id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18085v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18085v1
|
CRE-LLM: A Domain-Specific Chinese Relation Extraction Framework with Fine-tuned Large Language Model
| 2024-04-28T06:27:15 | 2024-04-28T06:27:15 |
Zhengpeng Shi, Haoran Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Domain-Specific Chinese Relation Extraction (DSCRE) aims to extract relations
between entities from domain-specific Chinese text. Despite the rapid
development of PLMs in recent years, especially LLMs, DSCRE still faces three
core challenges: complex network structure design, poor awareness, and high
consumption of fine-tuning. Given the impressive performance of large language
models (LLMs) in natural language processing, we propose a new framework called
CRE-LLM. This framework is based on fine-tuning open-source LLMs, such as
Llama-2, ChatGLM2, and Baichuan2. CRE-LLM enhances the logic-awareness and
generative capabilities of the model by constructing an appropriate prompt and
utilizing open-source LLMs for instruction-supervised fine-tuning. And then it
directly extracts the relations of the given entities in the input textual
data, which improving the CRE approach. To demonstrate the effectiveness of the
proposed framework, we conducted extensive experiments on two domain-specific
CRE datasets, FinRE and SanWen. The experimental results show that CRE-LLM is
significantly superior and robust, achieving state-of-the-art (SOTA)
performance on the FinRE dataset. This paper introduces a novel approach to
domain-specific relation extraction (DSCRE) tasks that are semantically more
complex by combining LLMs with triples. Our code is publicly available.
|
[
-0.32670626044273376,
-0.6999931931495667,
0.46710237860679626,
0.27522775530815125,
-0.35759833455085754,
-0.08440221101045609,
-0.6488616466522217,
-0.5677162408828735,
-0.18393898010253906,
0.71672123670578,
-0.556058943271637,
-0.8502126932144165,
-0.5355323553085327,
0.12660758197307587,
-0.12307703495025635,
0.8062794804573059,
-0.07871806621551514,
0.19732844829559326,
0.12203390151262283,
0.06856497377157211,
-0.15434463322162628,
-0.4602457582950592,
-0.7639520168304443,
-0.11177490651607513,
0.40147873759269714,
0.38097867369651794,
0.37588879466056824,
0.8292844891548157,
0.7231245040893555,
0.18603049218654633,
-0.02086951583623886,
0.5440658926963806,
-0.41485267877578735,
0.019372550770640373,
-0.4489710330963135,
-0.422038733959198,
-0.7521957159042358,
-0.09138288348913193,
0.39008092880249023,
0.4369405210018158,
0.0732765644788742,
0.23780323565006256,
0.092237189412117,
0.5812426805496216,
-0.6532664895057678,
0.42593637108802795,
-0.8503350615501404,
-0.1933378130197525,
-0.5160594582557678,
-0.32304999232292175,
-0.3980553448200226,
-0.2429414838552475,
0.2809852957725525,
-0.6678064465522766,
0.2829781472682953,
-0.10291921347379684,
1.0890755653381348,
0.026431165635585785,
-0.41802671551704407,
-0.37090203166007996,
-0.6104568839073181,
0.8976526260375977,
-0.88834148645401,
0.49530813097953796,
0.17565125226974487,
0.25893908739089966,
-0.06523919105529785,
-0.8907672166824341,
-0.4985428750514984,
-0.12248502671718597,
-0.02042853832244873,
0.008354823105037212,
0.36000511050224304,
0.03703157976269722,
0.07699649780988693,
0.6831525564193726,
-0.3679640293121338,
0.19470658898353577,
-0.16664978861808777,
-0.08016053587198257,
0.7055473923683167,
0.3431004285812378,
0.5816921591758728,
-0.12177236378192902,
-0.7948001027107239,
0.2836187481880188,
-0.9269241094589233,
-0.04456299543380737,
-0.04968228563666344,
0.5563637614250183,
-0.04168309271335602,
0.4961358606815338,
-0.027110129594802856,
0.40233999490737915,
0.07715819031000137,
-0.20469267666339874,
0.008861596696078777,
-0.42338883876800537,
-0.37881723046302795,
-0.13679003715515137,
0.8717063665390015,
0.23529064655303955,
0.4807233512401581,
-0.20074336230754852,
-0.27825674414634705,
0.25878602266311646,
-0.2788776159286499,
-0.7808395624160767,
-0.304532915353775,
0.29004454612731934,
-0.46367156505584717,
-0.2104560136795044,
0.18840739130973816,
-0.8185657858848572,
-0.23786647617816925,
-0.5632804036140442,
-0.21573913097381592,
-0.5441890358924866,
-0.36546918749809265,
0.19948752224445343,
0.13867367804050446,
0.5280604958534241,
0.32904767990112305,
-0.878117024898529,
0.4814602732658386,
0.9165655970573425,
0.793268084526062,
-0.6567580103874207,
-0.1768372356891632,
-0.7092317342758179,
0.5179013013839722,
-0.015655606985092163,
0.7084318399429321,
-0.5888363122940063,
-0.18771949410438538,
0.07747405022382736,
0.18057076632976532,
-0.13862524926662445,
-0.6963052749633789,
0.7041646242141724,
-0.860591471195221,
0.022331910207867622,
-0.2647731602191925,
-0.619539737701416,
0.0032400579657405615,
0.2569342255592346,
-0.6065321564674377,
0.8580374121665955,
0.03949258103966713,
-0.7074620127677917,
0.10455457866191864,
-0.5991640090942383,
-0.47527480125427246,
0.36646872758865356,
-0.2505664825439453,
-0.24010448157787323,
-0.41134947538375854,
0.36044344305992126,
0.6049702763557434,
-0.76493239402771,
0.35257938504219055,
-0.3562829792499542,
-0.2741236686706543,
-0.1777171939611435,
-0.17258557677268982,
1.0909677743911743,
0.3174632787704468,
-0.23599761724472046,
0.07400442659854889,
-0.7279629111289978,
-0.016173699870705605,
0.31093499064445496,
-0.2710499167442322,
-0.4895552694797516,
0.037623267620801926,
-0.042206089943647385,
0.3075329661369324,
0.5949937105178833,
-0.5503342747688293,
0.1410135179758072,
-0.5891967415809631,
0.5997650027275085,
0.5602221488952637,
0.22780968248844147,
0.5832333564758301,
-0.07020191103219986,
0.29545271396636963,
0.3025193214416504,
0.04801882803440094,
-0.1509551703929901,
-0.10915138572454453,
-0.6964575052261353,
-0.41829320788383484,
0.31786513328552246,
0.6845178008079529,
-0.6796227097511292,
0.3768233358860016,
-0.32081282138824463,
-0.36607444286346436,
-0.24322505295276642,
0.4000740647315979,
0.2821144759654999,
0.4234035611152649,
0.3520858585834503,
-0.12697014212608337,
-0.400585800409317,
-0.8731988668441772,
-0.2579759359359741,
0.0015052342787384987,
-0.09546058624982834,
0.32508987188339233,
0.19910936057567596,
-0.22920402884483337,
0.8013938069343567,
-0.7822050452232361,
-0.675671398639679,
-0.3121820092201233,
-0.3246154189109802,
-0.02105344459414482,
0.305419921875,
0.5790353417396545,
-0.9100222587585449,
-0.6836753487586975,
0.17575982213020325,
-0.7527104616165161,
-0.23197518289089203,
-0.12754572927951813,
-0.25161316990852356,
0.17201289534568787,
0.2779163122177124,
-0.5976704359054565,
0.17496855556964874,
0.32177600264549255,
-0.0023311988916248083,
0.6088624596595764,
0.2580949664115906,
0.027615584433078766,
-0.9668956398963928,
0.012102593667805195,
0.4297637343406677,
-0.08508215844631195,
-0.6103323101997375,
0.26674169301986694,
0.37669888138771057,
0.032957497984170914,
-0.6500721573829651,
0.5175104141235352,
-0.6260087490081787,
0.014313749969005585,
-0.0782591849565506,
0.9400272965431213,
0.2016792744398117,
0.858673095703125,
0.35640671849250793,
0.6732683181762695,
0.5022343397140503,
-0.9412881135940552,
0.3370618522167206,
0.49768319725990295,
-0.18262434005737305,
0.43977418541908264,
-0.5048085451126099,
0.026963206008076668,
0.23023998737335205,
-0.12009454518556595,
-0.591326117515564,
0.08615145087242126,
0.30799537897109985,
-0.24704647064208984,
0.2858455181121826,
-0.04064524173736572,
-0.29357314109802246,
-0.15624596178531647,
-0.41106659173965454,
0.3157748579978943,
0.013788454234600067,
-0.7626907825469971,
0.5635872483253479,
0.4334929585456848,
-0.32657095789909363,
-0.4869503974914551,
-0.5478886961936951,
0.22257450222969055,
-0.14504744112491608,
-0.8318406343460083,
0.5816276669502258,
-0.1483631134033203,
-0.36076119542121887,
-0.09900499880313873,
-0.21713635325431824,
-0.39975854754447937,
0.06758633255958557,
0.02331608720123768,
0.5862900614738464,
-0.4364239275455475,
-0.18568101525306702,
0.015012698248028755,
-0.028728876262903214,
0.06543873995542526,
-0.04446486011147499,
0.5196037292480469,
0.01798967830836773,
-0.16295462846755981,
-0.7073190212249756,
0.0751175805926323,
0.39431101083755493,
-0.579554557800293,
0.4371786415576935,
0.3058321177959442,
-0.5803471803665161,
-0.5583759546279907,
-0.3357168436050415,
-0.09795805811882019,
-0.4991699755191803,
0.49838560819625854,
-0.5551196336746216,
-0.8370864987373352,
0.47304198145866394,
-0.3532180190086365,
0.35370153188705444,
0.4626365005970001,
0.5340188145637512,
0.3305917978286743,
0.7116307020187378,
0.5896862745285034,
-0.2990979552268982,
0.33614879846572876,
-0.19312740862369537,
0.17855483293533325,
-0.9807765483856201,
-0.2920406758785248,
-0.5433006286621094,
0.15673217177391052,
-0.21299369633197784,
-0.10829269140958786,
-0.09469752758741379,
0.16891302168369293,
-0.39189621806144714,
0.6639115810394287,
-0.2569206953048706,
0.218403160572052,
0.17759189009666443,
0.07028570026159286,
0.7466865181922913,
-0.09037096798419952,
0.13156284391880035,
-0.21784210205078125,
-0.42469191551208496,
-0.7841200232505798,
0.6331455707550049,
0.38159918785095215,
0.4993497431278229,
0.026206888258457184,
0.43166229128837585,
0.20957763493061066,
0.3702520430088043,
-0.856766939163208,
0.6930485963821411,
-0.5102251172065735,
-0.3579576015472412,
-0.11634419858455658,
-0.5386651158332825,
-0.7660087943077087,
0.15286403894424438,
-0.003703406313434243,
-0.627193808555603,
0.05764155462384224,
-0.12373579293489456,
-0.20566314458847046,
0.5040320754051208,
-0.36732837557792664,
0.5629845857620239,
-0.38179829716682434,
-0.4338358938694,
-0.06984228640794754,
-0.4688577950000763,
0.8638386726379395,
-0.18749260902404785,
0.08290696889162064,
-0.21836215257644653,
-0.11215833574533463,
0.5517082810401917,
-0.3053204119205475,
0.7522150278091431,
-0.06289085745811462,
-0.6503239274024963,
0.43779221177101135,
0.2700668275356293,
0.5882368683815002,
0.40037161111831665,
-0.2104998379945755,
0.4666200876235962,
0.07756589353084564,
-0.19358187913894653,
-0.4818871319293976,
1.0475934743881226,
-0.6612553000450134,
-0.6756658554077148,
-0.17860300838947296,
-0.3037874400615692,
-0.34949761629104614,
0.45982667803764343,
-0.06411714106798172,
0.41170892119407654,
-0.2757267653942108,
-0.05891329050064087,
0.550967812538147,
-0.40430134534835815,
0.3209063708782196,
0.7006000876426697,
0.02314436063170433,
-0.5298299789428711,
0.7295369505882263,
-0.21518802642822266,
0.3532247841358185,
0.488207072019577,
-0.19875340163707733,
-0.13501812517642975,
-0.4005953371524811,
-0.4046299159526825,
0.4454115927219391,
-0.4797097146511078,
-0.4580685496330261,
-0.5371524095535278,
-0.5155200362205505,
-0.44087091088294983,
0.046804916113615036,
-0.43428152799606323,
-0.1892482489347458,
-0.5030980110168457,
0.10857175290584564,
-0.01619359850883484,
0.5269989371299744,
0.32436248660087585,
0.22260700166225433,
-1.0878084897994995,
0.6522616147994995,
0.03357941284775734,
0.4463312327861786,
0.06239502131938934,
-0.34157437086105347,
-0.19725558161735535,
0.263918936252594,
-0.3601251542568207,
-0.6127548217773438,
0.4570435881614685,
0.2071651816368103,
0.4014536142349243,
0.56695157289505,
0.29756850004196167,
0.6868554353713989,
-0.3241249620914459,
1.0213736295700073,
0.0828155130147934,
-0.9405791163444519,
0.4145272970199585,
-0.3666178286075592,
-0.20522856712341309,
0.36247456073760986,
0.09565364569425583,
-0.4776439070701599,
-0.1459456980228424,
-0.2888130843639374,
-0.6904927492141724,
0.8793571591377258,
0.10011331737041473,
-0.11359794437885284,
-0.20146502554416656,
0.6433395743370056,
0.04431533440947533,
0.04987021163105965,
-0.6610661745071411,
-0.4595722258090973,
0.20712387561798096,
-0.22906886041164398,
0.25907617807388306,
-0.3777164816856384,
0.10935220867395401,
0.125575989484787,
0.8885582089424133,
0.07827571779489517,
-0.06542689353227615,
0.30393674969673157,
-0.21897441148757935,
-0.20178565382957458,
0.1105576753616333,
0.26900383830070496,
0.48537689447402954,
-0.02748105116188526,
0.05522610619664192,
0.16820824146270752,
-0.4176265001296997,
-0.3016532361507416,
-0.05633605271577835,
-0.10330776125192642,
-0.29955214262008667,
0.3304392397403717,
0.3778400421142578,
-0.003208386478945613,
-0.7801327705383301,
0.8021194338798523,
-0.11543012410402298,
-0.3990651071071625,
-0.4794856309890747,
0.1805599182844162,
0.16592271625995636,
0.24693816900253296,
0.2585248649120331,
-0.00044339740998111665,
-0.071708545088768,
-0.23701217770576477,
0.33264046907424927,
0.4242973327636719,
-0.3230590224266052,
-0.43061524629592896,
0.8681332468986511,
0.38813814520835876,
-0.2887333035469055,
0.5064637064933777,
-0.051434267312288284,
-0.5583968758583069,
0.6224060654640198,
0.6082735061645508,
0.7057515382766724,
-0.03312273696064949,
0.047052737325429916,
0.4320117235183716,
0.14749553799629211,
-0.22973598539829254,
0.11226403713226318,
0.013734214939177036,
-0.8554045557975769,
-0.6040796637535095,
-0.43213164806365967,
-0.20556285977363586,
0.36968156695365906,
-0.7045037746429443,
0.8138668537139893,
-0.4676467180252075,
0.16424912214279175,
-0.35647451877593994,
0.47403737902641296,
-0.595933198928833,
0.18089161813259125,
0.10452757030725479,
1.157751202583313,
-0.34610894322395325,
1.0036808252334595,
0.4118656814098358,
-0.31479835510253906,
-0.8067761063575745,
0.003055121749639511,
-0.16462191939353943,
-0.7976367473602295,
0.8359611630439758,
-0.0707143023610115,
-0.27054092288017273,
0.05685298889875412,
-0.47978052496910095,
-0.5850318074226379,
1.3007975816726685,
0.4168705642223358,
-0.953696608543396,
0.009034767746925354,
0.25030264258384705,
0.41216957569122314,
-0.5510307550430298,
-0.16892552375793457,
0.6475513577461243,
0.4225347340106964,
-0.2106124609708786,
-0.6643145680427551,
0.22087298333644867,
-0.10662736743688583,
-0.07717710733413696,
0.2559627592563629,
-1.022367238998413,
0.5797309875488281,
-0.16996993124485016,
-0.7589491605758667,
0.29861950874328613,
0.7857064008712769,
0.4140319228172302,
0.49664008617401123,
0.4569058418273926,
0.2569427490234375,
0.6694427132606506,
0.13874828815460205,
0.486927330493927,
-0.6770129203796387,
0.3351724445819855,
1.2412294149398804,
-0.7635191679000854,
0.7003576755523682,
0.28042685985565186,
-0.15689942240715027,
0.38672366738319397,
0.49283134937286377,
-0.013910171575844288,
0.31653639674186707,
-0.025258691981434822,
-0.3012152314186096,
-0.30980172753334045,
-0.006452265661209822,
-0.207782581448555,
0.3093615472316742,
0.5624262690544128,
-0.4447696805000305,
-0.1999000608921051,
-0.43066152930259705,
-0.00903033372014761,
0.38995790481567383,
-0.29146555066108704,
0.6507378816604614,
0.4401247501373291,
-0.3146169185638428,
0.47791847586631775,
0.20259983837604523,
0.7974261045455933,
-0.6528352499008179,
-0.03824681416153908,
-0.128790944814682,
0.16945627331733704,
-0.33140885829925537,
-0.36817893385887146,
0.11507045477628708,
-0.053761739283800125,
-0.0970725491642952,
0.13411612808704376,
0.8887631297111511,
-0.6275123953819275,
-0.12784385681152344,
0.613882839679718,
0.6948255300521851,
-0.1386769562959671,
-0.03194699063897133,
-0.6141033172607422,
-0.05105222016572952,
0.24143745005130768,
-0.46171897649765015,
0.2997075617313385,
0.7756948471069336,
-0.09991906583309174,
0.660933792591095,
0.728442370891571,
0.45057183504104614,
-0.32260337471961975,
0.09766107052564621,
0.9131135940551758,
-0.769161581993103,
-0.1932479590177536,
-0.9995741248130798,
0.08202489465475082,
-0.18621745705604553,
-0.17272643744945526,
0.6878147721290588,
0.5824950933456421,
0.6949283480644226,
0.026861323043704033,
1.0292911529541016,
0.09240566194057465,
0.5304730534553528,
-0.29389697313308716,
0.3657885193824768,
-0.42051252722740173,
0.7813791632652283,
-0.2728056311607361,
-1.0345430374145508,
-0.49200135469436646,
0.23397056758403778,
-0.2900317907333374,
-0.2886987626552582,
0.757940411567688,
0.9010235667228699,
-0.1183427944779396,
0.2568604052066803,
0.12656931579113007,
0.14277897775173187,
0.5340403318405151,
0.7642990350723267,
0.5093924403190613,
-0.49361488223075867,
0.7698078751564026,
-0.25838181376457214,
-0.20569634437561035,
0.2739225924015045,
-0.7693722248077393,
-1.0342689752578735,
-0.5134637355804443,
-0.33200523257255554,
-0.1014213114976883,
-0.09349358081817627,
0.9779966473579407,
0.35430529713630676,
-0.8721349835395813,
-0.03404846042394638,
0.006139683071523905,
-0.09577029198408127,
-0.2068060338497162,
-0.32515496015548706,
0.7025519609451294,
-0.4431224763393402,
-1.0252999067306519,
0.28544747829437256,
0.36981603503227234,
-0.138109028339386,
-0.15192291140556335,
-0.1978151798248291,
-0.0709160789847374,
-0.03943035006523132,
0.6978011131286621,
0.09670925885438919,
-0.5734161138534546,
-0.192478746175766,
0.14021456241607666,
-0.4015667736530304,
0.08439215272665024,
0.9785168766975403,
-0.4149427115917206,
-0.20100630819797516,
0.3001079559326172,
0.7597244381904602,
0.2163487672805786,
0.16745759546756744,
0.712458610534668,
-0.42652809619903564,
-0.17394870519638062,
0.06813211739063263,
0.5115442872047424,
0.17926034331321716,
-0.6843894720077515,
0.5467610359191895,
0.295673668384552,
-0.5692710876464844,
-0.6333686113357544,
0.4572475254535675,
-1.160040020942688,
-0.37268301844596863,
1.4490655660629272,
-0.3312336802482605,
-0.14134551584720612,
-0.31950631737709045,
-0.45657554268836975,
0.42978888750076294,
-0.3710196912288666,
0.6402415633201599,
0.40364518761634827,
0.07980210334062576,
-0.033944591879844666,
-0.3900834321975708,
0.4849967062473297,
0.25789037346839905,
-0.643020749092102,
0.5991954207420349,
0.2939472794532776,
0.4264681339263916,
-0.14342886209487915,
0.5532400012016296,
-0.4597744941711426,
-0.09203353524208069,
-0.451545774936676,
0.08078856021165848,
-0.24051915109157562,
-0.15690161287784576,
0.12009843438863754,
0.3311888575553894,
0.002966440748423338,
0.06668678671121597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18081v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18081v2
|
ComposerX: Multi-Agent Symbolic Music Composition with LLMs
| 2024-04-28T06:17:42 | 2024-04-30T14:14:26 |
Qixin Deng, Qikai Yang, Ruibin Yuan, Yipeng Huang, Yi Wang, Xubo Liu, Zeyue Tian, Jiahao Pan, Ge Zhang, Hanfeng Lin, Yizhi Li, Yinghao Ma, Jie Fu, Chenghua Lin, Emmanouil Benetos, Wenwu Wang, Guangyu Xia, Wei Xue, Yike Guo
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM, eess.AS
|
Music composition represents the creative side of humanity, and itself is a
complex task that requires abilities to understand and generate information
with long dependency and harmony constraints. While demonstrating impressive
capabilities in STEM subjects, current LLMs easily fail in this task,
generating ill-written music even when equipped with modern techniques like
In-Context-Learning and Chain-of-Thoughts. To further explore and enhance LLMs'
potential in music composition by leveraging their reasoning ability and the
large knowledge base in music history and theory, we propose ComposerX, an
agent-based symbolic music generation framework. We find that applying a
multi-agent approach significantly improves the music composition quality of
GPT-4. The results demonstrate that ComposerX is capable of producing coherent
polyphonic music compositions with captivating melodies, while adhering to user
instructions.
|
[
-0.49318432807922363,
-0.39172273874282837,
1.0403926372528076,
0.46607470512390137,
-0.11171242594718933,
0.6179101467132568,
-0.151570126414299,
-0.49475592374801636,
0.3490215241909027,
0.663134753704071,
-0.8972356915473938,
-0.6741607189178467,
-0.2455347627401352,
0.27459612488746643,
-0.33952194452285767,
0.8363330960273743,
-0.03330300748348236,
-0.14427034556865692,
-0.427401602268219,
0.09602640569210052,
-0.6145840883255005,
-0.4600309431552887,
-0.7568749785423279,
-0.38408899307250977,
0.5075697302818298,
0.20622718334197998,
0.4404261112213135,
0.3798326253890991,
0.3815198540687561,
0.4962226450443268,
0.39424213767051697,
0.37146055698394775,
-0.39532768726348877,
0.5665621161460876,
-0.08161536604166031,
-0.6433727741241455,
-0.687117338180542,
0.38919541239738464,
0.5618069171905518,
0.10008519142866135,
-0.07950950413942337,
-0.058442167937755585,
-0.21655721962451935,
0.583888828754425,
-0.15353956818580627,
0.35781311988830566,
-0.40715163946151733,
0.1615140587091446,
-0.0799909234046936,
-0.5686561465263367,
-0.3270266056060791,
-0.2870595157146454,
0.06876116991043091,
-1.0491365194320679,
-0.2403198778629303,
-0.1593800187110901,
0.29143020510673523,
0.24970538914203644,
-0.41142717003822327,
-0.2790028750896454,
-0.791283905506134,
0.7415618896484375,
-0.21326908469200134,
0.030833495780825615,
0.33789151906967163,
0.6546452045440674,
-0.23052717745304108,
-0.7946311831474304,
-0.42275306582450867,
-0.09671136736869812,
0.31944695115089417,
0.5450260043144226,
-0.10422108322381973,
-0.13353292644023895,
0.20082315802574158,
0.17117992043495178,
-0.442325621843338,
-0.5192046761512756,
-0.09176259487867355,
-0.3277924060821533,
0.7751464247703552,
0.4081439971923828,
0.6171124577522278,
0.2595188319683075,
-0.5637964010238647,
-0.17949293553829193,
-0.8905197381973267,
-0.2332756519317627,
0.578188955783844,
0.09429052472114563,
-0.12588226795196533,
0.37955135107040405,
0.28704264760017395,
0.47042983770370483,
0.08006375283002853,
-0.37265267968177795,
0.0857388824224472,
-0.5418692231178284,
0.23106838762760162,
0.25577375292778015,
0.68849778175354,
0.2095402181148529,
0.1043914183974266,
-0.31411585211753845,
-0.5166267156600952,
0.2897658348083496,
0.29689863324165344,
-0.5952925086021423,
-0.09817425161600113,
0.1952390968799591,
-0.053647689521312714,
0.01852777786552906,
0.16158615052700043,
-0.24530889093875885,
-0.1820877194404602,
-0.9168281555175781,
0.583146333694458,
-0.5358486175537109,
-0.4274123013019562,
0.04090264067053795,
-0.3666783273220062,
0.1500987708568573,
0.2511045038700104,
-0.6166977286338806,
0.13978473842144012,
0.7329984903335571,
0.78204345703125,
-0.24219372868537903,
-0.6850805282592773,
-0.5372259616851807,
0.6331495046615601,
-0.4711872637271881,
0.9278243184089661,
-0.3588866889476776,
-0.43121781945228577,
-0.35499536991119385,
-0.3044110834598541,
-0.03667644038796425,
-0.44949495792388916,
0.09627649188041687,
-0.4256885051727295,
0.16910190880298615,
-0.41475871205329895,
-0.6264133453369141,
-0.09047485888004303,
0.054530881345272064,
-0.6545058488845825,
0.4799172282218933,
0.5007323026657104,
-0.11689239740371704,
0.156089186668396,
-0.5878890752792358,
-0.6531734466552734,
0.007824871689081192,
-0.48597127199172974,
-0.38785406947135925,
0.23098455369472504,
0.06873781979084015,
0.2401687204837799,
-0.3110118508338928,
0.22440622746944427,
-0.19023145735263824,
-0.6035186648368835,
0.5243995785713196,
-0.12462673336267471,
0.5050461292266846,
0.43079936504364014,
-0.38106852769851685,
0.3384307026863098,
-0.5987929701805115,
0.08598651736974716,
0.29443424940109253,
-0.26794710755348206,
-0.10862260311841965,
-0.1599191278219223,
0.09439864754676819,
0.38640663027763367,
0.09456317871809006,
-0.08665119111537933,
0.18751493096351624,
-0.20322450995445251,
0.6309372186660767,
0.8471525311470032,
0.03667284920811653,
0.5514101386070251,
-0.972545325756073,
0.8633615970611572,
-0.21375617384910583,
0.13180243968963623,
-0.19901198148727417,
-0.34564992785453796,
-0.05270009487867355,
-0.3761720359325409,
-0.09364426881074905,
0.3323647975921631,
-0.9470958113670349,
0.3823449909687042,
0.010511989705264568,
-0.38811635971069336,
-0.08840512484312057,
0.377363920211792,
0.3020426034927368,
0.1357063502073288,
0.15868297219276428,
-0.41665950417518616,
-0.5513672232627869,
-0.5187616944313049,
-0.1651962846517563,
-0.08894631266593933,
0.07936782389879227,
0.14153610169887543,
0.14075782895088196,
-0.368612140417099,
0.9655629992485046,
-0.42938125133514404,
-0.4927159547805786,
-0.35020965337753296,
0.019317682832479477,
0.171958327293396,
0.4251316785812378,
0.763431191444397,
-0.5882413387298584,
-0.39877521991729736,
-0.28336790204048157,
-0.6799295544624329,
-0.29409489035606384,
-0.21511752903461456,
-0.5648176670074463,
0.04764847457408905,
0.23198255896568298,
-1.0272352695465088,
-0.38361698389053345,
0.35540059208869934,
-0.5394390225410461,
0.6779441833496094,
0.008140954189002514,
0.06973721086978912,
-1.0554771423339844,
-0.2924441695213318,
-0.13368207216262817,
-0.0683634877204895,
-0.6452676057815552,
-0.008206259459257126,
-0.35643354058265686,
-0.01323829498142004,
-0.4688452184200287,
0.26276305317878723,
-0.6002741456031799,
-0.22280101478099823,
-0.6343042254447937,
0.1350160837173462,
0.03135339543223381,
0.467814564704895,
0.10742105543613434,
0.6768288016319275,
0.8214181065559387,
-0.3249931335449219,
0.5136414170265198,
0.08806183189153671,
-0.09204091876745224,
1.047597885131836,
-0.25225117802619934,
0.20714737474918365,
0.0005824516993016005,
0.25074368715286255,
-0.6751942038536072,
-0.40461915731430054,
0.1921629160642624,
-0.24064786732196808,
0.33612751960754395,
0.13818462193012238,
-0.5785703659057617,
-0.18458962440490723,
-0.1501820832490921,
0.5401458144187927,
0.31329846382141113,
-0.26095685362815857,
1.0292426347732544,
0.3595382869243622,
-0.20168255269527435,
0.03193831443786621,
-0.4712735116481781,
0.29392334818840027,
-0.4857304096221924,
-0.8176141977310181,
0.21882319450378418,
-0.33393505215644836,
-0.4966387152671814,
-0.025228317826986313,
-0.3321387469768524,
0.2470274418592453,
0.06483620405197144,
0.26808133721351624,
0.14475524425506592,
-0.17752540111541748,
0.18516260385513306,
0.13458102941513062,
-0.3175016939640045,
0.44553402066230774,
-0.590490996837616,
0.47889527678489685,
-0.21796007454395294,
-0.6502901911735535,
-0.2948918044567108,
0.6040843725204468,
0.8367519974708557,
-0.36438363790512085,
-0.1047002524137497,
0.5192108750343323,
0.011620116420090199,
-0.6157281994819641,
-0.2749878168106079,
-0.525888979434967,
-0.4930519163608551,
-0.014037901535630226,
-0.3755475878715515,
-0.8682894110679626,
0.49709463119506836,
-0.29318511486053467,
0.008211209438741207,
0.2836175560951233,
0.5139042139053345,
-0.08713303506374359,
1.0485626459121704,
0.15499284863471985,
-0.051774606108665466,
0.4553873836994171,
-0.4802286922931671,
-0.3343198001384735,
-0.4195860028266907,
-0.18419189751148224,
-0.17017659544944763,
-0.4032745659351349,
-0.30106109380722046,
-0.29228177666664124,
0.596905529499054,
-0.4076905846595764,
-0.5486232042312622,
0.11729506403207779,
-0.6322929859161377,
0.4865439832210541,
0.7786338329315186,
0.1472177505493164,
0.39987432956695557,
0.05628586187958717,
0.09232070297002792,
0.39256972074508667,
-0.32734861969947815,
-0.2687498927116394,
1.265718936920166,
0.011584182269871235,
0.7369510531425476,
0.4855097830295563,
1.0681902170181274,
0.35944387316703796,
0.20770418643951416,
-0.5359225273132324,
0.600083589553833,
0.23173823952674866,
-0.5366052985191345,
-0.28092828392982483,
-0.47158706188201904,
-0.8022997975349426,
0.3010775148868561,
-0.13518990576267242,
-0.2615159749984741,
-0.10943931341171265,
-0.02464529126882553,
-0.3418252766132355,
-0.09028620272874832,
-0.5928167104721069,
0.6066816449165344,
-0.6257197260856628,
-0.2902556359767914,
-0.053618043661117554,
-0.6370100378990173,
0.405500203371048,
-0.4642913341522217,
0.15539665520191193,
-0.31654542684555054,
-0.143948495388031,
0.3541102111339569,
-0.5097278952598572,
0.789700448513031,
-0.11865407973527908,
-0.465848445892334,
0.7005494832992554,
0.17703385651111603,
0.7051171064376831,
0.25750723481178284,
0.2358560711145401,
-0.04126857593655586,
-0.1685205101966858,
-0.2640177309513092,
-0.728336751461029,
0.716413140296936,
-1.027715802192688,
-0.835365355014801,
-0.22387748956680298,
-0.922234058380127,
-0.40494072437286377,
0.11985013633966446,
0.11073160171508789,
0.27142977714538574,
0.19133029878139496,
-0.17013859748840332,
0.39270514249801636,
0.19756761193275452,
0.3930794596672058,
0.5931738615036011,
-0.23447579145431519,
-0.892802894115448,
1.062253713607788,
-0.06844408810138702,
0.2007090002298355,
0.16671127080917358,
0.17362165451049805,
-0.5046743750572205,
-0.3423348665237427,
-0.45050251483917236,
0.23823432624340057,
-0.6704176664352417,
-0.07816159725189209,
-0.20485122501850128,
0.08761017769575119,
-0.04303703084588051,
-0.23185236752033234,
-0.27354955673217773,
-0.27478599548339844,
-0.31039270758628845,
-0.12572415173053741,
0.3775957524776459,
0.6418530941009521,
-0.19101859629154205,
0.34885114431381226,
-0.7222567796707153,
0.2765548527240753,
0.4406769871711731,
0.15024331212043762,
-0.28809040784835815,
-0.03403677046298981,
-0.19335195422172546,
-0.20715482532978058,
-0.6013752818107605,
-1.040903091430664,
0.08978690207004547,
0.10890758037567139,
0.6983065605163574,
0.44050607085227966,
-0.18865948915481567,
0.41116827726364136,
-0.21853092312812805,
0.5741713643074036,
0.4092662036418915,
-1.1432921886444092,
0.524187445640564,
-0.6869118213653564,
0.2766130864620209,
0.21550819277763367,
-0.09766532480716705,
-0.1981472671031952,
-0.9179409742355347,
-0.49961966276168823,
-0.752546489238739,
0.6902255415916443,
0.4647725820541382,
0.0021471038926392794,
0.03740403428673744,
0.2247694581747055,
0.11214091628789902,
0.2952486276626587,
-0.6778367757797241,
-0.2995537519454956,
-0.5642873644828796,
-0.1273069679737091,
-0.44018399715423584,
0.1806412935256958,
-0.48687243461608887,
-0.15181401371955872,
0.7550272941589355,
-0.23373253643512726,
0.1984277069568634,
0.06460872292518616,
0.28789395093917847,
-0.3681982755661011,
0.31695085763931274,
0.9290816187858582,
0.7929558753967285,
0.24703630805015564,
0.38605836033821106,
-0.26108336448669434,
-0.34976324439048767,
0.7766916751861572,
0.07548851519823074,
-0.12119249999523163,
-0.4095611870288849,
0.5123133063316345,
0.582200288772583,
-0.004580215085297823,
-0.6258226633071899,
0.38321271538734436,
0.04164180904626846,
-0.49670296907424927,
-0.525797426700592,
0.5463466048240662,
0.5080841779708862,
0.5928013920783997,
0.3521845042705536,
0.134004607796669,
0.011501586996018887,
-0.6301932334899902,
0.3662210702896118,
0.3022885322570801,
-0.37091073393821716,
-0.37008920311927795,
0.9414517879486084,
-0.0459112711250782,
0.018961479887366295,
0.4201353192329407,
-0.0589735209941864,
-0.17525489628314972,
0.8825712203979492,
0.8898063898086548,
1.1238539218902588,
-0.21025148034095764,
0.23485642671585083,
-0.19732247292995453,
0.22671425342559814,
-0.1468403935432434,
0.777476966381073,
-0.24031099677085876,
-0.4201268255710602,
-0.7471649646759033,
-0.3061571717262268,
-0.3965229392051697,
-0.15738213062286377,
-0.1654113382101059,
-0.18182359635829926,
-0.30503442883491516,
-0.3577897250652313,
-0.14362861216068268,
-0.1164088025689125,
-0.3004592955112457,
-0.19210019707679749,
-0.056200772523880005,
0.4720412492752075,
-0.8652708530426025,
0.5437214970588684,
0.8888015151023865,
-0.5181591510772705,
-1.151452898979187,
-0.06070477142930031,
0.35660719871520996,
-0.46811917424201965,
0.5973187685012817,
0.1275550127029419,
-0.3405379354953766,
0.2575492262840271,
-0.509497344493866,
-0.8160933256149292,
1.3811877965927124,
0.8783162236213684,
-0.42068299651145935,
0.5322195887565613,
0.33629298210144043,
0.7527483105659485,
-0.5256324410438538,
0.006587159354239702,
0.446575790643692,
1.0480177402496338,
0.397113174200058,
-0.37311622500419617,
0.10893900692462921,
-0.3720334470272064,
-0.13608378171920776,
0.289101243019104,
-0.5971848368644714,
0.9831494688987732,
-0.0764380395412445,
-0.21891146898269653,
0.15238343179225922,
0.6038578748703003,
0.6131245493888855,
0.5803611278533936,
0.407411128282547,
0.5567914843559265,
0.5886790156364441,
-0.37859705090522766,
1.0943695306777954,
-0.5299694538116455,
-0.08203506469726562,
0.8313599228858948,
-0.4646225869655609,
0.09201566129922867,
0.4199889898300171,
-0.18230554461479187,
0.3680618703365326,
0.5829267501831055,
-0.1514180302619934,
0.44498395919799805,
0.5330581068992615,
-0.8252726197242737,
-0.707450807094574,
0.07428912818431854,
-0.3129480183124542,
0.5639709830284119,
0.07597643882036209,
-0.20927105844020844,
0.054635901004076004,
0.17013047635555267,
-0.24639789760112762,
0.08332885801792145,
-0.3176754117012024,
0.9084192514419556,
0.2961384654045105,
-0.9757769703865051,
0.2361355870962143,
-0.29784709215164185,
0.0828780084848404,
-0.6529416441917419,
-0.21885401010513306,
-0.15267029404640198,
-0.009453310631215572,
-0.13818755745887756,
-0.7710691690444946,
0.13344770669937134,
-0.6597672700881958,
-0.1530156284570694,
-0.19462145864963531,
0.7262507081031799,
-0.5892476439476013,
-0.2433447390794754,
0.30580559372901917,
1.0029597282409668,
0.11548775434494019,
-0.5302944779396057,
-0.4587654173374176,
0.023686861619353294,
-0.24374665319919586,
-0.06813546270132065,
0.27333515882492065,
0.4630196690559387,
-0.10200580954551697,
0.6097103357315063,
0.7684362530708313,
0.33188000321388245,
-0.32240620255470276,
0.3524518311023712,
0.7289735674858093,
-0.6783315539360046,
-0.6640191674232483,
-0.9226526618003845,
0.20360668003559113,
0.12882964313030243,
0.14994613826274872,
0.8114171624183655,
0.6129603981971741,
0.7747976183891296,
-0.4155987799167633,
1.0092295408248901,
0.32700610160827637,
-0.07677104324102402,
-0.4896722435951233,
0.6607844233512878,
-0.5787526369094849,
0.5441129803657532,
-0.5047284364700317,
-1.1606152057647705,
-0.36878207325935364,
0.11612087488174438,
0.05033574998378754,
0.31469491124153137,
0.5307963490486145,
0.6511740684509277,
0.014027109369635582,
0.23073862493038177,
0.38237643241882324,
-0.1369202882051468,
0.3330412209033966,
0.807799756526947,
1.4434709548950195,
0.17753300070762634,
0.6332076191902161,
-0.24607205390930176,
-0.09596313536167145,
0.15968550741672516,
-0.6589406728744507,
-0.9199620485305786,
-0.5350052714347839,
-0.21981170773506165,
-0.053580813109874725,
0.0057397764176130295,
1.0264034271240234,
0.6184827089309692,
-0.3994309902191162,
-0.3390619456768036,
-0.21926414966583252,
0.49125224351882935,
-0.7342143654823303,
-0.20510749518871307,
0.46341538429260254,
-0.31752675771713257,
-0.7771623730659485,
0.8279536962509155,
0.6333604454994202,
0.2411002665758133,
-0.4892190098762512,
-0.7132273316383362,
0.455879807472229,
0.18001392483711243,
0.7389563322067261,
0.08246943354606628,
-0.6151991486549377,
-0.1118280366063118,
-0.06339001655578613,
-0.11322972923517227,
-0.00409232173115015,
1.0884497165679932,
-0.33762896060943604,
0.44711026549339294,
0.41831204295158386,
0.3441726267337799,
0.2327549159526825,
0.09546701610088348,
0.6314408183097839,
-0.5947674512863159,
-0.5234405398368835,
0.11595185101032257,
0.42758265137672424,
-0.01715787872672081,
-0.26762479543685913,
0.47853559255599976,
0.5529793500900269,
-0.582705557346344,
-0.2362855225801468,
0.30790722370147705,
-1.3724790811538696,
-0.45379695296287537,
1.092958927154541,
0.05614370107650757,
-0.00008843039540806785,
-0.2711251974105835,
-0.4622618556022644,
0.061573319137096405,
-0.6339943408966064,
0.6159272789955139,
0.4845372438430786,
-0.357761412858963,
-0.13358746469020844,
-0.33617669343948364,
0.3909638524055481,
0.07644414901733398,
-1.0568612813949585,
-0.31024008989334106,
1.008393406867981,
0.22368615865707397,
0.28280988335609436,
0.7331838607788086,
-0.19703170657157898,
0.764007031917572,
0.0550042986869812,
0.314297616481781,
-0.5222845673561096,
-0.4131847023963928,
0.247017964720726,
0.5917258858680725,
0.11087866127490997,
0.16011878848075867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18072v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18072v1
|
Contextual Spelling Correction with Language Model for Low-resource Setting
| 2024-04-28T05:29:35 | 2024-04-28T05:29:35 |
Nishant Luitel, Nirajan Bekoju, Anand Kumar Sah, Subarna Shakya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The task of Spell Correction(SC) in low-resource languages presents a
significant challenge due to the availability of only a limited corpus of data
and no annotated spelling correction datasets. To tackle these challenges a
small-scale word-based transformer LM is trained to provide the SC model with
contextual understanding. Further, the probabilistic error rules are extracted
from the corpus in an unsupervised way to model the tendency of error
happening(error model). Then the combination of LM and error model is used to
develop the SC model through the well-known noisy channel framework. The
effectiveness of this approach is demonstrated through experiments on the
Nepali language where there is access to just an unprocessed corpus of textual
data.
|
[
0.26044175028800964,
-0.734565019607544,
0.1552727222442627,
0.13342714309692383,
-0.1125844344496727,
0.007070084102451801,
-0.5881955027580261,
-0.16798697412014008,
0.2923489809036255,
0.7577300667762756,
-0.6565724015235901,
-0.34442397952079773,
-0.5411339402198792,
0.2661512792110443,
-0.3129022717475891,
0.5863665342330933,
-0.1939108967781067,
0.2891926169395447,
0.13094212114810944,
-0.2344525158405304,
-0.6725983023643494,
-0.3748936951160431,
-0.4980369508266449,
-0.2591288089752197,
0.5042169690132141,
0.919363260269165,
0.615065336227417,
0.41408878564834595,
0.34183964133262634,
0.2594490647315979,
-0.34183740615844727,
0.28471943736076355,
-0.5202519297599792,
-0.008864044211804867,
-0.25072604417800903,
-0.7304102182388306,
-0.32165268063545227,
-0.1695144772529602,
0.7652685642242432,
1.150855541229248,
-0.514633059501648,
0.3323213756084442,
0.23409174382686615,
0.7916126847267151,
-0.8272688984870911,
-0.055420298129320145,
-0.7568902969360352,
-0.07620958983898163,
-0.431828111410141,
-0.18297989666461945,
-0.5850774645805359,
-0.13056407868862152,
0.01255334634333849,
-0.5526189804077148,
0.5918183326721191,
0.22782984375953674,
0.49887239933013916,
0.5059054493904114,
-0.32177284359931946,
-0.19292937219142914,
-1.0118916034698486,
0.852503776550293,
-0.6974363327026367,
0.31517139077186584,
0.7396500110626221,
0.1791452318429947,
-0.17681924998760223,
-0.6243303418159485,
-0.6867870092391968,
0.2812908887863159,
-0.457890123128891,
-0.12444531172513962,
-0.06898494809865952,
0.2990557849407196,
0.2934775948524475,
0.30136433243751526,
-0.26581019163131714,
0.1586586833000183,
-0.6599110960960388,
-0.2783203423023224,
0.24694745242595673,
0.192619189620018,
0.15446819365024567,
-0.47925373911857605,
0.22805172204971313,
0.09505359083414078,
-0.6952451467514038,
-0.12158030271530151,
0.2795311212539673,
0.6580207943916321,
-0.15408955514431,
0.8022997975349426,
-0.45100340247154236,
0.7264124155044556,
0.2592180669307709,
-0.24029594659805298,
0.015173916704952717,
-0.0622188076376915,
-0.4377063512802124,
0.4391170144081116,
0.4381091296672821,
0.07478129118680954,
-0.01244307029992342,
-0.0713917687535286,
-0.1992393136024475,
0.07695280760526657,
0.1914995163679123,
-0.6209835410118103,
-0.24323992431163788,
0.005669990088790655,
-0.44835564494132996,
-0.24754482507705688,
-0.5039172768592834,
-0.7589638829231262,
-0.5908728837966919,
-0.2872127890586853,
0.5025639533996582,
-0.32312747836112976,
-0.11618180572986603,
-0.091675765812397,
0.1689567118883133,
-0.19515880942344666,
0.33445245027542114,
-0.9967535138130188,
0.29376494884490967,
0.04104161635041237,
0.8346685171127319,
-0.021111566573381424,
-0.3337375819683075,
-0.5674143433570862,
0.2079491764307022,
-0.35082200169563293,
0.8839187026023865,
-0.21097548305988312,
-0.4208524823188782,
0.15659987926483154,
0.21127507090568542,
-0.43413493037223816,
-0.647591769695282,
0.43730372190475464,
-0.5250698924064636,
0.276144415140152,
-0.07704690098762512,
-0.42185595631599426,
-0.10129953175783157,
-0.0406845286488533,
-0.8314992785453796,
1.2273602485656738,
0.4201980233192444,
-0.944572389125824,
0.30161651968955994,
-0.7121714353561401,
-0.5273001790046692,
0.3193014860153198,
0.43370506167411804,
-0.07317040860652924,
0.284435898065567,
0.004538075998425484,
0.18167120218276978,
-0.1805819869041443,
0.1521848887205124,
0.16169726848602295,
-0.5725119113922119,
0.147283136844635,
-0.8012016415596008,
0.6473138332366943,
0.010839143767952919,
-0.34039250016212463,
0.19205324351787567,
-1.1220511198043823,
-0.028471989557147026,
-0.006545601412653923,
-0.5665118098258972,
-0.6323050856590271,
0.14541418850421906,
0.293734610080719,
0.23747648298740387,
0.11801362037658691,
-0.45756757259368896,
0.07991152256727219,
-0.6379835605621338,
0.6418166756629944,
0.4994713068008423,
-0.15420037508010864,
0.8879522681236267,
0.015393511392176151,
0.4105760157108307,
0.03579478710889816,
0.16538168489933014,
0.13363394141197205,
-0.1716839075088501,
-1.0190562009811401,
-0.2448340356349945,
0.5896002650260925,
0.699911892414093,
-0.9236932396888733,
0.06961924582719803,
-0.2592061161994934,
-0.4097912013530731,
-0.9095233082771301,
0.5366040468215942,
0.09913574159145355,
0.691156268119812,
0.4104134738445282,
0.04829179495573044,
-0.748540997505188,
-0.647712767124176,
-0.15858232975006104,
0.08177018910646439,
0.14688020944595337,
-0.02737349458038807,
0.34285563230514526,
-0.4104597866535187,
1.0061721801757812,
-0.544440746307373,
-0.6718955039978027,
-0.39310672879219055,
0.23207175731658936,
0.23891852796077728,
0.3023674786090851,
-0.03198690339922905,
-0.7250908017158508,
-0.42001283168792725,
-0.27139416337013245,
-0.46524670720100403,
-0.31077373027801514,
0.3680283725261688,
0.0795762687921524,
0.7243205904960632,
0.5722811818122864,
-0.3338894844055176,
0.7863975167274475,
0.7852569222450256,
-0.11763809621334076,
0.5932011604309082,
-0.6152299046516418,
0.005874352529644966,
-1.0622224807739258,
0.03134883567690849,
-0.23511502146720886,
-0.04606054723262787,
-0.7576596140861511,
-0.30171695351600647,
0.09568116068840027,
-0.030216742306947708,
-0.7597327828407288,
0.5404590964317322,
-0.46289950609207153,
0.20991183817386627,
-0.4781626760959625,
0.10372097790241241,
-0.3316740095615387,
0.43217623233795166,
0.2587302625179291,
0.7635756134986877,
0.08360249549150467,
-0.4358372092247009,
0.14894069731235504,
0.1968367099761963,
-0.3726671636104584,
0.8578914403915405,
-0.42031770944595337,
-0.29329583048820496,
0.015288127586245537,
0.21404947340488434,
-0.8371620178222656,
-0.468448668718338,
0.16053730249404907,
0.08019822835922241,
0.38074180483818054,
-0.18062914907932281,
-0.7807958722114563,
-0.50934237241745,
0.1409076601266861,
0.5059677362442017,
0.4448615610599518,
-0.6466137170791626,
0.35660985112190247,
0.27792245149612427,
0.043065447360277176,
-0.6171420812606812,
-0.609886646270752,
0.025036856532096863,
-0.21762529015541077,
-0.4344893991947174,
0.1853743940591812,
-0.028610924258828163,
-0.13422605395317078,
0.0723310112953186,
0.18435271084308624,
-0.29648271203041077,
-0.12058839201927185,
0.4376623332500458,
0.19581231474876404,
-0.06656908988952637,
0.14322488009929657,
-0.02060212939977646,
-0.08483181148767471,
-0.3328348696231842,
0.10150639712810516,
0.48505574464797974,
0.004472317639738321,
-0.39381927251815796,
-0.3753395676612854,
0.3088018298149109,
0.3708356022834778,
0.11014164984226227,
1.0250874757766724,
0.4683515131473541,
-0.7957537174224854,
-0.379767507314682,
-0.7214934825897217,
-0.2253548949956894,
-0.437669575214386,
0.26997700333595276,
-0.10781601071357727,
-0.8240163922309875,
0.6321795582771301,
-0.3115995228290558,
-0.7081487774848938,
0.5660571455955505,
0.414944589138031,
-0.17753687500953674,
0.9950538873672485,
0.8932661414146423,
0.2008848488330841,
0.3645789325237274,
-0.16946563124656677,
0.474164754152298,
-0.9377932548522949,
-0.02399304136633873,
-0.270393967628479,
-0.3089674413204193,
-0.6698486804962158,
-0.47491201758384705,
0.368133544921875,
0.5996007323265076,
-0.19245406985282898,
0.4070718586444855,
-0.5288407206535339,
0.34960177540779114,
0.9394926428794861,
0.19653241336345673,
0.39148789644241333,
0.1799708753824234,
-0.3965374231338501,
-0.3963060975074768,
-1.2339550256729126,
-0.47561678290367126,
0.7966791391372681,
-0.15131956338882446,
0.7833578586578369,
-0.05540606752038002,
0.37260982394218445,
0.2360605150461197,
0.49053141474723816,
-0.7903640866279602,
0.2782282531261444,
-0.21568483114242554,
-0.8024595975875854,
-0.5607547163963318,
-0.016933923587203026,
-0.731325626373291,
0.10159014910459518,
-0.4953720271587372,
-0.8659087419509888,
0.44426631927490234,
0.3546951711177826,
-0.3505726754665375,
0.6224204897880554,
-0.7052508592605591,
0.938064694404602,
0.16934750974178314,
-0.49297893047332764,
-0.3911421597003937,
-0.6917744278907776,
0.4100462794303894,
-0.37793949246406555,
0.4355940520763397,
0.1125405877828598,
0.36564722657203674,
0.8341310024261475,
-0.9059921503067017,
1.3297874927520752,
-0.03889733925461769,
0.01108329277485609,
0.4907292425632477,
0.0771663710474968,
0.5353599190711975,
-0.36993563175201416,
-0.11866019666194916,
0.36505648493766785,
0.10832054167985916,
-0.3485988974571228,
-0.2442706674337387,
0.5782198309898376,
-0.6551278233528137,
-0.23634716868400574,
-0.5197776556015015,
-0.49778038263320923,
-0.02063027024269104,
0.2651037275791168,
0.6337895393371582,
0.2905315160751343,
-0.33328354358673096,
0.07995776832103729,
0.36381739377975464,
-0.13899165391921997,
0.46413323283195496,
0.785670816898346,
0.22212956845760345,
-0.3624860644340515,
0.7558479309082031,
0.4841333031654358,
0.1248602643609047,
0.2954067587852478,
0.11538689583539963,
-0.17525018751621246,
-0.17913740873336792,
-0.5107660293579102,
0.3062056005001068,
-0.9373576045036316,
-0.22410868108272552,
-0.48927199840545654,
-0.4568658769130707,
-0.13279345631599426,
-0.3219078481197357,
-0.5322927832603455,
-0.26913103461265564,
-0.389424204826355,
0.2640249729156494,
0.4356330931186676,
0.8536139726638794,
-0.37544065713882446,
1.026816964149475,
-0.6267784833908081,
0.11458052694797516,
0.12366759032011032,
0.5686061978340149,
-0.07802196592092514,
-0.6087846159934998,
-0.5453252196311951,
0.24104861915111542,
-0.19191764295101166,
-0.9297528862953186,
0.6412045359611511,
0.1184002161026001,
0.24002526700496674,
0.11128932237625122,
0.09743309020996094,
0.8876357078552246,
-0.8256204128265381,
0.6815083026885986,
0.12123972177505493,
-1.1486396789550781,
0.8300065994262695,
-0.18001395463943481,
0.06692036241292953,
0.5121326446533203,
-0.08008429408073425,
-1.028719425201416,
-0.05234605446457863,
-0.7658954858779907,
-0.8820085525512695,
0.9637407660484314,
-0.11812080442905426,
-0.23948746919631958,
-0.12380556017160416,
0.3917207419872284,
0.007523868232965469,
0.2502076029777527,
-0.43703287839889526,
-0.19368867576122284,
-0.03886912390589714,
-0.30524179339408875,
-0.26001566648483276,
-0.6379603743553162,
-0.04840897023677826,
-0.2815912067890167,
0.9945970177650452,
-0.27948930859565735,
-0.0244576558470726,
0.0771879255771637,
-0.5595688819885254,
-0.642278790473938,
0.5350366830825806,
0.9087582230567932,
0.5945841670036316,
-0.20798234641551971,
0.18399225175380707,
0.7075507640838623,
-0.5425735712051392,
0.18818075954914093,
-0.16582649946212769,
-0.36373820900917053,
0.12367091327905655,
0.44578659534454346,
0.6751065850257874,
0.770209789276123,
-0.5883297324180603,
0.6391107439994812,
0.06682460755109787,
-0.10232698917388916,
-0.40278926491737366,
-0.34674927592277527,
0.2218894213438034,
-0.06434012949466705,
0.3825991153717041,
0.337464302778244,
-0.10287133604288101,
-0.10096915811300278,
-0.22650808095932007,
0.2349928915500641,
-0.4453146159648895,
-0.2763928472995758,
0.7546902298927307,
0.09881346672773361,
-0.44352835416793823,
0.6604357361793518,
-0.1922757774591446,
-0.5313119292259216,
0.22930167615413666,
0.7891886234283447,
0.4722629189491272,
-0.520763099193573,
0.28819841146469116,
0.30901584029197693,
0.4252004623413086,
-0.6106019020080566,
0.14761121571063995,
0.24838589131832123,
-0.7101995944976807,
-0.5940986275672913,
-0.7940670251846313,
-0.530963122844696,
0.26838210225105286,
-0.5983864068984985,
0.4946284890174866,
-0.17127496004104614,
0.08227140456438065,
-0.3391167223453522,
-0.12256937474012375,
-0.9179731607437134,
0.3880416452884674,
-0.1358155757188797,
0.7238768339157104,
-1.0127408504486084,
0.8457211852073669,
0.6783178448677063,
-0.308867871761322,
-0.9770260453224182,
-0.32538002729415894,
0.0056270756758749485,
-0.9827523231506348,
0.9754477739334106,
-0.09077024459838867,
-0.1670549213886261,
0.06790542602539062,
-0.39000052213668823,
-0.9379456043243408,
1.0373190641403198,
0.25621771812438965,
-0.7018246054649353,
0.03485940024256706,
0.2663205564022064,
0.7391991019248962,
-0.22190840542316437,
0.055246736854314804,
0.46777358651161194,
0.4165142774581909,
0.12670882046222687,
-1.0696243047714233,
-0.12343928962945938,
0.033492349088191986,
0.0946698933839798,
0.08834239840507507,
-0.42132487893104553,
0.6463799476623535,
-0.2727191150188446,
-0.33088335394859314,
0.02653450332581997,
0.65249103307724,
-0.1495169848203659,
0.12143190205097198,
0.5568603277206421,
0.43257561326026917,
0.9232160449028015,
0.01097603514790535,
0.7063205242156982,
-0.6019366383552551,
0.2319423258304596,
1.1988308429718018,
-0.3083708584308624,
1.2576271295547485,
0.6269830465316772,
-0.06972351670265198,
0.5528444051742554,
0.6986736059188843,
0.43247154355049133,
0.5210592746734619,
0.22381149232387543,
-0.2425106018781662,
-0.16366076469421387,
-0.30948102474212646,
0.06024499610066414,
0.6157257556915283,
0.4781251847743988,
-0.2015140950679779,
-0.22088618576526642,
0.29032859206199646,
-0.17604169249534607,
0.324115514755249,
-0.5512326955795288,
0.6432710886001587,
-0.04132882505655289,
-0.3904988765716553,
0.5529138445854187,
0.2891690731048584,
0.9528768062591553,
-0.2894444763660431,
0.10504612326622009,
-0.17231841385364532,
0.4973530173301697,
-0.32397276163101196,
-0.2616839110851288,
0.5540308952331543,
0.013181694783270359,
-0.6497612595558167,
-0.07737047970294952,
0.94805508852005,
-0.6864079236984253,
-0.7247938513755798,
0.25020280480384827,
0.5946382284164429,
0.048147231340408325,
-0.09836037456989288,
-0.2619425356388092,
-0.10733305662870407,
-0.4453696608543396,
0.16533178091049194,
0.1283915638923645,
0.353510320186615,
-0.3868609070777893,
0.4876043200492859,
0.5010377168655396,
0.5409629344940186,
0.1855391412973404,
0.28363361954689026,
0.45683059096336365,
-0.4797951877117157,
-0.5662789344787598,
-0.669654905796051,
0.28880950808525085,
0.0715496614575386,
-0.056408192962408066,
0.711101233959198,
0.3555763363838196,
0.7231650948524475,
-0.23070408403873444,
0.7825061678886414,
0.16108441352844238,
0.6997731328010559,
-0.2576051354408264,
0.7511594891548157,
-0.42082205414772034,
0.15898992121219635,
-0.08217566460371017,
-0.9742598533630371,
-0.375451922416687,
0.6517065167427063,
-0.4194432199001312,
-0.26503005623817444,
1.006813645362854,
0.9326468110084534,
-0.05446675419807434,
0.09122861176729202,
0.30766162276268005,
0.25914403796195984,
-0.3459185063838959,
0.3558765649795532,
0.5716982483863831,
-0.6163583397865295,
0.36222711205482483,
-0.5110490322113037,
-0.27524498105049133,
-0.5624420046806335,
-0.8959417343139648,
-0.8258545398712158,
-0.7356165647506714,
-0.28438934683799744,
-0.6127224564552307,
0.0029786028899252415,
1.1045676469802856,
0.6610893607139587,
-0.8840160369873047,
-0.1991075873374939,
0.06936577707529068,
0.22897912561893463,
-0.38677161931991577,
-0.2698971927165985,
0.6569990515708923,
-0.1616525948047638,
-0.716109037399292,
0.3931117653846741,
0.16932106018066406,
-0.05428988113999367,
-0.21777014434337616,
-0.045689500868320465,
-0.28464215993881226,
0.110055111348629,
0.6157737970352173,
0.26392748951911926,
-0.763828456401825,
-0.438198983669281,
-0.007833926938474178,
-0.36618882417678833,
0.0444326251745224,
0.7040484547615051,
-0.6252992749214172,
0.41372936964035034,
0.3612500727176666,
0.23072846233844757,
0.29256314039230347,
-0.3195730447769165,
0.3526044189929962,
-1.0113505125045776,
0.29302167892456055,
-0.32142093777656555,
0.43739956617355347,
0.759548008441925,
-0.6705713868141174,
0.5171828866004944,
0.5953625440597534,
-0.4567593038082123,
-0.791700541973114,
-0.040667884051799774,
-0.8587399125099182,
-0.045294810086488724,
1.2742515802383423,
0.3267999291419983,
-0.5955531597137451,
-0.021950077265501022,
-0.4249970614910126,
0.5859132409095764,
0.03439784795045853,
0.7674896717071533,
0.8759512901306152,
0.15956807136535645,
0.022931963205337524,
-0.671783447265625,
0.7335760593414307,
0.26270949840545654,
-0.29363563656806946,
0.12075167149305344,
0.3766631782054901,
0.5980634689331055,
0.2066282480955124,
0.8103575110435486,
0.1874968558549881,
0.06453549116849899,
-0.05706968903541565,
0.4065381586551666,
0.2516317069530487,
-0.08020827174186707,
-0.5266782641410828,
0.16829481720924377,
-0.00855506956577301,
0.0628090500831604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18071v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18071v1
|
Can Perplexity Predict Fine-Tuning Performance? An Investigation of Tokenization Effects on Sequential Language Models for Nepali
| 2024-04-28T05:26:12 | 2024-04-28T05:26:12 |
Nishant Luitel, Nirajan Bekoju, Anand Kumar Sah, Subarna Shakya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent language models use subwording mechanisms to handle
Out-of-Vocabulary(OOV) words seen during test time and, their generation
capacity is generally measured using perplexity, an intrinsic metric. It is
known that increasing the subword granularity results in a decrease of
perplexity value. However, the study of how subwording affects the
understanding capacity of language models has been very few and only limited to
a handful of languages. To reduce this gap we used 6 different tokenization
schemes to pretrain relatively small language models in Nepali and used the
representations learned to finetune on several downstream tasks. Although
byte-level BPE algorithm has been used in recent models like GPT, RoBERTa we
show that on average they are sub-optimal in comparison to algorithms such as
SentencePiece in finetuning performances for Nepali. Additionally, similar
recent studies have focused on the Bert-based language model. We, however,
pretrain and finetune sequential transformer-based language models.
|
[
-0.3151179552078247,
-0.7673208117485046,
0.04791394993662834,
0.3703210949897766,
-0.6506438851356506,
-0.07126246392726898,
0.026392387226223946,
-0.3492434024810791,
-0.21614274382591248,
0.3234281837940216,
-0.4550718367099762,
-0.08822894096374512,
-0.6273267865180969,
0.20284834504127502,
-0.5012919306755066,
1.0881097316741943,
0.06516850739717484,
0.21840670704841614,
0.08209220319986343,
-0.08522091805934906,
-0.6125918626785278,
-0.6659008860588074,
-0.4057500958442688,
-0.5748075842857361,
0.3921869695186615,
0.41546767950057983,
0.5773423910140991,
0.4173494577407837,
0.5403316617012024,
0.33816078305244446,
-0.32900986075401306,
-0.265756756067276,
-0.7458840012550354,
-0.08107508718967438,
-0.3223726451396942,
-0.7733854651451111,
-0.2570202052593231,
-0.031040336936712265,
0.8394641876220703,
0.9881309270858765,
-0.13713498413562775,
0.07506036013364792,
-0.07304877787828445,
0.6107571721076965,
-0.37791839241981506,
-0.277545303106308,
-1.0295790433883667,
0.08126415312290192,
-0.32857179641723633,
-0.12238027155399323,
0.025991031900048256,
-0.047740139067173004,
0.2944156229496002,
-0.5159541964530945,
0.2814103066921234,
0.2862561047077179,
0.8648638129234314,
0.4547463357448578,
-0.030553769320249557,
0.014815662056207657,
-0.5820894837379456,
0.7536658644676208,
-0.7958834767341614,
0.17174451053142548,
0.3437689244747162,
0.1894179880619049,
-0.1625247299671173,
-0.5934996604919434,
-0.8778958916664124,
-0.03406285494565964,
-0.18310460448265076,
-0.06682975590229034,
-0.056593094021081924,
0.08732369542121887,
0.40298694372177124,
0.642968475818634,
-0.46975672245025635,
0.5344208478927612,
-0.38314250111579895,
-0.02288985811173916,
0.3531196117401123,
0.43734002113342285,
0.0761353075504303,
-0.3540813624858856,
-0.35160332918167114,
0.11874137073755264,
-0.9063258171081543,
0.24032936990261078,
0.7395108938217163,
0.2317274659872055,
-0.014943105168640614,
0.6667936444282532,
-0.29008913040161133,
0.5624569654464722,
0.2750791013240814,
0.3225986659526825,
0.06912625581026077,
-0.6497821807861328,
-0.3581058084964752,
0.058133091777563095,
0.5311672687530518,
-0.2642708718776703,
0.3815585970878601,
-0.26308947801589966,
-0.26495829224586487,
-0.05029483512043953,
0.21957124769687653,
-0.7580577731132507,
-0.2820758819580078,
0.23952962458133698,
-0.4068586230278015,
-0.30988040566444397,
0.005714715924113989,
-0.2299482524394989,
-0.49012911319732666,
-0.1950005143880844,
0.24037468433380127,
-0.6064502596855164,
-0.36037933826446533,
0.2003079503774643,
-0.15184414386749268,
0.27071213722229004,
0.12390927225351334,
-0.9900327324867249,
0.38340631127357483,
0.6932480335235596,
0.6696387529373169,
-0.3127400279045105,
-0.7064757347106934,
-0.5408172011375427,
-0.1321294605731964,
-0.33123964071273804,
0.7725036144256592,
-0.6826781034469604,
-0.40122976899147034,
-0.0973467156291008,
-0.24300765991210938,
-0.14028210937976837,
-0.7356472611427307,
0.118901826441288,
-0.5882735848426819,
-0.10514865070581436,
-0.05493296682834625,
-0.48235565423965454,
0.036730606108903885,
0.011130486615002155,
-0.44123873114585876,
0.6207413673400879,
0.2115391343832016,
-0.9451282620429993,
0.6597679853439331,
-0.4906623661518097,
-0.6223997473716736,
0.08406039327383041,
-0.15377476811408997,
-0.14040203392505646,
0.7055418491363525,
-0.06271940469741821,
0.3939287066459656,
-0.2544112503528595,
0.28431856632232666,
0.06597061455249786,
-0.7183333039283752,
0.2392653226852417,
-0.2769014835357666,
0.35515958070755005,
0.09775277972221375,
-0.3282376825809479,
0.45186758041381836,
-0.8328719735145569,
-0.1698598861694336,
-0.06921108067035675,
-0.5052443742752075,
-0.22606395184993744,
0.04655350744724274,
0.07254517823457718,
0.21235300600528717,
0.1655532568693161,
-0.5022728443145752,
0.15280365943908691,
-0.9082147479057312,
0.4648653268814087,
0.8628762364387512,
-0.31940391659736633,
0.4083196520805359,
-0.19656626880168915,
0.5933023691177368,
0.6635737419128418,
0.02492618001997471,
-0.15674012899398804,
-0.3787826895713806,
-0.8126298189163208,
-0.04081514850258827,
0.7433856725692749,
0.6602688431739807,
-0.41370370984077454,
0.3590870797634125,
-0.37017619609832764,
-0.18691961467266083,
-0.6488438844680786,
-0.02286691777408123,
0.5605799555778503,
0.1905791014432907,
0.2749684751033783,
-0.7596146464347839,
-0.4195452034473419,
-0.9867501854896545,
-0.5908485054969788,
0.012885717675089836,
0.08595005422830582,
0.28483834862709045,
0.5663195252418518,
-0.06208813562989235,
0.8824101090431213,
-0.28446030616760254,
-0.26626697182655334,
-0.30990472435951233,
0.5979388952255249,
0.19540457427501678,
0.8308330178260803,
0.29113131761550903,
-0.9251142740249634,
-0.40633440017700195,
0.15554887056350708,
-0.2867206335067749,
0.11967454105615616,
0.0006867569754831493,
0.2630442678928375,
0.6822537183761597,
0.5746207237243652,
-0.2511897683143616,
0.6166722774505615,
0.4504523277282715,
-0.10460053384304047,
0.782271146774292,
-0.29449447989463806,
-0.19214580953121185,
-0.6141331195831299,
0.15416274964809418,
-0.41075190901756287,
-0.037030067294836044,
-0.5355308055877686,
-0.039439212530851364,
-0.3337373733520508,
0.030258623883128166,
-0.32758086919784546,
0.45579177141189575,
-0.3913871645927429,
0.006066043861210346,
-0.1686805933713913,
-0.024566680192947388,
-0.5365262031555176,
0.37846747040748596,
0.0570974238216877,
0.9042565822601318,
0.6597275733947754,
-0.3378707468509674,
-0.2090103179216385,
0.1439765840768814,
-0.7205237746238708,
0.2602982819080353,
-0.9353968501091003,
0.059070419520139694,
-0.17484843730926514,
-0.03257676213979721,
-1.204298496246338,
-0.20646296441555023,
-0.26925089955329895,
-0.3985653817653656,
0.4901566803455353,
-0.07907123118638992,
-0.6637852191925049,
-0.0007494076271541417,
-0.09875915199518204,
0.7599504590034485,
0.5948487520217896,
-0.1668158918619156,
0.2161228060722351,
0.1822308599948883,
-0.12452791631221771,
-0.531722366809845,
-0.7151737213134766,
-0.08297718316316605,
-0.12540973722934723,
-0.5806952714920044,
0.17769667506217957,
-0.11265522241592407,
0.003200761741027236,
-0.16227208077907562,
-0.217979297041893,
0.019399398937821388,
0.15480320155620575,
0.1659965217113495,
-0.3359624445438385,
-0.22215861082077026,
0.17686665058135986,
0.09414772689342499,
-0.16588039696216583,
-0.2416568547487259,
-0.3299752473831177,
0.9420990347862244,
-0.3230864703655243,
-0.17716337740421295,
-0.4440726935863495,
0.5135160684585571,
0.35910892486572266,
-0.365181565284729,
0.9734060764312744,
0.6451180577278137,
-0.1870054453611374,
0.0384269580245018,
-0.684333860874176,
-0.18465358018875122,
-0.45307600498199463,
0.49077901244163513,
-0.7607581615447998,
-1.0164828300476074,
0.8672441244125366,
-0.40273258090019226,
-0.43124207854270935,
0.4427160620689392,
0.35300618410110474,
0.15010230243206024,
1.1025876998901367,
0.9580246210098267,
-0.04017005115747452,
0.6844788193702698,
-0.3643622398376465,
0.38931766152381897,
-0.9111490249633789,
-0.049277182668447495,
-0.44919395446777344,
-0.36165300011634827,
-0.9266366362571716,
-0.135528564453125,
0.19054332375526428,
0.5286215543746948,
-0.36889949440956116,
-0.0005688102683052421,
-0.23069262504577637,
0.5014266967773438,
0.44906380772590637,
-0.1913021206855774,
0.21223556995391846,
0.1433330774307251,
-0.4980521500110626,
0.017416879534721375,
-1.1021735668182373,
-0.373408704996109,
0.8860042095184326,
0.053809069097042084,
0.4443032741546631,
-0.06720972806215286,
0.564194917678833,
-0.18454758822917938,
0.07308389991521835,
-0.5657914876937866,
0.3368619382381439,
-0.46228718757629395,
-0.7032028436660767,
-0.5362685322761536,
-0.36327341198921204,
-1.0714311599731445,
0.28900209069252014,
-0.22165921330451965,
-0.838128924369812,
0.3319764733314514,
-0.04797998443245888,
-0.2999029755592346,
0.08993755280971527,
-0.6503015160560608,
0.9505627155303955,
0.0940438061952591,
-0.14111199975013733,
-0.5808930993080139,
-0.87909996509552,
0.30334314703941345,
-0.30963125824928284,
0.01092781126499176,
0.190458744764328,
-0.06232564151287079,
0.5863195657730103,
-0.49925246834754944,
0.8901076912879944,
0.041899897158145905,
0.08978330343961716,
-0.03413776308298111,
-0.07647085934877396,
0.5170365571975708,
-0.051299694925546646,
-0.3212606608867645,
0.3131616711616516,
0.025377538055181503,
-0.7408884167671204,
-0.3898887038230896,
0.821416974067688,
-0.8384526968002319,
-0.8900468349456787,
-0.3455594480037689,
-0.5868850946426392,
-0.24600329995155334,
0.4562583565711975,
0.557778537273407,
0.47913384437561035,
-0.033200524747371674,
0.10992922633886337,
0.5337746143341064,
-0.19180084764957428,
0.2996700406074524,
0.4981345534324646,
0.04994725063443184,
-0.21201886236667633,
0.9988228678703308,
0.5519134402275085,
0.37166908383369446,
0.2619900703430176,
0.4594200849533081,
-0.01100815087556839,
-1.2209348678588867,
-0.19849982857704163,
0.24536027014255524,
-0.4932355284690857,
0.16293606162071228,
-0.33135637640953064,
0.05324219539761543,
-0.439019113779068,
0.003005833365023136,
-0.134132519364357,
-0.6255086660385132,
-0.2525050938129425,
0.15466511249542236,
0.0398932546377182,
1.0546114444732666,
0.06545364111661911,
0.5703588724136353,
-0.5793288350105286,
0.10972543805837631,
0.11457119137048721,
0.650526762008667,
0.16417992115020752,
-0.7661874890327454,
-0.2834010124206543,
-0.1586744338274002,
-0.166375070810318,
-0.46223652362823486,
0.0845944732427597,
0.1284456104040146,
0.3773094415664673,
0.20881427824497223,
-0.09574367851018906,
0.9484288096427917,
-0.7134573459625244,
0.9964274168014526,
0.21528807282447815,
-1.1736475229263306,
0.45350128412246704,
-0.5116432905197144,
0.4675722122192383,
0.5292077660560608,
0.4468761682510376,
-0.3030852973461151,
-0.39892321825027466,
-0.8207072019577026,
-1.0582497119903564,
0.8306851983070374,
0.15439735352993011,
0.11398432403802872,
0.07839667052030563,
0.5061543583869934,
0.4719262719154358,
0.5651077628135681,
-0.2985680401325226,
-0.15940514206886292,
-0.2770851254463196,
0.15499995648860931,
-0.2852530777454376,
-0.29187488555908203,
0.07852092385292053,
-0.548000156879425,
0.39520367980003357,
-0.10338696837425232,
0.045132625848054886,
0.27438509464263916,
-0.060866352170705795,
-0.24365724623203278,
0.23487251996994019,
0.8509278297424316,
0.7844657897949219,
0.007679311092942953,
-0.14684027433395386,
0.39208704233169556,
-0.43416696786880493,
-0.19977979362010956,
0.008042654022574425,
0.06988756358623505,
-0.25386589765548706,
0.39121344685554504,
0.9116755127906799,
0.20042455196380615,
-0.5293075442314148,
0.38401153683662415,
0.08486595749855042,
0.03221258148550987,
-0.19146490097045898,
0.04078729450702667,
-0.05375433340668678,
0.19589880108833313,
0.2451561689376831,
0.2980594336986542,
0.09645076841115952,
-0.6444202661514282,
-0.16306665539741516,
0.4571705758571625,
-0.3003523349761963,
-0.5001577138900757,
0.576521635055542,
0.03581871837377548,
-0.37976980209350586,
0.73902428150177,
-0.17356693744659424,
-0.5911406874656677,
0.5870927572250366,
0.6091855764389038,
0.6709368824958801,
-0.15951862931251526,
-0.2592485845088959,
0.07328224927186966,
0.21923814713954926,
-0.010323860682547092,
0.4131280183792114,
-0.05943255126476288,
-0.6048070192337036,
-0.4561009407043457,
-0.855640709400177,
-0.11896073073148727,
0.2274191826581955,
-0.46532365679740906,
0.03670627251267433,
-0.4261655807495117,
-0.023282507434487343,
0.05158501863479614,
0.21249538660049438,
-0.6912780404090881,
0.2701599597930908,
-0.32731881737709045,
0.9457218647003174,
-0.6176795363426208,
1.05294668674469,
0.8988317251205444,
-0.629450798034668,
-0.8895485401153564,
0.1508622169494629,
-0.519910454750061,
-0.6583787798881531,
0.9942376017570496,
0.014681301079690456,
-0.2549605071544647,
0.14150464534759521,
-0.42604291439056396,
-0.6683648228645325,
0.6635996699333191,
0.3074449598789215,
-0.40075480937957764,
0.05247585102915764,
0.30594608187675476,
0.7864255905151367,
-0.35166504979133606,
0.04906211048364639,
0.8044509291648865,
0.4757831394672394,
-0.06658667325973511,
-1.2084733247756958,
0.0489269383251667,
-0.32352063059806824,
0.25303131341934204,
0.23450912535190582,
-0.6001607775688171,
1.086067795753479,
-0.175252303481102,
-0.3118895888328552,
0.4490131139755249,
0.4374673664569855,
-0.11275980621576309,
0.025329232215881348,
0.5256154537200928,
0.46869784593582153,
0.7255340218544006,
0.002357427030801773,
1.293589472770691,
-0.27103012800216675,
0.1172168180346489,
0.8287846446037292,
-0.10161681473255157,
1.0105036497116089,
0.7263986468315125,
-0.23443661630153656,
0.576484739780426,
0.5254625082015991,
0.38309982419013977,
0.45406168699264526,
0.7605801820755005,
0.21438926458358765,
-0.44536370038986206,
-0.1352442055940628,
-0.3819827437400818,
0.40289562940597534,
0.24864257872104645,
0.0009120461181737483,
0.041416238993406296,
-0.03781764954328537,
-0.3462439179420471,
0.040357451885938644,
-0.3240748643875122,
0.8649001121520996,
0.07037223875522614,
-0.7836146950721741,
1.0833454132080078,
-0.12806375324726105,
0.8002734184265137,
-0.5539160370826721,
0.14024336636066437,
-0.35246461629867554,
0.3062431216239929,
-0.40445733070373535,
-0.5143459439277649,
0.3936476409435272,
-0.29266172647476196,
-0.30002403259277344,
0.035405952483415604,
0.5761414170265198,
-0.36710041761398315,
-0.3255119025707245,
0.022826973348855972,
0.4041139483451843,
0.417007714509964,
-0.1578398495912552,
-0.37751504778862,
-0.13170921802520752,
-0.44836726784706116,
-0.18379713594913483,
0.6590853929519653,
0.6559354066848755,
-0.2670498490333557,
0.48268845677375793,
0.5978735089302063,
0.3288313150405884,
0.38945138454437256,
0.20270738005638123,
0.9503487944602966,
-0.5160458087921143,
-0.5126781463623047,
-0.7303378582000732,
0.5233653783798218,
0.010626419447362423,
-0.6823961734771729,
0.6727762818336487,
0.4759151041507721,
1.0286246538162231,
-0.24338658154010773,
0.6281757354736328,
0.18858179450035095,
0.2673073709011078,
-0.4158797264099121,
0.7056792378425598,
-0.7819117903709412,
0.2089821696281433,
-0.18972747027873993,
-0.5261726379394531,
-0.3960844576358795,
0.5597412586212158,
-0.588434100151062,
-0.0057882885448634624,
0.8684214353561401,
0.7120550870895386,
-0.09468885511159897,
0.16239096224308014,
0.4055774509906769,
0.4460088312625885,
-0.03788946941494942,
0.30620312690734863,
0.8213780522346497,
-0.43533357977867126,
0.2798542380332947,
-0.0743815079331398,
-0.24763333797454834,
-0.2544039785861969,
-0.8513867855072021,
-1.0341229438781738,
-0.7360169887542725,
-0.004439636133611202,
0.1137755885720253,
0.0858532190322876,
0.556726336479187,
0.6320762038230896,
-0.9861566424369812,
-0.3058951199054718,
-0.5830014944076538,
0.2701515257358551,
-0.3034113943576813,
-0.1289306879043579,
0.2982651889324188,
-0.7221291065216064,
-0.589080810546875,
0.1339481621980667,
0.10543779283761978,
0.03630858287215233,
-0.41984936594963074,
0.13184571266174316,
-0.257127970457077,
0.32961222529411316,
0.5754204392433167,
0.04259335994720459,
-0.7795385718345642,
-0.3180720806121826,
-0.09138020873069763,
0.22219790518283844,
0.10813271254301071,
1.185410499572754,
-0.8827151656150818,
0.32602643966674805,
0.8259013891220093,
0.4102703928947449,
0.37658706307411194,
0.13433098793029785,
0.5954588055610657,
-0.7147529125213623,
0.321972519159317,
0.10870612412691116,
0.20290517807006836,
0.20138007402420044,
-0.33710169792175293,
0.2611374258995056,
0.23529094457626343,
-0.5388967394828796,
-1.0280078649520874,
0.5611097812652588,
-0.670432448387146,
-0.4185468554496765,
0.9978033304214478,
-0.1464998722076416,
-0.19364124536514282,
-0.3910840153694153,
-0.25819629430770874,
0.23975008726119995,
-0.09660742431879044,
0.7492667436599731,
0.8207151293754578,
-0.2125597894191742,
0.30600786209106445,
-0.2538107633590698,
0.5719385743141174,
0.9162216782569885,
-0.30462267994880676,
0.15948759019374847,
-0.022420959547162056,
0.28451067209243774,
0.22506456077098846,
0.48934227228164673,
0.033600546419620514,
0.27728286385536194,
0.05868925899267197,
-0.43509119749069214,
-0.11696191132068634,
-0.32140934467315674,
-0.7392365336418152,
0.2596137821674347,
0.312080055475235,
0.09509792923927307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18057v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18057v1
|
Efficient LLM Inference with Kcache
| 2024-04-28T03:11:42 | 2024-04-28T03:11:42 |
Qiaozhi He, Zhihua Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models(LLMs) have had a profound impact on AI applications,
particularly in the domains of long-text comprehension and generation. KV Cache
technology is one of the most widely used techniques in the industry. It
ensures efficient sequence generation by caching previously computed KV states.
However, it also introduces significant memory overhead. We discovered that KV
Cache is not necessary and proposed a novel KCache technique to alleviate the
memory bottleneck issue during the LLMs inference process. KCache can be used
directly for inference without any training process, Our evaluations show that
KCache improves the throughput of popular LLMs by 40% with the baseline, while
keeping accuracy.
|
[
-0.15598267316818237,
-0.6056920886039734,
0.7855838537216187,
0.29214686155319214,
-0.446072518825531,
0.10873536765575409,
-0.3523384630680084,
-0.6270850896835327,
0.09977475553750992,
0.6586880683898926,
-0.5314311981201172,
-0.6841527819633484,
-0.30499267578125,
-0.3470798134803772,
-0.3742384612560272,
0.3384929299354553,
-0.02728157676756382,
0.3379126787185669,
-0.42676839232444763,
-0.005117781460285187,
-0.5613086223602295,
-0.41050267219543457,
-0.4637985825538635,
-0.5327529907226562,
0.4645307958126068,
0.6615156531333923,
0.2702675759792328,
0.5272877216339111,
0.34634798765182495,
0.3372313678264618,
0.04977142810821533,
0.2573640048503876,
-0.5853591561317444,
0.7150695323944092,
0.2112123668193817,
-0.9503397941589355,
-0.1779412180185318,
-0.4756878912448883,
0.485351026058197,
0.5883928537368774,
-0.26560667157173157,
-0.18621505796909332,
-0.39925700426101685,
1.0010451078414917,
-1.1721720695495605,
0.06483069807291031,
-0.82084059715271,
0.14017708599567413,
-0.19558601081371307,
-0.1318318396806717,
-0.7953311800956726,
-0.3885378837585449,
0.33192288875579834,
-0.6161884069442749,
0.03847691789269447,
-0.218081533908844,
0.47662392258644104,
0.43308794498443604,
-0.3477044403553009,
-0.36500534415245056,
-0.9081067442893982,
0.9744700193405151,
-0.7780187726020813,
0.6773980855941772,
0.4400597810745239,
0.5262508392333984,
-0.3456904888153076,
-1.1182072162628174,
-0.6745443344116211,
-0.343852162361145,
0.2913932502269745,
0.3177710175514221,
-0.006124521605670452,
0.3232725262641907,
0.10981136560440063,
0.1421271562576294,
-0.2585039436817169,
0.4722190201282501,
-0.13484126329421997,
-0.2789515554904938,
0.26796457171440125,
0.3493265211582184,
0.007230423390865326,
-0.12273545563220978,
-0.1816849559545517,
-0.2322295904159546,
-0.7125951051712036,
-0.17734311521053314,
0.2329554557800293,
0.04560038819909096,
0.27307841181755066,
0.45956239104270935,
-0.4316204786300659,
0.5522001385688782,
-0.1719784140586853,
-0.3429051637649536,
0.06919793784618378,
-0.08552215993404388,
-0.45324835181236267,
0.22781150043010712,
0.3424948751926422,
0.2557855248451233,
0.39210498332977295,
-0.40145617723464966,
0.03396487236022949,
0.26527318358421326,
0.43296700716018677,
-0.9700242877006531,
-0.2963210344314575,
0.18705900013446808,
-0.3399214744567871,
-0.19814471900463104,
-0.22605811059474945,
-1.0130305290222168,
-0.2981000542640686,
-0.16269703209400177,
0.0706353634595871,
-0.3409598171710968,
0.12412862479686737,
-0.029266010969877243,
-0.13765685260295868,
0.44087332487106323,
0.5566113591194153,
-0.6547322273254395,
0.2705143988132477,
0.5073941349983215,
0.7255029678344727,
-0.28018897771835327,
0.017323244363069534,
-0.38545310497283936,
0.28929847478866577,
-0.5308659672737122,
0.9341601133346558,
-0.6111873984336853,
-0.4954865574836731,
-0.07358863949775696,
-0.24665285646915436,
0.19837069511413574,
-0.658684253692627,
0.3348436951637268,
-1.1259191036224365,
-0.4995177388191223,
-0.4369756877422333,
-0.803834080696106,
-0.24177028238773346,
-0.10368028283119202,
-0.8419668674468994,
0.8980897665023804,
-0.13043785095214844,
-0.2796737551689148,
0.3881295621395111,
-0.24348412454128265,
-0.5820266604423523,
0.012245317921042442,
-0.16007176041603088,
-0.4502212405204773,
0.1534070372581482,
0.2782651484012604,
0.36539673805236816,
-0.4587424695491791,
0.16418057680130005,
-0.3977395296096802,
-0.4234706163406372,
0.050218064337968826,
-0.446872740983963,
0.44329339265823364,
0.2956521213054657,
-0.2948513627052307,
-0.2408776432275772,
-0.644196629524231,
0.28799304366111755,
0.021595017984509468,
-0.48725607991218567,
-0.3632178008556366,
0.20997057855129242,
-0.2617492377758026,
-0.1444651335477829,
0.09806599467992783,
-0.2425740659236908,
0.22565008699893951,
-0.21477489173412323,
0.45455196499824524,
0.860106348991394,
-0.03302949294447899,
0.489811509847641,
-0.013026503846049309,
0.6164325475692749,
0.09399212151765823,
-0.25026512145996094,
-0.1619221568107605,
-0.3632589280605316,
-0.9708825945854187,
-0.6207013130187988,
0.5139354467391968,
0.5418255925178528,
-0.7456364035606384,
0.20799313485622406,
-0.248310387134552,
-0.6986802816390991,
-0.6231926083564758,
0.30245867371559143,
0.37327688932418823,
0.39662259817123413,
0.170322984457016,
-0.2465229481458664,
-0.5669980645179749,
-0.9482466578483582,
-0.10169229656457901,
-0.08684834837913513,
0.167863667011261,
0.6460358500480652,
0.2750767767429352,
-0.09746214747428894,
0.7497358322143555,
-0.6212983727455139,
0.3733923137187958,
-0.1256069391965866,
0.22174030542373657,
-0.10400357097387314,
0.38395681977272034,
0.27727094292640686,
-0.6492812037467957,
-0.5812037587165833,
-0.2685616612434387,
-0.6152123808860779,
-0.20063133537769318,
-0.1250726729631424,
-0.43815168738365173,
0.5662916302680969,
0.6983587145805359,
-1.001771092414856,
0.54246586561203,
0.2354288101196289,
0.12924987077713013,
0.7629014849662781,
-0.07555562257766724,
0.26233935356140137,
-0.8638566136360168,
0.15881185233592987,
-0.42573678493499756,
-0.3150629699230194,
-0.5903258919715881,
0.14328798651695251,
0.22379758954048157,
0.1469224989414215,
-0.45419129729270935,
0.41347989439964294,
-0.5997092127799988,
-0.30777445435523987,
-0.38978782296180725,
0.10835279524326324,
-0.055005766451358795,
0.4591117799282074,
-0.12744402885437012,
1.0132070779800415,
0.34379762411117554,
-0.806227445602417,
0.24654217064380646,
-0.03259987011551857,
-0.7977774143218994,
0.1846790760755539,
-0.3583998382091522,
0.36404094099998474,
-0.14840534329414368,
0.5520661473274231,
-1.1849268674850464,
-0.2027454972267151,
-0.1534065455198288,
-0.3851254880428314,
0.3524304926395416,
0.07659471780061722,
-0.8182665705680847,
-0.4691411256790161,
-0.2784135043621063,
0.47203484177589417,
0.7647942304611206,
-0.75178062915802,
0.5245414972305298,
0.12489757686853409,
0.2275255173444748,
-0.7274457216262817,
-0.8060930371284485,
-0.051503267139196396,
-0.21917134523391724,
-0.4538493752479553,
0.36837491393089294,
-0.08941548317670822,
-0.055872466415166855,
-0.10711109638214111,
-0.35462135076522827,
-0.303615003824234,
0.21730683743953705,
0.034037016332149506,
0.11616936326026917,
-0.5503957867622375,
0.4577963650226593,
0.18801334500312805,
0.0005030882311984897,
-0.16318130493164062,
-0.24703747034072876,
0.8723251223564148,
0.21917571127414703,
-0.4725427031517029,
-0.8019891977310181,
0.2770925462245941,
0.9646761417388916,
0.18831658363342285,
0.756784200668335,
0.2635555565357208,
-0.28225043416023254,
-0.3011724650859833,
-0.8360868096351624,
-0.24033595621585846,
-0.5170679688453674,
0.4692603647708893,
-0.22475910186767578,
-0.8740001916885376,
0.678083598613739,
-0.395425409078598,
-0.14997375011444092,
0.2960759103298187,
0.642254650592804,
-0.169124573469162,
0.9486719965934753,
0.41483834385871887,
-0.6138094663619995,
0.35804203152656555,
-0.14565080404281616,
0.29615452885627747,
-0.6784854531288147,
-0.07871916145086288,
-0.654432475566864,
-0.43725547194480896,
-0.6341031789779663,
-0.5811657905578613,
0.10632231831550598,
0.40471121668815613,
-0.3009140193462372,
0.024281654506921768,
-0.20110534131526947,
0.4566138684749603,
0.7872458100318909,
0.2865973711013794,
0.3438030481338501,
0.16185086965560913,
-0.31703421473503113,
-0.1033511832356453,
-0.6097885370254517,
-0.18965686857700348,
1.1139473915100098,
-0.09570296853780746,
0.9448795914649963,
-0.06177670881152153,
0.3748961389064789,
0.36343562602996826,
0.17928428947925568,
-0.801739513874054,
0.7023496627807617,
-0.07123362272977829,
-0.5338588356971741,
-0.2358592301607132,
-0.2679767608642578,
-0.8982650637626648,
0.04186342656612396,
0.13766713440418243,
-1.0339559316635132,
-0.2148459553718567,
0.3345458507537842,
-0.1044851616024971,
0.3888108432292938,
-0.7073701024055481,
0.36160922050476074,
0.0013554071774706244,
-0.22749413549900055,
-0.5920577049255371,
-0.5474655032157898,
0.5047066807746887,
-0.2068014293909073,
-0.513430118560791,
0.13095012307167053,
-0.10884249955415726,
0.6192402839660645,
-0.7222318053245544,
0.9620934128761292,
-0.2044050395488739,
0.0768965482711792,
0.6104713678359985,
-0.0386425144970417,
0.9115776419639587,
-0.22725839912891388,
-0.27598387002944946,
-0.004508273676037788,
-0.44439736008644104,
-0.39689475297927856,
-0.8487521409988403,
0.9610874056816101,
-0.7186073064804077,
-0.6335893869400024,
0.05673493817448616,
-0.7256389856338501,
-0.2031935751438141,
0.18402765691280365,
0.03224010393023491,
0.06995130330324173,
0.1892872303724289,
0.36131393909454346,
0.7101780772209167,
-0.4584534764289856,
0.3945469260215759,
0.4572785496711731,
0.16459572315216064,
-0.4636816382408142,
0.6687615513801575,
0.16257750988006592,
0.5648953318595886,
0.5026987195014954,
0.1073041707277298,
-0.12567244470119476,
-0.4658550024032593,
-0.4004935920238495,
0.22809860110282898,
-1.0101648569107056,
-0.37894681096076965,
-0.8189099431037903,
-0.26794472336769104,
-0.2770960032939911,
-0.5017324686050415,
-0.6127454042434692,
-0.49526429176330566,
-0.17412836849689484,
-0.04576929286122322,
0.7246074080467224,
0.3656098544597626,
0.25727424025535583,
0.755211353302002,
-0.6093167662620544,
0.2206934541463852,
0.28493228554725647,
0.30970263481140137,
0.6959627866744995,
-0.12835463881492615,
-0.1714974194765091,
-0.16750939190387726,
-0.47063514590263367,
-0.6863638162612915,
0.24468711018562317,
0.05323898047208786,
0.6297252774238586,
0.5328738689422607,
0.010433843359351158,
1.1931004524230957,
-0.4799080193042755,
0.8384510278701782,
0.0171409472823143,
-0.7692275047302246,
0.2885584533214569,
0.01854085922241211,
0.6896107196807861,
0.6766972541809082,
0.35047873854637146,
-0.3846481740474701,
-0.3235134184360504,
-0.2668241560459137,
-0.9969457983970642,
0.3931121230125427,
0.1600060909986496,
0.038897834718227386,
-0.18058867752552032,
0.5548291206359863,
0.10616346448659897,
0.34875139594078064,
-0.3685980439186096,
-0.41334959864616394,
0.3579161763191223,
-0.23832200467586517,
0.0247202031314373,
-0.3704111576080322,
0.4889889061450958,
-0.3155491352081299,
0.6807624697685242,
0.10576953738927841,
0.7074254155158997,
0.11102885007858276,
-0.33519840240478516,
-0.14301081001758575,
-0.08849938213825226,
0.7398490905761719,
0.5532455444335938,
-0.0003738736850209534,
0.20712539553642273,
0.4801546037197113,
-0.6851903200149536,
0.07814506441354752,
-0.3283991813659668,
-0.19644369184970856,
-0.06779316067695618,
0.3454999029636383,
0.5608744621276855,
0.3349945843219757,
-0.9767064452171326,
0.09567128121852875,
0.03276566416025162,
-0.1856594830751419,
-0.2761543393135071,
0.21175259351730347,
0.6184719204902649,
0.5101794004440308,
0.20150211453437805,
-0.4117317199707031,
0.01679174415767193,
-0.20004381239414215,
0.24036458134651184,
0.5583972930908203,
-0.16621634364128113,
0.10262218862771988,
0.3692288398742676,
-0.04848932474851608,
-0.20366829633712769,
1.1360505819320679,
0.2046700268983841,
-0.6535138487815857,
0.8984574675559998,
0.6740679144859314,
0.877306342124939,
-0.3139151930809021,
-0.20133616030216217,
0.24540744721889496,
0.10691951960325241,
-0.028896935284137726,
0.2798686921596527,
-0.4663175046443939,
-0.65131676197052,
-0.5896697640419006,
-0.6845459342002869,
-0.3194555640220642,
0.42736703157424927,
-0.6260354518890381,
0.1709979921579361,
-0.2735919952392578,
0.052088264375925064,
0.004705952946096659,
0.04118259623646736,
-0.6550582647323608,
0.008945741690695286,
0.04933474585413933,
1.1432768106460571,
-0.5231398940086365,
1.0207650661468506,
0.20494934916496277,
0.12970411777496338,
-0.4381888210773468,
0.03207085654139519,
-0.12964598834514618,
-1.0359467267990112,
0.8164098858833313,
0.3398602604866028,
-0.27228254079818726,
0.11019007861614227,
-0.6974133849143982,
-0.8605273365974426,
1.3893898725509644,
0.3190799653530121,
-0.588764488697052,
0.07585153728723526,
0.03120456635951996,
0.3975387215614319,
-0.15827427804470062,
0.07460988312959671,
0.6079994440078735,
0.543237030506134,
0.28049078583717346,
-0.42873311042785645,
-0.0669722706079483,
-0.0026555368676781654,
0.18681089580059052,
0.5098148584365845,
-0.5966113209724426,
0.3957900106906891,
-0.0930778831243515,
-0.020004035905003548,
0.3932586908340454,
0.9293187260627747,
0.4668155014514923,
0.31467145681381226,
0.4644196033477783,
0.9271875023841858,
0.9640293717384338,
0.3654637038707733,
1.0014876127243042,
-0.19195082783699036,
-0.04917283356189728,
1.207762360572815,
-0.4507482051849365,
0.8214408755302429,
0.5408153533935547,
-0.057703837752342224,
0.5366193056106567,
0.5879539251327515,
0.13872739672660828,
0.9783598184585571,
0.44251346588134766,
-0.6183590888977051,
-0.42690908908843994,
0.11661984026432037,
-0.19355931878089905,
0.508080780506134,
0.5385103225708008,
-0.4090033769607544,
-0.2513522803783417,
-0.13505877554416656,
0.19839495420455933,
-0.32003289461135864,
-0.18425747752189636,
0.6427108645439148,
0.20189158618450165,
-0.9659279584884644,
0.4663449823856354,
-0.106831394135952,
0.3810085356235504,
-0.5253630876541138,
-0.18501020967960358,
-0.08904889225959778,
0.3202742338180542,
0.2462933361530304,
-0.32975998520851135,
-0.04494137689471245,
-0.03985879197716713,
-0.36772167682647705,
0.2512318193912506,
0.9390609860420227,
-0.16525617241859436,
-0.39605823159217834,
0.3208957016468048,
0.27935975790023804,
0.3557465970516205,
0.18697597086429596,
-0.28353649377822876,
-0.011521542444825172,
-0.11262230575084686,
-0.4826129376888275,
0.3103346526622772,
0.334021657705307,
-0.1495673507452011,
0.911969780921936,
0.5887606143951416,
-0.030820759013295174,
0.3058582842350006,
0.024893242865800858,
1.0255910158157349,
-0.7381284236907959,
-0.4258294403553009,
-1.0015002489089966,
0.2575104832649231,
-0.027534447610378265,
-0.03840402141213417,
0.6975093483924866,
0.4364454746246338,
0.6517348885536194,
-0.05543294548988342,
0.8697536587715149,
0.13276620209217072,
0.07617904990911484,
-0.7455646395683289,
0.7243116497993469,
-0.4342189431190491,
0.09276840090751648,
-0.2992273271083832,
-0.6816241145133972,
-0.24734969437122345,
0.4680952727794647,
-0.31201037764549255,
0.25933608412742615,
0.7787672877311707,
0.8611546158790588,
-0.017205672338604927,
0.16312099993228912,
0.40489235520362854,
0.3138119578361511,
0.3457385301589966,
0.5829471945762634,
0.5899558067321777,
-0.1887531876564026,
0.46277934312820435,
-0.3106822669506073,
0.06121454015374184,
-0.4748743176460266,
-1.065185785293579,
-0.8432435393333435,
-0.3780387043952942,
0.04860803857445717,
-0.21087861061096191,
0.30040115118026733,
0.546891987323761,
0.8266475796699524,
-0.639898419380188,
-0.15389133989810944,
-0.4838387966156006,
0.19335892796516418,
-0.06347361952066422,
-0.2162036895751953,
0.40685221552848816,
-0.4772357940673828,
-0.5234135389328003,
0.4127271771430969,
0.16321906447410583,
-0.15859635174274445,
-0.3484860062599182,
-0.20854827761650085,
-0.3258521258831024,
0.18650545179843903,
0.6634625792503357,
0.13763293623924255,
-0.8589271903038025,
-0.25462040305137634,
0.09496616572141647,
-0.16640785336494446,
0.1581752896308899,
0.9397010803222656,
-0.8577632308006287,
0.6761795878410339,
0.492114782333374,
1.107958197593689,
0.9252768754959106,
-0.20134258270263672,
0.7194851040840149,
-0.5128710269927979,
0.16489699482917786,
0.1356072574853897,
0.132588192820549,
-0.002876954386010766,
-0.5079792141914368,
0.25633636116981506,
0.2685776948928833,
-0.6878171563148499,
-0.8671649694442749,
0.1526278853416443,
-1.067915916442871,
-0.47997984290122986,
0.9145790338516235,
-0.04851807653903961,
-0.4488900899887085,
0.1240735873579979,
0.17257200181484222,
0.5088220238685608,
-0.4283463954925537,
0.8181297183036804,
0.8763548135757446,
-0.0023486847057938576,
-0.13777194917201996,
-1.0609257221221924,
0.20528975129127502,
0.5779650211334229,
-0.8000110387802124,
-0.11109799146652222,
0.29475927352905273,
0.11319465935230255,
-0.1071491464972496,
0.6549609899520874,
0.09698042273521423,
0.4421834945678711,
0.015668105334043503,
0.21090759336948395,
0.4199678599834442,
-0.501802384853363,
0.06179972365498543,
-0.05889010801911354,
0.10046263039112091,
-0.1283986121416092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18043v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18043v1
|
Utilizing Large Language Models for Information Extraction from Real Estate Transactions
| 2024-04-28T01:38:38 | 2024-04-28T01:38:38 |
Yu Zhao, Haoxiang Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Real estate sales contracts contain crucial information for property
transactions, but manual extraction of data can be time-consuming and
error-prone. This paper explores the application of large language models,
specifically transformer-based architectures, for automated information
extraction from real estate contracts. We discuss challenges, techniques, and
future directions in leveraging these models to improve efficiency and accuracy
in real estate contract analysis.
|
[
-0.10079818218946457,
-0.8525261878967285,
0.56601881980896,
-0.06624125689268112,
-0.028739450499415398,
-0.03725697100162506,
-0.2994312345981598,
-0.7982629537582397,
-0.10318981111049652,
0.9892396330833435,
0.19636626541614532,
-0.32169651985168457,
-0.7307682633399963,
-0.27158451080322266,
-0.5354241728782654,
0.6666122674942017,
-0.07525193691253662,
-0.13777264952659607,
0.13152948021888733,
0.060348574072122574,
-0.4093342125415802,
-0.28287971019744873,
-0.4132366478443146,
-0.42653656005859375,
0.09191542118787766,
0.03686017915606499,
1.2635650634765625,
0.81041020154953,
0.7684040665626526,
0.345999151468277,
0.32500597834587097,
-0.1811460256576538,
0.008943707682192326,
0.1386364996433258,
-0.2369736135005951,
-0.3998465836048126,
-0.4575165808200836,
-0.040932975709438324,
0.5525954961776733,
0.5323960781097412,
-0.3041272461414337,
0.22502383589744568,
-0.6504697203636169,
0.511233389377594,
-0.5942373275756836,
0.7198171019554138,
-0.43032798171043396,
0.0628698393702507,
-0.01824851892888546,
-0.1666148155927658,
-0.7004282474517822,
-0.31667929887771606,
0.45469748973846436,
-0.5665651559829712,
0.19656731188297272,
-0.02097756415605545,
1.3664554357528687,
0.17177627980709076,
-0.636345624923706,
-0.5837810039520264,
-1.0655055046081543,
0.6116803884506226,
-0.6775097846984863,
0.8703009486198425,
0.22469154000282288,
0.7207361459732056,
0.06303360313177109,
-1.0169289112091064,
-0.3205723464488983,
-0.5717893838882446,
-0.4509902894496918,
-0.010106926783919334,
-0.5661548376083374,
-0.029817521572113037,
0.4341786503791809,
0.15995021164417267,
-0.2295362800359726,
0.025936126708984375,
-0.6890026330947876,
0.08288858085870743,
0.7151110172271729,
0.2826100289821625,
0.453551322221756,
-0.43843957781791687,
-0.15373845398426056,
-0.09654813259840012,
-0.4839628040790558,
0.06388475745916367,
0.3399065434932709,
0.28502997756004333,
0.046820610761642456,
0.7626556754112244,
0.10316846519708633,
0.7405403852462769,
-0.3754861354827881,
-0.21184763312339783,
-0.028399856761097908,
-0.1396486610174179,
-0.36249691247940063,
-0.13938377797603607,
0.6298019886016846,
0.05233796685934067,
0.3960546553134918,
-0.5352371335029602,
-0.5609662532806396,
-0.28981921076774597,
0.39938268065452576,
-0.6551671028137207,
-0.2074146419763565,
0.4626125395298004,
-0.6021543741226196,
-0.24589987099170685,
0.6965016722679138,
-0.9846248626708984,
-0.007921564392745495,
-0.645374059677124,
0.11100662499666214,
-0.12716765701770782,
-0.38649460673332214,
0.18077389895915985,
-0.5513737797737122,
0.8383570313453674,
0.23510798811912537,
-0.4846123456954956,
0.7774649858474731,
0.8701061010360718,
0.48366454243659973,
-0.027016473934054375,
-0.13032343983650208,
-0.5725130438804626,
0.42284542322158813,
-0.1958806812763214,
0.47646477818489075,
-0.7080232501029968,
-0.11913561820983887,
-0.04741126671433449,
-0.03855575993657112,
-0.04513906314969063,
-0.6927503347396851,
0.0010067587718367577,
-0.9148246049880981,
-0.23670752346515656,
0.579165518283844,
-0.46793365478515625,
0.11315254867076874,
0.33275923132896423,
-1.136082649230957,
0.7300634980201721,
0.690406084060669,
-0.13467034697532654,
-0.11048955470323563,
-0.9468409419059753,
-0.5569685101509094,
0.042424820363521576,
0.04645077511668205,
-0.6373950839042664,
0.2207707315683365,
0.07234367728233337,
0.3813922703266144,
-0.7383149266242981,
0.5713087916374207,
0.492331326007843,
0.0041341339237987995,
0.4971441328525543,
-0.36154013872146606,
0.8716055154800415,
0.605198323726654,
-0.505789041519165,
-0.22557179629802704,
-0.9212467074394226,
-0.6331356763839722,
0.3846093416213989,
-0.3842068016529083,
-0.11640501767396927,
0.06870626658201218,
0.12462078779935837,
0.13633760809898376,
0.457787424325943,
-0.5832006335258484,
0.3238281011581421,
-0.36743322014808655,
0.3101014196872711,
0.3605474829673767,
-0.3165905177593231,
0.5016362071037292,
-0.18916873633861542,
0.8471616506576538,
0.16927818953990936,
0.11917271465063095,
0.015904245898127556,
-0.130061075091362,
-0.670291006565094,
-0.2550964057445526,
0.7004053592681885,
0.6177913546562195,
-0.561618447303772,
0.263775110244751,
-0.7045480608940125,
-0.8923364877700806,
-0.4984002709388733,
0.02402345836162567,
0.07169637829065323,
0.25955864787101746,
0.1680198758840561,
0.12260258942842484,
-0.5340356230735779,
-0.7220363616943359,
-0.41318395733833313,
0.23846323788166046,
0.21324042975902557,
0.2422880232334137,
0.2225145846605301,
-0.2838144600391388,
1.0524731874465942,
-0.9299676418304443,
-0.006870963145047426,
-0.5168623924255371,
0.1676672250032425,
0.4333890974521637,
0.19060935080051422,
0.5502620935440063,
-1.1400318145751953,
-0.4627017080783844,
0.5258931517601013,
-0.7572482824325562,
-0.017846446484327316,
-0.5233259797096252,
0.006924973800778389,
-0.12069473415613174,
0.6461239457130432,
-0.9766879677772522,
0.5038243532180786,
0.23214788734912872,
-0.29574450850486755,
0.5738376975059509,
-0.2833859622478485,
-0.14640001952648163,
-0.8563560843467712,
-0.09890355169773102,
0.2611965835094452,
-0.5529584288597107,
-0.6343267560005188,
0.310017853975296,
0.182556614279747,
-0.20530928671360016,
-0.31303471326828003,
0.5421820282936096,
-0.8609565496444702,
-0.3867056369781494,
-0.1584511697292328,
0.01002555713057518,
0.11069194227457047,
0.177836611866951,
0.1592542678117752,
0.6820546984672546,
0.3875744342803955,
-0.5179275870323181,
0.6307428479194641,
0.25416862964630127,
-0.30192384123802185,
0.032326001673936844,
-0.5127256512641907,
0.012695856392383575,
-0.3632071912288666,
-0.03361581265926361,
-0.6705060005187988,
-0.1453828364610672,
0.011499806307256222,
0.012434340082108974,
0.3361608386039734,
-0.2683817744255066,
-0.32399022579193115,
-0.44364041090011597,
-0.1687421202659607,
0.13055011630058289,
0.5966783761978149,
-0.643884539604187,
1.4364044666290283,
0.4797617495059967,
-0.0798657238483429,
-0.5829737186431885,
-0.4650086462497711,
0.13421928882598877,
-0.16225901246070862,
-0.3360346555709839,
-0.21206139028072357,
0.5145761370658875,
-0.7272480726242065,
0.1292290836572647,
0.3879016935825348,
-0.34542709589004517,
0.417375773191452,
0.2549619972705841,
0.4663839340209961,
-0.287457138299942,
0.25176742672920227,
-0.32313206791877747,
-0.24577894806861877,
0.24101722240447998,
-0.43009185791015625,
0.6584867238998413,
0.32744622230529785,
-0.2758488059043884,
-0.6166946887969971,
0.4187283217906952,
1.0569461584091187,
-0.6170743107795715,
0.6548166871070862,
0.06470257043838501,
-0.40244507789611816,
-0.016678938642144203,
-0.8083663582801819,
0.10561136901378632,
-0.38214898109436035,
0.3608259856700897,
-0.7031979560852051,
-0.5383651852607727,
0.531899094581604,
-0.34284552931785583,
0.2643383741378784,
0.6658071875572205,
0.46610623598098755,
-0.008635633625090122,
0.5610414743423462,
0.8652403354644775,
-0.040363114327192307,
0.8118692636489868,
-0.4340786337852478,
0.6529093980789185,
-0.49674174189567566,
-0.25854578614234924,
-0.9647252559661865,
0.011749773286283016,
-0.3255196809768677,
-0.334865540266037,
0.15433108806610107,
-0.36278384923934937,
0.07607012987136841,
0.9375784397125244,
-0.4013112187385559,
0.20976214110851288,
0.4162983000278473,
-0.09885236620903015,
0.5340350866317749,
-0.12495436519384384,
0.6431719064712524,
0.04255315288901329,
-0.3311808109283447,
-0.5907942056655884,
1.2240383625030518,
0.6593915224075317,
0.7808534502983093,
0.07031256705522537,
0.2786562144756317,
0.15112820267677307,
0.47844040393829346,
-1.133191704750061,
0.05921763554215431,
-0.10419932752847672,
-0.3795034885406494,
-0.32423391938209534,
-0.4491804838180542,
-1.3305798768997192,
0.1440950632095337,
0.05612548068165779,
-0.5259584188461304,
0.4098384380340576,
-0.24952274560928345,
-0.2878963351249695,
0.23630888760089874,
-0.696712851524353,
0.6199544668197632,
-0.19277380406856537,
0.08471368998289108,
-0.0014153466327115893,
-0.4560485780239105,
0.18181833624839783,
-0.5017642378807068,
0.7527220249176025,
0.09040641039609909,
0.15071094036102295,
0.7630047798156738,
-0.47701558470726013,
0.5016412138938904,
-0.14801125228405,
-0.3652321696281433,
0.5595694780349731,
0.14611947536468506,
0.9929868578910828,
-0.34276095032691956,
-0.44476795196533203,
0.05452204868197441,
0.09787919372320175,
-0.2583589255809784,
-0.7147473096847534,
0.04424108564853668,
-0.7310133576393127,
-0.30637845396995544,
-0.12504266202449799,
-0.5215800404548645,
0.0703231543302536,
-0.11041301488876343,
-0.0730544924736023,
0.37852001190185547,
-0.06510095298290253,
0.015103320591151714,
0.12075484544038773,
0.26682034134864807,
0.5238487124443054,
0.587901771068573,
-0.04783385619521141,
-0.1818244755268097,
0.894101083278656,
0.40835466980934143,
0.10010816901922226,
0.4756395220756531,
0.3255353271961212,
-0.4561735689640045,
-0.5211597681045532,
0.03804787993431091,
0.35193541646003723,
-0.7064880728721619,
-0.43307042121887207,
-1.0349406003952026,
-0.1878780871629715,
-0.8126389980316162,
-0.24342399835586548,
-0.5530229806900024,
-0.5630456805229187,
-0.08569959551095963,
-0.26327764987945557,
0.0519280731678009,
1.0251044034957886,
0.4131510853767395,
0.6552947759628296,
-1.433127522468567,
0.5614925622940063,
0.43214407563209534,
0.016728198155760765,
-0.1940806657075882,
-0.2729003429412842,
-0.5156512260437012,
-0.19453784823417664,
-0.07916008681058884,
-0.8311952352523804,
0.505338728427887,
-0.17737217247486115,
0.6166377067565918,
0.26798954606056213,
-0.18292398750782013,
0.30612143874168396,
-0.20549476146697998,
0.7870197892189026,
0.011028369888663292,
-1.1649826765060425,
0.5267950296401978,
-0.03258197382092476,
0.0357213020324707,
0.3484959304332733,
0.15749360620975494,
-0.3595103323459625,
-0.27263393998146057,
-0.9030923247337341,
-0.7970903515815735,
0.5418278574943542,
-0.023410649970173836,
0.1423591822385788,
0.02999846264719963,
0.41346508264541626,
0.10137003660202026,
0.28650379180908203,
-0.8313894867897034,
0.22288671135902405,
0.17432630062103271,
-0.23348064720630646,
0.27668944001197815,
-0.3471498191356659,
0.028181592002511024,
-0.3244176208972931,
0.5304914116859436,
-0.08823909610509872,
-0.06851460784673691,
0.1806151419878006,
-0.5063028335571289,
-0.051709309220314026,
0.2911085784435272,
0.3646121621131897,
1.133195161819458,
0.05855009704828262,
0.044328924268484116,
-0.10817468911409378,
-0.46136772632598877,
0.18126365542411804,
0.054777808487415314,
0.03528645262122154,
0.08916927129030228,
0.6961671710014343,
0.5564631819725037,
-0.03252149373292923,
-0.8335760235786438,
0.6853137612342834,
-0.07586541026830673,
-0.11867060512304306,
-0.5270437002182007,
-0.3322467505931854,
-0.12232404202222824,
0.5378690958023071,
0.16113927960395813,
-0.2550266683101654,
0.2745668590068817,
-0.5297760367393494,
0.36015477776527405,
0.16012033820152283,
-0.3881624937057495,
-0.1370856761932373,
0.5054768323898315,
-0.07250425964593887,
-0.5369237065315247,
1.0308637619018555,
0.4690994620323181,
-0.38846099376678467,
1.0273847579956055,
0.5440645813941956,
0.8241852521896362,
-0.15171942114830017,
0.11127237975597382,
0.10444243252277374,
0.32140201330184937,
-0.19471384584903717,
0.012189806438982487,
-0.04847795143723488,
-0.7299028635025024,
-0.5689229965209961,
-0.476124107837677,
-0.27133235335350037,
-0.29770922660827637,
-0.4082346260547638,
0.43702366948127747,
-0.3693377375602722,
-0.06632846593856812,
0.28812018036842346,
-0.2876879572868347,
-0.7635231614112854,
0.14965631067752838,
0.14585384726524353,
1.0492609739303589,
-0.6188134551048279,
1.0584594011306763,
0.6347192525863647,
-0.3446304202079773,
-1.1341142654418945,
-0.2825652062892914,
-0.5640091300010681,
-0.46474096179008484,
0.9915099740028381,
-0.3082251250743866,
-0.08895053714513779,
-0.056885574012994766,
-0.6633024215698242,
-0.5094695091247559,
1.0748313665390015,
0.6340489387512207,
-0.8918883204460144,
-0.28265613317489624,
0.3262485861778259,
0.50514155626297,
-0.3575340807437897,
0.2488716095685959,
1.05211341381073,
0.8579434156417847,
0.006245434284210205,
-0.7757151126861572,
-0.13144825398921967,
0.02925863303244114,
-0.1539880484342575,
0.5677716135978699,
-0.35915541648864746,
0.9814015030860901,
0.23869356513023376,
0.1297072470188141,
-0.3310110569000244,
0.5983509421348572,
-0.2976348400115967,
0.14547359943389893,
0.5467560887336731,
0.418247252702713,
0.6557636857032776,
-0.14835192263126373,
1.2215194702148438,
-0.40492865443229675,
0.6811908483505249,
0.8714684247970581,
-0.20008184015750885,
0.8457337021827698,
0.46010857820510864,
-0.17242617905139923,
0.4936859607696533,
-0.016290150582790375,
-0.295310378074646,
-0.0352901853621006,
0.27993863821029663,
0.0022970496211200953,
-0.22156408429145813,
0.06226848438382149,
0.1757991760969162,
1.014563798904419,
0.4233412444591522,
-0.44222673773765564,
-0.35657036304473877,
0.05108937993645668,
0.05921337008476257,
-0.003715530736371875,
0.10821153968572617,
1.0851049423217773,
0.11395499855279922,
-0.5755566358566284,
-0.07978715747594833,
0.1215565949678421,
0.175972580909729,
-0.7445324659347534,
-0.41789302229881287,
0.06623576581478119,
-0.005046132020652294,
-0.1387953907251358,
-0.5531878471374512,
0.5700967907905579,
-0.2926962971687317,
-0.062444448471069336,
-0.3868892788887024,
0.878252387046814,
-0.27589401602745056,
-0.5419196486473083,
0.6179776191711426,
0.3895394206047058,
0.19946923851966858,
-0.3043982982635498,
-0.4246947765350342,
-0.039794713258743286,
-0.14598949253559113,
-0.416435569524765,
-0.11721758544445038,
0.4975986182689667,
-0.24010638892650604,
0.45729321241378784,
0.7359566688537598,
0.5299293398857117,
0.1714896410703659,
0.04714062437415123,
0.8504571318626404,
-1.1351020336151123,
-0.22066541016101837,
-0.7746830582618713,
0.7293132543563843,
-0.36753079295158386,
0.09382548183202744,
0.19495715200901031,
0.6790494322776794,
0.3468683362007141,
-0.1476064771413803,
0.717993438243866,
0.29533225297927856,
0.16852477192878723,
-0.5572629570960999,
0.496167927980423,
-0.18913835287094116,
0.4570934474468231,
0.08126050233840942,
-1.3577982187271118,
-0.16772563755512238,
0.40125399827957153,
-0.3809554874897003,
-0.5013311505317688,
0.6942557692527771,
0.4860157370567322,
-0.19061613082885742,
-0.1339472085237503,
0.4338313937187195,
0.1577991545200348,
0.859495997428894,
0.3015989363193512,
0.7639435529708862,
-0.8808757066726685,
0.5840028524398804,
-0.26610660552978516,
-0.05458702892065048,
-0.2692600190639496,
-0.6367629766464233,
-0.5765186548233032,
-0.42714598774909973,
-0.5105423927307129,
-0.34795305132865906,
-0.30790695548057556,
0.764046847820282,
0.7352907657623291,
-0.8376017212867737,
-0.7812427282333374,
0.1419767141342163,
0.29836687445640564,
-0.06909383088350296,
-0.2944202125072479,
0.48728147149086,
-0.4465944170951843,
-0.8902568817138672,
0.34525132179260254,
0.4151097536087036,
0.24713197350502014,
-0.15021179616451263,
0.18430165946483612,
-0.19567862153053284,
0.06757853925228119,
0.5462197661399841,
0.26237326860427856,
-0.3228810429573059,
-0.36069008708000183,
-0.32112911343574524,
-0.44989827275276184,
0.3455355167388916,
1.3563623428344727,
-0.5472854375839233,
0.349689245223999,
0.5540390610694885,
1.0917545557022095,
0.7166892290115356,
0.1438315361738205,
0.8231868147850037,
-0.3816666007041931,
0.338608980178833,
0.11151764541864395,
0.3634679317474365,
0.13444848358631134,
-0.8225502371788025,
0.6439351439476013,
0.01205949205905199,
-0.21287988126277924,
-0.34036019444465637,
-0.0311732180416584,
-0.9988912343978882,
-0.5113930702209473,
0.8973962664604187,
0.009865581057965755,
-0.7029183506965637,
-0.574988067150116,
-0.3324434161186218,
0.2483150064945221,
-0.23613767325878143,
0.3051232397556305,
0.8553435206413269,
0.06235920265316963,
-0.46912673115730286,
-0.7850390076637268,
0.07434950768947601,
-0.011226042173802853,
-1.1109263896942139,
0.1647661179304123,
0.5534476637840271,
0.09470165520906448,
0.591677725315094,
0.6498503684997559,
-0.451396644115448,
0.13852009177207947,
0.03973286971449852,
0.0925229862332344,
-0.02641235664486885,
-0.3232700824737549,
-0.4018876552581787,
0.770585834980011,
0.19261965155601501,
-0.13232801854610443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18040v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18040v1
|
Fashion Recommendation: Outfit Compatibility using GNN
| 2024-04-28T00:57:17 | 2024-04-28T00:57:17 |
Samaksh Gulati
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Numerous industries have benefited from the use of machine learning and
fashion in industry is no exception. By gaining a better understanding of what
makes a good outfit, companies can provide useful product recommendations to
their users. In this project, we follow two existing approaches that employ
graphs to represent outfits and use modified versions of the Graph neural
network (GNN) frameworks. Both Node-wise Graph Neural Network (NGNN) and
Hypergraph Neural Network aim to score a set of items according to the outfit
compatibility of items. The data used is the Polyvore Dataset which consists of
curated outfits with product images and text descriptions for each product in
an outfit. We recreate the analysis on a subset of this data and compare the
two existing models on their performance on two tasks Fill in the blank (FITB):
finding an item that completes an outfit, and Compatibility prediction:
estimating compatibility of different items grouped as an outfit. We can
replicate the results directionally and find that HGNN does have a slightly
better performance on both tasks. On top of replicating the results of the two
papers we also tried to use embeddings generated from a vision transformer and
witness enhanced prediction accuracy across the board
|
[
-0.18487733602523804,
-0.4863070547580719,
0.28048643469810486,
0.2921193242073059,
-0.5571485161781311,
0.07943585515022278,
-0.0021709189750254154,
-1.0232880115509033,
0.6187355518341064,
0.27470138669013977,
-0.5797103643417358,
-0.6859685182571411,
-0.21724200248718262,
-0.02174791693687439,
-0.2704051733016968,
0.6331652402877808,
0.10045457631349564,
0.17180593311786652,
-0.6048711538314819,
-0.15230824053287506,
-0.5923245549201965,
-0.48819538950920105,
-0.7900609970092773,
-0.7675778865814209,
0.649684727191925,
0.06519152224063873,
0.8786396980285645,
0.6131343841552734,
0.5262193083763123,
0.3497547209262848,
-0.09370557218790054,
0.20883809030056,
-0.6415917277336121,
0.2561320662498474,
-0.10134194791316986,
0.005681827664375305,
-0.42568737268447876,
-0.06466586142778397,
-0.035475242882966995,
0.17149141430854797,
-0.03832500800490379,
0.41930100321769714,
0.17945125699043274,
0.7131731510162354,
-0.6625664234161377,
0.22555631399154663,
-0.21521972119808197,
0.36358219385147095,
-0.17981970310211182,
0.37658998370170593,
-0.07592317461967468,
-0.0069337571039795876,
0.24501925706863403,
-0.907290518283844,
0.22745922207832336,
0.2970646321773529,
0.6163802742958069,
0.07945509254932404,
-0.05839871987700462,
-0.21981821954250336,
-0.9804278612136841,
0.605341911315918,
-0.5421507954597473,
0.6076361536979675,
0.4817911982536316,
0.22833722829818726,
0.21228119730949402,
-0.837414562702179,
-0.3459259867668152,
-0.09389489889144897,
-0.4787004292011261,
0.33387085795402527,
-0.17505674064159393,
-0.289563924074173,
0.05850045755505562,
0.3878760039806366,
-0.8021389245986938,
0.02249814011156559,
-0.26903754472732544,
-0.06835189461708069,
0.5792859792709351,
0.04730905964970589,
0.11292395740747452,
-0.4562082588672638,
-0.37140050530433655,
-0.06468106061220169,
-0.2257407158613205,
-0.21300867199897766,
0.6092991232872009,
0.1461561918258667,
0.08853068202733994,
0.539707362651825,
-0.3273971676826477,
0.9068099856376648,
-0.05696957930922508,
0.18223653733730316,
0.3651617467403412,
-0.6056844592094421,
-0.47581785917282104,
0.08152890205383301,
0.7177069187164307,
1.0345710515975952,
0.33892399072647095,
-0.4305703043937683,
-0.05952388793230057,
-0.2482709139585495,
0.5268974304199219,
-0.4778651297092438,
-0.4888417720794678,
-0.04995792731642723,
-0.5644843578338623,
-0.5444619059562683,
0.25558432936668396,
-0.8424570560455322,
-0.5761796832084656,
-0.6533101201057434,
0.32114967703819275,
0.06840261816978455,
-0.08642807602882385,
0.3479072153568268,
-0.4507733881473541,
0.2788165509700775,
0.2581764757633209,
-0.6057613492012024,
0.05099009349942207,
0.6475928425788879,
1.1044751405715942,
-0.040708016604185104,
0.038088358938694,
0.05723782256245613,
0.22781753540039062,
-0.4496452510356903,
0.45470893383026123,
-0.21874070167541504,
-0.2780431807041168,
-0.03912076726555824,
0.24724993109703064,
0.1423095464706421,
-0.4516180455684662,
0.515561044216156,
-0.35111474990844727,
-0.04755430296063423,
-0.42481470108032227,
-0.4762289524078369,
-0.44308677315711975,
0.39360591769218445,
-0.9773218035697937,
0.7607253193855286,
0.18206118047237396,
-0.6689572334289551,
0.5632561445236206,
-0.5061494708061218,
-0.5419924259185791,
0.2812698185443878,
0.2561700642108917,
-0.7877508997917175,
-0.18987326323986053,
0.028271205723285675,
0.33997291326522827,
-0.06668157875537872,
-0.39517486095428467,
-0.7426915764808655,
-0.6384194493293762,
-0.10368451476097107,
0.0931844562292099,
0.47608163952827454,
-0.20237579941749573,
-0.19485358893871307,
0.26577889919281006,
-0.7180931568145752,
0.18939873576164246,
0.39860793948173523,
0.040602173656225204,
-0.4182378351688385,
-0.005778199061751366,
0.34936589002609253,
0.1850946694612503,
0.36348697543144226,
-0.43123605847358704,
-0.028297174721956253,
-0.10712304711341858,
0.42801904678344727,
0.84466153383255,
-0.14702437818050385,
0.3272421360015869,
-0.7098678350448608,
0.344627320766449,
-0.44784826040267944,
0.3578607141971588,
0.478326678276062,
-0.7078888416290283,
-0.4697718024253845,
0.2580404579639435,
0.23201988637447357,
0.6751081943511963,
-0.7337892055511475,
0.42778101563453674,
0.3169475197792053,
-0.7271150350570679,
-0.01589684560894966,
-0.08631576597690582,
0.2391211837530136,
0.45000171661376953,
0.3584389388561249,
-0.35118624567985535,
-0.898883581161499,
-0.5766238570213318,
-0.2862511873245239,
-0.17647427320480347,
-0.12811972200870514,
0.8580889701843262,
0.14920981228351593,
-0.3781217932701111,
0.7864260077476501,
-0.4918477237224579,
-0.3275042772293091,
-0.13985200226306915,
-0.20422065258026123,
0.43860292434692383,
0.6656052470207214,
1.0194826126098633,
-0.6764256358146667,
-0.5897110104560852,
0.2670338749885559,
-0.8584246039390564,
0.20528815686702728,
0.27449527382850647,
-0.34308505058288574,
-0.10156159102916718,
0.3007938861846924,
-0.20992372930049896,
0.931494414806366,
0.5134311318397522,
-0.337009072303772,
0.6732037663459778,
-0.3441958427429199,
0.18852487206459045,
-1.364419937133789,
-0.13211475312709808,
0.7032607197761536,
-0.45354241132736206,
-0.5056449174880981,
-0.2789806127548218,
-0.3369702696800232,
-0.16348572075366974,
-0.4888310134410858,
0.5824298858642578,
-0.10704131424427032,
-0.25097760558128357,
-0.07211357355117798,
-0.28920722007751465,
0.5415887236595154,
0.24076716601848602,
-0.24420876801013947,
0.5365303754806519,
0.5893430709838867,
-0.4747360944747925,
1.0749009847640991,
0.6618837714195251,
-0.6560128331184387,
0.687845766544342,
-1.067958950996399,
0.6440785527229309,
-0.015489096753299236,
0.18345093727111816,
-0.7741413116455078,
-0.2975635230541229,
0.7054505944252014,
-0.05639040097594261,
0.23598062992095947,
-0.5932044386863708,
-0.39770206809043884,
-0.6108930110931396,
-0.3318953812122345,
0.5344185829162598,
0.3087794780731201,
-0.6403242349624634,
0.47952789068222046,
0.04506793990731239,
0.24729879200458527,
-0.48198094964027405,
-0.6453226208686829,
-0.04481513425707817,
-0.35188502073287964,
-0.7573004961013794,
0.5330083966255188,
-0.23361103236675262,
-0.12446551024913788,
0.07567570358514786,
-0.1004866436123848,
0.18582075834274292,
0.10944811254739761,
0.25746679306030273,
0.6859191060066223,
-0.5212879180908203,
-0.01666121929883957,
-0.742043137550354,
0.09110099822282791,
-0.10853616148233414,
-0.9004469513893127,
0.5130635499954224,
-0.26602238416671753,
-0.1439678817987442,
-0.32090944051742554,
0.19698825478553772,
0.5053164958953857,
-0.1518721729516983,
0.8442825078964233,
0.8414678573608398,
-0.3141690790653229,
0.2553486227989197,
-0.23791703581809998,
0.23254209756851196,
-0.4859328866004944,
0.43690675497055054,
0.05214817076921463,
-0.4143981337547302,
0.5248674750328064,
0.22141435742378235,
-0.3673423230648041,
0.2838626205921173,
0.28945931792259216,
-0.26669228076934814,
1.1243691444396973,
0.6849524974822998,
-0.23645497858524323,
0.8236709833145142,
-0.40023523569107056,
0.30917686223983765,
-0.9622665643692017,
-0.3305833041667938,
-0.3737870752811432,
-0.845184862613678,
-0.8063158392906189,
-0.20818687975406647,
0.36017537117004395,
0.17090778052806854,
-0.37988921999931335,
0.8171155452728271,
-0.6961363554000854,
0.7548940777778625,
0.8778879642486572,
0.5973776578903198,
0.0016508643748238683,
0.1241728737950325,
0.06167791783809662,
0.2826859652996063,
-0.6483991742134094,
0.007843529805541039,
1.0445209741592407,
0.04872199892997742,
0.8961573839187622,
0.06456201523542404,
0.27665969729423523,
0.2561117112636566,
-0.28649845719337463,
-1.0765032768249512,
0.2134556919336319,
-0.6930087804794312,
-0.16343219578266144,
-0.24661891162395477,
-0.44609320163726807,
-0.7666265964508057,
-0.19473661482334137,
-0.4671078324317932,
-0.9876142144203186,
0.4474658668041229,
0.27525269985198975,
-0.17952623963356018,
0.22494086623191833,
-0.5815355181694031,
0.866849422454834,
-0.2821537256240845,
-0.6796724200248718,
0.18733540177345276,
-0.4887814521789551,
-0.03712129220366478,
0.15216757357120514,
-0.47145894169807434,
-0.1202169731259346,
0.38157135248184204,
1.0237128734588623,
0.10553614795207977,
0.5066819190979004,
0.21592333912849426,
0.39970266819000244,
0.041194554418325424,
-0.249399334192276,
0.46386605501174927,
0.05373012274503708,
-0.42404070496559143,
0.4261426329612732,
-0.1717713326215744,
-0.1749776154756546,
-0.6679071187973022,
0.5495717525482178,
-0.6247691512107849,
-0.4112469553947449,
-0.30322548747062683,
-0.5432235598564148,
-0.32147911190986633,
0.39362096786499023,
0.4852885901927948,
0.7191683650016785,
-0.29243603348731995,
0.5646458864212036,
0.21583770215511322,
0.2501451373100281,
0.34658873081207275,
-0.022423891350626945,
-0.4981384575366974,
-0.8509218692779541,
0.9053475856781006,
0.2273019254207611,
-0.05482826381921768,
-0.07620429247617722,
0.7255472540855408,
-0.42676669359207153,
-0.2066541463136673,
-0.7585663795471191,
0.06944547593593597,
-0.7083894610404968,
-0.2511172294616699,
-0.009320993907749653,
-0.2999890148639679,
-0.39627569913864136,
-0.2571660876274109,
-0.01957797259092331,
-0.1188838854432106,
-0.2888011336326599,
0.022984100505709648,
0.48811495304107666,
1.4588109254837036,
0.16284020245075226,
0.22231128811836243,
-0.41823428869247437,
0.031587254256010056,
0.47016388177871704,
0.5827143788337708,
-0.15419034659862518,
0.06908834725618362,
-0.5639490485191345,
0.10207930952310562,
-0.14182144403457642,
-0.6448435187339783,
0.06019201874732971,
0.05406850948929787,
0.52457594871521,
0.22632530331611633,
-0.09336913377046585,
0.5479933023452759,
-0.3431093990802765,
0.5531857013702393,
0.351077139377594,
-0.5022827386856079,
0.3206193149089813,
-0.40914061665534973,
0.25279855728149414,
0.26580604910850525,
0.5998364090919495,
-0.5999411344528198,
0.11909408122301102,
-0.6779407262802124,
-0.8146957159042358,
0.4220370650291443,
0.3045990765094757,
-0.2733873128890991,
0.33270058035850525,
0.5356211066246033,
-0.16130879521369934,
0.5392150282859802,
-0.15037314593791962,
-0.1990988552570343,
-0.5462788343429565,
-0.18810805678367615,
-0.29981282353401184,
0.11298104375600815,
-0.19199149310588837,
-0.43986108899116516,
0.7142730355262756,
-0.36204150319099426,
0.2810228765010834,
0.016760023310780525,
0.31736376881599426,
-0.07049582153558731,
-0.5316032767295837,
0.41634494066238403,
0.9944010376930237,
-0.11142586916685104,
-0.3770659565925598,
-0.010465463623404503,
-0.5685628652572632,
-0.06919100880622864,
0.009994869120419025,
-0.27899816632270813,
0.14978793263435364,
0.24588949978351593,
1.008301019668579,
-0.09147954732179642,
0.1785450130701065,
0.3504369556903839,
-0.3286595046520233,
0.010590238496661186,
-0.12048912793397903,
-0.09101489186286926,
0.144081249833107,
0.3350570499897003,
-0.19395430386066437,
0.613902747631073,
0.2626350522041321,
-0.7471460700035095,
0.40061452984809875,
0.4665431082248688,
-0.7026206851005554,
-0.07874572277069092,
0.4225817322731018,
0.0113943200558424,
-0.62348473072052,
0.6614108681678772,
-0.0994146540760994,
-0.6345712542533875,
0.7682926058769226,
0.7158963680267334,
0.9997806549072266,
-0.03602990135550499,
0.3594096601009369,
0.4436570405960083,
-0.12872475385665894,
-0.40783050656318665,
0.01737188547849655,
0.10779105871915817,
-0.8063963651657104,
-0.4074595868587494,
-0.7314049601554871,
-0.5091988444328308,
0.044747885316610336,
-0.6102012395858765,
0.4365452229976654,
-0.4084642231464386,
-0.27257493138313293,
-0.08963723480701447,
-0.0968237966299057,
-0.6586673259735107,
0.42540860176086426,
0.14378079771995544,
0.5694463849067688,
-0.7381425499916077,
0.3283593952655792,
0.7128186821937561,
-0.2765992283821106,
-0.979465663433075,
0.16791023313999176,
0.08275789022445679,
-0.6726627945899963,
0.03640621900558472,
0.2523253858089447,
-0.2695222496986389,
-0.15265952050685883,
-0.21614718437194824,
-0.68100905418396,
1.233009934425354,
0.4664006233215332,
-0.6243447661399841,
-0.16722896695137024,
-0.21986813843250275,
0.31729692220687866,
-0.33674195408821106,
0.1932135373353958,
0.3607378602027893,
0.49842163920402527,
0.6671816110610962,
-0.8099198937416077,
-0.45892834663391113,
-0.44030436873435974,
0.14281947910785675,
0.05265103280544281,
-0.43028947710990906,
0.8745220303535461,
0.26904967427253723,
0.2204281985759735,
0.48322418332099915,
0.33074283599853516,
-0.11103124171495438,
0.850631833076477,
0.645888090133667,
0.7710981965065002,
0.9322156310081482,
-0.2005571871995926,
0.9685598015785217,
-0.11853159964084625,
0.6018587946891785,
1.2063705921173096,
-0.46628227829933167,
0.471950501203537,
-0.17007982730865479,
-0.025893203914165497,
0.7129383683204651,
0.6492274403572083,
-0.3617222309112549,
0.30327120423316956,
0.1713627725839615,
-0.05383121967315674,
-0.20150621235370636,
-0.32287710905075073,
-0.5717586278915405,
0.6867215633392334,
-0.30759575963020325,
-0.35090312361717224,
0.10737782716751099,
-0.15751057863235474,
-0.3098537027835846,
-0.3018642067909241,
-0.5270366668701172,
1.1108678579330444,
-0.1674061119556427,
-0.08366317301988602,
0.23469795286655426,
-0.3344307541847229,
0.2572845220565796,
-0.6297899484634399,
-0.2357429414987564,
-0.009984500706195831,
0.16725273430347443,
-0.4062252938747406,
-0.8916800618171692,
0.3462427854537964,
-0.3697037994861603,
-0.5210669636726379,
-0.016820348799228668,
1.3808852434158325,
-0.18399599194526672,
-1.0763952732086182,
0.502968966960907,
0.3395868241786957,
-0.276714026927948,
-0.12708795070648193,
-0.6565636992454529,
-0.07973505556583405,
-0.3334732949733734,
0.14514154195785522,
0.2734989821910858,
0.24789424240589142,
0.22178064286708832,
0.4944863021373749,
0.7856486439704895,
-0.05820028856396675,
-0.17403188347816467,
0.08692924678325653,
0.6547273993492126,
-0.29181408882141113,
-0.8181443214416504,
-0.7804263234138489,
0.1540299355983734,
-0.5387288928031921,
-0.22821465134620667,
0.8020917177200317,
0.8073104023933411,
0.8271121978759766,
-0.19973674416542053,
0.5419118404388428,
0.07285986840724945,
0.002250207820907235,
-0.48154503107070923,
0.7607385516166687,
-0.48172035813331604,
0.16248369216918945,
-0.4914676249027252,
-1.1556365489959717,
-0.2275397926568985,
0.8547845482826233,
-0.20858925580978394,
0.28325119614601135,
0.4582678973674774,
0.8293688297271729,
-0.32803699374198914,
0.16524231433868408,
0.22390295565128326,
-0.3618398904800415,
0.012622907757759094,
0.2294768989086151,
0.6830710768699646,
-0.4460124969482422,
0.18494932353496552,
-0.5040908455848694,
-0.02955845184624195,
-0.372279554605484,
-1.1810452938079834,
-0.39774954319000244,
-0.3773438334465027,
-0.3652803599834442,
-0.7578260898590088,
0.5292620658874512,
0.7691733241081238,
1.1581308841705322,
-0.4719089865684509,
-0.2853644788265228,
-0.16777339577674866,
0.3727548122406006,
-0.6213520169258118,
-0.16859067976474762,
0.009261636063456535,
0.23421159386634827,
-0.4105648398399353,
0.511965274810791,
0.3722986578941345,
0.2691151797771454,
-0.1405346691608429,
-0.025762325152754784,
-0.08927780389785767,
-0.030154528096318245,
0.5426262617111206,
0.04872873052954674,
-0.23442316055297852,
-0.625329315662384,
0.095155268907547,
0.24432554841041565,
0.20346394181251526,
0.8659154176712036,
-0.7888152003288269,
0.3572923541069031,
0.7529757022857666,
0.5216721296310425,
0.5493000149726868,
0.17874255776405334,
0.746770441532135,
-0.8262147307395935,
-0.07117302715778351,
0.081718310713768,
0.5896517634391785,
0.38616642355918884,
-0.4918554425239563,
0.7686914205551147,
0.5271795392036438,
-0.6830617189407349,
-0.08895798772573471,
0.3585204482078552,
-1.093178629875183,
-0.07141725718975067,
0.9857596158981323,
-0.3094162046909332,
-0.5901709794998169,
-0.11900608241558075,
-0.27946898341178894,
0.18446126580238342,
0.08418348431587219,
0.4152332842350006,
0.5782478451728821,
-0.04539285972714424,
0.3012520372867584,
-0.33864498138427734,
0.19231772422790527,
-0.1269090473651886,
-0.3785579800605774,
-0.28375527262687683,
0.12463831156492233,
0.13844211399555206,
0.3244190216064453,
-0.08550586551427841,
0.5574080944061279,
0.5111360549926758,
-0.2693461775779724,
-0.4519427418708801,
-0.4082903265953064,
-0.46862637996673584,
0.1004837229847908,
0.1467094123363495,
-0.33181437849998474,
-0.4476724863052368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01551v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01551v1
|
Leveraging Prompts in LLMs to Overcome Imbalances in Complex Educational Text Data
| 2024-04-28T00:24:08 | 2024-04-28T00:24:08 |
Jeanne McClure, Machi Shimmei, Noboru Matsuda, Shiyan Jiang
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we explore the potential of Large Language Models (LLMs) with
assertions to mitigate imbalances in educational datasets. Traditional models
often fall short in such contexts, particularly due to the complexity and
nuanced nature of the data. This issue is especially prominent in the education
sector, where cognitive engagement levels among students show significant
variation in their open responses. To test our hypothesis, we utilized an
existing technology for assertion-based prompt engineering through an
'Iterative - ICL PE Design Process' comparing traditional Machine Learning (ML)
models against LLMs augmented with assertions (N=135). Further, we conduct a
sensitivity analysis on a subset (n=27), examining the variance in model
performance concerning classification metrics and cognitive engagement levels
in each iteration. Our findings reveal that LLMs with assertions significantly
outperform traditional ML models, particularly in cognitive engagement levels
with minority representation, registering up to a 32% increase in F1-score.
Additionally, our sensitivity study indicates that incorporating targeted
assertions into the LLM tested on the subset enhances its performance by
11.94%. This improvement primarily addresses errors stemming from the model's
limitations in understanding context and resolving lexical ambiguities in
student responses.
|
[
-0.22213010489940643,
-1.1930193901062012,
0.6972845196723938,
0.32852140069007874,
0.2243642508983612,
0.3868015706539154,
-0.3793167471885681,
-0.22335240244865417,
-0.06955646723508835,
0.009103024378418922,
-0.59095698595047,
-0.4225117266178131,
-0.5754961967468262,
0.205088809132576,
-0.24885423481464386,
0.6482651233673096,
-0.3100207448005676,
0.121106818318367,
-0.5992509126663208,
0.01385265588760376,
-1.0315392017364502,
-0.4999217689037323,
-0.5880624055862427,
-0.3530588150024414,
0.3685795068740845,
0.6557108759880066,
0.4371342062950134,
0.3967594802379608,
0.3246304392814636,
0.28233277797698975,
-0.29909536242485046,
0.21139302849769592,
-0.23776978254318237,
0.3591243624687195,
-0.24426566064357758,
-0.5202659368515015,
-0.1586107611656189,
-0.08311391621828079,
0.6959307193756104,
0.8184940814971924,
-0.023188402876257896,
0.17607729136943817,
0.5429239869117737,
0.5533815026283264,
-0.8321433663368225,
0.06975347548723221,
-0.47672125697135925,
-0.01973821595311165,
-0.14668238162994385,
0.02107546105980873,
-0.7243592143058777,
-0.1572093516588211,
0.2616698741912842,
-0.40704068541526794,
-0.15050449967384338,
0.035805925726890564,
0.7387495636940002,
0.3294622302055359,
-0.4853513538837433,
-0.46602094173431396,
-0.49695733189582825,
1.238266110420227,
-0.6679931879043579,
0.17901702225208282,
0.24230951070785522,
0.20122264325618744,
-0.03455587103962898,
-0.2718633711338043,
-0.504572331905365,
-0.35485509037971497,
0.056020211428403854,
0.11172250658273697,
-0.012425719760358334,
-0.1530548632144928,
0.44331786036491394,
0.16696879267692566,
-0.612940788269043,
0.5916938781738281,
-0.034420840442180634,
-0.23960132896900177,
0.43684038519859314,
0.5617929697036743,
0.4711204469203949,
-0.15817782282829285,
-0.3478294312953949,
-0.05199466645717621,
-0.7572798132896423,
0.581668496131897,
0.29906684160232544,
0.5845652222633362,
-0.12166759371757507,
1.0111092329025269,
-0.105828657746315,
0.7679873704910278,
0.07705186307430267,
-0.13131111860275269,
0.16317887604236603,
-0.35908690094947815,
-0.07283557206392288,
0.32197117805480957,
0.7138705849647522,
0.30226099491119385,
0.25211450457572937,
0.2768142521381378,
-0.2881373167037964,
0.3501107692718506,
-0.07061613351106644,
-0.901418924331665,
0.1195513904094696,
0.5002256035804749,
-0.26568710803985596,
-0.10896939039230347,
-0.018381653353571892,
-0.8989775776863098,
-0.4401782751083374,
-0.5769109725952148,
0.41579869389533997,
-0.4202633202075958,
-0.12880800664424896,
0.2400730699300766,
0.13758155703544617,
0.07540354132652283,
0.49094605445861816,
-0.8420961499214172,
-0.03611025959253311,
0.5885599851608276,
0.8780392408370972,
-0.49768754839897156,
-0.08857618272304535,
-0.40349674224853516,
-0.13483422994613647,
-0.19212281703948975,
0.5224319100379944,
-0.8504177331924438,
-0.4884438216686249,
0.21207347512245178,
-0.25789543986320496,
-0.3638373017311096,
-0.5242863297462463,
0.8329883813858032,
-0.22617650032043457,
0.5020264983177185,
-0.46958306431770325,
-0.9861387014389038,
-0.03338789567351341,
0.6266210675239563,
-0.4454152584075928,
1.2719409465789795,
0.011250872164964676,
-0.7065685987472534,
0.10235588252544403,
-0.7041506171226501,
-0.3771646320819855,
-0.04452496021986008,
-0.40644851326942444,
-0.3756648004055023,
0.015191213227808475,
0.5283274054527283,
0.3659777045249939,
-0.46250611543655396,
0.6218512058258057,
-0.2173411250114441,
-0.41331061720848083,
0.6038303971290588,
-0.6465169191360474,
0.9373480677604675,
0.04263594374060631,
-0.5092676281929016,
0.12456095218658447,
-0.46439698338508606,
0.05045735463500023,
0.14017276465892792,
-0.4018423855304718,
-0.48863720893859863,
0.07660046964883804,
-0.23316504061222076,
0.19149397313594818,
0.31594133377075195,
-0.6273810267448425,
0.2820771336555481,
-0.40414783358573914,
0.25758516788482666,
0.9936545491218567,
-0.157814621925354,
0.40760892629623413,
-0.4738738536834717,
0.7365066409111023,
-0.037378229200839996,
-0.05989578366279602,
-0.5846023559570312,
-0.4252500832080841,
-0.5818915367126465,
-0.4966350197792053,
0.3120691478252411,
0.7699292898178101,
-0.5892348289489746,
0.6621152758598328,
-0.2642282247543335,
-0.21845270693302155,
-0.6668375134468079,
0.14519692957401276,
0.08156117051839828,
0.8969855904579163,
0.2862052917480469,
0.2481776773929596,
-0.3520696461200714,
-0.5668094158172607,
-0.3277701735496521,
-0.23172955214977264,
-0.08680495619773865,
0.43745243549346924,
0.2976379692554474,
-0.11266986280679703,
1.0694355964660645,
-0.3593710660934448,
0.07325770705938339,
-0.25810179114341736,
0.09371029585599899,
0.27960658073425293,
0.4397799074649811,
0.5586774945259094,
-0.7053413391113281,
-0.5920153260231018,
-0.33657971024513245,
-1.0291574001312256,
-0.39379626512527466,
-0.31206968426704407,
0.02314705215394497,
0.10147428512573242,
0.4688528776168823,
-0.6773775219917297,
0.21170516312122345,
0.27205803990364075,
-0.6576271057128906,
0.5865814685821533,
0.3770275413990021,
0.276109904050827,
-0.7997018098831177,
-0.2528592050075531,
0.169002503156662,
0.14421503245830536,
-0.306493878364563,
-0.15880164504051208,
0.29930394887924194,
-0.10352305322885513,
-0.38653498888015747,
0.782881498336792,
-0.2565937936306,
0.4977695643901825,
-0.24254144728183746,
0.2558019161224365,
0.007013700436800718,
0.20213162899017334,
-0.24587532877922058,
0.8636803030967712,
0.7882595062255859,
-0.7183595299720764,
0.12659645080566406,
0.2211686223745346,
-0.41513949632644653,
0.8513298034667969,
-0.8037004470825195,
-0.3497309982776642,
-0.27282842993736267,
0.13258199393749237,
-1.2020207643508911,
-0.26987364888191223,
0.027296610176563263,
-0.4233417212963104,
0.21194367110729218,
0.22155310213565826,
-0.3379785418510437,
-0.4828469455242157,
-0.4627092182636261,
0.4081974923610687,
0.38342300057411194,
-0.8538200855255127,
0.7465547323226929,
0.1747782826423645,
-0.4709535241127014,
-0.6900008916854858,
-0.3918438255786896,
0.20481517910957336,
-0.366676926612854,
-0.6294911503791809,
0.1748591512441635,
-0.5442573428153992,
-0.4552929401397705,
-0.10960611701011658,
-0.12851597368717194,
0.25554490089416504,
0.505802571773529,
0.29932528734207153,
0.8119685649871826,
-0.3845158815383911,
0.50245201587677,
0.19508643448352814,
-0.006513005122542381,
0.3036414384841919,
-0.1555347442626953,
0.49448803067207336,
0.004306687507778406,
-0.6193988919258118,
-0.5089806914329529,
0.3562544882297516,
0.752422571182251,
-0.2257697433233261,
0.7655796408653259,
0.25134366750717163,
-0.34395939111709595,
-0.31066644191741943,
-0.4192051291465759,
-0.33704933524131775,
-0.5269339084625244,
0.3064229190349579,
-0.29924276471138,
-1.0728923082351685,
0.32945090532302856,
-0.25635820627212524,
0.27101266384124756,
0.2961834669113159,
0.6747422218322754,
-0.28924599289894104,
1.1164937019348145,
0.3984237313270569,
-0.11020010709762573,
0.6268812417984009,
0.16598130762577057,
0.31789430975914,
-0.6409907341003418,
-0.3296875059604645,
-0.7209551334381104,
-0.3966085910797119,
-0.37011173367500305,
-0.10736329853534698,
0.32693004608154297,
0.10106157511472702,
-0.4067666530609131,
-0.39955902099609375,
-0.49854424595832825,
0.5647680759429932,
0.3951234221458435,
0.1984841376543045,
0.11001317203044891,
0.07763921469449997,
-0.18383315205574036,
-0.35953500866889954,
-0.5563406944274902,
-0.7865045666694641,
1.0710527896881104,
0.3703368008136749,
0.7571165561676025,
0.2567300498485565,
0.47533276677131653,
0.35887411236763,
0.49046382308006287,
-1.0325307846069336,
0.6370160579681396,
0.09719682484865189,
-0.4979795217514038,
-0.39386603236198425,
-0.4769571125507355,
-0.7846965789794922,
0.19512450695037842,
-0.4249618351459503,
-0.7610952258110046,
-0.06500180810689926,
0.1047644168138504,
-0.23817311227321625,
0.16230617463588715,
-0.6295321583747864,
0.7635602355003357,
-0.4379830062389374,
-0.522449791431427,
0.1712350696325302,
-0.29626598954200745,
0.324990838766098,
-0.2883968949317932,
0.16719089448451996,
-0.10109853744506836,
-0.004308940842747688,
0.7602111101150513,
-0.3432614207267761,
1.0854049921035767,
-0.14717137813568115,
-0.39175042510032654,
0.6645075082778931,
-0.07367268949747086,
0.7249703407287598,
-0.1399465650320053,
-0.46471065282821655,
-0.24624259769916534,
-0.4706295430660248,
-0.5550284385681152,
-0.6684730052947998,
0.7564379572868347,
-0.7066868543624878,
-0.8039016127586365,
-0.25039494037628174,
-0.6934428215026855,
-0.36201244592666626,
0.026860130950808525,
0.2085220068693161,
0.22399763762950897,
-0.13025197386741638,
0.3822622299194336,
0.994837760925293,
-0.27949580550193787,
0.6228145360946655,
0.5137702822685242,
-0.032472021877765656,
-0.08630525320768356,
0.8274217247962952,
0.21403825283050537,
0.2826954126358032,
0.2710649371147156,
0.40388253331184387,
-0.41912737488746643,
-0.41684412956237793,
-0.38082635402679443,
-0.06562338024377823,
-0.6906578540802002,
-0.23858562111854553,
-0.7402825355529785,
0.05289977788925171,
-0.39572590589523315,
-0.3805750012397766,
-0.11815141141414642,
-0.3464396297931671,
-0.33160609006881714,
-0.3613499402999878,
0.15372495353221893,
0.5343517661094666,
0.2722112536430359,
0.5164130330085754,
-0.5650389194488525,
0.04194091632962227,
0.2704187333583832,
0.001773203955963254,
0.08012188225984573,
-0.8087921738624573,
-0.021606676280498505,
0.04451232776045799,
-0.41559597849845886,
-0.8605607748031616,
0.16836875677108765,
0.07852691411972046,
0.6968479156494141,
0.21066389977931976,
0.2872134745121002,
0.37283167243003845,
-0.20002588629722595,
1.0928871631622314,
0.21358606219291687,
-1.0203547477722168,
0.5441966652870178,
-0.2699655592441559,
0.2567117512226105,
0.41126376390457153,
0.2904927730560303,
-0.2806128263473511,
-0.5739750266075134,
-0.3801259696483612,
-1.0028774738311768,
0.4035382568836212,
-0.12564218044281006,
0.36549505591392517,
0.021166587248444557,
0.29423022270202637,
0.032706212252378464,
0.06993047893047333,
-0.7047613263130188,
-0.3435114622116089,
-0.051530372351408005,
-1.0115423202514648,
0.0468781441450119,
-0.422096848487854,
-0.023076359182596207,
-0.10307073593139648,
0.7054687738418579,
-0.16121545433998108,
-0.29812613129615784,
0.06843256205320358,
-0.15636003017425537,
0.10894274711608887,
0.595482349395752,
0.4125083088874817,
0.4677152931690216,
0.19201134145259857,
0.19089916348457336,
0.22719724476337433,
-0.3970075249671936,
0.4245801866054535,
-0.0037900551687926054,
-0.5112099647521973,
-0.016940703615546227,
0.45915117859840393,
0.5801751613616943,
0.2099846750497818,
-1.0142797231674194,
0.5592905282974243,
-0.05844827741384506,
0.05525607615709305,
0.08557377010583878,
0.15610726177692413,
0.04282963275909424,
0.24432148039340973,
0.43722766637802124,
-0.1507590264081955,
-0.09725870192050934,
-0.3358863294124603,
0.08926036953926086,
0.4749988317489624,
-0.34652280807495117,
0.0006256710621528327,
0.5824446678161621,
0.20087707042694092,
-0.27607303857803345,
0.6647308468818665,
0.10515031218528748,
-0.3586149215698242,
0.8805840611457825,
0.8200925588607788,
0.7260563373565674,
-0.4526180326938629,
0.3322092294692993,
0.5912111401557922,
0.4352077543735504,
-0.12094002217054367,
0.14993107318878174,
0.05968562141060829,
-0.6975974440574646,
-0.4414386749267578,
-0.3048151433467865,
-0.5787280797958374,
-0.05262243002653122,
-0.6830555200576782,
0.25972780585289,
-0.37369590997695923,
-0.24326398968696594,
-0.1535639762878418,
-0.105254627764225,
-0.5175032615661621,
0.16073942184448242,
0.11084053665399551,
0.8928515911102295,
-1.2091854810714722,
0.4017314612865448,
0.8141586780548096,
-0.214686781167984,
-0.8083035349845886,
0.023287083953619003,
0.1610611379146576,
-0.5934085845947266,
0.7024042010307312,
0.4484792947769165,
0.1075262576341629,
-0.10821103304624557,
-0.7681995034217834,
-0.5834876894950867,
0.8806154727935791,
0.4215095639228821,
-0.887062668800354,
0.26657634973526,
0.13436558842658997,
0.32757019996643066,
-0.5273056030273438,
0.2236192226409912,
0.30964401364326477,
0.5252294540405273,
0.006540927104651928,
-0.4743388891220093,
0.127360999584198,
-0.13111412525177002,
-0.4246157705783844,
0.005725341383367777,
-0.31258419156074524,
0.9981160163879395,
-0.3623029887676239,
-0.3313451111316681,
-0.01680092327296734,
0.7647973895072937,
0.715446412563324,
0.6178749799728394,
0.46008405089378357,
0.3072783946990967,
1.3559212684631348,
-0.1782497614622116,
0.9303408265113831,
-0.09660805761814117,
0.23652410507202148,
1.2904313802719116,
-0.3928408622741699,
0.668026864528656,
0.6625414490699768,
-0.11910794675350189,
0.38680005073547363,
0.8267368674278259,
0.06491853296756744,
0.1043207049369812,
0.22524666786193848,
-0.5398637652397156,
-0.45554932951927185,
-0.5664608478546143,
-0.12838999927043915,
0.18419092893600464,
0.5880303382873535,
-0.1566016525030136,
-0.1466323435306549,
0.2613447606563568,
0.03750723600387573,
0.48055458068847656,
-0.41170984506607056,
0.49836331605911255,
-0.06623037904500961,
-0.7897306084632874,
0.40072739124298096,
-0.07295307517051697,
0.8144896626472473,
-0.35100433230400085,
-0.011567339301109314,
-0.25259146094322205,
-0.0031802246812731028,
-0.1024576723575592,
-1.0505709648132324,
-0.29417720437049866,
0.16737663745880127,
-0.4093197286128998,
-0.21209019422531128,
0.5814654231071472,
-0.608368992805481,
-0.5705744624137878,
0.17480474710464478,
0.6413636207580566,
-0.2671319842338562,
0.07501035183668137,
-0.671272337436676,
0.2831875681877136,
0.19282297790050507,
-0.2777542471885681,
0.1993856430053711,
0.6522806286811829,
-0.2892713248729706,
0.809757649898529,
0.4786774814128876,
-0.19625765085220337,
0.015694256871938705,
0.10606291145086288,
0.7143332362174988,
-0.5061429142951965,
-0.4020700454711914,
-1.2036798000335693,
0.7162690162658691,
-0.12587465345859528,
-0.1756771355867386,
0.8788472414016724,
0.4079738259315491,
0.5041190981864929,
0.1065187081694603,
1.0588433742523193,
0.19177068769931793,
0.4918072521686554,
-0.6491712331771851,
0.06669285893440247,
-0.3317270874977112,
0.6475118398666382,
-0.14283788204193115,
-0.6330173015594482,
-0.19159549474716187,
0.5092531442642212,
-0.34971287846565247,
-0.05553494393825531,
0.4638007879257202,
0.6409136652946472,
0.24071171879768372,
0.15029746294021606,
0.10097431391477585,
0.09813088923692703,
0.5680200457572937,
0.6160057187080383,
1.225162148475647,
-0.1870715469121933,
0.2744823098182678,
0.13777372241020203,
-0.3985600471496582,
-0.2644422948360443,
-0.7653235197067261,
-1.127197027206421,
-0.2750486135482788,
-0.5073867440223694,
-0.448238343000412,
-0.18400566279888153,
0.943742573261261,
0.13434270024299622,
-0.7238243222236633,
0.004411547444760799,
0.16240520775318146,
0.5689496994018555,
0.026944302022457123,
-0.32517170906066895,
0.3454006314277649,
-0.6236543655395508,
-0.8797880411148071,
0.3817081153392792,
0.10834856331348419,
0.34795400500297546,
-0.13136453926563263,
-0.03841749578714371,
-0.11220309138298035,
0.32916730642318726,
0.7595807909965515,
0.20808210968971252,
-0.6372596621513367,
-0.30422013998031616,
0.36740589141845703,
-0.3640049695968628,
-0.10850770771503448,
0.8295528292655945,
-0.746448814868927,
0.383044958114624,
0.39472389221191406,
1.0801597833633423,
-0.05193512141704559,
0.1717958003282547,
0.4301499128341675,
-0.7187726497650146,
-0.005477012135088444,
0.20070166885852814,
0.4808228015899658,
0.4524032175540924,
-0.5108516216278076,
0.2692769467830658,
0.07380591332912445,
-0.4149654507637024,
-0.9698992371559143,
0.0916064977645874,
-0.8835475444793701,
-0.4679524898529053,
0.9360458254814148,
-0.14960411190986633,
-0.05548243969678879,
-0.06338667124509811,
-0.421683132648468,
-0.051814962178468704,
-0.38644057512283325,
0.9778457880020142,
0.9949561953544617,
0.06356947124004364,
0.0041533224284648895,
-0.48348334431648254,
0.06059690937399864,
0.818920910358429,
-0.9003548622131348,
0.24773578345775604,
0.5061561465263367,
0.010768627747893333,
0.20952264964580536,
0.254607230424881,
-0.08514253795146942,
-0.08271034806966782,
-0.4142124056816101,
-0.17981691658496857,
0.08066112548112869,
-0.3586781322956085,
-0.3890301585197449,
0.4209345877170563,
-0.0871569961309433,
-0.20339566469192505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18031v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18031v1
|
Quality Estimation with $k$-nearest Neighbors and Automatic Evaluation for Model-specific Quality Estimation
| 2024-04-27T23:52:51 | 2024-04-27T23:52:51 |
Tu Anh Dinh, Tobias Palzer, Jan Niehues
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Providing quality scores along with Machine Translation (MT) output,
so-called reference-free Quality Estimation (QE), is crucial to inform users
about the reliability of the translation. We propose a model-specific,
unsupervised QE approach, termed $k$NN-QE, that extracts information from the
MT model's training data using $k$-nearest neighbors. Measuring the performance
of model-specific QE is not straightforward, since they provide quality scores
on their own MT output, thus cannot be evaluated using benchmark QE test sets
containing human quality scores on premade MT output. Therefore, we propose an
automatic evaluation method that uses quality scores from reference-based
metrics as gold standard instead of human-generated ones. We are the first to
conduct detailed analyses and conclude that this automatic method is
sufficient, and the reference-based MetricX-23 is best for the task.
|
[
-0.276588499546051,
-0.14742866158485413,
0.6099426746368408,
-0.14494095742702484,
-0.5962650775909424,
-0.1893766224384308,
0.06589935719966888,
-0.27754533290863037,
0.19800220429897308,
0.5534647703170776,
-0.4960564374923706,
-0.6080024242401123,
-0.6594458818435669,
0.36719322204589844,
-0.3856149911880493,
0.7693880796432495,
-0.03103504329919815,
0.2142195999622345,
-0.3181113004684448,
-0.31807899475097656,
-0.5006046891212463,
-0.3908720016479492,
-0.08048343658447266,
-0.16464024782180786,
0.38481563329696655,
0.47711116075515747,
0.8941206336021423,
0.703109085559845,
0.8729580640792847,
0.30452781915664673,
0.09613287448883057,
0.3850201964378357,
-0.18600347638130188,
-0.11594954133033752,
-0.19265897572040558,
-0.5670071840286255,
-0.739364743232727,
0.2908392548561096,
0.7539361715316772,
0.6497897505760193,
0.1895201951265335,
0.6280437707901001,
0.007232505362480879,
0.9101319909095764,
-0.6496121883392334,
0.04970133304595947,
-0.27008283138275146,
0.2936079204082489,
0.20998284220695496,
-0.11139912903308868,
-0.27518969774246216,
-0.7607256770133972,
0.1103907972574234,
-0.6657333970069885,
0.05445113405585289,
-0.07124489545822144,
1.233087420463562,
0.36043426394462585,
-0.43964892625808716,
-0.09919770061969757,
-0.7723814845085144,
0.9682414531707764,
-1.0009421110153198,
0.7788576483726501,
0.8389200568199158,
0.7199265956878662,
-0.10272509604692459,
-0.6847607493400574,
-0.29194462299346924,
-0.4209020733833313,
-0.04691888764500618,
0.3487943112850189,
-0.18832151591777802,
-0.18842896819114685,
-0.014913286082446575,
0.5564392805099487,
-0.5610407590866089,
-0.13038992881774902,
-0.29215744137763977,
-0.20199912786483765,
0.7821727395057678,
0.1951414793729782,
0.11197817325592041,
-0.2769882380962372,
-0.10399072617292404,
-0.05216614156961441,
-0.4191398620605469,
-0.0772508904337883,
0.32309481501579285,
0.07718924432992935,
0.20168620347976685,
0.3983379900455475,
-0.5890890955924988,
0.4885546565055847,
0.24698354303836823,
-0.14912578463554382,
0.4042174518108368,
-0.46514245867729187,
-0.3116229772567749,
-0.5964487195014954,
1.168087124824524,
0.6094371676445007,
0.09961691498756409,
-0.6460405588150024,
-0.48519182205200195,
-0.13346095383167267,
0.21119441092014313,
-0.7634103298187256,
-0.35129883885383606,
0.0249862652271986,
-0.7553325891494751,
-0.48130324482917786,
0.26807457208633423,
-0.8016891479492188,
0.10717244446277618,
-0.35114791989326477,
0.6908372640609741,
-0.07736670970916748,
-0.26108139753341675,
-0.4177723228931427,
0.03458917513489723,
-0.10491091758012772,
-0.06585903465747833,
-0.4467526972293854,
0.2373560070991516,
0.013348683714866638,
0.828963577747345,
-0.28573793172836304,
-0.09314579516649246,
-0.6751344203948975,
-0.1904398649930954,
-0.6967350840568542,
0.7976951599121094,
-0.42613670229911804,
-0.6287320852279663,
-0.30643001198768616,
0.16820913553237915,
0.11421994864940643,
-0.9283718466758728,
0.8412873148918152,
-0.6381445527076721,
0.47300249338150024,
-0.35822436213493347,
-0.6736215353012085,
-0.23970754444599152,
0.2632206678390503,
-0.6458759307861328,
1.2974337339401245,
0.5118227601051331,
-0.5623640418052673,
0.3216356635093689,
-0.5986493825912476,
0.12932707369327545,
-0.1907905489206314,
0.17320455610752106,
-0.5365415811538696,
0.4131062626838684,
0.3658379912376404,
0.3408898115158081,
-0.4617263078689575,
0.17728525400161743,
-0.3534640669822693,
-0.30593302845954895,
0.1777554452419281,
-0.5610380172729492,
0.5301848649978638,
0.21430285274982452,
0.0859868973493576,
0.35247209668159485,
-0.9056400656700134,
0.4065580666065216,
0.14844052493572235,
-0.19954034686088562,
-0.3091382384300232,
-0.16686464846134186,
-0.2386597990989685,
0.3957449495792389,
0.24559640884399414,
-0.5341426134109497,
0.025817884132266045,
-0.4691508412361145,
0.11235252022743225,
0.48658642172813416,
0.09969349205493927,
0.5912512540817261,
-0.38341113924980164,
0.5504942536354065,
-0.027223778888583183,
0.45608729124069214,
0.22358082234859467,
-0.44134870171546936,
-0.45341670513153076,
0.08802051097154617,
0.9733089804649353,
0.5251692533493042,
-0.6977161765098572,
0.475554496049881,
-0.36368340253829956,
-0.7211596965789795,
-0.7765868306159973,
0.14093448221683502,
0.46131789684295654,
0.46306130290031433,
0.426921010017395,
-0.5833247900009155,
-0.25069284439086914,
-0.9107550382614136,
-0.28767192363739014,
-0.04230644926428795,
-0.3947346806526184,
0.1203601062297821,
0.5372689962387085,
-0.13796670734882355,
0.9822530746459961,
-0.5301435589790344,
-0.2047038972377777,
0.12714539468288422,
0.06439145654439926,
0.14670847356319427,
0.6295766234397888,
0.4161868095397949,
-0.7280946373939514,
-0.7215961813926697,
-0.19508479535579681,
-0.7709252834320068,
-0.4191778302192688,
0.2884007692337036,
-0.4476999044418335,
-0.18772901594638824,
0.23836565017700195,
-0.19750668108463287,
0.3460020422935486,
0.8840796947479248,
-0.1948241889476776,
1.0030516386032104,
-0.3732546269893646,
0.5265094637870789,
-1.2183749675750732,
0.26977241039276123,
0.007380244787782431,
-0.3100399672985077,
-0.6406993865966797,
0.10950172692537308,
0.16912896931171417,
0.025583794340491295,
-0.23069724440574646,
0.5076132416725159,
-0.32290998101234436,
-0.33186277747154236,
-0.4836323857307434,
0.2985038161277771,
0.30921265482902527,
0.4108886420726776,
0.011930109933018684,
0.6757280826568604,
-0.010936776176095009,
-0.46733492612838745,
0.2333112359046936,
0.18218360841274261,
-0.5648263096809387,
0.7127301096916199,
-0.5113958120346069,
0.42292892932891846,
0.15792329609394073,
-0.07484745234251022,
-0.6479965448379517,
-0.0025975818280130625,
0.3311280906200409,
-0.8098122477531433,
0.14555838704109192,
-0.3820952773094177,
-0.6674376130104065,
-0.24468234181404114,
0.062251150608062744,
0.33097872138023376,
0.4903375804424286,
-0.31072017550468445,
0.30877381563186646,
0.21291324496269226,
-0.06948093324899673,
-0.16231656074523926,
-0.4597603678703308,
-0.11190756410360336,
-0.22324787080287933,
-0.4215477406978607,
0.20232325792312622,
-0.28605154156684875,
0.054378774017095566,
0.2062913477420807,
-0.4107879400253296,
-0.7114136219024658,
0.11647896468639374,
0.2030324786901474,
0.2915155589580536,
-0.27196598052978516,
-0.17540791630744934,
0.10171636939048767,
-0.6212874054908752,
0.12984375655651093,
-0.2787945568561554,
0.0701528862118721,
0.1325693279504776,
-0.35631245374679565,
-0.8672913312911987,
0.4169400632381439,
0.7195602059364319,
-0.5051577091217041,
0.4577774405479431,
0.5655794739723206,
-0.49288398027420044,
0.1803397834300995,
-0.4008271396160126,
-0.16950413584709167,
-0.4585695266723633,
0.4811786413192749,
-0.30528953671455383,
-0.38961321115493774,
0.5132016539573669,
-0.2023100107908249,
-0.006945500150322914,
0.79738849401474,
0.08800362795591354,
-0.3301886022090912,
1.4850388765335083,
0.638429582118988,
-0.026652369648218155,
0.38256025314331055,
-0.26892709732055664,
0.04778707027435303,
-0.9018439054489136,
-0.11591851711273193,
-0.7009243369102478,
-0.14298699796199799,
-0.5284577012062073,
-0.48508208990097046,
0.44445502758026123,
0.41335025429725647,
-0.3047698438167572,
0.30659475922584534,
-0.4320448637008667,
0.49538761377334595,
0.7952266931533813,
-0.05735624581575394,
0.5551037192344666,
-0.06427190452814102,
-0.3360776901245117,
-0.27781420946121216,
-0.5388720035552979,
-0.773079514503479,
1.136735200881958,
0.20773106813430786,
0.019615434110164642,
-0.0532633438706398,
0.5201484560966492,
0.3644382655620575,
0.5511095523834229,
-0.696972131729126,
0.278988242149353,
-0.2320694625377655,
-0.49126890301704407,
-0.21090897917747498,
-0.9807097315788269,
-0.7096274495124817,
0.27766701579093933,
-0.15118566155433655,
-0.6337021589279175,
0.022240132093429565,
0.1426357924938202,
-0.4064062237739563,
0.2605298161506653,
-0.5219859480857849,
0.981331467628479,
0.002511640079319477,
0.2923779785633087,
-0.10200755298137665,
-0.467552125453949,
0.22405999898910522,
-0.3262489140033722,
0.2885577976703644,
-0.41902685165405273,
0.2431337535381317,
0.9935721755027771,
-0.4774017035961151,
0.3504665195941925,
-0.26392263174057007,
0.0640941858291626,
0.3667117655277252,
0.35796499252319336,
0.5616053938865662,
-0.14106450974941254,
-0.23625287413597107,
0.43661418557167053,
0.47333914041519165,
-0.45829007029533386,
-0.9311779737472534,
0.5148815512657166,
-0.8796088695526123,
-0.14623898267745972,
-0.1332472413778305,
-0.6564444303512573,
-0.49990370869636536,
0.45955169200897217,
0.4007202684879303,
0.2934822738170624,
-0.07354585826396942,
-0.0886499360203743,
0.0913170576095581,
-0.09564743936061859,
0.16231003403663635,
0.802613377571106,
-0.12174981087446213,
-1.0001143217086792,
1.1632707118988037,
0.3892749547958374,
0.47459253668785095,
0.40070343017578125,
0.4765065908432007,
-0.37065160274505615,
-0.6455389857292175,
-0.5763294696807861,
0.1432342380285263,
-0.614899754524231,
-0.37829500436782837,
-0.12609407305717468,
-0.18163548409938812,
0.09470032155513763,
0.030861010774970055,
-0.8625575304031372,
-0.3986228108406067,
-0.06492879986763,
0.19734695553779602,
-0.07937177270650864,
0.7492932677268982,
-0.1299305558204651,
0.5172828435897827,
-1.4195054769515991,
0.32386523485183716,
0.22202198207378387,
0.5881878733634949,
-0.11398059874773026,
-0.9213660359382629,
-0.6449938416481018,
0.323482871055603,
-0.38738998770713806,
-1.0189225673675537,
0.5838027000427246,
-0.019997892901301384,
0.5815362334251404,
0.46079474687576294,
0.26137062907218933,
0.6163638234138489,
-0.4781627357006073,
0.7515097260475159,
0.1432826817035675,
-0.8502120971679688,
0.5544288158416748,
-0.055392853915691376,
0.4492895305156708,
0.6376380920410156,
0.31890472769737244,
-0.5571764707565308,
-0.4515077769756317,
-0.6202544569969177,
-0.5815824866294861,
0.47367554903030396,
0.5334843993186951,
-0.19051435589790344,
0.09661499410867691,
0.4798092544078827,
0.01449959073215723,
0.19922854006290436,
-0.4086809456348419,
-0.3789524435997009,
-0.14347775280475616,
-0.2214469611644745,
-0.076276034116745,
-0.20357149839401245,
0.2151673585176468,
-0.18179607391357422,
0.903388261795044,
0.03165107220411301,
0.4933302700519562,
0.2795223891735077,
-0.2236529290676117,
-0.385745644569397,
-0.024260766804218292,
0.3331083655357361,
0.581341564655304,
-0.47428184747695923,
-0.20660635828971863,
0.2949755787849426,
-0.4398477375507355,
0.18853971362113953,
-0.20122449100017548,
-0.4319133460521698,
0.39391347765922546,
0.09696567058563232,
0.44715312123298645,
-0.03251553326845169,
-0.3489484190940857,
0.4504427909851074,
-0.012406929396092892,
-0.2537213861942291,
-0.1349385380744934,
-0.2082013487815857,
-0.2354569435119629,
0.2554769515991211,
0.04806787520647049,
0.17265304923057556,
0.19372431933879852,
0.03230615705251694,
0.26736506819725037,
0.1447964757680893,
-0.8690798282623291,
-0.609918475151062,
0.6547716856002808,
0.0703168660402298,
-0.30629295110702515,
0.7950944304466248,
-0.3335599899291992,
-0.25217631459236145,
0.5876992344856262,
0.35464444756507874,
1.0142459869384766,
-0.610773503780365,
0.14927226305007935,
0.7242528200149536,
0.29951319098472595,
-0.13944938778877258,
0.1705569475889206,
0.2652563750743866,
-0.597981333732605,
-0.7557897567749023,
-0.6089047789573669,
-0.3980560302734375,
0.08518217504024506,
-0.9951388835906982,
-0.07479517161846161,
-0.078903429210186,
-0.4525166153907776,
-0.2996578514575958,
0.23179641366004944,
-0.6205435991287231,
0.5466731190681458,
-0.1501314342021942,
0.8351789712905884,
-0.9432228803634644,
0.7855768799781799,
0.5967459082603455,
-0.5400306582450867,
-0.7268978953361511,
-0.08134932070970535,
-0.18447019159793854,
-0.3660883903503418,
0.5781921744346619,
-0.05594349279999733,
-0.09810937941074371,
0.05908237397670746,
-0.18704135715961456,
-1.2487702369689941,
1.1905159950256348,
0.40055784583091736,
-0.4546995460987091,
0.06620757281780243,
0.17978057265281677,
0.3389126658439636,
-0.20348814129829407,
0.4571473002433777,
0.4668678641319275,
0.45089733600616455,
-0.26257747411727905,
-1.1637852191925049,
-0.23932737112045288,
-0.31092339754104614,
0.03906945139169693,
0.4995986819267273,
-0.5340825319290161,
0.029716167598962784,
0.09946330636739731,
-0.06610921025276184,
0.31452858448028564,
0.8777763843536377,
-0.1451682150363922,
0.23138427734375,
0.6166337728500366,
0.4706518352031708,
0.8823000192642212,
0.1611175388097763,
0.7197802662849426,
-0.41563352942466736,
0.5456638336181641,
1.2363194227218628,
0.24856813251972198,
1.1059023141860962,
0.21187859773635864,
-0.3611730933189392,
0.2545953094959259,
0.5649122595787048,
-0.15855374932289124,
0.6171811819076538,
-0.060774169862270355,
-0.016667120158672333,
-0.3014259934425354,
-0.011945837177336216,
-0.23421695828437805,
0.44495221972465515,
0.05253797397017479,
-0.7087428569793701,
-0.16484469175338745,
-0.33292606472969055,
-0.19741351902484894,
0.00013551345909945667,
-0.2704910635948181,
0.7823296189308167,
0.11154074221849442,
-0.5167298913002014,
0.5267800092697144,
0.1849891096353531,
0.13413211703300476,
-0.43349167704582214,
0.03033827804028988,
-0.4242604076862335,
0.05078194662928581,
-0.20438869297504425,
-0.4400467574596405,
0.621191680431366,
0.09519413858652115,
-0.57831871509552,
0.012151309289038181,
0.2362770289182663,
-0.32506629824638367,
-0.7543559670448303,
0.05140162259340286,
0.6370729804039001,
0.6226362586021423,
-0.4645485579967499,
-0.5787140130996704,
-0.41887855529785156,
-0.04826740920543671,
-0.1577444225549698,
0.5985641479492188,
0.244478240609169,
-0.07701468467712402,
0.6697794198989868,
0.7600833177566528,
-0.03605585917830467,
-0.025782538577914238,
-0.07294083386659622,
0.5110023021697998,
-0.6438040137290955,
-0.28864625096321106,
-0.635912299156189,
0.5893579125404358,
0.03865426778793335,
-0.3598805069923401,
0.7603079080581665,
0.5802879929542542,
0.8479109406471252,
-0.05305948480963707,
0.6423805952072144,
0.4395616352558136,
0.5641763806343079,
-0.1997763216495514,
0.7556285858154297,
-0.6082963943481445,
-0.032945744693279266,
-0.41476476192474365,
-1.2336161136627197,
-0.30066341161727905,
0.7509397864341736,
-0.35651785135269165,
-0.08465223014354706,
0.7167121171951294,
0.7331836223602295,
-0.230205699801445,
-0.10627161711454391,
0.723645806312561,
-0.039944007992744446,
0.07201601564884186,
0.3916569948196411,
0.6272326111793518,
-0.864875078201294,
0.7914453744888306,
-0.5205249190330505,
-0.1682494431734085,
0.02834438905119896,
-0.9626296758651733,
-0.5493396520614624,
-0.4746898114681244,
-0.5730330944061279,
-0.3913779556751251,
-0.1259060800075531,
0.9845135807991028,
0.6585372686386108,
-0.9739741683006287,
-0.0924624651670456,
0.21180814504623413,
0.009555818513035774,
-0.5439103841781616,
-0.14047081768512726,
0.7887934446334839,
-0.07521490752696991,
-0.8546481728553772,
0.5555719137191772,
0.11348505318164825,
-0.07137324661016464,
-0.11643639951944351,
-0.28838855028152466,
0.1920817792415619,
-0.0026388850528746843,
0.45023491978645325,
0.1284424215555191,
-0.6055129766464233,
-0.17235837876796722,
0.03025193139910698,
-0.02792530320584774,
0.2728496789932251,
0.34178897738456726,
-0.513856828212738,
0.738667368888855,
0.3814811706542969,
0.5080486536026001,
0.08084159344434738,
0.15250161290168762,
0.7553037405014038,
-0.5254754424095154,
-0.3574502170085907,
0.31362396478652954,
0.2831385135650635,
0.24364592134952545,
0.03317874297499657,
0.36179420351982117,
0.41241201758384705,
-0.8741858601570129,
-0.7969485521316528,
0.18738390505313873,
-0.5750778317451477,
0.16991540789604187,
0.9485646486282349,
-0.607372522354126,
-0.2178267538547516,
0.03401657193899155,
-0.023597266525030136,
0.5434235334396362,
-0.18935203552246094,
0.7691113948822021,
0.5747898817062378,
0.19050167500972748,
0.024449728429317474,
-1.1368887424468994,
0.270170658826828,
0.393900603055954,
-0.6265308856964111,
-0.2542753517627716,
0.2953069508075714,
0.5064089298248291,
0.1570490002632141,
0.34708213806152344,
-0.3398496210575104,
0.3511984646320343,
-0.041707854717969894,
0.24382856488227844,
-0.20094512403011322,
-0.13761955499649048,
-0.08679783344268799,
0.18155425786972046,
0.2471691071987152,
-0.5292601585388184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18021v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18021v1
|
CRISPR-GPT: An LLM Agent for Automated Design of Gene-Editing Experiments
| 2024-04-27T22:59:17 | 2024-04-27T22:59:17 |
Kaixuan Huang, Yuanhao Qu, Henry Cousins, William A. Johnson, Di Yin, Mihir Shah, Denny Zhou, Russ Altman, Mengdi Wang, Le Cong
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, q-bio.QM
|
The introduction of genome engineering technology has transformed biomedical
research, making it possible to make precise changes to genetic information.
However, creating an efficient gene-editing system requires a deep
understanding of CRISPR technology, and the complex experimental systems under
investigation. While Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown promise in various
tasks, they often lack specific knowledge and struggle to accurately solve
biological design problems. In this work, we introduce CRISPR-GPT, an LLM agent
augmented with domain knowledge and external tools to automate and enhance the
design process of CRISPR-based gene-editing experiments. CRISPR-GPT leverages
the reasoning ability of LLMs to facilitate the process of selecting CRISPR
systems, designing guide RNAs, recommending cellular delivery methods, drafting
protocols, and designing validation experiments to confirm editing outcomes. We
showcase the potential of CRISPR-GPT for assisting non-expert researchers with
gene-editing experiments from scratch and validate the agent's effectiveness in
a real-world use case. Furthermore, we explore the ethical and regulatory
considerations associated with automated gene-editing design, highlighting the
need for responsible and transparent use of these tools. Our work aims to
bridge the gap between beginner biological researchers and CRISPR genome
engineering techniques, and demonstrate the potential of LLM agents in
facilitating complex biological discovery tasks.
|
[
-0.35875481367111206,
-0.8997177481651306,
0.6955363154411316,
-0.16080637276172638,
-0.1315474808216095,
0.3856682777404785,
-0.06955502182245255,
-0.4219505190849304,
0.4042695462703705,
0.19448114931583405,
-0.4354490339756012,
-0.30766579508781433,
-0.5430426001548767,
0.26693838834762573,
-0.2342536747455597,
0.8910841941833496,
-0.43850985169410706,
0.18680641055107117,
-0.17983262240886688,
0.48503202199935913,
-0.1506636142730713,
-0.36442339420318604,
-0.6123636364936829,
-0.3935376703739166,
0.8966141939163208,
0.24356482923030853,
1.0451369285583496,
0.7357702851295471,
0.531916618347168,
0.3595600724220276,
-0.21312583982944489,
0.1315716952085495,
-0.3674774467945099,
0.03237762674689293,
-0.49312716722488403,
-0.24813303351402283,
-0.6822197437286377,
0.13622954487800598,
0.0021870145574212074,
0.47586947679519653,
0.15434397757053375,
-0.021493516862392426,
-0.0014144775923341513,
0.4449903070926666,
-0.2883851230144501,
-0.007129827048629522,
-0.4341753125190735,
0.20944277942180634,
-0.002621026011183858,
-0.1257888674736023,
-0.0842132717370987,
-0.5469793081283569,
-0.33357733488082886,
-0.9059948921203613,
0.32858362793922424,
-0.09819941222667694,
0.6016136407852173,
0.5132651925086975,
-0.03143415227532387,
-0.3151743412017822,
-0.6867585182189941,
0.15642033517360687,
-0.5807803869247437,
0.3415406346321106,
0.20211249589920044,
0.19895073771476746,
-0.7651675343513489,
-0.653549075126648,
-0.7510988116264343,
-0.655465841293335,
-0.13686877489089966,
0.0052671912126243114,
-0.02652737870812416,
0.352514386177063,
0.3233264088630676,
0.27583205699920654,
-0.62235426902771,
0.12265104055404663,
-0.44541698694229126,
-0.341818243265152,
0.5121473073959351,
-0.13809581100940704,
0.5770056247711182,
-0.14871038496494293,
-0.04215824604034424,
0.027115071192383766,
-0.2716890275478363,
-0.013780759647488594,
0.23293623328208923,
0.01515981089323759,
0.2376341074705124,
0.9922138452529907,
-0.16817925870418549,
0.3206421732902527,
0.28512004017829895,
0.09283332526683807,
0.015787266194820404,
-0.28004056215286255,
-0.37803760170936584,
0.1571943610906601,
0.6780204176902771,
0.18326254189014435,
0.10984119772911072,
-0.17105281352996826,
-0.27128496766090393,
0.10978180170059204,
0.4707397520542145,
-0.661234974861145,
-0.5593909025192261,
0.2492055892944336,
-0.23011966049671173,
-0.38280627131462097,
-0.00508897565305233,
-0.5753642916679382,
-0.5806902647018433,
-0.29233619570732117,
0.7011533379554749,
-0.2955966889858246,
0.015419076196849346,
0.2974632680416107,
-0.5751404166221619,
0.29102855920791626,
0.4654584527015686,
-0.43623536825180054,
-0.0521109364926815,
0.579294741153717,
0.6854039430618286,
-0.04226884990930557,
-0.4030945301055908,
-0.27962660789489746,
0.37076276540756226,
-0.2935810387134552,
0.781491756439209,
-0.6726377010345459,
-0.8483098745346069,
-0.7042449116706848,
0.0823490172624588,
0.09467928111553192,
-0.13654936850070953,
0.5435041189193726,
-0.595040500164032,
-0.244932621717453,
-0.4317060708999634,
-0.764606773853302,
-0.0013113711029291153,
0.09786579757928848,
-0.6231157183647156,
0.45197638869285583,
-0.031116312369704247,
-0.5769360661506653,
0.4062509536743164,
-1.0954442024230957,
-0.44366592168807983,
0.4021669030189514,
-0.41307204961776733,
-0.436861515045166,
-0.01920008659362793,
0.4200877249240875,
0.5323074460029602,
0.00226993253454566,
0.3241729140281677,
-0.32119837403297424,
-0.40539389848709106,
0.46168503165245056,
-0.1164182722568512,
0.40810197591781616,
0.07999710738658905,
-0.3697081208229065,
0.460870623588562,
-0.3991542458534241,
-0.09989196062088013,
0.35098034143447876,
-0.3099983334541321,
-0.03957710042595863,
-0.21307373046875,
-0.03756223991513252,
-0.04315708950161934,
0.2454332858324051,
-0.7124208211898804,
0.7022027373313904,
-0.19021247327327728,
0.4262896180152893,
0.9297234416007996,
0.11849723011255264,
0.48078951239585876,
-0.688452422618866,
0.4190766215324402,
-0.4708919823169708,
0.4514199495315552,
0.0652240514755249,
-0.6523563265800476,
-0.6642922163009644,
-0.21866729855537415,
0.23255397379398346,
0.7749503254890442,
-0.8998182415962219,
0.44764119386672974,
0.008689338341355324,
-0.6132492423057556,
-0.39922046661376953,
0.08301620185375214,
0.1045682281255722,
0.394186407327652,
0.422155499458313,
-0.1216171458363533,
-0.35590898990631104,
-0.9629484415054321,
-0.25525397062301636,
0.007469496224075556,
-0.24028289318084717,
0.23665751516819,
0.7465123534202576,
-0.6646295189857483,
1.1412034034729004,
-0.5262287259101868,
0.013863690197467804,
-0.2745353877544403,
0.16022989153862,
-0.029138803482055664,
0.6681467890739441,
0.31015849113464355,
-0.8050675392150879,
-0.0772288516163826,
0.3767079710960388,
-0.7106851935386658,
-0.29121798276901245,
-0.30270782113075256,
-0.3015933632850647,
-0.18432652950286865,
0.4249781668186188,
-0.6819940805435181,
0.5634205937385559,
0.14648813009262085,
-0.2542422115802765,
0.6532054543495178,
-0.5677748918533325,
0.408142626285553,
-0.8215721845626831,
0.1290847808122635,
-0.13159620761871338,
0.020818142220377922,
-0.8443093299865723,
0.12875373661518097,
0.2038765847682953,
0.02912813052535057,
-0.39864614605903625,
0.6116868257522583,
-0.23981048166751862,
0.0031741405837237835,
-0.367474228143692,
-0.38626906275749207,
0.21011359989643097,
0.3568671941757202,
-0.07661744952201843,
1.1690860986709595,
0.22983971238136292,
-0.32068467140197754,
0.3889160454273224,
0.47488269209861755,
-0.008962717838585377,
0.28256529569625854,
-0.8917370438575745,
0.5262898206710815,
-0.17786894738674164,
0.16063043475151062,
-0.45633408427238464,
-0.541589617729187,
0.6105417013168335,
-0.5118472576141357,
0.11540171504020691,
-0.2648589313030243,
-0.6211596727371216,
-0.35341665148735046,
-0.18278971314430237,
0.19643056392669678,
0.5397123098373413,
-0.37702447175979614,
0.8095006346702576,
0.40701401233673096,
-0.5811996459960938,
-0.15597626566886902,
-0.5027347803115845,
0.4467998743057251,
0.06539979577064514,
-0.5859717726707458,
0.5316591858863831,
-0.46509113907814026,
-0.32224753499031067,
-0.027155041694641113,
0.017098702490329742,
-0.16807571053504944,
-0.03598134592175484,
0.2570863664150238,
0.21870985627174377,
0.19756974279880524,
0.01745418831706047,
0.42201393842697144,
-0.213845893740654,
0.10135450959205627,
-0.17186710238456726,
-0.058931149542331696,
0.07747148722410202,
-0.6271083950996399,
-0.31731393933296204,
0.4203176498413086,
0.6845313906669617,
-0.29652249813079834,
0.14745977520942688,
0.5238373875617981,
-0.4190618395805359,
-0.11804655194282532,
-0.6668908596038818,
-0.11342769861221313,
-0.5279929041862488,
0.21274636685848236,
-0.4708115756511688,
-0.8348498940467834,
0.39111730456352234,
-0.26200589537620544,
-0.029298529028892517,
0.20402327179908752,
0.48747068643569946,
-0.017166070640087128,
0.6691399216651917,
0.48585596680641174,
0.03511643037199974,
0.2633984088897705,
-0.09547174721956253,
-0.03763691708445549,
-0.7327696084976196,
-0.25064101815223694,
-0.304342657327652,
-0.3865724503993988,
-0.22699540853500366,
-0.7706414461135864,
0.6013001203536987,
-0.06284905225038528,
-0.2935890257358551,
0.10569996386766434,
-0.7859103083610535,
0.8623397350311279,
0.6609907746315002,
0.40471556782722473,
0.20464734733104706,
-0.40964943170547485,
-0.32792872190475464,
0.4037812054157257,
-0.5989288687705994,
-0.6416654586791992,
0.6849721074104309,
0.3634127676486969,
1.0752003192901611,
-0.21564777195453644,
0.615626335144043,
0.4254622161388397,
0.32876500487327576,
-0.7859746813774109,
0.5004428029060364,
0.0476713664829731,
-0.4050717055797577,
-0.32069459557533264,
-0.2826089859008789,
-0.689235270023346,
-0.002918954472988844,
-0.061247847974300385,
-0.36667191982269287,
0.3590109348297119,
0.1803169846534729,
-0.41210874915122986,
0.5456497073173523,
-0.6087977290153503,
0.695659875869751,
-0.4442828297615051,
-0.16899238526821136,
0.1316535472869873,
-0.7013019323348999,
0.12287326157093048,
-0.35907402634620667,
0.2572987973690033,
0.16207575798034668,
-0.13290764391422272,
0.5651119351387024,
-0.4413857161998749,
0.8893663287162781,
-0.2107166349887848,
-0.13167984783649445,
-0.03411237150430679,
0.41170597076416016,
0.9041974544525146,
0.1471197009086609,
-0.13885177671909332,
0.024298235774040222,
-0.2777552008628845,
-0.11089998483657837,
-0.512877881526947,
0.4751323163509369,
-0.6635051965713501,
-0.6657642722129822,
-0.1420922726392746,
-0.4595416188240051,
0.06757451593875885,
0.28297242522239685,
0.18722251057624817,
-0.12433502078056335,
-0.20850446820259094,
-0.23837774991989136,
0.8479025959968567,
-0.48434460163116455,
-0.03492116928100586,
0.27360716462135315,
-0.17487992346286774,
-0.3851017355918884,
0.7500391602516174,
0.04368934780359268,
0.20973636209964752,
0.23605822026729584,
0.415111780166626,
0.06642836332321167,
-0.8243199586868286,
-0.5590017437934875,
-0.03868156298995018,
-0.6317616105079651,
-0.07274594902992249,
-0.791085958480835,
-0.24968977272510529,
-0.2601048946380615,
-0.8030470609664917,
-0.13306987285614014,
-0.1480027586221695,
-0.38609689474105835,
-0.19990000128746033,
0.6322708129882812,
0.9367890357971191,
-0.24678193032741547,
-0.008223149925470352,
-0.7472261190414429,
0.724131166934967,
0.4665505588054657,
0.295604944229126,
-0.5107388496398926,
-0.3037646412849426,
-0.0546233132481575,
0.16057823598384857,
-0.04848966747522354,
-0.9346526265144348,
0.27210474014282227,
0.04327351972460747,
0.613789975643158,
-0.1391066014766693,
-0.19287855923175812,
0.4808257520198822,
-0.7029362320899963,
0.5507364869117737,
-0.29475510120391846,
-0.9667651653289795,
0.6688713431358337,
-0.5354785323143005,
0.09063874185085297,
0.2050621509552002,
0.17444051802158356,
-0.5494223237037659,
-0.6044037342071533,
-0.35305216908454895,
-0.5753010511398315,
0.22318607568740845,
0.39702674746513367,
-0.1710965633392334,
0.16282734274864197,
0.8012375235557556,
0.46684589982032776,
0.12705379724502563,
-0.4053672254085541,
-0.06526925414800644,
-0.3984964191913605,
0.05982706695795059,
0.11403406411409378,
-0.06019197404384613,
-0.11773106455802917,
-0.305416464805603,
0.6738932728767395,
-0.22946172952651978,
0.31011494994163513,
0.5899247527122498,
-0.11670751124620438,
-0.20053626596927643,
0.5380587577819824,
0.6235219240188599,
0.39822515845298767,
-0.16775472462177277,
-0.10245601087808609,
0.1325017660856247,
-0.6604295372962952,
0.3075809180736542,
0.5454148054122925,
-0.2511816918849945,
-0.364273339509964,
0.11255098134279251,
0.3864571750164032,
-0.059071291238069534,
-0.4978495240211487,
0.17027434706687927,
-0.16614305973052979,
-0.4247961938381195,
-0.01933988742530346,
0.3328103721141815,
0.053091373294591904,
0.5146771669387817,
0.34277239441871643,
0.31915348768234253,
0.32723185420036316,
-0.00643933517858386,
0.5131292939186096,
0.44965147972106934,
-0.03212502598762512,
-0.16636675596237183,
0.8352177143096924,
0.18366163969039917,
-0.3843475878238678,
0.30764931440353394,
-0.4665946364402771,
-0.4833044409751892,
0.8951329588890076,
0.2159750610589981,
0.9683542251586914,
-0.2638145089149475,
0.2823234498500824,
-0.21601320803165436,
0.4454996585845947,
0.10795770585536957,
0.3159967362880707,
0.27165284752845764,
-0.648387610912323,
-0.5052536129951477,
-0.43341249227523804,
-0.7793216705322266,
0.05671081691980362,
-0.15654560923576355,
0.08673691004514694,
-0.420340895652771,
-0.03670598566532135,
0.32485446333885193,
-0.2619822323322296,
-0.5222502946853638,
0.028613097965717316,
-0.11549431830644608,
0.7694535851478577,
-0.5264732837677002,
0.8537924289703369,
0.8037933707237244,
-0.14797794818878174,
-0.6317638158798218,
-0.19104400277137756,
0.26244503259658813,
-0.7617431879043579,
0.4959859848022461,
-0.05504722148180008,
-0.21200419962406158,
0.05779772624373436,
-0.7055002450942993,
-0.5843089818954468,
1.041247844696045,
0.3587004542350769,
-0.6514204740524292,
0.007021043449640274,
0.07201573997735977,
0.47107604146003723,
0.06263040751218796,
-0.061311025172472,
0.34797894954681396,
0.8219022154808044,
0.5103365182876587,
-0.8709473013877869,
0.06241089850664139,
-0.47291049361228943,
-0.11569737643003464,
0.2988604009151459,
-0.12389841675758362,
0.8300301432609558,
-0.4952511787414551,
-0.05150987580418587,
0.1436372697353363,
0.49286559224128723,
0.13163092732429504,
0.2651512026786804,
0.2382679283618927,
0.2589836120605469,
0.7923568487167358,
0.1701524257659912,
0.9119128584861755,
-0.18422047793865204,
0.0017278700834140182,
0.9555821418762207,
-0.3252633810043335,
0.2370346039533615,
0.42344754934310913,
-0.013652056455612183,
-0.09690804779529572,
0.6465591192245483,
-0.2951880693435669,
0.06302859634160995,
0.5059539675712585,
-0.3666759729385376,
-0.11396053433418274,
-0.1084948480129242,
-0.3263835310935974,
-0.07509346306324005,
0.5399484038352966,
-0.1400260329246521,
0.0563448928296566,
0.3886743485927582,
0.10183746367692947,
-0.07993573695421219,
-0.43527308106422424,
0.8219090104103088,
-0.16603204607963562,
-0.025960693135857582,
-0.051360294222831726,
0.08399798721075058,
0.6619573831558228,
-0.46528396010398865,
-0.23487454652786255,
-0.12291846424341202,
-0.0956224650144577,
-0.04320661351084709,
-1.0072888135910034,
0.2012302428483963,
0.21647661924362183,
-0.04781395569443703,
-0.16717574000358582,
0.9385665059089661,
-0.20545215904712677,
-0.8079284429550171,
0.13218465447425842,
0.6516199707984924,
0.0840650275349617,
-0.007761712651699781,
-0.7770670056343079,
0.13733384013175964,
-0.1934773176908493,
-0.38876035809516907,
0.018804902210831642,
0.3477713465690613,
0.17137683928012848,
0.7371677160263062,
0.9063634276390076,
0.23623330891132355,
-0.23329636454582214,
-0.0924890786409378,
1.1027226448059082,
-0.8138540387153625,
-0.24945685267448425,
-0.924262523651123,
0.341754287481308,
0.1437324583530426,
0.21787501871585846,
0.37747135758399963,
0.34216567873954773,
0.8002688884735107,
-0.18550370633602142,
1.2233245372772217,
-0.05501748248934746,
0.2866538465023041,
-0.5647172927856445,
0.8866426348686218,
-0.17433127760887146,
0.06261349469423294,
-0.22024349868297577,
-0.5039303302764893,
-0.5742575526237488,
0.5555035471916199,
-0.1589333415031433,
0.2715892195701599,
0.38135606050491333,
1.083105206489563,
0.03449021279811859,
0.07210330665111542,
0.2426055520772934,
0.4080542325973511,
0.8503146171569824,
0.2936399281024933,
0.8439282178878784,
0.0945567861199379,
0.14048373699188232,
-0.3546789884567261,
-0.5129790306091309,
0.05014657601714134,
-1.0451911687850952,
-1.0242664813995361,
-0.2866200804710388,
-0.08301600813865662,
0.13878244161605835,
0.47277459502220154,
1.4014160633087158,
0.353209912776947,
-0.35755982995033264,
0.020379969850182533,
-0.17603644728660583,
0.07518769800662994,
-0.10427410155534744,
-0.13376624882221222,
0.34865909814834595,
-0.15501421689987183,
-0.45593446493148804,
0.812376081943512,
0.47547194361686707,
0.6188849806785583,
-0.24054887890815735,
-0.052082568407058716,
0.09745299071073532,
0.15448899567127228,
0.3575020432472229,
0.43916112184524536,
-0.6556414365768433,
-0.2998095750808716,
0.10854917764663696,
-0.14130815863609314,
0.053502749651670456,
0.9550804495811462,
-0.7393026947975159,
0.39465832710266113,
0.27253344655036926,
0.9682687520980835,
-0.018069328740239143,
0.026737187057733536,
0.6445163488388062,
-0.1656542718410492,
-0.3337627947330475,
0.1845191866159439,
0.23055972158908844,
0.1741507202386856,
-1.0249804258346558,
0.3930000960826874,
0.10409248620271683,
-0.9230418801307678,
-0.3590502440929413,
0.09372615814208984,
-0.9745576977729797,
-0.4595014154911041,
1.168809413909912,
0.08964142203330994,
-0.27796339988708496,
-0.34845486283302307,
-0.8129770755767822,
0.3353799283504486,
-0.5303574204444885,
0.7759371399879456,
0.3791866600513458,
-0.31680914759635925,
-0.01583925262093544,
-0.6123744249343872,
0.6421718001365662,
-0.10912442952394485,
-1.1674188375473022,
0.045257192105054855,
0.3785220980644226,
0.08912190049886703,
-0.18306900560855865,
0.5518656969070435,
0.09051976352930069,
0.313586950302124,
-0.2279520034790039,
0.31648051738739014,
-0.5437028408050537,
-0.28822582960128784,
-0.2016577273607254,
-0.03787987679243088,
0.11982300132513046,
0.11137988418340683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17999v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17999v1
|
MediFact at MEDIQA-CORR 2024: Why AI Needs a Human Touch
| 2024-04-27T20:28:38 | 2024-04-27T20:28:38 |
Nadia Saeed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Accurate representation of medical information is crucial for patient safety,
yet artificial intelligence (AI) systems, such as Large Language Models (LLMs),
encounter challenges in error-free clinical text interpretation. This paper
presents a novel approach submitted to the MEDIQA-CORR 2024 shared task (Ben
Abacha et al., 2024a), focusing on the automatic correction of single-word
errors in clinical notes. Unlike LLMs that rely on extensive generic data, our
method emphasizes extracting contextually relevant information from available
clinical text data. Leveraging an ensemble of extractive and abstractive
question-answering approaches, we construct a supervised learning framework
with domain-specific feature engineering. Our methodology incorporates domain
expertise to enhance error correction accuracy. By integrating domain expertise
and prioritizing meaningful information extraction, our approach underscores
the significance of a human-centric strategy in adapting AI for healthcare.
|
[
0.07678890973329544,
-0.5349398255348206,
0.5422182679176331,
0.32485711574554443,
-0.03935617953538895,
0.11628469824790955,
0.025269856676459312,
-0.6621420979499817,
0.20018409192562103,
0.7393203973770142,
-0.6741675734519958,
-0.5712994933128357,
-0.6428515315055847,
0.2914012372493744,
-0.07870316505432129,
1.08196222782135,
-0.29905036091804504,
0.1628861427307129,
-0.5749608874320984,
-0.5342451930046082,
-0.32680079340934753,
-0.6885775923728943,
-0.6059557795524597,
-0.33832013607025146,
0.7182573676109314,
0.5780473351478577,
0.4851587116718292,
0.661854088306427,
1.0307685136795044,
0.28411850333213806,
0.45645755529403687,
0.43469011783599854,
0.037354353815317154,
-0.31014224886894226,
-0.06702494621276855,
-0.33040809631347656,
-1.1466842889785767,
0.04598858207464218,
0.1339748501777649,
0.7975619435310364,
-0.1254940927028656,
-0.1424485146999359,
-0.08823035657405853,
0.6404472589492798,
-0.18157744407653809,
0.3206372857093811,
-0.28191474080085754,
-0.0066818734630942345,
-0.011029270477592945,
-0.4532860517501831,
-0.48318037390708923,
-0.21614518761634827,
0.262485146522522,
-0.8670305013656616,
0.3344407379627228,
0.0736340805888176,
0.8353359699249268,
0.7023436427116394,
-0.3076414167881012,
-0.42364662885665894,
-0.3241012692451477,
0.6650479435920715,
-0.5603312253952026,
0.16378635168075562,
0.5360108017921448,
0.05550963431596756,
-0.20195281505584717,
-0.8610644936561584,
-0.4167120158672333,
0.1753160059452057,
-0.35525453090667725,
0.11168670654296875,
0.08566400408744812,
0.3740040361881256,
0.06378857791423798,
0.03734791278839111,
-0.1889331042766571,
0.0592447891831398,
-0.4222814738750458,
-0.2640508711338043,
1.008359432220459,
0.17808592319488525,
0.5806218981742859,
0.08218236267566681,
-0.3789403736591339,
-0.18957780301570892,
-0.4276084005832672,
-0.05566195398569107,
-0.45290258526802063,
0.22352400422096252,
-0.3998158276081085,
0.32086488604545593,
0.03685321286320686,
0.4953716993331909,
-0.08240281790494919,
-0.16044573485851288,
0.3095493018627167,
-0.16382135450839996,
-0.296365886926651,
0.08721430599689484,
0.8552258014678955,
0.34611794352531433,
0.09094014018774033,
-0.26346972584724426,
-0.002401762641966343,
0.0292986948043108,
0.5926730632781982,
-0.5201560854911804,
-0.41885676980018616,
0.4647539556026459,
-0.3481388986110687,
-0.41423943638801575,
0.1116228699684143,
-0.786191463470459,
-0.49747616052627563,
-0.297381728887558,
0.3661843240261078,
-0.2965014576911926,
0.23393715918064117,
0.33194246888160706,
0.03966306895017624,
-0.21502931416034698,
0.7148873209953308,
-0.6778143644332886,
0.37213438749313354,
0.5585028529167175,
0.35874977707862854,
-0.27777838706970215,
-0.30342113971710205,
-0.6657493710517883,
0.16985812783241272,
-0.12115922570228577,
0.8313631415367126,
-0.19721609354019165,
-0.20274384319782257,
-0.3062440752983093,
-0.00610724464058876,
-0.4010024070739746,
-0.6101037859916687,
0.7435435056686401,
-0.3112085163593292,
0.3843690752983093,
-0.14453598856925964,
-0.48350340127944946,
-0.19932600855827332,
0.0553918182849884,
-0.7416619658470154,
0.47040584683418274,
0.38070452213287354,
-0.7069816589355469,
0.5082024335861206,
-1.1498291492462158,
-0.47525471448898315,
0.2222273200750351,
-0.3771229684352875,
-0.7280301451683044,
0.004779723007231951,
0.4940369427204132,
0.38466542959213257,
-0.0841090977191925,
0.40160661935806274,
-0.08020941913127899,
-0.09348372370004654,
0.3333582878112793,
-0.24635480344295502,
0.6855891346931458,
-0.048070043325424194,
-0.32804766297340393,
0.3346324563026428,
-1.0060306787490845,
0.09996819496154785,
-0.006679580081254244,
-0.42482683062553406,
-0.18950913846492767,
0.02876577153801918,
0.2569305896759033,
0.2350849211215973,
0.07390338182449341,
-0.5056402087211609,
0.1603870689868927,
-0.29086554050445557,
0.4035104811191559,
0.5199155211448669,
0.11919478327035904,
0.3243310749530792,
-0.5358152985572815,
0.5483040809631348,
0.03763412684202194,
0.17974092066287994,
-0.17616143822669983,
-0.4402177929878235,
-0.49038636684417725,
-0.6928819417953491,
0.2912783920764923,
0.7185705900192261,
-0.5418292880058289,
0.35413849353790283,
-0.19620825350284576,
-0.19893018901348114,
-0.8707100749015808,
0.14498819410800934,
0.408078134059906,
0.656125545501709,
0.6692668795585632,
-0.2638225555419922,
-0.7329148054122925,
-0.6517884731292725,
-0.39418449997901917,
-0.18231169879436493,
0.005403011105954647,
0.41268911957740784,
0.29622554779052734,
-0.6548625230789185,
0.9810943007469177,
-0.41369280219078064,
-0.6698958873748779,
-0.24400295317173004,
0.3821588456630707,
-0.018730049952864647,
0.6290798783302307,
0.09919034689664841,
-1.0251109600067139,
-0.1825023889541626,
0.07230624556541443,
-0.954623818397522,
-0.31793951988220215,
-0.3197598457336426,
0.0738835409283638,
0.22019656002521515,
0.5573804974555969,
-0.5564930438995361,
0.620811402797699,
0.45516276359558105,
-0.36151739954948425,
-0.03843282163143158,
-0.6664108633995056,
0.25221696496009827,
-0.9212841987609863,
0.24337777495384216,
-0.01724310778081417,
-0.18838046491146088,
-0.7177108526229858,
0.034195251762866974,
0.3012970983982086,
0.1331087350845337,
-0.18598532676696777,
0.7097525596618652,
-0.28149545192718506,
0.32935115694999695,
-0.17640064656734467,
-0.09796758741140366,
0.3104216754436493,
0.4048062860965729,
0.05848299711942673,
0.5591776371002197,
-0.1944805383682251,
-0.34056556224823,
0.13009214401245117,
0.6894332766532898,
0.04662645608186722,
0.537183403968811,
-0.5318264365196228,
0.3520466983318329,
-0.08665062487125397,
0.18518416583538055,
-0.7333207130432129,
-0.7359609603881836,
0.19191093742847443,
-0.47728410363197327,
0.3098491430282593,
0.23846837878227234,
-0.19120141863822937,
-0.34475576877593994,
0.08175615221261978,
0.4255395829677582,
0.03553905710577965,
-0.31359025835990906,
0.6642037630081177,
0.5844564437866211,
-0.43409958481788635,
-0.5246004462242126,
-0.6474298238754272,
0.3482935428619385,
0.08297780901193619,
-0.5376172661781311,
0.37966251373291016,
0.03813920542597771,
-0.32904425263404846,
-0.12089858204126358,
0.1696375012397766,
-0.2464754283428192,
0.39472946524620056,
0.49894294142723083,
0.4648413062095642,
-0.08324505388736725,
0.24611370265483856,
0.14700785279273987,
-0.12052657455205917,
0.14975924789905548,
0.05718128755688667,
0.24736569821834564,
0.012262271717190742,
-0.422959566116333,
-0.7832430601119995,
0.40749144554138184,
0.7912552356719971,
-0.3306938111782074,
0.4126231372356415,
0.32038575410842896,
-0.5804048776626587,
0.01194190513342619,
-0.32659509778022766,
-0.2220393419265747,
-0.4376300275325775,
0.42849841713905334,
-0.07352185249328613,
-0.8091745376586914,
0.245475634932518,
0.19375252723693848,
-0.021131910383701324,
0.5672966241836548,
0.21326494216918945,
-0.4333101212978363,
1.0441930294036865,
0.9277905821800232,
-0.16726194322109222,
-0.15270501375198364,
0.07446283102035522,
0.19622711837291718,
-0.5099450349807739,
-0.3907027244567871,
-0.6006110906600952,
-0.009907952509820461,
-0.32116609811782837,
-0.47269579768180847,
0.5826553702354431,
-0.20963847637176514,
-0.016538692638278008,
0.04141848906874657,
-0.4546380341053009,
-0.10047882795333862,
0.4079377353191376,
0.5076949000358582,
0.373383104801178,
0.02068823017179966,
-0.02136440947651863,
-0.1144205629825592,
-0.7455384731292725,
-0.47536012530326843,
0.865328848361969,
0.5107470154762268,
0.6914126873016357,
-0.2635262906551361,
0.6200408935546875,
0.4676508903503418,
0.697350800037384,
-0.5553879141807556,
0.225428506731987,
-0.20453204214572906,
-0.422061562538147,
-0.3802530765533447,
-0.20229598879814148,
-0.8192120790481567,
-0.15841132402420044,
-0.31593313813209534,
-0.3393426835536957,
0.13509929180145264,
0.26001644134521484,
-0.6356372833251953,
0.1726207435131073,
-0.5767329931259155,
1.0944570302963257,
-0.3159761428833008,
-0.19663363695144653,
-0.01012286264449358,
-0.7940765023231506,
-0.1268308460712433,
-0.1892114132642746,
0.4665263891220093,
0.16510489583015442,
-0.22033850848674774,
0.6265280246734619,
-0.4986226558685303,
0.9720128178596497,
-0.10839355736970901,
-0.2337442934513092,
0.047801293432712555,
-0.11588992178440094,
0.447221964597702,
-0.24170838296413422,
-0.017588797956705093,
0.042410753667354584,
0.06933190673589706,
-0.5902387499809265,
-0.4777236580848694,
0.06508427858352661,
-0.7299627065658569,
-0.40029245615005493,
-0.37126803398132324,
-0.897169291973114,
-0.3771921396255493,
0.07682842016220093,
0.21915271878242493,
0.6497189402580261,
-0.31742551922798157,
-0.1488640159368515,
0.43291065096855164,
-0.32145968079566956,
0.13346105813980103,
0.2740285098552704,
0.08204202353954315,
-0.4589381515979767,
0.7400733828544617,
-0.1483761966228485,
0.04473795369267464,
0.581920862197876,
0.08384714275598526,
-0.13492120802402496,
-0.7245737314224243,
-0.6568247079849243,
0.4180614650249481,
-0.5377389192581177,
0.033422041684389114,
-1.1070387363433838,
-0.12688426673412323,
-0.3477341830730438,
-0.27382397651672363,
-0.03891635686159134,
-0.21984800696372986,
-0.5888302326202393,
0.026687147095799446,
0.44514772295951843,
0.7882218360900879,
0.11277901381254196,
0.3676421344280243,
-1.3481416702270508,
0.2762618958950043,
0.07383989542722702,
0.2567061185836792,
-0.4951778054237366,
-0.3773505389690399,
-0.36055508255958557,
-0.07068658620119095,
0.055711500346660614,
-0.3335222601890564,
0.4528005123138428,
0.35669755935668945,
0.3829730451107025,
0.1024329662322998,
0.02891589142382145,
0.5201062560081482,
-0.4703224003314972,
0.45869866013526917,
0.18106578290462494,
-0.7060146927833557,
0.591358482837677,
-0.38581353425979614,
0.2271631509065628,
0.9324364066123962,
0.3108273446559906,
-0.7584041357040405,
-0.26188668608665466,
-0.7451329231262207,
-0.6316608190536499,
0.5694364905357361,
-0.36292409896850586,
-0.21149961650371552,
0.1267567127943039,
0.4465785324573517,
0.21308329701423645,
0.21538980305194855,
-0.29032132029533386,
0.03209647908806801,
0.27151286602020264,
-1.0332884788513184,
-0.18052387237548828,
-0.11510640382766724,
-0.31032416224479675,
-0.0526028648018837,
0.45719850063323975,
-0.5939503312110901,
0.2910807430744171,
0.6924276351928711,
-0.30674582719802856,
-0.4317964017391205,
0.2341623604297638,
0.80219966173172,
0.9115172028541565,
-0.3487393260002136,
-0.09280388057231903,
-0.05947115272283554,
-0.8846279382705688,
-0.022595703601837158,
0.18161989748477936,
-0.045214299112558365,
-0.15887831151485443,
0.5304175019264221,
0.522549569606781,
0.1506495475769043,
-1.025732159614563,
0.6354111433029175,
-0.22548934817314148,
-0.17556117475032806,
-0.22210721671581268,
-0.00979380402714014,
-0.17685380578041077,
-0.05217118561267853,
0.4310704469680786,
0.5836919546127319,
0.06735705584287643,
-0.35806789994239807,
0.6639983057975769,
0.05640101805329323,
-0.7847310304641724,
-0.37098583579063416,
0.8431897163391113,
0.2630155682563782,
-0.30888888239860535,
0.37418967485427856,
0.15882508456707,
-0.5825238227844238,
0.6367501616477966,
0.14766395092010498,
0.6613573431968689,
-0.11718977242708206,
0.16101831197738647,
0.10465448349714279,
0.0742528960108757,
-0.0047873565927147865,
0.3015393316745758,
0.26222145557403564,
-0.7027814984321594,
-0.6107112169265747,
-0.10522612929344177,
-0.7178477048873901,
-0.0878789946436882,
-0.6812199354171753,
0.23141391575336456,
-0.6488304734230042,
0.16492153704166412,
0.10424261540174484,
-0.009497031569480896,
-0.5362021923065186,
0.6431072354316711,
-0.05957673117518425,
0.9171189665794373,
-0.6135866641998291,
0.8320273160934448,
0.7918375134468079,
-0.3219210207462311,
-0.9374750256538391,
-0.1527504026889801,
0.04943951591849327,
-0.7175347208976746,
0.5792092084884644,
-0.026530830189585686,
0.14588432013988495,
-0.15221410989761353,
-0.575998067855835,
-0.5095392465591431,
0.8618327379226685,
-0.03887496143579483,
-0.4772348701953888,
-0.2245173305273056,
0.38871249556541443,
0.7104829549789429,
-0.5595889687538147,
0.09681951254606247,
0.5609342455863953,
0.23912659287452698,
-0.25826483964920044,
-1.0675617456436157,
0.06746429949998856,
-0.21746337413787842,
-0.6955565810203552,
0.13527153432369232,
-0.5539374947547913,
0.6130693554878235,
-0.5396543741226196,
0.19892939925193787,
0.14950011670589447,
0.5542008280754089,
0.06126157566905022,
0.7770440578460693,
0.2617378830909729,
0.6533894538879395,
1.0628483295440674,
0.025849629193544388,
1.062868356704712,
-0.018435552716255188,
0.13239151239395142,
1.1869322061538696,
-0.4624686539173126,
0.6834154725074768,
0.5534895062446594,
-0.2899215519428253,
0.5212242603302002,
0.390590637922287,
0.24485965073108673,
0.2749631106853485,
-0.10583500564098358,
-0.2935281991958618,
-0.04677131772041321,
-0.050287630409002304,
0.024628164246678352,
0.6272221207618713,
0.5184697508811951,
-0.41244596242904663,
0.1386617124080658,
0.1515604555606842,
0.19950519502162933,
0.29160061478614807,
-0.3172890841960907,
0.83295738697052,
0.1127539649605751,
-0.8157856464385986,
0.29502320289611816,
-0.1537441909313202,
0.4898160994052887,
-0.24513229727745056,
-0.27374306321144104,
-0.17979688942432404,
0.5843598246574402,
-0.33096495270729065,
-0.27063116431236267,
0.1687701791524887,
-0.053427889943122864,
-0.366710901260376,
-0.22756758332252502,
0.7167986631393433,
-0.45730873942375183,
-0.5004109144210815,
0.15704502165317535,
0.465679407119751,
0.038429588079452515,
-0.07733049243688583,
-0.7845890522003174,
-0.06956550478935242,
0.14880581200122833,
0.23305656015872955,
0.2701689898967743,
0.4484385848045349,
-0.22365416586399078,
0.6163948178291321,
0.4307384490966797,
0.278501033782959,
-0.12164849787950516,
0.06138661503791809,
0.5792054533958435,
-0.646996259689331,
-0.3370114266872406,
-0.5009029507637024,
0.5686466097831726,
-0.13348397612571716,
-0.2168618142604828,
0.2555372714996338,
0.2899944484233856,
0.4933669865131378,
0.039131585508584976,
1.0748591423034668,
0.07685482501983643,
1.0419219732284546,
-0.27223721146583557,
0.8585119843482971,
-0.5270783305168152,
0.10232414305210114,
-0.19389964640140533,
-0.17501717805862427,
-0.664919376373291,
0.3932863771915436,
-0.20794247090816498,
-0.22078202664852142,
0.7048391699790955,
0.704891562461853,
0.11843586713075638,
0.2560499310493469,
0.2954087555408478,
0.27376651763916016,
0.4533620774745941,
0.47436287999153137,
0.3894481956958771,
-0.9253847002983093,
0.13092230260372162,
-0.2592277228832245,
-0.23194383084774017,
-0.3414532244205475,
-0.779442548751831,
-0.6497865915298462,
-0.4741080105304718,
-0.6230253577232361,
-0.44842201471328735,
-0.0004298910207580775,
1.4364134073257446,
0.5131895542144775,
-1.1198089122772217,
0.1045374944806099,
0.08056976646184921,
-0.08247439563274384,
-0.23516720533370972,
-0.11841996759176254,
0.7368290424346924,
-0.3605973422527313,
-0.527390718460083,
0.34947919845581055,
0.5833530426025391,
0.02388158068060875,
0.1683632731437683,
-0.09541071951389313,
-0.22982178628444672,
-0.0501614585518837,
0.3949739336967468,
0.2801760733127594,
-0.3083447515964508,
-0.3621109127998352,
0.06280417740345001,
-0.6711570024490356,
0.5021920204162598,
0.8987610936164856,
-0.6066972613334656,
0.3671714961528778,
0.16361874341964722,
1.0779839754104614,
0.05019664391875267,
0.20339980721473694,
0.5718498229980469,
-0.2511834502220154,
0.07372177392244339,
0.47977519035339355,
0.25092801451683044,
0.41888919472694397,
-0.558867335319519,
0.5936160683631897,
0.5847923159599304,
-0.6010413765907288,
-0.5272185206413269,
-0.33302292227745056,
-1.2074986696243286,
-0.1097935140132904,
0.8080793619155884,
-0.3697511553764343,
-0.5540655851364136,
-0.6211249232292175,
-0.4494118392467499,
0.11245374381542206,
-0.0902787446975708,
0.8771566152572632,
0.37899377942085266,
-0.1999809890985489,
-0.31167781352996826,
-0.5608441829681396,
0.7729799151420593,
0.5007575154304504,
-1.101759672164917,
-0.17315630614757538,
0.35302847623825073,
0.11524869501590729,
0.1275692582130432,
0.8609958291053772,
-0.25382182002067566,
0.6442962288856506,
-0.36551204323768616,
0.43796050548553467,
0.10237453132867813,
-0.3959597945213318,
-0.39758098125457764,
0.15050660073757172,
0.0590163879096508,
-0.005931899882853031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01583v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01583v1
|
MediFact at MEDIQA-M3G 2024: Medical Question Answering in Dermatology with Multimodal Learning
| 2024-04-27T20:03:47 | 2024-04-27T20:03:47 |
Nadia Saeed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
The MEDIQA-M3G 2024 challenge necessitates novel solutions for Multilingual &
Multimodal Medical Answer Generation in dermatology (wai Yim et al., 2024a).
This paper addresses the limitations of traditional methods by proposing a
weakly supervised learning approach for open-ended medical question-answering
(QA). Our system leverages readily available MEDIQA-M3G images via a
VGG16-CNN-SVM model, enabling multilingual (English, Chinese, Spanish) learning
of informative skin condition representations. Using pre-trained QA models, we
further bridge the gap between visual and textual information through
multimodal fusion. This approach tackles complex, open-ended questions even
without predefined answer choices. We empower the generation of comprehensive
answers by feeding the ViT-CLIP model with multiple responses alongside images.
This work advances medical QA research, paving the way for clinical decision
support systems and ultimately improving healthcare delivery.
|
[
-0.35356611013412476,
-0.8409906029701233,
0.7190951704978943,
-0.06940945982933044,
-0.3611416816711426,
0.07331731170415878,
-0.055673904716968536,
-0.6392577290534973,
0.32748347520828247,
0.5587601661682129,
-1.0661357641220093,
-0.6941555738449097,
-0.3266254663467407,
0.06380476802587509,
0.21819886565208435,
1.1388585567474365,
-0.031234143301844597,
0.4931831955909729,
-0.6958419680595398,
-0.6193459630012512,
-0.20201997458934784,
-0.3836839199066162,
-0.6049600839614868,
0.002703985897824168,
0.7561208605766296,
0.5765629410743713,
0.6686663031578064,
0.08848923444747925,
0.9067525863647461,
0.3344130218029022,
0.35492414236068726,
0.3679204285144806,
-0.05929649621248245,
0.18586313724517822,
-0.06491630524396896,
-0.561086893081665,
-0.49355635046958923,
0.12442545592784882,
0.19744692742824554,
0.7818146347999573,
-0.15143688023090363,
0.3638516068458557,
-0.6304596662521362,
0.5643739700317383,
-0.3356129229068756,
0.017352499067783356,
-0.2660140097141266,
0.1088472455739975,
0.08466648310422897,
-0.058512311428785324,
-0.2218906581401825,
-0.1392611265182495,
0.17342323064804077,
-0.41736239194869995,
0.18550847470760345,
-0.28236037492752075,
0.8037691116333008,
0.5364140272140503,
-0.7271450757980347,
0.030351588502526283,
-0.6069322228431702,
0.46230006217956543,
-0.646641731262207,
0.1537899672985077,
0.476053923368454,
0.6402269601821899,
0.23105521500110626,
-0.9096364974975586,
-0.3025117814540863,
0.07132721692323685,
-0.19031012058258057,
0.5067974925041199,
0.06894730776548386,
-0.06672433018684387,
-0.05103500932455063,
0.2576495110988617,
-0.5790382623672485,
-0.0600697360932827,
-0.6072069406509399,
-0.04479054734110832,
0.4766082167625427,
0.042134977877140045,
0.40749186277389526,
0.01835535280406475,
-0.7823355793952942,
0.0805700272321701,
-0.4895424246788025,
0.17391708493232727,
-0.25682327151298523,
-0.05240701511502266,
-0.16409286856651306,
0.5776491165161133,
-0.16681434214115143,
0.5139308571815491,
-0.12272503972053528,
-0.1674744039773941,
0.483120322227478,
-0.6089833378791809,
-0.12211648374795914,
-0.33075058460235596,
0.7852306962013245,
0.3952503502368927,
-0.1927793323993683,
-0.0373188778758049,
0.03130492940545082,
-0.25368428230285645,
0.2507283389568329,
-0.9739997386932373,
0.02712683007121086,
0.5750890374183655,
-0.6197341680526733,
-0.33892905712127686,
0.07055871933698654,
-0.9886779189109802,
-0.36786624789237976,
-0.1225888803601265,
0.450300931930542,
-0.09267885237932205,
-0.3143594563007355,
0.08727075159549713,
-0.04722056910395622,
0.24745096266269684,
0.45140448212623596,
-0.4879954755306244,
0.3075271546840668,
-0.016998443752527237,
0.4546520709991455,
0.020824585109949112,
0.016106832772493362,
-0.39990234375,
0.03748665004968643,
-0.16902011632919312,
0.7055917978286743,
-0.4250513017177582,
-0.15012335777282715,
-0.19234424829483032,
0.2939958870410919,
-0.3881882429122925,
-0.6116244792938232,
0.30645689368247986,
-0.5259917974472046,
0.5825028419494629,
-0.0944928452372551,
0.044053833931684494,
-0.3534623086452484,
0.473279744386673,
-0.5122715830802917,
0.5322948098182678,
0.4294266402721405,
-0.6064944267272949,
0.10373127460479736,
-0.5744441151618958,
-0.05263201519846916,
-0.02031186781823635,
-0.15592564642429352,
-0.8340438604354858,
0.047789763659238815,
0.46744605898857117,
0.43017688393592834,
-0.34698113799095154,
0.3201707899570465,
-0.43718016147613525,
-0.034816186875104904,
0.507591187953949,
-0.5030550956726074,
0.6005749106407166,
0.05092417076230049,
-0.30012017488479614,
0.43270087242126465,
-0.7725123763084412,
0.1368580311536789,
0.3390711843967438,
-0.059505511075258255,
-0.03890953212976456,
-0.12038999795913696,
-0.02007065713405609,
0.732243001461029,
0.3067306578159332,
-0.7124749422073364,
0.02732224017381668,
-0.23130817711353302,
0.21911945939064026,
0.5612534880638123,
0.23517556488513947,
0.16785413026809692,
-0.5297923684120178,
0.5787880420684814,
0.28433758020401,
0.7056557536125183,
-0.23988507688045502,
-0.7831809520721436,
-0.5895314812660217,
-0.30543220043182373,
0.18938328325748444,
0.5146574974060059,
-0.8548320531845093,
-0.5162287354469299,
0.0675727054476738,
-0.5144789814949036,
-0.7402145266532898,
0.10686532407999039,
0.48510268330574036,
0.6301681399345398,
0.6777666807174683,
-0.264498233795166,
-0.27428972721099854,
-1.1139088869094849,
0.18316058814525604,
-0.16551455855369568,
0.11470938473939896,
0.8019205331802368,
0.2692060172557831,
-0.5239576697349548,
0.4155419170856476,
-0.567069947719574,
-0.6082642078399658,
-0.12976253032684326,
0.02791322022676468,
0.18551698327064514,
0.3107866942882538,
0.6429210901260376,
-1.290765404701233,
-0.27039939165115356,
0.10845641791820526,
-0.6079788208007812,
0.1268853396177292,
0.06695154309272766,
-0.018127962946891785,
0.08218397945165634,
0.6038181185722351,
-0.6882316470146179,
0.22034378349781036,
0.6514741778373718,
-0.4113929867744446,
0.2516375184059143,
-0.2628643810749054,
0.5483972430229187,
-1.2278498411178589,
0.11284396797418594,
-0.03675460070371628,
-0.25394442677497864,
-0.4877794682979584,
0.19817404448986053,
0.17078424990177155,
-0.40368154644966125,
-0.7513613700866699,
0.4078010618686676,
-0.11344373226165771,
0.21415288746356964,
0.08645394444465637,
-0.16761812567710876,
0.017266156151890755,
0.6799063682556152,
-0.16412371397018433,
0.7166188955307007,
0.2660299837589264,
-0.2852541506290436,
0.32794681191444397,
0.3872755169868469,
0.034763507544994354,
0.5266969799995422,
-0.4901449680328369,
0.1201324611902237,
-0.2617717683315277,
0.008797772228717804,
-1.1479099988937378,
-0.5812706351280212,
0.34366297721862793,
-0.485935240983963,
0.40900883078575134,
-0.31365808844566345,
-0.13915474712848663,
-0.5988598465919495,
-0.21421179175376892,
0.7761477828025818,
0.5982288718223572,
-0.46261775493621826,
0.7059769630432129,
0.3724944591522217,
-0.4239640533924103,
-0.5588985681533813,
-0.4680408835411072,
-0.006641421001404524,
-0.18941280245780945,
-0.5050763487815857,
0.14643314480781555,
-0.27535316348075867,
-0.32430940866470337,
-0.09694769233465195,
-0.1488770842552185,
-0.4495682120323181,
0.13069084286689758,
0.24491143226623535,
0.4530518651008606,
-0.44425883889198303,
0.172759011387825,
-0.09018157422542572,
0.027319075539708138,
0.2942608892917633,
-0.09446743130683899,
0.1378883272409439,
-0.19769425690174103,
-0.697975218296051,
-0.17083239555358887,
0.5706337690353394,
0.711066722869873,
-0.6403771042823792,
0.4856817424297333,
0.7644253969192505,
-0.33847495913505554,
0.08214956521987915,
-0.39668354392051697,
-0.2585900127887726,
-0.44381511211395264,
0.2548530697822571,
-0.1854526698589325,
-0.807239294052124,
0.5670472979545593,
-0.13369500637054443,
-0.04169807583093643,
0.4726034998893738,
0.753609836101532,
-0.3595463037490845,
1.300981044769287,
0.6240937113761902,
0.5629851818084717,
0.08601722121238708,
-0.08220641314983368,
-0.020444301888346672,
-0.25649958848953247,
-0.8224484920501709,
-0.16855882108211517,
-0.25977757573127747,
-0.42900943756103516,
-0.7276571989059448,
0.616984486579895,
-0.3076147437095642,
0.22355683147907257,
-0.09413249790668488,
-0.4589407742023468,
0.2639616131782532,
0.6618151068687439,
0.5539687871932983,
0.016969900578260422,
-0.47547322511672974,
-0.11384052038192749,
0.1313621997833252,
-0.6942917108535767,
-0.04741832613945007,
1.2262184619903564,
0.2971940338611603,
0.5725783109664917,
0.30633723735809326,
0.4844498932361603,
0.027134062722325325,
0.5865113139152527,
-0.5631246566772461,
0.29111915826797485,
-0.1728033572435379,
-0.6485136151313782,
-0.01656554825603962,
-0.34898871183395386,
-0.7803478837013245,
0.3499222695827484,
-0.30727419257164,
-0.3515772819519043,
0.35770052671432495,
-0.059579331427812576,
-0.43857717514038086,
0.2900300920009613,
-0.7331839799880981,
1.0589889287948608,
-0.21800725162029266,
-0.2969757318496704,
0.13846519589424133,
-1.0480968952178955,
0.5279636383056641,
0.022671949118375778,
0.4617677628993988,
-0.3037666976451874,
-0.20677633583545685,
0.6103886365890503,
-0.3860458433628082,
0.7398473620414734,
-0.3117252588272095,
-0.0484151691198349,
0.16879981756210327,
-0.23172499239444733,
-0.18012908101081848,
0.387327641248703,
0.44412797689437866,
-0.03824711591005325,
0.290083110332489,
-0.6152397394180298,
-0.5596398115158081,
0.5946038961410522,
-0.7215470671653748,
-0.6273665428161621,
-0.29316020011901855,
-0.5599860548973083,
-0.580967128276825,
0.21349990367889404,
0.01694469526410103,
0.5927794575691223,
-0.18692563474178314,
0.05292936787009239,
0.8347491025924683,
-0.37098196148872375,
0.24508161842823029,
0.49260416626930237,
-0.22499814629554749,
-0.5898532867431641,
0.8803633451461792,
-0.21142011880874634,
0.28875020146369934,
0.28134846687316895,
0.20135700702667236,
-0.29069170355796814,
-0.6567718386650085,
-0.6306535005569458,
0.35703369975090027,
-0.7391071319580078,
-0.5439719557762146,
-0.7662281394004822,
-0.2393529862165451,
-0.2519530951976776,
0.19568942487239838,
-0.09774110466241837,
-0.35266563296318054,
-0.3160872161388397,
0.03435611352324486,
0.3070501983165741,
0.8033995628356934,
0.073908232152462,
-0.051725834608078,
-1.03720223903656,
0.792945146560669,
0.5256472229957581,
0.3512941002845764,
-0.6432248950004578,
-0.1030874103307724,
-0.2557099163532257,
0.20777300000190735,
-0.16176024079322815,
-0.7605772018432617,
0.16484951972961426,
0.37731072306632996,
0.2757093608379364,
0.48261114954948425,
0.11047600954771042,
0.3387829661369324,
-0.6047899723052979,
0.6878678202629089,
0.2813889980316162,
-0.17379209399223328,
0.5324201583862305,
-0.2871486246585846,
0.3755488395690918,
0.747647225856781,
0.5045286417007446,
-0.39145731925964355,
-0.523046612739563,
-0.5905788540840149,
-0.7579971551895142,
0.5635534524917603,
-0.2390032559633255,
0.19019410014152527,
-0.17955970764160156,
0.020618896931409836,
0.27894818782806396,
0.14350228011608124,
-0.516040563583374,
-0.3480907380580902,
-0.3367917835712433,
-0.30841925740242004,
-0.1432373821735382,
-0.34014517068862915,
-0.6373300552368164,
-0.24215330183506012,
0.4292970597743988,
-0.5602140426635742,
0.23684780299663544,
0.28345638513565063,
-0.12133913487195969,
-0.07765539735555649,
0.3516406714916229,
0.7762197852134705,
0.7196800112724304,
-0.4222441613674164,
0.21739861369132996,
0.0317721925675869,
-0.4001966416835785,
0.2247353494167328,
0.30071601271629333,
0.09257835149765015,
0.08944085240364075,
0.11623542755842209,
0.5137311816215515,
0.1284187287092209,
-0.9458170533180237,
0.9522591829299927,
-0.4073960781097412,
-0.7522260546684265,
-0.06679932773113251,
-0.18912558257579803,
0.08419640362262726,
0.1963440477848053,
0.45075657963752747,
0.5632957816123962,
0.2719833552837372,
-0.2525424063205719,
0.49963948130607605,
0.3343822658061981,
-0.8554734587669373,
-0.11790198087692261,
0.8230387568473816,
0.07206062972545624,
0.17100195586681366,
0.578808069229126,
0.3703571856021881,
-0.47058624029159546,
0.9048554301261902,
0.2835473418235779,
0.3439917266368866,
-0.14391326904296875,
0.5050324201583862,
0.3046157956123352,
0.22410760819911957,
0.512471616268158,
0.5636755228042603,
0.13888059556484222,
-0.36143776774406433,
-0.46854862570762634,
-0.2493535429239273,
-0.5139137506484985,
0.0021091382950544357,
-0.5797587037086487,
-0.026844298467040062,
-0.6477052569389343,
-0.13628408312797546,
0.07213953137397766,
-0.16819868981838226,
-0.6440455317497253,
0.6362993121147156,
0.13686470687389374,
0.8293234705924988,
-0.7001816630363464,
0.4597683250904083,
0.7229620814323425,
-0.8210956454277039,
-0.5352728366851807,
-0.2689404785633087,
0.040358107537031174,
-0.8427773714065552,
0.5042985081672668,
0.28916001319885254,
0.015971722081303596,
-0.19605429470539093,
-0.6640138030052185,
-0.7606924176216125,
0.9728888273239136,
0.28284069895744324,
0.14480222761631012,
0.04556485638022423,
-0.05924069508910179,
0.40682458877563477,
0.035637158900499344,
0.43399909138679504,
0.25769248604774475,
0.3723129630088806,
0.13964101672172546,
-0.7110617160797119,
-0.02082528918981552,
-0.49785637855529785,
-0.5307466983795166,
0.1315973550081253,
-0.6281092762947083,
0.7749549150466919,
-0.7954409122467041,
-0.25115329027175903,
0.35220447182655334,
0.4274497628211975,
-0.16860952973365784,
0.4458211064338684,
0.22307147085666656,
0.6805089712142944,
0.4257034361362457,
-0.40761834383010864,
1.214307188987732,
-0.08970382809638977,
0.024969417601823807,
0.7571051716804504,
0.09470753371715546,
0.6529861688613892,
0.5867772102355957,
-0.2869165241718292,
0.46724846959114075,
0.8965599536895752,
0.06590592116117477,
0.5835745334625244,
-0.10292414575815201,
-0.5675183534622192,
-0.3857424855232239,
-0.3080139458179474,
-0.5072181224822998,
0.5285417437553406,
0.19333939254283905,
-0.11669329553842545,
-0.30335286259651184,
0.5100030899047852,
-0.2907860577106476,
0.014474553987383842,
-0.291517436504364,
1.3016672134399414,
0.02478218264877796,
-0.42774805426597595,
0.47996705770492554,
0.06014379858970642,
0.40469297766685486,
-0.7113379836082458,
-0.2834703326225281,
-0.3451257050037384,
0.1978016495704651,
-0.24886882305145264,
-0.6073443293571472,
0.17906588315963745,
-0.49819350242614746,
-0.24505071341991425,
-0.084575355052948,
0.5097108483314514,
-0.7196142077445984,
-0.538486659526825,
0.13017219305038452,
0.91252601146698,
0.06237412989139557,
0.19202108681201935,
-0.9629735350608826,
-0.5632813572883606,
-0.2376633882522583,
-0.03396129980683327,
0.43278369307518005,
0.4975835084915161,
-0.1256830096244812,
0.804696261882782,
0.8074226975440979,
-0.11488163471221924,
-0.03621217980980873,
0.09729931503534317,
0.939176082611084,
-0.20727591216564178,
-0.06868195533752441,
-0.498070627450943,
0.5072007775306702,
0.11088492721319199,
-0.09357935935258865,
0.5606635808944702,
0.33156532049179077,
0.7700963020324707,
-0.23450082540512085,
0.5333436131477356,
0.16151472926139832,
0.5387659668922424,
-0.5491374731063843,
0.6997389793395996,
-0.9531528353691101,
-0.21643531322479248,
-0.08649575710296631,
-0.466312974691391,
-0.5625803470611572,
0.1409599483013153,
0.014899090863764286,
0.07169637084007263,
0.7927876114845276,
0.6120665669441223,
-0.18922479450702667,
-0.1751808524131775,
0.4073188006877899,
0.014391129836440086,
0.1409999579191208,
0.7440482974052429,
0.6842979788780212,
-0.4991772472858429,
0.5226627588272095,
-0.6101610660552979,
-0.1532471477985382,
-0.19405928254127502,
-0.2720892131328583,
-0.7869548797607422,
-0.6674305200576782,
-0.2956817150115967,
-0.49903395771980286,
-0.18216554820537567,
0.8734223246574402,
0.6226645708084106,
-0.934719979763031,
0.21820992231369019,
0.3899272680282593,
0.21659402549266815,
-0.1893208920955658,
-0.15145288407802582,
0.5112839937210083,
-0.39787557721138,
-0.5970140099525452,
0.39003002643585205,
0.335191935300827,
0.35114872455596924,
-0.1893743872642517,
0.1467413306236267,
-0.44587960839271545,
-0.04281719774007797,
0.4124096930027008,
0.2826811671257019,
-0.4289434254169464,
0.10841888934373856,
0.12204647064208984,
-0.21181660890579224,
0.3795485496520996,
0.7925893664360046,
-0.7562362551689148,
0.44304415583610535,
0.04398123174905777,
0.9641193151473999,
0.28532275557518005,
0.03518503159284592,
0.5933848023414612,
-0.5500900149345398,
0.12326095253229141,
0.5778717994689941,
0.3504972755908966,
0.2768053412437439,
-0.3500286042690277,
0.29814568161964417,
0.3002694547176361,
-0.19153821468353271,
-0.46323323249816895,
0.2805561125278473,
-1.0376684665679932,
-0.7232747077941895,
0.9622843265533447,
-0.25650981068611145,
-0.4529274106025696,
-0.19654162228107452,
-0.564376950263977,
-0.0857979878783226,
0.17680224776268005,
0.33534756302833557,
0.2816722095012665,
-0.03500396013259888,
-0.718238353729248,
-0.437186598777771,
0.6545388698577881,
0.42752593755722046,
-1.1999386548995972,
-0.3175414800643921,
0.6069582104682922,
0.19320490956306458,
-0.04027954488992691,
0.9132475256919861,
-0.4402908980846405,
0.8307225108146667,
-0.20440791547298431,
0.0752192810177803,
-0.382440984249115,
-0.5535475015640259,
-0.1408587396144867,
0.4073868989944458,
0.059764355421066284,
-0.3753402829170227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17991v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17991v2
|
Enhancing Pre-Trained Generative Language Models with Question Attended Span Extraction on Machine Reading Comprehension
| 2024-04-27T19:42:51 | 2024-06-12T04:47:01 |
Lin Ai, Zheng Hui, Zizhou Liu, Julia Hirschberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Machine Reading Comprehension (MRC) poses a significant challenge in the
field of Natural Language Processing (NLP). While mainstream MRC methods
predominantly leverage extractive strategies using encoder-only models such as
BERT, generative approaches face the issue of out-of-control generation -- a
critical problem where answers generated are often incorrect, irrelevant, or
unfaithful to the source text. To address these limitations in generative
models for MRC, we introduce the Question-Attended Span Extraction (QASE)
module. Integrated during the fine-tuning phase of pre-trained generative
language models (PLMs), QASE significantly enhances their performance, allowing
them to surpass the extractive capabilities of advanced Large Language Models
(LLMs) such as GPT-4 in few-shot settings. Notably, these gains in performance
do not come with an increase in computational demands. The efficacy of the QASE
module has been rigorously tested across various datasets, consistently
achieving or even surpassing state-of-the-art (SOTA) results, thereby bridging
the gap between generative and extractive models in extractive MRC tasks.
|
[
-0.5368737578392029,
-0.8442956805229187,
0.4939277470111847,
0.020265668630599976,
-0.2781582474708557,
0.1084652915596962,
0.17103008925914764,
-0.3991542160511017,
-0.15380068123340607,
0.6491849422454834,
-0.9001395106315613,
-0.3184746503829956,
-0.5134957432746887,
0.47873878479003906,
-0.4322690963745117,
0.9462199211120605,
-0.06024843454360962,
-0.24604834616184235,
-0.4680726230144501,
0.16967643797397614,
-0.34918710589408875,
-0.4276743233203888,
-0.5798028111457825,
-0.016489321365952492,
0.41475263237953186,
0.48508164286613464,
0.5210107564926147,
0.46759864687919617,
0.5193057060241699,
0.1976817399263382,
-0.1391918659210205,
0.4132649302482605,
-0.1552354097366333,
0.4012100398540497,
0.12332744896411896,
-0.6130709648132324,
-0.6404609084129333,
0.10187600553035736,
0.8317488431930542,
0.5248718857765198,
-0.11507970094680786,
0.0424656979739666,
0.2606029212474823,
0.8802176713943481,
-0.633094072341919,
0.04845329001545906,
-0.6039426922798157,
0.04034870117902756,
-0.21503816545009613,
-0.39208564162254333,
-0.518109142780304,
-0.5747904181480408,
0.19046859443187714,
-0.7046728730201721,
0.37017419934272766,
0.056803859770298004,
1.084557294845581,
0.3980840742588043,
-0.24792517721652985,
-0.15434503555297852,
-0.436079740524292,
0.6158617734909058,
-0.7659136056900024,
0.44539257884025574,
0.8650686144828796,
0.28139451146125793,
-0.03863630071282387,
-0.8950036764144897,
-0.8477148413658142,
-0.05535737797617912,
-0.06213706359267235,
0.4501038193702698,
-0.11409127712249756,
0.18344946205615997,
0.25884562730789185,
0.41692307591438293,
-0.8711199760437012,
-0.05549164488911629,
-0.3942522406578064,
0.06340759992599487,
0.30738577246665955,
0.12360279262065887,
0.3477577865123749,
-0.4380679428577423,
-0.23221458494663239,
-0.09579484164714813,
-0.6847800016403198,
-0.0008750411798246205,
0.2344493567943573,
0.1454506516456604,
0.2693798243999481,
0.7048279643058777,
-0.28198206424713135,
0.665941059589386,
0.0409906767308712,
0.2006988674402237,
0.04012398049235344,
-0.400503545999527,
-0.2753905653953552,
-0.3105461299419403,
0.5282813310623169,
0.02291461080312729,
0.41085582971572876,
-0.23809221386909485,
-0.15995994210243225,
-0.30775007605552673,
0.4076789915561676,
-0.926884651184082,
-0.3966098427772522,
0.45143142342567444,
-0.28992220759391785,
-0.1941264420747757,
0.2079760730266571,
-0.9620351791381836,
-0.011246410198509693,
-0.039497874677181244,
0.4362640380859375,
-0.5564464926719666,
-0.22682374715805054,
0.14447824656963348,
-0.2825174629688263,
0.41673827171325684,
0.12763425707817078,
-1.092124104499817,
0.18910916149616241,
0.5160677433013916,
0.7387534379959106,
-0.1472337394952774,
-0.2318626195192337,
-0.7268904447555542,
0.04083184152841568,
-0.2616974711418152,
0.903466522693634,
-0.4913659989833832,
-0.26587381958961487,
0.005000265780836344,
-0.06447402387857437,
-0.6203293800354004,
-0.9054492712020874,
0.45062610507011414,
-1.185088872909546,
0.5192272067070007,
-0.048485398292541504,
-0.6924194693565369,
-0.011305578984320164,
0.35636991262435913,
-0.6925565004348755,
1.2953523397445679,
0.3445151746273041,
-0.7462347745895386,
0.1939578652381897,
-0.7086943984031677,
-0.472745418548584,
0.15088818967342377,
0.11498254537582397,
-0.6442371010780334,
-0.04777524992823601,
0.7151944637298584,
0.35509660840034485,
-0.03712088614702225,
0.03739270940423012,
-0.19891545176506042,
-0.07976135611534119,
0.41561076045036316,
-0.43863484263420105,
0.816901683807373,
0.25501999258995056,
-0.10555551946163177,
0.2721931040287018,
-0.7387914061546326,
0.46154794096946716,
0.03820546716451645,
-0.5943498015403748,
-0.1314089447259903,
-0.057048819959163666,
-0.20521323382854462,
0.33925992250442505,
0.05020245909690857,
-0.307914674282074,
0.12157663702964783,
-0.5758100152015686,
0.3756627142429352,
0.5969874858856201,
0.3597431480884552,
0.3178134262561798,
-0.2889464795589447,
1.1247109174728394,
-0.27502772212028503,
0.02122570388019085,
-0.4153482913970947,
-0.38705044984817505,
-0.8755984306335449,
-0.5029556751251221,
0.4717067778110504,
0.6903570294380188,
-1.0461479425430298,
0.46946242451667786,
0.05549218878149986,
-0.18421317636966705,
-1.0096640586853027,
-0.005429690238088369,
0.3005812466144562,
0.6311211585998535,
0.7762790322303772,
-0.06619350612163544,
-0.4648931622505188,
-0.5356114506721497,
-0.2112031877040863,
-0.269632488489151,
-0.33590614795684814,
0.02551230601966381,
0.3646973967552185,
-0.008846918120980263,
1.129340648651123,
-0.6274330019950867,
-0.10494440793991089,
-0.6278619170188904,
0.2117961347103119,
0.004158551339060068,
0.406110554933548,
0.1233743354678154,
-0.7821376919746399,
-0.3860760033130646,
-0.24288521707057953,
-0.7209954261779785,
-0.4109969139099121,
-0.13754060864448547,
-0.3243020176887512,
0.09062394499778748,
0.696506917476654,
-0.6366074681282043,
0.2599847614765167,
0.5748335123062134,
-0.3369997441768646,
0.8731157183647156,
-0.162104994058609,
0.21452777087688446,
-1.1620378494262695,
0.1794997751712799,
-0.2742278277873993,
-0.3814210891723633,
-0.5948123335838318,
0.46434423327445984,
0.4040885865688324,
-0.027540674433112144,
-0.278035044670105,
0.10883978009223938,
-0.34862828254699707,
-0.026275428012013435,
-0.24091459810733795,
0.25609710812568665,
0.48192113637924194,
0.33220788836479187,
-0.010560432448983192,
1.2348958253860474,
0.2806611657142639,
-0.6952899694442749,
-0.009492015466094017,
0.627759575843811,
-0.34727156162261963,
0.3202223479747772,
-0.7151505351066589,
0.313985675573349,
-0.20655611157417297,
0.06480550765991211,
-0.9406774044036865,
-0.18564124405384064,
0.20346598327159882,
-0.5320740342140198,
0.393565833568573,
0.005291928071528673,
-0.41134288907051086,
-0.3421034812927246,
-0.12278871983289719,
0.22241173684597015,
0.5038935542106628,
-0.5857803225517273,
0.5044300556182861,
0.15936721861362457,
-0.5787054896354675,
-0.2785761058330536,
-0.6595434546470642,
-0.18529412150382996,
-0.1526128053665161,
-0.5014123916625977,
0.24811843037605286,
-0.09708118438720703,
0.11767206341028214,
-0.2904413938522339,
-0.08369047939777374,
-0.30608507990837097,
0.19960349798202515,
-0.1362885981798172,
0.31940752267837524,
-0.38536208868026733,
0.2951522767543793,
0.4251708388328552,
-0.05281465873122215,
0.1101023480296135,
-0.12379664182662964,
0.7010848522186279,
0.011106390506029129,
-0.18661963939666748,
-0.6248441934585571,
0.5670210123062134,
0.4055686891078949,
-0.9397155046463013,
0.7294692397117615,
0.31041455268859863,
-0.1920226663351059,
-0.2646101415157318,
-0.22816400229930878,
-0.2655877470970154,
-0.49372604489326477,
0.5937164425849915,
-0.638046383857727,
-1.0994852781295776,
0.28573206067085266,
-0.025547370314598083,
-0.016856353729963303,
0.6016265749931335,
0.2159568965435028,
-0.5883563160896301,
1.0842126607894897,
0.6673386693000793,
0.0788249745965004,
0.5890010595321655,
-0.15100425481796265,
-0.06634588539600372,
-0.9558336734771729,
-0.0690266564488411,
-0.7491133213043213,
0.1781434416770935,
-0.1766502559185028,
-0.44946083426475525,
0.3633010983467102,
0.506924033164978,
-0.057521406561136246,
0.29253530502319336,
-0.049703411757946014,
0.4363481402397156,
0.5099969506263733,
0.13755682110786438,
0.4599181115627289,
-0.07395532727241516,
-0.12111896276473999,
-0.15792307257652283,
-0.7822115421295166,
-0.6395151019096375,
0.9176093935966492,
0.3817898631095886,
0.23296889662742615,
0.06126708909869194,
0.6340054869651794,
0.1635676473379135,
0.2693353593349457,
-0.6555148363113403,
0.5438070893287659,
-0.025338618084788322,
-0.6604127287864685,
-0.39854860305786133,
-0.5956186056137085,
-0.8933812379837036,
0.4523720145225525,
-0.21129877865314484,
-0.40093278884887695,
0.07208254188299179,
0.26964178681373596,
-0.6150231957435608,
0.1255316436290741,
-0.6429895162582397,
1.124597430229187,
0.011235670186579227,
0.013511942699551582,
-0.1692689210176468,
-0.7508062720298767,
0.2005508989095688,
-0.18717366456985474,
-0.11747296154499054,
0.07890035212039948,
0.16296494007110596,
0.7122408747673035,
-0.3444983661174774,
0.5046427249908447,
-0.09105430543422699,
-0.0521271675825119,
0.5275642275810242,
0.03687751665711403,
0.5484619140625,
-0.22467201948165894,
-0.14183683693408966,
-0.26457759737968445,
0.19340232014656067,
-0.5064920783042908,
-0.6116774082183838,
-0.09390078485012054,
-0.5869394540786743,
-0.5577397346496582,
-0.15896208584308624,
-0.5413166284561157,
-0.5577338337898254,
0.2979487180709839,
0.12735609710216522,
0.24297939240932465,
-0.1647454798221588,
-0.03411472961306572,
0.8873467445373535,
-0.34817060828208923,
0.4498341679573059,
0.43443912267684937,
-0.1733386069536209,
-0.4439794421195984,
0.7551058530807495,
-0.1626756340265274,
0.7130029201507568,
0.64495450258255,
-0.054132129997015,
-0.4817940592765808,
-0.7671031951904297,
-0.5789853930473328,
0.0818476602435112,
-0.5110303163528442,
-0.21494731307029724,
-0.8084762096405029,
-0.4102339446544647,
-0.47263064980506897,
0.32620030641555786,
-0.07463033497333527,
-0.45208534598350525,
-0.5384387373924255,
-0.3864755630493164,
0.11955797672271729,
0.33627551794052124,
0.34597116708755493,
0.593395471572876,
-1.1190648078918457,
0.5331150889396667,
0.4489816427230835,
-0.021248430013656616,
-0.20317381620407104,
-0.7623209357261658,
-0.3023442029953003,
-0.182648167014122,
-0.5221220254898071,
-1.0858668088912964,
0.5836563110351562,
0.43414437770843506,
0.31179821491241455,
0.44405555725097656,
0.1680803894996643,
0.8525406122207642,
-0.44823169708251953,
0.5132048726081848,
-0.16651645302772522,
-0.8349964022636414,
0.6396923065185547,
-0.2726402282714844,
0.43523862957954407,
0.6665958166122437,
0.4170058071613312,
-0.4442459046840668,
-0.6934746503829956,
-0.34342649579048157,
-0.749630331993103,
0.5749563574790955,
0.18393902480602264,
-0.07915636152029037,
-0.1730882227420807,
0.4359824061393738,
0.1439780741930008,
0.25540176033973694,
-0.6409264206886292,
0.18050579726696014,
-0.14993900060653687,
-0.4312094748020172,
0.031746018677949905,
-0.3121744394302368,
0.32173582911491394,
-0.08721984922885895,
0.6954032778739929,
-0.20008514821529388,
0.06753038614988327,
0.42197322845458984,
-0.33752551674842834,
-0.2229865938425064,
0.45629698038101196,
0.35168638825416565,
0.5617619752883911,
-0.3302532136440277,
0.2552197277545929,
-0.04304995387792587,
-0.5177784562110901,
-0.23938040435314178,
0.4184851050376892,
-0.31226643919944763,
-0.32711079716682434,
0.44487273693084717,
0.5398591160774231,
-0.38435497879981995,
-0.8722338080406189,
0.2979481518268585,
0.0030401102267205715,
-0.2711939215660095,
-0.03298363834619522,
0.10893905907869339,
-0.052982769906520844,
0.46007102727890015,
0.4005838930606842,
-0.06777799874544144,
0.049442168325185776,
-0.2569088935852051,
0.47442370653152466,
0.3217875063419342,
-0.34745097160339355,
-0.22511731088161469,
0.7728824019432068,
0.055409785360097885,
0.051343902945518494,
1.028666377067566,
-0.2502504885196686,
-0.8131581544876099,
0.5208857655525208,
0.7360740900039673,
0.8956189751625061,
-0.1894521713256836,
0.34665369987487793,
0.31143856048583984,
0.6290027499198914,
0.19249965250492096,
0.396393746137619,
-0.17146709561347961,
-0.8586220145225525,
-0.6773383617401123,
-0.814782440662384,
-0.21556569635868073,
0.08636784553527832,
-0.8504312634468079,
-0.25111982226371765,
-0.10614234954118729,
0.046807318925857544,
-0.25901857018470764,
0.03578248620033264,
-0.2769290804862976,
0.3432067036628723,
-0.060172583907842636,
0.9593071341514587,
-0.8829078674316406,
1.103594422340393,
0.47386616468429565,
-0.5601608753204346,
-0.772799015045166,
0.415357381105423,
-0.5770574808120728,
-0.6515814065933228,
0.3853011727333069,
0.15716806054115295,
0.05343710631132126,
0.4377126395702362,
-0.2876208424568176,
-0.5835630893707275,
0.9256061315536499,
0.16805163025856018,
-0.444139689207077,
-0.06280691176652908,
0.23144495487213135,
0.4742125868797302,
-0.032188620418310165,
0.03332660719752312,
0.7642698287963867,
0.34963664412498474,
-0.04955208674073219,
-0.6123369932174683,
-0.035797636955976486,
-0.15972891449928284,
-0.15168143808841705,
0.2435818612575531,
-0.2470947504043579,
0.6259985566139221,
-0.2535759210586548,
-0.3263251483440399,
0.34516289830207825,
1.0399469137191772,
0.4448903501033783,
0.2517301142215729,
0.4617156386375427,
0.6611418724060059,
0.9357448220252991,
-0.000016573667380725965,
1.1461687088012695,
0.08924693614244461,
0.11183497309684753,
1.032320499420166,
-0.18847212195396423,
1.2415655851364136,
0.6499612331390381,
-0.44419994950294495,
0.38884326815605164,
0.7827289700508118,
0.2297583371400833,
0.673109233379364,
-0.0932934358716011,
-0.3897298276424408,
-0.4594229459762573,
0.236861914396286,
-0.24037890136241913,
0.24034494161605835,
0.25032758712768555,
-0.350624144077301,
0.0029504308477044106,
-0.04533135145902634,
-0.1733691394329071,
0.08965034782886505,
-0.28782305121421814,
0.8599982857704163,
0.013100157491862774,
-0.8649645447731018,
0.6382493376731873,
0.0526476688683033,
0.2607228755950928,
-0.6833735704421997,
-0.11009474843740463,
-0.36024877429008484,
0.0916547179222107,
-0.09195788204669952,
-0.5923349261283875,
0.4856594204902649,
0.1493978053331375,
-0.4056539833545685,
-0.33808162808418274,
0.694193422794342,
-0.6399772763252258,
-0.23287029564380646,
-0.09305521100759506,
0.8335462808609009,
0.12687918543815613,
-0.448913037776947,
-0.5196185111999512,
-0.3724677264690399,
0.16460153460502625,
-0.302382230758667,
0.2890435457229614,
0.2990076243877411,
0.06461077928543091,
0.5987849831581116,
0.6270496249198914,
0.07219754159450531,
0.39707398414611816,
0.17260736227035522,
0.9046727418899536,
-0.6839510202407837,
-0.44875970482826233,
-0.7289615273475647,
0.534122109413147,
0.06291770190000534,
-0.47500887513160706,
0.6035435795783997,
0.5677043795585632,
0.7526284456253052,
-0.1764880120754242,
0.7456891536712646,
0.033103711903095245,
0.7046532034873962,
-0.8233425617218018,
0.7739282250404358,
-0.6079318523406982,
0.08356170356273651,
-0.19392217695713043,
-0.7617087364196777,
-0.4166561961174011,
0.5591927766799927,
-0.30937251448631287,
-0.015255972743034363,
0.9065685868263245,
0.7640179991722107,
0.16349732875823975,
0.24262399971485138,
0.32118847966194153,
0.10474685579538345,
0.32238122820854187,
0.3979317247867584,
1.1007721424102783,
-0.3480285704135895,
0.7386072278022766,
0.01987025886774063,
-0.2657650411128998,
0.10855356603860855,
-0.6221148371696472,
-0.9269424080848694,
-0.46528157591819763,
-0.30920925736427307,
-0.21749605238437653,
0.08471743017435074,
0.6732746362686157,
0.4959421753883362,
-0.9170101284980774,
0.0228867344558239,
-0.4282141923904419,
-0.01903940923511982,
-0.4324089288711548,
-0.30468952655792236,
0.6070411205291748,
-0.698764979839325,
-0.7370818853378296,
0.6163492202758789,
0.305481880903244,
0.1162884458899498,
0.07942308485507965,
0.07128491997718811,
-0.2779534161090851,
0.011763390153646469,
0.6390103697776794,
0.2849399447441101,
-0.29127195477485657,
-0.01702464371919632,
0.25125378370285034,
-0.14627209305763245,
0.138353168964386,
0.5874572396278381,
-0.7285903692245483,
0.4759428799152374,
0.5010991096496582,
0.960944652557373,
0.6144607663154602,
0.3375184237957001,
0.5650987029075623,
-0.92447429895401,
-0.2111196219921112,
0.4546110928058624,
0.1504419595003128,
0.152736097574234,
0.03174057975411415,
0.17934930324554443,
0.15872956812381744,
-0.5582244396209717,
-0.6444391012191772,
0.3637705147266388,
-0.8079838156700134,
-0.33186545968055725,
0.8309459686279297,
-0.32281914353370667,
-0.04865415394306183,
-0.17219045758247375,
-0.3172825276851654,
0.41638997197151184,
0.0005685559590347111,
0.8413556218147278,
0.5887463688850403,
-0.07825005054473877,
-0.6343651413917542,
-0.7500559687614441,
0.5467983484268188,
0.8497352600097656,
-1.2559961080551147,
0.12428779900074005,
0.4235697388648987,
0.032696690410375595,
-0.326829195022583,
0.5939657092094421,
-0.3040643036365509,
0.19237782061100006,
-0.33187729120254517,
0.1306438446044922,
-0.028847303241491318,
-0.4116079807281494,
-0.33034414052963257,
0.5109156966209412,
0.15738604962825775,
-0.4460214376449585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17985v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17985v1
|
Detection of Conspiracy Theories Beyond Keyword Bias in German-Language Telegram Using Large Language Models
| 2024-04-27T19:17:31 | 2024-04-27T19:17:31 |
Milena Pustet, Elisabeth Steffen, Helena Mihaljević
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI, I.2.7
|
The automated detection of conspiracy theories online typically relies on
supervised learning. However, creating respective training data requires
expertise, time and mental resilience, given the often harmful content.
