,
-0.04104616492986679,
-0.6130262017250061,
-1.2284364700317383,
-0.09238886088132858,
0.15465466678142548,
0.28373828530311584,
0.13138163089752197,
0.1978152096271515,
-0.4999481737613678,
1.1839467287063599,
-0.5394381284713745,
-0.4569524824619293,
-0.5194565653800964,
0.4113510847091675,
0.5274006724357605,
0.20236103236675262,
0.47768834233283997,
-1.062146782875061,
-0.2751331031322479,
-0.22639459371566772,
-0.7129024863243103,
0.04405303671956062,
0.10412488132715225,
-0.19429346919059753,
0.7016081809997559,
0.45272067189216614,
-0.5369524955749512,
0.5772817134857178,
0.6181257367134094,
0.04649002477526665,
0.5478284955024719,
-0.05201663449406624,
0.10401079803705215,
-1.2377053499221802,
-0.3819693326950073,
-0.06644611060619354,
-0.4667218327522278,
-0.41652393341064453,
-0.21241185069084167,
0.487574964761734,
-0.5061385035514832,
-0.581474244594574,
0.5357340574264526,
-0.3336523473262787,
-0.11247724294662476,
-0.4056072533130646,
0.2052578181028366,
0.022623920813202858,
0.41733065247535706,
0.28253528475761414,
0.696231484413147,
0.47192269563674927,
-0.6757804155349731,
0.4940868318080902,
0.42877933382987976,
-0.8194996118545532,
0.15621107816696167,
-0.10089055448770523,
-0.2486952841281891,
-0.11200185120105743,
0.3962462544441223,
-0.6146469116210938,
-0.33358439803123474,
0.1696818619966507,
-0.5580281615257263,
0.23035891354084015,
0.06287924200296402,
-0.8235698342323303,
-0.5453165173530579,
-0.3109755516052246,
0.2507679760456085,
0.5150308012962341,
-0.5328198075294495,
0.5082603693008423,
0.4121568202972412,
-0.37461134791374207,
-0.5338053703308105,
-0.9224790930747986,
0.02913009189069271,
-0.0968572273850441,
-0.5595787763595581,
0.02046407386660576,
0.2467409372329712,
-0.03006298467516899,
0.11071036756038666,
-0.07333923876285553,
-0.2902143597602844,
-0.22900360822677612,
0.27821478247642517,
0.35718464851379395,
-0.07004023343324661,
0.4402742385864258,
0.00574294850230217,
-0.004637374542653561,
-0.16062504053115845,
-0.06317101418972015,
0.19393309950828552,
-0.4041703939437866,
-0.11162200570106506,
-0.05062945559620857,
0.32063984870910645,
0.398029088973999,
-0.38077330589294434,
0.8886769413948059,
0.8445332050323486,
-0.21064665913581848,
-0.07654765993356705,
-0.44391998648643494,
0.15660642087459564,
-0.36594903469085693,
0.1736360639333725,
-0.2672825753688812,
-0.798899233341217,
-0.040050774812698364,
0.24219706654548645,
0.15775035321712494,
0.5369215607643127,
0.48503005504608154,
-0.10110484063625336,
0.6170142889022827,
0.8461912274360657,
-0.5054906606674194,
0.2704472243785858,
-0.060499779880046844,
0.3290465474128723,
-0.5088305473327637,
-0.0628424882888794,
-0.6162782907485962,
0.047319862991571426,
-0.9088655710220337,
-0.38547736406326294,
0.22925420105457306,
-0.2185875028371811,
0.21375703811645508,
0.40738892555236816,
-0.4811350405216217,
0.3138672411441803,
0.5661986470222473,
0.2875755727291107,
0.27975136041641235,
-0.1251346617937088,
0.22195585072040558,
-0.1054721251130104,
-0.5689291954040527,
-0.5140798091888428,
1.0473549365997314,
0.2805110514163971,
1.0051789283752441,
0.34597039222717285,
0.8908607363700867,
0.6937009692192078,
0.2650054693222046,
-0.8721898198127747,
0.5361104011535645,
-0.27369341254234314,
-0.9001437425613403,
-0.35270196199417114,
-0.36128032207489014,
-0.9848942756652832,
0.05958481505513191,
-0.2574234902858734,
-0.35317349433898926,
0.11902724951505661,
-0.4253771901130676,
-0.27383628487586975,
0.3787045180797577,
-0.5286607146263123,
0.6898159384727478,
-0.3729507625102997,
-0.14645013213157654,
-0.26201608777046204,
-0.5279535055160522,
0.6467493176460266,
-0.45970672369003296,
0.6704608201980591,
-0.3921654224395752,
-0.07157490402460098,
1.008004903793335,
-0.38633817434310913,
0.6234764456748962,
0.05616843327879906,
-0.07264094799757004,
0.41918426752090454,
-0.3823927044868469,
0.2337331920862198,
0.22858348488807678,
-0.07053720951080322,
0.20648981630802155,
-0.2478746473789215,
-0.8443613648414612,
-0.2575417757034302,
0.7081244587898254,
-0.8551111221313477,
-0.4291262924671173,
-0.7868326306343079,
-0.28999218344688416,
-0.4594268798828125,
0.289413183927536,
0.3135746121406555,
0.821350634098053,
0.07790601998567581,
0.4764331877231598,
0.6713797450065613,
-0.43584775924682617,
0.42510831356048584,
0.45532864332199097,
-0.545066237449646,
-0.05448862910270691,
1.003857970237732,
-0.055530160665512085,
-0.10108323395252228,
0.5143152475357056,
-0.005124532151967287,
-0.12179867178201675,
-0.45534536242485046,
-0.13475379347801208,
0.06780588626861572,
-0.857123076915741,
-0.2671867311000824,
-0.6715659499168396,
-0.5752214193344116,
-0.34954237937927246,
-0.12493893504142761,
-0.2840101420879364,
-0.404825359582901,
-0.271189421415329,
-0.11335810273885727,
0.275049090385437,
0.5911048650741577,
-0.023855270817875862,
0.14798051118850708,
-1.0223166942596436,
0.5974655747413635,
0.36534926295280457,
0.36484500765800476,
-0.4245587885379791,
-0.4521006941795349,
-0.43979817628860474,
-0.052975621074438095,
-0.45956680178642273,
-0.9493142366409302,
0.19169755280017853,
0.011194703169167042,
0.4174511730670929,
0.20674926042556763,
0.2353130280971527,
0.22162942588329315,
-0.33449918031692505,
0.7988060116767883,
0.21946384012699127,
-0.7923423051834106,
0.9417593479156494,
-0.5400505065917969,
0.26652538776397705,
0.6124440431594849,
0.718877911567688,
-0.39621901512145996,
-0.5200778841972351,
-0.4460485875606537,
-0.8625490069389343,
0.6641268730163574,
0.37199288606643677,
-0.0197908952832222,
-0.25608164072036743,
0.011338571086525917,
0.35951104760169983,
-0.030691007152199745,
-0.8305498957633972,
-0.08254342526197433,
-0.08064325898885727,
-0.39350366592407227,
-0.3243280053138733,
-0.39679715037345886,
0.2784045338630676,
-0.20798687636852264,
0.9576200842857361,
0.1821533441543579,
0.11557088792324066,
0.08979389816522598,
-0.577104926109314,
0.5630540251731873,
0.6483994126319885,
0.6386851668357849,
0.7435575723648071,
-0.4832876920700073,
-0.00749659538269043,
0.11665622144937515,
-0.5922704935073853,
0.17756174504756927,
0.10470277070999146,
0.02938496321439743,
0.49847838282585144,
0.33621135354042053,
0.6901435852050781,
0.37337160110473633,
-0.5333595275878906,
0.6101260781288147,
-0.3262025713920593,
-0.1097707599401474,
-0.5082535147666931,
-0.2349115014076233,
0.05310725420713425,
-0.06539824604988098,
0.13878053426742554,
-0.04190490394830704,
0.23123790323734283,
-0.6515663266181946,
0.15977467596530914,
-0.1791650950908661,
-0.3385533392429352,
0.31278905272483826,
0.45061150193214417,
0.446615993976593,
0.19788096845149994,
0.9259336590766907,
0.08771943300962448,
-0.25453707575798035,
0.422270804643631,
-0.07749401777982712,
0.48483771085739136,
0.1827312707901001,
0.26134029030799866,
0.47697240114212036,
0.26777416467666626,
-0.03839358314871788,
-0.05954602360725403,
-0.1643046736717224,
-0.5190243721008301,
-0.34542104601860046,
-1.0540010929107666,
-0.665656328201294,
0.1837296187877655,
-0.9623727202415466,
0.7216521501541138,
-0.23524415493011475,
-0.3077932298183441,
0.31047937273979187,
0.32447659969329834,
-0.2952617108821869,
0.20491673052310944,
0.5778017640113831,
1.1346254348754883,
-0.7638331055641174,
1.3942371606826782,
0.5196998715400696,
-0.42266619205474854,
-0.35160908102989197,
-0.07986016571521759,
-0.12264113128185272,
-0.40569666028022766,
0.6540245413780212,
0.4234483242034912,
0.03007526323199272,
-0.15892046689987183,
-0.3288968801498413,
-0.6569805145263672,
0.8091630935668945,
-0.16947665810585022,
-0.7404679656028748,
0.009350353851914406,
0.111995168030262,
0.1968247890472412,
-0.08226905763149261,
-0.06236562877893448,
0.4025743007659912,
0.5881741642951965,
-0.36492276191711426,
-0.7759338021278381,
-0.48013895750045776,
-0.02697513997554779,
0.01626913994550705,
0.5976538062095642,
-0.6206932663917542,
0.7018256187438965,
-0.1424831748008728,
-0.059800099581480026,
0.08366486430168152,
0.9526893496513367,
0.11405020952224731,
0.18558067083358765,
0.3143960237503052,
0.6176905632019043,
0.6056484580039978,
-0.31988123059272766,
1.1788398027420044,
-0.1169668436050415,
0.49304530024528503,
1.102107048034668,
-0.02293260209262371,
0.8407040238380432,
0.08907314389944077,
-0.1857668161392212,
0.6944823265075684,
0.8560827374458313,
-0.06598008424043655,
0.6470075249671936,
0.15364950895309448,
-0.2528587877750397,
-0.09954775124788284,
0.1662256121635437,
-0.31952494382858276,
0.41178926825523376,
0.4791831374168396,
0.029860517010092735,
-0.4988935589790344,
0.7005072236061096,
0.0559648796916008,
0.08511543273925781,
-0.4852793216705322,
0.5235939621925354,
0.07006146758794785,
-0.4751841127872467,
0.387360543012619,
0.2999049127101898,
0.874631941318512,
-0.7747639417648315,
0.4210300147533417,
-0.26910334825515747,
0.3195134699344635,
-0.20983745157718658,
-1.2171481847763062,
0.4797588288784027,
0.09570284187793732,
-0.4719528257846832,
-0.010393491014838219,
1.0261225700378418,
-0.27706751227378845,
-0.5271120667457581,
0.17500969767570496,
0.14970889687538147,
0.21879571676254272,
0.026835883036255836,
-0.4565175473690033,
0.1506364494562149,
-0.17537477612495422,
-0.08884509652853012,
0.24425923824310303,
0.25974518060684204,
-0.45847800374031067,
0.5312975645065308,
0.32178598642349243,
-0.124296173453331,
0.14204856753349304,
0.06792349368333817,
0.540978193283081,
-0.829610288143158,
-0.6692371964454651,
-0.6156997680664062,
0.0002584461763035506,
-0.2250256985425949,
-0.09893964231014252,
0.9497312903404236,
0.9312543869018555,
0.639411449432373,
-0.1219092532992363,
1.0267201662063599,
-0.17871282994747162,
0.8664401173591614,
-0.5356000661849976,
0.599328875541687,
-0.5763411521911621,
-0.1161700189113617,
-0.014407501555979252,
-0.8449909090995789,
-0.07628796249628067,
0.1922231763601303,
-0.3483976423740387,
-0.012535786256194115,
0.7275972366333008,
0.3272435665130615,
-0.19007033109664917,
0.3224462866783142,
0.28241434693336487,
0.09152986854314804,
0.18667495250701904,
0.615436315536499,
0.8695275783538818,
-0.19003142416477203,
0.7484036087989807,
-0.4436793923377991,
-0.23708590865135193,
-0.5425748229026794,
-0.7119584679603577,
-0.8933887481689453,
-0.813882052898407,
-0.1979197859764099,
-0.17724578082561493,
0.09416338801383972,
0.47561612725257874,
0.6886664628982544,
-0.7535678148269653,
-0.03698359429836273,
0.025188453495502472,
0.12580792605876923,
0.292235791683197,
-0.288603812456131,
0.4233699142932892,
-0.6298917531967163,
-0.5237314105033875,
0.06458874046802521,
0.22041155397891998,
-0.1255718320608139,
0.04614429175853729,
0.14509451389312744,
-0.47164368629455566,
0.11614495515823364,
0.7848639488220215,
0.36935555934906006,
-0.5772019624710083,
-0.038963913917541504,
-0.42464011907577515,
-0.712063729763031,
-0.011893369257450104,
0.5850426554679871,
-0.7517233490943909,
0.25105583667755127,
0.3924480378627777,
0.5709395408630371,
0.8331794738769531,
-0.0844942107796669,
-0.01678244210779667,
-0.7918115258216858,
0.39201563596725464,
0.27026382088661194,
0.35782504081726074,
0.41474270820617676,
-0.21024726331233978,
0.6087606549263,
0.01613149605691433,
-0.5214454531669617,
-0.505919873714447,
0.14849473536014557,
-1.2920328378677368,
-0.5681974291801453,
1.2292585372924805,
0.09018098562955856,
-0.4429023861885071,
-0.09471895545721054,
-0.44305503368377686,
0.2825072705745697,
-0.21879978477954865,
0.4974888563156128,
0.9937498569488525,
-0.07273906469345093,
-0.2396215796470642,
-1.0085052251815796,
0.40464478731155396,
0.187709778547287,
-1.0791566371917725,
-0.15507148206233978,
0.5237395167350769,
0.18935883045196533,
0.22360782325267792,
0.7006535530090332,
-0.23694388568401337,
0.4026276469230652,
-0.3522036075592041,
0.14658352732658386,
0.023835811764001846,
-0.4589749872684479,
-0.18346808850765228,
0.04145423695445061,
-0.0639503076672554,
-0.3706681728363037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01585v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01585v1
|
Tabular Embedding Model (TEM): Finetuning Embedding Models For Tabular RAG Applications
| 2024-04-28T14:58:55 | 2024-04-28T14:58:55 |
Sujit Khanna, Shishir Subedi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
In recent times Large Language Models have exhibited tremendous capabilities,
especially in the areas of mathematics, code generation and general-purpose
reasoning. However for specialized domains especially in applications that
require parsing and analyzing large chunks of numeric or tabular data even
state-of-the-art (SOTA) models struggle. In this paper, we introduce a new
approach to solving domain-specific tabular data analysis tasks by presenting a
unique RAG workflow that mitigates the scalability issues of existing tabular
LLM solutions. Specifically, we present Tabular Embedding Model (TEM), a novel
approach to fine-tune embedding models for tabular Retrieval-Augmentation
Generation (RAG) applications. Embedding models form a crucial component in the
RAG workflow and even current SOTA embedding models struggle as they are
predominantly trained on textual datasets and thus underperform in scenarios
involving complex tabular data. The evaluation results showcase that our
approach not only outperforms current SOTA embedding models in this domain but
also does so with a notably smaller and more efficient model structure.
|
[
-0.3433760106563568,
-1.3132380247116089,
0.5537357330322266,
-0.09672825038433075,
-0.19735614955425262,
0.26414304971694946,
-0.014998314902186394,
-0.01410351600497961,
0.10536513477563858,
0.7048379182815552,
-0.18281467258930206,
-0.7491452097892761,
-0.42088082432746887,
-0.32697340846061707,
-0.36746901273727417,
0.8732382655143738,
-0.22984740138053894,
0.17627283930778503,
-0.5830017924308777,
0.08919333666563034,
-0.8492807149887085,
-0.24270032346248627,
-0.3453064262866974,
-0.19136439263820648,
0.22766433656215668,
0.7847766876220703,
0.6218443512916565,
0.8095020651817322,
0.6741095185279846,
0.25243446230888367,
-0.09277823567390442,
0.4366377890110016,
-0.6475109457969666,
0.27086108922958374,
-0.2536493241786957,
-0.5247126817703247,
-0.8466249704360962,
-0.17411307990550995,
0.880929708480835,
0.7572991251945496,
-0.3939622938632965,
0.3915749788284302,
0.07164015620946884,
0.5647501945495605,
-0.41787394881248474,
0.05997470021247864,
-0.7867358922958374,
0.21212056279182434,
-0.40889349579811096,
-0.33591651916503906,
-0.5979704856872559,
-0.4584837257862091,
0.04089253023266792,
-0.49184849858283997,
0.2117905616760254,
0.17208635807037354,
0.7322712540626526,
0.26991868019104004,
-0.38098037242889404,
0.02157049998641014,
-0.9362950325012207,
0.5547469258308411,
-0.657910168170929,
0.4394725263118744,
0.19234594702720642,
0.6317739486694336,
-0.13614410161972046,
-0.797857940196991,
-0.40358564257621765,
-0.32805323600769043,
0.08895774930715561,
-0.1267150342464447,
0.09722917526960373,
-0.1586921513080597,
0.14936619997024536,
0.2469790130853653,
-0.7945009469985962,
0.018526915460824966,
-0.23979289829730988,
0.44022899866104126,
0.15937530994415283,
0.6855248212814331,
0.3495783507823944,
0.09344840794801712,
-0.5136147141456604,
0.16172340512275696,
-0.7451026439666748,
-0.23395204544067383,
0.006670070346444845,
0.44203200936317444,
-0.12261036783456802,
0.6662679314613342,
0.08583920449018478,
0.7406296730041504,
-0.11599627137184143,
0.15516319870948792,
-0.0542130284011364,
-0.004152938723564148,
-0.4149935245513916,
-0.3973883092403412,
0.1747490018606186,
0.11188390105962753,
0.02586239017546177,
-0.3821527063846588,
-0.38575035333633423,
0.20412418246269226,
0.5784375667572021,
-0.6149060726165771,
0.0653771460056305,
0.16902071237564087,
-0.24400591850280762,
-0.4468952417373657,
0.11314993351697922,
-0.7977069616317749,
-0.5246066451072693,
-0.318575382232666,
0.5553178787231445,
-0.3512546718120575,
-0.14452500641345978,
0.07457617670297623,
0.2173176258802414,
0.23932474851608276,
0.3014189302921295,
-0.5726231932640076,
0.5803950428962708,
1.1215870380401611,
0.8486069440841675,
-0.23178614675998688,
-0.12583743035793304,
-0.8241379857063293,
0.356411337852478,
-0.5509611368179321,
1.093984603881836,
-0.950780987739563,
-0.20516611635684967,
0.09748996049165726,
-0.06342490017414093,
-0.039311088621616364,
-0.6777592301368713,
0.5491957068443298,
-0.7261124849319458,
-0.30980774760246277,
-0.08281412720680237,
-0.9135989546775818,
-0.25135764479637146,
0.4383721649646759,
-0.8863787055015564,
0.9009382724761963,
0.3678412437438965,
-0.49449458718299866,
0.2982010543346405,
-0.7416296005249023,
-0.009466461837291718,
0.33691319823265076,
-0.16059237718582153,
-0.6982091665267944,
0.31648483872413635,
-0.16057415306568146,
0.700016438961029,
-0.7808362245559692,
0.4300660789012909,
-0.47849270701408386,
-0.32299530506134033,
0.1446210741996765,
0.08352909982204437,
0.1016753613948822,
0.24173061549663544,
0.1144881471991539,
-0.03009682707488537,
-0.30957210063934326,
0.12223413586616516,
0.21122018992900848,
-0.14078079164028168,
-0.31441348791122437,
-0.10359172523021698,
0.2535548210144043,
0.06267795711755753,
0.13168427348136902,
-0.41573789715766907,
0.3399665355682373,
-0.23347775638103485,
0.22779859602451324,
0.47529685497283936,
-0.01433385070413351,
0.7040724754333496,
-0.510566234588623,
0.6474884152412415,
0.23327019810676575,
-0.0037319075781852007,
0.060016315430402756,
-0.12113413959741592,
-0.37701451778411865,
-0.08872377872467041,
0.7856569290161133,
0.44511905312538147,
-0.7048565745353699,
0.10098157823085785,
-0.48509982228279114,
-0.728820264339447,
-0.18713098764419556,
0.0010179743403568864,
0.3577756881713867,
0.4880725145339966,
0.2938801348209381,
-0.0726190060377121,
-0.39194127917289734,
-1.0207538604736328,
-0.5011186599731445,
0.5505044460296631,
0.1223730817437172,
0.26818808913230896,
0.5181727409362793,
-0.392813116312027,
0.8580483794212341,
-0.5706068873405457,
-0.509215235710144,
-0.6354052424430847,
0.06453382223844528,
0.117144376039505,
0.6613544225692749,
0.3576137125492096,
-0.8853089213371277,
-1.0173428058624268,
0.31435438990592957,
-0.5986517667770386,
-0.026995349675416946,
-0.055299218744039536,
-0.11091512441635132,
0.19136463105678558,
0.35801172256469727,
-0.5071403384208679,
0.6451156735420227,
0.23300276696681976,
-0.6766003370285034,
0.2260867804288864,
-0.09493733197450638,
-0.04328485205769539,
-1.0018272399902344,
-0.07519885897636414,
0.19284532964229584,
-0.6466212868690491,
-1.0145334005355835,
0.4336943030357361,
0.3351663649082184,
-0.33669716119766235,
-0.3861769735813141,
0.5194314122200012,
-0.5097315311431885,
-0.27653345465660095,
-0.2497929334640503,
0.13266970217227936,
0.2569303512573242,
0.3463156819343567,
-0.2551001012325287,
0.6243227124214172,
0.34566429257392883,
-0.6091384291648865,
0.06942563503980637,
0.2801121175289154,
-0.1143171563744545,
0.5850251913070679,
-0.6403090357780457,
0.058016587048769,
-0.17352376878261566,
0.013938815332949162,
-0.8947856426239014,
-0.07456526160240173,
-0.12187696248292923,
-0.3250361979007721,
0.888097882270813,
-0.34229719638824463,
-0.4052109122276306,
-0.18969684839248657,
-0.4359380006790161,
0.4739394187927246,
0.3012933135032654,
-0.41622698307037354,
0.902672529220581,
0.921014666557312,
-0.19534601271152496,
-0.29680994153022766,
-0.4420529007911682,
-0.05163175240159035,
-0.4122852385044098,
-0.7692123055458069,
0.856479287147522,
0.1696576625108719,
-0.08324763923883438,
0.16353127360343933,
-0.2845917046070099,
-0.3163662850856781,
0.08307932317256927,
-0.03342055529356003,
0.3253933787345886,
-0.22973047196865082,
0.1436888575553894,
0.06674101203680038,
-0.3286955654621124,
-0.24764369428157806,
-0.23991644382476807,
0.8009843230247498,
-0.3598329722881317,
-0.06996270269155502,
-0.35261616110801697,
0.5659697651863098,
0.40553614497184753,
-0.2877396047115326,
0.9415638446807861,
0.5237113833427429,
-0.8224281072616577,
-0.4635448753833771,
-0.7509268522262573,
0.018932972103357315,
-0.4708026051521301,
0.5752806663513184,
-0.498572438955307,
-0.6402819156646729,
0.6324180960655212,
-0.34725502133369446,
0.10379410535097122,
0.3336007297039032,
0.7036874294281006,
-0.22433707118034363,
0.7413709163665771,
0.72530597448349,
0.25605857372283936,
0.42443642020225525,
-0.5782533884048462,
0.04118574783205986,
-0.8388023972511292,
-0.3644384741783142,
-0.5801959037780762,
-0.450613796710968,
-0.5465027093887329,
-0.8274809122085571,
0.47455188632011414,
-0.26831209659576416,
-0.30985552072525024,
0.164199098944664,
-0.4304800033569336,
0.605968177318573,
0.2211921662092209,
0.14733491837978363,
0.12679758667945862,
0.24006980657577515,
-0.06705116480588913,
-0.10125844925642014,
-0.7202203869819641,
-0.7420021891593933,
1.038853645324707,
0.4966725707054138,
0.9808525443077087,
0.03748076409101486,
0.607422947883606,
0.6024808883666992,
0.20403066277503967,
-0.7125145792961121,
0.4174673855304718,
-0.5725077390670776,
-0.3911818563938141,
-0.4826579689979553,
-0.48107805848121643,
-0.9434909224510193,
0.13539116084575653,
-0.26539525389671326,
-0.6801693439483643,
0.0853397473692894,
0.05918514356017113,
-0.31499528884887695,
0.5980333089828491,
-0.7149416208267212,
1.0595574378967285,
0.22124336659908295,
-0.665956974029541,
-0.03518497943878174,
-0.06692536175251007,
0.161403089761734,
-0.1271466314792633,
0.15950949490070343,
-0.06276781857013702,
-0.17312172055244446,
0.7275651693344116,
-0.44699352979660034,
0.5281336307525635,
-0.5315979719161987,
0.05729180574417114,
0.49692031741142273,
0.5022522211074829,
0.709805428981781,
0.07089917361736298,
0.05922103300690651,
-0.1508607566356659,
0.10943134874105453,
-0.2969297170639038,
-0.8113821744918823,
0.8101071715354919,
-0.49830979108810425,
-0.6185068488121033,
-0.1256127655506134,
-0.6572296023368835,
-0.35593315958976746,
-0.082459956407547,
-0.15050575137138367,
0.6438220143318176,
-0.1576840728521347,
0.6431013345718384,
0.7531453371047974,
-0.14535725116729736,
0.09401554614305496,
0.4538842737674713,
-0.14827613532543182,
-0.22316952049732208,
0.9519942402839661,
0.5096610188484192,
-0.18510892987251282,
0.568778932094574,
0.30152228474617004,
-0.2698414921760559,
-0.5078337788581848,
-0.26931512355804443,
0.1489618718624115,
-0.34123510122299194,
-0.618346095085144,
-0.6116872429847717,
-0.11284103244543076,
-0.11959824711084366,
-0.12856820225715637,
-0.6788638830184937,
-0.5902608633041382,
-0.029457472264766693,
0.01563163287937641,
0.4490903913974762,
0.9057101607322693,
0.2433457374572754,
0.4791328012943268,
-1.0024741888046265,
0.599528431892395,
0.07725636661052704,
0.7137174606323242,
0.1142798587679863,
-0.725680947303772,
-0.5852005481719971,
-0.16636602580547333,
-0.4279996454715729,
-1.2143306732177734,
0.6139992475509644,
-0.0248246006667614,
0.5536226630210876,
-0.12960922718048096,
-0.13045594096183777,
0.6781859397888184,
-0.7377670407295227,
0.36661359667778015,
-0.30834338068962097,
-0.8775748610496521,
0.28424742817878723,
-0.45656129717826843,
-0.04642132297158241,
0.4201070964336395,
0.3123945891857147,
-0.2804883122444153,
0.08073598146438599,
-0.45865878462791443,
-0.8394296169281006,
0.6610977649688721,
-0.13895951211452484,
-0.06859852373600006,
0.31855717301368713,
0.5260404348373413,
0.3111606538295746,
0.008904601447284222,
-0.7303143739700317,
-0.06595250219106674,
0.21653850376605988,
-0.2740161716938019,
0.33438748121261597,
-0.6017802953720093,
0.13370847702026367,
-0.1473720818758011,
0.598660945892334,
0.12642529606819153,
0.3882450759410858,
-0.14715300500392914,
-0.3350721299648285,
-0.22369258105754852,
0.3272026777267456,
0.24111308157444,
0.5623732209205627,
-0.05724659562110901,
-0.0923493430018425,
0.34671956300735474,
-0.500739336013794,
0.10424572974443436,
0.005860229022800922,
-0.2595089375972748,
-0.13066406548023224,
-0.10955893248319626,
0.47220444679260254,
0.1784430891275406,
-0.2468031495809555,
0.3714725375175476,
-0.06384264677762985,
-0.029659856110811234,
-0.2884347140789032,
-0.12788794934749603,
0.1185307502746582,
0.40785178542137146,
0.27370449900627136,
-0.34207433462142944,
0.43345409631729126,
-0.3905981779098511,
0.32855477929115295,
0.581148087978363,
-0.106899693608284,
-0.15456777811050415,
0.548919677734375,
-0.2692435085773468,
-0.5008505582809448,
0.190116748213768,
-0.15662406384944916,
-0.37798354029655457,
0.7324643731117249,
0.7931909561157227,
0.8880689740180969,
-0.3743568956851959,
0.39425191283226013,
0.1003272756934166,
0.22125695645809174,