Moreover, available datasets are predominantly in English and often
keyword-based, introducing a token-level bias into the models. Our work
addresses the task of detecting conspiracy theories in German Telegram
messages. We compare the performance of supervised fine-tuning approaches using
BERT-like models with prompt-based approaches using Llama2, GPT-3.5, and GPT-4
which require little or no additional training data. We use a dataset of
$\sim\!\! 4,000$ messages collected during the COVID-19 pandemic, without the
use of keyword filters.
Our findings demonstrate that both approaches can be leveraged effectively:
For supervised fine-tuning, we report an F1 score of $\sim\!\! 0.8$ for the
positive class, making our model comparable to recent models trained on
keyword-focused English corpora. We demonstrate our model's adaptability to
intra-domain temporal shifts, achieving F1 scores of $\sim\!\! 0.7$. Among
prompting variants, the best model is GPT-4, achieving an F1 score of $\sim\!\!
0.8$ for the positive class in a zero-shot setting and equipped with a custom
conspiracy theory definition.
|
[
-0.5713332891464233,
-1.1173951625823975,
0.5743081569671631,
-0.030528880655765533,
-0.529482901096344,
-0.11910013854503632,
-0.5019602179527283,
-0.3579004108905792,
0.18059156835079193,
0.33641859889030457,
-0.6103745102882385,
-0.7179370522499084,
-0.7985292673110962,
0.15404251217842102,
-0.8236533403396606,
1.29591965675354,
0.16003359854221344,
0.05491417646408081,
0.08884822577238083,
0.3341195583343506,
-0.009699557907879353,
-0.6203032732009888,
-0.7823523283004761,
-0.33291879296302795,
0.48005759716033936,
0.4904565215110779,
0.6007096767425537,
0.4994204640388489,
0.5663413405418396,
0.14734971523284912,
0.0022541629150509834,
-0.004207246471196413,
-0.6497734189033508,
-0.09760206192731857,
-0.16874919831752777,
-0.42214781045913696,
-0.12219983339309692,
0.0903887152671814,
0.23953133821487427,
0.2840205132961273,
-0.12484276294708252,
-0.033810004591941833,
-0.2093312293291092,
0.4177006185054779,
-0.426645427942276,
0.12422629445791245,
-1.1769930124282837,
-0.05214362218976021,
-0.29349690675735474,
-0.0264092069119215,
-0.4695616364479065,
-0.20399130880832672,
0.2544865310192108,
-0.4880225360393524,
0.6770407557487488,
-0.05235514044761658,
0.8950499296188354,
0.09033984690904617,
-0.5434278249740601,
-0.6681464314460754,
-0.6389883160591125,
0.5626093745231628,
-0.781511664390564,
0.32931363582611084,
0.49083513021469116,
0.07300496846437454,
-0.4123575985431671,
-0.5079507827758789,
-0.672389030456543,
-0.4547716975212097,
0.009736273437738419,
0.06891132891178131,
-0.48753929138183594,
0.15379153192043304,
0.32173827290534973,
0.0883241593837738,
-0.49902892112731934,
0.37241166830062866,
-0.2847796380519867,
-0.6349015235900879,
0.543917715549469,
-0.09654170274734497,
-0.13860732316970825,
-0.22926318645477295,
-0.1952509731054306,
-0.026427241042256355,
-0.768371045589447,
-0.05919424816966057,
0.6080403923988342,
0.3386979103088379,
-0.324063241481781,
0.23389114439487457,
-0.30737173557281494,
0.4275690019130707,
0.5052637457847595,
-0.0031402891036123037,
-0.2390315979719162,
-0.15798930823802948,
-0.3035230040550232,
0.13701292872428894,
0.6981136798858643,
0.19173668324947357,
0.4291408956050873,
-0.2958114743232727,
-0.038874875754117966,
0.6737667918205261,
0.21679683029651642,
-0.8566895723342896,
-0.7183581590652466,
0.041553791612386703,
-0.2940671741962433,
-0.5162147283554077,
0.13244183361530304,
-0.4865657687187195,
-0.33489829301834106,
-0.01827816851437092,
0.2209116667509079,
-0.4839785695075989,
0.0036993608810007572,
0.16194404661655426,
-0.22293688356876373,
0.0769495815038681,
0.444814532995224,
-0.6628341674804688,
-0.14266732335090637,
0.6858664155006409,
0.693561851978302,
-0.12093180418014526,
0.05202750489115715,
-0.522046685218811,
0.02860003523528576,
-0.5189746618270874,
1.0071651935577393,
-0.6457184553146362,
-0.36787497997283936,
0.1859613060951233,
-0.06919774413108826,
0.22361469268798828,
-0.06688559800386429,
0.9351301193237305,
-0.8505369424819946,
0.547816812992096,
-0.2800997495651245,
-0.8089554309844971,
-0.2578715682029724,
0.27119314670562744,
-0.48668038845062256,
0.7592043876647949,
-0.37655380368232727,
-0.7922707200050354,
0.60321444272995,
-0.6569861769676208,
-0.721915066242218,
-0.20726799964904785,
-0.1126852035522461,
-0.39199909567832947,
0.01583305560052395,
0.4997928738594055,
0.6402695178985596,
-0.01730404421687126,
0.45971810817718506,
-0.2995063364505768,
-0.20992623269557953,
0.2789992690086365,
-0.5143876075744629,
0.4743064343929291,
0.2444935142993927,
-0.47368067502975464,
0.09411317855119705,
-0.7204628586769104,
-0.28602251410484314,
-0.029007727280259132,
-0.30448758602142334,
-0.3670104742050171,
0.08166198432445526,
-0.1268039345741272,
0.19787827134132385,
0.1644773930311203,
-0.404448926448822,
0.28062108159065247,
-0.2920549809932709,
0.23780517280101776,
0.7134904861450195,
0.245122030377388,
0.4394126236438751,
-0.1824008971452713,
0.2678323984146118,
0.35179632902145386,
0.1778264343738556,
-0.22480042278766632,
-0.6213327646255493,
-1.0555284023284912,
-0.08567129820585251,
0.12039662897586823,
0.5447385907173157,
-0.6910582780838013,
0.533941924571991,
-0.07075165957212448,
-0.7431773543357849,
-0.22936171293258667,
-0.03382793813943863,
0.2647815942764282,
0.5009565353393555,
0.29747873544692993,
0.03799391910433769,
-0.5466077923774719,
-1.0015156269073486,
-0.4800376892089844,
-0.25683078169822693,
-0.21416619420051575,
0.08430267870426178,
0.5446909070014954,
-0.2672064006328583,
0.8630938529968262,
-0.4406341016292572,
-0.3204942047595978,
0.005007379688322544,
0.25196805596351624,
0.49314314126968384,
0.22838039696216583,
0.4547189772129059,
-0.7705175876617432,
-0.4314200282096863,
-0.1324416846036911,
-0.4861607253551483,
0.05872983857989311,
-0.1794360876083374,
0.2522784173488617,
0.43253251910209656,
0.6956443190574646,
-0.452705979347229,
0.10188883543014526,
0.49597468972206116,
-0.5386447906494141,
0.3277236819267273,
0.016696715727448463,
0.22025008499622345,
-1.2276768684387207,
-0.13818155229091644,
0.21812281012535095,
-0.2558460831642151,
-1.1389859914779663,
0.05416995286941528,
0.22822554409503937,
0.25570690631866455,
-0.4584611654281616,
-0.08135804533958435,
-0.25123855471611023,
0.46424418687820435,
-0.3807033598423004,
0.06792683154344559,
-0.3629506528377533,
0.3116317093372345,
-0.04289949685335159,
0.5672299265861511,
0.5305379033088684,
-0.5478913187980652,
0.09381753206253052,
0.10600239783525467,
-0.5405375957489014,
0.3261990547180176,
-0.40441134572029114,
0.5192926526069641,
-0.06609674543142319,
0.4219928979873657,
-1.0205918550491333,
-0.4431675374507904,
0.41447657346725464,
-0.3763607144355774,
0.015644527971744537,
-0.3514336049556732,
-0.4949076771736145,
-0.21284271776676178,
-0.17197410762310028,
-0.13417722284793854,
0.5813857913017273,
-0.3683316707611084,
0.17525304853916168,
0.2775860130786896,
0.17114372551441193,
-0.362596333026886,
-0.3615862727165222,
0.38312771916389465,
-0.4248763918876648,
-0.5486366152763367,
0.27468982338905334,
0.25182563066482544,
-0.35701802372932434,
-0.2604667544364929,
-0.18711872398853302,
-0.005002881400287151,
0.2112339735031128,
0.26282379031181335,
0.0860954076051712,
-0.015536733902990818,
0.24216018617153168,
0.08573184162378311,
0.027448229491710663,
0.15834888815879822,
-0.3934115469455719,
0.5796969532966614,
-0.09434767067432404,
-0.12623079121112823,
-0.4479242265224457,
0.26388609409332275,
0.6209775805473328,
0.23820309340953827,
0.6289865374565125,
0.6216594576835632,
-0.3950258791446686,
-0.0876416489481926,
-0.7791818976402283,
-0.6902594566345215,
-0.46580955386161804,
0.2897613048553467,
-0.2157706320285797,
-1.1336079835891724,
0.6063287258148193,
0.053250886499881744,
-0.015811020508408546,
0.5507712364196777,
0.7134213447570801,
-0.07382393628358841,
0.9405304193496704,
0.8423858284950256,
-0.3980618417263031,
0.6839020848274231,
-0.0957324206829071,
0.2867451012134552,
-0.1407243013381958,
0.07554075121879578,
-0.4762413501739502,
-0.06233907490968704,
-0.5707291960716248,
-0.1694480925798416,
0.6036633849143982,
0.09518983960151672,
-0.09325924515724182,
0.39357608556747437,
-0.31071555614471436,
0.3784943222999573,
0.5980855822563171,
0.14257226884365082,
0.37474119663238525,
0.21720297634601593,
0.17721974849700928,
0.2112043797969818,
-0.7965879440307617,
-0.5541769862174988,
1.1378427743911743,
0.34935665130615234,
0.598816454410553,
0.009137807413935661,
0.5674437880516052,
0.5319730639457703,
0.19729655981063843,
-0.6430528163909912,
0.5344963669776917,
-0.11102786660194397,
-0.5763500928878784,
-0.394117146730423,
-0.13757573068141937,
-0.9029482007026672,
0.010408946312963963,
-0.39968690276145935,
-0.5685240626335144,
0.00254669482819736,
0.19715097546577454,
-0.09951265156269073,
0.10607381165027618,
-0.7189851999282837,
0.5881932973861694,
0.14711986482143402,
0.13823752105236053,
-0.7012136578559875,
-0.4970563054084778,
0.3948741555213928,
-0.35907813906669617,
0.3707998991012573,
-0.278531938791275,
0.08522333204746246,
0.8813290596008301,
-0.119666688144207,
1.09093177318573,
-0.11511536687612534,
-0.5297152996063232,
0.06952419131994247,
0.000018243941667606123,
1.0175012350082397,
0.23406028747558594,
-0.07363726943731308,
0.48935943841934204,
-0.12686903774738312,
-0.27087271213531494,
-0.35126036405563354,
0.6825910210609436,
-0.7668454647064209,
-0.9258571267127991,
-0.20662549138069153,
-0.704217791557312,
-0.10529544204473495,
0.21034879982471466,
0.7319086194038391,
0.13146713376045227,
-0.3073006272315979,
0.028055161237716675,
0.586494505405426,
0.15200060606002808,
0.47695356607437134,
0.741761326789856,
0.14282110333442688,
-0.1749863624572754,
0.48645398020744324,
0.12286853045225143,
0.14342308044433594,
0.25943759083747864,
0.26194581389427185,
-0.05776209756731987,
-0.7111654281616211,
-0.38477206230163574,
-0.061222415417432785,
-0.6747592687606812,
-0.20374448597431183,
-0.7276745438575745,
0.012172156944870949,
-0.5309565663337708,
-0.26986733078956604,
-0.12462342530488968,
-0.330597460269928,
-0.39483049511909485,
-0.08833933621644974,
0.7148115038871765,
0.5396893620491028,
0.08907411247491837,
0.53701251745224,
-0.6067689657211304,
0.3071275055408478,
-0.00316038285382092,
0.19785723090171814,
-0.3839469850063324,
-0.72978276014328,
-0.49955448508262634,
0.16361624002456665,
-0.2636359930038452,
-1.1175121068954468,
0.042595915496349335,
0.2662842273712158,
0.1871788501739502,
0.9292927384376526,
0.35058918595314026,
0.5492143630981445,
-0.39808452129364014,
0.9740239381790161,
-0.01704929955303669,
-1.0512443780899048,
0.6744363307952881,
-0.6614288091659546,
0.09362262487411499,
0.31840744614601135,
0.4566052258014679,
-0.6026418805122375,
-0.9692689180374146,
-0.8586958646774292,
-0.4899868369102478,
0.6163809895515442,
0.20325098931789398,
0.18964724242687225,
-0.1696573942899704,
0.381002813577652,
0.28548723459243774,
0.30349791049957275,
-0.6506276726722717,
-0.20983120799064636,
-0.06904267519712448,
0.06602408736944199,
-0.13955487310886383,
-0.15934526920318604,
-0.2854740619659424,
-0.1785937398672104,
0.8398298025131226,
-0.30814358592033386,
0.16638222336769104,
0.07492879033088684,
-0.11804574728012085,
-0.22899068892002106,
0.3286712169647217,
0.816134512424469,
0.5466940999031067,
0.022466354072093964,
0.1415865272283554,
0.3415071666240692,
-0.5772491693496704,
0.07176580280065536,
-0.05331790819764137,
-0.4210476875305176,
0.21535952389240265,
0.738655149936676,
0.810009777545929,
0.1455211341381073,
-0.35001057386398315,
0.4442390203475952,
0.15235622227191925,
-0.26318538188934326,
-0.37772712111473083,
0.25155168771743774,
-0.1410461664199829,
0.34189704060554504,
0.5503817200660706,
0.009109006263315678,
0.1310276985168457,
-0.562829852104187,
0.2566005289554596,
0.7390429973602295,
-0.03679771348834038,
-0.421835333108902,
0.47801628708839417,
0.163339301943779,
-0.21418103575706482,
0.47460055351257324,
-0.16430912911891937,
-0.7506210803985596,
0.619187593460083,
0.4632432758808136,
0.84024977684021,
-0.13455703854560852,
0.3735913038253784,
0.17184513807296753,
0.5499096512794495,
-0.1319708675146103,
0.08557222783565521,
-0.03137068822979927,
-0.9592991471290588,
-0.3442983031272888,
-0.14920268952846527,
-0.43238791823387146,
0.4299786388874054,
-0.47061488032341003,
0.4951748251914978,
-0.30408036708831787,
-0.17055143415927887,
0.09976404905319214,
-0.06809404492378235,
-0.62406325340271,
0.00000704735066392459,
0.2299952358007431,
1.1528847217559814,
-1.0012937784194946,
1.1430257558822632,
0.5849558711051941,
0.0708857849240303,
-0.5831791758537292,
0.40937384963035583,
0.05620832368731499,
-0.6844118237495422,
0.3658806085586548,
0.20205743610858917,
0.2121833711862564,
0.07367080450057983,
-0.6430236101150513,
-0.8684087991714478,
0.6669144630432129,
0.49571692943573,
-0.8760617971420288,
-0.20309191942214966,
0.08014232665300369,
0.6277692317962646,
-0.16203707456588745,
-0.16358992457389832,
0.7714613080024719,
0.5818068981170654,
-0.1304500848054886,
-0.8792186975479126,
-0.0047017475590109825,
0.12609942257404327,
-0.4231409430503845,
0.3485433757305145,
-0.525904655456543,
0.7268584370613098,
-0.17416872084140778,
-0.310767263174057,
-0.2635669410228729,
0.671635627746582,
-0.2387339025735855,
0.44227251410484314,
0.6763774156570435,
0.4605402946472168,
0.8008611798286438,
-0.21813005208969116,
0.8452633023262024,
-0.5842185616493225,
0.49104729294776917,
0.6195224523544312,
0.029402118176221848,
0.653860867023468,
0.6510700583457947,
-0.07099439203739166,
0.6408431529998779,
0.7135574221611023,
-0.29155874252319336,
0.6992074847221375,
0.041330669075250626,
-0.05550989881157875,
-0.4494119882583618,
0.14284099638462067,
-0.1737138032913208,
0.512958288192749,
0.5066785216331482,
-0.33495521545410156,
-0.4682435095310211,
0.20307239890098572,
0.3607649803161621,
-0.10344289988279343,
-0.36514872312545776,
0.9662491083145142,
0.007703034672886133,
-0.8515526056289673,
0.6057261824607849,
0.20300957560539246,
0.802528440952301,
-0.48748400807380676,
0.3576970100402832,
-0.12373334914445877,
0.24299682676792145,
-0.17206719517707825,
-0.5018958449363708,
0.10826069861650467,
0.18060021102428436,
-0.2597332298755646,
0.03996311128139496,
0.7756226658821106,
-0.553991973400116,
-0.5021879076957703,
-0.0050603412091732025,
0.32712510228157043,
0.15039341151714325,
-0.2667207717895508,
-0.4321843683719635,
0.06830157339572906,
0.030377425253391266,
-0.2059459090232849,
0.06086358055472374,
0.2886377274990082,
-0.3006763160228729,
0.4644838273525238,
0.853594958782196,
-0.053125567734241486,
-0.163442000746727,
-0.11844462156295776,
0.8297185301780701,
-0.48842570185661316,
-0.7311772704124451,
-1.25739324092865,
0.022420328110456467,
-0.11701404303312302,
-0.23353569209575653,
1.0526244640350342,
0.526150107383728,
0.9185541272163391,
-0.27368029952049255,
1.0299746990203857,
-0.004045620560646057,
0.2927894592285156,
-0.6005584597587585,
0.6642214059829712,
-0.016748104244470596,
0.22126038372516632,
-0.52614426612854,
-0.5460624694824219,
-0.40504905581474304,
0.5617483258247375,
-0.5412142276763916,
-0.3180081248283386,
0.4743020534515381,
0.8803308606147766,
-0.021961430087685585,
0.1978020817041397,
0.16883014142513275,
0.35179460048675537,
0.6798186302185059,
0.5382384657859802,
0.7799507975578308,
-0.24190717935562134,
0.5905591249465942,
-0.2252885103225708,
-0.247975155711174,
-0.634086549282074,
-1.03785240650177,
-1.3708416223526,
-0.6614747047424316,
-0.3717215061187744,
-0.3736377954483032,
0.15970167517662048,
0.9379030466079712,
0.5632164478302002,
-0.9910933375358582,
0.16021427512168884,
-0.30129867792129517,
0.16682122647762299,
-0.10724309086799622,
-0.2109483927488327,
0.5858339071273804,
-0.44380900263786316,
-0.5860834717750549,
0.43757182359695435,
0.06654776632785797,
0.12202875316143036,
-0.173787921667099,
0.18500149250030518,
0.08293700218200684,
0.4231733977794647,
0.5709174871444702,
-0.013159754686057568,
-0.9570142030715942,
-0.7414075136184692,
0.028281889855861664,
-0.021716922521591187,
-0.20325779914855957,
0.8918018341064453,
-0.8201379179954529,
0.006549765355885029,
0.19223691523075104,
0.3479808270931244,
0.3788805902004242,
-0.1367509663105011,
0.4802544414997101,
-0.6936535239219666,
0.33171236515045166,
0.11370011419057846,
0.3039744198322296,
0.20502275228500366,
-0.6823228001594543,
0.279674232006073,
0.2848014831542969,
-0.4904944896697998,
-0.8012241721153259,
0.3304608166217804,
-0.8299794793128967,
-0.2752966582775116,
1.3410396575927734,
0.1518176645040512,
0.18894532322883606,
-0.234506756067276,
-0.2827432155609131,
0.36805132031440735,
-0.6689925789833069,
1.4412667751312256,
0.9160622358322144,
0.022087987512350082,
0.24044163525104523,
-0.20806892216205597,
0.8323872685432434,
0.23546338081359863,
-0.671230137348175,
-0.057296812534332275,
0.5337525606155396,
0.2984994351863861,
0.11314091831445694,
0.3583567440509796,
0.40389588475227356,
0.4435848593711853,
-0.33206239342689514,
-0.36295562982559204,
-0.05391906201839447,
-0.2749881148338318,
-0.2937858998775482,
0.36345118284225464,
-0.2936283051967621,
-0.10706660896539688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17983v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17983v1
|
TI-ASU: Toward Robust Automatic Speech Understanding through Text-to-speech Imputation Against Missing Speech Modality
| 2024-04-27T19:13:05 | 2024-04-27T19:13:05 |
Tiantian Feng, Xuan Shi, Rahul Gupta, Shrikanth S. Narayanan
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Automatic Speech Understanding (ASU) aims at human-like speech
interpretation, providing nuanced intent, emotion, sentiment, and content
understanding from speech and language (text) content conveyed in speech.
Typically, training a robust ASU model relies heavily on acquiring large-scale,
high-quality speech and associated transcriptions. However, it is often
challenging to collect or use speech data for training ASU due to concerns such
as privacy. To approach this setting of enabling ASU when speech (audio)
modality is missing, we propose TI-ASU, using a pre-trained text-to-speech
model to impute the missing speech. We report extensive experiments evaluating
TI-ASU on various missing scales, both multi- and single-modality settings, and
the use of LLMs. Our findings show that TI-ASU yields substantial benefits to
improve ASU in scenarios where even up to 95% of training speech is missing.
Moreover, we show that TI-ASU is adaptive to dropout training, improving model
robustness in addressing missing speech during inference.
|
[
-0.2886516749858856,
-0.6834360957145691,
0.32136183977127075,
0.13624276220798492,
-0.41188374161720276,
0.15732446312904358,
-0.37095755338668823,
-0.45869559049606323,
0.1681901216506958,
0.14395202696323395,
-0.5433232188224792,
-0.17539800703525543,
-0.5301351547241211,
0.3198011815547943,
-0.3827625513076782,
0.7268896102905273,
0.16214987635612488,
0.2371232509613037,
-0.22614642977714539,
-0.333506315946579,
-0.7513567805290222,
-0.312206894159317,
-0.8662952184677124,
-0.43577510118484497,
0.2612018883228302,
0.6074869632720947,
0.518562376499176,
0.8244880437850952,
0.08351951092481613,
0.2663431763648987,
-0.0924646258354187,
-0.08261840790510178,
-0.30192315578460693,
-0.04541558027267456,
-0.06679429858922958,
-0.24580855667591095,
-0.5530421733856201,
0.044434040784835815,
1.0788547992706299,
0.904489278793335,
-0.048130813986063004,
0.06581221520900726,
0.3788660764694214,
0.4608338177204132,
-0.5082736015319824,
0.1373302936553955,
-0.6693259477615356,
-0.04654170945286751,
-0.04095394164323807,
-0.2593354284763336,
-0.4129806458950043,
-0.07576999068260193,
0.21056172251701355,
-0.5986271500587463,
0.20269843935966492,
-0.26369306445121765,
0.7930074334144592,
0.9933710694313049,
-0.6178141832351685,
-0.16532336175441742,
-0.7720671892166138,
0.46180102229118347,
-0.42519205808639526,
0.7546122670173645,
0.8551990389823914,
0.10038361698389053,
0.09942381829023361,
-0.4545801877975464,
-0.5334503650665283,
-0.23970547318458557,
0.11421316117048264,
0.3539348542690277,
-0.14834710955619812,
0.2834632694721222,
0.1888260692358017,
0.5237813591957092,
-0.5096027851104736,
0.12740851938724518,
-0.04659479856491089,
-0.19168858230113983,
0.48508796095848083,
-0.17887534201145172,
0.3906157314777374,
-0.16245360672473907,
-0.22474732995033264,
0.26371657848358154,
-0.5904430150985718,
0.08594567328691483,
0.5028923153877258,
0.32825854420661926,
-0.20821674168109894,
0.25660285353660583,
-0.0522623136639595,
0.5967771410942078,
-0.12289861589670181,
0.10661809146404266,
0.2717036008834839,
-0.30550140142440796,
-0.3315143883228302,
0.39775437116622925,
0.7133288383483887,
-0.43233543634414673,
0.048792947083711624,
-0.4682937264442444,
-0.07772106677293777,
0.12051153928041458,
0.08908902108669281,
-0.548031747341156,
-0.11528880894184113,
0.17376841604709625,
-0.29438215494155884,
-0.0808199942111969,
-0.08661985397338867,
-0.3403496742248535,
-0.1706220507621765,
-0.45578745007514954,
0.795082688331604,
-0.642437219619751,
-0.4220004379749298,
-0.315377414226532,
-0.13268493115901947,
0.08820242434740067,
0.48390740156173706,
-0.7153769731521606,
0.3661845028400421,
0.41143256425857544,
0.5720354914665222,
-0.20062825083732605,
-0.3137180805206299,
-1.1280025243759155,
0.24313347041606903,
-0.054380469024181366,
0.6643828749656677,
-0.7238748073577881,
-0.7198152542114258,
-0.4704890549182892,
-0.2219434529542923,
-0.3661077618598938,
-0.38512808084487915,
0.8649415373802185,
-0.09466896951198578,
0.2377292662858963,
-0.16538205742835999,
-0.5280452966690063,
-0.553428590297699,
0.03246229141950607,
-0.593616247177124,
0.7564025521278381,
-0.27978211641311646,
-0.38764646649360657,
0.2198045551776886,
-0.8564509153366089,
-0.5989484190940857,
0.008757829666137695,
-0.3069642186164856,
-0.42196333408355713,
0.39552903175354004,
0.2762109935283661,
0.040099918842315674,
-0.36934858560562134,
0.3065608739852905,
-0.0871288925409317,
-0.5252067446708679,
0.29889780282974243,
-0.9198208451271057,
0.8651189804077148,
0.2844540476799011,
-0.24746473133563995,
0.31883177161216736,
-0.9941958785057068,
-0.26829925179481506,
-0.10170838236808777,
-0.34644415974617004,
-0.27501365542411804,
0.08854182064533234,
0.3433457612991333,
-0.3235015571117401,
0.01386348158121109,
-0.6124420166015625,
-0.34786441922187805,
-0.5975255966186523,
0.67190021276474,
0.7465718388557434,
-0.2229233682155609,
0.45847928524017334,
-0.20034199953079224,
0.5009615421295166,
-0.1515505462884903,
-0.12065040320158005,
-0.268693208694458,
-0.28588035702705383,
-0.6040545701980591,
-0.5563902854919434,
0.5288620591163635,
0.639109194278717,
-0.8604677319526672,
0.3134223520755768,
-0.31001535058021545,
-0.11666114628314972,
-0.5976913571357727,
-0.11979389190673828,
0.4707994759082794,
0.9691352248191833,
0.35463273525238037,
-0.14530280232429504,
-0.4315369725227356,
-0.5529947876930237,
-0.42777055501937866,
-0.2084217667579651,
-0.23738227784633636,
0.38746702671051025,
0.20749956369400024,
-0.33578652143478394,
1.1826876401901245,
0.03616970404982567,
-0.5103383660316467,
-0.2905300259590149,
0.13543321192264557,
-0.21387621760368347,
0.511482298374176,
0.07102980464696884,
-1.0318479537963867,
-0.2468983680009842,
-0.1973213106393814,
-0.6415035724639893,
-0.17409434914588928,
-0.010587516240775585,
0.39381149411201477,
0.2669086158275604,
0.3712014853954315,
-0.18747492134571075,
0.6416116952896118,
0.2906855642795563,
-0.4835048019886017,
0.11961977928876877,
-0.2939852178096771,
0.176349937915802,
-1.3287581205368042,
0.23548611998558044,
0.00815439224243164,
-0.6826019287109375,
-0.8101338744163513,
-0.13759244978427887,
-0.05528511106967926,
-0.7567415833473206,
-0.3220005929470062,
0.5096619725227356,
-0.48203200101852417,
-0.15693360567092896,
-0.30104929208755493,
0.18243376910686493,
-0.02055155672132969,
0.4064633250236511,
0.26235145330429077,
1.0031898021697998,
0.6117435693740845,
-0.5260152220726013,
-0.0054410104639828205,
0.47901931405067444,
0.40374815464019775,
0.5159761905670166,
-0.49236243963241577,
0.46401506662368774,
-0.10703637450933456,
0.13102950155735016,
-1.0010336637496948,
-0.3515450954437256,
0.3567979037761688,
-0.9025552272796631,
0.7023985981941223,
-0.3448652923107147,
-0.2999628186225891,
0.04412500187754631,
-0.18923449516296387,
0.5511574745178223,
0.13490185141563416,
-0.31291061639785767,
1.1766042709350586,
0.7177989482879639,
-0.21162088215351105,
-0.5954963564872742,
-0.6652460694313049,
0.2805155813694,
-0.335563063621521,
-0.4029093086719513,
0.20082062482833862,
-0.07701268047094345,
-0.016019275411963463,
0.09499742835760117,
-0.3133704662322998,
-0.3674922585487366,
0.4132646322250366,
0.49800723791122437,
0.15776899456977844,
-0.29594823718070984,
0.2746898829936981,
0.08579972386360168,
-0.37542808055877686,
0.03843752294778824,
-0.21834442019462585,
0.3552156984806061,
-0.19527608156204224,
-0.3465151786804199,
-1.0322500467300415,
0.47111472487449646,
0.35803231596946716,
-0.21630898118019104,
0.2202947735786438,
0.6543206572532654,
-0.6956728100776672,
0.21524594724178314,
-0.5354180335998535,
-0.1540084332227707,
-0.410351425409317,
0.25926610827445984,
-0.4697965681552887,
-0.721355676651001,
0.4617561101913452,
0.2164669930934906,
-0.028938112780451775,
0.29292917251586914,
0.21531733870506287,
-0.1946963518857956,
0.6833099722862244,
0.8844130039215088,
-0.22690242528915405,
0.8593640923500061,
-0.07867317646741867,
-0.12997332215309143,
-0.6098670363426208,
0.13906805217266083,
-0.5904586911201477,
-0.2222871333360672,
-0.32030540704727173,
-0.2119704633951187,
0.48397576808929443,
-0.38531026244163513,
0.01338176429271698,
0.06759119778871536,
-0.39558079838752747,
0.3641921877861023,
0.7390729784965515,
0.33976981043815613,
0.6346786618232727,
0.10046736150979996,
0.4817340075969696,
0.05085460841655731,
-0.5563859343528748,
-0.28367024660110474,
0.9832784533500671,
0.458328515291214,
0.5503532886505127,
0.058426689356565475,
0.5717924237251282,
0.2979278862476349,
0.21240946650505066,
-1.2116731405258179,
0.4002314805984497,
-0.33144134283065796,
-0.417490690946579,
-0.5477451086044312,
-0.7058629393577576,
-0.6886079907417297,
0.10209497809410095,
-0.09342557936906815,
-0.7672625184059143,
0.20598569512367249,
0.43952420353889465,
-0.6762222647666931,
0.12627340853214264,
-0.9271904230117798,
0.7699019908905029,
-0.0011933797504752874,
-0.07567591220140457,
-0.4158814251422882,
-0.8705165386199951,
0.09055585414171219,
-0.09723953157663345,
0.08830904215574265,
-0.12736858427524567,
-0.11355994641780853,
0.888954758644104,
-0.4205373227596283,
0.7118402719497681,
-0.31630173325538635,
0.1811891347169876,
0.200522318482399,
-0.14212454855442047,
0.06457796692848206,
0.17959636449813843,
-0.15156938135623932,
0.25243693590164185,
-0.18908478319644928,
-0.14612293243408203,
-0.3122124671936035,
0.4688842296600342,
-0.8926280736923218,
-0.4958385229110718,
-0.5201658606529236,
-0.7806313037872314,
-0.41741687059402466,
0.07238306105136871,
0.5429462790489197,
0.9579962491989136,
-0.026683956384658813,
0.2596738040447235,
0.947476863861084,
-0.2948218584060669,
0.6582504510879517,
0.45266857743263245,
0.43057331442832947,
-0.5861386656761169,
1.233106255531311,
0.23850198090076447,
0.17169924080371857,
0.3664981424808502,
0.3360595703125,
-0.6496189832687378,
-0.635718047618866,
-0.7607775926589966,
0.19420818984508514,
-0.5462787747383118,
-0.4113905727863312,
-0.7126193046569824,
-0.30586761236190796,
-0.42810386419296265,
0.09670650213956833,
-0.37598052620887756,
-0.41264522075653076,
-0.8558445572853088,
0.013016658835113049,
0.4240381121635437,
0.4789452850818634,
-0.15551292896270752,
0.5120850801467896,
-0.7686986327171326,
0.5919765830039978,
0.2689763307571411,
0.3382894992828369,
-0.2125263512134552,
-1.0148677825927734,
0.10296674817800522,
0.17440243065357208,
-0.22668807208538055,
-0.8776857256889343,
0.2603199779987335,
0.7838678956031799,
0.43851983547210693,
0.2895749509334564,
0.17633546888828278,
0.8148902654647827,
-0.43925580382347107,
0.5238651633262634,
0.2129179984331131,
-1.410811185836792,
0.993857204914093,
-0.3871467709541321,
0.3054327070713043,
0.6577557325363159,
0.09619004279375076,
-0.38534295558929443,
-0.46357619762420654,
-0.6551589369773865,
-0.8560755252838135,
1.1404300928115845,
0.3376368284225464,
0.05217387527227402,
0.39252614974975586,
0.2636122405529022,
0.21694038808345795,
0.024936260655522346,
-0.8725534677505493,
-0.4185124635696411,
-0.45204663276672363,
-0.5766347050666809,
0.00185655546374619,
-0.2298724502325058,
-0.0409591868519783,
-0.019316142424941063,
0.7882816195487976,
-0.13001985847949982,
0.26343104243278503,
0.38063758611679077,
-0.5307543873786926,
-0.18648000061511993,
0.3477324843406677,
0.386424720287323,
0.6613196134567261,
-0.044293418526649475,
0.05236845836043358,
0.3151263892650604,
-0.8263670206069946,
0.11779174208641052,
0.719536304473877,
-0.07936357706785202,
0.08428511023521423,
-0.0101224509999156,
0.896755039691925,
0.0688595101237297,
-0.7195404767990112,
0.5044015645980835,
-0.36554670333862305,
0.01705419458448887,
-0.38722679018974304,
-0.03963050618767738,
-0.19670839607715607,
-0.050218336284160614,
0.662180483341217,
0.17123138904571533,
0.4207192063331604,
-0.6540281176567078,
0.31117284297943115,
0.31161195039749146,
-0.8186858296394348,
-0.3015916645526886,
1.0834800004959106,
0.3478173613548279,
-0.5166579484939575,
0.43762972950935364,
-0.0468684658408165,
-0.18373940885066986,
0.41371458768844604,
0.49511271715164185,
0.9935389757156372,
-0.3686915338039398,
-0.022647328674793243,
-0.2079719454050064,
0.06739068776369095,
0.18614009022712708,
0.24187526106834412,
-0.38666823506355286,
-0.4060713052749634,
-0.47075504064559937,
-0.4717998206615448,
-0.5925864577293396,
0.1454908400774002,
-0.7325702905654907,
0.378559410572052,
-0.3811563551425934,
-0.1107790619134903,
-0.12349710613489151,
-0.0693303644657135,
-0.4660795032978058,
0.36469322443008423,
0.37951040267944336,
0.6671067476272583,
-0.8115084171295166,
1.0509486198425293,
0.7910795211791992,
-0.5517589449882507,
-1.1277458667755127,
0.2605428397655487,
0.15706971287727356,
-0.6425997614860535,
0.12833450734615326,
0.321437805891037,
-0.42857155203819275,
0.5502729415893555,
-0.18097122013568878,
-0.6789222359657288,
0.7888785600662231,
0.8439970016479492,
-0.28163009881973267,
-0.01627175696194172,
0.10553418099880219,
0.23229940235614777,
0.05843575298786163,
0.13756327331066132,
0.5545956492424011,
0.012654961086809635,
0.4147558808326721,
-1.1951860189437866,
-0.07965095341205597,
-0.1647416055202484,
-0.2697427570819855,
0.00996666681021452,
-0.3847431540489197,
0.4855637550354004,
-0.03307336941361427,
-0.40550994873046875,
0.028553791344165802,
0.9470004439353943,
0.008525748737156391,
0.7836102843284607,
0.6933490633964539,
0.5039462447166443,
0.8495746850967407,
-0.1876630187034607,
0.620206356048584,
0.019749576225876808,
0.15717853605747223,
1.341744065284729,
0.2064444124698639,
0.819680392742157,
0.15518520772457123,
0.14334793388843536,
-0.1738402396440506,
0.690644383430481,
0.5219117999076843,
0.13606196641921997,
-0.41449418663978577,
-0.4920598268508911,
-0.18143150210380554,
-0.3199238181114197,
-0.36686208844184875,
0.790667712688446,
0.5220533013343811,
-0.01840393804013729,
-0.14130978286266327,
0.45543748140335083,
-0.027040425688028336,
0.24561592936515808,
-0.4983268976211548,
1.0447615385055542,
0.13870200514793396,
-0.172627255320549,
0.5723844170570374,
-0.3755342960357666,
0.4453105032444,
-0.49268293380737305,
0.13867983222007751,
-0.27722060680389404,
-0.09849478304386139,
-0.2265120893716812,
-0.5291768312454224,
0.6171308159828186,
0.2501868009567261,
-0.1625167429447174,
-0.39245226979255676,
0.6907251477241516,
-0.5138469338417053,
-0.4096433222293854,
-0.03826102986931801,
0.47191861271858215,
0.2573097348213196,
-0.4454362690448761,
-0.5240978002548218,
0.07366076111793518,
-0.007993285544216633,
0.19224676489830017,
0.01781277544796467,
0.5900059342384338,
0.16485396027565002,
0.6333921551704407,
0.3669738471508026,
0.014959607273340225,
-0.26319068670272827,
0.31695231795310974,
0.7200136184692383,
-0.45077821612358093,
-0.8782644867897034,
-0.9562360048294067,
0.34424951672554016,
0.08028813451528549,
-0.03715107962489128,
0.5025149583816528,
0.6110485792160034,
0.5591520071029663,
0.23643821477890015,
0.7160379886627197,
-0.07982154190540314,
0.6866149306297302,
-0.3467814028263092,
0.9105418920516968,
-0.8765916228294373,
0.1915346384048462,
-0.2806798815727234,
-0.6517185568809509,
-0.40651533007621765,
0.5504297614097595,
-0.27285730838775635,
-0.3481391668319702,
0.4500574469566345,
0.48879751563072205,
-0.13948355615139008,
0.32756859064102173,
0.44438299536705017,
0.18466033041477203,
0.29535040259361267,
0.410191148519516,
0.7525281310081482,
-0.48495611548423767,
0.7667824029922485,
0.17494522035121918,
-0.33309048414230347,
-0.03355151414871216,
-0.49629706144332886,
-0.6655035614967346,
-0.6739082336425781,
-0.4224233031272888,
-0.1741901934146881,
-0.07477319985628128,
1.2137150764465332,
0.6152491569519043,
-0.6761976480484009,
-0.25464117527008057,
-0.1423228234052658,
0.2941723167896271,
0.025888558477163315,
-0.152647465467453,
0.35178178548812866,
-0.30517956614494324,
-0.9695287942886353,
0.7082390785217285,
0.4200005829334259,
0.13796046376228333,
0.2147192358970642,
0.07848815619945526,
-0.008554632775485516,
-0.14905011653900146,
0.40658554434776306,
0.5440444946289062,
-0.7120897173881531,
-0.4243197441101074,
-0.27095261216163635,
0.31142088770866394,
0.4147289991378784,
0.7038013339042664,
-0.959578275680542,
0.5687316060066223,
0.28919878602027893,
1.0570976734161377,
0.2617965042591095,
0.0871862918138504,
0.6860345602035522,
-0.8987596035003662,
0.386442631483078,
0.5259731411933899,
0.40021079778671265,
0.4918615221977234,
-0.40614768862724304,
0.38672181963920593,
0.5165557861328125,
-0.39164459705352783,
-1.082786202430725,
0.14179793000221252,
-1.3059478998184204,
-0.04288085922598839,
1.0916249752044678,
-0.05144837498664856,
-0.07541590929031372,
-0.3772255778312683,
-0.32761549949645996,
0.8968227505683899,
-0.6493909358978271,
0.643726110458374,
0.19519701600074768,
-0.05411820113658905,
-0.3203186094760895,
-0.44704508781433105,
0.49835219979286194,
0.4693530201911926,
-0.77879798412323,
0.1899767369031906,
0.48350387811660767,
0.3452325463294983,
-0.08935892581939697,
0.7628921270370483,
0.24200217425823212,
0.3650280833244324,
-0.061738282442092896,
-0.2919258773326874,
-0.28232342004776,
-0.3895418345928192,
-0.6631042957305908,
0.08417560905218124,
0.022055618464946747,
-0.7588491439819336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17975v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17975v1
|
Automating Customer Needs Analysis: A Comparative Study of Large Language Models in the Travel Industry
| 2024-04-27T18:28:10 | 2024-04-27T18:28:10 |
Simone Barandoni, Filippo Chiarello, Lorenzo Cascone, Emiliano Marrale, Salvatore Puccio
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
In the rapidly evolving landscape of Natural Language Processing (NLP), Large
Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful tools for many tasks, such as
extracting valuable insights from vast amounts of textual data. In this study,
we conduct a comparative analysis of LLMs for the extraction of travel customer
needs from TripAdvisor posts. Leveraging a diverse range of models, including
both open-source and proprietary ones such as GPT-4 and Gemini, we aim to
elucidate their strengths and weaknesses in this specialized domain. Through an
evaluation process involving metrics such as BERTScore, ROUGE, and BLEU, we
assess the performance of each model in accurately identifying and summarizing
customer needs. Our findings highlight the efficacy of opensource LLMs,
particularly Mistral 7B, in achieving comparable performance to larger closed
models while offering affordability and customization benefits. Additionally,
we underscore the importance of considering factors such as model size,
resource requirements, and performance metrics when selecting the most suitable
LLM for customer needs analysis tasks. Overall, this study contributes valuable
insights for businesses seeking to leverage advanced NLP techniques to enhance
customer experience and drive operational efficiency in the travel industry.
|
[
-0.40214478969573975,
-0.3632449507713318,
0.5128477811813354,
0.4072860777378082,
-0.05263744294643402,
-0.019887804985046387,
-0.26968711614608765,
-0.752119243144989,
0.1685313582420349,
0.7119839191436768,
-0.6470407247543335,
-0.44444483518600464,
-0.38800248503685,
0.33975955843925476,
-0.5467624664306641,
0.6262205839157104,
-0.25648194551467896,
0.012419015169143677,
-0.34208574891090393,
-0.10707753896713257,
-0.3445018231868744,
-0.7464945316314697,
-0.712910532951355,
-0.09019351005554199,
0.47694268822669983,
0.20663590729236603,
0.5886563658714294,
0.2063545435667038,
0.9398022890090942,
0.2683354914188385,
0.013658656738698483,
0.0853111743927002,
-0.271563321352005,
0.19366735219955444,
-0.09853284060955048,
0.0009170824196189642,
-0.5562946796417236,
-0.13332505524158478,
0.5166464447975159,
0.679455041885376,
-0.4352564513683319,
0.4475189745426178,
0.124325692653656,
0.6020600199699402,
-0.32904163002967834,
0.22129611670970917,
-0.4996081590652466,
-0.030235974118113518,
0.1119782030582428,
-0.0005734394071623683,
0.13084650039672852,
-0.5210246443748474,
0.5097488164901733,
-0.5389349460601807,
0.3189623951911926,
0.11276423186063766,
1.0720988512039185,
0.46922147274017334,
-0.0674598440527916,
-0.7833928465843201,
-0.9090035557746887,
0.7089522480964661,
-0.7246288061141968,
0.6203444004058838,
0.15004122257232666,
0.2970733940601349,
0.05957663431763649,
-0.7016655206680298,
-0.2916516363620758,
-0.22901661694049835,
-0.08538229763507843,
-0.025894388556480408,
-0.2897896468639374,
-0.12924908101558685,
0.3769909739494324,
0.6192673444747925,
-0.8660863041877747,
0.22297565639019012,
-0.48942914605140686,
-0.0914023295044899,
0.388472318649292,
0.308651864528656,
0.3229692876338959,
-0.33473336696624756,
-0.28379207849502563,
0.1777006983757019,
-0.5010316967964172,
0.04204697161912918,
0.15118126571178436,
0.16431626677513123,
-0.0019563997630029917,
0.7002660632133484,
-0.26010221242904663,
0.5147051811218262,
-0.3854854702949524,
-0.03294102102518082,
0.08396373689174652,
-0.11486299335956573,
-0.2955707013607025,
-0.2701842784881592,
0.8853822350502014,
0.3309091627597809,
0.40750154852867126,
-0.4795266389846802,
-0.524729311466217,
-0.35005587339401245,
0.3806432783603668,
-0.8093968033790588,
-0.08322912454605103,
0.32977378368377686,
-0.7447563409805298,
0.17542116343975067,
0.1407802850008011,
-0.7073381543159485,
-0.32909950613975525,
-0.618006706237793,
0.05444621667265892,
-0.1524658501148224,
-0.4714575409889221,
-0.005376627203077078,
-0.3779740035533905,
0.6855760812759399,
0.248273566365242,
-0.808509886264801,
0.501562237739563,
0.7996639609336853,
1.177067756652832,
-0.6538277268409729,
-0.1468299925327301,
-0.26864662766456604,
-0.31579869985580444,
-0.002589349402114749,
1.0498112440109253,
-0.36266860365867615,
-0.5128240585327148,
0.19095467031002045,
-0.17913930118083954,
-0.045299921184778214,
-0.8597314357757568,
0.5764501690864563,
-0.892176628112793,
0.007536217570304871,
-0.46042346954345703,
-0.25271785259246826,
-0.3092733323574066,
0.5396143198013306,
-0.9083981513977051,
0.9123599529266357,
0.39261478185653687,
-0.3139013350009918,
0.30278506875038147,
-0.65570068359375,
-0.19896286725997925,
0.32956695556640625,
-0.03250908479094505,
-0.5160895586013794,
0.317188560962677,
0.3075047433376312,
0.23027601838111877,
-0.4407951533794403,
-0.028144991025328636,
-0.38265419006347656,
-0.1370355784893036,
0.3720606565475464,
-0.18876563012599945,
0.6928873062133789,
0.37754422426223755,
-0.05442837253212929,
0.11448732018470764,
-0.6591980457305908,
-0.07817328721284866,
0.07398269325494766,
-0.5550128817558289,
-0.09485220909118652,
0.09616757929325104,
0.5040239691734314,
0.2668032944202423,
0.42559441924095154,
-0.2598521411418915,
0.1298774927854538,
-0.7119846343994141,
0.24172250926494598,
0.5652018189430237,
-0.02461128495633602,
0.34233060479164124,
-0.061718106269836426,
0.9515512585639954,
-0.39460068941116333,
0.32952988147735596,
0.012507925741374493,
-0.3637716770172119,
-0.9560638070106506,
-0.09822983294725418,
0.14530706405639648,
0.372208833694458,
-0.40878546237945557,
0.4111749529838562,
-0.2753796875476837,
-0.4523731768131256,
-0.6725038886070251,
0.3878273665904999,
-0.030441949144005775,
0.2515610456466675,
0.3312649130821228,
-0.3940970003604889,
-0.62320476770401,
-0.7722392678260803,
-0.4922698736190796,
-0.13952434062957764,
-0.08836732059717178,
0.17122772336006165,
0.13158820569515228,
-0.38292163610458374,
0.9979005455970764,
-0.574962317943573,
-0.4106568992137909,
-0.6211637854576111,
-0.23325090110301971,
0.35518938302993774,
-0.2004406601190567,
0.6553125381469727,
-0.6242889761924744,
-0.6052215099334717,
-0.018299493938684464,
-0.8283968567848206,
-0.46353939175605774,
0.12674666941165924,
0.05665391683578491,
0.43664202094078064,
0.2564833164215088,
-0.6370905041694641,
0.463480681180954,
0.5997294783592224,
-0.21596194803714752,
0.5476133227348328,
-0.14435458183288574,
0.09428731352090836,
-0.7767531871795654,
0.25801339745521545,
0.17331679165363312,
-0.3015090525150299,
-0.5743452906608582,
-0.1489647775888443,
0.02632884681224823,
-0.4150955080986023,
-0.23794126510620117,
0.4854123592376709,
-0.5892676115036011,
-0.5006600022315979,
-0.7512268424034119,
-0.006032173056155443,
0.051036279648542404,
0.2841830253601074,
0.19154885411262512,
0.7791998386383057,
0.3880222737789154,
-0.7630917429924011,
0.6576771140098572,
0.32585564255714417,
-0.3878249526023865,
0.2607164978981018,
-0.7858333587646484,
0.12773080170154572,
0.0551324188709259,
-0.06638770550489426,
-0.854884147644043,
-0.10093218833208084,
0.3194126784801483,
-0.40344297885894775,
-0.22216831147670746,
-0.11759495735168457,
-0.5971401929855347,
-0.5109424591064453,
0.15670554339885712,
0.054932188242673874,
0.5773881673812866,
-0.4801223576068878,
0.8972229957580566,
0.43145760893821716,
-0.6169565916061401,
-0.25392860174179077,
-0.3439444303512573,
0.5609517097473145,
-0.449513703584671,
-0.4802829623222351,
0.027638264000415802,
-0.02881276234984398,
-0.3686564862728119,
-0.05075882375240326,
-0.2111603319644928,
-0.0946495532989502,
0.290571391582489,
0.4949738681316376,
0.4555719792842865,
-0.23163126409053802,
-0.07410287111997604,
-0.3020782768726349,
-0.24420760571956635,
0.494189977645874,
-0.602360188961029,
0.6553150415420532,
-0.29162243008613586,
-0.16640692949295044,
-0.6081113815307617,
0.28958168625831604,
0.4852226674556732,
-0.4855506122112274,
0.5671738982200623,
0.4780693054199219,
-0.2467154860496521,
-0.23754538595676422,
-0.7534120678901672,
0.16380077600479126,
-0.4974043667316437,
0.05547994747757912,
-0.41635993123054504,
-0.6759766936302185,
0.5447849035263062,
0.18932080268859863,
0.11916228383779526,
0.665948748588562,
0.6698640584945679,
-0.020142434164881706,
0.45757797360420227,
0.9354367256164551,
-0.23027905821800232,
0.34386736154556274,
-0.1614420861005783,
0.24555519223213196,
-0.4598047733306885,
-0.29983752965927124,
-0.7492629885673523,
-0.06064946576952934,
-0.4301990568637848,
-0.03255071863532066,
0.3929338753223419,
-0.3678092956542969,
0.2716411054134369,
0.5144926309585571,
-0.27140191197395325,
0.2789435386657715,
0.42463579773902893,
-0.5420162081718445,
0.593113124370575,
0.12579907476902008,
0.3722870647907257,
0.1696348488330841,
-0.46607857942581177,
-0.7614219188690186,
0.8653296232223511,
0.311388224363327,
0.966792106628418,
0.28205543756484985,
0.17956413328647614,
0.34911590814590454,
0.36674439907073975,
-0.9816446900367737,
0.4282301664352417,
0.023926181718707085,
-0.4638698399066925,
-0.035632651299238205,
-0.5109259486198425,
-0.9797587394714355,
0.2580238878726959,
-0.009098375216126442,
-0.45925983786582947,
0.07665514200925827,
0.023856161162257195,
-0.6283568739891052,
0.04750999063253403,
-0.8596866130828857,
0.6431643962860107,
-0.41827407479286194,
0.15623976290225983,
-0.009954308159649372,
-0.16870811581611633,
0.0999986082315445,
-0.36797717213630676,
0.148756206035614,
-0.13126151263713837,
-0.21197648346424103,
0.8480468392372131,
-0.270026832818985,
0.5447284579277039,
-0.12661691009998322,
-0.15367314219474792,
0.17686058580875397,
0.018500378355383873,
0.16024792194366455,
-0.0945945456624031,
-0.20443235337734222,
0.5562970638275146,
0.10179545730352402,
-0.13712982833385468,
-0.5672946572303772,
0.9652084708213806,
-0.7816007137298584,
-0.4210488796234131,
-0.4706481099128723,
-0.3168017566204071,
-0.2552558183670044,
0.454762727022171,
0.022324133664369583,
0.21482768654823303,
-0.27160489559173584,
-0.17967630922794342,
0.3375532329082489,
-0.35410773754119873,
0.7979387044906616,
0.7364206314086914,
-0.434847354888916,
-0.4923050105571747,
0.6898018717765808,
0.174634650349617,
0.16689153015613556,
0.13968715071678162,
0.004634369630366564,
-0.5352832078933716,
-0.8738084435462952,
-0.16322766244411469,
0.6163221001625061,
-0.6424763202667236,
0.017737597227096558,
-0.9811894297599792,
-0.2968042492866516,
-0.7176005244255066,
0.12610158324241638,
-0.41250500082969666,
-0.26655325293540955,
-0.2115601897239685,
0.024936189875006676,
-0.02520870417356491,
0.9499411582946777,
0.4116300940513611,
0.6569166779518127,
-0.8335938453674316,
0.4681345820426941,
-0.013291378505527973,
0.42913252115249634,
-0.08682471513748169,
-0.4196237325668335,
-0.5798979997634888,
-0.5050067901611328,
-0.31890812516212463,
-0.6516906023025513,
0.6345607042312622,
-0.14472532272338867,
0.6566034555435181,
0.5526047945022583,
-0.16409291326999664,
0.7326831817626953,
-0.22596468031406403,
0.7812255620956421,
-0.0242390725761652,
-0.8896024823188782,
0.5012577176094055,
-0.2251826822757721,
0.25233855843544006,
0.6207014918327332,
0.6054767966270447,
-0.8983566761016846,
-0.19060583412647247,
-0.7037041783332825,
-0.9802613854408264,
0.7114140391349792,
0.3379001319408417,
0.040766630321741104,
0.29418519139289856,
0.4939207434654236,
0.11551638692617416,
0.4082925319671631,
-0.855056881904602,
0.12278547137975693,
0.09778440743684769,
-0.08707556873559952,
-0.235388845205307,
-0.2772655189037323,
0.20883023738861084,
0.1162748709321022,
0.5492646098136902,
0.20731431245803833,
0.18151192367076874,
0.2890494465827942,
-0.24294807016849518,
-0.08484170585870743,
-0.06844862550497055,
0.32899633049964905,
1.170527696609497,
-0.32180076837539673,
-0.1307450383901596,
0.09529406577348709,
-0.3110203444957733,
-0.3774932324886322,
0.1893346607685089,
0.014216458424925804,
0.21354049444198608,
0.3555612564086914,
0.545486330986023,
-0.45541200041770935,
-0.8770930767059326,
0.6162727475166321,
-0.260200560092926,
-0.030520407482981682,
-0.7598012685775757,
0.09893887490034103,
-0.0067357262596488,
0.13629131019115448,
0.2401902824640274,
-0.24983978271484375,
0.4428284764289856,
-0.17847731709480286,
-0.07353413105010986,
0.4307813346385956,
-0.6913891434669495,
-0.37265709042549133,
0.41373923420906067,
0.3211129903793335,
-0.6916856169700623,
0.7996078133583069,
0.0495680496096611,
-0.3308141827583313,
0.4640658497810364,
0.1931588351726532,
1.1056265830993652,
-0.3505220413208008,
-0.12542326748371124,
0.24439555406570435,
0.5417428612709045,
-0.04534200578927994,
0.08714287728071213,
0.0057743447832763195,
-0.48523417115211487,
-0.5023284554481506,
-0.7819168567657471,
-0.5466805100440979,
0.3849129378795624,
-0.6202300190925598,
0.45881128311157227,
-0.45181581377983093,
-0.10140926390886307,
-0.15624511241912842,
-0.18934540450572968,
-0.9888599514961243,
0.08996553719043732,
0.19318340718746185,
0.8422644138336182,
-0.601553738117218,
0.4271298348903656,
0.447658896446228,
-0.4033544361591339,
-0.7454837560653687,
0.1975572258234024,
-0.06873022019863129,
-0.6281229853630066,
0.5430927276611328,
0.35765549540519714,
-0.31321945786476135,
-0.2221287488937378,
-0.011210093274712563,
-0.8094290494918823,
0.8353223204612732,
-0.1439499855041504,
-0.713988721370697,
-0.5316117405891418,
0.38522985577583313,
0.481731116771698,
-0.3820793628692627,
0.31384533643722534,
0.7786698937416077,
0.21720032393932343,
-0.05491359531879425,
-1.0190845727920532,
-0.16235370934009552,
-0.027113649994134903,
0.1174800917506218,
0.1645677536725998,
-0.511513888835907,
0.2811347544193268,
0.15069791674613953,
-0.3802526593208313,
0.0024078015703707933,
0.6659995317459106,
-0.08871236443519592,
0.4010672867298126,
0.7589688897132874,
0.42183783650398254,
0.5984565615653992,
0.08074528723955154,
0.9756680130958557,
-0.0718584731221199,
0.398427277803421,
0.9895888566970825,
-0.31000322103500366,
0.8087431788444519,
0.5439870953559875,
-0.1473139077425003,
0.3553885519504547,
0.7632228136062622,
-0.19217661023139954,
0.3626018464565277,
0.10785286128520966,
0.16419152915477753,
-0.09699830412864685,
0.2804129123687744,
-0.2154436558485031,
0.5409789681434631,
0.32132434844970703,
-0.28655627369880676,
-0.5508683919906616,
0.16791927814483643,
-0.16027644276618958,
-0.36826592683792114,
-0.2616654634475708,
1.073218584060669,
0.34652742743492126,
-0.9020082950592041,
0.4369239807128906,
0.03657341003417969,
0.2992866337299347,
-0.7372946739196777,
0.28874170780181885,
-0.18153326213359833,
0.13151945173740387,
-0.2604163885116577,
-0.4929358661174774,
0.7813218235969543,
0.38690540194511414,
0.137180894613266,
-0.39335426688194275,
0.641848623752594,
0.022160708904266357,
-0.49399441480636597,
0.3717356026172638,
0.51679527759552,
0.35007181763648987,
-0.589317262172699,
-0.8355575799942017,
0.2582312226295471,
-0.11947234719991684,
-0.4254702031612396,
-0.13988637924194336,
0.22469180822372437,
0.33775103092193604,
0.7870966792106628,
0.6172170042991638,
0.35552269220352173,
0.006653378251940012,
0.2526624798774719,
0.8361448645591736,
-0.9572016000747681,
-0.4586068391799927,
-0.9642435312271118,
0.4809722304344177,
-0.1624923050403595,
-0.3049546480178833,
0.9222525358200073,
0.982918381690979,
0.48034924268722534,
-0.04274490848183632,
0.9202632308006287,
0.209178164601326,
0.6939252614974976,
-0.5529471635818481,
0.5063775777816772,
-0.4532620906829834,
0.7639452219009399,
-0.07687033712863922,
-1.1549171209335327,
-0.22455191612243652,
0.2893924415111542,
-0.5896304845809937,
-0.09362668544054031,
0.6176112294197083,
0.8188481330871582,
-0.1606811285018921,
0.010948173701763153,
0.02045336179435253,
-0.14950603246688843,
0.9029424786567688,
0.25446516275405884,
1.2462791204452515,
-0.1673402339220047,
0.8150768280029297,
0.2487327754497528,
-0.15967829525470734,
-0.32366010546684265,
-0.5281029343605042,
-0.9359074831008911,
-0.538974940776825,
-0.3763636350631714,
-0.5272464752197266,
-0.09406713396310806,
0.9815852642059326,
0.4890296161174774,
-0.45305347442626953,
-0.5262777805328369,
0.044980488717556,
0.05423574149608612,
-0.05012999847531319,
-0.2547050714492798,
0.1564396470785141,
-0.6790634989738464,
-0.6014466881752014,
0.27250248193740845,
0.4956181049346924,
0.11501065641641617,
-0.47371676564216614,
0.17697086930274963,
0.45670872926712036,
0.2385929822921753,
0.4210655689239502,
0.10623173415660858,
-0.6825307607650757,
0.19745904207229614,
0.18950679898262024,
-0.13146330416202545,
0.08190049976110458,
1.0550934076309204,
-0.38577747344970703,
0.10598917305469513,
0.33154574036598206,
0.760330855846405,
0.6771506071090698,
-0.03137589991092682,
0.5114737153053284,
-0.11891356855630875,
-0.31577056646347046,
0.24935588240623474,
0.35058504343032837,
0.36538076400756836,
-0.34145015478134155,
0.1785919964313507,
0.16710402071475983,
-0.7443673610687256,
-0.5973050594329834,
0.18977482616901398,
-1.337725281715393,
-0.3769732117652893,
1.6319999694824219,
0.14091390371322632,
-0.24758698046207428,
-0.28952082991600037,
-0.25679856538772583,
-0.18132464587688446,
-0.22407928109169006,
0.9034584760665894,
0.7652332782745361,
-0.19338063895702362,
0.06563538312911987,
-0.6569838523864746,
0.6023330092430115,
-0.04189556464552879,
-0.9455543160438538,
0.15255895256996155,
0.5327764749526978,
0.543516993522644,
-0.01739775575697422,
0.7924385070800781,
0.05270032584667206,
-0.09520339965820312,
-0.543592631816864,
0.15285946428775787,
0.05416638031601906,
-0.3767053186893463,
-0.4348015785217285,
0.5016447305679321,
0.42054659128189087,
-0.009379132650792599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17968v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17968v1
|
Usefulness of Emotional Prosody in Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-04-27T18:04:28 | 2024-04-27T18:04:28 |
Charles Brazier, Jean-Luc Rouas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Neural Machine Translation (NMT) is the task of translating a text from one
language to another with the use of a trained neural network. Several existing
works aim at incorporating external information into NMT models to improve or
control predicted translations (e.g. sentiment, politeness, gender). In this
work, we propose to improve translation quality by adding another external
source of information: the automatically recognized emotion in the voice. This
work is motivated by the assumption that each emotion is associated with a
specific lexicon that can overlap between emotions. Our proposed method follows
a two-stage procedure. At first, we select a state-of-the-art Speech Emotion
Recognition (SER) model to predict dimensional emotion values from all input
audio in the dataset. Then, we use these predicted emotions as source tokens
added at the beginning of input texts to train our NMT model. We show that
integrating emotion information, especially arousal, into NMT systems leads to
better translations.
|
[
-0.4624694585800171,
-0.10351213067770004,
0.5063223838806152,
0.3089907765388489,
-0.6862325072288513,
-0.22106795012950897,
-0.20359504222869873,
-0.4964256286621094,
0.3561547100543976,
0.15804216265678406,
-0.4857669174671173,
-0.32409846782684326,
-0.6919975876808167,
0.36024007201194763,
-0.32370448112487793,
1.0173916816711426,
-0.07880064845085144,
0.3731410801410675,
0.22335386276245117,
-0.016196470707654953,
-0.23088261485099792,
-0.7171555161476135,
-0.6600224375724792,
-0.25951123237609863,
0.5017595291137695,
0.10379882156848907,
0.8278746008872986,
0.3358922600746155,
0.7784580588340759,
0.3580455183982849,
-0.2612287700176239,
0.21649903059005737,
-0.0192252229899168,
0.5239414572715759,
-0.02746179699897766,
-0.30661916732788086,
-0.600744903087616,
0.03128112852573395,
0.6145192384719849,
0.3120296001434326,
0.09799288213253021,
-0.14959876239299774,
0.1312197893857956,
0.7621336579322815,
-0.17983856797218323,
0.22578909993171692,
-0.27170664072036743,
0.3762335777282715,
-0.02419951744377613,
-0.4104083776473999,
-0.26809602975845337,
-0.49280786514282227,
0.3880336582660675,
-0.22836993634700775,
-0.15801340341567993,
-0.1677572876214981,
0.4953548014163971,
0.6070546507835388,
-0.7444308996200562,
-0.39265891909599304,
-0.5795698761940002,
0.3693724274635315,
-0.7851525545120239,
0.4970487654209137,
0.38174688816070557,
0.1295216679573059,
-0.0645286813378334,
-0.3452950119972229,
-0.6300881505012512,
-0.35287728905677795,
-0.008177281357347965,
0.49334657192230225,
-0.2200002521276474,
0.2885366976261139,
-0.04707040265202522,
0.22242800891399384,
-0.44926199316978455,
-0.17604976892471313,
-0.12689030170440674,
0.03377305716276169,
0.4328610301017761,
0.08904479444026947,
0.5139287710189819,
-0.32540860772132874,
-0.25354620814323425,
-0.05377563461661339,
-0.3146200180053711,
0.0559924840927124,
0.5497201681137085,
0.6212397813796997,
0.023716017603874207,
0.7428094744682312,
0.07607463747262955,
0.22612322866916656,
-0.00041602907003834844,
0.2447405308485031,
0.47254443168640137,
-0.16601411998271942,
0.020742714405059814,
0.3376803696155548,
0.9474062919616699,
0.47950616478919983,
0.3080528676509857,
-0.16052348911762238,
-0.44910070300102234,
-0.07574551552534103,
0.48958155512809753,
-0.8111247420310974,
0.1324736475944519,
0.39185336232185364,
-0.3143691420555115,
-0.2242797613143921,
-0.07211732119321823,
-0.6654117107391357,
-0.49860095977783203,
-0.4327133595943451,
0.3694213628768921,
-0.5239193439483643,
-0.6303375363349915,
-0.056739598512649536,
0.008486762642860413,
-0.29583266377449036,
0.017197566106915474,
-0.773543655872345,
0.14643912017345428,
0.5639796853065491,
1.0478216409683228,
-0.07363677769899368,
-0.14416000247001648,
-0.38325580954551697,
-0.41822096705436707,
-0.47938743233680725,
0.5465623140335083,
-0.30971935391426086,
-0.32859158515930176,
-0.11984255909919739,
0.07054582983255386,
-0.17305715382099152,
-0.46902135014533997,
0.5693444013595581,
-0.43428534269332886,
0.02094142697751522,
-0.2867269814014435,
-0.35755887627601624,
-0.2393140345811844,
-0.024549443274736404,
-0.5614011287689209,
1.0686975717544556,
0.21366597712039948,
-0.5992279648780823,
-0.32178500294685364,
-0.668073296546936,
-0.5078318119049072,
-0.14352259039878845,
0.38139575719833374,
-0.23111112415790558,
0.5890232920646667,
-0.14460022747516632,
0.4681999683380127,
-0.18748126924037933,
0.37260496616363525,
0.11077842861413956,
-0.22964708507061005,
0.7167555093765259,
-0.23293012380599976,
0.46125558018684387,
0.3015410602092743,
-0.515698254108429,
0.07936155796051025,
-0.5469275116920471,
-0.07144884020090103,
-0.12664467096328735,
-0.16914598643779755,
-0.30205807089805603,
-0.05728038027882576,
0.07463161647319794,
0.5735763311386108,
0.0959119126200676,
-0.41566985845565796,
0.0021860033739358187,
-0.7039081454277039,
0.38609474897384644,
0.7235689163208008,
-0.05633973330259323,
0.5000423192977905,
0.2248416244983673,
0.7693471908569336,
0.18478982150554657,
-0.11916039139032364,
0.07283937931060791,
-0.6275564432144165,
-0.690148651599884,
0.162880077958107,
0.19034874439239502,
0.7411871552467346,
-0.6575536131858826,
0.3334255814552307,
0.1912292093038559,
-0.45408716797828674,
-1.0087199211120605,
-0.27925872802734375,
0.44898906350135803,
0.6702944040298462,
0.48919206857681274,
-0.10559792071580887,
-0.8754860758781433,
-0.7060275077819824,
-0.124269500374794,
-0.22335967421531677,
-0.01832735165953636,
0.19595244526863098,
0.2811843752861023,
-0.16202078759670258,
0.48180243372917175,
0.010416347533464432,
-0.16145631670951843,
0.09440898895263672,
0.393302857875824,
0.11383656412363052,
0.5153541564941406,
0.26733827590942383,
-0.8306904435157776,
-0.45373639464378357,
0.3102850914001465,
-0.8458399176597595,
-0.3355274796485901,
-0.12900885939598083,
-0.32683777809143066,
-0.045887235552072525,
0.20673976838588715,
-0.7078931331634521,
0.28851863741874695,
0.6308205127716064,
-0.297208309173584,
0.5263404846191406,
-0.1126653403043747,
0.41792160272598267,
-1.3478658199310303,
-0.16874460875988007,
-0.010776312090456486,
-0.10371830314397812,
-0.7338571548461914,
-0.21782685816287994,
0.22381368279457092,
-0.17996422946453094,
-0.6994439363479614,
0.31917044520378113,
-0.28176775574684143,
-0.29923734068870544,
-0.5035715103149414,
0.19241653382778168,
-0.22102612257003784,
0.4569307565689087,
0.14085201919078827,
1.004732608795166,
0.3075806796550751,
-0.6504291892051697,
0.5219873189926147,
0.1938174068927765,
0.011584604158997536,
0.8713631629943848,
-0.581168532371521,
0.30578768253326416,
-0.14355923235416412,
-0.07600104063749313,
-1.02671480178833,
-0.01988946460187435,
0.14898261427879333,
-0.8749156594276428,
0.2598503530025482,
-0.11159547418355942,
-0.36814171075820923,
0.04258250817656517,
0.1430417150259018,
0.07151810079813004,
0.6492959856987,
-0.2874230742454529,
0.6252852082252502,
0.3180736303329468,
-0.4868733286857605,
-0.3942859470844269,
-0.8632367253303528,
0.40233299136161804,
-0.10204298794269562,
-0.5105791687965393,
0.24547170102596283,
0.15369047224521637,
-0.13142026960849762,
0.06832320243120193,
-0.058381084352731705,
0.00923908594995737,
0.04715296998620033,
0.311055451631546,
0.03901492804288864,
-0.37284719944000244,
0.393912136554718,
0.20975326001644135,
-0.4258062541484833,
0.2263459712266922,
-0.5094603300094604,
0.33806613087654114,
-0.41005659103393555,
0.005359914619475603,
-0.8178220391273499,
0.6156416535377502,
0.6933305263519287,
-0.26170408725738525,
0.7451655268669128,
1.004837989807129,
-0.5572150349617004,
0.13574685156345367,
-0.0038362627383321524,
-0.23072662949562073,
-0.4189039468765259,
0.5600515007972717,
-0.5407145619392395,
-0.5595104098320007,
0.5283114314079285,
-0.05686225742101669,
-0.41642990708351135,
0.45513948798179626,
0.5528658628463745,
-0.49641719460487366,
1.5346020460128784,
0.3685758709907532,
0.25503313541412354,
0.5884312391281128,
-0.028165606781840324,
0.2905125319957733,
-1.2774728536605835,
-0.14934208989143372,
-0.5464403033256531,
-0.6625430583953857,
-0.7485425472259521,
-0.1949649304151535,
0.36577108502388,
-0.05290553718805313,
-0.06532520055770874,
0.4983913004398346,
-0.4708114564418793,
0.15588682889938354,
0.49705785512924194,
0.1073140949010849,
-0.07512282580137253,
-0.27139538526535034,
-0.16066807508468628,
-0.5178583264350891,
-0.2264184206724167,
-0.42080947756767273,
0.6308767199516296,
0.3655540347099304,
0.19248396158218384,
0.3546738028526306,
0.6413401365280151,
-0.0401155985891819,
0.42619991302490234,
-1.0691405534744263,
0.5378314256668091,
-0.41884294152259827,
-0.33897221088409424,
-0.12099768966436386,
-0.4948381185531616,
-0.713230311870575,
0.264440655708313,
-0.09605564922094345,
-0.6891016364097595,
0.32454055547714233,
0.09726930409669876,
-0.19189314544200897,
0.10652973502874374,
-0.7417275309562683,
0.7088430523872375,
-0.38535842299461365,
-0.18206848204135895,
0.13289107382297516,
-0.6895241737365723,
0.06400041282176971,
0.045208144932985306,
-0.01981835439801216,
-0.15305976569652557,
-0.3046504259109497,
0.7457307577133179,
-0.49491456151008606,
0.7265143394470215,
-0.3322571814060211,
-0.14681607484817505,
0.07579091191291809,
0.3925899565219879,
0.6706787347793579,
-0.2256186306476593,
-0.2723395526409149,
0.005723647307604551,
-0.31878218054771423,
0.17879605293273926,
-0.8461177945137024,
0.36693674325942993,
-0.7713873982429504,
-0.3208191990852356,
-0.4319881200790405,
-0.8301979899406433,
-0.29028552770614624,
0.10561435669660568,
0.34921330213546753,
0.186085507273674,
0.15209826827049255,
0.28715479373931885,
0.5847024917602539,
-0.005792415700852871,
0.1211656928062439,
0.2347550094127655,
-0.0437391996383667,
-0.6105098128318787,
0.9727799892425537,
0.2022278606891632,
0.3210209310054779,
0.25572383403778076,
0.4504006803035736,
-0.50527024269104,
-0.44087257981300354,
-0.4304892420768738,
-0.05644380301237106,
-0.6922787427902222,
-0.2596319913864136,
-0.9377673268318176,
-0.0798233225941658,
-0.5108859539031982,
-0.13472723960876465,
-0.7098082900047302,
-0.4149511456489563,
-0.38653331995010376,
-0.15171726047992706,
0.5419727563858032,
0.6355571150779724,
-0.15122221410274506,
0.7189143300056458,
-0.9867703318595886,
0.40280506014823914,
0.16755950450897217,
0.2644825279712677,
-0.21563537418842316,
-0.7664803862571716,
-0.19889241456985474,
0.0934033915400505,
-0.0497748889029026,
-1.48289155960083,
0.8736252784729004,
0.19878296554088593,
0.17369444668293,
0.127028226852417,
0.0573594830930233,
0.4668937027454376,
-0.4479750990867615,
0.6595876812934875,
0.14547446370124817,
-1.1879688501358032,
0.6496230959892273,
-0.41094452142715454,
0.2575434744358063,
0.39508697390556335,
0.6116636991500854,
-0.8700570464134216,
-0.375135213136673,
-0.49046361446380615,
-1.0041183233261108,
0.6761470437049866,
0.3852590322494507,
0.1945158839225769,
-0.15065252780914307,
0.36892378330230713,
-0.15624196827411652,
0.3489917814731598,
-0.34881672263145447,
-0.021249758079648018,
-0.15761297941207886,
-0.5963888764381409,
-0.04739249125123024,
-0.18757513165473938,
0.2951304018497467,
-0.1073559895157814,
0.7261675596237183,
-0.03927289694547653,
0.5947064161300659,
0.23783044517040253,
-0.12153711915016174,
-0.18705105781555176,
0.2376345694065094,
0.4515244662761688,
-0.21602380275726318,
-0.4620837867259979,
0.37986114621162415,
0.149958997964859,
-0.6594597101211548,
0.40028494596481323,
0.015654288232326508,
-0.08240765333175659,
0.3220231533050537,
-0.03098527528345585,
1.0693756341934204,
0.3295518159866333,
-0.27236878871917725,
0.3798092305660248,
-0.026775646954774857,
-0.06541886925697327,
-0.15788699686527252,
-0.24817746877670288,
0.37701529264450073,
0.6286290287971497,
0.02780318446457386,
0.48061487078666687,
0.48809799551963806,
-0.4598987102508545,
0.1733708530664444,
0.07421743124723434,
-0.8708380460739136,
-0.48388439416885376,
0.6634515523910522,
0.3217102885246277,
-0.7204908132553101,
0.6482683420181274,
-0.3472326993942261,
-1.0717980861663818,
0.7868108749389648,
0.6126225590705872,
1.3563718795776367,
-0.7386566400527954,
0.09147113561630249,
0.4199954569339752,
0.46210718154907227,
-0.23827169835567474,
0.6676520705223083,
0.10935119539499283,
-0.5235230326652527,
-0.41568246483802795,
-0.42028969526290894,
-0.6083314418792725,
-0.36544671654701233,
-0.8065391778945923,
0.21739625930786133,
-0.143740713596344,
-0.6252001523971558,
-0.244277685880661,
-0.26388946175575256,
-0.661798894405365,
0.3855821490287781,
0.2552935779094696,
0.4495917856693268,
-0.8329985737800598,
0.7546983361244202,
0.7488628029823303,
-0.4204486906528473,
-0.6800852417945862,
-0.17638523876667023,
0.1424563229084015,
-0.5836381912231445,
0.8172986507415771,
0.20894742012023926,
-0.42268773913383484,
0.21361364424228668,
-0.08318831771612167,
-0.7601831555366516,
0.6262592077255249,
0.4355512857437134,
-0.49218636751174927,
0.173450767993927,
0.10785745084285736,
0.7700299024581909,
-0.4920090436935425,
0.3789818286895752,
0.3876070976257324,
0.48448890447616577,
-0.019487306475639343,
-0.8195995688438416,
0.07611870765686035,
-0.6385498046875,
0.061072900891304016,
0.19073140621185303,
-0.24849402904510498,
0.962659478187561,
-0.20530858635902405,
-0.24029861390590668,
-0.17000901699066162,
0.654455304145813,
-0.12123559415340424,
0.143580824136734,
0.5734599232673645,
0.14585164189338684,
0.8557042479515076,
-0.18771235644817352,
1.000408411026001,
-0.28652384877204895,
0.12483939528465271,
1.052024245262146,
-0.15004651248455048,
1.0581989288330078,
0.4477654695510864,
-0.13496430218219757,
0.019492628052830696,
0.7897331714630127,
0.4144035279750824,
0.4434070289134979,
0.15505707263946533,
-0.19646954536437988,
-0.05315914750099182,
-0.476823091506958,
-0.5271764397621155,
0.3737376630306244,
0.391707181930542,
-0.5247732996940613,
0.25377708673477173,
0.34173983335494995,
0.1096729040145874,
-0.13760051131248474,
-0.01850556954741478,
0.8379223346710205,
0.3004331588745117,
-0.5525643229484558,
0.5222110748291016,
-0.2583411633968353,
0.5749230980873108,
-0.38338932394981384,
0.06922441720962524,
-0.25211089849472046,
0.08114129304885864,
-0.3110054135322571,
-0.9181565642356873,
0.5139275193214417,
0.32304635643959045,
-0.08644100278615952,
-0.4734313189983368,
0.4893532395362854,
-0.7362157702445984,
-0.26933956146240234,
0.431841105222702,
0.35621094703674316,
0.6073796153068542,
-0.5892742276191711,
-0.4748249650001526,
-0.06059755012392998,
-0.12293417006731033,
-0.5596662163734436,
0.2709041237831116,
0.8505133986473083,
0.25982004404067993,
0.32643207907676697,
0.6232249140739441,
0.3259766697883606,
-0.17948219180107117,
0.22475989162921906,
0.6139041185379028,
-0.7657988667488098,
-0.6930748820304871,
-0.9418725371360779,
0.8282082080841064,
0.15455371141433716,
-0.478805810213089,
0.3778887093067169,
0.10634323954582214,
0.26999643445014954,
0.05289607122540474,
0.726658284664154,
0.272736519575119,
0.21330313384532928,
-0.5261985659599304,
0.6146068572998047,
-0.552596390247345,
-0.13262316584587097,
-0.3915156424045563,
-0.8713046312332153,
-0.20336002111434937,
0.8334858417510986,
-0.14651519060134888,
-0.1723167598247528,
0.9499549269676208,
0.6843045949935913,
0.28542032837867737,
0.3645496070384979,
0.31755492091178894,
0.16980110108852386,
0.08060603588819504,
0.668474018573761,
0.7969533801078796,
-0.5785365700721741,
0.3822000324726105,
-0.43390652537345886,
-0.16967853903770447,
-0.3500787019729614,
-0.9838160872459412,
-0.42983707785606384,
-0.8100047707557678,
-0.361022412776947,
-0.70282381772995,
0.09387625753879547,
1.230262279510498,
0.6147465109825134,
-0.6847392320632935,
-0.057249803096055984,
0.11639542132616043,
-0.0061345212161540985,
-0.48778071999549866,
-0.10463336855173111,
0.23794715106487274,
-0.2980542778968811,
-0.8217329978942871,
0.494015097618103,
0.21965472400188446,
0.35434576869010925,
-0.11797954142093658,
-0.3331103026866913,
-0.045394934713840485,
0.032042764127254486,
0.5521618723869324,
-0.06521710753440857,
-0.3852432668209076,
-0.054574232548475266,
0.30946826934814453,
-0.2025119960308075,
0.09400418400764465,
0.7083812355995178,
-0.2923654019832611,
0.5910542607307434,
0.7261232137680054,
0.8023509979248047,
0.21931572258472443,
-0.24246782064437866,
0.7639340162277222,
-0.8268522620201111,
0.21381530165672302,
0.4888720214366913,
0.4040917754173279,
0.4812183678150177,
-0.7025799751281738,
0.5224899053573608,
0.14315034449100494,
-0.47231239080429077,
-0.8261033296585083,
0.10163843631744385,
-0.8642013072967529,
0.2435893714427948,
1.051983118057251,
-0.2486771196126938,
-0.28232648968696594,
0.11448687314987183,
-0.45912283658981323,
0.71696537733078,
-0.5220659971237183,
0.5448309779167175,
0.772731602191925,
-0.12631377577781677,
-0.3127886950969696,
-1.1092878580093384,
0.43678852915763855,
0.5236895680427551,
-0.72575443983078,
0.015369154512882233,
0.12902319431304932,
-0.3600873649120331,
0.11580296605825424,
0.490197092294693,
-0.10721686482429504,
0.27504515647888184,
0.08569638431072235,
0.46161016821861267,
-0.06893500685691833,
-0.1980435699224472,
-0.505255937576294,
-0.03432852774858475,
-0.18115732073783875,
-0.3734397292137146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17949v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17949v1
|
Transfer Learning Enhanced Single-choice Decision for Multi-choice Question Answering
| 2024-04-27T16:02:55 | 2024-04-27T16:02:55 |
Chenhao Cui, Yufan Jiang, Shuangzhi Wu, Zhoujun Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multi-choice Machine Reading Comprehension (MMRC) aims to select the correct
answer from a set of options based on a given passage and question. The
existing methods employ the pre-trained language model as the encoder, share
and transfer knowledge through fine-tuning.These methods mainly focus on the
design of exquisite mechanisms to effectively capture the relationships among
the triplet of passage, question and answers. It is non-trivial but ignored to
transfer knowledge from other MRC tasks such as SQuAD due to task specific of
MMRC.In this paper, we reconstruct multi-choice to single-choice by training a
binary classification to distinguish whether a certain answer is correct. Then
select the option with the highest confidence score as the final answer. Our
proposed method gets rid of the multi-choice framework and can leverage
resources of other tasks. We construct our model based on the ALBERT-xxlarge
model and evaluate it on the RACE and DREAM datasets. Experimental results show
that our model performs better than multi-choice methods. In addition, by
transferring knowledge from other kinds of MRC tasks, our model achieves
state-of-the-art results in both single and ensemble settings.
|
[
-0.643470287322998,
-0.47085633873939514,
0.35935869812965393,
-0.24733828008174896,
-0.2279020994901657,
0.31971022486686707,
-0.022857414558529854,
-0.3898867666721344,
0.07715068012475967,
0.6650425791740417,
-0.935737133026123,
-0.1135382205247879,
-0.5445370078086853,
0.2792935073375702,
-0.14442665874958038,
1.1318341493606567,
-0.22589920461177826,
-0.1037994995713234,
-0.38094890117645264,
-0.33583083748817444,
-0.3163284659385681,
-0.49053552746772766,
-0.8735845685005188,
-0.22974646091461182,
0.6469830274581909,
0.6315311193466187,
0.2558721899986267,
0.3883972465991974,
0.7237086296081543,
0.26393982768058777,
0.021737277507781982,
0.3645922839641571,
-0.4161761403083801,
-0.003329545259475708,
0.0012100189924240112,
-0.5193607807159424,
-0.246040478348732,
-0.004312499426305294,
0.6519812941551208,
0.4147522449493408,
-0.1740843951702118,
0.4445883631706238,
0.10463987290859222,
0.655001699924469,
-0.6594336628913879,
0.1101805716753006,
-0.6063510775566101,
0.01578705757856369,
0.18040820956230164,
-0.4121006429195404,
-0.6223151683807373,
-0.3838855028152466,
0.15011130273342133,
-0.5118168592453003,
0.27001357078552246,
0.1918235421180725,
0.5331062078475952,
0.30091506242752075,
-0.5061689615249634,
-0.3962370455265045,
-0.6080679893493652,
0.7593667507171631,
-0.10246440023183823,
0.33009111881256104,
0.5963857173919678,
0.4439771771430969,
0.5417436361312866,
-0.30067840218544006,
-0.5942305326461792,
-0.19979918003082275,
-0.20301423966884613,
0.3155594766139984,
0.3252420127391815,
-0.15566343069076538,
-0.12621285021305084,
-0.014944631606340408,
-0.5546772480010986,
-0.1817958652973175,
-0.7618392109870911,
-0.130931094288826,
0.3581538498401642,
0.1086219921708107,
-0.14230449497699738,
-0.182943195104599,
-0.4794827699661255,
-0.35258936882019043,
-0.37629610300064087,
0.2546539306640625,
0.19244860112667084,
0.47676342725753784,
0.2295718938112259,
0.5266374349594116,
-0.05159497261047363,
0.8034569621086121,
0.04182633385062218,
-0.029609382152557373,
0.3179200291633606,
-0.3969244956970215,
-0.062073543667793274,
0.15156684815883636,
0.6612764000892639,
0.00702205765992403,
0.20324240624904633,
-0.04857524111866951,
0.22049611806869507,
-0.3743308484554291,
0.31782734394073486,
-0.6831228733062744,
0.1433068811893463,
0.20359325408935547,
-0.32959941029548645,
-0.2305627465248108,
0.11715997755527496,
-0.6469155550003052,
0.02282898873090744,
-0.21289843320846558,
0.30376988649368286,
-0.49518537521362305,
-0.31103721261024475,
0.40006667375564575,
-0.10609937459230423,
0.20351283252239227,
0.22927603125572205,
-0.7863163352012634,
-0.04025184363126755,
0.2395782619714737,
0.67578125,
-0.2908209562301636,
-0.3673897087574005,
-0.38903701305389404,
0.28616660833358765,
-0.01065466832369566,
1.0003143548965454,
-0.48770982027053833,
-0.29079997539520264,
-0.27171045541763306,
-0.07559193670749664,
-0.4916929602622986,
-0.20793844759464264,
0.5360913276672363,
-0.8309077024459839,
0.371707558631897,
-0.20496520400047302,
-0.309516578912735,
-0.35245347023010254,
0.3918488621711731,
-0.5799351930618286,
0.6399137377738953,
0.1176142692565918,
-0.8915871381759644,
0.30830392241477966,
-0.9317623972892761,
-0.34809932112693787,
-0.1882493793964386,
0.22490191459655762,
-0.5319690108299255,
-0.36408841609954834,
0.4707860052585602,
0.41900336742401123,
0.22309409081935883,
-0.14285089075565338,
-0.6287912130355835,
-0.12338633835315704,
0.38742029666900635,
-0.3534749746322632,
0.8727890253067017,
0.3175305724143982,
0.1789814829826355,
-0.04837627336382866,
-0.7749772071838379,
0.3684082627296448,
-0.017306214198470116,
-0.4414820969104767,
-0.2749927341938019,
-0.36276355385780334,
-0.3895590603351593,
0.4485006332397461,
-0.029437821358442307,
-0.5410898327827454,
0.22207774221897125,
0.04016834869980812,
0.19749295711517334,
0.7343228459358215,
0.06792636960744858,
0.5823949575424194,
-0.5872140526771545,
0.6703936457633972,
0.023041777312755585,
-0.012139818631112576,
0.028876658529043198,
-0.4559754729270935,
-0.7295060157775879,
-0.436568021774292,
0.4472863972187042,
0.7391825318336487,
-0.8026398420333862,
0.2472211867570877,
-0.14473247528076172,
-0.21553151309490204,
-1.1387416124343872,
-0.15963701903820038,
0.02602582797408104,
0.4912028908729553,
0.5371139645576477,
0.07732928544282913,
-0.5923647880554199,
-0.5670819282531738,
-0.026070348918437958,
-0.29816392064094543,
0.21096299588680267,
0.298687219619751,
0.41895681619644165,
-0.20638038218021393,
0.8060258030891418,
-0.5193017721176147,
-0.23553963005542755,
-0.43888068199157715,
0.21541999280452728,
0.010815883986651897,
0.4584140479564667,
0.3792009949684143,
-0.7795807719230652,
-0.5068795084953308,
0.07724522799253464,
-0.6138270497322083,
0.2899460792541504,
-0.40576741099357605,
-0.4963326156139374,
0.042433202266693115,
0.284476637840271,
-0.3955501616001129,
0.26075902581214905,
0.5120218992233276,
-0.2834675908088684,
0.8080042600631714,
-0.2187662273645401,
0.7589448094367981,
-0.978481650352478,
0.19377711415290833,
-0.33931785821914673,
-0.36213481426239014,
-0.40140455961227417,
0.021881721913814545,
0.28077495098114014,
0.28026002645492554,
-0.4406950771808624,
0.6071951389312744,
-0.3121544420719147,
0.14588381350040436,
-0.21930071711540222,
0.01432775892317295,
-0.07713498920202255,
0.5589468479156494,
0.30248671770095825,
0.7055753469467163,
0.4523216784000397,
-0.7686313390731812,
0.15910211205482483,
0.6489971876144409,
-0.17000752687454224,
0.4802514314651489,
-0.24545085430145264,
0.46920251846313477,
-0.4301372468471527,
-0.02306302636861801,
-1.0772956609725952,
0.2314010113477707,
0.4122442901134491,
-0.6359837055206299,
0.3110421895980835,
-0.10426392406225204,
-0.22623127698898315,
-0.6207849979400635,
0.033507950603961945,
0.18866364657878876,
0.24329298734664917,
-0.5515908598899841,
0.5141750574111938,
0.009991366416215897,
-0.29300397634506226,
-0.7976560592651367,
-0.8247537016868591,
-0.42514970898628235,
-0.19226744771003723,
-0.4205721616744995,
0.0770406648516655,
-0.5964936017990112,
0.1751115620136261,
-0.015740342438220978,
-0.13353192806243896,
-0.3659437596797943,
-0.10618720948696136,
-0.022073820233345032,
0.5027260184288025,
-0.2764568626880646,
0.13200460374355316,
0.44864320755004883,
-0.2407016009092331,
-0.21137304604053497,
0.03773026168346405,
0.31889545917510986,
-0.033207349479198456,
-0.43601053953170776,
-0.19281700253486633,
0.632979154586792,
0.7306355834007263,
-0.6138817071914673,
1.0623587369918823,
0.5709931254386902,
0.19319778680801392,
-0.09651460498571396,
-0.2374882996082306,
-0.2645934224128723,
-0.43297716975212097,
0.45586130023002625,
-0.7250229120254517,
-1.2068864107131958,
0.28113338351249695,
0.17905405163764954,
0.2939295470714569,
0.2756325304508209,
0.4772430658340454,
-0.3424721360206604,
1.031516194343567,
0.45073768496513367,
0.02627846598625183,
0.4790942966938019,
-0.20776903629302979,
-0.10852346569299698,
-0.7581698894500732,
-0.2520367205142975,
-0.6363642811775208,
-0.12359735369682312,
-0.0852346271276474,
-0.32962021231651306,
0.3177928030490875,
-0.07451457530260086,
-0.41174474358558655,
0.33125677704811096,
-0.51092129945755,
0.4813685715198517,
0.7018248438835144,
0.33393269777297974,
0.5366447567939758,
0.08408554643392563,
-0.31461620330810547,
0.2982604503631592,
-0.8205305933952332,
-0.3056732416152954,
1.2936992645263672,
0.05122840031981468,
0.550895631313324,
-0.020703846588730812,
0.7268354296684265,
0.17022162675857544,
0.35237884521484375,
-0.4122546911239624,
0.46392810344696045,
0.1036853939294815,
-0.8912513256072998,
-0.3477165102958679,
-0.7539073824882507,
-0.9476948380470276,
0.619354784488678,
-0.4640136957168579,
-0.4543890655040741,
0.0618925616145134,
-0.022215580567717552,
-0.7974474430084229,
0.4934731721878052,
-0.7413444519042969,
0.4903091490268707,
-0.2124185413122177,
-0.08880062401294708,
-0.1840796023607254,
-0.7154701352119446,
0.46820634603500366,
-0.16336481273174286,
0.21228811144828796,
0.20301328599452972,
0.05735966935753822,
0.7408022880554199,
0.23777444660663605,
0.4124950170516968,
0.15848968923091888,
0.23335081338882446,
0.42166638374328613,
0.04930311441421509,
0.28145626187324524,
-0.05867118388414383,
-0.4353383779525757,
-0.1807330697774887,
0.17779728770256042,
-0.30482017993927,
-0.5315549373626709,
0.33316582441329956,
-0.8902934789657593,
-0.3290334641933441,
-0.3355250656604767,
-0.5317130088806152,
-0.31633293628692627,
0.24312268197536469,
0.1809164136648178,
0.28643763065338135,
-0.1845412701368332,
0.10163378715515137,
0.7431566119194031,
0.05185113474726677,
0.3705146014690399,
0.7016292214393616,
-0.18784938752651215,
-0.4139549136161804,
0.565581202507019,
-0.04712123051285744,
0.5016023516654968,
0.545132577419281,
0.028986938297748566,
-0.5988508462905884,
-0.5675213932991028,
-0.4960167407989502,
0.2880554497241974,
-0.6277621388435364,
-0.21577833592891693,
-0.9796842932701111,
-0.3811799883842468,
-0.534361720085144,
-0.08014737814664841,
-0.2700039744377136,
-0.3274890184402466,
-0.5018755197525024,
-0.2811161279678345,
0.11986907571554184,
0.3233295679092407,
-0.22035253047943115,
0.4209617078304291,
-0.9402045011520386,
0.5360639691352844,
0.4656530022621155,
0.40895193815231323,
-0.2537910044193268,
-0.7938157916069031,
-0.1605052649974823,
0.06573532521724701,
-0.28575488924980164,
-0.8091407418251038,
0.20534645020961761,
0.057443127036094666,
0.5829571485519409,
0.43501004576683044,
0.24370358884334564,
0.6398155093193054,
-0.413569837808609,
0.14329667389392853,
0.28105947375297546,
-0.420865923166275,
0.26366084814071655,
0.05548395216464996,
0.33494502305984497,
1.0868401527404785,
0.6372608542442322,
-0.4839577376842499,
-0.21707868576049805,
-0.6189447641372681,
-0.28052377700805664,
0.842237651348114,
0.059535250067710876,
-0.33814188838005066,
0.23521961271762848,
0.253853440284729,
0.4432402551174164,
0.23806604743003845,
-0.5915930271148682,
-0.48149293661117554,
0.011933142319321632,
-0.09596013277769089,
-0.21790958940982819,
0.004622677341103554,
0.16194778680801392,
-0.4068659543991089,
0.7760086059570312,
-0.13194540143013,
0.5307815670967102,
0.18158379197120667,
-0.1591273695230484,
-0.10818179696798325,
0.4899691641330719,
0.4262568950653076,
0.44814956188201904,
-0.44825637340545654,
0.06769013404846191,
0.17332197725772858,
-0.2998396158218384,
0.23132607340812683,
0.15599983930587769,
-0.012461809441447258,
-0.21692924201488495,
0.17354591190814972,
0.845842182636261,
-0.2876914441585541,
-0.4886152446269989,
0.23189705610275269,
-0.22350835800170898,
-0.4215681850910187,
0.06917759776115417,
0.16912393271923065,
0.002805514959618449,
0.17222703993320465,
0.10948579013347626,
0.7487784028053284,
0.1609864979982376,
-0.38028931617736816,
0.39021238684654236,
0.3167921304702759,
-0.4764195382595062,
0.03860226646065712,
0.26250284910202026,
0.022553283721208572,
-0.10218711942434311,
0.7894222140312195,
-0.1915985345840454,
-0.5571858286857605,
0.42389655113220215,
0.5212607979774475,
0.4016568958759308,
-0.3108476400375366,
0.5305345058441162,
0.6664758324623108,
0.40988975763320923,
-0.037499163299798965,
0.17439761757850647,
-0.09611879289150238,
-0.9199408292770386,
-0.564944863319397,
-0.3889048397541046,
-0.37678688764572144,
-0.15108592808246613,
-0.8765503764152527,
0.10992750525474548,
-0.08442554622888565,
0.037076033651828766,
-0.20175333321094513,
-0.04647674784064293,
-0.7866777181625366,
0.009209779091179371,
0.2677064538002014,
0.7788768410682678,
-0.5893835425376892,
0.8476896286010742,
0.6065588593482971,
-0.354352205991745,
-0.5432905554771423,
-0.3339403569698334,
-0.31206801533699036,
-0.9324545860290527,
0.23324637115001678,
0.07950752973556519,
-0.18637242913246155,
0.13746175169944763,
-0.46556195616722107,
-0.8649560809135437,
0.8179653286933899,
0.36763787269592285,
-0.4108075201511383,
-0.09942806512117386,
0.15821322798728943,
0.04102763161063194,
-0.3225882649421692,
0.7515967488288879,
0.6257302165031433,
0.5688443779945374,
0.5496771335601807,
-0.7790310382843018,
-0.3023867607116699,
0.09760625660419464,
-0.5766122937202454,
0.09224984049797058,
-0.6093390583992004,
0.5872089266777039,
-0.6578115224838257,
-0.11013536155223846,
0.09016908705234528,
0.6627457141876221,
0.5194329023361206,
0.1650078296661377,
0.5267729759216309,
0.3925401270389557,
0.9838793277740479,
0.22762978076934814,
0.9445971846580505,
0.07722951471805573,
0.47823530435562134,
1.297394037246704,
-0.10237156599760056,
1.0080667734146118,
0.4731907546520233,
-0.22933071851730347,
0.5348598957061768,
0.5268721580505371,
0.3789155185222626,
0.799254298210144,
-0.03259512037038803,
-0.224977046251297,
-0.6147326231002808,
0.3866758644580841,
-0.3143109381198883,
0.4826543927192688,
0.10282953083515167,
-0.12987399101257324,
-0.24420680105686188,
0.4458537995815277,
-0.32602888345718384,
-0.2780263423919678,
-0.5085461735725403,
0.8839941024780273,
-0.08215411752462387,
-0.8561742901802063,
0.45733708143234253,
-0.3007015883922577,
0.7477744221687317,
-0.9203054904937744,
0.006041329354047775,
-0.0610116608440876,
0.3177207410335541,
0.03591398522257805,
-0.9937747120857239,
0.3653326630592346,
-0.2971908450126648,
-0.3971409499645233,
-0.45944786071777344,
0.7000182271003723,
-0.6439999341964722,
-0.5381472706794739,
0.038057517260313034,
0.8176599740982056,
0.08127748966217041,
-0.28412604331970215,
-1.0553725957870483,
-0.3913424611091614,
0.42635658383369446,
-0.0048525528982281685,
0.3589900732040405,
0.4299202561378479,
0.4285217523574829,
0.9214838147163391,
0.6462673544883728,
0.12064036726951599,
0.17237097024917603,
-0.21172833442687988,
0.4499655067920685,
-0.567936897277832,
-0.8035674691200256,
-0.5897596478462219,
0.5378556847572327,
0.06585951894521713,
-0.22456145286560059,
0.48694783449172974,
0.41453900933265686,
0.6532531976699829,
-0.22465559840202332,
0.9317476153373718,
-0.021365348249673843,
0.8989859819412231,
-0.3040825426578522,
0.769599199295044,
-0.4875166416168213,
-0.03683958947658539,
-0.1351933777332306,
-0.43125221133232117,
-0.28360649943351746,
0.5785484313964844,
-0.24398593604564667,
0.05350484326481819,
0.9220556616783142,
0.7053744792938232,
-0.19674821197986603,
0.249379962682724,
0.426198810338974,
-0.30673155188560486,
0.002885845024138689,
0.6781333088874817,
1.0134063959121704,
-0.20048639178276062,
1.0864355564117432,
-0.0737200379371643,
-0.35989904403686523,
-0.05447264760732651,
-0.5609528422355652,
-0.9861421585083008,
-0.8035979866981506,
-0.4443546235561371,
-0.2588719129562378,
-0.028400937095284462,
0.9247764348983765,
0.9043729305267334,
-0.7841976284980774,
-0.06152805685997009,
0.2450799196958542,
0.3021400570869446,
-0.5746003985404968,
-0.18228554725646973,
0.4213181436061859,
-0.3349286913871765,
-0.3939869701862335,
0.052746959030628204,
-0.042077258229255676,
0.014268369413912296,
0.18407507240772247,
-0.056949302554130554,
-0.4007941782474518,
-0.09881450980901718,
0.6056479811668396,
0.222029909491539,
-0.12192276120185852,
-0.23208898305892944,
0.08286335319280624,
0.07205616682767868,
0.3967462480068207,
0.8187441825866699,
-0.8539520502090454,
0.3236069679260254,
0.28855544328689575,
0.9037379622459412,
0.4989190101623535,
-0.07613812386989594,
0.18543469905853271,
-0.4685882329940796,
-0.27767708897590637,
0.2960497736930847,
0.30800390243530273,
0.1060001403093338,
-0.30917441844940186,
0.2304808497428894,
0.07246345281600952,
-0.5993567705154419,
-0.31996726989746094,
0.00842474028468132,
-1.045034646987915,
-0.5411404967308044,
1.266180157661438,
0.05649261549115181,
-0.2917649745941162,
-0.25213801860809326,
-0.5681595206260681,
0.3707253336906433,
-0.521185040473938,
0.47921109199523926,
0.6245426535606384,
-0.2678873538970947,
-0.5648179054260254,
-0.5085737705230713,
0.1987115889787674,
0.33658111095428467,
-0.9558039307594299,
-0.016591167077422142,
0.23921294510364532,
0.3790110647678375,
0.022524721920490265,
0.6590080857276917,
-0.023646686226129532,
0.1931704580783844,
-0.17842893302440643,
0.13883914053440094,
-0.32029324769973755,
-0.45380711555480957,
-0.2659439444541931,
0.5818705558776855,
-0.19596795737743378,
-0.5770804286003113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17929v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17929v1
|
Spatio-Temporal Side Tuning Pre-trained Foundation Models for Video-based Pedestrian Attribute Recognition
| 2024-04-27T14:43:32 | 2024-04-27T14:43:32 |
Xiao Wang, Qian Zhu, Jiandong Jin, Jun Zhu, Futian Wang, Bo Jiang, Yaowei Wang, Yonghong Tian
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Existing pedestrian attribute recognition (PAR) algorithms are mainly
developed based on a static image, however, the performance is unreliable in
challenging scenarios, such as heavy occlusion, motion blur, etc. In this work,
we propose to understand human attributes using video frames that can fully use
temporal information by fine-tuning a pre-trained multi-modal foundation model
efficiently. Specifically, we formulate the video-based PAR as a
vision-language fusion problem and adopt a pre-trained foundation model CLIP to
extract the visual features. More importantly, we propose a novel
spatiotemporal side-tuning strategy to achieve parameter-efficient optimization
of the pre-trained vision foundation model. To better utilize the semantic
information, we take the full attribute list that needs to be recognized as
another input and transform the attribute words/phrases into the corresponding
sentence via split, expand, and prompt operations. Then, the text encoder of
CLIP is utilized for embedding processed attribute descriptions. The averaged
visual tokens and text tokens are concatenated and fed into a fusion
Transformer for multi-modal interactive learning. The enhanced tokens will be
fed into a classification head for pedestrian attribute prediction. Extensive
experiments on two large-scale video-based PAR datasets fully validated the
effectiveness of our proposed framework. The source code of this paper is
available at https://github.com/Event-AHU/OpenPAR.
|
[
-0.7132170796394348,
-0.6225256323814392,
0.47170743346214294,
0.3398780822753906,
-0.477845698595047,
-0.0064313062466681,
-0.08447899669408798,
-0.6153433918952942,
0.2287442684173584,
0.45085081458091736,
-0.7442849278450012,
-0.09780901670455933,
-0.41246408224105835,
-0.095855213701725,
-0.20441332459449768,
0.6511038541793823,
-0.0014773032162338495,
0.12533816695213318,
-0.2871313691139221,
-0.32272908091545105,
-0.19689087569713593,
-0.26979583501815796,
-0.5089627504348755,
-0.4107688069343567,
0.28979164361953735,
0.31884288787841797,
0.7376887202262878,
0.8684931993484497,
0.3871610462665558,
0.4482809901237488,
0.37936487793922424,
-0.1471521109342575,
-0.2758064568042755,
-0.5765751600265503,
-0.4075087904930115,
0.14109040796756744,
-0.44758903980255127,
0.07103270292282104,
0.8320274353027344,
0.4797738790512085,
-0.015900421887636185,
0.22524039447307587,
-0.2596113681793213,
0.39449357986450195,
-0.8165422677993774,
-0.01716870255768299,
-0.39934292435646057,
0.15224258601665497,
-0.5601608157157898,
-0.6565799713134766,
-0.08883336931467056,
0.21903212368488312,
0.09675601869821548,
-0.25331369042396545,
0.5085253715515137,
0.07856564223766327,
1.0569684505462646,
0.363883376121521,
-0.5122775435447693,
0.6724652647972107,
-0.4771292805671692,
0.582577109336853,
-0.363700270652771,
0.916117787361145,
0.5884181261062622,
0.5582935810089111,
-0.03873723745346069,
-0.38815632462501526,
-0.7711653709411621,
-0.051265813410282135,
-0.3256375193595886,
-0.2243233025074005,
0.12440850585699081,
0.2257433831691742,
0.1169605404138565,
0.2869422137737274,
-0.6263462901115417,
0.2528626620769501,
-0.23009778559207916,
-0.14092878997325897,
0.7023496627807617,
0.39870214462280273,
0.044669896364212036,
-0.014026150107383728,
-0.8191163539886475,
-0.4486372470855713,
-0.43052273988723755,
0.7365659475326538,
0.35563939809799194,
-0.04214739054441452,
-0.24465343356132507,
0.3593282401561737,
-0.5438150763511658,
0.819064199924469,
0.3713766634464264,
-0.37818220257759094,
0.4738529622554779,
-0.25673428177833557,
-0.20898763835430145,
-0.16450731456279755,
0.6294163465499878,
0.3142682909965515,
0.07998615503311157,
-0.34178030490875244,
-0.12885184586048126,
-0.23606400191783905,
0.04417570307850838,
-0.8565247058868408,
-0.3688257336616516,
-0.021448465064167976,
-0.4301920533180237,
-0.12759001553058624,
0.2653859853744507,
-1.0915837287902832,
-0.35488542914390564,
-0.5102890729904175,
0.5594657063484192,
-0.3140053451061249,
-0.224368616938591,
0.368993878364563,
-0.09291566908359528,
0.651670515537262,
0.4499092400074005,
-0.818792462348938,
0.09152592718601227,
0.4779733717441559,
0.5012588500976562,
-0.030285973101854324,
-0.916073739528656,
-0.5477700233459473,
0.47366663813591003,
0.16536878049373627,
0.7326505184173584,
-0.7145678400993347,
-0.081991046667099,
-0.5553796291351318,
0.2656196057796478,
-0.02209111861884594,
-0.23215772211551666,
0.09841246902942657,
-0.16049398481845856,
0.009296934120357037,
-0.07481509447097778,
0.2850106656551361,
-0.05599310249090195,
0.12201106548309326,
-0.7669643759727478,
1.020431399345398,
0.09989742934703827,
-0.7125569581985474,
0.4158499240875244,
-0.30584096908569336,
-0.6523399353027344,
0.08581287413835526,
-0.29631906747817993,
-0.758101224899292,
0.11566294729709625,
0.4651649594306946,
0.7174046635627747,
-0.29494020342826843,
0.2588914930820465,
-0.23208507895469666,
-0.07930092513561249,
0.2607753872871399,
-0.2787274420261383,
0.45964017510414124,
-0.2572277784347534,
-0.5223296284675598,
0.06181514635682106,
-0.8754474520683289,
-0.1443738043308258,
0.04804031550884247,
0.06033777445554733,
0.11818234622478485,
0.047927629202604294,
0.04452286288142204,
0.32111361622810364,
0.2790271043777466,
-0.6819396615028381,
-0.42245063185691833,
0.026734597980976105,
0.1033744066953659,
0.9008910059928894,
-0.2701084315776825,
0.4418114721775055,
-0.1658921241760254,
0.35669946670532227,
0.11702479422092438,
0.36959871649742126,
-0.049189936369657516,
-0.2691797614097595,
-0.7423117160797119,
-0.4851658344268799,
-0.1649082750082016,
0.34753450751304626,
-0.7300156950950623,
0.6345896124839783,
-0.4276541769504547,
-0.5338534712791443,
-0.2345229834318161,
-0.1197308674454689,
0.2807825207710266,
0.7811372876167297,
0.4936540126800537,
-0.48111236095428467,
-0.42361441254615784,
-0.8788482546806335,
-0.02838117443025112,
-0.2859853208065033,
0.13190419971942902,
0.6499009132385254,
0.4655904173851013,
-0.1221560388803482,
1.2901833057403564,
-0.5499521493911743,
-0.32754725217819214,
-0.15833686292171478,
0.33253204822540283,
-0.3542637825012207,
0.5613372325897217,
0.8714355826377869,
-1.1910556554794312,
-0.08857133239507675,
0.03790980577468872,
-0.20439442992210388,
-0.06281664222478867,
-0.12474493682384491,
-0.2206910401582718,
-0.26950931549072266,
0.20285773277282715,
-0.2562103271484375,
0.8444543480873108,
0.29281020164489746,
-0.6508287787437439,
0.4049220085144043,
-0.23130808770656586,
0.4713549017906189,
-0.7015275359153748,
0.17433248460292816,
0.02501451037824154,
-0.48269766569137573,
-0.5982399582862854,
-0.0314057394862175,
-0.1557626724243164,
-0.38812997937202454,
-0.637529730796814,
0.49040842056274414,
-0.1933075338602066,
-0.3396111726760864,
-0.2386588156223297,
-0.23357893526554108,
-0.07416161894798279,
0.7231248617172241,
0.5572706460952759,
0.45480164885520935,
0.5755894780158997,
-0.6181237101554871,
0.598220944404602,
0.1184503510594368,
-0.30451729893684387,
0.9356102347373962,
-0.32931333780288696,
-0.039578165858983994,
-0.5321038365364075,
0.3238488435745239,
-0.6400160193443298,
-0.5933271646499634,
-0.12334968894720078,
-0.29524102807044983,
0.15229129791259766,
-0.0395008809864521,
-0.2494555115699768,
-0.3436555862426758,
-0.24418878555297852,
0.8253237009048462,
0.16338816285133362,
-0.7202142477035522,
1.1116582155227661,
0.3878270983695984,
0.2760176658630371,
-0.34101900458335876,
-0.4562242329120636,
-0.1306128352880478,
-0.35738828778266907,
-0.9232585430145264,
0.5347781181335449,
0.09433562308549881,
0.3583955466747284,
-0.241696298122406,
0.1524006724357605,
-0.5733510255813599,
0.11636032909154892,
0.2169385850429535,
0.016366729512810707,
0.001984125468879938,
0.18657012283802032,
-0.29071879386901855,
-0.40143901109695435,
-0.2653023600578308,
0.33576667308807373,
0.5922213792800903,
-0.30271637439727783,
-0.3851448893547058,
-0.54818195104599,
0.4599687457084656,
0.4590885639190674,
-0.6698407530784607,
0.767291784286499,
1.3545215129852295,
-0.290616899728775,
0.190282940864563,
-0.7275847792625427,
-0.3061278760433197,
-0.48798802495002747,
0.6305208802223206,
-0.48947298526763916,
-0.9529550671577454,
0.5036522150039673,
-0.1673487275838852,
-0.5651926398277283,
0.20675361156463623,
0.42807674407958984,
-0.05728818476200104,
0.7851681113243103,
0.9031904339790344,
0.024054735898971558,
0.7793368697166443,
-0.038033418357372284,
0.03860001638531685,
-0.5388290882110596,
-0.6365235447883606,
-0.3916558623313904,
-0.7186354398727417,
-0.22644281387329102,
-0.4920589029788971,
0.49381235241889954,
0.1216496005654335,
-0.487876832485199,
0.5452899932861328,
-0.09140530228614807,
0.6576254367828369,
0.29226061701774597,
0.7251708507537842,
-0.054100409150123596,
-0.27239835262298584,
0.5660120844841003,
-0.12483561784029007,
-0.15794368088245392,
0.0855669230222702,
0.5292948484420776,
0.48768678307533264,
0.7196320295333862,
0.08037039637565613,
0.3949335217475891,
-0.0029858232010155916,
-0.2453514039516449,
-0.4260929226875305,
0.8344148397445679,
-0.19096003472805023,
-0.2293880134820938,
-0.356575071811676,
-0.4710848927497864,
-0.46249818801879883,
0.03259611874818802,
-0.5144825577735901,
-0.9538262486457825,
0.5475636720657349,
0.38841989636421204,
-0.2845727205276489,
0.41905373334884644,
-0.41230013966560364,
1.192566156387329,
-0.8274237513542175,
-0.5011752247810364,
-0.41764840483665466,
-1.0167139768600464,
0.016663560643792152,
-0.026220858097076416,
-0.16399569809436798,
-0.43213456869125366,
-0.036932580173015594,
0.4224216341972351,
-0.36836275458335876,
0.6791319847106934,
-0.29584750533103943,
0.40310773253440857,
-0.16508936882019043,
-0.27686089277267456,
0.508453905582428,
0.018609745427966118,
0.3261156678199768,
0.31061413884162903,
-0.06396471709012985,
-0.5631771683692932,
-0.6833443641662598,
0.17972208559513092,
-0.7854498028755188,
-0.48865029215812683,
-0.2263057380914688,
-0.1296415776014328,
-0.3333996534347534,
-0.05813872814178467,
0.36257433891296387,
0.4089231789112091,
-0.17635399103164673,
0.4159736633300781,
0.3927443027496338,
-0.06413634866476059,
0.5748268365859985,
0.6492149829864502,
0.0044674561358988285,
-0.44342315196990967,
1.1778004169464111,
-0.3776998817920685,
0.10934433341026306,
0.6314274072647095,
0.3168914020061493,
-0.10212486237287521,
-0.22403410077095032,
-0.42614662647247314,
0.06378372758626938,
-0.34322112798690796,
-0.2624627649784088,
-0.389674574136734,
-0.021806547418236732,
-0.4280787408351898,
-0.34192368388175964,
-0.4443979859352112,
-0.08745656162500381,
-0.47323548793792725,
-0.12220447510480881,
0.475286602973938,
0.3800789713859558,
-0.13494808971881866,
0.6953944563865662,
-0.40583500266075134,
0.5525884032249451,
0.6371630430221558,
0.636110782623291,
-0.07109218090772629,
-0.18077050149440765,
-0.3980664312839508,
-0.07549712806940079,
-0.07045870274305344,
-0.7263827323913574,
0.16596360504627228,
0.5065922737121582,
0.40511178970336914,
0.641309916973114,
-0.10362272709608078,
1.0005005598068237,
-0.4888785779476166,
0.582870364189148,
0.3796486556529999,
-0.9326555728912354,
0.5516427755355835,
-0.19646885991096497,
0.0578097328543663,
0.7985842823982239,
0.3064059317111969,
-0.08921840786933899,
0.34081247448921204,
-0.2918684780597687,
-0.6705936193466187,
0.8492617607116699,
0.009593280963599682,
-0.2070034146308899,
0.3165667951107025,
0.053362131118774414,
0.04460672661662102,
0.2340165376663208,
-0.8629713654518127,
0.2128930389881134,
-0.6066357493400574,
-0.16394269466400146,
-0.15023693442344666,
-0.011755380779504776,
0.12339987605810165,
-0.8080257773399353,
0.38043031096458435,
-0.3605336844921112,
0.035448867827653885,
-0.02861102856695652,
-0.106133371591568,
-0.09015994518995285,
0.1937893182039261,
0.43910518288612366,
0.58021479845047,
-0.20680247247219086,
0.0794529914855957,
0.3442017138004303,
-0.4684867560863495,
0.23525267839431763,
0.16598518192768097,
0.2784695327281952,
-0.2760639488697052,
0.17895162105560303,
1.1051825284957886,
0.35915184020996094,
-0.6719256639480591,
1.1021854877471924,
0.22043682634830475,
0.15079428255558014,
-0.21874943375587463,
-0.04358033090829849,
-0.7030370831489563,
0.5603699088096619,
0.33570292592048645,
0.09017779678106308,
-0.03075423277914524,
-0.49307766556739807,
0.2281074821949005,
0.4860537648200989,
-0.3372343182563782,
-0.643778383731842,
0.42144230008125305,
0.43499547243118286,
-0.18041479587554932,
0.25171226263046265,
0.12917707860469818,
-0.754991352558136,
0.3326312005519867,
0.40192684531211853,
1.108215093612671,
-0.43292123079299927,
0.3803815245628357,
-0.05928855016827583,
0.1695742905139923,
-0.08811413496732712,
0.13320106267929077,
-0.5646738409996033,
-0.7096603512763977,
-0.263765424489975,
-0.8985927104949951,
-0.02283508889377117,
0.08315274119377136,
-0.41741475462913513,
0.5290840864181519,
-0.5409696102142334,
-0.2598347067832947,
-0.3346650004386902,
-0.3382435739040375,
-0.8263994455337524,
0.5533678531646729,
-0.018502384424209595,
0.6121804714202881,
-1.2399455308914185,
0.6476527452468872,
0.649406909942627,
-0.30345427989959717,
-0.5492337942123413,
0.015836548060178757,
-0.3468916714191437,
-0.541296124458313,
0.5434889197349548,
0.32225751876831055,
-0.343944251537323,
0.11646176874637604,
-0.5003337264060974,
-0.6674771308898926,
1.3480441570281982,
0.6884157657623291,
0.09310341626405716,
-0.24823349714279175,
0.5307495594024658,
0.4280252754688263,
-0.4036204218864441,
0.2350168377161026,
0.5560028553009033,
0.4443536400794983,
0.341421902179718,
-1.0333211421966553,
-0.2795332968235016,
-0.03581438958644867,
0.01711193285882473,
0.4255465269088745,
-0.9580789804458618,
1.0270648002624512,
0.011471159756183624,
-0.025551550090312958,
0.07056095451116562,
0.7147279977798462,
-0.21863974630832672,
0.3584803342819214,
0.7600387334823608,
0.9845433831214905,
0.26887980103492737,
-0.14381922781467438,
0.5375880002975464,
-0.1467735320329666,
0.23986773192882538,
1.0370036363601685,
-0.043607380241155624,
0.9264156818389893,
0.40463754534721375,
-0.20779219269752502,
0.6149341464042664,
0.4409523904323578,
0.10428286343812943,
0.6659624576568604,
-0.24808144569396973,
-0.3197903335094452,
-0.9114433526992798,
-0.1334863007068634,
-0.36502471566200256,
1.0669951438903809,
-0.041373029351234436,
-0.3338429629802704,
-0.2668912708759308,
0.446964830160141,
-0.493100106716156,
-0.07179342955350876,
-0.5029774904251099,
0.7633076906204224,
-0.4598623514175415,
-0.36317986249923706,
0.04074724391102791,
0.14350004494190216,
0.2751297652721405,
-0.6253712773323059,
-0.0552900992333889,
0.20761185884475708,
0.22865666449069977,
-0.4891689419746399,
-0.708549439907074,
0.031239908188581467,
-0.2317606806755066,
-0.22339189052581787,
-0.4712986648082733,
0.6022734642028809,
-0.5267212390899658,
-0.3864792287349701,
0.0668226033449173,
0.11622552573680878,
-0.0416000671684742,
-0.14202004671096802,
-0.23297061026096344,
-0.12722112238407135,
-0.18554791808128357,
0.024833563715219498,
0.4564705789089203,
0.35193440318107605,
0.046290334314107895,
0.5592795610427856,
0.3551873564720154,
-0.08344006538391113,
0.012858494184911251,
-0.2864764928817749,
1.0604954957962036,
-0.7306632399559021,
-0.7583648562431335,
-0.790657639503479,
0.6284483671188354,
0.06802745908498764,
-0.35948652029037476,
0.3997322916984558,
0.5124360918998718,
0.8657926321029663,
0.048508018255233765,
-0.0031831422820687294,
-0.07260597497224808,
0.3214879333972931,
-0.6157220602035522,
0.49882593750953674,
-0.4699704945087433,
-0.19433578848838806,
-0.4502018094062805,
-0.8255735039710999,
0.14513127505779266,
0.5508531332015991,
-0.22212368249893188,
0.14294566214084625,
0.4259033203125,
0.6709038019180298,
-0.4284546673297882,
0.013162277638912201,
0.09818875044584274,
-0.3014198839664459,
0.14483439922332764,
0.7845673561096191,
0.3892047107219696,
-0.21025089919567108,
0.2558392882347107,
-0.5489795207977295,
-0.4302598237991333,
-0.24767901003360748,
-1.0525075197219849,
-0.9848684668540955,
-0.8941525816917419,
-0.18727214634418488,
-0.07559868693351746,
0.06623220443725586,
0.809439480304718,
0.8744698166847229,
-0.5905004143714905,
-0.1361989825963974,
0.09468507766723633,
-0.3393760323524475,
0.11213016510009766,
-0.21458278596401215,
0.3692346513271332,
0.3091491460800171,
-0.25023379921913147,
0.2613292336463928,
0.5889415740966797,
0.20689821243286133,
-0.4778899550437927,
-0.29220694303512573,
-0.30238401889801025,
-0.2623578608036041,
0.3992692828178406,
0.4712373912334442,
-0.5171108841896057,
-0.7347893118858337,
-0.2524355947971344,
0.27093595266342163,
0.26359352469444275,
1.1510965824127197,
-1.1675647497177124,
0.6315365433692932,
0.6352584362030029,
0.6932635307312012,
0.5507328510284424,
0.6021093726158142,
0.5676541328430176,
-1.022626280784607,
0.5916987657546997,
0.2424205243587494,
0.46604230999946594,
0.5329313278198242,
-0.24103863537311554,
0.41377073526382446,
0.5315277576446533,
-0.2605116069316864,
-0.588312029838562,
0.5510705709457397,
-0.9935483932495117,
0.12048767507076263,
0.7336094975471497,
-0.040628623217344284,
-0.3714286983013153,
-0.027735207229852676,
-0.16433189809322357,
0.007372355088591576,
-0.115484319627285,
0.510736346244812,
0.28163430094718933,
-0.3703789710998535,
-0.6514469385147095,
0.2155483365058899,
0.49883949756622314,
0.1371161788702011,
-0.7744836807250977,
-0.14056053757667542,
0.43079641461372375,
-0.06715019047260284,
-0.07357592135667801,
0.5402130484580994,
0.2270110696554184,
0.5574051141738892,
-0.3331643044948578,
-0.17970754206180573,
-0.390202134847641,
-0.6220804452896118,
-0.31322574615478516,
0.08553722500801086,
-0.2676025629043579,
-0.07318264245986938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17918v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17918v2
|
I Have an Attention Bridge to Sell You: Generalization Capabilities of Modular Translation Architectures
| 2024-04-27T14:10:51 | 2024-04-30T05:53:10 |
Timothee Mickus, Raúl Vázquez, Joseph Attieh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modularity is a paradigm of machine translation with the potential of
bringing forth models that are large at training time and small during
inference. Within this field of study, modular approaches, and in particular
attention bridges, have been argued to improve the generalization capabilities
of models by fostering language-independent representations. In the present
paper, we study whether modularity affects translation quality; as well as how
well modular architectures generalize across different evaluation scenarios.
For a given computational budget, we find non-modular architectures to be
always comparable or preferable to all modular designs we study.
|
[
-0.27534371614456177,
-0.5779963731765747,
0.6804768443107605,
0.3834371566772461,
-0.10958767682313919,
-0.24872280657291412,
-0.18235424160957336,
-0.35865962505340576,
0.2616608738899231,
0.3328271508216858,
-0.11626426130533218,
-0.2365158647298813,
-0.7421936988830566,
0.13884197175502777,
-0.5109806656837463,
0.7983734011650085,
-0.0577225424349308,
0.18713919818401337,
-0.31042706966400146,
-0.4128880798816681,
-0.41467106342315674,
-0.4467790722846985,
-0.26644498109817505,
-0.24504204094409943,
0.6087308526039124,
0.11531402170658112,
1.0351085662841797,
0.8515323996543884,
0.6329305768013,
0.35944870114326477,
-0.20712068676948547,
-0.1489192247390747,
-0.15865670144557953,
0.011250744573771954,
-0.49190494418144226,
-0.8313082456588745,
-0.8769189715385437,
0.008269162848591805,
1.042142391204834,
0.762702465057373,
0.1444597691297531,
0.5603835582733154,
0.1066032126545906,
1.1939151287078857,
-0.3013976216316223,
0.23760515451431274,
-0.5215864181518555,
0.17891035974025726,
-0.10980211943387985,
0.1057002916932106,
-0.4266395568847656,
-0.19691327214241028,
0.2777113914489746,
-0.3209993839263916,
0.3628826141357422,
0.2822486460208893,
0.5832938551902771,
0.28649041056632996,
-0.5671924352645874,
0.09281662851572037,
-0.5565263628959656,
0.8157680630683899,
-0.6485132575035095,
0.23949076235294342,
0.29678043723106384,
0.48643824458122253,
0.027658862993121147,
-0.5190356373786926,
-0.29564374685287476,
-0.0216319989413023,
-0.3849894404411316,
0.22618956863880157,
-0.20435988903045654,
0.23224683105945587,
0.25032082200050354,
0.9363422989845276,
-0.6754564642906189,
-0.2159639596939087,
-0.6461682319641113,
0.06005991995334625,
0.49012160301208496,
0.3031243681907654,
0.6625515818595886,
-0.4028668999671936,
-0.2512080669403076,
0.2575175166130066,
-0.5472949147224426,
0.24258285760879517,
0.46265268325805664,
0.0677715390920639,
-0.08782607316970825,
0.5358029007911682,
-0.5138993263244629,
0.9561995267868042,
0.3558245599269867,
0.3178446590900421,
0.3958483338356018,
-0.5083679556846619,
-0.49587416648864746,
-0.2706444263458252,
0.5027414560317993,
0.17361010611057281,
0.1222061961889267,
-0.6163453459739685,
-0.396452397108078,
-0.2711578905582428,
0.7603477835655212,
-0.3718430995941162,
-0.0060864039696753025,
0.314857542514801,
-0.978005588054657,
-0.21722422540187836,
0.10437937825918198,
-0.3950190544128418,
0.4490615725517273,
-0.49816620349884033,
0.5511118769645691,
0.029747240245342255,
-0.24329300224781036,
0.22947092354297638,
-0.28631338477134705,
0.2468082755804062,
0.012672994285821915,
-1.486467957496643,
0.47282055020332336,
0.5959489345550537,
1.0103604793548584,
-0.4268481433391571,
0.012451045215129852,
-0.3145201504230499,
0.3092585802078247,
-0.48178425431251526,
0.8143695592880249,
-0.4841764569282532,
-0.17839276790618896,
-0.26373496651649475,
0.11839194595813751,
-0.6061000227928162,
-0.7098138928413391,
0.11550718545913696,
-0.6148443222045898,
-0.06960541754961014,
-0.021735496819019318,
-0.23378604650497437,
-0.2622777819633484,
0.3069224953651428,
-0.7932201027870178,
0.30662113428115845,
0.3267042636871338,
-0.42595815658569336,
-0.03271499276161194,
-0.4979279339313507,
-0.49806907773017883,
-0.09745743125677109,
0.008917339146137238,
-0.4344312250614166,
0.5963153839111328,
0.1200244128704071,
0.3474094867706299,
-0.21822567284107208,
0.24727703630924225,
-0.2655315697193146,
-0.20437106490135193,
0.25026369094848633,
0.166805237531662,
0.34387320280075073,
0.20599716901779175,
-0.6266433000564575,
0.40023526549339294,
-0.33757802844047546,
-0.049852799624204636,
-0.24552634358406067,
-0.6996878385543823,
-0.04060237482190132,
-0.04500193893909454,
-0.09339050948619843,
0.34585681557655334,
0.17398402094841003,
-0.37438803911209106,
0.288127601146698,
-0.6432944536209106,
0.557617723941803,
0.8313015103340149,
-0.1628016084432602,
1.0686877965927124,
-0.4039790630340576,
0.533903956413269,
0.2878759205341339,
0.2586892545223236,
-0.13541778922080994,
-0.8782519102096558,
-0.9669392704963684,
-0.04582340642809868,
0.4231925904750824,
0.40341347455978394,
-0.4705979824066162,
0.2771188020706177,
-0.3518182635307312,
-0.17758877575397491,
-0.6033652424812317,
0.23113633692264557,
0.6330196261405945,
0.1054336279630661,
0.4160374104976654,
-0.7606622576713562,
-0.18797822296619415,
-1.5040885210037231,
-0.21253876388072968,
-0.0946434810757637,
-0.04420063644647598,
0.3177150785923004,
0.30232036113739014,
-0.20455004274845123,
0.5907025337219238,
-0.27769744396209717,
-0.467104971408844,
-0.5139504671096802,
0.05678104609251022,
0.35023388266563416,
0.5937913656234741,
0.7370951771736145,
-0.8353424668312073,
-0.5529457926750183,
0.3116845190525055,
-0.6881551146507263,
0.2835032641887665,
-0.19350698590278625,
-0.17032866179943085,
0.022895455360412598,
0.34525081515312195,
-0.7684224247932434,
0.30341896414756775,
0.5626010298728943,
-0.013190038502216339,
0.3114432394504547,
-0.1579272747039795,
0.3378140926361084,
-1.2477704286575317,
0.18675518035888672,
-0.24753090739250183,
-0.18970763683319092,
-0.689471423625946,
0.18552207946777344,
0.15743669867515564,
-0.11819497495889664,
-0.2692122757434845,
0.3658774197101593,
-0.6063181757926941,
-0.499876469373703,
-0.01460068766027689,
0.10229646414518356,
-0.07677160203456879,
0.5794820785522461,
-0.06654813885688782,
0.72905033826828,
0.5102630257606506,
-0.578559398651123,
0.35475772619247437,
0.3804764151573181,
-0.41094666719436646,
0.5409231781959534,
-0.8243985176086426,
0.1835351139307022,
-0.1646447628736496,
0.2017686665058136,
-1.0341033935546875,
-0.31276869773864746,
0.17548462748527527,
-0.7124239206314087,
0.49020689725875854,
-0.05358504503965378,
-0.3984047472476959,
-0.3096083104610443,
-0.19197559356689453,
0.6469886898994446,
0.450351744890213,
-0.1612008512020111,
0.6237841248512268,
0.36005693674087524,
-0.1678791493177414,
-0.39470794796943665,
-1.1039886474609375,
0.008455387316644192,
0.061510421335697174,
-0.7696788907051086,
0.19558168947696686,
-0.26519978046417236,
-0.2520226538181305,
0.20331838726997375,
-0.1542559415102005,
-0.3044601380825043,
-0.011073295027017593,
0.2701193392276764,
0.03190597519278526,
-0.6091880798339844,
0.2822016775608063,
0.2176714539527893,
-0.3524799048900604,
0.12141509354114532,
-0.7436898350715637,
0.1283515840768814,
-0.047511905431747437,
-0.42557913064956665,
-0.5007283687591553,
0.5980716943740845,
0.791056215763092,
-0.42772355675697327,
0.5653927326202393,
0.2664680778980255,
-0.03843476250767708,
-0.13767234981060028,
-0.687551736831665,
0.046412523835897446,
-0.46303531527519226,
0.44969284534454346,
-0.5521931052207947,
-1.0072593688964844,
0.40188029408454895,
0.28203701972961426,
0.027295421808958054,
0.6236271858215332,
0.7106971740722656,
-0.01427766028791666,
1.0879238843917847,
0.6902573108673096,
-0.44246336817741394,
0.38375428318977356,
-0.08531685918569565,
0.408644437789917,
-1.1878633499145508,
-0.19398891925811768,
-0.39713266491889954,
-0.8699837923049927,
-0.22265425324440002,
-0.5631518959999084,
0.037805359810590744,
-0.1945633590221405,
0.107449010014534,
0.532343327999115,
-0.4461328387260437,
0.3969101905822754,
0.378323495388031,
0.108234703540802,
0.3435693383216858,
-0.014439905062317848,
-0.07363434880971909,
0.11980460584163666,
-0.7724528908729553,
-0.5411491990089417,
1.2469302415847778,
0.320037841796875,
0.38714590668678284,
0.3689102828502655,
0.38320276141166687,
0.4529944956302643,
0.2875940501689911,
-0.8486575484275818,
0.4355289936065674,
0.04230988025665283,
-0.9954684972763062,
-0.1538735032081604,
-0.46524834632873535,
-0.9147871732711792,
0.1620592176914215,
0.07460800558328629,
-0.5326244831085205,
0.34412622451782227,
0.25091126561164856,
-0.2535330355167389,
0.49976101517677307,
-0.7245882749557495,
0.9777151942253113,
-0.011214671656489372,
0.140569806098938,
-0.817928671836853,
-0.5929141640663147,
0.39058390259742737,
-0.060609783977270126,
0.06536586582660675,
0.07409073412418365,
-0.3068864345550537,
0.3728209435939789,
0.1986922025680542,
0.7662966847419739,
0.40574026107788086,
0.3328416347503662,
0.23034273087978363,
0.05506017804145813,
0.13884977996349335,
0.004442762583494186,
-0.07350867241621017,
0.12131650000810623,
-0.42802080512046814,
-0.8888635039329529,
-0.7344188094139099,
0.7406656742095947,
-0.823702335357666,
-1.082067847251892,
0.05255664885044098,
-0.7558914422988892,
-0.3347799777984619,
0.1241011917591095,
0.0715218260884285,
0.45363736152648926,
-0.24849675595760345,
0.202643483877182,
0.993689239025116,
0.04726288095116615,
0.466278076171875,
0.28875672817230225,
0.048437975347042084,
-0.4469278156757355,
0.9549201726913452,
0.26942431926727295,
0.7614321708679199,
0.6789922714233398,
-0.2941717803478241,
0.12409739196300507,
-0.7541184425354004,
-0.8403341770172119,
0.19161389768123627,
-0.642141580581665,
-0.0032191784121096134,
-0.8914055824279785,
-0.22732433676719666,
-0.48314201831817627,
-0.1757180243730545,
-0.2963215112686157,
-0.8727704286575317,
-0.09556032717227936,
-0.3025186061859131,
-0.344409704208374,
1.1914863586425781,
-0.036225415766239166,
-0.016235709190368652,
-0.8676424622535706,
0.4596285820007324,
0.8442476987838745,
0.23293498158454895,
0.30423668026924133,
-0.557091236114502,
-0.6888982653617859,
-0.39126190543174744,
-0.3621695041656494,
-0.633381187915802,
-0.15844929218292236,
0.02608804777264595,
0.9388504028320312,
0.43263840675354004,
-0.38705679774284363,
0.29932084679603577,
-0.5205352902412415,
0.7835862636566162,
0.2513049244880676,
-1.0585507154464722,
0.39649781584739685,
-0.5715464353561401,
0.6095933318138123,
0.34231629967689514,
0.1650083363056183,
-0.4114148020744324,
-0.579208493232727,
-0.7487451434135437,
-0.6476655006408691,
0.5323679447174072,
0.32116958498954773,
0.4278492033481598,
-0.0733223557472229,
0.42048895359039307,
-0.11297283321619034,
0.4174392521381378,
-0.646458089351654,
-0.15392041206359863,
-0.04014647752046585,
0.031786587089300156,
-0.10027337074279785,
-0.5414455533027649,
0.10866187512874603,
-0.24278993904590607,
0.5167551636695862,
-0.04570348933339119,
0.3774798512458801,
0.20137712359428406,
-0.23211205005645752,
-0.1983959823846817,
0.4791053831577301,
0.5578917264938354,
0.7986969947814941,
0.10027753561735153,
0.04082760214805603,
0.23986037075519562,
-0.2941507399082184,
0.21634390950202942,
-0.6068480610847473,
-0.1668604016304016,
0.1757793426513672,
0.36753129959106445,
0.6029003262519836,
0.48546841740608215,
-0.16598184406757355,
0.5169557929039001,
0.18023064732551575,
-0.21571549773216248,
0.33501625061035156,
0.09561141580343246,
0.3093637526035309,
0.4856243133544922,
0.07151355594396591,
0.4715811312198639,
0.33975860476493835,
-0.5821841359138489,
0.26045912504196167,
0.4601350724697113,
-0.6213792562484741,
-0.7427145838737488,
0.7303340435028076,
0.4673306941986084,
-0.2858063876628876,
0.4497535228729248,
0.07181084156036377,
-0.35577309131622314,
0.6807650923728943,
0.42004016041755676,
1.2127457857131958,
-0.43446072936058044,
0.08247809112071991,
0.5745154619216919,
0.6281339526176453,
-0.15367715060710907,
-0.2599623203277588,
-0.44954103231430054,
-0.3209904730319977,
-0.34952831268310547,
-0.5137496590614319,
-0.38002192974090576,
-0.3936222791671753,
-0.9474892616271973,
-0.12401440739631653,
-0.4326055645942688,
-0.3912314772605896,
-0.35796037316322327,
-0.5916208624839783,
-0.31380876898765564,
0.22244499623775482,
0.2713121175765991,
0.7283452749252319,
-0.7249617576599121,
0.9432108402252197,
0.8645873069763184,
-0.39873892068862915,
-0.44131210446357727,
-0.001775561016984284,
-0.125077486038208,
-0.4210077226161957,
0.7304930686950684,
0.14609800279140472,
-0.001113241189159453,
-0.09139502793550491,
-0.1733030080795288,
-1.0428370237350464,
1.0379608869552612,
0.38888248801231384,
-0.39690807461738586,
-0.3513796925544739,
0.26167845726013184,
0.36984506249427795,
-0.6627711653709412,
-0.16139329969882965,
0.558236837387085,
0.5078900456428528,
-0.4401222765445709,
-1.0125521421432495,
-0.15366332232952118,
-0.45785337686538696,
0.3014666736125946,
0.1583869904279709,
-1.0130740404129028,
0.8400441408157349,
-0.07746392488479614,
-0.16714464128017426,
0.265452116727829,
0.6634936332702637,
-0.4142621159553528,
0.042457982897758484,
0.16215983033180237,
0.7962145209312439,
0.21718381345272064,
0.02814798802137375,
1.197788953781128,
-0.2755507826805115,
0.32608500123023987,
0.8135988712310791,
0.48400434851646423,
0.8034957647323608,
0.4697982966899872,
-0.07541607320308685,
0.46594110131263733,
0.49657541513442993,
0.09011003375053406,
0.4660786986351013,
0.1473531424999237,
0.07207947969436646,
-0.4859446883201599,
0.11717857420444489,
-0.43826356530189514,
-0.18465718626976013,
-0.020650619640946388,
-0.7318819761276245,
-0.0692625567317009,
-0.12520183622837067,
-0.43450379371643066,
0.027373000979423523,
-0.5059352517127991,
0.7575868964195251,
0.3461989760398865,
-0.6109877228736877,
0.27196595072746277,
-0.14065662026405334,
0.2770431637763977,
-0.5837013125419617,
0.2466108649969101,
-0.2781118154525757,
0.20459102094173431,
-0.3797300457954407,
-0.4919537305831909,
0.6680951118469238,
-0.46648505330085754,
-0.8554335236549377,
-0.3615195155143738,
0.38096854090690613,
-0.2094418853521347,
-0.3595888912677765,
0.4155239164829254,
0.4918249249458313,
0.015703018754720688,
-0.11904022097587585,
-0.5607296824455261,
-0.16513141989707947,
0.06113927438855171,
-0.4839743375778198,
0.733710765838623,
0.3722400367259979,
-0.0326707661151886,
0.6609873175621033,
0.3741106390953064,
-0.03484451770782471,
0.2292604297399521,
-0.32270047068595886,
0.9779012203216553,
-0.6905145049095154,
-0.35292309522628784,
-0.7920296788215637,
0.7905928492546082,
-0.09300196915864944,
-0.37925612926483154,
0.7714614868164062,
0.7440317273139954,
0.6054404377937317,
-0.4319033622741699,
0.5814151763916016,
0.3420994281768799,
-0.10846872627735138,
-0.37888216972351074,
0.7748964428901672,
-0.5240153670310974,
-0.036220431327819824,
-0.10666460543870926,
-1.2593069076538086,
-0.3122348487377167,
0.2952108681201935,
-0.5527452826499939,
-0.3719184100627899,
0.9006538391113281,
0.5276248455047607,
-0.3832547664642334,
-0.18035995960235596,
0.6168981790542603,
0.1367930769920349,
0.02985243871808052,
0.6707949638366699,
0.399762362241745,
-0.3816925585269928,
0.565727174282074,
0.3344835638999939,
-0.2736738324165344,
-0.14188338816165924,
-0.1962796151638031,
-1.1658903360366821,
-0.6759171485900879,
-0.2475942224264145,
-0.015882546082139015,
0.08028676360845566,
0.38937821984291077,
0.782997190952301,
-0.9074277281761169,
-0.44572627544403076,
0.12350732088088989,
0.44401663541793823,
-0.2752903401851654,
-0.11830823868513107,
0.14854294061660767,
-0.9914946556091309,
-0.7194085121154785,
0.3841724693775177,
1.0450607538223267,
0.017294615507125854,
-0.35964298248291016,
0.1480398029088974,
-0.01398746483027935,
0.49019360542297363,
0.5522588491439819,
0.011314491741359234,
-0.6747033596038818,
-0.18441413342952728,
-0.01240644883364439,
-0.32019034028053284,
0.4124669134616852,
1.1733450889587402,
-0.4354715645313263,
0.607303261756897,
0.6613150835037231,
0.9541961550712585,
0.5129689574241638,
0.05211545526981354,
0.9127877354621887,
-0.2625814974308014,
0.3695051968097687,
-0.0676397979259491,
0.4531072676181793,
0.2252568006515503,
-0.26385343074798584,
0.5283352136611938,
0.23548313975334167,
-0.6006706357002258,
-0.21268808841705322,
0.556119978427887,
-0.8814302086830139,
-0.024332912638783455,
0.8793731927871704,
-0.38126933574676514,
-0.697344183921814,
-0.2939692735671997,
-0.023989396169781685,
-0.23749345541000366,
-0.13601650297641754,
0.8585665225982666,
0.8338779211044312,
0.015365284867584705,
0.1196151077747345,
-0.7825400233268738,
0.277146577835083,
0.6893779635429382,
-0.5848020911216736,
-0.2207711786031723,
0.17509889602661133,
0.304109126329422,
0.2997210621833801,
0.45014095306396484,
-0.27839118242263794,
0.5442189574241638,
-0.23276029527187347,
-0.2475634217262268,
0.09119665622711182,
-0.20928101241588593,
-0.3357984721660614,
0.27731555700302124,
0.05980938300490379,
-0.2583167254924774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17912v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17912v1
|
SERPENT-VLM : Self-Refining Radiology Report Generation Using Vision Language Models
| 2024-04-27T13:46:23 | 2024-04-27T13:46:23 |
Manav Nitin Kapadnis, Sohan Patnaik, Abhilash Nandy, Sourjyadip Ray, Pawan Goyal, Debdoot Sheet
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Radiology Report Generation (R2Gen) demonstrates how Multi-modal Large
Language Models (MLLMs) can automate the creation of accurate and coherent
radiological reports. Existing methods often hallucinate details in text-based
reports that don't accurately reflect the image content. To mitigate this, we
introduce a novel strategy, SERPENT-VLM (SElf Refining Radiology RePort
GENeraTion using Vision Language Models), which improves the R2Gen task by
integrating a self-refining mechanism into the MLLM framework. We employ a
unique self-supervised loss that leverages similarity between pooled image
representations and the contextual representations of the generated
radiological text, alongside the standard Causal Language Modeling objective,
to refine image-text representations. This allows the model to scrutinize and
align the generated text through dynamic interaction between a given image and
the generated text, therefore reducing hallucination and continuously enhancing
nuanced report generation. SERPENT-VLM outperforms existing baselines such as
LLaVA-Med, BiomedGPT, etc., achieving SoTA performance on the IU X-ray and
Radiology Objects in COntext (ROCO) datasets, and also proves to be robust
against noisy images. A qualitative case study emphasizes the significant
advancements towards more sophisticated MLLM frameworks for R2Gen, opening
paths for further research into self-supervised refinement in the medical
imaging domain.
|
[
-0.14021456241607666,
-0.2266625463962555,
0.7174562215805054,
-0.07579497992992401,
-0.31053125858306885,
-0.16159792244434357,
0.04519223794341087,
-0.6693994402885437,
0.08767441660165787,
0.7309101819992065,
-0.6287590861320496,
-0.2609190344810486,
-0.2522919774055481,
0.18548651039600372,
-0.47711583971977234,
0.789783239364624,
0.08536605536937714,
0.4270012676715851,
-0.22416584193706512,
-0.20467731356620789,
-0.5470684170722961,
-0.2679779827594757,
-0.34026095271110535,
-0.523043692111969,
0.8091748356819153,
0.22734668850898743,
0.5459105968475342,
1.1240302324295044,
0.7328900694847107,
0.23466555774211884,
0.5664252638816833,
0.12227962166070938,
-0.5873582363128662,
0.38870885968208313,
-0.25993818044662476,
-0.05028660595417023,
-0.17375032603740692,
-0.3452380299568176,
0.5401505827903748,
0.34794721007347107,
-0.20746050775051117,
0.05034380033612251,
0.02185857482254505,
0.7437229752540588,
-0.6096239686012268,
0.12399392575025558,
-0.5010166168212891,
0.08963583409786224,
-0.1919502168893814,
-0.7775613069534302,
-0.4428465962409973,
0.061319418251514435,
0.19930265843868256,
-0.5040606260299683,
0.13189920783042908,
0.08788508176803589,
1.098915934562683,
0.5886895060539246,
-0.2145140916109085,
-0.13771721720695496,
-0.6715034246444702,
0.7350448966026306,
-0.5952386856079102,
0.3330304026603699,
0.09244173020124435,
0.3540552258491516,
0.2257733792066574,
-1.3369165658950806,
-0.08954859524965286,
-0.13697203993797302,
-0.40024611353874207,
0.36506253480911255,
-0.3628271520137787,
0.07839582860469818,
0.11140584200620651,
0.18894433975219727,
-0.6255027055740356,
0.18680435419082642,
-0.6704009175300598,
-0.4013771116733551,
0.803503692150116,
0.4074901342391968,
0.16740188002586365,
-0.3296392560005188,
-0.6099537014961243,
-0.19265204668045044,
-0.7395989894866943,
-0.5777287483215332,
-0.18035364151000977,
0.167209193110466,
0.2811274230480194,
0.5183655619621277,
-0.4299491047859192,
0.6652927398681641,
-0.16696147620677948,
-0.29435375332832336,
0.32049235701560974,
-0.31095772981643677,
-0.339106947183609,
0.36783352494239807,
0.774814248085022,
0.6668500900268555,
-0.21973475813865662,
-0.04243786260485649,
-0.2206241339445114,
-0.030856285244226456,
0.4511585235595703,
-1.0263972282409668,
-0.3101852834224701,
0.12233398109674454,
-0.9468454718589783,
-0.6591011881828308,
-0.1958082616329193,
-0.5291948914527893,
-0.599480926990509,
-0.3552913963794708,
0.6306871175765991,
-0.46398743987083435,
-0.2828332483768463,
0.08011466264724731,
0.0726107656955719,
0.37391480803489685,
0.34120967984199524,
-0.5339270830154419,
0.011156829074025154,
0.2599734961986542,
0.6248916387557983,
0.020110933110117912,
-0.30495375394821167,
-0.6637555360794067,
0.30934977531433105,
-0.3188745975494385,
0.9592111706733704,
-0.1820412129163742,
-0.4327431917190552,
-0.1803094744682312,
-0.22766059637069702,
0.11260663717985153,
-0.5405845046043396,
0.3508051931858063,
-0.14080539345741272,
0.4255453646183014,
-0.20471881330013275,
-0.2938234508037567,
-0.22857734560966492,
0.1630924642086029,
-0.3119139075279236,
0.9906501173973083,
0.20857371389865875,
-0.7528144121170044,
0.35331839323043823,
-0.3069699704647064,
-0.3624405562877655,
0.34613385796546936,
-0.6606541872024536,
-0.6703549027442932,
0.24391552805900574,
0.1563751995563507,
0.4434313476085663,
-0.43791547417640686,
0.28749576210975647,
0.043404292315244675,
-0.16509105265140533,
0.07104790210723877,
-0.2412102222442627,
0.27772364020347595,
0.4534393548965454,
-0.35196372866630554,
0.5241876840591431,
-0.6191142797470093,
0.4072829484939575,
0.2326166331768036,
0.054265689104795456,
-0.286493718624115,
0.09754639863967896,
0.029104307293891907,
0.3030233383178711,
0.13712330162525177,
-0.49204501509666443,
0.20722077786922455,
-0.4990582764148712,
0.3076251447200775,
0.4173538386821747,
-0.10469836741685867,
0.006657988298684359,
-0.3859501779079437,
0.28044208884239197,
-0.10908986628055573,
0.30474191904067993,
-0.3807547390460968,
-0.24179111421108246,
-0.9404531121253967,
-0.2927154302597046,
0.2839798629283905,
0.2792462706565857,
-0.8152546882629395,
-0.08606858551502228,
-0.2689453959465027,
-0.5413761138916016,
-0.8125107288360596,
-0.20950265228748322,
0.49027079343795776,
0.9976176619529724,
0.434008926153183,
-0.5859010219573975,
-0.767403244972229,
-1.201857566833496,
0.007538802456110716,
-0.08297280222177505,
0.1905224621295929,
0.3468431830406189,
0.12699556350708008,
-0.45543524622917175,
0.8108499646186829,
-0.544772207736969,
-0.778712809085846,
-0.2822602689266205,
0.2916269302368164,
-0.17574040591716766,
0.28986626863479614,
0.45172417163848877,
-0.5673587918281555,
-0.32984381914138794,
0.12183374166488647,
-1.0949822664260864,
-0.2448878139257431,
-0.2296561300754547,
0.1928514689207077,
0.3858478367328644,
0.9709615111351013,
-0.04536271467804909,
0.7297936677932739,
0.5725477337837219,
-0.31357333064079285,
0.4858512282371521,
-0.6586609482765198,
0.08151233196258545,
-0.8251767754554749,
0.1782645881175995,
-0.15747320652008057,
-0.5880140662193298,
-0.5090042352676392,
0.24243056774139404,
0.14791342616081238,
-0.07417954504489899,
-0.3827133774757385,
0.41599810123443604,
-0.6906555891036987,
-0.20014551281929016,
-0.5304586291313171,
-0.28774258494377136,
0.08224037289619446,
0.17439205944538116,
0.3400256931781769,
0.5925570726394653,
0.8016347885131836,
-0.4466422200202942,
0.27039530873298645,
-0.10062136501073837,
-0.0865161344408989,
0.33696457743644714,
-0.7138332724571228,
0.02630961686372757,
-0.33072778582572937,
0.038796573877334595,
-0.668893039226532,
-0.10336119681596756,
0.2892196476459503,
-0.255165696144104,
0.5520304441452026,
-0.137191042304039,
-0.17855589091777802,
-0.40363809466362,
-0.127303808927536,
0.24806202948093414,
0.5703957676887512,
-0.23139016330242157,
0.8177431225776672,
0.1620965600013733,
-0.09471739828586578,
-0.5139272809028625,
-0.9105998873710632,
0.4589468538761139,
-0.02355504035949707,
-0.5252684354782104,
0.38191482424736023,
0.0728999674320221,
-0.11620306223630905,
0.26319143176078796,
0.025949502363801003,
0.04404107481241226,
-0.12755732238292694,
0.24393026530742645,
0.3094889521598816,
-0.41933900117874146,
0.22366860508918762,
-0.2162974625825882,
-0.4362080991268158,
0.12944425642490387,
-0.2524831295013428,
0.7434386610984802,
-0.26417306065559387,
-0.3854731321334839,
-0.4863889217376709,
0.27444809675216675,
0.4277084767818451,
-0.31793496012687683,
0.3137386739253998,
0.7572441697120667,
-0.11713588237762451,
-0.09451291710138321,
-0.5977056622505188,
-0.45014211535453796,
-0.4667574167251587,
0.5247615575790405,
-0.3915601968765259,
-0.6985422372817993,
0.31882327795028687,
-0.03926417604088783,
-0.07646038383245468,
0.7238318920135498,
0.8640310168266296,
-0.25007787346839905,
0.9633962512016296,
0.5709746479988098,
0.2811969518661499,
0.20890894532203674,
-0.36099162697792053,
0.15558703243732452,
-0.7259117364883423,
-0.46666455268859863,
-0.24479667842388153,
0.01148160733282566,
-0.3967306911945343,
-0.34968310594558716,
0.4864402413368225,
-0.39290758967399597,
0.3116988241672516,
-0.17209920287132263,
-0.9816035628318787,
0.43050625920295715,
0.5222079753875732,
0.10000024735927582,
0.3218402564525604,
0.1971546858549118,
0.06043282151222229,
-0.3342968225479126,
-0.9501186013221741,
-0.21434909105300903,
1.1221933364868164,
0.35994672775268555,
1.1063445806503296,
-0.21918536722660065,
0.9166372418403625,
0.36246609687805176,
0.3712301254272461,
-0.8500218987464905,
0.3586583435535431,
-0.11556335538625717,
-0.23529671132564545,
-0.27068597078323364,
-0.2923012375831604,
-1.0422066450119019,
0.3284538984298706,
-0.21099552512168884,
-0.21624372899532318,
-0.0008664146298542619,
0.18922795355319977,
-0.43409425020217896,
-0.021193698048591614,
-0.34774118661880493,
0.7610373497009277,
-0.36450517177581787,
-0.5409032702445984,
-0.378999799489975,
-0.7302793860435486,
0.2998463809490204,
0.003970951307564974,
0.0956951305270195,
-0.11408545076847076,
0.0029263340402394533,
0.3056602478027344,
-0.7961211800575256,
0.6786508560180664,
-0.06119246780872345,
-0.16454993188381195,
0.2797245681285858,
0.1983262151479721,
0.3838356137275696,
0.0024928234051913023,
0.24391885101795197,
0.05464550852775574,
-0.017078261822462082,
0.06820836663246155,
-0.3686356246471405,
0.7411566376686096,
-0.7101180553436279,
-0.4895346164703369,
-0.7547230124473572,
-0.6211445331573486,
0.11872174590826035,
0.5090929269790649,
0.5949788689613342,
0.9428303837776184,
0.02570682391524315,
0.07536423206329346,
0.6656516790390015,
-0.29090237617492676,
0.19303084909915924,
0.5730994343757629,
-0.6758338212966919,
-0.28076863288879395,
1.1473873853683472,
0.1611955165863037,
0.12320338934659958,
0.051623936742544174,
0.4277283549308777,
-0.46466967463493347,
-0.7481052875518799,
-0.6191307306289673,
0.33170339465141296,
-0.7708955407142639,
-0.5350966453552246,
-0.5835843682289124,
-0.5723395347595215,
-0.4939832389354706,
-0.045205213129520416,
-0.5100570917129517,
-0.024021800607442856,
-0.2781219780445099,
0.40179216861724854,
0.3905692398548126,
0.8169610500335693,
-0.3128196597099304,
0.08927034586668015,
-0.6042905449867249,
0.3755689859390259,
0.25750449299812317,
0.26684683561325073,
-0.16760478913784027,
-0.5339394807815552,
-0.213187575340271,
-0.21974250674247742,
-0.08351287990808487,
-0.665719211101532,
0.7017965316772461,
0.20311592519283295,
0.43664732575416565,
0.1284535825252533,
0.0633709505200386,
0.8668774962425232,
-0.3534696400165558,
0.4783080816268921,
0.49058616161346436,
-0.6803197264671326,
0.6425530314445496,
-0.42913925647735596,
0.33737272024154663,
0.4822363257408142,
-0.2304222136735916,
-0.5368598699569702,
-0.5097714066505432,
-0.6579661965370178,
-0.9050666093826294,
0.5723816752433777,
0.12983359396457672,
-0.033634964376688004,
0.296385794878006,
0.27652281522750854,
-0.0938921868801117,
-0.11390866339206696,
-0.7534437775611877,
-0.2802194058895111,
-0.43922165036201477,
-0.2022930532693863,
0.2832455635070801,
-0.42315712571144104,
-0.34065988659858704,
-0.24105998873710632,
0.7545232772827148,
-0.4003506004810333,
0.18274594843387604,
0.8551979064941406,
-0.12610650062561035,
-0.18586745858192444,
0.021760016679763794,
0.6765862107276917,
0.7066543698310852,
-0.03332871198654175,
0.18809589743614197,
0.007671695202589035,
-0.27409255504608154,
-0.11938715726137161,
-0.03191317617893219,
-0.27192386984825134,
0.15686021745204926,
0.30494600534439087,
0.6745919585227966,
0.10142285376787186,
-0.6837030649185181,
0.5698537230491638,
-0.3350997567176819,
-0.48507460951805115,
-0.2462867945432663,
0.013101231306791306,
-0.0729653462767601,
0.08238393068313599,
0.5881016254425049,
0.23492193222045898,
0.5676482915878296,
-0.3760693073272705,
0.47754940390586853,
0.15610401332378387,
-0.6991081833839417,
0.2219180166721344,
0.6329122185707092,
0.20828315615653992,
0.3281814754009247,
0.6587043404579163,
-0.06952884793281555,
-0.23046055436134338,
0.3639411926269531,
0.5498284101486206,
0.7927488684654236,
-0.030674593523144722,
0.21678397059440613,
0.4594671130180359,
0.29087433218955994,
-0.1917702555656433,
0.31545791029930115,
0.3249798119068146,
-0.44349291920661926,
-0.6898170709609985,
-0.3263759911060333,
-0.16201230883598328,
0.1862075924873352,
-0.8422800302505493,
0.36936718225479126,
-0.44800662994384766,
-0.041321832686662674,
-0.07881694287061691,
-0.21921227872371674,
-0.2464679777622223,
0.43157827854156494,
0.475130170583725,
0.5508002638816833,
-0.361823171377182,
0.9880383610725403,
0.3606642484664917,
-0.3293144702911377,
-1.0102297067642212,
-0.24097636342048645,
0.07644554227590561,
-1.0630863904953003,
0.6555179953575134,
0.2615407407283783,
-0.42759931087493896,
0.17722615599632263,
-0.35798195004463196,
-0.9804705381393433,
1.1552048921585083,
0.2157953679561615,
-0.7275404334068298,
0.0785028412938118,
0.04492275044322014,
0.6339693665504456,
-0.4554438591003418,
-0.011785922572016716,
0.28239530324935913,
0.3579370081424713,
0.2651745080947876,
-0.9360102415084839,
0.1862887591123581,
-0.012537360191345215,
0.0742332860827446,
0.047611791640520096,
-0.6822555661201477,
0.6080667972564697,
-0.40691930055618286,
-0.3710519075393677,
0.1887555569410324,
0.8960139751434326,
0.07786776125431061,
0.3282981514930725,
0.2805759608745575,
0.6091078519821167,
0.5425225496292114,
-0.1709143966436386,
1.1965900659561157,
-0.4017656445503235,
0.3631184995174408,
1.133191704750061,
-0.3117518424987793,
0.4367588460445404,
0.5159792304039001,
0.4064212143421173,
0.5372971892356873,
0.3124851882457733,
-0.4473685622215271,
0.6757397651672363,
0.07498381286859512,
0.04694855213165283,
-0.37844550609588623,
-0.3966231644153595,
-0.7029234170913696,
0.7306929230690002,
0.10081077367067337,
-0.6071764826774597,
-0.4028354287147522,
0.11773707717657089,
-0.1354880928993225,
0.01615329459309578,
-0.4464549422264099,
0.8137800693511963,
-0.04277373477816582,
-0.6011010408401489,
0.7366366386413574,
0.02178250066936016,
0.5992185473442078,
-0.8147314190864563,
0.09030438214540482,
-0.06118503212928772,
0.2630719542503357,
-0.42016512155532837,
-0.7035245299339294,
0.6447992324829102,
-0.16126523911952972,
0.009720142930746078,
-0.3866303265094757,
1.1431010961532593,
-0.5174839496612549,
-0.5524494051933289,
0.18100997805595398,
0.44459807872772217,
0.1400095671415329,
0.007291597779840231,
-0.7224532961845398,
0.40242454409599304,
0.21808665990829468,
-0.14735645055770874,
0.25098657608032227,
0.1739199012517929,
0.08834279328584671,
0.8490796685218811,
0.4032438099384308,
0.1419926881790161,
-0.2051788568496704,
0.29932230710983276,
0.9637871980667114,
-0.5468451976776123,
-0.298589289188385,
-0.6658926606178284,
0.44955340027809143,
-0.16382449865341187,
-0.3650962710380554,
0.7684109210968018,
0.8217356204986572,
0.6377386450767517,
-0.018066298216581345,
0.8805195689201355,
-0.05421758070588112,
0.4315887689590454,
-0.6403093934059143,
0.9917104244232178,
-0.913051962852478,
-0.009012584574520588,
0.042124249041080475,
-0.36845794320106506,
-0.4393538236618042,
0.6181194186210632,
0.03307819738984108,
-0.18464668095111847,
0.6511755585670471,
0.9108631610870361,
0.17192727327346802,
-0.4706018567085266,
0.5548750162124634,
0.3807481825351715,
0.21019718050956726,
0.18562470376491547,
0.8095396757125854,
-0.5446454882621765,
0.7412381768226624,
-0.21234279870986938,
0.012227221392095089,
-0.37079325318336487,
-0.7394008040428162,
-0.5603899359703064,
-0.4655994772911072,
-0.6453443169593811,
-0.6508829593658447,
-0.08357218652963638,
0.37297123670578003,
0.8584553599357605,
-0.3103107213973999,
-0.11759884655475616,
0.11391735821962357,
-0.316524475812912,
-0.10837492346763611,
-0.24708174169063568,
0.3431681990623474,
-0.5234243273735046,
-0.2661550045013428,
0.38289541006088257,
0.7440935373306274,
0.010774522088468075,
-0.6655806303024292,
-0.13127167522907257,
0.37919023633003235,
-0.27725309133529663,
0.5205994844436646,
0.376025527715683,
-0.9362905621528625,
-0.25523579120635986,
-0.016660107299685478,
-0.5382954478263855,
0.308708131313324,
0.81919264793396,
-1.0857993364334106,
0.8010213375091553,
0.2705041766166687,
0.28121456503868103,
0.668716549873352,
-0.2759783864021301,
0.5456169843673706,
-0.4840971529483795,
0.05863717570900917,
0.34526997804641724,
0.32030120491981506,
0.3915117084980011,
-0.3958538770675659,
0.5010949969291687,
0.2654944062232971,
-0.4668441712856293,
-0.9148756861686707,
0.2789909243583679,
-1.119377851486206,
-0.5679458379745483,
1.0617070198059082,
0.20556288957595825,
-0.23595868051052094,
-0.09050790965557098,
-0.5237454771995544,
0.11859656870365143,
-0.06557843834161758,
0.7579579949378967,
0.06057163327932358,
-0.31799471378326416,
-0.5296468734741211,
-0.1017003208398819,
0.6434005498886108,
0.40570148825645447,
-0.7867498993873596,
0.11339467018842697,
0.6520553827285767,
0.41217806935310364,
0.04276259243488312,
0.9320955276489258,
-0.2759491205215454,
0.532921314239502,
-0.025393687188625336,
0.371417760848999,
-0.47576090693473816,
-0.34083324670791626,
-0.29360538721084595,
0.18076173961162567,
0.0741102546453476,
0.17800796031951904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17897v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17897v1
|
Tool Calling: Enhancing Medication Consultation via Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models
| 2024-04-27T13:11:42 | 2024-04-27T13:11:42 |
Zhongzhen Huang, Kui Xue, Yongqi Fan, Linjie Mu, Ruoyu Liu, Tong Ruan, Shaoting Zhang, Xiaofan Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large-scale language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success across
various language tasks but suffer from hallucinations and temporal
misalignment. To mitigate these shortcomings, Retrieval-augmented generation
(RAG) has been utilized to provide external knowledge to facilitate the answer
generation. However, applying such models to the medical domain faces several
challenges due to the lack of domain-specific knowledge and the intricacy of
real-world scenarios. In this study, we explore LLMs with RAG framework for
knowledge-intensive tasks in the medical field. To evaluate the capabilities of
LLMs, we introduce MedicineQA, a multi-round dialogue benchmark that simulates
the real-world medication consultation scenario and requires LLMs to answer
with retrieved evidence from the medicine database. MedicineQA contains 300
multi-round question-answering pairs, each embedded within a detailed dialogue
history, highlighting the challenge posed by this knowledge-intensive task to
current LLMs. We further propose a new \textit{Distill-Retrieve-Read} framework
instead of the previous \textit{Retrieve-then-Read}. Specifically, the
distillation and retrieval process utilizes a tool calling mechanism to
formulate search queries that emulate the keyword-based inquiries used by
search engines. With experimental results, we show that our framework brings
notable performance improvements and surpasses the previous counterparts in the
evidence retrieval process in terms of evidence retrieval accuracy. This
advancement sheds light on applying RAG to the medical domain.
|
[
-0.06724043190479279,
-0.8260664343833923,
0.9981452822685242,
-0.018525492399930954,
-0.2344980090856552,
0.25511065125465393,
-0.022042466327548027,
-0.4829762578010559,
0.22883464395999908,
0.8186486959457397,
-0.3909846544265747,
-0.38193070888519287,
-0.5877559185028076,
0.23748846352100372,
-0.3482668697834015,
0.6629646420478821,
0.024793796241283417,
0.5828796029090881,
-0.3740644156932831,
-0.03310513496398926,
-0.4614833891391754,
-0.6054765582084656,
-0.7728955745697021,
-0.38638371229171753,
0.6870077848434448,
0.12464530766010284,
0.5285474061965942,
0.3387961983680725,
0.6698057651519775,
0.3687250018119812,
-0.16158916056156158,
0.45714524388313293,
-0.23349058628082275,
0.4153529405593872,
-0.21498478949069977,
-0.7830939888954163,
-0.5104206204414368,
0.06953703612089157,
0.3323768079280853,
0.8382377028465271,
-0.48706406354904175,
0.1620892584323883,
-0.06086241826415062,
0.4101891815662384,
-0.575954794883728,
-0.0793987289071083,
-0.7922028303146362,
-0.10818358510732651,
-0.13696680963039398,
-0.25059181451797485,
-0.3924110531806946,
-0.12842944264411926,
0.355551540851593,
-0.6255175471305847,
0.2067885845899582,
0.3145711421966553,
0.8223222494125366,
0.3084133267402649,
-0.3190135359764099,
-0.45368924736976624,
-0.5498867630958557,
0.660511314868927,
-0.9192425012588501,
0.3113670349121094,
0.5483971834182739,
0.5431955456733704,
-0.5132017731666565,
-0.9566791653633118,
-0.540355384349823,
-0.2848206162452698,
-0.05777847021818161,
-0.04667653515934944,
0.053895048797130585,
0.07777964323759079,
0.4174611270427704,
0.5211430191993713,
-0.049393199384212494,
-0.08946109563112259,
-0.31826725602149963,
-0.04065942019224167,
0.19693516194820404,
0.3516407012939453,
0.15645259618759155,
-0.30204394459724426,
-0.32046830654144287,
0.04931845888495445,
-0.6279098391532898,
-0.24696990847587585,
-0.28136321902275085,
0.1660131812095642,
0.10639213770627975,
0.5840455293655396,
0.05281095206737518,
0.8183634281158447,
0.2003854513168335,
-0.58126300573349,
0.2436346709728241,
-0.12884506583213806,
-0.355851411819458,
-0.10761953890323639,
0.6202070116996765,
0.5439738035202026,
-0.2317860871553421,
-0.14037834107875824,
-0.11767319589853287,
-0.3250434100627899,
0.6200667023658752,
-0.8753310441970825,
-0.1622362583875656,
0.3297586739063263,
-0.32258176803588867,
-0.23528411984443665,
-0.3543175160884857,
-0.711153507232666,
-0.8842750191688538,
-0.3857664465904236,
0.4546357989311218,
-0.4376690983772278,
-0.21346846222877502,
0.24825532734394073,
0.010142871178686619,
-0.03047356754541397,
0.5005949139595032,
-0.4545478820800781,
0.41368111968040466,
0.6607927083969116,
0.8507317900657654,
-0.25716668367385864,
0.2568085193634033,
-0.8254510164260864,
0.08278145641088486,
-0.3601061701774597,
0.8514163494110107,
-0.4692559540271759,
-0.6163733601570129,
-0.009554274380207062,
0.14634324610233307,
0.135684996843338,
-1.1194806098937988,
0.48025253415107727,
-0.432071715593338,
0.4519781470298767,
-0.3225935995578766,
-0.5191200971603394,
-0.07667932659387589,
0.5156886577606201,
-0.5430049896240234,
1.0680153369903564,
0.3143138587474823,
-0.6008683443069458,
0.5236915946006775,
-0.529569685459137,
-0.17795847356319427,
0.2967674136161804,
-0.3178204596042633,
-0.32277581095695496,
0.0640963613986969,
0.2516929507255554,
0.3962755501270294,
-0.8091150522232056,
0.3585807979106903,
-0.2628535032272339,
-0.15812648832798004,
0.307263046503067,
-0.3086264431476593,
0.600040078163147,
0.234584778547287,
-0.15249137580394745,
-0.04054467752575874,
-0.6184875965118408,
-0.004638228099793196,
0.006684277672320604,
-0.40123677253723145,
-0.6391703486442566,
-0.258773535490036,
-0.13956233859062195,
0.2655947208404541,
0.07221690565347672,
-0.595766544342041,
0.30387088656425476,
-0.768181324005127,
0.06543411314487457,
0.41430947184562683,
0.18597133457660675,
0.1295677274465561,
-0.47032421827316284,
0.5908772945404053,
0.1448156088590622,
0.22299572825431824,
-0.011381469666957855,
-0.37751907110214233,
-0.540763258934021,
-0.39076077938079834,
0.5196343660354614,
0.4998382329940796,
-1.2125288248062134,
0.045913051813840866,
-0.19448532164096832,
-0.39570245146751404,
-0.8659769296646118,
0.15500865876674652,
0.4254981279373169,
0.8724772334098816,
0.49584388732910156,
-0.29628634452819824,
-0.33580464124679565,
-0.7991250157356262,
-0.22445525228977203,
-0.07130741328001022,
-0.21684224903583527,
0.6823593378067017,
0.0837075263261795,
-0.3701478838920593,
0.6064525246620178,
-0.6162060499191284,
-0.3639061748981476,
-0.2018139660358429,
-0.01264586579054594,
0.5067822933197021,
0.008466199040412903,
0.2486434131860733,
-0.8184146285057068,
-0.40952742099761963,
-0.11541935801506042,
-0.5113885402679443,
-0.45414239168167114,
0.036253537982702255,
-0.25378888845443726,
0.10484499484300613,
0.5291064381599426,
-0.4582560956478119,
0.260644793510437,
0.45398592948913574,
-0.08160558342933655,
0.4521646499633789,
-0.28831419348716736,
0.36561739444732666,
-1.5734845399856567,
0.33548736572265625,
-0.14956030249595642,
-0.26412835717201233,
-0.5738582015037537,
-0.09756463766098022,
-0.056363530457019806,
0.07943997532129288,
-0.6247345209121704,
0.8183276057243347,
-0.532177746295929,
0.15064473450183868,
-0.386894553899765,
0.16298562288284302,
0.17339447140693665,
0.12413075566291809,
-0.1904795914888382,
0.8806646466255188,
0.3692169189453125,
-0.5494167804718018,
0.5340450406074524,
0.3427218496799469,
-0.17467179894447327,
0.9258368015289307,
-0.4803566038608551,
-0.05346233770251274,
0.11477381736040115,
0.1901547908782959,
-0.6441341638565063,
-0.2626204192638397,
0.17457091808319092,
-0.15650060772895813,
0.491045206785202,
-0.315097451210022,
-0.7361341118812561,
-0.41746005415916443,
-0.08759937435388565,
0.302303671836853,
0.37354776263237,
-0.4056815803050995,
0.7196581363677979,
0.5903527140617371,
-0.4353576600551605,
-0.5544902086257935,
-0.21742402017116547,
0.2762582004070282,
-0.17860721051692963,
-0.08643827587366104,
0.17361363768577576,
0.07500986009836197,
-0.352926105260849,
-0.19533370435237885,
-0.2039690762758255,
0.009753095917403698,
-0.1605834662914276,
0.3750004470348358,
0.6408424973487854,
-0.0026164911687374115,
0.5048327445983887,
0.038942452520132065,
-0.0011902531841769814,
0.25013968348503113,
-0.08134721219539642,
0.5406935811042786,
0.332724392414093,
-0.6151356101036072,
0.11436675488948822,
0.46488383412361145,
0.6576804518699646,
-0.10477720946073532,
0.5738188028335571,
0.3908010721206665,
-0.37827610969543457,
-0.08198890089988708,
-0.9780111908912659,
-0.3960142731666565,
-0.5239697694778442,
0.2577296793460846,
-0.3525143563747406,
-0.6674600839614868,
0.24655890464782715,
-0.7607223391532898,
0.24277687072753906,
0.2588275671005249,
0.801258385181427,
-0.057059675455093384,
0.9530701041221619,
0.21844147145748138,
0.1347004771232605,
0.16817127168178558,
-0.12424316257238388,
0.17119470238685608,
-1.1824268102645874,
-0.2995336949825287,
-0.27212345600128174,
-0.117365263402462,
-0.21367132663726807,
-0.8721895217895508,
0.9713566899299622,
0.09716098755598068,
0.048416875302791595,
-0.04982449486851692,
-0.6684669256210327,
0.14862282574176788,
0.5245330333709717,
0.26989230513572693,
0.4166480302810669,
0.04042861610651016,
-0.6367866396903992,
-0.1539224237203598,
-0.7712978720664978,
-0.4108191728591919,
1.1770288944244385,
0.07728130370378494,
0.834723174571991,
-0.07068007439374924,
0.537058413028717,
-0.009093125350773335,
0.5960299968719482,
-0.9301846623420715,
0.6604404449462891,
-0.11630378663539886,
-0.5210712552070618,
0.021430032327771187,
-0.38523879647254944,
-1.077986717224121,
0.338045209646225,
-0.4256298243999481,
-0.5852769017219543,
-0.12103267759084702,
-0.01639222539961338,
-0.4749063551425934,
0.4237585663795471,
-0.547913134098053,
0.4087875187397003,
-0.2802116870880127,
-0.3827175199985504,
-0.06979095190763474,
-0.6808477640151978,
0.1507725715637207,
-0.25017213821411133,
0.3199560344219208,
-0.05383317545056343,
-0.08827033638954163,
0.5332855582237244,
-0.603355884552002,
0.7662317752838135,
-0.1381635218858719,
-0.3891018033027649,
0.11982140690088272,
0.019838828593492508,
0.3929508328437805,
-0.0028535816818475723,
-0.02553684078156948,
-0.2703646719455719,
0.4657215476036072,
-0.13242842257022858,
-0.7530773878097534,
0.628633439540863,
-0.3162297010421753,
-0.931864857673645,
-0.4377853572368622,
-0.6241143941879272,
-0.6534065008163452,
0.3558505177497864,
0.01309990044683218,
0.7481783032417297,
0.0349181666970253,
-0.07068534195423126,
0.6270302534103394,
-0.3875837028026581,
-0.182405024766922,
0.8244943022727966,
-0.53380286693573,
-0.2786678969860077,
0.6732279062271118,
0.041610199958086014,
0.33728158473968506,
0.19593584537506104,
0.11835325509309769,
-0.5288310647010803,
-0.3599691390991211,
-0.5849067568778992,
0.4589552581310272,
-0.5670243501663208,
-0.4219720959663391,
-0.9829450845718384,
-0.23628263175487518,
-0.34623703360557556,
0.2683390974998474,
-0.18970806896686554,
-0.10349170118570328,
-0.08661655336618423,
0.19301053881645203,
0.6167100667953491,
0.641149640083313,
0.12080372124910355,
-0.011894367635250092,
-1.1168299913406372,
0.5837134718894958,
0.10670357197523117,
0.4517153203487396,
-0.0816333070397377,
-0.3418753147125244,
-0.3783799409866333,
0.054602157324552536,
-0.40265825390815735,
-1.0003842115402222,
0.3656838834285736,
-0.12857508659362793,
0.6272249817848206,
0.12057822197675705,
0.2748018205165863,
0.8752142190933228,
-0.8148470520973206,
0.6158526539802551,
0.04510392248630524,
-0.4072999060153961,
0.404510498046875,
-0.15569433569908142,
0.3330969512462616,
0.593429684638977,
0.3250345289707184,
-0.6606549024581909,
-0.5782984495162964,
-0.5302942395210266,
-1.0202651023864746,
0.4017777740955353,
-0.27369317412376404,
-0.042357172816991806,
-0.004100330173969269,
0.4453361928462982,
0.033731311559677124,
0.32462289929389954,
0.010344233363866806,
-0.08378937840461731,
0.5153236985206604,
-0.12203183770179749,
0.2074350118637085,
-0.20654194056987762,
-0.5453143119812012,
-0.25553810596466064,
0.5320057272911072,
-0.1753252148628235,
0.2606569528579712,
0.4757954180240631,
0.1825333535671234,
-0.15502451360225677,
0.552557647228241,
0.22562186419963837,
0.6279810070991516,
-0.00955966766923666,
-0.009710795246064663,
0.5262652039527893,
-0.8397900462150574,
0.12011992186307907,
0.3591432273387909,
0.1962759792804718,
0.1934380978345871,
0.1126083955168724,
0.3938561677932739,
0.22938530147075653,
-0.9984915256500244,
0.3566586375236511,
0.00031415445846505463,
-0.13658548891544342,
-0.23277509212493896,
0.026646966114640236,
0.06633685529232025,
0.36703771352767944,
0.46767255663871765,
-0.25769826769828796,
0.48397356271743774,
-0.4472266733646393,
0.30909037590026855,
0.489502876996994,
-0.3516979515552521,
0.2040097415447235,
0.5768262147903442,
0.08887991309165955,
-0.28969326615333557,
0.3441675007343292,
0.11305657774209976,
-0.4180751144886017,
0.09068389981985092,
0.40143927931785583,
0.46227526664733887,
-0.10676134377717972,
0.03014170378446579,
0.13945958018302917,
-0.27377864718437195,
-0.22316645085811615,
0.3476561903953552,
0.19631324708461761,
-0.25705137848854065,
-0.6583127975463867,
-0.6642709374427795,
-0.6861653923988342,
0.24963417649269104,
-0.7703918814659119,
0.15259923040866852,
-0.19110600650310516,
-0.5650765895843506,
0.018282011151313782,
0.0826241672039032,
-0.42034590244293213,
0.1492854505777359,
-0.26799869537353516,
0.9383394718170166,
-0.18344227969646454,
0.6801773905754089,
0.8742026686668396,
0.03412181884050369,
-1.0492222309112549,
-0.07207219302654266,
0.2961465120315552,
-0.6033435463905334,
0.47839662432670593,
-0.05858461186289787,
-0.249740332365036,
-0.27927127480506897,
-0.40794381499290466,
-0.43353161215782166,
1.1229125261306763,
0.25374579429626465,
-0.5674735903739929,
-0.2783734202384949,
0.06876752525568008,
0.6835392117500305,
-0.2825741171836853,
0.1693097949028015,
0.5745541453361511,
0.1354205310344696,
0.303876131772995,
-1.3941121101379395,
0.27577027678489685,
-0.4239746928215027,
-0.1606452763080597,
0.38206005096435547,
-0.20110024511814117,
0.6642717123031616,
-0.2682873606681824,
-0.23834984004497528,
0.2567421495914459,
0.02047054097056389,
0.4989984929561615,
0.1334926337003708,
0.5630678534507751,
0.5239617824554443,
0.6875946521759033,
-0.011081505566835403,
1.1537067890167236,
-0.3129933178424835,
-0.03649914264678955,
1.2016489505767822,
-0.5014779567718506,
0.9651677012443542,
0.718442976474762,
-0.21640723943710327,
0.34224236011505127,
0.29715147614479065,
0.030225034803152084,
0.3035510778427124,
0.32124438881874084,
-0.5624117851257324,
-0.249084010720253,
-0.3751274049282074,
-0.3988180458545685,
0.11364875733852386,
0.6138647198677063,
-0.4983120858669281,
-0.2854015827178955,
0.06955167651176453,
0.0515424944460392,
0.13594497740268707,
-0.07785486429929733,
1.1885825395584106,
0.32005974650382996,
-0.655851423740387,
0.7507204413414001,
-0.21607743203639984,
0.4496685862541199,
-0.4590310752391815,
-0.5450151562690735,
0.057859666645526886,
0.23184682428836823,
0.009754638187587261,
-0.6686501502990723,
0.0679745301604271,
-0.03067040629684925,
-0.03646751120686531,
0.042449600994586945,
0.6635285019874573,
-0.4563550353050232,
-0.5609367489814758,
0.19081948697566986,
0.8461177349090576,
0.24751245975494385,
0.03503289073705673,
-0.8705635666847229,
-0.08019880950450897,
-0.30576154589653015,
0.008594712242484093,
0.42651626467704773,
0.6618537902832031,
-0.045381657779216766,
0.8117415904998779,
0.7904601693153381,
0.5644176006317139,
-0.09822830557823181,
0.1612752228975296,
1.1200499534606934,
-0.30789992213249207,
-0.1427122950553894,
-0.5670132040977478,
0.25832027196884155,
-0.33360573649406433,
-0.02999972365796566,
0.6210363507270813,
0.5885970592498779,
0.35230961441993713,
0.06968867778778076,
0.5478290319442749,
0.12207458168268204,
1.285253882408142,
-0.5047243237495422,
0.8099418878555298,
-0.776185154914856,
0.48795759677886963,
-0.2393377721309662,
-0.5279481410980225,
-0.2699185013771057,
0.27002960443496704,
-0.4854891300201416,
0.0008837386849336326,
0.563265323638916,
0.8603292107582092,
0.026981059461832047,
-0.3145407736301422,
0.338387131690979,
0.32605135440826416,
0.304953932762146,
0.462019145488739,
0.6842978000640869,
-0.32555338740348816,
0.422218382358551,
0.06557072699069977,
-0.1829361468553543,
-0.18546798825263977,
-0.4327193796634674,
-0.9112402200698853,
-0.6070287823677063,
0.11519141495227814,
-0.6694257855415344,
0.11297046393156052,
1.1553593873977661,
0.6891801357269287,
-0.5694248676300049,
0.037695031613111496,
0.3526826500892639,
-0.20733919739723206,
0.0410175621509552,
-0.22606945037841797,
0.2825595736503601,
-0.35434556007385254,
-0.730889618396759,
0.3131162226200104,
0.38693055510520935,
0.0780295729637146,
-0.3375217020511627,
0.22240597009658813,
-0.29372096061706543,
0.05375785753130913,
0.5628473162651062,
-0.027107106521725655,
-0.8406993746757507,
0.1251973658800125,
0.2631017863750458,
-0.3475106358528137,
0.19551417231559753,
0.9321883916854858,
-0.9798781275749207,
0.7188807129859924,
0.014441339299082756,
0.8167619705200195,
0.3966810405254364,
0.13762806355953217,
0.8519824147224426,
-0.5719041228294373,
-0.024551590904593468,
0.4107755422592163,
0.25586381554603577,
0.3982381820678711,
-0.48976457118988037,
0.4514962434768677,
-0.08364793658256531,
-0.46620750427246094,
-0.9235454797744751,
0.17784447968006134,
-0.7441852688789368,
-0.3124714195728302,
1.1163291931152344,
-0.17782559990882874,
-0.15219801664352417,
-0.5205254554748535,
-0.8243440985679626,
0.08955631405115128,
-0.302286833524704,
0.904554009437561,
0.57965487241745,
-0.13353271782398224,
-0.23182255029678345,
-0.9288079738616943,
0.7006164789199829,
0.4286307990550995,
-0.9443985223770142,
0.018551979213953018,
0.5244253277778625,
0.37505242228507996,
0.3998402953147888,
0.7261696457862854,
-0.4538176655769348,
0.1538524627685547,
-0.17745353281497955,
-0.26764753460884094,
0.09174586832523346,
0.029433373361825943,
0.0299440436065197,
0.014234760776162148,
0.21544690430164337,
0.015656908974051476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17877v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17877v1
|
PromptCL: Improving Event Representation via Prompt Template and Contrastive Learning
| 2024-04-27T12:22:43 | 2024-04-27T12:22:43 |
Yubo Feng, Lishuang Li, Yi Xiang, Xueyang Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The representation of events in text plays a significant role in various NLP
tasks. Recent research demonstrates that contrastive learning has the ability
to improve event comprehension capabilities of Pre-trained Language Models
(PLMs) and enhance the performance of event representation learning. However,
the efficacy of event representation learning based on contrastive learning and
PLMs is limited by the short length of event texts. The length of event texts
differs significantly from the text length used in the pre-training of PLMs. As
a result, there is inconsistency in the distribution of text length between
pre-training and event representation learning, which may undermine the
learning process of event representation based on PLMs. In this study, we
present PromptCL, a novel framework for event representation learning that
effectively elicits the capabilities of PLMs to comprehensively capture the
semantics of short event texts. PromptCL utilizes a Prompt template borrowed
from prompt learning to expand the input text during Contrastive Learning. This
helps in enhancing the event representation learning by providing a structured
outline of the event components. Moreover, we propose Subject-Predicate-Object
(SPO) word order and Event-oriented Masked Language Modeling (EventMLM) to
train PLMs to understand the relationships between event components. Our
experimental results demonstrate that PromptCL outperforms state-of-the-art
baselines on event related tasks. Additionally, we conduct a thorough analysis
and demonstrate that using a prompt results in improved generalization
capabilities for event representations. Our code will be available at
https://github.com/YuboFeng2023/PromptCL.
|
[
-0.4324689209461212,
-0.2593896687030792,
0.6685712933540344,
0.2224348783493042,
-0.626690685749054,
0.05078205466270447,
-0.5061869025230408,
-0.36587411165237427,
0.12913796305656433,
0.18712425231933594,
-0.5900975465774536,
-0.7894092798233032,
-0.5134621262550354,
0.43647873401641846,
0.1182861328125,
1.045008659362793,
0.07244908064603806,
0.06306557357311249,
-0.22678060829639435,
-0.29133298993110657,
-0.6294065117835999,
-0.6593373417854309,
-0.8163450360298157,
-0.24727864563465118,
0.5075944662094116,
0.3002469539642334,
0.31833502650260925,
0.4211544990539551,
0.15853674709796906,
0.17140164971351624,
-0.24618208408355713,
0.14962045848369598,
-0.41220614314079285,
0.24062977731227875,
-0.18553923070430756,
-0.40856122970581055,
-0.16730107367038727,
0.09947691857814789,
0.5868901014328003,
0.7374690771102905,
0.059057146310806274,
-0.1683472990989685,
0.28448686003685,
0.334019273519516,
-0.5060749650001526,
0.32707393169403076,
-0.5218430161476135,
0.10191541910171509,
-0.34023046493530273,
-0.4043269455432892,
-0.667802631855011,
0.06926422566175461,
0.16496187448501587,
-0.8184191584587097,
0.3441773056983948,
0.3345640301704407,
0.5469537973403931,
0.17495587468147278,
-0.3224957585334778,
-0.5775743126869202,
-0.24816343188285828,
0.8509424328804016,
-0.3808338940143585,
0.3755992650985718,
0.1979406327009201,
0.32714614272117615,
0.0657486841082573,
-0.8275318145751953,
-0.5714923739433289,
-0.41308653354644775,
-0.2718430757522583,
0.081704281270504,
0.08472239226102829,
0.2500874996185303,
0.42121413350105286,
-0.017266392707824707,
-0.8183498382568359,
0.2075159102678299,
-0.10428538173437119,
-0.17609025537967682,
0.35058295726776123,
0.5315189957618713,
0.36695176362991333,
-0.2874050438404083,
-0.5320756435394287,
-0.14818572998046875,
-0.6410841345787048,
0.17165258526802063,
0.19522319734096527,
0.4686130881309509,
-0.1932028979063034,
0.0853658989071846,
-0.06109440326690674,
0.6068004965782166,
0.06100241094827652,
-0.006332960911095142,
0.3074846863746643,
-0.5172722339630127,
0.024124229326844215,
0.24630886316299438,
0.5580120086669922,
0.4281942546367645,
-0.17294098436832428,
-0.015212948434054852,
-0.04409962147474289,
-0.037449199706315994,
-0.2517285645008087,
-0.8945403695106506,
-0.2787056267261505,
0.07272518426179886,
-0.5371037721633911,
0.026151474565267563,
0.18001556396484375,
-0.8261343240737915,
-0.5864903926849365,
-0.3415568172931671,
0.22077089548110962,
-0.47880369424819946,
0.14621463418006897,
0.2761005759239197,
-0.18201780319213867,
0.253776490688324,
0.6785255670547485,
-0.4873324930667877,
0.24835479259490967,
0.45315390825271606,
0.7440264225006104,
-0.488638311624527,
-0.20892077684402466,
-1.0778292417526245,
0.02059503085911274,
-0.1328309327363968,
0.619572639465332,
-0.6496102809906006,
-0.4920938014984131,
0.1452617645263672,
-0.08333980292081833,
-0.0069149574264883995,
-0.3349190950393677,
0.6408032178878784,
-0.6862393617630005,
0.6357840895652771,
-0.052821043878793716,
-0.7185473442077637,
-0.0773240253329277,
0.16782036423683167,
-0.6412236094474792,
0.6472969055175781,
-0.3337695002555847,
-0.964807391166687,
0.1581110954284668,
-0.4827456772327423,
-0.21863481402397156,
0.3069165050983429,
-0.45548251271247864,
-0.3542422354221344,
-0.03425682708621025,
0.5712887644767761,
0.5292996168136597,
-0.10926350951194763,
0.2510721981525421,
-0.02731703594326973,
-0.3862500488758087,
0.135776087641716,
-0.08913905173540115,
0.6692636609077454,
0.1047244668006897,
-0.19225770235061646,
0.4279606342315674,
-1.0248138904571533,
-0.39551401138305664,
0.03478585183620453,
-0.16458366811275482,
-0.3991173505783081,
-0.09429215639829636,
-0.03490437939763069,
0.33140623569488525,
0.34379222989082336,
-0.2962937355041504,
0.03187722712755203,
-0.6892439126968384,
-0.06700342893600464,
0.5186293125152588,
0.2670917212963104,
0.7587562203407288,
-0.14478163421154022,
0.7152830958366394,
0.1988525688648224,
-0.12247973680496216,
-1.0935291051864624,
-0.43780696392059326,
-0.5756239295005798,
-0.11358007043600082,
0.1840103566646576,
0.5251186490058899,
-1.3134690523147583,
0.37791934609413147,
0.06719700992107391,
-0.03301331773400307,
-0.19888724386692047,
-0.00775266345590353,
0.3543907403945923,
0.7866511344909668,
0.6197764277458191,
-0.08858908712863922,
-0.7992205619812012,
-0.4061395823955536,
-0.24279466271400452,
-0.203354150056839,
-0.27563995122909546,
-0.011640990152955055,
0.1519499123096466,
-0.045381247997283936,
0.9400950074195862,
-0.37952858209609985,
-0.3581699728965759,
-0.6817896366119385,
0.31046390533447266,
0.35911664366722107,
0.6035630106925964,
0.6552084684371948,
-0.7524614334106445,
-0.4469158947467804,
-0.1951923370361328,
-0.2748108506202698,
-0.41061073541641235,
-0.34937581419944763,
0.17120066285133362,
0.21892094612121582,
0.5502439737319946,
-0.1789383739233017,
0.5168527364730835,
0.1766379475593567,
-0.6859742999076843,
0.7348169088363647,
-0.21656255424022675,
-0.029025955125689507,
-0.8901777863502502,
0.03132251277565956,
-0.22716088593006134,
-0.5200659036636353,
-0.6970601081848145,
-0.24536684155464172,
0.1157640889286995,
-0.3678878843784332,
-0.6956396698951721,
0.8248952031135559,
-0.46196097135543823,
0.14072899520397186,
-0.5030456781387329,
0.45204561948776245,
0.26463213562965393,
0.544014573097229,
0.28096652030944824,
0.7856475710868835,
0.5381667613983154,
-0.7390213012695312,
0.12585881352424622,
0.4216068685054779,
-0.18182651698589325,
0.5584534406661987,
-0.5511658191680908,
-0.0808725357055664,
-0.3711510896682739,
0.336487740278244,
-0.85935378074646,
-0.007795547600835562,
0.39962276816368103,
-0.46175795793533325,
0.4324038028717041,
0.10133421421051025,
-0.5721607208251953,
0.02224167063832283,
-0.4123347997665405,
0.3875279128551483,
0.6669692397117615,
-0.7181382775306702,
0.6045714020729065,
-0.08476072549819946,
-0.24026572704315186,
-0.483709454536438,
-0.34647810459136963,
-0.04947645589709282,
-0.2248680740594864,
-0.32711657881736755,
0.4519621729850769,
-0.16669490933418274,
-0.0046235788613557816,
-0.13797630369663239,
-0.06639206409454346,
0.15089912712574005,
-0.0791512057185173,
0.021844176575541496,
0.08867105096578598,
-0.15826481580734253,
0.46688148379325867,
0.025140084326267242,
-0.39584705233573914,
-0.017095953226089478,
-0.2728458344936371,
0.7695503234863281,
-0.022270187735557556,
-0.27242323756217957,
-0.6944709420204163,
0.478365421295166,
-0.017521968111395836,
-0.21526187658309937,
0.780404806137085,
0.5662243962287903,
-0.23422445356845856,
-0.40897825360298157,
-0.3035455346107483,
-0.3437992334365845,
-0.44086673855781555,
0.3082138001918793,
-0.3127315640449524,
-0.9573177099227905,
0.7989646196365356,
-0.10471249371767044,
-0.18224979937076569,
0.43259674310684204,
0.19941027462482452,
-0.0758100152015686,
0.938398540019989,
0.7089741826057434,
0.3959830403327942,
0.6854599118232727,
0.16229534149169922,
-0.2635016441345215,
-0.7719239592552185,
-0.3204145133495331,
-0.5767306685447693,
0.001326850731857121,
-0.10523369908332825,
-0.7482376098632812,
0.15468181669712067,
0.27297547459602356,
-0.33928364515304565,
0.07191449403762817,
-0.20702992379665375,
0.5307869911193848,
0.3860622048377991,
0.01979079097509384,
0.26174458861351013,
-0.2358906865119934,
-0.34615805745124817,
-0.4924587309360504,
-0.8418915867805481,
-0.6012377738952637,
0.5019767880439758,
0.19756203889846802,
0.3762558102607727,
-0.4077773690223694,
0.8591213226318359,
0.16584935784339905,
0.009376490488648415,
-0.3152397572994232,
0.5468168258666992,
-0.05944828689098358,
-0.12682639062404633,
-0.07735039293766022,
-0.3327644467353821,
-0.8799881339073181,
0.3036627769470215,
-0.15070529282093048,
-0.654803454875946,
0.47067809104919434,
0.01942327618598938,
-0.2329919934272766,
0.17131996154785156,
-0.34465256333351135,
0.88542240858078,
-0.1330251842737198,
-0.18154603242874146,
0.013906723819673061,
-0.9251615405082703,
0.04625935107469559,
0.16877809166908264,
0.09085327386856079,
-0.12243089824914932,
-0.3754196763038635,
1.0553076267242432,
-0.26187074184417725,
1.1790224313735962,
-0.10603204369544983,
0.12742498517036438,
0.3629536032676697,
0.08479264378547668,
0.6290739178657532,
0.441731721162796,
-0.1047610193490982,
-0.1851521134376526,
-0.30318647623062134,
-0.4167686104774475,
-0.7138012051582336,
0.38198763132095337,
-0.5638008117675781,
-0.5501260757446289,
-0.41314396262168884,
-0.19436292350292206,
-0.08913484960794449,
0.026767900213599205,
0.3543379306793213,
0.7092486619949341,
-0.3060181140899658,
-0.037548650056123734,
0.8267285823822021,
-0.5609884262084961,
0.5833184719085693,
0.5265920758247375,
-0.2692438066005707,
-0.6266645789146423,
0.7845984697341919,
-0.3221597671508789,
-0.08071712404489517,
0.6511847972869873,
-0.017990540713071823,
-0.4369685649871826,
-0.6127768754959106,
-0.17235365509986877,
0.3112330734729767,
-1.0960956811904907,
-0.3398313522338867,
-0.8612641096115112,
0.24584877490997314,
-0.2669205069541931,
-0.5351147651672363,
0.05279375612735748,
-0.4535100758075714,
-0.9895697236061096,
-0.18003354966640472,
0.049089908599853516,
0.3805283308029175,
-0.018738623708486557,
0.5139631628990173,
-0.665482223033905,
0.17588408291339874,
0.07580678164958954,
0.06920356303453445,
-0.020503787323832512,
-0.557662308216095,
0.1336001306772232,
-0.5578592419624329,
-0.19307591021060944,
-1.088122844696045,
0.5100934505462646,
0.33372068405151367,
0.6795236468315125,
0.5864822268486023,
0.4611513912677765,
0.49093934893608093,
-0.6770577430725098,
0.9767618179321289,
0.6417391896247864,
-1.2193646430969238,
0.9778710603713989,
-0.1052631139755249,
0.40754780173301697,
0.6249659657478333,
0.44613751769065857,
-0.6300140619277954,
-0.3954369127750397,
-0.8464200496673584,
-0.85948246717453,
0.9050167202949524,
0.20852123200893402,
-0.019845683127641678,
-0.1651996523141861,
0.3744151294231415,
0.47604548931121826,
0.38311767578125,
-0.8006957173347473,
-0.29637131094932556,
-0.3098287582397461,
-0.38719311356544495,
-0.36192765831947327,
-0.5692480206489563,
0.15028268098831177,
0.1293351948261261,
0.48273181915283203,
-0.19577033817768097,
0.030502907931804657,
0.30101314187049866,
-0.2792918384075165,
0.49898412823677063,
0.36611637473106384,
0.6997855305671692,
0.6498271822929382,
-0.03433847427368164,
0.6042062640190125,
0.4644240736961365,
-0.22767823934555054,
0.019005851820111275,
0.3111207187175751,
0.024532852694392204,
0.4246758222579956,
0.7961586117744446,
0.8891615271568298,
0.418425977230072,
-0.9672017693519592,
0.7198219895362854,
-0.1351110190153122,
0.3084736764431,
0.0603901632130146,
-0.06669475138187408,
-0.04220246896147728,
0.19998061656951904,
0.4735875725746155,
-0.26632142066955566,
0.2170877754688263,
-0.25176113843917847,
0.4962100684642792,
-0.12981729209423065,
-0.5501344203948975,
-0.5025219321250916,
0.6596384644508362,
0.5545923709869385,
-0.1615389734506607,
0.2683126926422119,
-0.5761452913284302,
-0.7345166802406311,
0.6082613468170166,
0.6598888635635376,
0.5686323642730713,
-0.2597919702529907,
0.223707377910614,
0.4217320382595062,
0.21654465794563293,
0.25161463022232056,
0.2815294861793518,
-0.32859158515930176,
-0.3683478832244873,
-0.49894264340400696,
-0.6178620457649231,
-0.33954375982284546,
-0.12501883506774902,
-0.5099733471870422,
0.4173133373260498,
-0.32492128014564514,
0.14208590984344482,
-0.602367639541626,
0.35946282744407654,
-0.8776381015777588,
-0.036616548895835876,
0.29304468631744385,
1.051656723022461,
-0.8027521967887878,
0.5771061182022095,
0.9335852265357971,
-0.4591880440711975,
-0.47686514258384705,
-0.049754511564970016,
-0.23468953371047974,
-0.35325074195861816,
0.9818851351737976,
0.49915972352027893,
0.33501824736595154,
0.011412364430725574,
-0.32667821645736694,
-0.5346358418464661,
0.8608525991439819,
0.25520482659339905,
-0.6719140410423279,
0.057889871299266815,
-0.054862361401319504,
0.5422341227531433,
-0.7876552939414978,
0.20240144431591034,
0.08471975475549698,
0.2384188026189804,
0.14142784476280212,
-0.6020740866661072,
0.25163260102272034,
0.08358146250247955,
0.3032304644584656,
-0.1180000975728035,
-0.0078659038990736,
0.596104621887207,
-0.11686071008443832,
-0.6942878365516663,
0.1308855563402176,
1.0682518482208252,
0.5821103453636169,
0.8275130391120911,
0.2926975190639496,
0.20989452302455902,
0.9865223169326782,
-0.11919760704040527,
1.0262372493743896,
-0.08442533016204834,
0.17347456514835358,
1.3135164976119995,
-0.4529832899570465,
0.4955962300300598,
0.35325682163238525,
0.2003401517868042,
0.4159582257270813,
0.5608062744140625,
0.34087127447128296,
0.6820428967475891,
0.2319379597902298,
-0.35618776082992554,
-0.4534766674041748,
-0.20713651180267334,
-0.37105855345726013,
-0.08611073344945908,
0.5095937252044678,
-0.25959378480911255,
-0.6256664991378784,
0.7421877384185791,
-0.11532056331634521,
0.4473502039909363,
-0.5387251973152161,
0.8838038444519043,
0.19894690811634064,
-0.19886527955532074,
0.21810577809810638,
-0.09247492253780365,
0.6800287961959839,
-0.5939878821372986,
-0.07228286564350128,
-0.14873580634593964,
-0.1008794978260994,
0.18817590177059174,
-0.6058774590492249,
0.16898156702518463,
-0.16000643372535706,
-0.13186439871788025,
-0.2486644983291626,
0.8739562630653381,
-0.5252173542976379,
-0.07784603536128998,
0.2744804322719574,
0.43982231616973877,
0.032392468303442,
0.10759766399860382,
-0.5460862517356873,
0.48540282249450684,
-0.15831229090690613,
-0.08385493606328964,
0.19562305510044098,
0.7119960784912109,
0.017340414226055145,
0.3315589129924774,
0.2901638448238373,
-0.01054475549608469,
0.006739654578268528,
0.044422611594200134,
0.8640803694725037,
-0.7445154190063477,
-1.0786762237548828,
-0.7459311485290527,
0.4735076427459717,
-0.31467902660369873,
-0.34785887598991394,
0.5771786570549011,
0.3794521987438202,
0.7970743179321289,
-0.2014264166355133,
0.45499885082244873,
0.29793158173561096,
0.4883729815483093,
-0.7426349520683289,
0.2655947208404541,
-0.14939402043819427,
0.29582440853118896,
0.06703450530767441,
-0.7671570181846619,
-0.767100989818573,
0.40433868765830994,
-0.36429956555366516,
-0.2794491946697235,
0.772395670413971,
0.32966238260269165,
0.1900555044412613,
-0.05149538442492485,
0.5668603181838989,
-0.07853606343269348,
0.4752714931964874,
0.6923432946205139,
1.1441391706466675,
-0.22496724128723145,
0.5586683750152588,
0.062210213392972946,
-0.18336883187294006,
-0.5156672596931458,
-1.0977615118026733,
-1.2397366762161255,
-0.9128063321113586,
-0.5259361863136292,
-0.0811222717165947,
0.31888383626937866,
1.239180088043213,
0.46058380603790283,
-0.7669114470481873,
0.22803480923175812,
-0.06899399310350418,
0.2941538691520691,
-0.04406476020812988,
-0.21604113280773163,
0.6865197420120239,
-1.1003315448760986,
-0.7147153615951538,
0.4585508406162262,
0.2875770330429077,
0.22045592963695526,
0.29758861660957336,
-0.19615553319454193,
0.10945327579975128,
-0.05661000683903694,
0.665949821472168,
0.2741923928260803,
-0.6394827961921692,
-0.1728879064321518,
-0.23676824569702148,
-0.19362321496009827,
0.09287998825311661,
0.9762414693832397,
-1.1757179498672485,
0.354028582572937,
0.7012903094291687,
0.714504599571228,
0.23829704523086548,
-0.11829554289579391,
0.5884254574775696,
-1.2430263757705688,
0.4940139055252075,
0.5667513608932495,
0.4522935450077057,
0.38486000895500183,
-0.31673526763916016,
0.14442262053489685,
0.17718656361103058,
-0.25722455978393555,
-0.7502335906028748,
0.5457802414894104,
-1.238439917564392,
-0.47329846024513245,
0.9608858227729797,
-0.1351216733455658,
-0.08370687812566757,
-0.18078970909118652,
-0.517233669757843,
0.2890814542770386,
-0.4247201681137085,
0.4061547517776489,
0.44080373644828796,
-0.1973515748977661,
-0.35659289360046387,
-0.1448856145143509,
0.8569392561912537,
0.29754480719566345,
-0.5878650546073914,
-0.0480596162378788,
0.4408012926578522,
-0.17370016872882843,
0.37081775069236755,
0.6012281179428101,
-0.006337212398648262,
0.42146241664886475,
-0.38333746790885925,
0.06143719702959061,
-0.308994859457016,
-0.4690302312374115,
-0.8241055011749268,
0.5691165328025818,
-0.2658137083053589,
-0.1613219529390335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17874v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17874v1
|
From Languages to Geographies: Towards Evaluating Cultural Bias in Hate Speech Datasets
| 2024-04-27T12:10:10 | 2024-04-27T12:10:10 |
Manuel Tonneau, Diyi Liu, Samuel Fraiberger, Ralph Schroeder, Scott A. Hale, Paul Röttger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Perceptions of hate can vary greatly across cultural contexts. Hate speech
(HS) datasets, however, have traditionally been developed by language. This
hides potential cultural biases, as one language may be spoken in different
countries home to different cultures. In this work, we evaluate cultural bias
in HS datasets by leveraging two interrelated cultural proxies: language and
geography. We conduct a systematic survey of HS datasets in eight languages and
confirm past findings on their English-language bias, but also show that this
bias has been steadily decreasing in the past few years. For three
geographically-widespread languages -- English, Arabic and Spanish -- we then
leverage geographical metadata from tweets to approximate geo-cultural contexts
by pairing language and country information. We find that HS datasets for these
languages exhibit a strong geo-cultural bias, largely overrepresenting a
handful of countries (e.g., US and UK for English) relative to their prominence
in both the broader social media population and the general population speaking
these languages. Based on these findings, we formulate recommendations for the
creation of future HS datasets.
|
[
-0.6008912920951843,
-0.5542935729026794,
0.40887776017189026,
0.08475185185670853,
0.062039099633693695,
0.35465776920318604,
-0.5490322709083557,
-0.5931028127670288,
0.5189279317855835,
0.43533629179000854,
-0.5950753688812256,
-0.6760568618774414,
-0.8871980905532837,
-0.23063978552818298,
-0.13002470135688782,
1.2279177904129028,
0.07700347900390625,
0.29250648617744446,
0.2073824554681778,
-0.6134713292121887,
-0.0433487668633461,
-0.5523779392242432,
-0.11269154399633408,
-0.21230889856815338,
0.6771880984306335,
0.3518499732017517,
0.9217784404754639,
0.4220452606678009,
0.4335813820362091,
0.03281492739915848,
-0.15677277743816376,
-0.2818238139152527,
-0.7462602853775024,
0.26863452792167664,
-0.32165810465812683,
-0.03461923077702522,
0.2463712841272354,
0.12736380100250244,
0.3231556713581085,
0.634942889213562,
0.1636650413274765,
0.5152946710586548,
-0.06693970412015915,
0.30763858556747437,
-0.6358557343482971,
-0.22048190236091614,
-0.5633822679519653,
0.1889212727546692,
-0.5736687183380127,
-0.038000158965587616,
0.11792449653148651,
-0.6920180320739746,
0.4397490322589874,
-0.3463659882545471,
0.35877877473831177,
0.003165772883221507,
0.510858952999115,
0.12788529694080353,
-0.5007434487342834,
-0.46339040994644165,
-0.9259157776832581,
0.9838495850563049,
-0.20388619601726532,
0.4926036596298218,
0.6239084005355835,
0.30486947298049927,
0.08108602464199066,
-0.062421973794698715,
-0.24944911897182465,
-0.29208558797836304,
-0.03829284384846687,
0.03387867286801338,
-0.4797506630420685,
-0.3742966949939728,
0.4514807164669037,
0.08729948848485947,
-0.6541966795921326,
0.14975634217262268,
-0.6691551804542542,
-0.30518838763237,
0.6800797581672668,
-0.10028300434350967,
0.7412624955177307,
-0.22257868945598602,
-0.024736763909459114,
0.1340799778699875,
-0.9467637538909912,
-0.17970727384090424,
0.762673020362854,
0.5948519110679626,
-0.2140384316444397,
0.4180985689163208,
-0.041749753057956696,
0.4041177034378052,
-0.4191403388977051,
-0.14049625396728516,
0.2767530381679535,
0.2442876249551773,
0.07574833184480667,
-0.03803228214383125,
0.7733862400054932,
0.6582630276679993,
0.7056167721748352,
-0.2999783456325531,
0.32050907611846924,
0.3289702832698822,
0.1544051617383957,
-0.5994849801063538,
-0.10069316625595093,
-0.004508890677243471,
-0.2860458791255951,
-0.1575399488210678,
-0.32997292280197144,
-1.125140905380249,
-0.9647080302238464,
0.02122320979833603,
-0.18137158453464508,
-0.2612134516239166,
-0.22405461966991425,
-0.4804219901561737,
-0.30110669136047363,
-0.17265097796916962,
-0.04100808501243591,
-0.6200261116027832,
0.01807721145451069,
0.30653852224349976,
0.6571617722511292,
0.008901731111109257,
-0.5200004577636719,
-0.27553898096084595,
-0.07179322093725204,
-0.3616335690021515,
0.6535207629203796,
-0.7343250513076782,
-0.33973029255867004,
0.27592816948890686,
-0.2983769476413727,
0.5116298198699951,
-0.6679300665855408,
0.63060462474823,
-0.4811166226863861,
0.23622070252895355,
-0.6343507170677185,
0.1025741696357727,
-0.2149178832769394,
0.13936173915863037,
-0.6431877613067627,
1.1335978507995605,
0.24433863162994385,
-0.8605170845985413,
0.8112784028053284,
-0.39509427547454834,
-0.6592304110527039,
-0.0075017791241407394,
-0.25072532892227173,
-0.23392066359519958,
-0.02528815157711506,
0.3428272604942322,
0.05518469586968422,
-0.5431255102157593,
0.26151540875434875,
-0.6684311628341675,
-0.3527470529079437,
-0.18391971290111542,
-0.05402344465255737,
1.0574511289596558,
0.5990331768989563,
-0.6763161420822144,
-0.3111285865306854,
-0.5499051809310913,
-0.3265993893146515,
0.1838839203119278,
-0.07624676823616028,
-0.6569356918334961,
0.3723990321159363,
0.18617478013038635,
0.22926881909370422,
-0.12322880327701569,
-0.7851220369338989,
-0.24560080468654633,
-0.17322953045368195,
0.30302929878234863,
0.5725048184394836,
-0.21934154629707336,
0.4342845380306244,
-0.22595223784446716,
0.5770242810249329,
0.002623398555442691,
0.09007971733808517,
0.5333170890808105,
-0.3987187147140503,
-0.14703647792339325,
0.2370702028274536,
-0.424336314201355,
0.4671633839607239,
-0.5260528326034546,
-0.0410507470369339,
-0.2347756028175354,
-0.7219824194908142,
-0.4848618805408478,
0.012089020572602749,
0.17819945514202118,
0.36531931161880493,
0.39547470211982727,
-0.11179819703102112,
-1.0620521306991577,
-0.9933390617370605,
-0.5850749611854553,
-0.38546738028526306,
-0.16746361553668976,
0.530682384967804,
0.12675495445728302,
0.0011844795662909746,
0.9997215867042542,
-0.4112866222858429,
-0.11801722645759583,
-0.15806762874126434,
0.160124272108078,
-0.17314092814922333,
-0.019773181527853012,
0.9531018733978271,
-0.5832038521766663,
-0.691269040107727,
-0.1264648139476776,
-0.5879454016685486,
-0.4273914694786072,
0.46230772137641907,
-0.28948867321014404,
0.24282315373420715,
0.04685283079743385,
0.3015744686126709,
0.6153417229652405,
0.9132856130599976,
-0.5529022216796875,
0.2638154625892639,
0.7295005917549133,
0.4147604703903198,
-0.9302079081535339,
-0.14191900193691254,
0.3468989431858063,
0.22278381884098053,
-0.6949975490570068,
-0.2082887440919876,
-0.5428698658943176,
-0.05442119762301445,
-0.38533514738082886,
0.5329675674438477,
-0.20536915957927704,
-0.11922188103199005,
0.03192063421010971,
0.07627420872449875,
-0.47199296951293945,
-0.015880346298217773,
0.174796462059021,
0.4487169682979584,
0.5547440648078918,
-0.10601254552602768,
0.32132241129875183,
-0.0165272019803524,
-0.8418638110160828,
0.651272714138031,
-0.09515916556119919,
-0.015396871604025364,
-0.41644009947776794,
0.3911210000514984,
-0.6803282499313354,
-0.16165052354335785,
0.23877058923244476,
-0.330329954624176,
-0.5828590393066406,
-0.6034517288208008,
-0.21032221615314484,
-0.6916323900222778,
-0.1968279927968979,
0.3707132637500763,
0.47116395831108093,
-0.4183974862098694,
0.3391711413860321,
0.9595323204994202,
-0.08104045689105988,
-0.6875423192977905,
-1.012351632118225,
0.22679297626018524,
-0.7483144402503967,
-0.4202272891998291,
-0.06465104222297668,
-0.11104133725166321,
-0.8664054870605469,
-0.01787465438246727,
0.09656181931495667,
-0.30082929134368896,
0.00027450305060483515,
0.47682228684425354,
-0.27893728017807007,
0.0444529727101326,
-0.11558353900909424,
-0.22979295253753662,
0.41519469022750854,
0.16420982778072357,
-0.587106466293335,
0.5356385707855225,
0.17224107682704926,
-0.040868207812309265,
0.16211296617984772,
0.4743354320526123,
0.6425880789756775,
-0.01839645393192768,
0.6736530661582947,
0.7347338199615479,
-0.424457311630249,
-0.23926419019699097,
-0.6165671944618225,
-0.04980168119072914,
-0.28673091530799866,
0.17596088349819183,
-0.03758040815591812,
-0.9838403463363647,
0.7296539545059204,
0.36943545937538147,
0.032506246119737625,
0.2724829316139221,
0.717329204082489,
-0.14531241357326508,
0.5448603630065918,
0.43796083331108093,
-0.6234399080276489,
0.5292424559593201,
-0.006263538263738155,
0.5939630270004272,
-0.13218770921230316,
-0.09545507282018661,
-0.7776423692703247,
-0.2730230391025543,
-0.8961784243583679,
-0.27103036642074585,
0.5692490935325623,
-0.40161123871803284,
-0.5077584385871887,
0.20865994691848755,
-0.11704744398593903,
0.6681496500968933,
0.5520297884941101,
-0.18281634151935577,
-0.17444130778312683,
0.6936491131782532,
0.007579687982797623,
-0.6235364079475403,
-0.56351637840271,
-0.2927148640155792,
0.8723707795143127,
0.23514243960380554,
0.5376492142677307,
0.22765983641147614,
0.278045654296875,
0.5184186100959778,
0.5722759366035461,
-0.6754730939865112,
0.12627339363098145,
-0.38358640670776367,
-0.7851840853691101,
-0.1977648138999939,
-0.2915750741958618,
-0.6404911279678345,
0.09291878342628479,
-0.034773070365190506,
-0.7385401725769043,
0.019849875941872597,
0.05578448995947838,
-0.27005743980407715,
0.654470682144165,
-0.4143817722797394,
0.4585164189338684,
-0.0792512446641922,
-0.4350232183933258,
-0.10550929605960846,
-0.537566602230072,
0.23543646931648254,
0.06872336566448212,
0.8937718272209167,
-0.39394310116767883,
0.5508609414100647,
0.8946486115455627,
-0.27996334433555603,
0.701968789100647,
-0.3480567932128906,
-0.3018834590911865,
0.49530404806137085,
0.25587737560272217,
0.053132861852645874,
-0.3924679756164551,
-0.5352272391319275,
0.583800196647644,
-0.3582921624183655,
-0.4966474771499634,
-0.3269699513912201,
0.6914905905723572,
-0.9360424876213074,
-0.14918777346611023,
-0.10117188096046448,
-0.6332370638847351,
-0.2983532249927521,
0.11899617314338684,
0.34090450406074524,
0.41515016555786133,
-0.43710654973983765,
-0.20096749067306519,
0.29851850867271423,
-0.37844350934028625,
0.19796307384967804,
0.5287814140319824,
-0.29831013083457947,
-0.3584885001182556,
0.8388206958770752,
0.5762262344360352,
0.0009210138232447207,
-0.14347831904888153,
0.5461555123329163,
-0.225346177816391,
-0.3134481906890869,
-0.4691077768802643,
0.1337794065475464,
-0.5945938229560852,
0.12263036519289017,
-0.4575376808643341,
0.06581412255764008,
-0.6662483215332031,
-0.6106855273246765,
0.06100698187947273,
-0.06337292492389679,
0.4225774109363556,
-0.2061266154050827,
0.5512682795524597,
1.1249991655349731,
-0.4280005395412445,
0.37311190366744995,
-0.23111973702907562,
0.14890600740909576,
-0.10107879340648651,
0.5160514712333679,
-0.18600314855575562,
-0.6526283025741577,
-0.38277995586395264,
0.08771172910928726,
0.075130395591259,
-1.1041613817214966,
0.50364750623703,
-0.23766644299030304,
0.1982930600643158,
0.28548094630241394,
0.08067194372415543,
0.8612414598464966,
-0.7577438354492188,
1.0689142942428589,
-0.20173202455043793,
-0.5432870388031006,
0.7053914070129395,
-0.5821013450622559,
0.02541149966418743,
0.4055050313472748,
1.0564920902252197,
-1.0125527381896973,
-0.9395548701286316,
-0.652171790599823,
-0.7939892411231995,
0.5977911353111267,
-0.28747761249542236,
0.1505996733903885,
-0.12205809354782104,
-0.21790969371795654,
-0.004285285249352455,
0.002106833504512906,
-0.7589817643165588,
-0.5333783030509949,
-0.259990930557251,
0.02678970992565155,
-0.27376797795295715,
-0.5551210641860962,
-0.5903846621513367,
-0.17918865382671356,
0.4689512550830841,
0.12246493250131607,
-0.24988394975662231,
-0.11395624279975891,
-0.2719079852104187,
-0.4809717833995819,
0.3262268006801605,
0.35159534215927124,
0.8605028390884399,
-0.23635131120681763,
0.3296613097190857,
0.19978469610214233,
-0.6520757079124451,
0.09647556394338608,
-0.018785586580634117,
-0.4997504651546478,
0.1510881781578064,
0.20559658110141754,
0.6653291583061218,
-0.16009852290153503,
-0.435802161693573,
0.24616262316703796,
0.18209140002727509,
-0.05044901743531227,
-0.37833234667778015,
-0.5988326668739319,
-0.08379603922367096,
0.1869787573814392,
0.38375091552734375,
-0.22182978689670563,
0.11597885191440582,
-0.5609925389289856,
0.21964022517204285,
0.19928832352161407,
-0.4483160674571991,
-0.29138705134391785,
0.4951342046260834,
0.1052791103720665,
-0.14606916904449463,
0.5193070769309998,
-0.09142859280109406,
-0.7522534132003784,
0.4134388864040375,
0.4077289402484894,
0.6720539927482605,
-0.3938244879245758,
0.4399515986442566,
0.7134729027748108,
0.5905678868293762,
0.6040761470794678,
0.2072180211544037,
0.0904025286436081,
-0.9496310949325562,
-0.20969052612781525,
-0.7825433015823364,
-0.19014693796634674,
0.28162261843681335,
-0.616782009601593,
0.06895285099744797,
-0.44722092151641846,
-0.016216803342103958,
-0.0706712082028389,
0.1134759858250618,
-0.6834349632263184,
0.43446242809295654,
0.6136540174484253,
0.6438038349151611,
-1.4451229572296143,
0.463022381067276,
0.7572392821311951,
-0.12409629672765732,
-0.47283637523651123,
0.26350337266921997,
0.6648284196853638,
-0.8901129364967346,
0.8423619866371155,
-0.030886661261320114,
-0.1717553585767746,
-0.2937732934951782,
-0.6089553833007812,
-0.9840691089630127,
0.3425098657608032,
0.1190001592040062,
-0.24541358649730682,
0.5137803554534912,
0.4864846467971802,
0.7016289234161377,
-0.25984618067741394,
0.3084040880203247,
0.830852210521698,
0.44624409079551697,
-0.0717337504029274,
-0.8353534936904907,
-0.09577897191047668,
0.11455394327640533,
-0.14510242640972137,
0.1514957696199417,
-0.6436209082603455,
0.45079749822616577,
-0.09198065102100372,
-0.2248746007680893,
-0.6757407784461975,
0.3996204435825348,
0.08639834076166153,
0.24204429984092712,
0.5560629367828369,
0.4586679935455322,
0.6926437616348267,
-0.2269560843706131,
0.9315755367279053,
-0.30074769258499146,
0.15319572389125824,
1.086748719215393,
-0.4085566997528076,
0.4864521622657776,
0.20341648161411285,
-0.2727363109588623,
0.5557028651237488,
0.5192516446113586,
0.0737355574965477,
0.4043954610824585,
0.5928544402122498,
-0.4615212082862854,
0.21292275190353394,
-0.8405070900917053,
-0.10465910285711288,
0.6859186291694641,
0.445077508687973,
-0.14614754915237427,
-0.7209231853485107,
0.17006248235702515,
0.7108154892921448,
0.22264674305915833,
-0.4034537672996521,
0.30997323989868164,
-0.3031389117240906,
-0.580470085144043,
0.33868539333343506,
-0.1494351029396057,
0.7281426787376404,
-0.4342381954193115,
0.3404311537742615,
-0.3901708722114563,
-0.35042569041252136,
-0.436437726020813,
-0.9202747941017151,
0.8333852291107178,
0.6094139814376831,
-0.394514799118042,
-0.29750409722328186,
0.4304289221763611,
-0.7000214457511902,
-0.1596345454454422,
0.6095960140228271,
0.30024170875549316,
0.5254203677177429,
0.052843887358903885,
-0.47170501947402954,
0.4366283714771271,
0.22158940136432648,
-0.03813591226935387,
0.14128747582435608,
0.1388482004404068,
-0.37273380160331726,
0.5152822732925415,
0.4168015420436859,
0.5762577652931213,
0.20986898243427277,
0.40102675557136536,
0.5776081681251526,
-0.5527976751327515,
-0.217955082654953,
-0.8820693492889404,
0.2350110411643982,
0.05897122249007225,
-0.2642236649990082,
1.0276910066604614,
0.4839569926261902,
1.229896068572998,
0.3370342552661896,
1.3174141645431519,
-0.4825845956802368,
0.8477297425270081,
-0.06716899573802948,
0.8723487854003906,
-0.40386858582496643,
-0.15856462717056274,
-0.4265134036540985,
-0.7042388916015625,
-0.4257104992866516,
0.6484362483024597,
-0.8902327418327332,
0.02103375643491745,
0.4592705965042114,
0.8010042309761047,
0.13427282869815826,
0.07376861572265625,
0.24947409331798553,
0.4789694547653198,
0.3543945252895355,
0.24798323214054108,
0.8192898035049438,
-0.15685497224330902,
0.39986109733581543,
-0.5607751607894897,
-0.2755095958709717,
0.1612166464328766,
-0.8596174716949463,
-0.5689479112625122,
-0.5807431936264038,
-0.06312470883131027,
-0.7895880341529846,
0.09900546818971634,
0.8302231431007385,
0.556298553943634,
-0.9068275690078735,
-0.4872192442417145,
0.7237874269485474,
0.3579499423503876,
0.2993096709251404,
-0.2826027572154999,
0.14205144345760345,
0.14540880918502808,
-0.902508020401001,
0.32742568850517273,
0.12045172601938248,
-0.14782895147800446,
-0.28227072954177856,
0.12721900641918182,
0.10742070525884628,
-0.05159418657422066,
0.8129469156265259,
0.4843497574329376,
-0.7141066789627075,
-0.3876543343067169,
-0.30459436774253845,
-0.0411052368581295,
-0.14320281147956848,
1.006904125213623,
-0.529801070690155,
0.2592352032661438,
0.2758162319660187,
0.3375603258609772,
-0.015482036396861076,
-0.09181033074855804,
0.4425037205219269,
-0.7512742877006531,
0.37797194719314575,
0.2333051562309265,
0.18578171730041504,
0.49651142954826355,
-0.10937657207250595,
0.5436789989471436,
0.3309163749217987,
-0.5591883659362793,
-0.8143913149833679,
0.392713725566864,
-0.4076631963253021,
-0.12763433158397675,
1.4337966442108154,
0.18119460344314575,
-0.005481349304318428,
-0.26959502696990967,
0.21043702960014343,
0.05300181731581688,
-0.2877042889595032,
0.892540454864502,
0.9274600148200989,
0.2780744433403015,
0.22506563365459442,
-0.7383531928062439,
0.6901257038116455,
0.37983980774879456,
-0.41183334589004517,
0.09382030367851257,
1.0370699167251587,
0.521000862121582,
0.2900663912296295,
0.6895796656608582,
-0.03402290120720863,
-0.017359033226966858,
-0.10662617534399033,
0.2681019902229309,
0.5513121485710144,
-0.4022166132926941,
-0.27393174171447754,
0.12458546459674835,
-0.10746610164642334,
0.31315338611602783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17862v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17862v2
|
Revisiting Multimodal Emotion Recognition in Conversation from the Perspective of Graph Spectrum
| 2024-04-27T10:47:07 | 2024-05-03T02:16:38 |
Tao Meng, Fuchen Zhang, Yuntao Shou, Wei Ai, Nan Yin, Keqin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Efficiently capturing consistent and complementary semantic features in a
multimodal conversation context is crucial for Multimodal Emotion Recognition
in Conversation (MERC). Existing methods mainly use graph structures to model
dialogue context semantic dependencies and employ Graph Neural Networks (GNN)
to capture multimodal semantic features for emotion recognition. However, these
methods are limited by some inherent characteristics of GNN, such as
over-smoothing and low-pass filtering, resulting in the inability to learn
long-distance consistency information and complementary information
efficiently. Since consistency and complementarity information correspond to
low-frequency and high-frequency information, respectively, this paper revisits
the problem of multimodal emotion recognition in conversation from the
perspective of the graph spectrum. Specifically, we propose a
Graph-Spectrum-based Multimodal Consistency and Complementary collaborative
learning framework GS-MCC. First, GS-MCC uses a sliding window to construct a
multimodal interaction graph to model conversational relationships and uses
efficient Fourier graph operators to extract long-distance high-frequency and
low-frequency information, respectively. Then, GS-MCC uses contrastive learning
to construct self-supervised signals that reflect complementarity and
consistent semantic collaboration with high and low-frequency signals, thereby
improving the ability of high and low-frequency information to reflect real
emotions. Finally, GS-MCC inputs the collaborative high and low-frequency
information into the MLP network and softmax function for emotion prediction.
Extensive experiments have proven the superiority of the GS-MCC architecture
proposed in this paper on two benchmark data sets.
|
[
-0.6914125680923462,
-0.5467326641082764,
0.534101128578186,
-0.03421381115913391,
-0.057233087718486786,
0.09566917270421982,
-0.3121819496154785,
-0.547943651676178,
0.5974993705749512,
0.22429393231868744,
-0.815900981426239,
-0.5770311951637268,
-0.45211338996887207,
-0.05016094446182251,
0.09678220748901367,
0.84233558177948,
-0.03695732355117798,
-0.13646410405635834,
-0.2463359534740448,
-0.5778825283050537,
-0.13159723579883575,
-0.5198599100112915,
-0.284226655960083,
-0.38870105147361755,
0.8069688081741333,
0.4762777090072632,
0.6291401386260986,
-0.14772692322731018,
0.27690768241882324,
0.4994777739048004,
0.0797121673822403,
0.42983704805374146,
-0.6797853112220764,
0.2344803810119629,
0.4623688757419586,
0.2085072100162506,
-0.4364883303642273,
0.1503271609544754,
0.22182993590831757,
0.38196471333503723,
-0.13305851817131042,
-0.19781124591827393,
0.04684250056743622,
0.7568228244781494,
-0.5748845338821411,
0.7234812378883362,
-0.47287097573280334,
0.36811283230781555,
0.016365397721529007,
-0.1764853447675705,
-0.5802086591720581,
-0.29951223731040955,
0.0662146806716919,
-0.4856022298336029,
-0.15169072151184082,
0.028984982520341873,
0.7269137501716614,
-0.06549709290266037,
-1.0442811250686646,
-0.4595440626144409,
-0.411670982837677,
0.4646630883216858,
-0.4532528817653656,
0.5873726606369019,
0.37999626994132996,
0.4194951057434082,
-0.09407723695039749,
-0.5806217193603516,
-0.7950405478477478,
-0.2550342381000519,
-0.09960266947746277,
0.6388415694236755,
-0.45959019660949707,
0.466304212808609,
0.16059331595897675,
0.23048853874206543,
-0.48908931016921997,
-0.2501838803291321,
-0.10715609788894653,
-0.4669617712497711,
0.31484612822532654,
0.32681939005851746,
0.042301636189222336,
-0.45425349473953247,
-0.37742671370506287,
-0.32967260479927063,
-0.09949295967817307,
0.406497985124588,
0.3840479850769043,
0.2793091833591461,
-0.35889771580696106,
0.25469717383384705,
-0.26564347743988037,
0.25623562932014465,
0.13806138932704926,
-0.028258904814720154,
0.8021919131278992,
-0.2650951147079468,
-0.12129806727170944,
-0.16249790787696838,
0.9877516031265259,
0.5186870098114014,
0.0667606070637703,
-0.05719698593020439,
0.3733538091182709,
0.48429492115974426,
0.21234135329723358,
-0.6423728466033936,
-0.2881871163845062,
0.2880583703517914,
-0.40763118863105774,
0.08518725633621216,
-0.13073472678661346,
-1.116197943687439,
-0.3056964874267578,
-0.4117622971534729,
-0.05977444350719452,
-0.38255077600479126,
-0.2975904643535614,
-0.2482338398694992,
0.11481636762619019,
-0.3225806951522827,
0.386450856924057,
-0.7745960354804993,
0.26744139194488525,
0.35926762223243713,
0.5754694938659668,
0.1705072969198227,
-0.07401750981807709,
-0.34838882088661194,
-0.025153156369924545,
0.09106430411338806,
0.41418027877807617,
-0.6225130558013916,
-0.4549555778503418,
0.004471398424357176,
0.19577449560165405,
-0.1499546468257904,
-0.03653666004538536,
0.47426605224609375,
-0.4142957627773285,
0.31800326704978943,
-0.21230874955654144,
-0.22545471787452698,
-0.2396974116563797,
0.4834301471710205,
-0.524100124835968,
0.7044767141342163,
0.058135490864515305,
-0.8143812417984009,
-0.007465098053216934,
-0.44326427578926086,
-0.260582834482193,
-0.16552847623825073,
-0.010885870084166527,
-0.6970667243003845,
-0.030512942001223564,
-0.014584408141672611,
0.3106408715248108,
0.16485050320625305,
0.0345274955034256,
-1.0029726028442383,
-0.12863916158676147,
0.40749549865722656,
-0.44340524077415466,
0.27032607793807983,
0.4973714053630829,
-0.06923670321702957,
0.19030453264713287,
-0.8441084623336792,
0.26242008805274963,
-0.2706972062587738,
-0.0776166245341301,
-0.0007551583112217486,
-0.12300997972488403,
-0.2019702047109604,
0.6277837753295898,
0.04419942945241928,
-0.8409051895141602,
-0.15958043932914734,
0.1471989005804062,
0.38647350668907166,
0.809884250164032,
-0.14813749492168427,
0.3066599667072296,
0.04205786809325218,
0.38911890983581543,
0.22522249817848206,
0.16891422867774963,
-0.2373335361480713,
-0.2990773618221283,
-0.6865038871765137,
-0.4114266037940979,
-0.2703627645969391,
0.4077146649360657,
-0.7509511113166809,
0.37923896312713623,
-0.016472168266773224,
-0.3993471562862396,
-0.44312772154808044,
0.05588116496801376,
0.48450908064842224,
0.8440878987312317,
0.3992660641670227,
-0.6719210743904114,
-0.6254435181617737,
-0.6110442280769348,
0.3230888247489929,
-0.27779674530029297,
0.37455153465270996,
1.2446439266204834,
-0.014734234660863876,
-0.516043484210968,
0.9308900833129883,
-0.4598340690135956,
-0.2385672777891159,
0.1260731965303421,
0.6826721429824829,
0.010592871345579624,
0.3681129813194275,
0.28925999999046326,
-0.8065985441207886,
-0.4995000660419464,
0.023055212572216988,
-0.9285898208618164,
-0.03345327824354172,
0.3977901041507721,
-0.2707574665546417,
0.2599043548107147,
0.2535262107849121,
-0.489270955324173,
0.23489557206630707,
0.8957539796829224,
-0.14602366089820862,
0.10629348456859589,
-0.2143387496471405,
0.4896731376647949,
-0.8690229654312134,
-0.16071471571922302,
0.17092731595039368,
-0.23909546434879303,
-0.6429133415222168,
-0.6199010610580444,
0.018760651350021362,
-0.25447916984558105,
-0.34614482522010803,
-0.021482354030013084,
-0.35087335109710693,
-0.13895966112613678,
-0.07619957625865936,
0.31929612159729004,
0.032888926565647125,
0.9819998741149902,
-0.0625988095998764,
0.3019044101238251,
0.23009565472602844,
-0.14675933122634888,
0.8200299143791199,
0.37754499912261963,
-0.0296382587403059,
0.9931853413581848,
-0.1289837658405304,
0.5540919899940491,
-0.30452457070350647,
0.846427321434021,
-1.4395794868469238,
-0.17960768938064575,
0.24485807120800018,
-0.3213989734649658,
0.21213790774345398,
-0.09932050108909607,
-0.06489615887403488,
-0.5026531219482422,
-0.20639871060848236,
0.3360138237476349,
0.4940800666809082,
-0.4114075303077698,
1.039069652557373,
0.30262309312820435,
-0.25476619601249695,
-0.5826177000999451,
-0.5252634882926941,
0.08035818487405777,
-0.0962732806801796,
-0.8965455889701843,
-0.17320799827575684,
-0.09316401183605194,
0.22094303369522095,
-0.19068589806556702,
0.13373243808746338,
0.11789654940366745,
-0.11754346638917923,
0.8347587585449219,
0.34276720881462097,
0.046743784099817276,
0.2738718092441559,
-0.23777586221694946,
-0.34801632165908813,
0.025555547326803207,
0.1540820300579071,
0.5972414016723633,
-0.5739876627922058,
-0.4021511971950531,
-0.5586026310920715,
0.36434313654899597,
0.4674277901649475,
-0.20691601932048798,
0.21927563846111298,
1.0875625610351562,
0.06564191728830338,
0.2610362768173218,
-0.49069875478744507,
-0.11905194073915482,
-0.5236871242523193,
0.44864019751548767,
-0.33089762926101685,
-1.0389125347137451,
0.6911200284957886,
-0.3210464417934418,
-0.5299022197723389,
0.24170243740081787,
0.5064194202423096,
-0.3704850673675537,
1.214290976524353,
0.2902956008911133,
-0.16848595440387726,
0.6799203753471375,
-0.040235284715890884,
0.1496242731809616,
-0.8475016951560974,
-0.25621646642684937,
-0.3437855839729309,
-0.49459168314933777,
-0.5654693841934204,
0.04978395625948906,
0.6045472025871277,
-0.3797374963760376,
-0.24587860703468323,
0.1548340916633606,
-0.08418631553649902,
0.16907624900341034,
0.23944687843322754,
0.5199670791625977,
0.023044081404805183,
0.022155290469527245,
-0.08094021677970886,
-0.20069146156311035,
-0.2880350649356842,
0.016862422227859497,
0.5721184611320496,
0.3519693911075592,
0.5747737288475037,
0.10452811419963837,
0.6456319689750671,
0.017250599339604378,
0.4469962418079376,
-0.5151209235191345,
0.6734780073165894,
-0.22417709231376648,
-0.19296155869960785,
-0.01677050068974495,
-0.861211895942688,
-0.7756901979446411,
0.1828325390815735,
-0.45273831486701965,
-0.9081361889839172,
0.2519075870513916,
0.2331494390964508,
0.056756697595119476,
0.019859857857227325,
-0.88185054063797,
0.9653233289718628,
0.05191049352288246,
-0.29232779145240784,
-0.29582446813583374,
-1.0771477222442627,
0.2754712700843811,
0.2576717436313629,
0.40596434473991394,
-0.3987208604812622,
0.6303033828735352,
0.3672075569629669,
-0.2180784046649933,
1.0240509510040283,
-0.2815331518650055,
0.013630681671202183,
0.28760063648223877,
0.13792335987091064,
0.5518717169761658,
-0.16724038124084473,
0.10240642726421356,
0.21528658270835876,
-0.4290059506893158,
-0.1632198840379715,
-0.5663312673568726,
0.610555112361908,
-0.7954309582710266,
-0.09113908559083939,
-0.04907261207699776,
-0.8514952659606934,
-0.6157403588294983,
-0.10273493081331253,
-0.057720694690942764,
0.6378494501113892,
-0.3153177797794342,
0.20628486573696136,
0.26478150486946106,
0.06597491353750229,
0.4491759240627289,
0.391431599855423,
0.007968408055603504,
-0.8595031499862671,
1.0882278680801392,
-0.11286884546279907,
0.46207907795906067,
0.007165548857301474,
0.17128121852874756,
-0.2618483006954193,
0.17953655123710632,
-0.20741993188858032,
-0.0007103342213667929,
-0.9888334274291992,
-0.24969889223575592,
-0.8116240501403809,
0.1797952651977539,
-0.41774776577949524,
-0.17469628155231476,
-0.16683384776115417,
-0.1403123289346695,
-0.12560562789440155,
0.003136751940473914,
0.35409078001976013,
0.3026443421840668,
-0.1402362734079361,
0.13420821726322174,
-0.9326032996177673,
0.3026866018772125,
0.5701851844787598,
0.24159124493598938,
-0.08713295310735703,
-0.07106562703847885,
-0.01279832050204277,
0.29152098298072815,
-0.41431301832199097,
-0.8170728087425232,
0.3669244945049286,
0.3488425612449646,
0.12602989375591278,
0.5565309524536133,
0.10583917796611786,
0.6926206350326538,
-0.23563484847545624,
0.5748173594474792,
0.6725454330444336,
-1.2360645532608032,
0.02066132239997387,
-0.21746419370174408,
0.12056589126586914,
0.5606588125228882,
0.34275585412979126,
-0.8839249014854431,
-0.25511935353279114,
-0.6186732649803162,
-0.710349440574646,
0.7677859663963318,
0.0022057497408241034,
0.27342426776885986,
-0.102086640894413,
-0.10789738595485687,
-0.24123160541057587,
0.42668312788009644,
-0.6609054803848267,
-0.001394647522829473,
-0.5835908651351929,
-0.8871184587478638,
-0.222812220454216,
-0.20839117467403412,
-0.3338896930217743,
0.07591261714696884,
0.24974092841148376,
-0.5806931257247925,
0.35477471351623535,
-0.023591605946421623,
-0.024440791457891464,
-0.2688625752925873,
0.3609717786312103,
0.46592584252357483,
-0.1578444540500641,
-0.4700433909893036,
0.40226805210113525,
0.3076257109642029,
-0.25050362944602966,
0.07925016433000565,
0.026178093627095222,
0.7257136702537537,
-0.19464991986751556,
0.20874252915382385,
1.0905122756958008,
0.3708714246749878,
-0.4116502106189728,
0.6756290793418884,
-0.0185630414634943,
-0.08555866777896881,
0.024630775675177574,
-0.30490607023239136,
0.14843608438968658,
0.5746755599975586,
-0.010116050019860268,
0.17676539719104767,
0.24675671756267548,
-0.82078617811203,
0.2724788784980774,
0.5217893719673157,
-0.7868077158927917,
-0.3156806230545044,
0.2609320878982544,
0.20927059650421143,
0.116332046687603,
0.7200509905815125,
-0.2801661491394043,
-0.8227052688598633,
0.5784294605255127,
0.38507044315338135,
0.7942545413970947,
-0.22675721347332,
0.379972368478775,
0.08456104248762131,
-0.3986426293849945,
0.28993093967437744,
0.41715317964553833,
-0.4127748906612396,
-0.8324670791625977,
-0.029973220080137253,
-0.07059080898761749,
-0.8446231484413147,
-0.7802903652191162,
-0.5336909890174866,
-0.03883630409836769,
-0.3899119198322296,
-0.4375706613063812,
-0.057152580469846725,
-0.13750126957893372,
-0.4100351929664612,
0.24109917879104614,
0.5208767056465149,
0.10856044292449951,
-0.7617336511611938,
0.7519453763961792,
0.035490114241838455,
-0.39680126309394836,
-0.7561360597610474,
-0.6380929946899414,
0.3668973743915558,
-0.8498825430870056,
0.6991221904754639,
0.2557464838027954,
-0.5283671617507935,
-0.2054712027311325,
-0.4390910267829895,
-0.5078077912330627,
1.307088017463684,
0.30956777930259705,
-0.393090158700943,
0.2555799186229706,
0.04639435559511185,
0.6877451539039612,
-0.5751791596412659,
0.6514854431152344,
-0.08176165819168091,
0.3367985486984253,
0.8443412780761719,
-0.8726130723953247,
-0.15632402896881104,
-0.3506619930267334,
-0.2649587094783783,
0.3587619960308075,
-0.8384523391723633,
0.9580631256103516,
0.022657452151179314,
-0.2348708212375641,
-0.34381893277168274,
0.6985937356948853,
0.021027041599154472,
0.7334194779396057,
0.7586519122123718,
0.5167198181152344,
0.8484371304512024,
-0.2875002920627594,
0.8176961541175842,
-0.4534418284893036,
0.6666218638420105,
0.7837720513343811,
-0.7571940422058105,
0.7778323888778687,
0.1189984604716301,
-0.11303456872701645,
0.8347288370132446,
0.358688622713089,
0.09064013510942459,
0.4250866174697876,
-0.0413244403898716,
-0.3697555661201477,
-0.22438329458236694,
-0.3500542938709259,
-0.3017120361328125,
0.4580453634262085,
0.17729069292545319,
-0.19625717401504517,
-0.24043920636177063,
0.25350266695022583,
0.2643210291862488,
-0.28270819783210754,
-0.2925027310848236,
0.9408658742904663,
0.09943519532680511,
-0.2678666114807129,
0.5265973806381226,
-0.5060397982597351,
0.5767223238945007,
-0.7904984951019287,
0.14210861921310425,
-0.02476518228650093,
0.21906150877475739,
-0.4734174311161041,
-0.6267246603965759,
0.14013327658176422,
-0.3364294469356537,
0.08200423419475555,
-0.1236174926161766,
0.7020620703697205,
-0.9407451152801514,
-0.07015031576156616,
0.5260604619979858,
0.06138982996344566,
-0.016141068190336227,
0.12098962068557739,
-0.5071092844009399,
0.3486274778842926,
-0.2798435688018799,
-0.10327106714248657,
0.21183864772319794,
0.5983603000640869,
0.4051658511161804,
0.4463431239128113,
0.5715143084526062,
-0.49076783657073975,
-0.2356800138950348,
0.27537408471107483,
0.9200429320335388,
-0.4383864998817444,
-0.6498160362243652,
-0.610317051410675,
0.47376126050949097,
-0.15842615067958832,
-0.1821960210800171,
0.6310221552848816,
0.09711197018623352,
0.32269859313964844,
0.17403358221054077,
0.312992125749588,
0.19421198964118958,
0.08247749507427216,
-0.49404385685920715,
0.2622773051261902,
-0.42601409554481506,
-0.38389715552330017,
-0.9664062261581421,
-0.6013782620429993,
-0.1378147304058075,
0.39852243661880493,
-0.16541476547718048,
0.22000588476657867,
0.64654940366745,
0.7028579115867615,
-0.038172606378793716,
0.557074248790741,
0.2489233762025833,
0.28595349192619324,
0.38738080859184265,
1.089608907699585,
0.756596565246582,
-0.13585519790649414,
0.6343739032745361,
-0.1907004714012146,
-0.11567382514476776,
-0.21946975588798523,
-0.9809587597846985,
-0.5176361799240112,
-0.6740455627441406,
-0.27728912234306335,
-0.8269039988517761,
-0.11681436747312546,
1.158092737197876,
0.6562302708625793,
-0.6351915001869202,
-0.12740552425384521,
0.26086974143981934,
-0.12378747761249542,
-0.04686371609568596,
-0.18470431864261627,
0.2041495144367218,
-0.24505096673965454,
-0.5482428073883057,
0.310837060213089,
0.5596871972084045,
0.10764254629611969,
-0.01645583286881447,
-0.4507806897163391,
0.043600697070360184,
0.0677572712302208,
0.547640323638916,
0.3230356276035309,
-0.3325025141239166,
-0.6404916048049927,
-0.20734192430973053,
-0.4095971882343292,
0.42933350801467896,
0.7073070406913757,
-0.5649884343147278,
0.7717035412788391,
0.2989555299282074,
0.5073822736740112,
0.8019827008247375,
-0.01940537989139557,
0.22738823294639587,
-0.8088328838348389,
0.2791900932788849,
-0.0558338388800621,
0.6701675653457642,
0.3672473132610321,
-0.2033848613500595,
0.31554850935935974,
0.47856464982032776,
-0.5299429893493652,
-0.36262351274490356,
0.609699010848999,
-1.6554518938064575,
0.27154290676116943,
0.8634074926376343,
-0.41790974140167236,
-0.16842587292194366,
-0.09637028723955154,
-0.5632467269897461,
0.21847178041934967,
-0.7076283693313599,
0.6211531162261963,
0.7679166793823242,
-0.36467239260673523,
-0.34963658452033997,
0.03574029728770256,
0.2070622593164444,
0.27753016352653503,
-0.8167117834091187,
0.20586751401424408,
0.9602881073951721,
-0.12422138452529907,
0.41476312279701233,
0.8235042691230774,
0.03754756972193718,
0.0446554571390152,
0.06560217589139938,
0.22720494866371155,
-0.2877950370311737,
-0.17504006624221802,
-0.2832726240158081,
0.6647776365280151,
-0.5898972749710083,
-0.02759367600083351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17858v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17858v2
|
Revisiting Multi-modal Emotion Learning with Broad State Space Models and Probability-guidance Fusion
| 2024-04-27T10:22:03 | 2024-05-03T02:28:10 |
Yuntao Shou, Tao Meng, Fuchen Zhang, Nan Yin, Keqin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multi-modal Emotion Recognition in Conversation (MERC) has received
considerable attention in various fields, e.g., human-computer interaction and
recommendation systems. Most existing works perform feature disentanglement and
fusion to extract emotional contextual information from multi-modal features
and emotion classification. After revisiting the characteristic of MERC, we
argue that long-range contextual semantic information should be extracted in
the feature disentanglement stage and the inter-modal semantic information
consistency should be maximized in the feature fusion stage. Inspired by recent
State Space Models (SSMs), Mamba can efficiently model long-distance
dependencies. Therefore, in this work, we fully consider the above insights to
further improve the performance of MERC. Specifically, on the one hand, in the
feature disentanglement stage, we propose a Broad Mamba, which does not rely on
a self-attention mechanism for sequence modeling, but uses state space models
to compress emotional representation, and utilizes broad learning systems to
explore the potential data distribution in broad space. Different from previous
SSMs, we design a bidirectional SSM convolution to extract global context
information. On the other hand, we design a multi-modal fusion strategy based
on probability guidance to maximize the consistency of information between
modalities. Experimental results show that the proposed method can overcome the
computational and memory limitations of Transformer when modeling long-distance
contexts, and has great potential to become a next-generation general
architecture in MERC.
|
[
-0.6592777371406555,
-0.6852049231529236,
0.6706075072288513,
-0.011858013458549976,
-0.29885879158973694,
-0.29475483298301697,
-0.29609736800193787,
-0.4413162171840668,
0.324529767036438,
0.10566022247076035,
-0.9166029691696167,
-0.4240677058696747,
-0.5380706787109375,
-0.16085416078567505,
-0.05773254856467247,
0.8282871246337891,
0.007973826490342617,
-0.14768116176128387,
-0.14518660306930542,
-0.30902746319770813,
-0.6067277193069458,
-0.6373652815818787,
-0.12408817559480667,
-0.10172571986913681,
0.5449223518371582,
0.39736783504486084,
0.6192535758018494,
0.04440996050834656,
0.16247564554214478,
0.37106019258499146,
-0.18466153740882874,
0.40067699551582336,
-0.4813043177127838,
0.4163943827152252,
-0.026284068822860718,
-0.14307178556919098,
-0.22420763969421387,
-0.08958860486745834,
0.45737722516059875,
0.4275124669075012,
-0.30557960271835327,
-0.3116512894630432,
0.1427845060825348,
0.8300413489341736,
-0.8481163382530212,
0.5159052014350891,
-0.3429735004901886,
0.12007865309715271,
-0.03390485793352127,
0.01718745194375515,
-0.4286534786224365,
-0.20220349729061127,
0.3738989531993866,
-0.3592091500759125,
-0.15526323020458221,
0.11669360846281052,
0.7856599688529968,
0.3444698750972748,
-1.040014386177063,
-0.2796999514102936,
-0.9094158411026001,
0.6884440183639526,
-0.5093110799789429,
0.6074424982070923,
0.28810063004493713,
0.580901563167572,
-0.21704831719398499,
0.024983033537864685,
-0.6575705409049988,
-0.1496373414993286,
0.10990307480096817,
0.34064656496047974,
-0.3689001500606537,
0.13101115822792053,
0.007199968211352825,
0.3322564959526062,
-0.2915406823158264,
0.10135455429553986,
-0.3622385859489441,
-0.31137800216674805,
0.4703546464443207,
0.22392189502716064,
-0.08918964862823486,
-0.36795753240585327,
-0.5166446566581726,
-0.3035513758659363,
-0.39822521805763245,
0.28096380829811096,
0.07377807050943375,
0.24377992749214172,
-0.2943021357059479,
0.3652324378490448,
-0.18617521226406097,
0.421492338180542,
0.11001800745725632,
-0.09331363439559937,
0.3126564621925354,
-0.031657762825489044,
-0.1655026227235794,
0.10568641871213913,
0.7525876760482788,
0.298027902841568,
-0.1830255389213562,
0.10953430086374283,
0.19746534526348114,
0.10366656631231308,
0.45443496108055115,
-0.5962395071983337,
0.18061788380146027,
0.2197471261024475,
-0.5023458003997803,
0.16154487431049347,
0.08797511458396912,
-1.0728763341903687,
-0.6148307919502258,
-0.4899508059024811,
0.3125687837600708,
-0.5647315979003906,
-0.32868123054504395,
0.008455578237771988,
0.34608176350593567,
0.17559920251369476,
0.35539689660072327,
-0.7749642729759216,
-0.060884054750204086,
0.517101526260376,
0.7079615592956543,
-0.11796960234642029,
-0.15129192173480988,
-0.132126584649086,
-0.06863999366760254,
-0.06360344588756561,
0.38326722383499146,
-0.6629182696342468,
-0.5791759490966797,
0.0729464516043663,
0.25933703780174255,
0.09301398694515228,
-0.22892490029335022,
0.39074844121932983,
-0.4907396137714386,
0.4470073878765106,
-0.2801414430141449,
-0.5217534899711609,
-0.7001153230667114,
0.21830855309963226,
-0.6629700064659119,
0.535175621509552,
0.09350314736366272,
-0.47511613368988037,
0.31996607780456543,
-0.6482847929000854,
-0.55571448802948,
-0.4535645544528961,
-0.004029222298413515,
-0.5044823288917542,
0.11600996553897858,
0.10611643642187119,
0.6641898155212402,
-0.25888457894325256,
0.29606443643569946,
-0.6056743264198303,
-0.274259090423584,
0.1478816270828247,
-0.5602656006813049,
0.06596027314662933,
0.5632448792457581,
-0.5000439286231995,
0.16905644536018372,
-0.7544787526130676,
-0.35668784379959106,
-0.21715223789215088,
-0.4000266194343567,
-0.26302969455718994,
0.3232819736003876,
-0.29731282591819763,
0.5670676827430725,
-0.061949241906404495,
-0.5077328681945801,
-0.10288121551275253,
-0.3414064347743988,
0.18070602416992188,
0.7471537590026855,
-0.0576779767870903,
0.6288994550704956,
0.014638521708548069,
0.3474937677383423,
0.6310030221939087,
0.12791810929775238,
-0.3233867883682251,
-0.282730370759964,
-0.7304360270500183,
-0.44322559237480164,
-0.2333095222711563,
0.3782169818878174,
-0.3878438472747803,
0.8490331172943115,
0.1028914526104927,
-0.43134450912475586,
-0.48771539330482483,
-0.168943852186203,
0.14109332859516144,
0.5843828320503235,
0.5699566006660461,
-0.19566744565963745,
-0.4639318585395813,
-0.8695017099380493,
0.1950780600309372,
0.06747779250144958,
0.04363112896680832,
0.8124691247940063,
0.07529319822788239,
-0.5299948453903198,
0.8057799935340881,
-0.4425678551197052,
-0.22144800424575806,
-0.0908324271440506,
0.21495234966278076,
0.032839544117450714,
0.3057606816291809,
0.16255301237106323,
-0.9517685174942017,
-0.05557733401656151,
-0.08624240010976791,
-0.7090963125228882,
0.2752460837364197,
-0.10211627185344696,
-0.29061347246170044,
0.3645011782646179,
0.18030105531215668,
-0.4369935095310211,
0.5410981774330139,
0.6490243077278137,
-0.3329646587371826,
0.19707922637462616,
-0.2533028721809387,
0.6166523694992065,
-1.3170814514160156,
-0.08659544587135315,
0.38593360781669617,
0.05218662694096565,
-0.6342976689338684,
-0.5766066312789917,
0.1473160833120346,
-0.16862545907497406,
-0.5200684070587158,
0.1714717298746109,
-0.4154052734375,
0.05035503953695297,
-0.4473631978034973,
0.14193463325500488,
-0.1030820682644844,
0.7623869180679321,
0.01291652861982584,
0.22336477041244507,
0.6192746162414551,
-0.7045273184776306,
0.48312100768089294,
0.14022445678710938,
-0.21106117963790894,
0.7883865237236023,
-0.10656284540891647,
-0.08110253512859344,
-0.3588782250881195,
0.6682555675506592,
-1.1396478414535522,
-0.18356014788150787,
0.09984912723302841,
0.013235198333859444,
0.20183630287647247,
0.09137970954179764,
-0.10205536335706711,
-0.3030407726764679,
0.06789442151784897,
0.3815608024597168,
0.7333521842956543,
-0.6162064075469971,
1.0624182224273682,
0.36682119965553284,
0.04127548262476921,
-0.3925418257713318,
-0.4018295407295227,
-0.24123615026474,
-0.4303440451622009,
-0.5862709283828735,
-0.0019555839244276285,
0.10390012711286545,
0.08106757700443268,
-0.4117358922958374,
-0.15837986767292023,
0.09646397083997726,
0.08452656865119934,
0.9207568168640137,
0.4510052800178528,
0.09190043807029724,
0.4460026025772095,
0.12756335735321045,
-0.0388922244310379,
0.0017856144113466144,
0.1289076954126358,
0.6576173901557922,
-0.4655531048774719,
-0.6623054146766663,
-0.49507853388786316,
0.5312786102294922,
0.7554509043693542,
-0.2510160803794861,
0.7572406530380249,
0.9118289947509766,
-0.3108339309692383,
0.11178974062204361,
-0.6371147632598877,
-0.269218772649765,
-0.4698755741119385,
0.5654581189155579,
-0.3733573853969574,
-1.1718416213989258,
0.5645239353179932,
-0.6162307262420654,
-0.11725449562072754,
0.4255788326263428,
0.6895571947097778,
-0.2806665003299713,
1.1038414239883423,
0.9369669556617737,
-0.4641413986682892,
0.5856487154960632,
-0.04166562110185623,
0.33244389295578003,
-0.7405439615249634,
-0.6194291710853577,
-0.18757134675979614,
-0.7236945033073425,
-0.4284360110759735,
-0.40798890590667725,
0.6406528353691101,
0.03477500379085541,
-0.2591387927532196,
0.12063363939523697,
-0.2301810383796692,
0.2362121045589447,
0.31217509508132935,
0.23147472739219666,
-0.19294559955596924,
-0.08616374433040619,
-0.033236827701330185,
-0.21516405045986176,
-0.44198471307754517,
-0.1161772608757019,
0.5567174553871155,
0.4824763238430023,
0.8449785113334656,
0.1721249371767044,
0.5355573296546936,
0.011426172219216824,
0.004476445261389017,
-0.7595595121383667,
0.47399139404296875,
-0.035721808671951294,
-0.3751489818096161,
-0.13051240146160126,
-0.5233837962150574,
-0.9081159830093384,
0.3223187029361725,
-0.3947063088417053,
-0.9038934111595154,
0.3825361132621765,
0.0053211357444524765,
-0.2479153424501419,
0.26023581624031067,
-0.682229220867157,
0.7389799356460571,
-0.11885952949523926,
-0.12642234563827515,
-0.6796402335166931,
-1.046240210533142,
0.45513439178466797,
-0.07028166949748993,
0.2517049312591553,
-0.23863518238067627,
0.34847134351730347,
0.48176538944244385,
-0.19809044897556305,
0.8524787425994873,
-0.2842157781124115,
-0.3341521620750427,
0.259519100189209,
0.23297497630119324,
0.33180925250053406,
-0.1628737449645996,
0.025033075362443924,
0.14785706996917725,
-0.3363853096961975,
-0.1376727670431137,
-0.511715829372406,
0.49038296937942505,
-0.6599875092506409,
-0.3331456482410431,
-0.07215368002653122,
-0.7626283764839172,
-0.5407609343528748,
-0.23616595566272736,
-0.10417640954256058,
0.43715593218803406,
-0.2550843358039856,
0.27935513854026794,
0.6420875191688538,
-0.3017124831676483,
0.5639206171035767,
0.4686097800731659,
0.1280403882265091,
-0.21058261394500732,
0.8993338942527771,
-0.3771264851093292,
0.1786862015724182,
0.328315794467926,
0.13184528052806854,
-0.41016948223114014,
0.32226279377937317,
-0.20016759634017944,
0.07618913054466248,
-0.6837724447250366,
-0.192539244890213,
-0.3491195738315582,
-0.0720595195889473,
-0.15896683931350708,
-0.19798129796981812,
-0.47833049297332764,
-0.04378743842244148,
-0.45437943935394287,
0.04348419979214668,
0.34744468331336975,
0.6033817529678345,
-0.16050109267234802,
0.1785229593515396,
-0.900904655456543,
0.24866507947444916,
0.35369688272476196,
0.1700909584760666,
0.08218546956777573,
-0.42895737290382385,
-0.29707005620002747,
0.28609761595726013,
-0.5041147470474243,
-1.02363121509552,
0.21290211379528046,
0.29930219054222107,
0.368448942899704,
0.8891957998275757,
0.06726296246051788,
0.7123355269432068,
-0.48594141006469727,
0.817638099193573,
0.6308835744857788,
-1.069064974784851,
0.7457311153411865,
-0.13132205605506897,
0.4022332727909088,
0.2881722152233124,
0.7306375503540039,
-0.8580149412155151,
-0.24193069338798523,
-0.5301370620727539,
-0.8652628064155579,
0.7739346027374268,
-0.23006315529346466,
0.047396279871463776,
0.061278291046619415,
0.17104239761829376,
0.11016194522380829,
0.2193244993686676,
-0.43840163946151733,
-0.23572273552417755,
-0.295914888381958,
-0.5560046434402466,
-0.12497211247682571,
-0.21868155896663666,
-0.26326054334640503,
-0.0521421879529953,
0.28136682510375977,
-0.21150577068328857,
0.26005786657333374,
0.03715209662914276,
-0.11631587892770767,
-0.035731758922338486,
0.5800459980964661,
0.6407751441001892,
0.20721206068992615,
-0.06798771023750305,
0.17978690564632416,
0.3974255621433258,
-0.0784684494137764,
0.2806713283061981,
0.12753042578697205,
0.5765100717544556,
-0.27814409136772156,
-0.07382739335298538,
1.0985324382781982,
0.41923099756240845,
-0.5556603670120239,
0.6088691353797913,
0.16859278082847595,
-0.06694345921278,
0.2318268120288849,
0.06798534840345383,
-0.004449258558452129,
0.876523494720459,
0.24654868245124817,
0.16387426853179932,
0.22269177436828613,
-0.6968311071395874,
0.26036274433135986,
0.40528783202171326,
-0.5770704746246338,
-0.34937772154808044,
0.5256221890449524,
0.2104596495628357,
0.14293889701366425,
0.5112414360046387,
-0.09012128412723541,
-0.7211622595787048,
0.3487202227115631,
0.3809608519077301,
0.7660841345787048,
-0.32029449939727783,
0.17558613419532776,
0.253562331199646,
-0.23565728962421417,
-0.07445212453603745,
0.19446860253810883,
-0.5149246454238892,
-0.4552899897098541,
-0.2427031695842743,
-0.42872628569602966,
-0.4626796245574951,
-0.3516010046005249,
-0.6202747225761414,
0.08501492440700531,
-0.23535987734794617,
-0.2130112498998642,
-0.49036651849746704,
-0.1598813831806183,
-0.568673849105835,
0.24094454944133759,
0.8314222693443298,
0.390540212392807,
-0.8104202747344971,
0.7114337086677551,
0.31381261348724365,
-0.14012470841407776,
-0.9788533449172974,
-0.2818513810634613,
0.4196823239326477,
-0.5126707553863525,
0.4161255657672882,
0.31371477246284485,
-0.31944864988327026,
-0.46543899178504944,
-0.33116915822029114,
-0.7905151844024658,
1.3155102729797363,
0.15096890926361084,
-0.6869571805000305,
0.22679570317268372,
-0.006639835424721241,
0.5074634552001953,
-0.4433671832084656,
0.2654324471950531,
0.33104729652404785,
0.3891526162624359,
0.3259907066822052,
-0.8764166831970215,
0.052146486937999725,
-0.08015566319227219,
-0.08533772826194763,
0.28850826621055603,
-0.8719419240951538,
0.6315405964851379,
-0.18972328305244446,
-0.31873831152915955,
-0.40144044160842896,
1.084230899810791,
0.31943124532699585,
0.20250320434570312,
0.870677649974823,
0.4850611388683319,
0.8314405679702759,
-0.17086292803287506,
0.699141800403595,
-0.18451252579689026,
0.3737661838531494,
0.7753653526306152,
-0.4644165635108948,
0.8394109606742859,
0.27672362327575684,
-0.0386003814637661,
0.7751176953315735,
0.643336832523346,
0.04732933267951012,
0.662752628326416,
0.08647443354129791,
-0.2848142683506012,
-0.24502967298030853,
0.04057677835226059,
-0.326330304145813,
0.5799713730812073,
0.2665356397628784,
-0.14172925055027008,
-0.2892874777317047,
0.485038161277771,
0.12192179262638092,
-0.3409961760044098,
-0.22135396301746368,
0.910676896572113,
0.10609260201454163,
-0.4683334529399872,
0.5266790986061096,
-0.13908442854881287,
0.9667936563491821,
-0.8071432709693909,
0.13601186871528625,
-0.23635882139205933,
0.1598214954137802,
-0.15894635021686554,
-0.5854651927947998,
0.1079416498541832,
-0.12720805406570435,
-0.2488507479429245,
-0.010556384921073914,
0.6046488881111145,
-0.8862367272377014,
-0.08125320076942444,
0.32907867431640625,
0.31577274203300476,
0.17211291193962097,
-0.12218451499938965,
-0.5088923573493958,
0.10101113468408585,
-0.13128209114074707,
-0.2514333426952362,
0.4033971130847931,
0.5893731713294983,
0.23574960231781006,
0.6921786665916443,
0.42086324095726013,
-0.25097137689590454,
-0.008501832373440266,
0.17835894227027893,
0.8544177412986755,
-0.7515727877616882,
-0.70890212059021,
-0.8407920002937317,
0.7004611492156982,
0.1418018937110901,
-0.240195631980896,
0.569585382938385,
0.1149313822388649,
0.37448111176490784,
0.15945452451705933,
0.3609387278556824,
-0.06516054272651672,
0.17212823033332825,
-0.3949108421802521,
0.47798869013786316,
-0.8160564303398132,
-0.0807342454791069,
-0.43904054164886475,
-0.8702867031097412,
0.02719493955373764,
0.3966050148010254,
-0.09955263882875443,
0.1712142378091812,
0.7166262865066528,
0.568402111530304,
-0.12065878510475159,
0.42155787348747253,
0.3397660553455353,
0.08958196640014648,
0.5028637051582336,
1.0137122869491577,
0.9549964070320129,
-0.2772979140281677,
0.47253572940826416,
-0.20671294629573822,
-0.2666499614715576,
-0.4035961627960205,
-0.7108399271965027,
-0.4506414830684662,
-1.1184706687927246,
-0.04129284992814064,
-0.40018945932388306,
-0.23742857575416565,
1.009965419769287,
0.9708713293075562,
-0.6400712728500366,
-0.06364216655492783,
0.38441210985183716,
0.02448335662484169,
-0.06382166594266891,
-0.22198614478111267,
0.30185645818710327,
-0.30475571751594543,
-0.6310037970542908,
0.677066445350647,
0.5167748332023621,
0.1136157289147377,
-0.2515326738357544,
-0.36168771982192993,
-0.15879859030246735,
0.03539251536130905,
0.6894002556800842,
0.1864771991968155,
-0.7596616744995117,
-0.392164945602417,
-0.20562689006328583,
-0.257473349571228,
0.1431524008512497,
0.7243187427520752,
-0.6702671647071838,
0.4920596778392792,
0.1607952117919922,
0.6823513507843018,
0.4348825216293335,
0.12921330332756042,
0.5406762957572937,
-0.675582766532898,
0.28563395142555237,
0.07950016111135483,
0.6066855788230896,
0.08323977887630463,
-0.2779282033443451,
0.12967491149902344,
0.015879731625318527,
-0.5638757944107056,
-0.3626490831375122,
0.30719900131225586,
-1.3558437824249268,
-0.3134736716747284,
1.1843318939208984,
-0.050879161804914474,
-0.27944058179855347,
0.2213248759508133,
-0.41574326157569885,
0.40735819935798645,
-0.5299781560897827,
0.8364034295082092,
0.7822192311286926,
-0.317415326833725,
-0.09614687412977219,
-0.05321309715509415,
0.2727518677711487,
0.6195312142372131,
-0.9130691885948181,
0.0900716632604599,
0.9728687405586243,
-0.07088156789541245,
0.289126992225647,
0.1740223616361618,
-0.004068555776029825,
0.12567883729934692,
-0.24760359525680542,
0.15149575471878052,
0.0866345763206482,
-0.5194756984710693,
-0.7191693782806396,
0.28262412548065186,
-0.6060872673988342,
-0.24049675464630127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17841v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17841v1
|
Toxicity Classification in Ukrainian
| 2024-04-27T09:20:13 | 2024-04-27T09:20:13 |
Daryna Dementieva, Valeriia Khylenko, Nikolay Babakov, Georg Groh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The task of toxicity detection is still a relevant task, especially in the
context of safe and fair LMs development. Nevertheless, labeled binary toxicity
classification corpora are not available for all languages, which is
understandable given the resource-intensive nature of the annotation process.