0.10887085646390915,
0.5963941812515259,
0.33154815435409546,
-0.4138118028640747,
-0.15400303900241852,
-0.5496434569358826,
-0.49781179428100586,
0.06799892336130142,
-0.6994508504867554,
0.44559794664382935,
-0.3426879048347473,
-0.34676593542099,
-0.12669290602207184,
0.14796602725982666,
-1.1026829481124878,
0.10024523735046387,
-0.009406547993421555,
0.834686279296875,
-0.6865347623825073,
0.7069636583328247,
0.8531462550163269,
-0.18978597223758698,
-0.8273170590400696,
-0.12885791063308716,
-0.425485223531723,
-0.40490663051605225,
0.3451227843761444,
0.04729558154940605,
0.25099217891693115,
-0.02037293277680874,
-0.25655001401901245,
-0.867334246635437,
1.1037676334381104,
0.34205806255340576,
-0.5303599834442139,
-0.15145130455493927,
0.5070726275444031,
0.4426176846027374,
-0.531474232673645,
0.13900931179523468,
0.741484522819519,
0.46620625257492065,
-0.2391418218612671,
-0.5543248653411865,
0.2106517106294632,
-0.20397602021694183,
0.35485878586769104,
0.2532308101654053,
-0.4780181050300598,
0.9661010503768921,
0.10106401145458221,
-0.09046187996864319,
-0.1474517285823822,
0.5568943619728088,
0.2901945114135742,
0.5202969908714294,
0.31813323497772217,
0.7015853524208069,
0.6429930329322815,
-0.09440461546182632,
0.8529936075210571,
-0.15333910286426544,
0.44482338428497314,
1.3351131677627563,
-0.35225242376327515,
1.012001872062683,
0.27086663246154785,
-0.10173927247524261,
0.4089285433292389,
0.33675509691238403,
-0.0551816001534462,
0.4233923852443695,
0.19689218699932098,
0.01933867484331131,
-0.17092107236385345,
-0.1594759076833725,
-0.3820633888244629,
0.5671736598014832,
0.7423380017280579,
-0.14644108712673187,
-0.40022870898246765,
-0.06939337402582169,
-0.28570452332496643,
0.3615545928478241,
-0.4075751304626465,
0.7223457098007202,
-0.015332656912505627,
-0.23755080997943878,
0.5177429914474487,
0.11950211971998215,
0.2198455035686493,
-0.20098310708999634,
-0.186106339097023,
-0.33299922943115234,
0.05569298192858696,
-0.3191884160041809,
-0.6514922976493835,
0.5863001346588135,
0.2843547761440277,
-0.12347063422203064,
-0.020637376233935356,
0.7991482615470886,
-0.4028100073337555,
-0.482858806848526,
0.19348467886447906,
0.9227869510650635,
-0.054323408752679825,
0.051473189145326614,
-0.44082462787628174,
0.05591436102986336,
-0.33811941742897034,
-0.4595896005630493,
0.29197806119918823,
0.8151772022247314,
-0.1613745242357254,
0.6907726526260376,
0.3715507686138153,
-0.10837536305189133,
0.08429224789142609,
0.18734273314476013,
1.1838459968566895,
-0.8619847297668457,
-0.6345112323760986,
-1.014196515083313,
0.7067646384239197,
0.07929698377847672,
0.4075402021408081,
0.4514845907688141,
0.7534242868423462,
0.35664448142051697,
-0.397838294506073,
0.38841742277145386,
0.22415634989738464,
0.7468026876449585,
-0.4242652952671051,
0.8046811819076538,
-0.764880359172821,
0.43386152386665344,
-0.3551327884197235,
-1.0646885633468628,
-0.4988872706890106,
0.4793268144130707,
-0.4390125572681427,
0.09976515918970108,
0.5526047348976135,
0.7735115885734558,
-0.22563646733760834,
-0.05695002153515816,
0.5960367918014526,
0.30815577507019043,
0.21498176455497742,
0.4649741053581238,
0.8866302371025085,
-0.3121269643306732,
0.3842395544052124,
0.0617598220705986,
-0.21144379675388336,
-0.33670616149902344,
-0.771135151386261,
-0.9372814297676086,
-0.5789206624031067,
-0.12028235197067261,
-0.051826111972332,
0.0037401679437607527,
0.862425684928894,
0.48956310749053955,
-0.6352249383926392,
-0.11396796256303787,
-0.18230344355106354,
0.2866275906562805,
0.15733705461025238,
-0.29311633110046387,
0.35481229424476624,
-0.3974880874156952,
-0.7237937450408936,
0.1814681738615036,
0.2509230077266693,
0.006025473587214947,
-0.16143642365932465,
0.25421708822250366,
-0.10409297049045563,
0.1948980987071991,
0.47762352228164673,
-0.018115868791937828,
-0.4518187940120697,
-0.02606184408068657,
0.08684485405683517,
-0.043980710208415985,
0.2111569494009018,
0.664933979511261,
-0.7796919941902161,
0.2038031816482544,
0.6144625544548035,
1.0375162363052368,
0.7421447038650513,
-0.01448129303753376,
0.5487646460533142,
-0.6846987009048462,
-0.12002409249544144,
0.40197768807411194,
0.510734498500824,
0.20383621752262115,
-0.5214655995368958,
0.6605804562568665,
-0.24648118019104004,
-0.5672591328620911,
-1.2263190746307373,
0.05154629051685333,
-0.9943621754646301,
-0.12028568238019943,
0.8477802872657776,
-0.05830102786421776,
-0.3214643895626068,
-0.057044483721256256,
-0.05976006016135216,
0.4808380603790283,
-0.22658486664295197,
0.8342353105545044,
0.2740172743797302,
0.22717121243476868,
0.05271662026643753,
-0.6760804653167725,
0.259848415851593,
0.29839417338371277,
-1.0544097423553467,
0.15412472188472748,
0.1240866407752037,
0.18212449550628662,
-0.009785315953195095,
0.2667819857597351,
-0.30159538984298706,
0.341299831867218,
0.051942724734544754,
-0.11890936642885208,
-0.4408310055732727,
-0.7421998381614685,
-0.23211254179477692,
0.4318893849849701,
0.044389914721250534,
-0.1101774051785469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01509v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01509v1
|
Learnable Linguistic Watermarks for Tracing Model Extraction Attacks on Large Language Models
| 2024-04-28T14:45:53 | 2024-04-28T14:45:53 |
Minhao Bai, Kaiyi Pang, Yongfeng Huang
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In the rapidly evolving domain of artificial intelligence, safeguarding the
intellectual property of Large Language Models (LLMs) is increasingly crucial.
Current watermarking techniques against model extraction attacks, which rely on
signal insertion in model logits or post-processing of generated text, remain
largely heuristic. We propose a novel method for embedding learnable linguistic
watermarks in LLMs, aimed at tracing and preventing model extraction attacks.
Our approach subtly modifies the LLM's output distribution by introducing
controlled noise into token frequency distributions, embedding an statistically
identifiable controllable watermark.We leverage statistical hypothesis testing
and information theory, particularly focusing on Kullback-Leibler Divergence,
to differentiate between original and modified distributions effectively. Our
watermarking method strikes a delicate well balance between robustness and
output quality, maintaining low false positive/negative rates and preserving
the LLM's original performance.
|
[
-0.3061245381832123,
-0.9179076552391052,
0.2977175712585449,
0.21050705015659332,
-0.5960395932197571,
0.2955505847930908,
-0.2539527714252472,
-0.48645174503326416,
0.2516825199127197,
0.8936031460762024,
-0.25791284441947937,
-0.44544070959091187,
-0.7661097049713135,
-0.3153054416179657,
-0.70423424243927,
0.7708161473274231,
0.1600203514099121,
-0.06327381730079651,
0.06659653037786484,
-0.17592112720012665,
-0.1681278795003891,
-0.7426919341087341,
-0.6621551513671875,
-0.27928104996681213,
0.46210047602653503,
-0.16778668761253357,
0.5359907150268555,
0.8968624472618103,
0.5130405426025391,
0.19674476981163025,
-0.27693644165992737,
-0.048022691160440445,
-0.31297969818115234,
0.457222580909729,
-0.05026901140809059,
-0.5907501578330994,
-0.2864137887954712,
-0.17730970680713654,
0.7567834258079529,
0.46726322174072266,
0.007136368192732334,
0.04591893404722214,
0.14162082970142365,
0.5185540318489075,
-0.7687948942184448,
0.5176095366477966,
-0.774675190448761,
0.1004127785563469,
-0.617965042591095,
-0.36923491954803467,
-0.7961955666542053,
-0.27036935091018677,
-0.2382102757692337,
-0.4101899564266205,
0.025679700076580048,
0.01912766695022583,
0.9038217067718506,
0.36566540598869324,
-0.15128421783447266,
-0.17072947323322296,
-0.9789507389068604,
0.817930281162262,
-0.9936890602111816,
0.48917156457901,
0.4613286256790161,
0.36786454916000366,
-0.18202871084213257,
-0.7887035012245178,
-0.23477864265441895,
-0.23677536845207214,
0.2229917347431183,
0.019962556660175323,
-0.38949519395828247,
-0.313465416431427,
0.4081089496612549,
0.08076386898756027,
-0.0854993388056755,
0.15186432003974915,
-0.04273741692304611,
-0.2536654770374298,
0.6673067212104797,
-0.01682056114077568,
0.2523438632488251,
0.27495571970939636,
-0.1467052549123764,
-0.20637252926826477,
-1.0106194019317627,
-0.15020222961902618,
0.6140536665916443,
0.5025162100791931,
-0.10508036613464355,
0.4125189185142517,
-0.04509439691901207,
0.34249943494796753,
-0.09393448382616043,
-0.20907001197338104,
0.08343987166881561,
0.061480503529310226,
0.010358029045164585,
0.17568254470825195,
0.7067531943321228,
-0.17256151139736176,
0.4953104257583618,
-0.07253771275281906,
-0.49659159779548645,
-0.14425133168697357,
0.12628726661205292,
-0.755987823009491,
-0.5463811159133911,
-0.09120455384254456,
-0.37399303913116455,
-0.45526784658432007,
0.07206717878580093,
-0.8225011825561523,
-0.5677019357681274,
-0.021989447996020317,
0.41925036907196045,
-0.3156607449054718,
-0.6209183931350708,
0.000009416940883966163,
-0.2352079153060913,
0.12175099551677704,
-0.06910403817892075,
-0.9759465456008911,
0.27743345499038696,
0.6384817957878113,
0.5544799566268921,
-0.249418705701828,
0.15875089168548584,
-0.6035261154174805,
0.5632703900337219,
-0.451607346534729,
0.7929216623306274,
-0.734198808670044,
-0.24244342744350433,
0.1057787835597992,
-0.09525775164365768,
0.0825374498963356,
-0.7328197956085205,
0.1146327555179596,
-1.1058048009872437,
-0.040315285325050354,
-0.0740106999874115,
-0.8308703899383545,
-0.060681987553834915,
-0.11963032186031342,
-0.9678925275802612,
0.8674424290657043,
-0.0018497533164918423,
-0.9507282972335815,
0.3148587942123413,
-0.7016658782958984,
-0.437980055809021,
0.2324882596731186,
-0.1110955998301506,
-0.7435523867607117,
0.0072421724908053875,
0.13660790026187897,
0.3389850854873657,
-0.03430697321891785,
0.16086922585964203,
-0.5531902313232422,
-0.061717379838228226,
0.5849841833114624,
-0.8582698106765747,
0.9438992738723755,
0.017266126349568367,
-0.566779375076294,
0.02604403719305992,
-0.8793739676475525,
0.08412384241819382,
0.3108587861061096,
-0.4336392879486084,
-0.5329731106758118,
0.2986486256122589,
-0.0737207904458046,
-0.39342209696769714,
0.2090655118227005,
-0.33969128131866455,
-0.023190215229988098,
-0.2452053427696228,
0.3740012049674988,
0.8562918901443481,
0.2264808863401413,
0.3318141996860504,
-0.09102950990200043,
0.5537183284759521,
0.1450071632862091,
0.14275576174259186,
-0.09172336757183075,
-0.46578630805015564,
-0.6937178373336792,
-0.8178800344467163,
0.5168967843055725,
0.4176870286464691,
-0.6241987347602844,
0.38270556926727295,
-0.06826451420783997,
-0.5619688034057617,
-0.35931479930877686,
0.32309573888778687,
0.14108309149742126,
0.35481250286102295,
0.24863068759441376,
-0.1733105629682541,
-0.23306241631507874,
-0.7445194125175476,
-0.4817805886268616,
-0.19011470675468445,
-0.0705704465508461,
0.2251794934272766,
0.41327181458473206,
-0.11809266358613968,
0.9228200316429138,
-0.5180901885032654,
-0.017369018867611885,
-0.2634255588054657,
0.11518621444702148,
0.0024827036540955305,
0.5893338322639465,
0.5370137095451355,
-0.789076566696167,
-0.38163504004478455,
0.023630915209650993,
-0.5935252904891968,
-0.5392309427261353,
0.02706313505768776,
-0.07906520366668701,
0.24503058195114136,
0.6683610677719116,
-0.5853079557418823,
0.5084603428840637,
0.40663743019104004,
-0.4341421127319336,
0.5870278477668762,
-0.12285158783197403,
-0.266815721988678,
-0.8635276556015015,
0.10212491452693939,
-0.30708634853363037,
-0.3305175304412842,
-0.4621073305606842,
0.1033707782626152,
0.17147201299667358,
0.24192717671394348,
-0.28321975469589233,
0.6358488202095032,
-0.42509832978248596,
0.06518766283988953,
-0.3876318037509918,
-0.2760155200958252,
-0.12354383617639542,
0.17565736174583435,
-0.18657684326171875,
0.3541448712348938,
0.6803575158119202,
-0.4815274477005005,
0.3034895360469818,
-0.12607699632644653,
-0.35068279504776,
0.3961716890335083,
-0.6099381446838379,
0.16162633895874023,
-0.10753199458122253,
-0.010132994502782822,
-0.8627222180366516,
-0.019295142963528633,
0.30799177289009094,
-0.1409839540719986,
0.551202654838562,
-0.4293590188026428,
-0.557811439037323,
0.3187406659126282,
-0.2053978443145752,
0.2555975317955017,
0.736480712890625,
-0.6354846358299255,
0.5438169836997986,
0.5029501914978027,
-0.38675034046173096,
-0.44635236263275146,
-0.6378215551376343,
-0.0068609630689024925,
-0.5747560858726501,
-0.21226583421230316,
0.19025197625160217,
-0.1293969303369522,
-0.4240386486053467,
0.00020973836944904178,
-0.032844606786966324,
-0.30339616537094116,
0.45604345202445984,
0.31715187430381775,
0.289452463388443,
-0.31053829193115234,
-0.008820964954793453,
0.15761901438236237,
-0.26103517413139343,
0.21420519053936005,
-0.19795863330364227,
0.6748312711715698,
0.2587164044380188,
-0.5895056128501892,
-0.3788996934890747,
0.38671183586120605,
0.5025752782821655,
-0.37097904086112976,
0.6238841414451599,
0.6547011137008667,
-0.49505147337913513,
-0.5220867395401001,
-0.5017090439796448,
-0.39278993010520935,
-0.5015513896942139,
0.3574465811252594,
0.022859184071421623,
-0.7945611476898193,
0.5285401940345764,
-0.16452252864837646,
0.1736154705286026,
0.43635106086730957,
0.3821013867855072,
-0.03906095027923584,
1.0590678453445435,
0.814835786819458,
-0.2924439609050751,
0.791936993598938,
-0.17096570134162903,
0.21648342907428741,
-0.5359212756156921,
-0.11941545456647873,
-0.5574820041656494,
-0.031906891614198685,
-0.4795258045196533,
-0.30770426988601685,
-0.08168765157461166,
0.3075932264328003,
-0.3246800899505615,
0.07651321589946747,
-0.1587284356355667,
0.5066930651664734,
0.7351956963539124,
-0.11929230391979218,
0.298785924911499,
0.38112589716911316,
-0.11308030784130096,
-0.12471270561218262,
-0.5158420205116272,
-0.49444717168807983,
1.0371084213256836,
0.3586488664150238,
1.0031362771987915,
0.11505626887083054,
0.8061823844909668,
0.5958470106124878,
0.5794403553009033,
-0.5588063597679138,
0.35882750153541565,
-0.08155010640621185,
-0.392523854970932,
-0.26399359107017517,
-0.4944753050804138,
-0.927202045917511,
0.013196077197790146,
-0.19429120421409607,
-0.8522319197654724,
0.019614920020103455,
0.1445915251970291,
-0.035990457981824875,
0.5042506456375122,
-0.32436421513557434,
0.5891990065574646,
-0.04496174305677414,
-0.2175244241952896,
-0.15549924969673157,
-0.1805208921432495,
0.06423488259315491,
-0.4369402825832367,
0.4009351134300232,
-0.17550618946552277,
-0.14081929624080658,
0.9165329933166504,
-0.2693314850330353,
1.0231667757034302,
-0.43000727891921997,
-0.3244747817516327,
0.22891297936439514,
0.44962918758392334,
0.6684463024139404,
-0.0002627583162393421,
0.05500224232673645,
0.29699987173080444,
0.015417627058923244,
-0.36271238327026367,
-0.39033207297325134,
0.37110772728919983,
-0.49112462997436523,
-0.6563753485679626,
-0.13318167626857758,
-0.536495566368103,
-0.010910047218203545,
0.5275386571884155,
0.10081096738576889,
0.43997085094451904,
0.032861948013305664,
0.21766605973243713,
0.6590571403503418,
-0.18332470953464508,
0.7255643606185913,
0.5290669798851013,
-0.17431412637233734,
-0.4903208315372467,
1.1568386554718018,
0.19848361611366272,
0.34938544034957886,
0.20846779644489288,
0.3653913140296936,
-0.359652578830719,
-0.8071486949920654,
-0.16991302371025085,
0.22510819137096405,
-0.8213975429534912,
-0.24190589785575867,
-0.402832567691803,
-0.48820194602012634,
-0.11522725969552994,
0.004383796360343695,
-0.5749729871749878,
-0.4591822326183319,
-0.20760804414749146,
0.019221946597099304,
0.5034039616584778,
0.8377466201782227,
-0.010786715894937515,
0.487745076417923,
-0.6742143630981445,
0.16905783116817474,
0.25856849551200867,
0.38059356808662415,
-0.02289111167192459,
-0.7366177439689636,
-0.11670462042093277,
0.18971805274486542,
-0.2160765826702118,
-0.7577354311943054,
0.5851716995239258,
0.31017497181892395,
0.6585527658462524,
0.6907245516777039,
0.20208030939102173,
0.4296703040599823,
-0.4451291561126709,
0.6066297888755798,
0.09387872368097305,
-0.9316805005073547,
0.4281441569328308,
-0.14035899937152863,
0.15756583213806152,
-0.014965873211622238,
0.11516937613487244,
-0.16779589653015137,
-0.7951499223709106,
-0.7146475315093994,
-1.0188405513763428,
0.30396366119384766,
-0.03445320576429367,
0.35600101947784424,
-0.0012906519696116447,
0.2110111117362976,
0.16265131533145905,
0.16060151159763336,
-0.8733274340629578,
-0.2888036370277405,
-0.054968465119600296,
-0.2695654034614563,
0.13092109560966492,
-0.40253114700317383,
-0.29610490798950195,
0.042204637080430984,
0.6890719532966614,
-0.1353074014186859,
0.12573407590389252,
-0.0932355672121048,
-0.30149081349372864,
0.016192646697163582,
0.07384750247001648,
0.3610035181045532,
0.5651518702507019,
0.035701338201761246,
0.5358733534812927,
-0.07878205180168152,
-0.5245177745819092,
0.035176847130060196,
-0.04292510822415352,
-0.4525481164455414,
0.0882035568356514,
0.6614188551902771,
0.5777708292007446,
-0.046345196664333344,
-0.6680164337158203,
0.4376942217350006,
0.014087176881730556,
0.02403421700000763,
-0.4212420880794525,
0.22375032305717468,
0.4080691635608673,
0.5362824201583862,
0.3817894756793976,
-0.06720831990242004,
-0.1628090739250183,
-0.0753985196352005,
0.25493884086608887,
0.6298967003822327,
-0.40723657608032227,
-0.4234977960586548,
0.7251241207122803,
-0.1784830391407013,
-0.39615729451179504,
0.429439902305603,
0.0778229609131813,
-0.4320012331008911,
0.573666512966156,
0.6898258924484253,
0.9333792924880981,
-0.36065685749053955,
0.026057157665491104,
0.0958886668086052,
0.399267315864563,
-0.09557918459177017,
0.3184737265110016,
-0.08389829844236374,
-0.7842655181884766,
-0.22409911453723907,
-0.5559858679771423,
-0.33985885977745056,
0.15519729256629944,
-0.7499769330024719,
0.08837722986936569,
-0.6932342648506165,
-0.1907142549753189,
0.2687804698944092,
-0.4244192838668823,
-0.38689154386520386,
0.0021220974158495665,
0.4530368149280548,
0.6922457814216614,
-0.7863547801971436,
0.8860757350921631,
0.10763762146234512,
-0.06728136539459229,
-0.5572509765625,
-0.07817377150058746,
-0.14633934199810028,
-0.8237001895904541,
0.6627993583679199,
0.0006079531158320606,
-0.056509923189878464,
0.029339062049984932,
-0.8410541415214539,
-0.994110643863678,
0.7936051487922668,
0.8297588229179382,
-0.39898446202278137,
0.5717288851737976,
0.3940805196762085,
0.37761354446411133,
-0.25829118490219116,
-0.07930567860603333,
0.5242411494255066,
0.42342615127563477,
-0.2486138939857483,
-0.5005276203155518,
0.20587275922298431,
-0.2597021162509918,
-0.15066680312156677,
0.2595999240875244,
-0.42528754472732544,
0.6121610999107361,
-0.11478044837713242,
-0.28163447976112366,
-0.21142183244228363,
0.5197150707244873,
0.3134518265724182,
0.03945364058017731,
0.6406158804893494,
0.2592468559741974,
0.8625713586807251,
-0.08156836032867432,
0.8037053942680359,
-0.41230958700180054,
0.23258477449417114,
1.0861445665359497,
-0.23539574444293976,
1.1833208799362183,
0.7146920561790466,
-0.05651433765888214,
0.3368949294090271,
0.33708518743515015,
-0.2251136749982834,
0.6843996644020081,
0.48760783672332764,
-0.4169941246509552,
-0.23935574293136597,
-0.13160718977451324,
-0.2944273352622986,
0.3651045858860016,
0.43627485632896423,
-0.5438938140869141,
0.057739514857530594,
-0.18818247318267822,
0.21524576842784882,
-0.15738634765148163,
-0.05905773863196373,
0.7947622537612915,
0.21860593557357788,
-0.18011562526226044,
0.6097391843795776,
-0.08920317143201828,
0.621213436126709,
-0.7146165370941162,
-0.1827811747789383,
-0.29150211811065674,
0.21608440577983856,
-0.15155048668384552,
-0.48116546869277954,
0.288217693567276,
0.07586479187011719,
-0.13291488587856293,
-0.1905706226825714,
0.7089488506317139,
-0.5814668536186218,
-0.5365747213363647,
0.5573145151138306,
0.2942974269390106,
0.12667149305343628,
-0.09089679270982742,
-0.4937649369239807,
0.2694392502307892,
-0.008808091282844543,
-0.5794703364372253,
0.3015408217906952,
0.24826911091804504,
-0.12694145739078522,
0.9596730470657349,
0.8062513470649719,
0.5489308834075928,
0.35846617817878723,
0.35130390524864197,
0.7089290618896484,
-0.6110159754753113,
-0.5253233313560486,
-1.2014758586883545,
0.21513110399246216,
-0.2240118384361267,
0.03978870064020157,
0.6666448712348938,
0.38211485743522644,
0.6238183379173279,
-0.10219181329011917,
0.9605373740196228,
0.15457817912101746,
0.15165314078330994,
-0.42844507098197937,
1.1328247785568237,
-0.1798427402973175,
0.47448524832725525,
-0.3116462826728821,
-0.8807602524757385,
-0.5285389423370361,
0.38486143946647644,
0.13263829052448273,
-0.08132562786340714,
0.4038505256175995,
0.9788030982017517,
-0.023578835651278496,
-0.09366420656442642,
0.38006699085235596,
0.26946496963500977,
0.6593989133834839,
0.1393154412508011,
0.9683799147605896,
-0.18929804861545563,
0.5135523676872253,
-0.5308115482330322,
-0.16457372903823853,
-0.10648427903652191,
-1.1453983783721924,
-0.7711570858955383,
-0.32842668890953064,
-0.7379708886146545,
-0.3198660612106323,
0.029780950397253036,
0.5160676836967468,
0.6116737723350525,
-1.0702258348464966,
-0.22284571826457977,
0.16378027200698853,
0.15894398093223572,
-0.319609671831131,
-0.270643949508667,
0.6501295566558838,
-0.09969557821750641,
-0.6278916597366333,
0.3210955560207367,
0.27771925926208496,
0.3611874282360077,
-0.278582364320755,
-0.042226459830999374,
0.1932983547449112,
0.28484269976615906,
0.3326082229614258,
0.2050289511680603,
-0.5272911190986633,
-0.4720672070980072,
-0.28940024971961975,
0.05052909255027771,
-0.16657423973083496,
0.6331681609153748,
-0.35527679324150085,
0.387482613325119,
0.34576600790023804,
0.7947968244552612,
0.3915964365005493,
-0.37497851252555847,
0.4331344664096832,
-0.658540666103363,
0.37377554178237915,
0.2694093883037567,
0.5414547920227051,
0.42682427167892456,
-0.22160956263542175,
0.2607820928096771,
0.5330721139907837,
-0.19635386765003204,
-1.1352298259735107,
0.005670763552188873,
-0.8912122845649719,
-0.11415202915668488,
1.2084341049194336,
-0.47190043330192566,
-0.23940876126289368,
-0.14357051253318787,
-0.09321271628141403,
0.24562712013721466,
-0.21926160156726837,
0.8613965511322021,
0.6046756505966187,
0.27902674674987793,
-0.07726079225540161,
-0.4912170469760895,
0.5329782962799072,
0.364850789308548,
-0.7133952975273132,
0.41272735595703125,
0.18093448877334595,
0.6394816637039185,
-0.013494664803147316,
0.23910215497016907,
-0.3924981355667114,
0.07281692326068878,
0.21509245038032532,
0.19489310681819916,
-0.05385728180408478,
-0.17174199223518372,
-0.299489825963974,
0.3086920976638794,
0.24121539294719696,
-0.12543295323848724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18191v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18191v2
|
Exploring the Robustness of In-Context Learning with Noisy Labels
| 2024-04-28T14:05:23 | 2024-05-01T09:15:16 |
Chen Cheng, Xinzhi Yu, Haodong Wen, Jingsong Sun, Guanzhang Yue, Yihao Zhang, Zeming Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG, math.OC
|
Recently, the mysterious In-Context Learning (ICL) ability exhibited by
Transformer architectures, especially in large language models (LLMs), has
sparked significant research interest. However, the resilience of Transformers'
in-context learning capabilities in the presence of noisy samples, prevalent in
both training corpora and prompt demonstrations, remains underexplored. In this
paper, inspired by prior research that studies ICL ability using simple
function classes, we take a closer look at this problem by investigating the
robustness of Transformers against noisy labels. Specifically, we first conduct
a thorough evaluation and analysis of the robustness of Transformers against
noisy labels during in-context learning and show that they exhibit notable
resilience against diverse types of noise in demonstration labels. Furthermore,
we delve deeper into this problem by exploring whether introducing noise into
the training set, akin to a form of data augmentation, enhances such robustness
during inference, and find that such noise can indeed improve the robustness of
ICL. Overall, our fruitful analysis and findings provide a comprehensive
understanding of the resilience of Transformer models against label noises
during ICL and provide valuable insights into the research on Transformers in
natural language processing. Our code is available at
https://github.com/InezYu0928/in-context-learning.
|
[
-0.5040888786315918,
-0.5685592293739319,
0.15560798346996307,
0.0558612085878849,
-0.06066315621137619,
0.11974789202213287,
-0.49196523427963257,
-0.7335036396980286,
-0.6036602854728699,
0.18925777077674866,
-0.5000357627868652,
-0.22389687597751617,
-0.5777623653411865,
0.2704448699951172,
-0.7593730092048645,
1.231817603111267,
0.3142854869365692,
0.002687144558876753,
-0.5440117716789246,
-0.1931592971086502,
-0.29240548610687256,
-0.4541839361190796,
-0.49083030223846436,
-0.377395361661911,
0.19235090911388397,
0.3824716806411743,
0.6954302787780762,
0.3126938045024872,
0.35403871536254883,
0.2751925587654114,
-0.3219527006149292,
0.030734194442629814,
-0.5760552883148193,
0.5570776462554932,
0.08867915719747543,
-0.5129802227020264,
0.07212337851524353,
-0.29840776324272156,
0.8801329731941223,
0.6642037630081177,
0.16863366961479187,
0.05978020653128624,
0.6514068245887756,
0.35769182443618774,
-0.5007784366607666,
0.4289277493953705,
-1.0005674362182617,
0.049737997353076935,
-0.18384374678134918,
0.19727391004562378,
-0.8100507855415344,
-0.0017429408617317677,
0.15370085835456848,
-0.32579195499420166,
0.25791236758232117,
-0.02112342230975628,
1.0067763328552246,
0.9539062976837158,
-0.10721324384212494,
-0.34089982509613037,
-1.0253556966781616,
0.7867972254753113,
-0.40358754992485046,
0.7628477215766907,
0.5123803019523621,
0.2532117962837219,
-0.18590886890888214,
-1.1367913484573364,
-0.3738175332546234,
-0.3300131857395172,
-0.2726553678512573,
0.15349596738815308,
-0.4110429286956787,
-0.112625852227211,
0.6105757355690002,
0.38121047616004944,
0.04581896960735321,
0.3168291449546814,
-0.2383318990468979,
-0.13831117749214172,
0.03644267097115517,
-0.16368673741817474,
0.2160799652338028,
0.3203333616256714,
-0.4702394902706146,
-0.35609564185142517,
-0.5078855156898499,
0.459739089012146,
0.3722662627696991,
0.18201476335525513,
-0.12409484386444092,
0.03301084414124489,
0.204603374004364,
0.6438279747962952,
0.26564526557922363,
-0.4659627377986908,
0.1843598484992981,
-0.18925459682941437,
-0.0334106869995594,
0.18952012062072754,
0.6103234887123108,
-0.2229190170764923,
0.10909723490476608,
-0.6111633777618408,
-0.46291908621788025,
-0.10979872196912766,
0.5229881405830383,
-0.9092322587966919,
-0.2943222224712372,
0.049668628722429276,
-0.3497503995895386,
-0.41442424058914185,
0.0010166772408410907,
-0.6675843000411987,
-0.18473902344703674,
-0.19531260430812836,
0.5130717158317566,
-0.5804717540740967,
-0.03785429149866104,
-0.1029316857457161,
0.23169904947280884,
0.12704788148403168,
-0.10948788374662399,
-0.9597692489624023,
0.3406032919883728,
0.7109305262565613,
0.4311946630477905,
-0.07519838213920593,
-0.3084200918674469,
-0.6319122314453125,
-0.07492467761039734,
0.032077278941869736,
0.9183566570281982,
-0.45971953868865967,
-0.3647487759590149,
-0.13709567487239838,
-0.022209562361240387,
-0.21133607625961304,
-0.8358833193778992,
0.7795002460479736,
-0.5326400399208069,
-0.15011802315711975,
-0.077779121696949,
-0.3391670286655426,
0.09523738920688629,
0.13779091835021973,
-0.6523287296295166,
1.2091981172561646,
0.2926224172115326,
-0.9891789555549622,
0.676869809627533,
-0.4722413420677185,
-0.6229795813560486,
-0.1750481128692627,
-0.1469527631998062,
-0.989879310131073,
0.04095086455345154,
0.09791210293769836,
0.2600972354412079,
0.10304436087608337,
0.29499906301498413,
-0.2156810611486435,
-0.6623309254646301,
0.8262766599655151,
-0.9652822017669678,
0.7762665748596191,
-0.010965191759169102,
-0.5348655581474304,
-0.04544652998447418,
-0.9077527523040771,
-0.3876250982284546,
-0.2990093529224396,
-0.39983731508255005,
-0.04186849296092987,
0.10379957407712936,
-0.28429681062698364,
0.2535727322101593,
-0.25675809383392334,
-0.37314581871032715,
-0.1314200609922409,
-0.5942919850349426,
0.3794735074043274,
0.6861225962638855,
-0.15489229559898376,
0.39074140787124634,
-0.31977930665016174,
0.41654878854751587,
0.1681351512670517,
0.1323605179786682,
-0.27470338344573975,
-0.3385833501815796,
-0.7593725919723511,
-0.5698968172073364,
0.38815638422966003,
0.1886247843503952,
-0.7318007946014404,
0.1785127967596054,
-0.2888909578323364,
-0.44787612557411194,
-0.5116065144538879,
0.129304900765419,
0.2382381707429886,
1.1655354499816895,
0.5637990236282349,
-0.004734907764941454,
-0.5064848065376282,
-0.814971923828125,
-0.23355992138385773,
-0.1161501556634903,
-0.16823795437812805,
0.12555252015590668,
0.3582615554332733,
-0.41388723254203796,
1.0866000652313232,
0.03589583933353424,
-0.11854473501443863,
-0.16898030042648315,
0.01865793764591217,
0.020868266001343727,
0.22604438662528992,
0.5966809988021851,
-0.8117058277130127,
-0.4650709331035614,
-0.35620349645614624,
-0.4640182852745056,
-0.38413721323013306,
-0.18706999719142914,
0.15547436475753784,
0.1341538429260254,
0.7451409697532654,
-0.2250061333179474,
0.5956531763076782,
0.3741541802883148,
0.027572687715291977,
0.5574136972427368,
0.0181248988956213,
-0.43309521675109863,
-0.9411197304725647,
-0.23191659152507782,
0.038709595799446106,
-0.15232910215854645,
-0.6288149356842041,
-0.23619964718818665,
0.02321069873869419,
0.03536216542124748,
-0.3861328661441803,
0.08312199264764786,
-0.21270257234573364,
0.0701417624950409,
-0.39533403515815735,
-0.13674303889274597,
-0.24536392092704773,
0.31937527656555176,
-0.10478414595127106,
0.9579337239265442,
0.9090858101844788,
-0.7481904029846191,
-0.3865860402584076,
0.27688491344451904,
-0.4866179823875427,
0.5387475490570068,
-0.38449278473854065,
-0.037697684019804,
-0.3081207573413849,
0.3213234841823578,
-1.0708717107772827,
-0.30257928371429443,
0.22494405508041382,
-0.15037119388580322,
0.6846969127655029,
-0.11443187296390533,
-0.5768049955368042,
-0.14768807590007782,
0.04090240225195885,
0.3372298777103424,
0.5563000440597534,
-1.1298781633377075,
0.39993706345558167,
0.45237696170806885,
0.26295822858810425,
-0.5137383341789246,
-0.7702391147613525,
-0.08026054501533508,
-0.5512075424194336,
-0.5049226880073547,
0.33433493971824646,
-0.28390035033226013,
-0.4031079113483429,
-0.2935069799423218,
-0.3610721826553345,
-0.20167021453380585,
0.384689062833786,
0.6178930997848511,
0.13806182146072388,
-0.13962656259536743,
0.28242582082748413,
-0.2603982388973236,
-0.3581194579601288,
0.2602342367172241,
-0.015065867453813553,
0.2840072810649872,
-0.4839688539505005,
-0.40865811705589294,
-0.3628893792629242,
-0.27151814103126526,
0.5963218212127686,
0.14881819486618042,
0.7365351319313049,
0.8800390958786011,
-0.2930963933467865,
-0.40404486656188965,
-0.2678317427635193,
-0.4671015739440918,
-0.5890985727310181,
0.3989195227622986,
-0.23317456245422363,
-0.758158802986145,
0.32491955161094666,
-0.10122618079185486,
0.11405779421329498,
0.2297476977109909,
0.36665910482406616,
-0.24296028912067413,
0.6492455005645752,
0.5789114832878113,
-0.11343607306480408,
0.5622193217277527,
-0.11007090657949448,
0.45523637533187866,
-0.73014897108078,
-0.20597822964191437,
-0.6495979428291321,
-0.5539700388908386,
-0.46144554018974304,
-0.1548638641834259,
0.49311086535453796,
-0.011650554835796356,
-0.32828059792518616,
0.28895679116249084,
-0.5290448665618896,
0.4322752356529236,
0.4836154580116272,
0.11021552979946136,
0.43512919545173645,
0.3911968469619751,
0.09444613754749298,
-0.3947221040725708,
-0.7365157008171082,
-0.40911129117012024,
0.574094295501709,
0.5453386306762695,
0.9086737036705017,
-0.0731312558054924,
0.4497896432876587,
-0.12059321999549866,
0.6801247000694275,
-0.784591555595398,
0.23694570362567902,
-0.05054780840873718,
-0.2553234398365021,
-0.21175628900527954,
-0.20405252277851105,
-0.9834439158439636,
0.1331188678741455,
-0.3176783323287964,
-1.0524946451187134,
0.31425225734710693,
0.058973174542188644,
-0.29008325934410095,
0.6167207360267639,
-0.5572574734687805,
0.4815483093261719,
-0.09760536253452301,
-0.42157182097435,
0.3178369104862213,
-0.8753721714019775,
0.2856519818305969,
-0.30728328227996826,
0.3864036798477173,
0.36567389965057373,
0.17189015448093414,
0.4746820628643036,
-0.15010470151901245,
1.208838701248169,
0.23301969468593597,
-0.31146466732025146,
0.41321539878845215,
0.07368544489145279,
0.455843985080719,
0.12798021733760834,
-0.0335971936583519,
0.13809360563755035,
-0.38008496165275574,
0.004330968484282494,
-0.49754196405410767,
0.5218260288238525,
-0.7027993202209473,
-0.260636568069458,
-0.157376229763031,
-0.8474850058555603,
-0.37220272421836853,
-0.017549050971865654,
0.6712325215339661,
0.6008303761482239,
0.185407355427742,
0.6522319316864014,
1.0217312574386597,
-0.03889749199151993,
0.8440009951591492,
0.30442801117897034,
0.15182600915431976,
-0.2701699137687683,
1.181276559829712,
0.30594179034233093,
0.45567384362220764,
0.2342958152294159,
0.14526736736297607,
-0.2497735321521759,
-0.46384355425834656,
-0.1704748272895813,
-0.3035926818847656,
-0.7782037258148193,
-0.2712036669254303,
-0.8397114872932434,
-0.5311715006828308,
0.18868108093738556,
-0.24013903737068176,
-0.46452486515045166,
-0.31972023844718933,
-0.3140019178390503,
-0.13517186045646667,
0.06494308263063431,
0.7496424913406372,
0.09227994084358215,
0.31606486439704895,
-0.5222912430763245,
0.22552111744880676,
0.37797901034355164,
0.42905306816101074,
0.14590097963809967,
-0.7628156542778015,
-0.35526201128959656,
-0.0267717894166708,
-0.46887868642807007,
-0.4714764356613159,
0.10450300574302673,
0.2865486145019531,
0.4837489724159241,
0.5412821173667908,
0.34460851550102234,
0.622363805770874,
-0.09744852781295776,
0.6913273334503174,
-0.24498870968818665,
-0.6996597051620483,
0.010147824883460999,
-0.08760560303926468,
0.33953380584716797,
0.6743050217628479,
0.09852930903434753,
0.017537806183099747,
-0.8773021101951599,
-1.0019848346710205,
-0.9139450788497925,
0.600399374961853,
0.36195996403694153,
0.0506686232984066,
0.0884975865483284,
0.1446342170238495,
0.33377328515052795,
0.028215590864419937,
-1.0426586866378784,
-0.4029640257358551,
-0.3271888494491577,
-0.08177897334098816,
0.2007213681936264,
-0.28725966811180115,
0.015134291723370552,
-0.3811141848564148,
0.6090060472488403,
-0.1804499626159668,
-0.016601108014583588,
0.049383554607629776,
-0.26164138317108154,
0.015750976279377937,
0.29725319147109985,
0.4690091907978058,
0.2630574405193329,
-0.08171789348125458,
0.35836949944496155,
0.46281397342681885,
-0.646801233291626,
0.01643965393304825,
0.21054786443710327,
-0.4578305780887604,
-0.054794806987047195,
0.5946948528289795,
0.7919792532920837,
0.7812507152557373,
-0.6739165186882019,
0.4119475483894348,
-0.34628719091415405,
-0.05964713543653488,
-0.30472567677497864,
0.09295501559972763,
-0.1301765739917755,
0.1321430206298828,
0.3940926194190979,
0.6106465458869934,
0.006966546177864075,
-0.3239564299583435,
0.49428272247314453,
0.4205499291419983,
-0.8947925567626953,
-0.41578447818756104,
0.8982436656951904,
-0.22991493344306946,
-0.3969937562942505,
0.6779003143310547,
-0.17135705053806305,
-0.5254099369049072,
0.5117005109786987,
0.9742166996002197,
0.9228984117507935,
0.17911414802074432,
-0.016149699687957764,
0.35991495847702026,
0.3617304563522339,
-0.050885919481515884,
-0.35279229283332825,
-0.3883393406867981,
-0.7179638147354126,
-0.32697656750679016,
-0.6343138217926025,
-0.48103994131088257,
0.08597786724567413,
-0.6236263513565063,
0.2196575254201889,
-0.15571212768554688,
-0.07000251114368439,
-0.3284469246864319,
-0.5035374164581299,
-0.5475226044654846,
0.07919538021087646,
0.15372957289218903,
0.7215165495872498,
-0.6550677418708801,
0.7711695432662964,
0.5260369777679443,
-0.03575601801276207,
-0.7787124514579773,
0.550446629524231,
-0.17817077040672302,
-0.4048742353916168,
0.6505959630012512,
0.4910877048969269,
-0.3332247734069824,
-0.11105460673570633,
-0.7239772081375122,
-0.7543390989303589,
1.0017119646072388,
0.6789913177490234,
-0.2608598470687866,
0.5502268671989441,
0.39648276567459106,
0.7236340045928955,
-0.11208231002092361,
0.2919342517852783,
0.6257522106170654,
0.4961080551147461,
0.10477807372808456,
-0.661942720413208,
-0.13208580017089844,
0.09319666773080826,
-0.46501317620277405,
0.00958911795169115,
-0.89315265417099,
0.4534567594528198,
-0.120271235704422,
-0.35164910554885864,
-0.06850773096084595,
0.910673975944519,
0.07231291383504868,
0.3658287823200226,
0.8388800024986267,
0.5122631788253784,
0.8716907501220703,
-0.36156928539276123,
0.9813705086708069,
-0.4377243220806122,
0.1813381016254425,
1.2377947568893433,
0.13252945244312286,
0.502798318862915,
0.5569711327552795,
-0.10036402195692062,
0.47012534737586975,
0.4048609733581543,
0.016254546120762825,
0.44870126247406006,
0.033478379249572754,
-0.5191595554351807,
-0.35288822650909424,
-0.2896602749824524,
-0.14778682589530945,
0.49174219369888306,
0.43491053581237793,
-0.17202958464622498,
-0.283830463886261,
0.17605909705162048,
-0.1374947428703308,
0.04685351997613907,
0.06482812762260437,
0.710729718208313,
0.1413714587688446,
-0.49745041131973267,
0.47109583020210266,
-0.6772575378417969,
0.7194668650627136,
-0.4254451096057892,
0.08423944562673569,
-0.006358236540108919,
0.24006083607673645,
-0.191818505525589,
-0.7839640974998474,
0.5846801400184631,
-0.26083898544311523,
-0.14518560469150543,
-0.3488503694534302,
0.9177992343902588,
-0.3359036147594452,
-0.3489660322666168,
0.23555845022201538,
-0.021911557763814926,
-0.05280778557062149,
0.20120228826999664,
-0.27547687292099,
0.22476784884929657,
-0.0709707960486412,
-0.09796985983848572,
0.7108453512191772,
0.41196998953819275,
0.1670842170715332,
1.054341197013855,
0.35401827096939087,
-0.3684912919998169,
0.12720663845539093,
0.028911160305142403,
0.9635037183761597,
-0.03961693495512009,
-0.16474856436252594,
-0.9587302803993225,
0.7160147428512573,
0.005922588519752026,
-0.32510295510292053,
0.7928452491760254,
0.6161510944366455,
1.0974489450454712,
-0.14495311677455902,
0.6175130009651184,
0.09044231474399567,
0.19434107840061188,
-0.29375168681144714,
0.7480794191360474,
-0.21984852850437164,
0.635481595993042,
-0.31962987780570984,
-0.6908294558525085,
-0.4527088701725006,
0.4231675863265991,
-0.06154828518629074,
-0.14898990094661713,
0.4707740247249603,
0.9244014024734497,
-0.3554694950580597,
0.25153791904449463,
0.44043320417404175,
0.43946149945259094,
0.30102965235710144,
0.08601107448339462,
0.9711993336677551,
-0.4186341464519501,
0.9113900065422058,
-0.760172963142395,
0.10376276820898056,
0.030034750699996948,
-0.7129297852516174,
-0.933730959892273,
-0.6073380708694458,
-0.41719695925712585,
-0.6876492500305176,
-0.2942790985107422,
0.683797299861908,
0.5215632915496826,
-0.7819969654083252,
0.024347230792045593,
-0.041356876492500305,
0.29842689633369446,
-0.4288092255592346,
-0.2922939658164978,
0.3537730872631073,
-0.7181890606880188,
-0.9643023610115051,
0.7111724019050598,
0.2306624799966812,
0.18916259706020355,
0.009212520904839039,
0.05328191816806793,
0.2951371371746063,
-0.22138611972332,
0.5199413299560547,
0.4278019666671753,
-0.34782788157463074,
-0.428235799074173,
-0.24821431934833527,
-0.011937018483877182,
0.25886964797973633,
0.5619050860404968,
-1.0374070405960083,
0.591078519821167,
0.24651949107646942,
0.7702966928482056,
0.3387202024459839,
0.004930824041366577,
0.3602440655231476,
-0.9657279253005981,
0.4625316262245178,
0.17847207188606262,
0.41392481327056885,
0.3342723846435547,
-0.3501648008823395,
0.5707712173461914,
0.12997549772262573,
-0.7875232696533203,
-1.1199966669082642,
0.22717159986495972,
-0.7841383218765259,
-0.026272011920809746,
1.1024365425109863,
0.15607881546020508,
-0.09125237911939621,
-0.45257827639579773,
-0.27019432187080383,
0.26765432953834534,
-0.18790626525878906,
1.1764070987701416,
0.6638464331626892,
-0.13590434193611145,
-0.01444220170378685,
-0.5785033106803894,
0.6656101942062378,
0.34220847487449646,
-0.2919088304042816,
-0.03206935152411461,
-0.056082554161548615,
0.1698569804430008,
0.2167014628648758,
0.004750996828079224,
0.06394539028406143,
-0.015524135902523994,
0.06959078460931778,
-0.5001419186592102,
-0.09386414289474487,
-0.34675726294517517,
-0.3438194990158081,
0.39096659421920776,
0.23084667325019836,
0.03717099130153656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18185v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18185v1
|
Ranked List Truncation for Large Language Model-based Re-Ranking
| 2024-04-28T13:39:33 | 2024-04-28T13:39:33 |
Chuan Meng, Negar Arabzadeh, Arian Askari, Mohammad Aliannejadi, Maarten de Rijke
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, H.3.3
|
We study ranked list truncation (RLT) from a novel "retrieve-then-re-rank"
perspective, where we optimize re-ranking by truncating the retrieved list
(i.e., trim re-ranking candidates). RLT is crucial for re-ranking as it can
improve re-ranking efficiency by sending variable-length candidate lists to a
re-ranker on a per-query basis. It also has the potential to improve re-ranking
effectiveness. Despite its importance, there is limited research into applying
RLT methods to this new perspective. To address this research gap, we reproduce
existing RLT methods in the context of re-ranking, especially newly emerged
large language model (LLM)-based re-ranking. In particular, we examine to what
extent established findings on RLT for retrieval are generalizable to the
"retrieve-then-re-rank" setup from three perspectives: (i) assessing RLT
methods in the context of LLM-based re-ranking with lexical first-stage
retrieval, (ii) investigating the impact of different types of first-stage
retrievers on RLT methods, and (iii) investigating the impact of different
types of re-rankers on RLT methods. We perform experiments on the TREC 2019 and
2020 deep learning tracks, investigating 8 RLT methods for pipelines involving
3 retrievers and 2 re-rankers. We reach new insights into RLT methods in the
context of re-ranking.