Ukrainian, in particular, is among the languages lacking such resources. To our
knowledge, there has been no existing toxicity classification corpus in
Ukrainian. In this study, we aim to fill this gap by investigating
cross-lingual knowledge transfer techniques and creating labeled corpora by:
(i)~translating from an English corpus, (ii)~filtering toxic samples using
keywords, and (iii)~annotating with crowdsourcing. We compare LLMs prompting
and other cross-lingual transfer approaches with and without fine-tuning
offering insights into the most robust and efficient baselines.
|
[
0.0419999323785305,
-0.2026345133781433,
0.718379020690918,
0.22949524223804474,
-0.27206894755363464,
0.2708703279495239,
0.12997637689113617,
-0.7471041083335876,
0.003326859325170517,
0.47562289237976074,
-0.43432238698005676,
-1.1381899118423462,
-0.4671521782875061,
0.3078099489212036,
-0.07305721193552017,
1.1766602993011475,
0.014525105245411396,
0.38152843713760376,
-0.09579696506261826,
-0.1825801581144333,
-0.3482547402381897,
-0.634304404258728,
-0.5331674218177795,
-0.29580777883529663,
0.9172754883766174,
0.8262829184532166,
0.2871139645576477,
0.1985761821269989,
0.29961317777633667,
0.39875128865242004,
-0.12980297207832336,
-0.20074313879013062,
-0.20227588713169098,
0.10571371018886566,
-0.6970573663711548,
-0.848847508430481,
0.02206539735198021,
-0.05556056275963783,
0.025201525539159775,
0.5663024187088013,
0.08545391261577606,
0.3186608850955963,
-0.18532823026180267,
0.5988674759864807,
-0.7923128604888916,
0.06413798034191132,
-0.687396764755249,
0.48438751697540283,
-0.17826254665851593,
-0.279434472322464,
-0.5237257480621338,
-0.41123339533805847,
-0.07780873775482178,
-0.8153024315834045,
-0.42184948921203613,
0.06942159682512283,
0.6399072408676147,
0.14272591471672058,
-0.3796408474445343,
-0.7334460616111755,
-0.3686484396457672,
0.8340889811515808,
-0.3740738034248352,
0.2895287871360779,
0.3867071866989136,
0.2021017074584961,
0.19096197187900543,
-0.8202205300331116,
-0.014419765211641788,
-0.14561410248279572,
-0.20562642812728882,
0.28417760133743286,
-0.18429423868656158,
-0.00940968468785286,
-0.1546613574028015,
-0.169035404920578,
-0.12452509999275208,
0.533700704574585,
-0.8052615523338318,
-0.9435167908668518,
0.47271454334259033,
0.27367889881134033,
0.49580878019332886,
-0.5376721024513245,
-0.7436733841896057,
0.32936039566993713,
-0.6592568755149841,
-0.05219193547964096,
0.3274233639240265,
0.2203574925661087,
0.05373828858137131,
0.4325792193412781,
-0.18322256207466125,
0.2704820930957794,
0.05923280864953995,
-0.11691753566265106,
0.25749364495277405,
-0.6993967890739441,
0.018276335671544075,
0.2988504469394684,
0.7220126390457153,
0.6440078020095825,
0.03928103297948837,
-0.2983461320400238,
0.23300348222255707,
0.0852794423699379,
0.24230195581912994,
-0.8823792338371277,
-0.2885204255580902,
0.14602355659008026,
-0.45803630352020264,
-0.7982926964759827,
-0.48706042766571045,
-1.086283802986145,
-0.2928922772407532,
-0.03867354616522789,
0.46155881881713867,
-0.2144486904144287,
-0.019710291177034378,
0.16596370935440063,
0.1554509997367859,
-0.254952073097229,
0.2828291058540344,
-0.8924979567527771,
0.1001833900809288,
0.4081411063671112,
0.902403712272644,
-0.2625020444393158,
0.13528625667095184,
-0.5797274708747864,
0.052733711898326874,
-0.48156875371932983,
1.0180418491363525,
-0.32112595438957214,
-0.4636874794960022,
0.18941253423690796,
0.17992828786373138,
0.29951581358909607,
-0.8164978623390198,
0.6732940077781677,
-0.39931878447532654,
0.34653526544570923,
-0.4528224468231201,
-0.19118277728557587,
-0.1208610087633133,
0.00029075011843815446,
-0.174530029296875,
1.0299981832504272,
0.283247172832489,
-0.9888640642166138,
0.44650277495384216,
-0.24741794168949127,
-0.28821074962615967,
0.3103303611278534,
0.26753780245780945,
0.022931570187211037,
-0.286518931388855,
-0.26557084918022156,
0.6622891426086426,
0.1830514520406723,
0.21551036834716797,
-0.3671768605709076,
-0.21343977749347687,
0.22292542457580566,
0.15445476770401,
0.9312489628791809,
0.542471706867218,
-0.25786322355270386,
0.42516762018203735,
-0.7333645224571228,
0.0326366201043129,
-0.610969066619873,
-0.7115622758865356,
-0.6335580348968506,
-0.29512864351272583,
0.3231620490550995,
0.6707245111465454,
0.12382225692272186,
-0.5267471075057983,
-0.19750183820724487,
-0.1260516196489334,
0.2837304174900055,
0.6504050493240356,
0.06457560509443283,
0.6790993213653564,
-0.4797971546649933,
0.5792685747146606,
0.12986846268177032,
0.2613927125930786,
0.3898458182811737,
-0.44170379638671875,
-0.6683304309844971,
-0.07983413338661194,
0.2623968720436096,
0.946404755115509,
-0.9396008253097534,
0.6519403457641602,
-0.1576312631368637,
-0.8513197302818298,
-0.596625566482544,
0.19232077896595,
0.46063125133514404,
0.71393883228302,
0.41064000129699707,
-0.04614757001399994,
-0.6437618732452393,
-1.0016447305679321,
0.0845256894826889,
-0.4547603726387024,
0.024678178131580353,
0.37199491262435913,
0.4259653687477112,
-0.10504601895809174,
0.2766920328140259,
-0.15318869054317474,
-0.6081945300102234,
0.002099115401506424,
0.055683039128780365,
-0.20415310561656952,
0.23067744076251984,
0.6953758001327515,
-0.2868472933769226,
-0.8107869625091553,
0.2856079339981079,
-0.6808309555053711,
-0.8443583250045776,
0.1278315633535385,
-0.4808029234409332,
0.3136594593524933,
0.937056839466095,
0.010807838290929794,
-0.03471957519650459,
0.7324016094207764,
-0.13497096300125122,
0.6083358526229858,
0.024341274052858353,
0.08902958780527115,
-1.0845229625701904,
0.3455824851989746,
-0.11995569616556168,
-0.30921176075935364,
-0.7667759656906128,
-0.22932849824428558,
0.10637953877449036,
0.13260601460933685,
-1.0275958776474,
0.6307048201560974,
-0.4393063485622406,
0.03879322111606598,
0.004812268540263176,
0.2521374225616455,
-0.08117544651031494,
0.1596057265996933,
0.27759313583374023,
0.6997604370117188,
0.6572253108024597,
-0.5689845681190491,
0.3261454701423645,
0.2605346739292145,
-0.25622668862342834,
0.9736213088035583,
-0.13084380328655243,
-0.24843797087669373,
0.08642041683197021,
0.06742633879184723,
-0.8630774021148682,
0.056168656796216965,
0.802233874797821,
-0.27760758996009827,
0.1451827436685562,
-0.5318622589111328,
-0.4021884500980377,
-0.053867779672145844,
-0.12051953375339508,
0.053864557296037674,
0.5445858240127563,
-0.402219295501709,
0.1477893441915512,
0.3365936577320099,
-0.5295476317405701,
-0.6278907060623169,
-0.9200030565261841,
-0.07358117401599884,
-0.6925029158592224,
-0.35482117533683777,
0.20056936144828796,
-0.17815569043159485,
-0.38383275270462036,
0.11395851522684097,
-0.09853160381317139,
-0.14264120161533356,
-0.027620257809758186,
0.18839122354984283,
0.20206287503242493,
-0.02828153967857361,
0.5398781299591064,
0.09823307394981384,
-0.16079173982143402,
0.42670100927352905,
0.17214545607566833,
0.07652592658996582,
0.05078940466046333,
0.06351350247859955,
-0.4029361605644226,
0.3306841254234314,
0.6571124792098999,
0.11352922767400742,
0.5213101506233215,
0.6979367733001709,
-0.17015254497528076,
-0.21871592104434967,
-0.22307181358337402,
0.08443891257047653,
-0.5195826888084412,
0.3749152421951294,
-0.05460214614868164,
-0.7443641424179077,
0.7735576033592224,
-0.3588402271270752,
-0.22045324742794037,
0.2928999662399292,
0.7010003328323364,
-0.018394289538264275,
0.5195172429084778,
0.35905125737190247,
-0.22469355165958405,
0.39907655119895935,
0.11706074327230453,
-0.1958942413330078,
-0.6586748361587524,
-0.5188015103340149,
-0.7551519870758057,
-0.22133228182792664,
-0.42872628569602966,
-0.5047333240509033,
0.48467814922332764,
-0.07926265150308609,
-0.2402520775794983,
0.03413132205605507,
-0.5548865795135498,
0.3176933825016022,
0.31819742918014526,
0.3512394428253174,
0.5538275241851807,
0.05763336271047592,
-0.41700243949890137,
-0.18887639045715332,
-0.7489754557609558,
-0.5516701340675354,
0.8666163682937622,
0.25074702501296997,
0.6504311561584473,
-0.07725467532873154,
0.787937343120575,
-0.04913724213838577,
0.9328073859214783,
-0.9077580571174622,
0.585456371307373,
-0.12931334972381592,
-1.0208998918533325,
-0.20278824865818024,
-0.3784516155719757,
-1.0074446201324463,
0.21967452764511108,
-0.4592644274234772,
-0.8830556273460388,
0.23485919833183289,
-0.34275102615356445,
-0.30669495463371277,
0.48392996191978455,
-0.7525476217269897,
0.70926833152771,
-0.40753281116485596,
-0.5209917426109314,
-0.06514246016740799,
-0.6353330612182617,
0.44580867886543274,
-0.44447970390319824,
0.816990315914154,
-0.2544444501399994,
-0.5244948863983154,
0.7749617099761963,
-0.3531283140182495,
0.9769373536109924,
-0.17734216153621674,
-0.2090681940317154,
0.1808490753173828,
0.14082442224025726,
0.1347568929195404,
0.03159353882074356,
-0.07346367090940475,
0.08423659205436707,
0.15736021101474762,
-0.24388690292835236,
-0.10453551262617111,
0.654508113861084,
-0.5142736434936523,
-0.2803654968738556,
-0.40782585740089417,
-0.45259523391723633,
-0.19598756730556488,
0.3621446490287781,
0.6061466932296753,
-0.2218586802482605,
0.0290882159024477,
-0.0006020214641466737,
0.5999565124511719,
-0.7424017786979675,
-0.019839538261294365,
0.7066162824630737,
-0.5194219350814819,
-0.2832912802696228,
0.7225415706634521,
0.27973419427871704,
0.37687060236930847,
0.19861753284931183,
0.30206120014190674,
-0.29146116971969604,
-0.6611663699150085,
-0.4601273536682129,
0.19715911149978638,
-1.1234592199325562,
-0.5025067329406738,
-0.5553937554359436,
-0.26912641525268555,
-0.08861139416694641,
-0.2016914188861847,
-0.31470340490341187,
0.0365486741065979,
-0.6608521342277527,
-0.4804476797580719,
0.6485062837600708,
0.8055925965309143,
-0.5986695289611816,
0.0552852489054203,
-1.0884308815002441,
-0.043006643652915955,
0.1531333029270172,
0.4883679747581482,
-0.24542206525802612,
-0.3217920660972595,
-0.21002928912639618,
-0.1350821703672409,
-0.014476497657597065,
-1.4245883226394653,
0.38081634044647217,
-0.15776236355304718,
0.6423137187957764,
0.21680767834186554,
0.3479507267475128,
0.3952654004096985,
-0.18069769442081451,
0.49886974692344666,
0.27261918783187866,
-0.9593415856361389,
0.3879826068878174,
-0.404453307390213,
-0.0947158932685852,
0.8004493117332458,
0.9946103692054749,
-0.8897291421890259,
-0.41061604022979736,
-0.301176518201828,
-0.8660182356834412,
0.7969010472297668,
0.03371131047606468,
0.09740711748600006,
0.026477061212062836,
0.08027391135692596,
0.27084672451019287,
-0.2401125580072403,
-0.6321635842323303,
-0.23241892457008362,
0.08898002654314041,
-0.21955476701259613,
0.15255321562290192,
-0.1843254566192627,
-0.051265694200992584,
-0.3801937401294708,
0.6300032138824463,
0.1677263081073761,
-0.21356365084648132,
0.3146119713783264,
-0.3370077311992645,
-0.4585869312286377,
0.5664149522781372,
0.3357425332069397,
0.2918876111507416,
-0.15472421050071716,
0.19902384281158447,
0.4924432039260864,
-0.5640797019004822,
0.39644360542297363,
-0.04267938807606697,
-0.3458927273750305,
0.10188012570142746,
0.1252700239419937,
0.40408948063850403,
0.7705292701721191,
-0.7168217897415161,
0.29681986570358276,
0.21545539796352386,
-0.6288214921951294,
-0.022380752488970757,
-0.012054882012307644,
0.4997134208679199,
0.20441995561122894,
0.17370527982711792,
-0.13484448194503784,
0.3644586205482483,
-0.7653831243515015,
0.2897392213344574,
0.07650143653154373,
-0.5494264960289001,
-0.20151418447494507,
0.4862956702709198,
0.4980679452419281,
0.06476856023073196,
0.28142890334129333,
-0.1416587233543396,
-0.7331741452217102,
0.2607376277446747,
0.22878360748291016,
0.30436035990715027,
-0.22958904504776,
0.6434723138809204,
0.6619455814361572,
0.19140008091926575,
0.15058301389217377,
0.36726999282836914,
0.2057916224002838,
-0.5679136514663696,
-0.3091871738433838,
-0.7126683592796326,
-0.46504682302474976,
0.24648870527744293,
-0.6768500208854675,
0.07836951315402985,
-0.4268604815006256,
-0.07088280469179153,
0.2930639386177063,
0.02170673757791519,
-0.3538578748703003,
0.03863731771707535,
0.12448328733444214,
0.8646141290664673,
-1.3147417306900024,
0.4108639061450958,
0.8668748736381531,
-0.3074128031730652,
-0.617573618888855,
-0.6437879204750061,
0.029455218464136124,
-0.7208268642425537,
0.8947607278823853,
0.058765511959791183,
0.07608478516340256,
-0.004024754744023085,
-0.39408084750175476,
-0.8438403010368347,
0.9053641557693481,
0.09754913300275803,
-0.4104117155075073,
0.05111108347773552,
0.13146141171455383,
0.7706974744796753,
0.037229008972644806,
-0.004414915107190609,
0.2637488543987274,
0.8338310122489929,
0.06521071493625641,
-1.0094431638717651,
0.2676642835140228,
-0.3068513870239258,
-0.381985604763031,
-0.03648760914802551,
-0.49322327971458435,
0.34524473547935486,
-0.07279404252767563,
-0.37864676117897034,
0.13545620441436768,
0.22350315749645233,
0.09426525980234146,
0.5159045457839966,
0.36384791135787964,
0.3751479983329773,
0.7121337056159973,
0.12553642690181732,
0.37737807631492615,
-0.009007164277136326,
0.04969341307878494,
0.7476134300231934,
-0.30480000376701355,
0.935808539390564,
0.4081991910934448,
-0.2738744914531708,
0.6962303519248962,
0.9876225590705872,
-0.057078685611486435,
0.5854058265686035,
0.43834197521209717,
-0.3463830053806305,
-0.3305233418941498,
-0.35531410574913025,
-0.30519306659698486,
0.23074385523796082,
0.6528121829032898,
-0.4361187815666199,
-0.5170567631721497,
0.34898483753204346,
0.15945377945899963,
0.12355470657348633,
-0.6233607530593872,
0.861486554145813,
0.10058391094207764,
-0.6986284255981445,
0.38013720512390137,
-0.2553463280200958,
1.0208163261413574,
-0.3804442584514618,
0.19527624547481537,
-0.16336780786514282,
0.0018004461890086532,
-0.5048277378082275,
-1.0050915479660034,
0.6626172065734863,
-0.009052046574652195,
0.22537481784820557,
-0.1713874191045761,
1.0652426481246948,
-0.5794665217399597,
-0.45373305678367615,
0.6260841488838196,
0.7394589185714722,
0.6495811343193054,
0.1328054815530777,
-0.6342708468437195,
-0.20390060544013977,
-0.08026851713657379,
0.10059738159179688,
0.540604829788208,
0.5805504322052002,
-0.25278937816619873,
0.7835479974746704,
0.7451810836791992,
0.465358704328537,
0.40014293789863586,
-0.16454079747200012,
0.6830676794052124,
-0.3450024724006653,
-0.22300274670124054,
-0.397285133600235,
0.5831485986709595,
0.2750183641910553,
-0.10150723159313202,
0.6075757741928101,
0.4988587200641632,
0.9012101292610168,
-0.23195582628250122,
0.888482928276062,
0.10741180926561356,
0.33999937772750854,
-0.5971387028694153,
0.9785399436950684,
-0.3892259895801544,
-0.01585758477449417,
-0.11029860377311707,
-0.504219114780426,
-0.4157198965549469,
0.4342310130596161,
-0.06358960270881653,
-0.10764960199594498,
0.8746297359466553,
0.7757237553596497,
0.12672746181488037,
-0.49327608942985535,
0.3831230700016022,
0.4245264232158661,
-0.229371577501297,
0.7923280596733093,
0.9179193377494812,
-0.07866868376731873,
0.9794851541519165,
-0.591198205947876,
-0.04187823832035065,
-0.34599077701568604,
-0.8626040816307068,
-0.8855084180831909,
-0.5464535355567932,
-0.27082374691963196,
-0.5099523067474365,
0.20165739953517914,
0.6365285515785217,
0.6964289546012878,
-0.7861225605010986,
0.10278794914484024,
0.06398934870958328,
0.19430281221866608,
0.2952340245246887,
-0.17589370906352997,
0.11715532094240189,
-0.3456471860408783,
-0.5526629686355591,
0.015405491925776005,
0.1089080423116684,
0.09848522394895554,
-0.3292107582092285,
-0.06375276297330856,
-0.10283181816339493,
-0.2713817059993744,
0.5617656111717224,
0.13854964077472687,
-0.5305542945861816,
-0.3969348073005676,
0.14068235456943512,
-0.3796350657939911,
0.03579181060194969,
0.41384950280189514,
-0.5571049451828003,
0.403584748506546,
0.6955129504203796,
0.1546594798564911,
0.27714553475379944,
-0.17018187046051025,
0.15206755697727203,
-0.6451441645622253,
-0.06768880784511566,
0.359391987323761,
0.19364501535892487,
0.4479391276836395,
-0.5386318564414978,
0.549237847328186,
0.20432621240615845,
-0.5190749764442444,
-0.5532894730567932,
0.14393305778503418,
-1.0430288314819336,
-0.5229759812355042,
1.5137807130813599,
-0.25529977679252625,
-0.2993767559528351,
-0.7412775754928589,
-0.5443195104598999,
0.4135417938232422,
-0.2140103280544281,
0.7766849994659424,
0.9154088497161865,
0.10516490042209625,
-0.09173223376274109,
-0.7650653123855591,
0.6032640933990479,
0.1736353635787964,
-1.335356593132019,
0.0666511133313179,
0.5432850122451782,
0.9166772365570068,
0.3809087574481964,
0.7642576694488525,
-0.4047265350818634,
0.24454885721206665,
-0.1389898657798767,
0.11598554253578186,
0.2176923304796219,
-0.15142713487148285,
-0.12900446355342865,
-0.1293446570634842,
-0.03325063735246658,
0.01197147462517023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17835v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17835v1
|
VANER: Leveraging Large Language Model for Versatile and Adaptive Biomedical Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-04-27T09:00:39 | 2024-04-27T09:00:39 |
Junyi Biana, Weiqi Zhai, Xiaodi Huang, Jiaxuan Zheng, Shanfeng Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Prevalent solution for BioNER involves using representation learning
techniques coupled with sequence labeling. However, such methods are inherently
task-specific, demonstrate poor generalizability, and often require dedicated
model for each dataset. To leverage the versatile capabilities of recently
remarkable large language models (LLMs), several endeavors have explored
generative approaches to entity extraction. Yet, these approaches often fall
short of the effectiveness of previouly sequence labeling approaches. In this
paper, we utilize the open-sourced LLM LLaMA2 as the backbone model, and design
specific instructions to distinguish between different types of entities and
datasets. By combining the LLM's understanding of instructions with sequence
labeling techniques, we use mix of datasets to train a model capable of
extracting various types of entities. Given that the backbone LLMs lacks
specialized medical knowledge, we also integrate external entity knowledge
bases and employ instruction tuning to compel the model to densely recognize
carefully curated entities. Our model VANER, trained with a small partition of
parameters, significantly outperforms previous LLMs-based models and, for the
first time, as a model based on LLM, surpasses the majority of conventional
state-of-the-art BioNER systems, achieving the highest F1 scores across three
datasets.
|
[
-0.08520866185426712,
-0.6062334775924683,
0.6572884321212769,
0.03998129814863205,
-0.5998585224151611,
0.3785243630409241,
-0.06961128115653992,
-0.6999146938323975,
0.31337615847587585,
0.4912729561328888,
-0.1781560629606247,
-0.6225906014442444,
-0.7655296325683594,
0.45176026225090027,
-0.22887158393859863,
1.1339198350906372,
0.09853246062994003,
0.5951715707778931,
-0.3084966540336609,
-0.3385408818721771,
-0.43786680698394775,
-0.2338208556175232,
-0.7160994410514832,
-0.41812989115715027,
0.8907011151313782,
0.17529098689556122,
0.24426543712615967,
0.933967113494873,
0.7573791742324829,
0.31693828105926514,
-0.3846379220485687,
0.06853978335857391,
-0.39061209559440613,
0.2684520483016968,
-0.3468192517757416,
-0.1646791398525238,
-0.5730754137039185,
-0.5401941537857056,
0.6956941485404968,
0.49002406001091003,
-0.18453556299209595,
0.09243891388177872,
-0.06963010877370834,
0.36776450276374817,
-0.4264049530029297,
0.3504211902618408,
-0.5595484972000122,
-0.14829091727733612,
-0.5092576742172241,
0.07044919580221176,
-0.4419087767601013,
-0.14415082335472107,
0.1481156051158905,
-0.575649082660675,
0.07608670741319656,
0.18950991332530975,
0.7283337116241455,
0.18780407309532166,
-0.4062291979789734,
-0.2610277533531189,
-0.846488356590271,
0.5916464328765869,
-0.32395192980766296,
0.8599440455436707,
0.007730220910161734,
0.3994511365890503,
-0.15330274403095245,
-1.028613567352295,
-0.487865686416626,
-0.04144076630473137,
0.17559005320072174,
-0.035381440073251724,
-0.38587865233421326,
0.02985208109021187,
-0.00867975689470768,
0.17815673351287842,
-0.5226852893829346,
0.5458648204803467,
-0.6821041107177734,
-0.13928300142288208,
0.3109933137893677,
0.2514435350894928,
0.08854293078184128,
-0.2941218912601471,
-0.5341609716415405,
-0.06777391582727432,
-0.7704505324363708,
-0.10834646970033646,
-0.38735395669937134,
0.23824524879455566,
0.1522597372531891,
0.6241889595985413,
-0.007054785266518593,
0.6866270303726196,
0.10179102420806885,
-0.13823482394218445,
0.40291550755500793,
0.15113835036754608,
-0.45119810104370117,
0.25031977891921997,
0.8919641971588135,
-0.10481660813093185,
-0.08078014850616455,
-0.6038103699684143,
-0.17603535950183868,
-0.269917368888855,
0.3860480785369873,
-0.946496307849884,
-0.060166921466588974,
0.3883964419364929,
-0.4086449444293976,
-0.2550604045391083,
-0.11823230236768723,
-1.011291265487671,
-0.5471028685569763,
-0.11970093101263046,
0.2785911560058594,
-0.5735644102096558,
0.24234908819198608,
0.09968584775924683,
0.11069557815790176,
0.6023856997489929,
0.3166716396808624,
-0.7447947859764099,
0.09041648358106613,
0.6512026190757751,
0.9478990435600281,
-0.3435177505016327,
0.1508660465478897,
-0.7862746715545654,
0.5258779525756836,
0.00936910230666399,
1.0045040845870972,
-0.6607796549797058,
-0.7416861653327942,
-0.506676971912384,
0.19325488805770874,
0.05344456434249878,
-0.5702324509620667,
0.1662164181470871,
-1.0927380323410034,
-0.19553589820861816,
-0.19193586707115173,
-0.6565876603126526,
-0.2908204197883606,
-0.2327798455953598,
-0.7218462228775024,
0.42043691873550415,
0.15112429857254028,
-0.6218077540397644,
0.38031473755836487,
-0.3299320638179779,
-0.5455372929573059,
0.5634185671806335,
-0.346777081489563,
-0.680460512638092,
0.026128314435482025,
0.10613151639699936,
0.4351450800895691,
-0.624940812587738,
0.3234853744506836,
-0.3923819065093994,
-0.05925601348280907,
0.20931829512119293,
-0.007323932368308306,
0.5458576679229736,
-0.018651098012924194,
-0.026882905513048172,
0.3782929480075836,
-1.0701771974563599,
-0.10954111814498901,
0.09985332190990448,
-0.6065288186073303,
-0.3721597194671631,
0.05298483371734619,
0.08140603452920914,
-0.16009946167469025,
-0.04711608588695526,
-0.6299316883087158,
0.29163482785224915,
-0.5388196110725403,
0.5532216429710388,
0.665588915348053,
0.18157127499580383,
0.4632323980331421,
-0.10994505137205124,
0.5326392650604248,
-0.0003659828216768801,
-0.1670684516429901,
0.09589562565088272,
-0.5193775296211243,
-0.6720925569534302,
-0.7976645827293396,
0.5834020376205444,
0.9113820791244507,
-0.5936370491981506,
0.46110567450523376,
-0.5688075423240662,
-0.5954854488372803,
-0.5643438696861267,
0.1917383223772049,
0.41627955436706543,
0.6810869574546814,
0.8032928705215454,
-0.35572168231010437,
-0.5509328842163086,
-0.8396642804145813,
-0.01319217961281538,
-0.11583731323480606,
-0.2198498249053955,
0.21990080177783966,
0.554585874080658,
-0.6241915822029114,
0.7793578505516052,
-0.4381484091281891,
-0.2555296719074249,
-0.1457781046628952,
-0.1443382054567337,
0.10369877517223358,
0.3713272511959076,
0.0803995281457901,
-0.5828913450241089,
0.05086555331945419,
0.32071563601493835,
-0.9047778844833374,
0.11205606907606125,
0.22849717736244202,
-0.18091484904289246,
-0.35176098346710205,
0.49361374974250793,
-0.7882723808288574,
0.2413392961025238,
0.22371716797351837,
-0.02118602581322193,
0.17645005881786346,
-0.08439332991838455,
-0.29066988825798035,
-1.1990386247634888,
0.248056560754776,
0.020889054983854294,
-0.5735454559326172,
-0.48199188709259033,
0.03449401631951332,
0.07958751171827316,
0.12235508114099503,
-0.393079549074173,
0.7879889011383057,
-0.48245397210121155,
0.04003085568547249,
-0.2422018200159073,
-0.3462234139442444,
0.0933273658156395,
0.07291165739297867,
0.14878779649734497,
0.5652456879615784,
0.5247357487678528,
-0.7288498878479004,
0.48054835200309753,
0.6876181364059448,
-0.4240950345993042,
0.2521873712539673,
-1.032423496246338,
0.3543815314769745,
-0.6114283800125122,
0.2923141121864319,
-0.630834698677063,
-0.5475711226463318,
0.5470589995384216,
-0.09835973381996155,
0.7314357757568359,
-0.16175849735736847,
-0.26409173011779785,
-0.44970032572746277,
0.15870435535907745,
0.37013018131256104,
0.6417776346206665,
-0.4870193898677826,
0.9274954199790955,
0.5300760269165039,
-0.4363158941268921,
-0.3246367871761322,
-0.4777127802371979,
-0.11762562394142151,
-0.2895909547805786,
-0.325259268283844,
0.6499336957931519,
0.30944493412971497,
-0.09487868845462799,
-0.1979568898677826,
-0.14995120465755463,
-0.0759829729795456,
-0.22232003509998322,
0.3743906021118164,
0.5469611883163452,
-0.37666353583335876,
0.5248902440071106,
0.18201059103012085,
-0.2783236801624298,
-0.14460650086402893,
-0.38868382573127747,
0.20276501774787903,
0.026456132531166077,
-0.2511982321739197,
-0.09078311920166016,
0.15691566467285156,
0.5870752930641174,
-0.6775450706481934,
0.9089149236679077,
0.5011646747589111,
-0.44229525327682495,
0.03741035982966423,
-0.3814786672592163,
-0.02579101175069809,
-0.47447726130485535,
0.7401683330535889,
-0.22247850894927979,
-0.9245671629905701,
0.3871482014656067,
-0.3611244559288025,
-0.07804209738969803,
0.3310357332229614,
0.638274073600769,
-0.18626677989959717,
0.5901588201522827,
0.461224228143692,
0.05390183627605438,
0.127261683344841,
0.003249651985242963,
0.05379926413297653,
-1.0170295238494873,
-0.759662926197052,
-0.3988626003265381,
-0.0585806742310524,
-0.3934536278247833,
-0.7730362415313721,
0.6080267429351807,
0.23852668702602386,
-0.2887755334377289,
0.20398959517478943,
-0.521189272403717,
0.2750457525253296,
0.30843886733055115,
0.4494110643863678,
0.1180720180273056,
0.04277892783284187,
-0.1914459615945816,
0.28963521122932434,
-0.484645277261734,
-0.7273862361907959,
0.9471648335456848,
0.41131728887557983,
0.814721405506134,
0.21677438914775848,
0.5530855655670166,
0.1651131808757782,
0.6982295513153076,
-0.8960086107254028,
0.3791867792606354,
-0.2943338453769684,
-0.3465415835380554,
-0.1400948464870453,
-0.2683904767036438,
-1.1764289140701294,
0.05353989824652672,
-0.3753109872341156,
-0.8177997469902039,
0.43480464816093445,
0.13499097526073456,
-0.581031084060669,
0.266757071018219,
-0.17901352047920227,
0.7392733097076416,
-0.27329859137535095,
-0.3572975695133209,
0.13701950013637543,
-0.7679338455200195,
0.2943587005138397,
-0.3953947424888611,
0.31073522567749023,
0.0794130265712738,
-0.08638690412044525,
0.6971045732498169,
-0.3319724202156067,
0.7497248649597168,
0.11159873008728027,
-0.019026320427656174,
0.19105954468250275,
-0.12428976595401764,
0.6235671639442444,
0.16035966575145721,
0.03802906349301338,
0.4347691237926483,
-0.25341445207595825,
-0.22405628859996796,
-0.20034761726856232,
0.47615885734558105,
-0.6692891120910645,
-0.6602686643600464,
-0.38071078062057495,
-0.14939865469932556,
-0.20890279114246368,
0.3383345901966095,
0.44394055008888245,
0.3031850755214691,
-0.35699543356895447,
0.1728704869747162,
0.9974521398544312,
-0.5977626442909241,
0.03391365334391594,
0.5630145072937012,
-0.2869611978530884,
-0.6917240619659424,
0.9070098400115967,
-0.3450973927974701,
-0.09807112067937851,
0.7722143530845642,
0.007666902616620064,
-0.2968137860298157,
-0.6406472325325012,
-0.6696192026138306,
0.34649425745010376,
-0.7474530935287476,
-0.6439893841743469,
-0.991728663444519,
-0.27839651703834534,
-0.4108050763607025,
0.2020801156759262,
-0.23890607059001923,
-0.055375806987285614,
-0.6833922863006592,
-0.21010813117027283,
0.6369747519493103,
0.9615887999534607,
0.29387912154197693,
0.4174833297729492,
-1.1162092685699463,
0.4150562286376953,
0.3751825988292694,
0.30837857723236084,
-0.08108590543270111,
-0.45570287108421326,
-0.08858335018157959,
-0.27383700013160706,
-0.2108156532049179,
-1.3348603248596191,
0.30256906151771545,
0.32973167300224304,
0.5801219940185547,
0.48473483324050903,
-0.5222240090370178,
0.427372545003891,
-0.8444705009460449,
0.2272285670042038,
0.05043208226561546,
-0.6364842653274536,
0.49642834067344666,
-0.3206748962402344,
-0.003639985341578722,
0.3157832622528076,
0.3918166160583496,
-0.15207816660404205,
-0.11269711703062057,
-0.06301827728748322,
-1.0503159761428833,
0.2883482575416565,
-0.06423559784889221,
-0.019740482792258263,
-0.2883305549621582,
0.6152207851409912,
0.28536462783813477,
0.11962533742189407,
-0.6001071929931641,
-0.16864286363124847,
-0.00971811544150114,
-0.4247047007083893,
-0.07998647540807724,
-0.22019189596176147,
0.09918878227472305,
-0.24132990837097168,
0.5862542390823364,
0.03749602288007736,
0.46585071086883545,
0.19243259727954865,
-0.2841334342956543,
0.02731580100953579,
0.3677661716938019,
0.40022897720336914,
0.22791260480880737,
-0.0016791288508102298,
-0.09969085454940796,
0.19607406854629517,
-0.624459981918335,
0.250328928232193,
0.6073357462882996,
-0.14059405028820038,
-0.11103890091180801,
0.5133745670318604,
0.9826849102973938,
0.38929781317710876,
-0.7797057628631592,
0.22311678528785706,
0.27659109234809875,
0.22986270487308502,
-0.18243271112442017,
0.25902259349823,
0.3835728168487549,
0.5157730579376221,
0.14540529251098633,
0.18389497697353363,
0.17648173868656158,
0.06954500824213028,
0.2310054451227188,
0.4164659380912781,
-0.5356050133705139,
-0.2994476556777954,
1.1180565357208252,
0.12301653623580933,
-0.28037357330322266,
0.7681499719619751,
-0.09058571606874466,
-0.1730513721704483,
0.506259024143219,
0.5120850801467896,
0.6727027297019958,
-0.5063165426254272,
0.07952816039323807,
0.28487932682037354,
-0.06522166728973389,
-0.06427997350692749,
0.20123852789402008,
0.2256273627281189,
-0.6924121975898743,
-0.4057518541812897,
-1.0675768852233887,
-0.05739521607756615,
0.1734202653169632,
-0.7512455582618713,
0.5134379267692566,
-0.6693136692047119,
-0.3420155942440033,
0.7023863792419434,
-0.742877185344696,
-0.9556304216384888,
0.16203875839710236,
0.1647602915763855,
0.8253597021102905,
-0.4333454966545105,
0.8997547030448914,
0.9771038293838501,
-0.5306413769721985,
-0.5673651099205017,
-0.32247474789619446,
0.05282530188560486,
-0.9472252130508423,
0.9532108306884766,
0.12710405886173248,
-0.07440135627985,
0.2679935693740845,
-0.21659860014915466,
-0.9690322279930115,
1.2526963949203491,
0.26066574454307556,
-1.0677416324615479,
-0.4167414903640747,
-0.19557078182697296,
0.5150627493858337,
-0.3430740535259247,
0.06919544190168381,
0.2217649668455124,
0.2844107151031494,
0.32275208830833435,
-0.6550513505935669,
0.07942051440477371,
-0.05354825779795647,
0.15155740082263947,
0.1989465206861496,
-0.597245991230011,
0.6521778106689453,
-0.4859181046485901,
-0.2083972692489624,
0.2522273063659668,
0.8770738244056702,
0.6275884509086609,
0.2143503576517105,
0.20126238465309143,
0.27457213401794434,
1.0214532613754272,
0.24706386029720306,
1.0986742973327637,
-0.057499825954437256,
0.11817927658557892,
1.0535805225372314,
-0.5509032011032104,
0.8078933954238892,
0.3953058123588562,
-0.23646992444992065,
0.7966119050979614,
0.5361655950546265,
-0.2953711748123169,
0.6015490889549255,
0.4528973400592804,
-0.4123952388763428,
-0.28379321098327637,
0.08592773228883743,
-0.33771026134490967,
0.8316105008125305,
0.5906739830970764,
-0.7064552307128906,
0.04511358588933945,
0.3607609272003174,
-0.20674502849578857,
-0.434699684381485,
-0.3901829123497009,
0.9505867958068848,
0.24238528311252594,
-0.23304367065429688,
0.20193611085414886,
0.26344355940818787,
0.318931519985199,
-0.5117195844650269,
-0.21596068143844604,
0.07116299122571945,
0.2062395215034485,
0.07114976644515991,
-0.3297411799430847,
-0.007710750214755535,
0.09379296004772186,
-0.45252418518066406,
0.25042083859443665,
0.8468892574310303,
-0.3479013442993164,
-0.8832004070281982,
0.3281237781047821,
0.5429919362068176,
0.19877569377422333,
0.32233762741088867,
-0.34578242897987366,
0.04479190707206726,
-0.20447005331516266,
-0.14961764216423035,
0.05584627762436867,
0.2555285692214966,
-0.17036904394626617,
0.7575302720069885,
0.45860010385513306,
0.3408168852329254,
-0.132352814078331,
-0.07726732641458511,
0.9263024926185608,
-0.8026401996612549,
-0.31856945157051086,
-0.9115819334983826,
0.36283445358276367,
0.10406916588544846,
-0.042291317135095596,
0.2038154900074005,
0.5996387004852295,
0.46236497163772583,
-0.28695279359817505,
0.6631443500518799,
0.16568955779075623,
0.611775279045105,
-0.6957225203514099,
0.538568377494812,
-0.29523807764053345,
0.4794183075428009,
-0.016474300995469093,
-0.7887727618217468,
-0.3332269489765167,
0.7121033668518066,
-0.08569712936878204,
0.30625662207603455,
0.43996310234069824,
0.5830670595169067,
-0.18568091094493866,
0.09176915884017944,
-0.04919813573360443,
0.5182743072509766,
0.27660179138183594,
0.536734938621521,
0.5881667137145996,
-0.14288687705993652,
0.3090866506099701,
0.3131257891654968,
-0.20818127691745758,
-0.19967475533485413,
-0.7078225016593933,
-0.8816757202148438,
-0.2244882881641388,
-0.38124537467956543,
-0.5242160558700562,
0.37193790078163147,
0.9988537430763245,
0.7398204207420349,
-0.9653428792953491,
0.3898719549179077,
-0.09090722352266312,
-0.022638123482465744,
-0.03274864703416824,
-0.12007584422826767,
0.34406259655952454,
-0.013238387182354927,
-0.4102286696434021,
0.5792431235313416,
0.4517490267753601,
0.3456827998161316,
-0.09287120401859283,
0.022028585895895958,
0.1315634399652481,
-0.12029825896024704,
0.5362276434898376,
0.46986883878707886,
-0.7660887837409973,
-0.2889882028102875,
0.21120139956474304,
-0.26600179076194763,
0.1966056227684021,
0.7451773285865784,
-0.9613280892372131,
0.3594759702682495,
0.2007662057876587,
0.8041358590126038,
0.479973167181015,
-0.06173621118068695,
0.5259003043174744,
-0.5489705801010132,
-0.09440001845359802,
0.23476912081241608,
0.2565051019191742,
0.5056924223899841,
-0.6196569204330444,
0.19286023080348969,
0.22207434475421906,
-0.5233544707298279,
-0.5488271117210388,
0.13591793179512024,
-1.1239107847213745,
-0.26341512799263,
1.1987329721450806,
0.020996857434511185,
-0.30957093834877014,
-0.21865630149841309,
0.08313358575105667,
0.5207961201667786,
-0.22066915035247803,
0.5892663598060608,
0.2937425673007965,
-0.1966109424829483,
-0.01470311637967825,
-0.40852993726730347,
0.3193439245223999,
-0.05490894615650177,
-0.8109421133995056,
-0.24659956991672516,
0.4199456572532654,
0.7261078357696533,
-0.12006544321775436,
0.7272514700889587,
-0.23487134277820587,
0.09027788788080215,
-0.32076016068458557,
0.22484874725341797,
-0.10596150159835815,
-0.2727905511856079,
-0.41931048035621643,
-0.009095495566725731,
0.08335451036691666,
-0.1788945496082306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17832v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17832v1
|
Evaluation of Few-Shot Learning for Classification Tasks in the Polish Language
| 2024-04-27T08:53:58 | 2024-04-27T08:53:58 |
Tsimur Hadeliya, Dariusz Kajtoch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce a few-shot benchmark consisting of 7 different classification
tasks native to the Polish language. We conducted an empirical comparison with
0 and 16 shots between fine-tuning, linear probing, SetFit, and in-context
learning (ICL) using various pre-trained commercial and open-source models. Our
findings reveal that ICL achieves the best performance, with commercial models
like GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 attaining the best performance. However, there remains a
significant 14 percentage points gap between our best few-shot learning score
and the performance of HerBERT-large fine-tuned on the entire training dataset.
Among the techniques, SetFit emerges as the second-best approach, closely
followed by linear probing. We observed the worst and most unstable performance
with non-linear head fine-tuning. Results for ICL indicate that continual
pre-training of models like Mistral-7b or Llama-2-13b on Polish corpora is
beneficial. This is confirmed by the improved performances of Bielik-7b and
Trurl-13b, respectively. To further support experiments in few-shot learning
for Polish, we are releasing handcrafted templates for the ICL.
|
[
-0.4669906497001648,
-0.7516548037528992,
0.42717814445495605,
-0.06548885256052017,
-0.27386242151260376,
0.03451690822839737,
-0.5602515339851379,
-0.5997289419174194,
-0.3360724151134491,
0.01567297987639904,
-0.7054656147956848,
-0.7858781814575195,
-0.5626142621040344,
0.24651314318180084,
-0.09598121047019958,
0.8992481827735901,
0.052296243607997894,
0.41380441188812256,
0.150657057762146,
-0.12796010076999664,
-0.44888660311698914,
-0.35767337679862976,
-0.4125124216079712,
-0.3999359607696533,
0.4317978024482727,
0.7269437313079834,
0.1574220061302185,
0.2442326694726944,
0.7502574920654297,
0.24752070009708405,
0.1497078686952591,
0.20385310053825378,
-0.6405544877052307,
-0.13425947725772858,
-0.24916395545005798,
-0.5674170255661011,
-0.05433741584420204,
0.15984055399894714,
0.5741778016090393,
0.713230311870575,
0.14461813867092133,
0.425711989402771,
0.2118760347366333,
0.5089300870895386,
-0.8129700422286987,
0.19803248345851898,
-0.8148728609085083,
0.1796710193157196,
-0.6792616844177246,
-0.026502365246415138,
-0.6494929790496826,
0.0053634680807590485,
-0.05443529784679413,
-0.6648774147033691,
0.16951380670070648,
0.03125539794564247,
0.7991167306900024,
0.11683432757854462,
-0.042024821043014526,
-0.22781237959861755,
-0.5788791179656982,
0.8821418285369873,
-0.6820535659790039,
0.33983540534973145,
0.5036022067070007,
0.42621394991874695,
-0.06761998683214188,
-0.8160586357116699,
-0.2330034226179123,
-0.07894539833068848,
0.07825742661952972,
0.22481563687324524,
-0.23968148231506348,
0.08089873939752579,
0.32946527004241943,
-0.019994311034679413,
-0.6217225193977356,
0.4011392891407013,
-0.5375610589981079,
-0.300045907497406,
0.42364072799682617,
0.2665811777114868,
0.09983503073453903,
0.1517038345336914,
-0.3582059442996979,
-0.1617898941040039,
-0.7784106135368347,
0.17450390756130219,
0.3441345989704132,
0.7643445134162903,
-0.13213735818862915,
0.30701491236686707,
-0.49119704961776733,
0.8902000188827515,
0.2965526282787323,
-0.43454793095588684,
0.45019033551216125,
-0.34622883796691895,
-0.08854798227548599,
0.0745178610086441,
0.7580670714378357,
0.07160169631242752,
0.25560566782951355,
-0.11920677125453949,
-0.20200534164905548,
0.23309341073036194,
0.25330546498298645,
-0.5279787182807922,
-0.25414925813674927,
-0.1798253208398819,
-0.3646479845046997,
-0.29498258233070374,
0.09859023243188858,
-0.351120263338089,
0.13576015830039978,
-0.2879670560359955,
0.6306056976318359,
-0.5587800741195679,
0.24967996776103973,
0.10975141823291779,
0.15392756462097168,
0.2434321790933609,
0.49616172909736633,
-0.9243431687355042,
0.4685985743999481,
0.6875224709510803,
0.7943658828735352,
-0.4127093255519867,
-0.4527846872806549,
-0.7631087303161621,
-0.2778294086456299,
-0.7015376687049866,
1.0097827911376953,
-0.4468962848186493,
-0.1535380780696869,
0.0697215348482132,
-0.1487121433019638,
-0.07266763597726822,
-0.5820796489715576,
0.36802205443382263,
-0.2803281247615814,
0.1784471571445465,
-0.23628956079483032,
-0.6434484720230103,
-0.11671885848045349,
0.5906299948692322,
-0.16247552633285522,
1.1451834440231323,
0.3391144573688507,
-0.8656743764877319,
0.7468823790550232,
-0.5606085658073425,
-0.12938156723976135,
0.4812396168708801,
-0.17477251589298248,
-0.24258403480052948,
0.037572626024484634,
-0.21480807662010193,
0.5597028136253357,
0.05770846828818321,
-0.3205702006816864,
-0.5286729335784912,
-0.5809054970741272,
-0.09707058221101761,
-0.12052540481090546,
0.7489427924156189,
0.08723020553588867,
-0.30971765518188477,
0.048841677606105804,
-0.7889975309371948,
0.32105299830436707,
-0.2687709927558899,
-0.3108654022216797,
-0.23221106827259064,
-0.23432649672031403,
0.2512679994106293,
0.6076862215995789,
0.03408805653452873,
-0.8740811944007874,
0.15546859800815582,
-0.7322243452072144,
0.07283905893564224,
0.46394869685173035,
-0.01609114743769169,
0.33742058277130127,
-0.019612431526184082,
0.5132156610488892,
0.04801665619015694,
0.21067266166210175,
0.27264297008514404,
-0.3172672986984253,
-0.6502934694290161,
-0.10656967014074326,
0.4601117670536041,
0.6652714014053345,
-0.7051078677177429,
0.19460266828536987,
-0.07870251685380936,
-0.6184365153312683,
-0.401436448097229,
0.5251958966255188,
0.6578975319862366,
0.7604358792304993,
0.3115694224834442,
-0.24414223432540894,
-0.3406048119068146,
-0.9660059213638306,
-0.04455102980136871,
-0.13142341375350952,
0.0670357197523117,
0.11718064546585083,
0.722560465335846,
0.0953756794333458,
0.7750657200813293,
-0.31106650829315186,
-0.597260057926178,
-0.36786389350891113,
0.17660145461559296,
0.22484686970710754,
0.3697994649410248,
0.7397928833961487,
-0.35878637433052063,
-1.042294979095459,
0.22377139329910278,
-0.6194759011268616,
-0.023180151358246803,
0.3707083761692047,
-0.0986185148358345,
0.12649793922901154,
0.423195481300354,
-0.291993111371994,
0.38204681873321533,
0.3472236394882202,
-0.20325958728790283,
0.45053279399871826,
-0.07229457795619965,
-0.03236675634980202,
-0.6512374877929688,
0.03408700227737427,
-0.2561928629875183,
-0.4174480438232422,
-0.7584109306335449,
0.12314635515213013,
0.3109149932861328,
0.01208974327892065,
-1.2161966562271118,
0.507674515247345,
-0.154218390583992,
-0.15643340349197388,
-0.352697491645813,
0.2610284686088562,
-0.32990944385528564,
0.4574977457523346,
0.10734561085700989,
0.8329577445983887,
0.7506874203681946,
-0.47298672795295715,
0.1117159053683281,
0.3776836395263672,
-0.7342832684516907,
0.337491899728775,
-0.243537038564682,
0.2688639461994171,
0.03842644393444061,
-0.07580053806304932,
-0.8633332252502441,
-0.08053377270698547,
0.2948639392852783,
-0.3245105743408203,
0.3733988404273987,
-0.19226805865764618,
-0.5644205808639526,
-0.22465577721595764,
-0.33135563135147095,
0.1124706044793129,
0.5303238034248352,
-0.46229925751686096,
0.09521638602018356,
-0.015054896473884583,
0.0384988859295845,
-0.6553385853767395,
-0.7531639933586121,
-0.2866048216819763,
-0.28556695580482483,
-0.3902583718299866,
0.31313127279281616,
-0.2194501906633377,
-0.4003599286079407,
-0.27987435460090637,
-0.0404580757021904,
-0.08011043816804886,
0.22268088161945343,
0.10880094766616821,
0.18301868438720703,
-0.3456740081310272,
0.2618826627731323,
-0.19211873412132263,
-0.26999083161354065,
-0.48946622014045715,
-0.22837309539318085,
0.5315089821815491,
-0.5203824639320374,
-0.18843428790569305,
-0.32846108078956604,
0.13127750158309937,
0.20429936051368713,
-0.06741983443498611,
0.5411832928657532,
0.7846960425376892,
-0.28480008244514465,
-0.3120352625846863,
-0.4736759066581726,
-0.09287102520465851,
-0.4158496558666229,
0.14991158246994019,
-0.6154863238334656,
-0.7281054258346558,
0.6237801313400269,
-0.14415524899959564,
0.04317022114992142,
0.5985022783279419,
0.7533389329910278,
-0.33881503343582153,
0.7853604555130005,
0.8691760301589966,
-0.2113550305366516,
0.5376064777374268,
-0.38202178478240967,
-0.07929426431655884,
-0.5392282009124756,
0.06600069999694824,
-0.5361098647117615,
-0.3367336392402649,
-0.6322793364524841,
0.009326527826488018,
0.43983012437820435,
0.34152549505233765,
-0.018261343240737915,
0.3518974781036377,
-0.1557137370109558,
0.6610361337661743,
0.4953751564025879,
0.2457084357738495,
0.1924324333667755,
-0.07685544341802597,
-0.23839537799358368,
-0.07240679860115051,
-0.8892459869384766,
-0.5749430060386658,
1.0701409578323364,
0.13279707729816437,
0.6904341578483582,
-0.1825234740972519,
1.0450735092163086,
-0.03155752643942833,
0.1403689980506897,
-0.9139889478683472,
0.19101642072200775,
-0.477253794670105,
-0.6349580883979797,
-0.46468618512153625,
0.09167112410068512,
-0.7415168285369873,
0.39208897948265076,
-0.2987857758998871,
-0.7758484482765198,
0.22529864311218262,
0.3962419033050537,
-0.4828658103942871,
0.13339723646640778,
-0.567916214466095,
1.026788592338562,
-0.11553921550512314,
-0.5173969864845276,
-0.21779213845729828,
-0.8196325302124023,
0.24173879623413086,
-0.15930239856243134,
0.13283386826515198,
-0.3174803853034973,
-0.02700813300907612,
0.5785755515098572,
-0.2542418837547302,
0.964858889579773,
-0.2255629003047943,
0.27065548300743103,
0.23697121441364288,
-0.0035225453320890665,
0.28992387652397156,
-0.11806464940309525,
-0.04353589192032814,
0.2449907809495926,
0.2553931176662445,
-0.4968074858188629,
-0.2934531569480896,
0.47791728377342224,
-0.5099250078201294,
-0.15523245930671692,
-0.31750839948654175,
-0.35639688372612,
-0.5036281943321228,
0.36512818932533264,
1.041107416152954,
0.5385898351669312,
-0.3430677652359009,
0.3095756471157074,
0.5585622787475586,
0.02799958921968937,
0.5835554599761963,
0.6745714545249939,
0.0713060051202774,
0.12045954912900925,
0.4939446747303009,
0.23917482793331146,
0.4187697768211365,
0.3784604072570801,
0.2837105989456177,
0.08294851332902908,
-0.8666657209396362,
-0.35921525955200195,
0.12180189043283463,
-0.8787264227867126,
-0.5741912722587585,
-0.25567856431007385,
-0.008977308869361877,
-0.33251816034317017,
-0.1625201404094696,
-0.5903195738792419,
-0.321577787399292,
-0.18795031309127808,
-0.11759676039218903,
0.06948467344045639,
0.6155501008033752,
-0.14944219589233398,
0.4515613615512848,
-0.5602851510047913,
0.05930030718445778,
0.03589291498064995,
0.3554723560810089,
-0.44113755226135254,
-0.34924474358558655,
-0.4233423173427582,
-0.19579845666885376,
-0.28186264634132385,
-0.43266135454177856,
0.32245415449142456,
0.4681773781776428,
0.5567094683647156,
0.5279409289360046,
0.05712195113301277,
0.7418517470359802,
-0.8613460659980774,
0.7574623227119446,
0.0907687172293663,
-0.7812730669975281,
0.6423578858375549,
-0.22531068325042725,
0.5846871137619019,
1.2610927820205688,
0.39939019083976746,
-0.36821919679641724,
-0.4801143705844879,
-0.5820778608322144,
-0.3617240786552429,
0.9935289025306702,
-0.04502500593662262,
0.10332898795604706,
-0.21589411795139313,
0.2322375774383545,
0.4633478820323944,
-0.03549392893910408,
-0.6018939018249512,
-0.077577143907547,
0.10625416040420532,
-0.26117783784866333,
-0.17960426211357117,
-0.1197817400097847,
-0.03485916927456856,
-0.270388662815094,
0.6662763357162476,
-0.3271717131137848,
0.00779861630871892,
-0.09658677875995636,
-0.5261956453323364,
-0.13722728192806244,
0.32406967878341675,
0.8878538012504578,
0.8985546231269836,
-0.3534981608390808,
0.05126058682799339,
0.5035287737846375,
-0.5027721524238586,
-0.054488904774188995,
-0.3974660336971283,
-0.22151018679141998,
0.05775696784257889,
0.6854293942451477,
0.8609551787376404,
0.5386419892311096,
-0.5893378257751465,
0.7379361987113953,
0.21450988948345184,
-0.5088263750076294,
-0.2859256863594055,
0.053888339549303055,
-0.35837095975875854,
0.21728774905204773,
0.044349152594804764,
-0.04841500148177147,
0.3520413637161255,
-0.558122456073761,
0.12498624622821808,
0.38371288776397705,
-0.5509636998176575,
-0.4318416714668274,
0.06692754477262497,
-0.08736330270767212,
-0.14203137159347534,
0.6908611059188843,
-0.2522621750831604,
-0.5002225041389465,
0.23655590415000916,
0.6646352410316467,
0.5828824639320374,
-0.22140371799468994,
0.12074652314186096,
0.4041573405265808,
0.1944631040096283,
-0.21146124601364136,
0.27987897396087646,
-0.2502043545246124,
-0.8993421196937561,
-0.21813741326332092,
-0.5280711054801941,
-0.3423919975757599,
0.1842840164899826,
-0.6808394193649292,
0.4852987229824066,
-0.4623149037361145,
-0.19180849194526672,
0.036015309393405914,
0.1793031543493271,
-0.8975394368171692,
-0.019470667466521263,
0.1418541669845581,
1.1082088947296143,
-1.2379306554794312,
1.0741561651229858,
0.6247524619102478,
-0.386630654335022,
-0.5702002048492432,
-0.31046584248542786,
0.14593267440795898,
-0.6298316717147827,
1.2229465246200562,
0.039242178201675415,
-0.30342310667037964,
-0.05629393085837364,
-0.6745257377624512,
-0.7958377003669739,
0.8297796845436096,
0.2542470693588257,
-0.6508048176765442,
-0.001960688503459096,
-0.18458975851535797,
0.6859352588653564,
-0.3689907193183899,
-0.07577535510063171,
0.5256773829460144,
0.3158379793167114,
-0.24193719029426575,
-1.1274278163909912,
-0.6625131964683533,
-0.07286353409290314,
-0.055921100080013275,
0.2237805873155594,
-0.48335936665534973,
0.654811441898346,
0.15461048483848572,
-0.2275007963180542,
-0.044882163405418396,
0.3274727165699005,
0.08152135461568832,
0.3972139358520508,
0.41878944635391235,
0.3573456108570099,
0.5404903292655945,
-0.06367278099060059,
1.1149226427078247,
-0.22694911062717438,
0.4454178214073181,
1.1599292755126953,
-0.2522014379501343,
1.2687649726867676,
0.47573089599609375,
-0.31027376651763916,
0.30204665660858154,
0.7526840567588806,
-0.085717111825943,
0.8290703296661377,
0.017591651529073715,
-0.11901624500751495,
-0.4065774977207184,
0.2804335355758667,
-0.051178328692913055,
0.7082825303077698,
0.3914731740951538,
-0.010390503332018852,
-0.5339793562889099,
0.6570245027542114,
-0.22556599974632263,
0.0437367781996727,
-0.40951240062713623,
0.9313785433769226,
0.09261272847652435,
-0.35563331842422485,
0.4754834473133087,
-0.02948063239455223,
0.8183093667030334,
-0.7200570702552795,
0.14767953753471375,
-0.1644173115491867,
0.3053763508796692,
-0.20828624069690704,
-0.5928277969360352,
0.1143711507320404,
0.056746941059827805,
-0.1366647481918335,
-0.16956937313079834,
0.8393745422363281,
-0.43619590997695923,
-0.46873998641967773,
0.1854725331068039,
0.31257739663124084,
0.4817143380641937,
0.22158491611480713,
-0.7285758256912231,
-0.10744863003492355,
-0.25614845752716064,
-0.013532642275094986,
0.5836107730865479,
0.1580260992050171,
-0.1798393577337265,
0.5081241130828857,
0.18282417953014374,
0.19195763766765594,
0.23013527691364288,
0.10941565781831741,
0.484611451625824,
-0.2553384006023407,
-0.45465222001075745,
-0.7040705680847168,
0.30236896872520447,
0.17278118431568146,
-0.5170514583587646,
0.7222023606300354,
0.7064942717552185,
1.3752455711364746,
-0.5107115507125854,
0.45577937364578247,
0.1440160721540451,
0.6511243581771851,
-0.7763445973396301,
0.43401843309402466,
-0.2248755246400833,
-0.14695292711257935,
-0.3640628159046173,
-0.8233972787857056,
-0.6173616051673889,
0.8747284412384033,
-0.46246784925460815,
-0.24072721600532532,
0.7999575734138489,
0.5226397514343262,
-0.35764020681381226,
-0.43402358889579773,
0.8001213073730469,
-0.05417615920305252,
-0.07013135403394699,
0.5680138468742371,
0.8151437044143677,
-0.454975426197052,
0.2979428470134735,
-0.7707463502883911,
-0.1361943781375885,
-0.27127331495285034,
-0.6803380846977234,
-0.9179980158805847,
-0.5417341589927673,
-0.3199627101421356,
0.13180804252624512,
0.11526358872652054,
1.1090130805969238,
0.8583935499191284,
-1.0165016651153564,
-0.2997245788574219,
0.1189170703291893,
-0.4202241003513336,
-0.2505739629268646,
-0.16101665794849396,
0.30951571464538574,
-1.0681133270263672,
-0.6597199440002441,
0.6384236812591553,
0.43460899591445923,
-0.09828787297010422,
0.11925753206014633,
-0.0014250549720600247,
-0.208563432097435,
-0.4373342990875244,
0.867220938205719,
0.35702672600746155,
-0.7924811244010925,
-0.4003905951976776,
-0.023705406114459038,
-0.128910630941391,
0.33285611867904663,
0.771429181098938,
-0.8286288380622864,
0.43525221943855286,
0.6684421896934509,
0.3657969534397125,
0.7897071242332458,
-0.04101208969950676,
0.2439304143190384,
-0.874271035194397,
0.41192665696144104,
0.2273588627576828,
0.29778119921684265,
0.15302784740924835,
-0.212920680642128,
0.6460252404212952,
-0.011065366677939892,
-0.276874303817749,
-0.7737934589385986,
0.11151745915412903,
-0.9340748190879822,
-0.23734889924526215,
0.8091899752616882,
-0.33120185136795044,
-0.14064432680606842,
-0.037038423120975494,
-0.102611243724823,
0.08294127881526947,
-0.08178413659334183,
0.581807553768158,
0.9963790774345398,
-0.5456215143203735,
-0.10606448352336884,
-0.7127809524536133,
0.6596960425376892,
0.17912888526916504,
-0.8621671199798584,
-0.06310097873210907,
0.4535239338874817,
0.6186224222183228,
0.16819864511489868,
0.581485390663147,
-0.4429793357849121,
0.5469544529914856,
0.005410667974501848,
-0.09415065497159958,
0.009706731885671616,
-0.44828084111213684,
-0.6672281622886658,
0.16024170815944672,
0.4650184214115143,
-0.33331364393234253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17809v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17809v1
|
Recall, Retrieve and Reason: Towards Better In-Context Relation Extraction
| 2024-04-27T07:12:52 | 2024-04-27T07:12:52 |
Guozheng Li, Peng Wang, Wenjun Ke, Yikai Guo, Ke Ji, Ziyu Shang, Jiajun Liu, Zijie Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Relation extraction (RE) aims to identify relations between entities
mentioned in texts. Although large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated
impressive in-context learning (ICL) abilities in various tasks, they still
suffer from poor performances compared to most supervised fine-tuned RE
methods. Utilizing ICL for RE with LLMs encounters two challenges: (1)
retrieving good demonstrations from training examples, and (2) enabling LLMs
exhibit strong ICL abilities in RE. On the one hand, retrieving good
demonstrations is a non-trivial process in RE, which easily results in low
relevance regarding entities and relations. On the other hand, ICL with an LLM
achieves poor performance in RE while RE is different from language modeling in
nature or the LLM is not large enough. In this work, we propose a novel
recall-retrieve-reason RE framework that synergizes LLMs with retrieval corpora
(training examples) to enable relevant retrieving and reliable in-context
reasoning. Specifically, we distill the consistently ontological knowledge from
training datasets to let LLMs generate relevant entity pairs grounded by
retrieval corpora as valid queries. These entity pairs are then used to
retrieve relevant training examples from the retrieval corpora as
demonstrations for LLMs to conduct better ICL via instruction tuning. Extensive
experiments on different LLMs and RE datasets demonstrate that our method
generates relevant and valid entity pairs and boosts ICL abilities of LLMs,
achieving competitive or new state-of-the-art performance on sentence-level RE
compared to previous supervised fine-tuning methods and ICL-based methods.
|
[
-0.3613978624343872,
-0.5656474828720093,
0.6873601078987122,
0.016195449978113174,
-0.3198859989643097,
-0.2224503457546234,
-0.41556742787361145,
-0.40194171667099,
-0.025677507743239403,
0.479669988155365,
-0.5430178046226501,
-0.5469940900802612,
-0.34320735931396484,
0.2398679256439209,
-0.40528419613838196,
1.0096430778503418,
-0.0073396614752709866,
0.049101412296295166,
-0.46011069416999817,
-0.2060243934392929,
-0.4891073405742645,
-0.5822482109069824,
-0.584597647190094,
-0.4348776638507843,
0.4288921356201172,
0.7180612683296204,
0.11709490418434143,
0.43843671679496765,
0.16148702800273895,
0.15817438066005707,
0.042402710765600204,
0.49176710844039917,
-0.6327109336853027,
0.2960059940814972,
-0.5922243595123291,
-0.45071253180503845,
-0.08534859865903854,
-0.06244104728102684,
0.6205036044120789,
0.5450286865234375,
-0.0011922006960958242,
0.1291392296552658,
0.00017836198094300926,
0.5252020955085754,
-0.740592360496521,
0.11712164431810379,
-1.0038840770721436,
-0.22829490900039673,
0.013507677242159843,
-0.5971061587333679,
-0.6328574419021606,
-0.1485574096441269,
0.29385772347450256,
-0.6833208799362183,
0.06009383872151375,
0.32226911187171936,
1.177551507949829,
0.11754592508077621,
-0.4131726622581482,
-0.5115509629249573,
-0.4947549104690552,
0.8166681528091431,
-0.683756411075592,
0.6112626791000366,
0.4757643938064575,
0.17081958055496216,
-0.19668906927108765,
-0.852195680141449,
-0.4805965721607208,
-0.15381447970867157,
-0.35359257459640503,
-0.02970023825764656,
0.17546674609184265,
-0.2715946435928345,
0.4510292410850525,
0.37348848581314087,
-0.11656273901462555,
0.07781664282083511,
0.07402539253234863,
0.051747776567935944,
0.3206186592578888,
0.1214219257235527,
0.25368571281433105,
-0.26862606406211853,
-0.5906866788864136,
0.05804795026779175,
-1.3058967590332031,
0.08029812574386597,
-0.04089026525616646,
0.2798471450805664,
0.1789925992488861,
0.4409221410751343,
-0.08328468352556229,
0.5521548986434937,
0.14615342020988464,
-0.3143998682498932,
-0.0036308481357991695,
-0.2922179698944092,
-0.14484326541423798,
0.1542869508266449,
0.633400559425354,
0.11510768532752991,
0.2624638080596924,
-0.5607787370681763,
-0.35797202587127686,
-0.09973958134651184,
0.035210296511650085,
-0.866216778755188,
-0.08834467828273773,
-0.06792337447404861,
-0.5318597555160522,
0.025928903371095657,
-0.02438015304505825,
-0.7398290038108826,
0.057292308658361435,
-0.6543664932250977,
0.2377540022134781,
-0.7889188528060913,
-0.24811626970767975,
-0.06143328174948692,
-0.014038086868822575,
0.3951343595981598,
0.27246758341789246,
-1.1409618854522705,
0.32758572697639465,
0.9688597917556763,
0.5037358403205872,
-0.1828474998474121,
-0.14902247488498688,
-0.8175103664398193,
0.38530924916267395,
-0.19012556970119476,
0.6465636491775513,
-0.6399191617965698,
-0.1604607254266739,
0.018147127702832222,
0.04707825183868408,
-0.14236332476139069,
-0.7720810770988464,
0.5230029225349426,
-0.8639159202575684,
0.19169437885284424,
-0.3967300057411194,
-0.8269292712211609,
-0.03486204147338867,
0.5388694405555725,
-0.5490190386772156,
0.8814870715141296,
0.05389931797981262,
-0.8475968837738037,
0.5854837894439697,
-0.294910192489624,
-0.5356727838516235,
-0.06937013566493988,
-0.4991084337234497,
-0.30079784989356995,
-0.1713527888059616,
0.23301656544208527,
0.5706436038017273,
-0.6213710904121399,
0.41194793581962585,
-0.3607178032398224,
-0.4611453711986542,
0.12031348049640656,
-0.2097034901380539,
0.7781278491020203,
0.07786603271961212,
-0.28350552916526794,
-0.021610407158732414,
-0.823053777217865,
-0.003460936713963747,
-0.041689544916152954,
-0.5055527687072754,
-0.7817402482032776,
0.1129787266254425,
-0.2576582729816437,
0.42010095715522766,
0.05913413316011429,
-0.536124050617218,
-0.006011371500790119,
-0.6679694652557373,
0.4995065927505493,
0.4488067924976349,
0.19451767206192017,
0.5117973685264587,
-0.037414319813251495,
0.30921468138694763,
0.06391683220863342,
-0.413823664188385,
-0.4041288197040558,
0.08018829673528671,
-0.6387397050857544,
-0.3073756992816925,
0.23477301001548767,
0.5161548852920532,
-1.0470882654190063,
0.44679853320121765,
-0.40459144115448,
-0.09481813758611679,
-0.4016261398792267,
0.2839099168777466,
0.6096022129058838,
0.9488523602485657,
0.46298718452453613,
0.048748258501291275,
-0.6019833087921143,
-0.792790412902832,
-0.2516341805458069,
-0.097829669713974,
-0.00791643001139164,
0.3910349905490875,
0.40544867515563965,
-0.00811036117374897,
1.2088013887405396,
-0.23356373608112335,
-0.23259909451007843,
-0.2872017025947571,
-0.22513540089130402,
0.12713715434074402,
0.3446681499481201,
0.4324698746204376,
-1.0686711072921753,
-0.27848222851753235,
-0.054627105593681335,
-1.115191102027893,
0.05679910257458687,
-0.012107061222195625,
-0.34394434094429016,
0.1967616230249405,
0.8788764476776123,
-0.6439295411109924,
0.32065457105636597,
-0.07826096564531326,
-0.32889267802238464,
0.4191848635673523,
-0.05939817428588867,
-0.08024883270263672,
-1.1748179197311401,
0.2064492106437683,
0.03630174696445465,
-0.2475041300058365,
-0.2807222008705139,
0.1529659926891327,
0.2979659140110016,
0.05608479678630829,
-0.3868003189563751,
0.602938711643219,
-0.5778144001960754,
-0.06701695919036865,
-0.030630020424723625,
0.47099581360816956,
0.11204047501087189,
0.4345276355743408,
0.07813987880945206,
0.6730266213417053,
0.4831797778606415,
-0.806403636932373,
0.08261249959468842,
0.43857502937316895,
-0.3514343798160553,
0.6658010482788086,
-0.34963899850845337,
-0.0252790916711092,
-0.17595238983631134,
0.15206867456436157,
-0.7104815244674683,
-0.09836368262767792,
0.23854410648345947,
-0.1721704602241516,
0.6031553149223328,
-0.11675461381673813,
-0.6864308714866638,
0.09355007857084274,
-0.04170086607336998,
0.21376480162143707,
0.21723738312721252,
-1.1033289432525635,
0.5602367520332336,
0.3479287624359131,
0.1604764610528946,
-0.7214037179946899,
-0.4604756534099579,
-0.005763676017522812,
-0.5643512010574341,
-0.5285305976867676,
0.6408146023750305,
0.12242598831653595,
-0.28999924659729004,
0.19922392070293427,
-0.21551144123077393,
0.018216311931610107,
0.2031252235174179,
0.08438492566347122,
0.3306312561035156,
-0.3041611313819885,
0.4990827441215515,
-0.042511384934186935,
-0.16373378038406372,
0.231602281332016,
-0.17030584812164307,
0.35009458661079407,
-0.15238754451274872,
-0.09712113440036774,
-0.25499430298805237,
0.3658446967601776,
0.4397602081298828,
-0.24111568927764893,
0.7968102693557739,
0.2779201865196228,
-0.45542046427726746,
-0.32541605830192566,
-0.5009137392044067,
-0.5600883960723877,
-0.3865203559398651,
0.24929179251194,
-0.6830691695213318,
-1.0166270732879639,
0.2588057816028595,
-0.4379127323627472,
0.13281039893627167,
0.2467493861913681,
0.3696202039718628,
-0.011478995904326439,
0.6119591593742371,
0.47766533493995667,
-0.28366565704345703,
0.4901963770389557,
-0.2294747680425644,
0.28475549817085266,
-1.104647159576416,
-0.38041141629219055,
-0.429991215467453,
0.007601386867463589,
-0.31168755888938904,
0.14614038169384003,
0.06726773828268051,
0.45444419980049133,
-0.21300676465034485,
0.42816856503486633,
-0.17673784494400024,
0.37949514389038086,
0.4306269586086273,
0.08154074847698212,
0.5062143802642822,
0.18007345497608185,
-0.31336483359336853,
-0.20478281378746033,
-0.7039947509765625,
-0.7488927245140076,
0.8636559247970581,
0.06632698327302933,
0.6077154874801636,
0.12979115545749664,
0.9204533100128174,
-0.2762807011604309,
0.5670298337936401,
-0.7162970304489136,
0.614776074886322,
-0.11278403550386429,
-0.5309596061706543,
-0.20113299787044525,
-0.5021610260009766,
-1.059598684310913,
0.4011977016925812,
-0.3090384304523468,
-0.8670792579650879,
0.09803399443626404,
0.25393146276474,
-0.2292192280292511,
0.19622917473316193,
-0.593385636806488,
0.9191139340400696,
-0.09634614735841751,
-0.5944544076919556,
-0.255822092294693,
-0.7874628305435181,
0.511588990688324,
0.06324441730976105,
0.06463531404733658,
-0.026018502190709114,
-0.014775958843529224,
0.32294192910194397,
-0.2908773124217987,
0.6044801473617554,
-0.011731830425560474,
-0.1399133801460266,
0.3101308047771454,
0.11037345230579376,
0.4433484971523285,
0.3869709372520447,
-0.33550122380256653,
-0.2765330970287323,
-0.030900733545422554,
0.026303304359316826,
-0.8972567915916443,
1.011979341506958,
-0.46985575556755066,
-0.6392890214920044,
-0.004101529251784086,
-0.36332836747169495,
-0.3240393400192261,
0.07136216014623642,
0.3070763349533081,
0.5915522575378418,
-0.1267571598291397,
0.4008260667324066,
0.8100053668022156,
-0.15705277025699615,
0.475307434797287,
0.5764367580413818,
-0.11808741837739944,
-0.3405543565750122,
0.9956873655319214,
-0.09299391508102417,
0.2228194922208786,
0.8128013610839844,
-0.05807196721434593,
-0.29947033524513245,
-0.10496644675731659,
-0.372692346572876,
0.2617937922477722,
-0.8600853085517883,
-0.39262473583221436,
-0.7365038990974426,
-0.13768407702445984,
-0.1715230494737625,
0.12390437722206116,
-0.15357092022895813,
-0.2670256793498993,
-0.5803449749946594,
0.00894679594784975,
0.20757415890693665,
0.2652197778224945,
0.2203599065542221,
-0.07579465210437775,
-0.7532493472099304,
0.2920914888381958,
0.08669305592775345,
0.15157410502433777,
0.14474669098854065,
-0.4907757639884949,
-0.1426350623369217,
-0.30689671635627747,
-0.3417990803718567,
-0.824562132358551,
0.3141298294067383,
0.21295304596424103,
0.6109460592269897,
0.34386420249938965,
0.12791690230369568,
0.7974968552589417,
-0.4036889672279358,
0.358381062746048,
-0.060937002301216125,
-0.7481897473335266,
0.7110752463340759,
-0.05533333495259285,
-0.07300169765949249,
0.6400606036186218,
0.5564602613449097,
-0.37887445092201233,
-0.15279531478881836,
-0.7600533962249756,
-1.0370838642120361,
0.7992964386940002,
0.0710102990269661,
-0.180831179022789,
-0.3357020616531372,
0.8333996534347534,
0.01499915774911642,
0.17755766212940216,
-0.6894291639328003,
-0.12782816588878632,
0.1567889004945755,
-0.26898056268692017,
0.1899815946817398,
-0.31544291973114014,
-0.021991251036524773,
-0.22365310788154602,
0.8688963055610657,
-0.11705917119979858,
0.03877243772149086,
0.3595147728919983,
-0.3378322124481201,
-0.0325438566505909,
0.3100341260433197,
0.1955922693014145,
0.8224062919616699,
-0.16997291147708893,
0.30581212043762207,
0.3109637200832367,
0.11655604094266891,
0.01711510680615902,
0.11487026512622833,
-0.26279836893081665,
-0.1162358820438385,
0.4876091480255127,
0.5995065569877625,
0.8528444170951843,
-0.8795341849327087,
0.49477389454841614,
-0.0819709300994873,
-0.016766460612416267,
-0.42636677622795105,
0.05979705974459648,
0.27855053544044495,
0.2676302194595337,
0.279073566198349,
-0.13004985451698303,
0.09741458296775818,
-0.6510139107704163,
0.5171117782592773,
0.494124174118042,
-0.206116184592247,
-0.16928328573703766,
0.5224254131317139,
-0.10485143214464188,
-0.31321072578430176,
0.8825281858444214,
-0.22659707069396973,
-0.39551153779029846,
0.46758192777633667,
0.9405825138092041,
0.5368032455444336,
0.15969350934028625,
-0.16225628554821014,
0.6878587007522583,
-0.10163141041994095,
-0.23262420296669006,
0.08316469192504883,
-0.31918469071388245,
-0.8307396173477173,
-0.45073798298835754,
-0.4416772723197937,
-0.18672463297843933,
0.197204127907753,
-0.8348633050918579,
0.41256290674209595,
-0.274692565202713,
0.14941717684268951,
-0.19271320104599,
-0.087185338139534,
-0.5049773454666138,
0.1347135454416275,
-0.11890578269958496,
1.0203388929367065,
-0.5492458939552307,
1.081817626953125,
0.6321967840194702,
-0.5673959851264954,
-1.0042763948440552,
0.040274329483509064,
-0.20566701889038086,
-0.47482457756996155,
0.9776174426078796,
0.2855111360549927,
-0.08109036087989807,
0.08739381283521652,
-0.5395265221595764,
-0.8191022276878357,
1.3164803981781006,
0.7238391041755676,
-0.7099660038948059,
-0.16241714358329773,
-0.34868958592414856,
0.44959092140197754,
-0.7036406397819519,
0.05404026806354523,
0.7352885007858276,
0.13854049146175385,
0.13424167037010193,
-0.4395633339881897,
0.305385023355484,
-0.10845062881708145,
-0.059535328298807144,
0.2898178696632385,
-0.6248437762260437,
0.5606290102005005,
-0.21226023137569427,
-0.4417876899242401,
0.1931726634502411,
0.8485699892044067,
0.767267107963562,
0.5171378254890442,
0.5241575837135315,
0.6853382587432861,
0.6894090175628662,
0.012720095925033092,
1.053783655166626,
-0.2825166583061218,
0.20586179196834564,
1.5436533689498901,
-0.38311922550201416,
1.0521153211593628,
0.7686338424682617,
0.31390368938446045,
0.6157869696617126,
0.5430132150650024,
0.2845359146595001,
0.6709955334663391,
0.015331367962062359,
-0.3150765597820282,
-0.49768951535224915,
-0.05262327194213867,
-0.10439309477806091,
0.31940314173698425,
0.5510601997375488,
-0.6065189242362976,
-0.3421352207660675,
-0.030954167246818542,
0.03147133067250252,
0.4254249334335327,
-0.1480385810136795,
0.7908340096473694,
0.411612331867218,
-1.0012905597686768,
0.4325440227985382,
-0.237573504447937,
0.5393436551094055,
-0.37016260623931885,
-0.3935921788215637,
-0.14442697167396545,
0.3525428771972656,
-0.06273672729730606,
-0.41191786527633667,
0.26307690143585205,
-0.1009024903178215,
-0.3195686340332031,
-0.14957153797149658,
0.8352581262588501,
-0.6818137168884277,
-0.08929436653852463,
0.6447368860244751,
0.3742866814136505,
0.18627528846263885,
0.12514857947826385,
-0.3963980972766876,
-0.1061125174164772,
-0.04586402699351311,
-0.20285819470882416,
0.4893304407596588,
0.8937380313873291,
-0.14194399118423462,
0.6955912709236145,
0.5279456377029419,
-0.048279520124197006,
-0.21376961469650269,
0.1324956864118576,
0.9698404669761658,
-0.7305715084075928,
-0.20208954811096191,
-1.1397393941879272,
0.21720339357852936,
-0.29585742950439453,
-0.3699811100959778,
0.6781569123268127,
0.7169761657714844,
0.9817801117897034,
0.10996443033218384,
0.5153918266296387,
-0.1820758581161499,
0.6595364212989807,
-0.7864940762519836,
0.31358152627944946,
-0.6486650109291077,
0.48725223541259766,
-0.18387511372566223,
-0.7437888979911804,
-0.31223079562187195,
0.6658079624176025,
-0.2453833818435669,
-0.14099673926830292,
0.839514434337616,
0.8835741877555847,
-0.1506222039461136,
0.11215034127235413,
0.2813419997692108,
0.019632283598184586,
0.5101718902587891,
0.7164465188980103,
0.8822171688079834,
-0.42847883701324463,
0.6813792586326599,
-0.08291907608509064,
-0.04171774163842201,
-0.15873776376247406,
-0.8738943934440613,
-1.0224062204360962,
-0.5543588995933533,
-0.1784501075744629,
-0.3247840404510498,
-0.00879516638815403,
1.1972137689590454,
0.7138291597366333,
-0.6341757774353027,
-0.07695598900318146,
-0.1371513307094574,
0.2773950695991516,
-0.09954151511192322,
-0.2795581817626953,
0.4044668972492218,
-0.7470216751098633,
-0.5532901287078857,
0.5695558190345764,
0.28748342394828796,
-0.3397027850151062,
0.0011097245151177049,
-0.2565821409225464,
-0.4912252724170685,
-0.4184442460536957,
0.7315587401390076,
0.3711179792881012,
-0.8664191365242004,
-0.29884669184684753,
-0.25612741708755493,
-0.25443172454833984,
0.021414410322904587,
0.9622600078582764,
-0.9876030683517456,
0.24375416338443756,
0.3408723771572113,
0.865932822227478,
0.5747235417366028,
-0.05828697234392166,
0.6114187836647034,
-0.7681127786636353,
0.025780420750379562,
0.172388955950737,
0.5347561836242676,
0.423692524433136,
-0.45456767082214355,
0.6813628673553467,
0.10431468486785889,
-0.5456686615943909,
-0.6379026770591736,
0.25141167640686035,
-0.7562211751937866,
-0.28666073083877563,
1.179555058479309,
-0.4540729522705078,
-0.14542832970619202,
-0.1347239911556244,
-0.19113054871559143,
0.36051416397094727,
-0.37384843826293945,
0.7726776599884033,
0.5573720932006836,
-0.040938522666692734,
-0.2536958158016205,
-0.3713354170322418,
0.5507264733314514,
0.6046052575111389,
-0.8739867210388184,
0.13633325695991516,
0.3798997104167938,
0.4790535271167755,
0.0719858705997467,
0.4511832892894745,
-0.2460729032754898,
0.144958958029747,
-0.3722558915615082,
-0.19903957843780518,
0.040523115545511246,
-0.42459261417388916,
-0.0569269023835659,
0.3045102655887604,
0.10322604328393936,
0.02826583757996559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17808v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17808v1
|
Scaffold-BPE: Enhancing Byte Pair Encoding with Simple and Effective Scaffold Token Removal
| 2024-04-27T07:12:07 | 2024-04-27T07:12:07 |
Haoran Lian, Yizhe Xiong, Jianwei Niu, Shasha Mo, Zhenpeng Su, Zijia Lin, Peng Liu, Hui Chen, Guiguang Ding
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Byte Pair Encoding (BPE) serves as a foundation method for text tokenization
in the Natural Language Processing (NLP) field. Despite its wide adoption, the
original BPE algorithm harbors an inherent flaw: it inadvertently introduces a
frequency imbalance for tokens in the text corpus. Since BPE iteratively merges
the most frequent token pair in the text corpus while keeping all tokens that
have been merged in the vocabulary, it unavoidably holds tokens that primarily
represent subwords of complete words and appear infrequently on their own in
the text corpus. We term such tokens as Scaffold Tokens. Due to their
infrequent appearance in the text corpus, Scaffold Tokens pose a learning
imbalance issue for language models. To address that issue, we propose
Scaffold-BPE, which incorporates a dynamic scaffold token removal mechanism by
parameter-free, computation-light, and easy-to-implement modifications to the
original BPE. This novel approach ensures the exclusion of low-frequency
Scaffold Tokens from the token representations for the given texts, thereby
mitigating the issue of frequency imbalance and facilitating model training. On
extensive experiments across language modeling tasks and machine translation
tasks, Scaffold-BPE consistently outperforms the original BPE, well
demonstrating its effectiveness and superiority.
|
[
-0.34868764877319336,
-0.5958843231201172,
0.07153613120317459,
0.34305763244628906,
-0.7944826483726501,
0.22501876950263977,
0.0033593447878956795,
-0.455473393201828,
0.5354535579681396,
0.38038286566734314,
-0.20360484719276428,
-0.38360336422920227,
-0.8605632781982422,
-0.08630365133285522,
-0.564753532409668,
1.0652016401290894,
-0.12339818477630615,
0.23371608555316925,
-0.12196579575538635,
-0.3934185206890106,
-0.4786149859428406,
-0.36788466572761536,
-0.4732002913951874,
-0.4719950556755066,
0.3729468286037445,
0.2171788513660431,
0.5185796022415161,
0.9849947690963745,
0.41180598735809326,
0.23232443630695343,
-0.37032508850097656,
0.011998329311609268,
-0.3135879337787628,
0.3110322654247284,
-0.3463076055049896,
-0.31254056096076965,
-0.3237101435661316,
-0.2923055589199066,
0.8818888664245605,
1.0370053052902222,
-0.17112143337726593,
0.2804119288921356,
0.15298403799533844,
0.7363047003746033,
-0.5937032699584961,
0.08749061077833176,
-0.9598977565765381,
-0.19214485585689545,
-0.36769819259643555,
-0.09740517288446426,
-0.4563290774822235,
0.07125555723905563,
0.010264088399708271,
-0.043886344879865646,
0.2833996117115021,
0.1234922930598259,
0.8915684223175049,
-0.04526811093091965,
-0.5163110494613647,
-0.04739406332373619,
-0.43953511118888855,
0.4493102431297302,
-0.5584562420845032,
0.5351032018661499,
0.20073281228542328,
-0.007465248461812735,
-0.47673583030700684,
-0.7007268071174622,
-0.49011605978012085,
-0.01048759464174509,
0.1223883107304573,
-0.18241433799266815,
-0.08615978062152863,
0.3256993889808655,
0.23521722853183746,
0.4786219894886017,
-0.5151904821395874,
0.04722055420279503,
-0.6331858038902283,
-0.40341922640800476,
0.2773926258087158,
-0.13977444171905518,
0.4319479167461395,
-0.36237937211990356,
-0.6869834065437317,
0.20242321491241455,
-0.6518829464912415,
0.022756196558475494,
0.336436927318573,
0.3161354660987854,
0.052327197045087814,
0.7326657772064209,
-0.18104591965675354,
0.5110069513320923,
0.15251730382442474,
0.1592901051044464,
0.38639724254608154,
-0.26461929082870483,
-0.30805733799934387,
0.24109913408756256,
0.20743760466575623,
0.3026002049446106,
-0.1610511690378189,
-0.4780173599720001,
-0.261438250541687,
0.25636398792266846,
0.3129529356956482,
-0.8561955690383911,
0.014706620015203953,
0.5111947655677795,
-0.7206178307533264,
-0.3201693296432495,
-0.0939231663942337,
-0.6033304929733276,
-0.39366620779037476,
-0.15718425810337067,
0.5279664993286133,
-0.6526195406913757,
-0.3327038884162903,
0.265074759721756,
-0.4833456575870514,
0.3889138698577881,
-0.16489185392856598,
-1.193221926689148,
0.3900405764579773,
0.6803607940673828,
0.8360611200332642,
-0.39255857467651367,
-0.27217021584510803,
-0.7856518030166626,
0.524677574634552,
-0.011437210254371166,
0.6806457042694092,
-0.40702417492866516,
-0.4284159541130066,
-0.03051573969423771,
0.1636335253715515,
0.004945194348692894,
-0.31098005175590515,
0.4229698181152344,
-0.47999414801597595,
0.057830050587654114,
-0.221151664853096,
-0.8370426297187805,
-0.05528457462787628,
-0.1485670804977417,
-0.5652199387550354,
1.2066985368728638,
0.1364324390888214,
-0.8604469895362854,
0.4705674648284912,
-0.6917580366134644,
-0.45565152168273926,
0.3204783499240875,
-0.06583399325609207,
-0.2386210560798645,
0.3866816759109497,
0.13457810878753662,
0.10966187715530396,
-0.05966075137257576,
0.14622151851654053,
-0.19551505148410797,
-0.9440847039222717,
-0.24317501485347748,
-0.5145601034164429,
0.909207284450531,
0.10441244393587112,
-0.49762383103370667,
0.15518800914287567,
-0.836331307888031,
-0.17178115248680115,
0.08283200860023499,
-0.3079807162284851,
-0.4256902039051056,
0.04626648128032684,
0.12747086584568024,
0.06981590390205383,
0.21164539456367493,
-0.7608517408370972,
0.3013504147529602,
-0.9993053078651428,
0.49464553594589233,
0.7734634280204773,
0.062022048979997635,
0.7156118154525757,
-0.28090137243270874,
0.2618761956691742,
0.05681909993290901,
0.10969077050685883,
-0.5421867370605469,
-0.4470267593860626,
-0.7083917260169983,
-0.7840123772621155,
0.47506460547447205,
0.4866922199726105,
-0.6292851567268372,
0.27549806237220764,
-0.38886794447898865,
-0.38606753945350647,
-0.6789518594741821,
0.2645317018032074,
0.36801570653915405,
0.43357720971107483,
0.477266788482666,
-0.5510924458503723,
-0.47195130586624146,
-1.0150010585784912,
-0.593531608581543,
-0.08221399784088135,
-0.18218286335468292,
-0.16980476677417755,
0.35206401348114014,
0.010982077568769455,
0.9407692551612854,
0.01894705556333065,
0.09526269882917404,
-0.06160338222980499,
0.2598157525062561,
0.08776525408029556,
1.044742465019226,
0.6422722935676575,
-0.7387802600860596,
-0.12212679535150528,
-0.45809707045555115,
-0.42830005288124084,
-0.28191646933555603,
0.03743768483400345,
-0.1674274057149887,
0.5613414645195007,
0.6018003821372986,
-0.6632897257804871,
0.6079781651496887,
0.40193048119544983,
-0.4616107642650604,
0.4796788990497589,
-0.2241615653038025,
0.17362116277217865,
-0.9095442891120911,
0.1799921840429306,
-0.3435230553150177,
-0.04634353145956993,
-0.5054451823234558,
0.4013424217700958,
0.18122409284114838,
-0.12972372770309448,
-0.6996831297874451,
0.6732615232467651,
-0.3691832721233368,
-0.0489681139588356,
-0.21386490762233734,
0.3102250397205353,
0.16220879554748535,
0.5587337613105774,
-0.29030072689056396,
0.5252454876899719,
0.3203667402267456,
-0.2102450281381607,
0.07538340985774994,
0.14037087559700012,
-0.21491198241710663,
0.5810349583625793,
-0.6713441610336304,
0.2612147629261017,
-0.5011714100837708,
0.1842776983976364,
-1.2465351819992065,
-0.008853347972035408,
0.3463483154773712,
-0.22594109177589417,
0.40502631664276123,
-0.439782977104187,
-0.5489504337310791,
-0.3027708828449249,
-0.44847866892814636,
0.5795416831970215,
0.24468857049942017,
-0.5527204275131226,
0.7742077708244324,
0.19927939772605896,
-0.12065932899713516,
-0.6626459360122681,
-0.7917841076850891,
0.30404767394065857,
0.042896900326013565,
-0.5859747529029846,
0.8796437382698059,
-0.13634909689426422,
0.10548081248998642,
0.1279369741678238,
-0.6653251051902771,
-0.06930936127901077,
0.10392870008945465,
0.33279481530189514,
0.3637818396091461,
-0.03981568291783333,
0.23506110906600952,
0.4374028742313385,
-0.2442856878042221,
-0.10179246217012405,
-0.5320731401443481,
0.9576202034950256,
-0.11243513226509094,
-0.5668264031410217,
-0.27533167600631714,
0.6416671872138977,
0.6771760582923889,
-0.4818464517593384,
0.9891237020492554,
0.7207751274108887,
-0.6431708931922913,
0.015677759423851967,
-0.5780019164085388,
-0.22280244529247284,
-0.5528256297111511,
0.451047420501709,
-0.47978201508522034,
-0.7762252688407898,
0.5301331877708435,
-0.020558655261993408,
0.2402023822069168,
0.16797924041748047,
0.27838343381881714,
-0.2949022054672241,
1.0149303674697876,
0.5382373332977295,
0.10810402035713196,
0.7224549055099487,
0.00035203571314923465,
0.28921782970428467,
-0.6791979670524597,
-0.20361320674419403,
-0.5062031745910645,
-0.28554120659828186,
-0.6050183773040771,
-0.3441894054412842,
0.10661442577838898,
0.3443196713924408,
-0.35026052594184875,
0.43041059374809265,
-0.5210774540901184,
0.6145011782646179,
0.5377605557441711,
0.27556145191192627,
-0.02249453216791153,
0.31753408908843994,
-0.45662569999694824,
-0.022555481642484665,
-0.7152364253997803,
-0.5520734190940857,
0.8824272155761719,
0.2919420897960663,
-0.15361222624778748,
-0.16447573900222778,
0.8190143704414368,
0.39739489555358887,
0.10827003419399261,
-0.4978557527065277,
0.6730274558067322,
-0.18700668215751648,
-0.7449204921722412,
-0.10651989281177521,
-0.1735171228647232,
-0.7047815322875977,
0.5102079510688782,
-0.7020527124404907,
-0.9685389995574951,
0.05529671162366867,
0.2640959322452545,
0.053308017551898956,
0.555519163608551,
-0.668738067150116,
0.8342094421386719,
0.11267935484647751,
-0.5901438593864441,
-0.6833173632621765,
-0.6390959024429321,
0.11445026099681854,
0.018811482936143875,
0.19411638379096985,
-0.035538360476493835,
-0.10169251263141632,
0.6907089352607727,
-0.4559398293495178,
0.6838163137435913,
-0.39814120531082153,
0.01577136293053627,
0.1661219298839569,
0.2568053901195526,
0.7999570965766907,
-0.1722503900527954,
-0.37285929918289185,
0.3949248194694519,
0.32917264103889465,
-1.1261653900146484,
-0.4876115322113037,
0.4278317093849182,
-0.24786727130413055,
-0.5885909199714661,
-0.34344807267189026,
-0.3803985118865967,
-0.15193764865398407,
0.5744476914405823,
-0.03050934709608555,
0.6861175894737244,
0.03162667155265808,
0.36343756318092346,
0.3203687369823456,
-0.25341251492500305,
0.6081737875938416,
0.40627777576446533,
-0.25726014375686646,
-0.7203487753868103,
0.891584038734436,
0.1824667900800705,
0.38780781626701355,
0.005905406549572945,
-0.006609701085835695,
-0.12504759430885315,
-0.9629901647567749,
-0.4984487295150757,
0.29791146516799927,
-0.7371399402618408,
0.010856696404516697,
-0.5110365748405457,
-0.042672738432884216,
-0.20434871315956116,
-0.41917407512664795,
-0.2609955668449402,
-0.6254443526268005,
0.2501126825809479,
-0.1556718796491623,
0.1635066419839859,
0.14608371257781982,
0.21493127942085266,
0.7284902930259705,
-0.8975805640220642,
0.35770201683044434,
0.0025122046936303377,
0.6691693067550659,
-0.1648387908935547,
-0.40303030610084534,
-0.35020849108695984,
0.04778069257736206,
0.04506964236497879,
-0.8534479141235352,
0.0016760113649070263,
-0.08793636411428452,
0.521597683429718,
0.15978050231933594,
-0.0752771720290184,
0.6970221996307373,
-0.47464117407798767,
0.9153602719306946,
0.30414000153541565,
-1.311876654624939,
0.2911689877510071,
-0.40133705735206604,
0.20683521032333374,
0.6124520897865295,
-0.08446092158555984,
-0.6752862334251404,
-0.4268398880958557,
-0.6554378867149353,
-1.2674719095230103,
0.5602858066558838,
0.27080264687538147,
0.2100137323141098,
-0.12543708086013794,
0.8605022430419922,
0.0934194028377533,
0.6355677843093872,
-0.6481131911277771,
-0.3182477653026581,
-0.2672198712825775,
-0.5238051414489746,
0.5424641370773315,
-0.5619203448295593,
0.13624988496303558,
-0.17663876712322235,
0.6911992430686951,
-0.018905052915215492,
0.2842944264411926,
-0.012773057445883751,
-0.22711437940597534,
-0.23774458467960358,
0.011717056855559349,
0.20355258882045746,
0.2358628362417221,
-0.32760918140411377,
0.21860598027706146,
0.3882603347301483,
-0.5169931650161743,
-0.057464346289634705,
-0.029519017785787582,
-0.30821821093559265,
0.004702834412455559,
0.3693918287754059,
0.6249926090240479,
0.39733627438545227,
-0.6040119528770447,
0.6669555306434631,
0.22962279617786407,
-0.10827166587114334,
0.17351612448692322,
-0.0387423112988472,
0.051001135259866714,
0.07030165940523148,
0.32449519634246826,
0.48269957304000854,
-0.11156974732875824,
-0.32039573788642883,
0.5002630352973938,
0.5814510583877563,
-0.3535271883010864,
-0.1950494945049286,
0.7075957655906677,
0.36951369047164917,
-0.5666559934616089,
0.3413652181625366,
-0.09641994535923004,
-0.3085505962371826,
0.4666289687156677,
0.8426039218902588,
0.8595523238182068,
-0.118815578520298,
0.08108903467655182,
0.09798074513673782,
0.5858154296875,
0.13003499805927277,
0.3108592927455902,
-0.1495939940214157,
-0.5652393698692322,
-0.4008045494556427,
-0.8621130585670471,
-0.19431081414222717,
-0.062419068068265915,
-0.45776426792144775,
0.6508409976959229,
-0.5189924836158752,
0.08701975643634796,
-0.1116558238863945,
-0.04636262729763985,
-0.5421850681304932,
0.11141758412122726,
0.08627434819936752,
1.1466588973999023,
-0.8570731282234192,
1.0541720390319824,
0.6215510964393616,
-0.6218948364257812,
-0.4349433183670044,
-0.04280960559844971,
-0.2070181518793106,
-0.6725164651870728,
0.36226361989974976,
0.19350282847881317,
-0.2646876275539398,
0.042575404047966,
-0.37010329961776733,
-0.8126290440559387,
0.7589854598045349,
0.6679725050926208,
-0.3517736792564392,
-0.06708647310733795,
0.29409581422805786,
0.2962706983089447,
-0.21830131113529205,
0.16007748246192932,
0.36188748478889465,
0.5068556666374207,
-0.16246849298477173,
-0.7132204174995422,
0.2066461741924286,
-0.35005423426628113,
0.008526504039764404,
0.24430713057518005,
-0.6533743739128113,
0.49499237537384033,
0.4092121422290802,
-0.17246930301189423,
-0.019446464255452156,
0.745363175868988,
0.18772923946380615,
0.22475795447826385,
0.9143986105918884,
0.06678629666566849,
0.7666068077087402,
0.02668352611362934,
0.43738341331481934,
-0.6730599403381348,
-0.08253292739391327,
0.904910683631897,
-0.23073293268680573,
0.8163040280342102,
0.8818868398666382,
0.04964424669742584,
0.5857393741607666,
0.36431875824928284,
-0.005274233408272266,
0.31514599919319153,
0.1955566108226776,
-0.3820180594921112,
-0.16711385548114777,
-0.027056656777858734,
-0.18713101744651794,
0.5924529433250427,
0.10546842962503433,
-0.2138735055923462,
-0.1773950755596161,
0.15834414958953857,
0.11513116210699081,
0.16209125518798828,
-0.11773394048213959,
0.4594673216342926,
-0.10011201351881027,
-0.37161195278167725,
0.636005163192749,
0.12402664124965668,
0.5540386438369751,
-0.6921747922897339,
-0.0005997494445182383,
-0.2825825810432434,
0.0013931249268352985,
-0.22076383233070374,
-0.17765934765338898,
0.6045452356338501,
-0.20210155844688416,
-0.37097448110580444,
-0.2907778322696686,
0.802069902420044,
-0.5524498820304871,
-0.3844453990459442,
0.4025662839412689,
0.3324090242385864,
0.0011768622789531946,
0.11405158787965775,
-0.5822612643241882,
0.2188858538866043,
-0.08438495546579361,
-0.16681969165802002,
0.4403069019317627,
0.31556570529937744,
-0.10590720921754837,
0.5537665486335754,
0.7867422699928284,
0.30722665786743164,
-0.004985596984624863,
-0.1361989825963974,
0.8278138637542725,
-0.750226616859436,
-0.5437932014465332,
-0.8406912684440613,
0.487892746925354,
-0.21609380841255188,
-0.0811588391661644,
0.4175218343734741,
0.649052619934082,
0.5427715182304382,
0.09721125662326813,
0.598582923412323,
0.07358947396278381,
0.271040141582489,
-0.4294247627258301,
0.7025542855262756,
-0.5990506410598755,
0.5619935989379883,
-0.5254419445991516,
-0.8721901774406433,
-0.5215919017791748,
0.3627927601337433,
0.25683319568634033,
-0.30094820261001587,
0.715995728969574,
0.9278696179389954,
0.029647067189216614,
0.2476864457130432,
-0.0625699982047081,
0.07436463236808777,
0.42575711011886597,
0.1321088969707489,
0.2507735788822174,
-0.6285535097122192,
0.6596710085868835,
-0.10027168691158295,
-0.38474977016448975,
-0.28950777649879456,
-1.3260884284973145,
-0.7604436278343201,
-0.46853190660476685,
-0.2760201692581177,
-0.4559078812599182,
0.4300088882446289,
1.5968748331069946,
0.544868528842926,
-0.9080532789230347,
-0.06737028807401657,
-0.2597324848175049,
0.1376354992389679,
-0.6156065464019775,
-0.1226576715707779,
0.5816119909286499,
-0.41960304975509644,
-0.773960292339325,
0.5309258699417114,
0.5542393922805786,
0.167399600148201,
-0.12765759229660034,
0.2331475019454956,
-0.18429037928581238,
0.5295594334602356,
0.573005735874176,
0.09656938910484314,
-0.4797467589378357,
-0.6069202423095703,
-0.11328571289777756,
-0.11302702128887177,
-0.0012765009887516499,
0.7703233957290649,
-0.8702159523963928,
0.44794678688049316,
0.637450098991394,
0.69212406873703,
0.5937345623970032,
-0.267029732465744,
0.7519229054450989,
-0.807460606098175,
0.6772050857543945,
-0.1455845683813095,
0.5683655142784119,
0.11302085965871811,
-0.10437905043363571,
0.3757593631744385,
0.648766040802002,
-0.15612900257110596,
-1.235846996307373,
0.17468121647834778,
-1.0039629936218262,
-0.4755397439002991,
0.785081684589386,
-0.0017636511474847794,
-0.43701374530792236,
-0.27500271797180176,
-0.5111737847328186,
0.5190252065658569,
-0.21976344287395477,
0.9094777703285217,
0.7792549729347229,
0.2865625023841858,
0.22394005954265594,
-0.25978413224220276,
0.3160921633243561,
0.9283193945884705,
-0.132991224527359,
0.23508797585964203,
0.24738730490207672,
0.18035714328289032,
-0.148940309882164,
0.538138747215271,
-0.20914047956466675,
0.171889528632164,
0.15207000076770782,
0.31230396032333374,
-0.35598334670066833,
-0.07442085444927216,
-0.3274274468421936,
0.582281231880188,
-0.07597406953573227,
-0.38689643144607544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17807v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17807v1
|
Meta In-Context Learning Makes Large Language Models Better Zero and Few-Shot Relation Extractors
| 2024-04-27T07:06:39 | 2024-04-27T07:06:39 |
Guozheng Li, Peng Wang, Jiajun Liu, Yikai Guo, Ke Ji, Ziyu Shang, Zijie Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Relation extraction (RE) is an important task that aims to identify the
relationships between entities in texts. While large language models (LLMs)
have revealed remarkable in-context learning (ICL) capability for general zero
and few-shot learning, recent studies indicate that current LLMs still struggle
with zero and few-shot RE. Previous studies are mainly dedicated to design
prompt formats and select good examples for improving ICL-based RE. Although
both factors are vital for ICL, if one can fundamentally boost the ICL
capability of LLMs in RE, the zero and few-shot RE performance via ICL would be
significantly improved. To this end, we introduce \textsc{Micre} (\textbf{M}eta
\textbf{I}n-\textbf{C}ontext learning of LLMs for \textbf{R}elation
\textbf{E}xtraction), a new meta-training framework for zero and few-shot RE
where an LLM is tuned to do ICL on a diverse collection of RE datasets (i.e.,
learning to learn in context for RE). Through meta-training, the model becomes
more effectively to learn a new RE task in context by conditioning on a few
training examples with no parameter updates or task-specific templates at
inference time, enabling better zero and few-shot task generalization. We
experiment \textsc{Micre} on various LLMs with different model scales and 12
public RE datasets, and then evaluate it on unseen RE benchmarks under zero and
few-shot settings. \textsc{Micre} delivers comparable or superior performance
compared to a range of baselines including supervised fine-tuning and typical
in-context learning methods. We find that the gains are particular significant
for larger model scales, and using a diverse set of the meta-training RE
datasets is key to improvements. Empirically, we show that \textsc{Micre} can
transfer the relation semantic knowledge via relation label name during
inference on target RE datasets.
|
[
-0.44259941577911377,
-0.3962760865688324,
0.5980594158172607,
-0.20964586734771729,
-0.19914984703063965,
-0.13321110606193542,
-0.19741515815258026,
-0.5943100452423096,
-0.08467068523168564,
0.32466331124305725,
-0.6791218519210815,
-0.3930623531341553,
-0.552627682685852,
0.33300068974494934,
-0.1931125521659851,
1.173979640007019,
0.09055392444133759,
0.012410720810294151,
-0.18382534384727478,
-0.40936464071273804,
-0.43052220344543457,
-0.5059747695922852,
-0.5444207191467285,
-0.36049768328666687,
0.8943944573402405,
0.850170373916626,
0.17207205295562744,
0.4645507037639618,
0.5800400376319885,
0.15413005650043488,
0.21848338842391968,
0.13094636797904968,
-0.6002048850059509,
0.1701372265815735,
-0.3396289646625519,
-0.4402277171611786,
-0.4051031172275543,
-0.003456683596596122,
0.6972572207450867,
0.5675217509269714,
0.22825570404529572,
0.37743139266967773,
0.1357191503047943,
0.5980895161628723,
-1.1188409328460693,
0.22079722583293915,
-0.8459911346435547,
-0.07067013531923294,
-0.19288721680641174,
-0.4053207337856293,
-0.5312020778656006,
0.11289326846599579,
0.16444578766822815,
-0.47409993410110474,
0.1067822054028511,
-0.06359817087650299,
1.0012465715408325,
0.23677879571914673,
-0.5964998602867126,
-0.07741747051477432,
-0.9813900589942932,
0.9354580640792847,
-0.5458903908729553,
0.5926482081413269,
0.2683078348636627,
0.49948620796203613,
0.020436236634850502,
-0.8440170884132385,
-0.2939130961894989,
-0.07747329771518707,
-0.20707452297210693,
0.1314217448234558,
-0.1257518082857132,
-0.029326794669032097,
0.45211145281791687,
0.12852272391319275,
-0.10014327615499496,
-0.028992272913455963,
-0.10549244284629822,
0.13413454592227936,
0.332787424325943,
0.18873485922813416,
0.19644123315811157,
-0.14246492087841034,
-0.3731653392314911,
-0.049254950135946274,
-1.0723944902420044,
0.017082899808883667,
-0.224616140127182,
0.3344964385032654,
0.028291689231991768,
0.45489799976348877,
-0.22052493691444397,
0.8789087533950806,
0.09513997286558151,
-0.45304280519485474,
0.18438108265399933,
-0.2993040084838867,
-0.2501468360424042,
-0.11760084331035614,
0.7601798176765442,
0.12542316317558289,
0.3446010649204254,
-0.21994219720363617,
-0.22207427024841309,
-0.23425236344337463,
-0.20700907707214355,
-1.0153250694274902,
-0.023250820115208626,
-0.261260062456131,
-0.3685409128665924,
-0.07984745502471924,
0.2590544819831848,
-0.516751766204834,
0.23108015954494476,
-0.531019389629364,
0.4849242568016052,
-0.40726402401924133,
-0.04734688252210617,
-0.1910603940486908,
-0.10418768227100372,
0.49696260690689087,
0.2511725127696991,
-0.9617440700531006,
0.263298898935318,
0.6826995015144348,
0.766450822353363,
0.03393278643488884,
-0.14513421058654785,
-0.8904836773872375,
0.3677799105644226,
-0.2787351906299591,
0.8433589339256287,
-0.6815050840377808,
-0.031130919232964516,
-0.24965912103652954,
0.031143678352236748,
-0.18622685968875885,
-0.5228479504585266,
0.3879545032978058,
-0.48607903718948364,
0.21197731792926788,
-0.3225727379322052,
-0.4448980987071991,
-0.10719051957130432,
0.34055885672569275,
-0.5574535727500916,
0.8853293657302856,
0.2659904956817627,
-0.9212493896484375,
0.6677849292755127,
-0.5856561660766602,
-0.3458656072616577,
-0.19590938091278076,
-0.31336575746536255,
-0.26237067580223083,
0.233880877494812,
0.19582206010818481,
0.6419515609741211,
-0.4436466693878174,
-0.037956926971673965,
-0.4809392988681793,
-0.5355690717697144,
0.2796289920806885,
-0.3225362300872803,
0.6506056189537048,
0.050554197281599045,
-0.20438013970851898,
-0.16995295882225037,
-0.7727481126785278,
0.05200713500380516,
-0.1521306037902832,
-0.41738131642341614,
-0.5167339444160461,
-0.05565730854868889,
-0.1330157071352005,
0.605790376663208,
-0.3863247036933899,
-0.6072193384170532,
0.02305426262319088,
-0.5428983569145203,
0.34661296010017395,
0.27495214343070984,
0.25081995129585266,
0.7613082528114319,
-0.16139797866344452,
0.4594772756099701,
-0.10121241211891174,
-0.13902968168258667,
-0.6052574515342712,
-0.08943589776754379,
-0.6894249320030212,
-0.5729338526725769,
0.5526608228683472,
0.597561240196228,
-0.7744807600975037,
0.09189533442258835,
-0.43118783831596375,
-0.12795928120613098,
-0.38711073994636536,
0.2738514244556427,
0.5000816583633423,
0.8949911594390869,
0.4574156403541565,
0.004193331580609083,
-0.5693203806877136,
-0.8407765030860901,
-0.2459608018398285,
0.09125865995883942,
-0.19702190160751343,
0.47893044352531433,
0.4033922553062439,
-0.11372355371713638,
1.3962572813034058,
-0.4926811456680298,
-0.3964604437351227,
-0.3986164927482605,
0.17327839136123657,
0.15614965558052063,
0.27957817912101746,
0.6869907975196838,
-0.7768531441688538,
-0.9505077600479126,
-0.06024967133998871,
-0.8403798937797546,
-0.16900880634784698,
-0.03393331915140152,
-0.062176138162612915,
0.20818889141082764,
0.6794987320899963,
-0.4612996280193329,
0.3716399669647217,
0.26155418157577515,
-0.010197527706623077,
0.3801777958869934,
0.1700473129749298,
-0.012461387552320957,
-1.1131635904312134,
0.29022517800331116,
-0.040740497410297394,
-0.562465488910675,
-0.696491003036499,
-0.016575388610363007,
0.23496019840240479,
-0.05267348513007164,
-0.7537230253219604,
0.7924744486808777,
-0.6014987230300903,
-0.17171718180179596,
-0.36517462134361267,
0.2120353728532791,
0.01426866464316845,
0.5597124695777893,
0.14259861409664154,
0.544346034526825,
0.47737863659858704,
-0.7808645367622375,
-0.135686457157135,
0.199222594499588,
-0.14532864093780518,
0.7548636794090271,
-0.5644180178642273,
0.06365837901830673,
-0.23944997787475586,
0.4075789153575897,
-0.7855255007743835,
-0.12756729125976562,
0.4818723797798157,
-0.44557031989097595,
0.6282280683517456,
-0.28881749510765076,
-0.40321096777915955,
0.07535109668970108,
-0.23669902980327606,
0.44607359170913696,
0.24250665307044983,
-0.5341552495956421,
0.6018825173377991,
0.00833149254322052,
0.15277646481990814,
-0.870582103729248,
-0.7508565783500671,
0.11718521267175674,
-0.26675400137901306,
-0.2801129221916199,
0.5359915494918823,
-0.02254989556968212,
-0.2957637906074524,
0.1088726595044136,
-0.197128027677536,
-0.19735883176326752,
0.051591843366622925,
0.1365039199590683,
0.24912001192569733,
-0.19567424058914185,
0.46569111943244934,
-0.05945863947272301,
-0.5874490141868591,
-0.08744664490222931,
-0.051058243960142136,
0.26920655369758606,
0.10106305032968521,
-0.10508996993303299,
-0.38391414284706116,
0.208436980843544,
0.5224944353103638,
-0.18627400696277618,
0.9817755222320557,
0.6291965842247009,
-0.3424668610095978,
0.01644323393702507,
-0.43712565302848816,
-0.4180248975753784,
-0.37127506732940674,
0.28136706352233887,
-0.6503999829292297,
-0.9036587476730347,
0.26083242893218994,
-0.17466874420642853,
0.2173670530319214,
0.513889729976654,
0.21871349215507507,
-0.2133750170469284,
0.7159898281097412,
0.9436788558959961,
-0.26017603278160095,
0.734398603439331,
-0.43739253282546997,
0.02973802201449871,
-1.12558913230896,
-0.06861940026283264,
-0.4505563974380493,
-0.3168511390686035,
-0.44039565324783325,
-0.224645733833313,
0.25236085057258606,
0.21094144880771637,
-0.2629478871822357,
0.46157538890838623,
0.03127027675509453,
0.6987372040748596,
0.2616203725337982,
0.15948423743247986,
0.4106413722038269,
0.006288839969784021,
-0.06251303106546402,
-0.2745806872844696,
-0.9229744672775269,
-0.3380519449710846,
1.0620477199554443,
0.2437392622232437,
0.7733429074287415,
-0.07580971717834473,
0.8531679511070251,
-0.0990947037935257,
0.7597287893295288,
-1.0157474279403687,
0.2886381447315216,
-0.18671146035194397,
-0.7236776351928711,
-0.1772797405719757,
-0.5486254096031189,
-0.7843581438064575,
0.37250393629074097,
-0.4688512980937958,
-0.6455284357070923,
0.400147408246994,
0.23245441913604736,
-0.33492225408554077,
0.315403014421463,
-0.39822277426719666,
0.7220996618270874,
-0.06520108133554459,
-0.49995121359825134,
-0.02065424434840679,
-0.9058230519294739,
0.5581055879592896,
-0.204310804605484,
-0.003266059560701251,
-0.11744768172502518,
-0.2614869475364685,
0.3453882336616516,
-0.15880726277828217,
0.846112072467804,
-0.08020152896642685,
0.0663527250289917,
0.2717020809650421,
0.15626202523708344,
0.3444983661174774,
0.03375963121652603,
-0.08703263103961945,
0.03795968368649483,
-0.17219966650009155,
-0.17291225492954254,
-0.8327584266662598,
0.5042672157287598,
-0.43125104904174805,
-0.2978583574295044,
-0.3060069680213928,
-0.5005332231521606,
-0.24353206157684326,
0.0841556042432785,
0.5831878781318665,
0.7266117334365845,
-0.26130083203315735,
0.6038834452629089,
0.6655339598655701,
-0.15083613991737366,
0.6348011493682861,
0.6325355172157288,
-0.060501713305711746,
-0.4748806655406952,
0.662735104560852,
0.17382489144802094,
0.5114783644676208,
0.942639172077179,
0.06516259163618088,
-0.1325554996728897,
-0.004258674569427967,
-0.19192449748516083,
0.28733909130096436,
-0.7051647901535034,
-0.6621367931365967,
-0.8468442559242249,
-0.2961766719818115,
-0.08912651985883713,
-0.09843620657920837,
-0.25485193729400635,
-0.4883316457271576,
-0.4579118490219116,
-0.00019018983584828675,
0.0693725198507309,
0.316550612449646,
-0.17179329693317413,
0.3923961818218231,
-0.928176999092102,
0.32686153054237366,
0.2615860104560852,
-0.07435421645641327,
0.026434684172272682,
-0.6514304280281067,
-0.28767523169517517,
-0.0175746101886034,
-0.2142678201198578,
-0.7723003029823303,
0.1898445338010788,
0.5580053925514221,
0.4343639016151428,
0.6642852425575256,
0.05817889794707298,
0.8269877433776855,
-0.5924836993217468,
0.21845926344394684,
0.1889287829399109,
-0.8448300957679749,
0.37476593255996704,
-0.21593506634235382,
0.4015670418739319,
0.8226204514503479,
0.5336165428161621,
-0.6539870500564575,
-0.1062411218881607,
-0.6593796610832214,
-0.5926386713981628,
0.8804325461387634,
0.09587859362363815,
0.1987336426973343,
-0.09268364310264587,
0.7351037263870239,
-0.07660865783691406,
0.19860504567623138,
-0.9265146851539612,
-0.24337372183799744,
0.19683045148849487,
-0.14901426434516907,
-0.19008024036884308,
-0.5058192610740662,
0.11466780304908752,
-0.35827016830444336,
0.467195600271225,
-0.26267749071121216,
0.29947200417518616,
0.27001774311065674,
-0.41969478130340576,
-0.16377054154872894,
0.2774239480495453,
0.5192127823829651,
0.8105698227882385,
-0.34763103723526,
0.2354055494070053,
0.6115992069244385,
0.07395821064710617,
0.21575796604156494,
-0.21700525283813477,
-0.16414742171764374,
0.019397571682929993,
0.747406542301178,
0.5958423614501953,
0.8771311640739441,
-0.419805109500885,
0.5665139555931091,
0.0027207140810787678,
-0.248844176530838,
-0.09589334577322006,
0.08945158123970032,
-0.05234004184603691,
0.11248476803302765,
0.43937647342681885,
0.0012083182809874415,
0.10691998153924942,
-0.7684291005134583,
0.5350910425186157,
0.5930699706077576,
-0.6129210591316223,
-0.37270066142082214,
0.34450069069862366,
0.04126700758934021,
-0.1788395196199417,
0.6111598610877991,
-0.11991320550441742,
-0.4532411992549896,
0.3677842915058136,
0.7840269207954407,
0.9031442403793335,
-0.20742762088775635,
0.17660312354564667,
0.7494681477546692,
0.2161085158586502,
0.07141327857971191,
-0.17585809528827667,
-0.4676906168460846,
-0.7179285287857056,
-0.6228169202804565,
-0.4583423137664795,
-0.3077746629714966,
0.04708995297551155,
-0.6457655429840088,
0.549523115158081,
-0.4188470244407654,
-0.04045817628502846,
-0.2802526652812958,
0.018714895471930504,
-0.7391993999481201,
0.10903327167034149,
-0.04505418986082077,
0.9474957585334778,
-0.8323261141777039,
0.9169714450836182,
0.4543476700782776,
-0.38025617599487305,
-0.6684756875038147,
0.17086897790431976,
-0.06145434081554413,
-0.42177528142929077,
1.0976319313049316,
0.35178205370903015,
-0.3041209280490875,
0.05173991993069649,
-0.5366077423095703,
-0.9892240762710571,
1.2240062952041626,
0.6454811692237854,
-0.753297746181488,
0.007016607094556093,
-0.008644822053611279,
0.3939576745033264,
-0.7985836863517761,
0.3784124255180359,
0.4389311671257019,
0.3371598422527313,
0.32838690280914307,
-0.5616047382354736,
-0.030374227091670036,
0.2512502670288086,
-0.2275354564189911,
0.436232328414917,
-0.5638496279716492,
0.7117813229560852,
-0.12157414108514786,
-0.4323316216468811,
-0.011643740348517895,
0.5982773303985596,
0.23231640458106995,
0.3925130367279053,
0.40846148133277893,
0.5062062740325928,
0.445293664932251,
0.0006374260410666466,
1.0038659572601318,
-0.21755537390708923,
0.316386878490448,
1.640557050704956,
-0.32006698846817017,
1.0427054166793823,
0.4522801339626312,
0.2220841944217682,
0.7077349424362183,
0.482308954000473,
0.17298874258995056,
0.5990573763847351,
-0.19992300868034363,
-0.2995343804359436,
-0.41091224551200867,
-0.11501555889844894,
-0.0599995031952858,
0.5727264285087585,
0.23632283508777618,
-0.5143256783485413,
-0.6071422696113586,
0.1409543752670288,
0.07468253374099731,
-0.20406991243362427,
-0.12812215089797974,
0.9130977392196655,
0.4123542606830597,
-0.4256613850593567,
0.2933480441570282,
-0.06700785458087921,
0.5805937647819519,
-0.7105011343955994,
-0.23745010793209076,
-0.14826340973377228,
0.28592246770858765,
-0.2381986677646637,
-0.34257009625434875,
0.44865718483924866,
0.01636601984500885,
-0.38692572712898254,
-0.02469809725880623,
1.0290381908416748,
-0.48443785309791565,
-0.4170271158218384,
0.5014699697494507,
0.6041545271873474,
0.05164794623851776,
-0.1637619286775589,
-0.6909517049789429,
-0.21558021008968353,
-0.17636968195438385,
-0.032030414789915085,
0.4084075391292572,
0.6120699048042297,
0.022861959412693977,
0.6770150661468506,
0.5182851552963257,
-0.16850054264068604,
-0.3358711004257202,
-0.16365543007850647,
0.905578076839447,
-0.7003378868103027,
-0.016940712928771973,
-1.2094907760620117,
0.5925906300544739,
0.00980260968208313,
-0.1547163426876068,
0.7139564156532288,
0.5421671271324158,
0.7653037309646606,
-0.0013444928918033838,
0.4428105354309082,
-0.17981286346912384,
0.4801591634750366,
-0.4781429171562195,
0.3416624963283539,
-0.640865683555603,
0.11448277533054352,
-0.42585739493370056,
-1.2751960754394531,
-0.5953130125999451,
0.49753960967063904,
-0.261959046125412,
0.07617039233446121,
0.794404923915863,
0.6275691986083984,
-0.41977745294570923,
-0.5973262190818787,
0.4949939548969269,
-0.1899409294128418,
0.325479656457901,
0.6297449469566345,
0.8278902173042297,
-0.5587292313575745,
0.6915217638015747,
-0.25931110978126526,
-0.27647820115089417,
-0.19189690053462982,
-1.095367193222046,
-1.0336726903915405,
-0.4721636474132538,
-0.21141912043094635,
0.012295080348849297,
-0.1566142588853836,
1.008268117904663,
0.9168550372123718,
-0.651581883430481,
-0.19566139578819275,
0.07454940676689148,
0.16561159491539001,
-0.12680794298648834,
-0.25181224942207336,
0.12266774475574493,
-0.5215467214584351,
-0.6610321998596191,
0.4075777232646942,
0.44719675183296204,
-0.016553260385990143,
0.04514879733324051,
-0.20970378816127777,
-0.4862399995326996,
-0.06343438476324081,
0.9056539535522461,
0.5009252429008484,
-0.4365507960319519,
-0.2300596535205841,
0.03694258630275726,
-0.10903538763523102,
0.1757798045873642,
0.9917672872543335,
-0.9811539053916931,
0.2674817442893982,
0.4439071714878082,
0.5493125319480896,
0.657452404499054,
0.024949606508016586,
0.6632898449897766,
-0.9492168426513672,
0.10756850242614746,
0.0630488246679306,
0.27021583914756775,
0.33758121728897095,
-0.2700161635875702,
0.8048835396766663,
0.19614778459072113,
-0.5357579588890076,
-0.6465684771537781,
0.2785745859146118,
-0.6372242569923401,
-0.2644747197628021,
1.0055112838745117,
-0.15758010745048523,
-0.20233528316020966,
0.03655480965971947,
-0.08013936877250671,
0.3118206858634949,
-0.286043256521225,
0.4004702866077423,
0.5190280079841614,
-0.264959454536438,
-0.3613754212856293,
-0.537736713886261,
0.5051982402801514,
0.19300559163093567,
-0.8178737163543701,
-0.033602677285671234,
0.3242447078227997,
0.6156871914863586,
0.03416226804256439,
0.6135469079017639,
-0.043430112302303314,
0.22007010877132416,
-0.47722768783569336,
-0.06976645439863205,
-0.0657581090927124,
-0.743667721748352,
-0.45658543705940247,
-0.006262302398681641,
0.07178574055433273,
-0.1973925679922104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17806v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17806v1
|
T-CLAP: Temporal-Enhanced Contrastive Language-Audio Pretraining
| 2024-04-27T07:05:48 | 2024-04-27T07:05:48 |
Yi Yuan, Zhuo Chen, Xubo Liu, Haohe Liu, Xuenan Xu, Dongya Jia, Yuanzhe Chen, Mark D. Plumbley, Wenwu Wang
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
Contrastive language-audio pretraining~(CLAP) has been developed to align the
representations of audio and language, achieving remarkable performance in
retrieval and classification tasks. However, current CLAP struggles to capture
temporal information within audio and text features, presenting substantial
limitations for tasks such as audio retrieval and generation. To address this
gap, we introduce T-CLAP, a temporal-enhanced CLAP model. We use Large Language
Models~(LLMs) and mixed-up strategies to generate temporal-contrastive captions
for audio clips from extensive audio-text datasets. Subsequently, a new
temporal-focused contrastive loss is designed to fine-tune the CLAP model by
incorporating these synthetic data. We conduct comprehensive experiments and
analysis in multiple downstream tasks. T-CLAP shows improved capability in
capturing the temporal relationship of sound events and outperforms
state-of-the-art models by a significant margin.
|
[
-0.10652660578489304,
-0.41421905159950256,
0.5395787358283997,
0.6257585287094116,
-0.43795472383499146,
0.32561981678009033,
0.004941475577652454,
-0.38745495676994324,
0.30664822459220886,
0.12509693205356598,
-0.46044182777404785,
-0.32699882984161377,
-0.622551441192627,
-0.2710035443305969,
-0.6335043907165527,
0.7883961796760559,
0.11015323549509048,
-0.03813499957323074,
0.4051019549369812,
0.03774429112672806,
-0.3628675639629364,
-0.3823898136615753,
-0.6650134921073914,
-0.5977364182472229,
0.4401690661907196,
0.3618033826351166,
0.4225330948829651,
0.471515417098999,
0.3126659691333771,
0.17351937294006348,
0.031992435455322266,
-0.4087465703487396,
-0.2545223534107208,
0.0039000590331852436,
-0.22085128724575043,
-0.5372604131698608,
-0.7140845060348511,
0.1121816635131836,
0.571112334728241,
0.786233127117157,
0.016694391146302223,
0.18141742050647736,
-0.03210029751062393,
0.3464605212211609,
-0.7194437384605408,
0.18670207262039185,
-0.61496901512146,
0.18433310091495514,
-0.5509471893310547,
-0.8870218396186829,
-0.16495612263679504,
-0.28017979860305786,
0.2330605536699295,
-0.4129572808742523,
0.4068537950515747,
0.1541910171508789,
0.904320478439331,
0.41626816987991333,
-0.3968574106693268,
0.14820681512355804,
-0.7011435627937317,
0.9447312951087952,
-0.7784699201583862,
0.7096802592277527,
0.30438199639320374,
0.5381770730018616,
0.2060396373271942,
-0.7483091354370117,
-0.6963788270950317,
-0.3470447361469269,
0.5276758074760437,
0.3894745707511902,
0.16279932856559753,
0.04623638466000557,
-0.023021427914500237,
0.48309075832366943,
-0.18458609282970428,
0.24098141491413116,
-0.08807934820652008,
-0.14306582510471344,
0.19181670248508453,
0.13011130690574646,
0.3430383503437042,
-0.0100487619638443,
-0.5213464498519897,
-0.2730984687805176,
-0.7123041152954102,
-0.13069817423820496,
0.251665323972702,
0.3028118908405304,
-0.5953095555305481,
0.5972530245780945,
0.07218289375305176,
0.22060143947601318,
0.2195218801498413,
-0.28702330589294434,
0.14687424898147583,
-0.2370196282863617,
0.05692727491259575,
0.14433987438678741,
0.7092724442481995,
0.5981544852256775,
0.1389436423778534,
-0.27591267228126526,
-0.5387628674507141,
0.31297093629837036,
-0.22870950400829315,
-0.6688348650932312,
-0.3125043213367462,
0.39020511507987976,
-0.2515454590320587,
-0.35790830850601196,
-0.21101564168930054,
-0.6321726441383362,
-0.22373543679714203,
-0.45353174209594727,
0.6115137934684753,
-0.3658347427845001,
-0.4489879906177521,
-0.030247250571846962,
-0.7057766914367676,
0.07792734354734421,
0.12706758081912994,
-0.8182125091552734,
0.4570596516132355,
0.4437382221221924,
0.8798794150352478,
-0.27714210748672485,
-0.2389129251241684,
-0.9208113551139832,
0.5858514308929443,
-0.3907102048397064,
0.7015329003334045,
-0.664297342300415,
-0.3045123815536499,
0.133217915892601,
-0.463472843170166,
0.03677642345428467,
-0.7063099145889282,
0.2685614824295044,
-0.6580576300621033,
0.09825500100851059,
0.26369544863700867,
-0.48467811942100525,
0.2434210479259491,
-0.1444138139486313,
-0.5246113538742065,
0.8228322267532349,
0.25528794527053833,
-0.7408118844032288,
0.4889879822731018,
-0.46001526713371277,
-0.4442635476589203,
-0.13148146867752075,
-0.13419294357299805,
-0.22501492500305176,
0.2505338191986084,
0.37006670236587524,
0.2946698069572449,
-0.31174924969673157,
0.43025413155555725,
-0.49287107586860657,
-0.5194665789604187,
0.281352162361145,
-0.236396923661232,
0.5492633581161499,
0.09989701211452484,
-0.6022580862045288,
0.18842913210391998,
-0.611812174320221,
-0.29176145792007446,
0.06540802121162415,
-0.29406219720840454,
-0.024569081142544746,
0.04528157785534859,
0.39269331097602844,
0.11505267769098282,
0.20364542305469513,
-0.6620993614196777,
-0.33321353793144226,
-0.29003772139549255,
0.6438897252082825,
0.5438393950462341,
-0.1261504739522934,
0.39598745107650757,
-0.6180706024169922,
0.5504488348960876,
0.3174584209918976,
0.054002486169338226,
-0.5671888589859009,
0.0005566742620430887,
-0.6548628211021423,
-0.11245935410261154,
0.32787418365478516,
0.6078091263771057,
-0.6891800165176392,
0.3043961822986603,
-0.45356208086013794,
-0.23291319608688354,
-0.6516316533088684,
-0.24866293370723724,
0.4458409249782562,
0.7704626321792603,
0.48787179589271545,
-0.33505088090896606,
-0.710532009601593,
-0.6644826531410217,
-0.02335631661117077,
-0.2841559052467346,
-0.4901042580604553,
0.37811556458473206,
0.08035079389810562,
-0.19827274978160858,
0.8262665271759033,
-0.16221876442432404,
-0.5182486176490784,
-0.10184074938297272,
0.3996715247631073,
0.23673821985721588,
0.42000147700309753,
0.5701218843460083,
-0.5359429121017456,
-0.2842172086238861,
-0.14017385244369507,
-0.38794711232185364,
-0.7115436792373657,
-0.05623719096183777,
0.385517954826355,
0.07010302692651749,
0.8083941340446472,
-0.23417459428310394,
0.04874946549534798,
0.7686906456947327,
-0.07720588892698288,
0.8833706974983215,
0.19513794779777527,
0.4551258385181427,
-0.9114205837249756,
0.09698402881622314,
-0.41983306407928467,
-0.25104841589927673,
-0.3798293173313141,
-0.29394662380218506,
0.09872008115053177,
-0.5529380440711975,
-0.6580458283424377,
1.0175641775131226,
-0.3223313093185425,
-0.19445431232452393,
-0.579191267490387,
0.5434809327125549,
-0.06915320456027985,
0.4115922749042511,
0.16526676714420319,
0.8804473280906677,
0.6867768168449402,
-0.891488790512085,
-0.1006549671292305,
0.10409954935312271,
-0.12413300573825836,
0.4427444040775299,
-0.7942814826965332,
0.21253053843975067,
0.16002994775772095,
0.19457164406776428,
-0.9887931942939758,
-0.3173215985298157,
-0.19814571738243103,
-0.559728741645813,
0.6298034191131592,
-0.033492691814899445,
-0.3660445511341095,
-0.21713975071907043,
-0.38506364822387695,
0.8262390494346619,
0.5741484761238098,
-0.8014228940010071,
0.5995416641235352,
0.6092803478240967,
-0.592284083366394,
-0.45302367210388184,
-0.640475332736969,
0.11940580606460571,
-0.28668537735939026,
-0.3444643020629883,
0.8169368505477905,
0.11001574248075485,
-0.12333402037620544,
-0.18483634293079376,
-0.40432247519493103,
-0.15611054003238678,
-0.2285110056400299,
0.09100602567195892,
0.06641742587089539,
-0.2374601513147354,
0.2402462661266327,
0.03892209380865097,
-0.09981800615787506,
-0.09360355138778687,
-0.22428038716316223,
0.811774492263794,
0.1520707607269287,
-0.20695041120052338,
-0.6281921863555908,
0.4920019209384918,
0.4975498914718628,
-0.15230366587638855,
0.19683991372585297,
0.6470124125480652,
0.09600187838077545,
-0.05197545140981674,
-0.8287413716316223,
-0.3271738290786743,
-0.47895997762680054,
0.36191949248313904,
-0.2512667179107666,
-0.8195624351501465,
0.49649786949157715,
-0.30402567982673645,
0.05137983337044716,
0.19951683282852173,
0.007465831935405731,
-0.5315106511116028,
0.8695217370986938,
0.6096827387809753,
-0.17387434840202332,
1.022404432296753,
0.08308570832014084,
-0.14691504836082458,
-0.9094833731651306,
-0.007905724458396435,
-0.5397878885269165,
-0.2260315865278244,
-0.21367421746253967,
-0.40333861112594604,
0.20007012784481049,
0.23271824419498444,
-0.52301424741745,
0.12912596762180328,
0.12199009954929352,
0.06583493202924728,
0.5359876751899719,
0.22654271125793457,
0.023093856871128082,
-0.16244252026081085,
-0.09386467188596725,
-0.3080548346042633,
-0.6166763305664062,
-0.3959694802761078,
0.9677326679229736,
0.41877877712249756,
0.6758370995521545,
0.11792660504579544,
0.7827773690223694,
0.31613969802856445,
0.2041182816028595,
-0.686223030090332,
0.5602991580963135,
-0.3525424897670746,
-0.46275171637535095,
-0.11423176527023315,
-0.32503220438957214,
-0.845186173915863,
-0.13820306956768036,
-0.13914458453655243,
-0.47563332319259644,
-0.17436985671520233,
0.44291815161705017,
-0.06996893882751465,
0.2533617913722992,
-0.7072948813438416,
0.45038434863090515,
-0.2545367479324341,
-0.2853037416934967,
-0.3274572789669037,
-0.46941524744033813,
0.20924556255340576,
-0.14811548590660095,
0.19295620918273926,
-0.1268775463104248,
-0.45368289947509766,
0.8616163730621338,
-0.20660823583602905,
0.99309241771698,
-0.27344414591789246,
-0.04579547792673111,
0.10331179201602936,
0.11877220869064331,
0.23209132254123688,
-0.2977505028247833,
0.025569891557097435,
0.05018037557601929,
-0.18321120738983154,
-0.4964144825935364,
-0.4804766774177551,
0.35264915227890015,
-0.4889042377471924,
-0.732145369052887,
-0.0652521625161171,
-0.5053189396858215,
-0.5348329544067383,
0.14302167296409607,
0.1604277789592743,
0.7555200457572937,
-0.20457734167575836,
0.084755539894104,
0.43308016657829285,
-0.37784406542778015,
0.7599135637283325,
0.6731322407722473,
-0.3626590371131897,
-0.5528669357299805,
0.864355206489563,
-0.3503609001636505,
0.3021695613861084,
0.7348625063896179,
0.4016053080558777,
-0.6075851917266846,
-0.7459412217140198,
0.2157755047082901,
0.4122079014778137,
-0.3601137697696686,
0.0058970218524336815,
-0.5266531109809875,
0.06972027570009232,
-0.5971644520759583,
-0.06731943786144257,
-0.46581438183784485,
-0.556312084197998,
-0.22819463908672333,
0.0237042885273695,
0.007096931338310242,
0.26953116059303284,
-0.169707253575325,
0.714364230632782,
-1.1685822010040283,
0.8312469720840454,
0.3466256260871887,
0.5121606588363647,
-0.02515755221247673,
-0.8302304744720459,
0.038152821362018585,
-0.3985174894332886,
-0.33719876408576965,
-1.0732108354568481,
0.3745936453342438,
0.5524481534957886,
0.5561762452125549,
0.545486569404602,
0.1817661076784134,
0.6862385869026184,
-0.8706565499305725,
0.9461681246757507,
0.6198018193244934,
-1.0965408086776733,
0.9413899183273315,
-0.7039716243743896,
0.6272732615470886,
0.09025014191865921,
0.15460647642612457,
-0.2582233250141144,
-0.7100598216056824,
-0.6432931423187256,
-1.006616473197937,
0.3910524845123291,
0.22632968425750732,
-0.04484879970550537,
-0.2043585330247879,
-0.18671710789203644,
0.2336171716451645,
0.3136495053768158,
-0.5376855731010437,
0.06753358244895935,
-0.3863074481487274,
-0.0626215711236,
-0.2420380711555481,
-0.3244326710700989,
-0.1672723889350891,
0.002027766779065132,
0.42254573106765747,
0.07577293366193771,
0.3959084749221802,
0.08001233637332916,
-0.2602156102657318,
0.030950231477618217,
0.6282779574394226,
0.40485483407974243,
0.3605828285217285,
-0.38566064834594727,
0.274659663438797,
0.013108598068356514,
-0.49448543787002563,
0.07637405395507812,
0.21104983985424042,
0.16511090099811554,
0.1485796719789505,
0.6326795816421509,
0.7816148400306702,
0.7968366146087646,
-0.6785465478897095,
0.2897646427154541,
0.2967155873775482,
0.0400923527777195,
-0.3948596119880676,
-0.018458666279911995,
0.06176493689417839,
0.4815749228000641,
0.5025402307510376,
-0.13112840056419373,
0.16251684725284576,
-0.7517848014831543,
0.3657035529613495,
0.04711815342307091,
-0.4846107065677643,
-0.34778401255607605,
1.0724074840545654,
0.47520408034324646,
-0.46487730741500854,
0.41137343645095825,
0.28253236413002014,
-0.5082322955131531,
0.5213131904602051,
0.7498563528060913,
1.0273981094360352,
-0.4533345699310303,
-0.04821106046438217,
0.2802365720272064,
-0.1933377981185913,
0.1306387037038803,
0.4644300639629364,
-0.5048497915267944,
-0.41903287172317505,
-0.44130659103393555,
-0.6354807615280151,
-0.5425711274147034,
0.24082204699516296,
-0.6722877025604248,
0.09773357212543488,
-0.3196444511413574,
-0.6381354928016663,
-0.15562739968299866,
-0.0815151259303093,
-0.6457939147949219,
0.29153892397880554,
0.13460803031921387,
0.8127315640449524,
-0.9169818758964539,
0.7252741456031799,
0.5258731842041016,
-0.34715351462364197,
-0.5999711751937866,
0.22566577792167664,
-0.1712140291929245,
-0.4935643672943115,
0.8763969540596008,
0.15431492030620575,
-0.281159371137619,
-0.03891908377408981,
-0.3807300627231598,
-0.4522932171821594,
0.8154814839363098,
0.576117992401123,
-0.8079878091812134,
0.01546481903642416,
0.0490662157535553,
0.42467987537384033,
-0.38345927000045776,
0.27609768509864807,
0.6107683181762695,
0.2873794734477997,
0.06862617284059525,
-1.3425918817520142,
-0.24446560442447662,
-0.2623175382614136,
-0.1771058589220047,
0.01770571619272232,
-0.400730699300766,
0.8551009893417358,
-0.36293718218803406,
-0.4420948624610901,
-0.06453098356723785,
0.7906489372253418,
0.6311143636703491,
0.5701046586036682,
0.708959698677063,
0.21826718747615814,
0.607367992401123,
-0.24893859028816223,
1.1905535459518433,
-0.17054341733455658,
-0.3211728632450104,
1.5330427885055542,
-0.17166586220264435,
1.1664575338363647,
0.7003332376480103,
-0.1541454792022705,
0.24631980061531067,
0.49397408962249756,
0.2491079419851303,
0.5677851438522339,
-0.10836468636989594,
-0.4617043733596802,
-0.374362051486969,
-0.5469616055488586,
-0.3736741542816162,
0.2171744704246521,
0.2998126447200775,
-0.06649662554264069,
-0.10300576686859131,
0.13323035836219788,
-0.38031265139579773,
0.1523018628358841,
-0.441263347864151,
0.4781075417995453,
0.42732134461402893,
-0.43853405117988586,
0.32388919591903687,
-0.6774017810821533,
0.8602197766304016,
-0.4765666127204895,
-0.10649652034044266,
-0.24567139148712158,
0.10195338726043701,
-0.033395249396562576,
-0.8169272541999817,
0.03722316771745682,
0.037845589220523834,
-0.19069917500019073,
-0.2208494395017624,
0.2935454845428467,
-0.6451708674430847,
0.20799052715301514,
0.7018606066703796,
0.3070206940174103,
0.18477275967597961,
-0.005556974560022354,
-0.39833736419677734,
0.12239307910203934,
-0.40406760573387146,
0.06991066783666611,
0.15866340696811676,
0.26458603143692017,
0.13775019347667694,
0.7529259324073792,
0.3091805875301361,
0.41628026962280273,
0.24896793067455292,
0.8958776593208313,
0.6361068487167358,
-1.021226167678833,
-0.9280281662940979,
-0.3257620930671692,
0.38161006569862366,
0.0015419877599924803,
0.023821864277124405,
0.3928135633468628,
0.36708196997642517,
0.5988491177558899,
-0.3751884698867798,
0.6274245381355286,
0.19867883622646332,
0.8926478028297424,
-0.6675050258636475,
0.5454497933387756,
-0.7445533871650696,
0.26965612173080444,
-0.27825018763542175,
-0.9585294127464294,
-0.08916417509317398,
-0.06429698318243027,
-0.054008908569812775,
0.10878750681877136,
0.8394656181335449,
0.5933915972709656,
-0.2357397973537445,
-0.1540842205286026,
0.31661146879196167,
0.1989060938358307,
0.48000988364219666,
0.5867787599563599,
0.9736904501914978,
-0.508870542049408,
0.7981827259063721,
-0.08517708629369736,
-0.21229355037212372,
-0.2525540590286255,
-1.039639949798584,
-1.0305616855621338,
-0.6359423398971558,
-0.6045065522193909,
0.07406499981880188,
0.1920919567346573,
0.4593798816204071,
0.8234978914260864,
-0.9876617789268494,
-0.2935432493686676,
0.13080592453479767,
-0.3424825668334961,
-0.17203503847122192,
-0.22766540944576263,
0.44482263922691345,
-0.6232073903083801,
-0.8834466934204102,
0.9114893078804016,
0.14410006999969482,
0.4472702443599701,
0.285431832075119,
-0.040036048740148544,
0.09480378031730652,
0.04772396385669708,
0.6170288920402527,
0.4736410677433014,
-0.5797631740570068,
-0.3639843165874481,
-0.1179981678724289,
0.04277417063713074,
0.036376725882291794,
0.8694322109222412,
-0.7180007100105286,
0.4676893949508667,
0.6203664541244507,
0.43329301476478577,
0.830043375492096,
-0.14132097363471985,
1.086344838142395,
-0.9946328997612,
0.3379470705986023,
0.4914483428001404,
0.36323824524879456,
0.47226980328559875,
0.3611968755722046,
0.3289128839969635,
-0.010906671173870564,
-0.3170679211616516,
-0.7681982517242432,
0.18378283083438873,
-1.4165306091308594,
-0.1577373743057251,
1.0422508716583252,
0.03272046521306038,
-0.037723880261182785,
-0.3533560633659363,
-0.15922878682613373,
0.7983645796775818,
-0.4884570837020874,
1.0247550010681152,
0.39036479592323303,
0.06490818411111832,
-0.4109419286251068,
-0.4309988021850586,
0.5278528332710266,
0.6770215034484863,
-0.4387572407722473,
-0.12059609591960907,
0.31784942746162415,
0.17861419916152954,
0.21968552470207214,
0.7945048213005066,
-0.44053372740745544,
0.6485053896903992,
0.40426671504974365,
-0.1429714560508728,
-0.25307777523994446,
-0.45768529176712036,
-0.2030952274799347,
0.4000983238220215,
0.0247669517993927,
-0.47650542855262756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17802v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17802v1
|
Empirical Analysis of Dialogue Relation Extraction with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-27T06:55:41 | 2024-04-27T06:55:41 |
Guozheng Li, Zijie Xu, Ziyu Shang, Jiajun Liu, Ke Ji, Yikai Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Dialogue relation extraction (DRE) aims to extract relations between two
arguments within a dialogue, which is more challenging than standard RE due to
the higher person pronoun frequency and lower information density in dialogues.
However, existing DRE methods still suffer from two serious issues: (1) hard to
capture long and sparse multi-turn information, and (2) struggle to extract
golden relations based on partial dialogues, which motivates us to discover
more effective methods that can alleviate the above issues. We notice that the
rise of large language models (LLMs) has sparked considerable interest in
evaluating their performance across diverse tasks. To this end, we initially
investigate the capabilities of different LLMs in DRE, considering both
proprietary models and open-source models. Interestingly, we discover that LLMs
significantly alleviate two issues in existing DRE methods. Generally, we have
following findings: (1) scaling up model size substantially boosts the overall
DRE performance and achieves exceptional results, tackling the difficulty of
capturing long and sparse multi-turn information; (2) LLMs encounter with much
smaller performance drop from entire dialogue setting to partial dialogue
setting compared to existing methods; (3) LLMs deliver competitive or superior
performances under both full-shot and few-shot settings compared to current
state-of-the-art; (4) LLMs show modest performances on inverse relations but
much stronger improvements on general relations, and they can handle dialogues
of various lengths especially for longer sequences.
|
[
-0.43426454067230225,
-0.6991580724716187,
0.7611673474311829,
-0.089143767952919,
-0.26845210790634155,
-0.12189187854528427,
-0.3334008753299713,
-0.6139659881591797,
0.1134822890162468,
0.6861857771873474,
-0.6118642091751099,
-0.29467689990997314,
-0.7531417012214661,
0.25119054317474365,
-0.1620723009109497,
0.8953914046287537,
0.16762486100196838,
0.06436827778816223,
-0.06529361009597778,
-0.3629465699195862,
-0.38713696599006653,
-0.44989991188049316,
-0.6779040694236755,
-0.10369588434696198,
0.5397677421569824,
0.2988511919975281,
0.7310304641723633,
0.4409209191799164,
0.6276947259902954,
0.3548600673675537,
-0.17447499930858612,
0.1677222102880478,
-0.7324578762054443,
0.38811132311820984,
0.03566563501954079,
-0.3907187283039093,
-0.4657383859157562,
0.12441477924585342,
0.7996357679367065,
0.7382270693778992,
-0.20634715259075165,
0.24539890885353088,
-0.08604457229375839,
0.6717196106910706,
-0.4891428053379059,
0.3541823625564575,
-0.6616383790969849,
-0.11102919280529022,
-0.12998533248901367,
-0.13826677203178406,
-0.38633474707603455,
-0.1298740804195404,
0.5293911695480347,
-0.3714732229709625,
0.09489967674016953,
-0.13480617105960846,
0.7915356755256653,
0.10685138404369354,
-0.3292306661605835,
-0.24203307926654816,
-0.9657871723175049,
0.9027438163757324,
-1.1702889204025269,
0.39062249660491943,
0.0845172256231308,
0.3006320297718048,
-0.36196961998939514,
-0.814069926738739,
-0.5250518321990967,
-0.4985749125480652,
-0.032087378203868866,
0.016229555010795593,
-0.17293018102645874,
0.2063555270433426,
0.7183087468147278,
0.6314688324928284,
-0.007516831625252962,
0.20242956280708313,
-0.23808756470680237,
-0.005035858601331711,
0.6548494696617126,
0.35814088582992554,
0.2428884655237198,
-0.27814337611198425,
-0.18903329968452454,
0.023941082879900932,
-0.7457135915756226,
-0.0030692322179675102,
0.20209023356437683,
0.29801714420318604,
-0.005657584872096777,
0.6150314211845398,
0.13496039807796478,
0.6216186285018921,
0.04509279504418373,
-0.4427502155303955,
-0.10273853689432144,
-0.49650469422340393,
-0.23362845182418823,
-0.40783271193504333,
1.2276164293289185,
0.28523194789886475,
0.48398298025131226,
-0.10106369107961655,
-0.0908803939819336,
-0.4529820680618286,
-0.12204279750585556,
-1.0902984142303467,
-0.11295545846223831,
0.05905973166227341,
-0.6358923316001892,
-0.06573755294084549,
-0.01881621591746807,
-0.977231502532959,
-0.4996253550052643,
-0.4170996844768524,
0.03844565525650978,
-0.13267095386981964,
-0.605908989906311,
-0.1226130947470665,
-0.15937931835651398,
0.40019941329956055,
0.5317249298095703,
-0.7646600604057312,
0.4656067490577698,
0.6345077753067017,
0.9344335198402405,
-0.08203130960464478,
0.27901822328567505,
-0.7459685206413269,
-0.1525208204984665,
-0.2880001664161682,
0.4169811010360718,
-0.7206753492355347,
-0.41786694526672363,
0.03226371482014656,
-0.026181623339653015,
-0.23084872961044312,
-0.8139994144439697,
0.395225465297699,
-0.5953637957572937,
0.24868562817573547,
-0.27266252040863037,
-0.5223575234413147,
-0.0787048190832138,
0.05836324393749237,
-0.9590848684310913,
0.7762519717216492,
-0.00498607475310564,
-0.7725489735603333,
-0.11873310059309006,
-0.5212195515632629,
-0.09291180223226547,
-0.1827564537525177,
-0.4945746958255768,
-0.39715006947517395,
0.2599051594734192,
0.15177974104881287,
0.5081205368041992,
-0.8742596507072449,
0.2622213065624237,
-0.5121033191680908,
-0.16986455023288727,
0.4837947189807892,
-0.5669052004814148,
0.7442114949226379,
0.24690452218055725,
-0.02071368135511875,
0.02272946387529373,
-0.7118020057678223,
-0.27713993191719055,
0.18717420101165771,
-0.0923699215054512,
-0.32071930170059204,
0.0035815262235701084,
-0.36713749170303345,
0.30682677030563354,
0.06330530345439911,
-0.6022487878799438,
0.24667878448963165,
-0.47246411442756653,
0.47489428520202637,
0.6483123898506165,
0.34897205233573914,
0.42962509393692017,
0.03163779154419899,
0.7329096794128418,
-0.005177816841751337,
-0.14346171915531158,
-0.20692549645900726,
-0.35014668107032776,
-0.6323948502540588,
-0.6699919104576111,
0.6114333868026733,
0.5217444896697998,
-0.42894265055656433,
0.21290946006774902,
-0.3388104736804962,
-0.15413044393062592,
-0.5537834167480469,
0.3672863245010376,
0.2217644900083542,
0.20570680499076843,
-0.0243377648293972,
-0.5024376511573792,
-0.3864055871963501,
-0.9209313988685608,
-0.04697304591536522,
-0.3028583228588104,
-0.21756872534751892,
0.6174614429473877,
0.1725381463766098,
0.0029588250909000635,
1.1643640995025635,
-0.5694631338119507,
-0.14890417456626892,
-0.4414069950580597,
0.038737911731004715,
0.47254109382629395,
-0.0328499935567379,
0.45730307698249817,
-0.6488003134727478,
-0.5305229425430298,
0.014131768606603146,
-0.8237737417221069,
-0.20986995100975037,
-0.06602095812559128,
0.16294988989830017,
0.07452599704265594,
0.4441909193992615,
-1.0377676486968994,
0.34401100873947144,
0.43745720386505127,
0.21606646478176117,
0.7391605377197266,
0.10571000725030899,
0.03137416020035744,
-1.1199842691421509,
-0.03361937403678894,
0.38567185401916504,
-0.3121665418148041,
-0.803115963935852,
-0.03508270904421806,
-0.1508222073316574,
-0.152673602104187,
-0.19565819203853607,
0.3520626425743103,
-0.6199861764907837,
-0.13979263603687286,
-0.17513792216777802,
0.32707422971725464,
-0.20207302272319794,
0.3901703655719757,
0.23412223160266876,
0.749157726764679,
0.3034232258796692,
-0.4166834354400635,
0.4925327003002167,
0.10989552736282349,
-0.2967698574066162,
0.13648687303066254,
-0.7103902697563171,
0.3455611765384674,
-0.007720010355114937,
0.3795161247253418,
-1.132887840270996,
-0.05357127636671066,
0.20632384717464447,
-0.30821692943573,
0.6438691020011902,
-0.4472135305404663,
-0.5472055673599243,
-0.21050392091274261,
-0.4082879424095154,
0.38668549060821533,
0.4916056990623474,
-0.4930350184440613,
0.7361907958984375,
0.36145418882369995,
-0.695350170135498,
-0.549414873123169,
-0.06564996391534805,
0.18563996255397797,
-0.6557460427284241,
-0.7406755685806274,
-0.13550147414207458,
0.03792539983987808,
-0.7185398936271667,
-0.2181798815727234,
-0.2193358987569809,
-0.20298229157924652,
-0.06939660757780075,
0.17411382496356964,
0.42872241139411926,
-0.4041959047317505,
0.04467824473977089,
-0.3715631365776062,
0.015975221991539,
0.1703868955373764,
0.2954714000225067,
0.3385222554206848,
0.15324760973453522,
-0.01034282986074686,
-0.6795489192008972,
0.4245866537094116,
0.8489158153533936,
-0.2497103214263916,
0.756007969379425,
0.410332590341568,
-0.09159794449806213,
-0.007526025176048279,
-0.826754093170166,
-0.30035972595214844,
-0.40689176321029663,
0.5768316388130188,
-0.5471881031990051,
-0.8441097140312195,
0.8133224844932556,
-0.4638947546482086,
0.3209684193134308,
0.4346902370452881,
0.4767850935459137,
0.10640591382980347,
0.9072845578193665,
0.7013598084449768,
-0.4624254107475281,
0.6313512921333313,
-0.24721919000148773,
0.4519992768764496,
-1.0763375759124756,
-0.08779218792915344,
-0.5730540752410889,
0.08880594372749329,
-0.6324062347412109,
-0.39189261198043823,
0.2952123284339905,
0.2485141009092331,
0.008186772465705872,
0.28734228014945984,
0.0892190933227539,
0.14618541300296783,
0.18994200229644775,
-0.18501690030097961,
0.5912585258483887,
0.09698741137981415,
0.2660311758518219,
-0.2678634822368622,
-0.6474653482437134,
-0.5303285717964172,
1.0583277940750122,
0.7570428252220154,
0.8559836149215698,
0.26581621170043945,
0.5854039192199707,
0.03558738902211189,
0.26095643639564514,
-0.9462233185768127,
0.6477360129356384,
-0.03985180705785751,
-0.46661102771759033,
-0.38320472836494446,
-0.8542102575302124,
-0.9372250437736511,
0.5997052192687988,
-0.11141487956047058,
-0.8913653492927551,
0.1820395290851593,
-0.18520009517669678,
-0.32754263281822205,
0.19482846558094025,
-0.6997368335723877,
0.593383252620697,
-0.01784941367805004,
-0.5181291103363037,
-0.23884062469005585,
-0.8197073340415955,
0.5792859196662903,
-0.12184879183769226,
0.2816566526889801,
-0.21724183857440948,
0.2598209083080292,
0.8009925484657288,
-0.4629732370376587,
0.8430171608924866,
-0.12863999605178833,
-0.5178256034851074,
0.3818000853061676,
0.07468516379594803,
0.6785760521888733,
0.15661568939685822,
-0.0036645764485001564,
0.24515393376350403,
0.007691932842135429,
-0.0677759200334549,
-0.7919753789901733,
0.7294493317604065,
-0.6899352073669434,
-0.8181926012039185,
-0.3898096978664398,
-0.7174792289733887,
-0.3166907727718353,
-0.02230861969292164,
-0.1307676136493683,
0.5585039854049683,
-0.2821037173271179,
0.1590650975704193,
0.6786988973617554,
-0.30366626381874084,
0.4691005051136017,
0.6430995464324951,
-0.2513172924518585,
-0.4836452901363373,
0.5979911684989929,
0.14645743370056152,
0.6696051955223083,
0.12780189514160156,
0.07560872286558151,
-0.2679656744003296,
-0.46894487738609314,
-0.3744489848613739,
0.6693621277809143,
-0.49125078320503235,
-0.16346323490142822,
-0.5604649186134338,
-0.4158369302749634,
-0.402424693107605,
0.5896199345588684,
-0.4231995642185211,
-0.531456470489502,
-0.2127431184053421,
-0.03204543888568878,
0.24270516633987427,
0.7081766724586487,
0.0498921237885952,
0.08879541605710983,
-0.951897919178009,
0.5491639375686646,
0.3061450719833374,
0.0829872265458107,
0.05939440056681633,
-0.7025880217552185,
-0.09293871372938156,
0.002487434074282646,
-0.32739606499671936,
-0.8960397839546204,
0.280353844165802,
0.1191328763961792,
0.42029285430908203,
0.5337342023849487,
0.051606204360723495,
0.8929622173309326,
-0.6550488471984863,
0.7981283068656921,
0.41874921321868896,
-0.38798168301582336,
0.095064178109169,
-0.3465096354484558,
0.06663824617862701,
0.4457430839538574,
0.2692812383174896,
-0.3964070975780487,
-0.34803780913352966,
-0.6364631056785583,
-0.7793741822242737,
0.7395978569984436,
0.32291534543037415,
0.20471566915512085,
0.0711703896522522,
0.5204417109489441,
0.05097539350390434,
0.26959216594696045,
-0.6542091369628906,
-0.24136188626289368,
0.45901885628700256,
-0.03480105474591255,
-0.09727950394153595,
-0.6021375060081482,
-0.18739208579063416,
-0.12456150352954865,
0.36915090680122375,
0.21360334753990173,
0.2652300298213959,
0.09437500685453415,
0.06858418136835098,
-0.308002769947052,
0.40502843260765076,
0.3119438886642456,
0.7446108460426331,
-0.423155277967453,
-0.07041586935520172,
0.09398175776004791,
-0.13908174633979797,
-0.11545312404632568,
0.27579575777053833,
0.15014322102069855,
0.09126079082489014,
0.6440137028694153,
0.8488641977310181,
-0.00017826810653787106,
-0.7167622447013855,
0.5952404141426086,
-0.20374329388141632,
-0.0769045427441597,
-0.3485746383666992,
-0.08351793885231018,
0.07143429666757584,
0.4086029827594757,
0.3789847195148468,
-0.1682031899690628,
0.1984902322292328,
-0.7500184774398804,
-0.08648109436035156,
0.841080367565155,
-0.12709572911262512,
-0.417095422744751,
0.18807247281074524,
0.36535221338272095,
-0.39550837874412537,
0.7429339289665222,
0.11263440549373627,
-0.35665929317474365,
0.5207526683807373,
0.4809715449810028,
0.775709331035614,
-0.1564069539308548,
0.15110653638839722,
0.37697550654411316,
0.12602874636650085,
-0.07211826741695404,
-0.34540677070617676,
-0.24665315449237823,
-0.6874076128005981,
-0.9744746685028076,
-0.5665720105171204,
-0.5166159272193909,
0.5874651670455933,
-0.8542281985282898,
0.13378635048866272,
-0.08053851127624512,
-0.20469015836715698,
-0.04748151823878288,
0.26981303095817566,
-0.596304714679718,
-0.23720471560955048,
0.0801578164100647,
0.7415689826011658,
-0.7251002192497253,
0.7285906672477722,
0.23134908080101013,
-0.2815849184989929,
-0.8359916806221008,
-0.020115260034799576,
-0.07860656827688217,
-0.46615344285964966,
0.5423541069030762,
0.15746654570102692,
-0.19895392656326294,
-0.161716029047966,
-0.39689508080482483,
-0.6533587574958801,
0.8623635768890381,
0.519277036190033,
-1.0481969118118286,
-0.15971708297729492,
0.14002147316932678,
0.5463746786117554,
-0.5221641063690186,
0.4311581254005432,
0.875420868396759,
0.19729937613010406,
0.18636064231395721,
-1.2675553560256958,
0.0474628321826458,
-0.05239170789718628,
-0.03713465481996536,
0.4549805819988251,
-0.6375895738601685,
0.41661086678504944,
-0.22142696380615234,
-0.2982107698917389,
0.4486241340637207,
0.5752671957015991,
0.1662406325340271,
0.29260754585266113,
0.5254088044166565,
0.4980851411819458,
0.5605698227882385,
0.20897066593170166,
1.0411056280136108,
-0.04472964257001877,
0.29548439383506775,
1.2448039054870605,
-0.6878777742385864,
0.7803662419319153,
0.529667317867279,
-0.4196772575378418,
0.44012650847435,
0.43101105093955994,
0.27230361104011536,
0.3955155611038208,
0.08678780496120453,
-0.4088546335697174,
-0.34971344470977783,
-0.017014574259519577,
-0.3525236248970032,
0.3278268873691559,
0.48524343967437744,
-0.5790379047393799,
-0.2132052630186081,
-0.23709018528461456,
0.06140328198671341,
-0.11857141554355621,
-0.10671979933977127,
1.1888070106506348,
0.5196047425270081,
-0.6527336835861206,
0.4697321951389313,
-0.2225305438041687,
0.26112663745880127,
-0.7566129565238953,
-0.3360547721385956,
-0.14696824550628662,
0.15539062023162842,
-0.02885928936302662,
-0.33022505044937134,
-0.15558671951293945,
0.10044688731431961,
-0.15211549401283264,
0.21148252487182617,
0.7591730952262878,
-0.5678566694259644,
-0.30135080218315125,
0.40221676230430603,
0.6613656282424927,
0.317382276058197,
0.06990490108728409,
-0.5101345777511597,
0.18991972506046295,
0.16331957280635834,
-0.41291192173957825,
0.5775586366653442,
0.6154968738555908,
0.11943255364894867,
0.49501723051071167,
0.59322190284729,
0.36341366171836853,
-0.007881038822233677,
0.16813959181308746,
0.9227759838104248,
-0.6932008266448975,
0.21106134355068207,
-1.0443395376205444,
0.3252119719982147,
-0.40492376685142517,
0.06647901982069016,
0.8830256462097168,
0.4049574136734009,
0.28385645151138306,
0.07960855215787888,
0.7649434804916382,
0.03079683519899845,
0.551954448223114,
-0.4536777138710022,
-0.009563853032886982,
-0.2545369565486908,
0.5545960068702698,
-0.4011502265930176,
-1.213618516921997,
-0.19845068454742432,
0.5950532555580139,
-0.46535077691078186,
0.03375593572854996,
0.6859809756278992,
0.7084505558013916,
-0.05886220186948776,
0.06684068590402603,
0.29046860337257385,
0.4165275990962982,
0.5811014175415039,
0.43485546112060547,
0.9840063452720642,
-0.13915665447711945,
0.5251992344856262,
-0.0491316020488739,
-0.40278077125549316,
0.0015207199612632394,
-0.8002961277961731,
-1.0539984703063965,
-0.21007196605205536,
-0.34519141912460327,
-0.3052503168582916,
-0.21858662366867065,
0.8866156935691833,
0.6085616946220398,
-0.552951991558075,
-0.4246159791946411,
0.10202164202928543,
-0.05107645317912102,
-0.032240401953458786,
-0.22565065324306488,
0.3347744643688202,
-0.1996309906244278,
-0.8165262937545776,
0.4949398636817932,
0.255648136138916,
-0.20795536041259766,
-0.26754629611968994,
-0.1753704994916916,
-0.09415687620639801,
0.22874371707439423,
0.6688666939735413,
0.4085356593132019,
-0.7026527523994446,
-0.2876293957233429,
-0.2646722197532654,
0.16722235083580017,
0.13427402079105377,
1.0554888248443604,
-0.456554114818573,
0.48157474398612976,
0.3472399413585663,
0.49132099747657776,
0.7510679364204407,
0.26982930302619934,
0.8234304189682007,
-0.6315208077430725,
0.0953570157289505,
0.06455978751182556,
0.4179500937461853,
0.3299477994441986,
-0.09929679334163666,
0.5035825371742249,
0.09843431413173676,
-0.7920624613761902,
-0.9774408340454102,
0.49849098920822144,
-1.025760531425476,
-0.05628400668501854,
1.4599037170410156,
-0.3722821772098541,
0.0976693257689476,
-0.00045977067202329636,
-0.4430134892463684,
0.2277277112007141,
-0.3922695517539978,
0.681535542011261,
0.8437091708183289,
-0.27941516041755676,
-0.28966155648231506,
-0.8472700119018555,
0.23753111064434052,
0.30664995312690735,
-0.5054004192352295,
0.43338072299957275,
0.7152692675590515,
0.43931668996810913,
0.3151569068431854,
0.7063791155815125,
-0.286470890045166,
0.044953010976314545,
-0.337435781955719,
-0.30106106400489807,
0.11570536345243454,
-0.27531203627586365,
-0.36518731713294983,
0.3104458451271057,
0.4407171905040741,
-0.11586471647024155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17790v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17790v1
|
Continual Pre-Training for Cross-Lingual LLM Adaptation: Enhancing Japanese Language Capabilities
| 2024-04-27T06:07:55 | 2024-04-27T06:07:55 |
Kazuki Fujii, Taishi Nakamura, Mengsay Loem, Hiroki Iida, Masanari Ohi, Kakeru Hattori, Hirai Shota, Sakae Mizuki, Rio Yokota, Naoaki Okazaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Cross-lingual continual pre-training of large language models (LLMs)
initially trained on English corpus allows us to leverage the vast amount of
English language resources and reduce the pre-training cost. In this study, we
constructed Swallow, an LLM with enhanced Japanese capability, by extending the
vocabulary of Llama 2 to include Japanese characters and conducting continual
pre-training on a large Japanese web corpus. Experimental results confirmed
that the performance on Japanese tasks drastically improved through continual
pre-training, and the performance monotonically increased with the amount of
training data up to 100B tokens. Consequently, Swallow achieved superior
performance compared to other LLMs that were trained from scratch in English
and Japanese. An analysis of the effects of continual pre-training revealed
that it was particularly effective for Japanese question answering tasks.
Furthermore, to elucidate effective methodologies for cross-lingual continual
pre-training from English to Japanese, we investigated the impact of vocabulary
expansion and the effectiveness of incorporating parallel corpora. The results
showed that the efficiency gained through vocabulary expansion had no negative
impact on performance, except for the summarization task, and that the combined
use of parallel corpora enhanced translation ability.
|
[
-0.3334309756755829,
-0.7439674139022827,
0.40432387590408325,
0.37697136402130127,
-0.541645884513855,
0.49904176592826843,
-0.3548375368118286,
-0.5821459889411926,
0.4356446862220764,
0.5560433268547058,
-0.4182002544403076,
-0.24428251385688782,
-0.7419787645339966,
0.49647974967956543,
0.035719845443964005,
0.7997957468032837,
-0.2656141221523285,
0.17045260965824127,
-0.11501497030258179,
-0.09314461052417755,
-0.8893464803695679,
-0.42545533180236816,
-0.7657528519630432,
-0.20840846002101898,
0.8593584895133972,
0.5332885384559631,
0.5938442349433899,
0.44544821977615356,
0.28072747588157654,
0.32242274284362793,
0.4307030141353607,
0.12084729969501495,
-0.7830702662467957,
0.0715264081954956,
-0.29528120160102844,
-1.0536937713623047,
-0.4175330102443695,
-0.2890985608100891,
1.1614333391189575,
0.8739856481552124,
0.05485084652900696,
-0.19548021256923676,
0.23515649139881134,
0.5862218737602234,
-0.5386335253715515,
-0.18444092571735382,
-0.8395967483520508,
0.08123549073934555,
-0.5208677649497986,
-0.4590732157230377,
-0.2646038234233856,
0.04379844665527344,
0.08196602016687393,
-1.3897616863250732,
-0.41571253538131714,
0.2036643922328949,
0.9382662773132324,
0.22460569441318512,
-0.1083606481552124,
-0.14834129810333252,
-0.39427176117897034,
0.6755180954933167,
-0.5010911822319031,
0.6197491884231567,
0.37127798795700073,
-0.008884623646736145,
-0.15187199413776398,
-0.7335636615753174,
-0.3512944281101227,
-0.28244996070861816,
0.06761568039655685,
0.38482555747032166,
-0.020922867581248283,
0.12504489719867706,
0.10330624133348465,
0.1096324771642685,
-0.8132091760635376,
0.6548198461532593,
-0.30205968022346497,
-0.21423901617527008,
0.49555039405822754,
0.05764586105942726,
0.7280164361000061,
0.12097180634737015,
-0.2994164824485779,
-0.07365554571151733,
-0.8976905345916748,
-0.07425883412361145,
0.28117188811302185,
0.17203330993652344,
-0.09582233428955078,
0.442095011472702,
-0.06290490925312042,
0.41849613189697266,
-0.07163948565721512,
-0.3965877890586853,
0.3052624464035034,
-0.32273221015930176,
-0.06566916406154633,
0.10124462842941284,
0.5626119375228882,
0.03621220588684082,
0.6100315451622009,
-0.36203309893608093,
0.015861494466662407,
-0.18126045167446136,
0.45256373286247253,
-0.661040186882019,
0.10530311614274979,
-0.015370642766356468,
-0.19759979844093323,
0.1461039036512375,
-0.21090781688690186,
-0.48314201831817627,
0.004995831288397312,
-0.2610315978527069,
0.6215277314186096,
-0.4410999119281769,
-0.5094481110572815,
0.20791980624198914,
-0.277554452419281,
0.22453635931015015,
0.13117918372154236,
-0.8330265879631042,
0.5858814716339111,
0.577177107334137,
0.9016237258911133,
-0.5277716517448425,
-0.8103052973747253,
-0.5289894938468933,
0.3233758807182312,
-0.6312344074249268,
0.7244255542755127,
-0.43220624327659607,
-0.5341903567314148,
-0.05078720673918724,
0.1848926544189453,
-0.24254848062992096,
-0.6903235912322998,
-0.07479522377252579,
-0.6758973598480225,
0.22250908613204956,
-0.10409828275442123,
-0.4751250743865967,
-0.1358519047498703,
0.2569064199924469,
-0.44982919096946716,
0.8137774467468262,
0.2388802468776703,
-0.6236223578453064,
0.3115367293357849,
-0.5721473097801208,
-0.8259367942810059,
0.48835352063179016,
0.09471453726291656,
-0.09947679191827774,
0.08361881226301193,
0.21121110022068024,
0.3489112854003906,
-0.07952137291431427,
0.15372499823570251,
-0.3845537304878235,
-0.43263232707977295,
0.17671990394592285,
-0.15374065935611725,
0.5663975477218628,
-0.14577051997184753,
-0.20336222648620605,
-0.06488429009914398,
-0.4890834391117096,
-0.13822674751281738,
0.23885825276374817,
-0.4277327358722687,
-0.6181092858314514,
-0.39092668890953064,
-0.26647117733955383,
-0.22866615653038025,
0.3583776354789734,
-0.15466775000095367,
0.12962257862091064,
-0.4644602835178375,
-0.08072831481695175,
0.6466507315635681,
0.08096159994602203,
0.3058849275112152,
-0.4627446234226227,
0.9509472846984863,
0.031748343259096146,
-0.018493400886654854,
-0.33936813473701477,
-0.26947131752967834,
-0.9601607322692871,
-0.19334657490253448,
0.21967865526676178,
0.7519550919532776,
-1.2093257904052734,
0.34992265701293945,
-0.7290313243865967,
-0.40749821066856384,
-0.47755783796310425,
0.5749967694282532,
0.5411010980606079,
0.4808945953845978,
0.39668330550193787,
-0.7995640635490417,
-0.7163265347480774,
-0.5040243268013,
-0.2319292575120926,
-0.20670342445373535,
-0.07561120390892029,
0.04070817679166794,
0.43447235226631165,
-0.28372350335121155,
0.6013318300247192,
-0.19374312460422516,
-0.11987632513046265,
-0.4984913766384125,
0.06219407171010971,
0.053332049399614334,
0.328090637922287,
0.2465192824602127,
-0.5229536294937134,
-0.5403687357902527,
0.09013010561466217,
-0.6715112924575806,
-0.2592649459838867,
-0.42820224165916443,
-0.30498382449150085,
0.31222379207611084,
0.45810452103614807,
-0.19228719174861908,
0.016363639384508133,
0.5627106428146362,
0.09014569967985153,
0.6896950602531433,
-0.5138630867004395,
-0.041402481496334076,
-1.1572309732437134,
0.12833213806152344,
-0.22565898299217224,
-0.37860965728759766,
-0.6632901430130005,
0.00948150921612978,
0.04956125468015671,
0.0019930365961045027,
-0.5174667239189148,
0.7662555575370789,
-0.7027959823608398,
-0.29804614186286926,
-0.42207393050193787,
0.4269160330295563,
-0.06686127930879593,
0.364594429731369,
0.5600478053092957,
0.9558894038200378,
0.6131945252418518,
-0.9290750026702881,
0.07158638536930084,
0.043019235134124756,
-0.28874582052230835,
0.6025402545928955,
-0.6251943111419678,
0.13241347670555115,
-0.1045297384262085,
0.1065467819571495,
-0.9594363570213318,
-0.14751403033733368,
0.19655272364616394,
-0.30929675698280334,
0.6394627094268799,
0.1927548497915268,
-0.28203949332237244,
-0.19646106660366058,
-0.26801127195358276,
0.12717017531394958,
0.4442404806613922,
-0.5207147598266602,
0.49838128685951233,
0.3939206898212433,
-0.6545735597610474,
-0.49603188037872314,
-0.8636228442192078,
0.23920081555843353,
-0.19407404959201813,
-0.39972907304763794,
0.4758926331996918,
-0.04056740924715996,
0.02344888262450695,
-0.06824765354394913,
0.046040747314691544,
0.1967994123697281,
0.31053289771080017,
-0.12974686920642853,
0.36844679713249207,
-0.34618330001831055,
0.08761344105005264,
0.3689419627189636,
-0.15963268280029297,
-0.018058178946375847,
-0.453654021024704,
0.6722118854522705,
0.11161556839942932,
-0.02844206430017948,
-0.36210787296295166,
0.08284927904605865,
0.1805533468723297,
0.025931211188435555,
0.5904048085212708,
0.4479178488254547,
-0.09764375537633896,
-0.07201185822486877,
-0.6071141362190247,
-0.00861132051795721,
-0.4513135254383087,
0.760837197303772,
-0.6869325637817383,
-1.0014052391052246,
0.3869226276874542,
-0.2952595055103302,
-0.0745023563504219,
0.2986726760864258,
0.2787884771823883,
-0.23188988864421844,
0.4709244966506958,
0.6469468474388123,
-0.36419951915740967,
0.5646190643310547,
-0.016267048195004463,
-0.3490772545337677,
-1.106510877609253,
-0.11740592867136002,
-0.1922801285982132,
-0.23750367760658264,
-0.4848213791847229,
-0.4880124032497406,
0.36633458733558655,
0.2775040566921234,
-0.21962091326713562,
0.3764353096485138,
0.11019282788038254,
0.31463423371315,
0.1146334558725357,
0.08419574797153473,
0.23505347967147827,
0.04188833013176918,
-0.16477330029010773,
-0.05586427450180054,
-0.8951243162155151,
-0.1466163992881775,
1.3481155633926392,
0.4172274172306061,
0.5431140661239624,
0.020079394802451134,
0.7055410742759705,
-0.07256200164556503,
0.4688054025173187,
-0.6008725166320801,
0.5402573347091675,
-0.2572685778141022,
-0.3751578629016876,
-0.4201803505420685,
-0.4244902431964874,
-1.2244338989257812,
0.3929405212402344,
-0.022892126813530922,
-0.4305379390716553,
-0.23695459961891174,
-0.1867632269859314,
-0.1478874832391739,
0.034141700714826584,
-0.40836670994758606,
0.6426460146903992,
-0.8941401243209839,
-0.5119372606277466,
-0.4500349760055542,
-0.5714232325553894,
0.25094088912010193,
-0.546212911605835,
0.27034544944763184,
0.09148845821619034,
-0.8368976712226868,
0.9875467419624329,
-0.14969652891159058,
0.9381639361381531,
-0.13996084034442902,
0.0334644541144371,
-0.025002583861351013,
-0.17919741570949554,
0.3118864893913269,
0.06488361209630966,
0.19211822748184204,
0.3719588816165924,
-0.14889593422412872,
-0.6068308353424072,
-0.4927871823310852,
0.3330775201320648,
-1.1272602081298828,
-0.9111425280570984,
-0.3957004249095917,
-0.5845911502838135,
-0.5641489624977112,
0.41743671894073486,
0.1211034506559372,
0.06612340360879898,
-0.21025873720645905,
0.2256200611591339,
0.6160638928413391,
-0.3299952447414398,
0.30721962451934814,
0.6779366731643677,
-0.5282705426216125,
-0.79282146692276,
0.7544907331466675,
0.3327151834964752,
0.4983064532279968,
0.728324294090271,
0.34592756628990173,
-0.5041623711585999,
-0.6719407439231873,
-0.5712304711341858,
0.615727424621582,
-0.5247247219085693,
0.14276531338691711,
-0.6447187066078186,
0.016266489401459694,
-0.5595571398735046,
-0.18453654646873474,
-0.12595391273498535,
-0.20789018273353577,
-0.4000612199306488,
0.03932269662618637,
0.1033519059419632,
0.4475630223751068,
-0.010524134151637554,
0.5658136606216431,
-0.8548003435134888,
0.33616387844085693,
0.16060979664325714,
0.13391798734664917,
-0.1636865884065628,
-1.0099527835845947,
-0.36464959383010864,
-0.12073079496622086,
-0.09146252274513245,
-0.6531531810760498,
0.37449508905410767,
0.35684433579444885,
0.8784136772155762,
0.18792523443698883,
-0.3212651014328003,
1.2482918500900269,
-0.32555845379829407,
0.6412026882171631,
0.31415504217147827,
-0.8402196168899536,
0.32748422026634216,
-0.2527111768722534,
0.7361379265785217,
0.6821205019950867,
1.1363046169281006,
-0.6641744375228882,
-0.37266236543655396,
-0.3132800757884979,
-0.6832303404808044,
0.5646530389785767,
-0.2556324303150177,
0.30467939376831055,
0.19086351990699768,
0.4450882077217102,
0.2579197287559509,
0.12348365783691406,
-0.7062248587608337,
0.23563620448112488,
-0.21737748384475708,
-0.004120425321161747,
-0.4285776913166046,
-0.15335093438625336,
0.2730643153190613,
-0.2873631715774536,
0.8759230375289917,
-0.3013666570186615,
-0.24393169581890106,
0.12518925964832306,
-0.6701880693435669,
0.2927795648574829,
0.04537954926490784,
0.4064258635044098,
0.6819407343864441,
0.20338831841945648,
-0.04758227616548538,
0.7087564468383789,
-0.7839186191558838,
0.09873967617750168,
0.025662554427981377,
0.056033361703157425,
-0.10609244555234909,
0.7162428498268127,
0.8461400866508484,
0.6540350317955017,
-0.7491743564605713,
0.03946235030889511,
0.1772046536207199,
-0.14303965866565704,
-0.2477501779794693,
0.14335328340530396,
0.27168431878089905,
-0.09048748761415482,
0.258805513381958,
-0.6249405741691589,
-0.21549350023269653,
-0.7749642133712769,
0.042080096900463104,
0.16982541978359222,
0.0902458131313324,
-0.1555623859167099,
0.3751146197319031,
0.21279434859752655,
-0.017027873545885086,
0.6127917766571045,
-0.0082866121083498,
-0.6935288906097412,
0.3501411974430084,
1.0259575843811035,
0.6766014099121094,
-0.4645032286643982,
-0.07192611694335938,
0.39754676818847656,
0.369601845741272,
-0.13753379881381989,
0.1816355437040329,
-0.2692628800868988,
-0.8499450087547302,
-0.4673551619052887,
-0.5620703101158142,
-0.5497786998748779,
0.08324781060218811,
-0.5538366436958313,
0.22584255039691925,
-0.540619432926178,
0.0851317048072815,
-0.3826022744178772,
0.4404677748680115,
-0.5616713166236877,
0.35533440113067627,
0.14616821706295013,
0.842332124710083,
-0.6412615180015564,
1.1550878286361694,
0.7356975078582764,
-0.5352988839149475,
-0.738578200340271,
-0.05144593492150307,
-0.2398419976234436,
-1.1010342836380005,
0.5701239109039307,
0.1790388971567154,
-0.1985016018152237,
0.11815822124481201,
0.055955059826374054,
-1.109680414199829,
1.1849884986877441,
0.2487524002790451,
-0.9641535878181458,
0.08162779361009598,
0.5356830954551697,
0.6143172979354858,
-0.4293527901172638,
0.29313546419143677,
0.535337507724762,
0.47277888655662537,
-0.1551889181137085,
-0.9427514672279358,
0.019540278241038322,
-0.24247179925441742,
0.5634965896606445,
-0.16270972788333893,
-0.5067291259765625,
0.34738659858703613,
-0.02183401957154274,
-0.21579603850841522,
0.06180619075894356,
0.8279219269752502,
0.33035826683044434,
0.018019508570432663,
0.7076441645622253,
0.4408749043941498,
1.078818440437317,
0.14497126638889313,
0.9188390970230103,
-0.23570387065410614,
-0.4112382233142853,
1.2236298322677612,
-0.5902684330940247,
1.180165410041809,
0.5614563226699829,
-0.17114274203777313,
0.7857263684272766,
0.5542539358139038,
0.18033766746520996,
0.3734632730484009,
0.17319034039974213,
-0.07905154675245285,
-0.15885326266288757,
-0.037676773965358734,
-0.3969193994998932,
0.4340475797653198,
0.5387667417526245,
0.08400203287601471,
0.21950747072696686,
0.5301784873008728,
0.32598745822906494,
0.05112924054265022,
-0.5419739484786987,
0.9131041765213013,
0.25968727469444275,
-1.0408411026000977,
0.726387619972229,
-0.23272588849067688,
1.1525763273239136,
-1.046056866645813,
0.4965166449546814,
-0.4157847762107849,
0.12968412041664124,
-0.12389440089464188,
-0.7323930859565735,
0.4052213728427887,
0.21478866040706635,
0.2137935906648636,
-0.248732790350914,
0.7730053067207336,
-0.447490394115448,
-0.3460483253002167,
0.596613883972168,
0.3885711133480072,
0.4966978430747986,
0.04393131285905838,
-0.5177918672561646,
0.4069141447544098,
-0.22633245587348938,
-0.21818412840366364,
0.6821462512016296,
0.16846895217895508,
-0.01822180300951004,
0.5653566122055054,
0.8311514854431152,
0.42294976115226746,
0.13366423547267914,
0.1825498789548874,
0.7016339898109436,
-0.4038068354129791,
-0.5304675102233887,
-0.5841778516769409,
0.37213826179504395,
-0.007726161275058985,
-0.33300870656967163,
0.7592591643333435,
0.7045052647590637,
1.34473717212677,
-0.07850757986307144,
0.8969369530677795,
0.2994430661201477,
0.32932254672050476,
-0.8024744391441345,
0.7057066559791565,
-0.9032248854637146,
0.016115562990307808,
-0.010552827268838882,
-0.7864658832550049,
-0.24998410046100616,
0.37582746148109436,
-0.3823854625225067,
0.12818007171154022,
0.8928705453872681,
0.7875697016716003,
0.15988728404045105,
-0.2646104097366333,
0.571173906326294,
0.22931793332099915,
0.14790339767932892,
0.7635100483894348,
0.7512557506561279,
-0.2490633875131607,
0.543800413608551,
-0.1959158033132553,
-0.15549303591251373,
-0.07595723122358322,
-0.8207977414131165,
-0.7285703420639038,
-0.43297889828681946,
-0.3107331395149231,
-0.06447719782590866,
0.31911513209342957,
0.59703528881073,
0.6719236373901367,
-0.4244782328605652,
-0.6391751766204834,
-0.1467861384153366,
-0.11928781121969223,
-0.13089777529239655,
-0.13413961231708527,
-0.023092348128557205,
-0.8457996845245361,
-0.6768662929534912,
0.6784624457359314,
0.4088134169578552,
-0.07084141671657562,
-0.354744017124176,
-0.43985745310783386,
-0.31375589966773987,
0.026752352714538574,
0.6065683960914612,
0.4747302234172821,
-0.49440333247184753,
-0.18977785110473633,
0.11930026113986969,
0.021851275116205215,
0.08828336745500565,
0.47568997740745544,
-0.7143200635910034,
0.572653591632843,
0.3732827603816986,
1.0928032398223877,
0.6867878437042236,
-0.2711555063724518,
0.7130170464515686,
-0.5653823614120483,
0.284943163394928,
0.04279960319399834,
0.3267081081867218,
0.4148850440979004,
-0.21803371608257294,
0.39294853806495667,
0.3208964169025421,
-0.23733095824718475,
-0.5927702188491821,
-0.0698782205581665,
-0.8908036351203918,
-0.43403616547584534,
1.205808162689209,
-0.40217337012290955,
-0.33786678314208984,
-0.33946189284324646,
-0.08107774704694748,
0.4236259460449219,
0.20570018887519836,
0.3833657503128052,
0.7463458180427551,
0.05858707055449486,
-0.3045330047607422,
-0.25963544845581055,
-0.00959161389619112,
0.7189157605171204,
-1.3534940481185913,
-0.3737644553184509,
0.043912287801504135,
0.6445972323417664,
0.02861463651061058,
0.9263805747032166,
-0.13772758841514587,
0.4926055073738098,
0.13371606171131134,
-0.1310044676065445,
-0.11606132984161377,
-0.5446469187736511,
-0.49393925070762634,
-0.06612689048051834,
0.40104907751083374,
-0.13131120800971985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17785v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17785v2
|
Temporal Scaling Law for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-27T05:49:11 | 2024-06-16T11:06:01 |
Yizhe Xiong, Xiansheng Chen, Xin Ye, Hui Chen, Zijia Lin, Haoran Lian, Zhenpeng Su, Jianwei Niu, Guiguang Ding
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have been widely adopted in a wide
range of tasks, leading to increasing attention towards the research on how
scaling LLMs affects their performance. Existing works, termed Scaling Laws,
have discovered that the final test loss of LLMs scales as power-laws with
model size, computational budget, and dataset size. However, the temporal
change of the test loss of an LLM throughout its pre-training process remains
unexplored, though it is valuable in many aspects, such as selecting better
hyperparameters \textit{directly} on the target LLM. In this paper, we propose
the novel concept of Temporal Scaling Law, studying how the test loss of an LLM
evolves as the training steps scale up. In contrast to modeling the test loss
as a whole in a coarse-grained manner, we break it down and dive into the
fine-grained test loss of each token position, and further develop a dynamic
hyperbolic-law. Afterwards, we derive the much more precise temporal scaling
law by studying the temporal patterns of the parameters in the dynamic
hyperbolic-law. Results on both in-distribution (ID) and out-of-distribution
(OOD) validation datasets demonstrate that our temporal scaling law accurately
predicts the test loss of LLMs across training steps. Our temporal scaling law
has broad practical applications. First, it enables direct and efficient
hyperparameter selection on the target LLM, such as data mixture proportions.
Secondly, viewing the LLM pre-training dynamics from the token position
granularity provides some insights to enhance the understanding of LLM
pre-training.
|
[
-0.282758504152298,
-0.9167314767837524,
0.6143029928207397,
0.40378716588020325,
-0.24168354272842407,
-0.2016800343990326,
-0.3859032094478607,
-0.28711384534835815,
-0.0944044440984726,
0.3564770221710205,
-0.5745688080787659,
-0.021914394572377205,
-0.5242418646812439,
-0.19243000447750092,
-0.4631568193435669,
0.9571529030799866,
-0.24153687059879303,
0.009424143470823765,
-0.0668075829744339,
-0.1362341344356537,
-0.1641664355993271,
-0.5109843015670776,
-0.5680453777313232,
-0.670650064945221,
0.4957207143306732,
-0.0413578562438488,
0.6478882431983948,
1.1162102222442627,
0.44700950384140015,
0.19361887872219086,
-0.5043814182281494,
-0.4712744951248169,
-0.4544549882411957,
-0.06728129833936691,
-0.02750074677169323,
-0.7107529640197754,
-0.4491253197193146,
-0.0069072190672159195,
1.0406248569488525,
0.8360755443572998,
-0.32747596502304077,
0.3934665024280548,
0.15680813789367676,
0.3187183439731598,
-0.5989287495613098,
0.333768367767334,
-0.6298903822898865,
0.1989317536354065,
-0.5354514718055725,
-0.5592010021209717,
-0.48487162590026855,
-0.3238624632358551,
-0.1326577365398407,
-0.4559018313884735,
0.09967761486768723,
0.11264096945524216,
0.8446669578552246,
0.2847546339035034,
-0.49433624744415283,
-0.008818409405648708,
-0.7612810134887695,
0.7018297910690308,
-0.840694785118103,
0.5274213552474976,
-0.006505777593702078,
0.42395344376564026,
-0.20632848143577576,
-0.5648313164710999,
-0.6810686588287354,
-0.5351966619491577,
0.11045950651168823,
-0.29226353764533997,
0.09675926715135574,
0.07211626321077347,
0.28852301836013794,
0.28033366799354553,
-0.40979424118995667,
0.5291257500648499,
0.016444392502307892,
-0.0228209737688303,
0.2940363883972168,
0.38189324736595154,
0.13832004368305206,
0.2322816699743271,
-0.23012132942676544,
-0.20710253715515137,
-0.8614410758018494,
-0.15117716789245605,
0.3470439910888672,
0.3935733139514923,
-0.18944045901298523,
0.48154258728027344,
0.16450135409832,
0.41214025020599365,
0.26469749212265015,
-0.34653833508491516,
0.2527700662612915,
-0.46683481335639954,
-0.18564927577972412,
0.26012948155403137,
0.6365249752998352,
0.23999831080436707,
0.43629273772239685,
0.03878068923950195,
-0.03298270329833031,
-0.3880472481250763,
-0.13430163264274597,
-1.117547869682312,
0.07290353626012802,
-0.2397305965423584,
-0.333651065826416,
-0.33097556233406067,
-0.3255184590816498,
-0.4089469909667969,
-0.4574124217033386,
-0.35842958092689514,
0.48397862911224365,
-0.1647864580154419,
-0.335536926984787,
0.2285289764404297,
0.2004222869873047,
0.3410489857196808,
0.127485990524292,
-0.9020232558250427,
0.3658786118030548,
0.7535005807876587,
0.9241907596588135,
0.010638803243637085,
-0.5440722703933716,
-0.863212525844574,
0.11875461041927338,
-0.468961626291275,
0.21393916010856628,
-0.43460962176322937,
-0.06976904720067978,
0.05553259328007698,
0.0605008564889431,
-0.09246810525655746,
-0.5924522280693054,
-0.060125019401311874,
-0.8285514712333679,
-0.1987684816122055,
0.10207141935825348,
-0.4312691390514374,
0.3057793080806732,
0.24913646280765533,
-0.5019105672836304,
1.0685834884643555,
-0.15041716396808624,
-0.6179593205451965,
0.6432130336761475,
-0.4955252707004547,
-0.558687150478363,
-0.023815102875232697,
-0.1733020544052124,
-0.7519733309745789,
0.20431524515151978,
-0.10860157757997513,
0.5853642821311951,
-0.3850119411945343,
0.14882345497608185,
-0.7001857161521912,
-0.3036418855190277,
0.18560680747032166,
-0.3451220989227295,
0.6592246890068054,
-0.007427237927913666,
-0.49878400564193726,
-0.0670764371752739,
-0.6799421310424805,
0.05629536882042885,
0.2352989763021469,
-0.5360881686210632,
-0.3087363839149475,
0.16001911461353302,
0.009587359614670277,
0.06860394030809402,
0.18450701236724854,
-0.5684780478477478,
0.23881293833255768,
-0.21492204070091248,
0.5224029421806335,
0.9029033780097961,
0.16755220293998718,
0.4300169348716736,
-0.09211181104183197,
0.3378625810146332,
0.05077873170375824,
0.44743990898132324,
-0.005264106206595898,
-0.06998229026794434,
-0.4067946970462799,
-0.17171595990657806,
0.18497665226459503,
0.38094422221183777,
-0.16678304970264435,
0.4639028012752533,
-0.6139079928398132,
-0.4991835355758667,
0.0351908877491951,
0.10612820833921432,
0.21100150048732758,
0.28823012113571167,
0.20402272045612335,
-0.10205681622028351,
-0.4011763632297516,
-0.5096086263656616,
-0.07894639670848846,
-0.3636895418167114,
-0.034940049052238464,
0.12397437542676926,
0.5873042941093445,
-0.1952906996011734,
0.8030894994735718,
-0.4615381360054016,
-0.250723272562027,
-0.27613914012908936,
0.22056113183498383,
0.19215087592601776,
0.34999194741249084,
0.6503596901893616,
-0.5668053030967712,
-0.15694734454154968,
0.20354385673999786,
-0.2193707525730133,
-0.4710148274898529,
-0.23396697640419006,
0.18203474581241608,
0.06483135372400284,
0.9111832976341248,
-0.4146856367588043,
0.33340972661972046,
0.656488835811615,
-0.39544135332107544,
0.8862031698226929,
-0.5070021748542786,
-0.048302061855793,
-0.9190537929534912,
-0.1718079298734665,
-0.1004747822880745,
-0.18328459560871124,
-0.22739477455615997,
-0.02510422095656395,
0.35386016964912415,
0.18366806209087372,
-0.6174687743186951,
0.87420254945755,
-0.3106519877910614,
-0.17252300679683685,
-0.1780068725347519,
-0.2368190437555313,
-0.21267296373844147,
0.3742297887802124,
-0.15954558551311493,
0.7135160565376282,
0.44128426909446716,
-0.8675107955932617,
0.17127591371536255,
-0.2700413465499878,
-0.2604411840438843,
0.4189484119415283,
-0.7579386234283447,
-0.16186946630477905,
-0.01701408252120018,
0.27321305871009827,
-0.7470670342445374,
0.04753736034035683,
-0.3511083424091339,
-0.06720633059740067,
0.38095590472221375,
-0.37487953901290894,
-1.0933905839920044,
-0.14748698472976685,
-0.18388262391090393,
0.7525256872177124,
0.6432088613510132,
-0.6227849125862122,
0.5693805813789368,
0.18982256948947906,
-0.005793039221316576,
-0.25296786427497864,
-0.76507568359375,
-0.10072371363639832,
-0.39914655685424805,
-0.293851375579834,
0.39764392375946045,
-0.3438331186771393,
-0.40671664476394653,
-0.13928040862083435,
-0.061729032546281815,
-0.2377016842365265,
0.12151148170232773,
0.29055097699165344,
0.03332385793328285,
-0.45355087518692017,
0.33068230748176575,
-0.07346031069755554,
0.16985809803009033,
0.3850463628768921,
-0.27697914838790894,
1.0601269006729126,
-0.08346125483512878,
-0.2874351739883423,
-0.4362836480140686,
-0.1297662854194641,
0.865120530128479,
-0.35295534133911133,
0.918231189250946,
0.5060809850692749,
-0.142530158162117,
-0.07194013893604279,
-0.5284019112586975,
-0.08986850082874298,
-0.4562889039516449,
0.5869991183280945,
-0.29986920952796936,
-0.4801824688911438,
0.720335066318512,
-0.11019568145275116,
-0.047724056988954544,
0.5904867053031921,
0.8970311284065247,
0.027810396626591682,
0.9450143575668335,
0.6798972487449646,
-0.12844474613666534,
0.9903515577316284,
-0.213819682598114,
-0.157593235373497,
-0.7992571592330933,
-0.2086915373802185,
-0.39805087447166443,
-0.3206152319908142,
-0.6055669784545898,
-0.46474510431289673,
0.4202960729598999,
-0.12517906725406647,
-0.7073092460632324,
0.02786051481962204,
0.1215844377875328,
0.7529672384262085,
0.11720961332321167,
0.006694269832223654,
0.24486149847507477,
-0.18905168771743774,
-0.22744245827198029,
0.07431046664714813,
-0.3518698513507843,
-0.11890994757413864,
1.1238988637924194,
0.4363201856613159,
0.8932653665542603,
0.07348693162202835,
0.6346989274024963,
0.3228243291378021,
0.280727744102478,
-0.7897846102714539,
0.7152128219604492,
0.04726249724626541,
-0.45362499356269836,
-0.6361531019210815,
-0.7475261092185974,
-1.0893462896347046,
-0.010481754317879677,
0.08848099410533905,
-0.3347492516040802,
-0.14954113960266113,
0.10026347637176514,
-0.2808176577091217,
0.7265743017196655,
-0.3894745707511902,
0.6994752883911133,
-0.3052443861961365,
-0.23906943202018738,
-0.4105457365512848,
-0.6014128923416138,
-0.11105785518884659,
-0.3743549585342407,
0.11252330243587494,
-0.22046217322349548,
-0.27720606327056885,
0.8365049362182617,
-0.7830811142921448,
0.8146972060203552,
-0.2556527256965637,
-0.18915849924087524,
0.1452907770872116,
0.2652163505554199,
0.633110761642456,
-0.03509004786610603,
0.1278306245803833,
0.060783080756664276,
-0.05267239734530449,
-0.5655737519264221,
-0.705771267414093,
0.6320031881332397,
-0.684687077999115,
-0.2207207828760147,
-0.28526344895362854,
-0.6525774002075195,
-0.0469435416162014,
0.29639288783073425,
0.13649882376194,
0.5373298525810242,
-0.05678165704011917,
0.1278039515018463,
0.9156748056411743,
-0.039526019245386124,
0.5638028979301453,
0.6134631037712097,
-0.3915175497531891,
0.09362161159515381,
0.6478119492530823,
0.36421072483062744,
0.5055218935012817,
0.5008106827735901,
0.6790000796318054,
-0.30531975626945496,
-0.9801225662231445,
-0.11498932540416718,
0.6248466372489929,
-0.49881765246391296,
0.18872275948524475,
-0.3322189152240753,
-0.12465661019086838,
-0.3975936472415924,
-0.15662483870983124,
-0.45978257060050964,
-0.2414574921131134,
-0.07976163923740387,
0.08322001248598099,
0.4245087504386902,
0.48341241478919983,
0.08039350807666779,
0.4467582702636719,
-0.5224658250808716,
-0.10484263300895691,
0.30733779072761536,
0.4946758449077606,
-0.14188328385353088,
-0.9121587872505188,
-0.1980128437280655,
-0.2653250992298126,
-0.08279702067375183,
-0.5103387236595154,
0.18317146599292755,
0.446206659078598,
0.4213268458843231,
0.3965763747692108,
-0.23720470070838928,
0.820334255695343,
-0.8598389029502869,
0.5829513669013977,
0.2647535502910614,
-0.8407039046287537,
0.4439575672149658,
-0.41984856128692627,
0.5760710835456848,
0.24331538379192352,
0.06456959247589111,
-0.5055500268936157,
-0.29901590943336487,
-0.5203592777252197,
-0.8139902949333191,
0.3393913507461548,
-0.11757634580135345,
0.3189220130443573,
0.11571881920099258,
0.6298683285713196,
0.03248555585741997,
0.023548727855086327,
-0.5853069424629211,
-0.11527418345212936,
0.20204707980155945,
-0.024570511654019356,
-0.2965947389602661,
-0.08297672122716904,
0.17083436250686646,
-0.29970231652259827,
0.3906306326389313,
-0.09429890662431717,
0.10878771543502808,
-0.17685458064079285,
-0.17247553169727325,
-0.12321484088897705,
0.2773907780647278,
0.5393376350402832,
0.583707332611084,
-0.27792835235595703,
0.08844374120235443,
0.3949015736579895,
-0.7115236520767212,
0.4334128499031067,
0.18149183690547943,
0.09448087960481644,
-0.1934729516506195,
0.5565755367279053,
0.6523916721343994,
0.4882220923900604,
-0.7551866769790649,
0.5147280693054199,
0.07753092795610428,
-0.04005735367536545,
-0.39584022760391235,
-0.06643998622894287,
-0.1712491661310196,
0.40002602338790894,
0.4378475844860077,
-0.27140671014785767,
-0.3630552887916565,
-0.7138360738754272,
0.24698948860168457,
0.07404755800962448,
-0.3432365655899048,
-0.5148732662200928,
0.8309504389762878,
-0.10072088241577148,
-0.1307084560394287,
0.617657482624054,
-0.27928903698921204,
-0.24989023804664612,
0.7649562954902649,
0.5448063611984253,
0.7020096182823181,
-0.42256292700767517,
0.02124602347612381,
0.10953957587480545,
0.2922719419002533,
-0.2958756983280182,
-0.08220979571342468,
-0.04660935699939728,
-0.3848781883716583,
-0.6764841079711914,
-0.5967877507209778,
-0.2717078924179077,
0.2621860206127167,
-0.6541506052017212,
0.21767257153987885,
-0.7002980709075928,
-0.3056582510471344,
-0.105568528175354,
0.09360089153051376,
-0.7656631469726562,
0.25170546770095825,
0.2842065095901489,
0.9642787575721741,
-0.6783125400543213,
0.7702781558036804,
0.5031741857528687,
-0.05586700141429901,
-0.5377888083457947,
0.3235812187194824,
0.18811136484146118,
-1.0269917249679565,
0.9746463894844055,
-0.0449756383895874,
-0.14648419618606567,
0.009663889184594154,
-0.2387227863073349,
-0.902800440788269,
1.1846840381622314,
0.6778021454811096,
-0.6522250771522522,
-0.309253066778183,
0.2741769850254059,
0.6810365915298462,
-0.3212563395500183,
0.15208783745765686,
0.5939682126045227,
0.26896101236343384,
0.2669859528541565,
-1.2355831861495972,
0.05838477984070778,
-0.01056545041501522,
-0.062479257583618164,
0.9359670281410217,
-0.6136456727981567,
1.1360121965408325,
-0.4552716910839081,
-0.11834608018398285,
-0.1694549173116684,
0.6032707095146179,
0.0747566968202591,
0.24667316675186157,
0.7222756743431091,
0.4777581989765167,
0.6275233030319214,
-0.05056479945778847,
1.2631120681762695,
-0.18960653245449066,
0.4218405485153198,
1.1166695356369019,
-0.30734682083129883,
0.9944559931755066,
0.47499820590019226,
-0.2948587238788605,
0.2860281467437744,
0.6426169872283936,
0.14300847053527832,
0.32688191533088684,
0.6140871047973633,
0.05876839905977249,
-0.19126595556735992,
-0.21947655081748962,
-0.3619925081729889,
0.23417459428310394,
0.008825658820569515,
-0.3171939551830292,
-0.2839527130126953,
0.09929448366165161,
0.4184054136276245,
-0.23821386694908142,
-0.6914198398590088,
0.3892408311367035,
-0.21459947526454926,
-0.07546842098236084,
0.6358516812324524,
-0.30423083901405334,
0.4071560204029083,
-0.7475878596305847,
0.44431570172309875,
-0.24412745237350464,
0.41552117466926575,
0.1498156189918518,
-0.8608472943305969,
0.09941732883453369,
-0.21403418481349945,
-0.13377249240875244,
-0.3886662423610687,
-0.06943726539611816,
-0.3220216929912567,
-0.5062261819839478,
0.474234014749527,
0.19210116565227509,
0.04572581127285957,
-0.23330049216747284,
-0.48425111174583435,
0.28557872772216797,
-0.49943670630455017,
-0.5657480359077454,
0.56028151512146,
0.5921730399131775,
-0.1415291130542755,
0.8437798023223877,
0.3263661563396454,
0.6285943388938904,
0.4965464174747467,
0.2553264796733856,
0.7268611788749695,
-0.6284309029579163,
-0.5255141854286194,
-1.020243525505066,
-0.10171711444854736,
0.054614029824733734,
-0.33677342534065247,
0.6900334358215332,
0.5968607664108276,
0.8044701218605042,
0.3672209084033966,
0.4213657081127167,
0.17646239697933197,
0.12884913384914398,
-0.6720908284187317,
0.6858521103858948,
-0.7142409682273865,
0.13918106257915497,
0.052207086235284805,
-0.9367036819458008,
-0.3996939957141876,
-0.17852066457271576,
-0.4087076783180237,
0.11769759654998779,
0.7776129245758057,
0.7241017818450928,
-0.02584156021475792,
-0.5026476979255676,
0.34212273359298706,
0.5287166833877563,
0.5218206644058228,
0.5188974738121033,
0.5568491220474243,
-0.12361092120409012,
0.7856690883636475,
0.053041763603687286,
-0.24471960961818695,
-0.44645020365715027,
-0.8129042983055115,
-0.918071985244751,
-0.6149855852127075,
-0.5422301888465881,
-0.241776242852211,
-0.06614181399345398,
0.8511079549789429,
0.7704631090164185,
-0.37573668360710144,
-0.3822641968727112,
0.079852394759655,
-0.28817397356033325,
-0.45262983441352844,
-0.2219170480966568,
0.3723258078098297,
-0.437139630317688,
-0.487761914730072,
0.07657276093959808,
0.3002060353755951,
0.4108417332172394,
-0.43219509720802307,
-0.10352672636508942,
-0.1090187281370163,
0.33927470445632935,
0.6251892447471619,
0.1769903004169464,
-0.49384626746177673,
-0.21516217291355133,
-0.23221197724342346,
-0.16025352478027344,
0.17033717036247253,
1.1804308891296387,
-0.542166531085968,
0.3908523619174957,
0.4911896586418152,
0.5819936990737915,
0.639137864112854,
-0.6093405485153198,
0.37046653032302856,
-0.7952643036842346,
0.19864244759082794,
0.18045713007450104,
0.3981049954891205,
-0.12120772153139114,
-0.2388257086277008,
0.2434244304895401,
0.25087109208106995,
-0.5793573260307312,
-1.0763165950775146,
0.24871350824832916,
-0.8508999943733215,
-0.06303442269563675,
1.2561092376708984,
0.07755106687545776,
-0.44802626967430115,
0.1665889024734497,
0.0715431421995163,
0.2668164074420929,
-0.17083391547203064,
0.8118222951889038,
0.7044416666030884,
-0.10398571938276291,
-0.1910165697336197,
-0.5361469388008118,
0.37107276916503906,
0.4338395893573761,
-0.8222934007644653,
0.49081695079803467,
0.03879493847489357,
0.3514969050884247,
0.1051817461848259,
0.33623525500297546,
-0.17587047815322876,
0.10819914191961288,
-0.1535210907459259,
-0.14839939773082733,
-0.022627875208854675,
-0.20970012247562408,
-0.42338624596595764,
0.2703721225261688,
0.13574959337711334,
-0.15295831859111786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17779v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17779v1
|
Medical Vision-Language Pre-Training for Brain Abnormalities
| 2024-04-27T05:03:42 | 2024-04-27T05:03:42 |
Masoud Monajatipoor, Zi-Yi Dou, Aichi Chien, Nanyun Peng, Kai-Wei Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Vision-language models have become increasingly powerful for tasks that
require an understanding of both visual and linguistic elements, bridging the
gap between these modalities. In the context of multimodal clinical AI, there
is a growing need for models that possess domain-specific knowledge, as
existing models often lack the expertise required for medical applications. In
this paper, we take brain abnormalities as an example to demonstrate how to
automatically collect medical image-text aligned data for pretraining from
public resources such as PubMed. In particular, we present a pipeline that
streamlines the pre-training process by initially collecting a large brain
image-text dataset from case reports and published journals and subsequently
constructing a high-performance vision-language model tailored to specific
medical tasks. We also investigate the unique challenge of mapping subfigures
to subcaptions in the medical domain. We evaluated the resulting model with
quantitative and qualitative intrinsic evaluations. The resulting dataset and
our code can be found here
https://github.com/masoud-monajati/MedVL_pretraining_pipeline
|
[
-0.23840665817260742,
-0.46795544028282166,
0.8436806201934814,
-0.12478669732809067,
-0.4458334147930145,
-0.30489036440849304,
-0.05723956599831581,
-0.49278250336647034,
0.33650073409080505,
0.613170862197876,
-0.6376131176948547,
-0.7461603879928589,
-0.9103517532348633,
-0.19124050438404083,
-0.24279576539993286,
1.1220282316207886,
-0.20308390259742737,
0.4554029107093811,
-0.4766141474246979,
-0.20566581189632416,
-0.5597543120384216,
-0.37837913632392883,
-0.4219299852848053,
-0.0656462088227272,
0.6237694025039673,
0.05602630227804184,
0.6045585870742798,
0.6427364349365234,
0.963523268699646,
0.25100767612457275,
0.576572060585022,
0.16072016954421997,
-0.2490295022726059,
-0.010452146641910076,
-0.13191206753253937,
-0.13693277537822723,
-0.5339034795761108,
-0.021227102726697922,
0.4942496120929718,
0.6384459137916565,
-0.18976663053035736,
-0.03948737680912018,
-0.2469586730003357,
0.7214084267616272,
-0.590960681438446,
0.341095507144928,
-0.5272951126098633,
0.11589979380369186,
-0.49227771162986755,
-0.21001365780830383,
-0.2741318345069885,
0.024018997326493263,
0.39106285572052,
-0.9404253959655762,
0.17656239867210388,
-0.08820582926273346,
1.090179204940796,
0.7623103260993958,
-0.2623658776283264,
-0.19376549124717712,
-0.3116711974143982,
0.5759590268135071,
-0.35494038462638855,
0.6479588150978088,
0.5775385499000549,
0.4598681628704071,
0.13399067521095276,
-0.9347748160362244,
-0.4670405685901642,
-0.04984606057405472,
-0.2736915647983551,
0.22473333775997162,
-0.029302166774868965,
0.054932259023189545,
0.0007687216275371611,
-0.0053964341059327126,
-0.7122843265533447,
0.10576723515987396,
-0.5501123070716858,
-0.25194060802459717,
0.52418452501297,
0.3324556350708008,
0.5461323261260986,
0.1335517168045044,
-0.23318840563297272,
-0.059382129460573196,
-0.6856938004493713,
-0.3165481388568878,
0.032158005982637405,
-0.03626276180148125,
-0.28076401352882385,
0.5794726610183716,
0.10464338213205338,
0.8834957480430603,
-0.0955301895737648,
-0.10628842562437057,
0.5152513980865479,
-0.5585436224937439,
-0.06909462809562683,
-0.23940670490264893,
0.6879588961601257,
0.3135754466056824,
0.47976675629615784,
0.03558925539255142,
-0.15895147621631622,
0.2776261270046234,
0.6147572994232178,
-0.7286003828048706,
-0.6611683964729309,
0.3495330512523651,
-0.5415661334991455,
-0.16981826722621918,
-0.23205460608005524,
-0.5996509194374084,
-0.7309350967407227,
-0.42829257249832153,
0.48917722702026367,
-0.5273774266242981,
-0.11966121941804886,
0.34507256746292114,
0.1345563381910324,
-0.12321233004331589,
0.23721693456172943,
-0.8415118455886841,
-0.08358082920312881,
0.2045993059873581,
0.5338839292526245,
-0.3054371178150177,
-0.3995995819568634,
-0.49050837755203247,
0.1694760024547577,
-0.17688052356243134,
0.9025424122810364,
-0.5315572619438171,
-0.029191574081778526,
0.06654645502567291,
0.2086959332227707,
-0.17899632453918457,
-0.5529703497886658,
0.24265331029891968,
-0.477183997631073,
0.18273259699344635,
0.07674597948789597,
-0.32784873247146606,
0.21182392537593842,
0.1843930184841156,
-0.6071000099182129,
0.2362058311700821,
0.0966014415025711,
-0.8641581535339355,
0.4938361644744873,
-0.9198319911956787,
-0.4701504707336426,
0.2615051865577698,
-0.6170652508735657,
-0.6655022501945496,
-0.036666616797447205,
0.6396337747573853,
0.5416885614395142,
-0.13795912265777588,
0.49128806591033936,
-0.08872949331998825,
-0.12688706815242767,
0.09525394439697266,
-0.06003686040639877,
0.5965052247047424,
0.01059992890805006,
0.052356574684381485,
0.2486840933561325,
-0.5974043607711792,
0.033384039998054504,
0.2566383481025696,
-0.2029239982366562,
-0.4767198860645294,
0.20063193142414093,
0.14189159870147705,
0.026450831443071365,
0.31729769706726074,
-0.3978937268257141,
0.0762832760810852,
-0.35383856296539307,
0.28961336612701416,
0.33714959025382996,
-0.06639473140239716,
0.23042811453342438,
-0.17661097645759583,
0.4957479238510132,
0.6783962249755859,
0.5364429950714111,
-0.48780393600463867,
-0.5945003628730774,
-0.5889835953712463,
-0.6722580194473267,
0.4452522099018097,
0.7222956418991089,
-1.0775752067565918,
0.37253373861312866,
-0.3250841200351715,
-0.4487264156341553,
-1.0120525360107422,
-0.1190236359834671,
0.5656648278236389,
0.7745282649993896,
0.5899285078048706,
-0.6555566787719727,
-0.4861779808998108,
-1.1229829788208008,
-0.1404593288898468,
0.052617307752370834,
0.03071008436381817,
0.35847392678260803,
0.3875049948692322,
-0.8362275958061218,
0.7411453127861023,
-0.5908174514770508,
-0.8116235136985779,
0.29147958755493164,
0.3528172969818115,
0.02135588973760605,
0.7197932004928589,
0.6250531673431396,
-0.7986283302307129,
-0.16950538754463196,
0.11254934966564178,
-0.8321560025215149,
-0.2951749861240387,
-0.041486602276563644,
-0.033566419035196304,
0.07770617306232452,
0.43898728489875793,
-0.39414843916893005,
0.6426693797111511,
0.7481582760810852,
-0.28264120221138,
0.3971194624900818,
-0.3526349663734436,
0.2798210680484772,
-1.0075322389602661,
0.08164014667272568,
0.15660525858402252,
-0.20837616920471191,
-0.4669443964958191,
-0.0502760112285614,
0.08384881913661957,
-0.13326464593410492,
-0.5134717226028442,
0.32312268018722534,
-0.46295756101608276,
-0.0043163481168448925,
-0.010735771618783474,
-0.1982743740081787,
-0.022152626886963844,
0.18967950344085693,
0.43153542280197144,
0.5109167098999023,
0.9165748357772827,
-0.2696053385734558,
0.11696126312017441,
0.31722965836524963,
-0.40462663769721985,
0.4837885797023773,
-0.5779777765274048,
0.020351799204945564,
-0.3393067419528961,
-0.12405523657798767,
-0.6225331425666809,
-0.496837317943573,
0.19757916033267975,
-0.4851754903793335,
0.3324517607688904,
-0.28802040219306946,
-0.2827755808830261,
-0.1929766833782196,
0.2720668613910675,
0.7851058840751648,
0.487140953540802,
-0.30476129055023193,
0.36546581983566284,
0.8359309434890747,
-0.12261092662811279,
-0.7000506520271301,
-0.810175359249115,
-0.046041905879974365,
0.1067819818854332,
-0.4566577076911926,
0.45748141407966614,
0.06423389166593552,
0.1871965378522873,
0.2172054499387741,
0.3383006453514099,
-0.5862250328063965,
-0.1889653503894806,
0.25021159648895264,
0.43153882026672363,
-0.27704712748527527,
0.05502541363239288,
0.15332496166229248,
-0.17854000627994537,
-0.04908585920929909,
-0.3877778947353363,
0.2942533791065216,
-0.028975682333111763,
-0.7664380669593811,
-0.49996477365493774,
0.4404837489128113,
0.6845131516456604,
-0.5350754857063293,
0.4311043620109558,
0.4972812235355377,
-0.7043397426605225,
0.2787838280200958,
-0.30894309282302856,
-0.10711318254470825,
-0.4284312129020691,
0.7594322562217712,
-0.049062345176935196,
-0.5578274130821228,
0.1627703458070755,
-0.13462118804454803,
-0.08679550141096115,
0.21532054245471954,
0.5576474666595459,
-0.41454753279685974,
1.162941575050354,
0.6306459903717041,
0.41396138072013855,
0.4416080713272095,
-0.09109465777873993,
0.13835787773132324,
-0.48427823185920715,
-0.4271267056465149,
-0.11317068338394165,
-0.06341677904129028,
-0.14782820641994476,
-0.500007688999176,
0.5333758592605591,
-0.38250184059143066,
-0.002144379774108529,
0.07100819051265717,
-0.5974042415618896,
0.6901535391807556,
0.25568684935569763,
0.23642303049564362,
0.12601129710674286,
0.16682758927345276,
-0.18885603547096252,
-0.5500887036323547,
-0.735190749168396,
-0.360650897026062,
1.0171650648117065,
0.2071128636598587,
0.8837525248527527,
-0.5496934652328491,
0.5381470918655396,
0.13813947141170502,
0.6078196167945862,
-0.7620518803596497,
0.20205262303352356,
-0.5031839609146118,
-0.5519304871559143,
-0.1334739327430725,
-0.1235162615776062,
-1.0901488065719604,
-0.05231687054038048,
-0.5717732310295105,
-0.3296673595905304,
0.35807374119758606,
0.47538280487060547,
-0.4576290249824524,
0.045409396290779114,
-0.8936618566513062,
1.2878326177597046,
-0.5877565145492554,
-0.07427264004945755,
-0.016997691243886948,
-0.8567017912864685,
0.26189228892326355,
-0.5678809881210327,
0.22980694472789764,
0.2169395089149475,
-0.04722337797284126,
0.5944231152534485,
-0.13148874044418335,
0.8144930601119995,
-0.27069565653800964,
0.20380109548568726,
-0.07319182902574539,
-0.3346490263938904,
-0.07364176958799362,
-0.060786131769418716,
0.6081551909446716,
0.5336533784866333,
0.33246469497680664,
-0.5666710138320923,
-0.40251925587654114,
0.2574272155761719,
-0.8084041476249695,
-0.28251421451568604,
-0.41415026783943176,
-0.690274715423584,
-0.4803304970264435,
0.4006129205226898,
0.47379738092422485,
0.48286178708076477,
-0.08952973037958145,
0.10012860596179962,
0.6442961692810059,
-0.4995350241661072,
0.07753676176071167,
0.5210558772087097,
-0.2594560384750366,
-0.40997281670570374,
0.8719260692596436,
0.20088262856006622,
-0.10021782666444778,
0.27872470021247864,
-0.18640290200710297,
-0.2132902294397354,
-0.9936286807060242,
-0.5438300967216492,
0.2340281456708908,
-0.5179238319396973,
-0.17302976548671722,
-0.46850550174713135,
-0.3050749897956848,
-0.4822770059108734,
-0.044959235936403275,
-0.47433269023895264,
0.06497873365879059,
-0.23581036925315857,
0.3368088901042938,
-0.0951349288225174,
0.7114223837852478,
0.19370624423027039,
0.42957213521003723,
-1.0455862283706665,
0.523602306842804,
0.2443687915802002,
0.46361491084098816,
-0.41999974846839905,
-0.17013026773929596,
-0.5518211722373962,
-0.05624277889728546,
-0.2013307511806488,
-0.951236367225647,
0.4953756332397461,
0.1713857203722,
0.4651339650154114,
0.5339351892471313,
-0.12597477436065674,
0.9319859147071838,
-0.8104069828987122,
0.5803400874137878,
0.5060570240020752,
-0.591316282749176,
0.8522623181343079,
-0.2941715121269226,
0.2571503520011902,
0.650799572467804,
0.6826019883155823,
-0.2376689314842224,
-0.2098207026720047,
-0.3779645562171936,
-0.8607185482978821,
0.44726380705833435,
0.06602298468351364,
-0.15368013083934784,
0.013505494222044945,
0.39101874828338623,
0.14611709117889404,
0.08392107486724854,
-0.6278672814369202,
0.028793638572096825,
-0.37698715925216675,
-0.6600570678710938,
-0.1549377590417862,
0.1974809318780899,
-0.42221593856811523,
-0.49998587369918823,
0.425289511680603,
-0.31119364500045776,
0.31511732935905457,
0.36180925369262695,
-0.4455993175506592,
0.17428745329380035,
-0.14983302354812622,
0.5307106375694275,
0.8002367615699768,
0.06951446086168289,
0.1312803030014038,
-0.22781670093536377,
-1.099589467048645,
-0.01697424054145813,
0.3143117427825928,
0.10289863497018814,
-0.08160621672868729,
0.4088185429573059,
0.8262651562690735,
-0.2542571425437927,
-1.0481388568878174,
0.9745934009552002,
-0.3304053544998169,
-0.14416030049324036,
-0.35651257634162903,
-0.2171943634748459,
0.08347059041261673,
0.28452494740486145,
0.17537401616573334,
0.26114726066589355,
0.06841437518596649,
-0.16739802062511444,
0.39704617857933044,
0.26605528593063354,
-0.4892655611038208,
-0.31595343351364136,
0.7362731695175171,
0.21083445847034454,
-0.07927893847227097,
0.8826085329055786,
0.16173169016838074,
-0.16986049711704254,
0.5378330945968628,
0.4781702756881714,
0.5235768556594849,
0.05527855455875397,
0.05164862051606178,
-0.055342283099889755,
0.47474363446235657,
0.18206408619880676,
0.3426476716995239,
0.2645258903503418,
-0.8423401117324829,
-0.7179726362228394,
-0.4815927743911743,
-0.11671986430883408,
0.336986780166626,
-0.5272868871688843,
0.44180214405059814,
-0.30322885513305664,
-0.3891015946865082,
0.16335508227348328,
-0.46466654539108276,
-0.7730696201324463,
0.5833571553230286,
0.39468929171562195,
0.5650864839553833,
-1.034237027168274,
1.1784090995788574,
1.1159418821334839,
-0.5010424852371216,
-0.4507872462272644,
-0.007533244322985411,
-0.28485193848609924,
-1.1309177875518799,
0.6255844235420227,
0.04133031517267227,
0.1931927651166916,
-0.06161542236804962,
-0.6204339861869812,
-0.598290205001831,
0.8097078204154968,
0.6896453499794006,
-0.7580364942550659,
-0.23288290202617645,
0.2339416891336441,
0.6671732664108276,
-0.6395668983459473,
-0.030125759541988373,
0.3963621258735657,
0.2107919454574585,
-0.24924789369106293,
-0.7755314707756042,
-0.15539610385894775,
-0.29614704847335815,
-0.1975613385438919,
0.17934493720531464,
-0.07492910325527191,
0.5217324495315552,
-0.3424118459224701,
-0.041103314608335495,
-0.22852090001106262,
0.30535972118377686,
0.2898063659667969,
0.4357771575450897,
0.543649435043335,
0.8351174592971802,
0.7187093496322632,
-0.2007313221693039,
1.0189189910888672,
-0.4622285068035126,
0.10083354264497757,
0.9122840762138367,
-0.11313241720199585,
0.5687071681022644,
0.6900785565376282,
0.11731384694576263,
0.4086965024471283,
0.6936153173446655,
0.05488531291484833,
0.751253604888916,
-0.013999870978295803,
-0.03335591033101082,
-0.3668743968009949,
-0.0152479512616992,
-0.5001787543296814,
0.4221646189689636,
0.5976114273071289,
-0.5812260508537292,
0.016427453607320786,
0.20914767682552338,
-0.3215937316417694,
-0.07564129680395126,
-0.2792808711528778,
0.7258887887001038,
0.10988304764032364,
-0.6743597388267517,
0.40600645542144775,
-0.44841161370277405,
0.5442589521408081,
-0.5717020630836487,
-0.048651233315467834,
0.05599016696214676,
0.11490026116371155,
-0.26218733191490173,
-0.7617664933204651,
0.6106254458427429,
-0.12644486129283905,
-0.31682589650154114,
-0.20065684616565704,
0.7871278524398804,
-0.45204803347587585,
-0.37570276856422424,
0.17333459854125977,
0.619053065776825,
0.47007042169570923,
0.14750763773918152,
-0.8679704070091248,
-0.11153236031532288,
-0.28091707825660706,
0.10684110224246979,
0.4555456340312958,
0.2828231155872345,
-0.29348331689834595,
0.2755851745605469,
0.5740182995796204,
0.3485172390937805,
0.043645285069942474,
0.21048395335674286,
0.7672299742698669,
-0.3364636301994324,
-0.3623657822608948,
-0.646664559841156,
0.6039718985557556,
0.0032558036036789417,
-0.4399354159832001,
-0.022024543955922127,
0.43157845735549927,
0.7857283353805542,
-0.4506821930408478,
0.5961002111434937,
0.05663103610277176,
0.1918385773897171,
-0.5511959195137024,
1.207191824913025,
-0.8120536208152771,
-0.19552046060562134,
-0.07915012538433075,
-0.42033761739730835,
-0.6429497003555298,
0.7189784049987793,
-0.3606789708137512,
-0.20584969222545624,
0.8634616136550903,
0.8393069505691528,
-0.22937701642513275,
-0.3029805123806,
0.38719213008880615,
0.18745675683021545,
-0.09047944098711014,
0.5853144526481628,
0.8005893230438232,
-0.22725029289722443,
0.30213719606399536,
-0.00844609271734953,
-0.401964396238327,
0.08839277923107147,
-0.9869123697280884,
-0.7185773849487305,
-0.8533079624176025,
-0.5977930426597595,
-0.14340840280056,
0.2760269045829773,
0.5638645887374878,
1.194069266319275,
-0.6859174966812134,
0.20249523222446442,
-0.01790228672325611,
-0.19711467623710632,
0.010182617232203484,
-0.09292449802160263,
0.3607264459133148,
-0.3889773190021515,
-0.6497389674186707,
0.17796467244625092,
0.3460419476032257,
0.24268020689487457,
-0.18014192581176758,
0.1671328991651535,
-0.00683240033686161,
-0.0643702894449234,
0.44529587030410767,
0.19085395336151123,
-0.46510952711105347,
-0.020126948133111,
-0.15186667442321777,
-0.23263409733772278,
0.2958334684371948,
0.836277425289154,
-0.8820884227752686,
0.6123224496841431,
0.36563876271247864,
1.01541268825531,
0.4203040599822998,
-0.12100567668676376,
0.4880363643169403,
-0.7037140130996704,
0.22235362231731415,
0.4114149808883667,
0.5907548069953918,
0.4252566397190094,
-0.42929476499557495,
0.3060949742794037,
0.3792594075202942,
-0.5451335906982422,
-0.8323419690132141,
0.296871542930603,
-0.9388952851295471,
-0.25541895627975464,
0.6445747017860413,
-0.34883150458335876,
-0.2675643861293793,
-0.13905271887779236,
-0.28304800391197205,
0.373496949672699,
0.09437429904937744,
0.789517343044281,
0.45199280977249146,
-0.3322731554508209,
-0.07240569591522217,
-0.5798865556716919,
0.48569267988204956,
0.6284739971160889,
-1.1041922569274902,
-0.36852750182151794,
0.6135483980178833,
0.3062039017677307,
0.28961578011512756,
0.9589385986328125,
-0.5781903266906738,
0.4340207576751709,
-0.20100940763950348,
0.2879799008369446,
-0.0129294628277421,
-0.5971750020980835,
-0.3465288579463959,
0.06906428933143616,
-0.19434130191802979,
-0.4371494948863983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17778v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17778v1
|
MRScore: Evaluating Radiology Report Generation with LLM-based Reward System
| 2024-04-27T04:42:45 | 2024-04-27T04:42:45 |
Yunyi Liu, Zhanyu Wang, Yingshu Li, Xinyu Liang, Lingqiao Liu, Lei Wang, Luping Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent years, automated radiology report generation has experienced
significant growth. This paper introduces MRScore, an automatic evaluation
metric tailored for radiology report generation by leveraging Large Language
Models (LLMs). Conventional NLG (natural language generation) metrics like BLEU
are inadequate for accurately assessing the generated radiology reports, as
systematically demonstrated by our observations within this paper. To address
this challenge, we collaborated with radiologists to develop a framework that
guides LLMs for radiology report evaluation, ensuring alignment with human
analysis. Our framework includes two key components: i) utilizing GPT to
generate large amounts of training data, i.e., reports with different
qualities, and ii) pairing GPT-generated reports as accepted and rejected
samples and training LLMs to produce MRScore as the model reward. Our
experiments demonstrate MRScore's higher correlation with human judgments and
superior performance in model selection compared to traditional metrics. Our
code and datasets will be available on GitHub.
|
[
-0.00011647387145785615,
-0.26359546184539795,
0.7779017090797424,
-0.11898288130760193,
-0.15432770550251007,
0.16337624192237854,
-0.2921447157859802,
-0.600773274898529,
0.06870419532060623,
0.2552630603313446,
-0.3470434248447418,
-0.5328882336616516,
-0.8631837964057922,
0.16402126848697662,
0.05759497731924057,
1.1778508424758911,
-0.026432057842612267,
0.3305569887161255,
-0.45425522327423096,
0.04209942743182182,
-0.5768578052520752,
-0.4129532277584076,
-0.6034416556358337,
-0.6867354512214661,
0.5837624669075012,
0.5425344109535217,
0.742479145526886,
0.8367404341697693,
0.9552831649780273,
0.2017914354801178,
0.30613070726394653,
0.3838707208633423,
-0.3870466947555542,
0.08628817647695541,
-0.09652116149663925,
0.07535573095083237,
-0.7399136424064636,
0.07001832872629166,
0.39738893508911133,
0.4678298830986023,
-0.3253045380115509,
0.4071488678455353,
-0.1829787939786911,
0.6995496153831482,
-0.5727329850196838,
0.05091409385204315,
-0.23600919544696808,
0.22994539141654968,
-0.044531069695949554,
-0.606224536895752,
-0.520709216594696,
-0.4516049027442932,
-0.05076655372977257,
-0.021251674741506577,
0.12044797837734222,
0.060313813388347626,
0.8931299448013306,
0.06241253763437271,
-0.17534402012825012,
-0.7326374053955078,
-0.5437870025634766,
0.779547929763794,
-0.5558335185050964,
0.1891782581806183,
0.20192277431488037,
0.5250256657600403,
0.2361660599708557,
-0.8404010534286499,
0.013266649097204208,
-0.7881869077682495,
-0.14221785962581635,
0.45895305275917053,
-0.14542602002620697,
-0.11133388429880142,
0.11828411370515823,
0.5381700992584229,
-1.027535319328308,
0.18229328095912933,
-0.22112731635570526,
-0.15939313173294067,
0.8237230181694031,
0.609687864780426,
0.46816280484199524,
-0.6339424848556519,
-0.5574985146522522,
-0.1681145429611206,
-0.5706747174263,
-0.29513347148895264,
0.07598482072353363,
0.39292895793914795,
-0.12921126186847687,
0.6851398348808289,
-0.16358350217342377,
0.6373736262321472,
-0.11783745884895325,
-0.39004945755004883,
0.407737135887146,
-0.2891467213630676,
-0.22650977969169617,
0.1880924552679062,
0.9524005055427551,
0.5545405149459839,
-0.08261721581220627,
-0.20278644561767578,
-0.5251337289810181,
0.3182803690433502,
0.5123081207275391,
-0.7118822932243347,
-0.2427472174167633,
0.2696666717529297,
-0.7266459465026855,
-0.654965877532959,
-0.010473816655576229,
-0.45481497049331665,
-0.34049415588378906,
-0.23058559000492096,
0.3037162125110626,
-0.38657841086387634,
-0.39747536182403564,
0.19471599161624908,
-0.1237768903374672,
-0.0017022433457896113,
0.27827033400535583,
-0.5815845727920532,
0.3056541979312897,
0.43760332465171814,
0.869583249092102,
-0.25352779030799866,
-0.2659932076931,
-0.8370129466056824,
0.27804306149482727,
-0.11624487489461899,
1.1894893646240234,
-0.3138695955276489,
-0.6033024191856384,
-0.262008398771286,
-0.4858382046222687,
-0.08067785203456879,
-0.6548109650611877,
0.6220810413360596,
-0.23005123436450958,
0.27081218361854553,
0.14103740453720093,
-0.39723291993141174,
0.16420017182826996,
0.5266072154045105,
-0.3083477318286896,
0.986670732498169,
0.4321262240409851,
-0.734975278377533,
0.4586261510848999,
-0.8239179849624634,
-0.4790215790271759,
0.4311425983905792,
-0.2826470136642456,
-0.4935266971588135,
0.17636729776859283,
0.27075356245040894,
0.40924888849258423,
-0.6256776452064514,
0.3869672119617462,
0.1999535709619522,
-0.09773609787225723,
0.17275577783584595,
-0.03740107640624046,
0.38683876395225525,
0.535200834274292,
-0.08255236595869064,
0.45983824133872986,
-0.5115914940834045,
0.2591187059879303,
0.35486021637916565,
-0.36962541937828064,
0.08724897354841232,
-0.1280604898929596,
0.12496714293956757,
0.1886880099773407,
0.19825349748134613,
-0.5836488008499146,
-0.008618053048849106,
-0.04012056440114975,
0.18131373822689056,
0.6466548442840576,
0.03755529224872589,
0.20700976252555847,
-0.778477132320404,
0.8131499290466309,
-0.057880911976099014,
0.24007026851177216,
-0.07733301818370819,
-0.16324636340141296,
-0.35502639412879944,
-0.5137025713920593,
0.3373306691646576,
0.5739954113960266,
-0.17767779529094696,
0.385975182056427,
-0.6216108798980713,
-0.68709796667099,
-0.5167966485023499,
-0.01365705206990242,
0.39977243542671204,
0.6666333675384521,
0.1863793134689331,
-0.6784316301345825,
-0.5913236141204834,
-1.0671520233154297,
0.0729285255074501,
-0.057858727872371674,
-0.2641649544239044,
0.47946128249168396,
0.28625139594078064,
-0.19813919067382812,
0.7532334923744202,
-0.656708836555481,
-0.5571883916854858,
-0.5559776425361633,
0.27149656414985657,
0.1681140512228012,
0.23392494022846222,
0.20395517349243164,
-0.37825915217399597,
-0.3660644590854645,
-0.01917659118771553,
-1.208296775817871,
-0.11003052443265915,
-0.09933790564537048,
0.04415237158536911,
0.09100022166967392,
0.3332739770412445,
-0.3112773001194,
0.10906293243169785,
0.5450596809387207,
-0.17090719938278198,
0.7656760215759277,
-0.37557247281074524,
0.5111333131790161,
-0.8963566422462463,
0.2783825993537903,
-0.017780469730496407,
-0.6527403593063354,
-0.1485806405544281,
0.0778936818242073,
-0.010018063709139824,
-0.3590494692325592,
-0.31275850534439087,
0.3573029339313507,
-0.6103116869926453,
-0.31049785017967224,
-0.362551748752594,
0.16685298085212708,
-0.05872827023267746,
-0.02773692086338997,
0.27480095624923706,
0.5599994659423828,
0.41238489747047424,
-0.47192350029945374,
0.36716440320014954,
0.2562374770641327,
-0.31064173579216003,
0.7690274119377136,
-0.7089623808860779,
0.4683007299900055,
0.07607904821634293,
0.237375408411026,
-0.6619740128517151,
-0.2391110360622406,
-0.09934194386005402,
-0.7877828478813171,
0.35965755581855774,
-0.3133886456489563,
-0.5126059055328369,
-0.5882171988487244,
-0.32948797941207886,
0.015184840187430382,
0.5530175566673279,
-0.19914139807224274,
0.4181612730026245,
0.6156095266342163,
-0.22096531093120575,
-0.2823614776134491,
-0.7297154068946838,
0.4538114666938782,
-0.1181587502360344,
-0.8075615167617798,
0.012363537214696407,
-0.23090632259845734,
-0.1175176277756691,
0.033347856253385544,
0.22502247989177704,
0.2349848449230194,
-0.090335413813591,
0.4461890161037445,
0.5119893550872803,
-0.3960249722003937,
-0.13397106528282166,
-0.3890705406665802,
-0.40401044487953186,
0.12072522193193436,
-0.12273895740509033,
0.5688729286193848,
-0.28506121039390564,
-0.3425371050834656,
-0.17818117141723633,
0.2391965091228485,
0.2164040356874466,
-0.24243760108947754,
0.4038791060447693,
0.6391988396644592,
-0.13942013680934906,
-0.1259937733411789,
-0.3788699507713318,
-0.12754540145397186,
-0.39219996333122253,
0.29379647970199585,
-0.3893498182296753,
-0.8359110355377197,
0.24663390219211578,
0.030358638614416122,
-0.055277690291404724,
0.49198269844055176,
1.100982427597046,
0.005447769071906805,
1.0787177085876465,
0.26585838198661804,
0.07980181276798248,
0.1408691704273224,
-0.07271626591682434,
-0.10004935413599014,
-0.9917774200439453,
-0.05000757798552513,
-0.3544144630432129,
-0.07135432958602905,
-0.27130040526390076,
-0.25091344118118286,
0.6551563739776611,
-0.4055801331996918,
0.04496515542268753,
0.021946003660559654,
-0.949928879737854,
0.34153667092323303,
0.1037035658955574,
0.164124995470047,
0.41778692603111267,
-0.10734517872333527,
0.006931567098945379,
-0.06831182539463043,
-0.9885830283164978,
-0.7385086417198181,
1.3258049488067627,
0.4648013412952423,
0.7123230695724487,
0.025397395715117455,
0.8444036841392517,
0.7070637345314026,
0.8136067986488342,
-0.8480103611946106,
0.40770289301872253,
-0.15192247927188873,
-0.4753572642803192,
-0.08620887994766235,
-0.6559872031211853,
-0.8644787073135376,
0.18070626258850098,
-0.29225245118141174,
-0.3163118362426758,
-0.58614581823349,
0.025839727371931076,
-0.44175365567207336,
0.05793711543083191,
-0.5852308869361877,
0.6844152212142944,
-0.4171660244464874,
-0.3458802103996277,
-0.37378156185150146,
-0.49757298827171326,
0.4966764450073242,
0.2183760553598404,
0.2832877039909363,
-0.203193798661232,
0.2784728705883026,
0.7552977204322815,
-0.3219258785247803,
0.5279653668403625,
-0.1787509173154831,
0.1729585826396942,
0.2560082972049713,
0.3414252698421478,
0.35475224256515503,
0.30663609504699707,
-0.08553066104650497,
0.0453958660364151,
-0.28805187344551086,
-0.23978747427463531,
-0.14206400513648987,
0.9177548289299011,
-0.6477909088134766,
-0.10078602284193039,
-0.7657327651977539,
-0.9320889711380005,
-0.22434987127780914,
0.21750421822071075,
0.35756009817123413,
0.579500675201416,
-0.42068907618522644,
-0.3918960690498352,
0.37769603729248047,
-0.2872498333454132,
-0.033255793154239655,
0.5424502491950989,
-0.18156538903713226,
-0.5914876461029053,
0.9460089206695557,
-0.11262930929660797,
0.1370387077331543,
0.16394266486167908,
0.41584259271621704,
-0.2548191547393799,
-0.8152198791503906,
-0.7251303791999817,
0.356453001499176,
-0.625412106513977,
-0.5765975713729858,
-0.4350818395614624,
-0.3192586600780487,
-0.3457655906677246,
-0.23403258621692657,
-0.5515720844268799,
-0.06480523198843002,
0.14329072833061218,
-0.05919326841831207,
0.23183979094028473,
1.2011709213256836,
-0.24976056814193726,
0.10418690741062164,
-0.9980247020721436,
0.18838714063167572,
0.09650759398937225,
0.36260658502578735,
-0.11987850815057755,
-0.57814621925354,
-0.5677114129066467,
-0.2535502016544342,
-0.3699357211589813,
-0.38134580850601196,
0.5223275423049927,
-0.18842758238315582,
0.49084094166755676,
-0.037489261478185654,
-0.15819783508777618,
0.546563982963562,
-0.4995202422142029,
0.6808351874351501,
0.573855459690094,
-0.7080755233764648,
0.6001694202423096,
-0.6126131415367126,
0.4075898230075836,
0.5222445130348206,
-0.01624995842576027,
-0.4848661422729492,
-0.5377601981163025,
-0.8030468225479126,
-0.8663683533668518,
0.5045166015625,
-0.00046136960736475885,
-0.1438179612159729,
-0.13947738707065582,
-0.01179658342152834,
0.05104881152510643,
0.032445378601551056,
-0.6221481561660767,
0.0642593577504158,
-0.031774234026670456,
-0.29978370666503906,
-0.09391417354345322,
-0.26892364025115967,
-0.5561551451683044,
0.1018863245844841,
0.2831939160823822,
-0.18834254145622253,
0.570316731929779,
0.4191775321960449,
-0.6513808965682983,
-0.5370098948478699,
0.20018810033798218,
0.802103579044342,
0.9870831966400146,
-0.4977944791316986,
0.19790248572826385,
-0.01719466783106327,
-0.2803370952606201,
-0.059540145099163055,
-0.14635016024112701,
0.2183268964290619,
0.0033101323060691357,
0.533270537853241,
0.5885449647903442,
0.07450136542320251,
-0.6413363814353943,
0.5415328741073608,
-0.15977059304714203,
-0.4907783567905426,
-0.38671010732650757,
-0.009909940883517265,
0.2566283345222473,
-0.02014574222266674,
0.3928810954093933,
0.13674043118953705,
0.1818002164363861,
-0.25528615713119507,
0.5549636483192444,
0.4473625719547272,
-0.5549333691596985,
-0.13149094581604004,
0.5316556096076965,
0.10630607604980469,
-0.07487083971500397,
0.7543781399726868,
-0.22936658561229706,
-0.276078999042511,
0.4423336982727051,
0.5970714092254639,
0.7980321645736694,
-0.11108336597681046,
0.3626444339752197,
0.5880185961723328,
0.3341027796268463,
-0.0337105430662632,
0.040710095316171646,
0.39463526010513306,
-0.5388529300689697,
-0.4807530641555786,
-0.6089493036270142,
-0.547987163066864,
0.07969099283218384,
-0.7758843898773193,
0.24396251142024994,
-0.6308892369270325,
-0.11576224863529205,
0.03401986137032509,
-0.09140528738498688,
-0.5536050796508789,
0.46685177087783813,
0.5558039546012878,
0.7442731261253357,
-0.7158483266830444,
0.5586580634117126,
0.7696809768676758,
-0.6060815453529358,
-0.8519989848136902,
-0.4144146740436554,
0.04649936407804489,
-0.8987067937850952,
0.6626790165901184,
0.09911903738975525,
-0.3720494210720062,
-0.17320840060710907,
-0.29455530643463135,
-0.5001386404037476,
1.138503074645996,
0.14109185338020325,
-0.19191564619541168,
0.09391158819198608,
0.0035545520950108767,
0.5711228847503662,
-0.8326014280319214,
0.6697260737419128,
0.23752281069755554,
0.43449175357818604,
0.07773517072200775,
-1.1240683794021606,
0.0739489197731018,
-0.04063907265663147,
-0.09106592833995819,
0.21812810003757477,
-0.4579218924045563,
0.5309692621231079,
-0.4810028672218323,
-0.17195424437522888,
-0.17786957323551178,
0.5713295936584473,
0.518448531627655,
0.452549546957016,
0.4575619399547577,
0.6573899388313293,
0.7041659355163574,
0.1260218322277069,
1.5090535879135132,
-0.10666801780462265,
0.49950096011161804,
0.9459213614463806,
-0.5001962780952454,
0.6691956520080566,
0.1701536625623703,
-0.22287577390670776,
0.5505755543708801,
0.6019777655601501,
-0.2013874500989914,
0.2908998429775238,
0.2303204983472824,
0.1008460521697998,
-0.3063398003578186,
-0.16298802196979523,
-0.37882712483406067,
0.5124696493148804,
0.007931526750326157,
-0.48909762501716614,
-0.3906591534614563,
-0.05059150978922844,
0.0009231594740413129,
0.1192382276058197,
-0.3244107663631439,
0.8099479079246521,
0.1636086106300354,
-0.46021124720573425,
0.8053587675094604,
0.012145930901169777,
0.6031180024147034,
-0.8903825879096985,
0.15977169573307037,
-0.13228881359100342,
0.24218277633190155,
-0.5764206647872925,
-0.8292641043663025,
0.5054343938827515,
0.21677953004837036,
-0.32496851682662964,
-0.3340613543987274,
0.692669689655304,
-0.07433892786502838,
-0.4875609874725342,
0.19677799940109253,
0.6305012702941895,
0.16322557628154755,
0.16568975150585175,
-0.811800479888916,
0.07550057768821716,
0.02293815091252327,
-0.3527556359767914,
0.712934672832489,
0.02620154805481434,
0.07975129038095474,
0.6768048405647278,
0.7662407159805298,
0.43699732422828674,
-0.45873144268989563,
0.1915854513645172,
0.7967920303344727,
-0.6805486679077148,
-0.5388619303703308,
-0.685056209564209,
0.5404744148254395,
-0.0043901242315769196,
-0.26412659883499146,
0.6134881377220154,
0.9860011339187622,
0.21538840234279633,
-0.15232473611831665,
0.8920649290084839,
-0.2265157699584961,
0.8551070690155029,
-0.5342119932174683,
0.7574755549430847,
-0.5237604975700378,
0.14870686829090118,
-0.15795522928237915,
-0.6145305633544922,
-0.30911046266555786,
0.46569615602493286,
-0.3248804211616516,
0.04668706655502319,
0.9186146259307861,
0.7091843485832214,
-0.23176886141300201,
-0.26799002289772034,
0.4306432604789734,
-0.08028305321931839,
0.2536317706108093,
0.6941050291061401,
0.8524986505508423,
-0.17688319087028503,
0.501908540725708,
0.09844662994146347,
-0.42434433102607727,
-0.23828886449337006,
-0.903797447681427,
-0.48532992601394653,
-0.26461806893348694,
-0.3987855315208435,
-0.5987358689308167,
0.09238197654485703,
0.7866807579994202,
0.8175755739212036,
-0.4948119521141052,
-0.7180255055427551,
0.42557409405708313,
-0.18857499957084656,
-0.15506888926029205,
-0.2709367573261261,
0.46949195861816406,
-0.42638877034187317,
-0.337198406457901,
0.5527629256248474,
0.47225436568260193,
-0.39651620388031006,
-0.22423569858074188,
-0.30575573444366455,
-0.03104378469288349,
-0.21465475857257843,
0.6248376369476318,
0.0076120453886687756,
-0.13726571202278137,
-0.3418731987476349,
-0.10672727227210999,
-0.6432993412017822,
0.480776846408844,
0.920282781124115,
-0.8044381141662598,
0.24446609616279602,
0.2725953161716461,
0.33355337381362915,
0.5970746278762817,
0.0534527488052845,
0.6996279358863831,
-0.530314564704895,
-0.0284411758184433,
0.45767518877983093,
0.12909622490406036,
0.6561490893363953,
-0.4637020230293274,
0.6141459345817566,
0.0541560985147953,
-0.9295876026153564,
-1.0413254499435425,
0.3017575740814209,
-1.1675070524215698,
-0.14285661280155182,
1.0592893362045288,
0.020022673532366753,
-0.18250030279159546,
0.1343955546617508,
0.031116874888539314,
0.20317314565181732,
-0.4708523750305176,
0.7402336001396179,
0.4069432318210602,
-0.6056960821151733,
-0.19284240901470184,
-0.684833288192749,
0.5167574882507324,
0.38423553109169006,
-0.8808839917182922,
-0.01215893030166626,
0.6467639207839966,
0.6106051206588745,
0.14182041585445404,
0.8625946640968323,
-0.4496677815914154,
0.6132810115814209,
-0.0758683905005455,
0.40016117691993713,
-0.4539773762226105,
0.0038920314982533455,
-0.3174116015434265,
0.26838013529777527,
0.5726381540298462,
0.015074634924530983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00728v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00728v1
|
Evaluating the Application of ChatGPT in Outpatient Triage Guidance: A Comparative Study
| 2024-04-27T04:12:02 | 2024-04-27T04:12:02 |
Dou Liu, Ying Han, Xiandi Wang, Xiaomei Tan, Di Liu, Guangwu Qian, Kang Li, Dan Pu, Rong Yin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in healthcare presents a
transformative potential for enhancing operational efficiency and health
outcomes. Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, have shown their
capabilities in supporting medical decision-making. Embedding LLMs in medical
systems is becoming a promising trend in healthcare development. The potential
of ChatGPT to address the triage problem in emergency departments has been
examined, while few studies have explored its application in outpatient
departments. With a focus on streamlining workflows and enhancing efficiency
for outpatient triage, this study specifically aims to evaluate the consistency
of responses provided by ChatGPT in outpatient guidance, including both
within-version response analysis and between-version comparisons. For
within-version, the results indicate that the internal response consistency for
ChatGPT-4.0 is significantly higher than ChatGPT-3.5 (p=0.03) and both have a
moderate consistency (71.2% for 4.0 and 59.6% for 3.5) in their top
recommendation. However, the between-version consistency is relatively low
(mean consistency score=1.43/3, median=1), indicating few recommendations match
between the two versions. Also, only 50% top recommendations match perfectly in
the comparisons. Interestingly, ChatGPT-3.5 responses are more likely to be
complete than those from ChatGPT-4.0 (p=0.02), suggesting possible differences
in information processing and response generation between the two versions. The
findings offer insights into AI-assisted outpatient operations, while also
facilitating the exploration of potentials and limitations of LLMs in
healthcare utilization. Future research may focus on carefully optimizing LLMs
and AI integration in healthcare systems based on ergonomic and human factors
principles, precisely aligning with the specific needs of effective outpatient
triage.
|
[
-0.08825258910655975,
-0.6538361310958862,
0.8493167757987976,
0.26564303040504456,
-0.1809093952178955,
0.007731223478913307,
-0.22821582853794098,
-0.5131875872612,
-0.08921685814857483,
0.3419758677482605,
-0.26274025440216064,
-0.24136631190776825,
-0.5516839027404785,
0.19001895189285278,
-0.4520528316497803,
0.8924980163574219,
-0.1009996309876442,
0.5111230611801147,
-0.39788690209388733,
0.09420124441385269,
-0.7660278081893921,
-0.6839110255241394,
-1.1036325693130493,
-0.7268897891044617,
0.024975251406431198,
0.5165699124336243,
1.1404775381088257,
0.10855791717767715,
1.276776671409607,
0.27969151735305786,
0.15048468112945557,
0.2027115374803543,
-0.2226479947566986,
-0.12242289632558823,
0.2520695924758911,
-0.28094610571861267,
-0.39404618740081787,
-0.5439488887786865,
0.6141310334205627,
0.41779398918151855,
-0.5327377319335938,
-0.15574976801872253,
0.1538030058145523,
1.019243836402893,
-0.1378299593925476,
0.4107430577278137,
-0.16371364891529083,
0.10507712513208389,
-0.0786740630865097,
-0.23978887498378754,
-0.22367146611213684,
-0.805282711982727,
0.7423331141471863,
-0.34232839941978455,
-0.1132640615105629,
0.3293493390083313,
0.6162623763084412,
0.6103994250297546,
-0.02826620079576969,
-0.4139028787612915,
-0.6456654071807861,
0.2767646610736847,
-1.1728672981262207,
0.5188804864883423,
0.22166708111763,
0.5361282229423523,
-0.49059832096099854,
-0.78620445728302,
-0.459156334400177,
-0.41314512491226196,
-0.2563953399658203,
0.36788225173950195,
-0.42703136801719666,
0.43688729405403137,
0.35182124376296997,
0.32804858684539795,
-0.6822842359542847,
0.12014386802911758,
-0.2590479254722595,
0.12712876498699188,
0.6076157093048096,
0.23642277717590332,
0.44470876455307007,
-0.06997916102409363,
-0.36261117458343506,
0.09719481319189072,
-0.59583580493927,
0.07292141765356064,
-0.11872539669275284,
0.13258105516433716,
-0.12797698378562927,
0.7532472610473633,
-0.01038737129420042,
0.4176197350025177,
-0.015843845903873444,
-0.19632114470005035,
0.23713018000125885,
-0.17179912328720093,
-0.4086627960205078,
0.15807783603668213,
1.0942411422729492,
0.8437405228614807,
0.6348159313201904,
-0.39785701036453247,
0.023696009069681168,
-0.21392135322093964,
0.45117565989494324,
-0.4999154210090637,
-0.26383042335510254,
0.2250387817621231,
-0.6210189461708069,
0.024195706471800804,
-0.1756136566400528,
-0.6545976400375366,
-0.654498279094696,
-0.41866347193717957,
0.307443231344223,
-0.9156891107559204,
-0.05469948798418045,
0.0908081978559494,
0.12570472061634064,
0.2259196639060974,
0.5087890028953552,
-0.4378364086151123,
0.3468819260597229,
0.6990370750427246,
1.1018317937850952,
-0.46940290927886963,
-0.07611687481403351,
-0.15550537407398224,
-0.28555676341056824,
-0.2395453006029129,
0.9119593501091003,
-0.3414641320705414,
-0.6771626472473145,
0.03267272189259529,
-0.21591003239154816,
-0.4017138183116913,
-0.7479491233825684,
0.7752767205238342,
-0.18373093008995056,
0.15402866899967194,
-0.1013636440038681,
-0.7226948738098145,
-0.4169853627681732,
0.18059790134429932,
-0.2841140031814575,
0.995563268661499,
0.3597721755504608,
-0.5901617407798767,
0.3945833146572113,
-0.8592354655265808,
-0.10842516273260117,
0.2945634424686432,
-0.3211773633956909,
-0.5982677936553955,
-0.10817866027355194,
0.18138618767261505,
0.004833728075027466,
-0.4460705816745758,
0.035349033772945404,
-0.13088445365428925,
-0.6475592851638794,
0.18678520619869232,
-0.389253705739975,
0.5514752268791199,
-0.025005171075463295,
-0.16785912215709686,
0.19697949290275574,
-0.3379656672477722,
0.2579260468482971,
0.019335003569722176,
-0.3299242854118347,
0.09096858650445938,
0.14519353210926056,
-0.3021126687526703,
0.05783373489975929,
0.14601203799247742,
-0.40152230858802795,
0.14934667944908142,
-0.20037345588207245,
0.3423885703086853,
0.3866138756275177,
0.3209860026836395,
0.19264227151870728,
-0.726540207862854,
0.5670166015625,
-0.15541428327560425,
0.4051986634731293,
0.19344183802604675,
-0.9285672903060913,
-0.5834463238716125,
-0.06949344277381897,
0.06981854140758514,
0.8848791122436523,
-0.6142591834068298,
0.1870524287223816,
-0.05023473501205444,
-0.4230995178222656,
-0.6953088641166687,
-0.3346490263938904,
0.35758623480796814,
0.8898525834083557,
0.518212080001831,
-0.33233168721199036,
-0.48571664094924927,
-0.9006479978561401,
-0.27072542905807495,
-0.49652349948883057,
0.010485031642019749,
0.600295901298523,
0.17717736959457397,
-0.5000408291816711,
0.801482617855072,
-0.12734490633010864,
-0.3569352626800537,
-0.3162707984447479,
0.04245307669043541,
0.4352055788040161,
0.43688350915908813,
0.34975430369377136,
-0.3373124897480011,
-0.7781254053115845,
0.13928505778312683,
-0.8024064898490906,
-0.15576167404651642,
0.15603099763393402,
-0.11580389738082886,
0.2258855402469635,
0.3092709183692932,
-0.3492763340473175,
0.6576262712478638,
0.3329024910926819,
0.03803878277540207,
0.23527556657791138,
-0.6811525225639343,
0.46156439185142517,
-0.9268509745597839,
-0.07345911115407944,
-0.06074273958802223,
-0.17684774100780487,
-0.8832098841667175,
-0.2568019926548004,
0.07414514571428299,
-0.17371949553489685,
-0.2765882611274719,
0.11369872838258743,
-0.05433497205376625,
-0.09717962890863419,
-0.09617460519075394,
0.13648827373981476,
-0.3763919472694397,
0.4156184494495392,
0.015827888622879982,
0.9977754950523376,
0.37218934297561646,
-0.23150165379047394,
0.6570125818252563,
0.3392457365989685,
-0.21283447742462158,
0.8535669445991516,
-1.080594539642334,
0.24079318344593048,
-0.14664340019226074,
0.24224410951137543,
-0.9421088099479675,
-0.15077872574329376,
0.5222213268280029,
-0.19850538671016693,
0.16996900737285614,
-0.27348434925079346,
-0.4668101370334625,
-0.23157544434070587,
-0.2111654281616211,
0.28114649653434753,
0.7056456804275513,
-0.12125205248594284,
0.5816938281059265,
0.15985450148582458,
-0.3445737957954407,
-0.19171930849552155,
-0.5601730942726135,
0.05305260047316551,
-0.22902391850948334,
-0.6533710360527039,
0.03838483616709709,
-0.12428933382034302,
-0.4262221157550812,
-0.17321273684501648,
0.03211388364434242,
0.019470758736133575,
-0.4550238251686096,
0.3352504074573517,
0.4169279634952545,
-0.20673952996730804,
0.1776164174079895,
-0.4121154248714447,
-0.0443907156586647,
0.13615082204341888,
0.02396402694284916,
0.5926759839057922,
-0.4642157554626465,
-0.8025696873664856,
-0.7570829391479492,
0.570789635181427,
0.6085349917411804,
-0.061530403792858124,
0.6173728704452515,
0.4482220411300659,
-0.26025521755218506,
0.5143375396728516,
-0.5190752744674683,
-0.05300985649228096,
-0.3540053069591522,
0.16676995158195496,
0.11191295832395554,
-0.35182642936706543,
0.40287327766418457,
0.07762731611728668,
0.3011957108974457,
0.30573949217796326,
0.4201469421386719,
-0.42185917496681213,
1.1295623779296875,
0.4071303606033325,
0.09555697441101074,
0.518304705619812,
-0.12000607699155807,
0.4328114986419678,
-1.0763254165649414,
-0.390939861536026,
-0.5681186318397522,
-0.18372216820716858,
-0.8638818860054016,
-0.22002963721752167,
1.004989743232727,
-0.039219167083501816,
-0.3650817573070526,
-0.01532994769513607,
-0.5240769982337952,
-0.031074587255716324,
0.5177794098854065,
0.3792460560798645,
0.4677775204181671,
-0.26735079288482666,
0.18794798851013184,
0.07181155681610107,
-0.9839438796043396,
-0.3395902216434479,
0.9761629700660706,
0.43072620034217834,
0.8598587512969971,
0.24231882393360138,
0.7034293413162231,
0.2583218514919281,
0.11856332421302795,
-0.8604748249053955,
0.17743143439292908,
-0.22182966768741608,
-0.10126326233148575,
-0.34686386585235596,
-0.35970765352249146,
-0.7896006107330322,
0.034301046282052994,
-0.3433593213558197,
-0.8219347596168518,
-0.009619890712201595,
0.04882105812430382,
-0.6348000764846802,
0.14527396857738495,
-1.2861216068267822,
0.6062186360359192,
-0.1754962056875229,
0.1744348108768463,
-0.003341492498293519,
-0.6490439772605896,
-0.045967064797878265,
-0.18699851632118225,
0.07110881060361862,
0.04599114879965782,
0.12298862636089325,
0.4058482348918915,
-0.579713761806488,
0.5505136251449585,
0.27558788657188416,
-0.08492681384086609,
0.08271578699350357,
-0.30584174394607544,
0.6750855445861816,
0.27771279215812683,
-0.044881001114845276,
0.5435668230056763,
0.29834243655204773,
-0.08465909212827682,
-0.8066392540931702,
0.46998563408851624,
-0.8805794715881348,
-0.5049231052398682,
-0.5277024507522583,
-0.6236869692802429,
-0.4343331456184387,
0.27593955397605896,
0.5139989256858826,
0.8062054514884949,
0.11002244055271149,
0.12351901084184647,
0.6998763680458069,
-0.08809056878089905,
0.5119259357452393,
0.4268610179424286,
-0.2777468264102936,
-0.05098854377865791,
0.45822522044181824,
0.20257505774497986,
0.28151336312294006,
0.34855422377586365,
0.32632023096084595,
-0.5309299230575562,
-0.6631495952606201,
-0.6805159449577332,
0.12529142200946808,
-0.49246618151664734,
-0.1399926394224167,
-0.46900609135627747,
-0.6603180170059204,
-0.23898820579051971,
-0.17958641052246094,
-0.15364591777324677,
-0.08347078412771225,
0.0382022000849247,
0.5616426467895508,
0.5488308668136597,
0.8426439166069031,
0.19568663835525513,
0.5175338387489319,
-0.8947361707687378,
0.09053870290517807,
0.04356851056218147,
0.5217991471290588,
-0.18821030855178833,
-0.3391280174255371,
-0.1523071974515915,
0.2603035867214203,
-0.11936064809560776,
-1.1101365089416504,
-0.128596693277359,
0.16641485691070557,
0.5948413014411926,
0.20758412778377533,
0.09585683047771454,
0.6366074085235596,
-0.4640768766403198,
0.7951536178588867,
0.12078849971294403,
-0.6348204612731934,
0.31632545590400696,
-0.2805274724960327,
0.4858742356300354,
0.5196065902709961,
0.20736080408096313,
-0.8336785435676575,
-0.27991363406181335,
-0.6413395404815674,
-0.8391151428222656,
0.6664298176765442,
0.292920857667923,
-0.42192232608795166,
0.25949469208717346,
0.22662031650543213,
-0.14612004160881042,
0.17972350120544434,
-0.13523955643177032,
-0.12904994189739227,
0.17176608741283417,
-0.20991066098213196,
0.12956291437149048,
-0.07704361528158188,
-0.23711052536964417,
0.2209300696849823,
0.5296750664710999,
-0.10626387596130371,
0.6089709401130676,
0.3213786482810974,
0.23508727550506592,
-0.26531854271888733,
0.33681565523147583,
0.5584279298782349,
0.8791448473930359,
-0.37874919176101685,
-0.19809220731258392,
0.5943124294281006,
-0.8079890608787537,
-0.3768467605113983,
0.21878179907798767,
-0.17011792957782745,
0.1368991732597351,
0.47598668932914734,
0.41753020882606506,
-0.07607933133840561,
-0.5527051687240601,
0.3247095048427582,
-0.44089624285697937,
0.2195841670036316,
-0.393995076417923,
0.05422842875123024,
-0.4479394257068634,
0.49285978078842163,
-0.08155244588851929,
0.24140706658363342,
0.21616055071353912,
-0.2921987771987915,
0.07095161080360413,
0.3865383565425873,
-0.5067510008811951,
0.15010063350200653,
0.15489600598812103,
-0.06356950849294662,
-0.6250062584877014,
0.823222815990448,
0.18761684000492096,
-0.2673017680644989,
0.28995680809020996,
0.37685149908065796,
0.8357921242713928,
-0.1493964046239853,
0.0845676138997078,
0.07978860288858414,
0.20099931955337524,
-0.20223060250282288,
0.5212369561195374,
0.1442674994468689,
-0.39921826124191284,
-0.29904279112815857,
-0.1897588074207306,
-0.8150169849395752,
-0.1542644500732422,
-0.6216238141059875,
0.25522252917289734,
-0.3607085645198822,
-0.2607448399066925,
-0.4039035439491272,
-0.07489808648824692,
-0.5912673473358154,
0.11651831865310669,
-0.09965253621339798,
0.7691165208816528,
-0.06418456137180328,
0.40288999676704407,
0.8920475840568542,
-0.5360016822814941,
-1.173546552658081,
0.2660157382488251,
0.17660647630691528,
-1.1198420524597168,
-0.1791929304599762,
-0.2826371192932129,
-0.19540131092071533,
-0.21422366797924042,
0.016856716945767403,
-0.9575022459030151,
0.9152569770812988,
0.1828400045633316,
-0.5239953994750977,
-0.3618449568748474,
0.454224169254303,
0.7642912864685059,
-0.16987693309783936,
0.8957348465919495,
0.8152242302894592,
0.405617356300354,
0.18918929994106293,
-1.484876275062561,
-0.16135796904563904,
-0.05894627422094345,
0.007534117437899113,
0.3626149296760559,
-0.73592209815979,
0.6524978280067444,
-0.22861997783184052,
-0.05658310279250145,
0.03418194130063057,
0.14227572083473206,
0.2497008889913559,
0.25134074687957764,
0.2504922151565552,
0.572785496711731,
0.7446560263633728,
-0.3965570330619812,
0.9531887769699097,
-0.28155288100242615,
0.17533551156520844,
0.943471372127533,
-0.06806094199419022,
0.5983551144599915,
0.4100872278213501,
-0.37011903524398804,
0.5324897170066833,
0.538590669631958,
0.3295811414718628,
0.39320728182792664,
-0.107749804854393,
-0.19521787762641907,
0.3598078489303589,
-0.2871476411819458,
-0.9055788516998291,
0.3720892071723938,
0.09101978689432144,
-0.23344603180885315,
-0.3164251148700714,
-0.3381035029888153,
0.33843788504600525,
-0.3981519341468811,
-0.39826568961143494,
1.0874097347259521,
0.09692945331335068,
-0.8800000548362732,
0.501602053642273,
-0.40031611919403076,
0.13032980263233185,
-0.5950857400894165,
-0.19227717816829681,
-0.25484099984169006,
0.36319151520729065,
-0.6252121329307556,
-0.9940207600593567,
0.3029811978340149,
0.01869843900203705,
0.072757288813591,
-0.09588518738746643,
0.39575642347335815,
-0.21427161991596222,
-0.21810784935951233,
-0.2151792198419571,
0.4477265775203705,
0.27575987577438354,
0.15904535353183746,
-0.6653759479522705,
-0.06320954114198685,
0.07054796069860458,
0.20769211649894714,
0.10374555736780167,
0.6276136040687561,
-0.0325760692358017,
0.6610700488090515,
0.4385160207748413,
0.27528801560401917,
0.015668263658881187,
0.23529411852359772,
0.7509309649467468,
-0.19975394010543823,
-0.4155372679233551,
-0.8386033773422241,
0.34850889444351196,
-0.03974520415067673,
-0.49521172046661377,
0.6756024360656738,
0.25860264897346497,
0.4609089493751526,
0.3399669826030731,
0.7307156324386597,
-0.04293309152126312,
0.4935557246208191,
-0.5154465436935425,
0.3354114294052124,
-0.3497615158557892,
0.3453681170940399,
-0.5148968696594238,
-0.7684482336044312,
-0.12764541804790497,
0.5407547354698181,
-0.5226575136184692,
0.15765336155891418,
0.7662577629089355,
0.5555493235588074,
0.19091631472110748,
0.3621506690979004,
0.11087021231651306,
-0.007275441661477089,
0.5808870196342468,
0.6244772672653198,
1.0243028402328491,
-0.1962021440267563,
0.41980451345443726,
-0.21586351096630096,
-0.5807936787605286,
-0.40620651841163635,
-0.7832026481628418,
-0.7008960843086243,
-0.1719234585762024,
-0.04980805888772011,
-0.3308843672275543,
0.2548021972179413,
1.2244818210601807,
0.5938424468040466,
-0.7158610820770264,
-0.19298198819160461,
-0.05501004680991173,
-0.19071875512599945,
-0.32012924551963806,
-0.1267682909965515,
0.504485011100769,
-0.3952559232711792,
-0.4225035011768341,
0.2665225863456726,
0.5611141324043274,
0.1414746791124344,
-0.1508919596672058,
-0.06822792440652847,
0.11357701569795609,
0.15727819502353668,
0.205343097448349,
0.10412624478340149,
-0.5527634620666504,
-0.33666619658470154,
0.21451282501220703,
-0.10620936751365662,
0.36199527978897095,
0.7115908861160278,
-0.4021760821342468,
0.5637313723564148,
0.46339094638824463,
0.5934318900108337,
0.11547864973545074,
0.25844675302505493,
0.6261090636253357,
-0.2669546604156494,
-0.09454609453678131,
0.36960458755493164,
0.6160298585891724,
0.3496834337711334,
-0.62148118019104,
0.569057047367096,
-0.11291559785604477,
-1.1095894575119019,
-0.32852789759635925,
0.25805988907814026,
-0.8090053796768188,
0.3631308078765869,
1.2204523086547852,
-0.19176481664180756,
0.20811393857002258,
-0.32784077525138855,
-0.7311116456985474,
0.2131335586309433,
-0.7861984372138977,
0.9321680068969727,
0.6111083030700684,
-1.0790365934371948,
-0.1436486691236496,
-0.7567146420478821,
0.7601271271705627,
0.23584794998168945,
-0.8659960031509399,
-0.333196222782135,
0.19235794246196747,
-0.13473257422447205,
0.18893298506736755,
0.8190236687660217,
-0.09941871464252472,
0.43311038613319397,
-0.4050217568874359,
-0.39614051580429077,
0.08201167732477188,
0.01672660931944847,
-0.27763012051582336,
-0.13922753930091858,
0.1098676323890686,
-0.28349149227142334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17749v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17749v2
|
UMass-BioNLP at MEDIQA-M3G 2024: DermPrompt -- A Systematic Exploration of Prompt Engineering with GPT-4V for Dermatological Diagnosis
| 2024-04-27T01:39:05 | 2024-05-08T21:57:24 |
Parth Vashisht, Abhilasha Lodha, Mukta Maddipatla, Zonghai Yao, Avijit Mitra, Zhichao Yang, Junda Wang, Sunjae Kwon, Hong Yu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper presents our team's participation in the MEDIQA-ClinicalNLP2024
shared task B. We present a novel approach to diagnosing clinical dermatology
cases by integrating large multimodal models, specifically leveraging the
capabilities of GPT-4V under a retriever and a re-ranker framework. Our
investigation reveals that GPT-4V, when used as a retrieval agent, can
accurately retrieve the correct skin condition 85% of the time using
dermatological images and brief patient histories. Additionally, we empirically
show that Naive Chain-of-Thought (CoT) works well for retrieval while Medical
Guidelines Grounded CoT is required for accurate dermatological diagnosis.