|
[
-0.5266678333282471,
-0.7477723956108093,
0.3596208691596985,
-0.18752923607826233,
-0.2691522240638733,
0.5120219588279724,
-0.2774413824081421,
-0.6425036191940308,
0.3808935284614563,
0.5924491882324219,
-0.6239615082740784,
-0.4584945738315582,
-0.5711994767189026,
0.06750325858592987,
-0.6785563826560974,
0.9748351573944092,
0.361054927110672,
-0.4719858169555664,
-0.17507681250572205,
-0.07539999485015869,
-0.40248340368270874,
-0.7359066605567932,
-0.6740506291389465,
-0.27229395508766174,
0.8682194948196411,
0.5987735986709595,
0.7343315482139587,
0.6607857346534729,
0.7172122001647949,
0.14612215757369995,
-0.2745732069015503,
0.11957262456417084,
-0.7631646394729614,
0.4542120695114136,
0.03593716397881508,
-0.38687950372695923,
-0.36784669756889343,
0.28847360610961914,
1.0634421110153198,
0.8031870126724243,
-0.3804361820220947,
0.41442155838012695,
0.29303374886512756,
0.6718456149101257,
-0.7717360258102417,
-0.38828524947166443,
-0.5285137295722961,
0.13744044303894043,
-0.33501359820365906,
-0.27471300959587097,
-0.8308765888214111,
-0.4940401017665863,
0.19055026769638062,
-0.21431680023670197,
0.4157731533050537,
0.08437761664390564,
0.7588083148002625,
0.14795531332492828,
-0.3901069462299347,
0.2576286196708679,
-0.9424495100975037,
0.7921865582466125,
-0.7189133167266846,
0.8463348150253296,
0.1414828598499298,
0.3235805928707123,
0.03352276235818863,
-1.0272773504257202,
0.07227566838264465,
-0.5018881559371948,
-0.032967180013656616,
-0.11518265306949615,
0.3324998617172241,
-0.10316230356693268,
0.27503910660743713,
0.47700339555740356,
-0.6202424764633179,
0.22259867191314697,
-0.3561452031135559,
-0.1349131315946579,
0.6759053468704224,
-0.08232426643371582,
-0.09751860797405243,
0.07587254047393799,
-0.2741415500640869,
-0.17653030157089233,
-0.9173100590705872,
-0.06870504468679428,
0.33916768431663513,
0.3565646708011627,
0.3382713496685028,
0.4715559482574463,
-0.2042502611875534,
0.5957303047180176,
-0.08942102640867233,
0.09996536374092102,
-0.002805434400215745,
-0.32053735852241516,
0.028300035744905472,
-0.252573698759079,
0.4565831124782562,
0.2384015917778015,
0.2583053708076477,
-0.3015279471874237,
-0.37025323510169983,
-0.6052400469779968,
0.36174067854881287,
-0.6685497760772705,
-0.20443351566791534,
-0.025187507271766663,
-0.5941153764724731,
-0.38237908482551575,
0.1597243845462799,
-0.8767023682594299,
-0.38131988048553467,
0.05506828799843788,
0.3220515549182892,
0.01521276868879795,
-0.36548227071762085,
-0.3350977599620819,
0.11378829926252365,
0.25428611040115356,
0.14664578437805176,
-0.6374756097793579,
0.40537071228027344,
0.9302070736885071,
0.6488615274429321,
-0.3309686779975891,
-0.3052746653556824,
-0.9680498242378235,
-0.16133040189743042,
-0.19091129302978516,
0.7465950846672058,
-0.714855968952179,
-0.5862646102905273,
0.1565210372209549,
-0.2810611426830292,
0.041047509759664536,
-0.6477545499801636,
0.6215116381645203,
-0.8132807612419128,
0.36725863814353943,
-0.04290330037474632,
-0.5909067988395691,
-0.04908493533730507,
0.34815511107444763,
-0.8584962487220764,
1.1182302236557007,
-0.2667986750602722,
-0.4120714068412781,
0.3591877520084381,
-0.5073123574256897,
-0.38218438625335693,
0.10450441390275955,
0.029738441109657288,
-0.5758432745933533,
0.15591931343078613,
0.16796737909317017,
0.2889707684516907,
-0.27571240067481995,
0.19654814898967743,
-0.24002359807491302,
-0.5298169255256653,
0.11647196114063263,
-0.5516661405563354,
0.47296142578125,
0.2124621868133545,
-0.04752707853913307,
0.00009739028610056266,
-0.5447802543640137,
0.5216408967971802,
0.00016125684487633407,
-0.5596233606338501,
-0.16609495878219604,
-0.042501773685216904,
0.020949678495526314,
0.11270071566104889,
0.26545384526252747,
-0.5281398892402649,
0.3767883777618408,
-0.5567101836204529,
0.3732759952545166,
0.6408119797706604,
0.14686037600040436,
0.31815385818481445,
-0.1346670687198639,
0.7914161682128906,
-0.4963260293006897,
0.31047964096069336,
0.313466340303421,
-0.10078556835651398,
-0.7316402792930603,
-0.054894689470529556,
0.8856542110443115,
0.4104146957397461,
-0.36759644746780396,
0.1695052683353424,
-0.5322796106338501,
-0.6219568848609924,
-0.5358890295028687,
-0.21506324410438538,
0.42582398653030396,
0.27106139063835144,
0.15250292420387268,
-0.27225232124328613,
-0.5834534168243408,
-0.9657087326049805,
-0.5998663306236267,
-0.12999700009822845,
0.31409746408462524,
0.24255110323429108,
0.24281562864780426,
0.05175686627626419,
1.042325735092163,
-0.6313056349754333,
-0.016650699079036713,
-0.3169378340244293,
0.05924985557794571,
0.16625823080539703,
0.374553382396698,
0.08249371498823166,
-0.8480316400527954,
-0.32319849729537964,
-0.282789945602417,
-0.3072967529296875,
0.1167837381362915,
0.18391644954681396,
0.02888353168964386,
0.2580069899559021,
0.4705990254878998,
-0.27960240840911865,
0.5831878781318665,
0.23015016317367554,
0.014944938011467457,
0.7469251155853271,
-0.21081072092056274,
0.20160405337810516,
-0.765076220035553,
0.14449883997440338,
-0.143061563372612,
-0.5072644352912903,
-0.6468220353126526,
0.35747411847114563,
0.13134951889514923,
-0.09895551949739456,
-0.5594064593315125,
0.5586285591125488,
-0.45634084939956665,
-0.35813385248184204,
-0.15107813477516174,
0.4105362892150879,
0.047676365822553635,
0.2128758430480957,
0.031494904309511185,
0.7853366136550903,
-0.047276075929403305,
-0.6209313273429871,
0.15641221404075623,
0.1092250645160675,
-0.20739224553108215,
-0.09101048111915588,
-0.42322981357574463,
0.3250817656517029,
0.052961356937885284,
0.3084910809993744,
-0.9003170132637024,
0.355651319026947,
0.14215563237667084,
-0.38485169410705566,
0.3978134095668793,
-0.36533215641975403,
-0.45266059041023254,
-0.46245336532592773,
-0.33350831270217896,
0.8026615977287292,
0.2661342918872833,
-0.4930144250392914,
0.127553328871727,
0.3078339993953705,
-0.18635223805904388,
-1.0022764205932617,
-0.5430086255073547,
0.25937604904174805,
-0.4181731343269348,
-0.22250525653362274,
0.39057499170303345,
-0.2094053477048874,
-0.048714347183704376,
-0.11223950237035751,
-0.2695513963699341,
-0.053284235298633575,
0.26512351632118225,
-0.10939876735210419,
0.24141688644886017,
0.017747459933161736,
-0.03294571116566658,
-0.43977072834968567,
-0.1020636111497879,
-0.08167693018913269,
-0.23859328031539917,
0.5779309272766113,
-0.3301592171192169,
-0.5037682056427002,
-0.26452428102493286,
0.4259466230869293,
0.4875657856464386,
-0.667704164981842,
0.7317193150520325,
0.5924652814865112,
-0.25313231348991394,
-0.03585487976670265,
-0.83321213722229,
-0.36385440826416016,
-0.4161038100719452,
0.49914926290512085,
-0.39923369884490967,
-1.255436658859253,
0.6140057444572449,
0.07389302551746368,
0.4483623504638672,
0.38077858090400696,
0.31919634342193604,
0.005402675364166498,
0.7648107409477234,
0.757853090763092,
-0.049498625099658966,
0.5725088119506836,
-0.44397053122520447,
0.3923080265522003,
-1.0438156127929688,
-0.2360418736934662,
-0.5503323674201965,
-0.5662087202072144,
-0.8557930588722229,
-0.09041007608175278,
0.08592034131288528,
-0.19397814571857452,
-0.15179787576198578,
0.1258559674024582,
-0.5712205171585083,
0.5924464464187622,
0.6376757621765137,
0.1332237720489502,
0.35612571239471436,
0.1896272748708725,
-0.3011681139469147,
-0.1311003863811493,
-0.5648557543754578,
-0.19748109579086304,
1.1882776021957397,
0.3951966464519501,
0.5764139294624329,
0.23745422065258026,
0.9858860969543457,
0.5825818181037903,
0.1462455689907074,
-0.8332319259643555,
0.7355177402496338,
-0.14772281050682068,
-0.5111441016197205,
-0.5798311829566956,
-0.4431946575641632,
-1.0448098182678223,
0.5047006607055664,
-0.0141471391543746,
-0.6776686310768127,
0.2387712299823761,
-0.032243553549051285,
-0.3798988461494446,
0.44361612200737,
-0.3177132308483124,
0.5612064003944397,
-0.06071045622229576,
-0.4938349723815918,
-0.32155105471611023,
-0.7751951217651367,
0.34125205874443054,
0.09100859612226486,
0.1716291904449463,
0.0792357549071312,
-0.09907162189483643,
0.9231184720993042,
-0.37814760208129883,
0.5055419206619263,
-0.24612706899642944,
-0.20283877849578857,
0.0020236405543982983,
0.2642557919025421,
0.7489687204360962,
0.04166721925139427,
-0.2619803845882416,
0.01072790939360857,
0.10643567889928818,
-0.2343226820230484,
-0.6829687356948853,
0.7120119333267212,
-0.593580424785614,
-1.0605318546295166,
-0.390200674533844,
-0.32953500747680664,
-0.21540218591690063,
0.45398953557014465,
0.12297750264406204,
0.5801487565040588,
-0.22809945046901703,
0.4757000505924225,
0.5989651083946228,
-0.05319863557815552,
0.283103883266449,
0.39652663469314575,
-0.5209324359893799,
-0.4159109890460968,
0.8455164432525635,
0.31798097491264343,
0.3021620810031891,
0.5615101456642151,
0.05496785044670105,
-0.5138201713562012,
-0.7542531490325928,
0.16225503385066986,
0.37210413813591003,
-0.5480523705482483,
0.03180486708879471,
-0.4219241440296173,
-0.7215410470962524,
-0.5164210200309753,
0.22643710672855377,
-0.6141890287399292,
-0.8275437355041504,
-0.08458177000284195,
-0.12999045848846436,
0.06419233977794647,
0.6456463932991028,
-0.05056673660874367,
0.11187971383333206,
-0.6787124276161194,
0.007914289832115173,
0.07497723400592804,
0.5222851037979126,
0.04428188130259514,
-0.629318356513977,
-0.47917184233665466,
0.020606976002454758,
-0.1703874170780182,
-0.42740583419799805,
0.356341689825058,
0.24550119042396545,
0.7355089783668518,
0.19349870085716248,
0.08232973515987396,
0.8007748126983643,
-0.5085347294807434,
0.8365442752838135,
-0.16465254127979279,
-0.3741433322429657,
0.5236093401908875,
-0.06314891576766968,
0.05789456516504288,
0.6277815699577332,
-0.06586387753486633,
-0.9007537364959717,
-0.4248277544975281,
-0.7493953108787537,
-1.043945550918579,
0.47873952984809875,
0.17904184758663177,
-0.20414863526821136,
0.01451049279421568,
0.7384888529777527,
0.1107347160577774,
0.2677859365940094,
-0.7420516610145569,
-0.5203620195388794,
0.2422511875629425,
0.17966613173484802,
-0.20482933521270752,
-0.727400004863739,
0.13353148102760315,
-0.04117310419678688,
0.7333565950393677,
0.4033015966415405,
0.19116966426372528,
0.1578829437494278,
-0.3257496654987335,
0.030008215457201004,
0.5529560446739197,
0.6773589253425598,
0.7326841354370117,
-0.46110260486602783,
0.12604016065597534,
0.03158964589238167,
-0.529212474822998,
0.24632994830608368,
-0.008201440796256065,
-0.1695024073123932,
-0.15776845812797546,
0.32631346583366394,
0.5099874138832092,
0.24337446689605713,
-0.5351632833480835,
0.11903781443834305,
-0.15809309482574463,
-0.22633318603038788,
-0.2928807735443115,
-0.07549118250608444,
-0.14074374735355377,
0.19754168391227722,
0.4985598027706146,
-0.07275077700614929,
0.23539593815803528,
-0.2836909890174866,
0.6394141316413879,
0.6314629316329956,
-0.35035696625709534,
0.05337061360478401,
0.5356913208961487,
0.2424573004245758,
-0.5484206080436707,
0.9135303497314453,
0.2701081335544586,
-0.46344661712646484,
0.46553054451942444,
0.30209028720855713,
0.8219394087791443,
-0.279723584651947,
0.1962839514017105,
0.2878652513027191,
0.3820633590221405,
-0.0762263610959053,
-0.12728717923164368,
-0.05482317507266998,
-0.4653504192829132,
-0.6729938983917236,
-0.37172931432724,
-0.38710838556289673,
0.2061159610748291,
-1.051408052444458,
0.0848504975438118,
-0.302024781703949,
-0.3455672264099121,
-0.47468051314353943,
0.591200053691864,
-0.555963933467865,
0.015620287507772446,
0.11314225941896439,
1.09410560131073,
-0.5038432478904724,
0.6449625492095947,
0.6695024371147156,
-0.17198587954044342,
-0.6530932188034058,
0.38720622658729553,
-0.1576855629682541,
-0.6536749601364136,
0.5657497644424438,
0.07061973959207535,
-0.2896266579627991,
0.42148467898368835,
-0.1826784610748291,
-1.1719117164611816,
1.1036425828933716,
0.25032296776771545,
-0.586383581161499,
-0.24366438388824463,
0.22582581639289856,
0.30808404088020325,
-0.24478931725025177,
0.380471408367157,
0.6463508605957031,
0.4205174446105957,
0.023175589740276337,
-0.9571950435638428,
-0.05086419731378555,
-0.09861624240875244,
0.08663424104452133,
0.4031762480735779,
-0.8543948531150818,
0.37099096179008484,
-0.21338407695293427,
-0.21135205030441284,
0.1956053227186203,
0.797189474105835,
0.4845940172672272,
0.16537657380104065,
0.636349081993103,
0.5512354373931885,
0.8418786525726318,
0.17042845487594604,
0.8377630710601807,
-0.012893830426037312,
0.6445403695106506,
1.2315888404846191,
-0.30226895213127136,
1.138671875,
0.4486173987388611,
-0.21321311593055725,
0.4132383465766907,
0.8787306547164917,
0.0895928293466568,
0.5440656542778015,
0.28285709023475647,
-0.0630059689283371,
-0.43452122807502747,
-0.08736836165189743,
-0.5226564407348633,
0.16509923338890076,
0.27413102984428406,
-0.25891754031181335,
-0.27961766719818115,
0.09427384287118912,
-0.16587212681770325,
-0.11261057108640671,
-0.15560868382453918,
0.5529326796531677,
0.11196016520261765,
-0.6679298281669617,
0.8037446737289429,
-0.054567720741033554,
0.404752254486084,
-0.05876427888870239,
0.01700039952993393,
-0.42059656977653503,
0.02435239776968956,
-0.05900115147233009,
-0.9654821753501892,
0.08273353427648544,
-0.11937376856803894,
-0.27325958013534546,
-0.3515676259994507,
0.7811477780342102,
-0.4681509733200073,
-0.4728661775588989,
0.2235773652791977,
0.8189370036125183,
0.38537129759788513,
-0.005858834367245436,
-0.6800146102905273,
0.12336859107017517,
0.21771886944770813,
-0.48119860887527466,
0.4146955609321594,
0.12980403006076813,
-0.07322134077548981,
1.0995731353759766,
0.46809121966362,
0.1283913254737854,
0.10660868138074875,
0.3583226799964905,
0.6152829527854919,
-0.7219122648239136,
-0.3743254840373993,
-0.796705424785614,
0.3744986355304718,
0.08975193649530411,
0.24987760186195374,
0.45730647444725037,
0.7969745397567749,
0.5937951803207397,
0.17389385402202606,
0.5563353300094604,
0.08316948264837265,
0.8366111516952515,
-0.3683619201183319,
0.8157460689544678,
-0.9326595664024353,
0.6201778650283813,
-0.040815576910972595,
-0.9829570651054382,
-0.4692630171775818,
0.2523037791252136,
-0.37939631938934326,
0.3339332342147827,
0.7006521821022034,
0.683252215385437,
0.05694211646914482,
-0.21019434928894043,
0.42048540711402893,
0.2649284303188324,
0.5231590270996094,
0.31985437870025635,
0.9059745073318481,
-0.3334249258041382,
0.9474748969078064,
-0.34098222851753235,
0.09415650367736816,
-0.581359326839447,
-0.7664773464202881,
-0.41785889863967896,
-0.4669451117515564,
-0.46704939007759094,
-0.2921523451805115,
0.3013158142566681,
0.7344422340393066,
0.6056317687034607,
-0.44419756531715393,
-0.22149264812469482,
0.2813286781311035,
0.4073472023010254,
-0.3972873091697693,
-0.25661903619766235,
0.5392062664031982,
-0.095469169318676,
-0.6132057309150696,
0.4134233891963959,
0.0018998170271515846,
-0.40795642137527466,
-0.2838138937950134,
0.1157308891415596,
-0.4778098464012146,
-0.5027325749397278,
0.5878323316574097,
0.3828054666519165,
-0.9710269570350647,
-0.5337783694267273,
-0.05930061265826225,
0.11749161034822464,
0.11142740398645401,
0.7360848188400269,
-1.126961350440979,
0.10925539582967758,
0.35564887523651123,
0.5307024121284485,
0.4171552062034607,
0.31445109844207764,
0.5648419857025146,
-1.041927695274353,
-0.13986656069755554,
0.3359323740005493,
0.03423788398504257,
0.07325055450201035,
-0.42950311303138733,
0.5951895117759705,
0.1633160263299942,
-0.812060534954071,
-1.1442967653274536,
0.31228742003440857,
-0.7577437162399292,
0.018512563779950142,
0.97657710313797,
0.02850649133324623,
0.03640199080109596,
0.19277453422546387,
0.05653959512710571,
0.3420270085334778,
-0.38321197032928467,
0.5335882902145386,
0.696614146232605,
-0.12553000450134277,
-0.7297647595405579,
-0.7061854004859924,
0.25371649861335754,
0.4277942180633545,
-0.4336931109428406,
0.3277139961719513,
0.3702157437801361,
0.47040897607803345,
-0.05531010031700134,
0.3927590548992157,
-0.11272101104259491,
0.10763461142778397,
-0.6354239583015442,
0.024157295003533363,
-0.05330110713839531,
-0.352642685174942,
-0.10275541245937347,
0.4517016112804413,
0.42570292949676514,
-0.14014975726604462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18180v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18180v1
|
EkoHate: Abusive Language and Hate Speech Detection for Code-switched Political Discussions on Nigerian Twitter
| 2024-04-28T13:25:11 | 2024-04-28T13:25:11 |
Comfort Eseohen Ilevbare, Jesujoba O. Alabi, David Ifeoluwa Adelani, Firdous Damilola Bakare, Oluwatoyin Bunmi Abiola, Oluwaseyi Adesina Adeyemo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Nigerians have a notable online presence and actively discuss political and
topical matters. This was particularly evident throughout the 2023 general
election, where Twitter was used for campaigning, fact-checking and
verification, and even positive and negative discourse. However, little or none
has been done in the detection of abusive language and hate speech in Nigeria.
In this paper, we curated code-switched Twitter data directed at three
musketeers of the governorship election on the most populous and economically
vibrant state in Nigeria; Lagos state, with the view to detect offensive speech
in political discussions. We developed EkoHate -- an abusive language and hate
speech dataset for political discussions between the three candidates and their
followers using a binary (normal vs offensive) and fine-grained four-label
annotation scheme. We analysed our dataset and provided an empirical evaluation
of state-of-the-art methods across both supervised and cross-lingual transfer
learning settings. In the supervised setting, our evaluation results in both
binary and four-label annotation schemes show that we can achieve 95.1 and 70.3
F1 points respectively. Furthermore, we show that our dataset adequately
transfers very well to three publicly available offensive datasets (OLID,
HateUS2020, and FountaHate), generalizing to political discussions in other
regions like the US.
|
[
-0.5726034641265869,
-0.8679897785186768,
0.29394155740737915,
0.1412268728017807,
-0.3972610533237457,
0.011755893938243389,
-0.29796719551086426,
-0.7052972316741943,
0.5869565606117249,
0.7799504399299622,
-0.07553446292877197,
-0.5993342995643616,
-0.8723593950271606,
0.2588341236114502,
-0.6431742310523987,
1.3892033100128174,
0.006380806211382151,
-0.24338708817958832,
0.5115585327148438,
-0.5014738440513611,
-0.14703108370304108,
-0.4803577959537506,
-0.4964033365249634,
0.045806922018527985,
0.40111368894577026,
0.2983998954296112,
0.5605718493461609,
0.4105956256389618,
0.14511145651340485,
0.27242979407310486,
0.16426442563533783,
-0.00905488058924675,
-0.6129769086837769,
0.22151590883731842,
-0.20143373310565948,
-0.2948477566242218,
-0.20781590044498444,
-0.27026668190956116,
0.1997300535440445,
-0.025506315752863884,
-0.1583128422498703,
0.1734658032655716,
-0.011297615244984627,
0.39453718066215515,
-0.7994804978370667,
0.08537791669368744,
-1.157719612121582,
-0.094925157725811,
-0.6250301003456116,
-0.021787019446492195,
-0.03086579032242298,
-0.564353346824646,
-0.12466860562562943,
-0.6039653420448303,
-0.026724083349108696,
-0.22452028095722198,
0.6581467390060425,
0.021967386826872826,
-0.4128458797931671,
-0.7803087830543518,
-0.4896969795227051,
0.6452100276947021,
-0.6508588790893555,
0.150645449757576,
0.5326564908027649,
0.3530610501766205,
0.10492303222417831,
-0.37595757842063904,
-0.7640160918235779,
0.056940507143735886,
0.05200628563761711,
0.08664387464523315,
-0.20071788132190704,
-0.0533711239695549,
-0.10840889811515808,
0.12383457273244858,
0.028697781264781952,
0.14027024805545807,
-0.32760798931121826,
-0.5063976049423218,
0.7273065447807312,
-0.07837420701980591,
0.345157265663147,
-0.4316707253456116,
-0.49646878242492676,
0.018106432631611824,
-0.38052740693092346,
-0.2761281132698059,
0.9333105683326721,
0.6794076561927795,
-0.01356852613389492,
0.08933605998754501,
-0.1919507086277008,
0.3277491629123688,
0.06981328129768372,
0.005030930042266846,
0.33076292276382446,
0.002881110878661275,
0.04607195779681206,
0.33335092663764954,
1.1832858324050903,
0.4102024734020233,
0.3471047878265381,
0.036511022597551346,
-0.32143285870552063,
0.5158877968788147,
0.3748824894428253,
-0.9391274452209473,
-0.17013373970985413,
0.29845353960990906,
-0.1277618259191513,
-0.6307810544967651,
-0.36850178241729736,
-1.4363408088684082,
-0.957109808921814,
0.12951429188251495,
0.38008973002433777,
-0.20993053913116455,
-0.28496330976486206,
-0.28073397278785706,
-0.04105538874864578,
-0.14229796826839447,
0.46356379985809326,
-0.9865136742591858,
0.2131573110818863,
0.5383923649787903,
0.45604392886161804,
-0.26715222001075745,
0.12528248131275177,
-0.2006060779094696,
-0.07413642853498459,
-0.25163546204566956,
0.5630574226379395,
-0.6273685693740845,
-0.05337017402052879,
0.33761703968048096,
-0.1958491951227188,
0.1905340701341629,
-0.7824509143829346,
0.9162648916244507,
-0.6714276075363159,
0.06705283373594284,
0.031373530626297,
-0.2534111440181732,
-0.30048465728759766,
0.18879762291908264,
-0.7071647047996521,
1.0270092487335205,
0.23609276115894318,
-0.506125271320343,
0.448102205991745,
-0.6752962470054626,
-0.41605061292648315,
0.10185138881206512,
-0.1376568228006363,
-0.6468108296394348,
-0.22040653228759766,
0.3580102026462555,
0.4688645303249359,
-0.016132919117808342,
0.2766473889350891,
-0.47909238934516907,
0.0014899305533617735,
0.10095465183258057,
-0.14008358120918274,
0.877651035785675,
0.30698004364967346,
-0.8786775469779968,
0.02510729990899563,
-0.8081181645393372,
-0.2161024510860443,
0.0008995964890345931,
-0.08249099552631378,
-0.4058920443058014,
-0.010498998686671257,
0.5224077701568604,
0.33466044068336487,
-0.10425135493278503,
-0.9511997103691101,
-0.15823592245578766,
-0.02828056551516056,
0.33317723870277405,
0.9852749705314636,
-0.11350615322589874,
0.1971808820962906,
-0.2383006513118744,
0.5414886474609375,
0.03564508259296417,
-0.07912004739046097,
0.4151010811328888,
-0.6378437280654907,
-0.3353961706161499,
0.027466507628560066,
0.1266304850578308,
0.7603376507759094,
-0.7881432175636292,
0.02033643238246441,
-0.2981152832508087,
-0.24229998886585236,
-0.6539654731750488,
0.06489211320877075,
0.14202408492565155,
0.21671345829963684,
0.49208295345306396,
0.1963585466146469,
-0.6456204056739807,
-0.8308799862861633,
-0.6244300603866577,
-0.24766981601715088,
0.19113297760486603,
0.39363253116607666,
0.7644244432449341,
-0.15265898406505585,
0.6549898386001587,
0.15824277698993683,
-0.5083210468292236,
-0.03716159984469414,
0.3436294496059418,
-0.15474969148635864,
0.061931174248456955,
0.8690245151519775,
-0.9886118173599243,
-0.8903319239616394,
0.27647683024406433,
-0.24381732940673828,
-0.5390281677246094,
-0.05968576297163963,
-0.1639653891324997,
0.24836798012256622,
0.20740719139575958,
0.10179156810045242,
0.4212908446788788,
0.8130747675895691,
-0.3581787943840027,
0.4990285634994507,
0.8182404041290283,
0.632366955280304,
-1.137450098991394,
-0.10473127663135529,
-0.20302458107471466,
-0.6587409973144531,
-0.6713695526123047,
0.014639127999544144,
-0.26593104004859924,
0.036883026361465454,
-0.4335850477218628,
0.5470131635665894,
-0.033574774861335754,
0.4605751931667328,
-0.25242552161216736,
0.24198973178863525,
-0.5714532136917114,
0.4579939842224121,
0.11142181605100632,
0.6727692484855652,
0.26636970043182373,
-0.29432758688926697,
0.5622180700302124,
0.2612782120704651,
-0.37713730335235596,
0.8190636038780212,
-0.15743279457092285,
0.4157947599887848,
0.2022031843662262,
-0.05450517684221268,
-0.9286321997642517,
-0.1545163244009018,
0.7460118532180786,
-0.44325000047683716,
0.0706430971622467,
-0.27494966983795166,
-0.19830816984176636,
-0.03544127196073532,
-0.3643283247947693,
0.22327059507369995,
0.05221028998494148,
-0.44989484548568726,
0.5416997671127319,
0.9463403820991516,
-0.21967971324920654,
-0.6770366430282593,
-0.5273697972297668,
0.24537259340286255,
-0.5684785842895508,
-0.17499114573001862,
0.43222853541374207,
0.30938002467155457,
-0.10494247823953629,
0.17258712649345398,
0.019702674821019173,
-0.22897306084632874,
-0.13639990985393524,
0.17091290652751923,
-0.11398566514253616,
-0.12275339663028717,
-0.1336093693971634,
0.014520193450152874,
0.3656896650791168,
0.3190818727016449,
0.05149015784263611,
0.42766284942626953,
-0.23264192044734955,
0.3168366849422455,
-0.17807580530643463,
0.378189355134964,
0.36397844552993774,
0.1841411292552948,
0.7884063124656677,
0.716429591178894,
-0.43025198578834534,
-0.3594968318939209,
-0.3012234568595886,
-0.12975718080997467,
-0.36870837211608887,
0.6441971063613892,
-0.1329975128173828,
-0.964755654335022,
0.681344211101532,
0.05908729135990143,
0.2601136565208435,
0.25960230827331543,
0.6726421117782593,
-0.04298747330904007,
0.666216254234314,
0.1543462723493576,
-0.2805648744106293,
0.5386171936988831,
-0.03744969144463539,
0.2039438784122467,
-0.5138493776321411,
0.2225252240896225,
-0.7594583630561829,
-0.4574146568775177,
-0.9109715223312378,
-0.16712063550949097,
0.2707624137401581,
-0.1720312535762787,
-0.12420224398374557,
0.37866848707199097,
-0.34339427947998047,
0.28753769397735596,
-0.09087482839822769,
0.266218364238739,
-0.014668326824903488,
0.20157954096794128,
0.14841563999652863,
-0.11726028472185135,
-0.3660736382007599,
-0.3976207375526428,
1.1911600828170776,
0.009497747756540775,
0.4839700758457184,
0.29611897468566895,
0.7166338562965393,
0.6055294275283813,
0.9137700200080872,
-0.7880682945251465,
0.36066436767578125,
-0.1631484180688858,
-1.0733129978179932,
-0.5674887299537659,
-0.7287462949752808,
-1.0338499546051025,
0.36694541573524475,
-0.3237265646457672,
-0.8868547677993774,
0.29500842094421387,
0.09439825266599655,
-0.04809162765741348,
0.8707008361816406,
-0.1795700341463089,
0.7654401659965515,
-0.11891733855009079,
-0.38844001293182373,
-0.20200350880622864,
-0.4958527982234955,
0.3458479344844818,
-0.22314712405204773,
0.7190735340118408,
-0.12574473023414612,
-0.07874969393014908,
1.1212859153747559,
-0.3943285644054413,
0.744196355342865,
-0.17882902920246124,
-0.28585919737815857,
0.27502375841140747,
0.08981189876794815,
0.3043200969696045,
-0.3422282040119171,
-0.16206315159797668,
0.484413206577301,
-0.17738032341003418,
-0.08797784894704819,
-0.4469819664955139,
0.5671430230140686,
-0.6696832180023193,
-0.22589606046676636,
-0.3961053192615509,
-0.4049954116344452,
-0.23180685937404633,
0.28326836228370667,
0.24259749054908752,
0.3809089958667755,
-0.3315817415714264,
0.2665552794933319,
0.3318459689617157,
-0.12361841648817062,
0.05798882618546486,
0.09388022869825363,
-0.31343498826026917,
-0.6009465456008911,
0.8672354221343994,
-0.022889720275998116,
0.18886947631835938,
0.2070041447877884,
0.2977604269981384,
-0.42195427417755127,
-0.33343827724456787,
-0.6909052133560181,
-0.02201955020427704,
-0.6726144552230835,
-0.397233784198761,
-0.5653014779090881,
0.2332805097103119,
-0.29502734541893005,
-0.10906282067298889,
-0.5095757842063904,
-0.5130144953727722,
0.03213530033826828,
0.15719465911388397,
0.4078304171562195,
0.7808942198753357,
-0.1875166893005371,
0.4597128927707672,
-0.37930744886398315,
0.6130033135414124,
0.13961456716060638,
0.3296907842159271,
-0.36037909984588623,
-0.8056532740592957,
-0.09661244601011276,
0.24356891214847565,
-0.6742137670516968,
-1.611840844154358,
0.14072903990745544,
0.3032030463218689,
0.26852527260780334,
0.49790990352630615,
0.3689196705818176,
0.46071887016296387,
-0.22822695970535278,
0.4665575623512268,
0.027352621778845787,
-0.7184638381004333,
0.5337185859680176,
-0.3658463656902313,
-0.3270098865032196,
0.6836860775947571,
0.6842694878578186,
-0.5831489562988281,
-0.6842123866081238,
-0.5857289433479309,
-0.6548385620117188,
0.7920337319374084,
0.3445635437965393,
0.3008047640323639,
-0.11235607415437698,
-0.04456125944852829,
0.13444113731384277,
0.3530048429965973,
-0.8869376182556152,
-0.7399311065673828,
-0.20312750339508057,
-0.08288158476352692,
0.3589976727962494,
-0.1401924341917038,
-0.1841607391834259,
-0.1407223492860794,
0.8830020427703857,
-0.00661806296557188,
0.23703192174434662,
-0.2329338937997818,
-0.06396277993917465,
-0.11522254347801208,
0.5675603151321411,
0.23035527765750885,
0.5040260553359985,
-0.20689520239830017,
-0.19608591496944427,
-0.10087231546640396,
-0.7997326850891113,
0.16371281445026398,
0.21478921175003052,
-0.2683184742927551,
0.24275079369544983,
-0.0826435461640358,
0.8378083109855652,
0.09040271490812302,
-0.2612723112106323,
0.5171353220939636,
0.12497512996196747,
-0.3467012345790863,
-0.04705284535884857,
-0.19024118781089783,
-0.057321906089782715,
-0.23720091581344604,
0.08918403089046478,
0.09690352529287338,
0.413496196269989,
-0.815804123878479,
0.16389097273349762,
0.2476508617401123,
-0.45330625772476196,
-0.2031366527080536,
0.7640566229820251,
0.6263916492462158,
-0.19666807353496552,
0.4120815694332123,
-0.25246763229370117,
-1.0674878358840942,
0.4586179554462433,
0.5125047564506531,
0.7985395193099976,
-0.5456844568252563,
0.5373097658157349,
0.511300265789032,
0.48781806230545044,
0.6821470260620117,
0.4127773940563202,
-0.24205276370048523,
-1.1926095485687256,
-0.09332837164402008,
-0.6811571717262268,
-0.15527339279651642,
0.5728729367256165,
-0.8616541624069214,
0.16349919140338898,
-0.5806284546852112,
-0.3477911651134491,
0.04594835266470909,
0.09808802604675293,
-0.47727587819099426,
0.026029059663414955,
0.36894407868385315,
0.3812609612941742,
-1.1172542572021484,
0.33131951093673706,
0.7727844715118408,
0.08448226004838943,
-0.3436233401298523,
-0.2911056876182556,
0.17502343654632568,
-0.8053532242774963,
0.3151569664478302,
0.15135042369365692,
-0.2529858946800232,
-0.11277233064174652,
-0.6032355427742004,
-0.2123599499464035,
0.2556682229042053,
0.3277246356010437,
-0.5371395349502563,
0.6138734817504883,
0.40703853964805603,
0.345969557762146,
-0.07604493200778961,
0.22566568851470947,
0.6701763868331909,
0.40244168043136597,
-0.1909971833229065,
-0.9305357336997986,
0.14729444682598114,
-0.2511148750782013,
-0.34059739112854004,
0.8151606917381287,
-0.5003088116645813,
0.48512497544288635,
0.07257764786481857,
-0.4414190649986267,
-0.11165667325258255,
0.40864071249961853,
-0.02147168666124344,
0.3397495746612549,
0.6184080243110657,
0.6915969848632812,
0.5392285585403442,
-0.20335738360881805,
0.9055128693580627,
-0.1449386477470398,
0.28926748037338257,
1.028064489364624,
-0.11458346992731094,
0.75135737657547,
0.33706870675086975,
-0.37485167384147644,
0.6651901006698608,
0.22540251910686493,
0.36995938420295715,
0.40843555331230164,
0.19684536755084991,
-0.28940463066101074,
-0.08016916364431381,
-0.2104855328798294,
-0.3756071627140045,
0.5673308372497559,
0.8099685311317444,
-0.1517530381679535,
-0.3532716929912567,
0.11233461648225784,
0.5525636672973633,
0.3749368190765381,
-0.32435131072998047,
0.7016844153404236,
-0.10616259276866913,
-0.21880176663398743,
0.6206386685371399,
0.061688389629125595,
0.794527530670166,
-0.5418757796287537,
-0.3354933261871338,
0.010598006658256054,
-0.04751396179199219,
-0.19213715195655823,
-0.9618722796440125,
0.36762356758117676,
0.10705224424600601,
0.27464571595191956,
-0.18238578736782074,
0.4816392660140991,
-0.5581332445144653,
-0.10323817282915115,
0.33138054609298706,
-0.08063262701034546,
0.3409050405025482,
-0.3026062846183777,
-0.9652315974235535,
0.19986334443092346,
0.01975146308541298,
0.03292037174105644,
0.2387869656085968,
0.6053497791290283,
-0.2606793940067291,
0.281472384929657,
0.6432570815086365,
0.3873167634010315,
0.2428962141275406,
-0.02647441439330578,
0.737232506275177,
-0.2534332871437073,
-0.6522480249404907,
-0.6541516780853271,
0.0674581453204155,
-0.14776287972927094,
-0.7812248468399048,
0.6906697750091553,
0.5070332884788513,
1.0862250328063965,
0.11385656893253326,
0.936954140663147,
-0.4579753577709198,
0.6360626816749573,
-0.38642287254333496,
0.7056044936180115,
-0.3823586702346802,
-0.15341967344284058,
-0.5854292511940002,
-0.7674793004989624,
-0.1721448004245758,
0.7678389549255371,
-0.28274649381637573,
0.07143901288509369,
0.44585755467414856,
0.82985919713974,
-0.11411554366350174,
0.2994144558906555,
0.26249459385871887,
0.5523146986961365,
0.25646892189979553,
0.47378990054130554,
0.8735066652297974,
-0.668761670589447,
0.660505473613739,
-0.5584108233451843,
-0.28459933400154114,
-0.33252474665641785,
-0.7784359455108643,
-0.7715815305709839,
-0.5510128140449524,
-0.3010472357273102,
-0.560100793838501,
0.21653594076633453,
0.6143589615821838,
0.5471322536468506,
-1.266899824142456,
-0.34972110390663147,
0.22879312932491302,
0.10580955445766449,
-0.03441186621785164,
-0.29858362674713135,
0.2866009771823883,
0.13140803575515747,
-0.7566487789154053,
-0.20224805176258087,
0.026612406596541405,
-0.5150373578071594,
0.11088825762271881,
0.026019159704446793,
-0.38156431913375854,
-0.030766714364290237,
0.6732529997825623,
0.44120267033576965,
-0.5781171917915344,
-0.32179194688796997,
-0.48405927419662476,
-0.04801830276846886,
0.03822661563754082,
0.6528857946395874,
-0.6325143575668335,
0.5363975167274475,
0.2454186975955963,
0.7888748645782471,
0.22372925281524658,
0.1989634782075882,
0.12252844870090485,
-0.4505336582660675,
0.21273641288280487,
0.5097124576568604,
0.1583494395017624,
0.31993645429611206,
-0.313959538936615,
0.31730568408966064,
0.3294007480144501,
-0.7083644270896912,
-0.6382161974906921,
0.02027321793138981,
-0.7079957723617554,
-0.022492723539471626,
1.063899278640747,
0.14936697483062744,
-0.24026232957839966,
-0.43206796050071716,
-0.20243258774280548,
0.10701294988393784,
-0.765714704990387,
1.058646559715271,
0.7472906708717346,
0.06817131489515305,
0.06917038559913635,
-0.8406420946121216,
0.6807194948196411,
0.27616992592811584,
-0.9526746869087219,
-0.022087492048740387,
0.5465817451477051,
0.26436564326286316,
0.17724724113941193,
0.6654248237609863,
-0.22524093091487885,
0.47481855750083923,
-0.03346630558371544,
0.021909387782216072,
0.35171130299568176,
-0.25168150663375854,
-0.04900719225406647,
-0.06130746006965637,
-0.7337613105773926,
-0.4517807960510254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18154v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18154v1
|
Explaining vague language
| 2024-04-28T12:11:34 | 2024-04-28T12:11:34 |
Paul Égré, Benjamin Spector
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.GT, cs.IT, math.IT, 91A86, I.2.7
|
Why is language vague? Vagueness may be explained and rationalized if it can
be shown that vague language is more useful to speaker and hearer than precise
language. In a well-known paper, Lipman proposes a game-theoretic account of
vagueness in terms of mixed strategy that leads to a puzzle: vagueness cannot
be strictly better than precision at equilibrium. More recently, \'Egr\'e,
Spector, Mortier and Verheyen have put forward a Bayesian account of vagueness
establishing that using vague words can be strictly more informative than using
precise words. This paper proposes to compare both results and to explain why
they are not in contradiction. Lipman's definition of vagueness relies
exclusively on a property of signaling strategies, without making any
assumptions about the lexicon, whereas \'Egr\'e et al.'s involves a layer of
semantic content. We argue that the semantic account of vagueness is needed,
and more adequate and explanatory of vagueness.