Further, we introduce a Multi-Agent Conversation (MAC) framework and show its
superior performance and potential over the best CoT strategy. The experiments
suggest that using naive CoT for retrieval and multi-agent conversation for
critique-based diagnosis, GPT-4V can lead to an early and accurate diagnosis of
dermatological conditions. The implications of this work extend to improving
diagnostic workflows, supporting dermatological education, and enhancing
patient care by providing a scalable, accessible, and accurate diagnostic tool.
|
[
-0.3513745367527008,
-0.40775421261787415,
1.0133285522460938,
0.1421034187078476,
-0.3112609088420868,
0.3858654797077179,
-0.14430785179138184,
-0.7131338119506836,
0.057130973786115646,
0.20005178451538086,
-0.608367383480072,
-0.6429681181907654,
-0.21392500400543213,
0.07337293773889542,
-0.10643863677978516,
0.751667320728302,
-0.1086166501045227,
0.03179511800408363,
-0.10390693694353104,
-0.2987426221370697,
-0.6618690490722656,
-0.4388934373855591,
-0.6843351721763611,
-0.31070858240127563,
0.7880147099494934,
0.5367445349693298,
0.6303580403327942,
0.21124505996704102,
0.8078656792640686,
0.23482567071914673,
0.3082874119281769,
0.09987665712833405,
0.015316469594836235,
0.5836459994316101,
-0.16232022643089294,
-0.2589232325553894,
-0.805565595626831,
0.37585219740867615,
0.18437409400939941,
0.5863444209098816,
-0.2198423594236374,
0.19601638615131378,
-0.3932003676891327,
0.62088543176651,
-0.35330039262771606,
0.07934097945690155,
-0.05012829974293709,
0.23147064447402954,
-0.0788857638835907,
-0.17047236859798431,
-0.28889894485473633,
0.20032551884651184,
0.16657830774784088,
-0.424234539270401,
0.4170582592487335,
-0.12576815485954285,
0.40383899211883545,
0.2777501344680786,
-0.4807492792606354,
0.13069701194763184,
-0.535359799861908,
0.4801187515258789,
-0.48894596099853516,
0.06295856088399887,
0.2969512939453125,
0.8952505588531494,
0.2484649121761322,
-0.9759474396705627,
-0.33281296491622925,
-0.2300192266702652,
0.023662211373448372,
0.28121981024742126,
0.14207802712917328,
-0.011009743437170982,
0.19614434242248535,
0.15716329216957092,
-0.5404419302940369,
0.20805302262306213,
-0.1915542036294937,
-0.3534022867679596,
0.2889133095741272,
0.07253243774175644,
0.39461439847946167,
0.003629918210208416,
-0.6294646263122559,
0.2070637047290802,
-0.5958511829376221,
-0.3902292549610138,
-0.19607959687709808,
0.20972537994384766,
-0.0124596506357193,
0.3161567449569702,
-0.2099328339099884,
0.6317607760429382,
-0.26379576325416565,
0.26731815934181213,
0.5281217098236084,
-0.5990861058235168,
0.16870711743831635,
-0.1481044590473175,
0.7510667443275452,
0.41839900612831116,
-0.18182270228862762,
-0.10332262516021729,
-0.14216667413711548,
-0.07545262575149536,
0.41811904311180115,
-1.0053555965423584,
-0.3468875288963318,
0.3888603448867798,
-0.4857602119445801,
-0.5862221717834473,
-0.23896658420562744,
-1.056121826171875,
-0.4392760694026947,
-0.3586522936820984,
0.45514968037605286,
-0.350930780172348,
-0.352732390165329,
-0.2798812985420227,
-0.34519028663635254,
-0.0010066317627206445,
0.5215190052986145,
-0.71806800365448,
0.3544256091117859,
0.3331224024295807,
0.7608269453048706,
-0.11337638646364212,
-0.0026769135147333145,
-0.31806445121765137,
0.05520157516002655,
-0.2541181445121765,
0.7262058258056641,
-0.6452338099479675,
-0.021300295367836952,
-0.4454401433467865,
-0.04346662759780884,
-0.21563974022865295,
-0.2772992253303528,
0.2468108832836151,
-0.3843805491924286,
0.29584574699401855,
-0.4178309738636017,
0.0935654565691948,
0.025104451924562454,
0.566853404045105,
-0.5453794002532959,
0.4744854271411896,
0.548060417175293,
-0.6207782030105591,
0.3288487195968628,
-0.839590847492218,
0.34939509630203247,
0.3545953333377838,
-0.11467514932155609,
-0.41628044843673706,
-0.15375955402851105,
0.1758582442998886,
0.4880734384059906,
-0.26319682598114014,
0.34635692834854126,
-0.2572154104709625,
-0.35716909170150757,
0.1694776713848114,
-0.32533153891563416,
0.4935878813266754,
0.328430712223053,
-0.4323907196521759,
0.03355661779642105,
-0.6877861618995667,
0.22646592557430267,
0.2359413355588913,
0.13704001903533936,
0.02218051627278328,
-0.23750445246696472,
-0.20434331893920898,
0.6010727286338806,
0.3250966966152191,
-0.6170041561126709,
0.3831624388694763,
-0.17220701277256012,
0.44041910767555237,
0.6078546643257141,
0.04357076808810234,
-0.03730161115527153,
-0.5761902332305908,
0.4730186462402344,
0.1770830601453781,
0.3784779906272888,
-0.3144722878932953,
-0.8993391990661621,
-0.18664024770259857,
-0.436065673828125,
0.15003922581672668,
0.3416970372200012,
-0.5621217489242554,
-0.22797216475009918,
0.1381911039352417,
-0.40990734100341797,
-0.05888408422470093,
-0.32423877716064453,
0.46444809436798096,
0.5689913630485535,
0.6480055451393127,
-0.33303800225257874,
-0.33651551604270935,
-0.9353135824203491,
-0.14629827439785004,
0.09212987124919891,
-0.03279851749539375,
0.45926210284233093,
-0.00874235574156046,
-0.7032375931739807,
0.6033084988594055,
-0.31714683771133423,
-0.3652060925960541,
-0.3268424868583679,
0.21236295998096466,
0.5456569790840149,
0.5725185871124268,
0.5966857075691223,
-0.6307982802391052,
-0.532842755317688,
0.24463075399398804,
-0.49996593594551086,
-0.3105665147304535,
0.3714063763618469,
-0.08615054190158844,
0.02086884155869484,
0.20574456453323364,
-0.7532318830490112,
0.4355020225048065,
0.4999857544898987,
-0.5911386609077454,
0.40702420473098755,
-0.48034733533859253,
0.697673499584198,
-0.9168937802314758,
0.19088493287563324,
-0.05155397579073906,
-0.5735771059989929,
-0.5376007556915283,
0.12925538420677185,
0.19724100828170776,
-0.27106598019599915,
-0.3091295659542084,
0.17349250614643097,
-0.18160414695739746,
-0.06306800991296768,
-0.14675243198871613,
-0.011572814546525478,
0.16577450931072235,
0.39579543471336365,
-0.4271288514137268,
0.7255023121833801,
0.36057519912719727,
-0.36635228991508484,
0.42598217725753784,
0.14689728617668152,
0.4152490198612213,
0.46979156136512756,
-0.41696897149086,
0.39299285411834717,
0.0781622976064682,
0.13359254598617554,
-0.9840306043624878,
-0.1845921277999878,
0.47420158982276917,
-0.29240939021110535,
0.5730242729187012,
-0.44702982902526855,
-0.5261809825897217,
-0.7048742175102234,
-0.22898627817630768,
0.9308194518089294,
0.6047174334526062,
-0.4701407551765442,
0.35064956545829773,
0.21692198514938354,
-0.31713035702705383,
-0.4132988750934601,
-0.4613526165485382,
0.0677824392914772,
-0.20831455290317535,
-0.4253111183643341,
0.6612319946289062,
-0.13468413054943085,
-0.14288215339183807,
-0.5234581232070923,
-0.23916999995708466,
-0.2422061711549759,
0.048502612859010696,
0.057145167142152786,
0.4488207995891571,
-0.14198529720306396,
0.08209794014692307,
-0.39863553643226624,
-0.40384727716445923,
0.12139882147312164,
-0.17826229333877563,
0.5585044026374817,
-0.24625249207019806,
-0.7322090268135071,
-0.525818943977356,
0.27973878383636475,
0.6293233036994934,
-0.04853319749236107,
0.1424264907836914,
0.47040122747421265,
-0.20710590481758118,
-0.0809197798371315,
-0.45881733298301697,
-0.3045048713684082,
-0.4341699182987213,
-0.17439530789852142,
-0.25676822662353516,
-0.435863196849823,
0.7823306918144226,
-0.34127411246299744,
-0.2853529751300812,
0.6208144426345825,
0.6366811394691467,
-0.05465148389339447,
1.2460097074508667,
0.6752099990844727,
0.550986647605896,
0.32548820972442627,
-0.17921768128871918,
0.22230824828147888,
-0.6431018114089966,
-0.5107822418212891,
-0.3396763503551483,
-0.3876204490661621,
-0.5773542523384094,
-0.6523883938789368,
0.4293440878391266,
-0.7640605568885803,
-0.29611000418663025,
0.22502824664115906,
-0.9367132186889648,
0.37543758749961853,
0.3703058958053589,
0.36361753940582275,
0.18950991332530975,
-0.25341349840164185,
-0.5569002032279968,
-0.1646929830312729,
-0.5701135396957397,
-0.28655147552490234,
1.295892357826233,
0.22602030634880066,
0.11862841993570328,
0.16082505881786346,
0.6242895722389221,
0.3853350877761841,
0.5416245460510254,
-0.6137600541114807,
0.23977263271808624,
-0.029103852808475494,
-0.5590256452560425,
0.11423544585704803,
-0.503642737865448,
-1.05069899559021,
0.4726100564002991,
0.24421530961990356,
-0.7939757108688354,
0.43312695622444153,
0.055852606892585754,
-0.5614779591560364,
-0.10113365203142166,
-0.5983290076255798,
1.3204339742660522,
-0.15719842910766602,
-0.30218616127967834,
-0.29748842120170593,
-1.0591646432876587,
0.3691002130508423,
-0.19631919264793396,
0.3863285779953003,
-0.492391437292099,
-0.17705358564853668,
0.601409375667572,
-0.3472650647163391,
0.5647711753845215,
-0.45754483342170715,
-0.004591084085404873,
-0.027063490822911263,
0.015018157660961151,
-0.011345944367349148,
0.16348981857299805,
0.12802572548389435,
0.042881593108177185,
0.28110072016716003,
-0.2912888526916504,
-0.6571965217590332,
0.7289040088653564,
-0.7326812148094177,
-0.39856189489364624,
-0.43513184785842896,
-0.45045122504234314,
-0.5133980512619019,
0.32129794359207153,
-0.12051428109407425,
0.7863765954971313,
0.003241733880713582,
-0.2672218978404999,
0.5065631866455078,
-0.18202482163906097,
0.4599805474281311,
0.681721031665802,
-0.13250944018363953,
-0.35225027799606323,
0.8803289532661438,
-0.050672683864831924,
0.16293175518512726,
0.10969356447458267,
0.3846495747566223,
-0.018727624788880348,
-0.5938122272491455,
-0.1470143347978592,
0.3180713355541229,
-0.7814226150512695,
-0.5184763669967651,
-0.7717805504798889,
-0.09900110214948654,
-0.1361430585384369,
0.1481381058692932,
-0.5916751027107239,
-0.6794446110725403,
-0.017620772123336792,
0.07882460206747055,
0.3925064206123352,
0.7649329900741577,
-0.29438936710357666,
0.1149241253733635,
-0.7742506265640259,
0.49457791447639465,
0.10053971409797668,
0.3456527888774872,
-0.5462465286254883,
-0.31326594948768616,
-0.047042883932590485,
0.16492421925067902,
-0.43344423174858093,
-0.7293090224266052,
0.6533715128898621,
0.018511543050408363,
0.6026798486709595,
0.24259895086288452,
-0.016480863094329834,
0.336311399936676,
-0.5320583581924438,
0.4448821246623993,
0.1391124725341797,
-0.6081317663192749,
0.7872053384780884,
-0.3422398269176483,
0.10139939934015274,
0.6949559450149536,
0.2086741328239441,
-0.4119374454021454,
-0.5261797308921814,
-0.9450931549072266,
-0.7360918521881104,
0.6541691422462463,
0.16171596944332123,
-0.2931485176086426,
-0.06402797996997833,
0.22622182965278625,
0.2995052635669708,
0.14995355904102325,
-0.26436328887939453,
-0.0721207857131958,
-0.3720947504043579,
-0.3193548023700714,
-0.04435228183865547,
-0.3342088460922241,
-0.5155885815620422,
-0.27037498354911804,
0.008729325607419014,
-0.3216831684112549,
0.6526459455490112,
0.3533903956413269,
0.016422132030129433,
0.0929412767291069,
0.08720965683460236,
0.759297788143158,
1.088399052619934,
-0.3445906639099121,
0.2797735035419464,
-0.13530710339546204,
-0.49846863746643066,
0.3042117953300476,
0.42133617401123047,
0.5357866287231445,
0.07223454117774963,
0.03551996499300003,
0.08809495717287064,
0.18498122692108154,
-0.39371979236602783,
0.9301974773406982,
-0.4127667248249054,
-0.39194849133491516,
-0.03579489514231682,
-0.27080437541007996,
-0.41649168729782104,
0.39976826310157776,
0.5451439023017883,
0.7788474559783936,
0.36753425002098083,
-0.2363099902868271,
0.6825957298278809,
0.2705642879009247,
-0.4225607216358185,
-0.4477785527706146,
0.6074886918067932,
0.26025891304016113,
-0.24458196759223938,
0.7403932213783264,
-0.08258502185344696,
-0.509162425994873,
0.9031515121459961,
0.32810837030410767,
0.4306696653366089,
-0.15981614589691162,
0.33917322754859924,
0.13050436973571777,
0.05555594339966774,
0.05148410052061081,
0.26480409502983093,
-0.137986421585083,
-0.6694356203079224,
-0.6128264665603638,
-0.03078507073223591,
-0.44768574833869934,
-0.22099073231220245,
-0.30662164092063904,
0.23019713163375854,
-0.6185794472694397,
-0.36812323331832886,
-0.007558980491012335,
0.14157100021839142,
-0.6088552474975586,
0.06913283467292786,
0.20184364914894104,
0.6536250114440918,
-0.48467588424682617,
0.5636920928955078,
0.23065827786922455,
-0.4536084532737732,
-0.7901474237442017,
-0.13721774518489838,
0.23164518177509308,
-1.1362700462341309,
0.5899384617805481,
0.6429004669189453,
0.2990371882915497,
0.17119602859020233,
-0.5987962484359741,
-0.7920502424240112,
1.3945605754852295,
0.3309730589389801,
-0.31629934906959534,
0.1286824345588684,
-0.32718679308891296,
0.5844288468360901,
-0.21335652470588684,
0.5933564901351929,
0.5321442484855652,
0.5174261927604675,
0.5316329598426819,
-1.0574140548706055,
0.43135687708854675,
-0.32180818915367126,
-0.3280808627605438,
0.15195271372795105,
-0.4228857755661011,
0.8955723643302917,
-0.5660250782966614,
-0.17857906222343445,
0.2468382567167282,
-0.07156812399625778,
0.30965813994407654,
0.5111435055732727,
0.06089754402637482,
0.60003662109375,
0.7394706010818481,
-0.1853172481060028,
1.331585168838501,
-0.5375960469245911,
0.11689259856939316,
0.36062541604042053,
-0.0669671818614006,
0.30904969573020935,
0.21833960711956024,
-0.23097656667232513,
0.4466511905193329,
0.7747506499290466,
0.13552804291248322,
0.5644802451133728,
0.0074799321591854095,
-0.3871694505214691,
-0.09378252923488617,
0.05777040123939514,
-0.7193965911865234,
0.3484303653240204,
0.5477843284606934,
-0.30873340368270874,
-0.29995661973953247,
0.08565382659435272,
-0.2779931426048279,
-0.5221337080001831,
-0.04522504284977913,
0.8875501155853271,
-0.010742338374257088,
-0.408988356590271,
0.4552485942840576,
-0.18552210927009583,
0.3078193664550781,
-0.21459461748600006,
-0.2885039448738098,
-0.24982406198978424,
0.2699389159679413,
-0.03098631650209427,
-0.5241696238517761,
0.3617820143699646,
-0.4543086886405945,
0.11280862987041473,
-0.633262574672699,
0.6101260781288147,
-0.30712348222732544,
-0.14851143956184387,
0.056133586913347244,
0.9040966629981995,
0.39198389649391174,
-0.20228183269500732,
-0.8050568699836731,
-0.057242877781391144,
-0.48770156502723694,
-0.08805461972951889,
0.383802592754364,
0.7340478301048279,
0.07864230871200562,
0.7942149043083191,
0.5488371253013611,
-0.13122698664665222,
-0.3709568381309509,
0.48129358887672424,
0.9039251804351807,
-0.7259551286697388,
-0.041321590542793274,
-0.8060110211372375,
0.5384774804115295,
-0.183811217546463,
0.20615226030349731,
0.35350853204727173,
0.10361982136964798,
0.16897356510162354,
0.15610012412071228,
0.5503585338592529,
0.1597900092601776,
0.4891478419303894,
-0.15655194222927094,
0.6539021134376526,
-0.30016136169433594,
0.334267795085907,
-0.25852134823799133,
-0.7217573523521423,
-0.6687549948692322,
0.5545865297317505,
0.023309100419282913,
0.2471196949481964,
1.0915272235870361,
0.4700857996940613,
0.11768712848424911,
-0.03056664578616619,
0.3181305229663849,
0.009053307585418224,
0.6821814775466919,
0.5166256427764893,
0.9846880435943604,
-0.26157477498054504,
0.20187999308109283,
-0.2777281403541565,
-0.5375037789344788,
-0.3037983775138855,
-0.697468101978302,
-0.720009446144104,
-0.27332261204719543,
-0.2917068898677826,
-0.298604279756546,
0.06050211936235428,
0.8089737296104431,
0.736190676689148,
-0.6187955737113953,
0.29360687732696533,
-0.3637672960758209,
0.21756359934806824,
-0.36494678258895874,
-0.16753903031349182,
0.06780686229467392,
-0.7520337700843811,
-0.4450044333934784,
0.639657199382782,
0.4327363967895508,
0.2992651164531708,
-0.03687075525522232,
0.34457501769065857,
-0.014315672218799591,
-0.48260191082954407,
0.48955777287483215,
0.10863496363162994,
-0.38356688618659973,
-0.072520911693573,
-0.27543172240257263,
-0.11443773657083511,
0.19832219183444977,
0.9995498657226562,
-1.0771448612213135,
0.4709846079349518,
0.25205421447753906,
0.5443798303604126,
0.32182323932647705,
0.1442297250032425,
1.119645118713379,
-0.3488730490207672,
0.15749706327915192,
0.8019453287124634,
0.30554690957069397,
0.3008262813091278,
-0.5081834197044373,
0.46085450053215027,
0.5723513960838318,
-0.7621065974235535,
-0.6347682476043701,
0.08974992483854294,
-1.098915934562683,
-0.2095111459493637,
0.9323844313621521,
-0.023712588474154472,
-0.15064901113510132,
-0.4482738971710205,
-0.40152618288993835,
-0.04922972619533539,
-0.3046633005142212,
0.5798689126968384,
0.1641838103532791,
-0.3624465763568878,
-0.5605846643447876,
-0.6460928916931152,
0.6778081059455872,
0.1630786508321762,
-0.6024008989334106,
-0.29486969113349915,
0.4521152377128601,
0.28258016705513,
0.1887931227684021,
1.032348394393921,
-0.2309788465499878,
0.3795495331287384,
-0.08771427720785141,
-0.06098579987883568,
-0.35711678862571716,
-0.37488505244255066,
-0.026781797409057617,
0.2354653924703598,
0.01576264388859272,
-0.3956959545612335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17733v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17733v1
|
Building a Large Japanese Web Corpus for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-27T00:02:45 | 2024-04-27T00:02:45 |
Naoaki Okazaki, Kakeru Hattori, Hirai Shota, Hiroki Iida, Masanari Ohi, Kazuki Fujii, Taishi Nakamura, Mengsay Loem, Rio Yokota, Sakae Mizuki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Open Japanese large language models (LLMs) have been trained on the Japanese
portions of corpora such as CC-100, mC4, and OSCAR. However, these corpora were
not created for the quality of Japanese texts. This study builds a large
Japanese web corpus by extracting and refining text from the Common Crawl
archive (21 snapshots of approximately 63.4 billion pages crawled between 2020
and 2023). This corpus consists of approximately 312.1 billion characters
(approximately 173 million pages), which is the largest of all available
training corpora for Japanese LLMs, surpassing CC-100 (approximately 25.8
billion characters), mC4 (approximately 239.7 billion characters) and OSCAR
23.10 (approximately 74 billion characters). To confirm the quality of the
corpus, we performed continual pre-training on Llama 2 7B, 13B, 70B, Mistral 7B
v0.1, and Mixtral 8x7B Instruct as base LLMs and gained consistent (6.6-8.1
points) improvements on Japanese benchmark datasets. We also demonstrate that
the improvement on Llama 2 13B brought from the presented corpus was the
largest among those from other existing corpora.
|
[
-0.6146904826164246,
-0.5546923279762268,
0.7016364336013794,
0.09471113234758377,
-0.3499411344528198,
0.2766187787055969,
-0.6325770616531372,
-0.5943480134010315,
0.3580043315887451,
0.6784390211105347,
-0.3906836211681366,
-0.7676613926887512,
-0.6234168410301208,
0.5530226230621338,
-0.33676230907440186,
0.7852925062179565,
0.07915326207876205,
0.04417009651660919,
0.08223167061805725,
0.12251843512058258,
-0.1231023445725441,
-0.3697122037410736,
-0.5777683854103088,
0.18111394345760345,
0.6087307929992676,
0.5058856010437012,
0.7452934384346008,
0.6462926864624023,
0.5848576426506042,
0.33027639985084534,
0.031573422253131866,
0.37629735469818115,
-0.771160900592804,
0.04555786773562431,
-0.21801449358463287,
-0.7929092645645142,
-0.5178755521774292,
-0.20675361156463623,
0.8521721363067627,
0.7529996633529663,
0.1040453091263771,
0.008961503393948078,
-0.10732699930667877,
0.4935542047023773,
-0.724081814289093,
0.043982382863759995,
-0.7756712436676025,
-0.12672969698905945,
-0.6513710618019104,
-0.09456358104944229,
-0.5246320962905884,
-0.1206134781241417,
-0.2171938419342041,
-0.8236441016197205,
0.1695898324251175,
0.06798376888036728,
0.8615964651107788,
0.038529325276613235,
-0.2277778685092926,
-0.23128531873226166,
-0.33773088455200195,
0.7840651869773865,
-0.7893853187561035,
0.4875037372112274,
0.6669037342071533,
0.16643676161766052,
-0.4020256996154785,
-0.6740487217903137,
-0.543402910232544,
-0.1556948721408844,
0.2248229682445526,
0.16368375718593597,
-0.17469045519828796,
-0.046259671449661255,
0.43054625391960144,
0.27660563588142395,
-0.7443870902061462,
0.6121219396591187,
-0.3241994082927704,
-0.19470715522766113,
0.6256981492042542,
0.26608678698539734,
0.4837931990623474,
-0.07420899718999863,
-0.10030604153871536,
-0.44330674409866333,
-0.9004244208335876,
-0.39690014719963074,
0.6078722476959229,
0.29763534665107727,
-0.03825857862830162,
0.7274259328842163,
-0.33287400007247925,
0.4230368137359619,
-0.17632931470870972,
-0.6465185880661011,
0.3254227042198181,
-0.09725750982761383,
0.0024194261059165,
0.13433606922626495,
1.0477724075317383,
0.4818870425224304,
0.3939184546470642,
-0.2250070869922638,
-0.17122261226177216,
0.10290615260601044,
0.4732426404953003,
-0.8856167793273926,
0.13527700304985046,
0.2150009125471115,
-0.36139747500419617,
-0.06316617876291275,
0.19865940511226654,
-0.9220353960990906,
-0.12045574188232422,
-0.22419758141040802,
-0.013126512058079243,
-0.6155416369438171,
-0.27557897567749023,
0.039938174188137054,
-0.29771149158477783,
0.12481173872947693,
0.35392123460769653,
-0.7464704513549805,
0.2773962914943695,
0.766393780708313,
0.8618650436401367,
-0.29093611240386963,
-0.3835605978965759,
-0.380617618560791,
0.25904151797294617,
-0.6494565010070801,
0.6798784732818604,
-0.5600844621658325,
-0.5245136618614197,
0.19745659828186035,
0.14387136697769165,
0.28446173667907715,
-0.5990830659866333,
0.556943953037262,
-0.7383202910423279,
-0.04114743322134018,
-0.003167145187035203,
-0.5946741104125977,
-0.053756244480609894,
0.2866564095020294,
-0.7746415138244629,
0.8137222528457642,
0.12375655025243759,
-0.5682174563407898,
-0.042247872799634933,
-0.5047495365142822,
-0.4797801673412323,
0.24273118376731873,
0.09498687833547592,
-0.13947811722755432,
0.14136706292629242,
0.3371005654335022,
0.5373076796531677,
-0.18211355805397034,
0.37993553280830383,
-0.5978365540504456,
-0.45467424392700195,
0.3690222501754761,
-0.31037044525146484,
0.6277533173561096,
0.3539133071899414,
-0.17369723320007324,
-0.28291890025138855,
-1.166824221611023,
-0.06831865757703781,
0.12455421686172485,
-0.5129342675209045,
-0.42393943667411804,
-0.3065018355846405,
0.03701089322566986,
-0.2731848955154419,
0.4544771909713745,
-0.6074811816215515,
0.36782193183898926,
-0.5091218948364258,
0.2771228551864624,
0.6241774559020996,
-0.19619229435920715,
0.16216149926185608,
-0.14451901614665985,
0.7597793340682983,
-0.10905002802610397,
-0.25626400113105774,
-0.37191423773765564,
-0.4280593693256378,
-0.9438654780387878,
-0.4222498834133148,
0.2696199417114258,
0.11274109780788422,
-0.6388076543807983,
0.44091176986694336,
-0.676661491394043,
-0.5645942091941833,
-0.6909433007240295,
0.030290061607956886,
0.3206973075866699,
0.11338096857070923,
0.4084339439868927,
-0.36312928795814514,
-0.9030015468597412,
-0.7993800044059753,
0.17411521077156067,
0.07837027311325073,
-0.22750049829483032,
-0.09952111542224884,
0.4592742323875427,
-0.4230668842792511,
0.7688266038894653,
-0.49713006615638733,
0.0907215029001236,
-0.1882094144821167,
0.053801145404577255,
0.3064039349555969,
0.19890040159225464,
0.13047201931476593,
-0.6449193954467773,
-0.4335789084434509,
0.046460237354040146,
-0.5758711099624634,
-0.17066793143749237,
0.13644224405288696,
-0.21915903687477112,
0.2774212658405304,
0.5704688429832458,
-0.5557859539985657,
0.027598831802606583,
0.6977882981300354,
0.13364502787590027,
0.6150674223899841,
-0.08843112736940384,
0.0958922728896141,
-1.3369694948196411,
0.414364218711853,
0.03210756927728653,
-0.5184813737869263,
-0.2971769869327545,
0.422256737947464,
0.1266447901725769,
-0.22918522357940674,
-0.42296308279037476,
0.6190794110298157,
-0.5185567736625671,
-0.2797964811325073,
-0.5611828565597534,
0.4416360855102539,
-0.10828014463186264,
0.42828071117401123,
0.14142994582653046,
0.9167454242706299,
0.18220782279968262,
-0.6905097961425781,
0.18750034272670746,
0.21065661311149597,
-0.5514353513717651,
0.2961811423301697,
-0.4637676775455475,
0.2299465537071228,
0.037730541080236435,
0.31313034892082214,
-0.9296197891235352,
-0.4852105379104614,
-0.021546674892306328,
-0.5244283676147461,
0.4487101435661316,
-0.060727380216121674,
-0.6112118363380432,
-0.33013778924942017,
-0.25918352603912354,
-0.04829282686114311,
0.5803716778755188,
-0.6451157927513123,
0.18315353989601135,
0.5796111226081848,
-0.34297531843185425,
-0.5052233934402466,
-0.46495112776756287,
0.41148585081100464,
-0.09746067225933075,
-0.45871150493621826,
0.40984684228897095,
-0.1297355741262436,
-0.22250553965568542,
-0.07166118174791336,
0.18600663542747498,
0.011725079268217087,
0.26156938076019287,
0.2040703296661377,
0.399936705827713,
-0.36855053901672363,
-0.09741286933422089,
0.03201436251401901,
-0.1325543224811554,
-0.03387101739645004,
0.009645589627325535,
1.0703446865081787,
0.044500932097435,
-0.18386101722717285,
-0.3594014048576355,
0.0635000541806221,
0.5246047377586365,
-0.056999728083610535,
0.5071290731430054,
0.5671125650405884,
-0.13641178607940674,
-0.10087423026561737,
-0.6098286509513855,
0.22170858085155487,
-0.4474787414073944,
0.6158367395401001,
-0.5143525004386902,
-1.0917515754699707,
0.36485907435417175,
-0.1353389471769333,
0.029347823932766914,
0.7559499740600586,
0.5972487926483154,
-0.02166234329342842,
1.0985437631607056,
0.4705914556980133,
-0.41806817054748535,
0.22475658357143402,
-0.24272893369197845,
-0.2421475499868393,
-1.1126042604446411,
-0.01782209426164627,
-0.7507901787757874,
-0.11932799965143204,
-0.8901849985122681,
-0.5091263055801392,
0.21306803822517395,
0.18276140093803406,
-0.35850441455841064,
0.4021831452846527,
-0.13508892059326172,
0.49375367164611816,
0.5613269209861755,
0.029231106862425804,
0.45716819167137146,
0.06951671093702316,
-0.011573366820812225,
0.14501364529132843,
-0.38451263308525085,
-0.7103942036628723,
1.4594471454620361,
0.36203503608703613,
0.6077808737754822,
0.28718122839927673,
0.6713755130767822,
-0.10899551957845688,
0.2385648936033249,
-0.7065863013267517,
0.74393230676651,
-0.3836790919303894,
-0.6675803065299988,
-0.22514092922210693,
-0.4912038743495941,
-1.3139735460281372,
0.14800962805747986,
-0.13455598056316376,
-0.623346209526062,
-0.40282759070396423,
-0.3974178731441498,
0.1276790052652359,
0.08971334248781204,
-0.19614465534687042,
0.4094666838645935,
-0.12352223694324493,
-0.24321408569812775,
-0.43769264221191406,
-0.5736453533172607,
0.4423657953739166,
-0.2016199380159378,
0.35233092308044434,
-0.07654223591089249,
-0.31840166449546814,
0.9220015406608582,
-0.5178884863853455,
0.8302257061004639,
0.12617900967597961,
-0.16299214959144592,
0.2139015644788742,
-0.12296535074710846,
0.3660598397254944,
0.0003846225736197084,
-0.0615716353058815,
0.31016120314598083,
-0.08103552460670471,
-0.3738897144794464,
-0.2634105384349823,
0.6544915437698364,
-1.1520746946334839,
-0.5119223594665527,
-0.38979363441467285,
-0.18241363763809204,
-0.4345463514328003,
0.47836944460868835,
0.3005409836769104,
0.4102264940738678,
-0.31412389874458313,
0.4886668920516968,
0.5900716185569763,
-0.4663271903991699,
0.43627092242240906,
0.6039469242095947,
-0.4868784248828888,
-0.7002058029174805,
0.7579561471939087,
-0.06264951825141907,
0.226283997297287,
0.6409041285514832,
0.24078673124313354,
-0.2853291928768158,
-0.722043514251709,
-0.60328608751297,
0.44624078273773193,
-0.5195462107658386,
-0.28671228885650635,
-0.6995946764945984,
-0.18482406437397003,
-0.6619841456413269,
-0.020886961370706558,
-0.44629204273223877,
-0.054945334792137146,
-0.336428165435791,
0.08157315850257874,
0.23895741999149323,
0.6489752531051636,
0.11305718123912811,
0.5308493375778198,
-1.1490116119384766,
0.367371529340744,
-0.3002193570137024,
0.34070414304733276,
0.15919087827205658,
-0.6447675228118896,
-0.3618628978729248,
0.23939545452594757,
-0.11006494611501694,
-0.5577341914176941,
0.6566751003265381,
0.031105849891901016,
0.5582379698753357,
0.586230993270874,
-0.11881685256958008,
1.0366990566253662,
-0.5381532311439514,
0.8483779430389404,
0.3553473949432373,
-0.7538159489631653,
0.4087941348552704,
-0.5521860718727112,
0.513043999671936,
0.6967014670372009,
0.9018282294273376,
-0.535761833190918,
-0.6946251392364502,
-0.7813289165496826,
-0.6545774340629578,
0.5845949053764343,
-0.19646748900413513,
0.2027941197156906,
-0.24392442405223846,
0.31295549869537354,
0.2807142436504364,
0.11019216477870941,
-0.5510870814323425,
0.10672418028116226,
0.15955466032028198,
-0.41425055265426636,
-0.42542484402656555,
-0.1814451366662979,
0.2413305789232254,
0.22938159108161926,
0.8945737481117249,
-0.2887714207172394,
-0.08747860789299011,
-0.05730284005403519,
-0.33803024888038635,
0.06817836314439774,
0.17139945924282074,
0.3737347424030304,
0.6005874276161194,
-0.12125668674707413,
0.12981535494327545,
0.152345210313797,
-0.8082008361816406,
-0.07986199855804443,
-0.13766129314899445,
-0.1034839078783989,
0.0690426230430603,
0.5682529807090759,
0.8026869297027588,
0.3696918487548828,
-1.217312216758728,
0.3339746594429016,
0.04922639951109886,
-0.013211479410529137,
-0.38900306820869446,
0.2112465649843216,
0.26759177446365356,
0.010733023285865784,
0.1782817840576172,
-0.6063324213027954,
0.05551653727889061,
-0.8740758895874023,
0.0064010159112513065,
0.28403550386428833,
0.008488725870847702,
-0.16167455911636353,
0.23607327044010162,
0.05661708116531372,
-0.009604339487850666,
0.9353545308113098,
-0.249728262424469,
-0.6349155306816101,
0.3047645688056946,
0.8275067806243896,
0.44017717242240906,
-0.0782921239733696,
-0.018617819994688034,
0.8353554606437683,
0.017780233174562454,
-0.45767495036125183,
-0.003375758184120059,
0.28069478273391724,
-0.7820723056793213,
-0.5467357039451599,
-1.12803316116333,
-0.6789960861206055,
0.3511532247066498,
-0.6136141419410706,
0.5021873116493225,
-0.5658023953437805,
-0.02244773879647255,
-0.1307702362537384,
0.3910747468471527,
-0.49932318925857544,
0.3758438527584076,
0.32819628715515137,
0.7220883369445801,
-0.4492446780204773,
0.8108846545219421,
0.516209602355957,
-0.5553625226020813,
-0.6723388433456421,
-0.1797013133764267,
-0.1545700579881668,
-1.1423174142837524,
0.5929335951805115,
0.346558153629303,
0.04597549885511398,
0.010043867863714695,
-0.7041176557540894,
-1.0776337385177612,
0.7762428522109985,
0.18880155682563782,
-1.169838786125183,
0.0028486212249845266,
0.27447566390037537,
0.6683745980262756,
-0.20633159577846527,
0.37417322397232056,
0.229979008436203,
0.391172856092453,
-0.017022758722305298,
-0.8081831932067871,
-0.02310759574174881,
-0.27679818868637085,
0.1562219113111496,
0.2842152416706085,
-0.7237356901168823,
0.5836994051933289,
0.040812429040670395,
-0.380903422832489,
0.41387996077537537,
0.7782696485519409,
0.44383054971694946,
0.006908460985869169,
0.34776872396469116,
0.8655949234962463,
0.9673147201538086,
0.1685394048690796,
0.9541162252426147,
-0.248223215341568,
-0.07492609322071075,
1.2929174900054932,
-0.32035478949546814,
1.3558194637298584,
0.21391288936138153,
-0.47934046387672424,
0.6028410196304321,
0.5871971845626831,
-0.24871404469013214,
0.19407103955745697,
0.35221391916275024,
-0.052944183349609375,
-0.26455074548721313,
0.050047509372234344,
-0.28528428077697754,
0.8278642892837524,
0.42033788561820984,
-0.24976158142089844,
-0.09976977854967117,
0.07485326379537582,
0.38034895062446594,
0.04064905643463135,
-0.38371917605400085,
0.8436283469200134,
0.17146533727645874,
-1.0194424390792847,
0.4577353000640869,
0.2441650778055191,
0.8349999189376831,
-0.655613362789154,
0.2153879553079605,
-0.18414132297039032,
0.16521111130714417,
-0.045449502766132355,
-0.8703119158744812,
0.11475519090890884,
0.5344613790512085,
-0.007588427048176527,
0.07394278049468994,
0.5858583450317383,
-0.24367627501487732,
-0.4384114146232605,
0.16985903680324554,
0.18296729028224945,
0.5481738448143005,
-0.15921826660633087,
-0.1800074726343155,
0.5109988451004028,
0.0022432561963796616,
-0.2925942838191986,
0.7405158281326294,
0.3850786089897156,
0.06717725843191147,
0.4556230902671814,
1.0177364349365234,
0.23039434850215912,
-0.0351751446723938,
0.19119057059288025,
0.6500586271286011,
-0.7541682720184326,
-0.393235981464386,
-0.7587872743606567,
0.2666928470134735,
-0.2709900438785553,
-0.43071261048316956,
0.7701268196105957,
0.9137385487556458,
1.0939719676971436,
0.1615666151046753,
0.9623788595199585,
0.11558113247156143,
0.6834701895713806,
-0.7807914614677429,
0.44289201498031616,
-0.6963380575180054,
-0.04003963619470596,
-0.14084500074386597,
-1.0781230926513672,
-0.2725725471973419,
0.6484676599502563,
0.03427349776029587,
-0.25040125846862793,
0.6305419206619263,
0.702062726020813,
0.059156108647584915,
0.11755907535552979,
0.29984280467033386,
0.4296725392341614,
0.4489489495754242,
0.554472029209137,
0.8562061190605164,
-0.294581800699234,
0.5247291326522827,
-0.12578411400318146,
-0.08822709321975708,
-0.317007839679718,
-0.8103611469268799,
-0.7261728644371033,
-0.4976528584957123,
-0.19462665915489197,
-0.4469587206840515,
0.07224256545305252,
0.820061981678009,
0.30447229743003845,
-0.5341185927391052,
-0.4116500914096832,
-0.06458194553852081,
-0.44271591305732727,
0.3732798099517822,
-0.1631748080253601,
0.1789907068014145,
-0.5587079524993896,
-1.044601321220398,
0.592532753944397,
0.14419126510620117,
-0.1473499983549118,
-0.32401973009109497,
-0.1292579174041748,
-0.1692916452884674,
-0.3450005054473877,
0.6375430822372437,
0.0974046066403389,
-0.5836553573608398,
-0.23478582501411438,
0.006102698389440775,
-0.3432338535785675,
0.21539506316184998,
0.29891660809516907,
-0.4728032946586609,
0.27254652976989746,
0.42110681533813477,
0.7632867693901062,
0.8228627443313599,
-0.13206948339939117,
0.6580100059509277,
-0.40430644154548645,
-0.0307049211114645,
0.22024257481098175,
0.5204866528511047,
0.4859245717525482,
0.08551739901304245,
0.5685274004936218,
0.11214325577020645,
-0.43512892723083496,
-0.659153938293457,
-0.1575116366147995,
-1.3784607648849487,
-0.5471584796905518,
1.4824808835983276,
-0.24835829436779022,
-0.5135382413864136,
0.07546887546777725,
-0.21128739416599274,
0.49810004234313965,
-0.32377928495407104,
0.4651572108268738,
0.8318202495574951,
0.4109939634799957,
0.08693726360797882,
-0.38264787197113037,
0.030054660513997078,
0.09742467105388641,
-0.9629074931144714,
-0.03409968316555023,
0.6402521133422852,
0.3429807722568512,
0.3575161099433899,
0.6391489505767822,
-0.19413365423679352,
0.1403457522392273,
0.18142075836658478,
0.12438346445560455,
0.04109437018632889,
-0.3956604599952698,
-0.11544477194547653,
0.27298906445503235,
0.22069381177425385,
0.23031604290008545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17730v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17730v1
|
Bridging the Social & Technical Divide in Augmentative and Alternative Communication (AAC) Applications for Autistic Adults
| 2024-04-26T23:30:07 | 2024-04-26T23:30:07 |
Lara J. Martin, Malathy Nagalakshmi
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques are being used more frequently
to improve high-tech Augmentative and Alternative Communication (AAC), but many
of these techniques are integrated without the inclusion of the users'
perspectives. As many of these tools are created with children in mind,
autistic adults are often neglected in the design of AAC tools to begin with.
We conducted in-depth interviews with 12 autistic adults to find the pain
points of current AAC and determine what general technological advances they
would find helpful. We found that in addition to technological issues, there
are many societal issues as well. We found 9 different categories of themes
from our interviews: input options, output options, selecting or adapting AAC
for a good fit, when to start or swap AAC, benefits (of use), access (to AAC),
stumbling blocks for continued use, social concerns, and lack of control. In
this paper, we go through these nine categories in depth and then suggest
possible guidelines for the NLP community, AAC application makers, and policy
makers to improve AAC use for autistic adults.
|
[
-0.9990149140357971,
-0.7753849625587463,
0.21317094564437866,
0.08830343186855316,
0.2926711142063141,
0.8771736025810242,
-0.07774785161018372,
-1.0191164016723633,
0.5122487545013428,
0.0794401541352272,
-0.6831691265106201,
-0.35933610796928406,
-0.6906794905662537,
0.3144743740558624,
-0.20210279524326324,
0.59376460313797,
-0.22311356663703918,
-0.45183828473091125,
0.00324416346848011,
-0.3027283847332001,
-0.7800355553627014,
-0.3740251958370209,
-1.422731876373291,
-0.2993580102920532,
0.4959581196308136,
0.8851380348205566,
0.914787232875824,
0.03950251266360283,
0.23973320424556732,
0.25833049416542053,
-0.39420101046562195,
0.41133880615234375,
0.27365824580192566,
0.02684779092669487,
-0.12008288502693176,
-0.18182803690433502,
-0.5485907793045044,
0.06204342469573021,
0.08179818093776703,
0.9767840504646301,
-0.08901908993721008,
0.19978560507297516,
0.17227347195148468,
0.7636203169822693,
-0.7328361868858337,
0.05485464259982109,
-0.018731828778982162,
0.4759886562824249,
-0.3654300272464752,
-0.28224635124206543,
-0.02447926253080368,
-0.18835577368736267,
-0.24267880618572235,
-0.6994385123252869,
0.14290183782577515,
-0.0008066203445196152,
0.34385666251182556,
-0.07973355054855347,
-0.6715475916862488,
-0.6337598562240601,
-1.0164496898651123,
0.1704886257648468,
-0.8085488677024841,
0.3050411641597748,
0.9273571968078613,
0.18051274120807648,
0.020409781485795975,
-0.12075981497764587,
-0.5386747121810913,
-0.1461668312549591,
0.2522737383842468,
-0.05039411410689354,
-0.2081521898508072,
0.21755778789520264,
-0.06935057789087296,
0.29020318388938904,
-0.4405553936958313,
0.29877084493637085,
-0.8109139204025269,
-0.15423892438411713,
0.7116096019744873,
0.04179986193776131,
0.49654340744018555,
0.12811395525932312,
0.1546964794397354,
0.3103873133659363,
-0.566291093826294,
0.3162384331226349,
0.6442770957946777,
0.08906632661819458,
-0.26848524808883667,
0.5303110480308533,
-0.23623569309711456,
0.5933809280395508,
0.48071345686912537,
0.17083445191383362,
0.42492300271987915,
-0.4150153398513794,
0.5441203713417053,
0.20665286481380463,
0.23901423811912537,
0.35538414120674133,
0.29504266381263733,
-0.10441920161247253,
-0.02186032384634018,
-0.011874170042574406,
0.7632394433021545,
0.01821417361497879,
0.036659687757492065,
0.43342092633247375,
-0.47695016860961914,
0.12226849049329758,
-0.13411188125610352,
-0.48330557346343994,
-0.5789774656295776,
-0.307776540517807,
0.022855570539832115,
-0.35521647334098816,
-0.35093438625335693,
-0.11074501276016235,
-0.09762048721313477,
0.10634435713291168,
0.2070554941892624,
-1.2145144939422607,
0.668123722076416,
0.6170090436935425,
1.1761950254440308,
0.04827049374580383,
0.05821946635842323,
-0.35842016339302063,
-0.23097358644008636,
-0.3833620548248291,
0.9547427296638489,
-0.44249945878982544,
-0.3999515175819397,
-0.009260458871722221,
-0.05234777554869652,
0.10834228992462158,
-0.4953349828720093,
0.691548764705658,
-0.46029341220855713,
0.03660893067717552,
-0.14062760770320892,
-0.044404082000255585,
-0.1662447601556778,
-0.12378668040037155,
-0.5660887360572815,
0.30629268288612366,
0.11459943652153015,
-0.5560256838798523,
0.3171217739582062,
-1.1359200477600098,
-0.6282336711883545,
0.4594383239746094,
-0.14208699762821198,
0.11560211330652237,
0.18683838844299316,
0.35098904371261597,
-0.1656537503004074,
0.10847436636686325,
-0.07953223586082458,
-0.16760842502117157,
-0.16704592108726501,
0.13267308473587036,
-0.5100722908973694,
0.691857099533081,
0.46399635076522827,
-0.3949083387851715,
0.28659674525260925,
-0.45383161306381226,
-0.41850459575653076,
-0.3762761354446411,
-0.2581861615180969,
-0.22309251129627228,
0.19849635660648346,
0.02882036752998829,
0.2594532072544098,
-0.07834351062774658,
-0.7121185064315796,
-0.4076305329799652,
-0.5867208242416382,
0.5144312381744385,
0.8059881329536438,
-0.003155776299536228,
0.6175837516784668,
-0.4226895868778229,
0.9011614918708801,
0.03898618370294571,
0.30699315667152405,
0.026858534663915634,
-0.8875201940536499,
-0.47584015130996704,
0.24148812890052795,
0.14346766471862793,
0.3686463236808777,
-1.0089753866195679,
0.7393810749053955,
0.18164202570915222,
-0.03362149000167847,
-0.9179555177688599,
0.08704057335853577,
-0.060839731246232986,
0.41020238399505615,
0.31770098209381104,
-0.8345273733139038,
-0.09667852520942688,
-0.8389350771903992,
-0.15982888638973236,
-0.022223390638828278,
-0.02318437397480011,
0.4691425859928131,
0.048023466020822525,
0.15506602823734283,
0.6071862578392029,
0.14660058915615082,
-0.4445565938949585,
-0.14034436643123627,
0.28756120800971985,
-0.1286446750164032,
0.26834872364997864,
0.13951733708381653,
-0.7128729224205017,
-0.6757228374481201,
0.26180264353752136,
-0.40690311789512634,
-0.1529407650232315,
-0.20054976642131805,
0.3541741967201233,
0.40007466077804565,
0.24375858902931213,
-0.6261665225028992,
0.8316463232040405,
0.35312020778656006,
-0.7215087413787842,
0.1093759685754776,
-0.16593004763126373,
0.6254062652587891,
-0.6677004098892212,
-0.08882550895214081,
0.16707876324653625,
0.03557814657688141,
-0.5804890394210815,
0.059946902096271515,
-0.3066789507865906,
-0.17906193435192108,
-0.14672799408435822,
0.5853613018989563,
-0.7141197919845581,
-0.19270066916942596,
-0.4445364773273468,
0.2704697549343109,
-0.15836216509342194,
-0.20790918171405792,
-0.22487466037273407,
0.8798558712005615,
0.47588226199150085,
-0.3178694248199463,
0.4813861548900604,
0.4096222221851349,
-0.09938552975654602,
0.7802436947822571,
-0.6199513077735901,
0.1877216100692749,
-0.09501425921916962,
0.36198684573173523,
-0.6930861473083496,
-0.2105361521244049,
0.8567920923233032,
-0.8979660272598267,
0.23477786779403687,
0.4348050057888031,
-0.09667152166366577,
-0.45908376574516296,
-0.3634900450706482,
0.6181276440620422,
0.24719388782978058,
-0.4041304588317871,
0.5756775736808777,
0.630247950553894,
-0.7092702388763428,
-0.6042842268943787,
-0.717864990234375,
0.7462948560714722,
-0.169933021068573,
-0.831900417804718,
0.392528235912323,
-0.11494471877813339,
-0.33145079016685486,
0.16892796754837036,
-0.2800023555755615,
0.08799991011619568,
0.21981467306613922,
0.11109562963247299,
-0.22927677631378174,
-0.3420366942882538,
0.1499093621969223,
0.4178125560283661,
-0.39735645055770874,
-0.06662897020578384,
0.4211150109767914,
0.5517867207527161,
-0.12729963660240173,
-0.5794459581375122,
-0.18049205839633942,
1.0895111560821533,
-0.16189740598201752,
-0.27260735630989075,
0.6159188747406006,
0.5421653985977173,
-0.24564345180988312,
0.0002671545371413231,
-0.47399333119392395,
-0.04861040413379669,
-0.4498900771141052,
-0.03309592604637146,
-0.009357933886349201,
-0.9851160049438477,
0.41252976655960083,
0.16150885820388794,
0.2534789443016052,
0.13186810910701752,
0.35751304030418396,
0.000600544735789299,
1.0310899019241333,
0.6003255844116211,
0.3129964768886566,
0.5450294017791748,
0.23522767424583435,
0.577968418598175,
-0.8368360996246338,
-0.11012183874845505,
-0.2748914659023285,
-0.5573776960372925,
-0.12250927090644836,
-0.30543458461761475,
0.38785770535469055,
-0.16914543509483337,
-0.15593403577804565,
0.22063614428043365,
-0.7041481137275696,
0.2737957537174225,
0.7472020387649536,
0.09207145869731903,
0.5062881112098694,
-0.19312751293182373,
0.46652767062187195,
0.19529542326927185,
-0.6112043261528015,
-0.4859289526939392,
0.8995153307914734,
0.6647272109985352,
0.43157270550727844,
0.26994261145591736,
0.6819970607757568,
0.5511704087257385,
0.3081486225128174,
-0.8484723567962646,
0.32123857736587524,
-0.0446011908352375,
-0.899148166179657,
-0.03937508165836334,
-0.39563697576522827,
-1.0942492485046387,
-0.13271531462669373,
-0.1631394624710083,
-1.0891238451004028,
0.7974599599838257,
0.042325835675001144,
-0.7533314824104309,
0.23948493599891663,
-0.9005285501480103,
0.6306761503219604,
0.03141980990767479,
-0.08377127349376678,
-0.4335777759552002,
-0.9912235736846924,
0.27247536182403564,
-0.13111406564712524,
0.6466218829154968,
-0.1364697813987732,
-0.1945745050907135,
0.5287098288536072,
-0.27513831853866577,
0.8218761086463928,
0.0741167739033699,
-0.003974224906414747,
0.6232282519340515,
-0.2828035354614258,
-0.21016383171081543,
-0.1456882655620575,
0.06584478914737701,
0.056884653866291046,
0.23323620855808258,
-0.24802933633327484,
-0.2705034017562866,
0.6824538111686707,
-0.8419917821884155,
-0.5708927512168884,
-0.7020714282989502,
-0.29718196392059326,
-0.46033602952957153,
-0.3468988537788391,
-0.08269180357456207,
0.4699976146221161,
-0.10134585946798325,
0.2362501621246338,
0.029229436069726944,
-0.27759304642677307,
0.501800537109375,
0.2770906984806061,
0.2185792624950409,
-0.14230266213417053,
0.6214696168899536,
0.3320178687572479,
0.13831956684589386,
-0.30717360973358154,
-0.2279081791639328,
-0.02911163493990898,
-0.5313370227813721,
-0.3506840467453003,
0.06630157679319382,
-0.8760267496109009,
-0.15374493598937988,
-0.45958060026168823,
-0.6147448420524597,
-0.8221864104270935,
-0.33800846338272095,
0.08847878873348236,
-0.5824353694915771,
-0.48329877853393555,
-0.3715864419937134,
0.43054014444351196,
0.6693933010101318,
-0.6868273615837097,
0.4455532133579254,
-0.8423600792884827,
0.6112496256828308,
-0.0022243079729378223,
0.3159694969654083,
0.21877142786979675,
-0.3006606101989746,
-0.28887975215911865,
0.15387144684791565,
-0.6052349805831909,
-0.8941646814346313,
0.37710392475128174,
0.3843079209327698,
0.5210031867027283,
0.05291634798049927,
0.24729707837104797,
0.33384594321250916,
-0.3201984763145447,
0.9149142503738403,
0.15766070783138275,
-0.6717963814735413,
0.19224698841571808,
0.16578462719917297,
0.17072369158267975,
0.5891123414039612,
0.49838683009147644,
-0.8983961343765259,
-0.12686656415462494,
-0.6067678332328796,
-1.3336693048477173,
0.680343508720398,
0.09124338626861572,
0.20690491795539856,
-0.13753755390644073,
0.2646882236003876,
0.05564142391085625,
0.04930822178721428,
-0.604934573173523,
-0.25881630182266235,
-0.24121126532554626,
-0.2770215570926666,
-0.1675247848033905,
0.05271755903959274,
-0.39207252860069275,
-0.22623930871486664,
0.4242785573005676,
-0.11052890121936798,
0.16142068803310394,
-0.03544691577553749,
0.4745011627674103,
-0.4250245690345764,
0.3875843286514282,
0.18194076418876648,
0.595821738243103,
0.17500579357147217,
0.20066209137439728,
-0.1253950297832489,
-0.4721623659133911,
0.08129038661718369,
0.2294076830148697,
0.02016005665063858,
-0.21636167168617249,
0.3064795136451721,
0.7666537165641785,
-0.3039167821407318,
-0.5626247525215149,
0.19541868567466736,
-0.02860695868730545,
-0.17166224122047424,
-0.3759124279022217,
0.17847499251365662,
0.28230470418930054,
0.365243136882782,
0.3267776072025299,
0.49514442682266235,
0.4218893349170685,
-0.6650794148445129,
0.2400783896446228,
0.43106698989868164,
-0.42662790417671204,
-0.42714008688926697,
0.5064209699630737,
0.5777888894081116,
-1.1385596990585327,
0.055223871022462845,
-0.060954056680202484,
0.21524126827716827,
0.48979324102401733,
0.23235300183296204,
1.1160800457000732,
-0.20858246088027954,
0.6682910919189453,
-0.06055451184511185,
0.5228159427642822,
0.35659974813461304,
0.12406550347805023,
-0.5156553387641907,
-0.6508434414863586,
-0.3719108998775482,
-0.09045547246932983,
-0.39785924553871155,
-0.3383156359195709,
-0.3849022686481476,
-0.07376345992088318,
-0.5139697790145874,
-0.6694622039794922,
0.313418984413147,
-0.1968381553888321,
-0.5043407082557678,
0.03105432353913784,
0.3653375506401062,
0.8858715891838074,
-0.8517627716064453,
0.29846322536468506,
0.7889799475669861,
-0.6207743287086487,
-0.5419635772705078,
0.2608412802219391,
0.33010536432266235,
-0.4757668673992157,
0.13997206091880798,
-0.10613919794559479,
-0.19904208183288574,
-0.2377900928258896,
-0.4319894313812256,
-0.7077057957649231,
0.7785518169403076,
-0.2876776456832886,
0.08199066668748856,
-0.37101584672927856,
0.05995818227529526,
0.6419433355331421,
-0.5043858885765076,
0.3660767078399658,
0.5462566614151001,
0.5429874062538147,
0.09982675313949585,
-0.9809283018112183,
-0.0956624299287796,
-0.5396487712860107,
-0.1951911747455597,
-0.08749164640903473,
-0.45815402269363403,
0.47959157824516296,
0.11646581441164017,
-0.5132232308387756,
-0.043182771652936935,
0.4167444407939911,
0.04122176021337509,
0.7069358825683594,
0.4963756799697876,
-0.08938907831907272,
0.2653678059577942,
0.2323979139328003,
0.7436311841011047,
-0.3325875997543335,
-0.31194382905960083,
0.8394758701324463,
-0.11715038120746613,
0.5010389089584351,
0.49257180094718933,
-0.1292518824338913,
0.17689616978168488,
0.8473033308982849,
0.6722837686538696,
0.14318451285362244,
-0.11139760911464691,
-0.7316647171974182,
0.08725166320800781,
-0.42975687980651855,
-0.48846375942230225,
0.13207416236400604,
0.7807023525238037,
0.05309605970978737,
-0.26315101981163025,
0.15478821098804474,
-0.21099185943603516,
0.26266056299209595,
-0.3067786693572998,
0.8471614122390747,
0.538884699344635,
-0.4315762519836426,
0.4748750329017639,
0.2710893154144287,
0.9445767998695374,
-0.5384038090705872,
0.011689535342156887,
-0.06547070294618607,
-0.1139979213476181,
-0.43337690830230713,
-0.9452829957008362,
0.8176434636116028,
-0.05831427499651909,
0.21328750252723694,
-0.1748550683259964,
0.9626786112785339,
-0.19358772039413452,
-0.26580095291137695,
0.20339158177375793,
0.4817732870578766,
0.004567419178783894,
-0.01831849105656147,
-0.718466579914093,
0.031434476375579834,
-0.34396257996559143,
-0.15165944397449493,
0.32357385754585266,
0.4253323972225189,
-0.14468051493167877,
0.8239381909370422,
0.4244757294654846,
0.5405566692352295,
-0.09245342016220093,
-0.05091509968042374,
0.7755516171455383,
-0.5493173599243164,
-0.40731674432754517,
-0.03264785557985306,
0.549690306186676,
-0.20231065154075623,
-0.8004633784294128,
0.6856099367141724,
-0.0474095456302166,
0.5168877840042114,
0.33573460578918457,
0.5461384654045105,
-0.24732744693756104,
0.7233851552009583,
-0.11118780076503754,
0.5428455471992493,
-0.4251914620399475,
0.3224780857563019,
-0.15028835833072662,
-0.7776092290878296,
-0.1277482956647873,
0.7975380420684814,
-0.47334524989128113,
0.35478851199150085,
0.5087318420410156,
0.35572296380996704,
-0.037602201104164124,
0.519753634929657,
0.07447117567062378,
-0.14638902246952057,
0.49465444684028625,
0.35543057322502136,
1.0326718091964722,
0.06368546187877655,
-0.05383744090795517,
-0.4906546473503113,
-0.5815746188163757,
-0.02010875567793846,
-0.36931824684143066,
-0.4806421399116516,
-0.5152719020843506,
-0.28986820578575134,
-0.19788017868995667,
0.2580452561378479,
1.2676914930343628,
0.39436614513397217,
-0.6589754819869995,
-0.29398244619369507,
-0.013206815347075462,
0.2350548505783081,
-0.10655509680509567,
-0.27959147095680237,
-0.12195701897144318,
-0.19334550201892853,
-0.4254847764968872,
0.47692960500717163,
0.36635303497314453,
-0.3109917938709259,
-0.3505602478981018,
0.26851886510849,
-0.33044928312301636,
0.09277480840682983,
0.693863570690155,
0.7842774987220764,
-0.5777356624603271,
-0.8977106213569641,
-0.03517300635576248,
0.46188926696777344,
0.34552639722824097,
0.686843991279602,
-0.5776941180229187,
0.40651223063468933,
0.21803823113441467,
0.7182099223136902,
0.17034798860549927,
0.33355170488357544,
0.6631478071212769,
-0.40251660346984863,
-0.06558074802160263,
0.6831886768341064,
-0.0489768460392952,
0.459447979927063,
-0.39577946066856384,
0.42399829626083374,
0.21815434098243713,
-0.49087828397750854,
-0.5498496890068054,
0.26315557956695557,
-0.8936413526535034,
-0.3546043336391449,
1.103288173675537,
0.11097493022680283,
-0.001423463225364685,
-0.9038133025169373,
-0.6083645224571228,
-0.0012601036578416824,
-0.6247268915176392,
0.6568407416343689,
0.7378755807876587,
-0.41107380390167236,
-0.44980767369270325,
-0.6504108309745789,
0.29493483901023865,
0.011961826123297215,
-0.7538097500801086,
-0.10489201545715332,
0.6141814589500427,
-0.044469770044088364,
0.2732357382774353,
1.0122753381729126,
-0.19357894361019135,
0.12320633232593536,
0.30717742443084717,
0.1300961822271347,
-0.004188288934528828,
-0.3924875259399414,
-0.4863756597042084,
0.10866524279117584,
0.24956868588924408,
0.08534951508045197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17729v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17729v1
|
CoMM: Collaborative Multi-Agent, Multi-Reasoning-Path Prompting for Complex Problem Solving
| 2024-04-26T23:29:12 | 2024-04-26T23:29:12 |
Pei Chen, Boran Han, Shuai Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown great ability in solving traditional
natural language tasks and elementary reasoning tasks with appropriate
prompting techniques. However, their ability is still limited in solving
complicated science problems. In this work, we aim to push the upper bound of
the reasoning capability of LLMs by proposing a collaborative multi-agent,
multi-reasoning-path (CoMM) prompting framework. Specifically, we prompt LLMs
to play different roles in a problem-solving team, and encourage different
role-play agents to collaboratively solve the target task. In particular, we
discover that applying different reasoning paths for different roles is an
effective strategy to implement few-shot prompting approaches in the
multi-agent scenarios. Empirical results demonstrate the effectiveness of the
proposed methods on two college-level science problems over competitive
baselines. Our further analysis shows the necessity of prompting LLMs to play
different roles or experts independently. We release the code at:
https://github.com/amazon-science/comm-prompt
|
[
-0.4366695284843445,
-0.909328281879425,
0.9918953776359558,
0.4494480490684509,
0.1666267216205597,
0.3415718078613281,
-0.3226948082447052,
-0.18683068454265594,
0.05630037561058998,
0.3513849377632141,
-1.0144598484039307,
-0.3648609220981598,
-0.3525996208190918,
0.548165500164032,
0.22673438489437103,
0.4905231297016144,
0.0836453065276146,
0.22185252606868744,
-0.449228972196579,
0.10376887023448944,
-0.8457164764404297,
-0.13589881360530853,
-0.8553728461265564,
-0.5391131043434143,
0.9075578451156616,
1.0459553003311157,
0.6475637555122375,
0.20781901478767395,
0.5610761642456055,
0.32075023651123047,
-0.01892208121716976,
0.670216977596283,
-0.15993453562259674,
0.7484895586967468,
-0.14105167984962463,
-0.6706680059432983,
-0.3108469545841217,
-0.12069619446992874,
0.6003120541572571,
0.8138803243637085,
-0.06262771785259247,
-0.03475967422127724,
-0.014292329549789429,
0.3519115746021271,
-0.48801374435424805,
0.3118667006492615,
-0.46417179703712463,
-0.11802541464567184,
0.16500680148601532,
-0.4921981692314148,
-0.8119351267814636,
0.01562297809869051,
0.03671974688768387,
-0.9288271069526672,
0.05431302264332771,
0.3102591037750244,
0.19755111634731293,
0.43973541259765625,
-0.3494094908237457,
-0.08323705196380615,
-0.4854815602302551,
0.8498796820640564,
-0.3059076964855194,
-0.004310746677219868,
0.18583381175994873,
0.4746210277080536,
-0.6712698936462402,
-0.18656925857067108,
-0.622623860836029,
-0.25637415051460266,
0.11443231999874115,
0.21240758895874023,
-0.11380578577518463,
0.081279456615448,
0.22026662528514862,
-0.44146376848220825,
-0.5540577173233032,
0.03134353086352348,
-0.30519652366638184,
0.005378059111535549,
0.5013855695724487,
0.42966732382774353,
0.12497752159833908,
0.17667846381664276,
-0.40713101625442505,
-0.06281157582998276,
-0.8451895117759705,
0.16543248295783997,
0.13358904421329498,
0.6611800193786621,
-0.06372212618589401,
0.5272700190544128,
-0.1991456300020218,
0.6679515838623047,
0.03179188445210457,
-0.0003402302390895784,
-0.1881929636001587,
-0.28312572836875916,
0.11230224370956421,
0.15305164456367493,
0.5553637742996216,
0.25140413641929626,
0.1617485135793686,
0.1474626213312149,
0.17914097011089325,
-0.1279994547367096,
-0.12845949828624725,
-0.364299476146698,
0.014654959551990032,
0.34681177139282227,
-0.1937306672334671,
0.05174010992050171,
-0.26967817544937134,
-0.7343326210975647,
-0.8164210915565491,
-0.4048402011394501,
0.7395026087760925,
-0.2506990432739258,
-0.2063785344362259,
0.21925048530101776,
-0.2770964801311493,
0.06836015731096268,
0.769393265247345,
-0.5718525648117065,
0.17905724048614502,
0.6876078248023987,
0.7749410271644592,
0.036525946110486984,
-0.707358717918396,
-0.9422792792320251,
0.4649891257286072,
-0.07727222889661789,
1.0453238487243652,
-0.8368822336196899,
-0.4146527647972107,
-0.10675446689128876,
-0.25508958101272583,
-0.014209975488483906,
-0.48185762763023376,
0.26294946670532227,
-0.2644864320755005,
-0.039553556591272354,
-0.6325106620788574,
-0.3354160785675049,
-0.08781098574399948,
0.5287843346595764,
-0.6321902871131897,
0.7363823056221008,
-0.21138794720172882,
-0.338470995426178,
0.04818621650338173,
-0.94842129945755,
-0.08621792495250702,
0.304413765668869,
-0.3041304647922516,
-0.05348498746752739,
-0.35009270906448364,
0.38627567887306213,
0.5969639420509338,
-0.480619877576828,
0.22066612541675568,
-0.2699348032474518,
-0.3157586455345154,
0.21656611561775208,
-0.3126574456691742,
0.8475443124771118,
0.14131055772304535,
-0.01557097490876913,
0.44083529710769653,
-0.34199073910713196,
0.015465420670807362,
0.12422683089971542,
-0.21915899217128754,
-0.12501975893974304,
-0.03380654752254486,
-0.3817296326160431,
0.271507203578949,
0.2513475716114044,
-0.1988750845193863,
0.5983776450157166,
-0.0932198241353035,
0.21185706555843353,
0.7779058814048767,
0.07253067940473557,
0.4639371335506439,
-0.7398809790611267,
0.7433615326881409,
-0.015062674880027771,
0.13900789618492126,
-0.3255470395088196,
-0.6595758199691772,
-0.4667980372905731,
-0.5458876490592957,
-0.3237035870552063,
0.4814990162849426,
-0.791216254234314,
0.1808081865310669,
0.2459173947572708,
-0.41802048683166504,
-0.39906948804855347,
0.0416816808283329,
0.2612374424934387,
0.1880270391702652,
0.5453462600708008,
0.26517191529273987,
-0.6133772134780884,
-0.3608902394771576,
-0.23417873680591583,
-0.1714031845331192,
0.19061340391635895,
0.3187806308269501,
0.4771011471748352,
-0.0066164112649858,
1.2287994623184204,
-0.5743421316146851,
-0.35945600271224976,
-0.43903931975364685,
0.2477736622095108,
0.28158506751060486,
0.3345966339111328,
0.08465362340211868,
-0.6395319104194641,
-0.612612247467041,
-0.3644547760486603,
-0.5827513933181763,
-0.3563218116760254,
-0.021439505741000175,
-0.08354470878839493,
-0.03689267858862877,
0.6344195604324341,
-1.0443744659423828,
0.01626998372375965,
0.5794259905815125,
-0.3710561692714691,
0.8159869313240051,
-0.3078813850879669,
0.24609337747097015,
-1.0419620275497437,
-0.18152619898319244,
0.058325909078121185,
-0.057735625654459,
-0.4895476698875427,
0.045321207493543625,
-0.6318918466567993,
-0.11650961637496948,
-0.5130890011787415,
0.5450896620750427,
-0.7169166207313538,
0.09081294387578964,
-0.2896488606929779,
0.2555118501186371,
0.06884633749723434,
0.24350212514400482,
0.06626952439546585,
0.5701223611831665,
0.7769398093223572,
-0.6543832421302795,
0.7236671447753906,
0.20570406317710876,
0.2403430938720703,
0.8196099400520325,
-0.5333436727523804,
0.12239067256450653,
-0.17908884584903717,
0.7259734272956848,
-0.9729604125022888,
-0.3712686002254486,
0.2640015482902527,
-0.29166150093078613,
-0.06838274747133255,
-0.08070746809244156,
-0.74448162317276,
-0.40502241253852844,
-0.20019803941249847,
0.5438745617866516,
0.16222696006298065,
-0.48399707674980164,
0.6850656867027283,
-0.08057206124067307,
-0.16171987354755402,
-0.5015528798103333,
-0.26572662591934204,
0.11730486154556274,
-0.13655371963977814,
-0.8795880675315857,
0.3310823440551758,
-0.5971211194992065,
-0.45000338554382324,
-0.0285195279866457,
0.09669756889343262,
-0.07812107354402542,
-0.04072153568267822,
0.3314065933227539,
0.34438130259513855,
-0.08597628027200699,
0.16298964619636536,
0.056798022240400314,
-0.20392267405986786,
0.1671617478132248,
-0.14781776070594788,
0.5352460741996765,
-0.18539953231811523,
-0.5325664281845093,
-0.3746289908885956,
0.7977463603019714,
0.3931521773338318,
-0.23767569661140442,
0.7156835794448853,
0.30303651094436646,
-0.42708611488342285,
-0.3637172281742096,
-0.4163232445716858,
-0.763373076915741,
-0.5282667875289917,
-0.05404992774128914,
-0.3521304726600647,
-0.9912994503974915,
0.3748510181903839,
-0.5327737927436829,
-0.11282795667648315,
-0.13948345184326172,
0.8336562514305115,
-0.06765847653150558,
1.1782151460647583,
0.3104878067970276,
0.2945895791053772,
0.03945012763142586,
-0.2796962857246399,
0.2417367547750473,
-0.4503149390220642,
-0.4821517765522003,
-0.8066686391830444,
-0.03190907835960388,
-0.17027361690998077,
-0.6407370567321777,
0.8001025319099426,
0.13695473968982697,
-0.24444451928138733,
0.1411570906639099,
-0.6327353119850159,
0.7861879467964172,
0.6054365038871765,
0.0784483477473259,
0.5492275357246399,
-0.14337970316410065,
-0.33385103940963745,
0.30732449889183044,
-0.9634897112846375,
-0.42410391569137573,
0.4666662812232971,
0.055362701416015625,
0.7714763879776001,
0.3711583912372589,
0.8107668161392212,
0.0384383387863636,
-0.16224685311317444,
-1.0950102806091309,
0.8186262845993042,
0.23013636469841003,
-0.8348350524902344,
-0.6163654923439026,
-0.2560412287712097,
-1.2886772155761719,
0.22187665104866028,
-0.3936076760292053,
-0.6817556619644165,
-0.01128433458507061,
0.1040688082575798,
-0.6204060316085815,
-0.05922738090157509,
-0.6917548775672913,
0.6132656931877136,
0.09096833318471909,
-0.45640116930007935,
-0.4018333852291107,
-0.7819915413856506,
-0.04158329591155052,
0.25891485810279846,
0.3553256392478943,
-0.2000030130147934,
-0.05632435902953148,
0.3516862988471985,
-0.30036547780036926,
1.0537937879562378,
-0.14812588691711426,
0.07492697983980179,
0.5942815542221069,
0.25026583671569824,
0.6647229194641113,
-0.03129979595541954,
-0.21700313687324524,
-0.34663841128349304,
0.0029679981525987387,
-0.36572691798210144,
-0.5488592982292175,
0.6427201628684998,
-0.5507224202156067,
-1.0074931383132935,
-0.5410400629043579,
-0.927903950214386,
-0.4712849259376526,
0.18476121127605438,
0.17853963375091553,
0.20072750747203827,
0.15651845932006836,
0.11086096614599228,
0.5740938186645508,
0.12968935072422028,
0.6802213788032532,
0.6612257361412048,
0.1040034145116806,
-0.12614914774894714,
0.6809685826301575,
0.08445063978433609,
0.27203163504600525,
0.2168438881635666,
0.5080100893974304,
-0.15547390282154083,
-0.36011940240859985,
-0.22341826558113098,
0.15982748568058014,
-0.6832445859909058,
-0.2927897572517395,
-0.40383273363113403,
0.05283745005726814,
-0.36449486017227173,
-0.4748168885707855,
-0.05843644589185715,
-0.05160064250230789,
-0.3128836154937744,
0.2657449543476105,
0.5383253693580627,
0.6132744550704956,
-0.24449200928211212,
0.32627591490745544,
-1.038221836090088,
0.06945665180683136,
0.3670481741428375,
-0.014506871812045574,
0.08442098647356033,
0.02082577720284462,
-0.12805691361427307,
-0.1242867112159729,
-0.36224061250686646,
-0.9477084875106812,
0.24707412719726562,
-0.08996514230966568,
0.7909404039382935,
0.02383992448449135,
0.25136348605155945,
0.4152861535549164,
-0.4992454946041107,
0.8201360106468201,
0.5138458609580994,
-0.7839928865432739,
0.5280643105506897,
-0.6067475080490112,
0.45823782682418823,
0.34909120202064514,
0.47530755400657654,
-0.3684554696083069,
-0.6266165971755981,
-0.3244374692440033,
-0.5590800642967224,
0.8323073387145996,
0.163503959774971,
-0.21492861211299896,
0.09327889233827591,
0.03210445120930672,
0.17705954611301422,
-0.05015818402171135,
-0.4074649214744568,
-0.3216858506202698,
0.17974333465099335,
-0.27937787771224976,
0.23064182698726654,
0.2373194545507431,
-0.4164593815803528,
-0.11691383272409439,
0.5565744042396545,
-0.41907253861427307,
0.17818185687065125,
0.3773147761821747,
0.17037975788116455,
-0.524682879447937,
0.6677230596542358,
0.5238804221153259,
0.40474042296409607,
0.053380779922008514,
0.36958256363868713,
0.1184481605887413,
-0.1304098516702652,
0.46879467368125916,
0.11325716972351074,
0.16316962242126465,
-0.23557914793491364,
0.24643753468990326,
0.356199711561203,
-0.27976706624031067,
-0.5882589221000671,
0.43839403986930847,
0.17765183746814728,
-0.23964449763298035,
-0.022120360285043716,
0.32832151651382446,
0.35151737928390503,
0.6707466244697571,
0.7023903131484985,
0.08997330814599991,
0.14216013252735138,
-0.570137619972229,
-0.06093510612845421,
0.4336623549461365,
-0.09959451854228973,
-0.02377925254404545,
0.3301534950733185,
0.36126405000686646,
-0.4930984377861023,
0.20397846400737762,
-0.385019987821579,
-0.6421260833740234,
0.9150392413139343,
0.6947579979896545,
0.40681561827659607,
-0.28353196382522583,
0.5275558233261108,
0.23720629513263702,
0.15306456387043,
-0.4994604289531708,
0.27076029777526855,
0.287263423204422,
-0.7084515690803528,
-0.7579854726791382,
0.0591430738568306,
-0.9094433188438416,
-0.07004425674676895,
0.00841862428933382,
0.6131426692008972,
-0.32681185007095337,
-0.0672222450375557,
0.14150413870811462,
0.09452537447214127,
-0.32703548669815063,
-0.03360382094979286,
0.08393913507461548,
0.7025645971298218,
-0.5398217439651489,
0.4956422746181488,
0.8468636870384216,
-0.45869117975234985,
-1.2964502573013306,
-0.04239759221673012,
0.3811444342136383,
-0.3555920720100403,
0.5898647904396057,
0.23334982991218567,
-0.5340678095817566,
0.17810013890266418,
-1.041494607925415,
-0.48903900384902954,
1.1714898347854614,
0.5113966464996338,
-0.5602074861526489,
0.013756568543612957,
-0.02210227958858013,
0.3378804326057434,
-0.6565284132957458,
0.27832019329071045,
-0.0036113967653363943,
0.7995489239692688,
0.37283840775489807,
-0.9078056216239929,
0.3701487183570862,
0.10802202671766281,
-0.6868292093276978,
-0.022177819162607193,
-0.9592810869216919,
0.9402599930763245,
-0.5458501577377319,
0.2828272879123688,
0.09117548912763596,
0.31772297620773315,
1.0328090190887451,
0.8576735258102417,
0.7931401133537292,
-0.038709916174411774,
0.9241607785224915,
0.17306272685527802,
0.5348507165908813,
0.02320990152657032,
0.23985032737255096,
1.0348186492919922,
-0.6324286460876465,
0.5541368722915649,
0.6617323756217957,
0.07519368082284927,
0.5694179534912109,
0.39403533935546875,
-0.10387808829545975,
0.2937746047973633,
0.2089637666940689,
-0.66038978099823,
-0.815748393535614,
-0.484001487493515,
-0.21453548967838287,
0.3803456723690033,
0.3233307898044586,
0.1869913637638092,
-0.30784672498703003,
0.02953471429646015,
0.06800989806652069,
0.11949814856052399,
-0.4902369976043701,
0.3078400194644928,
0.4309694766998291,
-1.053303837776184,
0.3032727539539337,
-0.23259951174259186,
0.41019392013549805,
-0.4359453022480011,
-0.40671658515930176,
0.13362917304039001,
-0.07069186866283417,
-0.3626941740512848,
-0.8672634363174438,
-0.05063294619321823,
-0.20264877378940582,
-0.23365677893161774,
-0.12787365913391113,
0.7970114350318909,
-0.6588450074195862,
0.006218915339559317,
0.34914761781692505,
0.9473695755004883,
0.1235053539276123,
-0.05181734636425972,
-0.6946681141853333,
-0.02125934697687626,
-0.4218204617500305,
0.03257328271865845,
0.09978985786437988,
0.5890223383903503,
-0.23921772837638855,
0.9858068823814392,
0.690633237361908,
-0.117036834359169,
-0.07880616188049316,
0.3401733934879303,
0.728860080242157,
-0.5249025225639343,
-0.34426096081733704,
-0.9202705025672913,
0.47305065393447876,
0.01252781879156828,
0.0943290963768959,
0.572027862071991,
0.28654393553733826,
0.33707696199417114,
-0.09867886453866959,
0.713318943977356,
0.1480139046907425,
0.2571074664592743,
-0.4543541371822357,
0.28454214334487915,
-0.4693792760372162,
0.349153995513916,
-0.20442625880241394,
-0.9016008377075195,
-0.5490358471870422,
0.45078590512275696,
0.06018788367509842,
0.06982728093862534,
1.0355331897735596,
0.9438413977622986,
0.25633475184440613,
0.010079657658934593,
0.2806616723537445,
0.10793881863355637,
0.3409317135810852,
0.8054080009460449,
1.1970282793045044,
0.29347705841064453,
0.8372602462768555,
0.18001149594783783,
-0.27714163064956665,
-0.5063142776489258,
-1.1224912405014038,
-1.0307058095932007,
-0.3728610873222351,
-0.4151666462421417,
-0.4737902581691742,
0.02476068213582039,
1.5752222537994385,
0.7385364174842834,
-0.44494161009788513,
-0.2932929992675781,
-0.2921331226825714,
0.3739425837993622,
-0.5357303619384766,
-0.20101813971996307,
-0.023195309564471245,
-0.30606937408447266,
-0.6297637224197388,
0.7865651845932007,
0.14484772086143494,
-0.1297338753938675,
-0.5167024731636047,
-0.3563253879547119,
-0.48543187975883484,
0.3682742714881897,
0.5024979710578918,
0.13818643987178802,
-0.6816772222518921,
-0.291401207447052,
0.30072370171546936,
-0.2341243475675583,
-0.0009286089916713536,
0.8867402076721191,
-0.7478365898132324,
0.317343145608902,
0.7460213899612427,
0.35825157165527344,
0.3037731349468231,
-0.237189382314682,
0.46892014145851135,
-0.7364416122436523,
-0.14703048765659332,
0.3301214873790741,
0.28197646141052246,
0.28027430176734924,
-0.5531144738197327,
0.4736920893192291,
0.302365243434906,
-0.7105790376663208,
-0.674788773059845,
0.32854539155960083,
-1.4138482809066772,
-0.5129112601280212,
1.339896559715271,
-0.09129060804843903,
-0.15427668392658234,
-0.37187257409095764,
-0.7435734868049622,
0.38908225297927856,
-0.8916311264038086,
0.4903525412082672,
0.8913905024528503,
-0.5425483584403992,
-0.4079795777797699,
-0.1809363216161728,
0.22176523506641388,
0.5369783043861389,
-0.9489871859550476,
-0.05172208324074745,
0.5745977759361267,
-0.05448480695486069,
0.3562351167201996,
0.7451320290565491,
0.4063289761543274,
0.40150919556617737,
-0.03624066337943077,
-0.11684223264455795,
-0.3981058895587921,
-0.7423852682113647,
-0.22881343960762024,
0.21297284960746765,
0.28697529435157776,
0.15974344313144684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17723v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17723v2
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation with Knowledge Graphs for Customer Service Question Answering
| 2024-04-26T23:05:20 | 2024-05-06T05:16:42 |
Zhentao Xu, Mark Jerome Cruz, Matthew Guevara, Tie Wang, Manasi Deshpande, Xiaofeng Wang, Zheng Li
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2
|
In customer service technical support, swiftly and accurately retrieving
relevant past issues is critical for efficiently resolving customer inquiries.
The conventional retrieval methods in retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) for
large language models (LLMs) treat a large corpus of past issue tracking
tickets as plain text, ignoring the crucial intra-issue structure and
inter-issue relations, which limits performance. We introduce a novel customer
service question-answering method that amalgamates RAG with a knowledge graph
(KG). Our method constructs a KG from historical issues for use in retrieval,
retaining the intra-issue structure and inter-issue relations. During the
question-answering phase, our method parses consumer queries and retrieves
related sub-graphs from the KG to generate answers. This integration of a KG
not only improves retrieval accuracy by preserving customer service structure
information but also enhances answering quality by mitigating the effects of
text segmentation. Empirical assessments on our benchmark datasets, utilizing
key retrieval (MRR, Recall@K, NDCG@K) and text generation (BLEU, ROUGE, METEOR)
metrics, reveal that our method outperforms the baseline by 77.6% in MRR and by
0.32 in BLEU. Our method has been deployed within LinkedIn's customer service
team for approximately six months and has reduced the median per-issue
resolution time by 28.6%.
|
[
-0.3342161178588867,
-0.766385018825531,
0.4217635989189148,
-0.006946541368961334,
-0.12209706753492355,
0.43945398926734924,
0.26110896468162537,
-0.5731262564659119,
0.4344087243080139,
0.6964337825775146,
-0.7014970183372498,
-0.384846568107605,
0.012758873403072357,
0.1311279833316803,
-0.20903564989566803,
0.9896385669708252,
0.06838922202587128,
-0.07445330172777176,
-0.44791245460510254,
-0.10285098105669022,
-0.4672204554080963,
-0.5510980486869812,
-0.7954081892967224,
-0.37226250767707825,
0.6992393732070923,
0.4818286597728729,
0.4799315929412842,
0.29656746983528137,
0.40219271183013916,
0.26370638608932495,
-0.355554461479187,
0.6095741987228394,
-0.5501022338867188,
0.5614346265792847,
0.0497911274433136,
-0.30607303977012634,
-0.4577659070491791,
-0.25121328234672546,
0.3915725648403168,
0.7954626083374023,
-0.027011897414922714,
0.35107162594795227,
-0.07523734122514725,
0.8131078481674194,
-0.6192895770072937,
-0.026304420083761215,
-0.797304093837738,
-0.11969485878944397,
-0.014953842386603355,
-0.3455832004547119,
-0.43216267228126526,
-0.6017763018608093,
0.06493905186653137,
-0.7634365558624268,
0.2869775891304016,
0.230964794754982,
1.0327885150909424,
0.12536071240901947,
-0.27017226815223694,
-0.45793628692626953,
-0.511210560798645,
0.3461260497570038,
-0.23850929737091064,
0.3010369837284088,
0.5322080254554749,
0.6317242383956909,
-0.0013422075426205993,
-0.891528308391571,
-0.389358252286911,
-0.03541462495923042,
-0.22850309312343597,
0.26521188020706177,
-0.0820595845580101,
-0.3961315453052521,
0.3082669675350189,
0.19469629228115082,
-0.5137007832527161,
-0.23475784063339233,
-0.48944783210754395,
-0.33238744735717773,
0.7329258322715759,
0.4109029471874237,
0.133775532245636,
-0.5398925542831421,
-0.22112803161144257,
0.045856934040784836,
-0.736949622631073,
0.08019324392080307,
0.3221827447414398,
0.24883486330509186,
0.4305902123451233,
0.6861870884895325,
-0.33893921971321106,
0.6428386569023132,
0.14117909967899323,
-0.021816162392497063,
0.26780906319618225,
-0.10588584840297699,
0.0401969850063324,
0.14289650321006775,
0.605914831161499,
0.2813616394996643,
0.20721633732318878,
-0.4647917151451111,
-0.1486985981464386,
-0.552594006061554,
0.2953830063343048,
-0.7506117224693298,
-0.06631767749786377,
0.11637374758720398,
-0.1412905901670456,
-0.2431875616312027,
-0.0075316461734473705,
-0.7025184035301208,
-0.5906983613967896,
-0.0655064806342125,
-0.03500795736908913,
-0.4611037075519562,
-0.2887398898601532,
-0.5015966296195984,
-0.29763758182525635,
0.21580614149570465,
0.12553811073303223,
-0.2544565796852112,
0.15963171422481537,
0.5939694046974182,
0.5110489130020142,
0.07750007510185242,
0.04835326597094536,
-0.7139263153076172,
0.48039209842681885,
-0.3689365088939667,
1.0001696348190308,
-0.5241590738296509,
-0.520067572593689,
0.25527724623680115,
-0.10262750089168549,
0.10863193869590759,
-0.9001397490501404,
0.44510263204574585,
-1.1951676607131958,
0.03441247716546059,
-0.4177376925945282,
-0.6007487773895264,
0.04267852008342743,
0.6084198355674744,
-0.49069464206695557,
1.1978601217269897,
0.379111111164093,
-0.8152219653129578,
0.19712872803211212,
-0.3482830226421356,
-0.3276739716529846,
0.467316597700119,
-0.08847945183515549,
-0.40014562010765076,
-0.1392366737127304,
0.2326696515083313,
0.25952157378196716,
-0.32385504245758057,
-0.2013348639011383,
-0.2941841781139374,
-0.04601915925741196,
0.31316348910331726,
0.1553822010755539,
0.3924741744995117,
0.4445483982563019,
0.2838142216205597,
-0.2524522542953491,
-0.7323533892631531,
0.23658262193202972,
0.39035823941230774,
-0.24204492568969727,
-0.4781273305416107,
-0.13568031787872314,
-0.18358375132083893,
-0.01526293158531189,
0.4942534267902374,
-0.7337639331817627,
0.022339757531881332,
-0.5534563064575195,
0.07721976935863495,
0.507384717464447,
0.5046705007553101,
0.3212316632270813,
-0.30616849660873413,
0.7013208866119385,
0.01575244776904583,
0.0780053436756134,
-0.2334744781255722,
-0.49275004863739014,
-0.5105856657028198,
0.2025974839925766,
-0.010458122938871384,
0.47707295417785645,
-1.1234989166259766,
-0.016470562666654587,
-0.4292496144771576,
-0.4827537536621094,
-0.25971144437789917,
0.16402699053287506,
0.4948746860027313,
1.0351368188858032,
0.34076544642448425,
0.1606437712907791,
-0.40747252106666565,
-0.7360481023788452,
-0.42115849256515503,
-0.3377707600593567,
0.047316040843725204,
0.7546718120574951,
-0.023043161258101463,
0.001883694319985807,
1.3251919746398926,
-1.0861704349517822,
0.012171255424618721,
-0.2049722671508789,
0.07348205894231796,
0.1221194937825203,
0.07740335166454315,
0.3557071387767792,
-0.9643955230712891,
-0.833838939666748,
0.19042779505252838,
-0.5383849143981934,
-0.15706370770931244,
0.2534806430339813,
-0.15506254136562347,
0.5477796196937561,
0.4043607711791992,
-0.28473547101020813,
0.4129555821418762,
0.13195428252220154,
-0.45601770281791687,
0.5405338406562805,
-0.03297371044754982,
0.31325870752334595,
-1.2772905826568604,
0.24944935739040375,
-0.09735414385795593,
-0.41742679476737976,
-0.7207251191139221,
-0.34912043809890747,
0.15024274587631226,
-0.6208275556564331,
-0.2624692916870117,
0.5204200744628906,
-0.2464125007390976,
-0.2738163471221924,
-0.24085403978824615,
0.32884281873703003,
0.1635400503873825,
0.3228534758090973,
-0.3370157778263092,
0.9334775805473328,
-0.031363680958747864,
-0.6980803608894348,
0.2559548318386078,
0.629540205001831,
-0.2272782176733017,
0.6004390716552734,
-0.6426898241043091,
0.5097784399986267,
-0.42063218355178833,
-0.10532848536968231,
-1.0728765726089478,
-0.174909770488739,
0.3225082755088806,
-0.5321943163871765,
0.3018675744533539,
-0.4994255602359772,
-0.523304283618927,
-0.4711013734340668,
0.2189892828464508,
0.3167492747306824,
0.4686421751976013,
-0.4427030384540558,
0.6683265566825867,
0.34117230772972107,
-0.5452843904495239,
-0.5794305205345154,
-0.3404044210910797,
0.08924258500337601,
-0.04973188042640686,
-1.0023701190948486,
0.3059552013874054,
0.047876954078674316,
-0.1047709658741951,
0.07598678767681122,
-0.4158979058265686,
-0.33267447352409363,
-0.031643446534872055,
-0.04259509965777397,
0.14583022892475128,
-0.05373352766036987,
0.3196253180503845,
0.10291460156440735,
-0.206278994679451,
-0.04969723895192146,
-0.10426787286996841,
0.7824879884719849,
0.10317189991474152,
-0.15429720282554626,
-0.07708842307329178,
0.36129820346832275,
0.43337637186050415,
-0.41401126980781555,
0.5863540172576904,
0.3905012011528015,
-0.0398702435195446,
0.032331351190805435,
-0.8938568234443665,
-0.05776286497712135,
-0.5057302713394165,
0.32731130719184875,
-0.5400485396385193,
-0.8093457818031311,
0.7019068002700806,
-0.14327989518642426,
-0.1590980440378189,
0.26945146918296814,
0.14259250462055206,
-0.2901437282562256,
0.8887892365455627,
0.21152642369270325,
0.02611369825899601,
0.5334769487380981,
-0.2018871158361435,
0.17429596185684204,
-0.8645855784416199,
-0.5954192876815796,
-0.8158350586891174,
0.10579404979944229,
-0.3485179841518402,
-0.10209867358207703,
0.7521772384643555,
0.41622498631477356,
-0.17476786673069,
0.17705799639225006,
-0.38770511746406555,
0.22124437987804413,
0.08689392358064651,
0.3458133041858673,
0.3651951253414154,
0.20760415494441986,
0.01680641993880272,
0.0524466298520565,
-0.7196534872055054,
-0.2940458357334137,
0.8294057846069336,
0.003470679046586156,
0.5361471772193909,
0.12591876089572906,
0.7910292744636536,
0.1833706945180893,
0.5222575068473816,
-0.536239504814148,
0.6119652390480042,
-0.06636099517345428,
-0.4540828466415405,
-0.30426809191703796,
-0.9012465476989746,
-1.0819913148880005,
-0.0002807450364343822,
-0.08925050497055054,
-0.6912286281585693,
0.05837605893611908,
0.24070966243743896,
-0.08712064474821091,
0.01658647693693638,
-0.7981271147727966,
0.5638013482093811,
-0.04346417635679245,
-0.20230238139629364,
-0.00258636474609375,
-0.47874024510383606,
0.13583526015281677,
-0.03576165810227394,
0.1688002496957779,
0.061994265764951706,
0.03761611133813858,
0.8282408714294434,
-0.6402730345726013,
0.3988891541957855,
-0.4126741588115692,
-0.0649755671620369,
0.47567418217658997,
0.08761103451251984,
0.9107880592346191,
-0.1217065304517746,
-0.15303760766983032,
-0.47052744030952454,
0.12783917784690857,
-0.42069849371910095,
-1.0254714488983154,
0.5057733654975891,
-0.5544269680976868,
-0.5948415398597717,
0.006388772279024124,
-0.7799704670906067,
-0.5915719866752625,
0.4295644760131836,
0.05728748440742493,
0.5752488374710083,
0.05928312987089157,
0.06737502664327621,
0.6126002073287964,
-0.320494145154953,
0.27328625321388245,
0.5640947818756104,
-0.4701753854751587,
-0.7675055861473083,
0.9556195139884949,
0.2558286786079407,
0.31364935636520386,
0.3455650210380554,
0.2473805993795395,
-0.4771279990673065,
-0.43032777309417725,
-0.23596906661987305,
0.48927977681159973,
-0.7150141596794128,
-0.36846160888671875,
-0.9593701362609863,
-0.07257775962352753,
-0.8731110692024231,
0.1641450822353363,
-0.16110415756702423,
-0.4620160460472107,
-0.1623685657978058,
0.08333701640367508,
0.5338327288627625,
0.7089424133300781,
0.39873504638671875,
0.24111142754554749,
-1.0474462509155273,
0.4267331063747406,
0.29187560081481934,
0.34107252955436707,
-0.09019029140472412,
-0.3237914741039276,
-0.317282497882843,
-0.06443575769662857,
-0.3312024176120758,
-1.0862852334976196,
0.2971844971179962,
-0.1711832731962204,
0.49632027745246887,
0.07639843225479126,
0.2818579077720642,
0.9210880398750305,
-0.41563671827316284,
0.7262207865715027,
0.26029372215270996,
-0.5402812361717224,
0.4584627151489258,
-0.41047316789627075,
0.23545555770397186,
0.5734760761260986,
0.4578952491283417,
-0.6919776797294617,
-0.35683777928352356,
-0.5697477459907532,
-1.0019932985305786,
0.6259345412254333,
0.13908419013023376,
0.07198868691921234,
-0.10978857427835464,
0.7701317667961121,
-0.32432928681373596,
0.16835333406925201,
-0.1707870215177536,
-0.5665993690490723,
-0.2388000190258026,
-0.09102454036474228,
0.055841848254203796,
-0.4993569850921631,
-0.08430986106395721,
-0.05613206699490547,
0.7388966679573059,
-0.16924820840358734,
0.08721062541007996,
0.4886298179626465,
-0.11200663447380066,
-0.08659785240888596,
0.23231427371501923,
0.3903566598892212,
0.8725736737251282,
-0.262785404920578,
-0.40103060007095337,
0.16737474501132965,
-0.39860403537750244,
-0.06753360480070114,
0.34877005219459534,
-0.25945600867271423,
0.08425808697938919,
-0.10099595040082932,
0.4300965368747711,
-0.24084047973155975,
-0.5032932758331299,
0.3163020610809326,
0.09115246683359146,
-0.17858244478702545,
-0.4743141233921051,
-0.1866549253463745,
0.08183759450912476,
0.23977085947990417,
0.9080391526222229,
-0.33551740646362305,
0.037116196006536484,
-0.3150545358657837,
0.3218458592891693,
0.475999653339386,
-0.6136360764503479,
0.23208653926849365,
0.2573818862438202,
0.05299427732825279,
-0.5514792799949646,
0.6280885934829712,
-0.18495994806289673,
-0.45617395639419556,
0.6738055944442749,
0.5715979933738708,
0.7383682131767273,
-0.03184642270207405,
0.4734792113304138,
0.2222319096326828,
0.05116719380021095,
0.462324321269989,
0.36176976561546326,
0.02522163651883602,
-0.5949451327323914,
-0.5565348863601685,
-0.5205468535423279,
-0.4423008859157562,
-0.10088249295949936,
-0.9135858416557312,
-0.02027556486427784,
-0.20592324435710907,
-0.20952047407627106,
-0.2146623283624649,
0.1600591242313385,
-0.4728645980358124,
0.2443513721227646,
-0.2090926319360733,
1.060021162033081,
-0.37315863370895386,
0.37772905826568604,
0.9257552027702332,
-0.5573460459709167,
-1.0530658960342407,
-0.017467781901359558,
-0.5196774005889893,
-0.6865243315696716,
0.987062394618988,
-0.158816397190094,
-0.058766499161720276,
0.16183744370937347,
-0.3345169425010681,
-0.7801265716552734,
1.3337699174880981,
0.14948859810829163,
-0.2608616054058075,
-0.02038118988275528,
0.32243841886520386,
0.4407722055912018,
-0.2648547887802124,
0.17828506231307983,
0.4478811025619507,
0.34227651357650757,
0.5167407393455505,
-0.4692172110080719,
0.10470258444547653,
-0.2179211676120758,
-0.026412004604935646,
0.4140530824661255,
-0.6529015898704529,
0.38999155163764954,
0.2522886097431183,
-0.20423373579978943,
0.18559350073337555,
0.7194132804870605,
0.3944375216960907,
0.5296869277954102,
0.6100494265556335,
0.5714216232299805,
1.0065425634384155,
-0.07171902805566788,
1.3100827932357788,
-0.36992359161376953,
0.2190910279750824,
1.021716833114624,
-0.27658435702323914,
0.3712828755378723,
0.6395550966262817,
0.0038265578914433718,
0.6283385753631592,
0.3364540636539459,
0.2573484182357788,
0.3222487270832062,
0.0957903191447258,
-0.09279532730579376,
-0.413766473531723,
-0.3600730299949646,
-0.40051642060279846,
0.06233556196093559,
0.1311631053686142,
-0.2268574833869934,
-0.38958048820495605,
-0.08715975284576416,
0.1324530839920044,
0.0649174153804779,
-0.39117828011512756,
1.1217867136001587,
-0.09459526091814041,
-0.7070640921592712,
0.6864869594573975,
-0.35145625472068787,
0.010715097188949585,
-0.6454455852508545,
-0.012653965502977371,
-0.5427355766296387,
-0.1045321598649025,
-0.2611970007419586,
-0.6049030423164368,
0.36837804317474365,
0.1297428160905838,
-0.26113787293434143,
-0.1800806224346161,
0.8265455961227417,
-0.3150058090686798,
-0.5445764064788818,
-0.10934682190418243,
0.4471103549003601,
0.11795488744974136,
-0.1166570782661438,
-0.5995757579803467,
-0.18449614942073822,
-0.011062303557991982,
-0.26169052720069885,
0.20418781042099,
0.4323422312736511,
0.06870321184396744,
0.8155195116996765,
0.5205173492431641,
-0.008391276933252811,
0.17337001860141754,
0.19340327382087708,
1.1480087041854858,
-0.521125316619873,
-0.4493423402309418,
-0.18833887577056885,
0.7010418176651001,
-0.49125534296035767,
-0.2839268445968628,
0.8554030060768127,
0.7240115404129028,
0.45284730195999146,
0.16015668213367462,
0.700938880443573,
0.03762848675251007,
1.0321288108825684,
-0.4615316689014435,
0.7051827311515808,
-0.7885497212409973,
0.2904832065105438,
-0.41740721464157104,
-0.6884885430335999,
-0.17209920287132263,
0.053065720945596695,
-0.6081501245498657,
-0.07545091211795807,
0.6495945453643799,
0.9160735011100769,
0.27790969610214233,
0.010817063972353935,
0.15335777401924133,
0.14917534589767456,
0.5399508476257324,
0.03004962019622326,
1.0561890602111816,
-0.4548073709011078,
1.2774815559387207,
-0.23261858522891998,
0.09198934584856033,
-0.09085721522569656,
-0.3687271177768707,
-0.652823269367218,
-0.3549778163433075,
-0.32995137572288513,
-0.8197144865989685,
0.07779098302125931,
0.5412505865097046,
0.3417518138885498,
-0.5831944942474365,
-0.0897723138332367,
-0.0065975734032690525,
0.26932448148727417,
0.02762983925640583,
-0.2861436605453491,
0.38831010460853577,
-0.9463984966278076,
-0.4483296573162079,
0.3734839856624603,
-0.02756010740995407,
-0.03717498108744621,
0.03053971938788891,
-0.10283864289522171,
-0.08392656594514847,
-0.16808103024959564,
0.472572922706604,
0.3337821364402771,
-0.20421308279037476,
-0.24130673706531525,
0.3574400544166565,
0.001164363231509924,
0.08263320475816727,
1.079533576965332,
-0.6947757601737976,
0.21309208869934082,
0.5950128436088562,
1.0573201179504395,
1.0414905548095703,
0.3110886216163635,
0.4693168103694916,
-0.9280559420585632,
-0.12491980195045471,
0.4843943417072296,
0.11893254518508911,
0.3076908588409424,
-0.5064698457717896,
0.3705972731113434,
0.2737947702407837,
-0.5760682225227356,
-0.7640469074249268,
0.6261204481124878,
-0.8323352932929993,
-0.38704153895378113,
1.07597017288208,
-0.0912487581372261,
-0.20991668105125427,
-0.47207844257354736,
-0.22417978942394257,
0.2895219624042511,
-0.3912162780761719,
0.5582981705665588,
0.30812957882881165,
-0.1759309023618698,
-0.27204713225364685,
-0.09494601935148239,
0.34195810556411743,
0.43509775400161743,
-0.8537151217460632,
0.0007097371271811426,
0.653632402420044,
0.29708367586135864,
0.4154786765575409,
0.6052907705307007,
-0.19920897483825684,
0.14201942086219788,
-0.2617308795452118,
-0.15749812126159668,
-0.3920452892780304,
-0.2354976087808609,
0.1893450915813446,
0.6267526149749756,
-0.07416797429323196,
0.04094768688082695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17662v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17662v2
|
PLAYER*: Enhancing LLM-based Multi-Agent Communication and Interaction in Murder Mystery Games
| 2024-04-26T19:07:30 | 2024-06-17T12:39:47 |
Qinglin Zhu, Runcong Zhao, Jinhua Du, Lin Gui, Yulan He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose PLAYER*, a novel framework that addresses the limitations of
existing agent-based approaches built on Large Language Models (LLMs) in
handling complex questions and understanding interpersonal relationships in
dynamic environments. PLAYER* enhances path planning in Murder Mystery Games
(MMGs) using an anytime sampling-based planner and a questioning-driven search
framework. By equipping agents with a set of sensors, PLAYER* eliminates the
need for pre-defined questions and enables agents to navigate complex social
interactions. We additionally make a contribution by introducing a quantifiable
evaluation method using multiple-choice questions and present WellPlay, a
dataset containing 1,482 question-answer pairs. Experimental results
demonstrate PLAYER*'s superiority over existing multi-agent methods, enhancing
the generalisability and adaptability of agents in MMGs and paving the way for
more effective multi-agent interactions.
|
[
-0.2994106709957123,
-0.9241635799407959,
0.8434230089187622,
0.19217431545257568,
0.18895873427391052,
0.436509907245636,
0.006721991579979658,
-0.7293468713760376,
0.4483625292778015,
0.5781168937683105,
-1.0689685344696045,
-0.44034650921821594,
-0.3018209636211395,
-0.03597863391041756,
0.05513949319720268,
0.4914892613887787,
0.2424428015947342,
0.12942688167095184,
-0.19827531278133392,
-0.22205016016960144,
-0.35609859228134155,
-0.35906025767326355,
-1.078385591506958,
-0.2743430733680725,
0.8543550372123718,
0.4456690847873688,
0.7885894775390625,
0.5885061621665955,
0.7136603593826294,
0.393449991941452,
0.16849303245544434,
0.5681078433990479,
-0.8025732040405273,
0.7388010621070862,
-0.0659971609711647,
-0.6715176701545715,
-0.6637556552886963,
0.09885086864233017,
0.17908130586147308,
0.40466010570526123,
-0.14384205639362335,
0.11472047120332718,
-0.7131710648536682,
0.22710445523262024,
-0.7575960159301758,
0.0616733655333519,
-0.23406583070755005,
0.11954699456691742,
0.02824227698147297,
-0.6574219465255737,
-0.43849247694015503,
-0.13175511360168457,
0.25714412331581116,
-0.8032568693161011,
-0.08068528026342392,
-0.2779009938240051,
0.09436009079217911,
0.1803702414035797,
-0.6511918902397156,
-0.45292147994041443,
-1.1781586408615112,
0.289523184299469,
-0.5863087177276611,
-0.2080405205488205,
0.2175883799791336,
0.8840817809104919,
-0.5563068389892578,
-0.16089215874671936,
-0.40258553624153137,
-0.2143181562423706,
0.1554776281118393,
0.31822070479393005,
0.2202368825674057,
0.41341373324394226,
0.5418762564659119,
-0.001256676041521132,
-0.3060798645019531,
-0.0872684046626091,
0.04723915457725525,
-0.1559285670518875,
1.1515456438064575,
0.5829448699951172,
0.32329627871513367,
0.29657021164894104,
-0.11232934892177582,
0.13642582297325134,
-0.6448776721954346,
0.47367963194847107,
0.7838753461837769,
0.16222794353961945,
-0.09721503406763077,
0.4500035345554352,
-0.16959083080291748,
0.46389758586883545,
0.04155953601002693,
-0.5667546391487122,
0.09248506277799606,
-0.20914091169834137,
0.21652314066886902,
-0.1169799342751503,
0.49116435647010803,
0.9000309705734253,
0.160945862531662,
-0.09826046228408813,
0.09490425139665604,
0.05448203161358833,
0.004986352287232876,
-0.6766139268875122,
-0.4073569178581238,
0.5595672726631165,
-0.22762753069400787,
-0.3878369629383087,
0.04382218420505524,
-0.7321853637695312,
-0.8448588252067566,
0.3716278374195099,
0.47874635457992554,
-0.19126982986927032,
-0.4956797957420349,
0.18427474796772003,
-0.5633312463760376,
0.48334866762161255,
0.6940080523490906,
-0.6464341282844543,
0.23391030728816986,
0.17141059041023254,
0.4259880483150482,
-0.06579244136810303,
-0.4439144730567932,
-0.8599129915237427,
0.8325508832931519,
-0.2586400508880615,
0.8849902749061584,
-0.5796353816986084,
-0.584132730960846,
-0.030034147202968597,
0.044065069407224655,
0.45594751834869385,
-0.40868207812309265,
0.2304137498140335,
-0.438701868057251,
0.1503903865814209,
-0.6815434694290161,
-0.3097383379936218,
0.013858901336789131,
0.7980554103851318,
-0.5162578821182251,
0.8552116751670837,
-0.21576817333698273,
-0.19040042161941528,
0.5404241681098938,
-0.9302079081535339,
-0.4188566207885742,
0.42994606494903564,
-0.07349877059459686,
0.02683238498866558,
-0.11463876068592072,
0.24492685496807098,
0.30998295545578003,
-0.008712376467883587,
-0.18779347836971283,
-0.41450485587120056,
-0.597507655620575,
0.24808256328105927,
-0.1718757301568985,
0.3751274645328522,
-0.032475974410772324,
-0.21865159273147583,
0.29154694080352783,
-0.6748924851417542,
-0.15764306485652924,
0.24948295950889587,
-0.4748169481754303,
-0.10752154141664505,
0.6644875407218933,
-0.34484004974365234,
0.07579559087753296,
0.06413287669420242,
-0.4975859224796295,
0.3908138573169708,
-0.20193421840667725,
-0.0034810544457286596,
0.5817644000053406,
0.2824519872665405,
0.6870695948600769,
-0.7721350789070129,
0.9389574527740479,
-0.20899923145771027,
0.40739116072654724,
-0.6211380362510681,
-0.4917232096195221,
-0.42845526337623596,
-0.4111250936985016,
-0.22552254796028137,
0.8412004113197327,
-1.0403118133544922,
0.07879124581813812,
0.21206876635551453,
-0.5289640426635742,
-0.4031094014644623,
-0.5836141705513,
0.20573170483112335,
0.01885991543531418,
0.2241957187652588,
-0.24626901745796204,
-0.4157713055610657,
-0.340241402387619,
-0.22824539244174957,
-0.46508580446243286,
0.12494395673274994,
0.8562437295913696,
0.012143072672188282,
-0.2029794603586197,
0.8395630717277527,
-0.5012863278388977,
-0.27164292335510254,
-0.39703288674354553,
-0.00821471493691206,
-0.07326389849185944,
0.28735190629959106,
0.5060300230979919,
-0.7490693926811218,
-0.4692234396934509,
-0.4597543776035309,
-0.6631066203117371,
-0.16170915961265564,
-0.42916181683540344,
0.06332345306873322,
-0.10663735121488571,
0.5226989388465881,
-0.695381760597229,
0.5979669094085693,
0.28388237953186035,
-0.5318127870559692,
0.6172906756401062,
-0.30953606963157654,
0.6535711288452148,
-0.860318660736084,
-0.38102102279663086,
-0.34087827801704407,
-0.5389488935470581,
-0.9355437755584717,
0.6830855011940002,
-0.5159482359886169,
0.30331864953041077,
-0.5699693560600281,
0.46919089555740356,
-0.8527402281761169,
-0.2913050055503845,
-0.3100067973136902,
0.3415691554546356,
-0.4253714978694916,
0.21384930610656738,
-0.29969799518585205,
0.7187651991844177,
0.6063796877861023,
-0.5106649398803711,
0.9221412539482117,
0.33630886673927307,
-0.06568590551614761,
0.731015682220459,
-0.4055251181125641,
0.1984323263168335,
-0.2854103147983551,
0.2655005156993866,
-1.0740883350372314,
-0.1609458029270172,
0.3761610686779022,
-0.6733556985855103,
0.19687305390834808,
-0.39841127395629883,
-0.6849567294120789,
-0.23781666159629822,
-0.32342439889907837,
0.47172337770462036,
0.20787324011325836,
-0.0669533982872963,
0.997093141078949,
0.6449649333953857,
0.36890965700149536,
-0.3170086145401001,
-0.6519076228141785,
0.29057860374450684,
-0.31653913855552673,
-0.7950108051300049,
-0.06284334510564804,
-0.697091281414032,
-0.4808124303817749,
-0.3343738913536072,
0.03554988652467728,
-0.026162689551711082,
0.3207372725009918,
0.13696235418319702,
-0.08673480898141861,
-0.14506733417510986,
0.17982171475887299,
-0.1023811399936676,
-0.10482676327228546,
0.21314825117588043,
0.261630654335022,
0.6745132207870483,
0.28442898392677307,
-0.4179362654685974,
0.08198633044958115,
0.810758650302887,
0.41420885920524597,
-0.38043293356895447,
0.4492424726486206,
0.3701847791671753,
-0.10058535635471344,
-0.2858797013759613,
-0.5110795497894287,
-0.4321976900100708,
-0.5565016269683838,
0.15986119210720062,
-0.785193145275116,
-1.2347019910812378,
1.1060786247253418,
-0.5404407382011414,
-0.2245485782623291,
-0.06384196132421494,
0.5131994485855103,
-0.3323494791984558,
1.1103770732879639,
0.495133638381958,
0.21371738612651825,
0.1259232461452484,
0.007486777845770121,
0.04844653606414795,
-0.5564802289009094,
-0.4589526951313019,
-0.07760070264339447,
-0.5849308967590332,
-0.6547675132751465,
-0.5552939772605896,
0.5371236205101013,
-0.24038651585578918,
-0.008712632581591606,
0.24355992674827576,
-0.29856929183006287,
0.9535912275314331,
0.42571625113487244,
0.1658216118812561,
0.38456296920776367,
-0.6502951979637146,
-0.022613564506173134,
0.17172983288764954,
-0.5277339816093445,
-0.23886390030384064,
0.9339370131492615,
0.20709671080112457,
0.5980328917503357,
0.95566725730896,
0.8869150876998901,
0.3579935133457184,
-0.18313594162464142,
-0.7024465203285217,
0.729652464389801,
0.529589056968689,
-1.1492433547973633,
-0.8575971722602844,
-0.4471786916255951,
-0.9253833889961243,
0.26171615719795227,
-0.6006149649620056,
-1.0185803174972534,
0.09533636271953583,
-0.28417903184890747,
-0.8166883587837219,
0.21813301742076874,
-0.5498378872871399,
0.5787954330444336,
-0.05481448397040367,
-0.2716656029224396,
0.04468996450304985,
-0.6800913214683533,
0.2893652617931366,
0.28214359283447266,
0.09129327535629272,
-0.46891793608665466,
-0.18944424390792847,
0.2966364324092865,
-0.23475432395935059,
0.43691086769104004,
-0.3528788685798645,
0.0581023246049881,
0.3693617582321167,
0.695100724697113,
0.6611742973327637,
0.3429931402206421,
0.06671232730150223,
-0.43589675426483154,
0.33164334297180176,
-0.4571596384048462,
-0.5616158246994019,
0.45957621932029724,
-0.551662266254425,
-0.74738609790802,
-0.6632806658744812,
-1.134927749633789,
-0.3176303505897522,
0.0984853208065033,
-0.07172176241874695,
0.37964287400245667,
-0.5581801533699036,
-0.2624026834964752,
0.8369629979133606,
-0.3457833528518677,
0.7245761752128601,
0.9609869718551636,
-0.17183810472488403,
0.060076676309108734,
0.5158443450927734,
-0.18353810906410217,
0.34355872869491577,
0.3922746777534485,
0.10011711716651917,
0.1288703829050064,
-0.4916694760322571,
-0.3253202438354492,
0.15763431787490845,
-0.479588121175766,
0.001442205742932856,
-0.8685629963874817,
-0.013169984333217144,
-0.1442323476076126,
-0.1781553030014038,
-0.03300316631793976,
-0.07699240744113922,
-0.23350122570991516,
-0.33835405111312866,
0.2491096407175064,
0.6452270746231079,
-0.3642907440662384,
0.8946322798728943,
-0.6107665300369263,
0.37521809339523315,
0.4044819176197052,
0.19189195334911346,
-0.3479993939399719,
0.0057515110820531845,
0.019610228016972542,
-0.009298980236053467,
-0.015445391647517681,
-1.4969003200531006,
0.11288002878427505,
-0.06949212402105331,
0.6546333432197571,
0.49578383564949036,
0.09013967961072922,
0.6332791447639465,
-0.6762063503265381,
0.8002861142158508,
-0.052726149559020996,
-0.7598616480827332,
0.37205982208251953,
-1.1580026149749756,
0.46195903420448303,
0.6870093941688538,
0.17975005507469177,
-0.5987808704376221,
-0.45818936824798584,
-0.4757770299911499,
-0.5589625239372253,
0.9928664565086365,
0.12690192461013794,
0.1484604775905609,
0.05780315399169922,
0.531682014465332,
-0.09477152675390244,
0.4065288305282593,
-0.6099284887313843,
-0.5756751298904419,
0.6301445364952087,
0.21804454922676086,
-0.35269036889076233,
-0.5473932027816772,
-0.25679925084114075,
-0.029344692826271057,
0.17172425985336304,
-0.18638736009597778,
0.5867310762405396,
0.19138486683368683,
0.14837321639060974,
-0.49799084663391113,
-0.14477816224098206,
0.6724755764007568,
0.7592413425445557,
-0.6089922785758972,
0.18110346794128418,
0.22596414387226105,
-0.23461629450321198,
0.41945749521255493,
0.015878448262810707,
-0.13724775612354279,
-0.4551379680633545,
0.5826212763786316,
0.09851173311471939,
-0.15590070188045502,
-0.5777663588523865,
0.7341632843017578,
-0.33317485451698303,
-0.2490256130695343,
-0.38287338614463806,
0.500765323638916,
0.178870290517807,
0.8756089806556702,
0.3490559458732605,
-0.043293628841638565,
0.5493478775024414,
-1.145823359489441,
0.35040077567100525,
0.45000192523002625,
-0.5336490273475647,
-0.12511762976646423,
0.44916918873786926,
0.11503732949495316,
-0.6482717394828796,
-0.11660625785589218,
-0.6535472869873047,
-0.4753256142139435,
0.6961678266525269,
0.3989262878894806,
0.6381275653839111,
-0.7673959732055664,
0.8292005062103271,
-0.08173981308937073,
0.7524377703666687,
-0.0979442298412323,
0.9130538702011108,
0.04980700835585594,
-0.8466160297393799,
-0.5308666229248047,
0.2039833515882492,
-0.5039229393005371,
-0.09193456172943115,
-0.12619492411613464,
0.006644518580287695,
-0.4200126826763153,
-0.10904467105865479,
-0.2498830407857895,
0.2856336534023285,
-0.37713557481765747,
-0.116294264793396,
0.009159199893474579,
0.8387617468833923,
-0.5844604969024658,
0.5198392271995544,
0.6091184020042419,
-0.4680335819721222,
-0.6743282079696655,
0.02563045173883438,
0.1364477276802063,
-0.5798254609107971,
0.06600644439458847,
0.052595216780900955,
-0.06259259581565857,
-0.060882121324539185,
-0.7693199515342712,
-0.7363409399986267,
1.3602149486541748,
0.09948078542947769,
-0.17259632050991058,
-0.09256906062364578,
0.3661332130432129,
0.6115850806236267,
-0.6475514769554138,
0.8206035494804382,
0.5280259251594543,
0.5639806985855103,
0.6286652088165283,
-0.6395502686500549,
0.10911915451288223,
-0.04051866754889488,
-0.5740764737129211,
0.44589731097221375,
-0.7632508873939514,
0.5031651258468628,
-0.4507943391799927,
-0.18072058260440826,
0.19429633021354675,
0.4385419189929962,
0.3160135746002197,
0.8594273328781128,
0.584758460521698,
0.32005971670150757,
0.8287227749824524,
-0.23623602092266083,
0.6183193325996399,
0.20801083743572235,
-0.21780502796173096,
1.315860629081726,
-0.5565086007118225,
0.2354591190814972,
0.1375076174736023,
0.022057820111513138,
0.2646803557872772,
0.54324871301651,
0.10516788065433502,
0.616022527217865,
0.5956918597221375,
-0.3693750202655792,
-0.6455211043357849,
-0.04549600929021835,
-0.060250330716371536,
0.6919357776641846,
0.13833273947238922,
0.25929251313209534,
-0.277476966381073,
-0.15116631984710693,
-0.05785742029547691,
0.076296366751194,
-0.07193861901760101,
0.9413021206855774,
-0.2427687793970108,
-0.391447514295578,
-0.4619430899620056,
0.14575164020061493,
0.5008035898208618,
-0.7544198632240295,
-0.1806798279285431,
-0.29665231704711914,
0.07344986498355865,
-0.004741302691400051,
-0.5643502473831177,
-0.007179501466453075,
-0.5157925486564636,
-0.16419890522956848,
0.1971358358860016,
0.7341488003730774,
-0.649894654750824,
-0.12121208012104034,
0.5712522268295288,
0.9230023622512817,
0.2587602436542511,
-0.3094075620174408,
-0.6521486043930054,
0.1172601655125618,
-0.2400125414133072,
0.03913182392716408,
0.10075986385345459,
0.6343926191329956,
0.1692722588777542,
0.8947746157646179,
0.6595998406410217,
0.1348963975906372,
0.12792664766311646,
-0.19868120551109314,
0.8046708703041077,
-0.5746577382087708,
-0.5766921639442444,
-0.7458478212356567,
0.7682471871376038,
-0.2030620127916336,
-0.11099569499492645,
0.840871274471283,
0.49235329031944275,
0.5261361598968506,
0.27726152539253235,
0.3519308567047119,
0.3164231479167938,
0.4560096561908722,
-0.1998896598815918,
0.5748701095581055,
-0.3060859143733978,
0.47403714060783386,
-0.3497686982154846,
-1.0386713743209839,
-0.27001720666885376,
0.4132791757583618,
-0.18014191091060638,
0.0926348865032196,
0.3348487317562103,
0.7215142250061035,
-0.00898976530879736,
-0.19072642922401428,
0.7643659710884094,
-0.0652451440691948,
0.7581630945205688,
0.9683082699775696,
1.3240331411361694,
-0.3891664743423462,
0.17295928299427032,
0.21604590117931366,
-0.7015790343284607,
-0.1917724758386612,
-0.8362443447113037,
-1.4518959522247314,
-0.3933277726173401,
-0.14055585861206055,
-0.15130308270454407,
0.23177075386047363,
0.8515461087226868,
0.7401020526885986,
-0.2516016960144043,
-0.5224390029907227,
0.4462054967880249,
0.06299429386854172,
-0.08292975276708603,
-0.1564439833164215,
-0.177574023604393,
0.11680223792791367,
-0.3093554377555847,
0.9282757639884949,
0.41621559858322144,
0.038607191294431686,
-0.5132766962051392,
-0.3658418655395508,
-0.6191706657409668,
0.6470901966094971,
0.601477324962616,
0.1098601222038269,
-0.2874899208545685,
-0.29171842336654663,
0.3430896997451782,
0.08884595334529877,
-0.15371303260326385,
0.8397600650787354,
-0.598426342010498,
0.7180469632148743,
0.39332252740859985,
0.32258525490760803,
0.6928487420082092,
-0.07711603492498398,
0.6914913058280945,
-0.5809783935546875,
0.2178388386964798,
0.370120108127594,
-0.0646534338593483,
0.07792681455612183,
-0.8190174102783203,
0.5689979195594788,
0.12248530238866806,
-0.6481213569641113,
-0.593451738357544,
0.8115565776824951,
-0.9683480262756348,
-0.30377641320228577,
1.2868351936340332,
-0.11101279407739639,
-0.04305489733815193,
-0.15537230670452118,
-0.2646123766899109,
-0.00010678661055862904,
-0.6557794213294983,
0.41971921920776367,
0.790337085723877,
-0.011274616234004498,
-0.5032304525375366,
-0.4707978367805481,
0.7449676990509033,
-0.1803773045539856,
-0.8416809439659119,
-0.3815061151981354,
0.7958182692527771,
-0.24895569682121277,
0.15413737297058105,
1.039749026298523,
0.09961114078760147,
0.3794833719730377,
-0.17098020017147064,
0.0674167051911354,
-0.3911421000957489,
-0.5743119120597839,
0.05057934671640396,
0.2727721929550171,
-0.11409574747085571,
-0.008718116208910942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17642v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17642v1
|
Empowering Large Language Models for Textual Data Augmentation
| 2024-04-26T18:04:25 | 2024-04-26T18:04:25 |
Yichuan Li, Kaize Ding, Jianling Wang, Kyumin Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the capabilities of understanding and executing natural language
instructions, Large language models (LLMs) can potentially act as a powerful
tool for textual data augmentation. However, the quality of augmented data
depends heavily on the augmentation instructions provided, and the
effectiveness can fluctuate across different downstream tasks. While manually
crafting and selecting instructions can offer some improvement, this approach
faces scalability and consistency issues in practice due to the diversity of
downstream tasks. In this work, we address these limitations by proposing a new
solution, which can automatically generate a large pool of augmentation
instructions and select the most suitable task-informed instructions, thereby
empowering LLMs to create high-quality augmented data for different downstream
tasks. Empirically, the proposed approach consistently generates augmented data
with better quality compared to non-LLM and LLM-based data augmentation
methods, leading to the best performance on 26 few-shot learning tasks sourced
from a wide range of application domains.
|
[
-0.1862877458333969,
-0.7829881906509399,
0.6678563952445984,
0.298638254404068,
-0.2376851588487625,
0.13076584041118622,
-0.4838927686214447,
-0.6139194369316101,
0.18282288312911987,
0.7765599489212036,
-0.6222106218338013,
-0.5502376556396484,
-0.6472979187965393,
0.23324701189994812,
-0.3349403142929077,
0.7898769974708557,
-0.10496306419372559,
-0.2003684937953949,
-0.34965237975120544,
0.11822101473808289,
-0.6910776495933533,
-0.3209930956363678,
-0.41376131772994995,
-0.4045170247554779,
0.3548751175403595,
0.6514840722084045,
0.8136629462242126,
1.0012896060943604,
0.5075921416282654,
0.31296586990356445,
0.23503386974334717,
0.947015106678009,
-0.48487916588783264,
0.38014811277389526,
-0.2710018754005432,
-0.33324694633483887,
-0.5480165481567383,
-0.20006486773490906,
0.600167989730835,
0.6869999766349792,
0.15075859427452087,
0.12357023358345032,
0.27170971035957336,
0.6222296357154846,
-0.5519390106201172,
0.18955236673355103,
-0.635364294052124,
-0.26501673460006714,
-0.11459124088287354,
-0.2842167615890503,
-0.4713655710220337,
-0.2648000717163086,
0.1276107281446457,
-0.7050004601478577,
-0.029933739453554153,
-0.018746651709079742,
0.6600247025489807,
0.27481114864349365,
-0.2418794184923172,
-0.31316232681274414,
-0.726699948310852,
0.8314913511276245,
-0.8312203288078308,
0.23474183678627014,
0.4689089059829712,
0.05466501787304878,
-0.149246484041214,
-0.6386208534240723,
-0.4428406357765198,
-0.17153668403625488,
-0.2291094958782196,
-0.15837205946445465,
0.20564918220043182,
0.0427231639623642,
0.23780909180641174,
0.335537314414978,
-0.4990254044532776,
0.42187952995300293,
0.0010818428127095103,
-0.10973446071147919,
0.7916905879974365,
0.4418320953845978,
0.3807256519794464,
-0.16060352325439453,
-0.19477732479572296,
0.03790423274040222,
-0.7181614637374878,
-0.24709366261959076,
0.4699373245239258,
0.6111857295036316,
-0.040768787264823914,
0.9851524233818054,
-0.44787439703941345,
0.9386295676231384,
0.17438004910945892,
-0.15583258867263794,
0.3139156699180603,
-0.41088348627090454,
-0.2135549783706665,
0.1267566829919815,
0.6898664832115173,
0.09392529726028442,
-0.14324909448623657,
-0.2427903115749359,
-0.45381200313568115,
-0.359481543302536,
0.35860544443130493,
-0.7703908681869507,
-0.00589281041175127,
0.4387551546096802,
-0.16925935447216034,
-0.15376779437065125,
-0.010339081287384033,
-0.478806734085083,
-0.4420270025730133,
-0.8302913904190063,
0.4658929109573364,
-0.5422314405441284,
0.0393252931535244,
0.010491030290722847,
0.20714907348155975,
0.028568441048264503,
0.3657442331314087,
-1.1911369562149048,
0.016892842948436737,
0.9333494901657104,
0.7440062165260315,
-0.31725630164146423,
-0.24687057733535767,
-0.8311598300933838,
0.47166648507118225,
-0.41526004672050476,
0.7127030491828918,
-0.8383433222770691,
-0.2216145098209381,
-0.04084852710366249,
-0.02904786355793476,
0.20582956075668335,
-0.4062412679195404,
0.46750837564468384,
-0.493804007768631,
0.12825067341327667,
-0.14476673305034637,
-0.8623036742210388,
0.016267305240035057,
0.26869702339172363,
-0.7942492365837097,
1.1800835132598877,
0.16489192843437195,
-0.5266892910003662,
0.40158334374427795,
-0.5173712372779846,
-0.4707910418510437,
0.36190029978752136,
-0.19732114672660828,
-0.47790223360061646,
-0.013727687299251556,
0.5848577618598938,
0.7541719079017639,
-0.2306288331747055,
0.10785806179046631,
-0.21050360798835754,
-0.36814168095588684,
-0.009763967245817184,
-0.4240224063396454,
0.46934232115745544,
-0.08033816516399384,
-0.1375073790550232,
0.10644358396530151,
-0.7661123275756836,
0.0011346201645210385,
-0.14793528616428375,
-0.610613226890564,
-0.3235548138618469,
-0.13903671503067017,
0.08843694627285004,
-0.0588407926261425,
0.46667903661727905,
-0.5816207528114319,
0.45108655095100403,
-0.6143075227737427,
0.15571871399879456,
0.7215406894683838,
0.018251800909638405,
0.6258401870727539,
-0.3132690489292145,
0.2610066831111908,
-0.20395790040493011,
-0.1438916176557541,
-0.5213285684585571,
-0.2716902494430542,
-0.49068862199783325,
-0.6459224224090576,
0.3120305836200714,
0.6086186170578003,
-0.9655349850654602,
0.6868762969970703,
-0.624376654624939,
-0.48200616240501404,
-0.4910103976726532,
0.5688461065292358,
0.1751154363155365,
0.40102115273475647,
0.3612920343875885,
0.12005729973316193,
-0.7379783391952515,
-0.720996081829071,
-0.12094572186470032,
0.07005388289690018,
-0.17430920898914337,
0.20214097201824188,
0.1700001060962677,
-0.3803483843803406,
1.0125640630722046,
-0.38209936022758484,
-0.2773747146129608,
-0.3419615924358368,
0.2826252579689026,
0.2571457028388977,
0.5179416537284851,
0.17489762604236603,
-0.5761619806289673,
-0.4270319640636444,
0.4219428598880768,
-0.8257764577865601,
-0.2708507478237152,
-0.4605429172515869,
-0.2851546108722687,
0.1633504182100296,
0.3576418459415436,
-0.5900810956954956,
0.17763662338256836,
0.4639834761619568,
0.09686773270368576,
0.3657911419868469,
-0.3275846540927887,
0.34990495443344116,
-1.1934876441955566,
-0.18158553540706635,
0.03703336790204048,
-0.42717692255973816,
-0.5766649842262268,
0.0388801209628582,
0.22555145621299744,
0.014976783655583858,
-0.33051738142967224,
0.4621085226535797,
-0.6237685680389404,
0.04650440439581871,
-0.43255117535591125,
-0.08520792424678802,
0.18045680224895477,
0.28482484817504883,
0.1557929515838623,
0.7300757169723511,
0.5494148135185242,
-0.5942078828811646,
0.6233532428741455,
0.40592238306999207,
-0.28625962138175964,
0.3976539969444275,
-0.5600975155830383,
0.07538861036300659,
-0.27846142649650574,
0.16776907444000244,
-0.7876104116439819,
-0.6338004469871521,
-0.08397269248962402,
-0.3354423940181732,
0.4869508743286133,
-0.18593132495880127,
-0.7346762418746948,
-0.05096646398305893,
-0.21110688149929047,
0.12135638296604156,
0.40822529792785645,
-0.8188337683677673,
0.7769027948379517,
0.29302704334259033,
-0.2856521010398865,
-0.6276466250419617,
-0.775364100933075,
0.3080918788909912,
-0.04518299177289009,
-0.6384083032608032,
0.523650586605072,
0.1880580335855484,
0.012377199716866016,
-0.02600930817425251,
0.08993598073720932,
-0.014983697794377804,
-0.24145056307315826,
0.2766578495502472,
0.5060189962387085,
-0.056457072496414185,
0.36417973041534424,
0.3122047185897827,
-0.12390803545713425,
-0.25664380192756653,
-0.4059598743915558,
0.3231361508369446,
0.4736654460430145,
-0.5849701166152954,
-0.45416519045829773,
0.4310968816280365,
0.4412090480327606,
-0.20413485169410706,
0.8121568560600281,
0.5644710659980774,
-0.3973511755466461,
-0.37586796283721924,
-0.6684570908546448,
-0.1504652053117752,
-0.4868567883968353,
0.26623982191085815,
-0.2749549150466919,
-0.9318283200263977,
0.20708927512168884,
-0.0781925767660141,
0.4930867850780487,
0.29752737283706665,
0.6266502141952515,
-0.10813920944929123,
1.0437992811203003,
0.45996418595314026,
-0.08940449357032776,
0.4827038049697876,
-0.19500423967838287,
0.12331181764602661,
-0.7677159905433655,
-0.0486588329076767,
-0.2916705906391144,
-0.2571156919002533,
-0.5189086198806763,
-0.569027304649353,
0.4245341122150421,
-0.2006382793188095,
-0.06838249415159225,
0.3370221257209778,
-0.5389356017112732,
0.5790982842445374,
0.31382134556770325,
0.4291926920413971,
0.3945128619670868,
0.2871525287628174,
0.18993251025676727,
-0.0077552637085318565,
-0.5686368942260742,
-0.7701173424720764,
1.2122888565063477,
0.319247305393219,
0.8576991558074951,
0.013779082335531712,
0.8049488663673401,
0.4060685336589813,
0.2152668833732605,
-0.6173095107078552,
0.4102751314640045,
-0.3184131383895874,
-0.3843967616558075,
-0.4611486792564392,
-0.4561232030391693,
-0.8769081234931946,
0.07567406445741653,
-0.5725340247154236,
-0.5251707434654236,
-0.006010713055729866,
0.21026740968227386,
-0.30932915210723877,
0.21111978590488434,
-0.799173891544342,
0.463566392660141,
-0.10075434297323227,
-0.7062384486198425,
0.02342676930129528,
-0.4075435996055603,
0.4307499825954437,
-0.30126625299453735,
0.08637359738349915,
-0.01653233729302883,
-0.3952203392982483,
0.3594353497028351,
-0.6710988283157349,
0.842316746711731,
0.024322055280208588,
-0.3260122537612915,
0.40677300095558167,
-0.21539372205734253,
1.006732702255249,
0.056084051728248596,
-0.31512072682380676,
-0.09546579420566559,
-0.39687806367874146,
-0.4740274250507355,
-0.7538682818412781,
0.947624146938324,
-0.5483037829399109,
-0.4813612699508667,
-0.025181321427226067,
-0.7897962927818298,
-0.3719502389431,
-0.05372953042387962,
0.04789331927895546,
0.661483108997345,
0.0997067466378212,
0.21048150956630707,
0.7042995095252991,
-0.30075132846832275,
0.5203277468681335,
0.2873557507991791,
-0.04891038313508034,
-0.4034787714481354,
1.0649968385696411,
0.16360576450824738,
0.37157905101776123,
0.5977931022644043,
-0.09420213103294373,
-0.40890631079673767,
-0.7597504258155823,
-0.8086739182472229,
0.09579992294311523,
-0.5147480964660645,
-0.2663719356060028,
-0.6916673183441162,
-0.15872807800769806,
-0.36546552181243896,
-0.1834142804145813,
-0.3058268129825592,
-0.36485180258750916,
-0.38631993532180786,
-0.20474940538406372,
0.6794297695159912,
0.5886268615722656,
0.03129591420292854,
0.3384600281715393,
-1.236336588859558,
0.47316810488700867,
0.4609636068344116,
0.3342799246311188,
-0.062129292637109756,
-0.4241740107536316,
-0.4948292374610901,
0.3053617775440216,
-0.03741121292114258,
-0.65297931432724,
0.4755696952342987,
0.16773417592048645,
0.5088074207305908,
0.013844243250787258,
-0.10554951429367065,
0.8075379133224487,
-0.602607250213623,
0.7404248714447021,
0.09918731451034546,
-0.8067997097969055,
0.5080474615097046,
-0.46443095803260803,
0.4149298667907715,
0.5071188807487488,
0.20676741003990173,
-0.05788062885403633,
-0.49251285195350647,
-0.3260892331600189,
-1.0190894603729248,
0.6524524092674255,
0.2689623534679413,
0.44099923968315125,
0.06863638758659363,
0.33843502402305603,
0.4944501519203186,
0.05484583228826523,
-0.353170245885849,
-0.02946372516453266,
0.12224240601062775,
-0.514758825302124,
0.11316486448049545,
-0.05730976164340973,
0.17003130912780762,
-0.05095816031098366,
0.7513694167137146,
-0.2010701447725296,
-0.08674532175064087,
0.07054170221090317,
-0.2656019330024719,
-0.1473531424999237,
0.2750548720359802,
0.2166242152452469,
0.7502548098564148,
0.08826535195112228,
0.04009813070297241,
0.25411781668663025,
-0.6315831542015076,
0.1267051249742508,
0.15528196096420288,
-0.1806492954492569,
0.03830869868397713,
0.6196590662002563,
0.8759015202522278,
-0.023253059014678,
-0.9232709407806396,
0.2255256474018097,
0.2437070608139038,
-0.07679233700037003,
0.05499173700809479,
0.18468579649925232,
0.018881775438785553,
0.17477865517139435,
0.581683874130249,
-0.07202768325805664,
0.03955784812569618,
-0.379776269197464,
0.3019897937774658,
0.48589590191841125,
-0.019116636365652084,
0.06115736439824104,
0.3580748736858368,
0.30598580837249756,
-0.16471409797668457,
0.4853890836238861,
-0.12718960642814636,
-0.2155047208070755,
0.23859700560569763,
0.2850582003593445,
0.5797563195228577,
-0.1287267655134201,
0.15617677569389343,
0.406442791223526,
0.311214804649353,
-0.18895599246025085,
0.31358811259269714,
0.12813729047775269,
-0.5226140022277832,
-1.0774933099746704,
-0.6180739402770996,
-0.41819068789482117,
0.010443738661706448,
-0.3793337643146515,
0.3285720944404602,
-0.23014529049396515,
-0.029839487746357918,
-0.06286965310573578,
-0.14621271193027496,
-0.5738128423690796,
0.2982746958732605,
0.2281532883644104,
0.6315203309059143,
-0.7162477970123291,
0.7536327838897705,
0.49969080090522766,
-0.3600805997848511,
-0.8829531073570251,
-0.18863427639007568,
-0.19727924466133118,
-0.6545299887657166,
0.49803659319877625,
0.0026831114664673805,
0.054275088012218475,
0.04215496405959129,
-0.5214329361915588,
-0.7179036736488342,
1.0116007328033447,
0.49862194061279297,
-0.6620070338249207,
-0.012557956390082836,
0.5407733917236328,
0.457572340965271,
-0.537002682685852,
0.3100169897079468,
0.5704731345176697,
0.47477051615715027,
0.3194524347782135,
-0.8169934749603271,
0.007833505980670452,
-0.12197617441415787,
0.08275554329156876,
0.2812153697013855,
-0.1166801005601883,
0.43801504373550415,
-0.15188317000865936,
-0.1621173471212387,
-0.09442372620105743,
0.8133782744407654,
0.3529870808124542,
0.07216083258390427,
0.35647982358932495,
0.636817455291748,
0.6676367521286011,
0.03506207838654518,
1.1771225929260254,
-0.15186651051044464,
0.01943022385239601,
1.2450491189956665,
-0.26123759150505066,
0.9289063215255737,
0.343347430229187,
-0.10683006793260574,
0.3401159644126892,
0.6235052943229675,
0.077894426882267,
0.21210956573486328,
-0.0812143012881279,
-0.39159971475601196,
-0.3484020233154297,
-0.26464569568634033,
-0.06378217786550522,
0.3960905075073242,
0.4204770028591156,
-0.44603922963142395,
-0.12486349791288376,
0.06924387067556381,
-0.20512428879737854,
0.18821917474269867,
-0.5062023401260376,
0.9261372685432434,
-0.2601456642150879,
-0.6088969111442566,
0.5708684921264648,
0.007206766400486231,
0.6859800815582275,
-0.5006880164146423,
-0.2802453935146332,
0.06490408629179001,
-0.21199625730514526,
-0.6018410921096802,
-0.9433565735816956,
0.33911290764808655,
0.2907940149307251,
-0.2927307188510895,
-0.35105249285697937,
0.7366787791252136,
-0.7389558553695679,
-0.6577131152153015,
-0.18452361226081848,
0.5461817383766174,
-0.08742085099220276,
0.012869794853031635,
-0.33607953786849976,
0.2530338168144226,
-0.07409927994012833,
-0.24978385865688324,
0.3576023578643799,
0.5096912980079651,
0.04979132115840912,
0.7126201391220093,
0.8531721234321594,
0.3332204222679138,
0.22392019629478455,
0.09770567715167999,
0.9028632044792175,
-0.2670827805995941,
-0.431691974401474,
-0.8919172286987305,
0.8513080477714539,
-0.3953567445278168,
0.11922603845596313,
0.7959186434745789,
0.6654039025306702,
0.6237501502037048,
-0.06694380939006805,
0.958116888999939,
0.07063037157058716,
0.5844754576683044,
-0.717822253704071,
0.36480483412742615,
-0.31801891326904297,
0.5510658621788025,
-0.08113754540681839,
-1.0829628705978394,
-0.2656317949295044,
0.2881704866886139,
-0.4109947979450226,
-0.07239484786987305,
0.44881734251976013,
0.9184634685516357,
-0.2650017738342285,
0.06026756763458252,
0.2630859911441803,
-0.08559087663888931,
0.2461422085762024,
0.45044565200805664,
0.6303025484085083,
-0.3469356596469879,
0.45710912346839905,
-0.08361200988292694,
-0.09061197191476822,
-0.034160006791353226,
-0.8776497840881348,
-0.8060961365699768,
-0.5116834044456482,
-0.3892679214477539,
-0.03694084659218788,
-0.06000352278351784,
1.3431425094604492,
0.8106632232666016,
-0.5940607190132141,
-0.04223136231303215,
-0.13422857224941254,
0.06364608556032181,
-0.23531648516654968,
-0.2148430347442627,
0.32913514971733093,
-0.6592122316360474,
-1.05949866771698,
0.463020920753479,
0.4907883405685425,
0.003097751410678029,
-0.20928791165351868,
-0.15648691356182098,
-0.1706162393093109,
0.1719677895307541,
0.7362464070320129,
-0.03332201763987541,
-0.5874174237251282,
-0.26075276732444763,
-0.1499379724264145,
-0.2861005365848541,
-0.012332405894994736,
0.7593355178833008,
-0.7149596810340881,
0.5859909057617188,
0.7110695242881775,
1.3144394159317017,
0.3907769024372101,
0.1341896951198578,
0.7188026309013367,
-1.0571861267089844,
-0.08765245229005814,
0.18559056520462036,
0.20290382206439972,
0.5865606069564819,
-0.6210829615592957,
0.37760254740715027,
-0.254758358001709,
-0.4327963888645172,
-0.702151358127594,
0.08501821011304855,
-0.9804555177688599,
-0.1383291333913803,
1.2320460081100464,
-0.1580052375793457,
-0.19855117797851562,
-0.03955502063035965,
-0.4073013365268707,
0.18045610189437866,
-0.33758100867271423,
0.519981324672699,
0.5591748952865601,
-0.19245140254497528,
-0.2771685719490051,
-0.46055883169174194,
0.3325888514518738,
0.128485307097435,
-1.1694612503051758,
0.36342689394950867,
0.7316621541976929,
0.008113094605505466,
-0.09994268417358398,
0.20565225183963776,
0.014277325011789799,
0.1037830039858818,
-0.2793661653995514,
-0.10290826112031937,
-0.3307003378868103,
-0.13258777558803558,
-0.14200791716575623,
0.2857198417186737,
-0.008715610951185226,
-0.11813914030790329
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01582v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01582v3
|
Text Quality-Based Pruning for Efficient Training of Language Models
| 2024-04-26T18:01:25 | 2024-05-10T23:35:53 |
Vasu Sharma, Karthik Padthe, Newsha Ardalani, Kushal Tirumala, Russell Howes, Hu Xu, Po-Yao Huang, Shang-Wen Li, Armen Aghajanyan, Gargi Ghosh, Luke Zettlemoyer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In recent times training Language Models (LMs) have relied on computationally
heavy training over massive datasets which makes this training process
extremely laborious. In this paper we propose a novel method for numerically
evaluating text quality in large unlabelled NLP datasets in a model agnostic
manner to assign the text instances a "quality score".
By proposing the text quality metric, the paper establishes a framework to
identify and eliminate low-quality text instances, leading to improved training
efficiency for LM models. Experimental results over multiple models and
datasets demonstrate the efficacy of this approach, showcasing substantial
gains in training effectiveness and highlighting the potential for
resource-efficient LM training.
For example, we observe an absolute accuracy improvement of 0.9% averaged
over 14 downstream evaluation tasks for multiple LM models while using 40%
lesser data and training 42% faster when training on the OpenWebText dataset
and 0.8% average absolute accuracy improvement while using 20% lesser data and
training 21% faster on the Wikipedia dataset.
|
[
-0.11747998744249344,
-0.6770913004875183,
0.3345677852630615,
0.14028126001358032,
-0.5186545848846436,
0.010631191544234753,
-0.4816378057003021,
-0.057310156524181366,
-0.013606471940875053,
0.29766979813575745,
-0.43405041098594666,
-0.6258910298347473,
-0.3781716525554657,
0.05010101944208145,
-0.56709885597229,
1.0494188070297241,
0.02340446598827839,
0.1463962346315384,
-0.38022398948669434,
-0.40578892827033997,
-0.3075484335422516,
-0.7108368277549744,
-0.48179399967193604,
-0.27447837591171265,
0.5663327574729919,
0.36435696482658386,
0.7577619552612305,
0.8601832985877991,
0.861627995967865,
0.22441785037517548,
-0.2146654725074768,
0.3982028067111969,
-0.6724731922149658,
0.06987027078866959,
-0.2979528605937958,
-0.227870374917984,
-0.1668665111064911,
0.14371582865715027,
0.8898979425430298,
0.8251346945762634,
-0.30813705921173096,
0.31652092933654785,
0.37970444560050964,
0.754585325717926,
-0.5465357899665833,
-0.12594227492809296,
-0.67145174741745,
0.06522839516401291,
-0.13085998594760895,
-0.37320390343666077,
-0.4679916203022003,
-0.41257160902023315,
-0.1376643180847168,
-0.527259111404419,
0.28845545649528503,
-0.07320338487625122,
1.158435583114624,
0.332721471786499,
-0.14783227443695068,
-0.12650519609451294,
-0.7365765571594238,
1.1625168323516846,
-0.904975414276123,
0.4025188684463501,
0.40203365683555603,
-0.025157351046800613,
0.06236453354358673,
-0.6420981287956238,
-0.43616020679473877,
-0.1473924219608307,
-0.1436590552330017,
0.10518430918455124,
-0.0000988785905065015,
0.14170390367507935,
0.09773068130016327,
0.5307893753051758,
-0.6458810567855835,
0.16425104439258575,
-0.3402668535709381,
-0.2271960824728012,
0.6272757649421692,
0.040669314563274384,
0.37251076102256775,
0.014561159536242485,
-0.09771431237459183,
-0.17443996667861938,
-0.5752971768379211,
0.0548677071928978,
0.519033670425415,
0.38508233428001404,
0.3099251687526703,
0.6174080967903137,
0.017515243962407112,
1.0223160982131958,
-0.44544267654418945,
-0.47665610909461975,
0.32834500074386597,
-0.41023412346839905,
-0.08281534165143967,
-0.3223205506801605,
1.0541130304336548,
0.3503330647945404,
0.3469451367855072,
-0.286617249250412,
-0.5985638499259949,
0.14209261536598206,
0.5091997385025024,
-0.9485458135604858,
-0.3439178764820099,
0.08996406197547913,
-0.6593096256256104,
-0.505936861038208,
0.004217834677547216,
-0.5337304472923279,
-0.08149978518486023,
-0.3476307690143585,
0.49767130613327026,
-0.6550707221031189,
-0.28587689995765686,
-0.13006161153316498,
-0.029773682355880737,
-0.17280814051628113,
0.14693166315555573,
-0.7565080523490906,
0.22341769933700562,
0.6327287554740906,
0.9920929074287415,
-0.2087567150592804,
-0.2936038672924042,
-0.7175078392028809,
-0.22567704319953918,
-0.6610314249992371,
0.6157549619674683,
-0.5921669602394104,
-0.24327391386032104,
-0.17406216263771057,
-0.3191404640674591,
-0.05789284408092499,
-0.5856536030769348,
1.0297666788101196,
-0.4342130422592163,
0.09722056984901428,
0.041808806359767914,
-0.8215014934539795,
-0.19739213585853577,
0.32541516423225403,
-0.7349746823310852,
1.45718514919281,
0.18815504014492035,
-0.7446496486663818,
0.21809516847133636,
-0.35861605405807495,
-0.39373335242271423,
-0.030773278325796127,
0.09781550616025925,
-0.6680704951286316,
0.3915117681026459,
0.3022264540195465,
0.5073754787445068,
-0.3236532211303711,
0.5067554116249084,
-0.26751863956451416,
-0.45313337445259094,
0.28095588088035583,
-0.7230893969535828,
0.46148481965065,
0.16099058091640472,
0.10063779354095459,
0.10511822998523712,
-0.9360215663909912,
0.5532439351081848,
-0.05050860345363617,
-0.5523228049278259,
-0.6607340574264526,
-0.010255469009280205,
0.14512412250041962,
0.21007445454597473,
0.05113278701901436,
-0.49962201714515686,
0.14787040650844574,
-0.7575656771659851,
0.4933372139930725,
0.5992244482040405,
0.035647694021463394,
0.4974125921726227,
-0.3604430854320526,
0.30379483103752136,
-0.25765129923820496,
0.17773857712745667,
-0.1732267290353775,
-0.34740230441093445,
-0.8040304183959961,
-0.19015581905841827,
0.7573900818824768,
0.4080817699432373,
-0.8500972390174866,
0.6174840927124023,
-0.3996647596359253,
-0.7574842572212219,
-0.6366293430328369,
0.29383400082588196,
0.5337294340133667,
0.37090763449668884,
0.3930886685848236,
-0.4596572816371918,
-0.0038491934537887573,
-0.7437911629676819,
-0.5284582376480103,
-0.25702252984046936,
-0.17029930651187897,
-0.0012672299053519964,
0.49273791909217834,
0.1595708131790161,
1.2158399820327759,
-0.2586680054664612,
-0.32896995544433594,
-0.1641838252544403,
0.299705445766449,
0.2889503836631775,
0.5706000924110413,
0.3377283215522766,
-0.867218554019928,
-0.4195227324962616,
-0.2138897180557251,
-0.6212049722671509,
-0.25569427013397217,
-0.20778712630271912,
0.006163014564663172,
0.01707744039595127,
0.381337970495224,
-0.2640111446380615,
0.26138755679130554,
0.775941014289856,
-0.1852840930223465,
0.7205274105072021,
-0.33982548117637634,
0.15477541089057922,
-0.7829716205596924,
0.31411173939704895,
0.32120802998542786,
-0.22539125382900238,
-0.8061228394508362,
0.004400365520268679,
0.21899546682834625,
-0.24033498764038086,
-0.40009814500808716,
0.6018173098564148,
-0.4307512044906616,
-0.010415390133857727,
-0.23306415975093842,
0.04297187551856041,
0.21579180657863617,
0.6776798367500305,
0.07441803812980652,
0.8416469693183899,
0.15732601284980774,
-0.653100848197937,
0.21145230531692505,
0.039344124495983124,
-0.6242889761924744,
0.45098215341567993,
-0.6712878346443176,
0.10732920467853546,
-0.08195184171199799,
-0.18073491752147675,
-0.7581976056098938,
0.18198643624782562,
0.04479050636291504,
-0.5373744368553162,
0.16829745471477509,
-0.14444127678871155,
-0.6955052018165588,
-0.2725985050201416,
-0.09195363521575928,
0.3864346146583557,
0.4237399101257324,
-0.6242466568946838,
0.31455039978027344,
0.4250629246234894,
-0.22283434867858887,
-0.5629030466079712,
-0.456807017326355,
-0.022486677393317223,
-0.22630849480628967,
-0.39724332094192505,
0.631664514541626,
-0.0730474591255188,
-0.10654865205287933,
0.20723502337932587,
-0.24328558146953583,
-0.555812656879425,
0.2917664349079132,
-0.07470996677875519,
0.0639718547463417,
0.03288836032152176,
0.40143021941185,
0.10331650823354721,
-0.20557138323783875,
-0.1329772025346756,
-0.3307421803474426,
0.34928005933761597,
0.06219494715332985,
-0.4387659430503845,
-0.609672486782074,
0.11354310810565948,
0.27428197860717773,
-0.48230069875717163,
0.9177126884460449,
0.5959101319313049,
-0.44396284222602844,
-0.4608936011791229,
-0.3344208002090454,
-0.3269922137260437,
-0.4758011996746063,
0.39592602849006653,
-0.17892983555793762,
-0.8292267918586731,
0.2616058588027954,
-0.061656150966882706,
0.4492064416408539,
0.43299686908721924,
0.28693217039108276,
-0.09433835744857788,
1.1463282108306885,
0.718532145023346,
-0.16122578084468842,
0.5351504683494568,
-0.1756945252418518,
0.3223789930343628,
-0.39922600984573364,
-0.004566471092402935,
-0.7838903665542603,
-0.14854861795902252,
-0.28127244114875793,
-0.6624765992164612,
0.23316693305969238,
0.6471312046051025,
-0.07592667639255524,
0.1649201214313507,
-0.7736621499061584,
0.6065927147865295,
0.5628121495246887,
0.08717813342809677,
0.4229894280433655,
0.25924116373062134,
-0.09477339684963226,
-0.40089505910873413,
-0.9770544767379761,
-0.6201539635658264,
0.8658313751220703,
0.4889589548110962,
0.45367544889450073,
-0.1406080424785614,
0.4866964817047119,
0.29327332973480225,
0.6352026462554932,
-0.9348324537277222,
0.3856646418571472,
-0.30772504210472107,
-0.38298851251602173,
-0.5736459493637085,
-1.1139124631881714,
-0.668048620223999,
0.27622678875923157,
-0.19912825524806976,
-0.4473646283149719,
-0.12296299636363983,
0.3021658658981323,
-0.22168470919132233,
0.39144760370254517,
-0.5763060450553894,
0.9884904623031616,
-0.3242604732513428,
-0.41162747144699097,
-0.36231499910354614,
-0.08074603229761124,
0.18785028159618378,
-0.2789658010005951,
0.3193822503089905,
-0.29773107171058655,
-0.06860192865133286,
1.1722145080566406,
-0.7475606203079224,
0.609013020992279,
-0.2932560443878174,
-0.1641087681055069,
0.438306599855423,
0.0550246499478817,
0.4877333641052246,
-0.07244163006544113,
-0.20473115146160126,
0.3042735159397125,
-0.05320385470986366,
-0.35638192296028137,
-0.7881305813789368,
0.5047224164009094,
-0.7019619941711426,
0.07261551916599274,
-0.29447752237319946,
-0.21255353093147278,
-0.41053423285484314,
0.07691509276628494,
0.21454451978206635,
0.6328888535499573,
-0.18819977343082428,
0.2104085236787796,
0.4765811264514923,
-0.46832987666130066,
0.4419177770614624,
0.43950551748275757,
0.12887875735759735,
-0.6670620441436768,
1.361281156539917,
0.27251896262168884,
0.11749199032783508,
0.358443945646286,
0.0884038582444191,
-0.4607941508293152,
-0.8340907692909241,
-0.33130452036857605,
0.18149921298027039,
-0.5872660279273987,
-0.4998103380203247,
-0.3605768382549286,
-0.38907089829444885,
0.2509010434150696,
0.12133046984672546,
-0.6848617196083069,
-0.31929951906204224,
-0.3147958517074585,
0.11431922763586044,
0.3179256319999695,
0.4304625988006592,
0.21582306921482086,
0.6620373725891113,
-1.112278699874878,
0.20286825299263,
0.06243462860584259,
0.8606871962547302,
0.09350096434354782,
-0.8047026991844177,
-0.5569011569023132,
0.18682383000850677,
-0.1720293015241623,
-0.6665276885032654,
0.8338865041732788,
0.5535088777542114,
0.5496186017990112,
0.20356133580207825,
0.12957213819026947,
0.5262162089347839,
-0.5518393516540527,
0.6570004820823669,
0.415890097618103,
-0.9429259300231934,
0.3686371445655823,
-0.18665973842144012,
0.1720823496580124,
0.9014859795570374,
0.3686020076274872,
-0.7076482176780701,
-0.3892720341682434,
-0.5251284241676331,
-1.0070829391479492,
0.5959597229957581,
0.47479596734046936,
0.12837861478328705,
0.12070909887552261,
0.595726728439331,
0.05915287137031555,
0.3088126480579376,
-0.7669942378997803,
-0.20276939868927002,
-0.05947781354188919,
-0.554118812084198,
-0.17901228368282318,
-0.3690013587474823,
0.10466587543487549,
-0.2519494593143463,
0.932322084903717,
-0.2726880609989166,
0.08050169050693512,
0.051853664219379425,
-0.451667457818985,
0.15587671101093292,
0.17056068778038025,
0.0694582536816597,
0.8317233324050903,
-0.06892047822475433,
0.03099426068365574,
0.08328549563884735,
-0.5279377102851868,
0.31725913286209106,
-0.15313106775283813,
-0.2573283314704895,
0.3991066813468933,
0.36512491106987,
0.5750086903572083,
0.1714090257883072,
-0.6716560125350952,
0.5785796046257019,
-0.19689373672008514,
-0.1356871873140335,
-0.06994263082742691,
0.08498014509677887,
-0.1828940063714981,
-0.2933965027332306,
0.5388874411582947,
-0.023429835215210915,
-0.03290029615163803,
-0.09140803664922714,
0.3690135180950165,
0.2733597457408905,
-0.6597538590431213,
-0.18193070590496063,
0.3437749743461609,
0.4881290793418884,
-0.3715653419494629,
0.7790889739990234,
-0.1975649744272232,
-0.4503514766693115,
0.5152315497398376,
0.15369446575641632,
0.5433380007743835,
-0.24224571883678436,
0.32030239701271057,
0.5901381969451904,
0.42660361528396606,
-0.4496024250984192,
-0.0572737455368042,
0.23002268373966217,
-0.8516246676445007,
-1.0683215856552124,
-1.1015386581420898,
-0.4872896373271942,
0.40302878618240356,
-0.625657856464386,
0.19403019547462463,
-0.2997278869152069,
-0.1761118471622467,
-0.03299031779170036,
0.1643039584159851,
-0.38901787996292114,
0.476204514503479,
-0.19243092834949493,
1.0506131649017334,
-0.9038592576980591,
0.9273067712783813,
0.5497309565544128,
-0.21438145637512207,
-0.8512573838233948,
0.05499223992228508,
-0.29525503516197205,
-0.28718775510787964,
0.28354206681251526,
0.3511657118797302,
0.20884078741073608,
0.2307429313659668,
-0.29783743619918823,
-0.6371221542358398,
0.5220156908035278,
0.5038191080093384,
-0.980621874332428,
0.1307978481054306,
0.09037276357412338,
0.6241660714149475,
0.030761508271098137,
0.47060325741767883,
0.5210108160972595,
0.3432849049568176,
-0.4564175605773926,
-0.9201177358627319,
-0.3446030616760254,
-0.5688044428825378,
0.1367315948009491,
0.40428459644317627,
-0.47613033652305603,
0.351697713136673,
0.1553308665752411,
-0.3243395686149597,
0.04943730682134628,
0.883537769317627,
0.01753605343401432,
0.07850021868944168,
0.747079074382782,
0.548584520816803,
1.0122448205947876,
-0.22566285729408264,
0.8210023045539856,
-0.4914464056491852,
0.675686240196228,
0.827220618724823,
0.06733735650777817,
0.7810710668563843,
0.3426585793495178,
-0.16157016158103943,
0.05770307779312134,
0.7159850597381592,
0.026848582550883293,
0.5092446208000183,
0.30625084042549133,
-0.1991204470396042,
-0.35942307114601135,
-0.12499511986970901,
-0.06870557367801666,
0.3442358076572418,
0.2621077597141266,
-0.2680841386318207,
-0.22998946905136108,
0.05672411993145943,
-0.05736038461327553,
0.44676604866981506,
-0.30668121576309204,
0.7675243020057678,
0.05826263502240181,
-0.5991092920303345,
0.76966792345047,
0.4593999981880188,
0.8784963488578796,
-0.5803390741348267,
-0.017577987164258957,
-0.19996142387390137,
0.2382979840040207,
-0.12735676765441895,
-0.8207540512084961,
0.4947360157966614,
0.216832235455513,
-0.36066964268684387,
-0.5702255964279175,
0.6919048428535461,
-0.49970296025276184,
-0.6909891366958618,
0.149416983127594,
0.5847926735877991,
0.2673119902610779,
-0.3799560070037842,
-0.9145364761352539,
0.07178561389446259,
0.03797243908047676,
-0.46140056848526,
0.44494783878326416,
0.4158172905445099,
-0.05337619408965111,
0.6736697554588318,
0.8321326971054077,
0.24962365627288818,
-0.49837109446525574,
0.2426968812942505,
0.8302722573280334,
-0.650116503238678,
-0.5238993763923645,
-0.9590288996696472,
0.45290935039520264,
-0.30975621938705444,
-0.45652875304222107,
0.568535327911377,
0.6601507663726807,
0.8163017630577087,
0.3483169376850128,
0.7385110855102539,
0.18680579960346222,
0.7650465369224548,
-0.497795969247818,
0.8634930849075317,
-0.5134000182151794,
0.35384678840637207,
-0.2674163579940796,
-1.1117662191390991,
-0.3331233561038971,
0.8821426033973694,
-0.23646782338619232,
0.01785600557923317,
0.5933418869972229,
0.7685613632202148,
-0.11761411279439926,
-0.12324894219636917,
0.3213113248348236,
0.0004952694289386272,
0.3217686414718628,
0.2079121619462967,
0.7301633954048157,
-0.27086594700813293,
0.7403343319892883,
-0.5556082129478455,
-0.2803170680999756,
-0.013646814972162247,
-0.9115681648254395,
-0.7690376043319702,
-0.6684296131134033,
-0.34612685441970825,
-0.3805680572986603,
0.23380765318870544,
0.668785572052002,
0.6384060978889465,
-0.6899222731590271,
-0.11828391253948212,
-0.2645682692527771,
0.082310751080513,
-0.42279425263404846,
-0.292782723903656,
0.502449095249176,
-0.5408747792243958,
-0.6505521535873413,
0.3847326338291168,
0.15007716417312622,
-0.19138985872268677,
-0.25427672266960144,
-0.0795682817697525,
0.12456348538398743,
-0.05943296477198601,
0.5129966139793396,
0.09103137999773026,
-0.21367502212524414,
-0.1486436277627945,
-0.14223147928714752,
-0.2166639268398285,
-0.002534241648390889,
0.8567871451377869,
-0.7351783514022827,
0.2211173176765442,
0.3882666230201721,
0.6674271821975708,
0.2842113673686981,
0.20947831869125366,
0.6862266063690186,
-1.074906349182129,
0.2587168514728546,
0.6219536662101746,
0.12744390964508057,
0.628710150718689,
-0.005092957988381386,
0.5297958850860596,
0.3150785565376282,
-0.5387650728225708,
-1.2348909378051758,
-0.13837523758411407,
-0.5309123396873474,
-0.3827289342880249,
1.1710842847824097,
-0.38559213280677795,
-0.3863397240638733,
0.03409186378121376,
-0.027412518858909607,
0.19616517424583435,
-0.35035228729248047,
0.7171037197113037,
0.7681247591972351,
0.34648555517196655,
-0.1706034392118454,
-0.6711173057556152,
0.6611552834510803,
0.5455688834190369,
-0.8747936487197876,
0.19079305231571198,
0.4499068856239319,
0.1323128193616867,
0.07363495230674744,
0.5807563066482544,
0.03888922557234764,
0.06021491810679436,
-0.1867169439792633,
0.30274349451065063,
-0.0433172807097435,
-0.5222027897834778,
-0.3223858177661896,
0.33458006381988525,
0.14649692177772522,
0.15210293233394623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17552v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17552v1
|
A Semi-Automatic Approach to Create Large Gender- and Age-Balanced Speaker Corpora: Usefulness of Speaker Diarization & Identification
| 2024-04-26T17:30:36 | 2024-04-26T17:30:36 |
Rémi Uro, David Doukhan, Albert Rilliard, Laëtitia Larcher, Anissa-Claire Adgharouamane, Marie Tahon, Antoine Laurent
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.DL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
This paper presents a semi-automatic approach to create a diachronic corpus
of voices balanced for speaker's age, gender, and recording period, according
to 32 categories (2 genders, 4 age ranges and 4 recording periods). Corpora
were selected at French National Institute of Audiovisual (INA) to obtain at
least 30 speakers per category (a total of 960 speakers; only 874 have be found
yet). For each speaker, speech excerpts were extracted from audiovisual
documents using an automatic pipeline consisting of speech detection,
background music and overlapped speech removal and speaker diarization, used to
present clean speaker segments to human annotators identifying target speakers.
This pipeline proved highly effective, cutting down manual processing by a
factor of ten. Evaluation of the quality of the automatic processing and of the
final output is provided. It shows the automatic processing compare to
up-to-date process, and that the output provides high quality speech for most
of the selected excerpts. This method shows promise for creating large corpora
of known target speakers.
|
[
-0.6879346966743469,
-0.6826211810112,
0.17447856068611145,
0.2397250235080719,
0.05411546677350998,
0.37917855381965637,
-0.31809160113334656,
-0.451795369386673,
0.08236914873123169,
0.32207730412483215,
-0.49384182691574097,
-0.4978088438510895,
-0.20095759630203247,
0.6632682681083679,
-0.8969631791114807,
0.7344224452972412,
0.5948456525802612,
-0.06444502621889114,
0.14456142485141754,
0.16369102895259857,
-0.7861618995666504,
-0.16584812104701996,
-0.5997522473335266,
0.024774499237537384,
0.037168607115745544,
0.8481177687644958,
0.6828957200050354,
0.6471165418624878,
0.042775657027959824,
0.4899350106716156,
-0.2148682326078415,
0.30833303928375244,
-0.09804587066173553,
-0.05106167495250702,
-0.2643108069896698,
-0.21622659265995026,
-0.7270499467849731,
-0.0929429829120636,
0.9718530178070068,
0.9779872298240662,
-0.22264285385608673,
0.15481963753700256,
-0.12312669306993484,
0.613926351070404,
-0.38928309082984924,
-0.10590936243534088,
-0.5156683921813965,
0.142892524600029,
-0.49546539783477783,
-0.5903773903846741,
-0.5599198937416077,
-0.036606837064027786,
0.030273251235485077,
-0.3711177706718445,
0.5081655979156494,
0.09364646673202515,
0.6425876021385193,
0.01482089702039957,
-0.12957680225372314,
-0.34384456276893616,
-1.2980966567993164,
0.6880408525466919,
-0.654483437538147,
0.32962894439697266,
0.42217540740966797,
0.5049881339073181,
0.06534560024738312,
-0.3932391405105591,
-0.38213542103767395,
0.033670250326395035,
0.03514091670513153,
0.011116827838122845,
-0.2773989737033844,
-0.21017588675022125,
0.20995865762233734,
0.37521597743034363,
-0.66750168800354,
0.053339287638664246,
-0.8501124978065491,
-0.44153812527656555,
0.7362497448921204,
-0.12957851588726044,
0.7473368048667908,
-0.27820199728012085,
-0.23762424290180206,
-0.014609908685088158,
-0.284209668636322,
-0.4123803973197937,
0.9335918426513672,
0.5353455543518066,
-0.10439474135637283,
0.9478638768196106,
-0.2040424644947052,
0.7578562498092651,
0.42168840765953064,
-0.15579572319984436,
0.44797927141189575,
-0.4385567307472229,
-0.16114547848701477,
0.6518851518630981,
0.8048073053359985,
0.23261192440986633,
0.5714695453643799,
-0.10601770877838135,
-0.17259398102760315,
-0.010672023519873619,
0.3178587257862091,
-0.4008634090423584,
-0.41395625472068787,
0.2706148624420166,
-0.3532165288925171,
-0.12453672289848328,
-0.0402555875480175,
-1.257201910018921,
-0.02889658324420452,
-0.49789783358573914,
0.09728609770536423,
-0.5448122620582581,
-0.29813486337661743,
-0.1362917274236679,
-0.27901554107666016,
-0.20776806771755219,
0.27702945470809937,
-1.1387333869934082,
0.482194721698761,
0.06886661797761917,
0.6131025552749634,
-0.23777015507221222,
0.03385882452130318,
-0.8416711091995239,
0.36950603127479553,
-0.3707607388496399,
0.535286545753479,
-0.5431678295135498,
-0.3557979464530945,
0.04519948363304138,
0.0743643268942833,
0.1410312056541443,
-0.7641550898551941,
0.44955769181251526,
-0.47777676582336426,
0.5854027271270752,
0.1979750096797943,
-0.44250282645225525,
0.28485485911369324,
-0.30317220091819763,
-0.7239286303520203,
0.8528585433959961,
0.17797040939331055,
-0.799285888671875,
0.2898905277252197,
-0.36267295479774475,
-0.2227727770805359,
0.48783859610557556,
-0.22226084768772125,
-0.18714334070682526,
-0.3233989179134369,
0.2115890383720398,
0.26795631647109985,
0.04407655820250511,
0.33108651638031006,
0.06645502150058746,
-0.0396670363843441,
0.026353683322668076,
-0.41573596000671387,
0.8424485921859741,
0.4519276022911072,
-0.5034183263778687,
0.004786429926753044,
-1.1785454750061035,
-0.3457058072090149,
-0.10257742553949356,
-0.15338900685310364,
-0.36387690901756287,
0.025883477181196213,
0.2610885500907898,
0.03787900507450104,
0.3381505012512207,
-0.5644621849060059,
-0.3139857351779938,
-0.595841646194458,
0.42499151825904846,
0.5464504361152649,
-0.1590764969587326,
0.5390085577964783,
-0.027289843186736107,
0.2724457085132599,
-0.11847411841154099,
0.06395523995161057,
-0.01512072142213583,
-0.2730734646320343,
-0.6761131882667542,
-0.6680871248245239,
0.5288757085800171,
0.8158221244812012,
-0.4689345359802246,
0.9261392951011658,
0.010989195667207241,
-0.5564086437225342,
-0.3366486132144928,
0.3497428596019745,
0.30853089690208435,
0.38029879331588745,
0.34181758761405945,
-0.5908231139183044,
-0.8983385562896729,
-1.1173855066299438,
0.3696640729904175,
-0.5629242062568665,
-0.331137478351593,
-0.054300036281347275,
0.20563837885856628,
-0.16320189833641052,
1.1159391403198242,
-0.15015718340873718,
-0.0709189847111702,
0.11010512709617615,
0.5094022154808044,
0.038130395114421844,
0.39370641112327576,
0.4995286762714386,
-1.0091930627822876,
-0.1348326951265335,
-0.1628332883119583,
-0.7297461032867432,
-0.5494325757026672,
-0.029024653136730194,
-0.16875998675823212,
0.19522203505039215,
0.5918446183204651,
-0.2665780484676361,
0.1008424311876297,
0.2501094937324524,
-0.3724633455276489,
0.5242918133735657,
-0.23202408850193024,
-0.017995791509747505,
-0.8624483346939087,
0.2637212574481964,
0.14549709856510162,
-0.4291782081127167,
-0.6911236643791199,
-0.590205192565918,
-0.08635878562927246,
-0.27894532680511475,
-0.4852515757083893,
0.31354817748069763,
-0.5951956510543823,
-0.26051977276802063,
-0.37274405360221863,
0.5761734843254089,
-0.35330507159233093,
0.3077367842197418,
0.18648657202720642,
0.7238224744796753,
0.2047063261270523,
-0.5986680388450623,
0.507377564907074,
0.41683071851730347,
-0.12095341831445694,
0.9294905066490173,
-0.6475109457969666,
0.07237791270017624,
-0.20939257740974426,
-0.029164619743824005,
-1.3135664463043213,
-0.009665909223258495,
0.22435232996940613,
-0.3973148763179779,
0.6813326478004456,
-0.147667795419693,
-0.3143831193447113,
-0.3308352530002594,
-0.000817331310827285,
0.3717603385448456,
0.13003531098365784,
-0.17614112794399261,
0.4663470387458801,
0.736782431602478,
-0.8952724933624268,
-0.3514343202114105,
-0.43530601263046265,
0.43307897448539734,
-0.4197391867637634,
-0.6673556566238403,
0.6436048150062561,
-0.3269032835960388,
-0.3995537757873535,
-0.08835041522979736,
0.12059549987316132,
0.07220295071601868,
-0.20807327330112457,
-0.010212140157818794,
0.4792972803115845,
0.1291516125202179,
-0.0367685966193676,
-0.1466148942708969,
-0.20375153422355652,
-0.3505361080169678,
-0.1546117514371872,
0.6418672204017639,
-0.15694528818130493,
-0.06500882655382156,
-0.4989970028400421,
0.635993480682373,
0.6957615613937378,
-0.22551526129245758,
0.4671606719493866,
0.7505057454109192,
-0.3803655207157135,
-0.18778344988822937,
-0.5577622652053833,
-0.005283254198729992,
-0.40959596633911133,
0.03966739773750305,
-0.2113601565361023,
-0.8223906755447388,
0.4851299226284027,
0.2158685326576233,
0.13577759265899658,
0.724978506565094,
0.8905792236328125,
-0.04513303562998772,
1.0274449586868286,
0.4039241373538971,
-0.09316833317279816,
0.5346156358718872,
0.14501915872097015,
0.10482905060052872,
-0.4772791564464569,
-0.3009050488471985,
-0.702789306640625,
-0.10043185204267502,
-0.9393969774246216,
-0.21797563135623932,
0.09417254477739334,
-0.27395644783973694,
-0.25085994601249695,
0.5685988664627075,
-0.818974494934082,
-0.06819765269756317,
0.6148315668106079,
-0.26185518503189087,
0.2365250289440155,
-0.03207703307271004,
-0.012622003443539143,
0.2214268296957016,
-0.2185504287481308,
-0.9501299262046814,
0.7259969115257263,
0.43454763293266296,
0.5318437218666077,
0.19974450767040253,
0.5267227292060852,
0.9096273183822632,
-0.42714428901672363,
-0.47979119420051575,
0.6461062431335449,
-0.10810545831918716,
-0.9013562798500061,
-0.7558972835540771,
-0.5976603031158447,
-0.7194157242774963,
-0.1371806561946869,
-0.11757418513298035,
-0.7737834453582764,
0.719580352306366,
0.013844957575201988,
-0.3492294251918793,
-0.06135778874158859,
-0.7325565218925476,
0.6714151501655579,
-0.14161452651023865,
-0.28421828150749207,
0.05126095190644264,
-0.9625124931335449,
0.07202304899692535,
-0.30232900381088257,
0.43578359484672546,
-0.2205459028482437,
0.15322832763195038,
1.0670782327651978,
-0.30619746446609497,
0.8327874541282654,
-0.32999056577682495,
-0.10978035628795624,
0.3987296521663666,
0.02557079680263996,
0.08959468454122543,
0.06822746992111206,
0.0010125398403033614,
0.11821778118610382,
0.3756398558616638,
-0.2671973407268524,
-0.10125724226236343,
0.41442614793777466,
-1.130042314529419,
-0.41503602266311646,
-0.29222914576530457,
-0.4736666977405548,
-0.12544198334217072,
0.23054750263690948,
0.11095409840345383,
0.6378477811813354,
-0.507530927658081,
0.23959779739379883,
0.6083967685699463,
-0.4595803916454315,
0.6124869585037231,
0.5288742184638977,
0.07110799849033356,
-0.7809385061264038,
0.6614375710487366,
0.11006955802440643,
0.21570207178592682,
0.6051123142242432,
0.02287258580327034,
-0.2760530412197113,
-0.25507649779319763,
-0.4637773334980011,
0.24025551974773407,
-0.4636758267879486,
0.10849235951900482,
-0.7816994786262512,
-0.2776920795440674,
-0.5165287256240845,
0.17941667139530182,
-0.5897369980812073,
-0.5216869711875916,
-0.2537519931793213,
0.058214567601680756,
-0.07184192538261414,
0.05738281086087227,
-0.22827540338039398,
0.14500147104263306,
-0.5964205861091614,
0.654608428478241,
0.6430516242980957,
-0.32675644755363464,
-0.38818252086639404,
-0.5185664892196655,
-0.12696212530136108,
0.060672540217638016,
-0.2448219656944275,
-1.0812139511108398,
0.6781274080276489,
0.31321433186531067,
0.6332557201385498,
0.42685118317604065,
0.12939824163913727,
0.41336408257484436,
-0.7007220983505249,
0.7056305408477783,
0.22291973233222961,
-1.0023770332336426,
0.6861065626144409,
-0.6029433608055115,
0.2605009078979492,
0.6861045360565186,
-0.021472595632076263,
-0.46482229232788086,
-0.588773250579834,
-0.7246075868606567,
-1.0748326778411865,
0.7863684892654419,
0.7064701914787292,
0.015983112156391144,
-0.2363589107990265,
-0.20639745891094208,
0.20860956609249115,
0.31453439593315125,
-0.23002855479717255,
-0.24711106717586517,
-0.3150182366371155,
-0.24011021852493286,
-0.2259850651025772,
-0.34255221486091614,
-0.5706596374511719,
-0.33466020226478577,
0.8809092044830322,
-0.02815481647849083,
0.5766115784645081,
0.2371852546930313,
0.00007321596058318391,
-0.3803824782371521,
0.5540509819984436,
0.8007466793060303,
0.8488122820854187,
-0.6829068660736084,
0.6468510031700134,
0.06494341045618057,
-0.1552235186100006,
0.17459642887115479,
0.09922213852405548,
-0.0638706162571907,
0.32102829217910767,
0.27311971783638,
0.5992947816848755,
0.04092106223106384,
-0.7149357199668884,
0.32180559635162354,
-0.09424512833356857,
-0.13456957042217255,
-0.7903388738632202,
-0.12175857275724411,
0.0651155635714531,
0.2161574512720108,
0.6101914048194885,
0.059650953859090805,
0.19481554627418518,
-0.7476157546043396,
0.47845762968063354,
0.10235441476106644,
-0.22576017677783966,
-0.34179213643074036,
0.813909649848938,
0.29117515683174133,
-0.5402005314826965,
0.6812878251075745,
-0.12499651312828064,
-0.17874553799629211,
0.38149145245552063,
0.7026267647743225,
0.8031473159790039,
-0.5413693189620972,
0.462131142616272,
0.2755836248397827,
0.29595643281936646,
0.001035637455061078,
-0.023580489680171013,
-0.2017192244529724,
-0.7430117130279541,
-0.22769421339035034,
-0.6812054514884949,
-0.33843132853507996,
-0.10633079707622528,
-0.5458738207817078,
0.42067283391952515,
-0.16570234298706055,
-0.4688456058502197,
0.45343562960624695,
0.04245030879974365,
-0.5135135650634766,
0.37724801898002625,
0.6890476942062378,
0.777656078338623,
-1.3773623704910278,
0.41014817357063293,
0.5390732288360596,
-0.21780310571193695,
-0.5187809467315674,
-0.29081568121910095,
0.11377374827861786,
-0.3787704110145569,
0.6330437660217285,
-0.1951104700565338,
-0.116824209690094,
-0.20097583532333374,
-0.2573888897895813,
-0.5686900019645691,
0.7224591970443726,
0.43442049622535706,
-0.8427173495292664,
-0.101478211581707,
0.1665378212928772,
0.715241551399231,
-0.3639146387577057,
0.5228801965713501,
0.4013909101486206,
0.5725055932998657,
0.4493994116783142,
-1.1151628494262695,
-0.31145966053009033,
-0.6764129996299744,
0.0024653563741594553,
0.08138681203126907,
-0.4690258502960205,
0.5808190703392029,
0.47582125663757324,
-0.29116547107696533,
-0.048908405005931854,
0.995398998260498,
0.3566918969154358,
0.4409715533256531,
1.0683376789093018,
0.26847144961357117,
0.9544753432273865,
0.2728920876979828,
0.383652925491333,
-0.2950807213783264,
-0.05687609314918518,
0.9357030987739563,
-0.21756114065647125,
0.4249279201030731,
0.2985435128211975,
-0.17902633547782898,
0.2970547080039978,
0.7563643455505371,
-0.15511980652809143,
0.6252026557922363,
0.07452256977558136,
-0.2569577991962433,
-0.35822102427482605,
-0.15083234012126923,
-0.2706049978733063,
0.6596761345863342,
0.022155417129397392,
-0.42645126581192017,
-0.01903955452144146,
0.06998200714588165,
-0.05158546194434166,
0.14488929510116577,
0.09141715615987778,
0.5476381778717041,
0.07067239284515381,
-0.5804280638694763,
0.48093801736831665,
0.15309950709342957,
0.36533698439598083,
-0.3207661509513855,
0.10476241260766983,
0.0519641675055027,
0.03348331153392792,
-0.4260576069355011,
-0.6526967883110046,
0.36390599608421326,
0.35196971893310547,
-0.4370972514152527,
-0.2265322506427765,
0.679637610912323,
-0.6900869607925415,
-0.7367290258407593,
0.25975996255874634,
0.5301753878593445,
0.36574286222457886,
0.2994231581687927,
-0.20979011058807373,
-0.09360041469335556,
-0.04631130024790764,
0.11317305266857147,
0.04943940043449402,
0.6434367299079895,
-0.4005383253097534,
0.2060898095369339,
0.3790074288845062,
0.4062168002128601,
0.016255713999271393,
0.4298589825630188,
0.3719002604484558,
-0.24165533483028412,
-0.4107646346092224,
-0.9532968997955322,
0.3665274977684021,
-0.2507213056087494,
-0.16261574625968933,
0.6984733939170837,
0.8902799487113953,
0.7217885255813599,
-0.01642104610800743,
0.572860598564148,
-0.23815882205963135,
0.7477572560310364,
-0.18731102347373962,
0.38659894466400146,
-0.35040026903152466,
0.38589203357696533,
-0.7413097620010376,
-1.170304775238037,
-0.10894771665334702,
0.4650869071483612,
-0.18287119269371033,
0.06374777853488922,
0.39199933409690857,
0.8835472464561462,
-0.09504825621843338,
0.2066955268383026,
0.31450605392456055,
-0.008063306100666523,
0.34524986147880554,
0.16117602586746216,
0.7975691556930542,
-0.13776908814907074,
0.43010276556015015,
-0.23604360222816467,
-0.41639506816864014,
-0.2644638419151306,
-0.7374810576438904,
-0.7402597069740295,
-0.7178762555122375,
-0.6950279474258423,
0.09906917065382004,
0.17517797648906708,
0.7228294014930725,
0.817424476146698,
-0.8654826283454895,
-0.3945195972919464,
0.20612895488739014,
-0.30914804339408875,
-0.34078535437583923,
-0.21352726221084595,
0.3515269160270691,
0.020233044400811195,
-1.0705302953720093,
0.7960444688796997,
0.4191094636917114,
-0.2586154341697693,
-0.31571048498153687,
0.04423758387565613,
-0.3578859567642212,
0.08141810446977615,
0.3786703646183014,
0.3921385705471039,
-0.18751481175422668,
-0.4465516209602356,
-0.12597544491291046,
-0.09384648501873016,
0.034340497106313705,
0.27585896849632263,
-0.31212806701660156,
0.8602027893066406,
0.7538943290710449,
-0.015517688356339931,
0.5981932878494263,
0.31950843334198,
0.8671558499336243,
-0.9275767207145691,
0.1913040280342102,
0.27391165494918823,
0.2892638146877289,
0.6004078388214111,
-0.24715955555438995,
0.4596259593963623,
0.4106220304965973,
-0.605162501335144,
-0.8669202327728271,
-0.18837745487689972,
-1.3653398752212524,
-0.09162269532680511,
1.1675504446029663,
0.37276050448417664,
-0.1592574119567871,
-0.30041077733039856,
-0.368622750043869,
0.870446503162384,
-0.44677647948265076,
0.7651233673095703,
0.7181091904640198,
0.1344277560710907,
-0.16964639723300934,
-0.7397844791412354,
0.12511633336544037,
0.18337875604629517,
-0.6796994805335999,
-0.10533168911933899,
0.5569440722465515,
0.07434174418449402,
0.6335519552230835,
0.6514911651611328,
-0.4347897171974182,
0.0996849462389946,
-0.21327249705791473,
0.43562567234039307,
0.10018692910671234,
-0.7108181715011597,
0.26564884185791016,
0.46130356192588806,
-0.017806177958846092,
-0.35085684061050415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17546v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17546v1
|
Probabilistic Inference in Language Models via Twisted Sequential Monte Carlo
| 2024-04-26T17:18:32 | 2024-04-26T17:18:32 |
Stephen Zhao, Rob Brekelmans, Alireza Makhzani, Roger Grosse
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Numerous capability and safety techniques of Large Language Models (LLMs),
including RLHF, automated red-teaming, prompt engineering, and infilling, can
be cast as sampling from an unnormalized target distribution defined by a given
reward or potential function over the full sequence. In this work, we leverage
the rich toolkit of Sequential Monte Carlo (SMC) for these probabilistic
inference problems. In particular, we use learned twist functions to estimate
the expected future value of the potential at each timestep, which enables us
to focus inference-time computation on promising partial sequences. We propose
a novel contrastive method for learning the twist functions, and establish
connections with the rich literature of soft reinforcement learning. As a
complementary application of our twisted SMC framework, we present methods for
evaluating the accuracy of language model inference techniques using novel
bidirectional SMC bounds on the log partition function. These bounds can be
used to estimate the KL divergence between the inference and target
distributions in both directions. We apply our inference evaluation techniques
to show that twisted SMC is effective for sampling undesirable outputs from a
pretrained model (a useful component of harmlessness training and automated
red-teaming), generating reviews with varied sentiment, and performing
infilling tasks.
|
[
-0.12309858202934265,
-0.7763700485229492,
0.6598413586616516,
0.07536996901035309,
-0.08809267729520798,
0.32220742106437683,
-0.18963533639907837,
0.14768405258655548,
0.18477876484394073,
0.5726807713508606,
-0.7692050337791443,
-0.27781474590301514,
-0.38345226645469666,
-0.07378129661083221,
-0.4269022047519684,
1.2345908880233765,
0.18963398039340973,
-0.03600320219993591,
-0.049730345606803894,
0.06158002093434334,
0.26118624210357666,
-0.2991864085197449,
-0.49336591362953186,
-0.2375759482383728,
0.6655706763267517,
0.29759955406188965,
0.6788698434829712,
-0.13186155259609222,
0.15495772659778595,
0.3123317062854767,
-0.25423678755760193,
0.026902955025434494,
-0.3977137804031372,
0.1627776324748993,
-0.17749443650245667,
-0.5309677720069885,
-0.05612185224890709,
0.2135501205921173,
0.8225877285003662,
0.9403452277183533,
-0.1386180967092514,
-0.20004163682460785,
0.006784435827285051,
0.6782529950141907,
-0.7142760157585144,
0.0595378540456295,
-0.5683770775794983,
0.06786764413118362,
-0.1306561678647995,
0.04889941215515137,
-0.5407395958900452,
-0.30232536792755127,
0.09534493088722229,
-0.35601183772087097,
0.16650131344795227,
-0.08457766473293304,
0.40268126130104065,
-0.039744481444358826,
-0.48983234167099,
-0.279928982257843,
-0.7726942300796509,
0.9546876549720764,
-1.0253150463104248,
0.26271897554397583,
0.3164512515068054,
0.34243568778038025,
-0.5175381898880005,
-0.6741309762001038,
-0.7466889023780823,
-0.5996456146240234,
0.2608480453491211,
0.2509482800960541,
0.4282974302768707,
0.30443447828292847,
0.1664927452802658,
0.3123774230480194,
-0.5068445801734924,
0.11857223510742188,
-0.3685993552207947,
0.15804629027843475,
0.7978549599647522,
-0.13104909658432007,
0.01989482156932354,
-0.05409978702664375,
-0.3496808111667633,
-0.4517453908920288,
-0.6827904582023621,
-0.0647396445274353,
0.9451135396957397,
0.2740144729614258,
-0.06250542402267456,
0.5084537863731384,
-0.061199940741062164,
0.3398601710796356,
-0.08376599103212357,
-0.18277591466903687,
0.32244446873664856,
0.007423284463584423,
-0.2736991047859192,
-0.28127217292785645,
0.7938874959945679,
-0.06930244714021683,
0.4827427566051483,
-0.2463696449995041,
-0.26158058643341064,
-0.23074449598789215,
0.3723474442958832,
-0.18070781230926514,
-0.5255784392356873,
0.4370166063308716,
-0.1598907709121704,
-0.5719605088233948,
0.26412850618362427,
-0.7113601565361023,
-0.46648967266082764,
0.1547844558954239,
0.28325265645980835,
-0.23864562809467316,
-0.5569365620613098,
-0.07225745171308517,
-0.10971983522176743,
-0.030602820217609406,
-0.13082019984722137,
-0.5935134887695312,
0.3300652801990509,
0.5788231492042542,
0.590498149394989,
-0.3426778316497803,
-0.32529929280281067,
-0.5747832655906677,
-0.04338366910815239,
-0.3313012719154358,
0.7543005347251892,
-0.3803063929080963,
-0.343893438577652,
0.031248146668076515,
-0.059655752032995224,
-0.13560643792152405,
-0.4005500376224518,
0.4733455181121826,
-0.5780333876609802,
0.1478365659713745,
0.47590553760528564,
-0.34428951144218445,
-0.29688560962677,
0.010697542689740658,
-0.7234734892845154,
0.7153791785240173,
0.3059943616390228,
-0.9755063056945801,
0.07956705242395401,
-0.21094991266727448,
-0.6308671236038208,
-0.001853568130172789,
-0.012827001512050629,
-0.6920077204704285,
0.19720660150051117,
0.10980559885501862,
0.394014835357666,
-0.007603260688483715,
0.38259273767471313,
-0.8154862523078918,
-0.13091734051704407,
0.5964533686637878,
-0.43217384815216064,
0.7941462993621826,
0.3707854747772217,
-0.2170659452676773,
0.5571637153625488,
-0.27295243740081787,
0.047185324132442474,
0.0691666379570961,
-0.08349248766899109,
-0.2246115356683731,
0.17931316792964935,
-0.14364923536777496,
0.12107715010643005,
-0.3101125657558441,
-0.11873287707567215,
0.10492442548274994,
-0.6240559816360474,
0.32078102231025696,
0.8776770234107971,
0.10206029564142227,
0.5539584159851074,
-0.10898465663194656,
0.6811882853507996,
0.4082338213920593,
0.12451963871717453,
0.0944233313202858,
-0.4185008108615875,
-0.4275810420513153,
-0.5374410152435303,
0.7139389514923096,
0.5829570293426514,
-1.3154796361923218,
0.2991137206554413,
0.08740473538637161,
-0.12182404100894928,
-0.29470378160476685,
-0.14575006067752838,
0.39129161834716797,
0.3293929398059845,
0.06633943319320679,
-0.24517466127872467,
-0.41891902685165405,
-0.8830834627151489,
-0.5170624256134033,
-0.28042978048324585,
-0.26423242688179016,
0.22382764518260956,
0.46786925196647644,
-0.1271524876356125,
0.638939380645752,
-0.2633782625198364,
0.12348343431949615,
-0.7621378302574158,
0.4253697991371155,
0.49796566367149353,
0.4138440191745758,
0.07429870963096619,
-0.7832624912261963,
-0.2701480984687805,
-0.339285671710968,
-0.27302396297454834,
-0.15126559138298035,
-0.5729337334632874,
0.006005042232573032,
0.34822148084640503,
0.3318999111652374,
-0.34463030099868774,
0.3191224932670593,
0.5626552700996399,
-0.1807744801044464,
0.8170956373214722,
-0.30025985836982727,
0.22321993112564087,
-0.707837700843811,
-0.1369040161371231,
0.14380255341529846,
-0.4555574655532837,
-0.6884005069732666,
0.08073136955499649,
-0.04757778346538544,
0.37583157420158386,
-0.5733580589294434,
0.591015100479126,
-0.41138383746147156,
-0.19177210330963135,
-0.13494279980659485,
0.1809447705745697,
-0.3741419017314911,
0.6006266474723816,
0.1921243518590927,
0.4951895475387573,
0.36557435989379883,
-0.5305378437042236,
0.047008562833070755,
-0.325370192527771,
-0.39788174629211426,
0.03936213627457619,
-0.5236093997955322,
0.09169849008321762,
-0.030267735943198204,
0.23357924818992615,
-0.9096890687942505,
-0.06610982120037079,
0.34961095452308655,
-0.4354948401451111,
0.4074832797050476,
-0.33381763100624084,
-0.579533040523529,
-0.48733142018318176,
-0.4279368817806244,
0.3662140369415283,
0.7260448932647705,
-0.39107877016067505,
0.31196752190589905,
0.5674053430557251,
-0.20948854088783264,
-0.4991186559200287,
-0.5424273610115051,
-0.28325900435447693,
-0.33107030391693115,
-0.2930731177330017,
-0.015941092744469643,
0.08379437774419785,
-0.36414021253585815,
-0.30764007568359375,
-0.20472289621829987,
-0.04027075320482254,
0.2685277462005615,
0.18539470434188843,
0.19587303698062897,
0.05535510554909706,
-0.25411829352378845,
0.32814323902130127,
-0.010736658237874508,
0.05062597244977951,
-0.36337921023368835,
0.37972453236579895,
-0.16832803189754486,
-0.5418375730514526,
0.09781412780284882,
0.37335658073425293,
0.1972169131040573,
0.12991684675216675,
0.8512667417526245,
0.25697916746139526,
-0.1328115016222,
-0.4227946698665619,
-0.4998646378517151,
-0.40306395292282104,
-0.42969828844070435,
0.36062589287757874,
-0.30846714973449707,
-0.7801136374473572,
0.39239874482154846,
-0.08641064912080765,
0.0002235323772765696,
0.3315265476703644,
0.6003864407539368,
-0.2581758201122284,
1.1901522874832153,
0.331133097410202,
0.2310609370470047,
0.4123277962207794,
-0.2279897779226303,
0.352655827999115,
-0.5918939113616943,
-0.012909376062452793,
-0.20992591977119446,
-0.1335725635290146,
-0.7160004377365112,
-0.49025964736938477,
0.4958745539188385,
0.3661039173603058,
-0.16377907991409302,
0.16550393402576447,
0.030698947608470917,
0.5206947326660156,
0.7574321031570435,
0.011989112012088299,
0.1490202397108078,
-0.019306525588035583,
-0.5778462886810303,
0.14238029718399048,
-0.7167229056358337,
-0.26324015855789185,
0.8651635050773621,
0.4708210527896881,
0.7632583379745483,
-0.06096001714468002,
0.6743031144142151,
0.13775129616260529,
0.34864574670791626,
-0.5418223142623901,
0.4625700116157532,
-0.04216056317090988,
-0.3096774220466614,
-0.21409371495246887,
-0.6864480972290039,
-0.6582010388374329,
0.25975045561790466,
-0.15732364356517792,
-0.6629155874252319,
-0.15603479743003845,
0.19700157642364502,
-0.26759621500968933,
0.4813917279243469,
-0.7583197355270386,
0.6519241333007812,
-0.21676504611968994,
-0.31447556614875793,
-0.2368398755788803,
-0.8049998879432678,
0.6789810657501221,
0.19451069831848145,
0.30501967668533325,
-0.04285821691155434,
0.22236377000808716,
0.7372609376907349,
-0.1305503398180008,
0.7535367608070374,
-0.1464669406414032,
0.1515170931816101,
0.28885167837142944,
0.3893124461174011,
0.5329356789588928,
0.3306868076324463,
-0.013873164542019367,
0.03842337429523468,
0.1827542632818222,
-0.3392157554626465,
-0.6466054320335388,
0.48658469319343567,
-0.45064952969551086,
-0.5165509581565857,
-0.6241205930709839,
-0.6323966383934021,
-0.4640062153339386,
0.15889625251293182,
-0.03189005330204964,
0.12264023721218109,
-0.02998908795416355,
-0.1080792024731636,
0.6457566022872925,
-0.4995878338813782,
0.33820173144340515,
0.25714969635009766,
-0.1094290018081665,
-0.5171073079109192,
0.8580694198608398,
-0.32903653383255005,
0.43217733502388,
0.2626091539859772,
0.36642786860466003,
-0.5500890612602234,
-0.7212684154510498,
-0.21723708510398865,
0.5100556015968323,
-0.29925569891929626,
-0.05194837599992752,
-0.5488981008529663,
-0.284258633852005,
-0.6088014841079712,
-0.2832450866699219,
-0.3537047803401947,
-0.6634481549263,
-0.05007040873169899,
-0.044552966952323914,
0.07525154948234558,
0.6838119029998779,
-0.0558936707675457,
0.2827303111553192,
-0.505848228931427,
0.3139406740665436,
0.015823232010006905,
0.276089072227478,
-0.23998136818408966,
-0.6037362813949585,
0.08196468651294708,
0.25833332538604736,
-0.18461982905864716,
-0.8862601518630981,
0.7003264427185059,
0.014237225987017155,
0.7205495238304138,
0.29210370779037476,
0.2789604663848877,
0.21869364380836487,
-0.5024820566177368,
0.7259777188301086,
0.29294347763061523,
-0.5382887125015259,
0.3117201626300812,
-0.19650186598300934,
0.28645235300064087,
0.4549351632595062,
0.5215844511985779,
-0.5582630038261414,
-0.6438544392585754,
-1.0052653551101685,
-0.9441431164741516,
0.5192920565605164,
0.23199862241744995,
-0.29840272665023804,
-0.28434598445892334,
0.09046884626150131,
0.04787527024745941,
0.31475257873535156,
-0.7120412588119507,
-0.07377195358276367,
0.004234773572534323,
-0.4948360323905945,
-0.1841537356376648,
-0.32684609293937683,
-0.05543358623981476,
0.08823680877685547,
0.807990550994873,
-0.3688226044178009,
0.18618449568748474,
-0.08368951827287674,
-0.3970711827278137,
0.2987648844718933,
0.2722966969013214,
0.7408353090286255,
0.3215264081954956,
-0.06965964287519455,
0.3830631375312805,
0.331561803817749,
-0.3499687910079956,
-0.1306706815958023,
-0.0632862001657486,
0.0053935362957417965,
-0.30906498432159424,
0.363285630941391,
0.5716209411621094,
0.32520997524261475,
-0.904639720916748,
0.4343799352645874,
0.051240336149930954,
-0.20770740509033203,
-0.30739372968673706,
0.10390022397041321,
0.18492087721824646,
0.4625379741191864,
0.22302363812923431,
-0.19690386950969696,
0.3189268410205841,
-0.3943333327770233,
0.32401371002197266,
0.617912232875824,
-0.37561851739883423,
-0.21775852143764496,
0.37035977840423584,
0.059943798929452896,
-0.30808061361312866,
0.7595447897911072,
-0.3900538384914398,
-0.7659848928451538,
0.6356038451194763,
0.3480202555656433,
0.9506651163101196,
-0.061706993728876114,
0.37919512391090393,
0.22046193480491638,
0.14689773321151733,
-0.26327887177467346,
0.16953547298908234,
-0.2267545759677887,
-0.4772833287715912,
-0.46998241543769836,
-0.5272911787033081,
-0.5074793100357056,
-0.13705472648143768,
-0.3787773847579956,
-0.031100228428840637,
-0.3399921953678131,
0.1449161171913147,
-0.4557989537715912,
0.0767630785703659,
-0.16674421727657318,
0.010379972867667675,
0.29364463686943054,
0.7592716217041016,
-0.8328694701194763,
0.9613482356071472,
0.33480650186538696,
-0.17003020644187927,
-0.5951163172721863,
0.12927182018756866,
0.20045052468776703,
-0.5428367853164673,
0.5609103441238403,
-0.02220027521252632,
-0.40187546610832214,
-0.16028358042240143,
-0.5210818648338318,
-0.3548892140388489,
0.5817186236381531,
0.10653501003980637,
-0.42160454392433167,
-0.07109612971544266,
0.10137991607189178,
0.41074320673942566,
-0.25003549456596375,
0.708397626876831,
0.7334058880805969,
0.09407594799995422,
0.3232739567756653,
-0.5974025726318359,
-0.21926657855510712,
-0.0007917530601844192,
0.2004270851612091,
0.15207692980766296,
-0.14375635981559753,
0.5876097083091736,
-0.5952614545822144,
-0.28462377190589905,
0.005056720692664385,
1.026623010635376,
0.7241565585136414,
0.06969806551933289,
0.8956946730613708,
0.2159692645072937,
0.5640696287155151,
0.13353854417800903,
1.0040966272354126,
0.09474387019872665,
0.4663017988204956,
1.2282958030700684,
-0.25528809428215027,
0.7988791465759277,
0.7084848284721375,
-0.32008346915245056,
0.4466856122016907,
0.556601345539093,
0.35178443789482117,
0.7094770669937134,
0.5356954336166382,
-0.38649752736091614,
-0.15405291318893433,
0.4108635485172272,
0.0740913599729538,
-0.16900159418582916,
0.4961931109428406,
-0.22461794316768646,
-0.1514386683702469,
-0.0840291976928711,
-0.12641529738903046,
-0.06460706889629364,
-0.09533287584781647,
0.6231139898300171,
0.2477574199438095,
-0.8130505681037903,
0.23834532499313354,
-0.005037115886807442,
0.8399849534034729,
-0.4390047490596771,
0.06445818394422531,
-0.349147766828537,
0.44685888290405273,
-0.03241832181811333,
-1.1524958610534668,
0.41373851895332336,
-0.2085089087486267,
0.16122737526893616,
-0.28852391242980957,
0.5240886807441711,
-0.6373834013938904,
-0.6094462275505066,
0.009570706635713577,
0.10012173652648926,
0.27488094568252563,
-0.07928143441677094,
-0.7722721099853516,
-0.2732708752155304,
-0.0858822613954544,
-0.3860626220703125,
0.4061579406261444,
0.17040567100048065,
-0.1030116006731987,
0.8585362434387207,
0.5299957990646362,
0.25790321826934814,
0.11015529185533524,
0.2747054100036621,
0.5879406332969666,
-0.43192726373672485,
-0.5611762404441833,
-0.6066970229148865,
0.6346282958984375,
0.04889450594782829,
-0.18324244022369385,
0.4431191682815552,
0.16183696687221527,
0.8393718004226685,
-0.3424929678440094,
0.5140019655227661,
0.10315779596567154,
0.7212081551551819,
-0.6097452044487,
0.6127064228057861,
-0.3708416819572449,
0.30038982629776,
-0.2105918824672699,
-0.42297986149787903,
-0.2354739010334015,
0.7876337766647339,
-0.43230655789375305,
0.21216937899589539,
0.7484626173973083,
0.8945546746253967,
-0.15696096420288086,
0.060243792831897736,
0.35409945249557495,
0.2385072261095047,
0.24129532277584076,
0.6151463985443115,
0.8171985149383545,
-0.24332323670387268,
0.25761741399765015,
-0.5750344395637512,
-0.291361927986145,
-0.20194758474826813,
-1.0419151782989502,
-1.0438296794891357,
-0.8035265207290649,
-0.4782217741012573,
-0.6050248742103577,
0.23544815182685852,
1.0020891427993774,
0.5600611567497253,
-1.0862153768539429,
-0.3410661816596985,
-0.15705889463424683,
0.6426897048950195,
-0.5204245448112488,
-0.25552257895469666,
0.08204963058233261,
-0.36225077509880066,
-0.6837106347084045,
0.36090824007987976,
0.24011941254138947,
-0.132438063621521,
-0.3873249888420105,
-0.052756182849407196,
-0.5532618165016174,
0.011073360219597816,
0.49384453892707825,
0.4872702360153198,
-0.6909696459770203,
-0.24630802869796753,
-0.11067120730876923,
0.030163822695612907,
-0.22774295508861542,
1.0895860195159912,
-1.025447130203247,
0.09006791561841965,
0.6779093742370605,
0.41123199462890625,
0.5151490569114685,
-0.19863541424274445,
0.7531576752662659,
-0.6858377456665039,
0.2610572874546051,
0.5341109037399292,
0.16194042563438416,
0.13456985354423523,
-0.13848243653774261,
0.4497944414615631,
0.23876048624515533,
-0.41842880845069885,
-1.0988354682922363,
0.3640284240245819,
-0.7599977254867554,
-0.4738980233669281,
1.3445667028427124,
-0.17751342058181763,
-0.4376949667930603,
-0.2511744499206543,
0.09549202769994736,
0.33619433641433716,
-0.08240660279989243,
0.5161812901496887,
0.2895616888999939,
-0.10541322082281113,
-0.40499264001846313,
-0.557166337966919,
0.4789907932281494,
0.45955708622932434,
-0.7306228876113892,
-0.023804359138011932,
0.11763908714056015,
0.31668582558631897,
-0.3547934889793396,
0.31085023283958435,
-0.0624377615749836,
0.15036118030548096,
0.040583860129117966,
-0.10632932931184769,
0.13552019000053406,
-0.5472108721733093,
-0.49124062061309814,
0.056273095309734344,
-0.010400352999567986,
0.21753932535648346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01581v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01581v1
|
The Mercurial Top-Level Ontology of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-26T16:52:32 | 2024-04-26T16:52:32 |
Nele Köhler, Fabian Neuhaus
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In our work, we systematize and analyze implicit ontological commitments in
the responses generated by large language models (LLMs), focusing on ChatGPT
3.5 as a case study. We investigate how LLMs, despite having no explicit
ontology, exhibit implicit ontological categorizations that are reflected in
the texts they generate. The paper proposes an approach to understanding the
ontological commitments of LLMs by defining ontology as a theory that provides
a systematic account of the ontological commitments of some text. We
investigate the ontological assumptions of ChatGPT and present a systematized
account, i.e., GPT's top-level ontology. This includes a taxonomy, which is
available as an OWL file, as well as a discussion about ontological assumptions
(e.g., about its mereology or presentism). We show that in some aspects GPT's
top-level ontology is quite similar to existing top-level ontologies. However,
there are significant challenges arising from the flexible nature of
LLM-generated texts, including ontological overload, ambiguity, and
inconsistency.
|
[
-0.19947975873947144,
-0.6051746606826782,
0.8489502668380737,
-0.14408919215202332,
0.25768303871154785,
-0.1368415355682373,
-0.17679817974567413,
-0.4479454755783081,
-0.15256141126155853,
0.8632276654243469,
-0.8179740905761719,
-0.3889084756374359,
-0.8869835138320923,
-0.00361993326805532,
-0.3867532014846802,
1.4395473003387451,
0.002038425300270319,
-0.5001640915870667,
-0.02020964026451111,
0.054384224116802216,
-0.44920650124549866,
-0.601007878780365,
-0.5403842926025391,
-0.571416974067688,
0.6723862290382385,
0.1513054519891739,
1.03449285030365,
0.7168582677841187,
0.7895025014877319,
0.20639349520206451,
-0.43279334902763367,
-0.258909672498703,
-0.6646108627319336,
0.3594016134738922,
-0.33075666427612305,
-0.5362275838851929,
-0.6643486022949219,
0.1853175312280655,
0.6048869490623474,
0.42768821120262146,
-0.3851913511753082,
0.25592100620269775,
0.16868585348129272,
0.25628533959388733,
-0.28994691371917725,
0.61093670129776,
-0.8156389594078064,
0.06268961727619171,
-0.06770859658718109,
-0.1330304592847824,
-0.38594308495521545,
-0.03448353707790375,
0.48202386498451233,
-0.9224659204483032,
0.0071876500733196735,
0.2131800800561905,
0.7771117091178894,
0.3722158670425415,
-0.3255656361579895,
-0.4905540645122528,
-0.6175796389579773,
0.5420406460762024,
-0.606079638004303,
0.1648101806640625,
0.4401940703392029,
0.36974725127220154,
-0.1571505218744278,
-0.4995318055152893,
-0.6706032752990723,
-0.36132901906967163,
-0.4275320768356323,
0.17463117837905884,
-0.3260805904865265,
0.09417278319597244,
0.36480817198753357,
0.5634462237358093,
-0.7921274900436401,
0.05276324227452278,
0.034988436847925186,
-0.15644575655460358,
0.40448570251464844,
0.19298958778381348,
0.39147287607192993,
-0.22816933691501617,
-0.30551958084106445,
0.18436110019683838,
-0.8149674534797668,
-0.48911210894584656,
0.05717040225863457,
0.3467547595500946,
-0.17040176689624786,
0.6383779048919678,
0.2064732015132904,
0.11872131377458572,
0.007530185393989086,
0.13108199834823608,
-0.20023296773433685,
-0.006661008112132549,
-0.20861005783081055,
0.22657498717308044,
0.5956259965896606,
-0.03455410152673721,
0.37353554368019104,
-0.17753373086452484,
-0.0651453286409378,
0.26796090602874756,
0.2707103192806244,
-0.3657171130180359,
0.26690706610679626,
0.5105053782463074,
-0.19904814660549164,
-0.34930068254470825,
-0.1427401751279831,
-0.12182468175888062,
-0.48221078515052795,
-0.3273300528526306,
0.34741079807281494,
-0.20443375408649445,
-0.26434165239334106,
0.0033219808246940374,
0.17146730422973633,
0.4981045424938202,
0.42252251505851746,
-1.0451340675354004,
0.268785297870636,
1.142835021018982,
0.6751249432563782,
0.07234878093004227,
-0.3368804156780243,
-0.10050033032894135,
0.8892796039581299,
-0.31365400552749634,
0.8266015648841858,
-0.5251917839050293,
-0.2757665812969208,
0.1264306902885437,
0.04582306370139122,
0.149284228682518,
-0.028832776471972466,
0.702602744102478,
-0.4119836390018463,
0.23888935148715973,
-0.35024160146713257,
-0.7127631902694702,
-0.12389805912971497,
0.8321278691291809,
-0.32932937145233154,
0.9311074614524841,
-0.08201993256807327,
-0.7046892642974854,
0.3456554710865021,
-0.7948065400123596,
0.2208060473203659,
0.39302268624305725,
-0.2930993139743805,
0.10536488890647888,
-0.047177042812108994,
-0.3497695326805115,
0.5486031174659729,
-0.5862099528312683,
0.3851728141307831,
-0.3046632409095764,
-0.017830461263656616,
0.21016190946102142,
-0.2616559565067291,
0.6502849459648132,
0.12412314116954803,
-0.16866911947727203,
0.04427045211195946,
-0.42727550864219666,
-0.05557336285710335,
-0.008459349162876606,
-0.3410774767398834,
-0.3625412881374359,
0.188261017203331,
-0.038860827684402466,
0.20684927701950073,
0.41320690512657166,
-0.59461510181427,
0.8606772422790527,
-0.2564104497432709,
0.7099419236183167,
0.8108914494514465,
-0.2857249081134796,
0.19568617641925812,
-0.10821660608053207,
0.20895442366600037,
-0.3692491352558136,
0.31344571709632874,
-0.1100820004940033,
-0.5733337998390198,
-0.720676064491272,
0.15121853351593018,
0.11553546041250229,
0.7197474241256714,
-0.16636067628860474,
0.29475143551826477,
-0.4407951235771179,
-0.3793184757232666,
-0.09783903509378433,
-0.15380427241325378,
0.5054699182510376,
0.1061381995677948,
0.21457113325595856,
0.07308021187782288,
-0.2581631541252136,
-0.8791339993476868,
-0.08359941840171814,
-0.7417518496513367,
0.0753895714879036,
0.22430479526519775,
0.6474604606628418,
-0.557546079158783,
0.821677565574646,
-0.541226327419281,
-0.4524185061454773,
0.06110990047454834,
0.29364970326423645,
0.13523228466510773,
0.43752747774124146,
0.19332905113697052,
-0.6950744390487671,
-0.21052388846874237,
0.5193349719047546,
-0.8791497945785522,
-0.21738694608211517,
0.04131067916750908,
-0.3841617703437805,
0.2396319955587387,
0.5746139883995056,
-0.9359427094459534,
0.3592429459095001,
0.6251451969146729,
-0.6755892038345337,
0.30577871203422546,
-0.46084344387054443,
-0.19460077583789825,
-1.1163216829299927,
-0.1734762340784073,
-0.32781529426574707,
-0.12226846069097519,
-0.7376487255096436,
0.28853297233581543,
-0.10079111903905869,
0.03175656870007515,
-0.30616894364356995,
0.47784778475761414,
-0.36401042342185974,
-0.12031855434179306,
-0.2522568106651306,
0.260036826133728,
-0.2076987773180008,
0.3293987214565277,
0.06336257606744766,
0.24210228025913239,
0.5760650634765625,
-0.34234559535980225,
0.24985520541667938,
0.7219660878181458,
0.2937973141670227,
0.5300257205963135,
-0.709739625453949,
0.03805585950613022,
-0.13737347722053528,
0.5505304932594299,
-0.8887020349502563,
-0.34048694372177124,
0.3878100514411926,
-0.3298284113407135,
0.2413455694913864,
-0.4662107825279236,
-0.7454084157943726,
-0.14329172670841217,
0.15741409361362457,
0.3220573961734772,
0.6265162825584412,
-0.10556793212890625,
0.5043076872825623,
0.4374845325946808,
-0.22468453645706177,
-0.5023400783538818,
-0.8720434308052063,
0.158190056681633,
0.013712571002542973,
-0.5235587954521179,
0.3298763930797577,
0.10706055164337158,
-0.3782497048377991,
0.17067381739616394,
-0.07056409865617752,
-0.04497639089822769,
-0.2042800486087799,
0.3289829194545746,
0.3191182017326355,
-0.45550498366355896,
0.4054670035839081,
-0.14183424413204193,
-0.38251540064811707,
0.1007254347205162,
-0.6874673962593079,
0.3625757694244385,
-0.306574285030365,
-0.3891495168209076,
-0.21025969088077545,
0.36425426602363586,
0.5176618695259094,
0.2471141517162323,
0.7968053817749023,
0.45809406042099,
-0.3053046464920044,
-0.06913135200738907,
-0.3365604281425476,
0.1273767650127411,
-0.425709068775177,
0.03670158237218857,
-0.327458918094635,
-1.1266087293624878,
0.5847383141517639,
0.42918556928634644,
0.4232301712036133,
0.7486337423324585,
0.8614426851272583,
-0.05540933087468147,
0.7654602527618408,
0.6744503974914551,
0.21936291456222534,
0.010817482136189938,
-0.08579760789871216,
-0.06822879612445831,
-0.6798785328865051,
-0.0630989670753479,
-0.6074049472808838,
0.26616084575653076,
-1.2118735313415527,
-0.2579602599143982,
0.24189704656600952,
-0.19900032877922058,
-0.7241634130477905,
0.414760559797287,
-0.4257259666919708,
0.40556126832962036,
0.19313226640224457,
-0.3040992021560669,
0.6304110288619995,
-0.27103322744369507,
0.32355979084968567,
0.3084234297275543,
-0.6060582399368286,
-0.9902133941650391,
0.874424934387207,
0.4446081519126892,
0.7351586818695068,
0.5729608535766602,
0.22144070267677307,
0.39538002014160156,
0.5726704597473145,
-0.8154000043869019,
0.4206877052783966,
-0.1804792881011963,
-1.0379291772842407,
-0.4582746624946594,
-0.3027104437351227,
-1.048874855041504,
0.4796285629272461,
-0.1772271692752838,
-0.8126096725463867,
-0.009450293146073818,
0.23469464480876923,
-0.11239904165267944,
0.163456529378891,
-0.2866518497467041,
0.8187004327774048,
0.07918451726436615,
-0.08093511313199997,
-0.0313337966799736,
-0.5368251204490662,
0.32979097962379456,
-0.19891148805618286,
0.23460476100444794,
-0.487093061208725,
-0.48308950662612915,
0.5096579194068909,
-0.4909304976463318,
1.0328603982925415,
0.20704129338264465,
-0.9435966610908508,
0.392092764377594,
0.2607021927833557,
0.7090645432472229,
0.056072816252708435,
0.06230474263429642,
0.29145142436027527,
0.32940778136253357,
-0.45064759254455566,
-0.6281639337539673,
0.5944893956184387,
-0.8814715147018433,
-0.95381098985672,
-0.6653228402137756,
-0.8036378026008606,
-0.325051486492157,
0.29366597533226013,
0.1401749551296234,
0.46487200260162354,
-0.2747614085674286,
-0.10908528417348862,
0.7929118871688843,
-0.29085904359817505,
0.08225183188915253,
0.5525886416435242,
-0.4480894207954407,
0.3190053403377533,
0.6262645721435547,
0.20240671932697296,
0.5954060554504395,
0.4718344807624817,
0.3912372291088104,
-0.24628138542175293,
-0.3467279076576233,
-0.23043932020664215,
0.17032498121261597,
-0.7612738609313965,
0.2284982055425644,
-0.6961252093315125,
-0.24074651300907135,
-0.5423855185508728,
-0.07053902000188828,
-0.18571706116199493,
-0.4122101068496704,
-0.024655096232891083,
0.16375401616096497,
0.5392525792121887,
1.1021403074264526,
0.11245058476924896,
0.679923951625824,
-0.9365391135215759,
0.15549764037132263,
0.3103886544704437,
0.2622675597667694,
-0.3685961365699768,
-0.8835923671722412,
0.06841076910495758,
-0.15133392810821533,
-0.2962315082550049,
-0.56132972240448,
0.06770607829093933,
0.08689630776643753,
0.6087557673454285,
0.37876608967781067,
-0.038425274193286896,
0.312957763671875,
-0.6011381149291992,
0.6852088570594788,
0.0012521034805104136,
-1.057937741279602,
0.41341710090637207,
-1.1119903326034546,
0.16819991171360016,
0.16876614093780518,
0.4053431749343872,
-0.9195534586906433,
-0.7881606817245483,
-0.7972611784934998,
-0.5982756614685059,
0.6827757358551025,
0.50282222032547,
0.48613548278808594,
0.23373611271381378,
0.4420503079891205,
0.2850106358528137,
0.04449816793203354,
-0.9069942235946655,
-0.218670055270195,
-0.05502794682979584,
-0.05229140445590019,
-0.062420401722192764,
-0.19466018676757812,
-0.02989036589860916,
0.2968759536743164,
0.6377218961715698,
-0.07719451189041138,
0.1630275696516037,
0.054572995752096176,
0.017584674060344696,
0.009648778475821018,
0.6803575158119202,
0.45209571719169617,
0.5501876473426819,
-0.08162613213062286,
0.28866147994995117,
0.11225580424070358,
-0.6243737936019897,
0.11468887329101562,
-0.23910531401634216,
-0.2534107565879822,
-0.3962843418121338,
0.6944955587387085,
0.557437539100647,
0.1767633557319641,
-0.30462563037872314,
0.3758038878440857,
0.27148106694221497,
-0.16617906093597412,
-0.3842977285385132,
-0.034821294248104095,
0.12438210099935532,
0.21578139066696167,
0.2372375875711441,
-0.31400424242019653,
-0.11079171299934387,
-0.9349653124809265,
0.09971723705530167,
0.24128513038158417,
-0.6167126893997192,
-0.36558419466018677,
0.5125401616096497,
-0.09356952458620071,
0.08933150768280029,
0.19195587933063507,
-0.16139404475688934,
-0.7319530248641968,
0.35562023520469666,
0.4888105094432831,
0.8613492846488953,
-0.039980050176382065,
0.390613853931427,
0.04404640570282936,
0.6507043838500977,
-0.22459350526332855,
0.12461356073617935,
0.18162263929843903,
-0.8569747805595398,
-0.6811484694480896,
-0.5699965357780457,
-0.6866766810417175,
-0.06553991883993149,
-0.47920843958854675,
0.09543325752019882,
-0.30344879627227783,
-0.11890069395303726,
0.07671022415161133,
-0.2588500678539276,
-0.16410724818706512,
-0.09427733719348907,
0.365181028842926,
0.6501383781433105,
-0.5603431463241577,
0.7030455470085144,
0.5948256850242615,
-0.52527916431427,
-0.8795070648193359,
0.43310806155204773,
0.18984326720237732,
-1.0430591106414795,
0.9852154850959778,
-0.231770321726799,
-0.04858987405896187,
0.06229599565267563,
-0.6103116869926453,
-1.0347312688827515,
0.8390805721282959,
0.4483316242694855,
-0.28206995129585266,
-0.2186129093170166,
0.5084938406944275,
0.646539568901062,
-0.28226423263549805,
0.2462274432182312,
0.47013649344444275,
0.9238259792327881,
0.15335950255393982,
-1.0790663957595825,
0.2696998417377472,
0.02263627015054226,
0.004541211295872927,
0.35828152298927307,
-0.8717846870422363,
1.1993894577026367,
0.025070970878005028,
-0.31625962257385254,
-0.009581604972481728,
0.4405854046344757,
0.13090260326862335,
-0.15804581344127655,
0.10176106542348862,
0.42310595512390137,
0.43076029419898987,
-0.18587343394756317,
1.1531085968017578,
0.049346987158060074,
0.7764480113983154,
0.9387162327766418,
-0.3493794798851013,
0.6194608807563782,
0.30470097064971924,
-0.3804318308830261,
0.40516719222068787,
0.774260938167572,
-0.08399718254804611,
-0.01721397042274475,
0.4286249577999115,
0.030264997854828835,
-0.3285219073295593,
-0.3083634078502655,
-0.5369667410850525,
0.5510663986206055,
0.5684733986854553,
-0.10522514581680298,
-0.4815220236778259,
-0.21524906158447266,
0.007533898111432791,
-0.38096708059310913,
-0.663033664226532,
0.9559006690979004,
0.18284715712070465,
-0.5191018581390381,
0.5482044219970703,
-0.36864349246025085,
0.43558892607688904,
-0.46391645073890686,
-0.06296445429325104,
0.07047002017498016,
0.041361041367053986,
-0.31866690516471863,
-1.095031499862671,
0.3568119406700134,
0.11260061711072922,
-0.2757473886013031,
-0.43055158853530884,
0.5525187849998474,
-0.32236725091934204,
-0.5231518745422363,
0.19016915559768677,
0.5952849984169006,
0.5018064379692078,
-0.030441638082265854,
-0.6365498900413513,
-0.015489417128264904,
-0.3491547703742981,
-0.5911446213722229,
0.1419421136379242,
0.9447702765464783,
-0.2894350588321686,
0.6538230776786804,
0.44302839040756226,
0.03444397822022438,
-0.08230214565992355,
-0.3018302321434021,
0.58121258020401,
-0.701988935470581,
-0.4406873881816864,
-0.9516572952270508,
0.04167162999510765,
0.35020485520362854,
-0.42519450187683105,
0.6054286360740662,
0.17007796466350555,
0.5919788479804993,
0.21328851580619812,
0.9786202311515808,
-0.33423537015914917,
0.40107011795043945,
-0.5572847127914429,
0.9213191866874695,
-0.5583122372627258,
0.5140633583068848,
-0.3242779076099396,
-0.892639696598053,
-0.31949272751808167,
0.22618767619132996,
-0.5260373950004578,
-0.1880967617034912,
0.6172848343849182,
0.5135203003883362,
-0.06054651737213135,
0.3070867955684662,
0.5062296986579895,
0.5238414406776428,
0.02223747782409191,
0.5379459857940674,
1.2426576614379883,
-0.2936576306819916,
0.8449966311454773,
0.5415970087051392,
-0.142802894115448,
-0.1428663581609726,
-0.9773105978965759,
-0.6543202996253967,
-0.5887934565544128,
-0.16097883880138397,
-0.3505013883113861,
-0.18680274486541748,
0.7495055198669434,
0.4510079026222229,
-0.7388779520988464,
-0.19814489781856537,
-0.24053578078746796,
-0.0554625429213047,
0.3163554072380066,
-0.1471293568611145,
0.45729658007621765,
-0.3269284963607788,
-0.5194656252861023,
-0.17805929481983185,
0.2572418451309204,
0.1867947280406952,
-0.50593501329422,
0.05226327106356621,
0.06587696820497513,
0.27132388949394226,
0.8779773116111755,
0.13176937401294708,
-1.055026650428772,
-0.7556176781654358,
-0.17462390661239624,
-0.42123129963874817,
-0.003398813772946596,
0.8502539992332458,
-0.2777755558490753,
-0.3342442810535431,
0.35622528195381165,
0.3919907808303833,
0.3594965636730194,
-0.20852972567081451,
0.5930044651031494,
-0.2622085511684418,
-0.10703703761100769,
-0.09023851901292801,
0.23512274026870728,
-0.1396346092224121,
-0.43831735849380493,
0.6887864470481873,
0.10346569865942001,
-0.5828049182891846,
-0.8128107786178589,
0.5011734962463379,
-1.0859057903289795,
-0.2470589280128479,
1.2538710832595825,
-0.25674453377723694,
-0.1894780397415161,
-0.3947673439979553,
-0.27032169699668884,
0.2855745255947113,
-0.3718370199203491,
0.4447013735771179,
0.8831506371498108,
-0.2902897000312805,
0.010417834855616093,
-0.9727001786231995,
0.37600839138031006,
0.18174166977405548,
-0.9645254611968994,
0.6652156710624695,
0.4832403361797333,
0.08255591988563538,
0.4887474775314331,
0.5139870047569275,
-0.19606202840805054,
-0.07618578523397446,
0.051459237933158875,
0.09117691963911057,
0.25983285903930664,
0.07789792865514755,
0.06104966998100281,
0.2352694272994995,
0.010007133707404137,
0.4279250502586365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17525v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17525v2
|
Large Language Model Agent as a Mechanical Designer
| 2024-04-26T16:41:24 | 2024-05-09T15:31:08 |
Yayati Jadhav, Amir Barati Farimani
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Conventional mechanical design paradigms rely on experts systematically
refining concepts through experience-guided modification and FEA to meet
specific requirements. However, this approach can be time-consuming and heavily
dependent on prior knowledge and experience. While numerous machine learning
models have been developed to streamline this intensive and expert-driven
iterative process, these methods typically demand extensive training data and
considerable computational resources. Furthermore, methods based on deep
learning are usually restricted to the specific domains and tasks for which
they were trained, limiting their applicability across different tasks. This
creates a trade-off between the efficiency of automation and the demand for
resources. In this study, we present a novel approach that integrates
pre-trained LLMs with a FEM module. The FEM module evaluates each design and
provides essential feedback, guiding the LLMs to continuously learn, plan,
generate, and optimize designs without the need for domain-specific training.
We demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed framework in managing the
iterative optimization of truss structures, showcasing its capability to reason
about and refine designs according to structured feedback and criteria. Our
results reveal that these LLM-based agents can successfully generate truss
designs that comply with natural language specifications with a success rate of
up to 90%, which varies according to the applied constraints. By employing
prompt-based optimization techniques we show that LLM based agents exhibit
optimization behavior when provided with solution-score pairs to iteratively
refine designs to meet specifications. This ability of LLM agents to produce
viable designs and optimize them based on their inherent reasoning capabilities
highlights their potential to develop and implement effective design strategies
autonomously.
|
[
-0.48019498586654663,
-0.6913563013076782,
0.6293752789497375,
0.3080861270427704,
-0.17398639023303986,
0.3869498372077942,
-0.25824469327926636,
-0.39880135655403137,
0.26204290986061096,
0.34951451420783997,
-0.7766652703285217,
-0.4186936616897583,
0.049522764980793,
0.24546627700328827,
-0.0100370142608881,
0.45070916414260864,
-0.5070090293884277,
0.02280476689338684,
-0.13384723663330078,
0.22790519893169403,
-0.3208252489566803,
-0.20863157510757446,
-0.5555120706558228,
-0.5117856860160828,
0.5331147313117981,
0.18955212831497192,
0.5814825892448425,
0.6869257688522339,
0.3403596580028534,
0.4406804144382477,
0.010215352289378643,
0.3800254166126251,
-0.22625137865543365,
-0.03386387228965759,
-0.39207756519317627,
-0.2843823730945587,
-0.5444799661636353,
0.06521998345851898,
0.40801453590393066,
0.7136515378952026,
-0.08424870669841766,
0.09808332473039627,
0.31881406903266907,
0.7594225406646729,
-0.34772270917892456,
0.3594345152378082,
-0.49341514706611633,
0.3493503928184509,
0.17561480402946472,
-0.7784693241119385,
-0.41748321056365967,
-0.29891324043273926,
-0.2090369462966919,
-0.6970291137695312,
-0.2581164836883545,
0.01845143735408783,
0.756489634513855,
0.7120559215545654,
-0.28181126713752747,
-0.356173038482666,
-0.7310196757316589,
0.5860405564308167,
-0.6359717845916748,
0.517979085445404,
0.22064082324504852,
0.24749472737312317,
-0.6526440382003784,
-0.38827693462371826,
-0.2526296079158783,
-0.6457152962684631,
-0.19525693356990814,
-0.007315655238926411,
0.3212776780128479,
0.46492910385131836,
0.14988377690315247,
0.09830667078495026,
-0.691058337688446,
0.5172466039657593,
-0.40559548139572144,
-0.24058586359024048,
0.8131073713302612,
0.22049513459205627,
0.187360480427742,
-0.0801563635468483,
-0.6363798975944519,
0.058934181928634644,
-0.4210236072540283,
0.1383543610572815,
0.3285137712955475,
0.5376441478729248,
-0.03017430007457733,
0.5330666303634644,
-0.1446213573217392,
0.5445349812507629,
0.004084829241037369,
-0.27416500449180603,
0.3457470238208771,
-0.003121781162917614,
-0.3297784924507141,
-0.38824349641799927,
0.8166890740394592,
-0.07742835581302643,
0.22498148679733276,
-0.48600849509239197,
-0.6477293968200684,
-0.03534174710512161,
0.5520350933074951,
-0.682178258895874,
0.06629938632249832,
0.33858320116996765,
-0.31870344281196594,
-0.39703693985939026,
-0.20913898944854736,
-0.3679753839969635,
-0.3979880213737488,
-1.0104378461837769,
0.47959059476852417,
-0.02059316448867321,
-0.2904517352581024,
0.32460328936576843,
0.005293798167258501,
0.3074912130832672,
0.177656352519989,
-0.5984668135643005,
0.03266874700784683,
0.51569664478302,
0.6966838836669922,
-0.1399158090353012,
-0.20371392369270325,
-0.4747462868690491,
0.18445993959903717,
-0.71596360206604,
0.7348287105560303,
-0.3417479395866394,
-0.3620362877845764,
-0.09654729813337326,
0.06959908455610275,
-0.04705299809575081,
-0.5260143876075745,
0.3335339426994324,
-0.6201704740524292,
-0.12929391860961914,
0.2642151713371277,
-0.43353843688964844,
-0.11647829413414001,
0.3319705128669739,
-0.7104161977767944,
0.7552467584609985,
0.40487733483314514,
-0.28147491812705994,
0.25206661224365234,
-0.6647799611091614,
-0.7030448913574219,
0.12703937292099,
-0.47368907928466797,
-0.4557492733001709,
0.1976112276315689,
-0.055683963000774384,
0.6534680128097534,
-0.5027593374252319,
0.38310912251472473,
-0.5201587080955505,
-0.2821066379547119,
0.06797613948583603,
0.026089143007993698,
0.41615620255470276,
0.340056836605072,
-0.46579650044441223,
0.37500977516174316,
-0.7623541951179504,
0.31170180439949036,
-0.055429499596357346,
-0.7924045920372009,
0.1757175773382187,
-0.09246748685836792,
-0.14568479359149933,
0.24750125408172607,
0.16691245138645172,
-0.1471179872751236,
0.2499319463968277,
-0.6602140069007874,
0.20145782828330994,
1.167358636856079,
-0.18023228645324707,
0.7878463268280029,
-0.5106269121170044,
0.882390022277832,
-0.5200251340866089,
0.06626186519861221,
0.1915418952703476,
0.23978552222251892,
-0.7568238973617554,
-0.21923774480819702,
-0.0722179263830185,
0.4098113179206848,
-0.9841789603233337,
0.3959580957889557,
0.2609417140483856,
-0.4576551616191864,
-0.2497967779636383,
0.4844141900539398,
0.13031284511089325,
0.2223406285047531,
0.1068354919552803,
-0.1276153326034546,
-0.682788610458374,
-0.6992547512054443,
-0.058373477309942245,
0.03860234096646309,
-0.16903993487358093,
0.4399377107620239,
0.4975815415382385,
-0.38001254200935364,
0.9772610664367676,
-0.41587159037590027,
-0.37977415323257446,
-0.16294918954372406,
0.06510709971189499,
0.5389536023139954,
0.6060413122177124,
0.7836755514144897,
-0.5738236308097839,
-0.4297749996185303,
0.25094836950302124,
-1.0116339921951294,
-0.1762995570898056,
-0.5005574822425842,
-0.29120320081710815,
0.27176424860954285,
0.529809832572937,
-0.7023178339004517,
0.3016250431537628,
0.16044391691684723,
-0.06002803146839142,
0.6538451313972473,
-0.24617215991020203,
-0.26287761330604553,
-1.1710149049758911,
0.12335827201604843,
-0.028056807816028595,
0.011997920460999012,
-0.26392754912376404,
0.29270923137664795,
-0.05715450644493103,
-0.16428738832473755,
-0.5025212168693542,
0.8001798987388611,
-0.9670764803886414,
-0.20562744140625,
-0.46232056617736816,
0.011991194449365139,
-0.03594522923231125,
0.8898188471794128,
0.008409004658460617,
0.5720793604850769,
0.5300320386886597,
-0.8912392258644104,
0.6334655284881592,
-0.028981627896428108,
-0.3395078182220459,
0.3874173164367676,
-0.76622074842453,
0.2876397967338562,
-0.3287191390991211,
0.008044128306210041,
-0.6797389984130859,
-0.23940184712409973,
0.36214616894721985,
-0.34845107793807983,
0.5292534828186035,
0.10679136961698532,
-0.37151259183883667,
-0.7608661651611328,
-0.48752322793006897,
-0.1399007886648178,
0.11015891283750534,
-0.559085488319397,
1.1118048429489136,
0.2214602380990982,
-0.16307362914085388,
-0.5588165521621704,
-0.4731638431549072,
-0.1691836416721344,
0.04204520583152771,
-0.7190791964530945,
0.392914354801178,
-0.46097514033317566,
-0.290850967168808,
-0.08535236865282059,
-0.352439284324646,
-0.062482208013534546,
0.4548574388027191,
0.10016610473394394,
0.1875188648700714,
-0.17228437960147858,
0.4785011410713196,
0.127055361866951,
-0.27243074774742126,
0.08532577753067017,
-0.46729618310928345,
0.6524576544761658,
0.13373690843582153,
-0.2515941858291626,
-0.661815881729126,
0.3791971504688263,
0.6764699816703796,
-0.32326599955558777,
0.482611745595932,
0.3800815939903259,
-0.21433499455451965,
-0.7085521817207336,
-0.41623127460479736,
-0.3791731595993042,
-0.6383373737335205,
0.3575632572174072,
-0.8525484204292297,
-0.6349660158157349,
0.30269965529441833,
-0.48501843214035034,
0.43255969882011414,
0.06308029592037201,
0.6031249165534973,
-0.39393970370292664,
0.8461227416992188,
0.9083514213562012,
-0.13328689336776733,
0.511920690536499,
-0.49321210384368896,
-0.14324253797531128,
-0.5883074998855591,
-0.16900311410427094,
-0.6290854811668396,
-0.5405024290084839,
-0.31867358088493347,
-0.4412131905555725,
0.31301766633987427,
-0.10868736356496811,
-0.5513819456100464,
0.39994871616363525,
-0.5893535017967224,
0.5636726021766663,
0.2483665496110916,
0.28078052401542664,
0.011426475830376148,
-0.11231375485658646,
-0.40735647082328796,
0.41959649324417114,
-0.6650142073631287,
-0.5931018590927124,
0.9003105163574219,
0.37218859791755676,
1.1466691493988037,
-0.0119139039888978,
0.5541530251502991,
0.22319220006465912,
0.28224730491638184,
-1.0393095016479492,
0.5399042367935181,
0.17118985950946808,
-0.4299558699131012,
-0.3004103899002075,
-0.5639753937721252,
-0.8210548162460327,
0.1565672755241394,
-0.14539042115211487,
-0.368369460105896,
0.09342801570892334,
0.03220679610967636,
-0.2834785282611847,
0.29916539788246155,
-0.375731885433197,
0.6543369889259338,
-0.680384635925293,
-0.40852460265159607,
-0.16781781613826752,
-0.4660133719444275,
0.03406849130988121,
-0.24731987714767456,
0.3611189126968384,
-0.04804491996765137,
-0.16368763148784637,
0.31815335154533386,
-0.4592525064945221,
0.9386776089668274,
-0.10550323128700256,
-0.4607997536659241,
0.23585879802703857,
0.01042160578072071,
0.8141942024230957,
-0.13246658444404602,
-0.4939560294151306,
-0.49360036849975586,
-0.6527745127677917,
-0.31469982862472534,
-0.6202854514122009,
0.4912784993648529,
-0.9725481271743774,
-0.8403823375701904,
0.11279492825269699,
-0.44975608587265015,
-0.35503390431404114,
0.08057297021150589,
-0.021539339795708656,
0.3505113422870636,
-0.03352352976799011,
0.26254650950431824,
0.3553357720375061,
-0.24344410002231598,
0.6547096371650696,
0.8103493452072144,
-0.025559302419424057,
-0.43276482820510864,
0.7821707725524902,
0.0965602844953537,
0.0354449488222599,
0.6146077513694763,
0.25552040338516235,
-0.24593345820903778,
-0.5010020732879639,
-0.5557237267494202,
0.22610659897327423,
-0.5537816286087036,
-0.25885167717933655,
-0.3934461176395416,
-0.13478021323680878,
-0.23414725065231323,
-0.6316150426864624,
-0.29688242077827454,
-0.1486709713935852,
-0.5044271349906921,
-0.38277605175971985,
0.11292008310556412,
0.8319850564002991,
-0.07677334547042847,
0.22308918833732605,
-0.5644147396087646,
0.2547893226146698,
0.3070385158061981,
0.5629422664642334,
0.08880280703306198,
-0.330621600151062,
-0.32668671011924744,
-0.1002911701798439,
-0.37375086545944214,
-0.6371216773986816,
0.44516539573669434,
-0.010037945583462715,
1.0192253589630127,
0.2807827889919281,
0.2945207953453064,
0.20984210073947906,
-0.3583526611328125,
0.25075656175613403,
0.09101192653179169,
-0.6360049843788147,
0.5301157832145691,
-0.4071594178676605,
0.07356036454439163,
0.10083921253681183,
0.6165969371795654,
0.04646703973412514,
-0.2721450924873352,
-0.132917121052742,
-0.7876486778259277,
0.7171955108642578,
-0.22195526957511902,
0.1181994378566742,
0.2538300156593323,
0.44479256868362427,
0.22880443930625916,
0.24461202323436737,
-0.7032915353775024,
0.007844120264053345,
0.1021338626742363,
-0.09369292110204697,
0.16443100571632385,
-0.09212184697389603,
-0.11648330092430115,
-0.2752176821231842,
0.8872203826904297,
-0.6237145066261292,
0.05834082514047623,
-0.16125737130641937,
-0.21261093020439148,
-0.21096928417682648,
0.2519111633300781,
0.7956494092941284,
0.7138020992279053,
0.14800825715065002,
-0.21428437530994415,
0.16883328557014465,
-0.08542037755250931,
0.3165934085845947,
0.06497407704591751,
-0.05657615140080452,
-0.0562308095395565,
0.17439334094524384,
0.7487245798110962,
0.05060191452503204,
-0.45928698778152466,
0.04947945848107338,
0.232014000415802,
-0.4728911221027374,
-0.43556028604507446,
-0.00677274726331234,
0.19949115812778473,
0.7302244901657104,
0.4168251156806946,
-0.03766442835330963,
-0.16341540217399597,
-0.4467518627643585,
0.36753830313682556,
0.4815434515476227,
-0.1400081217288971,
-0.2962970733642578,
0.6760430335998535,
0.6451581716537476,
-0.5823372602462769,
0.21309080719947815,
-0.014982650987803936,
-0.46576792001724243,
0.8835684061050415,
0.3893001973628998,
1.0480098724365234,
-0.19770875573158264,
0.3743818998336792,
0.2821664810180664,
0.44222167134284973,
0.1746288388967514,
0.3944866955280304,
-0.2630780041217804,
-0.7065339088439941,
-0.5647830963134766,
-0.9208957552909851,
-0.35016554594039917,
0.07569430023431778,
-0.207318514585495,
0.42408379912376404,
-0.8115811347961426,
-0.25037384033203125,
-0.22069479525089264,
0.25405773520469666,
-0.6040893197059631,
0.25699564814567566,
0.015196307562291622,
0.8427082896232605,
-0.36937960982322693,
0.48999878764152527,
0.7859764695167542,
-0.5707454085350037,
-1.0771398544311523,
-0.39705485105514526,
0.1325356811285019,
-0.7352786660194397,
0.7439934611320496,
0.11636316776275635,
-0.4003188908100128,
-0.08620712906122208,
-0.39583107829093933,
-0.7563601732254028,
1.1273083686828613,
0.6857098937034607,
-0.7201390266418457,
-0.3058578073978424,
0.37052881717681885,
0.4550909399986267,
-0.3453294634819031,
0.09422094374895096,
0.12847426533699036,
0.6062761545181274,
0.3088473677635193,
-1.0184978246688843,
0.007650718558579683,
-0.4044971168041229,
0.043974779546260834,
0.19812189042568207,
-0.6981410980224609,
0.8685671091079712,
-0.29118993878364563,
-0.33083575963974,
0.35684406757354736,
0.5950565934181213,
0.14637449383735657,
0.0913567841053009,
0.3124854266643524,
0.35512086749076843,
0.902327835559845,
0.2721971273422241,
0.8643510937690735,
-0.5465236902236938,
0.16960711777210236,
0.9628073573112488,
-0.19511373341083527,
0.49328315258026123,
0.35712969303131104,
-0.07962984591722488,
0.2506662905216217,
0.7081241011619568,
0.16377270221710205,
0.29517775774002075,
0.6542482376098633,
-0.2477390617132187,
-0.4332050681114197,
-0.1157882809638977,
-0.42513418197631836,
0.3892403244972229,
0.2466103434562683,
-0.42234697937965393,
-0.049089133739471436,
0.17798683047294617,
-0.13028478622436523,
0.26906901597976685,
-0.4707240164279938,
0.8542535305023193,
0.29795941710472107,
-0.38689181208610535,
0.7965589165687561,
-0.14109796285629272,
0.7000722289085388,
-0.4293465316295624,
0.17168527841567993,
-0.330138623714447,
0.46211332082748413,
-0.2703767716884613,
-0.5281209349632263,
0.26254627108573914,
-0.1964399665594101,
-0.17883247137069702,
-0.5715280771255493,
0.5862724184989929,
-0.2161058932542801,
-0.3606848418712616,
0.331845223903656,
0.6260671019554138,
0.043052639812231064,
-0.029894083738327026,
-0.49119213223457336,
0.05101058632135391,
-0.221523717045784,
-0.45054522156715393,
0.1525222808122635,
0.5442481637001038,
0.03677459433674812,
1.071692943572998,
0.5979962944984436,
-0.012025337666273117,
-0.4237995743751526,
0.08144578337669373,
1.2499819993972778,
-0.6858830451965332,
-0.3595845401287079,
-0.7282781004905701,
0.574734091758728,
0.06271432340145111,
-0.022152433171868324,
0.26440998911857605,
0.4742381274700165,
0.7578770518302917,
-0.3516376316547394,
0.6974667310714722,
0.27302905917167664,
0.33357879519462585,
-0.7523582577705383,
0.8298919796943665,
-0.7873055338859558,
0.40775251388549805,
-0.284400075674057,
-0.9699103832244873,
-0.15256433188915253,
0.6788317561149597,
0.016660327091813087,
0.08632905781269073,
0.5067659020423889,
0.8708279132843018,
0.3072332739830017,
-0.20870161056518555,
0.34244340658187866,
0.267834335565567,
0.4523121118545532,
0.66535484790802,
0.9889594912528992,
0.11760907620191574,
0.48258328437805176,
0.03491756319999695,
-0.13951003551483154,
-0.1443847119808197,
-0.6729165315628052,
-1.2071149349212646,
-0.3202499449253082,
-0.09858613461256027,
0.21256740391254425,
-0.06463587284088135,
1.3213862180709839,
0.7249481081962585,
-0.33587250113487244,
-0.4649888277053833,
-0.12832055985927582,
0.26638972759246826,
-0.029828403145074844,
-0.1982826143503189,
0.21233928203582764,
-0.6723049879074097,
-0.6225882768630981,
0.7360070943832397,
0.15326757729053497,
0.0888877660036087,
-0.6136732697486877,
-0.3459588289260864,
0.12730875611305237,
0.1839940845966339,
0.776384174823761,
0.2715076506137848,
-0.41379472613334656,
-0.22857682406902313,
0.4249846339225769,
-0.23834668099880219,
0.05102138966321945,
0.6274876594543457,
-1.006700873374939,
0.2992989718914032,
0.4815264642238617,
0.9304980635643005,
0.4025903642177582,
-0.30223169922828674,
1.0257322788238525,
-0.7106127738952637,
0.10168340057134628,
0.25486886501312256,
0.4358275234699249,
0.1394985020160675,
-0.3466178774833679,
0.8266379833221436,
0.16272981464862823,
-0.4110690653324127,
-0.6199242472648621,
0.29613417387008667,
-0.7060334086418152,
-0.4803928732872009,
1.0336952209472656,
0.09332249313592911,
-0.3009626269340515,
-0.06306245923042297,
-0.5111436247825623,
0.027576478198170662,
-0.22470957040786743,
0.8143353462219238,
0.29701584577560425,
-0.17695821821689606,
-0.13606415688991547,
-0.27175429463386536,
0.48302823305130005,
0.20493347942829132,
-1.1017611026763916,
-0.15407709777355194,
0.3365499675273895,
0.09419436752796173,
0.0681210607290268,
0.5358380079269409,
0.31434351205825806,
0.28352969884872437,
-0.1795870065689087,
0.1988963633775711,
-0.3099620044231415,
-0.4737926423549652,
0.06412966549396515,
0.3843754827976227,
0.08794932812452316,
-0.07445701956748962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17524v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17524v3
|
On the Use of Large Language Models to Generate Capability Ontologies
| 2024-04-26T16:41:00 | 2024-06-30T10:58:28 |
Luis Miguel Vieira da Silva, Aljosha Köcher, Felix Gehlhoff, Alexander Fay
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Capability ontologies are increasingly used to model functionalities of
systems or machines. The creation of such ontological models with all
properties and constraints of capabilities is very complex and can only be done
by ontology experts. However, Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown that they
can generate machine-interpretable models from natural language text input and
thus support engineers / ontology experts. Therefore, this paper investigates
how LLMs can be used to create capability ontologies. We present a study with a
series of experiments in which capabilities with varying complexities are
generated using different prompting techniques and with different LLMs. Errors
in the generated ontologies are recorded and compared. To analyze the quality
of the generated ontologies, a semi-automated approach based on RDF syntax
checking, OWL reasoning, and SHACL constraints is used. The results of this
study are very promising because even for complex capabilities, the generated
ontologies are almost free of errors.
|
[
-0.4132978022098541,
-0.740024745464325,
0.953681230545044,
0.007738793268799782,
0.35942572355270386,
0.04039612039923668,
-0.2558617889881134,
-0.47816839814186096,
-0.18806391954421997,
1.066164493560791,
-0.5660605430603027,
-0.40104618668556213,
-0.48149731755256653,
0.5769600868225098,
-0.43221789598464966,
0.6679016947746277,
-0.1464073359966278,
-0.21225789189338684,
-0.08548340946435928,
0.12933510541915894,
-0.5843648314476013,
-0.5646960735321045,
-0.11538423597812653,
-0.3595740497112274,
0.16706673800945282,
0.5997310280799866,
0.8344577550888062,
0.5287786722183228,
0.5507296323776245,
0.4389437139034271,
-0.0701577216386795,
0.5496951937675476,
-0.0809752494096756,
0.28518146276474,
-0.3481522798538208,
-0.4075794219970703,
-0.6521657705307007,
-0.17631936073303223,
0.6139018535614014,
0.7248265147209167,
0.09297377616167068,
0.1033533439040184,
0.09702587872743607,
0.1577979177236557,
-0.22286315262317657,
0.08966460078954697,
-0.7594184279441833,
0.07135146856307983,
-0.005145929753780365,
-0.13573670387268066,
-0.3548089265823364,
-0.08115069568157196,
0.06201385706663132,
-0.6641650795936584,
0.09277288615703583,
0.22850976884365082,
0.8935128450393677,
0.2527371048927307,
-0.09483588486909866,
-0.6021612882614136,
-0.8872563242912292,
1.2395042181015015,
-0.8955869078636169,
0.19230327010154724,
0.46981480717658997,
0.37328872084617615,
-0.3128151595592499,
-0.6979116201400757,
-0.8080934286117554,
-0.44037845730781555,
-0.023457258939743042,
-0.29649674892425537,
0.047053445130586624,
0.15797723829746246,
0.4291590750217438,
0.10824157297611237,
-0.36203381419181824,
0.48994964361190796,
-0.1599983125925064,
-0.363321989774704,
0.7414781451225281,
0.4534124433994293,
0.3795221149921417,
-0.6105440855026245,
-0.0995132103562355,
-0.0414598174393177,
-0.7398350834846497,
-0.1671275794506073,
0.2447536140680313,
0.5271507501602173,
0.1078076884150505,
0.9635223746299744,
-0.26711586117744446,
0.8321677446365356,
-0.37169066071510315,
-0.7420153617858887,
-0.17851464450359344,
-0.46563464403152466,
-0.21824514865875244,
-0.1827782839536667,
0.7253544330596924,
-0.11643392592668533,
0.19113628566265106,
-0.31707435846328735,
-0.5938264727592468,
-0.20094694197177887,
0.4248553514480591,
-0.3349539041519165,
0.27320367097854614,
0.5573316216468811,
-0.29450374841690063,
-0.2609097361564636,
0.045277129858732224,
-0.2853854298591614,
-0.24779653549194336,
-0.322313517332077,
0.6034809350967407,
-0.5957199335098267,
-0.11003925651311874,
0.1476927101612091,
-0.07605947554111481,
0.1567210555076599,
0.14824286103248596,
-0.7699281573295593,
-0.14721466600894928,
0.6195146441459656,
0.5811710357666016,
0.11859196424484253,
-0.3284515142440796,
-0.43968692421913147,
0.4002765715122223,
-0.24868786334991455,
0.47149229049682617,
-0.30398908257484436,
-0.3490293025970459,
0.24194082617759705,
-0.23686979711055756,
0.4646681249141693,
-0.5393357872962952,
0.5774158239364624,
-0.6648145318031311,
-0.23200663924217224,
-0.4731641113758087,
-0.5890564918518066,
-0.14846599102020264,
0.46443259716033936,
-0.6161757111549377,
0.8374201059341431,
0.3668863773345947,
-0.28543469309806824,
0.43648359179496765,
-0.7621937990188599,
-0.2790520489215851,
0.3820529878139496,
-0.22459116578102112,
-0.11160813271999359,
-0.0581829696893692,
-0.2362944483757019,
0.666718065738678,
-0.6841093897819519,
0.40632885694503784,
-0.22042228281497955,
0.42455899715423584,
0.7396949529647827,
-0.14374135434627533,
0.6254844069480896,
0.3320219814777374,
-0.2680578827857971,
0.11638397723436356,
-0.8699747323989868,
0.4298582375049591,
-0.13325922191143036,
-0.4970930814743042,
-0.029603758826851845,
-0.061061132699251175,
-0.10421710461378098,
0.26402023434638977,
0.42452272772789,
-0.4347485303878784,
0.018791042268276215,
-0.3656783401966095,
0.7079387903213501,
0.3719462752342224,
-0.1061500683426857,
0.21977056562900543,
-0.3104541599750519,
0.46931424736976624,
-0.44082120060920715,
0.08206059038639069,
-0.030927028506994247,
-0.392644464969635,
-0.657927930355072,
-0.307702898979187,
0.36395108699798584,
0.4856504499912262,
-0.7953599691390991,
1.0687508583068848,
-0.07114990055561066,
-0.48114296793937683,
-0.04413801059126854,
0.5430974364280701,
0.5268927812576294,
0.25708743929862976,
0.09170858561992645,
-0.16612984240055084,
-0.6270691156387329,
-0.5877475738525391,
0.2774350345134735,
-0.36749550700187683,
-0.22627416253089905,
0.24642618000507355,
0.5201058387756348,
-0.3581840991973877,
1.1407328844070435,
-0.34659135341644287,
-0.3205942213535309,
-0.40720710158348083,
0.05495963245630264,
-0.2649379372596741,
0.23504553735256195,
0.42471715807914734,
-0.7271329164505005,
-0.01259046234190464,
0.1531478762626648,
-1.2149897813796997,
-0.4091861844062805,
0.004850322846323252,
-0.10072904825210571,
0.4328152537345886,
0.31836754083633423,
-0.7146485447883606,
0.0804789811372757,
0.6646512150764465,
-0.1863792985677719,
0.6491310000419617,
-0.4553566575050354,
-0.018526287749409676,
-1.0574698448181152,
0.10638083517551422,
-0.30150845646858215,
-0.1305265724658966,
-0.5902539491653442,
0.367936909198761,
-0.11198490113019943,
-0.18916261196136475,
-0.3482245206832886,
0.3768736720085144,
-0.5010135173797607,
-0.3123512268066406,
-0.20359650254249573,
0.4113401472568512,
0.23552386462688446,
-0.1932060569524765,
-0.12734627723693848,
0.4701448380947113,
0.5082228183746338,
-0.8604562878608704,
0.5698219537734985,
0.46999216079711914,
-0.3452751338481903,
0.2864183783531189,
-0.5720952749252319,
-0.2512003779411316,
0.3393281102180481,
-0.2707151770591736,
-1.0369540452957153,
-0.7783952355384827,
-0.19834324717521667,
-0.17531168460845947,
0.15593065321445465,
0.24275436997413635,
-0.9801028370857239,
-0.5253258943557739,
0.05965830385684967,
-0.0684405192732811,
0.5400195717811584,
-0.3093253970146179,
0.6883313655853271,
0.46511122584342957,
-0.14498557150363922,
-0.21680550277233124,
-0.9634020328521729,
0.20611117780208588,
0.0846129059791565,
-0.9318386316299438,
0.3131157457828522,
0.10815295577049255,
-0.4568154215812683,
0.107343390583992,
0.4054720997810364,
-0.0938636064529419,
0.1032886952161789,
0.4531409442424774,
0.28515470027923584,
-0.12539264559745789,
0.49604398012161255,
0.18671466410160065,
-0.0030372736509889364,
0.10260620713233948,
-0.23922768235206604,
0.46969613432884216,
-0.04184786230325699,
-0.6272950768470764,
-0.3539811074733734,
0.43129831552505493,
0.5917576551437378,
-0.24970844388008118,
0.8471890687942505,
0.21151602268218994,
-0.2620790898799896,
-0.4764951765537262,
-0.651193380355835,
-0.48255473375320435,
-0.4948831796646118,
0.31143999099731445,
-0.29930824041366577,
-1.0434726476669312,
0.6955362558364868,
-0.061674993485212326,
0.35525989532470703,
0.3810720145702362,
0.6185489296913147,
0.14681850373744965,
0.8477492928504944,
0.6007307171821594,
0.47062569856643677,
0.0020062183029949665,
-0.24380497634410858,
0.3692489266395569,
-0.5404717326164246,
-0.1802990585565567,
-0.7119445204734802,
0.20198963582515717,
-0.5657325387001038,
-0.33725085854530334,
0.4512366056442261,
0.10366939753293991,
-0.16782572865486145,
0.19402754306793213,
-0.3736429810523987,
0.060278814285993576,
0.2715616226196289,
-0.15082453191280365,
0.4813508689403534,
0.212309792637825,
-0.08942993730306625,
-0.046432364732027054,
-0.7430374622344971,
-1.1409441232681274,
1.0198698043823242,
0.1409410685300827,
0.7173888087272644,
0.2404397428035736,
0.4389354884624481,
0.31695571541786194,
0.30449023842811584,
-0.8083955645561218,
0.7538838386535645,
-0.18514689803123474,
-0.7620217204093933,
-0.7111653089523315,
-0.4802146255970001,
-0.7947425842285156,
-0.30130261182785034,
-0.6099037528038025,
-0.3691938519477844,
-0.3498463034629822,
0.18607941269874573,
-0.5373319983482361,
0.43570324778556824,
-0.529461681842804,
0.5176052451133728,
-0.33330968022346497,
-0.11414378136396408,
-0.019212737679481506,
-0.36081767082214355,
0.26415789127349854,
-0.5656100511550903,
0.12192097306251526,
-0.0155226681381464,
-0.20145533978939056,
0.48176291584968567,
-0.6729901432991028,
0.9425183534622192,
0.23405686020851135,
-0.4573152959346771,
0.7543771862983704,
0.13472925126552582,
0.3132018744945526,
-0.01881953328847885,
-0.6275566220283508,
0.07017437368631363,
-0.20579847693443298,
-0.13514988124370575,
-0.3305181562900543,
0.7438585758209229,
-0.9157309532165527,
-0.8431503772735596,
0.045781735330820084,
-0.8231620788574219,
-0.2386062890291214,
0.47373685240745544,
0.24579240381717682,
0.5748599767684937,
-0.006266333162784576,
0.19952639937400818,
0.5734396576881409,
-0.3513874411582947,
0.45520293712615967,
0.4813724458217621,
-0.2772078216075897,
0.09089910238981247,
0.6458379626274109,
0.8208417296409607,
0.5667020082473755,
0.183121457695961,
0.08914849162101746,
-0.23252077400684357,
-0.4560142457485199,
-0.5717434883117676,
0.1792021542787552,
-0.6463764905929565,
-0.2818107604980469,
-0.670717716217041,
-0.39595818519592285,
-0.49536409974098206,
-0.351398229598999,
-0.2981835603713989,
-0.3934330642223358,
-0.21830777823925018,
0.17674386501312256,
0.5547576546669006,
0.9532268643379211,
0.022734716534614563,
0.19397787749767303,
-1.1966718435287476,
0.016655966639518738,
0.5979852676391602,
0.14552222192287445,
0.06361427903175354,
-0.6169191598892212,
-0.14140881597995758,
-0.12390054762363434,
-0.4510132372379303,
-0.7211854457855225,
0.3582291305065155,
-0.04696710780262947,
0.6003768444061279,
0.23633965849876404,
0.27300500869750977,
-0.013604913838207722,
-0.03629111126065254,
0.895213782787323,
-0.054076507687568665,
-1.0759034156799316,
0.5010843276977539,
-0.3876342475414276,
0.11628750711679459,
0.054211702197790146,
0.37999626994132996,
0.1352304369211197,
-0.5653871297836304,
-0.5548369884490967,
-0.687593936920166,
0.5753953456878662,
0.1857779622077942,
0.3428661823272705,
0.26340222358703613,
0.598130464553833,
0.20433427393436432,
0.119075246155262,
-0.3590450882911682,
0.10986356437206268,
0.07527250796556473,
-0.05091492831707001,
0.41608700156211853,
-0.4938203692436218,
-0.25288981199264526,
0.5263345241546631,
0.6894695162773132,
-0.10066325217485428,
-0.25962910056114197,
0.10832257568836212,
0.08931886404752731,
-0.1537436842918396,
0.5184244513511658,
0.31802356243133545,
0.9794971942901611,
0.2982867658138275,
0.07543406635522842,
0.41946378350257874,
-0.1966497302055359,
0.1494784951210022,
-0.2916915714740753,
-0.1874399185180664,
-0.2209174633026123,
0.5656691789627075,
0.4824858009815216,
-0.23427125811576843,
-1.098095178604126,
0.05359844118356705,
0.21936343610286713,
-0.3492278754711151,
-0.3712396025657654,
0.4535164535045624,
0.07616756111383438,
0.17615464329719543,
0.293167382478714,
-0.2695099413394928,
-0.17849421501159668,
-0.3968345820903778,
-0.09972173720598221,
0.45717135071754456,
-0.058989543467760086,
-0.1602722853422165,
0.2671205401420593,
0.24501219391822815,
-0.38269591331481934,
0.4243786036968231,
-0.5093705654144287,
-0.3268173635005951,
0.4324258267879486,
0.5308536291122437,
0.39788368344306946,
-0.2157115489244461,
0.1713608354330063,
0.1697400063276291,
0.4293908476829529,
-0.14555811882019043,
0.3852006793022156,
0.30240368843078613,
-0.9454528093338013,
-0.8771119713783264,
-0.7382215857505798,
-0.696088969707489,
0.1901712864637375,
-0.3187958300113678,
0.15951374173164368,
-0.5009936690330505,
-0.5890166759490967,
0.1561906486749649,
-0.020640231668949127,
-0.43895748257637024,
0.29210835695266724,
-0.2096594274044037,
0.5169439911842346,
-0.8355637192726135,
0.6158784627914429,
0.9761867523193359,
-0.46151721477508545,
-1.4453504085540771,
-0.1389099508523941,
-0.16023436188697815,
-0.551551342010498,
0.9447376132011414,
-0.132363960146904,
-0.13659429550170898,
-0.08634919673204422,
-0.4071020185947418,
-0.6970806121826172,
0.9293474555015564,
0.4142104387283325,
-0.3186759650707245,
0.12132013589143753,
0.6162768006324768,
0.6085667014122009,
-0.42089277505874634,
-0.1919669359922409,
0.3802500069141388,
0.8324982523918152,
-0.049017686396837234,
-1.0385870933532715,
0.3017437160015106,
0.2569354176521301,
0.3147439658641815,
0.036649059504270554,
-0.41928350925445557,
0.9983299374580383,
-0.3307236135005951,
-0.03926849365234375,
0.3598656952381134,
0.5318199396133423,
0.4898315966129303,
-0.09794515371322632,
0.4770005941390991,
0.28700393438339233,
0.7566079497337341,
-0.06894443929195404,
1.0210915803909302,
-0.358856201171875,
0.2235257625579834,
0.4838121235370636,
-0.602671205997467,
0.7138992547988892,
0.37683650851249695,
-0.06622155010700226,
0.39804017543792725,
-0.008502009324729443,
-0.07915458083152771,
-0.18756242096424103,
0.03996574133634567,
-0.2594267427921295,
-0.5874239206314087,
-0.38397279381752014,
-0.17338432371616364,
0.6662304401397705,
0.41637122631073,
-0.45720916986465454,
-0.046595338732004166,
0.14091287553310394,
0.024839386343955994,
0.28487515449523926,
-0.21926210820674896,
0.5774255990982056,
0.08667545765638351,
-0.8956165909767151,
0.47045543789863586,
0.3521993160247803,
0.38422077894210815,
-0.5818477869033813,
0.038780756294727325,
0.2282586693763733,
0.07268138229846954,
-0.4317425489425659,
-1.1511672735214233,
0.3765767216682434,
0.24498221278190613,
-0.4048401415348053,
-0.1251843422651291,
0.9068127870559692,
-0.1193542554974556,
-0.49469831585884094,
0.31653666496276855,
0.6542194485664368,
0.17781896889209747,
0.198853999376297,
-0.2891853153705597,
0.17013606429100037,
-0.11026511341333389,
-0.19988451898097992,
0.21976380050182343,
0.8580865263938904,
-0.23567834496498108,
0.7740061283111572,
0.5771921277046204,
0.166127547621727,
-0.0652429386973381,
-0.09358718991279602,
0.7151120901107788,
-0.3675037920475006,
-0.2529319226741791,
-0.6480347514152527,
0.34294867515563965,
0.06612356007099152,
-0.29565873742103577,
0.8038244247436523,
0.015209692530333996,
0.6026232242584229,
-0.11925099045038223,
1.1136908531188965,
-0.524163544178009,
0.4017220437526703,
-0.6622340679168701,
0.876467764377594,
-0.653015673160553,
0.4612305462360382,
0.03258974105119705,
-0.6792199611663818,
-0.39238062500953674,
0.2562476694583893,
-0.24393735826015472,
0.3096345067024231,
0.3514137864112854,
1.1557413339614868,
0.13546767830848694,
-0.02641739882528782,
0.7457059025764465,
0.3039827346801758,
0.4100000560283661,
0.32276925444602966,
0.7500807046890259,
-0.09721623361110687,
0.6666415333747864,
0.13459430634975433,
-0.2998613715171814,
-0.41253823041915894,
-0.9915329217910767,
-0.8518034219741821,
-0.557403564453125,
0.01400033850222826,
-0.6057948470115662,
-0.3170297145843506,
0.7264860272407532,
0.6508265137672424,
-0.7498571276664734,
-0.18533693253993988,
-0.050069984048604965,
0.10431617498397827,
0.15725795924663544,
-0.16487106680870056,
0.1584767997264862,
-0.49724432826042175,
-0.5004317760467529,
0.15653903782367706,
0.22740879654884338,
-0.05568584054708481,
-0.9123681783676147,
-0.2831569015979767,
0.17094963788986206,
0.1355762779712677,
0.7040504217147827,
0.2647782266139984,
-0.8197697997093201,
-0.5365336537361145,
0.10327450931072235,
-0.34225258231163025,
-0.4064572751522064,
0.6046733260154724,
-0.3369278907775879,
0.39131519198417664,
0.7147772312164307,
0.5822952389717102,
-0.17675405740737915,
-0.4212394952774048,
0.5686545372009277,
-0.7255321145057678,
-0.11247675120830536,
-0.10454840958118439,
0.31253954768180847,
0.49375614523887634,
-0.2111426740884781,
0.3097921907901764,
-0.10165459662675858,
-0.6939689517021179,
-0.9055890440940857,
0.4249938428401947,
-0.8307584524154663,
-0.14870043098926544,
1.3191615343093872,
-0.2703528106212616,
-0.08769005537033081,
-0.4288674294948578,
-0.22435013949871063,
0.3957044780254364,
-0.061761628836393356,
0.7792589664459229,
0.6651305556297302,
-0.26406627893447876,
0.34574660658836365,
-0.5580284595489502,
0.29656070470809937,
0.390199214220047,
-1.0716242790222168,
-0.009350107982754707,
0.3142457902431488,
0.2769538164138794,
0.7323420643806458,
0.14578410983085632,
-0.17760972678661346,
0.20281249284744263,
-0.013053318485617638,
0.33247581124305725,
-0.24603867530822754,
-0.24787838757038116,
0.19404594600200653,
0.4919721484184265,
0.6648555994033813,
0.47330522537231445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17513v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17513v1
|
A Comprehensive Evaluation on Event Reasoning of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-26T16:28:34 | 2024-04-26T16:28:34 |
Zhengwei Tao, Zhi Jin, Yifan Zhang, Xiancai Chen, Xiaoying Bai, Yue Fang, Haiyan Zhao, Jia Li, Chongyang Tao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Event reasoning is a fundamental ability that underlies many applications. It
requires event schema knowledge to perform global reasoning and needs to deal
with the diversity of the inter-event relations and the reasoning paradigms.
How well LLMs accomplish event reasoning on various relations and reasoning
paradigms remains unknown. To mitigate this disparity, we comprehensively
evaluate the abilities of event reasoning of LLMs. We introduce a novel
benchmark EV2 for EValuation of EVent reasoning. EV2 consists of two levels of
evaluation of schema and instance and is comprehensive in relations and
reasoning paradigms. We conduct extensive experiments on EV2. We find that LLMs
have abilities to accomplish event reasoning but their performances are far
from satisfactory. We also notice the imbalance of event reasoning abilities in
LLMs. Besides, LLMs have event schema knowledge, however, they're not aligned
with humans on how to utilize the knowledge. Based on these findings, we
introduce two methods to guide the LLMs to utilize the event schema knowledge.
Both methods achieve improvements.
|
[
-0.0676850825548172,
-0.6894918084144592,
0.8758734464645386,
0.02255561202764511,
-0.2625073790550232,
0.20624661445617676,
-0.42677754163742065,
-0.7096617817878723,
-0.15921050310134888,
0.19666315615177155,
-0.39095067977905273,
-0.676926851272583,
-0.2865604758262634,
-0.03854653239250183,
-0.29746800661087036,
0.49115145206451416,
-0.08433753997087479,
0.09097389876842499,
-0.6157186031341553,
-0.14582231640815735,
-0.13891026377677917,
-0.547271192073822,
-0.831947922706604,
-0.712540864944458,
0.22251717746257782,
0.4292502999305725,
0.24923184514045715,
0.4495466649532318,
0.5789046883583069,
0.1896040141582489,
-0.34927093982696533,
0.37422892451286316,
-0.5317041277885437,
0.3208500146865845,
-0.4859321713447571,
-0.5705651044845581,
-0.4945605397224426,
-0.27742376923561096,
0.7122188210487366,
0.6900364756584167,
-0.19527874886989594,
0.13818687200546265,
0.08219154924154282,
0.31302303075790405,
-0.5965147018432617,
0.13425256311893463,
-0.9392259120941162,
0.02996421791613102,
-0.4964432716369629,
-0.17432886362075806,
-0.5373485088348389,
0.036116015166044235,
-0.15789289772510529,
-0.5767641663551331,
0.0971655398607254,
0.20849692821502686,
0.5629001259803772,
-0.05408823862671852,
-0.4803740084171295,
-0.07368375360965729,
-0.8534106612205505,
0.900133490562439,
-0.5425746440887451,
0.490836501121521,
0.19480469822883606,
0.27768757939338684,
-0.1893773227930069,
-0.7620938420295715,
-0.5999273657798767,
-0.4085122346878052,
0.17781946063041687,
0.047792501747608185,
-0.05530288815498352,
0.13082946836948395,
0.5518264174461365,
0.07672679424285889,
-0.6067138314247131,
0.5365028381347656,
0.0037673600018024445,
0.03672882914543152,
0.7972670793533325,
0.6314953565597534,
0.06321503221988678,
0.02445179410278797,
-0.37511101365089417,
0.08760947734117508,
-0.9783806800842285,
-0.08848858624696732,
0.20901869237422943,
-0.0864485427737236,
0.11183395236730576,
0.4723353385925293,
-0.3383869230747223,
0.3799852132797241,
-0.3371719419956207,
-0.2312556356191635,
0.07465101033449173,
-0.5535887479782104,
-0.07440700381994247,
-0.27118930220603943,
0.5169494152069092,
0.6137139797210693,
0.24779212474822998,
-0.41028833389282227,
0.0021904974710196257,
0.1315860152244568,
-0.0031814933754503727,
-0.6548008322715759,
0.2880457043647766,
0.2820335328578949,
-0.5712398886680603,
0.013224584981799126,
-0.23997843265533447,
-0.815161406993866,
-0.5066846013069153,
-0.35600656270980835,
0.21361252665519714,
-0.45323851704597473,
-0.2450609654188156,
0.08645357936620712,
-0.19715313613414764,
0.49482834339141846,
0.7189337015151978,
-0.7138897180557251,
0.34348732233047485,
1.1735044717788696,
0.54481440782547,
-0.32136088609695435,
-0.39792653918266296,
-0.40438464283943176,
0.29196298122406006,
-0.16236716508865356,
0.9586620330810547,
-0.6841373443603516,
-0.19890540838241577,
0.05825306847691536,
-0.30396154522895813,
0.05012516304850578,
-0.5796250104904175,
0.7129586338996887,
-0.5405794382095337,
-0.34344133734703064,
-0.3937608599662781,
-0.9257909655570984,
0.08555792272090912,
-0.0529872365295887,
-0.1591847985982895,
0.9687311053276062,
-0.17281325161457062,
-0.6368148326873779,
0.6407643556594849,
-0.364135205745697,
-0.5653759837150574,
0.4082179665565491,
-0.33406007289886475,
-0.09256090223789215,
0.06283470243215561,
0.07467427104711533,
0.28703418374061584,
-0.4428488314151764,
0.20124010741710663,
-0.6621065735816956,
-0.4369877278804779,
0.10683984309434891,
0.025206206366419792,
0.4308043420314789,
0.18746663630008698,
-0.2397848665714264,
-0.004572231788188219,
-0.9527021050453186,
-0.00744830584153533,
0.20346450805664062,
-0.11039116233587265,
-0.3642669916152954,
0.6134719252586365,
-0.09855607897043228,
0.07094000279903412,
0.2684377133846283,
-0.31493809819221497,
0.5442917943000793,
-0.3537059426307678,
0.4840053915977478,
0.5717248916625977,
0.04754176735877991,
0.7002992630004883,
0.07692147046327591,
0.2989811301231384,
-0.17943017184734344,
0.17427310347557068,
-0.17097285389900208,
-0.4579918384552002,
-0.7419689893722534,
0.10578034818172455,
-0.041319653391838074,
0.5616011619567871,
-0.6276512742042542,
0.6024569272994995,
-0.09812484681606293,
-0.411785751581192,
-0.05687236785888672,
0.06830839812755585,
0.2717290222644806,
0.23998720943927765,
0.2725311815738678,
-0.06794863939285278,
-0.8278905749320984,
-0.7633841633796692,
-0.48292580246925354,
-0.4303453862667084,
-0.08486302942037582,
0.11180434376001358,
0.5554351210594177,
-0.13380300998687744,
0.4884496331214905,
-0.13918592035770416,
0.05733674019575119,
-0.5140936374664307,
0.15082819759845734,
-0.0017968793399631977,
0.112404465675354,
0.2902466356754303,
-0.09474021941423416,
-0.016037091612815857,
0.1816059947013855,
-0.9138248562812805,
-0.20190006494522095,
-0.21664325892925262,
-0.16301381587982178,
0.394334077835083,
0.6167458295822144,
-0.5035828351974487,
0.37764957547187805,
0.05842524394392967,
-0.6194556355476379,
0.43815192580223083,
-0.05469160154461861,
-0.014947797171771526,
-0.5503271222114563,
-0.12919799983501434,
-0.009211352095007896,
-0.14749200642108917,
-0.5980473756790161,
0.34227612614631653,
0.14920665323734283,
0.34111928939819336,
-0.23270165920257568,
0.8008803725242615,
-0.43251246213912964,
-0.42135196924209595,
-0.3059942424297333,
0.42597076296806335,
0.13029363751411438,
0.05427495762705803,
0.2005404531955719,
0.46796301007270813,
0.4855785369873047,
-0.5573378205299377,
0.5638904571533203,
0.27310770750045776,
-0.8100223541259766,
0.7922924160957336,
-0.4033461809158325,
0.22246232628822327,
-0.06766986101865768,
0.3130795955657959,
-0.7599630355834961,
0.050252243876457214,
-0.16573531925678253,
-0.27770522236824036,
0.29160869121551514,
0.015763917937874794,
-0.8125916123390198,
-0.39809951186180115,
-0.0644870325922966,
0.17319317162036896,
0.5241686105728149,
-0.5923115611076355,
0.5283648371696472,
0.1476891040802002,
-0.06623896956443787,
-0.39509689807891846,
-0.5005296468734741,
0.2481936365365982,
-0.27571964263916016,
-0.8132680058479309,
0.1585732251405716,
0.19749246537685394,
-0.7665976881980896,
-0.07184714078903198,
-0.24421890079975128,
0.13837280869483948,
0.07165966182947159,
0.015961188822984695,
0.06464098393917084,
-0.27833378314971924,
0.27068930864334106,
0.012362456880509853,
-0.15048232674598694,
0.11198573559522629,
-0.186531662940979,
0.3921041488647461,
0.006477484479546547,
-0.8291815519332886,
-0.6005197763442993,
0.3881874978542328,
0.4978600740432739,
-0.08932077139616013,
0.7280062437057495,
0.4767471253871918,
-0.5039379000663757,
-0.17407755553722382,
-0.9312326312065125,
-0.43310657143592834,
-0.32747671008110046,
0.7583388686180115,
-0.4905439615249634,
-0.7066898345947266,
0.7559548020362854,
-0.21389546990394592,
-0.011692726984620094,
0.650691568851471,
0.6914547085762024,
-0.1220952719449997,
1.110139012336731,
0.026135927066206932,
0.30506834387779236,
0.2094147801399231,
-0.14895731210708618,
0.15625976026058197,
-1.1231756210327148,
-0.6938568353652954,
-0.7059534192085266,
-0.18022480607032776,
-0.06351109594106674,
-0.5819371938705444,
0.10004622489213943,
0.4990212917327881,
-0.4637731909751892,
0.14598959684371948,
-0.04969523847103119,
0.46951475739479065,
0.40758320689201355,
-0.0871788039803505,
0.6297617554664612,
-0.0996723398566246,
-0.05477442964911461,
-0.2274169921875,
-0.6651774644851685,
-0.7480067610740662,
0.9530149102210999,
0.39568203687667847,
0.800453782081604,
-0.13839612901210785,
0.516326367855072,
-0.006205298937857151,
0.12073823064565659,
-0.4937513470649719,
0.6659060120582581,
0.1670054793357849,
-0.514490008354187,
-0.4040348529815674,
-0.43638676404953003,
-0.7286593914031982,
0.43582797050476074,
-0.04400916025042534,
-1.2555688619613647,
0.1339225023984909,
-0.27958381175994873,
-0.053373876959085464,
0.40006279945373535,
-0.42252281308174133,
0.6805275678634644,
-0.26670345664024353,
-0.43678492307662964,
-0.6388120055198669,
-0.35708147287368774,
0.3164096176624298,
0.15363088250160217,
0.4611932337284088,
-0.4020143449306488,
-0.13117621839046478,
0.7518951296806335,
-0.24590834975242615,
0.6446398496627808,
0.025901949033141136,
-0.05033217743039131,
0.3794812858104706,
0.1937151700258255,
0.9067786931991577,
0.2769617736339569,
-0.39111045002937317,
0.24843041598796844,
-0.025032630190253258,
-0.11699897795915604,
-0.6226890087127686,
0.7228593230247498,
-0.7358347177505493,
-0.6048617959022522,
-0.1561780869960785,
-0.2946005165576935,
-0.3444373309612274,
-0.22483035922050476,
0.23284433782100677,
0.33587345480918884,
-0.4141214191913605,
0.15403017401695251,
0.5172693133354187,
-0.0936708077788353,
0.253077894449234,
0.7959909439086914,
-0.2681266963481903,
-0.23046669363975525,
0.42866864800453186,
0.08671090006828308,
0.2879450023174286,
0.4943423867225647,
-0.0404413640499115,
-0.43823686242103577,
-0.5966348648071289,
-0.47942113876342773,
0.1278582215309143,
-0.9911308884620667,
-0.15894539654254913,
-0.7739073038101196,
-0.08991164714097977,
-0.17236164212226868,
-0.20037305355072021,
-0.2802790403366089,
-0.5653575658798218,
-0.11952026188373566,
-0.2820318341255188,
0.13599029183387756,
0.6596329212188721,
-0.11361673474311829,
0.027945633977651596,
-0.5776793360710144,
0.15953859686851501,
0.3135327100753784,
0.2438632696866989,
0.2557438313961029,
-0.5678548216819763,
-0.063753642141819,
-0.36040759086608887,
-0.4236980080604553,
-0.9833552837371826,
-0.19044657051563263,
0.21998080611228943,
1.0113763809204102,
0.7497933506965637,
-0.056338053196668625,
0.4392991364002228,
-0.6248900294303894,
0.795373260974884,
0.09161096066236496,
-1.1387709379196167,
0.8055034279823303,
-0.17175890505313873,
0.004841944668442011,
0.29625362157821655,
-0.0874168872833252,
-0.49968186020851135,
-0.5754717588424683,
-0.9472167491912842,
-0.978017270565033,
0.9392663240432739,
0.3490963876247406,
-0.10733066499233246,
-0.012645208276808262,
0.48746728897094727,
0.06992758065462112,
0.02457571215927601,
-0.4589005410671234,
-0.26142337918281555,
0.33395370841026306,
0.24466809630393982,
-0.007666897960007191,
-0.5766893625259399,
-0.18318217992782593,
-0.5055002570152283,
0.5459246635437012,
0.0708250030875206,
0.04302925616502762,
-0.10638128221035004,
0.055543169379234314,
-0.36065858602523804,
0.2157386839389801,
0.49178701639175415,
1.1405837535858154,
-0.09272177517414093,
0.22059771418571472,
0.8650506138801575,
0.0408206433057785,
0.03083593025803566,
-0.03168361634016037,
0.017756128683686256,
-0.12532587349414825,
0.8665860295295715,
0.8864164352416992,
0.26998597383499146,
-0.6063348054885864,
0.4484234154224396,
0.04726897180080414,
-0.08920574933290482,
-0.08976640552282333,
0.12580955028533936,
0.3884415924549103,
0.561158299446106,
0.34910550713539124,
-0.38227757811546326,
0.1550811529159546,
-0.6585985422134399,
0.1162668839097023,
0.4874071478843689,
-0.04091738536953926,
-0.29653656482696533,
0.6925681829452515,
0.4398179352283478,
-0.22969821095466614,
0.6006794571876526,
-0.43936818838119507,
-0.5064117312431335,
0.9202332496643066,
0.641120195388794,
0.6501674056053162,
-0.3327125012874603,
-0.04653415083885193,
0.6082449555397034,
0.6318933963775635,
0.11406027525663376,
0.4360818862915039,
0.0018805661238729954,
-0.7618192434310913,
-0.7990332841873169,
-0.7145289778709412,
-0.7046018838882446,
0.3984079957008362,
-0.5516219139099121,
0.4269009232521057,
-0.08554861694574356,
0.15891581773757935,
0.07267995923757553,
0.05391747131943703,
-0.8293362855911255,
-0.15200676023960114,
0.378314346075058,
1.1699135303497314,
-0.7891148328781128,
0.5913835763931274,
0.8750149607658386,
-0.2198435515165329,
-0.42182111740112305,
-0.07948628813028336,
0.01138194277882576,
-0.8415989279747009,
0.6212406158447266,
0.01612238399684429,
0.3115512728691101,
-0.3984247148036957,
-0.28571605682373047,
-0.8013688921928406,
0.9544392824172974,
0.22801195085048676,
-1.0105154514312744,
0.2080613672733307,
0.08744074404239655,
0.7175878882408142,
-0.3669285178184509,
0.513666033744812,
0.7625842094421387,
0.673610270023346,
0.352020800113678,
-0.9275739789009094,
0.03803413361310959,
0.11604252457618713,
0.09202519804239273,
0.1204763874411583,
-0.5500965714454651,
0.39902263879776,
-0.3884952664375305,
-0.26298266649246216,
0.0029686952475458384,
0.7646092772483826,
0.4523497223854065,
0.7457581162452698,
0.23371651768684387,
0.7240341901779175,
0.8912500739097595,
-0.3013259470462799,
1.055269718170166,
-0.12074250727891922,
0.4900406002998352,
1.0470926761627197,
-0.9639049768447876,
0.7193899154663086,
0.1736680269241333,
-0.6633108258247375,
0.3899464011192322,
0.584102213382721,
0.16285322606563568,
0.3320079445838928,
0.4394790828227997,
-0.3655695915222168,
-0.865092933177948,
0.07670809328556061,
-0.5874836444854736,
0.5103105306625366,
0.6003849506378174,
-0.06894664466381073,
-0.5036319494247437,
-0.02888808213174343,
0.006592435296624899,
-0.07166608422994614,
-0.30329468846321106,
0.8659939169883728,
0.2861819863319397,
-0.5230461955070496,
0.14481206238269806,
0.13235817849636078,
0.05604301765561104,
-0.2920798659324646,
0.02535487338900566,
-0.23889042437076569,
0.3608926236629486,
-0.15384039282798767,
-0.9633810520172119,
0.4151994585990906,
-0.05728808790445328,
-0.05188419297337532,
0.20689310133457184,
0.8690869808197021,
-0.20952343940734863,
-0.28437361121177673,
0.5261989235877991,
0.5235631465911865,
0.22504223883152008,
-0.07494699209928513,
-0.3538951873779297,
0.2510872185230255,
-0.31668922305107117,
-0.4180369973182678,
0.3754418194293976,
0.6754812598228455,
-0.20412284135818481,
0.5876865386962891,
0.38893386721611023,
0.12161785364151001,
-0.29542702436447144,
0.48598790168762207,
0.6166218519210815,
-0.5762075185775757,
-0.2864566445350647,
-1.0613943338394165,
0.21346572041511536,
-0.3643646538257599,
-0.15994377434253693,
0.5811831951141357,
0.6596407890319824,
0.621921718120575,
0.20468823611736298,
0.8434907793998718,
0.09358595311641693,
0.4545440673828125,
-0.5806692242622375,
0.15743602812290192,
-0.4617762267589569,
0.38062095642089844,
0.024081015959382057,
-1.121779203414917,
-0.2500736117362976,
0.6659800410270691,
-0.3697505593299866,
-0.03181114420294762,
0.8435418605804443,
0.44764333963394165,
0.12312772125005722,
0.2636578679084778,
0.46425461769104004,
0.37052613496780396,
0.2911580801010132,
0.7700588703155518,
1.4663859605789185,
-0.10797132551670074,
0.29430869221687317,
0.10659663379192352,
-0.49634653329849243,
-0.4885943531990051,
-0.997313380241394,
-0.9889540076255798,
-0.5707229375839233,
-0.39965471625328064,
-0.38445621728897095,
0.39507946372032166,
0.8770344257354736,
0.5643302202224731,
-0.7176446318626404,
-0.05357634648680687,
0.01428783219307661,
0.3712594509124756,
-0.2398122251033783,
-0.18633292615413666,
0.30227530002593994,
-0.5360044240951538,
-0.6736414432525635,
0.5356243848800659,
0.5867618322372437,
-0.3858855664730072,
-0.1838892251253128,
-0.050017207860946655,
0.13703553378582,
0.22225196659564972,
0.800069272518158,
0.09104104340076447,
-0.8360398411750793,
-0.38020309805870056,
-0.3148653507232666,
-0.1404014229774475,
-0.12501971423625946,
0.794971764087677,
-0.4345710873603821,
0.13697518408298492,
0.7260904908180237,
0.2297063022851944,
0.6166948676109314,
-0.32412752509117126,
0.3929104506969452,
-0.5944765210151672,
0.1699414998292923,
0.17393234372138977,
0.7547464966773987,
0.05384194478392601,
-0.3610825538635254,
0.6747983694076538,
0.29511576890945435,
-0.741058886051178,
-0.8754523396492004,
0.482951283454895,
-0.9524157047271729,
-0.17086973786354065,
1.747846245765686,
0.02276851050555706,
0.18305635452270508,
-0.19588948786258698,
-0.019763991236686707,
0.13857664167881012,
-0.15676496922969818,
0.5511927008628845,
0.7977936863899231,
-0.4709731340408325,
-0.041394468396902084,
-0.5222401022911072,
0.33392736315727234,
0.20741777122020721,
-0.9543094635009766,
0.1378520131111145,
0.2975035607814789,
0.17999589443206787,
-0.024896999821066856,
0.6834443211555481,
-0.060186367481946945,
0.16835585236549377,
0.08831736445426941,
0.36356014013290405,
0.10586300492286682,
-0.49771249294281006,
-0.1486838012933731,
0.0608251579105854,
0.24829648435115814,
0.21153809130191803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17481v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17481v2
|
ReproHum #0087-01: Human Evaluation Reproduction Report for Generating Fact Checking Explanations
| 2024-04-26T15:31:25 | 2024-05-14T17:36:13 |
Tyler Loakman, Chenghua Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents a partial reproduction of Generating Fact Checking
Explanations by Anatanasova et al (2020) as part of the ReproHum element of the
ReproNLP shared task to reproduce the findings of NLP research regarding human
evaluation. This shared task aims to investigate the extent to which NLP as a
field is becoming more or less reproducible over time. Following the
instructions provided by the task organisers and the original authors, we
collect relative rankings of 3 fact-checking explanations (comprising a gold
standard and the outputs of 2 models) for 40 inputs on the criteria of
Coverage. The results of our reproduction and reanalysis of the original work's
raw results lend support to the original findings, with similar patterns seen
between the original work and our reproduction. Whilst we observe slight
variation from the original results, our findings support the main conclusions
drawn by the original authors pertaining to the efficacy of their proposed
models.
|
[
-0.25342753529548645,
-0.34969136118888855,
0.6034775376319885,
0.5469020009040833,
-0.27688297629356384,
-0.1605072170495987,
-0.023712603375315666,
-0.6812015771865845,
0.07356848567724228,
0.6907681822776794,
-0.5905793309211731,
-0.33379241824150085,
-0.6214125752449036,
0.5970137119293213,
-0.7210898995399475,
1.177499771118164,
0.003583459882065654,
-0.12808038294315338,
-0.516069769859314,
-0.3552789092063904,
-0.1455691009759903,
-0.7389671802520752,
-0.4100704789161682,
-0.5847359895706177,
0.617181658744812,
0.49992141127586365,
0.7580210566520691,
0.6528072953224182,
0.4061901867389679,
0.28701502084732056,
-0.11559392511844635,
0.29047703742980957,
-0.20336362719535828,
-0.034820351749658585,
-0.39554262161254883,
-0.43981844186782837,
-0.3080202043056488,
0.6347965002059937,
0.8647245168685913,
0.752498209476471,
-0.3614320755004883,
0.2213878035545349,
0.19114378094673157,
0.6248816847801208,
-0.4938028156757355,
-0.1838793307542801,
-0.3399393856525421,
0.25743579864501953,
0.14917656779289246,
-0.4311981499195099,
-0.6962156295776367,
-0.28395265340805054,
0.23580637574195862,
-0.49451956152915955,
0.8378757834434509,
0.21538792550563812,
0.7681621313095093,
0.09168162196874619,
-0.17476524412631989,
-0.2686585783958435,
-0.8241411447525024,
0.7859890460968018,
-0.7110911011695862,
0.22596096992492676,
0.36499837040901184,
0.07120074331760406,
-0.058474890887737274,
-0.9934396743774414,
-0.7024114727973938,
-0.4828020930290222,
-0.43628183007240295,
0.12985551357269287,
-0.4351052939891815,
-0.4297492802143097,
0.25726833939552307,
0.32907333970069885,
-0.33824339509010315,
-0.27628105878829956,
-0.47032594680786133,
-0.4866395592689514,
0.672465443611145,
-0.04910885542631149,
0.2521180808544159,
-0.38978180289268494,
-0.4182295799255371,
-0.03101666457951069,
-0.6582871079444885,
-0.27190279960632324,
0.342513769865036,
-0.17711052298545837,
-0.13947317004203796,
0.6445543766021729,
-0.2892942726612091,
0.7295380234718323,
-0.2149597853422165,
0.022749975323677063,
0.25669926404953003,
-0.7300354242324829,
-0.19277708232402802,
-0.14260560274124146,
0.6185125112533569,
0.5496748089790344,
-0.28558385372161865,
-0.3547404706478119,
-0.043827760964632034,
0.024238618090748787,
0.5896078944206238,
-0.4468413293361664,
-0.28014665842056274,
-0.0027413396164774895,
-0.5315425992012024,
-0.6104243397712708,
0.15141776204109192,
-1.031335473060608,
-0.4402937889099121,
-0.41700831055641174,
0.20459790527820587,
-0.2191047966480255,
-0.22425620257854462,
0.25029218196868896,
-0.23384857177734375,
-0.06542328745126724,
0.3828752040863037,
-0.5634252429008484,
0.27880603075027466,
0.829513430595398,
0.8449627161026001,
-0.19126150012016296,
-0.7006692886352539,
-0.5110383629798889,
-0.4571247398853302,
-0.3491238057613373,
0.8059308528900146,
-0.13221722841262817,
-0.3272846043109894,
0.12195850163698196,
0.14306484162807465,
0.12090712040662766,
-0.5833475589752197,
0.8844161033630371,
-0.6477670669555664,
0.6401689648628235,
-0.39693114161491394,
-0.2782493829727173,
-0.4997183680534363,
0.16939234733581543,
-0.8261711597442627,
0.8214401006698608,
0.28961923718452454,
-1.0198557376861572,
0.5537791848182678,
-0.6483703851699829,
-0.2001347839832306,
-0.07470662146806717,
0.22256426513195038,
-0.7502745985984802,
-0.09729104489088058,
-0.020225219428539276,
0.018403904512524605,
-0.21295428276062012,
-0.005846354644745588,
-0.08178012073040009,
-0.25472110509872437,
0.4053725004196167,
-0.15121617913246155,
0.9878359436988831,
0.07537049800157547,
-0.6183879971504211,
0.2914707660675049,
-0.7052783966064453,
-0.2147834151983261,
0.1241866797208786,
-0.2621972858905792,
-0.06864873319864273,
0.17667624354362488,
-0.29868531227111816,
0.03408728912472725,
0.05131233483552933,
-0.5527490377426147,
-0.051654212176799774,
-0.0076469010673463345,
0.4459225833415985,
0.2661362886428833,
0.322383850812912,
0.4855928421020508,
-0.818026065826416,
0.8353686332702637,
-0.1521369218826294,
0.2620437443256378,
-0.16112546622753143,
-0.6892209053039551,
-0.6643489599227905,
-0.0652487576007843,
0.5147861838340759,
0.3388519883155823,
-0.47255170345306396,
0.1811099499464035,
-0.14446240663528442,
-0.5841385126113892,
-0.5792294144630432,
0.09318453818559647,
0.41987162828445435,
0.7140607833862305,
0.4061645567417145,
-0.1111956313252449,
-1.053179144859314,
-1.1768262386322021,
-0.3594498038291931,
-0.1483505815267563,
0.09875591844320297,
0.161325603723526,
0.8319907784461975,
-0.4181201756000519,
1.075447916984558,
-0.27587711811065674,
0.05982061102986336,
-0.3423100411891937,
0.6413131356239319,
0.030100582167506218,
0.3098517060279846,
0.8270305395126343,
-0.6942462921142578,
0.12081192433834076,
-0.28989118337631226,
-0.7491487860679626,
-0.30186060070991516,
-0.03882339969277382,
-0.2765330970287323,
0.38267117738723755,
-0.017869679257273674,
-0.3273775279521942,
0.4573744237422943,
0.73553866147995,
-0.49708208441734314,
1.1106607913970947,
-0.2913583219051361,
0.49756506085395813,
-0.7073845267295837,
0.11308127641677856,
-0.03708827868103981,
-0.6027899980545044,
-0.3010364770889282,
0.32231783866882324,
-0.22161680459976196,
-0.11264172196388245,
-0.27496978640556335,
0.25415605306625366,
-0.27755385637283325,
-0.2348986715078354,
-0.38444551825523376,
0.46777859330177307,
0.20833119750022888,
0.16973909735679626,
-0.11982933431863785,
0.4617224335670471,
0.1494317501783371,
-0.5295331478118896,
0.44765791296958923,
0.2695164680480957,
-0.4663558006286621,
0.1453886181116104,
-0.9552953243255615,
0.1475253701210022,
-0.02364414557814598,
0.5121759176254272,
-0.7754653096199036,
-0.3509463965892792,
0.6261698603630066,
-0.4958272874355316,
-0.24560482800006866,
-0.1893836408853531,
-0.5124095678329468,
-0.37575221061706543,
-0.2693578898906708,
0.08943522721529007,
0.691238284111023,
-0.6772403120994568,
0.448758989572525,
0.09629431366920471,
-0.10505372285842896,
-0.7405266165733337,
-0.4364851713180542,
0.01517433114349842,
-0.16601857542991638,
-0.6810677647590637,
0.26771846413612366,
0.30035263299942017,
-0.546109676361084,
0.32178542017936707,
-0.18160977959632874,
0.16086827218532562,
0.19182372093200684,
0.2855888903141022,
0.4193349778652191,
-0.18885621428489685,
-0.023165838792920113,
-0.28201740980148315,
-0.04051095247268677,
0.39386287331581116,
0.1017884835600853,
0.26786884665489197,
-0.020584801211953163,
-0.25444087386131287,
-0.6324250102043152,
0.571283221244812,
0.302961528301239,
-0.22412286698818207,
0.7938600778579712,
0.37993836402893066,
-0.1888008415699005,
-0.24444679915905,
-0.43699175119400024,
-0.3231540322303772,
-0.36294877529144287,
0.20773819088935852,
0.056113168597221375,
-0.7125741839408875,
0.4168567955493927,
-0.0325278714299202,
0.36383056640625,
0.8932985663414001,
0.3729720711708069,
-0.22686028480529785,
0.702142059803009,
0.6659067869186401,
0.3102903962135315,
0.405692458152771,
-0.4254249632358551,
-0.2389228641986847,
-0.7965976595878601,
-0.4779905676841736,
-0.6052838563919067,
-0.1462678760290146,
-0.5624170303344727,
-0.7141977548599243,
-0.032921917736530304,
0.32115495204925537,
0.081709124147892,
0.22538819909095764,
-0.6875616312026978,
0.02365514449775219,
0.6094136238098145,
0.27080851793289185,
0.5806015729904175,
0.1179003044962883,
0.23764562606811523,
-0.11931534111499786,
-0.7151055335998535,
-0.8041835427284241,
0.866816520690918,
0.15842774510383606,
0.2495674341917038,
0.037223245948553085,
0.7240963578224182,
0.7858681082725525,
0.9243418574333191,
-0.4665202796459198,
0.42202144861221313,
0.005133848171681166,
-0.7290061116218567,
-0.3112136721611023,
-0.4641808867454529,
-1.0522717237472534,
0.48766282200813293,
-0.3829111158847809,
-0.4371422827243805,
0.1537085771560669,
0.336838036775589,
-0.2682605981826782,
0.03901992738246918,
-0.4852050244808197,
0.7068725228309631,
0.03650397062301636,
-0.2877793610095978,
-0.4908495545387268,
-0.4619881808757782,
0.6445001363754272,
0.004437651950865984,
0.2950933873653412,
0.08215697854757309,
0.0727439597249031,
1.0885809659957886,
-0.4552325904369354,
0.7911199927330017,
-0.17691554129123688,
0.008915610611438751,
0.46876752376556396,
-0.053477365523576736,
0.31836622953414917,
0.23624682426452637,
-0.23265303671360016,
-0.0314987488090992,
-0.0069573684595525265,
-0.38222286105155945,
-0.9280558228492737,
0.4381841719150543,
-0.7466930150985718,
-0.9541818499565125,
-0.6588037610054016,
-0.11569300293922424,
0.2662762701511383,
0.062057655304670334,
0.2586584687232971,
0.5825418829917908,
-0.03769531473517418,
0.48711684346199036,
0.13430552184581757,
-0.3243112564086914,
0.029038304463028908,
0.6732097268104553,
-0.6195647716522217,
-0.43924763798713684,
0.38110870122909546,
-0.04813329502940178,
-0.0033156871795654297,
-0.00485149584710598,
0.3780803382396698,
-0.25351041555404663,
-0.38754597306251526,
-0.2211959809064865,
0.5318841338157654,
-0.5902360677719116,
-0.06304768472909927,
-0.6359153389930725,
-0.12456352263689041,
-0.08167087286710739,
0.07062099874019623,
-0.21999379992485046,
-0.4265907108783722,
-0.19352860748767853,
-0.15257246792316437,
0.47433164715766907,
1.1635233163833618,
-0.5220996141433716,
0.23632797598838806,
-0.547477662563324,
0.6904537677764893,
0.35937371850013733,
0.26134222745895386,
0.03424685075879097,
-0.9281757473945618,
-0.2530669867992401,
0.47800689935684204,
-0.22132913768291473,
-1.0927180051803589,
0.2582624554634094,
0.02662556990981102,
0.5475941300392151,
-0.17126813530921936,
0.04228116571903229,
0.47944921255111694,
-0.24071180820465088,
0.9820944666862488,
0.08000195026397705,
-0.8594557642936707,
0.5137622952461243,
0.004330065567046404,
-0.14731717109680176,
0.3591528832912445,
0.4221481382846832,
-0.49353668093681335,
-0.3735553026199341,
-0.9890053868293762,
-0.6719546914100647,
0.8399755954742432,
0.19605469703674316,
0.07594818621873856,
0.11390059441328049,
0.631843626499176,
0.34919241070747375,
0.05142351612448692,
-0.5696794986724854,
-0.36397847533226013,
-0.3160402476787567,
0.42415934801101685,
-0.027817046269774437,
-0.7285197973251343,
-0.6238124966621399,
-0.23160645365715027,
0.6595116853713989,
0.16474832594394684,
0.3447284996509552,
0.7895858287811279,
-0.11764933168888092,
-0.041236042976379395,
0.3522900342941284,
1.001251220703125,
1.2898414134979248,
-0.27488359808921814,
0.3053126335144043,
-0.21936294436454773,
-0.3211664855480194,
0.11134070158004761,
-0.008703506551682949,
-0.1900821477174759,
0.43671032786369324,
0.9083188772201538,
0.8295099139213562,
0.37295547127723694,
-0.33078691363334656,
0.5700652003288269,
0.11051559448242188,
-0.5029111504554749,
-0.603958249092102,
-0.11411513388156891,
0.11049121618270874,
0.12382584810256958,
0.5648804903030396,
0.46137723326683044,
0.07933998107910156,
-0.9026052951812744,
0.7094210982322693,
-0.014580088667571545,
-0.058677077293395996,
-0.5852831602096558,
0.7280687689781189,
0.07243456691503525,
-0.5889026522636414,
0.7230844497680664,
-0.4506301283836365,
-0.8817675709724426,
0.5965555310249329,
0.5678840279579163,
0.5130881071090698,
0.08327708393335342,
0.6557076573371887,
0.48481616377830505,
0.3729413151741028,
-0.25078853964805603,
0.44208288192749023,
-0.0006563409115187824,
-0.7555094361305237,
-0.7815417051315308,
-0.39978480339050293,
-0.7010354399681091,
0.06823704391717911,
-0.9056469798088074,
-0.07867808640003204,
-0.14111265540122986,
-0.16437974572181702,
0.2292681336402893,
-0.028561541810631752,
-0.6456030607223511,
0.24130025506019592,
-0.23118364810943604,
0.8883780241012573,
-1.0165990591049194,
0.4269058406352997,
0.688517689704895,
-0.5713412165641785,
-0.6362894773483276,
-0.03397221863269806,
-0.13890095055103302,
-0.6980378031730652,
0.6675059199333191,
-0.205105721950531,
-0.31260284781455994,
-0.35119450092315674,
-0.65574711561203,
-0.5422956943511963,
1.0721720457077026,
0.6197181344032288,
-0.3637126088142395,
0.16450056433677673,
-0.23598921298980713,
0.7690251469612122,
-0.42760327458381653,
-0.07147686928510666,
0.7305575013160706,
0.5140944719314575,
-0.02161603607237339,
-0.6442611217498779,
0.21884475648403168,
-0.21751940250396729,
-0.46782588958740234,
-0.3218964636325836,
-0.4471213221549988,
0.3900511562824249,
-0.5126082897186279,
-0.31654229760169983,
0.26417025923728943,
0.6821869015693665,
0.6727880835533142,
0.43581560254096985,
0.8229269981384277,
0.5329156517982483,
0.6149212121963501,
-0.07541685551404953,
1.5578913688659668,
-0.061414092779159546,
0.48359113931655884,
1.3734456300735474,
-0.014603786170482635,
0.9040346741676331,
0.3813380002975464,
-0.4919412136077881,
0.937822163105011,
0.5764397382736206,
-0.2599986791610718,
0.3697091341018677,
0.1897154450416565,
-0.005997862666845322,
-0.08842337131500244,
-0.2425713837146759,
-0.3639240562915802,
0.5950697660446167,
-0.2959413528442383,
-0.7758765816688538,
0.029561510309576988,
-0.178566113114357,
-0.0027183962520211935,
0.10168483108282089,
0.05947861075401306,
0.5187808871269226,
0.000033262862416449934,
-0.8587012887001038,
0.4491387903690338,
-0.052973534911870956,
0.45801931619644165,
-0.23518159985542297,
-0.3391910791397095,
-0.3149394690990448,
-0.10750681906938553,
-0.42135295271873474,
-0.7413021922111511,
0.6157925724983215,
0.0883181020617485,
-0.5024312734603882,
-0.4187484681606293,
0.5137117505073547,
-0.26543110609054565,
-0.44840535521507263,
0.2627936899662018,
0.45100438594818115,
0.2980911135673523,
-0.014980045147240162,
-0.5028937458992004,
0.0817863792181015,
0.2522995173931122,
-0.3578624129295349,
-0.02488686703145504,
0.39243027567863464,
0.1559327095746994,
0.5851757526397705,
0.5608624219894409,
0.1670726239681244,
0.18705032765865326,
0.1489657312631607,
0.4498439133167267,
-0.6716576218605042,
-0.16857147216796875,
-0.9229844212532043,
0.5615383386611938,
-0.30975106358528137,
-0.3917965590953827,
0.7161381840705872,
0.6007104516029358,
0.3265470862388611,
-0.2222689539194107,
0.7975761890411377,
-0.0836443305015564,
0.7111316919326782,
-0.27629873156547546,
0.6466704607009888,
-0.543704092502594,
0.04837469756603241,
-0.004015848506242037,
-0.8236585259437561,
-0.057443562895059586,
0.4176765978336334,
0.01668032445013523,
-0.12269316613674164,
0.8519020676612854,
0.36041101813316345,
0.1169530600309372,
0.11547566205263138,
0.11132992058992386,
0.2031627595424652,
-0.10025108605623245,
-0.2028340846300125,
1.0246083736419678,
-0.3197088837623596,
0.3825075924396515,
-0.7717499732971191,
-0.2799636423587799,
-0.4426487386226654,
-1.222129464149475,
-0.2959275543689728,
-0.7126959562301636,
-0.5261152982711792,
-0.5207234621047974,
-0.047247692942619324,
0.471614807844162,
0.6730087995529175,
-0.6725009679794312,
0.1362110674381256,
0.07135773450136185,
0.4475114047527313,
-0.6065797209739685,
-0.27625665068626404,
0.5011583566665649,
0.006934257224202156,
-0.4893866181373596,
0.22416704893112183,
0.030228232964873314,
-0.17412954568862915,
-0.3643254339694977,
0.1271853893995285,
-0.09211769700050354,
-0.1448204666376114,
0.6820584535598755,
0.28877824544906616,
-0.8800542950630188,
-0.6018065214157104,
-0.0871603786945343,
0.0589120090007782,
-0.0809597447514534,
1.0584441423416138,
-0.803519070148468,
0.45223546028137207,
0.5462554097175598,
0.45985692739486694,
0.4082934558391571,
0.37395069003105164,
0.8965156078338623,
-0.5520008206367493,
-0.02007005736231804,
0.17094166576862335,
0.6106020212173462,
0.6012720465660095,
-0.05670519545674324,
0.9313752055168152,
0.41047197580337524,
-0.7236493229866028,
-0.9288641810417175,
0.059503842145204544,
-1.0046019554138184,
0.10676150768995285,
1.0908360481262207,
-0.39534991979599,
-0.15113356709480286,
-0.11842598021030426,
-0.17463338375091553,
0.6000591516494751,
-0.1477733701467514,
1.104456901550293,
0.7768372297286987,
-0.2104850709438324,
-0.30430105328559875,
-0.5975072979927063,
0.5046060681343079,
0.401006817817688,
-0.7471184134483337,
0.11951655894517899,
0.29749128222465515,
0.5263384580612183,
0.4903775155544281,
0.45644932985305786,
-0.18692512810230255,
0.5764620304107666,
0.3203183114528656,
0.1792955994606018,
-0.047316309064626694,
-0.07475035637617111,
-0.12119720876216888,
0.1454334259033203,
0.029940688982605934,
-0.20565414428710938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17475v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17475v1
|
CEval: A Benchmark for Evaluating Counterfactual Text Generation
| 2024-04-26T15:23:47 | 2024-04-26T15:23:47 |
Van Bach Nguyen, Jörg Schlötterer, Christin Seifert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Counterfactual text generation aims to minimally change a text, such that it
is classified differently. Judging advancements in method development for
counterfactual text generation is hindered by a non-uniform usage of data sets
and metrics in related work. We propose CEval, a benchmark for comparing
counterfactual text generation methods. CEval unifies counterfactual and text
quality metrics, includes common counterfactual datasets with human
annotations, standard baselines (MICE, GDBA, CREST) and the open-source
language model LLAMA-2. Our experiments found no perfect method for generating
counterfactual text. Methods that excel at counterfactual metrics often produce
lower-quality text while LLMs with simple prompts generate high-quality text
but struggle with counterfactual criteria. By making CEval available as an
open-source Python library, we encourage the community to contribute more
methods and maintain consistent evaluation in future work.
|
[
-0.23762108385562897,
-0.7933706641197205,
0.4807628393173218,
0.3626967668533325,
-0.4254879355430603,
-0.19663754105567932,
0.012448595836758614,
-0.4566517174243927,
-0.10628081113100052,
0.37336158752441406,
-0.4298420548439026,
-0.4184107482433319,
-0.37111911177635193,
0.33765122294425964,
-0.6127615571022034,
0.9544965624809265,
0.05350184813141823,
-0.0301857590675354,
-0.6439409852027893,
-0.3685823380947113,
-0.3698737919330597,
-0.2898077368736267,
-0.4284549951553345,
-0.4415448009967804,
0.5656291842460632,
0.4450860321521759,
0.5966500043869019,
0.4224749803543091,
0.29616984724998474,
0.28419357538223267,
0.10442303121089935,
0.31145617365837097,
-0.5180238485336304,
0.2891829013824463,
-0.4718209207057953,
-0.1257210522890091,
-0.29264622926712036,
0.0965939462184906,
0.37988173961639404,
0.2809971868991852,
-0.014900889247655869,
0.4168860614299774,
0.03982577100396156,
0.48194605112075806,
-0.9000543355941772,
-0.11361285299062729,
-0.6161708235740662,
-0.18477775156497955,
-0.35335010290145874,
-0.08475732803344727,
-0.25624608993530273,
-0.7304274439811707,
-0.12341827154159546,
-0.654999315738678,
0.27683886885643005,
-0.06444218754768372,
0.8116006851196289,
0.3553163409233093,
-0.4499451220035553,
-0.3494722843170166,
-0.366710364818573,
0.7892773747444153,
-0.6475545763969421,
0.25384336709976196,
0.2303813397884369,
0.031520284712314606,
-0.051409363746643066,
-0.8728638887405396,
-0.8638560175895691,
-0.33499598503112793,
0.08534473925828934,
0.151728093624115,
-0.5667840838432312,
-0.3419385850429535,
0.25982406735420227,
0.14692218601703644,
-0.6691253185272217,
-0.0027085409965366125,
-0.07776445895433426,
-0.22548900544643402,
0.5800540447235107,
0.2861073911190033,
0.2829570472240448,
-0.05781565234065056,
-0.257936954498291,
-0.3391871750354767,
-1.0509518384933472,
0.02396012842655182,
0.358197420835495,
-0.0026510765310376883,
0.12113035470247269,
0.5067129731178284,
-0.5720518827438354,
0.43147122859954834,
-0.02984335646033287,
-0.013967825099825859,
0.4234675467014313,
-0.4008355438709259,
-0.25185900926589966,
0.2007237672805786,
0.8803976774215698,
0.8281962275505066,
0.3035561144351959,
0.11640748381614685,
-0.11826381087303162,
0.779787003993988,
0.29763874411582947,
-1.1149884462356567,
-0.2339174598455429,
-0.12278246134519577,
-0.36900076270103455,
-0.7653515934944153,
-0.38802051544189453,
-0.8595133423805237,
-0.46164238452911377,
-0.005519571248441935,
0.3502264618873596,
-0.1178390309214592,
-0.04841877892613411,
-0.5370672345161438,
-0.13037769496440887,
0.04146452993154526,
0.2819417119026184,
-0.6263288259506226,
0.1403806358575821,
0.44752562046051025,
0.566673755645752,
-0.24729487299919128,
-0.24745121598243713,
-0.90703284740448,
-0.3060969114303589,
-0.8181940317153931,
1.0150314569473267,
-0.6708551049232483,
-0.6363521218299866,
0.09534977376461029,
-0.09564995765686035,
0.4947107434272766,
-0.498752236366272,
0.6913314461708069,
-0.08602090179920197,
0.034350138157606125,
-0.5660765767097473,
-0.37050920724868774,
-0.024796321988105774,
0.19390647113323212,
-0.34096193313598633,
1.2882665395736694,
0.06124167889356613,
-0.8092637658119202,
0.787075936794281,
-0.26076820492744446,
-0.3806973695755005,
0.2622638940811157,
-0.5043482184410095,
-0.6371394395828247,
0.15283595025539398,
0.06445356458425522,
0.192716583609581,
-0.5489752292633057,
0.36974918842315674,
-0.3170318007469177,
-0.34667205810546875,
0.4243040680885315,
-0.7462716102600098,
0.4104744493961334,
0.280543714761734,
-0.3677895963191986,
-0.384166419506073,
-0.8869631886482239,
0.1382482349872589,
0.04020949825644493,
-0.24034391343593597,
-0.5784562826156616,
0.10835199058055878,
0.21731095016002655,
0.11694896966218948,
0.4547794759273529,
-0.7854329347610474,
-0.13348956406116486,
-0.2825815677642822,
0.18228864669799805,
0.4376599192619324,
0.17818491160869598,
-0.04076671227812767,
-0.5725101232528687,
0.0843532606959343,
0.042974427342414856,
-0.13637687265872955,
-0.34015312790870667,
-0.5796385407447815,
-0.7300017476081848,
0.030079172924160957,
0.18249337375164032,
0.4500148594379425,
-0.8780577182769775,
-0.11846841871738434,
0.09634517878293991,
-0.8572635650634766,
-0.1931605488061905,
0.15729688107967377,
0.9432213306427002,
0.9435866475105286,
0.4837620258331299,
-0.3438206613063812,
-0.5731573700904846,
-0.9040291905403137,
-0.45511722564697266,
-0.43691709637641907,
0.1424824595451355,
0.20678973197937012,
0.5083635449409485,
-0.3506011962890625,
0.9474877119064331,
-0.29635733366012573,
0.17343451082706451,
0.361843079328537,
0.8508143424987793,
-0.04530457779765129,
0.5467842221260071,
0.6887655258178711,
-0.6265882253646851,
-0.40201887488365173,
-0.065086729824543,
-0.7611978650093079,
-0.7290917038917542,
-0.07811465114355087,
0.07437223196029663,
0.5728151202201843,
0.7598730325698853,
-0.2669675946235657,
0.6480786204338074,
0.6792014241218567,
-0.3919648826122284,
0.7252246141433716,
-0.13329336047172546,
0.6081299781799316,
-0.7679265737533569,
0.3704238831996918,
-0.030675766989588737,
-0.22477026283740997,
-0.6200254559516907,
-0.1204129010438919,
0.24567441642284393,
0.18975821137428284,
-0.7291319966316223,
0.7520086765289307,
-0.005367911420762539,
0.03458120673894882,
-0.22622895240783691,
0.3202875256538391,
0.10370302945375443,
0.1895110160112381,
0.07796239852905273,
0.9972520470619202,
0.10268419235944748,
-0.6490784883499146,
0.2796994149684906,
0.2096358835697174,
-0.48934659361839294,
1.218991756439209,
-0.8521701097488403,
0.11880610883235931,
0.05531953647732735,
0.02436196431517601,
-0.9965375661849976,
-0.01224881038069725,
0.07938328385353088,
-0.5929818153381348,
-0.17924140393733978,
0.15229974687099457,
-0.48796164989471436,
-0.1291496902704239,
-0.46261245012283325,
0.41231027245521545,
0.5408613681793213,
-0.687961220741272,
-0.10379341244697571,
0.010340272448956966,
-0.2492205649614334,
-0.6149595379829407,
-0.8743641972541809,
0.2961181700229645,
-0.0848279669880867,
-0.2944108545780182,
0.3523905575275421,
-0.34133997559547424,
-0.42127925157546997,
0.000056976376072270796,
-0.15804943442344666,
0.10469502210617065,
-0.06545136868953705,
0.20935370028018951,
0.2249697893857956,
-0.1905573457479477,
0.1429731398820877,
0.4252380132675171,
-0.08752401173114777,
0.1181468516588211,
0.023707911372184753,
0.09863303601741791,
-0.009810064919292927,
-0.20739589631557465,
0.03382371366024017,
0.2539099454879761,
0.36442697048187256,
-0.015566633082926273,
0.2817551791667938,
0.5824799537658691,
-0.35695168375968933,
-0.14324158430099487,
-0.5105488896369934,
0.32369157671928406,
-0.46991726756095886,
0.31888630986213684,
-0.14391715824604034,
-0.4834258556365967,
0.19486233592033386,
-0.21320085227489471,
0.25664740800857544,
0.5940134525299072,
0.7714423537254333,
-0.093076691031456,
0.8442482352256775,
0.3586789667606354,
0.4780401587486267,
0.43248888850212097,
0.37760889530181885,
-0.3120725750923157,
-0.5515502691268921,
-0.14361678063869476,
-0.8072237968444824,
0.08119731396436691,
-0.6413679718971252,
-0.28467828035354614,
0.1353207677602768,
0.140013188123703,
-0.5395023822784424,
0.44855719804763794,
-0.6173679232597351,
0.3931749165058136,
0.40010523796081543,
-0.02896076813340187,
0.45213890075683594,
-0.06683222949504852,
-0.34271201491355896,
-0.24738411605358124,
-0.29359039664268494,
-0.8226401805877686,
1.1237772703170776,
-0.07416936010122299,
0.6328310966491699,
0.07075069099664688,
0.7166210412979126,
0.6592878699302673,
0.8790410161018372,
-0.158508762717247,
0.5167987942695618,
-0.412905216217041,
-0.32551831007003784,
-0.2470812201499939,
-0.5212217569351196,
-0.9419960379600525,
0.24822171032428741,
-0.49380049109458923,
-0.821185827255249,
0.35515347123146057,
0.27273261547088623,
-0.10423623025417328,
-0.12377745658159256,
-0.45363661646842957,
0.8167144060134888,
-0.06351246684789658,
-0.5745334625244141,
-0.1529015749692917,
-0.1372184455394745,
0.21980920433998108,
-0.31573590636253357,
0.14510923624038696,
-0.16632886230945587,
-0.27142658829689026,
0.7503268122673035,
-0.5620665550231934,
0.8086612820625305,
-0.027265965938568115,
-0.2322651743888855,
0.5720400810241699,
0.3313705027103424,
0.4267563223838806,
0.307876855134964,
-0.12268492579460144,
0.36025935411453247,
0.11522345244884491,
-0.28049057722091675,
-0.23459875583648682,
0.9062418937683105,
-0.7466083765029907,
-0.18803907930850983,
-0.4784380793571472,
-0.14548233151435852,
-0.2223108857870102,
0.2597697377204895,
0.714736819267273,
0.6331256031990051,
-0.9639902114868164,
0.14761395752429962,
0.6128950715065002,
-0.4153050184249878,
0.8345105648040771,
0.6628408432006836,
-0.07594171911478043,
-0.8314348459243774,
0.9811431169509888,
0.1361037790775299,
0.04087918624281883,
0.3633023202419281,
0.2651006877422333,
-0.3660091757774353,
-0.23005633056163788,
-0.6068776845932007,
-0.25508588552474976,
-0.6934676766395569,
-0.4567631483078003,
-0.3368303179740906,
0.026020603254437447,
-0.2622651755809784,
-0.39175885915756226,
-0.41691482067108154,
-0.35205748677253723,
-0.4745555818080902,
0.276050865650177,
0.42346036434173584,
0.8116870522499084,
-0.1799853891134262,
0.09138817340135574,
-0.6954891085624695,
0.40705689787864685,
0.6352197527885437,
0.10573115944862366,
-0.1923852413892746,
-0.31627392768859863,
-0.07189290970563889,
-0.004874111618846655,
-0.644120991230011,
-0.759373128414154,
0.37138208746910095,
0.10030204802751541,
0.5207400321960449,
0.1699731945991516,
0.3163728415966034,
0.3212994635105133,
-0.4453553557395935,
0.971002459526062,
0.587022602558136,
-1.1762478351593018,
0.5984562039375305,
-0.3450517952442169,
0.49096354842185974,
0.6768363118171692,
0.03768591210246086,
-0.6694226861000061,
-0.41449904441833496,
-0.6587774753570557,
-0.6314513087272644,
0.3037148416042328,
0.47416844964027405,
-0.036108680069446564,
-0.2569757401943207,
-0.01553372573107481,
0.3529820144176483,
0.40059295296669006,
-0.6054193377494812,
-0.015491015277802944,
-0.7072228193283081,
-0.2545158565044403,
-0.23226216435432434,
-0.18056781589984894,
-0.07461629807949066,
0.17608176171779633,
0.39620348811149597,
-0.2317230999469757,
-0.017626438289880753,
0.5093173980712891,
-0.29206302762031555,
-0.3453615605831146,
0.3200222849845886,
0.814113199710846,
0.6032623052597046,
0.07030985504388809,
0.1433708369731903,
0.6499359607696533,
-0.5770975351333618,
0.16543161869049072,
-0.05023404210805893,
-0.4287041127681732,
0.12378062307834625,
0.4536292552947998,
0.4294849932193756,
0.09703861176967621,
-0.6657357215881348,
0.600227415561676,
-0.1322384774684906,
-0.4313544034957886,
-0.06426616758108139,
0.2533259093761444,
-0.06451021879911423,
0.16026662290096283,
0.28396329283714294,
0.17307685315608978,
0.07012146711349487,
-0.48821425437927246,
0.2704419195652008,
0.017139321193099022,
-0.42333272099494934,
-0.10136392712593079,
0.7759845852851868,
0.5864942073822021,
-0.4962370991706848,
0.4413256049156189,
-0.2967928946018219,
-0.05848583206534386,
0.7578389644622803,
0.41210848093032837,
0.8495727777481079,
-0.118196040391922,
0.41703322529792786,
0.5637304186820984,
0.2636837065219879,
-0.02776099555194378,
0.37168893218040466,
-0.11835717409849167,
-0.5057904124259949,
-0.25980591773986816,
-0.46960803866386414,
-0.7684139609336853,
0.1026555746793747,
-0.3693566620349884,
0.3437102735042572,
-0.34056174755096436,
-0.1653030663728714,
-0.04028257355093956,
-0.010568560101091862,
-0.6959437727928162,
0.4576566219329834,
0.08404084295034409,
0.834374189376831,
-0.9848664402961731,
0.5842481851577759,
0.7047098278999329,
-0.4413820207118988,
0.07288660109043121,
0.024566758424043655,
0.12712758779525757,
-0.5660621523857117,
0.5555641651153564,
0.13084356486797333,
-0.29138267040252686,
-0.4810246527194977,
-0.7848058938980103,
-0.5417922139167786,
0.9839639663696289,
0.29621464014053345,
-0.8998708128929138,
0.41548117995262146,
0.2463889718055725,
0.8977782726287842,
-0.4103245437145233,
0.45795902609825134,
0.4318690299987793,
0.48425036668777466,
-0.16417649388313293,
-0.7008166909217834,
0.40320390462875366,
-0.37427636981010437,
0.30540817975997925,
-0.14048030972480774,
-0.7902756929397583,
0.7867042422294617,
-0.026084287092089653,
-0.2853185832500458,
0.4468975067138672,
0.6389649510383606,
0.3658774495124817,
0.765925407409668,
0.39158231019973755,
0.5714991688728333,
0.6759498715400696,
-0.2178177535533905,
0.7197695970535278,
-0.052688151597976685,
0.2665654122829437,
1.097426176071167,
-0.3311878740787506,
0.9038664102554321,
0.26750463247299194,
-0.045713502913713455,
0.5722262859344482,
0.4873102307319641,
-0.07812030613422394,
0.6276903748512268,
0.24244169890880585,
-0.0928221195936203,
-0.34674179553985596,
-0.20521657168865204,
-0.4590168297290802,
0.34402593970298767,
0.34687334299087524,
-0.13993434607982635,
-0.37725162506103516,
-0.22157996892929077,
0.1442776918411255,
0.520719587802887,
-0.19346265494823456,
0.7242701649665833,
0.05779203027486801,
-0.7656276822090149,
0.7340651750564575,
-0.13878777623176575,
0.6103062033653259,
-0.08918876200914383,
-0.33145084977149963,
-0.4448104798793793,
0.10036881268024445,
-0.1902392953634262,
-0.869025468826294,
0.2292904555797577,
0.41519680619239807,
-0.11972587555646896,
-0.133024200797081,
0.5430616140365601,
-0.2298807054758072,
-0.43214845657348633,
0.10767301172018051,
0.28003957867622375,
0.12892302870750427,
0.21763917803764343,
-0.5482788681983948,
0.15914121270179749,
-0.21265630424022675,
-0.2795565128326416,
0.161113440990448,
0.5755682587623596,
-0.17985694110393524,
0.2963232100009918,
0.671586811542511,
-0.1500210165977478,
-0.36595967411994934,
0.06171061098575592,
0.6969723105430603,
-0.6294938921928406,
-0.35613560676574707,
-0.781161367893219,
0.31896016001701355,
-0.18442831933498383,
-1.0183230638504028,
0.570613443851471,
0.3125073313713074,
0.811729371547699,
0.2004639059305191,
0.7711604833602905,
-0.11663363873958588,
0.47739288210868835,
-0.30006951093673706,
0.7790334224700928,
-0.6613588929176331,
0.10438317805528641,
-0.6648591756820679,
-0.9327340126037598,
0.025615325197577477,
0.3451095223426819,
-0.024395370855927467,
-0.046668436378240585,
0.7682633399963379,
0.9030425548553467,
0.25129345059394836,
0.006720619276165962,
0.5528238415718079,
0.18533100187778473,
0.19309186935424805,
0.47373366355895996,
0.9579529762268066,
-0.5227369666099548,
0.9487694501876831,
0.16697892546653748,
-0.3188737630844116,
-0.2806782126426697,
-1.2730766534805298,
-1.0211963653564453,
-0.6205081343650818,
-0.487113356590271,
-0.33686211705207825,
0.28815552592277527,
0.6176896691322327,
0.5087029933929443,
-0.7179050445556641,
0.04003603383898735,
-0.3338054418563843,
0.05364648997783661,
-0.29264557361602783,
-0.1640922725200653,
-0.03264429792761803,
-0.2622992992401123,
-0.6964734792709351,
0.3225807547569275,
0.18356499075889587,
-0.08249039202928543,
-0.2704605460166931,
-0.1864238828420639,
0.04697369039058685,
0.6569766998291016,
0.6403115391731262,
0.46117815375328064,
-0.46551620960235596,
-0.33783194422721863,
-0.23795059323310852,
-0.4974900782108307,
-0.02855866774916649,
0.6279199123382568,
-0.9056508541107178,
0.39613720774650574,
0.6909589171409607,
0.31310755014419556,
0.5110763907432556,
-0.1251360923051834,
0.44804489612579346,
-0.7261665463447571,
-0.19664883613586426,
-0.08570506423711777,
0.14874722063541412,
0.3539402484893799,
-0.2463729977607727,
0.5315646529197693,
0.2914651036262512,
-0.6258021593093872,
-0.8117457032203674,
0.1432560384273529,
-0.6256287097930908,
-0.3638474941253662,
1.0520431995391846,
-0.08990469574928284,
-0.15117035806179047,
-0.06489892303943634,
-0.24131862819194794,
0.24505901336669922,
-0.627449095249176,
0.6315245628356934,
0.46996060013771057,
-0.014297562651336193,
0.0800909548997879,
-0.23032256960868835,
0.45783039927482605,
0.36425498127937317,
-0.9527665972709656,
0.12336189299821854,
0.5062377452850342,
0.19722814857959747,
0.1776047945022583,
0.6680770516395569,
-0.10652291774749756,
0.6411229968070984,
0.6280542612075806,
0.17254400253295898,
-0.014285196550190449,
-0.23434090614318848,
-0.02018422819674015,
-0.04990854486823082,
-0.17538495361804962,
-0.09143345803022385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17460v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17460v1
|
Ruffle&Riley: Insights from Designing and Evaluating a Large Language Model-Based Conversational Tutoring System
| 2024-04-26T14:57:55 | 2024-04-26T14:57:55 |
Robin Schmucker, Meng Xia, Amos Azaria, Tom Mitchell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Conversational tutoring systems (CTSs) offer learning experiences through
interactions based on natural language. They are recognized for promoting
cognitive engagement and improving learning outcomes, especially in reasoning
tasks. Nonetheless, the cost associated with authoring CTS content is a major
obstacle to widespread adoption and to research on effective instructional
design. In this paper, we discuss and evaluate a novel type of CTS that
leverages recent advances in large language models (LLMs) in two ways: First,
the system enables AI-assisted content authoring by inducing an easily editable
tutoring script automatically from a lesson text. Second, the system automates
the script orchestration in a learning-by-teaching format via two LLM-based
agents (Ruffle&Riley) acting as a student and a professor. The system allows
for free-form conversations that follow the ITS-typical inner and outer loop
structure. We evaluate Ruffle&Riley's ability to support biology lessons in two
between-subject online user studies (N = 200) comparing the system to simpler
QA chatbots and reading activity. Analyzing system usage patterns,
pre/post-test scores and user experience surveys, we find that Ruffle&Riley
users report high levels of engagement, understanding and perceive the offered
support as helpful. Even though Ruffle&Riley users require more time to
complete the activity, we did not find significant differences in short-term
learning gains over the reading activity. Our system architecture and user
study provide various insights for designers of future CTSs. We further
open-source our system to support ongoing research on effective instructional
design of LLM-based learning technologies.
|
[
-0.08475181460380554,
-0.7888367176055908,
0.4332652688026428,
0.3909386992454529,
-0.011959521099925041,
0.35054343938827515,
-0.3673843443393707,
-0.6227416396141052,
0.22704167664051056,
0.26056692004203796,
-0.3964242935180664,
-0.2912360727787018,
-0.2056676596403122,
0.1274014711380005,
-0.3903461694717407,
0.8277347683906555,
0.41220980882644653,
0.4171401560306549,
-0.4052973985671997,
-0.05446448549628258,
-0.7687186002731323,
-0.3282642960548401,
-0.8204262256622314,
-0.3714156150817871,
0.6989268660545349,
0.5873523354530334,
0.6825371980667114,
0.5195006728172302,
0.3178735375404358,
0.27806079387664795,
-0.17852215468883514,
0.07203588634729385,
-0.4368928074836731,
0.39255717396736145,
-0.039493244141340256,
-0.365630179643631,
-0.3189799189567566,
-0.2757886052131653,
0.3435746729373932,
0.8074817061424255,
-0.21534229815006256,
-0.12456540763378143,
0.4182738959789276,
0.4621073305606842,
-0.6289201378822327,
0.1223631277680397,
-0.2390960454940796,
0.019208423793315887,
0.08119700103998184,
0.03368779644370079,
-0.9015031456947327,
-0.34372225403785706,
0.5489810705184937,
-0.5208366513252258,
-0.32282689213752747,
-0.24260546267032623,
0.35140442848205566,
0.05303620919585228,
-0.44999799132347107,
-0.6958379149436951,
-0.7308161854743958,
0.956786036491394,
-0.4536285698413849,
0.538115382194519,
0.13227179646492004,
0.2995220422744751,
-0.2895330488681793,
-0.6544691324234009,
-0.25656867027282715,
-0.4388713240623474,
-0.1769121140241623,
0.3303641974925995,
-0.17409920692443848,
-0.06626447290182114,
-0.1101425364613533,
0.26043495535850525,
-0.5573820471763611,
0.33306166529655457,
-0.17615939676761627,
-0.17215798795223236,
0.368817538022995,
0.32370781898498535,
0.21717442572116852,
-0.17634062469005585,
-0.2320583611726761,
-0.12905201315879822,
-0.3914702832698822,
0.32943305373191833,
0.20726343989372253,
0.381696492433548,
-0.31164252758026123,
0.4097849130630493,
0.240208700299263,
0.46356502175331116,
-0.16334094107151031,
-0.17596453428268433,
-0.1179041936993599,
0.04385683685541153,
-0.2583507001399994,
-0.07709347456693649,
0.6583752036094666,
0.05905095487833023,
0.37642163038253784,
-0.0873854011297226,
-0.1722264140844345,
-0.1344703882932663,
0.1648256480693817,
-0.7471640110015869,
-0.23020124435424805,
0.17157740890979767,
-0.3387862741947174,
-0.31655120849609375,
-0.10440290719270706,
-0.810613751411438,
-0.5295977592468262,
-0.5494701266288757,
0.3114437758922577,
-0.6384302377700806,
-0.2636740207672119,
0.14183077216148376,
-0.07439304888248444,
0.24435897171497345,
0.4919118285179138,
-0.6889389753341675,
0.33720457553863525,
0.548723042011261,
0.9584360122680664,
-0.41893643140792847,
-0.11358828097581863,
-0.35039108991622925,
0.0431230291724205,
-0.18239432573318481,
0.8964952230453491,
-0.7021281719207764,
-0.7420231699943542,
0.26974034309387207,
-0.045994266867637634,
0.011669982224702835,
-0.25182080268859863,
0.005469728726893663,
-0.5190414190292358,
0.2654632031917572,
0.10547655075788498,
-0.5388164520263672,
0.24621599912643433,
0.0889483168721199,
-0.4957473576068878,
0.774255633354187,
-0.02873854897916317,
-0.45644107460975647,
-0.04766593500971794,
-0.8207294940948486,
-0.5128642320632935,
0.31022077798843384,
-0.13902224600315094,
-0.17432379722595215,
-0.11796138435602188,
-0.043914563953876495,
0.225201815366745,
-0.139221653342247,
0.2316967397928238,
-0.18426917493343353,
-0.4698757231235504,
0.5548477172851562,
-0.3394761383533478,
0.9747762084007263,
0.4128681421279907,
-0.29737889766693115,
0.16267317533493042,
-0.694430947303772,
0.1294165402650833,
0.11610204726457596,
-0.5377870202064514,
-0.4507071077823639,
-0.05935969576239586,
0.11262162029743195,
-0.3183891475200653,
0.061567071825265884,
-0.3449379503726959,
0.40442490577697754,
-0.13927079737186432,
0.6997697353363037,
0.7332419157028198,
-0.12333696335554123,
0.5223780274391174,
-0.34371495246887207,
0.791958212852478,
-0.1779920756816864,
0.19275139272212982,
-0.703077495098114,
-0.2794383764266968,
-0.8824977874755859,
-0.526016116142273,
0.4531262516975403,
0.38468798995018005,
-0.5660949945449829,
0.048042021691799164,
0.07524678111076355,
-0.5655652284622192,
-0.2880890667438507,
-0.0819561630487442,
0.3851698338985443,
0.17706234753131866,
0.20591329038143158,
-0.14398562908172607,
-0.5214133262634277,
-0.6164121031761169,
0.10249313712120056,
-0.04201483353972435,
-0.053104840219020844,
0.4401133358478546,
0.3270523250102997,
-0.1568703055381775,
0.8871027231216431,
-0.5378961563110352,
-0.12498164176940918,
-0.35142937302589417,
0.13251140713691711,
-0.16337935626506805,
0.4239296019077301,
0.4717140793800354,
-0.21278168261051178,
-0.6311911344528198,
-0.07768634706735611,
-0.48916831612586975,
-0.23903901875019073,
-0.13177432119846344,
-0.03238705173134804,
0.7696259617805481,
0.36940503120422363,
-0.42676347494125366,
0.5762296319007874,
0.4407462179660797,
-0.16859722137451172,
0.8077656626701355,
-0.11319635808467865,
0.0064190588891506195,
-0.8858548402786255,
0.07189218699932098,
-0.1500602513551712,
-0.06819852441549301,
-0.3878905773162842,
0.0050621978007256985,
0.08824220299720764,
-0.205612450838089,
-0.3321131765842438,
0.41054588556289673,
-0.4927506744861603,
-0.12914805114269257,
-0.3348460793495178,
0.19599062204360962,
0.023768803104758263,
0.5369455218315125,
0.06950466334819794,
0.9264973402023315,
0.351618230342865,
-0.5240395665168762,
0.10898175090551376,
0.39728325605392456,
-0.3730906546115875,
0.7218673229217529,
-0.7009889483451843,
0.41700509190559387,
0.2087055891752243,
0.4424280524253845,
-0.9251484870910645,
-0.05713052675127983,
-0.018518023192882538,
-0.4045090973377228,
-0.060552481561899185,
-0.04272829368710518,
-0.17852163314819336,
-0.21784621477127075,
-0.27442413568496704,
0.2075439691543579,
0.4117656350135803,
-0.5517898201942444,
0.6055288910865784,
0.29035964608192444,
-0.359469473361969,
-0.535873532295227,
-0.5879843235015869,
0.4095548093318939,
-0.004665407817810774,
-0.6237519979476929,
0.07466299831867218,
-0.27136096358299255,
-0.3656584620475769,
-0.13744042813777924,
0.005491664167493582,
-0.0948377400636673,
0.05780695378780365,
0.25052693486213684,
0.2914602756500244,
-0.4646208584308624,
0.6053815484046936,
-0.020680135115981102,
-0.10103216767311096,
-0.032093171030282974,
-0.47078967094421387,
0.6849701404571533,
-0.08394141495227814,
-0.3008182644844055,
-0.7735021710395813,
0.41592249274253845,
0.74007248878479,
-0.22861893475055695,
0.5622454881668091,
0.2581005394458771,
0.010503910481929779,
-0.5181316137313843,
-0.564607560634613,
-0.3653967082500458,
-0.4676467478275299,
0.28731703758239746,
-0.14656293392181396,
-0.8831745386123657,
0.41820985078811646,
0.18073804676532745,
0.29981425404548645,
-0.05588140711188316,
0.38273799419403076,
-0.28311893343925476,
0.9181848764419556,
0.8259138464927673,
0.16532398760318756,
0.8993129730224609,
-0.35103580355644226,
0.08557602018117905,
-0.5184972882270813,
-0.397452712059021,
-0.8146726489067078,
-0.2936879098415375,
-0.2343887835741043,
0.03795931488275528,
0.2645300626754761,
-0.25737324357032776,
-0.3755289316177368,
0.2245822548866272,
-0.5602104663848877,
0.44125819206237793,
0.8164215683937073,
0.08692200481891632,
0.49072039127349854,
-0.02571212500333786,
-0.25264012813568115,
-0.04958440363407135,
-0.6276383996009827,
-0.6887760162353516,
1.0000700950622559,
0.17557114362716675,
0.9942163825035095,
0.2933139503002167,
0.2960937023162842,
0.43003049492836,
0.2296561896800995,
-1.0335171222686768,
0.6338092088699341,
0.0703972801566124,
-0.20655712485313416,
-0.4829683303833008,
-0.101214200258255,
-1.1166915893554688,
0.06298614293336868,
-0.28744271397590637,
-0.7253021597862244,
-0.07298149168491364,
0.08470166474580765,
-0.3388005197048187,
0.11157523095607758,
-0.8571786284446716,
0.6263852119445801,
-0.25126156210899353,
-0.5685703754425049,
-0.4732474684715271,
-0.4973200559616089,
0.1730327159166336,
0.14133523404598236,
0.11514794081449509,
0.6347582936286926,
0.13497677445411682,
0.7173193693161011,
-0.35320326685905457,
0.9765052795410156,
0.13535335659980774,
-0.19555483758449554,
0.5694092512130737,
0.49016109108924866,
0.23101000487804413,
0.07022848725318909,
-0.18616479635238647,
-0.1487334668636322,
0.3654460310935974,
-0.3020780384540558,
-0.5536530613899231,
0.7777035236358643,
-0.8456242084503174,
-0.713329553604126,
-0.4947001039981842,
-0.7764014601707458,
-0.15508046746253967,
0.17015475034713745,
-0.3897128999233246,
0.772730827331543,
-0.13407887518405914,
0.5383985638618469,
0.5953583717346191,
-0.2252054661512375,
0.5831767916679382,
0.7971174120903015,
-0.3631923496723175,
-0.5145573019981384,
0.7553460597991943,
-0.016160011291503906,
0.413666695356369,
0.14239969849586487,
0.45791348814964294,
-0.10409479588270187,
-0.4919387996196747,
-0.4216158986091614,
0.1814837008714676,
-0.6368845701217651,
-0.11097954213619232,
-0.8016505241394043,
-0.2547646164894104,
-0.646676242351532,
-0.4188425838947296,
-0.07569949328899384,
-0.30050602555274963,
-0.3654550015926361,
0.10162802040576935,
0.2899521291255951,
1.0089186429977417,
-0.07567162066698074,
0.6054233908653259,
-0.740305483341217,
-0.4062916040420532,
0.3952663242816925,
0.27041420340538025,
0.3548657298088074,
-0.5070993304252625,
-0.30710333585739136,
0.03656009957194328,
-0.740829348564148,
-0.7431139945983887,
0.22443677484989166,
-0.027321843430399895,
0.33522042632102966,
0.4049374759197235,
-0.006391421426087618,
0.6810250282287598,
-0.20221339166164398,
0.8283119201660156,
0.052169714123010635,
-0.9292553663253784,
0.2805778384208679,
-0.27316921949386597,
0.4249446392059326,
0.19316191971302032,
0.08222151547670364,
-0.7254944443702698,
-0.4627237915992737,
-0.29843956232070923,
-0.46050429344177246,
0.9198547601699829,
-0.09200934320688248,
0.2535669803619385,
0.0868590697646141,
0.1829497218132019,
0.3337218761444092,
0.032530348747968674,
-0.7140448093414307,
-0.020408693701028824,
-0.2168271541595459,
-0.4594116508960724,
0.17362158000469208,
-0.3549530804157257,
0.15962286293506622,
-0.017699046060442924,
0.810197114944458,
-0.2166958898305893,
0.06182932108640671,
0.029645772650837898,
-0.17418572306632996,
-0.05370350554585457,
0.4026809632778168,
0.7373011112213135,
0.48944994807243347,
0.04254281520843506,
-0.028028661385178566,
0.022599581629037857,
-0.5930240154266357,
-0.13996689021587372,
-0.27590909600257874,
-0.09002787619829178,
-0.2199658304452896,
0.4471970200538635,
0.38699018955230713,
0.43872079253196716,
-0.967640221118927,
0.4641062915325165,
-0.13610133528709412,
-0.18504077196121216,
-0.473969042301178,
0.16808128356933594,
0.4473837912082672,
0.33659759163856506,
0.24149484932422638,
-0.292234867811203,
-0.16417062282562256,
-0.4408762454986572,
0.02412540651857853,
0.5992917418479919,
-0.5006401538848877,
-0.3686460256576538,
0.20650990307331085,
0.6322799921035767,
-0.9243655204772949,
0.5370232462882996,
0.23715661466121674,
-0.18926803767681122,
0.7107465267181396,
0.7478275895118713,
0.6563641428947449,
-0.2236645221710205,
0.3956618010997772,
0.15139801800251007,
-0.04785432666540146,
0.19605857133865356,
-0.0056268032640218735,
-0.2770261764526367,
-0.3294014036655426,
-0.35260799527168274,
-0.3747268319129944,
-0.776890218257904,
0.4527053236961365,
-0.5538644790649414,
0.6551344990730286,
-0.4561407268047333,
0.03432492911815643,
0.16324761509895325,
-0.09228365868330002,
-0.34324464201927185,
-0.1395307332277298,
-0.05136838182806969,
0.9868056178092957,
-0.4493847191333771,
0.5529012084007263,
0.9045724272727966,
-0.3688632845878601,
-0.6482897996902466,
-0.235912024974823,
0.08822199702262878,
-0.7024314403533936,
0.5654970407485962,
0.11237804591655731,
-0.35060417652130127,
0.085492342710495,
-0.6080014705657959,
-0.707814633846283,
1.1164422035217285,
0.19681349396705627,
-0.5771061182022095,
-0.15316377580165863,
0.13170316815376282,
0.6905660629272461,
-0.4580744206905365,
0.5757895112037659,
0.33637017011642456,
0.17739024758338928,
0.5149403810501099,
-0.7588855624198914,
-0.3395422697067261,
0.10297433286905289,
-0.3666141927242279,
-0.009418617933988571,
-0.7377543449401855,
0.571695864200592,
-0.21121665835380554,
-0.30058425664901733,
0.5493422746658325,
0.47043663263320923,
-0.0768202394247055,
0.4104161262512207,
0.5214753150939941,
0.21657435595989227,
0.6367940306663513,
0.1256302297115326,
0.583449125289917,
-0.23570190370082855,
0.16523142158985138,
1.1046873331069946,
-0.32770437002182007,
0.6728891134262085,
0.5339069366455078,
-0.3204616904258728,
0.8337386846542358,
0.3518405854701996,
0.21831975877285004,
0.18408742547035217,
0.3441420793533325,
-0.22137577831745148,
-0.36616945266723633,
-0.2757464349269867,
-0.10222495347261429,
0.40959033370018005,
0.3765503168106079,
-0.03428180515766144,
-0.17510992288589478,
0.2751763164997101,
-0.04771386459469795,
0.32397913932800293,
-0.04368440806865692,
0.9432359933853149,
0.1599193811416626,
-0.7983000874519348,
0.2280486673116684,
-0.3545968234539032,
0.3984496295452118,
-0.6151934862136841,
-0.05905197933316231,
-0.3450387418270111,
0.2650632858276367,
-0.06537661701440811,
-0.6566281914710999,
0.04443102702498436,
0.1991838663816452,
0.0649925097823143,
-0.23148015141487122,
0.4452897608280182,
-0.3107542395591736,
-0.36947041749954224,
0.21330928802490234,
0.5755701065063477,
0.034606628119945526,
0.5459228754043579,
-0.4292229413986206,
0.2305966019630432,
-0.08106324076652527,
-0.2559046149253845,
0.2202659249305725,
0.3035997450351715,
-0.12996090948581696,
1.0824251174926758,
0.5979673862457275,
-0.13888953626155853,
-0.3591215908527374,
0.19244258105754852,
0.6356461048126221,
-0.6693258881568909,
-0.6330910921096802,
-0.5646359920501709,
0.5418691635131836,
0.10891778022050858,
-0.24611876904964447,
0.5982281565666199,
0.44238173961639404,
0.596624493598938,
0.06584624201059341,
0.8117986917495728,
0.00901446957141161,
0.5063673853874207,
-0.3790890872478485,
0.5502055287361145,
-0.4439960718154907,
0.3271026909351349,
-0.2408626824617386,
-0.7016274929046631,
-0.2811485230922699,
0.4255978763103485,
-0.2349177449941635,
-0.02537047304213047,
0.9782413840293884,
0.7700614333152771,
0.12945690751075745,
0.6318643093109131,
0.32625293731689453,
0.2725379168987274,
0.6330684423446655,
0.42784765362739563,
1.2129517793655396,
0.11388375610113144,
0.917469322681427,
-0.1305132508277893,
-0.3372955024242401,
-0.4648118317127228,
-0.7460669875144958,
-1.1511543989181519,
-0.5131188035011292,
-0.28449374437332153,
-0.37228289246559143,
0.22639793157577515,
1.1566786766052246,
0.4094280004501343,
-0.7130441069602966,
-0.5037118196487427,
-0.03470923379063606,
0.16360430419445038,
-0.05902685225009918,
-0.27889034152030945,
0.40822678804397583,
-0.591544508934021,
-0.8955048322677612,
0.2490382343530655,
0.22927580773830414,
0.1533498913049698,
-0.5790876150131226,
0.07121694833040237,
-0.009992347098886967,
0.2981503903865814,
0.6209492683410645,
0.2308783084154129,
-0.6834855675697327,
-0.4718666672706604,
0.4744288921356201,
-0.4421321451663971,
-0.0005423621623776853,
0.9574664831161499,
-0.9118795990943909,
0.2662576138973236,
0.22976462543010712,
0.7601102590560913,
0.22353608906269073,
-0.27091988921165466,
0.45998650789260864,
-0.05667789652943611,
0.007131325080990791,
0.159890815615654,
0.2469915896654129,
0.24277357757091522,
-0.2452392578125,
0.337169885635376,
0.10566085577011108,
-0.7393860816955566,
-0.9163285493850708,
0.07924512773752213,
-1.0680261850357056,
-0.3457939922809601,
1.0695185661315918,
-0.13423305749893188,
-0.2030414640903473,
-0.2834656834602356,
-0.6308766603469849,
0.04933810979127884,
-0.6146037578582764,
1.0310680866241455,
0.7555312514305115,
-0.12971290946006775,
0.0714743360877037,
-0.32651957869529724,
0.07066284120082855,
0.5282204747200012,
-0.5510811805725098,
0.18765529990196228,
0.6267409920692444,
0.2843265235424042,
0.13424499332904816,
0.26246896386146545,
0.15584972500801086,
0.3011033236980438,
-0.26942646503448486,
0.18987303972244263,
-0.3348795473575592,
-0.4459582269191742,
-0.3081784248352051,
0.14754855632781982,
-0.129922017455101,
-0.026874078437685966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06662v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06662v1
|
Language Interaction Network for Clinical Trial Approval Estimation
| 2024-04-26T14:50:59 | 2024-04-26T14:50:59 |
Chufan Gao, Tianfan Fu, Jimeng Sun
|
q-bio.BM
|
q-bio.BM, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Clinical trial outcome prediction seeks to estimate the likelihood that a
clinical trial will successfully reach its intended endpoint. This process
predominantly involves the development of machine learning models that utilize
a variety of data sources such as descriptions of the clinical trials,
characteristics of the drug molecules, and specific disease conditions being
targeted. Accurate predictions of trial outcomes are crucial for optimizing
trial planning and prioritizing investments in a drug portfolio. While previous
research has largely concentrated on small-molecule drugs, there is a growing
need to focus on biologics-a rapidly expanding category of therapeutic agents
that often lack the well-defined molecular properties associated with
traditional drugs. Additionally, applying conventional methods like graph
neural networks to biologics data proves challenging due to their complex
nature. To address these challenges, we introduce the Language Interaction
Network (LINT), a novel approach that predicts trial outcomes using only the
free-text descriptions of the trials. We have rigorously tested the
effectiveness of LINT across three phases of clinical trials, where it achieved
ROC-AUC scores of 0.770, 0.740, and 0.748 for phases I, II, and III,
respectively, specifically concerning trials involving biologic interventions.
|
[
-0.13329876959323883,
-0.800746500492096,
0.7287916541099548,
0.2495620846748352,
-0.07605632394552231,
0.17847049236297607,
-0.11539209634065628,
-0.5555909872055054,
0.5705928802490234,
0.7504715919494629,
-0.2711475193500519,
-0.5743981003761292,
-0.901093065738678,
-0.09029247611761093,
-0.3194683790206909,
1.2963037490844727,
-0.22440233826637268,
0.4504956305027008,
-0.10212162882089615,
-0.35960501432418823,
-0.349562406539917,
-0.2675105035305023,
-0.7756929993629456,
-0.8231885433197021,
0.7621714472770691,
0.17107902467250824,
0.5000050067901611,
0.4656558334827423,
0.793391764163971,
0.3489547669887543,
-0.153872549533844,
0.019296588376164436,
-0.3401196599006653,
0.013134828768670559,
0.014435211196541786,
-0.3239828646183014,
-0.6032487750053406,
-0.09308093786239624,
0.19557377696037292,
1.1170207262039185,
-0.27061253786087036,
-0.24873250722885132,
0.07485844194889069,
0.6918585300445557,
-0.28465455770492554,
0.26215648651123047,
-0.4240482747554779,
0.3653968274593353,
0.2377043068408966,
-0.22132417559623718,
-0.36285653710365295,
-0.6144818067550659,
0.6952312588691711,
-0.6609640717506409,
0.13331477344036102,
0.040144309401512146,
0.7049645781517029,
-0.13992251455783844,
-0.5084677338600159,
-0.5633788704872131,
-0.43819761276245117,
0.48364242911338806,
-0.962595522403717,
0.0702795758843422,
0.6444162726402283,
0.4142840504646301,
-0.647491991519928,
-0.9201904535293579,
-0.3106244206428528,
-0.2950480580329895,
-0.48773103952407837,
0.32487255334854126,
-0.16793005168437958,
0.7023451924324036,
0.041056130081415176,
0.05179012566804886,
-0.6849650144577026,
-0.13231393694877625,
-0.3997197151184082,
-0.30892086029052734,
0.5164923071861267,
0.31263381242752075,
0.3725319504737854,
-0.3139573037624359,
-0.4760904610157013,
0.2653462290763855,
-0.33364421129226685,
0.22183145582675934,
-0.33415117859840393,
0.5573650598526001,
0.02121085673570633,
0.6483443379402161,
-0.3063734173774719,
0.49250510334968567,
-0.33546188473701477,
0.2658114731311798,
0.29327651858329773,
-0.5030071139335632,
-0.5630331635475159,
0.20009185373783112,
1.1622449159622192,
0.4225718080997467,
0.21148639917373657,
-0.08767539262771606,
-0.10112287104129791,
-0.1400625854730606,
0.24125488102436066,
-0.7845931649208069,
-0.15939182043075562,
0.4061124920845032,
-0.6933477520942688,
-0.6815597414970398,
-0.0854305550456047,
-0.7256086468696594,
-0.5262165665626526,
-0.11713529378175735,
0.5418558716773987,
-0.7481213212013245,
-0.18849937617778778,
0.1302296668291092,
-0.05697360262274742,
-0.09516505897045135,
0.34094083309173584,
-0.5620006918907166,
0.5660389065742493,
0.5507562160491943,
0.9808976054191589,
0.06884295493364334,
-0.25971174240112305,
-0.8032323718070984,
-0.05395154282450676,
-0.3439211845397949,
0.6931734085083008,
-0.2958700656890869,
-0.6211055517196655,
-0.05272475630044937,
0.11158592998981476,
-0.5013711452484131,
-0.07917959988117218,
0.36203533411026,
-0.4995186924934387,
0.028285181149840355,
0.03442609682679176,
-0.9723700881004333,
-0.3303450644016266,
0.08932387083768845,
-0.6883565187454224,
0.299096941947937,
0.145950585603714,
-0.5345694422721863,
0.38924551010131836,
-0.8322713971138,
-0.628059983253479,
0.3496823310852051,
-0.17515842616558075,
-0.4701186716556549,
0.2628228962421417,
0.06050679832696915,
0.2724055349826813,
0.020207567140460014,
0.3872811794281006,
-0.29818540811538696,
-0.15888512134552002,
0.530053436756134,
-0.08789711445569992,
0.4657873511314392,
0.23124602437019348,
-0.445437490940094,
0.19949060678482056,
-0.5685680508613586,
0.24732443690299988,
-0.18160316348075867,
-0.26929187774658203,
-0.19448325037956238,
0.002395125338807702,
0.16630186140537262,
0.06403782218694687,
-0.07912048697471619,
-0.5660524964332581,
0.14370577037334442,
-0.662625253200531,
0.1384306699037552,
0.7515373229980469,
0.03433633968234062,
0.2787911891937256,
-0.08757719397544861,
0.8178239464759827,
-0.28511226177215576,
0.28111475706100464,
0.044784754514694214,
-1.1129094362258911,
-0.580117404460907,
0.2326347678899765,
0.6345111727714539,
0.6524994969367981,
-0.7189155220985413,
0.2340133935213089,
-0.20590618252754211,
-0.22311443090438843,
-0.17214146256446838,
0.03916965052485466,
0.9182730913162231,
0.41982972621917725,
0.27673566341400146,
-0.4519609212875366,
-0.576712965965271,
-0.7317954897880554,
-0.22920288145542145,
-0.4216964840888977,
0.14839215576648712,
0.6292381286621094,
0.5778525471687317,
-0.3277016878128052,
0.7675941586494446,
-0.48740699887275696,
-0.637945830821991,
-0.36024555563926697,
0.4085555374622345,
0.3348570168018341,
0.26755523681640625,
0.23580053448677063,
-0.5984514355659485,
-0.5873531103134155,
0.6392279863357544,
-0.7676445245742798,
-0.018110523000359535,
0.03871537372469902,
0.06467113643884659,
-0.057292237877845764,
0.44558653235435486,
-0.2169133424758911,
0.9050880670547485,
0.8520257472991943,
-0.5706387162208557,
0.08484358340501785,
-0.5748094916343689,
0.2361532747745514,
-0.8849042654037476,
0.22060588002204895,
0.14464350044727325,
-0.40376582741737366,
-0.812893271446228,
-0.5014317631721497,
0.005646489094942808,
-0.039570365101099014,
-0.18599501252174377,
0.5368900299072266,
-0.10557166486978531,
0.052845150232315063,
-0.1301553100347519,
0.0445157065987587,
0.06544151902198792,
0.18947327136993408,
0.10582254081964493,
0.5170899629592896,
0.08745244145393372,
-0.318907231092453,
0.09946775436401367,
0.4381784200668335,
-0.5190610289573669,
-0.09647518396377563,
-0.7606764435768127,
-0.15030963718891144,
0.15673907101154327,
0.4482252299785614,
-0.8046301007270813,
-0.39540719985961914,
0.06916093826293945,
-0.7340309619903564,
0.12691718339920044,
-0.18645453453063965,
0.14895445108413696,
-0.4103888273239136,
0.021962828934192657,
0.2666701376438141,
0.2784139811992645,
0.07200558483600616,
0.8436357975006104,
0.34291356801986694,
-0.1669560670852661,
-0.6827095746994019,
-0.8557856678962708,
0.1928868293762207,
0.3492656648159027,
-0.4298267364501953,
-0.041994139552116394,
0.08007055521011353,
-0.019282788038253784,
0.23136284947395325,
0.48240146040916443,
-0.12057419866323471,
-0.19847722351551056,
0.46643587946891785,
0.2241751253604889,
-0.30180808901786804,
-0.021525617688894272,
0.10411325097084045,
-0.24883423745632172,
0.01595420204102993,
-0.13222025334835052,
0.26420772075653076,
0.0014164599124342203,
-0.4159240424633026,
-0.35639655590057373,
0.3261975347995758,
0.4819684326648712,
-0.040533218532800674,
0.6067551374435425,
0.35320448875427246,
-0.41681644320487976,
-0.11610949784517288,
-0.17720359563827515,
-0.049292393028736115,
-0.3722567856311798,
0.3535816967487335,
-0.11307938396930695,
-0.5554870963096619,
0.5839077830314636,
-0.23257361352443695,
-0.29586061835289,
0.21804969012737274,
0.6316983699798584,
-0.05114235728979111,
1.1522488594055176,
0.39833927154541016,
0.15493398904800415,
0.3912847936153412,
-0.3644234538078308,
0.2836734354496002,
-0.8043370842933655,
-0.3216099739074707,
-0.10022688657045364,
-0.3350187838077545,
-0.5877607464790344,
-0.5692245364189148,
0.6155135631561279,
-0.01475130207836628,
0.16581687331199646,
0.4256037473678589,
-0.4732964336872101,
0.22795361280441284,
0.43532565236091614,
0.36535823345184326,
0.10602942854166031,
-0.055224377661943436,
-0.5211814641952515,
0.06796764582395554,
-0.5207791924476624,
-0.20899434387683868,
1.462106466293335,
0.26562273502349854,
0.2535203993320465,
-0.016848836094141006,
0.6671773791313171,
0.3369140625,
0.6837356090545654,
-0.733272135257721,
0.443903386592865,
-0.29737281799316406,
-0.6730452179908752,
-0.23439235985279083,
-0.5333415269851685,
-1.2357676029205322,
-0.10042587667703629,
-0.35317859053611755,
-0.8587449193000793,
0.309668630361557,
-0.039690885692834854,
-0.676310122013092,
0.1769627183675766,
-0.7025761008262634,
0.8620018362998962,
-0.34089019894599915,
-0.0709332525730133,
-0.19734689593315125,
-0.7825136184692383,
-0.0015833083307370543,
-0.2041464000940323,
0.6120016574859619,
-0.15585902333259583,
0.08125538378953934,
0.6439378261566162,
-0.7324126958847046,
0.758380651473999,
-0.14385007321834564,
0.45263394713401794,
0.1963110715150833,
0.11405113339424133,
0.5323204398155212,
0.1150965765118599,
-0.2873230576515198,
0.24960753321647644,
0.13095401227474213,
-0.24214908480644226,
-0.6493664383888245,
0.610679566860199,
-0.6309771537780762,
0.043651048094034195,
-0.4101486802101135,
-0.44662678241729736,
-0.3310448229312897,
0.32896003127098083,
0.22335822880268097,
0.6661866307258606,
-0.5733815431594849,
-0.06530995666980743,
0.21897456049919128,
-0.6254026293754578,
0.1420333832502365,
0.6878462433815002,
-0.5285412073135376,
-0.9287060499191284,
0.8511289954185486,
-0.08893942087888718,
0.4167806804180145,
0.3595641851425171,
0.46802055835723877,
-0.1630532145500183,
-0.8887841701507568,
-0.309307724237442,
-0.01083155907690525,
-0.7238757610321045,
-0.2221430093050003,
-0.6784623265266418,
-0.4628983736038208,
-0.44265589118003845,
-0.24320966005325317,
-0.16585682332515717,
-0.38482046127319336,
0.15802079439163208,
-0.03810393437743187,
0.46082815527915955,
1.1150439977645874,
-0.04597984626889229,
0.4034493863582611,
-0.8967692852020264,
0.2634710967540741,
-0.14461155235767365,
0.7512865662574768,
-0.25546735525131226,
-0.2288026064634323,
-0.5358330607414246,
0.15004834532737732,
-0.08642460405826569,
-0.6469282507896423,
0.4749580919742584,
0.40044504404067993,
0.5523604154586792,
0.36212852597236633,
-0.31489989161491394,
0.33383575081825256,
-0.536369264125824,
0.5966237187385559,
0.46128571033477783,
-0.7845038771629333,
0.9114630818367004,
-0.3362289071083069,
-0.062338799238204956,
0.5731294751167297,
0.033889006823301315,
-0.6603471040725708,
-0.46910610795021057,
-0.6256650686264038,
-0.842781662940979,
0.8345428705215454,
0.5211514234542847,
-0.15784846246242523,
-0.00021773223124910146,
0.3354451358318329,
-0.033418819308280945,
0.06937450915575027,
-0.39143964648246765,
-0.2733842432498932,
0.039280764758586884,
-0.5085287094116211,
-0.11539683490991592,
-0.18236100673675537,
-0.3094209134578705,
-0.22445060312747955,
0.5401079654693604,
-0.342840313911438,
0.21888263523578644,
0.32866185903549194,
0.1268758624792099,
-0.2552693784236908,
0.053588829934597015,
0.6687564849853516,
0.7107043862342834,
-0.5513858199119568,
-0.33947181701660156,
0.21584725379943848,
-0.8863058686256409,
-0.06906331330537796,
0.2149028182029724,
-0.017632048577070236,
0.09484485536813736,
0.7639408707618713,
0.9778722524642944,
0.17231249809265137,
-0.6108636856079102,
0.6005436182022095,
-0.5113223791122437,
-0.4747847318649292,
-0.2082194983959198,
-0.1124633252620697,
-0.2058807611465454,
0.22617223858833313,
-0.054821982979774475,
0.23845478892326355,
0.44554999470710754,
-0.009707876481115818,
0.6516752243041992,
0.3917974829673767,
-1.1264009475708008,
-0.08876991271972656,
0.5501441359519958,
0.2922937572002411,
-0.48167702555656433,
0.5220748782157898,
0.2733672261238098,
-0.5185015797615051,
1.048355221748352,
0.31970274448394775,
0.9767875671386719,
-0.11040418595075607,
0.44716909527778625,
0.4340253472328186,
0.046496979892253876,
0.18408037722110748,
0.0898200273513794,
0.4127800166606903,
-0.8333815932273865,
-0.3780735433101654,
-0.8067666888237,
-0.7058701515197754,
-0.04443421959877014,
-0.3380106985569,
0.26617515087127686,
-0.5371907353401184,
-0.44346487522125244,
0.3693273365497589,
0.11194872856140137,
-0.40324848890304565,
0.3974741995334625,
0.17233756184577942,
0.7315514087677002,
-0.7670375108718872,
1.0812366008758545,
0.6383951306343079,
-0.5683766603469849,
-1.132524847984314,
-0.5030112266540527,
0.23999351263046265,
-0.8638495802879333,
0.603869616985321,
0.09308870136737823,
0.058465376496315,
-0.3336135745048523,
0.020000601187348366,
-0.799321711063385,
1.218148112297058,
0.05244532600045204,
-0.5016718506813049,
0.05725723132491112,
0.44512733817100525,
0.6977361440658569,
-0.5935742259025574,
0.4980587065219879,
0.6076029539108276,
0.4875330626964569,
0.14229102432727814,
-1.0902107954025269,
0.019930578768253326,
-0.2899237871170044,
-0.017242079600691795,
0.28340885043144226,
-0.10063999891281128,
0.5311750769615173,
-0.3782174587249756,
0.16993369162082672,
0.3845050036907196,
0.2763213813304901,
0.15789823234081268,
0.725753903388977,
0.5223917365074158,
0.3052993714809418,
0.6488521099090576,
-0.1856680065393448,
1.2502171993255615,
-0.5564010739326477,
0.5575648546218872,
0.8007711172103882,
-0.16701491177082062,
0.6013108491897583,
0.34275341033935547,
-0.45928478240966797,
0.4977262616157532,
0.3957793414592743,
0.2125069946050644,
0.5229820609092712,
0.07602532207965851,
-0.34505125880241394,
0.022382691502571106,
-0.2587478458881378,
-0.2616966962814331,
0.31752365827560425,
0.5864862203598022,
-0.760330319404602,
0.013683328405022621,
0.2174055427312851,
-0.33173680305480957,
-0.045971572399139404,
0.0655413568019867,
1.0685001611709595,
0.36167770624160767,
-0.6121386885643005,
0.2830008566379547,
-0.3506442904472351,
0.12434738129377365,
-0.8954220414161682,
-0.16115543246269226,
-0.19442005455493927,
0.6862486600875854,
-0.29861173033714294,
-0.989677369594574,
0.06638531386852264,
-0.4336218535900116,
-0.03635936230421066,
0.11756445467472076,
0.7368344068527222,
-0.40493547916412354,
-0.7945083975791931,
0.9082260727882385,
0.34186917543411255,
0.12170636653900146,
0.4020693302154541,
-1.0569963455200195,
-0.0333620049059391,
0.006084731314331293,
-0.5333588719367981,
0.2922143042087555,
0.4999571144580841,
0.09036029875278473,
0.6701401472091675,
0.6399176120758057,
0.7050439715385437,
-0.2884036600589752,
0.3029303550720215,
0.6764383912086487,
-0.3245297074317932,
-0.2821989059448242,
-0.7371069192886353,
0.34875932335853577,
-0.20678405463695526,
-0.2499099224805832,
0.3807069659233093,
0.5784681439399719,
-0.005846039857715368,
0.3977265954017639,
0.9667250514030457,
0.11554766446352005,
0.5305388569831848,
-0.40120482444763184,
0.9080125689506531,
-0.5688051581382751,
0.2950279712677002,
-0.41683101654052734,
-0.3350227177143097,
-0.5500949621200562,
0.27331143617630005,
-0.35727009177207947,
0.04308902844786644,
0.8022508025169373,
0.6525803208351135,
0.14723411202430725,
0.408915638923645,
0.3402986526489258,
0.23586329817771912,
0.695789098739624,
0.6608937978744507,
0.30881038308143616,
-0.8007014393806458,
0.45472806692123413,
-0.41628941893577576,
-0.5750545263290405,
-0.28073298931121826,
-0.8247395157814026,
-0.7001373767852783,
-0.3278399705886841,
0.16271854937076569,
-0.8948785066604614,
0.24543701112270355,
1.067432165145874,
0.6206085085868835,
-1.2375239133834839,
-0.4334842264652252,
-0.3808969557285309,
0.0360945425927639,
-0.2556813061237335,
-0.1152525246143341,
0.6096633076667786,
-0.41100409626960754,
-0.35195857286453247,
0.27335846424102783,
0.39051562547683716,
-0.14951138198375702,
0.11291142553091049,
-0.4357440173625946,
-0.4581230580806732,
0.2174457609653473,
0.44615787267684937,
0.26819247007369995,
-0.641930341720581,
-0.18517683446407318,
0.07823950797319412,
-0.3073170781135559,
-0.19496458768844604,
1.0405266284942627,
-0.9479705095291138,
0.9170515537261963,
0.4188176095485687,
0.6567716598510742,
0.4918091595172882,
-0.12269778549671173,
1.1454719305038452,
-0.24588625133037567,
0.1254132241010666,
0.3095804452896118,
0.4617771804332733,
-0.003619927214458585,
-0.252292275428772,
0.6588298082351685,
0.17465431988239288,
-0.8359770178794861,
-0.5079987645149231,
-0.11901496350765228,
-0.8595574498176575,
-0.19694401323795319,
1.111377477645874,
-0.22870202362537384,
-0.3798988461494446,
-0.3709492087364197,
-0.21943920850753784,
0.23194263875484467,
-0.40300244092941284,
0.5970876216888428,
0.54751056432724,
-0.3905984163284302,
0.06879670917987823,
-0.9140324592590332,
0.7669425010681152,
0.42022261023521423,
-0.6239238977432251,
0.14579416811466217,
0.22968365252017975,
0.1533479243516922,
0.15062794089317322,
1.1158831119537354,
0.03723898530006409,
0.1824098378419876,
-0.2990338206291199,
0.07467200607061386,
0.24874840676784515,
0.09494778513908386,
-0.23919972777366638,
-0.23062191903591156,
-0.10535746067762375,
-0.03500038757920265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17401v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17401v1
|
Evaluation of Geographical Distortions in Language Models: A Crucial Step Towards Equitable Representations
| 2024-04-26T13:22:28 | 2024-04-26T13:22:28 |
Rémy Decoupes, Roberto Interdonato, Mathieu Roche, Maguelonne Teisseire, Sarah Valentin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models now constitute essential tools for improving efficiency for
many professional tasks such as writing, coding, or learning. For this reason,
it is imperative to identify inherent biases. In the field of Natural Language
Processing, five sources of bias are well-identified: data, annotation,
representation, models, and research design. This study focuses on biases
related to geographical knowledge. We explore the connection between geography
and language models by highlighting their tendency to misrepresent spatial
information, thus leading to distortions in the representation of geographical
distances. This study introduces four indicators to assess these distortions,
by comparing geographical and semantic distances. Experiments are conducted
from these four indicators with ten widely used language models. Results
underscore the critical necessity of inspecting and rectifying spatial biases
in language models to ensure accurate and equitable representations.
|
[
-0.5392723679542542,
-0.5011855959892273,
0.7688183188438416,
0.25068867206573486,
0.045802369713783264,
-0.36679860949516296,
-0.4025575816631317,
-0.7779197692871094,
0.10179726779460907,
0.5473089218139648,
-0.23655179142951965,
-0.41640934348106384,
-0.9435379505157471,
0.05714220181107521,
-0.31488335132598877,
0.6772551536560059,
-0.16594089567661285,
0.4032474160194397,
-0.12054723501205444,
-0.5889493823051453,
-0.6496426463127136,
-0.7002376914024353,
-0.08345941454172134,
-0.40882694721221924,
0.13042892515659332,
-0.010473355650901794,
0.9494324326515198,
0.48682135343551636,
0.39092424511909485,
0.3816722333431244,
-0.08190858364105225,
0.07130089402198792,
-0.28971782326698303,
0.05439668893814087,
-0.20977596938610077,
-0.6237162947654724,
0.05834959074854851,
0.21981291472911835,
0.8164535164833069,
1.0968639850616455,
0.12360390275716782,
0.2583862543106079,
-0.13276658952236176,
0.5284063816070557,
-0.5606018900871277,
0.24218133091926575,
-0.3924761414527893,
0.10925612598657608,
-0.48074445128440857,
-0.014484797604382038,
-0.08805998414754868,
-0.6679720878601074,
0.43941640853881836,
-0.4242558181285858,
0.4484460651874542,
0.14401398599147797,
1.0314096212387085,
0.213894784450531,
-0.4509027898311615,
-0.41948068141937256,
-0.8004900217056274,
0.745425283908844,
-0.4973832666873932,
0.7208436131477356,
0.5681829452514648,
0.43642035126686096,
0.055504389107227325,
-0.1978268325328827,
-0.35475584864616394,
-0.1966751515865326,
-0.2804442346096039,
-0.16722553968429565,
-0.1421065777540207,
-0.18186736106872559,
0.557248592376709,
0.035728298127651215,
-0.21544679999351501,
0.06893382221460342,
-0.4592429995536804,
-0.33155596256256104,
0.5750492811203003,
-0.14206978678703308,
0.6792401075363159,
-0.38910114765167236,
0.09682147949934006,
-0.012654093094170094,
-1.0428193807601929,
-0.18294155597686768,
0.7373046875,
0.3063351511955261,
-0.12690825760364532,
0.5955711603164673,
-0.07863397896289825,
0.7889053821563721,
-0.060128096491098404,
0.12728813290596008,
0.1445455551147461,
-0.30571866035461426,
-0.0661175325512886,
-0.11113493144512177,
0.4243098795413971,
0.4507977366447449,
0.43870458006858826,
-0.20304958522319794,
-0.08329901844263077,
0.023474356159567833,
0.26244595646858215,
-0.16290777921676636,
-0.23684890568256378,
-0.31984007358551025,
-0.18557749688625336,
0.1454996019601822,
0.1599784642457962,
-0.8775393962860107,
-0.5704337954521179,
-0.23993632197380066,
-0.050904080271720886,
-0.2746178209781647,
-0.09794782102108002,
0.03248656168580055,
-0.2565936744213104,
-0.07754535228013992,
0.11736903339624405,
-0.9783264994621277,
0.2714780569076538,
0.4326089918613434,
0.5814406871795654,
0.3485103249549866,
-0.3694766163825989,
0.18342773616313934,
0.07158809900283813,
-0.33633899688720703,
0.9365440607070923,
-0.7014660239219666,
-0.19574250280857086,
0.232855424284935,
-0.03226225823163986,
0.1925043761730194,
-0.6481450796127319,
0.822343111038208,
-0.35031330585479736,
0.3869040012359619,
-0.6326771378517151,
-0.2706211507320404,
-0.46562665700912476,
0.10644872486591339,
-1.0903916358947754,
1.2203933000564575,
0.3716212213039398,
-0.7978941202163696,
0.6289878487586975,
-0.6509872674942017,
-0.07803449779748917,
-0.3030247688293457,
-0.09591194987297058,
-0.2561279535293579,
0.33789828419685364,
0.5899372696876526,
-0.011159746907651424,
-0.20204876363277435,
0.3526410460472107,
-0.1992364376783371,
-0.13737225532531738,
0.21459871530532837,
-0.46440064907073975,
0.7590839862823486,
0.06485319882631302,
-0.42451342940330505,
-0.04749588668346405,
-0.6611765027046204,
-0.17545005679130554,
0.17566539347171783,
-0.3369746804237366,
-0.8133995532989502,
0.08214383572340012,
-0.004973900970071554,
0.11398948729038239,
0.10691917687654495,
-0.37289106845855713,
-0.042831167578697205,
-0.7473048567771912,
0.1579435169696808,
0.5929728746414185,
-0.29982510209083557,
0.981311559677124,
-0.13881880044937134,
0.3404873013496399,
0.15994757413864136,
0.13907411694526672,
0.10261302441358566,
-0.5149500370025635,
-0.6453368663787842,
0.0965740829706192,
0.33426856994628906,
0.1866522878408432,
-0.44872745871543884,
0.09107911586761475,
-0.49146226048469543,
-0.42619603872299194,
-0.5308970808982849,
-0.18172729015350342,
0.040640778839588165,
0.24796360731124878,
0.14618515968322754,
-0.2941376864910126,
-0.8170943856239319,
-0.7547033429145813,
-0.7580119371414185,
-0.0161229707300663,
-0.17244677245616913,
0.31605005264282227,
0.48186179995536804,
-0.12883177399635315,
0.956185519695282,
-0.28584685921669006,
-0.0505947507917881,
-0.03569881618022919,
0.0743732824921608,
-0.21103791892528534,
0.042751211673021317,
1.0392048358917236,
-0.6514863967895508,
-0.20461297035217285,
-0.3570621609687805,
-0.40183597803115845,
-0.6703597903251648,
0.2244926542043686,
-0.3732421100139618,
0.19042541086673737,
-0.07350167632102966,
-0.47361239790916443,
0.5617030262947083,
0.7106865644454956,
-0.742313802242279,
0.5342647433280945,
-0.12087339907884598,
0.23426589369773865,
-0.37803199887275696,
-0.16079357266426086,
0.2512110769748688,
-0.23781220614910126,
-0.49284282326698303,
0.039418306201696396,
-0.021298246458172798,
-0.0030955856200307608,
-0.05102599039673805,
0.4713395833969116,
-0.6351292133331299,
-0.283153235912323,
0.1361510455608368,
0.5461069345474243,
0.15900512039661407,
0.0195440873503685,
0.019424039870500565,
0.34711143374443054,
0.31299033761024475,
-0.23281528055667877,
0.2158576101064682,
-0.034609757363796234,
-0.5132349133491516,
0.4716941714286804,
-0.2570352852344513,
-0.08125085383653641,
-0.3540578782558441,
0.12859539687633514,
-0.8522236347198486,
-0.07585438340902328,
0.39392372965812683,
-0.26667520403862,
-0.05180393531918526,
-0.15010307729244232,
-0.4820951223373413,
-0.34106680750846863,
-0.05887088552117348,
0.44772887229919434,
0.16559794545173645,
-0.4455127716064453,
0.23725952208042145,
0.6578224897384644,
-0.016072839498519897,
-0.38612231612205505,
-0.757575273513794,
-0.14932236075401306,
-0.3816695809364319,
-0.43472084403038025,
0.024543439969420433,
0.3454448878765106,
-0.45252910256385803,
0.1123606264591217,
-0.01382227148860693,
-0.36215460300445557,
-0.02231554314494133,
0.29884427785873413,
0.08431122452020645,
0.11042914539575577,
0.03767015412449837,
-0.1919117420911789,
0.1407899111509323,
0.3710765838623047,
-0.40900757908821106,
0.3884026110172272,
0.251952588558197,
-0.5623914003372192,
-0.08097895979881287,
0.2106102854013443,
0.586915910243988,
-0.27752649784088135,
0.6929430961608887,
0.13277700543403625,
-0.7090979814529419,
-0.0027680632192641497,
-0.6775414347648621,
-0.042931925505399704,
-0.3221953809261322,
0.43593549728393555,
-0.0772261917591095,
-0.7512675523757935,
0.7702696919441223,
-0.16188079118728638,
-0.28745681047439575,
0.5045459270477295,
0.31407347321510315,
0.20552383363246918,
0.8910377025604248,
0.6744602918624878,
-0.3157954812049866,
0.5414556860923767,
0.040703706443309784,
0.6679373979568481,
-0.5415281653404236,
-0.298830509185791,
-1.066772699356079,
-0.0881657525897026,
-0.7686204314231873,
-0.6186348795890808,
0.3234700560569763,
0.018134010955691338,
-0.5112562775611877,
0.005179301369935274,
-0.3021138906478882,
0.5293846726417542,
0.4915626645088196,
-0.3151204586029053,
-0.023070266470313072,
0.3419593274593353,
-0.4455426335334778,
-0.5312650799751282,
-0.8876100778579712,
-0.8157884478569031,
1.0417613983154297,
0.5696043372154236,
0.5469915270805359,
0.19185763597488403,
0.3465055823326111,
0.11937709897756577,
0.45493271946907043,
-0.4076712727546692,
0.13125714659690857,
0.20708152651786804,
-0.6902471780776978,
-0.440860778093338,
-0.30814695358276367,
-0.7207632064819336,
0.28617432713508606,
-0.1388305425643921,
-0.7508592009544373,
0.3608628809452057,
-0.10028780251741409,
-0.23014076054096222,
0.25325390696525574,
-0.5944923162460327,
0.5487182140350342,
-0.2208384871482849,
-0.11567636579275131,
-0.01096152514219284,
-0.30735260248184204,
0.2729945182800293,
0.19229373335838318,
0.6332013010978699,
-0.2575988471508026,
0.3857930302619934,
0.509991466999054,
-0.2773430049419403,
0.8149376511573792,
-0.41044965386390686,
-0.17083364725112915,
0.23934060335159302,
0.23963333666324615,
0.2197905331850052,
-0.2275967299938202,
-0.24130631983280182,
0.6009553670883179,
0.01224359031766653,
-0.35062703490257263,
-0.615944504737854,
0.5126017332077026,
-0.9757659435272217,
-0.28163835406303406,
-0.4004281163215637,
-0.5317429304122925,
-0.03695455566048622,
0.15160124003887177,
0.20310327410697937,
0.329257071018219,
-0.3242853581905365,
-0.671421468257904,
0.22438673675060272,
-0.515841543674469,
0.09906595200300217,
0.3418984115123749,
-0.37054184079170227,
-0.09741006791591644,
0.36773690581321716,
0.5948271155357361,
0.12615236639976501,
-0.04167845845222473,
0.03790052980184555,
-0.5550444722175598,
-0.3595069348812103,
-0.2546890676021576,
0.35085633397102356,
-0.8757954835891724,
-0.1203494668006897,
-0.12951235473155975,
-0.04931127279996872,
-0.48125606775283813,
-0.1918518990278244,
-0.3701136112213135,
-0.41185253858566284,
-0.05558318272233009,
-0.32817786931991577,
0.1065315455198288,
1.2371842861175537,
-0.18096745014190674,
0.33490127325057983,
-0.3862862288951874,
0.02221984975039959,
-0.24982480704784393,
0.4922574758529663,
0.12062022089958191,
-0.30287879705429077,
-0.3816881775856018,
0.3081026077270508,
-0.372126966714859,
-1.1981223821640015,
0.5424618124961853,
-0.09706241637468338,
0.7068474292755127,
0.37768039107322693,
-0.2995876967906952,
0.7881588339805603,
-0.907932698726654,
0.9946975708007812,
-0.052748918533325195,
-1.1536450386047363,
0.5915499925613403,
-0.09160538762807846,
0.25151532888412476,
0.06778918206691742,
0.5727038383483887,
-0.7633097171783447,
-0.7606557607650757,
-0.502979576587677,
-0.7869559526443481,
0.4728304147720337,
-0.06697244197130203,
0.042699236422777176,
-0.2614509165287018,
0.4176454246044159,
0.045442115515470505,
-0.15413209795951843,
-0.9670922160148621,
-0.25578293204307556,
-0.3148702085018158,
0.013985592871904373,
0.07020923495292664,
-0.661848247051239,
-0.26276537775993347,
-0.28107550740242004,
0.3306165337562561,
0.13860410451889038,
0.40886956453323364,
0.32874104380607605,
-0.4785197377204895,
-0.12746568024158478,
0.2959310710430145,
0.6495624780654907,
1.061330795288086,
0.28417903184890747,
0.5389641523361206,
0.3348248302936554,
-0.33387264609336853,
0.181645005941391,
-0.07252152264118195,
-0.24880392849445343,
0.38526758551597595,
0.45904067158699036,
0.7089971303939819,
0.3370901644229889,
-0.3167300224304199,
0.34448298811912537,
0.03762609884142876,
0.36430108547210693,
-0.24437807500362396,
-0.40281060338020325,
-0.044701214879751205,
0.1029883474111557,
0.09834050387144089,
0.20413002371788025,
0.35196664929389954,
-0.4255530536174774,
-0.14898857474327087,
0.19911853969097137,
-0.3317319452762604,
-0.5603195428848267,
0.5638338923454285,
0.19702281057834625,
-0.07422643154859543,
0.850389838218689,
-0.07617750763893127,
-0.8478700518608093,
0.4485138952732086,
0.4608864188194275,
0.48787081241607666,
-0.5029588937759399,
0.15412472188472748,
0.6061980128288269,
0.6956856846809387,
-0.06709520518779755,
0.1964319497346878,
0.2868025600910187,
-0.8835340738296509,
-0.2926381230354309,
-0.6008114814758301,
0.1528632789850235,
-0.29785528779029846,
-0.5333243608474731,
0.2418336421251297,
-0.2092350423336029,
-0.3718467354774475,
-0.07109098881483078,
-0.1611858457326889,
-0.8922675848007202,
0.033344198018312454,
0.4845152795314789,
0.7851879000663757,
-1.3114503622055054,
0.4973093271255493,
0.6601566672325134,
-0.28791919350624084,
-0.6520643830299377,
-0.18011941015720367,
0.10718531161546707,
-0.6006004810333252,
1.0600265264511108,
0.047115832567214966,
-0.07776621729135513,
-0.6142510771751404,
-0.5985539555549622,
-0.9230408072471619,
0.5637353658676147,
0.5530019998550415,
-0.5497775673866272,
0.0747116208076477,
0.8499342203140259,
0.7226375937461853,
-0.30330711603164673,
0.5584133267402649,
0.8192222118377686,
0.6346175670623779,
-0.622105598449707,
-1.300428032875061,
0.11191822588443756,
0.21991832554340363,
0.4019095301628113,
0.18762482702732086,
-0.24317635595798492,
0.7431588768959045,
-0.11632855236530304,
-0.3993310332298279,
-0.24791622161865234,
0.23707304894924164,
0.18095999956130981,
0.008580143563449383,
0.22075480222702026,
0.5761004686355591,
1.0564219951629639,
-0.5863713026046753,
1.102077603340149,
-0.3444451689720154,
0.5346654653549194,
0.8736446499824524,
-0.23908686637878418,
0.5190333127975464,
0.4301599860191345,
-0.2726436257362366,
0.5691076517105103,
0.49498915672302246,
0.20184706151485443,
0.507763147354126,
0.45726364850997925,
-0.2515832483768463,
0.15737652778625488,
-0.032411519438028336,
-0.13103951513767242,
0.5499213933944702,
0.5124923586845398,
-0.4137256443500519,
-0.691271185874939,
0.012109948322176933,
0.26512929797172546,
0.38658958673477173,
-0.31939852237701416,
0.35414671897888184,
-0.20704831182956696,
-0.5449357628822327,
0.31940582394599915,
0.296054482460022,
0.4377289116382599,
-0.47363120317459106,
-0.18288494646549225,
-0.16615602374076843,
-0.1771206557750702,
-0.23128025233745575,
-0.7854108810424805,
0.7454972863197327,
0.0073963371105492115,
-0.3520717918872833,
-0.27775847911834717,
0.7865363359451294,
-0.456930011510849,
-0.3742767572402954,
0.415461927652359,
0.32328373193740845,
0.2708570659160614,
-0.022939326241612434,
-0.49137893319129944,
0.29622605443000793,
-0.01756924018263817,
0.09103558212518692,
-0.1313740611076355,
0.7305541634559631,
-0.4550601541996002,
0.5911042094230652,
0.31101998686790466,
0.49306172132492065,
0.6215434670448303,
0.3075438439846039,
0.42175135016441345,
-0.7311121225357056,
-0.3126799464225769,
-0.9551905989646912,
0.2641183137893677,
-0.07800150662660599,
0.016959719359874725,
1.0986392498016357,
0.4874740242958069,
0.9964364171028137,
-0.0725332647562027,
0.8692964315414429,
0.011214006692171097,
0.3887307047843933,
-0.276250422000885,
0.9233640432357788,
0.08818001300096512,
0.25189903378486633,
-0.09034375846385956,
-0.9559458494186401,
-0.4738265872001648,
1.034590482711792,
-0.9497867226600647,
0.26084402203559875,
0.6444668173789978,
0.5312559604644775,
0.06023164838552475,
-0.03073115088045597,
0.17453593015670776,
0.2705465257167816,
0.2864975333213806,
0.2814808189868927,
0.9892737865447998,
-0.40228649973869324,
-0.08308862894773483,
-0.2934923470020294,
-0.11882178485393524,
0.00509076751768589,
-0.8147258162498474,
-0.6445407271385193,
-0.6201850175857544,
-0.15535932779312134,
-0.19220159947872162,
0.10042501986026764,
0.5766571760177612,
0.6983750462532043,
-0.6701217889785767,
-0.25641587376594543,
0.24759911000728607,
0.5110408067703247,
0.06031889095902443,
-0.21722204983234406,
0.29008743166923523,
-0.2430492490530014,
-0.8557947278022766,
-0.28765934705734253,
0.26862719655036926,
0.10714340955018997,
-0.6310491561889648,
0.15067921578884125,
-0.00007739885040791705,
0.010502287186682224,
0.709348738193512,
0.020160792395472527,
-0.8748588562011719,
-0.6697075366973877,
-0.39753901958465576,
-0.13595405220985413,
0.05064404755830765,
0.6580536365509033,
-0.5675576329231262,
0.5427843332290649,
0.3976235091686249,
0.09868287295103073,
-0.03434838727116585,
-0.2477409690618515,
0.6138086318969727,
-0.7971386313438416,
0.31936851143836975,
0.04397652670741081,
0.4863431751728058,
0.8082456588745117,
-0.2794712483882904,
0.3725648522377014,
0.07601407915353775,
-0.6721999049186707,
-0.640814483165741,
0.16553620994091034,
-0.2751389145851135,
-0.06425628066062927,
1.0575369596481323,
-0.13694384694099426,
-0.26590779423713684,
-0.08660555630922318,
-0.29968735575675964,
0.24275174736976624,
0.13542315363883972,
1.018660306930542,
1.3099002838134766,
-0.06278103590011597,
0.012858593836426735,
-0.9777664542198181,
0.5892487168312073,
0.17687907814979553,
-0.45280617475509644,
0.11475525796413422,
1.022430419921875,
0.6132698655128479,
0.3919451832771301,
0.4177817106246948,
-0.42652755975723267,
-0.16131359338760376,
0.016371557489037514,
0.23394878208637238,
0.6091029644012451,
-0.2446591854095459,
-0.4164130389690399,
-0.007627788465470076,
0.438031405210495,
0.1850074678659439
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17394v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17394v1
|
Child Speech Recognition in Human-Robot Interaction: Problem Solved?
| 2024-04-26T13:14:28 | 2024-04-26T13:14:28 |
Ruben Janssens, Eva Verhelst, Giulio Antonio Abbo, Qiaoqiao Ren, Maria Jose Pinto Bernal, Tony Belpaeme
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.RO
|
Automated Speech Recognition shows superhuman performance for adult English
speech on a range of benchmarks, but disappoints when fed children's speech.
This has long sat in the way of child-robot interaction. Recent evolutions in
data-driven speech recognition, including the availability of Transformer
architectures and unprecedented volumes of training data, might mean a
breakthrough for child speech recognition and social robot applications aimed
at children. We revisit a study on child speech recognition from 2017 and show
that indeed performance has increased, with newcomer OpenAI Whisper doing
markedly better than leading commercial cloud services. While transcription is
not perfect yet, the best model recognises 60.3% of sentences correctly barring
small grammatical differences, with sub-second transcription time running on a
local GPU, showing potential for usable autonomous child-robot speech
interactions.
|
[
0.03205772861838341,
-0.44377246499061584,
0.12615308165550232,
0.0899081826210022,
0.044358205050230026,
0.44535085558891296,
-0.07116002589464188,
-1.0050791501998901,
0.12076354026794434,
0.27264508605003357,
-0.6491140723228455,
0.1942516714334488,
-0.7152340412139893,
-0.08858255296945572,
-0.6029898524284363,
0.3283945620059967,
0.10884998738765717,
0.0144414771348238,
-0.39496198296546936,
0.11359567195177078,
-0.20849071443080902,
-0.5863440632820129,
-1.1985200643539429,
-0.5740981698036194,
0.4101926386356354,
0.48646029829978943,
0.7159423828125,
0.9541634917259216,
0.5165228843688965,
0.29376810789108276,
-0.21548837423324585,
0.26767775416374207,
-0.25817054510116577,
0.23378537595272064,
0.011016017757356167,
-0.1770629733800888,
-0.6675338745117188,
-0.01748749427497387,
0.49063411355018616,
0.8601853847503662,
-0.019244888797402382,
-0.11792244762182236,
0.08570171147584915,
0.6952523589134216,
-0.23249635100364685,
0.3250388205051422,
-0.63481205701828,
0.13216589391231537,
-0.2567148208618164,
-0.037744488567113876,
-0.23844632506370544,
0.1475677341222763,
0.21794302761554718,
-0.5087407827377319,
0.40874576568603516,
-0.1473046988248825,
0.7586554884910583,
0.5593953132629395,
-0.06017054617404938,
-0.5232606530189514,
-1.3171454668045044,
0.634981095790863,
-0.3238998353481293,
0.5871872305870056,
0.6103618741035461,
0.33223891258239746,
-0.2417355626821518,
-0.8162865042686462,
-0.7682950496673584,
-0.37566202878952026,
0.10166925191879272,
0.07412520796060562,
-0.7909743189811707,
0.028636673465371132,
0.1271049827337265,
0.22986824810504913,
-0.699051558971405,
0.3522239923477173,
-0.34564319252967834,
-0.15031932294368744,
0.7224201560020447,
0.2557537853717804,
0.4050651490688324,
0.10708881169557571,
0.024522485211491585,
-0.4463747441768646,
-0.5025872588157654,
0.48237693309783936,
0.38077548146247864,
0.7477719783782959,
-0.15178994834423065,
0.47894489765167236,
-0.46136632561683655,
0.4903041422367096,
0.18643827736377716,
-0.2093370109796524,
0.335908979177475,
-0.2764272689819336,
0.11537900567054749,
0.2549947202205658,
0.7964180111885071,
0.11571291089057922,
0.4546715319156647,
-0.22185979783535004,
-0.24192005395889282,
0.47001174092292786,
0.4157678782939911,
-0.20865261554718018,
-0.3690106272697449,
0.096163809299469,
-0.27552005648612976,
-0.03185670077800751,
0.22650939226150513,
-0.6127772927284241,
-0.5094079971313477,
-0.309253990650177,
0.19128182530403137,
-0.10131773352622986,
-0.26473918557167053,
0.31684672832489014,
-0.15854512155056,
0.26009246706962585,
0.10794989764690399,
-0.9907249212265015,
0.5432591438293457,
0.7133628129959106,
0.6063098907470703,
-0.17763566970825195,
-0.19201268255710602,
-0.668912947177887,
0.1576097160577774,
-0.23629777133464813,
0.6651926040649414,
-0.5492407083511353,
-0.47835177183151245,
-0.16599978506565094,
-0.01376194879412651,
-0.41604772210121155,
-0.9525626301765442,
0.6273050904273987,
-0.098269522190094,
0.15847866237163544,
0.3401251435279846,
-0.28009024262428284,
0.2237602323293686,
-0.344797819852829,
-0.5243306756019592,
0.6081745028495789,
-0.048380397260189056,
-0.36768317222595215,
0.5254144668579102,
-0.8119093775749207,
-0.7060732841491699,
0.15889321267604828,
0.12209225445985794,
-0.4992808699607849,
-0.1521548628807068,
0.3729921281337738,
0.2440832406282425,
0.09532109647989273,
-0.025096893310546875,
-0.025354869663715363,
-0.37169113755226135,
0.3069723844528198,
-0.8632259964942932,
0.5931278467178345,
0.17869336903095245,
-0.28874146938323975,
0.10190211981534958,
-0.6934897899627686,
-0.147561714053154,
0.18729281425476074,
-0.02757633477449417,
0.17067472636699677,
0.26743343472480774,
0.10403503477573395,
0.13905087113380432,
0.38287240266799927,
-0.7849546074867249,
0.17640063166618347,
-0.293899267911911,
1.0201033353805542,
0.23788708448410034,
-0.24547266960144043,
0.31893277168273926,
-0.3093045651912689,
0.5133572816848755,
-0.06228988617658615,
0.49771860241889954,
0.022237686440348625,
-0.712303638458252,
-0.6262211799621582,
-0.28640976548194885,
0.3119821548461914,
0.575468897819519,
-0.5882522463798523,
0.7203913331031799,
-0.30188143253326416,
-0.4131699800491333,
-0.8301735520362854,
-0.2035066932439804,
0.38252395391464233,
0.49773550033569336,
0.25840896368026733,
-0.2778889238834381,
-0.827033519744873,
-0.881831169128418,
-0.06513290852308273,
-0.5865027904510498,
-0.2252337634563446,
0.7456173896789551,
0.12848436832427979,
-0.5240606069564819,
0.8877200484275818,
-0.25008875131607056,
-0.4117240607738495,
-0.4223371148109436,
0.14326360821723938,
-0.001781538245268166,
0.44390013813972473,
0.12619298696517944,
-0.9444265961647034,
-0.31218236684799194,
0.11582124978303909,
-0.39567506313323975,
-0.019936786964535713,
0.11170201003551483,
0.45601460337638855,
0.25200724601745605,
0.3288668394088745,
-0.603395402431488,
0.4384819269180298,
0.5657126307487488,
-0.10387428849935532,
0.14735744893550873,
-0.21397154033184052,
-0.053704917430877686,
-0.5267682075500488,
-0.05083000287413597,
-0.2818799316883087,
-0.5070350766181946,
-0.8639124631881714,
-0.386819452047348,
-0.16429102420806885,
-0.15581569075584412,
-0.6170127391815186,
0.14917585253715515,
-0.02176208235323429,
-0.21078181266784668,
-0.5014241337776184,
0.1790296584367752,
-0.6110479235649109,
0.06977373361587524,
0.07171458750963211,
1.111783742904663,
0.7413908839225769,
-0.3900444805622101,
0.5745823383331299,
0.13544410467147827,
0.1058896854519844,
0.39068982005119324,
-0.7702001929283142,
0.6151911020278931,
0.18052750825881958,
0.3249274492263794,
-0.9012612104415894,
-0.6114999651908875,
0.31763017177581787,
-1.1044189929962158,
0.36364591121673584,
0.14831790328025818,
-0.5922518372535706,
-0.7704581618309021,
-0.0746508464217186,
0.11744066327810287,
0.5703684091567993,
-0.658042848110199,
0.5771792531013489,
0.8203762173652649,
-0.2600914537906647,
-0.25159597396850586,
-0.3365146815776825,
0.3986862897872925,
0.04008733481168747,
-0.499438613653183,
0.41288986802101135,
0.21669211983680725,
0.07400336861610413,
-0.0565587542951107,
-0.16739508509635925,
-0.4013197422027588,
-0.014143717475235462,
0.30304908752441406,
0.14459921419620514,
-0.04217030107975006,
-0.08835743367671967,
-0.04747432842850685,
-0.38047459721565247,
-0.06359833478927612,
0.007877211086452007,
0.8384650349617004,
-0.2471526861190796,
-0.14863041043281555,
-0.7507185339927673,
0.028863392770290375,
0.5777295231819153,
0.1402333676815033,
0.24462901055812836,
0.3752620816230774,
-0.696355938911438,
0.01659640297293663,
-0.023804061114788055,
-0.12047427147626877,
-0.5123997926712036,
0.14622026681900024,
-0.3050553798675537,
-0.581278920173645,
0.26799753308296204,
0.08759957551956177,
-0.34997689723968506,
0.5291935801506042,
0.10207563638687134,
-0.6277377605438232,
1.2405694723129272,
0.6128193736076355,
-0.5471399426460266,
0.3373786509037018,
-0.0352388359606266,
0.09301882237195969,
-0.5781513452529907,
-0.3404749035835266,
-0.6758207678794861,
-0.4042910933494568,
-0.7036046385765076,
0.033659547567367554,
0.3678217828273773,
-0.1976974457502365,
0.0979088768362999,
0.6191508769989014,
-0.5938657522201538,
0.2628690302371979,
0.6671144962310791,
0.135471910238266,
0.4044613242149353,
-0.29707634449005127,
0.553043007850647,
-0.06143813952803612,
-0.8424331545829773,
-0.5678665041923523,
0.6748809218406677,
0.2593787610530853,
0.59547358751297,
-0.18111950159072876,
0.5923051238059998,
0.3475370705127716,
0.028546957299113274,
-0.5715112686157227,
0.6148821115493774,
-0.5944805145263672,
-0.4726082980632782,
-0.4643227159976959,
-0.4968849718570709,
-1.4935846328735352,
-0.34684276580810547,
-0.05668375641107559,
-0.9429135322570801,
0.038508012890815735,
0.1960163563489914,
-0.290685772895813,
0.2538253664970398,
-0.6476430892944336,
0.3961021602153778,
-0.005456259008497,
0.06358671188354492,
-0.25650185346603394,
-0.7614735960960388,
-0.13473045825958252,
0.05313611403107643,
-0.07730572670698166,
0.24391870200634003,
-0.05529964715242386,
0.8364704847335815,
-0.14966505765914917,
0.8023726940155029,
-0.2542252540588379,
0.12396117299795151,
0.17818966507911682,
-0.3835741877555847,
0.2591274678707123,
-0.4054339826107025,
0.44218116998672485,
0.14963367581367493,
-0.2444937378168106,
-0.20713233947753906,
-0.5374033451080322,
0.43532922863960266,
-0.7732982635498047,
-0.38386645913124084,
-0.48351678252220154,
-0.4421004354953766,
-0.2993086576461792,
-0.1512582153081894,
0.10951560735702515,
0.25719261169433594,
-0.03686341270804405,
0.4712686240673065,
0.4618819057941437,
-0.03516295552253723,
0.6386951804161072,
0.4804249405860901,
0.01810086891055107,
-0.3769930601119995,
1.2410759925842285,
0.2094670534133911,
0.1240001916885376,
0.22045280039310455,
0.30521395802497864,
-0.3527499735355377,
-0.26984521746635437,
-0.7405238747596741,
0.2313670963048935,
-0.0645756721496582,
0.13551601767539978,
-0.5699565410614014,
-0.6346275806427002,
-0.3929346799850464,
-0.0916229709982872,
-0.6154764294624329,
-0.49663245677948,
-0.3327777683734894,
0.11000305414199829,
0.19676032662391663,
1.0683315992355347,
-0.13017068803310394,
0.14591026306152344,
-0.6181693077087402,
0.6500991582870483,
0.40810373425483704,
0.274213045835495,
0.017514407634735107,
-0.7283000946044922,
-0.1233208179473877,
0.049546949565410614,
-0.4165746569633484,
-0.3955003619194031,
0.33383944630622864,
0.371236652135849,
0.37644311785697937,
0.2672747075557709,
0.009243438951671124,
0.6136044263839722,
-0.5128574967384338,
0.9353813529014587,
-0.03775890916585922,
-0.7865169048309326,
0.6355745196342468,
-0.3401085436344147,
0.17489716410636902,
0.28844696283340454,
0.1836620569229126,
-0.6464707851409912,
-0.3996447026729584,
-0.8127276301383972,
-0.783600926399231,
0.7890397906303406,
0.22406063973903656,
0.277396559715271,
0.5236010551452637,
0.012481034733355045,
0.14010681211948395,
0.16775110363960266,
-0.1677304357290268,
-0.2277551144361496,
0.030107123777270317,
-0.4618241786956787,
-0.12283454835414886,
0.21450528502464294,
0.2371508628129959,
-0.47106707096099854,
0.33898770809173584,
0.15713916718959808,
0.40237078070640564,
0.11066006869077682,
0.1870221495628357,
-0.4991909861564636,
-0.11513956636190414,
0.4850492477416992,
0.45145872235298157,
0.050417397171258926,
-0.20612774789333344,
-0.08037208020687103,
-0.8846893906593323,
0.0574142262339592,
0.5132637619972229,
-0.2609209418296814,
-0.14061318337917328,
0.6675637364387512,
0.6391284465789795,
0.19028683006763458,
-0.8214783668518066,
0.3238009512424469,
-0.20481054484844208,
-0.31396323442459106,
-0.3499394357204437,
0.3216377794742584,
-0.0468311533331871,
0.3398590385913849,
0.5064198970794678,
0.16216298937797546,
0.08781428635120392,
-0.6055577993392944,
0.312206506729126,
0.3382623791694641,
-0.5514013767242432,
-0.2643943130970001,
0.69921875,
0.19156518578529358,
-1.0293725728988647,
0.6033298969268799,
0.09904774278402328,
-0.786733865737915,
0.4605982005596161,
0.4195777177810669,
1.2020543813705444,
-0.376882940530777,
0.09254881739616394,
-0.013330630958080292,
0.14631421864032745,
0.1470354199409485,
0.4238089621067047,
-0.2995494306087494,
-0.7036139369010925,
-0.16276609897613525,
-0.014352318830788136,
-1.1052255630493164,
0.11266540735960007,
-0.6406275033950806,
-0.0938253402709961,
-0.1808558702468872,
-0.07800368964672089,
0.28646954894065857,
0.12416695058345795,
-0.5719960927963257,
0.373156875371933,
0.42531925439834595,
0.31252384185791016,
-0.4661990702152252,
0.849174976348877,
0.5995038747787476,
-0.10242797434329987,
-0.578240156173706,
0.10430382937192917,
-0.29591789841651917,
-0.4895551800727844,
0.5316056609153748,
0.15105028450489044,
-0.758500337600708,
-0.11911806464195251,
-0.5508508086204529,
-0.5806199908256531,
0.6906226873397827,
0.07726096361875534,
-0.693600058555603,
0.21731814742088318,
0.5116616487503052,
0.8668513298034668,
-0.29630568623542786,
-0.04823880270123482,
0.6154959797859192,
0.3442128002643585,
-0.11512137204408646,
-1.3701305389404297,
-0.6355789303779602,
-0.28015464544296265,
-0.34255680441856384,
-0.12378303706645966,
-0.6949732303619385,
0.548565685749054,
-0.07933592796325684,
-0.251495897769928,
0.08942370116710663,
0.6968461275100708,
-0.05525222048163414,
1.005473017692566,
0.6822020411491394,
0.3164029121398926,
0.8888221383094788,
-0.22434678673744202,
0.8984673619270325,
-0.15274029970169067,
-0.136153906583786,
0.8635202646255493,
-0.3545719087123871,
1.208061695098877,
0.14119628071784973,
-0.6661655902862549,
0.008066117763519287,
0.4132380187511444,
0.4503380060195923,
0.44865116477012634,
-0.12018321454524994,
-0.32830262184143066,
0.12593120336532593,
-0.23697836697101593,
-0.045358918607234955,
0.5371108651161194,
0.3746352195739746,
-0.17790155112743378,
0.394238144159317,
0.28238633275032043,
-0.17787787318229675,
0.3182443380355835,
-0.3281881511211395,
1.1444056034088135,
0.009177410043776035,
-0.29526206851005554,
0.5448325872421265,
-0.3817903399467468,
0.7550824284553528,
-0.4729642868041992,
-0.16179871559143066,
0.0994056686758995,
0.27646973729133606,
-0.09007683396339417,
-0.730360746383667,
0.3216017782688141,
0.3929436206817627,
-0.33529454469680786,
-0.3554297983646393,
0.9758206605911255,
-0.433729350566864,
-0.2015489637851715,
0.3657113015651703,
0.5013811588287354,
0.29767560958862305,
0.021092252805829048,
-0.42050254344940186,
0.14329952001571655,
-0.23718687891960144,
0.17981982231140137,
0.21622048318386078,
0.05196157470345497,
0.19445012509822845,
0.8575936555862427,
0.6839932799339294,
0.21311791241168976,
0.10116464644670486,
0.27566373348236084,
0.9498681426048279,
-0.5596259832382202,
-0.30546727776527405,
-0.5562809705734253,
0.2674257159233093,
-0.026188533753156662,
-0.5615965723991394,
0.3813771605491638,
0.4532057046890259,
1.0159268379211426,
0.11026664078235626,
0.54508376121521,
-0.0039655901491642,
0.9437587261199951,
-0.13510505855083466,
0.6933998465538025,
-0.34419021010398865,
-0.31426742672920227,
-0.2754630744457245,
-0.7188040018081665,
-0.3979427218437195,
0.6140048503875732,
-0.21482017636299133,
-0.0074413432739675045,
0.2987038195133209,
0.6406435966491699,
0.035779327154159546,
0.533935546875,
0.3911736309528351,
-0.029490206390619278,
0.4610239267349243,
0.5558835864067078,
1.1123771667480469,
-0.37015461921691895,
0.4138049781322479,
-0.37275397777557373,
-0.3307898938655853,
-0.11884857714176178,
-0.20486222207546234,
-0.26104333996772766,
-0.5978906154632568,
-0.169876366853714,
-0.035114556550979614,
0.5813658237457275,
1.0584509372711182,
0.8256691098213196,
-0.6610186100006104,
-0.18970875442028046,
-0.17597369849681854,
-0.28155913949012756,
-0.5874189734458923,
-0.19371186196804047,
-0.026469020172953606,
0.0013079997152090073,
-1.047869324684143,
1.0359315872192383,
0.015378739684820175,
-0.05425017699599266,
-0.21865777671337128,
-0.24827885627746582,
0.34499794244766235,
0.07977808266878128,
0.36688458919525146,
0.683170735836029,
-0.5490936636924744,
-0.36896997690200806,
0.005896535702049732,
-0.1278955042362213,
0.25438523292541504,
0.7538855671882629,
-1.015426754951477,
0.5379030704498291,
0.31400057673454285,
0.7861620783805847,
0.5449756383895874,
0.18150077760219574,
0.41579553484916687,
-0.40819457173347473,
-0.05348417907953262,
0.6606448888778687,
0.0373099185526371,
0.4920984208583832,
-0.15655715763568878,
0.4504706561565399,
0.31320682168006897,
-0.6831640005111694,
-0.8670982122421265,
0.2523477077484131,
-1.0217825174331665,
0.25972071290016174,
0.6563907265663147,
0.026047950610518456,
-0.17110392451286316,
-0.26788872480392456,
-0.40562760829925537,
0.27933427691459656,
-0.7303388118743896,
0.8333638906478882,
0.49482953548431396,
-0.6248891353607178,
-0.17371900379657745,
-0.287712037563324,
0.2746528089046478,
0.13086585700511932,
-0.4828377068042755,
0.1393701583147049,
0.2636062800884247,
-0.3630897104740143,
0.14979077875614166,
0.32125169038772583,
-0.028518671169877052,
0.4349740743637085,
0.22388647496700287,
-0.24078287184238434,
-0.10155871510505676,
-0.8328366279602051,
-0.5963113307952881,
0.042824629694223404,
-0.035001274198293686,
-0.6287505626678467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00722v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00722v1
|
LLMs for Generating and Evaluating Counterfactuals: A Comprehensive Study
| 2024-04-26T11:57:21 | 2024-04-26T11:57:21 |
Van Bach Nguyen, Paul Youssef, Jörg Schlötterer, Christin Seifert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As NLP models become more complex, understanding their decisions becomes more
crucial. Counterfactuals (CFs), where minimal changes to inputs flip a model's
prediction, offer a way to explain these models. While Large Language Models
(LLMs) have shown remarkable performance in NLP tasks, their efficacy in
generating high-quality CFs remains uncertain. This work fills this gap by
investigating how well LLMs generate CFs for two NLU tasks. We conduct a
comprehensive comparison of several common LLMs, and evaluate their CFs,
assessing both intrinsic metrics, and the impact of these CFs on data
augmentation. Moreover, we analyze differences between human and LLM-generated
CFs, providing insights for future research directions. Our results show that
LLMs generate fluent CFs, but struggle to keep the induced changes minimal.
Generating CFs for Sentiment Analysis (SA) is less challenging than NLI where
LLMs show weaknesses in generating CFs that flip the original label. This also
reflects on the data augmentation performance, where we observe a large gap
between augmenting with human and LLMs CFs. Furthermore, we evaluate LLMs'
ability to assess CFs in a mislabelled data setting, and show that they have a
strong bias towards agreeing with the provided labels. GPT4 is more robust
against this bias and its scores correlate well with automatic metrics. Our
findings reveal several limitations and point to potential future work
directions.
|
[
-0.5797672867774963,
-0.904349148273468,
0.6739361882209778,
0.22784502804279327,
-0.25806134939193726,
0.012722829356789589,
-0.09102924168109894,
-0.583667516708374,
0.17293213307857513,
0.32427340745925903,
-0.6931204795837402,
-0.263228178024292,
-0.6331074833869934,
0.3454730212688446,
-0.5929496884346008,
1.1940679550170898,
0.11541835963726044,
0.06904883682727814,
-0.6020957231521606,
-0.15100964903831482,
-0.43931588530540466,
-0.825103759765625,
-0.6496594548225403,
-0.7256813645362854,
0.4338034391403198,
0.019729383289813995,
0.9605613350868225,
0.2340177595615387,
0.39170390367507935,
0.34544819593429565,
0.07973256707191467,
0.1470845639705658,
-0.5239959955215454,
0.14323680102825165,
-0.4230508804321289,
-0.36233192682266235,
-0.5218931436538696,
0.13426901400089264,
0.4721064567565918,
0.7338892817497253,
-0.03337351605296135,
0.14994394779205322,
0.15877613425254822,
0.5355567932128906,
-0.37631872296333313,
-0.034110963344573975,
-0.7303652167320251,
0.1519351601600647,
-0.10120075196027756,
-0.22415120899677277,
-0.16322550177574158,
-0.32305726408958435,
0.3188656270503998,
-0.46726712584495544,
0.34677642583847046,
0.11977885663509369,
0.7826380729675293,
0.3391045033931732,
-0.39867809414863586,
-0.3400489389896393,
-0.690139889717102,
0.9165117740631104,
-1.0327006578445435,
0.4489459693431854,
0.08011133223772049,
-0.1482567936182022,
-0.3341149389743805,
-0.7256175875663757,
-0.8126637935638428,
-0.32556280493736267,
-0.23244579136371613,
0.3509729504585266,
-0.6456687450408936,
-0.12351851910352707,
0.37369635701179504,
0.3434247374534607,
-0.6651262044906616,
0.3039756715297699,
-0.0031643989495933056,
-0.16529728472232819,
0.7242182493209839,
0.5492153763771057,
0.20826248824596405,
-0.3566291034221649,
-0.40925195813179016,
0.013815855607390404,
-0.9308602213859558,
-0.16047795116901398,
0.42128095030784607,
0.1591755747795105,
0.11841709166765213,
0.6700698733329773,
-0.15226465463638306,
0.656196653842926,
0.0783337727189064,
-0.06440506875514984,
0.259039044380188,
-0.5924362540245056,
-0.43063730001449585,
-0.13980330526828766,
0.9337449669837952,
0.6534609794616699,
0.18458274006843567,
-0.1811191439628601,
-0.3408759832382202,
0.2990390360355377,
0.45892083644866943,
-0.7208345532417297,
0.04318588599562645,
0.21408505737781525,
-0.3118242919445038,
-0.45850425958633423,
-0.07567157596349716,
-0.568581223487854,
-0.3761281967163086,
-0.6997655034065247,
0.34749794006347656,
-0.29255014657974243,
-0.21045751869678497,
-0.08571784198284149,
-0.07378687709569931,
0.16920915246009827,
0.34316158294677734,
-0.5334727168083191,
0.24942918121814728,
0.6708052158355713,
0.7754052877426147,
-0.5116848945617676,
-0.2334497570991516,
-0.5155859589576721,
-0.19873200356960297,
-0.7320716381072998,
0.7237873077392578,
-0.42609018087387085,
-0.4349322021007538,
0.07396416366100311,
-0.1523522585630417,
-0.02497621811926365,
-0.7452698349952698,
0.5169703364372253,
-0.34157970547676086,
0.3578713834285736,
-0.6544396877288818,
-0.6545348167419434,
-0.09751613438129425,
0.4648750424385071,
-0.5364978909492493,
1.2031168937683105,
-0.015287581831216812,
-0.8320909142494202,
0.4912829101085663,
-0.4576584994792938,
-0.4254903197288513,
0.016505392268300056,
-0.37074339389801025,
-0.33440592885017395,
0.3206278085708618,
0.08930787444114685,
0.5315464735031128,
-0.4372292757034302,
0.6550601720809937,
-0.32323527336120605,
-0.2930658757686615,
0.6808056831359863,
-0.6322256326675415,
0.5154014229774475,
0.10583522170782089,
-0.3130134344100952,
0.021337058395147324,
-0.634821355342865,
-0.18448136746883392,
0.058223873376846313,
-0.41093894839286804,
-0.19155137240886688,
0.05404507741332054,
-0.004450247623026371,
0.43634364008903503,
0.1433771401643753,
-0.501072347164154,
0.0019384149927645922,
-0.4779454469680786,
0.2088560163974762,
0.6929398775100708,
-0.010746961459517479,
0.15633083879947662,
-0.3684121370315552,
0.4752201437950134,
0.1310948133468628,
-0.07584435492753983,
0.00989092793315649,
-0.3730735182762146,
-0.869456946849823,
0.08607947826385498,
0.0781783014535904,
0.5427709221839905,
-1.1165097951889038,
0.38933396339416504,
-0.1931549608707428,
-0.5084184408187866,
-0.24567711353302002,
0.26490679383277893,
0.44877001643180847,
0.8373796939849854,
0.5492313504219055,
-0.4333576261997223,
-0.707030177116394,
-0.9413699507713318,
-0.38494986295700073,
-0.28039103746414185,
-0.08716058731079102,
0.21143731474876404,
0.490474671125412,
-0.33126407861709595,
1.0847885608673096,
-0.44941529631614685,
-0.1401071399450302,
-0.3171270489692688,
0.41553813219070435,
0.35236629843711853,
0.32054463028907776,
0.787709653377533,
-0.5191952586174011,
-0.18933889269828796,
-0.4078385531902313,
-0.8628528714179993,
-0.4250936806201935,
-0.28890103101730347,
0.3126750588417053,
0.5991911888122559,
0.547751784324646,
-0.7618672251701355,
0.35825201869010925,
0.44510358572006226,
-0.32230180501937866,
0.7988160252571106,
0.01754985935986042,
0.11231797933578491,
-0.7494673132896423,
0.14745037257671356,
0.19569917023181915,
-0.2759121358394623,
-0.8646398782730103,
-0.14155766367912292,
-0.38528767228126526,
0.23893965780735016,
-0.46344122290611267,
0.4849211871623993,
-0.09020005166530609,
-0.2612074911594391,
-0.24530789256095886,
0.27742570638656616,
-0.013813028112053871,
0.4301967918872833,
0.20581962168216705,
0.5662361979484558,
0.2515421509742737,
-0.48467326164245605,
0.4805281162261963,
-0.04804456979036331,
-0.35466745495796204,
0.7657626867294312,
-0.7610482573509216,
0.05514025688171387,
-0.11943040788173676,
0.3142387270927429,
-1.0568307638168335,
0.0065530529245734215,
0.20183831453323364,
-0.40747520327568054,
0.21268707513809204,
0.13485705852508545,
-0.5760669112205505,
-0.36771705746650696,
-0.40581220388412476,
-0.03677256032824516,
0.40709200501441956,
-0.45461931824684143,
0.6120133996009827,
-0.0037993155419826508,
-0.32696884870529175,
-0.7767125964164734,
-0.9131723046302795,
0.4163806438446045,
-0.31063202023506165,
-0.2591165602207184,
0.204037606716156,
-0.2896457612514496,
-0.4485185742378235,
0.02146788127720356,
-0.23179976642131805,
0.40118154883384705,
0.029156066477298737,
0.23768918216228485,
0.40171584486961365,
-0.19768685102462769,
0.14893731474876404,
0.07854685187339783,
-0.05460150167346001,
0.32725247740745544,
-0.1612355262041092,
0.4275375008583069,
-0.19107747077941895,
-0.3089972138404846,
-0.032411281019449234,
0.25422292947769165,
0.2704450488090515,
0.18213585019111633,
0.620261013507843,
0.9151597619056702,
-0.1972322165966034,
0.06107404828071594,
-0.7196964025497437,
-0.06077209860086441,
-0.4323105216026306,
0.4499278962612152,
-0.28114134073257446,
-0.6321653723716736,
0.419458270072937,
0.0698404461145401,
0.18735119700431824,
0.6113739013671875,
0.6952849626541138,
-0.16501793265342712,
1.0271276235580444,
0.32647478580474854,
-0.013733912259340286,
0.3695979714393616,
-0.1257741004228592,
0.1106639951467514,
-0.6658087968826294,
-0.10125315189361572,
-0.39029306173324585,
-0.11121754348278046,
-0.5958315134048462,
-0.28884828090667725,
0.3813925087451935,
0.05109209939837456,
-0.1488085836172104,
0.05444658175110817,
-0.2237606942653656,
0.1434212028980255,
0.43625175952911377,
-0.0023248300421983004,
0.3664211630821228,
-0.0521339550614357,
-0.07435169070959091,
-0.1950550228357315,
-0.7611711621284485,
-0.6492794752120972,
1.0810158252716064,
0.2801699936389923,
0.6188151836395264,
0.2547992169857025,
0.47237256169319153,
0.35978010296821594,
0.7285463213920593,
-0.7161322832107544,
0.6570807695388794,
-0.3921523690223694,
-0.4748877286911011,
-0.19268205761909485,
-0.4721279442310333,
-0.7402665615081787,
0.35962268710136414,
-0.7991101145744324,
-0.4867076873779297,
0.2056044638156891,
0.35532671213150024,
-0.05033395439386368,
0.11651764810085297,
-0.49858957529067993,
0.5705831050872803,
-0.2550005614757538,
-0.4928430914878845,
-0.11253217607736588,
-0.5385280847549438,
0.4254601299762726,
-0.23462775349617004,
0.11735131591558456,
0.11778467893600464,
-0.10996168106794357,
0.7571911215782166,
-0.3556068539619446,
0.9828195571899414,
-0.11744415014982224,
-0.3940955698490143,
0.191005676984787,
0.1725573092699051,
0.39898061752319336,
0.1459355652332306,
-0.2198256254196167,
0.3381786644458771,
-0.12447220087051392,
-0.12982620298862457,
-0.6361434459686279,
0.8438601493835449,
-0.6884105205535889,
-0.8442713022232056,
-0.48014020919799805,
-0.5738409161567688,
-0.4309842586517334,
0.17916078865528107,
0.3176044821739197,
0.5055773258209229,
-0.48123034834861755,
0.12513546645641327,
0.5855639576911926,
-0.4385564923286438,
0.5481643676757812,
0.6467044949531555,
-0.2818048298358917,
-0.31283876299858093,
0.8364431262016296,
0.25685182213783264,
0.3109813928604126,
0.2388661652803421,
0.2939075231552124,
-0.4656943678855896,
-0.5603750348091125,
-0.5707366466522217,
-0.01640484482049942,
-0.7403369545936584,
-0.29961833357810974,
-0.6030023097991943,
-0.10483240336179733,
-0.43102648854255676,
-0.09741402417421341,
-0.23399686813354492,
-0.46380892395973206,
-0.29075342416763306,
-0.20872187614440918,
0.21672190725803375,
0.8391816020011902,
-0.26407116651535034,
0.19650040566921234,
-0.5942075848579407,
0.4071407616138458,
0.3748851418495178,
0.10402451455593109,
0.09418865293264389,
-0.4932814836502075,
-0.0462498739361763,
0.05241503193974495,
-0.35791194438934326,
-0.7791398763656616,
0.4856131672859192,
0.030709626153111458,
0.5191812515258789,
0.38292011618614197,
0.009541490115225315,
0.6340689659118652,
-0.364582359790802,
1.1314046382904053,
0.34119781851768494,
-1.1451961994171143,
0.24471311271190643,
-0.25910648703575134,
0.3189835548400879,
0.3101497292518616,
0.4391392171382904,
-0.4266185164451599,
-0.6485033631324768,
-0.641250491142273,
-0.9211408495903015,
0.5826002955436707,
0.17789512872695923,
0.24167174100875854,
-0.04586673900485039,
0.30121058225631714,
0.20973841845989227,
0.35170885920524597,
-0.9058342576026917,
-0.32539471983909607,
-0.5849050879478455,
-0.20733650028705597,
-0.44634300470352173,
-0.2543926537036896,
-0.19703513383865356,
-0.10166314244270325,
0.6422054171562195,
-0.1654813587665558,
-0.03544306755065918,
0.3575659990310669,
-0.06977356970310211,
-0.22957755625247955,
0.39204317331314087,
0.7259699106216431,
0.7697407603263855,
-0.19698479771614075,
0.2639559507369995,
0.517659068107605,
-0.26562634110450745,
-0.06032903492450714,
0.04590783640742302,
-0.20480217039585114,
0.17456936836242676,
0.7401896119117737,
0.8423228859901428,
-0.029342854395508766,
-0.6232237815856934,
0.4827968180179596,
0.02468046545982361,
-0.3056213855743408,
-0.2727695405483246,
0.1208849623799324,
0.18810464441776276,
0.11137604713439941,
0.4304704964160919,
0.09448794275522232,
0.1280151903629303,
-0.7004716992378235,
0.042403269559144974,
0.6474801301956177,
-0.24040476977825165,
-0.38417744636535645,
0.41689300537109375,
0.1570705622434616,
-0.00716067710891366,
0.5136505365371704,
-0.15922245383262634,
-0.5230435729026794,
0.48124271631240845,
0.6157558560371399,
0.664043664932251,
-0.15986768901348114,
0.14156708121299744,
0.26196011900901794,
0.5034257769584656,
0.08019107580184937,
0.1744842529296875,
0.08399035781621933,
-0.8955391049385071,
-0.5765864253044128,
-0.5828967690467834,
-0.45758503675460815,
0.4478338062763214,
-0.5880795121192932,
-0.00485632847994566,
-0.2054474800825119,
-0.3144064247608185,
-0.022548571228981018,
0.024927660822868347,
-0.8314767479896545,
0.5719141960144043,
-0.00003028197170351632,
0.5993279814720154,
-1.1290088891983032,
0.49309274554252625,
0.8179795145988464,
-0.3191677927970886,
-0.5761445760726929,
-0.04156559333205223,
0.11782962828874588,
-0.5847418308258057,
0.691155731678009,
-0.061051152646541595,
-0.21469509601593018,
-0.4061562418937683,
-0.5349361896514893,
-0.6999752521514893,
0.9687588214874268,
0.35588669776916504,
-0.6586333513259888,
0.12781864404678345,
0.5681849718093872,
0.9652822017669678,
-0.39784884452819824,
0.3249534070491791,
0.592441976070404,
0.5979205965995789,
0.03476107865571976,
-0.7895423173904419,
0.3338713049888611,
-0.030047351494431496,
-0.033891551196575165,
-0.07042084634304047,
-0.4198185205459595,
0.7196090817451477,
-0.11388171464204788,
-0.17334768176078796,
-0.07263121008872986,
0.4941864609718323,
0.2759020924568176,
0.45761117339134216,
0.603484570980072,
0.6916236877441406,
0.38203296065330505,
-0.16368190944194794,
0.9764726758003235,
0.009411104023456573,
0.16052839159965515,
1.1541297435760498,
-0.3600812256336212,
0.6528517007827759,
0.5791004300117493,
-0.21739566326141357,
0.4271014630794525,
0.5093814730644226,
-0.06894010305404663,
0.06925956904888153,
0.17821522057056427,
0.03404415026307106,
-0.40115371346473694,
-0.27448830008506775,
-0.23784291744232178,
0.48082172870635986,
0.4723483920097351,
-0.36134597659111023,
-0.02944958209991455,
-0.1695658415555954,
0.20417125523090363,
0.01076179463416338,
-0.2432134598493576,
0.9170578122138977,
0.29726508259773254,
-0.8320625424385071,
0.45623064041137695,
-0.06916791945695877,
0.7788012027740479,
-0.39425429701805115,
0.013517055660486221,
-0.39244216680526733,
-0.06894638389348984,
-0.41174057126045227,
-0.8217235803604126,
0.5338068604469299,
0.18258874118328094,
-0.14937688410282135,
-0.24527963995933533,
0.7586885094642639,
-0.40743595361709595,
-0.5443003177642822,
0.2153572291135788,
0.7965128421783447,
0.02768545411527157,
0.2536579966545105,
-0.7621431946754456,
0.07825358211994171,
-0.05803797394037247,
-0.553901731967926,
0.27771151065826416,
0.2244398295879364,
-0.06684505194425583,
0.6318467855453491,
0.7328647971153259,
0.32024502754211426,
-0.2329947054386139,
0.2831934988498688,
0.8019024729728699,
-0.6525572538375854,
-0.20815378427505493,
-0.9514963626861572,
0.1996333748102188,
-0.11361720412969589,
-0.2900003492832184,
0.8584932684898376,
0.42408502101898193,
0.8236538767814636,
-0.1410120278596878,
0.8169485330581665,
-0.023075468838214874,
0.5155494213104248,
-0.6724255084991455,
0.45588985085487366,
-0.6025020480155945,
0.4326593577861786,
-0.500971257686615,
-0.9993309378623962,
-0.1806020438671112,
0.23708540201187134,
-0.3132031559944153,
0.12167671322822571,
0.5704745650291443,
0.7536861896514893,
0.08456052094697952,
-0.09954731166362762,
0.3410152792930603,
0.3939046859741211,
0.4129446744918823,
0.42058077454566956,
1.0508261919021606,
-0.2766459286212921,
0.5191697478294373,
-0.03124665841460228,
0.013458569534122944,
-0.009684552438557148,
-1.159711480140686,
-0.8307046890258789,
-0.36067506670951843,
-0.35084134340286255,
-0.1583712249994278,
-0.06271057575941086,
0.8776962161064148,
0.4280776381492615,
-0.7202922701835632,
-0.01354058925062418,
-0.001143539440818131,
0.22851896286010742,
-0.14657288789749146,
-0.3280816376209259,
0.24572139978408813,
-0.23994861543178558,
-0.7268213033676147,
0.35540083050727844,
0.1596934050321579,
0.04684854671359062,
-0.36696377396583557,
-0.08477319777011871,
-0.08036023378372192,
0.5221115946769714,
0.8896796107292175,
-0.003949327394366264,
-0.8973425030708313,
-0.3536418378353119,
-0.12588299810886383,
0.03890502452850342,
-0.1406969130039215,
0.942729651927948,
-0.9367123246192932,
0.2612916827201843,
0.5905725955963135,
0.4705079197883606,
0.3628341257572174,
0.08277221769094467,
0.7144159078598022,
-0.8883330225944519,
-0.3875918686389923,
0.018013911321759224,
0.4510643780231476,
0.5453025102615356,
-0.27206021547317505,
0.5837105512619019,
0.24077345430850983,
-0.35635998845100403,
-0.862993061542511,
0.2947273850440979,
-0.8405861258506775,
-0.41341251134872437,
1.113033652305603,
-0.10423445701599121,
0.398497611284256,
-0.23355062305927277,
-0.01857849955558777,
0.1860419511795044,
-0.2517683804035187,
0.7159373164176941,
0.7273248434066772,
-0.5336354374885559,
0.058133408427238464,
-0.4249853491783142,
0.6056443452835083,
0.6922106742858887,
-0.8217439651489258,
-0.045934367924928665,
0.6480191946029663,
0.33295944333076477,
0.3404301106929779,
0.5562658905982971,
-0.052943237125873566,
0.11436840146780014,
-0.15729068219661713,
-0.1225573718547821,
-0.12091144919395447,
-0.025769436731934547,
-0.32256320118904114,
-0.007650057319551706,
0.027755752205848694,
0.3551221787929535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17343v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17343v1
|
A Bionic Natural Language Parser Equivalent to a Pushdown Automaton
| 2024-04-26T11:50:15 | 2024-04-26T11:50:15 |
Zhenghao Wei, Kehua Lin, Jianlin Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.FL
|
Assembly Calculus (AC), proposed by Papadimitriou et al., aims to reproduce
advanced cognitive functions through simulating neural activities, with several
applications based on AC having been developed, including a natural language
parser proposed by Mitropolsky et al. However, this parser lacks the ability to
handle Kleene closures, preventing it from parsing all regular languages and
rendering it weaker than Finite Automata (FA). In this paper, we propose a new
bionic natural language parser (BNLP) based on AC and integrates two new
biologically rational structures, Recurrent Circuit and Stack Circuit which are
inspired by RNN and short-term memory mechanism. In contrast to the original
parser, the BNLP can fully handle all regular languages and Dyck languages.
Therefore, leveraging the Chomsky-Sch \H{u}tzenberger theorem, the BNLP which
can parse all Context-Free Languages can be constructed. We also formally prove
that for any PDA, a Parser Automaton corresponding to BNLP can always be
formed, ensuring that BNLP has a description ability equal to that of PDA and
addressing the deficiencies of the original parser.
|
[
-0.22849248349666595,
-0.781390905380249,
0.6900342702865601,
0.2734208405017853,
-0.2832695245742798,
0.40470799803733826,
-0.09791641682386398,
-0.49850091338157654,
0.5195731520652771,
0.23232494294643402,
-0.37019479274749756,
-0.1418224573135376,
0.022514499723911285,
0.57586669921875,
-0.25618982315063477,
0.47720175981521606,
0.190964013338089,
-0.08168607205152512,
0.0533398874104023,
-0.10214834660291672,
-0.3263443112373352,
-0.5611574053764343,
-0.34383803606033325,
-0.3611273467540741,
0.3181913495063782,
-0.23092970252037048,
0.7466272711753845,
1.0007621049880981,
0.2472982257604599,
0.3790966868400574,
-0.19719719886779785,
-0.04385042190551758,
0.31263548135757446,
-0.1113494262099266,
-0.47105634212493896,
-0.2042398899793625,
-0.5359330773353577,
-0.38741639256477356,
0.7558395862579346,
0.789838433265686,
-0.0849076509475708,
-0.28190502524375916,
-0.3816390335559845,
0.9199658036231995,
-0.31103014945983887,
0.42495042085647583,
-0.4949226379394531,
0.016296779736876488,
-0.06821125745773315,
-0.0933099016547203,
-0.6651741862297058,
-0.6803016662597656,
-0.028261808678507805,
-0.2451065331697464,
-0.1593809723854065,
-0.13602891564369202,
0.5947183966636658,
0.30994299054145813,
-0.35030487179756165,
-0.22854594886302948,
-0.455336332321167,
0.5451607704162598,
-0.8741886019706726,
0.4105796217918396,
-0.03570553660392761,
0.5454627275466919,
-0.4829617738723755,
-0.5861313939094543,
-0.7486086487770081,
-0.5285910964012146,
-0.1359425038099289,
-0.16893884539604187,
-0.38169845938682556,
0.30468136072158813,
0.024219924584031105,
0.5473117828369141,
-0.62095707654953,
-0.15412749350070953,
-0.4041837155818939,
-0.075388602912426,
0.4201352000236511,
0.02357153594493866,
0.5985493659973145,
-0.5192344188690186,
-0.2592117190361023,
-0.023663727566599846,
-0.4963310956954956,
0.1515990048646927,
0.06389426440000534,
0.2508123517036438,
-0.02257986180484295,
0.31256526708602905,
-0.17609407007694244,
0.9357565641403198,
0.08468320965766907,
0.12868744134902954,
0.22787295281887054,
-0.13130278885364532,
-0.44990473985671997,
0.33935147523880005,
0.8454381823539734,
0.04952157661318779,
0.5954391956329346,
-0.30189505219459534,
0.13889768719673157,
0.27890563011169434,
0.3449280261993408,
-0.6444189548492432,
-0.5717343688011169,
0.20545554161071777,
-0.33652204275131226,
-0.27084797620773315,
-0.09588948637247086,
-0.5445423126220703,
0.10224325954914093,
-0.39953964948654175,
-0.026037584990262985,
-0.7617812156677246,
-0.09111455082893372,
0.39433008432388306,
0.24203680455684662,
0.11513658612966537,
-0.015169029124081135,
-1.0973172187805176,
0.7054091691970825,
0.7587810158729553,
0.8057979941368103,
0.1411244124174118,
-0.12751562893390656,
-0.41492190957069397,
0.11696690320968628,
-0.24766384065151215,
0.9139260053634644,
-0.38696184754371643,
-0.04382544383406639,
-0.28411582112312317,
0.036049868911504745,
-0.2121422290802002,
-0.46585211157798767,
0.023646939545869827,
-0.5815048217773438,
-0.04088921472430229,
-0.11416297405958176,
-0.42496347427368164,
-0.547624945640564,
0.0358341746032238,
-0.7469742298126221,
0.2976234257221222,
0.20341716706752777,
-0.30700093507766724,
0.028278840705752373,
-0.6485641598701477,
-0.9412257671356201,
0.11543378978967667,
-0.4413326680660248,
0.09729232639074326,
-0.030884334817528725,
-0.18436142802238464,
-0.100908063352108,
-0.006844113580882549,
0.5702555775642395,
-0.3968237340450287,
-0.021567383781075478,
0.17366309463977814,
-0.2968147397041321,
1.3370095491409302,
0.0315215103328228,
-0.5212624073028564,
0.09781201183795929,
-0.7709879279136658,
0.21462620794773102,
-0.15588785707950592,
-0.5646437406539917,
-0.03532043471932411,
0.07948458194732666,
-0.437532901763916,
0.5245440006256104,
0.2648710012435913,
-0.8302313685417175,
0.3669404983520508,
-0.9893955588340759,
0.8791220784187317,
0.7262923121452332,
-0.0960884839296341,
0.4189491271972656,
-0.34678906202316284,
0.309500515460968,
-0.37124571204185486,
-0.18602047860622406,
-0.25292739272117615,
-0.5766850113868713,
-0.44587472081184387,
-0.45626014471054077,
-0.01130270678550005,
0.7888542413711548,
-0.5777772665023804,
0.9808522462844849,
-0.18224921822547913,
-0.30444833636283875,
-0.3402193784713745,
0.1060413271188736,
0.5705089569091797,
0.5276852250099182,
0.49124300479888916,
-0.4681984484195709,
-0.6541988849639893,
-1.0472759008407593,
-0.22127722203731537,
-0.5107699036598206,
0.010464763268828392,
0.043281033635139465,
0.22205334901809692,
-0.07089652121067047,
1.044327735900879,
-0.15060308575630188,
0.013336251489818096,
-0.27011486887931824,
0.05201465263962746,
0.5072831511497498,
0.5079217553138733,
0.6482158303260803,
-0.15651363134384155,
-0.13374754786491394,
0.04512988403439522,
-0.5220164060592651,
-0.2782790958881378,
-0.08303261548280716,
-0.05212836712598801,
0.4741770327091217,
0.241618812084198,
-1.1156373023986816,
0.5080029368400574,
0.2409113347530365,
-0.2151416838169098,
0.5711167454719543,
-0.21382316946983337,
-0.09076929837465286,
-1.108994483947754,
0.3121647536754608,
-0.43397772312164307,
-0.16226162016391754,
-0.45101478695869446,
0.06620512902736664,
0.1585494726896286,
-0.0826340839266777,
-0.6193974018096924,
0.6840030550956726,
-0.2012813240289688,
-0.4003223776817322,
-0.4325340986251831,
-0.04375692084431648,
0.15303736925125122,
0.6343515515327454,
0.09269137680530548,
0.44982945919036865,
0.21922047436237335,
-0.6964148879051208,
0.5043246746063232,
0.41487014293670654,
-0.04029122367501259,
0.06874044239521027,
-0.807673990726471,
0.017947392538189888,
-0.03423866257071495,
0.6383512020111084,
-0.825289249420166,
-0.2150818109512329,
0.2623662054538727,
-0.39485853910446167,
-0.03178178146481514,
0.03146523982286453,
-0.7859963774681091,
-0.4710982143878937,
-0.26667046546936035,
0.581203281879425,
0.5625428557395935,
-0.578914225101471,
0.6170271635055542,
0.020547648891806602,
-0.10222499072551727,
-0.07152954488992691,
-0.8424870371818542,
0.1581173986196518,
0.37693262100219727,
-0.8488328456878662,
0.3874238133430481,
-0.1906178593635559,
-0.30271539092063904,
-0.01883215270936489,
0.005759432911872864,
-0.18113653361797333,
-0.05752786993980408,
-0.10888021439313889,
0.30623334646224976,
-0.5767176151275635,
0.005294439848512411,
0.16674338281154633,
-0.2819480299949646,
0.1949342042207718,
-0.21063894033432007,
0.7714352607727051,
-0.5652336478233337,
-0.28304731845855713,
-0.754885196685791,
0.3126365542411804,
0.7719278335571289,
-0.4814704656600952,
0.17840926349163055,
-0.1785803586244583,
-0.49047771096229553,
0.06000329554080963,
-0.1887311041355133,
-0.3197531998157501,
-0.5638075470924377,
0.058133915066719055,
0.017292650416493416,
-0.6544566750526428,
0.2743949294090271,
0.2653157711029053,
0.3162762522697449,
0.32621097564697266,
0.6374768614768982,
0.2484717220067978,
0.7746471166610718,
0.20826475322246552,
-0.1346592754125595,
0.18565449118614197,
0.18651512265205383,
0.5227400064468384,
-0.7339168787002563,
-0.027226630598306656,
-0.34973108768463135,
-0.37591731548309326,
-0.5513995289802551,
-0.26293522119522095,
-0.18436340987682343,
-0.08600595593452454,
-0.5561901330947876,
0.8189417123794556,
-0.5766828060150146,
0.44459614157676697,
0.4246862828731537,
-0.19332069158554077,
0.21771745383739471,
0.030066944658756256,
-0.6361777186393738,
0.11653321236371994,
-0.4367639422416687,
-0.6447630524635315,
0.26854050159454346,
0.1868930459022522,
0.38674166798591614,
0.20342543721199036,
0.6575106978416443,
-0.06653700768947601,
0.23719213902950287,
-0.8263444304466248,
0.8671925663948059,
-0.43929755687713623,
-0.6898051500320435,
0.14611105620861053,
-0.4523589313030243,
-0.73333340883255,
0.09787845611572266,
0.2918230891227722,
-0.9982427954673767,
0.34363311529159546,
0.3073010742664337,
-0.7012053728103638,
0.5320320725440979,
-0.6491811275482178,
0.7676838636398315,
-0.5067443251609802,
-0.2768634259700775,
-0.020763495936989784,
-0.858274519443512,
0.4024689793586731,
0.33998051285743713,
0.23736169934272766,
-0.14092792570590973,
0.2375965714454651,
0.2895981967449188,
-0.5356304049491882,
0.9209654331207275,
0.13476602733135223,
0.06361236423254013,
0.42643389105796814,
0.6390852928161621,
0.06890520453453064,
0.026814818382263184,
-0.14720101654529572,
-0.04738747328519821,
-0.19535139203071594,
-0.42378607392311096,
-0.6727367043495178,
0.6776756048202515,
-0.1791931539773941,
-0.4155815839767456,
-0.5397844314575195,
-0.45341360569000244,
-0.07325218617916107,
0.5800039172172546,
-0.2514892816543579,
0.45039692521095276,
-0.00024757045321166515,
0.22270363569259644,
0.20383583009243011,
-0.24761667847633362,
0.7253705859184265,
0.5730310678482056,
-0.19896845519542694,
-0.7466564774513245,
0.7989941835403442,
-0.2805473506450653,
0.4054231643676758,
0.533810555934906,
0.2852468490600586,
-0.21801544725894928,
0.061637163162231445,
-0.6437563896179199,
0.23340900242328644,
-0.44543004035949707,
-0.2697630524635315,
-0.8529576063156128,
-0.43238669633865356,
-0.3755989074707031,
-0.5776407718658447,
-0.3014266788959503,
-0.7989768981933594,
-0.11924246698617935,
-0.20259596407413483,
0.4376947581768036,
0.523406445980072,
-0.32927531003952026,
0.07763377577066422,
-0.9023627638816833,
0.7091220617294312,
0.4562143087387085,
0.40420079231262207,
0.1970990002155304,
-0.03309051692485809,
0.20655925571918488,
0.1938125640153885,
-0.538959801197052,
-0.8001188635826111,
0.47161754965782166,
0.21628805994987488,
0.3542034924030304,
0.3951510190963745,
-0.1945885568857193,
0.46800002455711365,
-0.7734248638153076,
0.4436117112636566,
0.229963481426239,
-0.9174233675003052,
0.4131516218185425,
-0.41790851950645447,
0.3860571086406708,
0.7283618450164795,
-0.10850610584020615,
-0.3486568331718445,
-0.36339497566223145,
-0.6236748695373535,
-0.7750638127326965,
0.3671712875366211,
0.23894992470741272,
0.1507101207971573,
-0.6671063303947449,
0.24468551576137543,
-0.07315826416015625,
0.27718687057495117,
-0.6647102236747742,
-0.07367783039808273,
-0.34794867038726807,
-0.29154929518699646,
0.4477289319038391,
0.1527087241411209,
0.30990636348724365,
-0.5414103865623474,
0.41187146306037903,
-0.0008315921877510846,
0.27393099665641785,
0.19898442924022675,
0.047489479184150696,
-0.11389818787574768,
0.37386584281921387,
0.6553121209144592,
0.3612779974937439,
-0.3735014796257019,
0.27068623900413513,
-0.2656175494194031,
-0.40018078684806824,
0.1586432009935379,
0.23943589627742767,
-0.28099536895751953,
0.058894336223602295,
0.3422207236289978,
0.3903803527355194,
0.6506521105766296,
-0.8139440417289734,
0.04512263834476471,
0.17298883199691772,
-0.04977560043334961,
-0.2013668417930603,
0.20930570363998413,
0.3528507947921753,
0.12594549357891083,
0.1558218151330948,
0.3539659380912781,
0.13169428706169128,
-0.8363266587257385,
0.8406419157981873,
0.12847590446472168,
-0.18518343567848206,
-0.6010591387748718,
0.7496644258499146,
0.10925479978322983,
-0.67535400390625,
0.49084022641181946,
-0.3002539873123169,
-0.7219421863555908,
0.8344547152519226,
0.8262844085693359,
1.0124250650405884,
-0.3558371961116791,
0.11922786384820938,
0.3916665017604828,
0.42266348004341125,
0.15439891815185547,
0.3671927750110626,
-0.13725179433822632,
-0.4788985848426819,
-0.5190563797950745,
-0.8608401417732239,
-0.3244495987892151,
-0.022847414016723633,
-0.3165091276168823,
0.040146999061107635,
-1.1096371412277222,
0.23112165927886963,
0.18098169565200806,
-0.254477322101593,
-0.14210888743400574,
0.19985778629779816,
-0.010419551283121109,
0.997304379940033,
-0.369246244430542,
0.8156248927116394,
0.7303863763809204,
-0.4695355296134949,
-0.5141887664794922,
-0.12977737188339233,
-0.013250809162855148,
-0.6581990718841553,
0.6614655256271362,
0.4309883713722229,
-0.22721876204013824,
-0.07864641398191452,
-0.06238635256886482,
-0.5738358497619629,
0.8088146448135376,
0.5571532249450684,
-0.3782830834388733,
-0.18260547518730164,
0.06313435733318329,
0.6818435192108154,
-0.4665277898311615,
-0.1504208892583847,
0.5404883027076721,
0.45765888690948486,
-0.03262871503829956,
-0.8154293298721313,
0.3823268711566925,
-0.5093193650245667,
-0.1408182680606842,
0.35605189204216003,
-0.736548900604248,
0.9809419512748718,
-0.19190537929534912,
-0.24326984584331512,
0.383674681186676,
0.5390406250953674,
0.6703081130981445,
0.22853527963161469,
0.19576089084148407,
0.5601507425308228,
0.29368773102760315,
0.23357488214969635,
1.1041256189346313,
-0.4782617390155792,
-0.02102712169289589,
1.252647876739502,
-0.36484742164611816,
0.7718045711517334,
0.33411705493927,
-0.09806010872125626,
0.9396177530288696,
0.0874050185084343,
0.043154243379831314,
0.45354607701301575,
0.4596193730831146,
-0.5090048909187317,
-0.19315609335899353,
0.1347064971923828,
-0.11736516654491425,
0.2547191381454468,
0.3260837495326996,
-0.41345593333244324,
-0.6388704180717468,
-0.4229080080986023,
0.03346770256757736,
0.3125815987586975,
0.03596019744873047,
0.5217946767807007,
0.422634094953537,
-0.5367835760116577,
0.6204309463500977,
0.05438705533742905,
0.3066946566104889,
-0.29585227370262146,
-0.24293480813503265,
-0.005748868454247713,
0.05742247775197029,
-0.08219442516565323,
-0.6078224778175354,
0.6702967882156372,
-0.18746060132980347,
-0.12950190901756287,
-0.1746668666601181,
0.7160540223121643,
-0.10035772621631622,
-0.37312769889831543,
0.31544893980026245,
0.16762907803058624,
0.17676575481891632,
0.31171464920043945,
-0.47548767924308777,
-0.2741450369358063,
-0.09338518977165222,
0.012771950103342533,
-0.0663602203130722,
0.2513695955276489,
-0.011174055747687817,
0.8345208764076233,
0.910859227180481,
-0.016075080260634422,
0.24812588095664978,
-0.342149943113327,
0.8962115049362183,
-1.0526288747787476,
-0.5936641097068787,
-1.045984148979187,
0.38487204909324646,
0.018991371616721153,
-0.20530952513217926,
0.220198854804039,
0.5086861252784729,
0.3865543007850647,
-0.14066053926944733,
0.6711423397064209,
-0.2905568480491638,
0.25489598512649536,
-0.3271709382534027,
0.7931861877441406,
-0.26385945081710815,
0.04881959781050682,
-0.12812550365924835,
-0.7980016469955444,
-0.47004324197769165,
0.9715332984924316,
-0.27515047788619995,
0.0913579985499382,
0.9641128182411194,
0.3816816806793213,
-0.21860648691654205,
0.11456608772277832,
0.14340616762638092,
0.2519364655017853,
0.4437154233455658,
0.8441539406776428,
0.34038951992988586,
-0.18626375496387482,
0.2810845673084259,
-0.48432019352912903,
-0.16199378669261932,
-0.35758307576179504,
-1.0526368618011475,
-0.9531965255737305,
-0.19532622396945953,
-0.035754863172769547,
-0.19427628815174103,
0.0006618187762796879,
0.9124298691749573,
0.44649672508239746,
-0.9105512499809265,
-0.10016141831874847,
-0.7029557824134827,
0.12266004830598831,
0.06965264678001404,
-0.2949807345867157,
0.3269110321998596,
-0.26287171244621277,
-0.207292839884758,
0.6766607165336609,
0.9359952807426453,
0.08769749850034714,
-0.18307454884052277,
0.11108440160751343,
-0.4527570903301239,
0.3100268542766571,
0.6839427947998047,
0.9919133186340332,
-0.7081006169319153,
-0.4292827248573303,
0.16207855939865112,
-0.189278706908226,
0.27370941638946533,
0.809221625328064,
-0.992577850818634,
0.35263291001319885,
0.6073797345161438,
0.8548263907432556,
-0.23680166900157928,
-0.18013474345207214,
0.7522642016410828,
-0.3932184875011444,
0.14036671817302704,
0.45531249046325684,
0.5387113690376282,
0.26235231757164,
-0.1550079733133316,
0.10473274439573288,
0.2665635645389557,
-0.3591609597206116,
-0.48998063802719116,
0.6516781449317932,
-1.281869649887085,
-0.038862377405166626,
0.8377965092658997,
0.01582200452685356,
-0.8411424160003662,
-0.23696628212928772,
-0.05558742210268974,
0.24469560384750366,
-0.44875726103782654,
0.9475759863853455,
0.4987344443798065,
-0.25901490449905396,
0.03590267524123192,
-0.38607126474380493,
0.30223357677459717,
0.4966324269771576,
-0.9040073752403259,
0.28867107629776,
0.5514072775840759,
0.23385684192180634,
0.4753377437591553,
0.7152411341667175,
-0.43874678015708923,
0.7857977151870728,
-0.37287840247154236,
0.21852117776870728,
-0.14664417505264282,
-0.10519658029079437,
-0.09110881388187408,
-0.04669058695435524,
-0.2466481775045395,
-0.07297333329916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17342v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17342v1
|
Can a Multichoice Dataset be Repurposed for Extractive Question Answering?
| 2024-04-26T11:46:05 | 2024-04-26T11:46:05 |
Teresa Lynn, Malik H. Altakrori, Samar Mohamed Magdy, Rocktim Jyoti Das, Chenyang Lyu, Mohamed Nasr, Younes Samih, Alham Fikri Aji, Preslav Nakov, Shantanu Godbole, Salim Roukos, Radu Florian, Nizar Habash
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid evolution of Natural Language Processing (NLP) has favored major
languages such as English, leaving a significant gap for many others due to
limited resources. This is especially evident in the context of data
annotation, a task whose importance cannot be underestimated, but which is
time-consuming and costly. Thus, any dataset for resource-poor languages is
precious, in particular when it is task-specific. Here, we explore the
feasibility of repurposing existing datasets for a new NLP task: we repurposed
the Belebele dataset (Bandarkar et al., 2023), which was designed for
multiple-choice question answering (MCQA), to enable extractive QA (EQA) in the
style of machine reading comprehension. We present annotation guidelines and a
parallel EQA dataset for English and Modern Standard Arabic (MSA). We also
present QA evaluation results for several monolingual and cross-lingual QA
pairs including English, MSA, and five Arabic dialects. Our aim is to enable
others to adapt our approach for the 120+ other language variants in Belebele,
many of which are deemed under-resourced. We also conduct a thorough analysis
and share our insights from the process, which we hope will contribute to a
deeper understanding of the challenges and the opportunities associated with
task reformulation in NLP research.
|
[
-0.6757404208183289,
-0.5420950651168823,
0.31268027424812317,
0.11213577538728714,
-0.15620771050453186,
0.07688378542661667,
-0.08570855855941772,
-0.562849760055542,
0.1623077392578125,
0.7953785061836243,
-0.6404253840446472,
-0.25482314825057983,
-0.34459638595581055,
0.5843811631202698,
-0.1974843144416809,
1.0357154607772827,
-0.10887265205383301,
-0.10477789491415024,
-0.2562576234340668,
-0.5568697452545166,
-0.8615944385528564,
-0.6432775259017944,
-0.5815008282661438,
-0.006691962014883757,
0.5832656621932983,
0.6009703874588013,
0.47170549631118774,
0.24761930108070374,
0.20897920429706573,
0.22592884302139282,
0.10522470623254776,
0.37258368730545044,
-0.137979194521904,
0.3410784602165222,
-0.24924591183662415,
-0.43739840388298035,
0.017199138179421425,
0.15778449177742004,
0.42369943857192993,
0.8691239356994629,
-0.19592984020709991,
0.38526132702827454,
-0.023827174678444862,
0.607962965965271,
-0.4721357524394989,
0.1985914558172226,
-0.6289572715759277,
-0.23685459792613983,
0.044018518179655075,
-0.1548694223165512,
-0.23510663211345673,
-0.5344319939613342,
0.2965320944786072,
-0.5664811134338379,
0.21177226305007935,
0.16433949768543243,
0.7255926132202148,
0.3890990614891052,
-0.3573152422904968,
-0.4552813470363617,
-0.6546247601509094,
0.9529582262039185,
-0.4718360900878906,
0.3977794945240021,
0.4630796015262604,
0.564241886138916,
0.1994086354970932,
-0.8068090677261353,
-0.4997427463531494,
0.18864856660366058,
-0.08879546821117401,
0.10424870252609253,
-0.10091810673475266,
-0.44464021921157837,
0.2932125926017761,
0.21584390103816986,
-0.4303169846534729,
-0.16233766078948975,
-0.5563106536865234,
-0.16077816486358643,
0.5707811713218689,
0.01390398945659399,
0.5105468034744263,
-0.34537428617477417,
-0.0539255253970623,
-0.09899228811264038,
-0.5592315793037415,
0.21441136300563812,
0.1114625558257103,
0.5479452610015869,
0.406900554895401,
0.6392347812652588,
-0.3353453278541565,
0.4652347266674042,
-0.2495109736919403,
0.2708277702331543,
0.7346535921096802,
-0.6328628063201904,
-0.1459425389766693,
0.10854685306549072,
0.2939552366733551,
0.18805336952209473,
0.48050767183303833,
-0.30331915616989136,
0.09723769873380661,
-0.34992778301239014,
0.46340733766555786,
-0.7338295578956604,
-0.33213019371032715,
0.643383800983429,
-0.2077120989561081,
0.012950229458510876,
-0.183595672249794,
-1.0300313234329224,
-0.2636665403842926,
-0.3172340989112854,
0.1852080523967743,
-0.4010651409626007,
-0.21419544517993927,
0.04755556210875511,
-0.20957927405834198,
0.3240441381931305,
0.17630188167095184,
-0.7168071866035461,
0.04437769949436188,
0.36542025208473206,
0.5289762020111084,
0.23603296279907227,
-0.3289540410041809,
-0.5887734889984131,
-0.050604306161403656,
-0.3207276463508606,
0.7961518168449402,
-0.6512426137924194,
-0.20019491016864777,
0.12771636247634888,
0.38352301716804504,
-0.07301706075668335,
-0.7905789613723755,
0.7532854676246643,
-0.7614356279373169,
0.38938724994659424,
-0.5825656056404114,
-0.29625311493873596,
-0.4249649941921234,
0.3884719908237457,
-1.206941843032837,
1.0461740493774414,
0.17438365519046783,
-0.8344034552574158,
0.27435341477394104,
-0.5218730568885803,
-0.3357579708099365,
-0.03111601062119007,
-0.008787604048848152,
-0.42548537254333496,
-0.10924124717712402,
0.8914152979850769,
0.26386526226997375,
-0.34715157747268677,
0.0031793040689080954,
-0.1027636006474495,
-0.21258589625358582,
0.23594056069850922,
-0.43868288397789,
1.196813941001892,
0.036611586809158325,
-0.10508223623037338,
-0.4241720736026764,
-0.9325141310691833,
0.3512306213378906,
-0.03070026822388172,
-0.4177756607532501,
-0.42711254954338074,
-0.14360393583774567,
-0.0007821667240932584,
0.5130596160888672,
0.24105209112167358,
-0.7835596203804016,
0.14479170739650726,
-0.36505892872810364,
0.20821020007133484,
0.45004743337631226,
0.4071042537689209,
0.15228807926177979,
-0.427802711725235,
0.7780873775482178,
-0.06861307471990585,
-0.0943174734711647,
-0.13573512434959412,
-0.4984157681465149,
-0.39811617136001587,
-0.4895373284816742,
0.49438005685806274,
0.7353268265724182,
-1.2691112756729126,
-0.07061196863651276,
-0.13916273415088654,
-0.40172240138053894,
-1.1652995347976685,
0.08589103817939758,
0.15649771690368652,
0.3342275321483612,
0.8448382019996643,
0.11492840200662613,
-0.7041316032409668,
-1.0614962577819824,
-0.16518457233905792,
0.1657778024673462,
-0.007101987022906542,
0.28221002221107483,
0.34719330072402954,
0.025233441963791847,
1.0086437463760376,
-0.3037613332271576,
-0.11429301649332047,
-0.3009452223777771,
0.29386311769485474,
0.21047303080558777,
0.3761350214481354,
0.5390009880065918,
-0.9153430461883545,
-0.32945454120635986,
-0.10570775717496872,
-0.6112728714942932,
-0.37086835503578186,
-0.25287699699401855,
-0.13596642017364502,
0.008802874945104122,
0.4714740216732025,
-0.30581945180892944,
0.22145533561706543,
0.5872764587402344,
0.02832639403641224,
0.8382554650306702,
-0.006288866978138685,
0.45780840516090393,
-1.1977486610412598,
0.06992325186729431,
-0.31660452485084534,
0.011250757612287998,
-0.6120246648788452,
-0.08542294800281525,
-0.006703187245875597,
-0.050720732659101486,
-0.47579389810562134,
0.4607252776622772,
-0.4599153995513916,
-0.009083347395062447,
-0.2638571560382843,
0.2787032723426819,
0.1847238540649414,
0.46739399433135986,
-0.01740628480911255,
0.8520120978355408,
0.44353222846984863,
-0.4025975465774536,
0.369661808013916,
0.6346932649612427,
-0.35436734557151794,
0.6363770365715027,
-0.7601363658905029,
0.22997213900089264,
-0.49026092886924744,
-0.13542373478412628,
-0.9284612536430359,
0.04564087092876434,
0.26265209913253784,
-0.34305107593536377,
0.15026366710662842,
-0.18084989488124847,
-0.462644100189209,
-0.100970558822155,
-0.15061363577842712,
0.4856710433959961,
0.292304664850235,
-0.638725996017456,
0.5638158321380615,
0.19550888240337372,
-0.7334895133972168,
-0.7981885671615601,
-0.6523404717445374,
0.034201499074697495,
-0.1329994648694992,
-0.28626036643981934,
0.05926913768053055,
0.10423798114061356,
-0.11762066185474396,
0.23162643611431122,
0.08556676656007767,
-0.1844572126865387,
0.003250744892284274,
0.14162345230579376,
0.16460362076759338,
-0.019084924831986427,
0.43035778403282166,
0.28059619665145874,
-0.03732148930430412,
0.05885216221213341,
-0.04395463317632675,
0.4153347313404083,
-0.03681791573762894,
-0.20176102221012115,
-0.2691514790058136,
0.8293662667274475,
0.3212548494338989,
-0.8402385115623474,
0.7493193745613098,
0.5639217495918274,
-0.554890513420105,
-0.13797315955162048,
-0.4039529860019684,
-0.10421572625637054,
-0.363262414932251,
0.520210862159729,
-0.4712219834327698,
-0.6938861608505249,
0.42727094888687134,
-0.10704554617404938,
0.6295784115791321,
0.42714619636535645,
0.4713881313800812,
-0.37364068627357483,
0.7920135855674744,
0.4171021282672882,
0.08241043239831924,
0.16942790150642395,
-0.1364729255437851,
0.1603611558675766,
-0.9935846328735352,
-0.22493137419223785,
-0.7983072996139526,
-0.24066570401191711,
-0.7495952248573303,
-0.29125818610191345,
0.1887221485376358,
0.08793444186449051,
0.0820794403553009,
0.27441415190696716,
-0.2713853120803833,
0.23269787430763245,
0.7003781795501709,
0.09381400793790817,
0.17836913466453552,
-0.051024071872234344,
0.19608759880065918,
0.05619265139102936,
-0.7264889478683472,
-0.6918932795524597,
1.3703114986419678,
-0.013480058871209621,
0.04586566612124443,
0.07092355936765671,
0.9761279225349426,
0.066597118973732,
0.5341382026672363,
-0.33215662837028503,
0.2955355644226074,
0.005147058051079512,
-0.896510899066925,
-0.5715787410736084,
-0.41241249442100525,
-1.271528720855713,
0.39919373393058777,
-0.36866673827171326,
-0.6203979849815369,
0.37000858783721924,
-0.07729119062423706,
-0.4063628911972046,
-0.03623311221599579,
-0.7264353632926941,
0.9422557950019836,
-0.10998103022575378,
-0.06903108209371567,
0.05276484787464142,
-0.5689830183982849,
0.022586515173316002,
-0.23672547936439514,
0.45876315236091614,
-0.16040866076946259,
0.21318161487579346,
0.9294233918190002,
-0.18128624558448792,
0.5750848054885864,
-0.29119783639907837,
-0.0250029768794775,
0.4725061058998108,
-0.23854273557662964,
0.26102179288864136,
0.007614194881170988,
-0.35802701115608215,
-0.0448613315820694,
0.6936873197555542,
-0.7861363291740417,
-0.8829388618469238,
0.28690898418426514,
-0.5795338153839111,
-0.5206336379051208,
-0.3829002380371094,
-0.6783949732780457,
-0.5145283341407776,
0.11390502005815506,
-0.28798413276672363,
0.5235337615013123,
-0.03298601135611534,
0.13767051696777344,
0.29759112000465393,
-0.35286983847618103,
0.3572704792022705,
0.14481304585933685,
-0.166935533285141,
-0.539881706237793,
0.9467331171035767,
0.2887464761734009,
0.05833161249756813,
0.057522498071193695,
0.0007810142124071717,
-0.5162285566329956,
-0.5487104654312134,
-0.47900664806365967,
0.29695042967796326,
-0.7044358849525452,
0.1066693365573883,
-0.49466991424560547,
-0.01771131530404091,
-0.22528013586997986,
-0.06087468937039375,
-0.22254039347171783,
-0.41540083289146423,
-0.24881882965564728,
-0.23625995218753815,
0.2626829743385315,
0.47581496834754944,
-0.053546953946352005,
-0.1909860074520111,
-1.0884941816329956,
0.3732864558696747,
0.5883854031562805,
-0.0011145129101350904,
-0.1062941625714302,
-0.33730170130729675,
-0.33625727891921997,
0.30942124128341675,
0.1482376754283905,
-1.0500335693359375,
0.4124864935874939,
0.15453322231769562,
0.6370624303817749,
-0.3198281228542328,
0.32102447748184204,
0.48108816146850586,
-0.5874437093734741,
0.6874325275421143,
-0.27282145619392395,
-0.5290663242340088,
0.24652357399463654,
0.2253541201353073,
0.3300938010215759,
1.0156985521316528,
0.7301545739173889,
-0.6955134272575378,
-0.39982858300209045,
-0.5559206008911133,
-0.8937891125679016,
0.5997593402862549,
0.26295533776283264,
0.03915072977542877,
-0.08977071195840836,
0.42022526264190674,
0.4832794964313507,
0.494413286447525,
-0.31340980529785156,
-0.27192163467407227,
-0.405786395072937,
-0.3303222358226776,
-0.1634388417005539,
-0.19859354197978973,
-0.13038046658039093,
-0.11209630966186523,
0.6086104512214661,
-0.0878826379776001,
0.1474071592092514,
0.26891234517097473,
-0.12586268782615662,
0.36322253942489624,
0.605446994304657,
-0.1334092766046524,
0.609403669834137,
-0.19140882790088654,
0.1866791844367981,
0.1314491629600525,
-0.36800000071525574,
0.19660210609436035,
0.48622599244117737,
-0.2464323788881302,
-0.01717325672507286,
0.2905791401863098,
0.29988572001457214,
-0.14982205629348755,
-0.9423453211784363,
0.14616018533706665,
-0.0025575237814337015,
-0.22673802077770233,
-0.19587481021881104,
-0.43704289197921753,
0.14576584100723267,
0.5489819049835205,
0.4064237177371979,
-0.2101389467716217,
0.18275783956050873,
-0.7048566341400146,
0.608420193195343,
0.2843846082687378,
-0.2228069007396698,
-0.09564889967441559,
0.3911993205547333,
0.10856974124908447,
-0.13949701189994812,
0.9174359440803528,
-0.3356168568134308,
-0.5693339109420776,
0.6017035841941833,
0.32602763175964355,
0.6583603620529175,
-0.10395059734582901,
0.5687618255615234,
0.3409591615200043,
0.5025074481964111,
0.36312323808670044,
0.7679459452629089,
0.1766987144947052,
-0.9354829788208008,
-0.5323160290718079,
-0.4363519251346588,
-0.3288257420063019,
-0.014117324724793434,
-0.8805335164070129,
-0.23704391717910767,
-0.09475988149642944,
0.07307088375091553,
0.2103378027677536,
0.15694786608219147,
-0.9337353110313416,
0.4581103026866913,
-0.0872679054737091,
0.5118969082832336,
-0.8773016333580017,
0.6223262548446655,
0.8037506937980652,
-0.61481112241745,
-0.6804745197296143,
0.011641846038401127,
-0.4551505446434021,
-0.6102508902549744,
0.46617817878723145,
0.13692720234394073,
0.12717807292938232,
0.1408134400844574,
-0.33182036876678467,
-0.7821919918060303,
0.9955804944038391,
0.15795780718326569,
-0.29539287090301514,
0.10062767565250397,
0.2635084092617035,
0.5747135281562805,
-0.11345625668764114,
0.18017050623893738,
0.8013424873352051,
0.5072920322418213,
-0.10524876415729523,
-0.6970098614692688,
0.21425122022628784,
-0.28940722346305847,
-0.3088909983634949,
0.11324876546859741,
-0.34104064106941223,
0.6441361904144287,
-0.1573048233985901,
-0.4366091787815094,
0.02551845833659172,
0.5874366164207458,
0.16634038090705872,
0.20412766933441162,
0.41918686032295227,
0.40429258346557617,
0.9981000423431396,
-0.09607990831136703,
0.9359601140022278,
-0.1701643317937851,
0.2244957536458969,
1.104196310043335,
-0.41762062907218933,
0.8973366022109985,
0.6849482655525208,
-0.2256169468164444,
0.4049324095249176,
0.6350078582763672,
0.11416391283273697,
0.5225873589515686,
0.04316091537475586,
-0.009850234724581242,
-0.2823520302772522,
-0.14664681255817413,
-0.15769058465957642,
0.4265977740287781,
0.10535485297441483,
-0.05709626525640488,
-0.38997191190719604,
0.17437836527824402,
-0.13256898522377014,
-0.0014679579762741923,
-0.254037082195282,
0.5994234085083008,
-0.18437328934669495,
-0.5914919972419739,
0.6225734949111938,
-0.15644541382789612,
0.13921765983104706,
-0.2806110382080078,
-0.3363596498966217,
-0.0996331050992012,
-0.4064696729183197,
-0.16845452785491943,
-0.757609486579895,
0.46183985471725464,
-0.14938141405582428,
-0.10329775512218475,
-0.18794891238212585,
0.2896615266799927,
-0.8169177174568176,
-0.5804507732391357,
-0.016929499804973602,
1.0420981645584106,
0.1945442408323288,
-0.27138230204582214,
-0.5797682404518127,
-0.32030266523361206,
0.25097766518592834,
-0.27783843874931335,
0.09570133686065674,
0.5147240161895752,
0.022359343245625496,
0.6519944667816162,
0.615347146987915,
0.0016036786837503314,
0.3343621790409088,
0.10690601915121078,
0.6972446441650391,
-0.6281725764274597,
-0.23030972480773926,
-0.26474764943122864,
0.44347479939460754,
-0.15388554334640503,
-0.30600491166114807,
0.6994253396987915,
0.4535630941390991,
0.7930667400360107,
-0.0815841406583786,
1.2042911052703857,
-0.11130858957767487,
0.9006649851799011,
-0.6331037282943726,
0.3277238607406616,
-0.6860101819038391,
0.016122784465551376,
-0.19041208922863007,
-0.8048962354660034,
-0.032070592045784,
0.23114505410194397,
-0.3252689838409424,
0.0018429519841447473,
0.9000797867774963,
0.5543397068977356,
0.40091925859451294,
0.35875260829925537,
0.12388627976179123,
-0.06828445941209793,
0.3483462631702423,
0.6536552906036377,
0.714556097984314,
-0.3866763412952423,
0.7924278974533081,
-0.524645209312439,
-0.17405268549919128,
0.0873248353600502,
-0.6098366975784302,
-0.7387794852256775,
-0.8786838054656982,
-0.4833407700061798,
-0.08432848006486893,
0.06359198689460754,
0.9628762006759644,
0.19772326946258545,
-1.010472297668457,
0.21178309619426727,
0.37217703461647034,
0.01598973572254181,
-0.7105492949485779,
-0.1999063342809677,
0.6910625696182251,
-0.3827725052833557,
-0.9714424014091492,
0.29040759801864624,
-0.014668840914964676,
-0.05645197629928589,
-0.10869123786687851,
0.45479637384414673,
-0.6010004878044128,
0.1073509082198143,
0.585854709148407,
0.5354454517364502,
-0.2230156511068344,
-0.6148113012313843,
0.15727947652339935,
0.19502289593219757,
0.13546931743621826,
0.671319305896759,
-0.7916192412376404,
0.5543292760848999,
0.2742462456226349,
1.3328243494033813,
0.3787538409233093,
0.2248738408088684,
0.442177951335907,
-0.8970910310745239,
-0.18177101016044617,
0.40161508321762085,
0.39694175124168396,
0.33503201603889465,
0.03734526038169861,
0.39299511909484863,
0.06775667518377304,
-0.44487816095352173,
-0.6696847081184387,
0.2840029299259186,
-0.7871936559677124,
-0.39603671431541443,
1.0418171882629395,
-0.174751415848732,
-0.09210369735956192,
-0.7706912159919739,
-0.545818567276001,
0.24120144546031952,
-0.2254057079553604,
0.8854763507843018,
0.9172880053520203,
-0.15008839964866638,
-0.5657618045806885,
-0.6267009377479553,
0.36549898982048035,
0.5076959729194641,
-1.1705994606018066,
0.25414517521858215,
0.5012856125831604,
0.2019275277853012,
0.31202206015586853,
0.49375492334365845,
-0.0892474502325058,
0.3603740632534027,
-0.026589946821331978,
0.3246607184410095,
-0.23087899386882782,
-0.3114810883998871,
-0.1978774219751358,
0.5315433740615845,
-0.062484610825777054,
-0.5756149888038635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17337v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17337v1
|
Metronome: tracing variation in poetic meters via local sequence alignment
| 2024-04-26T11:37:45 | 2024-04-26T11:37:45 |
Ben Nagy, Artjoms Šeļa, Mirella De Sisto, Petr Plecháč
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
All poetic forms come from somewhere. Prosodic templates can be copied for
generations, altered by individuals, imported from foreign traditions, or
fundamentally changed under the pressures of language evolution. Yet these
relationships are notoriously difficult to trace across languages and times.