|
[
-0.38130486011505127,
-0.8869035840034485,
0.8644590377807617,
0.14833606779575348,
-0.3177245855331421,
-0.16661399602890015,
-0.38319459557533264,
-0.5400984883308411,
0.3568607270717621,
0.3939366638660431,
-0.4413609206676483,
-0.16026483476161957,
-0.6217778921127319,
0.04715525731444359,
-0.566392183303833,
1.0988132953643799,
0.23542851209640503,
-0.19411899149417877,
0.15920348465442657,
0.03988347575068474,
-0.20600561797618866,
-0.14723020792007446,
-0.6738453507423401,
-0.4692522883415222,
0.6158857345581055,
0.3451665937900543,
1.1749153137207031,
0.6135474443435669,
0.4706519842147827,
0.38165178894996643,
-0.09805935621261597,
-0.5889158248901367,
-0.2817591428756714,
0.18350480496883392,
-0.1474696695804596,
-0.7222598195075989,
-0.005064027383923531,
-0.32389435172080994,
0.4509126543998718,
1.097287654876709,
-0.22934119403362274,
-0.09492585062980652,
0.13147024810314178,
0.5879971981048584,
-0.4907614290714264,
-0.04807151481509209,
-0.6288101673126221,
-0.0693310797214508,
-0.3912718594074249,
-0.18681950867176056,
0.27517539262771606,
-0.202367901802063,
0.6531534790992737,
-0.954338550567627,
0.5719476938247681,
-0.09158821403980255,
1.2006374597549438,
0.22619296610355377,
-0.25158244371414185,
-0.5564548373222351,
-1.0449905395507812,
0.6215957999229431,
-0.8431973457336426,
0.08826452493667603,
0.3137843906879425,
0.23789864778518677,
-0.12395303696393967,
-0.4622255265712738,
-0.6734259128570557,
-0.2973538637161255,
0.24503791332244873,
0.3695950210094452,
-0.08439554274082184,
0.44755011796951294,
0.3899476230144501,
0.3673313558101654,
-0.39178377389907837,
-0.11058066785335541,
-0.23555408418178558,
-0.12655429542064667,
0.4223001301288605,
-0.08437533676624298,
-0.020908890292048454,
-0.1880476176738739,
-0.5200897455215454,
0.2140231877565384,
-0.22112329304218292,
0.09781546145677567,
0.3433767557144165,
0.18689556419849396,
0.10671167820692062,
0.4086643159389496,
-0.16327154636383057,
0.5783399939537048,
0.03125507012009621,
-0.07144671678543091,
-0.2003679871559143,
-0.20196639001369476,
0.09876536577939987,
-0.20039571821689606,
0.6814267039299011,
0.3414976894855499,
0.16927051544189453,
-0.4612622857093811,
-0.37822428345680237,
-0.030771248042583466,
0.008958880789577961,
-0.6062811613082886,
-0.15434867143630981,
0.3703204393386841,
-0.3302370607852936,
0.23376789689064026,
0.16083143651485443,
-0.7379652857780457,
-0.09354707598686218,
0.13589178025722504,
0.32010263204574585,
-0.28817567229270935,
-0.3169177770614624,
0.45228132605552673,
-0.5022883415222168,
0.32558614015579224,
0.15362009406089783,
-0.9582908749580383,
0.8594591617584229,
0.7117419838905334,
0.629377007484436,
0.061883606016635895,
-0.2942660450935364,
0.11822638660669327,
0.30400606989860535,
-0.3996712565422058,
0.9468008875846863,
-0.495837539434433,
-0.38183650374412537,
0.1213303655385971,
-0.42440885305404663,
0.24052177369594574,
-0.6833897829055786,
0.5974845886230469,
-0.12685947120189667,
0.4885600209236145,
-0.3643013834953308,
-0.7347795367240906,
-0.19578738510608673,
-0.35962963104248047,
-0.33333274722099304,
0.8488489985466003,
0.09863810986280441,
-0.6035090088844299,
0.9584319591522217,
-0.2833954691886902,
-0.3494240641593933,
0.46977999806404114,
-0.2494332194328308,
-0.03615102916955948,
0.5874541997909546,
-0.30095866322517395,
0.2177855521440506,
-0.34535646438598633,
0.3943820893764496,
-0.4633285105228424,
-0.5503702759742737,
0.84329754114151,
-0.3343439996242523,
-0.022555669769644737,
0.38717129826545715,
-0.5413760542869568,
-0.2975393235683441,
-0.5750601291656494,
0.24351538717746735,
0.02372172102332115,
-0.3493193984031677,
-0.3726663589477539,
0.3982231020927429,
-0.04078430309891701,
0.1339147984981537,
0.3408934473991394,
-0.450601726770401,
-0.2640976905822754,
-0.6567147970199585,
0.23115918040275574,
0.4433531165122986,
-0.13830521702766418,
0.6824946999549866,
-0.6012061834335327,
0.37494057416915894,
-0.3116686940193176,
0.27415215969085693,
0.2967473864555359,
-0.5889596939086914,
-0.8035976886749268,
-0.3631722629070282,
0.40989950299263,
0.5752556324005127,
-0.4731602072715759,
0.030894652009010315,
-0.26369205117225647,
0.2029133439064026,
-0.5248134732246399,
0.011349240317940712,
0.28387534618377686,
0.19597066938877106,
0.07605956494808197,
-0.5696095824241638,
-0.3554935157299042,
-0.9818196892738342,
-0.5775969624519348,
-0.22276024520397186,
-0.14453856647014618,
0.44055941700935364,
0.37893226742744446,
0.265912801027298,
0.846992015838623,
-0.33789005875587463,
0.06303086131811142,
-0.31512418389320374,
0.04109423607587814,
0.3794061839580536,
0.26153919100761414,
0.3135444223880768,
-0.7777453064918518,
-0.2530539035797119,
-0.07424894720315933,
-0.5493781566619873,
-0.23148280382156372,
-0.26932212710380554,
0.17834270000457764,
-0.3824622929096222,
0.21495190262794495,
-0.5557153224945068,
0.4545993208885193,
0.060733817517757416,
-0.11172117292881012,
0.2878911793231964,
-0.11379262059926987,
-0.2950841188430786,
-0.7246565818786621,
-0.10678143799304962,
0.11959628015756607,
-0.3869319558143616,
-0.9284295439720154,
0.15981324017047882,
-0.5152388215065002,
-0.13131274282932281,
-0.13968224823474884,
0.5913674235343933,
-0.36966395378112793,
0.1227877214550972,
-0.7862984538078308,
0.6659649014472961,
-0.13963603973388672,
0.23450367152690887,
0.019402513280510902,
0.12709495425224304,
0.7400009036064148,
-0.7951916456222534,
0.22919988632202148,
-0.16442926228046417,
-0.05046572908759117,
0.41476160287857056,
-0.9012258052825928,
-0.38931262493133545,
-0.2515348494052887,
-0.142942875623703,
-0.9782028794288635,
-0.22250667214393616,
0.6316736936569214,
-0.40746474266052246,
0.30531659722328186,
-0.08687864989042282,
-0.3168240487575531,
-0.3452783226966858,
-0.13920485973358154,
0.1853017657995224,
0.6367974281311035,
0.0519631989300251,
0.047566406428813934,
0.2892439365386963,
-0.07509732991456985,
-0.5525694489479065,
-0.6645609140396118,
-0.020085321739315987,
-0.5233729481697083,
-0.32546108961105347,
0.2903834283351898,
0.0053939782083034515,
-0.5487154126167297,
0.22409948706626892,
-0.6754536628723145,
-0.5809415578842163,
0.3746975064277649,
0.18930529057979584,
-0.1482333242893219,
-0.28604158759117126,
0.25153979659080505,
-0.26995235681533813,
-0.34269851446151733,
0.1552736610174179,
-0.5057387948036194,
0.06295426934957504,
-0.08398167043924332,
-0.228819340467453,
-0.23861990869045258,
0.5964359641075134,
-0.10014887899160385,
0.7112396359443665,
0.5963209867477417,
0.43203628063201904,
-0.1651175171136856,
-0.07228917628526688,
-0.3936639130115509,
-0.3294139802455902,
-0.44355958700180054,
0.11890086531639099,
-0.4126794934272766,
-0.8899781703948975,
0.7594800591468811,
-0.35581278800964355,
-0.2790429890155792,
0.5648061037063599,
0.007813257165253162,
-0.1709061861038208,
0.7320504784584045,
0.8145439028739929,
0.4446048140525818,
0.36242568492889404,
0.22727759182453156,
0.12173423916101456,
-0.47094014286994934,
-0.06077015772461891,
-0.572829008102417,
0.0959453210234642,
-0.9046763777732849,
-0.10250747203826904,
-0.10195212066173553,
0.38006168603897095,
0.0936158299446106,
0.0006280760280787945,
-0.2637840211391449,
0.5113181471824646,
0.3556724786758423,
-0.006544654257595539,
0.0026891687884926796,
-0.254591166973114,
-0.19836577773094177,
-0.12004316598176956,
-1.2149947881698608,
-0.8071611523628235,
0.6698269248008728,
0.44003820419311523,
0.896345853805542,
0.28640103340148926,
0.7658292055130005,
-0.13907122611999512,
0.008651257492601871,
-0.939987063407898,
0.5436939001083374,
0.02846362814307213,
-1.005745530128479,
-0.4151114821434021,
-0.6551308631896973,
-1.0142295360565186,
0.40369048714637756,
-0.30666208267211914,
-0.7845556139945984,
0.13996395468711853,
0.11855859309434891,
-0.17866456508636475,
0.034425199031829834,
-0.7245591282844543,
0.7184432148933411,
-0.2363385558128357,
-0.19171684980392456,
0.13297967612743378,
-0.6988996863365173,
0.34076985716819763,
-0.05640428140759468,
0.6017574071884155,
-0.2962820827960968,
-0.604724645614624,
0.7245659232139587,
-0.767071545124054,
0.6807199716567993,
0.05017507076263428,
-0.08926078677177429,
0.25593921542167664,
-0.1866234838962555,
-0.007666941732168198,
0.04718983545899391,
0.2471850961446762,
0.042194779962301254,
0.097474604845047,
-0.8026018142700195,
-0.775152325630188,
0.36344483494758606,
-0.5350310802459717,
-0.8124851584434509,
-0.49594438076019287,
-0.40251198410987854,
0.11122947186231613,
0.17292897403240204,
0.4905749559402466,
0.49898532032966614,
-0.3254295289516449,
-0.34282034635543823,
0.9022670984268188,
-0.07704303413629532,
0.2664058208465576,
0.4462425708770752,
-0.2217349410057068,
-0.04347919300198555,
1.0435043573379517,
0.11806221306324005,
0.5451151728630066,
0.7351256012916565,
0.38617706298828125,
-0.24177458882331848,
-0.6565310955047607,
0.06581943482160568,
0.2553236186504364,
-0.7374624013900757,
0.42190977931022644,
-0.12384411692619324,
0.09049411863088608,
0.10482295602560043,
-0.04545394703745842,
-0.09727772325277328,
-0.6983453035354614,
0.032932836562395096,
0.3581271767616272,
0.16349482536315918,
0.994787335395813,
-0.43946653604507446,
0.6453515887260437,
-0.30745384097099304,
0.4124528169631958,
0.24507902562618256,
0.4533093571662903,
-0.0795179083943367,
-0.5250570774078369,
-0.243557870388031,
0.10459406673908234,
-0.05859013646841049,
-1.2612249851226807,
-0.18217262625694275,
0.5144657492637634,
0.8394981026649475,
0.5815163850784302,
-0.23889999091625214,
0.7612048387527466,
-0.3630181849002838,
0.644855260848999,
0.27804046869277954,
-1.2644414901733398,
0.44604814052581787,
-0.34426990151405334,
0.4589088261127472,
0.3933596909046173,
0.4048791825771332,
-0.4627774953842163,
-0.9687082171440125,
-1.0026527643203735,
-1.1736619472503662,
0.3760994076728821,
0.16034716367721558,
0.05048398673534393,
-0.1921510249376297,
0.6625868678092957,
0.4340285658836365,
0.4834204316139221,
-0.7382801175117493,
-0.50815349817276,
-0.29714661836624146,
0.0017066722502931952,
-0.038706135004758835,
-0.505659282207489,
-0.4087008237838745,
0.24346479773521423,
0.34180381894111633,
0.06476397067308426,
0.4591550827026367,
0.2875232994556427,
-0.10262955725193024,
0.06175217404961586,
0.6177805066108704,
0.7130794525146484,
1.061443567276001,
-0.08057276904582977,
0.3710005581378937,
0.18598434329032898,
-0.3426360785961151,
0.01235932856798172,
0.27267226576805115,
-0.433871328830719,
0.5476524829864502,
0.5801157355308533,
0.7652766108512878,
0.6425246596336365,
-0.4879988431930542,
0.6517420411109924,
0.04288418963551521,
-0.4845476746559143,
-0.10222011059522629,
0.14444376528263092,
-0.12722539901733398,
0.17617717385292053,
0.5677948594093323,
0.2625022232532501,
0.2351633459329605,
-0.5914772748947144,
0.2070518136024475,
0.4912598729133606,
-0.38569048047065735,
-0.3216586709022522,
0.6640793681144714,
0.1312945932149887,
-0.030859733000397682,
-0.0665556862950325,
-0.3322935998439789,
-0.5585971474647522,
0.36175885796546936,
0.36826789379119873,
0.6333335041999817,
0.08902611583471298,
0.4018513560295105,
-0.04469461739063263,
0.40651610493659973,
-0.07338361442089081,
0.6040399074554443,
-0.32940903306007385,
-0.55367511510849,
-0.4359194040298462,
-0.3013986051082611,
-0.46889665722846985,
-0.04903719574213028,
-0.7892038822174072,
-0.41407206654548645,
-0.584394633769989,
-0.5748581886291504,
0.19862456619739532,
0.01659918762743473,
-0.5851407647132874,
-0.02645830065011978,
0.05274839699268341,
0.7100412249565125,
-0.5159410834312439,
0.0609530508518219,
0.4552827477455139,
-0.3258861005306244,
-0.5980333685874939,
0.47609466314315796,
-0.21056880056858063,
-0.6646004319190979,
0.5232271552085876,
-0.2521992623806,
-0.1998620331287384,
-0.22858864068984985,
-0.5534898042678833,
-0.8482789397239685,
0.4730868339538574,
0.2464379072189331,
-0.42488688230514526,
0.3951876163482666,
0.1970430612564087,
0.626136839389801,
-0.11907506734132767,
0.4659958481788635,
0.009598287753760815,
0.5361891388893127,
0.18856041133403778,
-0.7969765663146973,
0.0588575080037117,
0.1217263787984848,
0.3530004024505615,
0.3814171254634857,
-0.444699227809906,
0.46401771903038025,
-0.5573971271514893,
-0.7479373216629028,
0.27828744053840637,
0.8292352557182312,
-0.3815777897834778,
0.22019271552562714,
0.042980510741472244,
0.2981700897216797,
0.7461656928062439,
-0.39304354786872864,
1.101426124572754,
-0.22447744011878967,
0.37385761737823486,
0.7329787015914917,
-0.1872330904006958,
0.6558986902236938,
0.44967105984687805,
-0.2211443930864334,
0.48875245451927185,
0.6000677347183228,
0.2632961869239807,
0.6320499181747437,
0.6961680054664612,
-0.43095308542251587,
-0.21744874119758606,
-0.15497656166553497,
-0.28229352831840515,
0.20273268222808838,
0.5108373761177063,
0.07430095970630646,
-0.4468250572681427,
0.039246369153261185,
0.029787547886371613,
0.054951876401901245,
-0.3693261444568634,
0.8353341817855835,
0.2804943919181824,
-0.2459549605846405,
0.5470899939537048,
-0.04716202989220619,
0.6606276631355286,
-0.7270420789718628,
0.2845805287361145,
0.06609246134757996,
-0.003876575268805027,
-0.2016175389289856,
-0.9930141568183899,
0.20682783424854279,
-0.21461540460586548,
-0.07442789524793625,
-0.09695182740688324,
0.7550287246704102,
-0.5112482309341431,
0.00038235742249526083,
0.08016996085643768,
0.8973560929298401,
0.5898208618164062,
0.3013764023780823,
-1.0975874662399292,
-0.1421847939491272,
-0.466622918844223,
0.13223467767238617,
0.05101386830210686,
0.9496333003044128,
0.5296161770820618,
0.9096939563751221,
0.4195336699485779,
0.4974566102027893,
0.2526286542415619,
-0.07719745486974716,
0.49367469549179077,
-0.7539088129997253,
-0.25592169165611267,
-0.831476092338562,
0.18773184716701508,
0.0461893230676651,
-0.607465386390686,
0.9039775729179382,
0.3373068869113922,
0.6407880783081055,
0.11819380521774292,
0.8380800485610962,
-0.2744401693344116,
0.25118231773376465,
-0.6472595930099487,
0.0927465409040451,
-0.3722379207611084,
0.2767558991909027,
-0.09381116181612015,
-0.75965815782547,
-0.16829514503479004,
0.6555380821228027,
-0.3789605498313904,
0.34796974062919617,
1.0565284490585327,
0.39764848351478577,
0.000020273619156796485,
-0.06342954188585281,
0.5039799809455872,
0.2866615951061249,
-0.3431590497493744,
0.6747261881828308,
1.286141276359558,
-0.31968700885772705,
0.5687759518623352,
-0.0174617487937212,
-0.3067793846130371,
-0.179625004529953,
-0.6701661348342896,
-0.7569843530654907,
-0.6345537304878235,
-0.3194705843925476,
-0.2732911705970764,
0.2191040962934494,
0.2970198392868042,
0.6087446808815002,
-0.38319921493530273,
-0.4855864346027374,
-0.2751425802707672,
0.5310205221176147,
-0.3009304106235504,
-0.27159157395362854,
-0.31511685252189636,
-0.28409963846206665,
-0.3618038296699524,
-0.06353047490119934,
0.34053757786750793,
0.23892171680927277,
-0.009357847273349762,
-0.007537457626312971,
0.22080808877944946,
0.22290541231632233,
0.1288784146308899,
0.7193355560302734,
-1.017916202545166,
-0.3477550745010376,
-0.19748668372631073,
-0.15783466398715973,
-0.08006724715232849,
0.7802489399909973,
-0.43572768568992615,
0.3916276693344116,
0.22003808617591858,
0.12138605117797852,
0.20924147963523865,
-0.24500612914562225,
0.7325955629348755,
-0.3530215919017792,
0.05727791413664818,
0.3597172498703003,
0.11633837223052979,
0.3674831688404083,
-0.15376681089401245,
0.028789078816771507,
0.3365783393383026,
-0.43153005838394165,
-0.28252145648002625,
0.5859734416007996,
-0.9190842509269714,
-0.35635364055633545,
0.9623739123344421,
-0.1661611795425415,
-0.32472148537635803,
-0.5027352571487427,
0.21762922406196594,
0.10060729086399078,
-0.6095348000526428,
0.5413908362388611,
0.9473196864128113,
-0.16819500923156738,
-0.17302797734737396,
-0.9774878025054932,
0.7935988903045654,
0.44602158665657043,
-0.47231051325798035,
-0.35349979996681213,
0.05561801418662071,
0.4318103492259979,
0.07602426409721375,
0.7146133780479431,
0.40595003962516785,
0.3404678404331207,
0.3101622462272644,
-0.4282219409942627,
0.586499035358429,
0.029377005994319916,
-0.3180495798587799,
-0.006076891906559467,
0.3358025550842285,
-0.1515045315027237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01584v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01584v1
|
Lightweight Conceptual Dictionary Learning for Text Classification Using Information Compression
| 2024-04-28T10:11:52 | 2024-04-28T10:11:52 |
Li Wan, Tansu Alpcan, Margreta Kuijper, Emanuele Viterbo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.SP
|
We propose a novel, lightweight supervised dictionary learning framework for
text classification based on data compression and representation. This
two-phase algorithm initially employs the Lempel-Ziv-Welch (LZW) algorithm to
construct a dictionary from text datasets, focusing on the conceptual
significance of dictionary elements. Subsequently, dictionaries are refined
considering label data, optimizing dictionary atoms to enhance discriminative
power based on mutual information and class distribution. This process
generates discriminative numerical representations, facilitating the training
of simple classifiers such as SVMs and neural networks. We evaluate our
algorithm's information-theoretic performance using information bottleneck
principles and introduce the information plane area rank (IPAR) as a novel
metric to quantify the information-theoretic performance. Tested on six
benchmark text datasets, our algorithm competes closely with top models,
especially in limited-vocabulary contexts, using significantly fewer
parameters. \review{Our algorithm closely matches top-performing models,
deviating by only ~2\% on limited-vocabulary datasets, using just 10\% of their
parameters. However, it falls short on diverse-vocabulary datasets, likely due
to the LZW algorithm's constraints with low-repetition data. This contrast
highlights its efficiency and limitations across different dataset types.
|
[
-0.2234458327293396,
-0.5425215363502502,
0.25119006633758545,
0.15445539355278015,
-0.486005038022995,
-0.03650069236755371,
-0.2524814009666443,
-0.4794422686100006,
0.18066558241844177,
0.042157240211963654,
-0.24605490267276764,
-0.4375383257865906,
-0.9089154005050659,
0.06449441611766815,
-0.5565482378005981,
0.8740683197975159,
0.07713977247476578,
0.008832626976072788,
-0.3178149163722992,
-0.06156918779015541,
-0.2739587724208832,
-0.4756007194519043,
-0.40484336018562317,
-0.38045555353164673,
0.43570858240127563,
0.542849063873291,
0.46242833137512207,
0.8340916633605957,
0.4904979169368744,
0.25180327892303467,
-0.14980188012123108,
0.053365614265203476,
-0.6317211985588074,
0.11640908569097519,
0.1556251049041748,
-0.31794273853302,
-0.12480834871530533,
-0.08866547048091888,
0.4795421063899994,
0.9425040483474731,
-0.44527557492256165,
0.006480247247964144,
0.354250431060791,
0.755187451839447,
-0.8930474519729614,
0.3189065158367157,
-0.8349549770355225,
0.20814527571201324,
-0.4441743493080139,
-0.224203959107399,
-0.4673769176006317,
-0.00613475451245904,
0.05930148437619209,
-0.6212677955627441,
0.5475006699562073,
0.18311260640621185,
0.8561837673187256,
0.38453829288482666,
-0.5347903370857239,
-0.422034353017807,
-0.3624071776866913,
0.6885413527488708,
-0.2586996853351593,
0.5968876481056213,
0.24928520619869232,
0.09712811559438705,
0.13798436522483826,
-0.9110120534896851,
-0.7195261120796204,
0.03232124075293541,
0.23286287486553192,
0.26102137565612793,
0.03329231217503548,
0.19763654470443726,
0.0038878133054822683,
0.3574945628643036,
-0.5139641761779785,
0.1944103240966797,
-0.586570143699646,
-0.042532484978437424,
0.4637874960899353,
0.1053977832198143,
-0.17552587389945984,
-0.1635679304599762,
-0.41252008080482483,
-0.2817305028438568,
-0.3113354444503784,
0.0012077762512490153,
0.014674500562250614,
0.402972936630249,
-0.1337152123451233,
0.5474694967269897,
-0.3908040225505829,
0.7627701759338379,
-0.0883149728178978,
-0.33436858654022217,
0.41913166642189026,
-0.09652060270309448,
-0.053151194006204605,
0.2829204201698303,
0.7496693134307861,
0.4807058274745941,
0.10563930869102478,
-0.16457530856132507,
-0.22915416955947876,
-0.06568078696727753,
0.27391546964645386,
-1.0079587697982788,
-0.3020854890346527,
-0.058806415647268295,
-0.7380682826042175,
-0.5130682587623596,
0.29756373167037964,
-0.5639513731002808,
-0.5821496844291687,
-0.14220619201660156,
0.5457939505577087,
-0.18036870658397675,
-0.07708543539047241,
0.17989897727966309,
-0.5062106251716614,
-0.19587038457393646,
0.42667505145072937,
-0.9930431842803955,
0.5812041163444519,
0.5376642942428589,
1.1075429916381836,
-0.15012811124324799,
-0.1546587198972702,
-0.20090371370315552,
0.15258504450321198,
-0.5078864693641663,
0.6634065508842468,
-0.14912302792072296,
-0.35544586181640625,
-0.07604971528053284,
-0.516122043132782,
0.28749173879623413,
-0.61182701587677,
0.6242097616195679,
-0.1112608090043068,
-0.18823039531707764,
-0.1403449922800064,
-0.6066316366195679,
0.021321525797247887,
0.06507686525583267,
-0.803916335105896,
1.209409475326538,
0.34846070408821106,
-1.1107428073883057,
0.5546272993087769,
-0.09562771022319794,
-0.48057010769844055,
0.2543768882751465,
-0.2674040198326111,
-0.34452927112579346,
0.21588380634784698,
-0.19201064109802246,
0.861362636089325,
-0.5500982999801636,
-0.11663863062858582,
-0.3363523781299591,
-0.4669807255268097,
-0.05769965425133705,
-0.18330799043178558,
0.4896332323551178,
0.32484450936317444,
0.05278461053967476,
-0.3302564024925232,
-1.0728754997253418,
-0.02705872431397438,
0.2665247917175293,
-0.35930749773979187,
-0.8274258971214294,
0.15632431209087372,
0.35494670271873474,
0.06757283955812454,
0.5135661363601685,
-0.5442914366722107,
0.30540168285369873,
-0.31267091631889343,
0.25213202834129333,
0.6645612120628357,
-0.15020187199115753,
0.36421337723731995,
-0.23032112419605255,
-0.11881016194820404,
0.04169498383998871,
0.1428498923778534,
0.2999359369277954,
-0.4825711250305176,
-0.7857243418693542,
-0.2784025967121124,
0.4716589152812958,
0.717753529548645,
-0.9087790846824646,
0.6888336539268494,
-0.5463157892227173,
-0.6263704895973206,
-0.2039709985256195,
0.5318772196769714,
0.17301560938358307,
0.6901126503944397,
0.39544957876205444,
-0.39866453409194946,
-0.4015507996082306,
-0.6840237975120544,
0.05338208004832268,
-0.36855369806289673,
-0.13081438839435577,
0.016311636194586754,
0.3914435803890228,
-0.06646043062210083,
0.9788991808891296,
-0.6297518014907837,
-0.5413024425506592,
-0.35308653116226196,
0.47364452481269836,
0.22181236743927002,
0.3795539140701294,
0.5406836867332458,
-1.141257405281067,
-0.49327194690704346,
-0.1806805580854416,
-0.6931092143058777,
-0.375754714012146,
0.1066298633813858,
0.334721177816391,
-0.09609142690896988,
0.4624295234680176,
-0.3922284245491028,
0.4411342740058899,
0.43688586354255676,
-0.3036435544490814,
0.046059511601924896,
-0.22080230712890625,
-0.27027076482772827,
-1.1480484008789062,
-0.3223276436328888,
0.14611923694610596,
0.08258908987045288,
-0.6556570529937744,
-0.27853015065193176,
0.2742275297641754,
0.15821175277233124,
-0.15260663628578186,
0.41969403624534607,
-0.21804411709308624,
0.187827929854393,
-0.32988956570625305,
0.050899092108011246,
-0.06765793263912201,
0.3953268229961395,
0.20032791793346405,
0.5639453530311584,
0.3192416727542877,
-0.8860829472541809,
0.35681673884391785,
0.1784670203924179,
-0.47086942195892334,
0.6555517911911011,
-0.5233253836631775,
-0.13974973559379578,
-0.36305415630340576,
0.1798126995563507,
-0.8275832533836365,
-0.1188032478094101,
0.08093118667602539,
-0.4001849889755249,
0.42660003900527954,
0.1637440174818039,
-0.5304839611053467,
-0.18918927013874054,
-0.45667731761932373,
0.46249982714653015,
0.5301050543785095,
-0.6141723394393921,
0.47696828842163086,
0.45646682381629944,
-0.10307241231203079,
-0.6962981820106506,
-0.8505957126617432,
-0.1703345775604248,
0.008257055655121803,
-0.24787525832653046,
0.5858597755432129,
-0.058796461671590805,
-0.1634168177843094,
0.09268871694803238,
-0.4384371340274811,
-0.45066604018211365,
0.2389969527721405,
0.3355748653411865,
0.023647824302315712,
0.37398698925971985,
0.482038676738739,
0.1580812633037567,
0.03927970677614212,
-0.3148152530193329,
-0.20511934161186218,
0.4721303880214691,
0.11047348380088806,
0.15674690902233124,
-0.16713948547840118,
0.22130818665027618,
-0.03273977339267731,
0.2729175090789795,
0.9309940338134766,
0.6163331270217896,
-0.4832253158092499,
-0.5753793120384216,
-0.22394639253616333,
-0.02944967895746231,
-0.4538327157497406,
0.5935712456703186,
-0.5315514802932739,
-0.7965989112854004,
0.12479489296674728,
-0.13213589787483215,
-0.044148243963718414,
0.692932665348053,
0.35880112648010254,
-0.22214557230472565,
0.826863169670105,
0.8932752013206482,
-0.21608345210552216,
0.5183303952217102,
-0.3299284279346466,
-0.05125447362661362,
-0.39590984582901,
-0.3274803161621094,
-0.7544957995414734,
-0.22141151130199432,
-0.47732219099998474,
-0.08980105817317963,
0.4828934967517853,
0.5902080535888672,
-0.19233150780200958,
0.10752927511930466,
-0.6802985072135925,
0.3105125427246094,
0.3729085922241211,
0.13016405701637268,
0.05455935746431351,
0.024111952632665634,
-0.12476618587970734,
0.029078753665089607,
-0.908166766166687,
0.012335469014942646,
1.1907343864440918,
0.3265019655227661,
0.8984273672103882,
0.03289109095931053,
0.7796452641487122,
0.5670654773712158,
0.1676834225654602,
-1.0737242698669434,
0.3377087712287903,
-0.35681602358818054,
0.052238740026950836,
-0.1185280904173851,
-0.9126070141792297,
-0.8414263129234314,
0.10232451558113098,
-0.5975446105003357,
-0.5851678252220154,
0.16270580887794495,
0.0914708822965622,
0.050194256007671356,
0.09760375320911407,
-0.7460841536521912,
0.570822536945343,
0.024491947144269943,
0.02357049472630024,
-0.25250309705734253,
-0.6907117962837219,
0.2884424030780792,
-0.2804846465587616,
0.36127081513404846,
0.01785227842628956,
-0.42370477318763733,
1.130244493484497,
-0.6637334823608398,
0.5982180833816528,
-0.18650475144386292,
-0.10933022946119308,
0.08676221966743469,
-0.19057242572307587,
0.21075493097305298,
-0.1366879791021347,
0.04049309343099594,
0.537359356880188,
0.1447511613368988,
-0.36207664012908936,
-0.6019322276115417,