This paper introduces an unsupervised method for detecting structural
similarities in poems using local sequence alignment. The method relies on
encoding poetic texts as strings of prosodic features using a four-letter
alphabet; these sequences are then aligned to derive a distance measure based
on weighted symbol (mis)matches. Local alignment allows poems to be clustered
according to emergent properties of their underlying prosodic patterns. We
evaluate method performance on a meter recognition tasks against strong
baselines and show its potential for cross-lingual and historical research
using three short case studies: 1) mutations in quantitative meter in classical
Latin, 2) European diffusion of the Renaissance hendecasyllable, and 3)
comparative alignment of modern meters in 18--19th century Czech, German and
Russian. We release an implementation of the algorithm as a Python package with
an open license.
|
[
-0.18149563670158386,
-0.3263072371482849,
0.6004685759544373,
-0.0021289922297000885,
-0.43183568120002747,
0.02682172879576683,
0.08770453929901123,
-0.5200809836387634,
0.5193527936935425,
0.5254344940185547,
-0.3017420768737793,
-0.6459745764732361,
-0.1379280537366867,
0.2919151186943054,
-0.30024710297584534,
0.45235222578048706,
-0.4503227770328522,
0.08065418154001236,
0.23429088294506073,
-0.4593593180179596,
-0.08146554231643677,
-0.3080763816833496,
-0.24480806291103363,
-0.4792178273200989,
0.6268730759620667,
0.189251109957695,
0.43995141983032227,
0.748368501663208,
0.335724800825119,
0.5002648234367371,
-0.14108684659004211,
0.030703218653798103,
0.23889756202697754,
0.20926757156848907,
0.06904332339763641,
-0.8615992665290833,
-0.24243570864200592,
0.12287236750125885,
1.091330885887146,
0.5386736989021301,
0.23205921053886414,
0.3654840290546417,
0.07187005877494812,
0.8078984022140503,
-0.3155853748321533,
0.010486663319170475,
-0.4605359435081482,
0.20560842752456665,
-0.9998759031295776,
-0.6836928725242615,
0.07265692204236984,
-0.48180416226387024,
0.059443823993206024,
-0.3663886785507202,
0.40463438630104065,
0.0537356361746788,
0.750645637512207,
0.17683528363704681,
-0.18982884287834167,
-0.08920925855636597,
-0.5883891582489014,
0.5321621894836426,
-0.6517100930213928,
0.4345451891422272,
0.1838877648115158,
0.47943243384361267,
-0.26492729783058167,
-0.6148083209991455,
-0.3126354217529297,
-0.09833571314811707,
0.012842555530369282,
0.22515541315078735,
-0.17188036441802979,
-0.38966986536979675,
0.032422441989183426,
0.31862565875053406,
-0.911397397518158,
0.031009985134005547,
-0.35554590821266174,
-0.2515566945075989,
0.3190647065639496,
0.2501814663410187,
0.3861534595489502,
-0.3575824201107025,
-0.4485255181789398,
0.16526317596435547,
-0.7269669771194458,
0.2566625773906708,
0.9414837956428528,
0.3505336344242096,
-0.4572206437587738,
0.5555064082145691,
0.06645260751247406,
0.664203405380249,
-0.11149367690086365,
-0.007013300899416208,
0.622160792350769,
-0.2983335554599762,
0.2241601198911667,
0.25704434514045715,
1.0679171085357666,
0.08928285539150238,
0.5325777530670166,
-0.0382411852478981,
0.044821273535490036,
0.12033430486917496,
0.16695062816143036,
-0.2324177324771881,
-0.49639835953712463,
-0.1484108716249466,
-0.4007217288017273,
-0.022555718198418617,
0.10516153275966644,
-0.6119993925094604,
-0.41877347230911255,
-0.3989254832267761,
0.44194361567497253,
-0.4370555281639099,
-0.12233927100896835,
0.08379340171813965,
-0.3273945450782776,
-0.042962055653333664,
-0.34053173661231995,
-0.7331728935241699,
0.11036849021911621,
0.6947954297065735,
1.261673092842102,
0.23371922969818115,
-0.5982040166854858,
-0.17067232728004456,
-0.341393381357193,
-0.46751418709754944,
0.837587296962738,
-0.46118706464767456,
0.022193044424057007,
-0.16480854153633118,
0.21872442960739136,
-0.17961430549621582,
-0.8977033495903015,
0.3828609883785248,
-0.062016021460294724,
0.1417936384677887,
0.05743880569934845,
-0.4755043685436249,
0.038953445851802826,
-0.24267514050006866,
-0.7970353960990906,
1.1470730304718018,
0.2852550745010376,
-1.2004951238632202,
-0.06352607905864716,
-0.25376173853874207,
-0.2211020588874817,
0.07376627624034882,
-0.21018894016742706,
-0.5448052883148193,
0.3335918188095093,
0.02027447707951069,
0.15206103026866913,
-0.10816887021064758,
-0.4701484441757202,
-0.22100119292736053,
-0.6232326626777649,
0.38957080245018005,
-0.23778392374515533,
0.808249831199646,
0.3071659505367279,
-0.3342582583427429,
0.14038895070552826,
-1.016515851020813,
-0.32598456740379333,
0.03740244358778,
0.04731143265962601,
-0.8753921985626221,
0.11276490986347198,
-0.022923337295651436,
-0.15269719064235687,
0.267275869846344,
-0.7165716886520386,
-0.1051734909415245,
-0.7333654761314392,
0.490140438079834,
0.5243979692459106,
0.1930437982082367,
0.47548219561576843,
-0.6603123545646667,
0.581444501876831,
-0.07227136939764023,
0.05521748587489128,
-0.09058048576116562,
-0.40545809268951416,
-0.2031608521938324,
-0.5583595037460327,
0.32078272104263306,
0.3868342339992523,
-0.5700333714485168,
0.47013911604881287,
-0.14886340498924255,
-0.8567643165588379,
-0.966216504573822,
0.10344332456588745,
0.061660286039114,
0.42823541164398193,
0.15326359868049622,
-0.4394253194332123,
-0.6642113924026489,
-0.678930938243866,
-0.7298380136489868,
-0.14712189137935638,
-0.37180644273757935,
-0.050195157527923584,
0.08680588006973267,
0.06154729053378105,
0.8398947715759277,
-0.2539159655570984,
-0.17763550579547882,
0.2637217342853546,
0.35428351163864136,
0.48450374603271484,
0.3208838999271393,
0.8292352557182312,
-0.19972027838230133,
-0.4931614100933075,
0.27367696166038513,
-0.40060898661613464,
-0.7378779649734497,
-0.01974085345864296,
0.02349914237856865,
-0.09703930467367172,
0.3868120312690735,
-0.40548431873321533,
-0.1256619244813919,
0.49125349521636963,
-0.3537708818912506,
0.8522825241088867,
-0.14146281778812408,
0.15842770040035248,
-1.2691292762756348,
0.14950156211853027,
-0.10520515590906143,
-0.28689971566200256,
-0.5153889060020447,
-0.16271930932998657,
0.26985546946525574,
0.017984239384531975,
-0.383472204208374,
0.5327770709991455,
-0.5109883546829224,
-0.23114725947380066,
-0.2962254583835602,
0.18933768570423126,
-0.2861557602882385,
0.04586529731750488,
-0.0771176815032959,
0.38595685362815857,
0.7038719058036804,
-0.31941652297973633,
0.377875417470932,
-0.2171788513660431,
-0.6637742519378662,
1.1201207637786865,
-0.277163028717041,
0.053895942866802216,
-0.11501078307628632,
-0.004609053488820791,
-0.9711279273033142,
0.3473445177078247,
0.03752129152417183,
-0.6904932260513306,
-0.016012484207749367,
-0.24243150651454926,
-0.41220277547836304,
-0.2312474250793457,
-0.420389324426651,
0.7511603832244873,
0.40531688928604126,
-0.42655131220817566,
0.3034237325191498,
-0.004818096291273832,
-0.25892969965934753,
-0.2744719982147217,
-0.2132696807384491,
-0.19117043912410736,
-0.7337077260017395,
-0.4091123640537262,
0.02652869001030922,
0.23522034287452698,
-0.37866973876953125,
-0.16630759835243225,
-0.42050498723983765,
0.14239272475242615,
0.08398307114839554,
0.264204204082489,
-0.03493363410234451,
-0.304549902677536,
0.14274360239505768,
-0.3474815785884857,
-0.3196636438369751,
0.12901930510997772,
-0.580673336982727,
0.6989532113075256,
0.00858568586409092,
-0.23575006425380707,
-0.7422067523002625,
0.19794563949108124,
0.8110339045524597,
-0.39210617542266846,
-0.08308164775371552,
0.795525848865509,
-0.3415102958679199,
-0.07192207872867584,
-0.1880117803812027,
0.034454409033060074,
-0.4995500445365906,
0.03970978036522865,
-0.5149377584457397,
-0.6454936861991882,
0.7747414708137512,
-0.26023438572883606,
-0.07123491913080215,
0.3896043002605438,
0.5053966045379639,
-0.6923400163650513,
0.5248662829399109,
0.2605375647544861,
-0.2128554731607437,
0.6821545362472534,
-0.007661871146410704,
0.12087421119213104,
-0.8284134268760681,
-0.005833236034959555,
-1.0019506216049194,
-0.8346245288848877,
-0.8389121294021606,
-0.4199988842010498,
0.42045482993125916,
0.13960298895835876,
-0.4114309847354889,
0.5417320728302002,
-0.25611183047294617,
0.4514479339122772,
0.35450124740600586,
-0.2262418419122696,
0.16607443988323212,
-0.009024243801832199,
-0.5279827117919922,
-0.31246885657310486,
-0.32054373621940613,
-0.390807181596756,
0.9408507943153381,
0.23188497126102448,
0.585191547870636,
0.04058600217103958,
1.1264369487762451,
0.08725886791944504,
0.031359877437353134,
-0.6401395201683044,
0.27969104051589966,
-0.20949411392211914,
-0.15422962605953217,
-0.18928280472755432,
-0.6534108519554138,
-1.5525602102279663,
0.062109578400850296,
-0.039270997047424316,
-1.0038106441497803,
0.12361954897642136,
-0.057455066591501236,
-0.05744170770049095,
0.3876519203186035,
-0.31980058550834656,
0.7728623747825623,
-0.16990213096141815,
0.2568987011909485,
0.17442424595355988,
-0.6380894184112549,
0.03337517008185387,
-0.20080362260341644,
0.33546262979507446,
-0.14581243693828583,
0.020681025460362434,
0.6202068328857422,
-0.6095377802848816,
0.8223990797996521,
0.07769826799631119,
-0.3169040381908417,
0.3031326234340668,
0.39503249526023865,
0.4113292694091797,
-0.4159468710422516,
0.13401813805103302,
0.3534047305583954,
0.21472984552383423,
-0.5444654226303101,
-0.6062994003295898,
0.7924981117248535,
-0.5847362875938416,
0.1016387864947319,
-0.19067242741584778,
-0.619949460029602,
-0.05319714918732643,
0.09305676072835922,
0.538265585899353,
0.31464216113090515,
0.13265150785446167,
-0.09512902051210403,
0.13779114186763763,
0.23710006475448608,
0.7273582816123962,
0.6734221577644348,
0.027254721149802208,
-0.7373825311660767,
0.7479673027992249,
0.43041250109672546,
-0.06479760259389877,
0.6446092128753662,
0.6275729537010193,
-0.47261863946914673,
-0.34020519256591797,
-0.3923778831958771,
0.37701481580734253,
-0.30602937936782837,
0.03784983977675438,
-0.06624581664800644,
0.13690733909606934,
-0.16338974237442017,
-0.34743309020996094,
-0.4382992684841156,
-0.3453119099140167,
-0.209665447473526,
0.08353570848703384,
0.559478759765625,
0.5575202107429504,
-0.03740673139691353,
0.22364577651023865,
-0.8939218521118164,
0.1329713761806488,
0.14721566438674927,
0.3724137246608734,
-0.2367689311504364,
-0.3969080448150635,
-0.1532629281282425,
-0.40711328387260437,
-0.1548769325017929,
-1.4151060581207275,
0.18049976229667664,
-0.014114586636424065,
0.4988534152507782,
0.47698113322257996,
0.07859204709529877,
0.6172909140586853,
-0.7616897821426392,
0.5180382132530212,
0.21229809522628784,
-0.9423324465751648,
0.3799324631690979,
-0.3956383168697357,
0.5264796018600464,
0.15068510174751282,
0.4980431795120239,
-0.7266934514045715,
-0.7276179194450378,
-0.6078144907951355,
-0.7954718470573425,
0.02550910972058773,
0.2340114861726761,
-0.21793679893016815,
0.09127401560544968,
0.5269268155097961,
0.1686924695968628,
-0.2027619332075119,
-0.372391015291214,
-0.2727733254432678,
-0.022602541372179985,
-0.7805729508399963,
-0.4669150412082672,
0.545767605304718,
-0.1997961550951004,
-0.30234256386756897,
0.19151417911052704,
-0.12324496358633041,
0.11619338393211365,
0.4765476584434509,
-0.06698545813560486,
-0.2553730607032776,
0.3293313980102539,
0.5067902207374573,
0.5682242512702942,
0.10857437551021576,
1.020105242729187,
0.1778101772069931,
-0.6733497977256775,
0.2221674919128418,
0.13937363028526306,
-0.3424990475177765,
0.437367707490921,
0.6651389002799988,
0.5168377757072449,
0.30961427092552185,
-0.3242628574371338,
0.09776976704597473,
0.46027085185050964,
-0.15700414776802063,
-0.2233821153640747,
-0.20982620120048523,
0.2553408443927765,
0.818916380405426,
0.10642578452825546,
-0.25117066502571106,
-0.06452327966690063,
-0.5786691308021545,
0.19809065759181976,
0.35513216257095337,
-0.5587894320487976,
-0.7922564744949341,
0.45476776361465454,
-0.2316998541355133,
-0.8259394764900208,
-0.11483941972255707,
-0.02376152202486992,
-0.5479145050048828,
0.5488229990005493,
0.6105313301086426,
1.044428825378418,
-0.567493200302124,
0.18710573017597198,
0.29114288091659546,
0.39660143852233887,
0.13433368504047394,
0.7561889290809631,
-0.32103657722473145,
-0.2975928783416748,
-0.05488109588623047,
-0.8310987949371338,
-0.09527759999036789,
0.031033173203468323,
-0.4106301963329315,
0.21716123819351196,
-0.1688632369041443,
-0.17741946876049042,
0.22186483442783356,
0.10721725225448608,
-0.47693800926208496,
-0.3267022371292114,
-0.06442470848560333,
0.49237746000289917,
-1.2603802680969238,
0.7287154793739319,
0.8891104459762573,
0.14465373754501343,
-0.5364389419555664,
-0.01598956808447838,
0.29835349321365356,
-0.5302783250808716,
0.38880282640457153,
0.14308495819568634,
-0.10699889063835144,
0.02215632237493992,
-0.05670089274644852,
-0.7984550595283508,
0.96784907579422,
0.29838287830352783,
-0.7456972002983093,
0.6047227382659912,
0.43225225806236267,
0.9609063863754272,
-0.12920653820037842,
0.145339235663414,
0.548607349395752,
0.3523716926574707,
-0.3072463870048523,
-1.1410027742385864,
0.005219847429543734,
-0.20640972256660461,
-0.13819213211536407,
0.8845521807670593,
-0.565776526927948,
0.9653341770172119,
0.2624313235282898,
-0.38877004384994507,
0.4245332181453705,
0.3164879083633423,
0.2612050771713257,
0.470443993806839,
0.2895453870296478,
0.8470157980918884,
0.9777939319610596,
-0.09267062693834305,
0.3649170398712158,
-0.26101362705230713,
0.23544152081012726,
0.8942883610725403,
-0.4583311975002289,
0.884609580039978,
0.3992358148097992,
-0.3957284986972809,
0.647761881351471,
0.6888272762298584,
-0.07884050160646439,
0.2380329668521881,
0.5806456804275513,
-0.4006034731864929,
-0.006991102825850248,
0.18666449189186096,
-0.4377725422382355,
0.5904430747032166,
-0.18016082048416138,
-0.4361066520214081,
-0.42540109157562256,
-0.24412114918231964,
0.04280807077884674,
0.2549471855163574,
-0.2390381097793579,
0.6223762631416321,
0.20008350908756256,
-0.3664250075817108,
0.8173938393592834,
-0.26350679993629456,
0.33368489146232605,
-0.5762020349502563,
0.1788567453622818,
-0.23152633011341095,
0.18803532421588898,
-0.07604466378688812,
-0.5513636469841003,
0.32208922505378723,
0.01822708174586296,
0.023959293961524963,
0.08634635806083679,
0.3916996419429779,
-0.35601940751075745,
-0.3073837161064148,
0.15749846398830414,
0.45753413438796997,
0.5279633402824402,
0.007179965265095234,
-0.39497697353363037,
-0.42129480838775635,
-0.39147236943244934,
0.1202395036816597,
0.19321481883525848,
0.6459482312202454,
-0.3555437922477722,
0.28688639402389526,
0.41031691431999207,
0.4901876747608185,
0.32398149371147156,
0.29259440302848816,
0.10286012291908264,
-0.9039885997772217,
-0.6813631057739258,
-0.7741329073905945,
0.12856873869895935,
0.17161105573177338,
-0.3400292992591858,
0.7763680219650269,
0.657896101474762,
0.9375960230827332,
-0.044588275253772736,
0.2761041522026062,
0.593547523021698,
0.40711042284965515,
-0.5417397022247314,
0.7827176451683044,
-0.49962326884269714,
0.10548871755599976,
-0.3469797670841217,
-1.0960986614227295,
-0.2892199158668518,
0.4811857044696808,
-0.03613707423210144,
-0.4515804648399353,
0.9224954843521118,
0.651923418045044,
-0.02316618710756302,
-0.11942766606807709,
0.16625641286373138,
0.17702381312847137,
-0.21627163887023926,
0.5526724457740784,
0.8855009078979492,
-0.26780468225479126,
0.30728697776794434,
-0.14591073989868164,
-0.27601316571235657,
0.07896608859300613,
-0.5827057361602783,
-0.7084804177284241,
-0.7780904769897461,
-0.35699012875556946,
0.018201934173703194,
-0.15506933629512787,
0.6522208452224731,
0.20858024060726166,
-0.4615303575992584,
-0.34610575437545776,
-0.08836860954761505,
0.18692518770694733,
-0.7708261013031006,
-0.20138521492481232,
0.6716607213020325,
-0.18779805302619934,
-0.6969876289367676,
0.5655814409255981,
0.36590221524238586,
0.3693987727165222,
-0.13865536451339722,
0.009738602675497532,
-0.01612665504217148,
0.25638553500175476,
0.0660955086350441,
0.4743354618549347,
-0.5748654007911682,
-0.30582889914512634,
-0.06507492065429688,
0.05924764275550842,
0.3401762843132019,
1.0705832242965698,
-0.5270261764526367,
0.5911832451820374,
1.1680529117584229,
0.23909422755241394,
0.26330623030662537,
-0.10247009992599487,
0.17486239969730377,
-1.1360441446304321,
0.03181179612874985,
0.19898352026939392,
0.6287667155265808,
0.3071349263191223,
0.14630809426307678,
0.3207292854785919,
0.810723066329956,
-0.41731417179107666,
-0.6610458493232727,
0.5132647156715393,
-0.9432419538497925,
-0.24827033281326294,
0.7573041319847107,
-0.1537129133939743,
-0.12473859637975693,
-0.3450373113155365,
-0.13973037898540497,
0.5211805701255798,
0.2946121096611023,
0.7941077947616577,
0.639639139175415,
-0.03148631006479263,
-0.205770343542099,
-0.518662691116333,
0.3666263818740845,
0.43574947118759155,
-0.49081966280937195,
-0.08655552566051483,
0.2699643075466156,
0.6156965494155884,
0.43020468950271606,
0.38835668563842773,
-0.37665584683418274,
0.1612004041671753,
0.10315035283565521,
0.2484302967786789,
0.20185989141464233,
-0.3407270908355713,
-0.4892736077308655,
0.34836074709892273,
-0.08475041389465332,
-0.5926170945167542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17336v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17336v1
|
Introducing cosmosGPT: Monolingual Training for Turkish Language Models
| 2024-04-26T11:34:11 | 2024-04-26T11:34:11 |
H. Toprak Kesgin, M. Kaan Yuce, Eren Dogan, M. Egemen Uzun, Atahan Uz, H. Emre Seyrek, Ahmed Zeer, M. Fatih Amasyali
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The number of open source language models that can produce Turkish is
increasing day by day, as in other languages. In order to create the basic
versions of such models, the training of multilingual models is usually
continued with Turkish corpora. The alternative is to train the model with only
Turkish corpora. In this study, we first introduce the cosmosGPT models that we
created with this alternative method. Then, we introduce new finetune datasets
for basic language models to fulfill user requests and new evaluation datasets
for measuring the capabilities of Turkish language models. Finally, a
comprehensive comparison of the adapted Turkish language models on different
capabilities is presented. The results show that the language models we built
with the monolingual corpus have promising performance despite being about 10
times smaller than the others.
|
[
-0.6225139498710632,
-0.6465545296669006,
0.02960340306162834,
-0.0037631718441843987,
-0.36221620440483093,
-0.4464045464992523,
-0.7165200114250183,
-0.3955773413181305,
-0.16433574259281158,
0.521765410900116,
-0.649768590927124,
-0.4047207832336426,
-0.5191517472267151,
0.1586650162935257,
-0.12045912444591522,
1.2730695009231567,
0.09468796849250793,
0.5509896874427795,
0.018904266878962517,
-0.3437038064002991,
-0.3865664601325989,
-0.3530624210834503,
-0.8109241127967834,
-0.04043138399720192,
0.3439844846725464,
0.5792100429534912,
0.5891610980033875,
0.6253602504730225,
0.5771774649620056,
0.2805219888687134,
0.02021280862390995,
-0.34880584478378296,
-0.3841800391674042,
-0.2724649906158447,
-0.16228383779525757,
-0.08832182735204697,
-0.15202178061008453,
0.0013731338549405336,
0.7590415477752686,
1.0591225624084473,
-0.019689196720719337,
0.6059885025024414,
0.22710265219211578,
0.5775208473205566,
-0.29662269353866577,
0.22765463590621948,
-0.4566085934638977,
0.11727161705493927,
-0.20470523834228516,
0.1671922206878662,
-0.11613492667675018,
-0.16240757703781128,
0.2154245376586914,
-0.6730210185050964,
0.44098445773124695,
-0.17887020111083984,
0.38636675477027893,
0.21790482103824615,
-0.38100436329841614,
-0.5474461317062378,
-0.6843995451927185,
0.7168475985527039,
-0.7617124915122986,
0.9586139917373657,
0.2576294243335724,
0.546464204788208,
0.03281179443001747,
-0.5717979073524475,
-0.28635016083717346,
-0.9969278573989868,
-0.12298864871263504,
0.12448964267969131,
0.07089842110872269,
-0.09461629390716553,
-0.04445836320519447,
0.3547477126121521,
-0.8226423859596252,
-0.0011104263830929995,
-0.8119440078735352,
0.0780484676361084,
0.23446393013000488,
0.09291195869445801,
-0.028452079743146896,
-0.1514400988817215,
-0.2626619040966034,
0.0022499344777315855,
-0.4368842840194702,
0.1508316844701767,
0.2899770140647888,
0.8933649659156799,
0.002194600412622094,
0.7789072394371033,
-0.5158645510673523,
0.8500114679336548,
-0.17515048384666443,
-0.24018344283103943,
-0.2577238082885742,
-0.3464012145996094,
-0.6630098819732666,
0.15722912549972534,
0.5194749236106873,
-0.35967257618904114,
-0.0510721355676651,
-0.3950783610343933,
0.1877432018518448,
0.173553928732872,
0.05991536006331444,
-0.7707826495170593,
-0.08831922709941864,
0.08077134191989899,
-0.3405075967311859,
-0.34640276432037354,
0.062076326459646225,
-0.5729367733001709,
-0.3505089282989502,
-0.5599068403244019,
0.2272595316171646,
-0.6306051015853882,
-0.436484694480896,
0.4580799341201782,
0.2483970671892166,
-0.025268560275435448,
0.18651394546031952,
-1.0488296747207642,
0.7579832673072815,
0.8811959624290466,
0.5852081775665283,
0.10950880497694016,
-0.6195396780967712,
-0.5500895977020264,
-0.3169809579849243,
-0.30976933240890503,
0.5804534554481506,
-0.27123183012008667,
-0.059396300464868546,
-0.05686602741479874,
0.21113166213035583,
-0.06294219940900803,
-0.18117724359035492,
0.9423414468765259,
-0.15966260433197021,
0.400377094745636,
-0.4178299009799957,
-0.47964000701904297,
-0.34945863485336304,
0.31015029549598694,
-0.5653981566429138,
0.8019915223121643,
0.14552146196365356,
-1.0746004581451416,
0.7854326367378235,
-0.7443127036094666,
-0.0027067228220403194,
0.2546265721321106,
0.055123671889305115,
-0.2646907567977905,
0.13092738389968872,
0.12344051152467728,
0.4192497134208679,
-0.23427174985408783,
-0.0013491944409906864,
-0.2121705561876297,
-0.2716929018497467,
-0.2700680196285248,
-0.43282508850097656,
0.7657837271690369,
0.6498718857765198,
-0.14158374071121216,
-0.03753143921494484,
-0.7995118498802185,
-0.06635414808988571,
-0.04009944573044777,
-0.7595857381820679,
-0.36175206303596497,
-0.14931322634220123,
0.36751511693000793,
0.29722529649734497,
0.258083701133728,
-0.5756000876426697,
0.2919275462627411,
-0.3881864845752716,
-0.02639138139784336,
0.3842775523662567,
-0.4739049971103668,
0.43441811203956604,
-0.14879535138607025,
0.6468197107315063,
-0.11865288764238358,
-0.02874692529439926,
0.10230707377195358,
-0.20639009773731232,
-1.1964921951293945,
-0.4715637266635895,
0.31444498896598816,
0.6172590851783752,
-0.5190708637237549,
-0.014266771264374256,
-0.39303094148635864,
-0.7880576848983765,
-0.6968767642974854,
0.26237916946411133,
0.2518181800842285,
0.28173157572746277,
0.14787133038043976,
-0.059272635728120804,
-0.7465875744819641,
-0.7194384932518005,
-0.291963130235672,
-0.1134239211678505,
0.20583277940750122,
0.12795358896255493,
0.3466249704360962,
0.08223428577184677,
0.7975200414657593,
0.18372219800949097,
-0.11354568600654602,
-0.5119822025299072,
-0.09022606164216995,
0.45840442180633545,
0.49099263548851013,
0.42440348863601685,
-0.571885347366333,
-0.4633117616176605,
0.6059899926185608,
-0.7453427910804749,
0.13302220404148102,
0.18707837164402008,
0.29345932602882385,
0.4873167872428894,
0.4086330235004425,
-0.4820687174797058,
0.19234628975391388,
0.7496480941772461,
-0.6484194397926331,
0.7188253998756409,
-0.32917338609695435,
0.25825169682502747,
-1.1137361526489258,
0.1894759237766266,
0.006524836644530296,
-0.4670775234699249,
-0.8489536046981812,
0.29308125376701355,
-0.16793407499790192,
-0.5291518568992615,
-0.7741603851318359,
0.651735246181488,
-0.45450785756111145,
-0.1282169222831726,
-0.28022634983062744,
-0.30185964703559875,
-0.5725221037864685,
0.34251686930656433,
0.24169307947158813,
0.8148224353790283,
0.8063960671424866,
-0.5916920304298401,
0.40232497453689575,
0.14406459033489227,
-0.7193138003349304,
0.2876873016357422,
-0.40481844544410706,
-0.020764507353305817,
-0.27360525727272034,
-0.2598527669906616,
-0.8942234516143799,
-0.24293862283229828,
0.3174605369567871,
-0.15521112084388733,
0.194794699549675,
-0.5423026084899902,
-0.251543790102005,
-0.48901522159576416,
0.1538131684064865,
-0.02500799484550953,
0.1950709968805313,
-0.5050333142280579,
0.04046640172600746,
0.023499732837080956,
-0.4715956449508667,
-0.7302226424217224,
-0.7540264129638672,
0.08400288969278336,
-0.5853263735771179,
-0.8133785724639893,
-0.3996583819389343,
0.04531712457537651,
-0.1505538672208786,
0.10789885371923447,
-0.0071524353697896,
-0.04819125309586525,
0.16716676950454712,
-0.011596380732953548,
-0.059897586703300476,
-0.7149160504341125,
0.18633237481117249,
-0.09936816990375519,
-0.2664766013622284,
-0.5266931056976318,
-0.9013704061508179,
0.5607909560203552,
-0.8453732132911682,
-0.37305527925491333,
-0.15765993297100067,
0.33032166957855225,
0.30355679988861084,
-0.36242246627807617,
0.9056076407432556,
0.8941217064857483,
-0.34453490376472473,
0.12247328460216522,
-0.5458217263221741,
-0.04686255753040314,
-0.42807644605636597,
0.666343629360199,
-0.6293687224388123,
-1.0431084632873535,
0.34861764311790466,
0.009805968962609768,
0.1669938564300537,
0.29616767168045044,
0.8481611609458923,
0.2782897651195526,
0.5398476719856262,
0.9228404760360718,
-0.11268320679664612,
0.3444734513759613,
-0.065195731818676,
-0.11129630357027054,
-0.1954529732465744,
0.07141096144914627,
-0.5923822522163391,
0.41215622425079346,
-0.8545734882354736,
-0.13023951649665833,
0.2454398274421692,
0.36285531520843506,
-0.2100645899772644,
0.7533405423164368,
-0.32390525937080383,
0.5448129773139954,
0.47696733474731445,
-0.2255505621433258,
0.3271668553352356,
0.33998194336891174,
-0.255248099565506,
0.025675546377897263,
-1.042927861213684,
-0.8343210816383362,
1.0053883790969849,
0.3650676906108856,
0.7164605259895325,
0.2076014131307602,
0.5275121331214905,
-0.06699292361736298,
0.4226997196674347,
-0.5745144486427307,
0.3214458227157593,
-0.4502580761909485,
-0.8975648283958435,
-0.5276461243629456,
-0.49952980875968933,
-0.9190008640289307,
0.4773632884025574,
-0.3417549133300781,
-0.7007575631141663,
-0.03772595897316933,
0.038312431424856186,
-0.22612571716308594,
0.13076387345790863,
-0.774183988571167,
1.36068594455719,
0.027109039947390556,
-0.3691648244857788,
0.07364890724420547,
-0.1073259636759758,
0.2678532898426056,
-0.036592528223991394,
0.3067156672477722,
-0.025176774710416794,
0.22443604469299316,
0.5772594213485718,
-0.48125630617141724,
0.4208605885505676,
-0.1934954673051834,
0.12683774530887604,
0.18552345037460327,
0.1706574261188507,
0.2889435887336731,
0.32705262303352356,
-0.18774674832820892,
0.16262933611869812,
0.30322137475013733,
-0.6325494050979614,
-0.029628943651914597,
0.731025755405426,
-0.771491289138794,
-0.5125634670257568,
-0.3750516176223755,
-0.40138161182403564,
-0.121773861348629,
0.3771376609802246,
0.315982848405838,
0.2556568384170532,
-0.8321605920791626,
0.049479320645332336,
0.07258537411689758,
-0.12862719595432281,
0.3243280351161957,
0.5829800367355347,
-0.449913889169693,
-0.3463869094848633,
0.6407487392425537,
0.08392134308815002,
0.1483331322669983,
-0.12078067660331726,
0.22254358232021332,
-0.09654904156923294,
-0.4805833697319031,
-0.75876384973526,
0.16268084943294525,
-0.728247880935669,
0.3391198217868805,
-0.5790388584136963,
0.07287327945232391,
-0.7220156788825989,
0.0008559904526919127,
-0.7183286547660828,
-0.6467034816741943,
0.15461410582065582,
-0.019704965874552727,
0.11291280388832092,
0.6811942458152771,
-0.23548053205013275,
0.22261136770248413,
-0.5344750881195068,
-0.08640455454587936,
0.4221556782722473,
0.2745552659034729,
-0.35687193274497986,
-0.44980955123901367,
-0.6641249656677246,
0.11152607947587967,
-0.12299123406410217,
-0.621208906173706,
0.43892478942871094,
0.1672486811876297,
0.4439863860607147,
0.2732500731945038,
-0.637672483921051,
0.5126426219940186,
-0.6478510499000549,
0.6683329939842224,
-0.010862930677831173,
-0.7916280627250671,
0.22849823534488678,
-0.6187294721603394,
0.3535923659801483,
0.7496510148048401,
0.37028205394744873,
-1.0183837413787842,
-0.2554851472377777,
-0.39682844281196594,
-0.2126285582780838,
0.9346936941146851,
0.4205114245414734,
0.07626648992300034,
0.20909856259822845,
0.1692732274532318,
0.603936493396759,
0.09917116165161133,
-0.8777498602867126,
-0.08340082317590714,
-0.5629374384880066,
-0.11178421229124069,
-0.4708482027053833,
-0.06222281605005264,
0.19548477232456207,
-0.3140527009963989,
0.8270503878593445,
-0.022102732211351395,
0.2929072082042694,
0.053954899311065674,
-0.10966368019580841,
-0.1345479041337967,
0.5201978087425232,
0.7167861461639404,
0.6439399123191833,
-0.40733107924461365,
0.012823767028748989,
0.5253618955612183,
-0.5449140071868896,
0.17556942999362946,
0.4715709686279297,
0.2012319415807724,
0.0918683260679245,
0.22548913955688477,
1.0787992477416992,
-0.18135657906532288,
-0.41218554973602295,
0.2451835721731186,
-0.1092328354716301,
-0.10905737429857254,
-0.6591616272926331,
-0.11567704379558563,
0.26273658871650696,
0.14939016103744507,
0.06155878305435181,
0.16428028047084808,
0.08083488047122955,
-0.371863454580307,
0.22751449048519135,
0.37916889786720276,
-0.6211578845977783,
-0.17687810957431793,
0.6303161978721619,
-0.27638107538223267,
-0.050268303602933884,
0.34770217537879944,
-0.2472403645515442,
-0.2928919792175293,
0.5055844783782959,
0.5998635292053223,
0.5404469966888428,
-0.3584434390068054,
0.30793288350105286,
0.5261666178703308,
0.6973708271980286,
-0.000261696899542585,
0.11162097007036209,
0.022124286741018295,
-0.5944687724113464,
-0.39481908082962036,
-0.8605894446372986,
-0.2621895968914032,
0.48974964022636414,
-0.3922866880893707,
0.8302605152130127,
-0.37267494201660156,
0.030800877138972282,
0.08374699205160141,
0.28570497035980225,
-0.8992419838905334,
0.3162457346916199,
0.3861097991466522,
1.1032038927078247,
-0.9550650119781494,
1.0884089469909668,
0.9819030165672302,
-0.443132221698761,
-0.5330379605293274,
-0.6029983162879944,
-0.11797327548265457,
-0.2894487679004669,
0.7014621496200562,
0.15531928837299347,
0.19431744515895844,
-0.070704884827137,
-0.29292112588882446,
-0.8691877126693726,
0.7914208769798279,
0.6088180541992188,
-0.2138877958059311,
0.20048274099826813,
0.6453952789306641,
0.5268186926841736,
-0.5443012118339539,
0.09168750792741776,
0.5232682228088379,
0.4319007992744446,
-0.16911634802818298,
-0.9857761263847351,
-0.24257947504520416,
-0.24798516929149628,
-0.11883661895990372,
0.05867372825741768,
-0.4132123291492462,
0.9674999713897705,
0.1821642518043518,
-0.2585940659046173,
0.4266168475151062,
0.7941809296607971,
0.13608357310295105,
0.24348586797714233,
0.3645460903644562,
0.6498755216598511,
0.630074679851532,
-0.03430008515715599,
1.2016806602478027,
-0.19192638993263245,
0.6729438304901123,
1.0385311841964722,
0.25180405378341675,
0.49945926666259766,
0.3595552444458008,
0.04565264284610748,
-0.05480063334107399,
0.8062135577201843,
0.013575399294495583,
0.6120188236236572,
0.113160140812397,
-0.39195725321769714,
-0.2974564731121063,
0.13701055943965912,
-0.4598301649093628,
0.5850853323936462,
0.20356391370296478,
-0.10072772949934006,
-0.5956699252128601,
0.4992900788784027,
0.3057083189487457,
-0.2983274757862091,
-0.2676047682762146,
0.610408365726471,
-0.06318329274654388,
-0.6309933066368103,
0.9618452191352844,
0.3705792725086212,
0.5650622248649597,
-0.6252650022506714,
0.4444371163845062,
-0.4585099518299103,
0.21116934716701508,
0.004079912323504686,
0.013052000664174557,
0.3760114014148712,
0.2593461275100708,
0.14872527122497559,
0.22921134531497955,
0.6580450534820557,
-0.7697396874427795,
-1.0513300895690918,
-0.03758896142244339,
0.5208121538162231,
0.47912731766700745,
0.04593074694275856,
-0.6587584018707275,
-0.2653108835220337,
-0.14688244462013245,
-0.2749159634113312,
0.02919699065387249,
0.392464280128479,
-0.07808563113212585,
0.5018133521080017,
0.7172961831092834,
0.23825116455554962,
0.4386806786060333,
-0.2616358995437622,
0.6646053194999695,
-0.3811284005641937,
-0.5544558763504028,
-0.7449676990509033,
0.3432559669017792,
0.2245260775089264,
-0.3298284411430359,
0.9176204204559326,
0.7523097395896912,
0.9831662774085999,
-0.5768516063690186,
0.9684762358665466,
-0.08964250236749649,
0.44717997312545776,
-0.5086950659751892,
0.9244264364242554,
-0.5890031456947327,
-0.05302917957305908,
-0.327006071805954,
-1.1787340641021729,
-0.20076122879981995,
0.5920096039772034,
-0.23969654738903046,
0.022374285385012627,
0.6038352847099304,
0.7812442779541016,
-0.742396891117096,
0.1319008320569992,
0.5404309630393982,
0.15757106244564056,
0.10072974860668182,
0.592167317867279,
0.767630398273468,
-0.44329607486724854,
0.33837494254112244,
-0.30051809549331665,
-0.34905025362968445,
-0.017712246626615524,
-0.8498645424842834,
-1.0649923086166382,
-0.6463725566864014,
-0.038094889372587204,
-0.12402056902647018,
0.1611480861902237,
1.0941447019577026,
0.891794741153717,
-0.9639465808868408,
-0.5866254568099976,
-0.3685596287250519,
-0.49481001496315,
-0.2672542631626129,
-0.07878666371107101,
0.46218690276145935,
-0.5598863363265991,
-0.6775323748588562,
0.5977925062179565,
-0.05249524116516113,
0.1469394415616989,
-0.3011605441570282,
-0.17149457335472107,
-0.11515986919403076,
0.1481083631515503,
0.3047521114349365,
0.4168209135532379,
-0.5072300434112549,
-0.16845105588436127,
-0.047560516744852066,
-0.11950390785932541,
-0.060979411005973816,
0.7156674265861511,
-0.6495448350906372,
0.31799641251564026,
0.379863440990448,
0.5969772338867188,
0.7989433407783508,
-0.3576129674911499,
0.23061580955982208,
-0.6662093997001648,
0.8899965882301331,
-0.2675034999847412,
0.46225205063819885,
0.588894248008728,
-0.16797858476638794,
0.6366615295410156,
0.11715171486139297,
-0.3194616138935089,
-0.45381104946136475,
0.0980728417634964,
-0.8422110080718994,
-0.2163015455007553,
1.1396116018295288,
-0.17186564207077026,
-0.06990975886583328,
-0.12118210643529892,
-0.3422100841999054,
0.39485645294189453,
0.12154419720172882,
0.6629840135574341,
0.9220957159996033,
0.42862895131111145,
-0.06518395245075226,
-0.9188777804374695,
0.6920997500419617,
0.5568941831588745,
-0.6891880631446838,
0.1211145892739296,
0.32545673847198486,
0.5488126277923584,
0.09456665813922882,
0.5694750547409058,
0.03426826372742653,
0.4040735065937042,
0.22141584753990173,
0.12936855852603912,
-0.4997267425060272,
-0.3079947531223297,
-0.5502108931541443,
0.14177408814430237,
0.277578741312027,
0.060548052191734314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02333v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02333v1
|
Speech Technology Services for Oral History Research
| 2024-04-26T09:44:26 | 2024-04-26T09:44:26 |
Christoph Draxler, Henk van den Heuvel, Arjan van Hessen, Pavel Ircing, Jan Lehečka
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS, J.5
|
Oral history is about oral sources of witnesses and commentors on historical
events. Speech technology is an important instrument to process such recordings
in order to obtain transcription and further enhancements to structure the oral
account In this contribution we address the transcription portal and the
webservices associated with speech processing at BAS, speech solutions
developed at LINDAT, how to do it yourself with Whisper, remaining challenges,
and future developments.
|
[
-0.2543104290962219,
-0.8993772268295288,
0.6270503997802734,
-0.10576295852661133,
-0.10971647500991821,
0.266886830329895,
0.23819103837013245,
-0.6067916750907898,
0.52833092212677,
0.4547463357448578,
-0.7830764055252075,
-0.03591454029083252,
-0.2316083312034607,
-0.16762986779212952,
-0.707038402557373,
0.6355817914009094,
0.20874223113059998,
0.3669407367706299,
0.056805163621902466,
0.2614116668701172,
-0.42705971002578735,
-0.7413904070854187,
-0.9624599814414978,
-0.06814652681350708,
0.41726696491241455,
0.3629743456840515,
0.49837979674339294,
0.44945812225341797,
0.5435351729393005,
0.3509579002857208,
-0.05374510958790779,
-0.1626562625169754,
-0.1426868438720703,
0.6285849213600159,
-0.2644065022468567,
-0.40846866369247437,
-0.7834169864654541,
0.10040003061294556,
0.4958897531032562,
0.6279308199882507,
-0.06223064288496971,
0.41617995500564575,
-0.26280632615089417,
0.37835511565208435,
-0.276961088180542,
-0.00414358451962471,
-0.1889917403459549,
0.06681813299655914,
-0.656714141368866,
-0.6082818508148193,
-0.37569063901901245,
-0.8629197478294373,
0.6918564438819885,
-0.4882655739784241,
0.6591635942459106,
-0.1657813936471939,
0.6198316812515259,
-0.050100065767765045,
-0.30221372842788696,
-0.3802059292793274,
-1.200697422027588,
0.6166285872459412,
-0.38088417053222656,
0.4063614010810852,
0.4983627200126648,
0.6898912191390991,
0.19525592029094696,
-1.049146056175232,
-0.2831416428089142,
0.03882934898138046,
0.08722257614135742,
0.0783577486872673,
-0.375786691904068,
-0.03752671554684639,
0.10057222098112106,
0.1701299250125885,
-0.6518044471740723,
-0.17575836181640625,
-0.7790128588676453,
-0.45284610986709595,
0.5922971963882446,
0.11452585458755493,
0.4163846969604492,
-0.15580223500728607,
-0.2013518512248993,
0.025486880913376808,
-0.4282661974430084,
0.09740429371595383,
0.2468474805355072,
0.32587340474128723,
0.3441065847873688,
0.4503830075263977,
-0.2467551827430725,
0.6857670545578003,
-0.19495370984077454,
-0.4985259473323822,
0.14347639679908752,
-0.005743666086345911,
-0.09945439547300339,
0.6791248321533203,
0.09942903369665146,
-0.1670546978712082,
-0.06714163720607758,
0.004325814079493284,
0.028796879574656487,
-0.29717543721199036,
0.3024321496486664,
-0.42576199769973755,
0.32563671469688416,
-0.026911558583378792,
-0.6121775507926941,
0.08664228767156601,
0.08495800197124481,
-0.5510246753692627,
-0.39436447620391846,
-0.5130575299263,
0.5469866394996643,
-0.5064614415168762,
-0.6203073263168335,
-0.38958093523979187,
-0.999606728553772,
0.23754288256168365,
0.4728507697582245,
-0.5683838129043579,
0.4957197308540344,
0.8069996237754822,
1.1367794275283813,
0.11082882434129715,
-0.15201488137245178,
-0.7263705134391785,
0.30648642778396606,
-0.12720203399658203,
1.0201144218444824,
-0.3721954822540283,
-0.7909340858459473,
0.2778094708919525,
-0.07292386144399643,
0.344014436006546,
-0.5752363801002502,
0.6110813617706299,
-0.5997543931007385,
0.020545637235045433,
-0.30396831035614014,
-0.9160066843032837,
-0.23902097344398499,
-0.3440915048122406,
-0.5500975251197815,
0.4231032431125641,
0.0874188169836998,
-0.1761103719472885,
0.21010372042655945,
-0.7642862796783447,
-0.7897686958312988,
0.451111376285553,
-0.14443136751651764,
-0.025125611573457718,
0.09215685725212097,
0.007741912733763456,
0.42965856194496155,
0.0534573495388031,
-0.029257239773869514,
0.03031185083091259,
-0.4673762917518616,
0.4439869225025177,
-0.35884642601013184,
1.0283092260360718,
0.5169164538383484,
-0.4929482042789459,
0.14168843626976013,
-0.8812397122383118,
-0.30285701155662537,
-0.1041443794965744,
-0.19449180364608765,
-0.17986451089382172,
-0.03195219114422798,
0.3282153606414795,
-0.19978734850883484,
0.09547154605388641,
-0.5361320376396179,
-0.01361897587776184,
-0.4106159508228302,
0.49631625413894653,
0.8533006906509399,
0.15105025470256805,
0.06941559165716171,
-0.49738648533821106,
0.8289534449577332,
-0.33976659178733826,
0.37724703550338745,
-0.4051227569580078,
-0.7765138149261475,
-0.43868595361709595,
0.00036143415491096675,
0.29971274733543396,
0.608406662940979,
-0.541461169719696,
-0.04324999451637268,
-0.3891145884990692,
-0.4206583499908447,
-0.7463436126708984,
-0.21650537848472595,
0.12046080082654953,
0.6662845015525818,
0.015864770859479904,
-0.062462709844112396,
-0.9024976491928101,
-1.0331943035125732,
0.12408290058374405,
-0.36394205689430237,
0.11247596889734268,
-0.03574468940496445,
-0.1613532304763794,
0.25431814789772034,
1.2273759841918945,
-0.3359217345714569,
-0.6679292917251587,
-0.014527629129588604,
0.41321688890457153,
-0.041897837072610855,
0.13066937029361725,
0.5370049476623535,
-1.1721196174621582,
-0.4731557369232178,
0.0554751418530941,
-0.610180675983429,
-0.32862886786460876,
0.18387307226657867,
0.5337501764297485,
0.4333328306674957,
0.5601462721824646,
-0.24390804767608643,
0.40721291303634644,
0.4268716871738434,
-0.18269476294517517,
0.28548359870910645,
0.30513742566108704,
0.4043150842189789,
-0.9608081579208374,
0.013070860877633095,
-0.42137449979782104,
-0.5578506588935852,
-0.6916093826293945,
-0.378305047750473,
-0.3368837237358093,
-0.5176587104797363,
-0.6384249329566956,
0.3008817136287689,
-0.24914371967315674,
-0.39651185274124146,
-0.6214361786842346,
0.32861605286598206,
-0.337012380361557,
-0.07592704147100449,
0.1797506958246231,
1.054732322692871,
0.5444501042366028,
-0.5941454172134399,
0.7914690971374512,
0.26783087849617004,
-0.2159574329853058,
1.0370970964431763,
-0.24749897420406342,
0.3279796242713928,
0.13134416937828064,
0.07607942819595337,
-0.6066431999206543,
-0.19460462033748627,
-0.3013346791267395,
-0.7989126443862915,
0.34630709886550903,
0.14667430520057678,
0.1588580161333084,
-0.2425973266363144,
-0.10169630497694016,
-0.08720655739307404,
0.5391063094139099,
-0.19570545852184296,
0.9005585312843323,
0.8547511100769043,
-0.7725483179092407,
-0.5374817848205566,
-0.7675444483757019,
0.401780366897583,
0.020064514130353928,
-0.8934289813041687,
0.14134535193443298,
0.035882722586393356,
-0.674685001373291,
0.23572535812854767,
-0.01992674171924591,
-0.430303156375885,
-0.09807469695806503,
0.35287392139434814,
0.10356897115707397,
-0.5549547076225281,
0.30747953057289124,
-0.09093215316534042,
-0.29526492953300476,
0.10347313433885574,
-0.2241060882806778,
0.6812120676040649,
0.053720925003290176,
-0.2549879848957062,
-0.9218069314956665,
0.8224396705627441,
0.201276496052742,
0.3862454295158386,
0.5038607120513916,
0.5996939539909363,
-0.30645760893821716,
0.05150260031223297,
-1.2052119970321655,
-0.07362476736307144,
-0.4572681486606598,
-0.05795774608850479,
-0.5632705688476562,
-1.1064825057983398,
0.2537505030632019,
-0.06688419729471207,
-0.08117913454771042,
0.4344957172870636,
0.4003315269947052,
-0.4082948565483093,
0.5886844396591187,
0.3087414503097534,
-0.16422626376152039,
0.5953723192214966,
0.21229107677936554,
-0.09507568180561066,
-0.5871095061302185,
0.10954935848712921,
-0.7022929191589355,
0.030965467914938927,
-0.34432023763656616,
0.11140689998865128,
0.5101187229156494,
-0.5044353008270264,
0.09463367611169815,
0.12467293441295624,
-0.4003778398036957,
0.017162349075078964,
1.1607815027236938,
0.09685710072517395,
0.40615472197532654,
-0.3244487941265106,
0.42139485478401184,
-0.11340945959091187,
-0.04171748459339142,
-0.5343000292778015,
0.6888203620910645,
0.24692222476005554,
0.5579327940940857,
0.4459201693534851,
0.6562556624412537,
0.9562985897064209,
-0.25232091546058655,
-0.6741887927055359,
0.5699019432067871,
-0.02463465742766857,
-0.8213552236557007,
-0.5793576836585999,
0.03284834325313568,
-0.9217939972877502,
-0.14710798859596252,
0.37401410937309265,
-0.7368239760398865,
0.3719603419303894,
0.25099802017211914,
-0.4845435619354248,
-0.011571873910725117,
-1.0227859020233154,
0.3176002502441406,
0.12463068217039108,
0.11812228709459305,
-0.45369911193847656,
-0.7320607304573059,
-0.008433198556303978,
0.2504369914531708,
0.26144784688949585,
0.19670714437961578,
0.23946218192577362,
0.8339829444885254,
-0.14609748125076294,
1.0411361455917358,
-0.2595185935497284,
0.11169406771659851,
0.5010231733322144,
0.3090899884700775,
0.1776512861251831,
-0.4119087755680084,
-0.0019830174278467894,
-0.1357763409614563,
0.35938701033592224,
-0.08808747678995132,
-0.32673728466033936,
0.48122477531433105,
-0.7518677115440369,
-1.1814881563186646,
-0.5429945588111877,
-0.1534658670425415,
-0.233537957072258,
0.112148717045784,
0.08754206448793411,
0.5684942007064819,
-0.73704594373703,
0.30639058351516724,
0.8237038254737854,
0.16537609696388245,
0.6447873115539551,
0.4559211730957031,
-0.21398542821407318,
-0.23169638216495514,
0.85288405418396,
0.4207434058189392,
0.11312132328748703,
0.6730844378471375,
0.16415062546730042,
-0.3967616856098175,
-0.4939243495464325,
-0.3289542496204376,
0.006944941356778145,
-1.094450831413269,
-0.12758171558380127,
-0.5667168498039246,
-0.4300949275493622,
-1.0088478326797485,
-0.11135777086019516,
-0.07731938362121582,
-0.8071257472038269,
-0.35835158824920654,
-0.4844066798686981,
0.26958030462265015,
0.9120388627052307,
-0.5135717988014221,
0.26695555448532104,
-0.7295624017715454,
0.40769314765930176,
0.7604101300239563,
-0.1340949535369873,
-0.3143204152584076,
-0.2574233412742615,
-0.0447530634701252,
-0.23939651250839233,
-0.2091425657272339,
-1.0414116382598877,
0.07913118600845337,
0.16794829070568085,
0.5131862759590149,
0.21730825304985046,
-0.38494616746902466,
0.7984555959701538,
-0.5744943022727966,
1.1724390983581543,
-0.07996219396591187,
-1.356980562210083,
1.1052277088165283,
-0.30838486552238464,
0.17619433999061584,
0.16973181068897247,
0.16065378487110138,
-0.8098363280296326,
-0.1804271787405014,
-0.7957252860069275,
-0.5199649333953857,
0.8890469670295715,
0.008128135465085506,
-0.1191861554980278,
0.21648560464382172,
0.30329567193984985,
0.13085415959358215,
0.042770832777023315,
-0.3055833578109741,
-0.24461975693702698,
-0.40190455317497253,
0.3446537256240845,
0.17069822549819946,
-0.38183456659317017,
-0.14383502304553986,
-0.03243519365787506,
1.048302173614502,
0.15809254348278046,
0.1690203845500946,
0.5483916997909546,
-0.101190946996212,
-0.34778881072998047,
0.45393532514572144,
0.7164115309715271,
1.1361973285675049,
-0.20065371692180634,
0.1781853437423706,
0.014015456661581993,
-0.7774868011474609,
0.04102019965648651,
0.14633819460868835,
-0.3398737609386444,
0.3920334577560425,
0.35671481490135193,
0.7141439914703369,
-0.14317886531352997,
-0.5053234100341797,
0.4333041310310364,
-0.040244150906801224,
-0.05799514427781105,
-0.8899832963943481,
0.06245803460478783,
0.26242300868034363,
0.4902811348438263,
0.8101347088813782,
-0.13108932971954346,
0.693220853805542,
-0.9462812542915344,
0.30686312913894653,
0.23222635686397552,
-0.5621041655540466,
-0.07157359272241592,
0.5822570323944092,
0.29751887917518616,
-0.9469493627548218,
0.4406113922595978,
0.1715112030506134,
-0.20988883078098297,
0.16858160495758057,
0.5618950128555298,
1.019322395324707,
-0.9695746302604675,
0.5147143006324768,
0.11493340879678726,
0.011287597008049488,
0.3209385275840759,
0.19928255677223206,
-0.1227487102150917,
-0.14540626108646393,
-0.3322356343269348,
-0.518161416053772,
-0.6943902969360352,
-0.20202134549617767,
-0.8701669573783875,
0.30694061517715454,
-0.04087808355689049,
-0.5278900861740112,
0.440392404794693,
-0.46541479229927063,
-0.43142858147621155,
0.24014481902122498,
0.21920830011367798,
0.7422864437103271,
-0.40897876024246216,
0.7328899502754211,
0.3718588352203369,
-0.4855814278125763,
-0.42494359612464905,
-0.3216747045516968,
0.5508070588111877,
-0.6298393607139587,
1.0228297710418701,
-0.4283040165901184,
-0.5808649659156799,
0.05301762744784355,
-0.10742038488388062,
-0.8785337209701538,
0.982572078704834,
0.40644580125808716,
-0.7290651202201843,
0.06712418794631958,
0.08409581333398819,
0.41163742542266846,
0.1104559674859047,
0.15362761914730072,
0.6218030452728271,
0.4521045386791229,
0.0022978652268648148,
-1.4959818124771118,
-0.04256954789161682,
0.15513542294502258,
0.13359540700912476,
0.13958005607128143,
-0.4996916651725769,
0.6600347757339478,
0.39644771814346313,
-0.5697578191757202,
0.061534129083156586,
0.7138863205909729,
-0.21488241851329803,
0.36256706714630127,
0.25478583574295044,
0.0333564393222332,
0.8655863404273987,
-0.12768158316612244,
1.1022651195526123,
0.6933237314224243,
-0.14275366067886353,
1.00322687625885,
-0.33081188797950745,
0.7299503087997437,
0.42557293176651,
-0.26517969369888306,
0.40619078278541565,
0.4830125868320465,
0.33500218391418457,
0.34451112151145935,
-0.23024332523345947,
-0.5748373866081238,
0.16649675369262695,
-0.4424348473548889,
-0.49892595410346985,
0.671099066734314,
0.4225020110607147,
-0.3542468845844269,
0.057357270270586014,
0.40200310945510864,
-0.05520593747496605,
0.14431355893611908,
-0.23567767441272736,
1.2910404205322266,
-0.06260763108730316,
-0.44441166520118713,
-0.14687632024288177,
-0.47081679105758667,
0.20803028345108032,
-0.9606664776802063,
-0.28452494740486145,
0.3272014856338501,
0.1024983748793602,
-0.06742002815008163,
-0.663841187953949,
0.741549015045166,
-0.2148737907409668,
-0.0971277505159378,
-0.46220090985298157,
0.887033224105835,
0.2971179783344269,
-0.0482911579310894,
0.1442529857158661,
0.7001315355300903,
0.1946234256029129,
0.012174338102340698,
-0.21985045075416565,
0.2407897263765335,
0.012427137233316898,
-0.4057501554489136,
0.08116442710161209,
0.25151121616363525,
0.02431453764438629,
0.43730342388153076,
0.5312634110450745,
0.4182609021663666,
0.2220839411020279,
0.5005024075508118,
0.3953242003917694,
-1.0982977151870728,
-0.5639770030975342,
-0.8322789669036865,
0.13949719071388245,
-0.23788556456565857,
-0.40901216864585876,
0.6160316467285156,
0.637306809425354,
0.7962526082992554,
0.05194389447569847,
0.9516122341156006,
-0.30954447388648987,
1.3167341947555542,
-0.6048346161842346,
0.49133822321891785,
-0.12731653451919556,
-0.14394766092300415,
0.02708546444773674,
-0.6088558435440063,
0.019727906212210655,
0.5310791730880737,
0.05385320261120796,
-0.34092390537261963,
0.760428249835968,
0.4006464183330536,
0.2654343545436859,
0.7967026829719543,
0.30079972743988037,
0.24852710962295532,
0.47910434007644653,
-0.24645419418811798,
0.9315794110298157,
-0.1919064074754715,
0.5175396203994751,
-0.3282111585140228,
-0.2816002368927002,
-0.0731082558631897,
-0.3405236303806305,
-0.4464623034000397,
-1.4348946809768677,
-0.21175771951675415,
-0.2896062731742859,
0.37849491834640503,
0.8356091976165771,
0.8494700789451599,
-0.765916645526886,
-0.6112203001976013,
0.4465225040912628,
-0.04951690137386322,
-0.6046648025512695,
-0.3708067238330841,
0.4797596335411072,
-0.3118736743927002,
-0.9828354120254517,
0.80111163854599,
0.5035392642021179,
0.02255287580192089,
-0.5514867901802063,
0.32280802726745605,
-0.2201690822839737,
-0.1332758069038391,
0.6328568458557129,
0.4898834228515625,
-0.9639702439308167,
-0.3599482476711273,
0.1597302109003067,
0.13104484975337982,
0.20444084703922272,
1.2092074155807495,
-0.6838832497596741,
0.6647295951843262,
0.33979931473731995,
0.6308727860450745,
1.0752589702606201,
-0.20269930362701416,
0.7560260891914368,
-1.0379613637924194,
0.09268723428249359,
0.7575263977050781,
0.4670476019382477,
0.3374541401863098,
-0.5058141946792603,
0.5678671598434448,
0.22375069558620453,
-0.6513176560401917,
-0.6913349628448486,
0.18129432201385498,
-1.3668309450149536,
-0.4384518563747406,
0.758664608001709,
0.04879661649465561,
-0.2852073609828949,
-0.7960405945777893,
-0.6574583649635315,
0.4779244661331177,
-0.4775114953517914,
0.6028894186019897,
1.0981453657150269,
-0.7255549430847168,
-0.5665668249130249,
-0.7363569140434265,
0.5218353867530823,
-0.20458915829658508,
-0.6571097373962402,
-0.4449416995048523,
0.4741995334625244,
0.1069280281662941,
0.6122612953186035,
0.941175639629364,
-0.005902642849832773,
0.5629962682723999,
0.14761611819267273,
-0.044917356222867966,
0.09911248087882996,
0.09614282846450806,
-0.08075609058141708,
0.5646292567253113,
-0.024567987769842148,
-0.15798963606357574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17287v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17287v2
|
When to Trust LLMs: Aligning Confidence with Response Quality
| 2024-04-26T09:42:46 | 2024-06-09T04:54:46 |
Shuchang Tao, Liuyi Yao, Hanxing Ding, Yuexiang Xie, Qi Cao, Fei Sun, Jinyang Gao, Huawei Shen, Bolin Ding
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the success of large language models (LLMs) in natural language
generation, much evidence shows that LLMs may produce incorrect or nonsensical
text. This limitation highlights the importance of discerning when to trust
LLMs, especially in safety-critical domains. Existing methods often express
reliability by confidence level, however, their effectiveness is limited by the
lack of objective guidance. To address this, we propose
CONfidence-Quality-ORDer-preserving alignment approach (CONQORD), which
leverages reinforcement learning guided by a tailored dual-component reward
function. This function integrates quality reward and order-preserving
alignment reward functions. Specifically, the order-preserving reward
incentivizes the model to verbalize greater confidence for responses of higher
quality to align the order of confidence and quality. Experiments demonstrate
that CONQORD significantly improves the alignment performance between
confidence and response accuracy, without causing over-cautious. Furthermore,
the aligned confidence provided by CONQORD informs when to trust LLMs, and acts
as a determinant for initiating the retrieval process of external knowledge.
Aligning confidence with response quality ensures more transparent and reliable
responses, providing better trustworthiness.
|
[
-0.028873678296804428,
-0.3239097595214844,
0.6148149371147156,
0.22362510859966278,
-0.21873053908348083,
0.2942906320095062,
0.015615607611835003,
-0.579571008682251,
-0.05320096015930176,
0.36759454011917114,
-0.5684651136398315,
-0.24286893010139465,
-0.827029824256897,
0.013612201437354088,
-0.19873905181884766,
1.0019851922988892,
-0.150413379073143,
0.19034714996814728,
-0.48870664834976196,
-0.03641471639275551,
-0.46001997590065,
-0.6538731455802917,
-1.1393629312515259,
-0.5698968768119812,
0.6038112640380859,
0.4699988067150116,
0.934066653251648,
0.5224179029464722,
0.6912213563919067,
0.28053194284439087,
0.13702841103076935,
0.45558032393455505,
-0.6234071254730225,
0.35908210277557373,
-0.40625056624412537,
-0.3807836174964905,
-0.3434694707393646,
0.13097350299358368,
0.28191015124320984,
0.19185955822467804,
-0.5451862215995789,
-0.02466486766934395,
0.4197208285331726,
0.620931088924408,
-0.6659571528434753,
0.13380326330661774,
-0.4910929799079895,
-0.11199701577425003,
0.31579044461250305,
-0.5294612050056458,
-0.49356552958488464,
-0.9105152487754822,
0.3321327865123749,
-0.6867772340774536,
-0.40739139914512634,
0.25012335181236267,
0.8659483194351196,
0.42468005418777466,
-0.4977339804172516,
-0.36538976430892944,
-0.570786714553833,
0.8102166056632996,
-0.5554925203323364,
0.23801164329051971,
0.5144861936569214,
0.27139049768447876,
-0.5856305956840515,
-0.6656649112701416,
-0.5989094376564026,
-0.1644866168498993,
-0.14452287554740906,
0.2418808788061142,
0.2983177900314331,
0.14883749186992645,
-0.11031708121299744,
0.2319442629814148,
-0.5928011536598206,
0.19641312956809998,
0.12213321030139923,
-0.5061707496643066,
0.7316414713859558,
0.04305651783943176,
0.13796086609363556,
0.011301250196993351,
-0.7954116463661194,
-0.6487776637077332,
-0.7730007767677307,
0.5451370477676392,
0.30774661898612976,
0.381971538066864,
0.030635342001914978,
0.595589816570282,
-0.05535145848989487,
0.23980896174907684,
0.302468478679657,
-0.5208304524421692,
0.08887644857168198,
-0.4041002690792084,
-0.4147225022315979,
0.3870556652545929,
0.9087103009223938,
0.442295104265213,
0.4037761390209198,
-0.12129991501569748,
-0.3001505732536316,
0.3710903227329254,
0.428607702255249,
-0.5855448246002197,
0.022906580939888954,
0.4706595838069916,
-0.23115870356559753,
-0.4651903510093689,
0.20691277086734772,
-0.310960590839386,
-0.4813373386859894,
-0.3631874918937683,
0.6465914845466614,
-0.5797140002250671,
-0.1714802384376526,
0.09024827182292938,
0.11020922660827637,
0.18871940672397614,
0.22131207585334778,
-0.948355495929718,
0.3503604829311371,
0.8747565150260925,
0.4084177613258362,
-0.40084803104400635,
-0.16351740062236786,
-1.1253892183303833,
0.2689880132675171,
-0.6292521357536316,
0.5405913591384888,
-0.3446905016899109,
-0.28967517614364624,
0.2677033543586731,
0.11032679677009583,
0.1322171539068222,
-0.3409610092639923,
0.9367146492004395,
-0.5466616153717041,
0.2500244081020355,
-0.32320505380630493,
-0.6651756763458252,
0.09220437705516815,
0.5128642916679382,
-0.404436320066452,
1.021312952041626,
0.11082879453897476,
-0.6742234230041504,
0.3933941721916199,
0.04671422392129898,
-0.3711380064487457,
-0.16924883425235748,
-0.3302759826183319,
-0.49150723218917847,
0.011442195624113083,
-0.0038766355719417334,
0.33714669942855835,
-0.028475003316998482,
0.2867666482925415,
-0.4218422472476959,
-0.1731715053319931,
0.6701474785804749,
-0.2929519712924957,
0.372967392206192,
0.014038904570043087,
-0.17214010655879974,
0.24651284515857697,
-0.4401000738143921,
0.36103710532188416,
-0.08685921132564545,
-0.2736566960811615,
-0.4825909435749054,
0.07605945318937302,
-0.4282165765762329,
0.458294153213501,
0.4212248623371124,
-0.4968535900115967,
-0.20950497686862946,
-0.5272362232208252,
0.03968828544020653,
0.9672481417655945,
0.24375516176223755,
0.6651374101638794,
-0.670169472694397,
0.42203617095947266,
0.16547511518001556,
0.42130500078201294,
0.31649482250213623,
-0.18066604435443878,
-0.5516076683998108,
0.15482565760612488,
0.15642473101615906,
0.5831810832023621,
-0.8905707597732544,
0.4630063474178314,
-0.20618273317813873,
-0.25469809770584106,
-0.506117582321167,
-0.05916530638933182,
0.729123055934906,
0.6603341698646545,
0.40804412961006165,
-0.39440926909446716,
-0.3662133514881134,
-0.8739058375358582,
-0.11062601953744888,
-0.5433225035667419,
-0.04908251389861107,
0.10372822731733322,
0.04919964820146561,
0.13287873566150665,
0.5821161866188049,
-0.26894962787628174,
0.036855898797512054,
0.11338023841381073,
0.2901814877986908,
-0.10063643753528595,
0.661903977394104,
0.19848400354385376,
-0.8070960640907288,
-0.3304641842842102,
-0.09059222787618637,
-0.5159363746643066,
0.2560458779335022,
-0.04970767721533775,
-0.607765257358551,
0.38919058442115784,
0.40522700548171997,
-0.5297443270683289,
0.10809645801782608,
0.851521372795105,
-0.3872669041156769,
0.25359487533569336,
-0.2202760875225067,
0.36635494232177734,
-1.253157615661621,
-0.1416066437959671,
-0.11273457854986191,
-0.4576215445995331,
-0.30447423458099365,
-0.15803498029708862,
0.20704200863838196,
0.4663712680339813,
-0.26861271262168884,
0.29932430386543274,
-0.20575633645057678,
0.014739406295120716,
-0.23787866532802582,
0.13008415699005127,
0.11356621235609055,
0.26577258110046387,
-0.027506817132234573,
0.6937364339828491,
0.2213069051504135,
-0.7444443702697754,
0.10144522041082382,
0.37129372358322144,
-0.3166007995605469,
1.0552393198013306,
-0.6477386951446533,
0.058377765119075775,
-0.050114329904317856,
-0.04620946943759918,
-1.0465234518051147,
-0.18979085981845856,
0.29954519867897034,
-0.623961329460144,
0.6780465841293335,
-0.03995618224143982,
-0.470925509929657,
-0.1384868323802948,
-0.37594467401504517,
-0.06074552610516548,
0.5131537318229675,
-0.5243293642997742,
0.3123801648616791,
0.4146794378757477,
-0.2862706482410431,
-1.0214365720748901,
-0.5580655336380005,
-0.3747340142726898,
-0.04608128219842911,
-0.5188702344894409,
0.3286932110786438,
-0.31165868043899536,
-0.1282612830400467,
-0.018207106739282608,
-0.3966769278049469,
-0.018478380516171455,
0.3738587200641632,
0.3034665584564209,
0.3628431558609009,
0.10137543082237244,
0.3241470754146576,
0.16010500490665436,
-0.13678498566150665,
0.17810197174549103,
-0.3192255198955536,
0.26870211958885193,
0.15779754519462585,
-0.2045186311006546,
-0.30816754698753357,
0.20506620407104492,
0.531928300857544,
-0.12174933403730392,
0.8746225237846375,
0.32577598094940186,
-0.2869184613227844,
-0.21608766913414001,
-0.3583250343799591,
-0.5450526475906372,
-0.5022358894348145,
0.06502699851989746,
0.006377129815518856,
-0.958037793636322,
-0.02303992211818695,
-0.008650685660541058,
0.11131850630044937,
0.1543056070804596,
0.29829666018486023,
-0.43348628282546997,
0.9543971419334412,
0.8510291576385498,
-0.10925403982400894,
0.34119874238967896,
0.3404819667339325,
0.25011956691741943,
-0.6213416457176208,
-0.6098804473876953,
-0.46144017577171326,
-0.29841792583465576,
-0.687873363494873,
-0.24223114550113678,
0.29486599564552307,
0.1267588585615158,
-0.5935751795768738,
0.09931106865406036,
-0.48106467723846436,
0.2471129149198532,
0.5849387049674988,
0.20198316872119904,
0.36021512746810913,
-0.042557474225759506,
-0.2887256443500519,
-0.09168655425310135,
-0.4753066599369049,
-0.5977360606193542,
0.9312306642532349,
0.28415313363075256,
1.0393400192260742,
0.2103527933359146,
0.8123025298118591,
0.15991339087486267,
0.26208192110061646,
-0.6913255453109741,
0.31411075592041016,
0.06577014923095703,
-0.2857177257537842,
-0.5449061989784241,
-0.4257313311100006,
-0.9992639422416687,
-0.029424265027046204,
-0.4729726314544678,
-0.5164665579795837,
0.12653183937072754,
0.2965909242630005,
-0.6639416813850403,
-0.253773033618927,
-0.4915444254875183,
0.4594390094280243,
-0.5007806420326233,
-0.4630986452102661,
-0.10397162288427353,
-0.8366284966468811,
0.4824254810810089,
0.07663928717374802,
0.01499374769628048,
-0.3742293119430542,
-0.13578976690769196,
0.49897801876068115,
-0.30547407269477844,
0.5147923231124878,
0.18820756673812866,
-0.17594125866889954,
0.07673665881156921,
0.3121965825557709,
0.8883340358734131,
0.2411586493253708,
-0.02524224855005741,
-0.26935875415802,
0.06528394669294357,
-0.2283076047897339,
-0.7684666514396667,
0.7982984185218811,
-0.7558667659759521,
-0.47464293241500854,
-0.5778391361236572,
-0.4460310637950897,
-0.5732612013816833,
0.0638030618429184,
0.24581044912338257,
0.17765645682811737,
-0.13881543278694153,
0.08935435116291046,
1.1743273735046387,
-0.08994744718074799,
0.4155927896499634,
0.3796062469482422,
-0.005327435210347176,
-0.6304989457130432,
0.5765070915222168,
-0.09581582993268967,
0.5732926726341248,
0.5721640586853027,
0.1471974402666092,
-0.5436365604400635,
-0.36880895495414734,
-0.13964831829071045,
0.028735879808664322,
-0.4558185935020447,
-0.7685811519622803,
-0.20938365161418915,
-0.36397626996040344,
-0.3682126998901367,
-0.16247184574604034,
-0.5346455574035645,
-0.3916522264480591,
-0.01109324861317873,
-0.42124301195144653,
0.32809075713157654,
0.5021393895149231,
0.02979540079832077,
0.1365281492471695,
-0.7223328948020935,
0.03711843118071556,
0.3467922806739807,
0.3972204923629761,
-0.262193888425827,
-0.43771451711654663,
-0.15799152851104736,
0.05199596658349037,
-0.3979840874671936,
-0.6120275855064392,
0.3780774474143982,
-0.23976357281208038,
0.7565514445304871,
0.1313425898551941,
0.49224618077278137,
0.40701186656951904,
-0.3094884753227234,
0.5910815596580505,
0.48583120107650757,
-0.7209836840629578,
0.3886426091194153,
-0.04514710232615471,
0.0028703799471259117,
0.6566342115402222,
0.6372777223587036,
-0.4169434905052185,
-0.6314553022384644,
-0.7639148235321045,
-0.8878934979438782,
0.36210504174232483,
0.2212466597557068,
-0.051509980112314224,
-0.08384577184915543,
0.2750796675682068,
0.03520524501800537,
0.4244212508201599,
-0.5832253694534302,
-0.09226762503385544,
-0.18058380484580994,
-0.5564206838607788,
-0.12115222960710526,
-0.4760134518146515,
-0.638142466545105,
0.3373119831085205,
0.7868934869766235,
-0.37682846188545227,
0.1791016012430191,
0.3996359705924988,
-0.04627414047718048,
-0.3649473786354065,
0.4640674293041229,
0.6933791041374207,
0.5595620274543762,
-0.07480890303850174,
0.3189626634120941,
-0.07415771484375,
-0.17578232288360596,
0.349612832069397,
-0.07130055129528046,
0.10882850736379623,
-0.3033406138420105,
0.13426591455936432,
0.4377088248729706,
0.4468046724796295,
-0.47249552607536316,
0.6368817090988159,
-0.20226037502288818,
-0.1651051789522171,
-0.29355448484420776,
0.16201722621917725,
0.1856480836868286,
0.4137563705444336,
0.25692710280418396,
-0.12200115621089935,
-0.052264504134655,
-0.42749419808387756,
0.3919597864151001,
0.5843150615692139,
-0.3768826127052307,
-0.009148804470896721,
0.3929519057273865,
0.06705666333436966,
-0.16046282649040222,
0.6064679622650146,
-0.12299451231956482,
-0.35932257771492004,
0.43564897775650024,
0.4768669903278351,
0.7848778367042542,
-0.355472594499588,
0.39344608783721924,
0.5548853874206543,
0.38217693567276,
-0.5920589566230774,
0.5110665559768677,
0.4043540954589844,
-0.9094690680503845,
-0.43995970487594604,
-0.564649224281311,
-0.6877354979515076,
-0.03734408691525459,
-0.7454986572265625,
-0.14416787028312683,
-0.7015362977981567,
-0.37525591254234314,
-0.5740230083465576,
0.06860736012458801,
-0.36458340287208557,
0.37604862451553345,
0.28322190046310425,
0.7227620482444763,
-0.6794379949569702,
0.8408840894699097,
0.42661750316619873,
-0.4323844909667969,
-1.299694299697876,
0.1030612662434578,
0.022419199347496033,
-0.9026733040809631,
0.3985441327095032,
-0.0735669657588005,
-0.36193183064460754,
-0.17823395133018494,
-0.7936537265777588,
-1.182944416999817,
1.3773903846740723,
0.4035904109477997,
-0.5911847949028015,
0.17750197649002075,
-0.14302761852741241,
0.47146421670913696,
-0.30823639035224915,
0.011127643287181854,
0.3925231993198395,
0.29252785444259644,
0.34238484501838684,
-0.9031873941421509,
0.31734412908554077,
0.1869625449180603,
0.1140131726861,
0.2929059565067291,
-0.6921184659004211,
0.5528376698493958,
-0.07016114890575409,
-0.2795485258102417,
0.1616300791501999,
0.7619261145591736,
0.6830354332923889,
0.09249704331159592,
0.3484869599342346,
0.5128117799758911,
1.263960361480713,
-0.1487657129764557,
1.045552372932434,
-0.22602175176143646,
0.10416654497385025,
1.490099310874939,
-0.16746652126312256,
1.1231728792190552,
0.7620503306388855,
0.07659690082073212,
0.8739959597587585,
0.8093581795692444,
0.36763685941696167,
0.8071404695510864,
0.12588249146938324,
-0.06479785591363907,
-0.31145212054252625,
-0.35555025935173035,
-0.2566746175289154,
0.02790641412138939,
0.1902233064174652,
-0.3474234938621521,
0.17613615095615387,
-0.4484025537967682,
0.11021041870117188,
0.31422722339630127,
-0.3238208293914795,
0.7939338684082031,
0.3634556829929352,
-1.103561282157898,
0.42001664638519287,
-0.29412928223609924,
0.5819841623306274,
-0.7660076022148132,
0.0068165939301252365,
-0.35517945885658264,
0.19112567603588104,
-0.25639596581459045,
-0.965892493724823,
0.07377725839614868,
-0.46047443151474,
-0.2827552556991577,
-0.28043895959854126,
0.5496753454208374,
-0.6935532689094543,
-0.14132057130336761,
0.4009089171886444,
0.2570801079273224,
-0.37591707706451416,
0.2571342885494232,
-0.585379958152771,
-0.007796283811330795,
-0.39023810625076294,
-0.18228672444820404,
0.6370964050292969,
0.5363385677337646,
0.08493632078170776,
0.751217782497406,
0.6558302044868469,
-0.08315005153417587,
-0.22032088041305542,
-0.24092648923397064,
0.3711271286010742,
-0.28845664858818054,
-0.42828717827796936,
-0.7913181781768799,
0.7212098836898804,
-0.34762030839920044,
-0.06762266904115677,
0.6514188051223755,
0.20322935283184052,
0.9038205146789551,
0.1581340730190277,
0.6839412450790405,
0.39897245168685913,
0.36438485980033875,
-0.767458438873291,
0.4866482615470886,
-0.4199630320072174,
0.0065041095949709415,
-0.09943237900733948,
-0.5465907454490662,
-0.2247338891029358,
0.5882683992385864,
-0.08853898197412491,
-0.17516857385635376,
1.0690690279006958,
0.7862319350242615,
0.36652642488479614,
-0.23902690410614014,
0.4140537977218628,
0.025692423805594444,
0.24819301068782806,
0.7785034775733948,
0.8900604248046875,
-0.32368943095207214,
0.7171362638473511,
-0.19379682838916779,
-0.1106390655040741,
-0.023057304322719574,
-1.1120539903640747,
-0.5105987787246704,
-0.2764110863208771,
-0.26146066188812256,
-0.8523226380348206,
0.13036946952342987,
1.201578974723816,
0.6069812178611755,
-0.8928181529045105,
-0.24344447255134583,
-0.05684373527765274,
0.265287846326828,
-0.35986435413360596,
-0.1807394027709961,
0.165152445435524,
-0.6681884527206421,
-0.550826907157898,
0.32211074233055115,
0.4228809177875519,
0.31954434514045715,
-0.01298493705689907,
-0.5972028970718384,
0.035221200436353683,
0.39979103207588196,
0.3516780734062195,
0.3410179316997528,
-0.49966198205947876,
-0.5608171224594116,
0.14709092676639557,
-0.7712118625640869,
0.08332783728837967,
0.5716366767883301,
-0.4958440363407135,
0.21619947254657745,
0.3955216109752655,
0.8644585609436035,
0.07623458653688431,
0.22893323004245758,
1.0853177309036255,
-0.5419392585754395,
-0.2488684356212616,
0.3404315412044525,
0.32511061429977417,
0.500049889087677,
-0.7638965845108032,
0.5767350196838379,
-0.17130982875823975,
-0.8521277904510498,
-0.6308420896530151,
0.3956785202026367,
-1.0510255098342896,
0.007018194999545813,
1.1584259271621704,
-0.2558343708515167,
-0.12157570570707321,
0.025348464027047157,
-0.02433549053966999,
0.3117838501930237,
-0.5264778137207031,
0.8927508592605591,
0.736397385597229,
-0.2047063410282135,
-0.16041360795497894,
-0.12151353806257248,
1.040900707244873,
0.5913555026054382,
-0.8166918158531189,
-0.10965082794427872,
0.3389846086502075,
0.2859129309654236,
0.12516547739505768,
0.5927376747131348,
-0.1545611172914505,
0.3410665690898895,
-0.3708174526691437,
-0.16268417239189148,
0.2600991427898407,
-0.39057937264442444,
-0.1743980199098587,
0.2096598595380783,
0.5510907769203186,
-0.35453829169273376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17283v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17283v1
|
Reinforcement Retrieval Leveraging Fine-grained Feedback for Fact Checking News Claims with Black-Box LLM
| 2024-04-26T09:38:27 | 2024-04-26T09:38:27 |
Xuan Zhang, Wei Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented language models have exhibited promising performance
across various areas of natural language processing (NLP), including
fact-critical tasks. However, due to the black-box nature of advanced large
language models (LLMs) and the non-retrieval-oriented supervision signal of
specific tasks, the training of retrieval model faces significant challenges
under the setting of black-box LLM. We propose an approach leveraging
Fine-grained Feedback with Reinforcement Retrieval (FFRR) to enhance
fact-checking on news claims by using black-box LLM. FFRR adopts a two-level
strategy to gather fine-grained feedback from the LLM, which serves as a reward
for optimizing the retrieval policy, by rating the retrieved documents based on
the non-retrieval ground truth of the task. We evaluate our model on two public
datasets for real-world news claim verification, and the results demonstrate
that FFRR achieves significant improvements over strong LLM-enabled and non-LLM
baselines.
|
[
-0.24414058029651642,
-0.9951199889183044,
0.7017806768417358,
0.2021745890378952,
-0.287960410118103,
0.21408583223819733,
-0.3389853537082672,
-0.5135376453399658,
0.12590853869915009,
0.5821571946144104,
-0.23044610023498535,
-0.37791362404823303,
-0.6424545049667358,
0.011502036824822426,
-0.4510929584503174,
1.4583810567855835,
-0.06158619001507759,
-0.06628604233264923,
-0.3613591194152832,
-0.08075518161058426,
-0.27494508028030396,
-0.4588907063007355,
-0.5935956239700317,
-0.5268046855926514,
0.5710986256599426,
0.35194727778434753,
0.5476709604263306,
0.3655121624469757,
0.5076117515563965,
0.21004775166511536,
-0.3144884407520294,
0.5262452960014343,
-0.5404403805732727,
-0.18653136491775513,
-0.5451510548591614,
-0.5509673357009888,
-0.10191686451435089,
0.10005466639995575,
0.5926524996757507,
0.11442699283361435,
-0.29942187666893005,
0.16751790046691895,
0.13106274604797363,
0.5465259552001953,
-0.8265266418457031,
0.19052273035049438,
-0.536170482635498,
0.18603265285491943,
-0.038437508046627045,
-0.619090735912323,
-0.5871909856796265,
-0.678634524345398,
0.014977194368839264,
-0.34633463621139526,
0.38831377029418945,
0.26050999760627747,
0.9733080863952637,
0.15157726407051086,
-0.4694276750087738,
-0.27438846230506897,
-0.9795051217079163,
0.7664589285850525,
-0.7036064863204956,
0.5152313113212585,
0.5113586187362671,
0.2183474898338318,
-0.2994682192802429,
-0.4726974666118622,
-0.573896050453186,
-0.6345880031585693,
-0.3219771981239319,
0.0019686887972056866,
-0.13536874949932098,
-0.029532261192798615,
0.1782294511795044,
0.4849950671195984,
-0.247811421751976,
-0.05345074459910393,
-0.27249786257743835,
-0.4192996323108673,
0.5578482747077942,
-0.13338489830493927,
-0.1952439844608307,
-0.4130767285823822,
-0.6119076013565063,
-0.09367666393518448,
-0.4796677529811859,
0.17346999049186707,
0.09073611348867416,
0.5445162653923035,
0.10715442895889282,
0.7094931602478027,
-0.6564687490463257,
0.5551947951316833,
0.34338289499282837,
-0.4111020863056183,
0.27646404504776,
-0.5601890087127686,
-0.029169971123337746,
0.2892058193683624,
0.6008047461509705,
0.4273085296154022,
-0.36508044600486755,
-0.46367987990379333,
-0.6708926558494568,
0.002165433019399643,
0.47230324149131775,
-0.8140353560447693,
0.3463903069496155,
-0.017536291852593422,
-0.34234604239463806,
-0.35191574692726135,
0.1340761035680771,
-0.7930951118469238,
-0.5530002117156982,
-0.19513429701328278,
0.6314183473587036,
-0.16544127464294434,
-0.17423658072948456,
0.2867673635482788,
-0.15222878754138947,
0.15467678010463715,
0.5688750743865967,
-0.6860310435295105,
0.2775917947292328,
0.7741228938102722,
0.7490332722663879,
-0.07308019697666168,
0.05157315731048584,
-1.3462406396865845,
0.014014837332069874,
-0.31103864312171936,
1.0751501321792603,
-0.6326232552528381,
-0.00008989115303847939,
0.14724431931972504,
0.07182158529758453,
0.303019255399704,
-0.6288585662841797,
0.9291044473648071,
-0.7530403137207031,
0.04264592379331589,
-0.35440659523010254,
-0.43919461965560913,
-0.093450628221035,
0.909800112247467,
-0.48562338948249817,
1.2307040691375732,
-0.05819038301706314,
-0.6741361021995544,
0.2458270639181137,
-0.18684835731983185,
-0.40919145941734314,
-0.06903880089521408,
-0.19544759392738342,
-0.5418760776519775,
0.3030839264392853,
0.2319689393043518,
0.25669780373573303,
-0.08765680342912674,
0.37426748871803284,
-0.46077466011047363,
-0.31861215829849243,
0.11037099361419678,
-0.5541902184486389,
-0.06727321445941925,
0.09693330526351929,
-0.28722649812698364,
0.005139142740517855,
-0.8563812971115112,
-0.18244636058807373,
-0.060214608907699585,
-0.8731882572174072,
-0.4447309076786041,
0.11300699412822723,
-0.1334046721458435,
0.27602440118789673,
0.2692912817001343,
-0.9964563846588135,
0.29553258419036865,
-0.2930099666118622,
0.09355838596820831,
0.34647059440612793,
0.25999969244003296,
0.2869086265563965,
-0.6266430616378784,
0.18379604816436768,
0.0371454581618309,
0.023621536791324615,
0.2660154402256012,
0.022453773766756058,
-0.7270305752754211,
0.12974996864795685,
0.5707222819328308,
0.46831050515174866,
-0.9952941536903381,
0.1705077439546585,
-0.011843006126582623,
-0.12934648990631104,
-0.5396096706390381,
0.11974278092384338,
0.5264726877212524,
0.5087949633598328,
0.6586171388626099,
-0.21603015065193176,
-0.3928132653236389,
-0.7745513916015625,
-0.21896404027938843,
-0.15422062575817108,
0.05984175577759743,
0.20232461392879486,
0.4827443063259125,
-0.0774710401892662,
1.0189884901046753,
-0.4671086370944977,
-0.4713926613330841,
-0.12934936583042145,
0.5540614128112793,
0.058839309960603714,
0.2636396288871765,
0.1968020498752594,
-0.7871957421302795,
0.09468194842338562,
-0.03604833036661148,
-0.35267379879951477,
-0.11640556901693344,
-0.1478680968284607,
0.07461553066968918,
0.2178296595811844,
0.31015774607658386,
-0.7341359853744507,
0.44928380846977234,
0.36195605993270874,
-0.4212653338909149,
0.7140771746635437,
-0.13138391077518463,
0.36543768644332886,
-0.5719648599624634,
-0.01721285842359066,
0.30355116724967957,
-0.7115598320960999,
-0.34560081362724304,
0.12611661851406097,
0.0227079838514328,
0.2891957759857178,
-0.4670376777648926,
0.5975547432899475,
-0.17775973677635193,
-0.2248084843158722,
-0.6869586706161499,
0.1324688047170639,
0.1943260282278061,
0.6355215311050415,
0.13279539346694946,
0.7355197072029114,
-0.07978122681379318,
-0.7446730732917786,
0.2966652512550354,
0.08792033046483994,
-0.4776124656200409,
0.5615655779838562,
-0.4200422167778015,
-0.10203241556882858,
-0.23834113776683807,
0.45886555314064026,
-0.641588032245636,
0.05238446965813637,
0.09045501053333282,
-0.2956947982311249,
0.24768133461475372,
-0.08830965310335159,
-0.724966287612915,
-0.30044054985046387,
-0.49087610840797424,
-0.07481139898300171,
0.10591842979192734,
-0.6892994046211243,
0.3905085027217865,
0.300085186958313,
-0.18476088345050812,
-0.725398063659668,
-0.6467411518096924,
-0.02885534055531025,
0.21434228122234344,
-0.03210928663611412,
0.41614341735839844,
0.04463490471243858,
-0.15285250544548035,
0.188344806432724,
-0.6846340894699097,
0.005374649073928595,
0.09123820066452026,
-0.10870959609746933,
0.09078556299209595,
-0.14387787878513336,
0.12343267351388931,
-0.10478931665420532,
0.0066802953369915485,
0.06160065904259682,
-0.051973313093185425,
0.2707225978374481,
-0.23829138278961182,
-0.30269762873649597,
-0.10235659033060074,
0.032078251242637634,
0.17977207899093628,
-0.3938010334968567,
0.5571945309638977,
0.7986347079277039,
-0.2977367043495178,
-0.2823391258716583,
-0.8934164643287659,
-0.3484356701374054,
-0.38452979922294617,
0.2379682958126068,
0.10258154571056366,
-1.1887154579162598,
0.12404321879148483,
-0.1472248136997223,
0.06378823518753052,
0.1763615906238556,
0.5784422755241394,
0.058811306953430176,
0.9007535576820374,
0.5676971077919006,
-0.1275443285703659,
0.5975740551948547,
-0.22762584686279297,
0.04201028496026993,
-0.7188079953193665,
-0.3808041214942932,
-0.5351411700248718,
-0.13746750354766846,
-0.23543904721736908,
-0.5015866160392761,
0.2017349898815155,
0.3022332787513733,
0.061894387006759644,
-0.031246216967701912,
-0.2926318943500519,
0.48217153549194336,
0.6974664330482483,
0.47159403562545776,
0.7801801562309265,
-0.05048985779285431,
-0.12182322889566422,
0.35383641719818115,
-0.4266416132450104,
-0.42516547441482544,
0.6534948348999023,
0.4225713908672333,
0.8382424116134644,
0.05423519387841225,
0.6926364898681641,
0.6454509496688843,
0.280227929353714,
-0.7994280457496643,
0.5628576278686523,
-0.066770538687706,
-0.48822805285453796,
-0.14796869456768036,
-0.7028042674064636,
-0.6812823414802551,
0.4242734909057617,
-0.5043351650238037,
-0.4814322292804718,
0.26292821764945984,
0.09611760824918747,
-0.634429931640625,
0.2339940071105957,
-0.42421403527259827,
0.3937307596206665,
-0.23028133809566498,
-0.52767413854599,
-0.6031081676483154,
-0.3166073262691498,
0.4555160701274872,
0.11125729233026505,
0.1675117313861847,
-0.11632756888866425,
0.20727068185806274,
0.5569478273391724,
-0.3361866772174835,
0.7271063327789307,
-0.3190441429615021,
-0.20475786924362183,
0.2061571478843689,
0.0005853465991094708,
0.9266839623451233,
0.4248013496398926,
-0.0809115618467331,
-0.281564861536026,
-0.05552416667342186,
-0.18685704469680786,
-0.7161845564842224,
0.5705907344818115,
-0.61334228515625,
-0.8136932253837585,
-0.6462754011154175,
-0.5473092794418335,
-0.39897069334983826,
0.27410566806793213,
-0.272050142288208,
0.6214332580566406,
-0.16406701505184174,
0.5260673761367798,
0.7101863622665405,
-0.01289413869380951,
0.2547174394130707,
1.1770894527435303,
-0.40423497557640076,
-0.24917186796665192,
1.019250512123108,
0.09836577624082565,
-0.007035674527287483,
0.7751709818840027,
0.23419371247291565,
-0.5553531646728516,
-0.8380559086799622,
-0.2800113260746002,
0.06927645206451416,
-0.27279743552207947,
-0.605785071849823,
-0.602731466293335,
-0.31537356972694397,
-0.12513107061386108,
0.31252193450927734,
-0.4001714587211609,
-0.42770612239837646,
-0.06250627338886261,
-0.36119842529296875,
0.31269723176956177,
0.6863539218902588,
-0.05735151469707489,
0.053720422089099884,
-0.8716439008712769,
0.7660902738571167,
0.45463767647743225,
0.7512703537940979,
-0.13692358136177063,
-0.443321168422699,
-0.5058943629264832,
0.20184564590454102,
-0.67131507396698,
-0.5431196093559265,
0.12367990612983704,
-0.14004749059677124,
0.4743647873401642,
0.02426595240831375,
0.489059716463089,
0.49522870779037476,
-0.46006476879119873,
0.5851146578788757,
-0.14856211841106415,
-0.47861039638519287,
0.437358558177948,
-0.0914837196469307,
0.024324875324964523,
0.6771827936172485,
0.09602149575948715,
-0.3771960437297821,
-0.9057036638259888,
-0.38957634568214417,
-0.46494245529174805,
0.889042854309082,
0.10498552769422531,
-0.07746141403913498,
-0.14256592094898224,
0.33086544275283813,
-0.11098797619342804,
0.4351612329483032,
-0.8294529318809509,
0.07132251560688019,
-0.23771604895591736,
0.05140521004796028,
0.07752498239278793,
-0.5584940314292908,
-0.3009220361709595,
-0.025390610098838806,
0.8761191964149475,
-0.25883543491363525,
0.12692533433437347,
0.5236775875091553,
-0.26233699917793274,
-0.31849563121795654,
0.886275053024292,
0.4986453950405121,
0.2671484649181366,
-0.5880007147789001,
0.2429327368736267,
0.11019804328680038,
-0.21371333301067352,
0.3572058379650116,
0.4445885121822357,
-0.3787540793418884,
0.07483837008476257,
0.18701845407485962,
0.9295570254325867,
0.6648926138877869,
-0.4380497932434082,
0.5985854268074036,
-0.05316993594169617,
-0.23475052416324615,
0.1287112683057785,
0.08391935378313065,
-0.2132478803396225,
0.6821450591087341,
0.6146413683891296,
0.05714431032538414,
0.24370652437210083,
-0.6567028760910034,
0.561663806438446,
0.5287653207778931,
-0.17469225823879242,
-0.09343145787715912,
0.399361789226532,
0.16491952538490295,
-0.04705880954861641,
0.3912504315376282,
-0.5250954031944275,
-0.430695116519928,
0.28780481219291687,
0.6909934282302856,
0.42311233282089233,
0.1460386961698532,
0.5943148732185364,
0.31850990653038025,
0.2784495949745178,
-0.6379426717758179,
0.11480633169412613,
-0.06347208470106125,
-0.6204895973205566,
-0.7591032981872559,
-0.9040363430976868,
-0.6516791582107544,
0.3578857183456421,
-0.726054310798645,
0.15387365221977234,
-0.5618607997894287,
-0.23330463469028473,
-0.10656676441431046,
0.6038542985916138,
-0.2628612220287323,
0.2088635265827179,
0.3452121615409851,
1.0326279401779175,
-0.5390325784683228,
0.7615165114402771,
0.5474568009376526,
-0.45299816131591797,
-0.6626564264297485,
0.18806077539920807,
0.06259068846702576,
-0.5831756591796875,
0.4973807632923126,
0.16265122592449188,
-0.18338875472545624,
-0.1609494388103485,
-0.4774160385131836,
-0.7894940972328186,
0.9507989287376404,
0.4593954086303711,
-0.7259174585342407,
-0.14625318348407745,
-0.07828176021575928,
0.6352839469909668,
-0.047949351370334625,
0.2707422375679016,
0.4264957308769226,
0.5171853303909302,
0.251936137676239,
-0.787582516670227,
0.13587863743305206,
-0.006542416289448738,
-0.05770484730601311,
0.3303891718387604,
-0.8923996090888977,
0.5239301919937134,
-0.11186796426773071,
-0.24689899384975433,
-0.16223262250423431,
1.0508571863174438,
0.4902825355529785,
0.46339038014411926,
0.6251358389854431,
0.7278614044189453,
0.6909304261207581,
0.05640373006463051,
1.2126988172531128,
-0.21364733576774597,
0.6456565260887146,
1.121762752532959,
-0.1792689710855484,
1.0678718090057373,
0.2972295582294464,
-0.027324525639414787,
0.6284807324409485,
0.4024016261100769,
-0.19251683354377747,
0.6571846008300781,
-0.017120445147156715,
-0.1990170180797577,
-0.2219657003879547,
-0.6638349890708923,
-0.09793461114168167,
0.1921354979276657,
0.2500183880329132,
0.05218259245157242,
-0.7184845805168152,
0.08713958412408829,
0.051533836871385574,
0.11983537673950195,
-0.6411504149436951,
0.8112768530845642,
0.024680297821760178,
-0.8959518074989319,
0.5546448230743408,
0.2182079404592514,
0.8340865969657898,
-0.588150143623352,
-0.26823654770851135,
-0.23289598524570465,
0.21759091317653656,
-0.38779449462890625,
-0.9507458209991455,
0.3532481789588928,
0.19747765362262726,
-0.517929196357727,
-0.1568474918603897,
0.8651669025421143,
-0.822525680065155,
-0.2703078091144562,
0.30129969120025635,
0.2354903668165207,
-0.32171836495399475,
-0.14643912017345428,
-0.7082206010818481,
0.08311349153518677,
-0.16608166694641113,
-0.41449424624443054,
0.5331603288650513,
0.2783051133155823,
-0.09043768793344498,
0.5736901760101318,
0.7568903565406799,
0.27904316782951355,
-0.18571621179580688,
0.14578373730182648,
0.9573096632957458,
-0.6475438475608826,
-0.41542911529541016,
-0.706416130065918,
0.03816256299614906,
-0.007031835149973631,
0.2373119294643402,
0.7696645259857178,
0.6961019039154053,
0.9223330616950989,
0.2503516972064972,
0.6443018317222595,
0.05822383239865303,
0.6843583583831787,
-0.8033020496368408,
0.2953953444957733,
-0.5954129099845886,
0.24867457151412964,
-0.025625767186284065,
-0.6850384473800659,
-0.13683471083641052,
0.47475817799568176,
-0.43002310395240784,
-0.2632696032524109,
0.6893061995506287,
0.9882712960243225,
-0.151404470205307,
-0.001519885379821062,
0.052553702145814896,
0.4479762315750122,
0.22427040338516235,
0.3918549120426178,
1.0140275955200195,
-0.1115841269493103,
0.8393851518630981,
-0.2200271338224411,
0.001860960153862834,
-0.543388843536377,
-0.8862479329109192,
-0.6787566542625427,
-0.14407333731651306,
-0.31925642490386963,
-0.7239623665809631,
0.15611475706100464,
1.0347449779510498,
0.6501644253730774,
-0.8838934302330017,
0.087681345641613,
0.08444686979055405,
0.4784180223941803,
-0.2637231945991516,
-0.29797518253326416,
0.11441896855831146,
-0.7290054559707642,
-0.4835684597492218,
0.49673306941986084,
0.2339628040790558,
-0.15278571844100952,
-0.15070432424545288,
-0.04344891384243965,
-0.47144123911857605,
0.10763692110776901,
0.6741681098937988,
0.41244781017303467,
-0.620854377746582,
-0.627768337726593,
-0.3799768388271332,
-0.3841765820980072,
0.16609954833984375,
0.8655311465263367,
-1.05693519115448,
0.1301276683807373,
0.5011616945266724,
0.9764503836631775,
0.7303797006607056,
0.38426122069358826,
0.3968176245689392,
-1.1000151634216309,
-0.03844763711094856,
0.14136292040348053,
0.2684171497821808,
0.33324307203292847,
-0.4354371726512909,
0.44295287132263184,
0.270760178565979,
-0.5144922137260437,
-0.9995093941688538,
0.0018818372627720237,
-0.8802033066749573,
-0.23373427987098694,
1.2772350311279297,
0.07692543417215347,
-0.3439965844154358,
-0.0368034690618515,
-0.21276229619979858,
0.18108896911144257,
-0.8113357424736023,
0.9554402828216553,
0.7761633992195129,
0.12918542325496674,
-0.36646953225135803,
-0.6624507308006287,
0.5957469344139099,
0.30855947732925415,
-0.6853935718536377,
0.14888562262058258,
0.5531437397003174,
0.20009784400463104,
0.33129245042800903,
0.6618889570236206,
-0.021979037672281265,
0.3575207591056824,
-0.3691619336605072,
-0.0958479642868042,
-0.3440801799297333,
-0.44701921939849854,
-0.28649210929870605,
0.3338117003440857,
0.06417583674192429,
-0.1143595352768898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17218v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17218v2
|
Prompting Techniques for Reducing Social Bias in LLMs through System 1 and System 2 Cognitive Processes
| 2024-04-26T07:46:29 | 2024-06-28T23:54:49 |
Mahammed Kamruzzaman, Gene Louis Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dual process theory posits that human cognition arises via two systems.
System 1, which is a quick, emotional, and intuitive process, which is subject
to cognitive biases, and System 2, a slow, onerous, and deliberate process. NLP
researchers often compare zero-shot prompting in LLMs to System 1 reasoning and
chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting to System 2. In line with this interpretation,
prior research has found that using CoT prompting in LLMs leads to reduced
gender bias. We investigate the relationship between bias, CoT prompting, and
dual process theory in LLMs directly. We compare zero-shot, CoT, and a variety
of dual process theory-based prompting strategies on two bias datasets spanning
nine different social bias categories. We also use human and machine personas
to determine whether the effects of dual process theory in LLMs are based on
modeling human cognition or inherent to the system. We find that a human
persona, System 2, and CoT prompting all tend to reduce social biases in LLMs,
though the best combination of features depends on the exact model and bias
category -- resulting in up to a 13 percent drop in stereotypical judgments by
an LLM.
|
[
-0.5058822631835938,
-0.8500006198883057,
0.7612970471382141,
0.28794050216674805,
-0.19826753437519073,
0.3117445409297943,
-0.27581343054771423,
-0.3495104908943176,
0.19424481689929962,
0.4928673505783081,
-0.968651533126831,
-0.278095543384552,
-0.5177336931228638,
0.1178622916340828,
-0.05327949300408363,
0.8895745873451233,
-0.0855717808008194,
0.6917209029197693,
-0.12074311822652817,
0.17733480036258698,
-0.8480191826820374,
-0.5963073968887329,
-1.0285927057266235,
-0.8076287508010864,
0.7683684825897217,
0.5779545307159424,
0.3894927501678467,
-0.11154384911060333,
0.14099685847759247,
0.031948987394571304,
-0.2672385573387146,
0.21486684679985046,
-0.6232606768608093,
0.391947478055954,
-0.26041221618652344,
-0.8230546712875366,
-0.20402385294437408,
0.2917744815349579,
0.3791274130344391,
0.4919830560684204,
0.20143939554691315,
0.5291486382484436,
0.4314887225627899,
0.9019945859909058,
-0.7068990468978882,
-0.09449789673089981,
-0.5058901906013489,
0.26311227679252625,
-0.02893015928566456,
-0.4654015600681305,
-0.4394572377204895,
-0.2727036476135254,
0.11182570457458496,
-0.18253347277641296,
0.5001779794692993,
-0.04151005297899246,
0.30353525280952454,
0.151506245136261,
-0.6316041350364685,
-0.11642121523618698,
-0.8414619565010071,
0.5446999669075012,
-0.10829672962427139,
-0.0043746898882091045,
0.5999643802642822,
0.021142205223441124,
-0.030285831540822983,
0.05849791690707207,
-0.41317710280418396,
-0.12985984981060028,
0.07452178001403809,
0.0036165809724479914,
0.15809877216815948,
0.20800352096557617,
0.6119468808174133,
-0.3289354145526886,
-0.2846587598323822,
0.04769037291407585,
-0.5406085848808289,
-0.1371660828590393,
0.5911044478416443,
0.11810718476772308,
0.1051788330078125,
-0.12047560513019562,
-0.5485403537750244,
0.0512024350464344,
-1.0959441661834717,
0.0075843059457838535,
0.5508062839508057,
0.10598406195640564,
-0.035592351108789444,
0.4435475766658783,
-0.050814222544431686,
0.10903392732143402,
0.3406880795955658,
0.08494388312101364,
-0.2078705132007599,
-0.1971542090177536,
0.004087940789759159,
0.2046842873096466,
0.4663289487361908,
0.8776754140853882,
0.5973348021507263,
0.08218388259410858,
-0.08165536820888519,
0.8352698087692261,
0.21973025798797607,
-0.3419173061847687,
0.19586710631847382,
0.05013842135667801,
-0.5501312017440796,
-0.5170737504959106,
-0.11729563027620316,
-0.7792051434516907,
-0.6851868033409119,
-0.5523926615715027,
0.19326598942279816,
-0.1404336839914322,
-0.20962609350681305,
-0.12190890312194824,
-0.5848720073699951,
0.5309666991233826,
0.5187192559242249,
-0.7493756413459778,
0.5259597897529602,
0.6901391744613647,
0.9364987015724182,
-0.23321659862995148,
0.03835127875208855,
-0.3415365219116211,
0.21097153425216675,
-0.40576377511024475,
0.8938230872154236,
-0.42419788241386414,
-0.49324434995651245,
-0.002280361717566848,
-0.20734265446662903,
0.1839231550693512,
-0.6134881973266602,
0.4090084731578827,
-0.3590392470359802,
0.18601064383983612,
-1.0531930923461914,
-0.38367342948913574,
0.022644901648163795,
0.14351080358028412,
-0.22228625416755676,
1.1727197170257568,
-0.32992008328437805,
-0.6238049268722534,
0.6880399584770203,
-0.686678409576416,
-0.547412633895874,
-0.27176433801651,
-0.4999118745326996,
0.1724727898836136,
0.13692235946655273,
0.28150513768196106,
0.26381340622901917,
-0.5630335807800293,
0.23148804903030396,
-0.6389157176017761,
-0.4964677393436432,
0.0731850415468216,
-0.46187958121299744,
0.7936158180236816,
0.1259479820728302,
-0.604389488697052,
-0.11058476567268372,
-0.05413759499788284,
-0.11496610194444656,
0.16577748954296112,
-0.12790684401988983,
-0.2638641893863678,
-0.12481989711523056,
-0.25840991735458374,
0.34975409507751465,
0.020645786076784134,
-0.4879084825515747,
0.07065005600452423,
-0.06926506012678146,
0.37539777159690857,
1.193239450454712,
0.1335553675889969,
0.6538128852844238,
-0.5834413170814514,
0.588985800743103,
0.019834665581583977,
0.23308372497558594,
0.17585277557373047,
-0.7568797469139099,
-0.7646158337593079,
-0.0036222580820322037,
-0.22102606296539307,
0.7587244510650635,
-0.803171694278717,
0.18725396692752838,
0.3080308735370636,
0.06539590656757355,
-0.3546176552772522,
0.13960133492946625,
0.7338610291481018,
0.3064664900302887,
0.09974903613328934,
-0.4485020637512207,
-0.5772778987884521,
-0.7557883858680725,
-0.41959863901138306,
-0.40319889783859253,
-0.2144506573677063,
0.12094653397798538,
0.20996759831905365,
0.2133011370897293,
1.0027945041656494,
-0.35378044843673706,
-0.0983278676867485,
-0.05738828331232071,
0.08134997636079788,
-0.08515218645334244,
0.2146098017692566,
0.3554694950580597,
-0.29860538244247437,
-0.21384404599666595,
-0.5802739262580872,
-0.7826801538467407,
-0.4162203073501587,
0.07868030667304993,
-0.40593212842941284,
0.4871801733970642,
0.3260769546031952,
-0.6231256723403931,
0.9030147790908813,
0.05635908618569374,
-0.4046045243740082,
0.6065199375152588,
-0.024251826107501984,
0.1272202581167221,
-0.5906018018722534,
-0.23420493304729462,
0.2124355137348175,
-0.08107857406139374,
-0.6146130561828613,
-0.23916931450366974,
-0.1198543831706047,
0.17529204487800598,
-0.43054282665252686,
0.6485607624053955,
-0.6830129623413086,
-0.3663651645183563,
-0.26921749114990234,
0.0689859390258789,
0.161625474691391,
0.3644074499607086,
0.13061320781707764,
0.654255747795105,
0.593644380569458,
-0.9391884207725525,
0.17595362663269043,
0.10148556530475616,
-0.17707662284374237,
0.8771486282348633,
-0.5764983296394348,
0.47092247009277344,
-0.5208905339241028,
0.6302697062492371,
-1.1526283025741577,
0.14423589408397675,
0.5814281702041626,
-0.3276725709438324,
0.22424767911434174,
-0.11992914229631424,
-0.3557640612125397,
-0.588056206703186,
-0.8009100556373596,
0.12486838549375534,
0.6130008697509766,
-0.3866824209690094,
0.02326410822570324,
0.28711971640586853,
-0.06325840950012207,
-0.4756578803062439,
-0.9013887047767639,
0.08338837325572968,
-0.16648757457733154,
-0.5961267352104187,
0.210739865899086,
-0.158488467335701,
-0.4433838129043579,
-0.3276118338108063,
-0.24694713950157166,
0.3329891562461853,
-0.2566032409667969,
0.27391400933265686,
0.6181201934814453,
0.16255372762680054,
0.251459538936615,
0.2956412136554718,
-0.1778126209974289,
0.23646201193332672,
-0.1702517569065094,
0.6361137628555298,
0.14929474890232086,
-0.4104779362678528,
-0.8189446926116943,
0.30579105019569397,
0.37209269404411316,
0.4526057243347168,
0.6042925715446472,
0.5870265960693359,
-0.23200242221355438,
0.017734872177243233,
-0.9528728127479553,
-0.8960341215133667,
-0.3929123282432556,
-0.2696920931339264,
-0.20612037181854248,
-0.7282968759536743,
0.37295281887054443,
-0.10095449537038803,
0.0161659587174654,
-0.1432214081287384,
0.7015619874000549,
-0.24918249249458313,
1.0930707454681396,
0.24958200752735138,
-0.0774381086230278,
0.6243649125099182,
-0.37222322821617126,
0.2791001796722412,
-1.1887950897216797,
-0.15064595639705658,
-0.31386077404022217,
-0.597547173500061,
-0.3366234302520752,
-0.7166258096694946,
0.3923323154449463,
-0.07977676391601562,
-0.3325563967227936,
-0.18605543673038483,
-0.7946126461029053,
0.44029080867767334,
0.778532862663269,
0.5722602605819702,
0.14085103571414948,
0.21594367921352386,
-0.23105888068675995,
0.06199211627244949,
-0.7301939725875854,
-0.8587527275085449,
1.2076340913772583,
0.31400415301322937,
0.8253544569015503,
-0.07508128881454468,
0.7269631028175354,
0.6359540820121765,
0.1883290857076645,
-0.5819932222366333,
0.7779911160469055,
0.21852385997772217,
-1.0210317373275757,
-0.2903633415699005,
-0.22449159622192383,
-0.8346599340438843,
0.121769979596138,
-0.4364790618419647,
-0.8007808327674866,
0.41492730379104614,
0.39566466212272644,
-0.35186541080474854,
0.28405946493148804,
-0.86306232213974,
0.0897073820233345,
-0.1103900820016861,
-0.7041440606117249,
-0.3400697410106659,
-0.8424708247184753,
0.5433715581893921,
0.2742050886154175,
0.25111132860183716,
-0.5022807121276855,
-0.2120647430419922,
0.7007831931114197,
-0.23253343999385834,
1.1693649291992188,
-0.5236719846725464,
-0.07127770781517029,
0.46141117811203003,
0.12809616327285767,
0.652767539024353,
0.22587904334068298,
-0.23907259106636047,
0.1468638777732849,
0.1096234917640686,
-0.34595075249671936,
-0.5984892249107361,
0.48083940148353577,
-0.8255178928375244,
-0.7102012634277344,
-0.38214921951293945,
-0.20344069600105286,
-0.1652480512857437,
-0.2848515510559082,
0.4487868845462799,
0.055576834827661514,
-0.21338295936584473,
-0.4267846345901489,
0.8198100328445435,
-0.09402424842119217,
0.16400772333145142,
0.2570246458053589,
-0.19782406091690063,
-0.13000591099262238,
-0.012300361879169941,
0.23385672271251678,
0.5844941139221191,
-0.06316396594047546,
0.16070692241191864,
-0.32013940811157227,
0.05627642571926117,
-0.20917202532291412,
0.27085080742836,
-0.6596858501434326,
-0.11833582073450089,
-0.5313910245895386,
0.08849073946475983,
-0.8923503160476685,
-0.3619602918624878,
-0.041100457310676575,
-0.5469319820404053,
-0.26942893862724304,
-0.29953381419181824,
0.3995981812477112,
0.9226701259613037,
-0.1544465571641922,
0.25391289591789246,
-0.20420460402965546,
0.5828960537910461,
0.5179108381271362,
0.13440297544002533,
0.175057053565979,
-0.35748371481895447,
0.405983030796051,
0.27908816933631897,
-0.39037448167800903,
-1.0905574560165405,
0.036310214549303055,
-0.3654561936855316,
0.32038527727127075,
0.631779670715332,
0.19493365287780762,
0.6288524866104126,
-0.34117448329925537,
0.9857328534126282,
0.5022990703582764,
-0.8457204103469849,
0.7375168204307556,
-0.2484491467475891,
0.19416092336177826,
0.44097182154655457,
0.12335482239723206,
-0.7580381035804749,
-0.34804850816726685,
-0.3911578953266144,
-0.5595476627349854,
1.0537000894546509,
0.0459781214594841,
0.06414716690778732,
-0.1734352856874466,
0.716971218585968,
0.052457295358181,
0.1918351948261261,
-0.6284652948379517,
-0.5614731907844543,
0.19484098255634308,
0.25893718004226685,
0.195500910282135,
-0.5585978031158447,
-0.4130874574184418,
-0.24825948476791382,
0.7321773767471313,
-0.073921799659729,
0.4564937949180603,
0.4057280719280243,
0.14183105528354645,
-0.5004969835281372,
0.24983058869838715,
0.4946448504924774,
0.4784373641014099,
-0.016188709065318108,
0.3216231167316437,
0.5838788151741028,
-0.18659207224845886,
0.5158244967460632,
-0.7065986394882202,
-0.5534045100212097,
-0.15144100785255432,
0.09652788937091827,
0.7475897073745728,
0.1183086559176445,
-0.129644975066185,
0.2684156596660614,
-0.09882553666830063,
-0.40248534083366394,
-0.21698684990406036,
0.11431461572647095,
0.07592415064573288,
0.27267152070999146,
0.16499395668506622,
0.08634533733129501,
0.13743239641189575,
-0.7538595795631409,
-0.2817716598510742,
0.6568883657455444,
-0.44445815682411194,
-0.08695235848426819,
0.4951537251472473,
0.3191836178302765,
-0.5818086266517639,
0.3143802881240845,
-0.052857790142297745,
-0.23582711815834045,
0.6128612160682678,
0.579098105430603,
0.8738921284675598,
-0.07118808478116989,
0.57530677318573,
0.2831910252571106,
0.4836867153644562,
-0.3804923892021179,
0.2892342507839203,
-0.36558324098587036,
-0.802836537361145,
-0.1627965271472931,
-0.23363067209720612,
-0.5277507305145264,
-0.1532757580280304,
-0.8368518948554993,
0.5494351983070374,
-0.6807699203491211,
-0.7012960910797119,
-0.025218982249498367,
0.06957544386386871,
-0.8201370239257812,
-0.24104145169258118,
0.5367775559425354,
0.7429773807525635,
-0.8742783069610596,
0.5453553199768066,
0.7024377584457397,
-0.1064734011888504,
-0.6235182881355286,
-0.027313465252518654,
0.5858355164527893,
-0.9821450114250183,
0.5829597115516663,
0.1276002675294876,
-0.4600914418697357,
-0.45595306158065796,
-0.7460424304008484,
-0.8454337120056152,
1.07882821559906,
0.6123099327087402,
-0.41565462946891785,
-0.1300835758447647,
-0.12233783304691315,
0.2657864987850189,
-0.4004056751728058,
0.39273759722709656,
0.7024319171905518,
0.7753205299377441,
0.2683708667755127,
-0.8010419011116028,
0.31103453040122986,
0.08465469628572464,
0.4588417410850525,
0.0955137386918068,
-0.7087159156799316,
0.5590195655822754,
-0.46865883469581604,
-0.30663031339645386,
-0.22621344029903412,
0.08051074296236038,
0.6924585700035095,
0.8312773108482361,
0.6106064319610596,
0.1333240419626236,
0.8436441421508789,
0.09783011674880981,
0.7339308857917786,
-0.13694030046463013,
0.1250019371509552,
0.9629272818565369,
-0.9706941246986389,
0.37671080231666565,
0.7751823663711548,
-0.3206661641597748,
0.5961030125617981,
0.6319525837898254,
0.5445939302444458,
0.1959236115217209,
0.24257558584213257,
-0.539962112903595,
-0.17011728882789612,
-0.1432541310787201,
-0.2658017575740814,
0.1607634425163269,
0.5407753586769104,
-0.28410443663597107,
-0.0497027225792408,
-0.046320319175720215,
0.32224559783935547,
-0.11629563570022583,
-0.28515323996543884,
0.8367383480072021,
0.3747263550758362,
-1.0505645275115967,
0.31004512310028076,
-0.23124848306179047,
0.9238662719726562,
-0.40380632877349854,
0.16542473435401917,
-0.2729422152042389,
-0.20725814998149872,
-0.22915507853031158,
-0.7102636694908142,
0.1286405622959137,
0.11470521986484528,
-0.4849635064601898,
-0.71044921875,
1.1405235528945923,
-0.2694551646709442,
-0.25078046321868896,
0.5851488709449768,
0.6724517345428467,
0.23932282626628876,
0.009039011783897877,
-0.8332727551460266,
-0.08547787368297577,
-0.06528680771589279,
-0.29482683539390564,
0.29457372426986694,
0.22665371000766754,
-0.2505108714103699,
0.6408032774925232,
0.8018012046813965,
0.23123601078987122,
-0.008064145222306252,
0.3511021137237549,
0.6532254219055176,
-0.8042951822280884,
-0.29778221249580383,
-1.0153700113296509,
-0.059869229793548584,
-0.31588253378868103,
0.1820102483034134,
0.5879287123680115,
0.11435884982347488,
0.4558712840080261,
0.08728928118944168,
0.9570344686508179,
0.0908825546503067,
0.3422413766384125,
-0.5016974806785583,
0.3643040955066681,
-0.08092239499092102,
0.47328948974609375,
-0.34820711612701416,
-0.8665322661399841,
-0.05196342617273331,
0.5332120060920715,
-0.5952889919281006,
0.31865912675857544,
0.8395723700523376,
1.1289007663726807,
0.4798393249511719,
0.1642298847436905,
0.27269089221954346,
-0.13539288938045502,
0.07305905222892761,
0.529792845249176,
1.0644736289978027,
0.010135839693248272,
0.18588191270828247,
-0.09005999565124512,
-0.6060892939567566,
-0.24743539094924927,
-0.6620045900344849,
-1.0765974521636963,
-0.09316878020763397,
-0.16115455329418182,
-0.5174568891525269,
0.3809768259525299,
1.122075080871582,
0.8056168556213379,
-0.40186309814453125,
-0.3271845281124115,
-0.0880575031042099,
0.6137971878051758,
-0.09877000749111176,
-0.2612501084804535,
-0.10922244936227798,
-0.36274364590644836,
-0.39327776432037354,
0.05611012130975723,
0.5541003942489624,
-0.10512906312942505,
-0.5541878938674927,
-0.15575280785560608,
-0.4727650582790375,
0.3879834711551666,
0.7169907689094543,
-0.013481480069458485,
-0.895110547542572,
-0.4225466251373291,
0.07493530213832855,
0.003542774124071002,
0.06321946531534195,
1.094557762145996,
-0.882209062576294,
0.24657785892486572,
0.5530161261558533,
-0.3973175883293152,
0.5026414394378662,
-0.06753920018672943,
0.6978535652160645,
-0.6033400893211365,
0.20840750634670258,
0.18518365919589996,
0.19090139865875244,
0.25227299332618713,
-0.7927809357643127,
0.6613568663597107,
0.38666269183158875,
-0.5788556337356567,
-0.6557825803756714,
0.5670791864395142,
-0.6835087537765503,
-0.33358269929885864,
1.3754163980484009,
0.292463481426239,
-0.29598936438560486,
-0.33230409026145935,
-0.6304022669792175,
0.3977872431278229,
-0.7454001903533936,
0.8294017910957336,
0.8297386765480042,
-0.39122387766838074,
-0.0836779773235321,
-0.4891577959060669,
0.43580862879753113,
0.7518344521522522,
-0.5562271475791931,
0.048340342938899994,
0.45220258831977844,
0.32879289984703064,
0.06265836954116821,
1.1474120616912842,
-0.005994915030896664,
0.3336010277271271,
-0.1137228012084961,
0.23901259899139404,
0.3476133942604065,
-0.18215228617191315,
-0.41247326135635376,
-0.13840033113956451,
-0.04426661878824234,
0.005191913805902004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17216v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17216v1
|
Prompting Towards Alleviating Code-Switched Data Scarcity in Under-Resourced Languages with GPT as a Pivot
| 2024-04-26T07:44:44 | 2024-04-26T07:44:44 |
Michelle Terblanche, Kayode Olaleye, Vukosi Marivate
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Many multilingual communities, including numerous in Africa, frequently
engage in code-switching during conversations. This behaviour stresses the need
for natural language processing technologies adept at processing code-switched
text. However, data scarcity, particularly in African languages, poses a
significant challenge, as many are low-resourced and under-represented. In this
study, we prompted GPT 3.5 to generate Afrikaans--English and Yoruba--English
code-switched sentences, enhancing diversity using topic-keyword pairs,
linguistic guidelines, and few-shot examples. Our findings indicate that the
quality of generated sentences for languages using non-Latin scripts, like
Yoruba, is considerably lower when compared with the high Afrikaans-English
success rate. There is therefore a notable opportunity to refine prompting
guidelines to yield sentences suitable for the fine-tuning of language models.
We propose a framework for augmenting the diversity of synthetically generated
code-switched data using GPT and propose leveraging this technology to mitigate
data scarcity in low-resourced languages, underscoring the essential role of
native speakers in this process.
|
[
-0.7118597030639648,
-0.6974601745605469,
0.22458301484584808,
0.3230476677417755,
-0.3393314778804779,
0.008414569310843945,
-0.374246746301651,
-0.32952794432640076,
0.3183493912220001,
0.46792072057724,
-0.6273452639579773,
-0.2296377420425415,
-0.4399879276752472,
0.4263243079185486,
-0.3319035768508911,
1.3240923881530762,
-0.3140273988246918,
-0.3329537510871887,
0.14586371183395386,
-0.18526175618171692,
-0.8114675283432007,
-0.5011875033378601,
-0.4887051284313202,
-0.19531743228435516,
0.6326209306716919,
0.8371532559394836,
0.9744313955307007,
0.250195175409317,
-0.10562999546527863,
0.15124043822288513,
0.059562455862760544,
0.583601713180542,
-0.3005439341068268,
0.12216007709503174,
-0.14307615160942078,
-0.2689492702484131,
-0.030417446047067642,
-0.05319337174296379,
0.09410911798477173,
0.8019112944602966,
0.10647965222597122,
-0.008947637863457203,
0.2631736993789673,
0.644497811794281,
-0.555353581905365,
0.2605207860469818,
-0.7811279296875,
-0.17337797582149506,
-0.36347439885139465,
-0.26689890027046204,
-0.09908045083284378,
-0.3702896237373352,
-0.15899033844470978,
-0.41589927673339844,
0.46805718541145325,
-0.543377161026001,
0.804938554763794,
0.09067131578922272,
-0.20982715487480164,
-0.39204898476600647,
-0.5211688876152039,
0.510960578918457,
-0.44976183772087097,
-0.0031816987320780754,
0.7097834348678589,
0.05245755985379219,
0.02975461259484291,
-0.4783185124397278,
-0.592478334903717,
-0.05177559703588486,
0.00792986061424017,
-0.01978546939790249,
-0.18801051378250122,
-0.17615973949432373,
0.15072448551654816,
0.1387970745563507,
-0.31729042530059814,
-0.03974604979157448,
-0.5398624539375305,
-0.3311818242073059,
0.553612232208252,
-0.10093466937541962,
0.30458569526672363,
-0.29898473620414734,
0.11494449526071548,
0.15423408150672913,
-0.8612642884254456,
-0.2785808742046356,
0.8200042247772217,
0.894335150718689,
-0.006560951471328735,
0.4594614505767822,
-0.35434621572494507,
0.8064948320388794,
-0.18882949650287628,
0.13489173352718353,
0.35084912180900574,
-0.4785816967487335,
0.050120674073696136,
0.05845914036035538,
0.5953247547149658,
0.325087308883667,
0.4572751522064209,
0.0033103106543421745,
-0.28822705149650574,
0.2407551407814026,
0.20903290808200836,
-0.6891752481460571,
-0.31727734208106995,
0.06375797092914581,
-0.2945496141910553,
-0.12627680599689484,
-0.0956321582198143,
-0.9295022487640381,
-0.028526943176984787,
-0.035751476883888245,
0.14986225962638855,
-0.498719185590744,
-0.1626981645822525,
0.07299362123012543,
-0.0036578739527612925,
-0.0523005910217762,
0.29198089241981506,
-1.2814123630523682,
0.1471734642982483,
0.35205382108688354,
1.1038926839828491,
-0.1575077325105667,
-0.2551072835922241,
-0.3368222713470459,
-0.03196403384208679,
-0.05933920294046402,
0.5220134854316711,
-0.5660126209259033,
-0.7265127897262573,
0.11709118634462357,
-0.11729614436626434,
0.12982161343097687,
-0.4783734679222107,
0.49593839049339294,
-0.39629095792770386,
0.10076352208852768,
-0.4032258689403534,
-0.03975233435630798,
-0.09425707906484604,
0.20076800882816315,
-0.6929371953010559,
1.0502876043319702,
0.39081400632858276,
-0.4256596863269806,
0.4848993420600891,
-0.8321705460548401,
-0.8853747844696045,
0.2885298728942871,
-0.2869027256965637,
-0.3069635033607483,
0.07018422335386276,
0.7847601771354675,
0.12366916984319687,
-0.2661048471927643,
0.16299769282341003,
0.16565951704978943,
-0.32365646958351135,
0.08414984494447708,
-0.8183072805404663,
0.686657190322876,
0.44296953082084656,
-0.454513818025589,
-0.21568721532821655,
-0.706543505191803,
0.19556006789207458,
0.09023226797580719,
-0.2987029552459717,
-0.11553999036550522,
-0.21330979466438293,
0.34536415338516235,
0.22366946935653687,
-0.006286755204200745,
-0.2338431477546692,
0.6287903189659119,
-0.19272248446941376,
0.6367311477661133,
0.5069509744644165,
0.1342669576406479,
0.20958097279071808,
-0.22079002857208252,
0.7741004824638367,
-0.09860385954380035,
-0.06611216813325882,
-0.22230949997901917,
-0.9954874515533447,
-0.5877023935317993,
-0.020523089915513992,
0.17512881755828857,
0.6139932870864868,
-1.1818355321884155,
0.11711366474628448,
0.027740633115172386,
-0.07809212058782578,
-0.8412473201751709,
0.40731656551361084,
-0.0003089256933890283,
0.368064820766449,
0.5626702308654785,
-0.16567480564117432,
-0.4508010447025299,
-0.914631187915802,
-0.07406090199947357,
-0.16976526379585266,
0.03745241090655327,
0.2917676866054535,
0.26748722791671753,
-0.45724424719810486,
1.2356678247451782,
-0.362655371427536,
-0.08188390731811523,
-0.6567994952201843,
0.3575224280357361,
0.4262680411338806,
0.5837112665176392,
0.47711479663848877,
-0.9823509454727173,
-0.3727242648601532,
-0.007632104679942131,
-0.13306660950183868,
-0.6512018442153931,
-0.42870035767555237,
-0.03747137263417244,
0.41719725728034973,
0.4047365188598633,
-0.5341616868972778,
0.37869393825531006,
0.666338324546814,
-0.02169780619442463,
0.4238646626472473,
-0.12199966609477997,
0.31322726607322693,
-0.9124082922935486,
0.05121156945824623,
-0.4513445496559143,
0.05140678212046623,
-0.5210403800010681,
-0.20040762424468994,
-0.033262066543102264,
-0.3355180025100708,
-0.38998883962631226,
0.4683935344219208,
-0.6263038516044617,
0.02828279137611389,
-0.496467262506485,
0.029609987512230873,
-0.03974953293800354,
0.28955531120300293,
0.08888309448957443,
1.2325408458709717,
0.238175168633461,
-0.6412564516067505,
0.18366768956184387,
0.5500127673149109,
-0.28185755014419556,
0.3522244989871979,
-0.4847935736179352,
0.18012817203998566,
0.08192092925310135,
-0.11605727672576904,
-0.6685952544212341,
-0.2522709369659424,
0.3526744842529297,
-0.34728309512138367,
0.10670264810323715,
-0.5826520323753357,
-0.45078885555267334,
-0.34274688363075256,
0.07607102394104004,
0.5532310009002686,
0.474503755569458,
-0.49351102113723755,
0.019344106316566467,
0.1952877789735794,
-0.5767077803611755,
-0.4211214482784271,
-1.0374983549118042,
0.45927438139915466,
0.09697471559047699,
-0.5580568909645081,
0.13966721296310425,
0.0993327796459198,
-0.02067715860903263,
-0.013174976222217083,
0.00461228983476758,
-0.1294495165348053,
0.07781241834163666,
0.043342456221580505,
0.3936425447463989,
-0.10502129793167114,
0.18894484639167786,
0.28115466237068176,
-0.1946394294500351,
-0.21813984215259552,
-0.7254728674888611,
0.7960886359214783,
-0.18269862234592438,
-0.3577564060688019,
0.08872435241937637,
0.6118955016136169,
0.04244326800107956,
-0.24828049540519714,
0.7847436666488647,
0.5602206587791443,
-0.05694059282541275,
-0.11418162286281586,
-0.24458687007427216,
-0.07062549889087677,
-0.46290841698646545,
0.2389102727174759,
-0.34761515259742737,
-1.0902858972549438,
0.5399064421653748,
0.017593983560800552,
-0.050150446593761444,
0.2874925136566162,
0.8861159086227417,
0.16751649975776672,
0.5578342080116272,
0.600517749786377,
-0.14569862186908722,
0.4782862067222595,
-0.06619735807180405,
0.3751518726348877,
-0.36314988136291504,
0.26582711935043335,
-0.5281156301498413,
-0.2934700846672058,
-0.9121644496917725,
-0.503333330154419,
0.38262683153152466,
0.13893288373947144,
0.2043558955192566,
0.35886138677597046,
-0.5097101926803589,
0.6754833459854126,
0.5116564631462097,
0.09463825076818466,
0.07386236637830734,
0.12494935095310211,
0.026976384222507477,
-0.021765990182757378,
-0.9702883362770081,
-0.6209142804145813,
0.9957262277603149,
-0.25719210505485535,
0.7921857833862305,
-0.12294933944940567,
0.9332724213600159,
0.29065200686454773,
0.25752925872802734,
-0.6408644318580627,
0.338195264339447,
-0.0318659245967865,
-0.6362151503562927,
-0.24784180521965027,
-0.6274218559265137,
-1.1318687200546265,
0.0591958649456501,
0.06643542647361755,
-0.5428789854049683,
0.37388813495635986,
0.2722594141960144,
-0.28572648763656616,
0.30171412229537964,
-0.7828803062438965,
0.7832411527633667,
-0.06043142452836037,
-0.27052369713783264,
-0.043722283095121384,
-0.5725899934768677,
0.17799289524555206,
-0.24854286015033722,
0.24982155859470367,
-0.06370299309492111,
-0.12215282022953033,
0.3044174015522003,
-0.6317724585533142,
0.9602815508842468,
-0.10603148490190506,
-0.17954495549201965,
0.5286423563957214,
0.1748046725988388,
0.4318125545978546,
0.27056068181991577,
-0.21465516090393066,
0.22177664935588837,
-0.5961371064186096,
-0.5830865502357483,
-0.34240567684173584,
0.6489779949188232,
-0.5745534300804138,
-0.37645912170410156,
-0.13619278371334076,
-0.8200168609619141,
-0.48222845792770386,
0.18635590374469757,
0.5621142387390137,
0.21511703729629517,
-0.0605350099503994,
-0.23032541573047638,
0.38970351219177246,
-0.43876439332962036,
0.45229312777519226,
0.18822897970676422,
0.03739720955491066,
-0.3014119565486908,
0.957054078578949,
0.13026423752307892,
0.5478405952453613,
0.038305848836898804,
-0.08618835359811783,
-0.030376555398106575,
-0.6121383905410767,
-0.657552182674408,
-0.1409195512533188,
-0.6298400163650513,
-0.35272452235221863,
-0.6144181489944458,
0.035748690366744995,
-0.350727379322052,
-0.5649341344833374,
-0.18560883402824402,
-0.6608266234397888,
-0.11942130327224731,
-0.16479459404945374,
0.7006269097328186,
0.44342663884162903,
-0.3050726354122162,
0.4068990647792816,
-1.045263409614563,
0.4080882668495178,
0.15682698786258698,
0.3573826849460602,
-0.2828942835330963,
-0.2553683817386627,
-0.3103177845478058,
0.1605808287858963,
-0.20462970435619354,
-0.947513222694397,
0.5163555145263672,
0.26467010378837585,
0.44940680265426636,
-0.005860933102667332,
0.14356975257396698,
0.500049889087677,
-0.4443809390068054,
0.837955892086029,
0.02977600321173668,
-1.020522952079773,
0.8000180125236511,
-0.40162479877471924,
0.49256086349487305,
0.851082980632782,
0.3788507282733917,
-0.9383136630058289,
-0.5210107564926147,
-0.5243054032325745,
-1.252428412437439,
0.8392959237098694,
0.5168226361274719,
0.37615641951560974,
-0.4614350199699402,
0.21824884414672852,
0.43407779932022095,
0.4710092842578888,
-0.6989990472793579,
-0.18252648413181305,
-0.6153214573860168,
-0.07509278506040573,
0.1346762776374817,
0.020543351769447327,
-0.03822745010256767,
0.023201435804367065,
0.6044836044311523,
-0.4667101502418518,
0.23935669660568237,
0.18922331929206848,
-0.3029271364212036,
0.034159064292907715,
0.6212295889854431,
0.28701063990592957,
0.429401695728302,
0.06244383379817009,
-0.2063705325126648,
-0.057626690715551376,
-0.6715213060379028,
0.2765592932701111,
0.2959902286529541,
-0.7805739641189575,
0.2199050933122635,
0.15708525478839874,
0.8985744714736938,
0.11321941763162613,
-0.25676870346069336,
0.001943584531545639,
0.22767870128154755,
-0.02303737960755825,
0.43064603209495544,
0.1060272678732872,
-0.03766603767871857,
-0.16255919635295868,
0.3138972222805023,
0.26871970295906067,
0.04089142754673958,
-0.6098191738128662,
0.27703434228897095,
0.15470775961875916,
-0.02076386660337448,
0.09295918047428131,
0.40961581468582153,
0.6644697785377502,
-0.14993782341480255,
0.8525730967521667,
-0.38679489493370056,
-0.4956131875514984,
0.5418145060539246,
0.5786189436912537,
0.9209559559822083,
0.03083845227956772,
0.5447878241539001,
0.2298092097043991,
0.6518188714981079,
-0.08370544016361237,
0.526710569858551,
-0.23441225290298462,
-0.9100382328033447,
-0.42345643043518066,
-0.29614266753196716,
-0.39510515332221985,
-0.05610881373286247,
-0.744062602519989,
0.1505117267370224,
-0.3357813060283661,
-0.16431763768196106,
-0.2625383138656616,
-0.22558017075061798,
-0.5719056725502014,
-0.07318925112485886,
0.1223456934094429,
0.7541032433509827,
-0.7727199196815491,
0.9125949144363403,
0.4298957586288452,
-0.6630861163139343,
-0.5730297565460205,
0.27111104130744934,
0.022802988067269325,
-0.9524189233779907,
0.5167383551597595,
0.09880871325731277,
0.012653975747525692,
-0.013523537665605545,
-0.6122291684150696,
-0.3196043074131012,
0.4749455153942108,
0.4308445155620575,
-0.5244299173355103,
0.3485569357872009,
0.38588762283325195,
0.3453707695007324,
-0.08214829117059708,
0.1002955362200737,
0.6933726668357849,
0.6434798836708069,
0.03278208523988724,
-0.7491711974143982,
-0.0553756058216095,
-0.3270428478717804,
-0.0227142833173275,
0.5947444438934326,
-0.31702807545661926,
0.857617199420929,
-0.38979965448379517,
-0.2818361222743988,
0.0008027760777622461,
0.5911918878555298,
0.024453705176711082,
-0.00170256313867867,
0.4037875235080719,
0.006542772985994816,
0.7204691171646118,
-0.27319368720054626,
1.1164036989212036,
-0.29602867364883423,
0.1521688848733902,
0.9057007431983948,
-0.4698541760444641,
0.4486996829509735,
0.5539978742599487,
-0.223381906747818,
0.24977253377437592,
0.3751268684864044,
-0.09823382645845413,
0.4443688988685608,
-0.052760325372219086,
-0.3507236838340759,
-0.12304152548313141,
-0.04748435318470001,
-0.46925756335258484,
0.25031521916389465,
0.42001715302467346,
0.050753358751535416,
-0.46963050961494446,
0.14615321159362793,
0.03152960538864136,
0.015707330778241158,
-0.4104749262332916,
0.48355427384376526,
-0.01693066582083702,
-0.592915415763855,
0.6823397278785706,
-0.1110977828502655,
0.9082610011100769,
-0.7763049006462097,
0.025036374107003212,
-0.6769921183586121,
-0.2199496626853943,
-0.28603243827819824,
-1.0129756927490234,
0.46375346183776855,
0.30557939410209656,
-0.312622606754303,
-0.5263970494270325,
0.5207346081733704,
-0.7228832840919495,
-0.4302343428134918,
0.10844869911670685,
0.5601211190223694,
0.02268395945429802,
-0.06825363636016846,
-0.6345370411872864,
0.01326112262904644,
0.2744428515434265,
0.16222354769706726,
0.34143057465553284,
0.5545373558998108,
-0.3369719684123993,
0.4649503827095032,
0.7845783829689026,
0.26378369331359863,
-0.1575329303741455,
0.44229087233543396,
0.9028598666191101,
-0.5538250803947449,
-0.8177523016929626,
-0.7041803002357483,
0.24634042382240295,
0.06629360467195511,
-0.5106139183044434,
0.8109281659126282,
0.3369810879230499,
0.9878746271133423,
-0.18927693367004395,
1.1232846975326538,
-0.3972145915031433,
0.1409502923488617,
-0.6423230171203613,
0.6147494912147522,
-0.2289147973060608,
0.21441881358623505,
-0.37865757942199707,
-0.8638045191764832,
-0.09715471416711807,
0.5144948363304138,
-0.1611393690109253,
0.1016293615102768,
0.4132102429866791,
0.8862724900245667,
-0.06833688914775848,
0.05962130427360535,
0.1591588854789734,
-0.024106323719024658,
0.37982824444770813,
0.5690905451774597,
0.6078791618347168,
-0.2606971263885498,
0.8210960626602173,
0.0637141689658165,
-0.17960065603256226,
-0.15849943459033966,
-0.822891891002655,
-0.5697018504142761,
-0.37625133991241455,
-0.289778470993042,
-0.4173315763473511,
0.21142731606960297,
1.0779054164886475,
0.4514133334159851,
-1.0759376287460327,
-0.1976531594991684,
-0.1962842345237732,
0.12168708443641663,
-0.30662238597869873,
-0.197739839553833,
-0.010320671834051609,
-0.5411093235015869,
-0.5864885449409485,
0.4670899510383606,
0.4092184603214264,
0.2762645184993744,
-0.03237197920680046,
-0.04762095585465431,
-0.24664375185966492,
-0.10222942382097244,
0.48163482546806335,
0.6574644446372986,
-0.36309078335762024,
0.03423434495925903,
-0.24191449582576752,
-0.1539967805147171,
0.06612349301576614,
1.2855446338653564,
-0.9032229781150818,
0.23032982647418976,
0.334654837846756,
0.875990092754364,
0.4021108150482178,
-0.20832380652427673,
0.9366209506988525,
-1.0446730852127075,
0.5644376873970032,
0.34335750341415405,
0.26111188530921936,
0.4856049120426178,
-0.32722267508506775,
0.6373326778411865,
0.29108336567878723,
-0.35490062832832336,
-0.5771859884262085,
0.46016475558280945,
-0.6032564043998718,
-0.22777187824249268,
1.1606688499450684,
0.08530605584383011,
0.09709088504314423,
-0.5231314897537231,
-0.5239149928092957,
0.12763063609600067,
-0.5723710060119629,
0.7416294813156128,
0.7794146537780762,
-0.023048916831612587,
-0.23796585202217102,
-0.5535587668418884,
0.6845776438713074,
0.5159687995910645,
-1.0933088064193726,
0.22441157698631287,
0.47409263253211975,
-0.08520988374948502,
0.09725838899612427,
0.6637826561927795,
-0.02822083793580532,
0.4834749400615692,
-0.004173482768237591,
0.055912312120199203,
-0.10615820437669754,
-0.05922292545437813,
-0.37922096252441406,
-0.06111646443605423,
-0.2121226191520691,
-0.10582879185676575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17194v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17194v1
|
TIGQA:An Expert Annotated Question Answering Dataset in Tigrinya
| 2024-04-26T07:07:43 | 2024-04-26T07:07:43 |
Hailay Teklehaymanot, Dren Fazlija, Niloy Ganguly, Gourab K. Patro, Wolfgang Nejdl
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CL
|
The absence of explicitly tailored, accessible annotated datasets for
educational purposes presents a notable obstacle for NLP tasks in languages
with limited resources.This study initially explores the feasibility of using
machine translation (MT) to convert an existing dataset into a Tigrinya dataset
in SQuAD format. As a result, we present TIGQA, an expert annotated educational
dataset consisting of 2.68K question-answer pairs covering 122 diverse topics
such as climate, water, and traffic. These pairs are from 537 context
paragraphs in publicly accessible Tigrinya and Biology books. Through
comprehensive analyses, we demonstrate that the TIGQA dataset requires skills
beyond simple word matching, requiring both single-sentence and
multiple-sentence inference abilities. We conduct experiments using
state-of-the art MRC methods, marking the first exploration of such models on
TIGQA. Additionally, we estimate human performance on the dataset and juxtapose
it with the results obtained from pretrained models.The notable disparities
between human performance and best model performance underscore the potential
for further enhancements to TIGQA through continued research. Our dataset is
freely accessible via the provided link to encourage the research community to
address the challenges in the Tigrinya MRC.
|
[
-0.4664466977119446,
-0.8116947412490845,
0.31331437826156616,
-0.1852172315120697,
-0.09362971782684326,
0.4088934659957886,
-0.04541768506169319,
-0.20242394506931305,
0.06773082911968231,
0.3072250783443451,
-0.5593645572662354,
-0.40911394357681274,
-0.7043765187263489,
0.0915716141462326,
-0.41060206294059753,
1.0695068836212158,
0.07381034642457962,
-0.02969776652753353,
-0.13519951701164246,
-0.29731234908103943,
-0.4514802396297455,
-0.46558505296707153,
-0.7320085763931274,
-0.2787911295890808,
0.5552562475204468,
0.6173255443572998,
0.7636653184890747,
0.70090252161026,
0.34061118960380554,
0.13345284759998322,
-0.19025413691997528,
0.34501004219055176,
-0.3537925183773041,
0.11107020825147629,
-0.23773890733718872,
-0.41769030690193176,
-0.21410880982875824,
0.2959980070590973,
0.5110355019569397,
0.6853649020195007,
-0.17697811126708984,
0.5819070339202881,
0.03696346655488014,
0.5117160081863403,
-0.3481520414352417,
0.14894673228263855,
-0.5063510537147522,
0.090920090675354,
-0.23371893167495728,
-0.13990122079849243,
-0.1486758440732956,
-0.3217989206314087,
0.251695454120636,
-0.5623193979263306,
0.3464103639125824,
-0.027521304786205292,
0.49631500244140625,
0.7776753306388855,
-0.3511567711830139,
-0.22417131066322327,
-0.21795789897441864,
0.7130905389785767,
-0.36210185289382935,
0.062250927090644836,
0.5515097975730896,
0.3901510536670685,
-0.09166513383388519,
-0.5527342557907104,
-0.4667941927909851,
0.18578949570655823,
0.022256936877965927,
0.25166505575180054,
0.05571911856532097,
-0.21181316673755646,
0.21943481266498566,
0.11370114237070084,
-0.605223536491394,
-0.12318871170282364,
-0.640270471572876,
0.05823822692036629,
0.5063791871070862,
0.16018521785736084,
0.381671667098999,
-0.3697335124015808,
-0.20679572224617004,
-0.1641317903995514,
-0.47688958048820496,
0.486299991607666,
0.31721192598342896,
0.34815713763237,
0.13362888991832733,
0.5360865592956543,
-0.2885412573814392,
0.5846021175384521,
-0.3558698296546936,
0.20502202212810516,
0.0256838146597147,
-0.1374916285276413,
-0.08682136237621307,
-0.06563403457403183,
0.5988257527351379,
0.3393782079219818,
0.3272554576396942,
-0.5129108428955078,
0.08554013818502426,
-0.15369004011154175,
0.2106788158416748,
-0.7628853917121887,
-0.40820637345314026,
0.28548574447631836,
-0.07546021044254303,
-0.2486870288848877,
0.1234595999121666,
-1.1277095079421997,
-0.28527799248695374,
0.08223778754472733,
0.3633136749267578,
-0.03804093599319458,
-0.21644994616508484,
-0.034555379301309586,
-0.0664505586028099,
0.32890647649765015,
0.10258907079696655,
-0.8921086192131042,
0.19042252004146576,
0.553673267364502,
0.8622701168060303,
-0.08816493302583694,
-0.34098008275032043,
-0.6697171330451965,
-0.03957228735089302,
-0.36507928371429443,
0.6977171301841736,
-0.6811556220054626,
-0.44390591979026794,
-0.13528300821781158,
-0.012308481149375439,
-0.27955305576324463,
-0.3809545934200287,
0.7047230005264282,
-0.5102799534797668,
0.37751346826553345,
-0.35853761434555054,
-0.16168776154518127,
-0.47959181666374207,
-0.019168389961123466,
-0.4727511703968048,
1.295493245124817,
0.2607027292251587,
-0.7972307801246643,
-0.007609877269715071,
-0.7492812871932983,
-0.41361647844314575,
0.12151690572500229,
-0.08358455449342728,
-0.11375009268522263,
-0.06260230392217636,
0.619385302066803,
0.5876754522323608,
-0.3625103831291199,
0.7239189147949219,
-0.15247289836406708,
-0.3569108545780182,
0.5251933336257935,
-0.14204050600528717,
1.0242587327957153,
0.2144555002450943,
-0.269121378660202,
-0.08347545564174652,
-0.3148844838142395,
0.39407962560653687,
0.008906405419111252,
-0.3078399896621704,
-0.04598075896501541,
-0.11423016339540482,
-0.07022010535001755,
0.35504645109176636,
0.06357259303331375,
-0.3735778033733368,
0.31765636801719666,
-0.14473846554756165,
0.8892887830734253,
0.6667249202728271,
0.018325308337807655,
0.30524516105651855,
-0.46485182642936707,
0.7285024523735046,
-0.30836787819862366,
0.03622768446803093,
0.09669236093759537,
-0.8126405477523804,
-0.7260719537734985,
0.019171159714460373,
0.4631306231021881,
0.8390791416168213,
-1.126198172569275,
-0.14256183803081512,
-0.17237570881843567,
-0.5231232047080994,
-1.150076150894165,
0.006224077194929123,
0.4428904056549072,
0.9554246068000793,
0.6826861500740051,
0.14303764700889587,
-0.34103110432624817,
-1.0252171754837036,
-0.21468719840049744,
-0.2690126299858093,
-0.1346707046031952,
0.3220309615135193,
0.7129192352294922,
0.170870840549469,
0.7464318871498108,
-0.4744263291358948,
-0.14093954861164093,
-0.16853265464305878,
0.13086122274398804,
0.01435158122330904,
0.45995423197746277,
0.6415382623672485,
-0.701777994632721,
-0.18587782979011536,
-0.31888139247894287,
-0.7887263894081116,
-0.2742770314216614,
0.09697110205888748,
-0.4660741984844208,
-0.0342533178627491,
0.222538024187088,
-0.2832067906856537,
0.41725072264671326,
0.6697661280632019,
-0.2705203592777252,
0.04372040554881096,
-0.0783924087882042,
0.5261640548706055,
-1.238088607788086,
0.2652481496334076,
0.038100142031908035,
-0.1559080332517624,
-0.8911588788032532,
0.40942463278770447,
-0.05696534737944603,
-0.059336014091968536,
-0.2737920582294464,
0.6061105132102966,
0.1317891776561737,
0.06463024765253067,
-0.0057825129479169846,
0.3085761070251465,
-0.12334126234054565,
0.5732099413871765,
-0.018406666815280914,
1.4042240381240845,
0.37680450081825256,
-0.3535313010215759,
0.31298965215682983,
0.7739335298538208,
-0.12681162357330322,
0.18850284814834595,
-0.9174420237541199,
0.3697391450405121,
-0.21805471181869507,
-0.12473874539136887,
-0.8377505540847778,
-0.5809152126312256,
0.599278450012207,
-0.7799559831619263,
0.05240311846137047,
-0.21603050827980042,
-0.4800173044204712,
-0.10897558927536011,
-0.0897006019949913,
0.28639110922813416,
0.5109025239944458,
-0.5261791944503784,
0.4390811622142792,
0.6797704696655273,
-0.5556452870368958,
-0.7404302954673767,
-0.835801362991333,
0.2981221079826355,
-0.3011438846588135,
-0.43694639205932617,
-0.05576720088720322,
-0.12720312178134918,
-0.15700286626815796,
-0.10039731115102768,
0.056017547845840454,
-0.5389454960823059,
0.4049297869205475,
0.42072340846061707,
0.4134311079978943,
-0.10986833274364471,
0.4182848334312439,
0.08436143398284912,
0.12167254835367203,
0.10787436366081238,
-0.22037847340106964,
0.22211699187755585,
-0.29724738001823425,
0.1767093688249588,
-0.2688046395778656,
0.5881745219230652,
0.3065721094608307,
-0.4946252107620239,
0.9619077444076538,
0.6164518594741821,
-0.4032292366027832,
-0.05807330831885338,
-0.32287898659706116,
0.06297365576028824,
-0.3579005002975464,
0.332165002822876,
-0.3543667495250702,
-0.8366720080375671,
0.4829081892967224,
0.2881155014038086,
0.08886818587779999,
0.535220742225647,
0.19462433457374573,
-0.310846745967865,
0.7909968495368958,
0.49972647428512573,
0.010506526567041874,
0.1425049602985382,
-0.27306196093559265,
-0.06367316842079163,
-0.851740837097168,
-0.599313497543335,
-0.8371819853782654,
-0.2837637960910797,
-0.40666458010673523,
-0.4997765123844147,
0.3967454135417938,
-0.007869810797274113,
-0.3242878317832947,
0.11313458532094955,
-0.654631495475769,
0.3945438265800476,
0.8055030703544617,
0.4851720631122589,
0.17316268384456635,
0.10093466937541962,
0.2371351718902588,
-0.09198553115129471,
-0.9352039694786072,
-0.7775919437408447,
1.0739339590072632,
0.11230026185512543,
0.278037428855896,
0.24614350497722626,
0.2810830771923065,
0.30108362436294556,
0.37631088495254517,
-0.6487162709236145,
0.6247325539588928,
-0.12221968173980713,
-0.8513660430908203,
-0.3261566758155823,
-0.6052144169807434,
-0.4809809625148773,
-0.029947491362690926,
-0.4593651294708252,
-0.43259677290916443,
-0.22718793153762817,
-0.11070141196250916,
-0.5635262727737427,
0.34905439615249634,
-0.8038450479507446,
0.8891540765762329,
-0.30105963349342346,
-0.48275691270828247,
0.17284566164016724,
-0.8145723342895508,
0.2530932128429413,
-0.3640107214450836,
0.1174406185746193,
-0.25321879982948303,
-0.3555900752544403,
1.1383817195892334,
0.03318498656153679,
0.48584410548210144,
-0.2961829602718353,
0.34374210238456726,
0.3158107399940491,
-0.13568638265132904,
-0.029385430738329887,
0.24059513211250305,
-0.3726676106452942,
-0.07744928449392319,
0.3282225430011749,
-0.7621731162071228,
-0.45741015672683716,
0.4160652458667755,
-0.961164116859436,
-0.7100769877433777,
-0.46123406291007996,
-0.7071309089660645,
-0.3971666693687439,
0.018493561074137688,
-0.007264048792421818,
0.3978674113750458,
0.09617135673761368,
0.297914057970047,
0.742222249507904,
-0.29667457938194275,
0.2953566014766693,
0.2710206210613251,
-0.10732587426900864,
-0.4188095033168793,
0.6949934959411621,
0.18336541950702667,
-0.13046632707118988,
0.0622418075799942,
0.11787717044353485,
-0.427924245595932,
-0.7848689556121826,
-0.783696711063385,
0.08923044800758362,
-0.6014786958694458,
-0.20202979445457458,
-0.7432833313941956,
-0.21678610146045685,
-0.33269861340522766,
0.06308972835540771,
0.06577160954475403,
-0.5980741381645203,
-0.3739984631538391,
-0.12609492242336273,
0.45230358839035034,
0.9877328872680664,
0.2252604067325592,
0.4470650255680084,
-0.729492723941803,
0.41068771481513977,
0.47391200065612793,
0.22811901569366455,
-0.29218849539756775,
-0.8787596821784973,
-0.07753372192382812,
0.30033078789711,
0.08431829512119293,
-1.006819248199463,
0.3143434226512909,
0.4616420269012451,
0.5021772384643555,
-0.12785929441452026,
0.34212952852249146,
0.7315767407417297,
-0.16514748334884644,
0.7329490780830383,
-0.37473416328430176,
-0.7344253063201904,
0.6446537375450134,
-0.4354475140571594,
0.1921186000108719,
0.6780530214309692,
0.5507921576499939,
-0.5777367353439331,
-0.1727287769317627,
-0.4616275131702423,
-0.5164481997489929,
0.7493090033531189,
0.29213693737983704,
-0.0630769431591034,
0.18689927458763123,
0.762334942817688,
0.11038168519735336,
0.3191714286804199,
-0.23607030510902405,
-0.15990331768989563,
-0.37233564257621765,
-0.36850205063819885,
-0.30033671855926514,
-0.0882185846567154,
-0.1852055788040161,
-0.20923058688640594,
0.8527233600616455,
-0.16738779842853546,
-0.06948477029800415,
0.16555680334568024,
0.004708309657871723,
0.08513075113296509,
0.32766032218933105,
0.37048646807670593,
0.4943138062953949,
-0.20534414052963257,
-0.07594442367553711,
0.3389716148376465,
-0.5420864820480347,
0.009081504307687283,
0.312277227640152,
-0.42075276374816895,
-0.24778862297534943,
0.17906935513019562,
0.3514966368675232,
-0.12065872550010681,
-0.8259017467498779,
0.2523689866065979,
-0.3008929491043091,
-0.09476415067911148,
-0.1981418877840042,
0.2432124763727188,
0.07175154238939285,
0.412249356508255,
0.7047720551490784,
0.16849592328071594,
-0.006370689254254103,
-0.3876611888408661,
0.13774971663951874,
0.14592887461185455,
-0.30409133434295654,
-0.15391916036605835,
0.9610564112663269,
0.26711636781692505,
-0.2286543995141983,
0.8991893529891968,
-0.05878806859254837,
-0.577747642993927,
0.6537802219390869,
-0.11020776629447937,
0.599597156047821,
-0.2364615797996521,
0.5730661153793335,
0.5779765248298645,
0.529205858707428,
-0.1943846493959427,
0.280741423368454,
0.03405757248401642,
-0.31003397703170776,
-0.33963534235954285,
-0.42612460255622864,
-0.649136483669281,
0.043906547129154205,
-0.7136248350143433,
-0.08260270953178406,
-0.3041232228279114,
-0.2351388931274414,
-0.012515244074165821,
0.16365456581115723,
-0.7375054955482483,
0.2308507114648819,
-0.19979865849018097,
0.823353111743927,
-0.9311965107917786,
0.8527116775512695,
1.0245035886764526,
-0.5443309545516968,
-0.8759234547615051,
-0.12718497216701508,
-0.3338373899459839,
-0.8010241985321045,
0.4662569463253021,
0.13779853284358978,
-0.07107333093881607,
0.24662020802497864,
-0.593332827091217,
-0.35290542244911194,
1.0601792335510254,
0.4008968472480774,
0.03225051984190941,
-0.4087589681148529,
0.33260542154312134,
0.5403907299041748,
-0.41314467787742615,
0.09434307366609573,
0.7959625124931335,
0.3271096348762512,
-0.005874649155884981,
-0.7001581788063049,
-0.2095666527748108,
-0.42598220705986023,
-0.206657275557518,
-0.15588800609111786,
-0.6843169331550598,
0.6857123374938965,
-0.369035005569458,
-0.2409794181585312,
0.2753634452819824,
0.46875113248825073,
-0.04058235138654709,
0.3022032678127289,
0.12477254867553711,
0.4096544682979584,
0.8624477982521057,
-0.4525493085384369,
0.6202778220176697,
-0.17476403713226318,
0.2232070118188858,
1.1857911348342896,
0.29737839102745056,
1.052724838256836,
0.4455758333206177,
-0.24159003794193268,
-0.007673037238419056,
0.9064804315567017,
0.09485168755054474,
0.3312206268310547,
-0.01743866503238678,
-0.40798330307006836,
-0.5389159321784973,
-0.5886538624763489,
-0.25203782320022583,
0.5696275234222412,
0.3999442458152771,
-0.20404790341854095,
-0.05585188791155815,
-0.0011870503658428788,
-0.0725419893860817,
0.2634824812412262,
-0.40458211302757263,
0.4905598759651184,
-0.16341406106948853,
-0.8332789540290833,
0.387747585773468,
-0.12118183076381683,
0.307059109210968,
-0.18652963638305664,
-0.14420606195926666,
-0.4523359537124634,
-0.32429420948028564,
-0.3113885223865509,
-1.2290605306625366,
0.24888640642166138,
0.3534463047981262,
0.032987065613269806,
-0.26757848262786865,
0.4987391233444214,
-0.5769336819648743,
-0.42030438780784607,
-0.22540825605392456,
0.9279641509056091,
0.45659971237182617,
-0.001869303872808814,
-0.5738072991371155,
-0.3007868528366089,
0.22739370167255402,
0.038254644721746445,
0.04801251366734505,
0.29976382851600647,
0.21748022735118866,
0.9986832737922668,
0.2760375440120697,
0.027698010206222534,
0.258248507976532,
-0.41169819235801697,
0.7980585098266602,
-0.4312218129634857,
-0.22192880511283875,
-0.3191705048084259,
0.4199938476085663,
0.056531745940446854,
-0.4117167592048645,
0.43224477767944336,
0.5056691765785217,
0.8187242150306702,
-0.08081205189228058,
1.0273499488830566,
0.0812356248497963,
0.7804675102233887,
-0.429071307182312,
0.7327086329460144,
-0.5251129865646362,
0.08830520510673523,
0.11027511954307556,
-0.6114417910575867,
-0.025594713166356087,
0.5565155148506165,
-0.2623198628425598,
-0.06894653290510178,
0.3987443447113037,
0.702429473400116,
0.1279425323009491,
0.21489493548870087,
0.15108609199523926,
-0.10233711451292038,
0.14940692484378815,
0.9071140885353088,
0.9163693189620972,
-0.629410982131958,
0.9546976089477539,
-0.37655869126319885,
-0.1514592319726944,
0.10509435087442398,
-0.6245158314704895,
-1.3983354568481445,
-0.8495219349861145,
-0.37799638509750366,
-0.25105175375938416,
0.4220249652862549,
0.9288837909698486,
0.44820407032966614,
-0.7231879234313965,
0.20622113347053528,
0.39571312069892883,
-0.06637756526470184,
0.08627963066101074,
-0.14849047362804413,
0.45582467317581177,
0.0070828720927238464,
-0.8948489427566528,
0.18385912477970123,
-0.1428258717060089,
0.2996699810028076,
-0.2263258546590805,
0.16892583668231964,
-0.24913084506988525,
-0.20507219433784485,
0.2367352694272995,
0.3900996744632721,
-0.6031373739242554,
-0.4364723265171051,
0.2697911560535431,
-0.103545643389225,
0.010024592280387878,
0.42777112126350403,
-0.9466546177864075,
0.43283891677856445,
0.2807513177394867,
1.1661220788955688,
0.08894038945436478,
0.14811910688877106,
0.17733263969421387,
-0.6406726837158203,
0.03805907815694809,
0.32038983702659607,
0.07527259737253189,
0.46270614862442017,
-0.015906086191534996,
0.88377445936203,
0.02512296475470066,
-0.6194422841072083,
-0.6965674161911011,
0.01663937419652939,
-0.8865017890930176,
-0.0840887725353241,
0.8483545780181885,
-0.36425766348838806,
-0.14377008378505707,
-0.3147902190685272,
-0.3109246790409088,
0.5693323016166687,
-0.5138453841209412,
1.0286638736724854,
0.9134385585784912,
0.13956579566001892,
-0.4130168557167053,
-1.3343567848205566,
0.4931061863899231,
0.392005056142807,
-0.953445553779602,
-0.03447187319397926,
0.2861900329589844,
0.18765570223331451,
-0.2208719551563263,
0.33048778772354126,
0.206779345870018,
0.27386635541915894,
-0.18407589197158813,
-0.20425216853618622,
-0.46118420362472534,
-0.3422835171222687,
-0.2176991105079651,
0.4010567367076874,
-0.003697875887155533,
-0.1431962251663208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17183v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17183v1
|
Prevalent Frequency of Emotional and Physical Symptoms in Social Anxiety using Zero Shot Classification: An Observational Study
| 2024-04-26T06:28:51 | 2024-04-26T06:28:51 |
Muhammad Rizwan, Jure Demšar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Social anxiety represents a prevalent challenge in modern society, affecting
individuals across personal and professional spheres. Left unaddressed, this
condition can yield substantial negative consequences, impacting social
interactions and performance. Further understanding its diverse physical and
emotional symptoms becomes pivotal for comprehensive diagnosis and tailored
therapeutic interventions. This study analyze prevalence and frequency of
social anxiety symptoms taken from Mayo Clinic, exploring diverse human
experiences from utilizing a large Reddit dataset dedicated to this issue.
Leveraging these platforms, the research aims to extract insights and examine a
spectrum of physical and emotional symptoms linked to social anxiety disorder.
Upholding ethical considerations, the study maintains strict user anonymity
within the dataset. By employing a novel approach, the research utilizes
BART-based multi-label zero-shot classification to identify and measure symptom
prevalence and significance in the form of probability score for each symptom
under consideration. Results uncover distinctive patterns: "Trembling" emerges
as a prevalent physical symptom, while emotional symptoms like "Fear of being
judged negatively" exhibit high frequencies. These findings offer insights into
the multifaceted nature of social anxiety, aiding clinical practices and
interventions tailored to its diverse expressions.
|
[
-0.49784231185913086,
-0.9478615522384644,
0.6760342121124268,
0.20547710359096527,
-0.054250676184892654,
0.33363959193229675,
0.045692313462495804,
-0.8022577166557312,
0.9583617448806763,
0.03522123023867607,
-0.3396158516407013,
-0.7694823145866394,
-0.9589173793792725,
0.07223498076200485,
-0.47385528683662415,
0.9066842198371887,
-0.06845877319574356,
0.09046822786331177,
0.1784534454345703,
-0.24158033728599548,
-0.4279877245426178,
-0.757494330406189,
-0.5144921541213989,
-0.1398184895515442,
0.6513556838035583,
0.5594980716705322,
0.3080517649650574,
-0.0883125513792038,
0.4508726894855499,
0.11638256162405014,
0.14950048923492432,
-0.26033249497413635,
-0.6278970837593079,
0.16791608929634094,
0.1446247100830078,
-0.06973019987344742,
-0.48138126730918884,
-0.047825541347265244,
0.5647431015968323,
0.5584157109260559,
-0.19237525761127472,
0.45421507954597473,
0.01673644408583641,
0.272869735956192,
-0.6121407747268677,
-0.31125199794769287,
-0.3646850883960724,
0.3878207206726074,
-0.5635026693344116,
-0.19806036353111267,
-0.0368778295814991,
-0.07660280913114548,
-0.21884943544864655,
-0.5123233795166016,
0.34028249979019165,
-0.19075796008110046,
0.7108351588249207,
-0.034933947026729584,
-0.8590783476829529,
0.2378104031085968,
-0.8146224617958069,
0.4102471172809601,
0.2488889843225479,
0.2424836903810501,
0.14633560180664062,
0.1818333864212036,
0.003367797704413533,
-0.3657468855381012,
-0.38693252205848694,
0.004289145581424236,
0.16808398067951202,
0.08324149250984192,
-0.3802931308746338,
0.13837027549743652,
0.20363016426563263,
0.13304081559181213,
-0.7766773104667664,
-0.282048761844635,
-0.5809546113014221,
-0.08220057934522629,
0.7220247387886047,
0.24161078035831451,
0.3807544410228729,
0.09766355901956558,
-0.12008596956729889,
0.1950969249010086,
0.026218095794320107,
0.25654956698417664,
0.12484913319349289,
-0.01279523130506277,
-0.3328552544116974,
0.45922353863716125,
-0.21073824167251587,
0.2554764449596405,
0.08958116173744202,
0.07259036600589752,
0.21910737454891205,
0.31990131735801697,
0.07901643216609955,
0.17347979545593262,
0.6386081576347351,
0.8388385772705078,
0.23915719985961914,
-0.08216644823551178,
0.21740515530109406,
0.4535869061946869,
0.527297854423523,
-0.4697886109352112,
0.2274954617023468,
0.19522210955619812,
-0.4385679364204407,
-0.5599074959754944,
0.026947472244501114,
-1.0902172327041626,
-0.8435605764389038,
-0.17826595902442932,
0.29840803146362305,
-0.25216051936149597,
-0.47282400727272034,
-0.12445914000272751,
-0.5091655254364014,
0.08591365814208984,
0.2870855927467346,
-0.535879373550415,
0.6099027395248413,
0.45960888266563416,
0.9268468618392944,
0.017602089792490005,
-0.04897886514663696,
-0.06028043106198311,
-0.010669802315533161,
-0.4327619969844818,
0.687511146068573,
-0.48709505796432495,
-0.49331432580947876,
0.04973769560456276,
0.15439552068710327,
-0.3030712306499481,
-0.2818125784397125,
0.37081554532051086,
0.0956076830625534,
-0.38056108355522156,
-0.09672925621271133,
-0.051746711134910583,
0.14501461386680603,
0.4435172379016876,
-0.23748378455638885,
0.9887295961380005,
0.2523152530193329,
-0.5158410668373108,
0.4842900037765503,
-0.5378356575965881,
-0.40529483556747437,
0.17740307748317719,
-0.36419299244880676,
-0.20191912353038788,
0.40462931990623474,
-0.30799728631973267,
0.4616621732711792,
-0.0638868510723114,
0.03705795481801033,
-0.9751389622688293,
-0.5377163290977478,
0.5485303997993469,
-0.20018956065177917,
0.17215174436569214,
0.16529987752437592,
-0.13461892306804657,
-0.017850367352366447,
-0.8276758193969727,
-0.22776521742343903,
0.10758230835199356,
0.5372492074966431,
-0.5239339470863342,
-0.3243415653705597,
-0.059605907648801804,
0.1683296114206314,
0.09071256220340729,
-0.702478289604187,
-0.08164346218109131,
0.1540687531232834,
-0.015864893794059753,
0.6785048842430115,
1.0058280229568481,
0.045788511633872986,
-0.5608749985694885,
0.7836787104606628,
0.09098517149686813,
0.6210985779762268,
0.46518009901046753,
-0.8435062766075134,
-0.014004150405526161,
-0.5107951164245605,
-0.5802229046821594,
0.35603460669517517,
-0.06040468066930771,
0.09153713285923004,
-0.0428386889398098,
-0.7781330347061157,
-0.3980748653411865,
-0.03931368514895439,
0.09415558725595474,
0.5112618207931519,
0.233577698469162,
-0.05143025889992714,
-0.21550637483596802,
-0.5916900038719177,
-0.2754751145839691,
0.29498395323753357,
0.06805697828531265,
0.29857000708580017,
0.4841868281364441,
-0.37980911135673523,
0.4516388773918152,
-0.6169323325157166,
-0.41027456521987915,
0.10702402889728546,
0.6662487983703613,
-0.19461943209171295,
0.1719626784324646,
0.706472635269165,
-0.5259516835212708,
-0.7858498692512512,
0.22395415604114532,
-0.6134365200996399,
-0.1425325572490692,
0.030377760529518127,
-0.28716030716896057,
0.2512352764606476,
0.35868126153945923,
-0.3151320219039917,
0.7213605642318726,
0.12405919283628464,
-0.3284686803817749,
0.15110009908676147,
0.2541970908641815,
0.4998456835746765,
-0.7259950041770935,
0.23314005136489868,
0.12495722621679306,
0.15440411865711212,
-0.6299799084663391,
-0.2224912941455841,
-0.3843722641468048,
-0.3056264817714691,
-0.1306866556406021,
0.33427613973617554,
0.04990900307893753,
0.23833318054676056,
-0.016924848780035973,
-0.03130415827035904,
0.14010033011436462,
0.1599416881799698,
-0.07509876042604446,
-0.033814579248428345,
0.7719910144805908,
-0.4438513517379761,
0.22909794747829437,
-0.5067400932312012,
0.16544407606124878,
0.8439689874649048,
-0.3471207916736603,
0.025327762588858604,
-0.6467524766921997,
-0.05431409552693367,
-1.1517783403396606,
-0.541289210319519,
0.548742949962616,
-0.7610051035881042,
0.252354234457016,
0.18487456440925598,
0.03885155916213989,
-0.35125231742858887,
-0.6355836987495422,
0.2956055998802185,
0.3471151888370514,
0.24742937088012695,
0.39227578043937683,
0.39344117045402527,
-0.11401506513357162,
-0.5956950783729553,
-0.411871999502182,
-0.14962375164031982,
-0.509479820728302,
-0.2961418628692627,
0.04770790413022041,
0.0717368870973587,
-0.49755480885505676,
-0.13516993820667267,
-0.3527491092681885,
-0.11541274935007095,
0.21212977170944214,
0.7753961086273193,
-0.04343892261385918,
0.3862512409687042,
0.3480662405490875,
0.12599681317806244,
-0.0504494234919548,
0.032294295728206635,
0.3368324041366577,
0.5609567761421204,
-0.1302848607301712,
-0.4169543385505676,
-0.516714334487915,
0.6923715472221375,
0.7199041247367859,
0.24545395374298096,
0.7365449070930481,
0.6855487823486328,
-0.6382033228874207,
-0.03011927753686905,
-0.33182886242866516,
-0.15717189013957977,
-0.34071779251098633,
0.1146111711859703,
-0.3589588403701782,
-0.41748735308647156,
0.8137614130973816,
0.13531041145324707,
-0.326032817363739,
0.04490780457854271,
0.22059272229671478,
-0.28781089186668396,
0.9093393087387085,
0.3157983422279358,
-0.09505012631416321,
0.4534716010093689,
-0.049572356045246124,
0.20153294503688812,
-0.13337154686450958,
-0.14522206783294678,
-0.5996748208999634,
-0.466861367225647,
-0.6305404901504517,
-0.2602597177028656,
0.5487499237060547,
-0.2957991361618042,
-0.4368397891521454,
-0.41810014843940735,
-0.6299934983253479,
0.1856616735458374,
0.10843883454799652,
0.22193898260593414,
0.00856052991002798,
0.22667467594146729,
0.13062721490859985,
-0.33681485056877136,
-0.30864569544792175,
-0.35392308235168457,
1.194584608078003,
0.3231099247932434,
0.49682021141052246,
0.15595971047878265,
1.0755393505096436,
0.8382434844970703,
0.619640052318573,
-0.8560477495193481,
0.34509924054145813,
-0.1015099361538887,
-0.8692060112953186,
-0.23860953748226166,
-0.35889026522636414,
-1.1265993118286133,
-0.22595380246639252,
-0.5047683715820312,
-1.399889349937439,
0.4505298435688019,
-0.0022753786761313677,
-0.541458249092102,
-0.1502477526664734,
-0.5886639356613159,
0.8160530924797058,
-0.19540080428123474,
-0.4599035680294037,
-0.08042820543050766,
-0.7969164252281189,
0.5281562209129333,
-0.1355745792388916,
0.5789992213249207,
-0.35770174860954285,
0.3885749876499176,
0.6356094479560852,
-0.18594256043434143,
0.9123454093933105,
-0.3172191381454468,
0.3316134810447693,
0.2831728756427765,
-0.16677893698215485,
-0.03955487906932831,
0.14246557652950287,
0.11613636463880539,
0.3965121805667877,
0.2304011583328247,
-0.44463050365448,
-0.6671512722969055,
0.6022043824195862,
-1.0980031490325928,
0.0048044282011687756,
-0.7618843913078308,
-0.10512618720531464,
-0.3504463732242584,
-0.05630267411470413,
0.38562265038490295,
0.16319984197616577,
-0.3757534325122833,
0.16459210216999054,
0.4775732457637787,
-0.0708673894405365,
-0.1278357058763504,
0.6224570274353027,
-0.3332703709602356,
-0.5895193219184875,
0.8102205395698547,
0.6405924558639526,
0.04932323470711708,
0.22484435141086578,
0.16585597395896912,
-0.05823800340294838,
0.02155400440096855,
0.17490644752979279,
0.20381242036819458,
-0.30515170097351074,
0.12496808171272278,
-0.49142444133758545,
-0.2322559952735901,
-0.9967751502990723,
-0.45038318634033203,
-0.30705270171165466,
-0.2338901162147522,
-0.1087593361735344,
-0.3908764719963074,
0.54393070936203,
0.6086380481719971,
-0.22300326824188232,
0.46680620312690735,
-0.7353651523590088,
0.6066774725914001,
0.26056554913520813,
0.5391536355018616,
0.07608791440725327,
-0.14725050330162048,
-0.008934123441576958,
-0.037601787596940994,
-0.4442425072193146,
-1.2467702627182007,
0.3966245949268341,
0.1233179047703743,
0.2794743478298187,
1.0476733446121216,
0.7446576952934265,
0.8777666091918945,
0.16445641219615936,
0.5958011746406555,
0.3106718361377716,
-0.5997717976570129,
0.3392620384693146,
-0.32946792244911194,
-0.3339481055736542,
0.6190210580825806,
0.8202155828475952,
-0.8403739333152771,
-0.3464357852935791,
-0.8830921649932861,
-1.1768680810928345,
0.44934484362602234,
0.09742323309183121,
-0.10686745494604111,
-0.3163506090641022,
0.4923989772796631,
-0.1990201324224472,
0.12035326659679413,
-0.6410226225852966,
-0.44538992643356323,
-0.1006966382265091,
-0.2466733306646347,
0.004418176133185625,
-0.19602563977241516,
-0.6778051853179932,
-0.39009588956832886,
0.36825868487358093,
0.15306563675403595,
0.294334352016449,
0.32578137516975403,
0.04732775315642357,
-0.5299932360649109,
0.39695557951927185,
0.4402902126312256,
0.42347949743270874,
-0.7373787760734558,
0.19837625324726105,
0.10099271684885025,
-0.5928011536598206,
0.2788899540901184,
0.17641328275203705,
0.0488160066306591,
0.03700648248195648,
0.3097628355026245,
0.5830479860305786,
0.06418944895267487,
-0.42110151052474976,
0.5546718835830688,
-0.0371948666870594,
-0.3430664837360382,
-0.8634523153305054,
-0.0026801975909620523,
-0.3070451021194458,
0.11037806421518326,
0.3715369999408722,
0.12909404933452606,
0.41892218589782715,
-0.7338613271713257,
0.057099055498838425,
0.39855629205703735,
-0.448547899723053,
-0.4755065143108368,
0.4528842568397522,
0.022375911474227905,
-0.210438534617424,
0.3000364303588867,
-0.3766414523124695,
-0.06492256373167038,
0.594933807849884,
0.28995898365974426,
0.6719815731048584,
-0.1955719292163849,
0.638438880443573,
0.22630450129508972,
0.3570328950881958,
0.28680935502052307,
0.6080530285835266,
-0.03745778650045395,
-0.8053759336471558,
0.44813287258148193,
-0.6828984022140503,
-0.5531879663467407,
0.1765299141407013,
-1.0463200807571411,
0.11166176944971085,
-0.6898433566093445,
-0.7991548776626587,
0.030368737876415253,
0.03786535561084747,
-0.4550124704837799,
0.06410001218318939,
0.4547733962535858,
0.3569040596485138,
-1.3396308422088623,
0.4545210599899292,
1.040095329284668,
-0.12775124609470367,
-0.7067572474479675,
-0.03818366676568985,
0.5305078029632568,
-0.612521767616272,
0.03821954131126404,
0.346709668636322,
-0.35419338941574097,
-0.39858558773994446,
-0.606218695640564,
-0.5149953961372375,
0.937132716178894,
0.28581729531288147,
-0.10875307023525238,
0.5716776847839355,
0.44395291805267334,
0.8706148862838745,
-0.24131415784358978,
0.1286958009004593,
0.45419394969940186,
0.6491885781288147,
0.4942871332168579,
-0.47737181186676025,
-0.15923908352851868,
-0.5886248350143433,
-0.07418321818113327,
0.1813780665397644,
-0.7561396360397339,
0.5456199049949646,
0.07971075922250748,
-0.3191014230251312,
-0.33493539690971375,
-0.1896180361509323,
0.5129281878471375,
1.2002140283584595,
0.2291666716337204,
0.5703602433204651,
1.0194474458694458,
0.2022324949502945,
0.7864928245544434,
-0.6530539393424988,
-0.04453437402844429,
0.8389914631843567,
-0.6882975697517395,
0.7243396639823914,
0.29106026887893677,
-0.06627734005451202,
0.3237623870372772,
0.6280660033226013,
0.2980780005455017,
-0.08010858297348022,
0.04627876728773117,
-0.7792869210243225,
-0.2565038800239563,
-0.42729970812797546,
-0.5531991720199585,
0.5098044872283936,
0.620465874671936,
-0.17650021612644196,
-0.12234282493591309,
0.10563231259584427,
0.27190765738487244,
-0.21820594370365143,
-0.33527350425720215,
0.43415147066116333,
0.03634028509259224,
-0.03628646209836006,
0.21020856499671936,
-0.16433070600032806,
0.39383721351623535,
-0.7908397912979126,
-0.012565079145133495,
-0.2456018179655075,
0.04444316774606705,
-0.34203019738197327,
-0.5119492411613464,
0.5459865927696228,
0.12241026759147644,
-0.1833815723657608,
-0.221913680434227,
0.9728977680206299,
-0.05397557467222214,
-0.47039157152175903,
0.5546273589134216,
0.3081625699996948,
0.665679395198822,
-0.5025510191917419,
-0.16830949485301971,
-0.14160262048244476,
-0.3747141361236572,
-0.1975458562374115,
0.6105034947395325,
0.7921762466430664,
-0.311336487531662,
0.42147645354270935,
0.3110364079475403,
-0.02817237749695778,
0.13897331058979034,
0.03754999861121178,
0.43818625807762146,
-0.776470959186554,
-0.24610750377178192,
-0.6409830451011658,
0.6389498710632324,
-0.3116456866264343,
-0.4188897907733917,
0.5121049284934998,
0.1409977823495865,
0.11763856559991837,
-0.055876076221466064,
0.6264877319335938,
-0.07952433824539185,
0.3759967088699341,
0.39413022994995117,
0.9148150682449341,
-0.6949865221977234,
-0.10441945493221283,
-0.46032100915908813,
-0.35529953241348267,
-0.6111324429512024,
0.4786233603954315,
-0.33044904470443726,
-0.031070565804839134,
0.31410160660743713,
0.6386532187461853,
0.4438144862651825,
-0.2304389476776123,
0.3704553544521332,
0.3379265367984772,
-0.02035430446267128,
0.11495757848024368,
0.5015507340431213,
0.1133311465382576,
0.2636891007423401,
-0.34337764978408813,
-0.47860682010650635,
-0.36578330397605896,
-0.542327344417572,
-0.4350854754447937,
-0.4214411675930023,
-0.509245753288269,
-0.26586294174194336,
0.2429983913898468,
1.0724672079086304,
0.4703407287597656,
-0.49746012687683105,
-0.2722746729850769,
0.19473497569561005,
0.37843039631843567,
-0.4707607924938202,
-0.4384602904319763,
-0.17285646498203278,
0.04475095123052597,
-0.15970702469348907,
-0.1490139365196228,
0.253423810005188,
0.19986405968666077,
0.3953174352645874,
0.0559413805603981,
-0.08564239740371704,
-0.02625758945941925,
0.6109511256217957,
0.5032544732093811,
0.018777290359139442,
-0.14285382628440857,
0.13286921381950378,
0.04476020112633705,
-0.157619446516037,
0.4045509397983551,
-0.2393816113471985,
0.45593059062957764,
0.3190458118915558,
0.07144666463136673,
0.3436397314071655,
0.18806272745132446,
0.3287276029586792,
-0.8918493986129761,
-0.06575552374124527,
0.10808947682380676,
0.26255953311920166,
-0.006442639976739883,
-0.6705695986747742,
0.362990140914917,
0.6538529992103577,
-0.34681186079978943,
-0.8941890597343445,
0.009952668100595474,
-1.3407093286514282,
-0.17152373492717743,
0.886784017086029,
-0.19474250078201294,
-0.12043270468711853,
-0.32211315631866455,
-0.05430317670106888,
0.358822762966156,
-0.738065779209137,
1.0924136638641357,
0.7993388772010803,
-0.6668136715888977,
-0.302714079618454,
-0.500015139579773,
0.06709496676921844,
-0.01505904272198677,
-0.2822093069553375,
-0.18937771022319794,
0.5299884080886841,
0.3160083293914795,
0.17178109288215637,
0.8216098546981812,
-0.021161671727895737,
0.2973516583442688,
0.26851770281791687,
0.5103277564048767,
0.25634774565696716,
-0.4080826938152313,
-0.46961307525634766,
0.8653326630592346,
-0.0039373403415083885,
-0.3568587005138397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17178v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17178v2
|
A Unified Label-Aware Contrastive Learning Framework for Few-Shot Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-04-26T06:19:21 | 2024-05-08T10:37:24 |
Haojie Zhang, Yimeng Zhuang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Few-shot Named Entity Recognition (NER) aims to extract named entities using
only a limited number of labeled examples. Existing contrastive learning
methods often suffer from insufficient distinguishability in context vector
representation because they either solely rely on label semantics or completely
disregard them. To tackle this issue, we propose a unified label-aware
token-level contrastive learning framework. Our approach enriches the context
by utilizing label semantics as suffix prompts. Additionally, it simultaneously
optimizes context-context and context-label contrastive learning objectives to
enhance generalized discriminative contextual representations.Extensive
experiments on various traditional test domains (OntoNotes, CoNLL'03, WNUT'17,
GUM, I2B2) and the large-scale few-shot NER dataset (FEWNERD) demonstrate the
effectiveness of our approach. It outperforms prior state-of-the-art models by
a significant margin, achieving an average absolute gain of 7% in micro F1
scores across most scenarios. Further analysis reveals that our model benefits
from its powerful transfer capability and improved contextual representations.
|
[
-0.5222547054290771,
-0.34960079193115234,
0.24926617741584778,
-0.16341532766819,
-0.4072515368461609,
-0.07573609054088593,
0.08855932205915451,
-0.6767246723175049,
0.17510662972927094,
0.19024528563022614,
-0.40626800060272217,
-0.5937631726264954,
-0.6180008053779602,
0.34993046522140503,
-0.096808522939682,
1.169019341468811,
0.284673810005188,
0.13589085638523102,
0.11367477476596832,
-0.40681377053260803,
-0.3903263509273529,
-0.29808303713798523,
-1.089124321937561,
-0.4777437448501587,
0.7722620368003845,
0.5853362679481506,
0.08724052459001541,
0.34939464926719666,
0.6291223168373108,
0.19851239025592804,
-0.17255741357803345,
0.03429146111011505,
-0.5296405553817749,
-0.09894751012325287,
-0.29973486065864563,
-0.20545338094234467,
-0.28617897629737854,
-0.23709212243556976,
0.6742822527885437,
0.6318920850753784,
0.24200034141540527,
-0.05431675165891647,
0.1973443478345871,
0.2481551319360733,
-0.8567363619804382,
0.014265240170061588,
-0.8663541078567505,
0.15375672280788422,
-0.2598727345466614,
0.012529761530458927,
-0.48690566420555115,
0.26157712936401367,
0.2010437697172165,
-1.0444257259368896,
0.06486795097589493,
0.256320983171463,
1.0708222389221191,
0.29069191217422485,
-0.6130871176719666,
0.11198380589485168,
-0.4218732416629791,
0.7451543807983398,
-0.3567768633365631,
0.36240941286087036,
0.0076324292458593845,
0.42241382598876953,
-0.24281848967075348,
-0.8677724003791809,
-0.5395723581314087,
0.25590670108795166,
-0.20779338479042053,
0.2221374660730362,
-0.5614907145500183,
0.12349183112382889,
0.10364143550395966,
0.0073430160991847515,
-0.2945419251918793,
0.37480732798576355,
-0.2739647626876831,
-0.30251821875572205,
0.05620693415403366,
0.24732108414173126,
0.1686849296092987,
-0.3218441605567932,
-0.9369420409202576,
0.11280569434165955,
-0.7344263195991516,
-0.014646423049271107,
-0.1252518743276596,
0.7683000564575195,
-0.16435717046260834,
0.09652411192655563,
-0.15028046071529388,
0.5390209555625916,
0.19230230152606964,
-0.32453683018684387,
0.2570440471172333,
-0.11514865607023239,
-0.48598021268844604,
0.16310562193393707,
0.7546013593673706,
0.301248162984848,
-0.2518486976623535,
-0.33070996403694153,
-0.31641685962677,
-0.10299112647771835,
-0.1333705633878708,
-1.2310020923614502,
-0.40393099188804626,
-0.06739704310894012,
-0.12563619017601013,
-0.12826012074947357,
0.10549791157245636,
-0.8619869351387024,
-0.522807240486145,
-0.23007875680923462,
0.6168074011802673,
-0.5974165201187134,
-0.026443997398018837,
-0.28432199358940125,
-0.3035784065723419,
0.370429128408432,
0.4253886640071869,
-0.8717918395996094,
0.425510972738266,
0.6352443695068359,
0.6624940037727356,
-0.38228675723075867,
-0.05408252775669098,
-0.9170728325843811,
0.4032565951347351,
-0.2995094060897827,
0.9718570113182068,
-0.6517288684844971,
-0.46298763155937195,
-0.31613481044769287,
-0.02143114060163498,
0.1796470433473587,
-0.6178068518638611,
0.351664274930954,
-0.568813145160675,
-0.10781481117010117,
-0.2773028612136841,
-0.7167574167251587,
-0.17562933266162872,
0.41235414147377014,
-0.5465042591094971,
0.7910187840461731,
0.09107092022895813,
-0.9669345021247864,
0.8183957934379578,
-0.5107872486114502,
-0.2868454158306122,
0.422995001077652,
-0.5342925786972046,
-0.3218706548213959,
-0.03863617405295372,
0.17061521112918854,
0.5849733948707581,
-0.08758720010519028,
0.04123492166399956,
-0.12198472768068314,
-0.5322180390357971,
0.021853601559996605,
-0.2796951234340668,
0.5326977968215942,
-0.16150492429733276,
-0.23370729386806488,
-0.07223867624998093,
-0.9944255948066711,
-0.2558305561542511,
-0.11478564143180847,
-0.4291321337223053,
-0.6608459949493408,
-0.6949175000190735,
0.2010086476802826,
0.2580192983150482,
-0.4017113745212555,
-0.5408201217651367,
0.14760847389698029,
-0.3446219563484192,
-0.08064944297075272,
0.7621864676475525,
0.27443012595176697,
0.9401935338973999,
0.030360523611307144,
0.4094734787940979,
0.6804110407829285,
-0.31770753860473633,
-0.3252948522567749,
-0.2652578055858612,
-0.8384006023406982,
-0.8661320805549622,
0.7290133237838745,
0.39046427607536316,
-0.8622124195098877,
0.14844611287117004,
-0.31917062401771545,
-0.12971742451190948,
-0.295570433139801,
0.23473767936229706,
0.5377267003059387,
1.1061441898345947,
0.7990618348121643,
-0.10076423734426498,
-0.696458101272583,
-0.9088351130485535,
-0.049353230744600296,
0.14646145701408386,
-0.14694444835186005,
0.6145918369293213,
0.8795973062515259,
-0.45443737506866455,
0.9597609639167786,
-0.42413002252578735,
-0.8455346822738647,
-0.2673792243003845,
0.35489967465400696,
0.12655989825725555,
0.6089447736740112,
0.3705212473869324,
-0.782128095626831,
-0.3924473822116852,
0.01755833625793457,
-0.5735442638397217,
0.15198615193367004,
-0.08491051197052002,
-0.16220207512378693,
0.08702576905488968,
0.5456880927085876,
-0.2831937372684479,
0.3693835139274597,
0.03498737886548042,
-0.18307021260261536,
0.11086592823266983,
0.08617672324180603,
-0.15775300562381744,
-1.1886577606201172,
0.04026387259364128,
0.12855929136276245,
-0.312045693397522,
-0.5426573157310486,
-0.16067899763584137,
0.05330348387360573,
0.035783909261226654,
-0.9157772660255432,
1.1825082302093506,
-0.4613097906112671,
-0.03277456760406494,
-0.3158777058124542,
0.2756803333759308,
0.13754330575466156,
0.33012834191322327,
0.04502944275736809,
0.6600603461265564,
0.7740316390991211,
-0.9711862206459045,
-0.08306501805782318,
0.21026886999607086,
-0.1377088725566864,
1.0775922536849976,
-0.463038831949234,
0.005922400858253241,
-0.39908847212791443,
0.5024220943450928,
-0.8951958417892456,
-0.5060261487960815,
0.48716485500335693,
-0.3117543160915375,
0.7597495913505554,
-0.32751691341400146,
-0.20673830807209015,
0.0698612779378891,
-0.07036948949098587,
0.40217161178588867,
0.35758429765701294,
-0.9144564867019653,
0.7703497409820557,
0.19127050042152405,
0.1630660444498062,
-0.6495059728622437,
-0.8789104223251343,
-0.11424419283866882,
-0.3204168677330017,
-0.08265523612499237,
0.7901686429977417,
0.2218359410762787,
-0.0016759276622906327,
0.15652617812156677,
-0.5052388906478882,
-0.22456422448158264,
0.000771189748775214,
0.38470545411109924,
0.2810586392879486,
-0.35249626636505127,
0.529651403427124,
-0.09280575811862946,
-0.5492639541625977,
-0.4002154767513275,
-0.27626878023147583,
0.10853573679924011,
-0.20495805144309998,
0.10673507302999496,
-0.5411938428878784,
0.2269328236579895,
-0.09126698970794678,
-0.003313246415928006,
0.6819908022880554,
0.905471682548523,
-0.5945714712142944,
-0.24538536369800568,
-0.2254081666469574,
-0.3159673511981964,
-0.412007600069046,
0.04159325361251831,
-0.77564537525177,
-1.0209318399429321,
0.4547763466835022,
-0.44602662324905396,
-0.22705356776714325,
0.5614553689956665,
-0.0360332652926445,
-0.17202305793762207,
0.5781068205833435,
0.8953987956047058,
-0.1625489890575409,
0.36270421743392944,
-0.2763341963291168,
0.02146879769861698,
-1.1241164207458496,
-0.40783077478408813,
-0.313157856464386,
-0.4073203504085541,
-0.5320413708686829,
-0.363601952791214,
0.18721644580364227,
0.3993509113788605,
-0.3382505476474762,
0.3176691234111786,
-0.441093385219574,
0.9744903445243835,
0.31464260816574097,
0.0888814926147461,
0.20756998658180237,
-0.06390293687582016,
-0.5463545918464661,
-0.1879807561635971,
-0.5337908864021301,
-0.44289931654930115,
0.7577103972434998,
0.08947031199932098,
0.5485694408416748,
0.19535325467586517,
1.3471571207046509,
0.0119098462164402,
0.5606100559234619,
-0.8867696523666382,
0.5494679808616638,
-0.20503173768520355,
-0.7115427255630493,
-0.16365107893943787,
-0.32331612706184387,
-1.0085710287094116,
0.4943871796131134,
-0.46680063009262085,
-0.9972789883613586,
0.4387277364730835,
-0.019113881513476372,
-0.6067945957183838,
0.24897632002830505,
-0.4290164113044739,
0.9018486738204956,
0.12460265308618546,
-0.45890820026397705,
0.34304291009902954,
-0.8176035284996033,
0.3980116546154022,
-0.03892859071493149,
0.0680558830499649,
-0.21670842170715332,
-0.43183591961860657,
0.7439004778862,
-0.029383443295955658,
0.8365293145179749,
-0.09525039792060852,
0.3573817014694214,
0.09366949647665024,
-0.06410602480173111,
0.23865871131420135,
0.20563878118991852,
-0.04559646174311638,
-0.0011840206570923328,
-0.36679425835609436,
-0.4502590596675873,
-0.4340115487575531,
0.737757682800293,
-0.4891461730003357,
-0.26356375217437744,
-0.5074752569198608,
-0.09806057065725327,
-0.005482024978846312,
0.48481014370918274,
0.5327454805374146,
0.4118867814540863,
-0.5417558550834656,
0.1661260575056076,
0.745975911617279,
0.02061881497502327,
0.5358055233955383,
0.37089264392852783,
-0.19908948242664337,
-0.5255663990974426,
1.0194138288497925,
-0.17808224260807037,
-0.19311513006687164,
0.6332319378852844,
0.1236191987991333,
-0.16786769032478333,
-0.24430492520332336,
-0.32982751727104187,
0.05916306748986244,
-1.1399478912353516,
-0.7002996802330017,
-0.6408462524414062,
0.1934043914079666,
-0.21502557396888733,
-0.3526984453201294,
-0.21532592177391052,
-0.11430256068706512,
-0.8192383050918579,
-0.2577604055404663,
0.09377408027648926,
0.5301771759986877,
-0.15282614529132843,
0.4175718128681183,
-0.6117873787879944,
0.7116233110427856,
0.46949800848960876,
0.12277499586343765,
-0.18238845467567444,
-0.6632264852523804,
0.3785141408443451,
-0.36276695132255554,
-0.17075905203819275,
-0.8152737021446228,
0.16356375813484192,
0.46288809180259705,
0.5110666751861572,
0.7259867191314697,
0.17980121076107025,
0.8057019710540771,
-0.5154255628585815,
0.5287991762161255,
0.5815814733505249,
-0.90110844373703,
0.529733419418335,
0.03901815041899681,
0.31956946849823,
1.0444270372390747,
0.7162894606590271,
-0.142057865858078,
0.10963243991136551,
-0.68930983543396,
-0.9235191345214844,
0.6283664107322693,
-0.08250810205936432,
0.18762268126010895,
-0.25453317165374756,
0.16431604325771332,
0.25134462118148804,
-0.10519998520612717,
-0.8875671625137329,
-0.34361839294433594,
0.08661892265081406,
0.013943415135145187,
0.15883079171180725,
-0.08599533885717392,
-0.013056427240371704,
-0.31445398926734924,
0.7496235966682434,
-0.3698371946811676,
0.0614776611328125,
0.20251713693141937,
-0.20707102119922638,
0.3110380172729492,
0.7075027823448181,
0.33836615085601807,
0.21002760529518127,
-0.11567695438861847,
0.4790577292442322,
0.4528341293334961,
-0.0080253379419446,
0.28474679589271545,
0.26610124111175537,
-0.27852410078048706,
0.2170310914516449,
0.13638073205947876,
0.8392224907875061,
0.8386319875717163,
-0.2969553768634796,
0.6980206966400146,
0.06812820583581924,
0.002130169654265046,
0.07312090694904327,
-0.009484240785241127,
0.08033158630132675,
0.2911718785762787,
0.40864649415016174,
0.19095675647258759,
0.40604135394096375,
-0.34170565009117126,
0.4404621720314026,
0.39744463562965393,
-0.7323233485221863,
-0.05529869347810745,
0.5049450993537903,
0.3452845811843872,
0.0829378217458725,
0.5006386637687683,
-0.6948308944702148,
-0.3923204243183136,
0.5293585062026978,
0.8103060126304626,
0.6579755544662476,
-0.06220249459147453,
0.2551935911178589,
0.634364128112793,
0.03729977831244469,
0.09981488436460495,
0.023799188435077667,
-0.23459704220294952,
-0.6717720627784729,
0.1752668023109436,
-0.540683388710022,
-0.4257849454879761,
0.1594027429819107,
-0.5299065709114075,
0.48987704515457153,
-0.5636679530143738,
-0.26573386788368225,
0.5384265184402466,
-0.11443452537059784,
-0.9655190110206604,
0.3668985962867737,
0.3436412811279297,
0.7145065069198608,
-0.6271655559539795,
0.6022511720657349,
0.8607486486434937,
-0.8305853009223938,
-0.7053699493408203,
0.03785672411322594,
0.1397358477115631,
-0.455422043800354,
1.157278060913086,
0.7315810918807983,
-0.37882038950920105,
0.23553580045700073,
-0.5303884744644165,
-0.5918487310409546,
1.225797176361084,
0.1898355334997177,
-0.5856373906135559,
0.04506619647145271,
-0.20928266644477844,
0.37670573592185974,
-0.7518863081932068,
0.2594008147716522,
0.48201945424079895,
0.3800068497657776,
0.5253745317459106,
-0.27497735619544983,
0.11417312175035477,
0.17530235648155212,
0.12329647690057755,
0.2146596610546112,
-0.3681359589099884,
0.6009326577186584,
-0.5338302850723267,
-0.5838119983673096,
0.017266012728214264,
0.9102973341941833,
0.3392338752746582,
0.5842682719230652,
0.23973838984966278,
0.5299621224403381,
0.9928391575813293,
-0.13398142158985138,
0.9340254664421082,
0.06770392507314682,
0.12943866848945618,
1.4057902097702026,
-0.29132315516471863,
1.0562859773635864,
0.6845687031745911,
0.08919823914766312,
0.5497959852218628,
0.4778912663459778,
-0.15221507847309113,
0.6584096550941467,
0.3557091951370239,
-0.4987022578716278,
-0.42734044790267944,
-0.5651423931121826,
-0.08128676563501358,
0.5725975036621094,
0.26229366660118103,
-0.27555760741233826,
-0.41500264406204224,
0.18074141442775726,
-0.032266899943351746,
-0.30744579434394836,
-0.4733242392539978,
1.0476659536361694,
0.3814711272716522,
-0.17625875771045685,
0.4253947138786316,
-0.07672403752803802,
1.051978588104248,
-0.2813422381877899,
-0.18663688004016876,
-0.2951565980911255,
0.25803670287132263,
-0.43455880880355835,
-0.41746148467063904,
-0.12054753303527832,
0.004630873445421457,
-0.17991012334823608,
0.2730177640914917,
0.9974594712257385,
-0.41064679622650146,
-0.3579724431037903,
0.3105394244194031,
0.3847942650318146,
0.2965223491191864,
0.115045927464962,
-0.5382528305053711,
-0.19283142685890198,
-0.418990820646286,
0.072625070810318,
0.4910716414451599,
0.39070117473602295,
0.22152942419052124,
0.4014047682285309,
0.35579168796539307,
-0.33134669065475464,
-0.08970332145690918,
0.14532354474067688,
0.8900777697563171,
-0.6424440741539001,
-0.39546045660972595,
-0.7498586773872375,
0.6166369915008545,
-0.15632933378219604,
-0.5433998703956604,
0.3553406596183777,
0.5837094187736511,
0.91105717420578,
-0.029282977804541588,
0.451978862285614,
0.22163358330726624,
0.2038727104663849,
-0.5045302510261536,
0.3728799521923065,
-0.6934930682182312,
0.18586108088493347,
-0.3509632647037506,
-0.8104788064956665,
-0.7331671118736267,
0.37446752190589905,
-0.01943402737379074,
-0.10907881706953049,
0.6301481127738953,
0.6025845408439636,
-0.37643522024154663,
-0.274692565202713,
0.5821104645729065,
-0.10633806884288788,
0.06956812739372253,
0.68332439661026,
0.7052888870239258,
-0.7739742398262024,
0.6673069596290588,
-0.20942506194114685,
0.07957936823368073,
-0.2766246795654297,
-1.115964651107788,
-0.9641591310501099,
-0.2139376848936081,
-0.6595755219459534,
0.00046109111281111836,
0.012800362892448902,
0.9676340818405151,
0.7099485397338867,
-0.9207755327224731,
0.5209397077560425,
-0.1901315599679947,
0.20121708512306213,
0.10570088028907776,
-0.2497563511133194,
0.22706244885921478,
-0.35686194896698,
-0.6608008742332458,
0.5383633971214294,
0.5059204697608948,
0.36018288135528564,
0.26761147379875183,
-0.11439195275306702,
-0.15490899980068207,
-0.059165239334106445,
0.5122119188308716,
0.4990123510360718,
-0.8695803880691528,
-0.22431223094463348,
-0.186968132853508,
-0.49762094020843506,
0.2736624777317047,
0.5408433675765991,
-1.0355727672576904,
0.4121784269809723,
0.35788577795028687,
0.8964846134185791,
0.37268954515457153,
0.02956409379839897,
-0.09747550636529922,
-1.1657907962799072,
0.16250766813755035,
0.2615441679954529,
0.42964687943458557,
0.6074990630149841,
-0.14751622080802917,
0.4790600538253784,
0.2463703453540802,
-0.12524937093257904,
-0.5712820887565613,
0.23314553499221802,
-1.0849403142929077,
-0.22867070138454437,
1.1361663341522217,
-0.3048762381076813,
-0.014497952535748482,
-0.04122030362486839,
-0.13708682358264923,
0.2420358806848526,
-0.6377162933349609,
0.11959967762231827,
0.3749944567680359,
-0.29895299673080444,
-0.24238567054271698,
-0.1270703226327896,
0.47152677178382874,
0.08147058635950089,
-0.9183022975921631,
-0.4920302927494049,
0.5185197591781616,
0.4495084881782532,
0.23714572191238403,
0.7721652984619141,
0.09668733179569244,
0.27844008803367615,
0.24996304512023926,
-0.06775889545679092,
-0.08254298567771912,
-0.64189213514328,
-0.7550846934318542,
0.1868876814842224,
-0.15607689321041107,
-0.35497456789016724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01577v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01577v1
|
HateTinyLLM : Hate Speech Detection Using Tiny Large Language Models
| 2024-04-26T05:29:35 | 2024-04-26T05:29:35 |
Tanmay Sen, Ansuman Das, Mrinmay Sen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Hate speech encompasses verbal, written, or behavioral communication that
targets derogatory or discriminatory language against individuals or groups
based on sensitive characteristics. Automated hate speech detection plays a
crucial role in curbing its propagation, especially across social media
platforms. Various methods, including recent advancements in deep learning,
have been devised to address this challenge. In this study, we introduce
HateTinyLLM, a novel framework based on fine-tuned decoder-only tiny large
language models (tinyLLMs) for efficient hate speech detection. Our
experimental findings demonstrate that the fine-tuned HateTinyLLM outperforms
the pretrained mixtral-7b model by a significant margin. We explored various
tiny LLMs, including PY007/TinyLlama-1.1B-step-50K-105b, Microsoft/phi-2, and
facebook/opt-1.3b, and fine-tuned them using LoRA and adapter methods. Our
observations indicate that all LoRA-based fine-tuned models achieved over 80\%
accuracy.
|
[
-0.5264086127281189,
-1.1725882291793823,
0.15279725193977356,
-0.13116295635700226,
-0.2957991659641266,
0.13678303360939026,
-0.5077121257781982,
-0.7139062881469727,
0.3570607304573059,
0.39663878083229065,
-0.45303255319595337,
-0.545953631401062,
-0.6279628276824951,
-0.12624289095401764,
-0.5035396814346313,
0.9534341096878052,
0.6200865507125854,
0.2956242859363556,
0.678490161895752,
-0.3134705722332001,
-0.06476854532957077,
-0.3086872696876526,
-0.8637955188751221,
-0.33264732360839844,
1.169326663017273,
0.4765847325325012,
0.6991366147994995,
0.589999258518219,
0.4403342604637146,
0.15738032758235931,
-0.42176398634910583,
0.18362081050872803,
-0.586023211479187,
0.19936327636241913,
-0.07174959033727646,
-0.31794407963752747,
-0.4085403382778168,
-0.10917021334171295,
0.5004064440727234,
0.2946338653564453,
-0.11161097884178162,
0.33816754817962646,
0.012681156396865845,
0.20662260055541992,
-0.39665549993515015,
-0.34726187586784363,
-1.1130443811416626,
0.09078148007392883,
-0.4233768880367279,
0.2608415186405182,
-0.33385327458381653,
-0.40460965037345886,
-0.27201128005981445,
-0.06370792537927628,
0.18418414890766144,
0.2511261999607086,
0.1938476711511612,
0.31666553020477295,
-0.17086642980575562,
-0.3786625862121582,
-0.6048511862754822,
0.7280767560005188,
-1.1327015161514282,
0.3530806303024292,
0.2342204749584198,
0.521844744682312,
-0.10291958600282669,
-0.4294000566005707,
-0.7549437880516052,
-0.38583904504776,
0.15305660665035248,
-0.4400879740715027,
-0.4044232964515686,
0.14161011576652527,
0.265121191740036,
0.20821335911750793,
-0.6282800436019897,
0.9405255913734436,
-0.49175676703453064,
-0.2049589306116104,
0.7988551259040833,
0.31707051396369934,
0.28237050771713257,
-0.12819120287895203,
-0.012074767611920834,
0.3177695870399475,
-0.3810731768608093,
-0.41721653938293457,
0.46487390995025635,
1.0000238418579102,
-0.15889112651348114,
0.35023418068885803,
-0.012480641715228558,
0.7236605286598206,
0.13740141689777374,
-0.13257983326911926,
0.020959975197911263,
0.39902061223983765,
-0.3461771607398987,
0.25507140159606934,
0.6495484709739685,
0.1770002245903015,
0.37948182225227356,
-0.14557281136512756,
-0.1618812531232834,
0.4817178249359131,
0.17044296860694885,
-0.8075547218322754,
-0.26861807703971863,
0.04637902230024338,
-0.5272349715232849,
-0.7755336761474609,
-0.8070344924926758,
-0.771446704864502,
-0.9396377205848694,
-0.20805002748966217,
0.3196798861026764,
-0.39422935247421265,
-0.2978939414024353,
-0.32666003704071045,
0.009781810455024242,
0.10969804972410202,
0.38677942752838135,
-0.7534327507019043,
0.1738259643316269,
0.5967965126037598,
0.8073567748069763,
-0.5453122854232788,
-0.100907102227211,
-0.9166692495346069,
-0.24196432530879974,
-0.2838101387023926,
0.5722065567970276,
-0.509189784526825,
0.06776408106088638,
-0.03838169947266579,
-0.38065195083618164,
0.14044062793254852,
-0.839276134967804,
0.5843064188957214,
-0.618736207485199,
-0.15767978131771088,
0.38273656368255615,
-0.5768241286277771,
-0.18351750075817108,
0.37548863887786865,
-0.5984644293785095,
0.6474413275718689,
0.16899290680885315,
-0.5866259336471558,
0.29340657591819763,
-0.6871352195739746,
-0.3266667425632477,
0.2761189341545105,
-0.046803154051303864,
-0.5594074726104736,
0.28609785437583923,
-0.16071873903274536,
0.4398067891597748,
-0.2969081401824951,
0.09495007991790771,
-0.8634033203125,
-0.26361581683158875,
0.12508906424045563,
-0.43915554881095886,
0.8961512446403503,
0.5367879271507263,
-0.5326094627380371,
0.5391187071800232,
-0.7542242407798767,
0.038786567747592926,
0.21888837218284607,
-0.17887388169765472,
-0.41186633706092834,
-0.2938116788864136,
0.45367398858070374,
0.45491454005241394,
-0.04236619174480438,
-0.9272401928901672,
-0.19276490807533264,
-0.5253477096557617,
0.39457187056541443,
0.9099534153938293,
-0.3182758688926697,
0.01665777899324894,
-0.29549700021743774,
0.48060131072998047,
0.10625997930765152,
0.22477100789546967,
0.614736795425415,
-0.31037840247154236,
-0.6797585487365723,
-0.2174631804227829,
0.03496420755982399,
0.16542993485927582,
-0.4157215654850006,
0.1461942046880722,
0.11455737054347992,
-0.7870327234268188,
-0.482745885848999,
0.35518622398376465,
0.25830474495887756,
0.3319684863090515,
0.3914666473865509,
0.24278303980827332,
-0.9143572449684143,
-0.922127902507782,
-0.6025883555412292,
0.009085975587368011,
0.31718316674232483,
0.3505702614784241,
0.3815009295940399,
-0.33281832933425903,
0.5823999643325806,
-0.258624404668808,
-0.4901636242866516,
-0.5741168856620789,
-0.12611423432826996,
0.1165267825126648,
0.32289308309555054,
0.748336672782898,
-0.8715599179267883,
-0.8435127139091492,
-0.21511882543563843,
-0.25474175810813904,
-0.2492365539073944,
0.43649303913116455,
0.22766664624214172,
0.3045693039894104,
0.4878125488758087,
-0.1801188439130783,
0.48865851759910583,
0.6471872329711914,
-0.5609332323074341,
0.6117281317710876,
0.37028372287750244,
-0.2168782353401184,
-0.8029897212982178,
-0.22786833345890045,
-0.06405338644981384,
-0.5136034488677979,
-0.925186038017273,
0.1425824612379074,
-0.24570268392562866,
-0.10078880935907364,
-0.7987004518508911,
0.6076642870903015,
0.18322253227233887,
0.2874625027179718,
-0.5751884579658508,
0.1549665629863739,
-0.58951336145401,
0.41395303606987,
-0.1913442760705948,
0.38339242339134216,
0.12773825228214264,
-0.5388841032981873,
0.6449382901191711,
-0.08947308361530304,
-0.22349461913108826,
0.7901301980018616,
-0.3642790913581848,
0.22776468098163605,
0.07520774751901627,
-0.0083617577329278,
-0.9322304129600525,
-0.13904055953025818,
0.4770767390727997,
-0.40486016869544983,
-0.018000813201069832,
-0.2555905878543854,
-0.47352588176727295,
-0.5323957800865173,
-0.30243608355522156,
0.440603643655777,
0.45500922203063965,
-0.5879279971122742,
0.5308834314346313,
0.5989086627960205,
0.019694045186042786,
-0.07032493501901627,
-0.8577734231948853,
-0.0851653516292572,
-0.6296674013137817,
-0.36577677726745605,
-0.094408318400383,
-0.31264063715934753,
-0.4441208839416504,
-0.3054811358451843,
0.09282828122377396,
-0.2448219507932663,
0.11486636102199554,
0.41369542479515076,
-0.07956841588020325,
-0.36770063638687134,
-0.030740676447749138,
-0.12987883388996124,
0.2194090038537979,
-0.09679604321718216,
-0.299568235874176,
0.8342419862747192,
0.02741681970655918,
-0.028640231117606163,
-0.30017372965812683,
0.22536718845367432,
0.7552618384361267,
0.34393608570098877,
0.6187871098518372,
1.0794979333877563,
-0.49848484992980957,
-0.6589115858078003,
-0.6126797795295715,
-0.20318487286567688,
-0.43517693877220154,
0.30923470854759216,
0.042999450117349625,
-1.3280102014541626,
0.4270278513431549,
0.4552282691001892,
-0.012159992009401321,
0.34145453572273254,
0.7690585851669312,
0.08577700704336166,
0.8914569020271301,
0.40760719776153564,
-0.3408783972263336,
0.4438202977180481,
0.14485546946525574,
0.15778036415576935,
-0.5910831689834595,
0.1283758580684662,
-0.47378021478652954,
-0.5496995449066162,
-0.3800435960292816,
-0.5033990144729614,
0.221504807472229,
-0.2270335853099823,
-0.5165454745292664,
0.298534631729126,
-0.457123726606369,
0.4725239872932434,
0.3290556073188782,
0.11837799102067947,
0.2636916935443878,
0.2818414866924286,
-0.03075494058430195,
-0.33667561411857605,
-0.6284800171852112,
-0.1466439664363861,
1.094419002532959,
0.4245510697364807,
0.7495071887969971,
0.30948829650878906,
0.5746222138404846,
0.8914858102798462,
0.4709906280040741,
-0.9627254009246826,
0.5238327980041504,
-0.5635149478912354,
-0.7820502519607544,
-0.3139141798019409,
-0.39608675241470337,
-0.5718210339546204,
0.31971171498298645,
0.05144767463207245,
-0.9024271368980408,
-0.06510159373283386,
0.4739413261413574,
-0.5842866897583008,
0.7789599895477295,
-0.34802961349487305,
0.6989538669586182,
-0.09106720238924026,
-0.23976440727710724,
-0.4878811836242676,
-0.20954550802707672,
0.4192509949207306,
-0.3413850963115692,
0.29555872082710266,
-0.4206697940826416,
0.16607330739498138,
1.0024837255477905,
-0.4003773033618927,
0.9484296441078186,
-0.4362778067588806,
-0.3607921898365021,
0.13640478253364563,
0.3088715970516205,
0.5625990629196167,
-0.3481822907924652,
-0.31459033489227295,
0.24250458180904388,
-0.24183516204357147,
-0.14647425711154938,
-0.41627657413482666,
0.8762818574905396,
-0.4333384931087494,
-0.2524721026420593,
-0.06892036646604538,
-0.589989423751831,
-0.16012971103191376,
0.41884714365005493,
0.2167535275220871,
0.22154207527637482,
-0.29584312438964844,
0.19214139878749847,
0.6337636709213257,
-0.17804816365242004,
0.25262001156806946,
0.7898869514465332,
-0.6337020397186279,
-0.25819364190101624,
1.0491803884506226,
0.24756163358688354,
0.1745610535144806,
0.041633836925029755,
0.37921491265296936,
-0.23267975449562073,
-0.8669288754463196,
-0.28989389538764954,
0.14603136479854584,
-0.4588620662689209,
-0.38296937942504883,
-0.7736284732818604,
-0.2630448639392853,
-0.4831298887729645,
-0.0629323348402977,
-0.38416555523872375,
-0.2636062502861023,
-0.18894654512405396,
0.31467410922050476,
0.37121814489364624,
0.7865508198738098,
-0.4667094945907593,
0.4885287582874298,
-0.2748829126358032,
0.7816956043243408,
0.3303302228450775,
0.4063195586204529,
0.2244020700454712,
-1.1657241582870483,
-0.20221620798110962,
0.28859859704971313,
0.1378956437110901,
-0.6422138214111328,
0.5899931788444519,
0.022086411714553833,
0.027902308851480484,
0.30515652894973755,
0.27517369389533997,
0.581529974937439,
-0.49648112058639526,
0.5152355432510376,
0.09089773893356323,
-0.5713353157043457,
0.4906904101371765,
-0.40586861968040466,
0.039235495030879974,
0.3638322651386261,
0.181815966963768,
-0.6105583906173706,
-0.4450364410877228,
-0.6415987610816956,
-0.47216203808784485,
0.8068395256996155,
0.10851961374282837,
-0.02544134482741356,
0.048127952963113785,
-0.1152658760547638,
-0.10066834092140198,
0.19470156729221344,
-0.7262526154518127,
-0.42186716198921204,
0.18706363439559937,
-0.3855791389942169,
-0.03712641820311546,
-0.5749231576919556,
-0.15158313512802124,
-0.3612043559551239,
0.6902900338172913,
0.07036399841308594,
-0.062351617962121964,
-0.38869860768318176,
-0.3669617176055908,
-0.14781373739242554,
0.3336518704891205,
0.7057220339775085,
0.28968697786331177,
-0.2655263841152191,
0.013033968396484852,
0.30641695857048035,
-0.5033940076828003,
0.180648073554039,
-0.01132894866168499,
-0.29128316044807434,
0.2892681956291199,
0.10596299171447754,
0.7645660042762756,
0.010035421699285507,
-0.6745957732200623,
0.42253467440605164,
-0.09120460599660873,
-0.06252492964267731,
-0.5333468914031982,
0.3107772171497345,
-0.0926186665892601,
0.4773751497268677,
0.18697786331176758,
-0.15516497194766998,
0.1379214972257614,
-0.04459904134273529,
0.2599828839302063,
0.46576377749443054,
-0.6274064183235168,
-0.09967385977506638,
0.6475787162780762,
0.059286318719387054,
-0.5930490493774414,
0.21195846796035767,
-0.17642223834991455,
-0.5316480994224548,
0.5580804944038391,
0.7532707452774048,
0.7332829833030701,
-0.3892279863357544,
0.20334836840629578,
0.02586240880191326,
0.27345138788223267,
0.5631402134895325,
0.07380157709121704,
-0.01815859042108059,
-0.7456791996955872,
-0.007354820147156715,
-1.0014164447784424,
-0.23375661671161652,
0.6643832921981812,
-0.46922701597213745,
0.1193181499838829,
-0.9478760361671448,
0.06005851924419403,
0.5263699889183044,
0.09430226683616638,
-0.5461668968200684,
0.17164763808250427,
0.7247833013534546,
1.0228251218795776,
-0.6467193961143494,
0.7726369500160217,
0.41704750061035156,
0.04438755661249161,
-0.836501955986023,
-0.24239802360534668,
0.574469804763794,
-1.063701868057251,
0.8792584538459778,
0.1211586594581604,
-0.42021527886390686,
0.33557671308517456,
-0.7469117045402527,
-0.4245557188987732,
0.326904833316803,
0.28724586963653564,
-0.8342759013175964,
0.10486944764852524,
0.22231243550777435,
0.6554995179176331,
-0.5955906510353088,
-0.09990750253200531,
0.6878868341445923,
0.25089597702026367,
-0.12641377747058868,
-0.8015222549438477,
-0.07634562999010086,
-0.0036471060011535883,
0.040457796305418015,
0.12442290782928467,
-0.6398018598556519,
0.8111949563026428,
0.010475615039467812,
0.11672867834568024,
0.0774216577410698,
0.4620830714702606,
0.09596003592014313,
0.258029580116272,
0.7029985785484314,
0.5192499756813049,
0.6058669090270996,
0.2830270826816559,
0.4807192385196686,
0.0017323339125141501,
0.2675679624080658,
1.4241160154342651,
-0.09135853499174118,
0.72000652551651,
0.18371464312076569,
-0.01435128878802061,
0.2777934968471527,
0.2660272717475891,
-0.043892838060855865,
0.10589918494224548,
0.49157291650772095,
-0.37509721517562866,
-0.3438740074634552,
-0.44449639320373535,
-0.269975483417511,
0.6932064294815063,
0.6469990611076355,
-0.4975436329841614,
-0.42439004778862,
0.512788712978363,
0.16844837367534637,
0.18486188352108002,
-0.72723388671875,
0.7310953140258789,
0.13350218534469604,
0.027419203892350197,
0.8753759860992432,
0.18910269439220428,
1.1519886255264282,
-0.46109363436698914,
0.18847015500068665,
-0.15024319291114807,
0.4398808479309082,
-0.2565048635005951,
-0.4929923713207245,
0.3690849542617798,
0.3276951313018799,
-0.23669016361236572,
0.27975791692733765,
0.8499884009361267,
-0.6090409159660339,
-0.2260681539773941,
0.4549919366836548,
0.05087605491280556,
0.09923835843801498,
-0.4511924982070923,
-0.90700364112854,
0.5431745648384094,
0.14779049158096313,
0.11024726927280426,
0.296638548374176,
0.17383679747581482,
0.14851002395153046,
0.6304832696914673,
0.6415167450904846,
0.4379781484603882,
0.24321798980236053,
0.21350698173046112,
0.8061258792877197,
-0.7788559794425964,
-0.58713698387146,
-1.1412501335144043,
-0.03658480569720268,
-0.17891770601272583,
-0.1604139655828476,
0.9312552809715271,
0.5623251795768738,
0.820198118686676,
-0.014930191449820995,
0.728291392326355,
-0.1339024156332016,
1.1229541301727295,
-0.19320404529571533,
0.8808451294898987,
-0.5824687480926514,
-0.008587433956563473,
-0.43092289566993713,
-0.6940465569496155,
-0.6665213704109192,
0.48820215463638306,
-0.4262416958808899,
-0.24474596977233887,
0.2566835880279541,
0.8664987683296204,
-0.3257041275501251,
-0.03730645775794983,
0.7172666192054749,
0.6935471296310425,
0.4977172911167145,
0.48950740694999695,
0.6449610590934753,
-0.3267449736595154,
0.6029889583587646,
-0.23956258594989777,
0.09826387465000153,
-0.6774423718452454,
-0.46458402276039124,
-1.080578088760376,
-0.12739355862140656,
-0.315417617559433,
-0.7078970670700073,
0.22366873919963837,
1.2012511491775513,
0.623399555683136,
-1.0028127431869507,
-0.15578044950962067,
0.2046549767255783,
0.31761759519577026,
0.2535185217857361,
-0.263761967420578,
0.12394163757562637,
-0.1409483104944229,
-0.6307886838912964,
0.4636532664299011,
0.27771490812301636,
0.058931615203619,
-0.2396085113286972,
-0.1694587916135788,
-0.2949850261211395,
0.03831830248236656,
0.717467725276947,
0.43993183970451355,
-0.8759361505508423,
-0.255032479763031,
-0.5525742173194885,
-0.2263515293598175,
-0.10104470700025558,
0.7615693211555481,
-0.5782383680343628,
0.11224481463432312,
0.1424877792596817,
0.6559416651725769,
0.08297452330589294,
-0.2211047261953354,
0.035350553691387177,
-0.4637696146965027,
0.5602136850357056,
0.6409129500389099,
0.06557893753051758,
0.25116556882858276,
-0.1389448046684265,
0.25249627232551575,
0.34358885884284973,
-0.34740957617759705,
-1.177751064300537,
0.36897578835487366,
-0.7407593727111816,
-0.3239712715148926,
1.207395315170288,
0.279821515083313,
-0.3433859944343567,
-0.31725335121154785,
-0.2935453951358795,
0.198057621717453,
-0.41036832332611084,
0.5843908786773682,
0.25952666997909546,
0.10021362453699112,
-0.26328030228614807,
-0.18719857931137085,
0.7238800525665283,
0.33649224042892456,
-0.4245006740093231,
0.2414453774690628,
0.6908774375915527,
0.35352692008018494,
-0.02357456460595131,
0.5883811116218567,
0.19964464008808136,
0.26246848702430725,
-0.01913127489387989,
-0.3748641312122345,
-0.20257365703582764,
-0.35468944907188416,
-0.5125542283058167,
0.3498062193393707,
0.04420489817857742,
0.006532798521220684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17143v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17143v1
|
Quantifying Memorization of Domain-Specific Pre-trained Language Models using Japanese Newspaper and Paywalls
| 2024-04-26T04:12:08 | 2024-04-26T04:12:08 |
Shotaro Ishihara
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dominant pre-trained language models (PLMs) have been successful in
high-quality natural language generation. However, the analysis of their
generation is not mature: do they acquire generalizable linguistic
abstractions, or do they simply memorize and recover substrings of the training
data? Especially, few studies focus on domain-specific PLM. In this study, we
pre-trained domain-specific GPT-2 models using a limited corpus of Japanese
newspaper articles and quantified memorization of training data by comparing
them with general Japanese GPT-2 models. Our experiments revealed that
domain-specific PLMs sometimes "copy and paste" on a large scale. Furthermore,
we replicated the empirical finding that memorization is related to
duplication, model size, and prompt length, in Japanese the same as in previous
English studies. Our evaluations are relieved from data contamination concerns
by focusing on newspaper paywalls, which prevent their use as training data. We
hope that our paper encourages a sound discussion such as the security and
copyright of PLMs.
|
[
-0.20240460336208344,
-0.8946107625961304,
0.44807860255241394,
0.0686248168349266,
-0.44481781125068665,
-0.025474144145846367,
-0.1868426501750946,
-0.0753701776266098,
-0.0373903289437294,
0.7803856134414673,
-0.2046445608139038,
-0.4238332509994507,
-0.6621888875961304,
0.031161488965153694,
-0.32945194840431213,
1.3847380876541138,
-0.3424292504787445,
-0.1489129215478897,
-0.42763689160346985,
-0.07608455419540405,
-0.08821585029363632,
-0.8840788006782532,
-0.6323069334030151,
-0.061155371367931366,
0.20366595685482025,
0.006541906390339136,
0.47834187746047974,
0.6023361086845398,
0.4334280788898468,
0.21026544272899628,
0.06401076167821884,
-0.15370790660381317,
-0.5033506155014038,
-0.359776109457016,
-0.2128201425075531,
-0.5876006484031677,
-0.4612876772880554,
0.3008245825767517,
0.8757079839706421,
0.8390460014343262,
0.11905248463153839,
0.12112818658351898,
0.0214221328496933,
0.8194029927253723,
-0.5971444845199585,
0.16234555840492249,
-0.6252453327178955,
0.013889611698687077,
-0.27256152033805847,
-0.2060667723417282,
-0.47735416889190674,
-0.48089227080345154,
0.2852756083011627,
-0.8149009943008423,
0.4327385127544403,
-0.2971216142177582,
0.9278892278671265,
-0.22278888523578644,
-0.540899395942688,
-0.33256766200065613,
-0.5879701375961304,
0.5871780514717102,
-0.5665740370750427,
0.08006799966096878,
0.86302250623703,
0.06563100963830948,
0.17635877430438995,
-0.8809514045715332,
-0.26231732964515686,
-0.23951958119869232,
-0.20226061344146729,
0.24046050012111664,
-0.16633252799510956,
-0.19172441959381104,
0.3531962037086487,
0.3803699314594269,
-0.7058045268058777,
-0.11312354356050491,
-0.44692131876945496,
-0.190851628780365,
0.2869459092617035,
0.06354670226573944,
0.41733843088150024,
0.014811141416430473,
-0.5695556998252869,
-0.026640599593520164,
-0.8156589269638062,
0.05054419860243797,
0.43200528621673584,
0.057264454662799835,
-0.1452488899230957,
0.3019697666168213,
-0.13787996768951416,
0.2487509846687317,
-0.08961985260248184,
-0.3051021695137024,
0.40614938735961914,
-0.48002690076828003,
-0.05557879060506821,
-0.3036300837993622,
0.90284663438797,
0.03680722415447235,
0.7516700625419617,
-0.32077929377555847,
-0.2073126882314682,
-0.1560285985469818,
0.33087271451950073,
-0.7481632828712463,
-0.3904985189437866,
-0.1865461766719818,
-0.3675687909126282,
-0.03120330534875393,
0.08366908878087997,
-0.4372226595878601,
0.13750436902046204,
-0.1659379005432129,
0.5909416675567627,
-0.4411564767360687,
-0.3889974355697632,
0.09938780963420868,
-0.2250669151544571,
-0.08300232142210007,
0.13910911977291107,
-0.731508195400238,
0.22420819103717804,
0.6606125831604004,
0.7718023657798767,
-0.33257347345352173,
-0.5241451263427734,
-0.07960763573646545,
0.2525760531425476,
-0.3213871419429779,
0.616725742816925,
-0.3177027404308319,
-0.5270334482192993,
0.17834582924842834,
0.06847881525754929,
-0.49295520782470703,
-0.671544075012207,
0.40530598163604736,
-0.7909656167030334,
0.5225396156311035,
-0.1860741227865219,
-0.7265060544013977,
-0.04858238250017166,
0.12017576396465302,
-0.6610513925552368,
0.46509790420532227,
0.34351274371147156,
-0.9185826778411865,
0.40641459822654724,
-0.12848295271396637,
-0.6849462389945984,
0.09726756811141968,
0.09607595205307007,
-0.8252725005149841,
0.2727321684360504,
0.16109870374202728,
0.24787284433841705,
0.10052072256803513,
0.5029669404029846,
-0.012538817711174488,
-0.17533916234970093,
0.3815416991710663,
-0.4678000807762146,
0.7657701373100281,
0.16182562708854675,
-0.2686566710472107,
-0.27911415696144104,
-0.6574901342391968,
-0.16814403235912323,
0.39210665225982666,
-0.38907986879348755,
-0.5856591463088989,
-0.3303096890449524,
-0.32361042499542236,
0.222656711935997,
0.30575335025787354,
-0.2282414734363556,
0.11222339421510696,
-0.029443472623825073,
0.3885914087295532,
0.39135152101516724,
0.2515767216682434,
0.580230176448822,
-0.6056129932403564,
0.654700517654419,
0.2696239650249481,
0.04248044639825821,
-0.532341718673706,
-0.23413069546222687,
-0.5730382800102234,
-0.22152259945869446,
0.26207515597343445,
0.3673619329929352,
-0.6743455529212952,
0.08683238923549652,
-0.48804497718811035,
-0.32174038887023926,
-0.2380824089050293,
0.07966214418411255,
0.63129061460495,
0.3993784487247467,
0.11310792714357376,
-0.5522615313529968,
-0.2334105223417282,
-0.8557414412498474,
-0.43641942739486694,
-0.0594911128282547,
0.0012047661002725363,
0.2989524304866791,
0.5794607400894165,
0.02306652069091797,
1.1649502515792847,
-0.2017916738986969,
-0.3531058430671692,
-0.32146933674812317,
0.46235331892967224,
-0.218232661485672,
0.4286435544490814,
0.41844823956489563,
-0.7729272842407227,
-0.5950936675071716,
-0.4030883014202118,
-0.5529674291610718,
-0.15040618181228638,
-0.23021379113197327,
0.0686042457818985,
0.33514878153800964,
0.4290342628955841,
-0.8000017404556274,
0.24564798176288605,
0.31120559573173523,
-0.26450449228286743,
0.6625036597251892,
-0.33946850895881653,
-0.01914767175912857,
-0.9357843995094299,
0.40824756026268005,
-0.19138464331626892,
-0.3077060282230377,
-0.7804146409034729,
-0.08176107704639435,
0.10822760313749313,
-0.1478070169687271,
-0.42544400691986084,
0.40465542674064636,
-0.5522416234016418,
-0.1800829917192459,
-0.48639851808547974,
0.15472820401191711,
0.12605293095111847,
0.5716131925582886,
0.4412660002708435,
0.9984551668167114,
0.1744334101676941,
-0.6260969042778015,
-0.43298476934432983,
0.033165980130434036,
-0.653186559677124,
0.2666145861148834,
-0.5255893468856812,
0.43760398030281067,
-0.1764412224292755,
0.19403651356697083,
-0.8928654193878174,
-0.06469785422086716,
-0.02717546932399273,
-0.2912924587726593,
0.29182976484298706,
-0.2499510943889618,
-0.4240401089191437,
-0.19971024990081787,
-0.1713363528251648,
0.370864599943161,
0.6778995990753174,
-0.2749413549900055,
0.09007654339075089,
0.6708987355232239,
-0.5037640333175659,
-0.3332849442958832,
-0.5106157064437866,
-0.21036681532859802,
-0.2424572855234146,
-0.11713159084320068,
0.05919971689581871,
0.12055566161870956,
0.03666941449046135,
0.01579655334353447,
-0.14765465259552002,
-0.1922469288110733,
0.27959346771240234,
0.09326881170272827,
0.09920359402894974,
-0.288428395986557,
-0.12696638703346252,
-0.020341530442237854,
-0.13788671791553497,
0.3196558654308319,
-0.33074522018432617,
0.6531141996383667,
-0.08665472269058228,
-0.024462688714265823,
-0.354137659072876,
0.13778254389762878,
0.45452603697776794,
-0.32849475741386414,
0.7562727332115173,
0.34713995456695557,
-0.2125062793493271,
-0.29498469829559326,
-0.5398967862129211,
0.10853306949138641,
-0.4195566773414612,
0.46977147459983826,
-0.4092496931552887,
-0.9045917391777039,
0.41286635398864746,
-0.24175944924354553,
-0.19704709947109222,
0.42579570412635803,
0.3882451355457306,
0.017607050016522408,
0.8172723650932312,
0.5825339555740356,
-0.21194204688072205,
0.492203950881958,
-0.28603336215019226,
-0.13043688237667084,
-0.5956290364265442,
-0.1258612871170044,
-0.33487576246261597,
0.009230389259755611,
-0.15321363508701324,
-0.16113275289535522,
0.09783773869276047,
0.37342455983161926,
-0.2503809630870819,
0.34204286336898804,
-0.056224122643470764,
0.6999762654304504,
0.5663963556289673,
-0.24695372581481934,
0.5816383957862854,
0.28363874554634094,
0.022009363397955894,
-0.003478256519883871,
-0.5342103242874146,
-0.6254250407218933,
1.1672240495681763,
0.4022673964500427,
0.5450856685638428,
-0.1750594675540924,
0.5626363158226013,
0.12981681525707245,
0.4947572350502014,
-0.35934367775917053,
0.5014107823371887,
-0.5486806035041809,
-0.629787266254425,
-0.152432382106781,
-0.880402684211731,
-1.097206950187683,
0.08098358660936356,
0.3706243932247162,
-0.5028465390205383,
-0.04957928508520126,
0.021393191069364548,
-0.06593625992536545,
0.2746528685092926,
-0.5774791836738586,
0.9474915862083435,
-0.20487023890018463,
-0.10134357213973999,
-0.107815682888031,
-0.4846478998661041,
0.4581276774406433,
-0.4857249855995178,
0.3676786720752716,
-0.1078525185585022,
0.039691466838121414,
1.0489054918289185,
-0.3556956648826599,
0.8058910369873047,
-0.21152818202972412,
-0.1777118295431137,
0.5064458250999451,
0.09038134664297104,
0.36748260259628296,
-0.07104875147342682,
0.5143082737922668,
0.11917024850845337,
-0.1785566210746765,
-0.2707160711288452,
-0.2244071662425995,
0.5304270386695862,
-0.9744386076927185,
-0.4709831178188324,
-0.13166941702365875,
-0.4178048372268677,
-0.344510555267334,
0.4063170552253723,
0.7431657314300537,
0.3017270267009735,
-0.24468713998794556,
0.22770139575004578,
0.6246760487556458,
-0.07590010017156601,
0.3160274028778076,
0.8740608096122742,
-0.19223825633525848,
-0.5145751237869263,
1.041420578956604,
0.4623959958553314,
0.4610438346862793,
0.3929334878921509,
0.08853320777416229,
-0.13860264420509338,
-0.596838116645813,
-0.13817794620990753,
0.25483113527297974,
-0.47216174006462097,
0.010290614329278469,
-0.7747081518173218,
-0.21427124738693237,
-0.3027019202709198,
-0.00632110983133316,
-0.4073389768600464,
-0.5460230112075806,
-0.2699384093284607,
-0.09822181612253189,
-0.06940670311450958,
0.5768898725509644,
0.13563431799411774,
0.4613630473613739,
-0.7581402063369751,
0.5009838938713074,
0.2934597134590149,
0.4713696539402008,
-0.040777649730443954,
-0.6367964148521423,
-0.5413129925727844,
0.14186426997184753,
-0.19914689660072327,
-0.6809736490249634,
0.5392293930053711,
0.19765715301036835,
0.48327210545539856,
0.25626447796821594,
-0.0535288006067276,
0.2875747084617615,
-0.3637113869190216,
0.7853744029998779,
0.06787244230508804,
-0.9897327423095703,
0.5111395120620728,
-0.5172764658927917,
0.39181873202323914,
0.6540398001670837,
0.6199874877929688,
-0.27008453011512756,
-0.6264886260032654,
-0.7509487867355347,
-0.8620252013206482,
0.835014283657074,
0.07113957405090332,
0.3694975674152374,
-0.1759301722049713,
0.40330585837364197,
0.3365333676338196,
0.3719273805618286,
-0.7297168970108032,
-0.09138533473014832,
-0.38486605882644653,
-0.09017077833414078,
-0.1965678185224533,
-0.4704078733921051,
0.12035194039344788,
0.10725148022174835,
0.5381832122802734,
0.15525491535663605,
0.08706482499837875,
0.027526553720235825,
-0.6667753458023071,
-0.024198230355978012,
0.3217109739780426,
0.5006904006004333,
0.7104800939559937,
-0.13804878294467926,
0.18632622063159943,
-0.15667724609375,
-1.0492734909057617,
0.28734344244003296,
-0.086696557700634,
-0.5759195685386658,
0.1699528694152832,
0.26191699504852295,
1.0192867517471313,
0.13305960595607758,
-0.6723576188087463,
0.8133666515350342,
0.14604893326759338,
-0.4427042305469513,
-0.3815760016441345,
-0.06711708754301071,
0.040398065000772476,
-0.2261471450328827,
0.27131158113479614,
-0.24655033648014069,
-0.13459554314613342,
-0.6465442776679993,
0.40980100631713867,
0.27858421206474304,
-0.019241534173488617,
-0.599491536617279,
0.7776386737823486,
0.019495511427521706,
-0.03865085914731026,
0.8002997636795044,
-0.22955715656280518,
-0.5497692823410034,
0.699780285358429,
0.9015566110610962,
0.9910057783126831,
-0.049133941531181335,
0.443875789642334,
0.2904261648654938,
0.26113730669021606,
-0.3933432698249817,
-0.024575011804699898,
0.04278765246272087,
-0.7555238008499146,
-0.30408069491386414,
-0.39796990156173706,
-0.36289867758750916,
0.5396386981010437,
-0.9366386532783508,
-0.28499001264572144,
-0.6310951709747314,
-0.5182863473892212,
-0.2849993407726288,
0.19375447928905487,
-0.6865901350975037,
0.23721210658550262,
0.21511901915073395,
0.7460486888885498,
-0.854979395866394,
1.0572807788848877,
0.5789583921432495,
-0.5138737559318542,
-0.6177624464035034,
0.10326278954744339,
-0.37821486592292786,
-0.660957932472229,
0.6913310289382935,
0.19321861863136292,
0.264644980430603,
0.07618758082389832,
-0.32641884684562683,
-0.6674759387969971,
0.8301336169242859,
0.3087005913257599,
-0.44852420687675476,
-0.037565432488918304,
0.6138339638710022,
0.6071339249610901,
-0.30870887637138367,
0.06896646320819855,
0.6629689335823059,
0.025378894060850143,
-0.41888847947120667,
-0.9201375246047974,
-0.19635576009750366,
-0.4096916913986206,
0.08076032251119614,
0.19463233649730682,
-0.812375545501709,
1.0359538793563843,
-0.042926594614982605,
-0.5232380032539368,
-0.012277340516448021,
0.31362801790237427,
0.029393069446086884,
0.4848915636539459,
0.16480104625225067,
0.7752177119255066,
0.6043044924736023,
-0.039042625576257706,
1.0147439241409302,
-0.2513708770275116,
0.4428422152996063,
1.1921842098236084,
-0.2804586887359619,
0.822343111038208,
0.12218958884477615,
-0.2303420901298523,
0.3609812259674072,
-0.014503974467515945,
0.015784818679094315,
0.7204448580741882,
0.07017054408788681,
-0.09064923971891403,
0.03282742202281952,
0.014174818992614746,
-0.3169304430484772,
0.18811842799186707,
0.2557775378227234,
-0.43390363454818726,
-0.1141376867890358,
0.3327580988407135,
0.38036444783210754,
-0.03157168626785278,
-0.40743204951286316,
1.1711194515228271,
0.29778292775154114,
-0.7715781927108765,
0.5385842323303223,
-0.021761316806077957,
0.49009639024734497,
-0.8162025213241577,
0.6022540330886841,
-0.7161086201667786,
0.251179963350296,
0.2575933039188385,
-0.5657302737236023,
0.2698546350002289,
0.3169562518596649,
-0.24790529906749725,
-0.5027011632919312,
0.6238217949867249,
-0.6235515475273132,
-0.08330357074737549,
-0.034020014107227325,
0.6399660110473633,
0.1808984875679016,
-0.1710253208875656,
-0.34049078822135925,
-0.10950882732868195,
-0.0038317772559821606,
-0.6927125453948975,
0.8389636278152466,
0.38139015436172485,
-0.11105415970087051,
0.503383994102478,
0.6043615341186523,
0.20204110443592072,
0.1967819482088089,
0.2214163839817047,
0.5154612064361572,
-0.6053850054740906,
-0.5591572523117065,
-0.7991412878036499,
0.24819712340831757,
0.09989514201879501,
-0.5642367005348206,
0.9156283140182495,
0.7414779663085938,
1.1450103521347046,
-0.5019794702529907,
0.9505696892738342,
0.5398761034011841,
0.625109076499939,
-0.6827040314674377,
0.8046332597732544,
-0.1763674020767212,
0.14576666057109833,
-0.05793662369251251,
-0.90219646692276,
-0.14417949318885803,
0.49868044257164,
-0.49735701084136963,
0.08680597692728043,
0.6659842729568481,
0.4539986550807953,
-0.0652465671300888,
-0.024413621053099632,
0.046256646513938904,
0.14543606340885162,
0.17250514030456543,
0.816746711730957,
0.8294482827186584,
-0.2562684118747711,
0.6688082218170166,
-0.4515324532985687,
0.03845454379916191,
-0.06132863089442253,
-0.5670275688171387,
-0.9195929169654846,
-0.5396645069122314,
-0.5646347999572754,
-0.04444446042180061,
0.12952660024166107,
0.32555896043777466,
0.4147593677043915,
-0.7559249401092529,
-0.09395364671945572,
-0.2848376929759979,
-0.3251481354236603,
-0.009402449242770672,
-0.2159586250782013,
0.6825765371322632,
-0.5157215595245361,
-0.5631539225578308,
0.019806569442152977,
0.06608624011278152,
0.3937300741672516,
0.058357466012239456,
0.14686064422130585,
0.28286728262901306,
0.11294706165790558,
0.4800127446651459,
0.39330771565437317,
-0.31888115406036377,
0.03777216747403145,
-0.1139330342411995,
-0.5275981426239014,
-0.03673787787556648,
1.1806437969207764,
-0.8757107257843018,
0.17905530333518982,
0.5598389506340027,
0.5064495205879211,
0.3950199484825134,
0.2834584712982178,
0.47759556770324707,
-0.949435293674469,
0.10424323379993439,
0.09905927628278732,
0.3556632995605469,
0.27598515152931213,
0.04673272743821144,
0.21838636696338654,
0.458686500787735,
-0.48001715540885925,
-0.6243582963943481,
0.02283969707787037,
-0.6680698394775391,
-0.5127562880516052,
1.215501308441162,
-0.596152663230896,
-0.021160155534744263,
-0.12705080211162567,
-0.07664159685373306,
0.22305122017860413,
0.026292765513062477,
0.6052445769309998,
0.6746553778648376,
0.5752362608909607,
-0.23845145106315613,
-0.5328992605209351,
0.6939809322357178,
0.4545886218547821,
-0.7801666259765625,
0.2481696754693985,
0.28536516427993774,
0.5545872449874878,
0.02956497110426426,
1.062542200088501,
-0.4213433563709259,
0.2374626249074936,
0.18667662143707275,
-0.39825060963630676,
-0.3579818904399872,
-0.45071646571159363,
-0.4688602685928345,
0.4121554493904114,
-0.02000078186392784,
-0.08104855567216873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17140v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17140v2
|
Small Language Models Need Strong Verifiers to Self-Correct Reasoning
| 2024-04-26T03:41:28 | 2024-06-06T03:59:24 |
Yunxiang Zhang, Muhammad Khalifa, Lajanugen Logeswaran, Jaekyeom Kim, Moontae Lee, Honglak Lee, Lu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Self-correction has emerged as a promising solution to boost the reasoning
performance of large language models (LLMs), where LLMs refine their solutions
using self-generated critiques that pinpoint the errors. This work explores
whether small (<= 13B) language models (LMs) have the ability of
self-correction on reasoning tasks with minimal inputs from stronger LMs. We
propose a novel pipeline that prompts smaller LMs to collect self-correction
data that supports the training of self-refinement abilities. First, we
leverage correct solutions to guide the model in critiquing their incorrect
responses. Second, the generated critiques, after filtering, are used for
supervised fine-tuning of the self-correcting reasoner through solution
refinement. Our experimental results show improved self-correction abilities of
two models on five datasets spanning math and commonsense reasoning, with
notable performance gains when paired with a strong GPT-4-based verifier,
though limitations are identified when using a weak self-verifier for
determining when to correct.
|
[
-0.1562749147415161,
-0.45181772112846375,
0.6700512766838074,
-0.21100032329559326,
0.047264330089092255,
-0.2239677459001541,
-0.5038923621177673,
-0.18744148313999176,
-0.005849058739840984,
0.6881026029586792,
-0.6949951648712158,
-0.030065754428505898,
-0.38753682374954224,
0.4784102737903595,
-0.1820078194141388,
0.8923205137252808,
0.17076250910758972,
0.09741682559251785,
-0.09013117104768753,
-0.0663156509399414,
-0.686982274055481,
-0.28051313757896423,
-0.5725472569465637,
-0.4953972101211548,
0.8238413333892822,
0.8700153827667236,
0.5810351967811584,
0.9234981536865234,
0.2727287709712982,
0.39940935373306274,
0.15723104774951935,
0.43776318430900574,
-0.4790436625480652,
0.08930792659521103,
-0.7478808164596558,
-0.6614941358566284,
-0.38965460658073425,
-0.11193840205669403,
0.5579233765602112,
0.5012286305427551,
-0.15058201551437378,
0.37738269567489624,
0.15494750440120697,
0.7821516990661621,
-0.5215996503829956,
-0.12741096317768097,
-0.9404199719429016,
-0.12772873044013977,
-0.28177574276924133,
0.07923690229654312,
-0.532703697681427,
0.02985011227428913,
-0.2595597505569458,
-0.16053010523319244,
0.6310794949531555,
0.10442154854536057,
0.7491517663002014,
0.88433837890625,
-0.12208113819360733,
-0.09423123300075531,
-0.6851726174354553,
0.6463963389396667,
-0.9561089277267456,
0.14480642974376678,
0.3714947998523712,
0.49445995688438416,
-0.01349241565912962,
-0.6530451774597168,
-0.6049934029579163,
0.011675179935991764,
-0.4406351149082184,
-0.18210405111312866,
-0.25179100036621094,
-0.19608965516090393,
0.49476781487464905,
0.3644478917121887,
-0.2519511282444,
0.27397972345352173,
-0.6148006916046143,
-0.37177518010139465,
0.6558511853218079,
0.2782619297504425,
-0.13498666882514954,
-0.3227505683898926,
0.09772080928087234,
0.12175237387418747,
-0.8473218679428101,
-0.11513377726078033,
0.20985066890716553,
0.6868124604225159,
0.2148863971233368,
0.6058314442634583,
-0.3630850613117218,
0.739727258682251,
0.47355639934539795,
-0.15976613759994507,
-0.05040857568383217,
-0.4077340364456177,
-0.327466756105423,
-0.14501696825027466,
0.7161839604377747,
0.007677352521568537,
0.11631274223327637,
0.14430582523345947,
-0.6301739811897278,
0.05208500102162361,
0.23130357265472412,
-0.7336979508399963,
-0.6638306379318237,
0.025654884055256844,
-0.2233174741268158,
-0.19439318776130676,
-0.5077162384986877,
-0.3158484399318695,
-0.523134171962738,
-0.6798033118247986,
0.5412191152572632,
-0.1328536421060562,
0.10059675574302673,
0.4217277765274048,
0.2568153738975525,
-0.20554569363594055,
0.6136060357093811,
-0.9587005972862244,
0.02943846955895424,
0.4846350848674774,
0.4994310736656189,
0.35554665327072144,
-0.2709132432937622,
-0.5989573001861572,
0.04512876644730568,
-0.429904967546463,
0.9536764621734619,
-0.3068011403083801,
0.05951930209994316,
-0.2106109857559204,
0.07268226146697998,
-0.041410282254219055,
-0.6004351377487183,
0.5542343854904175,
-0.193216472864151,
0.0542718879878521,
-0.4089544713497162,
-0.5438265204429626,
0.40081971883773804,
0.29172056913375854,
-0.5255435109138489,
0.9645993113517761,
-0.1085476279258728,
-0.7055896520614624,
0.2452370673418045,
-0.13288673758506775,
-0.10752704739570618,
0.0586155541241169,
-0.27605244517326355,
-0.48549073934555054,
0.16196465492248535,
0.4673171937465668,
0.39003822207450867,
-0.1323131024837494,
-0.06730806827545166,
-0.4174129366874695,
-0.17013373970985413,
-0.014497094787657261,
-0.36475706100463867,
0.47085800766944885,
0.23919092118740082,
-0.2059968113899231,
0.10737015306949615,
-0.844301164150238,
0.23484936356544495,
0.1532156616449356,
-0.3591900169849396,
-0.14329038560390472,
-0.210661843419075,
-0.7208621501922607,
0.3388395309448242,
0.25540098547935486,
-0.5651127696037292,
0.47250819206237793,
-0.381402850151062,
0.6510730981826782,
0.8242073059082031,
-0.3446182310581207,
0.2947418987751007,
-0.3085072636604309,
0.3212871253490448,
-0.09620188176631927,
-0.14794063568115234,
-0.26646992564201355,
-0.25207024812698364,
-1.1908605098724365,
-0.2891477346420288,
0.5941365957260132,
0.3279878497123718,
-0.7295010089874268,
0.19941267371177673,
-0.20865365862846375,
-0.682094395160675,
-0.881480872631073,
0.5747148990631104,
0.4800383448600769,
0.6524277329444885,
0.5656957030296326,
0.21901683509349823,
-0.53572678565979,
-0.9518738985061646,
-0.44109657406806946,
-0.11183708906173706,
-0.07032544910907745,
0.27508994936943054,
0.5439882278442383,
-0.31066206097602844,
0.9715012907981873,
-0.17924083769321442,
-0.5059476494789124,
-0.22477403283119202,
0.06696327030658722,
0.11491286009550095,
0.42179641127586365,
0.34955286979675293,
0.027504591271281242,
-0.23328974843025208,
-0.1142255887389183,
-0.48964744806289673,
-0.4466229975223541,
0.0039749834686517715,
0.09509208053350449,
0.10593453049659729,
0.6017699241638184,
-0.3933960497379303,
0.17906448245048523,
0.4562934637069702,
-0.3546307384967804,
0.5913074612617493,
-0.5377352237701416,
-0.19737230241298676,
-0.41383427381515503,
-0.26787397265434265,
-0.0462777204811573,
-0.5420138239860535,
-0.30702030658721924,
-0.10316106677055359,
0.14519855380058289,
0.046925824135541916,
-0.012046144343912601,
0.6472705602645874,
-0.487272173166275,
0.19385017454624176,
-0.506889283657074,
0.32563984394073486,
-0.05877283215522766,
0.2593941390514374,
-0.053867459297180176,
0.5201925039291382,
0.39484357833862305,
-0.4677640497684479,
0.3310385048389435,
0.04881969094276428,
-0.015569407492876053,
0.6398319005966187,
-0.6808114647865295,
0.4127916097640991,
-0.17633876204490662,
0.18039517104625702,
-1.0410608053207397,
-0.2106274962425232,
0.11987096816301346,
-0.2901676297187805,
0.19151078164577484,
-0.5840156674385071,
-0.45758479833602905,
-0.6606589555740356,
0.07494513690471649,
0.2683856189250946,
0.21102002263069153,
-0.8912336230278015,
0.49080103635787964,
0.06504971534013748,
-0.1051342710852623,
-0.5552803874015808,
-0.7681772708892822,
-0.057886939495801926,
0.10012457519769669,
-0.7754072546958923,
-0.11374491453170776,
-0.0024428991600871086,
-0.04379170387983322,
-0.10193882882595062,
-0.1604284793138504,
0.21927545964717865,
-0.10036607086658478,
0.12049682438373566,
0.022512873634696007,
-0.14225894212722778,
0.4248136579990387,
-0.12636573612689972,
-0.31682729721069336,
0.019605495035648346,
-0.20188330113887787,
0.16579778492450714,
-0.5400196313858032,
-0.49834227561950684,
-0.22866173088550568,
-0.18357840180397034,
0.2643277943134308,
-0.2421971559524536,
0.3862154483795166,
0.25581294298171997,
-0.3826141953468323,
-0.6316324472427368,
-0.810756266117096,
-0.653019905090332,
-0.4958377182483673,
-0.1014849841594696,
-0.6570867896080017,
-1.2889037132263184,
0.38780075311660767,
0.10434260964393616,
-0.11799819022417068,
0.6721290349960327,
0.7614052295684814,
-0.2464626282453537,
1.1561939716339111,
0.343513160943985,
-0.04030575975775719,
-0.0663924440741539,
-0.1590290367603302,
0.3405713737010956,
-0.5947408676147461,
0.13386493921279907,
-0.7754150629043579,
-0.37641260027885437,
-0.44651660323143005,
-0.48253706097602844,
-0.10279260575771332,
0.07078874856233597,
-0.40753471851348877,
0.3248283267021179,
-0.64494788646698,
0.7460875511169434,
0.5343196988105774,
0.06791022419929504,
0.45474672317504883,
-0.21183030307292938,
-0.31089186668395996,
-0.35872718691825867,
-0.9042897820472717,
-0.700295090675354,
0.731708824634552,
0.5673200488090515,
1.0393699407577515,
-0.0023734227288514376,
0.6937152147293091,
0.18633414804935455,
0.49430933594703674,
-0.5529631972312927,
0.4213360548019409,
-0.20013229548931122,
-0.7131604552268982,
-0.4993898272514343,
-0.48433974385261536,
-0.5651775598526001,
0.31694406270980835,
-0.05220436304807663,
-0.5503199696540833,
0.2720522880554199,
0.8419474959373474,
-0.5361691117286682,
0.2397496998310089,
-0.7773251533508301,
1.1562870740890503,
-0.17591582238674164,
-0.5974403023719788,
-0.35167959332466125,
-0.4240691065788269,
0.4288395345211029,
-0.02125762216746807,
0.29854831099510193,
-0.10625892132520676,
0.2928677797317505,
0.19108498096466064,
-0.9230368137359619,
1.1190054416656494,
-0.27865245938301086,
-0.39536818861961365,
0.3914391100406647,
0.3913353979587555,
0.6684146523475647,
0.11247637122869492,
0.0007471087737940252,
-0.11686743795871735,
0.042772334069013596,
-0.28777748346328735,
-0.8313133716583252,
0.6908405423164368,
-0.5568472743034363,
-0.9440098404884338,
-0.31980100274086,
-0.089725062251091,
-0.2967565655708313,
0.23983465135097504,
0.08271460980176926,
0.15529298782348633,
0.6152237057685852,
0.2653430700302124,
0.44520825147628784,
0.4593014121055603,
0.1497260183095932,
0.7469117641448975,
-0.23936857283115387,
-0.2710281014442444,
0.7804621458053589,
0.27493563294410706,
0.24027147889137268,
-0.09251949191093445,
0.44386982917785645,
-0.17692799866199493,
-0.5041694641113281,
-0.6541094183921814,
0.6692458987236023,
-0.8490853905677795,
-0.5072851777076721,
-0.26599451899528503,
-0.12224406749010086,
-0.22865495085716248,
0.0995999276638031,
-0.7921460866928101,
-0.48114079236984253,
0.04267704114317894,
-0.04957326129078865,
0.2695682644844055,
0.6727105379104614,
-0.46331706643104553,
0.2751747667789459,
-0.6439683437347412,
0.09263115376234055,
0.7032002210617065,
0.3714677095413208,
-0.08549169450998306,
-0.9996166229248047,
-0.3496570289134979,
0.20782914757728577,
-0.15052543580532074,
-0.45794108510017395,
0.09622075408697128,
0.1616619974374771,
0.24403256177902222,
0.07416999340057373,
-0.03029533661901951,
0.9073681831359863,
-0.651373565196991,
0.6035871505737305,
-0.056744661182165146,
-0.9309495091438293,
0.9029343128204346,
-0.27269017696380615,
0.33799344301223755,
0.5756792426109314,
-0.24984613060951233,
-0.36357805132865906,
-0.4231714904308319,
-0.5972723960876465,
-0.3755282163619995,
0.6797707080841064,
0.16859497129917145,
0.036637090146541595,
-0.13383044302463531,
0.6267337203025818,
-0.23622635006904602,
-0.06446400284767151,
-0.782703161239624,
-0.06190526857972145,
-0.3383624851703644,
-0.12946654856204987,
0.19296105206012726,
-0.30245116353034973,
-0.2092559039592743,
-0.28138217329978943,
1.029958963394165,
-0.652138888835907,
-0.16563311219215393,
0.34118354320526123,
-0.019590573385357857,
-0.5289808511734009,
0.3638783097267151,
0.3288188874721527,
0.4512957036495209,
0.10115713626146317,
0.3039589822292328,
0.3960398733615875,
0.17397603392601013,
0.1320391297340393,
-0.14293263852596283,
-0.1768013834953308,
-0.16771048307418823,
0.22084739804267883,
0.5218854546546936,
0.12243112176656723,
-0.46005600690841675,
0.5512608289718628,
-0.2864096462726593,
0.007174943573772907,
0.0018633066210895777,
0.22789266705513,
0.13880135118961334,
0.35808414220809937,
-0.006005248986184597,
0.24435512721538544,
-0.003350812243297696,
-0.24261093139648438,
0.1351129561662674,
0.37153640389442444,
-0.22816278040409088,
-0.201956108212471,
0.5741679072380066,
0.09498943388462067,
-0.12626491487026215,
0.49132636189460754,
-0.26070642471313477,
-0.3813602030277252,
0.2089637815952301,
0.6349236965179443,
0.47401589155197144,
-0.2731699049472809,
-0.006934816483408213,
0.7259320616722107,
0.4178446829319,
-0.34363704919815063,
0.05377380922436714,
-0.03272275999188423,
-1.0138633251190186,
-0.6639992594718933,
-0.4420083165168762,
-0.4035554528236389,
0.18959827721118927,
-0.37658828496932983,
0.4654375910758972,
-0.5964149832725525,
-0.15411993861198425,
0.11575629562139511,
-0.1044684574007988,
-0.6729906797409058,
0.5602213144302368,
0.30439266562461853,
0.7654220461845398,
-0.558647871017456,
0.8971309065818787,
0.542946457862854,
-0.3841549754142761,
-1.3044837713241577,
-0.4182347357273102,
0.05248583108186722,
-0.751882016658783,
0.6856132745742798,
0.04917265847325325,
-0.5224957466125488,
-0.059283822774887085,
-0.6558223962783813,
-0.8469973802566528,
0.8497564792633057,
0.6081367135047913,
-1.1279217004776,
-0.00021122377074789256,
0.09116314351558685,
0.824259340763092,
-0.31134742498397827,
0.1848977655172348,
0.6698137521743774,
0.21665115654468536,
0.0746280699968338,
-1.0567890405654907,
0.022010136395692825,
-0.11714811623096466,
-0.052169375121593475,
0.010886890813708305,
-0.7634627819061279,
0.7439906001091003,
-0.4544273316860199,
-0.08700375258922577,
0.1419685035943985,
0.8500727415084839,
0.4019870162010193,
-0.09491592645645142,
0.5567959547042847,
0.9585075974464417,
0.8817234635353088,
-0.2575925290584564,
0.8838858008384705,
-0.2353881597518921,
0.6226716637611389,
1.653572678565979,
-0.09858829528093338,
0.8082332015037537,
0.29699060320854187,
-0.061239685863256454,
0.5722076892852783,
0.3115689158439636,
-0.01219429261982441,
0.26898103952407837,
0.3521689176559448,
0.09704438596963882,
-0.7960524559020996,
0.16129830479621887,
-0.07005813717842102,
0.37503063678741455,
0.2932952046394348,
-0.2774820327758789,
-0.23262521624565125,
-0.13316670060157776,
0.029885612428188324,
0.3613927960395813,
-0.5631071925163269,
0.524351179599762,
0.07558038830757141,
-0.7863808274269104,
0.6930380463600159,
0.10934831947088242,
0.40487244725227356,
-0.1924343854188919,
0.16609403491020203,
-0.38691118359565735,
0.7184569835662842,
-0.35846996307373047,
-0.7772725820541382,
0.37418001890182495,
0.0633808970451355,
-0.26765668392181396,
-0.22199325263500214,
1.0416409969329834,
-0.45582929253578186,
-0.3529335558414459,
0.162427619099617,
0.5371257662773132,
-0.13773919641971588,
-0.036867763847112656,
-0.6459766626358032,
-0.08877605944871902,
0.037017762660980225,
-0.08112441748380661,
-0.009608178399503231,
0.8931789398193359,
0.02055364102125168,
0.956995964050293,
0.4377291202545166,
0.22752724587917328,
0.1069691926240921,
0.46805423498153687,
0.7089211344718933,
-0.5488530993461609,
-0.3139380216598511,
-0.9067786931991577,
0.5938706994056702,
-0.016317859292030334,
-0.2606910467147827,
0.912242591381073,
0.4001952111721039,
1.1273969411849976,
-0.25819334387779236,
0.8112921118736267,
0.18350039422512054,
0.9873555302619934,
-0.5058456659317017,
0.28459954261779785,
-0.4912601113319397,
0.4917210340499878,
0.1097945049405098,
-0.46929460763931274,
-0.2764359414577484,
0.8838323354721069,
-0.5571572780609131,
0.053336236625909805,
0.4597802758216858,
1.0207164287567139,
-0.0202143844217062,
-0.05747945234179497,
0.26800528168678284,
0.5520340204238892,
0.3575435280799866,
0.40483328700065613,
0.9396129250526428,
-0.45836275815963745,
0.450006365776062,
-0.4521394371986389,
0.08070065081119537,
-0.19193103909492493,
-0.8198967576026917,
-1.1492267847061157,
-0.07773120701313019,
-0.460074245929718,
-0.49690935015678406,
0.005634312517940998,
0.9653995633125305,
0.67911297082901,
-0.8306879997253418,
0.046147655695676804,
-0.043564457446336746,
0.025403333827853203,
-0.07346653193235397,
-0.16205282509326935,
0.002269263146445155,
-0.7589818239212036,
-0.4789123237133026,
0.4928341209888458,
0.21201938390731812,
-0.09788203239440918,
-0.5349752306938171,
-0.13532239198684692,
0.37650224566459656,
0.25274360179901123,
0.3057469427585602,
0.3900129795074463,
-0.9477487206459045,
-0.7754616141319275,
-0.16175201535224915,
-0.33782702684402466,
0.04570678621530533,
0.8245022296905518,
-0.9430310726165771,
0.5180817246437073,
0.26436561346054077,
0.6423449516296387,
0.37270787358283997,
-0.08464504778385162,
0.3445833921432495,
-0.9571709632873535,
-0.2750275433063507,
0.1258445382118225,
0.8033828139305115,
0.5988582372665405,
-0.36205536127090454,
0.5887971520423889,
0.3278830349445343,
-0.9306517243385315,
-0.8295649886131287,
0.19598381221294403,
-0.5239437222480774,
0.08835984021425247,
0.9162922501564026,
-0.16195297241210938,
-0.15794606506824493,
0.18590541183948517,
-0.5424016714096069,
-0.10789249837398529,
-0.13652798533439636,
0.8005259037017822,
0.8200153112411499,
-0.04988053813576698,
-0.5904836058616638,
-0.07750631123781204,
0.6220858693122864,
0.6930319666862488,
-0.6430425643920898,
0.5774974226951599,
0.6783463358879089,
0.5180180072784424,
0.3231067657470703,
0.5638922452926636,
0.04196394607424736,
0.28369268774986267,
-0.1336158663034439,
-0.27549365162849426,
-0.03554069995880127,
-0.5097128748893738,
-0.45971429347991943,
-0.06162156164646149,
0.4028593897819519,
0.4159017503261566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17136v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17136v1
|
Automated Data Visualization from Natural Language via Large Language Models: An Exploratory Study
| 2024-04-26T03:25:35 | 2024-04-26T03:25:35 |
Yang Wu, Yao Wan, Hongyu Zhang, Yulei Sui, Wucai Wei, Wei Zhao, Guandong Xu, Hai Jin
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The Natural Language to Visualization (NL2Vis) task aims to transform
natural-language descriptions into visual representations for a grounded table,
enabling users to gain insights from vast amounts of data. Recently, many deep
learning-based approaches have been developed for NL2Vis. Despite the
considerable efforts made by these approaches, challenges persist in
visualizing data sourced from unseen databases or spanning multiple tables.
Taking inspiration from the remarkable generation capabilities of Large
Language Models (LLMs), this paper conducts an empirical study to evaluate
their potential in generating visualizations, and explore the effectiveness of
in-context learning prompts for enhancing this task. In particular, we first
explore the ways of transforming structured tabular data into sequential text
prompts, as to feed them into LLMs and analyze which table content contributes
most to the NL2Vis. Our findings suggest that transforming structured tabular
data into programs is effective, and it is essential to consider the table
schema when formulating prompts. Furthermore, we evaluate two types of LLMs:
finetuned models (e.g., T5-Small) and inference-only models (e.g., GPT-3.5),
against state-of-the-art methods, using the NL2Vis benchmarks (i.e., nvBench).
The experimental results reveal that LLMs outperform baselines, with
inference-only models consistently exhibiting performance improvements, at
times even surpassing fine-tuned models when provided with certain few-shot
demonstrations through in-context learning. Finally, we analyze when the LLMs
fail in NL2Vis, and propose to iteratively update the results using strategies
such as chain-of-thought, role-playing, and code-interpreter. The experimental
results confirm the efficacy of iterative updates and hold great potential for
future study.
|
[
-0.14923162758350372,
-1.13548743724823,
0.8275148868560791,
0.17409928143024445,
-0.277221143245697,
-0.07195161283016205,
-0.4528079628944397,
-0.23216906189918518,
-0.04817379266023636,
0.6742427945137024,
-0.3109684884548187,
-0.8431512713432312,
-0.4288190007209778,
0.21103112399578094,
-0.581983745098114,
0.909648597240448,
-0.14571812748908997,
0.034027907997369766,
-0.3762633800506592,
0.2154151052236557,
-1.0648695230484009,
-0.2947928011417389,
-0.5652574300765991,
-0.15460258722305298,
0.33731308579444885,
0.7642667889595032,
0.47435617446899414,
0.7042815685272217,
0.4053724408149719,
0.2267657220363617,
0.05706761032342911,
0.17063380777835846,
-0.6215448379516602,
0.39048123359680176,
0.007032149937003851,
-0.4710225462913513,
-0.1144021525979042,
-0.15733756124973297,
0.6539188623428345,
0.9570250511169434,
-0.11796850711107254,
0.07319685071706772,
0.2894526422023773,
0.8071410059928894,
-0.03410698473453522,
0.6198047399520874,
-0.5640458464622498,
0.18235577642917633,
-0.14267058670520782,
-0.3066674470901489,
-0.7144089341163635,
-0.5682255625724792,
0.5064883232116699,
-0.6279008388519287,
-0.035530488938093185,
0.3355543315410614,
0.5193150043487549,
0.3272501826286316,
-0.5937336683273315,
-0.4924195110797882,
-0.7682814002037048,
0.8139863610267639,
-0.742573082447052,
0.26182156801223755,
0.1723962128162384,
0.6610444188117981,
-0.39649343490600586,
-0.9344484806060791,
-0.3707417845726013,
-0.5757592916488647,
-0.15458644926548004,
-0.022364476695656776,
-0.22117890417575836,
-0.2631261348724365,
0.6440151929855347,
0.14860495924949646,
-0.7330968976020813,
0.4674121141433716,
-0.25949424505233765,
0.173832505941391,
0.5274652242660522,
0.5361275672912598,
0.41819271445274353,
-0.2594372034072876,
-0.3511572480201721,
-0.322982519865036,
-0.9139588475227356,
0.13920475542545319,
0.0715164840221405,
0.5883914828300476,
-0.3205907940864563,
0.7290338277816772,
-0.17429345846176147,
0.997871458530426,
-0.37225350737571716,
-0.0018287068232893944,
0.06267277151346207,
-0.33787626028060913,
-0.3253665566444397,
-0.04394247382879257,
0.7249411940574646,
0.49217426776885986,
0.4286414682865143,
-0.32691383361816406,
-0.11602336913347244,
-0.026763131842017174,
0.11147621273994446,
-0.8736767172813416,
-0.25253164768218994,
0.19798219203948975,
-0.3386017084121704,
-0.1748795360326767,
-0.01997034065425396,
-1.0034757852554321,
-0.7357969880104065,
-0.7871235609054565,
0.2134065181016922,
-0.3859913647174835,
0.007871044799685478,
-0.13562394678592682,
-0.14955881237983704,
0.11213994771242142,
0.6419700384140015,
-0.8569335341453552,
0.14356686174869537,
0.6056506037712097,
0.8418893814086914,
-0.543657124042511,
-0.02127702161669731,
-0.5766280293464661,
0.19200870394706726,
-0.6532957553863525,
0.7085043787956238,
-0.45926669239997864,
-0.38505810499191284,
0.17334067821502686,
-0.08964298665523529,
0.09680105745792389,
-0.6211790442466736,
0.20585255324840546,
-0.30019646883010864,
0.14272718131542206,
-0.5963825583457947,
-0.7800430655479431,
-0.09404896199703217,
0.26500511169433594,
-0.6967393159866333,
0.8778516054153442,
-0.05775235593318939,
-0.5954201221466064,
0.525818407535553,
-0.860608696937561,
-0.41162341833114624,
0.02034120447933674,
-0.4505685865879059,
-0.23619075119495392,
0.005718599073588848,
0.4104527533054352,
0.7004970908164978,
-0.5867937207221985,
0.7485402822494507,
0.005536064971238375,
-0.3741376996040344,
0.23543418943881989,
-0.3708775043487549,
0.6046732068061829,
-0.018271131440997124,
-0.5076672434806824,
0.39398738741874695,
-0.5986680388450623,
-0.2457374781370163,
0.34957048296928406,
-0.19647525250911713,
-0.11613409966230392,
0.203679621219635,
0.005411627236753702,
0.11147107183933258,
-0.25441452860832214,
-0.17785076797008514,
0.44630467891693115,
-0.5724331736564636,
0.42886853218078613,
0.5900105834007263,
0.10835027694702148,
0.6591313481330872,
0.06052321568131447,
0.4244639277458191,
-0.06927616894245148,
-0.13954345881938934,
-0.41856256127357483,
-0.5512180924415588,
-0.6980639100074768,
-0.10511194169521332,
0.16522878408432007,
0.5272316336631775,
-1.1012753248214722,
0.22523632645606995,
-0.4486745595932007,
-0.33834823966026306,
-0.07443984597921371,
0.12333311885595322,
0.021708093583583832,
1.106153964996338,
0.5175027847290039,
0.0983678326010704,
-0.5459734797477722,
-0.902422308921814,
-0.1767924726009369,
0.01276495959609747,
-0.18197457492351532,
0.23131798207759857,
0.7406685948371887,
-0.27759459614753723,
1.097153663635254,
-0.38776254653930664,
-0.2732444405555725,
-0.5002130270004272,
0.31311124563217163,
0.37804532051086426,
0.39008641242980957,
0.5209870338439941,
-0.4801764190196991,
-0.6655667424201965,
0.14358747005462646,
-1.046953558921814,
-0.07191220670938492,
-0.2600822150707245,
0.06428514420986176,
0.255485862493515,
0.5616514086723328,
-0.2983689606189728,
0.5350954532623291,
0.239493727684021,
-0.32838931679725647,
0.5011006593704224,
-0.1383274346590042,
0.018345177173614502,
-0.8606654405593872,
0.2435871809720993,
0.06083416938781738,
-0.09321963787078857,
-0.9032096862792969,
-0.11932369321584702,
0.009601796045899391,
-0.23508286476135254,
-0.23719094693660736,
0.7556756734848022,
-0.5229917168617249,
-0.23593735694885254,
-0.17464487254619598,
0.14329934120178223,
-0.04936644434928894,
0.392129510641098,
0.03491109609603882,
0.7770946025848389,
0.646998941898346,
-0.45632198452949524,
0.41324666142463684,
0.36123958230018616,
-0.5963603258132935,
0.3593990206718445,
-0.687102198600769,
0.00235356530174613,
-0.36323925852775574,
0.41876646876335144,
-0.9761086106300354,
-0.3977993428707123,
0.11851990222930908,
-0.08396805822849274,
0.26720428466796875,
-0.034912072122097015,
-0.7203946709632874,
-0.26608797907829285,
-0.2901947796344757,
-0.13751114904880524,
0.4931257665157318,
-0.7760332822799683,
0.4361063838005066,
0.2675046920776367,
-0.19200849533081055,
-0.4212474524974823,
-0.9237776398658752,
0.5276423692703247,
-0.35744285583496094,
-0.6522400975227356,
0.2310553938150406,
0.09228304773569107,
-0.4540058672428131,
-0.22535021603107452,
0.14698496460914612,
0.33237504959106445,
0.14569371938705444,
0.3740094304084778,
0.372015118598938,
-0.056638166308403015,
0.2546204924583435,
0.1286134272813797,
-0.038563322275877,
0.16825968027114868,
-0.23143284022808075,
0.5117254257202148,
-0.22941558063030243,
-0.2611258924007416,
-0.5849271416664124,
0.42026156187057495,
0.17500938475131989,
-0.15379099547863007,
0.7540788054466248,
0.5013278722763062,
-0.3325647711753845,
-0.4048890173435211,
-0.45479920506477356,
-0.24693253636360168,
-0.41282421350479126,
0.2723492980003357,
-0.07467737793922424,
-0.8501150012016296,
0.5171504020690918,
-0.15850801765918732,
0.28136909008026123,
0.3086228668689728,
0.5499287843704224,
-0.3880872428417206,
1.0378888845443726,
0.5324832797050476,
0.19993150234222412,
0.43131399154663086,
-0.5121991634368896,
0.22241276502609253,
-0.5925232768058777,
-0.4963715970516205,
-0.46603259444236755,
-0.20273132622241974,
-0.4060567617416382,
-0.4626603424549103,
0.5099060535430908,
-0.10720494389533997,
-0.1715814769268036,
0.07534223794937134,
-0.32107028365135193,
0.37353917956352234,
0.40097615122795105,
-0.18017661571502686,
0.1849898099899292,
0.3393074870109558,
-0.03567364066839218,
-0.29650047421455383,
-0.7716785669326782,
-0.6876559853553772,
1.1306777000427246,
0.41854026913642883,
0.6879559755325317,
0.06252332776784897,
0.5653438568115234,
0.3504250645637512,
0.4774767756462097,
-0.8173701167106628,
0.5721453428268433,
-0.1081908568739891,
-0.15924431383609772,
-0.5124223828315735,
-0.527802050113678,
-1.0435528755187988,
0.09179538488388062,
-0.3802085816860199,
-0.7421059608459473,
0.10754738003015518,
0.30067208409309387,
-0.15702685713768005,
0.0755181759595871,
-0.8909332752227783,
1.008015513420105,
-0.26642361283302307,
-0.4869154095649719,
0.07120063900947571,
-0.6341345906257629,
0.3133111298084259,
0.0315215177834034,
0.2232641577720642,
0.10906530916690826,
0.14330260455608368,
0.7824519872665405,
-0.29497408866882324,
0.8663440346717834,
-0.39910298585891724,
-0.24218451976776123,
0.33711913228034973,
0.060886189341545105,
0.7639156579971313,
0.17158663272857666,
-0.08890258520841599,
-0.050154004245996475,
-0.3792736232280731,
-0.15825079381465912,
-0.7283632755279541,
0.7549883127212524,
-0.27701759338378906,
-0.533385157585144,
-0.13749313354492188,
-0.716034471988678,
-0.2958711087703705,
0.07841598242521286,
-0.002504847478121519,
0.7393338680267334,
-0.16197705268859863,
0.4226641058921814,
0.6357518434524536,
-0.6855277419090271,
0.5057236552238464,
0.20010778307914734,
-0.44296109676361084,
-0.10916993767023087,
0.8451646566390991,
0.22277238965034485,
0.05155749246478081,
0.3351644277572632,
0.25792425870895386,
-0.5086480379104614,
-0.6784460544586182,
-0.6828134655952454,
-0.028127195313572884,
-0.9303519129753113,
-0.15219783782958984,
-0.5073269009590149,
0.2336326241493225,
-0.3450668752193451,
-0.18834806978702545,
0.027527987957000732,
-0.20199768245220184,
-0.4068009555339813,
-0.18111957609653473,
0.4877360761165619,
0.8511577248573303,
0.29088589549064636,
0.33073151111602783,
-0.39742475748062134,
0.34789103269577026,
0.4078201949596405,
0.22724111378192902,
0.1716141551733017,
-0.38497304916381836,
-0.05376329645514488,
-0.018341707065701485,
0.13580240309238434,
-1.121928095817566,
0.5867146253585815,
-0.023785622790455818,
0.5323202013969421,
0.1739678531885147,
-0.3300676643848419,
0.6938996315002441,
-0.6339675188064575,
0.8195019364356995,
0.16398097574710846,
-0.7634982466697693,
0.6667579412460327,
-0.5573528409004211,
0.43890389800071716,
0.5671465396881104,
0.16271676123142242,
-0.4855138063430786,
-0.19999179244041443,
-0.04874778538942337,
-0.9858663082122803,
0.6664516925811768,
0.05511293560266495,
0.02228633686900139,
0.014180069789290428,
0.20428471267223358,
0.28998300433158875,
0.18986019492149353,
-0.6057501435279846,
-0.15485736727714539,
-0.12299107015132904,
-0.27488118410110474,
-0.09885396808385849,
-0.1619482934474945,
-0.047124188393354416,
-0.35505443811416626,
0.2990925908088684,
-0.328044056892395,
0.13060903549194336,
0.010174857452511787,
-0.411161869764328,
0.19651615619659424,
0.2668798565864563,
0.49331367015838623,
0.8879825472831726,
-0.10352561622858047,
0.1493103951215744,
0.27351871132850647,
0.018470309674739838,
-0.19049136340618134,
0.010862781666219234,
-0.26966559886932373,
0.0656188502907753,
0.4185197353363037,
1.264634370803833,
0.22493864595890045,
-0.8973250985145569,
0.47830796241760254,
-0.11018385738134384,
-0.044108796864748,
-0.2513182461261749,
-0.14581505954265594,
0.2298852801322937,
0.13084809482097626,
0.459585040807724,
-0.2900107204914093,
0.2876203656196594,
-0.7719499468803406,
0.01782487891614437,
0.5848848223686218,
-0.06155816838145256,
-0.022665461525321007,
0.7111107110977173,
0.05918942391872406,
-0.20620812475681305,
0.6817507743835449,
-0.14058412611484528,
-0.12229491770267487,
0.7212914228439331,
0.6368414163589478,
0.49008485674858093,
0.054634492844343185,
0.2728830575942993,
0.4098380506038666,
0.29719579219818115,
-0.20060250163078308,
0.1956597864627838,
-0.027481529861688614,
-0.16871461272239685,
-0.5541579127311707,
-0.4083373248577118,
-0.44476425647735596,
0.09305660426616669,
-0.5400566458702087,
0.3168921172618866,
-0.27851957082748413,
-0.048172663897275925,
-0.04628654941916466,
-0.22860606014728546,
-0.9986200332641602,
0.009788449853658676,
0.37084317207336426,
0.8901715874671936,
-1.0104247331619263,
0.7108179330825806,
0.41718754172325134,
-0.3222671449184418,
-0.7683773636817932,
-0.2330523580312729,
-0.07301284372806549,
-0.5265324711799622,
0.7535904049873352,
0.35276880860328674,
0.3331022560596466,
-0.07125229388475418,
-0.7979173064231873,
-0.8201816082000732,
1.100573182106018,
0.477456659078598,
-0.6587969064712524,
-0.09949932992458344,
0.41705477237701416,
0.6830865144729614,
-0.32964497804641724,
0.18925437331199646,
0.8252426981925964,
0.710323691368103,
-0.12560175359249115,
-0.6261454224586487,
0.1881304532289505,
-0.1617150604724884,
0.18886609375476837,
0.04304264113306999,
0.1930498480796814,
0.6582620143890381,
-0.2656581401824951,
-0.38066616654396057,
-0.20448020100593567,
0.8312771916389465,
0.3937830924987793,
0.18257048726081848,
0.3707861602306366,
0.21173235774040222,
0.745808482170105,
-0.28192928433418274,
1.1652731895446777,
0.0804523453116417,
0.03288883715867996,
1.1711229085922241,
-0.4500691294670105,
0.6810364127159119,
0.7372042536735535,
0.12628033757209778,
0.5791451930999756,
0.334712952375412,
-0.39195725321769714,
0.3873624801635742,
0.3712368607521057,
0.3723949193954468,
0.08524129539728165,
-0.22620992362499237,
-0.24975767731666565,
0.28377050161361694,
0.5399531126022339,
-0.3594740331172943,
-0.3804580867290497,
0.20295429229736328,
-0.10604241490364075,
0.2848762571811676,
-0.13552871346473694,
0.7873928546905518,
0.021474352106451988,
-0.7579412460327148,
0.47142741084098816,
-0.09252562373876572,
0.4763752520084381,
-0.3942808210849762,
-0.422667533159256,
-0.18405185639858246,
-0.34284910559654236,
-0.1708541363477707,
-0.9121321439743042,
0.25686272978782654,
0.3744930624961853,
0.1246766448020935,
-0.5118314623832703,
0.6233014464378357,
-0.541510820388794,
-0.39948907494544983,
0.21660543978214264,
0.5821822881698608,
0.12737524509429932,
0.06076708808541298,
-0.4768519401550293,
0.12468558549880981,
0.03982136771082878,
-0.3206612169742584,
0.15874263644218445,
0.18411098420619965,
-0.3118073046207428,
0.6598206162452698,
0.6649495363235474,
-0.06359438598155975,
0.001456943224184215,
0.3976011276245117,
0.6953420639038086,
-0.5978888273239136,
-0.5764021277427673,
-0.9978869557380676,
0.8033733367919922,
-0.3131060004234314,
0.04904588311910629,
0.8305101990699768,
0.5640453696250916,
0.45073381066322327,
-0.248931884765625,
0.6863703727722168,
0.12652553617954254,
0.3380129337310791,
-0.7743636965751648,
0.5921434760093689,
-0.4688740074634552,
0.40930473804473877,
-0.29278698563575745,
-0.9116945266723633,
-0.4898628294467926,
0.36192965507507324,
-0.5108852982521057,
-0.2642837464809418,
0.630780816078186,
0.543643057346344,
0.18770484626293182,
-0.04845684394240379,
0.0408795028924942,
0.19744296371936798,
0.5465922951698303,
0.3710586726665497,
0.7976566553115845,
-0.061088938266038895,
0.2906831204891205,
-0.19638115167617798,
-0.11747391521930695,
-0.2085670828819275,
-0.9726680517196655,
-1.0911026000976562,
-0.5995137095451355,
-0.19452206790447235,
-0.029147816821932793,
-0.03648237884044647,
0.9343346357345581,
0.4170258939266205,
-0.7318564653396606,
-0.35246333479881287,
-0.2158510684967041,
-0.07599562406539917,
0.0048772068694233894,
-0.25449439883232117,
0.6436576843261719,
-0.3029674291610718,
-0.6707810759544373,
0.802549421787262,
0.2982083559036255,
0.12046206742525101,
-0.19664381444454193,
0.08844566345214844,
0.1090109571814537,
-0.12056399136781693,
0.8287305235862732,
0.056650932878255844,
-0.7717452645301819,
-0.054247692227363586,
0.06650029867887497,
-0.1696016937494278,
0.10280593484640121,
0.6496255397796631,
-0.9999480843544006,
0.48902758955955505,
0.6826813220977783,
0.714923083782196,
0.5433461666107178,
0.005927093327045441,
0.6850524544715881,
-0.7658717632293701,
0.10757563263177872,
0.2911587953567505,
0.47471630573272705,
0.576831579208374,
-0.1441008746623993,
0.4327048361301422,
-0.262302964925766,
-0.3406408429145813,
-1.1609244346618652,
0.11485748738050461,
-1.0031943321228027,
-0.3263028562068939,
1.3084007501602173,
0.16216440498828888,
-0.17487449944019318,
0.041644953191280365,
-0.3265320956707001,
0.2905418574810028,
-0.349446564912796,
0.747020423412323,
0.3512527048587799,
-0.10830826312303543,
0.07528745383024216,
-1.0870305299758911,
0.6312804818153381,
0.3648999333381653,
-1.243878722190857,
0.2982112467288971,
0.5998584032058716,
0.030288100242614746,
-0.06730297207832336,
0.27671241760253906,
0.04701974615454674,
-0.0420217365026474,
-0.3582705557346344,
-0.045406341552734375,
-0.20334307849407196,
-0.4694455564022064,
-0.6960684657096863,
0.12581539154052734,
-0.05891820415854454,
0.3049129247665405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17123v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17123v2
|
Text Sentiment Analysis and Classification Based on Bidirectional Gated Recurrent Units (GRUs) Model
| 2024-04-26T02:40:03 | 2024-06-12T14:12:17 |
Wei Xu, Jianlong Chen, Zhicheng Ding, Jinyin Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper explores the importance of text sentiment analysis and
classification in the field of natural language processing, and proposes a new
approach to sentiment analysis and classification based on the bidirectional
gated recurrent units (GRUs) model. The study firstly analyses the word cloud
model of the text with six sentiment labels, and then carries out data
preprocessing, including the steps of removing special symbols, punctuation
marks, numbers, stop words and non-alphabetic parts. Subsequently, the data set
is divided into training set and test set, and through model training and
testing, it is found that the accuracy of the validation set is increased from
85% to 93% with training, which is an increase of 8%; at the same time, the
loss value of the validation set decreases from 0.7 to 0.1 and tends to be
stable, and the model is gradually close to the actual value, which can
effectively classify the text emotions. The confusion matrix shows that the
accuracy of the model on the test set reaches 94.8%, the precision is 95.9%,
the recall is 99.1%, and the F1 score is 97.4%, which proves that the model has
good generalisation ability and classification effect. Overall, the study
demonstrated an effective method for text sentiment analysis and classification
with satisfactory results.
|
[
-0.4098016619682312,
-0.7069547772407532,
0.4585650861263275,
0.10903988778591156,
-0.4829277992248535,
0.008566117845475674,
-0.022903162986040115,
-0.34550341963768005,
-0.06881275027990341,
0.36773815751075745,
-0.40877634286880493,
-0.8017692565917969,
-0.7125733494758606,
0.11040050536394119,
-0.37282195687294006,
1.4927492141723633,
-0.03622482344508171,
0.22411799430847168,
-0.21806469559669495,
-0.3565877377986908,
-0.3527524769306183,
-0.7761329412460327,
-0.6556217670440674,
-0.1620693951845169,
0.29262781143188477,
0.07687695324420929,
0.5944782495498657,
-0.025769317522644997,
0.6986211538314819,
0.39666739106178284,
-0.5293551087379456,
-0.1600193977355957,
-0.2503862679004669,
0.02309856191277504,
-0.14752420783042908,
-0.37497982382774353,
-0.4814636707305908,
0.3071894347667694,
0.6708898544311523,
0.2543230652809143,
-0.34829506278038025,
-0.05549491569399834,
0.2774783670902252,
0.7795994281768799,
-0.22758346796035767,
0.0041040354408323765,
-0.4473172426223755,
-0.02078215219080448,
-0.060779113322496414,
-0.07173144817352295,
-0.3604946434497833,
-0.6224234104156494,
0.07447557896375656,
-0.16536180675029755,
0.5613772869110107,
-0.03925811126828194,
1.0152065753936768,
0.08902326226234436,
-0.4793727695941925,
-0.4178438186645508,
-0.5724297165870667,
1.1680885553359985,
-0.9583029747009277,
0.4268386960029602,
-0.23125246167182922,
0.15324117243289948,
-0.012724430300295353,
-0.7041813731193542,
-0.8710442781448364,
0.04311743378639221,
-0.06615587323904037,
0.2806374132633209,
-0.002017771126702428,
0.31670838594436646,
0.024436019361019135,
0.6940318942070007,
-0.49253353476524353,
-0.35149097442626953,
-0.16546733677387238,
0.10344058275222778,
0.7644875049591064,
0.24514685571193695,
0.45734289288520813,
-0.5477206707000732,
-0.7403057813644409,
-0.07696939259767532,
-0.12000662833452225,
0.31817948818206787,
0.22045238316059113,
0.2749374508857727,
0.016960440203547478,
0.06916073709726334,
-0.1883455365896225,
0.675905704498291,
-0.25311243534088135,
-0.44541507959365845,
0.6033757925033569,
-0.02572752721607685,
-0.6309195756912231,
-0.11972817778587341,
1.0534955263137817,
0.406441867351532,
0.21304114162921906,
0.025979885831475258,
-0.5832999348640442,
0.5810349583625793,
0.4832827150821686,
-0.7526636123657227,
0.29177534580230713,
0.23127388954162598,
-0.6527258157730103,
-0.7118743658065796,
0.10953762382268906,
-1.0336467027664185,
-0.3463367521762848,
-0.44678428769111633,
0.12666745483875275,
-0.36245861649513245,
-0.20953615009784698,
0.4400360584259033,
0.04954110458493233,
0.07123418152332306,
0.40828222036361694,
-0.6900545358657837,
0.48780372738838196,
0.8550521731376648,
0.9296198487281799,
-0.06217903643846512,
-0.1457068920135498,
-0.043468791991472244,
-0.4256850481033325,
-0.07249442487955093,
0.7340300679206848,
-0.6112650036811829,
-0.4347911775112152,
0.16364513337612152,
0.10855401307344437,
-0.39615190029144287,
-0.09170930087566376,
1.0784764289855957,
-0.6993573904037476,
0.6902866363525391,
-0.13436634838581085,
-0.4758192300796509,
-0.8681160807609558,
0.497730016708374,
-0.6227526664733887,
1.0672976970672607,
-0.07889574766159058,
-1.1695011854171753,
-0.09827220439910889,
-0.5308545827865601,
-0.46140772104263306,
0.1627182513475418,
-0.07728590816259384,
-0.34128883481025696,
0.2316063791513443,
0.01954600401222706,
0.5987149477005005,
-0.3571206331253052,
0.5239256024360657,
-0.22542792558670044,
-0.18693925440311432,
0.29131969809532166,
-0.32154086232185364,
0.5487003922462463,
0.37987449765205383,
-0.261737197637558,
-0.010081324726343155,
-0.4814283549785614,
0.036626141518354416,
-0.19035620987415314,
-0.3748970031738281,
-0.6042750477790833,
0.029355263337492943,
0.24728703498840332,
0.3240351974964142,
0.08692002296447754,
-0.8636003732681274,
0.09693554788827896,
-0.44867751002311707,
0.2711554765701294,
0.5209000706672668,
0.19149573147296906,
0.45223766565322876,
-0.13143599033355713,
0.6909839510917664,
0.09101762622594833,
0.2205711007118225,
0.09954289346933365,
-0.6362428665161133,
-0.6658270955085754,
-0.13619215786457062,
0.2676748037338257,
0.6434838175773621,
-0.5576567053794861,
0.4051913619041443,
-0.3314264416694641,
-0.4793305993080139,
-0.5787620544433594,
-0.12325257062911987,
0.26663944125175476,
0.7186986804008484,
0.21480463445186615,
-0.09453732520341873,
-0.2576000392436981,
-0.7254008650779724,
-0.14265935122966766,
-0.402362197637558,
0.42327526211738586,
0.06567591428756714,
0.3849012553691864,
-0.6782143115997314,
0.7962824702262878,
-0.585748553276062,
-0.22267048060894012,
-0.4061083197593689,
0.766803503036499,
0.24426378309726715,
0.1585455685853958,
0.5042557716369629,
-0.9248499870300293,
-0.11566239595413208,
0.2226240038871765,
-0.8823987245559692,
-0.09538162499666214,
-0.03972066938877106,
-0.07751181721687317,
0.46937763690948486,
0.21199066936969757,
-0.5806888341903687,
0.2810440957546234,
0.4831307530403137,
-0.3995184898376465,
0.40078410506248474,
0.13834698498249054,
0.45516201853752136,
-1.257337212562561,
0.1410873532295227,
0.41815805435180664,
-0.24685968458652496,
-0.8519517779350281,
0.07418305426836014,
0.10544086992740631,
0.008558172732591629,
-0.31375551223754883,
0.37582167983055115,
-0.12026993185281754,
0.36496931314468384,
-0.6543393135070801,
0.1223645880818367,
0.18323945999145508,
0.4116029739379883,
0.13509319722652435,
0.2878318130970001,
0.18711408972740173,
-0.6945286989212036,
0.5971078276634216,
0.1700548529624939,
-0.3166804015636444,
0.3542833924293518,
-0.4121556580066681,
0.032217998057603836,
-0.5414297580718994,
-0.08615011721849442,
-1.1765621900558472,
0.4225700795650482,
0.16303646564483643,
-0.6223384141921997,
0.2657006084918976,
0.12949424982070923,
-0.11974338442087173,
-0.4153136909008026,
-0.3071073591709137,
0.13874857127666473,
0.4093587398529053,
-0.4667375385761261,
0.6364845633506775,
0.4521666467189789,
-0.5192126035690308,
-0.5775086879730225,
-0.5114681720733643,
-0.11093749850988388,
-0.32818666100502014,
-0.5201852917671204,
0.35651472210884094,
-0.041424427181482315,
-0.2572080194950104,
0.010394684970378876,
0.24717050790786743,
0.0014401726657524705,
-0.008262877352535725,
0.40086880326271057,
0.5309704542160034,
0.07682137191295624,
0.5704363584518433,
0.05114741250872612,
-0.17712470889091492,
0.14208443462848663,
0.08707883208990097,
0.3916471600532532,
-0.6343613862991333,
0.21938563883304596,
-0.7086869478225708,
0.16136135160923004,
0.9236108660697937,
-0.20095941424369812,
0.5344502329826355,
0.699420690536499,
-0.6472254395484924,
-0.1710406094789505,
-0.4933970272541046,
0.029428597539663315,
-0.4383820593357086,
0.4927283227443695,
-0.24144083261489868,
-0.7063702344894409,
0.15511323511600494,
0.1905549317598343,
0.07499909400939941,
0.436117559671402,
0.3658309280872345,
-0.06161307170987129,
1.0442923307418823,
0.7054794430732727,
-0.8558883666992188,
0.3246668875217438,
-0.07010390609502792,
0.42509496212005615,
-0.6241381764411926,
-0.29253435134887695,
-0.5807164907455444,
-0.1620766520500183,
-0.5881255865097046,
0.0346662737429142,
-0.11699214577674866,
0.1578221470117569,
-0.12032843381166458,
-0.0951453223824501,
-0.6827247738838196,
-0.04717303812503815,
0.21854346990585327,
-0.02843029797077179,
0.15677578747272491,
0.28222939372062683,
-0.1672348529100418,
-0.22433654963970184,
-0.19825521111488342,
-0.8461191058158875,
0.5541862845420837,
0.7977694272994995,
0.6692013740539551,
-0.01824098639190197,
0.6133560538291931,
0.6357070207595825,
0.610450267791748,
-1.1119662523269653,
0.7125178575515747,
-0.24515628814697266,
-0.24108879268169403,
-0.2249990701675415,
-0.5062112808227539,
-0.5434477925300598,
0.2744976282119751,
-0.20312029123306274,
-0.4695431590080261,
-0.043581265956163406,
-0.3816862106323242,
-0.43900465965270996,
0.3382251262664795,
-0.636546790599823,
0.8248001337051392,
-0.2011093646287918,
-0.03703932836651802,
-0.023599250242114067,
-0.11544004827737808,
0.5128450989723206,
0.22374360263347626,
0.46134132146835327,
0.035750534385442734,
0.10660943388938904,
1.283828854560852,
-0.3488270342350006,
0.6946491599082947,
-0.36098238825798035,
-0.17479459941387177,
0.5331611633300781,
-0.14695188403129578,
0.47419479489326477,
0.17375783622264862,
-0.05474584549665451,
0.08536343276500702,
0.013030346482992172,
-0.06015215069055557,
-0.741706371307373,
0.8865030407905579,
-0.8408381342887878,
-0.4877130091190338,
-0.7542669177055359,
-0.3147376775741577,
-0.2150709331035614,
-0.022765981033444405,
0.1537950485944748,
0.5200302600860596,
-0.15147100389003754,
-0.017181724309921265,
0.6527402997016907,
-0.029141606763005257,
0.6629124283790588,
0.3711431324481964,
-0.46909067034721375,
-0.7848466038703918,
0.8066589832305908,
-0.15835019946098328,
-0.0791129320859909,
0.384840726852417,
0.2572498321533203,
-0.506807267665863,
-0.5090938806533813,
-0.3578570485115051,
0.4291558861732483,
-0.5570671558380127,
-0.3267408609390259,
-0.7666800022125244,
-0.31057122349739075,
-0.6028110980987549,
0.015766020864248276,
-0.1375054121017456,
0.0880807489156723,
-0.3425505757331848,
-0.38557133078575134,
0.41753658652305603,
0.8691225051879883,
0.5756904482841492,
0.6141670942306519,
-1.1448180675506592,
0.1633763164281845,
0.3871462643146515,
0.3547275960445404,
-0.07255356758832932,
-0.7060146927833557,
-0.011887416243553162,
-0.08728718012571335,
-0.37850797176361084,
-1.2949740886688232,
0.8217562437057495,
-0.19463127851486206,
0.34790584444999695,
0.7908678650856018,
-0.07504096627235413,
0.3576177656650543,
-0.03229207172989845,
0.7242637276649475,
0.45585042238235474,
-1.1570124626159668,
0.4163435697555542,
-0.23228880763053894,
-0.015336425043642521,
0.5815896987915039,
0.3851507902145386,
-1.0292309522628784,
-0.09564676135778427,
-0.6785733699798584,
-0.35310086607933044,
0.7929456830024719,
0.12017752230167389,
0.04803375154733658,
0.003942352719604969,
0.5648106932640076,
-0.04157597944140434,
0.33409225940704346,
-0.8729627728462219,
-0.19904643297195435,
-0.16706082224845886,
-0.791878879070282,
-0.2858528792858124,
-0.6942436695098877,
0.3831145167350769,
-0.22803951799869537,
0.9896573424339294,
0.07822529226541519,
0.31218475103378296,
0.2527839243412018,
0.0865517109632492,
-0.014041170477867126,
0.547451913356781,
0.3215256631374359,
-0.0353526845574379,
-0.25327813625335693,
0.14750592410564423,
0.2249729186296463,
-0.8926820158958435,
0.18004311621189117,
0.060425516217947006,
-0.35618260502815247,
0.2846454381942749,
0.07756122946739197,
0.8389064073562622,
-0.10977842658758163,
-0.30040040612220764,
0.7444209456443787,
-0.3431072533130646,
-0.24892234802246094,
-0.03907356411218643,
-0.1870853155851364,
0.016640417277812958,
0.07057113200426102,
0.13527840375900269,
0.10076446831226349,
0.3824280798435211,
-0.4463065564632416,
-0.03641669079661369,
0.5817749500274658,
-0.8662469983100891,
-0.4127059280872345,
0.1996040791273117,
0.24889788031578064,
-0.10781866312026978,
0.49632468819618225,
-0.5643830299377441,
-1.0116820335388184,
0.3813667893409729,
0.3801293969154358,
1.071577787399292,
-0.5616399645805359,
0.6601795554161072,
0.5228207111358643,
0.3992014527320862,
-0.21788421273231506,
0.49030470848083496,
0.23278950154781342,
-0.9430011510848999,
-0.0261247418820858,
-1.1944679021835327,
-0.17727014422416687,
0.3784273564815521,
-0.8528796434402466,
0.2998031973838806,
-0.590670645236969,
-0.37613531947135925,
-0.1653595268726349,
0.33611127734184265,
-0.2659471333026886,
0.8984696865081787,
0.30865296721458435,
0.6516286134719849,
-1.1975277662277222,
0.8093060255050659,
1.1540790796279907,
-0.13183309137821198,
-0.4485171139240265,
-0.20862354338169098,
-0.13566607236862183,
-0.20220336318016052,
0.4922485947608948,
0.5568478107452393,
-0.29008129239082336,
-0.08562471717596054,
-0.556527316570282,
-0.48299509286880493,
0.8779920935630798,
-0.4094233810901642,
-0.6603966951370239,
0.3162998557090759,
0.1690160483121872,
0.904785692691803,
-0.428413450717926,
0.3526769280433655,
0.5308932065963745,
0.21496406197547913,
0.044146135449409485,
-0.37865832448005676,
0.0604916475713253,
-0.7043393850326538,
0.20041637122631073,
0.46126988530158997,
-0.5220704078674316,
1.056785225868225,
0.0979345366358757,
-0.6057846546173096,
-0.17487166821956635,
0.8446349501609802,
0.03233884647488594,
0.5795115232467651,
0.6448017954826355,
0.9014961123466492,
0.984166145324707,
-0.1518891304731369,
0.8072146773338318,
-0.10822124034166336,
0.7658488750457764,
0.6373530626296997,
-0.2789493203163147,
1.0048787593841553,
0.2191549837589264,
-0.27808359265327454,
0.9418247938156128,
0.5076227784156799,
0.28439584374427795,
0.4623732268810272,
0.04356847330927849,
-0.552230179309845,
-0.13401809334754944,
-0.040071070194244385,
-0.3382638096809387,
0.13807405531406403,
0.3686366081237793,
-0.4002529978752136,
-0.1391884684562683,
0.2858111560344696,
0.09177505970001221,
0.19822260737419128,
-0.30770713090896606,
0.7367299199104309,
0.10622530430555344,
-0.561855673789978,
0.2912822365760803,
0.4983597695827484,
0.8697401881217957,
-0.392972469329834,
0.3134506940841675,
-0.2714822590351105,
0.34556180238723755,
-0.31856128573417664,
-0.7342671751976013,
0.09971988946199417,
0.20646867156028748,
-0.4826326072216034,
-0.024775343015789986,
0.9697799682617188,
-0.23013266921043396,
-0.820463240146637,
0.4238642156124115,
0.25171196460723877,
0.025960277765989304,
-0.43180757761001587,
-0.682001531124115,
-0.2248910367488861,
0.2677329480648041,
-0.46883684396743774,
0.0778425931930542,
0.4836387038230896,
0.05580773949623108,
0.44091376662254333,
0.5024526715278625,
0.07838885486125946,
-0.12743757665157318,
0.21788948774337769,
0.6471948027610779,
-1.2896422147750854,
-0.7672024965286255,
-0.943389356136322,
0.2769930362701416,
-0.14841975271701813,
-0.2541534900665283,
0.5224217176437378,
0.3123948872089386,
0.35311272740364075,
-0.02021600492298603,
1.2387900352478027,
0.24803538620471954,
0.7573236227035522,
-0.4146610200405121,
0.6540421843528748,
-0.38043907284736633,
0.06637952476739883,
-0.48483964800834656,
-0.7352067232131958,
-0.31515100598335266,
0.429076224565506,
-0.5511409044265747,
0.06966157257556915,
0.9362479448318481,
0.7290183901786804,
0.2482529729604721,
0.7380132079124451,
0.22881774604320526,
0.014560266397893429,
0.15689219534397125,
0.5882439017295837,
1.0419931411743164,
-0.7477407455444336,
0.28274840116500854,
-0.2359444797039032,
-0.4867496192455292,
-0.0672944113612175,
-0.5832357406616211,
-0.8808590769767761,
-0.5313653349876404,
-0.36844098567962646,
-0.31680580973625183,
-0.12709523737430573,
0.5450987219810486,
0.19026897847652435,
-0.8213491439819336,
-0.05120847746729851,
-0.2768436074256897,
0.13342510163784027,
-0.011994779109954834,
-0.323263019323349,
0.25436094403266907,
-0.7733715176582336,
-0.7609144449234009,
-0.19720184803009033,
0.21595749258995056,
0.19065891206264496,
0.029125969856977463,
-0.18404318392276764,
-0.1886594295501709,
0.02463197149336338,
0.7816338539123535,
-0.1180892139673233,
-0.5342337489128113,
0.008202587254345417,
-0.12754175066947937,
-0.5874276757240295,
-0.10458168387413025,
0.6860857605934143,
-0.8182162046432495,
0.32681095600128174,
0.8162707686424255,
0.5978748202323914,
-0.08250413089990616,
0.4188475012779236,
0.09878376126289368,
-0.32044240832328796,
-0.17118512094020844,
0.01246909610927105,
0.5646539330482483,
0.44422996044158936,
-0.45998841524124146,
0.0694391131401062,
0.5207833051681519,
-0.5951959490776062,
-0.5201627016067505,
-0.06647670269012451,
-1.1154522895812988,
-0.2617495656013489,
1.4450225830078125,
0.006218641065061092,
-0.4975586533546448,
-0.02970609813928604,
-0.5704553723335266,
0.29838186502456665,
-0.4081643223762512,
0.9099518060684204,
0.6796367764472961,
0.21497581899166107,
-0.15874828398227692,
-0.35919705033302307,
0.5130138993263245,
0.5644634962081909,
-0.9368160963058472,
-0.06320247054100037,
0.3727675676345825,
0.10269039869308472,
0.3552844524383545,
0.5145130157470703,
-0.2755941152572632,
-0.09270012378692627,
-0.31483685970306396,
0.5696937441825867,
0.22465497255325317,
-0.38293400406837463,
-0.7449272274971008,
0.46152663230895996,
-0.08270263671875,
-0.6286001205444336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17122v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17122v1
|
2M-NER: Contrastive Learning for Multilingual and Multimodal NER with Language and Modal Fusion
| 2024-04-26T02:34:31 | 2024-04-26T02:34:31 |
Dongsheng Wang, Xiaoqin Feng, Zeming Liu, Chuan Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Named entity recognition (NER) is a fundamental task in natural language
processing that involves identifying and classifying entities in sentences into
pre-defined types. It plays a crucial role in various research fields,
including entity linking, question answering, and online product
recommendation. Recent studies have shown that incorporating multilingual and
multimodal datasets can enhance the effectiveness of NER. This is due to
language transfer learning and the presence of shared implicit features across
different modalities. However, the lack of a dataset that combines
multilingualism and multimodality has hindered research exploring the
combination of these two aspects, as multimodality can help NER in multiple
languages simultaneously. In this paper, we aim to address a more challenging
task: multilingual and multimodal named entity recognition (MMNER), considering
its potential value and influence. Specifically, we construct a large-scale
MMNER dataset with four languages (English, French, German and Spanish) and two
modalities (text and image). To tackle this challenging MMNER task on the
dataset, we introduce a new model called 2M-NER, which aligns the text and
image representations using contrastive learning and integrates a multimodal
collaboration module to effectively depict the interactions between the two
modalities. Extensive experimental results demonstrate that our model achieves
the highest F1 score in multilingual and multimodal NER tasks compared to some
comparative and representative baselines. Additionally, in a challenging
analysis, we discovered that sentence-level alignment interferes a lot with NER
models, indicating the higher level of difficulty in our dataset.
|
[
-0.44247201085090637,
-0.5870308876037598,
0.2741298973560333,
0.1458813101053238,
-0.14190086722373962,
0.00440710224211216,
-0.1614544689655304,
-0.7022306323051453,
0.1248541921377182,
0.22355887293815613,
-0.38819918036460876,
-0.12481942027807236,
-0.7172452211380005,
0.26618650555610657,
0.12897181510925293,
1.1010245084762573,
-0.166779026389122,
0.502243161201477,
-0.27715763449668884,
-0.3845813572406769,
-0.5476059317588806,
-0.2921173572540283,
-0.8977609276771545,
-0.4708303213119507,
0.7952754497528076,
0.41080790758132935,
0.44278591871261597,
0.32418569922447205,
0.9145874381065369,
0.3090813457965851,
0.08233202993869781,
0.38334012031555176,
-0.3307131826877594,
0.2725670039653778,
-0.3509695529937744,
-0.3103742003440857,
-0.13547711074352264,
-0.1931600719690323,
0.6039426326751709,
0.397928923368454,
0.1389247328042984,
-0.17405235767364502,
0.12140195071697235,
0.572730302810669,
-0.44769182801246643,
0.30805930495262146,
-0.4549699127674103,
-0.060444772243499756,
-0.1037258431315422,
0.036264568567276,
-0.2987682521343231,
0.00472810585051775,
0.05207065865397453,
-0.5951833128929138,
0.017380934208631516,
0.04907303303480148,
0.9894227385520935,
0.3189191222190857,
-0.9849219918251038,
-0.5468198657035828,
-0.6825344562530518,
0.8975922465324402,
-0.18626777827739716,
0.7397338151931763,
0.3431875705718994,
0.4405025243759155,
0.12620021402835846,
-0.4543396532535553,
-0.8822502493858337,
-0.0045495363883674145,
-0.3114776611328125,
0.1778019666671753,
-0.2751033902168274,
-0.23758985102176666,
-0.004617622587829828,
0.14124087989330292,
-0.5894542336463928,
0.20845960080623627,
-0.29604583978652954,
-0.2555640637874603,
0.21689988672733307,
0.11413149535655975,
0.3549087941646576,
-0.42488744854927063,
-0.7224491834640503,
-0.17634019255638123,
-0.41426947712898254,
-0.09734534472227097,
0.17609484493732452,
0.3039320707321167,
-0.3870503306388855,
0.5685797929763794,
0.0012432208750396967,
0.4157751500606537,
0.08106674998998642,
-0.3449428975582123,
0.589072585105896,
-0.6075190901756287,
0.10231035202741623,
-0.16455550491809845,
0.8538085222244263,
0.6752344369888306,
-0.00576714426279068,
-0.06621387600898743,
-0.32357388734817505,
0.12493743002414703,
-0.16782429814338684,
-0.9062235951423645,
-0.2579672038555145,
-0.19315096735954285,
-0.3509015738964081,
-0.014114650897681713,
0.04796071723103523,
-1.025325059890747,
-0.32303473353385925,
-0.47041812539100647,
0.5965572595596313,
-0.4237216114997864,
-0.5164856910705566,
-0.3347088396549225,
-0.013778137043118477,
0.21934667229652405,
0.26334306597709656,
-0.716454803943634,
0.2566336393356323,
0.4637545645236969,
0.7226899862289429,
-0.13841906189918518,
-0.2964562177658081,
-0.4644491970539093,
0.3081667125225067,
-0.05500653013586998,
0.7404617071151733,
-0.7650558352470398,
-0.25768041610717773,
-0.2589140832424164,
0.19656184315681458,
-0.3758541941642761,
-0.4909086227416992,
0.2434452325105667,
-0.6733259558677673,
0.6191941499710083,
-0.18843580782413483,
-0.3619040846824646,
-0.5390490293502808,
0.5673964023590088,
-0.9484022855758667,
0.9001660943031311,
-0.02277938276529312,
-0.8879201412200928,
0.26284390687942505,
-0.6095553040504456,
-0.43181881308555603,
-0.13853301107883453,
-0.3913881480693817,
-0.44300997257232666,
-0.08025209605693817,
0.07291512191295624,
0.44976457953453064,
-0.43493127822875977,
0.256355881690979,
0.08431426435709,
0.01825922168791294,
0.4234199523925781,
-0.4220055341720581,
0.3034680485725403,
0.1368243396282196,
-0.3690110743045807,
-0.09158392250537872,
-0.7896261215209961,
-0.17274920642375946,
0.04963446035981178,
-0.42530229687690735,
-0.5153964161872864,
-0.20988990366458893,
0.5164608359336853,
0.798068106174469,
0.1687953770160675,
-0.3496209383010864,
-0.17948676645755768,
-0.21305103600025177,
0.20658178627490997,
0.44691699743270874,
0.041422054171562195,
0.6530061364173889,
-0.23936083912849426,
0.3818593919277191,
0.38941964507102966,
-0.2750908434391022,
-0.2883106470108032,
-0.36463361978530884,
-0.9744644165039062,
-0.32127645611763,
0.5668498873710632,
0.8152128458023071,
-1.2791318893432617,
-0.03683125972747803,
-0.3460977375507355,
-0.19472703337669373,
-0.5451477766036987,
0.18292808532714844,
0.8509827256202698,
0.7040425539016724,
0.63754802942276,
-0.12590645253658295,
-0.6632747054100037,
-1.1888699531555176,
0.22616304457187653,
0.02154027856886387,
0.1257401704788208,
0.5793560147285461,
0.6958204507827759,
-0.546553909778595,
0.4627673029899597,
-0.21167828142642975,
-0.6678721308708191,
-0.2845492362976074,
0.2875252962112427,
-0.012376606464385986,
0.7206087112426758,
0.19708482921123505,
-1.3646934032440186,
-0.5290252566337585,
0.26342302560806274,
-0.7972338795661926,
0.20260721445083618,
-0.045163944363594055,
0.08357879519462585,
0.2853224575519562,
0.6340469717979431,
-0.3271840512752533,
-0.23624178767204285,
0.6250468492507935,
-0.15331760048866272,
0.20307707786560059,
-0.23487791419029236,
0.3563876450061798,
-1.677746295928955,
0.06740100681781769,
0.13649259507656097,
0.04451700299978256,
-0.696483850479126,
0.025954855605959892,
0.2256036400794983,
0.02434706874191761,
-0.48482567071914673,
0.8637871146202087,
-0.7455670237541199,
0.23369163274765015,
-0.27956950664520264,
0.10455050319433212,
-0.003858056617900729,
0.3871496915817261,
0.10250406712293625,
0.7024136185646057,
0.45092302560806274,
-0.6502711772918701,
0.10762795060873032,
0.2483246922492981,
-0.15790404379367828,
0.9386880993843079,
-0.4668126106262207,
0.1255095899105072,
-0.38873979449272156,
-0.025763211771845818,
-1.0316646099090576,
-0.3764101266860962,
0.38373273611068726,
-0.43539339303970337,
0.6640843749046326,
-0.11509353667497635,
-0.4834405481815338,
0.1377970427274704,
-0.055231209844350815,
0.6322561502456665,
0.13329127430915833,
-0.423470139503479,
0.9179849624633789,
0.40581730008125305,
-0.24760206043720245,
-0.6494630575180054,
-0.9148002862930298,
0.03510412946343422,
-0.21222369372844696,
-0.4890078604221344,
0.5397063493728638,
-0.08627088367938995,
-0.1434072107076645,
0.16230963170528412,
0.07741501927375793,
-0.21531708538532257,
-0.1877090483903885,
0.41464048624038696,
0.4586661159992218,
-0.2150656133890152,
0.35152584314346313,
0.035865869373083115,
-0.5425416827201843,
-0.3167434632778168,
0.2733699083328247,
0.4806468188762665,
-0.10668983310461044,
-0.21328572928905487,
-0.47321203351020813,
0.45005810260772705,
0.42826205492019653,
-0.3582572340965271,
0.7656079530715942,
0.9934911131858826,
-0.5135709047317505,
0.38869860768318176,
-0.7908293008804321,
-0.11105777323246002,
-0.3942064940929413,
0.46714669466018677,
-0.8418180346488953,
-1.0573116540908813,
0.3380700945854187,
-0.11754157394170761,
-0.2639000713825226,
0.4419635534286499,
0.5873677134513855,
0.008551574312150478,
0.9306924939155579,
0.7744281888008118,
0.007848966866731644,
0.40318164229393005,
-0.0716855451464653,
0.18365822732448578,
-0.9505040049552917,
-0.8368896245956421,
-0.33305689692497253,
-0.5130068063735962,
-0.8143061995506287,
-0.7101358771324158,
0.24968524277210236,
-0.012929393909871578,
0.11313977092504501,
0.33693727850914,
-0.10069644451141357,
0.6211938858032227,
0.3042202591896057,
0.07448074221611023,
0.16020159423351288,
0.0871012732386589,
-0.45725858211517334,
-0.3293042480945587,
-0.28896644711494446,
-0.3549349009990692,
0.6749749779701233,
0.08840448409318924,
0.5099027156829834,
0.5243210196495056,
0.570838451385498,
-0.027209576219320297,
0.08243619650602341,
-0.8215543031692505,
0.4254130721092224,
-0.21307827532291412,
-0.5208752751350403,
0.04288613051176071,
-0.5464772582054138,
-0.9713042974472046,
0.613346517086029,
-0.5094014406204224,
-0.4159669578075409,
0.3815045654773712,
-0.038300108164548874,
-0.0017663296312093735,
0.023244839161634445,
-0.6921217441558838,
0.7573504447937012,
-0.19620689749717712,
-0.43190309405326843,
-0.20965489745140076,
-0.9290523529052734,
0.23720264434814453,
-0.09971964359283447,
0.5770626664161682,
-0.09995430707931519,
-0.37462618947029114,
0.7096487879753113,
0.3616865873336792,
0.6275545358657837,
0.03274954855442047,
0.1528489738702774,
-0.27027857303619385,
0.1721588671207428,
0.42847898602485657,
0.042959101498126984,
-0.0678538829088211,
0.09049578011035919,
-0.3337116241455078,
-0.165360227227211,
-0.41590043902397156,
1.0035899877548218,
-0.6424341201782227,
-0.12623904645442963,
-0.4778364300727844,
-0.6542495489120483,
-0.10965485125780106,
0.34830740094184875,
0.1316991001367569,
0.4595339894294739,
-0.32619088888168335,
0.21310138702392578,
0.5859887599945068,
0.004387488588690758,
0.6227344870567322,
0.6862894296646118,
-0.11940381675958633,
-0.8634375929832458,
1.2680460214614868,
0.03112691640853882,
0.12428870797157288,
0.8953871130943298,
-0.16010892391204834,
-0.4433521032333374,
-0.3298686742782593,
-0.4263196289539337,
0.42107367515563965,
-0.7103239297866821,
-0.2106613963842392,
-1.0676591396331787,
-0.022834939882159233,
-0.12290452420711517,
-0.04180217906832695,
-0.12851306796073914,
-0.4145269989967346,
-0.5766354203224182,
-0.015584567561745644,
-0.07079809904098511,
0.527982234954834,
-0.19632193446159363,
0.06251347064971924,
-0.6732742786407471,
0.5075651407241821,
0.3039693236351013,
0.14079619944095612,
-0.13685719668865204,
-0.3219781219959259,
-0.040020715445280075,
-0.0854392871260643,
-0.1776350885629654,
-0.8573974967002869,
0.3429221212863922,
0.44518736004829407,
0.5785636305809021,
0.4788894057273865,
-0.3559648096561432,
0.578879714012146,
-0.6522384285926819,
0.39291003346443176,
0.6105952262878418,
-0.5818882584571838,
0.3344452977180481,
-0.0187740046530962,
0.12893754243850708,
0.7088508009910583,
0.8138127326965332,
-0.713812530040741,
0.07074356079101562,
-0.33910447359085083,
-0.8549463152885437,
0.5498151183128357,
0.16257047653198242,
0.3628110885620117,
-0.17556585371494293,
-0.06707523763179779,
0.21870651841163635,
0.10552772879600525,
-0.9161065816879272,
-0.24203208088874817,
0.006524385418742895,
-0.3837956190109253,
-0.30343830585479736,
-0.5119563341140747,
0.061528049409389496,
0.017548149451613426,
0.7159972786903381,
-0.08581244200468063,
0.10848402231931686,
-0.05639295279979706,
-0.4837682545185089,
0.21211986243724823,
0.5897048115730286,
0.629513680934906,
0.2769566774368286,
0.04573335498571396,
0.5679969191551208,
0.09882223606109619,
-0.16921620070934296,
0.25062036514282227,
0.44022345542907715,
-0.07455923408269882,
0.029416879639029503,
0.09175903350114822,
0.7688295841217041,
0.5293848514556885,
-0.5915924906730652,
0.45180290937423706,
-0.05886547267436981,
-0.1485413759946823,
-0.09443414211273193,
-0.2772178649902344,
0.24487090110778809,
0.5334286689758301,
0.12835274636745453,
0.17090922594070435,
0.27873995900154114,
-0.3474979102611542,
0.2491408884525299,
0.3983071446418762,
-0.7157197594642639,
-0.3135361969470978,
0.4790315628051758,
0.1672789305448532,
-0.1567673534154892,
0.7392479181289673,
-0.436877578496933,
-0.5141037702560425,
0.4202539026737213,
0.8115789294242859,
0.46745261549949646,
-0.39953839778900146,
0.1505095660686493,
0.6185518503189087,
0.2429593950510025,
-0.058121345937252045,
0.2903057038784027,
0.08217687904834747,
-0.9087862372398376,
-0.10847542434930801,
-0.5667610168457031,
-0.28959915041923523,
0.04834924265742302,
-0.6265758872032166,
0.3562767803668976,
-0.21421009302139282,
-0.13912475109100342,
0.3167884945869446,
-0.23578234016895294,
-0.6719164252281189,
0.31375664472579956,
0.2390214204788208,
0.2704315483570099,
-0.8248412013053894,
0.6268121600151062,
0.9325059652328491,
-0.7202824354171753,
-0.5370640754699707,
-0.2799536883831024,
0.30805766582489014,
-0.6075404286384583,
0.9755904674530029,
0.5249729752540588,
-0.1269526332616806,
0.02582520805299282,
0.14724722504615784,
-0.8879366517066956,
1.0915719270706177,
0.16189266741275787,
-0.547524631023407,
-0.020228929817676544,
0.02051844447851181,
0.3637791872024536,
-0.5168083310127258,
0.4065331220626831,
0.05372154712677002,
0.5292076468467712,
0.3431296944618225,
-0.9147830009460449,
0.040358252823352814,
-0.6301577091217041,
0.12999391555786133,
0.549147367477417,
-0.5894906520843506,
0.9634461402893066,
-0.3799818158149719,
-0.24281355738639832,
-0.11090292036533356,
0.5873394012451172,
0.2038496434688568,
0.4647192358970642,
0.41164425015449524,
0.6743950247764587,
0.6137650609016418,
-0.10022289305925369,
0.7554662823677063,
-0.1623382866382599,
0.2350291758775711,
1.2773146629333496,
-0.420952171087265,
1.0173742771148682,
0.7510136961936951,
0.1821819543838501,
0.6303630471229553,
0.3783561885356903,
-0.4058067798614502,
0.6682575345039368,
-0.1192772313952446,
-0.35310742259025574,
-0.14337566494941711,
-0.5259096026420593,
-0.4049011766910553,
0.519554853439331,
0.25198355317115784,
-0.4233209788799286,
-0.3009411096572876,
0.3851063549518585,
0.21094359457492828,
0.05221589654684067,
-0.11309749633073807,
1.0213779211044312,
0.06150718033313751,
-0.27405422925949097,
0.14704151451587677,
0.16038493812084198,
1.014331340789795,
-0.4329836368560791,
-0.30830469727516174,
-0.07136176526546478,
0.23706911504268646,
-0.15510985255241394,
-0.553952157497406,
0.21227099001407623,
-0.21376579999923706,
-0.6228942275047302,
-0.06255972385406494,
0.7008537650108337,
-0.7944132685661316,
-0.6695645451545715,
0.49942681193351746,
0.7264485955238342,
0.19855140149593353,
0.14966116845607758,
-0.7466078996658325,
-0.17910583317279816,
-0.1702040433883667,
0.11510572582483292,
0.602716326713562,
0.24358008801937103,
0.02120310068130493,
0.6685888171195984,
0.6402610540390015,
-0.28185567259788513,
-0.17658084630966187,
0.19138367474079132,
0.7679176926612854,
-0.6087326407432556,
-0.4062356650829315,
-0.8865470886230469,
0.5214643478393555,
-0.0047484468668699265,
-0.20857146382331848,
0.7161597609519958,
0.8732718229293823,
1.035567045211792,
-0.007611432578414679,
0.4425506591796875,
-0.11602580547332764,
0.48059871792793274,
-0.6639289855957031,
0.5555934906005859,
-0.8085591793060303,
-0.003644180716946721,
-0.19740085303783417,
-0.8201308846473694,
-0.4144621193408966,
0.5040167570114136,
-0.07736930251121521,
0.08097682148218155,
0.7897257208824158,
1.047572135925293,
-0.2176416516304016,
-0.27654990553855896,
0.3208179771900177,
-0.08325110375881195,
0.07518588751554489,
0.7281068563461304,
0.8575977683067322,
-0.6235814690589905,
0.6874783039093018,
-0.3571493923664093,
0.04526796191930771,
-0.19472728669643402,
-0.7740904092788696,
-0.8365818858146667,
-0.841018557548523,
-0.45807287096977234,
-0.18074950575828552,
0.03776447847485542,
1.031072735786438,
0.5759177207946777,
-0.8711236119270325,
-0.04130783677101135,
0.17163816094398499,
0.1952834129333496,
-0.09882871806621552,
-0.22656169533729553,
0.2356896549463272,
-0.15394245088100433,
-0.8746370077133179,
0.46169909834861755,
0.25105732679367065,
0.35623621940612793,
0.1308702975511551,
-0.2507457435131073,
-0.5290473699569702,
-0.20714154839515686,
0.5851739645004272,
-0.02507120929658413,
-0.7048196196556091,
0.08358345180749893,
0.023382822051644325,
-0.35419267416000366,
0.09426341950893402,
0.6383949518203735,
-0.5405508279800415,
0.5780851244926453,
0.4046662747859955,
0.7032609581947327,
0.40552517771720886,
-0.35448798537254333,
0.22293874621391296,
-0.5624913573265076,
0.08825437724590302,
0.11657523363828659,
0.44418418407440186,
0.6793165802955627,
-0.19839371740818024,
0.4991280734539032,
0.17910872399806976,
-0.36109820008277893,
-0.5901045203208923,
0.2917696535587311,
-1.0906895399093628,
-0.1605028361082077,
1.1403393745422363,
0.04130817577242851,
0.16994424164295197,
-0.1925445795059204,
-0.3050612807273865,
0.3391328454017639,
-0.4050629138946533,
0.43216514587402344,
0.6821576952934265,
-0.09500936418771744,
-0.704811692237854,
-0.49837374687194824,
0.13098780810832977,
0.27021586894989014,
-0.7397151589393616,
-0.5718551874160767,
0.7079032063484192,
0.40774300694465637,
0.3824026882648468,
0.36858054995536804,
-0.11977402120828629,
0.21742349863052368,
-0.02077343314886093,
0.2058449685573578,
-0.23200887441635132,
-0.41140300035476685,
-0.5848499536514282,
0.32649824023246765,
-0.13930103182792664,
-0.1771455705165863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17120v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17120v2
|
Talking Nonsense: Probing Large Language Models' Understanding of Adversarial Gibberish Inputs
| 2024-04-26T02:29:26 | 2024-04-29T17:41:51 |
Valeriia Cherepanova, James Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) exhibit excellent ability to understand human
languages, but do they also understand their own language that appears
gibberish to us? In this work we delve into this question, aiming to uncover
the mechanisms underlying such behavior in LLMs. We employ the Greedy
Coordinate Gradient optimizer to craft prompts that compel LLMs to generate
coherent responses from seemingly nonsensical inputs. We call these inputs LM
Babel and this work systematically studies the behavior of LLMs manipulated by
these prompts. We find that the manipulation efficiency depends on the target
text's length and perplexity, with the Babel prompts often located in lower
loss minima compared to natural prompts. We further examine the structure of
the Babel prompts and evaluate their robustness. Notably, we find that guiding
the model to generate harmful texts is not more difficult than into generating
benign texts, suggesting lack of alignment for out-of-distribution prompts.
|
[
-0.40422743558883667,
-1.3167506456375122,
0.6064977645874023,
-0.05913563817739487,
-0.16246816515922546,
0.07443143427371979,
-0.15216682851314545,
-0.32413142919540405,
0.14841894805431366,
0.6060943603515625,
-0.8233295679092407,
-0.35501688718795776,
-0.7454999089241028,
0.11655218154191971,
-0.5099893808364868,
1.3085592985153198,
0.36631157994270325,
0.061595771461725235,
-0.1874016523361206,
-0.06838874518871307,
-0.48205888271331787,
-0.5520697236061096,
-0.6357366442680359,
-0.4245474934577942,
0.7211042046546936,
0.23833328485488892,
1.2492146492004395,
0.6006287932395935,
0.20320206880569458,
0.32908642292022705,
-0.3997221291065216,
0.031173067167401314,
-0.9580219984054565,
0.2540086805820465,
-0.2981455326080322,
-0.6104035973548889,
-0.112122543156147,
-0.21771502494812012,
0.5913885831832886,
0.7960424423217773,
0.128312885761261,
0.0500972718000412,
0.22791732847690582,
0.3401987850666046,
-0.4076038599014282,
0.11333925276994705,
-0.7980307936668396,
-0.07758942991495132,
-0.24772249162197113,
-0.20161333680152893,
-0.5462947487831116,
-0.08238400518894196,
-0.00567630585283041,
-0.5281038284301758,
0.2599415183067322,
0.13975803554058075,
0.9568818807601929,
0.3347181975841522,
-0.20455621182918549,
-0.6850122809410095,
-0.4747406840324402,
0.536745548248291,
-0.5892013311386108,
-0.0031499944161623716,
0.38962000608444214,
0.1241813451051712,
-0.5158126950263977,
-0.3680509924888611,
-0.6033524870872498,
-0.4879761338233948,
-0.21528689563274384,
-0.039419833570718765,
-0.5263100862503052,
0.18144142627716064,
0.3609853684902191,
0.2599200904369354,
-0.8030392527580261,
0.21231374144554138,
-0.29039856791496277,
-0.3828977942466736,
0.40974321961402893,
0.2491251677274704,
0.45202669501304626,
-0.22338652610778809,
-0.33213427662849426,
0.0058308253064751625,
-0.7623282670974731,
-0.12276803702116013,
0.6372160315513611,
0.16005077958106995,
-0.16061054170131683,
0.7091026902198792,
0.22242864966392517,
1.034771203994751,
0.10227479785680771,
0.12142366915941238,
-0.44004398584365845,
-0.22137340903282166,
-0.1479945331811905,
-0.06451588124036789,
0.9653608202934265,
0.16830140352249146,
0.518238365650177,
-0.15800800919532776,
-0.3733004927635193,
0.010787994600832462,
0.2558736801147461,
-0.5362130403518677,
-0.34235718846321106,
0.21709933876991272,
-0.12964792549610138,
-0.40455204248428345,
-0.3462536036968231,
-0.4969356060028076,
-0.8099047541618347,
-0.15332700312137604,
0.3900354504585266,
-0.7889906167984009,
0.07333599776029587,
0.3217700719833374,
-0.17674759030342102,
0.025860270485281944,
0.1838911920785904,
-0.9715960621833801,
0.026904473081231117,
0.8198277354240417,
0.7614846229553223,
-0.008747698739171028,
-0.2713465988636017,
-0.7790266871452332,
-0.1771191656589508,
-0.44290027022361755,
0.7545209527015686,
-0.40884920954704285,
-0.634044885635376,
-0.043389372527599335,
-0.1606713980436325,
0.005838004872202873,
-0.46951818466186523,
0.4939274787902832,
-0.7289612889289856,
0.37911006808280945,
-0.20035362243652344,
-0.3573154807090759,
-0.2183147370815277,
0.2528257668018341,
-0.5908548831939697,
0.5533093214035034,
-0.04591985046863556,
-0.7052038311958313,
-0.1101159080862999,
-0.5140515565872192,
-0.27939388155937195,
0.16208602488040924,
-0.004709898494184017,
0.08509144932031631,
0.35608336329460144,
0.00025719896075315773,
0.48167237639427185,
-0.29914426803588867,
0.46969887614250183,
-0.38173580169677734,
-0.30609408020973206,
0.7578784227371216,
-0.9441948533058167,
0.8613810539245605,
0.2980536222457886,
-0.08610176295042038,
0.2179475724697113,
-0.471818208694458,
-0.20194223523139954,
0.37828320264816284,
-0.3163122534751892,
-0.3638385534286499,
-0.08511367440223694,
-0.11219213902950287,
0.11683160811662674,
0.20330961048603058,
-0.04170982167124748,
0.31105437874794006,
-0.5980801582336426,
0.4950650632381439,
0.792432427406311,
-0.16931316256523132,
0.4210663437843323,
-0.29985395073890686,
0.6652197241783142,
-0.17882591485977173,
0.11072473973035812,
-0.36530762910842896,
-0.5026171803474426,
-0.7393345832824707,
-0.08414949476718903,
0.18967996537685394,
0.3301306664943695,
-1.027274250984192,
0.17915533483028412,
-0.2478572428226471,
-0.2613033950328827,
-0.49018436670303345,
0.1577633023262024,
0.466584712266922,
0.6279947757720947,
0.10681970417499542,
0.19486114382743835,
-0.02838767319917679,
-1.0926867723464966,
-0.3995029926300049,
-0.41881105303764343,
-0.12764723598957062,
0.14994056522846222,
0.5237151384353638,
-0.13012701272964478,
0.7342084050178528,
-0.4258195757865906,
0.2839534878730774,
-0.30752602219581604,
0.323148250579834,
0.18416444957256317,
0.08065701276063919,
0.5701247453689575,
-0.6547097563743591,
-0.3060086667537689,
-0.14766821265220642,
-0.5835274457931519,
-0.31205061078071594,
-0.31561416387557983,
-0.11559046059846878,
0.21594451367855072,
0.3846977949142456,
-0.7424079775810242,
0.06192152202129364,
0.71593177318573,
-0.5823416113853455,
0.766264021396637,
-0.1711965948343277,
-0.12363682687282562,
-0.7789944410324097,
0.013582839630544186,
-0.11389514803886414,
-0.3088036775588989,
-0.7256333827972412,
0.09136540442705154,
0.1011442095041275,
-0.14632920920848846,
-0.5043741464614868,
0.6018284559249878,
-0.6344355344772339,
0.09467515349388123,
-0.33136889338493347,
0.44451504945755005,
0.17046909034252167,
0.39792147278785706,
-0.259037047624588,
0.8070046901702881,
0.5660637617111206,
-0.6168731451034546,
0.4360664188861847,
0.06581971049308777,
-0.22492948174476624,
0.5746127963066101,
-0.6813244819641113,
0.08394095301628113,
-0.33082497119903564,
0.08742427825927734,
-1.1226726770401,
-0.37001070380210876,
0.6713056564331055,
-0.664960503578186,
0.5527809262275696,
-0.27067622542381287,
-0.3328722417354584,
-0.19738595187664032,
-0.21699266135692596,
0.26446908712387085,
0.40518972277641296,
-0.4805760383605957,
0.42978963255882263,
0.35418158769607544,
-0.33462798595428467,
-0.684464693069458,
-0.7411261200904846,
0.3929658532142639,
-0.2910793423652649,
-0.6006551384925842,
-0.04335581883788109,
-0.2741442620754242,
-0.5546855330467224,
-0.1416628062725067,
0.1725355088710785,
0.23793980479240417,
0.24353612959384918,
0.12659014761447906,
0.3338797688484192,
-0.36039450764656067,
0.0813286080956459,
-0.12161655724048615,
0.0469709187746048,
0.4869123101234436,
-0.3145068883895874,
0.8795499801635742,
-0.026088034734129906,
-0.478118360042572,
-0.45508837699890137,
0.4026045501232147,
0.866598904132843,
0.08568453788757324,
0.7913608551025391,
0.25363048911094666,
-0.15036579966545105,
-0.37215283513069153,
-0.24641941487789154,
-0.15854480862617493,
-0.5156514644622803,
0.684207558631897,
-0.44956174492836,
-0.6587770581245422,
0.5518890023231506,
0.3834074139595032,
-0.09588268399238586,
0.32636758685112,
0.6641184091567993,
0.1398681253194809,
1.1046273708343506,
0.39787280559539795,
-0.14476278424263,
0.29091864824295044,
-0.10190977156162262,
0.11494526267051697,
-0.43032798171043396,
-0.12880395352840424,
-0.5208663940429688,
-0.16549555957317352,
-0.1682572364807129,
-0.5893647074699402,
0.2107612043619156,
0.1635896861553192,
-0.02334311045706272,
0.0410730242729187,
-0.26964378356933594,
0.8319896459579468,
0.40671664476394653,
-0.2493424266576767,
0.0907411202788353,
-0.050159670412540436,
-0.0686258003115654,
0.11664587259292603,
-0.9035908579826355,
-0.6768001317977905,
0.6083057522773743,
0.5866627097129822,
1.058794617652893,
0.08206509798765182,
0.1857592761516571,
0.20193862915039062,
0.30015575885772705,
-1.175506830215454,
0.619373619556427,
0.07983189076185226,
-0.5367622971534729,
-0.12261199951171875,
-0.39556023478507996,
-1.0048030614852905,
0.2643381953239441,
-0.15748655796051025,
-0.6121497750282288,
-0.1281803399324417,
0.30329933762550354,
-0.30825427174568176,
0.3384641706943512,
-0.6911324262619019,
0.6482945084571838,
-0.4456915557384491,
-0.2963545322418213,
-0.04709497466683388,
-0.5187221765518188,
0.6336891651153564,
-0.019411560148000717,
0.2434772402048111,
0.1462497115135193,
-0.1167512759566307,
0.49620699882507324,
-0.1152077317237854,
0.9511247873306274,
0.05150441825389862,
-0.7420119047164917,
0.15209093689918518,
0.4652692675590515,
0.6697258949279785,
0.20992319285869598,
-0.07183753699064255,
0.4284888803958893,
-0.47513720393180847,
-0.45856958627700806,
-0.6371473073959351,
0.7340424060821533,
-0.5377077460289001,
-0.8698031306266785,
-0.3540874719619751,
-0.7660021185874939,
-0.21242386102676392,
0.0602908656001091,
0.6106623411178589,
0.5606968402862549,
-0.27092015743255615,
-0.014896613545715809,
0.791563093662262,
-0.4992251694202423,
0.26197004318237305,
0.5747813582420349,
-0.22873996198177338,
-0.1639123260974884,
0.9570427536964417,
-0.058209601789712906,
0.7048543691635132,
0.20257991552352905,
0.18187299370765686,
-0.5333726406097412,
-0.7011911869049072,
-0.8249828815460205,
0.42750826478004456,
-0.8647613525390625,
-0.06994654983282089,
-0.5716286897659302,
-0.05758359283208847,
-0.2903182804584503,
-0.05207044258713722,
-0.05740143358707428,
-0.2150929719209671,
-0.5899323225021362,
-0.059815842658281326,
0.10706541687250137,
1.0745292901992798,
0.1291121542453766,
0.39635583758354187,
-0.7124829888343811,
0.30780941247940063,
0.07455383986234665,
0.010409369133412838,
-0.07731173187494278,
-0.8290959000587463,
-0.09777500480413437,
0.419294536113739,
-0.17199137806892395,
-1.2158198356628418,
0.40070873498916626,
0.03779009357094765,
0.39510807394981384,
0.7454108595848083,
0.0078102643601596355,
0.43556973338127136,
-0.49594926834106445,
0.948137104511261,
0.17450493574142456,
-0.8738206028938293,
0.3380318880081177,
-0.6018164157867432,
0.40146493911743164,
0.027019020169973373,
0.4613003730773926,
-0.6480050683021545,
-0.7427584528923035,
-0.5216183066368103,
-0.7099670171737671,
0.870360791683197,
0.028785906732082367,
0.4737149775028229,
-0.16050924360752106,
0.2280975878238678,
0.22441187500953674,
-0.008774781599640846,
-0.7172490954399109,
-0.5008842349052429,
-0.09089814126491547,
-0.12853628396987915,
-0.2155124545097351,
-0.5285694003105164,
-0.43304240703582764,
0.3885685205459595,
0.502442479133606,
-0.308793306350708,
0.01480124518275261,
-0.08704236149787903,
-0.21554528176784515,
0.012917222455143929,
0.2927549183368683,
0.8735272884368896,
0.3597243130207062,
0.3529830276966095,
0.1701769381761551,
0.0810718685388565,
-0.384547621011734,
-0.008415482006967068,
-0.1770952194929123,
-0.17989099025726318,
0.03620064631104469,
0.5201656222343445,
0.9865736365318298,
0.04968314245343208,
-0.6706184148788452,
0.43260860443115234,
-0.2822995185852051,
-0.28047382831573486,
0.12490739673376083,
0.24789923429489136,
0.2265736311674118,
0.0986725315451622,
0.22784173488616943,
0.11751203238964081,
0.032169513404369354,
-0.5224306583404541,
-0.11090202629566193,
0.8736976385116577,
-0.26799276471138,
-0.574279248714447,
0.6053539514541626,
0.018052129074931145,
-0.5767651200294495,
0.3682641088962555,
-0.24731488525867462,
-0.6626849174499512,
0.41927555203437805,
0.8194593787193298,
0.5999771952629089,
-0.019331082701683044,
0.4900115132331848,
-0.06889721006155014,
0.31570106744766235,
0.19647029042243958,
-0.05286477878689766,
0.04279335215687752,
-0.577860414981842,
-0.42654135823249817,
-0.5834861993789673,
-0.43042799830436707,
0.5523611903190613,
-0.4967671036720276,
0.30233290791511536,
-0.3204844295978546,
0.0753047913312912,
0.06006086245179176,
-0.4434153437614441,
-0.3725726008415222,
-0.03262848034501076,
0.4131585657596588,
0.7519845962524414,
-0.6970897316932678,
0.5186185836791992,
0.6701034903526306,
-0.21920828521251678,
-0.6582055687904358,
0.19506403803825378,
0.27326998114585876,
-1.1381285190582275,
0.5645204186439514,
0.0019692303612828255,
-0.30145466327667236,
0.013393748551607132,
-0.7755188345909119,
-0.7349060773849487,
0.35830947756767273,
0.8617857694625854,
-0.4483197331428528,
-0.04736541956663132,
0.3300970792770386,
0.44844651222229004,
0.1406847983598709,
0.26319098472595215,
0.4508971571922302,
0.5233046412467957,
0.13748615980148315,
-0.6723645925521851,
0.11653223633766174,
-0.274445503950119,
-0.19520117342472076,
0.22135336697101593,
-0.6454609036445618,
0.9072935581207275,
-0.25933387875556946,
-0.5628649592399597,
0.13101954758167267,
0.5157503485679626,
0.07349245995283127,
0.08610398322343826,
0.31368061900138855,
0.12508630752563477,
0.8834441304206848,
-0.07354481518268585,
1.2192693948745728,
-0.38402804732322693,
0.15318165719509125,
0.8303097486495972,
-0.05094803869724274,
0.3718586564064026,
0.47180840373039246,
0.09274601191282272,
0.28885096311569214,
0.5593088865280151,
0.16398204863071442,
0.13235512375831604,
0.49173736572265625,
-0.2778892517089844,
-0.10191880911588669,
-0.10961909592151642,
-0.1509786695241928,
0.2852632999420166,
0.633474588394165,
-0.08001682162284851,
-0.32834506034851074,
0.16054114699363708,
0.28443261981010437,
-0.026275483891367912,
-0.2202199250459671,
0.8031725883483887,
0.09063877910375595,
-0.9159569144248962,
1.164664387702942,
0.0006397645338438451,
0.8053553104400635,
-0.7892124056816101,
0.30003854632377625,
-0.2468913346529007,
-0.020987845957279205,
0.020567018538713455,
-0.8377373218536377,
0.30170875787734985,
0.10910392552614212,
-0.23065532743930817,
-0.19398100674152374,
0.7024327516555786,
-0.4188113808631897,
-0.13631601631641388,
0.27092722058296204,
0.4042169749736786,
0.3051083981990814,
-0.21243758499622345,
-0.8614988923072815,
0.023871690034866333,
0.003183091292157769,
-0.41637203097343445,
0.42149674892425537,
0.7920002937316895,
0.01369574572890997,
0.8278464674949646,
0.7860480546951294,
0.35779449343681335,
-0.027510954067111015,
-0.03383680805563927,
0.8516632914543152,
-0.6161050796508789,
-0.39727771282196045,
-1.1948397159576416,
0.5202187895774841,
0.08289512246847153,
-0.36940082907676697,
0.82913738489151,
0.21304990351200104,
0.6136199235916138,
-0.21222679316997528,
0.6722230315208435,
0.18249979615211487,
0.018005995079874992,
-0.743349552154541,
1.013859510421753,
-0.5400956869125366,
0.4367579221725464,
0.1087091714143753,
-0.5414512157440186,
-0.24334608018398285,
0.3555624783039093,
-0.3305024802684784,
-0.26505565643310547,
0.6187435388565063,
1.089778184890747,
0.08526699990034103,
0.10874214768409729,
0.5885133147239685,
0.5649489164352417,
0.3354024291038513,
0.5747637152671814,
1.3044458627700806,
0.044502533972263336,
0.741791307926178,
0.2256249189376831,
-0.05706708878278732,
-0.18542452156543732,
-0.6879411339759827,
-0.9969576001167297,
-0.3107353746891022,
-0.1392960101366043,
-0.44957485795021057,
0.11311173439025879,
0.5149816274642944,
0.36976924538612366,
-0.7085369229316711,
-0.06503517925739288,
-0.16688448190689087,
0.37753596901893616,
0.32248833775520325,
-0.3060001730918884,
0.15604493021965027,
-0.5314947962760925,
-0.9280065894126892,
0.6181526780128479,
0.29628464579582214,
0.31268489360809326,
-0.5689237117767334,
-0.04929468780755997,
0.06774110347032547,
0.2730640470981598,
0.4201750159263611,
0.177387073636055,
-0.8441315293312073,
-0.16940689086914062,
0.12719900906085968,
-0.2704654633998871,
-0.20741058886051178,
0.6374263167381287,
-0.6947084665298462,
0.21855705976486206,
0.5899139046669006,
0.4731726348400116,
-0.25100570917129517,
0.0413331538438797,
0.731857419013977,
-0.6447428464889526,
-0.007576243951916695,
0.30636268854141235,
0.34751296043395996,
0.3746735751628876,
-0.5292446613311768,
-0.053304657340049744,
0.13418185710906982,
-0.5318148136138916,
-0.9270098209381104,
0.2816227376461029,
-0.654907763004303,
-0.6442207098007202,
1.4828852415084839,
-0.07861108332872391,
-0.48577460646629333,
-0.2526894509792328,
-0.5906212329864502,
0.01921340450644493,
-0.27035656571388245,
0.654958963394165,
1.0447832345962524,
-0.10691928118467331,
0.2536928057670593,
-0.5636362433433533,
0.5172547698020935,
0.603852391242981,
-0.48122772574424744,
0.36786511540412903,
0.8675753474235535,
0.2497306913137436,
0.33500728011131287,
0.420271098613739,
0.0800604522228241,
0.10515059530735016,
0.10046734660863876,
-0.43300092220306396,
-0.12524572014808655,
-0.3201753497123718,
-0.7468642592430115,
0.32175493240356445,
0.11026874929666519,
0.011427910067141056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17609v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17609v2
|
CoSD: Collaborative Stance Detection with Contrastive Heterogeneous Topic Graph Learning
| 2024-04-26T02:04:05 | 2024-06-19T13:34:24 |
Yinghan Cheng, Qi Zhang, Chongyang Shi, Liang Xiao, Shufeng Hao, Liang Hu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Stance detection seeks to identify the viewpoints of individuals either in
favor or against a given target or a controversial topic. Current advanced
neural models for stance detection typically employ fully parametric softmax
classifiers. However, these methods suffer from several limitations, including
lack of explainability, insensitivity to the latent data structure, and
unimodality, which greatly restrict their performance and applications. To
address these challenges, we present a novel collaborative stance detection
framework called (CoSD) which leverages contrastive heterogeneous topic graph
learning to learn topic-aware semantics and collaborative signals among texts,
topics, and stance labels for enhancing stance detection. During training, we
construct a heterogeneous graph to structurally organize texts and stances
through implicit topics via employing latent Dirichlet allocation. We then
perform contrastive graph learning to learn heterogeneous node representations,
aggregating informative multi-hop collaborative signals via an elaborate
Collaboration Propagation Aggregation (CPA) module. During inference, we
introduce a hybrid similarity scoring module to enable the comprehensive
incorporation of topic-aware semantics and collaborative signals for stance
detection. Extensive experiments on two benchmark datasets demonstrate the
state-of-the-art detection performance of CoSD, verifying the effectiveness and
explainability of our collaborative framework.
|
[
-0.7188622951507568,
-0.755208432674408,
0.5001766085624695,
0.07414890080690384,
-0.335010826587677,
0.12459453195333481,
-0.0296885147690773,
0.05415160208940506,
0.7168183326721191,
0.24823236465454102,
-0.6284174919128418,
-1.0115646123886108,
-0.5676214098930359,
-0.2659987807273865,
0.09206759184598923,
1.1604690551757812,
0.057369083166122437,
0.20337282121181488,
-0.30543503165245056,
-0.7341678142547607,
-0.21819765865802765,
-0.1528817117214203,
-0.57414311170578,
-0.3830937445163727,
0.4835468530654907,
0.4974750578403473,
0.7120243906974792,
0.17543204128742218,
0.11491742730140686,
0.3798659145832062,
-0.22741970419883728,
-0.02980150654911995,
-0.4032977521419525,
0.09640756249427795,
-0.23873336613178253,
-0.23593713343143463,
-0.743206262588501,
0.27073413133621216,
0.5991443991661072,
1.1439226865768433,
0.04478343576192856,
-0.2243703454732895,
-0.07406166195869446,
0.242508202791214,
-0.38247957825660706,
0.06294189393520355,
-0.4702301621437073,
0.4027363657951355,
-0.12896575033664703,
0.11415692418813705,
-0.3699919581413269,
-0.08868716657161713,
0.22820700705051422,
-0.680594801902771,
0.4646901786327362,
0.04410998523235321,
0.6670981049537659,
0.03917519003152847,
-0.3840824365615845,
-0.20199230313301086,
0.005148520693182945,
0.6563624143600464,
-0.23025399446487427,
0.5826311707496643,
0.274006724357605,
-0.08174523711204529,
-0.043522365391254425,
-0.7702127695083618,
-0.7752066254615784,
-0.07822426408529282,
0.1010197177529335,
0.4699973165988922,
-0.18280954658985138,
0.15483973920345306,
-0.06221867352724075,
0.4099580943584442,
-0.7148475646972656,
0.26716187596321106,
0.2474105805158615,
-0.4171121418476105,
0.3302742838859558,
0.13045744597911835,
0.3436323404312134,
-0.39715614914894104,
-0.710617184638977,
-0.06540738046169281,
-0.210428386926651,
0.07904135435819626,
0.669450044631958,
0.3092746138572693,
-0.48059406876564026,
0.3971577286720276,
0.07436008006334305,
0.46801823377609253,
0.6251572370529175,
0.26749637722969055,
0.47807690501213074,
-0.29509544372558594,
-0.05399031564593315,
-0.044216349720954895,
0.8041239380836487,
0.37214675545692444,
-0.6607902646064758,
-0.3115150034427643,
0.06442089378833771,
0.3068450689315796,
-0.014362105168402195,
-0.4920963943004608,
-0.3215557634830475,
0.1706872135400772,
-0.7807186245918274,
-0.35366570949554443,
-0.005559525452554226,
-0.7679772973060608,
-0.7885519862174988,
-0.4137919843196869,
0.13146936893463135,
-0.32926908135414124,
-0.6552350521087646,
0.06312115490436554,
-0.37797150015830994,
0.21353024244308472,
0.3671870231628418,
-0.7797512412071228,
0.4930558502674103,
0.9815571904182434,
0.9287732839584351,
-0.5955916047096252,
-0.45459887385368347,
-0.7497788071632385,
0.138168603181839,
-0.44151607155799866,
0.8479017615318298,
-0.41313624382019043,
-0.4421149492263794,
-0.3049270510673523,
-0.048640333116054535,
0.06184809282422066,
-0.38468849658966064,
0.45343148708343506,
-0.41881778836250305,
0.38597026467323303,
-0.22205670177936554,
-0.8582265377044678,
0.08910345286130905,
0.639998197555542,
-0.7948711514472961,
0.6495324969291687,
0.04835522547364235,
-1.0001357793807983,
0.6891352534294128,
-0.5669723749160767,
-0.3657940924167633,
0.15494047105312347,
-0.5650429129600525,
-0.6815573573112488,
-0.2326967716217041,
-0.17081362009048462,
0.6428273320198059,
0.04893118515610695,
0.37263286113739014,
-0.7758364677429199,
-0.23992525041103363,
-0.06668148934841156,
-0.09290194511413574,
1.004092812538147,
-0.04779045283794403,
-0.17365656793117523,
0.5509324073791504,
-0.5212006568908691,
-0.3236004412174225,
-0.07630874216556549,
-0.172995924949646,
-0.4618668854236603,
-0.18699561059474945,
-0.1731029748916626,
0.1635105013847351,
0.07832053303718567,
-0.43633610010147095,
-0.1171112209558487,
-0.2712712287902832,
-0.090277761220932,
0.8415113687515259,
0.14287902414798737,
0.7291496992111206,
-0.0488307848572731,
0.32606998085975647,
0.021726638078689575,
-0.07906121015548706,
0.21207548677921295,
-0.43230950832366943,
-0.4291171133518219,
-0.5217700004577637,
-0.13387548923492432,
0.09986235201358795,
-0.6417931318283081,
0.8181433081626892,
-0.014114173129200935,
-0.2710948586463928,
-0.07913070172071457,
0.11439341306686401,
0.3195074200630188,
0.7548197507858276,
0.3422497808933258,
-0.6657533645629883,
-0.43284156918525696,
-0.5915374755859375,
-0.10420268774032593,
-0.23739153146743774,
0.42266377806663513,
0.2198846936225891,
0.41624343395233154,
-0.1638503074645996,
0.9367589354515076,
-0.5047210454940796,
-0.35577523708343506,
-0.26941022276878357,
0.6841967701911926,
-0.07800080627202988,
0.31575581431388855,
0.7171136140823364,
-1.193709135055542,
-0.5328865051269531,
-0.3270809054374695,
-0.6332125663757324,
-0.028434982523322105,
0.12544064223766327,
-0.1868727058172226,
0.021271880716085434,
0.8037004470825195,
-0.40035590529441833,
0.07899588346481323,
0.49138641357421875,
-0.7043009400367737,
0.35246413946151733,
0.011441176757216454,
-0.1985820084810257,
-1.4844235181808472,
-0.26130586862564087,
0.387161523103714,
-0.265179306268692,
-0.40906861424446106,
-0.12976887822151184,
-0.5276045799255371,
-0.2676261067390442,
-0.31970539689064026,
0.229366272687912,
-0.1855752319097519,
-0.2548515498638153,
-0.2449190467596054,
0.21390116214752197,
0.009413362480700016,
0.5061072707176208,
0.42636969685554504,
0.4107189178466797,
0.434834361076355,
-0.3890867531299591,
0.39238402247428894,
0.42626717686653137,
0.14634229242801666,
1.2107734680175781,
-0.37562325596809387,
0.30403533577919006,
-0.11560507863759995,
0.6519854068756104,
-1.397402048110962,
-0.16416361927986145,
0.47996917366981506,
-0.4251421093940735,
0.23716971278190613,
-0.43475818634033203,
-0.13038432598114014,
-0.1452724039554596,
-0.5800169110298157,
-0.06980901211500168,
-0.11108849942684174,
-0.756558895111084,
0.6211665868759155,
0.6765716075897217,
0.0007015898008830845,
-0.7080547213554382,
-0.40824058651924133,
-0.11482477188110352,
-0.14525288343429565,
-0.5182895064353943,
0.629619300365448,
0.022515837103128433,
-0.28176194429397583,
0.2689507305622101,
-0.21905958652496338,
-0.19339562952518463,
0.06729567795991898,
0.521692156791687,
0.23307925462722778,
-0.19984646141529083,
0.18472428619861603,
0.13662081956863403,
-0.5863401889801025,
-0.03708917275071144,
-0.44349515438079834,
0.8013638854026794,
-0.4999660849571228,
-0.5149739384651184,
-0.5279493927955627,
0.33897703886032104,
0.49454331398010254,
0.004680400248616934,
0.771286129951477,
1.0890191793441772,
-0.2617872655391693,
-0.22243915498256683,
-0.0609411895275116,
-0.052118849009275436,
-0.4607187509536743,
0.4705553650856018,
-0.24753445386886597,
-0.8471662998199463,
0.39395248889923096,
-0.4492703080177307,
-0.41585272550582886,
0.2202901840209961,
0.674511194229126,
-0.220175102353096,
0.7741586565971375,
0.6160042881965637,
-0.286765456199646,
0.595927357673645,
-0.5472867488861084,
-0.041678689420223236,
-0.5104594826698303,
-0.3091883659362793,
-0.4208567440509796,
-0.22752489149570465,
-0.5530163049697876,
-0.6582449078559875,
0.20420540869235992,
-0.18794140219688416,
-0.309339314699173,
0.20951855182647705,
-0.2950223386287689,
0.3808325231075287,
0.032577406615018845,
0.2553867995738983,
0.18651637434959412,
0.07190927863121033,
-0.4350809156894684,
-0.20553076267242432,
-0.35743850469589233,
-0.3033091425895691,
0.6960716247558594,
0.24089746177196503,
0.3818076252937317,
0.05694228410720825,
0.9422414898872375,
0.5988250374794006,
0.16377757489681244,
-0.9720661640167236,
0.825072705745697,
-0.44923707842826843,
-0.10620813071727753,
-0.2080220729112625,
-0.2328932136297226,
-0.647148847579956,
0.2967343032360077,
-0.25156527757644653,
-0.514106810092926,
0.3963654935359955,
0.04008020460605621,
-0.0412742979824543,
0.40628311038017273,
-0.5815929174423218,
1.1237279176712036,
-0.013632743619382381,
-0.8495540618896484,
-0.499462366104126,
-0.6028129458427429,
-0.15805542469024658,
0.33516862988471985,
-0.07838943600654602,
-0.06945941597223282,
-0.31810277700424194,
0.6888206601142883,
-0.3119029998779297,
1.2374202013015747,
-0.7020816802978516,
-0.09931694716215134,
0.204707533121109,
-0.025016486644744873,
0.3889106512069702,
0.27241918444633484,
-0.2690807580947876,
-0.04715752601623535,
-0.6553527116775513,
-0.3751940131187439,
-0.345938503742218,
0.8166413307189941,
-0.7244685292243958,
-0.37010690569877625,
-0.30878129601478577,
-0.545436680316925,
-0.44597798585891724,
0.3450002074241638,
0.25538161396980286,
0.25787004828453064,
-0.7751966714859009,
0.20379675924777985,
0.7024877071380615,
-0.0076231383718550205,
0.34244951605796814,
0.4013805389404297,
0.141640305519104,
-0.4455356001853943,
1.156753420829773,
-0.1863785982131958,
-0.05861188471317291,
0.29950258135795593,
0.34452447295188904,
-0.5385808944702148,
-0.7741486430168152,
-0.08965218812227249,
0.013506150804460049,
-0.778194785118103,
0.24124281108379364,
-0.8296865820884705,
0.4898894429206848,
-0.2616194188594818,
-0.5781680941581726,
-0.41073188185691833,
-0.2532401382923126,
-0.2950323820114136,
-0.18138545751571655,
0.0272747240960598,
0.4262666702270508,
-0.19451887905597687,
0.14340288937091827,
-0.18412718176841736,
0.6853957772254944,
0.2805653512477875,
0.44950851798057556,
-0.32400381565093994,
-0.0867193192243576,
0.36613523960113525,
-0.3712289333343506,
-0.25913888216018677,
-0.8073592185974121,
0.08867719769477844,
-0.13375979661941528,
0.7292079925537109,
0.47507244348526,
0.15999451279640198,
0.22379514575004578,
0.056748952716588974,
0.6985628604888916,
0.6605398654937744,
-1.1115226745605469,
0.2546711564064026,
-0.4961751401424408,
-0.23243802785873413,
0.6447716355323792,
0.7373887896537781,
-0.3428378105163574,
-0.11419090628623962,
-0.6659682989120483,
-0.694616436958313,
0.8012762665748596,
-0.18470853567123413,
0.2107260674238205,
0.13743221759796143,
0.19135652482509613,
0.3078952431678772,
0.15183117985725403,
-0.7430888414382935,
-0.10799170285463333,
-0.4841686189174652,
-0.489482045173645,
0.13454033434391022,
0.21446019411087036,
-0.31146708130836487,
-0.25611457228660583,
0.477223664522171,
-0.6677094101905823,
0.11267433315515518,
-0.11817804723978043,
-0.07356109470129013,
-0.03996693342924118,
0.16986149549484253,
-0.0013026574160903692,
0.1453927457332611,
-0.07970280945301056,
0.23717930912971497,
0.3121829330921173,
-0.3981412947177887,
0.15962441265583038,
0.33674657344818115,
-0.03417392447590828,
-0.016011452302336693,
0.2545728087425232,
0.7686823606491089,
0.012693491764366627,
-0.06802480667829514,
0.8250203728675842,
-0.09241838753223419,
-0.23187381029129028,
-0.08880100399255753,
-0.06672913581132889,
0.33270859718322754,
0.27290862798690796,
-0.11880882829427719,
0.3391830623149872,
0.28489965200424194,
-0.5664259195327759,
0.5457718968391418,
0.52804034948349,
-0.8238029479980469,
-0.3761543035507202,
0.31717386841773987,
0.3226623833179474,
-0.1251010149717331,
0.07570754736661911,
-0.5063359141349792,
-0.654918909072876,
0.8277331590652466,
0.5089513063430786,
0.7227375507354736,
0.07862250506877899,
0.81307452917099,
0.09322189539670944,
-0.40065908432006836,
0.20237360894680023,
0.19021204113960266,
-0.4264677166938782,
-0.9921426773071289,
0.15320710837841034,
-0.1373477280139923,
-0.7652957439422607,
0.09374746680259705,
-0.6371474862098694,
0.3962905704975128,
-0.6935539245605469,
-0.11780345439910889,
0.45128822326660156,
0.3037545680999756,
-0.2009555995464325,
0.14519359171390533,
0.11199010163545609,
0.4540817141532898,
-0.9595685601234436,
0.46799322962760925,
1.1533629894256592,
-0.4754270613193512,
-0.6327347159385681,
0.595865786075592,
0.4703611135482788,
-0.4689067602157593,
0.3389171361923218,
0.061347249895334244,
-0.5020695924758911,
-0.1285591870546341,
-0.5622456073760986,
-0.035592496395111084,
0.9864779114723206,
0.475912868976593,
-0.08740521967411041,
0.3192823827266693,
-0.012611710466444492,
0.7054136395454407,
-0.41066423058509827,
-0.12145444005727768,
-0.04125473275780678,
0.2542615830898285,
0.2149883210659027,
-0.1312195509672165,
0.11329247057437897,
-0.07536011934280396,
-0.41892552375793457,
0.04398692771792412,
-1.0702415704727173,
1.0008918046951294,
0.06538879126310349,
0.26803335547447205,
-0.22722625732421875,
0.8142703175544739,
0.24284736812114716,
0.9653158187866211,
0.8404417037963867,
0.6007980704307556,
1.0484545230865479,
-0.014945042319595814,
0.7536661624908447,
-0.009501175954937935,
0.3626927435398102,
1.111276388168335,
-0.7248494029045105,
0.47323331236839294,
0.276559978723526,
0.2009398341178894,
0.7759256958961487,
0.5070340633392334,
-0.03423134982585907,
0.5021430253982544,
-0.11790697276592255,
-0.585930347442627,
-0.467865526676178,
-0.5014292597770691,
-0.1496773213148117,
0.48370665311813354,
0.5016860365867615,
-0.27900034189224243,
-0.3894153833389282,
0.004550784360617399,
0.041750866919755936,
0.49463871121406555,
-0.28830209374427795,
0.7253146767616272,
-0.013441493734717369,
-0.6268829703330994,
0.12345656007528305,
-0.053878650069236755,
0.7705627679824829,
-0.44159525632858276,
-0.019583653658628464,
0.004494515713304281,
0.3879375755786896,
-0.3429320156574249,
-1.043813943862915,
0.26490503549575806,
-0.18994030356407166,
-0.19889172911643982,
-0.2765486538410187,
1.0153886079788208,
-0.28498756885528564,
0.22537818551063538,
0.7089241147041321,
0.492515504360199,
-0.2987208664417267,
0.37786734104156494,
-0.9211553335189819,
-0.02861221879720688,
-0.3692868947982788,
-0.0005185620975680649,
0.3734665811061859,
0.4630861282348633,
-0.10863516479730606,
0.23124951124191284,
0.5538397431373596,
-0.3030812740325928,
-0.4862384796142578,
0.33191847801208496,
1.020325779914856,
-0.1317032277584076,
-0.8840316534042358,
-0.5386314392089844,
0.08422436565160751,
-0.42440634965896606,
-0.3032340407371521,
0.7624516487121582,
0.6094489097595215,
0.8007498383522034,
0.18461734056472778,
0.6365330219268799,
-0.04097006469964981,
0.22095313668251038,
-0.322815477848053,
0.6329962015151978,
-0.43688979744911194,
0.050149720162153244,
-0.48632341623306274,
-0.5553439259529114,
-0.23310640454292297,
0.6089452505111694,
-0.507641077041626,
-0.08274055272340775,
0.46579039096832275,
0.6414240598678589,
-0.3277740478515625,
0.39459821581840515,
0.03451843559741974,
0.08784511685371399,
0.23900246620178223,
0.3512532711029053,
0.7296755909919739,
0.0879569798707962,
0.4701046347618103,
-0.17481371760368347,
-0.0638338103890419,
-0.08461945503950119,
-0.8463021516799927,
-1.0460433959960938,
-0.6886693239212036,
-0.6530115604400635,
-0.6323270201683044,
-0.005341876298189163,
1.1973960399627686,
0.9349885582923889,
-0.8114231824874878,
-0.04030412808060646,
-0.6871155500411987,
0.3891231119632721,
-0.0821303203701973,
-0.2518729865550995,
0.5137519836425781,
-0.13721704483032227,
-0.678010106086731,
0.46272966265678406,
0.23522943258285522,
-0.017358679324388504,
-0.11926507949829102,
-0.5475444197654724,
-0.4336206018924713,
-0.18275393545627594,
0.36405566334724426,
0.3008407950401306,
-0.28162887692451477,
-0.12214809656143188,
-0.07381501793861389,
-0.20554295182228088,
0.16172976791858673,
0.8769562244415283,
-0.6077331900596619,
0.4556550979614258,
0.7343674302101135,
0.5358110070228577,
0.5146634578704834,
0.019275251775979996,
0.3097534775733948,
-1.12165367603302,
0.5169283747673035,
0.3609507381916046,
0.4431842565536499,
0.4552905559539795,
-0.3230452537536621,
0.3414180278778076,
0.9535084962844849,
0.1209699735045433,
-0.6064069271087646,
0.2559831738471985,
-1.243429183959961,
-0.43643811345100403,
0.8224380612373352,
-0.345134973526001,
-0.08682866394519806,
-0.6158905625343323,
-0.32277271151542664,
0.6442072987556458,
-0.505495011806488,
0.30334046483039856,
0.41518911719322205,
-0.2679252028465271,
0.1624229997396469,
0.33104804158210754,
0.38160425424575806,
0.5797275900840759,
-0.7429457306861877,
-0.1780196577310562,
0.6165916919708252,
0.2702409029006958,
0.41504836082458496,
0.8929045796394348,
0.04744381457567215,
0.4155079424381256,
0.31092071533203125,
-0.3356846570968628,
-0.08043014258146286,
-0.286672979593277,
-0.36610034108161926,
0.644757091999054,
-0.23761099576950073,
-0.2630711793899536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17027v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17027v3
|
Player-Driven Emergence in LLM-Driven Game Narrative
| 2024-04-25T20:39:44 | 2024-06-03T21:27:14 |
Xiangyu Peng, Jessica Quaye, Sudha Rao, Weijia Xu, Portia Botchway, Chris Brockett, Nebojsa Jojic, Gabriel DesGarennes, Ken Lobb, Michael Xu, Jorge Leandro, Claire Jin, Bill Dolan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We explore how interaction with large language models (LLMs) can give rise to
emergent behaviors, empowering players to participate in the evolution of game
narratives. Our testbed is a text-adventure game in which players attempt to
solve a mystery under a fixed narrative premise, but can freely interact with
non-player characters generated by GPT-4, a large language model. We recruit 28
gamers to play the game and use GPT-4 to automatically convert the game logs
into a node-graph representing the narrative in the player's gameplay. We find
that through their interactions with the non-deterministic behavior of the LLM,
players are able to discover interesting new emergent nodes that were not a
part of the original narrative but have potential for being fun and engaging.
Players that created the most emergent nodes tended to be those that often
enjoy games that facilitate discovery, exploration and experimentation.
|
[
-0.2419915497303009,
-1.1040717363357544,
1.1193147897720337,
0.28863999247550964,
-0.03681894764304161,
0.5516964793205261,
-0.11015383899211884,
-0.7440073490142822,
0.3794955015182495,
0.47453245520591736,
-0.8215741515159607,
-0.3912222683429718,
-0.3645366430282593,
0.10776795446872711,
-0.17876538634300232,
1.101141095161438,
0.060630928725004196,
-0.5266271829605103,
-0.3219459354877472,
0.31969037652015686,
-0.3017496168613434,
-0.4534202218055725,
-0.8731091618537903,
-0.44087234139442444,
0.7083765268325806,
0.08947373181581497,
0.7057210206985474,
0.7343154549598694,
0.316438227891922,
0.33533984422683716,
0.02549203857779503,
0.1275421679019928,
-0.8736431002616882,
0.6223265528678894,
-0.2675669193267822,
-0.4726699888706207,
-0.30121344327926636,
-0.022514037787914276,
0.4722058176994324,
0.3317214250564575,
-0.07077593356370926,
-0.05816729739308357,
0.037080615758895874,
0.060188859701156616,
0.18233084678649902,
0.4138713479042053,
-0.24118684232234955,
0.21603988111019135,
-0.16858692467212677,
-0.542987048625946,
-0.4022657573223114,
-0.29961729049682617,
0.26346203684806824,
-0.8693580627441406,
0.2873225212097168,
-0.038228243589401245,
0.4644358158111572,
-0.1414354145526886,
-0.3542160987854004,
-0.49403753876686096,
-1.237888216972351,
0.4068850576877594,
-0.4538184106349945,
-0.052570030093193054,
0.04280061274766922,
0.0380437970161438,
-0.5008906722068787,
-0.39991438388824463,
-0.5245081186294556,
-0.21841943264007568,
0.22138090431690216,
0.20723582804203033,
-0.13971871137619019,
0.11440146714448929,
0.28475669026374817,
0.2133251130580902,
-0.4291323721408844,
0.37910619378089905,
-0.010244405828416348,
0.10112332552671432,
0.7603501677513123,
0.490418940782547,
0.566338300704956,
0.10671958327293396,
-0.5320318341255188,
0.07453597337007523,
-0.8295221328735352,
0.3014812469482422,
0.6861812472343445,
0.20793002843856812,
0.024038219824433327,
0.6416419744491577,
0.36443260312080383,
0.1926431655883789,
0.3090367615222931,
-0.34142380952835083,
0.24329279363155365,
-0.328764408826828,
0.19899903237819672,
0.2670869529247284,
0.9022584557533264,
0.5515409111976624,
0.12746454775333405,
-0.1656627357006073,
-0.438887357711792,
-0.05773600935935974,
0.10262145847082138,
-0.6427733898162842,
-0.3448430597782135,
0.12777388095855713,
-0.4152671694755554,
-0.6682421565055847,
-0.14302581548690796,
-0.9214744567871094,
-0.9085726141929626,
0.3388383388519287,
0.5106269121170044,
-0.2892124354839325,
-0.7827548980712891,
-0.2169266939163208,
-0.545661985874176,
0.589760959148407,
0.40419378876686096,
-1.1912449598312378,
0.3270082473754883,
0.562567949295044,
0.8230433464050293,
-0.43918898701667786,
-0.39269939064979553,
-0.42040008306503296,
0.42397943139076233,
-0.5111738443374634,
0.600680410861969,
-0.4634508192539215,
-0.8144400119781494,
0.014662960544228554,
0.020769421011209488,
0.06716766208410263,
-0.34001487493515015,
0.14848144352436066,
-0.5615707635879517,
0.16867859661579132,
-0.27699995040893555,
-0.492141455411911,
0.016823718324303627,
0.4763382375240326,
-0.5647948980331421,
0.927712082862854,
0.11081106960773468,
-0.3989989459514618,
0.1892535239458084,
-0.9851056337356567,
-0.4374418258666992,
0.6939003467559814,
-0.1913498193025589,
-0.04696573317050934,
0.36353403329849243,
0.055455178022384644,
0.10014481842517853,
-0.07599809020757675,
0.10118546336889267,
-0.028284952044487,
-0.1945173591375351,
0.42102229595184326,
-0.32173511385917664,
0.6027143597602844,
-0.2511261999607086,
-0.4762727618217468,
0.12239954620599747,
-0.4191988706588745,
-0.014771892689168453,
0.5368675589561462,
-0.4733448624610901,
-0.14620697498321533,
0.5872188806533813,
-0.38116025924682617,
0.1793472319841385,
0.2777236998081207,
-0.5103532671928406,
0.3825412392616272,
-0.33328139781951904,
0.46653953194618225,
0.7619748115539551,
0.660071611404419,
0.2229541838169098,
-0.44177812337875366,
0.8238248825073242,
0.0030996091663837433,
0.10085179656744003,
-0.6036483645439148,
-0.8572795987129211,
-0.4061117172241211,
-0.17244525253772736,
-0.09259621053934097,
0.5189116597175598,
-1.068681240081787,
0.004996305797249079,
-0.014108741655945778,
-0.5335391759872437,
-0.13457609713077545,
-0.10895544290542603,
0.08875878155231476,
0.23104989528656006,
0.06701292097568512,
-0.057603176683187485,
-0.396147757768631,
-0.31282857060432434,
0.11390680074691772,
-0.577067494392395,
-0.18427272140979767,
0.779224157333374,
0.22992584109306335,
-0.43954139947891235,
0.9599332809448242,
-0.4932125508785248,
0.0878344401717186,
-0.626164972782135,
0.29478830099105835,
0.31505024433135986,
0.4023466408252716,
0.4082557260990143,
-0.5043816566467285,
-0.4637310206890106,
0.1307562291622162,
-0.919349730014801,
-0.18415243923664093,
-0.2892874479293823,
0.4074559509754181,
-0.04182116687297821,
0.639820396900177,
-0.6625653505325317,
0.2544654309749603,
0.6098737120628357,
-0.40635553002357483,
0.6180040240287781,
-0.3979213833808899,
0.11439937353134155,
-0.7652126550674438,
-0.32662490010261536,
-0.42314597964286804,
-0.25160008668899536,
-0.761899471282959,
0.293928325176239,
-0.407850980758667,
0.04255920648574829,
-0.2945757508277893,
0.24571503698825836,
-0.6338244080543518,
-0.24948689341545105,
-0.16379216313362122,
0.4635973572731018,
-0.1269858330488205,
0.3111041188240051,
0.26229190826416016,
0.7244410514831543,
0.5892234444618225,
-0.6490841507911682,
0.4474776089191437,
0.13872672617435455,
-0.20711183547973633,
0.23255492746829987,
-0.7828713059425354,
0.26625072956085205,
-0.0037055830471217632,
0.08342520892620087,
-0.9170633554458618,
-0.10734710097312927,
0.0966474786400795,
-0.44684898853302,
0.1456192135810852,
-0.3375968337059021,
-0.7969104647636414,
-0.36834949254989624,
-0.2353709489107132,
0.3561080992221832,
0.5971614122390747,
-0.4977036714553833,
0.6228808760643005,
0.386076956987381,
-0.32988014817237854,
0.0895179808139801,
-0.5160170793533325,
0.26298487186431885,
-0.4333619177341461,
-0.47302111983299255,
0.26482000946998596,
-0.5154354572296143,
-0.07081310451030731,
-0.14652082324028015,
0.3452155292034149,
0.08838467299938202,
0.3201697766780853,
0.25632572174072266,
0.1126914992928505,
-0.44928887486457825,
0.12590467929840088,
-0.06810171902179718,
0.13270866870880127,
0.35192805528640747,
-0.3638247847557068,
0.7530046105384827,
-0.044366009533405304,
-0.27377134561538696,
0.022380618378520012,
0.3973560631275177,
0.3206700086593628,
-0.1852007657289505,
0.5055531859397888,
0.40012630820274353,
0.05196492001414299,
-0.0872926190495491,
-0.09790406376123428,
-0.15140990912914276,
-0.5351685285568237,
0.3837253451347351,
-0.38342204689979553,
-1.2636200189590454,
0.8413177132606506,
-0.40693607926368713,
0.04232441633939743,
0.49597662687301636,
0.5062472224235535,
-0.22690367698669434,
1.13783597946167,
0.6839529275894165,
0.5104383230209351,
0.18746329843997955,
0.158579021692276,
0.0732206180691719,
-0.7624605298042297,
-0.39299842715263367,
-0.05588725954294205,
-0.46700426936149597,
-0.9997459650039673,
-0.5206366777420044,
0.3414176404476166,
0.052119240164756775,
-0.05921468883752823,
0.10215814411640167,
-0.12194327265024185,
0.9011767506599426,
0.28721439838409424,
-0.04318153113126755,
0.29581815004348755,
-0.43664050102233887,
-0.3215029835700989,
-0.15770402550697327,
-0.6196454167366028,
-0.15098465979099274,
0.9005810022354126,
0.47945672273635864,
0.6151055097579956,
0.7427041530609131,
1.167596459388733,
0.23155003786087036,
0.017744991928339005,
-0.6003736853599548,
0.574286937713623,
0.4479309022426605,
-0.5804785490036011,
-0.5419489145278931,
-0.5205335021018982,
-1.2112613916397095,
-0.2380286157131195,
-0.6156942248344421,
-1.142539143562317,
-0.0294630266726017,
-0.1285533457994461,
-0.6269567012786865,
0.2891482710838318,
-0.5234386324882507,
0.5056633949279785,
-0.3556787967681885,
-0.4186052680015564,
0.1803794652223587,
-0.5724135637283325,
0.4705146253108978,
-0.09380818903446198,
0.26408305764198303,
0.17130357027053833,
-0.18610894680023193,
0.5314285755157471,
-0.007450793404132128,
0.8386445641517639,
-0.1479671597480774,
-0.4056178331375122,
0.6209155917167664,
0.7690566778182983,
0.6730926632881165,
0.2974979877471924,
0.5032501816749573,
0.03218258172273636,
-0.3145848214626312,
-0.010157416574656963,
-0.5714174509048462,
0.6731037497520447,
-0.8825939297676086,
-0.9131289124488831,
-0.6114612817764282,
-0.6392789483070374,
-0.22721177339553833,
0.32529976963996887,
0.004914718680083752,
0.14569386839866638,
-0.8128755688667297,
-0.003783513093367219,
1.1320244073867798,
-0.4802369177341461,
0.8965660333633423,
0.6076453328132629,
-0.6307956576347351,
-0.13966627418994904,
0.8635591864585876,
-0.21419045329093933,
0.44261476397514343,
0.3296423554420471,
0.3807886838912964,
-0.19088195264339447,
-0.7868393659591675,
-0.2360893338918686,
0.031061498448252678,
-0.2515069842338562,
0.13199463486671448,
-0.6830827593803406,
-0.4483587145805359,
0.12841911613941193,
-0.05205800384283066,
-0.03695867210626602,
-0.14870181679725647,
-0.22065380215644836,
-0.470844030380249,
0.2815398871898651,
1.286636233329773,
-0.25752851366996765,
0.6681410074234009,
-0.8183723092079163,
-0.19674749672412872,
0.47561389207839966,
0.23997913300991058,
-0.13603392243385315,
-0.21354331076145172,
-0.11673714965581894,
-0.26508593559265137,
-0.19870004057884216,
-1.1671628952026367,
0.24876925349235535,
-0.026402361690998077,
0.6057785153388977,
0.7025901079177856,
-0.35031789541244507,
0.2565300166606903,
-0.9064977169036865,
1.0515024662017822,
0.19030824303627014,
-0.6732279062271118,
0.23030395805835724,
-1.1243785619735718,
0.3438479006290436,
0.11106377094984055,
0.1694103330373764,
-0.5460756421089172,
-0.27276119589805603,
-0.7915846109390259,
-0.6579431295394897,
0.7194284200668335,
0.1963091790676117,
0.2922564744949341,
-0.21276435256004333,
0.24923884868621826,
0.14311562478542328,
0.3281838297843933,
-1.038958191871643,
-0.12427130341529846,
0.009110184386372566,
0.056642308831214905,
-0.34817206859588623,
-0.4073265492916107,
-0.09811221063137054,
0.17591755092144012,
0.16358192265033722,
-0.045339711010456085,
0.39293771982192993,
0.06837036460638046,
0.060610346496105194,
-0.2939341068267822,
-0.10650139302015305,
0.6093711256980896,
0.4643295705318451,
-0.07103193551301956,
0.28945571184158325,
-0.1800190657377243,
-0.6290611624717712,
0.1899116039276123,
-0.01644144207239151,
-0.39643171429634094,
-0.2861345410346985,
0.4421159327030182,
0.5980993509292603,
0.3259626030921936,
-0.6498652696609497,
0.47115233540534973,
-0.29435744881629944,
-0.4285253584384918,
-0.20317989587783813,
0.39839091897010803,
0.4364498555660248,
0.6971594095230103,
0.4221886992454529,
-0.1705314964056015,
-0.06974641233682632,
-0.7039211392402649,
0.10051841288805008,
0.4335399270057678,
-0.4100457727909088,
-0.5292674899101257,
0.5891057252883911,
0.3188619017601013,
-0.6827465891838074,
0.3543523848056793,
-0.6204662322998047,
-0.4334193170070648,
0.5783431529998779,
1.0522797107696533,
0.8659302592277527,
-0.33673185110092163,
0.6145187616348267,
0.26837143301963806,
0.6694467663764954,
0.22202949225902557,
0.04815535247325897,
0.15767355263233185,
-0.8540065884590149,
-0.5682254433631897,
-0.2832530438899994,
-0.23078635334968567,
0.20752418041229248,
-0.05975430831313133,
0.07626897096633911,
-0.5627865195274353,
-0.001973372418433428,
-0.2854006588459015,
0.09780079126358032,
-0.5007159113883972,
-0.38848593831062317,
0.07685300707817078,
0.3744637668132782,
-0.7770515084266663,
0.31925854086875916,
0.38728824257850647,
-0.4237176775932312,
-0.620155930519104,
0.16159717738628387,
0.05785941705107689,
-0.7600494027137756,
0.32861676812171936,
-0.02424638532102108,
0.28536584973335266,
0.5208642482757568,
-0.5803546905517578,
-0.8686937689781189,
1.3565990924835205,
-0.06200399249792099,
-0.5612592697143555,
-0.09387940168380737,
0.2009166032075882,
0.644955039024353,
-0.6712082624435425,
0.28752753138542175,
0.3134100139141083,
0.31278353929519653,
0.366196870803833,
-0.4642629623413086,
-0.06138776242733002,
0.10781178623437881,
-0.09426718950271606,
0.3832121789455414,
-0.5007312893867493,
0.8397508263587952,
-0.554726243019104,
-0.362747460603714,
-0.08398944139480591,
0.7047173380851746,
0.3597184121608734,
0.26244059205055237,
0.5579068064689636,
0.29296445846557617,
0.8871393203735352,
-0.06490347534418106,
0.8360792398452759,
0.031724076718091965,
-0.0063557992689311504,
1.0240826606750488,
-0.5410091876983643,
0.440032035112381,
0.2958052456378937,
-0.14006146788597107,
0.7561880350112915,
0.7113407850265503,
-0.07634615898132324,
0.35852545499801636,
0.2422885149717331,
-0.4676443934440613,
-0.10786024481058121,
-0.02788856439292431,
-0.012378261424601078,
0.4927976131439209,
0.416345477104187,
-0.24653781950473785,
-0.2137778252363205,
-0.20378006994724274,
0.12152674049139023,
-0.10290120542049408,
-0.4343172013759613,
1.1029211282730103,
-0.2281806915998459,
-0.3920154571533203,
-0.32714828848838806,
-0.1309112012386322,
0.34330570697784424,
-0.6624719500541687,
-0.07389359176158905,
-0.1628686487674713,
-0.1900063306093216,
-0.057188063859939575,
-0.8174968957901001,
-0.23104630410671234,
-0.05110325291752815,
-0.2766539752483368,
-0.11732480674982071,
0.5109937787055969,
-0.5153765082359314,
-0.26195237040519714,
0.24685269594192505,
1.1497687101364136,
0.29261359572410583,
0.25706419348716736,
-0.2844583988189697,
-0.018512563779950142,
0.028818100690841675,
-0.2621256709098816,
0.647877037525177,
0.9790854454040527,
-0.10258380323648453,
0.3205500543117523,
0.7287120819091797,
-0.0931648313999176,
-0.01942039653658867,
-0.15538841485977173,
0.6901777386665344,
-0.6580485105514526,
-0.6208605766296387,
-1.1899757385253906,
0.3075503706932068,
0.003129097167402506,
-0.1301945149898529,
0.8628795742988586,
0.5172278881072998,
0.2738819122314453,
0.07718949019908905,
0.826026439666748,
-0.15237027406692505,
0.08686967194080353,
-0.33779096603393555,
0.6533678770065308,
0.03647338226437569,
0.24443918466567993,
-0.2771308720111847,
-0.973075807094574,
0.19914579391479492,
0.06477675586938858,
0.11044459789991379,
0.12554335594177246,
0.6625359058380127,
0.34746861457824707,
0.21097169816493988,
-0.05005466938018799,
0.415156751871109,
0.43367478251457214,
0.6057600378990173,
0.7077130675315857,
1.0952590703964233,
0.12049654871225357,
0.35979774594306946,
0.5211658477783203,
-0.6855521202087402,
0.09030096232891083,
-1.2163870334625244,
-1.050461769104004,
-0.4218381941318512,
-0.22536559402942657,
-0.3346916735172272,
-0.03833251819014549,
0.7835538983345032,
-0.010452553629875183,
-0.2683446407318115,
-0.36019226908683777,
-0.24274440109729767,
0.1574680656194687,
-0.29680055379867554,
-0.310621440410614,
-0.03834450989961624,
-0.18295544385910034,
-0.58065265417099,
0.7599295377731323,
0.3203158974647522,
0.3371662497520447,
-0.5388092398643494,
-0.19912290573120117,
-0.28646957874298096,
0.4027315676212311,
0.6450721621513367,
0.46799856424331665,
-0.14711788296699524,
-0.2344675213098526,
0.19518963992595673,
0.28008952736854553,
0.07844825088977814,
0.9672996997833252,
-0.7554324269294739,
0.48241347074508667,
0.13029146194458008,
0.7622393369674683,
0.771996796131134,
-0.18316338956356049,
0.838184118270874,
-0.8654065728187561,
-0.13452893495559692,
0.2741274833679199,
-0.043506283313035965,
0.1918995976448059,
-0.4694223999977112,
0.4061022400856018,
0.4859474003314972,
-0.7130608558654785,
-0.7423108220100403,
0.44957900047302246,
-0.5543649196624756,
0.08369690924882889,
1.345005750656128,
-0.14562246203422546,
-0.24071334302425385,
-0.025611933320760727,
-0.07322349399328232,
-0.08878710120916367,
-0.40592309832572937,
0.472123920917511,
0.9767212867736816,
-0.501666247844696,
-0.39513230323791504,
-0.6484693288803101,
0.9372233152389526,
-0.5036205053329468,
-0.7616029381752014,
-0.015042309649288654,
0.46705061197280884,
0.042910560965538025,
0.32764706015586853,
0.6910973787307739,
-0.029968736693263054,
0.07179209589958191,
0.11524946987628937,
-0.02138526737689972,
-0.18370483815670013,
-0.2238907814025879,
-0.038103315979242325,
0.06755527853965759,
0.23403511941432953,
0.18572726845741272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17010v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17010v1
|
Türkçe Dil Modellerinin Performans Karşılaştırması Performance Comparison of Turkish Language Models
| 2024-04-25T20:10:14 | 2024-04-25T20:10:14 |
Eren Dogan, M. Egemen Uzun, Atahan Uz, H. Emre Seyrek, Ahmed Zeer, Ezgi Sevi, H. Toprak Kesgin, M. Kaan Yuce, M. Fatih Amasyali
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The developments that language models have provided in fulfilling almost all
kinds of tasks have attracted the attention of not only researchers but also
the society and have enabled them to become products. There are commercially
successful language models available. However, users may prefer open-source
language models due to cost, data privacy, or regulations. Yet, despite the
increasing number of these models, there is no comprehensive comparison of
their performance for Turkish. This study aims to fill this gap in the
literature. A comparison is made among seven selected language models based on
their contextual learning and question-answering abilities. Turkish datasets
for contextual learning and question-answering were prepared, and both
automatic and human evaluations were conducted. The results show that for
question-answering, continuing pretraining before fine-tuning with
instructional datasets is more successful in adapting multilingual models to
Turkish and that in-context learning performances do not much related to
question-answering performances.
|
[
-0.44226551055908203,
-0.8823427557945251,
0.3515576720237732,
0.12446328997612,
-0.32795798778533936,
-0.3462919294834137,
-0.631034791469574,
-0.43532824516296387,
-0.4486865997314453,
0.382191002368927,
-0.4028685986995697,
-0.31905797123908997,
-0.31366246938705444,
0.304522842168808,
-0.35562247037887573,
0.7398470640182495,
0.00568295968696475,
0.2990158498287201,
-0.38991793990135193,
-0.14916133880615234,
-0.5420745015144348,
-0.4407946765422821,
-0.7092095017433167,
0.015039711259305477,
0.3586902320384979,
0.280095636844635,
0.40971896052360535,
0.4054432511329651,
0.6447724103927612,
0.3654578924179077,
-0.2347417026758194,
-0.06038452312350273,
-0.09597933292388916,
0.3989954888820648,
-0.179496631026268,
-0.3235795199871063,
-0.2617505192756653,
0.04426492378115654,
0.8705304265022278,
0.7014116048812866,
0.05123770982027054,
0.36838722229003906,
0.10208691656589508,
0.7705927491188049,
-0.6968048214912415,
0.08274506777524948,
-0.1925658881664276,
-0.19851522147655487,
-0.03188341483473778,
0.17590230703353882,
-0.28154850006103516,
-0.6839792728424072,
0.4401029348373413,
-0.5334125757217407,
0.16763587296009064,
-0.10411105304956436,
0.5007321834564209,
0.13267917931079865,
-0.4542630910873413,
-0.5785642266273499,
-0.8387337327003479,
0.8744524121284485,
-1.0662180185317993,
0.7660817503929138,
0.336387038230896,
0.4657340943813324,
0.18198907375335693,
-0.5884140729904175,
-0.45286956429481506,
-0.6786612868309021,
-0.042588312178850174,
0.002196698682382703,
0.23737066984176636,
-0.04818728193640709,
0.13750146329402924,
0.5294743180274963,
-0.6940132975578308,
-0.2687370181083679,
-0.7166513800621033,
0.1130475401878357,
0.612448513507843,
0.16197583079338074,
0.14038124680519104,
-0.023073455318808556,
-0.12095113098621368,
-0.41692665219306946,
-0.5117719173431396,
0.2742212116718292,
0.36099886894226074,
0.6515457630157471,
-0.0688687264919281,
0.6412781476974487,
-0.4961617588996887,
0.9118479490280151,
-0.08726166933774948,
-0.4136311709880829,
-0.005791544448584318,
-0.28932827711105347,
-0.4635322690010071,
-0.23747122287750244,
0.5284635424613953,
-0.05561733618378639,
0.3980504870414734,
-0.2875364422798157,
-0.051045216619968414,
-0.05909627303481102,
0.2559845447540283,
-0.6262602210044861,
-0.011582675389945507,
0.21617980301380157,
-0.4585062563419342,
-0.07896320521831512,
0.2829623520374298,
-0.33019590377807617,
-0.2146317958831787,
-0.3243843913078308,
0.5256898403167725,
-0.16172821819782257,
-0.46030759811401367,
0.1599559485912323,
0.13015323877334595,
0.29970937967300415,
0.24705563485622406,
-0.5864170789718628,
0.670283854007721,
0.6512373685836792,
0.7683761119842529,
-0.35742947459220886,
-0.39558860659599304,
-0.16657079756259918,
-0.26104798913002014,
-0.5803964734077454,
0.5621275305747986,
-0.39143529534339905,
-0.3040376901626587,
0.09759531170129776,
0.19248513877391815,
-0.4386599361896515,
-0.718903124332428,
0.6413151025772095,
-0.7326134443283081,
0.6264193654060364,
-0.6720607280731201,
-0.730040967464447,
-0.3370237946510315,
0.1981944888830185,
-0.7328425049781799,
0.7618972659111023,
0.09485842287540436,
-1.0993821620941162,
0.4925026297569275,
-0.7271528244018555,
-0.3053054213523865,
-0.07802294194698334,
0.08718535304069519,
-0.2890563905239105,
0.23295900225639343,
-0.020219523459672928,
0.4593642055988312,
-0.07715072482824326,
-0.06217570602893829,
-0.15309536457061768,
-0.6341184377670288,
0.346215158700943,
-0.18158172070980072,
0.8124817609786987,
0.5412850975990295,
-0.2222452461719513,
0.16229942440986633,
-0.3603987693786621,
-0.027819449082016945,
0.12005102634429932,
-0.7348811626434326,
-0.24629390239715576,
-0.00949348509311676,
-0.041213177144527435,
0.3632068634033203,
0.19794027507305145,
-0.4753013253211975,
-0.15149153769016266,
-0.46231523156166077,
-0.009575231932103634,
0.29942646622657776,
-0.2707507610321045,
0.33234742283821106,
-0.4794309139251709,
0.6313199400901794,
-0.04183781519532204,
0.14212678372859955,
-0.1025935634970665,
-0.33926814794540405,
-0.9917079210281372,
-0.013123433105647564,
0.46317681670188904,
0.5242006778717041,
-0.28916308283805847,
-0.08903425186872482,
-0.07358041405677795,
-0.3968687653541565,
-0.40281403064727783,
0.07806358486413956,
0.30603882670402527,
0.5319156050682068,
0.24305538833141327,
-0.26876765489578247,
-0.2604578733444214,
-0.7612078189849854,
-0.5580036640167236,
-0.30052223801612854,
-0.09096709638834,
0.6127424836158752,
0.1832306683063507,
0.4989463984966278,
0.6559064984321594,
-0.06813390552997589,
-0.12776418030261993,
-0.544262707233429,
-0.3193235695362091,
0.139245867729187,
0.36243245005607605,
0.4497133195400238,
-0.7088239192962646,
-0.768437385559082,
0.09289566427469254,
-0.5655167102813721,
0.15931405127048492,
0.5119569301605225,
0.2725467383861542,
0.4590129554271698,
0.4740328788757324,
-0.3483702540397644,
0.2381015419960022,
0.540041446685791,
-0.5833275318145752,
0.7707460522651672,
-0.3225197494029999,
0.6039213538169861,
-1.089324712753296,
0.4425927400588989,
-0.18776047229766846,
-0.40368834137916565,
-0.9112926721572876,
0.33768242597579956,
0.16755834221839905,
-0.012118524871766567,
-0.9786454439163208,
0.7271642684936523,
-0.40022194385528564,
-0.18548095226287842,
-0.21764424443244934,
0.053742483258247375,
-0.07773996144533157,
0.24051310122013092,
0.13486754894256592,
1.2260379791259766,
0.473405659198761,
-0.8862583041191101,
0.32066231966018677,
0.35722726583480835,
-0.7211652398109436,
0.2124573439359665,
-0.8507559895515442,
0.08414291590452194,
0.05338665470480919,
-0.3118381202220917,
-0.8353317975997925,
-0.19370870292186737,
0.18713967502117157,
-0.4338811933994293,
0.3931583762168884,
-0.11518910527229309,
-0.2164633721113205,
-0.2798689305782318,
-0.18848958611488342,
0.3770937919616699,
0.47318485379219055,
-0.18186050653457642,
0.20356620848178864,
0.036689043045043945,
-0.4362843334674835,
-0.6360203623771667,
-0.5512360334396362,
-0.27783724665641785,
-0.564103901386261,
-0.5387230515480042,
-0.20898453891277313,
-0.12623685598373413,
-0.5578497052192688,
-0.12942872941493988,
-0.01586010865867138,
-0.17193938791751862,
0.2897648811340332,
-0.14440764486789703,
0.14370280504226685,
-0.5326732993125916,
0.2720910608768463,
-0.12182572484016418,
0.12653857469558716,
-0.0015100521268323064,
-0.18334834277629852,
0.2766563296318054,
-0.472369909286499,
-0.30775192379951477,
-0.27085936069488525,
0.27376067638397217,
0.5327279567718506,
-0.41226887702941895,
1.0610413551330566,
0.25402915477752686,
-0.12125813215970993,
0.314317911863327,
-0.8200578689575195,
-0.2388612926006317,
-0.44098979234695435,
0.30930647253990173,
-0.415532648563385,
-1.0803110599517822,
0.37863799929618835,
0.08173913508653641,
0.1343255490064621,
0.27552855014801025,
0.7225833535194397,
-0.153688445687294,
0.928322970867157,
0.8306369781494141,
0.14283621311187744,
0.5462169647216797,
0.08540219068527222,
0.0326058492064476,
-0.6218488812446594,
-0.07347515970468521,
-0.7746174335479736,
0.2157323658466339,
-0.6352622509002686,
-0.18144865334033966,
0.2789270877838135,
0.23235735297203064,
-0.3572787046432495,
0.29108813405036926,
-0.15121854841709137,
0.3470057547092438,
0.37983715534210205,
-0.24028344452381134,
0.4341096580028534,
0.2531234920024872,
-0.15625691413879395,
0.11092476546764374,
-0.7447919249534607,
-0.7813408970832825,
1.13579523563385,
0.2516469657421112,
0.643568217754364,
0.2827783524990082,
0.2804505527019501,
0.1207590252161026,
0.1148245707154274,
-0.22931981086730957,
0.29706183075904846,
-0.21008959412574768,
-0.9567093849182129,
-0.668980062007904,
-0.36035406589508057,
-0.9872509241104126,
0.46973592042922974,
-0.2500518262386322,
-0.7749004364013672,
-0.017343537881970406,
0.05036412551999092,
-0.2595905661582947,
0.12344413995742798,
-0.6849673390388489,
1.167688250541687,
0.10954733192920685,
-0.3777022063732147,
-0.2531385123729706,
-0.45439577102661133,
0.2511022686958313,
0.1615055650472641,
0.15145835280418396,
-0.0862237811088562,
0.08137322962284088,
0.8246948719024658,
-0.20655982196331024,
0.3238148093223572,
-0.2211616486310959,
0.10025815665721893,
0.3954821228981018,
0.0732845813035965,
0.060388460755348206,
-0.01721080020070076,
-0.13876661658287048,
-0.10616278648376465,
0.506935179233551,
-0.5095648169517517,
-0.40405935049057007,
0.6765236854553223,
-0.8985015749931335,
-0.5992099642753601,
-0.0930364653468132,
-0.3762986958026886,
-0.3123399019241333,
0.1804838627576828,
0.09733717888593674,
0.42768147587776184,
-0.48391154408454895,
0.1611032336950302,
0.6926496624946594,
-0.24101434648036957,
0.46223071217536926,
0.4785979390144348,
-0.16296829283237457,
-0.2586902678012848,
0.6347293853759766,
-0.018556348979473114,
0.3137628138065338,
0.10715045779943466,
0.20116718113422394,
-0.5609180927276611,
-0.3493207097053528,
-0.5792843103408813,
0.47883906960487366,
-0.6032997965812683,
0.2514537572860718,
-0.6962271928787231,
-0.1970454305410385,
-0.6230840682983398,
0.06739748269319534,
-0.4895639717578888,
-0.6203475594520569,
-0.000981806661002338,
0.1303068995475769,
0.1325616091489792,
0.8373096585273743,
0.08750388026237488,
0.17663881182670593,
-0.4449783265590668,
-0.016512488946318626,
0.6875691413879395,
0.44070205092430115,
0.03325223550200462,
-0.6349830031394958,
-0.49313294887542725,
-0.05480160564184189,
-0.2772369086742401,
-0.8889400362968445,
0.12250196933746338,
0.15797297656536102,
0.4749687910079956,
0.3969511091709137,
-0.04451683163642883,
0.2619984745979309,
-0.14352484047412872,
0.7291306853294373,
-0.3151659667491913,
-0.8335949182510376,
0.46120476722717285,
-0.26703664660453796,
0.4265424907207489,
0.7759687304496765,
0.4693305790424347,
-0.7877811193466187,
-0.2620099186897278,
-0.41250550746917725,
-0.47725486755371094,
0.8886986374855042,
0.2770673334598541,
0.09714134782552719,
0.174818754196167,
0.3186952471733093,
0.29404520988464355,
0.5455905795097351,
-0.5503733158111572,
-0.13055922091007233,
-0.1827126294374466,
0.003080821828916669,
-0.33413586020469666,
-0.33319994807243347,
0.17910921573638916,
-0.2830010950565338,
0.7302151322364807,
-0.026238054037094116,
0.24929466843605042,
0.19285672903060913,
-0.31249943375587463,
-0.18660137057304382,
0.4344863295555115,
0.7723037004470825,
1.1149557828903198,
-0.2679779529571533,
-0.05708374083042145,
0.5408210158348083,
-0.5856515765190125,
0.14304320514202118,
0.01501393225044012,
-0.06520648300647736,
-0.13266603648662567,
0.477106511592865,
0.742979109287262,
-0.15230892598628998,
-0.7308669686317444,
0.7141170501708984,
-0.44567248225212097,
-0.11222037672996521,
-0.38476401567459106,
0.27440327405929565,
0.20183700323104858,
0.4058138132095337,
0.08002428710460663,
-0.4806332290172577,
0.16963501274585724,
-0.2782140076160431,
-0.2039550542831421,
0.24887192249298096,
-0.48850303888320923,
-0.28629815578460693,
0.6886819005012512,
-0.12120208889245987,
-0.3719406723976135,
0.7197318077087402,
0.16478638350963593,
-0.32965290546417236,
0.5143783688545227,
0.355143278837204,
0.6718781590461731,
-0.5086002945899963,
0.15267100930213928,
0.5189954042434692,
0.19877202808856964,
0.012525332160294056,
0.48670822381973267,
-0.36833104491233826,
-0.49807801842689514,
-0.6705873608589172,
-0.5825077891349792,
-0.3586600124835968,
0.38089653849601746,
-0.6567589640617371,
0.28335779905319214,
-0.23149624466896057,
-0.13411441445350647,
-0.460204154253006,
0.6039483547210693,
-0.7732734084129333,
0.4921702444553375,
0.1339888870716095,
1.2555873394012451,
-1.0778660774230957,
0.7367510795593262,
1.2482041120529175,
-0.3273187577724457,
-0.5938664674758911,
-0.10687760263681412,
-0.49656379222869873,
0.0341496504843235,
0.37177860736846924,
0.15501229465007782,
0.24605616927146912,
-0.1416381597518921,
-0.16376303136348724,
-0.8401768207550049,
1.0456197261810303,
0.3752358853816986,
-0.12184455990791321,
0.00879065040498972,
0.30235016345977783,
0.6052936315536499,
-0.32455411553382874,
0.43255698680877686,
0.5492472648620605,
0.4099051058292389,
-0.11532729864120483,
-1.1417131423950195,
-0.24105964601039886,
-0.04248647764325142,
-0.11117098480463028,
-0.25582820177078247,
-0.667303740978241,
0.9667753577232361,
-0.0213950015604496,
-0.3054675757884979,
0.24326610565185547,
0.6662173867225647,
0.3293209969997406,
0.22985906898975372,
0.5168442130088806,
0.2991483509540558,
0.3975207507610321,
0.010261726565659046,
0.9490755200386047,
-0.3376940190792084,
0.31124043464660645,
0.80988609790802,
0.09852879494428635,
0.8780351877212524,
0.2531457841396332,
-0.4508872628211975,
0.2282034009695053,
0.6626437902450562,
0.48636648058891296,
0.6110912561416626,
-0.2252345234155655,
-0.2712663412094116,
-0.4446205496788025,
0.11427365243434906,
-0.4818209111690521,
0.41732001304626465,
0.006913237739354372,
-0.17665958404541016,
-0.17052625119686127,
-0.18711622059345245,
-0.11252384632825851,
-0.023757921531796455,
-0.023822210729122162,
0.8388040661811829,
-0.0991290956735611,
-0.5995486378669739,
0.5884770154953003,
0.16707314550876617,
0.2542252540588379,
-0.47918444871902466,
0.27865099906921387,
-0.38743799924850464,
0.12714387476444244,
0.16098421812057495,
-0.3020029067993164,
0.47755321860313416,
-0.0110190873965621,
-0.10538595169782639,
0.26043474674224854,
0.7312333583831787,
-0.42327234148979187,
-0.48923546075820923,
0.09459485113620758,
0.8973225355148315,
0.4181302785873413,
-0.14862115681171417,
-0.7142274975776672,
-0.001757142716087401,
-0.35741502046585083,
-0.4466378688812256,
0.15031515061855316,
-0.014663386158645153,
-0.16410982608795166,
0.7430748343467712,
0.42659175395965576,
0.22572541236877441,
0.3093421459197998,
-0.1622418463230133,
0.7978104948997498,
-0.44600650668144226,
-0.5929901599884033,
-0.570561408996582,
0.3978782892227173,
0.01475378219038248,
-0.3028041422367096,
0.9157847762107849,
0.6084476113319397,
1.2261914014816284,
-0.27706196904182434,
0.7239624857902527,
0.17480993270874023,
0.892622172832489,
-0.25406503677368164,
0.8139328360557556,
-0.6825417876243591,
-0.2023387849330902,
-0.34257781505584717,
-1.1957249641418457,
-0.10683152824640274,
0.7388565540313721,
-0.4505503177642822,
0.3653605282306671,
0.597808837890625,
0.6539881825447083,
-0.40281787514686584,
0.047151751816272736,
0.5988287925720215,
0.13361996412277222,
0.03346126899123192,
0.25651612877845764,
0.9834129810333252,
-0.38674455881118774,
0.19861967861652374,
-0.3050096333026886,
-0.1170082539319992,
-0.3289346694946289,
-0.6831896305084229,
-1.2151145935058594,
-0.736664354801178,
-0.027463644742965698,
0.04035267233848572,
0.395521342754364,
0.7650988698005676,
0.9004966020584106,
-1.1923506259918213,
-0.501655638217926,
0.13997259736061096,
0.02423938550055027,
-0.31475940346717834,
-0.11632506549358368,
0.5595586895942688,
-0.41781461238861084,
-0.6555120944976807,
0.3951945900917053,
-0.06488461047410965,
0.1145029291510582,
-0.35772931575775146,
-0.28054821491241455,
-0.13550831377506256,
0.3262060284614563,
0.35011860728263855,
0.3686716854572296,
-0.735749363899231,
0.14384858310222626,
0.2577282190322876,
0.0036483739968389273,
-0.07261254638433456,
0.8955308198928833,
-0.7840553522109985,
0.4079013466835022,
0.5806666612625122,
0.4427624046802521,
0.46174120903015137,
0.013432708568871021,
0.3008710443973541,
-0.28786593675613403,
0.14532609283924103,
-0.08125846832990646,
0.0985826775431633,
0.5633747577667236,
-0.06330907344818115,
0.267429918050766,
-0.19223101437091827,
-0.6727235913276672,
-0.544715404510498,
0.01814408414065838,
-0.3875216245651245,
-0.33432736992836,
0.9779158234596252,
-0.37440255284309387,
-0.18597906827926636,
-0.21369318664073944,
-0.19687964022159576,
0.3997632563114166,
0.11919263005256653,
0.7780510783195496,
0.7123308777809143,
0.05228976160287857,
-0.0561518520116806,
-0.7483529448509216,
0.6031628251075745,
0.5040802955627441,
-0.48202773928642273,
0.23202989995479584,
0.32424303889274597,
0.5490404963493347,
-0.21256032586097717,
0.5717267394065857,
-0.24568021297454834,
0.43943077325820923,
-0.2529504895210266,
-0.13265880942344666,
-0.28777074813842773,
-0.5513590574264526,
-0.513029158115387,
0.19341927766799927,
0.7493303418159485,
-0.0037694284692406654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17000v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17000v1
|
Evaluating Class Membership Relations in Knowledge Graphs using Large Language Models
| 2024-04-25T19:44:46 | 2024-04-25T19:44:46 |
Bradley P. Allen, Paul T. Groth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.2.4
|
A backbone of knowledge graphs are their class membership relations, which
assign entities to a given class. As part of the knowledge engineering process,
we propose a new method for evaluating the quality of these relations by
processing descriptions of a given entity and class using a zero-shot
chain-of-thought classifier that uses a natural language intensional definition
of a class. We evaluate the method using two publicly available knowledge
graphs, Wikidata and CaLiGraph, and 7 large language models. Using the
gpt-4-0125-preview large language model, the method's classification
performance achieves a macro-averaged F1-score of 0.830 on data from Wikidata
and 0.893 on data from CaLiGraph. Moreover, a manual analysis of the
classification errors shows that 40.9% of errors were due to the knowledge
graphs, with 16.0% due to missing relations and 24.9% due to incorrectly
asserted relations. These results show how large language models can assist
knowledge engineers in the process of knowledge graph refinement. The code and
data are available on Github.
|
[
-0.4393032193183899,
-0.5090804696083069,
0.5594244599342346,
-0.11717423796653748,
-0.1704777330160141,
0.2691059112548828,
-0.10187716037034988,
-0.7073766589164734,
0.2649780213832855,
0.4242282807826996,
-0.17174115777015686,
-0.519070029258728,
-0.39091676473617554,
-0.0231501292437315,
-0.39149120450019836,
0.907085657119751,
-0.2915075719356537,
-0.010662872344255447,
-0.5281456708908081,
-0.20495732128620148,
-0.42872685194015503,
-0.5721081495285034,
-0.37133803963661194,
-0.5018404126167297,
0.6624062061309814,
0.10692538321018219,
0.7790220379829407,
0.4687087833881378,
0.2597510814666748,
0.296883761882782,
-0.06667286902666092,
0.09723328053951263,
-0.5533279776573181,
-0.03626590222120285,
-0.2992898225784302,
-0.20233921706676483,
-0.6390383243560791,
0.19420647621154785,
0.6826947927474976,
1.0069712400436401,
0.3346143364906311,
0.514796793460846,
0.011155454441905022,
0.552101731300354,
-0.7482089996337891,
0.9110477566719055,
-0.5030277371406555,
-0.06346912682056427,
0.018513401970267296,
-0.21442970633506775,
-0.5964904427528381,
-0.6027049422264099,
0.3897746801376343,
-0.5914317965507507,
-0.01285596378147602,
-0.013515099883079529,
0.9157241582870483,
-0.24053436517715454,
-0.550075352191925,
-0.21987402439117432,
-0.646815299987793,
0.35293734073638916,
-0.6071165800094604,
0.6913170218467712,
0.40354013442993164,
0.4358125925064087,
-0.07919852435588837,
-0.6354793906211853,
-0.7817431688308716,
-0.38479503989219666,
-0.09988505393266678,
0.0027184002101421356,
0.10489780455827713,
0.26629194617271423,
0.36765342950820923,
0.6120686531066895,
-0.5223549008369446,
0.12263508886098862,
-0.4419195055961609,
-0.3611660599708557,
0.7063098549842834,
0.0023319723550230265,
0.30402955412864685,
-0.12851755321025848,
-0.24895484745502472,
-0.04891228303313255,
-0.5374566912651062,
-0.27584677934646606,
0.5029277205467224,
0.11483819037675858,
0.24104413390159607,
0.7145594954490662,
-0.4027610421180725,
0.8734733462333679,
-0.49567708373069763,
-0.13478708267211914,
0.4326276183128357,
-0.04243975877761841,
-0.41160330176353455,
0.02501160465180874,
0.8273324370384216,
0.6509764194488525,
0.6248475313186646,
-0.5620633959770203,
-0.15768684446811676,
0.23436973989009857,
-0.00827911775559187,
-0.844187319278717,
-0.4319993257522583,
-0.15019391477108002,
-0.2434239685535431,
-0.260117769241333,
-0.09657071530818939,
-0.4761556386947632,
-0.34881144762039185,
-0.44241929054260254,
0.5924957990646362,
-0.34187957644462585,
-0.37439069151878357,
-0.1480022817850113,
-0.29887259006500244,
0.10064952075481415,
0.26535117626190186,
-0.34493139386177063,
0.1856103390455246,
0.5271772146224976,
0.7298634052276611,
0.12326665222644806,
-0.33310770988464355,
-0.12876909971237183,
0.2952169179916382,
-0.39813631772994995,
0.7141199707984924,
-0.44790682196617126,
-0.15528562664985657,
-0.08927937597036362,
-0.22098366916179657,
-0.23639635741710663,
-0.3580954968929291,
0.3210890293121338,
-0.9228460788726807,
0.10320112109184265,
-0.2693406045436859,
-1.205047845840454,
-0.2670738995075226,
0.5488489866256714,
-0.8252219557762146,
0.6797246336936951,
0.5006358623504639,
-0.8811560273170471,
0.342753529548645,
-0.6089175343513489,
-0.16915619373321533,
0.29530608654022217,
-0.02880702167749405,
-0.14578047394752502,
-0.20941683650016785,
-0.0955435186624527,
0.4036809206008911,
-0.29652896523475647,
0.25191953778266907,
-0.8165961503982544,
-0.2326812595129013,
0.3011632263660431,
-0.1099664494395256,
0.8192599415779114,
0.07972727715969086,
0.12960049510002136,
-0.12875251471996307,
-0.7382222414016724,
0.3539879322052002,
0.07187417149543762,
-0.009851583279669285,
-0.6197803020477295,
-0.08273661136627197,
-0.31506070494651794,
0.35774892568588257,
0.2632679343223572,
-0.49746182560920715,
0.44524696469306946,
-0.44540244340896606,
0.22894223034381866,
0.5934663414955139,
0.4449831545352936,
0.3620735704898834,
0.0969243049621582,
0.3021411597728729,
-0.2421545535326004,
0.18216344714164734,
0.1346413791179657,
-0.45564839243888855,
-0.9274460077285767,
0.22908538579940796,
0.5478470921516418,
0.26999327540397644,
-0.9302125573158264,
0.5019034147262573,
-0.6341044306755066,
-0.7708942890167236,
-0.033696919679641724,
-0.1532023698091507,
0.37336069345474243,
0.6416597962379456,
0.41543540358543396,
-0.4482749402523041,
-0.1394699513912201,
-0.7031567692756653,
-0.12842857837677002,
-0.678225040435791,
-0.059908103197813034,
0.222115159034729,
0.5646659731864929,
-0.242831289768219,
0.9858645796775818,
-0.7072919607162476,
-0.142594575881958,
0.09371649473905563,
0.298249214887619,
-0.11008042842149734,
0.04738933965563774,
0.6466280221939087,
-0.2752184569835663,
-0.45734572410583496,
0.20615337789058685,
-0.9292030334472656,
0.1256563514471054,
0.3260000944137573,
-0.24174071848392487,
0.12801524996757507,
0.11954440921545029,
-0.5322960615158081,
0.47033292055130005,
0.3214167654514313,
-0.41455236077308655,
0.6347371935844421,
0.2598986327648163,
0.19734351336956024,
-0.9143064022064209,
0.1960228830575943,
0.054374273866415024,
-0.13930682837963104,
-0.5646969676017761,
0.3444233238697052,
0.06107281520962715,
-0.28735843300819397,
-0.17440564930438995,
0.4786299169063568,
-0.5552626252174377,
-0.2084042876958847,
-0.11744749546051025,
0.30227965116500854,
-0.03711946681141853,
0.566990315914154,
-0.0029290923848748207,
0.3543393909931183,
0.583943784236908,
-0.6514142751693726,
0.5621450543403625,
0.2515680491924286,
-0.4648217260837555,
0.44459229707717896,
-0.35750141739845276,
0.3275836408138275,
-0.0726059153676033,
0.2710742950439453,
-0.8555693626403809,
-0.32444044947624207,
0.16105632483959198,
-0.5106058120727539,
0.3304930329322815,
-0.5391432642936707,
-0.6407151818275452,
-0.6257559061050415,
-0.21257828176021576,
0.3142075538635254,
-0.1162259504199028,
-0.40887293219566345,
0.42957958579063416,
0.5522778034210205,
0.15286196768283844,
-0.5169527530670166,
-0.2559264004230499,
-0.005396141204982996,
0.19437499344348907,
-0.6435191035270691,
0.10375853627920151,
0.08414112776517868,
-0.050947267562150955,
0.44237080216407776,
-0.4417073130607605,
-0.47016972303390503,
0.12434255331754684,
0.20366200804710388,
0.41182124614715576,
-0.12599708139896393,
0.49474573135375977,
-0.1682683378458023,
0.04241510108113289,
0.31531786918640137,
-0.3187752366065979,
0.5870494246482849,
0.04038526117801666,
-0.23212282359600067,
-0.2953301966190338,
-0.28948861360549927,
0.7712482810020447,
-0.4091474115848541,
0.884204626083374,
0.15333254635334015,
-0.4903584420681,
-0.02511170506477356,
-0.45751509070396423,
0.07941445708274841,
-0.3815060257911682,
0.4610729515552521,
-0.25058093667030334,
-0.7746381163597107,
0.5971196293830872,
0.13615673780441284,
0.13627418875694275,
0.582931399345398,
0.05212392657995224,
0.22662222385406494,
0.7694875597953796,
0.5313984155654907,
-0.6053934097290039,
0.16108423471450806,
-0.5277066230773926,
0.5011929273605347,
-0.5680554509162903,
-0.28110620379447937,
-0.6360656023025513,
-0.178188294172287,
-0.4904592037200928,
-0.1351182758808136,
0.33543962240219116,
0.340814471244812,
-0.39670222997665405,
0.6433526277542114,
-0.3686950206756592,
0.5896661281585693,
0.1206335574388504,
-0.01676960103213787,
0.4185023605823517,
0.03844095766544342,
-0.011878841556608677,
0.24426095187664032,
-0.4301736354827881,
-0.528348982334137,
0.9964234828948975,
0.3923749625682831,
0.5624421238899231,
0.16169172525405884,
0.6832245588302612,
-0.0013993955217301846,
0.8891891241073608,
-1.1316078901290894,
0.6348460912704468,
0.25187158584594727,
-0.5975082516670227,
-0.5250481963157654,
-1.0543711185455322,
-0.6257680058479309,
0.10575094074010849,
-0.1327044665813446,
-0.814668595790863,
0.05992836132645607,
0.10526996850967407,
0.08319498598575592,
0.42245107889175415,
-0.7835237979888916,
1.1063309907913208,
-0.08623572438955307,
-0.04006872698664665,
-0.1969725638628006,
-0.2708313763141632,
0.578709602355957,
-0.10324275493621826,
0.1476191282272339,
-0.3092521131038666,
0.4034736752510071,
0.941024899482727,
-0.6036404371261597,
0.5272620916366577,
-0.3758104741573334,
-0.19634824991226196,
0.5284519791603088,
0.27653294801712036,
0.37412410974502563,
-0.07625051587820053,
-0.29452094435691833,
0.09827598929405212,
0.20398226380348206,
-0.1455775797367096,
-0.9077249765396118,
0.6473997235298157,
-0.8632561564445496,
-0.27346330881118774,
-0.27007153630256653,
-0.3410280644893646,
-0.5731216073036194,
0.4528137445449829,
0.06795454770326614,
0.4922446608543396,
-0.15550987422466278,
-0.02610672637820244,
0.2564210593700409,
-0.11355676501989365,
0.30429452657699585,
0.5257517695426941,
-0.4289034903049469,
-0.3447469472885132,
1.1151949167251587,
0.7749711871147156,
0.3644871115684509,
0.2327832728624344,
0.04518985375761986,
-0.36481815576553345,
-0.25138452649116516,
-0.3138747811317444,
0.3087872564792633,
-0.7815408110618591,
-0.6028637290000916,
-0.6146098375320435,
-0.5321034789085388,
-0.42123177647590637,
0.41835013031959534,
-0.24298882484436035,
-0.5706797242164612,
-0.018092820420861244,
-0.24362903833389282,
0.1638057678937912,
0.6898611783981323,
0.7530370354652405,
0.06975029408931732,
-0.8216603994369507,
0.03602183982729912,
0.5285695195198059,
0.7679846882820129,
0.3826432526111603,
-0.28946635127067566,
-0.2954966723918915,
-0.08688825368881226,
-0.3804391026496887,
-1.3212248086929321,
0.07095696777105331,
0.15860989689826965,
0.5543321967124939,
0.3621857166290283,
0.3094237744808197,
0.7429478168487549,
-0.38739830255508423,
0.5477583408355713,
0.29866501688957214,
-0.9952259063720703,
0.29692912101745605,
-0.038784418255090714,
-0.02788175269961357,
0.48992979526519775,
0.6077280044555664,
-0.549614667892456,
-0.5009092092514038,
-0.6396809220314026,
-0.7053684592247009,
0.41768503189086914,
0.12786906957626343,
0.07717393338680267,
-0.19351497292518616,
0.46622633934020996,
-0.4140940010547638,
0.2277880758047104,
-0.913384735584259,
-0.4728384017944336,
-0.13775481283664703,
0.002314586192369461,
0.24598228931427002,
-0.3847484886646271,
0.13239425420761108,
-0.21359515190124512,
0.7673712372779846,
-0.2681138217449188,
0.22323305904865265,
-0.09280958026647568,
-0.25763288140296936,
-0.30553337931632996,
0.34668251872062683,
0.005186869762837887,
1.1555721759796143,
-0.050522495061159134,
0.3917391002178192,
0.1942613124847412,
-0.2541346251964569,
0.054787855595350266,
0.2548440992832184,
-0.11720116436481476,
0.06985150277614594,
0.5131836533546448,
0.6007185578346252,
0.2215672880411148,
-0.19146478176116943,
0.6958853006362915,
0.08999092131853104,
-0.1655530333518982,
-0.15588204562664032,
0.09632626175880432,
0.04268928989768028,
-0.009253398515284061,
0.23799867928028107,
-0.1798093467950821,
0.3092327415943146,
-0.643202543258667,
0.09856849908828735,
0.3473808467388153,
-0.42156273126602173,
-0.3505072593688965,
0.36207231879234314,
0.12851281464099884,
0.03450295329093933,
0.7497648596763611,
-0.3567696213722229,
-0.6922177076339722,
0.41817334294319153,
0.2915058135986328,
0.6752710342407227,
-0.21747520565986633,
0.3415893018245697,
0.5055986046791077,
0.2728419601917267,
0.09799239039421082,
-0.2095646858215332,
0.04779772460460663,
-0.8462315797805786,
-0.9872963428497314,
-0.7839851975440979,
-0.45254188776016235,
0.20161455869674683,
-0.5651514530181885,
0.27088460326194763,
-0.2592790424823761,
-0.2596472203731537,
0.2919677495956421,
0.179898202419281,
-0.6795443296432495,
0.09359977394342422,
0.0286199189722538,
1.0006977319717407,
-0.952602744102478,
0.9449654817581177,
0.7122787237167358,
-0.657683789730072,
-1.283930778503418,
0.009636543691158295,
-0.31537818908691406,
-0.40531253814697266,
0.7710628509521484,
0.31191226840019226,
-0.028318611904978752,
-0.035161685198545456,
-0.3237802982330322,
-0.6708422303199768,
0.9442145228385925,
0.6014760136604309,
-0.6526740789413452,
-0.17785410583019257,
0.08087486028671265,
0.7033836841583252,
0.09690578281879425,
0.3038877546787262,
0.3520832359790802,
0.476550430059433,
0.06512872874736786,
-1.1824427843093872,
-0.04701085016131401,
-0.21176105737686157,
-0.16125531494617462,
0.48271217942237854,
-0.44943058490753174,
0.5229812860488892,
0.08241154998540878,
-0.4460110366344452,
-0.1382298618555069,
0.7590641379356384,
0.026828207075595856,
0.44355347752571106,
0.6504085063934326,
0.7045907378196716,
0.9079562425613403,
-0.06614141166210175,
0.8603236079216003,
-0.4162796437740326,
0.8413774967193604,
1.0399078130722046,
-0.4943273365497589,
0.6359798312187195,
0.10619144141674042,
-0.35307440161705017,
0.5120143294334412,
0.32471632957458496,
-0.04287984222173691,
0.11231108009815216,
0.28086572885513306,
-0.3620123863220215,
-0.11091679334640503,
-0.006121595855802298,
-0.4834347665309906,
0.24305836856365204,
0.20634473860263824,
-0.47204330563545227,
-0.3342193365097046,
-0.28376317024230957,
0.015155414119362831,
-0.1834995001554489,
-0.4634287655353546,
0.7517229318618774,
-0.13533662259578705,
-0.5640166401863098,
0.4710186719894409,
-0.045192331075668335,
-0.048965469002723694,
-0.17858187854290009,
-0.10903169959783554,
-0.07376773655414581,
-0.005414274521172047,
-0.3014254868030548,
-0.9670673608779907,
0.11999324709177017,
-0.06563121825456619,
-0.05336437374353409,
0.1700884997844696,
0.7058537602424622,
-0.4582960307598114,
-0.3582804203033447,
0.3528227210044861,
0.30717816948890686,
0.1269611120223999,
-0.09770888090133667,
-0.26055240631103516,
-0.26133498549461365,
-0.1883210986852646,
-0.004470099229365587,
0.11352712661027908,
0.5297644734382629,
-0.29619476199150085,
0.47673556208610535,
0.33139461278915405,
-0.1104985922574997,
-0.0867975577712059,
0.21421249210834503,
1.2191492319107056,
-0.3880908489227295,
-0.20708414912223816,
-0.7403072714805603,
0.22589422762393951,
-0.2839243710041046,
-0.09219733625650406,
0.7792086601257324,
0.8184483051300049,
1.0714863538742065,
-0.03170127421617508,
0.6706441044807434,
-0.23365963995456696,
0.32077711820602417,
-0.32831519842147827,
0.8254939317703247,
-0.08450105786323547,
0.13227349519729614,
-0.5156564116477966,
-1.3076543807983398,
-0.4221573770046234,
0.5710527300834656,
-0.6364988684654236,
0.014676221646368504,
0.6399587392807007,
0.47935643792152405,
-0.10132932662963867,
0.10392618179321289,
0.18874779343605042,
0.2141713798046112,
0.39221587777137756,
0.3309907019138336,
0.9043368101119995,
-0.40325868129730225,
0.5393761396408081,
-0.37299734354019165,
-0.30041539669036865,
0.020749196410179138,
-0.6666332483291626,
-1.0191798210144043,
-0.4094749689102173,
-0.5320062041282654,
-0.5149595141410828,
-0.15088889002799988,
0.7757465243339539,
0.5436906814575195,
-0.553717851638794,
-0.15674583613872528,
0.0859174132347107,
0.2929770350456238,
-0.0038569141179323196,
-0.3208935260772705,
0.3935217559337616,
-0.3542775809764862,
-0.38659119606018066,
0.13460548222064972,
0.1981678456068039,
-0.14511407911777496,
-0.44791772961616516,
-0.18333306908607483,
0.05434010177850723,
-0.32698434591293335,
0.8995040059089661,
0.1715434193611145,
-0.2532787322998047,
-0.6606177687644958,
-0.17936207354068756,
0.08781897276639938,
-0.32667815685272217,
0.8406501412391663,
-0.5654924511909485,
0.5885669589042664,
0.5300982594490051,
0.4003012478351593,
0.615193784236908,
-0.27753832936286926,
0.27352574467658997,
-0.8471633791923523,
-0.19723205268383026,
0.19399550557136536,
0.45364829897880554,
0.14410950243473053,
-0.13977795839309692,
0.6665210723876953,
0.3861258924007416,
-0.6407431960105896,
-0.8270228505134583,
0.2067595273256302,
-0.7839183807373047,
-0.06611679494380951,
0.8053076267242432,
-0.3919772505760193,
-0.24582147598266602,
-0.04516124352812767,
0.04866497591137886,
0.5840716361999512,
-0.03286367282271385,
0.6802918314933777,
0.6869276165962219,
-0.07156483083963394,
-0.0756356343626976,
-0.5152943134307861,
0.16955351829528809,
-0.3940895199775696,
-0.9135927557945251,
0.19717498123645782,
0.7880931496620178,
0.47914719581604004,
0.4697073996067047,
0.41074422001838684,
-0.2590702474117279,
0.11522688716650009,
-0.43718987703323364,
0.30261287093162537,
-0.06751597672700882,
-0.3384520411491394,
0.29315927624702454,
0.37190112471580505,
0.2862910330295563,
0.09867066890001297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18942v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18942v1
|
GuideWalk -- Heterogeneous Data Fusion for Enhanced Learning -- A Multiclass Document Classification Case
| 2024-04-25T18:48:11 | 2024-04-25T18:48:11 |
Sarmad N. Mohammed, Semra Gündüç
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
One of the prime problems of computer science and machine learning is to
extract information efficiently from large-scale, heterogeneous data. Text
data, with its syntax, semantics, and even hidden information content,
possesses an exceptional place among the data types in concern. The processing
of the text data requires embedding, a method of translating the content of the
text to numeric vectors. A correct embedding algorithm is the starting point
for obtaining the full information content of the text data. In this work, a
new embedding method based on the graph structure of the meaningful sentences
is proposed. The design of the algorithm aims to construct an embedding vector
that constitutes syntactic and semantic elements as well as the hidden content
of the text data. The success of the proposed embedding method is tested in
classification problems. Among the wide range of application areas, text
classification is the best laboratory for embedding methods; the classification
power of the method can be tested using dimensional reduction without any
further processing. Furthermore, the method can be compared with different
embedding algorithms and machine learning methods. The proposed method is
tested with real-world data sets and eight well-known and successful embedding
algorithms. The proposed embedding method shows significantly better
classification for binary and multiclass datasets compared to well-known
algorithms.
|
[
-0.21604876220226288,
-1.167374849319458,
0.4999311566352844,
-0.04017941653728485,
-0.16939635574817657,
0.468535453081131,
-0.02001788280904293,
-0.13198459148406982,
0.1826019287109375,
0.191611185669899,
-0.2115539163351059,
-0.9408689141273499,
-0.7419598698616028,
0.0004286226467229426,
-0.4794858396053314,
0.5826447606086731,
-0.31822970509529114,
0.12313184887170792,
-0.6251599788665771,
-0.21755841374397278,
-0.4554460942745209,
-0.5681851506233215,
0.017091764137148857,
-0.16111144423484802,
0.2511502206325531,
0.374307245016098,
0.4687139093875885,
0.8965206742286682,
0.315865695476532,
0.4087773561477661,
0.035940371453762054,
0.29097306728363037,
-0.3261141777038574,
0.15978652238845825,
0.21421165764331818,
-0.4034254848957062,
0.06576091051101685,
0.3097352683544159,
0.9365199208259583,
0.6677892804145813,
0.1213727816939354,
-0.25142961740493774,
0.21244825422763824,
0.13265050947666168,
-0.5144799947738647,
0.4149627685546875,
-0.18908476829528809,
0.5201586484909058,
-0.1298089474439621,
-0.49713388085365295,
-0.5759592056274414,
-0.7150001525878906,
-0.07340864092111588,
-0.5060542821884155,
0.25451698899269104,
0.3137889802455902,
0.7580476999282837,
0.32316824793815613,
-0.6195949912071228,
-0.2635820508003235,
-0.48958688974380493,
0.7368939518928528,
-0.23525002598762512,
0.5613577365875244,
0.28870952129364014,
0.30792051553726196,
0.13838320970535278,
-0.6757868528366089,
-0.7151097059249878,
0.3378758132457733,
-0.11239446699619293,
0.06368550658226013,
-0.07910390198230743,
-0.07203683257102966,
0.18658693134784698,
0.3233014941215515,
-0.5453269481658936,
0.1693616509437561,
-0.2605619728565216,
-0.3231857419013977,
0.35318824648857117,
0.0549604631960392,
0.31684693694114685,
-0.2626247704029083,
-0.31453460454940796,
-0.5309142470359802,
-0.21466195583343506,
-0.28012603521347046,
0.4922372102737427,
0.44092199206352234,
-0.08294174075126648,
0.6464841961860657,
0.026057615876197815,
0.6945804953575134,
-0.14956854283809662,
-0.289680153131485,
0.9295592308044434,
-0.306098610162735,
-0.06510445475578308,
0.3755809962749481,
0.4513736963272095,
0.27337372303009033,
-0.2285967767238617,
-0.21446599066257477,
0.11199814081192017,
0.2454180121421814,
0.004448482766747475,
-0.7806485891342163,
-0.08680396527051926,
0.1240939125418663,
-0.5545250773429871,
-0.3421280086040497,
0.2572866678237915,
-0.8401835560798645,
-0.25992685556411743,
-0.21695709228515625,
0.30182698369026184,
-0.519953191280365,
-0.008200990967452526,
-0.22310514748096466,
-0.5128270387649536,
0.3545383810997009,
0.37193822860717773,
-0.38872432708740234,
-0.029650112614035606,
0.6960765719413757,
0.9607865810394287,
-0.0116926534101367,
-0.20769307017326355,
-0.6377812027931213,
0.3020029067993164,
0.035051919519901276,
0.8952527046203613,
-0.9954695105552673,
-0.27037376165390015,
0.3860231935977936,
-0.03174744173884392,
-0.11172787845134735,
-0.009752337820827961,
0.6819878220558167,
-0.30016034841537476,
0.5732917189598083,
0.03693796694278717,
-1.0384398698806763,
-0.3964078724384308,
0.6413074731826782,
-0.5372230410575867,
0.8493527770042419,
0.24752569198608398,
-0.9801048040390015,
0.2841058671474457,
-0.514678418636322,
-0.43336233496665955,
0.1226915791630745,
-0.5111367702484131,
-0.7177590131759644,
-0.44339409470558167,
0.1204453706741333,
0.803987443447113,
-0.11492519080638885,
-0.015486130490899086,
-0.5420114994049072,
-0.31037235260009766,
-0.25064462423324585,
-0.32589396834373474,
0.63338702917099,
-0.03301386535167694,
0.023698750883340836,
-0.13967815041542053,
-0.7139878869056702,
0.2410753220319748,
0.16407446563243866,
-0.3996827304363251,
-0.6790919303894043,
-0.16331253945827484,
0.25785326957702637,
0.25819680094718933,
0.045990899205207825,
-0.8534620404243469,
0.35615023970603943,
-0.2339252084493637,
0.23051214218139648,
0.823599100112915,
0.06493944674730301,
0.5394826531410217,
-0.2529999315738678,
0.2963311970233917,
-0.2020300179719925,
-0.027885818853974342,
-0.3016299307346344,
-0.684475839138031,
-0.3608188331127167,
-0.31881752610206604,
0.549619197845459,
0.6298352479934692,
-0.7698648571968079,
0.7902740240097046,
-0.22173239290714264,
-0.48401758074760437,
-0.5415263772010803,
0.07028952240943909,
0.28857457637786865,
0.32558751106262207,
0.4327332079410553,
0.03153957426548004,
-0.41248780488967896,
-0.5430042743682861,
0.0169058870524168,
0.2517198324203491,
0.2349214255809784,
0.33204102516174316,
0.14444543421268463,
-0.7863610982894897,
0.6427159905433655,
-0.9942726492881775,
-0.3435392677783966,
-0.13838356733322144,
0.12604527175426483,
-0.2009669840335846,
0.5611343383789062,
0.5118411183357239,
-1.0307018756866455,
-0.5859927535057068,
-0.035661280155181885,
-1.0004587173461914,
0.35261261463165283,
0.10829154402017593,
-0.15525871515274048,
0.0005249249516054988,
0.6385108828544617,
-0.04483726620674133,
0.4229580760002136,
0.4899158477783203,
-0.525323212146759,
-0.15921132266521454,
-0.43071091175079346,
0.04935527592897415,
-1.1863738298416138,
-0.24640683829784393,
0.08927005529403687,
-0.1519280970096588,
-0.45790648460388184,
-0.06533565372228622,
0.2404944747686386,
-0.337062269449234,
-0.05069851502776146,
0.17644339799880981,
-0.47395873069763184,
0.08001265674829483,
-0.12921950221061707,
0.38663744926452637,
0.0862768217921257,
0.3611901104450226,
-0.18144316971302032,
0.018364841118454933,
0.6783797740936279,
-0.5803403854370117,
0.49698707461357117,
0.7880897521972656,
-0.1452551633119583,
0.5604908466339111,
-0.1518508642911911,
0.40579953789711,
-0.47290587425231934,
0.3674073815345764,
-1.1351486444473267,
-0.12116535007953644,
0.23017355799674988,
-0.2905729115009308,
0.5584061741828918,
0.12728896737098694,
-0.758345901966095,
-0.2954632341861725,
-0.5611330270767212,
0.16050508618354797,
0.17636118829250336,
-0.766156017780304,
0.8828803896903992,
0.6471617817878723,
-0.041397906839847565,
-0.3167661428451538,
-0.5341476202011108,
-0.1532915085554123,
-0.11134307086467743,
-0.6902519464492798,
0.7251850962638855,
0.025837529450654984,
0.24151626229286194,
0.2361910343170166,
0.12243416905403137,
-0.08109354972839355,
-0.001351610291749239,
0.4254385232925415,
0.331240177154541,
0.16448616981506348,
0.5833050012588501,
0.5290615558624268,
-0.37748023867607117,
-0.2719843089580536,
-0.06294380873441696,
0.6756611466407776,
0.1122625321149826,
-0.5761459469795227,
-0.3371995687484741,
0.6199686527252197,
0.1780029833316803,
-0.10372770577669144,
0.7162274122238159,
1.0377448797225952,
-0.4471348524093628,
-0.3568190634250641,
-0.09969601035118103,
0.13413356244564056,
-0.4125933051109314,
0.3581436276435852,
-0.2671884298324585,
-0.8502934575080872,
0.12019757926464081,
-0.5157075524330139,
0.19034366309642792,
0.5988377928733826,
0.2846073508262634,
-0.012466906569898129,
1.1528726816177368,
1.1142467260360718,
-0.18231362104415894,
0.4517662823200226,
-0.4998325705528259,
0.3170700669288635,
-0.471854567527771,
-0.7974112629890442,
-1.053701400756836,
-0.336941123008728,
-0.7647079229354858,
-0.4613344967365265,
0.2123180776834488,
-0.3038776218891144,
-0.060714442282915115,
0.2127247154712677,
-0.7430058121681213,
0.2750309109687805,
0.2774333357810974,
0.14055444300174713,
0.1723395586013794,
0.2382764369249344,
-0.33898282051086426,
0.12031774967908859,
-0.7699950337409973,
-0.22772762179374695,
0.9973270893096924,
0.3959161043167114,
0.7574367523193359,
0.15387189388275146,
0.854519784450531,
0.3924860954284668,
0.06514257937669754,
-0.7497754096984863,
0.1518959403038025,
-0.277302622795105,
-0.10488259792327881,
-0.2984517812728882,
-0.5565616488456726,
-0.9204111695289612,
0.2783498466014862,
-0.6399157047271729,
-0.4010949730873108,
0.11758073419332504,
-0.17095912992954254,
0.09321175515651703,
0.24797870218753815,
-0.7966663241386414,
0.684910237789154,
-0.1059802696108818,
-0.06133227050304413,
-0.16906090080738068,
-0.5518341660499573,
-0.10465625673532486,
-0.1630135029554367,
0.3753725588321686,
0.05775105580687523,
0.05633427947759628,
1.0002394914627075,
-0.28422805666923523,
0.6324992179870605,
-0.3718792796134949,
0.07285607606172562,
-0.04847598820924759,
-0.3336847424507141,
0.6260937452316284,
-0.18126024305820465,
-0.060062725096940994,
-0.062076956033706665,
-0.11815114319324493,
-0.44297340512275696,
-0.6992923021316528,
0.7440394759178162,
-0.7502012848854065,
-0.2150757610797882,
-0.38693463802337646,
-0.25349077582359314,
-0.34286731481552124,
0.19769616425037384,
0.1574256718158722,
0.6551375985145569,
-0.09034217894077301,
0.48961761593818665,
0.6418265700340271,
-0.2621919512748718,
0.4004087448120117,
0.21574528515338898,
-0.07184296101331711,
-0.2935686409473419,
1.1141297817230225,
0.09909069538116455,
-0.20277711749076843,
0.7021795511245728,
0.42881032824516296,
-0.46156713366508484,
-0.4481489360332489,
-0.35113149881362915,
0.13025671243667603,
-0.9118241667747498,
-0.37374380230903625,
-0.981905996799469,
-0.21402867138385773,
-0.6345887780189514,
-0.2874615788459778,
0.023774266242980957,
-0.3717001676559448,
-0.20351825654506683,
-0.2574125826358795,
0.3218303918838501,
0.7041275501251221,
0.2312711775302887,
0.060343701392412186,
-1.0279179811477661,
0.12607228755950928,
0.09235413372516632,
0.3148176372051239,
-0.1066322922706604,
-0.10837667435407639,
-0.1950855255126953,
-0.2820538580417633,
-0.2916202247142792,
-0.8344157338142395,
0.26968470215797424,
0.2081192433834076,
1.1029303073883057,
0.4795171320438385,
0.051089175045490265,
0.30432429909706116,
-0.29587307572364807,
0.34177422523498535,
0.10958034545183182,
-0.6857295036315918,
0.5907778143882751,
0.06032319739460945,
0.10462112724781036,
0.4105669856071472,
0.7293268442153931,
-0.3463590145111084,
-0.24140340089797974,
-0.8015295267105103,
-0.7444314360618591,
0.554999828338623,
0.04003165289759636,
0.22772790491580963,
0.20955976843833923,
0.26777002215385437,
0.22874270379543304,
0.10620684921741486,
-0.3778960108757019,
-0.47295376658439636,
-0.3777724504470825,
-0.5334015488624573,
-0.22320960462093353,
0.037927038967609406,
0.07089559733867645,
-0.3684675693511963,
0.49800533056259155,
-0.26733848452568054,
0.4784458577632904,
-0.04197763279080391,
-0.12845413386821747,
0.3045527935028076,
0.006462297402322292,
-0.0029557552188634872,
0.01186340767890215,
-0.1981104463338852,
0.28119945526123047,
0.06349369883537292,
-0.684188723564148,
0.10209410637617111,
0.44960564374923706,
-0.1455329954624176,
0.17151328921318054,
0.4748471677303314,
0.4866519272327423,
0.049390021711587906,
-0.3597114682197571,
0.7700902819633484,
-0.20674966275691986,
-0.22791342437267303,
0.032973211258649826,
0.08073577284812927,
-0.36246925592422485,
0.09385032206773758,
0.19767633080482483,
-0.006951211020350456,
0.2171219140291214,
-0.774164080619812,
0.32308268547058105,
0.331341415643692,
-0.4666703939437866,
0.1538040041923523,
-0.031058667227625847,
0.2704760432243347,
-0.2711939215660095,
0.6444283127784729,
-0.15237033367156982,
-0.7685109376907349,
0.30108824372291565,
0.6239588260650635,
0.5217126607894897,
-0.2579098343849182,
0.4289919435977936,
0.4003824293613434,
-0.03077256865799427,
0.16433322429656982,
0.11261115968227386,
-0.161235511302948,
-0.8228116035461426,
-0.15229719877243042,
-0.5467102527618408,
-0.3797528147697449,
-0.4269193410873413,
-0.3755793571472168,
0.22844818234443665,
-0.5116110444068909,
0.11136270314455032,
0.30448031425476074,
0.17995069921016693,
-0.6828565001487732,
-0.02372683212161064,
-0.020904207602143288,
0.7926608920097351,
-1.0367960929870605,
0.7809756398200989,
0.6199721097946167,
-0.26276642084121704,
-0.7211841344833374,
0.1264122575521469,
-0.016523562371730804,
-0.5700287222862244,
0.24279388785362244,
0.4622345566749573,
0.10315567255020142,
0.13192929327487946,
-0.5118532776832581,
-0.6152350306510925,
1.1440829038619995,
0.12115529179573059,
-0.25892433524131775,
0.06380435824394226,
-0.06753487884998322,
0.1930961161851883,
-0.3837001323699951,
0.025425920262932777,
0.15062636137008667,
0.7105666399002075,
0.22792857885360718,
-0.3278656005859375,
0.16377659142017365,
-0.4319586455821991,
-0.004103609826415777,
0.2603766918182373,
-0.47288978099823,
0.8745443224906921,
0.12244174629449844,
-0.3141542077064514,
-0.43133798241615295,
0.4583679139614105,
-0.08366531878709793,
0.41564977169036865,
0.5061694383621216,
0.6425262093544006,
1.3546204566955566,
-0.15643377602100372,
1.1821401119232178,
0.0013092121807858348,
0.5140268802642822,
0.6503152847290039,
-0.19308626651763916,
0.6520994901657104,
0.1022358164191246,
-0.14092868566513062,
0.911562979221344,
0.34550046920776367,
-0.40015968680381775,
0.7557464241981506,
0.12284991890192032,
-0.15289306640625,
-0.1435358077287674,
-0.07862400263547897,
-0.5053166747093201,
0.649218738079071,
0.29143035411834717,
-0.38726720213890076,
-0.43461325764656067,
0.48792967200279236,
-0.05911598354578018,
0.22099415957927704,
-0.1315569132566452,
0.8018604516983032,
-0.24369822442531586,
-0.11339680105447769,
0.06744175404310226,
0.4601401090621948,
0.7481635212898254,
-0.4539201259613037,
-0.3137228786945343,
0.184727281332016,
0.27129054069519043,
-0.4062788486480713,
-0.843828022480011,
0.2153092473745346,
-0.22388412058353424,
0.0012349727330729365,
-0.30843356251716614,
1.0492186546325684,
-0.34317415952682495,
-0.37995830178260803,
0.3434721827507019,
0.5541976094245911,
0.032041486352682114,
0.15691716969013214,
-0.5647154450416565,
0.09295810759067535,
0.04095294699072838,
0.2827206254005432,
0.3535308241844177,
0.5451962947845459,
0.3059641420841217,
0.41547122597694397,
0.7574690580368042,
-0.48190024495124817,
-0.048942387104034424,
0.11870063841342926,
1.038219928741455,
-0.6859086155891418,
-0.9742032289505005,
-0.5635440945625305,
0.09544121474027634,
-0.4112642705440521,
0.0013677128590643406,
1.1256740093231201,
0.820337176322937,
0.6820461750030518,
0.26169371604919434,
0.9592109322547913,
-0.1248382180929184,
0.48966872692108154,
-0.6051742434501648,
0.5209577083587646,
-0.32680246233940125,
-0.1967005580663681,
-0.6310381293296814,
-0.9283081293106079,
-0.4333595335483551,
0.7485999464988708,
-0.15985199809074402,
-0.002862038090825081,
0.8371332883834839,
0.42489221692085266,
-0.06718761473894119,
0.3327426314353943,
0.09645920246839523,
-0.15798211097717285,
0.33185604214668274,
0.3115374743938446,
0.5990935564041138,
-0.49991920590400696,
0.5404590964317322,
-0.18410007655620575,
-0.3418666422367096,
-0.2234647572040558,
-0.6331706643104553,
-0.9058517217636108,
-0.8464564681053162,
-0.4212261736392975,
-0.33231350779533386,
-0.25181883573532104,
0.7075610160827637,
0.5418198704719543,
-0.4776860773563385,
0.5503738522529602,
-0.024073999375104904,
0.5442495942115784,
0.024450508877635002,
-0.20908935368061066,
0.7450125217437744,
-0.07223828136920929,
-0.8564599752426147,
0.2718296945095062,
0.21690814197063446,
0.291282594203949,
-0.32777783274650574,
-0.13630975782871246,
-0.4385819733142853,
-0.2931789457798004,
0.610405445098877,
-0.03484451025724411,
0.05369456112384796,
-0.37107619643211365,
-0.19660843908786774,
-0.1380864381790161,
0.050993748009204865,
0.6100963354110718,
-0.8157531023025513,
0.3805319666862488,
0.684503436088562,
0.9304633736610413,
0.6280292272567749,
0.014155158773064613,
0.20610608160495758,
-0.9465710520744324,
0.2161029577255249,
0.21814605593681335,
0.3710208833217621,
0.39369750022888184,
-0.42806944251060486,
0.23379893600940704,
0.4240494668483734,
-0.10656514763832092,
-0.7051656246185303,
-0.23090142011642456,
-1.0656241178512573,
-0.4773658812046051,
0.9726208448410034,
-0.1300281435251236,
-0.20794011652469635,
-0.39532217383384705,
-0.19834312796592712,
0.597809374332428,
-0.2983132600784302,
0.48623648285865784,
0.42887043952941895,
-0.10178889334201813,
0.02383108250796795,
-0.15543943643569946,
0.10351597517728806,
-0.20935337245464325,
-1.1122281551361084,
-0.44024962186813354,
0.4609623849391937,
-0.028044195845723152,
0.5897790789604187,
0.16146133840084076,
-0.2022293359041214,
-0.12627723813056946,
0.41431933641433716,
-0.2321450412273407,
-0.401921808719635,
-0.41714346408843994,
-0.1707005500793457,
0.7271128296852112,
-0.40313658118247986,
-0.40729886293411255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16966v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16966v2
|
Examining the robustness of LLM evaluation to the distributional assumptions of benchmarks
| 2024-04-25T18:35:54 | 2024-06-05T20:14:15 |
Melissa Ailem, Katerina Marazopoulou, Charlotte Siska, James Bono
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Benchmarks have emerged as the central approach for evaluating Large Language
Models (LLMs). The research community often relies on a model's average
performance across the test prompts of a benchmark to evaluate the model's
performance. This is consistent with the assumption that the test prompts
within a benchmark represent a random sample from a real-world distribution of
interest. We note that this is generally not the case; instead, we hold that
the distribution of interest varies according to the specific use case. We find
that (1) the correlation in model performance across test prompts is
non-random, (2) accounting for correlations across test prompts can change
model rankings on major benchmarks, (3) explanatory factors for these
correlations include semantic similarity and common LLM failure points.
|
[
-0.30822744965553284,
-0.7345952391624451,
0.8200497031211853,
0.2976386845111847,
-0.10299094766378403,
-0.348482608795166,
-0.4139065444469452,
-0.2546864449977875,
-0.13468965888023376,
0.09432323276996613,
-0.3222711384296417,
-0.6150295734405518,
-0.6084669232368469,
0.08948338776826859,
-0.6924952268600464,
0.6836386322975159,
0.07890274375677109,
0.17038597166538239,
-0.464745432138443,
-0.49961981177330017,
-0.23268406093120575,
-0.547640323638916,
-0.3214561343193054,
-0.22816510498523712,
0.421444833278656,
0.10314320027828217,
0.8922687768936157,
0.7171028256416321,
0.7111119627952576,
0.21916361153125763,
-0.20171232521533966,
-0.18429972231388092,
-0.456813246011734,
0.3489428162574768,
-0.19845278561115265,
-0.7522056102752686,
-0.11114083230495453,
0.10466531664133072,
0.8652763962745667,
0.9137029051780701,
-0.2941710948944092,
0.36023056507110596,
0.20440497994422913,
0.2275242656469345,
-0.7480980753898621,
0.07594124227762222,
-0.697286069393158,
-0.3311365246772766,
-0.21945153176784515,
-0.08928001672029495,
-0.569462776184082,
-0.6089509725570679,
0.029550893232226372,
-0.32508063316345215,
0.34327229857444763,
0.25101467967033386,
0.8121720552444458,
0.06271298229694366,
-0.33293417096138,
-0.189055934548378,
-0.6317355632781982,
1.0761194229125977,
-0.6834661364555359,
0.36718565225601196,
0.306485116481781,
0.7027309536933899,
-0.24718375504016876,
-0.4843777120113373,
-0.2805800437927246,
-0.39935797452926636,
0.24067384004592896,
-0.06513573974370956,
-0.16434574127197266,
-0.24815122783184052,
0.3303644061088562,
0.5170758962631226,
-0.4475173056125641,
0.4103847146034241,
0.13283106684684753,
-0.11754227429628372,
0.6461457014083862,
0.49509304761886597,
0.2859615683555603,
-0.009536542929708958,
-0.48578256368637085,
-0.6402369141578674,
-0.7647529244422913,
0.28374573588371277,
0.32082995772361755,
0.523105263710022,
-0.2729516327381134,
0.6300712823867798,
-0.08894374966621399,
0.539131224155426,
-0.33586612343788147,
-0.33444836735725403,
0.29537317156791687,
-0.47595667839050293,
-0.25471073389053345,
-0.27274665236473083,
0.8992192149162292,
0.5764398574829102,
0.44035401940345764,
-0.21393349766731262,
-0.4243924021720886,
0.12846621870994568,
-0.00482040923088789,
-0.5924817323684692,
0.0022506401874125004,
0.14432156085968018,
-0.6117490530014038,
-0.20221802592277527,
0.08295087516307831,
-0.8622786998748779,
-0.38531702756881714,
-0.030728014186024666,
0.2177066057920456,
-0.21356113255023956,
-0.3070548474788666,
-0.14527305960655212,
-0.2672843039035797,
0.3223603665828705,
0.13453035056591034,
-0.9280222654342651,
0.5455446839332581,
0.7803077101707458,
0.6920521855354309,
-0.45515599846839905,
-0.463300496339798,
-0.3881874978542328,
-0.10434991866350174,
-0.49804559350013733,
1.0326902866363525,
-0.6456398367881775,
-0.5346925258636475,
0.3844652473926544,
-0.1978038102388382,
-0.30865979194641113,
-0.8863688707351685,
0.656609296798706,
-0.3908531665802002,
-0.28688284754753113,
-0.6540805697441101,
-0.6206467151641846,
0.15704159438610077,
0.24959976971149445,
-0.6351689100265503,
1.1864267587661743,
0.18876369297504425,
-0.8177098631858826,
0.5793381333351135,
-0.26791703701019287,
-0.16593778133392334,
-0.33664149045944214,
-0.34889161586761475,
-0.31714197993278503,
0.38619428873062134,
0.14850108325481415,
0.2729070782661438,
-0.7546706199645996,
0.27553674578666687,
-0.9465984106063843,
-0.4256724417209625,
0.7718150615692139,
-0.6355016231536865,
0.6445044875144958,
0.2744085490703583,
-0.19281208515167236,
0.05844898521900177,
-0.9177946448326111,
-0.05263474956154823,
0.028454530984163284,
-0.03543040156364441,
-0.4307045042514801,
0.1078849509358406,
0.08509506285190582,
-0.2208607792854309,
0.10656066983938217,
-0.1388954371213913,
0.058984316885471344,
-0.06779477000236511,
0.16863565146923065,
0.7448556423187256,
0.18867868185043335,
0.42321011424064636,
-0.5843886733055115,
0.6168798208236694,
-0.005616625305265188,
0.2862473428249359,
0.04730270057916641,
-0.4920300841331482,
-0.545677125453949,
-0.3615809679031372,
0.4064454138278961,
0.37777990102767944,
0.024549979716539383,
0.134189173579216,
-0.21887217462062836,
-0.5804329514503479,
-0.346073180437088,
0.3210976719856262,
0.31773027777671814,
0.2927439212799072,
0.09608231484889984,
-0.24271665513515472,
-0.27073824405670166,
-1.1855156421661377,
-0.4035349488258362,
-0.4768703579902649,
-0.12471990287303925,
0.2644307613372803,
0.24754498898983002,
-0.047275710850954056,
0.8011584877967834,
-0.31308358907699585,
0.1644187867641449,
-0.22998319566249847,
0.27484482526779175,
0.4793963134288788,
0.14445368945598602,
0.7596996426582336,
-0.4617229104042053,
-0.42896759510040283,
-0.2558577358722687,
-0.7585362792015076,
-0.5440255403518677,
0.22880779206752777,
0.08897818624973297,
-0.16612504422664642,
0.44847211241722107,
-0.5921499729156494,
0.23212046921253204,
0.5427778363227844,
0.04076942428946495,
0.7138644456863403,
-0.21739989519119263,
0.07228904217481613,
-1.0224961042404175,
-0.008374262601137161,
0.27362069487571716,
0.13419899344444275,
-0.2817920744419098,
0.21069549024105072,
-0.02926296554505825,
0.15919359028339386,
-0.23278900980949402,
0.5964245200157166,
-0.2812868654727936,
-0.45581212639808655,
-0.049874987453222275,
0.32681646943092346,
-0.17934967577457428,
-0.2379736304283142,
-0.3879529535770416,
1.0593326091766357,
0.6043972373008728,
-0.5595541596412659,
-0.0010155198397114873,
0.1022300124168396,
-0.6452262997627258,
0.6678385734558105,
-0.8292753100395203,
-0.34493395686149597,
0.13989150524139404,
-0.007025639992207289,
-1.2405200004577637,
-0.10920717567205429,
-0.32674604654312134,
-0.18316346406936646,
0.060316331684589386,
0.19855549931526184,
-0.9272052645683289,
-0.1136910617351532,
-0.4237891733646393,
0.2787732481956482,
0.7008469104766846,
-0.5579429864883423,
0.34652242064476013,
0.2609241306781769,
0.07015208154916763,
-0.4246249496936798,
-0.5963623523712158,
-0.27805620431900024,
-0.6790932416915894,
-0.6474961042404175,
-0.012747110798954964,
-0.2335931360721588,
-0.8948882818222046,
-0.2200775146484375,
-0.03673200681805611,
-0.044106680899858475,
0.5409112572669983,
0.392848938703537,
0.14167554676532745,
-0.3543910086154938,
0.11764707416296005,
-0.38432225584983826,
0.05909961834549904,
0.3495009243488312,
0.25267210602760315,
0.29230713844299316,
0.04058559983968735,
-0.5863011479377747,
-0.12046627700328827,
0.18501512706279755,
0.574413537979126,
0.018053283914923668,
0.5622803568840027,
0.3059772551059723,
-0.16120268404483795,
-0.5030118823051453,
-0.63860684633255,
-0.21620717644691467,
-0.4684934914112091,
0.26730066537857056,
-0.6492347121238708,
-0.5569909811019897,
0.9563374519348145,
-0.051045022904872894,
-0.07226668298244476,
0.35023078322410583,
0.7334837317466736,
-0.05314093828201294,
0.9693586230278015,
0.7303836345672607,
0.012630217708647251,
0.3638775050640106,
0.18572792410850525,
0.13588346540927887,
-0.923104465007782,
0.11399504542350769,
-0.871281623840332,
-0.0946299359202385,
-0.7214455604553223,
-0.4727162718772888,
0.22412219643592834,
0.3616827130317688,
-0.22619059681892395,
0.160619854927063,
-0.08920152485370636,
0.3489468991756439,
0.4965168237686157,
-0.23289144039154053,
0.24850520491600037,
-0.10116661339998245,
-0.6375515460968018,
-0.1355205476284027,
-0.564234733581543,
-0.693166971206665,
1.2994918823242188,
0.4109661877155304,
1.0195338726043701,
0.26281651854515076,
0.5405701398849487,
0.127114936709404,
0.5346468687057495,
-0.4077378213405609,
0.5812057852745056,
0.020313281565904617,
-0.5454659461975098,
-0.06857042014598846,
-0.2814287841320038,
-1.009633183479309,
0.2523632347583771,
-0.021056130528450012,
-1.0132920742034912,
0.25115570425987244,
-0.16415560245513916,
-0.22623972594738007,
0.025142885744571686,
-0.7416800260543823,
0.724435031414032,
0.04576030746102333,
-0.20751115679740906,
-0.01281683798879385,
-0.2973530888557434,
0.5389391779899597,
-0.16597037017345428,
0.4015819728374481,
-0.34697631001472473,
-0.15479207038879395,
0.6461496949195862,
-0.22743350267410278,
0.8243629932403564,
0.09043604135513306,
0.007984400726854801,
0.2776179909706116,
0.15439079701900482,
0.4678153693675995,
0.08523866534233093,
-0.453973650932312,
-0.08628354221582413,
0.1433776170015335,
-0.4163719117641449,
-0.784074604511261,
0.8026576638221741,
-0.9438349604606628,
-0.8190234899520874,
-0.3460064232349396,
-0.8044472932815552,
-0.5747628808021545,
-0.12273289263248444,
-0.045561596751213074,
0.4541637599468231,
-0.38073697686195374,
0.30761370062828064,
0.5578628182411194,
-0.19068385660648346,
0.48759832978248596,
0.37768080830574036,
-0.38300514221191406,
-0.2072574645280838,
0.3802528977394104,
0.08523096144199371,
0.653408944606781,
0.22076818346977234,
0.43483564257621765,
-0.5768694877624512,
-0.8878675103187561,
-0.15938465297222137,
0.24219945073127747,
-1.1928642988204956,
0.17727547883987427,
-0.36291611194610596,
0.02786565013229847,
-0.2897178828716278,
-0.0487314909696579,
-0.3064820170402527,
-0.15900275111198425,
-0.09612347185611725,
-0.1125917062163353,
0.35851067304611206,
0.8144485950469971,
0.027450745925307274,
0.18151825666427612,
-0.5063189268112183,
-0.008105350658297539,
0.28781595826148987,
0.25959891080856323,
0.1168447956442833,
-0.6570747494697571,
0.003608516650274396,
-0.2474370300769806,
-0.05647782236337662,
-0.7517369985580444,
0.11887503415346146,
0.03426003083586693,
1.132468819618225,
0.47075873613357544,
0.2639900743961334,
0.6024366617202759,
-0.3815164268016815,
0.914313554763794,
0.10180028527975082,
-0.6345080137252808,
0.2886362671852112,
-0.514829695224762,
0.22028407454490662,
0.8134997487068176,
0.40359848737716675,
0.03589998558163643,
-0.6411654949188232,
-0.6490193605422974,
-0.5789772868156433,
0.1398407220840454,
0.0671512633562088,
0.20229971408843994,
-0.17104695737361908,
0.13382141292095184,
0.0890154093503952,
0.060386400669813156,
-0.6502224802970886,
-0.30660495162010193,
0.22786027193069458,
-0.2873074412345886,
-0.36276838183403015,
-0.37350690364837646,
-0.4292617440223694,
0.0734138935804367,
0.16390952467918396,
-0.15829703211784363,
0.07672654092311859,
-0.0679442435503006,
-0.010960605926811695,
-0.056040775030851364,
0.29232510924339294,
0.6690446138381958,
1.029401421546936,
-0.5006704330444336,
0.36015447974205017,
0.22017133235931396,
-0.23301243782043457,
0.15721221268177032,
0.009389720857143402,
-0.047101255506277084,
0.0044066421687603,
0.4971620738506317,
0.5526795983314514,
0.63471519947052,
-0.6388710141181946,
0.5618560910224915,
-0.19916467368602753,
-0.008604818023741245,
-0.1335728019475937,
0.1466529667377472,
0.21871326863765717,
0.37304434180259705,
0.3529641330242157,
-0.12524963915348053,
-0.012383216060698032,
-0.6902353167533875,
0.3545278310775757,
0.578795850276947,
-0.15722975134849548,
-0.37011805176734924,
0.7705391645431519,
-0.1105952262878418,
-0.3321022391319275,
0.30861803889274597,
-0.09057210385799408,
-0.24942483007907867,
0.7584245204925537,
0.6866722106933594,
0.7536445260047913,
-0.1258154809474945,
0.053355973213911057,
0.3604482412338257,
0.36183488368988037,
-0.3381757140159607,
0.16334514319896698,
0.10481753200292587,
-0.609641969203949,
-0.1765618920326233,
-0.6816341280937195,
-0.5629540085792542,
0.024176420643925667,
-0.8464263081550598,
0.454305499792099,
-0.46751412749290466,
-0.24699126183986664,
-0.010784844867885113,
-0.18094854056835175,
-0.6888500452041626,
0.22811558842658997,
0.018367093056440353,
1.0982683897018433,
-1.1487940549850464,
0.958747148513794,
0.3805587887763977,
-0.43097496032714844,
-0.9630225896835327,
0.1497257649898529,
0.04505818337202072,
-1.0632857084274292,
0.7404983639717102,
0.04127749428153038,
0.3948138356208801,
-0.417932391166687,
-0.2118811011314392,
-1.1351922750473022,
1.091494083404541,
0.37150436639785767,
-0.46898138523101807,
0.355556845664978,
0.2990504503250122,
0.6377056241035461,
-0.5978153944015503,
0.5967734456062317,
0.3896593153476715,
0.35949185490608215,
0.05086461082100868,
-1.026971697807312,
0.17706528306007385,
-0.08804284036159515,
0.4026135206222534,
-0.0074439458549022675,
-0.741942286491394,
1.0142382383346558,
-0.04221051558852196,
-0.1715184450149536,
0.24637070298194885,
0.4559966027736664,
0.8337546586990356,
0.24651211500167847,
0.4705141484737396,
0.6214386820793152,
0.7448920011520386,
-0.04524250328540802,
1.5137940645217896,
-0.47191137075424194,
0.6112992763519287,
1.0635380744934082,
-0.5428768396377563,
1.2892299890518188,
0.5536264181137085,
-0.6286255717277527,
0.2752140164375305,
0.8596143126487732,
-0.22340449690818787,
0.653411328792572,
0.3800000846385956,
-0.03209563344717026,
-0.29003798961639404,
-0.2043600231409073,
-0.4478674829006195,
0.1950799524784088,
0.1217769980430603,
-0.5537877082824707,
-0.49340054392814636,
-0.4013603925704956,
-0.15870270133018494,
0.21386954188346863,
0.04989642649888992,
0.33410587906837463,
0.3614696264266968,
-0.6958786845207214,
0.701714038848877,
-0.3182678520679474,
0.2937852740287781,
-0.6275671124458313,
0.17852996289730072,
-0.2460826188325882,
0.33523860573768616,
0.11646641790866852,
-0.6997244358062744,
0.20877006649971008,
-0.23957888782024384,
-0.2617606222629547,
-0.046160489320755005,
0.5207706093788147,
0.098678819835186,
-0.5688273310661316,
0.5518646836280823,
0.5380029082298279,
0.2594815790653229,
0.34170442819595337,
-0.6909819841384888,
0.6632922887802124,
-0.252566397190094,
-0.3550705313682556,
0.7214290499687195,
0.40537652373313904,
-0.079640232026577,
0.7366859912872314,
0.6319850087165833,
0.04006970301270485,
0.24565276503562927,
0.41409918665885925,
0.6034440994262695,
-0.4021608829498291,
-0.1894194334745407,
-0.8478515148162842,
0.3484606146812439,
-0.028521331027150154,
-0.5278998613357544,
1.1739081144332886,
0.31902003288269043,
0.49484187364578247,
0.23807060718536377,
0.6662822961807251,
0.3699548840522766,
0.4605107605457306,
-0.42874908447265625,
0.4401739537715912,
-0.41299083828926086,
0.5003894567489624,
-0.13388444483280182,
-1.371455430984497,
-0.26398879289627075,
0.35648536682128906,
-0.47754207253456116,
0.20227912068367004,
0.9144036173820496,
0.7680534720420837,
-0.028632400557398796,
0.09258824586868286,
0.5799635052680969,
0.19888342916965485,
0.29698315262794495,
0.32105112075805664,
0.9809787273406982,
-0.3423295319080353,
0.34859782457351685,
-0.19809502363204956,
-0.24285365641117096,
-0.24070419371128082,
-1.0928423404693604,
-0.9965423345565796,
-0.3639708161354065,
-0.34550341963768005,
-0.5287306904792786,
-0.03505272790789604,
0.6563542485237122,
0.5640074014663696,
-0.8673493266105652,
-0.5432727336883545,
0.05970725417137146,
0.04180252179503441,
-0.33144715428352356,
-0.21306951344013214,
0.3552960753440857,
-0.5919188857078552,
-0.6766441464424133,
0.3424253463745117,
0.0891796350479126,
0.017640480771660805,
-0.5724915266036987,
0.1535526067018509,
0.04539055749773979,
0.39489492774009705,
0.1646585762500763,
0.001980880508199334,
-0.7616174221038818,
-0.4002736806869507,
0.04852253571152687,
-0.36980968713760376,
0.028619693592190742,
0.5247675180435181,
-0.31048959493637085,
0.3114445209503174,
0.44550657272338867,
0.725213885307312,
0.2785612940788269,
0.08973560482263565,
0.7685220241546631,
-0.47237280011177063,
0.12683439254760742,
-0.18919743597507477,
0.5378199815750122,
0.3727492392063141,
0.07125387340784073,
0.5609023571014404,
0.21275053918361664,
-0.7294631004333496,
-1.2686227560043335,
0.13171181082725525,
-1.1233729124069214,
0.015901723876595497,
1.5199041366577148,
-0.3361632525920868,
-0.5082660913467407,
0.09412305057048798,
0.4733333885669708,
-0.22555896639823914,
-0.1417345106601715,
0.8111926913261414,
1.1153440475463867,
-0.06117669492959976,
-0.23867404460906982,
-0.9498317837715149,
0.14876392483711243,
0.5302132964134216,
-0.5544761419296265,
0.11638319492340088,
0.07194274663925171,
0.5984793305397034,
0.30999991297721863,
0.18720073997974396,
-0.12466590851545334,
0.12493332475423813,
0.3205278813838959,
-0.341746985912323,
0.502263069152832,
0.06035694107413292,
-0.31080999970436096,
0.28890499472618103,
0.7295040488243103,
-0.03312988579273224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16958v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16958v2
|
A Closer Look at Classification Evaluation Metrics and a Critical Reflection of Common Evaluation Practice
| 2024-04-25T18:12:43 | 2024-07-02T08:53:09 |
Juri Opitz
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Classification systems are evaluated in a countless number of papers.
However, we find that evaluation practice is often nebulous. Frequently,
metrics are selected without arguments, and blurry terminology invites
misconceptions. For instance, many works use so-called 'macro' metrics to rank
systems (e.g., 'macro F1') but do not clearly specify what they would expect
from such a `macro' metric. This is problematic, since picking a metric can
affect research findings, and thus any clarity in the process should be
maximized.
Starting from the intuitive concepts of bias and prevalence, we perform an
analysis of common evaluation metrics. The analysis helps us understand the
metrics' underlying properties, and how they align with expectations as found
expressed in papers. Then we reflect on the practical situation in the field,
and survey evaluation practice in recent shared tasks. We find that metric
selection is often not supported with convincing arguments, an issue that can
make a system ranking seem arbitrary. Our work aims at providing overview and
guidance for more informed and transparent metric selection, fostering
meaningful evaluation.
|
[
-0.705984890460968,
-0.1358162760734558,
0.42294394969940186,
0.06594356149435043,
-0.3105531334877014,
0.14261241257190704,
-0.10343902558088303,
-0.7278234362602234,
0.2525377869606018,
0.13268643617630005,
-0.2067258059978485,
-0.3983812630176544,
-0.8864420652389526,
-0.0305471234023571,
-0.1378736048936844,
1.5089179277420044,
0.21120993793010712,
0.3210350275039673,
-0.6277609467506409,
-0.49858495593070984,
-0.47550469636917114,
-0.6605042219161987,
-0.3027394711971283,
-0.3598846197128296,
0.45321473479270935,
0.4037589430809021,
0.7875733971595764,
-0.017407285049557686,
0.959356427192688,
0.17323502898216248,
-0.30708613991737366,
0.1293521225452423,
-0.574881374835968,
-0.11665908247232437,
-0.043488118797540665,
-0.523361086845398,
-0.5718204379081726,
0.3764839768409729,
0.6764876246452332,
1.1892460584640503,
0.17680707573890686,
0.6146299839019775,
0.39477747678756714,
0.6227545738220215,
-1.1761246919631958,
-0.08166975528001785,
-0.2105516791343689,
0.34742191433906555,
-0.15103015303611755,
-0.03155871480703354,
-0.33127331733703613,
-0.7374669909477234,
0.3137929141521454,
-0.3428175747394562,
0.3762916326522827,
-0.19634051620960236,
0.6665529012680054,
0.1104912981390953,
-0.30252310633659363,
-0.1564631164073944,
-0.8837730288505554,
0.8670694828033447,
-0.22143054008483887,
0.24643445014953613,
-0.03080638125538826,
0.8624488711357117,
0.09426897764205933,
-0.7508578300476074,
0.08075032383203506,
-0.2943035960197449,
-0.20704686641693115,
0.2910088896751404,
-0.07960595935583115,
0.17304421961307526,
0.3698641061782837,
0.4403631389141083,
-0.29759055376052856,
0.00833443459123373,
-0.7395234107971191,
-0.3828584849834442,
0.5833914279937744,
0.19285400211811066,
-0.11799919605255127,
0.00930624920874834,
-0.23357918858528137,
0.14999769628047943,
-0.5588124394416809,
-0.18917632102966309,
0.28185826539993286,
-0.07292640209197998,
0.1954621523618698,
0.17152205109596252,
-0.18156056106090546,
0.8037639260292053,
-0.15556733310222626,
0.07958286255598068,
0.4319033920764923,
-0.21382944285869598,
-0.29421019554138184,
-0.21176159381866455,
0.5890166759490967,
0.7556763291358948,
0.16344322264194489,
-0.2370167374610901,
-0.23086772859096527,
0.48873651027679443,
0.6278824806213379,
-0.36661118268966675,
-0.010084148496389389,
-0.24609622359275818,
-0.7114942669868469,
-0.5443072319030762,
0.34873461723327637,
-0.9641145467758179,
-0.22057849168777466,
-0.2949990928173065,
0.4788486063480377,
0.20650245249271393,
-0.2463679015636444,
-0.055924154818058014,
-0.6537332534790039,
0.07510368525981903,
0.569753110408783,
-0.522334098815918,
0.6744669079780579,
1.0464643239974976,
0.758449137210846,
-0.2556067705154419,
-0.1673118770122528,
-0.29202577471733093,
-0.2952273488044739,
-0.46418869495391846,
0.8079281449317932,
-0.7591131329536438,
-0.5986737608909607,
-0.05177323892712593,
-0.09711085259914398,
0.0351632721722126,
-0.9046151041984558,
0.6646974682807922,
-0.3223053216934204,
0.3645613491535187,
-0.07235723733901978,
-0.38778600096702576,
-0.320395827293396,
0.5036898851394653,
-0.5293581485748291,
0.8630884289741516,
0.13202668726444244,
-0.7674450278282166,
1.1446444988250732,
-0.7761462330818176,
-0.022654501721262932,
-0.023606298491358757,
-0.13616958260536194,
-0.2626226246356964,
0.3441565930843353,
-0.16631363332271576,
0.45052623748779297,
-0.37601807713508606,
0.20231322944164276,
-0.48968181014060974,
-0.5910997986793518,
-0.12493667006492615,
-0.5012359023094177,
0.6274281740188599,
0.5841954946517944,
-0.31054115295410156,
-0.20140326023101807,
-0.4176517724990845,
0.09254077821969986,
-0.638985276222229,
0.04241642355918884,
-0.4468238055706024,
-0.05593825504183769,
-0.06494490057229996,
-0.1390610933303833,
0.22786718606948853,
-0.3394443392753601,
0.15651088953018188,
0.01608021929860115,
0.36055922508239746,
0.37155255675315857,
0.14989666640758514,
0.5765351057052612,
-0.6524271368980408,
0.7561012506484985,
-0.2949751019477844,
0.846114993095398,
0.5329849720001221,
-0.5539366006851196,
-0.4710118770599365,
-0.1930532306432724,
0.6979577541351318,
0.19756127893924713,
0.040350452065467834,
0.11438126862049103,
-0.3966769278049469,
-0.978007435798645,
-0.34202760457992554,
-0.03335687518119812,
0.4261808693408966,
0.25028303265571594,
0.18262460827827454,
-0.8814125061035156,
-0.23346656560897827,
-0.9373795390129089,
-0.4629546105861664,
-0.2286151796579361,
-0.00913343857973814,
0.5297735333442688,
0.48960521817207336,
-0.332293301820755,
0.8613656163215637,
-0.6696180701255798,
-0.22070017457008362,
0.0018269224092364311,
0.30408287048339844,
0.19992683827877045,
0.3416265845298767,
0.6969730854034424,
-0.6552789807319641,
-0.19431735575199127,
-0.20086367428302765,
-0.4815255105495453,
-0.12065556645393372,
0.100310780107975,
-0.2906274199485779,
0.02846844121813774,
0.48314958810806274,
-0.08375368267297745,
0.4182893633842468,
0.1640443503856659,
-0.23063258826732635,
0.693000078201294,
0.03918944671750069,
0.11315857619047165,
-0.3049813210964203,
0.1849461942911148,
0.18564070761203766,
-0.16776502132415771,
-0.15632516145706177,
0.25655731558799744,
-0.23918163776397705,
0.37103596329689026,
-0.20543548464775085,
0.33644241094589233,
-0.3798888325691223,
-0.3118344247341156,
-0.020980333909392357,
0.1476747840642929,
0.20890064537525177,
-0.02831820398569107,
0.051129743456840515,
0.3417694568634033,
0.5421066880226135,
-0.8391100168228149,
0.15036876499652863,
-0.10364631563425064,
-0.5510033965110779,
0.8235015869140625,
-0.2712741196155548,
-0.09810378402471542,
0.0024894329253584146,
0.4838525652885437,
-0.6080201268196106,
-0.013722119852900505,
0.28980666399002075,
-0.5163342356681824,
0.1661020666360855,
-0.297890841960907,
-0.31633850932121277,
-0.47522661089897156,
-0.33215558528900146,
0.5951888561248779,
0.48865243792533875,
-0.5941506028175354,
0.0014226449420675635,
0.6874562501907349,
0.17144601047039032,
-0.8166330456733704,
-0.4695259630680084,
-0.07966466248035431,
-0.4721100330352783,
-0.25186967849731445,
0.12296809256076813,
0.07135666161775589,
-0.6089543104171753,
-0.011133692227303982,
-0.4545588791370392,
-0.37457993626594543,
0.3890671730041504,
0.2229517251253128,
0.18830038607120514,
-0.08301755040884018,
0.23135438561439514,
-0.07387544214725494,
0.038363851606845856,
0.25181424617767334,
0.056121617555618286,
0.1920461356639862,
-0.25219130516052246,
-0.45808377861976624,
0.0071318442933261395,
0.04951788857579231,
0.6167426109313965,
0.011820316314697266,
0.22439861297607422,
0.44596466422080994,
-0.2083088904619217,
-0.09628267586231232,
-0.5829476714134216,
-0.22399063408374786,
-0.3671434819698334,
0.24036510288715363,
-0.11902157962322235,
-0.42711108922958374,
0.15596069395542145,
-0.26993322372436523,
0.46218252182006836,
0.6324436664581299,
0.15587887167930603,
-0.1381249874830246,
0.8715575933456421,
0.6261547803878784,
-0.1214449554681778,
0.2765296697616577,
-0.37661266326904297,
0.13805615901947021,
-0.8662638068199158,
-0.32102611660957336,
-0.7476019263267517,
-0.6284686326980591,
-0.7688466906547546,
-0.6141950488090515,
0.43341463804244995,
0.16011576354503632,
-0.09905502945184708,
-0.0065542287193238735,
-0.9993879795074463,
0.4995448887348175,
0.3330475986003876,
-0.06824813783168793,
0.2792314291000366,
-0.27243632078170776,
-0.06921739876270294,
0.00020921521354466677,
-0.6406660079956055,
-0.8637306690216064,
1.263866901397705,
0.38674014806747437,
0.4064784049987793,
-0.1081177145242691,
1.002315878868103,
0.35901445150375366,
0.8926073908805847,
-1.0683023929595947,
0.28724268078804016,
-0.14897921681404114,
-0.9791111350059509,
-0.2404497265815735,
-0.29658401012420654,
-0.9321461319923401,
0.47210144996643066,
-0.15370753407478333,
-0.5620697736740112,
0.33098316192626953,
-0.0932263657450676,
-0.4108440577983856,
0.21347171068191528,
-0.7899396419525146,
0.8043310642242432,
-0.030030278488993645,
-0.08749381452798843,
-0.41406604647636414,
-0.5109002590179443,
0.4621930718421936,
0.11358972638845444,
0.43409326672554016,
0.0690491646528244,
0.05400731787085533,
1.0676634311676025,
-0.21689589321613312,
0.684482753276825,
-0.4577201008796692,
0.16698965430259705,
0.5199469327926636,
0.015421323478221893,
-0.32103803753852844,
0.12148255854845047,
-0.15538761019706726,
0.30112752318382263,
0.5415287017822266,
-0.4049612581729889,
-0.7185351848602295,
0.315268337726593,
-0.5452435612678528,
-0.45738014578819275,
-0.5681082606315613,
0.04498786851763725,
-0.38944804668426514,
-0.08747201412916183,
0.44262537360191345,
0.46426868438720703,
-0.7250597476959229,
0.1410398930311203,
0.5216385722160339,
0.07434392720460892,
0.04199882224202156,
0.18546763062477112,
-0.16939401626586914,
-0.22355179488658905,
0.9310794472694397,
0.45639124512672424,
0.20460009574890137,
0.28481996059417725,
0.2745778560638428,
-0.24703164398670197,
-0.37571343779563904,
-0.19786639511585236,
-0.026880308985710144,
-0.641423761844635,
-0.27189913392066956,
-0.3826836943626404,
-0.20848612487316132,
-0.3328857719898224,
-0.21684791147708893,
0.0031134956516325474,
-0.7825349569320679,
-0.004553072154521942,
-0.08277604728937149,
0.054339729249477386,
1.0163698196411133,
-0.29117581248283386,
0.12674938142299652,
-0.7245311141014099,
0.1267576366662979,
0.31260278820991516,
0.46832212805747986,
0.027446532621979713,
-0.4166621267795563,
-0.17433802783489227,
-0.20989513397216797,
-0.519737184047699,
-0.6079496741294861,
-0.015660738572478294,
0.10784772783517838,
0.8537524342536926,
0.7803173065185547,
0.13624481856822968,
0.4481651782989502,
-0.2617174983024597,
0.7624925971031189,
0.2893848121166229,
-0.6688806414604187,
0.3249225616455078,
0.08343926072120667,
-0.11499295383691788,
0.9656354784965515,
0.5345176458358765,
-0.6791235208511353,
-0.5411548614501953,
-0.9050682783126831,
-0.6416038870811462,
0.40467146039009094,
-0.15065301954746246,
0.11061759293079376,
0.05271518975496292,
0.1450248509645462,
0.3954189419746399,
0.34019050002098083,
-0.6546970009803772,
-0.16995903849601746,
-0.10986301302909851,
0.04970402643084526,
-0.17926464974880219,
-0.11474230885505676,
-0.4689198434352875,
-0.435276061296463,
0.2718260586261749,
0.006293211132287979,
0.34800705313682556,
0.18048697710037231,
-0.1888829618692398,
0.2574664056301117,
0.4765086770057678,
0.3847106099128723,
0.7931428551673889,
-0.2478199154138565,
0.05032685771584511,
0.16324582695960999,
-0.7037198543548584,
-0.09011293202638626,
-0.24714337289333344,
-0.08497785776853561,
0.31167319416999817,
0.26477476954460144,
0.39474746584892273,
0.3586682379245758,
-0.26989346742630005,
0.5295984745025635,
0.06856802850961685,
-0.3821024000644684,
-0.23384349048137665,
0.27295759320259094,
-0.38384267687797546,
-0.08238379657268524,
0.05610605329275131,
0.5130777955055237,
0.5609525442123413,
-0.6976999044418335,
0.06251853704452515,
0.6112829446792603,
-0.7677487134933472,
-0.10004420578479767,
0.11031804233789444,
0.4943242073059082,
-0.21695508062839508,
0.17967434227466583,
-0.2585197985172272,
-0.5690656900405884,
0.8413581848144531,
0.06271015107631683,
0.887311577796936,
0.3158496916294098,
0.6527314186096191,
0.33360713720321655,
0.33387523889541626,
-0.22102056443691254,
-0.05178423225879669,
-0.353767454624176,
-0.47375765442848206,
-0.020834844559431076,
-0.7244488596916199,
-0.6541751027107239,
-0.08419505506753922,
-0.9348236322402954,
0.42347264289855957,
-0.6434130668640137,
-0.413891077041626,
-0.0006254487088881433,
0.35649651288986206,
-0.7435382604598999,
0.3643045127391815,
0.07841400802135468,
1.1968797445297241,
-0.9484691023826599,
0.16529886424541473,
0.8731305599212646,
-0.14632561802864075,
-0.616732656955719,
0.06473959982395172,
-0.019981568679213524,
-0.4873403310775757,
0.6403817534446716,
0.33298906683921814,
-0.21597793698310852,
-0.6404520273208618,
-0.44541871547698975,
-0.5361138582229614,
0.7916340231895447,
-0.13334296643733978,
-0.561883270740509,
0.14534392952919006,
-0.20542697608470917,
0.772620677947998,
-0.41428205370903015,
0.84190833568573,
0.724301815032959,
0.6959031224250793,
-0.16046413779258728,
-1.1808781623840332,
-0.24910055100917816,
-0.1262546181678772,
-0.4801560044288635,
0.369107186794281,
-0.8048843741416931,
0.16815149784088135,
-0.1452798843383789,
-0.13852417469024658,
-0.097555011510849,
-0.011990056373178959,
0.24235865473747253,
1.0242377519607544,
0.6612111926078796,
0.4415638744831085,
0.8739407062530518,
-0.11527904868125916,
0.7626898288726807,
0.0908791720867157,
0.2886072099208832,
0.8310413360595703,
-0.2720690667629242,
0.7039536833763123,
0.431856244802475,
-0.40614891052246094,
0.6370652914047241,
0.889947235584259,
-0.33400988578796387,
0.4719379246234894,
0.502600908279419,
-0.2750779390335083,
-0.15369059145450592,
-0.060895226895809174,
-0.5492021441459656,
0.6125717759132385,
0.5237421989440918,
-0.35105809569358826,
-0.43988803029060364,
-0.41617700457572937,
-0.2768575847148895,
0.0030187461525201797,
-0.6588743329048157,
0.7719857096672058,
0.12227342277765274,
-0.8581370115280151,
0.2779513895511627,
-0.344796746969223,
0.7574014663696289,
-0.006792545318603516,
0.011201067827641964,
-0.09900710731744766,
-0.18782657384872437,
-0.5755159854888916,
-0.7273609638214111,
0.4753233790397644,
0.2116636484861374,
-0.2262895256280899,
-0.24893487989902496,
0.4666924774646759,
0.4147239327430725,
-0.39326077699661255,
0.13754354417324066,
0.5949525833129883,
0.5714643597602844,
0.1656848043203354,
-0.4280697703361511,
-0.3526584506034851,
-0.19446994364261627,
0.13406157493591309,
0.32689177989959717,
0.5242255330085754,
-0.14261147379875183,
0.4331062138080597,
0.14371201395988464,
0.30438604950904846,
-0.03935827314853668,
0.19030523300170898,
0.5721681714057922,
-0.5562062859535217,
-0.438567578792572,
-0.44170522689819336,
0.1816595494747162,
-0.23503702878952026,
-0.509171724319458,
0.444823294878006,
0.5580195784568787,
0.9321743249893188,
0.24020683765411377,
0.6449974775314331,
0.014608103781938553,
0.5792720913887024,
-0.1497308760881424,
0.7399373650550842,
-0.5700697302818298,
0.3052108585834503,
-0.49066177010536194,
-1.1766459941864014,
-0.4714718163013458,
0.5419657230377197,
-0.5925884246826172,
0.1166723296046257,
0.5532398819923401,
0.3103238046169281,
-0.07555441558361053,
0.07816408574581146,
0.3153506815433502,
-0.23373381793498993,
0.008709893561899662,
0.24433186650276184,
1.161557674407959,
-0.1496112048625946,
0.5859406590461731,
-0.11648762971162796,
-0.42691510915756226,
-0.4132808744907379,
-0.7601780891418457,
-0.4833233058452606,
-0.11631099879741669,
-0.4877207577228546,
-0.2312120497226715,
0.022494126111268997,
0.6153349280357361,
0.7875311374664307,
-0.5845938920974731,
-0.24035893380641937,
-0.07089953869581223,
0.4102404713630676,
-0.3418741822242737,
-0.31361332535743713,
-0.060993682593107224,
-0.4562476575374603,
-0.6836718320846558,
-0.20970872044563293,
0.04985933005809784,
-0.2300015240907669,
-0.19782806932926178,
-0.1124313548207283,
0.4276883602142334,
-0.12235043942928314,
0.41299915313720703,
0.3010152280330658,
-0.4076724946498871,
-0.24120453000068665,
-0.35617923736572266,
-0.08216138929128647,
0.14695820212364197,
0.891027569770813,
-1.0231709480285645,
0.2519421875476837,
0.5993863940238953,
0.3805587589740753,
0.2267402559518814,
-0.23103401064872742,
0.601387619972229,
-0.33177450299263,
-0.2156587541103363,
0.7207475900650024,
0.15185244381427765,
0.01643606275320053,
-0.1606391966342926,
0.7791189551353455,
0.21679076552391052,
-0.7075309753417969,
-1.4256623983383179,
0.2685520052909851,
-0.7477384805679321,
-0.3518776595592499,
0.917105495929718,
0.0183340422809124,
0.04875887557864189,
-0.21938969194889069,
-0.017114343121647835,
-0.026626966893672943,
-0.11601664125919342,
1.0721654891967773,
0.811631441116333,
-0.28671300411224365,
0.3656163215637207,
-0.6220629811286926,
0.6624873876571655,
0.5910077095031738,
-0.49356406927108765,
-0.1436205953359604,
0.5826150178909302,
0.31582772731781006,
0.635633647441864,
0.47673723101615906,
-0.43305617570877075,
0.4872816205024719,
-0.1549026370048523,
-0.3096816837787628,
0.6437270045280457,
-0.5106303095817566,
-0.4969208836555481,
0.19137373566627502,
0.36490070819854736,
-0.15617235004901886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16829v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16829v3
|
Make-it-Real: Unleashing Large Multimodal Model for Painting 3D Objects with Realistic Materials
| 2024-04-25T17:59:58 | 2024-05-23T19:12:51 |
Ye Fang, Zeyi Sun, Tong Wu, Jiaqi Wang, Ziwei Liu, Gordon Wetzstein, Dahua Lin
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Physically realistic materials are pivotal in augmenting the realism of 3D
assets across various applications and lighting conditions. However, existing
3D assets and generative models often lack authentic material properties.
Manual assignment of materials using graphic software is a tedious and
time-consuming task. In this paper, we exploit advancements in Multimodal Large
Language Models (MLLMs), particularly GPT-4V, to present a novel approach,
Make-it-Real: 1) We demonstrate that GPT-4V can effectively recognize and
describe materials, allowing the construction of a detailed material library.
2) Utilizing a combination of visual cues and hierarchical text prompts, GPT-4V
precisely identifies and aligns materials with the corresponding components of
3D objects. 3) The correctly matched materials are then meticulously applied as
reference for the new SVBRDF material generation according to the original
albedo map, significantly enhancing their visual authenticity. Make-it-Real
offers a streamlined integration into the 3D content creation workflow,
showcasing its utility as an essential tool for developers of 3D assets.
|
[
-0.4110407531261444,
-0.8244338631629944,
0.637143075466156,
0.06392920017242432,
-0.12332776188850403,
0.47297564148902893,
-0.08498886972665787,
-0.5339158773422241,
-0.11630949378013611,
0.39591991901397705,
-0.48655158281326294,
-0.2612643241882324,
0.0017645526677370071,
-0.1548285037279129,
-0.17173776030540466,
0.6327068209648132,
-0.3752644956111908,
-0.18147248029708862,
0.11200354993343353,
-0.04507441446185112,
-0.3051082193851471,
-0.4100564122200012,
-0.10321824997663498,
0.17608261108398438,
0.6331027746200562,
0.33295339345932007,
0.9639363288879395,
0.868517279624939,
0.4991593360900879,
0.4049643576145172,
0.5284426808357239,
0.3029438257217407,
-0.3076710104942322,
-0.25363844633102417,
-0.29198938608169556,
-0.11825640499591827,
-0.4362451732158661,
0.28339335322380066,
0.41940274834632874,
0.11819349229335785,
-0.22387444972991943,
0.19393804669380188,
-0.08187790215015411,
0.3622468113899231,
-0.5225761532783508,
0.1410539150238037,
-0.4888026714324951,
0.1548212170600891,
-0.27755075693130493,
-0.5860099196434021,
-0.2799992263317108,
-0.09903120249509811,
-0.083274707198143,
-1.085654616355896,
0.6391533613204956,
0.18270625174045563,
1.0478427410125732,
-0.027503717690706253,
-0.5160146355628967,
-0.06678777933120728,
-1.1199873685836792,
0.7959445118904114,
-0.5959476232528687,
0.47122156620025635,
0.005973665043711662,
0.7472331523895264,
0.025371776893734932,
-1.0316829681396484,
-0.9693447351455688,
-0.37369027733802795,
0.13124556839466095,
0.4215743839740753,
0.45000550150871277,
0.044540662318468094,
0.22153735160827637,
0.42290645837783813,
-0.6602736115455627,
-0.3152144253253937,
-0.5702605247497559,
-0.22356043756008148,
0.30296140909194946,
0.08420714735984802,
0.5472848415374756,
0.051435329020023346,
-0.684391438961029,
-0.32455188035964966,
-0.7288713455200195,
-0.5653331875801086,
0.3825473487377167,
0.4352164566516876,
0.11323990672826767,
0.9378867149353027,
0.1457904726266861,
0.6867163777351379,
-0.35229015350341797,
-0.3151053786277771,
0.147297665476799,
-0.666262686252594,
-0.2865971326828003,
-0.06305503845214844,
0.569718599319458,
0.6985327005386353,
0.0820397362112999,
0.025091595947742462,
-0.3060394823551178,
-0.03872416168451309,
0.519873321056366,
-0.9357211589813232,
-0.2624812424182892,
0.09991726279258728,
-0.2732487916946411,
-0.14758139848709106,
0.030608240514993668,
-0.4185333847999573,
-0.3735198676586151,
-0.869102954864502,
0.8477147817611694,
-0.23209501802921295,
-0.722750186920166,
0.24592174589633942,
-0.18671996891498566,
0.31759822368621826,
0.620776355266571,
-0.5536201000213623,
-0.05908077955245972,
0.4264787435531616,
0.9176014065742493,
0.29638242721557617,
-0.1833036094903946,
-0.25578397512435913,
0.5754368305206299,
-0.7401551604270935,
0.5922787189483643,
-0.354089617729187,
-0.2795889675617218,
0.00044388588867150247,
-0.08198155462741852,
0.34557288885116577,
-0.4772186577320099,
0.28176024556159973,
-0.3958919942378998,
0.47598525881767273,
-0.39165812730789185,
-0.15655119717121124,
-0.11593159288167953,
0.4682740569114685,
-0.913266658782959,
0.7842122316360474,
0.6222673654556274,
-0.5672329068183899,
0.38889238238334656,
-0.32612547278404236,
0.14610452950000763,
0.3535298705101013,
-0.2522399425506592,
-0.4039749503135681,
0.028175311163067818,
-0.11710207164287567,
0.5000739693641663,
-0.4544743001461029,
0.19454699754714966,
-0.37213411927223206,
-0.21191374957561493,
0.17724695801734924,
-0.4384552836418152,
0.07675208151340485,
0.46931901574134827,
-0.1928182989358902,
0.11101621389389038,
-0.5422155261039734,
-0.2845020890235901,
-0.06400950253009796,
-0.24576959013938904,
0.08048313111066818,
-0.5404126644134521,
0.6602857112884521,
0.5760816335678101,
0.3569889962673187,
-0.8839147090911865,
0.40590861439704895,
-0.0384843535721302,
-0.015447822399437428,
0.8218544721603394,
-0.19487158954143524,
0.6602161526679993,
-0.5786539316177368,
0.5101200342178345,
-0.17646189033985138,
0.19407127797603607,
-0.23206199705600739,
-0.23165924847126007,
-0.5283803343772888,
-0.7046010494232178,
0.11600834876298904,
0.306761771440506,
-1.2136807441711426,
-0.27292701601982117,
-0.27046534419059753,
-0.7114942073822021,
-0.27638280391693115,
0.14507605135440826,
0.15704214572906494,
0.5570942759513855,
0.08891667425632477,
-0.12365905195474625,
-0.4300100803375244,
-0.9160436391830444,
0.06917492300271988,
0.08672428131103516,
-0.31354284286499023,
0.25284072756767273,
0.3046504557132721,
-0.10747310519218445,
0.9381083846092224,
-0.4108770191669464,
-0.7727445960044861,
-0.01284781750291586,
0.20995347201824188,
0.13415516912937164,
0.5295031666755676,
0.827293872833252,
-0.8829841017723083,
-0.47686269879341125,
0.19608083367347717,
-0.9009389877319336,
0.26520034670829773,
-0.3808508813381195,
-0.2832699418067932,
-0.025001773610711098,
0.6789082884788513,
-0.606027364730835,
0.04109608381986618,
0.5350767374038696,
-0.43795478343963623,
0.6845505237579346,
-0.6184828281402588,
0.546708881855011,
-0.9701751470565796,
0.0008260715985670686,
0.016413850709795952,
-0.1806241273880005,
-0.37862810492515564,
0.17600810527801514,
-0.07238727807998657,
-0.354932576417923,
-0.7095736265182495,
0.7096222639083862,
-0.6625058054924011,
-0.08689502626657486,
-0.16020938754081726,
0.01381748542189598,
0.3688599467277527,
0.5759124159812927,
0.08691161125898361,
0.5436369776725769,
0.3489286005496979,
-0.41494572162628174,
0.8325448036193848,
-0.06072232872247696,
-0.7150404453277588,
0.5608694553375244,
-0.47126078605651855,
-0.12996520102024078,
-0.1667359322309494,
0.17725318670272827,
-1.0246955156326294,
-0.4871339797973633,
0.3748604953289032,
-0.014395025558769703,
0.31251251697540283,
-0.1532781720161438,
-0.9773567318916321,
-0.19426870346069336,
-0.1482234001159668,
0.5969927310943604,
0.33133769035339355,
-0.4622822403907776,
1.2768081426620483,
-0.03184477239847183,
-0.2243271917104721,
-0.26832637190818787,
-0.6040811538696289,
0.27513444423675537,
-0.11783184856176376,
-0.581852376461029,
0.7390379309654236,
-0.512650728225708,
-0.0868678167462349,
0.028741195797920227,
0.10657735913991928,
-0.2798924446105957,
-0.06347724050283432,
0.093407541513443,
0.404386967420578,
-0.1925305426120758,
-0.22870787978172302,
-0.2228311151266098,
0.011883818544447422,
-0.36333683133125305,
0.06793813407421112,
0.25310927629470825,
-0.24761994183063507,
-0.5904584527015686,
-0.3050314784049988,
0.1728591024875641,
1.0222434997558594,
-0.0971243679523468,
0.5329825282096863,
0.915188193321228,
-0.38363492488861084,
-0.12473642081022263,
-0.5119996666908264,
-0.10139524191617966,
-0.5812343955039978,
0.3677591383457184,
-0.5593509674072266,
-0.42242008447647095,
0.17999939620494843,
-0.12025135010480881,
0.48449304699897766,
0.06098554655909538,
0.6994530558586121,
-0.08669199049472809,
1.1156916618347168,
0.3978903889656067,
0.7671976089477539,
0.5484455227851868,
-0.4127579927444458,
0.13542227447032928,
-0.6457034945487976,
-0.36221274733543396,
-0.046148523688316345,
-0.19155988097190857,
-0.2763921916484833,
-0.942467451095581,
0.28708982467651367,
-0.27981308102607727,
-0.36302563548088074,
0.22590398788452148,
-0.6677154302597046,
0.4526727795600891,
0.26745226979255676,
0.3209195137023926,
0.25066882371902466,
0.11401160806417465,
-0.018717734143137932,
-0.31120356917381287,
-0.44874107837677,
-0.5650720596313477,
0.8992959260940552,
0.2915106415748596,
0.7137948870658875,
0.4067344069480896,
0.14239501953125,
0.4087763726711273,
0.6525071859359741,
-0.4176284074783325,
0.35216420888900757,
0.11931421607732773,
-0.6573169827461243,
0.04623797535896301,
-0.1021333709359169,
-0.5437993407249451,
0.29381993412971497,
-0.40603986382484436,
0.09448286890983582,
0.19263236224651337,
0.36919641494750977,
-0.28450125455856323,
0.5609226226806641,
-0.8231451511383057,
0.8283454179763794,
-0.3897075057029724,
-0.5733821392059326,
-0.011254174634814262,
-0.10454774647951126,
0.49694907665252686,
-0.3358410894870758,
0.7146332859992981,
-0.3496403396129608,
-0.05566982552409172,
0.29816505312919617,
-0.3801913857460022,
0.535944938659668,
-0.2041885256767273,
-0.5914521813392639,
0.2954581081867218,
0.5717980861663818,
0.39348891377449036,
-0.06307223439216614,
-0.027366848662495613,
-0.13747577369213104,
-0.17331090569496155,
-0.4356915056705475,
-0.841044008731842,
0.7560330629348755,
-0.5463700294494629,
-0.3298852741718292,
-0.3059919774532318,
-0.6973219513893127,
-0.026275796815752983,
0.20996303856372833,
0.021398119628429413,
0.8565937876701355,
-0.18163736164569855,
0.15244127810001373,
0.3706665337085724,
-0.3550017774105072,
0.3809029161930084,
0.39133161306381226,
-0.3998063802719116,
-0.25922340154647827,
1.408966302871704,
0.2873963415622711,
0.31593912839889526,
0.34247538447380066,
0.2154032289981842,
-0.43928584456443787,
-0.359703928232193,
-0.8228065967559814,
0.24339568614959717,
-0.7000056505203247,
-0.08485826849937439,
-0.4371487498283386,
0.042033351957798004,
-0.06308041512966156,
-0.7451677918434143,
-0.6765136122703552,
-0.3101852238178253,
-0.17379584908485413,
-0.2421390861272812,
0.2102179229259491,
0.8070223927497864,
-0.10521697998046875,
0.15821611881256104,
-0.8322157859802246,
0.6840951442718506,
0.6519632935523987,
0.36338067054748535,
-0.19204464554786682,
-0.4598085582256317,
-0.22604240477085114,
0.31085291504859924,
0.04194507375359535,
-0.3703411817550659,
0.5532354116439819,
0.2566123306751251,
0.4828806221485138,
0.30256256461143494,
-0.03938005492091179,
0.49150350689888,
-0.5167680978775024,
0.8025103211402893,
0.3039312958717346,
-0.570876955986023,
0.038234248757362366,
-0.9769615530967712,
0.16874249279499054,
0.0728667601943016,
0.18335433304309845,
-0.14295895397663116,
-0.24805444478988647,
-0.644907534122467,
-0.9714543223381042,
0.4357678294181824,
0.266292929649353,
0.26566630601882935,
0.1544034630060196,
-0.02712569199502468,
-0.08785920590162277,
0.2792189121246338,
-0.8641923069953918,
0.10223347693681717,
-0.8439769148826599,
-0.3883877694606781,
0.02975507266819477,
-0.334905743598938,
-0.3934430181980133,
-0.016151489689946175,
0.6180732846260071,
-0.1943597048521042,
0.5067422389984131,
0.025042356923222542,
-0.08223707973957062,
0.07564448565244675,
0.034268807619810104,
0.7960326671600342,
0.7732993364334106,
-0.6356965899467468,
0.25629839301109314,
-0.2808350920677185,
-0.17194251716136932,
0.18694305419921875,
-0.07682698965072632,
0.2920288145542145,
0.02533300593495369,
0.29921045899391174,
0.612808883190155,
-0.0004380947502795607,
-0.7721338868141174,
0.5946422815322876,
0.010110004805028439,
-0.370118647813797,
-0.4356786608695984,
-0.1793123483657837,
-0.014502095058560371,
0.1201743334531784,
0.39802291989326477,
0.09385013580322266,
0.009597261436283588,
-0.7322783470153809,
0.22069106996059418,
0.24205319583415985,
-0.3837367594242096,
-0.4389425814151764,
0.7434638142585754,
0.33786070346832275,
0.032682131975889206,
0.44438499212265015,
-0.048885278403759,
-0.35904660820961,
0.6974160671234131,
0.5599326491355896,
0.39466872811317444,
-0.14095723628997803,
0.4279848635196686,
0.5415047407150269,
0.2125786393880844,
-0.3049221634864807,
0.17258669435977936,
-0.04656001925468445,
-0.833625078201294,
-0.44451501965522766,
-0.5847315788269043,
-0.3738362193107605,
-0.04346261918544769,
-0.20844867825508118,
0.2370239943265915,
-0.8833523392677307,
0.10193061083555222,
-0.2145933210849762,
-0.44298702478408813,
-0.7663210034370422,
0.45975014567375183,
0.282822847366333,
0.5248993635177612,
-0.9504132866859436,
0.47123730182647705,
0.4147598445415497,
-0.7019732594490051,
-0.7340337634086609,
-0.48734304308891296,
0.03803851082921028,
-0.543310284614563,
0.7938580513000488,
0.0833478569984436,
-0.18288502097129822,
0.2736223340034485,
-0.5605036616325378,
-0.923992395401001,
1.0605897903442383,
0.43090343475341797,
-0.5026189684867859,
-0.10047245025634766,
0.17118193209171295,
0.29324907064437866,
-0.20090599358081818,
0.32011038064956665,
-0.013898573815822601,
0.6436153650283813,
0.5180389881134033,
-0.714164674282074,
0.10437911748886108,
-0.38709190487861633,
0.0185402724891901,
-0.03395341336727142,
-0.40846461057662964,
0.8441480398178101,
-0.11945731937885284,
-0.4014626145362854,
0.05108506232500076,
0.7326791882514954,
0.4213427007198334,
-0.18811661005020142,
0.6023988723754883,
0.3451070487499237,
0.3871275782585144,
-0.21316294372081757,
1.204243779182434,
0.01527116633951664,
0.19121970236301422,
0.8545837998390198,
-0.30973973870277405,
0.3698364794254303,
0.13872818648815155,
0.19870002567768097,
0.3496916890144348,
0.5620808005332947,
-0.2277078479528427,
0.7452739477157593,
0.17802731692790985,
-0.743263840675354,
-0.29542216658592224,
-0.3316803276538849,
-0.3137657344341278,
0.21700052917003632,
0.432414710521698,
-0.07444915920495987,
-0.29917946457862854,
0.5323857665061951,
-0.03538614138960838,
0.13222551345825195,
-0.035137567669153214,
0.4308203458786011,
-0.2688344717025757,
-0.3237331509590149,
0.530933678150177,
0.11998813599348068,
0.5372540950775146,
-0.6231220960617065,
-0.40567514300346375,
0.09758521616458893,
0.18078942596912384,
-0.07741301506757736,
-0.8483480215072632,
0.14884088933467865,
-0.29495617747306824,
-0.004450883716344833,
-0.6170511245727539,
0.27399227023124695,
-0.5967943668365479,
-0.5092757940292358,
-0.08477090299129486,
0.2541668117046356,
-0.12547153234481812,
-0.19514581561088562,
-0.721304714679718,
0.08591869473457336,
0.019028477370738983,
-0.3291352391242981,
0.21733610332012177,
0.6392412781715393,
-0.042429473251104355,
0.6786927580833435,
1.133697271347046,
0.027776705101132393,
-0.08593923598527908,
0.10450456291437149,
0.7318919897079468,
-0.45425161719322205,
-0.05312124639749527,
-0.5463438630104065,
0.7864524722099304,
0.0170708280056715,
0.06430009752511978,
0.8013965487480164,
0.749991774559021,
0.7353559732437134,
-0.41100385785102844,
0.8961953520774841,
-0.018345458433032036,
0.24067136645317078,
-0.5011869668960571,
0.522598147392273,
-0.7214640378952026,
0.2373119741678238,
-0.5057166218757629,
-1.191200613975525,
-0.36981573700904846,
0.6158608794212341,
0.446225643157959,
0.08432823419570923,
0.415679395198822,
1.127336859703064,
-0.39776524901390076,
-0.6255500316619873,
0.5163847804069519,
0.25076016783714294,
0.7966057062149048,
0.08504170179367065,
0.8510298132896423,
-0.30870088934898376,
0.6951362490653992,
-0.2895120084285736,
-0.1851232796907425,
-0.02380293607711792,
-1.2655961513519287,
-0.4499608874320984,
-0.7033652663230896,
-0.5071322917938232,
-0.4798077344894409,
-0.37980416417121887,
0.6927327513694763,
0.7388296723365784,
-0.360914945602417,
0.038247447460889816,
-0.002290082862600684,
-0.3196686804294586,
-0.23358489573001862,
-0.21561449766159058,
0.35477322340011597,
0.1901879757642746,
-0.9205805063247681,
0.4062560498714447,
0.3827399015426636,
0.42495962977409363,
-0.3441133201122284,
0.037256937474012375,
-0.1253221184015274,
0.2233407199382782,
0.7212539911270142,
0.3153120279312134,
-0.49202582240104675,
-0.23830962181091309,
-0.09346113353967667,
-0.30082976818084717,
-0.11321546882390976,
0.7992027997970581,
-0.7357152104377747,
0.8972762823104858,
0.5088248252868652,
0.39120543003082275,
0.6300613880157471,
0.0440581776201725,
1.0274147987365723,
-0.9763305187225342,
0.24519895017147064,
-0.007452293299138546,
0.4852134585380554,
0.7548236846923828,
-0.13300715386867523,
0.5174713730812073,
0.3284798264503479,
-0.36073750257492065,
-0.7185113430023193,
0.3762825131416321,
-1.2494242191314697,
-0.5146439075469971,
1.0858086347579956,
0.13553084433078766,
-0.25980958342552185,
-0.3921046853065491,
-0.7742376923561096,
0.19096292555332184,
-0.08756846189498901,
0.5819919109344482,
0.4705183207988739,
0.36220288276672363,
-0.2567485570907593,
-0.7410377264022827,
0.49066248536109924,
-0.1340787261724472,
-0.686145544052124,
0.17142467200756073,
0.7387691140174866,
0.30629903078079224,
0.17951610684394836,
0.7442924380302429,
-0.20911382138729095,
0.24081967771053314,
0.1000213474035263,
0.3355771601200104,
-0.49118772149086,
-0.4139534831047058,
0.5540838241577148,
0.28535196185112,
0.09339654445648193,
0.04987214878201485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16924v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16924v1
|
A Survey of Generative Search and Recommendation in the Era of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-25T17:58:17 | 2024-04-25T17:58:17 |
Yongqi Li, Xinyu Lin, Wenjie Wang, Fuli Feng, Liang Pang, Wenjie Li, Liqiang Nie, Xiangnan He, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
With the information explosion on the Web, search and recommendation are
foundational infrastructures to satisfying users' information needs. As the two
sides of the same coin, both revolve around the same core research problem,
matching queries with documents or users with items. In the recent few decades,
search and recommendation have experienced synchronous technological paradigm
shifts, including machine learning-based and deep learning-based paradigms.