0.3863055109977722,
-0.7876629829406738,
-0.11844494938850403,
-0.6544510126113892,
-0.38123011589050293,
-0.14202123880386353,
0.2623577117919922,
0.6054354310035706,
0.48015812039375305,
0.022289253771305084,
0.437709242105484,
0.7877110242843628,
0.23251928389072418,
0.24421274662017822,
0.29027846455574036,
0.16037873923778534,
-0.5431562662124634,
1.0532679557800293,
0.4653102457523346,
-0.03131376579403877,
0.870954692363739,
0.24150048196315765,
-0.09959381073713303,
-0.8506613969802856,
-0.04857125133275986,
-0.1095493733882904,
-0.9731264114379883,
-0.461471825838089,
-0.3101029396057129,
-0.31794169545173645,
-0.4706304371356964,
-0.01508971769362688,
-0.24034468829631805,
-0.7068156599998474,
-0.19704841077327728,
0.1015104278922081,
0.255244642496109,
0.9834385514259338,
-0.046990763396024704,
0.5351617932319641,
-0.5790550112724304,
0.6410748362541199,
0.2217104732990265,
0.3109593689441681,
-0.012606563046574593,
-0.18424881994724274,
-0.5645827054977417,
-0.24404260516166687,
-0.22214017808437347,
-0.82264244556427,
0.13334444165229797,
0.643694281578064,
0.35073697566986084,
0.6734842658042908,
0.4828125536441803,
0.3720283508300781,
-0.5387032628059387,
0.8535138964653015,
0.3104943037033081,
-0.9293938875198364,
0.24591636657714844,
0.28887295722961426,
0.08236905932426453,
0.6895412802696228,
0.4270513653755188,
-0.491671621799469,
-0.17333371937274933,
-0.4879245162010193,
-0.867782711982727,
0.5104300379753113,
0.08275727927684784,
-0.061780598014593124,
-0.08164925873279572,
0.7388090491294861,
-0.059888940304517746,
0.44978511333465576,
-0.5980449914932251,
-0.44465580582618713,
-0.2961626648902893,
-0.9259507656097412,
-0.13724136352539062,
-0.46499893069267273,
0.02189651131629944,
-0.2534303665161133,
0.6864012479782104,
-0.3642158806324005,
0.2548869550228119,
0.2690902650356293,
-0.13415195047855377,
0.1954805999994278,
0.08258631080389023,
0.29228705167770386,
0.30499032139778137,
-0.25729599595069885,
0.4879796802997589,
0.17913371324539185,
-1.0282107591629028,
0.12758466601371765,
0.21458962559700012,
-0.27557772397994995,
0.1258276402950287,
0.5506012439727783,
0.5417581796646118,
-0.03990260884165764,
-0.6499707102775574,
0.7506434321403503,
-0.3791603147983551,
-0.4278711974620819,
-0.14711448550224304,
0.09608614444732666,
-0.39130768179893494,
0.13557514548301697,
0.6274741888046265,
0.07806908339262009,
0.45622074604034424,
-0.18421374261379242,
-0.08142859488725662,
0.48432064056396484,
-0.12855660915374756,
0.12270578742027283,
0.4919069707393646,
0.04759041592478752,
0.11995325982570648,
0.3988304138183594,
-0.12120910733938217,
-0.41358256340026855,
0.42551758885383606,
0.20992687344551086,
0.6267534494400024,
-0.1380246877670288,
-0.10243706405162811,
0.09344848245382309,
0.3440680503845215,
-0.3810422122478485,
0.3039764165878296,
-0.6462641954421997,
-0.8900616765022278,
0.0764458104968071,
-0.6334124207496643,
-0.3540183901786804,
-0.036696262657642365,
-0.7168589234352112,
0.29168716073036194,
-0.6688865423202515,
-0.044876471161842346,
-0.11158718168735504,
0.25540751218795776,
-0.4430350959300995,
0.2887018024921417,
-0.011186199262738228,
1.3657280206680298,
-0.7374033331871033,
0.9724324941635132,
0.3350095748901367,
-0.31449875235557556,
-0.6135780215263367,
0.11763940006494522,
-0.09082493931055069,
-0.383320689201355,
0.8684106469154358,
0.3702595829963684,
-0.12804050743579865,
0.02123987302184105,
-0.6348406672477722,
-0.5898216366767883,
1.1476795673370361,
0.167708158493042,
-0.5289144515991211,
-0.17855729162693024,
0.07843267917633057,
0.3502340018749237,
-0.030114183202385902,
0.05112846940755844,
0.1584826409816742,
-0.003168685594573617,
0.06962183117866516,
-1.0515352487564087,
-0.20791393518447876,
-0.49076858162879944,
0.33059820532798767,
0.11284276098012924,
-0.640507161617279,
0.9694339036941528,
0.19335724413394928,
-0.18635815382003784,
0.18528307974338531,
0.8704256415367126,
-0.029231367632746696,
0.43631771206855774,
0.6352982521057129,
0.8072274923324585,
0.9364530444145203,
-0.18560351431369781,
0.8687466979026794,
-0.3457894027233124,
0.5833937525749207,
0.7916951775550842,
-0.2554241120815277,
1.0686514377593994,
0.5162548422813416,
-0.010655911639332771,
0.49552083015441895,
0.629385232925415,
0.1296079009771347,
0.7765560746192932,
0.24148549139499664,
-0.3721807301044464,
-0.00883091613650322,
-0.20743583142757416,
-0.4548875689506531,
0.4303359389305115,
0.5717248916625977,
-0.13793671131134033,
-0.14952179789543152,
0.08792693167924881,
-0.17194099724292755,
0.01611032709479332,
-0.5382483005523682,
0.9118342995643616,
0.06385983526706696,
-0.03687136620283127,
0.6782081723213196,
0.44432228803634644,
0.9615857005119324,
-0.7679542899131775,
-0.08418381214141846,
0.20624621212482452,
0.3041209876537323,
-0.1913401335477829,
-0.4574553668498993,
-0.11132007092237473,
-0.14312462508678436,
-0.31029826402664185,
-0.15799923241138458,
0.7551634907722473,
-0.4690192639827728,
-0.36593878269195557,
0.030330421403050423,
0.09023687243461609,
0.0469660758972168,
0.18619634211063385,
-0.5959187746047974,
0.185079887509346,
-0.614401638507843,
-0.12012923508882523,
0.2911059856414795,
0.5431628227233887,
0.1638086885213852,
0.6346889138221741,
0.25862058997154236,
0.35286885499954224,
-0.1128496378660202,
-0.07312678545713425,
0.7833157181739807,
-0.49066469073295593,
-0.8033891916275024,
-0.6099074482917786,
-0.06805337965488434,
-0.24162518978118896,
-0.24271896481513977,
0.6315789818763733,
0.7086094617843628,
1.1037647724151611,
0.10665038228034973,
0.9338676333427429,
-0.21443523466587067,
0.5646947026252747,
-0.914670467376709,
0.637625515460968,
-0.6251319646835327,
0.15423858165740967,
-0.26212576031684875,
-0.7654046416282654,
-0.28916704654693604,
0.8934242725372314,
0.2367820292711258,
0.07843519747257233,
0.6963782906532288,
0.4387524127960205,
0.12073422223329544,
-0.10327161103487015,
0.04816814139485359,
0.09441188722848892,
0.02048112452030182,
0.6939395070075989,
0.5208183526992798,
-0.4910615384578705,
0.4293535351753235,
-0.5783740878105164,
-0.35142531991004944,
-0.11264148354530334,
-0.9279655814170837,
-0.9204330444335938,
-0.9985116720199585,
-0.20583036541938782,
-0.4662565588951111,
-0.12301314622163773,
1.164255142211914,
0.8072596788406372,
-0.4679640829563141,
-0.1817929893732071,
-0.425353080034256,
0.12896913290023804,
-0.3917526304721832,
-0.2947019934654236,
0.31236040592193604,
-0.35043200850486755,
-0.5566911697387695,
0.17541004717350006,
-0.013575362041592598,
0.08560819923877716,
-0.09957435727119446,
-0.30429235100746155,
0.19648632407188416,
-0.0372784286737442,
0.534820556640625,
0.1140650287270546,
-0.2990416884422302,
-0.08574278652667999,
-0.5579198002815247,
-0.2909316122531891,
-0.12268619239330292,
0.7421716451644897,
-0.8170791268348694,
0.35100534558296204,
0.6757239103317261,
0.7180249094963074,
0.4470936357975006,
-0.14530231058597565,
0.01378271821886301,
-1.247684359550476,
0.5256418585777283,
0.05998736992478371,
0.34721389412879944,
0.18031829595565796,
-0.3102366626262665,
0.32969263195991516,
0.48664915561676025,
-0.2419183999300003,
-0.8655914664268494,
0.002043920336291194,
-1.1559512615203857,
-0.6107644438743591,
0.9329851269721985,
0.2012646198272705,
-0.2483484148979187,
0.00043856381671503186,
-0.20217306911945343,
0.2973899841308594,
-0.30513834953308105,
0.8689703345298767,
0.7553001642227173,
-0.027251536026597023,
-0.4070684611797333,
-0.44987547397613525,
0.7334677577018738,
-0.07099407911300659,
-0.7500464916229248,
-0.18379758298397064,
0.29854851961135864,
0.06362628936767578,
0.35130590200424194,
0.6942825317382812,
0.36379724740982056,
0.19106976687908173,
0.16629758477210999,
0.1867651641368866,
-0.12324945628643036,
-0.5950145721435547,
-0.3872097134590149,
0.5686392784118652,
0.14344006776809692,
-0.0006576123414561152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18130v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18130v1
|
Logic Agent: Enhancing Validity with Logic Rule Invocation
| 2024-04-28T10:02:28 | 2024-04-28T10:02:28 |
Hanmeng Liu, Zhiyang Teng, Chaoli Zhang, Yue Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting has emerged as a pivotal technique for
augmenting the inferential capabilities of language models during reasoning
tasks. Despite its advancements, CoT often grapples with challenges in
validating reasoning validity and ensuring informativeness. Addressing these
limitations, this paper introduces the Logic Agent (LA), an agent-based
framework aimed at enhancing the validity of reasoning processes in Large
Language Models (LLMs) through strategic logic rule invocation. Unlike
conventional approaches, LA transforms LLMs into logic agents that dynamically
apply propositional logic rules, initiating the reasoning process by converting
natural language inputs into structured logic forms. The logic agent leverages
a comprehensive set of predefined functions to systematically navigate the
reasoning process. This methodology not only promotes the structured and
coherent generation of reasoning constructs but also significantly improves
their interpretability and logical coherence. Through extensive
experimentation, we demonstrate LA's capacity to scale effectively across
various model sizes, markedly improving the precision of complex reasoning
across diverse tasks.
|
[
-0.14357700943946838,
-0.9505117535591125,
1.0298075675964355,
-0.02073935978114605,
-0.1759626716375351,
0.36819013953208923,
-0.14231811463832855,
-0.36914005875587463,
0.029117990285158157,
0.6847580075263977,
-0.43636074662208557,
-0.19658145308494568,
-0.37755507230758667,
0.2536773383617401,
-0.4163176119327545,
0.800078809261322,
0.0173325315117836,
-0.07506284862756729,
-0.2608131468296051,
0.007460329681634903,
-0.5087388753890991,
-0.4438953101634979,
-0.7567561864852905,
-0.7776822447776794,
0.23661908507347107,
0.21683257818222046,
1.0495272874832153,
0.24771815538406372,
0.33836454153060913,
0.36954712867736816,
0.10159748792648315,
0.8334957957267761,
-0.2349039763212204,
0.4231308102607727,
-0.7985749840736389,
-0.5930058360099792,
-0.8379341959953308,
-0.041263729333877563,
0.6010035276412964,
0.4290749430656433,
-0.2812322974205017,
0.10964394360780716,
-0.2134169042110443,
0.5586912035942078,
-0.6339578032493591,
0.12042909860610962,
-0.9153665900230408,
-0.41057416796684265,
0.13941115140914917,
-0.33900198340415955,
-0.8924281597137451,
-0.4603562653064728,
0.020649602636694908,
-0.6048604846000671,
-0.41389191150665283,
0.16639602184295654,
0.8148664236068726,
0.35408276319503784,
-0.48619434237480164,
-0.32245588302612305,
-0.759972095489502,
0.6409256458282471,
-0.6571597456932068,
0.3033371865749359,
0.07479724287986755,
0.4507695734500885,
-0.6834933757781982,
-0.8558917045593262,
-0.9751901030540466,
-0.486589252948761,
0.010934174992144108,
-0.10912255942821503,
-0.2483406513929367,
0.1461360603570938,
0.5587998628616333,
-0.1689845621585846,
-0.1252555251121521,
-0.5116609334945679,
0.09166383743286133,
-0.09369533509016037,
0.5895982980728149,
0.10677585005760193,
0.37783360481262207,
0.19850224256515503,
-0.4440113306045532,
0.005502663087099791,
-0.782117486000061,
0.09779854118824005,
0.2749956250190735,
0.37760037183761597,
0.36109402775764465,
0.4985049068927765,
-0.29255610704421997,
0.6902598142623901,
0.2776322364807129,
-0.25683140754699707,
0.090779609978199,
-0.25555965304374695,
-0.3307560086250305,
0.3068300485610962,
0.5303352475166321,
0.3256213366985321,
0.4653511345386505,
0.10417993366718292,
-0.45203521847724915,
0.11643769592046738,
0.4748605489730835,
-0.5689889788627625,
0.1547309011220932,
0.32222604751586914,
-0.16773614287376404,
-0.14172020554542542,
0.38924846053123474,
-0.34165051579475403,
-0.522533118724823,
-0.568198025226593,
0.513095498085022,
-0.5658723711967468,
-0.3263198733329773,
0.4476577341556549,
-0.2584211826324463,
0.5062440037727356,
0.5894596576690674,
-0.3201679587364197,
0.5352648496627808,
0.792393684387207,
0.5018070340156555,
0.1609114706516266,
-0.13129352033138275,
-0.9448920488357544,
0.3245052099227905,
-0.6310842633247375,
0.923267662525177,
-0.7381520867347717,
0.07655694335699081,
-0.12036311626434326,
-0.1187971755862236,
-0.10972019284963608,
-0.7508659362792969,
0.6514503359794617,
-0.8339710831642151,
-0.37206360697746277,
-0.31641799211502075,
-0.5210532546043396,
-0.03857162222266197,
0.6284494996070862,
-0.6100115180015564,
0.8729134798049927,
0.1555708646774292,
-0.03127245604991913,
0.4297025501728058,
-0.8455895185470581,
-0.4304291009902954,
0.23618264496326447,
-0.46911174058914185,
0.06815782189369202,
-0.1300661414861679,
0.17343583703041077,
0.2916218042373657,
-0.48299548029899597,
0.28329798579216003,
-0.07403086870908737,
-0.16364914178848267,
0.5453494787216187,
-0.16130246222019196,
0.6498626470565796,
0.20227651298046112,
-0.36752548813819885,
0.4313856065273285,
-0.7605395317077637,
0.3739199638366699,
0.053396280854940414,
0.0486980602145195,
-0.16457809507846832,
0.13464009761810303,
-0.5718817710876465,
0.4808347523212433,
0.04143664240837097,
-0.44309893250465393,
0.09185840934515,
-0.5472793579101562,
0.2583588659763336,
0.7274548411369324,
0.16672539710998535,
0.4233655333518982,
-0.5199437737464905,
0.5658684968948364,
-0.058788593858480453,
0.19966736435890198,
0.2779175639152527,
-0.4460519850254059,
-0.5508977174758911,
-0.4032711088657379,
-0.05303262919187546,
0.5497329831123352,
-1.1676347255706787,
0.6812608242034912,
-0.246245875954628,
-0.35843783617019653,
-0.3272694945335388,
0.1906549334526062,
0.14576566219329834,
0.6030415892601013,
0.23616066575050354,
0.09514984488487244,
-0.31387823820114136,
-0.5589382648468018,
-0.27025914192199707,
-0.264120876789093,
0.1569710671901703,
-0.14233724772930145,
0.5589540600776672,
-0.3123883903026581,
1.0611629486083984,
-0.16785825788974762,
-0.02952628768980503,
-0.7108744382858276,
-0.2878396511077881,
0.3972666561603546,
0.12439028173685074,
0.306659996509552,
-0.5900955200195312,
-0.35076311230659485,
0.1616038829088211,
-0.805709719657898,
-0.1749696433544159,
-0.18702702224254608,
-0.555267333984375,
0.17998652160167694,
0.6723684668540955,
-0.7255534529685974,
0.4983840882778168,
0.09519737958908081,
-0.6715336441993713,
0.7407720685005188,
-0.09530526399612427,
0.18069010972976685,
-0.7696661353111267,
-0.1879613995552063,
-0.40127310156822205,
-0.5700012445449829,
-0.619173526763916,
0.2044818252325058,
-0.06676431745290756,
0.12613560259342194,
-0.5122449994087219,
0.5602545738220215,
-0.11808914691209793,
0.18875108659267426,
-0.5147101283073425,
0.4950290322303772,
0.38333314657211304,
0.1413630247116089,
-0.07440398633480072,
0.659033477306366,
0.36760419607162476,
-0.7691569328308105,
0.7446993589401245,
0.08976750075817108,
-0.21893100440502167,
0.7670838236808777,
-0.5959033370018005,
0.10979843884706497,
-0.09170475602149963,
0.5822921991348267,
-0.6420897245407104,
0.013720765709877014,
0.380436509847641,
-0.09026812762022018,
-0.18632251024246216,
0.16009771823883057,
-0.7761650681495667,
-0.09031488746404648,
-0.16129057109355927,
0.39570969343185425,
0.43363291025161743,
-0.6351403594017029,
1.121005654335022,
0.018116649240255356,
0.27243566513061523,
-0.431362122297287,
-0.29680168628692627,
-0.004352291580289602,
0.07683845609426498,
-0.7178009748458862,
-0.05906383693218231,
0.03917296975851059,
-0.8484557867050171,
-0.048459723591804504,
-0.09497358649969101,
0.33096736669540405,
-0.11826148629188538,
0.005265580490231514,
0.2937465012073517,
-0.02897166833281517,
0.37996095418930054,
0.11852628737688065,
-0.0002151240041712299,
0.42793816328048706,
-0.583976686000824,
0.5640634894371033,
-0.37517398595809937,
-0.38984212279319763,
-0.43121063709259033,
0.16007187962532043,
0.6920243501663208,
-0.5002172589302063,
0.786099910736084,
0.03678438439965248,
-0.4934673011302948,
-0.939738392829895,
-0.41658520698547363,
-0.2969070374965668,
-0.5305524468421936,
-0.02444293722510338,
-0.7185291647911072,
-0.36473676562309265,
0.3883199393749237,
-0.5710189938545227,
-0.16535678505897522,
0.36110201478004456,
0.4748489260673523,
0.13714364171028137,
0.9290604591369629,
0.2534385323524475,
0.28519028425216675,
0.2665695548057556,
-0.2639298737049103,
0.4127894341945648,
-0.6879119873046875,
-0.24140171706676483,
-0.2457406371831894,
-0.026976730674505234,
-0.23423027992248535,
-0.5728254318237305,
0.35267478227615356,
-0.16559691727161407,
-0.46059203147888184,
0.03048529662191868,
-0.4391102194786072,
0.7179633975028992,
0.16325870156288147,
0.32460853457450867,
0.43081703782081604,
-0.0980541929602623,
-0.3992410898208618,
0.47104811668395996,
-0.49282369017601013,
-1.0074015855789185,
0.7195130586624146,
0.20727799832820892,
0.7560250759124756,
0.4057595729827881,
0.41665133833885193,
0.5312180519104004,
0.13156715035438538,
-0.8944810628890991,
0.9661900401115417,
0.22258397936820984,
-0.566382110118866,
-0.3761107623577118,
-0.2560514509677887,
-0.6414479613304138,
0.29055142402648926,
-0.24903501570224762,
-0.7722665667533875,
0.14259378612041473,
0.14582911133766174,
-0.4687020182609558,
0.35280129313468933,
-0.498964786529541,
0.5605654120445251,
-0.28758808970451355,
-0.48868757486343384,
-0.47611963748931885,
-0.3800024688243866,
0.16838443279266357,
0.017136361449956894,
0.023459656164050102,
-0.2193998098373413,
-0.2130448818206787,
0.320565789937973,
-0.9395807981491089,
0.5613406896591187,
-0.0018145589856430888,
-0.3252114951610565,
0.7451247572898865,
0.3123422861099243,
0.9936231970787048,
-0.13363496959209442,
-0.4147021770477295,
-0.4110563099384308,
0.032197464257478714,
-0.46108338236808777,
-1.2181323766708374,
0.2709977328777313,
-0.5269787311553955,
-0.7387053966522217,
-0.5635749697685242,
-0.518555223941803,
-0.45385992527008057,
0.24599595367908478,
-0.13200777769088745,
0.5417538285255432,
0.03250112012028694,
0.05949525535106659,
0.6658182144165039,
0.08811540901660919,
0.05940668657422066,
0.19728025794029236,
-0.301740437746048,
-0.21218843758106232,
0.6777978539466858,
-0.12309981137514114,
0.8044230341911316,
0.3754309117794037,
0.2759931981563568,
-0.46754810214042664,
-0.28932690620422363,
-0.31430843472480774,
0.12472134828567505,
-1.0343329906463623,
-0.1698707938194275,
-0.3457944691181183,
-0.39346808195114136,
-0.16496479511260986,
-0.25576725602149963,
-0.3326191008090973,
-0.2112102210521698,
0.2746865451335907,
-0.20393003523349762,
0.37372034788131714,
0.8323513865470886,
0.46390825510025024,
0.01616303063929081,
-0.340894877910614,
0.17415684461593628,
0.24475711584091187,
0.15518338978290558,
0.03966459631919861,
-0.5400022268295288,
-0.019873756915330887,
-0.0026009792927652597,
-0.2852383255958557,
-0.7087283134460449,
0.04307956621050835,
0.05557612329721451,
0.6894063353538513,
0.4730702042579651,
0.3950350284576416,
0.5739776492118835,
-0.3317822217941284,
0.5517582893371582,
0.0005342383519746363,
-1.205499291419983,
0.8707628846168518,
-0.4370352625846863,
0.2796086370944977,
0.4341767430305481,
0.013015511445701122,
-0.045120079070329666,
-0.6735250949859619,
-0.5880996584892273,
-0.6311579346656799,
0.405513197183609,
0.23718048632144928,
-0.13785548508167267,
-0.11280184984207153,
0.5156241655349731,
-0.08425987511873245,
0.30458641052246094,
-0.4151524603366852,
0.16149061918258667,
-0.035660818219184875,
-0.38637951016426086,
0.314945250749588,
0.09112221002578735,
-0.2117702066898346,
-0.2772229313850403,
0.9507781267166138,
-0.507922351360321,
-0.032682571560144424,
0.4865693151950836,
-0.24675828218460083,
-0.07931262999773026,
0.4502771496772766,
0.562802255153656,
1.019687533378601,
-0.06463602185249329,
0.32425040006637573,
0.347464919090271,
-0.364054799079895,
0.43355709314346313,
-0.26494136452674866,
-0.2514534592628479,
-0.30027201771736145,
0.5219311714172363,
0.42629823088645935,
-0.1753343939781189,
-1.0682498216629028,
0.38406580686569214,
-0.02276744320988655,
-0.21188628673553467,
-0.28619012236595154,
0.41630372405052185,
-0.29319649934768677,
0.6082941293716431,
0.17014850676059723,
0.056268420070409775,
0.1398342102766037,
-0.9366692304611206,
0.24258704483509064,
0.3277583718299866,
-0.2127067744731903,
0.07760239392518997,
0.34004271030426025,
0.2497914731502533,
-0.2955910861492157,
0.567286491394043,
-0.506046712398529,
-0.6614071130752563,
0.5760116577148438,
0.7354884743690491,
0.7723630666732788,
0.19751250743865967,
0.28327468037605286,
0.12744778394699097,
0.42701247334480286,
-0.22478677332401276,
0.5159266591072083,
0.062358807772397995,
-1.1143018007278442,
-0.3699662685394287,
-0.31265464425086975,
-0.5462587475776672,
-0.23059533536434174,
-0.2537989616394043,
0.13181164860725403,
-0.8033820986747742,
-0.37957853078842163,
-0.3026614785194397,
0.19985127449035645,
-0.4706974923610687,
0.22857023775577545,
0.11567356437444687,
1.0872275829315186,
-0.3980795741081238,
0.99580979347229,
0.8967390060424805,
-0.3679639399051666,
-1.3022468090057373,
0.12595142424106598,
0.08969506621360779,
-0.3213975131511688,
0.5021912455558777,
-0.029835965484380722,
-0.990123450756073,
-0.20182926952838898,
-0.6049070358276367,
-0.5411815047264099,
1.2176913022994995,
0.6680151224136353,
-0.39780572056770325,
0.39142316579818726,
0.15342144668102264,
0.6311125755310059,
-0.8585379123687744,
0.29352784156799316,
0.6425929069519043,
0.4883938133716583,
0.42287683486938477,
-0.7073385715484619,
0.6419357061386108,
-0.2986811101436615,
-0.27962082624435425,
0.17857077717781067,
-0.6649921536445618,
0.6476308107376099,
-0.29930049180984497,
-0.017727749422192574,
0.01985088922083378,
0.6624020934104919,
0.7635510563850403,
0.3777885138988495,
0.8712242245674133,
0.19581204652786255,
1.3076976537704468,
-0.048981327563524246,
1.0556954145431519,
-0.1798241138458252,
-0.27202504873275757,
1.267381191253662,
-0.8934223055839539,
0.9160706996917725,
0.35254964232444763,
0.19784946739673615,
1.2236355543136597,
0.004370334092527628,
0.20419858396053314,
0.13466410338878632,
0.24781817197799683,
-0.5609976053237915,
-0.6112216114997864,
-0.427659809589386,
-0.007415242493152618,
0.4276864230632782,
0.4262600839138031,
-0.24319541454315186,
0.016285374760627747,
-0.22267942130565643,
-0.021540209650993347,
0.6149848699569702,
-0.49811822175979614,
0.5409640073776245,
0.08344481140375137,
-0.8966153264045715,
0.2601616680622101,
-0.25572827458381653,
0.06030332297086716,
-0.7235333323478699,
-0.23851598799228668,
0.30195286870002747,
0.6796494126319885,
-0.26140281558036804,
-0.7150502800941467,
0.11368253827095032,
-0.1528601497411728,
-0.08229561895132065,
-0.3062065541744232,
0.9696176052093506,
-0.18039259314537048,
-0.4211376905441284,
0.6651926636695862,
0.5062122941017151,
-0.05373024567961693,
-0.2031562328338623,
-0.5557186007499695,
0.13785302639007568,
-0.4619823396205902,
-0.06936615705490112,
-0.2033422589302063,
0.7887765169143677,
-0.4902244210243225,
0.8889898657798767,
0.5875268578529358,
0.24725709855556488,
-0.15537461638450623,
0.4576570391654968,
0.9086152911186218,
-0.6673023700714111,
-0.3613879382610321,
-0.9907586574554443,
0.5409541130065918,
-0.3801524043083191,
0.14666612446308136,
0.6391047835350037,
0.3180566728115082,
0.721516489982605,
0.06977074593305588,
0.7378799319267273,
-0.10831378400325775,
-0.0029641541186720133,
-0.5824446082115173,
0.6259251832962036,
-0.39756765961647034,
0.44006630778312683,
-0.2149248570203781,
-0.656487226486206,
-0.07430671155452728,
0.5965082049369812,
-0.48454490303993225,
0.16245907545089722,
0.9955731630325317,
0.9815322160720825,
0.24396716058254242,
0.011212675832211971,
0.4616042673587799,
0.20658573508262634,
0.652676522731781,
0.507264256477356,
1.2212438583374023,
-0.26249977946281433,
0.43262964487075806,
0.15818896889686584,
-0.39005181193351746,
0.1151072084903717,
-0.8865885138511658,
-1.1529239416122437,
-0.30622243881225586,
-0.25043243169784546,
-0.7250986099243164,
0.14730502665042877,
1.6834709644317627,
0.7247274518013,
-0.6505157351493835,
-0.2628636360168457,
-0.14003624022006989,
0.4929889738559723,
-0.557012677192688,
-0.1857154667377472,
0.0807664543390274,
-0.5807401537895203,
-0.3065471947193146,
0.4788464307785034,
0.3501085340976715,
-0.3173501193523407,
-0.061255160719156265,
-0.39052921533584595,
-0.5683856010437012,
0.8272348046302795,
0.9669783711433411,
-0.006120861042290926,
-0.8169811367988586,
-0.43512001633644104,
-0.1682080775499344,
-0.0519908107817173,
-0.18542204797267914,
0.7538980841636658,
-0.941447377204895,
0.44805026054382324,
0.48210713267326355,
0.45481616258621216,
-0.11470630019903183,
0.12636315822601318,
0.8394933938980103,
-0.4713580012321472,
0.01245897263288498,
0.22520242631435394,
0.3399178683757782,
-0.02635091356933117,
-0.5173888802528381,
0.5229607224464417,
0.12658093869686127,
-0.3821345567703247,
-0.6961147785186768,
0.48922544717788696,
-1.0826424360275269,
-0.16432161629199982,
1.1462316513061523,
0.09586851298809052,
-0.4698607325553894,
-0.18471695482730865,
-0.5165620446205139,
0.07155434787273407,
-0.6076205372810364,
0.36115434765815735,
0.7509684562683105,
-0.35241225361824036,
-0.013695059344172478,
-0.36862868070602417,
0.5467588305473328,
0.12943583726882935,
-1.1631360054016113,
-0.0668197050690651,
0.21948394179344177,
0.148292675614357,
0.21880045533180237,
0.6801175475120544,
-0.10963413864374161,
0.49523815512657166,
0.04898460954427719,
-0.130872443318367,
0.03734175115823746,
-0.5598189830780029,
0.029650753363966942,
0.15922406315803528,
0.3073326051235199,
0.11416764557361603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18094v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18094v1
|
USAT: A Universal Speaker-Adaptive Text-to-Speech Approach
| 2024-04-28T06:50:55 | 2024-04-28T06:50:55 |
Wenbin Wang, Yang Song, Sanjay Jha
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Conventional text-to-speech (TTS) research has predominantly focused on
enhancing the quality of synthesized speech for speakers in the training
dataset. The challenge of synthesizing lifelike speech for unseen,
out-of-dataset speakers, especially those with limited reference data, remains
a significant and unresolved problem. While zero-shot or few-shot
speaker-adaptive TTS approaches have been explored, they have many limitations.