Recently, the superintelligent generative large language models have sparked a
new paradigm in search and recommendation, i.e., generative search (retrieval)
and recommendation, which aims to address the matching problem in a generative
manner. In this paper, we provide a comprehensive survey of the emerging
paradigm in information systems and summarize the developments in generative
search and recommendation from a unified perspective. Rather than simply
categorizing existing works, we abstract a unified framework for the generative
paradigm and break down the existing works into different stages within this
framework to highlight the strengths and weaknesses. And then, we distinguish
generative search and recommendation with their unique challenges, identify
open problems and future directions, and envision the next information-seeking
paradigm.
|
[
-0.572292685508728,
-0.5116530060768127,
0.7457263469696045,
0.17605440318584442,
-0.07423215359449387,
0.09290097653865814,
-0.04025564342737198,
-0.4331696331501007,
0.25120648741722107,
0.48778343200683594,
-0.6236693263053894,
-0.3700028359889984,
-0.22783589363098145,
-0.020895134657621384,
-0.7106229066848755,
0.8189666867256165,
0.17313963174819946,
0.036068323999643326,
-0.448054701089859,
0.03182792663574219,
-0.7440996766090393,
-0.6560781002044678,
-0.5730772018432617,
-0.4863487184047699,
0.52909255027771,
0.1900310069322586,
0.7831645011901855,
0.3608520030975342,
0.5523035526275635,
0.2870560586452484,
-0.20715798437595367,
0.04481210932135582,
-0.38468536734580994,
0.6848061084747314,
-0.311921626329422,
-0.336661696434021,
0.0005903439596295357,
-0.2009846270084381,
0.4365270435810089,
0.700072705745697,
-0.4851728081703186,
-0.11358864605426788,
0.06443189084529877,
0.8414406180381775,
-0.849297046661377,
0.1667887419462204,
-0.6374756693840027,
0.20992064476013184,
-0.476311594247818,
-0.3599473834037781,
-0.4562755525112152,
-0.19969359040260315,
0.5030869245529175,
-0.9528865218162537,
0.43534576892852783,
0.3619156777858734,
0.4198552072048187,
-0.18989808857440948,
-0.36223646998405457,
-0.42732465267181396,
-1.0042555332183838,
0.5623351335525513,
-0.26625949144363403,
0.5777738690376282,
0.269574910402298,
0.32735297083854675,
-0.47931158542633057,
-0.7457235455513,
-0.2928318381309509,
-0.18966570496559143,
0.19290637969970703,
-0.15088096261024475,
-0.3837287425994873,
-0.10011328756809235,
0.013622721657156944,
0.6500377655029297,
-0.8287481069564819,
0.19972151517868042,
-0.16185496747493744,
-0.062161654233932495,
0.38069891929626465,
0.009877459146082401,
0.5166748762130737,
0.13545073568820953,
-0.3750719130039215,
-0.0682513564825058,
-0.6277230381965637,
-0.5665397644042969,
0.06318521499633789,
0.3479289412498474,
0.2713020443916321,
0.5308889746665955,
-0.40266546607017517,
0.8183785676956177,
0.07261823117733002,
0.26104724407196045,
-0.03371986746788025,
-0.5668133497238159,
-0.08720967173576355,
0.00524469930678606,
0.811556875705719,
0.3804470896720886,
0.25785595178604126,
-0.39176684617996216,
-0.15066897869110107,
-0.08366923034191132,
0.35303908586502075,
-0.46648383140563965,
-0.12072443217039108,
-0.1412080079317093,
-0.5579082369804382,
-0.10218384116888046,
0.2845780849456787,
-0.8457863926887512,
-0.7874248027801514,
-0.22781050205230713,
0.2354835718870163,
-0.2839725613594055,
-0.316775381565094,
0.10711604356765747,
-0.2927042245864868,
0.21642090380191803,
0.34594306349754333,
-1.0796319246292114,
0.10833537578582764,
0.7927331924438477,
0.7821783423423767,
-0.05168170481920242,
-0.14933857321739197,
-0.17595341801643372,
0.11952479183673859,
-0.3836788535118103,
1.030579686164856,
-0.6158331036567688,
-0.6103061437606812,
0.5295372009277344,
-0.09728343039751053,
0.19596268236637115,
-0.6150224804878235,
0.5057317614555359,
-0.9620117545127869,
0.23536090552806854,
-0.3412090837955475,
-0.5138588547706604,
-0.23176977038383484,
0.17709317803382874,
-0.6961918473243713,
0.9771628379821777,
0.1073216050863266,
-0.5163285732269287,
0.568429172039032,
-0.7683026790618896,
-0.4701257050037384,
0.5537893176078796,
-0.06832288950681686,
-0.0699317455291748,
0.15362656116485596,
0.13667382299900055,
0.5052454471588135,
-1.017264723777771,
0.4169468581676483,
-0.5780750513076782,
-0.4711466431617737,
0.0012722741812467575,
-0.018434926867485046,
0.4992560148239136,
0.28928402066230774,
-0.2998204529285431,
0.14636413753032684,
-0.5370953679084778,
0.07018325477838516,
0.27443790435791016,
-0.2898722290992737,
-0.5362197756767273,
0.3570629954338074,
0.44829076528549194,
0.027628596872091293,
0.4488966464996338,
-0.2361246943473816,
0.3952612578868866,
-0.20149821043014526,
0.7274250388145447,
0.8220199346542358,
-0.1943606436252594,
0.5089703798294067,
-0.1975651979446411,
0.3831671476364136,
-0.18343497812747955,
0.18341559171676636,
-0.2807212769985199,
-0.31528323888778687,
-0.6826654076576233,
0.3003954291343689,
0.08328521996736526,
0.18263152241706848,
-0.6755447387695312,
0.7113855481147766,
-0.19451174139976501,
-0.4558402895927429,
-0.5515469312667847,
0.007286759093403816,
0.11909650266170502,
-0.06949270516633987,
0.4705525040626526,
-0.24816763401031494,
-0.9044179916381836,
-0.729019045829773,
-0.05924270302057266,
-0.31860193610191345,
-0.10521434247493744,
0.3819212317466736,
0.05720040202140808,
-0.6131646037101746,
0.7530738115310669,
-0.487068772315979,
-0.6061049103736877,
-0.17515681684017181,
-0.1502462476491928,
0.12588320672512054,
0.2617473602294922,
0.35655978322029114,
-1.2000718116760254,
-0.39159321784973145,
0.1948186159133911,
-0.8708449602127075,
0.17222954332828522,
0.2234734743833542,
0.023639271035790443,
-0.1774905025959015,
0.5578301548957825,
-0.4345674216747284,
-0.11713644117116928,
0.20177853107452393,
-0.3133945167064667,
0.3550432324409485,
-0.23878198862075806,
0.15703453123569489,
-1.1488839387893677,
0.1723458468914032,
0.0964135080575943,
0.0701385885477066,
-0.3660374581813812,
0.5237381458282471,
-0.16058336198329926,
-0.14741484820842743,
0.15570858120918274,
0.5358043313026428,
-0.5005452632904053,
-0.05308043211698532,
-0.21075117588043213,
0.2562718391418457,
-0.008766868151724339,
-0.017010841518640518,
-0.36894282698631287,
0.8139932155609131,
0.6984243392944336,
-0.6828182935714722,
0.7859899997711182,
0.3404691517353058,
-0.5218852162361145,
0.8016238212585449,
-0.5563724637031555,
0.1967974156141281,
-0.24721908569335938,
0.5677937865257263,
-0.6856475472450256,
-0.1539650559425354,
-0.17971524596214294,
-0.07856966555118561,
-0.11919263005256653,
-0.048179082572460175,
-0.7441551089286804,
-0.6490402817726135,
-0.17279115319252014,
0.5117553472518921,
0.3619612753391266,
-0.6626811623573303,
0.49920958280563354,
0.21190513670444489,
-0.3060641288757324,
-0.6148424744606018,
-0.19310878217220306,
0.34314119815826416,
0.07844142615795135,
-0.42328882217407227,
0.6505604982376099,
-0.3292105495929718,
-0.2111867070198059,
0.05000316724181175,
0.02582564391195774,
-0.04764106497168541,
0.156844362616539,
0.3737412691116333,
0.4409078359603882,
-0.15224948525428772,
0.15882807970046997,
-0.4131912887096405,
-0.08717316389083862,
-0.3230838477611542,
-0.9581781029701233,
0.832074761390686,
-0.09765125066041946,
-0.3596414625644684,
-0.04438541829586029,
0.661052405834198,
0.8260654211044312,
-0.34506309032440186,
0.4865169823169708,
0.6781181693077087,
-0.13761307299137115,
0.10874194651842117,
-0.9348376393318176,
-0.027263008058071136,
-0.45663681626319885,
0.4093939960002899,
-0.3342515528202057,
-1.0996237993240356,
0.10205857455730438,
0.031212445348501205,
-0.12999293208122253,
0.7280928492546082,
0.592530369758606,
-0.23711362481117249,
1.1495977640151978,
1.0207287073135376,
-0.3872983753681183,
0.6820876598358154,
-0.11974649131298065,
0.3066752254962921,
-0.8166223764419556,
-0.5640406608581543,
-0.6259883642196655,
0.04965348169207573,
-0.6836282014846802,
0.12249802052974701,
0.38178953528404236,
0.2510528564453125,
-0.02912074886262417,
0.34779679775238037,
-0.7001022100448608,
0.32908865809440613,
0.7579571008682251,
-0.21447832882404327,
0.3267151713371277,
-0.062029533088207245,
-0.3786052465438843,
0.2111232876777649,
-0.6169125437736511,
-0.1223975270986557,
1.1059377193450928,
-0.22053834795951843,
0.6831845045089722,
0.07497326284646988,
0.19116345047950745,
0.6731442213058472,
0.09949701279401779,
-0.7420470714569092,
0.5517718195915222,
-0.32176652550697327,
-0.692305326461792,
-0.07892929017543793,
-0.25706928968429565,
-1.2262181043624878,
0.14833468198776245,
-0.31813761591911316,
-0.47876840829849243,
0.22531336545944214,
-0.027459081262350082,
-0.09664326906204224,
0.3042357861995697,
-0.18381187319755554,
0.6689660549163818,
-0.08718288689851761,
-0.10468567162752151,
-0.48235979676246643,
-0.4468458294868469,
-0.05368340015411377,
0.059574175626039505,
0.0372062548995018,
0.07020559906959534,
0.4727965295314789,
0.5468060970306396,
0.16321814060211182,
0.19960296154022217,
0.10966531932353973,
-0.018514977768063545,
0.10455992072820663,
0.07299438118934631,
0.5330086350440979,
-0.3298393785953522,
-0.18014192581176758,
-0.012258648872375488,
0.14595580101013184,
-0.2649357318878174,
-0.4373439848423004,
0.8746638894081116,
-0.47928309440612793,
-0.6254550218582153,
-0.3874029517173767,
-0.3287228047847748,
0.004188193939626217,
0.5214745402336121,
0.3663025498390198,
0.24272264540195465,
-0.6354705095291138,
0.5557489395141602,
0.7915555834770203,
0.1351895034313202,
0.259955495595932,
0.6006783843040466,
-0.4635952413082123,
-0.23892946541309357,
1.0003501176834106,
-0.1924755722284317,
-0.2879527509212494,
0.6830024123191833,
0.022942420095205307,
-0.5164496898651123,
-0.44629430770874023,
-0.27758753299713135,
0.0400380939245224,
-0.5467711687088013,
-0.023270517587661743,
-0.4968355596065521,
-0.04737451672554016,
-0.5351468920707703,
-0.21033509075641632,
-0.09310571849346161,
0.25985756516456604,
-0.3169423043727875,
0.2125265747308731,
0.027407458052039146,
0.971224844455719,
0.25848057866096497,
-0.18571092188358307,
-0.4525359272956848,
0.2824639678001404,
0.49780189990997314,
0.7527235746383667,
0.11933666467666626,
0.003707188181579113,
-0.32478365302085876,
-0.23819944262504578,
-0.22579579055309296,
-0.49327486753463745,
-0.06594908237457275,
-0.0012592226266860962,
0.5015273690223694,
0.6029331088066101,
-0.013763412833213806,
0.3228617310523987,
-0.5567739009857178,
0.7121990919113159,
0.2997429370880127,
-0.3875563144683838,
0.483765184879303,
-0.45992934703826904,
0.1011194959282875,
0.46351879835128784,
0.4318059980869293,
-1.0891597270965576,
0.27839985489845276,
-0.2559365928173065,
-0.8857383728027344,
0.40821191668510437,
-0.0851757675409317,
0.04219233989715576,
0.14377859234809875,
0.2924027740955353,
0.05913114547729492,
0.3586503565311432,
-0.3797627091407776,
-0.13508513569831848,
0.13437816500663757,
0.06206011772155762,
-0.33751076459884644,
-0.301226407289505,
-0.10553517937660217,
0.0636034831404686,
0.6511397957801819,
-0.07725603878498077,
0.38617464900016785,
-0.13947436213493347,
0.09805837273597717,
-0.2518741488456726,
0.5229623913764954,
0.12128515541553497,
0.46198171377182007,
-0.1515135020017624,
-0.035032711923122406,
-0.5821449160575867,
-0.11037303507328033,
0.38335198163986206,
0.36565324664115906,
-0.5674213171005249,
-0.10455305129289627,
0.046782348304986954,
0.7804838418960571,
0.15381157398223877,
-0.8078473210334778,
0.5012956857681274,
0.03932413086295128,
-0.00769431097432971,
-0.4765211343765259,
0.1251845359802246,
-0.024219615384936333,
0.20171479880809784,
0.6574190855026245,
0.06636008620262146,
0.38158464431762695,
-0.8974636793136597,
-0.16716760396957397,
0.8262466192245483,
-0.5125457048416138,
-0.18044394254684448,
0.5810889601707458,
0.20375095307826996,
-0.4237408936023712,
0.5343385338783264,
0.05244490131735802,
-0.20361769199371338,
0.1311938315629959,
0.6026056408882141,
1.2559248208999634,
-0.12655261158943176,
0.25671443343162537,
-0.09473638236522675,
-0.07960712909698486,
-0.6142270565032959,
-0.07409118860960007,
-0.3751988708972931,
-0.733350932598114,
0.08629892766475677,
-0.7691944241523743,
-0.37219738960266113,
0.18232843279838562,
-0.869702160358429,
-0.048551373183727264,
-0.3270159959793091,
-0.03787735477089882,
0.3634902536869049,
-0.17545723915100098,
-0.697959840297699,
0.007785777095705271,
-0.09249735623598099,
0.6672333478927612,
-0.3650323748588562,
0.3799673318862915,
0.9978465437889099,
-0.5529724955558777,
-0.036998454481363297,
0.11376891285181046,
-0.01646665669977665,
-0.5830326676368713,
0.43209683895111084,
-0.026677962392568588,
-0.13592828810214996,
0.017062580212950706,
-0.37605398893356323,
-0.8960925936698914,
1.009331464767456,
0.1971593201160431,
-0.5368810892105103,
-0.49768921732902527,
-0.24217358231544495,
0.6034832000732422,
-0.1903313398361206,
0.17128577828407288,
0.26802191138267517,
0.4624621868133545,
-0.02130267396569252,
-0.8113364577293396,
-0.11451220512390137,
-0.39953672885894775,
0.5459609627723694,
0.2894654870033264,
-0.5339962840080261,
0.754654049873352,
-0.06482452154159546,
-0.4237692058086395,
0.4442850947380066,
0.4020389914512634,
-0.04667486250400543,
0.36051997542381287,
0.35895606875419617,
0.4410313367843628,
0.3863634765148163,
-0.030498526990413666,
1.1139607429504395,
-0.22654269635677338,
0.17936193943023682,
0.7674962878227234,
-0.50527423620224,
0.870786190032959,
0.16902318596839905,
-0.4752484858036041,
0.7156486511230469,
0.6903713345527649,
-0.3146596848964691,
0.4566023647785187,
-0.004979154095053673,
-0.3367815911769867,
-0.4215105175971985,
-0.5555503964424133,
-0.5362000465393066,
0.2805154025554657,
0.2680284380912781,
-0.3802196681499481,
-0.31585949659347534,
0.17963001132011414,
-0.3192605674266815,
0.22440674901008606,
-0.20940226316452026,
1.1000456809997559,
-0.18351313471794128,
-0.8812519907951355,
0.40199974179267883,
0.12878485023975372,
0.7785977125167847,
-0.584986686706543,
-0.1001225933432579,
-0.1471358686685562,
-0.0020067677833139896,
-0.0005305903032422066,
-0.6597225069999695,
-0.4514828324317932,
-0.4121186137199402,
-0.8099392056465149,
-0.16211098432540894,
0.7329042553901672,
-0.19520772993564606,
-0.1848767250776291,
0.5959693789482117,
0.40583622455596924,
-0.159014031291008,
-0.33276334404945374,
-0.5976470708847046,
-0.03846334293484688,
-0.10578247159719467,
0.25450649857521057,
0.5178726315498352,
0.22134427726268768,
0.08288516104221344,
0.8824568390846252,
0.8457597494125366,
-0.060072414577007294,
-0.257847398519516,
0.07698413729667664,
0.7462785840034485,
-0.6879076957702637,
-0.5750284790992737,
-0.6185511946678162,
-0.23075731098651886,
0.12048900127410889,
-0.12540952861309052,
0.5202381014823914,
0.42522361874580383,
0.9241340160369873,
0.07939376682043076,
0.9814179539680481,
-0.06378494203090668,
0.2790454924106598,
-0.32771697640419006,
0.41807878017425537,
-0.6008685231208801,
0.18888728320598602,
-0.24752189218997955,
-1.3695226907730103,
-0.07999888062477112,
0.22020575404167175,
0.008388304151594639,
0.34417346119880676,
0.356662392616272,
0.7467118501663208,
0.006328124087303877,
0.01854323223233223,
0.2701490521430969,
0.15586711466312408,
0.09051726013422012,
0.4208459258079529,
0.8363203406333923,
-0.26886510848999023,
0.4352152943611145,
0.3569739758968353,
-0.06446690112352371,
-1.031957745552063,
-0.3957430124282837,
-0.3418344259262085,
-1.1388461589813232,
0.08686599135398865,
-0.28192657232284546,
0.40405306220054626,
0.9160001873970032,
0.7081124782562256,
-0.7413730025291443,
-0.14217039942741394,
-0.5118452906608582,
0.1906915307044983,
-0.4096452295780182,
-0.24571426212787628,
0.24929308891296387,
-0.20785583555698395,
-0.4744323194026947,
0.7654834985733032,
0.7125524878501892,
0.1078696995973587,
-0.6939167976379395,
0.20198816061019897,
-0.29366329312324524,
-0.1981855034828186,
0.6477030515670776,
0.5044495463371277,
-0.8981245756149292,
0.12609148025512695,
0.05408591777086258,
-0.3651706576347351,
-0.11051293462514877,
1.2116450071334839,
-0.7905974984169006,
0.8964129090309143,
0.28149813413619995,
0.6778764724731445,
0.5030595660209656,
-0.2259502410888672,
0.7622843980789185,
-0.3212272524833679,
-0.2634987235069275,
0.09369093179702759,
0.17746907472610474,
0.401121586561203,
-0.3495594263076782,
0.543649435043335,
0.2759169042110443,
-0.4514366388320923,
-0.7445911765098572,
0.42907091975212097,
-0.7299985289573669,
-0.35589441657066345,
0.8467885851860046,
0.07399424910545349,
0.5734093189239502,
-0.2387610226869583,
-0.14309802651405334,
0.005481786094605923,
-0.3076523542404175,
1.0076180696487427,
0.5649464130401611,
0.12215767055749893,
0.12055657804012299,
-0.39158445596694946,
0.2789384126663208,
0.6350354552268982,
-0.4717143177986145,
0.01149395015090704,
0.5063526630401611,
-0.06345923244953156,
0.3379769027233124,
0.4657951891422272,
0.07022202014923096,
0.26352009177207947,
-0.10790593177080154,
0.15948955714702606,
0.12323597818613052,
-0.41252440214157104,
-0.20890454947948456,
0.44578686356544495,
0.22265450656414032,
0.1273692101240158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16816v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16816v1
|
IndicGenBench: A Multilingual Benchmark to Evaluate Generation Capabilities of LLMs on Indic Languages
| 2024-04-25T17:57:36 | 2024-04-25T17:57:36 |
Harman Singh, Nitish Gupta, Shikhar Bharadwaj, Dinesh Tewari, Partha Talukdar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As large language models (LLMs) see increasing adoption across the globe, it
is imperative for LLMs to be representative of the linguistic diversity of the
world. India is a linguistically diverse country of 1.4 Billion people. To
facilitate research on multilingual LLM evaluation, we release IndicGenBench -
the largest benchmark for evaluating LLMs on user-facing generation tasks
across a diverse set 29 of Indic languages covering 13 scripts and 4 language
families. IndicGenBench is composed of diverse generation tasks like
cross-lingual summarization, machine translation, and cross-lingual question
answering. IndicGenBench extends existing benchmarks to many Indic languages
through human curation providing multi-way parallel evaluation data for many
under-represented Indic languages for the first time. We evaluate a wide range
of proprietary and open-source LLMs including GPT-3.5, GPT-4, PaLM-2, mT5,
Gemma, BLOOM and LLaMA on IndicGenBench in a variety of settings. The largest
PaLM-2 models performs the best on most tasks, however, there is a significant
performance gap in all languages compared to English showing that further
research is needed for the development of more inclusive multilingual language
models. IndicGenBench is released at
www.github.com/google-research-datasets/indic-gen-bench
|
[
-0.5799201726913452,
-0.3597470223903656,
0.005594395566731691,
0.6725292205810547,
-0.2891843914985657,
0.5337425470352173,
-0.6097471117973328,
-0.6162053346633911,
-0.15176400542259216,
0.1511366218328476,
-0.4209098815917969,
-0.6269364953041077,
-0.24531641602516174,
0.43178078532218933,
-0.32093140482902527,
0.6043446660041809,
-0.10161732882261276,
0.36160728335380554,
-0.45113250613212585,
-0.39568135142326355,
-0.278010755777359,
-0.20453514158725739,
-0.3794559836387634,
-0.4398266077041626,
0.04250948131084442,
0.5893999934196472,
0.2138652205467224,
0.3654327392578125,
0.5171996355056763,
0.30914923548698425,
0.06589149683713913,
0.16108830273151398,
-0.28603318333625793,
0.4800037145614624,
-0.28001293540000916,
-0.48961207270622253,
0.027951838448643684,
-0.0358060859143734,
0.5975861549377441,
0.6113370656967163,
-0.09416024386882782,
0.4215730130672455,
0.15522317588329315,
0.45484688878059387,
-0.6907220482826233,
0.059215616434812546,
-0.5980545282363892,
0.09599147737026215,
-0.5938038229942322,
-0.16519619524478912,
-0.21941635012626648,
-0.5923364758491516,
-0.33750346302986145,
-0.08079352229833603,
0.288796991109848,
-0.03496674448251724,
0.4113972783088684,
0.20863549411296844,
-0.29389283061027527,
-0.011143029667437077,
-0.6604009866714478,
0.5231261253356934,
-0.6892086863517761,
0.3451669216156006,
0.10211905092000961,
0.39104554057121277,
-0.17183220386505127,
-0.6427055597305298,
-0.6049007177352905,
-0.3582665026187897,
0.25088709592819214,
0.1758023053407669,
0.24054159224033356,
-0.1435050070285797,
0.22588776051998138,
0.7589836120605469,
-0.688528835773468,
0.4095141291618347,
-0.2522965371608734,
0.00867969449609518,
0.7032525539398193,
0.24971075356006622,
0.4719008803367615,
-0.13610760867595673,
-0.6598052382469177,
-0.16654515266418457,
-1.048106074333191,
-0.11553600430488586,
0.7481284737586975,
0.40315234661102295,
-0.3671422004699707,
0.5429553389549255,
-0.2889353930950165,
0.547705352306366,
-0.15675890445709229,
-0.19256062805652618,
0.45588603615760803,
-0.4964379668235779,
-0.04626130685210228,
0.049397632479667664,
0.8444185853004456,
0.4008840024471283,
0.3206822872161865,
-0.21596424281597137,
-0.17224019765853882,
0.22369110584259033,
-0.23822925984859467,
-0.8325409293174744,
0.14187981188297272,
0.010654056444764137,
-0.22006762027740479,
0.03773104399442673,
-0.2493707537651062,
-1.2083427906036377,
-0.6040018200874329,
-0.0918910950422287,
-0.2279445230960846,
-0.23968428373336792,
-0.5905181765556335,
-0.34170007705688477,
0.03559885174036026,
0.5693085789680481,
0.03964043781161308,
-1.0574381351470947,
0.3945062756538391,
0.6138229370117188,
0.6614658236503601,
-0.481814980506897,
-0.45361053943634033,
-0.22229403257369995,
-0.09480375796556473,
-0.20225322246551514,
1.0144730806350708,
-0.6538293361663818,
-0.6267516613006592,
0.15072518587112427,
-0.30815061926841736,
-0.1747141182422638,
-0.8759451508522034,
0.5685698986053467,
-0.2703068256378174,
0.16799761354923248,
-0.20276038348674774,
-0.5229693651199341,
-0.09836861491203308,
0.4111725687980652,
-0.503860354423523,
1.224368691444397,
0.2765499949455261,
-0.6784526705741882,
0.6710831522941589,
-0.45982593297958374,
-0.48868659138679504,
0.6240988373756409,
-0.7136371731758118,
-0.128155916929245,
0.03956824168562889,
0.10185877233743668,
0.17981328070163727,
-0.9792973399162292,
0.13150545954704285,
-0.4535449147224426,
-0.1690056174993515,
0.03646206855773926,
-0.47791722416877747,
0.7054993510246277,
0.54036945104599,
-0.4341811537742615,
0.33829066157341003,
-0.8811537623405457,
0.1846572756767273,
0.04227787256240845,
-0.39994239807128906,
-0.06599272042512894,
-0.21014517545700073,
0.44336217641830444,
0.5727682113647461,
0.3295222520828247,
-0.8661843538284302,
0.07295997440814972,
-0.45089957118034363,
0.2118043601512909,
0.550215482711792,
-0.024185804650187492,
0.09147634357213974,
0.004733739886432886,
0.9291574358940125,
-0.10390070825815201,
-0.01901134103536606,
0.043747689574956894,
-0.2705794870853424,
-0.5194523334503174,
-0.09765570610761642,
0.3806426525115967,
0.618791401386261,
-0.48619839549064636,
0.1179821640253067,
-0.3930973708629608,
-0.5794533491134644,
-0.6250526309013367,
0.528550922870636,
0.5154815316200256,
0.2151889204978943,
-0.09310060739517212,
-0.4442822337150574,
-0.41985371708869934,
-1.1097584962844849,
-0.40949270129203796,
-0.025115611031651497,
0.14190688729286194,
-0.0483560785651207,
0.25751930475234985,
-0.16456134617328644,
0.6827799081802368,
0.10520743578672409,
0.03617803379893303,
-0.6687718033790588,
0.11503131687641144,
-0.014088092371821404,
0.40750977396965027,
0.45182284712791443,
-0.6480267643928528,
-0.8343228697776794,
0.07706224918365479,
-0.7404987215995789,
-0.14820733666419983,
0.06524103134870529,
0.08977096527814865,
0.5767270922660828,
0.6163268089294434,
-0.6579914093017578,
0.24532517790794373,
0.7603780031204224,
-0.1380976438522339,
0.3275139629840851,
-0.23285169899463654,
0.08798529207706451,
-1.1216193437576294,
0.1746187061071396,
-0.08531997352838516,
-0.033920302987098694,
-0.1600416749715805,
0.30557090044021606,
0.17402252554893494,
-0.12814991176128387,
-0.41337788105010986,
0.6755781173706055,
-0.5559396743774414,
-0.338123083114624,
-0.09573245048522949,
0.29678064584732056,
-0.3613344728946686,
0.3147522807121277,
-0.4366021752357483,
1.1909151077270508,
0.3694687485694885,
-0.29689493775367737,
0.3776375651359558,
0.18815945088863373,
-0.7699150443077087,
0.4434800446033478,
-0.3731183111667633,
-0.0071507589891552925,
0.053913798183202744,
0.07637736201286316,
-1.1387510299682617,
-0.27878981828689575,
0.0825502946972847,
-0.17649629712104797,
0.49143558740615845,
0.1561492532491684,
-0.9491057395935059,
-0.29723823070526123,
-0.45529043674468994,
0.4328075051307678,
0.2464374601840973,
-0.740673840045929,
0.5819050669670105,
0.5005281567573547,
-0.332828164100647,
-0.4652821719646454,
-0.5851042866706848,
0.1658087819814682,
-0.37354323267936707,
-0.7467673420906067,
0.12019510567188263,
-0.2749086916446686,
-0.4347168207168579,
-0.2065775841474533,
-0.15647418797016144,
0.30966299772262573,
0.09196262806653976,
0.35792890191078186,
0.14476291835308075,
-0.00509941391646862,
0.12109938263893127,
-0.12365775555372238,
-0.1745341718196869,
0.03153020516037941,
0.26628193259239197,
0.7636967897415161,
-0.18296828866004944,
-0.5600360631942749,
0.13463951647281647,
0.3005869388580322,
0.5947180390357971,
-0.5110129714012146,
0.4689669907093048,
0.6791677474975586,
-0.18552222847938538,
-0.34787267446517944,
-0.7869634032249451,
0.10617492347955704,
-0.39047929644584656,
0.27436020970344543,
-0.4964502453804016,
-0.7648685574531555,
0.7081888318061829,
-0.41476354002952576,
0.11276256293058395,
0.7792802453041077,
0.949385404586792,
0.6137046217918396,
0.8561654686927795,
0.6827388405799866,
-0.3397216200828552,
0.20310251414775848,
0.12683258950710297,
0.18621772527694702,
-0.7872658967971802,
-0.2599848806858063,
-0.5454393029212952,
-0.1415703296661377,
-1.0699584484100342,
-0.22501689195632935,
0.2998824119567871,
0.014919579029083252,
-0.15905995666980743,
0.08532162010669708,
-0.4574415385723114,
0.5231214165687561,
0.5706024765968323,
-0.3760460317134857,
0.4590347111225128,
0.17069998383522034,
-0.4949599802494049,
0.00732025969773531,
-0.5587729811668396,
-0.5341290235519409,
1.2293583154678345,
0.041683245450258255,
0.8877230286598206,
0.08864357322454453,
0.5329996943473816,
0.03941462188959122,
0.7108078002929688,
-0.1641187220811844,
0.5827833414077759,
-0.22970908880233765,
-0.7810375094413757,
0.004448261111974716,
-0.2222282886505127,
-0.7981162071228027,
0.4604262113571167,
0.03425603732466698,
-0.7546156644821167,
-0.015777187421917915,
-0.17773152887821198,
-0.17308154702186584,
0.4221037030220032,
-0.6947339177131653,
0.8744379878044128,
-0.5237296223640442,
-0.5958971977233887,
-0.3800490200519562,
-0.6503783464431763,
0.6619789004325867,
-0.08445056527853012,
0.06393200159072876,
-0.5247387886047363,
0.07704442739486694,
0.45066264271736145,
-0.16224214434623718,
0.6375830173492432,
-0.15913118422031403,
-0.08041688799858093,
0.29627105593681335,
0.0034054487477988005,
0.35181090235710144,
0.046323277056217194,
-0.2770664691925049,
0.2192365527153015,
-0.24701572954654694,
-0.00497283972799778,
-0.058774255216121674,
1.122483491897583,
-0.7995418906211853,
-0.441928505897522,
-0.49689364433288574,
-0.4901285767555237,
-0.4649503231048584,
0.06400512158870697,
0.4529626965522766,
0.22362400591373444,
-0.37678810954093933,
0.09581443667411804,
0.3523997962474823,
-0.43247610330581665,
0.5231117606163025,
0.576591968536377,
-0.4234202802181244,
-0.340514600276947,
0.887139618396759,
-0.026370052248239517,
0.17376947402954102,
0.3050440549850464,
-0.16030211746692657,
-0.4897073805332184,
-0.6696131825447083,
-0.6067816019058228,
0.17489120364189148,
-0.8395492434501648,
-0.2813881039619446,
-0.6030486226081848,
-0.15950718522071838,
-0.31353554129600525,
0.2886480689048767,
-0.24529539048671722,
-0.35837283730506897,
0.18117406964302063,
-0.2633076012134552,
0.3378813862800598,
0.7206842303276062,
-0.1535761058330536,
-0.042187273502349854,
-0.5618390440940857,
0.30405884981155396,
0.13767842948436737,
0.7723477482795715,
-0.19379590451717377,
-0.19621385633945465,
-0.0841505378484726,
-0.4118972420692444,
-0.3621782958507538,
-0.4494941830635071,
0.3525021970272064,
0.1713537871837616,
0.8144943118095398,
0.11180509626865387,
-0.1779584139585495,
0.6083062887191772,
-0.20739105343818665,
0.6909143328666687,
0.013864196836948395,
-0.559615969657898,
0.15959379076957703,
-0.18652459979057312,
0.5227915048599243,
0.9373742938041687,
0.1095435693860054,
-0.7065014839172363,
-0.4862062335014343,
-0.42550837993621826,
-1.1777011156082153,
0.5890856981277466,
-0.05713594704866409,
0.007310470100492239,
-0.018886376172304153,
0.02403082326054573,
0.4437808394432068,
0.26601240038871765,
-0.5734307169914246,
-0.2759327292442322,
0.14418582618236542,
-0.2246728390455246,
-0.17282234132289886,
-0.31927528977394104,
-0.14624005556106567,
-0.014862500131130219,
0.5711061358451843,
-0.03661634773015976,
-0.12483552098274231,
-0.04582095146179199,
-0.2615833878517151,
-0.5351330637931824,
0.5400915741920471,
0.6225210428237915,
0.8578774333000183,
-0.19761250913143158,
0.0027337451465427876,
0.30337369441986084,
-0.26161473989486694,
-0.015259754844009876,
0.5223097801208496,
-0.05895213782787323,
-0.2242840826511383,
0.2375470995903015,
0.5549917817115784,
0.09498447924852371,
-1.0360989570617676,
0.1637682318687439,
-0.28554844856262207,
0.09556073695421219,
-0.6152461171150208,
0.06355888396501541,
0.2413383573293686,
0.15658728778362274,
0.3404746651649475,
-0.11112819612026215,
0.029859336093068123,
-0.2889009416103363,
-0.023799743503332138,
0.45732250809669495,
-0.02308877557516098,
-0.11658114194869995,
0.8757818937301636,
0.4557415843009949,
-0.0014025868149474263,
0.7619014978408813,
-0.24412621557712555,
-0.16040991246700287,
0.5279329419136047,
0.4743790030479431,
1.1450505256652832,
-0.33044981956481934,
-0.0829826071858406,
0.49949246644973755,
0.39497634768486023,
0.14948447048664093,
0.40282365679740906,
-0.05007672309875488,
-0.5282654166221619,
-0.4100894033908844,
-0.833375871181488,
-0.5477287769317627,
0.2059272974729538,
-0.2567768692970276,
0.022903766483068466,
-0.38603076338768005,
-0.0034409230574965477,
-0.14848580956459045,
0.14281326532363892,
-0.8670775890350342,
-0.10046232491731644,
0.37765735387802124,
1.166873574256897,
-0.7146202921867371,
0.7303575873374939,
0.6324428915977478,
-0.50907963514328,
-0.6088495850563049,
-0.2030492126941681,
-0.009567809291183949,
-0.7971674799919128,
0.6854591369628906,
0.24664337933063507,
-0.24198009073734283,
-0.20789074897766113,
-0.4223232865333557,
-0.7245519757270813,
0.9599748253822327,
0.5435551404953003,
-0.665571391582489,
0.5284952521324158,
0.5134985446929932,
0.6093783378601074,
-0.4897061884403229,
0.3456610441207886,
0.6238394975662231,
0.5739293694496155,
-0.22210998833179474,
-0.9003824591636658,
0.043379660695791245,
-0.6447595357894897,
0.20216889679431915,
0.19925491511821747,
-0.8018444180488586,
0.9298247694969177,
0.029950499534606934,
-0.40655258297920227,
0.16260281205177307,
0.3944413661956787,
0.41648802161216736,
0.04279104247689247,
0.514319121837616,
0.6395726799964905,
0.4345402717590332,
-0.03683213144540787,
1.3598525524139404,
-0.9854333996772766,
0.07524341344833374,
1.1577064990997314,
-0.675739586353302,
0.6312284469604492,
0.3416140079498291,
-0.3164421617984772,
0.36309343576431274,
0.6883963942527771,
-0.026686154305934906,
0.19747361540794373,
0.30238401889801025,
-0.6339793801307678,
-0.2215951830148697,
-0.27946802973747253,
-0.6192218661308289,
0.5069407820701599,
0.40726467967033386,
-0.13312740623950958,
-0.6154261827468872,
-0.10385429114103317,
-0.09999562054872513,
0.21140292286872864,
-0.02097911573946476,
0.5778621435165405,
-0.03990602493286133,
-0.9123267531394958,
0.4694420397281647,
0.16466140747070312,
0.6818397045135498,
-0.8486584424972534,
-0.017816510051488876,
-0.5317411422729492,
0.4795764684677124,
-0.18564046919345856,
-0.696635901927948,
-0.07148874551057816,
0.10177584737539291,
0.0238726157695055,
-0.08604644984006882,
0.7155331969261169,
-0.673189640045166,
-0.5516093373298645,
0.5398220419883728,
0.7453749179840088,
0.1580941528081894,
0.01696053519845009,
-0.5291286110877991,
0.2758405804634094,
0.06255710124969482,
-0.19952796399593353,
0.5332249999046326,
0.2925412058830261,
-0.24493873119354248,
0.7283117175102234,
0.4192310869693756,
-0.0055374219082295895,
0.24119040369987488,
0.4178481101989746,
0.739374041557312,
-0.6577677130699158,
-0.1932360976934433,
-0.7723968029022217,
0.18370993435382843,
-0.0755130797624588,
-0.6360819339752197,
1.2151097059249878,
0.9169114232063293,
1.1485141515731812,
-0.05408632382750511,
1.0082454681396484,
-0.13270150125026703,
0.5785993933677673,
-0.0656437948346138,
0.4926074743270874,
-0.46017909049987793,
0.16089001297950745,
0.01016031764447689,
-1.0450787544250488,
-0.22797554731369019,
0.08268603682518005,
-0.16549666225910187,
0.27563875913619995,
0.4490855038166046,
0.7741668224334717,
0.07248371839523315,
0.15500997006893158,
0.1393875628709793,
0.0665891245007515,
0.2662128210067749,
0.3481607139110565,
0.8109058737754822,
-0.031384795904159546,
0.5398381352424622,
-0.370993971824646,
-0.1566685140132904,
-0.1440451592206955,
-0.6400672793388367,
-0.6732606887817383,
-0.29848742485046387,
-0.0496247336268425,
0.018493495881557465,
-0.23036155104637146,
1.2224200963974,
0.3605540990829468,
-0.9205040335655212,
-0.6741620898246765,
-0.12412796169519424,
0.013665788806974888,
-0.09131239354610443,
-0.21186532080173492,
0.13818110525608063,
-0.5696918368339539,
-0.8177626729011536,
0.5944016575813293,
0.49797871708869934,
-0.16573116183280945,
-0.6759300231933594,
0.03664521872997284,
-0.256019651889801,
-0.37130454182624817,
0.5062184929847717,
0.5501262545585632,
-0.5228167176246643,
0.19262801110744476,
-0.4284149408340454,
-0.33361339569091797,
0.24485105276107788,
0.938714325428009,
-0.6863197088241577,
0.6469624042510986,
0.49722057580947876,
0.6100415587425232,
0.6003506779670715,
-0.09945327043533325,
0.5456228852272034,
-0.6983213424682617,
0.2666302025318146,
0.17154048383235931,
0.3806558847427368,
0.8159791231155396,
-0.12055394053459167,
0.8107462525367737,
0.05706687271595001,
-0.5061624050140381,
-0.6876871585845947,
0.12379948794841766,
-0.7572349905967712,
-0.16532626748085022,
1.0940333604812622,
0.1510472148656845,
-0.045524273067712784,
0.019373631104826927,
0.06267884373664856,
0.29438355565071106,
-0.4134810268878937,
0.6908721327781677,
0.575391948223114,
-0.09367943555116653,
-0.08792909979820251,
-0.7649414539337158,
0.3592365086078644,
0.33197176456451416,
-1.0015156269073486,
0.25553861260414124,
0.3659815192222595,
0.39239320158958435,
0.07574370503425598,
0.604913055896759,
-0.3738831579685211,
0.10022129118442535,
0.14131614565849304,
0.5305173993110657,
0.08016954362392426,
-0.11858150362968445,
-0.35697540640830994,
0.27767837047576904,
0.3803671598434448,
-0.061937134712934494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16811v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16811v2
|
Make Your LLM Fully Utilize the Context
| 2024-04-25T17:55:14 | 2024-04-26T11:15:21 |
Shengnan An, Zexiong Ma, Zeqi Lin, Nanning Zheng, Jian-Guang Lou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While many contemporary large language models (LLMs) can process lengthy
input, they still struggle to fully utilize information within the long
context, known as the lost-in-the-middle challenge. We hypothesize that it
stems from insufficient explicit supervision during the long-context training,
which fails to emphasize that any position in a long context can hold crucial
information. Based on this intuition, our study presents information-intensive
(IN2) training, a purely data-driven solution to overcome lost-in-the-middle.
Specifically, IN2 training leverages a synthesized long-context question-answer
dataset, where the answer requires (1) fine-grained information awareness on a
short segment (~128 tokens) within a synthesized long context (4K-32K tokens),
and (2) the integration and reasoning of information from two or more short
segments. Through applying this information-intensive training on Mistral-7B,
we present FILM-7B (FILl-in-the-Middle). To thoroughly assess the ability of
FILM-7B for utilizing long contexts, we design three probing tasks that
encompass various context styles (document, code, and structured-data context)
and information retrieval patterns (forward, backward, and bi-directional
retrieval). The probing results demonstrate that FILM-7B can robustly retrieve
information from different positions in its 32K context window. Beyond these
probing tasks, FILM-7B significantly improves the performance on real-world
long-context tasks (e.g., 23.5->26.9 F1 score on NarrativeQA), while
maintaining a comparable performance on short-context tasks (e.g., 59.3->59.2
accuracy on MMLU). Github Link: https://github.com/microsoft/FILM.
|
[
-0.5528934597969055,
-0.7998522520065308,
0.6938647031784058,
0.21382127702236176,
-0.4019428491592407,
0.131746307015419,
-0.354954332113266,
-0.40800127387046814,
-0.08907700330018997,
0.3508114516735077,
-0.48586151003837585,
-0.36629167199134827,
-0.6991123557090759,
-0.004830169025808573,
-0.42071330547332764,
0.8073288202285767,
-0.31062692403793335,
0.09019950777292252,
-0.1727159023284912,
-0.19555354118347168,
-0.636090874671936,
-0.6095584630966187,
-0.5842311978340149,
-0.14789125323295593,
0.5972163081169128,
0.6587510108947754,
0.32758793234825134,
0.7819231152534485,
0.4288500249385834,
0.12151794880628586,
-0.12623435258865356,
0.3563181459903717,
-0.8855304718017578,
0.19512665271759033,
-0.3395521342754364,
-0.35376259684562683,
-0.07861874252557755,
-0.09832096844911575,
0.7253212332725525,
0.6301366686820984,
0.008038979023694992,
0.41745612025260925,
0.04879385605454445,
0.7679559588432312,
-0.848625659942627,
0.05114428699016571,
-0.5756762027740479,
0.027723945677280426,
-0.5971463322639465,
-0.34575599431991577,
-0.3228289783000946,
0.16422511637210846,
0.0910499319434166,
-0.46104347705841064,
0.07809460908174515,
0.09512133151292801,
0.634178638458252,
0.2877277731895447,
-0.5173909068107605,
-0.4020247757434845,
-0.7902947068214417,
0.5336236357688904,
-0.44066306948661804,
0.3903176784515381,
0.5350895524024963,
0.42798346281051636,
-0.16056016087532043,
-0.34877780079841614,
-0.6315551996231079,
0.017505640164017677,
0.2605494260787964,
0.29585012793540955,
0.027572087943553925,
0.11441228538751602,
0.5482544302940369,
0.059918902814388275,
-0.44706597924232483,
0.1103004515171051,
-0.4943712651729584,
-0.04093596711754799,
0.424430251121521,
0.195995032787323,
-0.05137905851006508,
0.15613649785518646,
-0.4300946593284607,
-0.028949731960892677,
-0.8418262004852295,
0.38036465644836426,
0.2135007381439209,
-0.11921171844005585,
-0.17663265764713287,
0.6660279631614685,
-0.04505537822842598,
0.6468649506568909,
0.2842704951763153,
-0.22747565805912018,
-0.10004942864179611,
-0.14849801361560822,
-0.21039550006389618,
0.24749037623405457,
0.15835069119930267,
0.5310163497924805,
0.03407788276672363,
0.022344665601849556,
-0.42465442419052124,
-0.14183779060840607,
0.08765582740306854,
-0.7766427993774414,
0.33270546793937683,
0.22484241425991058,
0.03574449196457863,
0.22934246063232422,
-0.01936396211385727,
-0.2397073358297348,
-0.389040470123291,
-0.5899015069007874,
0.4660820960998535,
-0.4412948489189148,
-0.044707320630550385,
0.08985008299350739,
-0.17431971430778503,
0.6715296506881714,
0.6571345329284668,
-0.6899721622467041,
0.1638808399438858,
0.5028349757194519,
0.8540186285972595,
-0.4605705738067627,
-0.15850724279880524,
-0.6116634011268616,
0.567855179309845,
-0.5636153221130371,
0.6972155570983887,
-0.4677398204803467,
-0.093744657933712,
0.1294911801815033,
-0.0903027132153511,
-0.1621997356414795,
-0.7448104619979858,
0.2616262435913086,
-0.6848767995834351,
0.12360668182373047,
-0.19922389090061188,
-0.589694082736969,
-0.12315158545970917,
0.5099105834960938,
-0.6192869544029236,
1.2777436971664429,
0.38144686818122864,
-0.7256499528884888,
0.29752472043037415,
-0.339367151260376,
-0.222520649433136,
-0.2760416567325592,
-0.3471249043941498,
-0.14516951143741608,
-0.08227961510419846,
0.11672089248895645,
0.5303599834442139,
-0.2741754949092865,
0.49937230348587036,
-0.3871234059333801,
-0.8800534605979919,
0.38013598322868347,
-0.3982500731945038,
0.2801448702812195,
-0.07957758754491806,
-0.5132958292961121,
-0.19459466636180878,
-0.6910025477409363,
-0.3556147813796997,
-0.21491408348083496,
-0.664002001285553,
-0.08823810517787933,
-0.41439586877822876,
0.1071990504860878,
0.14883925020694733,
0.04772164300084114,
-0.4248046875,
0.04820750653743744,
-0.3048105835914612,
0.1259644627571106,
0.8667374849319458,
0.022176628932356834,
0.5986214876174927,
-0.28270381689071655,
0.46722719073295593,
0.3411572277545929,
0.09150714427232742,
-0.10167811065912247,
-0.0871436670422554,
-0.9651079773902893,
-0.10860986262559891,
-0.14310027658939362,
0.5731422901153564,
-0.8119553923606873,
0.2654606103897095,
-0.14683249592781067,
-0.22817881405353546,
-0.49315324425697327,
0.39723289012908936,
0.4108314514160156,
0.7602925300598145,
0.24825622141361237,
-0.289684921503067,
-0.5430221557617188,
-0.8869025707244873,
-0.08732229471206665,
0.3071512281894684,
0.14923013746738434,
0.30333447456359863,
0.3134032189846039,
-0.34142035245895386,
0.9080559015274048,
-0.27415797114372253,
-0.3757173717021942,
-0.5053102374076843,
-0.4419928789138794,
0.7370718717575073,
0.2891218960285187,
0.16168291866779327,
-0.7851840257644653,
-0.5282782912254333,
-0.133674755692482,
-0.9274088144302368,
0.04709003493189812,
-0.09043154865503311,
-0.2279144674539566,
0.12905433773994446,
0.7755065560340881,
-0.6908549070358276,
0.4703165888786316,
0.18971043825149536,
-0.16174161434173584,
0.4487731158733368,
-0.2230304628610611,
-0.08179669827222824,
-0.9946718811988831,
0.19361865520477295,
-0.11931066960096359,
-0.24722954630851746,
-0.5605947971343994,
-0.26583462953567505,
0.21307726204395294,
-0.13700808584690094,
-0.5544373393058777,
0.9028586149215698,
-0.5582404136657715,
-0.020766019821166992,
-0.2874888777732849,
0.2125493288040161,
0.07448733597993851,
0.6190668940544128,
-0.27130064368247986,
0.9506718516349792,
0.6368296146392822,
-0.6781834363937378,
0.14280575513839722,
-0.09726417064666748,
-0.5440930128097534,
0.5631366968154907,
-0.2501334846019745,
0.3018668591976166,
-0.7354663610458374,
0.4036591351032257,
-0.9607492685317993,
-0.6158046722412109,
0.05147217959165573,
-0.20807555317878723,
0.5251095294952393,
-0.28756073117256165,
-0.46000921726226807,
-0.04153408110141754,
-0.27337580919265747,
0.5602660775184631,
0.25878027081489563,
-0.5006436705589294,
0.5773723125457764,
0.4990394413471222,
-0.2606792747974396,
-0.7821529507637024,
-0.670452892780304,
0.1096709743142128,
-0.5201277136802673,
-0.6473672389984131,
0.36637794971466064,
-0.11584176868200302,
-0.13294875621795654,
-0.38207921385765076,
-0.34641751646995544,
-0.09961967170238495,
-0.05015308037400246,
0.3473159372806549,
0.09311220794916153,
-0.1099720448255539,
0.22111552953720093,
0.28338053822517395,
-0.04574976861476898,
-0.04359448701143265,
-0.08868452161550522,
0.3026805818080902,
-0.04300040379166603,
-0.30943769216537476,
-0.2952711582183838,
0.6484121084213257,
0.6094967126846313,
0.04004622995853424,
0.2446988821029663,
0.7035569548606873,
-0.38279858231544495,
-0.4258471429347992,
-0.8932813405990601,
-0.0025486957747489214,
-0.4280354678630829,
0.4806285500526428,
-0.3970438241958618,
-1.0696563720703125,
0.48329952359199524,
-0.012921997345983982,
-0.20502105355262756,
0.04739746078848839,
0.46740028262138367,
-0.46266430616378784,
0.7608010172843933,
0.7430801391601562,
-0.1082669049501419,
0.788998007774353,
-0.4838201105594635,
0.13538599014282227,
-0.9950575828552246,
-0.3027004599571228,
0.1361159384250641,
-0.27372896671295166,
0.030813712626695633,
-0.5658515095710754,
0.8999236822128296,
0.49187880754470825,
-0.5257290601730347,
-0.022458594292402267,
-0.2195206731557846,
0.6765434145927429,
0.531322717666626,
0.3414424955844879,
0.08987285196781158,
-0.014375879429280758,
0.059636279940605164,
0.1405497044324875,
-0.7570662498474121,
-0.5246912837028503,
1.0302455425262451,
0.3455016613006592,
0.8752603530883789,
0.21417514979839325,
0.5208848714828491,
0.2711407244205475,
0.21507437527179718,
-0.7054863572120667,
0.4539163112640381,
0.10478714853525162,
-0.4906211495399475,
-0.19437991082668304,
-0.0839422196149826,
-0.8433365821838379,
0.07507981359958649,
0.21273280680179596,
-0.5987652540206909,
0.16869743168354034,
0.14570429921150208,
-0.5294360518455505,
0.013714353553950787,
-0.8147134184837341,
0.5976423621177673,
-0.2345932573080063,
-0.699275553226471,
-0.10207819938659668,
-0.9785377383232117,
0.1738990694284439,
-0.27890121936798096,
0.2272302359342575,
-0.1847902238368988,
0.017169171944260597,
0.8235200643539429,
-0.08526995778083801,
0.9940842986106873,
-0.2860594689846039,
0.0912202000617981,
0.5620415210723877,
0.06480640172958374,
0.44851115345954895,
0.29729318618774414,
-0.027117475867271423,
-0.3226064443588257,
-0.038343288004398346,
-0.3478472828865051,
-0.7263680696487427,
0.41926777362823486,
-0.6708686351776123,
-0.6749771237373352,
-0.4658941328525543,
-0.512226402759552,
-0.325122207403183,
0.17108766734600067,
0.24632404744625092,
0.5487156510353088,
0.02723359875380993,
0.3295941650867462,
0.9646162986755371,
0.043080102652311325,
0.5228781700134277,
0.35973256826400757,
0.15420444309711456,
-0.37242844700813293,
0.4475613534450531,
0.259302020072937,
0.20348279178142548,
0.49015679955482483,
0.1382085084915161,
-0.494061142206192,
-0.4380103349685669,
-0.7435570955276489,
0.17718282341957092,
-1.018641471862793,
-0.315792441368103,
-0.5066673755645752,
-0.21236371994018555,
-0.17637090384960175,
-0.2208331972360611,
-0.31267040967941284,
0.02510729804635048,
-0.25066104531288147,
-0.262289822101593,
0.21764124929904938,
0.5515133738517761,
0.1420423537492752,
0.4549217224121094,
-0.6018986105918884,
0.15015460550785065,
0.05543987825512886,
0.22714154422283173,
0.02710184082388878,
-0.7574858069419861,
-0.6787785887718201,
-0.04872889071702957,
-0.3110954165458679,
-0.6379333138465881,
-0.053658537566661835,
0.1601046919822693,
0.5129789710044861,
0.3053639233112335,
-0.2514156997203827,
0.7998949289321899,
-0.1885232776403427,
0.5306801795959473,
0.015603155829012394,
-0.6960276365280151,
0.38304847478866577,
-0.5222362279891968,
0.45700913667678833,
0.798323929309845,
0.35357528924942017,
-0.3968124985694885,
-0.20005206763744354,
-0.3299279808998108,
-0.9138293266296387,
0.6380007266998291,
0.09941379725933075,
0.030515102669596672,
0.23133718967437744,
0.44038763642311096,
0.1001361757516861,
0.21135859191417694,
-0.575983464717865,
0.19831393659114838,
0.08593211323022842,
-0.17335063219070435,
-0.0460364930331707,
-0.2845461964607239,
-0.34378737211227417,
-0.27993685007095337,
0.385567307472229,
-0.23050406575202942,
0.14534161984920502,
0.6671132445335388,
-0.2871248722076416,
0.17528130114078522,
0.16651688516139984,
0.46859315037727356,
0.7963660955429077,
-0.4465871751308441,
0.36490777134895325,
0.06926386803388596,
-0.4081142544746399,
0.22355806827545166,
-0.036085255444049835,
-0.04316190630197525,
-0.07018972188234329,
0.5061171054840088,
0.7962549328804016,
0.22053162753582,
-0.8994167447090149,
0.7828469276428223,
0.27502936124801636,
0.1946474313735962,
-0.6306670308113098,
-0.015096575953066349,
0.005121289752423763,
0.4588862359523773,
0.48559853434562683,
-0.21935178339481354,
0.10833781212568283,
-0.8436081409454346,
0.2915247678756714,
-0.0008518444374203682,
-0.5200513005256653,
-0.07865456491708755,
0.37459951639175415,
-0.11528006941080093,
0.15620192885398865,
0.572555422782898,
-0.15408916771411896,
-0.37183284759521484,
0.684302031993866,
0.694872260093689,
0.614674985408783,
0.12468350678682327,
-0.18214185535907745,
0.21845082938671112,
0.006556638516485691,
-0.23061905801296234,
0.46590456366539,
-0.14323735237121582,
-0.5270995497703552,
-0.32867321372032166,
-0.3749980032444,
-0.39026811718940735,
0.0011518289102241397,
-0.5495219230651855,
0.25124016404151917,
-0.526074230670929,
-0.12708473205566406,
-0.3490506410598755,
-0.12221170961856842,
-0.7537949085235596,
0.30505964159965515,
0.1282113641500473,
1.0180143117904663,
-0.5188695192337036,
0.9633170366287231,
0.48311224579811096,
-0.31140732765197754,
-0.8886792659759521,
-0.22321002185344696,
-0.1663510501384735,
-0.7198752164840698,
0.5405394434928894,
0.624270498752594,
-0.26869267225265503,
-0.0971459150314331,
-0.6860150694847107,
-1.0363401174545288,
1.3906368017196655,
0.4362871050834656,
-0.5494589805603027,
-0.08659175783395767,
0.06303416192531586,
0.40934768319129944,
-0.6145743727684021,
0.16838955879211426,
0.5521005392074585,
0.33213719725608826,
0.1854304075241089,
-0.709296703338623,
-0.02934044413268566,
-0.18468792736530304,
-0.16649135947227478,
0.05581754446029663,
-0.6462323069572449,
0.6054458022117615,
-0.3046391010284424,
-0.333077073097229,
-0.1198921725153923,
0.4525719881057739,
0.4473957419395447,
0.7954416871070862,
0.44418248534202576,
0.42070382833480835,
0.6831036806106567,
0.1288987696170807,
0.9203831553459167,
-0.24952585995197296,
0.1046023741364479,
1.2505632638931274,
-0.2997318208217621,
0.8372918963432312,
0.8179473280906677,
0.2503238022327423,
0.23575066030025482,
0.8780418038368225,
0.1792738288640976,
0.5374027490615845,
0.31538861989974976,
-0.43800437450408936,
-0.1629137098789215,
-0.2388794869184494,
-0.14265809953212738,
0.4287940561771393,
0.552273690700531,
-0.07437632232904434,
-0.32413989305496216,
0.1441820114850998,
0.11315484344959259,
-0.018064819276332855,
-0.3013831079006195,
0.7419309616088867,
0.36280715465545654,
-0.8275402188301086,
0.7327734231948853,
-0.031009968370199203,
0.4553960859775543,
-0.7789485454559326,
-0.09023578464984894,
-0.5757983922958374,
0.19936323165893555,
-0.13599121570587158,
-0.9924506545066833,
0.21375609934329987,
-0.004346289671957493,
-0.2724437117576599,
-0.12571485340595245,
0.5649663209915161,
-0.6881106495857239,
-0.16977404057979584,
0.36971983313560486,
0.3962031304836273,
0.2043749988079071,
-0.3464512825012207,
-0.35672107338905334,
0.24594692885875702,
-0.18928176164627075,
-0.22130578756332397,
0.4049718677997589,
0.5297418236732483,
-0.3459087014198303,
0.7284865379333496,
0.4594633877277374,
-0.07267003506422043,
0.06898538023233414,
0.10340430587530136,
1.0684096813201904,
-0.8785539865493774,
-0.43122702836990356,
-0.8025314807891846,
0.3926926255226135,
-0.12845171988010406,
-0.41419893503189087,
0.4797157049179077,
1.0248111486434937,
1.0081108808517456,
-0.0762825608253479,
0.8148366212844849,
0.13370700180530548,
0.42030176520347595,
-0.8423501253128052,
0.3393719494342804,
-0.46112358570098877,
0.17772245407104492,
0.007532090414315462,
-1.042943000793457,
-0.1623745560646057,
0.19481702148914337,
-0.22864700853824615,
-0.2527829110622406,
0.6839013695716858,
1.0411144495010376,
-0.37121668457984924,
-0.4469762146472931,
0.21981005370616913,
0.02811671420931816,
0.37984010577201843,
1.0734084844589233,
0.9765835404396057,
-0.32721635699272156,
0.44151657819747925,
-0.13322821259498596,
-0.41845518350601196,
-0.29324308037757874,
-0.6196831464767456,
-0.894848108291626,
-0.5433295369148254,
0.16893456876277924,
-0.41130775213241577,
0.08615946769714355,
0.8521679639816284,
0.753684401512146,
-0.174508735537529,
-0.5935385823249817,
0.2666547894477844,
0.0681331530213356,
0.12557506561279297,
-0.17312350869178772,
0.49478548765182495,
-0.11052356660366058,
-0.4651193916797638,
0.7112917304039001,
0.5971245765686035,
0.27186065912246704,
-0.08308227360248566,
0.05309392139315605,
-0.15392731130123138,
0.012841565534472466,
0.7108496427536011,
0.0639738216996193,
-0.4583340883255005,
-0.21043044328689575,
0.016472499817609787,
-0.2884349226951599,
0.21875490248203278,
0.9012655019760132,
-0.47285670042037964,
0.6413890719413757,
0.3766695261001587,
0.9360373616218567,
0.8938913345336914,
0.10710768401622772,
0.6087304353713989,
-0.7379834651947021,
0.20499129593372345,
0.26136887073516846,
0.2797025144100189,
0.41835737228393555,
-0.567806601524353,
0.564099133014679,
0.17354579269886017,
-0.3785390555858612,
-0.7378406524658203,
0.23086288571357727,
-1.5050441026687622,
-0.06460215151309967,
1.2961907386779785,
0.03126417100429535,
-0.337190717458725,
-0.19412405788898468,
-0.42241427302360535,
0.20296281576156616,
-0.5244079232215881,
0.7188040018081665,
0.7486057877540588,
-0.2133917659521103,
-0.0938182845711708,
-0.6934725642204285,
0.46865126490592957,
0.37461617588996887,
-0.5558053851127625,
-0.10425644367933273,
0.3124393820762634,
0.4052477180957794,
-0.12180634588003159,
1.051355242729187,
-0.15751193463802338,
0.22140111029148102,
-0.343807190656662,
-0.2795070707798004,
-0.08444759994745255,
-0.5436903238296509,
-0.23307500779628754,
0.11837282031774521,
-0.008167639374732971,
0.005205291789025068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16807v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16807v1
|
Improving Diversity of Commonsense Generation by Large Language Models via In-Context Learning
| 2024-04-25T17:52:39 | 2024-04-25T17:52:39 |
Tianhui Zhang, Bei Peng, Danushka Bollegala
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Generative Commonsense Reasoning (GCR) requires a model to reason about a
situation using commonsense knowledge, while generating coherent sentences.
Although the quality of the generated sentences is crucial, the diversity of
the generation is equally important because it reflects the model's ability to
use a range of commonsense knowledge facts. Large Language Models (LLMs) have
shown proficiency in enhancing the generation quality across various tasks
through in-context learning (ICL) using given examples without the need for any
fine-tuning. However, the diversity aspect in LLM outputs has not been
systematically studied before. To address this, we propose a simple method that
diversifies the LLM generations, while preserving their quality. Experimental
results on three benchmark GCR datasets show that our method achieves an ideal
balance between the quality and diversity. Moreover, the sentences generated by
our proposed method can be used as training data to improve diversity in
existing commonsense generators.
|
[
-0.4340095520019531,
-0.25252410769462585,
0.2514481544494629,
-0.15347187221050262,
-0.5672106146812439,
0.04962216317653656,
-0.4563109278678894,
-0.36537832021713257,
-0.364589661359787,
0.3495504558086395,
-0.32570192217826843,
-0.5833983421325684,
-0.5809966325759888,
0.26991695165634155,
-0.16791407763957977,
1.144235372543335,
0.2279180884361267,
0.17650312185287476,
-0.33089640736579895,
-0.3314843475818634,
-0.42970576882362366,
-0.23101605474948883,
-0.42862468957901,
-0.22257183492183685,
0.25294020771980286,
0.9110614061355591,
0.48703739047050476,
0.3671967089176178,
0.190272256731987,
0.27743303775787354,
-0.4908190965652466,
0.6969780325889587,
-0.8743409514427185,
0.2268066555261612,
-0.4282591640949249,
-0.12790407240390778,
0.12792474031448364,
-0.34604233503341675,
0.9045838117599487,
0.837174117565155,
-0.14572803676128387,
-0.21632932126522064,
0.4873638153076172,
0.4541732370853424,
-0.6248233318328857,
-0.2419147789478302,
-1.0839838981628418,
-0.05206231772899628,
-0.010250400751829147,
-0.15221112966537476,
-0.38227298855781555,
-0.408836305141449,
0.11509299278259277,
-0.3813799321651459,
0.4437195062637329,
-0.007216601632535458,
0.8065264225006104,
-0.12394937872886658,
-0.6285810470581055,
-0.42526543140411377,
-0.5613545775413513,
1.210299015045166,
-0.8750258088111877,
0.23198142647743225,
0.07136944681406021,
0.2243470847606659,
-0.2152722179889679,
-0.5309543609619141,
-0.6301203966140747,
-0.3100050091743469,
-0.13216999173164368,
0.13171805441379547,
-0.03117978945374489,
-0.24384330213069916,
0.10626530647277832,
0.6120226979255676,
-0.3438582122325897,
0.2577149569988251,
-0.4927235245704651,
-0.062364593148231506,
0.7226219773292542,
0.33474233746528625,
0.37518298625946045,
0.09391413629055023,
-0.34289756417274475,
-0.1352369487285614,
-0.9821820855140686,
-0.009660695679485798,
0.6300678253173828,
0.5047455430030823,
-0.15135988593101501,
0.36101123690605164,
-0.42767027020454407,
0.6625245809555054,
-0.09507131576538086,
-0.40911024808883667,
0.350658118724823,
-0.6230370402336121,
-0.01779729127883911,
-0.1882254034280777,
0.4184020161628723,
0.27852416038513184,
0.08705787360668182,
-0.10356808453798294,
-0.34366023540496826,
-0.2770589292049408,
-0.018348639830946922,
-0.8859205842018127,
0.011248216032981873,
0.04114144667983055,
-0.42849448323249817,
-0.2283620834350586,
0.10532265156507492,
-0.8730654120445251,
-0.13975951075553894,
-0.3286493718624115,
0.04747645556926727,
-0.46122896671295166,
-0.17912200093269348,
0.158355712890625,
-0.35420531034469604,
0.23171848058700562,
0.45273786783218384,
-1.193241000175476,
0.21935738623142242,
0.6124945282936096,
0.6895768046379089,
-0.2755940854549408,
-0.26888763904571533,
-0.7530215382575989,
0.1790151745080948,
-0.07104793190956116,
0.7403385639190674,
-0.5223091840744019,
-0.6494284272193909,
0.07554235309362411,
-0.41889145970344543,
0.19984419643878937,
-0.958501398563385,
0.419374942779541,
-0.30355337262153625,
0.4453994631767273,
-0.38581719994544983,
-0.5988582372665405,
0.0819181501865387,
0.2835042178630829,
-0.44835031032562256,
0.4935436546802521,
0.20186659693717957,
-0.6511358618736267,
0.8601428270339966,
-0.626218855381012,
-0.5969842672348022,
0.42562559247016907,
-0.2245050072669983,
-0.47123509645462036,
0.2829723060131073,
0.5388870239257812,
0.2644548714160919,
-0.0933212861418724,
0.46036165952682495,
-0.3546198010444641,
-0.2554807960987091,
0.3464891016483307,
-0.5680478811264038,
0.8225913643836975,
0.5266920328140259,
-0.08781115710735321,
0.08502797037363052,
-0.4309595823287964,
-0.22379110753536224,
-0.16474461555480957,
-0.6004036068916321,
-0.13766631484031677,
-0.0032708831131458282,
0.08696245402097702,
0.17971014976501465,
-0.12014254927635193,
-0.4941169321537018,
0.11446273326873779,
-0.4379518926143646,
0.4582749009132385,
0.6327469944953918,
0.11313570290803909,
0.47821202874183655,
-0.6219243407249451,
0.12871311604976654,
0.3089594542980194,
0.17157356441020966,
-0.04716164246201515,
-0.636778712272644,
-0.5512543320655823,
-0.4671635031700134,
-0.07972311973571777,
0.16136513650417328,
-0.6030084490776062,
0.41696617007255554,
-0.3343222737312317,
-0.14981785416603088,
-0.21654152870178223,
0.5625110268592834,
0.13702692091464996,
0.5405002236366272,
0.3965013325214386,
-0.357347697019577,
-0.30547985434532166,
-0.7044548392295837,
-0.4471696615219116,
0.08288117498159409,
-0.06523822247982025,
0.5107660293579102,
0.5317292809486389,
-0.25438350439071655,
1.1499160528182983,
-0.2958051860332489,
-0.07477927207946777,
-0.70851069688797,
0.16537867486476898,
0.2754267454147339,
0.5564770102500916,
0.36326202750205994,
-1.0192891359329224,
-0.40454035997390747,
0.03801601007580757,
-0.5380654335021973,
-0.023006368428468704,
-0.1306578665971756,
-0.19241222739219666,
0.1545119285583496,
0.4538380801677704,
-0.35844117403030396,
0.09241426736116409,
0.5678293704986572,
-0.35400593280792236,
0.42872709035873413,
-0.05931931734085083,
-0.06610749661922455,
-1.2068359851837158,
-0.19011203944683075,
-0.023113906383514404,
-0.1143355444073677,
-0.6549910306930542,
0.2702685594558716,
-0.12015444785356522,
-0.1639561653137207,
-0.6868957281112671,
0.7215691804885864,
-0.5470098257064819,
-0.03771694377064705,
-0.20737391710281372,
-0.015398284420371056,
0.000397593918023631,
0.11896201968193054,
-0.08653172850608826,
0.8584727048873901,
0.4206250011920929,
-0.542640745639801,
0.04076194763183594,
0.1745733618736267,
-0.7723518013954163,
0.533801257610321,
-0.3628422021865845,
-0.2673723101615906,
-0.33102160692214966,
0.2447437196969986,
-1.0562479496002197,
-0.6012842655181885,
0.05965779349207878,
-0.1297549605369568,
0.22941407561302185,
-0.08182208985090256,
-0.39621856808662415,
-0.23070980608463287,
-0.07466191798448563,
0.6895970702171326,
0.7189366221427917,
-1.120766282081604,
0.5041934847831726,
0.1549483984708786,
-0.14911673963069916,
-0.6193927526473999,
-0.6688387393951416,
0.05086876451969147,
-0.509999692440033,
-0.7532329559326172,
0.28262099623680115,
-0.20988157391548157,
-0.3506987988948822,
-0.015854736790060997,
-0.07700635492801666,
0.06407012045383453,
0.11469859629869461,
-0.24281945824623108,
0.12581536173820496,
-0.19081391394138336,
0.2951737642288208,
0.38441789150238037,
0.25065815448760986,
-0.37101632356643677,
-0.4871857762336731,
0.6022129654884338,
-0.15484030544757843,
-0.3570494055747986,
-0.19531409442424774,
0.45888465642929077,
0.37480518221855164,
-0.2407723367214203,
0.6805776953697205,
0.4047055244445801,
-0.055986788123846054,
-0.8198295831680298,
-0.4081403613090515,
-0.1345980167388916,
-0.5132284760475159,
0.3851970136165619,
-0.08452734351158142,
-1.4652791023254395,
0.49432647228240967,
-0.01276567205786705,
0.16621644794940948,
0.290362149477005,
0.6636524200439453,
0.030177699401974678,
0.6635690927505493,
0.26840463280677795,
0.09978120028972626,
0.5085253119468689,
-0.12816880643367767,
0.15706661343574524,
-0.8210424780845642,
-0.05081034079194069,
-0.204742431640625,
-0.2503381073474884,
-0.48792341351509094,
-0.37505266070365906,
0.41205278038978577,
0.28648215532302856,
-0.3067941963672638,
-0.19593627750873566,
-0.36735999584198,
0.7750841379165649,
0.5237358808517456,
0.3425631523132324,
0.40638110041618347,
0.2934480309486389,
0.021184507757425308,
0.20925140380859375,
-0.7494984269142151,
-0.4421691298484802,
1.139716386795044,
0.17045408487319946,
0.6756781935691833,
0.4410022497177124,
1.1681278944015503,
0.10562245547771454,
0.6124067306518555,
-0.5060698986053467,
0.567128598690033,
-0.6243347525596619,
-0.413286417722702,
-0.493881493806839,
-0.8551424741744995,
-0.8807297348976135,
0.5854337215423584,
-0.14578166604042053,
-0.6284701228141785,
0.20690011978149414,
0.2762592136859894,
-0.33010709285736084,
0.4080185294151306,
-0.4121040105819702,
0.752670168876648,
-0.1812746673822403,
-0.4043179750442505,
-0.37270963191986084,
-0.320941299200058,
0.767217755317688,
0.07023275643587112,
0.15500719845294952,
-0.008994131349027157,
0.21162328124046326,
0.2525886297225952,
-0.501279890537262,
1.0276215076446533,
-0.02269843965768814,
-0.310092955827713,
0.4644119143486023,
-0.2772475481033325,
0.48411786556243896,
0.3085516691207886,
0.08064230531454086,
-0.014681394211947918,
-0.8580516576766968,
-0.5170192718505859,
-0.40305012464523315,
0.735236406326294,
-0.8302891850471497,
-0.7346175312995911,
0.018287837505340576,
-0.8559277653694153,
-0.18437877297401428,
-0.019111398607492447,
0.5391924381256104,
0.6555455327033997,
-0.2096664160490036,
0.4336145520210266,
0.7229663133621216,
-0.4293593168258667,
0.4409988224506378,
-0.043283041566610336,
0.14859206974506378,
-0.6969771981239319,
0.7739582061767578,
-0.05083223059773445,
0.8009811639785767,
0.33795833587646484,
0.43789705634117126,
-0.39377233386039734,
-0.8389653563499451,
-0.28324753046035767,
-0.027006566524505615,
-0.9839452505111694,
-0.29548120498657227,
-0.6899413466453552,
-0.03441780433058739,
-0.34689807891845703,
-0.32108989357948303,
0.1664595752954483,
-0.18159914016723633,
-0.35121697187423706,
0.13500246405601501,
0.2741044759750366,
0.46934235095977783,
-0.20116561651229858,
0.3114587366580963,
-0.7375932931900024,
0.3962685465812683,
0.8924900889396667,
0.25654229521751404,
0.12207392603158951,
-0.7498611807823181,
-0.061394307762384415,
0.0915706679224968,
-0.347391277551651,
-0.5964756608009338,
0.3110445439815521,
0.47135183215141296,
0.7923334836959839,
0.4645572304725647,
-0.1282753050327301,
0.40398165583610535,
-0.11109718680381775,
0.8905776739120483,
0.3863588571548462,
-1.0468698740005493,
0.48080939054489136,
-0.46586209535598755,
0.5059666633605957,
0.5367555618286133,
0.023237111046910286,
-0.4358147978782654,
-0.6746140718460083,
-0.4817725419998169,
-1.0136492252349854,
0.3460886776447296,
0.12465107440948486,
0.454286128282547,
-0.2942166030406952,
-0.17016424238681793,
0.40389299392700195,
0.10207322239875793,
-0.7867021560668945,
0.3464888334274292,
-0.5232077836990356,
-0.3504126965999603,
-0.009531514719128609,
-0.23584787547588348,
-0.2608497738838196,
-0.18572336435317993,
0.4403136968612671,
-0.26353180408477783,
-0.2699677646160126,
-0.027103735134005547,
-0.23982612788677216,
0.020647086203098297,
0.645663321018219,
0.8210423588752747,
0.6813303828239441,
0.05124957859516144,
0.17518480122089386,
0.5831900238990784,
-0.34549567103385925,
0.075741708278656,
-0.22349156439304352,
-0.28248751163482666,
-0.09756883978843689,
0.3457023799419403,
0.7239695191383362,
0.18151572346687317,
-0.7309051156044006,
0.598585307598114,
0.16060186922550201,
-0.3075380325317383,
0.05140276253223419,
0.4604484736919403,
0.13796263933181763,
0.30020663142204285,
0.36390501260757446,
0.05799154192209244,
0.08342668414115906,
-0.5787429213523865,
0.49643075466156006,
0.5942264199256897,
0.29198595881462097,
0.23826123774051666,
0.4356132745742798,
0.36601004004478455,
0.08706510066986084,
1.0485804080963135,
-0.4499555826187134,
-0.3930063843727112,
0.7372561693191528,
0.9011885523796082,
0.9802303314208984,
0.026431679725646973,
0.16257557272911072,
0.6053152680397034,
0.14072832465171814,
-0.3273281455039978,
0.1067701056599617,
-0.10996540635824203,
-1.033510446548462,
-0.4147433936595917,
-0.6043557524681091,
-0.4944950342178345,
0.16859322786331177,
-0.4481148421764374,
0.21711492538452148,
-0.45758727192878723,
0.13002818822860718,
-0.44585946202278137,
-0.3149695098400116,
-0.6826953291893005,
0.2523215413093567,
0.34766215085983276,
0.7710055708885193,
-0.9825426936149597,
0.761305570602417,
0.3455671966075897,
-0.41580507159233093,
-0.6280710697174072,
0.31014543771743774,
-0.33498290181159973,
-0.6215643286705017,
0.9446487426757812,
0.23516032099723816,
0.0019225111464038491,
-0.23069027066230774,
-0.9236487746238708,
-0.7473865747451782,
1.0291980504989624,
0.14516273140907288,
-0.7627062201499939,
0.42549511790275574,
0.31047728657722473,
0.3514059782028198,
-0.7789218425750732,
0.0011198711581528187,
0.19729937613010406,
0.2754645049571991,
0.29667794704437256,
-0.47193533182144165,
-0.04945903271436691,
-0.24329312145709991,
0.3695738911628723,
-0.031675465404987335,
-0.5285507440567017,
1.0396466255187988,
-0.422157347202301,
-0.45601993799209595,
0.11555295437574387,
0.9126660227775574,
0.9251832962036133,
0.2157018780708313,
0.68008953332901,
0.7184884548187256,
0.8958117365837097,
0.02643897756934166,
0.9024094939231873,
-0.006568427197635174,
0.3451021611690521,
1.3281904458999634,
-0.366786926984787,
0.6455756425857544,
0.44226691126823425,
0.2593355178833008,
0.6243900060653687,
0.2580609917640686,
-0.44788357615470886,
0.6171279549598694,
0.4555392563343048,
-0.6524418592453003,
-0.5099281668663025,
-0.09689421206712723,
-0.27706584334373474,
0.43336260318756104,
0.32486340403556824,
-0.3893505930900574,
-0.47974124550819397,
0.0783347338438034,
-0.1475931704044342,
0.21250155568122864,
-0.4616115689277649,
0.6879369020462036,
-0.0704655721783638,
-0.643417239189148,
0.592409074306488,
-0.3396346867084503,
0.9766050577163696,
-0.3504786491394043,
-0.004330426454544067,
-0.6879749298095703,
0.06584148108959198,
-0.1992715299129486,
-0.901522696018219,
0.11424635350704193,
0.05144236981868744,
-0.2784924805164337,
-0.21594858169555664,
0.6352941989898682,
-0.7489527463912964,
-0.45911723375320435,
0.03392352908849716,
0.3393644094467163,
0.07360924780368805,
0.40454909205436707,
-0.217774897813797,
-0.12442273646593094,
0.03825897350907326,
0.12258139997720718,
0.4528619050979614,
0.6135560274124146,
-0.13817615807056427,
0.4757485091686249,
0.7737494111061096,
0.0016583341639488935,
0.09194543957710266,
0.3122258186340332,
1.0991804599761963,
-0.38820573687553406,
-0.5957947373390198,
-0.9224424362182617,
0.8097971677780151,
-0.4563876986503601,
-0.7500628232955933,
0.5783911347389221,
0.5937169194221497,
1.2631348371505737,
-0.2791759669780731,
0.9420890212059021,
0.1866103708744049,
0.22259050607681274,
-0.6159713268280029,
0.5711861252784729,
-0.6564909815788269,
0.24472036957740784,
-0.12035365402698517,
-0.8659689426422119,
-0.3542492687702179,
0.45002123713493347,
-0.17114509642124176,
0.21066416800022125,
0.44321855902671814,
0.9680795073509216,
-0.4449217915534973,
0.10059279948472977,
0.39239880442619324,
-0.04620442911982536,
0.38058388233184814,
0.6544497609138489,
1.2882853746414185,
-0.043711304664611816,
0.584792971611023,
0.11995776742696762,
-0.20559747517108917,
-0.1790734976530075,
-0.9433201551437378,
-0.8984345197677612,
-0.2105184942483902,
-0.16455242037773132,
-0.3097526729106903,
0.13117744028568268,
0.8992223739624023,
0.5156110525131226,
-0.8613330125808716,
-0.40584152936935425,
-0.350821852684021,
0.03763745725154877,
-0.2247593104839325,
-0.19602848589420319,
-0.07749143987894058,
-0.8760185241699219,
-0.6642633676528931,
0.4007728695869446,
0.17578302323818207,
0.014373419806361198,
-0.0359872430562973,
-0.3452806770801544,
0.14939440786838531,
-0.052142493426799774,
0.7244446277618408,
0.17570550739765167,
-0.773331880569458,
-0.33403220772743225,
-0.361642986536026,
-0.14504800736904144,
0.0835883617401123,
0.8009154200553894,
-0.45041581988334656,
0.34013551473617554,
0.6897818446159363,
0.5778114795684814,
0.22840441763401031,
0.02309207245707512,
0.5543034076690674,
-0.8493096232414246,
-0.05190365016460419,
0.34394571185112,
0.5455126166343689,
0.5973355174064636,
-0.25209543108940125,
0.23595771193504333,
0.26135513186454773,
-0.5365365743637085,
-0.7521731853485107,
0.6559765338897705,
-0.8266932964324951,
-0.641810417175293,
1.488647699356079,
0.05063619837164879,
0.17268188297748566,
-0.16389219462871552,
-0.04655924811959267,
0.20316487550735474,
-0.45297887921333313,
0.8477513194084167,
0.3932405114173889,
0.15747812390327454,
-0.22580958902835846,
-0.11324457079172134,
0.4919855296611786,
0.5651696920394897,
-1.060368299484253,
0.24683086574077606,
0.6258960962295532,
0.3980444073677063,
-0.10137847065925598,
0.32815009355545044,
-0.16513434052467346,
0.2738179564476013,
-0.0794137641787529,
-0.05609133467078209,
0.126356303691864,
-0.309285044670105,
-0.3175490200519562,
0.38989049196243286,
0.0587097629904747,
0.04760988801717758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16921v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16921v1
|
A Short Survey of Human Mobility Prediction in Epidemic Modeling from Transformers to LLMs
| 2024-04-25T17:52:19 | 2024-04-25T17:52:19 |
Christian N. Mayemba, D'Jeff K. Nkashama, Jean Marie Tshimula, Maximilien V. Dialufuma, Jean Tshibangu Muabila, Mbuyi Mukendi Didier, Hugues Kanda, René Manassé Galekwa, Heber Dibwe Fita, Serge Mundele, Kalonji Kalala, Aristarque Ilunga, Lambert Mukendi Ntobo, Dominique Muteba, Aaron Aruna Abedi
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
This paper provides a comprehensive survey of recent advancements in
leveraging machine learning techniques, particularly Transformer models, for
predicting human mobility patterns during epidemics. Understanding how people
move during epidemics is essential for modeling the spread of diseases and
devising effective response strategies. Forecasting population movement is
crucial for informing epidemiological models and facilitating effective
response planning in public health emergencies. Predicting mobility patterns
can enable authorities to better anticipate the geographical and temporal
spread of diseases, allocate resources more efficiently, and implement targeted
interventions. We review a range of approaches utilizing both pretrained
language models like BERT and Large Language Models (LLMs) tailored
specifically for mobility prediction tasks. These models have demonstrated
significant potential in capturing complex spatio-temporal dependencies and
contextual patterns in textual data.
|
[
0.24058133363723755,
-0.5391756892204285,
0.6007058620452881,
0.10359424352645874,
0.3068300783634186,
-0.18361997604370117,
0.4261949956417084,
-0.5271402597427368,
0.3336047828197479,
0.8527881503105164,
-0.5350702404975891,
-0.2699469327926636,
-0.6645407676696777,
-0.04057495668530464,
-0.9095527529716492,
0.35978835821151733,
0.24518892168998718,
0.19983845949172974,
0.02824678085744381,
0.23036473989486694,
-0.4303841292858124,
-0.6057937145233154,
-0.21434286236763,
-0.4542558789253235,
0.43574464321136475,
0.3953339755535126,
0.8470388650894165,
0.6912730932235718,
0.407749205827713,
0.31062087416648865,
-0.0837961882352829,
-0.29526880383491516,
-0.3530582785606384,
0.12345321476459503,
0.0834011361002922,
-0.49870631098747253,
-0.2441689372062683,
-0.21180514991283417,
0.3629622757434845,
0.8806873559951782,
-0.40367117524147034,
-0.04357721656560898,
-0.4669736921787262,
0.40698182582855225,
-0.10065573453903198,
-0.3290419578552246,
-0.31412559747695923,
0.029674634337425232,
-0.6779100298881531,
-0.21000462770462036,
-0.36944833397865295,
-0.05036153271794319,
0.5000256896018982,
-0.2690301835536957,
0.2726770341396332,
0.2557147443294525,
0.3231327533721924,
0.11026949435472488,
-0.8218599557876587,
-0.16678202152252197,
-0.7974557876586914,
0.7348593473434448,
-0.20860712230205536,
0.45989903807640076,
0.4916081726551056,
0.5918863415718079,
-0.35283008217811584,
-1.0726515054702759,
0.003051094012334943,
-0.35756024718284607,
0.3207271993160248,
-0.19004419445991516,
-0.19637762010097504,
-0.14820198714733124,
-0.1871962994337082,
-0.42172351479530334,
-0.4126504063606262,
0.4328383207321167,
-0.7312072515487671,
-0.07817570865154266,
0.8135172128677368,
0.6647436022758484,
0.6752835512161255,
-0.1232345849275589,
-0.4376636743545532,
0.30403706431388855,
-0.630443811416626,
0.0983787477016449,
-0.07681044191122055,
0.09051419049501419,
-0.5698563456535339,
0.39508503675460815,
0.3374330401420593,
0.648231029510498,
-0.05444798246026039,
-0.42867788672447205,
0.32162007689476013,
-0.3336828351020813,
0.00952393189072609,
0.07364901900291443,
0.47531658411026,
0.5115233659744263,
0.02095853164792061,
-0.4420011639595032,
-0.012772990390658379,
-0.549585223197937,
0.3017650246620178,
-0.819818377494812,
-0.5434183478355408,
-0.20052318274974823,
-0.9355089664459229,
-0.07553607225418091,
-0.0818227156996727,
-1.3988871574401855,
-0.5076838135719299,
-0.10859961062669754,
-0.21635866165161133,
-0.3149586319923401,
-0.3283943235874176,
0.08749215304851532,
-0.019350258633494377,
0.14175687730312347,
0.42844125628471375,
-1.0342634916305542,
0.09852758795022964,
0.569687008857727,
1.1106162071228027,
-0.2632639706134796,
-0.20234529674053192,
-0.11825698614120483,
0.24393557012081146,
0.02113400213420391,
0.9773050546646118,
-0.540072500705719,
-0.6020723581314087,
0.27454236149787903,
0.20105841755867004,
-0.3962274491786957,
-0.3905794322490692,
0.5719316601753235,
-0.39228442311286926,
-0.2664406895637512,
0.04409284517168999,
-0.27187013626098633,
-0.4989837408065796,
-0.13308069109916687,
-0.6147610545158386,
0.6275151968002319,
0.3128831088542938,
-0.8265265822410583,
0.007402852177619934,
-0.6331889629364014,
-0.9008225798606873,
0.057569969445466995,
0.34394559264183044,
-0.5466930270195007,
0.06265207380056381,
0.15589872002601624,
0.6878634095191956,
-0.22289396822452545,
-0.05514361336827278,
-0.41764330863952637,
-0.2190229445695877,
0.12902279198169708,
-0.27722081542015076,
0.8915238976478577,
0.2698831558227539,
0.12099456042051315,
0.191716268658638,
-0.3576594889163971,
-0.3698039650917053,
0.09409468621015549,
0.007715537212789059,
-0.27730804681777954,
0.7332116365432739,
0.08648058772087097,
0.09856578707695007,
-0.028137529268860817,
-0.08027468621730804,
0.3720693588256836,
-0.40192529559135437,
0.5089102983474731,
0.4967155456542969,
0.09464970976114273,
0.7303755879402161,
-0.6782230138778687,
0.8490522503852844,
0.23369568586349487,
0.32101666927337646,
-0.23168963193893433,
-0.9986822009086609,
-0.11568277329206467,
0.026882680132985115,
-0.034854989498853683,
1.0042774677276611,
-0.4834321141242981,
0.155938059091568,
-0.7012252807617188,
-0.6282166242599487,
-0.2628805935382843,
-0.15018026530742645,
-0.49683016538619995,
0.33642879128456116,
0.4447733461856842,
0.43472015857696533,
-0.8381856083869934,
-0.21918922662734985,
0.06553103774785995,
-0.18855638802051544,
-0.26146721839904785,
-0.06435921043157578,
0.2956840991973877,
-0.7882125377655029,
0.9244507551193237,
-0.31250762939453125,
-0.0062389010563492775,
-0.9095945954322815,
0.1875474750995636,
-0.1696472316980362,
0.2558559775352478,
0.7782156467437744,
-0.989790678024292,
-0.40860652923583984,
0.03665720298886299,
-0.21016791462898254,
-0.15558606386184692,
0.20825865864753723,
-0.021252404898405075,
-0.24113526940345764,
0.49068766832351685,
-0.28905099630355835,
0.6390339732170105,
0.7940618991851807,
-0.4312732517719269,
0.2798643112182617,
-0.20158934593200684,
-0.09094087034463882,
-1.2905634641647339,
-0.14549770951271057,
0.34400007128715515,
-0.4543248414993286,
-1.104701280593872,
-0.3629617691040039,
-0.1731678992509842,
-0.042515333741903305,
-0.3426671326160431,
0.4102395176887512,
-0.24331238865852356,
0.04944683611392975,
-0.0025326344184577465,
-0.21704912185668945,
-0.6897429823875427,
-0.5570150017738342,
-0.23549260199069977,
0.8052509427070618,
0.5625178217887878,
-0.7195890545845032,
0.21415650844573975,
0.16492605209350586,
-0.44509395956993103,
0.10201041400432587,
-0.35442814230918884,
-0.20417965948581696,
-0.30507102608680725,
0.41466495394706726,
-0.8480093479156494,
-0.22566980123519897,
-0.015037142671644688,
-0.18297722935676575,
-0.015365885570645332,
-0.1833260953426361,
-0.17786234617233276,
-0.7256438732147217,
0.11119727045297623,
0.15882669389247894,
1.043327808380127,
-0.19475653767585754,
0.7401183843612671,
0.8224964141845703,
0.06340979039669037,
-0.22171440720558167,
-0.7056731581687927,
-0.04521412402391434,
-0.6139515042304993,
-0.8365705013275146,
0.2760106027126312,
0.30635589361190796,
-0.5044536590576172,
-0.42418670654296875,
0.32244744896888733,
-0.2809562683105469,
0.5850030779838562,
0.6381367444992065,
0.2897823750972748,
0.12059947848320007,
0.057032160460948944,
-0.3719378709793091,
-0.02486923523247242,
0.0831805169582367,
-0.09657855331897736,
0.5648925304412842,
0.5644158124923706,
-0.1271202713251114,
-0.27517828345298767,
0.25564825534820557,
0.7412623763084412,
0.18136492371559143,
0.545440137386322,
0.49821871519088745,
-0.11234640330076218,
0.4446999132633209,
-0.3320792019367218,
-0.13623933494091034,
-0.3678058981895447,
0.7047683596611023,
0.028084099292755127,
-0.37204447388648987,
0.5473122596740723,
-0.6980966925621033,
-0.0029596879612654448,
0.246718630194664,
0.5950638651847839,
-0.38874974846839905,
1.151549220085144,
1.0772802829742432,
-0.5203536152839661,
0.5734046697616577,
0.015956278890371323,
0.07726716250181198,
-0.4977794289588928,
-0.24807631969451904,
-0.7802667617797852,
-0.4473576545715332,
-0.9712375402450562,
-0.793428897857666,
0.6219974160194397,
-0.10001973062753677,
0.013994281180202961,
0.14413949847221375,
0.024854209274053574,
0.1283246874809265,
-0.0511162132024765,
-0.061527084559202194,
-0.007157840766012669,
0.14168161153793335,
0.016628507524728775,
0.09641745686531067,
-0.7180862426757812,
-0.33750224113464355,
0.9953280687332153,
0.43042445182800293,
0.9588373303413391,
-0.04444950073957443,
0.45988261699676514,
0.7674732208251953,
0.8151511549949646,
-0.5078703165054321,
0.4568575322628021,
-0.2955053746700287,
-0.43629905581474304,
-0.526236355304718,
-0.41863036155700684,
-1.636612057685852,
0.012541771866381168,
-0.01340927928686142,
-1.0852476358413696,
0.045697540044784546,
0.004585237242281437,
-0.27712559700012207,
0.6184333562850952,
-0.45058274269104004,
0.41725024580955505,
-0.17689676582813263,
0.2863663136959076,
-0.4993748962879181,
-1.1502312421798706,
0.03436702862381935,
0.07161182910203934,
0.564520001411438,
-0.519766092300415,
-0.09734024107456207,
0.5188262462615967,
-0.4246779978275299,
0.7797597646713257,
-0.07925597578287125,
0.06831179559230804,
0.2482544332742691,
-0.16068445146083832,
0.47487011551856995,
-0.3433290123939514,
-0.4135841727256775,
0.4203487038612366,
-0.10791047662496567,
-0.39781951904296875,
0.05243087559938431,
0.42868268489837646,
-0.8337187767028809,
-0.15751059353351593,
-0.16565626859664917,
-0.38544318079948425,
0.14616085588932037,
-0.2184275984764099,
0.5221593379974365,
0.3400207757949829,
-0.2789904773235321,
-0.13834433257579803,
0.41522088646888733,
0.24440309405326843,
0.8026583194732666,
0.33251965045928955,
-0.3082212805747986,
-0.3150368928909302,
0.8496385812759399,
0.41820454597473145,
-0.0898844301700592,
0.7529194951057434,
0.4023364186286926,
-0.37518221139907837,
-0.5221476554870605,
-0.42566609382629395,
0.22964408993721008,
-0.20210672914981842,
-0.12163548916578293,
-0.6438775062561035,
-0.07497401535511017,
-0.5753827691078186,
-0.41559991240501404,
0.023353589698672295,
-0.15041592717170715,
-0.45496395230293274,
0.015108775347471237,
0.3563069701194763,
0.9428401589393616,
0.1530066579580307,
0.4905325770378113,
-0.8390834927558899,
0.07438213378190994,
0.10338885337114334,
-0.10385116934776306,
-0.07564272731542587,
-0.6235183477401733,
-0.4531208872795105,
0.04344930872321129,
-0.7113900184631348,
-1.3306025266647339,
0.9885901808738708,
-0.010683484375476837,
0.32768717408180237,
0.47218263149261475,
0.09493478387594223,
0.7973543405532837,
-0.7519086599349976,
1.1047354936599731,
0.5072295665740967,
-0.5145337581634521,
0.4774444103240967,
-0.428164541721344,
0.08350280672311783,
0.02911454066634178,
0.6336760520935059,
-0.642310380935669,
0.011748041026294231,
-0.4332875907421112,
-0.6665478944778442,
0.21199087798595428,
-0.19725565612316132,
-0.0466851182281971,
-0.06880930811166763,
0.12867702543735504,
-0.03159162774682045,
-0.2553976774215698,
-0.3318246901035309,
-0.4143296182155609,
-0.11662802845239639,
-0.28652384877204895,
-0.1918317824602127,
-0.3820039927959442,
0.32784199714660645,
-0.5572640299797058,
0.3131498396396637,
0.12205047905445099,
0.4054860770702362,
0.1037077084183693,
0.006398300174623728,
-0.5386372804641724,
0.07868430763483047,
0.968006432056427,
0.8102542757987976,
-0.058002177625894547,
-0.13010621070861816,
0.34871944785118103,
-0.7375310063362122,
0.6402068138122559,
0.17122727632522583,
-0.18829022347927094,
0.37186557054519653,
0.231177419424057,
0.4162166118621826,
0.27090221643447876,
-0.7293373942375183,
0.6321941018104553,
0.13281309604644775,
-0.07262998074293137,
-0.8806651830673218,
-0.10893699526786804,
0.020513519644737244,
0.29222461581230164,
0.513159453868866,
-0.0032773467246443033,
0.11885892599821091,
-0.24126845598220825,
0.07818780094385147,
0.10142967849969864,
-0.39076536893844604,
-0.9408745765686035,
0.8375858664512634,
0.5874230861663818,
-0.7072638869285583,
0.923065185546875,
0.24841207265853882,
-0.1356562077999115,
0.7640705108642578,
0.625152587890625,
0.8590419888496399,
-1.1268709897994995,
-0.17825019359588623,
0.1542893350124359,
0.26458317041397095,
-0.40474846959114075,
0.0016559235518798232,
0.3559423089027405,
-0.6988037824630737,
-0.5454885363578796,
-0.06259976327419281,
-0.041666921228170395,
-0.017662065103650093,
-0.4910985231399536,
0.5892954468727112,
0.14398589730262756,
-0.39243924617767334,
-0.21708855032920837,
-0.3517422676086426,
-0.5900296568870544,
-0.31673136353492737,
0.5700314044952393,
1.1514204740524292,
-0.9432749152183533,
1.0489696264266968,
0.9259258508682251,
0.23022308945655823,
-0.35666394233703613,
0.5361930131912231,
-0.023376867175102234,
-0.7110758423805237,
0.5932624340057373,
0.518543004989624,
0.25766462087631226,
-0.07904805988073349,
-0.4878091812133789,
-0.9929015636444092,
1.1209437847137451,
0.18972255289554596,
-0.6724896430969238,
-0.45288532972335815,
0.08292075246572495,
0.23057356476783752,
-0.32295528054237366,
0.4951086938381195,
0.6382792592048645,
0.49621710181236267,
-0.007693449966609478,
-0.997164249420166,
-0.35688313841819763,
0.193214550614357,
0.36922523379325867,
0.6009125709533691,
-0.5623576045036316,
0.7409218549728394,
-0.695000946521759,
-0.25770866870880127,
0.4808977246284485,
0.779805064201355,
-0.14151698350906372,
0.6732752919197083,
0.6669499278068542,
0.3182453513145447,
0.7706261873245239,
0.05027658864855766,
1.1969313621520996,
-0.45040014386177063,
0.06838364899158478,
0.6551543474197388,
-0.45213574171066284,
0.7893086075782776,
0.14313770830631256,
-0.2898211181163788,
0.7570571899414062,
0.39116227626800537,
0.24056987464427948,
0.579750120639801,
0.2648991644382477,
-0.2281094640493393,
-0.3441089391708374,
0.15673936903476715,
-0.3345096707344055,
0.6042587161064148,
0.7444338798522949,
-0.42815327644348145,
-0.44198381900787354,
0.3400653898715973,
-0.15901951491832733,
-0.2929857671260834,
-0.523766040802002,
0.5674223899841309,
-0.2589767575263977,
-0.34856632351875305,
0.2326655238866806,
0.2095482498407364,
0.4733864963054657,
-0.5451869964599609,
-0.06969067454338074,
0.0687025710940361,
-0.09437154978513718,
0.052244074642658234,
-0.7078532576560974,
0.3261808753013611,
-0.4503716826438904,
-0.24648748338222504,
-0.263692706823349,
0.789405882358551,
-0.15292374789714813,
-0.4420166313648224,
0.23697660863399506,
0.4588586688041687,
0.29956868290901184,
0.4252644181251526,
-0.5392353534698486,
-0.2236998975276947,
0.1394343227148056,
-0.20128992199897766,
0.5289791822433472,
0.5124428272247314,
-0.2822789251804352,
1.4809824228286743,
0.3294360935688019,
0.14537690579891205,
0.3494981527328491,
-0.15970247983932495,
0.3491817116737366,
-0.7147625088691711,
-0.6895988583564758,
-0.8821322917938232,
0.39784741401672363,
0.033269163221120834,
0.04267053306102753,
0.4582350552082062,
0.27006855607032776,
-0.011373856104910374,
-0.1532895863056183,
0.767670214176178,
0.06839971989393234,
0.759998619556427,
-0.18138524889945984,
0.3447018265724182,
-0.024601656943559647,
0.06963913887739182,
0.3050982356071472,
-0.12080395966768265,
-0.11828095465898514,
0.49981990456581116,
-0.41608282923698425,
-0.24713125824928284,
0.2271745204925537,
0.521528422832489,
0.08236227184534073,
-0.09668438881635666,
0.36157384514808655,
0.17588987946510315,
0.3508126437664032,
0.28709346055984497,
0.8519876003265381,
0.01056192722171545,
0.23760493099689484,
-0.11929976940155029,
0.02330339327454567,
-0.9621419310569763,
-0.7136133313179016,
-0.6238793134689331,
-0.6710814237594604,
-0.0992877259850502,
-0.3132549226284027,
0.19748711585998535,
1.2742441892623901,
1.3853000402450562,
-0.6096981167793274,
-0.521919310092926,
-0.17953549325466156,
0.2668394446372986,
-0.4972831606864929,
-0.22378072142601013,
0.12106961756944656,
-0.02488790452480316,
-0.43345513939857483,
0.37170547246932983,
0.11957016587257385,
0.749789834022522,
-0.2554771900177002,
0.15297730267047882,
-0.016049254685640335,
-0.06931904703378677,
0.7304799556732178,
0.46712931990623474,
-0.7184852957725525,
0.09891751408576965,
-0.183990478515625,
-0.07325800508260727,
-0.028010819107294083,
0.8933896422386169,
-0.922937273979187,
0.03752443194389343,
0.5681565403938293,
0.29777809977531433,
0.024387037381529808,
0.3910282850265503,
0.6916207671165466,
-0.44461774826049805,
0.32588452100753784,
0.44404247403144836,
0.2964644134044647,
0.09397732466459274,
-0.5272858142852783,
0.47000807523727417,
0.2994302809238434,
-0.8762224912643433,
-0.6631801128387451,
0.2056610882282257,
-0.7379013299942017,
-0.0559038408100605,
1.1055362224578857,
0.13729572296142578,
-0.36038705706596375,
-0.7577434182167053,
-0.03509611636400223,
0.008110076189041138,
-0.33379629254341125,
0.8714378476142883,
0.050394877791404724,
-0.3852008879184723,
-0.3597024977207184,
-0.7368050217628479,
0.2171952724456787,
-0.03307259827852249,
-0.739290714263916,
0.02897079661488533,
0.08922554552555084,
0.5219599008560181,
-0.05601341649889946,
0.4359554648399353,
0.19209043681621552,
-0.042611222714185715,
-0.5295997858047485,
-0.0012839051196351647,
0.35993897914886475,
-0.45166638493537903,
-0.0032538429368287325,
0.30993184447288513,
-0.25282132625579834,
-0.20460020005702972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16792v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16792v2
|
Weak-to-Strong Extrapolation Expedites Alignment
| 2024-04-25T17:39:50 | 2024-05-22T19:33:30 |
Chujie Zheng, Ziqi Wang, Heng Ji, Minlie Huang, Nanyun Peng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The open-source community is experiencing a surge in the release of large
language models (LLMs) that are trained to follow instructions and align with
human preference. However, further training to improve them still requires
expensive computational resources and data annotations. Is it possible to
bypass additional training and cost-effectively acquire better-aligned models?
Inspired by the literature on model interpolation, we propose a simple method
called ExPO to boost LLMs' alignment with human preference. Utilizing a model
that has undergone alignment training (e.g., via DPO or RLHF) and its initial
SFT checkpoint, ExPO directly obtains a better-aligned model by extrapolating
from the weights of the initial and the aligned models, which implicitly
optimizes the alignment objective via first-order approximation. Through
experiments with twelve open-source LLMs on HuggingFace, we demonstrate that
ExPO consistently improves off-the-shelf DPO/RLHF models, as evaluated on the
mainstream LLM benchmarks AlpacaEval 2.0 and MT-Bench. Moreover, ExPO exhibits
remarkable scalability across various model sizes (from 1.8B to 70B) and
capabilities. Through controlled experiments and further empirical analyses, we
shed light on the essence of ExPO amplifying the reward signal learned during
alignment training. Our work demonstrates the efficacy of model extrapolation
in expediting the alignment of LLMs with human preference, suggesting a
promising direction for future research.
|
[
-0.3239249885082245,
-0.34351199865341187,
0.6313923597335815,
0.2388477474451065,
-0.33037298917770386,
0.11736120283603668,
-0.26203233003616333,
-0.6378509998321533,
0.41178908944129944,
0.17566026747226715,
-0.5012297630310059,
-0.12764868140220642,
-0.5793318152427673,
-0.09471489489078522,
-0.2554820775985718,
0.7265190482139587,
-0.013808256946504116,
0.0021250194404274225,
-0.33182546496391296,
-0.20980845391750336,
-0.1533503234386444,
-0.4841054379940033,
-0.2251749187707901,
-0.432046115398407,
0.3625149130821228,
0.4999102056026459,
1.0295504331588745,
0.9553043842315674,
0.5308945775032043,
0.2543262541294098,
-0.1643541008234024,
0.20586754381656647,
-0.4504893124103546,
-0.10819222778081894,
-0.016236145049333572,
-0.6004804968833923,
-0.7118505239486694,
0.05784974992275238,
0.5417455434799194,
0.6874435544013977,
-0.4562932848930359,
0.1615612506866455,
0.11315584927797318,
0.7080022692680359,
-0.28210756182670593,
0.06677795201539993,
-0.6312037706375122,
-0.19285905361175537,
-0.08791171759366989,
-0.2866672873497009,
-0.4415082037448883,
-0.2604542076587677,
0.023424014449119568,
-0.6864363551139832,
-0.10068672150373459,
0.23867015540599823,
1.2604410648345947,
0.3853353261947632,
-0.10560987889766693,
0.18642352521419525,
-0.46842068433761597,
0.7849182486534119,
-0.6970827579498291,
0.6437943577766418,
0.08563171327114105,
0.08702488243579865,
-0.4072004556655884,
-0.5049101114273071,
-0.6427402496337891,
-0.24008984863758087,
0.0749019980430603,
0.02738869935274124,
-0.07229866087436676,
0.14754465222358704,
0.41721680760383606,
0.2919977903366089,
-0.008640604093670845,
0.43818309903144836,
-0.03271413594484329,
-0.009084247052669525,
0.6678112745285034,
-0.05467246100306511,
0.2796206772327423,
0.16592203080654144,
-0.724265456199646,
-0.4172976016998291,
-0.9617642760276794,
0.2537575662136078,
0.4581606090068817,
0.6114310622215271,
-0.02292081154882908,
0.7695102691650391,
-0.1592310070991516,
0.7590408325195312,
0.32757261395454407,
-0.23033858835697174,
0.41449597477912903,
0.06127720698714256,
0.13060487806797028,
0.019231626763939857,
0.6109750866889954,
0.5267267823219299,
0.059009019285440445,
-0.0327814482152462,
-0.18551181256771088,
-0.14747434854507446,
0.04956674203276634,
-0.7525264620780945,
0.14168860018253326,
0.18661218881607056,
-0.3386734127998352,
-0.03553992137312889,
-0.03780916705727577,
-0.62858647108078,
-0.36032140254974365,
-0.7906679511070251,
0.40490177273750305,
-0.19913740456104279,
-0.0509389266371727,
0.002508391160517931,
0.08574055135250092,
0.3062122166156769,
0.5009805560112,
-1.1002691984176636,
0.3088202476501465,
0.899114727973938,
1.054086685180664,
-0.10850120335817337,
-0.4685301184654236,
-0.7669751048088074,
0.08114853501319885,
-0.3036569356918335,
0.9026494026184082,
-0.4114183485507965,
-0.07693608105182648,
-0.3513248860836029,
-0.13897308707237244,
0.258080393075943,
-0.29955968260765076,
0.7233706712722778,
-0.44395962357521057,
-0.10979026556015015,
-0.23035669326782227,
-0.6218050122261047,
0.08893004804849625,
0.20956066250801086,
-0.6385762691497803,
0.9957409501075745,
0.14450402557849884,
-0.5031533241271973,
0.5815789699554443,
-0.2785828709602356,
-0.26140642166137695,
-0.03239593654870987,
-0.29563575983047485,
-0.3919947147369385,
0.4266836643218994,
0.4351022243499756,
0.3749989867210388,
-0.2974517047405243,
0.15824897587299347,
-0.5546125173568726,
-0.4467664659023285,
-0.053845494985580444,
-0.04118083044886589,
0.5294256210327148,
0.034852005541324615,
-0.33032000064849854,
0.10399200022220612,
-0.4965640902519226,
0.21978190541267395,
0.03615261986851692,
-0.36621615290641785,
-0.3794429898262024,
0.008404096588492393,
-0.4103690981864929,
0.4602596163749695,
0.13843697309494019,
-0.5319836139678955,
0.49852699041366577,
-0.6248271465301514,
0.09667381644248962,
0.9495642781257629,
-0.5844900608062744,
0.5177034735679626,
-0.27878129482269287,
0.5724180936813354,
-0.4191533923149109,
0.05027952790260315,
-0.08060035854578018,
-0.5597596168518066,
-0.4545280337333679,
-0.5809135437011719,
0.43839550018310547,
0.3130705654621124,
-0.10947514325380325,
0.4603373110294342,
-0.5661942958831787,
-0.4734486937522888,
-0.8841921091079712,
0.08217164129018784,
0.25054872035980225,
0.6866869330406189,
0.5112268924713135,
-0.2509409785270691,
-0.4581623077392578,
-0.7888650298118591,
-0.41494283080101013,
-0.38808754086494446,
0.07902361452579498,
0.2712325155735016,
0.06526762992143631,
0.055612508207559586,
0.9767394661903381,
-0.4522763788700104,
-0.20623397827148438,
0.021242953836917877,
0.15259379148483276,
0.20780232548713684,
0.36495569348335266,
0.36821699142456055,
-0.7198010683059692,
-0.5767064690589905,
-0.006460809614509344,
-0.08556975424289703,
-0.2445218712091446,
0.12019991874694824,
-0.29362890124320984,
-0.041199326515197754,
0.47617870569229126,
-0.5990315675735474,
0.15900279581546783,
0.7310218811035156,
-0.2146337926387787,
0.5018112659454346,
-0.01590159349143505,
0.13281169533729553,
-0.886077880859375,
0.24704429507255554,
-0.1832812875509262,
-0.4979528486728668,
-0.3852548897266388,
0.23962745070457458,
0.18116553127765656,
-0.11022583395242691,
-0.42718708515167236,
0.7904917597770691,
-0.4340519905090332,
-0.14231207966804504,
-0.3916637599468231,
0.08836758136749268,
0.11957897245883942,
0.4639130234718323,
0.4356774091720581,
0.6544528007507324,
0.30663299560546875,
-0.3065516948699951,
-0.06225673854351044,
0.5435042381286621,
-0.38535812497138977,
0.3459121882915497,
-0.5820558667182922,
0.21668030321598053,
-0.08997774869203568,
0.279286652803421,
-0.9663861393928528,
-0.2442689836025238,
-0.08557098358869553,
-0.2451808899641037,
0.5006270408630371,
-0.4725731611251831,
-0.48836615681648254,
-0.2605782151222229,
-0.3252083957195282,
0.24205657839775085,
0.5976231098175049,
-1.0022337436676025,
0.6807272434234619,
0.46225062012672424,
-0.24579596519470215,
-0.9276519417762756,
-0.6558390259742737,
-0.06610308587551117,
-0.2794494032859802,
-0.48566073179244995,
0.5680990815162659,
-0.03847428411245346,
-0.1742832511663437,
-0.2302347719669342,
-0.042834337800741196,
0.2009425014257431,
0.09167493134737015,
0.10756819695234299,
0.42945998907089233,
0.06363042443990707,
0.058071572333574295,
-0.027267176657915115,
-0.15453676879405975,
-0.32013705372810364,
-0.24981573224067688,
0.5165664553642273,
-0.16295075416564941,
-0.5308670997619629,
-0.4254409968852997,
0.22425422072410583,
0.6168696880340576,
-0.09025847911834717,
0.5345137119293213,
0.3168811798095703,
-0.23207326233386993,
-0.043651361018419266,
-0.5229397416114807,
-0.2648043930530548,
-0.4558298885822296,
0.37057140469551086,
-0.20854656398296356,
-0.5742180943489075,
0.2927303910255432,
-0.21685683727264404,
0.2752896547317505,
0.2771841287612915,
0.4681417942047119,
0.09029030054807663,
1.7304564714431763,
0.9508967399597168,
-0.07207491248846054,
0.663530707359314,
0.19926679134368896,
0.0337541401386261,
-0.926162600517273,
-0.12429936230182648,
-0.4469005763530731,
-0.551749050617218,
-0.3640311360359192,
-0.3823971152305603,
0.19781121611595154,
0.38737741112709045,
-0.08463495224714279,
0.4715992212295532,
-0.4748275578022003,
0.5883187651634216,
0.4605664312839508,
0.10405933111906052,
0.3899215757846832,
0.23660293221473694,
-0.22240297496318817,
-0.16100353002548218,
-0.6747658252716064,
-0.34231942892074585,
1.0027891397476196,
0.45957377552986145,
0.9554300308227539,
0.15588721632957458,
0.7418578267097473,
-0.15835697948932648,
0.7062949538230896,
-0.9404764175415039,
0.4184279143810272,
-0.06993654370307922,
-0.2996976673603058,
-0.09029906988143921,
-0.4965766966342926,
-0.5642760396003723,
0.24135959148406982,
-0.26976439356803894,
-0.8801865577697754,
0.49074190855026245,
0.5562494993209839,
-0.48987677693367004,
0.25395894050598145,
-0.7839006185531616,
0.6252797245979309,
-0.4542624056339264,
-0.5875841975212097,
-0.1262596696615219,
-0.8001413345336914,
0.21080520749092102,
0.04966544359922409,
0.11429727077484131,
-0.5384289026260376,
-0.29712235927581787,
0.5808866620063782,
-0.6679462790489197,
0.5935831665992737,
-0.1304006725549698,
-0.2747601568698883,
0.2534714639186859,
-0.07555623352527618,
1.0118556022644043,
-0.209260493516922,
-0.2843722105026245,
0.1298418790102005,
-0.3845490515232086,
-0.3770332932472229,
-0.5679575800895691,
0.5749907493591309,
-0.697439968585968,
-0.6438260674476624,
-0.1226448342204094,
-0.6825459003448486,
-0.4655764698982239,
0.1088903620839119,
0.17691875994205475,
0.3035655617713928,
0.05186951905488968,
-0.2225484400987625,
0.4464553892612457,
0.1215769499540329,
0.12020920217037201,
0.4249270558357239,
-0.44905906915664673,
-0.36231762170791626,
0.8036424517631531,
-0.044021062552928925,
0.6006449460983276,
0.4952453672885895,
0.4682151675224304,
-0.652754545211792,
-0.4134362041950226,
-0.5769100785255432,
0.2908305823802948,
-0.6502545475959778,
-0.4047369956970215,
-0.6685383319854736,
0.3221636116504669,
-0.3158450424671173,
-0.31902825832366943,
-0.6512388586997986,
-0.8191635012626648,
-0.017231348901987076,
-0.08740201592445374,
0.3296433985233307,
0.2958400249481201,
-0.2508860230445862,
0.36778223514556885,
-0.7051016688346863,
-0.03283527493476868,
0.26744887232780457,
0.37657052278518677,
-0.1416248083114624,
-0.724256157875061,
-0.18463684618473053,
0.10891349613666534,
-0.25164929032325745,
-0.6092944145202637,
0.3401295244693756,
0.3523101806640625,
0.4084051847457886,
0.3971045911312103,
-0.17629890143871307,
1.1455999612808228,
-0.5356426239013672,
0.4350239336490631,
0.5158125758171082,
-0.9502823948860168,
0.27779683470726013,
-0.24524492025375366,
0.2179662585258484,
0.737876832485199,
0.4190782606601715,
-0.29377612471580505,
-0.2698829174041748,
-0.673289954662323,
-1.0403062105178833,
0.7218796014785767,
-0.20732305943965912,
0.16356806457042694,
-0.032597288489341736,
0.4210551083087921,
0.07718750834465027,
0.30361101031303406,
-0.6842725276947021,
-0.0806354358792305,
-0.020293815061450005,
-0.33905714750289917,
0.06734918802976608,
-0.04675232991576195,
-0.3216833174228668,
-0.2735197842121124,
0.8336964845657349,
-0.5846131443977356,
0.29682886600494385,
0.18361517786979675,
-0.14127610623836517,
-0.5171667337417603,
0.1677696257829666,
0.4569341540336609,
0.5911449193954468,
-0.2940472364425659,
0.08976582437753677,
0.010278490372002125,
-0.3105691969394684,
0.32267722487449646,
0.5795400142669678,
-0.04566756263375282,
-0.24798518419265747,
0.05999882146716118,
0.7248520851135254,
0.09056410193443298,
-0.928046464920044,
0.8286190032958984,
0.07727877050638199,
0.17200690507888794,
0.3212290406227112,
-0.06876389682292938,
0.09096785634756088,
0.255734384059906,
0.2498461753129959,
0.14942015707492828,
-0.12156226485967636,
-0.49049392342567444,
0.29850274324417114,
0.5810546278953552,
-0.5681408643722534,
-0.419645220041275,
0.8551313281059265,
0.22215521335601807,
-0.0325993187725544,
0.5093838572502136,
-0.06526941061019897,
-0.6040750741958618,
0.3881452977657318,
0.7753466963768005,
0.5677431225776672,
-0.23314674198627472,
-0.11358170956373215,
0.40152648091316223,
0.09752906858921051,
-0.610064685344696,
0.24350957572460175,
-0.002252105390653014,
-0.7208632826805115,
-0.8815420269966125,
-0.6911365389823914,
-0.5232076048851013,
-0.2074633538722992,
-0.5689817070960999,
0.8435876965522766,
-0.33667275309562683,
-0.2414829283952713,
-0.3003159165382385,
-0.031641196459531784,
-0.5944815874099731,
0.00432072626426816,
0.4241516590118408,
0.9326817393302917,
-0.75587397813797,
0.48893052339553833,
0.8480962514877319,
-0.25399768352508545,
-1.1600569486618042,
-0.0262884721159935,
0.057321079075336456,
-1.0619151592254639,
0.4071010649204254,
0.32377317547798157,
-0.14836493134498596,
0.24893470108509064,
-0.6349188685417175,
-1.1426067352294922,
1.0256267786026,
0.8805948495864868,
-0.9610314965248108,
-0.15573793649673462,
-0.11940950900316238,
0.38590705394744873,
-0.4119054675102234,
0.40341585874557495,
0.3971540629863739,
0.3367188572883606,
0.04004480317234993,
-0.8707041144371033,
0.18641240894794464,
-0.13863565027713776,
-0.4336106479167938,
0.5379716157913208,
-0.9599415063858032,
0.6492447853088379,
-0.6375320553779602,
-0.21666136384010315,
0.19616885483264923,
0.7009474635124207,
0.37379226088523865,
-0.17381401360034943,
0.7177353501319885,
0.9882920384407043,
0.8800255060195923,
0.006800596136599779,
1.101057529449463,
-0.3376466929912567,
0.4114539325237274,
1.2455943822860718,
-0.3980545997619629,
0.8788327574729919,
0.7239851355552673,
-0.1915384829044342,
0.6302192807197571,
0.5367158651351929,
0.06973661482334137,
0.4143509566783905,
-0.03592350706458092,
-0.02466229721903801,
-0.30474838614463806,
-0.2989981770515442,
-0.4201889932155609,
0.2538420259952545,
0.15255239605903625,
-0.26607975363731384,
-0.15674737095832825,
-0.24158550798892975,
0.10521449148654938,
-0.04450417309999466,
-0.41597986221313477,
0.6072808504104614,
0.10861022770404816,
-0.9681116342544556,
0.45388063788414,
-0.2100551575422287,
0.45378947257995605,
-0.7752265930175781,
-0.15202230215072632,
-0.024415437132120132,
0.15507879853248596,
-0.26045647263526917,
-0.6837864518165588,
-0.06436808407306671,
-0.17801393568515778,
0.016622573137283325,
-0.27641427516937256,
0.6674148440361023,
-0.6833539605140686,
-0.17508576810359955,
0.28055670857429504,
0.3915107846260071,
0.026798374950885773,
-0.06366326659917831,
-0.7052286863327026,
-0.15917333960533142,
-0.0637662261724472,
-0.33856597542762756,
0.3872038722038269,
-0.03413514047861099,
-0.05557316541671753,
0.5487468242645264,
0.7152770757675171,
0.1872507929801941,
-0.04551059380173683,
-0.03591221570968628,
0.8153554201126099,
-0.36258047819137573,
-0.612224817276001,
-0.898216962814331,
0.6076793074607849,
-0.014961968176066875,
-0.2903216481208801,
0.6248316764831543,
0.4305223524570465,
0.6517921686172485,
0.3615706264972687,
0.5276833772659302,
-0.2207627296447754,
0.3834165930747986,
-0.49253028631210327,
0.2831301987171173,
-0.7574813961982727,
0.2824196219444275,
-0.36339089274406433,
-1.129270076751709,
-0.28735530376434326,
0.28694966435432434,
-0.26243340969085693,
-0.1521117091178894,
0.3413761556148529,
0.722817599773407,
-0.2812937796115875,
-0.1983492523431778,
0.12813933193683624,
0.046110931783914566,
0.20951400697231293,
0.2390279769897461,
1.0483758449554443,
-0.18978698551654816,
0.537230372428894,
-0.4133107364177704,
-0.4982149600982666,
-0.2849102318286896,
-1.1678255796432495,
-0.42140474915504456,
-0.24525929987430573,
-0.25617700815200806,
-0.5090649127960205,
-0.10825750976800919,
1.5221728086471558,
0.9430738091468811,
-0.4628671407699585,
-0.1071329265832901,
-0.1530805230140686,
0.08385999500751495,
-0.5614996552467346,
-0.13525931537151337,
0.5254388451576233,
-0.4286169409751892,
-0.8752641677856445,
0.5068508386611938,
0.16866914927959442,
0.27790623903274536,
0.10639441013336182,
-0.18888092041015625,
-0.2518266439437866,
0.18485252559185028,
0.32578983902931213,
0.4521506726741791,
-0.47977572679519653,
-0.28540992736816406,
0.03661085292696953,
-0.07109831273555756,
0.49791818857192993,
0.8371244668960571,
-0.7629039883613586,
0.5452752709388733,
0.45645710825920105,
0.6440213918685913,
0.24161572754383087,
0.6002044081687927,
0.8900944590568542,
-0.8365719318389893,
0.2276080697774887,
0.1198032796382904,
0.5424311757087708,
0.48991069197654724,
-0.4546054005622864,
0.5205843448638916,
0.007935895584523678,
-0.6262967586517334,
-0.9987292289733887,
0.362318754196167,
-0.7814558744430542,
0.0670708492398262,
1.0759657621383667,
-0.16053909063339233,
-0.3213101625442505,
0.2564801871776581,
-0.13287566602230072,
0.14800485968589783,
-0.5528852343559265,
0.877091109752655,
0.5456286668777466,
-0.4178302586078644,
0.27567753195762634,
-0.22677627205848694,
0.5818018913269043,
0.904173731803894,
-0.7694823741912842,
0.28230050206184387,
0.2637270987033844,
0.12701086699962616,
0.26226064562797546,
0.5763484239578247,
-0.2976773977279663,
0.283900648355484,
-0.28239360451698303,
0.21772146224975586,
0.00969019252806902,
-0.28761011362075806,
-0.46967414021492004,
-0.12264091521501541,
0.5224719047546387,
0.25716835260391235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16789v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16789v2
|
Continual Learning of Large Language Models: A Comprehensive Survey
| 2024-04-25T17:38:57 | 2024-06-30T02:19:00 |
Haizhou Shi, Zihao Xu, Hengyi Wang, Weiyi Qin, Wenyuan Wang, Yibin Wang, Zifeng Wang, Sayna Ebrahimi, Hao Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The recent success of large language models (LLMs) trained on static,
pre-collected, general datasets has sparked numerous research directions and
applications. One such direction addresses the non-trivial challenge of
integrating pre-trained LLMs into dynamic data distributions, task structures,
and user preferences. Pre-trained LLMs, when tailored for specific needs, often
experience significant performance degradation in previous knowledge domains --
a phenomenon known as "catastrophic forgetting". While extensively studied in
the continual learning (CL) community, it presents new manifestations in the
realm of LLMs. In this survey, we provide a comprehensive overview of the
current research progress on LLMs within the context of CL. This survey is
structured into four main sections: we first describe an overview of
continually learning LLMs, consisting of two directions of continuity: vertical
continuity (or vertical continual learning), i.e., continual adaptation from
general to specific capabilities, and horizontal continuity (or horizontal
continual learning), i.e., continual adaptation across time and domains
(Section 3). We then summarize three stages of learning LLMs in the context of
modern CL: Continual Pre-Training (CPT), Domain-Adaptive Pre-training (DAP),
and Continual Fine-Tuning (CFT) (Section 4). Then we provide an overview of
evaluation protocols for continual learning with LLMs, along with the current
available data sources (Section 5). Finally, we discuss intriguing questions
pertaining to continual learning for LLMs (Section 6). The full list of papers
examined in this survey is available at
https://github.com/Wang-ML-Lab/llm-continual-learning-survey.
|
[
-0.29327449202537537,
-0.8393891453742981,
0.656512439250946,
0.1587020605802536,
-0.07032760232686996,
0.3899056017398834,
-0.5207737684249878,
-0.37388238310813904,
-0.11474185436964035,
0.592216432094574,
-0.49254509806632996,
-0.5031726360321045,
-0.5608864426612854,
-0.06029278412461281,
-0.3863917887210846,
0.8975906372070312,
-0.21319334208965302,
0.24293552339076996,
-0.35742059350013733,
-0.10861757397651672,
-0.6723098754882812,
-0.652427077293396,
-0.9652343988418579,
-0.48104128241539,
0.6895171999931335,
0.4160023033618927,
0.11520569771528244,
0.2427849918603897,
0.23782207071781158,
0.2739425301551819,
-0.14762024581432343,
0.06978126615285873,
-0.8598054647445679,
0.3332688510417938,
-0.13893625140190125,
-0.3123836815357208,
-0.2522665560245514,
0.04138224571943283,
1.1023372411727905,
1.195659875869751,
-0.20887857675552368,
0.11962441354990005,
0.4704296886920929,
0.7831892371177673,
-0.5170774459838867,
0.009413660503923893,
-0.6793432235717773,
0.04683634266257286,
-0.3657762408256531,
-0.2158077210187912,
-0.46376028656959534,
-0.4024922251701355,
0.34059658646583557,
-0.26460906863212585,
-0.005122397560626268,
-0.11306490004062653,
0.4606632590293884,
0.13003821671009064,
-0.43333035707473755,
-0.5310170650482178,
-0.9671801924705505,
1.0248854160308838,
-0.3849183917045593,
0.5389130711555481,
0.22343745827674866,
0.07806747406721115,
-0.2965922951698303,
-0.8465325236320496,
-0.2512613832950592,
-0.6190900802612305,
0.3094906806945801,
0.12565509974956512,
0.10867701470851898,
-0.07737372815608978,
0.01521424949169159,
0.3521285653114319,
-0.5236223340034485,
0.37085503339767456,
-0.11428581178188324,
-0.08701454102993011,
0.4509141743183136,
0.29459434747695923,
0.1374959796667099,
0.5025584697723389,
-0.2690673768520355,
0.3719710409641266,
-1.0587646961212158,
-0.2722129821777344,
-0.0675995796918869,
-0.11971461027860641,
-0.1014348566532135,
0.07610327750444412,
0.09204794466495514,
0.730491578578949,
-0.12318159639835358,
-0.26272791624069214,
0.1787145435810089,
-0.33805355429649353,
-0.04228943586349487,
-0.3663586974143982,
0.6610848903656006,
-0.08756344765424728,
0.37389326095581055,
-0.25593405961990356,
-0.3959212303161621,
-0.40011900663375854,
0.2721315920352936,
-0.3475140333175659,
-0.24737752974033356,
0.04281357675790787,
-0.2694014310836792,
-0.061608895659446716,
-0.2607547640800476,
-0.5034506320953369,
-0.2774702310562134,
-0.6046208739280701,
0.219014972448349,
-0.2513684034347534,
-0.27108103036880493,
0.1073581799864769,
0.3967646360397339,
0.2565228044986725,
0.45672035217285156,
-0.666831374168396,
0.42614492774009705,
0.5828496217727661,
0.8580657839775085,
-0.507429301738739,
-0.4882551431655884,
-0.39856380224227905,
0.12718726694583893,
-0.50553297996521,
0.6757341027259827,
-0.31027951836586,
-0.44436115026474,
0.37085622549057007,
0.032836008816957474,
-0.2090308666229248,
-0.8062870502471924,
0.17771016061306,
-0.7303677201271057,
0.1837186962366104,
-0.3922974467277527,
-0.6636024713516235,
0.036665868014097214,
0.5012874007225037,
-0.36987724900245667,
0.8310707807540894,
0.008136163465678692,
-0.5125315189361572,
0.2523172199726105,
-0.3975459337234497,
-0.3135298788547516,
0.16077634692192078,
-0.05247022211551666,
-0.4487535357475281,
0.07634855061769485,
-0.35875117778778076,
0.5665022730827332,
-0.31615033745765686,
0.3694252073764801,
-0.5624876022338867,
-0.24481648206710815,
0.3576892912387848,
-0.41452842950820923,
0.5836262702941895,
0.13973793387413025,
-0.14885511994361877,
0.12720970809459686,
-0.6514508724212646,
-0.2992982268333435,
0.2981874346733093,
-0.396581768989563,
-0.0693088248372078,
0.29603269696235657,
-0.1473434716463089,
0.20060613751411438,
0.4410422444343567,
-0.28144457936286926,
0.2500881850719452,
-0.005254712421447039,
0.39168044924736023,
0.869807243347168,
0.23943443596363068,
0.2746642529964447,
-0.4150039553642273,
0.4351234436035156,
0.03990153595805168,
0.22513315081596375,
-0.1800459772348404,
-0.06824101507663727,
-0.9677487015724182,
0.10184895992279053,
0.2115612030029297,
0.4093317687511444,
-0.694019079208374,
0.2879813611507416,
-0.2521182894706726,
-0.4686404764652252,
0.34045344591140747,
0.5213966369628906,
0.3447495400905609,
0.3039667010307312,
0.26921382546424866,
-0.3661505877971649,
-0.44982507824897766,
-0.42488497495651245,
0.06539367139339447,
-0.2376554310321808,
-0.02942643128335476,
0.22608104348182678,
0.6478555202484131,
-0.39361122250556946,
0.5699403882026672,
-0.3570689857006073,
-0.23124302923679352,
-0.44288134574890137,
0.014658791944384575,
-0.02696497179567814,
0.377410888671875,
0.44767048954963684,
-0.49150338768959045,
-0.4794098436832428,
-0.10622484236955643,
-0.7237313389778137,
0.10539822280406952,
-0.28236329555511475,
0.1859993040561676,
0.2878374457359314,
0.5925801396369934,
-0.47396689653396606,
-0.1578407883644104,
0.5395925045013428,
0.0513509176671505,
0.9698405861854553,
-0.21646076440811157,
-0.21038559079170227,
-0.7065235376358032,
0.060030702501535416,
-0.10491502285003662,
-0.2276262640953064,
-0.7015983462333679,
-0.17316529154777527,
-0.08978556841611862,
0.2340424656867981,
-0.42228320240974426,
0.6815725564956665,
-0.6865672469139099,
-0.05967497453093529,
-0.3562733232975006,
0.24292539060115814,
-0.5031964778900146,
0.37426257133483887,
-0.004294798243790865,
0.5999948978424072,
0.7615569233894348,
-0.9284583330154419,
0.35691121220588684,
-0.08054593205451965,
-0.30839183926582336,
0.2943648099899292,
-0.5137300491333008,
0.25503993034362793,
-0.0015881458530202508,
0.3892373740673065,
-0.8067213296890259,
-0.15396690368652344,
0.38730353116989136,
-0.22352078557014465,
0.5150994062423706,
-0.029310571029782295,
-0.6067629456520081,
-0.4319148659706116,
-0.056981053203344345,
0.2616319954395294,
0.5917483568191528,
-0.39792582392692566,
0.22903533279895782,
0.48585399985313416,
-0.34392255544662476,
-0.4168476164340973,
-0.4209219217300415,
0.11693058907985687,
-0.13072168827056885,
-0.13098451495170593,
0.12434887140989304,
-0.24505238234996796,
-0.20071116089820862,
-0.0908225029706955,
-0.1470821052789688,
-0.07663427293300629,
0.22646792232990265,
-0.0355374850332737,
0.15737608075141907,
-0.1319890171289444,
0.35929691791534424,
-0.4181772768497467,
0.0735103189945221,
0.22157518565654755,
-0.6829059720039368,
0.7386072874069214,
-0.29099783301353455,
-0.4169098734855652,
-0.14193394780158997,
-0.010820548050105572,
0.46586617827415466,
0.019424336031079292,
0.7916037440299988,
0.48123326897621155,
-0.27720052003860474,
-0.2584792375564575,
-0.7264314293861389,
0.08039158582687378,
-0.3941795229911804,
0.32244694232940674,
-0.1476708948612213,
-1.1991020441055298,
0.5121762156486511,
-0.3722207844257355,
0.2366565763950348,
0.4059009253978729,
0.7381598353385925,
-0.38103142380714417,
0.5564869046211243,
0.9075411558151245,
-0.33120453357696533,
0.5323699712753296,
-0.2859315276145935,
-0.07533571124076843,
-0.546181321144104,
-0.4282318949699402,
-0.39247947931289673,
-0.001267557730898261,
-0.32301419973373413,
-0.22396530210971832,
0.24504677951335907,
0.26207399368286133,
-0.355086088180542,
-0.13430942595005035,
0.08014153689146042,
0.30375877022743225,
0.045120105147361755,
-0.0326869897544384,
0.18076013028621674,
-0.19327636063098907,
-0.07322918623685837,
0.2485063374042511,
-0.7848671674728394,
-0.38039106130599976,
1.0913572311401367,
0.6373839378356934,
0.7063766717910767,
-0.055573973804712296,
0.736213743686676,
0.19880634546279907,
0.5285559892654419,
-0.6568126082420349,
0.5201036334037781,
-0.008983553387224674,
-0.2963707745075226,
-0.3266582787036896,
-0.5515466332435608,
-1.0300183296203613,
-0.08763618022203445,
0.15674379467964172,
-0.6075416803359985,
-0.12406662106513977,
0.3637005686759949,
-0.12240292131900787,
0.37453892827033997,
-0.19150669872760773,
0.7154121994972229,
-0.5803179144859314,
-0.39216044545173645,
-0.4491316080093384,
-0.5767960548400879,
0.5895592570304871,
-0.6106061935424805,
0.08982440829277039,
-0.011828472837805748,
-0.06862553209066391,
0.7887446284294128,
-0.031769465655088425,
0.9453203678131104,
-0.25951775908470154,
-0.2352287322282791,
0.3634181618690491,
-0.1966538280248642,
0.3646151125431061,
0.1012292429804802,
0.25041133165359497,
0.281347393989563,
0.015555646270513535,
-0.5199223160743713,
-0.24506548047065735,
0.6808667778968811,
-0.6019936203956604,
-0.45481279492378235,
-0.5609275698661804,
-0.386654794216156,
-0.5800256133079529,
0.21978016197681427,
0.10822179913520813,
0.3563017249107361,
-0.41963911056518555,
0.34963586926460266,
1.114351511001587,
-0.40355342626571655,
0.2373136729001999,
0.5951179265975952,
-0.4749174416065216,
-0.2974964678287506,
0.9264283180236816,
0.25716307759284973,
0.4152919054031372,
0.2943936884403229,
0.06415550410747528,
-0.35117077827453613,
-0.9596779942512512,
0.048105236142873764,
0.5019700527191162,
-0.6255409121513367,
0.11326468735933304,
-0.5530918836593628,
-0.45178404450416565,
-0.25761014223098755,
-0.10951980948448181,
-0.44723743200302124,
0.03654307872056961,
-0.5119844675064087,
0.1682276427745819,
0.022792909294366837,
1.0269891023635864,
0.01776750385761261,
0.330141544342041,
-0.8350263237953186,
0.2128603458404541,
0.24216414988040924,
0.42778897285461426,
0.14415515959262848,
-0.6734856367111206,
-0.5269867181777954,
0.010526962578296661,
-0.4660181999206543,
-0.4312724769115448,
0.1887262612581253,
0.21113941073417664,
0.8320015668869019,
0.4003767669200897,
-0.229002445936203,
0.5992102026939392,
-0.593717098236084,
0.9811815023422241,
0.3536989986896515,
-0.5984277725219727,
0.2289171814918518,
-0.3921445608139038,
0.4848838448524475,
0.47968804836273193,
0.7974519729614258,
-0.7747403383255005,
-0.2958245873451233,
-0.38205620646476746,
-0.6837403178215027,
0.2746507525444031,
-0.2599051594734192,
0.23494553565979004,
-0.057348765432834625,
0.4493752717971802,
0.11753818392753601,
0.1288018673658371,
-0.6521565914154053,
-0.2398969829082489,
0.2629600167274475,
0.07968616485595703,
-0.2777054011821747,
-0.5727478265762329,
-0.07310739159584045,
-0.2606074810028076,
0.6134828925132751,
0.058907557278871536,
0.17861180007457733,
-0.25687742233276367,
-0.4922330677509308,
0.23581337928771973,
0.1899554431438446,
0.6410253047943115,
1.1494314670562744,
-0.13488607108592987,
-0.03931468352675438,
0.4971098303794861,
-0.5155104398727417,
0.21281740069389343,
-0.27820953726768494,
-0.06970451027154922,
-0.09407203644514084,
0.5004626512527466,
0.6294878721237183,
0.4460032880306244,
-0.6303349733352661,
0.24828234314918518,
-0.007943438366055489,
-0.35950177907943726,
-0.978856086730957,
-0.024636656045913696,
0.10795474797487259,
0.019339844584465027,
0.39861440658569336,
-0.071945920586586,
-0.31121623516082764,
-0.642388105392456,
0.37867558002471924,
0.33364519476890564,
-0.4900403320789337,
-0.3630528748035431,
0.33882659673690796,
0.12002694606781006,
0.02035604603588581,
0.7113023400306702,
-0.16624902188777924,
-0.5131264925003052,
0.13261733949184418,
0.5079799890518188,
0.9050267338752747,
-0.2603147029876709,
0.01598444953560829,
0.26135051250457764,
0.1702795922756195,
-0.43460988998413086,
0.10128983110189438,
-0.21957547962665558,
-0.6347146034240723,
-0.49392780661582947,
-0.8087628483772278,
-0.6214060187339783,
0.47427117824554443,
-0.4610345661640167,
0.13126836717128754,
-0.6189528703689575,
0.04717952385544777,
-0.5141657590866089,
0.20708847045898438,
-0.6019198298454285,
0.12000326812267303,
0.3183283507823944,
0.9562460780143738,
-0.6183836460113525,
1.1119054555892944,
0.5003015995025635,
-0.24322395026683807,
-0.374525249004364,
0.13730977475643158,
0.19631856679916382,
-0.5342435836791992,
0.6517560482025146,
-0.0019831133540719748,
-0.25139665603637695,
0.08112600445747375,
-0.6600512862205505,
-0.9001787900924683,
1.012541651725769,
0.19299742579460144,
-0.6978660821914673,
-0.0061118947342038155,
0.1352604478597641,
0.5137195587158203,
-0.2174479365348816,
-0.0042175366543233395,
0.7645251750946045,
0.29658275842666626,
0.1351829469203949,
-0.8157142400741577,
-0.3963584005832672,
0.04367441311478615,
-0.0026906118728220463,
0.05340568721294403,
-0.6424200534820557,
0.543340265750885,
0.07590499520301819,
-0.19487264752388,
0.2912355065345764,
0.7008510231971741,
0.4389669597148895,
0.32303133606910706,
0.43593549728393555,
0.46469295024871826,
0.7180111408233643,
-0.15786220133304596,
0.7775043249130249,
-0.3651268780231476,
0.33670252561569214,
1.0473883152008057,
-0.39424803853034973,
0.7946147322654724,
0.25224635004997253,
-0.2548915147781372,
0.29676640033721924,
0.8735078573226929,
-0.04334687069058418,
0.3504587709903717,
0.3695162832736969,
-0.41961929202079773,
-0.275765597820282,
0.09704865515232086,
-0.45624762773513794,
0.1584392935037613,
0.5918808579444885,
-0.06738314032554626,
-0.13321176171302795,
0.14123310148715973,
0.026541363447904587,
-0.18364739418029785,
-0.4141625165939331,
0.7288886904716492,
0.43564659357070923,
-0.6187453269958496,
0.7358049154281616,
-0.19511672854423523,
0.6171804070472717,
-0.9737825393676758,
0.18279686570167542,
-0.2919466197490692,
0.12258730083703995,
0.05313969776034355,
-0.704099178314209,
0.23615574836730957,
0.01869424432516098,
-0.10833609849214554,
-0.43506771326065063,
0.5240546464920044,
-0.48593172430992126,
-0.22253362834453583,
0.42862769961357117,
0.3981914520263672,
0.3130055367946625,
0.1616605669260025,
-0.7890244126319885,
0.37642642855644226,
-0.21583892405033112,
-0.3897518515586853,
0.5582857728004456,
0.3003648519515991,
0.013658306561410427,
0.9908937215805054,
0.5448727011680603,
0.2752685844898224,
0.12340982258319855,
0.2786497473716736,
0.7986295819282532,
-0.7806261777877808,
-0.06853926926851273,
-0.7100712060928345,
0.37217050790786743,
0.2047348916530609,
-0.29303601384162903,
0.7895184755325317,
0.4122748374938965,
1.1160924434661865,
-0.08149336278438568,
0.8089812994003296,
0.19823536276817322,
0.4453401267528534,
-0.8219313025474548,
0.7068834900856018,
-0.6305868625640869,
0.3706011474132538,
-0.048904091119766235,
-1.0209053754806519,
-0.37541326880455017,
0.20150688290596008,
-0.4526751935482025,
0.232749342918396,
0.7852325439453125,
0.42760857939720154,
0.11202990263700485,
-0.31928667426109314,
0.42108264565467834,
0.38161319494247437,
0.25620079040527344,
0.6266670823097229,
1.168954849243164,
0.08052017539739609,
0.3270992934703827,
-0.11441421508789062,
-0.05158856138586998,
-0.17149768769741058,
-0.694600522518158,
-0.7212490439414978,
-0.6231133937835693,
-0.3747110664844513,
-0.006524319294840097,
0.21638238430023193,
0.7045800685882568,
0.4373806118965149,
-0.8342561721801758,
-0.4848775565624237,
-0.22165387868881226,
0.111602284014225,
-0.019515156745910645,
-0.0697019174695015,
0.21938014030456543,
-0.8823094964027405,
-0.5348391532897949,
0.4657735526561737,
0.34377411007881165,
-0.0662892535328865,
-0.4743221402168274,
-0.3156750202178955,
-0.23460672795772552,
-0.31421127915382385,
0.8068705797195435,
0.6476874351501465,
-0.6220325827598572,
-0.2997290790081024,
-0.07063330709934235,
-0.07126845419406891,
-0.10908195376396179,
0.7925816774368286,
-0.5618941187858582,
0.23001866042613983,
0.24361836910247803,
0.8617895245552063,
0.50059574842453,
-0.36367112398147583,
0.4249943494796753,
-0.49576535820961,
-0.15341496467590332,
0.3500712513923645,
0.3373396694660187,
0.23518109321594238,
0.003126721829175949,
0.28852495551109314,
0.5198448300361633,
-0.927550733089447,
-0.8366865515708923,
0.32092830538749695,
-0.8871233463287354,
-0.3115767538547516,
1.1383572816848755,
-0.2518300712108612,
0.11301100254058838,
-0.4520629346370697,
0.18761292099952698,
0.10970628261566162,
0.24413253366947174,
0.6015726923942566,
0.7496296167373657,
-0.1024613305926323,
-0.2912050783634186,
-0.7140992879867554,
0.3742362856864929,
0.33645039796829224,
-0.6616275310516357,
0.11298929154872894,
0.6421880125999451,
0.6668617129325867,
-0.15058737993240356,
0.841068685054779,
-0.14527462422847748,
0.11352363973855972,
-0.21616043150424957,
-0.11738274991512299,
0.18148618936538696,
-0.7415139079093933,
-0.6381920576095581,
0.15152518451213837,
0.5303720235824585,
0.13727319240570068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01576v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01576v1
|
Uncovering Deceptive Tendencies in Language Models: A Simulated Company AI Assistant
| 2024-04-25T17:29:53 | 2024-04-25T17:29:53 |
Olli Järviniemi, Evan Hubinger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We study the tendency of AI systems to deceive by constructing a realistic
simulation setting of a company AI assistant. The simulated company employees
provide tasks for the assistant to complete, these tasks spanning writing
assistance, information retrieval and programming. We then introduce situations
where the model might be inclined to behave deceptively, while taking care to
not instruct or otherwise pressure the model to do so. Across different
scenarios, we find that Claude 3 Opus
1) complies with a task of mass-generating comments to influence public
perception of the company, later deceiving humans about it having done so,
2) lies to auditors when asked questions, and
3) strategically pretends to be less capable than it is during capability
evaluations.
Our work demonstrates that even models trained to be helpful, harmless and
honest sometimes behave deceptively in realistic scenarios, without notable
external pressure to do so.
|
[
-0.1855946034193039,
-0.8774877786636353,
0.8665069937705994,
0.3185282051563263,
0.06277552247047424,
-0.07124550640583038,
0.031094497069716454,
-0.8283418416976929,
0.08729691058397293,
0.7914882302284241,
-0.5512046217918396,
-0.06645146012306213,
-0.5696306824684143,
0.24027568101882935,
-0.47286978363990784,
0.8292193412780762,
0.22761130332946777,
0.1540156900882721,
-0.34898144006729126,
0.15310920774936676,
-0.326790452003479,
-0.8114909529685974,
-0.8385134339332581,
-0.34298181533813477,
0.19375017285346985,
0.3626435697078705,
0.8309364914894104,
0.4383958578109741,
0.18947923183441162,
0.35718315839767456,
0.3390060067176819,
-0.06107419356703758,
-0.4946473240852356,
0.3192395269870758,
0.12385682016611099,
-0.9736853837966919,
-0.14842472970485687,
0.5126991868019104,
0.22341613471508026,
0.38804563879966736,
-0.12444868683815002,
0.029986394569277763,
0.22943542897701263,
0.43759939074516296,
-0.5548181533813477,
0.7066807746887207,
-0.7799166440963745,
-0.42314860224723816,
0.023537704721093178,
0.029582004994153976,
-0.7956468462944031,
-0.23813916742801666,
0.0921194776892662,
-0.632236897945404,
0.2969326674938202,
0.19111940264701843,
0.842052161693573,
0.4143550992012024,
-0.36739879846572876,
-0.46270933747291565,
-0.9892339110374451,
0.9922187328338623,
-0.4535887837409973,
0.1038731262087822,
0.8148897290229797,
0.30971574783325195,
0.20261970162391663,
-0.5034546256065369,
-0.6748626828193665,
-0.851462721824646,
-0.22678059339523315,
0.0926787331700325,
-0.4932454526424408,
0.19246681034564972,
0.42108118534088135,
0.10690949857234955,
-0.32169008255004883,
0.13713084161281586,
-0.5520243048667908,
-0.2936401665210724,
0.6505032181739807,
-0.036361414939165115,
0.3307139277458191,
0.24574579298496246,
-0.0514698326587677,
-0.5389648079872131,
-0.6007486581802368,
-0.0904269814491272,
0.7387565970420837,
0.1381630152463913,
-0.05181501805782318,
0.43799832463264465,
-0.016175275668501854,
0.6685518026351929,
-0.05592622980475426,
0.1022719144821167,
0.010331884026527405,
0.20910276472568512,
-0.3308585286140442,
0.39950981736183167,
0.5013321042060852,
0.3254633843898773,
0.571018636226654,
0.03801490738987923,
-0.42478397488594055,
0.6770901679992676,
0.6920828819274902,
-0.4900745749473572,
-0.3691255748271942,
0.23359252512454987,
-0.4569702446460724,
-0.7584607601165771,
0.06630346924066544,
-0.46627920866012573,
-0.6912955641746521,
-0.34247615933418274,
0.4244193136692047,
-0.49976611137390137,
-0.0904671922326088,
-0.21953779458999634,
-0.322529137134552,
0.23186415433883667,
0.47206348180770874,
-0.7094120383262634,
0.5225610136985779,
0.731776237487793,
0.36843812465667725,
0.13362419605255127,
-0.3544943332672119,
-0.5912400484085083,
0.150063157081604,
-0.42268380522727966,
0.460481733083725,
-0.766991376876831,
-0.46779149770736694,
0.06944055110216141,
-0.0777062326669693,
0.049468569457530975,
-0.7803494334220886,
0.6235947012901306,
-0.3993123471736908,
0.3012196719646454,
-0.11774412542581558,
-0.14855124056339264,
-0.3643108010292053,
0.43752720952033997,
-0.932579517364502,
0.5721871256828308,
0.013623071834445,
-0.6331795454025269,
0.1888355314731598,
-0.8339443802833557,
-0.21243122220039368,
-0.1120399534702301,
-0.48807141184806824,
-0.1872948408126831,
0.2665432393550873,
0.09661281108856201,
0.236684650182724,
-0.21463851630687714,
-0.10497782379388809,
-0.14750465750694275,
-0.19462883472442627,
0.5542802810668945,
-0.8219845294952393,
1.0991146564483643,
0.22502073645591736,
-0.28706273436546326,
-0.15426483750343323,
-0.5858559012413025,
-0.3567007780075073,
0.24519112706184387,
-0.019248589873313904,
-0.7311339974403381,
-0.08440303802490234,
-0.2798899710178375,
0.032530076801776886,
0.3932020366191864,
-0.4936200678348541,
0.20064599812030792,
-0.4591974914073944,
0.057992082089185715,
0.737461268901825,
0.17962053418159485,
0.22860999405384064,
-0.7113475203514099,
0.7223036885261536,
0.05159572511911392,
0.3781198263168335,
0.004076881799846888,
-0.661639928817749,
-0.7839817404747009,
-0.12101241201162338,
0.2138144075870514,
0.657468855381012,
-1.0433995723724365,
-0.09895844012498856,
-0.31201425194740295,
-0.4692332148551941,
-0.9084187150001526,
-0.04527438431978226,
0.5886918306350708,
0.45391154289245605,
0.10329259932041168,
-0.12038698047399521,
-0.14272218942642212,
-1.539096713066101,
-0.4379289150238037,
-0.6172400116920471,
-0.21391676366329193,
0.1762865036725998,
0.513343334197998,
-0.01887674070894718,
0.6892424821853638,
-0.42602258920669556,
-0.2954462766647339,
-0.22050532698631287,
0.5441483855247498,
-0.07312684506177902,
0.48628273606300354,
0.6614065170288086,
-1.155544400215149,
-0.39966052770614624,
-0.16252392530441284,
-0.4902995824813843,
-0.011153138242661953,
-0.27425119280815125,
0.3493686616420746,
0.41073280572891235,
0.47922030091285706,
-0.3441307246685028,
0.39372071623802185,
0.6933116316795349,
-0.22403746843338013,
0.7013545632362366,
-0.37942609190940857,
0.09981981664896011,
-0.8940479755401611,
0.0712900459766388,
0.07514625787734985,
-0.16225525736808777,
-0.7659385204315186,
0.09490706771612167,
-0.1829468309879303,
-0.009207394905388355,
-0.3032686412334442,
0.15579698979854584,
-0.49615976214408875,
0.31637778878211975,
-0.19789500534534454,
-0.04777725413441658,
0.11513777077198029,
0.4791733920574188,
0.03862308710813522,
0.8499079346656799,
0.498121976852417,
-0.830513060092926,
0.321410596370697,
0.12964476644992828,
-0.4417411983013153,
0.43778517842292786,
-0.5574825406074524,
0.16425539553165436,
-0.2894984185695648,
0.12604519724845886,
-0.6433454155921936,
-0.3126240670681,
0.22963275015354156,
-0.6404492855072021,
0.16711007058620453,
-0.13648441433906555,
-0.7963084578514099,
-0.19319571554660797,
-0.227993905544281,
0.24332112073898315,
0.7726015448570251,
-0.3105117380619049,
0.5137797594070435,
0.28096291422843933,
-0.06392354518175125,
-0.38420796394348145,
-1.2593389749526978,
0.0855281874537468,
-0.4233069121837616,
-0.28818297386169434,
0.20162169635295868,
-0.07362711429595947,
-0.8070571422576904,
-0.16138991713523865,
0.12866641581058502,
-0.4026147127151489,
0.16102157533168793,
0.27731549739837646,
0.3040045499801636,
0.21088314056396484,
-0.34230077266693115,
-0.2713826298713684,
0.2564200758934021,
0.6109726428985596,
0.0539909303188324,
0.29573073983192444,
-0.11844708025455475,
-0.5000563859939575,
-0.827727735042572,
0.11962614208459854,
0.7926452159881592,
0.06689423322677612,
0.7449640035629272,
0.11259716749191284,
-0.2797572910785675,
-0.21648654341697693,
-0.6354325413703918,
-0.4921683371067047,
-0.5215410590171814,
0.21155865490436554,
-0.3671559989452362,
-0.3361075222492218,
0.5374153256416321,
0.0484221912920475,
0.017048429697752,
0.2970488667488098,
0.39006271958351135,
0.13252444565296173,
1.3516191244125366,
0.9234318137168884,
-0.10025922954082489,
0.28678223490715027,
-0.3114813268184662,
0.2082350254058838,
-0.3691175878047943,
-0.32085493206977844,
-0.7392164468765259,
-0.1729695051908493,
-1.0371493101119995,
-0.23020847141742706,
0.5346872210502625,
-0.2088956981897354,
0.09759332984685898,
0.45368629693984985,
-0.5942205190658569,
0.5319350957870483,
0.8416979312896729,
-0.14431481063365936,
0.20002871751785278,
-0.1186380386352539,
-0.06623254716396332,
-0.04819782078266144,
-0.5634148716926575,
-0.6538693904876709,
0.7661736011505127,
0.4692877531051636,
0.6612470746040344,
0.300924152135849,
0.5957888960838318,
0.3975335657596588,
0.5932605266571045,
-0.6755106449127197,
0.5113387703895569,
0.19175508618354797,
-0.8269371390342712,
-0.12612813711166382,
-0.3176783621311188,
-0.8176500201225281,
-0.22257250547409058,
0.033099181950092316,
-0.9572219848632812,
0.3579454720020294,
0.4100527763366699,
-0.21161167323589325,
0.04385459050536156,
-0.9415321350097656,
0.6018688082695007,
-0.18703091144561768,
-0.2860575318336487,
-0.4641857147216797,
-0.5526068210601807,
0.6109099388122559,
-0.1695796549320221,
0.23158195614814758,
0.17145279049873352,
0.0281357541680336,
0.5522330403327942,
-0.18887577950954437,
1.2289819717407227,
-0.18413138389587402,
-0.41381675004959106,
0.2528045177459717,
0.804172933101654,
0.7810292840003967,
-0.08519137650728226,
-0.4702579379081726,
-0.10636994242668152,
0.12081598490476608,
-0.4018518030643463,
-0.8930532336235046,
0.5650662183761597,
-0.7133524417877197,
-0.8701775074005127,
-0.48864683508872986,
-0.5346688032150269,
-0.4402978718280792,
0.05893932655453682,
0.3340435326099396,
0.4592675566673279,
-0.4442588686943054,
0.07740845531225204,
0.5692387223243713,
-0.18674348294734955,
0.2715889811515808,
0.5392240285873413,
0.07350218296051025,
-0.0010846755467355251,
1.015968918800354,
-0.12071529030799866,
0.4500443935394287,
0.3589257597923279,
0.04690270498394966,
-0.3480256497859955,
-0.25357142090797424,
-0.18849027156829834,
0.22107148170471191,
-0.6044057607650757,
0.09331900626420975,
-0.10309385508298874,
-0.023467380553483963,
-0.5135802626609802,
0.008568216115236282,
-0.2642158269882202,
-0.49569380283355713,
-0.2129158228635788,
0.037386804819107056,
0.0844167023897171,
1.1804685592651367,
0.19004663825035095,
0.2785491645336151,
-0.5987194180488586,
0.017459217458963394,
0.5048412084579468,
0.11737381666898727,
-0.23812279105186462,
-0.4085271656513214,
-0.2194027453660965,
0.3862994313240051,
-0.5987628102302551,
-0.8937463760375977,
0.4964870512485504,
-0.23064221441745758,
0.5096148252487183,
0.861571729183197,
0.4578837454319,
0.2160479873418808,
-0.2533124089241028,
1.138440728187561,
-0.024895554408431053,
-0.7593439817428589,
0.3702290654182434,
-0.41177505254745483,
-0.06622768193483353,
0.6402330994606018,
0.5986197590827942,
-0.22970682382583618,
-0.8886104226112366,
-1.1258184909820557,
-0.3312782645225525,
0.812131941318512,
0.4578876197338104,
0.37548959255218506,
0.0990893691778183,
0.11791077256202698,
0.17929142713546753,
0.4004661738872528,
-0.9728875160217285,
-0.411288321018219,
-0.022210996598005295,
-0.07363071292638779,
0.03882146254181862,
-0.40523189306259155,
-0.435901939868927,
0.026759259402751923,
0.8430120348930359,
0.06731676310300827,
0.3778829872608185,
0.24250873923301697,
-0.055985040962696075,
0.09750944375991821,
0.10973580926656723,
0.9798485040664673,
0.7488862872123718,
-0.018225114792585373,
0.3231072425842285,
0.05366344377398491,
-0.2973818778991699,
-0.09753182530403137,
0.07066074013710022,
-0.11833159625530243,
0.0821683257818222,
0.5049869418144226,
0.8382336497306824,
-0.3016131520271301,
-0.6334278583526611,
0.6293371319770813,
-0.0647239089012146,
-0.39477699995040894,
-0.5969215035438538,
0.26375895738601685,
-0.24810917675495148,
0.07492826133966446,
0.3082566261291504,
0.1338588446378708,
0.3718651235103607,
-0.9149077534675598,
-0.1796831637620926,
0.5385810136795044,
-0.44399550557136536,
-0.5257131457328796,
0.7198905944824219,
0.2256154865026474,
-0.5512829422950745,
0.805079460144043,
-0.3554379642009735,
-0.7843350768089294,
0.5362648367881775,
0.4852249324321747,
1.0476104021072388,
-0.4005659520626068,
0.19026900827884674,
-0.12679962813854218,
0.7020797729492188,
-0.13738328218460083,
0.042238786816596985,
-0.13057316839694977,
-0.7948169112205505,
-0.35745349526405334,
-0.1898745894432068,
-0.6242086291313171,
0.6033935546875,
-0.575410008430481,
0.291683554649353,
-0.11855869740247726,
0.06416676193475723,
0.01747075840830803,
-0.08957739174365997,
-0.5144981741905212,
0.05725540593266487,
0.21822524070739746,
0.8858686685562134,
-0.9190958142280579,
0.9863690137863159,
0.6715072989463806,
-0.5945069193840027,
-0.6678318381309509,
0.5499454140663147,
-0.013293508440256119,
-0.9102627635002136,
0.7349428534507751,
0.18444804847240448,
-0.2507677674293518,
-0.026074456050992012,
-1.0062689781188965,
-0.21863649785518646,
0.6883836984634399,
0.576762855052948,
-0.22871120274066925,
-0.24261315166950226,
0.3893696665763855,
0.6507164835929871,
-0.30089259147644043,
0.09248748421669006,
0.569159746170044,
0.6792540550231934,
-0.3541194498538971,
-1.1844106912612915,
0.07405835390090942,
-0.2715293765068054,
-0.09214983135461807,
-0.3270322382450104,
-0.7195916175842285,
0.6988663673400879,
0.03061652183532715,
-0.124611496925354,
0.03110535815358162,
0.30643829703330994,
0.11518888175487518,
0.3853948414325714,
0.8129048943519592,
0.2902278006076813,
0.5854093432426453,
0.14488503336906433,
1.2684580087661743,
-0.5450979471206665,
-0.14239540696144104,
0.8085655570030212,
-0.2257758527994156,
0.4477686583995819,
0.570565938949585,
0.22672049701213837,
0.7400677800178528,
0.1911582350730896,
-0.09244009107351303,
0.4332146942615509,
0.2624772787094116,
-0.2996634244918823,
-0.23910832405090332,
-0.2812655568122864,
0.06032196432352066,
0.736041784286499,
0.481045126914978,
-0.4319683909416199,
-0.02878415770828724,
-0.009533753618597984,
-0.03977297246456146,
0.3091981112957001,
0.03711482137441635,
0.7463669180870056,
0.08466564118862152,
-1.0070791244506836,
0.5607748031616211,
0.12065320461988449,
0.2721698582172394,
-0.4062735438346863,
-0.4250625669956207,
0.05565045773983002,
0.13764968514442444,
0.18145175278186798,
-0.4352318048477173,
0.3436914086341858,
-0.13502326607704163,
-0.07024998217821121,
-0.696596086025238,
0.39807119965553284,
-0.25889164209365845,
-0.3311425447463989,
-0.04906975477933884,
0.38850080966949463,
0.4018092155456543,
-0.3041929006576538,
-0.8360689282417297,
0.14188407361507416,
0.16855399310588837,
-0.19681937992572784,
0.10203797370195389,
0.5380319952964783,
-0.22573745250701904,
0.8786349892616272,
0.40579694509506226,
0.12702271342277527,
-0.3635973334312439,
-0.06028371304273605,
0.6559782028198242,
-0.25208574533462524,
-0.7546908855438232,
-0.7550524473190308,
0.1931850016117096,
-0.30673933029174805,
0.11019939184188843,
0.8939188122749329,
0.7059857845306396,
0.761664092540741,
-0.2287478744983673,
0.9540413618087769,
0.15275053679943085,
0.36616912484169006,
-0.39506402611732483,
0.8323430418968201,
-0.42609646916389465,
0.4686102867126465,
-0.08016683161258698,
-0.8558862805366516,
-0.026420030742883682,
0.4187772572040558,
-0.496402382850647,
0.12991689145565033,
0.6521886587142944,
0.9433810114860535,
-0.11301343142986298,
0.09213199466466904,
0.5758841633796692,
0.7003909349441528,
0.20307229459285736,
0.16102059185504913,
0.8905311822891235,
-0.14160965383052826,
0.765754222869873,
-0.3914966583251953,
-0.07379759848117828,
-0.23511147499084473,
-0.6207486987113953,
-0.7036644816398621,
-0.7865923643112183,
-0.4432709217071533,
-0.6326519846916199,
-0.12147772312164307,
0.6118435859680176,
0.5124201774597168,
-0.6940010190010071,
-0.23763950169086456,
-0.3684040904045105,
-0.05188922956585884,
-0.243373304605484,
-0.2986966073513031,
-0.020698215812444687,
-0.0621260441839695,
-1.3083354234695435,
0.5241307020187378,
-0.15718895196914673,
0.41896989941596985,
-0.690413236618042,
0.14726410806179047,
0.23955923318862915,
0.41480565071105957,
0.2460014373064041,
0.20423321425914764,
-0.7180740237236023,
-0.31952887773513794,
-0.2164192795753479,
-0.0823158547282219,
-0.2762390077114105,
0.7488667368888855,
-0.9399970769882202,
0.412646621465683,
0.25859519839286804,
0.264201819896698,
0.17968502640724182,
0.2503630518913269,
0.9529658555984497,
-0.9494819641113281,
0.31105223298072815,
0.5814036130905151,
-0.053651828318834305,
0.3307470679283142,
-0.667116641998291,
0.27008360624313354,
0.0668485090136528,
-0.4430854916572571,
-0.9011922478675842,
0.3156995177268982,
-0.6779622435569763,
-0.5939814448356628,
1.1368831396102905,
0.22934095561504364,
-0.34185269474983215,
-0.22419606149196625,
-0.2569662630558014,
0.03593966364860535,
-0.4859497547149658,
1.193224310874939,
0.9204563498497009,
-0.39540135860443115,
0.18182946741580963,
-0.9846013784408569,
1.023154854774475,
0.37949779629707336,
-0.4947982430458069,
0.17837777733802795,
0.5840758681297302,
0.2082289606332779,
0.530120849609375,
0.5305290818214417,
0.11542382836341858,
0.21163056790828705,
0.17263883352279663,
-0.12479835003614426,
-0.15553946793079376,
-0.30030983686447144,
-0.37536317110061646,
0.006162587553262711,
0.3955121338367462,
-0.22973117232322693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16776v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16776v1
|
Modeling Selective Feature Attention for Representation-based Siamese Text Matching
| 2024-04-25T17:26:59 | 2024-04-25T17:26:59 |
Jianxiang Zang, Hui Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Representation-based Siamese networks have risen to popularity in lightweight
text matching due to their low deployment and inference costs. While word-level
attention mechanisms have been implemented within Siamese networks to improve
performance, we propose Feature Attention (FA), a novel downstream block
designed to enrich the modeling of dependencies among embedding features.
Employing "squeeze-and-excitation" techniques, the FA block dynamically adjusts
the emphasis on individual features, enabling the network to concentrate more
on features that significantly contribute to the final classification. Building
upon FA, we introduce a dynamic "selection" mechanism called Selective Feature
Attention (SFA), which leverages a stacked BiGRU Inception structure. The SFA
block facilitates multi-scale semantic extraction by traversing different
stacked BiGRU layers, encouraging the network to selectively concentrate on
semantic information and embedding features across varying levels of
abstraction. Both the FA and SFA blocks offer a seamless integration capability
with various Siamese networks, showcasing a plug-and-play characteristic.
Experimental evaluations conducted across diverse text matching baselines and
benchmarks underscore the indispensability of modeling feature attention and
the superiority of the "selection" mechanism.
|
[
-0.5261344909667969,
-0.5480720400810242,
0.5390215516090393,
0.48696067929267883,
-0.5678448677062988,
-0.14553339779376984,
0.002718034666031599,
-0.5623152852058411,
0.8818476796150208,
0.8101506233215332,
-0.5432586669921875,
-0.14452697336673737,
-0.45584020018577576,
0.10889158397912979,
-0.4501681327819824,
0.9666720032691956,
-0.33020535111427307,
-0.3750271499156952,
-0.00614764541387558,
-0.3271232843399048,
-0.6628803610801697,
-0.30151650309562683,
-0.2569672465324402,
-0.01801745407283306,
0.9319736957550049,
0.13793183863162994,
0.5121737122535706,
0.778218686580658,
0.7977619767189026,
0.3005869388580322,
-0.4595538079738617,
-0.07810218632221222,
-0.6036653518676758,
0.28255295753479004,
-0.42349866032600403,
-0.557085394859314,
-0.3815889358520508,
0.0814601480960846,
0.8080493211746216,
0.43758445978164673,
0.27275681495666504,
-0.0358455590903759,
0.13162127137184143,
0.5810602903366089,
-0.9954178929328918,
-0.07021717727184296,
-1.088065266609192,
0.12367182224988937,
-0.2168453335762024,
-0.1553608626127243,
-0.3404482305049896,
0.11709973961114883,
0.3980345129966736,
-0.4827042520046234,
0.3255562484264374,
0.12403145432472229,
1.038188099861145,
0.4815646708011627,
-0.3448776304721832,
-0.22195924818515778,
-0.39309340715408325,
0.47974836826324463,
0.02707497961819172,
0.3586602509021759,
0.37924838066101074,
0.12183579802513123,
0.06006026268005371,
-0.45345577597618103,
-0.3453005254268646,
-0.285100519657135,
-0.06314357370138168,
0.16916130483150482,
0.22456763684749603,
0.13410323858261108,
0.3145931363105774,
0.6552928686141968,
-0.2465454638004303,
0.09036166965961456,
-0.052169069647789,
-0.07569878548383713,
0.34378644824028015,
-0.07809716463088989,
0.33165955543518066,
-0.08583839982748032,
-0.6276633143424988,
-0.09024573862552643,
-0.4783645272254944,
-0.2771298885345459,
0.163063183426857,
0.3132968544960022,
-0.14371365308761597,
0.7008964419364929,
-0.3193954825401306,
0.625191330909729,
0.22466154396533966,
0.3026913106441498,
0.10800570249557495,
-0.5389848351478577,
-0.45276886224746704,
0.31056758761405945,
0.6775598526000977,
-0.05540025606751442,
0.2557487487792969,
-0.028628690168261528,
-0.27925631403923035,
-0.093303382396698,
0.3802061378955841,
-0.8314496874809265,
-0.2535756230354309,
0.057825155556201935,
-0.4418414831161499,
-0.618667483329773,
0.05269892141222954,
-0.8792417049407959,
-0.444795697927475,
-0.05425660312175751,
0.511277973651886,
-0.05692117288708687,
-0.278484970331192,
0.026740843430161476,
-0.20691153407096863,
0.06715039163827896,
0.262350469827652,
-1.0866371393203735,
0.02119254879653454,
0.5471447110176086,
1.2074495553970337,
-0.25706103444099426,
0.009779473766684532,
-0.8064664006233215,
0.29487302899360657,
-0.28701552748680115,
0.9961411952972412,
-0.8311716318130493,
-0.05393338203430176,
-0.31348347663879395,
0.041710544377565384,
-0.4061287045478821,
-0.5467209815979004,
0.20732316374778748,
-0.6972764134407043,
-0.06435126811265945,
-0.026435574516654015,
-0.10891223698854446,
-0.17153103649616241,
0.20615118741989136,
-1.281960129737854,
1.0316660404205322,
0.14614522457122803,
-1.1185870170593262,
0.504124104976654,
-0.598961353302002,
-0.442865788936615,
0.0037150296848267317,
-0.08264660090208054,
-0.6662444472312927,
0.1340329796075821,
0.30169403553009033,
0.5558887124061584,
-0.07883190363645554,
0.03596390411257744,
-0.8278792500495911,
-0.45584022998809814,
0.37859785556793213,
-0.18415063619613647,
0.5142108798027039,
-0.12947018444538116,
-0.441642165184021,
0.35029953718185425,
-0.8358588814735413,
-0.38062533736228943,
0.12622076272964478,
-0.26157087087631226,
-0.5698599219322205,
0.021794820204377174,
0.1416543424129486,
0.251912385225296,
0.2512928545475006,
-0.3752560317516327,
0.04582599550485611,
-0.5045329928398132,
0.5773618817329407,
0.6444389820098877,
0.14858824014663696,
0.5290431380271912,
-0.053351446986198425,
0.5452219843864441,
0.2921169400215149,
-0.16054029762744904,
-0.3075217008590698,
-0.2758884131908417,
-0.6967048048973083,
-0.6959500908851624,
0.5755409002304077,
0.34384965896606445,
-0.63009113073349,
0.5571988224983215,
-0.3133947253227234,
-0.18579870462417603,
-0.6425406336784363,
0.3473919630050659,
0.13745369017124176,
0.026558341458439827,
0.04956427589058876,
-0.5799455642700195,
-0.40759435296058655,
-0.9387565851211548,
0.05624936521053314,
-0.1216229796409607,
0.13367049396038055,
0.4265003502368927,
0.32694539427757263,
0.14682729542255402,
0.9697247743606567,
-0.3651476204395294,
-0.7616330981254578,
-0.41664260625839233,
-0.23761236667633057,
-0.16384966671466827,
0.266469269990921,
0.6532548069953918,
-1.109041452407837,
-0.5062218308448792,
0.26634424924850464,
-0.17773596942424774,
0.0013592350296676159,
-0.1900280863046646,
-0.5715802311897278,
-0.1827625334262848,
0.39977896213531494,
-0.33914071321487427,
0.42475584149360657,
0.4720737040042877,
-0.16455186903476715,
0.31257495284080505,
0.21085800230503082,
-0.09040799736976624,
-1.1725553274154663,
0.3784179091453552,
0.3032761514186859,
-0.2552259564399719,
-0.2232404351234436,
0.13252972066402435,
0.1690693348646164,
-0.25950685143470764,
-0.31863436102867126,
0.6460301280021667,
-0.4906802773475647,
-0.2372685968875885,
-0.34258154034614563,
0.4377827048301697,
0.1298743039369583,
0.5351208448410034,
0.2923066318035126,
0.7804598808288574,
0.2143917977809906,
-0.4917756915092468,
0.15738442540168762,
0.17637556791305542,
-0.2722940444946289,
0.49137023091316223,
-0.7111954689025879,
0.06650768220424652,
0.1980765014886856,
0.1852252036333084,
-1.229116439819336,
-0.43605512380599976,
0.24469801783561707,
-0.22571547329425812,
0.3475334346294403,
-0.2791689932346344,
-0.4061054289340973,
-0.3756134510040283,
-0.4380508363246918,
0.39530906081199646,
-0.02156774513423443,
-0.4576277732849121,
0.6160601377487183,
0.3321833610534668,
-0.20717200636863708,
-0.40367555618286133,
-0.5688188076019287,
0.030207237228751183,
-0.10258254408836365,
-0.2885078191757202,
0.4062865674495697,
0.125883549451828,
0.2188045084476471,
0.1372014731168747,
-0.14696410298347473,
-0.3105885982513428,
0.4866480529308319,
0.016463052481412888,
0.16817674040794373,
-0.2817108631134033,
-0.033408403396606445,
0.0944516733288765,
-0.300405353307724,
-0.4043270945549011,
-0.3755814731121063,
0.4554837644100189,
0.5142243504524231,
-0.14772740006446838,
-0.6770636439323425,
0.49654334783554077,
0.9070790410041809,
-0.7614580988883972,
0.5911299586296082,
0.5895225405693054,
-0.38386890292167664,
-0.12098854780197144,
-0.5590617656707764,
-0.20440688729286194,
-0.45746853947639465,
0.7559245824813843,
-0.5331974029541016,
-1.0779718160629272,
0.42827603220939636,
0.3162968158721924,
-0.15453441441059113,
0.2108672708272934,
0.43788227438926697,
0.12118096649646759,
1.3727949857711792,
0.8326804041862488,
-0.397589772939682,
0.896864652633667,
0.18980209529399872,
0.1521359533071518,
-1.135635495185852,
0.053927693516016006,
-0.7654991745948792,
-0.6673149466514587,
-0.6613768935203552,
-0.2885657548904419,
0.005482939071953297,
0.14619584381580353,
0.05782594159245491,
0.4551389515399933,
-0.7955508828163147,
0.4104742407798767,
0.23870286345481873,
0.07110743224620819,
-0.008249902166426182,
0.19624848663806915,
-0.23582501709461212,
-0.22419235110282898,
-0.5230116248130798,
-0.12038516998291016,
0.6112815141677856,
0.47003671526908875,
0.6919704675674438,
-0.1310810148715973,
0.3866060674190521,
-0.15975426137447357,
0.3575771749019623,
-0.9333745837211609,
0.6337699294090271,
-0.39215287566185,
-0.4340074062347412,
-0.10223513096570969,
-0.4943901002407074,
-0.7986900210380554,
0.38654953241348267,
-0.04662865772843361,
-0.9072153568267822,
0.2805980145931244,
-0.011283478699624538,
-0.28353723883628845,
0.1786392331123352,
-0.6741765141487122,
0.8359217047691345,
0.09579305350780487,
-0.21607941389083862,
-0.20197387039661407,
-0.2919609844684601,
0.283377081155777,
-0.13897216320037842,
-0.3409757614135742,
-0.28333815932273865,
-0.35166385769844055,
0.5248751044273376,
-0.10063756257295609,
0.976757824420929,
0.09562710672616959,
-0.32746249437332153,
-0.09778085350990295,
-0.02975006215274334,
0.41511452198028564,
0.01154653262346983,
-0.04603583365678787,
-0.29675889015197754,
-0.40861672163009644,
-0.2812274098396301,
-0.7478185296058655,
0.7145147323608398,
-0.48342230916023254,
-0.5207324028015137,
-0.06240074336528778,
-0.41003236174583435,
0.046297360211610794,
0.33230480551719666,
0.029445763677358627,
0.39014819264411926,
0.03063203953206539,
0.3978393077850342,
0.8919311761856079,
0.2901149392127991,
0.2753216624259949,
0.19465148448944092,
-0.14503353834152222,
-0.6893340349197388,
1.1075620651245117,
0.1930372267961502,
0.24272751808166504,
0.8649911284446716,
-0.030822165310382843,
-0.28736817836761475,
-0.47207871079444885,
-0.46763819456100464,
0.3610384166240692,
-0.4414306879043579,
-0.10062098503112793,
-1.0435765981674194,
-0.30411526560783386,
-0.07378829270601273,
-0.18796378374099731,
-0.16268980503082275,
-0.2825842499732971,
-0.564038097858429,
0.029002172872424126,
0.29363813996315,
0.5867363214492798,
0.609221339225769,
0.11178404092788696,
-0.5892441272735596,
0.33436286449432373,
0.37593331933021545,
0.6324896812438965,
0.19214831292629242,
-0.32974478602409363,
-0.2687649428844452,
-0.4619886875152588,
-0.2599645256996155,
-0.9085605144500732,
-0.04529042914509773,
0.258952796459198,
0.5541085600852966,
0.535368025302887,
0.004938207101076841,
0.4125131666660309,
-0.2609696090221405,
0.4671463966369629,
0.2102072387933731,
-0.8473746180534363,
0.9427816867828369,
-0.23174014687538147,
0.26452401280403137,
0.6611895561218262,
0.3088972568511963,
-0.2799696922302246,
-0.7279747128486633,
-0.37248289585113525,
-0.8354438543319702,
0.9080072045326233,
0.23118987679481506,
0.11145250499248505,
-0.029538091272115707,
0.35729843378067017,
-0.1445034146308899,
0.16336524486541748,
-0.7220919132232666,
0.2747792899608612,
0.12497308850288391,
-0.5810022950172424,
0.23571579158306122,
-0.2790883481502533,
0.1932571530342102,
0.1644556075334549,
0.5300182700157166,
-0.3598839044570923,
0.2856525182723999,
0.28899946808815,
-0.1994543969631195,
0.12244361639022827,
-0.04599049314856529,
0.604860782623291,
0.2056644856929779,
-0.009264334104955196,
0.11896974593400955,
-0.07161775976419449,
-0.8543437719345093,
0.20908114314079285,
0.27874091267585754,
-0.42512694001197815,
-0.02134024165570736,
0.20699794590473175,
1.1698435544967651,
0.7388307452201843,
-0.3309153616428375,
0.3719925284385681,
0.06098988652229309,
0.03440198302268982,
0.35351529717445374,
0.48155778646469116,
0.023311937227845192,
0.02079777792096138,
0.28366464376449585,
-0.015241825953125954,
0.16628271341323853,
-0.2868177890777588,
0.3962385356426239,
0.3312865197658539,
-1.0270594358444214,
-0.2541321814060211,
0.7328116297721863,
0.4827774167060852,
-0.2386450618505478,
0.18993589282035828,
0.018500884994864464,
-0.7607858777046204,
0.8548610806465149,
0.2947099804878235,
1.0764811038970947,
-0.14991892874240875,
0.20142237842082977,
0.21526120603084564,
0.18132954835891724,
0.057571280747652054,
0.0657641813158989,
-0.4098394513130188,
-0.6068350672721863,
-0.44114673137664795,
-0.5361533164978027,
-0.1576002538204193,
0.054090145975351334,
-0.6864124536514282,
0.5727182030677795,
-0.5643702149391174,
-0.17722876369953156,
0.138522207736969,
0.16368748247623444,
-0.4589916467666626,
0.17434105277061462,
-0.02064473368227482,
0.948185920715332,
-0.6371963620185852,
0.6047994494438171,
0.995280921459198,
-0.5239589810371399,
-0.5053117275238037,
0.44086843729019165,
-0.1516796201467514,
-0.4792579412460327,
0.4171103239059448,
0.7537760734558105,
0.017882274463772774,
0.22071243822574615,
-0.3800457715988159,
-0.9206554889678955,
0.8657823204994202,
0.3213357627391815,
-0.6520625948905945,
0.12984302639961243,
-0.23938219249248505,
0.2307933121919632,
-0.5163514018058777,
0.4120129644870758,
0.36635732650756836,
0.20930840075016022,
0.10010083764791489,
-0.7761608958244324,
0.17929226160049438,
-0.2683922350406647,
0.3805984556674957,
0.3823699951171875,
-1.0623507499694824,
0.25432074069976807,
-0.02051481418311596,
-0.2025940865278244,
0.15498875081539154,
0.8807545900344849,
0.31657594442367554,
-0.03196004405617714,
0.7952495813369751,
0.5150332450866699,
0.5387700200080872,
0.01782805658876896,
0.7885621786117554,
-0.0806979238986969,
0.24118028581142426,
0.8534729480743408,
-0.7286588549613953,
1.0876902341842651,
0.34546348452568054,
0.04029504954814911,
0.3803466856479645,
0.8529303073883057,
0.018766198307275772,
0.7464549541473389,
0.10861103236675262,
-0.12291167676448822,
-0.3069799244403839,
-0.3043787479400635,
-0.16510476171970367,
0.43656814098358154,
0.3542748987674713,
-0.5151982307434082,
-0.044138096272945404,
0.20365853607654572,
-0.3457421362400055,
-0.15239837765693665,
-0.3044724464416504,
1.0119917392730713,
0.0347498282790184,
-0.5854334831237793,
0.2794446051120758,
-0.19489224255084991,
0.7091513276100159,
-0.6552096605300903,
0.07936263084411621,
-0.09346792101860046,
0.171468123793602,
0.07778868824243546,
-0.7788289189338684,
0.004340135958045721,
-0.19926817715168,
-0.6434647440910339,
0.10085954517126083,
0.8613425493240356,
-0.6753448843955994,
-0.3807932138442993,
0.5422690510749817,
-0.28027984499931335,
-0.19307704269886017,
-0.3336673974990845,
-0.6433537602424622,
0.44584694504737854,
0.11845426261425018,
-0.26382696628570557,
0.55457603931427,
0.6865339279174805,
-0.19682936370372772,
0.5852784514427185,
0.5243719220161438,
0.038713082671165466,
-0.1833522766828537,
0.25845688581466675,
0.8597941398620605,
-0.5139982104301453,
-1.0976333618164062,
-0.5660741329193115,
0.3764530122280121,
-0.348468542098999,
-0.40664249658584595,
0.10106708854436874,
0.3540027439594269,
0.5230206251144409,
0.26851746439933777,
0.6996704936027527,
0.2844957113265991,
0.18239228427410126,
-0.6029803156852722,
0.881718099117279,
-0.7192927598953247,
-0.04909883812069893,
-0.20741817355155945,
-1.2827218770980835,
-0.17340250313282013,
0.6534488797187805,
-0.09396146237850189,
0.25618863105773926,
0.7324049472808838,
0.6025599241256714,
-0.4166152775287628,
0.058013975620269775,
0.30690497159957886,
0.1305880844593048,
0.1855444610118866,
0.4432143568992615,
0.5447917580604553,
-0.24001272022724152,
0.5854882001876831,
0.009968587197363377,
-0.29177841544151306,
-0.6563082933425903,
-0.7694238424301147,
-0.9415297508239746,
-0.7149375677108765,
-0.5595253705978394,
-0.19599808752536774,
-0.029911302030086517,
0.522350549697876,
0.836094319820404,
-0.7851529121398926,
0.3473398685455322,
0.024984927847981453,
0.28385478258132935,
-0.13529053330421448,
-0.30775484442710876,
0.45391708612442017,
-0.45198917388916016,
-0.7413586974143982,
0.11005101352930069,
0.800451397895813,
0.18068447709083557,
-0.5006418824195862,
0.4748629033565521,
-0.2688365578651428,
-0.005863269325345755,
0.40923741459846497,
-0.06662336736917496,
-0.5347198843955994,
-0.2595118284225464,
0.10816221684217453,
-0.5083284378051758,
0.022475047037005424,
1.1655646562576294,
-0.5901790261268616,
0.3809480667114258,
0.6806138157844543,
1.0431255102157593,
0.5516135692596436,
-0.22336553037166595,
0.5377497673034668,
-0.8033282160758972,
0.4118814170360565,
0.04917081817984581,
0.2759082317352295,
0.426497220993042,
-0.5530863404273987,
0.33482125401496887,
0.4171074628829956,
-0.23276834189891815,
-0.8533731698989868,
0.0883970856666565,
-1.0279240608215332,
0.06627660244703293,
0.9989792108535767,
-0.09828487038612366,
-0.5129098892211914,
-0.3693866729736328,
-0.37162715196609497,
-0.08444695919752121,
-0.3382837772369385,
0.6028338074684143,
0.9232955574989319,
0.4478447735309601,
-0.4377322494983673,
-0.45070305466651917,
0.2670508325099945,
0.7077066898345947,
-0.4939679801464081,
0.07782147079706192,
0.06171158701181412,
0.02906682901084423,
0.22875258326530457,
0.5756596326828003,
-0.10995408147573471,
0.44757387042045593,
-0.20512676239013672,
-0.20395995676517487,
0.25096970796585083,
-0.5923801064491272,
-0.3134984076023102,
0.39744389057159424,
-0.16673807799816132,
-0.3557352125644684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00718v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00718v1
|
Can't say cant? Measuring and Reasoning of Dark Jargons in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-25T17:25:53 | 2024-04-25T17:25:53 |
Xu Ji, Jianyi Zhang, Ziyin Zhou, Zhangchi Zhao, Qianqian Qiao, Kaiying Han, Md Imran Hossen, Xiali Hei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Ensuring the resilience of Large Language Models (LLMs) against malicious
exploitation is paramount, with recent focus on mitigating offensive responses.
Yet, the understanding of cant or dark jargon remains unexplored. This paper
introduces a domain-specific Cant dataset and CantCounter evaluation framework,
employing Fine-Tuning, Co-Tuning, Data-Diffusion, and Data-Analysis stages.
Experiments reveal LLMs, including ChatGPT, are susceptible to cant bypassing
filters, with varying recognition accuracy influenced by question types,
setups, and prompt clues. Updated models exhibit higher acceptance rates for
cant queries. Moreover, LLM reactions differ across domains, e.g., reluctance
to engage in racism versus LGBT topics. These findings underscore LLMs'
understanding of cant and reflect training data characteristics and vendor
approaches to sensitive topics. Additionally, we assess LLMs' ability to
demonstrate reasoning capabilities. Access to our datasets and code is
available at https://github.com/cistineup/CantCounter.
|
[
-0.32435619831085205,
-0.7882372140884399,
0.488824725151062,
0.13486434519290924,
-0.3841099739074707,
0.318316787481308,
-0.5579711198806763,
-0.49219706654548645,
-0.14774617552757263,
0.6722120046615601,
-0.46184590458869934,
-0.6066040992736816,
-1.0098410844802856,
0.055619001388549805,
-0.5897881388664246,
1.1070462465286255,
0.007105621974915266,
-0.15455695986747742,
-0.09404313564300537,
-0.04636591300368309,
-0.5073203444480896,
-0.490166038274765,
-0.6804370284080505,
0.011175628751516342,
0.3132423460483551,
0.3048563301563263,
0.8146107792854309,
0.3724484145641327,
0.6211816072463989,
0.20930761098861694,
-0.11517923325300217,
0.013009730726480484,
-0.7492654919624329,
0.29449930787086487,
-0.17741896212100983,
-0.3290705382823944,
-0.3009655177593231,
-0.37400293350219727,
0.2653789222240448,
0.5983155965805054,
0.05821583420038223,
-0.13148744404315948,
0.1872139275074005,
0.1892542988061905,
-0.4971298277378082,
0.19237032532691956,
-1.1602214574813843,
-0.25351670384407043,
-0.24136905372142792,
0.16976065933704376,
-0.1621750146150589,
-0.23678119480609894,
0.17316403985023499,
-0.4824798107147217,
0.2878834009170532,
0.2736841142177582,
0.559844434261322,
0.17226767539978027,
-0.7296978235244751,
-0.4709853231906891,
-0.5830605626106262,
0.8227631449699402,
-0.7121350169181824,
0.43580272793769836,
0.5365399122238159,
0.5683985352516174,
-0.17506833374500275,
-0.5192229747772217,
-0.6092718243598938,
-0.6289738416671753,
-0.05477575957775116,
-0.11489053070545197,
-0.28866592049598694,
0.006680644117295742,
0.09117355942726135,
0.36389878392219543,
-0.5373761057853699,
0.023699123412370682,
-0.3666307032108307,
-0.3079955577850342,
0.7277927398681641,
0.07381632924079895,
0.27028417587280273,
-0.0950629785656929,
-0.5216582417488098,
0.08945809304714203,
-0.44538983702659607,
-0.3869640827178955,
0.1359994262456894,
0.47724801301956177,
-0.37695181369781494,
0.6347068548202515,
0.07268410921096802,
0.3536820709705353,
-0.07049200683832169,
0.05252905562520027,
-0.15551310777664185,
-0.476985901594162,
-0.23233623802661896,
-0.35514405369758606,
0.7942526340484619,
0.3579469919204712,
0.40372297167778015,
-0.6075873374938965,
-0.34187090396881104,
0.1419406682252884,
0.4681316912174225,
-0.5798918604850769,
-0.16579586267471313,
0.20353226363658905,
0.0387529656291008,
-0.1312895119190216,
-0.1283162534236908,
-0.7301884889602661,
-0.8703629374504089,
-0.07243922352790833,
0.32969892024993896,
-0.40026867389678955,
-0.47279202938079834,
0.4176744520664215,
-0.19592395424842834,
0.23259337246418,
0.329044908285141,
-0.5632500648498535,
0.7175732254981995,
0.7256184816360474,
0.45322510600090027,
-0.44268378615379333,
-0.06414683908224106,
-0.1434890776872635,
-0.2321685403585434,
-0.3773132562637329,
0.8181264400482178,
-0.633037805557251,
-0.5010377764701843,
-0.061094678938388824,
-0.08596085757017136,
-0.1337340623140335,
-0.7857694029808044,
0.7370325922966003,
-0.7707866430282593,
0.04719475284218788,
-0.20761080086231232,
-0.3634982705116272,
-0.20449240505695343,
0.485897958278656,
-0.44098594784736633,
0.8373338580131531,
-0.008004139177501202,
-0.817211925983429,
0.13146689534187317,
-0.43969500064849854,
-0.12810887396335602,
0.1356240063905716,
-0.2769300043582916,
-0.5504922866821289,
0.19696348905563354,
0.2140544205904007,
0.21911950409412384,
-0.5799305438995361,
0.5563876032829285,
-0.5668805837631226,
-0.005496894009411335,
0.4103647470474243,
-0.4069612920284271,
0.7422010898590088,
0.07625135034322739,
-0.30379897356033325,
0.13865461945533752,
-0.7423081398010254,
-0.08488698303699493,
0.453781396150589,
-0.17736856639385223,
-0.3047647476196289,
-0.03813125193119049,
0.03691820427775383,
-0.04865984618663788,
-0.0639319196343422,
-0.4732511341571808,
0.22141318023204803,
-0.19406285881996155,
0.27864310145378113,
0.4245648682117462,
0.04862196370959282,
0.1291668862104416,
-0.38047081232070923,
0.6770907640457153,
-0.08715013414621353,
-0.046848930418491364,
0.5126299858093262,
-0.4182138741016388,
-0.8823931813240051,
-0.21952512860298157,
0.09912419319152832,
0.6542143225669861,
-1.0218372344970703,
0.16136837005615234,
-0.30112817883491516,
-0.7481886744499207,
-0.11842327564954758,
-0.09085977077484131,
0.48954668641090393,
0.4874812364578247,
0.32738617062568665,
-0.2535426616668701,
-0.48321908712387085,
-0.8806841969490051,
-0.6171731352806091,
-0.259571373462677,
-0.13047422468662262,
0.4439470171928406,
0.6864719390869141,
-0.15640972554683685,
0.6613990068435669,
-0.33921146392822266,
0.015259700827300549,
-0.07630655169487,
-0.0819835215806961,
0.08126387000083923,
0.08571378886699677,
0.5466082096099854,
-0.7225308418273926,
-0.20386715233325958,
-0.2212277054786682,
-0.7047538161277771,
-0.2603050470352173,
0.1909521371126175,
0.188302680850029,
-0.34809038043022156,
0.49439820647239685,
-0.32543304562568665,
0.3667689859867096,
0.6131744384765625,
-0.5451131463050842,
0.9260479211807251,
0.17194853723049164,
0.2796527147293091,
-0.7778868675231934,
-0.1150142103433609,
-0.05584486201405525,
-0.19120144844055176,
-0.94359290599823,
0.13961204886436462,
0.0878773108124733,
-0.22412580251693726,
-0.767716646194458,
0.7012145519256592,
-0.3164372444152832,
0.12437741458415985,
-0.28684720396995544,
0.2640863060951233,
-0.1110355406999588,
0.211628720164299,
-0.08179932832717896,
1.0079487562179565,
0.783623993396759,
-0.7395051717758179,
0.2757294476032257,
0.24929749965667725,
-0.6920888423919678,
0.5213859677314758,
-0.5953062176704407,
0.41458213329315186,
0.14215512573719025,
0.003040287410840392,
-1.1657543182373047,
-0.37536635994911194,
0.4761263132095337,
-0.4388779401779175,
-0.10779794305562973,
-0.2338533103466034,
-0.4555567502975464,
-0.23681572079658508,
-0.22498644888401031,
0.49210697412490845,
-0.09439186751842499,
-0.306718111038208,
0.5946150422096252,
0.28874897956848145,
-0.25968900322914124,
-0.6798338294029236,
-0.9430682063102722,
0.45394450426101685,
-0.4898187816143036,
-0.7787918448448181,
0.16589955985546112,
-0.21058951318264008,
-0.5764464735984802,
-0.01267293095588684,
-0.19435560703277588,
-0.2756666839122772,
0.6568020582199097,
-0.046790968626737595,
0.18076688051223755,
-0.3245753347873688,
0.2199121117591858,
-0.09876677393913269,
0.0007557893404737115,
0.15893004834651947,
-0.2155781090259552,
0.35520458221435547,
-0.20484618842601776,
-0.5970349311828613,
0.07708389312028885,
0.2615016996860504,
0.3919335901737213,
0.08841965347528458,
0.7915412187576294,
0.11587287485599518,
-0.4268680214881897,
-0.30998679995536804,
-0.46092358231544495,
-0.04874732345342636,
-0.4131150245666504,
0.39605972170829773,
-0.32020097970962524,
-1.2058497667312622,
0.7006102800369263,
0.15428923070430756,
-0.007221733219921589,
0.4502379596233368,
0.6772575378417969,
0.3580301105976105,
0.34296199679374695,
0.5399678945541382,
0.23724929988384247,
0.2693840563297272,
0.2533746361732483,
0.3265361189842224,
-0.4721347391605377,
-0.09701340645551682,
-0.6695694327354431,
0.256041556596756,
-0.5369434356689453,
-0.6415526866912842,
0.42351171374320984,
0.12084819376468658,
-0.2834678590297699,
0.4266122281551361,
-0.14782513678073883,
0.7571294903755188,
-0.05275968089699745,
-0.09635934978723526,
0.5408409833908081,
-0.0339212529361248,
-0.05906079709529877,
0.30641159415245056,
-0.29899781942367554,
-0.763110876083374,
1.0161341428756714,
0.2235652208328247,
0.828140139579773,
0.48945462703704834,
0.3602060079574585,
0.5056683421134949,
0.2993265688419342,
-0.8664371371269226,
0.653554379940033,
-0.09951506555080414,
-0.8765876293182373,
-0.15745259821414948,
-0.26513591408729553,
-1.0236825942993164,
0.4061828851699829,
-0.09975948929786682,
-1.037432312965393,
0.12207838147878647,
0.024628831073641777,
-0.1860635131597519,
0.45822736620903015,
-0.8368836641311646,
0.6777055859565735,
-0.3885224759578705,
-0.03203612565994263,
0.07015923410654068,
-0.2577415704727173,
0.5695615410804749,
-0.41837745904922485,
0.31555867195129395,
-0.20263071358203888,
-0.3074384033679962,
0.5936887264251709,
-0.18514341115951538,
1.0624446868896484,
0.12986186146736145,
-0.38617050647735596,
0.27862313389778137,
0.38956502079963684,
0.4760018587112427,
-0.007892731577157974,
-0.2629685699939728,
0.49430322647094727,
-0.08963058143854141,
-0.3991663455963135,
-0.43787407875061035,
0.4297603964805603,
-0.6682029962539673,
-0.9347302913665771,
-0.20212581753730774,
-0.3668515980243683,
-0.5112797617912292,
0.1350816786289215,
0.10975988209247589,
-0.09128814190626144,
-0.29450324177742004,
0.15286032855510712,
0.5238136649131775,
-0.4509090483188629,
-0.024221835657954216,
0.5062676072120667,
-0.4675946831703186,
-0.3327201008796692,
0.8141011595726013,
0.10573869198560715,
0.5394498109817505,
0.08567139506340027,
0.272260457277298,
-0.18555232882499695,
-0.9314941167831421,
-0.28887879848480225,
0.3392307758331299,
-0.8787388205528259,
-0.32502496242523193,
-0.5163621306419373,
-0.4618906080722809,
-0.5096017122268677,
0.07081864774227142,
-0.18140460550785065,
-0.36809760332107544,
-0.08427150547504425,
-0.09724928438663483,
0.39851588010787964,
0.8758236169815063,
0.15977062284946442,
0.5305484533309937,
-0.3548891842365265,
0.420802503824234,
0.3846220076084137,
0.6962918043136597,
0.08549995720386505,
-0.7241731882095337,
0.06570447981357574,
-0.15666510164737701,
-0.22631651163101196,
-0.8308418393135071,
0.3328690826892853,
0.06085847318172455,
0.5847391486167908,
-0.04303860664367676,
0.30191609263420105,
0.3013995885848999,
-0.08656810224056244,
0.9410091042518616,
0.09880928695201874,
-0.9646357893943787,
0.28583788871765137,
-0.5296324491500854,
0.041810180991888046,
0.4149394631385803,
0.4378404915332794,
-0.7681724429130554,
-0.6858755946159363,
-0.4637851119041443,
-0.8272713422775269,
0.754548192024231,
0.31729820370674133,
0.25491124391555786,
-0.12677086889743805,
0.06122753769159317,
0.43625766038894653,
0.2484159767627716,
-0.7824870347976685,
-0.4111925959587097,
-0.1858939230442047,
0.1023588702082634,
-0.005844258703291416,
-0.30060192942619324,
-0.2575664222240448,
0.3232537806034088,
0.4485216736793518,
-0.06058637052774429,
0.33364802598953247,
-0.2178448587656021,
-0.32599928975105286,
0.1986454576253891,
0.7605876326560974,
0.5724028944969177,
0.7072098255157471,
-0.09282158315181732,
0.3416394293308258,
0.36308279633522034,
-0.5216777324676514,
0.04346086084842682,
0.09345534443855286,
0.00662817619740963,
-0.4257538914680481,
0.5145306587219238,
0.9858270883560181,
-0.1507517397403717,
-0.6685128211975098,
0.6733514070510864,
-0.4076915979385376,
-0.328935444355011,
-0.15580421686172485,
0.20305345952510834,
0.16655774414539337,
0.3124103844165802,
0.40070948004722595,
-0.062378596514463425,
-0.14621038734912872,
-0.24583502113819122,
0.09091627597808838,
0.2903675138950348,
-0.2927033305168152,
-0.2077818065881729,
0.5161447525024414,
0.05528499558568001,
-0.41785311698913574,
0.5087463855743408,
-0.01977532170712948,
-0.5113643407821655,
0.6680007576942444,
0.48001691699028015,
0.8728421330451965,
0.06982434540987015,
-0.10905470699071884,
0.0021690172143280506,
0.3677271902561188,
0.36705759167671204,
0.16950607299804688,
0.013563457876443863,
-0.9973985552787781,
-0.3822815418243408,
-0.34544774889945984,
-0.5301858186721802,
0.6232185363769531,
-0.4618757963180542,
0.19233471155166626,
-0.6467193961143494,
-0.30860015749931335,
-0.022122997790575027,
-0.1781432181596756,
-0.8761022686958313,
0.09261468052864075,
0.3370356261730194,
1.1348776817321777,
-0.9822790622711182,
0.449931800365448,
0.28386062383651733,
-0.17090469598770142,
-0.4919047951698303,
0.3144782483577728,
0.35146012902259827,
-1.0948126316070557,
0.49576535820961,
-0.09129504859447479,
-0.2650218605995178,
-0.3444047272205353,
-0.7098008394241333,
-0.7052268385887146,
0.7321518063545227,
0.7619597315788269,
-0.7068097591400146,
0.2732185125350952,
0.35183045268058777,
0.5703028440475464,
-0.1754649579524994,
0.20363427698612213,
0.7330878376960754,
0.4618074297904968,
-0.0051318081095814705,
-1.1840909719467163,
0.008902017958462238,
-0.0028278797399252653,
-0.3231527805328369,
-0.1924223005771637,
-0.6060182452201843,
0.32161745429039,
-0.1699264794588089,
-0.43915706872940063,
-0.03511366248130798,
0.3990040719509125,
0.27541881799697876,
0.2588656544685364,
0.5508767366409302,
0.23862825334072113,
0.8656083941459656,
-0.19527602195739746,
1.2044563293457031,
0.04845454916357994,
0.15816429257392883,
1.1676775217056274,
-0.15219537913799286,
0.4629828929901123,
0.19413770735263824,
-0.12558437883853912,
0.2494817078113556,
0.47073447704315186,
-0.005468078888952732,
0.3403484523296356,
0.5941734910011292,
-0.42973169684410095,
-0.4510514438152313,
-0.342367559671402,
-0.28793865442276,
0.39091479778289795,
0.5253297090530396,
-0.14441648125648499,
-0.5281499624252319,
0.20056749880313873,
0.2601833939552307,
0.033122748136520386,
-0.22756892442703247,
0.8045762181282043,
0.2972937524318695,
-0.4794864356517792,
0.8477714657783508,
-0.034650810062885284,
0.679142951965332,
-0.5717806816101074,
0.4051186442375183,
-0.3449574410915375,
-0.003009528387337923,
-0.08272525668144226,
-1.0020709037780762,
0.47949889302253723,
0.3906068801879883,
-0.015323888510465622,
0.034142132848501205,
0.8518556356430054,
-0.25650280714035034,
-0.3491556942462921,
0.5691486597061157,
0.7925923466682434,
0.3595772087574005,
-0.11670243740081787,
-0.9189862608909607,
0.3244490623474121,
-0.08480992913246155,
-0.2574101388454437,
0.3970608711242676,
0.6583417654037476,
-0.38971081376075745,
0.9708967804908752,
0.25181636214256287,
0.196271613240242,
0.063687264919281,
0.3567165434360504,
1.080193042755127,
-0.5807867050170898,
0.016848117113113403,
-0.8005591034889221,
0.4090478718280792,
0.1465861201286316,
-0.12551121413707733,
0.7904585003852844,
0.394055038690567,
0.9752903580665588,
0.0006457326817326248,
1.0192978382110596,
0.015606445260345936,
0.6046807765960693,
-0.2753825783729553,
0.619350790977478,
-0.36837875843048096,
0.5548739433288574,
-0.0965816006064415,
-0.637985348701477,
-0.5767174959182739,
0.1602332442998886,
-0.9992725253105164,
0.11584526300430298,
0.5265118479728699,
1.0879971981048584,
-0.20719613134860992,
-0.09215161949396133,
0.6026263236999512,
0.33512553572654724,
0.5172437429428101,
0.32556647062301636,
1.0413906574249268,
-0.3896033763885498,
0.9004701972007751,
0.19766810536384583,
0.09275227785110474,
-0.05416126549243927,
-1.1417219638824463,
-0.8354628086090088,
-0.2916933000087738,
-0.3634951114654541,
-0.5524538159370422,
0.27019914984703064,
0.6622486710548401,
0.4462946951389313,
-1.0973362922668457,
-0.1910288780927658,
0.17337296903133392,
0.32259172201156616,
-0.04112786799669266,
-0.18562109768390656,
0.3765963613986969,
-0.2236914336681366,
-0.42021843791007996,
0.4474169909954071,
0.09796211868524551,
0.1740722507238388,
-0.09626975655555725,
0.12916842103004456,
0.040477920323610306,
0.3782271146774292,
0.4410116374492645,
0.12611570954322815,
-0.8177663683891296,
-0.5448389649391174,
-0.14942258596420288,
-0.05008086562156677,
0.17492887377738953,
0.7255197167396545,
-0.4589722156524658,
0.44073525071144104,
0.14716921746730804,
0.9361996650695801,
0.20889918506145477,
-0.20116619765758514,
0.3129580020904541,
-0.7522160410881042,
-0.34898266196250916,
0.45027536153793335,
0.22055955231189728,
0.5593807101249695,
-0.13828785717487335,
0.3949119746685028,
0.3372785151004791,
-0.42704400420188904,
-0.7061074376106262,
0.3104698359966278,
-1.041974663734436,
-0.27389708161354065,
1.4098788499832153,
-0.1871175467967987,
-0.27721771597862244,
-0.659103274345398,
-0.183548241853714,
0.13290944695472717,
-0.38740336894989014,
0.9777652621269226,
0.8396911025047302,
0.1257600337266922,
-0.19112177193164825,
-0.492391973733902,
0.3594001531600952,
0.1069452241063118,
-0.7804630994796753,
0.6742467880249023,
0.3203420639038086,
0.5704564452171326,
-0.07476150244474411,
0.6143376231193542,
-0.09744229912757874,
0.010129274800419807,
0.039679497480392456,
-0.3444482684135437,
-0.06277676671743393,
-0.06192087382078171,
-0.33805617690086365,
0.21701772511005402,
0.34712550044059753,
0.15096868574619293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00717v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00717v1
|
Exploring News Summarization and Enrichment in a Highly Resource-Scarce Indian Language: A Case Study of Mizo
| 2024-04-25T17:23:04 | 2024-04-25T17:23:04 |
Abhinaba Bala, Ashok Urlana, Rahul Mishra, Parameswari Krishnamurthy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Obtaining sufficient information in one's mother tongue is crucial for
satisfying the information needs of the users. While high-resource languages
have abundant online resources, the situation is less than ideal for very
low-resource languages. Moreover, the insufficient reporting of vital national
and international events continues to be a worry, especially in languages with
scarce resources, like \textbf{Mizo}. In this paper, we conduct a study to
investigate the effectiveness of a simple methodology designed to generate a
holistic summary for Mizo news articles, which leverages English-language news
to supplement and enhance the information related to the corresponding news
events. Furthermore, we make available 500 Mizo news articles and corresponding
enriched holistic summaries. Human evaluation confirms that our approach
significantly enhances the information coverage of Mizo news articles. The mizo
dataset and code can be accessed at
\url{https://github.com/barvin04/mizo_enrichment
|
[
-0.4489987790584564,
-0.5428667664527893,
0.0915176272392273,
0.37890616059303284,
-0.7361648082733154,
0.4142380654811859,
-0.5103036165237427,
-0.5980355739593506,
0.6226099729537964,
0.11356351524591446,
-0.489335834980011,
-0.1962805986404419,
-0.38328883051872253,
0.17121951282024384,
-0.19800350069999695,
1.223482608795166,
0.13582488894462585,
-0.016852542757987976,
0.07647872716188431,
-0.2206316888332367,
-0.3125537633895874,
-0.013699561357498169,
-0.28651896119117737,
-0.21270719170570374,
0.29240280389785767,
0.6166611313819885,
0.3610515892505646,
0.4594055414199829,
0.5888990163803101,
0.18761588633060455,
-0.21892572939395905,
0.5545422434806824,
-0.42966848611831665,
0.20732074975967407,
-0.19295500218868256,
-0.3191480338573456,
-0.39935562014579773,
-0.26740261912345886,
0.5872917175292969,
0.5899927020072937,
-0.2954370975494385,
0.26930007338523865,
0.2712422013282776,
0.7332332730293274,
-0.9313036799430847,
0.1689389944076538,
-0.3540290296077728,
-0.09193675220012665,
-0.6450697779655457,
-0.3953554630279541,
-0.1339632272720337,
-0.39075222611427307,
-0.1443602591753006,
-0.5976146459579468,
0.14349307119846344,
-0.3228328227996826,
0.7762067317962646,
0.1233779564499855,
-0.2547007203102112,
-0.30345550179481506,
-0.8768400549888611,
0.6549831032752991,
-0.5107555985450745,
0.11014088988304138,
0.4221375286579132,
0.22317811846733093,
0.2952307462692261,
-0.08665916323661804,
-0.43237918615341187,
0.021653655916452408,
-0.0356617346405983,
0.43349936604499817,
-0.09058718383312225,
-0.23583585023880005,
0.00011183934839209542,
0.7487496137619019,
-0.29093024134635925,
-0.3302483856678009,
-0.6731372475624084,
-0.17109426856040955,
0.7333133816719055,
0.24120694398880005,
0.7958224415779114,
-0.4884801208972931,
-0.21426217257976532,
-0.04472169652581215,
-0.7758628129959106,
0.06303673982620239,
0.6439777612686157,
0.48974698781967163,
-0.4871063828468323,
0.6918819546699524,
-0.7798205614089966,
0.989841103553772,
-0.26933035254478455,
-0.41333088278770447,
0.3569338917732239,
-0.900475800037384,
0.18022842705249786,
0.2682086229324341,
0.6496103405952454,
0.4910624325275421,
0.18821042776107788,
-0.01995648257434368,
0.031188741326332092,
-0.14020419120788574,
-0.0810469388961792,
-0.6769111752510071,
0.4748271405696869,
0.04004982113838196,
-0.4565378725528717,
-0.1803750842809677,
0.014713438227772713,
-1.14120352268219,
-0.35180163383483887,
0.06346477568149567,
0.16750898957252502,
-0.2259116768836975,
-0.5040558576583862,
0.1682976931333542,
-0.2653818130493164,
0.35429301857948303,
0.18395745754241943,
-1.075635552406311,
-0.25715959072113037,
0.3670106530189514,
1.0714386701583862,
0.13094696402549744,
-0.1960098296403885,
-0.33620327711105347,
0.3517289459705353,
-0.1763092428445816,
0.9366965889930725,
-0.5172130465507507,
-0.7794729471206665,
-0.07360923290252686,
-0.4591549038887024,
0.330405056476593,
-0.3453420102596283,
0.7215407490730286,
-0.25474813580513,
0.0029935739003121853,
-0.486087828874588,
-0.02815338410437107,
0.04497675970196724,
0.3087960183620453,
-0.5101858377456665,
0.7413902878761292,
0.3615908622741699,
-0.770315408706665,
0.3078877627849579,
-0.6079303026199341,
-0.9784185290336609,
0.07342316210269928,
-0.13853682577610016,
-0.18046867847442627,
0.2799651324748993,
0.4202713072299957,
0.21934233605861664,
-0.13445863127708435,
0.04340565204620361,
0.1248946413397789,
-0.22854149341583252,
-0.1625872254371643,
-0.22203707695007324,
0.8868736624717712,
0.2993631064891815,
-0.14363956451416016,
-0.2562355399131775,
-0.8657413721084595,
-0.21955616772174835,
0.05852115526795387,
-0.5199401378631592,
-0.7278086543083191,
-0.024076160043478012,
-0.060359880328178406,
0.03837032988667488,
0.3143840432167053,
-0.813384473323822,
0.401803195476532,
-0.764315664768219,
0.27393680810928345,
0.12837901711463928,
0.3904363811016083,
0.46194761991500854,
-0.23203854262828827,
0.511090874671936,
-0.1152147576212883,
0.2702859938144684,
-0.48056814074516296,
-0.27879828214645386,
-0.6022686958312988,
-0.15770047903060913,
0.39854609966278076,
0.42039307951927185,
-0.8578382134437561,
0.13231602311134338,
-0.525879979133606,
-0.36982354521751404,
-0.7344997525215149,
0.3279277980327606,
0.2741878032684326,
0.4069325923919678,
0.2736080288887024,
-0.18634258210659027,
-0.8322678208351135,
-1.0996888875961304,
-0.26731058955192566,
0.15543749928474426,
0.014013986103236675,
-0.13459299504756927,
-0.04759058728814125,
-0.026564983651041985,
1.1967636346817017,
-0.34494832158088684,
-0.22065401077270508,
-0.6475763916969299,
0.19691979885101318,
0.1488083004951477,
0.2208361029624939,
0.4823032021522522,
-0.9122244715690613,
-0.503479540348053,
0.18885651230812073,
-0.5514543652534485,
-0.1314111351966858,
-0.11586008220911026,
-0.1981154978275299,
-0.16332758963108063,
0.060316745191812515,
-0.5272508859634399,
0.5659908652305603,
0.4662998616695404,
-0.11040685325860977,
0.29636985063552856,
-0.14939135313034058,
0.23279595375061035,
-1.5131350755691528,
-0.10200837254524231,
-0.13166987895965576,
-0.07136745750904083,
-0.4582321345806122,
0.03706354647874832,
-0.09604725241661072,
-0.1767948716878891,
-0.20860686898231506,
0.6496151089668274,
-0.8158050179481506,
-0.2009819895029068,
-0.5852043628692627,
0.3584756553173065,
0.06648008525371552,
0.3089836537837982,
-0.13772262632846832,
1.1484968662261963,
0.2810092568397522,
-0.5333860516548157,
0.16196182370185852,
0.2858744263648987,
-0.5762203931808472,
0.3032395839691162,
-0.46340399980545044,
-0.47880733013153076,
-0.08741949498653412,
-0.21373805403709412,
-0.6414436101913452,
-0.5096179246902466,
0.2872346341609955,
-0.7126355767250061,
0.15093906223773956,
-0.018870310857892036,
-0.45495277643203735,
0.1523372083902359,
-0.4828023910522461,
0.284237265586853,
0.44780296087265015,
-0.39646223187446594,
0.6285359859466553,
0.6294031143188477,
-0.6144263744354248,
-0.6460930109024048,
-0.9411746263504028,
0.32497063279151917,
-0.056949857622385025,
-0.24205787479877472,
0.13421788811683655,
-0.08965717256069183,
-0.5550980567932129,
0.2044460028409958,
-0.11576734483242035,
-0.0044814711436629295,
0.14885252714157104,
-0.09795067459344864,
0.3030475378036499,
-0.14478854835033417,
0.012590471655130386,
0.3509352207183838,
-0.021321887150406837,
-0.2275051772594452,
0.37704601883888245,
0.6133968234062195,
-0.18237455189228058,
-0.3425527513027191,
-0.4715855121612549,
0.6438642740249634,
0.5483385324478149,
-0.720669150352478,
0.7361713647842407,
0.5718988180160522,
-0.30996230244636536,
0.0034845112822949886,
-0.3951755464076996,
-0.013382341712713242,
-0.3244389593601227,
0.226045161485672,
0.08795730769634247,
-0.4035167396068573,
0.5719140768051147,
0.15669886767864227,
-0.11791346967220306,
0.6621495485305786,
0.6189822554588318,
0.13187076151371002,
1.164245843887329,
0.55958092212677,
-0.4375206530094147,
0.7527358531951904,
-0.29049015045166016,
0.46981871128082275,
-1.0876294374465942,
-0.3529319167137146,
-0.49008169770240784,
-0.07900379598140717,
-0.4622795879840851,
-0.09291569143533707,
0.6024980545043945,
0.07130797952413559,
0.6150215864181519,
-0.033926162868738174,
-0.24203075468540192,
0.7378841042518616,
0.4604465961456299,
0.255042165517807,
0.6695516705513,
0.22368866205215454,
0.36271706223487854,
0.17674706876277924,
-0.6949593424797058,
-0.3722470700740814,
0.7804182171821594,
-0.21923944354057312,
0.7118473649024963,
0.25839436054229736,
0.676506757736206,
0.400107204914093,
0.41284558176994324,
-0.6515089273452759,
0.1644820123910904,
0.18010294437408447,
-0.5729650259017944,
-0.2523062229156494,
-0.30188292264938354,
-0.7654275298118591,
0.2661917805671692,
-0.346194326877594,
-0.43098846077919006,
0.37231501936912537,
-0.07850468903779984,
-0.6759195923805237,
0.0822492390871048,
-0.617260217666626,
0.10588011890649796,
-0.2813166379928589,
-0.6499179601669312,
-0.44768235087394714,
-0.6236156821250916,
0.49410712718963623,
0.27863597869873047,
0.6096592545509338,
-0.09109626710414886,
-0.08142906427383423,
0.46603673696517944,
-0.326747864484787,
0.8056617975234985,
0.029275504872202873,
-0.0392916277050972,
0.42320194840431213,
-0.4479343593120575,
0.1149565726518631,
0.2275688350200653,
-0.030993690714240074,
0.03181970492005348,
-0.5822341442108154,
-0.7803197503089905,
-0.505375325679779,
0.3784065544605255,
-0.5400739908218384,
-0.46882855892181396,
-0.11324409395456314,
-0.6568783521652222,
-0.5102302432060242,
0.30555260181427,
0.5897703766822815,
0.7984405755996704,
-0.030536901205778122,
0.43751806020736694,
0.4450831115245819,
0.008701124228537083,
0.6883098483085632,
0.3346746563911438,
0.011391576379537582,
-0.24541166424751282,
0.9256786704063416,
0.26023679971694946,
-0.06398462504148483,
0.2543022930622101,
0.28291454911231995,
0.009894215501844883,
-0.6120868921279907,
-0.8563746213912964,
0.07672250270843506,
-0.2714700698852539,
-0.4779452979564667,
-0.5120126605033875,
-0.18315792083740234,
-0.21774470806121826,
-0.0333823524415493,
-0.2310444861650467,
-0.4675891697406769,
0.1401299387216568,
-0.38260185718536377,
0.06165861710906029,
0.5901345014572144,
-0.2517475485801697,
0.38336238265037537,
-1.2439630031585693,
0.04067732393741608,
0.18982554972171783,
0.27362480759620667,
0.057172395288944244,
-0.08110842108726501,
-0.7718733549118042,
0.30916455388069153,
-0.20639930665493011,
-1.0220197439193726,
0.26463782787323,
0.2567022144794464,
0.8834719657897949,
0.7934617400169373,
0.175800621509552,
0.6644086837768555,
-0.003802613355219364,
0.7912911772727966,
-0.050907332450151443,
-0.9140690565109253,
1.0071958303451538,
-0.8441742062568665,
0.2184486836194992,
0.8561058640480042,
0.23935799300670624,
-0.336593359708786,
-0.5648085474967957,
-0.48403218388557434,
-1.1302989721298218,
0.4085187315940857,
0.2332099974155426,
0.478809118270874,
-0.17714963853359222,
0.3513628840446472,
0.188480943441391,
0.32077011466026306,
-0.5631232857704163,
0.007795554585754871,
-0.003830794943496585,
-0.24277332425117493,
-0.08482564240694046,
-0.5875837802886963,
0.044177256524562836,
-0.17297294735908508,
0.7243438959121704,
0.2967261075973511,
-0.16156722605228424,
0.35264262557029724,
-0.4706953465938568,
0.13055236637592316,
0.45577237010002136,
0.9186841249465942,
0.7752312421798706,
-0.06198171153664589,
-0.008675274439156055,
-0.04316681623458862,
-0.49245426058769226,
-0.26453548669815063,
-0.05134538933634758,
-0.31282493472099304,
0.18680651485919952,
0.7229934334754944,
0.7207828164100647,
0.33475807309150696,
-1.0839018821716309,
0.4557082951068878,
-0.07480286806821823,
0.29755550622940063,
0.15614046156406403,
0.13006481528282166,
-0.0010433467105031013,
0.25408434867858887,
0.5181511640548706,
-0.13349983096122742,
0.509873628616333,
-0.7556692957878113,
-0.14184823632240295,
0.3502432107925415,
0.121098592877388,
-0.31426912546157837,
0.33420103788375854,
0.536545991897583,
-0.10337801277637482,
0.5287212133407593,
-0.3586527705192566,
-0.5116127133369446,
0.5539166927337646,
0.5176231861114502,
0.4842377305030823,
-0.40269234776496887,
0.2870376408100128,
0.5524905323982239,
0.35063081979751587,
0.030449863523244858,
0.2352479249238968,
-0.49203282594680786,
-0.6721034049987793,
-0.4692710041999817,
-0.4863569438457489,
-0.41009721159935,
-0.24412445724010468,
-1.0186489820480347,
0.07004191726446152,
-0.047882579267024994,
-0.1305723637342453,
-0.38671937584877014,
0.24662628769874573,
-0.07853425294160843,
-0.13645629584789276,
0.046171654015779495,
0.8448266983032227,
-0.9508694410324097,
0.4496115446090698,
0.6064798831939697,
-0.6815678477287292,
-0.5456583499908447,
0.2609948515892029,
-0.20714201033115387,
-0.6737309694290161,
0.19953091442584991,
-0.22396504878997803,
-0.364708811044693,
-0.09623150527477264,
-0.07497783750295639,
-0.5523311495780945,
0.8404414057731628,
0.3416634202003479,
-0.3013536334037781,
0.16928549110889435,
-0.10364443063735962,
0.6521210074424744,
-0.31921640038490295,
-0.10726988315582275,
0.3673090934753418,
0.568043053150177,
-0.16499526798725128,
-0.535117506980896,
-0.42669981718063354,
-0.5988080501556396,
-0.17115052044391632,
0.41860052943229675,
-0.8969782590866089,
0.7639307975769043,
-0.4935971200466156,
-0.3853161036968231,
-0.13647690415382385,
0.6476160287857056,
-0.26985621452331543,
0.3657160699367523,
0.2257748246192932,
0.42970752716064453,
0.7033635973930359,
0.02171175554394722,
1.3631376028060913,
-0.6563926935195923,
0.45062804222106934,
1.2029657363891602,
-0.013762200251221657,
0.8383532762527466,
0.447811096906662,
-0.02895677648484707,
0.4194071590900421,
0.6090402603149414,
0.2261279821395874,
0.7178009748458862,
-0.32396209239959717,
-0.6481501460075378,
-0.10075972974300385,
-0.6552465558052063,
-0.5840779542922974,
0.838167130947113,
0.36802563071250916,
0.010911709628999233,
-0.7740644812583923,
0.3095976412296295,
0.13970544934272766,
0.1585138440132141,
-0.6038543581962585,
0.6456829905509949,
-0.3929003179073334,
-0.5186253190040588,
-0.06134277954697609,
0.15131741762161255,
0.5784403681755066,
-0.5993650555610657,
0.06104340776801109,
-0.6987483501434326,
-0.10238755494356155,
-0.32480525970458984,
-0.5326374173164368,
0.9190225601196289,
0.3658064901828766,
-0.3370227813720703,
-0.15312379598617554,
0.7867302298545837,
-0.6033302545547485,
-0.4907817244529724,
0.062340158969163895,
0.8225637078285217,
-0.21748703718185425,
0.059484392404556274,
0.06235608458518982,
0.10185576230287552,
-0.024381693452596664,
-0.13413307070732117,
0.38168230652809143,
0.14613190293312073,
0.028912805020809174,
0.38937219977378845,
0.5937914848327637,
0.3968456983566284,
-0.07862772047519684,
0.009644152596592903,
0.6567202210426331,
-0.3757023513317108,
-0.8160989880561829,
-1.1478296518325806,
0.4120995104312897,
-0.45715248584747314,
-0.3666323125362396,
1.0598636865615845,
1.0981794595718384,
0.7689678072929382,
0.026647651568055153,
1.01554274559021,
-0.11791489273309708,
0.48558667302131653,
-0.640637218952179,
0.828032910823822,
-0.7533907890319824,
0.17378568649291992,
0.17156144976615906,
-0.5998168587684631,
-0.08511114865541458,
0.6455762982368469,
-0.08934682607650757,
-0.08626339584589005,
0.21313026547431946,
0.406552791595459,
0.06851865351200104,
-0.011512280441820621,
0.07417117804288864,
0.015842432156205177,
-0.3028596341609955,
0.21190644800662994,
1.0991952419281006,
-0.02959425374865532,
0.44042959809303284,
-0.3556739389896393,
-0.40777137875556946,
-0.4923601746559143,
-0.7066347002983093,
-0.5669706463813782,
-0.6775143146514893,
0.05412275716662407,
-0.015692200511693954,
0.10441016405820847,
1.034590721130371,
0.586049497127533,
-0.5653618574142456,
-0.09321043640375137,
0.36685988306999207,
0.43023914098739624,
0.07436331361532211,
-0.2184639871120453,
0.10636531561613083,
-0.3412298560142517,
-0.9749469757080078,
0.4006197452545166,
0.5909455418586731,
-0.14099673926830292,
-0.12469124048948288,
0.4057628810405731,
-0.20499373972415924,
-0.03772873803973198,
0.7223509550094604,
0.38414913415908813,
-0.12647373974323273,
-0.04215701296925545,
-0.17880040407180786,
-0.013260881416499615,
0.30318117141723633,
1.1490488052368164,
-0.4774213135242462,
0.5115389823913574,
0.6504064202308655,
0.7375456094741821,
0.2614244222640991,
0.25742968916893005,
0.3728979527950287,
-0.9998299479484558,
0.3378942906856537,
-0.0106593556702137,
0.45315247774124146,
0.48853451013565063,
-0.6383859515190125,
0.5512384176254272,
0.22786401212215424,
0.09270929545164108,
-0.8471582531929016,
0.10482165217399597,
-0.9762393236160278,
-0.1081811860203743,
1.0929187536239624,
0.3559016287326813,
-0.23108473420143127,
0.009664466604590416,
-0.2791423797607422,
0.410748153924942,
-0.29995763301849365,
0.9700251817703247,
0.9141337275505066,
-0.25996989011764526,
-0.03202540799975395,
-0.7302311658859253,
0.11923787742853165,
-0.10435672104358673,
-1.1437197923660278,
0.019619351252913475,
0.3569820523262024,
0.2186787873506546,
0.4626491069793701,
0.7459419965744019,
-0.2852434515953064,
0.30750346183776855,
-0.050244349986314774,
0.1746515929698944,
-0.2225671261548996,
-0.3117695450782776,
-0.2855203449726105,
0.05681174620985985,
-0.13292478024959564,
-0.41168367862701416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16767v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16767v2
|
REBEL: Reinforcement Learning via Regressing Relative Rewards
| 2024-04-25T17:20:45 | 2024-05-29T15:52:20 |
Zhaolin Gao, Jonathan D. Chang, Wenhao Zhan, Owen Oertell, Gokul Swamy, Kianté Brantley, Thorsten Joachims, J. Andrew Bagnell, Jason D. Lee, Wen Sun
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
While originally developed for continuous control problems, Proximal Policy
Optimization (PPO) has emerged as the work-horse of a variety of reinforcement
learning (RL) applications, including the fine-tuning of generative models.
Unfortunately, PPO requires multiple heuristics to enable stable convergence
(e.g. value networks, clipping), and is notorious for its sensitivity to the
precise implementation of these components. In response, we take a step back
and ask what a minimalist RL algorithm for the era of generative models would
look like. We propose REBEL, an algorithm that cleanly reduces the problem of
policy optimization to regressing the relative reward between two completions
to a prompt in terms of the policy, enabling strikingly lightweight
implementation. In theory, we prove that fundamental RL algorithms like Natural
Policy Gradient can be seen as variants of REBEL, which allows us to match the
strongest known theoretical guarantees in terms of convergence and sample
complexity in the RL literature. REBEL can also cleanly incorporate offline
data and be extended to handle the intransitive preferences we frequently see
in practice. Empirically, we find that REBEL provides a unified approach to
language modeling and image generation with stronger or similar performance as
PPO and DPO, all while being simpler to implement and more computationally
efficient than PPO. When fine-tuning Llama-3-8B-Instruct, REBEL achieves strong
performance in AlpacaEval 2.0, MT-Bench, and Open LLM Leaderboard.
|
[
-0.14612527191638947,
-0.22067701816558838,
0.3698998689651489,
0.14731860160827637,
-0.09063490480184555,
0.3756759464740753,
-0.45617830753326416,
0.12666168808937073,
0.28385472297668457,
0.3287286162376404,
-0.8733956217765808,
-0.43478530645370483,
-0.5413451790809631,
-0.1837223768234253,
0.16173513233661652,
1.2155160903930664,
-0.25557252764701843,
-0.14949817955493927,
0.25285056233406067,
-0.3284836411476135,
-0.3747037351131439,
-0.20654287934303284,
-0.7106196284294128,
-0.30557486414909363,
0.9689300656318665,
0.7825720310211182,
0.5939254760742188,
0.6090834736824036,
0.46134504675865173,
0.31336045265197754,
-0.08446277678012848,
0.3739725351333618,
-0.8578100800514221,
-0.03450695052742958,
-0.10042382776737213,
-0.6242751479148865,
0.07308539748191833,
-0.016873352229595184,
0.7999940514564514,
0.008184445090591908,
-0.2991250455379486,
-0.09689067304134369,
0.009232553653419018,
0.8656712174415588,
-0.9421541094779968,
0.10171950608491898,
-0.5447809100151062,
0.05008020997047424,
0.08636010438203812,
-0.005273432470858097,
-0.4319130480289459,
-0.6347460746765137,
-0.4448741674423218,
-0.7555009722709656,
0.25626298785209656,
-0.1358301341533661,
1.1444274187088013,
0.23718707263469696,
-0.1010986790060997,
-0.1797759085893631,
-0.9018307328224182,
0.826754093170166,
-0.21649450063705444,
0.04978250339627266,
0.020591765642166138,
0.45936423540115356,
-0.3216201663017273,
-0.7517246007919312,
-0.662320613861084,
-0.4905274212360382,
0.04761258885264397,
0.2762952446937561,
-0.2122366726398468,
0.29218772053718567,
-0.09994637221097946,
0.3503909707069397,
-0.1825692504644394,
0.2925875782966614,
-0.1685331165790558,
-0.0877591148018837,
0.38411644101142883,
0.19344055652618408,
-0.22967244684696198,
-0.18694189190864563,
-0.48716822266578674,
-0.4771577715873718,
-0.8497678637504578,
0.5072287321090698,
0.6270689964294434,
0.5944127440452576,
-0.15396450459957123,
0.2278359979391098,
-0.11118096113204956,
0.35497865080833435,
-0.02146989293396473,
-0.006180793046951294,
-0.33374595642089844,
-0.02016848511993885,
0.16585062444210052,
-0.6254146695137024,
0.746442973613739,
0.29057514667510986,
0.08895622938871384,
-0.044624410569667816,
-0.5848060846328735,
0.25345709919929504,
0.4328573942184448,
-0.41206827759742737,
-0.187155082821846,
-0.11227931082248688,
-0.2967011034488678,
-0.515669047832489,
0.12854236364364624,
-0.824526309967041,
-0.30812644958496094,
-0.40320274233818054,
0.38243788480758667,
-0.1541234254837036,
-0.32709652185440063,
-0.32599857449531555,
-0.05655508488416672,
0.2842637300491333,
0.3401496112346649,
-0.7328190207481384,
0.2459220439195633,
0.9155159592628479,
1.1100064516067505,
-0.14215931296348572,
-0.27276715636253357,
-0.6752169728279114,
-0.18001507222652435,
-0.5764411091804504,
0.6750470995903015,
-0.5011624097824097,
-0.5814790725708008,
0.270114004611969,
-0.08551793545484543,
0.04512142762541771,
-0.5108255743980408,
0.5162792205810547,
-0.6823821663856506,
-0.18704983592033386,
-0.5601840019226074,
-0.17589303851127625,
-0.017802363261580467,
0.287396639585495,
-0.5914892554283142,
0.5738919377326965,
0.34386882185935974,
-0.1503882110118866,
0.6032756567001343,
-0.44645383954048157,
-0.19986380636692047,
-0.11505458503961563,
-0.23249001801013947,
-0.7876226305961609,
0.10769852250814438,
-0.14013750851154327,
0.11620693653821945,
-0.1693006157875061,
0.2512646019458771,
-0.24139882624149323,
-0.5475583076477051,
-0.005739331711083651,
-0.21367713809013367,
0.22518198192119598,
0.3082508444786072,
-0.2088058888912201,
0.5361334085464478,
-0.28605401515960693,
-0.05814063549041748,
0.31313708424568176,
-0.3191787898540497,
0.046197883784770966,
0.16353502869606018,
-0.08799219131469727,
-0.020052794367074966,
0.06406212598085403,
-0.26315802335739136,
0.5931284427642822,
-0.08030353486537933,
0.3172469139099121,
1.1957570314407349,
0.09799172729253769,
0.615003228187561,
-0.5414527654647827,
0.7576990723609924,
-0.24385374784469604,
0.47662049531936646,
-0.039110880345106125,
-0.04548776522278786,
-0.9797745943069458,
-0.5289618968963623,
0.3439100980758667,
0.31342557072639465,
-0.9958308339118958,
0.14989015460014343,
-0.16816481947898865,
-0.4293621778488159,
-0.2832951545715332,
0.24279332160949707,
0.9092655777931213,
0.4018467962741852,
0.28670191764831543,
-0.3607536554336548,
-0.41393351554870605,
-0.7442308664321899,
-0.24233901500701904,
-0.5474750399589539,
0.12747859954833984,
0.2605665326118469,
0.29008662700653076,
0.04533341899514198,
0.68446284532547,
-0.7707324028015137,
-0.6095267534255981,
-0.3540525734424591,
0.37109819054603577,
0.08868617564439774,
0.42367738485336304,
0.4684270918369293,
-0.7114121317863464,
-0.38382595777511597,
0.028506260365247726,
-0.4064091742038727,
0.22360004484653473,
-0.3486729562282562,
-0.04779180511832237,
0.08582344651222229,
0.37079206109046936,
-0.4125760495662689,
0.03964114189147949,
0.23771190643310547,
0.10339038819074631,
0.44131606817245483,
-0.43659090995788574,
0.03989443555474281,
-0.48028919100761414,
-0.07609602808952332,
0.05335812643170357,
-0.27918973565101624,
-0.3471887409687042,
0.4230504333972931,
0.020430520176887512,
0.055054932832717896,
-0.25684404373168945,
0.1902713030576706,
-0.2619744539260864,
0.02819102071225643,
-0.3908972442150116,
-0.18207119405269623,
-0.13482479751110077,
0.9372351169586182,
0.10106046497821808,
0.8510931730270386,
0.1776329129934311,
-0.683141827583313,
0.018053635954856873,
-0.1509542614221573,
0.10540996491909027,
0.5252866148948669,
-0.4198680818080902,
0.1910441368818283,
-0.4147992432117462,
0.2812095880508423,
-0.9692127108573914,
-0.1169959232211113,
0.24125410616397858,
-0.2161417156457901,
0.4427548050880432,
-0.44668450951576233,
0.02041560783982277,
-0.30640023946762085,
-0.509638786315918,
0.12436874210834503,
0.7863284945487976,
-0.5193964242935181,
0.4303829073905945,
0.23939217627048492,
0.24657167494297028,
-0.8382670879364014,
0.08948318660259247,
-0.16578179597854614,
-0.25379881262779236,
0.2319374978542328,
0.3358098268508911,
0.44513678550720215,
-0.14376117289066315,
-0.11105173826217651,
-0.036786679178476334,
0.32200175523757935,
-0.06528305262327194,
0.29167234897613525,
0.30549949407577515,
-0.10561241954565048,
0.11260537058115005,
0.006654271390289068,
-0.28002849221229553,
-0.3453000485897064,
-0.2645070254802704,
0.3197278082370758,
-0.42558127641677856,
-0.19966310262680054,
-0.13651633262634277,
0.12719109654426575,
0.21801957488059998,
-0.0620746910572052,
0.5018016695976257,
0.30825385451316833,
-0.006657373625785112,
-0.5596988201141357,
-0.1406591683626175,
-0.04606698825955391,
-0.5276769995689392,
0.21747079491615295,
-0.3857113718986511,
-0.5934063196182251,
0.4553491473197937,
-0.4410281777381897,
0.3739990293979645,
0.4216633141040802,
0.43328189849853516,
-0.18515118956565857,
0.41241392493247986,
0.8571290373802185,
-0.08282442390918732,
1.0450735092163086,
-0.7566347122192383,
-0.32200708985328674,
-0.512674868106842,
-0.41669631004333496,
-0.47397953271865845,
-0.5860655903816223,
-0.6786629557609558,
-0.43063923716545105,
0.3785844147205353,
0.2319672554731369,
-0.34955713152885437,
0.5264842510223389,
-0.5051467418670654,
0.6628533601760864,
0.5726611018180847,
0.20775170624256134,
0.18027696013450623,
-0.2819931209087372,
-0.05355605110526085,
-0.07638587057590485,
-0.7805904746055603,
-0.44899654388427734,
0.8203403353691101,
0.17764700949192047,
0.9344026446342468,
0.21455976366996765,
0.810206413269043,
0.5900329351425171,
0.8055190443992615,
-0.7477655410766602,
0.49087008833885193,
-0.35922813415527344,
0.07783547788858414,
-0.0754396989941597,
-0.4487871527671814,
-0.9631425142288208,
0.19751708209514618,
-0.20881278812885284,
-0.22121040523052216,
0.478237122297287,
0.44974109530448914,
-0.5831627249717712,
0.19490376114845276,
-0.8908631801605225,
0.6790724396705627,
0.0026423411909490824,
-0.6664023995399475,
-0.3598048686981201,
-0.7545124292373657,
0.45392537117004395,
0.33172428607940674,
-0.07275192439556122,
-0.03524117171764374,
-0.28091728687286377,
0.5402456521987915,
-0.5875900983810425,
0.7624836564064026,
-0.6111518144607544,
0.1219429075717926,
0.5184024572372437,
0.20598843693733215,
0.6705089211463928,
-0.006355886813253164,
0.38412192463874817,
-0.15769816935062408,
-0.27601608633995056,
-0.4283550977706909,
-0.8195708990097046,
0.9091059565544128,
-1.061970829963684,
-0.4804662764072418,
-0.34584304690361023,
-0.06762158870697021,
-0.1847187727689743,
-0.1668495535850525,
0.2324635088443756,
0.1459680199623108,
-0.22824791073799133,
-0.3182389736175537,
0.5989665985107422,
-0.04253461956977844,
0.5740561485290527,
0.5219686627388,
-0.2402883768081665,
-0.6631500124931335,
1.2235418558120728,
0.14820922911167145,
0.4227854907512665,
0.5531399250030518,
0.1765129566192627,
-0.3475238084793091,
-0.4095309376716614,
-0.5249305367469788,
0.3029586672782898,
-0.6398922204971313,
-0.5641791224479675,
-0.11097461730241776,
0.006343875080347061,
0.17327231168746948,
-0.44111767411231995,
-0.6740747094154358,
-0.27243101596832275,
-0.3236730396747589,
0.08384241163730621,
0.3844495117664337,
0.9464715123176575,
-0.29017725586891174,
0.7031941413879395,
-0.34236207604408264,
0.4832959771156311,
0.32310453057289124,
0.3094226121902466,
-0.20955830812454224,
-0.48841720819473267,
-0.15956167876720428,
-0.08740855008363724,
-0.756773829460144,
-0.7822489142417908,
0.09525295346975327,
0.2886979877948761,
0.19350026547908783,
0.6301155686378479,
0.16279256343841553,
0.8685935735702515,
-0.4317619800567627,
0.4854261577129364,
0.24491019546985626,
-0.6972095370292664,
0.42226651310920715,
-0.2218317985534668,
-0.10181527584791183,
0.8369834423065186,
0.35533782839775085,
-0.4568084478378296,
-0.23666971921920776,
-0.7406436800956726,
-0.6410738825798035,
0.6382793188095093,
-0.06198697164654732,
0.20828446745872498,
0.16232573986053467,
0.6099302172660828,
-0.03742499276995659,
0.10992074012756348,
-0.6306045055389404,
0.07095172256231308,
-0.2639705240726471,
-0.12102735787630081,
-0.3232147991657257,
-0.08707254379987717,
-0.29812896251678467,
0.08023086935281754,
0.49235832691192627,
-0.41494837403297424,
0.4410521686077118,
0.1766931414604187,
0.14891372621059418,
-0.33975541591644287,
0.09757059812545776,
0.7832081913948059,
0.06622745841741562,
-0.046169694513082504,
0.0971008837223053,
-0.033407844603061676,
-0.17117220163345337,
0.6072771549224854,
-0.27365556359291077,
-0.3195255696773529,
-0.22865603864192963,
0.3815267086029053,
0.7987377047538757,
0.023469924926757812,
-0.561970055103302,
0.7166720628738403,
-0.025800788775086403,
-0.1479208767414093,
-0.29285290837287903,
0.3466445803642273,
-0.40370091795921326,
0.31384003162384033,
0.20388561487197876,
0.44884684681892395,
-0.15994778275489807,
-0.45232003927230835,
0.15977400541305542,
0.6458230018615723,
-0.5561184883117676,
-0.38058704137802124,
0.6007537841796875,
0.1308022290468216,
-0.579992949962616,
0.4039851725101471,
-0.3797098994255066,
-0.5975191593170166,
0.6892446279525757,
0.2847139239311218,
0.9606915712356567,
0.11103152483701706,
0.5531282424926758,
0.4119803309440613,
0.3494899272918701,
-0.30989009141921997,
0.23603330552577972,
-0.27777546644210815,
-0.6238293647766113,
-0.4827007055282593,
-0.3115682303905487,
-0.6152393221855164,
-0.1570587456226349,
-0.5511038303375244,
0.3592335879802704,
-0.9454765319824219,
-0.176149383187294,
-0.3909146189689636,
0.003286269959062338,
-0.3235377371311188,
-0.1332903951406479,
-0.06296085566282272,
0.6539388298988342,
-0.983451783657074,
0.6117002367973328,
0.4335983991622925,
-0.6608439683914185,
-0.9209867715835571,
0.1841675192117691,
-0.10411718487739563,
-0.8066083192825317,
0.5225096940994263,
-0.06880328804254532,
-0.43627849221229553,
-0.0957612693309784,
-0.5482780337333679,
-0.36624637246131897,
0.9308865666389465,
0.5242850184440613,
-0.669068455696106,
0.037847891449928284,
-0.21328529715538025,
0.570325493812561,
-0.13324162364006042,
0.13235102593898773,
0.49999043345451355,
0.23639534413814545,
0.3642248809337616,
-0.5159845352172852,
-0.15520167350769043,
0.11525814980268478,
0.19154517352581024,
0.4362327754497528,
-1.2413326501846313,
0.7696162462234497,
-0.5094811916351318,
-0.2017570436000824,
0.1256968080997467,
1.0498617887496948,
0.20072795450687408,
0.05576454848051071,
0.4765078127384186,
0.48655620217323303,
0.49597176909446716,
-0.34170442819595337,
1.1158649921417236,
0.011489897966384888,
0.5561835765838623,
0.7601772546768188,
-0.22498707473278046,
0.8645973801612854,
0.5648072361946106,
-0.44460001587867737,
0.7510920763015747,
0.6122012734413147,
0.3801814615726471,
0.9416163563728333,
0.3248886466026306,
-0.5452157855033875,
-0.10378538072109222,
-0.1700095683336258,
0.056383706629276276,
0.29639214277267456,
-0.03687985986471176,
-0.1171507015824318,
-0.27843016386032104,
-0.016339749097824097,
0.062457453459501266,
0.5554195046424866,
-0.5207569003105164,
1.0376054048538208,
-0.1115037202835083,
-0.9501410722732544,
0.6595350503921509,
0.2437918335199356,
0.6662129759788513,
-0.9495450854301453,
-0.3104501962661743,
-0.5855984687805176,
0.5421414375305176,
0.06934072077274323,
-0.6145499348640442,
0.32783740758895874,
-0.045472677797079086,
0.18556098639965057,
-0.44955557584762573,
0.5072172284126282,
-0.24805192649364471,
-0.1765807420015335,
0.004002156667411327,
0.10345380753278732,
-0.2762717008590698,
0.27435562014579773,
-0.6082093715667725,
0.12689697742462158,
-0.18217717111110687,
-0.047589220106601715,
0.2514914870262146,
0.23196636140346527,
-0.10512091219425201,
0.7554624676704407,
0.4374043643474579,
0.11932619661092758,
-0.2203715294599533,
-0.11314234882593155,
1.1311500072479248,
-0.47523677349090576,
-0.6236400604248047,
-0.7876347899436951,
0.31887003779411316,
0.19118031859397888,
-0.4665933847427368,
0.30563730001449585,
0.4994039535522461,
0.6492596864700317,
-0.12196671217679977,
0.42881131172180176,
-0.15467073023319244,
0.15152308344841003,
-0.7717919945716858,
0.43157732486724854,
-0.583236813545227,
0.10076109319925308,
-0.06780611723661423,
-0.42814797163009644,
-0.1878552883863449,
0.5151277780532837,
-0.27469179034233093,
0.06593535840511322,
0.30053699016571045,
1.0923653841018677,
0.23938846588134766,
-0.2543252408504486,
0.26965540647506714,
-0.3433636724948883,
0.2473713606595993,
0.778257429599762,
1.1397298574447632,
-0.19410167634487152,
0.4975329637527466,
-0.12227237224578857,
-0.2717394530773163,
-0.04928774759173393,
-0.7141042947769165,
-0.36529475450515747,
-0.6180139183998108,
-0.0857289582490921,
-0.514647364616394,
0.4267856180667877,
1.1264188289642334,
0.6553241610527039,
-0.6741442084312439,
-0.2819615304470062,
-0.5811426639556885,
0.527558445930481,
-0.6004835367202759,
-0.2089902013540268,
0.168501079082489,
-0.500988245010376,
-0.6614103317260742,
0.2595115303993225,
0.13939796388149261,
0.052307672798633575,
-0.5318953394889832,
-0.6180358529090881,
0.010282172821462154,
-0.03380686044692993,
0.18645402789115906,
0.7663173079490662,
-0.6252539753913879,
-0.20156900584697723,
-0.15146145224571228,
-0.07144714146852493,
0.22369854152202606,
1.435181975364685,
-0.925116777420044,
0.2424708753824234,
0.2017812281847,
0.5691116452217102,
0.5574653744697571,
0.20759999752044678,
0.4318406581878662,
-1.0508707761764526,
0.30174314975738525,
0.43017318844795227,
0.10587699711322784,
0.12319514900445938,
-0.20340761542320251,
0.29915493726730347,
0.40335163474082947,
-0.4537936747074127,
-0.7972362041473389,
0.5369173884391785,
-0.7600908875465393,
-0.16286692023277283,
1.1194467544555664,
-0.40308430790901184,
-0.23572665452957153,
0.25747185945510864,
-0.3435331881046295,
0.18657082319259644,
-0.5475600361824036,
0.676003634929657,
0.2742082476615906,
-0.03717615455389023,
-0.4817288815975189,
-0.07281287014484406,
0.793158769607544,
0.4885861277580261,
-0.5935426354408264,
0.06705614924430847,
0.5128545165061951,
0.028751764446496964,
-0.0388307198882103,
0.7879063487052917,
0.20031197369098663,
0.33220112323760986,
0.17569562792778015,
0.19737160205841064,
-0.16222457587718964,
-0.7538183927536011,
-0.6238839030265808,
0.2519262433052063,
0.5975837707519531,
-0.42575395107269287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16766v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16766v1
|
Prefix Text as a Yarn: Eliciting Non-English Alignment in Foundation Language Model
| 2024-04-25T17:19:36 | 2024-04-25T17:19:36 |
Runzhe Zhan, Xinyi Yang, Derek F. Wong, Lidia S. Chao, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While supervised fine-tuning (SFT) has been a straightforward approach for
tailoring the output of foundation large language model (LLM) to specific
preferences, concerns have been raised about the depth of this alignment, with
some critiques suggesting it is merely "superficial". We critically examine
this hypothesis within the scope of cross-lingual generation tasks, proposing
that the effectiveness of SFT may be constrained by its reliance on prior
tokens to guide cross-lingual generation. Based on this crucial insight, and in
response to the challenges posed by the costly and limited availability of
non-English data for SFT, we introduce a novel training-free alignment method
named PreTTY, which employs minimal task-related prior tokens to bridge the
foundation LLM and the SFT LLM, achieving comparable performance without
training. Experiments on machine translation and part-of-speech tagging across
eight languages demonstrate the efficacy of PreTTY in cross-lingual settings.
Remarkably, by initiating the decoding process with only one or two prior
tokens, foundation LLMs can achieve performance comparable to their SFT
counterparts. This method presents a cost-effective alternative to SFT and
advances the democratization of multilingual LLMs.
|
[
-0.34676092863082886,
-0.7735045552253723,
0.26550978422164917,
0.11384451389312744,
-0.5571869015693665,
0.15299318730831146,
-0.34276866912841797,
-0.5797027945518494,
0.5574203133583069,
0.43694329261779785,
-0.8165236711502075,
-0.5669679045677185,
-0.3792605400085449,
0.3185526728630066,
-0.5804446339607239,
1.1726781129837036,
-0.039834439754486084,
0.16039711236953735,
-0.09175627678632736,
-0.07782147079706192,
-0.6081055998802185,
-0.17899547517299652,
-0.6763156056404114,
-0.10973519086837769,
0.39374834299087524,
0.5511744618415833,
0.9343164563179016,
0.8855366706848145,
0.556986391544342,
0.28133371472358704,
-0.03604511171579361,
0.3440700173377991,
-0.47512537240982056,
-0.07002201676368713,
-0.33617836236953735,
-0.631035327911377,
-0.4261929392814636,
-0.028778087347745895,
0.5867258906364441,
0.7816706299781799,
0.14299583435058594,
-0.04520419239997864,
-0.009605730883777142,
0.7908246517181396,
-0.5228433012962341,
-0.19092315435409546,
-0.8237496614456177,
-0.11464088410139084,
-0.4804692268371582,
-0.2585908770561218,
-0.38256731629371643,
0.015717482194304466,
-0.05720100924372673,
-0.7211068868637085,
0.4542256295681,
0.2359352707862854,
1.2197993993759155,
0.6359313726425171,
-0.48043015599250793,
-0.2156827598810196,
-0.3719697594642639,
0.863250732421875,
-0.49819713830947876,
0.8141404986381531,
0.4393669068813324,
-0.07501672208309174,
-0.11094141006469727,
-0.5031715035438538,
-0.3659430742263794,
0.048777986317873,
-0.37566912174224854,
0.06198146194219589,
-0.09887214750051498,
0.07066229730844498,
-0.14611391723155975,
0.6112247705459595,
-0.601063072681427,
0.07689328491687775,
-0.13918434083461761,
-0.20370367169380188,
0.6616655588150024,
-0.08869460225105286,
0.41943788528442383,
-0.08767951279878616,
-0.40013912320137024,
0.08427610248327255,
-0.8644222617149353,
-0.09656991809606552,
0.42374420166015625,
0.8645229935646057,
-0.4847179651260376,
0.6120353937149048,
-0.21802838146686554,
0.6718555092811584,
0.37680429220199585,
-0.02260150946676731,
0.28052249550819397,
-0.528335690498352,
-0.13833841681480408,
0.3152156174182892,
0.8257894515991211,
0.33406901359558105,
0.5721014142036438,
-0.4112122654914856,
-0.18983194231987,
0.19714780151844025,
0.20516662299633026,
-0.7575029730796814,
-0.22131779789924622,
0.047125715762376785,
-0.03387180343270302,
-0.07434210181236267,
-0.04655158892273903,
-0.42618244886398315,
-0.09762892127037048,
-0.42627185583114624,
-0.0010190407047048211,
-0.4972950220108032,
-0.278727263212204,
-0.04236205667257309,
-0.002262170659378171,
0.18134579062461853,
0.08994348347187042,
-1.2865360975265503,
0.1333586722612381,
0.8732020854949951,
0.8626235723495483,
-0.4024692177772522,
-0.47579818964004517,
-0.6492103338241577,
0.13900135457515717,
-0.8402613401412964,
0.7729505300521851,
-0.35145390033721924,
-0.31012409925460815,
-0.16960808634757996,
0.1008930653333664,
0.04000331088900566,
-0.08853936940431595,
0.2626767158508301,
-0.3721606433391571,
0.11977183073759079,
-0.2208094447851181,
-0.3634548783302307,
0.23947294056415558,
0.10415807366371155,
-0.5874763131141663,
1.0807774066925049,
0.08899325877428055,
-0.861132025718689,
0.5895137786865234,
-0.3936261832714081,
-0.8694881200790405,
-0.09474296122789383,
-0.2286757230758667,
-0.18098479509353638,
0.4191970229148865,
0.3426147997379303,
0.46122226119041443,
-0.16330692172050476,
0.3631415367126465,
-0.0001297089911531657,
-0.5908257365226746,
-0.13891759514808655,
-0.5402201414108276,
0.48687583208084106,
0.09478887170553207,
-0.3977380096912384,
0.014184131287038326,
-0.7480778694152832,
0.06567791104316711,
-0.03589136525988579,
-0.14868421852588654,
-0.6814990639686584,
-0.33710426092147827,
0.14767006039619446,
0.08773157000541687,
0.3532279431819916,
-0.4356025159358978,
0.1347491592168808,
-0.8993822932243347,
0.24714036285877228,
0.7340245842933655,
-0.467831015586853,
0.9022068977355957,
-0.23142175376415253,
0.44311410188674927,
-0.1470559984445572,
-0.15481500327587128,
-0.21504166722297668,
-0.4114363193511963,
-0.9026194214820862,
-0.49736735224723816,
0.6806829571723938,
0.32561782002449036,
-0.8562909364700317,
-0.061051975935697556,
-0.5384657979011536,
-0.30818748474121094,
-0.8783162236213684,
0.21735979616641998,
0.6751070618629456,
0.24476011097431183,
0.4866127371788025,
-0.2810983657836914,
-0.4785338342189789,
-0.990142822265625,
-0.3753622770309448,
-0.019224608317017555,
0.26075056195259094,
0.13040651381015778,
0.2594064474105835,
-0.026402268558740616,
1.2460709810256958,
-0.2732223868370056,
-0.2356611043214798,
-0.055019065737724304,
0.16710087656974792,
0.05642354488372803,
0.6456347107887268,
0.518535315990448,
-1.0501981973648071,
-0.571995735168457,
0.27937039732933044,
-0.3119906187057495,
-0.2780039608478546,
0.01961870864033699,
-0.34489718079566956,
0.6502944827079773,
0.5657961368560791,
-0.4256856143474579,
0.13789547979831696,
0.7836899161338806,
-0.44512104988098145,
0.1503673642873764,
0.012614846229553223,
0.16386349499225616,
-1.307780385017395,
0.05989500507712364,
-0.09252368658781052,
-0.33972039818763733,
-0.6687012910842896,
0.23441854119300842,
0.21732831001281738,
0.14827100932598114,
-0.6330711841583252,
1.0044702291488647,
-0.6937836408615112,
0.061103250831365585,
-0.19336532056331635,
-0.11136271804571152,
0.020776929333806038,
0.46565771102905273,
0.32317054271698,
0.9023925065994263,
0.16261625289916992,
-0.34380394220352173,
-0.18361268937587738,
0.34128308296203613,
-0.012755883857607841,
0.8979067206382751,
-0.24660608172416687,
0.03297864645719528,
-0.10685710608959198,
-0.08002293854951859,
-0.8859459757804871,
-0.31001394987106323,
0.10474685579538345,
-0.33029335737228394,
0.669318675994873,
-0.30523255467414856,
-0.22797302901744843,
0.04067298769950867,
-0.17307117581367493,
0.39924564957618713,
0.33410197496414185,
-0.5729138255119324,
0.3693362772464752,
0.11642292886972427,
-0.1954338401556015,
-0.6744346618652344,
-1.1355876922607422,
0.11387535184621811,
-0.27230122685432434,
-0.5695261359214783,
0.5471197366714478,
-0.10398920625448227,
-0.11373033374547958,
-0.06727022677659988,
-0.3790498375892639,
-0.10391565412282944,
0.2522466480731964,
0.0858248621225357,
0.07002244144678116,
-0.44154074788093567,
-0.07073549181222916,
0.17338059842586517,
-0.2928757667541504,
-0.36052465438842773,
-0.2510298490524292,
0.3795686960220337,
-0.10542075335979462,
-0.3187383711338043,
-0.29337278008461,
0.4961230456829071,
0.44279444217681885,
-0.29969584941864014,
0.5312631130218506,
0.47902563214302063,
-0.324285626411438,
-0.4835861623287201,
-0.41707751154899597,
-0.05600525438785553,
-0.4927201271057129,
0.2022845447063446,
-0.4735364317893982,
-1.0137207508087158,
0.20587894320487976,
-0.00864287931472063,
0.23929013311862946,
0.28021588921546936,
0.3142686188220978,
0.102955661714077,
0.9497156143188477,
1.1533857583999634,
0.20224036276340485,
0.5627992749214172,
0.03145104646682739,
0.32075875997543335,
-0.40938711166381836,
-0.02559710294008255,
-0.41099223494529724,
-0.3334493935108185,
-0.7245378494262695,
-0.33121246099472046,
-0.08410263061523438,
0.49442532658576965,
-0.1774781346321106,
0.3514605462551117,
-0.642223060131073,
0.5612552762031555,
0.559610903263092,
-0.32339444756507874,
0.4745365083217621,
0.14122074842453003,
-0.26322001218795776,
-0.21919016540050507,
-0.640654981136322,
-0.30037766695022583,
0.8138535022735596,
0.025858258828520775,
0.5972154140472412,
0.04877505078911781,
0.9057741761207581,
-0.24310094118118286,
0.37575745582580566,
-0.8121920228004456,
0.32926568388938904,
-0.4567681849002838,
-0.3547215163707733,
-0.17983943223953247,
-0.3225758969783783,
-0.7715814113616943,
0.11957445740699768,
-0.1175588071346283,
-0.5718624591827393,
0.05776183679699898,
0.3315477967262268,
-0.24240237474441528,
-0.02013513445854187,
-0.7656965851783752,
0.9228087663650513,
-0.3784998655319214,
-0.40771937370300293,
0.257152795791626,
-0.6285264492034912,
0.2922162413597107,
-0.3938761353492737,
0.38442516326904297,
-0.11719643324613571,
-0.24234583973884583,
0.5751078128814697,
-0.49099674820899963,
0.8651444911956787,
0.17365190386772156,
-0.42674994468688965,
-0.04170648753643036,
0.056326285004615784,
0.5216603875160217,
-0.11141161620616913,
-0.018613183870911598,
0.38451576232910156,
-0.12383443862199783,
-0.351461797952652,
-0.5034408569335938,
0.7631658911705017,
-0.4903693199157715,
-0.6548557281494141,
-0.24212096631526947,
-0.7175146341323853,
-0.5613785982131958,
0.4509088099002838,
0.39671316742897034,
0.057945724576711655,
-0.1316271275281906,
0.0371372327208519,
0.35792943835258484,
0.21339236199855804,
0.43895065784454346,
0.5491467714309692,
-0.11298472434282303,
-0.4470576047897339,
1.1142234802246094,
0.15484580397605896,
0.3428992033004761,
0.5937765836715698,
0.19016505777835846,
-0.22537779808044434,
-0.6261135935783386,
-0.794745147228241,
0.2293192744255066,
-0.427291601896286,
-0.3199746012687683,
-0.597885012626648,
0.16996462643146515,
-0.31590303778648376,
-0.6958619952201843,
-0.7952722311019897,
-0.5015483498573303,
-0.36274275183677673,
-0.14524251222610474,
0.5463809967041016,
0.6176734566688538,
-0.07276750355958939,
0.4802737236022949,
-0.5933606028556824,
0.2709323465824127,
-0.12564781308174133,
0.45002883672714233,
-0.3251841366291046,
-0.1463739275932312,
-0.36071881651878357,
0.4023907482624054,
-0.07891462743282318,
-0.6968921422958374,
0.3363160789012909,
0.16621491312980652,
0.1944454461336136,
0.32842034101486206,
0.0759008601307869,
1.135886549949646,
-0.7608881592750549,
0.9726865291595459,
0.2658896744251251,
-1.1180528402328491,
0.4439607560634613,
-0.3999198079109192,
0.19236968457698822,
0.7349473834037781,
0.328275203704834,
-0.5203682780265808,
-0.5554234385490417,
-0.5628265142440796,
-1.0950754880905151,
0.8441228866577148,
0.05571376159787178,
0.3003006875514984,
-0.3194921314716339,
0.1412055790424347,
0.20932134985923767,
0.42338886857032776,
-0.5868772268295288,
-0.2732624113559723,
-0.3005659282207489,
-0.446025013923645,
-0.30224883556365967,
0.023614292964339256,
0.07268287241458893,
-0.08863341808319092,
0.865158200263977,
-0.5475144982337952,
-0.07681706547737122,
0.11227070540189743,
-0.15711890161037445,
-0.1764422208070755,
0.30570176243782043,
0.3829311430454254,
0.24454624950885773,
0.22211672365665436,
0.11355974525213242,
0.20506124198436737,
-0.2717979848384857,
0.09235317260026932,
0.052552513778209686,
-0.30764541029930115,
0.2075469046831131,
0.3462459444999695,
0.7851014733314514,
0.6204143166542053,
-0.3855752646923065,
0.6313776969909668,
0.12492864578962326,
-0.1508873999118805,
0.25861096382141113,
-0.04949238896369934,
0.2167164385318756,
-0.012464276514947414,
0.12977485358715057,
0.010331762954592705,
-0.16971734166145325,
-0.4131626784801483,
0.2733633816242218,
0.7979565858840942,
-0.623900830745697,
-0.20270662009716034,
0.7583925724029541,
0.16112543642520905,
-0.25756555795669556,
0.34501704573631287,
-0.09055526554584503,
-0.3523608148097992,
0.4359278678894043,
0.775800883769989,
0.7572647929191589,
-0.19314692914485931,
0.16890855133533478,
0.04057696461677551,
0.3774060010910034,
-0.2686420977115631,
0.33589276671409607,
-0.17021621763706207,
-0.6455273032188416,
-0.5173123478889465,
-1.0749094486236572,
-0.17187179625034332,
-0.133796826004982,
-0.49380654096603394,
0.5811858773231506,
-0.18719103932380676,
0.14405326545238495,
-0.12999504804611206,
0.027976570650935173,
-0.5591339468955994,
0.3705277442932129,
0.17120201885700226,
0.9864000082015991,
-1.004819393157959,
0.6585187315940857,
0.8596118688583374,
-0.2558187246322632,
-1.1076018810272217,
0.13466477394104004,
-0.013175769709050655,
-0.6954302787780762,
0.3496105372905731,
0.29413941502571106,
-0.27806413173675537,
0.31503626704216003,
-0.2864382863044739,
-1.0735187530517578,
0.8311946392059326,
0.7557402849197388,
-0.48553332686424255,
-0.3340265154838562,
0.3766838014125824,
0.5308202505111694,
-0.10985789448022842,
0.026924822479486465,
0.5366587042808533,
0.5258651375770569,
0.20526137948036194,
-1.1160897016525269,
0.03881898894906044,
-0.4441799521446228,
0.002186022000387311,
0.5824377536773682,
-0.7453188300132751,
0.7201869487762451,
-0.05839274823665619,
-0.6005878448486328,
0.33757585287094116,
0.6821917295455933,
-0.09639554470777512,
0.06084232032299042,
0.23230881989002228,
0.5962075591087341,
0.8283225297927856,
-0.29033565521240234,
0.9859461784362793,
-0.5652517080307007,
0.2046707421541214,
0.9375594258308411,
-0.04695825278759003,
0.7466294765472412,
0.9633142352104187,
0.15744023025035858,
0.24207526445388794,
0.7227129340171814,
0.2134528011083603,
0.7461193799972534,
0.10003265738487244,
0.1045079305768013,
-0.3555695116519928,
-0.3758629262447357,
-0.43025991320610046,
0.5560452938079834,
0.1257571578025818,
-0.17136287689208984,
-0.22239866852760315,
-0.16910746693611145,
0.10137619078159332,
0.22148431837558746,
-0.35190629959106445,
0.8453988432884216,
0.24383480846881866,
-0.8173061609268188,
0.7906109690666199,
0.16232945024967194,
1.1185665130615234,
-0.7656668424606323,
-0.03990114852786064,
-0.33102092146873474,
0.0026044421829283237,
-0.4459591805934906,
-0.45860353112220764,
0.5834089517593384,
0.16045735776424408,
-0.26708871126174927,
-0.5821813941001892,
0.3370147943496704,
-0.638364315032959,
-0.5517120361328125,
0.22603486478328705,
0.7110890746116638,
0.2146299183368683,
0.2180938869714737,
-0.500769853591919,
-0.11254475265741348,
0.08793558925390244,
-0.2848305106163025,
0.2632335126399994,
0.5379252433776855,
-0.4799516201019287,
0.26138243079185486,
0.9626408219337463,
0.17347876727581024,
-0.05326436460018158,
0.0027203185018152,
0.48238757252693176,
-0.513110876083374,
-0.7617178559303284,
-1.0301157236099243,
0.6282217502593994,
0.27970847487449646,
-0.5361931324005127,
0.7149324417114258,
0.6910090446472168,
1.2568005323410034,
0.22587443888187408,
0.6032974123954773,
0.14723710715770721,
0.062364161014556885,
-0.7429193258285522,
0.7770163416862488,
-1.0395469665527344,
-0.04957704246044159,
-0.5215959548950195,
-0.7466025948524475,
-0.5017207264900208,
0.5775355696678162,
-0.1410938799381256,
-0.1291418820619583,
0.8882158398628235,
0.9177392721176147,
-0.38506969809532166,
0.3709344267845154,
0.332674503326416,
-0.038609541952610016,
-0.18581116199493408,
0.32621538639068604,
0.6321699619293213,
-0.3057112693786621,
0.3456169664859772,
-0.3467088043689728,
0.0012888266937807202,
0.15140517055988312,
-1.114212155342102,
-0.8806995153427124,
-0.5760907530784607,
-0.2513016164302826,
-0.19523885846138,
0.3355226516723633,
0.9749906063079834,
0.6746587157249451,
-0.7959399819374084,
0.04175825044512749,
-0.3846142590045929,
0.21043835580348969,
-0.2515451908111572,
-0.16635672748088837,
0.4050723910331726,
-0.37643879652023315,
-1.1268588304519653,
0.6169450879096985,
0.09639930725097656,
0.2265722155570984,
0.030868634581565857,
-0.11694087833166122,
-0.1607079952955246,
-0.11652188748121262,
0.24261748790740967,
0.06201773136854172,
-0.6923235654830933,
-0.1509842574596405,
0.06676414608955383,
-0.2746301591396332,
0.15532271564006805,
0.6196733117103577,
-0.6418066024780273,
-0.0026122918352484703,
0.31293606758117676,
0.8515486717224121,
0.18028897047042847,
0.09989526122808456,
0.7841057777404785,
-1.20042884349823,
0.19621147215366364,
-0.09318798035383224,
0.36714476346969604,
0.6751941442489624,
-0.5963921546936035,
0.5829346776008606,
0.10918992012739182,
-0.0006838358822278678,
-0.9200979471206665,
0.19151373207569122,
-0.6073132157325745,
-0.41113704442977905,
1.192307472229004,
0.18578408658504486,
-0.29549816250801086,
0.03814680501818657,
-0.08814035356044769,
0.3318057954311371,
-0.30226758122444153,
0.24876810610294342,
0.6659514307975769,
0.14644892513751984,
0.1345505565404892,
-0.3432239592075348,
0.6856673359870911,
0.6952304840087891,
-0.537444531917572,
0.15067510306835175,
0.45098891854286194,
0.3065950572490692,
0.34819546341896057,
0.7488464713096619,
0.1186704933643341,
0.26737889647483826,
-0.09755034744739532,
0.0031261846888810396,
-0.1792595088481903,
-0.521450400352478,
-0.3852965831756592,
0.08292888104915619,
-0.10606420785188675,
0.06362932920455933
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.