Zero-shot approaches tend to suffer from insufficient generalization
performance to reproduce the voice of speakers with heavy accents. While
few-shot methods can reproduce highly varying accents, they bring a significant
storage burden and the risk of overfitting and catastrophic forgetting. In
addition, prior approaches only provide either zero-shot or few-shot
adaptation, constraining their utility across varied real-world scenarios with
different demands. Besides, most current evaluations of speaker-adaptive TTS
are conducted only on datasets of native speakers, inadvertently neglecting a
vast portion of non-native speakers with diverse accents. Our proposed
framework unifies both zero-shot and few-shot speaker adaptation strategies,
which we term as "instant" and "fine-grained" adaptations based on their
merits. To alleviate the insufficient generalization performance observed in
zero-shot speaker adaptation, we designed two innovative discriminators and
introduced a memory mechanism for the speech decoder. To prevent catastrophic
forgetting and reduce storage implications for few-shot speaker adaptation, we
designed two adapters and a unique adaptation procedure.
|
[
-0.30053070187568665,
-0.6772680878639221,
0.3120519816875458,
0.05055615305900574,
-0.4402327835559845,
0.08981284499168396,
-0.1915162205696106,
-0.2966053783893585,
0.06269924342632294,
0.42046886682510376,
-0.3112676739692688,
-0.26389575004577637,
-0.18947143852710724,
0.1333153396844864,
-0.17562782764434814,
0.8964809775352478,
0.43515142798423767,
-0.23121190071105957,
0.471032977104187,
-0.15673252940177917,
-0.7954361438751221,
-0.41108888387680054,
-0.566075325012207,
-0.3461713194847107,
0.10722071677446365,
0.7832874059677124,
0.6663101315498352,
0.4506855010986328,
-0.0673418715596199,
0.16478231549263,
-0.03894982859492302,
-0.07298076152801514,
-0.5725828409194946,
0.19963325560092926,
-0.34462517499923706,
-0.17736048996448517,
-0.40648138523101807,
-0.49084752798080444,
0.7230019569396973,
0.45738837122917175,
-0.12208812683820724,
-0.1547815054655075,
0.051355209201574326,
0.5472383499145508,
-0.6121845841407776,
-0.39974576234817505,
-1.1556750535964966,
0.24131622910499573,
-0.04756619408726692,
-0.44305136799812317,
-0.5802035927772522,
-0.018201956525444984,
0.3190845847129822,
-0.5810757279396057,
0.3961029350757599,
-0.3339534103870392,
0.13319920003414154,
0.11651618778705597,
-0.36368030309677124,
0.09725993871688843,
-1.2008335590362549,
0.43594226241111755,
-0.5658959746360779,
0.4543347954750061,
-0.20496536791324615,
0.320209801197052,
-0.40230265259742737,
-0.3389398455619812,
-0.46813443303108215,
-0.12811322510242462,
0.43649035692214966,
0.43552878499031067,
-0.37860366702079773,
0.17920969426631927,
-0.09367065131664276,
0.018683061003684998,
-0.8254474401473999,
0.15922775864601135,
-0.03687509521842003,
-0.3062322735786438,
0.46939313411712646,
0.03775809705257416,
0.30298206210136414,
-0.15950331091880798,
-0.46362969279289246,
-0.12838152050971985,
-0.48433515429496765,
-0.1610926389694214,
-0.08144550770521164,
0.9156622886657715,
-0.05808288976550102,
0.15477290749549866,
-0.3189014494419098,
0.539499044418335,
-0.05120011419057846,
-0.04520828649401665,
-0.08210087567567825,
-0.14561761915683746,
-0.10857636481523514,
0.2927110195159912,
0.7897576689720154,
0.2711075246334076,
0.6019206047058105,
-0.4545268714427948,
0.13974106311798096,
-0.24949011206626892,
0.1812906265258789,
-0.764043390750885,
-0.08170715719461441,
-0.044399287551641464,
0.008190812543034554,
0.2520237863063812,
-0.1004597470164299,
-1.133702278137207,
-0.19506925344467163,
-0.0721190944314003,
0.9159924983978271,
-0.5010644197463989,
-0.29548391699790955,
0.05574163421988487,
-0.26471981406211853,
0.12416398525238037,
0.15181833505630493,
-1.238839864730835,
0.5331660509109497,
0.2085554301738739,
0.7993251085281372,
-0.1967848539352417,
-0.35096272826194763,
-0.4894255995750427,
0.47454261779785156,
-0.4680856168270111,
0.9564492106437683,
-0.261561781167984,
-0.7977825403213501,
-0.0048647113144397736,
-0.34380561113357544,
-0.10916019231081009,
-0.15736819803714752,
0.6474573612213135,
-0.12261568754911423,
-0.0065690381452441216,
-0.3531113266944885,
-0.46867209672927856,
0.10228908061981201,
-0.1533675640821457,
-0.21915334463119507,
0.8588978052139282,
0.09796244651079178,
-0.5192978978157043,
0.2970069348812103,
-0.879289984703064,
-0.3503338694572449,
0.16848954558372498,
-0.17702865600585938,
-0.14563794434070587,
0.5643669366836548,
0.40857213735580444,
0.5468503832817078,
-0.18801595270633698,
0.09564570337533951,
0.02373887039721012,
-0.7885264754295349,
0.19440650939941406,
-0.8278194665908813,
0.5650199055671692,
0.3233499825000763,
-0.20984166860580444,
-0.15683212876319885,
-0.9984826445579529,
-0.06763295084238052,
0.32489728927612305,
-0.1369611918926239,
-0.3196360170841217,
-0.035295646637678146,
0.36368170380592346,
-0.2555680274963379,
-0.1864100694656372,
-0.6257049441337585,
0.0010325242765247822,
-0.5274260640144348,
0.41212737560272217,
0.8473846316337585,
0.22341589629650116,
0.39672040939331055,
-0.20248998701572418,
0.32496699690818787,
-0.2827931344509125,
-0.00702831894159317,
-0.5286839604377747,
-0.07215683162212372,
-0.6704628467559814,
-0.14001907408237457,
0.16867101192474365,
0.825790286064148,
-0.6316507458686829,
0.23781898617744446,
-0.6018418073654175,
-0.4653357267379761,
-0.12121225148439407,
-0.2404944896697998,
0.38514605164527893,
0.51877760887146,
0.4316931366920471,
-0.5428345203399658,
-0.6623102426528931,
-0.45790383219718933,
-0.42756587266921997,
-0.3032565712928772,
-0.4400533437728882,
0.08216642588376999,
0.2237803339958191,
0.03928536921739578,
1.214556097984314,
-0.27444717288017273,
-0.3035215437412262,
-0.06945471465587616,
0.031284887343645096,
0.058669593185186386,
0.4539864957332611,
0.5730081796646118,
-0.4473983943462372,
-0.47685179114341736,
-0.0017750781262293458,
-0.5008710622787476,
0.009974625892937183,
-0.462083101272583,
0.27505943179130554,
0.17246215045452118,
0.24708372354507446,
-0.4642280042171478,
0.448220431804657,
0.4224257469177246,
-0.4105031192302704,
0.4333157241344452,
-0.48087504506111145,
0.16328687965869904,
-1.2260096073150635,
-0.25996094942092896,
-0.1323470175266266,
-0.23207944631576538,
-0.9942551255226135,
-0.276399165391922,
-0.2323327362537384,
-0.3887178897857666,
-0.5590821504592896,
0.7503700256347656,
-0.18010668456554413,
-0.2712492048740387,
-0.23607803881168365,
0.3668554425239563,
-0.0407111719250679,
0.4630458652973175,
-0.0353817492723465,
1.1201717853546143,
0.47992682456970215,
-0.611568033695221,
0.3816843628883362,
0.4088054597377777,
0.15792380273342133,
1.0728081464767456,
-0.5598605871200562,
0.49379241466522217,
-0.06789815425872803,
0.49928587675094604,
-1.0826281309127808,
-0.1704147309064865,
0.08979230374097824,
-0.6172009706497192,
0.4963666498661041,
-0.1903713345527649,
-0.27392566204071045,
-0.19892039895057678,
-0.3787964880466461,
0.2589988708496094,
0.5086046457290649,
-0.655189037322998,
0.6359202861785889,
0.2151930183172226,
-0.5522968769073486,
-0.1276692897081375,
-0.7332622408866882,
0.6095280647277832,
-0.13058005273342133,
-0.3397825360298157,
0.4671010673046112,
-0.2946348786354065,
0.18057215213775635,
-0.2699272334575653,
-0.2781400978565216,
-0.3877030313014984,
-0.15733398497104645,
-0.12785203754901886,
0.046684373170137405,
-0.3139488399028778,
0.26961061358451843,
0.02307484671473503,
-0.31367069482803345,
-0.47038018703460693,
-0.46997976303100586,
0.24867276847362518,
0.05954300984740257,
-0.1856018751859665,
-0.7134982943534851,
0.6249676942825317,
0.537765383720398,
0.2383345067501068,
0.12254966050386429,
0.6447293162345886,
-0.1401716023683548,
-0.11774259805679321,
-0.6721663475036621,
-0.08846541494131088,
-0.44049564003944397,
0.7917006015777588,
-0.6242087483406067,
-0.9749335050582886,
0.35079389810562134,
-0.0787593275308609,
0.08375513553619385,
0.2637329697608948,
0.4317077398300171,
-0.03948242589831352,
0.6853123307228088,
0.6899204850196838,
-0.272956907749176,
0.6113927364349365,
0.2565802335739136,
-0.11238633841276169,
-0.7647251486778259,
0.12398640066385269,
-0.7553775906562805,
0.04822000116109848,
-0.675983190536499,
-0.2531055808067322,
0.2860342860221863,
-0.14787404239177704,
-0.36842021346092224,
0.47594693303108215,
-0.8491570353507996,
0.5887578129768372,
0.5549787878990173,
-0.07606504112482071,
0.28566494584083557,
0.3075159192085266,
-0.09423156082630157,
-0.09115356206893921,
-0.6393921375274658,
-0.314477801322937,
1.387842059135437,
0.273578941822052,
0.7073931694030762,
-0.07454492151737213,
0.7030951380729675,
0.5432996153831482,
-0.23012398183345795,
-0.5168123245239258,
0.5076859593391418,
-0.4574629068374634,
-0.524775505065918,
-0.5557883381843567,
-0.4676419794559479,
-0.8843879699707031,
0.3078238070011139,
-0.008865492418408394,
-1.195001482963562,
0.03869595751166344,
0.3004768490791321,
-0.6102926731109619,
0.3427351117134094,
-0.8255288004875183,
0.545178234577179,
-0.0836368128657341,
-0.011034823954105377,
-0.07238710671663284,
-0.7296156287193298,
-0.1661411076784134,
-0.08892425894737244,
0.26846200227737427,
-0.13012169301509857,
0.1819089651107788,
0.7640618085861206,
0.09731727838516235,
0.7160839438438416,
-0.40531060099601746,
0.18396635353565216,
0.40337008237838745,
0.05977822467684746,
0.31383126974105835,
0.000008429059562331531,
-0.17267894744873047,
0.11235164850950241,
0.2488570362329483,
-0.568388819694519,
-0.3913826048374176,
0.3984128534793854,
-0.7806546092033386,
-0.3761638402938843,
-0.29922300577163696,
-0.6530953049659729,
-0.7214057445526123,
0.021360715851187706,
0.4021790325641632,
0.6409884691238403,
-0.9086029529571533,
0.14276334643363953,
0.692819356918335,
-0.20601217448711395,
0.7084720134735107,
0.6331916451454163,
0.01586356945335865,
-0.7860982418060303,
1.0378494262695312,
0.06324359029531479,
0.37967386841773987,
0.5724183917045593,
0.3597932457923889,
-0.252752423286438,
-0.7748697400093079,
-0.5950688719749451,
0.04743051528930664,
-0.45112931728363037,
-0.19885887205600739,
-0.30511772632598877,
-0.28095743060112,
-0.4577893912792206,
-0.36689940094947815,
-0.5923037528991699,
-0.5750404596328735,
-0.5122843384742737,
-0.007431081961840391,
0.5715157389640808,
0.39680132269859314,
-0.3924718201160431,
0.6570664048194885,
-0.9033787846565247,
0.8041582703590393,
0.782062828540802,
0.392396479845047,
-0.3014666736125946,
-1.1362663507461548,
-0.038385603576898575,
0.10748752951622009,
-0.34672755002975464,
-0.7360748648643494,
0.08287954330444336,
0.6713401675224304,
0.3535573184490204,
0.11249116063117981,
0.15964002907276154,
0.832434356212616,
-0.8177469372749329,
0.8043919205665588,
0.316385954618454,
-0.98590487241745,
0.5545530319213867,
-0.47922220826148987,
0.520548939704895,
0.6162567138671875,
-0.2179289609193802,
-0.7697662711143494,
-0.23861919343471527,
-0.45323774218559265,
-0.6214829087257385,
0.8112047910690308,
0.35975703597068787,
0.7621956467628479,
0.24144701659679413,
0.5477138757705688,
0.1467253416776657,
-0.2315535992383957,
-0.5794743895530701,
-0.19922930002212524,
-0.5618872046470642,
-0.28756317496299744,
-0.13981492817401886,
-0.4437873661518097,
0.08656307309865952,
-0.12487614154815674,
0.6056219935417175,
-0.3241269886493683,
0.5301650762557983,
0.46385475993156433,
-0.035975318402051926,
-0.18708838522434235,
0.9157248735427856,
0.583313524723053,
0.45134928822517395,
-0.4609183073043823,
0.0029744894709438086,
0.431110680103302,
-0.6220768690109253,
0.34926822781562805,
0.21942704916000366,
-0.27015912532806396,
0.15927769243717194,
0.07723835855722427,
0.8836328983306885,
0.34127187728881836,
-0.42070817947387695,
0.3386944532394409,
-0.12395049631595612,
-0.24391314387321472,
-0.19525198638439178,
0.08219046890735626,
-0.09012112766504288,
0.046481143683195114,
0.7832046151161194,
0.19207149744033813,
-0.06632095575332642,
-0.5579750537872314,
0.4347759187221527,
0.2988848388195038,
-0.6901262402534485,
-0.6827033162117004,
0.5889810919761658,
0.4387974143028259,
-0.719182014465332,
0.21180632710456848,
-0.16339032351970673,
-0.3136400282382965,
0.10064392536878586,
0.9388449788093567,
1.1177499294281006,
-0.795849084854126,
0.3073224127292633,
0.10393288731575012,
0.20093382894992828,
-0.01489123236387968,
0.31014811992645264,
-0.08425160497426987,
-0.743052065372467,
-0.17406436800956726,
-0.4875776767730713,
-0.5384237170219421,
0.12212367355823517,
-0.4502042233943939,
0.039011333137750626,
-0.4350109100341797,
-0.028935618698596954,
-0.2405799776315689,
-0.23434123396873474,
-0.5063983798027039,
0.40642547607421875,
0.19907037913799286,
0.7523168921470642,
-0.9214354157447815,
0.7569158673286438,
0.3353637158870697,
-0.087953120470047,
-0.5312796235084534,
0.19064484536647797,
0.06565144658088684,
-0.6780995726585388,
-0.13349668681621552,
-0.11440929025411606,
-0.11935832351446152,
0.480342835187912,
-0.21133844554424286,
-0.6673719882965088,
0.8281001448631287,
0.9061543941497803,
-0.44289422035217285,
-0.037811752408742905,
0.4333110749721527,
0.4195905923843384,
-0.22220543026924133,
0.1937827318906784,
0.7741917371749878,
0.1398421823978424,
0.45002442598342896,
-1.1321057081222534,
-0.27428409457206726,
0.20620442926883698,
0.3389740586280823,
0.0050696320831775665,
-0.5282004475593567,
0.5099619030952454,
-0.03268551826477051,
-0.07434820383787155,
0.1353835165500641,
0.5903487801551819,
0.13567842543125153,
0.2570216953754425,
0.4825315773487091,
0.3861462473869324,
0.4116922616958618,
0.11746645718812943,
0.5299962759017944,
0.23557253181934357,
0.21564431488513947,
1.2909642457962036,
-0.20969346165657043,
0.8431761264801025,
0.5209422707557678,
-0.5397099256515503,
0.07585069537162781,
0.2154865860939026,
0.22334739565849304,
0.5633305907249451,
-0.03574217110872269,
-0.46009543538093567,
-0.11994900554418564,
-0.26351070404052734,
-0.3963591158390045,
0.8784140944480896,
0.3040396273136139,
0.2511959671974182,
-0.4060749411582947,
0.08954176306724548,
-0.22416824102401733,
0.2636090815067291,
-0.14132320880889893,
0.9024168252944946,
-0.013815628364682198,
-0.2760092318058014,
0.7030664682388306,
-0.380837619304657,
0.6179792284965515,
-0.5746142268180847,
-0.05179760605096817,
-0.19464081525802612,
-0.07611733675003052,
0.08889180421829224,
-0.5077918767929077,
0.20158973336219788,
0.2772015333175659,
-0.1148890033364296,
-0.06359004229307175,
0.5767139196395874,
-0.11302490532398224,
-0.4008110463619232,
0.20327726006507874,
0.32483750581741333,
0.11973758786916733,
-0.19778944551944733,
-0.6113576889038086,
0.19221708178520203,
0.19567519426345825,
-0.24697892367839813,
0.34994202852249146,
0.6071352958679199,
0.15422673523426056,
0.2994692921638489,
0.5438865423202515,
0.20692607760429382,
-0.0042788018472492695,
0.36633703112602234,
0.6096634864807129,
-0.7712315917015076,
-0.6112730503082275,
-0.7629035711288452,
0.5858120322227478,
0.21670155227184296,
-0.24714869260787964,
0.39377591013908386,
0.3803333342075348,
0.6290194392204285,
0.10238487273454666,
0.8378931879997253,
0.1499888151884079,
0.776502251625061,
-0.5124104022979736,
0.5506678819656372,
-0.37513622641563416,
0.08915657550096512,
-0.7551504373550415,
-0.9541088342666626,
-0.42831486463546753,
0.41280266642570496,
0.3369688391685486,
-0.05574357882142067,
0.5387722253799438,
0.5876767635345459,
0.03427629917860031,
0.18142622709274292,
0.8034680485725403,
0.33735665678977966,
0.4420199990272522,
0.6444453001022339,
0.5536388158798218,
-0.6860523819923401,
1.0042787790298462,
-0.000966481922660023,
-0.35295021533966064,
-0.23604093492031097,
-0.9507303237915039,
-0.6114339232444763,
-0.5410864949226379,
-0.26404619216918945,
0.30891433358192444,
0.2895798683166504,
0.7464900016784668,
0.7649457454681396,
-0.870600163936615,
-0.2484881728887558,
-0.2688062787055969,
-0.11308521777391434,
0.0318978950381279,
-0.20328854024410248,
0.3644384443759918,
-0.21054707467556,
-0.4991777837276459,
0.7605870962142944,
0.7279947996139526,
0.43442705273628235,
0.3344742953777313,
0.03320106863975525,
0.13248266279697418,
0.33404189348220825,
0.5139504075050354,
0.7435228824615479,
-0.6556552052497864,
-0.7500401735305786,
-0.13480931520462036,
0.2568362355232239,
0.31210654973983765,
0.6215664744377136,
-0.8125597238540649,
1.0085660219192505,
0.06481907516717911,
0.7272034883499146,
0.49087727069854736,
-0.0040809414349496365,
0.5861749649047852,
-1.0419272184371948,
0.5320917963981628,
0.3181374967098236,
0.04922621697187424,
0.40234968066215515,
-0.07129690796136856,
0.17326681315898895,
0.1688985675573349,
-0.6481316685676575,
-0.8155035972595215,
0.2644854784011841,
-1.0908039808273315,
-0.19179944694042206,
0.8466824293136597,
-0.03044392354786396,
0.30476775765419006,
-0.31287944316864014,
-0.3801107704639435,
0.46012675762176514,
-0.7137967944145203,
0.8836902379989624,
0.22635418176651,
-0.3076302707195282,
-0.02825249545276165,
-0.55401611328125,
0.24893076717853546,
0.3380047082901001,
-0.713787853717804,
0.24477912485599518,
0.3929378390312195,
0.3324146270751953,
0.07947076857089996,
0.9996389746665955,
0.1463196575641632,
0.39391961693763733,
0.09025514125823975,
0.015405476093292236,
0.14606627821922302,
-0.2742014229297638,
-0.47292232513427734,
0.07270786911249161,
0.1416642963886261,
-0.4026775062084198
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.